id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06611v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06611v1
|
MedKP: Medical Dialogue with Knowledge Enhancement and Clinical Pathway Encoding
| 2024-03-11T10:57:45 | 2024-03-11T10:57:45 |
Jiageng Wu, Xian Wu, Yefeng Zheng, Jie Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
With appropriate data selection and training techniques, Large Language
Models (LLMs) have demonstrated exceptional success in various medical
examinations and multiple-choice questions. However, the application of LLMs in
medical dialogue generation-a task more closely aligned with actual medical
practice-has been less explored. This gap is attributed to the insufficient
medical knowledge of LLMs, which leads to inaccuracies and hallucinated
information in the generated medical responses. In this work, we introduce the
Medical dialogue with Knowledge enhancement and clinical Pathway encoding
(MedKP) framework, which integrates an external knowledge enhancement module
through a medical knowledge graph and an internal clinical pathway encoding via
medical entities and physician actions. Evaluated with comprehensive metrics,
our experiments on two large-scale, real-world online medical consultation
datasets (MedDG and KaMed) demonstrate that MedKP surpasses multiple baselines
and mitigates the incidence of hallucinations, achieving a new
state-of-the-art. Extensive ablation studies further reveal the effectiveness
of each component of MedKP. This enhancement advances the development of
reliable, automated medical consultation responses using LLMs, thereby
broadening the potential accessibility of precise and real-time medical
assistance.
|
[
-0.30332788825035095,
-0.631285548210144,
0.9319556951522827,
0.021695274859666824,
-0.21753375232219696,
0.13239149749279022,
-0.01886293664574623,
-0.6513636112213135,
0.5613548755645752,
0.8213322162628174,
-0.7643119096755981,
-0.5471705198287964,
-0.5377416610717773,
0.12564390897750854,
0.16701263189315796,
0.5854132175445557,
0.22853131592273712,
0.8661952018737793,
-0.22876474261283875,
0.05316033959388733,
-0.6143156290054321,
-0.5235681533813477,
-0.7832058072090149,
-0.5405546426773071,
0.4484045207500458,
0.16690462827682495,
0.5838454961776733,
0.38421791791915894,
0.6792057752609253,
0.27870863676071167,
0.11077460646629333,
0.5725218653678894,
-0.11032962799072266,
0.5217160582542419,
0.055015359073877335,
-0.4426129460334778,
-0.4118959605693817,
-0.4322952628135681,
0.43149349093437195,
0.9207345843315125,
-0.32402539253234863,
-0.23853319883346558,
-0.10662280768156052,
0.8091964721679688,
-0.45694461464881897,
0.12191864103078842,
-0.47796228528022766,
0.24581970274448395,
0.25530171394348145,
-0.6189963817596436,
-0.2581321895122528,
-0.37203294038772583,
0.12824758887290955,
-0.4897908866405487,
-0.1161101683974266,
-0.018528901040554047,
0.508416473865509,
0.6216394901275635,
-0.2029111087322235,
-0.5592131018638611,
-0.7498888969421387,
0.17342866957187653,
-0.9292190074920654,
0.567793071269989,
0.5381177663803101,
0.433936208486557,
-0.516703724861145,
-0.7777203321456909,
-0.34977054595947266,
-0.21098020672798157,
-0.17324088513851166,
0.3429683446884155,
0.20670174062252045,
0.67275470495224,
0.2592350244522095,
0.24253533780574799,
-0.16967038810253143,
0.028580673038959503,
-0.3040124773979187,
-0.3754937946796417,
0.21815048158168793,
0.6041193604469299,
0.17306295037269592,
-0.20054717361927032,
-0.06748038530349731,
0.2548741102218628,
-0.7340455651283264,
-0.11376112699508667,
-0.12424735724925995,
-0.0032582206185907125,
-0.1192769855260849,
0.6769881844520569,
-0.2543531060218811,
0.8403489589691162,
-0.06578488647937775,
-0.4234485924243927,
0.029529044404625893,
-0.21202689409255981,
-0.3941749632358551,
0.07867222279310226,
0.6465529203414917,
0.8325448036193848,
-0.1851205974817276,
-0.14364270865917206,
0.2952762544155121,
0.22915637493133545,
0.44324931502342224,
-0.7409487366676331,
-0.2001425325870514,
0.5486548542976379,
-0.6935777068138123,
-0.32762646675109863,
-0.3260148763656616,
-0.7645165324211121,
-0.8720129132270813,
-0.45878180861473083,
0.03266926109790802,
-0.5327739715576172,
-0.1798170953989029,
0.4649997353553772,
0.006066030357033014,
0.22149740159511566,
0.4234723150730133,
-0.7496790885925293,
0.33764827251434326,
0.5590900182723999,
0.6141451001167297,
0.07207071036100388,
0.3580899238586426,
-0.2622796297073364,
0.30040839314460754,
-0.39716994762420654,
0.9039989709854126,
-0.7102496027946472,
-0.35663238167762756,
0.2656680941581726,
0.005921552423387766,
0.12799809873104095,
-0.8005640506744385,
0.5418912768363953,
-0.32229480147361755,
0.27620065212249756,
-0.2918585538864136,
-0.7131670117378235,
-0.002863114234060049,
0.3452211022377014,
-0.1861642301082611,
0.5909315943717957,
0.16926944255828857,
-0.5753178000450134,
0.52988600730896,
-0.7817872762680054,
-0.12747018039226532,
0.2376381903886795,
-0.6937703490257263,
-0.043744973838329315,
0.05102366954088211,
0.2985805869102478,
0.39341238141059875,
-0.49566927552223206,
0.13554225862026215,
-0.25936228036880493,
0.08374461531639099,
0.2911031246185303,
-0.3384140431880951,
0.4681893587112427,
0.277228981256485,
0.033725351095199585,
0.041066959500312805,
-0.9307883381843567,
0.11677046120166779,
-0.04476318135857582,
-0.4977157711982727,
-0.2980669438838959,
-0.23628956079483032,
-0.4916796088218689,
0.49277836084365845,
-0.09980610758066177,
-0.6504108905792236,
0.38720831274986267,
-0.8883370161056519,
0.17912401258945465,
0.5540826320648193,
0.5283952951431274,
0.06728657335042953,
-0.5062330961227417,
0.5692930221557617,
0.18904106318950653,
0.2585609555244446,
-0.21071061491966248,
-0.8460203409194946,
-0.7792350649833679,
-0.19648171961307526,
-0.09405814111232758,
0.6089645028114319,
-0.9312289953231812,
0.47774583101272583,
-0.17520351707935333,
-0.3390541076660156,
-0.9049374461174011,
-0.048709936439991,
0.2383027970790863,
1.0693022012710571,
0.35671865940093994,
-0.2751210629940033,
-0.6585267186164856,
-0.771390438079834,
0.042211923748254776,
-0.24427105486392975,
-0.32442399859428406,
0.6364452838897705,
-0.12466689199209213,
-0.5124187469482422,
0.7110031843185425,
-0.5485933423042297,
-0.35393184423446655,
-0.15691663324832916,
-0.2102348357439041,
0.23277558386325836,
0.3058026134967804,
0.16752320528030396,
-0.2908284664154053,
-0.5372448563575745,
-0.1031767874956131,
-0.7533220052719116,
-0.4197808504104614,
-0.22370098531246185,
-0.18057769536972046,
0.12465228140354156,
0.31217068433761597,
-0.6102725267410278,
0.3046010732650757,
0.36743825674057007,
-0.4681835174560547,
0.4326213598251343,
-0.34205538034439087,
0.5739498734474182,
-1.3112932443618774,
-0.06883678585290909,
-0.41134369373321533,
-0.0883714109659195,
-0.7865614891052246,
-0.28224724531173706,
-0.1985165774822235,
-0.03865006938576698,
-0.19583237171173096,
0.42755964398384094,
-0.05432919040322304,
0.07476160675287247,
-0.29846927523612976,
0.04737928882241249,
-0.20246873795986176,
0.48649075627326965,
0.1752437949180603,
0.2546195387840271,
0.552345335483551,
-0.5690519213676453,
0.5895922780036926,
0.5194529294967651,
-0.2174859493970871,
0.8236656785011292,
-0.024113455787301064,
0.18683785200119019,
-0.14875191450119019,
0.2788943350315094,
-0.763124406337738,
-0.4302850365638733,
0.5669390559196472,
-0.44543445110321045,
0.4017564356327057,
-0.3040247857570648,
-0.452662855386734,
-0.4028843343257904,
-0.00771735655143857,
0.2098126858472824,
0.5709241628646851,
-0.3575931787490845,
0.49562010169029236,
0.3933982849121094,
-0.3826749622821808,
-0.482346773147583,
-0.44681844115257263,
0.29495495557785034,
-0.02670663222670555,
-0.7019277811050415,
-0.023960992693901062,
-0.16511042416095734,
-0.15939749777317047,
-0.42176926136016846,
-0.1510927975177765,
-0.011025951243937016,
-0.36157557368278503,
0.3933941721916199,
0.3773413300514221,
-0.2073146104812622,
0.1634804606437683,
0.29722893238067627,
-0.31806325912475586,
0.43616729974746704,
-0.30490830540657043,
0.7295424342155457,
0.4409237205982208,
-0.7430575489997864,
-0.551898717880249,
0.3877742886543274,
0.5295409560203552,
0.3528192937374115,
0.7042412161827087,
0.28201693296432495,
-0.5670264363288879,
0.12843145430088043,
-0.8679447770118713,
-0.5630146265029907,
-0.4739370048046112,
0.32105767726898193,
-0.08798005431890488,
-0.7290621995925903,
0.4308061897754669,
-0.43057140707969666,
0.047895483672618866,
0.0804995745420456,
0.7795703411102295,
-0.15753909945487976,
1.2837573289871216,
0.2216479331254959,
0.2127796858549118,
-0.10635370016098022,
0.021815869957208633,
0.19628511369228363,
-0.8840863108634949,
-0.6607664823532104,
-0.2650049328804016,
0.023621361702680588,
-0.37572312355041504,
-0.5089725255966187,
0.6919359564781189,
-0.09575724601745605,
-0.001900986535474658,
-0.20201250910758972,
-0.6833016276359558,
0.22388353943824768,
0.2115652859210968,
0.5355496406555176,
0.43208372592926025,
0.15317969024181366,
-0.49620527029037476,
-0.5800994038581848,
-0.9866750836372375,
-0.3070482313632965,
1.2340891361236572,
0.4434049427509308,
0.7109261155128479,
-0.18045847117900848,
0.3530709743499756,
0.0913541316986084,
0.32833951711654663,
-0.7862087488174438,
0.5544231534004211,
0.14612266421318054,
-0.20150889456272125,
0.13165751099586487,
-0.4290563464164734,
-0.6989563703536987,
0.07702163606882095,
-0.5406157374382019,
-0.5955209732055664,
-0.07205250859260559,
0.326724648475647,
-0.6595529317855835,
0.29043591022491455,
-0.5259228348731995,
0.4269205629825592,
-0.09098157286643982,
-0.2495407909154892,
-0.2776198983192444,
-0.9247304797172546,
0.3000003397464752,
-0.07191278785467148,
0.19136682152748108,
0.08824022859334946,
-0.14118140935897827,
0.5098841190338135,
-0.5688831210136414,
0.8041639924049377,
-0.3207550644874573,
-0.28349432349205017,
-0.1410769671201706,
0.038866374641656876,
0.4873100817203522,
0.16276700794696808,
0.3054961562156677,
0.03014420159161091,
0.011114386841654778,
-0.014127461239695549,
-0.7683589458465576,
0.5175341367721558,
-0.40925106406211853,
-0.5652598738670349,
0.0541643425822258,
-0.774341881275177,
-0.8843904137611389,
0.0009571862174198031,
0.10760375112295151,
0.5543171167373657,
0.1574333757162094,
-0.04583924263715744,
0.5544394254684448,
-0.7012670636177063,
-0.19597721099853516,
0.6678351163864136,
-0.30343544483184814,
-0.590285062789917,
0.49723008275032043,
-0.16731984913349152,
0.59784996509552,
0.32441118359565735,
0.26941895484924316,
-0.42795056104660034,
-0.5638598799705505,
-0.16394518315792084,
0.5342384576797485,
-1.1476880311965942,
-0.26756083965301514,
-0.9804296493530273,
-0.5486102104187012,
-0.68781977891922,
-0.2164863795042038,
-0.09166530519723892,
-0.428189754486084,
0.1016494408249855,
-0.022186772897839546,
0.33790987730026245,
0.7231776118278503,
-0.07242885231971741,
0.20016984641551971,
-0.976012110710144,
0.5150244832038879,
0.03624366223812103,
0.5332064032554626,
-0.12207293510437012,
-0.28104713559150696,
-0.27278146147727966,
0.11762665957212448,
-0.20385703444480896,
-0.9101912379264832,
0.32748958468437195,
-0.20074698328971863,
0.5091733336448669,
0.8048518300056458,
0.054325252771377563,
0.8917403221130371,
-0.6575214862823486,
0.7747980356216431,
0.4745995104312897,
-0.20863685011863708,
0.5469062328338623,
-0.19535358250141144,
0.3020917773246765,
0.31976354122161865,
0.2681155204772949,
-0.850614070892334,
-0.9247527122497559,
-0.4795359671115875,
-0.4567945599555969,
0.5018641948699951,
0.06299978494644165,
-0.1911105364561081,
-0.014962075278162956,
0.4544334411621094,
0.04781901463866234,
0.1546878069639206,
-0.38081276416778564,
-0.31045958399772644,
0.0891878753900528,
-0.3522537052631378,
0.2909219563007355,
-0.33061909675598145,
-0.5725564360618591,
-0.27415919303894043,
0.513831615447998,
0.014897206798195839,
0.58939528465271,
0.573555588722229,
0.27604517340660095,
-0.07922602444887161,
0.22102802991867065,
0.6726206541061401,
0.47939690947532654,
-0.001998898573219776,
0.0627044066786766,
0.16344423592090607,
-0.7956103086471558,
0.017170336097478867,
-0.10667551308870316,
0.24284841120243073,
0.05957924947142601,
0.3712071180343628,
0.4830586016178131,
-0.12594938278198242,
-0.8143230080604553,
0.11050327867269516,
-0.07705328613519669,
-0.23521699011325836,
-0.121049664914608,
0.1771394908428192,
0.01433733943849802,
0.3482152223587036,
0.09372939169406891,
0.05003674700856209,
0.14340081810951233,
-0.12040436267852783,
0.2636404037475586,
0.5437900424003601,
-0.3563433885574341,
0.10066147893667221,
0.7301687002182007,
0.3372064530849457,
-0.4457528293132782,
0.4085582494735718,
0.30026155710220337,
-0.3396204113960266,
0.27697789669036865,
0.5285910367965698,
0.6081872582435608,
-0.1906171441078186,
-0.005175475031137466,
0.39996564388275146,
0.27667155861854553,
0.22510911524295807,
0.3150770664215088,
-0.04573614150285721,
-0.6274268627166748,
-0.5966809391975403,
-0.42870762944221497,
-0.5133920907974243,
0.5592291355133057,
-0.28957241773605347,
0.24986693263053894,
-0.43734827637672424,
-0.22579413652420044,
-0.0923587828874588,
-0.13906626403331757,
-0.36574411392211914,
0.0265114177018404,
0.10452684015035629,
0.8950490355491638,
-0.5804168581962585,
0.6338021755218506,
0.4650757312774658,
-0.18741971254348755,
-0.5779950618743896,
-0.19162413477897644,
0.04650777950882912,
-0.9653773903846741,
0.37627026438713074,
0.04689484462141991,
-0.00035523937549442053,
-0.17116451263427734,
-0.3865044414997101,
-0.5168951153755188,
0.9248831272125244,
0.40422654151916504,
-0.36377599835395813,
-0.18503260612487793,
0.7563682794570923,
0.5655242204666138,
-0.5725297927856445,
0.1214374303817749,
0.45440390706062317,
0.2588975131511688,
0.2892848253250122,
-0.903601884841919,
0.29554614424705505,
-0.10310851782560349,
-0.2888390123844147,
0.2168450504541397,
-0.0070319510996341705,
-0.21496060490608215,
-0.18925540149211884,
-0.06475293636322021,
0.19390104711055756,
-0.05307888239622116,
0.31286749243736267,
0.13161608576774597,
0.36436641216278076,
0.44177696108818054,
0.6209008097648621,
-0.027046170085668564,
0.8519809246063232,
-0.8135393857955933,
-0.3126792907714844,
0.9446719288825989,
-0.19949081540107727,
0.33062997460365295,
0.6218884587287903,
-0.19926714897155762,
0.24640046060085297,
0.6082221865653992,
0.11203650385141373,
0.500969409942627,
0.02660875767469406,
-0.5699038505554199,
-0.3958578407764435,
-0.2461315244436264,
-0.5155817270278931,
-0.03644588962197304,
0.7248057126998901,
-0.5965947508811951,
-0.1003497764468193,
0.040174275636672974,
0.0011721355840563774,
-0.08373496681451797,
-0.2822795510292053,
1.136957049369812,
0.2472716122865677,
-0.8110601305961609,
0.5365437865257263,
-0.3368575870990753,
0.2982085347175598,
-0.9697754383087158,
-0.39401617646217346,
-0.09463440626859665,
0.10316304117441177,
-0.3825942277908325,
-0.5388188362121582,
0.1666349619626999,
-0.32405611872673035,
0.03972630947828293,
-0.09890903532505035,
0.9826934933662415,
-0.5369876027107239,
-0.4293690621852875,
0.1555156707763672,
0.3658430874347687,
0.26000022888183594,
0.37667593359947205,
-0.7305202484130859,
-0.24743042886257172,
0.04236564785242081,
0.18342822790145874,
0.2390098124742508,
0.2900872230529785,
0.4782966077327728,
0.9474363923072815,
0.8355273604393005,
0.7202995419502258,
0.01971467211842537,
0.3612273633480072,
0.941001832485199,
-0.38380131125450134,
-0.4583693742752075,
-0.5766022801399231,
0.5117524862289429,
-0.26662421226501465,
0.1906713843345642,
0.4905908405780792,
0.5069995522499084,
0.37930911779403687,
-0.03389090672135353,
0.7317262291908264,
0.27046462893486023,
0.7134683728218079,
-0.776944637298584,
0.7692455649375916,
-0.28187793493270874,
0.4604736268520355,
-0.4083525538444519,
-0.5160462856292725,
-0.3864108622074127,
0.5055202841758728,
0.021455205976963043,
-0.06051355600357056,
0.7390680313110352,
0.8212318420410156,
0.2059721201658249,
-0.051434896886348724,
0.5639799237251282,
0.4029060900211334,
0.34350672364234924,
0.6764110326766968,
0.8317341804504395,
-0.06051158159971237,
0.3991042971611023,
-0.255033016204834,
-0.3174766004085541,
0.06131352111697197,
-0.5748679041862488,
-0.8867917656898499,
-0.4676399230957031,
-0.1267109215259552,
-0.7020883560180664,
-0.039803676307201385,
1.1546372175216675,
0.5582248568534851,
-0.4175289571285248,
0.010059460066258907,
-0.174531489610672,
-0.16174449026584625,
-0.01687268540263176,
-0.20558378100395203,
0.1992790549993515,
-0.5622453689575195,
-0.269098699092865,
0.46409377455711365,
0.59503173828125,
0.20358695089817047,
-0.4178951680660248,
-0.35051482915878296,
0.23981942236423492,
0.018533218652009964,
0.3782161474227905,
0.06091722100973129,
-0.5634810328483582,
-0.05416536331176758,
0.16806863248348236,
0.04894628748297691,
0.4686293303966522,
1.0876046419143677,
-0.7707475423812866,
0.8149415254592896,
0.16928009688854218,
0.8078404068946838,
0.18045379221439362,
-0.22515609860420227,
0.849072277545929,
-0.4224531948566437,
0.13943912088871002,
0.3787311017513275,
0.32232025265693665,
0.1807641088962555,
-0.49265727400779724,
0.3986629247665405,
0.31136202812194824,
-0.5623964667320251,
-0.7649868130683899,
0.45420247316360474,
-0.6483467221260071,
-0.15434858202934265,
0.9664519429206848,
0.10238741338253021,
0.27716100215911865,
-0.6589909791946411,
-0.5535991787910461,
0.2008068561553955,
-0.12172139436006546,
1.0722476243972778,
0.6245709657669067,
-0.5715888142585754,
-0.05473591014742851,
-0.8578199148178101,
0.9809194207191467,
0.34054797887802124,
-1.074892282485962,
0.14466506242752075,
0.6552243232727051,
0.016776759177446365,
0.17451073229312897,
0.9557015299797058,
-0.2857474088668823,
0.2815248966217041,
-0.023280436173081398,
-0.1386563926935196,
0.005378061439841986,
0.007887428626418114,
-0.2037591189146042,
0.0040073818527162075,
-0.05492042005062103,
-0.04846486449241638
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06609v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06609v2
|
Guiding Clinical Reasoning with Large Language Models via Knowledge Seeds
| 2024-03-11T10:53:20 | 2024-06-08T04:14:46 |
Jiageng WU, Xian Wu, Jie Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Clinical reasoning refers to the cognitive process that physicians employ in
evaluating and managing patients. This process typically involves suggesting
necessary examinations, diagnosing patients' diseases, and deciding on
appropriate therapies, etc. Accurate clinical reasoning requires extensive
medical knowledge and rich clinical experience, setting a high bar for
physicians. This is particularly challenging in developing countries due to the
overwhelming number of patients and limited physician resources, contributing
significantly to global health inequity and necessitating automated clinical
reasoning approaches. Recently, the emergence of large language models (LLMs)
such as ChatGPT and GPT-4 have demonstrated their potential in clinical
reasoning. However, these LLMs are prone to hallucination problems, and the
reasoning process of LLMs may not align with the clinical decision path of
physicians. In this study, we introduce a novel framework, In-Context Padding
(ICP), designed to enhance LLMs with medical knowledge. Specifically, we infer
critical clinical reasoning elements (referred to as knowledge seeds) and use
these as anchors to guide the generation process of LLMs. Experiments on two
clinical question datasets demonstrate that ICP significantly improves the
clinical reasoning ability of LLMs.
|
[
-0.16715148091316223,
-0.7161188125610352,
1.0865654945373535,
0.24247246980667114,
-0.2260054498910904,
-0.07165078073740005,
-0.3819049298763275,
-0.2902514636516571,
-0.015483253635466099,
0.5511935353279114,
-0.25784510374069214,
-0.6405534744262695,
-0.6261904835700989,
0.010952017270028591,
0.18958379328250885,
0.7572678327560425,
-0.1330210268497467,
0.32486703991889954,
-0.441845566034317,
-0.10582315921783447,
-0.6347272396087646,
-0.45133474469184875,
-0.4172201454639435,
-0.33655309677124023,
0.02722688391804695,
0.593255877494812,
0.5655418038368225,
0.5672846436500549,
0.4236690104007721,
0.18684163689613342,
-0.0337388701736927,
0.43137848377227783,
-0.2708342373371124,
0.42197126150131226,
-0.16519294679164886,
-0.35036394000053406,
-0.28677037358283997,
-0.2563140392303467,
0.17584767937660217,
0.9620624780654907,
-0.21617478132247925,
-0.37423810362815857,
0.07330957800149918,
0.27121347188949585,
-0.45448848605155945,
0.09304502606391907,
-0.6446791887283325,
0.17543691396713257,
-0.013561164028942585,
-0.6602100133895874,
-0.48550572991371155,
-0.4251597821712494,
0.3522661328315735,
-0.666600227355957,
0.27740490436553955,
-0.13781410455703735,
0.5515400767326355,
0.1350395828485489,
-0.3877004384994507,
-0.563098669052124,
-0.28623244166374207,
0.6995384693145752,
-0.8905502557754517,
0.0455598384141922,
0.6644256114959717,
0.1985461413860321,
-0.5409043431282043,
-0.5679135918617249,
-0.4845139980316162,
-0.15194660425186157,
-0.19867904484272003,
-0.11639324575662613,
0.23784895241260529,
0.35082754492759705,
0.3438475430011749,
0.1517297774553299,
-0.3682311475276947,
-0.021637236699461937,
-0.20019440352916718,
-0.12430086731910706,
0.48609793186187744,
0.07836979627609253,
0.5157222151756287,
-0.05683860555291176,
-0.2819055914878845,
-0.010962819680571556,
-1.050270438194275,
-0.0595603883266449,
-0.4944103956222534,
0.1266895830631256,
-0.12956508994102478,
0.3771113455295563,
-0.04136452078819275,
0.8370545506477356,
-0.14018461108207703,
-0.5648074746131897,
-0.05134373903274536,
0.11777788400650024,
-0.38737913966178894,
0.36666086316108704,
0.5916340351104736,
0.5709483623504639,
0.18675296008586884,
-0.12166494131088257,
0.17533434927463531,
0.24152995645999908,
0.34229737520217896,
-0.8150399327278137,
-0.2399379312992096,
0.39986279606819153,
-0.45126283168792725,
-0.42223411798477173,
-0.3260907828807831,
-0.7521892189979553,
-0.7828400135040283,
-0.1582481414079666,
0.18183065950870514,
-0.8398979306221008,
-0.023385748267173767,
0.4153008460998535,
-0.03236759454011917,
0.19192413985729218,
0.6317322254180908,
-0.8603999018669128,
0.2014438360929489,
0.7001107335090637,
0.7363360524177551,
0.18523678183555603,
0.1865829974412918,
-0.4039165675640106,
0.5224636793136597,
-0.420204758644104,
0.8694053292274475,
-0.8071144223213196,
-0.6365030407905579,
0.2855933904647827,
-0.07890097796916962,
-0.20363552868366241,
-0.4856698513031006,
0.6635378003120422,
-0.19786886870861053,
0.1418641060590744,
-0.5802754163742065,
-0.7789555788040161,
-0.14037400484085083,
0.5056736469268799,
0.03640829399228096,
0.506210207939148,
0.10548614710569382,
-0.6686165928840637,
0.6492123007774353,
-0.5976781249046326,
-0.5416334271430969,
0.32989850640296936,
-0.8964972496032715,
-0.3069194555282593,
0.06079000607132912,
0.6569664478302002,
0.5166405439376831,
-0.627764105796814,
0.40868380665779114,
-0.4347856044769287,
-0.10681846737861633,
0.35314637422561646,
-0.09764021635055542,
0.6060310006141663,
0.31327617168426514,
-0.36546480655670166,
0.04900050163269043,
-0.6321888566017151,
0.12248382717370987,
-0.05514689162373543,
-0.040190014988183975,
-0.5062462687492371,
0.054761748760938644,
-0.4030805826187134,
0.31407031416893005,
-0.39321377873420715,
-0.502434253692627,
0.6568002700805664,
-0.3376392126083374,
0.7140219211578369,
0.5328047871589661,
0.395649790763855,
0.132267028093338,
-0.3497283458709717,
0.6754617691040039,
0.10586326569318771,
0.20540779829025269,
-0.36118730902671814,
-0.758564829826355,
-0.6964067816734314,
-0.25011053681373596,
-0.18495109677314758,
0.3673607409000397,
-0.7584159970283508,
0.27183839678764343,
-0.19561438262462616,
-0.40245234966278076,
-0.4741578698158264,
-0.022899171337485313,
0.37282681465148926,
0.8941664099693298,
0.49523138999938965,
-0.04824824258685112,
-0.314222514629364,
-0.6153789162635803,
0.024698780849575996,
-0.06461226940155029,
0.1393292099237442,
0.42944595217704773,
0.4943667948246002,
-0.20308999717235565,
0.7654024958610535,
-0.7234559059143066,
-0.42499881982803345,
-0.40038010478019714,
-0.1594645380973816,
0.0984448492527008,
0.6992948055267334,
0.22570262849330902,
-0.6529860496520996,
-0.2951717674732208,
0.13128484785556793,
-1.0646976232528687,
-0.23399630188941956,
-0.24306946992874146,
-0.3530358076095581,
-0.24387769401073456,
0.7472746968269348,
-0.7873733043670654,
0.5046833753585815,
0.2821941375732422,
-0.6379464864730835,
0.44550657272338867,
-0.5754354596138,
0.1458214968442917,
-1.11588716506958,
-0.07393275946378708,
0.0020267509389668703,
-0.09802959114313126,
-0.5675875544548035,
0.004423609934747219,
0.11450935900211334,
-0.05299043655395508,
-0.08709301799535751,
0.6006424427032471,
-0.33718279004096985,
0.39381083846092224,
-0.23242180049419403,
0.038033295422792435,
0.22442911565303802,
0.07182111591100693,
0.3642491102218628,
0.6769735813140869,
0.5098918080329895,
-0.6248107552528381,
-0.015098039992153645,
0.5317767262458801,
-0.5658941268920898,
0.6346133351325989,
-0.6025940179824829,
-0.043376389890909195,
0.00648422772064805,
0.4950995445251465,
-0.5361312627792358,
-0.4479809105396271,
0.004545492120087147,
-0.27121198177337646,
0.3243851959705353,
-0.5251886248588562,
-0.3961184024810791,
-0.35662922263145447,
0.11269216984510422,
0.5426605343818665,
0.43994179368019104,
-0.32963624596595764,
0.12771329283714294,
0.5461408495903015,
-0.2983179986476898,
-0.3899688720703125,
-0.5534678101539612,
0.0654284730553627,
-0.2591685652732849,
-0.7071981430053711,
0.45393627882003784,
0.10765065252780914,
-0.3898659944534302,
-0.2607771158218384,
0.1893361359834671,
-0.03541649878025055,
-0.17518945038318634,
0.31181800365448,
0.2179262489080429,
-0.3365890383720398,
0.6209558844566345,
0.3279690146446228,
-0.14358475804328918,
0.027576643973588943,
-0.4914950430393219,
0.47019436955451965,
-0.013419453985989094,
-0.7123841047286987,
-0.1442435085773468,
0.37538859248161316,
0.5995429158210754,
-0.15916307270526886,
0.8889504075050354,
0.0661069005727768,
-0.5238426923751831,
-0.27226927876472473,
-0.9225340485572815,
-0.44283774495124817,
-0.3962370753288269,
0.13818715512752533,
-0.269422322511673,
-0.8809001445770264,
0.258735716342926,
-0.2911149263381958,
-0.234760582447052,
0.20719586312770844,
0.8218762278556824,
-0.10927601903676987,
1.0539581775665283,
0.44796866178512573,
0.29012390971183777,
-0.35594120621681213,
-0.19879592955112457,
0.3100999593734741,
-0.9706023335456848,
-0.36683759093284607,
-0.3139570951461792,
-0.013689090497791767,
-0.37729015946388245,
-0.9621685743331909,
0.8410760760307312,
0.21195299923419952,
-0.1416662484407425,
-0.20372426509857178,
-0.6702725887298584,
0.3736876845359802,
0.32482799887657166,
0.26814842224121094,
0.19334185123443604,
-0.09126512706279755,
-0.6552764773368835,
-0.07076576352119446,
-0.987276554107666,
-0.6138978600502014,
0.9707971215248108,
0.2763651907444,
0.5637447834014893,
-0.04795096069574356,
0.3362266719341278,
0.053022630512714386,
0.33963820338249207,
-0.3569904863834381,
0.4130594730377197,
0.1323244720697403,
-0.3212827444076538,
-0.20631888508796692,
-0.1885858178138733,
-0.9984002709388733,
0.39961686730384827,
-0.2597256898880005,
-0.7301278710365295,
0.30725452303886414,
0.1951725035905838,
-0.7052698731422424,
0.3482481837272644,
-0.5438007712364197,
0.8222905397415161,
-0.1419927179813385,
-0.42072075605392456,
-0.12545239925384521,
-0.684334397315979,
0.34362566471099854,
0.23795485496520996,
0.3481299579143524,
-0.029784392565488815,
0.195221409201622,
0.39173105359077454,
-0.8543297052383423,
0.8746709227561951,
-0.362741082906723,
-0.06443319469690323,
0.2476317286491394,
0.22370554506778717,
0.45797520875930786,
0.35127055644989014,
-0.022505588829517365,
-0.2369057983160019,
0.09372025728225708,
-0.47635558247566223,
-0.48857060074806213,
0.8644097447395325,
-0.5693919658660889,
-0.6901870369911194,
-0.40283551812171936,
-0.7186975479125977,
-0.6892784237861633,
0.008034825325012207,
0.20785893499851227,
0.47041478753089905,
0.02036261186003685,
0.27819666266441345,
0.9523832201957703,
-0.8633044362068176,
-0.10068095475435257,
0.45351263880729675,
-0.03964893892407417,
-0.23208852112293243,
0.440586119890213,
-0.10618685185909271,
0.30078548192977905,
0.30215170979499817,
0.4944663345813751,
-0.1944354921579361,
-0.7798107862472534,
-0.3264591693878174,
0.40584370493888855,
-0.8183889389038086,
-0.26494288444519043,
-0.8594279885292053,
-0.19225558638572693,
-0.6598204970359802,
-0.5425117611885071,
0.05148577317595482,
-0.11462230235338211,
0.12155161052942276,
-0.11941662430763245,
0.5386256575584412,
0.5320649743080139,
0.2614250183105469,
0.2614820897579193,
-0.880124568939209,
0.12587806582450867,
0.14645540714263916,
0.2779272794723511,
-0.02435559406876564,
-0.37391698360443115,
-0.11233775317668915,
-0.04423827305436134,
-0.3681531548500061,
-0.8141537308692932,
0.53775554895401,
-0.14839671552181244,
0.49483010172843933,
0.7712738513946533,
0.14107047021389008,
1.0450795888900757,
-0.45612362027168274,
0.6274285316467285,
0.1096140593290329,
-0.5841542482376099,
0.811008870601654,
-0.5275521278381348,
0.22226323187351227,
0.5002430081367493,
0.21503864228725433,
-0.7135053277015686,
-0.39471304416656494,
-0.6671671867370605,
-0.6982154250144958,
0.3927113115787506,
0.09406843036413193,
-0.06599445641040802,
-0.36614951491355896,
0.3913308382034302,
0.2518879175186157,
0.16027365624904633,
-0.4632945656776428,
0.3846481740474701,
0.0761168822646141,
-0.29443758726119995,
0.10177585482597351,
-0.4380633533000946,
-0.5410180687904358,
-0.26643356680870056,
0.6575192809104919,
-0.3792140781879425,
0.023728638887405396,
0.6101544499397278,
-0.12725409865379333,
-0.041554756462574005,
0.34804463386535645,
0.7198274731636047,
0.7070709466934204,
-0.03418237715959549,
0.21906426548957825,
0.0656595379114151,
-0.3654695749282837,
-0.004196527414023876,
0.004755786620080471,
-0.1525782197713852,
-0.4260653257369995,
0.5682345032691956,
0.6080113053321838,
0.145288348197937,
-0.9186705350875854,
0.680625855922699,
0.08917097002267838,
-0.12935049831867218,
-0.29817521572113037,
-0.04248695820569992,
0.12552383542060852,
0.1594894677400589,
-0.12518452107906342,
0.009306211024522781,
-0.08259563148021698,
-0.2250863015651703,
0.13361379504203796,
0.37222301959991455,
-0.501994788646698,
0.007369457744061947,
0.5818802714347839,
0.19759170711040497,
0.20207782089710236,
0.855446994304657,
0.0746646523475647,
-0.4009969234466553,
0.5203561186790466,
0.815146803855896,
0.4654575288295746,
-0.027267131954431534,
0.13548755645751953,
0.28833481669425964,
0.11750859767198563,
-0.11443635821342468,
0.18796080350875854,
-0.116907998919487,
-0.8174943923950195,
-0.6106336712837219,
-0.42858338356018066,
-0.36018112301826477,
0.3307604193687439,
-0.25713810324668884,
0.2918109893798828,
-0.32951200008392334,
-0.043980371206998825,
-0.2708075940608978,
-0.26689785718917847,
-0.5197856426239014,
0.33438023924827576,
0.11193627864122391,
0.9919369220733643,
-0.7149006724357605,
1.046817660331726,
0.5499382615089417,
-0.3769020140171051,
-0.7697327136993408,
0.009377839975059032,
0.06185156852006912,
-0.9659945368766785,
0.5219770669937134,
0.23740363121032715,
0.34464940428733826,
-0.5104535222053528,
-0.34884151816368103,
-0.6237420439720154,
1.0047109127044678,
0.19867120683193207,
-0.3524095118045807,
0.010133912786841393,
0.3012993633747101,
0.4984973669052124,
-0.554533839225769,
0.2636495530605316,
0.44899216294288635,
0.32919323444366455,
0.27621421217918396,
-0.6758070588111877,
0.28825023770332336,
-0.3616701066493988,
-0.12981830537319183,
0.023418713361024857,
-0.23066624999046326,
0.6155202388763428,
-0.5878793597221375,
0.25552791357040405,
0.04927049204707146,
0.18448828160762787,
0.871353268623352,
0.2797553241252899,
0.3904775083065033,
0.638300895690918,
0.8730391263961792,
-0.11208730190992355,
1.2906641960144043,
-0.5396764278411865,
-0.166824072599411,
1.0231648683547974,
-0.490033358335495,
0.46934422850608826,
0.7094942331314087,
-0.045735787600278854,
0.5217313170433044,
0.41779157519340515,
0.11767341941595078,
0.3394125699996948,
0.3542592525482178,
-0.44845911860466003,
-0.42694291472435,
-0.3263993561267853,
-0.6841393113136292,
0.3196743130683899,
0.8830159902572632,
-0.6365691423416138,
0.03308780491352081,
0.03879920765757561,
0.4115767478942871,
0.2007831633090973,
-0.05700227618217468,
0.714486837387085,
0.3170829713344574,
-1.0725061893463135,
0.46141499280929565,
-0.10071634501218796,
0.09008491784334183,
-0.7663331031799316,
-0.38804665207862854,
-0.2193402796983719,
0.4133080542087555,
-0.13424022495746613,
-0.7345409989356995,
-0.03429976478219032,
-0.03227601572871208,
0.006227044854313135,
-0.36987119913101196,
0.8097625970840454,
-0.38133949041366577,
-0.6176660060882568,
0.011530074290931225,
0.4152374565601349,
0.09552615135908127,
-0.04278977960348129,
-0.4578142464160919,
-0.05987121909856796,
-0.04401742294430733,
-0.010331438854336739,
0.45665302872657776,
0.9035946726799011,
-0.3052007257938385,
0.9069982171058655,
0.8062637448310852,
0.5721927285194397,
-0.28314054012298584,
0.41177815198898315,
0.9119674563407898,
-0.5104328989982605,
-0.6205688118934631,
-0.9094399213790894,
0.2151014804840088,
-0.38490530848503113,
-0.1592607945203781,
0.5197488069534302,
0.33570972084999084,
0.3156798183917999,
-0.09993678331375122,
0.9877106547355652,
0.011056327261030674,
0.4694143235683441,
-0.6188645958900452,
0.7491448521614075,
-0.3082372844219208,
0.5098320841789246,
-0.42606496810913086,
-0.25739532709121704,
-0.7053171992301941,
0.7830378413200378,
-0.5397936105728149,
0.043687790632247925,
0.5843203067779541,
0.775879442691803,
0.10346625745296478,
0.12941409647464752,
0.36371850967407227,
0.5153204798698425,
0.7765073180198669,
0.7990201711654663,
0.7101334929466248,
0.0071471380069851875,
0.21864277124404907,
-0.31651732325553894,
-0.4552152454853058,
-0.16589005291461945,
-1.0195292234420776,
-0.7954705953598022,
-0.3073487877845764,
-0.2613838016986847,
-0.517440676689148,
0.11523690819740295,
1.2797679901123047,
0.9237672686576843,
-0.786083459854126,
-0.011399098671972752,
-0.3886217474937439,
-0.10167896002531052,
-0.2703723907470703,
-0.18449130654335022,
0.8155214190483093,
-0.5638810396194458,
-0.12083643674850464,
0.41336724162101746,
0.5438458919525146,
-0.0049889711663126945,
-0.07226508110761642,
-0.1739879995584488,
-0.1143481507897377,
-0.07335668057203293,
0.6382631063461304,
0.17459110915660858,
-0.6942703723907471,
-0.09607859700918198,
-0.23227083683013916,
0.041112951934337616,
0.14243899285793304,
1.2189488410949707,
-0.9770598411560059,
0.7102324366569519,
0.19977721571922302,
0.5620850920677185,
0.1544117033481598,
-0.19288796186447144,
0.955193042755127,
-0.31402555108070374,
0.3405070900917053,
0.4963138997554779,
0.564558744430542,
0.34589847922325134,
-0.22550928592681885,
0.3773772120475769,
0.2536470293998718,
-0.6871721744537354,
-0.8356066346168518,
0.128271222114563,
-0.7552827596664429,
-0.40841150283813477,
1.306482195854187,
-0.23071129620075226,
0.12191351503133774,
-0.260104775428772,
-0.4708538353443146,
0.16307637095451355,
-0.14392176270484924,
1.194356083869934,
0.5477619767189026,
-0.3212568759918213,
-0.021996207535266876,
-0.6606935262680054,
0.8723160624504089,
0.4468238651752472,
-0.9667593836784363,
0.0509255975484848,
0.2407958209514618,
0.1316555291414261,
-0.10204111039638519,
0.8850239515304565,
-0.5560766458511353,
0.2214258313179016,
-0.010831508785486221,
-0.05828440561890602,
0.2367897927761078,
0.033773284405469894,
0.2040299028158188,
0.2431994527578354,
0.15592990815639496,
0.08277787268161774
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06591v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06591v1
|
Academically intelligent LLMs are not necessarily socially intelligent
| 2024-03-11T10:35:53 | 2024-03-11T10:35:53 |
Ruoxi Xu, Hongyu Lin, Xianpei Han, Le Sun, Yingfei Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY
|
The academic intelligence of large language models (LLMs) has made remarkable
progress in recent times, but their social intelligence performance remains
unclear. Inspired by established human social intelligence frameworks,
particularly Daniel Goleman's social intelligence theory, we have developed a
standardized social intelligence test based on real-world social scenarios to
comprehensively assess the social intelligence of LLMs, termed as the
Situational Evaluation of Social Intelligence (SESI). We conducted an extensive
evaluation with 13 recent popular and state-of-art LLM agents on SESI. The
results indicate the social intelligence of LLMs still has significant room for
improvement, with superficially friendliness as a primary reason for errors.
Moreover, there exists a relatively low correlation between the social
intelligence and academic intelligence exhibited by LLMs, suggesting that
social intelligence is distinct from academic intelligence for LLMs.
Additionally, while it is observed that LLMs can't ``understand'' what social
intelligence is, their social intelligence, similar to that of humans, is
influenced by social factors.
|
[
-0.03571907430887222,
-0.9040188789367676,
0.8214187026023865,
0.15932951867580414,
0.028434008359909058,
0.8238561153411865,
-0.4133235812187195,
-0.5924007892608643,
0.6185367107391357,
-0.17571114003658295,
-0.5223374962806702,
-0.5330742001533508,
-0.5842077136039734,
0.17243698239326477,
-0.2779359519481659,
0.6635457277297974,
0.3902176320552826,
0.11909499764442444,
-0.5091133713722229,
-0.44786855578422546,
0.13383695483207703,
-0.4926247000694275,
-0.6885830760002136,
-0.3820425271987915,
0.5877444744110107,
0.3890642821788788,
0.6816311478614807,
0.19346825778484344,
0.7757566571235657,
0.42265820503234863,
-0.47188496589660645,
0.20584167540073395,
-0.8270364999771118,
-0.011650791391730309,
-0.31427767872810364,
-0.28571444749832153,
-0.5626156330108643,
0.13453060388565063,
0.615739643573761,
0.9261631965637207,
-0.11068358272314072,
0.33831363916397095,
0.08373484015464783,
0.9101806282997131,
-0.3620598018169403,
0.05002729222178459,
-0.6397088766098022,
-0.27770912647247314,
-0.14042052626609802,
-0.044731687754392624,
-0.46253523230552673,
-0.6702199578285217,
0.16742518544197083,
-0.3326283395290375,
-0.13182099163532257,
0.24682605266571045,
0.6535002589225769,
-0.007275020238012075,
-0.33983439207077026,
-0.03822896257042885,
-0.6827707886695862,
0.8294615745544434,
-0.5470570921897888,
0.05509401485323906,
0.020707031711935997,
0.3891909420490265,
-0.478716641664505,
-0.48930177092552185,
-0.46961233019828796,
-0.32629719376564026,
0.16847734153270721,
0.3116110563278198,
0.4417605400085449,
-0.13369721174240112,
0.027652839198708534,
-0.10393879562616348,
-0.4241078794002533,
0.04245585948228836,
-0.48927420377731323,
0.22108010947704315,
1.0500237941741943,
0.39779990911483765,
0.3934171795845032,
-0.1494847536087036,
-0.3225354254245758,
0.1398412138223648,
-0.6484861969947815,
0.40769580006599426,
0.14634265005588531,
0.07167714834213257,
-0.2179861068725586,
0.48454734683036804,
-0.27002424001693726,
-0.07973117381334305,
-0.28886425495147705,
-0.10465097427368164,
0.3628648519515991,
-0.33994919061660767,
0.06991901993751526,
0.04011939465999603,
0.710005521774292,
0.5085840821266174,
0.8088632822036743,
-0.2342267781496048,
-0.21273821592330933,
0.2883961498737335,
0.19306056201457977,
-0.6037786602973938,
0.1700628250837326,
0.09984643757343292,
-0.4658381938934326,
-0.46713605523109436,
0.18131627142429352,
-0.5721904635429382,
-0.4169890582561493,
-0.18208980560302734,
0.2189561426639557,
-0.2767525315284729,
-0.26394256949424744,
-0.27720746397972107,
-0.11521953344345093,
0.6795413494110107,
0.26964807510375977,
-0.5703964829444885,
0.2541391849517822,
0.922075629234314,
0.8717261552810669,
-0.4379189610481262,
-0.47176021337509155,
-0.09701069444417953,
0.14497314393520355,
-0.6666749715805054,
1.050449252128601,
-0.8972852230072021,
-0.5810208320617676,
0.15303783118724823,
0.08478853106498718,
-0.2612062096595764,
-0.4208512604236603,
0.20885306596755981,
-0.5699190497398376,
-0.40258216857910156,
-0.5457732081413269,
-0.4950461685657501,
0.044584184885025024,
0.2014586329460144,
-0.0646517425775528,
0.9581267237663269,
0.029823368415236473,
-0.4694846272468567,
0.1930236518383026,
-0.6833854913711548,
-0.4536912739276886,
0.5304948687553406,
-0.20210471749305725,
-0.007844089530408382,
0.05432705953717232,
-0.3756369650363922,
0.5281285643577576,
-0.09428660571575165,
0.4816027283668518,
-0.9941012859344482,
-0.9088373780250549,
0.752730131149292,
-0.3087595999240875,
0.6757916808128357,
-0.14621809124946594,
-0.2649819552898407,
0.02074485458433628,
-0.7905176877975464,
0.13546967506408691,
0.3843829333782196,
-0.3001277446746826,
-0.4243144094944,
0.33802950382232666,
-0.5540438294410706,
-0.05877644196152687,
0.552273154258728,
-0.5495447516441345,
-0.1341426968574524,
-0.39362838864326477,
0.5381055474281311,
1.1747949123382568,
0.05311723053455353,
0.39721986651420593,
-0.7640048861503601,
0.16215260326862335,
-0.4853382706642151,
0.10099814087152481,
0.5867313146591187,
-0.45054957270622253,
-0.8704105019569397,
-0.17388634383678436,
0.08579933643341064,
0.7181258201599121,
-0.5199849605560303,
0.30837902426719666,
-0.5639011263847351,
-0.8139997124671936,
-0.29170337319374084,
0.31386104226112366,
0.29615721106529236,
-0.19297204911708832,
-0.06550798565149307,
0.03936176002025604,
-0.1513596922159195,
-0.7509909868240356,
-0.7226631045341492,
-0.4185514748096466,
0.3033492863178253,
0.3836296796798706,
0.7783359885215759,
-0.2786892056465149,
0.3200749158859253,
-0.026598265394568443,
0.140123650431633,
-0.38811346888542175,
-0.26912015676498413,
0.004748354200273752,
0.16050061583518982,
0.24006713926792145,
-0.2881375551223755,
-0.24272257089614868,
-0.04494178295135498,
-1.0363709926605225,
-0.000574195000808686,
0.35612940788269043,
-0.2298625409603119,
0.05822443962097168,
0.7603355646133423,
-0.37090620398521423,
0.3636765778064728,
0.18049658834934235,
-0.49835073947906494,
0.37225988507270813,
-0.1903844177722931,
0.22185279428958893,
-0.7418091297149658,
-0.2961781919002533,
0.19284763932228088,
-0.11181804537773132,
-0.5922093391418457,
-0.1423792541027069,
-0.12914220988750458,
0.09525864571332932,
-0.4715608060359955,
0.6835487484931946,
-0.2584215998649597,
-0.29943472146987915,
0.25717538595199585,
0.6197500824928284,
-0.21218253672122955,
0.4576122462749481,
-0.3854716122150421,
0.6702815890312195,
0.2952905297279358,
-0.674869179725647,
0.3681824207305908,
-0.06236831843852997,
-0.5047362446784973,
0.8999739289283752,
-0.796634316444397,
0.36951929330825806,
-0.30994072556495667,
-0.19445165991783142,
-1.0182123184204102,
-0.5536249279975891,
-0.032447997480630875,
-0.44452103972435,
0.16213004291057587,
0.4379631280899048,
-0.34416675567626953,
-0.31964877247810364,
-0.6382307410240173,
0.046668656170368195,
0.6808714270591736,
-0.4467407166957855,
0.7021445035934448,
0.4304654896259308,
-0.5406665205955505,
-0.1886802613735199,
-0.42455971240997314,
-0.17668619751930237,
-0.26026707887649536,
-0.8681635856628418,
0.2611047327518463,
-0.30001094937324524,
-1.0087125301361084,
0.09056518226861954,
0.005691481754183769,
0.0819665715098381,
0.27313780784606934,
0.23916611075401306,
0.516984760761261,
-0.189219132065773,
0.0014831749722361565,
0.07562225311994553,
0.14742904901504517,
0.4344010055065155,
0.7233313918113708,
0.09727354347705841,
-0.4983028769493103,
-0.5685913562774658,
-0.34371277689933777,
-0.0004288384225219488,
0.7271999716758728,
0.02755778282880783,
0.8371577858924866,
-0.0819929763674736,
-0.2910166382789612,
-0.26683124899864197,
-0.5618260502815247,
-0.046087946742773056,
-0.4874206483364105,
0.5037413835525513,
-0.2603863775730133,
-0.8084921836853027,
0.6736941337585449,
-0.1277197003364563,
0.12173829227685928,
0.3337906301021576,
0.3041943907737732,
-0.4085344672203064,
1.144144892692566,
0.2707837224006653,
0.12648114562034607,
0.47507476806640625,
-0.23938773572444916,
0.28715598583221436,
-0.8044362664222717,
-0.5474042296409607,
-0.5143743753433228,
-0.5072100162506104,
-0.527156412601471,
0.040519267320632935,
0.15022191405296326,
-0.40069594979286194,
-0.4633900225162506,
-0.33959439396858215,
-0.3054095506668091,
0.695472002029419,
0.16942283511161804,
0.14775125682353973,
0.13948415219783783,
-0.1111740693449974,
0.2923540771007538,
0.18012762069702148,
-0.5157742500305176,
-0.9281966686248779,
0.8440555930137634,
0.4219733476638794,
0.7832313179969788,
0.4174952208995819,
0.5992246866226196,
0.3326740264892578,
0.48994219303131104,
-0.6384029388427734,
1.1039341688156128,
-0.13668979704380035,
-0.3008166253566742,
-0.37871065735816956,
-0.4511793255805969,
-0.6901837587356567,
0.0145613644272089,
-0.15304593741893768,
-0.7821309566497803,
0.1214052140712738,
-0.49521464109420776,
-0.42157697677612305,
-0.07543319463729858,
-0.7779049873352051,
0.707175076007843,
-0.4094959795475006,
-0.436000257730484,
-0.31300488114356995,
-0.5077849626541138,
0.24685567617416382,
-0.04380260407924652,
0.34862542152404785,
-0.7318791151046753,
0.003631914732977748,
0.9447288513183594,
-0.2495701164007187,
0.8561955094337463,
-0.14052675664424896,
0.431940495967865,
0.33034899830818176,
-0.0164816714823246,
0.5118081569671631,
0.20251010358333588,
-0.33106017112731934,
0.21070216596126556,
0.3710102140903473,
-0.6122363209724426,
-0.6948733329772949,
0.8825153112411499,
-1.0756285190582275,
-0.8354072570800781,
-0.5521007180213928,
-0.17819255590438843,
-0.17248757183551788,
-0.1562950164079666,
-0.10077042132616043,
0.4117072522640228,
-0.6312551498413086,
0.3548488914966583,
0.5873970985412598,
-0.017769549041986465,
0.41588294506073,
0.6029344797134399,
-0.0501464381814003,
-0.15720751881599426,
1.0068483352661133,
0.4996328353881836,
0.31955331563949585,
-0.16112421452999115,
0.020158205181360245,
-0.3340212106704712,
-0.43426209688186646,
-0.2802475690841675,
0.48395007848739624,
-0.9120798110961914,
0.2526833117008209,
-0.3862847685813904,
-0.48122891783714294,
-0.468037486076355,
-0.614668071269989,
-0.15656234323978424,
0.026170335710048676,
-0.2846493422985077,
-0.002919386839494109,
0.3451620638370514,
1.1322507858276367,
0.2312195599079132,
-0.07602842897176743,
-0.458853155374527,
-0.0691717267036438,
0.37182092666625977,
0.26093143224716187,
-0.22299621999263763,
-0.781234860420227,
0.07047595828771591,
-0.11106754094362259,
0.08890277147293091,
-0.7560867667198181,
-0.08066181093454361,
0.36779433488845825,
0.822961688041687,
0.5196791887283325,
0.2263800948858261,
0.5271228551864624,
-0.22707617282867432,
0.7751953601837158,
-0.3393108546733856,
-0.6250281929969788,
0.37954750657081604,
-0.001756797544658184,
0.091917484998703,
0.9015833735466003,
0.24500153958797455,
-0.1422652006149292,
-0.720657467842102,
-0.6643301844596863,
-0.5996115207672119,
0.5548131465911865,
-0.039667025208473206,
0.43196403980255127,
-0.3408794105052948,
0.594747006893158,
-0.3475551903247833,
-0.0524882934987545,
-0.7461832761764526,
-0.17749978601932526,
0.10956589132547379,
-0.42804276943206787,
-0.00750302616506815,
-0.5800567865371704,
0.036149438470602036,
-0.2096683830022812,
0.9028096795082092,
-0.004514850676059723,
0.0876530110836029,
0.14586931467056274,
0.08521223813295364,
0.0059279268607497215,
0.37288716435432434,
0.34350520372390747,
1.0539499521255493,
-0.2401633858680725,
0.10871422290802002,
0.6665614247322083,
-0.33959659934043884,
0.42919230461120605,
-0.2200108766555786,
-0.018437912687659264,
-0.26869434118270874,
0.31195130944252014,
0.40845686197280884,
0.3414139449596405,
-0.7785815596580505,
0.7979212403297424,
-0.25488796830177307,
-0.3641323149204254,
-0.9102298021316528,
0.4853101074695587,
0.3334978222846985,
0.4918574392795563,
0.18196944892406464,
-0.05147348716855049,
-0.15013885498046875,
-0.7950087189674377,
-0.26785680651664734,
0.781798779964447,
-0.48132485151290894,
-0.341482937335968,
0.30646541714668274,
0.5098057985305786,
-0.7931191921234131,
0.36727121472358704,
-0.7175939083099365,
-0.4406336545944214,
0.8353968858718872,
0.4164487421512604,
0.6356387138366699,
-0.14319013059139252,
0.2974272072315216,
-0.07327405363321304,
0.5122697353363037,
-0.007966911420226097,
0.4426022469997406,
0.24966633319854736,
-0.87074875831604,
-0.35882842540740967,
-0.64896160364151,
-0.5266960263252258,
-0.00038073290488682687,
-0.3128511309623718,
0.2637316584587097,
-0.7661696672439575,
-0.05028446018695831,
-0.12308163940906525,
0.22188985347747803,
-0.5600530505180359,
0.030929267406463623,
-0.20882302522659302,
0.9260016679763794,
-0.6725562810897827,
0.6007890701293945,
1.1118268966674805,
0.04802205041050911,
-0.7719224095344543,
-0.1755320131778717,
-0.013223139569163322,
-0.8351550102233887,
0.7591113448143005,
0.49312686920166016,
-0.4235868453979492,
0.03371579945087433,
-0.4815676510334015,
-0.7273102402687073,
1.1118496656417847,
0.15922392904758453,
-0.4426380693912506,
0.03831887245178223,
-0.06497813761234283,
0.6309958696365356,
-0.5492023229598999,
0.3778146505355835,
0.6589393019676208,
0.45665988326072693,
0.10716085135936737,
-0.14802969992160797,
-0.10771604627370834,
-0.7246158719062805,
0.2774486541748047,
-0.08110484480857849,
-1.0465439558029175,
0.18533362448215485,
-0.33670344948768616,
-0.4082159698009491,
0.06521959602832794,
0.8432598114013672,
0.3670368790626526,
0.7198877930641174,
0.30539485812187195,
0.27600860595703125,
0.9852914214134216,
-0.1623416244983673,
1.0079604387283325,
-0.6137273907661438,
-0.09315630793571472,
0.5911984443664551,
-0.7656039595603943,
0.8454642295837402,
0.17769581079483032,
-0.2218005210161209,
0.7403256297111511,
0.7838776707649231,
0.13639028370380402,
0.40094780921936035,
0.11583268642425537,
-0.5548389554023743,
-0.42420199513435364,
-0.09956096112728119,
-0.13673026859760284,
0.3938746452331543,
0.4151066541671753,
-0.19575051963329315,
0.3987322151660919,
-0.3921439051628113,
-0.03384396433830261,
0.27440714836120605,
-0.42866241931915283,
0.861665666103363,
0.24686656892299652,
-0.5512550473213196,
0.13687406480312347,
-0.06721183657646179,
0.5426238179206848,
-0.3265734016895294,
0.20601055026054382,
-0.2842112183570862,
0.11812739074230194,
-0.17009517550468445,
-0.6581005454063416,
0.3812991976737976,
0.12347137928009033,
0.11625368148088455,
0.19228415191173553,
1.017088770866394,
0.09772694110870361,
-0.5285685658454895,
0.6818915605545044,
0.8767350316047668,
0.5164836645126343,
0.40417060256004333,
-0.5938522815704346,
-0.1227446049451828,
-0.24154983460903168,
-0.5005991458892822,
0.3923394978046417,
0.6789063215255737,
0.11173839122056961,
0.8867800831794739,
0.7178906798362732,
0.1870526820421219,
-0.17164459824562073,
0.2719350755214691,
0.5779155492782593,
-0.7997131943702698,
-0.07277059555053711,
-1.2279133796691895,
0.2235744595527649,
-0.347019225358963,
-0.4083755612373352,
0.5357169508934021,
0.1738661378622055,
0.5749393701553345,
0.4679696559906006,
0.5885427594184875,
0.3237677812576294,
0.5418357849121094,
-0.3544725179672241,
0.7708351016044617,
-0.564287543296814,
0.4898516535758972,
-0.1461285501718521,
-1.0244991779327393,
0.12124938517808914,
0.6829108595848083,
-0.7153716683387756,
0.3793891370296478,
0.7593888640403748,
0.8605906367301941,
0.38697198033332825,
0.24757206439971924,
0.5594337582588196,
0.2164154201745987,
-0.03929564356803894,
0.42381879687309265,
1.2701234817504883,
0.19230632483959198,
0.44992437958717346,
-0.111615389585495,
-0.44988036155700684,
-0.1960914433002472,
-0.5127886533737183,
-1.4187638759613037,
-0.05837700143456459,
-0.31852105259895325,
-0.32958710193634033,
0.44202306866645813,
1.0433903932571411,
0.31912821531295776,
-0.4390880763530731,
-0.09922748804092407,
0.11245371401309967,
0.4725764989852905,
0.10463916510343552,
-0.3025107979774475,
-0.06648795306682587,
-0.3221411406993866,
-0.5376213192939758,
0.5411624312400818,
0.705903947353363,
0.05652722716331482,
-0.4588880240917206,
-0.278780072927475,
-0.034108877182006836,
0.6952430009841919,
0.6294456720352173,
-0.11045002937316895,
-0.5655386447906494,
-0.6329700350761414,
0.3816911578178406,
-0.4154617190361023,
-0.033258844166994095,
-0.02943151630461216,
-0.3940448760986328,
-0.14008209109306335,
0.4016994833946228,
0.6379842758178711,
-0.26763319969177246,
-0.0691717192530632,
-0.07272527366876602,
-0.10019058734178543,
-0.20041464269161224,
0.043176330626010895,
0.5300854444503784,
0.3671500086784363,
-0.43637514114379883,
0.634498119354248,
0.5476648211479187,
-0.9881978034973145,
-0.7832530736923218,
0.05040512979030609,
-0.6858716011047363,
-0.10288166999816895,
1.2610920667648315,
-0.2095002382993698,
-0.7859287261962891,
-0.2113063633441925,
0.1492307335138321,
-0.025971781462430954,
-0.6159101128578186,
0.8655869364738464,
0.7346431612968445,
-0.09058913588523865,
0.041792381554841995,
-0.6043610572814941,
0.1325521469116211,
0.5708233118057251,
-0.9803919792175293,
-0.28153514862060547,
0.1939011961221695,
0.15580955147743225,
0.2690061628818512,
0.8440901041030884,
-0.093670554459095,
0.19398446381092072,
-0.21137282252311707,
-0.1628636121749878,
0.29358431696891785,
-0.39646437764167786,
-0.09427811950445175,
0.1047968938946724,
0.47762998938560486,
0.33561384677886963
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06586v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06586v1
|
ContextGPT: Infusing LLMs Knowledge into Neuro-Symbolic Activity Recognition Models
| 2024-03-11T10:32:23 | 2024-03-11T10:32:23 |
Luca Arrotta, Claudio Bettini, Gabriele Civitarese, Michele Fiori
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Context-aware Human Activity Recognition (HAR) is a hot research area in
mobile computing, and the most effective solutions in the literature are based
on supervised deep learning models. However, the actual deployment of these
systems is limited by the scarcity of labeled data that is required for
training. Neuro-Symbolic AI (NeSy) provides an interesting research direction
to mitigate this issue, by infusing common-sense knowledge about human
activities and the contexts in which they can be performed into HAR deep
learning classifiers. Existing NeSy methods for context-aware HAR rely on
knowledge encoded in logic-based models (e.g., ontologies) whose design,
implementation, and maintenance to capture new activities and contexts require
significant human engineering efforts, technical knowledge, and domain
expertise. Recent works show that pre-trained Large Language Models (LLMs)
effectively encode common-sense knowledge about human activities. In this work,
we propose ContextGPT: a novel prompt engineering approach to retrieve from
LLMs common-sense knowledge about the relationship between human activities and
the context in which they are performed. Unlike ontologies, ContextGPT requires
limited human effort and expertise. An extensive evaluation carried out on two
public datasets shows how a NeSy model obtained by infusing common-sense
knowledge from ContextGPT is effective in data scarcity scenarios, leading to
similar (and sometimes better) recognition rates than logic-based approaches
with a fraction of the effort.
|
[
-0.12449122220277786,
-0.639763355255127,
0.8369348049163818,
0.08570284396409988,
-0.2393680214881897,
-0.2710971534252167,
-0.09303257614374161,
-0.3851947486400604,
0.1567765176296234,
0.45656639337539673,
-0.6003974676132202,
-0.43902817368507385,
-0.4694772958755493,
-0.06021271273493767,
-0.17170526087284088,
0.6551101207733154,
-0.09203454852104187,
-0.1340196132659912,
-0.0858202651143074,
-0.06139269843697548,
-0.7065281867980957,
-0.7391228079795837,
-0.6784688830375671,
-0.5286568403244019,
0.33598241209983826,
0.18869687616825104,
0.272744357585907,
0.39801618456840515,
0.1556091606616974,
0.2653767168521881,
-0.12780997157096863,
0.2909177243709564,
-0.09751465171575546,
0.13814978301525116,
0.12700879573822021,
-0.0200657919049263,
-0.4585728049278259,
-0.15234516561031342,
0.16672228276729584,
0.621230959892273,
-0.042535752058029175,
0.048624612390995026,
0.30321088433265686,
0.36198553442955017,
-0.4796057939529419,
0.40959611535072327,
-0.5092065334320068,
0.04483240842819214,
0.17411744594573975,
-0.1985492706298828,
-0.1396889090538025,
0.013732816092669964,
0.3500980734825134,
-0.6707018613815308,
-0.04001886397600174,
-0.09395778924226761,
0.48540034890174866,
0.5188769698143005,
-0.5964995622634888,
-0.3846338987350464,
-0.265133261680603,
0.7406374216079712,
-0.4835803806781769,
0.2655218243598938,
0.37678465247154236,
0.25934329628944397,
-0.2932080924510956,
-0.6374796628952026,
-0.5586612820625305,
-0.3494676351547241,
-0.2163333296775818,
0.044334329664707184,
-0.02049536444246769,
0.0488860085606575,
0.3513700067996979,
-0.24686408042907715,
-0.42757317423820496,
-0.19077520072460175,
-0.05738860368728638,
-0.13043098151683807,
0.6398645639419556,
0.340668261051178,
0.4962159991264343,
-0.44423624873161316,
-0.5576573610305786,
0.2537458837032318,
-0.7168678641319275,
0.08010999113321304,
-0.33527711033821106,
0.3013096749782562,
-0.02053886465728283,
0.42649176716804504,
-0.4251304268836975,
0.712925136089325,
0.04375934973359108,
0.026205942034721375,
0.14440792798995972,
-0.2928946614265442,
-0.20513232052326202,
0.39478054642677307,
0.560036301612854,
0.256111204624176,
0.028440669178962708,
-0.4545605182647705,
-0.5370488166809082,
-0.04911680147051811,
0.19175468385219574,
-0.9376636743545532,
-0.147047221660614,
0.03501933813095093,
-0.2823748290538788,
-0.08283956348896027,
-0.011473283171653748,
-0.23142226040363312,
-0.6317975521087646,
-0.5886744856834412,
0.5574060678482056,
-0.4624457359313965,
-0.10724470019340515,
0.3827768564224243,
-0.0574302151799202,
0.1325661689043045,
0.5375298261642456,
-0.7220903038978577,
0.03803408145904541,
0.9244871735572815,
0.9934968948364258,
-0.1594318002462387,
-0.36775854229927063,
-0.5543692708015442,
0.266998291015625,
0.15931473672389984,
0.5939169526100159,
-0.4463847279548645,
-0.17165614664554596,
-0.19324669241905212,
0.15461796522140503,
-0.15722593665122986,
-0.1852959543466568,
0.5169223546981812,
-0.6710493564605713,
-0.17294012010097504,
-0.30314648151397705,
-0.4475192427635193,
-0.4253666400909424,
0.5806383490562439,
-0.5199952125549316,
0.9449053406715393,
0.05421153083443642,
-0.6048302054405212,
0.40230682492256165,
-1.1119130849838257,
-0.5271348357200623,
0.2605355978012085,
-0.3618251085281372,
-0.031246673315763474,
0.09342923015356064,
0.2615302801132202,
0.7894269227981567,
-0.16231772303581238,
0.5724501013755798,
-0.1451040357351303,
-0.3218412399291992,
0.34130537509918213,
-0.3560025691986084,
0.8035498261451721,
0.11331069469451904,
-0.5143166780471802,
0.15252049267292023,
-0.6357322335243225,
-0.054141800850629807,
-0.1644219309091568,
-0.17066068947315216,
-0.5981618762016296,
0.07695753127336502,
0.0893893837928772,
0.614759087562561,
0.34256258606910706,
-0.6062836647033691,
0.21140427887439728,
-0.38058432936668396,
0.8678781390190125,
0.7576287388801575,
-0.08211375027894974,
0.45337381958961487,
-0.12053008377552032,
0.2626309394836426,
-0.15773487091064453,
-0.13061115145683289,
-0.12295510619878769,
-0.5480645298957825,
-0.23924176394939423,
-0.22630028426647186,
-0.11547477543354034,
0.6215518712997437,
-0.6165404319763184,
0.6457529067993164,
-0.4949979782104492,
-0.3465995788574219,
0.2337687611579895,
-0.050836604088544846,
0.11678525805473328,
0.9300889372825623,
0.32805702090263367,
-0.19750763475894928,
-0.5406237840652466,
-0.4456777572631836,
-0.2154586762189865,
0.07884442806243896,
-0.32967066764831543,
0.756418764591217,
0.6206077337265015,
-0.5587723255157471,
1.1976122856140137,
-0.5154921412467957,
-0.2530626952648163,
-0.21923679113388062,
0.3004307746887207,
0.4516925811767578,
0.47105488181114197,
0.30392932891845703,
-0.7982559204101562,
-0.29538747668266296,
0.1323106735944748,
-0.9526058435440063,
-0.0803404375910759,
-0.13277064263820648,
-0.10669585317373276,
-0.10500776767730713,
0.4959237575531006,
-0.8144050240516663,
0.5754317045211792,
0.3345847427845001,
-0.655077338218689,
0.24178864061832428,
-0.1504967361688614,
0.07197808474302292,
-1.166294813156128,
0.2725749909877777,
-0.09295263141393661,
-0.1217641532421112,
-0.7999703288078308,
-0.41230806708335876,
0.101931631565094,
-0.42697569727897644,
-0.6057010889053345,
1.0118016004562378,
-0.5155901908874512,
0.05919451639056206,
-0.47049787640571594,
-0.13676489889621735,
-0.29067936539649963,
0.5678561925888062,
0.3867865800857544,
0.7034049034118652,
0.6815077662467957,
-0.890418529510498,
0.1835019290447235,
0.3380386531352997,
-0.16742496192455292,
0.3555131256580353,
-0.6123006939888,
0.17442166805267334,
-0.001028177561238408,
0.2210913896560669,
-0.7916484475135803,
-0.6291648745536804,
0.2683981657028198,
-0.31244489550590515,
-0.11578258872032166,
-0.3119068741798401,
-0.5541424751281738,
0.023433642461895943,
0.10181814432144165,
0.7051063179969788,
0.6121824383735657,
-0.8866703510284424,
1.0146803855895996,
0.6057831048965454,
0.0923900306224823,
-0.4865609407424927,
-0.6059970259666443,
0.08873041719198227,
-0.5082860589027405,
-0.7288836240768433,
0.46565911173820496,
0.1570339798927307,
0.1805756837129593,
-0.15118399262428284,
-0.44076821208000183,
-0.46631237864494324,
0.38850685954093933,
0.6644267439842224,
0.28925713896751404,
0.05424346402287483,
0.22390536963939667,
-0.13310977816581726,
-0.31240978837013245,
0.44962552189826965,
-0.3972373306751251,
0.5957431197166443,
-0.21515537798404694,
-0.4774852991104126,
-0.4201613664627075,
0.22548739612102509,
0.40856072306632996,
0.10527990758419037,
0.343487024307251,
0.5359823107719421,
-0.5524020195007324,
-0.0349888801574707,
-0.25216707587242126,
-0.41138848662376404,
-0.5510237812995911,
0.3770655691623688,
-0.18979386985301971,
-1.067704677581787,
0.27450665831565857,
-0.5059869289398193,
-0.043803248554468155,
0.0559152327477932,
0.27990245819091797,
-0.08490902930498123,
1.082614779472351,
0.4409834146499634,
-0.15800563991069794,
0.6285131573677063,
-0.11232168972492218,
0.2663955092430115,
-0.8260195851325989,
-0.1710771769285202,
-0.09164788573980331,
-0.5113822221755981,
-0.36214306950569153,
-0.304063618183136,
0.5684749484062195,
-0.07862509042024612,
-0.5123036503791809,
0.3895179331302643,
-0.6767191290855408,
0.518208920955658,
0.4119105935096741,
0.441946417093277,
0.11322198808193207,
-0.01823689416050911,
0.3884887993335724,
0.12667594850063324,
-0.8019932508468628,
-0.7423304319381714,
0.9364669919013977,
-0.055962175130844116,
0.6707464456558228,
-0.04752814769744873,
0.969272255897522,
0.1012207642197609,
0.4227161407470703,
-0.9269908666610718,
0.8182774782180786,
0.06609285622835159,
-0.4047389626502991,
-0.3649693429470062,
-0.28464025259017944,
-1.102079153060913,
-0.12883834540843964,
0.08263663202524185,
-0.939339280128479,
0.08746418356895447,
0.4035717248916626,
-0.623569667339325,
0.22909730672836304,
-0.6158894300460815,
1.0295408964157104,
-0.5151671171188354,
-0.39218518137931824,
-0.12222215533256531,
-0.6994964480400085,
0.23425205051898956,
0.11413349211215973,
0.012739361263811588,
-0.12855203449726105,
-0.1752159744501114,
0.7413391470909119,
-0.2259148806333542,
1.180685043334961,
-0.3424889147281647,
0.05838586017489433,
0.2503589987754822,
0.14603185653686523,
0.8251571655273438,
0.339974969625473,
0.09608839452266693,
0.1452527642250061,
-0.2645389139652252,
-0.24848119914531708,
-0.7008954882621765,
0.7022644281387329,
-0.4316614270210266,
-0.49696648120880127,
-0.5478940606117249,
-0.604636549949646,
-0.19383357465267181,
0.2637057602405548,
0.05333372950553894,
0.46338722109794617,
-0.20225290954113007,
0.07320260256528854,
0.7707595229148865,
0.013553127646446228,
0.6423469185829163,
0.09312941879034042,
0.27654585242271423,
-0.16556885838508606,
0.9606150984764099,
-0.004230463411659002,
-0.4004238247871399,
0.3400595188140869,
0.06766432523727417,
-0.21447180211544037,
-0.2335333526134491,
-0.4023134708404541,
-0.0148152532055974,
-0.5787407159805298,
-0.20161332190036774,
-0.7557092905044556,
-0.07100784033536911,
-0.18200217187404633,
-0.4553097188472748,
-0.20246466994285583,
-0.41827288269996643,
-0.4392920136451721,
0.21393521130084991,
0.4569878578186035,
0.4983549118041992,
-0.0071070934645831585,
0.3809852600097656,
-0.8171617388725281,
0.22258947789669037,
0.5840907096862793,
0.20775288343429565,
-0.00122273457236588,
-0.3367643356323242,
-0.21006613969802856,
-0.05710635334253311,
-0.14908282458782196,
-0.9434099793434143,
0.4673303961753845,
-0.03568322956562042,
0.48740318417549133,
0.3268449008464813,
0.08244787156581879,
0.5412658452987671,
-0.33960261940956116,
0.744475245475769,
0.3247745633125305,
-0.9163956046104431,
0.5270758867263794,
-0.26993465423583984,
0.07321329414844513,
0.46605384349823,
0.4062938690185547,
-0.596400797367096,
0.554492712020874,
-0.6862787008285522,
-1.0785801410675049,
0.8119925856590271,
-0.0263393372297287,
0.2607688009738922,
-0.017913788557052612,
0.29272451996803284,
-0.04445301368832588,
0.17963117361068726,
-0.6912380456924438,
0.1318236142396927,
-0.36532464623451233,
-0.2334643304347992,
0.19909319281578064,
-0.0032609892077744007,
-0.24818021059036255,
-0.2825668156147003,
0.4722110629081726,
-0.26091769337654114,
0.3231143653392792,
0.2207498997449875,
-0.3687596321105957,
0.6098228096961975,
0.25146761536598206,
0.37419193983078003,
0.40963035821914673,
-0.05225230008363724,
0.34474021196365356,
0.501121997833252,
-0.5111979246139526,
0.25029456615448,
0.011755300685763359,
-0.2321363091468811,
-0.07887333631515503,
0.06328476220369339,
0.6132351160049438,
0.36158475279808044,
-0.91790372133255,
0.5502499341964722,
0.047150105237960815,
-0.015853282064199448,
-0.5138899683952332,
0.24343298375606537,
0.012488014996051788,
0.30581071972846985,
0.18411104381084442,
0.20602203905582428,
0.29407355189323425,
-0.3672245144844055,
0.21620897948741913,
0.5210100412368774,
-0.5612096786499023,
-0.5307309031486511,
0.4278208911418915,
0.2314276397228241,
-0.44344839453697205,
0.5685670375823975,
-0.4375218152999878,
-0.546865701675415,
0.6689431071281433,
0.49170610308647156,
1.07049560546875,
0.06259014457464218,
-0.027219204232096672,
0.6014969944953918,
-0.013921782374382019,
-0.29725781083106995,
0.4391968250274658,
-0.41543489694595337,
-0.6338503360748291,
-0.3453623950481415,
-0.2494277060031891,
-0.24566374719142914,
0.11397538334131241,
-0.22091828286647797,
0.20577682554721832,
-0.21897383034229279,
-0.14532750844955444,
-0.38035058975219727,
-0.2536652088165283,
-0.7512805461883545,
0.19541388750076294,
0.03339715301990509,
0.598773181438446,
-0.7388306856155396,
0.801354169845581,
0.886986494064331,
-0.16631117463111877,
-0.8363875150680542,
0.09950008243322372,
-0.2200041115283966,
-0.6504974365234375,
1.141899585723877,
0.5408618450164795,
-0.0801813080906868,
-0.009548511356115341,
-0.5998918414115906,
-0.9147889018058777,
1.4519286155700684,
0.3320503234863281,
-0.2725120186805725,
-0.05560264363884926,
-0.07102197408676147,
0.24134618043899536,
-0.4600030183792114,
0.0850132405757904,
0.3493654727935791,
0.6852355599403381,
-0.0007824792992323637,
-0.5608125329017639,
0.5153236985206604,
-0.27857762575149536,
-0.20707379281520844,
0.10440488159656525,
-0.23798568546772003,
0.7326859831809998,
-0.18303437530994415,
-0.44596007466316223,
-0.29404792189598083,
0.6747781038284302,
0.6980263590812683,
0.8201077580451965,
0.6758145689964294,
0.2890523374080658,
0.7553512454032898,
0.05694849044084549,
0.7824536561965942,
-0.5483129024505615,
0.12985390424728394,
0.988415002822876,
-0.31100738048553467,
0.521704375743866,
0.6942837834358215,
0.23082362115383148,
0.1792447417974472,
0.5343988537788391,
0.1922105997800827,
0.6218597888946533,
0.1471087485551834,
-0.6374916434288025,
-0.5099776387214661,
-0.11436466872692108,
-0.20890502631664276,
0.35248157382011414,
0.2449210286140442,
-0.2235288769006729,
-0.269361287355423,
-0.12853291630744934,
-0.006243601907044649,
-0.25001925230026245,
-0.254446804523468,
0.6540855765342712,
0.12566687166690826,
-0.7072718739509583,
0.47275689244270325,
-0.14027124643325806,
0.9106061458587646,
-0.48253050446510315,
-0.2732639014720917,
0.015822727233171463,
-0.17007988691329956,
-0.2995535135269165,
-0.6701558828353882,
0.3947218060493469,
0.06876559555530548,
-0.15531951189041138,
-0.3342117369174957,
1.0047715902328491,
-0.08747147768735886,
-0.13389283418655396,
0.08047081530094147,
0.49553382396698,
0.20302064716815948,
-0.5575855374336243,
-0.5759784579277039,
-0.4562303423881531,
-0.31667059659957886,
-0.28541499376296997,
0.46857282519340515,
0.6604426503181458,
-0.16824498772621155,
0.6897903680801392,
0.6568943858146667,
-0.21850183606147766,
-0.26747027039527893,
-0.2400253415107727,
1.033463954925537,
-0.8398926258087158,
-0.7986806035041809,
-0.9151593446731567,
0.43578633666038513,
-0.1986420899629593,
-0.4096810817718506,
0.6091333627700806,
0.46045011281967163,
0.4718608856201172,
-0.10645849257707596,
0.8461438417434692,
-0.35062089562416077,
-0.0802500918507576,
-0.5003848671913147,
0.7831857204437256,
-0.4534212350845337,
0.32921305298805237,
0.06763657182455063,
-0.4442151188850403,
-0.21322667598724365,
0.7548142075538635,
-0.46535050868988037,
-0.013936284929513931,
0.5152732729911804,
1.0225672721862793,
-0.5222901701927185,
0.054373301565647125,
0.2886701822280884,
-0.14734433591365814,
0.13457706570625305,
0.9152479767799377,
1.058593988418579,
-0.28804174065589905,
0.3169802129268646,
-0.05051598325371742,
-0.24984227120876312,
-0.1990930289030075,
-1.16864013671875,
-0.9408101439476013,
-0.672284722328186,
-0.11291671544313431,
-0.16868101060390472,
0.05844655632972717,
1.1814223527908325,
0.9233905673027039,
-0.5604944825172424,
-0.19622007012367249,
-0.548863410949707,
0.04923277720808983,
-0.3406904339790344,
-0.15901179611682892,
0.5362991094589233,
-0.3024844825267792,
-0.3565511107444763,
0.7173588275909424,
0.08450445532798767,
-0.0791221633553505,
0.11302106082439423,
-0.35832837224006653,
0.04470090568065643,
-0.20955179631710052,
0.7782717943191528,
0.3711892366409302,
-0.6033630967140198,
-0.31752046942710876,
0.1754579246044159,
-0.0386546365916729,
0.026461349800229073,
1.0239546298980713,
-1.0268726348876953,
-0.1086471825838089,
0.7307747602462769,
0.9959457516670227,
0.31918850541114807,
-0.05249627307057381,
0.3341428339481354,
-0.8260436058044434,
0.05382275953888893,
0.34387272596359253,
0.42531344294548035,
0.14500944316387177,
-0.5754381418228149,
0.7767090797424316,
0.2925872206687927,
-0.5814482569694519,
-0.8026292324066162,
0.25930944085121155,
-1.3358168601989746,
-0.2176527976989746,
1.240977168083191,
-0.09694334119558334,
-0.4300808310508728,
-0.36179473996162415,
-0.3542003631591797,
0.24387390911579132,
-0.6257785558700562,
1.1332454681396484,
0.38278070092201233,
-0.5540444850921631,
0.05911337956786156,
-0.5760699510574341,
0.5318443775177002,
0.41636040806770325,
-0.9219170808792114,
0.33979901671409607,
0.42651310563087463,
0.250016450881958,
0.04802068695425987,
0.6109142899513245,
0.3765468895435333,
0.40143099427223206,
-0.329951673746109,
0.08401944488286972,
-0.4272277355194092,
-0.15397100150585175,
-0.21932248771190643,
0.30792149901390076,
-0.42474421858787537,
-0.03557458892464638
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06574v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06574v1
|
AC-EVAL: Evaluating Ancient Chinese Language Understanding in Large Language Models
| 2024-03-11T10:24:37 | 2024-03-11T10:24:37 |
Yuting Wei, Yuanxing Xu, Xinru Wei, Simin Yang, Yangfu Zhu, Yuqing Li, Di Liu, Bin Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Given the importance of ancient Chinese in capturing the essence of rich
historical and cultural heritage, the rapid advancements in Large Language
Models (LLMs) necessitate benchmarks that can effectively evaluate their
understanding of ancient contexts. To meet this need, we present AC-EVAL, an
innovative benchmark designed to assess the advanced knowledge and reasoning
capabilities of LLMs within the context of ancient Chinese. AC-EVAL is
structured across three levels of difficulty reflecting different facets of
language comprehension: general historical knowledge, short text understanding,
and long text comprehension. The benchmark comprises 13 tasks, spanning
historical facts, geography, social customs, art, philosophy, classical poetry
and prose, providing a comprehensive assessment framework. Our extensive
evaluation of top-performing LLMs, tailored for both English and Chinese,
reveals a substantial potential for enhancing ancient text comprehension. By
highlighting the strengths and weaknesses of LLMs, AC-EVAL aims to promote
their development and application forward in the realms of ancient Chinese
language education and scholarly research. The AC-EVAL data and evaluation code
are available at https://github.com/yuting-wei/AC-EVAL.
|
[
-0.3303101062774658,
-1.0973011255264282,
0.6344326138496399,
0.1265629082918167,
-0.21711690723896027,
0.08975441008806229,
-0.6435219049453735,
-0.34795334935188293,
-0.26016613841056824,
0.33160704374313354,
-0.1345665007829666,
-0.6300197839736938,
-0.22458991408348083,
0.15784430503845215,
-0.5309879779815674,
0.7385060787200928,
-0.45673468708992004,
0.20777159929275513,
-0.12062520533800125,
-0.30146485567092896,
-0.12169750779867172,
-0.4447709321975708,
-0.8980848789215088,
-0.442268431186676,
0.11940592527389526,
0.26798585057258606,
0.5022778511047363,
0.7866557836532593,
0.5316795110702515,
0.23809188604354858,
-0.2850077152252197,
0.20953892171382904,
-0.2535707354545593,
0.07607835531234741,
-0.09313316643238068,
-0.4149872064590454,
-0.6834165453910828,
0.04787442460656166,
0.9386194348335266,
0.661872386932373,
-0.2065953016281128,
0.19356778264045715,
0.23409397900104523,
0.7013199925422668,
-0.7808608412742615,
0.10790388286113739,
-0.5147427916526794,
-0.09263897687196732,
-0.3066152036190033,
-0.38290584087371826,
-0.4410870671272278,
-0.20904049277305603,
0.2227291613817215,
-0.6042330861091614,
-0.056288134306669235,
0.17541810870170593,
0.7149275541305542,
0.14014527201652527,
-0.3720884621143341,
-0.1420133113861084,
-0.39889177680015564,
0.6358157992362976,
-0.6550315022468567,
0.34754493832588196,
0.3735431432723999,
0.3752342760562897,
0.20895615220069885,
-0.9832903146743774,
-0.6679033041000366,
-0.603289008140564,
0.02413281984627247,
0.05658707767724991,
-0.3595774471759796,
0.12599283456802368,
0.20495381951332092,
0.7839067578315735,
-0.7040637135505676,
0.0654943659901619,
-0.083866648375988,
-0.07347238808870316,
0.5460166335105896,
0.31800299882888794,
0.5698533058166504,
-0.009238212369382381,
-0.4888831079006195,
-0.1998675912618637,
-0.7939143180847168,
0.10038440674543381,
0.047680340707302094,
0.006998163182288408,
-0.2029677927494049,
0.2926281690597534,
-0.25335603952407837,
0.623306930065155,
-0.21766628324985504,
-0.023693324998021126,
0.20880138874053955,
-0.2620715796947479,
-0.3092513382434845,
-0.0295757707208395,
0.7187530398368835,
0.03895999491214752,
0.27211469411849976,
-0.03259854391217232,
-0.3542628884315491,
-0.031439408659935,
-0.05679607018828392,
-0.5536202788352966,
-0.38205158710479736,
-0.037161748856306076,
-0.5532089471817017,
-0.013948739506304264,
-0.01447885762900114,
-0.6082826256752014,
-0.42813611030578613,
-0.14674685895442963,
0.427534818649292,
-0.6186512112617493,
-0.25080424547195435,
-0.034631434828042984,
0.017080726101994514,
0.3957548439502716,
0.4747992157936096,
-0.610506534576416,
0.5848885774612427,
0.8805898427963257,
0.9068882465362549,
-0.330624520778656,
-0.7163886427879333,
-0.5116153359413147,
-0.05739254504442215,
-0.39904242753982544,
0.7629011869430542,
-0.576541543006897,
-0.15637585520744324,
-0.08965300023555756,
-0.2531253695487976,
-0.016782166436314583,
-0.44162753224372864,
0.8051035404205322,
-0.4560132622718811,
-0.12134488672018051,
-0.003718758001923561,
-0.5350562334060669,
-0.4700092673301697,
0.48915207386016846,
-0.7431403994560242,
0.945505678653717,
0.08837035298347473,
-0.4322754144668579,
0.004001034423708916,
-0.5598481893539429,
-0.5146235823631287,
0.5440453886985779,
-0.15913709998130798,
0.008535453118383884,
-0.0070387255400419235,
0.34436771273612976,
0.16323500871658325,
-0.5356234908103943,
0.070744089782238,
-0.16593630611896515,
-0.4831017553806305,
0.13053235411643982,
-0.8749451041221619,
0.6424721479415894,
0.35470128059387207,
-0.6263226270675659,
0.036325909197330475,
-0.5415297746658325,
0.14439620077610016,
0.006108325440436602,
-0.30558642745018005,
-0.5110749006271362,
0.0777416080236435,
0.11787361651659012,
-0.07463181763887405,
0.5213103890419006,
-0.1128234714269638,
0.24495664238929749,
-0.3802274763584137,
0.20331721007823944,
0.7086853384971619,
-0.2015760987997055,
0.20840543508529663,
-0.18241026997566223,
0.5996221899986267,
-0.35514023900032043,
-0.09534455090761185,
-0.37577003240585327,
-0.08284113556146622,
-0.8511492609977722,
-0.02630806155502796,
0.204203799366951,
0.4326692521572113,
-0.7061824202537537,
0.3360099196434021,
-0.2919921278953552,
-0.6633597612380981,
-0.7022141814231873,
0.32791146636009216,
0.517075777053833,
0.28722861409187317,
0.3992393910884857,
-0.32050666213035583,
-0.20068798959255219,
-0.5858607888221741,
-0.3597833216190338,
-0.6740821599960327,
-0.021312320604920387,
0.5223334431648254,
0.4568063020706177,
-0.02736923098564148,
0.43419429659843445,
-0.18767207860946655,
-0.3014339804649353,
-0.5338566899299622,
0.21876516938209534,
-0.03604617342352867,
0.2002294957637787,
0.4801803231239319,
-0.6281667947769165,
-0.4272588789463043,
0.483271986246109,
-0.3337756097316742,
-0.2739095091819763,
-0.16634905338287354,
-0.06063252314925194,
0.3845660388469696,
0.3415048122406006,
-0.24652400612831116,
0.40680015087127686,
0.7270678281784058,
-0.4970444142818451,
0.6428321003913879,
-0.3478086292743683,
0.47679373621940613,
-0.6730136275291443,
0.5184426307678223,
0.0847180038690567,
0.034689612686634064,
-0.6066297292709351,
0.45149359107017517,
0.40005257725715637,
0.09399612993001938,
-0.6036757230758667,
0.794288694858551,
-0.6735267043113708,
0.10239827632904053,
-0.39820849895477295,
0.5806620717048645,
0.04103122279047966,
0.30888885259628296,
0.3058897852897644,
0.6613934636116028,
0.5195127725601196,
-0.5312615036964417,
0.5211229920387268,
0.03236803784966469,
-0.5687881708145142,
0.4628567695617676,
-0.4021904170513153,
0.13272222876548767,
0.20164939761161804,
0.23421570658683777,
-0.76882404088974,
-0.0380391888320446,
0.0616319440305233,
-0.40359795093536377,
0.05131998658180237,
0.06218879669904709,
-0.33041781187057495,
-0.12228814512491226,
-0.13713523745536804,
0.7523863315582275,
0.32074424624443054,
-0.5841488838195801,
0.703211784362793,
0.1549137830734253,
-0.019617559388279915,
-0.6474211812019348,
-0.5205103754997253,
0.21529515087604523,
-0.27987828850746155,
-0.48511895537376404,
0.07872951775789261,
-0.1756811887025833,
-0.6925548911094666,
0.025576988235116005,
-0.16776101291179657,
-0.271342396736145,
0.3448643684387207,
-0.341665118932724,
0.3858981430530548,
-0.6397020816802979,
-0.13222138583660126,
-0.12402951717376709,
0.0608145035803318,
0.07578005641698837,
0.09639417380094528,
0.8308852314949036,
-0.41646820306777954,
-0.45715659856796265,
-0.49403616786003113,
-0.05992363020777702,
0.6357638239860535,
-0.37910792231559753,
0.4998565912246704,
0.22211796045303345,
-0.5275483727455139,
-0.3743533194065094,
-0.7496097683906555,
0.22842620313167572,
-0.42889800667762756,
0.5379719734191895,
-0.39473065733909607,
-0.5511325597763062,
0.4873565137386322,
0.14535649120807648,
0.1678578108549118,
0.7283603549003601,
0.6264193058013916,
0.4649289548397064,
0.7741482257843018,
0.23181815445423126,
-0.5486603379249573,
0.2755230963230133,
-0.12164335697889328,
-0.12212751060724258,
-0.9839882850646973,
-0.18359549343585968,
-0.5241174101829529,
-0.1779954582452774,
-0.2320910543203354,
-0.32305318117141724,
0.22844946384429932,
0.10932451486587524,
-0.27505913376808167,
0.19541583955287933,
-0.114421546459198,
0.4712657928466797,
0.23028331995010376,
-0.03831174224615097,
0.5530623197555542,
-0.42276179790496826,
0.09898111969232559,
0.39316070079803467,
-0.26148682832717896,
-0.7518410086631775,
0.9172636866569519,
0.5293713808059692,
0.9344154000282288,
0.06401713192462921,
0.41196587681770325,
0.3177874982357025,
0.30015018582344055,
-0.8832895159721375,
0.5658622980117798,
-0.22969749569892883,
-0.3729217052459717,
-0.282755583524704,
-0.5707163214683533,
-0.8094438314437866,
0.3439492881298065,
0.10809602588415146,
-0.6835013031959534,
-0.156719371676445,
0.11452401429414749,
-0.4590056538581848,
0.4652535617351532,
-0.5170867443084717,
1.0268852710723877,
-0.7504191398620605,
-0.05020764097571373,
-0.528667151927948,
-0.35266900062561035,
0.40212002396583557,
-0.04922885075211525,
0.2784176170825958,
0.015374058857560158,
-0.36342570185661316,
0.6391986608505249,
0.0315818190574646,
0.31135597825050354,
0.1811114102602005,
0.027659131214022636,
0.20422130823135376,
0.3403850197792053,
0.28250330686569214,
-0.005146291572600603,
-0.26059699058532715,
0.09606096893548965,
0.171652153134346,
-0.21403691172599792,
-0.4957912862300873,
0.824244499206543,
-0.8288195729255676,
-0.5898194909095764,
-0.547829270362854,
-0.4215163290500641,
0.1205626130104065,
0.15264275670051575,
-0.09469176828861237,
0.4233609139919281,
-0.5625966191291809,
0.24077069759368896,
0.4032348692417145,
-0.3400118350982666,
0.44203823804855347,
0.8242955207824707,
-0.07945214956998825,
-0.29592519998550415,
0.6706472039222717,
-0.18514291942119598,
0.44695261120796204,
0.4667139947414398,
0.23391786217689514,
-0.11597820371389389,
-0.8478730916976929,
-0.4622161090373993,
-0.10785471647977829,
-0.6950249075889587,
-0.03705715015530586,
-0.40991833806037903,
-0.42137253284454346,
-0.3192739188671112,
0.03041692264378071,
-0.31965622305870056,
-0.04595888406038284,
-0.430685430765152,
0.08038551360368729,
0.024305330589413643,
0.7627867460250854,
-0.04041846841573715,
0.008404087275266647,
-0.6529549956321716,
0.44176992774009705,
-0.009138723835349083,
0.46889618039131165,
0.3185826241970062,
-0.566947877407074,
-0.303682416677475,
-0.010467960499227047,
-0.29134219884872437,
-0.6991168856620789,
0.44770896434783936,
0.2685152590274811,
0.835681140422821,
0.6937732100486755,
0.0965413972735405,
0.7903251647949219,
-0.564089834690094,
0.9438650012016296,
-0.08933085948228836,
-1.2478524446487427,
0.44567179679870605,
0.11161571741104126,
0.2768530547618866,
0.6104574799537659,
0.10542438924312592,
-0.9938352704048157,
-0.4847559928894043,
-0.45445647835731506,
-1.0789501667022705,
0.6510568857192993,
0.05291494354605675,
-0.10366649925708771,
-0.014463279396295547,
0.3394123911857605,
0.14766038954257965,
-0.2283092439174652,
-0.922936737537384,
-0.5416134595870972,
0.07290594279766083,
0.02948729880154133,
-0.18205466866493225,
-0.07944223284721375,
0.15606296062469482,
-0.2950955629348755,
0.68427973985672,
-0.04551036283373833,
-0.1941707730293274,
0.13056223094463348,
-0.46369102597236633,
-0.17283223569393158,
0.44977790117263794,
0.33405551314353943,
0.8968815207481384,
0.050516773015260696,
0.35430094599723816,
0.7341229319572449,
-0.6016721129417419,
-0.2316628247499466,
0.31798726320266724,
0.14328940212726593,
-0.3155568540096283,
0.6067915558815002,
0.823590099811554,
-0.04538791999220848,
-0.8457441329956055,
0.355049729347229,
-0.2262479066848755,
0.1132914125919342,
-0.4834372103214264,
0.19230034947395325,
-0.23443327844142914,
0.21493273973464966,
0.8667915463447571,
-0.315583735704422,
0.27934715151786804,
-0.7319441437721252,
0.2553648352622986,
0.41533347964286804,
-0.31179723143577576,
-0.13443796336650848,
0.5763751864433289,
0.14275868237018585,
-0.31542763113975525,
0.5923120379447937,
0.01893804408609867,
-0.7824786901473999,
0.550262451171875,
0.4373810887336731,
0.8719546794891357,
-0.39637506008148193,
-0.032394323498010635,
0.3541027903556824,
0.3741055130958557,
-0.1538792848587036,
-0.08379057049751282,
-0.15797485411167145,
-0.48383450508117676,
-0.5352778434753418,
-0.6649494767189026,
-0.6846362948417664,
0.3780990242958069,
-0.62357097864151,
0.4127712547779083,
-0.21363423764705658,
0.3875090777873993,
-0.21320925652980804,
0.5023013949394226,
-0.651793360710144,
0.3153807818889618,
0.48693954944610596,
1.332150936126709,
-0.7192578911781311,
0.8829319477081299,
0.6955803036689758,
-0.17417152225971222,
-0.7686070799827576,
0.23832173645496368,
0.13853050768375397,
-0.9258886575698853,
0.48735830187797546,
0.14746996760368347,
-0.10473410040140152,
0.01759018748998642,
-0.39446213841438293,
-0.5993014574050903,
1.0601094961166382,
0.22904565930366516,
-0.5427082180976868,
0.0031857620924711227,
-0.06553217768669128,
0.7178013324737549,
-0.3248060941696167,
0.697609007358551,
1.0271012783050537,
0.5862542986869812,
-0.13491953909397125,
-1.0999186038970947,
0.1104353815317154,
-0.6111370921134949,
-0.28343066573143005,
0.0664157047867775,
-0.559921145439148,
0.6446422338485718,
0.003741421503946185,
-0.5416769981384277,
0.6595642566680908,
0.7643946409225464,
0.3844296932220459,
0.4921596050262451,
0.559868335723877,
0.5205923914909363,
0.604035496711731,
-0.3298620581626892,
1.135392427444458,
-0.45244652032852173,
0.13617634773254395,
0.8009432554244995,
-0.066914401948452,
0.9951929450035095,
0.1871030032634735,
-0.13569167256355286,
0.4888833463191986,
0.6874749064445496,
0.06111985445022583,
0.19205239415168762,
0.25776931643486023,
-0.5484278798103333,
-0.2689794600009918,
-0.11848999559879303,
-0.5834112763404846,
0.4270581305027008,
0.42909786105155945,
-0.19238947331905365,
-0.1208585873246193,
-0.27143529057502747,
0.047511350363492966,
0.07945919036865234,
-0.5803877711296082,
0.7416970133781433,
0.1764821857213974,
-0.7817457318305969,
0.3985729217529297,
-0.05653494969010353,
0.4995289146900177,
-0.597920298576355,
-0.1384250819683075,
-0.2097495198249817,
0.24890607595443726,
-0.039489805698394775,
-1.0718783140182495,
-0.12295433133840561,
0.0662880539894104,
0.4609730541706085,
0.018878987058997154,
0.45908644795417786,
-0.42389458417892456,
-0.25063568353652954,
0.3247903883457184,
0.5556683540344238,
0.3190763592720032,
0.09616059809923172,
-0.5409882068634033,
0.18721020221710205,
-0.13709382712841034,
-0.48262229561805725,
0.060360636562108994,
0.6432276964187622,
0.0786021500825882,
0.7103238105773926,
0.45462265610694885,
0.40906643867492676,
-0.45434609055519104,
0.1698702573776245,
0.6702678203582764,
-0.759290874004364,
-0.3268851339817047,
-1.243537187576294,
0.34990328550338745,
0.20738919079303741,
-0.5619819760322571,
0.7562419772148132,
0.7122998237609863,
0.8214632272720337,
0.48473405838012695,
0.8241013288497925,
-0.035365499556064606,
0.1336120218038559,
-0.40481507778167725,
1.073944091796875,
-0.7136304378509521,
0.4156365394592285,
-0.46331945061683655,
-0.8927276134490967,
-0.2538515627384186,
0.6032969355583191,
-0.386471688747406,
0.030411524698138237,
0.9385682940483093,
0.2637680470943451,
0.133592426776886,
0.06745931506156921,
0.2748410999774933,
0.18380150198936462,
0.23112601041793823,
0.829753577709198,
1.163755178451538,
-0.10989726334810257,
0.7351222634315491,
-0.3418135344982147,
-0.4532288610935211,
0.1034068763256073,
-0.7470237612724304,
-0.8180957436561584,
-0.601334273815155,
-0.15100452303886414,
-0.27995795011520386,
0.11368855834007263,
0.961656391620636,
0.12243165075778961,
-0.8517181277275085,
-0.5104526281356812,
0.11152198165655136,
0.17977523803710938,
-0.44066449999809265,
-0.22840149700641632,
0.8181072473526001,
-0.276246041059494,
-0.9479011297225952,
0.4955815076828003,
0.2968563437461853,
-0.14680293202400208,
-0.34145471453666687,
-0.3770467936992645,
-0.02257869392633438,
-0.09589140862226486,
0.440362811088562,
0.38870707154273987,
-0.9496014714241028,
-0.3573908805847168,
0.11337529867887497,
-0.1257617175579071,
-0.03693860024213791,
0.8070683479309082,
-0.7078859806060791,
0.40514788031578064,
0.6441023349761963,
0.6257304549217224,
0.24824963510036469,
0.02112801931798458,
0.654900312423706,
-0.1595981866121292,
-0.25717613101005554,
0.3060813546180725,
0.7700270414352417,
0.29327812790870667,
-0.09066778421401978,
0.5236762762069702,
-0.07358536869287491,
-0.6529482007026672,
-0.8105801939964294,
-0.12500379979610443,
-1.052036166191101,
-0.402511328458786,
1.3452324867248535,
-0.30896469950675964,
-0.19117723405361176,
-0.05071413889527321,
-0.3278883397579193,
0.36588937044143677,
-0.2533906400203705,
0.8746451735496521,
0.8266689777374268,
0.03140728175640106,
-0.4876544177532196,
-0.4175434410572052,
0.28399989008903503,
0.3948473036289215,
-0.9407123327255249,
0.21342606842517853,
0.6228155493736267,
-0.002134401584044099,
-0.009154802188277245,
0.4729699492454529,
-0.027368884533643723,
0.7218224406242371,
-0.262069970369339,
0.04892539232969284,
0.14488956332206726,
-0.18472014367580414,
-0.38265687227249146,
0.0892009511590004,
0.29542356729507446,
0.13831521570682526
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06570v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06570v1
|
Improving Speaker Assignment in Speaker-Attributed ASR for Real Meeting Applications
| 2024-03-11T10:11:29 | 2024-03-11T10:11:29 |
Can Cui, Imran Ahamad Sheikh, Mostafa Sadeghi, Emmanuel Vincent
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Past studies on end-to-end meeting transcription have focused on model
architecture and have mostly been evaluated on simulated meeting data. We
present a novel study aiming to optimize the use of a Speaker-Attributed ASR
(SA-ASR) system in real-life scenarios, such as the AMI meeting corpus, for
improved speaker assignment of speech segments. First, we propose a pipeline
tailored to real-life applications involving Voice Activity Detection (VAD),
Speaker Diarization (SD), and SA-ASR. Second, we advocate using VAD output
segments to fine-tune the SA-ASR model, considering that it is also applied to
VAD segments during test, and show that this results in a relative reduction of
Speaker Error Rate (SER) up to 28%. Finally, we explore strategies to enhance
the extraction of the speaker embedding templates used as inputs by the SA-ASR
system. We show that extracting them from SD output rather than annotated
speaker segments results in a relative SER reduction up to 20%.
|
[
-0.5185572504997253,
-0.5585914850234985,
0.169968381524086,
0.13738636672496796,
-0.33209657669067383,
0.06639392673969269,
-0.27243873476982117,
-0.5685500502586365,
0.3648509681224823,
0.33019715547561646,
-0.5355945825576782,
-0.07881001383066177,
-0.24880903959274292,
0.012138241901993752,
-0.4480920732021332,
0.47727131843566895,
0.3336382508277893,
0.28439491987228394,
-0.4262012839317322,
-0.14934790134429932,
-0.43471306562423706,
-0.9192396402359009,
-0.7810539603233337,
-0.19087332487106323,
0.08584986627101898,
0.5615748167037964,
0.2999209463596344,
0.7518471479415894,
0.4545031487941742,
0.22353561222553253,
-0.46297937631607056,
0.18360456824302673,
-0.17392268776893616,
0.12886829674243927,
0.011770252138376236,
-0.22686322033405304,
-0.6593078374862671,
-0.17582297325134277,
0.7796716094017029,
0.7073052525520325,
-0.5938246250152588,
0.1720171570777893,
-0.12101582437753677,
0.23954591155052185,
-0.4614197909832001,
0.07316115498542786,
-0.6202915906906128,
-0.10518898069858551,
-0.203939750790596,
-0.40112942457199097,
-0.4062277376651764,
-0.08847071975469589,
0.27179068326950073,
-0.3666178584098816,
0.406310498714447,
0.10452720522880554,
0.915215790271759,
0.20795950293540955,
-0.09284231811761856,
-0.19950635731220245,
-0.9993157386779785,
0.4463810324668884,
-0.7910363674163818,
0.7284818291664124,
0.2961901128292084,
0.5463376641273499,
-0.0786605030298233,
-0.3370656371116638,
-0.6623716354370117,
-0.27453896403312683,
0.17280451953411102,
-0.03699253872036934,
-0.15357518196105957,
0.2139826864004135,
0.2943502366542816,
0.31066620349884033,
-0.23824109137058258,
0.30854710936546326,
-0.42797309160232544,
-0.28883060812950134,
0.6024937629699707,
0.028509529307484627,
0.3363704979419708,
0.03257209435105324,
-0.10126025229692459,
-0.07614093273878098,
-0.6254771947860718,
-0.016638167202472687,
0.32626742124557495,
0.7301285862922668,
0.09171879291534424,
0.6884065270423889,
-0.12827879190444946,
0.6137439012527466,
0.309705913066864,
0.2768089771270752,
0.24424855411052704,
-0.37952178716659546,
0.0761813074350357,
0.44911402463912964,
0.43843135237693787,
0.4501315653324127,
0.3165392577648163,
-0.08803143352270126,
-0.22732609510421753,
-0.03504106029868126,
0.32548657059669495,
-0.7738077640533447,
-0.35694849491119385,
-0.04393073543906212,
-0.32116132974624634,
0.061404503881931305,
0.03798185661435127,
-0.6705527305603027,
-0.14846768975257874,
-0.46114417910575867,
0.519668698310852,
-0.508347749710083,
-0.16119857132434845,
-0.16272452473640442,
-0.2043554037809372,
0.2843087613582611,
0.3579168915748596,
-0.8681486248970032,
0.6785176396369934,
0.5638639330863953,
0.9750889539718628,
-0.12533913552761078,
-0.08305943757295609,
-1.136117696762085,
0.47166645526885986,
-0.07318201661109924,
0.8695235848426819,
-0.5125468969345093,
-0.6532654762268066,
-0.19889546930789948,
-0.31726494431495667,
-0.28639650344848633,
-0.7057207226753235,
0.5726246237754822,
-0.13061299920082092,
0.17841802537441254,
-0.36065950989723206,
-0.6850488781929016,
0.4978291988372803,
-0.12359382957220078,
-0.3879024088382721,
0.7677818536758423,
-0.05231127142906189,
-0.16037245094776154,
0.2554250657558441,
-1.0355234146118164,
-0.45887625217437744,
0.029393356293439865,
-0.42319101095199585,
-0.3645288646221161,
0.1268850415945053,
0.42254072427749634,
0.24480853974819183,
0.0030837843660265207,
-0.23062027990818024,
0.10564124584197998,
-0.5716182589530945,
0.47962242364883423,
-0.1600065976381302,
0.32254311442375183,
0.3209218680858612,
-0.3576754927635193,
0.16679531335830688,
-0.9636285901069641,
-0.24032069742679596,
-0.23165728151798248,
-0.3757268190383911,
-0.5001294016838074,
0.5653678178787231,
0.21635624766349792,
-0.060223910957574844,
-0.13426519930362701,
-0.886751651763916,
-0.11387401074171066,
-0.6867288947105408,
0.26293936371803284,
0.7679228186607361,
0.19226305186748505,
0.4493001103401184,
-0.13280253112316132,
0.512467622756958,
-0.08953350782394409,
-0.049052778631448746,
-0.06054012477397919,
-0.2833254933357239,
-0.8755097985267639,
-0.6633884906768799,
0.3650263547897339,
0.4807877242565155,
-0.4889388680458069,
0.6850752830505371,
-0.6703385710716248,
-0.4878237843513489,
-0.8243268728256226,
-0.4542483687400818,
0.6389222741127014,
0.4774312376976013,
0.3000114858150482,
-0.46100524067878723,
-0.5557971000671387,
-0.7846450209617615,
-0.43002814054489136,
-0.341554194688797,
-0.3566431999206543,
0.6224420070648193,
-0.147971972823143,
-0.028876030817627907,
0.9903472661972046,
-0.4082866311073303,
-0.357589453458786,
-0.19545157253742218,
0.06002297252416611,
0.0010980026563629508,
0.5045775771141052,
0.3919864594936371,
-0.850476861000061,
-0.4966927468776703,
-0.034936241805553436,
0.22352473437786102,
-0.5456518530845642,
-0.19829782843589783,
0.11861125379800797,
0.2008204162120819,
0.5750168561935425,
-0.35713642835617065,
0.4636424481868744,
0.29724058508872986,
-0.4654140770435333,
0.5341724157333374,
-0.046373747289180756,
0.12497653067111969,
-0.8420224785804749,
0.031589724123477936,
-0.10478506982326508,
-0.32872724533081055,
-0.8962201476097107,
-0.1690988689661026,
-0.12312185764312744,
-0.2700532376766205,
-0.3997119069099426,
0.2613210082054138,
-0.5505315661430359,
-0.4626334309577942,
-0.30873700976371765,
0.19173100590705872,
-0.1853250414133072,
0.4319896996021271,
0.20110951364040375,
1.1112562417984009,
0.15523381531238556,
-0.7171716690063477,
0.12901991605758667,
0.7953500747680664,
-0.460299015045166,
0.6423295140266418,
-0.6106247305870056,
0.33990252017974854,
0.021995404735207558,
0.1980830729007721,
-1.1452234983444214,
-0.18374906480312347,
-0.00545013090595603,
-0.5705585479736328,
0.38253170251846313,
-0.258670449256897,
-0.2819689214229584,
0.06837183237075806,
-0.08472780883312225,
0.3503498435020447,
0.33917155861854553,
-0.6202359795570374,
0.5322731137275696,
0.6685243844985962,
-0.5664886236190796,
0.01712685264647007,
-0.5243058800697327,
0.24757739901542664,
-0.24766099452972412,
-0.353639155626297,
0.6234068870544434,
-0.05610983818769455,
-0.11652390658855438,
-0.32241877913475037,
-0.2682424783706665,
-0.026575515046715736,
-0.23501978814601898,
0.34245336055755615,
-0.06018201634287834,
-0.16234736144542694,
-0.14200499653816223,
-0.18617196381092072,
-0.22932682931423187,
-0.20552805066108704,
0.24082395434379578,
0.6842744946479797,
-0.09713120758533478,
-0.7262418866157532,
-0.8304567933082581,
0.668729305267334,
0.581477165222168,
-0.29314151406288147,
0.4720472991466522,
0.5036213994026184,
-0.3434111475944519,
0.18845458328723907,
-0.7647829055786133,
0.1022319495677948,
-0.4638415277004242,
0.493927001953125,
-0.44106167554855347,
-0.8634503483772278,
0.699541449546814,
-0.004089602269232273,
0.0590694323182106,
0.12962575256824493,
0.4639793634414673,
-0.149424746632576,
0.9479619264602661,
0.48644864559173584,
-0.10481145232915878,
0.9209621548652649,
-0.005372055806219578,
0.5181781053543091,
-1.144736409187317,
-0.2620942294597626,
-0.8122081756591797,
-0.3071689307689667,
-0.2929798662662506,
-0.5314524173736572,
0.4438663721084595,
-0.2884454131126404,
0.08984609693288803,
0.6049494743347168,
-0.43020543456077576,
0.36123931407928467,
0.7223027348518372,
-0.041609302163124084,
0.03289742395281792,
0.035849109292030334,
0.21685028076171875,
-0.3150252103805542,
-0.6553046107292175,
-0.3914564251899719,
0.5528004169464111,
0.27804943919181824,
0.397016704082489,
0.3107054829597473,
0.6408907175064087,
0.2429121434688568,
-0.07012571394443512,
-0.6029985547065735,
0.5875466465950012,
-0.17939253151416779,
-0.3920228183269501,
-0.567088782787323,
-0.4920920431613922,
-0.6364849805831909,
0.2832341194152832,
0.14461687207221985,
-0.9847820997238159,
0.744871973991394,
0.2820545732975006,
-0.6368153095245361,
-0.007148429751396179,
-0.8168033361434937,
0.5579338669776917,
-0.06668122857809067,
0.21743284165859222,
-0.17395520210266113,
-0.6373687982559204,
-0.34989842772483826,
0.05694098770618439,
0.3238556683063507,
-0.1997278332710266,
0.22390468418598175,
0.9438365697860718,
-0.3361462354660034,
0.5997171401977539,
-0.41410404443740845,
0.05479327589273453,
0.2155015468597412,
-0.11118563264608383,
0.6858343482017517,
-0.2721182405948639,
-0.5525624752044678,
-0.20372293889522552,
0.23200103640556335,
-0.10604589432477951,
-0.5000174641609192,
0.48291775584220886,
-0.8940015435218811,
-0.36050763726234436,
-0.047976672649383545,
-0.4008435904979706,
-0.3074304461479187,
-0.2170397937297821,
0.4267699718475342,
0.8830869197845459,
-0.36450308561325073,
0.4148117005825043,
0.4211280643939972,
-0.14617788791656494,
0.221278578042984,
0.49425968527793884,
0.12762805819511414,
-0.3593367338180542,
1.2267040014266968,
0.27765825390815735,
0.5586223006248474,
0.43125638365745544,
0.01022262405604124,
-0.20744143426418304,
-0.8435191512107849,
-0.23264117538928986,
-0.03615722805261612,
-0.4103811979293823,
-0.015131074003875256,
-0.7627635598182678,
-0.23664523661136627,
-0.7981202006340027,
-0.1806180775165558,
-0.7001738548278809,
-0.8341765403747559,
-0.520187258720398,
-0.15615077316761017,
-0.011686557903885841,
-0.2132268249988556,
-0.029424592852592468,
0.8841619491577148,
-0.6371501088142395,
0.4294201135635376,
0.13483230769634247,
0.22528576850891113,
-0.4538820683956146,
-0.769753634929657,
-0.29928380250930786,
0.24615824222564697,
-0.13308727741241455,
-0.8617064952850342,
0.5267997980117798,
0.9883689880371094,
0.7665538787841797,
0.37879741191864014,
0.2316591739654541,
1.3344056606292725,
-0.549721360206604,
0.9140425324440002,
0.04688841849565506,
-0.9695761799812317,
0.6751386523246765,
-0.40705475211143494,
0.15607763826847076,
0.7458524107933044,
-0.18812595307826996,
-0.7589146494865417,
-0.3623468279838562,
-0.6155867576599121,
-1.2381823062896729,
0.9985969662666321,
0.4239463210105896,
0.14397478103637695,
-0.014666950330138206,
0.45225775241851807,
-0.09696555137634277,
0.11706062406301498,
-0.2891038954257965,
-0.20941781997680664,
-0.07483626157045364,
0.13993826508522034,
-0.04744214564561844,
-0.4145844280719757,
-0.17524556815624237,
-0.4730234146118164,
0.8823038339614868,
-0.05222303047776222,
0.6648018956184387,
0.2499164193868637,
-0.08765896409749985,
-0.36379435658454895,
0.35007673501968384,
0.5761377811431885,
0.6555023789405823,
-0.44904184341430664,
0.09710846096277237,
0.31315433979034424,
-0.2628398835659027,
-0.009242627769708633,
0.11842560023069382,
0.09729977697134018,
0.2735441029071808,
0.17483381927013397,
0.9150906801223755,
0.1551673263311386,
-0.9523328542709351,
0.6333867907524109,
-0.1314583718776703,
-0.00017262589244637638,
-0.5725786685943604,
0.29301509261131287,
-0.10052313655614853,
0.1445804089307785,
0.44140544533729553,
-0.08608196675777435,
0.23776385188102722,
-0.5023984313011169,
0.38683128356933594,
0.23862998187541962,
-0.6514378190040588,
-0.3650723099708557,
0.6319395303726196,
0.5555083751678467,
-1.0157392024993896,
0.7658929228782654,
-0.07100843638181686,
-0.5118203163146973,
0.5140267014503479,
0.6996141672134399,
0.8159658312797546,
-0.6799474954605103,
-0.17322196066379547,
0.03135992959141731,
0.13279381394386292,
0.405052125453949,
0.38079652190208435,
-0.23544634878635406,
-0.5800394415855408,
-0.411109060049057,
-0.6550406813621521,
-0.6608308553695679,
0.02626223862171173,
-0.9311464428901672,
0.3897995054721832,
-0.07544420659542084,
-0.19773398339748383,
0.1656499207019806,
-0.16464769840240479,
-0.3562309443950653,
0.00711000245064497,
0.2373073250055313,
0.6774126887321472,
-0.88676518201828,
0.6971944570541382,
0.8347672820091248,
0.08714713901281357,
-0.5709730982780457,
-0.06164257600903511,
-0.03753018006682396,
-0.3601188063621521,
-0.09663663059473038,
0.0314791314303875,
-0.002780458191409707,
0.09096502512693405,
-0.2565248906612396,
-0.80820631980896,
0.9821344614028931,
0.4752103388309479,
-0.8163985013961792,
0.07483679801225662,
0.06481938064098358,
0.5979777574539185,
-0.49870964884757996,
-0.083301842212677,
0.401827871799469,
0.2675720453262329,
0.40520426630973816,
-1.3036963939666748,
-0.2406575232744217,
-0.39222630858421326,
-0.07886700332164764,
0.3093249201774597,
-0.4425120949745178,
0.38851916790008545,
-0.018397752195596695,
-0.16897337138652802,
0.10309338569641113,
0.9308247566223145,
0.37338587641716003,
0.4756283760070801,
0.8131681680679321,
0.10485322773456573,
0.530762255191803,
0.07403511554002762,
0.7882993221282959,
0.01027851365506649,
-0.08508624136447906,
1.4084066152572632,
-0.44746920466423035,
0.9701045155525208,
0.9128977656364441,
-0.14242899417877197,
0.1788601130247116,
0.47694727778434753,
0.018294960260391235,
0.7642210125923157,
0.29102209210395813,
-0.4183211922645569,
-0.3388749361038208,
-0.250537246465683,
-0.31126099824905396,
0.5985420346260071,
0.5523363351821899,
-0.10772492736577988,
0.08469482511281967,
0.09202592819929123,
-0.2951793372631073,
0.2389514148235321,
0.04315657913684845,
0.9369697570800781,
0.026684613898396492,
-0.3688685894012451,
0.1893891841173172,
-0.06100720167160034,
0.31864890456199646,
-0.3813754916191101,
0.07504234462976456,
-0.006380828563123941,
0.20395047962665558,
-0.06429729610681534,
-0.062617227435112,
0.5083863735198975,
0.1822342574596405,
-0.09204772859811783,
-0.30022913217544556,
0.5676356554031372,
-0.5536312460899353,
-0.4567178785800934,
-0.026567848399281502,
0.25476983189582825,
0.41028887033462524,
-0.2578921318054199,
-0.15017567574977875,
0.10819912701845169,
0.00545094208791852,
-0.19581320881843567,
0.4728465974330902,
0.2135714888572693,
-0.16528239846229553,
0.5702715516090393,
0.7040471434593201,
0.2867562770843506,
0.14500389993190765,
0.42366668581962585,
0.893463134765625,
-0.4758543074131012,
-0.8365874290466309,
-0.6155464053153992,
0.4036903977394104,
-0.26103344559669495,
-0.2454223781824112,
0.640831708908081,
0.8406463861465454,
0.46462148427963257,
0.17950208485126495,
0.5878727436065674,
-0.12400428205728531,
0.8992522358894348,
-0.045185502618551254,
0.5365935564041138,
-0.2420155555009842,
0.5785359144210815,
-0.538425087928772,
-0.7243208289146423,
-0.2130851149559021,
0.7979217171669006,
-0.06781693547964096,
-0.31246471405029297,
0.17450976371765137,
0.9929574131965637,
-0.16184061765670776,
0.09486294537782669,
0.23616072535514832,
-0.057410720735788345,
0.912037193775177,
0.11842826753854752,
0.9025099873542786,
-0.43397772312164307,
0.5658919215202332,
-0.21823391318321228,
-0.26247334480285645,
-0.4942834675312042,
-0.6787311434745789,
-0.5122930407524109,
-0.8004178404808044,
-0.7887241244316101,
0.004031349439173937,
0.35875365138053894,
1.1944866180419922,
0.5725950598716736,
-0.8348855972290039,
-0.44971922039985657,
0.2030181735754013,
-0.48478391766548157,
-0.46472737193107605,
-0.15273281931877136,
0.46686646342277527,
-0.009813324548304081,
-0.7245621085166931,
0.9379218220710754,
0.2116788625717163,
-0.0828288272023201,
0.48323333263397217,
-0.1935584545135498,
-0.3894921839237213,
0.24715597927570343,
0.4586569666862488,
0.2721584439277649,
-0.5517481565475464,
-0.8754576444625854,
0.002340486506000161,
0.1612483710050583,
-0.04579829052090645,
0.6793730854988098,
-0.4241010546684265,
0.46095648407936096,
0.4358537793159485,
0.42604508996009827,
0.6260057687759399,
0.5442118048667908,
0.9328010678291321,
-1.1864615678787231,
0.07102661579847336,
0.45574596524238586,
0.0643400177359581,
0.3038841784000397,
-0.32242801785469055,
0.5122684836387634,
0.015459565445780754,
-0.6256837248802185,
-1.2326196432113647,
-0.029841933399438858,
-1.3833187818527222,
0.17488020658493042,
1.2600537538528442,
-0.013253303244709969,
0.05883187800645828,
-0.2758263051509857,
-0.3984377384185791,
0.5673388242721558,
-0.4194657504558563,
0.8880314826965332,
0.5254660248756409,
-0.6445578932762146,
-0.13345226645469666,
-0.32472389936447144,
0.4625341296195984,
0.5389449000358582,
-0.5243843793869019,
0.24985317885875702,
0.6870546936988831,
0.021170584484934807,
0.20679064095020294,
0.961408793926239,
-0.0063779717311263084,
0.38895753026008606,
-0.4276648759841919,
0.16984736919403076,
-0.1619216501712799,
-0.25232821702957153,
-0.2956225275993347,
0.022701524198055267,
0.020151287317276,
-0.7085203528404236
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06563v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06563v3
|
Unraveling the Mystery of Scaling Laws: Part I
| 2024-03-11T10:05:29 | 2024-04-05T06:39:34 |
Hui Su, Zhi Tian, Xiaoyu Shen, Xunliang Cai
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Scaling law principles indicate a power-law correlation between loss and
variables such as model size, dataset size, and computational resources
utilized during training. These principles play a vital role in optimizing
various aspects of model pre-training, ultimately contributing to the success
of large language models such as GPT-4, Llama and Gemini. However, the original
scaling law paper by OpenAI did not disclose the complete details necessary to
derive the precise scaling law formulas, and their conclusions are only based
on models containing up to 1.5 billion parameters. Though some subsequent works
attempt to unveil these details and scale to larger models, they often neglect
the training dependency of important factors such as the learning rate, context
length and batch size, leading to their failure to establish a reliable formula
for predicting the test loss trajectory. In this technical report, we confirm
that the scaling law formulations proposed in the original OpenAI paper remain
valid when scaling the model size up to 33 billion, but the constant
coefficients in these formulas vary significantly with the experiment setup. We
meticulously identify influential factors and provide transparent, step-by-step
instructions to estimate all constant terms in scaling-law formulas by training
on models with only 1M~60M parameters. Using these estimated formulas, we
showcase the capability to accurately predict various attributes for models
with up to 33B parameters before their training, including (1) the minimum
possible test loss; (2) the minimum required training steps and processed
tokens to achieve a specific loss; (3) the critical batch size with an optimal
time/computation trade-off at any loss value; and (4) the complete test loss
trajectory with arbitrary batch size.
|
[
-0.3647915720939636,
-0.4521329700946808,
0.5713735222816467,
0.27337053418159485,
0.07126423716545105,
-0.6245178580284119,
-0.2947200536727905,
-0.20043087005615234,
-0.09527545422315598,
0.5979762673377991,
-0.5958635210990906,
0.3461090922355652,
-0.603621244430542,
-0.23158887028694153,
-0.2733507752418518,
1.151473879814148,
-0.23305630683898926,
0.2612636387348175,
0.06857932358980179,
-0.17911577224731445,
-0.24142678081989288,
-0.31240007281303406,
-0.425773948431015,
-0.22912649810314178,
0.5398916006088257,
0.3265119791030884,
0.6146214604377747,
0.9698952436447144,
0.7485899925231934,
0.08037672936916351,
-0.40257129073143005,
-0.2600860893726349,
-0.7163659334182739,
-0.46120133996009827,
0.060817379504442215,
-0.8348342180252075,
-0.38753363490104675,
0.25439581274986267,
0.9121024012565613,
0.6587827205657959,
-0.30130720138549805,
0.20068436861038208,
0.07905679196119308,
0.698212206363678,
-0.6796560883522034,
0.13160330057144165,
-0.37321895360946655,
0.11491351574659348,
-0.1960686892271042,
-0.14886493980884552,
-0.553390622138977,
-0.13788311183452606,
-0.04265723377466202,
-0.6812098026275635,
0.3618026375770569,
0.07140909135341644,
1.0455759763717651,
0.31826722621917725,
-0.6844402551651001,
-0.34485071897506714,
-0.7583099603652954,
0.7996768355369568,
-0.705147385597229,
0.17427434027194977,
0.39591076970100403,
0.377672016620636,
-0.025622885674238205,
-0.7558121681213379,
-0.5413578152656555,
-0.44647952914237976,
-0.05136491358280182,
-0.20950858294963837,
-0.04719145596027374,
0.17798377573490143,
0.578467845916748,
0.5211876034736633,
-0.36765262484550476,
0.33949896693229675,
-0.5833402872085571,
-0.2418932169675827,
0.5664412379264832,
0.29976460337638855,
0.24577157199382782,
0.3206612467765808,
-0.0996798425912857,
-0.3199893534183502,
-0.963459849357605,
-0.0936388149857521,
0.3186793327331543,
0.5754405856132507,
-0.2923908531665802,
0.37253808975219727,
0.10129592567682266,
0.2614773213863373,
0.18194781243801117,
-0.3525109589099884,
0.20441178977489471,
-0.6210547685623169,
-0.2081911712884903,
0.04074409604072571,
0.778428316116333,
0.28408119082450867,
0.28958016633987427,
-0.027388794347643852,
0.10163123160600662,
-0.5936977863311768,
0.38019585609436035,
-1.2252051830291748,
0.03973725438117981,
-0.21721088886260986,
-0.5157634615898132,
-0.40515318512916565,
0.0023137503303587437,
-0.32965168356895447,
-0.367410808801651,
-0.12944425642490387,
0.7059727907180786,
-0.047192808240652084,
-0.45828408002853394,
-0.03724055737257004,
0.05809810385107994,
0.4179803729057312,
0.21280741691589355,
-1.1074273586273193,
0.3475291132926941,
0.5210955739021301,
0.8475699424743652,
0.36041268706321716,
-0.2952232360839844,
-0.33453837037086487,
-0.19573917984962463,
-0.5735791325569153,
-0.13354012370109558,
-0.11334600299596786,
-0.17240044474601746,
-0.16689635813236237,
0.029355164617300034,
-0.03190712258219719,
-0.1930726170539856,
0.3966737389564514,
-0.5341356992721558,
-0.15862791240215302,
-0.3591388165950775,
-0.5760689377784729,
-0.16847150027751923,
-0.01739591732621193,
-0.835185170173645,
0.46462222933769226,
0.08773523569107056,
-0.7536554336547852,
0.5832706689834595,
-0.6506134271621704,
-0.5052714943885803,
-0.13808217644691467,
0.02915804833173752,
-0.7650683522224426,
0.3070423901081085,
-0.16130851209163666,
0.4615749418735504,
-0.6667920351028442,
-0.07648933678865433,
-0.4110615849494934,
-0.14793117344379425,
-0.16235652565956116,
-0.28168895840644836,
0.9623656272888184,
0.31696197390556335,
-0.37338653206825256,
-0.039206333458423615,
-0.6803548336029053,
0.1165507584810257,
0.3630506694316864,
-0.24865449965000153,
-0.06092383340001106,
-0.17503689229488373,
-0.09786989539861679,
-0.19828811287879944,
0.135476753115654,
-0.6300138235092163,
0.2727511525154114,
0.03613732382655144,
0.5774966478347778,
0.5611454844474792,
-0.03973858430981636,
0.5811861157417297,
-0.019630173221230507,
0.5499880313873291,
-0.23128654062747955,
0.31803634762763977,
-0.2861238121986389,
-0.37063080072402954,
-0.37016481161117554,
-0.04598340764641762,
0.28670915961265564,
0.20594331622123718,
0.06278679519891739,
-0.00898992270231247,
-0.27199703454971313,
-0.8243733048439026,
-0.2830224633216858,
0.10688134282827377,
0.43899381160736084,
0.425617516040802,
0.16781415045261383,
-0.013657032512128353,
-0.7872690558433533,
-0.8205510973930359,
-0.2415105402469635,
-0.316705584526062,
-0.09446510672569275,
0.14235587418079376,
0.6532793641090393,
-0.0690363198518753,
0.6590999960899353,
-0.40093016624450684,
-0.3069760501384735,
-0.17256921529769897,
0.15806546807289124,
0.24448978900909424,
0.4841729998588562,
0.6436586380004883,
-0.8473529815673828,
-0.41892221570014954,
0.30866360664367676,
-0.5050511956214905,
0.04754853621125221,
-0.08495965600013733,
0.2603794038295746,
-0.23048539459705353,
0.6931326985359192,
-0.3872050344944,
0.44650501012802124,
0.3805532455444336,
-0.05437752604484558,
0.9101443290710449,
-0.4427274167537689,
-0.006280888337641954,
-0.8285325169563293,
-0.0891377255320549,
0.22037261724472046,
0.13835057616233826,
-0.7101713418960571,
0.3687942624092102,
0.49904510378837585,
0.17693203687667847,
-0.4303227365016937,
0.4663955569267273,
-0.3452187478542328,
0.09251882880926132,
-0.21920521557331085,
-0.5691414475440979,
-0.22442954778671265,
0.4391411244869232,
-0.41724470257759094,
0.9893665909767151,
0.5223729014396667,
-0.8522985577583313,
0.035154569894075394,
-0.13271397352218628,
-0.042201124131679535,
0.3482230603694916,
-0.6964320540428162,
-0.20124782621860504,
0.14958003163337708,
0.16631652414798737,
-0.7362778186798096,
-0.16380488872528076,
-0.22646532952785492,
-0.3479749858379364,
0.49752137064933777,
-0.30753621459007263,
-0.6655667424201965,
-0.3472093939781189,
-0.1269248127937317,
0.5035381317138672,
0.7581000328063965,
-0.4447990953922272,
0.6340841054916382,
0.3401816487312317,
0.4279177486896515,
-0.47729071974754333,
-0.8852041959762573,
-0.2083163559436798,
-0.38707035779953003,
-0.5583140850067139,
0.20925968885421753,
-0.2312169075012207,
-0.30336421728134155,
-0.3544193208217621,
-0.11504119634628296,
-0.31637611985206604,
0.1428491473197937,
0.3429538309574127,
-0.07027121633291245,
-0.5516898036003113,
0.07201056182384491,
-0.2759268581867218,
0.23324993252754211,
0.5352407097816467,
-0.24912826716899872,
0.3656638264656067,
-0.500911295413971,
0.03486691787838936,
-0.49518436193466187,
-0.3076033890247345,
0.7478947043418884,
-0.0912269800901413,
0.8444979190826416,
0.5640724897384644,
-0.11849038302898407,
0.10895298421382904,
-0.3498692512512207,
-0.06988905370235443,
-0.43992891907691956,
0.5326361060142517,
-0.5349624156951904,
-0.44004204869270325,
0.8066871166229248,
0.11068368703126907,
-0.014663582667708397,
0.8460054397583008,
0.6220645308494568,
0.13398674130439758,
0.9259912371635437,
1.0333949327468872,
-0.1925351619720459,
0.5502642393112183,
-0.29738849401474,
0.05788587033748627,
-0.8499512672424316,
-0.06468468904495239,
-0.5605111718177795,
-0.18000318109989166,
-0.995834231376648,
-0.2677464485168457,
0.3332762122154236,
-0.13017511367797852,
-0.6984803676605225,
0.37162673473358154,
-0.1254577338695526,
0.6872918009757996,
0.44868430495262146,
0.12485864758491516,
-0.016076356172561646,
-0.06387542933225632,
-0.042342595756053925,
0.04369749873876572,
-0.4707454741001129,
-0.03753980994224548,
1.6552090644836426,
0.5637418031692505,
0.8649466037750244,
0.0537433885037899,
0.5363353490829468,
0.1195358857512474,
0.3824116289615631,
-0.8646937012672424,
0.42307373881340027,
0.07926808297634125,
-0.8222066760063171,
-0.6155876517295837,
-0.8879048824310303,
-0.8749030828475952,
0.06927669048309326,
0.2759719789028168,
-0.3768487274646759,
-0.16552145779132843,
0.09954224526882172,
-0.19477039575576782,
0.7371952533721924,
-0.6656634211540222,
0.8000114560127258,
-0.19314119219779968,
-0.15996971726417542,
-0.2821114957332611,
-0.9473093748092651,
0.28076353669166565,
-0.2748023271560669,
0.17070996761322021,
0.15048284828662872,
-0.13144823908805847,
1.0235573053359985,
-1.037415862083435,
0.6340635418891907,
-0.2823588252067566,
-0.2601371109485626,
0.3804642856121063,
0.026403464376926422,
0.3447186350822449,
-0.30676594376564026,
0.11557916551828384,
0.18034882843494415,
-0.03566034883260727,
-0.5225442051887512,
-0.6361201405525208,
0.4032716453075409,
-0.904968798160553,
-0.25984588265419006,
-0.04150458797812462,
-0.5021312832832336,
0.043853744864463806,
0.5186402797698975,
0.4803200662136078,
0.26465699076652527,
-0.0020517748780548573,
0.4019084572792053,
0.8872058391571045,
0.1885015219449997,
0.35949844121932983,
0.5354520678520203,
-0.13556110858917236,
-0.2749009132385254,
0.8157788515090942,
0.366586834192276,
0.5121163129806519,
0.2965123653411865,
0.6433917284011841,
0.037655822932720184,
-0.74225914478302,
-0.27168402075767517,
0.630906343460083,
-0.6551408767700195,
0.1455651819705963,
-0.1664782166481018,
-0.344312846660614,
-0.40209415555000305,
0.034807853400707245,
-0.6005946397781372,
-0.27959296107292175,
-0.14961417019367218,
-0.07366852462291718,
0.27638134360313416,
0.7065321207046509,
-0.16200999915599823,
0.5842212438583374,
-0.351831316947937,
-0.03771721571683884,
0.1285460740327835,
0.41223931312561035,
0.027966002002358437,
-1.0203800201416016,
-0.43091312050819397,
0.10025817900896072,
-0.22284963726997375,
-0.6221039295196533,
0.1995173543691635,
0.21551989018917084,
0.3843095898628235,
0.6556318402290344,
-0.10452207922935486,
0.601660430431366,
-0.629194974899292,
0.4872550666332245,
0.4283636510372162,
-0.6438738703727722,
0.5196888446807861,
-0.33802667260169983,
0.05996404215693474,
0.34489309787750244,
0.5072505474090576,
-0.15701408684253693,
-0.01997026428580284,
-0.7793515920639038,
-0.6339083909988403,
0.6493733525276184,
0.12614190578460693,
0.3011291027069092,
0.5237805247306824,
0.835045337677002,
0.09843239188194275,
0.029296664521098137,
-0.7227613925933838,
-0.2246181070804596,
-0.07453587651252747,
-0.15090464055538177,
-0.22994491457939148,
-0.16738370060920715,
-0.05233268067240715,
-0.27142077684402466,
0.6537083387374878,
-0.030552169308066368,
0.07867813855409622,
-0.10782543569803238,
0.03163006529211998,
-0.22466334700584412,
-0.03757896646857262,
0.87225741147995,
0.6918192505836487,
-0.31086546182632446,
-0.2230391949415207,
0.19753554463386536,
-1.0854274034500122,
0.3777085840702057,
-0.08388224989175797,
-0.2348461002111435,
-0.4336342215538025,
0.3113742172718048,
0.8825541734695435,
0.07283414155244827,
-0.4657807946205139,
0.48497891426086426,
-0.21552301943302155,
-0.503777265548706,
-0.4033830761909485,
0.07071974873542786,
-0.29519134759902954,
-0.0004853905120398849,
0.43182122707366943,
-0.02640374004840851,
-0.05874314531683922,
-0.4601883888244629,
0.19149784743785858,
0.18477927148342133,
-0.545954704284668,
-0.38512691855430603,
0.8728405833244324,
-0.11456789076328278,
-0.11002439260482788,
0.7308818101882935,
-0.08970261365175247,
-0.20121248066425323,
0.9854102730751038,
0.3480108380317688,
0.6777023077011108,
-0.44314706325531006,
0.11225231736898422,
0.5109736323356628,
0.6721914410591125,
-0.476712703704834,
-0.28331154584884644,
0.09197192639112473,
-0.421064555644989,
-0.3226284086704254,
-0.39537766575813293,
-0.5601027607917786,
0.21843034029006958,
-0.9863884449005127,
0.2176838368177414,
-0.768429160118103,
-0.0783444344997406,
0.04387577995657921,
0.29288655519485474,
-0.6711856126785278,
0.4500739276409149,
0.0644388422369957,
0.9121352434158325,
-0.8360607028007507,
0.3649563491344452,
0.2660422921180725,
-0.8640044331550598,
-1.279065489768982,
0.03474954888224602,
0.19561858475208282,
-0.9290500283241272,
0.6821498870849609,
0.1913159042596817,
0.1549682766199112,
-0.1236814334988594,
-0.688585102558136,
-0.9310561418533325,
1.1319130659103394,
0.5393504500389099,
-0.3328793942928314,
-0.29294878244400024,
0.08911547809839249,
0.5582440495491028,
-0.4144255220890045,
0.46224695444107056,
0.4961445927619934,
0.32829830050468445,
0.2964881360530853,
-1.2720319032669067,
0.3318865895271301,
-0.05765620991587639,
-0.11332666128873825,
0.4849167466163635,
-0.7343490719795227,
1.2575018405914307,
-0.6942601799964905,
0.17681851983070374,
0.0911027267575264,
0.6505880951881409,
-0.15882810950279236,
0.2857862710952759,
0.37178876996040344,
0.6280661225318909,
0.6506568789482117,
0.010098896920681,
1.347393274307251,
-0.154214009642601,
0.5374898314476013,
0.8676928281784058,
-0.14967122673988342,
0.7308270335197449,
0.25330111384391785,
-0.4582592248916626,
0.28724437952041626,
0.7057589292526245,
-0.17696276307106018,
0.4721374213695526,
0.37925583124160767,
0.22690434753894806,
0.2491573542356491,
0.09236739575862885,
-0.3584767282009125,
0.2429085075855255,
0.0420755073428154,
-0.5408913493156433,
-0.05514957383275032,
0.06305166333913803,
0.39407965540885925,
-0.3714033365249634,
-0.8308491110801697,
0.46987903118133545,
-0.21074466407299042,
-0.39951542019844055,
0.7081481218338013,
-0.15695708990097046,
0.19739361107349396,
-0.7250596880912781,
0.29056504368782043,
-0.20432007312774658,
0.442994624376297,
0.013890397734940052,
-0.5321641564369202,
0.05670581012964249,
-0.237395241856575,
-0.22362913191318512,
-0.24165348708629608,
0.1770843267440796,
0.021480459719896317,
-0.39694663882255554,
-0.0086125573143363,
-0.132473886013031,
0.38858741521835327,
-0.3122272491455078,
-0.36115220189094543,
-0.08828255534172058,
0.023523962125182152,
-0.3461652398109436,
0.3988116681575775,
0.41930708289146423,
0.044621191918849945,
0.8095749616622925,
0.2396117001771927,
0.2252308428287506,
0.2409999966621399,
0.020779501646757126,
0.6700823307037354,
-0.536067008972168,
-0.5341747403144836,
-0.7455602288246155,
0.267644464969635,
0.04859599098563194,
-0.3514518737792969,
0.7975533604621887,
0.4869210124015808,
0.8014585375785828,
0.11904168128967285,
0.6692674160003662,
0.03889349102973938,
0.04737091064453125,
-0.3898150324821472,
0.7452560067176819,
-0.734757125377655,
0.06148725748062134,
-0.026711707934737206,
-0.7078152894973755,
-0.1514454483985901,
0.25876113772392273,
-0.1947818547487259,
0.3782818019390106,
0.7988728284835815,
0.6694295406341553,
0.034088149666786194,
-0.06709795445203781,
0.3248251974582672,
0.40183013677597046,
0.49212029576301575,
0.38069143891334534,
-0.010751994326710701,
-0.686228334903717,
0.9704995155334473,
-0.10602796822786331,
-0.3683772087097168,
-0.4796238839626312,
-0.5569218397140503,
-0.627569854259491,
-0.5370973348617554,
-0.4615502655506134,
-0.45457321405410767,
-0.3571390211582184,
0.36702531576156616,
0.9176552891731262,
-0.480307012796402,
-0.3840048909187317,
-0.428518146276474,
-0.2557830512523651,
-0.49611371755599976,
-0.17594286799430847,
0.25344160199165344,
-0.35241901874542236,
-0.09675571322441101,
-0.03191114589571953,
-0.07856297492980957,
0.29049941897392273,
-0.5995111465454102,
-0.37814801931381226,
0.055306680500507355,
0.2835380434989929,
0.18185226619243622,
0.5960429310798645,
-0.6430778503417969,
0.007071270607411861,
-0.287153035402298,
-0.1825677752494812,
0.057752467691898346,
1.0344340801239014,
-0.21044433116912842,
0.47423306107521057,
0.34051501750946045,
0.5194830298423767,
0.7138826847076416,
-0.5398197174072266,
0.6223315596580505,
-0.5748835802078247,
0.051854487508535385,
0.033692844212055206,
0.3225853145122528,
-0.039897020906209946,
-0.35886162519454956,
0.789117157459259,
0.10905478149652481,
-0.6579499840736389,
-1.0250972509384155,
0.25860047340393066,
-0.790948212146759,
0.025209546089172363,
0.8939414620399475,
-0.23021851480007172,
-0.531798779964447,
0.626778244972229,
0.01639430783689022,
0.09496559947729111,
0.06141853705048561,
0.5578795671463013,
0.7444482445716858,
-0.08389438688755035,
-0.3140569031238556,
-0.7089701294898987,
0.34569743275642395,
0.4751257002353668,
-0.43995222449302673,
0.3564455509185791,
0.178428515791893,
0.39924490451812744,
0.361136794090271,
0.36930692195892334,
-0.09059212356805801,
0.30321237444877625,
0.4150511622428894,
-0.037284404039382935,
-0.06511162221431732,
-0.138618603348732,
-0.3813784420490265,
0.20501616597175598,
0.01993686892092228,
-0.05123934894800186
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.07039v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.07039v1
|
From English to ASIC: Hardware Implementation with Large Language Model
| 2024-03-11T09:57:16 | 2024-03-11T09:57:16 |
Emil Goh, Maoyang Xiang, I-Chyn Wey, T. Hui Teo
|
cs.AR
|
cs.AR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
In the realm of ASIC engineering, the landscape has been significantly
reshaped by the rapid development of LLM, paralleled by an increase in the
complexity of modern digital circuits. This complexity has escalated the
requirements for HDL coding, necessitating a higher degree of precision and
sophistication. However, challenges have been faced due to the
less-than-optimal performance of modern language models in generating hardware
description code, a situation further exacerbated by the scarcity of the
corresponding high-quality code datasets. These challenges have highlighted the
gap between the potential of LLMs to revolutionize digital circuit design and
their current capabilities in accurately interpreting and implementing hardware
specifications. To address these challenges, a strategy focusing on the
fine-tuning of the leading-edge nature language model and the reshuffling of
the HDL code dataset has been developed. The fine-tuning aims to enhance
models' proficiency in generating precise and efficient ASIC design, while the
dataset reshuffling is intended to broaden the scope and improve the quality of
training material. The model demonstrated significant improvements compared to
the base model, with approximately 10% to 20% increase in accuracy across a
wide range of temperature for the pass@1 metric. This approach is expected to
facilitate a simplified and more efficient LLM-assisted framework for complex
circuit design, leveraging their capabilities to meet the sophisticated demands
of HDL coding and thus streamlining the ASIC development process.
|
[
-0.5670956969261169,
-0.7997541427612305,
0.326689749956131,
0.2147267460823059,
-0.2732909321784973,
0.1017511710524559,
-0.3631400465965271,
-0.6711657643318176,
-0.09590835124254227,
0.538488507270813,
-0.629156768321991,
-0.3973483443260193,
-0.4881385266780853,
0.09241573512554169,
-0.34215834736824036,
0.5943164825439453,
-0.44706106185913086,
-0.02594834752380848,
-0.05867999792098999,
0.11263521015644073,
-0.45062485337257385,
-0.319661408662796,
-0.47792908549308777,
-0.6972837448120117,
-0.014067619107663631,
0.21045322716236115,
0.49167799949645996,
0.688702404499054,
0.7143470644950867,
0.2547421157360077,
-0.3534906506538391,
0.23232579231262207,
-0.11947589367628098,
0.014114098623394966,
-0.16123108565807343,
-0.2378852367401123,
-0.7926642298698425,
0.030776353552937508,
0.8059647679328918,
0.7614192366600037,
-0.18764038383960724,
0.3053082823753357,
0.20795834064483643,
0.777184009552002,
-0.306184321641922,
0.20821532607078552,
-0.6765403747558594,
0.054865751415491104,
-0.21172131597995758,
-0.5356350541114807,
-0.4039105176925659,
-0.072270467877388,
-0.2867213189601898,
-0.5712688565254211,
-0.12238233536481857,
0.08895504474639893,
0.8887789845466614,
0.11167976260185242,
-0.28692686557769775,
-0.29083430767059326,
-1.0527955293655396,
0.8301976323127747,
-0.7242840528488159,
0.9128133058547974,
0.17692610621452332,
0.1419551968574524,
-0.133685901761055,
-0.5894037485122681,
-0.3201105296611786,
-0.08668945729732513,
0.3649676740169525,
-0.10821869224309921,
0.09755579382181168,
0.2887037396430969,
0.24701446294784546,
0.68783038854599,
-0.23079872131347656,
0.29355597496032715,
-0.6271810531616211,
0.024420330300927162,
0.7719986438751221,
0.19747063517570496,
0.09567094594240189,
0.04005088657140732,
-0.10357250273227692,
0.38350340723991394,
-1.1223185062408447,
-0.2308616191148758,
0.5067185163497925,
0.7394819259643555,
-0.1874319165945053,
0.3278874456882477,
-0.2335958480834961,
0.646998405456543,
-0.047732219099998474,
0.07855638861656189,
0.07269985228776932,
-0.4406979978084564,
-0.2866238057613373,
0.019743572920560837,
0.5095338225364685,
0.31509214639663696,
0.27043676376342773,
0.14751698076725006,
-0.4842854142189026,
-0.16262374818325043,
0.23781803250312805,
-0.9949420094490051,
-0.24855853617191315,
0.42253798246383667,
-0.6018772125244141,
-0.2906739115715027,
-0.16041024029254913,
-0.5110699534416199,
-0.16499614715576172,
-0.7787423133850098,
0.1613430231809616,
-0.12119848281145096,
-0.1952235996723175,
0.4112449586391449,
0.3187527060508728,
0.23960788547992706,
0.30439460277557373,
-1.0075373649597168,
0.5234440565109253,
0.9378877282142639,
0.6502564549446106,
-0.029230261221528053,
-0.08107125014066696,
-0.2763424515724182,
0.1736416518688202,
-0.25008726119995117,
0.5808122754096985,
-0.4835498631000519,
-0.4993759095668793,
-0.097074493765831,
-0.09819678217172623,
0.4047641158103943,
-0.5961571931838989,
0.46715202927589417,
-0.6845682263374329,
-0.09509624540805817,
-0.06481226533651352,
-0.4235166013240814,
0.03484051674604416,
0.3594876527786255,
-0.45305177569389343,
0.8141314387321472,
-0.4238930642604828,
-0.6290302872657776,
0.015110482461750507,
-0.7689803838729858,
-0.8347000479698181,
0.1335771679878235,
-0.12996774911880493,
-0.28217998147010803,
0.30672597885131836,
0.05984039977192879,
0.2030746191740036,
-0.7196274399757385,
0.11748898029327393,
-0.029658693820238113,
-0.3652307987213135,
0.019973281770944595,
-0.5524799823760986,
0.7606619596481323,
0.42696478962898254,
-0.13920612633228302,
0.09938213229179382,
-0.6796445846557617,
0.20613716542720795,
-0.1161104366183281,
-0.6823275089263916,
-0.05967951938509941,
0.09525524079799652,
0.27999454736709595,
0.0012392416829243302,
0.681529700756073,
-0.7561002373695374,
0.20758621394634247,
-0.6632928848266602,
0.7565680146217346,
0.7586515545845032,
-0.24116496741771698,
0.34166717529296875,
-0.04660278558731079,
0.3225381076335907,
-0.20529846847057343,
0.5066699385643005,
-0.13549843430519104,
-0.5000152587890625,
-0.3630361557006836,
0.1677449494600296,
0.4149426221847534,
0.6172082424163818,
-0.582132875919342,
0.30361655354499817,
-0.1570044904947281,
-0.2373499572277069,
-0.5985627174377441,
0.35808783769607544,
0.3941704332828522,
0.24485847353935242,
0.3687015771865845,
-0.18782517313957214,
-0.6837913393974304,
-0.765792965888977,
0.12840916216373444,
-0.05822368711233139,
-0.2031213492155075,
0.44838982820510864,
0.22054477035999298,
-0.43706220388412476,
0.501180112361908,
-0.5519394278526306,
0.004719773773103952,
-0.2689681649208069,
0.009295032359659672,
0.48532915115356445,
0.6483758687973022,
-0.04937540739774704,
-0.7060260772705078,
-0.29379743337631226,
0.544174313545227,
-0.6618977785110474,
-0.03628366440534592,
0.3525318205356598,
0.10418800264596939,
0.5318278074264526,
0.6286023259162903,
-0.471432626247406,
0.2946557402610779,
0.49440672993659973,
-0.12763045728206635,
0.6969063878059387,
-0.5426194667816162,
0.39093634486198425,
-1.0594009160995483,
0.09952195733785629,
-0.10238208621740341,
-0.042572714388370514,
-0.49404677748680115,
0.6690241098403931,
0.08613427728414536,
-0.23666912317276,
-0.5215945839881897,
0.6142576932907104,
-0.3880487084388733,
-0.026461411267518997,
-0.3937816321849823,
-0.1943168342113495,
-0.08064550906419754,
0.04573621228337288,
0.05910540744662285,
0.8111163377761841,
0.5374640226364136,
-0.7224264740943909,
0.3863488435745239,
0.04321923851966858,
-0.12874948978424072,
0.5366500616073608,
-0.767308235168457,
0.0006134387804195285,
-0.01307806558907032,
-0.23215366899967194,
-0.3931431472301483,
0.058545179665088654,
-0.11612045764923096,
-0.2804231345653534,
0.49642372131347656,
-0.01625308208167553,
-0.7931448817253113,
-0.6612472534179688,
-0.28375542163848877,
0.6875508427619934,
0.5944032073020935,
-0.4640377163887024,
0.7720646858215332,
0.5237078070640564,
-0.17918746173381805,
-0.20308873057365417,
-0.6226538419723511,
-0.030033422634005547,
0.06503703445196152,
-0.672330379486084,
0.5122379064559937,
-0.39784055948257446,
-0.37654802203178406,
-0.3865378499031067,
-0.08868741244077682,
-0.10308446735143661,
0.1616978943347931,
0.18336746096611023,
0.24226535856723785,
-0.5468816757202148,
0.04665259271860123,
0.026069937273859978,
-0.2589700520038605,
0.019865814596414566,
-0.5001875758171082,
0.7389084100723267,
-0.12046398222446442,
-0.20173479616641998,
-0.8853883147239685,
0.3342689573764801,
0.6136003136634827,
-0.21254605054855347,
0.3586953282356262,
-0.06927695870399475,
-0.6148395538330078,
-0.294574111700058,
-0.3958859443664551,
-0.2591722905635834,
-0.605137050151825,
0.2933635711669922,
-0.7562946677207947,
-0.6985747814178467,
0.632505476474762,
-0.06394100934267044,
0.4394634962081909,
0.36004871129989624,
0.31648096442222595,
-0.3872409760951996,
1.0372402667999268,
0.8304734826087952,
-0.07314497232437134,
0.38925811648368835,
-0.16937988996505737,
0.23365727066993713,
-0.8850167393684387,
-0.14805103838443756,
-0.3850400745868683,
-0.45241063833236694,
-0.6995018124580383,
-0.3090996742248535,
0.20816288888454437,
-0.06897192448377609,
-0.5341223478317261,
0.254169225692749,
-0.534122884273529,
0.6421879529953003,
0.3788456618785858,
0.2045292854309082,
0.529161810874939,
0.3873135447502136,
0.024246959015727043,
-0.11279790848493576,
-0.521124541759491,
-0.3535834848880768,
1.0776808261871338,
0.6780208945274353,
0.9890217781066895,
-0.036866988986730576,
0.40339043736457825,
0.0883883461356163,
0.15800583362579346,
-0.55551677942276,
0.4920290410518646,
-0.7278451919555664,
-0.5733229517936707,
-0.14153766632080078,
-0.38544487953186035,
-0.6938156485557556,
-0.47846847772598267,
0.16633571684360504,
-0.5745463371276855,
-0.19598326086997986,
0.2532149851322174,
-0.5236793756484985,
0.4643881022930145,
-0.34995102882385254,
0.7179058790206909,
-0.3383236527442932,
-0.4443657696247101,
-0.5881887674331665,
-0.2696525454521179,
0.21269714832305908,
0.09325394034385681,
0.28290441632270813,
0.09362156689167023,
0.19852295517921448,
0.6207650303840637,
-0.496163547039032,
0.6185315251350403,
0.017769375815987587,
-0.43292897939682007,
0.39133042097091675,
0.09122394770383835,
0.3538506329059601,
0.015529212541878223,
-0.37056198716163635,
0.1829083412885666,
-0.0031667565926909447,
-0.45408502221107483,
-0.35189855098724365,
0.883988082408905,
-0.872295081615448,
-0.587615430355072,
0.10250770300626755,
-0.764945924282074,
-0.2001924067735672,
0.0705740824341774,
0.127052441239357,
0.7563685774803162,
0.08616888523101807,
0.0729779601097107,
1.0000375509262085,
-0.37539568543434143,
0.1995580494403839,
0.4302940368652344,
-0.5201546549797058,
-0.3592659533023834,
1.118124008178711,
0.11454134434461594,
0.2912530303001404,
0.34733718633651733,
-0.07165241986513138,
-0.21063978970050812,
-0.7871360778808594,
-0.48454153537750244,
0.2448401153087616,
-0.695254921913147,
-0.3020085394382477,
-0.37210386991500854,
-0.7003517746925354,
-0.2659958600997925,
-0.48569074273109436,
-0.7038692831993103,
-0.10222920775413513,
-0.3356945216655731,
0.04256495460867882,
0.4515586197376251,
1.0367056131362915,
0.2151433527469635,
0.34816107153892517,
-0.7228257656097412,
0.3436843752861023,
0.16493061184883118,
0.7536881566047668,
0.017408980056643486,
-0.8104348182678223,
-0.26780965924263,
0.13463295996189117,
-0.38862091302871704,
-0.41346466541290283,
0.22002963721752167,
0.12010568380355835,
0.4078778028488159,
0.12714256346225739,
-0.35676342248916626,
0.7683064341545105,
-0.5139039158821106,
0.4046589136123657,
-0.10165685415267944,
-0.9960073828697205,
0.7931694388389587,
-0.37520575523376465,
0.5015934705734253,
0.5000892877578735,
0.09107904881238937,
-0.3736244738101959,
-0.1468157023191452,
-0.5530344843864441,
-0.8931286334991455,
0.4851231276988983,
-0.05896137282252312,
0.22422583401203156,
0.43026846647262573,
0.5904409289360046,
0.06170777603983879,
0.44219163060188293,
-0.5601264834403992,
-0.20070526003837585,
0.1813877671957016,
-0.395028293132782,
0.11766768991947174,
-0.24369440972805023,
0.15175318717956543,
-0.5372413992881775,
0.8250831365585327,
-0.04232846945524216,
0.2785228192806244,
-0.3280981481075287,
-0.009123191237449646,
-0.1978691816329956,
0.1545691341161728,
0.5975694060325623,
0.511164128780365,
-0.24688857793807983,
0.09603460878133774,
0.221165731549263,
-0.5667518973350525,
-0.0481613427400589,
0.1297273337841034,
-0.40255007147789,
-0.23315651714801788,
0.06865329295396805,
0.5513620972633362,
0.2606554925441742,
-0.6405404210090637,
0.06367950886487961,
0.07958488166332245,
-0.05462857335805893,
-0.16975842416286469,
-0.13569530844688416,
0.07096098363399506,
0.2196427434682846,
0.31283479928970337,
-0.10358972102403641,
0.18070121109485626,
-0.7537556290626526,
0.43004342913627625,
0.6075600981712341,
-0.301132470369339,
-0.5635245442390442,
0.7713220119476318,
0.5101845860481262,
-0.45836541056632996,
0.9655185341835022,
-0.35969072580337524,
-0.4781757891178131,
0.8186227679252625,
0.6793976426124573,
0.6720801591873169,
-0.2273278385400772,
-0.1525275558233261,
0.48074716329574585,
0.546945333480835,
-0.04004650190472603,
0.862086832523346,
0.03775792196393013,
-0.68165123462677,
-0.49402397871017456,
-1.073082447052002,
-0.22076144814491272,
-0.006943365093320608,
-0.4754285514354706,
0.6115357875823975,
-0.8597519993782043,
0.13040757179260254,
-0.2229885458946228,
0.3403986394405365,
-0.5666243433952332,
0.24236580729484558,
0.35844436287879944,
1.3144359588623047,
-0.9112346172332764,
0.9570814371109009,
0.7774572968482971,
-0.059467580169439316,
-0.7682478427886963,
-0.20397736132144928,
-0.18659177422523499,
-0.7026968002319336,
0.701826810836792,
0.01796843484044075,
0.005785416346043348,
0.21045592427253723,
-0.259580135345459,
-0.7155502438545227,
1.118881106376648,
0.24141494929790497,
-0.8719651699066162,
0.08191583305597305,
0.08511640876531601,
0.5869689583778381,
-0.41819730401039124,
0.10151498764753342,
0.7829325795173645,
0.3649330735206604,
0.4311079978942871,
-1.21965754032135,
-0.10539629310369492,
-0.2732134461402893,
-0.02239198237657547,
0.5147426724433899,
-0.46347978711128235,
0.7915037870407104,
-0.1303689330816269,
-0.11164963245391846,
0.08944372087717056,
0.6477731466293335,
0.4455912709236145,
0.1412169337272644,
-0.050590191036462784,
0.2982341945171356,
0.8347740173339844,
-0.07918083667755127,
0.9853239059448242,
-0.9105076789855957,
0.14247463643550873,
0.9420964121818542,
-0.3685775697231293,
1.1547890901565552,
0.47852903604507446,
-0.3770359754562378,
0.16310785710811615,
0.5316352248191833,
0.12990860641002655,
0.23665443062782288,
0.20943889021873474,
-0.3059995174407959,
-0.2627801299095154,
-0.19377928972244263,
-0.26830869913101196,
0.07648319751024246,
0.6744276285171509,
-0.26161354780197144,
-0.04628594592213631,
0.1412641853094101,
-0.24088779091835022,
0.07221704721450806,
-0.9834350347518921,
0.4393371045589447,
0.13932745158672333,
-0.20587711036205292,
0.5095133185386658,
0.25900813937187195,
0.8924462795257568,
-0.1455519050359726,
0.1691649705171585,
-0.19806885719299316,
0.1937628835439682,
-0.35880911350250244,
-0.9461970925331116,
0.5727353096008301,
-0.056714724749326706,
-0.4835055470466614,
-0.4338456094264984,
0.6044831871986389,
-0.29815244674682617,
-0.8410577178001404,
0.1073850765824318,
0.16490446031093597,
0.218068927526474,
0.044704876840114594,
-0.5817358493804932,
0.6410459876060486,
-0.001369117177091539,
0.0037553005386143923,
-0.002437035320326686,
0.2421802431344986,
-0.03738546743988991,
0.7883205413818359,
0.35634246468544006,
0.4039454162120819,
-0.06349188834428787,
0.032290078699588776,
0.7399309873580933,
-0.6772775650024414,
-0.4359041750431061,
-0.7663195729255676,
0.47286421060562134,
0.17485110461711884,
-0.0663287490606308,
0.46733254194259644,
0.8079901337623596,
0.6885420680046082,
0.073573537170887,
0.609752357006073,
0.1991635411977768,
0.133566752076149,
-0.6231817603111267,
0.6205965280532837,
-0.5494043827056885,
0.596447765827179,
0.09011736512184143,
-0.7232731580734253,
-0.45081827044487,
0.4394303262233734,
-0.4611815810203552,
0.051201436668634415,
0.6256064176559448,
0.8007892370223999,
-0.3096889853477478,
0.16102753579616547,
0.2863807678222656,
0.5538833737373352,
0.24641667306423187,
0.5621806383132935,
0.47462743520736694,
-0.8190895318984985,
0.27993014454841614,
-0.06480413675308228,
-0.08869350701570511,
-0.10674526542425156,
-0.7303231954574585,
-0.5484214425086975,
-0.4553118050098419,
-0.534062922000885,
-0.12697462737560272,
0.11952447891235352,
1.0705095529556274,
0.6670936346054077,
-1.0175124406814575,
-0.5719196200370789,
-0.42541244626045227,
0.05839153379201889,
0.02191207744181156,
-0.16259288787841797,
0.01528126746416092,
-0.144648015499115,
-0.6360543966293335,
0.24500831961631775,
0.6506474614143372,
0.09576836973428726,
-0.5401427149772644,
-0.33075979351997375,
0.05034869164228439,
0.3339725434780121,
0.8289079666137695,
0.28094491362571716,
-0.6897424459457397,
-0.08760413527488708,
0.07996759563684464,
-0.07496124505996704,
0.2252771407365799,
0.6381319761276245,
-0.6925786137580872,
0.2686885893344879,
0.45051324367523193,
0.6289475560188293,
0.2844724953174591,
-0.15450064837932587,
0.7760719656944275,
-0.7182918190956116,
-0.043797075748443604,
-0.043791405856609344,
0.23697495460510254,
0.40913277864456177,
-0.33858969807624817,
0.11406777799129486,
0.10218218713998795,
-0.5416296124458313,
-1.007251501083374,
0.453665167093277,
-0.6597607731819153,
-0.33864477276802063,
1.1969218254089355,
0.28650861978530884,
-0.41176149249076843,
0.027165204286575317,
-0.1399167776107788,
0.10737943649291992,
-0.1737097054719925,
0.8936014175415039,
0.6108351349830627,
-0.056758251041173935,
-0.17355608940124512,
-0.7559005618095398,
0.2947878837585449,
0.1478646844625473,
-0.8473731875419617,
0.41085562109947205,
0.21275483071804047,
0.26451823115348816,
0.12790144979953766,
0.46983397006988525,
-0.07110477238893509,
0.4025607109069824,
-0.090556301176548,
0.3832431435585022,
-0.07351703196763992,
-0.6142293214797974,
-0.5337441563606262,
0.3123217225074768,
0.5379559397697449,
0.10215282440185547
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06537v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06537v1
|
On the Consideration of AI Openness: Can Good Intent Be Abused?
| 2024-03-11T09:24:06 | 2024-03-11T09:24:06 |
Yeeun Kim, Eunkyung Choi, Hyunjun Kim, Hongseok Oh, Hyunseo Shin, Wonseok Hwang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Openness is critical for the advancement of science. In particular, recent
rapid progress in AI has been made possible only by various open-source models,
datasets, and libraries. However, this openness also means that technologies
can be freely used for socially harmful purposes. Can open-source models or
datasets be used for malicious purposes? If so, how easy is it to adapt
technology for such goals? Here, we conduct a case study in the legal domain, a
realm where individual decisions can have profound social consequences. To this
end, we build EVE, a dataset consisting of 200 examples of questions and
corresponding answers about criminal activities based on 200 Korean precedents.
We found that a widely accepted open-source LLM, which initially refuses to
answer unethical questions, can be easily tuned with EVE to provide unethical
and informative answers about criminal activities. This implies that although
open-source technologies contribute to scientific progress, some care must be
taken to mitigate possible malicious use cases. Warning: This paper contains
contents that some may find unethical.
|
[
0.24052949249744415,
-0.9896969199180603,
0.9020155668258667,
-0.1884857714176178,
-0.17574003338813782,
-0.701106071472168,
-0.23369506001472473,
-0.6603952050209045,
-0.22912286221981049,
0.7663337588310242,
-0.055940527468919754,
-0.5286833047866821,
-0.4789626896381378,
-0.20099078118801117,
-0.31710678339004517,
1.0230838060379028,
0.07416936755180359,
0.2272731065750122,
-0.35498955845832825,
-0.485599547624588,
-0.3762338161468506,
-0.3587101697921753,
-0.6451094746589661,
0.1461450159549713,
0.4484770894050598,
0.39124807715415955,
0.9190833568572998,
0.7663723826408386,
0.7677710056304932,
0.3778340518474579,
0.31062233448028564,
-0.18576690554618835,
-0.728313684463501,
0.19966132938861847,
-0.5118396282196045,
-0.7491746544837952,
-0.4637395739555359,
0.288720041513443,
0.07472743839025497,
0.40678662061691284,
0.028827926144003868,
0.3840487003326416,
-0.17049916088581085,
0.663423478603363,
-0.6316413283348083,
-0.17834648489952087,
-0.7605237364768982,
-0.028981493785977364,
-0.30917438864707947,
-0.014415505342185497,
-0.33678290247917175,
-0.44419318437576294,
-0.08472006767988205,
-0.9318411946296692,
-0.09554031491279602,
-0.007016671821475029,
0.31888312101364136,
0.6878460645675659,
0.038688696920871735,
-0.5556509494781494,
-1.1131373643875122,
0.5797972083091736,
-0.45755550265312195,
0.04916219040751457,
0.4667208790779114,
0.45764756202697754,
-0.14195258915424347,
-0.8178662061691284,
-0.42293304204940796,
-0.36331242322921753,
0.05209274962544441,
0.14403976500034332,
-0.5463311672210693,
0.1698228120803833,
0.5140315294265747,
-0.10880649089813232,
-0.37835124135017395,
0.023415885865688324,
-0.8245367407798767,
-0.15700185298919678,
0.7950310707092285,
0.16306982934474945,
0.6555168032646179,
0.23856616020202637,
-0.1315518617630005,
0.013451151549816132,
-0.8619569540023804,
0.38108983635902405,
0.8101297616958618,
0.38510793447494507,
0.019541805610060692,
1.0453763008117676,
0.009703593328595161,
0.12398166954517365,
-0.2098572552204132,
0.4170503318309784,
0.11194510012865067,
-0.36284661293029785,
-0.401140034198761,
0.21250054240226746,
0.7130251526832581,
0.5844838619232178,
0.49123814702033997,
-0.10808310657739639,
0.0669233649969101,
0.017709219828248024,
0.716197669506073,
-0.47263023257255554,
0.08184453845024109,
0.7280310988426208,
-0.807303249835968,
-0.355819970369339,
0.44445765018463135,
-0.5039869546890259,
-0.5932154655456543,
-0.08842320740222931,
0.13486725091934204,
-0.22670218348503113,
-0.16853143274784088,
0.11323188990354538,
-0.07715961337089539,
0.10258210450410843,
0.516237199306488,
-0.07139360159635544,
0.03799924626946449,
0.8209921717643738,
0.6893956065177917,
0.2564615309238434,
-0.25411632657051086,
-0.5671564340591431,
0.11470703780651093,
-0.43136173486709595,
0.04988249018788338,
-0.46752288937568665,
-0.40145665407180786,
-0.11287686973810196,
0.08469721674919128,
0.35355550050735474,
-0.46338844299316406,
0.6869381666183472,
-0.6140131950378418,
0.03363151475787163,
-0.046855296939611435,
-0.12819765508174896,
-0.31321004033088684,
-0.012373176403343678,
-0.5970178246498108,
0.5371267795562744,
-0.16622190177440643,
-0.6883339881896973,
0.5064713954925537,
-1.1845574378967285,
-0.4591810405254364,
0.18636833131313324,
-0.0904339998960495,
-0.3134027421474457,
0.17140693962574005,
-0.0820927694439888,
0.27241235971450806,
0.2636880874633789,
0.4514966905117035,
-0.6097863912582397,
-0.31377387046813965,
0.3992040753364563,
-0.48654258251190186,
1.2905362844467163,
0.5616702437400818,
-0.35980719327926636,
0.27126699686050415,
-0.6342707276344299,
-0.21377243101596832,
0.15185292065143585,
-0.018718106672167778,
-0.9889792799949646,
0.1756991446018219,
-0.4973006844520569,
0.05528904125094414,
0.11420615017414093,
-0.8448115587234497,
-0.04802807420492172,
-0.30321940779685974,
0.14682316780090332,
1.1334021091461182,
-0.17254003882408142,
0.5344834923744202,
-0.5233784914016724,
0.3755531907081604,
-0.08784620463848114,
0.3966667652130127,
-0.030436113476753235,
-0.6797178387641907,
-0.34170815348625183,
0.05333550646901131,
-0.16506540775299072,
0.6887927651405334,
-0.4482092559337616,
0.03412618115544319,
0.0662032887339592,
-0.5004996061325073,
-1.0018857717514038,
-0.2933993935585022,
0.2622074782848358,
0.22072848677635193,
0.2520541846752167,
0.13601908087730408,
-0.32622408866882324,
-0.8262102007865906,
-0.6295720934867859,
-0.27644824981689453,
-0.03808194398880005,
0.9442004561424255,
0.5529277324676514,
0.18846911191940308,
0.6377655863761902,
-0.1633526235818863,
-0.19682033360004425,
0.30990225076675415,
-0.19432435929775238,
0.47684234380722046,
0.534255862236023,
0.43670499324798584,
-0.766707181930542,
-0.23378978669643402,
0.007341329008340836,
-1.263672113418579,
0.05294787883758545,
0.004497205838561058,
-0.29480093717575073,
-0.06225180998444557,
0.6973169445991516,
-0.6207327842712402,
0.7321470975875854,
-0.0665145069360733,
-0.7628454566001892,
0.311025470495224,
-0.2832227051258087,
0.36117491126060486,
-0.84370356798172,
0.3079616129398346,
-0.20003411173820496,
-0.16772685945034027,
-0.901222825050354,
0.5236139893531799,
-0.24242109060287476,
-0.12955544888973236,
-1.105788230895996,
0.33848607540130615,
0.23385637998580933,
0.048614583909511566,
-0.2662811875343323,
-0.07648440450429916,
-0.5464785695075989,
-0.2029668241739273,
-0.45273512601852417,
0.7637761831283569,
0.6635158061981201,
-0.782869279384613,
0.28129228949546814,
0.16935746371746063,
-0.31274107098579407,
0.5498089790344238,
-0.7152613401412964,
0.2880019545555115,
-0.4908665418624878,
-0.27821776270866394,
-0.18590261042118073,
-0.28923308849334717,
0.6609402894973755,
-0.6250010132789612,
-0.2921411395072937,
-0.1049477756023407,
-0.13486196100711823,
-0.015158732421696186,
-0.45809516310691833,
0.5720299482345581,
0.5012009143829346,
-0.3480701148509979,
0.5272672176361084,
0.2837764024734497,
-0.08522625267505646,
-0.8157173991203308,
-0.7597538232803345,
-0.12133479863405228,
-0.46346932649612427,
-0.9092851877212524,
0.017069967463612556,
-0.09745802730321884,
-1.0019053220748901,
0.46987056732177734,
0.2607939839363098,
0.22243499755859375,
0.3569200038909912,
0.5585660934448242,
0.1660136580467224,
-0.26521986722946167,
-0.12234301120042801,
-0.3130638599395752,
0.12451650202274323,
0.40046247839927673,
-0.17787450551986694,
0.26273271441459656,
0.03678439185023308,
-0.5152868628501892,
-0.3515271246433258,
0.4735107421875,
0.6428759694099426,
0.02775620110332966,
0.45384129881858826,
0.18942420184612274,
-0.4983312785625458,
-0.09493174403905869,
-0.023375462740659714,
-0.0054533048532903194,
-0.5350919961929321,
0.304720938205719,
-0.09572955220937729,
-1.042137861251831,
0.4603663980960846,
0.17091183364391327,
0.3718915581703186,
0.4630873203277588,
0.6184747219085693,
-0.252543568611145,
0.6690999865531921,
0.6506799459457397,
-0.10915300250053406,
0.2494361698627472,
0.10587374866008759,
0.25425639748573303,
-0.42177513241767883,
-0.23592573404312134,
-0.601374626159668,
-0.22830981016159058,
-0.9451854228973389,
-0.25208455324172974,
0.4228837788105011,
-0.22685794532299042,
-0.38032230734825134,
0.09146056324243546,
-0.4368857443332672,
0.7222301959991455,
0.8632715940475464,
0.39194047451019287,
0.32783570885658264,
-0.08160743862390518,
0.3659074604511261,
0.5127109885215759,
-0.29694193601608276,
-0.8368499279022217,
1.4836363792419434,
0.4988595247268677,
0.7832933068275452,
0.0964839905500412,
0.4602617621421814,
0.6376276016235352,
0.041346557438373566,
-0.46228042244911194,
0.5721267461776733,
-0.2482207715511322,
-0.8076753616333008,
-0.6548670530319214,
-0.13642676174640656,
-1.2157812118530273,
-0.15785090625286102,
0.20033667981624603,
-0.8705927133560181,
0.20976726710796356,
0.017374420538544655,
-0.43314477801322937,
0.5208885073661804,
-0.3805115818977356,
0.4488031566143036,
-0.32892951369285583,
-0.5510229468345642,
-0.4095657765865326,
-0.5979695320129395,
0.5324016213417053,
0.014797746203839779,
0.44025200605392456,
-0.26033803820610046,
0.1084095686674118,
0.7827339172363281,
-0.44777345657348633,
0.660712718963623,
-0.6288542151451111,
0.14569714665412903,
0.7716021537780762,
0.11264408379793167,
0.41363778710365295,
0.26537325978279114,
-0.1284332126379013,
0.2570424973964691,
-0.23438496887683868,
-0.16585156321525574,
-0.45470497012138367,
0.5281760096549988,
-0.9617686867713928,
-0.936311662197113,
-0.33908313512802124,
-0.6241094470024109,
0.23538082838058472,
0.35405996441841125,
0.20042133331298828,
-0.03025815263390541,
-0.3569338321685791,
0.21205444633960724,
0.5501731634140015,
-0.3252113461494446,
0.23786111176013947,
0.5544167160987854,
-0.17865103483200073,
-0.010966740548610687,
0.9082282781600952,
-0.22652271389961243,
0.1229400485754013,
-0.3404553532600403,
0.40656861662864685,
0.15961141884326935,
-0.767961859703064,
-0.3552035093307495,
0.009870233945548534,
-0.8500205278396606,
-0.11395314335823059,
-0.4131982922554016,
0.02035801112651825,
-0.48822346329689026,
-0.19528412818908691,
-0.13834787905216217,
-0.3112260401248932,
-0.3482155203819275,
0.0048323944211006165,
0.3320881426334381,
1.03597891330719,
-0.18588422238826752,
-0.17917652428150177,
-0.5143864154815674,
0.33086270093917847,
-0.013748178258538246,
0.3691174387931824,
-0.45068463683128357,
-0.2363131195306778,
0.08955865353345871,
0.3570704162120819,
-0.07278113067150116,
-0.47266942262649536,
-0.18473303318023682,
-0.16047127544879913,
0.60654217004776,
0.40942612290382385,
0.316835880279541,
0.1643998622894287,
-0.4367996156215668,
0.9639348983764648,
-0.19403918087482452,
-0.3838149309158325,
0.774802029132843,
-0.4300609230995178,
-0.12449879944324493,
0.6937946677207947,
0.752524733543396,
-0.16816064715385437,
-0.6627700924873352,
-0.6889925003051758,
-0.5951246619224548,
0.9195746183395386,
0.3712417483329773,
0.33929944038391113,
0.41141754388809204,
0.480907678604126,
0.39952731132507324,
0.13223589956760406,
-0.7967610359191895,
-0.23807524144649506,
-0.5317348837852478,
-0.008000032044947147,
0.2265314906835556,
0.2791551351547241,
-0.495039165019989,
-0.06897986680269241,
0.7337241172790527,
0.0411936454474926,
0.4440380930900574,
0.22492718696594238,
0.1042371541261673,
-0.3361390233039856,
0.3537762761116028,
0.405161052942276,
0.29742592573165894,
0.038041166961193085,
-0.055177152156829834,
-0.2662496566772461,
-0.5173468589782715,
0.15182876586914062,
-0.015465870499610901,
-0.7305615544319153,
-0.4896756410598755,
0.06586026400327682,
0.5127496123313904,
-0.727807879447937,
-0.7658922672271729,
0.6748889684677124,
-0.02251986786723137,
-0.28312253952026367,
-0.31250447034835815,
0.404619038105011,
-0.4594038724899292,
0.5353830456733704,
0.0905860885977745,
0.29039689898490906,
0.32212790846824646,
-1.0030055046081543,
0.17161275446414948,
0.5999974608421326,
-0.47210755944252014,
-0.2435729056596756,
0.788581371307373,
-0.03420408442616463,
-0.45109957456588745,
0.8785156011581421,
-0.20027057826519012,
-0.16637203097343445,
0.6655929088592529,
0.34333106875419617,
0.9022800326347351,
-0.23065637052059174,
0.1495123654603958,
0.1224883571267128,
0.6710366606712341,
0.23286426067352295,
0.6858242750167847,
0.13327310979366302,
-0.8537613153457642,
-0.15859375894069672,
-0.2181083709001541,
-0.3467257618904114,
0.3535792827606201,
-0.2954910397529602,
0.28680357336997986,
-0.48472851514816284,
0.027136096730828285,
-0.06282934546470642,
-0.7651494741439819,
-0.5847477912902832,
0.039308324456214905,
-0.14817291498184204,
0.8128288388252258,
-0.6351131200790405,
0.47832420468330383,
0.680132269859314,
-0.36217111349105835,
-0.37126174569129944,
-0.009197425097227097,
0.1867491900920868,
-0.8841762542724609,
0.33346953988075256,
0.05449008196592331,
0.06932475417852402,
-0.37304115295410156,
-1.1534368991851807,
-0.7773323059082031,
0.9808304905891418,
0.26125213503837585,
-0.19634075462818146,
-0.07005589455366135,
0.53829026222229,
0.3991814851760864,
-0.14037001132965088,
0.06945977360010147,
0.41912901401519775,
0.6735759377479553,
-0.2179209440946579,
-0.6149467825889587,
0.21632015705108643,
-0.4192585051059723,
-0.6470975279808044,
0.12700729072093964,
-0.513176441192627,
0.8330936431884766,
-0.5068932175636292,
-0.4198039472103119,
0.06332655996084213,
0.42119649052619934,
-0.014342724345624447,
0.9364539980888367,
0.3538009226322174,
0.4023081362247467,
0.743514358997345,
-0.022295786067843437,
1.0089236497879028,
-0.1382363885641098,
-0.25104689598083496,
0.8938297629356384,
-0.40188732743263245,
0.4075849950313568,
0.26738810539245605,
-0.15135569870471954,
0.11654534935951233,
0.24777300655841827,
-0.2920028567314148,
0.6463849544525146,
0.11445668339729309,
-0.039048824459314346,
0.17605933547019958,
-0.3536249101161957,
-0.07173135131597519,
0.5998439192771912,
0.5199308395385742,
-0.42946624755859375,
-0.16446316242218018,
0.22526465356349945,
-0.04711653292179108,
0.07364026457071304,
-0.6200657486915588,
0.882043182849884,
-0.04809977486729622,
-0.6305997967720032,
-0.34955692291259766,
0.1265544295310974,
0.4250442683696747,
-0.39853137731552124,
-0.13791318237781525,
0.36006006598472595,
0.014457248151302338,
-0.45409730076789856,
-1.0643235445022583,
0.5353938937187195,
0.2614802420139313,
0.15536420047283173,
0.03330465406179428,
1.09013032913208,
0.1828521192073822,
-0.14304113388061523,
0.09575343132019043,
0.5747407674789429,
0.43028584122657776,
-0.029653184115886688,
-0.5197089910507202,
-0.1619485765695572,
-0.061858367174863815,
-0.16328753530979156,
0.05763816088438034,
0.2435767501592636,
-0.24729612469673157,
0.5494086146354675,
0.9164959788322449,
0.23822851479053497,
0.1319485306739807,
-0.21733057498931885,
0.8973633050918579,
-0.4613192677497864,
-0.4875512421131134,
-0.977435827255249,
0.5375597476959229,
-0.08090272545814514,
-0.33431476354599,
0.6357070207595825,
0.46700167655944824,
1.1569457054138184,
0.3905172348022461,
1.165570616722107,
-0.2611512243747711,
0.31316524744033813,
-0.7862136960029602,
0.7454108595848083,
-0.3924376368522644,
0.25057631731033325,
-0.21673698723316193,
-0.7925375699996948,
-0.08593694865703583,
0.31988856196403503,
-0.18686488270759583,
0.14027076959609985,
0.4072996973991394,
0.5962181091308594,
-0.05961868166923523,
0.4552769660949707,
0.4001200795173645,
0.27902477979660034,
0.45058971643447876,
0.1661468893289566,
0.8997336626052856,
-0.005604863632470369,
0.3834001123905182,
-0.3589670956134796,
-0.33803197741508484,
-0.11320251226425171,
-0.7317280173301697,
-0.7983714938163757,
-0.3059220314025879,
-0.0008123808656819165,
-0.43245238065719604,
0.35796689987182617,
0.9231607913970947,
0.2545112669467926,
-0.6946347951889038,
-0.057608284056186676,
-0.18716399371623993,
-0.03555373474955559,
-0.031027711927890778,
-0.24892280995845795,
0.27560052275657654,
-0.1144653856754303,
-0.5262115001678467,
0.6500433087348938,
0.09554567188024521,
0.12400726974010468,
-0.2733074426651001,
-0.03622389957308769,
0.05436703935265541,
0.23136219382286072,
0.44202327728271484,
0.3241505026817322,
-0.5995835065841675,
-0.4971870481967926,
0.23284517228603363,
0.02462163195014,
0.0870770588517189,
1.077580213546753,
-0.44352591037750244,
0.5245229601860046,
0.28395217657089233,
0.658488392829895,
-0.07230834662914276,
0.0954534262418747,
0.536736249923706,
-0.3181149363517761,
0.007202281150966883,
0.6277537941932678,
0.4129372537136078,
-0.16451486945152283,
-0.853992223739624,
0.631358802318573,
-0.045952361077070236,
-0.8605841994285583,
-0.6245795488357544,
0.16201692819595337,
-0.4997137784957886,
-0.5513870716094971,
0.9946835041046143,
-0.20156897604465485,
-0.3922516107559204,
-0.4244365096092224,
-0.12443364411592484,
0.23038332164287567,
-0.6567812561988831,
0.7583190202713013,
0.48314130306243896,
-0.4062349796295166,
0.4239681363105774,
-0.8949554562568665,
0.37372711300849915,
-0.027952004224061966,
-0.8217161297798157,
0.2143108993768692,
0.4399050772190094,
0.10744481533765793,
0.24940162897109985,
0.7612791061401367,
-0.3497362434864044,
0.5900551676750183,
-0.09256265312433243,
-0.33630701899528503,
-0.4532369077205658,
-0.538698136806488,
-0.40759968757629395,
0.2682502269744873,
0.10312772542238235,
-0.19097493588924408
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06520v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06520v1
|
How to Understand Named Entities: Using Common Sense for News Captioning
| 2024-03-11T08:52:52 | 2024-03-11T08:52:52 |
Ning Xu, Yanhui Wang, Tingting Zhang, Hongshuo Tian, Mohan Kankanhalli, An-An Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
News captioning aims to describe an image with its news article body as
input. It greatly relies on a set of detected named entities, including
real-world people, organizations, and places. This paper exploits commonsense
knowledge to understand named entities for news captioning. By ``understand'',
we mean correlating the news content with common sense in the wild, which helps
an agent to 1) distinguish semantically similar named entities and 2) describe
named entities using words outside of training corpora. Our approach consists
of three modules: (a) Filter Module aims to clarify the common sense concerning
a named entity from two aspects: what does it mean? and what is it related to?,
which divide the common sense into explanatory knowledge and relevant
knowledge, respectively. (b) Distinguish Module aggregates explanatory
knowledge from node-degree, dependency, and distinguish three aspects to
distinguish semantically similar named entities. (c) Enrich Module attaches
relevant knowledge to named entities to enrich the entity description by
commonsense information (e.g., identity and social position). Finally, the
probability distributions from both modules are integrated to generate the news
captions. Extensive experiments on two challenging datasets (i.e., GoodNews and
NYTimes) demonstrate the superiority of our method. Ablation studies and
visualization further validate its effectiveness in understanding named
entities.
|
[
-0.6296387910842896,
-0.6439319849014282,
0.6052253246307373,
0.04368111118674278,
-0.8758838176727295,
0.08705996721982956,
-0.14812038838863373,
-0.7547626495361328,
0.31215378642082214,
0.4918581545352936,
-0.4087328612804413,
-0.5335779190063477,
-0.505786657333374,
0.209348663687706,
-0.4193350076675415,
1.113523244857788,
0.03887272998690605,
0.13296478986740112,
-0.38574090600013733,
-0.4933648705482483,
-0.3904068171977997,
-0.016564222052693367,
-0.7039042115211487,
0.02230876311659813,
0.8053354024887085,
0.3594021797180176,
0.6697902679443359,
0.523760199546814,
0.3787546157836914,
0.2909666895866394,
-0.24320188164710999,
0.33461877703666687,
-0.3776296079158783,
-0.35437291860580444,
-0.41600552201271057,
-0.29713010787963867,
-0.05321589484810829,
0.027460504323244095,
0.38785529136657715,
0.8146055340766907,
0.06605151295661926,
-0.06064172834157944,
-0.1693676859140396,
0.5502163171768188,
-0.41142478585243225,
0.3623790740966797,
-0.8635619878768921,
0.050444599241018295,
-0.00787658803164959,
-0.26167094707489014,
-0.21782179176807404,
-0.13334698975086212,
0.14754420518875122,
-1.1695280075073242,
0.3111061751842499,
0.43783149123191833,
1.3139595985412598,
0.34133633971214294,
-0.5998485088348389,
-0.2017972320318222,
-0.3057245910167694,
0.8569620847702026,
-0.3777647018432617,
0.4947262704372406,
-0.042332008481025696,
0.4894901514053345,
-0.05581829324364662,
-0.6063494086265564,
-0.9967420101165771,
-0.012685609981417656,
-0.29741787910461426,
0.19484645128250122,
-0.3678111732006073,
-0.08764911442995071,
0.027396736666560173,
0.25720179080963135,
-0.35328617691993713,
0.006312886252999306,
-0.7394909858703613,
-0.175753653049469,
0.4388662278652191,
-0.4663412570953369,
0.44325685501098633,
-0.4423782527446747,
-0.8100170493125916,
0.31616196036338806,
-0.609814465045929,
-0.22218072414398193,
0.17382200062274933,
0.2596626579761505,
-0.12393717467784882,
0.4466271996498108,
-0.5021195411682129,
0.7967790961265564,
-0.17602956295013428,
-0.09965763241052628,
0.16331888735294342,
0.2002992480993271,
-0.4905414581298828,
0.0931607335805893,
0.2026410698890686,
0.8798369765281677,
0.7215845584869385,
-0.5297134518623352,
-0.02155209891498089,
-0.11034101992845535,
0.17332178354263306,
-0.43711066246032715,
-0.1011548638343811,
-0.03249640762805939,
-0.35926562547683716,
-0.47824186086654663,
0.21648675203323364,
-0.7152631282806396,
-0.5416201949119568,
-0.8013133406639099,
0.3880419135093689,
-0.1744270920753479,
-0.3946242034435272,
-0.04407453536987305,
-0.47272539138793945,
0.4207717776298523,
0.6668877005577087,
-0.5451416969299316,
0.4442361891269684,
0.7615278363227844,
0.750542402267456,
-0.4176346957683563,
-0.29730767011642456,
-0.7355831265449524,
0.309344083070755,
0.08547205477952957,
1.2987089157104492,
-0.2399888038635254,
0.33193615078926086,
-0.24146701395511627,
0.1496717929840088,
-0.0015281341038644314,
-0.4946405589580536,
0.20595484972000122,
-0.950385332107544,
-0.12600752711296082,
0.07214629650115967,
-0.6751524209976196,
-0.6622775197029114,
0.3324712812900543,
-1.0808305740356445,
0.17206546664237976,
0.008129234425723553,
-0.7601575255393982,
0.660641074180603,
-0.7430274486541748,
-0.5196962356567383,
0.17892864346504211,
-0.06702541559934616,
-0.10378164052963257,
0.35513290762901306,
0.52565598487854,
0.6669764518737793,
0.23187831044197083,
0.4077951908111572,
-0.1534956693649292,
-0.0026651101652532816,
0.3936736285686493,
-0.2658153176307678,
0.5648868680000305,
0.5375992655754089,
0.22896558046340942,
-0.23795244097709656,
-0.8799846768379211,
-0.3236374258995056,
0.029226722195744514,
-0.022037656977772713,
-0.6651352643966675,
-0.0717998668551445,
0.05143546313047409,
-0.39767491817474365,
-0.07278477400541306,
-0.4334011375904083,
-0.195956289768219,
-0.07200799882411957,
0.5431347489356995,
0.16474296152591705,
0.6245763301849365,
0.7510939240455627,
-0.1121344044804573,
0.08747444301843643,
0.49288210272789,
0.03573693335056305,
-0.12009512633085251,
-0.3630591034889221,
-0.4176845848560333,
-0.2116289734840393,
0.33453065156936646,
0.2703886032104492,
-0.8956051468849182,
0.028978528454899788,
-0.29873916506767273,
-0.34635743498802185,
-0.15445250272750854,
0.05472033843398094,
-0.016238240525126457,
0.6425238847732544,
0.5861350893974304,
-0.27353331446647644,
-0.4388777017593384,
-1.0307738780975342,
-0.7418241500854492,
0.09051495045423508,
0.08629275113344193,
0.24207177758216858,
0.43074896931648254,
0.05724538490176201,
1.1096032857894897,
-0.6030572652816772,
-0.1744462251663208,
-0.3124302625656128,
0.2619631588459015,
0.1452479064464569,
0.25898003578186035,
0.36116117238998413,
-1.3957549333572388,
-0.019074784591794014,
-0.06309401988983154,
-0.40947479009628296,
0.030278293415904045,
-0.5034278631210327,
-0.07697353512048721,
0.15158461034297943,
0.468311607837677,
-0.8756210803985596,
0.3988938629627228,
0.2172006517648697,
-0.15182678401470184,
0.4346112906932831,
0.14961810410022736,
0.10692423582077026,
-0.938515305519104,
-0.12907928228378296,
0.19275861978530884,
-0.42935484647750854,
-0.45189133286476135,
0.2461535781621933,
-0.07147540152072906,
-0.1919354349374771,
-0.7710646390914917,
0.7700119018554688,
-0.7991208434104919,
-0.4117630124092102,
-0.09117560088634491,
0.6502112150192261,
0.2548940181732178,
0.4171764850616455,
0.5384912490844727,
0.37412288784980774,
0.5944722890853882,
-0.8291712999343872,
0.6203299760818481,
-0.04688010364770889,
-0.4978676736354828,
0.9037330746650696,
-0.4336549937725067,
-0.21308179199695587,
-0.42155390977859497,
0.09615806490182877,
-0.7117567658424377,
-0.47802433371543884,
0.332828164100647,
-0.6339578628540039,
0.07229441404342651,
-0.4132004678249359,
-0.5784819722175598,
-0.091342031955719,
0.3559532165527344,
0.0454656258225441,
-0.046853989362716675,
-0.6500726938247681,
0.510215699672699,
0.43060263991355896,
0.011494198814034462,
-0.564562976360321,
-0.9318481683731079,
0.15239903330802917,
-0.35246166586875916,
-0.4225347340106964,
0.2091846615076065,
0.08826348930597305,
-0.46417802572250366,
0.38653692603111267,
-0.3002048134803772,
-0.6022234559059143,
0.42087623476982117,
0.15654712915420532,
0.08549376577138901,
-0.16492199897766113,
0.5317221283912659,
0.29053956270217896,
-0.18274961411952972,
0.004730916582047939,
0.019953567534685135,
0.09876096248626709,
-0.0640828087925911,
-0.1851288378238678,
-0.2550494968891144,
0.3838387727737427,
0.5785425305366516,
-0.46782082319259644,
0.7376049757003784,
0.5090060234069824,
-0.547153115272522,
-0.2817629277706146,
-0.3063827157020569,
-0.2300119549036026,
-0.3543303608894348,
0.41943609714508057,
-0.15306419134140015,
-0.6059483289718628,
0.5996100902557373,
-0.24468894302845,
-0.05900311842560768,
0.3956605792045593,
-0.026417188346385956,
-0.09931455552577972,
0.4375656843185425,
0.3237171471118927,
-0.08575192093849182,
0.1847860962152481,
-0.11404848098754883,
0.32232001423835754,
-0.47684386372566223,
-0.15102368593215942,
-0.14857813715934753,
-0.4004754424095154,
-0.36409616470336914,
-0.37212085723876953,
-0.14019642770290375,
0.23149743676185608,
0.049135275185108185,
0.44003620743751526,
-0.5752488970756531,
1.0089410543441772,
0.4026655852794647,
0.05584060773253441,
0.7641488909721375,
0.2603769600391388,
0.2590152621269226,
0.15748856961727142,
-0.25981271266937256,
-0.6039374470710754,
0.5261248350143433,
0.44343897700309753,
0.8185996413230896,
0.06340057402849197,
0.8198167085647583,
0.28354501724243164,
0.44265612959861755,
-0.9895622134208679,
0.5472384691238403,
-0.004027692601084709,
-0.6587144136428833,
-0.17273467779159546,
-0.34070885181427,
-0.9014996886253357,
0.17187222838401794,
-0.1982886791229248,
-0.5831119418144226,
0.14466264843940735,
-0.09224240481853485,
-0.5068119764328003,
0.32087722420692444,
-0.7879505753517151,
0.7681045532226562,
-0.08043195307254791,
0.15013855695724487,
-0.38153818249702454,
-0.5644529461860657,
0.40664395689964294,
0.24315109848976135,
0.43514248728752136,
-0.1410188227891922,
-0.2660299837589264,
0.6539086103439331,
0.14832715690135956,
0.8292108178138733,
-0.256707102060318,
0.18512943387031555,
0.3859408497810364,
-0.278887003660202,
0.19478105008602142,
0.5190939903259277,
0.24692723155021667,
0.1968919187784195,
-0.08758702874183655,
-0.3588310182094574,
-0.7209702134132385,
0.7933560013771057,
-0.6864659786224365,
-0.3450063169002533,
-0.33633551001548767,
-0.5418014526367188,
0.13291218876838684,
0.3525589406490326,
0.2104126662015915,
0.5584686994552612,
-0.21371814608573914,
0.14722439646720886,
0.6476277112960815,
-0.04091893136501312,
0.3150002956390381,
0.8229069709777832,
-0.037432268261909485,
-0.500257670879364,
0.8425101637840271,
0.17651651799678802,
-0.14271515607833862,
0.6477096676826477,
-0.2253720462322235,
-0.24539174139499664,
-0.5833759307861328,
-0.6024733185768127,
0.21681851148605347,
-0.7208490371704102,
-0.5118350982666016,
-0.5663405060768127,
-0.14734190702438354,
-0.20852461457252502,
-0.199861541390419,
-0.06232400983572006,
-0.43891772627830505,
-0.5432028770446777,
-0.21210332214832306,
0.5987285375595093,
0.636538565158844,
0.09359335899353027,
0.26200225949287415,
-0.9286113977432251,
0.7270320057868958,
0.546742856502533,
0.4724508821964264,
-0.02420191839337349,
-0.11149918287992477,
-0.2101450115442276,
-0.0535716712474823,
-0.15547074377536774,
-1.3202528953552246,
0.35539013147354126,
0.1343241184949875,
0.8290319442749023,
0.6298431158065796,
0.4000442624092102,
0.6463338136672974,
-0.3329831659793854,
0.6315429210662842,
0.00824431236833334,
-0.8482135534286499,
0.5232393145561218,
-0.15124131739139557,
-0.05628116801381111,
0.5940663814544678,
0.29456162452697754,
-0.6772223711013794,
-0.5781587958335876,
-0.7552878260612488,
-0.6845401525497437,
0.3246046304702759,
0.2422848492860794,
0.23061440885066986,
-0.300650954246521,
0.38514870405197144,
0.07146874815225601,
0.34007489681243896,
-1.0497304201126099,
-0.14919860661029816,
-0.19294749200344086,
-0.1565096527338028,
0.23077617585659027,
0.07658324390649796,
-0.26265352964401245,
-0.003429956967011094,
0.47568783164024353,
-0.12241494655609131,
0.15092752873897552,
0.4286056160926819,
-0.7287686467170715,
-0.044031329452991486,
0.42705437541007996,
0.7049407362937927,
0.5452823042869568,
0.007867325097322464,
0.4233456552028656,
0.08480992913246155,
-0.2087469846010208,
-0.43001502752304077,
0.39782819151878357,
0.03786100074648857,
0.3007640540599823,
0.3609127998352051,
0.6911779642105103,
0.5800195336341858,
-0.40960410237312317,
0.494686096906662,
-0.004260515794157982,
0.01228007860481739,
-0.3952333927154541,
0.1238764151930809,
0.26658040285110474,
0.3606529235839844,
0.6759405136108398,
0.40388697385787964,
0.2995784282684326,
-0.5758421421051025,
0.33574989438056946,
0.22866718471050262,
-0.16262033581733704,
-0.11581837385892868,
0.3575097918510437,
0.6260731816291809,
-0.050854843109846115,
0.289743036031723,
-0.5421301126480103,
-0.4838995635509491,
0.9382564425468445,
0.43194520473480225,
0.47883209586143494,
0.45081546902656555,
0.3503568470478058,
0.3615846633911133,
0.15506717562675476,
0.02405928261578083,
-0.061870213598012924,
-0.30894550681114197,
-0.9717060923576355,
-0.42398330569267273,
-0.42952051758766174,
-0.4336024522781372,
0.16840319335460663,
-0.7822531461715698,
0.30243322253227234,
-0.2838580906391144,
0.2686830759048462,
0.3385373651981354,
0.2808035910129547,
-0.8371434211730957,
0.35878485441207886,
0.3719542324542999,
1.3460428714752197,
-1.10044527053833,
0.38012149930000305,
1.2412768602371216,
-0.535778820514679,
-0.93766850233078,
0.06868442893028259,
-0.10100642591714859,
-0.835472047328949,
0.5523966550827026,
0.48513874411582947,
0.40494170784950256,
0.34177711606025696,
-0.9137350916862488,
-0.7987252473831177,
1.291850209236145,
0.056924913078546524,
-0.7332045435905457,
0.21698248386383057,
-0.19415777921676636,
0.30207693576812744,
-0.5668550133705139,
0.05952609330415726,
0.34211063385009766,
0.8619153499603271,
0.1848386973142624,
-0.5681721568107605,
0.02609233930706978,
0.0074136462062597275,
-0.3435923755168915,
0.08504732698202133,
-0.5822232365608215,
0.3589014410972595,
-0.5381921529769897,
-0.57411789894104,
0.030425913631916046,
1.0755598545074463,
0.3409641981124878,
1.158316969871521,
0.7578794956207275,
0.7392585873603821,
0.9089865684509277,
0.05001102015376091,
0.7458339929580688,
-0.09585759788751602,
0.4304836094379425,
1.1520850658416748,
0.07249438017606735,
0.6473186612129211,
0.6703271269798279,
0.10552038252353668,
0.6035363078117371,
0.5782471299171448,
-0.36380860209465027,
0.5978519916534424,
0.25618892908096313,
-0.2741675078868866,
-0.14397257566452026,
-0.1950383335351944,
0.009020214900374413,
0.38961276412010193,
0.14193150401115417,
-0.43132492899894714,
-0.6279133558273315,
0.19022716581821442,
0.07970260828733444,
0.2647819519042969,
-0.6170397996902466,
0.9175267219543457,
0.3222270905971527,
-0.7028599381446838,
-0.05317043885588646,
-0.24475359916687012,
0.30806222558021545,
-0.057531073689460754,
-0.0673595741391182,
-0.209170401096344,
-0.25488337874412537,
-0.3058975338935852,
-1.2068982124328613,
0.4462531805038452,
0.11414588242769241,
-0.299587219953537,
0.13555002212524414,
0.9059020280838013,
-0.5897648930549622,
-0.24037107825279236,
0.008589117787778378,
0.5687652230262756,
0.5500879883766174,
-0.4506891071796417,
-0.44006213545799255,
-0.2731102406978607,
-0.12758846580982208,
-0.17066223919391632,
-0.10425233840942383,
0.8569443821907043,
-0.07594427466392517,
0.5010479092597961,
0.4386512041091919,
0.22795164585113525,
-0.27603381872177124,
0.38074854016304016,
0.800416111946106,
-0.6614566445350647,
-0.5490338802337646,
-0.47775763273239136,
0.4917070269584656,
-0.4783148169517517,
-0.23169074952602386,
0.2811889052391052,
0.5206748843193054,
0.6812902092933655,
-0.30641359090805054,
0.45695215463638306,
-0.013410954736173153,
0.47949978709220886,
-0.4914029538631439,
0.9999951124191284,
-0.5886629819869995,
0.11141916364431381,
0.07432026416063309,
-1.0318069458007812,
-0.6162092089653015,
0.3785346448421478,
-0.3116898238658905,
-0.34867173433303833,
0.5299022197723389,
0.6044751405715942,
-0.23850508034229279,
-0.07047810405492783,
0.3283248841762543,
0.12006238102912903,
-0.07527261227369308,
0.23491156101226807,
0.8501861095428467,
-0.14128635823726654,
0.7085269689559937,
-0.1748005598783493,
0.08727142959833145,
-0.055328093469142914,
-1.1086246967315674,
-0.7754127383232117,
-0.3908766806125641,
-0.5526978373527527,
0.38372716307640076,
0.11938191205263138,
0.5060359835624695,
0.8122861981391907,
-0.7103337645530701,
0.564762532711029,
-0.3231028914451599,
0.6911290884017944,
-0.19711627066135406,
-0.3544914722442627,
0.2512178122997284,
-0.37832170724868774,
-0.8167545199394226,
-0.0007461911300197244,
0.016355302184820175,
0.04523443803191185,
0.008459925651550293,
-0.11085342615842819,
0.14718523621559143,
0.05539795383810997,
0.33950626850128174,
0.2733130156993866,
-0.9504808783531189,
-0.5210266709327698,
-0.23007109761238098,
0.03131912276148796,
-0.1458514928817749,
0.5277930498123169,
-1.0440278053283691,
0.13588139414787292,
0.46795395016670227,
0.2888964116573334,
0.05534318462014198,
0.2757236659526825,
0.15520869195461273,
-0.9016637802124023,
0.03865418955683708,
0.08950675278902054,
0.4203742444515228,
0.5658738613128662,
-0.5196964740753174,
0.38559046387672424,
0.4623385965824127,
-0.4262629747390747,
-0.569995641708374,
0.33275333046913147,
-1.4950414896011353,
-0.335288941860199,
1.054734468460083,
-0.09136909991502762,
-0.42004168033599854,
-0.19765138626098633,
-0.15826085209846497,
0.5452671647071838,
-0.709568202495575,
0.6104730367660522,
0.46326974034309387,
0.2309296876192093,
-0.7308884263038635,
-0.5733840465545654,
0.29906368255615234,
-0.12961937487125397,
-0.8023892045021057,
-0.09304480999708176,
0.4389229118824005,
0.5355499982833862,
0.3232160806655884,
0.14516054093837738,
0.041841521859169006,
0.38532406091690063,
-0.25986698269844055,
-0.014443579129874706,
-0.3095482587814331,
-0.31565696001052856,
-0.06696486473083496,
-0.04130195826292038,
-0.30511200428009033,
-0.4868241250514984
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06503v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06503v1
|
Automatic Generation of Python Programs Using Context-Free Grammars
| 2024-03-11T08:25:52 | 2024-03-11T08:25:52 |
Kamel Yamani, Marwa Naïr, Riyadh Baghdadi
|
cs.PL
|
cs.PL, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
In recent years, data has emerged as the new gold, serving as a powerful tool
for creating intelligent systems. However, procuring high-quality data remains
challenging, especially for code. To address this, we developed TinyPy
Generator, a tool that generates random Python programs using a context-free
grammar. The generated programs are guaranteed to be correct by construction.
Our system uses custom production rules (in the Backus-Naur Form (BNF) format)
to recursively generate code. This allows us to generate code with different
levels of complexity, ranging from code containing only assignments to more
complex code containing conditionals and loops. Our proposed tool enables
effortless large-scale Python code generation, beneficial for a wide range of
applications. TinyPy Generator is particularly useful in the field of machine
learning, where it can generate substantial amounts of Python code for training
Python language models. Additionally, researchers who are studying programming
languages can utilize this tool to create datasets for their experiments, which
can help validate the robustness of code interpreters or compilers. Unlike
existing research, we have open-sourced our implementation. This allows
customization according to user needs and extends potential usage to other
languages.
|
[
-0.12250268459320068,
-0.6254737377166748,
0.2915284335613251,
0.3952571451663971,
0.02939002774655819,
-0.42519938945770264,
-0.516045093536377,
-0.068614162504673,
0.21473202109336853,
0.29907742142677307,
-0.47265881299972534,
-0.2429860681295395,
-0.17356732487678528,
0.4362942576408386,
-0.3781771957874298,
1.1384979486465454,
0.3488798141479492,
-0.40685588121414185,
-0.31456077098846436,
-0.031399406492710114,
-0.4674094319343567,
-0.22291815280914307,
-0.4123649299144745,
-0.257372111082077,
0.2782626152038574,
0.7030991315841675,
0.670415997505188,
0.8831472992897034,
0.16792936623096466,
0.351583331823349,
0.33330026268959045,
-0.0030400368850678205,
-0.29058942198753357,
0.22999203205108643,
-0.2322075515985489,
-0.17951907217502594,
-0.31611132621765137,
-0.14278103411197662,
0.6233408451080322,
0.6104764938354492,
-0.06964826583862305,
0.5587658882141113,
-0.06631536036729813,
0.35212242603302,
-0.5592758059501648,
0.24975083768367767,
-0.708484411239624,
-0.0258440300822258,
-0.05750003084540367,
-0.29598501324653625,
-0.3208816647529602,
-0.5247367024421692,
-0.29823675751686096,
-0.5191429257392883,
0.3907829225063324,
-0.13396470248699188,
0.6766662001609802,
0.4044339656829834,
-0.2827761173248291,
-0.5130600929260254,
-0.20746716856956482,
0.7406197786331177,
-0.6336802244186401,
-0.055259887129068375,
0.05057511478662491,
0.2109624743461609,
-0.5188088417053223,
-0.9799295663833618,
-0.5352652072906494,
-0.11954312771558762,
-0.2825824022293091,
-0.28905564546585083,
-0.2819066643714905,
-0.06556398421525955,
0.4418758749961853,
0.5265181064605713,
-0.7546568512916565,
-0.3043444752693176,
-0.2670125365257263,
-0.14575767517089844,
0.6800775527954102,
0.289831280708313,
0.24023938179016113,
-0.5185317397117615,
0.4157264530658722,
0.09716473519802094,
-0.7503489255905151,
-0.050178900361061096,
0.37253111600875854,
0.4148973524570465,
-0.019307374954223633,
0.8756221532821655,
-0.5644164681434631,
0.7169150710105896,
-0.049309756606817245,
0.08748875558376312,
0.21631182730197906,
-0.39765143394470215,
-0.4710795283317566,
0.010224404744803905,
0.8992812037467957,
0.3367382287979126,
0.3776276111602783,
-0.10144414007663727,
-0.34582656621932983,
0.11227180808782578,
0.04383004456758499,
-1.0437180995941162,
-0.5749541521072388,
0.4530828297138214,
-0.4222222566604614,
-0.7271769046783447,
-0.14528177678585052,
-0.45031872391700745,
-0.12355300784111023,
-0.06751928478479385,
0.16282016038894653,
-0.5022233724594116,
-0.15097495913505554,
-0.2507997751235962,
-0.35275840759277344,
-0.18177296221256256,
-0.13899008929729462,
-0.9297618865966797,
-0.170695498585701,
0.5956014394760132,
0.6576951146125793,
0.23844832181930542,
-0.4127746522426605,
-1.0307340621948242,
0.1169455274939537,
-0.48725607991218567,
0.44307178258895874,
-0.33311253786087036,
-0.11804094165563583,
-0.06701682507991791,
-0.09723987430334091,
0.04501314088702202,
-0.49584320187568665,
-0.012051423080265522,
-0.04861066862940788,
0.08977250009775162,
0.2576858401298523,
-0.3237895369529724,
0.2197350710630417,
-0.0252703744918108,
-0.35405656695365906,
0.8815940022468567,
0.4876345098018646,
-0.7005228400230408,
0.4693269729614258,
-0.4452063739299774,
-0.5939872860908508,
0.36965346336364746,
-0.44178906083106995,
-0.4117538630962372,
0.2909460961818695,
-0.04275636002421379,
0.4122943878173828,
0.21039311587810516,
0.37786611914634705,
-0.2688223719596863,
-0.2742314338684082,
0.4042741656303406,
-0.04590238258242607,
0.8789815306663513,
0.4922649562358856,
-0.3340819776058197,
0.29657259583473206,
-0.9664881825447083,
0.6190032958984375,
0.09304094314575195,
-0.6953904628753662,
-0.23133540153503418,
-0.026622718200087547,
0.15331870317459106,
0.2610682249069214,
0.16284938156604767,
-0.4515187442302704,
0.49392232298851013,
-0.575879693031311,
0.7814629673957825,
0.5302442908287048,
0.09227974712848663,
0.6008226871490479,
-0.21060287952423096,
0.2835252285003662,
-0.3599304258823395,
-0.21998736262321472,
-0.40178725123405457,
-0.5486571192741394,
-0.7582286596298218,
-0.27935102581977844,
0.2766147553920746,
0.36303675174713135,
-0.6381317377090454,
0.6814197301864624,
-0.14923933148384094,
-0.17109109461307526,
-0.2420881986618042,
0.36189329624176025,
0.26050034165382385,
0.20442131161689758,
0.013768418692052364,
0.05570143833756447,
-1.0542235374450684,
-0.6099327206611633,
0.0228707417845726,
-0.020776689052581787,
-0.2599741816520691,
0.32888874411582947,
0.5900996327400208,
-0.5854613184928894,
1.1623866558074951,
-0.43700987100601196,
-0.033968549221754074,
-0.6134675741195679,
0.12348155677318573,
0.3026001751422882,
0.847070574760437,
0.6253443956375122,
-0.3738546073436737,
-0.15640531480312347,
-0.08599253743886948,
-0.48251643776893616,
-0.4667510688304901,
-0.20136544108390808,
-0.22600334882736206,
0.5574706196784973,
0.2270243912935257,
-0.695334792137146,
0.14341150224208832,
0.6333374977111816,
-0.4500310719013214,
0.4801158905029297,
-0.23923133313655853,
-0.37209028005599976,
-1.0049793720245361,
0.5291874408721924,
-0.2093348354101181,
-0.27569761872291565,
-0.3061506748199463,
0.5174686312675476,
0.03400419279932976,
-0.43422767519950867,
-0.2989543378353119,
0.5090458393096924,
0.019595472142100334,
-0.061453867703676224,
-0.017528852447867393,
-0.26578661799430847,
-0.15849602222442627,
0.17592091858386993,
0.1418657898902893,
0.7394313216209412,
0.31538522243499756,
-0.6110793352127075,
0.3813899755477905,
-0.021461915224790573,
-0.12034882605075836,
0.18197672069072723,
-0.5733537673950195,
-0.09309012442827225,
0.326020210981369,
0.04406702145934105,
-0.6278151273727417,
-0.7711259126663208,
0.22104161977767944,
-0.535655677318573,
0.05937112495303154,
-0.31232038140296936,
-0.4465729892253876,
-0.2944934368133545,
-0.10628648102283478,
0.11282587051391602,
0.5797049403190613,
-0.5221473574638367,
-0.010512156412005424,
0.15070612728595734,
-0.1996665745973587,
-0.33207064867019653,
-0.6825827360153198,
0.07091861218214035,
-0.10408786684274673,
-0.6519725918769836,
-0.06924709677696228,
-0.2090015560388565,
-0.36882904171943665,
0.048094071447849274,
0.023734411224722862,
-0.1696593463420868,
0.16324713826179504,
0.42096981406211853,
-0.01895061321556568,
-0.37341979146003723,
-0.183390274643898,
0.1661616712808609,
-0.19204729795455933,
0.02266944944858551,
-0.6504920721054077,
0.4799986183643341,
-0.4484836757183075,
0.17446067929267883,
-0.21534597873687744,
0.41854873299598694,
0.2598858177661896,
-0.01638464629650116,
0.22164711356163025,
0.535840630531311,
-0.35295370221138,
-0.8616561889648438,
0.0780174657702446,
0.07574386894702911,
-0.4927900433540344,
0.1012595072388649,
-0.3551153838634491,
-0.6651965975761414,
0.07222038507461548,
0.18464751541614532,
0.15872593224048615,
0.2904703915119171,
0.8562209606170654,
0.1356663852930069,
0.9750915765762329,
0.7436726093292236,
0.1294359266757965,
0.45595136284828186,
-0.4284156262874603,
0.09114322066307068,
-0.1596449464559555,
0.110007144510746,
-0.5250100493431091,
-0.09924660623073578,
-0.6625493764877319,
-0.092742420732975,
-0.07819043844938278,
0.008534261025488377,
-0.33497875928878784,
0.4020354151725769,
-0.8097526431083679,
0.6806389093399048,
0.9518138766288757,
-0.4379108250141144,
0.12971508502960205,
0.09678078442811966,
-0.14382974803447723,
0.29044365882873535,
-0.9007936120033264,
-0.5383244752883911,
1.1507562398910522,
-0.21722622215747833,
0.7752805352210999,
-0.2719883322715759,
1.3152461051940918,
0.3571549355983734,
0.23383376002311707,
-0.8819761276245117,
0.4712385833263397,
0.07678324729204178,
-0.3986358046531677,
-0.2030602991580963,
-0.7650195360183716,
-0.8795921206474304,
-0.04698328301310539,
-0.010218947194516659,
-0.688082754611969,
0.02447810210287571,
0.4574911594390869,
-0.5884538292884827,
-0.2019285261631012,
-0.9258390069007874,
1.1968002319335938,
0.10256282240152359,
-0.4413049519062042,
0.025503072887659073,
-0.49214813113212585,
0.4287564158439636,
0.10442613810300827,
0.09043733030557632,
0.05430535972118378,
0.28307458758354187,
0.4283696413040161,
-0.8088103532791138,
0.49665990471839905,
-0.11162951588630676,
-0.008683825843036175,
0.5592509508132935,
0.5280947089195251,
0.24767935276031494,
0.5138043165206909,
-0.03155062347650528,
0.18750044703483582,
0.23095156252384186,
-0.17647328972816467,
-0.13031667470932007,
0.9227323532104492,
-0.48026859760284424,
-0.18767951428890228,
-0.5475133061408997,
-0.8290560841560364,
0.33464324474334717,
0.6006975769996643,
0.5243532657623291,
0.28042179346084595,
-0.15404735505580902,
0.32008951902389526,
0.2518632113933563,
-0.29335007071495056,
0.6845402121543884,
0.07545912265777588,
-0.13460253179073334,
-0.48883694410324097,
1.2423726320266724,
0.0522812083363533,
-0.17227301001548767,
0.09269385039806366,
0.2603316605091095,
0.1709308624267578,
-0.3266628682613373,
-0.7463912963867188,
-0.18411728739738464,
-0.39092445373535156,
-0.5544076561927795,
-0.36421310901641846,
-0.14296728372573853,
-0.7442633509635925,
-0.40945011377334595,
-0.23611599206924438,
-1.013651967048645,
-0.12196238338947296,
0.2019767016172409,
0.1447141319513321,
0.5106204152107239,
-0.2414391040802002,
0.08540096133947372,
-0.5816124081611633,
0.48901936411857605,
0.34144553542137146,
0.253871887922287,
-0.4380365312099457,
0.15916404128074646,
-0.3861912190914154,
0.04739658161997795,
-0.46803519129753113,
-0.36743074655532837,
0.5477479100227356,
0.4419311583042145,
0.26968035101890564,
0.2765069901943207,
0.2415664792060852,
0.3739740550518036,
-0.4457147717475891,
0.8796696066856384,
-0.1255195438861847,
-0.9013367891311646,
0.7669206261634827,
-0.37880170345306396,
0.06444872170686722,
0.263658344745636,
-0.3587440848350525,
-0.4806687831878662,
-0.6682672500610352,
-0.7722894549369812,
-0.7184554934501648,
0.8811608552932739,
0.45164045691490173,
-0.019534526392817497,
-0.24882586300373077,
0.14713448286056519,
0.23144571483135223,
0.40710383653640747,
-0.5801773071289062,
0.12876681983470917,
-0.7070772051811218,
-0.6388298273086548,
0.010936720296740532,
-0.0010284450836479664,
-0.1994982808828354,
-0.09879894554615021,
0.6269693970680237,
-0.3781543970108032,
0.14896835386753082,
-0.12634141743183136,
-0.3451913595199585,
-0.41248399019241333,
0.3791200518608093,
0.40035757422447205,
0.47672730684280396,
-0.22462384402751923,
0.17207549512386322,
-0.26888617873191833,
-0.37291961908340454,
0.022536462172865868,
-0.03637034818530083,
-0.6546636819839478,
0.06594745814800262,
0.1960766613483429,
0.18245241045951843,
-0.19905422627925873,
-1.0121097564697266,
0.6124925017356873,
-0.052273236215114594,
-0.12015371769666672,
-0.5271666646003723,
0.7210875153541565,
-0.10402590036392212,
0.32264965772628784,
0.08907713741064072,
0.14269281923770905,
0.10399402678012848,
-0.340780109167099,
0.3540785014629364,
0.31472107768058777,
0.38183778524398804,
-0.22123368084430695,
0.7525778412818909,
0.2311902642250061,
-0.29765403270721436,
0.9433386325836182,
-0.4729496240615845,
0.036656420677900314,
0.7889904379844666,
0.9113366603851318,
0.8126543164253235,
0.18991532921791077,
0.12844692170619965,
0.39866989850997925,
0.30963829159736633,
0.15210086107254028,
0.5288697481155396,
-0.2681828439235687,
-0.3875249922275543,
-0.2584037780761719,
-0.917813777923584,
-0.347880482673645,
0.2291693091392517,
-0.29325512051582336,
0.14071542024612427,
-0.6188819408416748,
0.03393755480647087,
-0.30323395133018494,
0.13709308207035065,
-0.5263315439224243,
0.26632365584373474,
0.2760818898677826,
0.7538872957229614,
-0.6974294781684875,
1.0596920251846313,
0.8451666831970215,
-0.5617064833641052,
-0.7456984519958496,
-0.09769709408283234,
0.00412774458527565,
-0.3990987241268158,
0.5639365315437317,
0.47398641705513,
0.25297459959983826,
0.11324457824230194,
-0.7554454803466797,
-0.7391735911369324,
0.8103739619255066,
0.5152909159660339,
0.012705168686807156,
-0.11627794802188873,
0.09999612718820572,
0.38481083512306213,
-0.45887717604637146,
-0.0762307420372963,
0.7071170806884766,
0.2642771601676941,
-0.22404225170612335,
-0.5573070049285889,
0.20021462440490723,
-0.6946920156478882,
0.1356966644525528,
-0.1242639422416687,
-0.44411543011665344,
1.1166315078735352,
-0.3642069697380066,
-0.18294137716293335,
0.4665048122406006,
0.5798799395561218,
0.5324790477752686,
0.47983843088150024,
0.05833346024155617,
0.4732500910758972,
0.6541858911514282,
-0.22508540749549866,
0.9612680673599243,
-0.5137540698051453,
0.3579561710357666,
1.1062270402908325,
0.061090148985385895,
0.5572409629821777,
0.5671901702880859,
0.16864469647407532,
0.5409786701202393,
0.46357595920562744,
-0.2293751984834671,
0.4154711663722992,
0.24144840240478516,
0.0062240599654614925,
-0.18670837581157684,
0.23781335353851318,
-0.39080575108528137,
0.18640469014644623,
0.46445775032043457,
-0.43499451875686646,
-0.21664904057979584,
-0.21887649595737457,
-0.0008214613771997392,
-0.1571130007505417,
-0.27196457982063293,
0.4572487771511078,
-0.06627096235752106,
-0.7507389783859253,
0.8161312937736511,
0.2770904302597046,
0.6795890927314758,
-0.5458605289459229,
-0.11360947787761688,
-0.5172159671783447,
0.536299467086792,
-0.6941683292388916,
-0.6112532019615173,
0.5137495994567871,
0.20845365524291992,
-0.16468675434589386,
-0.3146129548549652,
0.6348977088928223,
-0.3581331670284271,
-0.32066866755485535,
-0.4378586411476135,
0.22569498419761658,
0.2931944727897644,
0.07156350463628769,
-0.373080313205719,
-0.06529898941516876,
-0.07800772041082382,
-0.4514405131340027,
0.22296088933944702,
0.7422353029251099,
0.010791698470711708,
0.5623915195465088,
0.7064533233642578,
0.3504170775413513,
0.36805135011672974,
-0.22854289412498474,
0.7288188338279724,
-0.5744432806968689,
-0.7749070525169373,
-0.6070094108581543,
0.32281938195228577,
-0.026644650846719742,
-0.2712302803993225,
0.8786211013793945,
0.8115993738174438,
1.1825119256973267,
-0.3069761097431183,
1.149908185005188,
-0.8158469200134277,
-0.0725974291563034,
-0.25833937525749207,
0.9550541639328003,
-0.5048527121543884,
0.00352155021391809,
-0.19261068105697632,
-0.706572413444519,
-0.39760416746139526,
0.9346282482147217,
0.08755306154489517,
-0.2705139219760895,
0.5602421164512634,
0.9380268454551697,
-0.25679492950439453,
-0.223895862698555,
-0.007906465791165829,
-0.0018048916244879365,
0.4444018304347992,
0.7465206384658813,
0.6650696396827698,
-0.17941835522651672,
0.8864899277687073,
-0.6375908851623535,
-0.1936468482017517,
-0.4590851962566376,
-1.019669532775879,
-0.7870143055915833,
-0.1990172415971756,
-0.2544202208518982,
-0.5917496681213379,
-0.18452326953411102,
1.2580779790878296,
0.5816136598587036,
-0.9048869013786316,
-0.4394277036190033,
-0.4519653022289276,
0.3284277021884918,
-0.5271889567375183,
-0.2883566915988922,
0.2610521912574768,
-0.8388777375221252,
-0.6997476816177368,
0.5171622037887573,
0.0443943552672863,
-0.19926628470420837,
0.06826744228601456,
-0.3507975935935974,
0.280147522687912,
-0.15725091099739075,
0.6264797449111938,
0.6058757305145264,
-0.24154196679592133,
-0.36310437321662903,
-0.2189423143863678,
-0.35283029079437256,
-0.1360471248626709,
1.0395437479019165,
-0.9090738892555237,
0.14324751496315002,
0.836721658706665,
0.3750074803829193,
-0.11662188172340393,
-0.1201782375574112,
0.5428777933120728,
-1.1929996013641357,
0.33854395151138306,
0.026371680200099945,
0.4979139566421509,
0.2009068876504898,
-0.35788044333457947,
0.5342723727226257,
0.5000354051589966,
-0.5523537993431091,
-0.9834533929824829,
0.17072930932044983,
-0.6986940503120422,
-0.2755684554576874,
1.348850965499878,
-0.028747573494911194,
-0.3050001263618469,
0.20118869841098785,
-0.27959680557250977,
0.3795206844806671,
-0.5754024386405945,
0.7194125056266785,
0.2534742057323456,
-0.35989275574684143,
0.3305237293243408,
-0.1955975741147995,
0.5304219126701355,
-0.11657030135393143,
-0.5343521237373352,
0.37861448526382446,
0.9594506025314331,
0.649372935295105,
0.11139480769634247,
0.6654409766197205,
0.15809266269207,
0.46111375093460083,
0.3320873975753784,
0.17439799010753632,
-0.5546102523803711,
-0.42630383372306824,
-0.30491337180137634,
0.5222489237785339,
-0.10948216915130615,
-0.0337698794901371
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06487v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06487v3
|
Multilingual Turn-taking Prediction Using Voice Activity Projection
| 2024-03-11T07:50:29 | 2024-03-14T23:59:59 |
Koji Inoue, Bing'er Jiang, Erik Ekstedt, Tatsuya Kawahara, Gabriel Skantze
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
This paper investigates the application of voice activity projection (VAP), a
predictive turn-taking model for spoken dialogue, on multilingual data,
encompassing English, Mandarin, and Japanese. The VAP model continuously
predicts the upcoming voice activities of participants in dyadic dialogue,
leveraging a cross-attention Transformer to capture the dynamic interplay
between participants. The results show that a monolingual VAP model trained on
one language does not make good predictions when applied to other languages.
However, a multilingual model, trained on all three languages, demonstrates
predictive performance on par with monolingual models across all languages.
Further analyses show that the multilingual model has learned to discern the
language of the input signal. We also analyze the sensitivity to pitch, a
prosodic cue that is thought to be important for turn-taking. Finally, we
compare two different audio encoders, contrastive predictive coding (CPC)
pre-trained on English, with a recent model based on multilingual wav2vec 2.0
(MMS).
|
[
-0.41910499334335327,
-0.38109061121940613,
0.5964144468307495,
0.48612773418426514,
-0.03872010111808777,
0.033529117703437805,
-0.08437909930944443,
-0.40959280729293823,
0.36137765645980835,
0.6542447805404663,
-0.6286517381668091,
-0.3133305311203003,
-0.49801042675971985,
-0.1122363954782486,
-0.29820895195007324,
0.5481448769569397,
0.18711529672145844,
0.5735032558441162,
-0.18337686359882355,
0.030463807284832,
-0.5462294816970825,
-0.725590169429779,
-0.6494241952896118,
-0.5074895620346069,
0.28810223937034607,
0.3316647410392761,
0.47963112592697144,
-0.05280998721718788,
0.18818777799606323,
0.28173816204071045,
-0.0874539464712143,
0.011399820446968079,
-0.10793838649988174,
0.18718986213207245,
0.16002540290355682,
-0.6060506701469421,
-0.44470155239105225,
-0.0342247448861599,
0.7206777930259705,
0.5909075140953064,
-0.43496254086494446,
-0.05659911409020424,
-0.021516447886824608,
0.4321701228618622,
-0.37941375374794006,
0.4963819682598114,
-0.4981214106082916,
0.18743634223937988,
0.017733952030539513,
-0.36344048380851746,
-0.4552103877067566,
-0.03895542025566101,
0.1957402527332306,
-0.4629948139190674,
0.20449385046958923,
-0.21674340963363647,
0.2679600417613983,
0.15662896633148193,
-0.28559646010398865,
-0.27187579870224,
-1.0288811922073364,
0.6146376729011536,
-0.7119649052619934,
0.5411490797996521,
0.5004937052726746,
0.43510693311691284,
0.06802500039339066,
-0.5127103924751282,
-0.8108208179473877,
-0.14378002285957336,
0.035619597882032394,
0.3926105201244354,
0.04108738526701927,
0.0868607833981514,
0.24059130251407623,
0.28300660848617554,
-0.45856523513793945,
0.013289236463606358,
-0.3620586693286896,
0.05480698496103287,
0.5497550368309021,
0.046761054545640945,
0.27011170983314514,
-0.21836256980895996,
-0.2549479901790619,
-0.05661803483963013,
-0.5560628771781921,
0.3887189030647278,
0.32620692253112793,
0.4653966426849365,
-0.4456377327442169,
0.4877478778362274,
-0.05781157687306404,
0.41346460580825806,
0.17852698266506195,
-0.3929242789745331,
0.26805293560028076,
-0.3471216559410095,
-0.11773517727851868,
0.3916449546813965,
0.8305597901344299,
0.3549710512161255,
0.2684023976325989,
0.2951558530330658,
0.17747634649276733,
-0.10481931269168854,
0.28143593668937683,
-0.5347453951835632,
0.027174193412065506,
0.33291158080101013,
-0.3361150324344635,
-0.02236100658774376,
0.08800676465034485,
-0.8350061774253845,
-0.22722823917865753,
-0.3699035048484802,
-0.0568489208817482,
-0.35096460580825806,
-0.5388799905776978,
0.17471803724765778,
0.19397146999835968,
0.23577217757701874,
0.2021559327840805,
-0.9434418678283691,
0.30324211716651917,
0.6508179903030396,
0.9558709859848022,
-0.24895566701889038,
-0.5532836318016052,
-0.5924168229103088,
0.12046045809984207,
-0.22652022540569305,
0.49430784583091736,
-0.512015700340271,
-0.6034886837005615,
0.42481711506843567,
0.22907720506191254,
-0.21188487112522125,
-0.3641261160373688,
0.46075576543807983,
-0.09542371332645416,
0.3888415992259979,
0.021555859595537186,
-0.07052002847194672,
-0.38848230242729187,
0.11494604498147964,
-1.013009786605835,
0.7202352285385132,
-0.034867413341999054,
-0.5806996822357178,
0.21728995442390442,
-0.48284268379211426,
-0.5429162979125977,
-0.08381738513708115,
-0.3138228952884674,
-0.522939920425415,
0.062378063797950745,
0.24664580821990967,
0.4299876093864441,
-0.05246882885694504,
0.29715508222579956,
-0.013876245357096195,
-0.20291994512081146,
0.48240673542022705,
-0.6272522211074829,
0.5699439644813538,
-0.13561494648456573,
-0.26708459854125977,
0.15348681807518005,
-0.6543044447898865,
-0.14027348160743713,
0.04854794964194298,
-0.14589466154575348,
0.04662083834409714,
0.29896512627601624,
0.06276028603315353,
0.717923104763031,
-0.01804482378065586,
-0.6812337040901184,
0.05664557218551636,
-0.4131941795349121,
0.1327122151851654,
0.37440818548202515,
-0.05895475670695305,
0.2537975013256073,
-0.05353669822216034,
1.0091122388839722,
0.10049489140510559,
0.12218153476715088,
-0.47718724608421326,
-0.7301400899887085,
-0.8384711146354675,
0.07109633833169937,
0.10028361529111862,
0.6942613124847412,
-0.924868106842041,
-0.18267935514450073,
-0.18751883506774902,
-0.5089297890663147,
-0.8094238638877869,
-0.3774424195289612,
0.6071544289588928,
0.09097006916999817,
0.41588786244392395,
-0.20517006516456604,
-0.5889689922332764,
-0.7900925874710083,
-0.01872759684920311,
-0.5163381695747375,
-0.05160507559776306,
0.24103008210659027,
-0.07636352628469467,
0.1720479428768158,
0.17220641672611237,
-0.36363157629966736,
-0.2898823022842407,
-0.7316941618919373,
0.29131439328193665,
0.2511172294616699,
0.31238171458244324,
0.39368441700935364,
-1.0639097690582275,
-0.8056018352508545,
0.18798142671585083,
-0.30607685446739197,
-0.006481921300292015,
-0.3747977018356323,
0.14084996283054352,
0.10766158998012543,
0.49325212836265564,
-0.5328709483146667,
0.3876018822193146,
1.0672211647033691,
-0.14817163348197937,
0.5260519981384277,
-0.09142894297838211,
0.3336959779262543,
-1.1040904521942139,
-0.1846500039100647,
0.09224938601255417,
-0.17685212194919586,
-1.049617886543274,
-0.493517130613327,
-0.1296042650938034,
-0.2660661041736603,
-0.7931959629058838,
0.30073922872543335,
-0.36301055550575256,
-0.19549527764320374,
-0.25625374913215637,
-0.1313047558069229,
-0.17741908133029938,
0.668265700340271,
0.7073023319244385,
0.7634153366088867,
0.4615239202976227,
-0.593934953212738,
0.16597265005111694,
0.18444888293743134,
-0.5269903540611267,
0.18478111922740936,
-0.46175700426101685,
0.11117684841156006,
0.001146588590927422,
0.030683310702443123,
-0.9726795554161072,
-0.0700388178229332,
-0.2021845281124115,
-0.7331213355064392,
0.6970146894454956,
-0.22947798669338226,
0.044651057571172714,
-0.3003145456314087,
0.002911147428676486,
0.4373149573802948,
0.2889460623264313,
-0.45996618270874023,
0.6307246088981628,
0.5705708861351013,
-0.5966829061508179,
-0.5533572435379028,
-0.5534300804138184,
-0.23405931890010834,
-0.11692158877849579,
-0.18563248217105865,
0.5188248753547668,
0.03400619700551033,
0.027259347960352898,
-0.6843237280845642,
0.17031961679458618,
-0.05270632356405258,
-0.3582911193370819,
0.4281901717185974,
0.30297863483428955,
0.09328432381153107,
-0.23267987370491028,
-0.13793863356113434,
-0.3359196186065674,
0.22939521074295044,
0.16843968629837036,
0.8215417265892029,
0.07516726106405258,
-0.5608507394790649,
-0.32329651713371277,
0.7113626599311829,
0.8360074758529663,
-0.24574053287506104,
0.29908040165901184,
0.6342512369155884,
-0.21970759332180023,
0.276424765586853,
-0.3664206266403198,
0.13537563383579254,
-0.3722241222858429,
0.6633448600769043,
-0.40058374404907227,
-0.5005062818527222,
0.40627095103263855,
0.02228632941842079,
-0.037944987416267395,
0.1743149310350418,
0.901647686958313,
0.04554238170385361,
1.6321756839752197,
0.7871459126472473,
-0.01828821189701557,
0.7021389603614807,
-0.14802372455596924,
0.32224151492118835,
-0.940305233001709,
-0.4512347877025604,
-0.4294285476207733,
0.016815155744552612,
-1.04831063747406,
-0.8042609095573425,
0.5737659931182861,
-0.23479755222797394,
0.2955479025840759,
0.2635945975780487,
-0.33022448420524597,
0.1310870498418808,
0.5519942045211792,
-0.46694374084472656,
0.11281193792819977,
-0.13317300379276276,
-0.026954034343361855,
-0.3410138487815857,
-0.7258841395378113,
-0.33982712030410767,
0.9280560612678528,
0.33510255813598633,
0.4149561822414398,
0.08426449447870255,
0.3754560053348541,
-0.11807406693696976,
0.055176910012960434,
-0.7751733660697937,
0.369098424911499,
-0.10793591290712357,
-0.48279449343681335,
-0.31875577569007874,
0.07193931937217712,
-0.8592480421066284,
0.4382622539997101,
-0.1301615983247757,
-0.5577743053436279,
0.23379404842853546,
0.014332244172692299,
-0.1745082139968872,
0.21775193512439728,
-0.4466345012187958,
0.4860723316669464,
-0.44055670499801636,
-0.20256859064102173,
-0.3658251166343689,
-0.3408770263195038,
0.08331651240587234,
0.20212015509605408,
0.38812872767448425,
-0.1365983933210373,
0.3082273006439209,
0.6138368248939514,
0.23364484310150146,
0.7956996560096741,
-0.4413372278213501,
-0.049587711691856384,
0.3407340347766876,
0.08470947295427322,
0.20319993793964386,
0.24861188232898712,
-0.04533262923359871,
0.4534217417240143,
0.09654819220304489,
-0.14870457351207733,
-0.40677401423454285,
0.4645634889602661,
-0.6389198303222656,
-0.5178711414337158,
-0.5448794364929199,
-0.1239984855055809,
-0.3336499333381653,
0.05784676969051361,
0.5211800932884216,
0.15746073424816132,
-0.7300753593444824,
-0.025739172473549843,
0.3033129572868347,
-0.18513482809066772,
0.5655200481414795,
0.7481884360313416,
-0.537079393863678,
-0.34868085384368896,
0.9565840363502502,
0.2051428109407425,
0.3921634256839752,
0.647298276424408,
0.0618661493062973,
-0.14101335406303406,
-0.45303359627723694,
-0.39658015966415405,
0.1935269683599472,
-0.3540344834327698,
0.07278169691562653,
-0.4486013948917389,
-0.29752007126808167,
-0.4569588899612427,
0.01887686178088188,
-0.6925856471061707,
-0.37384307384490967,
0.15734532475471497,
-0.16374953091144562,
-0.37478333711624146,
0.5249273777008057,
0.07568122446537018,
0.1642865389585495,
-0.5285378098487854,
0.36547333002090454,
0.26437053084373474,
0.08474650979042053,
-0.2715331017971039,
-0.4088228940963745,
-0.55796217918396,
0.0620729885995388,
-0.36506980657577515,
-0.8465116620063782,
0.917496919631958,
0.20608334243297577,
0.6420366168022156,
0.22101521492004395,
-0.23643483221530914,
0.32580363750457764,
-0.6472256779670715,
1.0990116596221924,
0.5215849280357361,
-0.7881988883018494,
0.5987040400505066,
-0.23395289480686188,
0.638049304485321,
0.33920443058013916,
0.6145615577697754,
-0.974699079990387,
-0.3164418637752533,
-0.6008005738258362,
-0.6537269949913025,
0.7207984924316406,
0.009272937662899494,
-0.01636582985520363,
0.07302672415971756,
-0.05730666220188141,
0.41351836919784546,
0.41809478402137756,
-0.7890341877937317,
-0.17996621131896973,
-0.46145978569984436,
0.08886570483446121,
-0.46808573603630066,
-0.23582720756530762,
0.2003510594367981,
-0.30873921513557434,
0.5984595417976379,
-0.3858749568462372,
0.6860822439193726,
0.09384260326623917,
0.31476178765296936,
-0.22221004962921143,
0.30178576707839966,
0.7403883934020996,
0.43744176626205444,
-0.17513751983642578,
-0.08333653956651688,
0.12341135740280151,
-0.544800877571106,
0.035900868475437164,
-0.10781926661729813,
-0.1360020786523819,
0.3707781136035919,
0.6254869103431702,
1.2570374011993408,
0.191635400056839,
-0.586519181728363,
0.4305800199508667,
-0.2168339341878891,
-0.06197703629732132,
-0.9167231917381287,
-0.1526551991701126,
0.12867999076843262,
0.08920024335384369,
0.02604413963854313,
-0.22601088881492615,
0.3530024290084839,
-0.6541082262992859,
-0.29236000776290894,
0.17654849588871002,
-0.7350630760192871,
-0.7098597288131714,
0.42006441950798035,
0.242012158036232,
-0.5316479206085205,
0.38065382838249207,
0.04158546030521393,
-0.8763070702552795,
0.6597890853881836,
0.5722195506095886,
1.1457798480987549,
-0.9358955025672913,
0.1657096892595291,
0.6484969258308411,
0.0293726846575737,
0.2746942937374115,
0.5126165747642517,
-0.12445729225873947,
-0.7968237400054932,
-0.6122192740440369,
-0.40485671162605286,
-0.7507230639457703,
0.30757325887680054,
-0.947911262512207,
0.42180323600769043,
-0.11238628625869751,
-0.2613034248352051,
0.16024178266525269,
-0.12848159670829773,
-0.7195389270782471,
0.18269123136997223,
0.7997896671295166,
0.38386985659599304,
-0.9266510009765625,
1.0879024267196655,
0.7767916321754456,
-0.21072502434253693,
-0.3730553686618805,
0.18291670083999634,
0.10061705112457275,
-0.7287775874137878,
0.3658362030982971,
0.3503056764602661,
-0.26178574562072754,
-0.39314964413642883,
-0.048632100224494934,
-0.9423834681510925,
0.8412721753120422,
0.06918484717607498,
-0.6687655448913574,
-0.162787064909935,
0.4119006395339966,
0.5321632027626038,
-0.6840013265609741,
0.3965446352958679,
0.6425378322601318,
0.416288286447525,
-0.05162123590707779,
-1.297184944152832,
-0.5371460318565369,
-0.3744988739490509,
-0.06788320094347,
0.10595843940973282,
-0.7212788462638855,
0.9916984438896179,
-0.2216958999633789,
-0.16390883922576904,
-0.26325491070747375,
0.5989386439323425,
0.15254950523376465,
0.3628228008747101,
0.4771624505519867,
-0.09207969903945923,
0.31644055247306824,
-0.11190976202487946,
0.9787103533744812,
-0.41232728958129883,
0.0090360501781106,
1.2062032222747803,
-0.3651789128780365,
1.161585807800293,
0.6717464923858643,
-0.4383985996246338,
0.5791678428649902,
0.25538134574890137,
0.4687773883342743,
0.7183317542076111,
-0.2923940420150757,
-0.26405540108680725,
-0.222264364361763,
-0.14435915648937225,
-0.13997428119182587,
1.0852246284484863,
0.5980085134506226,
-0.30959850549697876,
0.5480562448501587,
0.2670624554157257,
-0.10362682491540909,
0.017504645511507988,
-0.22366207838058472,
0.9994044899940491,
0.07430142909288406,
-1.285814881324768,
0.48471933603286743,
-0.0203829538077116,
0.5440598726272583,
-0.5448746085166931,
-0.2039344161748886,
0.088424913585186,
0.176631897687912,
-0.0314052477478981,
-0.8357848525047302,
0.23560427129268646,
-0.29618868231773376,
-0.28423622250556946,
-0.3181400001049042,
0.41925954818725586,
-0.8110585808753967,
-0.5029983520507812,
0.7441138029098511,
0.4271807372570038,
0.10493819415569305,
-0.041888006031513214,
-0.7124999165534973,
-0.11609456688165665,
0.40078848600387573,
-0.33552172780036926,
0.4291726052761078,
0.20518897473812103,
0.09131228178739548,
0.5433393120765686,
0.49432969093322754,
0.39296069741249084,
0.053866732865571976,
0.482363760471344,
0.4985630214214325,
-0.5511436462402344,
-0.7884436249732971,
-0.41126713156700134,
0.5327677726745605,
-0.04264310747385025,
-0.2431769073009491,
0.4758923053741455,
0.4864560663700104,
1.0483462810516357,
-0.06134479492902756,
1.0004743337631226,
0.2620869278907776,
0.8616144061088562,
-0.7436792254447937,
0.1137009933590889,
-0.31169044971466064,
-0.002781013259664178,
-0.20283852517604828,
-0.8578580617904663,
0.29826924204826355,
0.660493016242981,
-0.1841985136270523,
0.09900318831205368,
0.7680391669273376,
0.49271827936172485,
0.14518877863883972,
0.04671521112322807,
0.5428841710090637,
-0.07279115170240402,
0.4939076006412506,
0.672130286693573,
0.6179797053337097,
-0.2447284311056137,
0.22171051800251007,
-0.7248514890670776,
-0.124514639377594,
-0.37263768911361694,
-0.614687979221344,
-0.7410407662391663,
-1.0057584047317505,
-0.20249180495738983,
-0.26068392395973206,
-0.32640257477760315,
0.6552829146385193,
0.7448486089706421,
-0.9262263178825378,
-0.652978241443634,
0.1418345868587494,
-0.07603337615728378,
-0.6004171967506409,
-0.19100242853164673,
0.08713904768228531,
0.038901202380657196,
-1.2654427289962769,
0.799088180065155,
0.35182327032089233,
0.07378940284252167,
-0.6726818680763245,
-0.29510244727134705,
-0.3609539568424225,
0.1026894822716713,
0.6817846894264221,
0.42358145117759705,
-0.8742582201957703,
-0.08551008999347687,
0.0643734261393547,
0.13479627668857574,
0.20460866391658783,
1.212927222251892,
-0.5213115215301514,
0.833507239818573,
0.42553097009658813,
-0.1347217559814453,
1.0032895803451538,
-0.0458894744515419,
0.9831621646881104,
-0.7305745482444763,
0.6000493764877319,
0.4514912962913513,
0.45291125774383545,
0.5169107913970947,
-0.33228278160095215,
0.3185483515262604,
-0.18475978076457977,
-0.42027562856674194,
-0.6129717230796814,
0.3219287395477295,
-0.8722608089447021,
-0.08967290818691254,
1.1727007627487183,
-0.1771123856306076,
-0.05621681362390518,
-0.248641699552536,
-0.45737558603286743,
0.43002212047576904,
-0.3499186635017395,
0.5095570087432861,
0.9200902581214905,
-0.3526241183280945,
-0.3598361611366272,
-0.9652066230773926,
0.7264149188995361,
0.5666106939315796,
-0.43331179022789,
0.24571309983730316,
0.20124638080596924,
-0.32636669278144836,
0.5562918782234192,
0.7810925245285034,
-0.11637582629919052,
0.42255085706710815,
0.10925079882144928,
0.3246408700942993,
0.10328256338834763,
-0.6492945551872253,
-0.48832786083221436,
0.10071352124214172,
0.15261802077293396,
-0.15967479348182678
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06485v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06485v1
|
Knowledge-aware Alert Aggregation in Large-scale Cloud Systems: a Hybrid Approach
| 2024-03-11T07:48:35 | 2024-03-11T07:48:35 |
Jinxi Kuang, Jinyang Liu, Junjie Huang, Renyi Zhong, Jiazhen Gu, Lan Yu, Rui Tan, Zengyin Yang, Michael R. Lyu
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Due to the scale and complexity of cloud systems, a system failure would
trigger an "alert storm", i.e., massive correlated alerts. Although these
alerts can be traced back to a few root causes, the overwhelming number makes
it infeasible for manual handling. Alert aggregation is thus critical to help
engineers concentrate on the root cause and facilitate failure resolution.
Existing methods typically utilize semantic similarity-based methods or
statistical methods to aggregate alerts. However, semantic similarity-based
methods overlook the causal rationale of alerts, while statistical methods can
hardly handle infrequent alerts.
To tackle these limitations, we introduce leveraging external knowledge,
i.e., Standard Operation Procedure (SOP) of alerts as a supplement. We propose
COLA, a novel hybrid approach based on correlation mining and LLM (Large
Language Model) reasoning for online alert aggregation. The correlation mining
module effectively captures the temporal and spatial relations between alerts,
measuring their correlations in an efficient manner. Subsequently, only
uncertain pairs with low confidence are forwarded to the LLM reasoning module
for detailed analysis. This hybrid design harnesses both statistical evidence
for frequent alerts and the reasoning capabilities of computationally intensive
LLMs, ensuring the overall efficiency of COLA in handling large volumes of
alerts in practical scenarios. We evaluate COLA on three datasets collected
from the production environment of a large-scale cloud platform. The
experimental results show COLA achieves F1-scores from 0.901 to 0.930,
outperforming state-of-the-art methods and achieving comparable efficiency. We
also share our experience in deploying COLA in our real-world cloud system,
Cloud X.
|
[
-0.30775290727615356,
-0.8779290914535522,
0.6018036007881165,
0.6016757488250732,
-0.04143582284450531,
0.18391896784305573,
-0.09394931048154831,
-0.7532029747962952,
0.5752668380737305,
0.2933906316757202,
-0.4595964550971985,
-0.44082269072532654,
-0.3299228250980377,
-0.1350126415491104,
-0.7476216554641724,
0.8187061548233032,
0.3157413601875305,
-0.2607281506061554,
-0.5165190100669861,
0.20126478374004364,
-0.6971474289894104,
-0.7957104444503784,
-0.6100908517837524,
-0.15143083035945892,
0.032802339643239975,
0.29896798729896545,
0.7846705317497253,
0.16719581186771393,
0.657787561416626,
0.3217179477214813,
-0.06324359029531479,
0.36071011424064636,
-0.5307066440582275,
0.029117975383996964,
0.136098250746727,
-0.5260201096534729,
-0.3201912045478821,
-0.5206748843193054,
0.38993293046951294,
0.5690637230873108,
-0.37811532616615295,
-0.22342531383037567,
-0.001035241293720901,
0.43401676416397095,
-1.0033174753189087,
0.1995777189731598,
-0.7646719217300415,
0.0049424488097429276,
0.10300907492637634,
-0.2099589854478836,
-0.27799174189567566,
-0.06348516047000885,
0.0917191207408905,
-0.7108321189880371,
0.013101964257657528,
0.22778531908988953,
0.3815421760082245,
0.21218341588974,
-0.313264936208725,
-0.36254364252090454,
-0.7470675110816956,
1.0702892541885376,
-0.22067034244537354,
0.3565394878387451,
0.2620668113231659,
0.43655627965927124,
-0.3332778513431549,
-0.5003284811973572,
-0.32126834988594055,
0.1944841742515564,
-0.09978996962308884,
0.4390661418437958,
-0.1594027727842331,
-0.24339675903320312,
-0.1613832265138626,
0.3873743414878845,
-0.37952283024787903,
0.3781959116458893,
-0.0019693844951689243,
-0.40658941864967346,
0.7159296870231628,
0.3884383738040924,
0.12296202778816223,
0.052388519048690796,
-0.9565058946609497,
0.08637015521526337,
-0.6795192360877991,
-0.044717978686094284,
0.025022845715284348,
0.3888084292411804,
-0.415081650018692,
0.2197473794221878,
-0.15557335317134857,
0.6135774254798889,
0.02701476961374283,
-0.34117257595062256,
0.06860539317131042,
-0.5203535556793213,
-0.4331667721271515,
0.3663724660873413,
0.989764928817749,
0.44263678789138794,
-0.2165602147579193,
-0.40675872564315796,
-0.28725767135620117,
0.24791164696216583,
0.11674213409423828,
-0.41309306025505066,
0.01684051938354969,
0.5861361622810364,
-0.2557992935180664,
-0.27140533924102783,
-0.024511808529496193,
-0.9924416542053223,
-0.8010335564613342,
-0.26782312989234924,
0.4099860191345215,
-0.5295608639717102,
-0.26850664615631104,
0.028475988656282425,
-0.23107050359249115,
-0.12976545095443726,
0.3156886696815491,
-0.5078431367874146,
0.32770687341690063,
1.098313570022583,
0.8208959102630615,
-0.08119409531354904,
-0.22719763219356537,
-0.6059990525245667,
0.031175751239061356,
-0.384049654006958,
0.897279679775238,
-0.2577308714389801,
-0.4918223023414612,
0.20803506672382355,
-0.6031745672225952,
-0.08139060437679291,
-0.7143747210502625,
0.6473222374916077,
-0.8259077072143555,
-0.04866806045174599,
0.02828185074031353,
-0.46537330746650696,
-0.09587372839450836,
0.14767669141292572,
-0.2552001178264618,
1.0061506032943726,
-0.050304725766181946,
-0.6419389843940735,
0.39869457483291626,
-0.3934888541698456,
-0.5249553918838501,
0.18773256242275238,
-0.30134040117263794,
-0.2672644257545471,
0.043768107891082764,
0.27893325686454773,
0.3569791615009308,
-0.9958672523498535,
0.4794406592845917,
-0.49162474274635315,
0.0644397959113121,
0.07839703559875488,
0.21365013718605042,
0.8980650305747986,
0.4962860941886902,
-0.08957511186599731,
0.08257999271154404,
-0.7343959212303162,
0.08192066103219986,
0.13105551898479462,
0.24155375361442566,
-0.6675018668174744,
0.0024152384139597416,
-0.11384333670139313,
-0.005984804593026638,
0.44179266691207886,
-0.3314148187637329,
-0.14716222882270813,
0.13224953413009644,
0.1435261219739914,
0.6286851763725281,
0.24470184743404388,
0.3221862018108368,
-0.4440074563026428,
0.32476991415023804,
0.206917867064476,
0.5037189722061157,
-0.08781668543815613,
-0.39852550625801086,
-0.7035159468650818,
-0.6371937394142151,
-0.2514990568161011,
0.787280797958374,
-0.556481659412384,
1.0885568857192993,
-0.4145984351634979,
-0.6655979156494141,
-0.03679332137107849,
0.43700647354125977,
0.15267693996429443,
0.6727988123893738,
0.3752012550830841,
0.07943454384803772,
-0.8513916730880737,
-0.8834959268569946,
-0.06355652958154678,
-0.11156480759382248,
-0.08285597711801529,
0.18497644364833832,
0.2270982712507248,
-0.4709821939468384,
1.110940933227539,
-0.6814745664596558,
-0.4966341555118561,
-0.0486888661980629,
0.18815217912197113,
0.31098735332489014,
0.16594205796718597,
0.6757586598396301,
-0.8732239007949829,
-0.18549898266792297,
-0.008879883214831352,
-0.97817063331604,
-0.08337008208036423,
-0.2751351594924927,
-0.054191749542951584,
-0.23157474398612976,
0.49219048023223877,
-0.45109063386917114,
-0.02609853819012642,
0.5030401349067688,
-0.34428784251213074,
0.6985048055648804,
-0.12382229417562485,
0.10678596794605255,
-0.9006337523460388,
-0.3289926052093506,
0.04584665969014168,
0.10817697644233704,
-0.5998334288597107,
0.14546845853328705,
-0.15043067932128906,
-0.24267719686031342,
-0.292444109916687,
-0.05798006057739258,
-0.28021568059921265,
-0.13449187576770782,
-0.27229928970336914,
-0.00918235257267952,
-0.21621166169643402,
0.1976596862077713,
-0.028807615861296654,
0.533149242401123,
1.0156368017196655,
-0.9523218870162964,
0.7442344427108765,
0.027703233063220978,
-0.5303426384925842,
0.6803958415985107,
-0.36876076459884644,
-0.06214025989174843,
0.01932837814092636,
0.34241941571235657,
-0.7203953862190247,
-0.12981317937374115,
-0.2628677487373352,
-0.15120235085487366,
-0.20556265115737915,
0.2344786822795868,
-0.7380120754241943,
-0.15652874112129211,
-0.21071979403495789,
0.17731353640556335,
0.5130511522293091,
-0.7785388231277466,
0.9681867957115173,
0.65133136510849,
0.08176075667142868,
-0.10164758563041687,
-0.6997405290603638,
0.07017676532268524,
-0.3823578655719757,
-0.9558492302894592,
0.2191697061061859,
0.1356075257062912,
-0.6436823606491089,
-0.1049068421125412,
-0.14809288084506989,
-0.15331198275089264,
0.3081988990306854,
0.46251389384269714,
0.22374239563941956,
-0.043338753283023834,
0.04094315692782402,
-0.49044927954673767,
-0.11951414495706558,
0.3198866844177246,
-0.23774570226669312,
0.5878679752349854,
-0.17458786070346832,
-0.23890936374664307,
-0.47709155082702637,
0.6169189214706421,
0.852463960647583,
0.05876082181930542,
1.0030879974365234,
0.12004711478948593,
-0.518538773059845,
-0.20139798521995544,
-0.5556243658065796,
-0.23491531610488892,
-0.40199166536331177,
0.01729586347937584,
-0.30578580498695374,
-0.3804316520690918,
0.769472599029541,
-0.28242138028144836,
0.07108623534440994,
0.5146793723106384,
0.4780235290527344,
-0.15267139673233032,
0.8518424034118652,
0.5228114128112793,
-0.4653548300266266,
0.61130291223526,
-0.3620513379573822,
0.43761903047561646,
-0.5076106786727905,
-0.3616238534450531,
-0.6444219946861267,
0.05678373947739601,
-0.34003713726997375,
-0.3484385907649994,
0.7148813009262085,
0.17564770579338074,
-0.3249388337135315,
0.15719661116600037,
-0.043922532349824905,
-0.01591544598340988,
0.5146016478538513,
0.19324891269207,
0.36910417675971985,
0.09719444066286087,
0.16167007386684418,
0.4007398784160614,
-0.8601841330528259,
0.16924302279949188,
0.6625282168388367,
0.007240054197609425,
0.6457192897796631,
0.266255259513855,
0.6484194993972778,
0.42670491337776184,
0.17156551778316498,
-0.6751284599304199,
0.5553500652313232,
0.15376240015029907,
-0.4994400143623352,
-0.09826552867889404,
-0.6696082949638367,
-0.8313709497451782,
0.15699678659439087,
-0.6173359751701355,
-0.8604497313499451,
0.15474671125411987,
0.27793654799461365,
-0.377652645111084,
0.09191344678401947,
-1.1995543241500854,
0.31207340955734253,
-0.5640837550163269,
-0.3159455955028534,
-0.5046179294586182,
-0.40722256898880005,
0.5271115899085999,
-0.3649010956287384,
0.8198176026344299,
0.25345900654792786,
-0.040981706231832504,
0.6211736798286438,
-0.9096139073371887,
0.991034209728241,
0.07047459483146667,
-0.15455497801303864,
0.7970753908157349,
0.03241220861673355,
0.9161485433578491,
-0.08774455636739731,
-0.13737814128398895,
0.3767075538635254,
-0.3666226267814636,
-0.3277375102043152,
-0.8405171632766724,
1.1038755178451538,
-0.9608047604560852,
-0.4480535686016083,
-0.5794728398323059,
-0.5281882882118225,
-0.38548892736434937,
0.18404318392276764,
0.37334081530570984,
0.27101942896842957,
0.22009076178073883,
0.30685701966285706,
0.20906409621238708,
0.08583768457174301,
0.09977987408638,
0.49167150259017944,
-0.24467402696609497,
-0.5694960951805115,
0.7738043665885925,
0.08985716849565506,
0.4158712923526764,
0.6038541793823242,
0.5054097771644592,
-0.38649481534957886,
-0.3679214417934418,
0.24523980915546417,
-0.023512210696935654,
-0.6932801008224487,
-0.3803302049636841,
-0.6214207410812378,
-0.18232692778110504,
-0.47976234555244446,
-0.40002894401550293,
-0.3591406047344208,
-0.02873421460390091,
-0.11939097195863724,
0.0012096326099708676,
0.6713917851448059,
0.21332167088985443,
0.01878267712891102,
0.46830427646636963,
-0.8752724528312683,
0.3533453345298767,
0.3944476246833801,
0.3969745934009552,
0.19309170544147491,
-0.1129617691040039,
-0.1680362969636917,
0.087642602622509,
-0.12124663591384888,
-0.7002607583999634,
0.18269318342208862,
0.04890843853354454,
0.5157179236412048,
0.6331437230110168,
0.5255603194236755,
0.8895304203033447,
0.12725745141506195,
0.6909396052360535,
0.6561421751976013,
-0.8519750237464905,
0.6328381299972534,
-0.3517451882362366,
0.06835509091615677,
0.35497286915779114,
0.353063702583313,
-0.3668506145477295,
-0.3472301959991455,
-0.8650696873664856,
-0.9439492225646973,
0.46182724833488464,
0.16224227845668793,
-0.45231297612190247,
0.03895088657736778,
-0.21429216861724854,
-0.14739392697811127,
0.05276889726519585,
-0.24927625060081482,
-0.31660783290863037,
0.06861352175474167,
-0.07555103302001953,
-0.26671648025512695,
-0.025251520797610283,
-0.5205823183059692,
0.2058330774307251,
0.7118935585021973,
-0.012678341940045357,
0.143136128783226,
0.056861765682697296,
-0.1450267732143402,
0.07955002784729004,
0.20672300457954407,
0.2166242152452469,
0.5321938991546631,
-0.34133782982826233,
0.275664359331131,
0.2883848547935486,
-0.31607329845428467,
-0.1064736470580101,
-0.2084541767835617,
-0.36564111709594727,
-0.38175100088119507,
0.5557960271835327,
0.4179477393627167,
0.18857590854167938,
-0.9273852705955505,
0.4200422465801239,
0.06570275872945786,
-0.06503237783908844,
-0.510819137096405,
0.08833704888820648,
-0.04123814031481743,
-0.006078985054045916,
0.43646377325057983,
0.11310407519340515,
0.2036833018064499,
-0.7401448488235474,
-0.10944084823131561,
0.5975486636161804,
-0.1684534102678299,
-0.12839996814727783,
0.30530938506126404,
0.41458097100257874,
-0.1643492728471756,
0.4907096326351166,
0.0746094360947609,
-0.5687733888626099,
0.9195250868797302,
0.8269990086555481,
0.7361430525779724,
0.11538565158843994,
-0.18380261957645416,
0.1545426994562149,
0.2969415783882141,
-0.034151967614889145,
0.24817124009132385,
-0.06126038730144501,
-0.9063950181007385,
-0.26815858483314514,
-0.38367390632629395,
-0.4671911597251892,
0.28096306324005127,
-0.3808676302433014,
0.40330201387405396,
-0.6947284936904907,
0.00960087776184082,
-0.013618014752864838,
-0.188667893409729,
-0.7397772669792175,
0.27551984786987305,
0.009464893490076065,
1.0508594512939453,
-1.2178722620010376,
0.08515286445617676,
0.7785279750823975,
-0.11631900072097778,
-0.6901611685752869,
-0.40439051389694214,
0.35289615392684937,
-0.9636866450309753,
0.38183891773223877,
-0.04774076119065285,
-0.18024274706840515,
-0.4498942792415619,
-0.2116447240114212,
-0.8146721720695496,
0.9751831293106079,
0.20943059027194977,
-0.6228998899459839,
0.6184711456298828,
-0.021419335156679153,
0.6592130661010742,
-0.3903672993183136,
0.4397919476032257,
0.6001819372177124,
0.3378993272781372,
0.21444007754325867,
-0.6876367926597595,
0.00001149707350123208,
0.05754406005144119,
-0.29290831089019775,
0.4899277985095978,
-0.9571429491043091,
0.43656522035598755,
-0.2536672055721283,
-0.30180686712265015,
-0.41582557559013367,
0.7606982588768005,
0.2466154545545578,
0.6945178508758545,
0.9566140174865723,
0.6192988157272339,
0.855072557926178,
0.18608660995960236,
1.1743321418762207,
-0.5334476232528687,
0.275594025850296,
1.0880745649337769,
-0.37064599990844727,
0.6131523847579956,
0.437467098236084,
-0.3185713589191437,
0.48209434747695923,
0.4620405435562134,
0.3706618845462799,
0.5478951334953308,
-0.28508883714675903,
-0.57087641954422,
-0.6311525702476501,
-0.48654496669769287,
-0.4200383126735687,
0.3225909471511841,
0.539174497127533,
-0.21577467024326324,
-0.25032180547714233,
-0.2409137487411499,
-0.12808774411678314,
0.07692945748567581,
-0.5243069529533386,
0.9462388157844543,
0.13548444211483002,
-0.770203709602356,
0.5683705806732178,
-0.3518275320529938,
0.556550145149231,
-0.6895112991333008,
0.32112422585487366,
0.06817255914211273,
0.4138393700122833,
-0.6255488991737366,
-0.5467101335525513,
0.2982787489891052,
0.1331397444009781,
-0.35953089594841003,
-0.2587338387966156,
0.5482409596443176,
0.07741435617208481,
-0.5481674075126648,
0.5609315633773804,
0.2723594009876251,
-0.05644533410668373,
-0.14432068169116974,
-0.174752876162529,
0.07399342209100723,
-0.148538276553154,
0.47552821040153503,
0.44082945585250854,
0.37445586919784546,
-0.3197510540485382,
0.8790407180786133,
0.9174153804779053,
0.22988474369049072,
-0.006177701987326145,
0.03852832689881325,
0.9102851152420044,
-0.4225315451622009,
-1.0539995431900024,
-0.6669595241546631,
0.16803285479545593,
-0.2912627160549164,
-0.030348340049386024,
0.7605786919593811,
0.7969454526901245,
0.3147720396518707,
-0.03522269427776337,
0.9993014931678772,
-0.09394846856594086,
0.4143371284008026,
-0.4982796609401703,
0.04616225138306618,
-0.38689523935317993,
0.5838915109634399,
-0.06730997562408447,
-0.6367805600166321,
-0.3221868574619293,
0.08012671023607254,
-0.5779229402542114,
-0.415321946144104,
0.6372528076171875,
0.821958601474762,
0.042223475873470306,
0.4385049641132355,
-0.03430048003792763,
0.2712503969669342,
0.530737578868866,
0.5922417640686035,
0.9505661129951477,
-0.2437591552734375,
0.8242276310920715,
-0.3878876268863678,
-0.6938803791999817,
-0.5750677585601807,
-1.0807057619094849,
-0.3739304542541504,
-0.36176207661628723,
-0.39264923334121704,
-0.32951468229293823,
-0.19371885061264038,
0.8959513306617737,
0.6653140783309937,
-0.8755165338516235,
-0.12639789283275604,
-0.38745516538619995,
0.43060001730918884,
-0.6986053586006165,
-0.2576011121273041,
0.3443194627761841,
-0.4833698272705078,
-0.1074867770075798,
0.35283002257347107,
0.19827717542648315,
-0.1533409059047699,
0.007213145960122347,
0.11329234391450882,
0.014291130006313324,
-0.09108548611402512,
0.6477287411689758,
0.22861887514591217,
-0.2526666522026062,
-0.23903575539588928,
-0.10867593437433243,
0.015683533623814583,
-0.17306865751743317,
0.8407777547836304,
-0.7245622277259827,
0.47599369287490845,
0.8291314244270325,
0.7397172451019287,
0.22358760237693787,
0.13135339319705963,
0.4308701753616333,
-0.6924010515213013,
0.36790594458580017,
0.16303643584251404,
0.6164543628692627,
0.2902941107749939,
-0.7354300618171692,
0.18199604749679565,
0.35219985246658325,
-0.42742618918418884,
-0.6379084587097168,
0.2327767312526703,
-1.1283433437347412,
-0.12681889533996582,
1.1404755115509033,
0.09702663123607635,
-0.1515243798494339,
-0.18048076331615448,
0.05115940421819687,
-0.14722830057144165,
-0.5919961929321289,
1.0727860927581787,
0.46591541171073914,
-0.4509620666503906,
0.15747901797294617,
0.011334477923810482,
0.07811141014099121,
0.3041900098323822,
-1.1038398742675781,
0.08999965339899063,
0.5649648904800415,
-0.015806905925273895,
0.7941992878913879,
0.32595688104629517,
0.14634336531162262,
0.26660677790641785,
0.3671010434627533,
-0.12112873792648315,
0.0715637281537056,
-0.4334559440612793,
-0.09719768911600113,
0.47689497470855713,
-0.24458974599838257,
-0.39407551288604736
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06448v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06448v2
|
Unsupervised Real-Time Hallucination Detection based on the Internal States of Large Language Models
| 2024-03-11T05:51:03 | 2024-06-10T05:48:30 |
Weihang Su, Changyue Wang, Qingyao Ai, Yiran HU, Zhijing Wu, Yujia Zhou, Yiqun Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Hallucinations in large language models (LLMs) refer to the phenomenon of
LLMs producing responses that are coherent yet factually inaccurate. This issue
undermines the effectiveness of LLMs in practical applications, necessitating
research into detecting and mitigating hallucinations of LLMs. Previous studies
have mainly concentrated on post-processing techniques for hallucination
detection, which tend to be computationally intensive and limited in
effectiveness due to their separation from the LLM's inference process. To
overcome these limitations, we introduce MIND, an unsupervised training
framework that leverages the internal states of LLMs for real-time
hallucination detection without requiring manual annotations. Additionally, we
present HELM, a new benchmark for evaluating hallucination detection across
multiple LLMs, featuring diverse LLM outputs and the internal states of LLMs
during their inference process. Our experiments demonstrate that MIND
outperforms existing state-of-the-art methods in hallucination detection.
|
[
-0.592473030090332,
-0.850551426410675,
0.8313041925430298,
0.15878844261169434,
-0.4184846878051758,
0.08678333461284637,
-0.5877705216407776,
-0.6814975738525391,
0.4299730360507965,
0.5044487714767456,
-0.7898183465003967,
-0.4945536255836487,
-0.45275619626045227,
0.09788542985916138,
-0.5343905687332153,
0.5054647326469421,
0.09041231870651245,
0.18986336886882782,
-0.3023482859134674,
0.045826129615306854,
-0.3617337644100189,
-0.7380815148353577,
-0.43596723675727844,
-0.5201769471168518,
0.24495913088321686,
0.14323019981384277,
0.3212132751941681,
0.13898564875125885,
0.29478973150253296,
0.2090543508529663,
0.18029369413852692,
0.4943189024925232,
-0.40587666630744934,
0.4418303072452545,
0.020316990092396736,
-0.335489958524704,
-0.2533953785896301,
-0.18169517815113068,
0.4444715976715088,
0.5528072714805603,
-0.24622614681720734,
0.0790996178984642,
0.03412525728344917,
0.5550171732902527,
-0.8780247569084167,
0.10583676397800446,
-0.7999380230903625,
0.3810965120792389,
-0.1581827849149704,
-0.2402338981628418,
-0.5667457580566406,
-0.18453112244606018,
-0.04555604234337807,
-0.34341853857040405,
0.2798750698566437,
0.16498692333698273,
0.4166397750377655,
0.583858072757721,
0.13409744203090668,
-0.2324167788028717,
-0.6752845644950867,
0.6412425637245178,
-0.6068314909934998,
0.8454416990280151,
0.34699344635009766,
0.22834454476833344,
-0.24925874173641205,
-0.5902979969978333,
-1.0685288906097412,
-0.22607044875621796,
-0.006301249843090773,
0.026001842692494392,
-0.07774269580841064,
0.06317900121212006,
0.30148059129714966,
0.2671966850757599,
-0.4973897337913513,
0.23549221456050873,
0.1604306846857071,
-0.4572412371635437,
0.22438277304172516,
0.0527474470436573,
0.18323497474193573,
-0.06806037575006485,
-0.16109244525432587,
-0.1733226329088211,
-0.5101548433303833,
-0.37117889523506165,
0.12550900876522064,
0.10525484383106232,
0.062490660697221756,
0.488271564245224,
-0.15390737354755402,
0.5031150579452515,
0.0502488911151886,
-0.20368030667304993,
0.3283107280731201,
0.32352307438850403,
-0.38363757729530334,
0.3909618556499481,
0.7670860290527344,
0.3054986894130707,
0.48526841402053833,
-0.7259260416030884,
-0.35927873849868774,
0.5364834666252136,
0.4697943329811096,
-0.7063711881637573,
-0.21470992267131805,
0.4678637683391571,
-0.29671621322631836,
-0.2159828096628189,
0.014166721142828465,
-0.7045052647590637,
-0.8688815832138062,
-0.34888333082199097,
0.4098185896873474,
-0.30939069390296936,
-0.595847487449646,
0.2837217450141907,
0.13910989463329315,
0.3540394902229309,
0.07051777094602585,
-0.6481432318687439,
0.41773930191993713,
0.6706331372261047,
0.8936083912849426,
-0.6352933645248413,
-0.29709264636039734,
-0.6304640173912048,
0.020410552620887756,
-0.5427234768867493,
1.2551934719085693,
-0.329875648021698,
-0.1799079030752182,
0.006786366458982229,
0.13724537193775177,
0.14968805015087128,
-0.8248913884162903,
0.4719531834125519,
-0.40031084418296814,
-0.1719822734594345,
-0.2861839830875397,
-0.6059412956237793,
-0.2553452253341675,
0.1553821861743927,
-0.4245113432407379,
0.941737174987793,
-0.04162399843335152,
-0.6681324243545532,
0.5168176889419556,
-0.2950226366519928,
-0.3500646650791168,
0.07660890370607376,
-0.4434909522533417,
-0.42223528027534485,
0.3748225271701813,
0.34809115529060364,
0.6675571203231812,
-0.22459015250205994,
0.5897043347358704,
-0.45182251930236816,
-0.7788619995117188,
0.3878194987773895,
-0.33587121963500977,
0.5095095038414001,
-0.06113448739051819,
-0.6030332446098328,
0.46651357412338257,
-0.7220366597175598,
-0.044752102345228195,
0.0953497663140297,
0.09863536059856415,
-0.19419147074222565,
0.13549844920635223,
0.05027605965733528,
-0.00621033227071166,
-0.1430279165506363,
-0.7061939835548401,
0.0895778015255928,
-0.5261766314506531,
0.10961010307073593,
0.7102548480033875,
-0.010634029284119606,
0.18382537364959717,
-0.186885267496109,
0.18470324575901031,
0.1815933883190155,
-0.0593239888548851,
0.25062793493270874,
-0.22075699269771576,
-0.9324086904525757,
-0.4956277012825012,
-0.2870546877384186,
0.4850713312625885,
-0.49276259541511536,
0.706804096698761,
-0.16970980167388916,
-0.3543330729007721,
-0.5740313529968262,
-0.14935459196567535,
0.29756981134414673,
0.581302285194397,
0.48765847086906433,
-0.22964826226234436,
-0.7799960374832153,
-0.8729422688484192,
-0.34317901730537415,
0.014858233742415905,
-0.2531469166278839,
-0.03264794126152992,
0.5492430329322815,
-0.5076786279678345,
0.837465763092041,
-0.5504807233810425,
-0.5940114259719849,
-0.1852838546037674,
0.14528021216392517,
0.04320407658815384,
0.2147897630929947,
0.13486348092556,
-0.49104973673820496,
-0.09770826250314713,
-0.2360212802886963,
-1.2114334106445312,
-0.2553316652774811,
-0.13058097660541534,
0.055581431835889816,
0.3501609265804291,
0.6980916261672974,
-0.6107798218727112,
0.41365811228752136,
0.3335217535495758,
-0.14490386843681335,
0.8147285580635071,
-0.06920452415943146,
0.13699260354042053,
-0.8073251843452454,
-0.15204016864299774,
-0.1937871277332306,
-0.11738408356904984,
-0.4472179114818573,
-0.02848171629011631,
0.12528595328330994,
0.19365951418876648,
-0.3152875006198883,
0.5329763293266296,
-0.6558887362480164,
-0.460465669631958,
-0.42945829033851624,
0.2376335710287094,
-0.33375149965286255,
0.6398646235466003,
0.40298202633857727,
0.7588902115821838,
0.7618983387947083,
-0.7015029788017273,
0.563531219959259,
0.07234010845422745,
-0.7368547320365906,
0.6754008531570435,
-0.24074293673038483,
0.29423198103904724,
-0.24703095853328705,
0.3637993633747101,
-0.8617630004882812,
-0.3833906054496765,
0.41677188873291016,
-0.17142939567565918,
0.10195855051279068,
0.18444451689720154,
-0.6652606129646301,
-0.2837595045566559,
-0.32276347279548645,
0.22955965995788574,
0.3650566637516022,
-0.7609691023826599,
0.493582546710968,
0.5909168124198914,
0.42106571793556213,
-0.39841288328170776,
-0.8515239357948303,
0.22412419319152832,
-0.13698641955852509,
-0.21799130737781525,
0.3535197675228119,
-0.17466548085212708,
-0.5223008990287781,
-0.2035217583179474,
-0.43571537733078003,
-0.05316825583577156,
-0.010702031664550304,
0.5163399577140808,
0.03239844739437103,
-0.015517056919634342,
0.17236857116222382,
-0.075384221971035,
-0.036820538341999054,
0.2864254117012024,
-0.42639705538749695,
0.793674647808075,
0.07241936773061752,
-0.6358737945556641,
-0.6871922612190247,
0.1508050262928009,
0.7051892876625061,
-0.10232686251401901,
0.6831547617912292,
0.6178918480873108,
-0.9138492941856384,
-0.5763238668441772,
-0.8364740014076233,
-0.6786418557167053,
-0.43531444668769836,
0.3440578579902649,
-0.42415618896484375,
-0.6135260462760925,
0.5233083963394165,
0.028725994750857353,
-0.06377024948596954,
0.05633780360221863,
0.6417407393455505,
0.027404317632317543,
0.7951688766479492,
0.3076993525028229,
-0.042113982141017914,
0.09614136070013046,
-0.17524711787700653,
0.39586395025253296,
-1.030488133430481,
-0.5087510347366333,
-0.04930683225393295,
-0.268555223941803,
-0.2785120904445648,
-0.5435010194778442,
0.37980765104293823,
-0.12718985974788666,
-0.12756188213825226,
0.06298039108514786,
-0.8200826644897461,
0.5171410441398621,
0.22849754989147186,
0.35633713006973267,
0.3691835105419159,
0.17708425223827362,
-0.24788103997707367,
-0.2686082422733307,
-0.2897481322288513,
-0.33723530173301697,
0.9701828360557556,
0.11186983436346054,
0.7849346995353699,
-0.12172196805477142,
0.566810131072998,
0.553466260433197,
0.5059770345687866,
-1.0023421049118042,
0.709452748298645,
0.05883361026644707,
-0.36158934235572815,
-0.4208565056324005,
-0.1609710305929184,
-0.5465983152389526,
0.5949111580848694,
-0.3976091742515564,
-0.8860592842102051,
0.0024704444222152233,
-0.12909947335720062,
-0.3236336410045624,
0.75831139087677,
-0.26682716608047485,
0.6087378263473511,
-0.21073667705059052,
-0.29706740379333496,
-0.334095299243927,
-0.24177876114845276,
0.5713835954666138,
-0.24731676280498505,
0.1519317328929901,
-0.14618231356143951,
0.16183005273342133,
0.7599573135375977,
-0.05795755609869957,
0.9477311372756958,
-0.19931288063526154,
-0.3880583643913269,
0.15838952362537384,
0.2351600080728531,
0.5053324699401855,
0.08163587749004364,
0.16715575754642487,
0.33424362540245056,
-0.37807944416999817,
0.07545144855976105,
-0.38211891055107117,
0.9493574500083923,
-0.4708877503871918,
-0.4986231327056885,
-0.5553180575370789,
-0.7552041411399841,
-0.5575295090675354,
0.046954117715358734,
0.4787343144416809,
0.37146851420402527,
-0.22002732753753662,
0.01835988089442253,
1.0221556425094604,
-0.2593638598918915,
0.3406415581703186,
0.45804741978645325,
-0.4326827824115753,
-0.25559908151626587,
0.8605891466140747,
0.12421806156635284,
-0.19868256151676178,
0.32271841168403625,
0.001234535127878189,
-0.4519738554954529,
-0.6028188467025757,
-0.33180537819862366,
0.4587070941925049,
-0.7205392718315125,
-0.005375070031732321,
-0.9782022833824158,
-0.17646515369415283,
-0.5039544701576233,
0.02043260633945465,
-0.47636470198631287,
0.017004845663905144,
-0.255244642496109,
-0.13835041224956512,
0.21333527565002441,
0.7418689131736755,
-0.0011911222245544195,
0.17067337036132812,
-0.3906778395175934,
0.8646572828292847,
0.3635309636592865,
0.43065914511680603,
0.07432365417480469,
-0.4769338071346283,
-0.01632433757185936,
-0.07935823500156403,
-0.017288675531744957,
-0.8758328557014465,
0.35052281618118286,
-0.11185506731271744,
0.5611337423324585,
0.6480019688606262,
0.20404604077339172,
0.7626696825027466,
-0.39146289229393005,
0.47159504890441895,
0.07550028711557388,
-0.9457517266273499,
0.1878899484872818,
0.069066621363163,
0.23091347515583038,
0.307646244764328,
0.1558389961719513,
-0.6162005662918091,
-0.7021386027336121,
-0.17577092349529266,
-0.5672614574432373,
0.4578990340232849,
-0.1386527568101883,
-0.3190593123435974,
-0.10470247268676758,
0.2243186980485916,
0.32164743542671204,
0.26353946328163147,
-0.7655927538871765,
-0.05934545770287514,
0.06528037786483765,
-0.08022197335958481,
-0.002143262652680278,
-0.34672245383262634,
0.05863369256258011,
-0.2657025456428528,
0.47686007618904114,
-0.08036015927791595,
0.3936384618282318,
0.266003280878067,
-0.585185170173645,
-0.21548032760620117,
-0.10008128732442856,
0.5621703267097473,
0.6699533462524414,
-0.3818223178386688,
0.42951253056526184,
0.3980913758277893,
-0.5450421571731567,
0.16125543415546417,
-0.34448036551475525,
-0.06334303319454193,
0.04631869122385979,
0.5474034547805786,
0.7422813177108765,
0.4149046242237091,
-0.8545483946800232,
0.3833722174167633,
-0.048946429044008255,
-0.17630192637443542,
-0.6979566812515259,
0.093533456325531,
0.09832550585269928,
0.35461369156837463,
0.41055506467819214,
0.01769717037677765,
0.12048696726560593,
-0.46177929639816284,
0.4414835274219513,
0.6085459589958191,
-0.4819980263710022,
-0.2886010706424713,
0.7699959874153137,
-0.14435812830924988,
-0.25859561562538147,
0.6743279695510864,
-0.09026677161455154,
-0.5439826250076294,
0.4005734324455261,
0.636800229549408,
1.3056739568710327,
-0.20883364975452423,
-0.01032929215580225,
0.20827341079711914,
0.4910734295845032,
-0.2567416727542877,
0.3812260329723358,
-0.17768840491771698,
-0.9999276995658875,
-0.3308050036430359,
-0.8264216184616089,
-0.46731120347976685,
0.6785605549812317,
-0.6684521436691284,
0.019857043400406837,
-0.41430774331092834,
-0.06305291503667831,
-0.29815009236335754,
-0.3639545142650604,
-0.49840089678764343,
0.2169884890317917,
0.467061847448349,
0.6707057356834412,
-0.6758875250816345,
0.8780269622802734,
0.39017418026924133,
0.0014178483979776502,
-0.11685125529766083,
0.5327746868133545,
0.11843894422054291,
-0.743384838104248,
0.4383077919483185,
0.5252343416213989,
-0.7083505392074585,
-0.03195382282137871,
-0.5458382964134216,
-0.40674448013305664,
0.7173713445663452,
0.4672616124153137,
-0.6456688046455383,
0.10079582780599594,
-0.06707055866718292,
0.41349107027053833,
-0.323699951171875,
-0.030493710190057755,
0.7234328389167786,
0.4832626283168793,
-0.2533314526081085,
-0.5801674127578735,
0.1491154134273529,
0.23413538932800293,
-0.34404245018959045,
0.15384051203727722,
-0.26641103625297546,
0.6415809988975525,
-0.3065206706523895,
-0.45500800013542175,
-0.2496272474527359,
0.9209925532341003,
0.476655513048172,
0.21981991827487946,
0.7638875842094421,
0.7106755971908569,
0.9440196752548218,
-0.07963510602712631,
0.720868706703186,
-0.40913891792297363,
0.08281223475933075,
1.0328549146652222,
-0.5209447145462036,
0.8040519952774048,
0.548504650592804,
-0.04217234253883362,
0.36579808592796326,
0.6153450608253479,
0.1075245663523674,
0.5213531851768494,
0.4467609226703644,
-0.39584365487098694,
-0.5043469071388245,
-0.0117636788636446,
-0.26455193758010864,
0.3120003044605255,
0.5320882201194763,
0.17179453372955322,
0.012594782747328281,
0.3984659016132355,
-0.004784471355378628,
0.06871312111616135,
-0.1724807173013687,
0.696955144405365,
0.1355878710746765,
-0.728481113910675,
0.859342634677887,
-0.358929306268692,
1.0359495878219604,
-0.43097564578056335,
-0.1321733146905899,
-0.30443161725997925,
0.336229532957077,
-0.26075634360313416,
-0.5881606340408325,
0.31296929717063904,
0.1291225254535675,
-0.08167080581188202,
-0.07966506481170654,
0.6394385695457458,
-0.3532973825931549,
-0.34699827432632446,
0.7418144345283508,
0.44897666573524475,
0.4944433867931366,
-0.6363212466239929,
-0.17541411519050598,
0.24180348217487335,
-0.22213728725910187,
-0.3106765151023865,
0.2531157433986664,
0.4404037296772003,
-0.09140370786190033,
0.9341937899589539,
0.6558162569999695,
0.343485027551651,
-0.07079105824232101,
0.3253178894519806,
0.7250357866287231,
-0.6727981567382812,
-0.41329750418663025,
-0.9881587624549866,
-0.09061598777770996,
-0.10249058157205582,
-0.11220826953649521,
0.6347180008888245,
0.5387105345726013,
0.9893540740013123,
-0.29840952157974243,
0.7807890772819519,
0.28351911902427673,
0.5053821206092834,
-0.5118570923805237,
0.9199040532112122,
-0.6155967116355896,
0.28218454122543335,
-0.19912560284137726,
-1.0818907022476196,
-0.4401622414588928,
0.8904679417610168,
-0.024917636066675186,
-0.22624848783016205,
0.9407128691673279,
0.8964347839355469,
-0.14092448353767395,
0.09965019673109055,
0.5519305467605591,
0.5003604292869568,
0.07179460674524307,
0.3523000180721283,
0.8205122351646423,
0.08741936832666397,
0.21637092530727386,
-0.37817978858947754,
-0.20186267793178558,
-0.19189707934856415,
-0.7161279916763306,
-1.0636342763900757,
-0.6538450121879578,
-0.16264422237873077,
-0.2111186683177948,
0.009082774631679058,
0.9341087937355042,
0.5903252363204956,
-1.1581693887710571,
-0.5022856593132019,
-0.14506033062934875,
0.02951406128704548,
-0.4935038685798645,
-0.23682832717895508,
0.4203025996685028,
-0.40100929141044617,
-0.5865830183029175,
0.764153003692627,
0.49769845604896545,
-0.16226737201213837,
-0.7430891394615173,
-0.06051700934767723,
-0.03178049996495247,
0.053971029818058014,
0.7476189732551575,
-0.10916417837142944,
-1.053002119064331,
-0.36813440918922424,
-0.001111700083129108,
-0.08247540891170502,
0.020783977583050728,
0.8209002614021301,
-1.0362942218780518,
0.4321647584438324,
0.3380374014377594,
0.535945475101471,
0.4796806275844574,
-0.3764283061027527,
0.22735755145549774,
-0.4953598082065582,
0.36413198709487915,
0.21643607318401337,
0.36611077189445496,
0.43614962697029114,
-0.30988213419914246,
0.5089573264122009,
0.5635629892349243,
-0.3690279424190521,
-1.1381150484085083,
0.18169982731342316,
-0.8107886910438538,
-0.6554564237594604,
1.008384346961975,
0.33109384775161743,
-0.26955729722976685,
-0.23280243575572968,
-0.19319812953472137,
0.49210384488105774,
-0.13570718467235565,
1.097997784614563,
0.758882462978363,
-0.26060715317726135,
-0.023719582706689835,
-0.6288151144981384,
0.5778194069862366,
0.19279421865940094,
-0.9103476405143738,
0.4684921205043793,
0.47104570269584656,
0.04687384143471718,
0.04265478625893593,
0.6545951962471008,
0.14684166014194489,
-0.006835606414824724,
-0.07669142633676529,
0.4781314730644226,
0.05439354106783867,
-0.6120487451553345,
-0.12485410273075104,
0.23048646748065948,
-0.3056281507015228,
-0.2855460047721863
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.12999v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.12999v1
|
Prompt Selection and Augmentation for Few Examples Code Generation in Large Language Model and its Application in Robotics Control
| 2024-03-11T04:13:29 | 2024-03-11T04:13:29 |
On Tai Wu, Frodo Kin Sun Chan, Zunhao Zhang, Yan Nei Law, Benny Drescher, Edmond Shiao Bun Lai
|
cs.RO
|
cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Few-shot prompting and step-by-step reasoning have enhanced the capabilities
of Large Language Models (LLMs) in tackling complex tasks including code
generation. In this paper, we introduce a prompt selection and augmentation
algorithm aimed at improving mathematical reasoning and robot arm operations.
Our approach incorporates a multi-stage example augmentation scheme combined
with an example selection scheme. This algorithm improves LLM performance by
selecting a set of examples that increase diversity, minimize redundancy, and
increase relevance to the question. When combined with the Program-of-Thought
prompting, our algorithm demonstrates an improvement in performance on the
GSM8K and SVAMP benchmarks, with increases of 0.3% and 1.1% respectively.
Furthermore, in simulated tabletop environments, our algorithm surpasses the
Code-as-Policies approach by achieving a 3.4% increase in successful task
completions and a decrease of over 70% in the number of examples used. Its
ability to discard examples that contribute little to solving the problem
reduces the inferencing time of an LLM-powered robotics system. This algorithm
also offers important benefits for industrial process automation by
streamlining the development and deployment process, reducing manual
programming effort, and enhancing code reusability.
|
[
-0.5979617834091187,
-0.8933517932891846,
0.8151317834854126,
0.25510215759277344,
-0.44034016132354736,
-0.10208811610937119,
-0.09528618305921555,
-0.20206859707832336,
-0.14531797170639038,
0.6544248461723328,
-0.8803727626800537,
-0.4714800715446472,
-0.29403188824653625,
0.3094857335090637,
0.10940766334533691,
0.7141092419624329,
0.09074874967336655,
-0.07054412364959717,
-0.11438151448965073,
0.025350458920001984,
-0.53022700548172,
-0.21156980097293854,
-0.6494608521461487,
-0.574081540107727,
0.28767943382263184,
0.6640874743461609,
0.6793050169944763,
0.590840756893158,
0.5450200438499451,
0.31870219111442566,
-0.24317339062690735,
0.5640009045600891,
-0.034397050738334656,
0.12287914007902145,
0.04296664893627167,
-0.5165446400642395,
-0.3027009069919586,
-0.2382427155971527,
0.4612216055393219,
0.6032732129096985,
0.029367618262767792,
0.07085227966308594,
-0.05152316391468048,
0.6639273762702942,
-0.46071192622184753,
0.12979258596897125,
-0.4669019281864166,
0.030297959223389626,
0.25741592049598694,
-0.517747700214386,
-0.4482133686542511,
-0.5580158829689026,
-0.25110575556755066,
-0.4940503239631653,
-0.21509212255477905,
0.16183416545391083,
0.45118388533592224,
0.31421396136283875,
-0.1304193139076233,
-0.29092249274253845,
-0.5186398029327393,
0.8620421886444092,
-0.8670791983604431,
-0.010641980916261673,
0.2625865936279297,
0.2729448974132538,
-0.614348828792572,
-0.4216584265232086,
-0.8274903893470764,
-0.5574325919151306,
0.023253003135323524,
0.08130421489477158,
-0.2906431257724762,
0.38222289085388184,
0.8747071623802185,
-0.1552903652191162,
-0.5913852453231812,
0.2641097903251648,
-0.36894553899765015,
-0.15795578062534332,
0.3402695059776306,
0.06020103394985199,
0.2691921591758728,
-0.31872040033340454,
-0.11302588135004044,
-0.36130499839782715,
-0.9654712080955505,
0.13940657675266266,
0.6053937077522278,
0.5347931385040283,
-0.047534093260765076,
0.7304140329360962,
-0.49286600947380066,
0.8266977071762085,
-0.05421663075685501,
-0.3811168968677521,
0.47624486684799194,
-0.3134767711162567,
-0.05051884800195694,
-0.19499856233596802,
0.510624349117279,
0.35121625661849976,
0.2002418041229248,
0.4428877830505371,
-0.2751446068286896,
0.12969164550304413,
0.10560227930545807,
-0.7224026918411255,
-0.02946474589407444,
0.3221479058265686,
-0.4157520830631256,
-0.0818825215101242,
-0.06884653121232986,
-0.6954900622367859,
-0.30685678124427795,
-0.35538986325263977,
0.38177406787872314,
-0.34662413597106934,
0.19364847242832184,
0.11186075955629349,
-0.3027259409427643,
0.24740935862064362,
0.6474394202232361,
-0.5021727085113525,
-0.010889485478401184,
0.8052573204040527,
0.7547761797904968,
-0.046530745923519135,
-0.17879752814769745,
-1.0383431911468506,
-0.1884942501783371,
-0.559856116771698,
0.7834823131561279,
-0.7140442728996277,
-0.4795096516609192,
0.07457317411899567,
-0.21118900179862976,
0.41298967599868774,
-0.8029747009277344,
0.6026191115379333,
-0.6058664917945862,
0.19491305947303772,
0.09784740954637527,
-0.29435408115386963,
-0.24659164249897003,
0.18459852039813995,
-0.43538370728492737,
0.9942247271537781,
0.08716847002506256,
-0.1815594881772995,
0.38924339413642883,
-0.9187588691711426,
-0.5800804495811462,
0.1600726693868637,
-0.3463441729545593,
-0.5183386206626892,
-0.19961552321910858,
0.5787205696105957,
0.5535182952880859,
-0.009579303674399853,
-0.2402319312095642,
-0.31862324476242065,
-0.30261504650115967,
0.03769279271364212,
-0.20017054677009583,
0.6867483258247375,
0.3151395916938782,
-0.11096742749214172,
0.3423113524913788,
-0.5923638343811035,
0.2446242719888687,
0.01160785835236311,
-0.06789502501487732,
-0.10575959831476212,
-0.22495287656784058,
-0.33870360255241394,
0.5046605467796326,
0.2001129388809204,
-0.3087480366230011,
0.6021852493286133,
-0.6216636896133423,
0.1854524463415146,
0.6893377900123596,
0.3201901614665985,
0.6869774460792542,
-0.4118194282054901,
0.853111982345581,
-0.09907209128141403,
0.1036796048283577,
-0.6614494919776917,
-0.5828980207443237,
-0.47459182143211365,
-0.43863144516944885,
0.11005611717700958,
0.8565744757652283,
-1.3070250749588013,
0.6525909900665283,
0.24843411147594452,
-0.21348726749420166,
-0.257486492395401,
0.5208842754364014,
0.35749369859695435,
0.46511533856391907,
0.4385012090206146,
-0.05635623633861542,
-0.4006386399269104,
-0.8210156559944153,
0.18857111036777496,
-0.21497945487499237,
-0.3497193455696106,
0.2666836082935333,
0.39574745297431946,
-0.14740730822086334,
0.87026047706604,
-0.5090163946151733,
-0.010460983030498028,
-0.6458167433738708,
0.20557299256324768,
0.6658945083618164,
0.5555616617202759,
0.45104730129241943,
-0.4177195727825165,
-0.0721864402294159,
0.06921955943107605,
-0.44278910756111145,
-0.29939112067222595,
-0.4433461129665375,
-0.1829736828804016,
0.05924374237656593,
0.34435221552848816,
-0.6615801453590393,
0.34291160106658936,
0.32260966300964355,
0.1358649581670761,
0.38068675994873047,
-0.4341883361339569,
0.20395846664905548,
-0.9008123278617859,
-0.23689132928848267,
0.067526675760746,
-0.2650965452194214,
-0.4718988537788391,
0.22800135612487793,
-0.004954460542649031,
-0.1548662930727005,
-0.6144238710403442,
0.4250693917274475,
-0.3852793574333191,
-0.11903753131628036,
-0.6155685186386108,
0.31781989336013794,
-0.043809495866298676,
0.5047698616981506,
-0.07164209336042404,
0.9150441288948059,
0.5369561314582825,
-0.9047984480857849,
0.2770940959453583,
0.20891126990318298,
-0.4156034588813782,
0.2523188889026642,
-0.5044461488723755,
0.28417330980300903,
-0.1594262421131134,
0.286813884973526,
-0.9061372876167297,
-0.13693960011005402,
0.4245865046977997,
-0.28144511580467224,
0.05725736916065216,
-0.2676790654659271,
-0.5648247003555298,
-0.7082641124725342,
-0.4556009769439697,
0.013305354863405228,
0.9674320220947266,
-0.7003822326660156,
0.5972217321395874,
0.06848713755607605,
-0.4043482840061188,
-0.43154487013816833,
-0.3764677941799164,
-0.19858187437057495,
-0.08481945842504501,
-0.43715572357177734,
-0.026167381554841995,
-0.2724989056587219,
-0.16723547875881195,
-0.38876524567604065,
-0.3172643184661865,
0.052456844598054886,
0.10588768869638443,
0.003513898467645049,
0.5632140636444092,
0.004075177945196629,
-0.030295079573988914,
0.5666773319244385,
-0.24777358770370483,
-0.011074841022491455,
-0.12978892028331757,
0.7637730836868286,
0.25204142928123474,
-0.6589792966842651,
-0.6497452259063721,
0.23122535645961761,
0.1819496601819992,
-0.07344137877225876,
0.0977526307106018,
0.3664886951446533,
-0.22027182579040527,
-0.7088979482650757,
-0.32377779483795166,
-0.5966578722000122,
-0.5923051238059998,
0.37575429677963257,
-0.4180663824081421,
-0.8568052649497986,
0.3452761769294739,
-0.4556407630443573,
0.2991889715194702,
0.012854631058871746,
0.5420641899108887,
-0.07539006322622299,
1.0394657850265503,
0.3208352029323578,
-0.050671860575675964,
0.783245325088501,
-0.19310630857944489,
0.30583804845809937,
-0.6772318482398987,
0.13058437407016754,
-0.7503235340118408,
-0.05497656762599945,
-0.4874754846096039,
-0.790928840637207,
0.5748308300971985,
0.1999521255493164,
-0.12170028686523438,
0.40723857283592224,
-0.5860657095909119,
0.7184083461761475,
0.4603272080421448,
0.3137214183807373,
0.26208826899528503,
0.048024192452430725,
-0.17668403685092926,
0.2898695170879364,
-0.8499393463134766,
-0.8077638149261475,
0.6972212195396423,
0.10816165059804916,
0.7704227566719055,
-0.08124483376741409,
0.8055655360221863,
0.5052347183227539,
-0.04075212404131889,
-0.8443999886512756,
0.8089177012443542,
0.06331922858953476,
-0.17528317868709564,
-0.3706349730491638,
-0.3837359547615051,
-0.8540198802947998,
0.20337191224098206,
-0.16465868055820465,
-0.6676571369171143,
0.09240533411502838,
0.3921283781528473,
-0.7626592516899109,
-0.05421575531363487,
-0.7848964333534241,
0.5468654036521912,
-0.05903574824333191,
-0.12651801109313965,
-0.46347835659980774,
-0.5048702359199524,
0.24987365305423737,
0.04093337059020996,
0.027801277115941048,
-0.17336799204349518,
-0.12091439217329025,
0.31481850147247314,
-0.2783876657485962,
0.5852561593055725,
-0.22105887532234192,
-0.06977030634880066,
0.6460913419723511,
0.005578760523349047,
1.048439860343933,
-0.07037375122308731,
-0.22653722763061523,
-0.12662622332572937,
-0.36684074997901917,
-0.2885422110557556,
-0.9188986420631409,
0.39225220680236816,
-0.47264549136161804,
-0.5800397992134094,
-0.10530903935432434,
-0.42163094878196716,
-0.26819631457328796,
0.023725086823105812,
-0.08139524608850479,
0.384611576795578,
0.4322032630443573,
0.18324795365333557,
0.5347984433174133,
-0.507202684879303,
0.7513498067855835,
0.2394523322582245,
-0.29010310769081116,
-0.3162323236465454,
0.7520468831062317,
-0.27320027351379395,
0.38108155131340027,
0.37796348333358765,
0.20387586951255798,
-0.26638051867485046,
-0.5754367709159851,
-0.6582214832305908,
-0.11875967681407928,
-0.784535825252533,
-0.5066605806350708,
-0.5466399788856506,
0.07099267840385437,
-0.27032271027565,
-0.40941834449768066,
-0.02111569233238697,
-0.5125834941864014,
-0.24136368930339813,
0.03932444751262665,
0.47466886043548584,
0.5243374705314636,
0.14007438719272614,
0.6380821466445923,
-0.8276016116142273,
0.7301623821258545,
0.34378382563591003,
0.06497756391763687,
-0.09482424706220627,
-0.5219457149505615,
-0.025210022926330566,
-0.014049503020942211,
-0.4398884177207947,
-0.6645078659057617,
0.2345961481332779,
-0.05716094374656677,
0.7359899878501892,
0.4942933917045593,
0.10490477085113525,
0.7169325351715088,
-0.5132501721382141,
0.7000481486320496,
0.23765763640403748,
-0.981704592704773,
0.6779648661613464,
-0.25834164023399353,
0.540562093257904,
0.36387431621551514,
0.028690265491604805,
-0.26708725094795227,
-0.4412040114402771,
-0.4321722984313965,
-0.7498548030853271,
0.7469074726104736,
0.11311548948287964,
0.2294541299343109,
0.08002544194459915,
0.18404114246368408,
0.055727142840623856,
0.24182161688804626,
-0.28986912965774536,
-0.19821153581142426,
0.22610880434513092,
-0.08140354603528976,
0.26549047231674194,
0.026054026558995247,
0.017121242359280586,
-0.05510185286402702,
0.7049722075462341,
-0.5188212394714355,
0.3339671790599823,
0.0013692241627722979,
-0.0991329625248909,
-0.09018588811159134,
0.5862767100334167,
0.9886046648025513,
0.615280032157898,
0.15474475920200348,
-0.31619152426719666,
0.4853362441062927,
-0.2401583343744278,
0.044020965695381165,
0.05313969776034355,
-0.3689859211444855,
-0.1351499706506729,
0.18344907462596893,
0.6920551061630249,
-0.2234516739845276,
-0.7364171743392944,
0.281025767326355,
0.47137391567230225,
-0.026606472209095955,
-0.037378426641225815,
0.46756595373153687,
-0.40893813967704773,
0.5215364098548889,
0.6250973343849182,
0.24475592374801636,
0.2678662836551666,
-0.30468693375587463,
0.3199700117111206,
0.5142411589622498,
0.2502502202987671,
0.10713553428649902,
0.16300252079963684,
0.16683344542980194,
-0.30862078070640564,
0.3980858325958252,
-0.6403732299804688,
-0.5480870008468628,
0.84218829870224,
0.49651631712913513,
0.7340018153190613,
0.10342302173376083,
0.21384352445602417,
0.44295990467071533,
0.5048921704292297,
-0.20559042692184448,
0.4069782495498657,
-0.1503848135471344,
-0.8910432457923889,
-0.9328513145446777,
-0.2911990284919739,
-0.7510977983474731,
-0.1000392884016037,
-0.2347279042005539,
0.45621541142463684,
-0.7398648262023926,
-0.18172718584537506,
-0.26982754468917847,
0.1278606653213501,
-0.5282981395721436,
-0.0445411317050457,
0.22825945913791656,
0.7345701456069946,
-0.7453821897506714,
0.8253054022789001,
0.6407627463340759,
-0.3421422839164734,
-0.7969406843185425,
-0.16986694931983948,
-0.1992015242576599,
-0.7606209516525269,
0.5227758884429932,
0.06382361054420471,
-0.26973915100097656,
-0.2354888916015625,
-0.6717223525047302,
-0.4053376615047455,
0.7687707543373108,
0.26923051476478577,
-0.6482642889022827,
0.2344442456960678,
-0.11197929084300995,
0.43825215101242065,
-0.4960376024246216,
0.5695540308952332,
0.5491499304771423,
0.5950577855110168,
0.2673453390598297,
-0.7967173457145691,
-0.0381866991519928,
-0.07027094811201096,
0.09080079942941666,
0.1735796183347702,
-0.4821028709411621,
0.5301772356033325,
-0.5186943411827087,
0.05987353250384331,
0.25985535979270935,
0.7267860174179077,
0.8869274258613586,
0.37510988116264343,
0.5846139192581177,
0.23941119015216827,
0.7500360608100891,
-0.0052198003977537155,
1.0585265159606934,
-0.27796241641044617,
-0.0423809178173542,
1.0563156604766846,
-0.5461263060569763,
0.6658309102058411,
0.4819472134113312,
-0.33539044857025146,
0.5451496243476868,
0.456207811832428,
-0.13440155982971191,
0.35264715552330017,
0.15296319127082825,
-0.20610971748828888,
-0.35315170884132385,
-0.10320717096328735,
-0.2986663579940796,
0.2632492482662201,
0.2346123307943344,
-0.1376267820596695,
-0.3419869542121887,
0.2783460319042206,
-0.02846231497824192,
-0.0192929208278656,
-0.44762513041496277,
0.6740716099739075,
0.03525647148489952,
-0.6124704480171204,
0.3149372339248657,
-0.001090534497052431,
0.7006650567054749,
-0.5672909617424011,
-0.5785394310951233,
-0.1210673600435257,
-0.09320373088121414,
-0.1800794005393982,
-0.7809420824050903,
-0.07139409333467484,
-0.0016498466720804572,
-0.13233022391796112,
-0.5130415558815002,
0.7458205223083496,
-0.3229128420352936,
-0.3772331178188324,
-0.15280646085739136,
0.6278505325317383,
0.16310229897499084,
0.07712273299694061,
-0.6808083653450012,
0.06646249443292618,
0.10114537924528122,
-0.126977801322937,
0.09437943994998932,
0.4737831950187683,
-0.2251695692539215,
0.8798103332519531,
0.9474222660064697,
0.1060459315776825,
-0.043737173080444336,
0.2310800850391388,
1.1121654510498047,
-0.5080056190490723,
-0.508711576461792,
-0.7655794620513916,
0.5128392577171326,
-0.1042034924030304,
-0.24368640780448914,
0.7604802846908569,
0.3967892825603485,
0.7362185120582581,
-0.2319575846195221,
0.7121188044548035,
-0.021329062059521675,
0.41112130880355835,
-0.739020824432373,
0.20309968292713165,
-0.29147621989250183,
0.3988340497016907,
-0.5608376860618591,
-0.9389595985412598,
-0.49660059809684753,
0.884827733039856,
-0.3872952163219452,
0.20677125453948975,
0.6315287351608276,
1.0492631196975708,
0.29306745529174805,
-0.3028663098812103,
0.546565592288971,
-0.21709607541561127,
0.16590826213359833,
0.3805816173553467,
0.900453507900238,
-0.12577617168426514,
0.51340651512146,
-0.3096972703933716,
-0.10542181879281998,
-0.15434396266937256,
-1.0062689781188965,
-0.8429587483406067,
-0.08956880122423172,
-0.38660651445388794,
-0.29711148142814636,
-0.10654964298009872,
1.7322157621383667,
0.664931058883667,
-0.839714527130127,
-0.15752075612545013,
-0.06566263735294342,
0.49251610040664673,
-0.3330138921737671,
-0.19402267038822174,
0.017629656940698624,
-0.6228666305541992,
-0.833813488483429,
0.6925411224365234,
0.36670228838920593,
-0.019177095964550972,
0.007417449727654457,
-0.16537973284721375,
0.049497656524181366,
0.08429434895515442,
0.8846815228462219,
0.39490893483161926,
-0.6376951932907104,
-0.20390188694000244,
0.06710074096918106,
0.05822550877928734,
0.26461294293403625,
0.8316260576248169,
-0.8905019760131836,
0.341991126537323,
0.7059122920036316,
0.7392498254776001,
0.1950218230485916,
0.2851921319961548,
0.3801587224006653,
-0.7333385348320007,
0.5498789548873901,
0.43227580189704895,
0.4551282525062561,
0.09732583910226822,
-0.21897415816783905,
0.2455502450466156,
-0.06219925731420517,
-0.4682691693305969,
-0.6682206988334656,
0.4046521782875061,
-1.1280280351638794,
-0.10836885869503021,
1.1711546182632446,
0.062007348984479904,
-0.22982697188854218,
-0.022849058732390404,
-0.5685475468635559,
0.048065945506095886,
-0.9156858921051025,
0.5785374641418457,
0.4573149085044861,
-0.37156522274017334,
-0.46766233444213867,
-0.44184961915016174,
0.32716163992881775,
0.35216471552848816,
-1.1040794849395752,
-0.20454710721969604,
0.7887226939201355,
-0.2724822163581848,
0.1631973385810852,
0.34846779704093933,
0.1235673725605011,
0.5122300386428833,
-0.14744152128696442,
0.23429428040981293,
-0.08775238692760468,
-0.39448994398117065,
-0.6631850600242615,
0.17886564135551453,
0.22295282781124115,
-0.21147392690181732
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06414v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06414v1
|
Evolving Knowledge Distillation with Large Language Models and Active Learning
| 2024-03-11T03:55:24 | 2024-03-11T03:55:24 |
Chengyuan Liu, Yangyang Kang, Fubang Zhao, Kun Kuang, Zhuoren Jiang, Changlong Sun, Fei Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable capabilities across
various NLP tasks. However, their computational costs are prohibitively high.
To address this issue, previous research has attempted to distill the knowledge
of LLMs into smaller models by generating annotated data. Nonetheless, these
works have mainly focused on the direct use of LLMs for text generation and
labeling, without fully exploring their potential to comprehend the target task
and acquire valuable knowledge. In this paper, we propose EvoKD: Evolving
Knowledge Distillation, which leverages the concept of active learning to
interactively enhance the process of data generation using large language
models, simultaneously improving the task capabilities of small domain model
(student model). Different from previous work, we actively analyze the student
model's weaknesses, and then synthesize labeled samples based on the analysis.
In addition, we provide iterative feedback to the LLMs regarding the student
model's performance to continuously construct diversified and challenging
samples. Experiments and analysis on different NLP tasks, namely, text
classification and named entity recognition show the effectiveness of EvoKD.
|
[
-0.04146882891654968,
-1.2382010221481323,
0.5419609546661377,
-0.14094336330890656,
-0.3687989413738251,
0.2850533723831177,
-0.5836993455886841,
-0.41737788915634155,
-0.012463868595659733,
0.4483329951763153,
-0.3371447026729584,
-0.4539394974708557,
-0.4624650180339813,
0.12073320895433426,
-0.2286842167377472,
1.043961763381958,
-0.27025651931762695,
-0.1420636624097824,
-0.17655140161514282,
-0.06822414696216583,
-0.435732901096344,
-0.3105851709842682,
-0.8266544938087463,
-0.4698117673397064,
0.33941450715065,
0.3872637450695038,
0.19809876382350922,
0.3590983748435974,
0.21722029149532318,
0.27821287512779236,
-0.3210493326187134,
0.4780330955982208,
-0.4572359621524811,
0.8674085140228271,
-0.19751563668251038,
-0.44588860869407654,
-0.3909163773059845,
-0.16171742975711823,
0.4327726662158966,
0.7563955783843994,
-0.29003646969795227,
0.16884522140026093,
0.2948504090309143,
0.5217453837394714,
-0.31049326062202454,
0.06922047585248947,
-0.8915300369262695,
-0.05868025869131088,
-0.11080583184957504,
0.07519800215959549,
-0.29616135358810425,
-0.14832466840744019,
0.3911781907081604,
-0.5317613482475281,
0.29164227843284607,
-0.02339283376932144,
0.7426747679710388,
0.4256620705127716,
-0.2887665927410126,
-0.6678220629692078,
-1.0518385171890259,
0.61077481508255,
-0.7500365972518921,
0.26295578479766846,
0.25373175740242004,
0.34311363101005554,
-0.19840674102306366,
-1.0516358613967896,
-0.6659358143806458,
-0.11539316922426224,
0.32423362135887146,
0.03450639545917511,
-0.10234528034925461,
-0.04700412601232529,
0.08465015143156052,
0.35597822070121765,
-0.07164773344993591,
0.1794603168964386,
-0.42685264348983765,
0.2918771207332611,
0.5083504915237427,
-0.03705355152487755,
0.24799028038978577,
0.003138394793495536,
-0.24417197704315186,
-0.06579528748989105,
-0.6338781118392944,
-0.16519515216350555,
0.43621912598609924,
0.46466031670570374,
0.41408392786979675,
0.706303060054779,
-0.05208195745944977,
0.7044071555137634,
0.3147376477718353,
-0.21187151968479156,
0.28824713826179504,
-0.08719971776008606,
-0.3955886960029602,
0.2127167135477066,
0.5327471494674683,
-0.09545829892158508,
-0.1780773550271988,
-0.04372282326221466,
-0.18218830227851868,
-0.39048245549201965,
0.4057334065437317,
-0.6832213997840881,
-0.6265783309936523,
0.3170534372329712,
-0.3113015294075012,
-0.39389291405677795,
-0.23487421870231628,
-0.7915008664131165,
-0.48730015754699707,
-0.357098788022995,
0.4828733801841736,
-0.57314532995224,
-0.49062857031822205,
0.1465533971786499,
-0.10101352632045746,
-0.15693004429340363,
0.6180315017700195,
-0.9636858105659485,
0.11877242475748062,
0.45723044872283936,
0.8437174558639526,
-0.4203110933303833,
-0.09937779605388641,
-0.23159687221050262,
0.24270260334014893,
-0.12874841690063477,
0.6435867547988892,
-0.4891825318336487,
-0.13719552755355835,
-0.0867990180850029,
0.04757864028215408,
-0.014367629773914814,
-0.7376315593719482,
0.47118470072746277,
-0.642444908618927,
-0.050037138164043427,
0.12859265506267548,
-0.7428983449935913,
-0.339774489402771,
0.26185929775238037,
-0.8961704969406128,
1.3871439695358276,
0.09305743128061295,
-0.5617187023162842,
0.6499747037887573,
-0.7409559488296509,
-0.45878511667251587,
0.42406314611434937,
-0.11138037592172623,
-0.7277300357818604,
0.2554558515548706,
0.16313673555850983,
0.6083494424819946,
0.033604517579078674,
0.5102207064628601,
-0.2037317454814911,
0.3925631642341614,
0.06293150037527084,
-0.24487973749637604,
0.6028929352760315,
0.3742032051086426,
-0.47003456950187683,
-0.05840234458446503,
-0.8254162669181824,
-0.17547668516635895,
0.20776116847991943,
-0.780424177646637,
-0.7789617776870728,
0.14983238279819489,
-0.22366149723529816,
-0.013483920134603977,
0.25170955061912537,
-0.3996720016002655,
0.5409064292907715,
-0.15629756450653076,
0.45204076170921326,
0.6860151290893555,
0.3092951476573944,
0.5858978033065796,
0.0017379896016791463,
0.5379290580749512,
-0.005062581039965153,
-0.03206663578748703,
-0.2519511282444,
-0.5822781920433044,
-0.868603527545929,
-0.3728886544704437,
0.48128557205200195,
0.1621270775794983,
-1.0799874067306519,
0.5360205769538879,
-0.2371908575296402,
-0.5274614691734314,
-0.6567853093147278,
0.5459222793579102,
-0.24211947619915009,
0.19717907905578613,
0.43430715799331665,
0.23057876527309418,
-0.385323166847229,
-0.5371382236480713,
-0.04348253458738327,
-0.19530652463436127,
-0.08977814763784409,
0.1335853487253189,
0.40082040429115295,
-0.253988116979599,
0.8538334369659424,
-0.5158437490463257,
-0.2525099217891693,
-0.67177814245224,
0.21329045295715332,
-0.005392768420279026,
0.3477022349834442,
0.41671520471572876,
-0.712882936000824,
-0.7472532391548157,
0.19844578206539154,
-0.5197093486785889,
-0.2953627109527588,
-0.26125580072402954,
-0.23417656123638153,
-0.13543018698692322,
0.4809098541736603,
-0.39642202854156494,
-0.02939184010028839,
0.6215370297431946,
-0.3182297646999359,
0.0979875773191452,
-0.1329517364501953,
-0.02373160794377327,
-1.2364490032196045,
-0.03992335498332977,
-0.08276983350515366,
-0.2678772807121277,
-0.6578232049942017,
-0.029143689200282097,
0.14810720086097717,
-0.020366806536912918,
-0.23646895587444305,
0.6450745463371277,
-0.8035321831703186,
0.41276541352272034,
-0.4795023202896118,
0.1652660071849823,
0.028090981766581535,
0.21552880108356476,
0.15731050074100494,
0.14656974375247955,
0.5634375810623169,
-0.7062207460403442,
0.707659900188446,
0.06622546911239624,
-0.5408334732055664,
0.08842793852090836,
-0.4037279486656189,
0.02902984619140625,
-0.008153233677148819,
0.06806251406669617,
-0.9282976388931274,
-0.09102880954742432,
-0.0802624523639679,
-0.1659131497144699,
0.6322838664054871,
-0.2760746479034424,
-0.35140547156333923,
-0.3907393217086792,
-0.0960947796702385,
0.2915897071361542,
0.6303746104240417,
-0.8929192423820496,
0.838544487953186,
0.35533440113067627,
-0.538162350654602,
-0.24977946281433105,
-0.453475683927536,
0.11838968098163605,
-0.33564579486846924,
-0.5165134072303772,
0.25279563665390015,
0.15320417284965515,
-0.4307931661605835,
0.22892196476459503,
-0.12715652585029602,
0.08639075607061386,
0.0781594067811966,
-0.01577349379658699,
0.11822279542684555,
-0.06988522410392761,
0.512963056564331,
0.49184879660606384,
0.313019335269928,
-0.1772758513689041,
-0.4220578670501709,
0.40995338559150696,
0.47538796067237854,
-0.32206812500953674,
-0.1280677318572998,
-0.09721328318119049,
0.48374953866004944,
-0.14571669697761536,
0.7489438652992249,
0.31937646865844727,
-0.3614742159843445,
-1.0837222337722778,
-0.47331613302230835,
-0.2959558963775635,
-0.5009955763816833,
0.4797888696193695,
-0.23339825868606567,
-0.9292520880699158,
0.4142652153968811,
-0.7482742667198181,
0.6374142169952393,
0.5033044219017029,
0.681807816028595,
0.03635694086551666,
0.7556881904602051,
0.7746075391769409,
0.4176558554172516,
0.7060039043426514,
-0.23140430450439453,
0.25551483035087585,
-0.7622172236442566,
-0.40756887197494507,
-0.34907835721969604,
-0.5849854350090027,
-0.05703732743859291,
-0.6959103345870972,
0.10295367985963821,
0.4252569377422333,
0.17977698147296906,
0.07303151488304138,
-0.5827380418777466,
0.2983143627643585,
0.39306676387786865,
0.13887564837932587,
0.37157437205314636,
0.07229384779930115,
-0.18352770805358887,
0.006409564055502415,
-0.7739948630332947,
-0.6052832007408142,
1.4267528057098389,
0.4840390384197235,
1.015068769454956,
0.09797261655330658,
0.8033896088600159,
0.37505999207496643,
0.42740562558174133,
-0.8863062262535095,
0.36785972118377686,
-0.04758268967270851,
-0.5810003876686096,
-0.4822043478488922,
-0.5129206776618958,
-0.9090269804000854,
0.33250001072883606,
-0.2642422020435333,
-0.27775686979293823,
0.09013509005308151,
0.1280170977115631,
-0.42882239818573,
0.3773280680179596,
-0.749297559261322,
0.49440544843673706,
-0.533869206905365,
-0.4274527430534363,
0.009034661576151848,
-0.17542019486427307,
0.3469375967979431,
-0.543848991394043,
0.14557158946990967,
-0.07091479748487473,
-0.09399663656949997,
1.067670226097107,
-0.45579200983047485,
0.8849493265151978,
-0.3510238230228424,
-0.34611594676971436,
0.570912778377533,
-0.022268349304795265,
0.675390899181366,
0.1980188637971878,
-0.16654962301254272,
-0.2719425559043884,
-0.4694373607635498,
-0.1599942296743393,
-0.5511704087257385,
0.7007075548171997,
-0.6402304172515869,
-0.5549893379211426,
-0.14679475128650665,
-0.2470483034849167,
-0.15506479144096375,
0.13010896742343903,
-0.12468148022890091,
0.1562620848417282,
-0.2007562220096588,
0.22942136228084564,
0.9649327397346497,
-0.32215645909309387,
0.4272771179676056,
0.5981015563011169,
-0.32402434945106506,
-0.27288123965263367,
0.5260608196258545,
0.214843288064003,
0.3401210308074951,
0.0589170902967453,
0.1540534645318985,
-0.2783438563346863,
-0.8407061100006104,
-0.5580210089683533,
0.16093283891677856,
-0.8113824129104614,
-0.4054167568683624,
-0.8238036632537842,
-0.029230665415525436,
-0.29168900847435,
-0.1214035227894783,
-0.5873730778694153,
-0.5172425508499146,
-0.3012102544307709,
-0.5369826555252075,
0.6434483528137207,
0.8960769176483154,
0.06905340403318405,
0.0857255682349205,
-0.6508463621139526,
0.32519304752349854,
0.6205708384513855,
0.030285993590950966,
0.18404453992843628,
-0.7373452186584473,
-0.3908756673336029,
0.12707367539405823,
-0.4082098603248596,
-0.8036884665489197,
0.4616723656654358,
0.5379709005355835,
0.8320198059082031,
0.47115010023117065,
0.3943531811237335,
0.40034735202789307,
-0.5955966114997864,
0.8880425095558167,
0.13049326837062836,
-0.6881322860717773,
0.6913453936576843,
-0.050102349370718,
0.24316823482513428,
0.6141961216926575,
0.36922821402549744,
-0.23027683794498444,
-0.6926102042198181,
-0.5554710626602173,
-1.3280271291732788,
0.615585207939148,
0.09412084519863129,
0.24923284351825714,
-0.01385218184441328,
0.5860349535942078,
0.5642859935760498,
0.13327625393867493,
-0.732257604598999,
-0.13866716623306274,
0.024898944422602654,
-0.47563427686691284,
0.21474216878414154,
-0.09605441987514496,
-0.12170267105102539,
-0.4448276460170746,
0.9686589241027832,
-0.020510291680693626,
-0.08723823726177216,
-0.03984435275197029,
-0.20572161674499512,
-0.11110682040452957,
0.1671094447374344,
0.08991070836782455,
0.5119816064834595,
0.10950395464897156,
0.406583696603775,
0.2798100709915161,
-0.8179426193237305,
0.13948954641819,
0.006979566998779774,
-0.11304734647274017,
0.15925125777721405,
0.24140791594982147,
0.9137054681777954,
0.02606680803000927,
-0.7613946199417114,
0.22263115644454956,
-0.06518229097127914,
-0.404584139585495,
-0.012723054736852646,
0.2639254033565521,
0.30434831976890564,
0.49415525794029236,
0.7354059219360352,
-0.2504233419895172,
-0.1930692046880722,
-0.6172651052474976,
0.2496437430381775,
0.05521935597062111,
-0.14319458603858948,
-0.35347792506217957,
0.7148561477661133,
0.6273031830787659,
-0.10765060037374496,
0.672530472278595,
-0.24190811812877655,
-0.6008198857307434,
0.48683950304985046,
0.5467824935913086,
1.0116301774978638,
-0.4958546459674835,
0.23867733776569366,
0.310670405626297,
0.19176803529262543,
-0.30056795477867126,
0.11548773944377899,
-0.12067150324583054,
-0.7328671216964722,
-0.35924574732780457,
-1.0550659894943237,
-0.2465442568063736,
0.3265059292316437,
-0.5300267934799194,
0.5063028335571289,
-0.15566128492355347,
-0.2176111787557602,
0.17978858947753906,
-0.00028961696079932153,
-0.47651103138923645,
0.04340491071343422,
-0.06440414488315582,
0.4296552836894989,
-0.9314224123954773,
1.082381248474121,
1.1319330930709839,
-0.05469674989581108,
-0.5964350700378418,
-0.09481740742921829,
-0.3568296730518341,
-0.4958561360836029,
0.8063111305236816,
-0.1682354360818863,
0.2927122414112091,
0.2709718942642212,
-0.4489337205886841,
-0.5927494764328003,
1.3365144729614258,
0.05743333324790001,
-0.777014970779419,
0.03932898864150047,
-0.12484975904226303,
0.6343366503715515,
-0.2894195318222046,
-0.12738174200057983,
0.31102636456489563,
0.3762982189655304,
0.3302065432071686,
-0.6925085186958313,
-0.04546583816409111,
-0.3112008571624756,
-0.25945553183555603,
0.3505815267562866,
-0.25249600410461426,
0.8782517313957214,
-0.2494787871837616,
-0.35836169123649597,
-0.3950645327568054,
0.6348521113395691,
0.09451530128717422,
0.19209137558937073,
0.5282219052314758,
0.746045708656311,
0.9346290230751038,
0.006417249329388142,
0.3728804290294647,
-0.0944407656788826,
0.4212479591369629,
1.1573904752731323,
-0.4568975865840912,
0.8727716207504272,
0.47177615761756897,
-0.19383102655410767,
0.2727586328983307,
0.6415163278579712,
-0.21481645107269287,
0.6695173978805542,
0.20878995954990387,
-0.49695539474487305,
-0.21608871221542358,
0.3478676676750183,
-0.07861770689487457,
0.2261282354593277,
0.42553240060806274,
-0.5169417262077332,
-0.25947269797325134,
0.5138848423957825,
0.030350105836987495,
0.0044366586953401566,
-0.2341693639755249,
1.2463442087173462,
-0.0025435066781938076,
-0.5204411149024963,
0.4399307072162628,
0.1316358745098114,
0.8191876411437988,
-0.6342064738273621,
-0.13854943215847015,
-0.07188614457845688,
0.22981159389019012,
-0.0974644124507904,
-0.5808935165405273,
0.05752234533429146,
0.21813638508319855,
-0.06912698596715927,
-0.4212509095668793,
0.7468356490135193,
-0.8299124836921692,
-0.5298416614532471,
0.18045534193515778,
0.717943012714386,
-0.050423745065927505,
0.1291685253381729,
-0.5891169309616089,
0.03776772320270538,
0.26464176177978516,
-0.6587731838226318,
0.3873733580112457,
0.8458828926086426,
0.0881161093711853,
0.5831502676010132,
0.568930983543396,
0.2879469394683838,
0.4442116618156433,
-0.001502737170085311,
1.1127229928970337,
-0.26072168350219727,
-0.35994458198547363,
-0.8992782235145569,
0.4437951445579529,
-0.205848827958107,
-0.20249880850315094,
0.8688204288482666,
0.5225173830986023,
0.6967165470123291,
0.043409619480371475,
1.1395816802978516,
-0.32428789138793945,
0.5196816325187683,
-0.5571818947792053,
0.8262667655944824,
-0.560865044593811,
0.4857669770717621,
-0.15623198449611664,
-1.2364674806594849,
-0.06764204055070877,
0.6342427134513855,
-0.1590583324432373,
-0.08058848977088928,
0.6938058137893677,
0.21636928617954254,
-0.1229611486196518,
-0.08063632249832153,
0.1796535700559616,
0.30814045667648315,
0.513763427734375,
0.14377404749393463,
0.843072772026062,
-0.094725601375103,
0.41418328881263733,
-0.18617872893810272,
-0.3566676378250122,
-0.19500982761383057,
-0.6501066088676453,
-1.1015677452087402,
-0.7891547679901123,
-0.5858240723609924,
-0.09608166664838791,
0.08749593794345856,
0.7845736742019653,
0.42363470792770386,
-0.5552840232849121,
0.13681760430335999,
-0.16368620097637177,
-0.0016940132481977344,
-0.26538947224617004,
-0.24043232202529907,
0.5361769795417786,
-0.5139073133468628,
-1.1079214811325073,
0.43482068181037903,
0.12318714708089828,
0.17366310954093933,
-0.24419493973255157,
0.04509574919939041,
-0.2520114481449127,
0.08515707403421402,
0.6860384941101074,
0.09591740369796753,
-0.3645351529121399,
-0.03624480217695236,
-0.15807589888572693,
0.101620614528656,
-0.29590868949890137,
0.7694465517997742,
-0.6378517746925354,
0.7720997333526611,
0.5167528986930847,
0.82159024477005,
0.6500326991081238,
0.06874526292085648,
0.6675246953964233,
-0.6904009580612183,
-0.08075153827667236,
0.4592139720916748,
0.1381610631942749,
0.3288269639015198,
-0.28747066855430603,
0.4250012934207916,
0.042683519423007965,
-0.6065210700035095,
-0.9719390869140625,
-0.026454001665115356,
-0.8123050332069397,
-0.6967440843582153,
1.5482923984527588,
-0.22610874474048615,
-0.11383809894323349,
-0.47639498114585876,
-0.2404516190290451,
0.35813194513320923,
-0.4332537353038788,
0.9837578535079956,
0.5940005779266357,
-0.12670601904392242,
-0.026421990245580673,
-0.723039448261261,
0.667048990726471,
-0.012308268807828426,
-0.8504447937011719,
0.42071911692619324,
0.43898919224739075,
0.4199505150318146,
0.011093996465206146,
0.28927740454673767,
0.12191438674926758,
-0.261726975440979,
0.01699681580066681,
0.31760671734809875,
-0.3146161139011383,
-0.3301732540130615,
-0.08499156683683395,
0.24017836153507233,
0.3274472653865814,
-0.023660993203520775
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06412v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06412v3
|
CLIcK: A Benchmark Dataset of Cultural and Linguistic Intelligence in Korean
| 2024-03-11T03:54:33 | 2024-03-15T08:53:31 |
Eunsu Kim, Juyoung Suk, Philhoon Oh, Haneul Yoo, James Thorne, Alice Oh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Despite the rapid development of large language models (LLMs) for the Korean
language, there remains an obvious lack of benchmark datasets that test the
requisite Korean cultural and linguistic knowledge. Because many existing
Korean benchmark datasets are derived from the English counterparts through
translation, they often overlook the different cultural contexts. For the few
benchmark datasets that are sourced from Korean data capturing cultural
knowledge, only narrow tasks such as bias and hate speech detection are
offered. To address this gap, we introduce a benchmark of Cultural and
Linguistic Intelligence in Korean (CLIcK), a dataset comprising 1,995 QA pairs.
CLIcK sources its data from official Korean exams and textbooks, partitioning
the questions into eleven categories under the two main categories of language
and culture. For each instance in CLIcK, we provide fine-grained annotation of
which cultural and linguistic knowledge is required to answer the question
correctly. Using CLIcK, we test 13 language models to assess their performance.
Our evaluation uncovers insights into their performances across the categories,
as well as the diverse factors affecting their comprehension. CLIcK offers the
first large-scale comprehensive Korean-centric analysis of LLMs' proficiency in
Korean culture and language.
|
[
-0.3428780734539032,
-0.46974360942840576,
0.3732835650444031,
0.21591384708881378,
-0.032647278159856796,
0.2682782709598541,
-0.43660804629325867,
-0.28263527154922485,
0.13651718199253082,
0.6126384139060974,
-0.6769440770149231,
-0.7154501676559448,
-0.2731751501560211,
0.14635764062404633,
-0.08254830539226532,
0.745330274105072,
0.055944349616765976,
0.2072790563106537,
-0.5976164937019348,
-0.46392324566841125,
-0.2684720456600189,
-0.20316670835018158,
-0.5511393547058105,
-0.3561117649078369,
0.4749312698841095,
0.4762861430644989,
0.62191241979599,
0.7300772070884705,
0.4476760923862457,
0.20492033660411835,
-0.07762733846902847,
0.057573623955249786,
-0.6062200665473938,
0.10922933369874954,
-0.16043397784233093,
-0.6003851890563965,
-0.2945254147052765,
0.5467385649681091,
0.329321026802063,
0.9835130572319031,
0.4424349069595337,
0.684699535369873,
-0.4385785460472107,
0.8810248970985413,
-0.3745238184928894,
0.19286787509918213,
-0.6995561718940735,
-0.07273943722248077,
-0.18969084322452545,
0.010553543455898762,
-0.24784189462661743,
-0.7940073013305664,
0.08219370245933533,
-0.5907926559448242,
-0.1868542730808258,
-0.08399765938520432,
0.5570304989814758,
0.47652462124824524,
-0.903721034526825,
-0.1350756585597992,
-0.44213956594467163,
0.7080219388008118,
-0.30380284786224365,
0.6788063645362854,
0.5812087059020996,
0.17814584076404572,
0.05752616748213768,
-0.5377663373947144,
-0.4813638925552368,
-0.5111831426620483,
0.08957550674676895,
0.1846534162759781,
0.20888325572013855,
-0.25761643052101135,
0.46464547514915466,
0.19428257644176483,
-0.7973886728286743,
0.01035586278885603,
-0.347568541765213,
-0.23252654075622559,
0.9056750535964966,
0.311990886926651,
0.6701267957687378,
-0.36434483528137207,
-0.3614713251590729,
-0.12183535099029541,
-0.6768948435783386,
0.2412792593240738,
0.4700116217136383,
0.15381760895252228,
0.024756621569395065,
0.4459158778190613,
-0.7642126083374023,
0.38992172479629517,
-0.12616047263145447,
-0.5485408306121826,
0.5261759757995605,
-0.46684327721595764,
0.21861864626407623,
-0.048775382339954376,
0.6490222215652466,
0.7481854557991028,
0.9010722041130066,
-0.19468878209590912,
0.24336892366409302,
0.25322425365448,
0.001423774752765894,
-0.7498716711997986,
-0.47230494022369385,
0.34429633617401123,
-0.6338266134262085,
-0.22992119193077087,
-0.35877034068107605,
-0.7950562238693237,
-0.4760141372680664,
-0.32348260283470154,
0.14692255854606628,
-0.20817871391773224,
-0.44471627473831177,
-0.1149270236492157,
0.02551213838160038,
0.11635760962963104,
-0.10786847770214081,
-0.5418263077735901,
0.015242529101669788,
0.5475152134895325,
0.2634493112564087,
-0.41870883107185364,
-0.6196093559265137,
-0.22922419011592865,
-0.1434946358203888,
-0.5949103236198425,
0.6450026631355286,
-0.6990001201629639,
-0.1215941309928894,
0.09647613763809204,
0.05231820046901703,
-0.1780284196138382,
-0.9153473973274231,
0.5584805607795715,
-0.7715343236923218,
-0.0033236765302717686,
-0.4064410626888275,
-0.5001928806304932,
-0.5448172688484192,
0.29557332396507263,
-0.7620013356208801,
1.2342783212661743,
0.1539420634508133,
-0.37000784277915955,
0.5858622789382935,
-0.317025363445282,
-0.39111077785491943,
0.3829956650733948,
-0.23037457466125488,
0.1252753883600235,
-0.13837464153766632,
0.06442409008741379,
0.3552210032939911,
-0.2852088212966919,
0.1704745590686798,
-0.44063135981559753,
-0.20334167778491974,
0.4040093719959259,
-0.1927049309015274,
0.8358854055404663,
0.10732430964708328,
-0.1276244819164276,
-0.17837832868099213,
-1.1225793361663818,
0.4138088524341583,
0.3161388039588928,
-0.5676689147949219,
-0.5057094693183899,
-0.21388761699199677,
-0.047116369009017944,
0.5327264666557312,
0.4448475241661072,
-0.2777045965194702,
-0.0000896694982657209,
-0.02148246392607689,
-0.10268884152173996,
0.3596537709236145,
-0.2218429148197174,
0.49861931800842285,
-0.18131236732006073,
0.7047616839408875,
-0.06885389983654022,
0.02327592298388481,
-0.17929759621620178,
-0.3763434588909149,
-0.4532925486564636,
-0.18308186531066895,
0.2883383333683014,
0.8382453322410583,
-0.7441056370735168,
0.09762635827064514,
-0.4864990711212158,
-0.6514863967895508,
-0.9042313694953918,
0.44838982820510864,
0.3707098364830017,
0.5422577857971191,
0.014904355630278587,
-0.046587150543928146,
-0.39915981888771057,
-0.7643056511878967,
-0.5819263458251953,
-0.20864158868789673,
-0.23555198311805725,
0.45363348722457886,
0.39892515540122986,
0.15930049121379852,
0.7409766316413879,
-0.38448581099510193,
-0.03637439385056496,
-0.2194860577583313,
-0.056566596031188965,
0.24554122984409332,
0.08315806835889816,
0.28784894943237305,
-0.9414258003234863,
-0.8003999590873718,
0.01564996875822544,
-0.8085882067680359,
-0.4863162338733673,
0.2856021523475647,
-0.126685231924057,
0.14698471128940582,
0.8716839551925659,
-0.19169239699840546,
0.23459745943546295,
0.5555117130279541,
-0.41639795899391174,
0.5957983732223511,
0.39209672808647156,
0.4673417806625366,
-0.9778196811676025,
0.25538209080696106,
-0.23582583665847778,
0.07818246632814407,
-0.956430971622467,
0.013857879675924778,
0.24457712471485138,
-0.16211937367916107,
-0.5630102753639221,
0.7026844024658203,
-0.14618933200836182,
-0.002247567055746913,
-0.25211045145988464,
0.34553879499435425,
-0.1536620408296585,
0.47729936242103577,
0.04975901544094086,
0.7257277369499207,
0.13801231980323792,
-0.595669686794281,
0.5066593885421753,
0.3206416070461273,
-0.5752097368240356,
0.9165132641792297,
-0.3810407817363739,
0.2433813065290451,
-0.02886187843978405,
-0.029670197516679764,
-0.981930673122406,
-0.4330047070980072,
0.0447634793817997,
-0.46144452691078186,
-0.08036753535270691,
-0.5163581967353821,
-0.3488461673259735,
-0.328717440366745,
-0.28663399815559387,
0.5393069386482239,
0.540342390537262,
-0.38653117418289185,
0.5108174085617065,
0.42880892753601074,
-0.27956512570381165,
-0.4656432867050171,
-0.3324071168899536,
-0.12259213626384735,
-0.37914496660232544,
-0.7938224673271179,
0.06994736939668655,
-0.20121528208255768,
-0.3267335295677185,
0.007506777998059988,
0.03169543668627739,
0.07898902148008347,
0.16806605458259583,
0.09730102866888046,
0.2161460667848587,
-0.3968420624732971,
0.138635516166687,
-0.3410152494907379,
-0.27372491359710693,
0.3398178815841675,
-0.06501611322164536,
0.6586791276931763,
0.0829089805483818,
-0.33229658007621765,
-0.18122701346874237,
0.11547322571277618,
0.8667966723442078,
-0.2372576892375946,
0.5276361107826233,
0.6924890279769897,
-0.20193034410476685,
-0.03954925388097763,
-0.6177871227264404,
-0.0622374564409256,
-0.42062944173812866,
0.6592415571212769,
-0.5512890219688416,
-0.7318413257598877,
0.7464657425880432,
-0.4578860402107239,
-0.41764622926712036,
0.2112177014350891,
0.4401029348373413,
-0.043573860079050064,
1.0833461284637451,
0.3207590579986572,
-0.37252911925315857,
0.12752200663089752,
0.11394059658050537,
0.19624409079551697,
-0.702171266078949,
-0.39758121967315674,
-0.4658288061618805,
-0.4455178380012512,
-0.7690987586975098,
-0.35362470149993896,
0.44263502955436707,
0.10753601044416428,
-0.4492570161819458,
0.020688682794570923,
0.18460309505462646,
0.8144511580467224,
0.5931540727615356,
-0.17666247487068176,
0.3341587781906128,
-0.03100704587996006,
-0.16677652299404144,
-0.2725241184234619,
-0.530904233455658,
-0.5438582897186279,
1.1162856817245483,
0.1670079380273819,
0.6546080112457275,
-0.04190578684210777,
0.21107730269432068,
-0.0010746890911832452,
-0.009815904311835766,
-0.7813227772712708,
0.8556450605392456,
-0.30008840560913086,
-0.5334121584892273,
-0.1886877715587616,
-0.3107544779777527,
-0.6812140941619873,
-0.0160902738571167,
0.07071438431739807,
-0.7205089926719666,
-0.10007290542125702,
-0.21189221739768982,
0.01822110265493393,
0.08614328503608704,
-0.513482928276062,
0.9261177778244019,
-0.19726227223873138,
-0.13600312173366547,
-0.10211041569709778,
-0.5197291374206543,
0.307720810174942,
-0.050105880945920944,
-0.030045541003346443,
-0.649551272392273,
-0.14075039327144623,
0.8020967245101929,
0.11592186242341995,
0.7119650840759277,
-0.013213707134127617,
0.12245695292949677,
0.11280418932437897,
0.36230170726776123,
0.352321982383728,
-0.20505787432193756,
-0.1425628811120987,
0.13245846331119537,
-0.05464177206158638,
-0.41489991545677185,
-0.5254608392715454,
0.7072263956069946,
-0.6018622517585754,
-0.426323264837265,
-0.03343737870454788,
-0.8636977076530457,
-0.5530247092247009,
0.03615500405430794,
-0.04922422394156456,
0.1916404664516449,
-0.02989332750439644,
0.19529308378696442,
0.7411038279533386,
-0.15386579930782318,
0.14300699532032013,
0.7911421060562134,
-0.45130395889282227,
-0.5036730766296387,
1.033337950706482,
0.24884958565235138,
0.4060768187046051,
-0.05522910878062248,
0.028453519567847252,
-0.48087412118911743,
-0.36247944831848145,
-0.4732132852077484,
0.3696710169315338,
-0.9819920659065247,
0.1683366596698761,
-0.5718047022819519,
-0.32812511920928955,
-0.33709314465522766,
-0.061847373843193054,
-0.27464205026626587,
-0.042397111654281616,
0.03413262218236923,
-0.033331770449876785,
0.46557947993278503,
0.716050922870636,
0.09853389114141464,
-0.1074216291308403,
-0.6612746119499207,
0.34857675433158875,
0.3854162096977234,
0.5981115102767944,
0.06459669768810272,
-0.4469369351863861,
-0.1406933069229126,
-0.27490052580833435,
0.07778692245483398,
-0.9017528295516968,
0.17933496832847595,
0.03814670443534851,
0.688517153263092,
0.36011603474617004,
0.103648841381073,
0.36044129729270935,
-0.4447157382965088,
0.7996503114700317,
-0.40106791257858276,
-0.5947335958480835,
0.4877248704433441,
-0.42583411931991577,
0.5569888353347778,
0.8135037422180176,
0.9801391363143921,
-1.0620752573013306,
-0.23121681809425354,
-0.4075060784816742,
-0.6188806295394897,
0.7966524958610535,
-0.32578274607658386,
0.02345976047217846,
-0.08271922916173935,
0.06520716100931168,
0.07787679880857468,
0.1860547810792923,
-0.6028900146484375,
-0.4125247597694397,
0.11077728867530823,
-0.4314240515232086,
0.05758284404873848,
-0.3605993688106537,
-0.12723945081233978,
-0.13590627908706665,
0.6745234131813049,
-0.422953337430954,
-0.2658239006996155,
-0.213935986161232,
-0.34084364771842957,
-0.05376311019062996,
0.002098075347021222,
0.26622524857521057,
0.742034912109375,
0.013844894245266914,
-0.04317030310630798,
0.3845096230506897,
-0.8052586913108826,
0.1465492844581604,
-0.21106009185314178,
-0.313951700925827,
-0.400472491979599,
0.1545325070619583,
0.505439281463623,
0.09748145192861557,
-0.8811852335929871,
0.293838769197464,
0.21476073563098907,
-0.10388143360614777,
-0.14646925032138824,
-0.05327075719833374,
0.41226664185523987,
0.2720613479614258,
0.30913540720939636,
-0.4783281981945038,
-0.06706739217042923,
-0.43907612562179565,
0.2620525658130646,
0.23251020908355713,
-0.36601635813713074,
-0.3112761974334717,
0.5556931495666504,
0.27161601185798645,
-0.18327200412750244,
0.8205328583717346,
-0.26384419202804565,
-0.935913622379303,
0.6952722668647766,
0.39957019686698914,
0.6727514266967773,
-0.20881833136081696,
0.522794783115387,
0.47781914472579956,
0.35613396763801575,
0.20937420427799225,
0.6563529968261719,
0.3192436099052429,
-0.7889599204063416,
-0.5586701035499573,
-0.603155791759491,
-0.303300142288208,
0.5301176309585571,
-0.667165219783783,
0.13548658788204193,
-0.11080986261367798,
0.3185204565525055,
-0.23211683332920074,
0.3516465723514557,
-0.8216593265533447,
0.39155834913253784,
0.32742422819137573,
1.1078169345855713,
-1.2535895109176636,
0.6603811383247375,
0.9148228168487549,
-0.3651981055736542,
-0.6810930967330933,
0.1807819902896881,
0.20992788672447205,
-0.9351714849472046,
0.8512546420097351,
0.16490770876407623,
0.18037068843841553,
-0.0846574604511261,
-0.4215629994869232,
-1.1489440202713013,
0.9483528137207031,
0.04874967038631439,
0.004190895240753889,
0.6943497061729431,
0.5767412781715393,
0.6201962232589722,
-0.484159916639328,
0.28344404697418213,
0.9825921654701233,
0.38985204696655273,
-0.014746952801942825,
-0.846640408039093,
0.049902331084012985,
-0.4041740596294403,
-0.06592920422554016,
0.09776390343904495,
-0.8887194395065308,
0.5143141746520996,
0.040993623435497284,
-0.027314994484186172,
-0.05745183303952217,
0.5803592205047607,
0.37007442116737366,
0.743072509765625,
0.5807733535766602,
0.547962486743927,
0.950623095035553,
-0.12991683185100555,
0.6524580717086792,
-0.474944531917572,
-0.19007690250873566,
1.017154335975647,
-0.5180623531341553,
0.9130575060844421,
0.07644304633140564,
-0.3882753551006317,
0.3576061427593231,
0.6935042142868042,
0.052187275141477585,
0.3929407596588135,
0.273040771484375,
-0.23089949786663055,
-0.4378916621208191,
-0.6977327466011047,
-0.1578366458415985,
0.8096720576286316,
0.23636990785598755,
-0.15725181996822357,
0.135820209980011,
0.008542981930077076,
0.34800785779953003,
0.3239266574382782,
-0.5029024481773376,
0.7287659645080566,
-0.22619661688804626,
-0.7482617497444153,
0.4342232048511505,
-0.459438294172287,
0.5793173313140869,
-0.5704078674316406,
0.26635172963142395,
-0.5234856605529785,
-0.16742047667503357,
-0.10887575149536133,
-0.7792552709579468,
-0.05947991460561752,
-0.03816194459795952,
-0.46715623140335083,
0.060568153858184814,
0.840426504611969,
-0.7757126092910767,
-0.30572980642318726,
0.36439740657806396,
0.6826611161231995,
0.5007264018058777,
-0.00907632801681757,
-0.45173409581184387,
0.06475057452917099,
0.09150426089763641,
-0.1408344954252243,
0.38845154643058777,
0.32126709818840027,
-0.2740669846534729,
0.8108721971511841,
0.6409486532211304,
0.16349700093269348,
0.2808859348297119,
0.3448637127876282,
0.5992805361747742,
-0.7361949682235718,
-0.24597197771072388,
-0.5086263418197632,
0.28304633498191833,
-0.22875429689884186,
-0.5077201128005981,
0.6705788969993591,
0.4527515769004822,
1.2885476350784302,
-0.10474387556314468,
0.8171366453170776,
0.07533931732177734,
0.7265578508377075,
-0.38972821831703186,
0.8835538029670715,
-0.601081371307373,
-0.1859259158372879,
-0.02108299918472767,
-0.7233647108078003,
0.12316355854272842,
0.08378580212593079,
-0.5683759450912476,
0.27038413286209106,
0.8168598413467407,
0.9006418585777283,
0.10039885342121124,
0.20975463092327118,
0.5689353942871094,
0.3273044526576996,
-0.1303703933954239,
0.41861122846603394,
0.9387267231941223,
-0.3213047981262207,
0.8063427209854126,
-0.49505168199539185,
-0.09695711731910706,
-0.10306835919618607,
-0.9298696517944336,
-1.1077766418457031,
-0.7440329790115356,
-0.5160453915596008,
-0.21815788745880127,
-0.1941094845533371,
0.9631914496421814,
0.4975336194038391,
-0.8362480998039246,
-0.25256413221359253,
0.7571508884429932,
0.1959216594696045,
-0.2199796438217163,
-0.26335370540618896,
0.4777297377586365,
-0.37847986817359924,
-0.8873770833015442,
0.60830157995224,
0.20569060742855072,
-0.10136554390192032,
-0.25442221760749817,
0.03521997854113579,
-0.17615322768688202,
0.0749831274151802,
0.4926353096961975,
0.26506873965263367,
-0.6419163346290588,
-0.20534424483776093,
0.34466519951820374,
-0.15299828350543976,
-0.327618807554245,
0.608754575252533,
-0.9222536087036133,
0.465472012758255,
0.7651228904724121,
0.7889634370803833,
-0.18339072167873383,
-0.13983990252017975,
0.38048607110977173,
-0.6039341688156128,
-0.045738037675619125,
0.09599453210830688,
-0.06278012692928314,
0.31428787112236023,
-0.19886209070682526,
0.7938628196716309,
0.3758353292942047,
-0.7330756187438965,
-0.6317943334579468,
0.3167285919189453,
-0.6783835291862488,
0.02204853482544422,
1.2940601110458374,
-0.11995024234056473,
-0.233614981174469,
-0.3681970238685608,
0.04303387552499771,
0.0015027873450890183,
-0.006908533629029989,
0.7317163348197937,
0.9637581706047058,
0.14414191246032715,
0.08983438462018967,
-0.8675383925437927,
0.7365201115608215,
0.6317592859268188,
-0.6935528516769409,
0.08846329152584076,
0.32142576575279236,
0.4203747510910034,
0.15418197214603424,
0.48263776302337646,
-0.06053842231631279,
0.5375058650970459,
-0.0380847230553627,
0.06808056682348251,
0.19426849484443665,
-0.45469069480895996,
-0.26824820041656494,
0.17795075476169586,
-0.11085367947816849,
-0.1640363484621048
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06410v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06410v1
|
A Logical Pattern Memory Pre-trained Model for Entailment Tree Generation
| 2024-03-11T03:45:09 | 2024-03-11T03:45:09 |
Li Yuan, Yi Cai, Haopeng Ren, Jiexin Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Generating coherent and credible explanations remains a significant challenge
in the field of AI. In recent years, researchers have delved into the
utilization of entailment trees to depict explanations, which exhibit a
reasoning process of how a hypothesis is deduced from the supporting facts.
However, existing models often overlook the importance of generating
intermediate conclusions with logical consistency from the given facts, leading
to inaccurate conclusions and undermining the overall credibility of entailment
trees. To address this limitation, we propose the logical pattern memory
pre-trained model (LMPM). LMPM incorporates an external memory structure to
learn and store the latent representations of logical patterns, which aids in
generating logically consistent conclusions. Furthermore, to mitigate the
influence of logically irrelevant domain knowledge in the Wikipedia-based data,
we introduce an entity abstraction approach to construct the dataset for
pre-training LMPM. The experimental results highlight the effectiveness of our
approach in improving the quality of entailment tree generation. By leveraging
logical entailment patterns, our model produces more coherent and reasonable
conclusions that closely align with the underlying premises. Code and Data are
released at https://github.com/YuanLi95/T5-LMPM
|
[
-0.18117088079452515,
-0.9688354730606079,
0.7752462029457092,
-0.13600988686084747,
-0.47702234983444214,
-0.4187523424625397,
-0.03855036944150925,
-0.42077428102493286,
0.11242885887622833,
0.40846842527389526,
-0.4395385980606079,
-0.5601499080657959,
-0.46127238869667053,
-0.07209637016057968,
-0.6942731142044067,
0.795872151851654,
-0.2550772726535797,
-0.09588948637247086,
-0.38034409284591675,
0.11203853785991669,
-0.6041427254676819,
-0.27870556712150574,
-0.6966774463653564,
-0.2569277286529541,
0.3852153718471527,
0.24735583364963531,
0.3821295499801636,
1.0289229154586792,
0.31952279806137085,
0.381939560174942,
0.43753162026405334,
0.4746084213256836,
-0.46493008732795715,
0.19466632604599,
-0.2102801650762558,
-0.569403886795044,
-0.3544251024723053,
0.13673031330108643,
0.5268599987030029,
0.4875715672969818,
-0.39422133564949036,
0.15242348611354828,
-0.16515697538852692,
0.48204830288887024,
-0.5640743374824524,
0.4182673990726471,
-0.9926086664199829,
-0.016239862889051437,
-0.2864764630794525,
-0.4812106490135193,
-0.7071239948272705,
-0.3693927526473999,
0.043411985039711,
-0.8540424108505249,
0.12559735774993896,
0.1282714158296585,
1.1186022758483887,
0.5339958667755127,
-0.009928792715072632,
-0.23653723299503326,
-0.6893294453620911,
0.4388764798641205,
-0.7219211459159851,
0.3595488369464874,
0.4865534007549286,
0.27808627486228943,
-0.23932293057441711,
-0.787534773349762,
-0.6004080772399902,
-0.12219654023647308,
-0.09426005184650421,
0.23708461225032806,
0.16415436565876007,
-0.17380084097385406,
0.33295419812202454,
-0.006085946690291166,
-0.37502461671829224,
-0.1750241369009018,
-0.24688611924648285,
-0.06241685524582863,
0.49491339921951294,
0.22425000369548798,
0.3030414581298828,
0.10561471432447433,
-0.27014973759651184,
0.2449599653482437,
-0.7926880121231079,
0.010012026876211166,
0.3092975914478302,
0.023498041555285454,
0.1823512315750122,
0.631342351436615,
-0.09124521911144257,
0.8833447098731995,
0.30925247073173523,
-0.3161757290363312,
0.14076779782772064,
-0.25282275676727295,
-0.410214900970459,
0.4791681468486786,
0.5591443777084351,
0.18481937050819397,
0.5181302428245544,
-0.33361804485321045,
-0.1547851860523224,
0.45642760396003723,
0.35491785407066345,
-1.2050113677978516,
-0.4413413405418396,
0.15477603673934937,
-0.6157504320144653,
-0.11245743930339813,
0.24601419270038605,
-0.3679828643798828,
-0.012810919433832169,
-0.5975664258003235,
0.44420310854911804,
-1.024105191230774,
-0.24082595109939575,
0.30614638328552246,
-0.032343827188014984,
0.24407847225666046,
0.6494505405426025,
-0.5703686475753784,
0.2554178535938263,
0.6700575947761536,
0.5061405897140503,
-0.02566230297088623,
-0.2969154417514801,
-0.42175742983818054,
0.7124903798103333,
-0.555284857749939,
0.7704461216926575,
-0.81502366065979,
-0.0351075679063797,
-0.2760925590991974,
-0.09746464341878891,
-0.047362178564071655,
-0.4513165056705475,
0.40721166133880615,
-0.652821958065033,
0.38243675231933594,
-0.04575052112340927,
-0.8514306545257568,
-0.40921705961227417,
0.3163159489631653,
-0.34724730253219604,
0.6758525967597961,
-0.15265478193759918,
-1.0520896911621094,
0.4576301574707031,
-0.3612865209579468,
-0.42709293961524963,
-0.09798766672611237,
-0.6533999443054199,
-0.45313236117362976,
0.04240284860134125,
0.07115048915147781,
0.29453355073928833,
-0.277785062789917,
0.5260517001152039,
-0.2276524007320404,
-0.3019832372665405,
0.09195301681756973,
-0.2558583617210388,
0.8286400437355042,
0.08723050355911255,
-0.3071672320365906,
0.1302340179681778,
-0.6961607336997986,
0.060454316437244415,
0.3571789562702179,
-0.19094452261924744,
-0.5028371214866638,
0.3808872401714325,
-0.787826418876648,
0.16100674867630005,
0.12978646159172058,
-0.3680118918418884,
-0.17853541672229767,
-0.3851412534713745,
0.20339345932006836,
0.9269123673439026,
0.05663838982582092,
0.3218967318534851,
-0.40165573358535767,
0.0539960116147995,
0.7419666051864624,
-0.23800870776176453,
-0.7094511985778809,
-0.5909250378608704,
-0.8425582051277161,
-0.21917593479156494,
0.11920695006847382,
0.4771850109100342,
-0.5447632670402527,
0.6240034103393555,
-0.3728832006454468,
-0.34962889552116394,
-0.21844330430030823,
0.005802573170512915,
0.24967065453529358,
1.0108174085617065,
0.32103216648101807,
-0.4255266487598419,
-0.5982566475868225,
-0.8024885654449463,
-0.3634629249572754,
-0.32620325684547424,
0.05954155698418617,
0.0031057028099894524,
0.5862356424331665,
-0.16807976365089417,
1.1486213207244873,
-0.4040016233921051,
-0.01944103091955185,
0.20755553245544434,
-0.038353536278009415,
0.13229496777057648,
0.6781626343727112,
0.3096795380115509,
-0.730521023273468,
-0.40272778272628784,
-0.36239442229270935,
-0.8139975666999817,
0.25083479285240173,
-0.17993521690368652,
-0.5393694043159485,
0.22695502638816833,
0.5140215754508972,
-1.241418480873108,
0.4922184646129608,
-0.06870052218437195,
-0.38576918840408325,
0.26159408688545227,
-0.1601896584033966,
0.028119903057813644,
-1.0614603757858276,
-0.06965766102075577,
-0.05594370886683464,
-0.20197363197803497,
-0.37768658995628357,
-0.13116641342639923,
-0.09790179878473282,
0.017178010195493698,
-0.19443118572235107,
0.14412373304367065,
-0.38844481110572815,
0.191973477602005,
0.03142666071653366,
-0.07755456864833832,
0.045070670545101166,
0.504456102848053,
0.19034752249717712,
0.34928905963897705,
0.6286015510559082,
-0.7599822282791138,
0.2208971530199051,
0.10936373472213745,
-0.4924432337284088,
0.3018965721130371,
-0.4138956665992737,
0.07395964860916138,
-0.5947338938713074,
0.3111928105354309,
-0.6231867671012878,
-0.308514267206192,
0.6060060262680054,
-0.4202078580856323,
0.4770767390727997,
-0.01304949726909399,
-0.495917946100235,
-0.00840873084962368,
-0.10895834863185883,
0.21568895876407623,
0.7485616207122803,
-0.5524455308914185,
0.7678743004798889,
0.3059805929660797,
0.20648331940174103,
-0.2468649446964264,
-0.49115893244743347,
-0.452218621969223,
-0.42322883009910583,
-0.8092038035392761,
0.49296465516090393,
-0.005137627478688955,
-0.4677266478538513,
0.3228755295276642,
-0.44716373085975647,
-0.02766237035393715,
-0.03994997963309288,
0.28165093064308167,
0.15361644327640533,
-0.512572169303894,
0.2846941649913788,
-0.3551587164402008,
-0.20004740357398987,
0.5057898163795471,
-0.5628613829612732,
0.4058527648448944,
-0.002070694463327527,
-0.5895167589187622,
-0.3668577969074249,
0.17666438221931458,
0.09920437633991241,
-0.4204675257205963,
0.8190015554428101,
0.2800828516483307,
-0.7889014482498169,
-0.5142107605934143,
-0.21031813323497772,
-0.2436043918132782,
-0.44645586609840393,
0.3237861394882202,
-0.4922313392162323,
-0.3633531332015991,
0.1873396635055542,
-0.31206580996513367,
0.15111050009727478,
0.5003608465194702,
0.3603445291519165,
-0.22560933232307434,
0.9651939868927002,
0.39186280965805054,
0.11955717206001282,
0.3594975471496582,
-0.11200875788927078,
0.25288936495780945,
-0.16292068362236023,
-0.4591320753097534,
-0.3819008767604828,
-0.1269499808549881,
-0.3701147437095642,
-0.5849806666374207,
-0.24078106880187988,
0.5215816497802734,
-0.7340563535690308,
-0.06157134845852852,
-0.5240039825439453,
0.5501965284347534,
0.5570886135101318,
0.3354308307170868,
0.4221137464046478,
0.3267584443092346,
0.24035613238811493,
-0.0634564533829689,
-0.7245864868164062,
-0.5949599742889404,
0.911119818687439,
0.19267132878303528,
0.7394442558288574,
0.01221241895109415,
0.8015791177749634,
0.03015369549393654,
0.4396989941596985,
-0.6369815468788147,
0.7537007331848145,
0.09262640029191971,
-0.28145354986190796,
-0.36899858713150024,
-0.5653306245803833,
-0.761162281036377,
0.04574478045105934,
0.026090338826179504,
-0.5805820822715759,
-0.19586648046970367,
0.4160946309566498,
-0.15121357142925262,
0.3460248112678528,
-0.7183380722999573,
0.8001475930213928,
-0.31975898146629333,
-0.17435002326965332,
-0.38878151774406433,
-0.4092656970024109,
0.7813381552696228,
-0.26493772864341736,
-0.007716669235378504,
-0.2305397093296051,
-0.012476326897740364,
0.7218613624572754,
-0.7419834136962891,
0.8087629079818726,
-0.3257697522640228,
-0.0956290066242218,
0.6754657626152039,
0.10546226054430008,
0.735345721244812,
0.2143053412437439,
-0.03571467474102974,
0.15199311077594757,
-0.46247398853302,
-0.28125202655792236,
-0.5910360813140869,
0.5325430035591125,
-0.7822862267494202,
-0.9701496958732605,
-0.31719210743904114,
-0.3585340976715088,
-0.1276862919330597,
0.2733767032623291,
0.27118581533432007,
0.2539713978767395,
-0.011396799236536026,
-0.05061894655227661,
1.0458221435546875,
-0.18300744891166687,
0.16870813071727753,
0.4573509693145752,
-0.18668104708194733,
0.052461251616477966,
1.0349583625793457,
0.13676397502422333,
0.010510582476854324,
0.4697783887386322,
0.12475713342428207,
0.025562815368175507,
-0.6909545660018921,
-0.31098252534866333,
-0.06560194492340088,
-0.7278518080711365,
-0.33219730854034424,
-0.5700497031211853,
-0.5318699479103088,
-0.1486961841583252,
0.13707399368286133,
-0.15802700817584991,
-0.3178505003452301,
-0.02533571980893612,
-0.1492922157049179,
0.5256989002227783,
0.46017786860466003,
0.2138337641954422,
0.05833066999912262,
-0.5236638188362122,
0.637825071811676,
0.24342697858810425,
0.2732887268066406,
0.027267474681138992,
-0.504677951335907,
-0.19210925698280334,
0.24771235883235931,
-0.3205247223377228,
-0.8972799181938171,
0.18276871740818024,
0.3065621554851532,
0.6472890973091125,
0.7295474410057068,
-0.010581581853330135,
0.8858520984649658,
-0.857387363910675,
0.3694206774234772,
0.2624271810054779,
-0.6715794205665588,
0.8581258654594421,
-0.27645567059516907,
-0.006008547265082598,
0.1521761417388916,
0.5154186487197876,
0.03797262907028198,
-0.4005086421966553,
-0.8448458909988403,
-0.6426105499267578,
0.8465831875801086,
0.11496264487504959,
-0.21266888082027435,
-0.1333274394273758,
0.3519362807273865,
0.14626994729042053,
0.10610708594322205,
-0.5092545747756958,
-0.2565346956253052,
-0.5653697848320007,
-0.426932692527771,
0.023078763857483864,
0.024781854823231697,
-0.17798253893852234,
-0.3595244288444519,
0.7634944319725037,
0.03220593184232712,
0.274792343378067,
0.05522588640451431,
-0.1906849890947342,
-0.13833066821098328,
-0.11337892711162567,
0.34411776065826416,
0.8452427387237549,
-0.12482455372810364,
0.3587377071380615,
-0.028669381514191628,
-0.43151354789733887,
0.02296522818505764,
0.12077758461236954,
-0.5715695023536682,
0.2651014029979706,
0.4666336178779602,
0.5863115787506104,
-0.2684711515903473,
-0.5829870700836182,
0.2795519530773163,
0.11632107943296432,
-0.1096283569931984,
-0.5201225876808167,
0.3847229480743408,
0.41859450936317444,
-0.021605217829346657,
0.10247471183538437,
0.33145204186439514,
-0.12985005974769592,
-0.5912330150604248,
0.2706688940525055,
0.3930050730705261,
0.06782291829586029,
-0.283139169216156,
0.6528329849243164,
0.0460636243224144,
-0.1618584394454956,
0.8787409663200378,
0.010776964016258717,
-0.1866379827260971,
0.841830313205719,
0.7558683753013611,
0.5673753619194031,
-0.24707891047000885,
0.024186208844184875,
0.5246863961219788,
0.37914901971817017,
-0.15679877996444702,
0.3711082339286804,
-0.019541993737220764,
-0.9715821743011475,
-0.4242519438266754,
-0.6251017451286316,
0.09046638011932373,
0.14984031021595,
-0.22318267822265625,
0.2829141616821289,
-0.5900516510009766,
0.16405688226222992,
-0.008784439414739609,
-0.25567132234573364,
-0.6880331039428711,
0.4057351052761078,
0.014017297886312008,
1.164509892463684,
-0.40651586651802063,
1.273762822151184,
0.4991469383239746,
-0.5936912894248962,
-1.0827664136886597,
0.13180691003799438,
-0.28255167603492737,
-0.8248465657234192,
0.7615807056427002,
0.4520968496799469,
-0.12616370618343353,
0.003437355626374483,
-0.6523892283439636,
-0.8757103085517883,
1.1153537034988403,
0.644514262676239,
-0.4912484884262085,
-0.16394229233264923,
0.11947950720787048,
0.16287001967430115,
-0.5902016162872314,
0.0836636871099472,
0.36012011766433716,
0.5956203937530518,
0.05272964760661125,
-0.1803874373435974,
0.331617534160614,
-0.26978766918182373,
-0.06986841559410095,
0.2512950301170349,
-0.40681207180023193,
0.9754812121391296,
-0.40354737639427185,
-0.5857554078102112,
-0.12064670026302338,
0.8606029152870178,
0.5947847962379456,
0.21529357135295868,
0.5394297242164612,
0.9399848580360413,
0.9074144959449768,
-0.04101698473095894,
0.7589774131774902,
-0.4952999949455261,
-0.26136118173599243,
1.5507750511169434,
-0.21337759494781494,
0.7740744352340698,
0.5065536499023438,
0.10407665371894836,
0.6730254888534546,
0.884607195854187,
0.13700485229492188,
0.558247983455658,
0.3184064030647278,
-0.08908676356077194,
-0.523338258266449,
0.019720742478966713,
-0.6724430918693542,
0.3137058913707733,
0.5529446601867676,
-0.5571767091751099,
-0.1959928572177887,
-0.6856231689453125,
-0.14768272638320923,
0.0047632381319999695,
-0.5368777513504028,
0.6205166578292847,
0.17772383987903595,
-0.8260204195976257,
0.27788442373275757,
0.16563042998313904,
0.39000004529953003,
-0.8050414323806763,
-0.4070608913898468,
-0.14330488443374634,
0.31321075558662415,
-0.39125990867614746,
-0.4974895715713501,
0.40690889954566956,
-0.05729006975889206,
-0.3085545301437378,
-0.3972921073436737,
0.910366952419281,
-0.5371013879776001,
-0.47673648595809937,
0.06957341730594635,
0.5002779364585876,
0.2213921695947647,
0.14294253289699554,
-0.4895297884941101,
-0.2916448414325714,
-0.13453203439712524,
-0.31014713644981384,
0.07275422662496567,
1.0858197212219238,
-0.2830052971839905,
0.4393670856952667,
0.8247689604759216,
-0.07688730955123901,
0.1527414619922638,
-0.10643379390239716,
0.8252708315849304,
-0.6350054740905762,
-0.5318958163261414,
-1.225109577178955,
0.45132777094841003,
-0.08894787728786469,
0.0913250744342804,
0.9671131372451782,
0.7038766145706177,
1.1184883117675781,
-0.07979881018400192,
0.5625026822090149,
0.00789061188697815,
0.263760507106781,
-0.744455873966217,
0.5744746923446655,
-0.2462790310382843,
0.20550978183746338,
-0.017027270048856735,
-0.8027981519699097,
0.08524224907159805,
0.7822483777999878,
0.02304406277835369,
0.15394632518291473,
0.702597439289093,
0.7141532897949219,
-0.2734527587890625,
0.23176155984401703,
0.06346633285284042,
0.5151212811470032,
0.008246579207479954,
0.6286736726760864,
1.0927612781524658,
-0.15633097290992737,
0.4363844394683838,
0.005628838669508696,
0.031684957444667816,
0.244707852602005,
-0.8910046219825745,
-0.8856580853462219,
-0.37403982877731323,
-0.33302736282348633,
-0.36732035875320435,
0.12066787481307983,
0.6855875253677368,
0.7402891516685486,
-0.7641725540161133,
0.0024550578091293573,
-0.6558975577354431,
0.15807309746742249,
0.10274384170770645,
-0.16142123937606812,
0.3544740080833435,
-0.44325295090675354,
-0.3276236951351166,
0.18777626752853394,
0.27320152521133423,
0.07358571141958237,
-0.10869325697422028,
-0.5097552537918091,
-0.17561182379722595,
0.18657729029655457,
0.3987566828727722,
-0.007327946834266186,
-0.7833041548728943,
-0.2449457049369812,
-0.23612704873085022,
-0.0839524045586586,
0.14649276435375214,
0.8876127004623413,
-1.090319275856018,
0.1787545531988144,
0.5130143761634827,
0.7963285446166992,
0.3791236877441406,
0.07985013723373413,
0.7256641387939453,
-0.40439116954803467,
0.18800203502178192,
0.0778970718383789,
0.6127462387084961,
0.12515874207019806,
-0.2919357717037201,
0.48719388246536255,
0.3368011713027954,
-0.004525807686150074,
-0.6187187433242798,
0.28088051080703735,
-0.5533246397972107,
-0.48876523971557617,
0.7587069869041443,
-0.3496902883052826,
-0.3073713779449463,
-0.014114533551037312,
0.030636508017778397,
0.46414437890052795,
-0.2905932664871216,
0.7583036422729492,
0.6336755156517029,
-0.17125917971134186,
-0.07567674666643143,
-0.345736563205719,
0.7271967530250549,
0.32081833481788635,
-1.1245213747024536,
-0.21262924373149872,
0.5974016785621643,
0.22758406400680542,
0.15969067811965942,
0.8250998854637146,
0.056780047714710236,
0.21171048283576965,
0.31700506806373596,
-0.24266834557056427,
-0.2075480967760086,
-0.5582420825958252,
0.17515315115451813,
0.20274896919727325,
-0.09203905612230301,
-0.28796082735061646
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09712v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09712v1
|
A Knowledge-Injected Curriculum Pretraining Framework for Question Answering
| 2024-03-11T03:42:03 | 2024-03-11T03:42:03 |
Xin Lin, Tianhuang Su, Zhenya Huang, Shangzi Xue, Haifeng Liu, Enhong Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Knowledge-based question answering (KBQA) is a key task in NLP research, and
also an approach to access the web data and knowledge, which requires
exploiting knowledge graphs (KGs) for reasoning. In the literature, one
promising solution for KBQA is to incorporate the pretrained language model
(LM) with KGs by generating KG-centered pretraining corpus, which has shown its
superiority. However, these methods often depend on specific techniques and
resources to work, which may not always be available and restrict its
application. Moreover, existing methods focus more on improving language
understanding with KGs, while neglect the more important human-like complex
reasoning. To this end, in this paper, we propose a general Knowledge-Injected
Curriculum Pretraining framework (KICP) to achieve comprehensive KG learning
and exploitation for KBQA tasks, which is composed of knowledge injection (KI),
knowledge adaptation (KA) and curriculum reasoning (CR). Specifically, the KI
module first injects knowledge into the LM by generating KG-centered
pretraining corpus, and generalizes the process into three key steps that could
work with different implementations for flexible application. Next, the KA
module learns knowledge from the generated corpus with LM equipped with an
adapter as well as keeps its original natural language understanding ability to
reduce the negative impacts of the difference between the generated and natural
corpus. Last, to enable the LM with complex reasoning, the CR module follows
human reasoning patterns to construct three corpora with increasing
difficulties of reasoning, and further trains the LM from easy to hard in a
curriculum manner. We provide an implementation of the general framework, and
evaluate the proposed KICP on four real-word datasets. The results demonstrate
that our framework can achieve higher performances.
|
[
-0.4109179973602295,
-0.7828686833381653,
0.562923014163971,
0.08500417321920395,
-0.3102332651615143,
0.055293288081884384,
0.06620378792285919,
-0.1486215889453888,
-0.07711148262023926,
0.7058979272842407,
-0.4612874388694763,
-0.5501581430435181,
-0.5479527711868286,
-0.15333682298660278,
-0.14406129717826843,
0.6162245869636536,
-0.11706153303384781,
0.13901811838150024,
-0.37662273645401,
0.13100431859493256,
-0.6664603352546692,
-0.5149793028831482,
-0.36991164088249207,
-0.26567795872688293,
0.26485535502433777,
0.43192946910858154,
0.4709429442882538,
0.2825823426246643,
0.04553679749369621,
0.22313447296619415,
0.13256828486919403,
0.18995052576065063,
-0.35298171639442444,
-0.21696992218494415,
-0.16470447182655334,
-0.6467088460922241,
-0.2599778473377228,
-0.08555146306753159,
0.48165714740753174,
0.7812243700027466,
-0.16357934474945068,
-0.042748525738716125,
0.18017013370990753,
0.7185861468315125,
-1.0769026279449463,
0.13658075034618378,
-0.6824660897254944,
-0.017673464491963387,
0.1325138509273529,
-0.15152719616889954,
-0.49790093302726746,
-0.4850795567035675,
0.35058748722076416,
-1.0800474882125854,
-0.16668832302093506,
0.03757763281464577,
0.8300150632858276,
0.13656920194625854,
-0.5811563730239868,
-0.7230893969535828,
-0.26321399211883545,
0.6537476181983948,
-0.6205772161483765,
0.5150477886199951,
0.6412002444267273,
0.7140974402427673,
-0.21440140902996063,
-1.0642575025558472,
-0.6995423436164856,
0.03820766136050224,
-0.28104448318481445,
0.34671980142593384,
0.18667072057724,
0.2698996961116791,
-0.08590272814035416,
0.02045176550745964,
-0.6488972306251526,
-0.160832941532135,
-0.41531381011009216,
-0.4024845063686371,
0.06481615453958511,
0.050062887370586395,
0.3354901671409607,
-0.23653960227966309,
-0.3056288957595825,
-0.06770381331443787,
-0.6592692136764526,
0.28015902638435364,
0.3855796456336975,
0.25125378370285034,
-0.03843695670366287,
0.2675393223762512,
-0.4455539584159851,
0.8669017553329468,
-0.12515632808208466,
-0.041986752301454544,
0.1439276784658432,
-0.09613601118326187,
-0.3010472059249878,
0.14368164539337158,
0.4981885254383087,
0.20954403281211853,
0.5958952307701111,
-0.36875972151756287,
0.3646600842475891,
-0.1192021295428276,
0.6079931855201721,
-0.8336347341537476,
-0.33454060554504395,
0.1474328339099884,
-0.10541097819805145,
-0.23557932674884796,
-0.288085013628006,
-0.6715470552444458,
0.046220600605010986,
-0.3778316378593445,
0.7062478065490723,
-0.6812155842781067,
-0.1894860863685608,
0.4646940529346466,
-0.06497768312692642,
0.5195279121398926,
0.3977258801460266,
-0.6154201626777649,
0.08565644919872284,
0.5363997220993042,
0.35110995173454285,
-0.06001158431172371,
-0.11716394126415253,
-0.21865983307361603,
0.3584871292114258,
-0.2692849040031433,
0.6549541354179382,
-0.5372796058654785,
-0.2136813849210739,
0.1578841507434845,
-0.046580780297517776,
-0.2388884574174881,
-0.3638356924057007,
0.3315369188785553,
-1.1170583963394165,
0.5019239783287048,
-0.4130648076534271,
-0.6233590841293335,
-0.2775612771511078,
0.6357364058494568,
-0.2387838512659073,
0.8672181963920593,
0.3415501117706299,
-0.7556674480438232,
0.2954241931438446,
-0.7452033758163452,
-0.26671698689460754,
0.18561293184757233,
-0.1575978547334671,
-0.040436286479234695,
-0.6361692547798157,
0.4201582372188568,
0.4050276279449463,
-0.34812673926353455,
0.5541523694992065,
-0.08674909174442291,
-0.3966502249240875,
-0.08409924060106277,
0.08661539107561111,
1.0293692350387573,
0.19668832421302795,
-0.15668566524982452,
-0.13984446227550507,
-0.6991919875144958,
0.6196720600128174,
-0.0585588663816452,
-0.44086089730262756,
-0.2313614934682846,
-0.26428112387657166,
-0.432862788438797,
0.16513592004776,
0.0769294872879982,
-0.34988224506378174,
0.12700864672660828,
-0.6389564275741577,
0.31777745485305786,
0.5493274927139282,
0.2144034057855606,
0.5714776515960693,
-0.07706940919160843,
0.7875649929046631,
0.26174405217170715,
0.035221587866544724,
0.029262395575642586,
-0.41194242238998413,
-0.7112331390380859,
-0.25915175676345825,
0.3941802680492401,
0.7612936496734619,
-1.2466524839401245,
0.444324254989624,
-0.07933437824249268,
-0.632479727268219,
-0.4850839078426361,
0.10661880671977997,
0.6626446843147278,
0.9695213437080383,
0.7190138697624207,
-0.18956899642944336,
-0.39331725239753723,
-0.849970281124115,
-0.2318262755870819,
-0.26189523935317993,
-0.30740949511528015,
0.25629207491874695,
0.29757803678512573,
-0.006433731876313686,
1.2778525352478027,
-0.736748218536377,
-0.07690025120973587,
-0.37415602803230286,
0.20432141423225403,
0.18789564073085785,
0.5143219828605652,
0.5628646016120911,
-0.8579307198524475,
-0.4191558361053467,
-0.3760782480239868,
-0.6444430351257324,
-0.15910747647285461,
0.16942866146564484,
-0.6456884145736694,
-0.23594877123832703,
0.3750954568386078,
-0.39910897612571716,
0.4212336540222168,
0.19058889150619507,
-0.30319857597351074,
1.0035419464111328,
-0.01845887489616871,
0.24735714495182037,
-1.0692418813705444,
0.15270023047924042,
-0.4805755913257599,
-0.00764768011868,
-0.7288408875465393,
0.11347370594739914,
0.2557731568813324,
-0.1840202659368515,
-0.7364869713783264,
0.5937677025794983,
-0.06036121025681496,
0.19003631174564362,
-0.03432079404592514,
0.1664978414773941,
0.34401893615722656,
0.8100023865699768,
-0.013032247312366962,
0.6963168978691101,
0.4034861922264099,
-0.8875985145568848,
0.10848589986562729,
0.40164947509765625,
-0.6181552410125732,
0.39060738682746887,
-0.5367684364318848,
0.19329208135604858,
-0.40809303522109985,
0.37080448865890503,
-0.9078494906425476,
-0.09223438054323196,
0.40583178400993347,
-0.3914758265018463,
0.22425715625286102,
-0.0423857681453228,
-0.28771862387657166,
-0.3274950385093689,
-0.032699380069971085,
0.45965930819511414,
0.39815035462379456,
-0.38394322991371155,
0.7641012668609619,
0.12100904434919357,
-0.024894852191209793,
-0.9564704298973083,
-0.5302435755729675,
-0.33257201313972473,
0.0501251257956028,
-0.5029088854789734,
0.31393003463745117,
-0.16381625831127167,
0.32387402653694153,
0.12299907952547073,
0.1063305214047432,
-0.5596608519554138,
0.15500283241271973,
-0.0013567113783210516,
0.227522075176239,
-0.37208348512649536,
0.25338029861450195,
0.35794511437416077,
-0.13582472503185272,
0.07414156198501587,
-0.3334234058856964,
0.7140254974365234,
-0.11037018895149231,
-0.4846158027648926,
-0.3025941848754883,
0.16243408620357513,
0.27818670868873596,
-0.22585909068584442,
0.671093761920929,
0.5625532865524292,
-0.2236286848783493,
0.03266989812254906,
-0.6079167723655701,
-0.034836865961551666,
-0.488239049911499,
0.5870378613471985,
-0.38483938574790955,
-1.0656036138534546,
0.22260349988937378,
-0.35330137610435486,
-0.1335759162902832,
0.17769357562065125,
0.39223819971084595,
-0.23473408818244934,
0.6499652862548828,
0.3161892294883728,
-0.0417376384139061,
-0.10686562210321426,
-0.23635654151439667,
0.2649397552013397,
-0.8079962730407715,
-0.2597018778324127,
-0.5443596839904785,
-0.10764812678098679,
-0.1455114781856537,
-0.47157007455825806,
0.2366776019334793,
0.7611552476882935,
-0.6546041369438171,
0.16328567266464233,
-0.42967426776885986,
0.551875114440918,
0.49522408843040466,
0.09390275180339813,
-0.0076930103823542595,
-0.2578282654285431,
-0.6685989499092102,
0.046387046575546265,
-0.8473008871078491,
-0.41936904191970825,
1.1453038454055786,
-0.09050372987985611,
0.17337413132190704,
-0.032951947301626205,
0.4082460105419159,
0.06567773222923279,
0.4911991059780121,
-0.45918339490890503,
0.6213105320930481,
0.06588312983512878,
-0.7490405440330505,
-0.2493385672569275,
-0.39024409651756287,
-0.7505174279212952,
0.15841808915138245,
-0.32710927724838257,
-0.8086950778961182,
-0.00343951303511858,
0.376855731010437,
-0.2696394920349121,
0.17327317595481873,
-0.8519590497016907,
0.9864658713340759,
-0.2059628963470459,
-0.06555897742509842,
-0.03350093215703964,
-0.9560022354125977,
0.4112212359905243,
-0.10919317603111267,
0.22541217505931854,
0.11274129897356033,
0.17448236048221588,
0.692704975605011,
-0.210932195186615,
0.7389577627182007,
-0.6740515232086182,
0.266032874584198,
0.6283547282218933,
-0.012380789034068584,
0.27355918288230896,
-0.09538102895021439,
-0.1499699056148529,
-0.16611343622207642,
0.301281601190567,
-0.6652052402496338,
-0.8235269784927368,
0.16629399359226227,
-0.9689334034919739,
-0.6860811710357666,
0.05386162921786308,
-0.6956015229225159,
-0.7888185381889343,
0.3677518665790558,
0.04874471575021744,
0.30016881227493286,
-0.17741510272026062,
0.348247766494751,
0.504718005657196,
-0.6117461323738098,
-0.11716575175523758,
0.4489513039588928,
-0.3242643177509308,
-0.6096875071525574,
0.7741659879684448,
0.050326909869909286,
0.5115218758583069,
0.6118531823158264,
0.3134441673755646,
-0.4458725154399872,
-0.4197116792201996,
-0.5945145487785339,
-0.040657296776771545,
-0.8446253538131714,
-0.2490576207637787,
-0.8927952647209167,
-0.3195466101169586,
-0.7250837683677673,
-0.5053784251213074,
-0.05203990265727043,
-0.3247147500514984,
-0.01815570518374443,
0.035066284239292145,
-0.03590976074337959,
0.20803198218345642,
0.3427256941795349,
0.7576729655265808,
-0.7371329069137573,
0.415508508682251,
0.6943629384040833,
0.14836490154266357,
0.19961991906166077,
-0.4676612317562103,
-0.07112476229667664,
0.17706122994422913,
-0.4230613112449646,
-0.8335022926330566,
0.12027386575937271,
0.15280257165431976,
0.5966708064079285,
0.39238816499710083,
0.23385001718997955,
0.8261155486106873,
-0.32320812344551086,
0.6418654322624207,
0.25687870383262634,
-0.7841589450836182,
0.36860015988349915,
-0.1890108585357666,
0.6594604849815369,
0.8825634717941284,
0.8382920026779175,
-0.43064749240875244,
-0.3531458377838135,
-0.43656888604164124,
-0.8038696646690369,
0.612766444683075,
0.11198977380990982,
0.10443639755249023,
-0.05857706442475319,
0.7037140727043152,
-0.013609147630631924,
0.4764805734157562,
-0.5735887289047241,
-0.06346222013235092,
-0.44013074040412903,
-0.4244951903820038,
0.362672358751297,
-0.326076865196228,
0.1131264716386795,
-0.382720947265625,
0.9133963584899902,
-0.2935125529766083,
0.10998581349849701,
0.07017749547958374,
-0.3564346134662628,
0.40066781640052795,
0.3769940137863159,
0.18738259375095367,
0.7294167876243591,
-0.2769334316253662,
0.10245199501514435,
0.42873868346214294,
-0.6145877838134766,
0.08720964938402176,
-0.1690850704908371,
-0.14497289061546326,
-0.49195224046707153,
0.31900784373283386,
0.46483492851257324,
0.3780314326286316,
-0.8583834171295166,
0.6906355619430542,
0.051040168851614,
-0.4011287987232208,
-0.17536970973014832,
0.22627505660057068,
0.676691472530365,
0.13210944831371307,
0.35145074129104614,
-0.353208988904953,
-0.16619299352169037,
-0.2912653088569641,
0.2230660766363144,
0.2376459240913391,
-0.32600417733192444,
-0.012665917165577412,
0.42271479964256287,
0.03463270142674446,
-0.07235928624868393,
0.8801859617233276,
-0.3831718862056732,
-0.9123095870018005,
0.6374507546424866,
0.7564737200737,
0.3566237688064575,
-0.2992948591709137,
0.2609044015407562,
0.6262515187263489,
0.19559605419635773,
0.30654507875442505,
0.305378794670105,
-0.3013865351676941,
-1.0680737495422363,
-0.6510033011436462,
-0.9268142580986023,
-0.3268069326877594,
0.23418590426445007,
-0.7004395127296448,
0.36090731620788574,
-0.4081122577190399,
0.39356714487075806,
-0.25657764077186584,
-0.07839799672365189,
-0.7582556009292603,
0.569602906703949,
-0.2273278832435608,
1.0369395017623901,
-0.7263336777687073,
1.0022671222686768,
0.6695107817649841,
-0.2421119064092636,
-1.1839033365249634,
-0.14610709249973297,
-0.269713819026947,
-1.1196179389953613,
0.8638647794723511,
0.2660103440284729,
0.08361271023750305,
0.3065353333950043,
-0.5128864049911499,
-0.6085329055786133,
1.2908929586410522,
0.40055492520332336,
-0.23433509469032288,
-0.3430132567882538,
0.6155949831008911,
0.3114042580127716,
-0.41255906224250793,
0.23989945650100708,
0.3533143997192383,
0.5321663022041321,
0.45425868034362793,
-0.4263104498386383,
-0.050321776419878006,
-0.1298808753490448,
-0.37950068712234497,
0.17323197424411774,
-0.19928386807441711,
0.36564019322395325,
0.11448618769645691,
-0.039231665432453156,
-0.16181398928165436,
0.6028990745544434,
0.40666434168815613,
0.19492629170417786,
0.8047797679901123,
0.8541936874389648,
0.6513650417327881,
0.1434231698513031,
0.6576966643333435,
-0.38406825065612793,
0.0543823204934597,
1.207579255104065,
-0.16669103503227234,
0.6458988189697266,
0.31145790219306946,
-0.3123369812965393,
0.5443654656410217,
0.33188262581825256,
0.4728778600692749,
0.6811981797218323,
0.36183133721351624,
-0.2123325765132904,
-0.6301793456077576,
0.008113539777696133,
-0.5039281249046326,
0.5355408191680908,
0.503905177116394,
-0.08476967364549637,
-0.497504323720932,
-0.0270833820104599,
0.07173782587051392,
-0.04260044917464256,
-0.23882320523262024,
0.5269210934638977,
0.026835236698389053,
-0.6744866967201233,
0.47729793190956116,
-0.16971364617347717,
0.3432917594909668,
-1.0619856119155884,
-0.14129985868930817,
0.2273920476436615,
-0.22544695436954498,
0.030411366373300552,
-0.6127880811691284,
0.29914647340774536,
-0.06076670438051224,
0.003895675530657172,
-0.154593363404274,
1.023928165435791,
-0.3953317105770111,
-0.33901312947273254,
0.30982428789138794,
0.6349396705627441,
0.1540527492761612,
-0.021446075290441513,
-0.6349917054176331,
-0.5207390785217285,
0.03345029428601265,
-0.31722262501716614,
0.5722931623458862,
0.565060555934906,
0.14641578495502472,
0.505159318447113,
0.8187735676765442,
-0.11093053221702576,
0.0007494171732105315,
-0.05621296912431717,
1.0953209400177002,
-0.38518041372299194,
-0.6701896786689758,
-0.3732406795024872,
0.551551878452301,
0.03973362222313881,
-0.23601149022579193,
0.17101092636585236,
0.4942881464958191,
0.7644014954566956,
-0.0015216906322166324,
0.6578627228736877,
-0.19290481507778168,
0.4489833414554596,
-0.5461416244506836,
0.9572314620018005,
-0.3610847592353821,
-0.1445501446723938,
-0.33063483238220215,
-0.6589095592498779,
-0.23877689242362976,
0.4924700856208801,
-0.6017836928367615,
-0.13930733501911163,
0.659119725227356,
0.8500727415084839,
0.019750051200389862,
0.19366680085659027,
0.41770845651626587,
0.09382675588130951,
0.2453845888376236,
0.7308367490768433,
0.6664378643035889,
-0.10137882083654404,
0.8055513501167297,
-0.2844218313694,
-0.14389388263225555,
0.07645706087350845,
-1.0491509437561035,
-0.6904363632202148,
-0.5992023944854736,
0.0089271180331707,
-0.2889440655708313,
0.3169856667518616,
0.7588016986846924,
0.6287747025489807,
-0.7084755897521973,
0.15910950303077698,
-0.23539334535598755,
-0.027699876576662064,
0.14403986930847168,
-0.26740381121635437,
0.708737313747406,
-0.5217982530593872,
-0.32794302701950073,
0.21271029114723206,
0.0325007401406765,
-0.31558510661125183,
0.027256950736045837,
-0.22985777258872986,
-0.5918054580688477,
-0.0881301760673523,
0.5878535509109497,
0.1841878890991211,
-0.3595432937145233,
-0.6525938510894775,
-0.020231178030371666,
0.08782093226909637,
-0.02313532866537571,
0.7421558499336243,
-1.0962883234024048,
0.6681426167488098,
0.3623557686805725,
1.2946628332138062,
0.45051246881484985,
-0.03687911480665207,
0.4888767898082733,
-0.7847601175308228,
0.1553068459033966,
0.41033458709716797,
0.08146167546510696,
-0.03517848625779152,
-0.13573677837848663,
0.30073195695877075,
0.17100965976715088,
-0.4471869170665741,
-0.6185824871063232,
0.3369166851043701,
-0.8473430871963501,
-0.4377157986164093,
0.7968407273292542,
-0.4491795003414154,
-0.12259677797555923,
-0.5738065838813782,
-0.10646242648363113,
0.5461282134056091,
0.08058753609657288,
0.6797782778739929,
0.8930610418319702,
0.0077268886379897594,
0.11377175152301788,
-0.7279115319252014,
0.31081104278564453,
0.6584358215332031,
-0.9060282707214355,
-0.2433098703622818,
0.17256125807762146,
0.3287316560745239,
0.22901791334152222,
0.8626512885093689,
-0.16879776120185852,
0.32656002044677734,
-0.32009032368659973,
0.19771400094032288,
-0.23176680505275726,
-0.1673685610294342,
0.4596812129020691,
0.4860835075378418,
-0.009644837118685246,
-0.006131697911769152
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06402v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06402v1
|
'One size doesn't fit all': Learning how many Examples to use for In-Context Learning for Improved Text Classification
| 2024-03-11T03:28:13 | 2024-03-11T03:28:13 |
Manish Chandra, Debasis Ganguly, Yiwen Li, Iadh Ounis
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Predictive models in natural language processing (NLP) have evolved from
training models from scratch to fine-tuning pre-trained models with labelled
data. An extreme form of this fine-tuning involves in-context learning (ICL),
where the output of a pre-trained generative model (frozen decoder parameters)
is controlled only with variations in the input strings (called instructions or
prompts). An important component of ICL is the use of a small number of
labelled data instances as examples in the prompt. While existing work uses a
static number of examples during inference for each data instance, in this
paper we propose a novel methodology of dynamically adapting the number of
examples as per the data. This is analogous to the use of a variable-sized
neighborhood in k-nearest neighbors (k-NN) classifier. In our proposed workflow
of adaptive ICL (AICL), the number of demonstrations to employ during the
inference on a particular data instance is predicted by the Softmax posteriors
of a classifier. The parameters of this classifier are fitted on the optimal
number of examples in ICL required to correctly infer the label of each
instance in the training set with the hypothesis that a test instance that is
similar to a training instance should use the same (or a closely matching)
number of few-shot examples. Our experiments show that our AICL method results
in improvement in text classification task on several standard datasets.
|
[
-0.48753347992897034,
-0.6693440079689026,
0.43998047709465027,
0.03701423481106758,
-0.5619000792503357,
-0.12148763984441757,
-0.24588148295879364,
-0.18967054784297943,
-0.39588066935539246,
0.3137001693248749,
-0.34848111867904663,
-0.6084527969360352,
-0.42554983496665955,
0.4194018542766571,
-0.3295809030532837,
1.339842677116394,
-0.07848072797060013,
-0.17814311385154724,
-0.32763129472732544,
-0.3700619041919708,
-0.4887072741985321,
-0.2864813506603241,
-0.5407330989837646,
-0.19794976711273193,
0.3697763979434967,
0.886362612247467,
0.3387422561645508,
0.6909291744232178,
0.19603098928928375,
0.2553046941757202,
-0.09004643559455872,
0.25157710909843445,
-0.28832536935806274,
0.09210268408060074,
0.07809273898601532,
-0.4523874521255493,
0.014215708710253239,
0.010528339073061943,
0.9024367332458496,
0.4370674192905426,
-0.07384897023439407,
0.11758029460906982,
0.2820882797241211,
0.4690922200679779,
-0.5624370574951172,
-0.07968796789646149,
-0.7597259879112244,
0.11216194927692413,
0.012723542749881744,
-0.16789253056049347,
-0.6552246809005737,
-0.1965067982673645,
0.3789980113506317,
-0.6341874003410339,
0.17177213728427887,
0.20056280493736267,
0.21687112748622894,
0.37008973956108093,
-0.4886600971221924,
-0.5436670184135437,
-0.42361220717430115,
0.8573362231254578,
-0.9867695569992065,
0.12788324058055878,
0.2987273931503296,
0.285531222820282,
-0.22052498161792755,
-0.6909676194190979,
-0.4829617738723755,
-0.039160434156656265,
-0.2306336760520935,
0.0011059948010370135,
0.0055294157937169075,
-0.14073269069194794,
0.2617812752723694,
-0.13831660151481628,
-0.5094785094261169,
0.35541674494743347,
-0.22762270271778107,
0.11698584258556366,
0.41131487488746643,
0.0857747495174408,
0.129479318857193,
0.2349170446395874,
-0.3634800612926483,
-0.18245720863342285,
-0.4122912585735321,
0.011782164685428143,
-0.023422816768288612,
0.4665313959121704,
-0.19862255454063416,
-0.021079936996102333,
-0.11155549436807632,
1.0607073307037354,
0.18656492233276367,
-0.3789721727371216,
0.20677030086517334,
-0.10748816281557083,
-0.27939677238464355,
0.5093326568603516,
0.6520900726318359,
0.1250290721654892,
0.15330378711223602,
-0.03268709033727646,
0.07390078902244568,
-0.33413055539131165,
0.2419487088918686,
-1.0232694149017334,
-0.10679496824741364,
-0.05799094960093498,
-0.4607546329498291,
-0.4703024923801422,
-0.006284030620008707,
-0.946509063243866,
-0.3323885202407837,
-0.2509022653102875,
0.5245406627655029,
-0.43904921412467957,
0.23205821216106415,
0.18212459981441498,
-0.06641726940870285,
-0.00247041299007833,
0.4176803529262543,
-0.8336904048919678,
0.480830579996109,
0.3188962936401367,
1.0252938270568848,
-0.25927212834358215,
-0.3350529074668884,
-0.5710852146148682,
-0.02131582796573639,
-0.2925058603286743,
0.9104702472686768,
-0.5985745191574097,
-0.09776400774717331,
-0.03937777504324913,
-0.2175559401512146,
-0.16893886029720306,
-0.5002034306526184,
0.47388285398483276,
-0.17214173078536987,
0.4543909430503845,
0.08685155212879181,
-0.7285683751106262,
-0.10784308612346649,
0.23715171217918396,
-0.32910192012786865,
0.7563951015472412,
0.19414035975933075,
-0.8097050189971924,
0.5161904692649841,
-0.7859749794006348,
-0.4092070758342743,
0.132462278008461,
-0.07543403655290604,
-0.8115381598472595,
0.2537757456302643,
0.2662699222564697,
0.653024435043335,
-0.1753772497177124,
0.048087023198604584,
-0.3426209092140198,
-0.4611090123653412,
0.3324221968650818,
-0.5088565349578857,
0.7009087204933167,
0.19245269894599915,
-0.33470356464385986,
0.2788602113723755,
-0.7107940912246704,
0.01500725094228983,
-0.24250482022762299,
-0.40676119923591614,
-0.4562971293926239,
-0.001431480050086975,
0.1601213663816452,
0.2833790183067322,
-0.19798186421394348,
-0.4762601852416992,
0.3330661356449127,
-0.43068715929985046,
0.4576835632324219,
0.7172563076019287,
0.18743015825748444,
0.6449339985847473,
-0.5316091179847717,
0.42625412344932556,
-0.034042470157146454,
-0.08944184333086014,
-0.3637767434120178,
-0.3410183787345886,
-0.5116257667541504,
-0.36191436648368835,
0.4834328889846802,
0.37975987792015076,
-0.6875929832458496,
0.4529998004436493,
-0.18037912249565125,
-0.6285609006881714,
-0.2561433017253876,
0.21182096004486084,
0.19396494328975677,
0.5855088233947754,
0.3053777813911438,
-0.07942776381969452,
-0.3700858950614929,
-0.6041719913482666,
-0.23509803414344788,
-0.11946341395378113,
-0.12448233366012573,
0.3109607696533203,
0.5179600119590759,
-0.026125213131308556,
1.0086491107940674,
-0.23544372618198395,
-0.4639895558357239,
-0.2545016407966614,
0.1479048728942871,
0.15664473176002502,
0.46390241384506226,
0.7838783860206604,
-0.9237357378005981,
-0.9355473518371582,
0.0763712003827095,
-0.5619993805885315,
-0.12492376565933228,
-0.5160447359085083,
0.0265094805508852,
0.11762137711048126,
0.715395987033844,
0.024104489013552666,
0.49418726563453674,
0.39664989709854126,
-0.3817051649093628,
0.24108366668224335,
-0.490972638130188,
-0.28233954310417175,
-0.9849974513053894,
-0.5099219083786011,
0.22734373807907104,
-0.2712249159812927,
-0.6174209117889404,
-0.08325862884521484,
0.20741787552833557,
0.12372986227273941,
-0.3469081521034241,
0.7724267840385437,
-0.32169610261917114,
0.26561233401298523,
-0.4551878869533539,
-0.015970541164278984,
-0.1611100286245346,
0.3567708432674408,
-0.21071533858776093,
0.6811078786849976,
0.6003649234771729,
-0.8261460065841675,
0.03958193212747574,
0.247726172208786,
-0.5441350936889648,
0.5095742344856262,
-0.253841757774353,
0.18930916488170624,
-0.38906148076057434,
0.5183323621749878,
-1.1251165866851807,
-0.1708168089389801,
0.08566208928823471,
-0.16292020678520203,
0.31705135107040405,
0.09247567504644394,
-0.5576629042625427,
0.009366207756102085,
-0.2681843340396881,
0.4806387722492218,
0.5561583042144775,
-1.0157878398895264,
0.6822562217712402,
0.0662459284067154,
-0.050808582454919815,
-0.2695445418357849,
-0.5334605574607849,
-0.043818142265081406,
-0.6578558087348938,
-0.060237348079681396,
0.4888472557067871,
-0.4871132969856262,
-0.03931518271565437,
-0.07578977197408676,
-0.1028905138373375,
-0.3325612246990204,
0.35003986954689026,
0.05656464025378227,
-0.07885709404945374,
-0.13575226068496704,
0.4594844579696655,
0.37791600823402405,
0.1024603545665741,
-0.3007377088069916,
-0.4990776777267456,
0.20945732295513153,
-0.19086097180843353,
-0.0020434455946087837,
-0.47101107239723206,
0.297882616519928,
0.6163737177848816,
0.1749873161315918,
0.7616912722587585,
0.5712748169898987,
-0.417130708694458,
-0.6711342930793762,
-0.1718207448720932,
-0.21825458109378815,
-0.43937915563583374,
0.444570392370224,
-0.35015058517456055,
-0.8632826805114746,
0.23209604620933533,
-0.10851890593767166,
0.18992513418197632,
0.1814863085746765,
0.4627158045768738,
0.019272271543741226,
1.0444982051849365,
0.8336920142173767,
-0.21122333407402039,
0.6396274566650391,
0.09562638401985168,
0.20898188650608063,
-0.6705588102340698,
0.0626857578754425,
-0.5727571845054626,
-0.2853766083717346,
-0.6741176843643188,
-0.16853301227092743,
0.41969817876815796,
0.10659186542034149,
-0.25550276041030884,
0.24841688573360443,
-0.6768105030059814,
0.6797745823860168,
0.43700772523880005,
0.303750216960907,
0.1302289366722107,
0.18388471007347107,
-0.10347793251276016,
0.0014883914263918996,
-1.10426926612854,
-0.4589272439479828,
0.8604437112808228,
0.16936419904232025,
0.5269131064414978,
0.23787641525268555,
0.549453854560852,
0.32627758383750916,
0.7105423212051392,
-0.8668371438980103,
0.3150538504123688,
-0.6173455119132996,
-0.40667644143104553,
-0.360442578792572,
-0.2506946623325348,
-0.8360015749931335,
0.3549227714538574,
-0.31791985034942627,
-0.738267183303833,
0.23267215490341187,
0.2628425657749176,
-0.2514795660972595,
0.28392496705055237,
-0.6353284120559692,
0.835883378982544,
-0.18400752544403076,
-0.1740345060825348,
0.029190242290496826,
-0.4141652286052704,
-0.0024773606564849615,
-0.5571151375770569,
0.2713097929954529,
0.10079111158847809,
-0.10873740166425705,
0.679755687713623,
-0.16919736564159393,
1.0843571424484253,
-0.04539389908313751,
0.10989965498447418,
0.36931365728378296,
-0.178924098610878,
0.45458969473838806,
0.036125801503658295,
-0.37196066975593567,
-0.18197758495807648,
-0.04199375584721565,
-0.48426732420921326,
-0.700374186038971,
0.4911821782588959,
-0.5247690677642822,
-0.09727037698030472,
-0.49351224303245544,
-0.594048261642456,
-0.20185783505439758,
0.002741311676800251,
0.6290287971496582,
0.6301314234733582,
0.03444519639015198,
0.7221404910087585,
0.5718769431114197,
-0.2630610466003418,
0.6592801809310913,
0.3446628749370575,
0.1957862824201584,
-0.1391168087720871,
0.6623688340187073,
0.18318134546279907,
0.13176995515823364,
0.568911075592041,
0.582374095916748,
-0.1380682736635208,
-0.8116021752357483,
-0.41034406423568726,
-0.08940048515796661,
-0.7357526421546936,
-0.4927423894405365,
-0.5648901462554932,
0.04365384951233864,
-0.26769906282424927,
-0.47768571972846985,
0.08432552963495255,
0.037880174815654755,
-0.6020287871360779,
0.08451046049594879,
0.43077895045280457,
0.639974057674408,
0.3229548931121826,
0.7686038613319397,
-0.524024486541748,
0.04026300832629204,
0.3734428584575653,
0.4885973632335663,
0.16762545704841614,
-0.9821314215660095,
-0.24295474588871002,
-0.2441747486591339,
-0.02848139964044094,
-0.8831889033317566,
0.5819542407989502,
0.6769802570343018,
0.6230664849281311,
0.3363804221153259,
0.33645838499069214,
0.48124197125434875,
-0.6502804160118103,
0.36042487621307373,
0.09397079050540924,
-0.8501158356666565,
0.3986499309539795,
-0.1618552803993225,
0.6788042783737183,
0.6946207880973816,
0.5793489217758179,
-0.5131590366363525,
-0.1691734492778778,
-0.5286714434623718,
-0.6682291626930237,
0.6438477635383606,
-0.03908570483326912,
0.18107864260673523,
0.05999035760760307,
0.6686418056488037,
0.4141387939453125,
-0.0076967282220721245,
-0.6992865800857544,
-0.06710229814052582,
-0.037796054035425186,
-0.9101051092147827,
-0.05963653326034546,
-0.3502829670906067,
0.19689379632472992,
-0.4065958261489868,
0.6933141946792603,
-0.6714633107185364,
0.09414483606815338,
0.08217009902000427,
-0.20798875391483307,
0.24129383265972137,
0.36788660287857056,
0.6399405002593994,
0.7400663495063782,
-0.14153288304805756,
0.16923102736473083,
0.639128565788269,
-0.4405505657196045,
0.134104385972023,
-0.1051250696182251,
-0.3205574154853821,
0.15198102593421936,
0.3398814797401428,
0.8632095456123352,
0.21703870594501495,
-0.6967836618423462,
0.4035446345806122,
-0.26696160435676575,
-0.40500974655151367,
-0.28198060393333435,
0.16238723695278168,
-0.4399147927761078,
0.1958693265914917,
0.42266368865966797,
0.014474458992481232,
0.17418088018894196,
-0.5000616312026978,
0.3950290381908417,
0.2294492870569229,
-0.7563787698745728,
0.028867851942777634,
0.2916095554828644,
-0.1581304967403412,
-0.4623081386089325,
0.5392531156539917,
-0.35185712575912476,
-0.4766896069049835,
0.648405909538269,
0.8287956118583679,
0.6859118342399597,
-0.07972947508096695,
0.28109055757522583,
0.36856508255004883,
0.06319216638803482,
-0.2660047113895416,
-0.3354604244232178,
-0.06621014326810837,
-0.8367688059806824,
-0.31755465269088745,
-0.6093946099281311,
-0.32784736156463623,
0.17048411071300507,
-0.48451879620552063,
0.26913198828697205,
-0.6221732497215271,
0.24253712594509125,
0.3033590018749237,
-0.10267054289579391,
-0.6222696900367737,
0.15876659750938416,
-0.03220633044838905,
0.9632782340049744,
-1.0741688013076782,
1.041617751121521,
0.7584114670753479,
0.013459879904985428,
-0.4539153277873993,
0.139059379696846,
0.032570455223321915,
-0.16367942094802856,
0.4720943868160248,
0.3885757625102997,
0.2630831003189087,
0.0580228753387928,
-0.8594050407409668,
-0.6648241877555847,
0.7710269093513489,
0.06551056355237961,
-0.46607235074043274,
0.35976314544677734,
-0.3083758056163788,
0.6143513321876526,
-0.9354599118232727,
0.07303059846162796,
0.4198017120361328,
0.2836836874485016,
-0.2470884919166565,
-0.7220735549926758,
-0.040629979223012924,
-0.08961792290210724,
0.036651961505413055,
0.048187535256147385,
-0.4299573004245758,
0.6258571743965149,
-0.20577475428581238,
0.10297304391860962,
0.21147267520427704,
0.43561631441116333,
0.35904940962791443,
0.5051301121711731,
0.9028891921043396,
0.02444174885749817,
0.7036397457122803,
0.1541748344898224,
1.0645307302474976,
0.19400754570960999,
0.2660214900970459,
1.3263099193572998,
-0.01023212168365717,
0.7520349621772766,
0.2910071313381195,
0.05742466822266579,
0.6064243316650391,
0.6834180951118469,
-0.17145584523677826,
0.4874638319015503,
0.270060658454895,
-0.3290947675704956,
-0.15027645230293274,
-0.06966957449913025,
0.10804177075624466,
0.5594934225082397,
0.437404066324234,
-0.32182496786117554,
-0.19999977946281433,
0.501525342464447,
-0.13411591947078705,
0.3258320093154907,
-0.19616320729255676,
0.9458563923835754,
-0.17202040553092957,
-0.4259042739868164,
0.38090550899505615,
0.015643645077943802,
0.8855076432228088,
-0.4047062397003174,
-0.18925167620182037,
-0.08246953785419464,
0.269226610660553,
-0.09142560511827469,
-0.4780743420124054,
-0.15154439210891724,
-0.05291853845119476,
-0.27267467975616455,
-0.24801339209079742,
0.6912555694580078,
-0.3389240503311157,
-0.7203913331031799,
0.03336859121918678,
0.019576357677578926,
0.23646949231624603,
-0.07743887603282928,
-0.5895426869392395,
-0.2547987103462219,
0.19956183433532715,
-0.04916936159133911,
0.6498433947563171,
0.6501895785331726,
-0.264375776052475,
0.5806200504302979,
0.36371910572052,
-0.1572885662317276,
0.09672079980373383,
-0.0740821436047554,
0.6481693983078003,
-0.41996607184410095,
-0.5247974395751953,
-0.8404163718223572,
0.3770076334476471,
-0.20499947667121887,
-0.566037654876709,
0.6081384420394897,
0.4231220781803131,
1.034706950187683,
-0.013782352209091187,
0.7105650901794434,
0.15016786754131317,
0.3988991677761078,
-0.4719187021255493,
0.3149755895137787,
-0.5920406579971313,
0.25010547041893005,
-0.19384245574474335,
-0.8281126618385315,
-0.6281497478485107,
1.0409200191497803,
-0.14592911303043365,
0.020813923329114914,
0.6950762271881104,
0.4089672565460205,
-0.11902301013469696,
0.041366174817085266,
0.33150312304496765,
0.21995887160301208,
0.3273380398750305,
0.3446970283985138,
0.3947993516921997,
-0.4392443895339966,
0.5381311178207397,
-0.45795461535453796,
-0.27513250708580017,
-0.36554303765296936,
-1.0649809837341309,
-0.8056146502494812,
-0.7370381355285645,
-0.5461931228637695,
-0.19454066455364227,
-0.00011085795267717913,
1.0468217134475708,
0.9000263214111328,
-0.7669764161109924,
-0.08871391415596008,
-0.17278075218200684,
0.15863773226737976,
-0.32998761534690857,
-0.20099760591983795,
0.297946959733963,
-0.547160804271698,
-0.7084922790527344,
0.29286566376686096,
0.23946808278560638,
0.2019067406654358,
0.20472368597984314,
0.08091872185468674,
-0.2690802216529846,
-0.25954532623291016,
0.7874045968055725,
0.20950548350811005,
-0.37440386414527893,
-0.31191200017929077,
-0.2510499954223633,
0.17380428314208984,
0.06535033136606216,
0.7395492792129517,
-0.8804401159286499,
0.4943588078022003,
0.4813877046108246,
0.8448266983032227,
0.5381079316139221,
-0.05512905493378639,
0.3634070158004761,
-0.8874188661575317,
0.3241696357727051,
0.2885276675224304,
0.10750176757574081,
0.23190638422966003,
-0.39403876662254333,
0.448718786239624,
-0.18569377064704895,
-0.6094739437103271,
-0.8088633418083191,
0.19626040756702423,
-0.8731788396835327,
-0.8543117642402649,
0.9378926157951355,
0.010571589693427086,
-0.114622563123703,
-0.17117305099964142,
-0.24820354580879211,
-0.0021745667327195406,
-0.4272098243236542,
0.8516840934753418,
0.5500720739364624,
-0.22773657739162445,
-0.360515832901001,
-0.6849055290222168,
0.49978798627853394,
0.3418111801147461,
-0.871512234210968,
-0.0345333106815815,
0.25671496987342834,
0.21095918118953705,
0.04866325482726097,
0.31447023153305054,
0.2774570882320404,
0.07323935627937317,
-0.24562408030033112,
-0.3308778405189514,
0.1992330402135849,
-0.5212116837501526,
-0.6747900247573853,
0.273808091878891,
0.016423191875219345,
-0.02738049440085888
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06399v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06399v2
|
GlossLM: Multilingual Pretraining for Low-Resource Interlinear Glossing
| 2024-03-11T03:21:15 | 2024-06-27T05:22:05 |
Michael Ginn, Lindia Tjuatja, Taiqi He, Enora Rice, Graham Neubig, Alexis Palmer, Lori Levin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Language documentation projects often involve the creation of annotated text
in a format such as interlinear glossed text (IGT), which captures fine-grained
morphosyntactic analyses in a morpheme-by-morpheme format. However, there are
few existing resources providing large amounts of standardized, easily
accessible IGT data, limiting their applicability to linguistic research, and
making it difficult to use such data in NLP modeling.
We compile the largest existing corpus of IGT data from a variety of sources,
covering over 450k examples across 1.8k languages, to enable research on
crosslingual transfer and IGT generation. We normalize much of our data to
follow a standard set of labels across languages.
Furthermore, we explore the task of automatically generating IGT in order to
aid documentation projects. As many languages lack sufficient monolingual data,
we pretrain a large multilingual model on our corpus. We demonstrate the
utility of this model by finetuning it on monolingual corpora, outperforming
SOTA models by up to 6.6%. We will make our pretrained model and dataset
available through Hugging Face, as well as provide access through a web
interface for use in language documentation efforts.
|
[
-0.6774230599403381,
-0.5388078093528748,
0.05430964380502701,
0.39165422320365906,
-0.20546714961528778,
0.11377941817045212,
-0.340118944644928,
-0.3761339485645294,
0.30950695276260376,
0.5268844962120056,
-0.593528151512146,
-0.4846111238002777,
-0.6877774596214294,
0.019223429262638092,
-0.4805261194705963,
1.456537127494812,
-0.015585360117256641,
0.2400984764099121,
-0.2921447157859802,
-0.18528422713279724,
0.389976441860199,
-0.881362795829773,
-0.46986642479896545,
-0.3223574459552765,
0.6931508183479309,
0.5785571336746216,
0.619134783744812,
0.14443187415599823,
0.4799509644508362,
0.10999618470668793,
0.12135135382413864,
0.08594804257154465,
-0.5394393801689148,
-0.10355424135923386,
-0.06864181905984879,
-0.18672730028629303,
-0.6679655313491821,
0.060801297426223755,
0.45303875207901,
0.9139307737350464,
-0.23253127932548523,
0.36561429500579834,
0.12639299035072327,
0.5188078284263611,
-0.48820793628692627,
0.2768963575363159,
-0.4549039900302887,
-0.1592688411474228,
-0.713493824005127,
-0.19826503098011017,
-0.1459977775812149,
-0.2918905019760132,
0.25306829810142517,
-0.8201813697814941,
0.17281582951545715,
-0.012483510188758373,
1.0023986101150513,
0.21466206014156342,
-0.18301557004451752,
-0.6819848418235779,
-0.41271060705184937,
0.3653812110424042,
-0.8546428084373474,
0.4391767978668213,
0.6861552596092224,
0.19376026093959808,
0.2878861725330353,
-1.1211680173873901,
-0.3346480429172516,
-0.47701892256736755,
-0.27083200216293335,
0.21687808632850647,
0.07673855125904083,
0.350275456905365,
0.30339059233665466,
0.3374481797218323,
-0.7192700505256653,
0.027183622121810913,
-0.5730432868003845,
-0.08249527215957642,
0.43351852893829346,
-0.11688417941331863,
0.34044817090034485,
-0.032720427960157394,
-0.42278003692626953,
-0.11756434291601181,
-0.637150228023529,
-0.2132917195558548,
0.5090988278388977,
0.5179144144058228,
-0.20179693400859833,
0.34878331422805786,
-0.04313750937581062,
0.5059928297996521,
-0.2907204031944275,
-0.14605236053466797,
0.25630995631217957,
-0.5395450592041016,
-0.08626250922679901,
-0.1002369076013565,
0.7722629904747009,
0.14962486922740936,
0.38719096779823303,
-0.2598603665828705,
-0.2849273383617401,
-0.32952162623405457,
0.22463010251522064,
-0.9683167934417725,
-0.37190404534339905,
-0.15075230598449707,
-0.26186615228652954,
0.31135693192481995,
0.050538070499897,
-0.8123021721839905,
-0.11082742363214493,
-0.5553061366081238,
0.2672249674797058,
-0.6170904636383057,
-0.26196059584617615,
0.04637439548969269,
0.11477812379598618,
0.027968447655439377,
0.12691418826580048,
-1.1781878471374512,
0.47676941752433777,
0.30727285146713257,
0.8875396847724915,
-0.14572034776210785,
-0.608099102973938,
-0.567687451839447,
-0.015198350884020329,
-0.030215511098504066,
0.5321305990219116,
-0.16490033268928528,
-0.3602108657360077,
0.23221425712108612,
0.004096804652363062,
-0.03178653493523598,
-0.5214347243309021,
0.380884051322937,
-0.40843015909194946,
0.3454034924507141,
0.0638265609741211,
-0.4431585967540741,
0.033354487270116806,
0.330919086933136,
-0.5924094915390015,
1.0710675716400146,
0.5133403539657593,
-0.7675571441650391,
0.2753404974937439,
-0.8265882730484009,
-0.2773393392562866,
0.2980312407016754,
-0.1597737818956375,
-0.2570808231830597,
-0.06191626191139221,
0.0024192933924496174,
0.17296886444091797,
-0.4424862563610077,
0.5077893137931824,
-0.12294188886880875,
-0.030613791197538376,
-0.5441350936889648,
-0.2284746617078781,
0.8322283625602722,
0.31297779083251953,
-0.2009914219379425,
0.37262415885925293,
-0.7774070501327515,
0.07314004749059677,
-0.1389535367488861,
-0.4362216293811798,
-0.5706358551979065,
-0.4853183329105377,
0.4611084759235382,
0.35532301664352417,
0.5105266571044922,
-0.2058393955230713,
0.5120089054107666,
-0.26763060688972473,
0.03907978907227516,
0.4428555369377136,
-0.4993526339530945,
0.36167702078819275,
-0.0734122171998024,
0.9452531933784485,
-0.040601082146167755,
0.4611961543560028,
0.05338253080844879,
-0.2094346433877945,
-0.9687466621398926,
0.015293640084564686,
0.59959876537323,
0.457148939371109,
-1.13459312915802,
0.003433520207181573,
-0.315169095993042,
-0.422397643327713,
-0.6264564394950867,
0.21920470893383026,
0.7161191701889038,
0.47011852264404297,
0.42133843898773193,
-0.2715076506137848,
-0.5748149752616882,
-0.9386511445045471,
-0.0011433785548433661,
0.03997984156012535,
0.02246384136378765,
0.016345564275979996,
0.39112553000450134,
-0.33761149644851685,
0.8149694204330444,
-0.2498331069946289,
-0.41714438796043396,
-0.06287849694490433,
0.6199421882629395,
0.11599955707788467,
0.42202961444854736,
0.7831047177314758,
-0.6872636675834656,
-0.8199722766876221,
-0.06420242786407471,
-0.7011454105377197,
-0.3786426782608032,
0.1645783632993698,
-0.16459393501281738,
0.2488550990819931,
0.9647725224494934,
-0.25400328636169434,
0.1761726289987564,
0.995940089225769,
-0.3655102550983429,
0.6040359139442444,
-0.5257009863853455,
-0.24887344241142273,
-0.7530390024185181,
0.3580162227153778,
-0.36216995120048523,
-0.2890388071537018,
-0.7982771992683411,
0.10637462884187698,
0.1247231662273407,
-0.073117695748806,
-0.47057726979255676,
0.893068253993988,
-0.6459763646125793,
0.06929049640893936,
-0.1262853592634201,
0.18927207589149475,
-0.1315276026725769,
0.4044693410396576,
-0.05651339516043663,
1.0131937265396118,
0.6004769802093506,
-0.5605563521385193,
-0.009791409596800804,
0.4551351070404053,
-0.3372429311275482,
0.40641966462135315,
-0.23505182564258575,
0.15452702343463898,
-0.2866264283657074,
-0.039899129420518875,
-0.5832938551902771,
-0.20949965715408325,
0.10889692604541779,
-0.0928601324558258,
0.34030312299728394,
-0.1077926754951477,
-0.4530012607574463,
-0.1343553215265274,
-0.11092230677604675,
0.22882969677448273,
0.3268549144268036,
-0.5507211685180664,
0.5590282678604126,
0.4145413935184479,
-0.5570110082626343,
-0.6690267324447632,
-0.5311743021011353,
0.18088398873806,
-0.1788654327392578,
-0.550932765007019,
0.2903902530670166,
-0.3474805951118469,
-0.3717404305934906,
-0.16458845138549805,
0.08422340452671051,
-0.16450421512126923,
0.054858945310115814,
0.1722286343574524,
0.06624811887741089,
-0.3332700729370117,
0.4387716054916382,
-0.23919296264648438,
-0.11373884975910187,
-0.11709528416395187,
-0.24491620063781738,
0.7945455312728882,
-0.32785654067993164,
-0.3556831181049347,
0.32979485392570496,
0.5454380512237549,
0.575110912322998,
-0.23397395014762878,
0.6859319806098938,
0.8406789302825928,
-0.31355926394462585,
-0.09758739918470383,
-0.3519168496131897,
-0.07386244833469391,
-0.41880303621292114,
0.09861502051353455,
-0.5033079385757446,
-0.6308717727661133,
0.44840869307518005,
-0.19262003898620605,
0.17057257890701294,
0.3380589187145233,
0.3138940632343292,
0.025724155828356743,
0.6720874905586243,
0.9861201047897339,
0.14081081748008728,
0.6164199113845825,
-0.2150077074766159,
0.025215182453393936,
-0.5569728016853333,
-0.23715943098068237,
-0.32236790657043457,
0.05967608094215393,
-0.42298656702041626,
-0.3276617228984833,
0.48537731170654297,
0.4886777102947235,
0.02845262922346592,
0.031559284776449203,
-0.17820832133293152,
0.24615029990673065,
0.983656108379364,
-0.2753419876098633,
0.36112529039382935,
-0.05594837665557861,
-0.1428772211074829,
-0.002728757681325078,
-0.7727771997451782,
-0.6057695150375366,
0.9638336300849915,
0.06270363926887512,
0.8663415908813477,
0.06759775429964066,
0.6780006885528564,
0.03965244069695473,
0.6033533811569214,
-0.6749475598335266,
0.2614193260669708,
-0.7332903146743774,
-0.49994930624961853,
-0.35870838165283203,
-0.06940482556819916,
-1.0053645372390747,
0.08983579277992249,
-0.07726454734802246,
-0.20965105295181274,
-0.05703863874077797,
0.247195765376091,
-0.24752867221832275,
-0.028986139222979546,
-0.7804498076438904,
0.901738703250885,
-0.545620322227478,
-0.06420568376779556,
0.13656671345233917,
-0.8202705383300781,
0.31411072611808777,
-0.4374144971370697,
0.3740328550338745,
-0.22279544174671173,
0.11647350341081619,
0.8134100437164307,
-0.704370379447937,
0.6341109871864319,
-0.2950001060962677,
-0.28260958194732666,
0.005241768434643745,
-0.2512942850589752,
0.25462502241134644,
-0.10642582178115845,
-0.16348333656787872,
0.3935457766056061,
0.18562904000282288,
-0.4117875099182129,
-0.27416136860847473,
0.3619280457496643,
-0.6325920224189758,
-0.5026899576187134,
-0.24529479444026947,
-0.5542806386947632,
-0.5473067164421082,
0.299591988325119,
0.6517837643623352,
0.3420757055282593,
-0.28552043437957764,
-0.04475507140159607,
0.4541299641132355,
-0.048997774720191956,
0.33820345997810364,
0.4797227382659912,
-0.7218952775001526,
-0.17562924325466156,
0.8725473880767822,
0.3199670910835266,
0.5399839282035828,
0.007604482118040323,
0.14587579667568207,
-0.3703400194644928,
-0.6903384327888489,
-0.3936953842639923,
0.37359002232551575,
-0.9504417181015015,
-0.06144768372178078,
-0.5503198504447937,
-0.4844266176223755,
-0.4259527325630188,
-0.09265494346618652,
-0.214872345328331,
-0.33328986167907715,
-0.26497188210487366,
0.06294393539428711,
0.3960767984390259,
0.7963393926620483,
-0.20206283032894135,
0.7702431678771973,
-0.7476583123207092,
0.475093811750412,
0.27606549859046936,
0.514583945274353,
-0.39470258355140686,
-0.365650475025177,
-0.4829012155532837,
-0.029785707592964172,
0.18206757307052612,
-0.5095906257629395,
0.5710633993148804,
0.5439122319221497,
0.5510401725769043,
0.17145965993404388,
0.00659805815666914,
0.782983660697937,
-0.453370600938797,
0.6229682564735413,
0.2908645272254944,
-0.9906443357467651,
0.4212999641895294,
-0.40686023235321045,
0.5436266660690308,
0.8572592735290527,
0.6967729330062866,
-0.7162044644355774,
-0.4964732825756073,
-0.6617545485496521,
-1.1067653894424438,
0.7767645716667175,
-0.16078780591487885,
0.1131189614534378,
0.11869170516729355,
0.2388053834438324,
0.4929306209087372,
0.2768729329109192,
-0.7511625289916992,
-0.27853816747665405,
-0.36647307872772217,
-0.2572382688522339,
-0.31355029344558716,
-0.25556910037994385,
-0.4103429913520813,
-0.13842123746871948,
0.7761695981025696,
-0.5224783420562744,
-0.35007327795028687,
0.1078500971198082,
-0.43255922198295593,
0.2122168242931366,
0.13371342420578003,
0.6069052219390869,
0.8871467113494873,
-0.248554527759552,
0.43045201897621155,
0.09992676973342896,
-0.7243437767028809,
-0.15372537076473236,
0.41308119893074036,
-0.27125945687294006,
0.29306554794311523,
0.28852564096450806,
0.9931497573852539,
0.009809929877519608,
-0.8513427376747131,
0.5445517897605896,
-0.1492006778717041,
-0.34935152530670166,
-0.35453981161117554,
-0.36900290846824646,
0.21418578922748566,
0.09213575720787048,
0.13417576253414154,
-0.2381862848997116,
-0.05099146068096161,
-0.461570143699646,
0.3726981282234192,
0.41664445400238037,
-0.46363112330436707,
-0.3151749074459076,
0.6430667042732239,
0.11495056003332138,
-0.11570318043231964,
0.6686052680015564,
-0.2942461669445038,
-0.3532369136810303,
0.27585023641586304,
0.35602113604545593,
0.5133260488510132,
-0.2828789949417114,
0.17374546825885773,
0.4015086889266968,
0.20611542463302612,
-0.08880645781755447,
0.35586172342300415,
0.16192419826984406,
-0.27332761883735657,
-0.21984726190567017,
-1.015547513961792,
-0.4061255156993866,
0.42838406562805176,
-0.576324999332428,
0.4720054864883423,
-0.4196678400039673,
-0.045341379940509796,
0.004226854536682367,
-0.19040852785110474,
-0.6884516477584839,
0.23350933194160461,
0.5196513533592224,
0.9663474559783936,
-0.8019766807556152,
1.0777084827423096,
0.49604305624961853,
-0.6628660559654236,
-0.5549466609954834,
0.02507738023996353,
-0.23899519443511963,
-0.9250146150588989,
0.8366551995277405,
-0.006641242653131485,
-0.26629507541656494,
0.16202861070632935,
-0.5708157420158386,
-1.0234721899032593,
0.7126913070678711,
0.6778572797775269,
-0.6558879017829895,
-0.5209764242172241,
0.15535502135753632,
0.5982609987258911,
-0.13133591413497925,
0.24249008297920227,
0.5845102667808533,
0.7158763408660889,
-0.05388089269399643,
-1.3045871257781982,
-0.22581805288791656,
-0.37722471356391907,
-0.27675414085388184,
0.08045623451471329,
-0.4246271848678589,
1.2568951845169067,
0.14125299453735352,
-0.363302081823349,
-0.08628518879413605,
0.39023557305336,
0.006266603246331215,
0.09775057435035706,
0.4980764091014862,
0.3084845542907715,
0.9845240116119385,
-0.1557272970676422,
0.9859921932220459,
-0.5035555362701416,
0.22287152707576752,
1.3760054111480713,
0.04688762128353119,
0.5682307481765747,
0.57655268907547,
0.03552410006523132,
0.36241719126701355,
0.7032605409622192,
0.20399029552936554,
0.4929240345954895,
0.3930417001247406,
-0.31892916560173035,
-0.012750032357871532,
-0.3884178400039673,
-0.4024749994277954,
0.38677680492401123,
0.5452789068222046,
-0.12243624031543732,
-0.48595747351646423,
0.4576672613620758,
0.1739567071199417,
-0.09006451815366745,
-0.396943598985672,
0.7298884391784668,
0.1532953977584839,
-0.8111469745635986,
0.9764447808265686,
-0.3993319869041443,
1.0266501903533936,
-1.1636337041854858,
0.13497932255268097,
-0.3698399066925049,
0.02994762547314167,
-0.37515392899513245,
-0.5444881319999695,
0.4279138147830963,
-0.09598901867866516,
0.08181063085794449,
-0.6592630743980408,
0.5101246237754822,
-0.9948344230651855,
-0.2037978172302246,
0.6164609789848328,
0.8946142792701721,
0.43654412031173706,
-0.015678195282816887,
-0.5438273549079895,
-0.34210434556007385,
-0.12097715586423874,
-0.21852263808250427,
0.49189141392707825,
0.304332435131073,
-0.33159661293029785,
0.4839431941509247,
0.5482137799263,
0.17061373591423035,
0.45683103799819946,
0.606895387172699,
0.8002009987831116,
-0.47763970494270325,
-0.3220818340778351,
-0.6463655233383179,
0.45959314703941345,
-0.01683303527534008,
-0.5183255076408386,
0.7612552046775818,
0.6448154449462891,
0.8763823509216309,
-0.18171104788780212,
0.934693455696106,
-0.14769577980041504,
0.4002639949321747,
-0.7603684067726135,
0.795157253742218,
-0.6703181266784668,
-0.21060335636138916,
0.17980600893497467,
-0.7007924318313599,
-0.34186625480651855,
0.22200363874435425,
-0.03864732012152672,
-0.29875448346138,
0.6748387813568115,
0.41721847653388977,
-0.3035082519054413,
-0.3251834213733673,
0.36403271555900574,
0.09444021433591843,
0.329210102558136,
0.2889914810657501,
0.8431792259216309,
-0.19941231608390808,
0.592922568321228,
-0.2413627952337265,
-0.11578162014484406,
-0.35976657271385193,
-0.9033927321434021,
-0.7384529113769531,
-0.9588088393211365,
-0.16319629549980164,
-0.17934280633926392,
-0.0026080692186951637,
0.7757121324539185,
0.9165889620780945,
-0.7335734963417053,
-0.4569603204727173,
-0.12247425317764282,
-0.2345835566520691,
0.203901469707489,
-0.14283327758312225,
0.33773618936538696,
-0.6878438591957092,
-0.8098469972610474,
0.3415636420249939,
0.2035558670759201,
0.4169345200061798,
-0.5158048868179321,
-0.09513332694768906,
-0.4919430911540985,
-0.05287971347570419,
0.6041963696479797,
0.4091078042984009,
-0.6548708081245422,
-0.026736434549093246,
-0.17900770902633667,
-0.41168394684791565,
0.3061918020248413,
0.7202699780464172,
-0.5180606245994568,
0.5132975578308105,
0.39376941323280334,
0.3249281048774719,
0.8881345987319946,
-0.034077323973178864,
0.48936331272125244,
-1.170883297920227,
0.37899765372276306,
0.34102863073349,
0.3553791642189026,
0.44279512763023376,
-0.13903899490833282,
0.8257179260253906,
-0.13456648588180542,
-0.30849549174308777,
-0.7151784896850586,
0.12930305302143097,
-0.7992879748344421,
-0.2943124771118164,
1.1468309164047241,
-0.38428443670272827,
0.06010159105062485,
-0.21542204916477203,
-0.2866370975971222,
0.3786282241344452,
0.06280477344989777,
0.5313074588775635,
0.9460782408714294,
-0.26672202348709106,
-0.12920041382312775,
-0.775955319404602,
1.017564296722412,
0.26393502950668335,
-1.368007779121399,
0.30654704570770264,
0.28413423895835876,
0.16209635138511658,
0.49835026264190674,
1.146510362625122,
0.16430890560150146,
-0.10377417504787445,
0.10969425737857819,
0.42140600085258484,
0.09175296872854233,
-0.33823466300964355,
-0.34549805521965027,
0.19863587617874146,
0.2673642039299011,
0.19708582758903503
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06360v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06360v1
|
Human and Automatic Interpretation of Romanian Noun Compounds
| 2024-03-11T01:18:00 | 2024-03-11T01:18:00 |
Ioana Marinescu, Christiane Fellbaum
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Determining the intended, context-dependent meanings of noun compounds like
"shoe sale" and "fire sale" remains a challenge for NLP. Previous work has
relied on inventories of semantic relations that capture the different meanings
between compound members. Focusing on Romanian compounds, whose morphosyntax
differs from that of their English counterparts, we propose a new set of
relations and test it with human annotators and a neural net classifier.
Results show an alignment of the network's predictions and human judgments,
even where the human agreement rate is low. Agreement tracks with the frequency
of the selected relations, regardless of structural differences. However, the
most frequently selected relation was none of the sixteen labeled semantic
relations, indicating the need for a better relation inventory.
|
[
-0.1465478092432022,
-0.33807119727134705,
0.23209139704704285,
0.35644274950027466,
-0.4243822991847992,
0.13644643127918243,
-0.15007393062114716,
-0.8673734068870544,
0.41194745898246765,
0.2448526918888092,
-0.47817617654800415,
-0.4288927912712097,
-0.53398597240448,
0.6527794599533081,
-0.2893185317516327,
0.8789408802986145,
-0.06299185752868652,
0.23949268460273743,
-0.026093943044543266,
-0.40481099486351013,
-0.33193397521972656,
-0.5093294978141785,
-0.3360203206539154,
-0.5357010364532471,
0.6965274810791016,
-0.08868297189474106,
0.9591935276985168,
0.5621888637542725,
0.8771649599075317,
0.380715012550354,
-0.11772321909666061,
-0.23119620978832245,
0.02429972216486931,
0.2514953017234802,
-0.2382192760705948,
-0.6113541722297668,
-0.40050843358039856,
-0.0998295396566391,
0.24865472316741943,
0.9021168351173401,
0.04278823360800743,
0.08983656018972397,
-0.24886097013950348,
0.49626749753952026,
-0.7274006605148315,
0.14737758040428162,
-0.7175447344779968,
-0.04031575843691826,
-0.029388198629021645,
-0.4532039165496826,
-0.4429027736186981,
-0.0777285099029541,
0.439873069524765,
-0.6229036450386047,
0.33065909147262573,
0.27089300751686096,
1.3001272678375244,
0.046694833785295486,
-0.5113797783851624,
-0.45413529872894287,
-0.6959511041641235,
0.6879875063896179,
-0.46189767122268677,
0.2776797413825989,
0.30588990449905396,
0.2768576145172119,
-0.5309107303619385,
-0.6492154002189636,
-0.30201172828674316,
-0.3179140090942383,
-0.5501223802566528,
-0.028961675241589546,
-0.1916630119085312,
0.17200005054473877,
-0.145501971244812,
0.6340624094009399,
-0.4958837330341339,
-0.1736084669828415,
-0.5536527037620544,
-0.18206636607646942,
0.4781046211719513,
0.12480314821004868,
0.6776246428489685,
-0.6687982082366943,
-0.8080185055732727,
0.2202979177236557,
-0.7403457760810852,
-0.16214172542095184,
0.35763120651245117,
0.5256655812263489,
0.10894028842449188,
0.6579465866088867,
-0.1390066146850586,
0.7688266038894653,
-0.18522347509860992,
-0.048357341438531876,
0.2527111768722534,
-0.593029797077179,
-0.6580079197883606,
0.13178446888923645,
0.7034305334091187,
0.49383243918418884,
0.0989157184958458,
-0.5474469065666199,
-0.3104500472545624,
0.568434476852417,
0.029857521876692772,
-0.5232448577880859,
-0.4961819648742676,
0.038999032229185104,
-0.38420480489730835,
-0.4310627579689026,
0.11813762038946152,
-0.46853309869766235,
0.15159042179584503,
-0.5976135730743408,
0.41525688767433167,
0.02892615832388401,
-0.21693965792655945,
0.26568716764450073,
-0.3600049614906311,
0.04861458018422127,
0.08270837366580963,
-1.0506218671798706,
0.9121371507644653,
0.6545424461364746,
0.7060365080833435,
-0.4601479172706604,
-0.2818982005119324,
-0.21630001068115234,
0.013063102960586548,
-0.34364795684814453,
0.8418061137199402,
-0.36200806498527527,
-0.3040880560874939,
-0.3356413245201111,
0.2543671131134033,
-0.14637744426727295,
-0.7507224678993225,
0.2296106070280075,
-0.535906195640564,
0.3913221061229706,
-0.16874928772449493,
-0.47261202335357666,
-0.0929657444357872,
0.24391312897205353,
-0.5486043691635132,
0.7542775273323059,
0.25281980633735657,
-0.6219680905342102,
0.46156632900238037,
-0.28128722310066223,
-0.39497750997543335,
0.25160831212997437,
-0.4467552602291107,
0.1739625781774521,
0.052745163440704346,
-0.21129611134529114,
0.2514619529247284,
-0.2703510522842407,
0.24983566999435425,
0.0010164572158828378,
-0.015145610086619854,
0.387412428855896,
0.0014007369754835963,
1.0436936616897583,
0.04274279996752739,
-0.49973100423812866,
0.14320048689842224,
-0.7536584734916687,
-0.4060392677783966,
-0.26868945360183716,
-0.48284274339675903,
-0.5988103747367859,
-0.013250703923404217,
0.507119357585907,
0.42096006870269775,
-0.027529414743185043,
-0.504790186882019,
0.42391344904899597,
-0.5069446563720703,
0.3756207227706909,
0.8033021092414856,
-0.046971824020147324,
0.6527251601219177,
-0.09350430220365524,
0.8958656787872314,
-0.012765584513545036,
-0.03908926248550415,
-0.02360345423221588,
-0.838302731513977,
-0.7761653065681458,
0.1895700991153717,
0.6153095364570618,
0.516694962978363,
-0.35903871059417725,
0.4283421039581299,
-0.3803500533103943,
-0.2183019518852234,
0.11107195168733597,
0.26682770252227783,
0.3677656948566437,
0.321622759103775,
0.09003555029630661,
-0.4471173882484436,
-0.539646565914154,
-0.9808226227760315,
-0.2493162304162979,
-0.3374994993209839,
-0.17633453011512756,
0.48943352699279785,
0.7207353115081787,
-0.30427590012550354,
0.9001913070678711,
-0.678127110004425,
-0.5917260646820068,
0.17169047892093658,
0.4438600540161133,
0.03277769684791565,
0.3913605213165283,
0.6550775766372681,
-0.843462347984314,
-0.2632281482219696,
0.18161216378211975,
-0.3126623332500458,
0.1781315952539444,
-0.2625117599964142,
-0.5557982325553894,
0.23130403459072113,
0.19087904691696167,
-0.585692286491394,
0.4783146381378174,
0.49506041407585144,
-0.7862321138381958,
0.4237014353275299,
-0.1449042409658432,
-0.10483500361442566,
-1.101447582244873,
-0.05066792666912079,
0.207785502076149,
-0.11249640583992004,
-0.519146740436554,
-0.09304236620664597,
-0.16987213492393494,
0.223165363073349,
-0.7368384003639221,
0.5441995859146118,
-0.6981117129325867,
-0.49620476365089417,
0.18129496276378632,
0.3220542371273041,
0.32933101058006287,
0.4658392667770386,
0.24168731272220612,
0.5579195022583008,
0.23078258335590363,
-0.8898274898529053,
0.9667525291442871,
0.478538453578949,
-0.4868593215942383,
0.5542908906936646,
-0.6046815514564514,
-0.23581992089748383,
-0.01156990509480238,
0.2878129780292511,
-0.8275172710418701,
-0.2733539640903473,
0.41818761825561523,
-0.6536659598350525,
0.07095946371555328,
-0.2608032822608948,
-0.3894634246826172,
0.07093457877635956,
0.13374371826648712,
0.42850813269615173,
-0.1284574419260025,
-0.26643162965774536,
0.6898841261863708,
0.30792197585105896,
0.34574469923973083,
-0.506303071975708,
-1.0240199565887451,
0.25908970832824707,
-0.38049277663230896,
-0.8344247937202454,
0.5342654585838318,
0.1341223269701004,
-0.6870530247688293,
0.27649980783462524,
-0.1627422720193863,
-0.4580932855606079,
0.35092970728874207,
0.11730065196752548,
0.44423961639404297,
-0.4147915840148926,
0.741068959236145,
-0.5271655321121216,
-0.2242909073829651,
0.26447823643684387,
-0.19321930408477783,
0.25298449397087097,
-0.15097685158252716,
0.12336257845163345,
-0.3864348828792572,
0.27169492840766907,
0.5357112884521484,
0.05014600232243538,
0.601552426815033,
0.015226386487483978,
-0.6512765884399414,
0.3011459708213806,
-0.14624112844467163,
-0.22996532917022705,
-0.3898593783378601,
-0.004610187374055386,
-0.48250359296798706,
-0.16433365643024445,
0.5817191004753113,
0.19847123324871063,
-0.1844252645969391,
0.6176824569702148,
0.45121634006500244,
-0.02361847646534443,
0.6704322099685669,
0.2620071470737457,
-0.08253780007362366,
-0.13529638946056366,
-0.17820946872234344,
0.2707718014717102,
-0.8361785411834717,
-0.3817567527294159,
-0.6423376202583313,
-0.6923916339874268,
-0.6779364943504333,
-0.10202611237764359,
-0.1516295075416565,
-0.08174792677164078,
0.13630683720111847,
0.8598915338516235,
-0.5299627184867859,
0.40114644169807434,
0.4160776436328888,
0.0563298799097538,
0.44544628262519836,
-0.05814795568585396,
0.05115240439772606,
-0.1533377766609192,
-0.24282963573932648,
-0.4470890760421753,
0.8299906849861145,
-0.073032446205616,
0.4410112500190735,
0.38150373101234436,
0.4382764995098114,
0.054257236421108246,
0.14683812856674194,
-1.1721075773239136,
0.29809653759002686,
-0.02836681343615055,
-1.0075873136520386,
-0.07388677448034286,
-0.3640042543411255,
-1.347570538520813,
0.2504136264324188,
-0.3511423170566559,
-0.9977462887763977,
0.53822261095047,
0.06881691515445709,
-0.5459375381469727,
0.1786002516746521,
-0.7133094072341919,
1.140333890914917,
-0.6816652417182922,
-0.07176875323057175,
-0.030422281473875046,
-0.6175875067710876,
0.28114476799964905,
0.1366724818944931,
0.08074130117893219,
-0.4674193859100342,
-0.2683678865432739,
0.7464521527290344,
-0.2415170967578888,
0.32618167996406555,
0.2929300367832184,
-0.02416071482002735,
-0.09437001496553421,
0.2563363015651703,
0.14109940826892853,
-0.2508532404899597,
0.10012777894735336,
-0.3248527944087982,
0.17689374089241028,
-0.41425472497940063,
-0.8344466090202332,
0.6538333296775818,
-0.4960501790046692,
-0.3403540551662445,
-0.6483235955238342,
-0.32930120825767517,
-0.012206561863422394,
0.04520859569311142,
0.31501758098602295,
0.647412896156311,
-0.2876490652561188,
0.4635787308216095,
0.06441517919301987,
-0.07110141962766647,
0.0048642028123140335,
0.030050652101635933,
-0.5620654225349426,
-0.03310493007302284,
0.7626951932907104,
0.054276321083307266,
0.4532318711280823,
0.4438749849796295,
0.30070391297340393,
-0.16298352181911469,
-0.3169412314891815,
-0.25770094990730286,
0.01644004136323929,
-0.7094292044639587,
-0.15280906856060028,
-0.490837424993515,
0.21136802434921265,
-0.4150676131248474,
-0.06476014107465744,
0.018762169405817986,
-0.6623015403747559,
-0.4018857479095459,
-0.20162734389305115,
0.49780896306037903,
0.7647423148155212,
0.03553526848554611,
0.3083614110946655,
-0.6899423599243164,
0.5717248916625977,
0.43125081062316895,
0.2532985806465149,
-0.42689892649650574,
-0.24292507767677307,
0.07791390269994736,
-0.04066278040409088,
-0.062260061502456665,
-1.1710996627807617,
0.3965078294277191,
0.34119731187820435,
0.24734513461589813,
0.8193185329437256,
0.11165979504585266,
0.5389924049377441,
-0.10130324214696884,
0.6414403915405273,
0.42011743783950806,
-0.8158861398696899,
0.6378514766693115,
-0.46286511421203613,
-0.06858165562152863,
0.5542711019515991,
0.34525948762893677,
-0.793586790561676,
-0.006009564734995365,
-0.8399735689163208,
-1.0663355588912964,
0.7391899824142456,
0.7712848782539368,
0.30816301703453064,
-0.12690623104572296,
0.11887660622596741,
-0.2168508917093277,
0.19016055762767792,
-0.6279913187026978,
-0.5792966485023499,
0.27760428190231323,
0.04607994109392166,
0.049234483391046524,
-0.22769521176815033,
-0.02492457628250122,
-0.5152536630630493,
0.7165002822875977,
0.27863356471061707,
-0.019783245399594307,
0.07547423243522644,
-0.17971494793891907,
0.009976477362215519,
0.31843292713165283,
0.6750938892364502,
1.1199945211410522,
-0.4129932224750519,
0.4295760989189148,
-0.10976848751306534,
-0.5132849216461182,
0.34053945541381836,
-0.2882011830806732,
-0.19519129395484924,
0.4751378297805786,
0.029252853244543076,
0.6836462616920471,
0.8005523681640625,
-0.6893656253814697,
0.5217437744140625,
-0.12249074876308441,
-0.1511492133140564,
-0.5265108346939087,
-0.2175888866186142,
0.22133442759513855,
-0.10870502889156342,
0.3165525794029236,
0.37367236614227295,
0.3100784122943878,
-0.9477271437644958,
0.3948565125465393,
0.149620920419693,
-0.31700804829597473,
-0.42503154277801514,
0.28611090779304504,
0.3322293162345886,
-0.738487184047699,
0.6154372692108154,
-0.25828829407691956,
-0.8125964999198914,
0.8142319321632385,
0.05094029754400253,
0.6577392220497131,
-0.19045236706733704,
0.3125206530094147,
0.3269719183444977,
0.2835450768470764,
0.08963223546743393,
0.09076767414808273,
-0.10806239396333694,
-0.9812780022621155,
-0.0040630861185491085,
-0.4458549916744232,
-0.1571054309606552,
0.07460421323776245,
-0.8543514609336853,
0.5045475363731384,
-0.14594455063343048,
-0.31555628776550293,
0.33560556173324585,
0.007408484350889921,
-0.4103491008281708,
0.3472900390625,
-0.1084013283252716,
0.622974157333374,
-0.9552386403083801,
0.7534103989601135,
0.5397963523864746,
-0.6031241416931152,
-0.6697341203689575,
-0.17702990770339966,
0.13863958418369293,
-0.2983653247356415,
1.4027528762817383,
0.1304522603750229,
-0.07668143510818481,
-0.3309650123119354,
0.0031278308015316725,
-0.696760892868042,
0.8771225810050964,
0.29440292716026306,
-0.2882423996925354,
-0.3612859547138214,
0.1310773491859436,
0.4859829843044281,
-0.49465566873550415,
0.07785362005233765,
0.7824704051017761,
0.5125474333763123,
0.09657929092645645,
-0.7048683762550354,
-0.23787754774093628,
-0.526689350605011,
-0.0030265336390584707,
0.3804031312465668,
0.12540411949157715,
0.8389176726341248,
0.36609840393066406,
-0.5938891172409058,
0.11988289654254913,
0.5335928201675415,
-0.02318619377911091,
0.20330548286437988,
0.6521650552749634,
0.4440435767173767,
0.6225960850715637,
-0.18868474662303925,
0.9229122400283813,
-0.357619047164917,
0.3201896846294403,
1.3766223192214966,
0.13461706042289734,
1.0741291046142578,
0.7393244504928589,
-0.46313557028770447,
0.7698108553886414,
0.8790459036827087,
-0.20858806371688843,
0.10969192534685135,
0.5837172269821167,
-0.39156705141067505,
-0.26582837104797363,
-0.11951521784067154,
-0.0813673883676529,
0.6048049926757812,
0.45430904626846313,
-0.6250115633010864,
-0.20208585262298584,
-0.2947462499141693,
-0.06463953852653503,
0.0719541609287262,
0.08310171961784363,
0.6681122183799744,
0.21538284420967102,
-0.6711986064910889,
0.4225996136665344,
-0.08217370510101318,
0.6268684267997742,
-0.2666313350200653,
0.17946664988994598,
0.041410356760025024,
0.22923077642917633,
-0.5131464004516602,
-0.39910799264907837,
0.5089371800422668,
-0.27691972255706787,
-0.17300903797149658,
0.03635528311133385,
0.41512060165405273,
-0.31927812099456787,
-0.6786033511161804,
0.646691620349884,
0.1165342628955841,
0.31345778703689575,
-0.08702640235424042,
-0.49455901980400085,
-0.2876216769218445,
-0.234013631939888,
-0.1337689608335495,
0.03830379992723465,
0.30073782801628113,
0.14290496706962585,
0.35978126525878906,
0.5709315538406372,
0.34388265013694763,
0.41217532753944397,
-0.25908568501472473,
0.4445643126964569,
-0.4813082218170166,
-0.1660865992307663,
-0.5965818762779236,
0.3975542187690735,
0.03678066283464432,
-0.5877231955528259,
0.6454288959503174,
0.5967005491256714,
0.8919247388839722,
0.1345152109861374,
0.3698570132255554,
0.2315480262041092,
0.06332266330718994,
-0.43719226121902466,
0.485749214887619,
-0.4204017221927643,
0.33038070797920227,
-0.14398090541362762,
-1.0651997327804565,
-0.5032834410667419,
0.7197340130805969,
-0.0913626179099083,
-0.3247867524623871,
0.9227806925773621,
0.6598815321922302,
-0.2547105848789215,
-0.05891301482915878,
0.19943803548812866,
0.16637064516544342,
-0.08612947165966034,
0.5506190657615662,
0.6641768217086792,
-0.7496493458747864,
0.6048629283905029,
-0.60881108045578,
0.14927947521209717,
-0.21755588054656982,
-0.7459480166435242,
-0.6410051584243774,
-0.764805257320404,
-0.4098380208015442,
-0.3931131660938263,
-0.19803442060947418,
1.3178561925888062,
0.4364038109779358,
-0.8436182737350464,
-0.5940361022949219,
-0.39589011669158936,
0.018699994310736656,
0.013873881660401821,
-0.203044593334198,
0.42206165194511414,
-0.2264806628227234,
-0.8237993717193604,
0.08489298075437546,
0.31694817543029785,
0.13242819905281067,
-0.5991471409797668,
-0.2080342173576355,
-0.40964943170547485,
-0.27341845631599426,
0.5457760691642761,
0.1263345628976822,
-1.0933496952056885,
-0.02704090252518654,
0.22849830985069275,
-0.023020869120955467,
0.43174150586128235,
1.103472352027893,
-0.7674456834793091,
0.6059107184410095,
0.9074785709381104,
0.41221046447753906,
0.13093852996826172,
-0.08953327685594559,
0.8465743064880371,
-0.5529088973999023,
0.37949591875076294,
0.24039341509342194,
0.6596367955207825,
0.37627723813056946,
-0.48604264855384827,
0.4039689004421234,
0.466397762298584,
-0.23721539974212646,
-0.5930067896842957,
0.48325315117836,
-0.9869294166564941,
-0.4230647087097168,
1.2528425455093384,
-0.3108600080013275,
-0.44842037558555603,
-0.44856953620910645,
-0.07711038738489151,
0.00439817551523447,
-0.2934451699256897,
0.8351114392280579,
0.8128958940505981,
0.12617112696170807,
-0.05408884584903717,
-0.5537175536155701,
0.5410178303718567,
0.16163261234760284,
-0.8257150650024414,
-0.125381201505661,
0.6255063414573669,
-0.15698005259037018,
0.5405416488647461,
0.40516427159309387,
0.022152163088321686,
0.3153575658798218,
-0.43172699213027954,
-0.10605106502771378,
0.6299378275871277,
-0.2719540596008301,
-0.19574615359306335,
-0.13350805640220642,
-0.0690535306930542,
-0.4009456932544708
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06355v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06355v1
|
Multi-modal Semantic Understanding with Contrastive Cross-modal Feature Alignment
| 2024-03-11T01:07:36 | 2024-03-11T01:07:36 |
Ming Zhang, Ke Chang, Yunfang Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Multi-modal semantic understanding requires integrating information from
different modalities to extract users' real intention behind words. Most
previous work applies a dual-encoder structure to separately encode image and
text, but fails to learn cross-modal feature alignment, making it hard to
achieve cross-modal deep information interaction. This paper proposes a novel
CLIP-guided contrastive-learning-based architecture to perform multi-modal
feature alignment, which projects the features derived from different
modalities into a unified deep space. On multi-modal sarcasm detection (MMSD)
and multi-modal sentiment analysis (MMSA) tasks, the experimental results show
that our proposed model significantly outperforms several baselines, and our
feature alignment strategy brings obvious performance gain over models with
different aggregating methods and models even enriched with knowledge. More
importantly, our model is simple to implement without using task-specific
external knowledge, and thus can easily migrate to other multi-modal tasks. Our
source codes are available at https://github.com/ChangKe123/CLFA.
|
[
-0.5422210693359375,
-0.49390852451324463,
0.5969640016555786,
0.11559932678937912,
-0.6030505299568176,
-0.07885363698005676,
-0.23420998454093933,
-0.4563416838645935,
0.21993854641914368,
0.08661570399999619,
-0.9460299015045166,
-0.45390522480010986,
-0.5467017889022827,
-0.16619113087654114,
-0.08603637665510178,
0.8779048919677734,
0.14869897067546844,
0.377631276845932,
-0.32600513100624084,
-0.3926893472671509,
-0.5286834239959717,
-0.23713241517543793,
-0.09558995068073273,
-0.0035629156045615673,
0.37965264916419983,
0.3390035331249237,
0.8362330198287964,
0.33745619654655457,
0.42301732301712036,
0.2917995750904083,
-0.11991705745458603,
0.4597732424736023,
-0.2803812026977539,
-0.18906788527965546,
-0.3522982895374298,
-0.2211320847272873,
-0.2766464948654175,
-0.1965513676404953,
0.2823798358440399,
0.49049994349479675,
0.2596769630908966,
-0.005977454595267773,
0.07684244215488434,
0.28099462389945984,
-0.7505693435668945,
0.10479814559221268,
-0.5457108020782471,
-0.10721290111541748,
0.07077143341302872,
-0.07371322065591812,
-0.2537648677825928,
0.12835007905960083,
0.255346417427063,
-0.6979649662971497,
0.09545213729143143,
-0.20451132953166962,
0.8621437549591064,
0.38966691493988037,
-0.8062137365341187,
-0.47283491492271423,
-0.12789300084114075,
0.8720569610595703,
-0.4519597589969635,
0.6446391940116882,
-0.018051691353321075,
0.2880594730377197,
0.2676713466644287,
-0.42607244849205017,
-0.76214599609375,
0.17762096226215363,
-0.1403445601463318,
0.2068033665418625,
0.20510666072368622,
-0.08412878215312958,
-0.23879674077033997,
0.48922184109687805,
-0.3324023187160492,
-0.040787942707538605,
-0.24627342820167542,
-0.35010087490081787,
0.09126973897218704,
0.22566600143909454,
0.2730851471424103,
-0.48836594820022583,
-1.10658597946167,
-0.055214621126651764,
-0.2527373731136322,
0.35249757766723633,
-0.027212390676140785,
0.29061493277549744,
-0.3875305950641632,
0.33821871876716614,
0.005893429275602102,
0.46698513627052307,
0.1660999059677124,
-0.281068354845047,
0.551206111907959,
-0.8187940716743469,
-0.31264838576316833,
-0.31658411026000977,
0.6447558403015137,
0.4663296937942505,
-0.2605946660041809,
-0.001112523372285068,
-0.13228826224803925,
0.2932155132293701,
0.15347705781459808,
-0.8728631734848022,
0.015825772657990456,
-0.05597275123000145,
-0.5953689813613892,
-0.39323118329048157,
0.24648180603981018,
-0.8423036336898804,
-0.305044025182724,
-0.44686052203178406,
0.5486503839492798,
-0.7166296243667603,
-0.17070239782333374,
0.3179655373096466,
-0.24722333252429962,
0.3253110647201538,
0.551384449005127,
-0.5751473903656006,
0.0037808874621987343,
0.6035317778587341,
0.7267677187919617,
-0.12557463347911835,
-0.4802577793598175,
-0.38251450657844543,
0.2269579917192459,
0.08828533440828323,
0.5869554281234741,
-0.7308942675590515,
-0.23602423071861267,
-0.04776766896247864,
-0.008928928524255753,
-0.2062445729970932,
-0.17711366713047028,
0.633063793182373,
-0.6617799997329712,
0.5211383104324341,
-0.29570916295051575,
-0.27094337344169617,
-0.5738425850868225,
0.45298632979393005,
-0.6520799398422241,
0.6690270304679871,
-0.10732246190309525,
-0.736331045627594,
0.4632575213909149,
-0.60804283618927,
-0.35681912302970886,
-0.3451576232910156,
-0.3330734372138977,
-0.19511516392230988,
0.06970258057117462,
0.5685281753540039,
0.41378673911094666,
-0.3349229097366333,
0.29117152094841003,
-0.40324831008911133,
-0.3074710965156555,
0.47516557574272156,
-0.5014024376869202,
0.5816850662231445,
0.17618077993392944,
-0.22803816199302673,
0.24869291484355927,
-0.5339707136154175,
-0.19118274748325348,
-0.03881548345088959,
-0.20364998281002045,
-0.3793376684188843,
-0.19596698880195618,
0.1760372817516327,
0.6653867959976196,
0.35694432258605957,
-0.4557899534702301,
-0.10058348625898361,
-0.08814682811498642,
0.2814800441265106,
0.655674397945404,
-0.1239035502076149,
0.5203164219856262,
-0.21462152898311615,
0.3116708993911743,
0.6243340373039246,
0.31784072518348694,
-0.581556499004364,
-0.2101629078388214,
-0.6240886449813843,
-0.8268213868141174,
0.18118804693222046,
0.47227656841278076,
-0.7999473214149475,
0.4809982478618622,
-0.32694151997566223,
0.002806134521961212,
-0.6259360909461975,
0.31136563420295715,
0.5640193223953247,
0.7579953074455261,
0.6455325484275818,
-0.5208595991134644,
-0.2946334481239319,
-0.8304373621940613,
0.1070372462272644,
0.319917768239975,
0.08162140101194382,
0.6009517312049866,
0.37959858775138855,
-0.5384471416473389,
0.7394900918006897,
-0.5322992205619812,
-0.5276761651039124,
-0.005306451581418514,
0.2401055246591568,
-0.11873418837785721,
0.4311161935329437,
0.5614556074142456,
-1.0779099464416504,
-0.1320967823266983,
0.061688926070928574,
-0.5307748913764954,
-0.004177678842097521,
-0.2212890237569809,
-0.26378104090690613,
-0.11298337578773499,
0.41824454069137573,
-0.5957484245300293,
0.22670678794384003,
0.3732371926307678,
-0.47903016209602356,
0.33555173873901367,
0.20816892385482788,
0.38345056772232056,
-1.3501412868499756,
0.057582125067710876,
0.06067200377583504,
-0.3400881886482239,
-0.37413862347602844,
-0.04843335598707199,
0.25216203927993774,
-0.06106970086693764,
-0.5475907325744629,
0.2070716917514801,
-0.5168614983558655,
-0.05062947794795036,
-0.22228802740573883,
0.4061717092990875,
0.46982118487358093,
0.6608148217201233,
0.06105321645736694,
0.7677642107009888,
0.5020354986190796,
-0.48970460891723633,
0.05510135367512703,
0.40466412901878357,
-0.20728354156017303,
0.7840437889099121,
-0.23837213218212128,
-0.05312998220324516,
-0.08663694560527802,
0.1533469408750534,
-0.9472678899765015,
-0.1264895647764206,
0.20036178827285767,
-0.4692970812320709,
0.18131019175052643,
-0.1968177855014801,
0.04084571450948715,
-0.002282507251948118,
-0.6777966022491455,
0.6927230954170227,
0.2145458161830902,
-0.7717074155807495,
0.9012002348899841,
0.18827851116657257,
0.15241515636444092,
-0.9318942427635193,
-0.7049421072006226,
-0.16765323281288147,
-0.15680839121341705,
-0.7340775728225708,
0.631840705871582,
-0.032801005989313126,
0.26382768154144287,
0.2902225852012634,
-0.1617790311574936,
-0.21026511490345,
-0.027100548148155212,
0.23481979966163635,
0.3960459232330322,
-0.46165919303894043,
0.3830811083316803,
0.18544931709766388,
0.08829168975353241,
-0.22180236876010895,
-0.03890570253133774,
0.5450109839439392,
-0.21284982562065125,
-0.5506429076194763,
-0.6994728446006775,
0.5238004922866821,
0.9019104242324829,
-0.4129950702190399,
0.5504338145256042,
0.8738336563110352,
-0.14935703575611115,
-0.2020999640226364,
-0.5407369136810303,
-0.11998791992664337,
-0.4534946084022522,
0.42860230803489685,
-0.6133689284324646,
-0.9353165626525879,
0.4932123124599457,
-0.3447406589984894,
-0.24349501729011536,
0.3645437955856323,
0.5235409736633301,
-0.10075641423463821,
1.0105297565460205,
0.8878746628761292,
-0.042262639850378036,
0.6180746555328369,
-0.05765906721353531,
0.1493457406759262,
-0.8951188921928406,
-0.453761488199234,
-0.1060822606086731,
-0.3816784620285034,
0.04678274318575859,
-0.928628146648407,
0.18890470266342163,
0.21897590160369873,
-0.06702366471290588,
0.06166145205497742,
-0.30603712797164917,
0.41962963342666626,
0.20277781784534454,
0.39887529611587524,
0.35916703939437866,
-0.28364235162734985,
-0.1931343823671341,
-0.14443786442279816,
-0.3549613058567047,
-0.20219622552394867,
0.6125336289405823,
0.36236655712127686,
0.8838041424751282,
0.239131897687912,
0.4015296697616577,
0.1583269089460373,
-0.10789825022220612,
-0.9327690005302429,
0.3659975528717041,
-0.29022231698036194,
-0.09159480035305023,
-0.02308979071676731,
-0.2326265275478363,
-0.4662748873233795,
0.7202613949775696,
-0.35768717527389526,
-0.24168947339057922,
0.5536147356033325,
-0.052507273852825165,
-0.24502761662006378,
0.09154638648033142,
-0.827610969543457,
1.0624452829360962,
-0.4541556239128113,
-0.13755300641059875,
-0.5024728178977966,
-0.7543679475784302,
0.6531963348388672,
0.24063658714294434,
0.3039208948612213,
-0.17956186830997467,
-0.5028204917907715,
0.254798024892807,
-0.22594870626926422,
1.1927095651626587,
-0.17479504644870758,
0.10441053658723831,
0.024375926703214645,
0.01822713576257229,
0.02294735796749592,
0.2577897012233734,
0.16981841623783112,
-0.08991905301809311,
-0.02023349516093731,
-0.22519946098327637,
-0.8561340570449829,
0.610363781452179,
-0.5890201330184937,
-0.2705868184566498,
-0.07419990748167038,
-0.6664462089538574,
-0.15262816846370697,
0.17018038034439087,
-0.005854662507772446,
0.5654952526092529,
-0.4132721424102783,
0.13447147607803345,
0.7042276859283447,
0.09934921562671661,
0.5046964883804321,
0.43933168053627014,
-0.0031113282311707735,
-0.7591286301612854,
0.8622018694877625,
-0.5270446538925171,
0.19560503959655762,
0.46303674578666687,
0.10815852880477905,
-0.32710686326026917,
-0.18207332491874695,
-0.6223751306533813,
0.1572399139404297,
-0.9757989645004272,
-0.4278223514556885,
-0.6266974210739136,
0.16579972207546234,
-0.39219993352890015,
-0.48867687582969666,
-0.4261072278022766,
-0.2681463658809662,
-0.609399676322937,
0.2149454951286316,
0.06835756450891495,
0.45302262902259827,
0.05043340474367142,
0.16597536206245422,
-0.8366414308547974,
0.4055708944797516,
0.4434265196323395,
0.2106344848871231,
0.009523208253085613,
-0.44497057795524597,
-0.14612342417240143,
-0.0930381566286087,
-0.29603537917137146,
-0.9486300945281982,
0.1318310797214508,
0.3300454318523407,
0.5352470278739929,
0.8041344881057739,
-0.004365640226751566,
0.9337520599365234,
-0.1336354911327362,
0.6778060793876648,
0.6413779258728027,
-1.3907345533370972,
0.3328152000904083,
0.010926471091806889,
0.43287137150764465,
0.814522385597229,
0.3784772455692291,
-0.5234016180038452,
0.06553788483142853,
-0.18692487478256226,
-0.5800308585166931,
0.6247292757034302,
-0.3545074760913849,
0.1955421417951584,
0.11013815551996231,
-0.025603996589779854,
0.3772747814655304,
0.2279004603624344,
-0.777447521686554,
0.13427673280239105,
-0.5199100971221924,
-0.6490873098373413,
0.17970259487628937,
-0.25278007984161377,
-0.44893842935562134,
-0.24256832897663116,
0.33554282784461975,
-0.6170774698257446,
0.16319957375526428,
0.23121345043182373,
-0.6961256265640259,
0.3455217182636261,
0.45590823888778687,
0.7912286520004272,
0.5079479813575745,
0.11278823763132095,
0.4093494713306427,
0.1771174818277359,
-0.2818912863731384,
-0.13271130621433258,
0.13389307260513306,
0.07636415213346481,
-0.1833035796880722,
0.12741193175315857,
0.8025936484336853,
0.7178161144256592,
-0.6972342133522034,
1.1155775785446167,
-0.03335142880678177,
-0.029448658227920532,
0.15093199908733368,
-0.13635247945785522,
0.0980740413069725,
0.5029096007347107,
0.08392288535833359,
0.26208147406578064,
0.31547287106513977,
-0.5883912444114685,
0.31767481565475464,
0.7363542914390564,
-0.5065045356750488,
-0.4996143877506256,
0.32471421360969543,
0.3916873037815094,
0.23401780426502228,
0.2101118564605713,
-0.06963498145341873,
-0.8530899286270142,
0.3038944602012634,
0.4760175049304962,
0.8152804374694824,
0.025547616183757782,
0.3092162609100342,
-0.04284704849123955,
0.13472384214401245,
0.3247601091861725,
0.3920411765575409,
-0.5415475368499756,
-0.6810895204544067,
-0.42064401507377625,
-0.43784767389297485,
-0.36146309971809387,
-0.22778917849063873,
-0.6029564738273621,
0.3883588910102844,
-0.23598702251911163,
0.033949024975299835,
0.0034886712674051523,
-0.48865455389022827,
-0.7534967660903931,
0.19983479380607605,
0.21745792031288147,
0.8750358819961548,
-0.8772914409637451,
0.6526085138320923,
0.6223294734954834,
-0.5962651371955872,
-0.40924423933029175,
0.2211616486310959,
0.14862139523029327,
-0.8195332884788513,
0.5562628507614136,
0.4877455234527588,
-0.6192532181739807,
-0.5513051748275757,
-0.3717494606971741,
-0.7491823434829712,
1.2879366874694824,
0.29470786452293396,
-0.016015132889151573,
0.10282056033611298,
-0.11419154703617096,
0.32091593742370605,
-0.7825713753700256,
0.22381417453289032,
0.25430572032928467,
0.24154599010944366,
0.2528982162475586,
-0.8160631656646729,
0.23681318759918213,
-0.25004875659942627,
-0.10692423582077026,
0.18165414035320282,
-0.8011513948440552,
0.7323335409164429,
-0.20389404892921448,
-0.2714046537876129,
-0.2444426417350769,
0.8443306684494019,
-0.268648236989975,
0.2947409152984619,
0.5962404012680054,
0.7552875280380249,
0.7102437019348145,
0.17990389466285706,
0.5422936677932739,
-0.2435702681541443,
0.2535851299762726,
1.097185730934143,
-0.1920595020055771,
0.7898300886154175,
0.6091592311859131,
0.3254319727420807,
0.8303647041320801,
0.3014894425868988,
0.055018410086631775,
0.7617511749267578,
-0.4107491075992584,
-0.40517058968544006,
-0.5324205160140991,
-0.19443254172801971,
-0.2838292717933655,
0.7097307443618774,
0.43576580286026,
-0.5412411689758301,
-0.3771531283855438,
0.17688937485218048,
-0.19319447875022888,
0.01717621088027954,
-0.2427292913198471,
0.9724532961845398,
-0.08756580948829651,
-0.3813122808933258,
0.3502741754055023,
-0.06277820467948914,
1.1513638496398926,
-0.5314807295799255,
-0.0006131326663307846,
0.17369423806667328,
0.16737639904022217,
-0.24299094080924988,
-0.8734313249588013,
0.28392696380615234,
-0.3369312882423401,
-0.5188103914260864,
0.023891087621450424,
0.7203139662742615,
-0.5419090986251831,
-0.18840914964675903,
0.38159891963005066,
0.5385317206382751,
-0.25794270634651184,
0.1412658393383026,
-0.7530176043510437,
0.2287430763244629,
-0.0639340877532959,
-0.025194425135850906,
0.3738274872303009,
0.5301406979560852,
0.08700131624937057,
0.33015966415405273,
0.5714395046234131,
-0.49542132019996643,
0.026637820526957512,
0.1746634542942047,
1.2214478254318237,
-0.6538602113723755,
-0.6957724690437317,
-0.7136796116828918,
0.5934443473815918,
-0.29867300391197205,
-0.44264206290245056,
0.357046902179718,
0.402907133102417,
0.7665534615516663,
-0.08471161127090454,
0.5135990381240845,
0.03947603702545166,
0.3293517529964447,
-0.6606664657592773,
0.2976016700267792,
-0.7184219360351562,
0.048646993935108185,
-0.05878381431102753,
-0.4919310212135315,
-0.20401263236999512,
0.3423943817615509,
-0.16390879452228546,
-0.12897911667823792,
0.8702439069747925,
0.7674240469932556,
-0.4684131443500519,
0.04141785576939583,
0.30408775806427,
-0.1868664175271988,
0.15648342669010162,
0.7609848976135254,
0.7623056173324585,
-0.26296067237854004,
0.8422215580940247,
-0.4058088958263397,
-0.28269946575164795,
-0.20329542458057404,
-0.7843838334083557,
-0.9680033326148987,
-0.6417637467384338,
-0.08003028482198715,
-0.09357546269893646,
-0.29386812448501587,
0.8386185765266418,
0.8502473831176758,
-0.6826527118682861,
0.19351251423358917,
0.30232688784599304,
0.25693556666374207,
-0.17872269451618195,
-0.23747874796390533,
0.4487587809562683,
-0.6109110713005066,
-0.6828897595405579,
0.5881770849227905,
0.44047272205352783,
-0.1103273406624794,
-0.14843662083148956,
-0.06183862313628197,
-0.18679669499397278,
0.21528097987174988,
0.56937175989151,
0.14781728386878967,
-0.8715510368347168,
-0.3189018964767456,
0.04846527427434921,
-0.39798393845558167,
0.28047966957092285,
1.0227965116500854,
-0.7974438667297363,
0.4478136897087097,
0.5502995252609253,
0.9982410669326782,
0.32930195331573486,
0.23342394828796387,
0.32493409514427185,
-0.627200722694397,
0.1943143904209137,
0.1369948834180832,
0.44977232813835144,
0.36075377464294434,
-0.49546724557876587,
0.044608891010284424,
0.29709044098854065,
-0.25328847765922546,
-0.47920119762420654,
0.39107030630111694,
-1.41725492477417,
-0.5587591528892517,
0.7258660197257996,
0.08448664098978043,
-0.22091145813465118,
-0.15391704440116882,
-0.4707304835319519,
0.13615478575229645,
-0.4848858714103699,
0.6290925145149231,
0.40078556537628174,
-0.08835975080728531,
-0.3710920810699463,
-0.02830193005502224,
0.4235497713088989,
0.6436368227005005,
-0.6832161545753479,
-0.09278583526611328,
0.8221936225891113,
0.25089338421821594,
0.26373475790023804,
0.3716808259487152,
-0.30243560671806335,
0.6347540616989136,
-0.09723290055990219,
0.054858069866895676,
-0.3340930640697479,
-0.41432854533195496,
-0.6028079390525818,
0.4739554822444916,
-0.3147277235984802,
-0.5865452885627747
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06354v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06354v1
|
Amharic LLaMA and LLaVA: Multimodal LLMs for Low Resource Languages
| 2024-03-11T01:04:36 | 2024-03-11T01:04:36 |
Michael Andersland
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) like GPT-4 and LLaMA have shown incredible
proficiency at natural language processing tasks and have even begun to excel
at tasks across other modalities such as vision and audio. Despite their
success, LLMs often struggle to perform well on low-resource languages because
there is so little training data available. This shortcoming is especially
prevalent with open source models. In this work, we explore training LLaMA-2 to
speak Amharic, a language which is spoken by over 50 million people world wide,
but has orders of magnitude less data available than languages like English. We
employ methods previously used for training LLMs on other languages with data
scarcity, and use open source translation models to perform data augmentation
and grow our dataset from millions of tokens to billions. We further enhance
the capabilities of our model by connecting an image encoder and training on a
translated visual instruction tuning dataset in the same manner as LLaVA,
resulting in a multimodal Amharic LLM that can understand images along with
text. We introduce an Amharic version of a popular benchmarking dataset to
evaluate our work. Our models and dataset are open sourced and available on
GitHub.
|
[
-0.1860557198524475,
-0.6598961353302002,
0.30641815066337585,
0.1857469528913498,
-0.4200884699821472,
0.49528637528419495,
-0.5170235633850098,
-0.8075858950614929,
0.33205801248550415,
0.33218154311180115,
-0.4071744978427887,
-0.5206570625305176,
-0.7261865139007568,
0.1784701943397522,
-0.11072906851768494,
0.735090434551239,
-0.4422074258327484,
0.26848742365837097,
-0.28113746643066406,
-0.5904462337493896,
-0.3828134834766388,
-0.38043448328971863,
-0.5371547341346741,
-0.20230382680892944,
0.4448094069957733,
0.722015380859375,
0.7531067728996277,
0.6827766299247742,
0.26873740553855896,
0.32638847827911377,
0.003087360644713044,
0.4040223956108093,
-0.4493889808654785,
0.10411562770605087,
0.22630180418491364,
-0.5940443873405457,
-0.2826489508152008,
-0.06047872081398964,
0.6229755878448486,
0.468269407749176,
-0.15359781682491302,
0.3657156825065613,
-0.12458694726228714,
0.4722084701061249,
-0.6774061918258667,
0.44411447644233704,
-0.6666933298110962,
0.06677912175655365,
-0.4407145380973816,
0.036395568400621414,
-0.15225835144519806,
-0.25494125485420227,
-0.36363667249679565,
-0.6889359354972839,
-0.038823213428258896,
0.23875188827514648,
0.500636100769043,
0.46424242854118347,
-0.5551226139068604,
-0.4142981767654419,
-0.5491530299186707,
0.9733805656433105,
-0.43021732568740845,
0.3792079985141754,
0.5538510084152222,
0.30130836367607117,
0.07000813633203506,
-0.4545252323150635,
-0.7011813521385193,
-0.39168912172317505,
0.1528678685426712,
-0.060843706130981445,
-0.28988730907440186,
-0.1000325083732605,
0.18050755560398102,
0.609352171421051,
-0.3748786449432373,
0.3068372905254364,
-0.41703078150749207,
-0.20200258493423462,
0.3252798020839691,
0.18975664675235748,
0.21557846665382385,
-0.22560422122478485,
-0.3764825165271759,
-0.11070602387189865,
-0.724063515663147,
-0.03768778592348099,
0.45213380455970764,
0.14021450281143188,
-0.5041441321372986,
0.8628594875335693,
-0.08004050701856613,
0.6621331572532654,
-0.5173811316490173,
-0.3189646899700165,
0.3229964077472687,
-0.4651370644569397,
0.02501523867249489,
-0.12232109904289246,
0.673270583152771,
0.237554669380188,
0.3935689926147461,
0.0028855379205197096,
-0.31678128242492676,
0.10361509770154953,
0.06787995994091034,
-0.5939691066741943,
-0.13548485934734344,
-0.21228571236133575,
-0.4990836977958679,
-0.20723788440227509,
-0.5836998224258423,
-0.7677187919616699,
-0.40814098715782166,
-0.3625156581401825,
0.17350612580776215,
-0.3055288791656494,
-0.0473356731235981,
-0.13102199137210846,
0.3017100393772125,
0.22179579734802246,
0.5450835227966309,
-1.1991568803787231,
0.2487640678882599,
0.17954736948013306,
1.1331586837768555,
-0.04804346337914467,
-0.2669426500797272,
-0.6028634309768677,
0.21033009886741638,
-0.2879396080970764,
0.76595139503479,
-0.7703121304512024,
-0.38340258598327637,
-0.01559564657509327,
0.03924817219376564,
0.08337665349245071,
-0.5209276080131531,
0.536992073059082,
-0.38120269775390625,
-0.22664159536361694,
-0.2098473310470581,
-0.0059694088995456696,
-0.31204015016555786,
0.3816354274749756,
-0.7670702934265137,
0.8726229667663574,
0.14191828668117523,
-0.6369462013244629,
0.08558465540409088,
-0.6748597025871277,
-0.49691468477249146,
0.11681658774614334,
-0.31491705775260925,
-0.165085107088089,
0.17338846623897552,
0.5543925166130066,
0.24037110805511475,
-0.6402215957641602,
-0.22119662165641785,
-0.3512127995491028,
-0.16511870920658112,
0.2488652914762497,
-0.6342451572418213,
0.49384626746177673,
0.29915738105773926,
0.09884607791900635,
0.0651620402932167,
-0.64521324634552,
-0.018502691760659218,
0.3159051537513733,
-0.8937031030654907,
-0.2917364239692688,
-0.10425896942615509,
0.3940570056438446,
0.06725842505693436,
0.42907074093818665,
-0.6906996965408325,
0.2630985379219055,
-0.23868153989315033,
0.7534166574478149,
0.7547521591186523,
-0.3772789239883423,
0.3630061745643616,
-0.21375331282615662,
0.6525012254714966,
0.1308155059814453,
0.15587660670280457,
-0.23604609072208405,
-0.5958669781684875,
-1.0350786447525024,
-0.3573181629180908,
0.3860124945640564,
0.6452692747116089,
-1.0729496479034424,
-0.259754478931427,
-0.31320008635520935,
-0.18154674768447876,
-0.9340454339981079,
0.6112606525421143,
0.34041762351989746,
0.35808348655700684,
0.47851288318634033,
-0.459269255399704,
-0.4923427700996399,
-1.1027753353118896,
0.05843331664800644,
-0.20923453569412231,
-0.04906012862920761,
0.5656853914260864,
0.4849746823310852,
-0.32073527574539185,
0.4130694568157196,
-0.31515568494796753,
-0.3417922556400299,
-0.3544728457927704,
-0.09307270497083664,
0.13824142515659332,
0.3541189134120941,
0.45910143852233887,
-0.6037670373916626,
-0.36240440607070923,
0.2934281527996063,
-0.8291988968849182,
0.08073171228170395,
0.30569371581077576,
0.09126017987728119,
0.344432532787323,
0.42127475142478943,
-0.3938579857349396,
0.15203514695167542,
0.9433504939079285,
0.14779439568519592,
0.2768579423427582,
-0.3296591341495514,
0.24146582186222076,
-1.1331602334976196,
-0.09316269308328629,
-0.0634842962026596,
-0.2884805500507355,
-0.44114115834236145,
-0.09511582553386688,
0.07605918496847153,
-0.2697327136993408,
-0.5695667266845703,
0.6613129377365112,
-0.6370174884796143,
-0.33208516240119934,
-0.24377749860286713,
-0.04728839546442032,
-0.3535238802433014,
0.5785683393478394,
-0.03147440403699875,
1.018458366394043,
0.4538147747516632,
-0.29919981956481934,
0.6061696410179138,
0.4920309782028198,
-0.6806186437606812,
0.3842889070510864,
-0.489263653755188,
0.15790021419525146,
-0.01277677621692419,
0.10222452133893967,
-0.7899618744850159,
-0.5760604739189148,
0.38346436619758606,
-0.10232575237751007,
0.24286480247974396,
-0.22184738516807556,
-0.6983493566513062,
-0.3272015154361725,
-0.28722891211509705,
0.6430589556694031,
0.3581034243106842,
-0.8542320728302002,
0.5871233344078064,
0.5244655013084412,
-0.17566874623298645,
-0.8112857937812805,
-0.8490097522735596,
0.30096256732940674,
-0.015818554908037186,
-0.6374257802963257,
0.1351107954978943,
-0.07403083145618439,
-0.08123345673084259,
-0.014638709835708141,
0.06626735627651215,
-0.03400163725018501,
0.052418556064367294,
0.3566032350063324,
0.1698925495147705,
-0.16788829863071442,
0.2788218557834625,
0.046487271785736084,
-0.12092342227697372,
-0.3573567867279053,
-0.12935121357440948,
0.5093027949333191,
-0.3485092222690582,
-0.5364007949829102,
-0.21933768689632416,
0.29036223888397217,
0.4977894425392151,
-0.35660263895988464,
0.7504904866218567,
0.636610209941864,
-0.31817173957824707,
0.010763317346572876,
-0.5721407532691956,
0.21383953094482422,
-0.458279550075531,
0.35244253277778625,
-0.3153032660484314,
-0.9105264544487,
0.43344542384147644,
-0.18899847567081451,
-0.028987983241677284,
-0.010811234824359417,
0.8403728008270264,
-0.06188850477337837,
0.6491179466247559,
0.8234476447105408,
-0.24965395033359528,
0.5744485855102539,
-0.15319964289665222,
-0.023448677733540535,
-0.8102936744689941,
-0.2952660024166107,
-0.16024580597877502,
-0.5680223703384399,
-0.6367789506912231,
-0.8704662919044495,
0.44058945775032043,
0.05097442492842674,
0.09861847758293152,
0.22939306497573853,
-0.10321858525276184,
0.7893840074539185,
0.6549398303031921,
0.1923520714044571,
0.550973117351532,
0.2719297707080841,
-0.1364961862564087,
-0.008302662521600723,
-0.5983151197433472,
-0.7871142029762268,
1.1854325532913208,
0.365816205739975,
1.1413955688476562,
0.13253793120384216,
0.2734931409358978,
0.21473832428455353,
0.24861663579940796,
-0.9114558696746826,
0.4329509437084198,
-0.35064995288848877,
-0.3811882734298706,
-0.11851626634597778,
-0.2712715268135071,
-0.6865440011024475,
0.2699289619922638,
-0.31941720843315125,
-0.31325504183769226,
0.006175123620778322,
0.288576602935791,
0.08030998706817627,
0.4636383652687073,
-0.8009475469589233,
0.7343120574951172,
-0.5278051495552063,
-0.2672250270843506,
-0.4088720679283142,
-0.5725017189979553,
0.5629060864448547,
-0.28198158740997314,
0.26700350642204285,
-0.2875402867794037,
-0.5148097276687622,
0.5525259971618652,
-0.25159752368927,
0.9363425374031067,
0.010603554546833038,
-0.10756398737430573,
0.24227876961231232,
-0.20909518003463745,
0.5688712000846863,
0.24613958597183228,
-0.056552134454250336,
0.5509018898010254,
-0.3797319829463959,
-0.6871029138565063,
-0.17744489014148712,
0.6820704340934753,
-0.965576708316803,
-0.3951297998428345,
-0.10201112180948257,
-0.5777286887168884,
-0.15314152836799622,
-0.0852341577410698,
0.016470536589622498,
0.16984237730503082,
-0.2129780501127243,
0.2544892132282257,
0.2963528335094452,
-0.42023611068725586,
0.4081404507160187,
0.5183156132698059,
0.08111429214477539,
-0.634289562702179,
0.8003376126289368,
0.058890677988529205,
0.1398358941078186,
0.28306812047958374,
-0.1300651580095291,
-0.21374385058879852,
-0.7156081795692444,
-0.7928835153579712,
0.36824026703834534,
-0.9305857419967651,
-0.35611197352409363,
-0.5668514966964722,
-0.04464622214436531,
-0.006651235744357109,
-0.00041809503454715014,
-0.35137462615966797,
-0.4564434289932251,
-0.35994094610214233,
0.03969196230173111,
0.5432288646697998,
0.8807519674301147,
-0.13838273286819458,
0.5216627717018127,
-0.6928440928459167,
0.2558894455432892,
0.41061538457870483,
0.41526687145233154,
-0.02588079869747162,
-0.38975515961647034,
-0.5455365180969238,
0.023991426452994347,
-0.42432650923728943,
-0.5999395251274109,
0.4556867182254791,
0.3197062909603119,
0.4660075306892395,
0.12823741137981415,
-0.24736429750919342,
0.6493679285049438,
-0.5881524085998535,
0.5789576172828674,
0.27829235792160034,
-0.9292490482330322,
0.5432645678520203,
-0.14840351045131683,
0.29000693559646606,
0.4601821303367615,
0.44550108909606934,
-0.5471274852752686,
-0.27126431465148926,
-0.022891145199537277,
-0.5818214416503906,
0.8025103211402893,
0.2300109565258026,
0.2593229413032532,
0.10743923485279083,
0.185889333486557,
0.2256670743227005,
0.35861197113990784,
-0.9295496940612793,
-0.07594329118728638,
-0.40125879645347595,
-0.35933712124824524,
-0.29246431589126587,
-0.2948843836784363,
-0.12142553180456161,
-0.0024899307172745466,
0.4589509665966034,
-0.28480902314186096,
0.16371667385101318,
-0.27074989676475525,
-0.3453756868839264,
-0.2972666323184967,
0.26594775915145874,
0.5554688572883606,
0.2623308300971985,
0.14602947235107422,
0.2348565012216568,
0.5178138017654419,
-0.6672722101211548,
0.3444899022579193,
-0.015993591398000717,
0.09082446247339249,
-0.20597171783447266,
0.482904314994812,
1.0257586240768433,
0.3856102228164673,
-0.9414823055267334,
0.45212671160697937,
-0.11715365946292877,
0.007665220648050308,
-0.35710883140563965,
-0.08751950412988663,
0.15435874462127686,
0.48781007528305054,
0.10292184352874756,
0.23129744827747345,
-0.2379261702299118,
-0.3388507664203644,
-0.23902714252471924,
0.45187535881996155,
-0.11099346727132797,
-0.4806284010410309,
0.723924994468689,
0.4298650324344635,
-0.06747955828905106,
0.704268753528595,
-0.047583967447280884,
-0.24575011432170868,
0.46285635232925415,
0.4412166476249695,
0.49896857142448425,
-0.12825538218021393,
0.10256347805261612,
0.3176743686199188,
0.5857698917388916,
-0.004698735661804676,
0.25079503655433655,
-0.25200220942497253,
-0.6554471850395203,
-0.5636045932769775,
-0.8599269390106201,
-0.6617015600204468,
0.24940767884254456,
-0.24073539674282074,
0.4463002681732178,
-0.33910566568374634,
-0.02409978397190571,
-0.2473982572555542,
-0.034135378897190094,
-0.7217048406600952,
-0.2522525489330292,
0.27908599376678467,
0.6321724057197571,
-0.9329556822776794,
1.0105243921279907,
0.7852177619934082,
-0.47693848609924316,
-0.49702543020248413,
-0.27035951614379883,
-0.01994963176548481,
-1.3374295234680176,
0.8499829769134521,
0.2445100098848343,
-0.03637656569480896,
-0.016764895990490913,
-0.6432755589485168,
-0.8904436826705933,
1.19282066822052,
0.7673198580741882,
-0.5902613997459412,
-0.030554858967661858,
0.20220230519771576,
0.41740837693214417,
-0.41616058349609375,
0.14841455221176147,
0.2176591157913208,
0.39435818791389465,
0.277149498462677,
-0.9316985011100769,
-0.2426694631576538,
-0.24705807864665985,
0.11680332571268082,
0.18509654700756073,
-0.8178604245185852,
0.893471896648407,
-0.5061758756637573,
-0.33525940775871277,
0.24952302873134613,
0.5800398588180542,
0.1211128681898117,
0.12343613058328629,
0.5208042860031128,
0.6032910346984863,
0.7532830238342285,
0.08587571233510971,
0.908838152885437,
-0.30487895011901855,
0.02986677922308445,
0.9779122471809387,
-0.21987521648406982,
0.9591304659843445,
0.46381595730781555,
-0.14923086762428284,
0.3958832919597626,
0.7532273530960083,
-0.05153685808181763,
0.4295240342617035,
0.15598748624324799,
-0.5404182076454163,
-0.3511955440044403,
-0.45989087224006653,
-0.20426598191261292,
0.7490883469581604,
0.423456609249115,
-0.20053496956825256,
-0.23241929709911346,
0.3170568645000458,
-0.22746722400188446,
-0.049963731318712234,
-0.3705723285675049,
0.5738662481307983,
0.18117199838161469,
-0.1749522089958191,
0.8175041675567627,
0.09595721960067749,
0.8100298047065735,
-0.5605871081352234,
-0.030217928811907768,
-0.31497952342033386,
0.07717641443014145,
-0.05536773428320885,
-0.6562873721122742,
0.10898638516664505,
0.35275545716285706,
-0.18047964572906494,
-0.12268227338790894,
0.6169164776802063,
-0.5197202563285828,
-0.4741845428943634,
0.3283522427082062,
0.6614972352981567,
0.40474313497543335,
0.36158815026283264,
-0.6361222267150879,
0.22707092761993408,
0.036215100437402725,
-0.0667487308382988,
0.4186284840106964,
0.29905030131340027,
-0.2505475580692291,
0.9193390607833862,
0.5877841114997864,
0.1665601283311844,
0.16461500525474548,
0.020232275128364563,
1.0251171588897705,
-0.44367480278015137,
-0.10456857830286026,
-0.6902632117271423,
0.1265445053577423,
0.191445454955101,
-0.1706504225730896,
0.6334974765777588,
0.5334537029266357,
0.8990615606307983,
-0.3716118335723877,
0.7154641151428223,
0.11069604009389877,
0.2827114462852478,
-0.6806379556655884,
0.4645015299320221,
-0.5450550317764282,
0.22287292778491974,
0.18613870441913605,
-0.8909182548522949,
-0.08578527718782425,
0.5088983178138733,
-0.22153370082378387,
-0.07362160831689835,
0.4228789508342743,
0.850851833820343,
-0.13721853494644165,
0.0400715172290802,
0.4340049624443054,
0.14244653284549713,
0.1741725504398346,
0.6718277335166931,
1.1256171464920044,
-0.338914692401886,
0.8988174796104431,
-0.12432282418012619,
-0.17157380282878876,
-0.11354614794254303,
-0.7638068795204163,
-0.9609025120735168,
-0.4571102559566498,
-0.0018564567435532808,
0.17380265891551971,
-0.05134221538901329,
0.9320380091667175,
0.6065402030944824,
-0.6179209351539612,
-0.33281397819519043,
0.03766295313835144,
0.1343613862991333,
0.17494429647922516,
-0.010521032847464085,
0.010403881780803204,
-0.36236321926116943,
-0.9590325951576233,
0.6312494277954102,
0.31880706548690796,
0.5163886547088623,
-0.38208669424057007,
-0.21460022032260895,
-0.1586327701807022,
-0.1811809241771698,
0.7088362574577332,
0.3033851683139801,
-0.7471563816070557,
-0.0016165164997801185,
-0.2000109702348709,
0.02254103310406208,
0.231984943151474,
0.6997868418693542,
-0.7695854306221008,
0.47904446721076965,
0.21009476482868195,
0.6400794386863708,
0.6286311149597168,
-0.03757192939519882,
0.3570939898490906,
-0.8910093307495117,
0.466084748506546,
0.05766462907195091,
0.4536490738391876,
0.6696678996086121,
0.05355726554989815,
0.6989017128944397,
0.19237032532691956,
-0.495654821395874,
-0.7633113861083984,
0.16026532649993896,
-0.8378157615661621,
-0.072918601334095,
1.08712899684906,
-0.06659892201423645,
-0.3167053163051605,
-0.09512254595756531,
-0.17017382383346558,
0.20166344940662384,
-0.46813395619392395,
0.485370397567749,
0.65052330493927,
0.09351523965597153,
-0.2295023649930954,
-1.0052562952041626,
0.18590176105499268,
0.18232454359531403,
-0.90160071849823,
0.1600901037454605,
0.43940985202789307,
0.09978902339935303,
0.07337643206119537,
0.6667447090148926,
-0.005013745743781328,
0.01723940670490265,
0.020582756027579308,
0.11887062340974808,
-0.186181902885437,
-0.2560408115386963,
-0.41099849343299866,
-0.14823471009731293,
0.31509488821029663,
-0.39483171701431274
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06350v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06350v1
|
IndicLLMSuite: A Blueprint for Creating Pre-training and Fine-Tuning Datasets for Indian Languages
| 2024-03-11T00:46:56 | 2024-03-11T00:46:56 |
Mohammed Safi Ur Rahman Khan, Priyam Mehta, Ananth Sankar, Umashankar Kumaravelan, Sumanth Doddapaneni, Suriyaprasaad G, Varun Balan G, Sparsh Jain, Anoop Kunchukuttan, Pratyush Kumar, Raj Dabre, Mitesh M. Khapra
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Despite the considerable advancements in English LLMs, the progress in
building comparable models for other languages has been hindered due to the
scarcity of tailored resources. Our work aims to bridge this divide by
introducing an expansive suite of resources specifically designed for the
development of Indic LLMs, covering 22 languages, containing a total of 251B
tokens and 74.8M instruction-response pairs. Recognizing the importance of both
data quality and quantity, our approach combines highly curated manually
verified data, unverified yet valuable data, and synthetic data. We build a
clean, open-source pipeline for curating pre-training data from diverse
sources, including websites, PDFs, and videos, incorporating best practices for
crawling, cleaning, flagging, and deduplication. For instruction-fine tuning,
we amalgamate existing Indic datasets, translate/transliterate English datasets
into Indian languages, and utilize LLaMa2 and Mixtral models to create
conversations grounded in articles from Indian Wikipedia and Wikihow.
Additionally, we address toxicity alignment by generating toxic prompts for
multiple scenarios and then generate non-toxic responses by feeding these toxic
prompts to an aligned LLaMa2 model. We hope that the datasets, tools, and
resources released as a part of this work will not only propel the research and
development of Indic LLMs but also establish an open-source blueprint for
extending such efforts to other languages. The data and other artifacts created
as part of this work are released with permissive licenses.
|
[
-0.1407870501279831,
-0.2664058208465576,
0.045077208429574966,
0.4119923412799835,
-0.24939675629138947,
0.3631434142589569,
-0.48429158329963684,
-0.39734041690826416,
0.1829139143228531,
0.4620782732963562,
-0.703494668006897,
-0.5554622411727905,
-0.4049607813358307,
0.25000715255737305,
-0.3429192006587982,
1.1026698350906372,
-0.08143489807844162,
0.17731772363185883,
-0.20950569212436676,
-0.23708784580230713,
-0.6446352005004883,
-0.03277803957462311,
-0.5124486088752747,
-0.16457559168338776,
0.35568350553512573,
0.8446669578552246,
0.3228631913661957,
0.5271767377853394,
0.3811088502407074,
0.18953466415405273,
0.15300028026103973,
0.4085692763328552,
-0.5388868451118469,
0.33489692211151123,
-0.35372573137283325,
-0.5728766322135925,
-0.10206246376037598,
0.08393842726945877,
0.32286229729652405,
0.44563034176826477,
-0.2655787169933319,
0.5834837555885315,
0.29031693935394287,
0.4645214080810547,
-0.7183808088302612,
0.222884863615036,
-0.6858058571815491,
-0.045015640556812286,
-0.5277800559997559,
-0.4123257100582123,
-0.3824537694454193,
-0.5779151916503906,
-0.43146812915802,
-0.5386507511138916,
-0.353046715259552,
-0.07661332190036774,
0.4565471410751343,
0.4686274826526642,
-0.15051743388175964,
-0.46967679262161255,
-0.7126860618591309,
0.7642953395843506,
-0.8177835941314697,
0.27560293674468994,
0.42534124851226807,
0.06882412731647491,
-0.028244080021977425,
-0.7706575989723206,
-0.36923137307167053,
-0.05413055419921875,
-0.04523385688662529,
0.1831989288330078,
0.38276803493499756,
-0.07551852613687515,
0.016298266127705574,
0.5967225432395935,
-0.556704580783844,
0.32523471117019653,
-0.5781807899475098,
0.00810152292251587,
0.7590479850769043,
0.5327990651130676,
0.6368985772132874,
0.2267419397830963,
-0.403287798166275,
0.2036779373884201,
-1.2051852941513062,
-0.017698241397738457,
0.5023199915885925,
0.5520790815353394,
-0.4184073507785797,
0.8479433059692383,
-0.11799123883247375,
0.5548621416091919,
-0.15577055513858795,
-0.1658972203731537,
0.16193817555904388,
-0.43960797786712646,
-0.13011661171913147,
0.10279599577188492,
0.7067002654075623,
0.1703350841999054,
0.34248045086860657,
-0.2135535627603531,
-0.1716020107269287,
0.11579310148954391,
0.02296522632241249,
-0.6853253841400146,
-0.1987190991640091,
0.3763996660709381,
-0.16540053486824036,
-0.18448476493358612,
-0.5200165510177612,
-0.6230714917182922,
-0.6144295334815979,
-0.7829806208610535,
0.12649622559547424,
-0.4678429961204529,
-0.4485321044921875,
-0.09913644194602966,
0.22967371344566345,
0.52764493227005,
-0.012976001016795635,
-1.189123272895813,
0.21089999377727509,
0.5087281465530396,
0.6995159387588501,
-0.38693228363990784,
-0.45100611448287964,
-0.19780263304710388,
0.2237171232700348,
-0.4193064868450165,
0.892749011516571,
-0.8672823309898376,
-0.4444934129714966,
0.26841264963150024,
-0.19984613358974457,
0.1228201761841774,
-0.589851975440979,
0.5058445930480957,
-0.21992914378643036,
0.2118336409330368,
-0.14527739584445953,
-0.5552759170532227,
0.16330388188362122,
0.3901318311691284,
-0.2637935280799866,
1.1423801183700562,
0.06258765608072281,
-0.9337337613105774,
0.43597254157066345,
-0.8227057456970215,
-0.5344550013542175,
0.44517847895622253,
-0.4507557153701782,
0.07515693455934525,
-0.03730583190917969,
0.09309032559394836,
0.28645920753479004,
-0.6276134252548218,
0.05015560984611511,
0.005021058488637209,
-0.43583863973617554,
-0.232167050242424,
-0.08884292095899582,
1.1740291118621826,
0.4900091588497162,
-0.11834365874528885,
0.25481662154197693,
-0.6772170066833496,
0.15644285082817078,
0.062391508370637894,
-0.4329642355442047,
-0.3173951804637909,
-0.10006406158208847,
0.02993352711200714,
0.24605922400951385,
0.2934359908103943,
-0.646430253982544,
0.09008637070655823,
-0.4912116527557373,
0.3521811068058014,
0.6671314239501953,
-0.04996972158551216,
0.49349141120910645,
-0.08510894328355789,
0.6673234105110168,
0.02077857218682766,
0.5940595865249634,
-0.28508976101875305,
-0.16847842931747437,
-0.6752095818519592,
-0.20847167074680328,
-0.07822640240192413,
0.9141146540641785,
-0.511710524559021,
0.10752221941947937,
-0.21616458892822266,
-0.6736845374107361,
-0.8423606753349304,
0.491166353225708,
0.4036954939365387,
0.48641660809516907,
0.2811679542064667,
-0.15489061176776886,
-0.6913008093833923,
-0.9496568441390991,
-0.3378964066505432,
0.08058096468448639,
0.06475948542356491,
-0.1067635640501976,
0.13859710097312927,
-0.24357272684574127,
0.8642867803573608,
-0.1735018789768219,
-0.2762151062488556,
-0.10825426876544952,
-0.18248963356018066,
0.1381886899471283,
0.5355710983276367,
0.21260859072208405,
-0.45180743932724,
-0.8368867039680481,
0.00912939477711916,
-0.781528651714325,
-0.02304297499358654,
0.18934805691242218,
-0.18418733775615692,
0.08158271014690399,
0.7733074426651001,
-0.5575500726699829,
0.1836124211549759,
0.5268456935882568,
-0.008915233425796032,
0.4300391376018524,
0.028424106538295746,
0.04910315200686455,
-1.4661351442337036,
-0.03142816573381424,
-0.17671088874340057,
0.13303709030151367,
-0.4721781611442566,
0.09384752064943314,
0.009188463911414146,
-0.28947725892066956,
-0.7395386099815369,
0.7607285380363464,
-0.5463311076164246,
0.2834753692150116,
0.04063042998313904,
0.023684317246079445,
-0.46174725890159607,
0.36770927906036377,
-0.176913321018219,
1.2016428709030151,
0.5393975377082825,
-0.5778826475143433,
0.19467280805110931,
0.6238534450531006,
-0.27211886644363403,
0.6756487488746643,
-0.5203374624252319,
0.025677243247628212,
-0.13864314556121826,
-0.21590647101402283,
-0.825634777545929,
-0.18577656149864197,
0.2534325420856476,
-0.45628270506858826,
0.5966095328330994,
-0.2626565396785736,
-0.6439264416694641,
0.01852181926369667,
-0.42981037497520447,
0.23701058328151703,
0.4362114667892456,
-0.6275609135627747,
0.5280396938323975,
0.7149196267127991,
-0.42097586393356323,
-0.7962279915809631,
-0.9045631289482117,
0.13240006566047668,
-0.26332318782806396,
-0.41996994614601135,
-0.11713403463363647,
-0.29680702090263367,
-0.2471528947353363,
-0.1189323216676712,
-0.0018152836710214615,
-0.03743891790509224,
-0.12166038900613785,
0.41955694556236267,
0.27992385625839233,
-0.04388154670596123,
0.06914235651493073,
0.09028270095586777,
-0.11990449577569962,
0.1887819916009903,
-0.0373079814016819,
0.44824323058128357,
-0.005674420390278101,
-0.4067141115665436,
-0.24315808713436127,
0.16407880187034607,
0.5318541526794434,
-0.6114432215690613,
0.5878690481185913,
0.5546625256538391,
-0.5118908286094666,
-0.29827558994293213,
-0.5471092462539673,
-0.11710930615663528,
-0.4950629472732544,
0.2159331887960434,
-0.06646592915058136,
-0.6533098816871643,
0.5155916213989258,
-0.2084258645772934,
0.48659199476242065,
0.24524888396263123,
0.8305036425590515,
0.03158167377114296,
0.6704520583152771,
0.7265570759773254,
-0.13070441782474518,
0.3992784023284912,
-0.15926353633403778,
0.4309436082839966,
-0.8310909271240234,
-0.604555606842041,
-0.41496869921684265,
0.0010852417908608913,
-0.667849600315094,
-0.17021068930625916,
0.11639048904180527,
-0.3379688858985901,
-0.5767245292663574,
0.14151400327682495,
-0.6695111393928528,
0.8795551657676697,
0.3845984637737274,
-0.08447947353124619,
0.2194923758506775,
0.15844982862472534,
-0.060852400958538055,
-0.2550317645072937,
-0.6435438990592957,
-0.7358693480491638,
1.2132970094680786,
0.23221755027770996,
1.1480436325073242,
0.030036145821213722,
0.6811732053756714,
0.12850366532802582,
0.6877290606498718,
-0.3475903570652008,
0.398368775844574,
-0.14833472669124603,
-0.8036089539527893,
-0.27132824063301086,
0.07560797035694122,
-0.7490508556365967,
-0.17306776344776154,
-0.21463896334171295,
-0.41972365975379944,
-0.06895274668931961,
0.06376663595438004,
-0.23720799386501312,
0.3005032539367676,
-0.969055712223053,
0.714558482170105,
-0.38801607489585876,
-0.5813586711883545,
-0.16502603888511658,
-0.6840595602989197,
0.6840866208076477,
0.0590323880314827,
0.17047782242298126,
-0.24956288933753967,
-0.186298206448555,
0.5014722943305969,
-0.41422373056411743,
1.0047632455825806,
-0.12285260856151581,
-0.19714896380901337,
0.4573017358779907,
0.061933211982250214,
0.3547402322292328,
0.2576751410961151,
0.0372915081679821,
0.08946288377046585,
-0.003317758906632662,
-0.4303109347820282,
-0.09962118417024612,
0.8115956783294678,
-0.6742912530899048,
-0.24914279580116272,
-0.24465422332286835,
-0.6136396527290344,
-0.5532660484313965,
0.15787169337272644,
0.3408884108066559,
0.14085634052753448,
0.035555608570575714,
-0.06619864702224731,
0.8483026623725891,
-0.33692145347595215,
0.28814804553985596,
0.58879154920578,
0.0036078887060284615,
-0.2419891059398651,
0.9686585664749146,
-0.017634715884923935,
0.09615872800350189,
0.24107103049755096,
-0.21074409782886505,
-0.4294993579387665,
-0.7673084735870361,
-0.30384182929992676,
0.2941078245639801,
-0.861911416053772,
-0.5441136360168457,
-0.3271682560443878,
-0.4183981716632843,
-0.24168045818805695,
-0.0440521314740181,
-0.5395755767822266,
-0.17926643788814545,
-0.19618123769760132,
-0.2142043262720108,
0.5788136720657349,
0.906021237373352,
-0.12795180082321167,
0.07113142311573029,
-0.7070629596710205,
-0.09839728474617004,
0.2777990400791168,
0.8782829642295837,
-0.22190354764461517,
-0.48545199632644653,
-0.36596357822418213,
0.047013066709041595,
-0.04719824716448784,
-0.5123273134231567,
0.2814182937145233,
0.15604989230632782,
0.6154829859733582,
0.11485614627599716,
-0.03884963318705559,
0.5928480625152588,
-0.3844541907310486,
0.8069374561309814,
0.0531592033803463,
-0.5375823974609375,
0.7165617346763611,
-0.36212292313575745,
0.002542951377108693,
0.9399051070213318,
0.6305520534515381,
-0.5115864276885986,
-0.5394900441169739,
-0.20992906391620636,
-1.0341923236846924,
0.663219690322876,
0.13206568360328674,
0.43275606632232666,
-0.16522592306137085,
0.37068235874176025,
0.3358648717403412,
0.09470684081315994,
-0.4982229173183441,
-0.4327627122402191,
-0.001439639599993825,
-0.5477647185325623,
0.03589235246181488,
-0.36375924944877625,
-0.28239870071411133,
-0.29329535365104675,
0.7897946238517761,
0.1195075586438179,
-0.18592555820941925,
-0.13621476292610168,
-0.36497244238853455,
-0.027420159429311752,
0.2530129849910736,
0.5030889511108398,
0.7968261241912842,
-0.12306199967861176,
-0.09036193042993546,
0.3985463082790375,
-0.7969422936439514,
0.13811801373958588,
0.06569981575012207,
0.05360656604170799,
-0.39172857999801636,
0.2558653652667999,
0.49857449531555176,
0.03206890448927879,
-1.1349115371704102,
0.34655672311782837,
-0.25966116786003113,
0.25736138224601746,
-0.7710562348365784,
0.12148269265890121,
0.27114391326904297,
0.17636710405349731,
0.20065587759017944,
-0.26591217517852783,
-0.06882785260677338,
-0.3037358522415161,
0.07219768315553665,
0.3407019376754761,
-0.296183705329895,
-0.23760546743869781,
0.86850905418396,
0.4729371666908264,
-0.2559508979320526,
0.7491105794906616,
-0.15237772464752197,
-0.00936891045421362,
0.30264848470687866,
0.4124884307384491,
0.6560083031654358,
-0.5212015509605408,
-0.0644611120223999,
0.6741694808006287,
0.6464515924453735,
0.08101332932710648,
0.5942867994308472,
0.19035392999649048,
-0.374931275844574,
-0.579965353012085,
-0.6312039494514465,
-0.4198223054409027,
0.4002240002155304,
-0.37166476249694824,
0.5725013613700867,
-0.6077062487602234,
0.3093610107898712,
-0.3848559558391571,
0.008116288110613823,
-0.8500690460205078,
0.16510793566703796,
0.1975197196006775,
1.2615503072738647,
-1.1966581344604492,
0.6412663459777832,
0.8066842555999756,
-0.9138204455375671,
-0.8898472785949707,
-0.36463433504104614,
-0.10680842399597168,
-1.0571972131729126,
0.530835747718811,
-0.1349901556968689,
0.030092529952526093,
0.09827279299497604,
-0.7877744436264038,
-0.8750910758972168,
1.0766942501068115,
0.5562288165092468,
-0.5360881090164185,
0.18838801980018616,
0.4716845750808716,
0.46004584431648254,
-0.38593611121177673,
0.3360324800014496,
0.675700306892395,
0.30375218391418457,
-0.21487000584602356,
-0.7430641651153564,
-0.031205134466290474,
-0.5486395955085754,
-0.05349178612232208,
0.08980048447847366,
-0.5884342193603516,
0.6991968154907227,
-0.14494797587394714,
-0.31293049454689026,
-0.13611771166324615,
0.35400399565696716,
0.11742494255304337,
-0.0495726577937603,
0.17001302540302277,
0.6184400320053101,
0.5908783078193665,
0.10293029993772507,
0.9560637474060059,
-0.786011278629303,
-0.06562729924917221,
1.452163815498352,
-0.212372824549675,
0.7523773908615112,
0.5764952301979065,
-0.2692272365093231,
0.29777345061302185,
0.926777720451355,
0.31144607067108154,
0.3223188817501068,
0.19835811853408813,
-0.3604995906352997,
-0.0008024872513487935,
-0.41879191994667053,
-0.38167980313301086,
0.3258691132068634,
0.7383062243461609,
-0.03310519829392433,
-0.3346594572067261,
-0.07640201598405838,
-0.0009755345527082682,
0.3322792053222656,
-0.22321859002113342,
0.6707242727279663,
0.044994987547397614,
-0.5378806591033936,
0.615427553653717,
-0.3407103717327118,
0.8952305316925049,
-0.787128210067749,
-0.0456114299595356,
-0.7255392670631409,
-0.024921434000134468,
-0.5411756634712219,
-1.03328275680542,
0.4775293171405792,
0.11411342769861221,
0.10780074447393417,
-0.13301309943199158,
0.6144651174545288,
-0.8483607769012451,
-0.1900440752506256,
0.11651607602834702,
0.4587431252002716,
0.1762927919626236,
0.2659642696380615,
-0.4484017789363861,
0.1018848568201065,
-0.07134824991226196,
0.045867905020713806,
0.32207733392715454,
0.4243766665458679,
0.0016909143887460232,
0.7287824749946594,
0.4802010953426361,
0.21043382585048676,
0.26486244797706604,
-0.00485590286552906,
0.8032587170600891,
-0.34758463501930237,
-0.17199283838272095,
-0.6822836995124817,
0.7526062726974487,
-0.03238809481263161,
-0.4395803213119507,
0.7509203553199768,
0.9112722873687744,
1.086249589920044,
-0.23298248648643494,
0.9135205149650574,
-0.006395368371158838,
0.619814395904541,
-0.34149622917175293,
0.794845461845398,
-0.41153469681739807,
0.2997439205646515,
0.291607141494751,
-0.8817879557609558,
-0.26582881808280945,
0.20974647998809814,
0.08439067751169205,
-0.11097054928541183,
0.39918163418769836,
1.0567107200622559,
-0.20537607371807098,
-0.18067312240600586,
-0.1275055706501007,
0.24567073583602905,
0.19890904426574707,
0.40275126695632935,
0.8372931480407715,
-0.20530691742897034,
0.6229866743087769,
-0.2527002990245819,
-0.16441017389297485,
0.0279508326202631,
-0.8502955436706543,
-0.8544072508811951,
-0.7887746095657349,
-0.2682128846645355,
-0.14214082062244415,
0.047820813953876495,
1.2942755222320557,
0.6707419753074646,
-0.9178321957588196,
-0.34091803431510925,
-0.11885838210582733,
-0.010689875110983849,
0.34482839703559875,
-0.16530923545360565,
0.12528134882450104,
-0.8322717547416687,
-0.6363658905029297,
0.33763211965560913,
0.5092483758926392,
0.08406016230583191,
-0.41778966784477234,
-0.20157606899738312,
-0.2964082658290863,
0.17080636322498322,
0.7320940494537354,
0.7332642674446106,
-0.31536972522735596,
0.2335275411605835,
-0.11328007280826569,
-0.2115624099969864,
-0.023998189717531204,
0.7411739826202393,
-0.5092254877090454,
0.45352301001548767,
0.273240327835083,
0.7585919499397278,
0.1948564499616623,
-0.4387374222278595,
0.36427804827690125,
-0.97788405418396,
0.5322047472000122,
0.41199591755867004,
0.18202009797096252,
0.6079837083816528,
-0.3649384379386902,
0.8432053923606873,
-0.21522226929664612,
-0.4254280924797058,
-0.991717517375946,
0.12569363415241241,
-0.5522989630699158,
-0.08562837541103363,
1.1162272691726685,
0.20186465978622437,
-0.11463991552591324,
-0.12169848382472992,
-0.20051270723342896,
0.32350069284439087,
-0.12064904719591141,
0.840258777141571,
0.4958116114139557,
-0.08016953617334366,
-0.014998948201537132,
-0.652754008769989,
0.8164607882499695,
0.2323870062828064,
-1.1764452457427979,
0.2503981292247772,
0.24151475727558136,
0.5748428702354431,
-0.12066052854061127,
0.8719289302825928,
-0.38179320096969604,
0.06283930689096451,
-0.10932514071464539,
0.3873046040534973,
-0.06616675853729248,
-0.13498824834823608,
-0.21098411083221436,
-0.4128536283969879,
0.47020500898361206,
-0.22954298555850983
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06326v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06326v1
|
From Instructions to Constraints: Language Model Alignment with Automatic Constraint Verification
| 2024-03-10T22:14:54 | 2024-03-10T22:14:54 |
Fei Wang, Chao Shang, Sarthak Jain, Shuai Wang, Qiang Ning, Bonan Min, Vittorio Castelli, Yassine Benajiba, Dan Roth
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
User alignment is crucial for adapting general-purpose language models (LMs)
to downstream tasks, but human annotations are often not available for all
types of instructions, especially those with customized constraints. We observe
that user instructions typically contain constraints. While assessing response
quality in terms of the whole instruction is often costly, efficiently
evaluating the satisfaction rate of constraints is feasible. We investigate
common constraints in NLP tasks, categorize them into three classes based on
the types of their arguments, and propose a unified framework, ACT (Aligning to
ConsTraints), to automatically produce supervision signals for user alignment
with constraints. Specifically, ACT uses constraint verifiers, which are
typically easy to implement in practice, to compute constraint satisfaction
rate (CSR) of each response. It samples multiple responses for each prompt and
collect preference labels based on their CSR automatically. Subsequently, ACT
adapts the LM to the target task through a ranking-based learning process.
Experiments on fine-grained entity typing, abstractive summarization, and
temporal question answering show that ACT is able to enhance LMs' capability to
adhere to different classes of constraints, thereby improving task performance.
Further experiments show that the constraint-following capabilities are
transferable.
|
[
-0.05004106089472771,
-0.39945289492607117,
0.5545101165771484,
0.22277455031871796,
0.178399458527565,
-0.12384526431560516,
-0.24252595007419586,
-0.38069218397140503,
-0.02603544294834137,
0.8814783096313477,
-0.5874753594398499,
-0.4552725851535797,
-0.5021945238113403,
0.2862110435962677,
-0.39616507291793823,
0.9247751235961914,
-0.32636046409606934,
-0.27092206478118896,
-0.48102110624313354,
-0.08189303427934647,
-0.8405938148498535,
-0.6193204522132874,
-0.2213459461927414,
-0.26927220821380615,
0.16042199730873108,
0.39688795804977417,
0.8721435070037842,
0.9524251222610474,
0.6748448610305786,
0.41980722546577454,
0.22119736671447754,
0.400296688079834,
-0.11402955651283264,
-0.05489831790328026,
-0.4225366711616516,
-0.40139463543891907,
-0.29157957434654236,
-0.16777002811431885,
0.3858405351638794,
0.7346028685569763,
-0.2419201135635376,
0.18981000781059265,
0.3645399212837219,
0.3304232954978943,
-0.7186611294746399,
0.08087819069623947,
-0.4083961844444275,
-0.1505831629037857,
0.03714534267783165,
-0.14702442288398743,
-0.4928101599216461,
-0.35741594433784485,
0.14329153299331665,
-0.6031957864761353,
0.024921616539359093,
0.187234029173851,
1.1031924486160278,
0.8250584006309509,
-0.5198395848274231,
-0.5242727994918823,
-0.8789324164390564,
0.637531578540802,
-0.6419228911399841,
0.2346426397562027,
0.323569118976593,
0.11414344608783722,
-0.3382537066936493,
-0.5594801902770996,
-0.45620042085647583,
-0.26030492782592773,
-0.5508938431739807,
-0.24277469515800476,
-0.0007353572291322052,
0.32084551453590393,
0.40747278928756714,
0.2168489396572113,
-0.5999437570571899,
0.09827473014593124,
-0.15305469930171967,
-0.3881934881210327,
0.6087899208068848,
0.2048356831073761,
0.6358627080917358,
-0.2660987079143524,
-0.35834047198295593,
-0.006533640902489424,
-0.451078861951828,
0.2960047423839569,
0.36145076155662537,
0.4516027867794037,
0.022686878219246864,
0.7310228943824768,
-0.23802673816680908,
1.1178882122039795,
0.17963626980781555,
0.04252789914608002,
0.016556518152356148,
-0.2819660007953644,
-0.16005277633666992,
-0.042562924325466156,
0.7913540005683899,
0.20800046622753143,
0.03147168084979057,
-0.13654661178588867,
-0.3252623379230499,
-0.022238394245505333,
0.6549188494682312,
-0.3526052236557007,
0.005455671809613705,
0.07494311779737473,
-0.1555546522140503,
0.13550551235675812,
0.06848294287919998,
-0.21483075618743896,
-0.33709263801574707,
-0.7643312811851501,
0.6220006346702576,
-0.22052186727523804,
0.1844286173582077,
0.23806753754615784,
0.30256712436676025,
0.2532082498073578,
0.380790114402771,
-1.1845370531082153,
0.5910297632217407,
0.982674241065979,
0.46249470114707947,
-0.2975027859210968,
-0.3206588923931122,
-0.743652880191803,
0.23786680400371552,
-0.09615612775087357,
0.5837224721908569,
-0.3997615873813629,
-0.03377501666545868,
0.07835400104522705,
0.05073227733373642,
-0.40692734718322754,
-0.29009971022605896,
0.7544066905975342,
-0.3472693860530853,
0.32004961371421814,
-0.3135903477668762,
-0.7986999154090881,
-0.09240630269050598,
0.11774349957704544,
-0.4746055006980896,
0.9343463182449341,
0.2670818567276001,
-0.45491257309913635,
0.20360414683818817,
-0.7136077284812927,
-0.602118968963623,
-0.025386661291122437,
-0.2366911619901657,
-0.03157469257712364,
0.07394734025001526,
0.3101096451282501,
0.23945333063602448,
-0.23049382865428925,
0.22172214090824127,
-0.09801964461803436,
-0.30306610465049744,
0.2789832353591919,
0.05334334075450897,
0.835640549659729,
0.14621195197105408,
-0.31684908270835876,
0.3053918778896332,
-0.6667579412460327,
0.11180202662944794,
-0.24492543935775757,
-0.3759849965572357,
-0.32012397050857544,
0.2670113444328308,
-0.25450772047042847,
0.1322634071111679,
0.23440082371234894,
-0.2791081964969635,
0.4317546784877777,
-0.3308032751083374,
0.4976455569267273,
0.48853304982185364,
-0.003021715674549341,
0.42213746905326843,
-0.03020394779741764,
0.3995175063610077,
-0.4286401569843292,
0.31220346689224243,
0.10321130603551865,
-0.2953481376171112,
-0.7813006043434143,
0.016844963654875755,
0.29442715644836426,
0.8672294020652771,
-0.31255534291267395,
0.836660623550415,
-0.2831280529499054,
0.0037022000178694725,
-0.6184486150741577,
0.44092312455177307,
0.577027440071106,
0.6254720091819763,
0.4653194844722748,
-0.49548810720443726,
-0.6380971074104309,
-0.8891088962554932,
-0.26028716564178467,
-0.5107815861701965,
-0.25829166173934937,
0.1988622397184372,
0.3956422507762909,
-0.051420070230960846,
1.0417518615722656,
-0.5241194367408752,
-0.4356785714626312,
-0.09587258845567703,
0.32918858528137207,
0.019861340522766113,
0.6126545667648315,
0.14653030037879944,
-0.6864913702011108,
-0.3410423994064331,
-0.14144863188266754,
-0.5518221855163574,
-0.6428470015525818,
-0.34280329942703247,
-0.07860932499170303,
0.16426420211791992,
0.5623119473457336,
-0.3917897045612335,
0.3683255910873413,
0.5497452020645142,
-0.36350059509277344,
0.3156585991382599,
-0.12171194702386856,
0.13803943991661072,
-0.86124587059021,
0.08869916945695877,
-0.08103182911872864,
-0.3793642222881317,
-0.6137424111366272,
0.13874679803848267,
0.0944124087691307,
-0.07812309265136719,
-0.09755176305770874,
0.3691293001174927,
-0.5345777273178101,
-0.01749069057404995,
-0.34546083211898804,
0.057379186153411865,
0.09215150773525238,
0.6169188022613525,
0.14555799961090088,
0.6329154968261719,
0.2654017508029938,
-0.5971624255180359,
0.1936134397983551,
0.4425177276134491,
-0.3576171100139618,
0.556278645992279,
-0.6655087471008301,
0.2982753813266754,
0.13236938416957855,
0.0075447349809110165,
-0.9537692070007324,
-0.33439305424690247,
0.36379092931747437,
-0.18810738623142242,
0.3384612798690796,
-0.3418000638484955,
-0.3210032284259796,
-0.302876740694046,
0.18555498123168945,
0.012876425869762897,
0.33577749133110046,
-0.31089913845062256,
0.9912658333778381,
0.2684846818447113,
0.09984656423330307,
-0.8780982494354248,
-0.5652243494987488,
0.16049599647521973,
-0.003941119648516178,
-0.4520815312862396,
0.539546012878418,
-0.010242480784654617,
-0.048116449266672134,
0.28561699390411377,
-0.2238587737083435,
-0.12374548614025116,
0.30572709441185,
0.4993951618671417,
0.1719309687614441,
-0.04231743514537811,
-0.11645311862230301,
-0.04388273507356644,
0.03478005900979042,
0.04036273434758186,
-0.3327028453350067,
0.22560317814350128,
-0.07566910982131958,
-0.7173841595649719,
-0.7440347075462341,
0.23222336173057556,
0.37838661670684814,
-0.2943742871284485,
0.3801521062850952,
0.3889094889163971,
-0.27898839116096497,
-0.14147400856018066,
-0.5575242042541504,
-0.07457316666841507,
-0.48647210001945496,
0.3011550009250641,
-0.3399769961833954,
-0.9445193409919739,
0.27140694856643677,
0.08191832900047302,
0.36496132612228394,
0.2160126119852066,
0.3769265413284302,
0.032441671937704086,
1.1602462530136108,
0.770320475101471,
-0.16285528242588043,
0.2704818546772003,
0.31152501702308655,
0.2165200114250183,
-0.7779316306114197,
-0.02800804376602173,
-0.729771614074707,
-0.4217938482761383,
-0.2849746644496918,
-0.21697507798671722,
-0.02076556161046028,
0.3916192948818207,
-0.021729810163378716,
0.8799713253974915,
-0.7884150743484497,
0.49826422333717346,
0.5518676042556763,
-0.17775487899780273,
0.07725071907043457,
-0.41860103607177734,
0.006085309199988842,
-0.009380259551107883,
-0.3167729079723358,
-0.6185142397880554,
0.7834256291389465,
0.17551171779632568,
0.689125120639801,
0.3251922130584717,
0.8047289848327637,
0.35090404748916626,
0.4723758101463318,
-0.6443504095077515,
0.6158767938613892,
-0.2050684541463852,
-0.6922072172164917,
-0.37209588289260864,
-0.3704533576965332,
-0.6392771005630493,
-0.08974114805459976,
-0.2220831662416458,
-1.1325563192367554,
0.07418050616979599,
0.5810110569000244,
-0.5916314721107483,
-0.13498671352863312,
-0.7900556325912476,
0.9974865317344666,
-0.5075321197509766,
-0.2258417159318924,
0.1329440176486969,
-0.820967435836792,
0.22512365877628326,
0.19493801891803741,
-0.035970717668533325,
-0.20433300733566284,
-0.09474840760231018,
0.5353202819824219,
-0.5743781328201294,
0.9860930442810059,
-0.279053270816803,
-0.1866014301776886,
0.2478940784931183,
-0.00525274220854044,
0.5461910963058472,
-0.21745368838310242,
0.10122419148683548,
-0.3691306412220001,
0.04645133763551712,
-0.05254363268613815,
-0.9296447038650513,
0.4560096263885498,
-0.6258621215820312,
-0.9170592427253723,
-0.10011348873376846,
-0.7244269847869873,
-0.30227938294410706,
0.1792616844177246,
0.07174740731716156,
0.29570451378822327,
-0.12893669307231903,
0.03195986896753311,
0.5211473703384399,
0.0576339028775692,
0.19614169001579285,
0.47589099407196045,
-0.2463388442993164,
-0.2848135530948639,
0.7225267887115479,
-0.045470304787158966,
0.2629930078983307,
0.7205376625061035,
0.06981047987937927,
-0.4538528621196747,
-0.6212188601493835,
-0.5025821328163147,
-0.03948568180203438,
-0.6845573782920837,
-0.19131073355674744,
-0.5760936737060547,
-0.12098361551761627,
-0.47956886887550354,
-0.22962161898612976,
-0.2560807168483734,
-0.5633673667907715,
-0.2574461102485657,
0.09349102526903152,
0.01288803294301033,
0.4772721230983734,
0.07749424129724503,
0.3971821665763855,
-0.6938271522521973,
0.21106427907943726,
0.48894840478897095,
0.24377624690532684,
-0.3515000343322754,
-0.6932538151741028,
-0.10742944478988647,
-0.28120195865631104,
-0.32436785101890564,
-0.7987541556358337,
-0.03422931954264641,
0.328977108001709,
0.4816347658634186,
0.33522167801856995,
0.2350015789270401,
0.587390124797821,
-0.48082447052001953,
0.7775112390518188,
-0.012696295976638794,
-1.1809743642807007,
0.40498101711273193,
0.11318260431289673,
0.18439018726348877,
0.6790508031845093,
0.25393104553222656,
-0.6403746604919434,
-0.5294895768165588,
-0.1987375169992447,
-0.6757515668869019,
0.7290650606155396,
0.1080588549375534,
0.19591102004051208,
0.2765059173107147,
0.6745076179504395,
-0.203838512301445,
-0.024834437295794487,
-0.8046391010284424,
-0.16151440143585205,
-0.014112677425146103,
-0.6138761043548584,
0.09935420006513596,
-0.22063422203063965,
-0.3874048590660095,
-0.03696945682168007,
0.5911316275596619,
-0.3031214773654938,
-0.08270017057657242,
0.151212677359581,
-0.3832501471042633,
-0.034817736595869064,
0.4806470572948456,
0.7393291592597961,
0.6070895195007324,
-0.11529133468866348,
0.10984895378351212,
0.08080838620662689,
-0.14331284165382385,
0.3666801452636719,
0.3280664384365082,
-0.4301653206348419,
-0.19034674763679504,
0.4345106780529022,
0.9576518535614014,
0.2654740512371063,
-0.39387091994285583,
0.5266345143318176,
-0.10842619836330414,
-0.12987668812274933,
0.07401195168495178,
0.5773922801017761,
0.03388288989663124,
0.04468007758259773,
0.10676486045122147,
-0.010923182591795921,
0.15989547967910767,
-0.2238096445798874,
0.23600633442401886,
0.30243584513664246,
-0.5509985089302063,
-0.4028441607952118,
0.84115070104599,
0.2963672876358032,
-0.4947023093700409,
0.4497920274734497,
-0.1731940656900406,
-0.538022518157959,
0.24060098826885223,
0.5823920369148254,
0.9427776336669922,
-0.38922837376594543,
0.16469474136829376,
0.36404865980148315,
0.44726863503456116,
-0.2780439555644989,
0.3572251498699188,
-0.10254344344139099,
-0.680690348148346,
-0.8134520649909973,
-0.5471673607826233,
-0.5614804029464722,
-0.05652254819869995,
-0.8053802847862244,
0.28781428933143616,
-0.4627588987350464,
-0.17008979618549347,
0.24564407765865326,
-0.23007696866989136,
-0.47567224502563477,
0.14118772745132446,
0.23274435102939606,
0.6526497602462769,
-0.8846157193183899,
0.6428501009941101,
0.7958502769470215,
-0.41366684436798096,
-1.0127527713775635,
-0.024493921548128128,
0.45006266236305237,
-0.7500726580619812,
0.5582727789878845,
0.22969579696655273,
-0.1646081954240799,
-0.0626460537314415,
-0.5415104031562805,
-0.8695424795150757,
0.5787632465362549,
0.5534504652023315,
-0.5408489108085632,
-0.24146287143230438,
0.43023622035980225,
0.5455108284950256,
-0.39640480279922485,
-0.07635702192783356,
0.5172696113586426,
0.48181405663490295,
-0.17811036109924316,
-0.8853517770767212,
0.2236153483390808,
-0.07244457304477692,
-0.04181539639830589,
0.44553330540657043,
-0.15214580297470093,
0.3552900552749634,
-0.1850685477256775,
-0.33846768736839294,
0.047091320157051086,
0.8513559103012085,
-0.10346987843513489,
-0.04348072409629822,
0.8549609184265137,
0.6618494391441345,
0.6874167323112488,
-0.15225256979465485,
0.7973612546920776,
-0.35655832290649414,
0.17900164425373077,
1.4502885341644287,
-0.4992526173591614,
0.737973153591156,
0.5545943975448608,
-0.04516424611210823,
0.6119881868362427,
0.37054896354675293,
-0.05252121388912201,
0.2823899984359741,
0.45247936248779297,
0.050420667976140976,
-0.2639229893684387,
-0.2968071401119232,
0.08756016194820404,
0.5096130967140198,
0.3034004271030426,
-0.16658195853233337,
0.0038870531134307384,
-0.17997823655605316,
-0.12026642262935638,
0.44779732823371887,
-0.0959475189447403,
0.8923105001449585,
-0.06397481262683868,
-1.167686104774475,
0.5202817916870117,
-0.03466523438692093,
0.28660881519317627,
-0.6854951977729797,
-0.05799935758113861,
0.0872025340795517,
0.1258961260318756,
-0.36592644453048706,
-0.7944608330726624,
0.3651735782623291,
0.05507366731762886,
-0.23904787003993988,
-0.31248268485069275,
0.5806511044502258,
-0.5562682747840881,
-0.14647948741912842,
0.12469765543937683,
0.06303910911083221,
-0.05173160135746002,
0.24754802882671356,
-0.7497925162315369,
0.07114872336387634,
0.1560209095478058,
-0.1704024076461792,
0.16034947335720062,
0.23832350969314575,
-0.14358612895011902,
0.6351334452629089,
0.27847567200660706,
0.06604427844285965,
-0.029178157448768616,
0.12400306016206741,
0.47261080145835876,
-0.3443697988986969,
-0.2993801534175873,
-0.645540177822113,
0.5721717476844788,
-0.1386791169643402,
-0.3602018654346466,
0.49441036581993103,
0.3190912902355194,
0.9143326878547668,
0.09659299999475479,
0.6256962418556213,
-0.3035910129547119,
0.4670346677303314,
-0.654790997505188,
0.2794411778450012,
-0.4817826449871063,
0.35182830691337585,
-0.14035667479038239,
-0.8480598330497742,
-0.6089965105056763,
0.3153235614299774,
-0.3525736927986145,
-0.27888181805610657,
0.635921061038971,
0.8752684593200684,
-0.14031454920768738,
-0.15849800407886505,
-0.05246295407414436,
-0.3296504020690918,
0.394257128238678,
0.6293805241584778,
0.7602375149726868,
-0.1080426275730133,
0.7261689305305481,
-0.39039433002471924,
-0.12023025751113892,
-0.25457432866096497,
-1.0481631755828857,
-0.6517534852027893,
-0.6757914423942566,
-0.6112228035926819,
-0.30424779653549194,
-0.104607954621315,
1.2475495338439941,
0.7115392684936523,
-1.0595684051513672,
-0.42639458179473877,
-0.027141420170664787,
0.0943736806511879,
-0.6328878998756409,
-0.16714581847190857,
0.561907947063446,
-0.6520044207572937,
-0.6524356603622437,
0.3271440863609314,
0.2606115937232971,
-0.04559078440070152,
0.0037485677748918533,
-0.25930315256118774,
-0.17512445151805878,
0.05429844558238983,
0.10346484184265137,
0.7497280836105347,
-0.8987258672714233,
-0.6592512130737305,
-0.037681397050619125,
-0.497010737657547,
0.0017094466602429748,
1.040703535079956,
-0.23458081483840942,
0.37101849913597107,
0.4130692481994629,
1.0426875352859497,
-0.09041465818881989,
0.35059666633605957,
0.7506787180900574,
-1.0249104499816895,
-0.22708605229854584,
0.1362898051738739,
0.33391115069389343,
0.3928879201412201,
-0.32012420892715454,
0.518142580986023,
-0.21576924622058868,
-0.7599585056304932,
-0.9372467398643494,
0.39896807074546814,
-0.9861633777618408,
-0.07820796966552734,
0.9953896403312683,
-0.33949822187423706,
-0.24121999740600586,
-0.2202327400445938,
-0.24875394999980927,
0.203095480799675,
-0.19590312242507935,
0.8447577357292175,
0.6769275665283203,
-0.30027973651885986,
-0.11048905551433563,
-0.34347259998321533,
0.7906395792961121,
0.6771804094314575,
-0.8586550354957581,
0.4150601327419281,
0.6082338690757751,
0.15662357211112976,
0.4768148958683014,
0.3466311991214752,
0.1388748586177826,
0.23233789205551147,
-0.589540421962738,
0.30708298087120056,
-0.1215783879160881,
-0.25243711471557617,
-0.27282607555389404,
0.18247060477733612,
0.2530800700187683,
-0.16240568459033966
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06301v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06301v1
|
LIEDER: Linguistically-Informed Evaluation for Discourse Entity Recognition
| 2024-03-10T20:20:16 | 2024-03-10T20:20:16 |
Xiaomeng Zhu, Robert Frank
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Discourse Entity (DE) recognition is the task of identifying novel and known
entities introduced within a text. While previous work has found that large
language models have basic, if imperfect, DE recognition abilities (Schuster
and Linzen, 2022), it remains largely unassessed which of the fundamental
semantic properties that govern the introduction and subsequent reference to
DEs they have knowledge of. We propose the Linguistically-Informed Evaluation
for Discourse Entity Recognition (LIEDER) dataset that allows for a detailed
examination of language models' knowledge of four crucial semantic properties:
existence, uniqueness, plurality, and novelty. We find evidence that
state-of-the-art large language models exhibit sensitivity to all of these
properties except novelty, which demonstrates that they have yet to reach
human-level language understanding abilities.
|
[
-0.3879517912864685,
-0.6206154823303223,
0.9100227952003479,
0.031895652413368225,
-0.2708296775817871,
0.2970618009567261,
-0.15257182717323303,
-0.4808567762374878,
0.02489868924021721,
0.6677113175392151,
-0.28686627745628357,
-0.47956207394599915,
-0.7837392091751099,
0.10786468535661697,
-0.6187394857406616,
1.0814893245697021,
0.20088468492031097,
-0.05719977617263794,
-0.16242170333862305,
-0.2298031598329544,
-0.28207927942276,
-0.1986200213432312,
-0.11128450930118561,
-0.34789714217185974,
0.2518273591995239,
-0.003204100299626589,
0.6071553230285645,
0.4780341386795044,
0.5145701169967651,
0.43031272292137146,
-0.2840687334537506,
-0.19904856383800507,
-0.5679018497467041,
0.044244199991226196,
-0.5927541851997375,
-0.529251217842102,
-0.15164096653461456,
-0.05415983870625496,
1.0585752725601196,
1.0390130281448364,
0.2531266510486603,
0.162751242518425,
-0.033186811953783035,
0.31745028495788574,
-0.615720808506012,
0.1510583907365799,
-1.0694584846496582,
-0.17178556323051453,
-0.2287605106830597,
0.16193288564682007,
-0.6822091341018677,
-0.3923821449279785,
0.6994944214820862,
-0.49709439277648926,
0.3303285241127014,
-0.00281965802423656,
1.1028497219085693,
0.36009475588798523,
-0.8961736559867859,
-0.43419069051742554,
-0.8954553604125977,
0.6715335845947266,
-0.5084820985794067,
0.616639256477356,
0.1135195791721344,
0.15158872306346893,
-0.17532265186309814,
-0.7204725742340088,
-0.673672080039978,
-0.2609461545944214,
-0.3502446413040161,
0.04902726784348488,
-0.3608757555484772,
0.14529481530189514,
0.3150157332420349,
0.44539356231689453,
-0.4278213381767273,
0.25797784328460693,
-0.21157197654247284,
-0.32635873556137085,
0.39925578236579895,
0.07991896569728851,
0.3708140552043915,
-0.48197808861732483,
-0.5300870537757874,
0.38528111577033997,
-0.45537132024765015,
0.11093569546937943,
0.36732280254364014,
-0.14994080364704132,
-0.03907611966133118,
0.48286575078964233,
0.08415084332227707,
0.6583422422409058,
-0.022672191262245178,
-0.3909739553928375,
0.3806665241718292,
-0.05775255337357521,
-0.020619669929146767,
0.06953722983598709,
0.746553897857666,
-0.09206267446279526,
0.0941184014081955,
-0.3107828199863434,
-0.3204129636287689,
0.2079520970582962,
0.2309456765651703,
-0.5844505429267883,
-0.29973822832107544,
0.12293863296508789,
-0.48658230900764465,
-0.2399139255285263,
0.27609866857528687,
-0.5727657079696655,
-0.4782421588897705,
-0.45465216040611267,
0.15154366195201874,
-0.6476265788078308,
-0.4232428967952728,
0.07125314325094223,
-0.21961107850074768,
0.5419028997421265,
0.3646020293235779,
-0.6921934485435486,
0.6238151788711548,
0.9127203226089478,
0.38986483216285706,
-0.5226336121559143,
-0.29995962977409363,
-0.32957908511161804,
-0.0019451786065474153,
-0.1577731817960739,
1.0745611190795898,
-0.8368539214134216,
-0.26029956340789795,
-0.1642693132162094,
0.1756972223520279,
-0.1302180141210556,
-0.34968674182891846,
0.7969205975532532,
-0.8010034561157227,
0.1651581972837448,
-0.29728636145591736,
-0.8721466064453125,
-0.43327420949935913,
-0.006948342081159353,
-0.8940527439117432,
0.6845477819442749,
0.29825490713119507,
-0.9663552641868591,
0.5922432541847229,
-0.4823255240917206,
-0.3348337411880493,
0.3348444104194641,
-0.18614092469215393,
-0.24357187747955322,
0.4945024847984314,
-0.046370480209589005,
0.17537742853164673,
-0.3949081003665924,
0.5839930772781372,
-0.04361036792397499,
-0.2147437036037445,
0.6427283883094788,
-0.685147762298584,
0.8554940819740295,
-0.02993553876876831,
-0.12607932090759277,
-0.11395144462585449,
-1.2675302028656006,
-0.0010514711029827595,
-0.00391919631510973,
-0.39068400859832764,
-0.6712038516998291,
-0.245749369263649,
-0.05395058915019035,
0.10068054497241974,
0.30407869815826416,
-0.6065880656242371,
-0.08422032743692398,
-0.8823939561843872,
0.2685720920562744,
0.6604525446891785,
0.3818748891353607,
0.5409128665924072,
0.16627830266952515,
0.516273558139801,
0.20118120312690735,
-0.45136481523513794,
-0.24097484350204468,
-0.37824809551239014,
-0.9943192601203918,
-0.28867149353027344,
1.0004971027374268,
0.5587393045425415,
-0.5781139135360718,
0.6010957360267639,
-0.557307243347168,
-0.41205161809921265,
-0.5658367276191711,
-0.22441495954990387,
0.5633761882781982,
0.3335953950881958,
-0.04714734107255936,
-0.4122241735458374,
-0.6474063396453857,
-1.157185435295105,
-0.26397982239723206,
-0.21564461290836334,
-0.08424989879131317,
0.31645432114601135,
0.8892238140106201,
-0.12522508203983307,
1.0999256372451782,
-0.6922711133956909,
0.2911039888858795,
-0.01461812388151884,
0.3106769323348999,
0.09881596267223358,
0.052256468683481216,
0.6087137460708618,
-0.811576783657074,
-0.21207918226718903,
0.08388686180114746,
-0.8724079728126526,
-0.053311292082071304,
-0.007914993911981583,
0.06472749263048172,
0.04812020808458328,
0.0727800503373146,
-0.5034066438674927,
0.35241883993148804,
0.4371248781681061,
-0.3025042712688446,
0.3379291296005249,
-0.14302781224250793,
0.058809295296669006,
-0.8497812747955322,
0.031993817538022995,
-0.1203920990228653,
-0.21146917343139648,
-0.8394020199775696,
-0.24521447718143463,
0.10800083726644516,
-0.07575403153896332,
-0.49302157759666443,
0.7439948916435242,
-0.5499749779701233,
-0.31227532029151917,
-0.23497961461544037,
0.2936941087245941,
0.23656119406223297,
0.3916964530944824,
0.18017899990081787,
0.5120275616645813,
0.5355251431465149,
-0.6357443928718567,
0.20109696686267853,
0.3767988085746765,
-0.5416530966758728,
0.9700815677642822,
-0.5880611538887024,
0.404178649187088,
-0.27654796838760376,
-0.05743931978940964,
-0.9737251400947571,
-0.31855952739715576,
0.14283086359500885,
-0.2822977304458618,
0.28520461916923523,
-0.20502279698848724,
-0.08522617071866989,
-0.34623000025749207,
0.21366560459136963,
0.4696018397808075,
0.19716452062129974,
-0.3640071749687195,
0.8996054530143738,
0.8288085460662842,
-0.0485125295817852,
-0.5448346734046936,
-0.3812939524650574,
0.1410476565361023,
-0.1647731363773346,
-0.4577503204345703,
0.3902657926082611,
0.2473565936088562,
-0.3392816483974457,
0.1260787844657898,
-0.13304737210273743,
-0.4351089596748352,
0.1531611829996109,
0.304974228143692,
0.3013351559638977,
-0.2719534635543823,
0.2829785943031311,
0.18158318102359772,
-0.3567580580711365,
0.1943039447069168,
-0.4149620532989502,
0.28315603733062744,
-0.2848720848560333,
-0.37965795397758484,
-0.4035031497478485,
0.11537590622901917,
0.4211893677711487,
-0.325970321893692,
0.5327377915382385,
0.40788304805755615,
-0.6280423402786255,
-0.02559182234108448,
-0.5995706915855408,
0.008745405822992325,
-0.391145795583725,
0.3177982270717621,
-0.697043240070343,
-0.8586339950561523,
0.5008375644683838,
-0.25935548543930054,
-0.17081594467163086,
0.6798985600471497,
0.3555152416229248,
0.0031827192287892103,
0.4755730926990509,
0.5414544939994812,
-0.006071887910366058,
-0.12096422910690308,
0.07246167212724686,
0.42272838950157166,
-0.7179471850395203,
-0.21148864924907684,
-0.7504071593284607,
-0.1609991490840912,
-0.9041394591331482,
-0.013143517076969147,
0.1890663355588913,
-0.36110377311706543,
0.041269466280937195,
0.3442303538322449,
-0.34386947751045227,
0.555996835231781,
0.2561458647251129,
0.02025136724114418,
0.4660749137401581,
-0.3679932951927185,
-0.12802371382713318,
-0.4481290280818939,
-0.23958119750022888,
-0.8725600242614746,
0.799923300743103,
0.4627441167831421,
0.5695842504501343,
0.013867422007024288,
0.6757362484931946,
0.16007526218891144,
0.02824457176029682,
-0.9094080328941345,
0.7921447157859802,
-0.05942900478839874,
-0.48998627066612244,
-0.19822673499584198,
-0.47908228635787964,
-1.1798585653305054,
0.28035011887550354,
-0.3403831124305725,
-0.9643039703369141,
0.34924280643463135,
-0.055052563548088074,
-0.23418274521827698,
0.04119410738348961,
-0.5286562442779541,
0.6560173034667969,
-0.2975715696811676,
0.22111158072948456,
0.06551190465688705,
-0.6194219589233398,
0.5211588144302368,
-0.3638443350791931,
0.25597521662712097,
-0.21000969409942627,
-0.1554408222436905,
0.8153998851776123,
0.0761873722076416,
0.6451184153556824,
-0.11490140855312347,
-0.3279234766960144,
0.2724844515323639,
0.29277563095092773,
0.38639065623283386,
0.05477924644947052,
0.004950477741658688,
0.0368293821811676,
-0.022464057430624962,
0.11836300790309906,
-0.7866240739822388,
0.6006558537483215,
-0.6094556450843811,
-0.5110726952552795,
-0.46911779046058655,
-0.4261091351509094,
-0.1354759782552719,
0.5798106789588928,
0.09400500357151031,
0.3366384208202362,
-0.8817147612571716,
0.04675797373056412,
0.8463096022605896,
-0.22760170698165894,
0.14274191856384277,
0.7249312996864319,
-0.21975956857204437,
-0.2603727877140045,
0.9739709496498108,
0.15785183012485504,
0.004659208934754133,
0.4238590896129608,
0.031069865450263023,
-0.30932149291038513,
-0.5249634981155396,
-0.24730490148067474,
0.3657730519771576,
-0.8452139496803284,
0.001358707551844418,
-1.0464911460876465,
-0.3633536994457245,
-0.006854203529655933,
0.2256632298231125,
-0.3430394232273102,
-0.6263386607170105,
-0.24632328748703003,
-0.22693243622779846,
0.1368458867073059,
1.0893474817276,
0.29820799827575684,
0.25442013144493103,
-0.6257112622261047,
0.42358747124671936,
0.2531079351902008,
0.29518434405326843,
-0.3374519348144531,
-0.7736377120018005,
0.1936359703540802,
-0.11612735688686371,
-0.22903652489185333,
-1.0761512517929077,
0.03717106580734253,
0.3151623010635376,
0.6490494608879089,
0.5148329734802246,
-0.012795131653547287,
0.019412478432059288,
-0.5941075086593628,
0.6663383841514587,
-0.019920451566576958,
-1.286275029182434,
0.6226997375488281,
-0.15322160720825195,
0.2647482454776764,
0.5534461140632629,
0.5452980399131775,
-0.24048884212970734,
-0.33666130900382996,
-0.8411560654640198,
-0.5463408827781677,
0.6063264012336731,
0.38926568627357483,
0.3307366967201233,
0.0032668958883732557,
0.2497871071100235,
0.2489231377840042,
0.4651082158088684,
-0.8501455783843994,
-0.1955193132162094,
0.015690548345446587,
-0.015545791015028954,
0.4026503264904022,
-0.46542057394981384,
-0.030711213126778603,
-0.13344940543174744,
0.49759796261787415,
-0.005163777153939009,
0.2505449652671814,
-0.3738689124584198,
-0.3397466540336609,
0.24203574657440186,
0.6328859329223633,
0.2644995450973511,
0.8570079207420349,
0.06603112816810608,
0.4073379635810852,
0.5055441856384277,
-0.48086825013160706,
0.5264335870742798,
0.11488808691501617,
-0.35700279474258423,
0.20982563495635986,
0.3184632956981659,
0.9697105884552002,
0.7060447931289673,
-0.40647071599960327,
0.6501324772834778,
-0.08628293126821518,
-0.07851890474557877,
-0.35820841789245605,
0.10657773911952972,
0.00313940760679543,
-0.058197420090436935,
0.12738433480262756,
0.15116740763187408,
0.5155867338180542,
-0.3567298352718353,
0.3488687574863434,
0.41183799505233765,
-0.41812723875045776,
-0.550987184047699,
0.20314307510852814,
-0.017926929518580437,
-0.3279222249984741,
0.5451696515083313,
-0.5113210678100586,
-0.7501019835472107,
0.3199474513530731,
0.5673708319664001,
0.736979067325592,
-0.5929945111274719,
0.3891986906528473,
0.38841530680656433,
0.2667933404445648,
0.23260432481765747,
0.06878350675106049,
0.2769891917705536,
-1.0152755975723267,
-0.09818097203969955,
-0.6840143203735352,
-0.2795538604259491,
0.12171541154384613,
-0.6410565972328186,
0.5153059959411621,
-0.27399787306785583,
-0.19734665751457214,
0.631687343120575,
-0.2629714012145996,
-0.9030815362930298,
0.3652970492839813,
-0.06146365776658058,
0.5522919297218323,
-0.8042852282524109,
0.5751569271087646,
0.4789187014102936,
-0.22513465583324432,
-0.5965589284896851,
0.0238107331097126,
0.1511741727590561,
-0.6068613529205322,
0.5353313088417053,
0.08719034492969513,
-0.12210021167993546,
0.03593049570918083,
-0.21707259118556976,
-0.9954416155815125,
0.633259117603302,
0.6636680364608765,
-0.3545384407043457,
-0.21806743741035461,
0.30831703543663025,
0.6334102153778076,
-0.506883978843689,
0.4251435101032257,
1.0225520133972168,
0.6369007229804993,
0.08583658933639526,
-0.8493688702583313,
-0.012612276710569859,
-0.12995468080043793,
0.2644746005535126,
0.3696657419204712,
-0.10721781849861145,
0.44985952973365784,
-0.1501864343881607,
-0.5537441372871399,
-0.1972726434469223,
0.775637149810791,
-0.10409941524267197,
0.11093851923942566,
0.7115197777748108,
0.559597373008728,
1.1517658233642578,
-0.3023552894592285,
0.7034633159637451,
-0.2071203589439392,
0.3210908770561218,
1.2680997848510742,
-0.4800194203853607,
0.6072383522987366,
0.06622165441513062,
-0.2366635501384735,
0.7234396934509277,
0.16086044907569885,
-0.1391647607088089,
0.44436129927635193,
0.23634807765483856,
-0.32910534739494324,
-0.024620313197374344,
-0.3271893262863159,
-0.11138001084327698,
1.1824345588684082,
0.4921322762966156,
-0.5840126872062683,
-0.241312637925148,
0.2635881304740906,
-0.04077141359448433,
0.13209404051303864,
0.04281067103147507,
1.168034553527832,
0.12254595756530762,
-0.7078279852867126,
0.5327929258346558,
-0.24386321008205414,
0.19069570302963257,
-0.31292060017585754,
-0.0035204412415623665,
0.3437701463699341,
-0.16979418694972992,
-0.22251009941101074,
-1.1404451131820679,
0.38528972864151,
-0.06406977772712708,
-0.23276008665561676,
0.34716737270355225,
1.1080266237258911,
-0.18391764163970947,
-0.47563862800598145,
0.26565250754356384,
0.6137357354164124,
0.31754299998283386,
0.19423076510429382,
-0.44468075037002563,
0.1479204148054123,
-0.03466489911079407,
-0.14138703048229218,
-0.02403615042567253,
0.8552207946777344,
0.12065606564283371,
0.5135911107063293,
0.3022879362106323,
-0.14725512266159058,
-0.2892506420612335,
0.23403623700141907,
0.8795444965362549,
-0.6366177797317505,
-0.37707412242889404,
-0.6586133241653442,
0.5929718017578125,
-0.27810198068618774,
-0.45286017656326294,
0.5410369038581848,
0.5396826267242432,
0.6194348335266113,
-0.006036327686160803,
0.9248616695404053,
0.05039077252149582,
0.5881600975990295,
-0.4880950450897217,
0.4968808889389038,
-0.03437400981783867,
0.3823959231376648,
-0.615543007850647,
-1.0052549839019775,
-0.05737894028425217,
0.5623353719711304,
-0.6190587878227234,
-0.005363347940146923,
0.8257248997688293,
0.5766268372535706,
-0.2783571183681488,
0.43414655327796936,
0.39410319924354553,
0.3940982222557068,
0.011348351836204529,
0.3127724826335907,
1.0341438055038452,
-0.3994453251361847,
0.18275105953216553,
0.056008823215961456,
-0.3482441008090973,
0.26881539821624756,
-0.9504241943359375,
-0.8590283989906311,
-0.9525665044784546,
-0.27392441034317017,
-0.22087624669075012,
-0.0027655260637402534,
0.8030201196670532,
0.4150794446468353,
-0.8731305599212646,
0.18813788890838623,
-0.007964080199599266,
0.1533723920583725,
0.1779133826494217,
-0.1785275936126709,
0.28838029503822327,
-0.06699518114328384,
-0.6583688855171204,
0.24771210551261902,
0.39879342913627625,
0.06191261485219002,
-0.38883769512176514,
0.21326349675655365,
-0.16852501034736633,
0.24125345051288605,
0.4734214246273041,
0.08477767556905746,
-0.9575632810592651,
-0.5457618236541748,
-0.1870381087064743,
-0.04635617882013321,
0.12776750326156616,
0.858571469783783,
-0.8270600438117981,
0.4632161855697632,
0.31964409351348877,
0.7633459568023682,
0.2634202539920807,
-0.19011615216732025,
0.46509450674057007,
-0.5701220631599426,
0.16982105374336243,
0.47191187739372253,
0.6616237163543701,
0.3403629958629608,
-0.45605742931365967,
0.45464399456977844,
0.13704685866832733,
-0.6473495364189148,
-0.7814614772796631,
0.46282222867012024,
-0.914097249507904,
-0.00835829135030508,
0.8902521133422852,
-0.4338451325893402,
-0.152837336063385,
-0.49071744084358215,
-0.36033713817596436,
-0.008427077904343605,
-0.2352372258901596,
0.48395344614982605,
0.7421379089355469,
0.19396178424358368,
-0.36897268891334534,
-0.3617601692676544,
0.37806636095046997,
0.02181193418800831,
-0.9909387230873108,
-0.06896638125181198,
0.48965373635292053,
0.33131733536720276,
0.28294774889945984,
0.5312942862510681,
-0.010083824396133423,
0.14511314034461975,
-0.10375586152076721,
-0.2621780037879944,
0.5269158482551575,
-0.47276535630226135,
-0.25418391823768616,
0.18879947066307068,
0.2938411831855774,
0.21131961047649384
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06292v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06292v1
|
Transformer based Multitask Learning for Image Captioning and Object Detection
| 2024-03-10T19:31:13 | 2024-03-10T19:31:13 |
Debolena Basak, P. K. Srijith, Maunendra Sankar Desarkar
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
In several real-world scenarios like autonomous navigation and mobility, to
obtain a better visual understanding of the surroundings, image captioning and
object detection play a crucial role. This work introduces a novel multitask
learning framework that combines image captioning and object detection into a
joint model. We propose TICOD, Transformer-based Image Captioning and Object
detection model for jointly training both tasks by combining the losses
obtained from image captioning and object detection networks. By leveraging
joint training, the model benefits from the complementary information shared
between the two tasks, leading to improved performance for image captioning.
Our approach utilizes a transformer-based architecture that enables end-to-end
network integration for image captioning and object detection and performs both
tasks jointly. We evaluate the effectiveness of our approach through
comprehensive experiments on the MS-COCO dataset. Our model outperforms the
baselines from image captioning literature by achieving a 3.65% improvement in
BERTScore.
|
[
-0.42485588788986206,
-0.23826192319393158,
0.2584034204483032,
-0.15121063590049744,
-0.6900065541267395,
0.26128819584846497,
0.006113192066550255,
-0.5820448994636536,
-0.06618130207061768,
0.5561908483505249,
-0.49615004658699036,
-0.40064316987991333,
-0.6751585602760315,
0.08315785974264145,
-0.1249818205833435,
0.5469865798950195,
0.008088131435215473,
0.05040234699845314,
-0.5837961435317993,
-0.3077309727668762,
-0.8934508562088013,
-0.28521665930747986,
-0.7173953056335449,
-0.06380106508731842,
0.33294281363487244,
0.6421077251434326,
0.4245631694793701,
0.4261889159679413,
0.6842201948165894,
0.31507283449172974,
0.4348371922969818,
0.493441641330719,
-0.030259830877184868,
0.1581716537475586,
-0.04625856131315231,
-0.6057533025741577,
0.05020294338464737,
-0.3878617286682129,
0.25280267000198364,
0.22749875485897064,
0.011972282081842422,
-0.0712115615606308,
-0.18732652068138123,
0.5734883546829224,
-0.887094259262085,
0.6921743750572205,
-0.5194709300994873,
0.27673736214637756,
-0.12098752707242966,
-0.13519376516342163,
-0.4481646418571472,
0.4842272698879242,
-0.27502208948135376,
-0.6269466280937195,
0.7256109118461609,
0.44720983505249023,
0.7484448552131653,
0.5440512299537659,
-0.4138326942920685,
-0.20346394181251526,
-0.41003602743148804,
0.8124197125434875,
-0.15288808941841125,
0.668545126914978,
0.020815450698137283,
0.5117807388305664,
0.4049781858921051,
-0.519324541091919,
-0.710469663143158,
-0.20438529551029205,
-0.35387229919433594,
0.29805898666381836,
0.036554399877786636,
-0.03635120764374733,
-0.044273827224969864,
0.4499744772911072,
-0.46774822473526,
-0.04992353171110153,
-0.3311000168323517,
-0.22655458748340607,
0.4701246917247772,
0.058737751096487045,
0.48035508394241333,
-0.22152899205684662,
-0.5975185632705688,
-0.2867196202278137,
-0.35994723439216614,
0.41753721237182617,
0.09187181293964386,
0.19783446192741394,
-0.13815844058990479,
0.35223183035850525,
-0.3015688955783844,
0.6107774972915649,
-0.15198300778865814,
-0.051956530660390854,
0.3582696318626404,
-0.32664862275123596,
-0.096204973757267,
-0.10358312726020813,
0.8957663774490356,
0.6238316893577576,
0.14903941750526428,
-0.6827821731567383,
-0.2803456485271454,
0.1968221664428711,
0.3763071894645691,
-0.4439498782157898,
-0.2664955258369446,
0.01180215273052454,
-0.5340315699577332,
-0.39034298062324524,
0.5636636018753052,
-0.6005538105964661,
-0.16661570966243744,
-0.36410629749298096,
0.17126330733299255,
-0.14536535739898682,
-0.4174764156341553,
0.20077747106552124,
0.03845802694559097,
0.41012412309646606,
0.12786094844341278,
-0.7150087952613831,
0.3021405041217804,
0.4874979257583618,
0.9572498202323914,
-0.6832908391952515,
-0.44082027673721313,
-0.9481049180030823,
0.269442081451416,
-0.22277581691741943,
1.3091182708740234,
-0.1654059886932373,
-0.34864264726638794,
-0.08817140758037567,
0.5778409838676453,
-0.29519426822662354,
-0.4354190528392792,
0.4438198208808899,
-0.5670041441917419,
-0.10466158390045166,
0.03568723797798157,
0.09023032337427139,
-0.47593745589256287,
0.41919586062431335,
-0.9640056490898132,
0.9670713543891907,
-0.0688394084572792,
-0.7765058875083923,
0.49292466044425964,
-1.0212832689285278,
-0.9886986017227173,
0.22810311615467072,
-0.029238009825348854,
-1.1574801206588745,
0.05243619158864021,
0.5881516933441162,
0.8859873414039612,
-0.0867156982421875,
0.3440360128879547,
-0.1407318264245987,
-0.39251527190208435,
0.13883830606937408,
-0.3445945382118225,
0.44972971081733704,
-0.025792216882109642,
-0.15554775297641754,
0.37272563576698303,
-0.11143087595701218,
-0.2748773992061615,
0.2788887619972229,
-0.06272104382514954,
-0.017609121277928352,
-0.13016213476657867,
0.39728546142578125,
0.25594690442085266,
0.04528060555458069,
-0.7749566435813904,
0.08727087825536728,
-0.0526106096804142,
0.2609921991825104,
0.20852568745613098,
0.015224577859044075,
0.4900391697883606,
-0.2607654631137848,
0.6782089471817017,
0.1708601415157318,
0.3745124936103821,
-0.505494236946106,
-0.580003559589386,
-0.6406585574150085,
-0.06030835211277008,
-0.2319878190755844,
0.47450295090675354,
-1.1781775951385498,
0.3832550048828125,
-0.3612351417541504,
-0.13652904331684113,
-0.12642209231853485,
-0.12201236188411713,
0.43954622745513916,
0.45752039551734924,
0.5944571495056152,
-0.31217578053474426,
-0.39424753189086914,
-0.7267704606056213,
-0.00711109209805727,
0.24747195839881897,
0.14648255705833435,
0.22507622838020325,
0.6485020518302917,
0.17542169988155365,
0.717864453792572,
-0.6569256782531738,
-0.9091558456420898,
-0.41923758387565613,
-0.014273864217102528,
-0.2186467945575714,
0.3593660295009613,
0.4612683057785034,
-1.3034439086914062,
-0.708112895488739,
0.058552712202072144,
-0.718691349029541,
0.33978471159935,
0.005376312881708145,
0.18525750935077667,
0.0774809718132019,
0.736084520816803,
-0.45921260118484497,
0.46734920144081116,
0.23812392354011536,
-0.004693630617111921,
0.4403267800807953,
-0.1953016221523285,
0.436145544052124,
-1.1867245435714722,
-0.14785881340503693,
-0.056270379573106766,
-0.5067105889320374,
-0.4536052346229553,
0.23257094621658325,
0.22091016173362732,
-0.2599303424358368,
-0.6953703165054321,
0.11192336678504944,
-0.7199752330780029,
-0.36571162939071655,
-0.5377681851387024,
-0.19989486038684845,
0.14436089992523193,
0.7351297736167908,
0.30766016244888306,
0.7986271381378174,
1.0239578485488892,
-0.45768386125564575,
0.6913737654685974,
0.2345000058412552,
-0.32070788741111755,
0.8520883321762085,
-0.4983181357383728,
0.1760619431734085,
-0.39188382029533386,
0.2251943051815033,
-1.1327006816864014,
-0.2294774353504181,
0.36311060190200806,
-0.23019349575042725,
0.19431772828102112,
-0.32546257972717285,
-0.5679590702056885,
-0.7343025207519531,
-0.2318967878818512,
0.29978933930397034,
-0.1506766378879547,
-0.6586492657661438,
0.8752639889717102,
0.16642139852046967,
0.20176656544208527,
-0.8076543807983398,
-0.7046634554862976,
0.12230588495731354,
-0.15579697489738464,
-0.5060197114944458,
0.4886623024940491,
0.1496123969554901,
0.4909023940563202,
0.10816655308008194,
-0.24907679855823517,
-0.20715047419071198,
-0.045525941997766495,
0.530985414981842,
0.5025400519371033,
0.05178774893283844,
0.31933271884918213,
-0.19668641686439514,
-0.4317852854728699,
-0.10336527973413467,
-0.3384198248386383,
0.5232217907905579,
-0.2649639844894409,
-0.5719668865203857,
-0.712006151676178,
0.3834761083126068,
0.8497475385665894,
-0.9888715147972107,
0.6305036544799805,
0.9744717478752136,
-0.2127935290336609,
0.10919950157403946,
-0.5077696442604065,
-0.3733550012111664,
-0.4620422422885895,
0.5906621813774109,
-0.6203964948654175,
-0.547827422618866,
0.29836633801460266,
-0.11816789954900742,
-0.2230476588010788,
0.22499461472034454,
0.26684343814849854,
-0.2579843997955322,
0.620230495929718,
0.644478976726532,
0.0392947793006897,
0.6478082537651062,
-0.8142741322517395,
0.4332129657268524,
-0.9533308744430542,
-0.5123340487480164,
-0.08724608272314072,
-0.1584896594285965,
-0.08108837157487869,
-0.7055879831314087,
0.3823075592517853,
-0.09714841097593307,
0.27508753538131714,
0.6020851135253906,
-0.7472214698791504,
0.6893256902694702,
0.46461188793182373,
0.6793411374092102,
0.6785595417022705,
0.015876594930887222,
0.2621021270751953,
0.2664974331855774,
-0.6163555383682251,
-0.17188043892383575,
1.1567528247833252,
0.03677308186888695,
0.49473437666893005,
-0.15457725524902344,
0.41598036885261536,
0.4347752630710602,
0.3882216811180115,
-0.9151709675788879,
0.4191892743110657,
-0.32233670353889465,
-0.26986733078956604,
-0.3274146318435669,
-0.03719589114189148,
-0.8138682842254639,
0.36084407567977905,
-0.09993685781955719,
-0.44414061307907104,
0.027422064915299416,
-0.0607198029756546,
-0.19558903574943542,
0.6041348576545715,
-0.7414135336875916,
1.33332097530365,
-0.401827871799469,
-0.2968098819255829,
-0.08484453707933426,
-0.6802963018417358,
0.40128105878829956,
0.2265165001153946,
0.2818770706653595,
-0.18478094041347504,
0.029400980100035667,
0.720954418182373,
0.11042892932891846,
0.7864488959312439,
-0.36734703183174133,
0.3135546147823334,
0.5286925435066223,
-0.022313078865408897,
0.527642011642456,
0.1738133281469345,
0.3770001232624054,
0.16095031797885895,
-0.16712523996829987,
-0.192574143409729,
-0.4489423930644989,
0.429058313369751,
-0.41928529739379883,
-0.29426878690719604,
-0.3480188250541687,
-0.8916274309158325,
0.16941416263580322,
0.19652867317199707,
0.38296982645988464,
0.4396785497665405,
0.21206489205360413,
0.40899887681007385,
0.37150174379348755,
-0.10541784018278122,
0.7629343271255493,
0.3205675184726715,
-0.09493019431829453,
-0.16523385047912598,
1.0021576881408691,
-0.35680174827575684,
0.03112514317035675,
0.707251787185669,
0.10139332711696625,
-0.6546863913536072,
-0.4266643822193146,
-0.45622703433036804,
0.07022164016962051,
-0.6561394333839417,
-0.530796229839325,
-0.8448728919029236,
0.12329008430242538,
-0.24124859273433685,
-0.15731868147850037,
-0.4973176121711731,
0.22944653034210205,
-0.20384334027767181,
0.10590022802352905,
0.19604286551475525,
0.6119686365127563,
0.3104478716850281,
0.5368286371231079,
-0.4768922030925751,
0.7229647636413574,
0.45684391260147095,
0.46377354860305786,
0.13974522054195404,
-0.17269547283649445,
-0.19809064269065857,
-0.20095038414001465,
-0.41065743565559387,
-0.5766769647598267,
0.20475992560386658,
-0.003814278868958354,
0.5560168623924255,
0.3244749903678894,
0.3135637938976288,
0.3037368059158325,
-0.21295562386512756,
0.5102740526199341,
0.523669421672821,
-0.7796473503112793,
0.31992942094802856,
0.11992888152599335,
0.289893239736557,
0.21314416825771332,
0.023701870813965797,
-0.547346830368042,
-0.2709672451019287,
-0.36218830943107605,
-0.40217480063438416,
0.808017373085022,
0.10028356313705444,
-0.07040654122829437,
0.3452543318271637,
-0.05007557570934296,
0.003921472001820803,
0.15021611750125885,
-1.0262585878372192,
0.0570622980594635,
-0.45032060146331787,
-0.29055169224739075,
-0.008151543326675892,
0.19893814623355865,
0.20788750052452087,
-0.16623924672603607,
0.2068690061569214,
-0.5115112066268921,
0.5391106605529785,
0.029654446989297867,
-0.43049225211143494,
0.13513065874576569,
0.12946149706840515,
0.5096415281295776,
0.1728099137544632,
0.18656276166439056,
0.19857798516750336,
0.18662361800670624,
-0.3776533007621765,
0.2228943109512329,
0.05814450979232788,
0.3759958744049072,
-0.1436832994222641,
0.4866810142993927,
0.7473227977752686,
0.19263912737369537,
-0.43248435854911804,
0.9221407175064087,
-0.015216582454741001,
-0.03723129630088806,
-0.19636698067188263,
0.09953052550554276,
0.17079171538352966,
0.22611582279205322,
0.5450644493103027,
0.6269409656524658,
0.1857672929763794,
-0.28071972727775574,
0.38005340099334717,
0.47522085905075073,
-0.4103027582168579,
-0.05028755962848663,
0.8968178033828735,
0.15534687042236328,
-0.3781880736351013,
0.37204569578170776,
-0.5277397632598877,
-0.8411319851875305,
1.1274242401123047,
0.23172271251678467,
0.7064500451087952,
-0.18757089972496033,
0.28698331117630005,
0.29290348291397095,
0.2336844503879547,
-0.18575060367584229,
0.17640134692192078,
-0.5275897979736328,
-0.9574266672134399,
-0.42129015922546387,
-0.21869014203548431,
-0.23720641434192657,
-0.0489819310605526,
-0.4898631274700165,
0.2968183755874634,
0.06837009638547897,
0.1601114571094513,
0.04033934697508812,
-0.37811803817749023,
-0.9202803373336792,
0.1952502727508545,
-0.06461434066295624,
0.13066861033439636,
-0.8895843625068665,
0.74111008644104,
0.770959198474884,
-0.5642387866973877,
-0.37147095799446106,
-0.04007713869214058,
-0.4113868772983551,
-0.7920050621032715,
0.738908052444458,
0.8783686757087708,
-0.3298558294773102,
0.08394315093755722,
-0.25746455788612366,
-0.4653888940811157,
1.3118144273757935,
0.02677028253674507,
-0.618341326713562,
0.034794725477695465,
0.2292025089263916,
0.11626484245061874,
-0.5501191020011902,
0.21059823036193848,
-0.054149895906448364,
0.32679858803749084,
0.28649088740348816,
-0.8450126051902771,
-0.17343266308307648,
0.17172323167324066,
0.06467558443546295,
0.14499212801456451,
-0.6865954995155334,
0.7604703307151794,
-0.5560393333435059,
-0.20977303385734558,
-0.08271358162164688,
0.40398091077804565,
-0.12832793593406677,
0.4216165840625763,
0.8731489777565002,
0.4144178330898285,
0.2406710535287857,
-0.12269178032875061,
0.7801725268363953,
-0.34408169984817505,
0.6834632158279419,
0.9908831715583801,
-0.12096711248159409,
0.538788378238678,
0.4907524883747101,
-0.06400758028030396,
0.3770170509815216,
0.3759714663028717,
-0.23337732255458832,
0.7293593883514404,
-0.1959654837846756,
-0.3481498062610626,
-0.4812812805175781,
-0.2534048855304718,
0.04205571115016937,
0.656902015209198,
0.23090100288391113,
-0.1310722976922989,
-0.3915511965751648,
1.0552775859832764,
-0.5042988061904907,
0.020627086982131004,
-0.2572936713695526,
0.7112749218940735,
-0.3291471302509308,
-0.6760275959968567,
0.2957848310470581,
-0.006134732160717249,
0.840000331401825,
-0.05856730788946152,
-0.1271546483039856,
0.09163738042116165,
0.2348615527153015,
-0.2985118627548218,
-1.0685855150222778,
0.48987454175949097,
-0.15967653691768646,
-0.1686147302389145,
-0.1643514484167099,
0.8082526922225952,
-0.457953542470932,
-0.4354887902736664,
0.19195415079593658,
0.3357919156551361,
0.05102955922484398,
-0.7014127373695374,
-0.5613559484481812,
0.15526802837848663,
-0.10992158204317093,
0.3161855936050415,
-0.20112495124340057,
0.0812506303191185,
-0.0077228243462741375,
0.8593534827232361,
0.717323899269104,
-0.4709375202655792,
0.03772605583071709,
-0.005244204308837652,
0.7511595487594604,
-0.22199517488479614,
-0.88742995262146,
-0.47910016775131226,
0.5156865119934082,
-0.17928358912467957,
0.27195480465888977,
0.17363083362579346,
0.8077138066291809,
0.899171769618988,
-0.7081918120384216,
0.5774835348129272,
-0.17489315569400787,
0.0753137618303299,
-0.48706814646720886,
0.42345017194747925,
-0.6180815696716309,
-0.016736095771193504,
0.08518990874290466,
-0.8625126481056213,
-0.5003536343574524,
0.4983437657356262,
-0.31760847568511963,
-0.10924217849969864,
0.941822350025177,
0.8076764345169067,
-0.5862014889717102,
0.018181048333644867,
0.5753039717674255,
-0.6226082444190979,
0.4344189465045929,
0.7174147963523865,
0.642760694026947,
-0.8613784909248352,
0.9468070864677429,
-0.5795788764953613,
0.08709535747766495,
-0.23143072426319122,
-0.7870045304298401,
-1.1802223920822144,
-0.8525216579437256,
-0.46244359016418457,
0.255940318107605,
-0.012798766605556011,
0.346794068813324,
1.122373104095459,
-0.7854985594749451,
-0.054126862436532974,
-0.4606689512729645,
0.14942823350429535,
-0.5820605158805847,
-0.3577131927013397,
0.5792210102081299,
-0.32888248562812805,
-0.8350793123245239,
0.20789873600006104,
0.35112014412879944,
-0.00819022860378027,
-0.1487964391708374,
-0.12450955808162689,
-0.2554020583629608,
-0.6904591917991638,
0.6875728368759155,
0.08850353211164474,
-0.7425264120101929,
-0.32648608088493347,
0.07457918673753738,
0.13741691410541534,
0.39264366030693054,
0.924715518951416,
-0.7213653326034546,
0.6389469504356384,
0.09696400165557861,
0.5242916941642761,
0.6555371284484863,
-0.011919403448700905,
-0.029846062883734703,
-0.9316374063491821,
0.4961337447166443,
-0.17856653034687042,
0.4227088689804077,
0.6303609609603882,
-0.4301295280456543,
0.41137242317199707,
0.5732211470603943,
-0.32345202565193176,
-0.34204357862472534,
0.22482900321483612,
-1.107422947883606,
-0.3205777108669281,
0.450058251619339,
-0.2301715910434723,
-0.23882479965686798,
-0.38047224283218384,
-0.355817973613739,
0.3717731237411499,
-0.4159955382347107,
0.6328708529472351,
0.30243217945098877,
-0.06539907306432724,
-0.9137890934944153,
-0.4623606503009796,
0.10823789238929749,
-0.0038571942131966352,
-1.0187411308288574,
0.045550618320703506,
0.047354865819215775,
0.32663026452064514,
0.3940102756023407,
0.12661325931549072,
0.2170776128768921,
0.6116675138473511,
-0.24089939892292023,
0.5416704416275024,
-0.7684664726257324,
-0.5745165944099426,
0.08260377496480942,
0.33095383644104004,
-0.5567144155502319,
-1.1356908082962036
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06265v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06265v2
|
Unpacking Tokenization: Evaluating Text Compression and its Correlation with Model Performance
| 2024-03-10T17:02:53 | 2024-06-22T16:00:49 |
Omer Goldman, Avi Caciularu, Matan Eyal, Kris Cao, Idan Szpektor, Reut Tsarfaty
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Despite it being the cornerstone of BPE, the most common tokenization
algorithm, the importance of compression in the tokenization process is still
unclear. In this paper, we argue for the theoretical importance of compression,
that can be viewed as 0-gram language modeling where equal probability is
assigned to all tokens. We also demonstrate the empirical importance of
compression for downstream success of pre-trained language models. We control
the compression ability of several BPE tokenizers by varying the amount of
documents available during their training: from 1 million documents to a
character-based tokenizer equivalent to no training data at all. We then
pre-train English language models based on those tokenizers and fine-tune them
over several tasks. We show that there is a correlation between tokenizers'
compression and models' downstream performance, suggesting that compression is
a reliable intrinsic indicator of tokenization quality. These correlations are
more pronounced for generation tasks (over classification) or for smaller
models (over large ones). We replicated a representative part of our
experiments on Turkish and found similar results, confirming that our results
hold for languages with typological characteristics dissimilar to English. We
conclude that building better compressing tokenizers is a fruitful avenue for
further research and for improving overall model performance.
|
[
-0.26031529903411865,
-0.3201037645339966,
0.30643096566200256,
0.16041520237922668,
-0.6301122903823853,
-0.04061916470527649,
-0.23341046273708344,
-0.4706581234931946,
0.19534415006637573,
0.16510431468486786,
0.07667139172554016,
-0.16403836011886597,
-0.9932003021240234,
0.18987151980400085,
-0.6453866362571716,
1.0282119512557983,
0.1251477599143982,
0.16956044733524323,
-0.0796736553311348,
0.2350606620311737,
-0.5865129828453064,
-0.9550327062606812,
-0.6751431822776794,
-0.3130307197570801,
0.38612648844718933,
-0.13635441660881042,
0.5459147691726685,
0.7590769529342651,
0.4115678369998932,
0.36987560987472534,
-0.46151864528656006,
-0.2632734179496765,
-0.43056797981262207,
0.15606443583965302,
-0.13770142197608948,
-0.44410547614097595,
-0.1915009766817093,
0.06276977062225342,
0.7169995903968811,
0.8858715295791626,
0.06332062929868698,
0.42599213123321533,
0.2633199691772461,
0.7161332368850708,
-0.5357810258865356,
-0.015228988602757454,
-0.5640820264816284,
-0.20008669793605804,
-0.27933913469314575,
-0.3527981638908386,
-0.5420282483100891,
-0.025745218619704247,
-0.16560563445091248,
-0.1869940459728241,
0.4407298266887665,
0.3234253525733948,
1.0139650106430054,
0.18722233176231384,
-0.4512500762939453,
-0.1676933616399765,
-0.792153000831604,
0.6740801334381104,
-0.8214312791824341,
0.39783862233161926,
0.07635869830846786,
-0.06313874572515488,
-0.22306503355503082,
-0.8308144211769104,
-0.4583069980144501,
0.1717359572649002,
-0.16325101256370544,
0.04036843404173851,
-0.19426968693733215,
0.28561657667160034,
0.022308895364403725,
0.7373790144920349,
-0.44277113676071167,
0.3268641233444214,
-0.5807471871376038,
-0.3079919219017029,
0.3175729215145111,
-0.2770104706287384,
0.5231310129165649,
-0.20484384894371033,
-0.16018418967723846,
-0.21791814267635345,
-0.5710397362709045,
0.31677210330963135,
0.6526307463645935,
0.518958330154419,
0.2768012583255768,
0.7316333055496216,
0.06306397914886475,
0.9290715456008911,
-0.11733385920524597,
0.0844004824757576,
-0.019321518018841743,
-0.4308909475803375,
-0.3548446297645569,
0.09049797803163528,
0.6560987234115601,
-0.043497201055288315,
0.257221519947052,
-0.4533737301826477,
-0.46890950202941895,
0.06124451011419296,
0.529112696647644,
-1.1541320085525513,
0.09574024379253387,
0.5111361742019653,
-0.9751158952713013,
-0.4189685583114624,
0.4929772913455963,
-0.5650709867477417,
-0.053336188197135925,
-0.2583949863910675,
0.4758002758026123,
-0.17357347905635834,
-0.16942475736141205,
0.5031381249427795,
-0.4624846875667572,
-0.14204740524291992,
-0.06874372810125351,
-1.2190790176391602,
0.3173286020755768,
0.9687399864196777,
0.9482929110527039,
-0.030713407322764397,
-0.33310386538505554,
-0.5901528000831604,
-0.13866502046585083,
-0.4053393602371216,
0.9111872315406799,
-0.49931806325912476,
-0.4292648136615753,
0.1601259857416153,
0.05062597990036011,
-0.09067918360233307,
-0.3293308615684509,
0.9564460515975952,
-0.2725370526313782,
0.17405031621456146,
-0.04267168045043945,
-0.8466290831565857,
-0.00206690258346498,
-0.0906703770160675,
-0.7270179986953735,
1.0630278587341309,
0.09303529560565948,
-0.7285057306289673,
0.5342397093772888,
-0.39532431960105896,
-0.36511263251304626,
0.13148942589759827,
0.040072519332170486,
-0.13578087091445923,
0.9674704670906067,
0.12041755765676498,
0.6405025720596313,
-0.32892993092536926,
0.22836840152740479,
0.044570840895175934,
-0.6933333873748779,
0.19111153483390808,
-0.3982698917388916,
0.6203964948654175,
0.17493891716003418,
-0.04427587613463402,
-0.09749550372362137,
-0.763611912727356,
0.048818960785865784,
-0.09516681730747223,
-0.7359006404876709,
-0.31162601709365845,
-0.07508530467748642,
0.19344462454319,
0.15360940992832184,
0.26898521184921265,
-0.651267409324646,
0.3912314772605896,
-0.6039013266563416,
0.43571677803993225,
0.6285786032676697,
-0.1055721715092659,
0.4435218572616577,
-0.3043179512023926,
0.43490397930145264,
-0.04750162735581398,
0.18289294838905334,
-0.3903251886367798,
-0.42140206694602966,
-0.6919501423835754,
-0.45248278975486755,
0.9927523136138916,
0.1916879564523697,
-0.13407030701637268,
0.5391512513160706,
-0.5399988293647766,
-0.40071290731430054,
-0.5329304337501526,
-0.18181197345256805,
0.2330150455236435,
0.11276047676801682,
0.09664920717477798,
-0.6012860536575317,
-0.48209914565086365,
-0.641813337802887,
-0.4230327308177948,
-0.46959906816482544,
-0.3347018361091614,
0.0012235435424372554,
0.37841007113456726,
0.15719406306743622,
0.9298042058944702,
-0.10818640887737274,
-0.14092740416526794,
-0.18876518309116364,
0.7343295812606812,
0.27140894532203674,
0.7142351865768433,
0.6263924241065979,
-0.5913845300674438,
-0.2624298334121704,
-0.17717720568180084,
-0.1802992969751358,
-0.34566730260849,
-0.11692638695240021,
0.05414433777332306,
0.25612664222717285,
0.4902908504009247,
-0.5654394030570984,
0.4955501854419708,
0.8411503434181213,
-0.5276161432266235,
0.6835999488830566,
-0.5876622200012207,
0.1983186900615692,
-1.0917415618896484,
0.3299393057823181,
-0.42000389099121094,
-0.11987288296222687,
-0.8333389759063721,
0.19599011540412903,
-0.1240982785820961,
-0.42794719338417053,
-0.37474632263183594,
0.528884768486023,
-0.5985581874847412,
-0.1740228235721588,
-0.38615772128105164,
-0.029652684926986694,
0.15963226556777954,
0.34191036224365234,
0.0028848478104919195,
0.9153313636779785,
0.38227471709251404,
-0.4910220205783844,
-0.1778833270072937,
0.020632386207580566,
-0.620188295841217,
0.07176385074853897,
-0.8881467580795288,
0.22628052532672882,
-0.35830172896385193,
0.017943179234862328,
-0.975899875164032,
0.1367957592010498,
-0.263342946767807,
-0.5526056885719299,
0.6699630618095398,
-0.3527347147464752,
-0.771072506904602,
-0.2996141314506531,
-0.1719815880060196,
0.43202662467956543,
0.6988410353660583,
-0.4378757178783417,
0.5523257851600647,
0.2572738826274872,
0.10251484811306,
-0.4527817666530609,
-0.6720924377441406,
0.09082607924938202,
-0.19297845661640167,
-0.3850685954093933,
0.49125155806541443,
-0.2199925035238266,
0.09914261102676392,
0.09976530075073242,
-0.36711159348487854,
-0.08252465724945068,
0.26530346274375916,
0.2577937841415405,
0.12207668274641037,
0.08760824054479599,
0.273176908493042,
-0.0839042142033577,
-0.17746353149414062,
-0.10112816840410233,
-0.814717710018158,
0.8004715442657471,
0.13665039837360382,
-0.08299264311790466,
-0.0904366746544838,
0.3126220405101776,
0.43556854128837585,
-0.14974290132522583,
1.1806988716125488,
0.5501833558082581,
-0.24899160861968994,
0.1550612449645996,
-0.49885812401771545,
0.014613844454288483,
-0.44642120599746704,
0.11541319638490677,
-0.4134509861469269,
-0.9974782466888428,
0.5124848484992981,
-0.3285439908504486,
-0.00545469718053937,
0.3314623534679413,
0.38044893741607666,
0.15588898956775665,
1.0456883907318115,
0.9492539763450623,
-0.1756487339735031,
0.5651494860649109,
0.08805087208747864,
0.5242125988006592,
-0.5371341705322266,
0.07239992171525955,
-1.0736650228500366,
-0.16623488068580627,
-0.7140032052993774,
-0.30103251338005066,
-0.0072821662761271,
0.6905137896537781,
-0.022213976830244064,
0.3604505658149719,
-0.6333912014961243,
0.7616041302680969,
0.39334505796432495,
-0.3534109890460968,
0.10137899219989777,
0.14217974245548248,
-0.17358513176441193,
0.1754017472267151,
-0.8122557401657104,
-0.7653419375419617,
1.0077351331710815,
0.3397360146045685,
0.2763500511646271,
0.1248338520526886,
0.767281711101532,
0.27993208169937134,
-0.011873931623995304,
-0.8044818639755249,
0.18008579313755035,
-0.3575465679168701,
-0.5856236815452576,
-0.1582254022359848,
-0.3910478949546814,
-1.4108130931854248,
0.1883566677570343,
-0.4697117507457733,
-1.019527792930603,
0.2605591118335724,
0.15877515077590942,
-0.22603335976600647,
0.2615247070789337,
-0.7986946105957031,
0.838752031326294,
0.13560797274112701,
0.029822682961821556,
-0.13924191892147064,
-0.4586035907268524,
0.10622884333133698,
-0.3120621144771576,
0.33713892102241516,
0.18181824684143066,
-0.11695197969675064,
0.9984742403030396,
-0.5145387053489685,
0.6001420021057129,
0.15604449808597565,
0.06582117080688477,
0.10055303573608398,
0.09355343133211136,
0.4560052752494812,
-0.33286815881729126,
0.01125068124383688,
0.47632044553756714,
0.48693907260894775,
-0.824567437171936,
-0.9515206217765808,
0.24432164430618286,
-0.7083452343940735,
-0.6264930367469788,
-0.28053897619247437,
-0.2472110390663147,
0.102930448949337,
0.35048454999923706,
0.5249404907226562,
0.7373719811439514,
-0.12988165020942688,
0.16209085285663605,
0.17025455832481384,
-0.20096051692962646,
0.5612116456031799,
0.3410942554473877,
-0.270155131816864,
-0.2890857756137848,
0.9217503070831299,
0.18468119204044342,
0.08792851865291595,
0.47564709186553955,
0.3546799421310425,
-0.047542866319417953,
-0.9456969499588013,
-0.22883346676826477,
0.186700701713562,
-0.6361531615257263,
-0.13269400596618652,
-0.49817949533462524,
-0.14770254492759705,
-0.5866471529006958,
-0.27638953924179077,
-0.47479021549224854,
-0.6511527299880981,
-0.18198223412036896,
-0.028225213289260864,
-0.2733256220817566,
0.923845112323761,
-0.11843796819448471,
0.4974517226219177,
-1.064178705215454,
-0.14157025516033173,
0.08718471974134445,
0.3504953682422638,
0.10642307251691818,
-0.6199252605438232,
-0.5268092751502991,
-0.25766226649284363,
0.0847768560051918,
-0.9222759008407593,
0.38407963514328003,
0.05962051451206207,
0.3374810218811035,
0.5587276816368103,
-0.034763604402542114,
0.6334933638572693,
-0.6092576384544373,
1.1184823513031006,
0.0913040041923523,
-1.233217716217041,
0.2529541850090027,
0.05278341472148895,
0.16306965053081512,
0.4973451495170593,
0.3717809319496155,
-0.6554685235023499,
-0.3305642902851105,
-0.7654224634170532,
-0.9755821824073792,
0.40245336294174194,
0.3668416440486908,
0.37364643812179565,
-0.16598831117153168,
0.5696301460266113,
0.10007981956005096,
0.4474732279777527,
-0.6878642439842224,
-0.12008872628211975,
-0.1148083359003067,
-0.1553439199924469,
-0.17034336924552917,
-0.7810580134391785,
0.23762457072734833,
-0.1999988555908203,
0.6353619694709778,
0.07013155519962311,
0.36958563327789307,
0.044399701058864594,
-0.08913716673851013,
0.056527696549892426,
0.4638393521308899,
0.4456523358821869,
0.35207802057266235,
-0.3185560405254364,
0.24947905540466309,
-0.3013339638710022,
-0.5082995295524597,
0.278125137090683,
0.029934609308838844,
-0.0488012470304966,
0.13195133209228516,
0.5186132788658142,
0.9181244373321533,
0.13598230481147766,
-0.6106095910072327,
0.6222696900367737,
-0.2189028263092041,
0.06669983267784119,
0.1304754912853241,
-0.19792863726615906,
-0.3977296054363251,
-0.06754206866025925,
0.243175208568573,
0.06586244702339172,
0.15371926128864288,
-0.6082016229629517,
-0.0507427342236042,
0.3345871865749359,
-0.20142598450183868,
-0.4774731397628784,
0.5214711427688599,
0.26952043175697327,
-0.4504993259906769,
0.5806894302368164,
-0.13613851368427277,
-0.6084979176521301,
0.2895733714103699,
0.6403900384902954,
0.812377393245697,
-0.062044769525527954,
0.04465232044458389,
0.4973587989807129,
0.48675987124443054,
-0.36089661717414856,
-0.19606885313987732,
-0.20767423510551453,
-0.6802096962928772,
-0.7768079042434692,
-0.8960097432136536,
-0.027150988578796387,
0.06201448291540146,
-0.6409395337104797,
0.299156129360199,
-0.0690617486834526,
-0.29183316230773926,
-0.1423616260290146,
0.15809820592403412,
-0.6097509860992432,
0.0659242570400238,
-0.026119345799088478,
1.177045226097107,
-0.9540568590164185,
0.593248188495636,
0.5303582549095154,
-0.5719196200370789,
-0.9204052090644836,
0.06907139718532562,
-0.28827282786369324,
-0.4011174142360687,
0.8420717120170593,
0.2880535125732422,
0.22531355917453766,
0.16695941984653473,
-0.3524255156517029,
-0.9323682188987732,
0.7063297033309937,
0.4276527464389801,
-0.32353103160858154,
-0.10118822008371353,
0.2003539800643921,
0.6875779032707214,
-0.2841064929962158,
0.45823246240615845,
0.46360141038894653,
0.2600986659526825,
-0.04534854739904404,
-0.8719270825386047,
-0.024974439293146133,
-0.39433300495147705,
0.3907426595687866,
0.37401285767555237,
-0.4474506676197052,
0.6935913562774658,
0.1851947009563446,
-0.7652906775474548,
0.07548874616622925,
0.5445171594619751,
-0.19745829701423645,
-0.23635701835155487,
0.4482260048389435,
0.4851849377155304,
0.7408942580223083,
0.0274208914488554,
1.3227962255477905,
-0.7853858470916748,
0.29759907722473145,
0.872093915939331,
0.19426757097244263,
0.8996434211730957,
0.62681645154953,
-0.15026411414146423,
0.38340047001838684,
0.654050886631012,
0.05865340679883957,
0.214126855134964,
0.3788377642631531,
-0.18451419472694397,
-0.07989916205406189,
-0.391287237405777,
-0.056286487728357315,
0.42650216817855835,
-0.1192205548286438,
-0.40528932213783264,
-0.11885106563568115,
-0.21751809120178223,
0.09604515880346298,
-0.05427934601902962,
-0.17589689791202545,
0.6407985687255859,
-0.1467098444700241,
-0.7811863422393799,
0.5899710059165955,
0.14008460938930511,
0.5830363631248474,
-0.5061988830566406,
0.26231083273887634,
-0.23779886960983276,
-0.23940424621105194,
-0.0774419754743576,
-0.42536550760269165,
0.4310280680656433,
0.13441617786884308,
-0.2686810791492462,
-0.43550905585289,
0.8160202503204346,
-0.32106176018714905,
-0.33900490403175354,
0.10631769150495529,
0.5797826051712036,
0.6486231088638306,
-0.1628187745809555,
-0.2394237369298935,
0.2040659338235855,
-0.297784686088562,
-0.45635291934013367,
0.5590280294418335,
0.5734648108482361,
0.2954995334148407,
0.3538942039012909,
0.921341061592102,
0.5886982679367065,
-0.0018523125909268856,
0.12273980677127838,
0.7204231023788452,
-0.4504585266113281,
-0.4179891049861908,
-0.9324970841407776,
0.6111876964569092,
-0.07230976223945618,
-0.14931288361549377,
0.6391324400901794,
0.6321379542350769,
0.8601217269897461,
-0.026431484147906303,
0.4189862608909607,
0.004695109557360411,
0.11263234913349152,
-0.5710679888725281,
0.6024249792098999,
-0.6126337647438049,
0.1596461683511734,
-0.10256504267454147,
-0.9402269124984741,
-0.2182062864303589,
0.3603613078594208,
0.11199385672807693,
-0.07761027663946152,
0.8800572752952576,
0.5398411750793457,
0.062289875000715256,
-0.2369941622018814,
0.5333433151245117,
-0.03840536251664162,
0.3067992031574249,
0.12910957634449005,
0.4568459391593933,
-0.567941427230835,
0.6023960113525391,
-0.051027312874794006,
-0.12598377466201782,
0.2142781764268875,
-1.227312445640564,
-1.013584852218628,
-0.9043435454368591,
-0.18789975345134735,
-0.35454484820365906,
-0.17742477357387543,
0.9468231201171875,
0.8908482789993286,
-0.580029308795929,
-0.19584967195987701,
-0.31947264075279236,
-0.11806824058294296,
-0.26218852400779724,
-0.17841336131095886,
0.3549012243747711,
-0.7406760454177856,
-1.023057460784912,
0.12213607132434845,
0.35020938515663147,
0.5045276880264282,
-0.2430494874715805,
0.18084798753261566,
0.1968974471092224,
0.5519278049468994,
0.5319455862045288,
0.08560407906770706,
-0.5001125931739807,
-0.21142306923866272,
-0.3755313754081726,
0.08747051656246185,
-0.06979602575302124,
1.3614095449447632,
-0.8518182635307312,
0.5213391184806824,
0.7531561255455017,
0.6853156089782715,
0.4026038348674774,
0.11920907348394394,
0.8040345907211304,
-1.0457462072372437,
0.5091999769210815,
-0.20741094648838043,
0.5594041347503662,
0.28957948088645935,
-0.38052672147750854,
0.5816426277160645,
0.13336756825447083,
-0.8184932470321655,
-1.0866708755493164,
0.1306525021791458,
-0.7030134797096252,
-0.6066463589668274,
1.0373085737228394,
-0.35029086470603943,
-0.45987656712532043,
0.0070321206003427505,
-0.2574291229248047,
0.5122124552726746,
-0.27306365966796875,
1.0036654472351074,
1.2030613422393799,
0.19059787690639496,
-0.14053668081760406,
-0.3984730839729309,
0.6226270794868469,
0.6506335139274597,
-0.6026386022567749,
0.15834341943264008,
0.14544427394866943,
-0.07503007352352142,
0.3088549077510834,
0.6374924182891846,
-0.04377454146742821,
-0.2609559893608093,
0.1638832986354828,
0.12378723174333572,
-0.11759552359580994,
-0.17362898588180542,
-0.7373952269554138,
0.27351391315460205,
0.26188910007476807,
-0.028849495574831963
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06260v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06260v1
|
SCORE: Self-supervised Correspondence Fine-tuning for Improved Content Representations
| 2024-03-10T16:57:51 | 2024-03-10T16:57:51 |
Amit Meghanani, Thomas Hain
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
There is a growing interest in cost-effective self-supervised fine-tuning
(SSFT) of self-supervised learning (SSL)-based speech models to obtain
task-specific representations. These task-specific representations are used for
robust performance on various downstream tasks by fine-tuning on the labelled
data. This work presents a cost-effective SSFT method named Self-supervised
Correspondence (SCORE) fine-tuning to adapt the SSL speech representations for
content-related tasks. The proposed method uses a correspondence training
strategy, aiming to learn similar representations from perturbed speech and
original speech. Commonly used data augmentation techniques for content-related
tasks (ASR) are applied to obtain perturbed speech. SCORE fine-tuned HuBERT
outperforms the vanilla HuBERT on SUPERB benchmark with only a few hours of
fine-tuning (< 5 hrs) on a single GPU for automatic speech recognition, phoneme
recognition, and query-by-example tasks, with relative improvements of 1.09%,
3.58%, and 12.65%, respectively. SCORE provides competitive results with the
recently proposed SSFT method SPIN, using only 1/3 of the processed speech
compared to SPIN.
|
[
-0.2715687155723572,
-0.6514126658439636,
0.26423153281211853,
0.21342946588993073,
-0.2672768831253052,
0.09825367480516434,
-0.3916130065917969,
-0.248911514878273,
0.33938273787498474,
0.5973035097122192,
-0.747316837310791,
-0.6011479496955872,
-0.2983633875846863,
-0.05091874673962593,
-0.32933366298675537,
0.7745096683502197,
0.27248597145080566,
-0.003432274330407381,
-0.2492775022983551,
0.11428266763687134,
-0.435385525226593,
-0.44950243830680847,
-0.8051974177360535,
-0.23125548660755157,
0.4872274696826935,
0.7087445855140686,
0.4025508165359497,
0.9880895614624023,
0.6937086582183838,
0.3171969950199127,
0.2112351953983307,
0.3332672119140625,
-0.7343719601631165,
0.3719293475151062,
-0.4012201428413391,
-0.18433627486228943,
-0.3547290861606598,
0.13477815687656403,
0.7222768664360046,
0.4826841354370117,
-0.16565299034118652,
0.44204339385032654,
0.3168657422065735,
0.9185888767242432,
-0.5649094581604004,
0.3239183723926544,
-0.833865225315094,
-0.023872043937444687,
-0.29473423957824707,
-0.530403733253479,
-0.2678220570087433,
0.15021942555904388,
-0.22846460342407227,
-0.5790390968322754,
0.3212854862213135,
0.06304525583982468,
0.7016698122024536,
0.7169347405433655,
0.06670289486646652,
-0.0029064645059406757,
-0.7154233455657959,
0.8419663310050964,
-0.5955677628517151,
0.43171483278274536,
0.6138249039649963,
0.3118971586227417,
-0.19122283160686493,
-0.37772122025489807,
-0.3173081874847412,
-0.20137594640254974,
-0.01008403766900301,
0.3071382939815521,
-0.03949892148375511,
0.12218300998210907,
0.3250283896923065,
0.48246699571609497,
-0.4880641996860504,
0.13359978795051575,
-0.3164380192756653,
-0.27721935510635376,
0.9449651837348938,
0.15834906697273254,
-0.10654939711093903,
-0.20365703105926514,
-0.17622248828411102,
-0.3032963275909424,
-0.42274588346481323,
0.04409167170524597,
0.6927204132080078,
0.8325999975204468,
-0.10865016281604767,
0.40307140350341797,
-0.6733238101005554,
0.7320379614830017,
0.7082050442695618,
-0.04407092183828354,
0.21998068690299988,
-0.24144479632377625,
-0.15772219002246857,
0.3527279794216156,
0.9551851153373718,
0.2071230113506317,
0.3929133713245392,
-0.04668637365102768,
-0.0729968249797821,
-0.05251697823405266,
0.36877232789993286,
-0.4760150611400604,
-0.5958722233772278,
0.049184899777173996,
-0.2534925937652588,
-0.09813018888235092,
0.020738516002893448,
-0.36250513792037964,
-0.04948484152555466,
-0.7018917798995972,
0.6862598657608032,
-0.4854021370410919,
-0.05939648300409317,
-0.052945271134376526,
0.22456610202789307,
0.05847276374697685,
0.39532506465911865,
-1.1731023788452148,
0.31213584542274475,
0.471491277217865,
0.6725377440452576,
-0.527355968952179,
-0.24833473563194275,
-0.9660838842391968,
0.2565881013870239,
-0.4178154170513153,
1.0147039890289307,
-0.46665188670158386,
-0.24743500351905823,
-0.29268062114715576,
-0.23363283276557922,
-0.14421793818473816,
-0.6612184047698975,
0.6832299828529358,
0.0051250820979475975,
0.056328706443309784,
-0.04426280036568642,
-0.772487223148346,
0.20786979794502258,
-0.1206638514995575,
-0.5473352670669556,
1.1565024852752686,
0.2462681382894516,
-0.49833807349205017,
0.15219280123710632,
-0.4732363820075989,
-0.6299383044242859,
0.11251141875982285,
-0.1696031093597412,
-0.3548926115036011,
0.08002445846796036,
0.3159524202346802,
0.5766979455947876,
-0.010495159775018692,
0.07870940864086151,
-0.33602041006088257,
-0.5888800621032715,
-0.13846345245838165,
-0.3465064764022827,
0.2196781486272812,
0.3114328384399414,
-0.2690138816833496,
0.29342859983444214,
-0.9341763854026794,
0.13438139855861664,
-0.2188122570514679,
-0.29669269919395447,
-0.20220163464546204,
-0.022151170298457146,
0.06911630183458328,
0.08479976654052734,
0.38517022132873535,
-0.4850330948829651,
-0.13244768977165222,
-0.4142168462276459,
0.28106215596199036,
0.6887912750244141,
-0.25721657276153564,
0.32845422625541687,
-0.37219059467315674,
0.2062678188085556,
0.07876557111740112,
0.12073053419589996,
-0.20555715262889862,
-0.22779446840286255,
-0.6664702296257019,
-0.39678362011909485,
0.5646703839302063,
0.3558678925037384,
-0.3309555947780609,
0.6435452103614807,
-0.17005977034568787,
-0.6598308682441711,
-1.0898725986480713,
0.2951441705226898,
0.3030999004840851,
0.7898027300834656,
0.7979211211204529,
-0.31009647250175476,
-0.35387030243873596,
-0.8919923305511475,
-0.4851438105106354,
0.024331891909241676,
-0.17492416501045227,
0.36571019887924194,
-0.04884158447384834,
0.18090474605560303,
0.8235930800437927,
-0.4036170542240143,
-0.9909759759902954,
0.23388183116912842,
0.17990510165691376,
0.18217706680297852,
0.9515480399131775,
0.08680885285139084,
-0.47899582982063293,
-0.9501036405563354,
-0.11139151453971863,
-0.27118992805480957,
-0.1298648864030838,
-0.10441473126411438,
0.14819703996181488,
0.13078390061855316,
0.7633787393569946,
-0.0666341781616211,
0.18527434766292572,
0.7201185822486877,
-0.05200831964612007,
0.4194437265396118,
-0.48517364263534546,
0.3122824728488922,
-0.773842990398407,
-0.15396738052368164,
0.1377120018005371,
-0.5205978751182556,
-0.5377958416938782,
-0.22370192408561707,
0.021315505728125572,
-0.17526501417160034,
-0.30272018909454346,
0.18160974979400635,
-0.29244548082351685,
0.16973651945590973,
-0.3596345782279968,
0.20334969460964203,
-0.19036556780338287,
0.5412436723709106,
0.007895794697105885,
0.9603514075279236,
0.7703639268875122,
-0.3976227045059204,
0.2722892165184021,
0.2883927822113037,
-0.2238544076681137,
0.8404058814048767,
-0.6171581745147705,
0.4286002516746521,
-0.018366973847150803,
-0.09075093269348145,
-1.16078519821167,
-0.16893385350704193,
0.14113149046897888,
-0.4815708100795746,
0.6337060332298279,
-0.22796538472175598,
-0.2677523195743561,
0.1594638228416443,
-0.18415775895118713,
0.20215485990047455,
0.33344927430152893,
-0.5283471345901489,
0.7066453099250793,
0.3678623139858246,
-0.038070667535066605,
-0.16713403165340424,
-0.6501619815826416,
-0.09323389083147049,
-0.18034367263317108,
-0.5456584095954895,
0.7410276532173157,
-0.22225144505500793,
0.3892408013343811,
-0.074532151222229,
-0.4922657012939453,
0.15844587981700897,
-0.08287470787763596,
0.3103136718273163,
-0.22940291464328766,
-0.32724010944366455,
0.08456175029277802,
0.3267958164215088,
-0.22785399854183197,
-0.121681809425354,
-0.06459994614124298,
0.4229174554347992,
0.011759806424379349,
-0.4390530586242676,
-0.7345334887504578,
0.5424216389656067,
0.17971888184547424,
-0.19698920845985413,
0.2557515799999237,
0.787972092628479,
-0.2512054741382599,
-0.19647377729415894,
-0.824187695980072,
-0.28054922819137573,
-0.578789234161377,
0.1346948742866516,
-0.6208484768867493,
-1.1104187965393066,
0.3857962489128113,
-0.070443294942379,
-0.29682666063308716,
0.6521480083465576,
0.15782421827316284,
-0.6478086113929749,
0.9700952768325806,
0.3395977318286896,
-0.3194236159324646,
0.6853470206260681,
-0.02833307720720768,
-0.07137670367956161,
-0.8972405791282654,
0.029420768842101097,
-0.5479064583778381,
-0.28012028336524963,
-0.7204920053482056,
-0.34269979596138,
0.14601115882396698,
0.01938159577548504,
-0.2906547486782074,
0.5108494758605957,
-0.6009912490844727,
0.3836406469345093,
0.9203874468803406,
0.3353502154350281,
0.27905401587486267,
0.3262632191181183,
0.02100951224565506,
-0.19174621999263763,
-0.6732094287872314,
-0.09664254635572433,
0.9333222508430481,
0.16213591396808624,
0.9600676894187927,
-0.3079739212989807,
0.9106438159942627,
0.5819004774093628,
-0.26507872343063354,
-0.577502965927124,
0.45031145215034485,
-0.7305251359939575,
-0.23787756264209747,
-0.5916124582290649,
-0.6604124903678894,
-0.7334395051002502,
-0.014200299046933651,
-0.5410611629486084,
-0.6921897530555725,
0.02044619433581829,
0.4936635494232178,
-0.3406372368335724,
-0.2790367603302002,
-0.611838698387146,
0.8684160113334656,
-0.018856706097722054,
-0.4108261466026306,
-0.6459150910377502,
-0.6137312054634094,
-0.2047271579504013,
-0.18592682480812073,
-0.10348530858755112,
-0.5207001566886902,
0.5265268087387085,
0.7896725535392761,
0.13669130206108093,
0.701461911201477,
-0.09904534369707108,
-0.08575058728456497,
0.013938728719949722,
-0.003031965112313628,
0.40066561102867126,
0.0822625532746315,
-0.2406127005815506,
0.31751883029937744,
0.12671668827533722,
-0.18113361299037933,
-0.6138488054275513,
1.0117720365524292,
-0.6843825578689575,
-0.7856314778327942,
-0.2684929370880127,
-0.5605036616325378,
-0.5282372236251831,
0.10874143987894058,
0.026933703571558,
0.42671599984169006,
0.062186483293771744,
0.18651331961154938,
0.667979896068573,
0.1746288239955902,
0.1532280445098877,
0.6958913803100586,
0.34319907426834106,
-0.5832481384277344,
1.1976128816604614,
0.07402503490447998,
0.24261987209320068,
0.5293693542480469,
0.2491637021303177,
-0.46648553013801575,
-0.49596118927001953,
-0.19076550006866455,
0.2666897177696228,
-0.4962175190448761,
-0.42063626646995544,
-0.2017449587583542,
-0.3190852999687195,
-0.5908622145652771,
0.1519048511981964,
-0.7067491412162781,
-0.2799142301082611,
-0.7804229855537415,
0.28030362725257874,
0.24962864816188812,
0.32205531001091003,
-0.3409973382949829,
0.4526253938674927,
-0.4490770995616913,
0.5148512721061707,
0.33324331045150757,
0.686111569404602,
-0.5300264358520508,
-0.9834319949150085,
-0.365224152803421,
0.18390735983848572,
-0.23498773574829102,
-0.5608853101730347,
0.06720016151666641,
0.629086434841156,
0.5369399189949036,
0.3190411925315857,
0.34830042719841003,
1.2789853811264038,
-0.6212927103042603,
0.4598535895347595,
0.12981051206588745,
-1.1243444681167603,
0.848063051700592,
-0.20026274025440216,
0.4149935245513916,
0.8906671404838562,
0.27185800671577454,
-0.2501499354839325,
-0.5643432140350342,
-0.4985045790672302,
-0.5400837063789368,
0.8517982959747314,
0.044708751142024994,
0.24885743856430054,
0.10484010726213455,
0.43918392062187195,
-0.0792347863316536,
-0.09953122586011887,
-0.12357257306575775,
-0.4010952115058899,
-0.22838489711284637,
-0.5448133945465088,
-0.3146832287311554,
-0.03274378180503845,
0.03998297080397606,
-0.5114853978157043,
0.7256439328193665,
-0.5308284759521484,
0.19791485369205475,
0.4176066517829895,
0.00872999057173729,
-0.4778694808483124,
-0.04574067145586014,
0.452847421169281,
0.2864357829093933,
-0.2626281976699829,
0.06128856912255287,
0.17080754041671753,
-0.3297787308692932,
-0.12075331807136536,
0.39493849873542786,
0.022304654121398926,
-0.10885465145111084,
0.08415113389492035,
0.9280796051025391,
0.2730350196361542,
-0.4219994843006134,
0.35482266545295715,
0.05486634746193886,
-0.27325835824012756,
-0.1064721867442131,
0.4931616485118866,
-0.026051336899399757,
0.44859471917152405,
0.25754159688949585,
0.020369332283735275,
0.32184773683547974,
-0.35191458463668823,
0.290153831243515,
0.543274998664856,
-0.7581411600112915,
-0.08684594929218292,
0.6995072364807129,
-0.07484807074069977,
-0.3492686152458191,
0.5356913805007935,
0.09677141159772873,
-0.1518438458442688,
0.03871462866663933,
0.6717382669448853,
0.6291155219078064,
-0.7187015414237976,
0.19748236238956451,
0.46591874957084656,
0.03582502901554108,
-0.09312373399734497,
0.35650184750556946,
-0.3176579177379608,
-0.4444686770439148,
-0.582517683506012,
-0.7574349045753479,
-0.5592106580734253,
0.08080071210861206,
-0.7551838159561157,
0.3462972640991211,
-0.20009174942970276,
-0.10719553381204605,
0.14476898312568665,
0.15212121605873108,
-0.541797935962677,
0.5137729048728943,
0.276651531457901,
0.7483164072036743,
-0.7143498063087463,
0.9669212698936462,
0.43044111132621765,
-0.21238954365253448,
-1.1090357303619385,
-0.07480218261480331,
-0.4691707491874695,
-0.6527777314186096,
0.343067467212677,
0.05436930060386658,
-0.29376116394996643,
0.30230650305747986,
-0.3051035404205322,
-1.0836224555969238,
0.7289635539054871,
0.8268014788627625,
-0.9198552966117859,
0.19558773934841156,
0.4015486538410187,
0.6296630501747131,
-0.30216407775878906,
0.021372659131884575,
0.626259982585907,
0.2199873924255371,
0.12662163376808167,
-1.0580482482910156,
0.09524659812450409,
0.07751508057117462,
-0.21001365780830383,
-0.02926398627460003,
-0.6447139382362366,
0.4331761300563812,
0.11749769002199173,
-0.16408096253871918,
-0.2009129524230957,
0.9762805104255676,
0.032060809433460236,
0.15666097402572632,
0.6171476244926453,
0.3933541178703308,
0.6900822520256042,
-0.11673511564731598,
0.28579312562942505,
-0.6120114326477051,
0.5694886445999146,
1.4800727367401123,
-0.04215141758322716,
1.0330837965011597,
0.4591715633869171,
-0.23662154376506805,
0.2745777368545532,
0.43649160861968994,
-0.3305789530277252,
0.7231106758117676,
0.36176690459251404,
0.021235553547739983,
-0.6383196711540222,
0.028417371213436127,
-0.2234572321176529,
0.8279466032981873,
0.33208364248275757,
-0.21846066415309906,
-0.03988936170935631,
-0.14769543707370758,
-0.5357103943824768,
0.37700334191322327,
-0.37468719482421875,
1.0740175247192383,
0.12367917597293854,
-0.646425187587738,
0.7099149227142334,
-0.2723873257637024,
0.4904543459415436,
-0.6594963669776917,
-0.07731791585683823,
-0.16301502287387848,
0.09744223952293396,
-0.35157331824302673,
-0.7433621883392334,
0.3820154368877411,
-0.33552730083465576,
-0.16692940890789032,
-0.3226540684700012,
0.75030118227005,
-0.830295205116272,
-0.3539024889469147,
0.18630261719226837,
0.15302449464797974,
0.1435794234275818,
-0.5506921410560608,
-0.8005074858665466,
0.039349112659692764,
-0.12296490371227264,
0.06946146488189697,
0.36151573061943054,
0.18818728625774384,
0.3386128544807434,
0.5318285226821899,
0.6499156951904297,
0.13880655169487,
-0.15336228907108307,
0.13059182465076447,
0.8015847206115723,
-0.636626660823822,
-0.5963925719261169,
-0.6116196513175964,
0.23970308899879456,
-0.06622196733951569,
-0.30898281931877136,
0.6513814926147461,
0.5764380097389221,
0.9809706211090088,
-0.14619840681552887,
0.49898552894592285,
0.34508270025253296,
0.7152256965637207,
-0.5208126306533813,
0.6423168778419495,
-0.6836791634559631,
-0.10647685825824738,
-0.5218636989593506,
-0.727770984172821,
-0.33908066153526306,
0.8574990034103394,
-0.20846620202064514,
-0.19180046021938324,
0.49873605370521545,
0.8025878667831421,
-0.2258680909872055,
-0.020915379747748375,
0.601563572883606,
-0.1393270045518875,
0.0495857372879982,
0.23643997311592102,
0.5076377987861633,
-0.48152869939804077,
0.5255268216133118,
-0.4220741391181946,
-0.07056043297052383,
-0.1235245019197464,
-0.7513927817344666,
-0.937232255935669,
-0.7718273997306824,
-0.7371560335159302,
-0.23752255737781525,
0.31096428632736206,
0.8834967017173767,
0.8743903040885925,
-1.0402984619140625,
-0.23562933504581451,
0.15545620024204254,
-0.2034170776605606,
-0.5451292395591736,
-0.15033558011054993,
0.5464519262313843,
-0.7118805646896362,
-0.6314705610275269,
0.7702678442001343,
0.35736069083213806,
-0.18874652683734894,
-0.25357484817504883,
0.06960855424404144,
0.0706467255949974,
0.04883290454745293,
0.42014309763908386,
0.15115274488925934,
-0.6130586266517639,
-0.4286113679409027,
-0.050680793821811676,
0.002205427037551999,
0.5002956986427307,
0.5410234332084656,
-0.7553519606590271,
0.5917891263961792,
0.18829114735126495,
0.5546873807907104,
0.8676935434341431,
0.2691628336906433,
0.3288532495498657,
-0.9282277226448059,
-0.3305802345275879,
0.16915269196033478,
0.2387145608663559,
0.6020851135253906,
-0.4793854057788849,
0.3102242648601532,
0.03322604298591614,
-0.6594582796096802,
-0.4687823951244354,
0.15794304013252258,
-1.4876503944396973,
0.11287770420312881,
0.991858720779419,
-0.12278643250465393,
-0.1150059774518013,
0.04692930355668068,
-0.3247544467449188,
0.3887632489204407,
-0.637321412563324,
1.0055495500564575,
0.31271809339523315,
-0.16754338145256042,
-0.18537601828575134,
-0.1044888123869896,
0.7336224317550659,
0.5284034609794617,
-0.6149351596832275,
0.11310157924890518,
0.19774655997753143,
0.42292892932891846,
0.11564529687166214,
0.5273266434669495,
0.14969024062156677,
0.16664929687976837,
-0.2782774865627289,
-0.2824280261993408,
-0.20388075709342957,
-0.3606926202774048,
-0.25967690348625183,
0.14563608169555664,
-0.13596048951148987,
-0.2982926666736603
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06259v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06259v1
|
Editing Conceptual Knowledge for Large Language Models
| 2024-03-10T16:57:10 | 2024-03-10T16:57:10 |
Xiaohan Wang, Shengyu Mao, Ningyu Zhang, Shumin Deng, Yunzhi Yao, Yue Shen, Lei Liang, Jinjie Gu, Huajun Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DB, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
Recently, there has been a growing interest in knowledge editing for Large
Language Models (LLMs). Current approaches and evaluations merely explore the
instance-level editing, while whether LLMs possess the capability to modify
concepts remains unclear. This paper pioneers the investigation of editing
conceptual knowledge for LLMs, by constructing a novel benchmark dataset
ConceptEdit and establishing a suite of new metrics for evaluation. The
experimental results reveal that, although existing editing methods can
efficiently modify concept-level definition to some extent, they also have the
potential to distort the related instantial knowledge in LLMs, leading to poor
performance. We anticipate this can inspire further progress in better
understanding LLMs. Our project homepage is available at
https://zjunlp.github.io/project/ConceptEdit.
|
[
-0.22598665952682495,
-0.7478331923484802,
0.6194269061088562,
-0.11637431383132935,
-0.14144374430179596,
0.35024121403694153,
-0.4495157301425934,
-0.4592357575893402,
0.07717803120613098,
0.4272727370262146,
-0.33360326290130615,
-0.7558280825614929,
-0.5314869284629822,
-0.012890275567770004,
-0.6299644112586975,
0.7217202186584473,
-0.28452321887016296,
-0.079117551445961,
-0.4611991047859192,
-0.27114975452423096,
-0.544995129108429,
-0.3931698501110077,
-0.7254945635795593,
-0.25325748324394226,
0.44194167852401733,
0.3983752131462097,
0.6541650891304016,
0.7711390852928162,
0.533600926399231,
0.3282020390033722,
-0.6599014401435852,
0.2877074182033539,
-0.5937303304672241,
0.13878987729549408,
-0.5452467203140259,
-0.6190484762191772,
-0.9831830859184265,
-0.1076081246137619,
1.065226435661316,
0.8161801099777222,
-0.2053304761648178,
0.2418058216571808,
-0.06419149786233902,
0.6903101205825806,
-0.5822951197624207,
0.2391359508037567,
-1.0649493932724,
-0.11576336622238159,
-0.2656182050704956,
-0.006740286014974117,
-0.17565315961837769,
-0.05156436190009117,
0.01148893777281046,
-0.7291131019592285,
0.2674785256385803,
-0.033560268580913544,
0.5733851790428162,
0.5076017379760742,
-0.1055726483464241,
-0.21494077146053314,
-0.6554189920425415,
0.36520373821258545,
-0.8351367115974426,
0.47068557143211365,
0.02654658630490303,
0.11188554763793945,
-0.296618789434433,
-0.7135412096977234,
-0.7418406009674072,
-0.03932398557662964,
0.05156271159648895,
-0.02533739246428013,
-0.12961314618587494,
0.11314506083726883,
0.4095055162906647,
0.41875943541526794,
-0.21158839762210846,
0.4640619456768036,
-0.2409733235836029,
0.06408010423183441,
0.750032901763916,
0.3979712128639221,
0.11318175494670868,
-0.2619243264198303,
-0.04534668102860451,
0.07317303866147995,
-0.9691807627677917,
-0.20332477986812592,
0.09775912761688232,
-0.0476609505712986,
0.17270734906196594,
0.7806863784790039,
-0.4980041980743408,
0.8440710306167603,
-0.0347115695476532,
-0.05970057100057602,
0.2829580008983612,
-0.05670427903532982,
-0.2838645875453949,
0.13441410660743713,
0.4354615807533264,
0.5787578225135803,
0.19940082728862762,
-0.12702268362045288,
-0.455083429813385,
0.0077918516471982,
0.14313335716724396,
-0.8058574199676514,
-0.0010305368341505527,
0.30015847086906433,
0.03842565044760704,
-0.3519447147846222,
0.005675626453012228,
-0.45827433466911316,
-0.6215882897377014,
-0.38323530554771423,
0.35800233483314514,
-0.617602527141571,
-0.20837606489658356,
0.4384597837924957,
-0.1960776150226593,
-0.22855472564697266,
0.6541358232498169,
-0.5176341533660889,
0.196073979139328,
0.8933742642402649,
0.8152170181274414,
-0.09055234491825104,
-0.5053686499595642,
-0.22292587161064148,
0.41272833943367004,
-0.7081992626190186,
0.711858868598938,
-0.5929073691368103,
-0.4029034674167633,
-0.19480815529823303,
-0.4599235951900482,
0.025702470913529396,
-0.6747111678123474,
0.22418658435344696,
-0.9164177775382996,
-0.20524828135967255,
-0.21330030262470245,
-1.1057171821594238,
0.14686913788318634,
0.20163653790950775,
-0.6131502389907837,
1.1414237022399902,
0.18286707997322083,
-0.8377805352210999,
0.49150198698043823,
-0.8697457909584045,
-0.2392604798078537,
0.003394191851839423,
0.1297156810760498,
-0.12651503086090088,
0.33463114500045776,
0.18510913848876953,
0.5202449560165405,
-0.16739726066589355,
0.3464617431163788,
-0.29643088579177856,
-0.34947529435157776,
0.5083147287368774,
0.05520908907055855,
0.4100656509399414,
0.1800697296857834,
0.0812518447637558,
0.17915432155132294,
-1.1267508268356323,
-0.1692361831665039,
0.09480226039886475,
-0.1861032396554947,
-0.6214959025382996,
-0.12229099124670029,
-0.3848433494567871,
0.1285533457994461,
0.23489293456077576,
-0.6218241453170776,
0.36676543951034546,
-0.22001805901527405,
0.6387582421302795,
0.9568286538124084,
0.24410125613212585,
0.24587202072143555,
-0.25748902559280396,
0.4672080874443054,
0.05850199609994888,
0.035868048667907715,
0.134226992726326,
-0.10530225187540054,
-1.1021891832351685,
-0.20080432295799255,
0.7585563063621521,
0.21633288264274597,
-0.9514332413673401,
0.3133900761604309,
-0.5532457828521729,
-0.6754597425460815,
-0.5981875658035278,
0.3514344096183777,
0.1230408325791359,
0.34652379155158997,
0.28666457533836365,
-0.22434581816196442,
-0.4110129773616791,
-0.8520447611808777,
-0.40444257855415344,
-0.2295713871717453,
-0.038974154740571976,
0.08861757814884186,
0.6244418621063232,
-0.23408354818820953,
1.1251097917556763,
-0.7242250442504883,
-0.20748595893383026,
-0.09195537120103836,
0.010717658326029778,
0.07711340487003326,
0.34682539105415344,
0.4343312978744507,
-0.3150635361671448,
-0.2549670338630676,
-0.1386406421661377,
-0.6431534886360168,
-0.37878331542015076,
-0.047350965440273285,
0.033469341695308685,
-0.25355976819992065,
0.9208953380584717,
-0.767360508441925,
0.13394920527935028,
0.37921014428138733,
-0.17023669183254242,
0.6535650491714478,
-0.2500644624233246,
0.14771492779254913,
-1.012805461883545,
-0.23711217939853668,
0.09588173776865005,
-0.05270678177475929,
-0.6382550597190857,
0.40701937675476074,
0.5326979756355286,
0.30816951394081116,
-0.5605878829956055,
0.5956360101699829,
-0.3945211172103882,
-0.17093361914157867,
-0.09481734037399292,
0.36104923486709595,
-0.06067474186420441,
0.10580914467573166,
-0.021169433370232582,
0.9920601844787598,
0.35606464743614197,
-0.6059325933456421,
0.501616895198822,
0.37781429290771484,
-1.0001704692840576,
0.7756957411766052,
-0.7443063259124756,
0.30303874611854553,
-0.10619563609361649,
0.2557210922241211,
-0.6584157347679138,
-0.048375096172094345,
-0.09834251552820206,
-0.20275790989398956,
0.3493701219558716,
-0.03806280717253685,
-0.9027238488197327,
-0.12888817489147186,
-0.20616130530834198,
0.2918652296066284,
-0.006835888139903545,
-0.5868746042251587,
0.14966265857219696,
0.3362795114517212,
-0.2696019411087036,
-0.351988822221756,
-0.5488059520721436,
0.460616797208786,
-0.3727084696292877,
-0.4787077307701111,
0.6186497807502747,
-0.18881163001060486,
-0.6415271162986755,
0.04868615046143532,
0.023340925574302673,
-0.08456815034151077,
0.16639494895935059,
0.00448689516633749,
0.173549622297287,
0.013996286317706108,
0.6003993153572083,
0.1811354011297226,
0.0005483409040607512,
0.029620371758937836,
0.09071111679077148,
0.30630552768707275,
0.15652363002300262,
-0.3005235195159912,
-0.3320358693599701,
-0.22676408290863037,
0.5932150483131409,
-0.5337693095207214,
0.6257097721099854,
0.14848893880844116,
-0.4790755808353424,
-0.37379536032676697,
-0.6450303792953491,
0.1092790737748146,
-0.49277228116989136,
0.8137282133102417,
-0.8523843884468079,
-1.1287833452224731,
0.492784321308136,
-0.38039907813072205,
0.0032963918056339025,
0.5648945569992065,
0.4108417332172394,
-0.04283784702420235,
0.5922895669937134,
0.5182962417602539,
-0.0237509086728096,
0.3561376631259918,
-0.25301456451416016,
-0.11954005807638168,
-1.2799125909805298,
0.035201217979192734,
-0.5317400097846985,
-0.15928375720977783,
-0.4585430324077606,
-0.872711181640625,
0.452816367149353,
0.15831100940704346,
-0.13466905057430267,
0.12633119523525238,
0.04640865698456764,
0.5751577019691467,
0.07662773877382278,
0.21514414250850677,
0.7535344958305359,
-0.4230028986930847,
-0.20183098316192627,
-0.11658516526222229,
-0.8468641042709351,
-0.5086637139320374,
1.2819987535476685,
0.3970157206058502,
0.6528311967849731,
0.17331621050834656,
0.4918317496776581,
0.4001333713531494,
0.31704825162887573,
-0.6359781622886658,
0.6561208367347717,
0.007525471039116383,
-0.622789740562439,
-0.6004822254180908,
-0.3773884177207947,
-0.440199613571167,
0.2349867969751358,
-0.14053978025913239,
-0.5577155351638794,
0.06997428834438324,
0.03262193500995636,
-0.151554673910141,
0.5772421956062317,
-0.4461494982242584,
0.6048579216003418,
0.021801460534334183,
-0.34774157404899597,
-0.7048411965370178,
-0.06271854043006897,
0.43292880058288574,
-0.5554398894309998,
0.46633175015449524,
-0.12737470865249634,
-0.18934835493564606,
0.7795087695121765,
-0.5431775450706482,
0.6863633394241333,
-0.06340622156858444,
-0.45895203948020935,
0.09311391413211823,
0.21204771101474762,
0.5958582758903503,
0.3317826986312866,
-0.38857102394104004,
0.20635905861854553,
-0.014071020297706127,
-0.2370116412639618,
-0.8399174809455872,
0.7767824530601501,
-0.5693105459213257,
-0.6749668717384338,
-0.20077238976955414,
-0.7711701393127441,
-0.7067795991897583,
0.011637470684945583,
-0.2832217812538147,
0.23362505435943604,
-0.6619266271591187,
0.2049683779478073,
0.7401103377342224,
-0.317173033952713,
0.12295176833868027,
0.6835018992424011,
-0.2258162796497345,
-0.18303854763507843,
0.5862821936607361,
0.41113120317459106,
0.49568048119544983,
0.4652535021305084,
0.08503318578004837,
-0.12984098494052887,
-0.9124122262001038,
-0.4767254889011383,
0.08541596680879593,
-0.8662896156311035,
-0.08898182958364487,
-0.5089830160140991,
-0.22331640124320984,
-0.172507643699646,
0.06480465084314346,
-0.684885561466217,
-0.7724691033363342,
-0.09993062913417816,
-0.3223915100097656,
0.498898983001709,
0.9865129590034485,
-0.13288730382919312,
0.44687095284461975,
-0.5081861615180969,
0.261728972196579,
0.3423692584037781,
0.7770362496376038,
0.1418370008468628,
-0.6996356248855591,
-0.5845634937286377,
0.0437198244035244,
0.16293083131313324,
-0.5037081837654114,
-0.10862678289413452,
0.21981574594974518,
0.42901280522346497,
0.2732180058956146,
0.0750599130988121,
0.9395911693572998,
-0.6200212240219116,
0.5629861950874329,
-0.04490815848112106,
-1.3037083148956299,
0.5642780065536499,
-0.2086407095193863,
0.4605115056037903,
0.4140259921550751,
0.009802942164242268,
-0.9580852389335632,
-0.5004051923751831,
-0.6060488224029541,
-0.34777286648750305,
0.5180647969245911,
-0.00946337915956974,
0.1714600920677185,
0.31647637486457825,
0.6973124742507935,
0.20548373460769653,
0.3882308304309845,
-0.16660502552986145,
-0.286907821893692,
0.1071915403008461,
0.03930708393454552,
-0.38189736008644104,
-0.5747336149215698,
0.10748854279518127,
-0.7053035497665405,
0.816572904586792,
0.14545667171478271,
-0.2053857147693634,
0.012949705123901367,
-0.46381762623786926,
-0.21824583411216736,
0.5389091968536377,
0.4416569769382477,
1.2820829153060913,
-0.3583168685436249,
-0.035382095724344254,
0.5923266410827637,
-0.24328850209712982,
0.10599944740533829,
-0.04933856055140495,
-0.26576370000839233,
-0.027342990040779114,
0.4843062162399292,
0.9272491931915283,
0.31040921807289124,
-0.6031533479690552,
0.04998568072915077,
-0.0547521598637104,
-0.3697986602783203,
-0.06504498422145844,
0.4071342349052429,
0.23461000621318817,
0.21425049006938934,
0.12471460551023483,
-0.28420451283454895,
-0.14201202988624573,
-0.3771924674510956,
0.06566084176301956,
0.2516808807849884,
-0.1101873591542244,
-0.20791783928871155,
0.48873764276504517,
-0.020062413066625595,
-0.09455209970474243,
0.3013112545013428,
0.01503688097000122,
-0.5552195906639099,
0.30766043066978455,
0.18209660053253174,
0.5001140832901001,
-0.4186181128025055,
0.10632511973381042,
0.28037935495376587,
0.4777517318725586,
0.27265435457229614,
-0.2151302993297577,
0.21955451369285583,
-1.2227529287338257,
-0.4049534797668457,
-0.5267060995101929,
-0.6304017901420593,
0.512334406375885,
-0.5449846982955933,
0.3421541452407837,
-0.5510745048522949,
0.022298751398921013,
0.38997891545295715,
-0.024663424119353294,
-0.8190184235572815,
0.4579002261161804,
-0.3361310064792633,
1.0127975940704346,
-0.5290294289588928,
1.0784281492233276,
0.8974012136459351,
-0.04309321194887161,
-0.48440784215927124,
-0.05155184492468834,
-0.014889135025441647,
-0.8009357452392578,
0.4576784670352936,
-0.2734726369380951,
0.11333485692739487,
0.20682449638843536,
-0.3375047445297241,
-0.8605238199234009,
0.9571897983551025,
0.15860356390476227,
-0.9295564889907837,
0.05663776770234108,
0.5509893298149109,
0.666111171245575,
-0.248359814286232,
0.13391853868961334,
0.996639609336853,
0.5635960102081299,
0.11335500329732895,
-0.9300143718719482,
-0.054606471210718155,
-0.19315974414348602,
0.2755308747291565,
0.025955019518733025,
-0.7134636640548706,
0.6796857118606567,
-0.18159687519073486,
0.02316286601126194,
-0.06951557099819183,
0.6023172736167908,
-0.09832672029733658,
-0.08990060538053513,
0.6273784041404724,
1.0030009746551514,
0.8011327981948853,
0.06650236994028091,
0.6823325753211975,
-0.39961060881614685,
0.32170379161834717,
1.439695119857788,
-0.5248669385910034,
0.824373722076416,
0.5019827485084534,
-0.41092202067375183,
0.2188967913389206,
0.7350595593452454,
0.10793206095695496,
0.20423007011413574,
0.4868925213813782,
-0.249104842543602,
-0.19511450827121735,
0.02052345871925354,
-0.4737407863140106,
0.7597309947013855,
0.5970088243484497,
-0.1742069274187088,
-0.08417348563671112,
-0.24070696532726288,
0.19470210373401642,
0.009300642646849155,
-0.29528144001960754,
0.8415473103523254,
-0.06721653044223785,
-0.237630233168602,
0.6176291704177856,
0.4478917419910431,
0.49928003549575806,
-0.37652990221977234,
0.1335376650094986,
-0.1983860433101654,
0.1247425302863121,
-0.09154665470123291,
-0.9248560667037964,
0.16098514199256897,
0.2806091010570526,
-0.04708195850253105,
-0.041024573147296906,
0.5993958711624146,
-0.2965463399887085,
-0.541217029094696,
0.20111016929149628,
0.8592745661735535,
-0.1804434210062027,
-0.2974949777126312,
-0.6206653118133545,
0.3091786503791809,
-0.16269800066947937,
-0.3025515377521515,
0.3208327293395996,
0.7718935012817383,
0.024239426478743553,
0.6674140691757202,
0.535460352897644,
0.5456312298774719,
-0.17334255576133728,
0.2327311933040619,
0.8766164779663086,
-0.7400403022766113,
-0.4818592369556427,
-0.7731748223304749,
0.37058085203170776,
-0.23881512880325317,
-0.325067400932312,
0.757938802242279,
0.6037431955337524,
1.2452229261398315,
-0.025945404544472694,
0.927264392375946,
0.04727662727236748,
0.6932282447814941,
-0.7081011533737183,
0.9149875044822693,
-0.5401101112365723,
0.539911687374115,
-0.6154419779777527,
-1.1135387420654297,
-0.2508048713207245,
0.23441366851329803,
-0.3822428286075592,
-0.18301665782928467,
0.764574408531189,
0.8623576760292053,
0.04698066785931587,
0.1614808291196823,
0.450693279504776,
0.7308427095413208,
0.3165488839149475,
0.2227095067501068,
0.9565041065216064,
-0.1948906034231186,
-0.012157820165157318,
-0.5554743409156799,
-0.217658132314682,
0.09049693495035172,
-0.8960994482040405,
-1.0207972526550293,
-0.548002302646637,
-0.5321742296218872,
0.12924827635288239,
0.448628306388855,
0.8779987692832947,
0.37261733412742615,
-0.7004518508911133,
-0.39375922083854675,
0.13365356624126434,
0.1771126240491867,
-0.15443329513072968,
-0.15063659846782684,
0.5164016485214233,
-0.13447892665863037,
-0.7971773147583008,
0.48995906114578247,
0.12004092335700989,
-0.1447327584028244,
-0.20679078996181488,
-0.02043740637600422,
-0.23218098282814026,
-0.04922216013073921,
0.8064741492271423,
-0.30127906799316406,
-0.511589765548706,
-0.35242870450019836,
-0.6026473641395569,
0.1399570107460022,
0.08588778972625732,
0.8407003283500671,
-0.6753944754600525,
0.5155957341194153,
0.03820394352078438,
0.6870169043540955,
0.5889179706573486,
-0.16012535989284515,
0.4879760444164276,
-0.8177058100700378,
0.08678937703371048,
-0.1269485503435135,
0.553411602973938,
0.5018762946128845,
-0.19905251264572144,
0.5412883162498474,
0.37625959515571594,
-0.1921299248933792,
-0.8000072836875916,
-0.11687372624874115,
-0.6416719555854797,
-0.369759202003479,
1.2012306451797485,
0.03363361209630966,
-0.006198939401656389,
0.254899799823761,
-0.12721601128578186,
0.364829421043396,
-0.24600279331207275,
0.9219788908958435,
1.079715371131897,
0.17219480872154236,
-0.24953939020633698,
-0.7544171810150146,
0.4686085879802704,
0.34623467922210693,
-0.9511185884475708,
0.32191720604896545,
0.7642276287078857,
0.47396403551101685,
-0.3335796594619751,
0.2805010676383972,
-0.061077166348695755,
0.13634295761585236,
-0.2665734589099884,
0.207758367061615,
-0.24056078493595123,
-0.24676673114299774,
-0.2954348027706146,
-0.14578308165073395,
0.5715510249137878,
0.1835731714963913
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06249v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06249v2
|
No Language is an Island: Unifying Chinese and English in Financial Large Language Models, Instruction Data, and Benchmarks
| 2024-03-10T16:22:20 | 2024-04-16T12:05:33 |
Gang Hu, Ke Qin, Chenhan Yuan, Min Peng, Alejandro Lopez-Lira, Benyou Wang, Sophia Ananiadou, Wanlong Yu, Jimin Huang, Qianqian Xie
|
cs.CE
|
cs.CE, cs.CL
|
While the progression of Large Language Models (LLMs) has notably propelled
financial analysis, their application has largely been confined to singular
language realms, leaving untapped the potential of bilingual Chinese-English
capacity. To bridge this chasm, we introduce ICE-PIXIU, seamlessly amalgamating
the ICE-INTENT model and ICE-FLARE benchmark for bilingual financial analysis.
ICE-PIXIU uniquely integrates a spectrum of Chinese tasks, alongside translated
and original English datasets, enriching the breadth and depth of bilingual
financial modeling. It provides unrestricted access to diverse model variants,
a substantial compilation of diverse cross-lingual and multi-modal instruction
data, and an evaluation benchmark with expert annotations, comprising 10 NLP
tasks, 20 bilingual specific tasks, totaling 95k datasets. Our thorough
evaluation emphasizes the advantages of incorporating these bilingual datasets,
especially in translation tasks and utilizing original English data, enhancing
both linguistic flexibility and analytical acuity in financial contexts.
Notably, ICE-INTENT distinguishes itself by showcasing significant enhancements
over conventional LLMs and existing financial LLMs in bilingual milieus,
underscoring the profound impact of robust bilingual data on the accuracy and
efficacy of financial NLP.
|
[
0.1545959711074829,
-0.5122859477996826,
0.05218280851840973,
0.7032715678215027,
-0.07155819982290268,
0.31131666898727417,
-0.5817018747329712,
-0.36751341819763184,
0.2293976992368698,
0.5170717239379883,
-0.18049950897693634,
-0.4736223518848419,
-0.5820468664169312,
-0.15496639907360077,
-0.35039907693862915,
1.0993034839630127,
-0.09300790727138519,
0.3794780373573303,
-0.13031144440174103,
0.04802170395851135,
-0.17297892272472382,
-0.1164429560303688,
-1.1022180318832397,
-0.45152944326400757,
0.37159913778305054,
0.3549383282661438,
0.9479448199272156,
0.46196237206459045,
0.45409026741981506,
0.18253903090953827,
0.36035802960395813,
0.023174334317445755,
-0.5286946296691895,
-0.4076605439186096,
-0.007161273155361414,
-0.42314067482948303,
-0.724402904510498,
0.18176452815532684,
0.7337782979011536,
0.8773044943809509,
-0.23341470956802368,
0.02923302724957466,
0.09144827723503113,
0.601525604724884,
-0.73270183801651,
0.6902242302894592,
-0.6048692464828491,
-0.0024030208587646484,
-0.3250269889831543,
0.15119251608848572,
-0.59010249376297,
0.0664994865655899,
0.35034018754959106,
-0.6278555989265442,
-0.39834266901016235,
0.04226590692996979,
0.7785950899124146,
0.04662318900227547,
-0.8489468097686768,
-0.08684215694665909,
-0.5785948038101196,
0.9908843636512756,
-0.5688493847846985,
0.5139954090118408,
0.34025838971138,
-0.11322637647390366,
0.06750120222568512,
-0.6617280840873718,
-0.283507376909256,
-0.11805455386638641,
-0.13637693226337433,
0.2308548092842102,
-0.5551453828811646,
-0.22724668681621552,
-0.22367213666439056,
0.28372225165367126,
-0.42957332730293274,
0.4896874725818634,
-0.3978058993816376,
-0.0826522707939148,
1.1478679180145264,
0.06768155843019485,
0.664722740650177,
0.22438348829746246,
-0.2885952293872833,
-0.15048380196094513,
-0.7680834531784058,
0.24433940649032593,
0.23695585131645203,
0.6288732290267944,
-0.49609607458114624,
0.41997256875038147,
0.13148586452007294,
0.3870285451412201,
-0.09626635909080505,
-0.3763033449649811,
0.32385969161987305,
0.023403557017445564,
-0.2641357183456421,
0.2496538609266281,
0.9649369716644287,
0.32711464166641235,
0.19491104781627655,
-0.3558464050292969,
-0.3412562310695648,
-0.6791669130325317,
-0.27306893467903137,
-0.5827946066856384,
-0.22865906357765198,
0.34757938981056213,
-0.30360540747642517,
0.19551800191402435,
0.2680124342441559,
-0.5451025366783142,
-0.15084658563137054,
-0.346074640750885,
0.04294293746352196,
-0.3030311167240143,
-0.6094567179679871,
0.21332409977912903,
-0.026219792664051056,
0.6131454110145569,
0.00874285027384758,
-1.005690097808838,
0.5966705083847046,
1.3486034870147705,
0.6279879808425903,
-0.4924044907093048,
-0.6356706619262695,
-0.6887893676757812,
0.246438667178154,
-0.6075341105461121,
0.589233934879303,
-0.7111763954162598,
-0.23000271618366241,
-0.006571142468601465,
-0.03923855349421501,
-0.42388099431991577,
-0.33040544390678406,
0.2105979174375534,
-0.28413712978363037,
0.27758359909057617,
0.036358002573251724,
-0.33045804500579834,
-0.47384896874427795,
-0.07977669686079025,
-0.7658715844154358,
0.9638493657112122,
-0.024686822667717934,
-0.6210744976997375,
0.4302110970020294,
-0.8914855718612671,
-0.7726165056228638,
0.21707840263843536,
-0.08150263130664825,
-0.40498867630958557,
-0.233584463596344,
0.2306606024503708,
0.4899827539920807,
-0.7516127824783325,
0.6551681160926819,
-0.39250075817108154,
-0.15723195672035217,
0.30576014518737793,
-0.4826914072036743,
1.0152735710144043,
0.12300557643175125,
-0.4382878839969635,
-0.10470114648342133,
-0.5128777623176575,
-0.15154622495174408,
0.13913121819496155,
0.004734333138912916,
-0.6425682306289673,
0.09658830612897873,
0.30589184165000916,
-0.34783437848091125,
0.7285767197608948,
-0.4199645519256592,
0.029749225825071335,
-0.3750026226043701,
0.48168647289276123,
0.6359972953796387,
-0.6614749431610107,
0.4814930856227875,
-0.11491084843873978,
0.5492427349090576,
-0.019354287534952164,
-0.038802020251750946,
-0.4199233651161194,
-0.493889719247818,
-0.34747451543807983,
-0.6135557293891907,
0.42806321382522583,
1.0212651491165161,
-0.39315468072891235,
-0.050932906568050385,
-0.31581491231918335,
-0.6417189836502075,
-0.47132229804992676,
0.2892814576625824,
0.23155494034290314,
0.1766701191663742,
0.07755984365940094,
0.05291387066245079,
-0.23787380754947662,
-1.0618246793746948,
-0.35987111926078796,
-0.06190832331776619,
-0.17730140686035156,
0.27561917901039124,
0.3726450204849243,
-0.05766770988702774,
0.6589232683181763,
-0.34214287996292114,
-0.15546298027038574,
-0.6449637413024902,
0.26623061299324036,
0.6431714296340942,
0.43903404474258423,
1.0082855224609375,
-1.061466932296753,
-1.0880308151245117,
0.7098183631896973,
-0.6246196627616882,
-0.013614250347018242,
-0.33547696471214294,
-0.020404774695634842,
0.1398393213748932,
0.32740235328674316,
-0.5428696274757385,
0.31315135955810547,
0.6474708318710327,
-0.4069972634315491,
0.24856476485729218,
-0.20810659229755402,
0.23520635068416595,
-1.0018055438995361,
0.12091995775699615,
0.08607646077871323,
0.06974457949399948,
-0.8151475787162781,
0.1627425253391266,
0.2499772012233734,
-0.21941892802715302,
-0.3812899589538574,
0.8500616550445557,
-0.45501509308815,
0.06559086591005325,
-0.24672244489192963,
0.21142622828483582,
-0.12510138750076294,
0.32606324553489685,
0.02181927114725113,
0.7069495320320129,
1.1192331314086914,
-0.25836309790611267,
0.5810160636901855,
-0.20537099242210388,
-0.19123972952365875,
0.3978486955165863,
-0.6983030438423157,
-0.03324975445866585,
-0.041675399988889694,
-0.07873852550983429,
-0.8718172311782837,
-0.21920879185199738,
0.17451655864715576,
-0.11374242603778839,
0.49229222536087036,
0.11252489686012268,
-0.44654756784439087,
-0.10578203201293945,
-0.2211489975452423,
0.6140249371528625,
0.23216316103935242,
-0.4644492268562317,
1.0302233695983887,
0.5322012305259705,
-0.6410385966300964,
-0.8963583111763,
-0.7608957886695862,
0.21547666192054749,
-0.35292771458625793,
-0.7251414060592651,
0.3796546459197998,
-0.0035134137142449617,
-0.7318032383918762,
0.03552120923995972,
0.22048905491828918,
-0.4209076762199402,
0.24377331137657166,
-0.12109503149986267,
0.8691474795341492,
-0.5984953045845032,
0.05513701215386391,
0.06547249108552933,
-0.09531261026859283,
-0.013088913634419441,
-0.46766138076782227,
0.31097540259361267,
-0.1847253292798996,
-0.19007550179958344,
-0.39545080065727234,
0.3147490918636322,
0.6656112670898438,
-0.5758447647094727,
0.9048260450363159,
0.3310915231704712,
-0.46146222949028015,
-0.020038247108459473,
-0.48993614315986633,
0.3633885681629181,
-0.4394111931324005,
0.2084103375673294,
-0.37876805663108826,
-0.8637101054191589,
0.6837243437767029,
0.29177019000053406,
0.597342848777771,
0.5728873610496521,
0.4512021541595459,
0.1994180679321289,
0.7412354350090027,
0.7951251864433289,
-0.5698680877685547,
0.2931443750858307,
0.10707473754882812,
0.5762357711791992,
-0.2720623016357422,
-0.1949625164270401,
-0.3795757293701172,
-0.3279789090156555,
-0.3924151360988617,
-0.2690328359603882,
0.2144576758146286,
-0.2172991782426834,
-0.16545404493808746,
0.322473406791687,
0.1559189110994339,
0.5854824781417847,
0.33639153838157654,
-0.20843954384326935,
0.17680129408836365,
-0.048485856503248215,
0.046948593109846115,
-0.2599831223487854,
-0.5854877829551697,
-0.2227669507265091,
1.5397593975067139,
0.412840873003006,
0.6258594393730164,
-0.12568126618862152,
0.325501024723053,
0.21995823085308075,
0.49504727125167847,
-0.5913206338882446,
0.18659409880638123,
-0.6969369649887085,
-0.33803099393844604,
-0.3918094038963318,
-0.6477886438369751,
-0.9956521987915039,
0.2337588667869568,
-0.06945287436246872,
-0.7783997058868408,
-0.0819263905286789,
-0.11750121414661407,
-0.5174602270126343,
0.5399237275123596,
-0.8270363211631775,
0.9959911704063416,
-0.7250289916992188,
-0.32138603925704956,
-0.2899632453918457,
0.10371498018503189,
0.6626985669136047,
-0.48559051752090454,
0.6842987537384033,
-0.380132257938385,
-0.33247143030166626,
0.591191828250885,
-0.2210720330476761,
0.8355145454406738,
0.18236497044563293,
-0.391577810049057,
0.09993987530469894,
-0.04187099263072014,
0.3497717082500458,
0.197485089302063,
-0.2486356645822525,
0.39774975180625916,
-0.0674152821302414,
-0.6457934975624084,
-0.4157155156135559,
0.9235696196556091,
-0.7146755456924438,
-0.6347160339355469,
-0.3321506083011627,
-0.8945152163505554,
0.061822567135095596,
0.32846423983573914,
-0.1733846217393875,
0.05505938455462456,
-0.159598246216774,
0.24031595885753632,
0.43829649686813354,
-0.20274439454078674,
0.4951854944229126,
0.8726217150688171,
-0.35043659806251526,
-0.46569907665252686,
1.0516011714935303,
-0.007453996688127518,
-0.009940003976225853,
0.6776455640792847,
0.18114608526229858,
-0.04522576928138733,
-0.16323284804821014,
-0.05830950662493706,
0.5438668131828308,
-0.32728129625320435,
0.05054371803998947,
-0.387373149394989,
-0.12406009435653687,
-0.7052403092384338,
-0.27790290117263794,
-0.842072606086731,
-0.16470064222812653,
-0.1413482278585434,
-0.265047162771225,
0.26923686265945435,
0.5101848244667053,
-0.3732839524745941,
0.10975733399391174,
-0.7204784154891968,
0.2935669422149658,
0.23525121808052063,
0.3889237344264984,
0.04245050996541977,
-0.30306488275527954,
-0.4851614534854889,
0.31671378016471863,
0.07867752760648727,
-0.45710310339927673,
0.4942237436771393,
0.31131842732429504,
0.6757850050926208,
0.7953689098358154,
0.029246313497424126,
0.7271555066108704,
-0.22706395387649536,
0.7000293731689453,
0.34328049421310425,
-1.1848541498184204,
0.33775562047958374,
-0.23009686172008514,
0.28847536444664,
0.19721952080726624,
0.7239843606948853,
-0.8923161625862122,
-0.4906049370765686,
-0.36586907505989075,
-1.1203516721725464,
0.7704282999038696,
-0.1140715628862381,
0.23221153020858765,
0.06185828894376755,
0.16252562403678894,
0.35819011926651,
0.22714544832706451,
-1.188264012336731,
-0.30845317244529724,
-0.10391531139612198,
0.0991952046751976,
-0.2726019024848938,
-0.019400516524910927,
-0.12321294844150543,
-0.27468863129615784,
0.7880030870437622,
-0.15462344884872437,
-0.325748085975647,
-0.21146556735038757,
0.09096959978342056,
-0.058402057737112045,
-0.12497313320636749,
0.26295042037963867,
0.8483800888061523,
0.16164585947990417,
-0.1416376233100891,
0.21584460139274597,
-0.3954547643661499,
-0.3849489688873291,
0.23940959572792053,
-0.22216565907001495,
0.032241154462099075,
0.6299894452095032,
0.5900833606719971,
0.5757602453231812,
-1.1800141334533691,
0.4436276853084564,
-0.18368946015834808,
-0.08221007883548737,
-0.6526094079017639,
-0.13889731466770172,
0.1979255974292755,
0.22714954614639282,
0.6814898252487183,
-0.31475940346717834,
-0.006368648260831833,
-0.6956527233123779,
0.219491109251976,
0.5098834037780762,
-0.3764479458332062,
-0.3377908170223236,
0.8579632043838501,
0.1966053694486618,
-0.031904593110084534,
0.9864029288291931,
-0.05322764813899994,
-0.4030476212501526,
0.6766186356544495,
0.35177087783813477,
1.1730865240097046,
-0.37055861949920654,
0.2716763913631439,
0.3422252833843231,
0.5385923981666565,
-0.041682809591293335,
0.3331429064273834,
0.1461571305990219,
-0.7837509512901306,
-0.5697675943374634,
-0.29922422766685486,
-0.3468150496482849,
0.07373759895563126,
-0.6793431639671326,
0.5282891988754272,
-0.474075049161911,
0.27306029200553894,
0.016258610412478447,
-0.215498149394989,
-0.48977193236351013,
0.0018321805400773883,
0.5069772005081177,
1.048090934753418,
-0.854729175567627,
0.6643866896629333,
0.7038736343383789,
-0.03120258077979088,
-0.7298259139060974,
-0.16420871019363403,
0.029945673421025276,
-0.8780456185340881,
0.7486467957496643,
0.05572207644581795,
0.060392722487449646,
-0.4829859137535095,
-0.5068678855895996,
-0.8883930444717407,
1.1630150079727173,
0.6064807772636414,
-0.4216712415218353,
0.10498972237110138,
0.6514540314674377,
0.2998709976673126,
-0.7378038167953491,
0.31643083691596985,
0.7680507302284241,
0.726466715335846,
-0.022400420159101486,
-1.2470488548278809,
-0.4156743288040161,
-0.5048813223838806,
-0.4052848517894745,
0.18082812428474426,
-1.0319032669067383,
0.9827974438667297,
-0.21152779459953308,
-0.28931328654289246,
-0.29307228326797485,
0.9047956466674805,
0.015918686985969543,
0.6921608448028564,
0.37047696113586426,
0.399828165769577,
0.7890810370445251,
-0.35343825817108154,
0.9891484975814819,
-0.7988148927688599,
0.18895651400089264,
0.9734076261520386,
-0.46893075108528137,
1.1290479898452759,
0.33071136474609375,
-0.20636019110679626,
0.34367844462394714,
0.5617959499359131,
-0.04417487233877182,
0.09400677680969238,
-0.1392255276441574,
-0.33639535307884216,
-0.3677464723587036,
-0.24288378655910492,
-0.04131075367331505,
0.6409151554107666,
0.3787596821784973,
0.10151359438896179,
-0.03569387272000313,
0.019092969596385956,
0.5628941655158997,
0.16254901885986328,
-0.5156120657920837,
0.41953524947166443,
0.28635409474372864,
-0.7345731854438782,
0.11925823241472244,
0.18283212184906006,
0.6489056348800659,
-0.9310334920883179,
0.3185286223888397,
-0.5353134870529175,
-0.022364335134625435,
-0.15999667346477509,
-0.7274481654167175,
0.27441757917404175,
0.13404980301856995,
0.09911612421274185,
-0.37248846888542175,
0.17251066863536835,
-0.6483564376831055,
-0.8943703770637512,
0.5482538938522339,
0.13436444103717804,
0.13519108295440674,
0.010292225517332554,
-0.6066251397132874,
-0.15828032791614532,
0.19345811009407043,
-0.052731044590473175,
0.22253410518169403,
0.6770154237747192,
0.14256493747234344,
0.8745061755180359,
0.669278085231781,
0.06410601735115051,
-0.10412072390317917,
-0.23290753364562988,
0.5338993668556213,
-0.6247212886810303,
-0.6121749877929688,
-0.8399726748466492,
0.6175398826599121,
0.13301946222782135,
-0.4456944763660431,
0.6219380497932434,
1.1473323106765747,
1.0621731281280518,
-0.07257400453090668,
0.8486311435699463,
0.1474744826555252,
0.1759364753961563,
-0.4415082037448883,
0.6735734939575195,
-0.7743488550186157,
0.4621851444244385,
-0.1800110638141632,
-0.875392496585846,
-0.36066576838493347,
0.15399646759033203,
-0.6015811562538147,
-0.338039755821228,
0.5645933151245117,
0.4117286801338196,
-0.3378853499889374,
0.044799141585826874,
0.4229755103588104,
0.28408342599868774,
0.042908914387226105,
0.6814697980880737,
0.38448387384414673,
-0.414098858833313,
0.5828509330749512,
-0.31804728507995605,
-0.32419222593307495,
-0.030846908688545227,
-0.9074049592018127,
-0.9914532899856567,
-0.4674283266067505,
-0.7037278413772583,
0.29032137989997864,
-0.38204053044319153,
0.9503126740455627,
0.38611263036727905,
-0.8926170468330383,
-1.1528211832046509,
0.5704911947250366,
0.2870855927467346,
-0.3870179355144501,
-0.26533305644989014,
0.4131220281124115,
-0.2502461373806,
-1.1715939044952393,
0.5226561427116394,
0.8412810564041138,
-0.0015703607350587845,
-0.2737017571926117,
-0.2498122900724411,
0.050785861909389496,
0.2101864069700241,
0.4987466335296631,
0.4633142948150635,
-0.5470287799835205,
0.22286978363990784,
0.20739826560020447,
-0.025160424411296844,
-0.047952380031347275,
0.9122827053070068,
-0.049603089690208435,
0.22260616719722748,
0.28406596183776855,
0.7993609309196472,
0.38744544982910156,
-0.5419781804084778,
1.0220402479171753,
-0.190288707613945,
0.34183576703071594,
-0.060468144714832306,
0.6486189365386963,
-0.03154011815786362,
-0.4250217080116272,
0.4170241355895996,
-0.0396016463637352,
-0.18963947892189026,
-0.6612096428871155,
-0.2017495483160019,
-0.7908849716186523,
-0.4076939523220062,
0.8259009718894958,
-0.624613344669342,
-0.43412870168685913,
0.19143828749656677,
0.06205467879772186,
-0.3011360168457031,
-0.4463593065738678,
0.6987990736961365,
0.9942959547042847,
0.15903036296367645,
-0.40715864300727844,
-0.46503010392189026,
0.09824766218662262,
0.43465688824653625,
-0.5371105670928955,
0.24966037273406982,
0.09994623064994812,
0.029626594856381416,
0.07649669796228409,
0.4387610852718353,
0.07074765861034393,
0.5427057147026062,
0.07763653993606567,
-0.05447385832667351,
0.18030661344528198,
-0.29417353868484497,
0.030164580792188644,
0.13576050102710724,
-0.10759104043245316,
0.3329738676548004
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06221v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06221v1
|
TRAD: Enhancing LLM Agents with Step-Wise Thought Retrieval and Aligned Decision
| 2024-03-10T13:58:38 | 2024-03-10T13:58:38 |
Ruiwen Zhou, Yingxuan Yang, Muning Wen, Ying Wen, Wenhao Wang, Chunling Xi, Guoqiang Xu, Yong Yu, Weinan Zhang
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Numerous large language model (LLM) agents have been built for different
tasks like web navigation and online shopping due to LLM's wide knowledge and
text-understanding ability. Among these works, many of them utilize in-context
examples to achieve generalization without the need for fine-tuning, while few
of them have considered the problem of how to select and effectively utilize
these examples. Recently, methods based on trajectory-level retrieval with task
meta-data and using trajectories as in-context examples have been proposed to
improve the agent's overall performance in some sequential decision making
tasks. However, these methods can be problematic due to plausible examples
retrieved without task-specific state transition dynamics and long input with
plenty of irrelevant context. In this paper, we propose a novel framework
(TRAD) to address these issues. TRAD first conducts Thought Retrieval,
achieving step-level demonstration selection via thought matching, leading to
more helpful demonstrations and less irrelevant input noise. Then, TRAD
introduces Aligned Decision, complementing retrieved demonstration steps with
their previous or subsequent steps, which enables tolerance for imperfect
thought and provides a choice for balance between more context and less noise.
Extensive experiments on ALFWorld and Mind2Web benchmarks show that TRAD not
only outperforms state-of-the-art models but also effectively helps in reducing
noise and promoting generalization. Furthermore, TRAD has been deployed in
real-world scenarios of a global business insurance company and improves the
success rate of robotic process automation.
|
[
-0.16924013197422028,
-0.8767738342285156,
0.8073723912239075,
-0.055259138345718384,
-0.3922783136367798,
0.2743750214576721,
0.04992836341261864,
-0.45213279128074646,
0.17547152936458588,
0.5042508840560913,
-0.5972875952720642,
-0.6714974045753479,
-0.13577963411808014,
-0.21965175867080688,
-0.23706378042697906,
0.9252010583877563,
-0.16163837909698486,
-0.29827892780303955,
-0.34390148520469666,
-0.1725630760192871,
-0.5249376893043518,
-0.0010095251491293311,
-0.9664070010185242,
-0.6823399662971497,
0.13461542129516602,
0.2957667410373688,
0.7568164467811584,
0.4171757102012634,
0.5771713256835938,
0.2835657298564911,
0.0849902480840683,
0.3865482807159424,
-0.2957819402217865,
0.41050705313682556,
-0.45224884152412415,
-0.2057131677865982,
-0.8175857067108154,
-0.07654453068971634,
0.35812968015670776,
0.30065929889678955,
-0.33826160430908203,
0.12892505526542664,
-0.07669726759195328,
0.5949094295501709,
-0.6775224804878235,
0.07363138347864151,
-0.2829033136367798,
0.14101563394069672,
0.22869190573692322,
-0.2862250804901123,
-0.4816268980503082,
-0.3264193832874298,
0.32199913263320923,
-0.746491551399231,
-0.1022808775305748,
-0.10632715374231339,
0.5817390084266663,
0.4051940143108368,
-0.5463964343070984,
-0.3740173578262329,
-0.8792852163314819,
0.6226447224617004,
-0.6000465154647827,
0.3270834982395172,
0.13691803812980652,
0.3825228214263916,
-0.28945639729499817,
-0.8286920189857483,
-0.6236343383789062,
-0.09901069104671478,
0.027530016377568245,
0.23189377784729004,
-0.04289444535970688,
0.317078173160553,
0.2480531483888626,
-0.10735976696014404,
-0.5331243276596069,
-0.04888250306248665,
0.1608215570449829,
-0.30536824464797974,
0.47404831647872925,
0.06825654208660126,
0.07806971669197083,
0.12385675311088562,
-0.4777272939682007,
-0.35997191071510315,
-0.5798822045326233,
0.043931879103183746,
0.03434578701853752,
0.23815873265266418,
0.17355124652385712,
0.37019822001457214,
-0.40015798807144165,
0.8051331639289856,
0.2222449779510498,
-0.44405463337898254,
0.4524680972099304,
-0.2585906982421875,
-0.4700547456741333,
-0.0798165425658226,
0.4966980516910553,
0.39028021693229675,
0.0352531336247921,
-0.0966600701212883,
-0.4389297664165497,
-0.05217767879366875,
0.36922982335090637,
-0.6566388607025146,
0.2556562125682831,
0.3252570927143097,
-0.26977604627609253,
-0.2178173065185547,
-0.04254789277911186,
-0.7641858458518982,
-0.34722700715065,
-0.17389127612113953,
0.6764395833015442,
-0.3874686360359192,
-0.16091248393058777,
0.2463971972465515,
-0.015505461022257805,
0.4804657995700836,
0.5554000735282898,
-0.2427000254392624,
0.14591996371746063,
0.8260822892189026,
0.7916120290756226,
-0.34780353307724,
-0.0641784816980362,
-0.6455596089363098,
0.3695560693740845,
-0.35570019483566284,
0.7288007140159607,
-0.7105944752693176,
-0.16713587939739227,
0.11159233748912811,
-0.33031409978866577,
-0.0457865446805954,
-0.536851167678833,
0.5022340416908264,
-0.8996949195861816,
0.19918259978294373,
-0.03941302001476288,
-0.2975015342235565,
-0.39461749792099,
0.5982813835144043,
-0.5085340738296509,
0.8993832468986511,
-0.019557667896151543,
-0.37436020374298096,
0.6159108281135559,
-0.8509034514427185,
-0.5290670990943909,
0.07160598784685135,
-0.2202683389186859,
-0.3743354380130768,
-0.26143765449523926,
0.1606048047542572,
0.45302489399909973,
0.01839076168835163,
0.21316689252853394,
-0.09373234957456589,
-0.4184820353984833,
-0.07524015754461288,
-0.0957183688879013,
0.49253636598587036,
0.22703830897808075,
-0.3685547709465027,
0.34354168176651,
-0.6001010537147522,
0.14870671927928925,
-0.20620986819267273,
-0.1435750275850296,
-0.5993545055389404,
-0.047011733055114746,
-0.38452741503715515,
0.5868908762931824,
0.12354661524295807,
-0.3516922891139984,
0.2553294897079468,
-0.326829195022583,
0.08708562701940536,
0.7455012798309326,
0.29732412099838257,
0.49586939811706543,
-0.5526139736175537,
0.8370161652565002,
0.2544715404510498,
-0.016131367534399033,
0.21890686452388763,
-0.11694428324699402,
-0.7228679656982422,
-0.4119904339313507,
0.09105845540761948,
0.4932279884815216,
-1.108690857887268,
0.3581583797931671,
-0.34450265765190125,
-0.1745905727148056,
-0.6356162428855896,
0.04297815263271332,
0.2720361053943634,
0.8171244263648987,
0.24989579617977142,
-0.212823286652565,
-0.40168440341949463,
-0.7484152913093567,
-0.09537063539028168,
-0.18833820521831512,
0.15592284500598907,
0.09253735095262527,
0.5034626722335815,
-0.5629273653030396,
1.063037395477295,
-0.3538358807563782,
-0.3778159022331238,
-0.47916853427886963,
0.1543499082326889,
0.18856696784496307,
0.25977233052253723,
0.027592308819293976,
-0.8041831254959106,
-0.26476261019706726,
0.024345632642507553,
-0.6287052035331726,
0.1251372992992401,
-0.3840591311454773,
-0.5210346579551697,
0.1883658766746521,
0.38964444398880005,
-0.9423097968101501,
0.53626549243927,
-0.05352110415697098,
-0.3402045667171478,
0.20529334247112274,
-0.37892261147499084,
0.039552487432956696,
-1.2283269166946411,
-0.11237335205078125,
-0.0012390813790261745,
-0.6923792362213135,
-0.6590985059738159,
0.28753674030303955,
0.05653251335024834,
0.27832332253456116,
-0.5229483842849731,
0.4376753568649292,
-0.3375083804130554,
-0.2709349989891052,
-0.4587920904159546,
0.5070431232452393,
-0.09367469698190689,
0.5274373888969421,
0.10564005374908447,
0.9136353731155396,
0.41446104645729065,
-0.9821491241455078,
0.018523721024394035,
0.36114221811294556,
-0.34797999262809753,
0.6051390767097473,
-0.3431423008441925,
0.4066210985183716,
-0.2670833170413971,
0.5420821905136108,
-0.5220725536346436,
0.1508100926876068,
0.35367250442504883,
0.03470764681696892,
0.13767318427562714,
0.29116982221603394,
-0.4197552502155304,
-0.2573038637638092,
-0.3937717378139496,
0.46283963322639465,
0.5019834041595459,
-0.40750759840011597,
0.9515200257301331,
0.3718191981315613,
0.19731539487838745,
-0.9002271294593811,
-0.2979266941547394,
-0.06699032336473465,
-0.3605312407016754,
-0.3255476653575897,
0.40457770228385925,
-0.155898317694664,
-0.4334375560283661,
-0.0567060224711895,
-0.4009484052658081,
0.2292623072862625,
-0.05689605697989464,
0.06335616856813431,
0.2500799596309662,
0.09561663120985031,
0.3055107295513153,
-0.06262746453285217,
0.0895417109131813,
-0.018081001937389374,
-0.5069025754928589,
0.4243653118610382,
-0.04088602587580681,
-0.37735429406166077,
-0.2676442861557007,
0.04634656012058258,
0.5439940094947815,
-0.25582149624824524,
0.37222525477409363,
0.4748985767364502,
-0.35590660572052,
-0.6851028800010681,
-0.433808833360672,
-0.03789941221475601,
-0.50382399559021,
0.48216015100479126,
-0.4353024959564209,
-0.702211320400238,
0.30779245495796204,
-0.35856369137763977,
0.19486229121685028,
0.060009412467479706,
0.5805023312568665,
-0.3026672899723053,
0.714546799659729,
0.6144881248474121,
-0.04809792712330818,
0.5405119061470032,
-0.40082281827926636,
0.25490379333496094,
-0.9186108708381653,
-0.279215008020401,
-0.03102484904229641,
-0.4584228992462158,
-0.5109549760818481,
-0.691394567489624,
0.41288572549819946,
-0.3045026957988739,
-0.2654080390930176,
0.23532938957214355,
-0.2766190469264984,
0.38647058606147766,
0.33571651577949524,
0.39356428384780884,
0.39221712946891785,
-0.24310870468616486,
-0.503020167350769,
0.34570425748825073,
-0.4378773868083954,
-0.6249005198478699,
1.0899335145950317,
0.000284426670987159,
0.6969833374023438,
0.20652994513511658,
0.7717326283454895,
0.7014156579971313,
0.13819940388202667,
-0.8156384825706482,
1.0264406204223633,
0.3207134008407593,
-0.34853628277778625,
-0.3600035011768341,
-0.12252198904752731,
-1.0859687328338623,
0.4869871437549591,
-0.03045768104493618,
-0.6869736313819885,
0.14692199230194092,
0.09652535617351532,
-0.45828181505203247,
0.06902793049812317,
-0.24385841190814972,
0.5405662059783936,
-0.2026805430650711,
-0.4556419253349304,
-0.6508775949478149,
-0.6819301843643188,
0.2398352026939392,
-0.08457666635513306,
0.13924093544483185,
0.05750701203942299,
-0.23094691336154938,
0.7121273279190063,
-0.32320931553840637,
0.5932901501655579,
-0.19314713776111603,
-0.22955600917339325,
0.5773180723190308,
0.20996960997581482,
0.9328868985176086,
-0.3266277015209198,
-0.1234339028596878,
-0.432584673166275,
-0.28220632672309875,
-0.07651283591985703,
-0.8932479023933411,
0.5617132186889648,
-0.4451214075088501,
-0.8075393438339233,
-0.3976690471172333,
-0.888970673084259,
-0.5461676120758057,
0.23071973025798798,
-0.29189422726631165,
0.29454663395881653,
-0.11998870223760605,
0.025614837184548378,
0.6978013515472412,
0.07193852216005325,
0.6603906750679016,
0.6906247735023499,
-0.18043749034404755,
-0.21985282003879547,
0.6370691061019897,
-0.2417171150445938,
0.3273579776287079,
0.7297301888465881,
-0.09960462152957916,
-0.5885658860206604,
-0.39958468079566956,
-0.045241620391607285,
0.23087142407894135,
-0.9103404879570007,
-0.2728191316127777,
-0.5048015117645264,
0.05365594103932381,
-0.3213861286640167,
0.11052651703357697,
0.03882937133312225,
-0.3968373239040375,
-0.13248370587825775,
-0.5930330753326416,
-0.03796480596065521,
0.6973371505737305,
0.09291644394397736,
0.2826923727989197,
-0.2762599587440491,
0.5252220630645752,
0.36724045872688293,
0.17946720123291016,
0.14154066145420074,
-0.27365025877952576,
-0.30395954847335815,
-0.01734156906604767,
-0.6641950011253357,
-0.6770105361938477,
0.3032407760620117,
0.08288408815860748,
0.6039067506790161,
0.5115717649459839,
0.2942736744880676,
0.9548068642616272,
-0.3267322778701782,
0.292420357465744,
-0.24326428771018982,
-0.8618578314781189,
0.7070440649986267,
-0.10130937397480011,
0.15718521177768707,
0.5857941508293152,
0.1902436912059784,
-0.3352971076965332,
-0.5506982803344727,
-0.5845662951469421,
-0.8139883279800415,
0.6444658637046814,
0.15052396059036255,
-0.2754226326942444,
0.20141418278217316,
0.24480487406253815,
0.06832794100046158,
0.37767472863197327,
-0.6204187273979187,
-0.09513481706380844,
0.2074902206659317,
-0.41002756357192993,
0.055995650589466095,
0.1166243851184845,
-0.1398007571697235,
-0.15366379916667938,
0.7618818283081055,
-0.18198229372501373,
0.2668568789958954,
0.3304193317890167,
-0.4914720356464386,
-0.1366785615682602,
0.3167426884174347,
0.6684239506721497,
0.8276700973510742,
-0.2548651397228241,
0.06503921002149582,
0.13217562437057495,
-0.4084584414958954,
0.4630695879459381,
-0.09155087172985077,
-0.45515745878219604,
-0.15598855912685394,
0.27521586418151855,
0.6837859153747559,
-0.048531219363212585,
-0.8758776187896729,
0.35069936513900757,
0.2161748707294464,
0.018652452155947685,
-0.2649799585342407,
0.33678561449050903,
-0.15761663019657135,
0.6785938143730164,
0.3270086348056793,
0.11140980571508408,
0.28564155101776123,
-0.6128926277160645,
0.5112698078155518,
0.6979494690895081,
-0.3601939380168915,
-0.1355319768190384,
0.416104793548584,
0.22855764627456665,
-0.5211743712425232,
0.5232265591621399,
-0.4465924799442291,
-0.4378066956996918,
0.5388826727867126,
0.6654770970344543,
1.137909173965454,
0.10296445339918137,
0.5123958587646484,
-0.01017081644386053,
0.19253595173358917,
-0.21619662642478943,
0.4204455614089966,
-0.2724960744380951,
-0.9072585105895996,
-0.40567833185195923,
-0.35034236311912537,
-0.486751526594162,
0.053900960832834244,
-0.5676530003547668,
0.16527798771858215,
-0.3226734697818756,
-0.45184484124183655,
-0.6709725856781006,
0.15511153638362885,
-0.7719041109085083,
0.29433712363243103,
0.0663985162973404,
0.9645764231681824,
-0.5275888442993164,
1.0127384662628174,
0.8769791722297668,
-0.15183193981647491,
-0.6119270920753479,
0.5042838454246521,
-0.13202857971191406,
-0.7702264785766602,
0.4578173756599426,
0.14492595195770264,
-0.5425133109092712,
0.005395492073148489,
-0.27241143584251404,
-0.7107788324356079,
1.5052136182785034,
0.3622448146343231,
-0.41919243335723877,
-0.10264673084020615,
-0.04716310650110245,
0.7183882594108582,
-0.6505153179168701,
0.37565356492996216,
0.631049394607544,
0.4497579336166382,
0.4307832717895508,
-0.5521159172058105,
0.30989396572113037,
0.03380458429455757,
-0.15770824253559113,
0.22664110362529755,
-0.8036110997200012,
0.4696664810180664,
-0.4625655710697174,
-0.23131392896175385,
-0.20499534904956818,
0.8036021590232849,
0.5712282061576843,
0.6316712498664856,
0.7431910634040833,
0.7381880283355713,
0.8965922594070435,
0.23744632303714752,
0.8280000686645508,
-0.038932424038648605,
0.1377505213022232,
1.2196422815322876,
-0.7212156653404236,
0.8134475946426392,
0.39003807306289673,
0.0675363838672638,
0.8626715540885925,
0.5227242708206177,
0.4619251787662506,
0.8585583567619324,
-0.11374180763959885,
-0.27555230259895325,
-0.3798615038394928,
-0.126081183552742,
0.08449289202690125,
0.3860875070095062,
0.3298596143722534,
-0.06411082297563553,
-0.24310754239559174,
0.08712466061115265,
-0.23631906509399414,
-0.07670091092586517,
-0.3615971505641937,
0.86025470495224,
-0.0028243153356015682,
-0.9177938103675842,
0.23937931656837463,
-0.21201983094215393,
0.4316980540752411,
-0.5543327927589417,
-0.241557776927948,
-0.18581008911132812,
0.34612101316452026,
0.025969596579670906,
-0.6736078262329102,
0.02416098304092884,
-0.25655776262283325,
0.0900532454252243,
-0.48301321268081665,
0.693271279335022,
-0.4545506238937378,
-0.31624072790145874,
0.35800573229789734,
0.6375885009765625,
0.03396202251315117,
0.22374118864536285,
-0.6114949584007263,
-0.342960923910141,
0.0010926909744739532,
-0.1499086171388626,
0.14394158124923706,
0.5174923539161682,
-0.41626864671707153,
1.1818023920059204,
0.2694033682346344,
0.20512402057647705,
-0.40162643790245056,
0.09323194622993469,
0.6135484576225281,
-0.7957514524459839,
-0.5465346574783325,
-0.7698137760162354,
0.4016936123371124,
-0.10252172499895096,
0.025831177830696106,
0.49298781156539917,
0.49163779616355896,
0.7124372124671936,
0.09679634124040604,
0.5953541994094849,
0.05612938478589058,
0.426056444644928,
-0.5191723704338074,
0.4072204828262329,
-0.4550855755805969,
0.4032960832118988,
-0.3700758218765259,
-0.8166773915290833,
-0.12936216592788696,
0.6159292459487915,
-0.25485917925834656,
0.2124946564435959,
0.8494454026222229,
0.7629852294921875,
0.07447738200426102,
-0.25091874599456787,
0.35920098423957825,
0.2049955129623413,
0.48602086305618286,
0.6469413042068481,
0.7222285270690918,
-0.24298247694969177,
0.5516143441200256,
0.0515117421746254,
-0.004524643998593092,
-0.09831133484840393,
-0.8210004568099976,
-0.8698955774307251,
-0.42979177832603455,
-0.5014154314994812,
-0.15665990114212036,
0.17140990495681763,
1.2519649267196655,
0.6731782555580139,
-0.6716161370277405,
-0.3344098925590515,
-0.09931617975234985,
0.5089888572692871,
-0.5249738097190857,
-0.20230962336063385,
0.33114901185035706,
-0.3542840778827667,
-0.5877074003219604,
0.41194039583206177,
0.3044009208679199,
0.13108409941196442,
-0.011474053375422955,
-0.2555977702140808,
-0.35335731506347656,
0.21549080312252045,
0.6735654473304749,
-0.02950119972229004,
-0.5901104211807251,
-0.4007037878036499,
-0.2629220187664032,
-0.12651892006397247,
0.15752729773521423,
0.6976024508476257,
-1.2450443506240845,
0.3642432987689972,
0.3248438835144043,
0.6787551641464233,
0.5284546613693237,
0.4239649176597595,
0.6596792936325073,
-0.6659159660339355,
0.1856321096420288,
0.45317453145980835,
0.29443708062171936,
0.08295302093029022,
-0.407383531332016,
0.6098930239677429,
-0.11462246626615524,
-0.42844676971435547,
-0.5081714391708374,
0.1988907754421234,
-1.0280250310897827,
-0.08689769357442856,
1.1160811185836792,
0.06580150872468948,
-0.08767474442720413,
-0.043847955763339996,
-0.12724725902080536,
0.3313030004501343,
-0.7329664826393127,
0.7431839108467102,
0.611129105091095,
-0.4322698414325714,
-0.09063133597373962,
-0.4855796694755554,
0.4380740225315094,
0.3667982816696167,
-0.9154645800590515,
-0.1665937602519989,
0.5246991515159607,
-0.007602199912071228,
0.011263296008110046,
0.7387016415596008,
0.3530757427215576,
0.1553831249475479,
-0.58673495054245,
-0.1500021368265152,
-0.019284619018435478,
-0.5064620971679688,
-0.250114381313324,
0.14695769548416138,
0.012693452648818493,
-0.5122836828231812
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06208v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06208v1
|
Personalized LoRA for Human-Centered Text Understanding
| 2024-03-10T13:04:54 | 2024-03-10T13:04:54 |
You Zhang, Jin Wang, Liang-Chih Yu, Dan Xu, Xuejie Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Effectively and efficiently adapting a pre-trained language model (PLM) for
human-centered text understanding (HCTU) is challenging since user tokens are
million-level in most personalized applications and do not have concrete
explicit semantics. A standard and parameter-efficient approach (e.g., LoRA)
necessitates memorizing numerous suits of adapters for each user. In this work,
we introduce a personalized LoRA (PLoRA) with a plug-and-play (PnP) framework
for the HCTU task. PLoRA is effective, parameter-efficient, and dynamically
deploying in PLMs. Moreover, a personalized dropout and a mutual information
maximizing strategies are adopted and hence the proposed PLoRA can be well
adapted to few/zero-shot learning scenarios for the cold-start issue.
Experiments conducted on four benchmark datasets show that the proposed method
outperforms existing methods in full/few/zero-shot learning scenarios for the
HCTU task, even though it has fewer trainable parameters. For reproducibility,
the code for this paper is available at: https://github.com/yoyo-yun/PLoRA.
|
[
-0.3384734094142914,
-0.8259309530258179,
0.49001607298851013,
0.20406277477741241,
-0.48386862874031067,
0.17320597171783447,
-0.49737268686294556,
-0.1028541699051857,
0.0856996402144432,
0.40648630261421204,
-0.45798102021217346,
-0.9241949319839478,
-0.14278949797153473,
0.09655599296092987,
-0.31281545758247375,
1.1297680139541626,
-0.03875667229294777,
-0.5543689727783203,
-0.07387179881334305,
-0.2455231249332428,
-0.5240024328231812,
-0.510731041431427,
-0.26496729254722595,
-0.419567346572876,
0.751081645488739,
0.8621049523353577,
0.38766390085220337,
0.6381005048751831,
0.43266671895980835,
0.26158714294433594,
-0.2601272761821747,
-0.08262871205806732,
-0.4910179376602173,
0.06219740957021713,
-0.25225624442100525,
-0.4075530469417572,
-0.3388405442237854,
-0.21513354778289795,
0.36592787504196167,
0.5873816609382629,
-0.3427574038505554,
0.14976921677589417,
-0.045878298580646515,
0.4059123396873474,
-0.6416077613830566,
-0.1803453415632248,
-0.6004828810691833,
0.10846204310655594,
-0.2740553021430969,
-0.32406380772590637,
-0.4541124701499939,
-0.06660007685422897,
0.6676522493362427,
-1.2357522249221802,
0.27589255571365356,
-0.14511935412883759,
0.6802990436553955,
0.30403509736061096,
-0.5149713158607483,
-0.11745239049196243,
-0.5900815725326538,
0.8352652788162231,
-0.6391457319259644,
0.1264067441225052,
0.4128669500350952,
0.38612493872642517,
0.01784634031355381,
-0.4843306839466095,
-0.6346985697746277,
0.06908223032951355,
-0.023077087476849556,
0.19621197879314423,
0.06291718035936356,
-0.06166206672787666,
-0.07721742242574692,
0.3851676881313324,
-0.665411114692688,
0.3334059715270996,
0.025371616706252098,
-0.14356575906276703,
0.2136426419019699,
0.10683808475732803,
0.2206432819366455,
-0.20547813177108765,
-0.5891737937927246,
-0.004214732442051172,
-0.29963746666908264,
0.018627183511853218,
0.22806987166404724,
0.2826026380062103,
-0.5432604551315308,
0.33585983514785767,
-0.3663255274295807,
0.7875583171844482,
0.1502736657857895,
-0.28222784399986267,
0.39494428038597107,
-0.25338658690452576,
-0.48538970947265625,
-0.08807247877120972,
0.7279127240180969,
-0.14602020382881165,
0.17462258040905,
-0.23752541840076447,
0.1481531262397766,
-0.025001218542456627,
0.036300674080848694,
-0.7493783831596375,
-0.3544408082962036,
0.07438548654317856,
-0.2969294488430023,
-0.3910045623779297,
-0.015207071788609028,
-0.798728883266449,
-0.6296343803405762,
-0.3896152377128601,
0.42709290981292725,
-0.3711492121219635,
-0.08843852579593658,
0.33078619837760925,
0.27199918031692505,
0.22225815057754517,
0.5893672704696655,
-0.777594268321991,
0.2152213454246521,
0.4685829281806946,
0.8428337574005127,
-0.5441028475761414,
-0.4682980179786682,
-0.7920292615890503,
0.1359628587961197,
0.2639048993587494,
0.9571294784545898,
-0.05410920828580856,
-0.2558775246143341,
0.08434168994426727,
-0.2162758708000183,
-0.09496372938156128,
-0.3539348244667053,
0.489313006401062,
-0.6077032089233398,
0.6723788976669312,
-0.2624368965625763,
-0.4089116156101227,
-0.2922750413417816,
0.2959250807762146,
-0.42808398604393005,
0.4598889648914337,
0.11821440607309341,
-0.9973481297492981,
0.1918589323759079,
-0.9403449296951294,
-0.7110495567321777,
0.23374992609024048,
-0.13456721603870392,
-0.5290215015411377,
-0.030137574300169945,
0.044453464448451996,
0.4747315049171448,
-0.20150882005691528,
0.031069792807102203,
-0.07922320067882538,
-0.5315924286842346,
0.11745727807283401,
-0.10370084643363953,
0.7784325480461121,
0.1532590389251709,
-0.38562649488449097,
0.5808171033859253,
-0.9851885437965393,
-0.21039344370365143,
0.22362743318080902,
-0.6098529696464539,
-0.49660569429397583,
-0.20498302578926086,
0.3814735412597656,
0.00515440758317709,
0.39084142446517944,
-0.40881437063217163,
0.027868790552020073,
-0.5934934020042419,
0.5875900387763977,
0.9095540046691895,
-0.15989628434181213,
0.7009075284004211,
-0.15144336223602295,
0.6094529032707214,
0.27085942029953003,
-0.024160180240869522,
-0.47601786255836487,
-0.3413226306438446,
-0.7424429059028625,
-0.41467538475990295,
0.21089968085289001,
0.7287595868110657,
-0.7356147170066833,
0.48727157711982727,
0.07760614901781082,
-0.2771299183368683,
-0.39470818638801575,
0.6795336008071899,
0.41584980487823486,
0.8350199460983276,
0.3206622898578644,
-0.3004826307296753,
-0.4648050367832184,
-0.6086879372596741,
-0.2659154236316681,
-0.1958727389574051,
-0.04007955640554428,
0.3323999345302582,
0.38792654871940613,
-0.39339113235473633,
1.3621701002120972,
-0.6166641116142273,
-0.5496774911880493,
-0.4644383490085602,
0.18889465928077698,
0.5039962530136108,
0.29173240065574646,
0.382671982049942,
-0.8783118724822998,
-0.6823664903640747,
0.25752905011177063,
-0.7882090210914612,
-0.09944304078817368,
-0.17582836747169495,
-0.2678111493587494,
0.05587797239422798,
0.09308937191963196,
-0.5463537573814392,
0.489034503698349,
0.6131939888000488,
-0.7363371253013611,
0.4455679655075073,
-0.37312620878219604,
-0.24678027629852295,
-1.4889720678329468,
0.4092720150947571,
0.11697286367416382,
-0.4139799177646637,
-0.8011609315872192,
-0.029319463297724724,
-0.13246716558933258,
0.059093620628118515,
-0.6396694779396057,
0.8023227453231812,
-0.10408221930265427,
0.028196977451443672,
-0.2703915238380432,
0.2457038015127182,
0.2138243168592453,
0.5866617560386658,
0.1717505306005478,
0.6049256920814514,
0.13141001760959625,
-0.6268255114555359,
0.08086032420396805,
0.6560574173927307,
-0.5983732342720032,
0.5959775447845459,
-0.7600570917129517,
0.3793211579322815,
-0.16488587856292725,
0.1664813607931137,
-0.48714014887809753,
-0.39503172039985657,
0.28873923420906067,
-0.19331349432468414,
-0.26219800114631653,
0.04894104227423668,
-0.4521090090274811,
0.17399759590625763,
-0.2370491325855255,
0.4442695379257202,
0.48818957805633545,
-0.7961320877075195,
0.6379056572914124,
0.13299167156219482,
0.11933214217424393,
-0.4809041917324066,
-0.5241967439651489,
-0.036557212471961975,
-0.5475369095802307,
-0.4460090696811676,
0.47070640325546265,
-0.5235859751701355,
-0.2354428470134735,
-0.3504122197628021,
0.28786951303482056,
-0.2572726905345917,
0.46795380115509033,
0.1813814491033554,
0.11702608317136765,
-0.3152989447116852,
0.13058313727378845,
-0.05325855687260628,
-0.1656409502029419,
-0.3926505148410797,
-0.12100578844547272,
0.6405244469642639,
-0.25221577286720276,
-0.015445639379322529,
-0.9439988732337952,
0.2839047610759735,
0.4376469850540161,
-0.22802570462226868,
0.82355797290802,
0.932759165763855,
-0.24296949803829193,
-0.10629983246326447,
-0.425870805978775,
-0.23051223158836365,
-0.485676109790802,
0.2090378850698471,
-0.3845287263393402,
-0.9904984831809998,
0.5285544991493225,
0.22626011073589325,
0.29316091537475586,
-0.015942277386784554,
0.7488840818405151,
-0.4188956916332245,
0.4778214395046234,
0.9354951977729797,
-0.13553574681282043,
0.704131007194519,
-0.15428075194358826,
0.08562974631786346,
-0.7103715538978577,
-0.2318381816148758,
-0.2905384600162506,
-0.2527261972427368,
-0.30763155221939087,
-0.19963808357715607,
0.23393023014068604,
0.07511670142412186,
-0.5098788142204285,
0.4219342768192291,
-0.24909693002700806,
0.3721470534801483,
0.8698413372039795,
0.3253573179244995,
0.6743147373199463,
0.07765699177980423,
0.0781221017241478,
-0.041160307824611664,
-0.7019656300544739,
-0.2520298659801483,
0.6547257304191589,
0.4150426387786865,
0.6051909923553467,
0.20364993810653687,
0.7770463228225708,
0.2793363630771637,
0.3628978133201599,
-0.9515703320503235,
0.36044546961784363,
-0.3032821714878082,
-0.42237645387649536,
-0.20127815008163452,
-0.4514448642730713,
-0.9202679991722107,
0.3510398268699646,
-0.16309760510921478,
-0.6471636891365051,
0.21382254362106323,
0.5265296101570129,
-0.6917415857315063,
0.09728678315877914,
-0.8554003238677979,
1.029249906539917,
-0.209635391831398,
-0.4337674677371979,
-0.03572007641196251,
-0.6445103883743286,
0.34470871090888977,
-0.20419840514659882,
0.22206662595272064,
-0.07667753100395203,
-0.16769352555274963,
0.8839874863624573,
-0.3252100646495819,
1.1363097429275513,
-0.20916835963726044,
-0.026691004633903503,
0.17968088388442993,
-0.04833709076046944,
0.28018370270729065,
0.24028122425079346,
-0.13655588030815125,
-0.16486698389053345,
-0.04900168254971504,
-0.5403903722763062,
-0.46841463446617126,
0.6358997225761414,
-0.9315655827522278,
-0.38230979442596436,
-0.5112568140029907,
-0.5027269721031189,
-0.19570782780647278,
0.36528897285461426,
0.48751893639564514,
0.16325105726718903,
-0.2132432460784912,
0.2635795474052429,
0.819620668888092,
-0.5383810997009277,
0.41183990240097046,
0.6472564935684204,
-0.024475136771798134,
-0.49195733666419983,
0.8340911865234375,
-0.5204212665557861,
-0.04837666451931,
0.5681490898132324,
0.6961637735366821,
0.07983952015638351,
-0.45881304144859314,
-0.2741992771625519,
0.2892429530620575,
-0.6293313503265381,
-0.32798996567726135,
-0.444027841091156,
0.2766381502151489,
-0.15217527747154236,
-0.3899053633213043,
-0.20409423112869263,
0.03100750781595707,
-0.9197366833686829,
0.2455858588218689,
0.5711237788200378,
0.4898543655872345,
0.3114418089389801,
1.058728814125061,
-0.48989778757095337,
0.449018269777298,
0.3178088963031769,
0.354095458984375,
-0.19478605687618256,
-0.8237167596817017,
-0.36837485432624817,
-0.2574109137058258,
-0.13414503633975983,
-0.7526237964630127,
0.4065874218940735,
0.37356284260749817,
0.15774965286254883,
0.6891334056854248,
0.20109161734580994,
0.5532492995262146,
-0.22599972784519196,
0.4199313521385193,
0.3788083493709564,
-1.0806045532226562,
0.557360827922821,
-0.6574052572250366,
0.9179395437240601,
0.9639715552330017,
0.10146293044090271,
-0.5323846936225891,
0.3856232464313507,
-0.2544529438018799,
-0.7172897458076477,
0.5537909269332886,
0.038326893001794815,
0.13970503211021423,
0.3967064321041107,
0.4925329089164734,
0.3704431653022766,
0.15034504234790802,
-0.6705785989761353,
-0.009810535237193108,
-0.21729698777198792,
-0.5648040175437927,
-0.21399010717868805,
-0.12180957943201065,
0.14641794562339783,
-0.21438951790332794,
0.3486713469028473,
-0.45892542600631714,
-0.10022620111703873,
0.130881205201149,
-0.4327431619167328,
0.16140921413898468,
0.419672429561615,
0.5770039558410645,
0.648322582244873,
-0.2242272049188614,
-0.031329818069934845,
0.13990093767642975,
-0.5142942070960999,
-0.051268234848976135,
-0.12725915014743805,
-0.39623403549194336,
-0.05686577782034874,
0.3482501208782196,
0.7588130831718445,
0.48927345871925354,
-0.8634999990463257,
0.5748981237411499,
-0.2838660180568695,
-0.0784197449684143,
-0.40168312191963196,
-0.14233718812465668,
0.02316301129758358,
-0.07864928990602493,
0.027857087552547455,
-0.08649136126041412,
-0.027290208265185356,
-0.5813599824905396,
-0.025609975680708885,
0.09090330451726913,
-0.2643496096134186,
-0.7497127652168274,
0.40411004424095154,
0.4844059646129608,
-0.4505411386489868,
0.5856904983520508,
-0.029483802616596222,
-0.6186208724975586,
0.2687157690525055,
0.509035050868988,
0.7186383008956909,
-0.1570238173007965,
0.5424992442131042,
-0.00857509020715952,
-0.05426827445626259,
0.1777118295431137,
0.33146706223487854,
-0.2660113275051117,
-0.7158538103103638,
-0.4699321985244751,
-0.628740668296814,
-0.47049185633659363,
0.26926425099372864,
-0.612036943435669,
0.48358768224716187,
-0.7017959952354431,
-0.05337909236550331,
-0.22869044542312622,
0.050439029932022095,
-0.9715524911880493,
0.10051891207695007,
-0.0725172758102417,
0.925881564617157,
-0.6603107452392578,
0.9348357915878296,
0.8654665946960449,
-0.18331319093704224,
-0.24656528234481812,
0.007723859511315823,
0.0005378675414249301,
-0.4852568209171295,
0.34452512860298157,
0.015433691442012787,
-0.03374181687831879,
0.06819038093090057,
-0.20631197094917297,
-0.457243412733078,
1.1234222650527954,
0.41330674290657043,
-0.6024314761161804,
-0.2432776391506195,
0.060434672981500626,
0.5537129640579224,
-0.33771541714668274,
0.0026621923316270113,
0.6021966338157654,
0.3148535490036011,
-0.014114117249846458,
-0.7794944047927856,
-0.2261715680360794,
0.023613203316926956,
-0.15060065686702728,
-0.16644792258739471,
-0.5918888449668884,
0.6504312753677368,
-0.36598458886146545,
-0.0007131930906325579,
0.27953872084617615,
0.778892993927002,
0.3059527575969696,
0.5943624377250671,
0.6931589245796204,
0.5002861618995667,
0.7108686566352844,
0.42433860898017883,
0.8927608728408813,
-0.1020381972193718,
0.1724734604358673,
1.530014157295227,
-0.24505236744880676,
1.0504666566848755,
0.5500485301017761,
0.1845192164182663,
0.6130755543708801,
0.5079311728477478,
0.36899858713150024,
0.5502781271934509,
0.15434427559375763,
-0.4151770770549774,
-0.27052679657936096,
-0.1963321715593338,
-0.06378259509801865,
0.726203978061676,
0.15978096425533295,
-0.21860380470752716,
-0.05706775560975075,
0.22481529414653778,
0.2098129540681839,
0.43301233649253845,
-0.0042419140227139,
1.0405484437942505,
0.1447635442018509,
-0.38347795605659485,
0.3023762106895447,
0.12428823113441467,
0.9637566804885864,
-0.438395231962204,
0.26704496145248413,
-0.37967368960380554,
0.40931081771850586,
-0.41776061058044434,
-0.40570971369743347,
-0.016733704134821892,
0.2452409267425537,
-0.2754571735858917,
-0.2921491861343384,
0.5986928939819336,
-0.2513328194618225,
-0.24593046307563782,
0.18219991028308868,
0.5621660351753235,
-0.0904310867190361,
-0.12867891788482666,
-0.4377632141113281,
0.17478260397911072,
-0.14851899445056915,
-0.3382674753665924,
0.44992896914482117,
0.06707052886486053,
0.1449633091688156,
0.5398475527763367,
0.6092697381973267,
-0.16371193528175354,
-0.12431862950325012,
0.22542624175548553,
0.6903864741325378,
-0.6302328705787659,
-0.7257058024406433,
-0.8084956407546997,
0.4002067744731903,
0.0420570932328701,
-0.7491143345832825,
0.6675621271133423,
0.424471914768219,
0.6514283418655396,
-0.13005448877811432,
0.9220249652862549,
0.20847895741462708,
0.6289443373680115,
-0.36423787474632263,
0.8192782402038574,
-0.3286784887313843,
0.324313759803772,
-0.23374226689338684,
-0.9022144675254822,
-0.3576837480068207,
0.6811361312866211,
-0.26032716035842896,
-0.15606553852558136,
0.6058326959609985,
0.21200522780418396,
-0.2859870195388794,
-0.14676502346992493,
0.3827493190765381,
0.22827644646167755,
0.3353271782398224,
0.662175178527832,
0.6196801662445068,
-0.20181462168693542,
0.5229142904281616,
-0.4952353537082672,
-0.48574796319007874,
-0.3671618700027466,
-0.9684782028198242,
-1.1543258428573608,
-0.7158172130584717,
-0.5019367933273315,
-0.2095469981431961,
0.11081111431121826,
0.9695485234260559,
0.9385729432106018,
-0.8030993938446045,
-0.3669251799583435,
-0.17356261610984802,
0.23628149926662445,
0.20725873112678528,
-0.20445087552070618,
0.41642051935195923,
-0.18408699333667755,
-0.4629185199737549,
0.37622830271720886,
0.06862042099237442,
-0.07551171630620956,
-0.3481067419052124,
-0.17064258456230164,
-0.08292785286903381,
-0.14401452243328094,
0.783275306224823,
0.6279332041740417,
-0.51054847240448,
0.011831403709948063,
0.17693573236465454,
0.03645026683807373,
0.14970152080059052,
0.9747238159179688,
-1.1864289045333862,
0.29886960983276367,
0.660432755947113,
0.8619979619979858,
0.4320683777332306,
0.15753507614135742,
0.5143240094184875,
-0.607557475566864,
0.16626790165901184,
0.2481459081172943,
0.154568150639534,
0.5194731950759888,
-0.41191595792770386,
0.1782846450805664,
0.23643159866333008,
-0.36232200264930725,
-0.7968013882637024,
0.22901219129562378,
-1.3029308319091797,
-0.1006612777709961,
1.023389458656311,
-0.33535656332969666,
-0.33060041069984436,
-0.248370960354805,
-0.17120909690856934,
0.07550176233053207,
-0.4740917384624481,
0.9333838224411011,
0.2640915811061859,
-0.007071787025779486,
-0.18343892693519592,
-0.37419578433036804,
0.3753904700279236,
0.6191452741622925,
-1.2285869121551514,
-0.13737179338932037,
0.044437479227781296,
0.36449122428894043,
-0.007353991270065308,
0.4790154993534088,
0.4066612124443054,
0.3649238049983978,
-0.7869039177894592,
-0.07768648117780685,
-0.023563480004668236,
-0.2772935926914215,
-0.5453925132751465,
0.1522432267665863,
0.03862035647034645,
-0.07338695228099823
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06204v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06204v1
|
Identifying and interpreting non-aligned human conceptual representations using language modeling
| 2024-03-10T13:02:27 | 2024-03-10T13:02:27 |
Wanqian Bao, Uri Hasson
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The question of whether people's experience in the world shapes conceptual
representation and lexical semantics is longstanding. Word-association,
feature-listing and similarity rating tasks aim to address this question but
require a subjective interpretation of the latent dimensions identified. In
this study, we introduce a supervised representational-alignment method that
(i) determines whether two groups of individuals share the same basis of a
certain category, and (ii) explains in what respects they differ. In applying
this method, we show that congenital blindness induces conceptual
reorganization in both a-modal and sensory-related verbal domains, and we
identify the associated semantic shifts. We first apply supervised
feature-pruning to a language model (GloVe) to optimize prediction accuracy of
human similarity judgments from word embeddings. Pruning identifies one subset
of retained GloVe features that optimizes prediction of judgments made by
sighted individuals and another subset that optimizes judgments made by blind.
A linear probing analysis then interprets the latent semantics of these
feature-subsets by learning a mapping from the retained GloVe features to 65
interpretable semantic dimensions. We applied this approach to seven semantic
domains, including verbs related to motion, sight, touch, and amodal verbs
related to knowledge acquisition. We find that blind individuals more strongly
associate social and cognitive meanings to verbs related to motion or those
communicating non-speech vocal utterances (e.g., whimper, moan). Conversely,
for amodal verbs, they demonstrate much sparser information. Finally, for some
verbs, representations of blind and sighted are highly similar. The study
presents a formal approach for studying interindividual differences in word
meaning, and the first demonstration of how blindness impacts conceptual
representation of everyday verbs.
|
[
-0.42751771211624146,
-0.6502992510795593,
0.5049283504486084,
0.008199320174753666,
-0.3259716033935547,
0.11582688987255096,
-0.11550858616828918,
-0.6054322123527527,
0.5195245742797852,
0.3631184697151184,
-0.5264355540275574,
-0.493831992149353,
-0.6933817267417908,
-0.15800829231739044,
-0.4130264222621918,
0.5960811972618103,
-0.03583095222711563,
0.012103531509637833,
-0.5460491180419922,
-0.2745164930820465,
-0.7567334771156311,
-0.28787705302238464,
-0.1365400105714798,
-0.2787170112133026,
0.3233865797519684,
0.3675139546394348,
0.8147759437561035,
0.7107531428337097,
0.5395815968513489,
0.2843085825443268,
-0.01715056411921978,
-0.09975901246070862,
-0.2118712067604065,
-0.14530973136425018,
-0.3461483418941498,
-0.49012136459350586,
-0.30290260910987854,
0.4150472581386566,
0.4126259386539459,
1.1023712158203125,
-0.15820032358169556,
0.07650423794984818,
0.21633347868919373,
0.4259570837020874,
-0.6691538095474243,
0.22878442704677582,
-0.47332578897476196,
0.10791327804327011,
-0.337475448846817,
-0.21544292569160461,
-0.1142200157046318,
-0.0172724649310112,
0.4553152620792389,
-0.7655220031738281,
0.492290198802948,
0.25848591327667236,
1.0233699083328247,
0.3739483952522278,
-0.41590797901153564,
-0.17831845581531525,
-0.40029045939445496,
0.7890551686286926,
-0.482621967792511,
0.7231150269508362,
0.48424601554870605,
0.015222673304378986,
0.13581863045692444,
-0.18948523700237274,
-0.9019476175308228,
-0.4426858723163605,
-0.41517630219459534,
0.29119208455085754,
0.09059219062328339,
0.11309193819761276,
0.1592448502779007,
0.1445344239473343,
-0.7589581608772278,
0.07792606204748154,
-0.5200470685958862,
-0.31478461623191833,
0.6989587545394897,
0.08552972227334976,
0.4220612347126007,
-0.4738079905509949,
-0.522224485874176,
-0.09863098710775375,
-0.4619450271129608,
-0.3019588589668274,
0.3504858613014221,
0.16407465934753418,
-0.3089400827884674,
0.7861764430999756,
-0.024466998875141144,
0.9352318644523621,
0.03933636471629143,
-0.17675425112247467,
0.3752943277359009,
-0.1454574316740036,
-0.05860033631324768,
0.02175021730363369,
0.24569879472255707,
0.6484012007713318,
0.4352545738220215,
-0.298855721950531,
-0.053555309772491455,
0.5232459902763367,
0.5961102247238159,
-0.09462389349937439,
-0.12472822517156601,
-0.2663900554180145,
-0.5033320784568787,
-0.30821600556373596,
0.4049772620201111,
-0.6052464842796326,
-0.6828155517578125,
-0.6664630174636841,
0.49656805396080017,
-0.36237549781799316,
-0.4316476881504059,
0.17211280763149261,
-0.1927454173564911,
0.40518254041671753,
0.198389932513237,
-0.9205648899078369,
0.546295702457428,
0.764979362487793,
0.699488639831543,
-0.44241097569465637,
-0.3339877426624298,
0.026880739256739616,
0.25915178656578064,
-0.419942706823349,
0.4323146939277649,
-0.5113059878349304,
-0.21292565762996674,
-0.2390240579843521,
0.06401924043893814,
-0.2515649199485779,
-0.6996466517448425,
0.22006914019584656,
-0.44704383611679077,
0.17698074877262115,
-0.03153660148382187,
-0.6082918643951416,
-0.3801584541797638,
0.12526647746562958,
-0.620741605758667,
0.47316476702690125,
0.07797183841466904,
-0.909932553768158,
0.6384832262992859,
-0.5530054569244385,
-0.37262845039367676,
-0.016323300078511238,
-0.47615429759025574,
-0.19602422416210175,
0.5539906620979309,
-0.02230573073029518,
0.4221423268318176,
-0.21977508068084717,
0.1624840945005417,
-0.13072450459003448,
-0.09272129833698273,
0.43958580493927,
-0.10293898731470108,
0.49835869669914246,
-0.18592344224452972,
-0.3090638518333435,
0.15324389934539795,
-0.6095666289329529,
-0.26619192957878113,
0.2558671236038208,
0.19043058156967163,
-0.7060329914093018,
0.22133979201316833,
-0.028847329318523407,
0.20512180030345917,
0.35512787103652954,
-0.6267739534378052,
-0.0008947475580498576,
-0.6426765322685242,
0.31332579255104065,
0.7283798456192017,
0.16575132310390472,
0.6341320276260376,
-0.29595112800598145,
0.37340039014816284,
0.5935109853744507,
0.2570444643497467,
0.19010964035987854,
-0.5891306400299072,
-0.9215115308761597,
0.11459146440029144,
0.24442432820796967,
0.48225560784339905,
-0.6297828555107117,
0.37870195508003235,
-0.46172699332237244,
-0.14475934207439423,
-0.6143887042999268,
0.029007865116000175,
0.39118874073028564,
0.5061046481132507,
0.36316007375717163,
-0.8355848789215088,
-0.20154903829097748,
-1.1762083768844604,
-0.25875920057296753,
-0.4339948892593384,
0.05193569138646126,
0.36420848965644836,
0.44450658559799194,
-0.03590709716081619,
1.0684574842453003,
-0.6588123440742493,
-0.6641353368759155,
0.18679854273796082,
0.1799420267343521,
-0.12490887939929962,
0.523337721824646,
0.32792824506759644,
-1.0453168153762817,
-0.03064480423927307,
0.17849957942962646,
-0.8016624450683594,
0.029089372605085373,
-0.2020205706357956,
-0.02747848443686962,
0.180765300989151,
0.39703425765037537,
-0.3989420235157013,
0.740528404712677,
0.4689144194126129,
-0.6342548131942749,
0.222608745098114,
-0.1419282853603363,
-0.10247162729501724,
-0.7605782151222229,
0.04271551966667175,
0.06073765456676483,
0.0349915437400341,
-0.3899068832397461,
0.029761401936411858,
0.060909632593393326,
0.004624985158443451,
-0.22687441110610962,
0.6190073490142822,
-0.6018175482749939,
-0.39137738943099976,
-0.018901998177170753,
0.5199360847473145,
-0.11060994863510132,
0.44352665543556213,
0.20215515792369843,
0.578626811504364,
0.41822242736816406,
-0.4552546441555023,
0.12447190284729004,
0.21953219175338745,
-0.42923760414123535,
0.7559363842010498,
-0.42025765776634216,
0.06773350387811661,
-0.4294765889644623,
-0.3809734582901001,
-0.8866665363311768,
-0.17385917901992798,
0.3711622357368469,
-0.6772805452346802,
0.3006000816822052,
0.27364233136177063,
-0.37685707211494446,
-0.19449828565120697,
-0.06040751934051514,
0.34174013137817383,
0.20535269379615784,
-0.1052585169672966,
0.6262742877006531,
0.5142861008644104,
0.09272119402885437,
-0.37179169058799744,
-0.7573400735855103,
-0.06786325573921204,
-0.43511876463890076,
-0.5620221495628357,
0.5671404600143433,
0.3441278040409088,
-0.46822693943977356,
0.33997344970703125,
-0.40812572836875916,
-0.06574861705303192,
0.3365197777748108,
0.4808276295661926,
0.36433732509613037,
-0.13546429574489594,
0.3044213056564331,
0.02965853363275528,
-0.1938866674900055,
-0.048798155039548874,
-0.39144790172576904,
0.2534509301185608,
0.24326308071613312,
-0.4896405339241028,
-0.3425001800060272,
0.23882153630256653,
0.32831329107284546,
-0.4213597774505615,
0.7633857727050781,
0.29805293679237366,
-0.5149752497673035,
0.16361933946609497,
-0.5499046444892883,
-0.2888180613517761,
-0.3728695511817932,
0.2795630097389221,
-0.3951128125190735,
-0.8333166837692261,
0.5579543113708496,
0.08808085322380066,
-0.14772212505340576,
0.315773069858551,
0.3286084532737732,
-0.16090838611125946,
0.7942002415657043,
0.8912069201469421,
0.09708060324192047,
0.41625070571899414,
-0.16163581609725952,
0.19928333163261414,
-1.0066043138504028,
-0.38690751791000366,
-0.2186724692583084,
-0.5752232670783997,
-0.4138758182525635,
-0.7028219103813171,
0.2163643091917038,
0.22640731930732727,
-0.034633439034223557,
0.3699725270271301,
-0.4821207821369171,
0.2582836151123047,
0.32089781761169434,
0.09663371741771698,
0.25432088971138,
-0.09197685867547989,
-0.4038417637348175,
-0.3593396842479706,
-0.3577294945716858,
-0.5192713737487793,
0.9403918981552124,
0.17200127243995667,
0.6436576247215271,
0.27616581320762634,
0.7808102369308472,
0.2832431495189667,
0.4661264717578888,
-0.9177873134613037,
0.5318360924720764,
-0.0004542995011433959,
-0.6066925525665283,
-0.2346278876066208,
-0.2297665774822235,
-0.9989222884178162,
0.4039340317249298,
-0.32150998711586,
-1.0298551321029663,
0.49041253328323364,
-0.0816403180360794,
-0.1021675318479538,
-0.14863274991512299,
-0.9312226176261902,
0.9806943535804749,
-0.2951301634311676,
-0.13458748161792755,
-0.5042628645896912,
-0.8156706690788269,
0.3313347101211548,
-0.23992764949798584,
0.12355109304189682,
-0.1319350302219391,
-0.44598862528800964,
0.8602742552757263,
-0.2055070549249649,
0.9905369877815247,
-0.3415747880935669,
-0.08766119927167892,
0.03740585222840309,
0.1230800598859787,
-0.019969649612903595,
-0.18414509296417236,
0.1684146225452423,
0.2242826372385025,
-0.06523557752370834,
-0.3397735059261322,
-0.9350005388259888,
0.5657054781913757,
-0.7978438138961792,
-0.9178332090377808,
-0.561251699924469,
-0.4010453522205353,
-0.4424680173397064,
0.09813865274190903,
-0.08890791982412338,
0.16536766290664673,
-0.249148428440094,
-0.1661054491996765,
0.2873319089412689,
-0.2936567962169647,
-0.041068289428949356,
0.5789182782173157,
-0.24920053780078888,
-0.006997206248342991,
0.9212940335273743,
0.3062516450881958,
0.2762065529823303,
0.5108681917190552,
0.0197665523737669,
-0.36890026926994324,
-0.42987003922462463,
-0.19626285135746002,
0.5560798048973083,
-0.5786239504814148,
-0.025150083005428314,
-0.36510756611824036,
-0.0014340117340907454,
-0.19654251635074615,
0.05607018992304802,
0.13361115753650665,
-0.4905681014060974,
-0.3444337844848633,
-0.19929681718349457,
0.16103926301002502,
0.5904284715652466,
0.02564062923192978,
0.2970356047153473,
-0.48140424489974976,
0.3669624924659729,
0.2820369303226471,
0.27990102767944336,
0.2912697196006775,
-0.44970864057540894,
-0.18325552344322205,
-0.051829993724823,
-0.40545034408569336,
-1.1487343311309814,
0.28475669026374817,
0.3728078007698059,
0.5585178732872009,
0.6260659098625183,
-0.026719629764556885,
0.801485538482666,
-0.3693108558654785,
0.5532663464546204,
0.33045661449432373,
-1.0687581300735474,
0.49549898505210876,
-0.020356830209493637,
0.0019085523672401905,
0.26555028557777405,
0.37297147512435913,
-0.7051944136619568,
-0.3758482336997986,
-0.837462306022644,
-0.6658838391304016,
0.7159361243247986,
0.18993479013442993,
0.06431028246879578,
-0.07048718631267548,
0.33454740047454834,
-0.12321345508098602,
0.09210279583930969,
-0.2612839937210083,
-0.27979952096939087,
-0.15988118946552277,
-0.390499085187912,
-0.2811492085456848,
-0.005571633577346802,
-0.1518278270959854,
-0.23312529921531677,
0.2581401467323303,
-0.19691342115402222,
0.409397691488266,
0.07424735277891159,
-0.4268641173839569,
-0.09221770614385605,
-0.07663176953792572,
0.6218646764755249,
0.7838919162750244,
0.11604846268892288,
0.36666151881217957,
0.120667964220047,
-0.5699267983436584,
0.10163788497447968,
0.06388373672962189,
0.03784821927547455,
-0.049490395933389664,
0.713904082775116,
0.6794222593307495,
0.3766605257987976,
-0.5746328234672546,
0.8433939218521118,
0.06915781646966934,
0.04379201680421829,
-0.126691997051239,
-0.007737032137811184,
0.2860361337661743,
0.12037403136491776,
0.15554192662239075,
0.21259377896785736,
0.053605277091264725,
-0.444983571767807,
0.30811387300491333,
0.3283974230289459,
-0.541024923324585,
-0.521376371383667,
0.5610387921333313,
0.014199803583323956,
-0.04642447456717491,
0.6780062913894653,
-0.02095564268529415,
-0.46179571747779846,
0.4729743003845215,
0.23634709417819977,
0.7728404998779297,
-0.18083342909812927,
0.18340998888015747,
0.1590558886528015,
0.39116886258125305,
0.31383514404296875,
0.19206683337688446,
-0.29254913330078125,
-1.190514087677002,
-0.29616203904151917,
-0.8028587698936462,
0.06266056001186371,
-0.3133421242237091,
-0.8985655307769775,
0.14498159289360046,
-0.3627970218658447,
-0.22210612893104553,
0.3234809637069702,
-0.09370601922273636,
-0.7345286011695862,
0.26823222637176514,
0.22218990325927734,
0.5342676639556885,
-1.1326680183410645,
0.8970165252685547,
0.8887197375297546,
-0.650982677936554,
-0.7405215501785278,
0.3837607800960541,
0.24045152962207794,
-0.989874005317688,
0.8174682855606079,
0.06521956622600555,
0.04225404933094978,
0.06776035577058792,
-0.26177912950515747,
-0.8501937389373779,
0.9661630392074585,
0.2983303964138031,
-0.5329031348228455,
-0.10518329590559006,
0.2115900218486786,
0.5541603565216064,
-0.30009061098098755,
-0.23757106065750122,
0.5811992883682251,
0.3283167779445648,
-0.01709843799471855,
-1.0499650239944458,
0.1246417909860611,
0.0788513571023941,
0.31276652216911316,
0.3774246275424957,
-0.3176725506782532,
0.5083143711090088,
-0.2604493498802185,
-0.590764582157135,
0.03395729139447212,
0.691649317741394,
0.1714523583650589,
0.150908961892128,
0.5420384407043457,
0.6647743582725525,
0.771672248840332,
-0.03421349823474884,
0.7930063009262085,
-0.24494504928588867,
0.3429819941520691,
0.7554589509963989,
-0.2422410100698471,
0.655310332775116,
0.6837372779846191,
-0.02410190738737583,
0.3754020929336548,
0.39090031385421753,
0.253699392080307,
0.5423599481582642,
0.367574006319046,
-0.08537119626998901,
-0.18841058015823364,
-0.17033381760120392,
-0.008277099579572678,
0.5880104899406433,
0.6212931275367737,
-0.3294422924518585,
-0.08112041652202606,
0.2322796732187271,
-0.3621232807636261,
0.20777124166488647,
-0.11457966268062592,
0.9616389274597168,
0.29905804991722107,
-0.44287875294685364,
0.5921065807342529,
0.012311053462326527,
0.587665319442749,
-0.2287934422492981,
-0.09266162663698196,
0.004405634943395853,
0.13928012549877167,
-0.23027458786964417,
-0.8577522039413452,
0.6044087409973145,
-0.24630524218082428,
-0.19240880012512207,
-0.047653548419475555,
0.6800066828727722,
-0.19593757390975952,
-0.2879466414451599,
0.45228391885757446,
0.7306816577911377,
0.3432837128639221,
0.09905978292226791,
-0.7863703370094299,
0.07256058603525162,
-0.10675438493490219,
0.13640768826007843,
0.22149783372879028,
0.43485838174819946,
-0.6917898058891296,
0.520005464553833,
0.32256019115448,
0.1747661530971527,
0.2597372233867645,
0.13710856437683105,
0.6875608563423157,
-0.8812259435653687,
-0.3743133842945099,
-0.5572437047958374,
0.4292612373828888,
0.056067802011966705,
-0.31566181778907776,
0.5823186039924622,
0.44138583540916443,
1.0612232685089111,
-0.21627311408519745,
0.46796727180480957,
-0.2078353464603424,
0.3591316342353821,
-0.4424024522304535,
0.601233959197998,
-0.7621463537216187,
-0.10232710093259811,
-0.34724509716033936,
-0.9809274077415466,
-0.48210248351097107,
1.0213801860809326,
-0.6016186475753784,
-0.061527885496616364,
0.6355453729629517,
0.8576589226722717,
-0.11942887306213379,
-0.039780840277671814,
0.4242589473724365,
0.18258365988731384,
-0.0397401824593544,
0.2863088846206665,
0.9116073250770569,
-0.15422046184539795,
-0.053253546357154846,
-0.0937037318944931,
-0.29095882177352905,
-0.13066436350345612,
-0.4377935528755188,
-0.4964068830013275,
-0.9199255704879761,
-0.4534229040145874,
-0.08986984193325043,
-0.0766722783446312,
0.6665878891944885,
0.7057918310165405,
-0.6081238389015198,
-0.20765380561351776,
-0.09671592712402344,
0.15828125178813934,
-0.5035167336463928,
-0.2625832259654999,
0.45877137780189514,
-0.07352475076913834,
-0.5213587284088135,
0.026885811239480972,
0.38115906715393066,
0.09066762030124664,
-0.5605544447898865,
-0.06099514663219452,
-0.07580068707466125,
-0.1366858333349228,
0.5139867663383484,
-0.0015516745625063777,
-1.0874520540237427,
-0.49629777669906616,
-0.14351987838745117,
0.040618106722831726,
0.027360593900084496,
0.7576216459274292,
-0.9010942578315735,
0.5833712220191956,
0.34575191140174866,
0.4066402018070221,
0.34394994378089905,
0.1703096181154251,
0.3951147198677063,
-0.8020108342170715,
0.31825655698776245,
0.384223610162735,
0.16173511743545532,
0.48917558789253235,
-0.13073603808879852,
0.4112408757209778,
0.5422380566596985,
0.032809067517519,
-0.5186899304389954,
0.3905845880508423,
-1.1099896430969238,
-0.19648770987987518,
0.7729792594909668,
-0.0008983251173049212,
-0.3756089210510254,
-0.20775645971298218,
-0.14703401923179626,
0.26085221767425537,
-0.02951657399535179,
0.8000909686088562,
0.7714199423789978,
-0.1285904496908188,
-0.2787785828113556,
-0.4349922835826874,
0.21419239044189453,
0.36067092418670654,
-0.4356532394886017,
-0.04298168420791626,
0.4285846948623657,
0.34863999485969543,
0.4492764472961426,
0.35696670413017273,
-0.29299697279930115,
0.015872463583946228,
-0.13916265964508057,
0.03831468150019646,
0.2579694092273712,
-0.20828767120838165,
-0.334522008895874,
-0.1467238813638687,
0.20218254625797272,
-0.3092173933982849
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06201v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06201v1
|
Are You Being Tracked? Discover the Power of Zero-Shot Trajectory Tracing with LLMs!
| 2024-03-10T12:50:35 | 2024-03-10T12:50:35 |
Huanqi Yang, Sijie Ji, Rucheng Wu, Weitao Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC, cs.LG
|
There is a burgeoning discussion around the capabilities of Large Language
Models (LLMs) in acting as fundamental components that can be seamlessly
incorporated into Artificial Intelligence of Things (AIoT) to interpret complex
trajectories. This study introduces LLMTrack, a model that illustrates how LLMs
can be leveraged for Zero-Shot Trajectory Recognition by employing a novel
single-prompt technique that combines role-play and think step-by-step
methodologies with unprocessed Inertial Measurement Unit (IMU) data. We
evaluate the model using real-world datasets designed to challenge it with
distinct trajectories characterized by indoor and outdoor scenarios. In both
test scenarios, LLMTrack not only meets but exceeds the performance benchmarks
set by traditional machine learning approaches and even contemporary
state-of-the-art deep learning models, all without the requirement of training
on specialized datasets. The results of our research suggest that, with
strategically designed prompts, LLMs can tap into their extensive knowledge
base and are well-equipped to analyze raw sensor data with remarkable
effectiveness.
|
[
-0.03949994221329689,
-0.7487053275108337,
0.8580141663551331,
-0.17713187634944916,
-0.5101917386054993,
0.5979067087173462,
0.10600502789020538,
-0.6857731342315674,
0.49607396125793457,
0.5010446310043335,
-1.1470484733581543,
-0.8094913363456726,
-0.3033771514892578,
-0.37932440638542175,
-0.6035851836204529,
0.8452882170677185,
0.012991510331630707,
-0.09304675459861755,
-0.1058959811925888,
-0.25492724776268005,
-0.8078199625015259,
-0.4244297444820404,
-0.2524004578590393,
-0.4395572245121002,
0.8097642064094543,
0.582413911819458,
0.19617114961147308,
0.5338968634605408,
0.41742050647735596,
0.04958506301045418,
0.12467489391565323,
0.10959962010383606,
-0.3696783185005188,
0.39168545603752136,
0.24652111530303955,
-0.37188979983329773,
-0.18020455539226532,
0.014120002277195454,
0.42755934596061707,
0.5852659344673157,
0.050808411091566086,
0.4599064588546753,
-0.14553281664848328,
0.3095862865447998,
-0.7102344632148743,
-0.022658636793494225,
-0.31388339400291443,
0.2361750453710556,
-0.28365325927734375,
-0.5626516342163086,
-0.18399101495742798,
-0.11076323688030243,
-0.10485747456550598,
-0.4520180821418762,
0.002132514026015997,
0.2110096663236618,
0.4587721526622772,
0.36882543563842773,
-0.5088083148002625,
-0.31017354130744934,
-1.242816686630249,
0.68839031457901,
-0.6287935376167297,
0.2681962251663208,
0.2910264730453491,
0.5402300953865051,
-0.26869499683380127,
-0.4596844017505646,
-0.5116574168205261,
-0.5428867340087891,
0.1010303869843483,
0.2219710797071457,
-0.05249997228384018,
-0.10086947679519653,
0.3315751850605011,
-0.32261425256729126,
-0.5645462870597839,
0.5060057640075684,
-0.11914297938346863,
-0.1493576318025589,
0.5510812401771545,
0.4896546006202698,
0.13007216155529022,
0.18023137748241425,
-0.4471428394317627,
0.15578585863113403,
-0.9162130951881409,
0.4751438498497009,
0.1984541416168213,
0.49721330404281616,
-0.29794928431510925,
0.741590142250061,
-0.4429740607738495,
0.7299761772155762,
-0.06800723075866699,
-0.16172051429748535,
-0.2564002275466919,
-0.2552521228790283,
0.05390654876828194,
0.3008613884449005,
0.6851111650466919,
0.27452996373176575,
-0.030899889767169952,
-0.5547628998756409,
-0.11203958094120026,
-0.06763247400522232,
0.13203464448451996,
-0.6506927013397217,
-0.03816515579819679,
0.2665069103240967,
0.08506729453802109,
-0.16748148202896118,
-0.10113155841827393,
-0.6043781042098999,
-0.6109879612922668,
-0.3352734446525574,
0.3023543953895569,
-0.2946590781211853,
0.03540131822228432,
0.18393976986408234,
0.18839649856090546,
0.7481928467750549,
0.6407966613769531,
-0.7722988724708557,
-0.16505515575408936,
0.9746862649917603,
1.1826016902923584,
0.08452028781175613,
-0.3971082270145416,
-0.661734402179718,
0.1743466556072235,
-0.5937005281448364,
1.0411752462387085,
-0.44459882378578186,
-0.5241793990135193,
-0.04587876424193382,
-0.2041529417037964,
0.06905411183834076,
-0.18381938338279724,
0.5543166399002075,
-0.3136964738368988,
-0.02406434901058674,
-0.08728551864624023,
-0.6201462149620056,
-0.31553447246551514,
0.4960891604423523,
-0.24292531609535217,
1.2289069890975952,
-0.034940142184495926,
-0.38397201895713806,
0.5481117963790894,
-0.70149165391922,
-0.5977281332015991,
0.5758446455001831,
-0.15059985220432281,
-0.4582783877849579,
0.22598466277122498,
0.050260111689567566,
0.5180307626724243,
0.034624047577381134,
0.16334891319274902,
-0.5782591700553894,
-0.5663338899612427,
0.09600108116865158,
-0.4660860300064087,
0.8498314023017883,
-0.024400128051638603,
-0.2844761610031128,
0.2564292848110199,
-0.790266215801239,
-0.1818573772907257,
-0.10534785687923431,
-0.3308653235435486,
-0.17004691064357758,
0.24116410315036774,
-0.36349987983703613,
0.22460684180259705,
0.23429995775222778,
-0.9837144017219543,
0.45602738857269287,
0.03266816958785057,
0.20643335580825806,
0.7783957719802856,
0.03217686712741852,
0.3934198319911957,
-0.11031261831521988,
0.8576437830924988,
-0.3754861056804657,
0.04424605146050453,
-0.4783567786216736,
-0.5347167253494263,
-0.5264078974723816,
-0.31320902705192566,
-0.13450010120868683,
0.6848594546318054,
-0.41728946566581726,
0.3318794369697571,
-0.4554813504219055,
-0.6063147783279419,
-0.35043254494667053,
-0.14847621321678162,
0.00446697324514389,
0.9336601495742798,
0.09983315318822861,
0.1360386162996292,
-0.4263702630996704,
-0.08642315864562988,
-0.13743196427822113,
-0.3019642233848572,
-0.33084961771965027,
0.2266235202550888,
0.5744226574897766,
-0.06341294944286346,
1.091525673866272,
-0.4214659035205841,
-0.20780734717845917,
-0.3666011393070221,
0.17292673885822296,
0.006591441575437784,
0.2628021538257599,
0.5250433087348938,
-0.358728289604187,
-0.37128669023513794,
0.04202958941459656,
-1.055197834968567,
-0.27943041920661926,
-0.33835792541503906,
-0.25192511081695557,
-0.0869673639535904,
0.6558148860931396,
-0.7254341840744019,
0.6626547574996948,
0.2063131481409073,
-0.6995393633842468,
0.47740569710731506,
-0.15858136117458344,
0.0568445548415184,
-0.7394492030143738,
0.19943831861019135,
-0.07809007167816162,
-0.45444822311401367,
-0.7364522218704224,
0.0015707113780081272,
0.03611556068062782,
-0.15737177431583405,
-0.7253055572509766,
0.6016937494277954,
-0.3168169856071472,
-0.2256702035665512,
-0.3776019215583801,
0.04442492872476578,
-0.2819281220436096,
0.3685985207557678,
-0.23588696122169495,
0.47849124670028687,
0.6784528493881226,
-0.6449397206306458,
0.611893892288208,
0.1801442801952362,
-0.4852141737937927,
0.6945493221282959,
-0.09694863855838776,
0.305939644575119,
-0.26918235421180725,
0.262959748506546,
-1.185777187347412,
-0.2353956550359726,
0.27689555287361145,
-0.5888878107070923,
0.2228647917509079,
-0.3084580898284912,
-0.8315948247909546,
-0.4922144412994385,
-0.29609164595603943,
0.05706581100821495,
0.4205825924873352,
-0.6020906567573547,
0.7461165189743042,
0.18314281105995178,
0.28502947092056274,
-0.4119046628475189,
-0.703579843044281,
0.25803548097610474,
-0.5800361037254333,
-0.2338256537914276,
-0.14314569532871246,
-0.19564679265022278,
0.10850774496793747,
-0.30492621660232544,
-0.201111301779747,
0.1200413703918457,
0.5803828239440918,
0.728492259979248,
0.44023483991622925,
-0.06605807691812515,
-0.05006234347820282,
-0.34622859954833984,
-0.4022897779941559,
0.04487242549657822,
-0.3349142372608185,
0.5860254764556885,
0.37677231431007385,
-0.5833827257156372,
-0.7336317300796509,
0.20259588956832886,
0.8086255788803101,
-0.18321436643600464,
0.337615042924881,
0.3890140950679779,
-0.30778372287750244,
-0.1944490373134613,
-0.12759293615818024,
-0.2499668151140213,
-0.48747169971466064,
0.19054482877254486,
-0.1447952836751938,
-1.0327003002166748,
0.4289182722568512,
-0.3028028607368469,
0.3476576507091522,
-0.05597405880689621,
0.3714606463909149,
-0.8652327060699463,
0.9033893942832947,
0.9990615248680115,
-0.3524419665336609,
0.5291725993156433,
-0.04107877239584923,
0.3961102068424225,
-0.7798434495925903,
-0.513550877571106,
-0.4159835875034332,
-0.781586766242981,
-0.5344976782798767,
-0.21513482928276062,
0.4437514841556549,
0.028179936110973358,
-0.412138968706131,
0.22452469170093536,
-0.28934597969055176,
0.6006826162338257,
0.6225195527076721,
0.14181479811668396,
0.24322004616260529,
-0.1360122114419937,
0.11792933940887451,
0.04305700957775116,
-0.6154235005378723,
-0.4218396842479706,
1.1498684883117676,
0.12001912295818329,
0.8870667815208435,
-0.15823547542095184,
0.6341916918754578,
0.30961695313453674,
0.38044092059135437,
-1.2175698280334473,
0.9822750687599182,
0.02616604045033455,
-0.6198599934577942,
-0.09697163850069046,
-0.057876672595739365,
-0.9059118032455444,
-0.04455604404211044,
-0.13148652017116547,
-0.9405505061149597,
-0.2622761130332947,
0.17377665638923645,
-0.7555805444717407,
0.6419018507003784,
-0.28019142150878906,
0.600456178188324,
-0.7209181189537048,
-0.2820379436016083,
0.15032371878623962,
-0.6317263841629028,
0.2032509595155716,
0.005991692189127207,
-0.04682250693440437,
-0.7103016376495361,
0.037219371646642685,
0.5945634841918945,
-0.13153743743896484,
1.1231207847595215,
-0.3827104866504669,
0.093170166015625,
0.5442150831222534,
0.40518978238105774,
0.4507104456424713,
-0.2929736375808716,
0.17482417821884155,
0.34129682183265686,
-0.32971498370170593,
-0.20098009705543518,
-0.5152096152305603,
0.6931016445159912,
-0.29619717597961426,
-0.1909174621105194,
-0.46633127331733704,
-0.4606180191040039,
-0.07282526791095734,
0.15063489973545074,
0.146744504570961,
0.07945562899112701,
-0.09627561271190643,
0.1504090577363968,
0.17107421159744263,
-0.007192504592239857,
0.9182713627815247,
1.0811207294464111,
-0.22745616734027863,
0.19521042704582214,
0.8836309313774109,
0.3199062645435333,
-0.2543500065803528,
0.6374239921569824,
0.2814415991306305,
-0.2700656056404114,
-0.6024293303489685,
-0.6192877292633057,
0.12058437615633011,
-0.4812631905078888,
-0.40428027510643005,
-0.5200499892234802,
0.046422794461250305,
-0.058396559208631516,
-0.5092301964759827,
-0.3295784890651703,
-0.3436526358127594,
-0.5354931950569153,
-0.5311242341995239,
0.35719001293182373,
0.9192083477973938,
0.03942980617284775,
0.7302579283714294,
-0.6522669196128845,
0.13216103613376617,
0.09029625356197357,
0.38898786902427673,
-0.1724725067615509,
-0.5039991736412048,
-0.4821247458457947,
-0.03399442881345749,
-0.41509130597114563,
-0.7440013289451599,
0.5718879103660583,
-0.1310734748840332,
0.40643543004989624,
0.2786955237388611,
0.08656799793243408,
0.9296734929084778,
-0.639775276184082,
1.0127838850021362,
0.051696836948394775,
-0.6464980244636536,
0.7149845957756042,
-0.4529546797275543,
0.5095629096031189,
0.3837474584579468,
0.24975267052650452,
-0.4792003631591797,
-0.4253283739089966,
-0.2357999086380005,
-0.8918812870979309,
0.7089643478393555,
-0.04332556948065758,
0.02922012470662594,
0.41068151593208313,
0.591564416885376,
-0.08389756083488464,
0.238946333527565,
-0.5920804738998413,
0.010444661602377892,
0.08167875558137894,
-0.19129879772663116,
-0.21185444295406342,
-0.04918395355343819,
0.14611753821372986,
-0.1297900527715683,
0.34212416410446167,
-0.24595141410827637,
0.20619447529315948,
0.025981852784752846,
-0.09274952858686447,
-0.38095754384994507,
-0.08006498962640762,
0.6625804901123047,
0.336668998003006,
-0.4298749566078186,
0.17825204133987427,
0.11814150214195251,
-0.36744222044944763,
0.20886261761188507,
-0.18572594225406647,
-0.5766860246658325,
0.03757432475686073,
0.5894344449043274,
0.6031932234764099,
0.14629508554935455,
-0.6699897646903992,
0.24113646149635315,
0.15631750226020813,
0.08161627501249313,
-0.3698715567588806,
0.012380444444715977,
-0.05601848289370537,
0.2650401294231415,
0.4319867193698883,
-0.052078574895858765,
-0.04254791885614395,
-0.35310912132263184,
0.24470926821231842,
0.7192025780677795,
-0.5411216616630554,
-0.8321751356124878,
0.854769766330719,
0.022032998502254486,
-0.5695228576660156,
0.5241765975952148,
0.0315420888364315,
-0.39021462202072144,
0.7705478072166443,
0.2308068573474884,
1.2329179048538208,
-0.27764925360679626,
0.2482244372367859,
0.2974133789539337,
0.5320507287979126,
0.12095559388399124,
0.15908336639404297,
-0.40878430008888245,
-0.530723512172699,
-0.46854060888290405,
-0.6256842613220215,
-0.7301563024520874,
0.04664875194430351,
-0.33709391951560974,
0.3830370306968689,
-0.6273307204246521,
0.07485141605138779,
-0.10733361542224884,
0.0741361752152443,
-0.7267196774482727,
-0.02742120996117592,
0.5549998879432678,
0.6398718357086182,
-0.7568483948707581,
0.885288655757904,
0.43885719776153564,
-0.1505851447582245,
-0.5539110898971558,
0.18167933821678162,
0.3901810646057129,
-0.8823408484458923,
0.6044514179229736,
0.5037066340446472,
-0.4850422739982605,
0.03284330293536186,
-0.9547051787376404,
-0.6814544200897217,
1.376274585723877,
0.4595921039581299,
-0.6059172749519348,
-0.08926617354154587,
0.39453208446502686,
0.5511223673820496,
-0.3875458240509033,
0.26724547147750854,
0.429065465927124,
0.2955837547779083,
0.3577269911766052,
-0.5877081155776978,
-0.31255680322647095,
0.3665589690208435,
-0.42715492844581604,
0.25524112582206726,
-0.6865445971488953,
0.49769607186317444,
-0.30462631583213806,
-0.4342210292816162,
0.1486542969942093,
0.4363625943660736,
0.19664491713047028,
0.780187726020813,
0.04747353494167328,
0.5609272122383118,
0.640055239200592,
-0.10787742584943771,
1.0108833312988281,
-0.34173718094825745,
0.28340405225753784,
1.3413619995117188,
-0.5868558287620544,
0.8780619502067566,
0.4031337797641754,
0.048684991896152496,
0.4734288454055786,
0.5659864544868469,
0.08898907899856567,
0.605503261089325,
-0.026553833857178688,
-0.4966568648815155,
-0.27737540006637573,
-0.09641110897064209,
0.41028183698654175,
0.6763888001441956,
0.3097749650478363,
0.21656359732151031,
-0.5961886048316956,
0.2505078911781311,
0.11385160684585571,
-0.23597779870033264,
-0.3040953278541565,
0.7844666242599487,
-0.19281227886676788,
-0.5124028325080872,
0.22620855271816254,
-0.1808251142501831,
0.6565719246864319,
-0.9595311880111694,
-0.08859965205192566,
-0.5427218079566956,
-0.014886193908751011,
-0.19305157661437988,
-1.083166241645813,
0.28120097517967224,
0.2194233387708664,
0.17100562155246735,
-0.46512091159820557,
0.49010300636291504,
-0.12521600723266602,
-0.6116428375244141,
0.506904661655426,
0.4609275758266449,
0.1494830697774887,
-0.11613020300865173,
-0.29394686222076416,
-0.15278540551662445,
0.21600143611431122,
-0.06708308309316635,
0.20713362097740173,
0.4403128921985626,
-0.07626276463270187,
1.1263777017593384,
0.7899190187454224,
-0.07409044355154037,
0.35585200786590576,
-0.365792453289032,
0.7441502213478088,
-1.0637906789779663,
-0.4603476822376251,
-1.0821911096572876,
0.7717386484146118,
0.32958391308784485,
-0.2974413335323334,
1.0006200075149536,
0.6135361194610596,
0.7445751428604126,
0.17638961970806122,
0.6382230520248413,
0.21798335015773773,
0.776177704334259,
-0.34125688672065735,
0.4096290171146393,
-0.4069410264492035,
0.5735776424407959,
0.33145418763160706,
-0.5764997601509094,
-0.5899741649627686,
0.4656495451927185,
-0.15448197722434998,
-0.24928085505962372,
0.20820562541484833,
0.655320405960083,
-0.23199154436588287,
-0.185527965426445,
0.5675540566444397,
0.17408087849617004,
0.77347731590271,
0.5655860900878906,
1.0084974765777588,
-0.15115247666835785,
0.3803272247314453,
-0.34535521268844604,
-0.25839415192604065,
-0.367990106344223,
-0.9920623898506165,
-0.7271562218666077,
-0.2509187161922455,
-0.44762682914733887,
0.03849533200263977,
-0.09739352762699127,
0.6400429010391235,
0.8791130185127258,
-0.5432776808738708,
-0.40968480706214905,
-0.29006674885749817,
0.02649936079978943,
0.1475318819284439,
-0.2044229805469513,
0.016165398061275482,
0.03872467204928398,
-0.3998236656188965,
0.9036151170730591,
0.583278238773346,
0.36887112259864807,
-0.3434044122695923,
0.06240060552954674,
-0.22458063066005707,
-0.000682490470353514,
0.718215823173523,
0.6428434252738953,
-0.4632193446159363,
-0.4165591895580292,
0.23366180062294006,
0.1504567712545395,
0.22685422003269196,
0.9577540159225464,
-1.1488237380981445,
0.7315704822540283,
0.20739203691482544,
0.31315797567367554,
0.7424449920654297,
-0.022901538759469986,
0.12585009634494781,
-0.9109282493591309,
0.3262087404727936,
0.5536560416221619,
0.1615874022245407,
0.33980825543403625,
-0.48223742842674255,
0.6283599734306335,
0.101203553378582,
-0.6557645201683044,
-0.8706365823745728,
0.3330475986003876,
-1.0541836023330688,
-0.1331104189157486,
1.0192455053329468,
-0.17059390246868134,
-0.19732743501663208,
0.053219426423311234,
-0.16518567502498627,
0.12760163843631744,
-0.41602379083633423,
0.6507406234741211,
0.44677725434303284,
-0.5741475820541382,
-0.4651540219783783,
-0.7844775915145874,
-0.004753155633807182,
0.06116069108247757,
-0.6671402454376221,
0.08517339825630188,
0.7069070339202881,
0.2945549786090851,
0.0459289513528347,
0.5016593337059021,
0.33887481689453125,
-0.02838514931499958,
-0.2052236944437027,
-0.08501428365707397,
-0.14509713649749756,
-0.4987519681453705,
-0.6486165523529053,
0.08207019418478012,
-0.18633249402046204,
-0.6290011405944824
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06199v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06199v4
|
Mipha: A Comprehensive Overhaul of Multimodal Assistant with Small Language Models
| 2024-03-10T12:43:27 | 2024-03-25T05:36:56 |
Minjie Zhu, Yichen Zhu, Xin Liu, Ning Liu, Zhiyuan Xu, Chaomin Shen, Yaxin Peng, Zhicai Ou, Feifei Feng, Jian Tang
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs) have showcased impressive skills in
tasks related to visual understanding and reasoning. Yet, their widespread
application faces obstacles due to the high computational demands during both
the training and inference phases, restricting their use to a limited audience
within the research and user communities. In this paper, we investigate the
design aspects of Multimodal Small Language Models (MSLMs) and propose an
efficient multimodal assistant named Mipha, which is designed to create synergy
among various aspects: visual representation, language models, and optimization
strategies. We show that without increasing the volume of training data, our
Mipha-3B outperforms the state-of-the-art large MLLMs, especially
LLaVA-1.5-13B, on multiple benchmarks. Through detailed discussion, we provide
insights and guidelines for developing strong MSLMs that rival the capabilities
of MLLMs. Our code is available at https://github.com/zhuyiche/llava-phi.
|
[
-0.38107240200042725,
-0.5344198942184448,
0.5832132697105408,
0.265956312417984,
-0.2524014413356781,
0.031137296929955482,
-0.22694669663906097,
-0.48637470602989197,
0.3217703700065613,
0.29326504468917847,
-0.5628476738929749,
-0.09651611000299454,
-0.43675342202186584,
0.05509844049811363,
0.08165941387414932,
0.39344069361686707,
-0.03003905713558197,
0.3030562698841095,
-0.12397892773151398,
-0.28135162591934204,
-0.4299526512622833,
-0.0751628652215004,
-0.389093279838562,
-0.08537280559539795,
1.0854085683822632,
0.6172676682472229,
0.5462167859077454,
0.23292012512683868,
0.5754191279411316,
0.34430062770843506,
0.04830070212483406,
0.786109983921051,
-0.42950141429901123,
0.2954806089401245,
0.1107233464717865,
-0.19477921724319458,
-0.6869426369667053,
-0.4513736069202423,
0.6588897705078125,
0.5755042433738708,
0.06332122534513474,
0.05002082511782646,
0.34134483337402344,
0.5985857844352722,
-0.8703050017356873,
0.28853434324264526,
-0.4190892279148102,
-0.07221860438585281,
-0.38265979290008545,
-0.15365929901599884,
-0.683131992816925,
0.1583131104707718,
-0.07255485653877258,
-0.8068649768829346,
-0.3971329927444458,
0.4341122806072235,
0.6218060851097107,
0.07288537919521332,
-0.4264002740383148,
-0.10959968715906143,
-0.4898475408554077,
1.0928722620010376,
-0.44839799404144287,
0.6797458529472351,
0.16657088696956635,
0.44049471616744995,
-0.05046255886554718,
-0.48981422185897827,
-0.6530746221542358,
-0.38853105902671814,
-0.16212183237075806,
0.006511557847261429,
-0.220851868391037,
0.2213919758796692,
0.09182828664779663,
0.2704870402812958,
-0.6886207461357117,
0.1280859410762787,
-0.603975772857666,
-0.2489635944366455,
0.3407703936100006,
0.2720409631729126,
0.4235972762107849,
-0.21900399029254913,
-0.4086277484893799,
-0.012665590271353722,
-0.5716255307197571,
-0.10021605342626572,
0.13058921694755554,
0.44008803367614746,
-0.18243944644927979,
0.7161411643028259,
-0.4424896836280823,
0.7413830161094666,
-0.3825860321521759,
-0.5889968872070312,
0.4264823794364929,
-0.4257396459579468,
-0.45610982179641724,
-0.5362299680709839,
0.7732076048851013,
0.42803898453712463,
0.1682794988155365,
0.03489845246076584,
-0.1862257719039917,
-0.034598130732774734,
0.28102362155914307,
-0.738237202167511,
-0.08679758757352829,
0.12671829760074615,
-0.6906275153160095,
-0.17724469304084778,
-0.40436795353889465,
-0.6266618967056274,
-0.434598445892334,
-0.3842480778694153,
0.5208085775375366,
-0.5010935068130493,
-0.08500076085329056,
-0.05759546533226967,
0.09625312685966492,
0.10585445910692215,
0.6250749826431274,
-1.0001376867294312,
-0.034294337034225464,
0.2865087687969208,
0.8382744789123535,
-0.21195119619369507,
-0.5907992720603943,
-0.5239514708518982,
0.17036940157413483,
-0.3555747866630554,
0.7534969449043274,
-0.5594711899757385,
-0.2112414687871933,
-0.23878681659698486,
-0.0787552148103714,
-0.1750263273715973,
-0.2048826813697815,
0.3421227037906647,
-0.30969205498695374,
0.1060728058218956,
-0.019151009619235992,
-0.09748974442481995,
-0.15152966976165771,
0.28172123432159424,
-0.6594493389129639,
0.6164151430130005,
-0.186054989695549,
-0.7497998476028442,
0.1326911896467209,
-0.7864537835121155,
-0.35220783948898315,
-0.00454707071185112,
-0.23857136070728302,
-0.26853418350219727,
0.18363726139068604,
0.49880486726760864,
0.4679935574531555,
-0.32576388120651245,
-0.06598403304815292,
-0.580899178981781,
-0.37340202927589417,
0.0753304660320282,
-0.3342624008655548,
0.7462069988250732,
0.5431610345840454,
0.16697101294994354,
0.38790690898895264,
-0.7111051678657532,
0.033202506601810455,
0.13777075707912445,
-0.4853406250476837,
-0.23463770747184753,
-0.1697355955839157,
0.22185909748077393,
0.14894214272499084,
0.25811806321144104,
-0.3402725160121918,
0.30762240290641785,
-0.13681210577487946,
0.24452196061611176,
0.7940953373908997,
-0.26392143964767456,
0.7365711331367493,
-0.1921250820159912,
0.56634122133255,
-0.22161392867565155,
0.4541194438934326,
-0.6060834527015686,
-0.6329002380371094,
-0.8399694561958313,
-0.8717886209487915,
0.15567250549793243,
0.3764680325984955,
-1.2474663257598877,
-0.20395414531230927,
-0.13405612111091614,
-0.42163020372390747,
-0.8346092700958252,
0.6038628220558167,
0.3364938199520111,
0.2069709748029709,
0.35618042945861816,
-0.03684845194220543,
-0.5284844040870667,
-1.3890491724014282,
-0.08284638077020645,
0.050417181104421616,
-0.16151343286037445,
0.2968445122241974,
0.39079123735427856,
-0.3223116099834442,
0.5286585092544556,
-0.27801454067230225,
-0.27139467000961304,
-0.5921899080276489,
-0.040909022092819214,
-0.18371611833572388,
0.4528321325778961,
0.5561702251434326,
-0.5873885750770569,
-0.3374418020248413,
0.2080686241388321,
-0.8797827363014221,
-0.1371183544397354,
-0.07450516521930695,
-0.1578427255153656,
0.032556820660829544,
0.26292654871940613,
-0.6617594361305237,
0.06718595325946808,
0.6816921830177307,
-0.049057427793741226,
0.45294344425201416,
-0.2484866976737976,
0.08294908702373505,
-0.9466692209243774,
0.12621799111366272,
-0.14614121615886688,
-0.0006830087513662875,
-0.8890455961227417,
0.3681162893772125,
0.3926595449447632,
-0.2828214168548584,
-0.520206093788147,
0.6995639204978943,
-0.7097969055175781,
-0.08593571186065674,
-0.26067060232162476,
0.11085975915193558,
0.3097248077392578,
0.9620700478553772,
-0.09161149710416794,
0.5829614400863647,
0.5404797196388245,
-0.2665885388851166,
0.4256388545036316,
0.0641959086060524,
-0.414829820394516,
0.5679065585136414,
-0.5242084860801697,
0.01611858420073986,
-0.12695567309856415,
0.06360801309347153,
-0.9217920303344727,
-0.35864943265914917,
0.24808184802532196,
-0.18458914756774902,
0.24582476913928986,
0.04628320038318634,
-0.7387112975120544,
-0.2954722046852112,
-0.5474334955215454,
0.3269733190536499,
0.14048081636428833,
-0.5213289260864258,
0.9403638243675232,
0.3810391128063202,
-0.3413136601448059,
-0.5976873636245728,
-0.8296753764152527,
0.11931812763214111,
-0.14201070368289948,
-0.8562571406364441,
0.004198509268462658,
-0.15238088369369507,
-0.20462805032730103,
-0.45686882734298706,
0.2201608419418335,
0.06737618893384933,
-0.1118200421333313,
0.091929592192173,
0.42985647916793823,
-0.32881101965904236,
0.48208409547805786,
0.03768482804298401,
-0.10767969489097595,
-0.38771599531173706,
0.10792605578899384,
0.33912530541419983,
-0.18215134739875793,
-0.5424756407737732,
-0.5078024864196777,
0.5701587796211243,
0.9311268925666809,
-0.4316956698894501,
0.4733203649520874,
0.5148484110832214,
-0.1976429969072342,
-0.02635718137025833,
-0.4540325105190277,
-0.04875825718045235,
-0.4724288284778595,
0.36892813444137573,
-0.610447108745575,
-0.6557797789573669,
0.09258577972650528,
0.15718047320842743,
0.17501325905323029,
0.01865548826754093,
0.7959597110748291,
-0.3835535943508148,
1.1000463962554932,
0.6314237117767334,
0.1119171679019928,
0.706151008605957,
-0.02572050504386425,
0.06202606111764908,
-0.9620961546897888,
-0.31442010402679443,
-0.15276622772216797,
-0.3679644465446472,
-0.36483120918273926,
-0.7226330041885376,
0.5180451273918152,
-0.1631603240966797,
0.05480792373418808,
0.18202006816864014,
-0.14241981506347656,
0.26184648275375366,
0.5756648778915405,
0.11889483779668808,
0.32006189227104187,
0.15824846923351288,
-0.2904801666736603,
-0.07397536933422089,
-0.8415198922157288,
-0.4616623520851135,
0.9162839651107788,
0.5513187646865845,
1.0644416809082031,
0.25011277198791504,
0.41574811935424805,
-0.033007267862558365,
0.2323523461818695,
-0.7204297780990601,
0.644619882106781,
-0.027564818039536476,
-0.48479005694389343,
-0.19715332984924316,
-0.30768832564353943,
-0.7445962429046631,
1.016456127166748,
-0.5314393639564514,
-0.7330436110496521,
0.24259650707244873,
0.36130616068840027,
-0.31789150834083557,
0.17850665748119354,
-1.1341532468795776,
1.070665717124939,
-0.417214035987854,
-0.6461068391799927,
-0.3107858896255493,
-0.5190267562866211,
0.5807567238807678,
0.030794350430369377,
0.427651971578598,
-0.08171027153730392,
-0.15462927520275116,
0.34016621112823486,
-0.31234022974967957,
0.6538336873054504,
-0.16920381784439087,
-0.12955814599990845,
0.148734450340271,
0.05694602429866791,
0.3171205222606659,
-0.2607303559780121,
0.07078059762716293,
-0.19240309298038483,
-0.32003477215766907,
-0.6199743747711182,
-0.570447564125061,
0.7153745889663696,
-0.34808671474456787,
-0.22043484449386597,
0.008674466982483864,
-0.6995701789855957,
-0.3657717704772949,
0.31485819816589355,
-0.1024974137544632,
0.5682709217071533,
0.011529533192515373,
0.34700292348861694,
0.5165554285049438,
-0.40232929587364197,
0.33262354135513306,
0.26945140957832336,
-0.4800316393375397,
-0.3881828188896179,
1.075260877609253,
-0.024202153086662292,
0.3955322206020355,
0.49118292331695557,
0.022231394425034523,
-0.04872506856918335,
-0.41963499784469604,
-0.8348356485366821,
0.159047931432724,
-0.7607806921005249,
-0.08081331104040146,
-0.6551743149757385,
0.19919337332248688,
-0.290664941072464,
-0.09299427270889282,
-0.3953336179256439,
-0.40010643005371094,
-0.10981469601392746,
0.20159506797790527,
0.008001339621841908,
0.5232834815979004,
0.050005264580249786,
0.3343232572078705,
-0.5737341046333313,
0.6141133308410645,
0.6676367521286011,
0.21417762339115143,
0.10455333441495895,
-0.2834651470184326,
-0.31244730949401855,
-0.19089457392692566,
-0.2970065772533417,
-0.8173794746398926,
0.16859586536884308,
0.03440321981906891,
0.6784843802452087,
0.519402801990509,
-0.4784241020679474,
0.669333815574646,
-0.45606717467308044,
0.5377288460731506,
0.350495845079422,
-0.5620969533920288,
0.4659029245376587,
-0.3192066252231598,
0.6489163041114807,
0.35227251052856445,
-0.008525736629962921,
-0.24823230504989624,
-0.32301732897758484,
-0.2553318440914154,
-0.5052759647369385,
0.5986475348472595,
0.42012819647789,
-0.0659964457154274,
0.4180621802806854,
-0.4303288757801056,
-0.08272410184144974,
0.22550541162490845,
-0.7497003078460693,
-0.06853718310594559,
-0.01423546764999628,
-0.19080369174480438,
0.06402841210365295,
-0.4042954742908478,
0.08375752717256546,
-0.23803794384002686,
0.5563466548919678,
-0.3560747504234314,
0.13976366817951202,
-0.20145118236541748,
-0.376770943403244,
0.17621052265167236,
0.3717402517795563,
0.9642965197563171,
0.5308969020843506,
-0.036825940012931824,
0.24483069777488708,
0.33709248900413513,
-0.18034487962722778,
-0.1359228789806366,
0.05937504023313522,
0.1004147008061409,
0.0038306242786347866,
0.6078468561172485,
0.7424522638320923,
0.4547806978225708,
-0.9599325060844421,
0.4705035090446472,
-0.09397429972887039,
0.09664664417505264,
0.28617095947265625,
-0.12073344737291336,
0.3766947090625763,
0.3439185619354248,
0.19538216292858124,
0.13563722372055054,
0.24772872030735016,
-0.6798393130302429,
-0.18376567959785461,
0.4948987662792206,
0.04970809444785118,
-0.06641893833875656,
0.4542732834815979,
0.4563363492488861,
-0.04735485836863518,
0.24055717885494232,
-0.045445121824741364,
-0.28855329751968384,
0.15691551566123962,
0.2104085087776184,
0.4526469111442566,
-0.26204541325569153,
-0.08695369958877563,
0.12961284816265106,
0.5594848394393921,
0.26963967084884644,
0.36921387910842896,
-0.3208658695220947,
-0.585790753364563,
-0.3469553291797638,
-0.5686399340629578,
-0.38979363441467285,
-0.07534760236740112,
-0.18496228754520416,
0.39931631088256836,
-0.25101205706596375,
0.00833374448120594,
0.21002526581287384,
-0.20164069533348083,
-0.5579301118850708,
0.029524940997362137,
0.48987245559692383,
0.749661922454834,
-0.466686487197876,
1.091604232788086,
0.5550833344459534,
-0.3877767026424408,
-0.4143981337547302,
-0.5159574747085571,
0.23197120428085327,
-0.8960533142089844,
0.4846267104148865,
0.06736313551664352,
-0.5359371304512024,
-0.5999609231948853,
-0.3115185499191284,
-0.5052347779273987,
1.0623693466186523,
0.5080127120018005,
-0.7128466963768005,
-0.23700083792209625,
-0.1463598608970642,
0.43232589960098267,
-0.5128722786903381,
0.19495145976543427,
0.26741278171539307,
0.4950403869152069,
-0.03698944300413132,
-1.1465855836868286,
-0.30608221888542175,
-0.4682798683643341,
0.21935351192951202,
-0.11312279850244522,
-0.8395040035247803,
0.9991219639778137,
-0.4069918990135193,
-0.08085307478904724,
0.30750998854637146,
0.504085898399353,
0.4909006655216217,
0.2685830891132355,
0.4942125380039215,
0.22725564241409302,
0.5229077935218811,
0.12807221710681915,
1.022895097732544,
-0.08260782808065414,
0.10077539086341858,
1.084075689315796,
-0.14978118240833282,
0.9078370332717896,
0.8923146724700928,
0.06549305468797684,
0.2851097285747528,
0.3774878978729248,
0.24103622138500214,
0.5306984186172485,
-0.16788402199745178,
-0.11410658061504364,
-0.33870527148246765,
0.09906487166881561,
-0.24530789256095886,
0.5907857418060303,
0.43706321716308594,
-0.4948365390300751,
-0.1784864366054535,
0.38570722937583923,
-0.22399526834487915,
-0.11773592978715897,
-0.2421371340751648,
0.5959436297416687,
0.1235707551240921,
-0.38106444478034973,
0.502724289894104,
0.013529575429856777,
0.6287550926208496,
-0.6946666240692139,
0.0034762630239129066,
-0.33505797386169434,
0.16898253560066223,
0.005736908875405788,
-0.5469481945037842,
-0.02241552248597145,
-0.04415947571396828,
0.08695726096630096,
-0.4293845295906067,
0.9570251107215881,
-0.42653366923332214,
-0.5261967182159424,
0.2912798821926117,
0.6396167874336243,
0.052068281918764114,
0.14616243541240692,
-0.6756616830825806,
0.6087367534637451,
-0.04061375558376312,
-0.21399226784706116,
0.19905030727386475,
0.21887919306755066,
0.10474777966737747,
1.0555936098098755,
0.5102155208587646,
-0.028236592188477516,
0.037493351846933365,
0.14595812559127808,
0.9145662188529968,
-0.21744371950626373,
-0.47146835923194885,
-0.7546886205673218,
0.5774440169334412,
-0.1997658908367157,
-0.2165711671113968,
0.6619603633880615,
0.5640084147453308,
0.5447583794593811,
-0.2736460566520691,
0.5239329934120178,
0.12587395310401917,
0.42367374897003174,
-0.80759596824646,
0.5942589640617371,
-1.1181977987289429,
0.1472361981868744,
-0.3669830560684204,
-0.7245884537696838,
-0.4019005000591278,
0.7842695116996765,
-0.04373787343502045,
0.03142699971795082,
0.5106881260871887,
0.9862352609634399,
-0.3086259961128235,
-0.026289265602827072,
0.655177116394043,
-0.01409992016851902,
0.2067926973104477,
0.7485728859901428,
1.0945791006088257,
-0.1630571335554123,
0.6479371786117554,
-0.3054661750793457,
-0.21598085761070251,
-0.623655378818512,
-0.5512071847915649,
-0.9021350741386414,
-0.47903597354888916,
0.17985454201698303,
0.16822288930416107,
-0.07283806055784225,
0.919708788394928,
0.9797991514205933,
-0.4481397569179535,
-0.28884828090667725,
0.5364571213722229,
0.17882519960403442,
-0.08631312847137451,
-0.12174225598573685,
0.08053377270698547,
-0.20800438523292542,
-0.9008507132530212,
0.6392667889595032,
0.6154214143753052,
0.06959005445241928,
-0.6876946687698364,
-0.27831825613975525,
-0.2350568175315857,
0.0971749797463417,
1.056504249572754,
0.18264184892177582,
-0.9375039935112,
-0.1820828765630722,
-0.02624908648431301,
-0.4115208387374878,
0.01587609574198723,
0.8068711757659912,
-0.4057486355304718,
0.880088746547699,
0.5232843160629272,
0.4942385256290436,
0.35512396693229675,
-0.4025267958641052,
0.5297105312347412,
-0.6301387548446655,
0.41335898637771606,
-0.0790858045220375,
0.8883773684501648,
0.43061792850494385,
0.07143430411815643,
0.37839406728744507,
-0.08334774523973465,
-0.1740705817937851,
-0.9139159321784973,
0.2671593427658081,
-1.2331793308258057,
-0.3656139671802521,
0.967684805393219,
0.14424338936805725,
-0.1643638163805008,
0.24040886759757996,
-0.7223966121673584,
-0.2296505570411682,
-0.36427924036979675,
0.49995550513267517,
0.5498049259185791,
-0.3215213716030121,
-0.4980534613132477,
-0.7697029709815979,
0.17654909193515778,
0.4250829517841339,
-0.8388808965682983,
0.058486875146627426,
0.505695104598999,
-0.0290030799806118,
0.3341653048992157,
0.8932101130485535,
0.10662955045700073,
0.4092414379119873,
0.11503145098686218,
0.07955388724803925,
-0.10559336841106415,
-0.7095781564712524,
-0.16869482398033142,
0.292011022567749,
0.16909512877464294,
-0.4302707016468048
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06149v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06149v2
|
Can Large Language Models Automatically Score Proficiency of Written Essays?
| 2024-03-10T09:39:00 | 2024-04-16T00:24:55 |
Watheq Mansour, Salam Albatarni, Sohaila Eltanbouly, Tamer Elsayed
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Although several methods were proposed to address the problem of automated
essay scoring (AES) in the last 50 years, there is still much to desire in
terms of effectiveness. Large Language Models (LLMs) are transformer-based
models that demonstrate extraordinary capabilities on various tasks. In this
paper, we test the ability of LLMs, given their powerful linguistic knowledge,
to analyze and effectively score written essays. We experimented with two
popular LLMs, namely ChatGPT and Llama. We aim to check if these models can do
this task and, if so, how their performance is positioned among the
state-of-the-art (SOTA) models across two levels, holistically and per
individual writing trait. We utilized prompt-engineering tactics in designing
four different prompts to bring their maximum potential to this task. Our
experiments conducted on the ASAP dataset revealed several interesting
observations. First, choosing the right prompt depends highly on the model and
nature of the task. Second, the two LLMs exhibited comparable average
performance in AES, with a slight advantage for ChatGPT. Finally, despite the
performance gap between the two LLMs and SOTA models in terms of predictions,
they provide feedback to enhance the quality of the essays, which can
potentially help both teachers and students.
|
[
-0.26526620984077454,
-0.9307525753974915,
0.8715066909790039,
0.4644671082496643,
0.04077601432800293,
0.27837446331977844,
-0.3595285713672638,
-0.6733482480049133,
0.10529264062643051,
0.4551922082901001,
-0.3407982289791107,
-0.5431777238845825,
-0.6053735613822937,
0.5481477379798889,
-0.4893214702606201,
0.9563729763031006,
-0.31060758233070374,
0.11821763217449188,
-0.41595977544784546,
0.13599514961242676,
-0.44486409425735474,
-0.3400261700153351,
-0.9092335104942322,
-0.08202998340129852,
0.7161111831665039,
0.29402172565460205,
0.2734719216823578,
0.4723338782787323,
0.7831515073776245,
0.32336488366127014,
-0.04000331461429596,
0.13560496270656586,
-0.29742446541786194,
0.2945570945739746,
-0.008315124548971653,
-0.6205652952194214,
-0.39925408363342285,
0.1472354680299759,
0.8136746287345886,
0.5382809638977051,
0.08839141577482224,
0.19979573786258698,
0.413224458694458,
0.1808304339647293,
-0.2110881358385086,
0.13439276814460754,
-0.5891538858413696,
-0.015498265624046326,
-0.037616755813360214,
-0.04264789819717407,
-0.7200605273246765,
-0.49022001028060913,
-0.035559821873903275,
-0.36073094606399536,
-0.23261086642742157,
0.2397344559431076,
0.7601229548454285,
0.22387444972991943,
-0.43830737471580505,
-0.4097691774368286,
-0.561257004737854,
0.8602214455604553,
-0.7521538138389587,
0.03693654015660286,
-0.03045150265097618,
0.31585222482681274,
-0.14335516095161438,
-0.5771493315696716,
-0.6192700266838074,
-0.661897599697113,
-0.03781058266758919,
0.09726006537675858,
0.03566296026110649,
0.1326531022787094,
0.37321460247039795,
0.44174888730049133,
-0.5789692997932434,
0.5895135402679443,
-0.22145545482635498,
-0.11264444887638092,
0.6398406028747559,
0.38746410608291626,
0.4097263813018799,
-0.23964768648147583,
-0.27417635917663574,
0.029666664078831673,
-0.6806933283805847,
0.4847441613674164,
0.451019823551178,
0.29359114170074463,
0.027851758524775505,
0.8522723913192749,
0.1796812266111374,
0.48514890670776367,
-0.0861557275056839,
-0.31244611740112305,
-0.20880216360092163,
0.06548479199409485,
0.013670905493199825,
-0.26137053966522217,
0.9289063811302185,
0.4061669111251831,
0.522382378578186,
-0.012235090136528015,
-0.5183004140853882,
0.054139379411935806,
0.10507917404174805,
-0.728413462638855,
0.0431288480758667,
-0.021733632311224937,
-0.37536782026290894,
-0.38497158885002136,
-0.16909395158290863,
-0.7806932330131531,
-0.48811179399490356,
-0.40280410647392273,
0.6651002168655396,
-0.2127654105424881,
0.03816965967416763,
-0.08235841989517212,
0.08939109742641449,
0.44003382325172424,
0.2950877249240875,
-0.7575624585151672,
0.36314964294433594,
0.8423870205879211,
0.9121063351631165,
-0.5143749117851257,
-0.5852324366569519,
-0.43940281867980957,
-0.3290070593357086,
-0.6091616749763489,
1.0729187726974487,
-0.8489406108856201,
-0.45291587710380554,
0.23103025555610657,
-0.14811241626739502,
-0.3505927324295044,
-0.34430238604545593,
0.6885117888450623,
-0.5482735633850098,
0.1996138095855713,
-0.37050309777259827,
-0.8616930842399597,
-0.036469925194978714,
0.34115299582481384,
-0.5784844756126404,
1.1463521718978882,
-0.16162067651748657,
-0.6177781224250793,
0.049250341951847076,
-0.6145507097244263,
-0.42327433824539185,
-0.11941538006067276,
-0.1303422600030899,
-0.25511637330055237,
0.10967990756034851,
0.050815824419260025,
0.7970073819160461,
-0.47021856904029846,
0.1964597851037979,
-0.14737141132354736,
-0.5097358226776123,
0.5254233479499817,
-0.5134788751602173,
0.44442346692085266,
-0.09622109681367874,
-0.25461545586586,
-0.08676730841398239,
-0.7365026473999023,
-0.027752675116062164,
0.003095871303230524,
-0.6166691184043884,
-0.08420304954051971,
-0.10018850862979889,
-0.07604465633630753,
0.142181396484375,
0.2586580216884613,
-0.5776727199554443,
0.3854983448982239,
-0.3791569471359253,
0.3909999430179596,
0.9198616147041321,
0.06425812095403671,
0.08518150448799133,
-0.5469198226928711,
0.7815341353416443,
-0.4456598460674286,
-0.22532311081886292,
-0.42524445056915283,
-0.6095464825630188,
-0.7616560459136963,
-0.44508418440818787,
0.383739173412323,
0.6509953141212463,
-0.3385780453681946,
0.4297367334365845,
-0.18051661550998688,
-0.693634569644928,
-0.5170121788978577,
0.012876499444246292,
0.2632902264595032,
0.4983415901660919,
0.17491665482521057,
-0.01043867040425539,
-0.2753070592880249,
-0.6803962588310242,
-0.4557952582836151,
-0.1711668223142624,
-0.10993890464305878,
0.3416983187198639,
0.5812161564826965,
0.09349106252193451,
0.8625509738922119,
-0.5713857412338257,
-0.04525427520275116,
-0.5034911036491394,
0.2974204123020172,
0.2392512708902359,
0.19943349063396454,
0.4817892909049988,
-0.3627307415008545,
-0.7891251444816589,
-0.1729663759469986,
-0.6098198890686035,
-0.5991986989974976,
-0.14072631299495697,
0.04792507365345955,
0.33614587783813477,
0.5730805993080139,
-0.7421531081199646,
0.15655261278152466,
0.5271291732788086,
-0.25864753127098083,
0.870631992816925,
-0.07750880718231201,
0.4606224596500397,
-0.9797109365463257,
0.16563722491264343,
0.12752659618854523,
-0.13526111841201782,
-0.49817734956741333,
0.11520293354988098,
0.02118459902703762,
-0.08054496347904205,
-0.12978427112102509,
0.6239106059074402,
-0.0870063528418541,
0.06730633974075317,
-0.36066681146621704,
-0.11589895188808441,
0.14735861122608185,
0.5067970156669617,
-0.1327064037322998,
0.8491562604904175,
0.4473173916339874,
-0.4266636371612549,
0.17701008915901184,
-0.06951245665550232,
-0.4382875859737396,
0.5478708744049072,
-0.8172805309295654,
0.12457764148712158,
-0.17565438151359558,
0.27813318371772766,
-1.5772870779037476,
-0.3235372304916382,
-0.3614353835582733,
-0.4014297127723694,
0.2957209348678589,
0.20920324325561523,
-0.40654194355010986,
-0.23674514889717102,
-0.38477593660354614,
-0.006291396450251341,
0.5060839653015137,
-0.4167698621749878,
0.8724644780158997,
0.18708856403827667,
-0.5725597143173218,
-0.3816089630126953,
-0.4755609333515167,
0.18977387249469757,
-0.29028722643852234,
-0.6630178093910217,
0.1587989628314972,
-0.19437983632087708,
-0.3855059742927551,
-0.24320147931575775,
0.2983703017234802,
0.05009785667061806,
0.0762050524353981,
0.3415520489215851,
0.5383408665657043,
-0.38353368639945984,
0.3501684069633484,
0.0625830590724945,
-0.03467355668544769,
0.17857518792152405,
-0.163544163107872,
0.5275132656097412,
0.008005562238395214,
-0.5079342126846313,
-0.34706899523735046,
0.5677692294120789,
0.8538301587104797,
-0.37255430221557617,
0.8795980215072632,
0.2513410449028015,
-0.27862513065338135,
-0.3953767418861389,
-0.9400374293327332,
-0.22270120680332184,
-0.4391060471534729,
0.20475809276103973,
-0.3854553699493408,
-1.1141297817230225,
0.642672598361969,
-0.0614020973443985,
0.39900004863739014,
0.625660240650177,
0.4536094665527344,
-0.2691258192062378,
1.0668503046035767,
0.6161519289016724,
-0.19382765889167786,
0.1376965492963791,
-0.18218891322612762,
0.524159848690033,
-0.6454581618309021,
-0.09045732021331787,
-0.8356818556785583,
-0.25666701793670654,
-0.6194436550140381,
-0.14083045721054077,
0.5649704337120056,
-0.2223869264125824,
-0.201178640127182,
0.02207352966070175,
-0.28622207045555115,
0.6186354756355286,
0.2976802587509155,
-0.2572108507156372,
0.3100672960281372,
-0.15006771683692932,
-0.35701489448547363,
-0.10586642473936081,
-0.4111967086791992,
-0.9274625778198242,
1.0772578716278076,
0.539635419845581,
0.567101240158081,
-0.2549745738506317,
0.3980333209037781,
0.24078823626041412,
0.31654104590415955,
-0.6827528476715088,
0.8955284953117371,
-0.23767930269241333,
-0.38443368673324585,
-0.37726953625679016,
-0.22144921123981476,
-0.5735834836959839,
0.039125919342041016,
-0.18464812636375427,
-0.6472282409667969,
-0.0958549752831459,
-0.05434727296233177,
-0.5395071506500244,
0.20481964945793152,
-0.6120643615722656,
0.7480336427688599,
-0.08652927726507187,
-0.3844969570636749,
-0.05262380465865135,
-0.32785752415657043,
0.22519026696681976,
-0.3475172519683838,
0.12892945110797882,
-0.09098012000322342,
-0.026040490716695786,
0.880079984664917,
-0.04189300164580345,
0.940892219543457,
0.10158854722976685,
-0.21058465540409088,
0.5429310202598572,
0.12282971292734146,
0.6569225788116455,
-0.18816156685352325,
-0.3970656991004944,
0.11050309240818024,
-0.08384118229150772,
-0.025046052411198616,
-0.5996525287628174,
0.794008731842041,
-0.8114418983459473,
-0.7605717182159424,
-0.2737876772880554,
-0.25847339630126953,
-0.20437400043010712,
0.04825419932603836,
0.2078516036272049,
0.43739399313926697,
-0.22506177425384521,
0.14469541609287262,
0.6853099465370178,
-0.2244657725095749,
0.5560889840126038,
0.6715096831321716,
-0.20574787259101868,
-0.1076209619641304,
0.7241260409355164,
0.3950785994529724,
0.10577449947595596,
0.4472495913505554,
0.3640671372413635,
-0.3746374845504761,
-0.4948919713497162,
-0.39702820777893066,
0.3025739789009094,
-0.9140567183494568,
-0.07048872858285904,
-0.908379852771759,
-0.39931225776672363,
-0.3644077479839325,
-0.4863074719905853,
-0.2337036430835724,
-0.29705843329429626,
-0.1909112185239792,
-0.308925062417984,
0.24910441040992737,
0.783837080001831,
0.18287187814712524,
0.19356873631477356,
-0.6891970634460449,
0.03697052225470543,
0.4098016321659088,
0.22333583235740662,
0.1463913470506668,
-0.8253965377807617,
0.12174926698207855,
-0.28247982263565063,
-0.2550254166126251,
-0.7218953371047974,
0.14696857333183289,
0.07553444802761078,
0.3212810158729553,
0.2867949903011322,
-0.2537182569503784,
0.25383779406547546,
-0.6269459128379822,
1.0682724714279175,
-0.2302393764257431,
-0.9112291932106018,
0.1957603543996811,
-0.4586887061595917,
0.10457601398229599,
0.5446517467498779,
0.5291854739189148,
-0.6566326022148132,
-0.6406744122505188,
-0.19873838126659393,
-0.6415437459945679,
0.4205177426338196,
-0.1757746934890747,
0.42387792468070984,
0.06495911628007889,
0.501383900642395,
0.3633507192134857,
0.08829652518033981,
-0.8905181288719177,
0.25134944915771484,
0.1970129907131195,
-0.6191555261611938,
-0.14090029895305634,
-0.4053865671157837,
0.27790188789367676,
-0.049462027847766876,
0.6896269917488098,
-0.06920753419399261,
0.04843739792704582,
0.08209913223981857,
0.19880375266075134,
-0.057267315685749054,
0.27366456389427185,
0.4658137559890747,
0.5294499397277832,
0.28354763984680176,
0.08872778713703156,
0.49504217505455017,
-0.5111071467399597,
0.30721279978752136,
-0.09016601741313934,
-0.21723999083042145,
-0.18032656610012054,
0.715125322341919,
0.5654536485671997,
0.11575488746166229,
-0.9000383615493774,
0.6540244221687317,
-0.0357830636203289,
-0.12247738242149353,
-0.2773902416229248,
0.32271701097488403,
0.1626751869916916,
0.24977079033851624,
0.2731941044330597,
-0.15196289122104645,
-0.04530925303697586,
-0.4748748540878296,
-0.16866423189640045,
0.44938018918037415,
-0.04233919456601143,
-0.24840259552001953,
0.41473445296287537,
0.19944414496421814,
-0.5232531428337097,
0.4101836681365967,
-0.06981416046619415,
-0.5710715651512146,
0.6940953731536865,
0.5158354640007019,
0.7881889343261719,
-0.5296303033828735,
0.208274707198143,
0.28392353653907776,
0.3662349283695221,
-0.218528613448143,
0.20261850953102112,
0.1793852001428604,
-0.4506131112575531,
-0.7445172667503357,
-0.9759652614593506,
-0.47343990206718445,
0.21869824826717377,
-0.20021851360797882,
0.5159657597541809,
-0.2883511781692505,
-0.010931236669421196,
0.02141675353050232,
0.16586658358573914,
-0.5358560085296631,
0.2830510139465332,
-0.07053252309560776,
0.8943014740943909,
-1.099790096282959,
0.34921541810035706,
0.7927829027175903,
-0.139158234000206,
-1.1169816255569458,
0.09916236251592636,
-0.20716769993305206,
-0.6109203696250916,
0.5597198605537415,
0.40151092410087585,
-0.10942443460226059,
0.0808839350938797,
-0.3657098412513733,
-0.8336467742919922,
0.7548141479492188,
0.14543959498405457,
-0.6120811104774475,
-0.0481528677046299,
0.5185202360153198,
0.8606252074241638,
-0.5004091858863831,
0.6581683158874512,
0.4903416335582733,
0.5791715979576111,
0.05132312700152397,
-1.0158183574676514,
-0.1914229393005371,
-0.21871131658554077,
-0.09550656378269196,
-0.07155390083789825,
-0.6716156005859375,
0.9425174593925476,
0.01429186761379242,
-0.038790516555309296,
0.06425178050994873,
0.5977973937988281,
0.17391666769981384,
0.34483638405799866,
0.5132989287376404,
0.4396568238735199,
0.7516220808029175,
-0.006264118477702141,
0.9602401852607727,
-0.2799610197544098,
-0.03140240162611008,
0.5167691111564636,
-0.5588407516479492,
1.007827877998352,
0.16977325081825256,
-0.10853910446166992,
0.4790038466453552,
0.4789251685142517,
-0.02729264833033085,
0.11611604690551758,
0.3377246558666229,
-0.2736898362636566,
-0.36891117691993713,
-0.16041885316371918,
0.08976512402296066,
0.7817928791046143,
0.12811441719532013,
-0.35788366198539734,
0.033801883459091187,
0.3238455355167389,
0.15381868183612823,
0.32146236300468445,
-0.39175206422805786,
0.7580394148826599,
0.16662804782390594,
-1.3015391826629639,
0.1842939853668213,
0.22861063480377197,
0.5634282827377319,
-0.4835541546344757,
-0.04728920757770538,
-0.33179956674575806,
0.01568945311009884,
-0.02663434110581875,
-0.8714700937271118,
0.11932028084993362,
0.48294857144355774,
-0.06634251028299332,
-0.09462499618530273,
0.8165901303291321,
-0.3012896180152893,
-0.8068546652793884,
0.06566205620765686,
0.33622583746910095,
0.08268821239471436,
0.1251000165939331,
-0.1394333839416504,
0.14161990582942963,
-0.25777649879455566,
-0.4459674656391144,
0.21114663779735565,
0.44228309392929077,
-0.04547158256173134,
0.6139852404594421,
0.5201393365859985,
0.14384663105010986,
-0.014690169133245945,
-0.06531507521867752,
0.661611020565033,
-0.36743631958961487,
-0.5552206039428711,
-1.0283509492874146,
0.40723147988319397,
-0.12501218914985657,
-0.35601192712783813,
0.8115925192832947,
0.47669488191604614,
0.47511059045791626,
-0.0019047129899263382,
0.9113824367523193,
0.2967514097690582,
0.8970975875854492,
-0.6456479430198669,
0.626621663570404,
-0.40692150592803955,
0.27811500430107117,
-0.3017856180667877,
-1.117748737335205,
-0.2603733539581299,
0.5599534511566162,
-0.564598560333252,
0.10452209413051605,
0.8085273504257202,
0.9267516136169434,
0.18573714792728424,
0.2702387571334839,
0.316964328289032,
0.253781259059906,
0.47885021567344666,
0.5944227576255798,
1.165924310684204,
-0.11250648647546768,
0.33476099371910095,
0.10653211176395416,
-0.3879857659339905,
-0.2294674962759018,
-0.8892572522163391,
-1.2276794910430908,
-0.5792117118835449,
-0.21340863406658173,
0.07465149462223053,
0.02981565333902836,
0.874366044998169,
0.058012474328279495,
-0.5132958889007568,
-0.10034886002540588,
0.1301933228969574,
-0.03280061110854149,
0.08710961788892746,
-0.19710059463977814,
0.43612292408943176,
-0.38849079608917236,
-0.7007520794868469,
0.2470119297504425,
0.41403862833976746,
0.03788653761148453,
-0.4983011484146118,
0.2241116613149643,
0.18735429644584656,
0.7478018403053284,
0.394204318523407,
-0.12369690835475922,
-0.5446128845214844,
-0.49385806918144226,
0.37986838817596436,
-0.4545127749443054,
-0.13438299298286438,
0.7316186428070068,
-0.4246416687965393,
-0.07728602737188339,
0.6270450949668884,
0.6994972229003906,
-0.062273476272821426,
-0.1276927888393402,
0.3166157007217407,
-0.32671216130256653,
-0.4112478792667389,
0.37353333830833435,
0.44696882367134094,
0.3413340747356415,
-0.404414564371109,
0.0885777398943901,
-0.04718002676963806,
-1.0238908529281616,
-0.80695641040802,
-0.15793675184249878,
-0.5831329226493835,
-0.21138691902160645,
1.2820472717285156,
-0.42922940850257874,
-0.07852761447429657,
0.15504303574562073,
-0.4516870379447937,
0.059242889285087585,
-0.03851104527711868,
1.2520784139633179,
1.2033249139785767,
0.01989205926656723,
-0.0024609710089862347,
-0.6233786940574646,
0.4641791582107544,
0.5404648184776306,
-0.8958452939987183,
-0.000024024588128668256,
0.25991085171699524,
0.13711640238761902,
0.1751190572977066,
0.5335614085197449,
0.2268226444721222,
0.19861771166324615,
-0.18867337703704834,
-0.16876278817653656,
0.020803844556212425,
-0.5629276037216187,
-0.3233070373535156,
0.5480898022651672,
0.33252033591270447,
0.265445739030838
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06139v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06139v1
|
Fine-grainedly Synthesize Streaming Data Based On Large Language Models With Graph Structure Understanding For Data Sparsity
| 2024-03-10T08:59:04 | 2024-03-10T08:59:04 |
Xin Zhang, Linhai Zhang, Deyu Zhou, Guoqiang Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Due to the sparsity of user data, sentiment analysis on user reviews in
e-commerce platforms often suffers from poor performance, especially when faced
with extremely sparse user data or long-tail labels. Recently, the emergence of
LLMs has introduced new solutions to such problems by leveraging graph
structures to generate supplementary user profiles. However, previous
approaches have not fully utilized the graph understanding capabilities of LLMs
and have struggled to adapt to complex streaming data environments. In this
work, we propose a fine-grained streaming data synthesis framework that
categorizes sparse users into three categories: Mid-tail, Long-tail, and
Extreme. Specifically, we design LLMs to comprehensively understand three key
graph elements in streaming data, including Local-global Graph Understanding,
Second-Order Relationship Extraction, and Product Attribute Understanding,
which enables the generation of high-quality synthetic data to effectively
address sparsity across different categories. Experimental results on three
real datasets demonstrate significant performance improvements, with
synthesized data contributing to MSE reductions of 45.85%, 3.16%, and 62.21%,
respectively.
|
[
-0.7422162890434265,
-0.9716972708702087,
0.3650781512260437,
0.054092466831207275,
-0.13469643890857697,
0.41691112518310547,
-0.11531835049390793,
-0.4494416117668152,
0.7367977499961853,
0.5344705581665039,
-0.7320830225944519,
-0.7139937877655029,
-0.21090386807918549,
0.03853771835565567,
-0.6472037434577942,
1.3409911394119263,
-0.014437406323850155,
-0.32991495728492737,
-0.013622925616800785,
-0.11504215002059937,
-0.11231043934822083,
-0.6733731627464294,
-0.5496757626533508,
-0.06810422986745834,
0.8672032356262207,
0.43527230620384216,
0.8353005647659302,
0.4321742057800293,
0.20325669646263123,
0.31485486030578613,
0.06643066555261612,
0.567545473575592,
-1.1070985794067383,
0.31784477829933167,
-0.09663547575473785,
-0.07755239307880402,
-0.784540593624115,
-0.24388855695724487,
0.542293906211853,
0.8164040446281433,
0.10739748924970627,
0.46047350764274597,
0.5999759435653687,
0.8108698725700378,
-0.34937798976898193,
0.17749518156051636,
-0.5993911623954773,
0.05451878905296326,
-0.21240094304084778,
-0.1476181447505951,
-0.3260754346847534,
-0.011047473177313805,
-0.17457565665245056,
-0.7188853621482849,
0.6266253590583801,
0.19654253125190735,
0.9235262274742126,
0.06291560083627701,
-0.0448291152715683,
-0.03965197131037712,
-0.787677526473999,
0.46115386486053467,
-0.551301121711731,
0.3908214867115021,
0.2258986234664917,
0.42726078629493713,
-0.371322900056839,
-0.8327263593673706,
-0.4881693720817566,
0.2965528666973114,
-0.08205149322748184,
0.13689909875392914,
-0.39523643255233765,
-0.001625875593163073,
-0.14181160926818848,
0.2835383713245392,
-0.7436253428459167,
0.046262893825769424,
-0.2642940580844879,
-0.15553246438503265,
0.8658673167228699,
0.46102121472358704,
0.01274816133081913,
-0.2269035428762436,
-0.2947717308998108,
0.07052399218082428,
-0.6794864535331726,
-0.020544830709695816,
0.6380029320716858,
0.7839387655258179,
0.04763631150126457,
0.6284136176109314,
-0.37911325693130493,
0.584014892578125,
0.005979661829769611,
0.04184112697839737,
0.29284968972206116,
-0.11818929016590118,
-0.2583076059818268,
-0.2608494758605957,
0.7299065589904785,
0.5548776388168335,
0.23294959962368011,
-0.1968010812997818,
-0.5040494203567505,
0.1275559514760971,
0.13107015192508698,
-0.893878161907196,
-0.09237971156835556,
0.3466167747974396,
-0.692118227481842,
-0.25809940695762634,
0.04274710640311241,
-0.9045560956001282,
-0.5208332538604736,
-0.39671969413757324,
0.0916411504149437,
0.002747330581769347,
-0.19327183067798615,
0.10620064288377762,
0.22753553092479706,
-0.3730296790599823,
0.2630588710308075,
-0.702028751373291,
0.7274001240730286,
0.8016027212142944,
0.8926703929901123,
-0.2447158843278885,
-0.3438512086868286,
-0.7236824631690979,
0.27454280853271484,
-0.1350286453962326,
0.8980133533477783,
-0.38029876351356506,
-0.1583339422941208,
0.040982846170663834,
0.007755982223898172,
0.21475869417190552,
-0.502299427986145,
0.33363789319992065,
-0.39364519715309143,
-0.32751762866973877,
-0.13109968602657318,
-0.668512225151062,
-0.13240081071853638,
0.2770143151283264,
-0.7036713361740112,
1.0567445755004883,
0.3603079915046692,
-0.5134137868881226,
0.15699976682662964,
-0.22060318291187286,
-0.4685222804546356,
0.28858569264411926,
0.14006061851978302,
-0.3423576354980469,
0.35933154821395874,
0.21914207935333252,
0.8455976247787476,
0.023267723619937897,
0.24189238250255585,
-0.7587834000587463,
-0.5060774683952332,
0.6362963914871216,
-0.34776511788368225,
-0.041391897946596146,
0.6389747858047485,
0.26881763339042664,
-0.05029363930225372,
-0.9255406856536865,
-0.0748523473739624,
0.09163901209831238,
-0.1857941448688507,
-0.12168583273887634,
0.5475433468818665,
0.6304078698158264,
0.07747110724449158,
-0.20633742213249207,
-0.25614258646965027,
0.13994565606117249,
-0.46370482444763184,
0.7330912351608276,
0.7227293848991394,
0.07002008706331253,
0.16062340140342712,
-0.152383953332901,
0.4162607789039612,
-0.07666115462779999,
0.0666620209813118,
0.00022539234487339854,
-0.2360215187072754,
-0.7729073166847229,
-0.13381457328796387,
0.06205713748931885,
0.17242023348808289,
-0.4553166925907135,
0.4024488627910614,
-0.6122565865516663,
-0.02253602258861065,
-0.45157957077026367,
0.5285601615905762,
0.09909269958734512,
0.34079742431640625,
0.29955509305000305,
-0.4466603398323059,
-0.4620511829853058,
-0.8254963159561157,
-0.14731240272521973,
-0.07862645387649536,
-0.28724217414855957,
0.4447628855705261,
0.1425684690475464,
-0.4868270456790924,
0.9514700770378113,
-0.8878346681594849,
-0.5250439643859863,
-0.4911663234233856,
-0.04146084189414978,
0.19117681682109833,
0.22462308406829834,
0.39131960272789,
-0.3737592101097107,
-0.540992259979248,
0.0589711032807827,
-0.19256024062633514,
-0.2819451093673706,
-0.24137471616268158,
-0.3095075488090515,
0.12873747944831848,
0.2170170545578003,
-0.5329145789146423,
0.21924112737178802,
0.5021755695343018,
-0.19855009019374847,
0.046557579189538956,
0.253069132566452,
-0.15128682553768158,
-1.1610394716262817,
-0.12431147694587708,
0.456739217042923,
-0.5340455770492554,
-0.7006686329841614,
-0.23566481471061707,
-0.4343629479408264,
-0.28326505422592163,
-0.275706946849823,
0.5102007389068604,
-0.312846839427948,
-0.36559250950813293,
-0.21356721222400665,
0.4177172780036926,
0.1228625699877739,
0.5566098093986511,
-0.05894971266388893,
0.4765291213989258,
0.2186182737350464,
-0.3788187503814697,
0.07433877885341644,
0.1324440985918045,
-0.2422841638326645,
0.3731892704963684,
-0.6883042454719543,
-0.0651685819029808,
-0.10386059433221817,
0.25819385051727295,
-1.4558196067810059,
-0.6792985796928406,
0.26439300179481506,
-0.4919666647911072,
0.33373063802719116,
-0.6455110311508179,
-0.6061335802078247,
-0.312538206577301,
-0.26871365308761597,
0.16632845997810364,
0.4978328049182892,
-0.36516329646110535,
0.46413153409957886,
0.6546478271484375,
-0.3456250727176666,
-0.19935443997383118,
-0.674403727054596,
0.15483245253562927,
-0.22414082288742065,
-0.9435379505157471,
0.3042636513710022,
-0.04162014648318291,
-0.11617782711982727,
0.0071434383280575275,
-0.05391855165362358,
-0.07145486027002335,
-0.010447232984006405,
0.09288456290960312,
0.25124824047088623,
-0.002092363778501749,
0.03197440505027771,
0.050880175083875656,
-0.2339380979537964,
-0.09819741547107697,
-0.07201429456472397,
0.5217702388763428,
-0.20605583488941193,
-0.21298032999038696,
-0.35637274384498596,
0.30147600173950195,
0.3724258244037628,
0.306767076253891,
0.33124908804893494,
0.6874210834503174,
-0.16177880764007568,
-0.7859976887702942,
-0.4902012050151825,
-0.1502787470817566,
-0.501610517501831,
0.4439193606376648,
-0.32750144600868225,
-1.0596824884414673,
0.7263560891151428,
0.09306240826845169,
-0.12811675667762756,
0.10800515860319138,
0.6514624357223511,
-0.38515999913215637,
1.3477816581726074,
0.13536830246448517,
-0.07841001451015472,
0.37373843789100647,
-0.27083465456962585,
0.453823983669281,
-0.4873807430267334,
-0.02047671377658844,
-0.3292786478996277,
-0.6373379230499268,
-0.663956880569458,
-0.24537824094295502,
0.40552160143852234,
0.06724528968334198,
-0.14691725373268127,
-0.01203009020537138,
-0.4913720190525055,
0.5271711349487305,
0.035110656172037125,
0.20210932195186615,
0.10852762311697006,
0.623329222202301,
0.46234437823295593,
0.033868446946144104,
-0.3512144982814789,
-0.5754343867301941,
0.7835094928741455,
0.4479752779006958,
1.0171916484832764,
0.022040072828531265,
0.5001100897789001,
0.613278865814209,
0.08566813915967941,
-0.9859749674797058,
0.46420323848724365,
-0.35556894540786743,
-0.239455446600914,
0.1113826259970665,
-0.511466920375824,
-1.0142625570297241,
0.3742219805717468,
-0.2815820872783661,
-0.684388279914856,
-0.11952632665634155,
0.39352500438690186,
-0.2949780523777008,
0.15192370116710663,
-0.8508375883102417,
0.6679544448852539,
-0.06317625939846039,
-0.7406395673751831,
-0.00649278936907649,
-0.5668582320213318,
0.3284848630428314,
0.14550736546516418,
0.45885834097862244,
-0.365263968706131,
0.11236687004566193,
0.5301162600517273,
-0.7724612951278687,
0.9355341792106628,
-0.16936597228050232,
0.1979215145111084,
0.492341548204422,
0.466318815946579,
0.6518616080284119,
0.28316712379455566,
0.2612559497356415,
0.14159685373306274,
-0.1500551700592041,
-0.3847213089466095,
-0.5868995189666748,
0.9813457727432251,
-0.7534684538841248,
-0.44533079862594604,
-0.06605561077594757,
-0.43315351009368896,
-0.6380591988563538,
-0.02681753970682621,
-0.19358739256858826,
0.34272345900535583,
-0.09631530195474625,
0.11519252508878708,
0.42023587226867676,
0.11482948064804077,
0.2842366099357605,
0.3190157115459442,
-0.363042414188385,
-0.5879271030426025,
1.1048774719238281,
0.2870877683162689,
0.06519320607185364,
0.06863130629062653,
0.030084948986768723,
-0.24257376790046692,
-0.688957154750824,
-0.5713010430335999,
0.2772468328475952,
-0.5424257516860962,
-0.37691730260849,
-0.6025772094726562,
-0.24312350153923035,
-0.18080951273441315,
-0.37549614906311035,
-0.4083850681781769,
-0.386781245470047,
-0.5200036764144897,
-0.2945476174354553,
0.3870476186275482,
0.8244082927703857,
0.2372024655342102,
0.4602280855178833,
-1.0631396770477295,
0.2803988754749298,
-0.027810441330075264,
0.5713921189308167,
0.27981558442115784,
-0.3173011243343353,
-0.4669053554534912,
0.03751645237207413,
-0.3879425525665283,
-0.5885414481163025,
0.7651676535606384,
0.12079020589590073,
0.2736700177192688,
0.48775994777679443,
-0.242209792137146,
1.0937962532043457,
-0.3723635971546173,
1.0206845998764038,
0.21621088683605194,
-0.9166994094848633,
0.2315385639667511,
-0.294859915971756,
-0.2317640781402588,
0.4477119743824005,
0.3187856376171112,
-0.6017853021621704,
-0.4228089153766632,
-0.22485554218292236,
-1.1195223331451416,
0.6725335717201233,
0.3467097580432892,
0.4940657317638397,
0.08226943016052246,
0.2917681932449341,
0.41498079895973206,
0.11074743419885635,
-0.7065345644950867,
-0.1454586237668991,
-0.22725428640842438,
-0.29044774174690247,
-0.17041656374931335,
-0.3009747862815857,
0.05728205293416977,
-0.23619523644447327,
0.6026989817619324,
-0.3226219117641449,
-0.16115841269493103,
-0.028035752475261688,
-0.0077666318975389,
-0.17643265426158905,
0.25310686230659485,
-0.03774037957191467,
0.6263269782066345,
-0.2157166451215744,
0.26167136430740356,
-0.2368788868188858,
-0.3590632379055023,
-0.07301728427410126,
0.07162849605083466,
-0.3466182053089142,
-0.031154166907072067,
0.13060860335826874,
0.8191239237785339,
0.011252112686634064,
-0.6116454005241394,
0.3861122727394104,
0.058180227875709534,
-0.09492027014493942,
0.03257755935192108,
-0.0026049588341265917,
0.20217151939868927,
0.17161820828914642,
0.2448519468307495,
0.05431129410862923,
0.32903754711151123,
-0.41986405849456787,
-0.015683474019169807,
0.3446524441242218,
-0.11146795749664307,
-0.7048839926719666,
0.5936137437820435,
0.2630595266819,
0.005869803950190544,
0.5282043814659119,
0.0315094031393528,
-0.15664923191070557,
0.0661870688199997,
0.5077618360519409,
0.8922595381736755,
0.12065204977989197,
0.3689276874065399,
0.24230578541755676,
-0.15294909477233887,
0.09999515861272812,
0.3742377758026123,
-0.08767005801200867,
-0.6571356058120728,
-0.4223484694957733,
-1.0079493522644043,
-0.061403948813676834,
0.16295699775218964,
-0.6319645047187805,
0.383186012506485,
-0.3190597593784332,
-0.4321751594543457,
0.2703199088573456,
-0.13750247657299042,
-0.5564637184143066,
-0.04725148528814316,
0.3724672794342041,
0.39285799860954285,
-0.9999342560768127,
0.5374526977539062,
0.3062018156051636,
-0.4995719790458679,
-0.6575902700424194,
-0.25282588601112366,
0.03993600606918335,
-0.5525172352790833,
0.29036107659339905,
0.1058332696557045,
-0.2907868027687073,
-0.10280095785856247,
-0.598325252532959,
-0.8169366121292114,
0.7001782655715942,
0.26602932810783386,
-0.7602748870849609,
0.26370179653167725,
0.3902190625667572,
0.8640642762184143,
-0.4645916521549225,
0.01105499267578125,
0.4693063795566559,
0.1737658977508545,
0.4242360293865204,
-0.3861142098903656,
-0.12999273836612701,
-0.29942426085472107,
0.31603917479515076,
0.13689984381198883,
-0.7445798516273499,
0.7779420614242554,
0.1836957484483719,
-0.40956535935401917,
-0.1651414930820465,
0.5370328426361084,
0.19499742984771729,
0.5538796186447144,
0.3282983601093292,
0.5653350353240967,
0.620525598526001,
0.04145847260951996,
0.8730981349945068,
-0.2425733357667923,
0.6079332828521729,
1.030583143234253,
-0.6916747689247131,
0.9354828000068665,
0.5088638067245483,
-0.4585629403591156,
0.4139177203178406,
0.8840224146842957,
-0.008782058954238892,
0.2963748574256897,
0.40096697211265564,
-0.06127846613526344,
-0.4032651484012604,
-0.13364052772521973,
-0.1171516478061676,
0.11516047269105911,
0.6119143962860107,
-0.34396615624427795,
-0.22314338386058807,
-0.1942392885684967,
0.1549813151359558,
-0.001786916283890605,
-0.5298163890838623,
0.8389011025428772,
0.06494562327861786,
-0.45079001784324646,
0.9801849722862244,
0.011165647767484188,
0.42493000626564026,
-0.5142542123794556,
0.10428474098443985,
-0.5202401280403137,
0.26649782061576843,
-0.7400688529014587,
-1.1758421659469604,
0.35893741250038147,
0.3198614716529846,
-0.20800745487213135,
-0.28634247183799744,
0.7643320560455322,
-0.3273821473121643,
-0.6623953580856323,
0.22629982233047485,
0.5951105952262878,
0.366141140460968,
0.07904008775949478,
-0.6214366555213928,
0.3266724646091461,
-0.023700326681137085,
-0.6139475107192993,
0.5394271612167358,
0.0994541347026825,
-0.160493865609169,
0.5829833149909973,
0.7383460402488708,
0.20269592106342316,
0.004723298363387585,
0.4070420563220978,
1.065870761871338,
-0.3932068347930908,
-0.5027756094932556,
-0.8713711500167847,
0.44769373536109924,
-0.03282042592763901,
0.0333368293941021,
0.8754660487174988,
0.7702763676643372,
1.0083024501800537,
-0.08716009557247162,
0.8474072217941284,
0.10450378060340881,
0.41908395290374756,
-0.5084089636802673,
0.5330878496170044,
-0.760441780090332,
0.3673824369907379,
-0.37386682629585266,
-1.1503112316131592,
-0.38774678111076355,
0.3154032528400421,
0.17073267698287964,
-0.16877029836177826,
0.22205349802970886,
1.0571215152740479,
-0.3773086369037628,
-0.004270321689546108,
0.20343557000160217,
0.45253193378448486,
0.3022423982620239,
0.5169187188148499,
0.831139326095581,
-0.22653476893901825,
0.5601588487625122,
-0.021809782832860947,
0.01597103849053383,
-0.2521660029888153,
-0.5963541865348816,
-0.8765785694122314,
-0.4899013042449951,
-0.1556156426668167,
-0.7154704332351685,
-0.17331942915916443,
1.1008782386779785,
0.7303388714790344,
-0.9019528031349182,
-0.4551316201686859,
-0.09474656730890274,
0.04984229803085327,
-0.04696483910083771,
-0.31465768814086914,
0.41174501180648804,
-0.38461998105049133,
-0.7319780588150024,
0.3421724736690521,
0.29901206493377686,
0.17015372216701508,
-0.4120686948299408,
-0.20211584866046906,
0.4675724506378174,
0.23832331597805023,
0.8798040151596069,
0.10133326798677444,
-0.7489980459213257,
-0.2732197642326355,
-0.1396923065185547,
0.14104445278644562,
0.19961366057395935,
0.8312113285064697,
-0.6471279263496399,
0.5041992664337158,
0.7469079494476318,
0.5586355924606323,
0.8420312404632568,
0.5191150903701782,
-0.0008544425945729017,
-0.9374086260795593,
-0.06770065426826477,
0.11098743230104446,
0.5201234221458435,
0.28155815601348877,
-0.45716357231140137,
0.45726749300956726,
0.3738975524902344,
-0.5354483723640442,
-0.9469860792160034,
0.14541633427143097,
-1.3395086526870728,
-0.4183170199394226,
1.2928835153579712,
0.012485463172197342,
-0.3590877056121826,
-0.08012184500694275,
-0.19370728731155396,
-0.1017407774925232,
-0.6408690810203552,
0.7113294005393982,
0.62516850233078,
-0.32048359513282776,
0.23508238792419434,
-0.4633514881134033,
0.2918180227279663,
-0.09879191219806671,
-0.6786739826202393,
0.4115743637084961,
1.131790280342102,
0.41213154792785645,
-0.21685558557510376,
0.6417772173881531,
0.09343069791793823,
-0.22668787837028503,
-0.07407274842262268,
-0.1413731426000595,
-0.2849251627922058,
-0.4250849485397339,
0.04937736690044403,
0.4330996572971344,
0.002305275062099099,
0.21844695508480072
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06115v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06115v1
|
FMPAF: How Do Fed Chairs Affect the Financial Market? A Fine-grained Monetary Policy Analysis Framework on Their Language
| 2024-03-10T07:21:31 | 2024-03-10T07:21:31 |
Yayue Deng, Mohan Xu, Yao Tang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CE
|
The effectiveness of central bank communication is a crucial aspect of
monetary policy transmission. While recent research has examined the influence
of policy communication by the chairs of the Federal Reserve on various
financial variables, much of the literature relies on rule-based or
dictionary-based methods in parsing the language of the chairs, leaving nuanced
information about policy stance contained in nonverbal emotion out of the
analysis. In the current study, we propose the Fine-Grained Monetary Policy
Analysis Framework (FMPAF), a novel approach that integrates large language
models (LLMs) with regression analysis to provide a comprehensive analysis of
the impact of the press-conference communications of chairs of the Federal
Reserve on financial markets. We conduct extensive comparisons of model
performance under different levels of granularity, modalities, and
communication scenarios. Based on our preferred specification, a one-unit
increase in the sentiment score is associated with an increase of the price of
S\&P 500 Exchange-Traded Fund by approximately 500 basis points, a
15-basis-point decrease in the policy interest rate, while not leading to a
significant response in exchange rates.
|
[
-0.6458110213279724,
-1.085555911064148,
0.35742565989494324,
0.4655279219150543,
-0.20938730239868164,
-0.46441853046417236,
-0.38667088747024536,
-0.44930508732795715,
0.13549596071243286,
0.4790397584438324,
-0.4134971797466278,
-0.31535714864730835,
-0.5564731955528259,
0.12327803671360016,
-0.4101673662662506,
1.0539509057998657,
0.15068413317203522,
0.038598522543907166,
-0.28688132762908936,
0.27266842126846313,
0.22397242486476898,
-0.306908518075943,
-0.5906680226325989,
-0.57077556848526,
0.03948361054062843,
0.07839744538068771,
0.9843535423278809,
0.3913441598415375,
0.9330528974533081,
0.31595104932785034,
-0.33412307500839233,
-0.47971487045288086,
-0.3887409269809723,
-0.18957942724227905,
-0.21758629381656647,
-0.4271267056465149,
-0.4623432755470276,
0.23230277001857758,
0.7372315526008606,
0.7803742289543152,
-0.37935006618499756,
-0.10970141738653183,
0.26458993554115295,
0.7625564336776733,
-0.4799259305000305,
0.6575983762741089,
-0.22195479273796082,
0.03498613461852074,
-0.19096021354198456,
-0.5531953573226929,
-0.4704488515853882,
-0.16627034544944763,
0.34750908613204956,
-0.22336994111537933,
-0.22650209069252014,
0.0004274585808161646,
0.6733430624008179,
-0.20634110271930695,
-0.5438442826271057,
-0.4956871271133423,
-0.6356654167175293,
0.6322144269943237,
-0.644126296043396,
0.21190030872821808,
0.6716487407684326,
0.2297912985086441,
-0.1692350208759308,
-0.22551845014095306,
-0.5094586610794067,
-0.20534570515155792,
-0.18116797506809235,
-0.18505123257637024,
-0.2473745048046112,
0.4606768488883972,
0.1011321023106575,
0.8483730554580688,
-0.08996398001909256,
-0.42749738693237305,
-0.31249141693115234,
0.14034058153629303,
0.5846206545829773,
0.1151965782046318,
-0.39943554997444153,
-0.17526692152023315,
-0.4938496947288513,
-0.4021967053413391,
-0.3455755114555359,
0.06964441388845444,
0.3029038608074188,
0.7130012512207031,
-0.33414384722709656,
0.3471863269805908,
-0.38915055990219116,
0.7559014558792114,
0.20262223482131958,
-0.4067109227180481,
-0.09030422568321228,
-0.07135223597288132,
-0.610538899898529,
-0.3374313712120056,
0.6857931017875671,
0.5702894330024719,
0.09179577976465225,
-0.05312533304095268,
-0.5220603346824646,
-0.1587708741426468,
-0.21388205885887146,
-0.7883176207542419,
0.14958688616752625,
0.02290266752243042,
-0.808239221572876,
-0.7062992453575134,
0.35267531871795654,
-1.0647732019424438,
-0.50666344165802,
-0.36715221405029297,
0.3321911692619324,
-0.022353148087859154,
-0.20162098109722137,
0.06752365082502365,
-0.12504622340202332,
0.6388862729072571,
-0.09037187695503235,
-1.1757656335830688,
0.5825544595718384,
0.8424851298332214,
0.37744084000587463,
0.14349697530269623,
0.16360346972942352,
-0.3339073956012726,
-0.1721821278333664,
-0.1223720982670784,
1.0890589952468872,
-0.8691479563713074,
-0.9330496191978455,
0.4223388135433197,
-0.0008367912378162146,
-0.267197847366333,
-0.5085198879241943,
0.26869910955429077,
-0.13255053758621216,
0.27242252230644226,
-0.4264722466468811,
-0.23560886085033417,
0.13800984621047974,
0.22866182029247284,
-0.34335169196128845,
0.4736782908439636,
0.43158379197120667,
-0.39910051226615906,
0.2332412749528885,
-0.651267945766449,
-0.4705694913864136,
-0.6497936844825745,
-0.27531304955482483,
0.0308886356651783,
0.06045636534690857,
0.09324519336223602,
0.42820459604263306,
-0.7078626751899719,
0.2550504505634308,
-0.645744800567627,
-0.2954947054386139,
0.845576286315918,
-0.5787676572799683,
0.3472311496734619,
0.13081325590610504,
-0.28253355622291565,
0.0006654281169176102,
-1.002695918083191,
-0.19943054020404816,
-0.06522426009178162,
-0.46494001150131226,
-0.14205308258533478,
0.08506713062524796,
0.3705461025238037,
0.18696995079517365,
-0.12359556555747986,
-0.13023748993873596,
0.20169955492019653,
-0.35147351026535034,
0.3033556044101715,
1.0101616382598877,
0.18682727217674255,
0.8379588723182678,
-0.5349817872047424,
0.5435583591461182,
-0.3439468741416931,
0.5493060350418091,
-0.20577062666416168,
0.10824079066514969,
-0.4421420395374298,
-0.23498834669589996,
0.22338342666625977,
0.23893141746520996,
-0.03096092864871025,
-0.046910881996154785,
0.27909788489341736,
-0.1191975474357605,
0.09596487134695053,
-0.14587055146694183,
0.3670143187046051,
0.32624107599258423,
0.04008028656244278,
-0.11479037255048752,
-0.06145211309194565,
-0.8337796330451965,
-0.36434951424598694,
-0.235090434551239,
0.21167200803756714,
0.36285096406936646,
0.08606382459402084,
0.005234000273048878,
0.7448107004165649,
-0.623276948928833,
-0.5154830813407898,
-0.0748535618185997,
0.19033662974834442,
0.37286534905433655,
0.4039345681667328,
0.8081572651863098,
-0.3269881010055542,
-0.18829701840877533,
0.13809655606746674,
-0.0453796349465847,
-0.3026491403579712,
-0.22780807316303253,
-0.08366131037473679,
0.42098283767700195,
0.48140642046928406,
-0.6585332751274109,
0.1818847358226776,
0.8097640872001648,
-0.6782351732254028,
0.23756374418735504,
0.1696610450744629,
0.11011719703674316,
-0.6940816044807434,
0.14726364612579346,
0.16508525609970093,
-0.03985084220767021,
-0.31949612498283386,
0.022461634129285812,
-0.3629003167152405,
-0.019073694944381714,
-0.12506330013275146,
0.6315740346908569,
-0.11956115067005157,
-0.17653493583202362,
-0.4425925016403198,
0.24781101942062378,
0.031098103150725365,
0.46747857332229614,
-0.2764911651611328,
0.6569103598594666,
0.39038047194480896,
-0.3020235002040863,
0.14085161685943604,
0.25272804498672485,
-0.23289355635643005,
0.8462986350059509,
-0.4011092483997345,
-0.2014715075492859,
-0.03379540890455246,
0.2740887403488159,
-1.0810625553131104,
-0.212000772356987,
0.3276396095752716,
-0.03724415972828865,
0.51301109790802,
0.22485335171222687,
-0.1374385803937912,
-0.11437772959470749,
-0.25095856189727783,
-0.32278403639793396,
0.05865855887532234,
-0.33925652503967285,
0.5365740060806274,
0.4492182433605194,
-0.19472171366214752,
-0.6081259250640869,
-0.8000956773757935,
-0.333229660987854,
-0.11752167344093323,
-0.6737754344940186,
0.19337952136993408,
-0.07062646001577377,
-0.7315557599067688,
-0.15599438548088074,
-0.6680616736412048,
-0.19496646523475647,
0.18634213507175446,
0.08475268632173538,
0.2919667065143585,
-0.28511205315589905,
0.24969297647476196,
-0.11938577145338058,
-0.294178307056427,
0.42095446586608887,
-0.025883588939905167,
0.5089096426963806,
-0.50252366065979,
0.058851636946201324,
-0.6610170006752014,
0.24421457946300507,
0.5222854018211365,
-0.08207562565803528,
0.8314781785011292,
0.14965054392814636,
0.048285968601703644,
-0.030282406136393547,
-0.2164727747440338,
-0.11478119343519211,
-0.511223316192627,
-0.04080909863114357,
-0.28067106008529663,
-0.842557430267334,
0.44343501329421997,
-0.21932531893253326,
-0.022955970838665962,
0.4876116216182709,
0.2886108458042145,
0.007542516570538282,
0.6443238258361816,
1.1044121980667114,
-0.11880931258201599,
0.9040096998214722,
-0.1874418705701828,
0.026953428983688354,
-0.2987581193447113,
-0.18844500184059143,
-0.7759822607040405,
-0.24235579371452332,
-0.4011516571044922,
-0.31501585245132446,
-0.19107890129089355,
0.12201668322086334,
-0.11295555531978607,
0.006902230903506279,
-0.10434157401323318,
0.5323905944824219,
-0.061972346156835556,
-0.21770381927490234,
0.2036566138267517,
-0.09211625903844833,
-0.08982754498720169,
0.2952830493450165,
-0.10998237878084183,
-0.4407671391963959,
0.9384153485298157,
0.5945295691490173,
1.0378309488296509,
0.04820527136325836,
0.3535938262939453,
0.4558170735836029,
0.6166906952857971,
-0.6867730021476746,
0.45675525069236755,
-0.004278674256056547,
-0.44834402203559875,
-0.18940605223178864,
-0.290476530790329,
-0.33898189663887024,
0.45431214570999146,
-0.8369656801223755,
-0.3074263036251068,
0.6645308136940002,
0.04632642865180969,
-0.6045382618904114,
-0.36008939146995544,
-0.48857352137565613,
0.9067422747612,
0.13119135797023773,
0.005242370069026947,
-0.2623692452907562,
-0.2575562596321106,
0.5640206933021545,
-0.16273710131645203,
0.3577750027179718,
-0.45411187410354614,
0.08369244635105133,
0.463174045085907,
-0.42987650632858276,
0.726539671421051,
-0.15677174925804138,
-0.2890995144844055,
0.30698758363723755,
-0.27159416675567627,
0.7522404193878174,
0.22382734715938568,
-0.3723367154598236,
-0.07190756499767303,
0.24885883927345276,
-0.3155714273452759,
-0.25381654500961304,
0.6814822554588318,
-0.5870533585548401,
-0.570370614528656,
-0.5716338753700256,
-0.46546146273612976,
-0.3624674677848816,
-0.03206091746687889,
-0.3203037977218628,
0.3768002390861511,
-0.6613007187843323,
0.3504182994365692,
0.2514505684375763,
0.0543326660990715,
0.5323201417922974,
0.4919182360172272,
-0.59788978099823,
-0.3693975806236267,
0.3629404604434967,
-0.24599608778953552,
0.39724037051200867,
0.3474692106246948,
0.32648053765296936,
-0.1017291471362114,
0.032438937574625015,
0.25883111357688904,
0.23697328567504883,
-0.8007171750068665,
-0.19245095551013947,
-0.32795724272727966,
0.15955255925655365,
-0.6134421229362488,
-0.28452593088150024,
-0.187611922621727,
-0.510441243648529,
-0.24594730138778687,
-0.1719089299440384,
0.21611222624778748,
0.45589834451675415,
-0.2183794379234314,
1.024721622467041,
-0.4610711336135864,
0.042470257729291916,
0.20880940556526184,
0.6341573596000671,
-0.429920494556427,
-0.1737205684185028,
-0.22176069021224976,
-0.1605340540409088,
-0.3249748647212982,
-0.7357422709465027,
0.17373304069042206,
0.44189873337745667,
0.35065022110939026,
1.1288485527038574,
0.11654771864414215,
0.8708600401878357,
0.17915146052837372,
0.3814888596534729,
0.180035799741745,
-1.0205899477005005,
0.08102677017450333,
-0.4524781107902527,
0.24236321449279785,
0.40280094742774963,
-0.2810588777065277,
-0.7281179428100586,
-0.7018341422080994,
-0.5747238993644714,
-0.49145957827568054,
1.1220898628234863,
-0.09257364273071289,
0.5209178924560547,
-0.4508810341358185,
0.09228373318910599,
-0.10300590842962265,
0.28074193000793457,
-0.45193806290626526,
-0.18147768080234528,
0.15222840011119843,
-0.01101029384881258,
0.10166089236736298,
-0.6731910705566406,
-0.47637221217155457,
0.07049667835235596,
0.3935098648071289,
-0.07895313948392868,
0.2837534546852112,
0.0018399705877527595,
0.25711169838905334,
-0.630956768989563,
0.41975829005241394,
1.0670276880264282,
0.626301646232605,
-0.45844852924346924,
0.01934736594557762,
-0.2526710629463196,
-0.1941152811050415,
-0.26563307642936707,
0.4588342010974884,
0.13439346849918365,
-0.013300583697855473,
0.29959189891815186,
0.6237436532974243,
0.5003420114517212,
-0.7776563167572021,
0.7678298354148865,
-0.21511676907539368,
-0.4764690399169922,
-0.39778831601142883,
-0.049902066588401794,
-0.04353443905711174,
0.6911617517471313,
0.49612030386924744,
0.42447108030319214,
-0.10531231760978699,
-0.8480619788169861,
0.4394370913505554,
0.6540862321853638,
-0.5488179922103882,
-0.34316861629486084,
0.5476751923561096,
0.5984086394309998,
0.159269317984581,
0.23309209942817688,
0.3681553602218628,
0.0005610507796518505,
0.5642642974853516,
0.6162540912628174,
0.6147000789642334,
-0.4069855809211731,
0.3189188838005066,
-0.06442105025053024,
0.4268595278263092,
-0.18259263038635254,
0.26010391116142273,
-0.17325523495674133,
-0.4245474338531494,
-0.2064201384782791,
-0.955291211605072,
-0.1903599202632904,
0.07666400074958801,
-0.6751399636268616,
0.16584418714046478,
-0.978757381439209,
-0.6144869327545166,
0.3514634668827057,
0.07882347702980042,
-0.40599900484085083,
0.17159166932106018,
0.35927677154541016,
1.1005594730377197,
-0.9734864830970764,
0.5585218667984009,
0.4482588768005371,
-0.2587844133377075,
-0.24415600299835205,
0.21739058196544647,
0.1612406075000763,
-0.6045508980751038,
0.18974599242210388,
0.05004790797829628,
0.39543354511260986,
-0.5349599123001099,
-0.24947622418403625,
-0.9496960043907166,
0.7962678074836731,
0.4305747151374817,
-0.28746312856674194,
0.3318617343902588,
0.3740728795528412,
0.39394477009773254,
-0.6455838680267334,
0.08943258970975876,
0.8897206783294678,
0.8642590641975403,
0.2648846507072449,
-0.7784574031829834,
-0.20900382101535797,
-0.15162211656570435,
-0.21741963922977448,
0.5158281922340393,
-0.8443186283111572,
0.8306137919425964,
0.06945008039474487,
-0.20166262984275818,
-0.07360884547233582,
0.9085241556167603,
-0.2937527596950531,
0.40638303756713867,
0.41458064317703247,
0.01997833140194416,
0.6134937405586243,
-0.2286219596862793,
1.186385989189148,
-0.6032424569129944,
0.6147313117980957,
0.5100592970848083,
-0.23207752406597137,
0.8930312395095825,
0.6420584321022034,
-0.4786185324192047,
0.2585456371307373,
0.5016372799873352,
0.14490462839603424,
0.6105225086212158,
0.24623484909534454,
-0.46225473284721375,
-0.15970361232757568,
-0.1036590188741684,
-0.21542499959468842,
0.5124517679214478,
0.23039188981056213,
-0.7261747717857361,
-0.42758679389953613,
0.23402069509029388,
0.19602380692958832,
0.28911399841308594,
-0.2486245036125183,
0.4203318953514099,
0.5119190216064453,
-0.20600824058055878,
0.1770721822977066,
0.1467607319355011,
0.42920979857444763,
-0.5345048904418945,
0.14953362941741943,
-0.597680389881134,
0.6386467814445496,
-0.026606861501932144,
-0.44848376512527466,
0.882252037525177,
-0.04684796184301376,
-0.2727499008178711,
-0.38546404242515564,
0.5560640096664429,
-0.529170036315918,
-0.17259244620800018,
0.15874318778514862,
0.15000563859939575,
-0.054584354162216187,
-0.051546983420848846,
-0.6223620772361755,
0.3448038399219513,
-0.22893334925174713,
-0.8265228271484375,
0.5853443741798401,
0.24168060719966888,
0.05242479220032692,
0.36311084032058716,
0.703925371170044,
-0.40195491909980774,
-0.41832804679870605,
-0.08367211371660233,
0.8138458728790283,
-0.8517127633094788,
-0.4379793703556061,
-0.6539303660392761,
0.04371838644146919,
0.03341755270957947,
-0.4063792824745178,
0.16463199257850647,
0.21099908649921417,
0.5602238774299622,
-0.2015615701675415,
0.36364564299583435,
-0.11280212551355362,
-0.09953626245260239,
-0.41821834444999695,
0.789592444896698,
-0.2985661029815674,
0.4593200385570526,
-0.2023611217737198,
-0.9615784883499146,
-0.44773146510124207,
0.9665325284004211,
-0.4751648008823395,
-0.01798255555331707,
0.6966195106506348,
0.775153398513794,
0.24492529034614563,
0.41323763132095337,
0.34683969616889954,
0.32809922099113464,
0.061655037105083466,
0.008403654210269451,
0.4585166275501251,
-0.21036142110824585,
0.8521085977554321,
-0.3592088520526886,
-0.06591783463954926,
-0.5559816360473633,
-0.7795276641845703,
-0.941371738910675,
-0.2757117450237274,
-0.2999648153781891,
-0.34407103061676025,
0.035733599215745926,
1.1500731706619263,
0.2659302055835724,
-0.5615745186805725,
-0.4467912018299103,
0.20097489655017853,
-0.020622313022613525,
-0.36908215284347534,
-0.24605388939380646,
0.342573344707489,
-0.3318398892879486,
-0.7549193501472473,
0.3039095401763916,
0.5502675175666809,
0.061874862760305405,
-0.111006960272789,
0.046390317380428314,
0.05418708175420761,
0.7145600318908691,
0.6557319760322571,
0.2727528214454651,
-0.4564414322376251,
-0.25676488876342773,
-0.009216769598424435,
-0.6721621155738831,
-0.15808238089084625,
0.6673981547355652,
-0.4244369566440582,
0.18093648552894592,
0.38554325699806213,
0.2705710828304291,
0.1468595564365387,
0.25089165568351746,
0.6776992082595825,
-0.5418025255203247,
0.5130044221878052,
-0.28110548853874207,
0.23680128157138824,
-0.10101156681776047,
-0.3271036744117737,
0.3991549611091614,
0.2924523949623108,
-0.5580413341522217,
-0.6376660466194153,
-0.2815796434879303,
-1.129447102546692,
-0.376949280500412,
1.185868501663208,
0.08394598960876465,
-0.6470646262168884,
0.40672457218170166,
-0.18978343904018402,
-0.2556132674217224,
-0.49738436937332153,
0.8659407496452332,
0.9495671391487122,
-0.051381856203079224,
-0.4371851980686188,
-0.45671916007995605,
0.6362322568893433,
0.1175617128610611,
-0.357622891664505,
0.44180527329444885,
0.5100866556167603,
0.056731704622507095,
-0.1817072033882141,
1.0550731420516968,
-0.18281856179237366,
0.21760883927345276,
0.13267287611961365,
-0.08224733173847198,
-0.0257343091070652,
0.08030620217323303,
-0.5220659375190735,
0.2050802856683731,
0.0027839785907417536,
0.017827896401286125
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06108v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06108v2
|
Large Language Models on Fine-grained Emotion Detection Dataset with Data Augmentation and Transfer Learning
| 2024-03-10T06:30:54 | 2024-04-09T16:38:01 |
Kaipeng Wang, Zhi Jing, Yongye Su, Yikun Han
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This paper delves into enhancing the classification performance on the
GoEmotions dataset, a large, manually annotated dataset for emotion detection
in text. The primary goal of this paper is to address the challenges of
detecting subtle emotions in text, a complex issue in Natural Language
Processing (NLP) with significant practical applications. The findings offer
valuable insights into addressing the challenges of emotion detection in text
and suggest directions for future research, including the potential for a
survey paper that synthesizes methods and performances across various datasets
in this domain.
|
[
-0.25618067383766174,
-0.6726188063621521,
0.4065435230731964,
0.051493868231773376,
-0.21208786964416504,
-0.14074817299842834,
-0.42858025431632996,
-0.9011303186416626,
0.009789548814296722,
0.46216288208961487,
-0.5034894347190857,
-0.4668389558792114,
-0.7313776612281799,
0.11624838411808014,
-0.5762515664100647,
0.9402264356613159,
-0.1623929738998413,
-0.2999630868434906,
0.13906905055046082,
-0.4307067096233368,
-0.12447825819253922,
-0.5659414529800415,
-0.8496291041374207,
-0.13287723064422607,
0.24930603802204132,
0.5295987725257874,
0.8286357522010803,
0.2699716091156006,
0.8553308248519897,
0.29711923003196716,
-0.11333170533180237,
0.24287480115890503,
-0.43515917658805847,
0.42173486948013306,
-0.22197847068309784,
-0.6205301880836487,
-0.1410842090845108,
-0.2112579196691513,
0.5649039149284363,
0.3060719668865204,
0.06728211790323257,
0.002115598414093256,
-0.08691802620887756,
0.944436252117157,
-0.5758742690086365,
0.2639501392841339,
-0.22768273949623108,
0.426514595746994,
-0.30877894163131714,
-0.10599400848150253,
-0.5660808086395264,
-0.3923546075820923,
0.36054477095603943,
-0.18756914138793945,
0.060204364359378815,
0.1856689751148224,
0.6976325511932373,
0.3823295533657074,
-0.4855523109436035,
-0.6349208950996399,
-0.734879195690155,
0.9684250354766846,
-0.6976847648620605,
0.11813792586326599,
0.33690381050109863,
0.20170678198337555,
0.04020130634307861,
-0.8258131742477417,
-0.6465385556221008,
-0.010934296064078808,
0.09600017219781876,
0.022463062778115273,
-0.650493860244751,
-0.011278736405074596,
0.28782251477241516,
0.7261523604393005,
-0.6637887954711914,
0.04255182296037674,
0.24628454446792603,
0.013365371152758598,
0.7482118606567383,
0.26004377007484436,
0.5751098394393921,
-0.1293642371892929,
0.19271737337112427,
-0.30118975043296814,
-0.1781257838010788,
0.11445358395576477,
0.5373382568359375,
0.25259509682655334,
-0.31464552879333496,
0.4062395989894867,
-0.13641177117824554,
0.635838508605957,
-0.2778679132461548,
0.4342641830444336,
0.5603341460227966,
-0.31436315178871155,
-0.3296496570110321,
-0.09298725426197052,
0.8460413813591003,
0.43016019463539124,
0.5547268986701965,
-0.03871684893965721,
-0.17686744034290314,
0.04054110869765282,
0.09626879543066025,
-0.9031296968460083,
-0.2976669669151306,
0.40160223841667175,
-0.5222762823104858,
-0.3649008870124817,
-0.1522565633058548,
-1.1939494609832764,
-0.4488008916378021,
-0.5573440194129944,
0.16008415818214417,
-0.5487586259841919,
-0.21173860132694244,
0.31981587409973145,
-0.0018792357295751572,
0.021411459892988205,
0.3028625249862671,
-0.9261716604232788,
0.2426256537437439,
0.3557724058628082,
0.8013260960578918,
-0.10675861686468124,
0.025712525472044945,
-0.3291069269180298,
-0.2718675434589386,
-0.42536240816116333,
0.8514869213104248,
-1.1180357933044434,
-0.24221192300319672,
0.25150591135025024,
0.2086983621120453,
-0.018887510523200035,
-0.5837929844856262,
0.8212743997573853,
-0.13507281243801117,
0.32794898748397827,
-0.19601282477378845,
-0.5034099817276001,
-0.30978360772132874,
0.11406981945037842,
-0.6981854438781738,
1.416663646697998,
0.2839091718196869,
-0.9072297215461731,
0.10549905151128769,
-0.7552524209022522,
-0.4757113456726074,
-0.06283489614725113,
0.33331093192100525,
-0.28744983673095703,
0.5089505314826965,
0.15302208065986633,
0.7785559892654419,
-0.2086598128080368,
0.23843570053577423,
-0.32369524240493774,
-0.2254226803779602,
0.33347398042678833,
-0.3213998079299927,
0.27010849118232727,
0.28772565722465515,
-0.3968820869922638,
0.13464759290218353,
-0.8955464959144592,
-0.08522091805934906,
0.06761845201253891,
-0.03284730762243271,
-0.6921230554580688,
0.021555552259087563,
0.18022631108760834,
0.2643733322620392,
0.0813145563006401,
-0.34810060262680054,
0.3652653098106384,
-0.3836959898471832,
0.29849886894226074,
0.579128623008728,
-0.17996791005134583,
0.6330966949462891,
0.142342671751976,
0.4157088100910187,
0.17681069672107697,
0.08663208782672882,
-0.3208974003791809,
-0.3602035939693451,
-0.7690705060958862,
-0.13878203928470612,
0.1776801198720932,
0.5716502666473389,
-0.9610173106193542,
0.7408505082130432,
-0.027831973508000374,
-0.4176165759563446,
-0.5745587944984436,
-0.06668321043252945,
0.037751104682683945,
0.5373151898384094,
0.5216842889785767,
0.03925979509949684,
-0.410795658826828,
-0.6564642190933228,
-0.36177152395248413,
0.007130516227334738,
0.009100266732275486,
0.3559216260910034,
0.5748468637466431,
-0.5205719470977783,
0.7974637746810913,
-0.47669124603271484,
-0.22607927024364471,
-0.10729516297578812,
0.6383995413780212,
-0.09442022442817688,
0.46710532903671265,
0.6261298060417175,
-0.8243587017059326,
-0.5065469145774841,
0.33038976788520813,
-1.0082758665084839,
-0.251973032951355,
0.09361536800861359,
0.04380396753549576,
0.12086176872253418,
0.6309405565261841,
-0.42741045355796814,
0.3405061960220337,
0.5906322002410889,
-0.36225324869155884,
0.4231787621974945,
-0.12523961067199707,
0.32244545221328735,
-1.1013834476470947,
0.018697554245591164,
0.21886925399303436,
-0.3020707070827484,
-0.7488162517547607,
-0.1790967732667923,
0.08182358741760254,
0.10850850492715836,
-0.5236815214157104,
0.8207047581672668,
-0.14954468607902527,
0.16389790177345276,
-0.250444233417511,
0.03149690106511116,
-0.07616385072469711,
0.22605232894420624,
0.15638868510723114,
0.5891162753105164,
0.8416736125946045,
-0.6441701650619507,
0.7265073657035828,
0.14714038372039795,
-0.24662049114704132,
1.0641772747039795,
-0.31886616349220276,
0.1700069159269333,
-0.3467073440551758,
0.15347446501255035,
-1.2510558366775513,
-0.7764755487442017,
0.1751144677400589,
-0.38748595118522644,
0.48193639516830444,
0.18865083158016205,
-0.5816699862480164,
-0.4872807264328003,
-0.6179041266441345,
0.16825099289417267,
0.3838711977005005,
-0.5297771692276001,
0.7554270625114441,
0.19695580005645752,
-0.45399317145347595,
-0.3592110574245453,
-0.9441211819648743,
0.3390771150588989,
-0.3994927406311035,
-0.5383245944976807,
-0.11330999433994293,
-0.005707448348402977,
-0.1608257293701172,
-0.024368537589907646,
0.19285327196121216,
-0.19416746497154236,
0.023753197863698006,
0.20639589428901672,
0.061730798333883286,
0.05740915983915329,
0.7502780556678772,
0.2358430027961731,
-0.02289193868637085,
0.048958078026771545,
0.021503983065485954,
0.40055516362190247,
-0.24730679392814636,
-0.06907939165830612,
-0.5999154448509216,
0.1855766326189041,
0.4262988567352295,
-0.08998723328113556,
0.6012593507766724,
1.1646393537521362,
-0.537581741809845,
-0.38233914971351624,
-0.2854595482349396,
0.10226581245660782,
-0.4222685992717743,
0.6161106824874878,
-0.10616565495729446,
-1.0932844877243042,
0.6673392653465271,
-0.20806176960468292,
-0.3197349011898041,
0.5188800096511841,
0.5675408244132996,
-0.010109703987836838,
1.153210997581482,
0.6656020283699036,
-0.5137082934379578,
0.7032435536384583,
-0.0951373428106308,
0.20760634541511536,
-0.7996405363082886,
-0.04646299406886101,
-0.9561881422996521,
-0.571665346622467,
-0.7045679092407227,
-0.443666934967041,
-0.39014339447021484,
-0.31201741099357605,
-0.1343836784362793,
0.000032980497053358704,
-0.6407120227813721,
0.5580928325653076,
0.13504429161548615,
0.06345173716545105,
0.0878523588180542,
-0.014218457043170929,
0.5114825367927551,
-0.16793935000896454,
-0.22297263145446777,
-0.5664502382278442,
0.9711017608642578,
0.5124533176422119,
0.9177157878875732,
0.1589081883430481,
0.5845040082931519,
0.39911985397338867,
0.3712760806083679,
-0.8812186121940613,
0.43386393785476685,
-0.3944409489631653,
-0.3594959080219269,
-0.22973819077014923,
-0.6458103656768799,
-0.9664848446846008,
-0.25948792695999146,
-0.034498922526836395,
-1.2509431838989258,
0.37571123242378235,
-0.016759149730205536,
-0.051864318549633026,
0.25512078404426575,
-1.0095373392105103,
0.888123095035553,
0.04432414099574089,
-0.312984824180603,
0.1858096569776535,
-0.8233101963996887,
0.3548058569431305,
-0.1121383085846901,
0.20459096133708954,
-0.023207562044262886,
-0.0854114443063736,
0.9861540198326111,
-0.1742599606513977,
0.6100319027900696,
-0.16304540634155273,
-0.17537976801395416,
0.43652403354644775,
0.11730343848466873,
0.7174552083015442,
-0.12632863223552704,
-0.13340266048908234,
-0.10631553083658218,
-0.40491554141044617,
-0.20968292653560638,
-0.41184666752815247,
0.723440408706665,
-0.4218911826610565,
0.2528309226036072,
-0.15220944583415985,
-0.7770917415618896,
-0.28725072741508484,
0.006085042841732502,
0.30697816610336304,
0.22456851601600647,
-0.07008512318134308,
0.3979412615299225,
1.0537806749343872,
-0.26422518491744995,
0.71900475025177,
0.17074811458587646,
-0.270778089761734,
-0.05882848799228668,
1.0331779718399048,
0.003834258299320936,
-0.049697548151016235,
0.21383094787597656,
0.22521795332431793,
-0.4331084191799164,
-0.4940336346626282,
-0.19266194105148315,
-0.0802871361374855,
-0.6154196858406067,
-0.23450230062007904,
-0.7598171234130859,
0.2536459267139435,
-0.22834031283855438,
-0.20970092713832855,
-0.4754522442817688,
-0.05471567064523697,
-0.6331427693367004,
-0.24349072575569153,
0.5103622674942017,
0.7751618027687073,
-0.08602278679609299,
0.6545846462249756,
-1.0735231637954712,
0.41460809111595154,
0.3513316810131073,
0.5621788501739502,
-0.11579529941082001,
-0.7390126585960388,
-0.19441895186901093,
-0.1164693608880043,
-0.0318361334502697,
-0.6632751822471619,
0.7169908881187439,
0.30804622173309326,
0.05067822337150574,
0.5667645335197449,
0.16872037947177887,
0.381499707698822,
-0.11651938408613205,
0.969992458820343,
-0.01785939186811447,
-1.132209062576294,
0.6496534943580627,
-0.3239372968673706,
0.3077917993068695,
0.7315666079521179,
0.535811722278595,
-0.5462068915367126,
-0.32686537504196167,
-0.625028133392334,
-0.918208658695221,
0.9917876124382019,
0.34231308102607727,
0.4546925723552704,
0.027506090700626373,
0.22733819484710693,
-0.007295744493603706,
0.18984858691692352,
-0.6289302706718445,
-0.08310287445783615,
0.35970064997673035,
-1.0201530456542969,
-0.17105764150619507,
-0.3829334080219269,
0.1783735305070877,
0.022750049829483032,
0.46356919407844543,
-0.2212705761194229,
0.36557912826538086,
0.3064413368701935,
-0.3181125521659851,
-0.1930321455001831,
0.14406214654445648,
0.4064462184906006,
-0.009239851497113705,
-0.34118393063545227,
0.17769455909729004,
0.06113097071647644,
-0.7556654810905457,
0.1704523265361786,
0.21312469244003296,
0.3241429328918457,
0.17132537066936493,
0.48507195711135864,
0.9337660670280457,
0.059767019003629684,
-0.690557062625885,
0.5261796116828918,
-0.27194249629974365,
-0.09064584970474243,
0.3385432958602905,
-0.056655675172805786,
-0.08405429124832153,
0.35841771960258484,
0.3988439440727234,
-0.013248414732515812,
0.6685079336166382,
-0.5746210217475891,
0.1884939968585968,
0.23902274668216705,
-0.7931626439094543,
-0.5321587324142456,
0.20167213678359985,
0.27020230889320374,
-0.22090962529182434,
0.276848167181015,
-0.42389050126075745,
-0.599348783493042,
0.6517024636268616,
0.12641528248786926,
1.0091056823730469,
-0.7009639143943787,
0.11090502142906189,
-0.0020805641543120146,
0.37849360704421997,
-0.5581058859825134,
0.3388943672180176,
0.08775371313095093,
-0.5619624853134155,
-0.5763220191001892,
-0.41898930072784424,
-0.6626657843589783,
0.07751110941171646,
-0.6369137763977051,
0.2304968386888504,
-0.14754720032215118,
-0.15240226686000824,
0.060124319046735764,
-0.2058069109916687,
-0.663857638835907,
0.524567723274231,
0.5548388361930847,
0.7742671966552734,
-1.068232536315918,
0.4661771059036255,
0.7501899600028992,
0.0231028962880373,
-0.6616300940513611,
0.02256864868104458,
-0.11390179395675659,
-0.39368078112602234,
0.5864591598510742,
0.5584853887557983,
0.021359369158744812,
0.05853884294629097,
-1.0094902515411377,
-0.3930361270904541,
0.5249750018119812,
0.29677915573120117,
-0.47431954741477966,
0.03665781021118164,
0.11243174970149994,
0.935154914855957,
-0.25741609930992126,
0.5186243653297424,
0.7296077013015747,
0.5708508491516113,
-0.011173680424690247,
-0.48700106143951416,
-0.32565999031066895,
-0.1874544769525528,
-0.21617911756038666,
0.40511947870254517,
-0.5422433018684387,
0.7395489811897278,
0.33700135350227356,
-0.047643404453992844,
-0.23219776153564453,
0.6555999517440796,
-0.486177921295166,
0.5800791382789612,
0.19284994900226593,
0.9152238965034485,
0.9898212552070618,
-0.4257965087890625,
1.1737544536590576,
0.03613351285457611,
0.6654739379882812,
1.0687569379806519,
-0.48272666335105896,
0.6534478664398193,
0.29010364413261414,
-0.3934803009033203,
0.41798245906829834,
0.6843721866607666,
0.24366529285907745,
0.15551817417144775,
0.13265979290008545,
-0.32728227972984314,
-0.0412675142288208,
-0.2518840730190277,
-0.3897542357444763,
0.37100526690483093,
0.5676964521408081,
-0.3821876347064972,
-0.26766476035118103,
0.4804966449737549,
0.14696621894836426,
-0.1442348062992096,
-0.5567399263381958,
0.7230821251869202,
-0.10230203717947006,
-0.08006751537322998,
-0.02512972801923752,
-0.4136336147785187,
0.8175404071807861,
-0.5422189235687256,
-0.003039164235815406,
-0.31936588883399963,
0.10550367087125778,
-0.40354886651039124,
-1.14934504032135,
0.49695417284965515,
0.12195873260498047,
0.07900474220514297,
0.07968247681856155,
1.1947453022003174,
-0.35038459300994873,
-0.40069103240966797,
0.337395042181015,
0.16202186048030853,
0.25529131293296814,
-0.4263347387313843,
-0.5680413246154785,
0.08830131590366364,
0.08899882435798645,
-0.87065190076828,
0.3068571090698242,
1.2649694681167603,
0.0759507268667221,
0.7097275853157043,
0.4963966906070709,
-0.22338144481182098,
-0.07502168416976929,
0.04824386537075043,
0.7955809235572815,
-0.887576699256897,
-0.38911908864974976,
-1.0694259405136108,
0.6319572329521179,
-0.2564563751220703,
-0.14512509107589722,
0.5428583025932312,
0.30815497040748596,
0.4847909212112427,
-0.20875436067581177,
0.7420382499694824,
-0.042040809988975525,
0.4538562297821045,
-0.4388886094093323,
0.1763913929462433,
-0.369943767786026,
-0.2319081425666809,
-0.6264338493347168,
-0.9039481282234192,
-0.5800278782844543,
0.6325969696044922,
-0.3481082320213318,
0.060466062277555466,
0.709952712059021,
0.3298271596431732,
0.07632534950971603,
0.2611415982246399,
0.33909401297569275,
0.2656508982181549,
0.30335870385169983,
0.7714799046516418,
0.7581141591072083,
-0.5216512680053711,
0.20098455250263214,
-0.14166155457496643,
-0.21387039124965668,
-0.5979713201522827,
-0.9644511342048645,
-0.8210707902908325,
-0.4005381762981415,
-0.5458220839500427,
-0.232730895280838,
-0.1730993390083313,
0.6414158344268799,
0.33206138014793396,
-0.8391972780227661,
0.21127097308635712,
-0.2366337925195694,
0.14526858925819397,
0.16259519755840302,
-0.2992191016674042,
0.367667555809021,
-0.5822464823722839,
-1.0505023002624512,
-0.013665718026459217,
0.5748477578163147,
0.2199319303035736,
0.2304910272359848,
0.09505108743906021,
-0.3352414667606354,
0.13715095818042755,
0.7315808534622192,
0.10195393115282059,
0.06949801743030548,
-0.5306377410888672,
-0.227121040225029,
-0.15516266226768494,
-0.03978271782398224,
0.4892255365848541,
-0.4117613434791565,
0.5898637771606445,
0.6168041229248047,
0.849902868270874,
0.2787063419818878,
-0.06879023462533951,
0.023357268422842026,
-0.9636315703392029,
0.4438561499118805,
0.19759222865104675,
0.2974354028701782,
0.3836311995983124,
-0.5057814717292786,
0.7617397308349609,
0.13609202206134796,
-0.7900184988975525,
-0.9082845449447632,
0.022334113717079163,
-1.145519495010376,
-0.004974955692887306,
1.1034797430038452,
-0.2367498278617859,
-0.3176169693470001,
-0.1823028177022934,
-0.4927597641944885,
0.26920005679130554,
-0.5701177716255188,
0.5387184619903564,
1.0117698907852173,
-0.11692002415657043,
0.020479999482631683,
-0.6794769763946533,
0.5315773487091064,
0.5381298065185547,
-1.3134759664535522,
0.5438323616981506,
0.5913326740264893,
-0.4118565618991852,
0.37749791145324707,
0.17108948528766632,
0.029343314468860626,
0.08135819435119629,
-0.2455163300037384,
0.33510109782218933,
0.23212988674640656,
-0.2019859403371811,
-0.7766035199165344,
0.21908782422542572,
-0.18838970363140106,
-0.09373731911182404
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06100v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06100v1
|
Automatic design optimization of preference-based subjective evaluation with online learning in crowdsourcing environment
| 2024-03-10T05:55:00 | 2024-03-10T05:55:00 |
Yusuke Yasuda, Tomoki Toda
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.AS, stat.ML
|
A preference-based subjective evaluation is a key method for evaluating
generative media reliably. However, its huge combinations of pairs prohibit it
from being applied to large-scale evaluation using crowdsourcing. To address
this issue, we propose an automatic optimization method for preference-based
subjective evaluation in terms of pair combination selections and allocation of
evaluation volumes with online learning in a crowdsourcing environment. We use
a preference-based online learning method based on a sorting algorithm to
identify the total order of evaluation targets with minimum sample volumes. Our
online learning algorithm supports parallel and asynchronous execution under
fixed-budget conditions required for crowdsourcing. Our experiment on
preference-based subjective evaluation of synthetic speech shows that our
method successfully optimizes the test by reducing pair combinations from 351
to 83 and allocating optimal evaluation volumes for each pair ranging from 30
to 663 without compromising evaluation accuracies and wasting budget
allocations.
|
[
-0.9897902607917786,
-0.3267585337162018,
0.41199254989624023,
0.5047838687896729,
-0.5307730436325073,
0.1391036957502365,
-0.5445603728294373,
-0.36970189213752747,
0.46477335691452026,
0.23346392810344696,
-0.6430947184562683,
-0.02947506494820118,
-0.3758805990219116,
0.28184157609939575,
0.08072756230831146,
0.8120001554489136,
0.11556700617074966,
0.3566231429576874,
-0.6055902242660522,
-0.3670741021633148,
-0.38904598355293274,
-0.3769502639770508,
-0.6205291152000427,
-0.0824471190571785,
0.15546797215938568,
0.6088013052940369,
0.4462340474128723,
0.6890947818756104,
0.4603838324546814,
0.4315128028392792,
-0.004429490305483341,
0.42725059390068054,
-0.6586002707481384,
0.009185371920466423,
-0.15115199983119965,
-0.10258343815803528,
-0.11718682944774628,
0.17586231231689453,
0.35767021775245667,
0.6422820091247559,
-0.26841801404953003,
0.4641249179840088,
-0.061243344098329544,
0.9102108478546143,
-0.7545835375785828,
-0.09354378283023834,
-0.45650264620780945,
0.2630351781845093,
0.05163171887397766,
-0.46439751982688904,
-0.25244370102882385,
-0.7882416248321533,
0.4531794488430023,
-0.7247825860977173,
0.2961694002151489,
0.14328739047050476,
0.4228363037109375,
0.5535730123519897,
0.1732972413301468,
-0.2617102861404419,
-0.5592811703681946,
0.9706307649612427,
-0.29986387491226196,
0.5267657041549683,
0.678488552570343,
0.2605627775192261,
0.3869076073169708,
-0.33098310232162476,
-0.34742042422294617,
-0.37250301241874695,
0.27972790598869324,
0.2646544873714447,
0.014576423913240433,
0.26013654470443726,
0.05891004204750061,
0.42029520869255066,
-0.853131890296936,
0.0835137739777565,
-0.4459246098995209,
-0.3371128439903259,
0.9246681928634644,
-0.10607632249593735,
0.10846398025751114,
-0.38410434126853943,
-0.16594953835010529,
-0.15736757218837738,
0.09249129146337509,
-0.06678233295679092,
0.6449288129806519,
0.23895716667175293,
-0.04908321052789688,
0.5105106830596924,
-0.48714566230773926,
0.7420143485069275,
0.6976591348648071,
-0.05018697306513786,
0.5341303944587708,
-0.2444392740726471,
-0.05788895860314369,
0.11605540663003922,
0.7045115828514099,
0.49676358699798584,
0.04905272275209427,
-0.24531954526901245,
-0.25080785155296326,
0.08900304138660431,
0.5053213238716125,
-0.5494005680084229,
-0.08072841167449951,
0.38449469208717346,
-0.6325175762176514,
-0.5307356715202332,
0.027828656136989594,
-0.8451302647590637,
-0.22014258801937103,
-0.8877084255218506,
0.6794485449790955,
0.08033515512943268,
-0.061329297721385956,
0.0655292496085167,
-0.18449683487415314,
-0.3027794063091278,
0.024318600073456764,
-0.9286256432533264,
0.2514640986919403,
0.485017329454422,
0.9776804447174072,
-0.35649850964546204,
0.03864787146449089,
-0.7331104874610901,
-0.27045926451683044,
0.031360507011413574,
0.9592297077178955,
-0.5122561454772949,
-0.7750788331031799,
-0.31161269545555115,
-0.5633665919303894,
0.24989427626132965,
-0.7162095904350281,
0.7025852203369141,
-0.5181054472923279,
0.39097028970718384,
-0.14806348085403442,
-0.7130810022354126,
0.03901418671011925,
-0.2052311897277832,
-0.7753500938415527,
0.6690784692764282,
0.08535127341747284,
-0.4908432960510254,
0.5385308265686035,
-0.9092983603477478,
-0.40841367840766907,
0.21130123734474182,
0.03683464229106903,
-0.7449638843536377,
0.16614869236946106,
0.22981689870357513,
0.1879618763923645,
-0.16477055847644806,
0.43341392278671265,
-0.49975165724754333,
-0.41066884994506836,
0.06478465348482132,
-0.1501423418521881,
0.8590600490570068,
0.5301389694213867,
-0.6459075808525085,
0.4981062114238739,
-0.701956570148468,
0.25865456461906433,
0.026980265974998474,
-0.32732781767845154,
-0.14206962287425995,
0.11798059940338135,
0.2824263572692871,
-0.05178730562329292,
0.19933059811592102,
-0.41662296652793884,
-0.10803933441638947,
-0.6047226190567017,
0.36261656880378723,
1.1662311553955078,
-0.0941847637295723,
0.7752099633216858,
-0.31098756194114685,
0.4122486710548401,
-0.5958567261695862,
0.7625147104263306,
0.7153224945068359,
-0.4746379852294922,
-0.7898098826408386,
-0.07214827090501785,
0.2659100592136383,
0.2518925070762634,
-0.4448751211166382,
0.730680525302887,
-0.06081216409802437,
-0.47779980301856995,
-0.6689439415931702,
0.26931464672088623,
0.39693185687065125,
0.15428265929222107,
0.2903962731361389,
-0.6708942651748657,
-0.6782426238059998,
-1.1965019702911377,
-0.15293088555335999,
-0.036851271986961365,
-0.13271871209144592,
0.5330700874328613,
-0.04349583387374878,
-0.030384648591279984,
1.2495664358139038,
-0.6734883785247803,
-0.2283201962709427,
0.12310203909873962,
0.36978834867477417,
-0.10011057555675507,
0.1741102635860443,
0.5588564872741699,
-0.9480172991752625,
-0.41586169600486755,
-0.43476054072380066,
-0.27632471919059753,
-0.4850817918777466,
0.04764944314956665,
-0.1893189698457718,
0.0867810994386673,
0.06569838523864746,
-0.07703501731157303,
-0.05973429977893829,
0.577090859413147,
0.07802148163318634,
0.4920165538787842,
-0.09792431443929672,
0.19518406689167023,
-0.6982157826423645,
-0.24477539956569672,
0.1114288941025734,
-0.19519777595996857,
-0.23273763060569763,
0.09981309622526169,
-0.07292316108942032,
-0.3080986440181732,
-0.4883284866809845,
0.31201979517936707,
-0.3719272017478943,
-0.23534582555294037,
-0.325960636138916,
0.3294273316860199,
0.05582081526517868,
0.5388866662979126,
0.1175011545419693,
0.63554847240448,
0.35370776057243347,
-0.5626978278160095,
0.5697999596595764,
0.1437055915594101,
-0.5995961427688599,
0.7054920792579651,
-0.5380118489265442,
0.6477941274642944,
-0.22753043472766876,
0.09229554980993271,
-0.6403995752334595,
-0.14833782613277435,
0.3882535994052887,
-0.29850471019744873,
-0.07956746965646744,
0.04336656630039215,
-0.25489169359207153,
-0.3498184382915497,
-0.39624083042144775,
0.4644632339477539,
0.3008299469947815,
-0.766416072845459,
0.14106208086013794,
0.7598469257354736,
-0.15638186037540436,
-0.06777817755937576,
-0.19107024371623993,
-0.2921575903892517,
-0.2845868468284607,
-0.551988959312439,
0.37822049856185913,
-0.5073170065879822,
-0.519037663936615,
-0.1651807576417923,
-0.06648341566324234,
-0.017883609980344772,
-0.1326800286769867,
0.31812965869903564,
0.21719437837600708,
0.10877024382352829,
0.10920969396829605,
0.12727029621601105,
-0.3361486792564392,
-0.025188593193888664,
-0.4459878206253052,
0.45801445841789246,
-0.1236313059926033,
-0.36713266372680664,
-0.44292232394218445,
0.43219947814941406,
0.3203296661376953,
-0.22424370050430298,
0.24616563320159912,
0.47529950737953186,
-0.04870085418224335,
-0.23776963353157043,
-0.9073398113250732,
-0.09599888324737549,
-0.5729911923408508,
0.3662746250629425,
-0.2147143930196762,
-0.5532642006874084,
-0.003416063729673624,
0.07824841886758804,
-0.02671048231422901,
0.5013652443885803,
0.6133680939674377,
0.07189930975437164,
0.9204973578453064,
0.03772656247019768,
-0.35477516055107117,
0.594830334186554,
-0.24069245159626007,
-0.03890567645430565,
-0.2963797152042389,
-0.0998433455824852,
-0.4218858778476715,
-0.3911871016025543,
-0.5389523506164551,
-0.37242400646209717,
0.6570755243301392,
-0.39781317114830017,
-0.0944429561495781,
0.12723557651042938,
-1.090057611465454,
0.7904965281486511,
0.9325145483016968,
0.4526822865009308,
0.25854408740997314,
0.28072813153266907,
0.1818360835313797,
0.09700269252061844,
-0.2691096365451813,
-0.1340353935956955,
1.2224563360214233,
-0.07920756936073303,
0.18151381611824036,
0.011038918048143387,
0.8272053003311157,
0.5785515308380127,
0.15159204602241516,
-1.0926182270050049,
0.41907498240470886,
0.0031553616281598806,
-0.44351884722709656,
-0.5869115591049194,
-0.6277192234992981,
-0.6668493151664734,
0.22617650032043457,
-0.17214372754096985,
-0.1964082270860672,
0.23236514627933502,
0.03621520474553108,
-0.5458326935768127,
0.05445340648293495,
-0.8390206694602966,
0.3841761648654938,
-0.5011113882064819,
-0.3861140310764313,
-0.9043562412261963,
-0.5906352996826172,
0.01678147353231907,
-0.20728908479213715,
0.24642440676689148,
0.02225426584482193,
0.2016867995262146,
0.9946914911270142,
-0.38593271374702454,
0.3247931897640228,
-0.3276516795158386,
0.27652299404144287,
0.2992017865180969,
-0.16039936244487762,
0.29403313994407654,
0.0021554818376898766,
-0.4210129976272583,
0.24912121891975403,
-0.3237287700176239,
-0.3195817768573761,
-0.5534671545028687,
0.7710782289505005,
-1.1491589546203613,
-0.5746133923530579,
-0.23896712064743042,
-0.13593050837516785,
-0.5203390121459961,
-0.10319173336029053,
0.5557364225387573,
0.6427851915359497,
-0.20018675923347473,
0.042028024792671204,
0.24709613621234894,
-0.22283335030078888,
0.5155265927314758,
0.3608236312866211,
0.0565747432410717,
-0.8871746063232422,
1.4714075326919556,
0.11767333745956421,
0.354636013507843,
0.23505687713623047,
0.6523764729499817,
-0.5655856132507324,
-0.5562847852706909,
-0.6709430813789368,
-0.04756060615181923,
-0.44475245475769043,
-0.002922728192061186,
-0.3582223951816559,
0.1409914344549179,
-0.3123221695423126,
-0.2901693284511566,
-0.35875385999679565,
-0.4246538579463959,
-0.4071180522441864,
-0.07174263894557953,
0.12536388635635376,
0.48790502548217773,
-0.3474513292312622,
-0.05923505127429962,
-0.4738590717315674,
0.5767132043838501,
0.7756537199020386,
0.7252562046051025,
-0.04093235731124878,
-0.4724552035331726,
-0.24681907892227173,
0.060394104570150375,
-0.6362594962120056,
-0.7705510854721069,
0.4673561155796051,
0.21340732276439667,
0.5145479440689087,
0.732597827911377,
0.21944506466388702,
0.7761242389678955,
-0.41248059272766113,
0.3084888458251953,
0.14442308247089386,
-0.9533869624137878,
0.5864797234535217,
-0.25617268681526184,
0.010625001043081284,
0.9539390206336975,
0.31399744749069214,
-0.2265794724225998,
-0.14267422258853912,
-0.7285969257354736,
-0.7462828755378723,
0.7497144341468811,
0.422688752412796,
-0.06841298192739487,
0.257011353969574,
0.08428991585969925,
0.38996055722236633,
0.28702467679977417,
-0.33045443892478943,
-0.4952198565006256,
-0.5068711638450623,
0.12953971326351166,
-0.22796210646629333,
-0.12218081206083298,
-0.21401192247867584,
-0.5832856893539429,
0.5401332378387451,
0.0673956423997879,
0.23644742369651794,
0.059813398867845535,
-0.05695342645049095,
-0.33595359325408936,
0.07504212856292725,
0.599831223487854,
0.6360990405082703,
-0.28924909234046936,
-0.32988083362579346,
0.13196152448654175,
-0.2806183695793152,
0.11815019696950912,
0.028443461284041405,
-0.2539512813091278,
0.04965045303106308,
-0.298305869102478,
0.9505001306533813,
0.10369251668453217,
-0.6781359910964966,
0.5285428762435913,
0.08782915771007538,
-0.24822181463241577,
-0.5190448760986328,
-0.129320427775383,
-0.08570630848407745,
0.10875073820352554,
0.4486549198627472,
0.3153589963912964,
0.713181734085083,
-0.15379276871681213,
0.12957952916622162,
0.4742441475391388,
-0.09494666010141373,
-0.0002810851437970996,
0.43139973282814026,
0.6197401881217957,
-0.6378369927406311,
0.508541464805603,
-0.4336075484752655,
-0.3836246430873871,
0.7162734866142273,
0.15676049888134003,
1.1895579099655151,
-0.30214306712150574,
0.573972225189209,
0.3075038194656372,
-0.13382960855960846,
-0.05657855421304703,
0.09757321327924728,
-0.3633062243461609,
-0.5535255670547485,
-0.14155958592891693,
-0.8968890905380249,
-0.842496931552887,
-0.0066025336273014545,
-0.87281733751297,
0.46657249331474304,
-0.5576022863388062,
-0.23756246268749237,
0.1183416023850441,
0.04060355946421623,
-0.6834827661514282,
0.3958020806312561,
0.17443722486495972,
0.1099584773182869,
-0.7237929701805115,
0.2614954710006714,
0.36239027976989746,
-0.2618190050125122,
-0.5427742004394531,
-0.040743593126535416,
0.2828139066696167,
-0.6943536996841431,
0.5985257625579834,
0.0654563456773758,
-0.30496418476104736,
0.12237219512462616,
-0.3508075475692749,
-0.7929194569587708,
0.471623957157135,
0.4637264311313629,
-0.6744418740272522,
0.37278687953948975,
-0.022626951336860657,
0.4860891103744507,
0.0322689451277256,
0.4917467534542084,
0.05426913499832153,
0.6803175806999207,
0.005353106185793877,
-1.1681995391845703,
-0.3066677451133728,
-0.34988880157470703,
-0.2029065638780594,
0.09765647351741791,
-0.9349618554115295,
0.3018421232700348,
-0.12168549746274948,
-0.18893176317214966,
-0.2060064673423767,
0.564500629901886,
0.18873699009418488,
0.4029679000377655,
1.0066032409667969,
0.4981144964694977,
0.6937727332115173,
0.1891249716281891,
0.9549286365509033,
-0.07966252416372299,
0.48253190517425537,
0.8321351408958435,
0.022260120138525963,
0.760578989982605,
0.42282551527023315,
-0.5886675119400024,
0.15059931576251984,
0.962278425693512,
-0.1693505197763443,
0.7525671124458313,
0.5137025117874146,
-0.5162776112556458,
-0.4035169184207916,
-0.2438664436340332,
-0.3284868001937866,
0.5339462757110596,
-0.17546218633651733,
-0.17424945533275604,
0.2208860218524933,
0.22703729569911957,
-0.5211339592933655,
0.044311847537755966,
-0.34721794724464417,
0.9980406165122986,
-0.16380490362644196,
-0.781949520111084,
0.7442901134490967,
0.0688110888004303,
0.7379938960075378,
-0.11661310493946075,
0.3629143536090851,
-0.060275156050920486,
-0.11799120157957077,
-0.3459862470626831,
-0.19109389185905457,
0.19320307672023773,
-0.17944249510765076,
-0.25787341594696045,
-0.4373812973499298,
0.24675020575523376,
-0.147667795419693,
-0.5929454565048218,
0.2220267653465271,
0.2179354578256607,
0.13829411566257477,
-0.3634297549724579,
-0.6527439951896667,
0.08996959775686264,
0.05238160863518715,
-0.2908121645450592,
0.41585302352905273,
-0.2009870558977127,
0.1187305822968483,
0.5081800818443298,
0.8366355895996094,
0.273368775844574,
-0.22358465194702148,
0.42943790555000305,
0.8308553695678711,
-0.3248615860939026,
-0.8070697784423828,
-0.7971871495246887,
0.1635040044784546,
-0.25924816727638245,
-0.20288118720054626,
0.4272932708263397,
0.8958544731140137,
0.9830470681190491,
-0.25816503167152405,
1.0077840089797974,
0.12675127387046814,
0.36591964960098267,
-0.3589947521686554,
0.6738870143890381,
-0.5040425062179565,
-0.10634041577577591,
-0.5083083510398865,
-1.1272532939910889,
-0.13967271149158478,
0.7875826954841614,
-0.4711931049823761,
-0.07611682265996933,
0.5049921870231628,
0.7244570851325989,
-0.08879658579826355,
0.5254663228988647,
0.134862020611763,
-0.2935756742954254,
-0.1816685050725937,
0.3146771192550659,
0.5158907175064087,
0.10418304800987244,
0.5305303931236267,
-0.7261487245559692,
-0.532224714756012,
-0.3996363580226898,
-0.593051552772522,
-0.7114655375480652,
-0.8778696656227112,
-0.3191567659378052,
-0.11245671659708023,
0.11722816526889801,
1.5366647243499756,
0.7947559356689453,
-0.8034970760345459,
-0.43281570076942444,
0.07638576626777649,
-0.16944929957389832,
-0.24846188724040985,
-0.28372833132743835,
0.42500507831573486,
-0.1748349964618683,
-1.0894237756729126,
0.5811715722084045,
0.24458645284175873,
-0.369944304227829,
-0.49994632601737976,
-0.2030988335609436,
0.17602762579917908,
-0.20077045261859894,
0.7282654643058777,
0.20601080358028412,
-0.836887538433075,
-0.26789358258247375,
-0.07607541233301163,
0.1453823447227478,
0.1592479795217514,
0.927001953125,
-0.7278655171394348,
1.0129656791687012,
0.7809954881668091,
0.5830535292625427,
0.5839311480522156,
0.35140275955200195,
0.6001845002174377,
-0.401963472366333,
0.034438829869031906,
0.36129575967788696,
0.057441167533397675,
0.23798605799674988,
-0.35985466837882996,
0.3766404688358307,
0.42439016699790955,
-0.6816185116767883,
-0.6240809559822083,
-0.00744543457403779,
-1.1219284534454346,
-0.050377704203128815,
1.1753181219100952,
0.4052908420562744,
0.3114604949951172,
-0.25779619812965393,
-0.5308783054351807,
0.3785429894924164,
-0.6921578645706177,
1.302780270576477,
0.5061498284339905,
-0.3504123091697693,
0.06327610462903976,
-0.24450565874576569,
0.5000810027122498,
0.5517192482948303,
-0.6317471861839294,
-0.40610572695732117,
0.6232779026031494,
0.061066433787345886,
0.20946086943149567,
0.3747234344482422,
0.2719963490962982,
0.1948564350605011,
-0.2969367802143097,
0.05285653844475746,
-0.16713300347328186,
0.10042252391576767,
-0.26204913854599,
0.4552849233150482,
-0.08892078697681427,
-0.4833787679672241
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06098v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06098v3
|
VidProM: A Million-scale Real Prompt-Gallery Dataset for Text-to-Video Diffusion Models
| 2024-03-10T05:40:12 | 2024-05-14T13:01:02 |
Wenhao Wang, Yi Yang
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
The arrival of Sora marks a new era for text-to-video diffusion models,
bringing significant advancements in video generation and potential
applications. However, Sora, along with other text-to-video diffusion models,
is highly reliant on prompts, and there is no publicly available dataset that
features a study of text-to-video prompts. In this paper, we introduce VidProM,
the first large-scale dataset comprising 1.67 Million unique text-to-Video
Prompts from real users. Additionally, this dataset includes 6.69 million
videos generated by four state-of-the-art diffusion models, alongside some
related data. We initially discuss the curation of this large-scale dataset, a
process that is both time-consuming and costly. Subsequently, we underscore the
need for a new prompt dataset specifically designed for text-to-video
generation by illustrating how VidProM differs from DiffusionDB, a large-scale
prompt-gallery dataset for image generation. Our extensive and diverse dataset
also opens up many exciting new research areas. For instance, we suggest
exploring text-to-video prompt engineering, efficient video generation, and
video copy detection for diffusion models to develop better, more efficient,
and safer models. The project (including the collected dataset VidProM and
related code) is publicly available at https://vidprom.github.io under the
CC-BY-NC 4.0 License.
|
[
-0.5573254823684692,
-0.9817156195640564,
0.5099535584449768,
0.32128721475601196,
-0.32964977622032166,
-0.3124735653400421,
-0.03950188681483269,
0.1925904005765915,
-0.018377812579274178,
0.43128061294555664,
-0.6308489441871643,
-0.18162250518798828,
-0.6838046312332153,
-0.07533104717731476,
-0.7696058750152588,
0.9652578830718994,
0.07944131642580032,
0.007531552575528622,
-0.13737158477306366,
-0.09956565499305725,
-0.6284047961235046,
-0.14108510315418243,
-0.45477738976478577,
0.24153494834899902,
0.6189420223236084,
0.6851317286491394,
0.30923956632614136,
0.4731840193271637,
0.3191702961921692,
0.13064539432525635,
0.042399827390909195,
0.15978887677192688,
-0.6717000603675842,
0.22665640711784363,
-0.16165557503700256,
0.007223824970424175,
-0.2046137899160385,
-0.21380819380283356,
1.007685899734497,
0.10400311648845673,
0.11490027606487274,
0.3661149740219116,
-0.06546872109174728,
0.7936623096466064,
-0.607405960559845,
-0.30395516753196716,
-0.07630741596221924,
0.32793503999710083,
-0.34589651226997375,
-0.13929986953735352,
-0.469281941652298,
-0.6291635036468506,
0.23066534101963043,
-0.6240168809890747,
0.4171005189418793,
-0.13869209587574005,
0.38134002685546875,
0.1661621779203415,
-0.4597075879573822,
0.09163887798786163,
-0.9099907875061035,
0.36571595072746277,
-0.034261349588632584,
0.13026851415634155,
0.028900092467665672,
0.7261675000190735,
0.055222686380147934,
-0.9430165886878967,
-0.7536182999610901,
0.16999344527721405,
0.6651391983032227,
0.10760592669248581,
-0.4661538898944855,
-0.3215869665145874,
0.28208455443382263,
0.12756569683551788,
-0.7778509259223938,
0.035996418446302414,
-0.2908906042575836,
-0.014932414516806602,
0.4905969202518463,
0.27125778794288635,
0.35358259081840515,
-0.2074543535709381,
-0.6285863518714905,
-0.2773538827896118,
-0.6526360511779785,
-0.24813741445541382,
0.3498145341873169,
0.09833688288927078,
-0.22194990515708923,
0.5743220448493958,
-0.08658459037542343,
0.6597286462783813,
0.03350043296813965,
0.16416645050048828,
0.03223937749862671,
-0.5114536285400391,
-0.25387367606163025,
0.17201799154281616,
1.1240888833999634,
0.5974518656730652,
0.4133700430393219,
0.4422001838684082,
0.22296804189682007,
-0.02838265150785446,
0.07585027068853378,
-1.1955448389053345,
-0.3263879120349884,
-0.12552475929260254,
-0.6452864408493042,
-0.1399487406015396,
-0.08872620761394501,
-1.316014289855957,
-0.8022695779800415,
-0.02078372985124588,
0.6065742373466492,
-0.10950382053852081,
-0.49883320927619934,
0.16707393527030945,
-0.3360230624675751,
0.02808394655585289,
0.7291788458824158,
-0.6053194999694824,
0.08668908476829529,
0.47882911562919617,
1.1465054750442505,
-0.298929899930954,
-0.15768258273601532,
-0.8192611932754517,
-0.17084859311580658,
-0.2000419795513153,
1.0777835845947266,
-0.562065839767456,
-0.7284857630729675,
0.2574755549430847,
0.03545372933149338,
0.22258859872817993,
-0.47189927101135254,
0.4332462549209595,
-0.5234032869338989,
0.2598126530647278,
-0.524061381816864,
-0.5788550972938538,
0.07160626351833344,
0.05392969399690628,
-0.7705588936805725,
0.7110311985015869,
-0.1892499327659607,
-0.7646670937538147,
0.3703807592391968,
-0.7057345509529114,
-0.22694405913352966,
0.18579550087451935,
-0.21058544516563416,
-0.33395814895629883,
-0.07524695992469788,
-0.06979386508464813,
0.5197154879570007,
-0.5624833106994629,
0.43991246819496155,
-0.07152857631444931,
-0.12992744147777557,
0.25752726197242737,
-0.9506009221076965,
0.4739876985549927,
0.4338494837284088,
0.041099581867456436,
0.07998012006282806,
-0.7857615947723389,
-0.5494614243507385,
-0.07071927189826965,
-0.06178855895996094,
-0.05472376197576523,
-0.14402994513511658,
0.4577161371707916,
0.2114962935447693,
0.15094028413295746,
-0.4904136061668396,
0.24948552250862122,
0.37384358048439026,
0.40753570199012756,
0.8528732061386108,
0.16012799739837646,
0.5119139552116394,
-0.05685727670788765,
0.9672253131866455,
0.10051219910383224,
0.3991125822067261,
-0.8562083840370178,
-0.8254203796386719,
-0.05792229250073433,
-0.3829326629638672,
0.09438402205705643,
0.35979998111724854,
-0.6098518371582031,
-0.06684704124927521,
-0.3475160300731659,
-0.44864988327026367,
-0.1992068886756897,
-0.11996868252754211,
0.0487109050154686,
0.8264204263687134,
0.2260599583387375,
-0.2543432414531708,
-0.2507272958755493,
-0.5236775279045105,
0.22252580523490906,
0.17822754383087158,
-0.05742882937192917,
0.40837132930755615,
0.25320300459861755,
-0.10901600122451782,
1.1696287393569946,
-0.6254937052726746,
-0.47621849179267883,
-0.06604712456464767,
0.2538241446018219,
0.23316720128059387,
0.4450746476650238,
0.5672482848167419,
-0.98370760679245,
-0.6943017840385437,
-0.23983924090862274,
-0.7820948958396912,
-0.15465113520622253,
-0.17160861194133759,
-0.10868284851312637,
-0.12357759475708008,
0.6953997611999512,
-0.6808746457099915,
0.4609454572200775,
0.687221348285675,
-0.5852445960044861,
0.8441084623336792,
-0.5569714307785034,
0.3101966083049774,
-1.1942251920700073,
0.22449041903018951,
0.3039814233779907,
-0.32297664880752563,
-0.5908983945846558,
-0.3039102852344513,
-0.11083057522773743,
-0.34434106945991516,
-0.6907545328140259,
0.7696195840835571,
-0.07489228993654251,
-0.11107279360294342,
-0.022183211520314217,
0.21346347033977509,
0.05280734971165657,
0.06721657514572144,
0.10766001790761948,
0.89227694272995,
0.8789884448051453,
-0.7411566376686096,
0.48649153113365173,
0.5561267733573914,
-0.5129624605178833,
0.9746707081794739,
-0.7314149737358093,
-0.33653706312179565,
-0.452986478805542,
0.29913243651390076,
-1.4738346338272095,
-0.3094450831413269,
0.34609490633010864,
-0.3271149694919586,
0.042616475373506546,
-0.38273391127586365,
-0.5056801438331604,
-0.1768038272857666,
-0.3106571137905121,
0.6351107358932495,
0.7118697762489319,
-0.6667577624320984,
0.37624841928482056,
0.2821059226989746,
-0.48352882266044617,
-0.4312926232814789,
-0.43354713916778564,
0.22359172999858856,
-0.3278030753135681,
-0.5554925203323364,
0.27415943145751953,
-0.3429325520992279,
0.13034409284591675,
-0.1871030330657959,
0.203921839594841,
-0.22777606546878815,
-0.2298690378665924,
0.3984110653400421,
0.2690267264842987,
-0.006374896503984928,
0.17443250119686127,
0.01964457519352436,
-0.27247628569602966,
0.10695421695709229,
-0.3293544054031372,
0.646351158618927,
0.5200232863426208,
-0.13240796327590942,
-0.5958638787269592,
0.4776332974433899,
0.45191651582717896,
-0.13852620124816895,
0.4755939841270447,
0.7303628921508789,
-0.06873185187578201,
0.04236093908548355,
-0.2796725630760193,
0.11756094545125961,
-0.47873789072036743,
0.2663741409778595,
-0.1008908599615097,
-0.7253751754760742,
0.44175201654434204,
-0.2196548879146576,
0.09226591885089874,
0.17920807003974915,
0.6730082035064697,
-0.10043080896139145,
1.0517622232437134,
0.5085873007774353,
0.09485325962305069,
1.123172640800476,
-0.4912320673465729,
-0.014361729845404625,
-0.38920116424560547,
-0.12084949016571045,
-0.38016703724861145,
-0.38132110238075256,
-0.2571974992752075,
-0.7620060443878174,
0.5158748030662537,
-0.31140145659446716,
-0.40654823184013367,
-0.128030464053154,
-0.4905256927013397,
0.5531235933303833,
0.32349351048469543,
0.027452154085040092,
0.4454335868358612,
0.2946423888206482,
0.2504217326641083,
-0.09185321629047394,
-0.6280239820480347,
-0.43862050771713257,
1.0337644815444946,
0.13183660805225372,
0.926207959651947,
0.12363706529140472,
0.19259393215179443,
0.9752167463302612,
0.08081118017435074,
-0.628420352935791,
0.8806841373443604,
-0.35147523880004883,
-0.3441821336746216,
-0.25869739055633545,
-0.40006691217422485,
-1.0691859722137451,
-0.16584698855876923,
-0.145301952958107,
-0.28447219729423523,
0.3340453505516052,
0.30813345313072205,
-0.30739399790763855,
0.17736852169036865,
-0.5893664956092834,
1.0049079656600952,
0.17326760292053223,
-0.7432531714439392,
-0.2403508722782135,
-0.8093050718307495,
0.27450546622276306,
-0.12309225648641586,
0.20585335791110992,
0.06169810891151428,
0.2070123851299286,
0.735209047794342,
-0.5985110402107239,
0.646501362323761,
-0.572333574295044,
-0.2428499460220337,
0.4705619215965271,
0.12878866493701935,
0.2894245386123657,
0.11709508299827576,
0.12289072573184967,
-0.2989703416824341,
-0.27760806679725647,
-0.19627195596694946,
-0.30523231625556946,
0.6805884838104248,
-0.4582637548446655,
-0.16416522860527039,
-0.02192685380578041,
-0.18840797245502472,
0.35133200883865356,
0.32060402631759644,
0.7365525364875793,
0.843252956867218,
-0.4167778193950653,
0.0766371488571167,
1.2725502252578735,
-0.46358180046081543,
0.5449875593185425,
0.16616427898406982,
-0.47891509532928467,
-0.33927273750305176,
1.1702240705490112,
0.20271217823028564,
0.14924044907093048,
0.31149834394454956,
0.18213658034801483,
-0.3659645915031433,
-0.32544583082199097,
-0.7909741997718811,
0.03710326552391052,
-0.5328902006149292,
-0.25804072618484497,
-0.7262634038925171,
0.0801081582903862,
-0.2263375073671341,
-0.13379481434822083,
-0.3408975303173065,
-0.31336042284965515,
-0.7144791483879089,
-0.15783026814460754,
0.8466674089431763,
0.5136256814002991,
0.0034655830822885036,
0.594192385673523,
-0.9121178984642029,
0.5902640223503113,
0.635040283203125,
0.28616800904273987,
0.04251953586935997,
-0.5191739797592163,
-0.22240762412548065,
-0.16859671473503113,
-0.2938263416290283,
-0.7550532817840576,
0.5303989052772522,
0.28802990913391113,
0.10615264624357224,
0.6779555082321167,
0.0947226881980896,
0.5456309914588928,
-0.6903406381607056,
1.1775799989700317,
0.43512842059135437,
-0.617338240146637,
0.5158373117446899,
-0.6185431480407715,
0.21329715847969055,
0.26684457063674927,
0.3612437844276428,
-0.525532603263855,
0.20391641557216644,
-0.4998701214790344,
-0.6797952651977539,
0.4701782166957855,
-0.23124070465564728,
0.38981953263282776,
-0.022969970479607582,
0.16244643926620483,
0.37801694869995117,
0.15767255425453186,
-0.25960513949394226,
-0.1307627558708191,
-0.33799800276756287,
-0.3003882169723511,
-0.2132452130317688,
-0.23521730303764343,
-0.0005227753426879644,
0.0674961507320404,
0.0686240941286087,
-0.15841148793697357,
0.2822847366333008,
0.35281965136528015,
-0.1978752762079239,
-0.16146968305110931,
0.11195449531078339,
0.3392069935798645,
0.2553650736808777,
0.07044248282909393,
-0.026141498237848282,
-0.3318008780479431,
-0.7536643147468567,
0.424578994512558,
0.03538817912340164,
-0.2550811767578125,
0.09520416706800461,
-0.03457430750131607,
0.7893388867378235,
-0.2319955974817276,
-1.050157070159912,
0.9501084089279175,
-0.22803384065628052,
-0.4278132915496826,
-0.24600379168987274,
-0.0499158576130867,
-0.31865230202674866,
0.3077274262905121,
0.45549625158309937,
0.14228157699108124,
0.4744671881198883,
-0.357928603887558,
0.25676485896110535,
0.18504676222801208,
-0.46943244338035583,
-0.5208374857902527,
1.1384121179580688,
0.3302394151687622,
-0.2628191411495209,
0.550399124622345,
-0.09875110536813736,
-0.1355230212211609,
0.48006054759025574,
0.2139902561903,
0.7562288045883179,
-0.17723973095417023,
0.8019177913665771,
0.22777758538722992,
-0.2876181900501251,
-0.6014964580535889,
0.36364224553108215,
-0.34063929319381714,
-0.4526955485343933,
-0.35419923067092896,
-0.21736116707324982,
-0.40188631415367126,
-0.42042097449302673,
-0.7002975940704346,
0.3537106513977051,
-0.7054397463798523,
-0.5053240060806274,
-0.07099366188049316,
-0.22734388709068298,
-0.5299347639083862,
0.18168765306472778,
0.14422301948070526,
1.13144850730896,
-1.1672439575195312,
0.6978115439414978,
0.5548210740089417,
-0.25780460238456726,
-0.10969500988721848,
-0.3483129143714905,
-0.13909108936786652,
-0.50620037317276,
0.5967212319374084,
0.15392009913921356,
0.2295738011598587,
0.2571560740470886,
-0.6028609871864319,
-0.2360967993736267,
0.9406914710998535,
0.363107293844223,
-0.7151382565498352,
0.12964314222335815,
0.030158525332808495,
0.5168408751487732,
-0.2543903887271881,
0.1804770678281784,
0.44388243556022644,
0.372441828250885,
0.35838305950164795,
-0.2978282570838928,
-0.07895824313163757,
-0.2277270406484604,
-0.018102001398801804,
0.24276931583881378,
-0.8245232701301575,
0.9048832654953003,
-0.2419518679380417,
-0.12543125450611115,
0.11402955651283264,
0.4161350131034851,
0.3513438403606415,
0.5625525116920471,
0.3921114504337311,
0.4800455868244171,
0.5571406483650208,
0.1341785341501236,
0.77204829454422,
0.25722208619117737,
0.10811714082956314,
0.953927218914032,
-0.4292874336242676,
0.7099340558052063,
0.4084409773349762,
-0.08761939406394958,
0.3962467908859253,
0.48400476574897766,
-0.19262371957302094,
0.7184616923332214,
-0.1334610879421234,
-0.4995814561843872,
-0.2387242466211319,
-0.4632497727870941,
-0.36145272850990295,
-0.10847632586956024,
0.3216380178928375,
-0.4424043595790863,
-0.09090773016214371,
0.5906835198402405,
-0.27185961604118347,
-0.00446442561224103,
-0.3086661398410797,
0.7637911438941956,
-0.24776634573936462,
-0.3538788855075836,
0.03998182341456413,
-0.5959052443504333,
0.5123995542526245,
-0.48720216751098633,
-0.08710133284330368,
-0.40823987126350403,
0.03182569891214371,
-0.13583031296730042,
-1.127771019935608,
-0.09436997771263123,
0.5685431957244873,
-0.44068482518196106,
-0.5996543169021606,
0.6754767894744873,
-0.24768930673599243,
-0.2736425995826721,
-0.027216367423534393,
0.31939712166786194,
0.2221400886774063,
-0.07357896864414215,
-0.316558837890625,
0.11889342963695526,
-0.12384599447250366,
-0.375868558883667,
0.49165284633636475,
0.6817111968994141,
-0.041941966861486435,
0.6264294981956482,
0.44741904735565186,
-0.08907344937324524,
0.15461909770965576,
0.3131049871444702,
0.7892763018608093,
-0.7760112285614014,
-0.696175217628479,
-0.8812527656555176,
0.6603858470916748,
0.012697159312665462,
-0.30720755457878113,
0.8222519159317017,
0.602778971195221,
0.23720063269138336,
-0.16513697803020477,
0.9977487325668335,
-0.09944546222686768,
0.32358527183532715,
-0.33519217371940613,
0.39881953597068787,
-0.5706561207771301,
0.04402618855237961,
-0.4482325613498688,
-0.9441001415252686,
-0.209327831864357,
0.3754424750804901,
0.08308319002389908,
-0.26070624589920044,
0.0776451975107193,
0.7911046147346497,
-0.017424453049898148,
0.17991669476032257,
0.1721925437450409,
0.27558428049087524,
0.5782675743103027,
0.21102078258991241,
1.1093635559082031,
-0.5025316476821899,
0.7095886468887329,
0.4361186623573303,
-0.3418567478656769,
-0.6406278014183044,
-1.0200878381729126,
-0.4622889757156372,
-0.6602930426597595,
-0.4056950509548187,
-0.2295878529548645,
-0.14974777400493622,
0.6661511659622192,
0.6855418682098389,
-0.26134711503982544,
-0.1968938410282135,
-0.37339726090431213,
-0.03240837901830673,
-0.13126295804977417,
-0.1743444800376892,
0.24795763194561005,
0.3191736340522766,
-0.6345955729484558,
0.09229929000139236,
0.3139686584472656,
0.27508410811424255,
-0.4312342405319214,
-0.03241855278611183,
0.05980964004993439,
-0.012815045192837715,
0.7415900230407715,
0.44729161262512207,
0.01982719823718071,
0.08547364175319672,
0.137717604637146,
0.07365255802869797,
0.14125344157218933,
0.7572560906410217,
-0.9122663736343384,
0.7513311505317688,
1.0689332485198975,
0.35192057490348816,
0.756852924823761,
0.03473326563835144,
0.7041552662849426,
-0.737066924571991,
0.16236472129821777,
-0.17257177829742432,
0.17521487176418304,
0.2510937750339508,
-0.19864729046821594,
0.320682168006897,
0.17608191072940826,
-0.7825533747673035,
-0.8994950652122498,
0.14629025757312775,
-1.2992905378341675,
-0.20456863939762115,
0.971084713935852,
-0.0008894421625882387,
-0.02738805301487446,
-0.03260763734579086,
-0.7565410733222961,
0.19223693013191223,
-0.6879024505615234,
0.5324353575706482,
0.26230162382125854,
0.1433577984571457,
-0.4825711250305176,
-0.46209588646888733,
0.41110512614250183,
0.07758638262748718,
-0.735772967338562,
0.5299780368804932,
0.8540545105934143,
0.15983858704566956,
-0.10512758791446686,
0.8028215169906616,
0.03915421664714813,
0.5761943459510803,
-0.04969067499041557,
-0.13796167075634003,
-0.03746721148490906,
-0.7124024629592896,
-0.6503993272781372,
0.3731216490268707,
-0.2537606656551361,
-0.20083408057689667
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06097v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06097v2
|
Can LLM Substitute Human Labeling? A Case Study of Fine-grained Chinese Address Entity Recognition Dataset for UAV Delivery
| 2024-03-10T05:12:16 | 2024-03-19T11:36:26 |
Yuxuan Yao, Sichun Luo, Haohan Zhao, Guanzhi Deng, Linqi Song
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
We present CNER-UAV, a fine-grained \textbf{C}hinese \textbf{N}ame
\textbf{E}ntity \textbf{R}ecognition dataset specifically designed for the task
of address resolution in \textbf{U}nmanned \textbf{A}erial \textbf{V}ehicle
delivery systems. The dataset encompasses a diverse range of five categories,
enabling comprehensive training and evaluation of NER models. To construct this
dataset, we sourced the data from a real-world UAV delivery system and
conducted a rigorous data cleaning and desensitization process to ensure
privacy and data integrity. The resulting dataset, consisting of around 12,000
annotated samples, underwent human experts and \textbf{L}arge \textbf{L}anguage
\textbf{M}odel annotation. We evaluated classical NER models on our dataset and
provided in-depth analysis. The dataset and models are publicly available at
\url{https://github.com/zhhvvv/CNER-UAV}.
|
[
-0.3679412305355072,
-0.5753488540649414,
0.20400460064411163,
-0.3529135584831238,
-0.13691888749599457,
-0.15893885493278503,
0.032048363238573074,
-0.9868605136871338,
0.04571138322353363,
0.8381334543228149,
-0.3054889738559723,
-0.6568695902824402,
-0.11657823622226715,
0.2192865014076233,
-0.31627532839775085,
0.8981176614761353,
0.1521037369966507,
-0.19648854434490204,
0.03631148114800453,
-0.22884102165699005,
-0.36081641912460327,
-0.9418171048164368,
-0.6253626942634583,
-0.3391261100769043,
0.5593894720077515,
0.3684583902359009,
0.6457942724227905,
1.445393681526184,
0.6614119410514832,
0.21296758949756622,
-0.15535739064216614,
0.4272536337375641,
-0.018063798546791077,
-0.31746140122413635,
-0.3306138515472412,
-0.1562732607126236,
-0.7816611528396606,
-0.16046710312366486,
0.6857218742370605,
0.675041675567627,
-0.2794286608695984,
0.20933465659618378,
-0.11467435956001282,
0.6007835268974304,
-0.48752889037132263,
-0.2988823354244232,
-0.651884138584137,
0.1764620691537857,
-0.35668447613716125,
-0.1466720849275589,
-0.7204437851905823,
-0.06770246475934982,
0.3966417908668518,
-0.815689206123352,
0.18411628901958466,
0.5942686200141907,
1.2795302867889404,
0.3783813416957855,
-0.6026957035064697,
-0.1179877519607544,
-0.9326677322387695,
0.7260226607322693,
-0.6844831705093384,
0.32449260354042053,
0.19485799968242645,
0.5072579383850098,
-0.4397861063480377,
-0.5478538274765015,
-0.2598313093185425,
-0.1890767365694046,
0.07330051809549332,
0.02789481356739998,
-0.18366163969039917,
0.47573795914649963,
0.19558869302272797,
0.34632131457328796,
-0.21157865226268768,
0.5835680961608887,
-0.3813125789165497,
-0.4971194863319397,
0.6726557612419128,
0.3043871521949768,
0.3714706003665924,
-0.12683947384357452,
-0.6755051612854004,
0.05753634497523308,
-0.8485709428787231,
0.40400630235671997,
0.4569823443889618,
0.5101251602172852,
-0.09545742720365524,
0.7246384620666504,
-0.6214370131492615,
0.7992828488349915,
0.1974347084760666,
-0.02322148159146309,
0.282014399766922,
-0.11163899302482605,
-0.6976762413978577,
0.21913191676139832,
0.9108890891075134,
0.3159063458442688,
0.25981155037879944,
-0.22957812249660492,
-0.3683680593967438,
-0.16720649600028992,
0.2642129063606262,
-0.6596093773841858,
-0.5675985813140869,
0.08091749250888824,
-0.5006611943244934,
-0.3388311564922333,
0.3383129835128784,
-0.6864360570907593,
-0.5560835003852844,
-0.24082475900650024,
-0.13530583679676056,
-0.03358624875545502,
0.12120287120342255,
-0.01898929476737976,
0.22504039108753204,
0.7172670364379883,
0.5084001421928406,
-0.9394022226333618,
0.4112153947353363,
0.7093679904937744,
0.47358977794647217,
-0.024505166336894035,
-0.2851024866104126,
-0.7276086807250977,
0.1492784172296524,
-0.13847140967845917,
1.0290714502334595,
-0.5911038517951965,
-0.10538031905889511,
-0.13291844725608826,
0.010768965817987919,
0.37786972522735596,
-1.0076556205749512,
0.5332781672477722,
-0.786622166633606,
-0.39109691977500916,
-0.29034364223480225,
-0.42712631821632385,
-0.38550665974617004,
0.4238201677799225,
-0.6918749213218689,
0.8020109534263611,
-0.18274043500423431,
-0.7239348292350769,
0.18452288210391998,
-0.31934189796447754,
-0.30436113476753235,
-0.029332133010029793,
-0.08876299113035202,
-0.605700671672821,
-0.2627260386943817,
0.24438370764255524,
0.5570530295372009,
-0.2642299234867096,
0.31911733746528625,
-0.35746413469314575,
-0.3054875433444977,
0.3179190158843994,
-0.6369047164916992,
0.6733911037445068,
0.1973457932472229,
-0.11773081868886948,
-0.046942975372076035,
-1.0442979335784912,
-0.19315530359745026,
-0.1156078577041626,
-0.7175034284591675,
-0.3587285280227661,
-0.055949024856090546,
0.3238920569419861,
0.170453280210495,
0.22390620410442352,
-0.6192992925643921,
0.4464995265007019,
-0.5383628010749817,
0.13802124559879303,
0.8249359726905823,
0.15526548027992249,
0.6210163235664368,
-0.2820148468017578,
0.42901962995529175,
0.4141339063644409,
0.09846562147140503,
-0.40100154280662537,
-0.42653894424438477,
-0.8735573291778564,
-0.14456532895565033,
0.29667481780052185,
0.8021990060806274,
-0.4937385618686676,
0.1945141702890396,
-0.3195643126964569,
-0.485699325799942,
-0.5039131045341492,
0.07019218057394028,
0.5241170525550842,
0.7607519030570984,
0.585104763507843,
-0.09563952684402466,
-0.6772005558013916,
-1.0940051078796387,
-0.08062367886304855,
-0.2914503812789917,
-0.22889326512813568,
0.5653126239776611,
0.31996896862983704,
-0.3668535649776459,
0.8887046575546265,
-0.3911389708518982,
-0.475635826587677,
0.051658306270837784,
0.03453335911035538,
-0.1751302033662796,
0.3546479046344757,
0.18745072185993195,
-0.7523552775382996,
0.028754819184541702,
0.3989492952823639,
-0.8428272604942322,
-0.0022873191628605127,
-0.2225186675786972,
-0.05691462382674217,
0.296815425157547,
0.2451428920030594,
-0.35489240288734436,
0.6316456198692322,
0.10370630770921707,
-0.07394599169492722,
0.5972825884819031,
-0.4912976920604706,
-0.06540274620056152,
-1.2198216915130615,
-0.23296679556369781,
0.5013301372528076,
-0.21648000180721283,
-0.710163950920105,
-0.045260682702064514,
-0.03329665586352348,
0.19888457655906677,
-0.9920862317085266,
0.45049065351486206,
-0.55724036693573,
-0.48025083541870117,
-0.3483515977859497,
-0.13538062572479248,
0.18848691880702972,
0.3626970946788788,
0.08800625801086426,
0.8316065669059753,
0.4208826720714569,
-0.7346935868263245,
0.5196371674537659,
0.25527697801589966,
0.03173057734966278,
0.5659297704696655,
-0.5997836589813232,
0.34400999546051025,
-0.24202536046504974,
0.40985462069511414,
-0.6642463803291321,
-0.47280728816986084,
0.8046948313713074,
-0.2576103210449219,
0.010855356231331825,
-0.4236312508583069,
-0.6476441025733948,
-0.12957622110843658,
-0.09600743651390076,
0.4530182182788849,
0.4054344594478607,
-0.6790926456451416,
0.6922280192375183,
0.4253990650177002,
0.29681792855262756,
-0.5598562955856323,
-0.8268421292304993,
0.3255329132080078,
-0.35913795232772827,
-0.1877923607826233,
0.4004993736743927,
0.29642900824546814,
-0.22134393453598022,
-0.02128273993730545,
0.062208376824855804,
-0.557149350643158,
0.22810116410255432,
0.4723408818244934,
0.6249198913574219,
-0.3862164318561554,
0.040669359266757965,
-0.3356684744358063,
-0.09113168716430664,
0.27437296509742737,
-0.31296056509017944,
-0.1199822947382927,
-0.22246268391609192,
-0.3421754539012909,
-0.8218854069709778,
0.051496025174856186,
0.17356862127780914,
-0.4806137681007385,
0.40659594535827637,
0.35776287317276,
-0.8511559963226318,
0.05755190923810005,
-0.5165200233459473,
0.07867922633886337,
-0.5087850689888,
0.10515366494655609,
-0.36374661326408386,
-0.4805663824081421,
0.5697262287139893,
-0.3009958565235138,
-0.019929274916648865,
0.41848665475845337,
-0.042829640209674835,
-0.3887604773044586,
0.3052333891391754,
0.6931905150413513,
-0.4151087999343872,
0.2585446536540985,
-0.2647112309932709,
0.0345408134162426,
-1.1384238004684448,
-0.5871711373329163,
-0.48296886682510376,
-0.22021061182022095,
-0.7336300611495972,
-0.3173474073410034,
-0.1251537948846817,
-0.19891518354415894,
-0.2727295458316803,
0.3484461307525635,
-0.8361431360244751,
0.6320334672927856,
0.345628023147583,
0.21323542296886444,
0.18034721910953522,
-0.07213438302278519,
0.08246096223592758,
-0.014863482676446438,
-0.415328711271286,
-0.8825539350509644,
0.9004635214805603,
0.3800762891769409,
0.6994086503982544,
-0.14106830954551697,
0.844607949256897,
0.4352049231529236,
0.3634878396987915,
-0.8970202803611755,
0.784476637840271,
-0.22188301384449005,
-0.3786013722419739,
-0.3734917938709259,
-0.17337635159492493,
-1.2242238521575928,
-0.013088774867355824,
-0.12150675058364868,
-0.9852527976036072,
0.3177073299884796,
0.1695314347743988,
-0.6702271699905396,
0.7664982080459595,
-0.4836711585521698,
0.7009634375572205,
-0.2840561866760254,
-0.07778950780630112,
0.5346387028694153,
-0.7376080751419067,
0.2890787124633789,
-0.09849511831998825,
0.10368582606315613,
-0.23380394279956818,
-0.10593780875205994,
0.9046892523765564,
-0.43812304735183716,
0.8845807909965515,
-0.23746106028556824,
-0.12773828208446503,
0.540587306022644,
-0.41893479228019714,
0.6627786159515381,
-0.1797933429479599,
-0.24840384721755981,
0.357439249753952,
-0.5444811582565308,
-0.17669343948364258,
-0.43514594435691833,
0.6017029285430908,
-0.8885396718978882,
-0.5041002631187439,
-0.5494316220283508,
-0.437884122133255,
0.357250839471817,
0.3654651939868927,
0.12106483429670334,
0.4167395234107971,
-0.045203547924757004,
0.02939768321812153,
0.8178843259811401,
-0.3242092728614807,
0.3186185956001282,
0.36889442801475525,
0.16263511776924133,
-0.45188164710998535,
0.984287440776825,
0.5400343537330627,
-0.1496816724538803,
0.7367673516273499,
-0.1279062032699585,
-0.3241230249404907,
-0.7560893297195435,
-0.49901580810546875,
-0.012824341654777527,
-0.8280609846115112,
-0.4822564721107483,
-0.7438468337059021,
-0.6047725677490234,
0.10074092447757721,
-0.25293388962745667,
-0.46265533566474915,
0.18534715473651886,
-0.9986763596534729,
-0.14662902057170868,
0.35724928975105286,
1.1132458448410034,
0.45694923400878906,
0.4096737205982208,
-0.8518288731575012,
0.6512614488601685,
0.01182524673640728,
0.2692224085330963,
-0.07086663693189621,
-0.7017186880111694,
-0.4359719753265381,
0.47519928216934204,
-0.3021085262298584,
-0.8675774931907654,
0.482805073261261,
-0.026342948898673058,
0.5247482061386108,
0.20582443475723267,
0.4206002354621887,
0.9217939376831055,
-0.6527482867240906,
0.7509027719497681,
-0.24437005817890167,
-0.7463693022727966,
0.7608267068862915,
-0.39693111181259155,
0.062199655920267105,
0.437744677066803,
-0.14337998628616333,
-0.16168037056922913,
-0.0799713134765625,
-0.4998866319656372,
-1.1973679065704346,
0.5714412331581116,
-0.06187743321061134,
0.03557795286178589,
0.26051607728004456,
0.7800997495651245,
-0.14804109930992126,
-0.15761546790599823,
-0.8191481828689575,
-0.6942918300628662,
0.033877283334732056,
0.006989357993006706,
0.27932411432266235,
-0.2753043472766876,
0.41959232091903687,
0.11121770739555359,
0.6758240461349487,
0.07561028003692627,
0.19429239630699158,
0.3562934696674347,
-0.0065735457465052605,
0.10229308903217316,
0.5677210092544556,
0.4049508571624756,
0.12248343974351883,
-0.4205363690853119,
0.15353725850582123,
0.3675975799560547,
-0.39451366662979126,
0.6382704973220825,
0.3388318419456482,
-0.45355305075645447,
-0.08646564930677414,
-0.09274017065763474,
0.4417947232723236,
0.014485886320471764,
-0.43766796588897705,
0.40084901452064514,
0.2554289996623993,
-0.10461270064115524,
-0.5935486555099487,
-0.013096865266561508,
-0.18279725313186646,
0.21828192472457886,
0.5747707486152649,
0.27658939361572266,
0.5997132658958435,
-0.036606620997190475,
0.3347000479698181,
0.3431607782840729,
-0.3129766881465912,
-0.29007047414779663,
1.2618958950042725,
0.24511173367500305,
-0.5407984256744385,
0.7799311876296997,
-0.23103874921798706,
-0.19126656651496887,
1.005001425743103,
0.3292181193828583,
0.9861293435096741,
-0.14751553535461426,
0.06670023500919342,
0.29029205441474915,
0.6630988717079163,
-0.23495477437973022,
-0.049655359238386154,
0.04831424728035927,
-0.6673268675804138,
-0.23517663776874542,
-0.1542140394449234,
-0.7027945518493652,
0.33436277508735657,
-0.8554788827896118,
0.3800341486930847,
-0.6494134068489075,
-0.06012394651770592,
0.3950033485889435,
-0.14242741465568542,
-0.8635541200637817,
0.6246078014373779,
0.6619548201560974,
0.8737398982048035,
-0.8655824065208435,
1.2021911144256592,
1.2633472681045532,
-0.2826898992061615,
-0.9741683006286621,
0.28094232082366943,
0.12993073463439941,
-0.3005887269973755,
0.9647393822669983,
0.48166629672050476,
-0.2493140995502472,
-0.11640100181102753,
-0.2693605124950409,
-0.7092251181602478,
1.3075429201126099,
0.2307823896408081,
-0.6288655996322632,
0.002057008445262909,
0.49123048782348633,
0.6037121415138245,
-0.536201536655426,
0.14427129924297333,
0.3629060685634613,
0.31004178524017334,
0.012235271744430065,
-0.7547298669815063,
0.07157980650663376,
-0.16158893704414368,
0.2772512137889862,
-0.04435673728585243,
-0.844651997089386,
0.569146454334259,
-0.4199928939342499,
-0.20775991678237915,
0.03601783886551857,
1.0552079677581787,
0.49734169244766235,
0.669154703617096,
0.2954534590244293,
0.46457040309906006,
0.9462929368019104,
-0.041907988488674164,
0.8022029399871826,
0.14595064520835876,
0.09574510157108307,
1.274657130241394,
-0.5016726851463318,
1.062522530555725,
0.6280149817466736,
-0.11262638866901398,
0.08070380985736847,
0.9348499774932861,
-0.2792547047138214,
0.4305913746356964,
0.4983289837837219,
-0.1627683937549591,
0.04409288987517357,
-0.6115283370018005,
-0.13521404564380646,
0.4847942888736725,
0.16802531480789185,
-0.19161540269851685,
-0.055616363883018494,
0.04149341210722923,
-0.2296319156885147,
0.09107442945241928,
-0.319667786359787,
0.9231485724449158,
-0.07424292713403702,
-0.24955005943775177,
0.6646087169647217,
0.21023710072040558,
0.8634741306304932,
-0.016175834462046623,
-0.21323637664318085,
-0.15472804009914398,
-0.10132049024105072,
-0.48854127526283264,
-0.8168764114379883,
0.33078983426094055,
0.16173164546489716,
-0.26388734579086304,
-0.0945911705493927,
0.8284038305282593,
-0.37647882103919983,
-0.5310559868812561,
0.0034827408380806446,
0.035286422818899155,
0.3607305884361267,
0.11920344084501266,
-0.4018825590610504,
0.09321849793195724,
0.017725279554724693,
-0.17245891690254211,
0.2964287996292114,
0.5364507436752319,
0.056248873472213745,
1.078493356704712,
0.7258142232894897,
0.16286879777908325,
0.17473357915878296,
-0.19305086135864258,
1.0219535827636719,
-0.9436232447624207,
-0.3495315611362457,
-1.0992342233657837,
0.6268090605735779,
0.23519696295261383,
-0.06024729460477829,
0.5566664934158325,
0.850104033946991,
0.9764337539672852,
-0.09602445363998413,
0.9325423240661621,
0.5209529399871826,
0.06406190991401672,
-0.4384421706199646,
0.30267342925071716,
-0.2915981709957123,
0.8356302380561829,
-0.12551921606063843,
-0.6801648139953613,
-0.4999832808971405,
0.3461855947971344,
-0.20988325774669647,
-0.32183733582496643,
0.049946270883083344,
0.6636425852775574,
-0.1501407027244568,
-0.3939387798309326,
0.35870054364204407,
-0.08517077565193176,
0.5281938314437866,
0.7496317625045776,
0.9494526386260986,
-0.9517416954040527,
0.6097195744514465,
-0.39276736974716187,
0.204436257481575,
-0.6290381550788879,
-1.0085492134094238,
-0.8381867408752441,
-0.17203442752361298,
-0.7363526225090027,
-0.1759699434041977,
0.18569837510585785,
1.2525652647018433,
0.6483467817306519,
-0.6893144249916077,
0.011723657138645649,
-0.044993046671152115,
0.12659767270088196,
-0.03172316774725914,
-0.24143004417419434,
0.3386991322040558,
0.27640852332115173,
-0.5249098539352417,
0.12015164643526077,
0.48873376846313477,
0.8462368845939636,
0.026359863579273224,
-0.034135352820158005,
-0.12591442465782166,
-0.061509475111961365,
0.1860453337430954,
0.53267502784729,
-1.4352439641952515,
-0.40107491612434387,
0.19941949844360352,
-0.39987245202064514,
0.4422435760498047,
0.180121511220932,
-0.820960283279419,
0.38327208161354065,
0.05925234779715538,
1.1881033182144165,
-0.20178739726543427,
0.35846561193466187,
0.17745622992515564,
-0.7724452614784241,
0.3018741309642792,
-0.13182830810546875,
0.4920883774757385,
0.5239468216896057,
-1.018475890159607,
0.19366338849067688,
-0.16868770122528076,
-0.5821346640586853,
-0.7804252505302429,
0.0654626116156578,
-1.3436565399169922,
0.3500961661338806,
1.2103488445281982,
-0.5156156420707703,
-0.39906826615333557,
-0.33633604645729065,
-0.5009979009628296,
0.37243154644966125,
-0.6937128901481628,
0.5573828816413879,
0.5141738653182983,
0.10790353268384933,
-0.5183987021446228,
-0.5123623013496399,
0.0872468426823616,
-0.2045297622680664,
-1.1804784536361694,
0.16229891777038574,
0.5825393795967102,
0.24533648788928986,
-0.08162849396467209,
0.6110819578170776,
0.3267245590686798,
0.24304057657718658,
-0.34532076120376587,
0.24234634637832642,
-0.34054386615753174,
-0.3902153968811035,
-0.41180020570755005,
0.021550290286540985,
0.33197373151779175,
-0.7078303694725037
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06082v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06082v1
|
FrameQuant: Flexible Low-Bit Quantization for Transformers
| 2024-03-10T04:01:49 | 2024-03-10T04:01:49 |
Harshavardhan Adepu, Zhanpeng Zeng, Li Zhang, Vikas Singh
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Transformers are the backbone of powerful foundation models for many Vision
and Natural Language Processing tasks. But their compute and memory/storage
footprint is large, and so, serving such models is expensive often requiring
high-end hardware. To mitigate this difficulty, Post-Training Quantization
seeks to modify a pre-trained model and quantize it to eight bits or lower,
significantly boosting compute/memory/latency efficiency. Such models have been
successfully quantized to four bits with some performance loss. In this work,
we outline a simple scheme to quantize Transformer-based models to just two
bits (plus some overhead) with only a small drop in accuracy. Key to our
formulation is a concept borrowed from Harmonic analysis called Fusion Frames.
Our main finding is that the quantization must take place not in the original
weight space, but instead in the Fusion Frame representations. If quantization
is interpreted as the addition of noise, our casting of the problem allows
invoking an extensive body of known consistent recovery and noise robustness
guarantees. Further, if desired, de-noising filters are known in closed form.
We show empirically, via a variety of experiments, that (almost) two-bit
quantization for Transformer models promises sizable efficiency gains.
|
[
-0.5212671160697937,
-0.39117157459259033,
0.32467442750930786,
-0.14718404412269592,
-0.37779247760772705,
-0.22665028274059296,
-0.02174650877714157,
-0.23729705810546875,
0.003844212042167783,
0.6443935036659241,
-0.409536212682724,
0.13970009982585907,
-0.5498629808425903,
-0.17386895418167114,
-0.5665831565856934,
0.7617383003234863,
-0.00991755723953247,
-0.05271872505545616,
-0.05425938963890076,
-0.29557767510414124,
-0.2646668553352356,
-0.2919186055660248,
-0.4116751551628113,
-0.33276882767677307,
-0.08110915869474411,
0.1765161007642746,
1.303360939025879,
0.4003208875656128,
0.8316311836242676,
0.23251259326934814,
-0.17919331789016724,
-0.4628830850124359,
-0.3886370062828064,
-0.05709172040224075,
-0.0012982701882719994,
-0.9233034253120422,
-0.4781974256038666,
-0.10807096213102341,
0.7035723924636841,
0.7025992274284363,
-0.2522695064544678,
0.2586095631122589,
-0.2326570600271225,
0.817785382270813,
-0.8915706872940063,
0.12335480004549026,
-0.4638054072856903,
0.3620474636554718,
-0.0985671728849411,
0.23180335760116577,
-0.293079137802124,
-0.12370850145816803,
0.0195783618837595,
-0.6163426041603088,
0.3802088499069214,
-0.1744997650384903,
0.8877659440040588,
0.8264738917350769,
-0.3644712269306183,
0.447329580783844,
-1.1136722564697266,
0.675441324710846,
-0.5006712079048157,
0.7037390470504761,
0.38828253746032715,
0.4617738127708435,
0.44035401940345764,
-0.9543853998184204,
-0.6233996152877808,
0.3496057987213135,
-0.31641843914985657,
0.11312519013881683,
-0.6897135376930237,
0.3100426495075226,
0.5942055583000183,
0.8361884951591492,
-0.4919587969779968,
-0.36581525206565857,
-0.3929596245288849,
-0.25639116764068604,
0.1502220779657364,
0.009342081844806671,
-0.1455552726984024,
-0.31319183111190796,
-0.3725319504737854,
-0.36984893679618835,
-0.5590298771858215,
0.1466732621192932,
0.13237634301185608,
-0.30241790413856506,
-0.141427680850029,
0.5848888158798218,
-0.2882794439792633,
0.5866143107414246,
0.4752161502838135,
0.04378974437713623,
-0.20894372463226318,
-0.3518107831478119,
-0.27686744928359985,
-0.039349742233753204,
0.5011782050132751,
-0.018030289560556412,
-0.07721707969903946,
-0.18958693742752075,
-0.6210805177688599,
0.6247905492782593,
0.5478376150131226,
-1.173813819885254,
-0.7885422706604004,
-0.02549981139600277,
-0.6461310386657715,
-0.2220950424671173,
0.011496568098664284,
-0.44886842370033264,
-0.038092970848083496,
-0.17520558834075928,
0.9802690148353577,
-0.4835994243621826,
-0.36264631152153015,
0.32568979263305664,
-0.3255000710487366,
0.40351250767707825,
-0.0562390498816967,
-1.0535708665847778,
0.32733941078186035,
0.6173564791679382,
0.6131072044372559,
0.23108841478824615,
0.4347604811191559,
-0.3757396340370178,
0.037033338099718094,
-0.39634960889816284,
0.6668806672096252,
-0.45074644684791565,
-0.49681344628334045,
-0.3216444253921509,
-0.21436388790607452,
0.2901473641395569,
-0.4477236866950989,
0.15847574174404144,
-0.770665168762207,
0.12720723450183868,
0.07422799617052078,
-0.21505782008171082,
-0.08641025424003601,
-0.08738072961568832,
-0.9944148063659668,
0.9238630533218384,
0.6217870116233826,
-0.6095004081726074,
0.23945757746696472,
-0.5691162943840027,
-0.44398680329322815,
0.19655032455921173,
0.030134551227092743,
-0.6917276978492737,
0.561604380607605,
0.03512384742498398,
-0.019565071910619736,
-0.24511976540088654,
0.2789759933948517,
-0.054668355733156204,
-0.6981906890869141,
0.015749536454677582,
-0.8781743049621582,
0.5194501280784607,
0.21271495521068573,
-0.508952796459198,
0.07777556777000427,
-0.7842393517494202,
-0.038597673177719116,
-0.1357046365737915,
-0.06336287409067154,
-0.06740731000900269,
-0.3156369626522064,
-0.147493377327919,
0.011695894412696362,
0.051921602338552475,
-0.4039517343044281,
-0.09757494181394577,
-0.7901290059089661,
0.6514033675193787,
0.2898492217063904,
-0.28734156489372253,
0.8915172815322876,
-0.235726997256279,
0.5651869773864746,
-0.15513040125370026,
0.42420142889022827,
-0.27098989486694336,
-0.33306989073753357,
-1.0133517980575562,
-0.26279541850090027,
0.464331716299057,
0.3333042562007904,
-1.257215142250061,
0.3894164562225342,
-0.5455695390701294,
-0.4278521239757538,
-0.5843929648399353,
-0.2827804982662201,
0.22207239270210266,
0.18123826384544373,
0.3146399259567261,
-0.5875062942504883,
-0.5084003806114197,
-0.9497838616371155,
-0.10265965014696121,
0.03702453151345253,
-0.45753857493400574,
-0.1604345440864563,
0.3771437108516693,
-0.14708738029003143,
1.3403505086898804,
-0.6102583408355713,
-0.17688368260860443,
0.03776947408914566,
0.12354791909456253,
0.1395442634820938,
0.5043978691101074,
0.23673680424690247,
-1.2843520641326904,
-0.24256479740142822,
-0.35817384719848633,
-0.48676905035972595,
0.30717000365257263,
0.11789868772029877,
-0.13442397117614746,
0.12365318834781647,
0.2893490195274353,
-0.8866686820983887,
0.7269600629806519,
0.6564938426017761,
-0.20724697411060333,
0.12453565746545792,
0.010188491083681583,
-0.10655492544174194,
-0.9433666467666626,
0.08619318157434464,
-0.14968037605285645,
-0.5638700723648071,
-0.6005876064300537,
-0.07107313722372055,
0.15475881099700928,
-0.5349189639091492,
-0.5129769444465637,
0.27769264578819275,
-0.0418580062687397,
-0.10829275846481323,
-0.4366595447063446,
-0.1248474270105362,
0.34224778413772583,
0.6787266731262207,
0.1623453050851822,
0.8299282789230347,
0.20011606812477112,
-0.3902546465396881,
0.2578202486038208,
0.3925149738788605,
-0.07463887333869934,
0.9608240723609924,
-0.8465597033500671,
-0.04983048886060715,
-0.3505247235298157,
0.4578596353530884,
-0.8712294101715088,
-0.17314550280570984,
0.12178181111812592,
-0.25591906905174255,
0.2759917676448822,
-0.231387197971344,
-0.27543044090270996,
-0.2855195105075836,
-0.37165817618370056,
0.6823593974113464,
0.8345889449119568,
-0.4899859130382538,
0.7570578455924988,
0.5295664072036743,
0.34211185574531555,
-0.15401658415794373,
-0.7131216526031494,
-0.26806220412254333,
-0.09157667309045792,
-0.7637510895729065,
0.7224612236022949,
0.18170729279518127,
0.00406479649245739,
0.23379482328891754,
-0.560703456401825,
-0.4364835321903229,
0.09159091114997864,
0.3645801246166229,
0.20783281326293945,
-0.40656542778015137,
0.24214494228363037,
-0.021782685071229935,
-0.7496494054794312,
-0.06671613454818726,
-0.5140163898468018,
0.420206755399704,
-0.490615576505661,
-0.032865628600120544,
-0.3341899514198303,
0.178842231631279,
0.24511168897151947,
-0.34251073002815247,
0.5334460735321045,
1.0854406356811523,
-0.6819950342178345,
0.13521353900432587,
-0.36946892738342285,
-0.5298854112625122,
-0.5563405752182007,
0.21969440579414368,
-0.5292136669158936,
-0.9931811094284058,
0.025759294629096985,
-0.13064059615135193,
-0.1872110515832901,
0.7215724587440491,
0.354420006275177,
-0.1686832755804062,
0.6802541017532349,
0.8548407554626465,
0.49696534872055054,
0.5702552199363708,
-0.553738534450531,
0.6106576323509216,
-0.6281906366348267,
0.19719555974006653,
-0.23866496980190277,
-0.4952872693538666,
-0.7077357769012451,
-0.6376357078552246,
0.6792091131210327,
0.34751787781715393,
-0.38044485449790955,
0.83812016248703,
-0.5701095461845398,
0.6309436559677124,
0.6685560345649719,
0.26893290877342224,
0.19610975682735443,
-0.1144711822271347,
0.7064566612243652,
-0.022618690505623817,
-0.8893741965293884,
-0.2710280120372772,
0.8106597065925598,
0.16941222548484802,
0.7185450196266174,
0.2762471139431,
0.4557979106903076,
0.15241728723049164,
0.06161804869771004,
-0.7959818840026855,
0.2300156056880951,
-0.4590141475200653,
-0.6112771034240723,
-0.5738236904144287,
-0.46876320242881775,
-0.6998001933097839,
0.24788634479045868,
-0.5072464942932129,
-0.4378257393836975,
0.3473956286907196,
0.37672513723373413,
-0.8621140718460083,
0.44614481925964355,
-0.5236204266548157,
0.9847342371940613,
0.2861001491546631,
-0.1592583954334259,
-0.39392033219337463,
-0.918861448764801,
0.4560626149177551,
-0.13396449387073517,
-0.07423900067806244,
0.04121934622526169,
0.15377812087535858,
0.7046995759010315,
-0.45189088582992554,
0.785344123840332,
-0.017058150842785835,
0.08069320023059845,
0.532187819480896,
0.28104686737060547,
0.5006732940673828,
-0.022590676322579384,
0.24723844230175018,
0.39093881845474243,
0.5007606744766235,
-0.40548229217529297,
-0.7083334922790527,
0.18638832867145538,
-0.5336440801620483,
-0.5295186042785645,
-0.06157475337386131,
-0.44645678997039795,
-0.16709767282009125,
0.14769010245800018,
0.5363511443138123,
0.48816412687301636,
0.18770036101341248,
0.565649151802063,
0.9289608001708984,
0.06853161752223969,
0.6845332980155945,
0.07653770595788956,
0.19867020845413208,
-0.48156440258026123,
1.0536210536956787,
0.05489209294319153,
0.3736303448677063,
0.5651213526725769,
0.27066078782081604,
-0.36077815294265747,
0.126562237739563,
-0.3916597366333008,
-0.06859279423952103,
-0.6018146276473999,
-0.5377850532531738,
-0.4136313796043396,
-0.34340909123420715,
-0.2038435935974121,
-0.11610551923513412,
-0.8954836130142212,
-1.0344581604003906,
-0.14869940280914307,
0.14357705414295197,
0.3112749755382538,
0.3924224376678467,
-0.10495743900537491,
1.044187068939209,
-0.9889261722564697,
0.747571587562561,
0.5261917114257812,
0.7465507388114929,
-0.09482705593109131,
-0.5506089329719543,
-0.37675803899765015,
0.001968592405319214,
-0.6271461844444275,
-0.49196216464042664,
0.1619911640882492,
0.17541691660881042,
-0.031637419015169144,
0.3115377724170685,
0.36823609471321106,
0.6047435998916626,
-0.32280391454696655,
0.8492583632469177,
0.48253193497657776,
-1.338531494140625,
0.31000396609306335,
0.211844801902771,
0.11584185808897018,
0.39967671036720276,
0.22663921117782593,
-0.3718734085559845,
0.13970530033111572,
-0.880246639251709,
-0.739008367061615,
0.6905255913734436,
0.4278445839881897,
0.2527572214603424,
0.3940683901309967,
0.23401758074760437,
-0.1281450241804123,
0.4107446074485779,
-0.5444711446762085,
-0.15978938341140747,
-0.6270979642868042,
-0.27192628383636475,
0.23989807069301605,
-0.40846019983291626,
-0.0974300354719162,
-0.12204168736934662,
0.4422995150089264,
-0.15926316380500793,
0.4524971544742584,
-0.005182451102882624,
-0.3060004711151123,
-0.16072095930576324,
0.31318947672843933,
0.2911128103733063,
0.21123777329921722,
-0.00650069722905755,
0.3446063995361328,
0.09601190686225891,
-0.41195589303970337,
0.328551322221756,
-0.0236757043749094,
-0.29290536046028137,
0.02095617726445198,
0.0071408688090741634,
1.1576943397521973,
0.704015851020813,
-0.27253228425979614,
0.8622749447822571,
0.041830748319625854,
0.013898427598178387,
-0.25777167081832886,
0.1124851331114769,
-0.24296589195728302,
0.4437771439552307,
0.07415827363729477,
0.6052075028419495,
0.325950026512146,
-0.11147632449865341,
0.5633866786956787,
0.4814913272857666,
-0.6177600622177124,
-0.5430630445480347,
1.0852305889129639,
0.2652771472930908,
-0.4534156918525696,
0.47023364901542664,
-0.27080440521240234,
-0.3685636818408966,
0.2672884464263916,
0.3083980083465576,
0.9484884738922119,
0.08121860772371292,
0.16219112277030945,
0.23223423957824707,
0.12831832468509674,
-0.2777562737464905,
0.006753521040081978,
-0.4267556965351105,
-0.6579185724258423,
-0.5144006609916687,
-0.6962683200836182,
-0.33979183435440063,
-0.5286498069763184,
-0.8266218304634094,
0.29380613565444946,
-0.2026652842760086,
-0.590738832950592,
-0.056619953364133835,
-0.2536938786506653,
-0.6817933320999146,
0.15056085586547852,
0.3492056727409363,
0.6167656183242798,
-0.5196185111999512,
0.796965479850769,
0.08485022932291031,
-0.17933471500873566,
-0.6328507661819458,
-0.22160930931568146,
-0.2965563237667084,
-0.5320852398872375,
0.17852327227592468,
0.10940084606409073,
0.08032768964767456,
0.3794447183609009,
-0.21839772164821625,
-0.9284226894378662,
1.0771750211715698,
0.5971822738647461,
-0.6109224557876587,
-0.1748494952917099,
0.2548019587993622,
0.29923394322395325,
0.28571221232414246,
0.3323286771774292,
0.878994882106781,
0.4241349399089813,
0.3370281457901001,
-0.737835168838501,
-0.1316344439983368,
0.0528658926486969,
0.37003597617149353,
0.6191307306289673,
-0.7111802101135254,
0.8472594618797302,
-0.021036017686128616,
-0.4362827241420746,
0.09016644954681396,
0.6802207231521606,
-0.11948905140161514,
0.1465694159269333,
0.6128656268119812,
0.7006254196166992,
0.48559969663619995,
-0.4210920035839081,
1.0362483263015747,
-0.6586862802505493,
0.6254514455795288,
0.539162278175354,
0.08559221029281616,
0.7804821729660034,
0.6386612057685852,
-0.5341429114341736,
0.11532919108867645,
0.22285118699073792,
0.018909819424152374,
0.5576415061950684,
0.047559577971696854,
-0.210363507270813,
-0.5126175284385681,
-0.018733706325292587,
-0.027657007798552513,
0.4515954256057739,
-0.011911898851394653,
0.11901726573705673,
-0.18717946112155914,
0.17230767011642456,
-0.2818163335323334,
-0.1725316345691681,
-0.2555159032344818,
0.6247382760047913,
0.24560244381427765,
-0.2700900435447693,
0.6013380289077759,
0.01166555192321539,
0.8084158897399902,
-0.5075059533119202,
-0.17660801112651825,
-0.16165189445018768,
0.09439721703529358,
-0.23178033530712128,
-0.5142644047737122,
0.8133987188339233,
-0.28700533509254456,
-0.4837174713611603,
-0.3258001506328583,
0.5526204705238342,
-0.360360711812973,
-0.5622702240943909,
-0.4525368809700012,
0.0816757008433342,
-0.10948711633682251,
-0.4471767842769623,
-0.028898946940898895,
0.07613881677389145,
-0.06588736176490784,
-0.19980759918689728,
0.12638704478740692,
0.23864567279815674,
-0.016452927142381668,
0.2969260811805725,
0.4409993588924408,
-0.15765419602394104,
0.024264058098196983,
-0.3876008689403534,
0.6155848503112793,
-0.7184895873069763,
-0.4335082769393921,
-0.6892838478088379,
0.6315516233444214,
0.384380042552948,
-0.08077841997146606,
0.18386143445968628,
0.41493740677833557,
0.7487977743148804,
-0.10040903836488724,
0.39982685446739197,
0.09167073667049408,
-0.09275639057159424,
-0.5787851214408875,
0.6668391227722168,
-0.3402704894542694,
0.1780668944120407,
0.09154806286096573,
-1.0365625619888306,
-0.45218002796173096,
0.7824643850326538,
-0.055705443024635315,
-0.26794305443763733,
0.5458658337593079,
0.6917632222175598,
-0.10002125054597855,
0.3565075099468231,
0.6527003049850464,
-0.13761770725250244,
0.23328013718128204,
0.6826972961425781,
0.5008890628814697,
-1.0081485509872437,
0.7522963881492615,
-0.5970066785812378,
0.02708757109940052,
-0.038040339946746826,
-0.41831517219543457,
-0.3093883991241455,
-0.44452738761901855,
-0.4817923307418823,
-0.2446039468050003,
-0.2753106355667114,
0.4801570773124695,
1.068838357925415,
-0.6055268049240112,
0.1651611328125,
-0.136139377951622,
0.08749907463788986,
-0.14217939972877502,
-0.21823641657829285,
0.45056861639022827,
-0.07074885070323944,
-0.6348686218261719,
0.15485405921936035,
0.3928704857826233,
0.28520289063453674,
-0.31756892800331116,
-0.11133801192045212,
0.6318228244781494,
0.1928943693637848,
0.7639092803001404,
0.009000406600534916,
-0.5835862159729004,
-0.43740808963775635,
0.057090505957603455,
-0.05609904229640961,
0.2533627450466156,
0.8873211741447449,
-1.1577643156051636,
0.3956841826438904,
0.35896041989326477,
0.6273568272590637,
0.8812207579612732,
0.048634666949510574,
0.3704467713832855,
-0.7995980381965637,
0.5611371994018555,
0.35864996910095215,
0.25213637948036194,
0.19544413685798645,
-0.16365784406661987,
0.5455158352851868,
0.4937955141067505,
-0.27236220240592957,
-0.7887435555458069,
0.3105642795562744,
-0.843808650970459,
-0.09839135408401489,
0.7494300603866577,
0.048437152057886124,
-0.36285245418548584,
0.3692307770252228,
0.04403384029865265,
0.2556489408016205,
0.04245997965335846,
0.5799465775489807,
0.27882325649261475,
-0.06103602051734924,
-0.22928845882415771,
-0.19066214561462402,
0.542835533618927,
0.3927145004272461,
-0.2876895070075989,
-0.21209558844566345,
0.20415952801704407,
-0.013652005232870579,
0.341799259185791,
0.463101863861084,
-0.0527292862534523,
0.36938199400901794,
0.5010958313941956,
0.0694151371717453,
0.21599730849266052,
-0.3285887539386749,
-0.653810977935791,
0.2751988172531128,
-0.16568323969841003,
-0.306352436542511
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06064v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06064v3
|
L^2GC:Lorentzian Linear Graph Convolutional Networks for Node Classification
| 2024-03-10T02:16:13 | 2024-06-14T04:15:20 |
Qiuyu Liang, Weihua Wang, Feilong Bao, Guanglai Gao
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Linear Graph Convolutional Networks (GCNs) are used to classify the node in
the graph data. However, we note that most existing linear GCN models perform
neural network operations in Euclidean space, which do not explicitly capture
the tree-like hierarchical structure exhibited in real-world datasets that
modeled as graphs. In this paper, we attempt to introduce hyperbolic space into
linear GCN and propose a novel framework for Lorentzian linear GCN.
Specifically, we map the learned features of graph nodes into hyperbolic space,
and then perform a Lorentzian linear feature transformation to capture the
underlying tree-like structure of data. Experimental results on standard
citation networks datasets with semi-supervised learning show that our approach
yields new state-of-the-art results of accuracy 74.7$\%$ on Citeseer and
81.3$\%$ on PubMed datasets. Furthermore, we observe that our approach can be
trained up to two orders of magnitude faster than other nonlinear GCN models on
PubMed dataset. Our code is publicly available at
https://github.com/llqy123/LLGC-master.
|
[
-0.03487024083733559,
-0.7188141345977783,
0.3646344542503357,
-0.3601522445678711,
-0.28751516342163086,
0.09987238049507141,
-0.005866277497261763,
-0.6969455480575562,
0.39016953110694885,
0.04827504605054855,
-0.2766525447368622,
-0.7597513794898987,
-0.5377709865570068,
-0.26070892810821533,
-0.6026726961135864,
1.230653166770935,
0.20542582869529724,
0.15337412059307098,
0.20869803428649902,
-0.1539708375930786,
0.324227899312973,
-0.20856915414333344,
-0.8300947546958923,
-0.5068444609642029,
1.0728689432144165,
0.02192605473101139,
1.2172050476074219,
0.8466824889183044,
0.43822503089904785,
0.3333004117012024,
-0.21685515344142914,
0.5023576021194458,
-0.5955103635787964,
-0.24760940670967102,
-0.11866817623376846,
0.11621814221143723,
-0.2329871952533722,
-0.03453752398490906,
0.5896336436271667,
0.916697084903717,
0.11184831708669662,
-0.043798305094242096,
0.10200341790914536,
0.5032624006271362,
-0.33123552799224854,
0.41899141669273376,
-0.5023388266563416,
0.29484623670578003,
-0.15153975784778595,
-0.1974342167377472,
-0.24965807795524597,
-0.7488371729850769,
0.18196964263916016,
-0.982829213142395,
0.6625162363052368,
0.3020963668823242,
0.8027063608169556,
0.04065418988466263,
-0.5027279257774353,
-0.22502575814723969,
-0.8055658936500549,
0.08125020563602448,
-0.3699847459793091,
0.14303870499134064,
-0.12469294667243958,
0.6230292916297913,
-0.2170214056968689,
-1.199630856513977,
-0.514495849609375,
0.154355987906456,
-0.1488611102104187,
0.06410278379917145,
-0.2457524836063385,
0.19958028197288513,
0.15003888309001923,
0.10800489783287048,
-0.5762161612510681,
0.3245757520198822,
-0.5337473750114441,
-0.015947451815009117,
0.550689697265625,
0.06263706833124161,
-0.11885051429271698,
0.0014474872732535005,
-0.564581036567688,
0.00812759343534708,
-0.7793564796447754,
0.047991394996643066,
0.2628394663333893,
0.541893482208252,
0.11520396173000336,
0.33964163064956665,
0.11369379609823227,
0.4499009847640991,
-0.09487681835889816,
0.24617058038711548,
0.2432105839252472,
-0.1900293231010437,
-0.3629706799983978,
0.07542983442544937,
0.9740532040596008,
0.16232547163963318,
0.31235140562057495,
-0.2020748108625412,
0.25412479043006897,
-0.17524734139442444,
0.04505077004432678,
-1.0494847297668457,
-0.6010047197341919,
-0.1009657233953476,
-0.2853909730911255,
-0.33719316124916077,
0.07187364250421524,
-0.36845430731773376,
-0.5258482694625854,
-0.14378108084201813,
-0.14173783361911774,
0.08054593205451965,
-0.018506813794374466,
0.268328458070755,
0.2224069982767105,
-0.08358168601989746,
0.5513147115707397,
-0.5769712328910828,
0.3599274158477783,
0.7439404129981995,
1.068890929222107,
-0.04014823958277702,
-0.011645812541246414,
-0.4868374764919281,
-0.028836669400334358,
-0.30080389976501465,
0.4759821891784668,
-0.2248261719942093,
-0.13351209461688995,
0.21898891031742096,
0.3233162760734558,
0.05138265714049339,
-0.23235854506492615,
0.3812624514102936,
-0.8180983066558838,
0.044914793223142624,
0.07585769146680832,
-0.4919394254684448,
-0.302057147026062,
0.12091599404811859,
-0.5718097686767578,
0.9291801452636719,
0.15865272283554077,
-1.0231852531433105,
0.05345664173364639,
-0.29684025049209595,
-0.1661139875650406,
0.30426958203315735,
-0.1971912533044815,
-0.7824458479881287,
-0.208865687251091,
0.07492366433143616,
0.7058737277984619,
-0.33881986141204834,
0.43082302808761597,
-0.904133141040802,
-0.46395450830459595,
0.32827994227409363,
-0.0451715923845768,
0.7153319716453552,
0.20762181282043457,
-0.15782134234905243,
0.08216723054647446,
-0.5140491127967834,
0.3081575632095337,
0.042783062905073166,
-0.242966890335083,
-0.239590123295784,
0.05165402218699455,
0.44165074825286865,
0.3822380602359772,
-0.16537673771381378,
-0.7952740788459778,
0.2482890486717224,
-0.37077680230140686,
0.579628586769104,
0.5487388372421265,
0.021252159029245377,
0.15905342996120453,
0.21132393181324005,
0.054135046899318695,
-0.07234746962785721,
-0.038236554712057114,
0.4205935299396515,
-0.6251448392868042,
-0.15882167220115662,
-0.05697445198893547,
0.042184919118881226,
0.40790799260139465,
-0.94477778673172,
0.48782697319984436,
-0.5335010886192322,
-0.45004957914352417,
0.12627854943275452,
0.03809115290641785,
0.3263791501522064,
0.8363037109375,
0.3090611696243286,
0.047806933522224426,
-0.2855319678783417,
-0.5673039555549622,
0.43634289503097534,
-0.18541373312473297,
0.049167484045028687,
0.3746395409107208,
0.560314953327179,
-0.24316515028476715,
0.6809710264205933,
-0.45959943532943726,
-0.17366327345371246,
0.052467167377471924,
-0.12287744879722595,
0.5905947089195251,
0.40613606572151184,
0.38583192229270935,
-0.629577100276947,
-0.3188551962375641,
0.533146858215332,
-0.9526126384735107,
0.24258656799793243,
0.08911489695310593,
0.006968398112803698,
-0.42352068424224854,
0.7464020252227783,
-0.33947864174842834,
0.6568037867546082,
0.5344874262809753,
-0.4256821274757385,
0.08696787059307098,
-0.49944543838500977,
-0.30109357833862305,
-1.0830261707305908,
0.09668073803186417,
0.3842127323150635,
-0.6555770635604858,
-0.5098117589950562,
-0.2501681447029114,
0.13332583010196686,
-0.5378953218460083,
-0.5611127614974976,
0.2887257933616638,
-0.26055991649627686,
-0.39168262481689453,
-0.25446853041648865,
0.20829492807388306,
-0.2555936872959137,
0.7287328839302063,
-0.17026863992214203,
0.31308940052986145,
0.5495843887329102,
-0.4708006680011749,
0.8042738437652588,
0.17736832797527313,
-0.14928795397281647,
0.24235506355762482,
-0.9036734700202942,
0.38029611110687256,
-0.3628077805042267,
0.48132848739624023,
-1.1541332006454468,
0.21438275277614594,
0.4831571877002716,
-0.41842880845069885,
0.3030991554260254,
-0.29918843507766724,
-0.5190663933753967,
-0.5772638916969299,
-0.09701859951019287,
0.6728754043579102,
-0.14663554728031158,
-0.8292691707611084,
-0.011715889908373356,
0.21716631948947906,
0.4321519434452057,
-0.4886161983013153,
-0.6031976938247681,
-0.16141150891780853,
0.01933964528143406,
-0.46539413928985596,
0.4942120313644409,
0.18733899295330048,
0.43127569556236267,
0.3599727153778076,
0.12484437972307205,
0.10577765107154846,
0.023692889139056206,
0.4495168626308441,
0.12803253531455994,
-0.29494813084602356,
0.3532496690750122,
-0.07333384454250336,
-0.41118472814559937,
-0.18347398936748505,
-1.0696449279785156,
0.21237844228744507,
-0.24053522944450378,
-0.2681998312473297,
-0.8104316592216492,
0.05973711237311363,
0.41414332389831543,
0.07349599897861481,
0.3709714412689209,
0.618728518486023,
-0.6486268043518066,
-0.31647199392318726,
0.34014835953712463,
-0.007122354116290808,
-0.4601685106754303,
0.9298915266990662,
0.15827733278274536,
-1.1419622898101807,
0.39166000485420227,
-0.368589848279953,
-0.20023012161254883,
0.4170074462890625,
0.461497962474823,
-0.39567580819129944,
0.5378077626228333,
0.4641834795475006,
-0.3047780990600586,
0.4737442135810852,
-0.7666283249855042,
0.5236575603485107,
-0.6550585627555847,
-0.3493490219116211,
-0.6519308090209961,
-0.9762623310089111,
-0.8428435325622559,
-0.47209927439689636,
0.5445567965507507,
0.058579832315444946,
-0.5758892893791199,
0.32715505361557007,
-0.7387082576751709,
0.4830937683582306,
-0.17022958397865295,
0.41605275869369507,
-0.05888865515589714,
0.28079953789711,
-0.07170438021421432,
-0.12192586809396744,
-0.7034731507301331,
-0.08395075798034668,
0.8808134198188782,
0.6765503883361816,
0.8079863786697388,
-0.042705636471509933,
0.3075450360774994,
0.45437338948249817,
0.4633602797985077,
-0.7672169804573059,
0.36404529213905334,
-0.4601636826992035,
-0.37436094880104065,
-0.4983677566051483,
-0.5177054405212402,
-1.2243759632110596,
0.20557524263858795,
-0.3561738431453705,
-0.6611060500144958,
0.5947234034538269,
0.08809920400381088,
-0.24967099726200104,
0.7653382420539856,
-0.4377686381340027,
0.6627607941627502,
-0.27282315492630005,
-0.3604995608329773,
-0.049751922488212585,
-0.42948904633522034,
0.01434987224638462,
0.3803745210170746,
-0.0040476955473423,
-0.06117050722241402,
-0.0010314072715118527,
0.5676712989807129,
-0.540463924407959,
0.9427585005760193,
-0.614309549331665,
0.36081060767173767,
0.3027270436286926,
0.047816287726163864,
0.778683066368103,
0.3878677189350128,
0.250181645154953,
0.17490606009960175,
-0.48705172538757324,
-0.46298307180404663,
-0.9398092031478882,
0.6337668299674988,
-0.8551116585731506,
0.051754675805568695,
-0.3995964527130127,
-0.5781967639923096,
-0.1333378106355667,
-0.12789617478847504,
0.1360173523426056,
0.5948381423950195,
-0.1616048812866211,
0.30181658267974854,
0.5829703211784363,
0.2309602051973343,
0.48019835352897644,
-0.25052064657211304,
-0.39258500933647156,
-0.5973255038261414,
0.61383056640625,
0.12631118297576904,
-0.16623955965042114,
0.18521568179130554,
0.08878310769796371,
-0.5099390149116516,
-0.8829652070999146,
-0.2429547905921936,
0.526683509349823,
-0.723809540271759,
-0.49907252192497253,
-0.3452747166156769,
-0.5874924659729004,
-0.12263474613428116,
-0.1320246011018753,
-0.2165278196334839,
-0.5233424305915833,
-0.23250314593315125,
-0.35532718896865845,
0.40332576632499695,
0.8976008892059326,
0.3158164620399475,
0.766075074672699,
-0.17131026089191437,
0.008839556016027927,
0.3140718638896942,
0.24582569301128387,
-0.055990446358919144,
-0.4235823452472687,
-0.6139404773712158,
-0.206867054104805,
-0.39841464161872864,
-0.7560346126556396,
0.3792441487312317,
0.41156601905822754,
0.3123580515384674,
0.5361951589584351,
-0.42983201146125793,
0.533706784248352,
-0.3332226276397705,
0.0933162271976471,
0.6049659848213196,
-0.5797617435455322,
0.23676086962223053,
-0.34585604071617126,
-0.25464725494384766,
0.2541680932044983,
0.7187128067016602,
-0.5866715908050537,
-0.01771080307662487,
-0.49587830901145935,
-0.5481584072113037,
0.4406055510044098,
-0.001085649710148573,
0.02148038148880005,
0.10399769991636276,
0.8910894989967346,
-0.44450849294662476,
-0.10919900238513947,
-0.7546759843826294,
-0.3238770067691803,
-0.22176428139209747,
-0.2819739878177643,
-0.26804614067077637,
0.1254347860813141,
-0.08583491295576096,
-0.5152344703674316,
0.2679769992828369,
-0.6179541945457458,
0.47022753953933716,
0.5178807377815247,
0.21431343257427216,
0.03116939589381218,
-0.20056727528572083,
0.32634803652763367,
0.5912531614303589,
-0.06962701678276062,
0.6132538914680481,
0.07123834639787674,
-0.4305106997489929,
0.308331698179245,
0.3002277910709381,
-0.15836407244205475,
0.1313754767179489,
0.31541311740875244,
0.5780259966850281,
0.3779292106628418,
0.48422765731811523,
0.44339045882225037,
0.00558461481705308,
-0.29756373167037964,
-0.0328080877661705,
-0.13198810815811157,
0.28799912333488464,
0.387513130903244,
0.2961195707321167,
0.2338719218969345,
0.0927821472287178,
-0.28211575746536255,
0.2004673331975937,
0.3506259024143219,
-0.680398166179657,
-0.45028936862945557,
0.6918067336082458,
-0.06440167129039764,
-0.21206499636173248,
0.6725489497184753,
-0.40126243233680725,
-0.3225981891155243,
0.582168698310852,
0.8169501423835754,
0.7531887292861938,
0.004156667273491621,
0.35026779770851135,
0.7246628999710083,
0.06940174102783203,
0.2104327231645584,
-0.05154916271567345,
-0.012408866547048092,
-0.8624338507652283,
-0.22170591354370117,
-0.2699161171913147,
-0.18546965718269348,
-0.177107572555542,
-0.11910330504179001,
0.11170641332864761,
-1.26006281375885,
-0.36452290415763855,
0.4510832726955414,
0.15309196710586548,
-0.527036726474762,
0.09689688682556152,
0.1974949836730957,
0.7632768750190735,
-0.937483549118042,
1.373502492904663,
0.5162618160247803,
-0.034378089010715485,
-0.6884198784828186,
-0.5096719264984131,
-0.07823757082223892,
-0.7978806495666504,
0.7927839756011963,
0.05354289337992668,
-0.2895388901233673,
-0.0845714583992958,
-0.9214827418327332,
-0.6624857783317566,
1.3813176155090332,
0.3773272931575775,
-0.45749950408935547,
-0.29931798577308655,
0.18320618569850922,
0.7716524004936218,
-0.7167313694953918,
0.1403304785490036,
-0.1519830971956253,
0.08625232428312302,
0.3663068115711212,
-0.42295730113983154,
0.032124292105436325,
-0.46473726630210876,
0.5289241671562195,
0.04128628969192505,
-0.43396657705307007,
0.7493136525154114,
-0.22382302582263947,
-0.3388506770133972,
-0.3331843912601471,
0.9604668617248535,
0.052107322961091995,
0.3728640377521515,
0.3746229112148285,
0.6020731925964355,
1.2139602899551392,
-0.44657671451568604,
0.9818204045295715,
0.11066983640193939,
0.9980195164680481,
0.8848086595535278,
-0.13207431137561798,
0.38506585359573364,
0.1863163858652115,
-0.29394230246543884,
0.47561800479888916,
0.5697063207626343,
-0.022540805861353874,
0.33256804943084717,
0.6335347294807434,
-0.11547883599996567,
-0.0917786955833435,
-0.048265691846609116,
-0.4571015536785126,
0.06640610843896866,
0.4946309030056,
-0.30471205711364746,
-0.5602471232414246,
-0.1323062628507614,
0.3381693363189697,
0.10340984165668488,
-0.4868745803833008,
0.13603366911411285,
0.10294590890407562,
0.17292854189872742,
0.5382064580917358,
0.0637846514582634,
0.5806449055671692,
-0.4749610722064972,
0.19272270798683167,
-0.10694632679224014,
0.332614541053772,
-0.6345769166946411,
-0.8921440243721008,
0.4872570335865021,
-0.26666712760925293,
-0.11373195052146912,
-0.1634434461593628,
0.5252020359039307,
-0.3207191824913025,
-0.6276140213012695,
0.5354711413383484,
0.24174262583255768,
0.1715867668390274,
0.26237353682518005,
-0.631219208240509,
-0.4174251854419708,
-0.37697428464889526,
0.1857098937034607,
0.08584928512573242,
0.7828501462936401,
-0.2088494598865509,
0.579757034778595,
0.708129346370697,
0.18130594491958618,
0.09090209007263184,
0.0460674948990345,
1.0302824974060059,
-0.5760540962219238,
-0.5330216288566589,
-0.5150352716445923,
0.1787978559732437,
0.01645246520638466,
-0.3636975586414337,
0.39435139298439026,
0.7510590553283691,
0.8653120994567871,
0.25994205474853516,
0.16688843071460724,
0.0989764928817749,
0.14333534240722656,
-0.4991176128387451,
0.8483784198760986,
-0.3006342053413391,
-0.07866240292787552,
-0.17115890979766846,
-0.7035123109817505,
-0.735164225101471,
0.3671121597290039,
-0.2907368242740631,
0.10931587219238281,
0.8593266606330872,
1.045262336730957,
-0.25524935126304626,
0.05941135436296463,
0.37556490302085876,
0.06479828804731369,
0.5637660622596741,
1.1059441566467285,
0.699255645275116,
-0.6862779259681702,
0.35444164276123047,
-0.09104826301336288,
-0.09110680967569351,
0.035700250416994095,
-0.7747142910957336,
-0.7175441980361938,
-0.6829966306686401,
-0.5174694061279297,
-0.6936748027801514,
0.024564024060964584,
0.7990900874137878,
1.0792605876922607,
-0.8866125345230103,
-0.10349728912115097,
-0.1393699198961258,
0.44722485542297363,
0.056317977607250214,
-0.08598928153514862,
0.8878355622291565,
-0.17620334029197693,
-0.46191784739494324,
-0.017145829275250435,
0.2822520434856415,
0.022444628179073334,
-0.0006683744722977281,
-0.33752214908599854,
-0.12334401160478592,
-0.6035540103912354,
0.18900856375694275,
0.5180027484893799,
-0.37872904539108276,
-0.5461070537567139,
-0.004931801464408636,
-0.3492814004421234,
0.32224559783935547,
1.1474639177322388,
-0.7174907326698303,
0.415132999420166,
0.45623496174812317,
0.9167694449424744,
0.882235586643219,
-0.31089216470718384,
-0.2536405026912689,
-0.8195353150367737,
0.325459361076355,
0.07932649552822113,
0.5599942803382874,
0.3045629560947418,
-0.5606417059898376,
0.3235621452331543,
0.7370976209640503,
-0.587960422039032,
-0.29736214876174927,
0.10293976962566376,
-1.246767520904541,
0.13812917470932007,
0.8744952082633972,
-0.3128352463245392,
-0.4708678424358368,
-0.16035795211791992,
0.09065307676792145,
0.46433740854263306,
-0.03892230987548828,
0.3548949658870697,
0.02293521538376808,
-0.1719997674226761,
-0.19112396240234375,
-0.3891741931438446,
0.37819722294807434,
-0.3273064196109772,
-0.8007933497428894,
-0.05392001196742058,
0.324169784784317,
0.12708209455013275,
0.2392672300338745,
0.5742952227592468,
-0.36991602182388306,
0.4145720899105072,
-0.5263953804969788,
0.03021329827606678,
-0.5672423243522644,
-0.6283931732177734,
-0.5850951075553894,
0.4450939893722534,
-0.10043276101350784,
-0.2815406322479248
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06063v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06063v1
|
Target-constrained Bidirectional Planning for Generation of Target-oriented Proactive Dialogue
| 2024-03-10T02:14:24 | 2024-03-10T02:14:24 |
Jian Wang, Dongding Lin, Wenjie Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Target-oriented proactive dialogue systems aim to lead conversations from a
dialogue context toward a pre-determined target, such as making recommendations
on designated items or introducing new specific topics. To this end, it is
critical for such dialogue systems to plan reasonable actions to drive the
conversation proactively, and meanwhile, to plan appropriate topics to move the
conversation forward to the target topic smoothly. In this work, we mainly
focus on effective dialogue planning for target-oriented dialogue generation.
Inspired by decision-making theories in cognitive science, we propose a novel
target-constrained bidirectional planning (TRIP) approach, which plans an
appropriate dialogue path by looking ahead and looking back. By formulating the
planning as a generation task, our TRIP bidirectionally generates a dialogue
path consisting of a sequence of <action, topic> pairs using two Transformer
decoders. They are expected to supervise each other and converge on consistent
actions and topics by minimizing the decision gap and contrastive generation of
targets. Moreover, we propose a target-constrained decoding algorithm with a
bidirectional agreement to better control the planning process. Subsequently,
we adopt the planned dialogue paths to guide dialogue generation in a pipeline
manner, where we explore two variants: prompt-based generation and
plan-controlled generation. Extensive experiments are conducted on two
challenging dialogue datasets, which are re-purposed for exploring
target-oriented dialogue. Our automatic and human evaluations demonstrate that
the proposed methods significantly outperform various baseline models.
|
[
-0.4354715645313263,
-0.44747820496559143,
0.593609094619751,
0.3214660882949829,
-0.358956903219223,
0.08106822520494461,
-0.2059854120016098,
0.06605583429336548,
0.3690411448478699,
0.8575135469436646,
-1.1997473239898682,
-0.3291923701763153,
-0.22711358964443207,
0.06267247349023819,
0.046239256858825684,
0.963447630405426,
-0.10248149931430817,
-0.10913275182247162,
0.18493682146072388,
0.041784338653087616,
-1.0503259897232056,
-0.22293487191200256,
-0.7175667881965637,
-0.06690391153097153,
0.43816617131233215,
0.7341724038124084,
0.7631207704544067,
0.10840634256601334,
0.4976291060447693,
0.1395350843667984,
-0.07215772569179535,
0.3700209856033325,
-0.5073823928833008,
0.43794193863868713,
-0.2840873599052429,
-0.12046311795711517,
-0.47449854016304016,
-0.19768781960010529,
0.6798723936080933,
0.7223057746887207,
-0.254372239112854,
-0.09957761317491531,
0.08715053647756577,
0.35542282462120056,
-0.7436457872390747,
0.28836390376091003,
-0.6130713224411011,
0.1542130410671234,
0.13701753318309784,
-0.21823404729366302,
-0.39175474643707275,
-0.07522338628768921,
0.24765966832637787,
-0.41678813099861145,
0.20813581347465515,
-0.061321187764406204,
0.4577316343784332,
0.19456790387630463,
-0.3448128402233124,
-0.33586812019348145,
-1.0505889654159546,
0.7713708281517029,
-0.4168889820575714,
0.2676549553871155,
0.2845511734485626,
0.21732652187347412,
-0.36279869079589844,
-0.5939196348190308,
-0.5372036099433899,
-0.09671580046415329,
-0.14054597914218903,
0.40535029768943787,
-0.30488115549087524,
0.29689472913742065,
0.1933370977640152,
-0.1220473051071167,
-0.5942904353141785,
-0.2754650115966797,
-0.09999880939722061,
-0.2955613136291504,
0.6002235412597656,
0.28107213973999023,
-0.27610495686531067,
-0.40430930256843567,
-0.27085554599761963,
-0.05814347416162491,
-0.7751492857933044,
-0.039786446839571,
0.4271508455276489,
0.5641207695007324,
0.2864231765270233,
0.5112274289131165,
-0.4858386218547821,
0.4963762164115906,
0.2822365164756775,
0.11894428730010986,
-0.349724680185318,
-0.7219796776771545,
0.05516902729868889,
0.21083274483680725,
0.6876963973045349,
0.6506533622741699,
0.18792866170406342,
0.08692658692598343,
-0.07080650329589844,
-0.014070096425712109,
0.566455066204071,
-0.7413722276687622,
-0.203959122300148,
0.11837848275899887,
-0.22754602134227753,
-0.28926530480384827,
-0.27068382501602173,
-0.5999630689620972,
0.1907065063714981,
-0.030725790187716484,
0.17909574508666992,
-0.2044415920972824,
-0.2341482788324356,
0.13391470909118652,
0.23970311880111694,
0.22837521135807037,
0.167842298746109,
-0.7537257671356201,
0.16776148974895477,
0.37091684341430664,
0.6153275370597839,
0.04958125203847885,
-0.05891510099172592,
-0.7176565527915955,
0.5163039565086365,
-0.34041446447372437,
0.8034576177597046,
-0.6214297413825989,
-0.8785869479179382,
0.15526778995990753,
-0.23456765711307526,
-0.025028394535183907,
-0.3348895311355591,
0.8858798146247864,
-0.28039243817329407,
0.4569227397441864,
-0.19257065653800964,
0.17465274035930634,
-0.08058281242847443,
0.5501192212104797,
-0.33368632197380066,
0.42675405740737915,
0.1475156843662262,
-0.5262015461921692,
0.21439456939697266,
-0.5887112021446228,
-0.6171554923057556,
0.10571293532848358,
-0.19251605868339539,
-0.2920129895210266,
-0.09502535313367844,
0.21970410645008087,
0.14001533389091492,
-0.33033666014671326,
0.8600060939788818,
0.3624815046787262,
-0.13087986409664154,
-0.04909851402044296,
-0.5564557909965515,
0.45713141560554504,
0.3297744691371918,
-0.5646467208862305,
0.4028806984424591,
-0.38963866233825684,
0.08082512021064758,
0.15087413787841797,
-0.25435733795166016,
0.09611167758703232,
0.46530354022979736,
-0.0785522609949112,
0.23511067032814026,
-0.007982532493770123,
-0.433481901884079,
0.28531613945961,
-0.3476700782775879,
0.2508711814880371,
0.6005359888076782,
0.25559356808662415,
0.35558727383613586,
-0.15994232892990112,
0.41625669598579407,
0.04656657949090004,
0.35201606154441833,
-0.34354063868522644,
-0.3219280242919922,
-0.8981917500495911,
0.17620916664600372,
-0.11364156007766724,
0.6439389586448669,
-0.816655695438385,
0.43466436862945557,
-0.16598010063171387,
-0.259544312953949,
-0.12210769951343536,
-0.33854466676712036,
0.666621744632721,
0.5776534676551819,
0.35753199458122253,
-0.5866120457649231,
-0.48910078406333923,
-0.9054030776023865,
-0.23131968080997467,
-0.5227625966072083,
-0.0956609770655632,
0.40025344491004944,
-0.10296081006526947,
-0.10421913862228394,
0.866420567035675,
-0.8847092390060425,
-0.24986478686332703,
-0.799161434173584,
0.17602825164794922,
0.13434533774852753,
0.5317855477333069,
-0.046721119433641434,
-0.9079787135124207,
-0.5559638738632202,
-0.513800323009491,
-0.2914404273033142,
-0.03502792492508888,
-0.5252971053123474,
-0.5148729681968689,
-0.19668620824813843,
0.314340740442276,
-0.9159611463546753,
0.4077529311180115,
0.23344184458255768,
-0.33403298258781433,
0.6659621000289917,
0.011410440318286419,
-0.1838173270225525,
-1.1621923446655273,
-0.10645677894353867,
-0.22446230053901672,
-0.014545169658958912,
-1.0508078336715698,
-0.31081193685531616,
-0.3674360513687134,
-0.40420299768447876,
-0.39025354385375977,
0.09021858870983124,
-0.3201262652873993,
0.16185130178928375,
-0.24225986003875732,
-0.0966261699795723,
0.011062292382121086,
0.9720932841300964,
0.5523635149002075,
0.5673248171806335,
0.42081770300865173,
-0.5249068737030029,
0.1718037873506546,
0.7530493140220642,
-0.08295002579689026,
0.7038533687591553,
-0.4885770380496979,
0.24553194642066956,
0.0624568909406662,
0.6695237755775452,
-0.716671884059906,
0.09057554602622986,
0.6398208141326904,
-0.12059902399778366,
0.36209580302238464,
-0.03470965102314949,
0.12494619190692902,
-0.26726919412612915,
-0.05834946781396866,
0.5180360674858093,
0.45626357197761536,
-0.11025908589363098,
0.7353931069374084,
0.19856546819210052,
-0.5399556159973145,
-0.23996971547603607,
-0.05904309079051018,
0.2616049349308014,
-0.13762898743152618,
-0.4410857558250427,
0.6099436283111572,
-0.09262501448392868,
-0.21625004708766937,
-0.29218894243240356,
-0.31162938475608826,
0.4153927266597748,
-0.4366218149662018,
0.29404518008232117,
0.2863161563873291,
0.10080180317163467,
-0.39885058999061584,
0.12504710257053375,
-0.35724249482154846,
0.14049750566482544,
-0.5425096154212952,
0.7717944979667664,
0.11439281702041626,
-0.37237703800201416,
-0.43608567118644714,
0.8845651745796204,
0.4610234498977661,
-0.3870399296283722,
0.11616984009742737,
0.24252551794052124,
-0.0006384993903338909,
0.04184849187731743,
-0.3684679865837097,
-0.3610014021396637,
-0.4553743898868561,
0.2732691466808319,
-0.4867776036262512,
-0.34566769003868103,
0.10604238510131836,
-0.39684054255485535,
0.40002134442329407,
0.08434484899044037,
0.4842917025089264,
-0.052933238446712494,
1.2283873558044434,
0.564565896987915,
0.34782564640045166,
0.5071195363998413,
-0.41284334659576416,
0.6202812194824219,
-0.8470733165740967,
-0.41568490862846375,
-0.34094110131263733,
-0.45080238580703735,
-0.5358538627624512,
-0.544939398765564,
0.3238607943058014,
-0.05236567556858063,
-0.08644863963127136,
0.6545248627662659,
-0.445829838514328,
0.08032091706991196,
0.8520894646644592,
-0.06644343584775925,
0.14841432869434357,
-0.11242200434207916,
-0.1145697757601738,
0.007332766894251108,
-0.8488774299621582,
-0.4968452751636505,
0.827423095703125,
-0.015566838905215263,
0.397352933883667,
-0.05272391438484192,
0.7636809945106506,
0.10049090534448624,
-0.13815657794475555,
-0.8351723551750183,
1.0728646516799927,
0.2347697913646698,
-0.37253978848457336,
-0.37480267882347107,
-0.24740882217884064,
-0.8746210932731628,
-0.0684126541018486,
-0.04374266043305397,
-0.6351803541183472,
0.51734858751297,
0.09627062827348709,
-0.36750325560569763,
0.08880987018346786,
-0.5601761937141418,
0.7596219182014465,
-0.23491114377975464,
-0.5081337690353394,
-0.4173588156700134,
-0.895606279373169,
-0.0026810644194483757,
0.14952343702316284,
-0.3358211815357208,
-0.10142067074775696,
0.5581409335136414,
0.7021946310997009,
-0.2515226900577545,
0.6073639392852783,
-0.5084565877914429,
0.04480005428195,
0.7324339151382446,
0.5028905272483826,
0.854131281375885,
0.026583200320601463,
0.31812429428100586,
0.017153043299913406,
-0.3642353117465973,
-0.3400101065635681,
-0.3036084473133087,
0.3145522475242615,
-0.22928108274936676,
-0.9207385778427124,
-0.19267739355564117,
-0.8229750990867615,
-0.5452907681465149,
0.3195270597934723,
0.3694078028202057,
0.48345282673835754,
-0.48585566878318787,
-0.2934282124042511,
0.4334515929222107,
-0.13393883407115936,
0.5058709383010864,
0.5153513550758362,
0.24648500978946686,
-0.16941872239112854,
1.0662972927093506,
-0.17186792194843292,
0.4541715979576111,
0.5008686184883118,
-0.047088369727134705,
-0.35026830434799194,
-0.8636537194252014,
-0.17116133868694305,
0.09636380523443222,
-0.2697237730026245,
-0.17457447946071625,
-0.40878382325172424,
-0.24335944652557373,
-0.3929905593395233,
-0.31032490730285645,
-0.41315603256225586,
-0.40679776668548584,
-0.03741304203867912,
0.005469298455864191,
-0.39630866050720215,
0.4313918948173523,
-0.05855114385485649,
0.4287942051887512,
-0.5221424698829651,
0.308000773191452,
0.4065187871456146,
0.03324459120631218,
-0.5916746854782104,
-0.04861072450876236,
0.005964507348835468,
0.17816226184368134,
-0.7884851098060608,
-0.9266548752784729,
0.5399637818336487,
-0.034756649285554886,
0.46592584252357483,
0.670985996723175,
0.4971162676811218,
0.4560484290122986,
-0.686892032623291,
0.7212716341018677,
0.3253936767578125,
-0.589783787727356,
1.1781268119812012,
-0.3469328284263611,
0.41362351179122925,
0.5314165353775024,
0.21498750150203705,
-0.5145038366317749,
-0.5352755784988403,
-0.6703928112983704,
-0.705462634563446,
0.9094003438949585,
0.6204594373703003,
0.06658342480659485,
-0.042204082012176514,
-0.0776977464556694,
-0.15366414189338684,
0.18454976379871368,
-0.33733952045440674,
0.14860758185386658,
-0.39716771245002747,
-0.03250152990221977,
-0.28017550706863403,
-0.34552228450775146,
-0.5364760756492615,
0.20129254460334778,
0.45493340492248535,
-0.3027380704879761,
0.5410388708114624,
0.3007032871246338,
0.16127055883407593,
-0.22598643600940704,
0.4668906629085541,
0.7163988947868347,
0.46101075410842896,
-0.4382210373878479,
-0.02336486428976059,
-0.0307760089635849,
-0.6269997358322144,
0.06586064398288727,
0.19317512214183807,
-0.4248221814632416,
0.10521745681762695,
0.07989086210727692,
0.9424550533294678,
-0.011253849603235722,
-0.8164516687393188,
0.20240233838558197,
-0.14041879773139954,
-0.23408475518226624,
-0.010390239767730236,
0.010081454180181026,
-0.2212427705526352,
0.5242890119552612,
0.16644370555877686,
0.1254611313343048,
0.15095779299736023,
-0.43711408972740173,
-0.12317349761724472,
0.42064425349235535,
-0.5486946105957031,
-0.27026140689849854,
0.43722274899482727,
0.6420180797576904,
-0.7193963527679443,
0.8428040742874146,
-0.16959568858146667,
-0.6428924202919006,
0.3122658431529999,
0.6477696299552917,
1.365767002105713,
-0.23582710325717926,
0.5550114512443542,
0.4011146128177643,
0.2882236838340759,
0.21507029235363007,
0.2537826895713806,
-0.5766915082931519,
-0.8205379843711853,
-0.2854287028312683,
-0.5030941367149353,
-0.6026995182037354,
-0.2647980749607086,
-0.7365594506263733,
0.22367462515830994,
-0.17103825509548187,
-0.21172505617141724,
-0.5758225321769714,
-0.040860988199710846,
-0.43025222420692444,
0.13403207063674927,
0.03498328849673271,
0.6312870979309082,
-0.5464626550674438,
0.5654504299163818,
0.3699983060359955,
-0.04570254683494568,
-0.8388019800186157,
0.5618070960044861,
-0.20129084587097168,
-0.6497130990028381,
0.5163864493370056,
0.07080244272947311,
-0.3468373417854309,
0.07476932555437088,
-0.11010382324457169,
-0.6488271951675415,
1.0331445932388306,
-0.05916439741849899,
-0.8790165781974792,
-0.5375308990478516,
0.2628101706504822,
0.16496580839157104,
-0.4186663329601288,
-0.03514748811721802,
0.7712967395782471,
0.378132164478302,
0.5971786379814148,
-0.9289661645889282,
0.18657560646533966,
-0.09790977835655212,
-0.044258199632167816,
0.47633540630340576,
-0.7397182583808899,
0.3414159119129181,
-0.48107755184173584,
-0.31532353162765503,
-0.13973775506019592,
0.4714300036430359,
0.2015892118215561,
0.39825448393821716,
0.6613766551017761,
0.32752591371536255,
0.0945243239402771,
-0.1969466656446457,
0.6494775414466858,
-0.3104798495769501,
-0.10538521409034729,
1.0595983266830444,
-0.5336889028549194,
0.6456105709075928,
0.5826109647750854,
-0.0038529359735548496,
0.42653608322143555,
0.4268755614757538,
0.2564697861671448,
0.990831732749939,
-0.09694278240203857,
-0.5199924111366272,
-0.3952431082725525,
-0.3545490801334381,
0.05415751785039902,
0.6429580450057983,
0.4373075067996979,
-0.10241002589464188,
-0.23426659405231476,
0.17028719186782837,
0.018301229923963547,
-0.1509389877319336,
-0.17412413656711578,
0.941443681716919,
-0.3336835205554962,
-1.3132095336914062,
0.573501467704773,
-0.0793851688504219,
0.10135076940059662,
-0.8139119744300842,
0.08261062204837799,
-0.4009771943092346,
0.063322052359581,
0.20599566400051117,
-0.7694621682167053,
0.441469669342041,
0.08656901866197586,
0.1195843517780304,
-0.7108262181282043,
0.7500233054161072,
-0.5566806197166443,
-0.23390069603919983,
-0.07451243698596954,
0.425548255443573,
-0.0218689925968647,
-0.21942736208438873,
-0.4376024901866913,
0.0033848686143755913,
0.41936981678009033,
-0.3310518264770508,
0.1150643453001976,
0.10189761221408844,
-0.2821856439113617,
0.4771019220352173,
0.5790806412696838,
0.13356590270996094,
-0.33782312273979187,
0.0071440646424889565,
1.0173182487487793,
-0.6002412438392639,
-0.5774587392807007,
-0.3713395297527313,
0.5088486075401306,
0.022616397589445114,
-0.2007867842912674,
0.36334893107414246,
0.47393107414245605,
0.8772375583648682,
0.1426801234483719,
0.5473788380622864,
-0.08053828030824661,
0.21181727945804596,
-0.4669085144996643,
0.015917718410491943,
-0.09431065618991852,
0.22168795764446259,
-0.2995374798774719,
-1.23546302318573,
-0.11908828467130661,
0.6870865821838379,
-0.392159640789032,
-0.2551346719264984,
0.6047216653823853,
0.9292172193527222,
0.1282052993774414,
-0.08904054015874863,
0.20181016623973846,
-0.08735022693872452,
0.7378398180007935,
1.0650629997253418,
1.1125565767288208,
0.008190052583813667,
0.9172430634498596,
-0.2760716676712036,
-0.2305276095867157,
-0.29775965213775635,
-0.5661165118217468,
-0.6116136312484741,
-0.5522934794425964,
-0.2927795648574829,
-0.24548226594924927,
0.19546690583229065,
0.6497125029563904,
0.7367959022521973,
-0.6104260683059692,
-0.34381547570228577,
-0.6561398506164551,
0.07801799476146698,
-0.36401188373565674,
-0.20881207287311554,
0.19116546213626862,
-0.20234805345535278,
-0.9463666677474976,
0.6416550874710083,
0.5721379518508911,
0.026869622990489006,
-0.313698947429657,
-0.3632740378379822,
-0.19994646310806274,
0.2587282657623291,
0.551872193813324,
0.38119056820869446,
-0.5560336112976074,
-0.22671660780906677,
0.06878890097141266,
0.16649046540260315,
-0.11860872060060501,
1.385288953781128,
-0.8265833854675293,
0.5832725763320923,
0.2613895535469055,
-0.01003890298306942,
0.7220487594604492,
0.0736834928393364,
0.8044999241828918,
-0.5859118103981018,
0.2724405527114868,
0.9385374784469604,
-0.02765585668385029,
0.00812947191298008,
-0.23150590062141418,
0.28488731384277344,
0.1062125414609909,
-0.5025020837783813,
-0.8453606963157654,
0.9143187999725342,
-1.1047766208648682,
-0.2545826733112335,
1.0507606267929077,
0.10104253143072128,
0.3229019343852997,
-0.032293178141117096,
-0.8871824741363525,
0.443859726190567,
-0.22473566234111786,
0.4757990837097168,
0.3793248236179352,
-0.6768534779548645,
-0.10266584903001785,
-0.12125316262245178,
0.506449818611145,
0.6723338961601257,
-0.4780706465244293,
0.2872520983219147,
0.7015020847320557,
-0.36761388182640076,
0.34591299295425415,
0.7758236527442932,
0.27081871032714844,
0.05191350355744362,
0.1366233378648758,
-0.3134422302246094,
0.15087619423866272,
-0.9815399050712585,
0.2613869905471802,
0.1006309762597084,
-0.13035182654857635,
-0.40386030077934265
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06060v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06060v1
|
Ensemble Language Models for Multilingual Sentiment Analysis
| 2024-03-10T01:39:10 | 2024-03-10T01:39:10 |
Md Arid Hasan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, I.2.7
|
The rapid advancement of social media enables us to analyze user opinions. In
recent times, sentiment analysis has shown a prominent research gap in
understanding human sentiment based on the content shared on social media.
Although sentiment analysis for commonly spoken languages has advanced
significantly, low-resource languages like Arabic continue to get little
research due to resource limitations. In this study, we explore sentiment
analysis on tweet texts from SemEval-17 and the Arabic Sentiment Tweet dataset.
Moreover, We investigated four pretrained language models and proposed two
ensemble language models. Our findings include monolingual models exhibiting
superior performance and ensemble models outperforming the baseline while the
majority voting ensemble outperforms the English language.
|
[
-0.4995171129703522,
-0.5116701722145081,
0.23284971714019775,
0.48797672986984253,
-0.4415452182292938,
0.6394361257553101,
-0.5187702775001526,
-0.5760829448699951,
0.3537948727607727,
0.2051367610692978,
-0.5492439270019531,
-0.8417021632194519,
-0.711707592010498,
0.08594609051942825,
-0.2236633002758026,
1.108177900314331,
-0.05837961286306381,
0.3798693120479584,
0.06684192270040512,
-0.6897463798522949,
0.0280173160135746,
-0.6094620227813721,
-0.676089882850647,
-0.0936020165681839,
0.5265514254570007,
0.378185898065567,
0.6438365578651428,
-0.3447096049785614,
0.5045202374458313,
0.27439799904823303,
0.1891375184059143,
0.008496712893247604,
-0.2772855758666992,
0.04076947644352913,
-0.13646148145198822,
0.0209537111222744,
-0.372154176235199,
-0.1019367054104805,
0.6794470548629761,
0.6477402448654175,
-0.1314321756362915,
0.0920410230755806,
0.23035939037799835,
0.42583975195884705,
-0.44498899579048157,
-0.0785672664642334,
-0.41066083312034607,
-0.10503389686346054,
-0.2946712374687195,
0.025256464257836342,
-0.06839434057474136,
-0.513441264629364,
0.16328249871730804,
0.018977899104356766,
0.012839979492127895,
-0.11812756210565567,
0.5932531952857971,
-0.047107744961977005,
-0.47269582748413086,
-0.28977805376052856,
-0.5668283104896545,
1.3264241218566895,
-0.735163688659668,
0.23815420269966125,
0.20307657122612,
0.2163955420255661,
0.5398930311203003,
-0.3627457618713379,
-0.5068531036376953,
-0.08848327398300171,
0.051659926772117615,
0.2788199186325073,
-0.11852945387363434,
-0.08761447668075562,
-0.4517558813095093,
0.17505337297916412,
-0.5072993636131287,
0.10244739055633545,
-0.3957390785217285,
-0.05610109865665436,
0.9837703704833984,
-0.17449378967285156,
0.45977604389190674,
-0.29402175545692444,
-0.40380972623825073,
-0.16786623001098633,
-0.3129345774650574,
-0.023291150107979774,
0.4427589178085327,
0.3926655054092407,
-0.4316991865634918,
0.26294568181037903,
0.014820792712271214,
0.35226479172706604,
-0.44814935326576233,
0.13688354194164276,
0.4039982259273529,
-0.15091808140277863,
-0.26564788818359375,
0.16898830235004425,
1.266932725906372,
0.30823415517807007,
0.43080753087997437,
-0.024568865075707436,
-0.40217188000679016,
0.33280643820762634,
0.06706523895263672,
-0.6109225749969482,
-0.00031521337223239243,
0.3728944957256317,
-0.7040883302688599,
-0.6386647820472717,
0.010629018768668175,
-1.1155509948730469,
-0.5166071057319641,
0.022419027984142303,
0.2800986170768738,
-0.5720797181129456,
-0.6855451464653015,
-0.13181337714195251,
-0.17667467892169952,
0.19381597638130188,
0.4343172013759613,
-0.6065472364425659,
0.39367473125457764,
0.45004749298095703,
0.8488856554031372,
-0.27920836210250854,
-0.47013774514198303,
0.014910445548593998,
-0.4893167316913605,
-0.5163130164146423,
0.9303168058395386,
-0.9262852072715759,
-0.6163004040718079,
0.3119036555290222,
-0.17162206768989563,
-0.24586965143680573,
-0.20908355712890625,
0.7548885345458984,
-0.6579081416130066,
0.16646191477775574,
-0.19740012288093567,
-0.46833574771881104,
-0.42643123865127563,
0.2672004699707031,
-0.5780465006828308,
0.8846563100814819,
-0.02775743417441845,
-0.8603651523590088,
0.3415249288082123,
-0.8045967817306519,
-0.6907176971435547,
-0.04229669272899628,
-0.13877063989639282,
-0.1500774472951889,
0.3489328622817993,
0.4684187173843384,
0.594578206539154,
-0.2744036614894867,
-0.05238080769777298,
-0.5637673139572144,
-0.0611230693757534,
0.2595354914665222,
-0.40286019444465637,
0.7072861790657043,
0.6188027858734131,
-0.07939434051513672,
-0.0073578255251049995,
-0.4334731698036194,
0.05868183448910713,
0.005692551843822002,
-0.1137624979019165,
-0.44373252987861633,
0.04126143828034401,
0.679893970489502,
0.20483216643333435,
0.4127909243106842,
-0.590326726436615,
0.10841728746891022,
-0.22002282738685608,
0.5075112581253052,
0.7204079031944275,
0.23751528561115265,
0.6201211214065552,
-0.12173796445131302,
0.8868137001991272,
0.3347983658313751,
-0.29046761989593506,
-0.048371873795986176,
-0.24001522362232208,
-0.44874393939971924,
0.01982794888317585,
0.16465874016284943,
0.44037479162216187,
-0.7554132342338562,
-0.1046595498919487,
-0.3958035409450531,
-0.6411011219024658,
-0.8141067028045654,
0.1624755561351776,
-0.11093627661466599,
-0.20994623005390167,
0.19919061660766602,
0.01917755976319313,
-0.5862776041030884,
-0.8088794946670532,
-0.6018760204315186,
-0.294107586145401,
0.5122812390327454,
0.0676078274846077,
0.34748801589012146,
-0.40494418144226074,
0.4793732762336731,
0.018081577494740486,
0.0987108051776886,
-0.700509250164032,
0.4582802951335907,
0.10383456200361252,
0.2710528075695038,
0.8055683970451355,
-0.6932163238525391,
-0.5742833018302917,
0.28466230630874634,
-0.7307612895965576,
0.07663197070360184,
0.12080972641706467,
-0.00012273060565348715,
0.6895885467529297,
0.20985248684883118,
-0.36263957619667053,
0.16843630373477936,
0.8825098872184753,
0.03108016587793827,
0.15669089555740356,
0.3572676479816437,
0.5223674774169922,
-1.4488749504089355,
-0.2419300377368927,
0.23907530307769775,
-0.18661004304885864,
-0.6578992605209351,
-0.10776788741350174,
-0.13961748778820038,
-0.12346993386745453,
-0.4784267544746399,
0.7525933384895325,
-0.30934733152389526,
0.06949751824140549,
-0.2623665928840637,
-0.29204580187797546,
-0.3055373430252075,
0.26873984932899475,
0.35930466651916504,
0.59273761510849,
0.6529455184936523,
-0.3101639151573181,
0.14105072617530823,
-0.1354248821735382,
-0.5646805763244629,
0.21798208355903625,
-0.5483097434043884,
0.15566477179527283,
-0.2603588104248047,
-0.12161029130220413,
-1.3328202962875366,
-0.5374323725700378,
-0.022014612331986427,
-0.6900215148925781,
0.3551546335220337,
-0.016662202775478363,
-0.4562688171863556,
-0.2741081118583679,
-0.5681560635566711,
0.49670514464378357,
0.42817622423171997,
-0.31660595536231995,
0.6521350741386414,
0.5992340445518494,
-0.37640050053596497,
-0.6325259804725647,
-0.6434510350227356,
0.08535867184400558,
-0.3942130208015442,
-0.7900577187538147,
0.03126561641693115,
0.29648739099502563,
-0.6081076860427856,
-0.05632317066192627,
0.16924898326396942,
-0.2627367675304413,
0.04753557965159416,
0.04250446707010269,
0.2212485820055008,
-0.2765134871006012,
0.6011204123497009,
0.20971974730491638,
0.3345232903957367,
-0.11532603949308395,
-0.2856694757938385,
0.8976665139198303,
-0.49722665548324585,
-0.1064392551779747,
-0.13804103434085846,
0.5673683285713196,
0.8075881600379944,
-0.4541236460208893,
0.9899495840072632,
1.0033918619155884,
-0.47871696949005127,
-0.11638005077838898,
-0.628341019153595,
-0.14718183875083923,
-0.40266773104667664,
0.4334834814071655,
-0.2189636528491974,
-0.9490278959274292,
0.48536643385887146,
0.12317268550395966,
0.06766866892576218,
0.6031773686408997,
0.7220613956451416,
-0.3457607328891754,
1.1587724685668945,
0.323319673538208,
-0.5821925401687622,
0.4421847462654114,
-0.057725802063941956,
0.30657657980918884,
-0.10349118709564209,
0.2530413568019867,
-0.5459865927696228,
-0.33509108424186707,
-1.0426812171936035,
0.004208821337670088,
0.4304876923561096,
0.07995710521936417,
-0.07613982260227203,
-0.00606297655031085,
-0.10020674765110016,
0.18780653178691864,
0.5288083553314209,
-0.1634378433227539,
-0.15844391286373138,
0.6072545647621155,
-0.03737497702240944,
0.04374299570918083,
-0.721731424331665,
-0.9683788418769836,
0.804955244064331,
0.29563984274864197,
0.8672212958335876,
0.22214482724666595,
1.1425986289978027,
0.519656777381897,
0.2342650145292282,
-0.7140803933143616,
0.3882073760032654,
-0.2750220000743866,
-0.5853931307792664,
-0.29859456419944763,
-0.19126367568969727,
-0.7555592656135559,
0.0435347780585289,
-0.06141549348831177,
-0.7716990113258362,
0.03328258916735649,
-0.1974875032901764,
-0.39406153559684753,
0.16403436660766602,
-0.7221263647079468,
1.0393401384353638,
-0.12765227258205414,
-0.2912714183330536,
-0.4773475229740143,
-0.4240359961986542,
0.3495555520057678,
-0.09244798123836517,
0.6701906323432922,
-0.0674646645784378,
0.011258605867624283,
0.9181949496269226,
-0.41195249557495117,
0.8489569425582886,
-0.13759461045265198,
-0.06652107834815979,
0.5797910094261169,
0.019219473004341125,
0.21727655827999115,
0.13146495819091797,
-0.36469322443008423,
0.37411051988601685,
0.2524077892303467,
-0.6542254090309143,
-0.24601472914218903,
0.9638807773590088,
-1.2543001174926758,
-0.16620765626430511,
-0.4900701940059662,
-0.000868344446644187,
-0.3494472801685333,
-0.14237184822559357,
0.5074548721313477,
0.36717742681503296,
-0.5203019976615906,
0.08165448904037476,
-0.020401686429977417,
-0.3092300593852997,
0.8971577286720276,
0.1707778424024582,
-0.2080727368593216,
-0.35761433839797974,
0.8684604167938232,
0.2553507685661316,
0.010496113449335098,
0.257246196269989,
0.14848902821540833,
-0.5091220736503601,
-0.12911811470985413,
-0.5054540038108826,
-0.02773222327232361,
-0.7039599418640137,
0.08651126176118851,
-0.8233160972595215,
-0.006480110343545675,
-0.7590459585189819,
-0.14927470684051514,
-0.32664772868156433,
-0.5730434656143188,
-0.04241436347365379,
-0.16459572315216064,
0.42299360036849976,
0.8728193640708923,
-0.18123871088027954,
0.4955276846885681,
-1.395468831062317,
-0.2495054453611374,
0.13207697868347168,
-0.03569889813661575,
0.1359037607908249,
-0.28784897923469543,
-0.3208509087562561,
-0.008698699995875359,
-0.2207913100719452,
-1.1128464937210083,
0.6856549978256226,
0.277279257774353,
0.29598286747932434,
0.5719417929649353,
-0.034680046141147614,
0.3887560963630676,
-0.2528013586997986,
0.9437450170516968,
0.11312048882246017,
-0.9177238345146179,
0.5505000352859497,
-0.6017277240753174,
0.27364933490753174,
0.5351846218109131,
0.42644935846328735,
-0.8031371235847473,
-0.21961276233196259,
-0.5651612281799316,
-0.46958303451538086,
0.6622929573059082,
0.1118818148970604,
0.46331003308296204,
-0.28272515535354614,
-0.311831533908844,
0.19000837206840515,
0.3101477324962616,
-0.6122989058494568,
0.08639386296272278,
-0.3271171748638153,
-0.6133603453636169,
-0.4506200850009918,
-0.2500797212123871,
0.16054615378379822,
-0.10515042394399643,
0.6956243515014648,
0.1495814025402069,
0.32519957423210144,
-0.14375659823417664,
-0.24517665803432465,
-0.3089889585971832,
0.6443571448326111,
0.3770682215690613,
0.3872494101524353,
-0.11408009380102158,
0.04304145649075508,
0.3969784677028656,
-0.2520790100097656,
0.12469286471605301,
0.2177387773990631,
0.11051678657531738,
0.06471545249223709,
0.7044683694839478,
0.7570636868476868,
0.06302095949649811,
-0.6175774931907654,
0.3843264579772949,
0.02144647017121315,
0.06644284725189209,
-0.435457706451416,
-0.3671613335609436,
0.2737398147583008,
0.03969918191432953,
0.41634300351142883,
0.42147722840309143,
0.08350428938865662,
-0.721069872379303,
-0.06603763997554779,
0.37128910422325134,
-0.6239508390426636,
-0.7188449501991272,
0.12444207817316055,
0.167911559343338,
-0.010166180320084095,
0.35002315044403076,
-0.3682385981082916,
-0.8465059995651245,
0.46664175391197205,
0.03468523547053337,
0.98683762550354,
-0.47720417380332947,
0.5324968695640564,
0.253582239151001,
0.2869202792644501,
0.01827642321586609,
0.5608964562416077,
0.008503466844558716,
-1.1689633131027222,
-0.39037370681762695,
-0.9854987263679504,
-0.14882023632526398,
-0.08910174667835236,
-0.5969833135604858,
0.30902180075645447,
-0.3040050268173218,
-0.1968979388475418,
0.1201542317867279,
0.10046520829200745,
-0.9000973105430603,
0.474595844745636,
0.17370440065860748,
0.4604872167110443,
-0.821908712387085,
0.7857964038848877,
1.4806139469146729,
-0.43188321590423584,
-0.7707698941230774,
-0.05138427019119263,
0.029086261987686157,
-0.9421584606170654,
0.5659467577934265,
0.28722769021987915,
-0.13102823495864868,
0.027892282232642174,
-0.7824819087982178,
-0.5100011229515076,
0.5495991110801697,
-0.12992402911186218,
-0.34597474336624146,
0.29941606521606445,
0.1220276728272438,
0.7266180515289307,
-0.47588902711868286,
0.2376062273979187,
0.4220077097415924,
0.25641146302223206,
0.027363112196326256,
-0.5711643099784851,
-0.4669860601425171,
-0.3558020293712616,
-0.2613174021244049,
0.24657697975635529,
-0.7077506184577942,
0.8762491345405579,
0.09556122124195099,
-0.29292964935302734,
-0.10608263313770294,
0.6475959420204163,
0.0653030201792717,
0.42488163709640503,
0.5189682841300964,
0.4493952691555023,
0.6701110005378723,
0.10155756026506424,
1.3305224180221558,
-0.636481761932373,
0.4146588444709778,
0.7260496020317078,
-0.4250972867012024,
1.1280021667480469,
0.37060844898223877,
-0.33018022775650024,
0.4816846549510956,
0.8659912943840027,
0.5117752552032471,
0.44816505908966064,
-0.2568095624446869,
-0.6670951247215271,
-0.5839201211929321,
-0.25150254368782043,
-0.29818204045295715,
0.6713258028030396,
0.34066301584243774,
-0.3878674805164337,
-0.21154840290546417,
0.16300354897975922,
0.01821298338472843,
-0.026546409353613853,
-0.5589050054550171,
0.7039195895195007,
0.3534413278102875,
-0.7764931917190552,
0.1979874223470688,
0.18826454877853394,
0.6801555156707764,
-0.2487718164920807,
0.27854758501052856,
-0.16533008217811584,
0.1982332319021225,
-0.1662515252828598,
-0.7455617785453796,
0.27285635471343994,
0.17220452427864075,
0.17323052883148193,
-0.01060872245579958,
1.01886785030365,
-0.3738025724887848,
-1.1244901418685913,
0.45356810092926025,
0.9949740171432495,
0.15028640627861023,
-0.19014135003089905,
-0.6293779015541077,
0.05260753631591797,
-0.013661982491612434,
-0.3259863257408142,
0.11154711991548538,
0.5343089699745178,
-0.08476676046848297,
0.3508865237236023,
0.37858444452285767,
-0.07503432780504227,
0.0018802308477461338,
0.4247310161590576,
0.6572879552841187,
-0.5960339903831482,
-0.4845723807811737,
-1.1711013317108154,
0.2782604694366455,
-0.18896135687828064,
-0.1972910463809967,
0.8400760293006897,
0.20198774337768555,
0.6831027865409851,
-0.19100047647953033,
1.3754551410675049,
0.068444162607193,
0.8460350632667542,
-0.33664149045944214,
0.9114173650741577,
-0.7382328510284424,
0.07067699730396271,
-0.49596717953681946,
-0.9133586287498474,
0.01707594096660614,
0.7015323638916016,
-0.508597731590271,
0.39143919944763184,
0.4637851417064667,
0.6990076303482056,
-0.03404635936021805,
0.4316689670085907,
0.21121297776699066,
0.2058669924736023,
-0.004800810944288969,
0.2504872679710388,
1.2792701721191406,
-0.3350832462310791,
0.19591131806373596,
-0.14357589185237885,
0.06592532247304916,
-0.11043228954076767,
-0.5802914500236511,
-1.1651930809020996,
-0.43375784158706665,
-0.08866515755653381,
-0.34590214490890503,
-0.07124987244606018,
1.4935182332992554,
0.5222491025924683,
-1.0796394348144531,
-0.43114402890205383,
-0.01923125982284546,
0.01695386692881584,
0.15324293076992035,
-0.25437185168266296,
0.45444801449775696,
-0.6795206665992737,
-0.7498877048492432,
0.08359184861183167,
0.10633591562509537,
0.14309462904930115,
-0.1616470366716385,
-0.24310152232646942,
-0.2276816964149475,
0.28801360726356506,
0.5889910459518433,
-0.07437878847122192,
-0.5065445303916931,
-0.2223171442747116,
0.12774595618247986,
-0.167558491230011,
-0.01856835000216961,
0.5947546362876892,
-0.41807764768600464,
0.2570961117744446,
0.5476641654968262,
0.48232367634773254,
0.3589162826538086,
0.08404857665300369,
0.5980527997016907,
-0.7419361472129822,
0.094476118683815,
0.3629518747329712,
0.5495316982269287,
0.4974606931209564,
0.15047267079353333,
0.3526665270328522,
0.060819439589977264,
-0.3707449436187744,
-0.5387048125267029,
-0.024288421496748924,
-0.7719470858573914,
-0.2612541615962982,
1.2656217813491821,
0.01507404912263155,
-0.18943101167678833,
0.1703978031873703,
-0.18620173633098602,
0.19700947403907776,
-0.8281506896018982,
0.6601654291152954,
1.1466723680496216,
0.3817942440509796,
-0.4005809426307678,
-0.29879075288772583,
0.3989083170890808,
0.5290682315826416,
-0.6109276413917542,
-0.5168590545654297,
0.28582754731178284,
-0.06259032338857651,
0.12381099164485931,
0.7343496084213257,
0.19158048927783966,
0.20900419354438782,
-0.1641298532485962,
0.05422775447368622,
0.6871718764305115,
-0.08858472108840942,
-0.5296082496643066,
0.4205459952354431,
0.13006827235221863,
-0.16907373070716858
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00688v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00688v1
|
Understanding Social Perception, Interactions, and Safety Aspects of Sidewalk Delivery Robots Using Sentiment Analysis
| 2024-03-09T23:28:01 | 2024-03-09T23:28:01 |
Yuchen Du, Tho V. Le
|
cs.RO
|
cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.LG
|
This article presents a comprehensive sentiment analysis (SA) of comments on
YouTube videos related to Sidewalk Delivery Robots (SDRs). We manually
annotated the collected YouTube comments with three sentiment labels: negative
(0), positive (1), and neutral (2). We then constructed models for text
sentiment classification and tested the models' performance on both binary and
ternary classification tasks in terms of accuracy, precision, recall, and F1
score. Our results indicate that, in binary classification tasks, the Support
Vector Machine (SVM) model using Term Frequency-Inverse Document Frequency
(TF-IDF) and N-gram get the highest accuracy. In ternary classification tasks,
the model using Bidirectional Encoder Representations from Transformers (BERT),
Long Short-Term Memory Networks (LSTM) and Gated Recurrent Unit (GRU)
significantly outperforms other machine learning models, achieving an accuracy,
precision, recall, and F1 score of 0.78. Additionally, we employ the Latent
Dirichlet Allocation model to generate 10 topics from the comments to explore
the public's underlying views on SDRs. Drawing from these findings, we propose
targeted recommendations for shaping future policies concerning SDRs. This work
provides valuable insights for stakeholders in the SDR sector regarding social
perception, interaction, and safety.
|
[
-0.34966662526130676,
-0.5842322707176208,
0.6535472273826599,
0.35431841015815735,
-0.31610238552093506,
0.2926011085510254,
0.3354032039642334,
-0.3158632516860962,
0.2715112864971161,
0.4940195083618164,
-0.4760783612728119,
-0.3738960921764374,
-0.8636682629585266,
-0.11903902888298035,
-0.6259427666664124,
1.4385383129119873,
0.4442697763442993,
0.001742419321089983,
-0.006542909424751997,
-0.09575168043375015,
-0.0365181602537632,
-0.5820238590240479,
-0.3737535774707794,
0.01929324120283127,
0.5500314235687256,
-0.0535917691886425,
0.9567320346832275,
0.30491504073143005,
0.5038992166519165,
0.44063758850097656,
-0.32919391989707947,
-0.3209325671195984,
-0.14657767117023468,
-0.5104916095733643,
-0.42089760303497314,
0.055948641151189804,
-0.5096985101699829,
-0.3647804260253906,
0.2044660896062851,
0.7270329594612122,
-0.06998836249113083,
0.18501947820186615,
0.0666348934173584,
0.7694812417030334,
-0.5488533973693848,
-0.0617578886449337,
-0.25450146198272705,
0.18929657340049744,
0.019022664055228233,
-0.09963816404342651,
-0.15880627930164337,
-0.8139955401420593,
0.19209104776382446,
0.09131862223148346,
0.4275692105293274,
-0.33700811862945557,
0.5585767030715942,
0.48324427008628845,
-0.6880555748939514,
-0.4745963513851166,
-1.04972505569458,
0.6316322684288025,
-0.4449682831764221,
0.5898854732513428,
0.14606879651546478,
0.165342777967453,
-0.014006535522639751,
-0.1583748161792755,
-0.9084333777427673,
0.0509486198425293,
0.17601612210273743,
0.3281796872615814,
-0.2207074612379074,
0.26100122928619385,
0.0262574665248394,
-0.10692155361175537,
-0.4554907977581024,
-0.11414167284965515,
-0.6876362562179565,
0.07604354619979858,
0.6538903713226318,
0.0962173268198967,
0.19343635439872742,
-0.8456871509552002,
-0.6506145000457764,
-0.3141046166419983,
-0.1950986385345459,
0.5520206093788147,
0.6643340587615967,
0.15946125984191895,
-0.3509468138217926,
0.6871979832649231,
-0.018884878605604172,
0.6276247501373291,
-0.04257819801568985,
-0.2425178438425064,
0.7965351343154907,
-0.23837926983833313,
-0.21592262387275696,
-0.15007445216178894,
0.958672821521759,
0.9881943464279175,
0.3425794243812561,
-0.02499556727707386,
-0.3664512634277344,
0.24188929796218872,
0.8625630736351013,
-0.17029118537902832,
-0.13284267485141754,
0.2648782432079315,
-0.8349688649177551,
-0.7251107096672058,
0.5008570551872253,
-0.9978150129318237,
-0.6193085312843323,
-0.2668280005455017,
0.26364147663116455,
0.0402468778192997,
-0.20314395427703857,
0.10840623080730438,
-0.3102024793624878,
0.2606797218322754,
0.5766284465789795,
-0.7283540368080139,
0.4084520936012268,
0.702521026134491,
0.8293807506561279,
0.051454052329063416,
-0.060030560940504074,
-0.4535568058490753,
0.3640681505203247,
-0.21742670238018036,
0.6562710404396057,
-0.10834546387195587,
-0.4051734209060669,
0.3631768226623535,
0.35306301712989807,
0.008848663419485092,
-0.30805519223213196,
0.45279040932655334,
-0.4342523217201233,
-0.2704126536846161,
-0.11827964335680008,
-0.03882352635264397,
-0.3853287100791931,
0.4569784700870514,
-0.45026424527168274,
1.038125991821289,
0.13610762357711792,
-0.7757154107093811,
0.17470955848693848,
-0.47384655475616455,
-0.7475171089172363,
-0.03294611722230911,
-0.142151340842247,
-0.114603191614151,
0.27129727602005005,
-0.021379735320806503,
0.9021040797233582,
0.16556337475776672,
0.14194487035274506,
-0.34465956687927246,
0.031963050365448,
0.42864179611206055,
-0.3748601973056793,
0.6231598854064941,
-0.025218628346920013,
-0.39062389731407166,
0.30583468079566956,
-0.5588055849075317,
-0.394839882850647,
-0.2603609263896942,
-0.21019694209098816,
-0.02036592923104763,
0.19554635882377625,
0.2059849500656128,
0.512477457523346,
0.34048691391944885,
-0.7442216873168945,
-0.3185747563838959,
-0.3262515962123871,
0.35772550106048584,
1.2441208362579346,
0.04097647964954376,
0.5055434703826904,
-0.2010318636894226,
0.6363192796707153,
-0.08921391516923904,
0.6275767087936401,
0.37004104256629944,
-0.5012382864952087,
-0.6077804565429688,
0.27754709124565125,
-0.23626072704792023,
0.6282752752304077,
-0.6506819128990173,
0.485915869474411,
-0.6287258267402649,
-0.4090504050254822,
-0.29730769991874695,
0.025746086612343788,
0.23293828964233398,
0.47639548778533936,
0.23138795793056488,
-0.24277792870998383,
-0.19328154623508453,
-0.7123948335647583,
0.45579826831817627,
-0.6000127792358398,
0.0042799245566129684,
0.41260620951652527,
0.46554216742515564,
-0.2752675414085388,
0.7258527278900146,
-0.4859565198421478,
-0.30126288533210754,
-0.3351624310016632,
-0.04291344806551933,
0.08953255414962769,
0.11433868855237961,
0.5174938440322876,
-0.9542615413665771,
-0.31428518891334534,
-0.03428129851818085,
-0.5698662996292114,
0.354509562253952,
0.05646737292408943,
0.2280227392911911,
0.2295178323984146,
0.43624797463417053,
-0.6699767112731934,
0.5870987772941589,
0.4847087860107422,
0.059583596885204315,
0.23406927287578583,
-0.21696053445339203,
0.04363452270627022,
-0.728367269039154,
-0.37423253059387207,
0.52500981092453,
-0.08121809363365173,
-0.6224531531333923,
-0.31370747089385986,
-0.3303612470626831,
0.057375892996788025,
-0.7632168531417847,
-0.014895130880177021,
0.38077110052108765,
-0.45164796710014343,
-0.21624740958213806,
0.24182602763175964,
-0.32218286395072937,
0.18006356060504913,
0.2081306129693985,
0.5345854163169861,
0.2094416320323944,
-0.8002558350563049,
0.5352256894111633,
0.18614636361598969,
-0.06000204756855965,
0.3092072904109955,
-0.933867871761322,
0.19114720821380615,
-0.37891316413879395,
0.2609935700893402,
-1.2216076850891113,
-0.04349779337644577,
0.5649961829185486,
-0.7099440097808838,
-0.31695735454559326,
-0.31132733821868896,
-0.7814591526985168,
-0.676017165184021,
-0.5549137592315674,
-0.3123335540294647,
0.6357656717300415,
-0.340455025434494,
0.773270845413208,
0.7788087129592896,
-0.1355307698249817,
-0.45725733041763306,
-0.303073525428772,
-0.27540895342826843,
-0.20327647030353546,
-0.612999439239502,
0.06352131068706512,
-0.0027641330379992723,
-0.2840751111507416,
-0.09857895970344543,
-0.2078760415315628,
0.06336165964603424,
0.07287198305130005,
0.6202757358551025,
0.1599615216255188,
0.4349871873855591,
0.048296961933374405,
-0.04468357190489769,
-0.33840227127075195,
0.6304534673690796,
0.28276604413986206,
0.7109596729278564,
-0.19163000583648682,
-0.07938942313194275,
-0.08536352217197418,
-0.07854990661144257,
0.6186413764953613,
0.14040841162204742,
0.6119744777679443,
0.7975240349769592,
-0.3198508620262146,
0.14183810353279114,
-0.289364218711853,
-0.1372724175453186,
-0.5556023716926575,
0.3907793164253235,
-0.0589817613363266,
-0.3394135534763336,
0.08735696226358414,
-0.04361391067504883,
-0.21217580139636993,
0.018520070239901543,
0.25816717743873596,
-0.6894137263298035,
1.1362111568450928,
0.8389862775802612,
-0.40190640091896057,
0.4699647128582001,
-0.16717574000358582,
0.33230164647102356,
-0.7619487047195435,
-0.5697517991065979,
-0.5548651814460754,
-0.04593054950237274,
-0.7137346863746643,
-0.4553303122520447,
0.4091062545776367,
-0.19654184579849243,
-0.40704113245010376,
0.35592564940452576,
-0.5477569699287415,
0.18581761419773102,
0.42900049686431885,
0.3014334738254547,
-0.24045661091804504,
0.00790218822658062,
0.2690443694591522,
-0.011062330566346645,
-0.208672896027565,
-0.9245471954345703,
0.8426723480224609,
0.527888834476471,
0.45804378390312195,
0.35925716161727905,
0.3869589865207672,
0.7044432759284973,
-0.059903647750616074,
-0.7131320238113403,
0.9906818866729736,
-0.7478296756744385,
-0.20918332040309906,
-0.08229947090148926,
-0.16382485628128052,
-0.7161079049110413,
-0.1503913849592209,
-0.226266548037529,
-0.9090673923492432,
-0.16121387481689453,
-0.158200204372406,
-0.39786115288734436,
0.306254506111145,
-0.347780704498291,
0.7082305550575256,
-0.552345871925354,
-0.2755787670612335,
-0.40740177035331726,
-1.13255774974823,
-0.06762677431106567,
0.38336944580078125,
0.6941237449645996,
-0.06006442755460739,
0.04627833515405655,
0.708304762840271,
-0.3909711241722107,
0.9268154501914978,
-0.4534100890159607,
-0.02365999110043049,
0.08533458411693573,
-0.16140294075012207,
0.3865097761154175,
-0.16207647323608398,
0.14979147911071777,
0.05928146839141846,
-0.1905222237110138,
-0.14790992438793182,
-0.6616673469543457,
0.491590291261673,
-1.144046664237976,
-0.35429203510284424,
-0.5866912007331848,
-0.16220082342624664,
-0.1066024899482727,
-0.10063052922487259,
-0.09325158596038818,
0.03597412258386612,
0.16177985072135925,
0.18258997797966003,
0.8178848624229431,
-0.3687340021133423,
0.5000091791152954,
0.2006397396326065,
-0.2551470696926117,
-0.5639159679412842,
0.9498770833015442,
0.08335551619529724,
0.1320175975561142,
0.5819724798202515,
0.18065232038497925,
-0.5544267296791077,
-0.5970743298530579,
-0.5091432929039001,
0.03243448585271835,
-0.8510254621505737,
0.11652514338493347,
-1.0052015781402588,
-0.2651117742061615,
-0.43695268034935,
-0.3717673718929291,
-0.271712988615036,
-0.1412472128868103,
-0.2491583228111267,
-0.6659437417984009,
0.4301106631755829,
1.1329535245895386,
-0.08650995045900345,
0.7566747069358826,
-0.841106116771698,
0.555921733379364,
0.1402014046907425,
0.051511723548173904,
0.13248500227928162,
-0.19824087619781494,
0.07270140945911407,
-0.1196170523762703,
-0.33959296345710754,
-1.0056062936782837,
0.3141082525253296,
-0.7092519402503967,
0.27663758397102356,
0.48477137088775635,
0.22978384792804718,
0.4370269179344177,
-0.1967630684375763,
1.0101871490478516,
0.395214706659317,
-0.8110077381134033,
0.6518186330795288,
-0.4518805742263794,
-0.3803393542766571,
0.12189139425754547,
0.5658034086227417,
-0.3604283928871155,
-0.04770299047231674,
-0.5256586074829102,
-0.9850336909294128,
0.5466060638427734,
0.04254068806767464,
0.5504563450813293,
-0.2212274670600891,
-0.04320177808403969,
-0.06649678200483322,
0.4335237145423889,
-0.926249623298645,
-0.3074604272842407,
-0.47133180499076843,
-0.47861209511756897,
-0.3167787194252014,
-0.3543177545070648,
0.15986110270023346,
-0.049691516906023026,
0.5249167084693909,
0.0013028763933107257,
0.06171412765979767,
-0.22199298441410065,
0.05241352319717407,
-0.10744255036115646,
0.4311285614967346,
0.4312613010406494,
0.38174816966056824,
-0.5210309028625488,
0.22104321420192719,
0.06358042359352112,
-0.5229368209838867,
0.1463162899017334,
-0.1325206309556961,
-0.49450385570526123,
-0.026764903217554092,
0.013723290525376797,
0.39745986461639404,
0.10491470992565155,
-0.5904772877693176,
0.7855134606361389,
0.21548804640769958,
0.043044667690992355,
-0.8501703143119812,
-0.003120649140328169,
-0.012823040597140789,
0.21451589465141296,
0.3375648856163025,
0.5013598203659058,
0.31333205103874207,
-0.4399203360080719,
-0.09562063962221146,
0.37727752327919006,
-0.8267298340797424,
-0.533128023147583,
0.4465433359146118,
0.30132749676704407,
-0.4648212194442749,
0.4433844983577728,
-0.3132965862751007,
-0.8142203092575073,
0.6574637293815613,
0.17991222441196442,
0.8430982828140259,
0.10679202526807785,
0.850233793258667,
0.15428437292575836,
0.627178430557251,
-0.04992730915546417,
0.37267425656318665,
0.012727942317724228,
-0.8660661578178406,
0.03951177000999451,
-0.5095670223236084,
-0.3450837731361389,
0.04939701780676842,
-0.8242883682250977,
0.20853792130947113,
-1.0227898359298706,
-0.4296063482761383,
0.07588993012905121,
-0.10921970754861832,
-0.5507233142852783,
0.5583799481391907,
-0.1355220228433609,
0.30721986293792725,
-1.2516645193099976,
0.6321402192115784,
1.132504940032959,
-0.7238850593566895,
-0.44716325402259827,
0.25124499201774597,
0.08673152327537537,
-0.4409816265106201,
0.8826804161071777,
0.22649900615215302,
-0.4821895956993103,
-0.3701373338699341,
-0.33833563327789307,
-0.4202069938182831,
0.6525683999061584,
-0.2105855792760849,
-0.35859739780426025,
0.0340593047440052,
0.420589417219162,
0.7554819583892822,
-0.07196027785539627,
0.1829642802476883,
0.15685218572616577,
0.15662655234336853,
-0.0555562824010849,
-0.6781813502311707,
-0.055984966456890106,
-0.284778892993927,
0.2511190176010132,
0.2320975959300995,
-0.8631572723388672,
0.6181488633155823,
0.011719292961061,
0.2777486741542816,
-0.03510632365942001,
0.3733159303665161,
0.3071834444999695,
0.7477676868438721,
0.7542215585708618,
0.47972196340560913,
0.336245059967041,
0.07276488840579987,
1.0459222793579102,
-0.11582786589860916,
-0.0295132864266634,
0.7172514200210571,
-0.23814590275287628,
1.0001726150512695,
0.6206430196762085,
-0.4869714379310608,
0.6507607698440552,
0.3777150511741638,
0.0601477175951004,
0.799605667591095,
0.07693911343812943,
-0.1697130799293518,
0.028405193239450455,
-0.3968204855918884,
-0.1356627345085144,
0.24697920680046082,
0.39360302686691284,
-0.2791041135787964,
0.16293933987617493,
0.2967669665813446,
-0.19666071236133575,
0.20651322603225708,
-0.4807353615760803,
0.8909813761711121,
-0.11860239505767822,
-0.028119806200265884,
-0.5243812203407288,
0.09759055078029633,
0.677588939666748,
-0.1843419224023819,
0.0010255525121465325,
0.09983383119106293,
0.42101532220840454,
-0.4009380638599396,
-1.2304787635803223,
0.44532933831214905,
0.17524071037769318,
-0.48780393600463867,
-0.37970638275146484,
0.6802700757980347,
0.36437535285949707,
-0.5631015300750732,
0.5959043502807617,
0.1804848313331604,
0.1415262222290039,
0.16370920836925507,
-0.7346832156181335,
0.34230610728263855,
0.023661956191062927,
0.14545994997024536,
0.2279796302318573,
0.41240960359573364,
0.04725997895002365,
0.8194643259048462,
0.7251223921775818,
-0.0223793163895607,
0.18137818574905396,
0.1388595700263977,
0.7611936926841736,
-0.8013692498207092,
-0.5482132434844971,
-0.7629186511039734,
0.7016319632530212,
-0.045261748135089874,
-0.18244504928588867,
0.8743984699249268,
0.3420638144016266,
0.9428170323371887,
-0.35628241300582886,
0.8860815167427063,
-0.1811564713716507,
0.6569802761077881,
-0.27597635984420776,
0.3855880796909332,
-0.21818052232265472,
0.32436156272888184,
-0.8170502185821533,
-0.6833282113075256,
0.08456747233867645,
1.0004496574401855,
-0.5168789625167847,
0.16784872114658356,
0.11188343167304993,
0.5918309092521667,
0.0522703118622303,
-0.006279514171183109,
-0.09383370727300644,
-0.033316951245069504,
0.208440899848938,
0.23028813302516937,
1.0704617500305176,
-0.46408388018608093,
0.7023270130157471,
-0.7532530426979065,
0.1000254899263382,
-0.2049601823091507,
-0.6345564723014832,
-0.9328225255012512,
-0.3135409653186798,
-0.4407939314842224,
-0.6897035837173462,
0.27773401141166687,
0.9648064374923706,
0.7324193716049194,
-0.614874541759491,
-0.30167466402053833,
-0.35649317502975464,
0.35363540053367615,
0.013166505843400955,
-0.35541343688964844,
0.33014681935310364,
0.20574237406253815,
-0.5243430137634277,
0.02986077405512333,
0.3914719223976135,
0.1875559389591217,
-0.17676770687103271,
-0.1989762783050537,
0.08443554490804672,
-0.12321054935455322,
0.7214879393577576,
-0.07031318545341492,
-0.7410936951637268,
-0.6439160108566284,
0.18453603982925415,
0.042694807052612305,
-0.08395229279994965,
0.2642725110054016,
-0.73909592628479,
0.13026173412799835,
0.5645613670349121,
0.2906450927257538,
0.2911558151245117,
0.33173254132270813,
0.23394910991191864,
-0.5107077956199646,
0.026054801419377327,
0.18592937290668488,
0.165708526968956,
0.4789297878742218,
-0.24994762241840363,
0.549726665019989,
0.18515895307064056,
-0.40819618105888367,
-0.7137256860733032,
0.30685731768608093,
-1.1321097612380981,
-0.0489225760102272,
1.02360200881958,
0.17986436188220978,
-0.24788928031921387,
-0.23309114575386047,
-0.09502092003822327,
0.19267255067825317,
-0.6450616121292114,
0.9506190419197083,
0.30393126606941223,
0.06882665306329727,
-0.5405469536781311,
-0.8160316348075867,
0.14704155921936035,
0.05448306351900101,
-0.6387010216712952,
-0.3010246753692627,
0.42800089716911316,
0.2764967679977417,
0.3064475357532501,
0.7364926338195801,
0.06287775933742523,
0.2681317627429962,
-0.20468270778656006,
-0.1342388093471527,
0.2982001304626465,
-0.6024616956710815,
-0.3024146854877472,
0.4523316025733948,
-0.13317358493804932,
-0.40414977073669434
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09709v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09709v1
|
Exploratory Data Analysis on Code-mixed Misogynistic Comments
| 2024-03-09T23:21:17 | 2024-03-09T23:21:17 |
Sargam Yadav, Abhishek Kaushik, Kevin McDaid
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The problems of online hate speech and cyberbullying have significantly
worsened since the increase in popularity of social media platforms such as
YouTube and Twitter (X). Natural Language Processing (NLP) techniques have
proven to provide a great advantage in automatic filtering such toxic content.
Women are disproportionately more likely to be victims of online abuse.
However, there appears to be a lack of studies that tackle misogyny detection
in under-resourced languages. In this short paper, we present a novel dataset
of YouTube comments in mix-code Hinglish collected from YouTube videos which
have been weak labelled as `Misogynistic' and `Non-misogynistic'.
Pre-processing and Exploratory Data Analysis (EDA) techniques have been applied
on the dataset to gain insights on its characteristics. The process has
provided a better understanding of the dataset through sentiment scores, word
clouds, etc.
|
[
-0.5178841352462769,
-1.0510764122009277,
-0.2355472445487976,
0.27498725056648254,
-0.3663236200809479,
0.3416464924812317,
-0.12453728169202805,
-0.3666224777698517,
0.4466133415699005,
0.475511759519577,
-0.5338024497032166,
-0.2782926559448242,
-0.5237061381340027,
0.1813453882932663,
-0.6420564651489258,
1.1740574836730957,
0.13402427732944489,
0.32627514004707336,
0.03967687115073204,
-0.30951350927352905,
-0.6070569753646851,
-0.7201902866363525,
-0.0008430999587289989,
0.05928917974233627,
0.09422376751899719,
0.2772340178489685,
0.8214455842971802,
0.3697693943977356,
0.46061867475509644,
0.2069229930639267,
-0.16192269325256348,
0.1059352234005928,
-0.8117051720619202,
0.16690070927143097,
-0.1963275521993637,
-0.33114829659461975,
-0.10868775844573975,
0.003333693603053689,
0.1632181704044342,
0.500137448310852,
-0.07625088095664978,
0.32672449946403503,
0.4000711739063263,
0.37094348669052124,
-0.7012232542037964,
-0.025048421695828438,
-0.5036296248435974,
0.4036911427974701,
-0.14571897685527802,
-0.45951125025749207,
-0.0179270152002573,
-0.49913060665130615,
-0.0011661597527563572,
-0.2262575775384903,
0.3036647140979767,
-0.22502277791500092,
0.3858254849910736,
0.2694624662399292,
-0.2734663188457489,
-0.6592270135879517,
-0.9235775470733643,
1.0117428302764893,
-0.8053823709487915,
0.2908177971839905,
0.37074634432792664,
0.10168051719665527,
-0.038255441933870316,
-0.17110112309455872,
-0.44740623235702515,
0.18673357367515564,
-0.12968197464942932,
-0.17381003499031067,
-0.39188435673713684,
-0.2102893888950348,
0.20812740921974182,
0.37924134731292725,
-0.5724416971206665,
0.14850619435310364,
-0.4233958125114441,
-0.0533297061920166,
0.45864441990852356,
-0.23423828184604645,
0.6617167592048645,
-0.5669265389442444,
-0.07762284576892853,
0.18713824450969696,
-0.40604421496391296,
-0.06759314984083176,
0.8526068925857544,
0.4972285032272339,
-0.19255399703979492,
0.6398257613182068,
-0.034333594143390656,
0.5045544505119324,
-0.1421496570110321,
-0.19666367769241333,
0.4327039122581482,
-0.44263756275177,
-0.3348402678966522,
-0.028712080791592598,
0.7287364602088928,
0.3346346616744995,
0.6258283853530884,
0.18563400208950043,
0.02667529694736004,
0.5411943793296814,
0.37156882882118225,
-0.6609939336776733,
-0.35700976848602295,
0.021841056644916534,
-0.6784966588020325,
-0.546119213104248,
-0.16720937192440033,
-1.4162871837615967,
-0.5693709850311279,
-0.2247244268655777,
0.01771561987698078,
-0.03190440684556961,
-0.7006772756576538,
-0.029128221794962883,
-0.23790648579597473,
0.12049048393964767,
0.04316423460841179,
-0.5304657220840454,
0.3251652419567108,
0.3845899701118469,
0.5447153449058533,
0.08222851157188416,
0.21764184534549713,
-0.47405052185058594,
-0.3788292109966278,
-0.18559932708740234,
0.4532347023487091,
-0.8117936849594116,
-0.19404800236225128,
0.5195088982582092,
-0.24536290764808655,
0.03201417624950409,
-0.7697744965553284,
0.6247278451919556,
-0.43065640330314636,
0.37438279390335083,
-0.10827191919088364,
-0.28736451268196106,
-0.09570607542991638,
0.25888150930404663,
-0.7190788984298706,
1.3540937900543213,
-0.0012780909892171621,
-1.065150499343872,
0.3958197832107544,
-0.4232279062271118,
-0.40193092823028564,
-0.0863337591290474,
-0.3141186833381653,
-0.2512081265449524,
-0.057409271597862244,
0.3951534032821655,
0.26552698016166687,
-0.10920403897762299,
0.45156341791152954,
-0.6146414875984192,
-0.1819169670343399,
0.35593992471694946,
-0.27678853273391724,
0.722407877445221,
0.2364862710237503,
-0.6519924998283386,
-0.006520177237689495,
-0.7222890853881836,
0.17558878660202026,
-0.05385371297597885,
-0.04321671277284622,
-0.5797079801559448,
0.008279232308268547,
0.3953689932823181,
0.6654510498046875,
-0.09923163801431656,
-0.4182177186012268,
-0.2190653681755066,
-0.09393861889839172,
0.3210984766483307,
0.6607385873794556,
-0.12599116563796997,
0.09340841323137283,
0.1350628286600113,
0.8311795592308044,
-0.033432867377996445,
0.12046970427036285,
0.3374471664428711,
-0.6235988140106201,
-0.600913941860199,
-0.019496269524097443,
-0.010592793114483356,
0.46941694617271423,
-1.0756981372833252,
0.16620101034641266,
-0.0678863376379013,
-0.1387317031621933,
-0.5282185673713684,
0.4393968880176544,
0.6901780366897583,
0.09214559197425842,
0.5300019979476929,
-0.1590081751346588,
-1.100475549697876,
-0.923559844493866,
-0.44670888781547546,
-0.09251963347196579,
0.19465035200119019,
0.37404167652130127,
0.4996013939380646,
-0.2703597843647003,
0.8461288809776306,
-0.4687404930591583,
-0.24391740560531616,
-0.4342336654663086,
0.49690231680870056,
-0.016299687325954437,
0.15449358522891998,
0.45875102281570435,
-1.0204704999923706,
-0.5795759558677673,
-0.24604405462741852,
-0.8954097032546997,
-0.36282843351364136,
0.21056397259235382,
-0.24175387620925903,
-0.285330593585968,
0.4738689661026001,
-0.021885458379983902,
0.4241945147514343,
0.7309395670890808,
-0.33925193548202515,
0.49407926201820374,
0.3080466091632843,
0.3589138984680176,
-0.7332856059074402,
-0.1667853742837906,
0.34404677152633667,
-0.256347119808197,
-0.6813159584999084,
0.12206090986728668,
-0.2261912226676941,
-0.043916258960962296,
-0.38259708881378174,
-0.10912200063467026,
-0.37320253252983093,
-0.03758549690246582,
-0.41384729743003845,
-0.07031281292438507,
-0.5252238512039185,
0.5620462894439697,
0.062479473650455475,
0.5527485609054565,
0.23609307408332825,
-0.44133901596069336,
0.30222123861312866,
0.19527427852153778,
-0.010136320255696774,
0.5490242838859558,
-0.45166128873825073,
0.3169037401676178,
-0.1445329189300537,
-0.12508565187454224,
-0.9622120261192322,
-0.1957678198814392,
0.10948649793863297,
-0.436927855014801,
-0.012235105969011784,
-0.3731668293476105,
-0.5949143171310425,
-0.30908170342445374,
-0.6986027956008911,
0.5327481627464294,
0.2256324142217636,
-0.4391326308250427,
0.26720955967903137,
0.9902321100234985,
-0.18073385953903198,
-0.6092272996902466,
-0.4503271281719208,
0.04676458612084389,
-0.34210458397865295,
-0.5650395750999451,
0.19521814584732056,
-0.15907733142375946,
-0.5187810063362122,
0.07817979902029037,
0.1369500458240509,
-0.5404290556907654,
-0.24906978011131287,
0.11374231427907944,
0.2935357689857483,
-0.14694596827030182,
-0.27126261591911316,
-0.2192072570323944,
0.4129491150379181,
0.0945005938410759,
0.32873743772506714,
0.8611718416213989,
0.02136218175292015,
0.251008003950119,
-0.03501112014055252,
0.6007158756256104,
0.26185739040374756,
0.0019676496740430593,
0.679663360118866,
0.7675294280052185,
-0.4460410475730896,
-0.4947471022605896,
-0.27826616168022156,
-0.02949296496808529,
-0.3948683738708496,
0.3755645751953125,
0.013838659971952438,
-0.876062273979187,
0.4717346727848053,
0.5006617307662964,
-0.1361369639635086,
0.17625975608825684,
0.5319811105728149,
-0.10942795872688293,
0.9722119569778442,
0.8201283812522888,
-0.3754773736000061,
0.5533850789070129,
-0.07696399092674255,
0.3888414204120636,
-0.38899511098861694,
0.043816931545734406,
-0.6042922735214233,
-0.25336378812789917,
-1.146162509918213,
-0.24446700513362885,
0.13645018637180328,
-0.09793739020824432,
0.10564737021923065,
0.46050626039505005,
-0.3794907033443451,
0.2592104375362396,
0.16286656260490417,
0.10054180026054382,
0.19591282308101654,
0.01873038522899151,
0.15142542123794556,
-0.5360740423202515,
-0.661853551864624,
-0.3059379756450653,
1.1772876977920532,
0.27984851598739624,
0.7753450870513916,
0.4457016587257385,
0.37817031145095825,
0.8275883197784424,
0.22594140470027924,
-0.5113435983657837,
0.4692668318748474,
-0.2647092640399933,
-0.7953746318817139,
0.08892795443534851,
-0.6012622117996216,
-0.7565853595733643,
0.2717841863632202,
-0.2354203760623932,
-0.564214289188385,
0.042282018810510635,
0.06129331886768341,
-0.20792388916015625,
0.30571240186691284,
-0.6287055611610413,
0.6566448211669922,
-0.006908690556883812,
-0.6243632435798645,
-0.18046429753303528,
-0.39263656735420227,
0.6395707726478577,
-0.01594565063714981,
0.7093091607093811,
0.16417469084262848,
0.4850987195968628,
1.0253957509994507,
-0.3568601906299591,
0.9554218649864197,
-0.18527692556381226,
-0.23758363723754883,
0.22622737288475037,
-0.19861945509910583,
0.1963518261909485,
-0.2916944622993469,
0.44546201825141907,
-0.013619438745081425,
-0.20388150215148926,
-0.18972943723201752,
-0.3416597247123718,
0.7642732262611389,
-0.7483338713645935,
-0.0886683538556099,
-0.258053183555603,
-0.25997236371040344,
-0.24972926080226898,
0.028917411342263222,
0.07489030808210373,
0.4858212172985077,
0.02192002534866333,
0.3356199860572815,
0.7772814631462097,
-0.4401285946369171,
0.24764487147331238,
0.22525283694267273,
-0.4939543306827545,
-0.38395026326179504,
0.7911360859870911,
0.2942737936973572,
-0.08732172101736069,
0.08690817654132843,
0.08329760283231735,
-0.3073892891407013,
-0.22578445076942444,
-0.5000337362289429,
0.16297253966331482,
-0.7992562651634216,
-0.026716720312833786,
-0.5887342095375061,
-0.14445847272872925,
-0.46812722086906433,
0.08302310109138489,
-0.33422720432281494,
0.025286130607128143,
-0.25054633617401123,
-0.17845971882343292,
0.09048434346914291,
0.9311708807945251,
0.31564298272132874,
0.12546801567077637,
-0.5004010796546936,
0.8868922591209412,
0.22674641013145447,
0.4447889029979706,
-0.121126689016819,
-0.5888544917106628,
-0.19828206300735474,
-0.0839584693312645,
-0.1566689908504486,
-1.3547567129135132,
0.7002684473991394,
-0.01549503393471241,
0.4100935161113739,
0.23892733454704285,
-0.08864837139844894,
0.7856737971305847,
0.07096630334854126,
0.7008529901504517,
0.01439766027033329,
-0.6994025707244873,
0.559222936630249,
-0.48585397005081177,
-0.25323596596717834,
0.27706435322761536,
0.3909263014793396,
-0.5561341643333435,
-0.4111105799674988,
-0.670975923538208,
-0.900877058506012,
0.4717245101928711,
0.6040275692939758,
0.10769664496183395,
0.07496717572212219,
-0.15089234709739685,
0.27597999572753906,
0.5869551301002502,
-1.0300815105438232,
-0.618719756603241,
-0.2452969253063202,
-0.07711592316627502,
0.1512177437543869,
-0.5379276275634766,
0.11405277252197266,
-0.19635997712612152,
0.777571976184845,
-0.049799494445323944,
0.20706415176391602,
-0.40057802200317383,
-0.4916080832481384,
-0.09878839552402496,
0.4686492085456848,
0.22622139751911163,
0.44454267621040344,
-0.42426565289497375,
0.12890173494815826,
-0.27191776037216187,
-0.6378315687179565,
0.130393847823143,
0.03464896231889725,
-0.26803696155548096,
0.2932891249656677,
0.29421770572662354,
0.39567989110946655,
0.3660871684551239,
-0.7019608020782471,
0.5448879599571228,
0.000900307553820312,
0.16225942969322205,
-0.33104032278060913,
-0.11766151338815689,
-0.2673671543598175,
-0.14884339272975922,
0.368690550327301,
0.12780258059501648,
0.4148929715156555,
-0.9287804961204529,
0.3044041395187378,
0.384133517742157,
-0.4748818278312683,
-0.2965857684612274,
0.3563985526561737,
0.4111804664134979,
-0.058441970497369766,
0.2558690011501312,
-0.31442850828170776,
-0.6707773208618164,
0.43631675839424133,
0.42760366201400757,
0.9094641208648682,
-0.016297582536935806,
0.43661025166511536,
0.3646743893623352,
0.33857303857803345,
0.11541733145713806,
0.5792502164840698,
-0.008386272937059402,
-0.91488116979599,
-0.3985522985458374,
-0.4933156371116638,
-0.10564501583576202,
0.4580099880695343,
-0.9810047745704651,
0.4475793242454529,
-0.5370646119117737,
-0.08981006592512131,
0.15558935701847076,
-0.21305280923843384,
-0.8252553343772888,
0.29435357451438904,
0.32602670788764954,
0.30007675290107727,
-1.1911075115203857,
0.6086955070495605,
0.5281195044517517,
-0.38816654682159424,
-0.6052904725074768,
-0.10329549759626389,
0.24537542462348938,
-0.5601800084114075,
0.5260833501815796,
0.3161454200744629,
-0.2214977890253067,
-0.32673215866088867,
-0.4675297737121582,
-0.5488285422325134,
0.15018005669116974,
0.12023306638002396,
-0.23753713071346283,
0.20097798109054565,
0.422791987657547,
0.8413439393043518,
-0.2551642656326294,
0.5048884749412537,
0.8294379711151123,
0.1571865826845169,
-0.3668306767940521,
-1.0159908533096313,
-0.21656519174575806,
-0.8676692247390747,
-0.1748572289943695,
0.3007446527481079,
-0.14344793558120728,
0.827544093132019,
0.302141010761261,
-0.17727389931678772,
-0.383057177066803,
0.41051116585731506,
0.010814514011144638,
0.28371790051460266,
0.4156428575515747,
0.4453887641429901,
0.48662206530570984,
0.13367673754692078,
0.7495171427726746,
0.15681672096252441,
0.43164533376693726,
1.0971461534500122,
-0.1313903033733368,
0.6992254853248596,
0.4623495638370514,
-0.476778507232666,
0.7179543375968933,
0.3603856861591339,
0.1623736321926117,
0.2821095883846283,
0.24242593348026276,
0.04571036621928215,
0.064646415412426,
-0.4302113950252533,
-0.2928679883480072,
0.5474408864974976,
0.17613114416599274,
-0.5781571865081787,
-0.20008820295333862,
0.16053882241249084,
0.20180922746658325,
0.28165170550346375,
-0.48091328144073486,
0.7065284252166748,
-0.1905442625284195,
-0.4060254395008087,
0.5171300172805786,
0.044550176709890366,
1.3500854969024658,
-0.4292290508747101,
-0.1879071593284607,
-0.15426458418369293,
0.04130842164158821,
-0.588584840297699,
-0.7154760956764221,
0.26197054982185364,
0.6907044053077698,
-0.33844301104545593,
-0.1611092984676361,
0.6998425722122192,
-0.5382638573646545,
-0.45572659373283386,
0.5780439972877502,
0.7141594290733337,
0.0020487343426793814,
-0.17469795048236847,
-0.611109733581543,
-0.045439738780260086,
0.4589616358280182,
0.17119067907333374,
0.3356267809867859,
0.18176238238811493,
-0.15457426011562347,
0.4517142176628113,
0.6431905031204224,
0.049619562923908234,
0.4586928188800812,
0.30641406774520874,
0.9426432847976685,
-0.8354766368865967,
-0.7712468504905701,
-0.869263768196106,
0.2644575834274292,
-0.2730208933353424,
-0.4630894958972931,
1.1237677335739136,
0.5354111194610596,
1.0638816356658936,
-0.014900339767336845,
0.9732435941696167,
-0.21174989640712738,
0.7238594889640808,
-0.39920908212661743,
0.231008380651474,
-0.17605005204677582,
0.3238120377063751,
-0.7863690257072449,
-0.7372965216636658,
-0.07131636887788773,
0.4717211425304413,
-0.25789010524749756,
0.17389415204524994,
0.3931238353252411,
0.7512804269790649,
-0.31651055812835693,
0.37626126408576965,
0.19866158068180084,
0.258210152387619,
0.374895304441452,
0.12763477861881256,
0.8960850238800049,
-0.38093769550323486,
0.6451898813247681,
-0.4557933211326599,
-0.07803590595722198,
-0.3621169626712799,
-0.6265830993652344,
-0.9915478825569153,
-0.11422105133533478,
-0.43843820691108704,
-0.5081161260604858,
-0.18872617185115814,
0.9852880239486694,
0.5231194496154785,
-0.8313983082771301,
-0.27437183260917664,
0.001968790777027607,
0.020023640245199203,
-0.17447784543037415,
-0.34469369053840637,
0.012020080350339413,
0.08458829671144485,
-0.6784968972206116,
0.09196575731039047,
0.07406607270240784,
-0.3589267134666443,
-0.5958395004272461,
0.021502824500203133,
-0.3362405002117157,
0.08088844269514084,
0.5399900674819946,
0.049243953078985214,
-0.24396108090877533,
-0.001989456359297037,
0.11139888316392899,
-0.04830653965473175,
0.22287487983703613,
1.0774543285369873,
-0.5930984020233154,
0.7108641266822815,
0.567255973815918,
0.34820637106895447,
0.29756906628608704,
0.09007085859775543,
0.449924498796463,
-0.9281997084617615,
0.17490434646606445,
0.3316749930381775,
0.4543581008911133,
0.6221171617507935,
-0.37473562359809875,
0.3474361300468445,
0.5027154684066772,
-0.0871126800775528,
-0.8909164071083069,
0.061851177364587784,
-0.6501408815383911,
-0.28639131784439087,
1.3607251644134521,
0.00011171228834427893,
-0.03710189834237099,
-0.4792063534259796,
-0.22263360023498535,
0.34750890731811523,
-0.6221478581428528,
0.8600490093231201,
0.816400945186615,
-0.10559853166341782,
-0.11188570410013199,
-0.8813490271568298,
0.587572455406189,
0.31211569905281067,
-0.9221761226654053,
-0.12597140669822693,
0.6312083601951599,
0.23814509809017181,
0.11968012154102325,
0.4463081359863281,
-0.01912529580295086,
0.23233602941036224,
-0.11577644944190979,
-0.07312440127134323,
0.2511647939682007,
-0.2668669819831848,
-0.45429709553718567,
0.4787319600582123,
-0.5193750858306885,
-0.12717314064502716
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06023v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06023v1
|
Persian Slang Text Conversion to Formal and Deep Learning of Persian Short Texts on Social Media for Sentiment Classification
| 2024-03-09T22:18:26 | 2024-03-09T22:18:26 |
Mohsen Khazeni, Mohammad Heydari, Amir Albadvi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The lack of a suitable tool for the analysis of conversational texts in the
Persian language has made various analyses of these texts, including Sentiment
Analysis, difficult. In this research, we tried to make the understanding of
these texts easier for the machine by providing PSC, Persian Slang Converter, a
tool for converting conversational texts into formal ones, and by using the
most up-to-date and best deep learning methods along with the PSC, the
sentiment learning of short Persian language texts for the machine in a better
way. be made More than 10 million unlabeled texts from various social networks
and movie subtitles (as Conversational texts) and about 10 million news texts
(as formal texts) have been used for training unsupervised models and formal
implementation of the tool. 60,000 texts from the comments of Instagram social
network users with positive, negative, and neutral labels are considered
supervised data for training the emotion classification model of short texts.
Using the formal tool, 57% of the words of the corpus of conversation were
converted. Finally, by using the formalizer, FastText model, and deep LSTM
network, an accuracy of 81.91 was obtained on the test data.
|
[
-0.38031110167503357,
-0.7868764996528625,
0.5924113392829895,
0.1132015734910965,
-0.8416966795921326,
0.6028427481651306,
-0.596006453037262,
-0.35390764474868774,
0.44135546684265137,
0.29217299818992615,
-0.45857539772987366,
-0.8647851347923279,
-0.6474205255508423,
0.26806768774986267,
-0.5341596007347107,
1.4438239336013794,
-0.020960209891200066,
0.275302916765213,
-0.09650207310914993,
0.10795961320400238,
0.08022253215312958,
-0.6061739325523376,
-0.5342792868614197,
0.09655451774597168,
0.3667151629924774,
0.8041645884513855,
0.7448874115943909,
-0.40728601813316345,
0.70009446144104,
0.29794713854789734,
-0.015455340966582298,
0.2606525421142578,
-0.4834790825843811,
0.0376167930662632,
-0.2501695454120636,
-0.07405364513397217,
-0.29160141944885254,
0.0073462361469864845,
0.487775593996048,
0.2931858003139496,
0.14982303977012634,
0.508388340473175,
0.1277703493833542,
0.8538471460342407,
-0.4345872700214386,
0.11409912258386612,
-0.3109571039676666,
0.1776898205280304,
-0.5235540270805359,
-0.2780471444129944,
-0.19171477854251862,
-0.8273729085922241,
-0.08762635290622711,
-0.14291644096374512,
0.06838612258434296,
-0.18709126114845276,
0.8777599334716797,
-0.058111127465963364,
-0.5519389510154724,
-0.22669033706188202,
-1.0761024951934814,
0.8072654604911804,
-0.8318322896957397,
0.15530428290367126,
0.2103491723537445,
0.5306642651557922,
0.03503336384892464,
-0.6920996308326721,
-0.7756932377815247,
-0.27918732166290283,
-0.048818133771419525,
0.16331607103347778,
-0.16410201787948608,
0.06808619201183319,
-0.0164991095662117,
0.6579742431640625,
-0.2943849563598633,
-0.16926690936088562,
-0.6874918937683105,
0.15193893015384674,
0.9301312565803528,
0.07731630653142929,
0.3409615755081177,
-0.3355257511138916,
-0.18513253331184387,
-0.07234834879636765,
-0.3507053554058075,
0.10115258395671844,
0.3081018626689911,
0.2524476647377014,
-0.18694494664669037,
0.5649926662445068,
-0.43972691893577576,
0.16805221140384674,
0.27955496311187744,
-0.20120902359485626,
0.505023181438446,
-0.49485287070274353,
-0.27873238921165466,
0.16860729455947876,
1.114483118057251,
0.511284589767456,
0.5482535362243652,
0.07949947565793991,
-0.1833062767982483,
0.18502825498580933,
0.25596675276756287,
-0.8156651854515076,
-0.030934909358620644,
0.009150967933237553,
-0.49665483832359314,
-0.5322069525718689,
0.01092173159122467,
-0.7604565024375916,
-0.4783884584903717,
-0.1581186056137085,
-0.06350722908973694,
-0.4609733819961548,
-0.041562940925359726,
0.2912043631076813,
0.03521900251507759,
0.17823021113872528,
0.41595813632011414,
-0.41870012879371643,
0.49187934398651123,
0.4310840666294098,
0.974371612071991,
0.13515320420265198,
0.22719022631645203,
-0.04778166860342026,
-0.30633068084716797,
-0.4501289427280426,
0.8700841665267944,
-0.34808677434921265,
-0.378315806388855,
0.033848635852336884,
-0.09185352921485901,
-0.014267045073211193,
-0.0263340026140213,
1.1497554779052734,
-0.4521001875400543,
0.5083682537078857,
0.20065012574195862,
-0.5013221502304077,
-0.4530421197414398,
0.09720815718173981,
-0.31644877791404724,
1.0811564922332764,
0.12317917495965958,
-0.8073983192443848,
0.01499796099960804,
-0.6352188587188721,
-0.4635333716869354,
0.21556422114372253,
0.20572835206985474,
-0.4362495243549347,
0.3135787546634674,
0.18694636225700378,
0.9442335963249207,
-0.4898103177547455,
0.3044179081916809,
-0.3610023260116577,
-0.4253237545490265,
0.6978810429573059,
-0.044242966920137405,
0.37571030855178833,
0.513437807559967,
-0.377118319272995,
0.3008720278739929,
-0.5400430560112,
0.17570646107196808,
0.06033109501004219,
-0.04615500196814537,
-0.4714486300945282,
0.10509742051362991,
0.33261236548423767,
0.5859123468399048,
0.07920006662607193,
-0.6581698656082153,
-0.06955798715353012,
-0.7889922857284546,
0.3258497416973114,
0.5312286615371704,
0.184920072555542,
0.5353631377220154,
0.1148729994893074,
0.5239627361297607,
-0.08932467550039291,
0.18445874750614166,
0.34233221411705017,
-0.38127806782722473,
-0.6745691895484924,
0.1826741099357605,
0.045079443603754044,
0.41998785734176636,
-0.6223400831222534,
0.5555993318557739,
-0.3478803336620331,
-0.9147739410400391,
-0.34738826751708984,
0.14366842806339264,
0.48933953046798706,
0.3723932206630707,
0.22333811223506927,
-0.49467572569847107,
-0.48030340671539307,
-0.8083871603012085,
-0.5217981338500977,
-0.040128882974386215,
0.12868954241275787,
0.24770644307136536,
0.4066162109375,
-0.43633556365966797,
0.516876220703125,
-0.3676958978176117,
-0.43176525831222534,
-0.6189031004905701,
0.11191243678331375,
0.3658996522426605,
0.32434138655662537,
0.6560314893722534,
-0.6422462463378906,
-1.083337664604187,
0.1765919029712677,
-0.37891408801078796,
0.12205846607685089,
-0.16946066915988922,
-0.2003873884677887,
0.17638717591762543,
0.6738156080245972,
-0.390068382024765,
0.40071985125541687,
0.5931907296180725,
-0.3323901891708374,
0.6204365491867065,
0.3744755983352661,
0.42387667298316956,
-1.2914782762527466,
-0.10520573705434799,
0.38344767689704895,
-0.3963618874549866,
-0.8463456630706787,
-0.11014761030673981,
-0.059343308210372925,
-0.18940725922584534,
-0.6645128726959229,
0.524087131023407,
-0.3201669454574585,
0.291072279214859,
-0.19271154701709747,
0.08514277637004852,
-0.11686093360185623,
0.5105780363082886,
-0.1350271850824356,
0.6875619292259216,
0.6331527233123779,
-0.5744141936302185,
0.6116899847984314,
0.2642211318016052,
-0.488908976316452,
0.20538990199565887,
-0.5018728375434875,
0.3846336901187897,
-0.20913487672805786,
0.2573872208595276,
-0.9471964240074158,
-0.31024008989334106,
0.7475728988647461,
-0.562137246131897,
0.01651129126548767,
-0.04952800273895264,
-0.6005685925483704,
-0.33777517080307007,
-0.5158970355987549,
0.26323628425598145,
0.531683087348938,
-0.2506686747074127,
0.3678094446659088,
0.45412418246269226,
-0.06344933062791824,
-0.08321559429168701,
-0.5449162721633911,
0.18129800260066986,
-0.2855406701564789,
-0.5983129739761353,
0.33784720301628113,
0.08815482258796692,
-0.30336788296699524,
0.006859259679913521,
0.038791850209236145,
-0.3113672733306885,
-0.1182427704334259,
0.2794836759567261,
0.08689282089471817,
-0.20869454741477966,
0.28205427527427673,
0.37419238686561584,
0.04084281995892525,
0.11279702186584473,
0.0293879471719265,
0.6626365780830383,
-0.5543275475502014,
-0.017544301226735115,
-0.7066859006881714,
0.25995221734046936,
0.4848782420158386,
-0.00541454553604126,
0.9305248260498047,
0.707182765007019,
-0.22766630351543427,
-0.04263760894536972,
-0.26873070001602173,
-0.07213608920574188,
-0.4450254738330841,
0.2734368145465851,
-0.06309796124696732,
-0.8414300680160522,
0.08788187801837921,
-0.2506152391433716,
-0.22915279865264893,
0.5678048729896545,
0.33171528577804565,
-0.12318155914545059,
1.1167080402374268,
0.5515968203544617,
-0.12130173295736313,
0.49890175461769104,
0.08897816389799118,
0.421644389629364,
-0.2867414653301239,
-0.08553994446992874,
-0.49803847074508667,
-0.4141417443752289,
-0.63492751121521,
-0.38403162360191345,
0.29045602679252625,
-0.10280641168355942,
-0.1409328579902649,
0.15958018600940704,
-0.362714558839798,
0.49819454550743103,
0.3907003402709961,
0.29266396164894104,
0.1627468317747116,
0.33914536237716675,
0.2806112766265869,
-0.22202645242214203,
-0.22058448195457458,
-0.6159868240356445,
0.7221419215202332,
0.3860696852207184,
0.7037025094032288,
0.007091026287525892,
0.7649630904197693,
0.40585482120513916,
-0.039191119372844696,
-1.1554651260375977,
0.6681564450263977,
-0.5871428847312927,
-0.3564254343509674,
-0.09191164374351501,
-0.153423011302948,
-0.42188888788223267,
-0.2708132565021515,
-0.31411129236221313,
-0.4658343195915222,
0.2074217051267624,
-0.03513774275779724,
-0.2809794247150421,
0.19774585962295532,
-0.6161521673202515,
0.7792133688926697,
-0.35580208897590637,
-0.07494276016950607,
-0.5681015849113464,
-0.6689497232437134,
0.5866273045539856,
-0.04536009207367897,
0.22031152248382568,
-0.28893736004829407,
0.11927977949380875,
0.8900085687637329,
-0.5039022564888,
1.039154052734375,
0.08583644032478333,
0.099520742893219,
0.3398336172103882,
0.13574591279029846,
0.2907862365245819,
0.05556522682309151,
0.17336344718933105,
0.31557294726371765,
-0.2268848866224289,
-0.24365025758743286,
-0.4242876172065735,
0.6124873757362366,
-0.7935018539428711,
-0.36399951577186584,
-0.73164963722229,
0.13276176154613495,
-0.4136736989021301,
0.056763872504234314,
0.16963090002536774,
0.2940651774406433,
-0.4683889150619507,
0.2787598669528961,
0.468705415725708,
-0.19548507034778595,
0.2043462097644806,
0.08532069623470306,
-0.146712526679039,
-0.2402607798576355,
0.674415647983551,
-0.4433746635913849,
0.07321792840957642,
0.28326722979545593,
0.2753234803676605,
-0.23437508940696716,
-0.36302241683006287,
-0.2936001718044281,
0.24825520813465118,
-0.6732057332992554,
-0.3193858861923218,
-0.5105890035629272,
-0.3426857888698578,
-0.5936293005943298,
-0.2390655130147934,
-0.511379599571228,
-0.41868630051612854,
-0.584938645362854,
-0.14025752246379852,
0.7362155318260193,
0.7494714856147766,
0.14049549400806427,
0.5877029895782471,
-1.1665270328521729,
0.12385962158441544,
-0.08979658782482147,
0.13406595587730408,
-0.37834101915359497,
-0.5316662192344666,
-0.5415960550308228,
0.02487259916961193,
-0.20873324573040009,
-1.2679368257522583,
0.8812142014503479,
0.601060688495636,
-0.31408682465553284,
0.6436465978622437,
0.02370270900428295,
0.6952522397041321,
-0.34419602155685425,
0.6989457607269287,
0.4224277138710022,
-1.1180697679519653,
0.620821475982666,
-0.2529022693634033,
0.08622585237026215,
0.6437620520591736,
0.6393862962722778,
-1.0505783557891846,
-0.34603434801101685,
-0.5137972831726074,
-0.809874951839447,
0.6771261096000671,
0.09211933612823486,
0.47154501080513,
0.027482446283102036,
0.41434261202812195,
-0.0029181495774537325,
0.2586839497089386,
-0.6375998854637146,
-0.2925913333892822,
-0.2366512268781662,
-0.3147331178188324,
-0.43434008955955505,
-0.44371116161346436,
0.11155279725790024,
-0.5458386540412903,
0.7741568088531494,
-0.09722182154655457,
0.1153111681342125,
0.027117125689983368,
-0.1547514945268631,
-0.15492229163646698,
0.6301850080490112,
0.3246038258075714,
0.20392414927482605,
-0.043150413781404495,
0.0051980153657495975,
0.1911657601594925,
-0.6235483288764954,
-0.05030566081404686,
-0.13856588304042816,
-0.1472102552652359,
0.28888222575187683,
-0.14454385638237,
0.7950765490531921,
0.38762956857681274,
-0.6444385647773743,
0.5439457297325134,
-0.363411545753479,
-0.0703374370932579,
-0.7074646949768066,
-0.021897777915000916,
-0.029859310016036034,
0.09665463119745255,
0.18089337646961212,
0.4355373978614807,
0.49341630935668945,
-0.640072226524353,
-0.09902235865592957,
0.3452985882759094,
-0.7237185835838318,
-0.45304638147354126,
0.10350010544061661,
0.19004622101783752,
0.06753289699554443,
0.20312534272670746,
-0.46616631746292114,
-0.7663180828094482,
0.13179679214954376,
0.27080482244491577,
1.0992316007614136,
-0.1414920538663864,
0.8186556100845337,
0.5199583172798157,
-0.10216746479272842,
-0.14959678053855896,
0.2580541670322418,
-0.08419562131166458,
-0.5912565588951111,
-0.42876774072647095,
-0.9115660786628723,
-0.3255818784236908,
0.0445234477519989,
-0.4488784670829773,
0.39985355734825134,
-0.8071098923683167,
-0.13854463398456573,
-0.1855112910270691,
0.14251597225666046,
-0.4674127399921417,
0.3479166030883789,
0.19816948473453522,
0.49838393926620483,
-0.9270671606063843,
0.8600220084190369,
0.9076220393180847,
-0.3996109664440155,
-0.9150252342224121,
-0.027104856446385384,
-0.04661044105887413,
-0.3427696228027344,
0.6835293173789978,
0.04693947732448578,
-0.4751790463924408,
-0.003012225264683366,
-0.8031566143035889,
-0.7974354028701782,
0.4183586537837982,
0.009217229671776295,
-0.7122046947479248,
0.09204059094190598,
0.1932705193758011,
0.9116503596305847,
-0.2623208165168762,
0.1526918113231659,
0.4207039773464203,
0.2712516784667969,
-0.13107837736606598,
-0.8979503512382507,
0.1591118574142456,
-0.5917854905128479,
-0.12307010591030121,
0.24047988653182983,
-0.4541037380695343,
0.8727655410766602,
0.12379341572523117,
-0.7661939859390259,
0.06080402433872223,
0.8052542805671692,
-0.21436485648155212,
0.39162224531173706,
0.33951282501220703,
0.12801729142665863,
0.48586103320121765,
0.0051649464294314384,
0.8808320760726929,
-0.201486274600029,
0.31709662079811096,
0.7165449261665344,
0.03022424690425396,
0.8788111805915833,
0.301624059677124,
-0.011631987057626247,
1.0637869834899902,
0.6341930627822876,
0.14656300842761993,
0.41805800795555115,
0.06422580033540726,
-0.5004916787147522,
-0.28844138979911804,
-0.11665693670511246,
-0.2955087125301361,
0.39969536662101746,
0.5562237501144409,
-0.42819374799728394,
-0.14251808822155,
0.06679137051105499,
0.31480419635772705,
0.42637041211128235,
-0.4922875761985779,
0.946159303188324,
0.16789686679840088,
-0.23427072167396545,
0.4122728109359741,
0.35954469442367554,
0.9206936359405518,
-0.39240381121635437,
0.2942301332950592,
-0.19632941484451294,
0.420673131942749,
-0.5648117661476135,
-0.8118028044700623,
0.40779009461402893,
0.16055941581726074,
0.11004181951284409,
-0.3079582154750824,
1.1989448070526123,
-0.22249585390090942,
-0.6648979187011719,
0.06550559401512146,
0.5858549475669861,
0.36471468210220337,
-0.3657865822315216,
-0.8083056807518005,
-0.4374164342880249,
-0.12530343234539032,
0.017004862427711487,
0.3114381432533264,
0.4802102744579315,
-0.058998264372348785,
0.3565654158592224,
0.7673535943031311,
0.08659321069717407,
-0.1292680948972702,
0.2154071033000946,
1.076278567314148,
-0.9538238644599915,
-0.5768564343452454,
-0.9090002775192261,
0.2651243507862091,
-0.2571721374988556,
-0.4127809405326843,
1.2953433990478516,
0.3005776107311249,
0.6968862414360046,
-0.4066738486289978,
0.6060182452201843,
-0.09749630838632584,
0.7843623161315918,
-0.4643302261829376,
0.8645961284637451,
-0.657806396484375,
-0.03605329617857933,
-0.584782600402832,
-0.5947195887565613,
-0.3376629054546356,
0.5109206438064575,
-0.3206012547016144,
-0.12864592671394348,
0.9040742516517639,
0.4908125400543213,
-0.0009644268429838121,
0.035237159579992294,
0.029286667704582214,
0.0511309988796711,
0.0031468658708035946,
0.42667728662490845,
0.9373380541801453,
-0.47165894508361816,
0.46420082449913025,
-0.6587057709693909,
-0.04540051147341728,
-0.3274720013141632,
-0.6557095050811768,
-1.117292881011963,
-0.6134043335914612,
-0.3044824004173279,
-0.692630410194397,
0.2400672733783722,
1.0967386960983276,
0.3571760058403015,
-0.9903291463851929,
-0.36850056052207947,
-0.0980725958943367,
0.13236024975776672,
0.007576249539852142,
-0.291191965341568,
0.2858690321445465,
-0.3026730716228485,
-0.8338742256164551,
0.3342667520046234,
0.23398646712303162,
0.009697104804217815,
-0.15786691009998322,
-0.06275729835033417,
-0.1129520833492279,
0.08775371313095093,
0.7216969132423401,
0.3889690041542053,
-0.2430790215730667,
-0.21742744743824005,
0.19319960474967957,
-0.38511088490486145,
0.15966245532035828,
0.9038408398628235,
-0.7084832191467285,
-0.025160042569041252,
0.6273759007453918,
0.21197234094142914,
0.38331085443496704,
0.024965737015008926,
0.3103639483451843,
-0.9050535559654236,
0.17922833561897278,
0.5235579013824463,
0.19801878929138184,
0.2972296476364136,
-0.548669159412384,
0.16434930264949799,
0.2002740502357483,
-0.45992928743362427,
-0.6395301222801208,
0.11347373574972153,
-1.1510077714920044,
-0.3073388636112213,
1.2473158836364746,
0.21872876584529877,
-0.5964855551719666,
-0.14243918657302856,
-0.6064540147781372,
0.2919099032878876,
-0.8135873675346375,
0.9741123914718628,
0.2969784438610077,
0.05271719768643379,
-0.04783031344413757,
-0.16052252054214478,
0.9473894834518433,
0.28224146366119385,
-0.8774892687797546,
-0.3043310046195984,
0.6100425720214844,
0.01492894534021616,
0.19720490276813507,
0.7679700255393982,
-0.12503157556056976,
0.42341771721839905,
-0.4883204996585846,
0.061608653515577316,
0.37515977025032043,
-0.1728024184703827,
-0.3315914273262024,
0.024254845455288887,
-0.05255088582634926,
0.04417695477604866
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06018v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06018v1
|
Few-Shot Cross-Lingual Transfer for Prompting Large Language Models in Low-Resource Languages
| 2024-03-09T21:36:13 | 2024-03-09T21:36:13 |
Christopher Toukmaji
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large pre-trained language models (PLMs) are at the forefront of advances in
Natural Language Processing. One widespread use case of PLMs is "prompting" -
or in-context learning - where a user provides a description of a task and some
completed examples of the task to a PLM as context before prompting the PLM to
perform the task on a new example. Only the largest, most capable PLMs are able
to perform in-context learning effectively, and these models are typically
trained with a predominantly English corpus, leaving all other languages
behind. The data limitations in most languages preclude the training of
language-specific PLMs capable of prompting. Albeit the surge in work of
prompting settings, it is still unclear how PLMs should be adapted
cross-lingually specifically for prompting. We evaluate the possible methods to
adapt LLaMa, a 7B parameter open-source PLM mainly trained in English, for
prompting in low-resource languages, namely for Kinyarwanda, Hausa, and
Luganda. We consider three methods: few-shot prompting (prompt),
language-adaptive fine-tuning (LAFT), and neural machine translation
(translate), and evaluate on abstractive summarization, multi-class topic
classification, and named-entity recognition. Although LAFT carries the
greatest compute cost and intuitively should lead to the best results, our
experiments exhibit that LAFT is only occasionally the optimal choice for
adapting PLMs for prompting. Rather, the translate and prompt settings are a
compute-efficient and cost-effective method of few-shot prompting for the
selected low-resource languages. We find that the results are task and language
dependent but find that the prompting method is the best on average across all
tasks and languages. Results show that the prompt setting performs better than
both translating and LAFT with statistical significance for all shots when
aggregated across all tasks and languages.
|
[
-0.4367801249027252,
-0.8460931181907654,
0.5345500707626343,
0.514423668384552,
-0.34105366468429565,
-0.18418081104755402,
-0.6415688395500183,
-0.259081095457077,
-0.015343801118433475,
0.22102120518684387,
-0.5347426533699036,
-0.33611568808555603,
-0.40564367175102234,
0.5146610736846924,
-0.15124580264091492,
0.9284905791282654,
-0.1254417598247528,
-0.026245901361107826,
-0.12418869882822037,
-0.16470076143741608,
-0.7603909969329834,
-0.20923717319965363,
-0.9144262075424194,
-0.41896313428878784,
0.7352572679519653,
0.7253086566925049,
0.2981575131416321,
0.06510370224714279,
0.15566132962703705,
0.1795106828212738,
-0.061383411288261414,
0.26441293954849243,
-0.5543887615203857,
-0.15251536667346954,
-0.27960166335105896,
-0.7794162034988403,
-0.21007131040096283,
-0.19782619178295135,
0.781032919883728,
0.8101462721824646,
0.22089451551437378,
0.24264700710773468,
0.3551449179649353,
0.576585590839386,
-0.6852543950080872,
0.06041698902845383,
-0.6573677659034729,
0.16001848876476288,
-0.2450972944498062,
-0.438131183385849,
-0.5348615646362305,
-0.1884830743074417,
0.14035464823246002,
-0.6574757099151611,
-0.11731034517288208,
0.07301986962556839,
0.46535825729370117,
0.24314580857753754,
-0.27592402696609497,
-0.11430396139621735,
-0.5387340188026428,
0.8577096462249756,
-0.43074044585227966,
0.22827178239822388,
0.6865643262863159,
0.187945157289505,
-0.12550048530101776,
-0.3620857000350952,
-0.5197290182113647,
-0.3602752983570099,
-0.08665680140256882,
0.07476680725812912,
-0.4737222194671631,
-0.05314815044403076,
0.3871142566204071,
-0.09441749006509781,
-0.5512670874595642,
0.5410512089729309,
-0.3501734435558319,
-0.17495648562908173,
0.31542208790779114,
0.07463819533586502,
0.08822452276945114,
-0.17663562297821045,
-0.46943148970603943,
-0.04196103662252426,
-1.069327712059021,
0.29403895139694214,
0.1753387451171875,
0.6215627789497375,
-0.5042567253112793,
0.3418146073818207,
-0.3260370194911957,
1.0043940544128418,
0.3521071970462799,
-0.1960497945547104,
-0.2135658711194992,
-0.43884503841400146,
-0.08163503557443619,
0.11921622604131699,
0.8449283242225647,
0.3342331647872925,
0.4114728271961212,
0.17361296713352203,
-0.15149913728237152,
-0.21460849046707153,
-0.1934947371482849,
-0.6318651437759399,
0.06880666315555573,
-0.11422137916088104,
-0.43525102734565735,
0.10405976325273514,
-0.4465436637401581,
-0.8201825022697449,
-0.46407631039619446,
-0.10090816766023636,
0.5660193562507629,
-0.30944982171058655,
-0.007612427230924368,
-0.07401177287101746,
0.22942984104156494,
0.4504062533378601,
0.45788249373435974,
-1.033395767211914,
0.06021364405751228,
0.3780559301376343,
1.071952223777771,
-0.39666399359703064,
-0.5757660865783691,
-1.0266034603118896,
-0.037398431450128555,
-0.4022688865661621,
0.9581963419914246,
-0.456944078207016,
-0.5410729050636292,
0.17022527754306793,
-0.008521631360054016,
-0.1785031408071518,
-0.5314236879348755,
0.31241458654403687,
-0.4758515954017639,
0.22512011229991913,
-0.6234603524208069,
-0.1868855208158493,
-0.12760686874389648,
0.35092484951019287,
-0.5366642475128174,
0.8765705823898315,
0.13862454891204834,
-0.39165884256362915,
0.33245956897735596,
-0.8277865052223206,
-0.6493769288063049,
0.04119731858372688,
0.06494396924972534,
0.07646772265434265,
0.08503735810518265,
0.5453009009361267,
0.4892488121986389,
-0.3616389334201813,
-0.038595519959926605,
0.03852858021855354,
-0.32564088702201843,
0.23120234906673431,
-0.5905945897102356,
0.8028430342674255,
0.16094784438610077,
-0.08388011902570724,
0.15293627977371216,
-0.5470916032791138,
-0.21418924629688263,
0.13159331679344177,
-0.40054282546043396,
-0.33819520473480225,
-0.4337579309940338,
-0.1817350536584854,
0.16940763592720032,
0.16120006144046783,
-0.13632388412952423,
0.3098844587802887,
-0.4767764210700989,
0.33616402745246887,
0.5960594415664673,
0.017211809754371643,
0.9176027774810791,
-0.3388560116291046,
0.7962108850479126,
0.014918757602572441,
-0.09599139541387558,
-0.5362071990966797,
-0.4758078455924988,
-0.6642316579818726,
-0.11029790341854095,
0.29962021112442017,
0.6804265975952148,
-1.060029149055481,
0.004034160636365414,
-0.19406703114509583,
-0.15685227513313293,
-0.6589532494544983,
0.4662238657474518,
0.3633787930011749,
0.7589321136474609,
0.3569266200065613,
-0.17719757556915283,
-0.3420819044113159,
-0.7216640710830688,
-0.24987220764160156,
-0.352168470621109,
0.02293589524924755,
0.1667546182870865,
0.22490140795707703,
0.19596457481384277,
0.8628417253494263,
-0.09860159456729889,
-0.3838202953338623,
-0.6063982248306274,
0.23108689486980438,
0.22958172857761383,
0.3465087115764618,
0.7459641695022583,
-0.38670891523361206,
-0.862300455570221,
0.1320137232542038,
-0.3321813642978668,
-0.5151588320732117,
-0.4182305335998535,
-0.0858149379491806,
0.41655707359313965,
0.4137512743473053,
-0.5586541891098022,
0.13932612538337708,
0.7113676071166992,
0.1209237352013588,
0.37881311774253845,
-0.1537598967552185,
0.18350304663181305,
-1.0151944160461426,
0.18577498197555542,
-0.1688917726278305,
-0.3078131377696991,
-0.6475703120231628,
-0.25035375356674194,
0.0012975555146113038,
-0.04352632910013199,
-0.8389573097229004,
1.1121770143508911,
-0.5379050374031067,
-0.14835166931152344,
-0.5247243046760559,
0.2087465524673462,
-0.05626576393842697,
0.4675278067588806,
0.22457237541675568,
0.8889991641044617,
0.6714001893997192,
-0.7287701964378357,
0.24217887222766876,
0.2825462222099304,
-0.31375378370285034,
0.8940675258636475,
-0.41500478982925415,
0.30961576104164124,
-0.04643385857343674,
0.27183178067207336,
-0.8997589349746704,
-0.08484821021556854,
0.4246796667575836,
-0.15335874259471893,
0.2300443798303604,
-0.38272807002067566,
-0.3641689121723175,
-0.1215442642569542,
-0.27309659123420715,
0.4058035612106323,
0.5486401319503784,
-0.842117190361023,
0.40953460335731506,
-0.15391409397125244,
-0.4268009662628174,
-0.5036781430244446,
-0.79908686876297,
0.12826748192310333,
-0.27177682518959045,
-0.3857380151748657,
0.2699137330055237,
-0.04056937247514725,
-0.19229106605052948,
-0.12221197783946991,
0.1596723347902298,
0.007520320825278759,
0.025491446256637573,
-0.032390423119068146,
0.36177533864974976,
-0.3708310127258301,
-0.0480564646422863,
0.1987246572971344,
-0.1825212836265564,
-0.21958330273628235,
-0.2504142224788666,
0.5403798818588257,
-0.08622459322214127,
-0.3433607816696167,
-0.4934852123260498,
0.4141688048839569,
0.22360859811306,
-0.1651208996772766,
0.6721014380455017,
0.7373343706130981,
-0.24618998169898987,
-0.2892999053001404,
-0.4295836389064789,
-0.3561078906059265,
-0.4178275465965271,
0.2350175380706787,
-0.4888036549091339,
-0.9301877617835999,
0.5748738050460815,
-0.23499561846256256,
0.15128764510154724,
0.09443458169698715,
0.7443055510520935,
-0.060147952288389206,
0.8685169219970703,
0.7223547101020813,
-0.29783159494400024,
0.7640345096588135,
-0.09592773020267487,
0.06861428171396255,
-0.5574961304664612,
0.14378705620765686,
-0.5287350416183472,
-0.5080731511116028,
-0.35002389550209045,
-0.45747625827789307,
0.4983270466327667,
0.19933249056339264,
0.1959524154663086,
0.2977139949798584,
-0.01692512072622776,
0.7365131378173828,
0.6408224701881409,
-0.15204524993896484,
0.338434636592865,
0.19758635759353638,
0.05160682275891304,
0.09327303618192673,
-1.101796269416809,
-0.30687570571899414,
0.7402964234352112,
0.08259514719247818,
0.8819791078567505,
-0.07101070135831833,
0.7522324919700623,
-0.0696900486946106,
0.2259625643491745,
-1.2102304697036743,
0.5722610950469971,
-0.14783509075641632,
-0.268011212348938,
-0.2814207375049591,
-0.25222301483154297,
-1.2607370615005493,
0.20881594717502594,
-0.31933504343032837,
-0.67816162109375,
0.2821100056171417,
0.25999677181243896,
-0.8140286207199097,
0.12453034520149231,
-0.8062768578529358,
0.7221353054046631,
-0.35056981444358826,
-0.4851979911327362,
-0.20983754098415375,
-0.5549980998039246,
0.27993398904800415,
-0.21358081698417664,
0.11879557371139526,
-0.028768302872776985,
-0.21639984846115112,
0.5643845200538635,
0.06298277527093887,
1.2410519123077393,
-0.22027002274990082,
-0.2001393735408783,
0.3483329713344574,
0.3555496633052826,
0.7506254315376282,
-0.11339158564805984,
-0.011434954591095448,
0.12400862574577332,
-0.03747348487377167,
-0.34837520122528076,
-0.5153723955154419,
0.6588451862335205,
-0.5455597639083862,
-0.6626733541488647,
-0.22011269629001617,
-0.6928398013114929,
-0.3614533841609955,
0.141285702586174,
0.46903157234191895,
0.045094482600688934,
-0.0745883584022522,
0.004133854992687702,
0.44686034321784973,
-0.43075644969940186,
0.718754768371582,
0.6708709001541138,
-0.11469589918851852,
-0.10795942693948746,
0.7056151628494263,
0.0850217193365097,
0.3887300193309784,
0.3257831335067749,
0.456187903881073,
-0.31162866950035095,
-0.4392915964126587,
-0.6891084909439087,
0.22839491069316864,
-0.7740802764892578,
-0.30743706226348877,
-0.23967808485031128,
0.08512763679027557,
-0.2677299678325653,
-0.4639861583709717,
-0.23578356206417084,
-0.27588939666748047,
-0.5493183732032776,
0.07334183156490326,
0.4044557809829712,
0.4223417043685913,
-0.06060464307665825,
0.5738053321838379,
-1.1116124391555786,
0.3092067837715149,
0.3857165575027466,
0.04502111300826073,
-0.11501169204711914,
-0.7768536806106567,
-0.20262713730335236,
-0.15308232605457306,
-0.04317423328757286,
-0.8940961360931396,
0.34988221526145935,
0.46278753876686096,
0.5827280282974243,
0.3148757815361023,
0.13323310017585754,
0.8246195912361145,
-0.5584263205528259,
0.911398708820343,
0.32043951749801636,
-0.902116060256958,
0.6411168575286865,
-0.11611230671405792,
0.6745758652687073,
0.6548157334327698,
0.5146920680999756,
-0.7846469283103943,
-0.022870704531669617,
-0.10991029441356659,
-0.48787468671798706,
0.9585511684417725,
-0.2966676950454712,
0.35144710540771484,
0.05920954421162605,
0.17020002007484436,
0.43611398339271545,
-0.08939925581216812,
-0.6709828972816467,
0.02835536003112793,
0.08400361984968185,
-0.1406640261411667,
0.12841114401817322,
-0.050524577498435974,
-0.21391713619232178,
-0.0308699794113636,
0.40798303484916687,
-0.6776928901672363,
0.07388332486152649,
0.1589251607656479,
-0.4775940477848053,
-0.312078595161438,
0.5628477931022644,
0.808368444442749,
0.6009745001792908,
0.3830542266368866,
0.22458048164844513,
0.7247874736785889,
-0.09749364852905273,
0.24762628972530365,
-0.0008852569153532386,
-0.27892476320266724,
-0.009699582122266293,
0.491428941488266,
1.1454390287399292,
0.32386907935142517,
-0.504883348941803,
0.46648046374320984,
0.2678813338279724,
-0.013851887546479702,
0.24814008176326752,
-0.021123165264725685,
-0.11873665452003479,
0.3372098207473755,
0.2636338472366333,
-0.18822024762630463,
-0.11024948209524155,
-0.48842570185661316,
-0.3046206533908844,
0.3564552068710327,
-0.054604873061180115,
-0.5310728549957275,
0.39815762639045715,
0.32821622490882874,
-0.28967347741127014,
0.39001497626304626,
-0.2510114014148712,
-0.47073835134506226,
0.21750681102275848,
0.747768223285675,
0.7808279991149902,
-0.17324700951576233,
0.2515430152416229,
0.46594980359077454,
0.34403079748153687,
-0.2612314224243164,
0.22034668922424316,
-0.3988281786441803,
-0.6261093020439148,
-0.8317039012908936,
-0.49444031715393066,
-0.5448341369628906,
0.14407669007778168,
-0.43409451842308044,
0.4470771551132202,
-0.3532893657684326,
-0.13903690874576569,
-0.28317081928253174,
-0.15872234106063843,
-0.6880772113800049,
-0.3922041952610016,
0.46930575370788574,
1.0344667434692383,
-0.997694194316864,
0.8909279704093933,
0.8819854259490967,
-0.3631061017513275,
-0.6130320429801941,
-0.073086217045784,
0.12749502062797546,
-0.9977466464042664,
0.665894627571106,
-0.16746124625205994,
-0.12794432044029236,
0.11223984509706497,
-0.6003907918930054,
-0.6802492141723633,
0.7993282079696655,
0.7076825499534607,
-0.8059976100921631,
0.08521296083927155,
0.19047802686691284,
0.4181942939758301,
-0.23528477549552917,
-0.013872562907636166,
0.5841847062110901,
0.5981299877166748,
-0.025338679552078247,
-1.261878490447998,
0.03166927769780159,
0.2131754457950592,
0.028323329985141754,
-0.036212146282196045,
-0.7041343450546265,
0.6292856931686401,
-0.3313352167606354,
-0.1975930780172348,
0.08259282261133194,
0.6598151326179504,
0.44419580698013306,
0.3165575861930847,
0.687267005443573,
-0.062365125864744186,
0.7689298391342163,
0.09015753120183945,
0.9386604428291321,
-0.20525716245174408,
-0.11045113205909729,
1.052836298942566,
-0.5024076104164124,
0.9931336045265198,
0.8223381042480469,
-0.14601534605026245,
0.20977655053138733,
0.6071866154670715,
0.19702261686325073,
0.5371178388595581,
-0.22918784618377686,
-0.2763059735298157,
-0.17429448664188385,
-0.4450393319129944,
-0.19425249099731445,
0.4407406449317932,
0.3293464183807373,
-0.10297838598489761,
-0.31173643469810486,
0.46678876876831055,
-0.05819331109523773,
-0.15800517797470093,
-0.5747960209846497,
0.848678708076477,
0.47439271211624146,
-1.0467169284820557,
0.8497865200042725,
-0.1795770227909088,
0.878270149230957,
-0.7246395945549011,
0.017877714708447456,
-0.4585760235786438,
-0.24993474781513214,
-0.2619229853153229,
-0.8103892207145691,
0.06113550812005997,
0.3599872589111328,
-0.14436621963977814,
-0.5168607234954834,
0.8806523680686951,
-0.749282717704773,
-0.09383528679609299,
0.26517343521118164,
0.7575971484184265,
0.2212275266647339,
0.008835293352603912,
-0.673851728439331,
0.010433807969093323,
-0.17292162775993347,
-0.1382906138896942,
0.6086440086364746,
0.32175523042678833,
-0.39804962277412415,
0.4303354024887085,
0.7561366558074951,
0.3512926995754242,
0.17487551271915436,
0.4152953624725342,
0.5459420084953308,
-0.5167210102081299,
-0.5687930583953857,
-0.8102907538414001,
0.33052971959114075,
0.3831265866756439,
-0.23100413382053375,
0.6500117182731628,
0.0651046633720398,
0.9308927059173584,
-0.15404565632343292,
0.6765741109848022,
0.13902287185192108,
0.07700899988412857,
-0.8287612795829773,
0.45461490750312805,
-0.510216236114502,
0.17412124574184418,
0.028156612068414688,
-0.928954005241394,
-0.23589463531970978,
0.6536229252815247,
-0.43637654185295105,
-0.11397530138492584,
0.7046606540679932,
0.7618038654327393,
0.020314529538154602,
-0.21407289803028107,
0.4829752743244171,
0.02944018691778183,
-0.012271781452000141,
0.7992649078369141,
1.092361330986023,
0.05201435461640358,
0.7161763906478882,
-0.28019610047340393,
-0.1443077027797699,
-0.3772428631782532,
-1.005686640739441,
-0.9040157794952393,
-0.41684383153915405,
-0.3109091818332672,
-0.12328450381755829,
-0.111402727663517,
1.287640929222107,
0.658162534236908,
-0.882270097732544,
-0.29535147547721863,
0.25883254408836365,
0.17627491056919098,
-0.26907819509506226,
-0.1586044281721115,
0.2075396627187729,
-0.5014447569847107,
-0.9658198356628418,
0.8198180198669434,
0.27447596192359924,
0.13461080193519592,
-0.2882575988769531,
-0.1618098020553589,
-0.11102711409330368,
-0.14656350016593933,
0.8265028595924377,
0.6322512030601501,
-0.7623238563537598,
-0.21927706897258759,
0.20751328766345978,
-0.14996282756328583,
0.13314823806285858,
0.7974133491516113,
-0.8517517447471619,
0.3545975685119629,
0.7754256129264832,
0.8702123165130615,
0.34265539050102234,
-0.21484386920928955,
0.5676780939102173,
-1.0109282732009888,
0.4353353679180145,
0.09830699861049652,
0.34377530217170715,
0.4717496931552887,
-0.23102827370166779,
0.32131820917129517,
0.01114309299737215,
-0.2572770416736603,
-0.8053715825080872,
0.06603694707155228,
-0.9181992411613464,
-0.14210626482963562,
1.3307042121887207,
-0.06770496815443039,
-0.4150691628456116,
-0.034572675824165344,
-0.5177791118621826,
0.09361343830823898,
-0.4102005362510681,
0.4437717795372009,
0.7682809233665466,
-0.25778016448020935,
-0.47885146737098694,
-0.5287675261497498,
0.419097363948822,
0.7082225680351257,
-0.8438804745674133,
-0.007053763139992952,
0.4111371338367462,
0.15366733074188232,
0.02594834193587303,
0.8020408749580383,
0.1465720236301422,
0.5308732986450195,
-0.295388787984848,
-0.2163344919681549,
0.09119551628828049,
-0.3484998345375061,
-0.9927790760993958,
-0.06892744451761246,
0.3173476457595825,
-0.09333714097738266
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06016v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06016v1
|
End-to-end solution for linked open data query logs analytics
| 2024-03-09T21:29:40 | 2024-03-09T21:29:40 |
Dihia Lanasri
|
cs.DB
|
cs.DB, cs.CL
|
Important advances in pillar domains are derived from exploiting query-logs
which represents users interest and preferences. Deep understanding of users
provides useful knowledge which can influence strongly decision-making. In this
work, we want to extract valuable information from Linked Open Data (LOD)
query-logs. LOD logs have experienced significant growth due to the large
exploitation of LOD datasets. However, exploiting these logs is a difficult
task because of their complex structure. Moreover, these logs suffer from many
risks related to their Quality and Provenance, impacting their trust. To tackle
these issues, we start by clearly defining the ecosystem of LOD query-logs.
Then, we provide an end-to-end solution to exploit these logs. At the end, real
LOD logs are used and a set of experiments are conducted to validate the
proposed solution.
|
[
-0.4797378182411194,
-0.8267055153846741,
0.3298904299736023,
-0.24158157408237457,
-0.5583182573318481,
0.09381606429815292,
0.3209381103515625,
-0.9362510442733765,
0.4725581705570221,
0.7140498757362366,
-0.6835044622421265,
-1.031390905380249,
-0.3240664303302765,
-0.21080242097377777,
-0.36441880464553833,
1.1384977102279663,
0.0722862184047699,
-0.43999481201171875,
-0.3338834345340729,
-0.2592959403991699,
-0.28177332878112793,
-0.5162705183029175,
-0.868712306022644,
0.3628225028514862,
0.5261859893798828,
0.4227307438850403,
0.4410111904144287,
0.36609312891960144,
0.636538565158844,
0.1191752627491951,
-0.11923958361148834,
0.2943374812602997,
-0.9294441938400269,
0.4114108085632324,
-0.5691420435905457,
-0.265550822019577,
-0.774331271648407,
-0.11286439001560211,
0.3369080424308777,
0.8472047448158264,
-0.21603477001190186,
0.43586236238479614,
-0.030559679493308067,
0.5639448165893555,
-0.7298252582550049,
0.32139113545417786,
-0.7198360562324524,
0.12879586219787598,
-0.24615629017353058,
-0.45196568965911865,
-0.32088449597358704,
-0.34481003880500793,
0.17259211838245392,
-0.612371027469635,
0.30522820353507996,
0.642860472202301,
0.7277368307113647,
0.03901999443769455,
-0.5412476062774658,
-0.4561510682106018,
-0.5116944909095764,
0.396584689617157,
-0.6662778854370117,
0.2808768153190613,
0.5674401521682739,
0.515815794467926,
-0.46327078342437744,
-0.7478513717651367,
-0.1490817815065384,
0.24122166633605957,
-0.3919737935066223,
-0.12649734318256378,
0.03665516525506973,
-0.10041347146034241,
0.04268186166882515,
0.6186584830284119,
-0.5358166694641113,
0.30240023136138916,
-0.6025175452232361,
-0.044884081929922104,
0.9304313063621521,
0.40013736486434937,
-0.06468740105628967,
0.010062570683658123,
-0.3205188512802124,
0.04840761423110962,
-0.8768529891967773,
0.1584273874759674,
0.399196058511734,
0.49425673484802246,
0.23055440187454224,
0.8247624635696411,
-0.9995050430297852,
0.7151947617530823,
-0.0008311525452882051,
0.2065460979938507,
0.04070550203323364,
-0.26481497287750244,
-0.2416541576385498,
0.6065911054611206,
0.6802288293838501,
0.25486859679222107,
-0.048411834985017776,
-0.4295666813850403,
0.09533923864364624,
-0.4055047035217285,
0.027073027566075325,
-0.805980920791626,
0.19352519512176514,
0.5978905558586121,
-0.47648128867149353,
-0.28910595178604126,
0.1818854808807373,
-1.1021605730056763,
-0.635002851486206,
0.15210621058940887,
0.3189104497432709,
-0.12718935310840607,
-0.42838990688323975,
0.5468565821647644,
0.25213804841041565,
0.23469503223896027,
0.27164342999458313,
-0.6991674304008484,
0.45169997215270996,
0.7725831866264343,
0.8553479909896851,
-0.2739209234714508,
0.12823455035686493,
-0.945725679397583,
0.36963599920272827,
-0.3072277009487152,
0.6306435465812683,
-0.39784276485443115,
-0.6591744422912598,
0.23554985225200653,
0.0045697963796556,
0.1887880265712738,
-0.36877724528312683,
0.7829169631004333,
-0.9391782879829407,
0.3706372380256653,
-0.28873905539512634,
-0.560133695602417,
-0.3417697250843048,
0.38860195875167847,
-0.8224227428436279,
0.8909411430358887,
0.21115662157535553,
-1.0635157823562622,
0.3191438317298889,
-0.7832650542259216,
-0.24885669350624084,
0.02877729944884777,
-0.0336335226893425,
-0.4404129981994629,
0.2483772486448288,
0.2800787091255188,
0.6046178936958313,
-0.6623743176460266,
-0.1069820448756218,
-0.5508034229278564,
0.14824727177619934,
0.04527560621500015,
0.1283724009990692,
0.9571766257286072,
0.3163556158542633,
-0.06794208288192749,
0.14357629418373108,
-0.8117995858192444,
0.09370172023773193,
0.2403121292591095,
-0.0052851284854114056,
-0.6402174234390259,
0.06114213168621063,
-0.16341949999332428,
-0.05863231420516968,
0.2252192348241806,
-0.9752653241157532,
0.14744944870471954,
-0.12567918002605438,
-0.1655263453722,
0.6529214978218079,
0.5457002520561218,
-0.18165720999240875,
0.14562545716762543,
0.46328821778297424,
0.13334031403064728,
0.30391088128089905,
-0.13020777702331543,
-0.46389076113700867,
-0.3899115025997162,
-0.15912938117980957,
-0.030680103227496147,
0.08971510827541351,
-0.004556404892355204,
0.3514784276485443,
-0.39367544651031494,
-0.491455614566803,
-0.4104873538017273,
0.08110377937555313,
0.2635343372821808,
0.6642554402351379,
0.18823860585689545,
-0.4053688943386078,
-0.0865643173456192,
-0.635855495929718,
-0.27280208468437195,
-0.19089694321155548,
-0.021856719627976418,
0.37396058440208435,
0.3857523202896118,
0.04181304946541786,
1.6097949743270874,
-1.1598482131958008,
-0.6656351685523987,
0.2507898807525635,
-0.06712870299816132,
0.5682849287986755,
0.3555741310119629,
0.2616879940032959,
-0.9834198355674744,
-0.5352192521095276,
0.5890917181968689,
-0.9351135492324829,
0.11908010393381119,
-0.007323177065700293,
-0.36253154277801514,
-0.12118544429540634,
0.5186387896537781,
-0.7949528694152832,
0.51884925365448,
0.05745990201830864,
-0.9609665274620056,
0.8735132217407227,
0.06353442370891571,
0.21146269142627716,
-0.8244920969009399,
0.2110801488161087,
-0.34648436307907104,
-0.21068145334720612,
-0.2979033887386322,
0.1861926168203354,
-0.19703932106494904,
-0.3080703616142273,
-0.3887633979320526,
0.3191041946411133,
-0.3729175329208374,
-0.4956898093223572,
0.16798609495162964,
0.1902761608362198,
-0.04385663568973541,
0.3423043489456177,
0.003917317371815443,
0.15959559381008148,
0.7239173650741577,
-0.5623648762702942,
0.8422610759735107,
0.27766528725624084,
-0.4722340404987335,
0.762228786945343,
-0.8140806555747986,
0.017923345789313316,
-0.14425377547740936,
0.07544836401939392,
-0.8478276133537292,
-0.3124898672103882,
0.34835267066955566,
-0.6708532571792603,
0.1517169326543808,
-0.4000037610530853,
-0.41287872195243835,
-0.1216866746544838,
-0.21814171969890594,
0.3270406424999237,
0.36768025159835815,
-0.7677841782569885,
0.3957271873950958,
0.2686389088630676,
-0.11133608967065811,
-0.4565037190914154,
0.0071687218733131886,
-0.11084646731615067,
-0.6130187511444092,
-0.7843372821807861,
0.17333845794200897,
0.051934029906988144,
-0.21673613786697388,
0.512803852558136,
-0.3176533877849579,
-0.1286325603723526,
-0.19302700459957123,
0.3957940638065338,
0.1451118439435959,
-0.5215170979499817,
-0.17054305970668793,
0.021516885608434677,
-0.4790429174900055,
0.3194506764411926,
-0.7584095597267151,
0.34892013669013977,
-0.06514939665794373,
-1.0824756622314453,
-0.3452203571796417,
0.3673740029335022,
0.9746506810188293,
-0.5773833394050598,
1.022615909576416,
0.4111330509185791,
-0.5534317493438721,
-0.047459620982408524,
-0.4112195074558258,
-0.06869015097618103,
-0.46168631315231323,
0.3150220513343811,
-0.3439371585845947,
-0.8282167911529541,
0.7027597427368164,
-0.275767982006073,
0.2583223581314087,
0.4945216774940491,
0.08467953652143478,
-0.1558724194765091,
0.6985307931900024,
0.4245697259902954,
0.04723246023058891,
-0.1502164751291275,
-0.2889363467693329,
0.5051124691963196,
-0.8810474872589111,
-0.891422688961029,
-0.6449510455131531,
-0.005417341832071543,
-0.281307190656662,
-0.22796228528022766,
0.6841114163398743,
0.5971479415893555,
0.0687422826886177,
0.13705627620220184,
-0.19801178574562073,
0.3609910011291504,
0.2428531050682068,
0.03140284866094589,
0.6739192008972168,
0.18466348946094513,
0.20856645703315735,
0.2927112281322479,
-0.29891806840896606,
-0.01461061555892229,
1.128318190574646,
0.22366444766521454,
0.8711527585983276,
0.33203428983688354,
0.6232227683067322,
0.6004795432090759,
-0.24312065541744232,
-0.530113935470581,
0.48169755935668945,
0.47457075119018555,
-0.6655065417289734,
-0.5266429781913757,
-0.23278191685676575,
-1.0346189737319946,
0.4377433955669403,
0.06134459748864174,
-1.041232705116272,
0.30300748348236084,
0.1724526286125183,
-0.11534669250249863,
0.5942356586456299,
-0.4227827489376068,
0.984049916267395,
-0.11061682552099228,
-0.7081534266471863,
-0.39752256870269775,
-0.5944137573242188,
0.5237450003623962,
-0.08879372477531433,
0.2972037196159363,
-0.06064441800117493,
0.19800397753715515,
0.8457766771316528,
-0.5600140690803528,
0.8770214915275574,
-0.34269052743911743,
-0.25223517417907715,
0.6518560647964478,
0.29801446199417114,
0.945698618888855,
0.3502746820449829,
-0.09526193886995316,
-0.01915137656033039,
0.10221855342388153,
-0.6433898210525513,
-0.6158838868141174,
0.7943904399871826,
-0.376470685005188,
-0.5549137592315674,
-0.4127289652824402,
-0.01376842986792326,
-0.4242627024650574,
0.20772197842597961,
-0.06618781387805939,
0.49537643790245056,
-0.50592440366745,
0.3034675419330597,
0.8261470198631287,
-0.08935193717479706,
0.263281911611557,
0.4926462769508362,
-0.5633785128593445,
-0.18232108652591705,
0.6989540457725525,
-0.3717866837978363,
0.4606708884239197,
0.19286508858203888,
0.13983921706676483,
-0.5699182748794556,
-0.7982746958732605,
-0.38294970989227295,
0.20662716031074524,
-0.7241800427436829,
-0.33687302470207214,
-0.5601021647453308,
0.08684590458869934,
-0.39157477021217346,
-0.09118450433015823,
-0.39098799228668213,
-0.4005391001701355,
-0.1946883648633957,
-0.5489212870597839,
0.7119878530502319,
0.585929274559021,
0.056371089071035385,
0.39402905106544495,
-0.9151061177253723,
0.11740965396165848,
0.19228495657444,
0.6357090473175049,
0.08015584200620651,
-0.0571490079164505,
-0.5615031719207764,
0.04173322021961212,
0.08914174139499664,
-0.8006518483161926,
0.25150856375694275,
0.2379201501607895,
0.5559282302856445,
0.8380175828933716,
0.5589337348937988,
0.4348217248916626,
-0.07405459880828857,
0.7728196978569031,
0.24347220361232758,
-0.5070188641548157,
0.7235318422317505,
-0.49141499400138855,
-0.24796895682811737,
0.30177175998687744,
0.8957034349441528,
-0.610559344291687,
0.21503862738609314,
-0.5791680812835693,
-0.8698450326919556,
0.762605607509613,
0.1055976152420044,
-0.29999998211860657,
0.1519269496202469,
0.2850379943847656,
0.5246726274490356,
0.16751863062381744,
-0.19495803117752075,
-0.09359493851661682,
-0.02430814877152443,
0.20872296392917633,
0.2616572082042694,
-0.19163204729557037,
-0.19882500171661377,
0.0749245211482048,
0.6169627904891968,
-0.216618150472641,
-0.28327757120132446,
0.3323225975036621,
-0.12180623412132263,
-0.11819814145565033,
0.04411105066537857,
-0.3399524390697479,
0.8893259167671204,
-0.6752089858055115,
0.0477629117667675,
0.03724227100610733,
-0.36453160643577576,
-0.2936684191226959,
-0.34865331649780273,
0.1390727311372757,
-0.11720439046621323,
0.4728643000125885,
0.7173230051994324,
-0.11917102336883545,
-0.9427095055580139,
0.23339778184890747,
0.2214232236146927,
0.265912801027298,
-0.22489342093467712,
-0.0340246707201004,
0.09049998968839645,
0.1864597648382187,
0.5077275633811951,
-0.41507992148399353,
0.20598889887332916,
-0.6101334691047668,
0.21063989400863647,
0.6035322546958923,
-0.6437211632728577,
-0.361609548330307,
0.5289899110794067,
0.27060338854789734,
-0.12937523424625397,
0.9305667281150818,
-0.10940461605787277,
-0.296251505613327,
0.4537949562072754,
0.7836388945579529,
0.8049461841583252,
-0.11991827189922333,
0.09230663627386093,
0.36970198154449463,
0.024822909384965897,
0.7791294455528259,
0.05158120021224022,
-0.17934028804302216,
-0.4008864164352417,
-0.4429326057434082,
-0.9401072859764099,
-0.3443441689014435,
-0.24486394226551056,
-1.1410249471664429,
0.4681609272956848,
-0.2641254663467407,
0.2160646915435791,
-0.3431374430656433,
-0.06486284732818604,
-0.4878964424133301,
0.17196743190288544,
-0.46751976013183594,
1.0880076885223389,
-0.619420051574707,
0.5730106234550476,
0.33379584550857544,
-0.34289583563804626,
0.11634071171283722,
-0.5404689311981201,
-0.01202121190726757,
-0.6689099073410034,
0.7176965475082397,
-0.20109139382839203,
-0.30996081233024597,
0.07850303500890732,
-0.4221128225326538,
-0.6873996257781982,
1.0922002792358398,
-0.19976088404655457,
-0.2160618007183075,
0.15569384396076202,
0.30721062421798706,
0.3256274163722992,
-0.507366418838501,
0.15413767099380493,
0.42177635431289673,
0.22136199474334717,
0.4743499457836151,
-0.6880879402160645,
0.18969742953777313,
-0.0635899007320404,
-0.5421958565711975,
0.3434150516986847,
-0.3459213674068451,
0.4370023012161255,
-0.4626740515232086,
-0.26964229345321655,
-0.5428751111030579,
0.9142056703567505,
-0.03722279518842697,
0.6598564386367798,
0.4846968650817871,
0.6484130024909973,
0.8108421564102173,
0.38922062516212463,
0.9653894305229187,
0.1390012502670288,
0.6987190246582031,
1.0655808448791504,
-0.29565584659576416,
1.0004314184188843,
0.42727503180503845,
-0.3081554174423218,
0.26670920848846436,
0.9204718470573425,
0.4883458614349365,
0.638495683670044,
0.09589091688394547,
-0.5650521516799927,
-0.11527816951274872,
-0.46899154782295227,
-0.7464067339897156,
0.12257815152406693,
0.753350019454956,
0.10535111278295517,
-0.4709281921386719,
-0.4310198724269867,
0.05495095252990723,
-0.17214109003543854,
-0.42320019006729126,
0.7110942006111145,
-0.05469466373324394,
-0.25180351734161377,
0.4531792998313904,
-0.10789170861244202,
0.2563900351524353,
-0.9034791588783264,
0.10426631569862366,
-0.1462567150592804,
-0.04204079881310463,
-0.5572869181632996,
-0.6621361970901489,
0.6270042061805725,
-0.16133464872837067,
0.0750102624297142,
0.00337993330322206,
0.6181584596633911,
-0.15095874667167664,
-0.019278505817055702,
0.4155140221118927,
0.41634422540664673,
0.2519127130508423,
-0.3262193500995636,
0.0662008672952652,
-0.039841048419475555,
0.20581677556037903,
-0.13791026175022125,
0.592643141746521,
0.470071017742157,
-0.20427878201007843,
0.5521219372749329,
1.1488906145095825,
0.06620388478040695,
0.22641389071941376,
-0.5073468089103699,
0.9317049980163574,
-0.7148213386535645,
-0.6782122850418091,
-0.6532106399536133,
0.5608878135681152,
-0.5284377932548523,
-0.2524760365486145,
0.5423189401626587,
0.8724707961082458,
0.7604964375495911,
0.008555881679058075,
0.4877294600009918,
-0.35502442717552185,
0.5210062265396118,
-0.7082398533821106,
0.7029663920402527,
-0.3836221396923065,
0.37343159317970276,
0.01644333451986313,
-1.1097675561904907,
-0.11561959981918335,
-0.010679326020181179,
0.012937822379171848,
-0.5360751748085022,
0.8389304876327515,
0.7030372023582458,
-0.5602265000343323,
0.5275291800498962,
0.04637586325407028,
0.28394100069999695,
0.7363092303276062,
0.2875367999076843,
0.4812026023864746,
-0.2857224643230438,
0.5396515727043152,
-0.016112010926008224,
-0.36593279242515564,
-0.4212217628955841,
-0.9638701677322388,
-0.8359931111335754,
-0.607492983341217,
-0.4530978202819824,
-0.3857996165752411,
0.10074489563703537,
0.551943838596344,
0.7034898400306702,
-0.9851349592208862,
-0.27253738045692444,
0.0860556960105896,
0.3290138840675354,
-0.15602247416973114,
-0.19580337405204773,
1.0836535692214966,
-0.2666902542114258,
-0.41060367226600647,
0.30943045020103455,
0.30073511600494385,
-0.3020287752151489,
-0.24005064368247986,
-0.21502724289894104,
-0.0985124483704567,
-0.35029131174087524,
0.7284078598022461,
0.5697266459465027,
-0.41018083691596985,
-0.08211171627044678,
-0.19040796160697937,
0.38452306389808655,
-0.19941839575767517,
0.9969296455383301,
-0.8261606097221375,
0.4596918821334839,
0.7232677340507507,
0.9255563616752625,
1.1092854738235474,
0.22407306730747223,
0.26567888259887695,
-0.5539848804473877,
-0.22088798880577087,
0.06123143061995506,
0.17385421693325043,
0.05164982005953789,
-0.6244454383850098,
0.6890391707420349,
0.33597201108932495,
-0.12716583907604218,
-0.9519087672233582,
0.21332846581935883,
-1.0997010469436646,
-0.09945378452539444,
0.7559086680412292,
-0.47655361890792847,
-0.11925441771745682,
-0.4060899317264557,
-0.19145236909389496,
-0.09758694469928741,
-0.31935566663742065,
0.5028449296951294,
0.45716893672943115,
-0.6361591815948486,
0.22787757217884064,
-0.5544164776802063,
0.29726120829582214,
0.13203781843185425,
-1.118112564086914,
0.3482223153114319,
0.6640527248382568,
0.05718612298369408,
0.16393297910690308,
0.49110302329063416,
-0.3930712640285492,
-0.23636065423488617,
0.07970281690359116,
-0.44256728887557983,
-0.27815836668014526,
-0.24653662741184235,
0.09507734328508377,
0.5777974724769592,
-0.03718264773488045,
-0.6706745624542236
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09708v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09708v1
|
Institutional-Level Monitoring of Immune Checkpoint Inhibitor IrAEs Using a Novel Natural Language Processing Algorithmic Pipeline
| 2024-03-09T19:18:27 | 2024-03-09T19:18:27 |
Michael Shapiro, Herut Dor, Anna Gurevich-Shapiro, Tal Etan, Ido Wolf
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Background: Immune checkpoint inhibitors (ICIs) have revolutionized cancer
treatment but can result in severe immune-related adverse events (IrAEs).
Monitoring IrAEs on a large scale is essential for personalized risk profiling
and assisting in treatment decisions.
Methods: In this study, we conducted an analysis of clinical notes from
patients who received ICIs at the Tel Aviv Sourasky Medical Center. By
employing a Natural Language Processing algorithmic pipeline, we systematically
identified seven common or severe IrAEs. We examined the utilization of
corticosteroids, treatment discontinuation rates following IrAEs, and
constructed survival curves to visualize the occurrence of adverse events
during treatment.
Results: Our analysis encompassed 108,280 clinical notes associated with
1,635 patients who had undergone ICI therapy. The detected incidence of IrAEs
was consistent with previous reports, exhibiting substantial variation across
different ICIs. Treatment with corticosteroids varied depending on the specific
IrAE, ranging from 17.3% for thyroiditis to 57.4% for myocarditis. Our
algorithm demonstrated high accuracy in identifying IrAEs, as indicated by an
area under the curve (AUC) of 0.89 for each suspected note and F1 scores of
0.87 or higher for five out of the seven IrAEs examined at the patient level.
Conclusions: This study presents a novel, large-scale monitoring approach
utilizing deep neural networks for IrAEs. Our method provides accurate results,
enhancing understanding of detrimental consequences experienced by ICI-treated
patients. Moreover, it holds potential for monitoring other medications,
enabling comprehensive post-marketing surveillance to identify susceptible
populations and establish personalized drug safety profiles.
|
[
-0.39917856454849243,
-0.436318963766098,
0.5022968649864197,
-0.2257394641637802,
-0.1332331895828247,
0.4483487904071808,
0.10743890702724457,
-0.5411300659179688,
0.31723418831825256,
0.5478740334510803,
-0.7254772782325745,
-1.027740716934204,
-0.7770153880119324,
-0.018512330949306488,
0.06205321103334427,
1.3125704526901245,
-0.03481394052505493,
0.48583540320396423,
0.4087563753128052,
-0.21190637350082397,
-0.2803279161453247,
0.11284221708774567,
-0.8994916677474976,
-0.3265673518180847,
0.7174607515335083,
0.4063519537448883,
0.12020448595285416,
-0.09843547642230988,
1.0157276391983032,
0.19470052421092987,
-0.031127525493502617,
-0.2972052991390228,
-0.43464943766593933,
0.10348296910524368,
-0.07346601784229279,
-0.21780823171138763,
-0.47012022137641907,
-0.1370341032743454,
0.5028546452522278,
0.6909854412078857,
-0.1649237871170044,
0.20669697225093842,
0.003814698662608862,
0.5172857046127319,
-0.5068522691726685,
-0.11277689784765244,
-0.5736818313598633,
0.614242672920227,
-0.2845098078250885,
-0.07932941615581512,
-0.24320310354232788,
-0.3021281659603119,
0.5020251274108887,
-0.5627461075782776,
0.08584272861480713,
0.148681178689003,
0.5822111368179321,
-0.14520159363746643,
-0.5454739332199097,
-0.5642352104187012,
-0.15850067138671875,
0.6074466705322266,
-0.8299402594566345,
0.038203105330467224,
0.22593672573566437,
0.35219207406044006,
-0.5032214522361755,
-0.5642970204353333,
-0.03756757080554962,
-0.2963247299194336,
-0.2643640637397766,
0.3577859103679657,
-0.4995540678501129,
0.39346903562545776,
0.3685348927974701,
0.2772577404975891,
-0.6298050880432129,
0.575323224067688,
-0.5140289664268494,
-0.5515708923339844,
0.3009781241416931,
0.4893452525138855,
0.5566086769104004,
-0.10552137345075607,
-0.45921584963798523,
0.4259068965911865,
-0.36490398645401,
0.5051978230476379,
-0.2498568296432495,
-0.035123951733112335,
-0.14577962458133698,
0.5037172436714172,
-0.5333853363990784,
0.21699978411197662,
0.07161502540111542,
-0.0011460650712251663,
-0.04846269264817238,
-0.4582897424697876,
-0.2524776756763458,
0.31331703066825867,
1.1334902048110962,
0.31429943442344666,
-0.03135906904935837,
-0.21595267951488495,
0.3381209075450897,
-0.30600303411483765,
0.060755763202905655,
-1.0619574785232544,
-0.09526524692773819,
0.4643244445323944,
-0.4846388101577759,
-0.4502538740634918,
0.24876564741134644,
-0.8781853914260864,
-0.09915868192911148,
0.007479941472411156,
0.051254089921712875,
-0.5278310775756836,
-0.11412488669157028,
-0.10798152536153793,
-0.17734824120998383,
0.2314462810754776,
0.2576466202735901,
-0.364177405834198,
0.4992307722568512,
0.4922296404838562,
0.9288434386253357,
-0.3251330256462097,
-0.08052664995193481,
-0.9389013051986694,
0.39095339179039,
-0.4627840220928192,
0.919248104095459,
-0.39044246077537537,
-0.23141026496887207,
0.08531199395656586,
-0.2313915640115738,
-0.5616236925125122,
-0.4610878527164459,
0.6656704545021057,
-0.3672480285167694,
0.15805254876613617,
-0.14169101417064667,
-0.4698405861854553,
-0.09473153203725815,
0.24758599698543549,
-0.6139311194419861,
0.42673397064208984,
0.08212350308895111,
-0.6235509514808655,
0.48208826780319214,
-0.8418987989425659,
-0.4148622453212738,
0.3879795968532562,
0.0078705670312047,
-0.7066660523414612,
0.2244415283203125,
0.10986222326755524,
0.5991802215576172,
-0.2687526345252991,
0.5735703706741333,
-0.32109954953193665,
-0.19070270657539368,
0.15683434903621674,
-0.09099588543176651,
0.6877097487449646,
0.4450209140777588,
-0.6780821084976196,
0.19064070284366608,
-0.7891960144042969,
0.21508708596229553,
-0.3471176028251648,
-0.1818186491727829,
-0.030454538762569427,
-0.2786823809146881,
-0.20270459353923798,
0.34497958421707153,
-0.22784960269927979,
-0.5945863127708435,
-0.13663466274738312,
-0.30105528235435486,
0.2765217125415802,
0.47901973128318787,
0.5155155062675476,
0.2584470510482788,
-0.14074404537677765,
0.6287963390350342,
0.4202157258987427,
0.01675841584801674,
-0.13633067905902863,
-0.6074091792106628,
-0.42293781042099,
-0.5679683089256287,
-0.009906154125928879,
0.610344409942627,
-0.2774890661239624,
0.6546748280525208,
-0.19051702320575714,
-0.2624291181564331,
-0.1948963701725006,
-0.24005378782749176,
0.6363276243209839,
0.4527338147163391,
0.17947249114513397,
-0.3299713432788849,
-0.3028738498687744,
-0.9114705324172974,
-0.21785292029380798,
-0.1710621416568756,
-0.009244988672435284,
0.10226662456989288,
0.7083873748779297,
-0.3041899800300598,
0.5199499726295471,
-0.37912362813949585,
-0.785142719745636,
-0.25812453031539917,
0.39508500695228577,
-0.023137103766202927,
0.6143344640731812,
0.27459532022476196,
0.05953534319996834,
-0.45315021276474,
0.46036022901535034,
-0.59665447473526,
-0.12287755310535431,
-0.285388320684433,
-0.32962554693222046,
-0.1380368024110794,
0.593317985534668,
-0.3239162564277649,
0.9002504348754883,
0.15591923892498016,
-0.34201371669769287,
0.10374049097299576,
0.009370692074298859,
0.3626268208026886,
-0.9445070028305054,
0.35795679688453674,
0.3230271637439728,
0.033353403210639954,
-0.6423343420028687,
-0.24578776955604553,
-0.22634218633174896,
-0.22592033445835114,
-0.23297803103923798,
0.16042660176753998,
-0.25964996218681335,
0.10610514134168625,
0.0796533077955246,
-0.6055031418800354,
0.08274725079536438,
0.42346909642219543,
0.029587235301733017,
0.39085158705711365,
0.389117956161499,
-0.3987045884132385,
-0.17353014647960663,
0.02752843126654625,
-0.7769182324409485,
0.5552294850349426,
-0.40643998980522156,
-0.3099660277366638,
-0.093134805560112,
0.6319342255592346,
-0.9523926377296448,
-0.3577941060066223,
0.5752902030944824,
-0.3555264174938202,
0.21649140119552612,
-0.3336718678474426,
0.05170127749443054,
-0.39618629217147827,
-0.28616854548454285,
0.18858735263347626,
-0.02250043675303459,
0.050649113953113556,
0.6879206895828247,
0.15535226464271545,
-0.36941850185394287,
-0.29939699172973633,
-0.6843361258506775,
0.36456310749053955,
-0.31730347871780396,
-0.4996255934238434,
0.24416513741016388,
-0.14600017666816711,
-0.3402000069618225,
-0.11982996016740799,
0.14598296582698822,
-0.27768436074256897,
0.16425295174121857,
0.18318894505500793,
-0.020208409056067467,
-0.26275551319122314,
-0.3126051723957062,
0.3994082808494568,
0.05084914341568947,
0.19337651133537292,
-0.07474099844694138,
0.26304343342781067,
-0.20305725932121277,
-0.4447493851184845,
-1.332861304283142,
0.678048849105835,
0.908912181854248,
-0.47438952326774597,
0.7720996141433716,
0.8401836156845093,
-0.7043434977531433,
0.16938796639442444,
-0.4970916509628296,
-0.18564806878566742,
-0.29340434074401855,
0.28497299551963806,
-0.19063495099544525,
-0.7547881603240967,
0.9830103516578674,
0.013815497979521751,
0.010080267675220966,
0.6756985783576965,
0.4427638649940491,
-0.11317270994186401,
0.9283142685890198,
0.009895207360386848,
-0.19637039303779602,
0.4687613546848297,
-0.4150407612323761,
0.31831854581832886,
-0.9896084070205688,
-0.5041823387145996,
-0.5707651972770691,
-0.5283696055412292,
-0.46833595633506775,
-0.20548968017101288,
0.7084324359893799,
-0.10033641010522842,
-0.506753146648407,
-0.155954048037529,
-0.41860753297805786,
0.339542418718338,
0.5653815865516663,
0.16084972023963928,
0.17301160097122192,
0.17141886055469513,
-0.05813849717378616,
-0.08723443001508713,
-0.6710193157196045,
-0.13840803503990173,
1.1355791091918945,
0.5061436891555786,
0.1511668711900711,
0.052045922726392746,
0.7388346791267395,
0.11099184304475784,
0.5926476716995239,
-0.6858763694763184,
0.27127954363822937,
-0.20773428678512573,
-0.6875663995742798,
-0.10484680533409119,
-0.41485822200775146,
-0.9111780524253845,
-0.16610534489154816,
-0.2200937718153,
-1.0210639238357544,
0.41722697019577026,
-0.16240225732326508,
-0.8862751722335815,
0.3649904131889343,
-1.0068891048431396,
0.9500480890274048,
-0.19653934240341187,
-0.21176186203956604,
-0.13255822658538818,
-0.5995634198188782,
0.3612244725227356,
-0.04756892845034599,
0.21448557078838348,
-0.14759518206119537,
0.28553861379623413,
0.5026581287384033,
-0.5754125714302063,
0.9288519024848938,
-0.023884564638137817,
0.27692675590515137,
0.38929903507232666,
0.0632878988981247,
0.48940664529800415,
0.6887375712394714,
-0.21873457729816437,
0.6902550458908081,
-0.04239819198846817,
-0.4928553104400635,
-0.19410763680934906,
1.0856314897537231,
-0.5566104054450989,
-0.2752087712287903,
-0.8790566921234131,
-0.2452557384967804,
0.12069544196128845,
0.47469016909599304,
0.44822070002555847,
0.656048059463501,
-0.2993307113647461,
0.11846849322319031,
0.47522595524787903,
-0.3129965364933014,
0.3200025260448456,
0.725145161151886,
0.7079963684082031,
-0.7677444815635681,
0.6141936182975769,
0.2790052592754364,
0.12560339272022247,
0.3054710924625397,
0.19803878664970398,
0.23349303007125854,
-1.0310248136520386,
-0.49841731786727905,
-0.16928672790527344,
-0.2886519730091095,
-0.3855058252811432,
-0.7908221483230591,
-0.1646106094121933,
-0.3815635144710541,
-0.15028299391269684,
-0.08907576650381088,
0.08882194757461548,
-0.2215227633714676,
-0.242234468460083,
0.25082218647003174,
0.5813015699386597,
0.0719984695315361,
0.23961418867111206,
-0.6145271062850952,
0.106634721159935,
-0.1539933681488037,
0.7037228345870972,
-0.11333020776510239,
-0.2677473723888397,
-0.35362619161605835,
0.29864102602005005,
-0.1694403737783432,
-0.5632621049880981,
0.3035746216773987,
0.5543317794799805,
0.5756635665893555,
0.5820834040641785,
-0.09946140646934509,
0.7852218151092529,
-0.28120484948158264,
0.6277220249176025,
0.3983137309551239,
-0.8359084129333496,
0.7655475735664368,
-0.5361281633377075,
0.7178457379341125,
0.7230610847473145,
0.2155938595533371,
-0.4151952266693115,
-0.621222734451294,
-0.5106247067451477,
-0.9286238551139832,
1.0514799356460571,
0.443705290555954,
-0.44263485074043274,
-0.3523334562778473,
0.5690341591835022,
-0.22273531556129456,
-0.0590081587433815,
-0.37490785121917725,
-0.16638246178627014,
0.09938620030879974,
-0.4038771986961365,
-0.025523055344820023,
-0.20634843409061432,
-0.5563650131225586,
-0.11476968973875046,
0.7369362711906433,
-0.12236684560775757,
0.15540330111980438,
0.4133264422416687,
-0.09114544838666916,
-0.37571951746940613,
0.36064767837524414,
0.6645617485046387,
0.7080564498901367,
-0.36825889348983765,
-0.183469757437706,
0.2902224659919739,
-0.9150611162185669,
-0.33837082982063293,
0.33840349316596985,
-0.1349303126335144,
-0.18128381669521332,
0.5314766764640808,
0.640306293964386,
0.2896336019039154,
-0.8135507702827454,
0.30308520793914795,
-0.3385576605796814,
-0.127467542886734,
-0.5781850218772888,
-0.028047338128089905,
-0.35067757964134216,
0.19227096438407898,
0.4073783755302429,
0.3671344220638275,
0.5529416799545288,
-0.3712300956249237,
0.37024736404418945,
0.7595469355583191,
-1.14058518409729,
-0.3495013117790222,
0.45767277479171753,
0.017997557297348976,
0.14429503679275513,
0.6889829635620117,
0.28107306361198425,
-0.16927984356880188,
1.0633941888809204,
0.07732018083333969,
0.7935121655464172,
-0.0906190276145935,
0.45120593905448914,
0.6590542197227478,
0.28053316473960876,
0.33886414766311646,
-0.10946314036846161,
0.36014801263809204,
-0.36933252215385437,
-0.3533358573913574,
-0.3759196400642395,
-0.1835203617811203,
0.0826747789978981,
-1.0521479845046997,
0.1028982549905777,
-0.8859648108482361,
-0.07836694270372391,
0.44142889976501465,
0.32780006527900696,
-0.5533257126808167,
0.3896208703517914,
0.3206198215484619,
0.6872698664665222,
-0.6044942140579224,
0.5688520669937134,
0.820601761341095,
-0.33586737513542175,
-0.7081478238105774,
-0.08738653361797333,
0.21562479436397552,
-0.5106210708618164,
0.4792589545249939,
0.48277151584625244,
-0.03540725260972977,
-0.010514210909605026,
-0.25344693660736084,
-0.8318028450012207,
1.525851845741272,
0.21946030855178833,
-0.582786500453949,
0.5494222640991211,
0.23805320262908936,
0.8890367150306702,
-0.4996519982814789,
0.4395623803138733,
0.7683377265930176,
0.1427961140871048,
0.18819913268089294,
-0.6248807311058044,
-0.3271530866622925,
-0.29937583208084106,
-0.5183612108230591,
0.5010004639625549,
-0.5355463027954102,
0.09894808381795883,
-0.2933197021484375,
-0.15166671574115753,
0.1727624237537384,
0.2120468020439148,
0.004473261535167694,
1.1919584274291992,
0.12842649221420288,
1.0708812475204468,
0.7644923329353333,
-0.34834352135658264,
0.9272335171699524,
-0.3811299204826355,
-0.1849050372838974,
0.554831862449646,
-0.25414466857910156,
0.5413329601287842,
0.40752503275871277,
0.0033494203817099333,
0.5567872524261475,
0.3870665431022644,
0.33518198132514954,
0.38050657510757446,
0.20227636396884918,
-0.6867557764053345,
-0.1863023191690445,
-0.2751767337322235,
-0.319637656211853,
0.03182176500558853,
0.3894980847835541,
-0.47112807631492615,
-0.1309080272912979,
0.3603326678276062,
0.16879607737064362,
-0.26043352484703064,
-0.39566659927368164,
1.190720796585083,
-0.10152090340852737,
-0.8851972222328186,
0.3488505482673645,
-0.26478123664855957,
0.16628994047641754,
-0.7846441268920898,
0.045390550047159195,
-0.36638811230659485,
0.4292537271976471,
-0.4723193645477295,
-0.7009724378585815,
0.23639167845249176,
0.10031504929065704,
-0.3052215278148651,
0.08297893404960632,
0.17301765084266663,
-0.07306819409132004,
-0.6822684407234192,
0.24682633578777313,
0.11265702545642853,
-0.11476238071918488,
0.0793817862868309,
-0.8206086754798889,
0.1764707863330841,
0.22880229353904724,
-0.3024713099002838,
0.6340964436531067,
0.48737427592277527,
-0.40727490186691284,
0.6637033224105835,
0.588672399520874,
-0.02109157107770443,
0.10172951221466064,
0.20801621675491333,
0.8509272933006287,
-0.55547696352005,
-0.17289794981479645,
-0.493674099445343,
0.6288357973098755,
-0.1456531137228012,
-0.7739886045455933,
0.4129212498664856,
0.7825223207473755,
0.5092325210571289,
0.3674643039703369,
0.6272032260894775,
0.1408616453409195,
0.45077890157699585,
-0.46497461199760437,
0.8260033130645752,
-0.08408292382955551,
0.7706955075263977,
-0.1654689759016037,
-0.48444733023643494,
-0.8433200120925903,
0.2061416208744049,
-0.6868321895599365,
-0.4562784731388092,
0.5742097496986389,
0.5909858345985413,
0.12429583072662354,
-0.022102003917098045,
-0.18258200585842133,
0.325760155916214,
0.7320989370346069,
0.590036153793335,
0.4731975793838501,
-0.5297874808311462,
0.49939292669296265,
-0.46762678027153015,
-0.38264355063438416,
0.03664209693670273,
-0.47897329926490784,
-0.8913208246231079,
-0.14217568933963776,
-0.7512114644050598,
-0.2822163999080658,
0.3475150167942047,
0.9495155215263367,
0.466561496257782,
-1.3550218343734741,
-0.02950792759656906,
-0.25478458404541016,
0.12018027156591415,
-0.2702842354774475,
-0.09678233414888382,
0.5858883261680603,
-0.2406090646982193,
-0.6183805465698242,
0.33794575929641724,
0.6617603302001953,
0.008555572479963303,
0.05536776781082153,
-0.03929121792316437,
-0.21590808033943176,
-0.502945601940155,
0.4703110158443451,
0.43560150265693665,
-0.5744040608406067,
0.0858282521367073,
-0.12846742570400238,
-0.3436506390571594,
-0.17212969064712524,
0.929531991481781,
-0.44995513558387756,
0.605738639831543,
0.3583559989929199,
0.38088488578796387,
0.23546965420246124,
-0.2881101667881012,
0.6163938641548157,
0.009041422978043556,
-0.11626406759023666,
0.5757647752761841,
0.3563734292984009,
-0.2162974774837494,
-0.40276360511779785,
-0.0274508073925972,
0.009824218228459358,
-0.4120306968688965,
-0.7346441149711609,
-0.01508730836212635,
-0.9733914732933044,
0.03553904965519905,
0.8652052879333496,
-0.43403124809265137,
-0.1417945921421051,
-0.26293134689331055,
-0.275816410779953,
-0.1860843151807785,
-0.6072587966918945,
0.7142008543014526,
0.4616885483264923,
-0.09885750710964203,
-0.21910572052001953,
-0.6495736241340637,
0.574699342250824,
0.342841774225235,
-0.7185684442520142,
-0.5556339025497437,
0.46025073528289795,
0.20926985144615173,
-0.3176272213459015,
0.5327457189559937,
-0.2863689959049225,
0.4985164701938629,
-0.7275250554084778,
0.0427769236266613,
0.19319088757038116,
0.05026054009795189,
-0.4389346241950989,
0.18539197742938995,
-0.26584506034851074,
-0.03899908810853958
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.05982v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.05982v1
|
Enhanced Auto Language Prediction with Dictionary Capsule -- A Novel Approach
| 2024-03-09T18:43:48 | 2024-03-09T18:43:48 |
Pinni Venkata Abhiram, Ananya Rathore, Abhir Mirikar, Hari Krishna S, Sheena Christabel Pravin, Vishwanath Kamath Pethri, Manjunath Lokanath Belgod, Reetika Gupta, K Muthukumaran
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The paper presents a novel Auto Language Prediction Dictionary Capsule
(ALPDC) framework for language prediction and machine translation. The model
uses a combination of neural networks and symbolic representations to predict
the language of a given input text and then translate it to a target language
using pre-built dictionaries. This research work also aims to translate the
text of various languages to its literal meaning in English. The proposed model
achieves state-of-the-art results on several benchmark datasets and
significantly improves translation accuracy compared to existing methods. The
results show the potential of the proposed method for practical use in
multilingual communication and natural language processing tasks.
|
[
-0.3609788119792938,
-0.6059383749961853,
0.27270326018333435,
0.18653614819049835,
-0.2220451980829239,
0.28865206241607666,
-0.06432919949293137,
-0.598293125629425,
0.41506484150886536,
0.049402158707380295,
-0.37558069825172424,
-0.26153016090393066,
-0.9120468497276306,
0.46191713213920593,
-0.5302662253379822,
0.7031635046005249,
-0.21538102626800537,
0.20531676709651947,
0.1709413230419159,
-0.10549670457839966,
-0.5334958434104919,
-0.4973417818546295,
-0.6804913282394409,
-0.06718701124191284,
0.3056313395500183,
0.07175958156585693,
0.9383082985877991,
0.8374072909355164,
0.4025310277938843,
0.321066290140152,
0.2599745988845825,
0.34383147954940796,
0.24796055257320404,
-0.08583616465330124,
0.22834302484989166,
-0.373352587223053,
-0.6272442936897278,
0.021156882867217064,
0.5551336407661438,
0.8526989817619324,
-0.3956856429576874,
-0.3425231873989105,
0.2815713882446289,
0.3943367004394531,
-0.6133176684379578,
0.49942344427108765,
-0.7805890440940857,
0.22163984179496765,
-0.11997263133525848,
0.0056111570447683334,
-0.29011011123657227,
-0.17693203687667847,
-0.2331075817346573,
-0.6598690152168274,
-0.16915956139564514,
0.20394781231880188,
0.3666195571422577,
0.12390989810228348,
-0.669977605342865,
-0.5771477818489075,
-0.4681054651737213,
0.6318694949150085,
-0.7195084691047668,
0.5353847742080688,
0.587426483631134,
0.5455885529518127,
-0.13286490738391876,
-0.7395163774490356,
-0.9676477909088135,
-0.3098304569721222,
-0.13645008206367493,
0.12203436344861984,
0.04437191039323807,
0.26174139976501465,
-0.3282013535499573,
0.40110450983047485,
-0.4629341959953308,
0.001492052455432713,
-0.38534313440322876,
-0.04852903261780739,
0.270799845457077,
0.32832345366477966,
0.5312925577163696,
-0.315071702003479,
-0.11578632891178131,
0.0340900793671608,
-0.30504506826400757,
-0.053489916026592255,
0.16068832576274872,
0.47112157940864563,
-0.22903962433338165,
0.4619112014770508,
-0.31998223066329956,
0.8305874466896057,
-0.07562335580587387,
0.04895256832242012,
0.4273860454559326,
-0.36912912130355835,
-0.2449629008769989,
0.24709025025367737,
0.9209856986999512,
0.24875667691230774,
0.3650689721107483,
-0.22072680294513702,
-0.2759288251399994,
0.055687204003334045,
0.028994213789701462,
-0.5173740386962891,
-0.24952365458011627,
0.23126745223999023,
-0.47703301906585693,
-0.5352075695991516,
-0.02175791561603546,
-0.6155139803886414,
-0.14818978309631348,
-0.31938880681991577,
-0.012239948846399784,
-0.5011526942253113,
-0.16672198474407196,
0.1421922743320465,
0.3363095819950104,
-0.15340279042720795,
0.18031080067157745,
-1.0355544090270996,
0.5126429200172424,
0.43872103095054626,
1.0224555730819702,
-0.5065514445304871,
-0.545968234539032,
-0.31547603011131287,
0.4087074100971222,
-0.7500532269477844,
0.7916784882545471,
-0.35432276129722595,
-0.24181167781352997,
0.3964027166366577,
0.03727876767516136,
0.13108041882514954,
-0.3077569603919983,
0.5261788368225098,
-0.21196632087230682,
0.12992733716964722,
-0.07463223487138748,
-0.20108318328857422,
0.04045914486050606,
0.2833010256290436,
-1.0225834846496582,
0.902749240398407,
-0.1304992437362671,
-0.5742579698562622,
0.4699335992336273,
-0.49620404839515686,
-0.8504617214202881,
0.2095356285572052,
-0.20685723423957825,
-0.04530154913663864,
0.008658016100525856,
0.5269160866737366,
0.5868515372276306,
-0.3512461185455322,
0.5457909107208252,
-0.1783822923898697,
0.05185895785689354,
0.34037336707115173,
-0.5663992762565613,
0.68187016248703,
0.6182292699813843,
-0.224456787109375,
-0.10770104080438614,
-0.7678029537200928,
-0.016058726236224174,
-0.16166472434997559,
-0.3597554564476013,
-0.24977503716945648,
0.0718979611992836,
0.20932860672473907,
0.5521190166473389,
0.40894240140914917,
-0.25916001200675964,
0.3298954665660858,
-0.6553348302841187,
0.4775446057319641,
0.8264599442481995,
-0.4493001699447632,
0.8391337394714355,
0.07280895113945007,
0.6330787539482117,
-0.043355539441108704,
0.2331571727991104,
-0.14123959839344025,
-0.6948318481445312,
-0.5307765603065491,
-0.23199036717414856,
0.33541762828826904,
0.6952154636383057,
-0.87273108959198,
0.828879714012146,
-0.2318674623966217,
-0.24321943521499634,
-0.5966376066207886,
0.21437539160251617,
0.19321084022521973,
0.4425906836986542,
0.530463457107544,
-0.3831064999103546,
-0.745865523815155,
-0.8817964196205139,
-0.28833627700805664,
-0.4125548303127289,
0.22173680365085602,
-0.012634209357202053,
0.3214748203754425,
-0.28687694668769836,
0.5952785015106201,
-0.34363773465156555,
-0.561083972454071,
-0.5821678042411804,
0.3216930031776428,
0.36141619086265564,
0.48871445655822754,
0.4418788552284241,
-0.646784245967865,
-0.855175256729126,
0.10217741131782532,
-0.5770570635795593,
-0.040715884417295456,
-0.10082242637872696,
-0.13740061223506927,
0.43054962158203125,
0.5842295289039612,
-0.7527039647102356,
0.5354049801826477,
0.6645349264144897,
-0.3408460319042206,
0.37852466106414795,
-0.3949960470199585,
0.40069109201431274,
-1.325049877166748,
0.12916509807109833,
-0.3721947968006134,
-0.1818072497844696,
-0.5974432229995728,
-0.10516224801540375,
0.3961648941040039,
-0.014745816588401794,
-0.3703305423259735,
0.6288174390792847,
-0.3428884446620941,
0.28347647190093994,
-0.33111605048179626,
-0.24781116843223572,
-0.10743626952171326,
0.11910072714090347,
0.13817600905895233,
0.7497361898422241,
0.47106683254241943,
-0.42144644260406494,
0.6279471516609192,
0.2230207324028015,
-0.6263746619224548,
0.22349807620048523,
-0.5308920741081238,
-0.04682937636971474,
-0.03200915455818176,
0.23966671526432037,
-1.1839368343353271,
-0.022238362580537796,
0.08018884807825089,
-0.6522712707519531,
0.42268824577331543,
0.46682941913604736,
-0.7407277226448059,
-0.44039055705070496,
0.023088833317160606,
0.40692567825317383,
0.22208671271800995,
-0.37178197503089905,
0.6769224405288696,
0.38187211751937866,
-0.2038806527853012,
-0.5012823343276978,
-1.1836028099060059,
0.49404269456863403,
0.21682609617710114,
-0.24760283529758453,
0.42215803265571594,
-0.2892443835735321,
-0.1157868430018425,
-0.152467280626297,
0.31145381927490234,
-0.30495792627334595,
0.019857697188854218,
0.018757525831460953,
0.4081145226955414,
0.2162240445613861,
0.16228404641151428,
0.3123524785041809,
-0.03383165970444679,
-0.07397711277008057,
-0.3278871178627014,
0.7134442329406738,
0.0007415565196424723,
0.06837671995162964,
-0.4005153477191925,
0.7522069215774536,
0.49144530296325684,
-0.3643629550933838,
1.181779146194458,
0.33625590801239014,
-0.6951544284820557,
-0.20829689502716064,
-0.4474480450153351,
-0.1437232941389084,
-0.4885469079017639,
0.6513494849205017,
-0.4923153221607208,
-0.0647367313504219,
0.5138616561889648,
0.2219725102186203,
-0.2753880023956299,
0.37009498476982117,
0.6509223580360413,
-0.15288802981376648,
1.3577724695205688,
0.6611025333404541,
-0.5970187187194824,
0.27333590388298035,
-0.1373557597398758,
0.41905373334884644,
-0.26984304189682007,
-0.31929004192352295,
-0.4903070032596588,
-0.11952053755521774,
-0.3232552707195282,
-0.3849067687988281,
0.15561965107917786,
0.05732177570462227,
-0.017481515184044838,
0.6687096953392029,
-0.4369962215423584,
0.14677724242210388,
0.3765923082828522,
-0.3200570046901703,
0.3760222792625427,
0.08982399851083755,
-0.7222573757171631,
-0.05966630205512047,
-0.5798899531364441,
-0.10231959819793701,
1.2865443229675293,
0.2672196626663208,
0.34816670417785645,
-0.06255999952554703,
0.38180363178253174,
0.3528434634208679,
0.14723679423332214,
-0.8692240118980408,
0.43622642755508423,
-0.22107769548892975,
-0.6910923719406128,
-0.06747686862945557,
-0.25942984223365784,
-0.6533701419830322,
-0.23453757166862488,
-0.2759002149105072,
-0.35361045598983765,
0.1931222826242447,
0.0499664843082428,
-0.24410632252693176,
0.18298156559467316,
-0.5019420385360718,
0.6962320804595947,
-0.5002186298370361,
0.00426149507984519,
-0.321283221244812,
-0.49247679114341736,
-0.11321955919265747,
-0.27982452511787415,
0.6019976735115051,
0.17715007066726685,
-0.32815536856651306,
0.6881927847862244,
-0.35697799921035767,
0.5763581991195679,
0.024233024567365646,
-0.171100452542305,
0.06066729128360748,
0.3669053018093109,
0.6951377987861633,
-0.08589338511228561,
-0.24475784599781036,
0.4059167206287384,
-0.03261411562561989,
-0.3254394829273224,
-0.5554695725440979,
0.7456607818603516,
-0.7385210990905762,
-0.1641332060098648,
-0.6420310735702515,
-0.7802618145942688,
-0.19705484807491302,
0.390849769115448,
0.19276991486549377,
0.24266430735588074,
-0.29637235403060913,
-0.1298125833272934,
0.032574012875556946,
-0.2838935852050781,
0.6541166305541992,
0.5900861024856567,
-0.16822980344295502,
-0.8665881752967834,
0.3834438920021057,
0.30942460894584656,
0.1398693323135376,
0.6378255486488342,
-0.15297523140907288,
-0.4533698260784149,
-0.5841115117073059,
-0.4630054235458374,
0.12716253101825714,
-0.8402698636054993,
-0.3354741930961609,
-0.6821593046188354,
0.01888413168489933,
-1.167227864265442,
-0.24312813580036163,
-0.49366137385368347,
-0.560973584651947,
-0.10712987929582596,
-0.332694947719574,
0.06217255815863609,
0.6741345524787903,
0.006995443720370531,
0.19261138141155243,
-0.4722933769226074,
0.49051034450531006,
0.09913578629493713,
0.23947708308696747,
-0.3923327326774597,
-0.4169715642929077,
-0.5127806663513184,
0.018678266555070877,
-0.20235608518123627,
-1.0421991348266602,
1.0657873153686523,
0.49444010853767395,
0.6142226457595825,
0.34177640080451965,
-0.11925816535949707,
0.6808789968490601,
-0.8973855972290039,
0.6550494432449341,
0.5236114859580994,
-0.9746332168579102,
0.598177433013916,
-0.07332456111907959,
0.33581751585006714,
0.5029476284980774,
0.47378867864608765,
-0.68675297498703,
-0.14999625086784363,
-0.16461493074893951,
-0.6943507790565491,
0.32887229323387146,
0.04989996552467346,
-0.002333825221285224,
-0.3634980320930481,
0.3958507180213928,
0.028609272092580795,
0.4954540431499481,
-0.7131014466285706,
-0.4535292983055115,
-0.32393091917037964,
-0.7047752737998962,
-0.41226378083229065,
-0.1367853432893753,
0.34404751658439636,
-0.6874133944511414,
0.5731084942817688,
-0.35940587520599365,
0.4446139335632324,
0.00804757047444582,
0.07377934455871582,
-0.31451353430747986,
-0.04542932286858559,
0.17148011922836304,
0.48344677686691284,
-0.05768248811364174,
0.209417924284935,
0.39802712202072144,
-0.5351195335388184,
0.07964931428432465,
0.3207842707633972,
0.1940261721611023,
-0.018537716940045357,
0.3470473289489746,
0.5284267663955688,
-0.20090466737747192,
-0.6513785123825073,
0.5189498662948608,
-0.01986992172896862,
0.042197927832603455,
-0.6437022686004639,
-0.484213262796402,
-0.05031420290470123,
-0.18373890221118927,
0.41758525371551514,
0.31205931305885315,
0.4961862862110138,
-0.7646054029464722,
0.23516187071800232,
0.5401903986930847,
-0.3849165141582489,
-0.33965638279914856,
0.7909563183784485,
0.1850508749485016,
-0.08259415626525879,
0.48052966594696045,
-0.15826940536499023,
-0.6199427843093872,
0.6399080753326416,
0.6324142217636108,
0.8863856792449951,
-0.8544774055480957,
0.07771100103855133,
0.36194631457328796,
0.5392157435417175,
-0.01652480475604534,
0.19415171444416046,
-0.011607810854911804,
-0.7958976626396179,
-0.5196077823638916,
-0.6572363972663879,
0.05104156211018562,
0.08425254374742508,
-0.2792690694332123,
0.6165140867233276,
-0.45214980840682983,
0.09278937429189682,
-0.37254688143730164,
0.17006425559520721,
-0.634082019329071,
0.3342307507991791,
0.2957736551761627,
1.1138209104537964,
-0.9343969225883484,
1.7254576683044434,
0.5914711952209473,
-0.3886609673500061,
-0.8526986241340637,
-0.1887243390083313,
-0.16309574246406555,
-0.8626611232757568,
0.9024397134780884,
0.12604208290576935,
0.05454730987548828,
-0.14621040225028992,
-0.05817814916372299,
-0.8291338086128235,
0.9761094450950623,
0.40390413999557495,
-0.6483458876609802,
-0.3051394522190094,
0.8549571633338928,
0.4077596962451935,
-0.49263623356819153,
0.37684229016304016,
0.5024443864822388,
0.3959433436393738,
-0.16488663852214813,
-1.3151246309280396,
0.04396597668528557,
-0.6325130462646484,
0.15130168199539185,
-0.012017186731100082,
-0.13186956942081451,
1.0976371765136719,
0.17478986084461212,
-0.0006850557983852923,
0.1864566057920456,
0.9267605543136597,
-0.11763402819633484,
-0.0020008389838039875,
0.44085463881492615,
0.46309760212898254,
0.4498939514160156,
0.23941951990127563,
1.142675518989563,
-0.8359929919242859,
0.22647954523563385,
0.948447048664093,
-0.06679890304803848,
0.9259331822395325,
0.732987105846405,
-0.26136213541030884,
0.44843438267707825,
0.37265071272850037,
0.27688857913017273,
0.9882195591926575,
-0.13149423897266388,
-0.3277692198753357,
-0.05905080959200859,
-0.025611653923988342,
-0.35561710596084595,
0.37510183453559875,
0.5186100006103516,
-0.6712056994438171,
0.15468350052833557,
0.24454006552696228,
-0.1655026078224182,
0.20641766488552094,
-0.2628358006477356,
0.5257786512374878,
0.11566347628831863,
-0.7932129502296448,
0.7239564061164856,
0.26317915320396423,
0.8947077989578247,
-0.5636765956878662,
-0.21618463099002838,
-0.17285704612731934,
0.44521504640579224,
-0.04454139992594719,
-0.47432681918144226,
0.43898773193359375,
-0.4527025520801544,
0.13719677925109863,
-0.3719126582145691,
0.8012445569038391,
-0.5849173069000244,
-0.714169442653656,
0.5329526662826538,
0.38008660078048706,
-0.13341942429542542,
-0.10439085960388184,
-0.9894647598266602,
-0.0859924703836441,
-0.15311633050441742,
0.033430006355047226,
0.13319893181324005,
0.42741167545318604,
0.31555864214897156,
0.8148312568664551,
0.41784271597862244,
0.6020934581756592,
0.24430149793624878,
-0.346431165933609,
0.6517435312271118,
-0.257750928401947,
-0.9097851514816284,
-0.7405709028244019,
0.304392009973526,
0.09451697766780853,
-0.11829712241888046,
0.5896092653274536,
0.7498836517333984,
0.678743839263916,
-0.13765370845794678,
1.1140742301940918,
-0.16657952964305878,
0.5198382139205933,
-0.3861846625804901,
0.9473375082015991,
-0.48097971081733704,
0.2511886954307556,
-0.25607311725616455,
-0.7932794690132141,
-0.37591034173965454,
0.8995630145072937,
-0.20857836306095123,
-0.013867486268281937,
0.9935389757156372,
0.7841472625732422,
-0.11054952442646027,
-0.1374308168888092,
0.3832181692123413,
0.23042036592960358,
0.3521232008934021,
0.5905401110649109,
0.4087039530277252,
-0.630104124546051,
0.5649322867393494,
-0.6575501561164856,
-0.3048988878726959,
0.07889608293771744,
-0.9504791498184204,
-0.829676628112793,
-1.0547493696212769,
-0.0866393893957138,
-0.4195863604545593,
0.2129419445991516,
1.0676757097244263,
0.5464475750923157,
-1.1702769994735718,
-0.45611947774887085,
-0.6856452226638794,
-0.3777618408203125,
-0.33113259077072144,
-0.18965508043766022,
0.41979917883872986,
-0.46378910541534424,
-1.1137059926986694,
0.5130754709243774,
-0.008249664679169655,
-0.05552290007472038,
-0.4128694236278534,
-0.38536185026168823,
-0.3468586504459381,
0.018280740827322006,
0.43560972809791565,
-0.06153659150004387,
-0.5787389278411865,
-0.05619537830352783,
-0.07718554139137268,
-0.22301657497882843,
-0.027994757518172264,
0.7762796878814697,
-1.0508311986923218,
0.5064408779144287,
0.4034276604652405,
0.4273207485675812,
0.026908520609140396,
-0.6623253226280212,
0.948946475982666,
-0.5344687104225159,
0.6146405935287476,
0.2401830106973648,
0.6324036717414856,
0.17891445755958557,
-0.4628797471523285,
0.11618584394454956,
0.2085370272397995,
-0.26870983839035034,
-0.6088100075721741,
0.10079746693372726,
-0.7395652532577515,
-0.47802045941352844,
1.0582953691482544,
-0.07242728769779205,
-0.23242495954036713,
-0.2392762303352356,
-0.16623465716838837,
0.5182173252105713,
-0.5346037745475769,
0.9825699925422668,
0.5748514533042908,
0.2957991659641266,
-0.29369857907295227,
-0.7508262991905212,
0.5606254935264587,
0.412406861782074,
-0.7217398881912231,
-0.01084888819605112,
0.1665661782026291,
-0.03981533274054527,
0.11328953504562378,
0.6020589470863342,
-0.22034117579460144,
0.0912981703877449,
-0.3482678234577179,
0.3318222165107727,
-0.041730623692274094,
-0.4192889630794525,
-0.22823534905910492,
0.12330204248428345,
0.10988450795412064,
-0.09866442531347275
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.05975v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.05975v1
|
Measuring Bias in a Ranked List using Term-based Representations
| 2024-03-09T18:24:58 | 2024-03-09T18:24:58 |
Amin Abolghasemi, Leif Azzopardi, Arian Askari, Maarten de Rijke, Suzan Verberne
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In most recent studies, gender bias in document ranking is evaluated with the
NFaiRR metric, which measures bias in a ranked list based on an aggregation
over the unbiasedness scores of each ranked document. This perspective in
measuring the bias of a ranked list has a key limitation: individual documents
of a ranked list might be biased while the ranked list as a whole balances the
groups' representations. To address this issue, we propose a novel metric
called TExFAIR (term exposure-based fairness), which is based on two new
extensions to a generic fairness evaluation framework, attention-weighted
ranking fairness (AWRF). TExFAIR assesses fairness based on the term-based
representation of groups in a ranked list: (i) an explicit definition of
associating documents to groups based on probabilistic term-level associations,
and (ii) a rank-biased discounting factor (RBDF) for counting
non-representative documents towards the measurement of the fairness of a
ranked list. We assess TExFAIR on the task of measuring gender bias in passage
ranking, and study the relationship between TExFAIR and NFaiRR. Our experiments
show that there is no strong correlation between TExFAIR and NFaiRR, which
indicates that TExFAIR measures a different dimension of fairness than NFaiRR.
With TExFAIR, we extend the AWRF framework to allow for the evaluation of
fairness in settings with term-based representations of groups in documents in
a ranked list.
|
[
-0.5049816370010376,
-0.44575467705726624,
0.5305486917495728,
0.0720859169960022,
0.21221794188022614,
0.27627816796302795,
0.38092222809791565,
-0.22222687304019928,
0.059675589203834534,
0.4978744089603424,
-0.3811820447444916,
-0.254454106092453,
-0.8920552134513855,
0.23681797087192535,
-0.5983586311340332,
1.441044807434082,
0.17215560376644135,
0.1589263677597046,
-0.6285814642906189,
-0.49069079756736755,
-0.34210896492004395,
-0.6064245700836182,
-0.44484812021255493,
-0.4880402386188507,
0.45989614725112915,
0.17431150376796722,
0.8287423849105835,
0.4022681713104248,
0.8019245266914368,
0.29196715354919434,
-0.16615155339241028,
-0.24277235567569733,
-0.4051087200641632,
-0.20806506276130676,
-0.3187205195426941,
-0.5585340261459351,
-0.5670414566993713,
0.35175853967666626,
1.0849794149398804,
0.8177614808082581,
-0.22063307464122772,
0.3562428951263428,
-0.037823740392923355,
0.8152790069580078,
-0.7026208639144897,
-0.14158383011817932,
-0.2311154305934906,
0.4161844849586487,
-0.06576545536518097,
-0.199098140001297,
-0.2548462748527527,
-0.5346575379371643,
0.16881904006004333,
-0.44723328948020935,
0.5940966606140137,
0.38601937890052795,
0.651003897190094,
0.1869155764579773,
-0.6798761487007141,
-0.16401059925556183,
-0.6161774396896362,
0.9119399785995483,
-0.3839219808578491,
0.6810558438301086,
0.20149782299995422,
0.44122612476348877,
-0.10277123004198074,
-0.44431668519973755,
-0.42953264713287354,
-0.26772648096084595,
-0.22232213616371155,
0.162117600440979,
-0.2809319794178009,
-0.0740850418806076,
0.458614706993103,
0.44238635897636414,
-0.3246270418167114,
-0.3880588412284851,
-0.11821607500314713,
-0.22044184803962708,
0.6004148125648499,
-0.04321105778217316,
0.21138837933540344,
-0.06232457235455513,
-0.6008796691894531,
-0.06974095851182938,
-0.047849420458078384,
0.07746552675962448,
0.6362399458885193,
0.16032396256923676,
-0.11026708781719208,
0.4094946086406708,
0.03601469472050667,
0.40055879950523376,
0.3268793821334839,
-0.12060683965682983,
0.31345444917678833,
-0.16791799664497375,
-0.032319698482751846,
0.11262337118387222,
0.48179060220718384,
0.7513039708137512,
-0.0029250707011669874,
-0.5371768474578857,
-0.43850433826446533,
-0.12291507422924042,
0.15653268992900848,
-0.8571083545684814,
0.3592088520526886,
-0.05897308886051178,
-0.6318498849868774,
-0.43278542160987854,
0.43554437160491943,
-1.01752507686615,
-0.6114407777786255,
0.2107202261686325,
0.5902005434036255,
-0.013260544277727604,
-0.28112950921058655,
-0.2367171049118042,
-0.5758716464042664,
0.29216113686561584,
0.15216344594955444,
-0.6820305585861206,
0.7239533066749573,
0.813850462436676,
0.856149435043335,
-0.2180246114730835,
-0.11560752242803574,
-1.0480104684829712,
0.06318573653697968,
-0.21495871245861053,
0.9524708986282349,
-0.8338975310325623,
-0.5500510334968567,
-0.1722017526626587,
-0.12596850097179413,
0.006512065418064594,
-0.3733448386192322,
0.6327545642852783,
-0.3088766932487488,
0.5533851981163025,
-0.3714260458946228,
-0.6062807440757751,
0.011945270001888275,
0.15709486603736877,
-0.8488430976867676,
1.0881643295288086,
0.4113076627254486,
-1.034504771232605,
0.7414330244064331,
-0.883897602558136,
-0.24566775560379028,
-0.23921671509742737,
-0.3561551570892334,
-0.349586546421051,
-0.09355788677930832,
0.13684894144535065,
-0.20524179935455322,
-0.3206392228603363,
0.3611103892326355,
-0.27085891366004944,
-0.6200070381164551,
0.4845351278781891,
-0.1018192246556282,
0.36306867003440857,
0.05233006924390793,
-0.5113732218742371,
-0.010655632242560387,
-0.2883545458316803,
-0.22159072756767273,
-0.2880147397518158,
-0.2178572118282318,
-0.4209057688713074,
-0.13915704190731049,
0.353245347738266,
0.3708959221839905,
-0.008149240165948868,
-0.7247081995010376,
-0.24576899409294128,
-0.3340470790863037,
-0.07659932225942612,
1.1106083393096924,
-0.23736800253391266,
0.963325560092926,
-0.6838895082473755,
0.7121797204017639,
-0.16334113478660583,
0.17936784029006958,
0.47421351075172424,
-0.3408074975013733,
-0.5336136221885681,
0.0735045000910759,
0.6662973761558533,
0.21387159824371338,
-0.27245599031448364,
0.27350732684135437,
-0.46133729815483093,
-0.17449899017810822,
-0.3506866991519928,
-0.24197009205818176,
0.48566004633903503,
0.5494553446769714,
0.060551878064870834,
-0.6078667640686035,
-0.08042752742767334,
-0.9214383363723755,
-0.5361128449440002,
-0.10195232182741165,
0.08755990117788315,
0.44340285658836365,
0.6219190955162048,
-0.033770959824323654,
1.1245226860046387,
-0.5148884654045105,
-0.8329415917396545,
-0.07600384950637817,
0.3731095790863037,
0.11000104248523712,
0.3620661199092865,
0.6739702224731445,
-0.7310059070587158,
-0.06095847859978676,
-0.3104403614997864,
-0.30287545919418335,
-0.3703852593898773,
0.19255216419696808,
-0.5433458089828491,
0.6156537532806396,
0.3214901089668274,
0.08272046595811844,
0.332292377948761,
0.2849508225917816,
-1.060880184173584,
0.09276064485311508,
0.03220883011817932,
0.3761565387248993,
-0.727080225944519,
0.37970370054244995,
0.14144191145896912,
-0.3100546896457672,
-0.3869072496891022,
0.10217529535293579,
-0.16984345018863678,
0.11607756465673447,
-0.2560286223888397,
0.9477449655532837,
-0.14894694089889526,
-0.4947878420352936,
-0.30980539321899414,
0.12327638268470764,
0.2432197779417038,
0.30548524856567383,
0.048087649047374725,
0.7199486494064331,
-0.030142346397042274,
-0.26819801330566406,
-0.4225637912750244,
0.3525408208370209,
0.05537721514701843,
0.9212910532951355,
-0.2147579789161682,
0.24713067710399628,
-0.4818641245365143,
0.6315298676490784,
-0.8104432225227356,
0.3367682099342346,
0.14501577615737915,
-0.5864627361297607,
-0.06950106471776962,
-0.309321790933609,
-0.22413697838783264,
-0.22197601199150085,
-0.5811408162117004,
0.31740519404411316,
0.2785828709602356,
-0.29129934310913086,
0.8166943192481995,
0.40858009457588196,
0.18358321487903595,
-1.1342662572860718,
-0.6688985228538513,
-0.32534217834472656,
-0.29036474227905273,
-0.27052804827690125,
0.6356750726699829,
-0.23942027986049652,
-0.3588448464870453,
0.24925680458545685,
-0.8618873953819275,
-0.03854595497250557,
0.023225272074341774,
0.48282262682914734,
0.0989953801035881,
0.04823697730898857,
-0.0008276175940409303,
-0.0442579984664917,
-0.20781932771205902,
0.17598655819892883,
0.08000960201025009,
0.3786146640777588,
-0.17848138511180878,
-0.16583184897899628,
0.11657916009426117,
0.6265830993652344,
0.4748261570930481,
-0.321075439453125,
0.6971938014030457,
0.7869202494621277,
-0.39538800716400146,
-0.17744110524654388,
-0.837223470211029,
-0.22290612757205963,
-0.423993855714798,
0.028702301904559135,
-0.15191303193569183,
-1.0481387376785278,
0.6313795447349548,
0.30874308943748474,
0.08254000544548035,
0.6034286022186279,
-0.09539486467838287,
0.0484420470893383,
1.149620532989502,
1.0351461172103882,
-0.22336381673812866,
0.38011860847473145,
-0.17451731860637665,
-0.0288557019084692,
-0.8028606176376343,
-0.27639877796173096,
-0.8489205241203308,
-0.6623048782348633,
-0.9080392122268677,
-0.3533981144428253,
0.18286332488059998,
-0.1315160095691681,
-0.6105958223342896,
-0.47962242364883423,
-0.5049027800559998,
0.4811685383319855,
0.6635540723800659,
-0.030425041913986206,
0.35672852396965027,
0.10816758871078491,
-0.32057997584342957,
-0.000489288882818073,
-0.37138602137565613,
-0.5681743621826172,
1.2951451539993286,
0.2945139706134796,
0.4641088843345642,
0.3997906744480133,
0.7763893604278564,
0.9654032588005066,
0.48392453789711,
-0.6420435309410095,
0.5352771878242493,
-0.4228765666484833,
-0.631443202495575,
-0.27417728304862976,
-0.5907856822013855,
-0.658822238445282,
0.13236089050769806,
-0.12169583886861801,
-0.5721431374549866,
0.42241060733795166,
-0.3063223958015442,
-0.17127494513988495,
0.2494252771139145,
-0.335750013589859,
0.6081562042236328,
-0.1352260708808899,
-0.37355566024780273,
-0.09308435022830963,
-0.32331913709640503,
0.16506296396255493,
-0.10430517047643661,
0.50014728307724,
-0.3115581274032593,
-0.17818574607372284,
1.2644188404083252,
-0.4873436987400055,
0.19400359690189362,
-0.525719165802002,
0.019125081598758698,
-0.3204161822795868,
0.026053626090288162,
0.08574824035167694,
0.17012517154216766,
-0.5135577917098999,
0.3411485254764557,
-0.03701329603791237,
-0.24640929698944092,
-0.5145506262779236,
0.5797381401062012,
-0.6665717959403992,
-0.5842175483703613,
-1.2197461128234863,
-0.5604313611984253,
-0.10489121079444885,
0.3611147105693817,
-0.1302911341190338,
0.28329914808273315,
-0.3710172176361084,
0.0008465246646665037,
0.35850656032562256,
-0.22904351353645325,
0.3162054419517517,
0.8165668845176697,
-0.47059136629104614,
-0.24735797941684723,
0.5532698035240173,
0.27631741762161255,
0.07563457638025284,
0.7699229717254639,
0.1724163442850113,
-0.5471940636634827,
-0.10435999184846878,
-0.14549772441387177,
0.007860686630010605,
-0.6568713188171387,
-0.18665224313735962,
-0.8867444396018982,
-0.31688812375068665,
-0.16736136376857758,
-0.06899575889110565,
0.06269429624080658,
-0.6018102169036865,
0.25522470474243164,
-0.12832340598106384,
0.5201786160469055,
0.4163200259208679,
-0.12950704991817474,
0.23311901092529297,
-0.16958564519882202,
0.47038865089416504,
0.3013010323047638,
0.7671853303909302,
-0.02347157523036003,
-0.5345795154571533,
0.02483118325471878,
-0.3441939353942871,
-0.3242063820362091,
-0.5858049988746643,
0.14160184562206268,
0.09084794670343399,
0.8768832683563232,
0.171181783080101,
0.1694164127111435,
0.32421088218688965,
-0.28866350650787354,
0.5585778951644897,
-0.007763573434203863,
-1.0810694694519043,
0.4825725853443146,
-0.25216397643089294,
0.030462024733424187,
0.5561785697937012,
-0.02671641856431961,
-0.5712779760360718,
-0.8225264549255371,
-0.7161890864372253,
-0.6646803617477417,
1.0813270807266235,
0.3464083969593048,
0.03771296888589859,
0.030622629448771477,
0.08282854408025742,
0.18068963289260864,
0.350314736366272,
-0.7711980938911438,
-0.5540767312049866,
-0.2656952738761902,
-0.010344384238123894,
-0.06622082740068436,
-0.17759333550930023,
-0.12703381478786469,
-0.1490766853094101,
0.4161059856414795,
-0.11210756748914719,
0.737490177154541,
0.4394080638885498,
-0.21784797310829163,
-0.14548024535179138,
0.6014416813850403,
0.4066774249076843,
0.665796160697937,
-0.8753947019577026,
0.0927545353770256,
-0.0459509938955307,
-0.7415075898170471,
0.3442526161670685,
0.4773263931274414,
-0.27230560779571533,
0.1597519814968109,
0.14945559203624725,
0.4842642545700073,
0.020603522658348083,
-0.43621131777763367,
0.6213086247444153,
-0.19096776843070984,
-0.08870072662830353,
-0.21447297930717468,
0.13843953609466553,
-0.2719997763633728,
0.18039731681346893,
0.7076936960220337,
0.09450329095125198,
0.5778183341026306,
-0.4960830509662628,
0.4619671404361725,
0.5719335675239563,
-0.7651455998420715,
0.340798020362854,
0.9339475631713867,
0.2780545949935913,
-0.052477750927209854,
0.3049250841140747,
-0.13693757355213165,
-0.4215005934238434,
0.8895143866539001,
0.4128465950489044,
0.7418551445007324,
-0.24624314904212952,
0.49583977460861206,
0.28622516989707947,
0.5805482864379883,
-0.020189516246318817,
0.25214850902557373,
-0.017046669498085976,
-0.614427387714386,
0.2314206063747406,
-0.8657390475273132,
-0.4799395501613617,
-0.09062199294567108,
-0.751653254032135,
-0.1341770887374878,
-0.45491278171539307,
-0.5636857151985168,
0.09096106886863708,
0.27520784735679626,
-0.7622270584106445,
0.23233041167259216,
0.0053813261911273,
0.9470028877258301,
-0.7925291061401367,
0.22145390510559082,
0.6650561690330505,
-0.6400483846664429,
-0.3884645998477936,
0.5277751684188843,
0.10460332036018372,
-0.37999796867370605,
0.6395641565322876,
0.4923434555530548,
-0.32456496357917786,
-0.12942709028720856,
0.3122909963130951,
-0.7769068479537964,
1.1835390329360962,
0.48690780997276306,
-0.3376605212688446,
0.052083518356084824,
0.4584057927131653,
0.26878321170806885,
-0.38770413398742676,
0.7958446741104126,
0.5690255761146545,
0.6027205586433411,
-0.3335723280906677,
-0.8792216181755066,
0.2647399306297302,
-0.45759063959121704,
0.08215649425983429,
0.2712370753288269,
-0.8173267841339111,
0.6807003617286682,
-0.07672782242298126,
-0.12446416914463043,
-0.29317161440849304,
0.40290841460227966,
0.26872363686561584,
0.699227511882782,
0.7989850044250488,
0.44593024253845215,
0.9110516309738159,
-0.2994891107082367,
1.0457667112350464,
0.2054521143436432,
0.16106578707695007,
0.9692187309265137,
-0.5462874174118042,
0.5580950379371643,
0.4381566047668457,
-0.10411510616540909,
0.682584822177887,
0.18869604170322418,
-0.11115783452987671,
0.579192042350769,
0.22820615768432617,
-0.2867695987224579,
0.09368200600147247,
-0.5665396451950073,
-0.5632684230804443,
0.26662811636924744,
-0.025715330615639687,
-0.6147083044052124,
-0.3985980153083801,
0.10618750005960464,
0.10747929662466049,
0.30100882053375244,
-0.45759856700897217,
0.654948890209198,
0.09517481178045273,
-0.5444141030311584,
0.0626395046710968,
0.31558147072792053,
0.9842844009399414,
-0.25087738037109375,
-0.026704242452979088,
-0.6913101673126221,
0.07080518454313278,
-0.2911425828933716,
-0.8826918005943298,
0.13068725168704987,
0.25105610489845276,
-0.5637170672416687,
-0.17049314081668854,
0.6495079398155212,
-0.1060648113489151,
-1.0051956176757812,
0.5540034770965576,
0.6180527210235596,
-0.10893470048904419,
0.07035508006811142,
-0.6139917373657227,
-0.13667084276676178,
-0.3092435896396637,
-0.07202037423849106,
0.4889618158340454,
0.06355349719524384,
-0.3252829313278198,
0.7306027412414551,
0.41563549637794495,
-0.32855671644210815,
-0.1647997498512268,
0.5789124965667725,
0.4102086126804352,
-0.7164440751075745,
-0.7343716621398926,
-0.7194973230361938,
0.18620771169662476,
-0.2842547297477722,
0.001007197075523436,
0.5143369436264038,
0.8698131442070007,
0.513179361820221,
0.20126302540302277,
0.7135331034660339,
0.030444223433732986,
0.45365196466445923,
-0.2518940567970276,
1.2336143255233765,
-0.6850433349609375,
0.12322789430618286,
-0.6958668231964111,
-1.0306267738342285,
-0.0727287009358406,
0.607316792011261,
-0.25354817509651184,
0.44072839617729187,
0.7663012146949768,
0.7853140830993652,
-0.21631015837192535,
-0.06580813229084015,
-0.06321520358324051,
-0.007900342345237732,
0.09500625729560852,
0.3706851601600647,
0.6481806635856628,
-0.3855854868888855,
0.5923877954483032,
0.06379245966672897,
-0.34084585309028625,
-0.1085636094212532,
-1.0704514980316162,
-0.7929981350898743,
-0.4051479995250702,
-0.49391040205955505,
-0.3006313443183899,
0.3459857106208801,
0.7410238981246948,
0.5201265215873718,
-0.5004916191101074,
-0.3150014281272888,
0.19270458817481995,
0.6288893818855286,
-0.4162239730358124,
-0.3447034955024719,
0.41156241297721863,
0.15888771414756775,
-0.5728939175605774,
-0.13171087205410004,
-0.03800952807068825,
-0.2523607909679413,
-0.07804379612207413,
-0.19954316318035126,
-0.002992946421727538,
0.27512672543525696,
0.48147401213645935,
-0.2643747925758362,
-0.6569859981536865,
-0.3939332962036133,
-0.11140532791614532,
-0.016580158844590187,
-0.04871489107608795,
0.4757847785949707,
-1.0173439979553223,
0.2386828511953354,
0.28568050265312195,
0.25992950797080994,
0.31359216570854187,
0.0905190259218216,
0.6547788381576538,
-0.7832249999046326,
-0.08583415299654007,
0.04543297737836838,
0.2509462535381317,
0.3347817659378052,
-0.4770437777042389,
0.7234923839569092,
0.030667314305901527,
-0.37758758664131165,
-1.113340973854065,
-0.14350593090057373,
-1.1093947887420654,
-0.012697571888566017,
0.9453099966049194,
0.4048565924167633,
0.0847344845533371,
0.05865006893873215,
-0.028414594009518623,
0.3064841628074646,
-0.8861439228057861,
0.8057738542556763,
0.8649083971977234,
0.015846820548176765,
-0.26515069603919983,
-0.7858226299285889,
0.45961612462997437,
0.2685604393482208,
-0.616640567779541,
-0.17664076387882233,
0.44596636295318604,
0.43193331360816956,
0.06761195510625839,
1.0163915157318115,
-0.35730835795402527,
0.3979346454143524,
-0.38740766048431396,
0.0052316938526928425,
0.010161719284951687,
0.05883007496595383,
-0.16132788360118866,
0.2829369008541107,
-0.009408925659954548,
0.045259989798069
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.05973v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.05973v1
|
Calibrating Large Language Models Using Their Generations Only
| 2024-03-09T17:46:24 | 2024-03-09T17:46:24 |
Dennis Ulmer, Martin Gubri, Hwaran Lee, Sangdoo Yun, Seong Joon Oh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
As large language models (LLMs) are increasingly deployed in user-facing
applications, building trust and maintaining safety by accurately quantifying a
model's confidence in its prediction becomes even more important. However,
finding effective ways to calibrate LLMs - especially when the only interface
to the models is their generated text - remains a challenge. We propose APRICOT
(auxiliary prediction of confidence targets): A method to set confidence
targets and train an additional model that predicts an LLM's confidence based
on its textual input and output alone. This approach has several advantages: It
is conceptually simple, does not require access to the target model beyond its
output, does not interfere with the language generation, and has a multitude of
potential usages, for instance by verbalizing the predicted confidence or
adjusting the given answer based on the confidence. We show how our approach
performs competitively in terms of calibration error for white-box and
black-box LLMs on closed-book question-answering to detect incorrect LLM
answers.
|
[
-0.1185401901602745,
-0.5748211145401001,
0.6367220282554626,
0.1798798143863678,
-0.10556574165821075,
-0.08563873171806335,
-0.5951281189918518,
-0.34841352701187134,
-0.07834511250257492,
0.6009191274642944,
-0.7028692960739136,
-0.5023322105407715,
-0.5784781575202942,
0.13774323463439941,
-0.37592509388923645,
0.7337186932563782,
-0.08990480750799179,
0.059011060744524,
-0.2619844377040863,
0.13339944183826447,
-0.459305077791214,
-0.42931225895881653,
-0.8129896521568298,
-0.3628523647785187,
0.37276360392570496,
0.58442223072052,
0.5862854719161987,
0.6919431686401367,
0.0803016647696495,
0.3182453215122223,
-0.0421116016805172,
0.20439067482948303,
-0.4752497375011444,
0.35781824588775635,
0.049863677471876144,
-0.7120434045791626,
-0.07636284828186035,
-0.09852898865938187,
0.49730247259140015,
0.39540669322013855,
-0.22249162197113037,
0.07153977453708649,
0.34893155097961426,
0.3285408318042755,
-0.5969448089599609,
0.33973178267478943,
-0.8889610171318054,
-0.23497603833675385,
-0.05516388267278671,
-0.5515989065170288,
-0.8418326377868652,
-0.5606042742729187,
-0.2561919093132019,
-0.5936764478683472,
-0.0032997336238622665,
0.05153629556298256,
0.4833543002605438,
0.38877275586128235,
-0.5678168535232544,
-0.22977763414382935,
-0.69540935754776,
0.9711920022964478,
-0.7627192735671997,
0.17604583501815796,
0.4670827388763428,
0.36409491300582886,
-0.3224231004714966,
-0.3747214674949646,
-0.3299419581890106,
-0.47640612721443176,
-0.05271177366375923,
0.03021354414522648,
0.3726661503314972,
0.06501927971839905,
0.05374690517783165,
0.11799902468919754,
-0.45357993245124817,
0.03256634250283241,
-0.18180261552333832,
-0.2471632957458496,
0.7631112933158875,
-0.05987530201673508,
0.1330697238445282,
0.1127580851316452,
-0.2691417336463928,
-0.27121439576148987,
-1.04456627368927,
-0.20698921382427216,
0.3864290416240692,
0.6215178966522217,
-0.005442952271550894,
0.8300347328186035,
-0.11057760566473007,
0.5485002398490906,
0.056346744298934937,
-0.22951699793338776,
0.003716349136084318,
-0.014557273127138615,
0.002615370089188218,
0.31885388493537903,
0.8344975113868713,
0.08407256007194519,
0.650883674621582,
0.11798034608364105,
-0.23788557946681976,
0.024761032313108444,
0.17197410762310028,
-0.7648778557777405,
-0.24912090599536896,
0.26242220401763916,
0.35171863436698914,
-0.4734423756599426,
-0.1269397735595703,
-0.5584861636161804,
-0.48475655913352966,
-0.13033975660800934,
0.4586363732814789,
-0.44361576437950134,
0.015031924471259117,
-0.2453019618988037,
0.26872938871383667,
0.06746669113636017,
0.4883820414543152,
-0.9069475531578064,
0.1791355162858963,
0.7056875824928284,
0.5992976427078247,
0.0980832576751709,
-0.19662028551101685,
-0.7609267234802246,
0.20373503863811493,
-0.5591402649879456,
0.5171071887016296,
-0.45613765716552734,
-0.5019477009773254,
0.1836661547422409,
-0.13552869856357574,
-0.1325806975364685,
-0.12009220570325851,
0.8628697395324707,
-0.4727005064487457,
-0.00019190763123333454,
0.029517190530896187,
-0.567349374294281,
-0.09077447652816772,
0.44262105226516724,
-0.43237054347991943,
1.0036360025405884,
-0.08620654791593552,
-0.6503105759620667,
0.13057151436805725,
-0.19049355387687683,
-0.4392642378807068,
0.015400194562971592,
-0.3892272412776947,
-0.25953567028045654,
0.15036022663116455,
0.31088629364967346,
0.33688244223594666,
-0.19339030981063843,
0.17060673236846924,
-0.2666550874710083,
-0.2818147838115692,
0.3761053681373596,
-0.7639092803001404,
0.5156705975532532,
0.12337139248847961,
-0.19076400995254517,
-0.035417765378952026,
-0.6868625283241272,
0.37347501516342163,
0.029613735154271126,
-0.4978763461112976,
-0.34744882583618164,
0.05069997161626816,
-0.04070879891514778,
0.05560055747628212,
0.5254865288734436,
-0.7919153571128845,
-0.010635885410010815,
-0.4402819573879242,
0.1606418788433075,
0.8400323390960693,
-0.02076263539493084,
0.16418632864952087,
-0.4475456476211548,
0.5807914137840271,
-0.2924741804599762,
-0.02845466323196888,
-0.4178946614265442,
-0.4961774945259094,
-0.8446860909461975,
-0.051356349140405655,
0.3853243291378021,
0.47881701588630676,
-0.6511200070381165,
0.5752902626991272,
-0.4519975781440735,
-0.6157895922660828,
-0.2104247361421585,
0.3914875388145447,
0.3850048780441284,
0.46286630630493164,
0.04446028918027878,
-0.08687679469585419,
-0.4477553963661194,
-0.660700261592865,
-0.3060663342475891,
-0.520606517791748,
-0.09443290531635284,
0.30986487865448,
0.0864097997546196,
0.1451786905527115,
0.8141934275627136,
-0.44116175174713135,
-0.17154532670974731,
-0.1461344212293625,
0.20022286474704742,
0.06680487841367722,
0.3924658000469208,
0.1376054286956787,
-0.8370702266693115,
-0.7642955780029297,
0.17554302513599396,
-0.49542126059532166,
-0.20706520974636078,
0.041894473135471344,
0.10344377160072327,
0.13897328078746796,
0.3847784399986267,
-0.4548824429512024,
0.1414518505334854,
0.9603008031845093,
0.04158218950033188,
0.4325936436653137,
-0.21082115173339844,
0.19064806401729584,
-1.1219191551208496,
0.03855450078845024,
0.25980493426322937,
-0.5548580884933472,
-0.6439803242683411,
0.11818699538707733,
0.31467145681381226,
0.056971196085214615,
-0.4122709035873413,
0.7099229097366333,
-0.3820473253726959,
0.23325204849243164,
-0.2725585699081421,
0.14283880591392517,
0.09283888339996338,
0.2884046733379364,
0.2716422379016876,
0.9026485681533813,
0.2160186767578125,
-0.48385724425315857,
0.16090670228004456,
0.4132288098335266,
-0.2490689903497696,
0.546404242515564,
-0.4801127016544342,
0.19346608221530914,
0.06333816796541214,
0.28618186712265015,
-1.1452077627182007,
-0.4238450825214386,
-0.12555617094039917,
-0.6988197565078735,
0.5038949251174927,
-0.3477155566215515,
-0.2870807945728302,
-0.30238422751426697,
-0.27944216132164,
0.26829224824905396,
0.5992966890335083,
-0.5550167560577393,
0.7895902991294861,
0.1509028524160385,
-0.5048789978027344,
-0.7309512495994568,
-0.913216233253479,
-0.03342170640826225,
-0.09719929099082947,
-0.563044548034668,
-0.02782687358558178,
-0.16730715334415436,
0.06488840281963348,
-0.33462074398994446,
-0.09222087264060974,
-0.04793420061469078,
0.08179890364408493,
0.4025932550430298,
0.2884184718132019,
-0.25032883882522583,
0.10232063382863998,
0.04570716619491577,
-0.11913618445396423,
-0.06602740287780762,
-0.025624090805649757,
0.6001512408256531,
0.1503237783908844,
-0.5003855228424072,
-0.12448268383741379,
0.07117225974798203,
0.539077639579773,
-0.3508540987968445,
0.7596535682678223,
0.20358076691627502,
-0.4219553470611572,
-0.4522862732410431,
-0.7116707563400269,
-0.26232194900512695,
-0.5425034761428833,
0.3732812702655792,
-0.36971965432167053,
-0.6353996992111206,
0.283459335565567,
-0.007504613604396582,
0.3002777695655823,
0.3584613502025604,
0.7354565262794495,
0.4331374764442444,
1.2154459953308105,
0.7255918383598328,
0.11645961552858353,
0.3062174916267395,
0.19644491374492645,
0.12341392785310745,
-0.8364033699035645,
-0.12164902687072754,
-0.7158798575401306,
0.10719883441925049,
-0.47691887617111206,
-0.2551294267177582,
0.4389786124229431,
-0.052862245589494705,
-0.2999962866306305,
0.4641977548599243,
-0.3912891745567322,
0.534085750579834,
0.6296427249908447,
0.20518217980861664,
0.6504764556884766,
-0.09901701658964157,
-0.16018688678741455,
0.04829641431570053,
-0.6304694414138794,
-0.732690691947937,
1.4160810708999634,
0.4773644506931305,
1.0918537378311157,
-0.06469468027353287,
0.9337759613990784,
-0.17767740786075592,
1.034146785736084,
-0.7555360794067383,
0.46843069791793823,
-0.19641481339931488,
-0.811082661151886,
-0.29088151454925537,
-0.7617663145065308,
-0.5507452487945557,
0.06435785442590714,
-0.14740802347660065,
-0.9649747610092163,
0.09233821928501129,
0.4571763575077057,
-0.4684085547924042,
0.0858515053987503,
-0.7526459097862244,
0.7725260257720947,
-0.4559422433376312,
-0.46221697330474854,
0.11705528944730759,
-0.3521239757537842,
0.6612571477890015,
-0.6059401631355286,
0.27164334058761597,
-0.2769821286201477,
-0.13790813088417053,
0.5158817768096924,
-0.4202524423599243,
0.8417213559150696,
0.08563535660505295,
-0.24300576746463776,
0.3201654851436615,
0.3779503405094147,
0.7229112386703491,
0.06121625006198883,
-0.42015641927719116,
-0.1980234682559967,
0.3374597132205963,
-0.11442055553197861,
-0.30092111229896545,
1.0181297063827515,
-0.8231397867202759,
-0.6070046424865723,
-0.563093364238739,
-0.6039008498191833,
-0.621391773223877,
0.33361825346946716,
0.2675900161266327,
0.3125399947166443,
-0.5222476124763489,
0.23639744520187378,
0.46408963203430176,
-0.18574321269989014,
0.10123393684625626,
0.4758628010749817,
-0.24110540747642517,
-0.2908032536506653,
0.6096929311752319,
-0.13150261342525482,
0.4873647689819336,
0.46888044476509094,
0.3185625374317169,
-0.635310709476471,
-0.48263847827911377,
-0.5139344930648804,
0.0875767171382904,
-0.8534245491027832,
-0.3419491946697235,
-0.4095812737941742,
-0.2652094066143036,
-0.3163006007671356,
-0.03269634023308754,
-0.5385246872901917,
-0.30898433923721313,
-0.15779811143875122,
0.06331732869148254,
0.47531142830848694,
0.5412934422492981,
0.04812583327293396,
0.5546427369117737,
-0.7974438071250916,
-0.1040244996547699,
0.28555935621261597,
0.22336207330226898,
-0.2566630244255066,
-0.6255205869674683,
-0.00683080917224288,
0.5010845065116882,
-0.42097246646881104,
-0.7267965078353882,
0.42744678258895874,
0.4295528531074524,
0.2902464270591736,
0.18772003054618835,
0.23529423773288727,
0.43841731548309326,
-0.5889833569526672,
0.49006447196006775,
0.2089112550020218,
-0.7509419322013855,
0.4240991771221161,
-0.22142015397548676,
0.10088355839252472,
0.9729635715484619,
0.3010771572589874,
-0.6007667183876038,
-0.4385133981704712,
-0.3923861086368561,
-0.719316303730011,
0.6177777647972107,
0.09929925948381424,
0.3609813451766968,
-0.05530818551778793,
0.23989549279212952,
-0.07098513096570969,
0.2840695381164551,
-0.7548325061798096,
-0.0012110288953408599,
0.05994776263833046,
-0.9003155827522278,
-0.5215233564376831,
-0.11509373784065247,
-0.2983669936656952,
0.2979131042957306,
0.9788633584976196,
-0.3197992444038391,
-0.19559602439403534,
0.012404762208461761,
-0.009215136058628559,
-0.6165882349014282,
0.33501142263412476,
0.2558908462524414,
0.532805860042572,
-0.32280048727989197,
0.19642262160778046,
0.13431069254875183,
-0.5227999091148376,
0.4541051387786865,
0.2755695879459381,
-0.28025180101394653,
-0.12679579854011536,
0.2129569798707962,
0.3577524721622467,
0.18799443542957306,
-0.9113410711288452,
0.7063120007514954,
-0.13138936460018158,
0.009027213789522648,
-0.6370172500610352,
0.17903900146484375,
0.14461560547351837,
-0.017275003716349602,
0.3610345721244812,
0.01118047721683979,
-0.34759461879730225,
-0.5552249550819397,
0.45077478885650635,
0.536195695400238,
-0.394471138715744,
0.0381137952208519,
0.7773853540420532,
0.28338339924812317,
-0.286048948764801,
0.38103172183036804,
0.09198983758687973,
-0.4899987280368805,
0.6657597422599792,
0.5387788414955139,
0.868181586265564,
-0.6309577226638794,
0.03957441821694374,
0.3267265856266022,
0.5321013927459717,
-0.37066206336021423,
-0.02219580113887787,
0.46194037795066833,
-0.9086652398109436,
-0.673672080039978,
-0.8154208064079285,
-0.7031383514404297,
0.17615774273872375,
-0.4276881814002991,
0.46917247772216797,
-0.4455406963825226,
-0.1122155413031578,
-0.17540958523750305,
0.04308571293950081,
-0.6081622242927551,
0.4017561972141266,
0.16933414340019226,
1.079797387123108,
-1.0413472652435303,
0.863796591758728,
0.5473400950431824,
-0.1825215071439743,
-1.0833293199539185,
0.10006977617740631,
0.1351611316204071,
-1.0749740600585938,
0.1726081669330597,
0.28516674041748047,
-0.10024787485599518,
0.204501211643219,
-0.42102953791618347,
-0.7717662453651428,
0.9941705465316772,
0.47893160581588745,
-0.8238885402679443,
0.00648352038115263,
0.17613396048545837,
0.34726786613464355,
-0.4573216140270233,
0.4668373465538025,
0.4418572783470154,
0.5554298758506775,
0.5344581007957458,
-0.8130113482475281,
0.10469597578048706,
-0.12723001837730408,
-0.0853152945637703,
0.20521408319473267,
-0.4359717071056366,
0.6962686777114868,
-0.09016299992799759,
-0.28443780541419983,
0.6095595359802246,
0.4769633114337921,
0.5336881875991821,
-0.01517130434513092,
0.5553842782974243,
0.3401808440685272,
0.557244598865509,
-0.22420404851436615,
1.2602671384811401,
-0.6840353012084961,
0.3085606098175049,
1.239321231842041,
-0.2878519892692566,
1.1714102029800415,
0.49140945076942444,
-0.028590301051735878,
0.11742737144231796,
0.7742733359336853,
0.31018856167793274,
0.288039892911911,
0.16022196412086487,
-0.3835422694683075,
-0.26163777709007263,
-0.0075202276930212975,
-0.06939823925495148,
0.2895609140396118,
0.46466708183288574,
-0.37630796432495117,
-0.04404451325535774,
-0.28845834732055664,
0.17848967015743256,
0.24210840463638306,
-0.26945188641548157,
0.5474092960357666,
0.305820494890213,
-0.9407050609588623,
0.6158756613731384,
0.23737113177776337,
0.5601840019226074,
-0.8735566735267639,
0.1339050829410553,
-0.107872873544693,
0.47323548793792725,
-0.15011106431484222,
-0.652843713760376,
-0.02151442877948284,
0.011998032219707966,
0.6013010144233704,
0.17642651498317719,
0.5692510604858398,
-0.8422818779945374,
-0.888667643070221,
-0.009738430380821228,
0.3943936228752136,
-0.14070959389209747,
-0.20336973667144775,
-0.47509077191352844,
0.19806930422782898,
0.024646122008562088,
-0.47872647643089294,
0.09680556505918503,
0.3810274600982666,
0.13524752855300903,
0.7810073494911194,
0.5399982929229736,
0.23663605749607086,
0.11462537199258804,
-0.25368306040763855,
0.6091775298118591,
-0.20443928241729736,
-0.47441160678863525,
-0.7197262048721313,
0.283500075340271,
-0.0016674072248861194,
-0.3154893219470978,
0.805388867855072,
0.5144349336624146,
0.6139337420463562,
0.1554853767156601,
0.9941463470458984,
0.2267601042985916,
0.540105938911438,
-0.517906904220581,
0.39747220277786255,
-0.5833920836448669,
0.47055354714393616,
-0.1240098774433136,
-1.2530553340911865,
-0.29267096519470215,
0.6906947493553162,
-0.5698555707931519,
0.3377288281917572,
0.6614186763763428,
1.0783458948135376,
-0.13350272178649902,
0.05805196985602379,
0.36714088916778564,
0.39021655917167664,
0.23839887976646423,
0.6788474321365356,
0.6946563124656677,
-0.23647752404212952,
0.671261191368103,
-0.4435485005378723,
-0.5459632277488708,
-0.29297304153442383,
-1.1028268337249756,
-0.704846978187561,
-0.27987343072891235,
-0.2113485187292099,
-0.3871753215789795,
0.09136681258678436,
0.9582787752151489,
0.6672459244728088,
-0.8761880993843079,
-0.3372552990913391,
-0.1805230677127838,
-0.26274561882019043,
0.06751668453216553,
-0.13070213794708252,
0.19034650921821594,
-0.16193526983261108,
-0.8762908577919006,
0.3500467538833618,
0.06893327832221985,
0.14212565124034882,
-0.46122103929519653,
-0.21449525654315948,
-0.029925018548965454,
0.5087544322013855,
0.19275540113449097,
0.40987277030944824,
-0.5334200263023376,
-0.5972536206245422,
-0.21196724474430084,
-0.20700626075267792,
0.10137049853801727,
0.5795555710792542,
-0.3770756423473358,
0.37296199798583984,
0.2461649477481842,
0.6598647236824036,
0.6280612349510193,
0.33067095279693604,
0.9240654706954956,
-1.1151503324508667,
0.1590741127729416,
0.3147544264793396,
0.45959165692329407,
0.693548858165741,
-0.4690341651439667,
0.412801593542099,
-0.351775199174881,
-0.5630682706832886,
-0.7126640677452087,
0.3196219503879547,
-0.7684628367424011,
-0.042511969804763794,
1.2864993810653687,
-0.16108374297618866,
-0.4112545847892761,
0.049917325377464294,
-0.26829519867897034,
0.17390690743923187,
-0.4302150011062622,
0.6473430395126343,
0.6293208003044128,
0.37712541222572327,
-0.3083069324493408,
-0.6609671115875244,
0.44725102186203003,
0.3936507999897003,
-0.741122841835022,
0.3176228404045105,
0.3371870219707489,
0.35946568846702576,
0.22104409337043762,
0.5026622414588928,
-0.14210905134677887,
0.10988780111074448,
-0.07140402495861053,
0.12133543938398361,
-0.056704118847846985,
-0.28399723768234253,
-0.19730673730373383,
0.027229510247707367,
0.754118025302887,
0.03708278015255928
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.05931v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.05931v1
|
Thread Detection and Response Generation using Transformers with Prompt Optimisation
| 2024-03-09T14:50:20 | 2024-03-09T14:50:20 |
Kevin Joshua T, Arnav Agarwal, Shriya Sanjay, Yash Sarda, John Sahaya Rani Alex, Saurav Gupta, Sushant Kumar, Vishwanath Kamath
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, I.2.7; I.2.6
|
Conversational systems are crucial for human-computer interaction, managing
complex dialogues by identifying threads and prioritising responses. This is
especially vital in multi-party conversations, where precise identification of
threads and strategic response prioritisation ensure efficient dialogue
management. To address these challenges an end-to-end model that identifies
threads and prioritises their response generation based on the importance was
developed, involving a systematic decomposition of the problem into discrete
components - thread detection, prioritisation, and performance optimisation
which was meticulously analysed and optimised. These refined components
seamlessly integrate into a unified framework, in conversational systems.
Llama2 7b is used due to its high level of generalisation but the system can be
updated with any open source Large Language Model(LLM). The computational
capabilities of the Llama2 model was augmented by using fine tuning methods and
strategic prompting techniques to optimise the model's performance, reducing
computational time and increasing the accuracy of the model. The model achieves
up to 10x speed improvement, while generating more coherent results compared to
existing models.
|
[
-0.6941428184509277,
-0.9616321325302124,
0.48749586939811707,
0.42470571398735046,
-0.38490983843803406,
0.2276599258184433,
-0.23454047739505768,
-0.4880661070346832,
0.009519911371171474,
0.5361389517784119,
-0.8114000558853149,
0.059297699481248856,
-0.40822869539260864,
0.24986638128757477,
-0.5271166563034058,
0.8629294037818909,
0.11494450271129608,
-0.10954157263040543,
-0.2690492868423462,
-0.1463382989168167,
-0.5918856859207153,
-0.6243164539337158,
-0.8673097491264343,
-0.4900503158569336,
0.3905223309993744,
0.6371335387229919,
0.5090761780738831,
0.1816672831773758,
0.7010605931282043,
0.4429541528224945,
-0.45070838928222656,
0.27630671858787537,
-0.5647270679473877,
0.7130387425422668,
0.013783317059278488,
-0.450405478477478,
-0.45336946845054626,
-0.31072568893432617,
0.33627113699913025,
0.4210614562034607,
-0.3663488030433655,
0.4781673550605774,
0.29260432720184326,
0.4493062198162079,
-0.5597192049026489,
0.3652924597263336,
-0.6235941648483276,
0.028892388567328453,
0.0014541051350533962,
-0.5356907248497009,
-0.5201300978660583,
-0.3142782151699066,
0.14527086913585663,
-0.31424880027770996,
0.1456492692232132,
0.1116630956530571,
0.514755368232727,
0.3968616724014282,
-0.03518553823232651,
-0.42184945940971375,
-0.9138541221618652,
0.7933545112609863,
-0.6574070453643799,
-0.03955221548676491,
-0.04596444219350815,
0.47019872069358826,
-0.21198251843452454,
-0.7050476670265198,
-0.6049140095710754,
-0.004002774134278297,
-0.07312516123056412,
0.3055399954319,
-0.3872501254081726,
0.1375662088394165,
0.336345911026001,
0.31482064723968506,
-0.4613310694694519,
0.11665064096450806,
-0.2531536817550659,
-0.07802952826023102,
0.3490167260169983,
0.6530287861824036,
0.0511745885014534,
-0.14225491881370544,
-0.18919090926647186,
0.06054012477397919,
-0.5133916735649109,
0.16668207943439484,
0.46722638607025146,
0.311735600233078,
-0.10658254474401474,
0.43122872710227966,
-0.3208642303943634,
0.45727047324180603,
0.5488932728767395,
-0.3723677396774292,
-0.1459464430809021,
-0.37702733278274536,
-0.04571430757641792,
-0.021123822778463364,
0.8232212066650391,
0.46662601828575134,
0.3156708776950836,
0.1531582921743393,
-0.23075328767299652,
0.35227468609809875,
0.27300184965133667,
-0.9372422695159912,
-0.05086936801671982,
0.2811494469642639,
-0.5817812085151672,
-0.6404664516448975,
-0.41570135951042175,
-0.6425907611846924,
-0.1436060070991516,
-0.4787517786026001,
-0.09096035361289978,
0.014441781677305698,
-0.5047888159751892,
0.007841872051358223,
-0.06895683705806732,
0.34670260548591614,
0.3107147216796875,
-0.8539952039718628,
0.16261067986488342,
0.6311008930206299,
0.6123146414756775,
-0.20431265234947205,
0.23333968222141266,
-0.3006684184074402,
0.2611978352069855,
-0.32463929057121277,
1.1745102405548096,
-0.6499006152153015,
-0.6905122995376587,
0.06301867216825485,
-0.13722994923591614,
0.05733269825577736,
-0.8219183087348938,
0.6920666694641113,
-0.5227404832839966,
0.2560882866382599,
-0.23393037915229797,
-0.23988837003707886,
-0.08252597600221634,
0.193618506193161,
-0.5544335842132568,
0.9844341278076172,
0.2116423100233078,
-0.9163349866867065,
-0.0779045969247818,
-0.6977836489677429,
-0.40188226103782654,
0.0505085326731205,
-0.05317050963640213,
-0.42800360918045044,
0.17248933017253876,
0.35009828209877014,
0.3234708607196808,
-0.8392340540885925,
0.38293543457984924,
-0.23118917644023895,
-0.27604174613952637,
0.45631980895996094,
-0.6335809230804443,
0.2988262474536896,
0.4010189473628998,
-0.21792273223400116,
0.4135173261165619,
-0.5864900946617126,
-0.08718492835760117,
0.10723020136356354,
-0.38712313771247864,
0.38252806663513184,
0.3656558096408844,
0.07959126681089401,
0.13655008375644684,
0.33684012293815613,
-0.2722058892250061,
0.001336812973022461,
-0.3730573356151581,
0.7011483311653137,
1.0838159322738647,
-0.008262117393314838,
0.3230575919151306,
-0.31045010685920715,
0.7147496342658997,
0.34681758284568787,
0.4416194260120392,
-0.5842748880386353,
-0.5907070636749268,
-1.1083711385726929,
0.01726214960217476,
-0.08225417882204056,
0.8191843032836914,
-0.681786060333252,
0.36690080165863037,
0.006632914766669273,
-0.1984599083662033,
-0.3548213541507721,
0.05344322323799133,
0.404228150844574,
0.6471967101097107,
0.07434007525444031,
-0.5290155410766602,
-0.6837380528450012,
-0.9329376220703125,
0.052124496549367905,
-0.5790778994560242,
-0.23461906611919403,
0.4488377571105957,
-0.184444397687912,
-0.18394850194454193,
0.92074054479599,
-0.591063380241394,
0.05808303877711296,
-0.5131082534790039,
0.16069231927394867,
0.5392988324165344,
0.19113227725028992,
0.3859907388687134,
-0.5090072751045227,
-0.4952928125858307,
0.09839054942131042,
-0.7882781028747559,
-0.6105386018753052,
-0.08100813627243042,
-0.12088609486818314,
0.18350742757320404,
0.5538995862007141,
-0.6511642932891846,
0.3466704189777374,
0.44902303814888,
0.16338075697422028,
0.7123562693595886,
0.256986528635025,
0.07823923230171204,
-1.2625948190689087,
0.1309688240289688,
-0.16427698731422424,
-0.3401919901371002,
-0.6850929856300354,
-0.012745397165417671,
-0.25518813729286194,
-0.33652499318122864,
-0.4877939224243164,
0.12081056833267212,
-0.2789933979511261,
-0.015955878421664238,
-0.46567317843437195,
0.004006821662187576,
-0.14117082953453064,
0.8378841280937195,
-0.19423595070838928,
1.2340335845947266,
0.3647058308124542,
-0.6104789972305298,
0.4273860454559326,
0.37317678332328796,
-0.24767856299877167,
0.813007116317749,
-0.966745913028717,
0.45165565609931946,
-0.1764540821313858,
0.12689180672168732,
-1.2607332468032837,
-0.25907596945762634,
0.36438247561454773,
-0.3416450619697571,
0.14666087925434113,
0.048237867653369904,
-0.2964629530906677,
-0.7812582850456238,
-0.11135280132293701,
0.43562957644462585,
0.4967908561229706,
-0.5213106274604797,
0.7493842840194702,
0.5329074263572693,
-0.6173357367515564,
-0.27836209535598755,
-0.17228151857852936,
0.017993157729506493,
-0.21648970246315002,
-0.7299321889877319,
0.07781676203012466,
-0.3459073305130005,
-0.192175954580307,
-0.5820587873458862,
-0.013291286304593086,
-0.06867095082998276,
0.07288052886724472,
0.3611489236354828,
0.23744507133960724,
-0.24030344188213348,
-0.26137953996658325,
0.07191196829080582,
-0.5217379927635193,
0.1329132616519928,
-0.008900647982954979,
0.9805335402488708,
0.019533496350049973,
-0.49295327067375183,
-0.9489557147026062,
0.7724749445915222,
0.8007196187973022,
-0.09566984325647354,
0.2775004506111145,
0.5815783143043518,
0.10379277169704437,
0.055808618664741516,
-0.7537509799003601,
-0.5140001177787781,
-0.6593942046165466,
0.30741897225379944,
-0.28309229016304016,
-0.8851449489593506,
0.7260645031929016,
-0.3159191906452179,
0.1958562582731247,
0.17328672111034393,
0.8914289474487305,
-0.17274369299411774,
1.5408272743225098,
0.622521698474884,
-0.42423301935195923,
0.5177318453788757,
0.14010046422481537,
0.5360739827156067,
-0.8131484389305115,
-0.10804091393947601,
-0.7909875512123108,
-0.34426313638687134,
-0.3574380874633789,
-0.2695273458957672,
0.5744098424911499,
0.09973642230033875,
-0.22044764459133148,
0.2936786413192749,
-0.7715064287185669,
0.3658420443534851,
0.5708252787590027,
0.1737596094608307,
0.20502787828445435,
0.03835541382431984,
-0.05128628388047218,
0.1514636129140854,
-0.5918504595756531,
-0.6094686388969421,
0.7897228002548218,
0.23445260524749756,
0.9422136545181274,
0.16064591705799103,
0.10693509876728058,
0.2687946856021881,
0.2974424362182617,
-0.7527706623077393,
0.7846046090126038,
0.3013448119163513,
-0.34289756417274475,
0.060785721987485886,
-0.26843562722206116,
-0.9584429264068604,
-0.08999758213758469,
0.07274654507637024,
-0.6420316696166992,
-0.10909612476825714,
0.16071167588233948,
-0.5624210834503174,
0.09465774148702621,
-0.8086851239204407,
0.30088746547698975,
0.24931634962558746,
-0.025605516508221626,
-0.3852224349975586,
-0.4059428572654724,
0.364825040102005,
0.0486215241253376,
-0.16062818467617035,
-0.24170531332492828,
0.3920559287071228,
0.4556540548801422,
-0.1906377226114273,
0.9431527853012085,
0.10115120559930801,
-0.10285476595163345,
0.6315606236457825,
0.022809527814388275,
0.516987681388855,
-0.055578749626874924,
0.06916719675064087,
0.002259207656607032,
-0.14009274542331696,
-0.24258415400981903,
-0.3944627344608307,
0.4402622580528259,
-0.8389958739280701,
-0.9671456217765808,
0.07860031723976135,
-0.5057404637336731,
0.01900978572666645,
-0.2413882464170456,
0.09296650439500809,
0.49844154715538025,
0.05745776370167732,
0.11313893646001816,
0.5400957465171814,
-0.30148807168006897,
0.8729120492935181,
0.5759826898574829,
-0.13520635664463043,
-0.3570767939090729,
0.6531411409378052,
-0.3208712935447693,
0.21404992043972015,
0.24143598973751068,
-0.03614118695259094,
-0.26085126399993896,
-0.36002787947654724,
-0.22423556447029114,
-0.038637299090623856,
-0.46695536375045776,
-0.5547513365745544,
-0.5580052733421326,
-0.3593898117542267,
-0.43069517612457275,
0.033428121358156204,
-0.1472422331571579,
-0.3037710189819336,
-0.5364461541175842,
0.05331408232450485,
0.2807467579841614,
0.6404063701629639,
0.22593842446804047,
0.8286908864974976,
-0.7376096844673157,
0.44103553891181946,
0.5988578200340271,
0.3225477337837219,
0.18228626251220703,
-0.4134337902069092,
-0.043120332062244415,
-0.1874677538871765,
-1.0002909898757935,
-0.8649040460586548,
0.5261437892913818,
0.19794951379299164,
0.5987516045570374,
0.6887078285217285,
0.10262112319469452,
0.7153857350349426,
-0.5753235220909119,
0.7539836168289185,
0.37857240438461304,
-0.8322575688362122,
0.6976639032363892,
-0.43899407982826233,
0.4127616286277771,
0.23759904503822327,
-0.03470420837402344,
-0.6642037034034729,
-0.3698832094669342,
-0.3516199290752411,
-0.8647668957710266,
0.8224095702171326,
0.242601215839386,
0.1686132848262787,
-0.32284897565841675,
0.299044132232666,
-0.1397976279258728,
0.2545888125896454,
-0.12994574010372162,
-0.04299405589699745,
0.23933827877044678,
-0.15456245839595795,
0.24364717304706573,
-0.5591648817062378,
-0.15385273098945618,
-0.01897505111992359,
0.39809587597846985,
-0.3958098292350769,
0.6947307586669922,
0.09154357016086578,
-0.09571482986211777,
-0.4034239947795868,
0.1498233526945114,
0.6056720018386841,
0.5964826345443726,
0.1005728468298912,
-0.33614733815193176,
0.31916970014572144,
-0.3459439277648926,
0.012260961346328259,
-0.19664941728115082,
0.006469836458563805,
-0.010235077701508999,
0.11327500641345978,
0.744502604007721,
0.2621738910675049,
-0.6189536452293396,
0.3082791864871979,
-0.2979300618171692,
0.14069469273090363,
-0.34770190715789795,
0.2617395520210266,
0.09526260942220688,
0.5788971185684204,
0.44889068603515625,
0.2050214558839798,
0.2320626825094223,
-0.3320799171924591,
0.13823120296001434,
0.39708736538887024,
-0.23388880491256714,
-0.4725724756717682,
0.6627718806266785,
0.4949299097061157,
-0.6698417067527771,
0.534305989742279,
0.19967679679393768,
-0.6807944774627686,
0.6214239001274109,
0.4248819053173065,
0.9729198217391968,
-0.6337979435920715,
0.07748088985681534,
0.43106111884117126,
-0.05235179886221886,
0.18629083037376404,
0.28723573684692383,
-0.24242228269577026,
-0.6817270517349243,
-0.5378369092941284,
-0.7150399684906006,
-0.7393350601196289,
-0.07268360257148743,
-0.848751962184906,
0.23821383714675903,
-0.4538083076477051,
-0.5432419776916504,
0.04884039983153343,
-0.2215685397386551,
-0.7296572327613831,
-0.26598572731018066,
0.2584424614906311,
0.6412569880485535,
-0.6238787174224854,
0.5550115704536438,
0.03967837244272232,
-0.17350883781909943,
-0.7529679536819458,
-0.2903549075126648,
-0.10531862080097198,
-0.8958688378334045,
0.5070545077323914,
0.308776319026947,
-0.10317565500736237,
-0.13654372096061707,
-0.5220363736152649,
-0.649556577205658,
0.9351680278778076,
0.49878764152526855,
-0.8178465366363525,
0.02577734738588333,
0.38514187932014465,
0.3702283203601837,
-0.20195640623569489,
0.8926960229873657,
0.6533547639846802,
0.2696531116962433,
0.29353439807891846,
-1.1512823104858398,
-0.18526490032672882,
-0.29250720143318176,
0.27408331632614136,
0.30246293544769287,
-0.8553754687309265,
0.6673228740692139,
0.19405299425125122,
-0.33576199412345886,
0.44943398237228394,
0.5908219814300537,
0.20776745676994324,
0.07294344156980515,
0.47067511081695557,
0.39937153458595276,
0.46861958503723145,
-0.3971189260482788,
0.819218099117279,
-0.7170448303222656,
0.2318144142627716,
0.7251195311546326,
-0.3505317270755768,
0.8089781999588013,
0.49340149760246277,
-0.36345306038856506,
0.4177156686782837,
0.5734745860099792,
0.5327648520469666,
0.27411437034606934,
0.062204230576753616,
-0.5472828149795532,
-0.2612442970275879,
-0.4186808168888092,
-0.3882182836532593,
0.4968786835670471,
0.6050516366958618,
-0.19130839407444,
-0.27502429485321045,
-0.18209828436374664,
-0.1435951590538025,
-0.10533546656370163,
-0.1826554238796234,
1.1902971267700195,
-0.030963778495788574,
-0.9869333505630493,
0.7578172087669373,
-0.1285397857427597,
0.7269762754440308,
-0.45065271854400635,
0.12165558338165283,
-0.5751475691795349,
0.30786681175231934,
0.0317859910428524,
-0.7331841588020325,
0.31387943029403687,
0.022051097825169563,
-0.39571306109428406,
-0.290220707654953,
0.7907666563987732,
-0.23022490739822388,
-0.418092280626297,
0.18726381659507751,
0.29436224699020386,
0.015493298880755901,
-0.06463833898305893,
-0.7457848191261292,
0.26130545139312744,
0.0787503644824028,
-0.3078329861164093,
0.24485310912132263,
0.33674198389053345,
-0.0384286530315876,
0.8059589862823486,
0.9592321515083313,
-0.38136571645736694,
-0.24317018687725067,
0.3508283197879791,
1.2359641790390015,
-0.4203334152698517,
-0.44708824157714844,
-0.7795592546463013,
0.4244266152381897,
-0.2431006133556366,
-0.19125628471374512,
0.3803133964538574,
0.3550795912742615,
0.251025527715683,
0.04831564053893089,
0.5429154634475708,
0.4055655300617218,
0.5662240386009216,
-0.2268926352262497,
0.4342847764492035,
0.028125625103712082,
0.2600914239883423,
-0.40602821111679077,
-0.9443766474723816,
-0.06040525063872337,
0.5654215812683105,
0.13188856840133667,
-0.2824261486530304,
0.41273191571235657,
1.1859322786331177,
0.035002097487449646,
0.4267074465751648,
0.25082680583000183,
0.14507928490638733,
0.6724911332130432,
0.6895681619644165,
1.0895875692367554,
-0.15114863216876984,
0.7826213836669922,
0.03064863570034504,
-0.1800842583179474,
-0.2688790261745453,
-0.7903146147727966,
-0.9228276610374451,
-0.5667271018028259,
-0.10818933695554733,
-0.13601082563400269,
-0.041208866983652115,
0.6630823016166687,
0.8446722030639648,
-0.9655374884605408,
-0.42036059498786926,
-0.07417584210634232,
-0.18864920735359192,
-0.061769820749759674,
-0.2761176526546478,
-0.1289374977350235,
-0.726836085319519,
-0.6770374774932861,
0.2971479296684265,
0.599575936794281,
-0.09260725975036621,
-0.35714271664619446,
-0.045415960252285004,
0.17999669909477234,
0.3331024944782257,
0.864262044429779,
0.15535026788711548,
-0.7433719038963318,
-0.2195768803358078,
0.17855426669120789,
0.036387909203767776,
0.2001248598098755,
0.8939197063446045,
-0.7793262600898743,
0.24984611570835114,
0.5908242464065552,
0.5317750573158264,
0.5064899921417236,
-0.03713560849428177,
0.8149394392967224,
-0.7194784283638,
0.5693334937095642,
0.23630738258361816,
0.32207879424095154,
0.3290310502052307,
-0.3217710256576538,
0.3631508946418762,
0.15840740501880646,
-0.7556468844413757,
-0.8056910037994385,
0.40573516488075256,
-1.0136483907699585,
-0.06806626915931702,
0.8827113509178162,
-0.03902759775519371,
-0.2943308353424072,
-0.13141073286533356,
-0.6995654702186584,
0.24691054224967957,
-0.5853558778762817,
0.9117839336395264,
0.49812889099121094,
-0.07932346314191818,
-0.2633199095726013,
-0.3693811893463135,
0.2128235101699829,
0.5474199652671814,
-0.7414847612380981,
0.02336324192583561,
0.26295050978660583,
-0.09711068123579025,
0.3397751450538635,
0.6265279650688171,
0.10791338235139847,
0.2594377398490906,
-0.37515154480934143,
-0.19216762483119965,
0.32711878418922424,
-0.21466724574565887,
0.10205938667058945,
0.36948302388191223,
-0.03264255076646805,
-0.17584660649299622
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.05920v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.05920v1
|
High Throughput Phenotyping of Physician Notes with Large Language and Hybrid NLP Models
| 2024-03-09T14:02:59 | 2024-03-09T14:02:59 |
Syed I. Munzir, Daniel B. Hier, Michael D. Carrithers
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2; J.2
|
Deep phenotyping is the detailed description of patient signs and symptoms
using concepts from an ontology. The deep phenotyping of the numerous physician
notes in electronic health records requires high throughput methods. Over the
past thirty years, progress toward making high throughput phenotyping feasible.
In this study, we demonstrate that a large language model and a hybrid NLP
model (combining word vectors with a machine learning classifier) can perform
high throughput phenotyping on physician notes with high accuracy. Large
language models will likely emerge as the preferred method for high throughput
deep phenotyping of physician notes.
|
[
0.020530063658952713,
-0.763759434223175,
1.000511884689331,
0.23865152895450592,
-0.16437388956546783,
0.017531072720885277,
-0.10864067077636719,
-0.7003583908081055,
0.46723222732543945,
0.9466239213943481,
-0.387225866317749,
-0.5720912218093872,
-0.7074640393257141,
-0.1561155468225479,
-0.3696254789829254,
1.2165967226028442,
0.10709722340106964,
0.3435225784778595,
0.019754573702812195,
0.13044477999210358,
-0.28566455841064453,
-1.1023273468017578,
-0.5005407929420471,
-0.6245295405387878,
0.3909764587879181,
0.0709083303809166,
0.7532165050506592,
0.450054794549942,
0.8200349807739258,
0.21020200848579407,
-0.15421301126480103,
0.006268918514251709,
-0.14185300469398499,
0.2684212923049927,
-0.06190365180373192,
-0.4654591679573059,
-0.7932384610176086,
-0.10260126739740372,
0.6671682596206665,
1.0274507999420166,
-0.09392663091421127,
-0.09286242723464966,
-0.04313730075955391,
0.4443928897380829,
-0.3276652693748474,
-0.007132393307983875,
-0.21424077451229095,
0.3787471354007721,
-0.35724639892578125,
-0.33742451667785645,
-0.34422606229782104,
-0.008489075116813183,
0.34798476099967957,
-0.4713834226131439,
0.24075408279895782,
-0.1648484319448471,
0.5982179641723633,
-0.14146563410758972,
-0.3944694399833679,
-0.09247920662164688,
-1.1266759634017944,
0.6927183270454407,
-1.0617954730987549,
0.3254311978816986,
0.35911038517951965,
0.1409003734588623,
-0.12077988684177399,
-0.9950452446937561,
-0.6201832294464111,
-0.4700142741203308,
-0.37926986813545227,
0.02861865796148777,
0.10897357016801834,
0.38839760422706604,
0.5566868782043457,
0.8551801443099976,
-0.5551982522010803,
0.2858571410179138,
-0.23565833270549774,
-0.1290852576494217,
0.5807896256446838,
0.3686946928501129,
0.4937780201435089,
-0.31989699602127075,
-0.34002938866615295,
-0.02511274814605713,
-0.20778906345367432,
-0.16339850425720215,
0.006550766993314028,
0.17488369345664978,
-0.09571487456560135,
0.8159641623497009,
-0.09422861784696579,
0.8125469088554382,
-0.3700762093067169,
-0.5707666277885437,
0.21925941109657288,
-0.44532400369644165,
-0.3064996302127838,
0.22669869661331177,
0.8186359405517578,
0.19142183661460876,
-0.19027943909168243,
-0.10086135566234589,
-0.11330950260162354,
0.21674226224422455,
0.1597917228937149,
-0.7704848051071167,
-0.42980703711509705,
0.5526363849639893,
-0.7974591255187988,
-0.15435859560966492,
-0.08606160432100296,
-1.255070686340332,
-0.846660315990448,
-0.29467615485191345,
0.22530236840248108,
-0.5114102959632874,
-0.26009601354599,
0.47100207209587097,
-0.2159225344657898,
-0.19489780068397522,
0.35328468680381775,
-0.8849948048591614,
0.43754681944847107,
0.8707535266876221,
0.8857681751251221,
-0.19475407898426056,
-0.27255406975746155,
-0.42163553833961487,
0.11383063346147537,
-0.04977383464574814,
0.7947249412536621,
-0.6336493492126465,
-0.4938340187072754,
-0.07339181751012802,
-0.310700386762619,
-0.28958266973495483,
-0.5456032156944275,
0.64372318983078,
-0.11446811258792877,
0.17948119342327118,
0.013817986473441124,
-0.8371293544769287,
0.012187380343675613,
0.32385075092315674,
-0.5381049513816833,
0.8547002673149109,
0.24069546163082123,
-0.7501283884048462,
0.4345204532146454,
-0.6163566708564758,
-0.7343315482139587,
0.35724014043807983,
-0.18917900323867798,
-0.5687984824180603,
0.18318597972393036,
-0.020755356177687645,
0.8008655309677124,
-0.21384501457214355,
0.14324085414409637,
-0.0019988534040749073,
-0.12873968482017517,
0.38204658031463623,
0.06095966696739197,
0.8056753873825073,
-0.020459819585084915,
-0.2907974123954773,
0.05397917330265045,
-1.2707552909851074,
-0.17081895470619202,
0.25136274099349976,
-0.5267884135246277,
-0.5750391483306885,
-0.10645321011543274,
0.1461171656847,
0.4681488871574402,
0.2227562814950943,
-0.7420956492424011,
0.3406076431274414,
-0.6550411581993103,
0.4336562156677246,
0.06307405978441238,
0.3316079378128052,
-0.008697274141013622,
-0.3000345826148987,
0.5921324491500854,
-0.02816292643547058,
0.1079457625746727,
-0.568477213382721,
-1.0294208526611328,
-0.41384580731391907,
-0.3774188458919525,
-0.002315383404493332,
0.827226459980011,
-0.047137245535850525,
0.6679937243461609,
-0.1410241574048996,
-0.5683344006538391,
-0.5036983489990234,
0.061893031001091,
0.534798264503479,
0.7083521485328674,
0.6129152774810791,
-0.517722487449646,
-0.5884332656860352,
-0.5591487288475037,
-0.18774300813674927,
-0.09236222505569458,
-0.16272763907909393,
0.1469239890575409,
0.4402065873146057,
-0.4085361659526825,
0.20861905813217163,
-0.6545267105102539,
-0.45198559761047363,
-0.2828884720802307,
0.490327924489975,
0.17069922387599945,
0.5470418334007263,
0.24274568259716034,
-0.5978220105171204,
-0.06653047353029251,
0.21555840969085693,
-0.6425107717514038,
0.08162496984004974,
-0.3073326051235199,
0.1186266615986824,
-0.1990251988172531,
0.6382250189781189,
-0.6855741739273071,
0.4324488639831543,
0.8341792225837708,
-0.5427069067955017,
0.5908012390136719,
-0.5361186265945435,
0.076640784740448,
-1.2451320886611938,
0.09809422492980957,
0.1957058608531952,
-0.04286598414182663,
-0.7807803153991699,
0.1230400800704956,
-0.3118649423122406,
-0.2776109278202057,
-0.04125460237264633,
0.3454957604408264,
-0.29722678661346436,
-0.01572452299296856,
-0.09366832673549652,
-0.32987910509109497,
0.3941083252429962,
-0.029037078842520714,
0.29728078842163086,
0.06555133312940598,
0.40260839462280273,
-0.24738873541355133,
0.7576671242713928,
0.3468926250934601,
-0.21398772299289703,
0.6633471846580505,
-0.5319033861160278,
0.08966760337352753,
0.10141228884458542,
0.3477444052696228,
-1.0001140832901,
-0.2360023558139801,
0.07883492112159729,
-0.2757384777069092,
0.409914493560791,
-0.06809809058904648,
-0.7981512546539307,
-0.47503724694252014,
-0.0876602753996849,
0.38564231991767883,
0.5035909414291382,
-0.1003497838973999,
0.8205704092979431,
0.23244674503803253,
-0.17377930879592896,
0.013791867531836033,
-0.820914626121521,
0.2814607322216034,
0.033426955342292786,
-0.38748931884765625,
0.4535906910896301,
0.4192791283130646,
-0.14692556858062744,
-0.15828552842140198,
0.39319485425949097,
-0.14627328515052795,
-0.07267140597105026,
0.3726946711540222,
0.33254075050354004,
-0.5007562041282654,
0.3156295120716095,
-0.3788645267486572,
-0.2799619734287262,
0.18389159440994263,
-0.44020533561706543,
0.8329291343688965,
0.3683815598487854,
-0.3195398151874542,
-0.5395300984382629,
0.8571832776069641,
0.5942839980125427,
-0.4197629392147064,
0.8392345309257507,
0.47911345958709717,
-0.5921341180801392,
-0.00281320046633482,
-0.3791038691997528,
-0.19968682527542114,
-0.33320245146751404,
0.49089136719703674,
-0.2661359906196594,
-0.5627140402793884,
0.5027557611465454,
-0.3407149910926819,
-0.11596839129924774,
0.6415501236915588,
0.635272741317749,
-0.22937795519828796,
1.194830060005188,
0.7099694609642029,
0.03273637220263481,
0.13551920652389526,
-0.10457492619752884,
0.2492779642343521,
-0.6314659714698792,
-0.4948175847530365,
-0.8272033333778381,
-0.14549703896045685,
-0.6519060134887695,
-0.490441232919693,
0.32171717286109924,
-0.2937964200973511,
0.0020567895844578743,
0.018963923677802086,
-0.7070111036300659,
-0.0313415452837944,
0.6279772520065308,
0.4347119629383087,
0.5559408664703369,
0.005449574440717697,
-0.11648841947317123,
-0.42394888401031494,
-0.45643720030784607,
-0.38461047410964966,
1.1495025157928467,
0.3325573205947876,
0.6939840316772461,
-0.2591392397880554,
0.4821491241455078,
0.08196798712015152,
-0.05293238162994385,
-0.7346404790878296,
0.5202394723892212,
-0.7100175023078918,
-0.546237587928772,
-0.2616283893585205,
-0.32744500041007996,
-0.9140211343765259,
-0.054300855845212936,
-0.8640918731689453,
-1.0237700939178467,
0.14512424170970917,
0.5578241348266602,
-0.48518818616867065,
0.6218627691268921,
-0.5008693933486938,
1.0680867433547974,
-0.3576270639896393,
0.1830226480960846,
-0.3387369215488434,
-0.7557915449142456,
0.32730963826179504,
-0.004609192721545696,
-0.04800919443368912,
0.1035395935177803,
0.14841964840888977,
0.8503100275993347,
-0.3725537657737732,
0.9153199195861816,
0.040269915014505386,
-0.2797396779060364,
-0.20916295051574707,
0.0909390076994896,
0.41495847702026367,
-0.3607531487941742,
0.03122187964618206,
0.3101390600204468,
0.062761090695858,
-0.4655575156211853,
-0.4513462781906128,
0.4711223840713501,
-0.5057532787322998,
-0.2900407016277313,
-0.4134509861469269,
-0.40173524618148804,
-0.35158786177635193,
0.3174353539943695,
0.5717851519584656,
0.6030319929122925,
-0.14104272425174713,
-0.34045207500457764,
0.7509865164756775,
-0.6856898665428162,
-0.2558939754962921,
0.25661829113960266,
-0.3994837999343872,
-0.04777456074953079,
1.0209251642227173,
0.1889684498310089,
0.1830708235502243,
0.6952688694000244,
0.6130881905555725,
-0.05422409251332283,
-0.7165368795394897,
-0.3046216070652008,
0.49466338753700256,
-0.5450984835624695,
0.39681270718574524,
-1.0714861154556274,
-0.3122740685939789,
-0.5245435833930969,
-0.2513175308704376,
-0.2192905992269516,
-0.18141421675682068,
-0.20421500504016876,
0.016949011012911797,
0.4046417474746704,
0.6903719902038574,
0.2624383866786957,
0.28284311294555664,
-1.2020366191864014,
0.6451249718666077,
0.3526401221752167,
0.33127081394195557,
-0.036111559718847275,
-0.37672844529151917,
-0.104631207883358,
-0.2851710617542267,
-0.0029144668951630592,
-0.9781954884529114,
0.2711895704269409,
0.20696666836738586,
0.35464221239089966,
0.5305708050727844,
-0.3887432813644409,
0.504161536693573,
-0.42172592878341675,
0.878939151763916,
0.3670397400856018,
-0.7781357765197754,
0.9250043630599976,
-0.3986414968967438,
0.33354464173316956,
0.24058875441551208,
0.46810024976730347,
-0.7978406548500061,
-0.40087825059890747,
-0.7988470792770386,
-0.8802269697189331,
0.23793424665927887,
-0.24984779953956604,
-0.04893549159169197,
0.27478986978530884,
0.3478168845176697,
0.22219732403755188,
0.10593575239181519,
-0.2093694806098938,
-0.1198163703083992,
-0.019549494609236717,
-0.12760721147060394,
-0.42274922132492065,
-0.4162710905075073,
-0.34119102358818054,
-0.4064505696296692,
0.0833248719573021,
0.07652238011360168,
0.25703227519989014,
0.2920700013637543,
0.16522079706192017,
-0.15076394379138947,
0.2985292673110962,
0.6202452182769775,
0.7625542283058167,
-0.32833749055862427,
0.15204527974128723,
-0.10798738151788712,
-0.8392564654350281,
-0.1035996675491333,
0.6500865817070007,
-0.3920029401779175,
0.20263513922691345,
0.8526487350463867,
0.8587050437927246,
0.017173301428556442,
-0.7878462076187134,
0.5895717144012451,
0.22076217830181122,
-0.11921343952417374,
-0.30837756395339966,
-0.0937153697013855,
-0.04783973470330238,
0.10533230751752853,
0.2217729687690735,
0.13259634375572205,
0.5358266830444336,
-0.7804674506187439,
0.03970906138420105,
0.1598539799451828,
-0.21636687219142914,
-0.3631856441497803,
0.7948282361030579,
0.06495322287082672,
-0.23283705115318298,
0.6381440758705139,
0.39946746826171875,
-0.42310571670532227,
0.5439285635948181,
0.5394577980041504,
0.6088224649429321,
-0.27105948328971863,
0.27386510372161865,
0.2084003984928131,
0.07888501137495041,
-0.2318527102470398,
0.27348411083221436,
0.07456111162900925,
-0.5951035618782043,
-0.9110382795333862,
-0.7167074084281921,
-0.6614783406257629,
0.32565635442733765,
-0.6344127655029297,
-0.08220329135656357,
-0.7787577509880066,
-0.3240191638469696,
0.7003218531608582,
-0.08650104701519012,
-0.4891285300254822,
0.645433247089386,
0.44112691283226013,
0.5792493224143982,
-1.1461955308914185,
0.7592209577560425,
1.000969648361206,
-0.1874167025089264,
-0.8491033315658569,
0.010825221426784992,
0.014010255225002766,
-0.8530506491661072,
0.6513727307319641,
0.11319276690483093,
0.16298584640026093,
-0.2180860936641693,
-0.1552218347787857,
-0.2901918888092041,
0.42308396100997925,
0.23690171539783478,
-0.6038444638252258,
-0.213101327419281,
0.25376468896865845,
0.9010605812072754,
-0.12414924800395966,
-0.14133833348751068,
0.8842417001724243,
0.3846820890903473,
-0.12023790180683136,
-1.0989437103271484,
0.26346883177757263,
-0.19007906317710876,
0.050726622343063354,
0.3809519112110138,
-0.20684386789798737,
0.9085232615470886,
-0.3065934181213379,
0.013009077869355679,
-0.24260371923446655,
0.4843059182167053,
0.24845890700817108,
0.5191462635993958,
0.24127182364463806,
0.9256529808044434,
0.8047380447387695,
0.005164337810128927,
1.3641616106033325,
-0.19283415377140045,
0.022848740220069885,
0.964834988117218,
-0.42350226640701294,
0.8450561165809631,
0.3429359197616577,
-0.3948410451412201,
0.6953150629997253,
0.16587090492248535,
-0.21039128303527832,
-0.10211953520774841,
0.29943227767944336,
-0.3816962242126465,
-0.22941257059574127,
-0.19300679862499237,
-0.41121581196784973,
0.3335902690887451,
0.6348866820335388,
-0.7653481364250183,
0.10429622232913971,
0.18033543229103088,
0.2484406977891922,
0.27818000316619873,
-0.43613094091415405,
0.820045530796051,
0.20917239785194397,
-0.5950918197631836,
0.3506331443786621,
-0.1501288264989853,
0.6858615875244141,
-0.6865448951721191,
-0.46141597628593445,
0.15034116804599762,
0.2920321822166443,
-0.4388674795627594,
-0.9122995734214783,
0.28230467438697815,
-0.19395743310451508,
-0.33657997846603394,
-0.32492125034332275,
0.7788967490196228,
-0.2830847203731537,
-0.8186532258987427,
0.4049730598926544,
0.34730264544487,
0.321420282125473,
-0.08536231517791748,
-0.5924805998802185,
-0.1511397808790207,
-0.4102257788181305,
-0.25689953565597534,
0.3481083810329437,
0.5117502212524414,
0.08874676376581192,
0.4128431975841522,
0.7660058736801147,
0.929068922996521,
0.15695665776729584,
0.1998910754919052,
0.6621862053871155,
-0.7591342329978943,
-0.6768972277641296,
-0.9884108304977417,
0.3857266902923584,
-0.16273804008960724,
-0.6828609704971313,
0.6587666273117065,
0.36930355429649353,
0.5258784890174866,
-0.06581717729568481,
0.7679926753044128,
0.11440084129571915,
0.957597553730011,
-0.6615318655967712,
0.3461678624153137,
-0.5330794453620911,
-0.10328606516122818,
-0.5551301836967468,
-0.53636634349823,
-0.631564736366272,
0.38597825169563293,
-0.3400910198688507,
-0.12543751299381256,
0.6357568502426147,
0.33106616139411926,
-0.01776508055627346,
-0.016528772190213203,
0.26972341537475586,
0.43957245349884033,
0.13889019191265106,
0.7152380347251892,
0.5202844738960266,
-0.08842455595731735,
0.31174376606941223,
-0.47668755054473877,
-0.3070122003555298,
-0.3994136452674866,
-0.6853612065315247,
-0.8375939130783081,
-0.5680971145629883,
-0.4636160731315613,
-0.8074958324432373,
-0.019084464758634567,
0.7348716259002686,
0.7253501415252686,
-0.9675951600074768,
0.05435292050242424,
0.03807854652404785,
-0.39814212918281555,
-0.4869900345802307,
-0.22066830098628998,
0.6539492011070251,
0.23000219464302063,
-0.39597782492637634,
0.1580180525779724,
0.6464411616325378,
0.360097736120224,
-0.445267915725708,
0.2849511206150055,
0.08534803241491318,
-0.305430144071579,
0.5990654230117798,
0.56022709608078,
-0.45917731523513794,
0.23734953999519348,
-0.17031900584697723,
-0.49021634459495544,
0.19028010964393616,
1.2879739999771118,
-0.5676141977310181,
0.5697757005691528,
0.7250796556472778,
0.6255910992622375,
0.5459437966346741,
-0.042480435222387314,
0.6977014541625977,
-0.43334218859672546,
0.32694506645202637,
0.7010273337364197,
0.4504071772098541,
0.5455818176269531,
-0.7443687915802002,
0.20483613014221191,
0.5053412318229675,
-0.4327313303947449,
-0.7381259799003601,
0.241685688495636,
-1.1511882543563843,
-0.268396258354187,
0.9995641708374023,
-0.38318148255348206,
0.0983102098107338,
-0.32204800844192505,
-0.2686053216457367,
0.11855141073465347,
-0.051318150013685226,
0.7786334156990051,
0.2913307845592499,
-0.3593100309371948,
-0.27155959606170654,
-0.8137332797050476,
0.4170997142791748,
0.3327797055244446,
-0.8518193960189819,
-0.281902939081192,
0.3559274673461914,
-0.11843474209308624,
0.38769838213920593,
0.9310787320137024,
-0.16317079961299896,
0.09748971462249756,
0.2405732125043869,
0.22822299599647522,
0.3014739751815796,
-0.015285968780517578,
-0.22040557861328125,
0.3719054162502289,
-0.028780998662114143,
0.0324033685028553
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.05902v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.05902v1
|
MaiBaam Annotation Guidelines
| 2024-03-09T12:46:53 | 2024-03-09T12:46:53 |
Verena Blaschke, Barbara Kovačić, Siyao Peng, Barbara Plank
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This document provides the annotation guidelines for MaiBaam, a Bavarian
corpus annotated with part-of-speech (POS) tags and syntactic dependencies.
MaiBaam belongs to the Universal Dependencies (UD) project, and our annotations
elaborate on the general and German UD version 2 guidelines. In this document,
we detail how to preprocess and tokenize Bavarian data, provide an overview of
the POS tags and dependencies we use, explain annotation decisions that would
also apply to closely related languages like German, and lastly we introduce
and motivate decisions that are specific to Bavarian grammar.
|
[
-0.692478597164154,
-0.8524121642112732,
0.49090883135795593,
0.4848466217517853,
-0.42102333903312683,
-0.5166815519332886,
0.12200500071048737,
-0.37681737542152405,
0.5897806882858276,
0.9353320598602295,
-0.3377772867679596,
-0.876643180847168,
-0.6554643511772156,
0.13404691219329834,
-0.10501237213611603,
1.1099462509155273,
-0.2526155710220337,
0.483295738697052,
-0.21162767708301544,
-0.44126468896865845,
-0.6960744857788086,
-0.99989253282547,
-0.5525519251823425,
0.011166113428771496,
0.8317445516586304,
0.6965123414993286,
0.6593924164772034,
0.46557724475860596,
0.6751394271850586,
0.17699041962623596,
-0.42118367552757263,
0.047680482268333435,
-0.028918854892253876,
0.0880081057548523,
-0.22829914093017578,
-0.6748085021972656,
-0.8327105641365051,
0.10424019396305084,
0.6939628720283508,
0.7410714030265808,
-0.23702220618724823,
0.47440358996391296,
-0.17162203788757324,
0.526244044303894,
-0.820214033126831,
0.6371399760246277,
-0.25079014897346497,
-0.09752661734819412,
-0.6760779023170471,
-0.26464125514030457,
-0.41985180974006653,
-0.40763166546821594,
-0.13043777644634247,
-0.43184709548950195,
0.05841416120529175,
-0.14916038513183594,
0.9047754406929016,
0.07539058476686478,
-0.44605913758277893,
0.0924297347664833,
-0.5469985604286194,
0.37187767028808594,
-0.6147798299789429,
-0.10330167412757874,
1.0571768283843994,
0.458804190158844,
-0.44720157980918884,
-0.5698397755622864,
-0.38375458121299744,
0.09519746154546738,
-0.46269944310188293,
0.007034274749457836,
-0.16160796582698822,
0.23689302802085876,
0.3890412449836731,
0.17756615579128265,
-0.22704604268074036,
0.20574623346328735,
-0.5405241250991821,
-0.41927558183670044,
0.4580584466457367,
0.01025119237601757,
0.35210347175598145,
-0.23130954802036285,
-0.1527753323316574,
0.29542234539985657,
-0.798929750919342,
-0.2268388569355011,
0.5449051856994629,
0.2915914058685303,
-0.17489312589168549,
0.6396718621253967,
-0.32334205508232117,
0.8789668083190918,
-0.12189643085002899,
-0.15622752904891968,
0.295562207698822,
-0.017189690843224525,
-0.04850778728723526,
0.19249515235424042,
0.4716997742652893,
0.4670378267765045,
0.44516780972480774,
-0.14406879246234894,
-0.02911064215004444,
0.1391994208097458,
0.21700631082057953,
-0.9837812185287476,
-0.5853923559188843,
0.0225299634039402,
-0.3804991841316223,
0.12752766907215118,
0.445168137550354,
-0.6340981125831604,
-0.3094312846660614,
-0.464154988527298,
0.42413267493247986,
-0.3547806143760681,
-0.20551034808158875,
-0.23808573186397552,
-0.30836978554725647,
0.2300952672958374,
0.3073609471321106,
-1.0783472061157227,
0.0816149190068245,
0.5876564383506775,
0.717551052570343,
0.1635703146457672,
-0.3639990985393524,
-0.5362805128097534,
0.6227415800094604,
-0.282377690076828,
1.1066718101501465,
-0.5817396640777588,
-0.6597002744674683,
0.2525939345359802,
0.22118766605854034,
0.1370856910943985,
-0.4810185134410858,
0.9925475716590881,
-0.3754464089870453,
0.19768942892551422,
-0.38721320033073425,
-0.6826551556587219,
-0.9198392033576965,
-0.3250017464160919,
-0.7797155380249023,
0.6441472172737122,
0.37942126393318176,
-0.9910966753959656,
0.511616587638855,
-0.9132164716720581,
-1.0415456295013428,
-0.08278258144855499,
-0.3743080198764801,
-0.27060481905937195,
0.24030891060829163,
0.10744813084602356,
0.6551225781440735,
-0.02799409255385399,
0.11604858189821243,
-0.19802525639533997,
-0.3337550163269043,
0.008898836560547352,
-0.004712373483926058,
1.2631241083145142,
0.06649945676326752,
-0.11675181239843369,
0.41622060537338257,
-0.9908276200294495,
-0.45549556612968445,
0.1992846578359604,
-0.38144925236701965,
-0.22220250964164734,
0.26660019159317017,
0.13406522572040558,
-0.17536988854408264,
0.097069151699543,
-0.24911504983901978,
0.182644784450531,
0.06619112938642502,
0.32810577750205994,
0.7239171266555786,
0.3975875675678253,
0.25708869099617004,
-0.38662058115005493,
0.5761212110519409,
0.23914048075675964,
0.4255349040031433,
-0.4034893810749054,
-0.7430504560470581,
-0.9725624322891235,
-0.5936317443847656,
0.407190203666687,
0.5790746212005615,
-0.15705646574497223,
0.9268608093261719,
0.27791282534599304,
-0.8347316384315491,
-0.6169390678405762,
0.1344945728778839,
0.07137779146432877,
0.48389798402786255,
0.43211016058921814,
-0.4008684754371643,
-0.8652483224868774,
-1.3258516788482666,
0.4788397252559662,
-0.3186599910259247,
0.19492293894290924,
-0.37669914960861206,
0.24065366387367249,
-0.38691458106040955,
1.0920308828353882,
-0.3400599956512451,
-0.7472049593925476,
-0.13265854120254517,
0.2859555184841156,
-0.08346811681985855,
0.4451755881309509,
1.1024457216262817,
-0.8543444871902466,
-0.16096316277980804,
-0.4696221947669983,
-0.48816967010498047,
-0.47697025537490845,
0.31259283423423767,
-0.5335773229598999,
0.3588736355304718,
0.3542240262031555,
-0.4368283450603485,
0.5615404844284058,
0.6280737519264221,
-0.3996770977973938,
0.3720668852329254,
-0.023931430652737617,
0.13729499280452728,
-1.2830160856246948,
-0.10011207312345505,
-0.18526366353034973,
-0.3086392283439636,
-0.32930734753608704,
-0.14964300394058228,
-0.12576521933078766,
0.3737628757953644,
-0.47129422426223755,
0.29730892181396484,
-0.45121216773986816,
0.22984781861305237,
-0.20623239874839783,
0.13732022047042847,
0.18982096016407013,
0.276728093624115,
0.0028004494961351156,
0.611457884311676,
0.9191656708717346,
-0.8828204274177551,
0.4018942713737488,
0.586727499961853,
-0.08041460067033768,
0.8854881525039673,
-0.47880494594573975,
-0.16945768892765045,
-0.26357710361480713,
0.3574812710285187,
-0.9657955169677734,
-0.24922654032707214,
0.5581757426261902,
-0.47414618730545044,
0.7047916054725647,
-0.26413241028785706,
-1.071825385093689,
0.12156602740287781,
-0.19466878473758698,
0.16834363341331482,
0.5930745601654053,
-0.3043491542339325,
0.8085792064666748,
1.089515209197998,
-0.0782611221075058,
-0.09609126299619675,
-0.7847771644592285,
-0.07557462900876999,
-0.4272053837776184,
-0.29941943287849426,
0.025731004774570465,
0.05279669165611267,
-0.32401636242866516,
-0.11622848361730576,
0.31890618801116943,
0.013871608301997185,
0.4787557125091553,
0.8374214172363281,
0.24271398782730103,
-0.08220097422599792,
-0.0811687707901001,
0.2241857796907425,
-0.47740861773490906,
0.03177523612976074,
-0.015690580010414124,
0.6121671795845032,
0.2089015394449234,
-0.4340061843395233,
-0.5620340704917908,
0.5277599096298218,
0.0013220361433923244,
-0.3123394250869751,
0.7239634990692139,
0.8849604725837708,
-0.5692652463912964,
0.28897029161453247,
-0.6119783520698547,
-0.13984951376914978,
-0.3899213373661041,
0.10235472768545151,
-0.5590617060661316,
-0.773581326007843,
0.5606117248535156,
-0.023434346541762352,
0.1762140542268753,
0.9576408267021179,
0.8614882230758667,
-0.41082823276519775,
0.942563533782959,
0.8739613890647888,
-0.2003660351037979,
0.6600210070610046,
0.04621920362114906,
-0.188210129737854,
-0.7597134709358215,
-0.2651369571685791,
-0.7459098696708679,
-0.3409857153892517,
-0.7725077867507935,
-0.2784838378429413,
-0.14241240918636322,
0.696712076663971,
0.013829698786139488,
0.6800005435943604,
-0.475492924451828,
0.18053038418293,
0.7194682955741882,
-0.32890379428863525,
0.017602361738681793,
-0.029844388365745544,
-0.23219740390777588,
-0.008161475881934166,
-0.5253748893737793,
-0.9573363065719604,
0.8387314081192017,
0.22592073678970337,
0.43312498927116394,
0.24473698437213898,
0.7249142527580261,
0.43466120958328247,
0.6142650246620178,
-0.6374901533126831,
0.7128672003746033,
-0.007127405144274235,
-1.0702039003372192,
0.05478058382868767,
-0.08407118171453476,
-1.2149959802627563,
-0.008387205190956593,
-0.17545977234840393,
-1.2624608278274536,
-0.10860161483287811,
-0.04533444717526436,
-0.0851273313164711,
0.17105768620967865,
-0.9119812250137329,
0.8004996180534363,
0.13382543623447418,
0.4891224205493927,
-0.1898328810930252,
-0.7357214689254761,
-0.11389878392219543,
-0.04356662929058075,
0.029651688411831856,
-0.6996159553527832,
-0.031578317284584045,
1.3399698734283447,
-0.2547054588794708,
1.1028448343276978,
-0.2965385615825653,
0.007061111740767956,
0.8400355577468872,
0.056001465767621994,
-0.05535949021577835,
-0.04954769089818001,
-0.02434167079627514,
0.7239036560058594,
0.3241966962814331,
-0.6240296959877014,
-0.0682031586766243,
0.2233443409204483,
-0.5486467480659485,
-0.7385165095329285,
-0.49580761790275574,
-0.29418647289276123,
-0.3733995854854584,
0.36003559827804565,
0.24772955477237701,
0.12859004735946655,
-0.3788820505142212,
-0.04771370813250542,
0.17840048670768738,
0.26789507269859314,
0.19149348139762878,
0.7494314908981323,
-0.8151768445968628,
-0.4699706435203552,
0.7096319198608398,
0.42645150423049927,
-0.13709108531475067,
0.4907186031341553,
0.00129694864153862,
-0.18171817064285278,
-0.5595710277557373,
-0.6515031456947327,
0.3218632638454437,
-0.9773046374320984,
-0.18621684610843658,
-0.3938295841217041,
-0.16244113445281982,
-0.5884121060371399,
-0.06061704084277153,
0.2293400913476944,
-0.6709887981414795,
-0.598426342010498,
-0.5694026947021484,
0.819939374923706,
0.7610293030738831,
-0.21079881489276886,
0.6672684550285339,
-1.091065526008606,
0.3487696349620819,
-0.22163140773773193,
0.00003153043508064002,
-0.5817864537239075,
-0.6016477942466736,
-0.47266989946365356,
-0.13392072916030884,
-0.32946643233299255,
-1.2672886848449707,
-0.40813735127449036,
-0.14590564370155334,
0.9259898662567139,
0.8766846060752869,
0.00004371514660306275,
0.4240178167819977,
-0.42653030157089233,
0.8074058294296265,
0.20475800335407257,
-0.7183135151863098,
0.858333945274353,
-0.3239327371120453,
0.055298831313848495,
0.681528627872467,
0.5902261137962341,
-0.34828171133995056,
-0.51915442943573,
-0.723183274269104,
-0.8345893025398254,
0.43256232142448425,
0.11777639389038086,
0.24829807877540588,
-0.2642901539802551,
0.3745921850204468,
0.37717872858047485,
0.239212766289711,
-0.09392251074314117,
-0.5007627606391907,
0.28337785601615906,
-0.037955392152071,
0.029977645725011826,
-0.7865021228790283,
-0.43287181854248047,
-0.4418857991695404,
0.766487717628479,
0.06287135183811188,
0.1353544294834137,
-0.07651010155677795,
-0.09899621456861496,
-0.119377002120018,
0.017621003091335297,
0.2900640666484833,
1.0502434968948364,
-0.1358964592218399,
0.061741456389427185,
0.028345484286546707,
-0.36657285690307617,
-0.03990728035569191,
0.5052928328514099,
-0.6463765501976013,
0.39170557260513306,
0.26642006635665894,
0.8301677107810974,
-0.06343763321638107,
-0.3386138677597046,
0.16820645332336426,
0.19121596217155457,
-0.020708544179797173,
-0.5493517518043518,
0.23059917986392975,
0.33755606412887573,
0.18183937668800354,
0.06054996699094772,
-0.3136148750782013,
0.1798981875181198,
-0.5472017526626587,
0.25348085165023804,
0.14441952109336853,
-0.31207475066185,
-0.42363306879997253,
0.546038031578064,
0.07937736064195633,
-0.2606152892112732,
0.2868236303329468,
-0.28991320729255676,
-0.4424907863140106,
0.3042754530906677,
0.4438289403915405,
0.8160731792449951,
-0.39815977215766907,
0.31501078605651855,
0.3050570785999298,
0.19955942034721375,
0.3032189905643463,
0.7908617854118347,
-0.14296641945838928,
-0.3410279452800751,
-0.08537435531616211,
-0.8748829960823059,
-0.3413859009742737,
-0.46039602160453796,
-0.7952851057052612,
0.7656241059303284,
-0.6374799013137817,
-0.5957477688789368,
0.3713831603527069,
-0.3164646327495575,
-0.39975884556770325,
0.3151981234550476,
0.3096998631954193,
0.8057602643966675,
-0.6432292461395264,
1.0406887531280518,
1.1158597469329834,
-1.075783610343933,
-0.7066248655319214,
-0.03939620777964592,
0.025528179481625557,
-0.8303730487823486,
0.2571503520011902,
0.2913946807384491,
-0.03727530688047409,
-0.25110435485839844,
-0.29949960112571716,
-0.4446890950202942,
1.0913231372833252,
0.3445768356323242,
-0.2792358696460724,
0.12899154424667358,
0.06175214424729347,
0.38501518964767456,
-0.2704404294490814,
0.09342441707849503,
0.6680788397789001,
0.9169291257858276,
-0.015788758173584938,
-0.6964625716209412,
-0.023450788110494614,
-0.06480272114276886,
-0.14102700352668762,
0.473697304725647,
-0.8076990246772766,
0.575108528137207,
-0.173250213265419,
-0.3568788468837738,
0.2172841727733612,
0.952316164970398,
-0.10023588687181473,
0.17296884953975677,
0.4270704984664917,
0.7049283981323242,
0.6699938774108887,
-0.18825113773345947,
0.7546154856681824,
-0.27362629771232605,
0.14655904471874237,
1.2462501525878906,
-0.013498072512447834,
1.051648497581482,
0.5142024755477905,
-0.41341379284858704,
0.5137551426887512,
1.0578458309173584,
-0.30072301626205444,
0.24088717997074127,
0.30006423592567444,
-0.009495541453361511,
0.09929212927818298,
-0.5390653014183044,
-0.5490959286689758,
0.6854258179664612,
0.3439026176929474,
-0.36230406165122986,
-0.12331702560186386,
-0.2212563306093216,
0.857647716999054,
-0.12744317948818207,
-0.28906625509262085,
1.01296865940094,
0.13495492935180664,
-0.41857001185417175,
0.2276214212179184,
0.2276933491230011,
0.23035874962806702,
-0.798258900642395,
-0.040877629071474075,
-0.08548370003700256,
0.0720476433634758,
-0.4992828965187073,
-0.807753324508667,
0.6016862392425537,
-0.10981761664152145,
-0.23487041890621185,
0.30769503116607666,
0.5326146483421326,
-0.3667801022529602,
-0.6782634258270264,
0.40707331895828247,
0.4027625322341919,
0.37975603342056274,
-0.295850932598114,
-0.30823373794555664,
-0.20783190429210663,
-0.28175950050354004,
-0.3276636302471161,
0.3665088713169098,
0.6079614758491516,
-0.20507696270942688,
0.18066614866256714,
0.4085586667060852,
0.16817952692508698,
-0.0072288294322788715,
0.4899933636188507,
0.663243293762207,
-0.5356504917144775,
-0.47540634870529175,
-0.8802117109298706,
0.48377346992492676,
0.08153601735830307,
-0.25725388526916504,
1.0346546173095703,
0.6731961965560913,
0.8689653873443604,
0.15512172877788544,
0.7412976622581482,
-0.1151176318526268,
0.37319186329841614,
-0.5914373397827148,
0.9968221783638,
-0.5771234035491943,
-0.442229688167572,
-0.1045774295926094,
-1.2945221662521362,
-0.6444598436355591,
0.6743658185005188,
-0.1364838033914566,
-0.04178929328918457,
0.5912908315658569,
0.5169683694839478,
0.41386157274246216,
0.21893711388111115,
0.29540038108825684,
0.13110052049160004,
0.1706194430589676,
0.026048028841614723,
0.7407065629959106,
0.07011871784925461,
0.37467142939567566,
-0.47111523151397705,
-0.3064168691635132,
-0.5679600834846497,
-0.8708168864250183,
-0.8881363272666931,
-0.8876504302024841,
-0.5486013293266296,
-0.39840006828308105,
-0.2550082504749298,
0.712760865688324,
0.7093855142593384,
-1.0559121370315552,
-0.09240482747554779,
0.3082846701145172,
-0.033709924668073654,
-0.10465657711029053,
-0.21461156010627747,
0.4848690629005432,
-0.21552757918834686,
-0.6644847989082336,
0.013164924457669258,
0.5493013858795166,
0.37165817618370056,
-0.3591785430908203,
-0.052886001765728,
-0.40313148498535156,
0.12190089374780655,
0.5576018691062927,
0.18040406703948975,
-0.5763856768608093,
-0.3031722903251648,
-0.6476491093635559,
-0.24980872869491577,
0.26508066058158875,
0.8426390886306763,
-0.1690935641527176,
0.4505375027656555,
0.5259557366371155,
0.2868116796016693,
0.25881505012512207,
-0.0899256020784378,
0.34861719608306885,
-0.47196945548057556,
0.5776917934417725,
0.21949009597301483,
1.0052844285964966,
0.36149904131889343,
-0.02534734085202217,
0.7026402950286865,
0.25531792640686035,
-0.4380680024623871,
-0.3464164435863495,
0.36625686287879944,
-1.4042857885360718,
-0.0648592934012413,
1.4874722957611084,
-0.5469218492507935,
-0.23194566369056702,
-0.1304798722267151,
-0.9039615988731384,
0.6792429685592651,
-0.36516842246055603,
0.6133967638015747,
1.0163122415542603,
-0.12598925828933716,
0.1939851939678192,
-0.5570635795593262,
0.39054960012435913,
0.2057763785123825,
-0.8875430226325989,
-0.15805840492248535,
0.8506583571434021,
0.035042304545640945,
0.2807336747646332,
0.729936420917511,
-0.30231398344039917,
0.1281549334526062,
0.19019342958927155,
0.16237077116966248,
-0.004517953377217054,
-0.4447941184043884,
0.002643975894898176,
-0.033139120787382126,
0.4813222587108612,
-0.7009143233299255
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.05881v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.05881v2
|
KG-Rank: Enhancing Large Language Models for Medical QA with Knowledge Graphs and Ranking Techniques
| 2024-03-09T11:23:38 | 2024-03-19T03:48:11 |
Rui Yang, Haoran Liu, Edison Marrese-Taylor, Qingcheng Zeng, Yu He Ke, Wanxin Li, Lechao Cheng, Qingyu Chen, James Caverlee, Yutaka Matsuo, Irene Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have significantly advanced healthcare
innovation on generation capabilities. However, their application in real
clinical settings is challenging due to potential deviations from medical facts
and inherent biases. In this work, we develop an augmented LLM framework,
KG-Rank, which leverages a medical knowledge graph (KG) with ranking and
re-ranking techniques, aiming to improve free-text question-answering (QA) in
the medical domain. Specifically, upon receiving a question, we initially
retrieve triplets from a medical KG to gather factual information.
Subsequently, we innovatively apply ranking methods to refine the ordering of
these triplets, aiming to yield more precise answers. To the best of our
knowledge, KG-Rank is the first application of ranking models combined with KG
in medical QA specifically for generating long answers. Evaluation of four
selected medical QA datasets shows that KG-Rank achieves an improvement of over
18% in the ROUGE-L score. Moreover, we extend KG-Rank to open domains, where it
realizes a 14% improvement in ROUGE-L, showing the effectiveness and potential
of KG-Rank.
|
[
-0.26693397760391235,
-0.741920530796051,
0.8621410727500916,
0.10308097302913666,
-0.18740157783031464,
0.2395215630531311,
0.10578004270792007,
-0.5306031107902527,
0.6124275326728821,
0.6175751686096191,
-0.027316736057400703,
-0.7270057201385498,
-0.9477553367614746,
0.1973477154970169,
-0.03191636502742767,
0.9144895076751709,
0.09423098713159561,
0.3755761981010437,
-0.5536488890647888,
-0.33394041657447815,
-0.323829710483551,
-0.6805358529090881,
-0.873741865158081,
-0.41485947370529175,
0.9294964671134949,
0.2471785545349121,
1.1654247045516968,
0.6413151621818542,
0.5891409516334534,
0.2191288322210312,
-0.24370083212852478,
0.24267959594726562,
-0.5986285209655762,
0.28704923391342163,
0.07319992035627365,
-0.4155283272266388,
-0.95610111951828,
-0.06810951232910156,
0.564259946346283,
0.9228972792625427,
-0.06829569488763809,
0.029878893867135048,
-0.29589492082595825,
0.8110437393188477,
-0.4456012547016144,
0.24314965307712555,
-0.22743798792362213,
-0.18378938734531403,
0.09862659871578217,
-0.358076274394989,
-0.3804946839809418,
-0.8082377314567566,
0.016066137701272964,
-0.5790053009986877,
-0.20550286769866943,
-0.06339672207832336,
0.6912338733673096,
0.22576716542243958,
-0.8230612874031067,
-0.30909085273742676,
-0.3677094280719757,
0.40715378522872925,
-0.6719088554382324,
0.6920543313026428,
0.554246187210083,
0.506868302822113,
-0.22973988950252533,
-0.9715640544891357,
-0.31138768792152405,
-0.46007031202316284,
-0.10073570907115936,
0.1764417141675949,
0.1454920917749405,
0.22442218661308289,
0.19880837202072144,
0.36339789628982544,
-0.4446271061897278,
0.22032999992370605,
-0.27047020196914673,
-0.08422251790761948,
0.7286471128463745,
0.17586453258991241,
0.5629389882087708,
-0.061186425387859344,
-0.007680294569581747,
-0.10726089030504227,
-0.9352885484695435,
0.019503943622112274,
-0.12495116144418716,
0.09082217514514923,
0.17705275118350983,
0.8498620390892029,
-0.551548957824707,
0.8312181234359741,
-0.09137024730443954,
-0.545166552066803,
0.4065741002559662,
-0.021762456744909286,
-0.21070004999637604,
-0.043013207614421844,
0.6600474119186401,
0.6576627492904663,
0.16435818374156952,
-0.4457853436470032,
0.039274949580430984,
-0.34347254037857056,
0.2638888657093048,
-1.0954663753509521,
-0.45884352922439575,
0.4376734495162964,
-0.5730574131011963,
-0.6037699580192566,
-0.3180508315563202,
-0.6229015588760376,
-0.6305103302001953,
-0.11445414274930954,
0.654590368270874,
-0.2939133644104004,
-0.30966734886169434,
0.025511305779218674,
0.09291943162679672,
0.11084822565317154,
0.374221533536911,
-0.6581709980964661,
0.1048654168844223,
0.4926343262195587,
0.41546759009361267,
-0.13703447580337524,
0.007311703637242317,
-0.5989747047424316,
0.09289449453353882,
-0.6363699436187744,
0.6798821091651917,
-0.5155296921730042,
-0.5335394144058228,
-0.050106555223464966,
-0.09259038418531418,
0.07683338969945908,
-0.933847963809967,
0.4632461667060852,
-0.9168283939361572,
0.21415956318378448,
-0.28573426604270935,
-0.6612807512283325,
-0.005832057446241379,
0.531301736831665,
-0.558440089225769,
1.0533801317214966,
0.3232705295085907,
-0.4278167486190796,
0.3777031898498535,
-0.6287752985954285,
-0.38741663098335266,
0.17403237521648407,
-0.06098812073469162,
-0.4026883840560913,
-0.20901605486869812,
0.6352664232254028,
0.5311512351036072,
-0.36889058351516724,
0.2681087255477905,
-0.1882176697254181,
-0.0030535408295691013,
0.3157535493373871,
-0.06736426800489426,
0.5030860900878906,
-0.03722987323999405,
0.28831589221954346,
0.04111064225435257,
-0.7651787996292114,
0.5427827835083008,
0.05972586199641228,
-0.5737477540969849,
-0.315168559551239,
-0.13799212872982025,
-0.5078777074813843,
0.32826703786849976,
0.2680869400501251,
-0.5886292457580566,
0.47688549757003784,
-0.5091880559921265,
0.08656347543001175,
0.3092344403266907,
0.3489964008331299,
0.21547026932239532,
-0.36386898159980774,
0.7338530421257019,
-0.1444391906261444,
0.25397029519081116,
0.35590997338294983,
-0.8852407336235046,
-0.5706937313079834,
-0.516993522644043,
0.5367337465286255,
0.5838718414306641,
-1.0569381713867188,
0.19364610314369202,
-0.7140981554985046,
-0.6028524041175842,
-0.8346090912818909,
0.022944960743188858,
0.4930782914161682,
0.6140658259391785,
0.5965765118598938,
-0.07671397179365158,
-0.09605409950017929,
-0.8844779133796692,
-0.20629820227622986,
-0.34349191188812256,
-0.26997002959251404,
0.5104857087135315,
0.10910110175609589,
-0.39830854535102844,
0.8962011933326721,
-1.0168309211730957,
-0.005978540051728487,
-0.16455473005771637,
-0.06466279178857803,
0.25924307107925415,
0.11149509996175766,
0.3638322353363037,
-0.9748539924621582,
-0.5208367109298706,
0.02327602170407772,
-0.8080924153327942,
-0.3022771179676056,
0.5813262462615967,
-0.10832036286592484,
-0.16557927429676056,
0.3707076609134674,
-0.4082040786743164,
0.15001121163368225,
0.523327648639679,
-0.41062140464782715,
0.5041696429252625,
-0.27156034111976624,
0.6029524207115173,
-1.4266678094863892,
0.043194420635700226,
-0.4383348226547241,
-0.4061207175254822,
-0.8039203882217407,
0.2935733497142792,
0.1381692737340927,
-0.33831536769866943,
-0.22637908160686493,
0.7491064071655273,
-0.11044786125421524,
0.12555374205112457,
-0.3436453938484192,
0.15361878275871277,
-0.05833973363041878,
0.3167250454425812,
-0.22768688201904297,
0.74494469165802,
0.3520453870296478,
-0.5659812688827515,
0.4214598834514618,
0.34113678336143494,
-0.27149835228919983,
0.39991495013237,
-0.535488486289978,
0.0313277542591095,
-0.062386006116867065,
0.08522909879684448,
-0.9733814597129822,
-0.3834560513496399,
-0.015702299773693085,
-0.6928636431694031,
0.3640805184841156,
-0.3213130235671997,
-0.6281939148902893,
-0.44134753942489624,
-0.13666075468063354,
0.7299383282661438,
0.6243142485618591,
-0.6176393628120422,
0.31804564595222473,
0.5702996253967285,
-0.4752409756183624,
-0.5952038168907166,
-0.25165969133377075,
0.046335700899362564,
0.21119968593120575,
-0.7994357943534851,
0.35690057277679443,
-0.1019599586725235,
-0.12284954637289047,
-0.07153264433145523,
-0.006808917038142681,
-0.295798659324646,
0.043753474950790405,
0.12370749562978745,
0.17652389407157898,
-0.16033752262592316,
0.404827743768692,
0.196775421500206,
-0.203482523560524,
-0.04386094585061073,
0.013472303748130798,
0.4627735912799835,
0.2591988742351532,
-0.26953041553497314,
-0.26401686668395996,
0.24870340526103973,
0.948612630367279,
-0.2208411693572998,
0.79913729429245,
0.06777893006801605,
-0.41892462968826294,
0.11688757687807083,
-0.627794623374939,
-0.08417139947414398,
-0.4332687258720398,
0.569977879524231,
-0.20803533494472504,
-1.0978755950927734,
0.4496954679489136,
-0.20887495577335358,
-0.14624693989753723,
0.4162333011627197,
0.6431151032447815,
-0.0028388407081365585,
1.3899377584457397,
0.48107948899269104,
0.0012448629131540656,
-0.03192971646785736,
0.07117541134357452,
0.421843558549881,
-0.8010720014572144,
-0.41596636176109314,
-0.3687025308609009,
-0.0966259092092514,
-0.6719343066215515,
-0.5649693608283997,
1.1462568044662476,
0.3689602017402649,
-0.011367137543857098,
-0.18345701694488525,
-0.5050215125083923,
0.5153073668479919,
0.18606814742088318,
0.3383682668209076,
0.3844026029109955,
-0.21379190683364868,
-0.39688366651535034,
0.24661020934581757,
-0.6788852214813232,
-0.1953740119934082,
1.3477600812911987,
0.20651334524154663,
0.46027901768684387,
0.29113468527793884,
0.6379702091217041,
0.2441677749156952,
0.7800328731536865,
-0.7730213403701782,
0.5512535572052002,
-0.09636466950178146,
-0.42235368490219116,
-0.3740123212337494,
-0.6856321096420288,
-1.031145691871643,
0.3334228992462158,
-0.23818282783031464,
-0.4816998839378357,
-0.30910494923591614,
0.02283492684364319,
-0.42480191588401794,
0.07290292531251907,
-0.6337499618530273,
0.7051306366920471,
-0.11222028732299805,
-0.05322304368019104,
0.028838954865932465,
-0.5602167844772339,
0.3858266770839691,
0.0441141277551651,
-0.051161617040634155,
-0.03486401215195656,
0.05804719403386116,
0.7442255020141602,
-0.6049569249153137,
0.45430272817611694,
-0.1683097928762436,
-0.39161866903305054,
-0.055265553295612335,
-0.0836372971534729,
0.47655075788497925,
0.2702244520187378,
-0.20740337669849396,
-0.12220945209264755,
0.19343240559101105,
-0.4993191659450531,
-0.8797543048858643,
0.7921500205993652,
-0.7769292593002319,
-0.5981863141059875,
-0.0653642937541008,
-0.6605373024940491,
-0.7618953585624695,
0.31670668721199036,
0.02627543732523918,
0.6250107288360596,
0.07828106731176376,
0.09629763662815094,
0.7091822624206543,
-0.5512678623199463,
-0.2990664541721344,
0.49738767743110657,
-0.6779241561889648,
-0.8901203870773315,
0.8355832695960999,
0.3552265465259552,
0.44205978512763977,
0.6589372754096985,
0.24722528457641602,
-0.47823113203048706,
-0.6104306578636169,
-0.5647992491722107,
0.36981427669525146,
-0.7766146063804626,
-0.265460342168808,
-0.8155158758163452,
-0.571336567401886,
-0.7753108143806458,
-0.22810404002666473,
-0.024724237620830536,
-0.7758018970489502,
0.2073385864496231,
-0.27056628465652466,
0.5176127552986145,
0.6341581344604492,
0.40358561277389526,
0.11002010852098465,
-0.962051510810852,
0.7897666096687317,
0.5647497773170471,
0.6116443872451782,
-0.01844802126288414,
-0.10636097192764282,
-0.23533952236175537,
-0.050632309168577194,
-0.22311675548553467,
-0.8996647596359253,
0.40649357438087463,
-0.329933226108551,
0.6357970833778381,
0.2550886273384094,
-0.09441619366407394,
0.5906932353973389,
-0.4511718451976776,
0.8507920503616333,
0.15907277166843414,
-0.29670751094818115,
0.3401177227497101,
-0.4178767800331116,
0.3751022517681122,
0.5064553618431091,
0.3659398555755615,
-0.6282360553741455,
-0.5094302892684937,
-0.47917264699935913,
-0.9026414752006531,
0.29540613293647766,
0.23057784140110016,
-0.17932674288749695,
-0.1479266881942749,
0.6197871565818787,
-0.049052413552999496,
0.22126531600952148,
-0.6202273368835449,
-0.3940800130367279,
0.15464434027671814,
-0.3858048915863037,
-0.02802431769669056,
-0.6138864159584045,
-0.27357447147369385,
-0.40642428398132324,
0.8503762483596802,
-0.15197202563285828,
0.407852441072464,
0.26571962237358093,
0.00614665262401104,
0.0984175056219101,
0.31280776858329773,
0.5799383521080017,
0.8603219389915466,
-0.20310349762439728,
0.0008173948153853416,
0.17158415913581848,
-0.5570516586303711,
0.1543811559677124,
0.2140779048204422,
-0.07627380639314651,
-0.19769145548343658,
0.23758646845817566,
0.3529350459575653,
0.03498469293117523,
-0.6350520849227905,
0.46403414011001587,
0.10122533142566681,
-0.08562906086444855,
0.05059579759836197,
0.03625217080116272,
0.2815329432487488,
0.13098664581775665,
0.23811279237270355,
-0.45005181431770325,
-0.01451004296541214,
-0.3173520565032959,
0.24153143167495728,
0.4388282299041748,
-0.3791561722755432,
0.1336001306772232,
0.5500941872596741,
0.271712064743042,
-0.3451973497867584,
0.6276059746742249,
-0.08286315947771072,
-0.5305312275886536,
0.788292407989502,
0.530718982219696,
0.45138123631477356,
-0.36299827694892883,
0.2920772135257721,
0.347873717546463,
0.01980143040418625,
-0.015404962003231049,
0.5495936870574951,
0.19239574670791626,
-0.6046269536018372,
-0.5104691982269287,
-0.6465422511100769,
-0.5061303377151489,
0.029111389070749283,
-0.5027587413787842,
0.15309154987335205,
-0.11793173104524612,
-0.2215026170015335,
-0.026903662830591202,
0.053122419863939285,
-0.27517104148864746,
0.43323564529418945,
-0.12703391909599304,
0.8220794200897217,
-0.3166634738445282,
0.8211053013801575,
0.6818060278892517,
-0.2574186325073242,
-0.7857572436332703,
0.025657476857304573,
-0.4295628070831299,
-0.8918753862380981,
0.6574379801750183,
0.08433461934328079,
-0.03381086140871048,
0.21145975589752197,
-0.3153247535228729,
-1.0617979764938354,
1.3950945138931274,
0.20128095149993896,
0.04659691080451012,
-0.061624251306056976,
0.4296663701534271,
0.7430373430252075,
-0.2457047402858734,
0.29875218868255615,
0.1877238005399704,
0.32390832901000977,
0.003838341450318694,
-1.096734642982483,
0.04761969670653343,
-0.24029786884784698,
-0.26161912083625793,
0.6891279220581055,
-0.5428791046142578,
0.29661038517951965,
-0.3622682988643646,
0.1600152999162674,
0.42185723781585693,
0.2527274191379547,
0.5173385143280029,
0.5210080146789551,
0.2986191511154175,
0.789131760597229,
0.9321370124816895,
-0.081724613904953,
1.344454288482666,
-0.3989163041114807,
0.2501083016395569,
0.6515125036239624,
-0.39995715022087097,
0.7694063782691956,
0.19136126339435577,
-0.1191873699426651,
0.5051382184028625,
0.40314480662345886,
0.32222938537597656,
0.43661049008369446,
0.25177237391471863,
-0.30616065859794617,
-0.37449154257774353,
-0.07988458126783371,
-0.6008889675140381,
0.1145867258310318,
0.2788952589035034,
-0.6662119626998901,
-0.18018190562725067,
0.1327448934316635,
0.28852128982543945,
-0.17346125841140747,
-0.5202953219413757,
0.7796496152877808,
0.07828111946582794,
-0.7495812773704529,
0.8745875954627991,
0.036368388682603836,
0.11518678814172745,
-0.7097943425178528,
-0.17416007816791534,
-0.16433930397033691,
-0.03377506509423256,
-0.020622041076421738,
-0.8118556141853333,
-0.20454764366149902,
0.000709221581928432,
-0.4597482681274414,
-0.21204082667827606,
0.73564213514328,
-0.48506060242652893,
-0.6890003085136414,
0.23474664986133575,
0.6583160161972046,
0.192210391163826,
0.07816733419895172,
-0.3888605237007141,
-0.5618095993995667,
-0.21976959705352783,
-0.13908229768276215,
0.5929993391036987,
0.24426908791065216,
-0.15172964334487915,
1.0032830238342285,
0.771202564239502,
0.10981350392103195,
-0.024227483198046684,
0.1426336020231247,
0.9458953142166138,
-0.4742787778377533,
-0.513278067111969,
-0.5204074382781982,
0.1655186414718628,
-0.21946530044078827,
-0.16026531159877777,
0.4230181872844696,
0.6146887540817261,
0.45223918557167053,
0.03070136159658432,
0.44294068217277527,
0.09461463987827301,
0.7748266458511353,
-0.6346579790115356,
1.1983360052108765,
-0.7033547163009644,
0.0022252011112868786,
-0.12170463055372238,
-0.4963265061378479,
-0.7831798195838928,
-0.0030256863683462143,
-0.45061925053596497,
0.14955292642116547,
0.6311270594596863,
0.892034113407135,
0.18586252629756927,
-0.2366073876619339,
0.6635666489601135,
0.4555942118167877,
0.440321683883667,
0.5050910115242004,
0.6074572205543518,
-0.3110596239566803,
0.5373576283454895,
-0.15137332677841187,
-0.17454586923122406,
-0.12843674421310425,
-0.5657171607017517,
-0.6171306371688843,
-0.22212719917297363,
-0.2128341943025589,
-0.5776147842407227,
0.17555871605873108,
0.9249457120895386,
0.6921809911727905,
-0.551253616809845,
0.18279266357421875,
0.4487353563308716,
0.2657690644264221,
-0.4041966199874878,
-0.2382292002439499,
0.688191831111908,
-0.11907237023115158,
-0.4700385630130768,
0.6076391339302063,
0.21849007904529572,
-0.21526461839675903,
0.13446886837482452,
-0.16838155686855316,
-0.11728010326623917,
0.03830110281705856,
0.9721288681030273,
0.1979251503944397,
-0.44139301776885986,
-0.3272548019886017,
0.21571409702301025,
-0.1391681581735611,
0.15999166667461395,
0.7380167245864868,
-1.0663461685180664,
0.5357137322425842,
0.5385211110115051,
0.8686065077781677,
0.007896396331489086,
0.24099592864513397,
0.47813379764556885,
-0.6527323722839355,
-0.5194773077964783,
0.41899940371513367,
0.17977941036224365,
0.2760588228702545,
-0.4425159990787506,
0.5321468710899353,
0.13222439587116241,
-0.8152182698249817,
-0.8467044830322266,
0.3013691008090973,
-1.0713248252868652,
-0.2624644637107849,
1.421223521232605,
0.1193859651684761,
0.17623594403266907,
-0.15320540964603424,
-0.249651238322258,
0.31981533765792847,
-0.027734635397791862,
1.042849063873291,
0.6836091876029968,
-0.4039309322834015,
0.0776122659444809,
-0.640311598777771,
0.540671169757843,
0.5110765695571899,
-1.0546197891235352,
-0.11777593940496445,
0.3867887556552887,
0.5373638868331909,
0.15997634828090668,
0.9223418831825256,
-0.554354727268219,
0.3849501609802246,
-0.6294514536857605,
-0.101316437125206,
-0.1458439826965332,
-0.27504563331604004,
0.02626284584403038,
0.6059844493865967,
0.34849813580513,
-0.06185540184378624
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.05846v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.05846v1
|
Diffusion Lens: Interpreting Text Encoders in Text-to-Image Pipelines
| 2024-03-09T09:11:49 | 2024-03-09T09:11:49 |
Michael Toker, Hadas Orgad, Mor Ventura, Dana Arad, Yonatan Belinkov
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, I.2.7; I.4.0
|
Text-to-image diffusion models (T2I) use a latent representation of a text
prompt to guide the image generation process. However, the process by which the
encoder produces the text representation is unknown. We propose the Diffusion
Lens, a method for analyzing the text encoder of T2I models by generating
images from its intermediate representations. Using the Diffusion Lens, we
perform an extensive analysis of two recent T2I models. Exploring compound
prompts, we find that complex scenes describing multiple objects are composed
progressively and more slowly compared to simple scenes; Exploring knowledge
retrieval, we find that representation of uncommon concepts requires further
computation compared to common concepts, and that knowledge retrieval is
gradual across layers. Overall, our findings provide valuable insights into the
text encoder component in T2I pipelines.
|
[
-0.13481859862804413,
-0.9270173907279968,
1.0821385383605957,
-0.046071793884038925,
-0.3374668061733246,
0.04111660644412041,
0.1713564246892929,
-0.204347163438797,
-0.2239713966846466,
0.35870614647865295,
-0.5108949542045593,
-0.3371436297893524,
-1.0833208560943604,
0.009639126248657703,
-0.6549170017242432,
0.7474415898323059,
-0.1604795604944229,
0.053005293011665344,
-0.1237797886133194,
0.12931329011917114,
-0.3749309480190277,
0.19573743641376495,
-0.9532131552696228,
-0.48407232761383057,
0.4997875988483429,
0.06287819892168045,
0.5697870254516602,
0.4531407952308655,
0.45624983310699463,
0.2497837245464325,
-0.3219476640224457,
0.0453825481235981,
-0.42644646763801575,
0.09050194174051285,
0.038128409534692764,
-0.5458289980888367,
0.157639279961586,
-0.31995251774787903,
0.8300436735153198,
0.7091287970542908,
0.14370138943195343,
-0.10113133490085602,
0.16555848717689514,
0.5473824739456177,
-0.5939351320266724,
-0.2295900583267212,
-0.18362289667129517,
0.4805298149585724,
-0.3394313156604767,
-0.30376195907592773,
-0.5979001522064209,
-0.14574001729488373,
0.38619109988212585,
-0.6991710662841797,
0.3969149887561798,
0.020274534821510315,
0.5172068476676941,
0.19892960786819458,
-0.6503021717071533,
-0.6033012270927429,
-0.8913072943687439,
0.6351975202560425,
-0.28019505739212036,
0.17738544940948486,
-0.10562943667173386,
0.2655313014984131,
0.09598833322525024,
-0.9007774591445923,
-0.6409828066825867,
0.2514239251613617,
-0.171239972114563,
0.3530069589614868,
-0.2597845494747162,
-0.04626518860459328,
0.07514329999685287,
0.20235773921012878,
-0.5797647833824158,
-0.26387152075767517,
-0.5421407222747803,
0.08508924394845963,
0.2427493929862976,
0.21475115418434143,
0.4978390038013458,
-0.04097912833094597,
-0.21925464272499084,
0.09512864798307419,
-0.39463385939598083,
-0.3151663839817047,
0.2890227437019348,
-0.5555562973022461,
-0.18159903585910797,
0.7101277112960815,
0.34996333718299866,
0.7533655762672424,
0.22050926089286804,
-0.2643669545650482,
0.16391538083553314,
-0.30491793155670166,
-0.04497316852211952,
-0.0006277240463532507,
0.790638267993927,
0.6360952258110046,
0.19529734551906586,
-0.4269472062587738,
-0.23765361309051514,
0.02661428600549698,
0.19104479253292084,
-0.93400639295578,
-0.013539480976760387,
0.12788847088813782,
-0.8200563788414001,
-0.3721696138381958,
0.05894842371344566,
-0.862357497215271,
-0.40946805477142334,
0.149308979511261,
0.4265275001525879,
-0.24988491833209991,
-0.4412926733493805,
0.01129960361868143,
-0.9799854755401611,
0.1353287696838379,
0.35329532623291016,
-0.6448543071746826,
0.28788772225379944,
0.47244688868522644,
1.340826392173767,
-0.5470911860466003,
0.06155797839164734,
-0.1598801463842392,
0.44525906443595886,
-0.5877611041069031,
1.2445483207702637,
-0.9289433360099792,
-0.9105328917503357,
0.28975269198417664,
0.08634068816900253,
-0.10071687400341034,
-0.6558336615562439,
0.2257142812013626,
-0.759821891784668,
0.32657572627067566,
-0.08033230900764465,
-0.7437317967414856,
-0.12731210887432098,
0.0710824579000473,
-0.6776958703994751,
0.9922681450843811,
0.19765661656856537,
-0.8761009573936462,
0.23014318943023682,
-0.878233790397644,
-0.27190908789634705,
-0.015905926004052162,
-0.13543763756752014,
-0.1444481909275055,
0.07673892378807068,
-0.1308630257844925,
0.3730650246143341,
-0.31253334879875183,
0.18572430312633514,
-0.3442917764186859,
-0.2665626108646393,
0.4014286398887634,
-0.48979178071022034,
0.44362908601760864,
0.19520960748195648,
-0.054331567138433456,
-0.21463890373706818,
-0.4714011251926422,
-0.496875524520874,
-0.014335080049932003,
-0.10816138237714767,
-0.337017685174942,
0.17650862038135529,
0.23359079658985138,
-0.07892661541700363,
0.15176084637641907,
-0.6329268217086792,
0.1080731600522995,
-0.11831884831190109,
0.6776179075241089,
0.5887168645858765,
0.6682094931602478,
1.0855457782745361,
0.06898093223571777,
0.46413472294807434,
0.7497376799583435,
-0.005444811657071114,
-0.5717933773994446,
-0.9948166012763977,
-0.8567644357681274,
0.30439814925193787,
-0.048892103135585785,
0.6050019264221191,
-0.9227635860443115,
-0.24023489654064178,
-0.08401181548833847,
-0.19080045819282532,
-0.43088072538375854,
-0.012649156153202057,
0.09436672925949097,
0.7056776285171509,
0.23891903460025787,
-0.27620986104011536,
0.09447544068098068,
-0.8367035984992981,
-0.1716107577085495,
0.007166045717895031,
-0.2442207932472229,
0.21829961240291595,
0.6705862283706665,
-0.5639195442199707,
0.9770551919937134,
-0.8731388449668884,
-0.16360947489738464,
0.05271480605006218,
0.5862830877304077,
-0.0045186253264546394,
0.47581589221954346,
0.4077143371105194,
-0.9541840553283691,
-0.43254736065864563,
-0.025676609948277473,
-0.9059889912605286,
-0.11084926873445511,
-0.14569416642189026,
-0.28334668278694153,
0.12351754307746887,
0.797132134437561,
-0.6591811776161194,
0.5785267949104309,
0.2650260329246521,
-0.5229619145393372,
0.27163973450660706,
-0.24077720940113068,
0.19044312834739685,
-1.1778626441955566,
0.14499853551387787,
0.3806544244289398,
-0.2749173045158386,
-0.6153634190559387,
-0.15634892880916595,
-0.0845237672328949,
-0.11578860878944397,
-0.2976342439651489,
0.6639868021011353,
-0.5233193039894104,
-0.10448651760816574,
-0.22698822617530823,
0.23428846895694733,
0.2521904408931732,
0.03480884060263634,
0.4011184573173523,
0.9938580393791199,
0.5982388854026794,
-0.7913914918899536,
0.21976976096630096,
0.0681946724653244,
-0.43981868028640747,
0.6623579263687134,
-0.9314225912094116,
0.3558287024497986,
-0.5262616872787476,
0.20984062552452087,
-1.2201849222183228,
-0.17147491872310638,
0.5685980319976807,
-0.1832171529531479,
0.2529113292694092,
-0.20578457415103912,
-0.5661254525184631,
-0.29240748286247253,
-0.021217677742242813,
0.6716276407241821,
0.7145811915397644,
-0.2628238797187805,
0.6956339478492737,
0.1575545072555542,
-0.12859377264976501,
-0.21078594028949738,
-1.1379462480545044,
-0.13894258439540863,
-0.17322437465190887,
-0.6910189986228943,
0.614541232585907,
-0.1875586360692978,
-0.28992000222206116,
0.41800257563591003,
0.22155463695526123,
-0.6365190744400024,
-0.2626842260360718,
0.1589709371328354,
-0.014657787047326565,
-0.1908663809299469,
0.09844134747982025,
0.540917158126831,
-0.16176368296146393,
0.12956972420215607,
-0.6290034055709839,
0.08000706881284714,
0.5897382497787476,
-0.18390241265296936,
-0.40506264567375183,
0.6529000997543335,
0.3132275640964508,
0.08647595345973969,
0.7797127962112427,
0.7827090620994568,
-0.23179946839809418,
0.051802121102809906,
-0.3164750635623932,
0.0155213987454772,
-0.48561421036720276,
0.20426662266254425,
-0.3388898968696594,
-0.5609682202339172,
0.5706343054771423,
-0.30757996439933777,
-0.12581996619701385,
0.520650327205658,
0.33816781640052795,
-0.3141610324382782,
1.0037028789520264,
0.5119687914848328,
0.4208918511867523,
0.6142661571502686,
-0.6110091209411621,
0.09273526817560196,
-0.8964294195175171,
-0.6345574855804443,
-0.2529330551624298,
-0.2313576638698578,
-0.13247917592525482,
-0.8501482605934143,
0.5090151429176331,
-0.079224593937397,
-0.16305625438690186,
-0.3015408217906952,
-0.38203829526901245,
0.7234482169151306,
0.3991585671901703,
0.3600575625896454,
0.3605418801307678,
0.25060591101646423,
0.00766576174646616,
-0.04421273246407509,
-0.522652268409729,
-0.5399192571640015,
0.9177546501159668,
0.29054298996925354,
0.5816223621368408,
0.21303199231624603,
0.3921745717525482,
0.6213122606277466,
-0.018971549347043037,
-0.7324855923652649,
0.4652046263217926,
-0.34751737117767334,
-0.41248729825019836,
0.1083177849650383,
-0.1318858116865158,
-0.7949762344360352,
-0.018066275864839554,
-0.0910649448633194,
-0.3961229622364044,
0.3560963273048401,
-0.08901142328977585,
-0.1393471211194992,
0.25293922424316406,
-0.9315091371536255,
0.8224982619285583,
0.3399695158004761,
-0.3691730499267578,
-0.33946526050567627,
-0.46352922916412354,
0.15078414976596832,
-0.1263725906610489,
0.11429689079523087,
0.45625630021095276,
-0.5071082711219788,
0.8513942360877991,
-0.24963943660259247,
0.6975425481796265,
-0.33361610770225525,
-0.1512160301208496,
0.5661267638206482,
0.16624175012111664,
0.09651274979114532,
0.01251111552119255,
-0.04460904374718666,
0.13405045866966248,
-0.3049885630607605,
-0.38750770688056946,
-0.7670347094535828,
0.3706025183200836,
-0.593002438545227,
-0.4281516969203949,
-0.33192625641822815,
-0.14982442557811737,
0.2870737910270691,
0.17746961116790771,
0.8756300210952759,
0.7297624349594116,
-0.11221735924482346,
-0.10542910546064377,
0.9648059606552124,
-0.22216202318668365,
0.8098365664482117,
0.2333742082118988,
-0.056278642266988754,
-0.08893844485282898,
0.749945878982544,
0.22413387894630432,
0.39322158694267273,
0.5197632312774658,
-0.011637547053396702,
-0.32588711380958557,
-0.621199369430542,
-0.7679355144500732,
0.172679603099823,
-0.7405078411102295,
-0.0802256241440773,
-0.7022444009780884,
-0.12267789244651794,
-0.014080125838518143,
-0.2572968304157257,
-0.11712756007909775,
-0.20826289057731628,
-1.0810976028442383,
0.09713590890169144,
0.29077860713005066,
1.168626070022583,
0.3554808497428894,
0.6263514161109924,
-0.784910261631012,
0.27590176463127136,
0.3079032003879547,
0.30354776978492737,
0.16695208847522736,
-0.6338791847229004,
-0.2920890152454376,
-0.10126610845327377,
-0.45525050163269043,
-1.1390548944473267,
0.26497316360473633,
0.4060113728046417,
0.0710463747382164,
0.8338891267776489,
-0.3220199942588806,
0.7607234120368958,
-0.8992286324501038,
1.3167678117752075,
0.33377522230148315,
-0.8624971508979797,
0.7483717203140259,
-0.32674965262413025,
0.41534796357154846,
-0.019327569752931595,
0.4140235185623169,
-0.42832842469215393,
-0.5187686085700989,
-0.3786444365978241,
-0.5053454041481018,
0.49268051981925964,
0.13569219410419464,
0.3070020377635956,
-0.11441957205533981,
0.6495136022567749,
0.15443097054958344,
-0.0013774242252111435,
-0.5602051615715027,
-0.26776736974716187,
-0.11098939925432205,
-0.4773806929588318,
0.1226939857006073,
-0.5901244282722473,
-0.06099797412753105,
0.2904074490070343,
0.17528383433818817,
0.06552360206842422,
0.7546610236167908,
0.5613675713539124,
-0.3203899562358856,
-0.09639129042625427,
0.0715666338801384,
0.2577156126499176,
0.239095538854599,
0.11509212851524353,
0.07169398665428162,
-0.23710134625434875,
-0.6571708917617798,
0.15332774817943573,
-0.23876440525054932,
-0.5482759475708008,
0.36199086904525757,
0.4878369867801666,
0.8682618141174316,
0.14293397963047028,
-0.2925174832344055,
0.7433418035507202,
0.02233186922967434,
-0.29164788126945496,
-0.37494710087776184,
0.08861585706472397,
-0.06779215484857559,
0.48277029395103455,
0.6391687393188477,
0.49399611353874207,
0.8581635355949402,
-0.4123016595840454,
-0.03837325796484947,
0.1689620018005371,
-0.3869234621524811,
-0.5387409925460815,
0.7134301066398621,
0.4454382061958313,
-0.3372691869735718,
0.5718327760696411,
-0.24434490501880646,
-0.2771586775779724,
0.5400079488754272,
0.5616765022277832,
0.8904247879981995,
0.053561534732580185,
0.5914552807807922,
0.23594129085540771,
0.12384650111198425,
-0.37441450357437134,
-0.05525416135787964,
-0.07850560545921326,
-0.7764179706573486,
-0.25792351365089417,
-0.18294906616210938,
-0.12483368813991547,
-0.3197241425514221,
-0.5387634634971619,
-0.026273082941770554,
-0.1694880574941635,
-0.29269155859947205,
0.06486613303422928,
-0.4238528609275818,
-0.5408062934875488,
0.19514529407024384,
0.2111968994140625,
0.8045284152030945,
-0.930441677570343,
0.6517637372016907,
0.5663183927536011,
-0.31661659479141235,
-0.3554653823375702,
0.2733250856399536,
-0.11603029072284698,
-0.5488762855529785,
0.8483788371086121,
0.14309832453727722,
-0.07773899286985397,
0.05581973120570183,
-0.5603748559951782,
-0.354836642742157,
1.177789330482483,
0.20639096200466156,
-0.3580020070075989,
-0.23173788189888,
0.16722121834754944,
0.5305303931236267,
-0.6745234131813049,
0.5969598293304443,
0.3835480809211731,
0.3525331914424896,
0.30985209345817566,
-0.22955642640590668,
-0.15316987037658691,
-0.3067193925380707,
0.47532927989959717,
0.11008942127227783,
-0.4395557641983032,
0.7191356420516968,
-0.2106173187494278,
-0.5282957553863525,
0.15602557361125946,
0.46472740173339844,
-0.13115572929382324,
0.8688068389892578,
0.34603920578956604,
0.5204726457595825,
0.6190397143363953,
-0.1598109006881714,
1.1705642938613892,
-0.004380472935736179,
0.2930527627468109,
0.5448057651519775,
-0.13303446769714355,
0.8384407162666321,
0.5738655924797058,
-0.010732335038483143,
1.0458258390426636,
0.7599104046821594,
-0.1269586980342865,
0.7913075685501099,
-0.45774853229522705,
-0.48682549595832825,
0.10110949724912643,
-0.13794338703155518,
-0.31252768635749817,
-0.18498429656028748,
0.3855321407318115,
-0.7340664863586426,
0.012037098407745361,
0.3125160038471222,
-0.29314297437667847,
-0.24830350279808044,
-0.329570472240448,
0.994080662727356,
0.1008654236793518,
-0.6307047009468079,
-0.030638722702860832,
-0.11256089806556702,
0.724392831325531,
-0.3251512944698334,
-0.18451234698295593,
-0.1670258790254593,
-0.0529126301407814,
-0.23997412621974945,
-1.2953671216964722,
0.5194169282913208,
0.18956951797008514,
-0.538382351398468,
-0.3198944926261902,
0.9289839863777161,
-0.6095700860023499,
-0.5905953049659729,
0.3279128670692444,
0.2708328664302826,
0.24810345470905304,
0.009145536459982395,
-0.5686832666397095,
-0.010234926827251911,
-0.09444152563810349,
-0.3435666263103485,
-0.14172641932964325,
0.770759642124176,
0.3881058692932129,
0.47689884901046753,
0.2321750670671463,
-0.14512407779693604,
0.265619695186615,
0.1238119900226593,
0.6890844702720642,
-0.6220849752426147,
-0.2734752595424652,
-0.8842753171920776,
0.8110215663909912,
-0.13020937144756317,
-0.15368255972862244,
0.43000176548957825,
0.6542550921440125,
0.3683123290538788,
-0.42046189308166504,
0.7905687093734741,
0.15458771586418152,
0.22350673377513885,
-0.7821668386459351,
0.6289664506912231,
-0.6996988654136658,
0.21148771047592163,
-0.20804986357688904,
-1.0306118726730347,
-0.16181974112987518,
0.6068152189254761,
-0.19207605719566345,
-0.08091563731431961,
0.9316716194152832,
0.8307756185531616,
-0.1887461096048355,
0.0821973979473114,
-0.03012351505458355,
0.15119950473308563,
0.04644269496202469,
0.2905925512313843,
0.7100504040718079,
-0.6974525451660156,
0.6151002049446106,
0.22871799767017365,
-0.0488257072865963,
0.05641035735607147,
-0.6316356658935547,
-0.7450746893882751,
-0.6793419122695923,
-0.5808508396148682,
-0.33887284994125366,
-0.013695714063942432,
0.06397286057472229,
0.8162854909896851,
-0.25061607360839844,
-0.05464811250567436,
-0.6640149354934692,
0.1466350555419922,
0.19677889347076416,
-0.2540821135044098,
0.003584972582757473,
-0.24733196198940277,
-0.8891061544418335,
-0.019333112984895706,
0.3436594307422638,
0.41829293966293335,
-0.41058841347694397,
-0.12523384392261505,
0.2223680168390274,
0.04083961620926857,
0.6475672721862793,
-0.2988947629928589,
-0.5434969663619995,
0.0871710404753685,
0.12561039626598358,
0.11302386224269867,
0.13395385444164276,
0.8275936841964722,
-0.701306939125061,
0.673222541809082,
0.5795143246650696,
0.3452030122280121,
0.7827098965644836,
-0.28280559182167053,
0.6252581477165222,
-0.7062666416168213,
0.32888081669807434,
-0.0746951624751091,
0.045135971158742905,
0.3574804365634918,
-0.24641580879688263,
0.3899868428707123,
0.5536637902259827,
-0.4335203468799591,
-0.6364029049873352,
0.3442852795124054,
-1.0033655166625977,
-0.352201372385025,
1.377739667892456,
-0.12364115566015244,
-0.4567141830921173,
-0.1063309758901596,
-0.31136012077331543,
0.19014950096607208,
-0.6218293309211731,
0.2583954632282257,
0.6972601413726807,
0.20167218148708344,
-0.6597679853439331,
-0.49263325333595276,
0.178331196308136,
-0.006701595149934292,
-0.533292829990387,
-0.505272388458252,
0.4587719142436981,
0.4232332110404968,
0.35178419947624207,
0.7538853883743286,
-0.24446775019168854,
0.013283067382872105,
0.21074603497982025,
-0.5582612156867981,
0.41468310356140137,
-0.20401409268379211,
-0.4138393700122833,
0.19620686769485474,
-0.2481207251548767,
-0.20232276618480682
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.05845v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.05845v1
|
Reverse That Number! Decoding Order Matters in Arithmetic Learning
| 2024-03-09T09:04:53 | 2024-03-09T09:04:53 |
Daniel Zhang-Li, Nianyi Lin, Jifan Yu, Zheyuan Zhang, Zijun Yao, Xiaokang Zhang, Lei Hou, Jing Zhang, Juanzi Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recent advancements in pretraining have demonstrated that modern Large
Language Models (LLMs) possess the capability to effectively learn arithmetic
operations. However, despite acknowledging the significance of digit order in
arithmetic computation, current methodologies predominantly rely on sequential,
step-by-step approaches for teaching LLMs arithmetic, resulting in a conclusion
where obtaining better performance involves fine-grained step-by-step.
Diverging from this conventional path, our work introduces a novel strategy
that not only reevaluates the digit order by prioritizing output from the least
significant digit but also incorporates a step-by-step methodology to
substantially reduce complexity. We have developed and applied this method in a
comprehensive set of experiments. Compared to the previous state-of-the-art
(SOTA) method, our findings reveal an overall improvement of in accuracy while
requiring only a third of the tokens typically used during training. For the
purpose of facilitating replication and further research, we have made our code
and dataset publicly available at
\url{https://anonymous.4open.science/r/RAIT-9FB7/}.
|
[
-0.2690657377243042,
-0.5763994455337524,
0.4092058539390564,
0.23169998824596405,
-0.581821084022522,
0.11879044026136398,
0.06997929513454437,
-0.29198896884918213,
0.28372687101364136,
0.6583753228187561,
-0.4745400846004486,
-0.46024033427238464,
-0.8070547580718994,
0.19633610546588898,
-0.3458801805973053,
0.8459721207618713,
0.2559647560119629,
0.7071738243103027,
-0.12905117869377136,
-0.12149930745363235,
-0.06918284296989441,
-0.8325894474983215,
-0.9250147342681885,
-0.30856046080589294,
0.5147395133972168,
0.6952849626541138,
0.5321993827819824,
0.8554618954658508,
0.7059628963470459,
0.40636947751045227,
0.010725868865847588,
0.052216481417417526,
-0.8116368055343628,
-0.3438529074192047,
0.0667286142706871,
-0.7000272870063782,
-0.6923520565032959,
-0.2449609637260437,
0.572869598865509,
0.8445063233375549,
-0.09806055575609207,
0.4263797402381897,
-0.46799999475479126,
1.1298863887786865,
-0.7261629700660706,
0.14340396225452423,
-0.48240038752555847,
-0.13236995041370392,
-0.24309216439723969,
-0.5276750326156616,
-0.8230862021446228,
-0.7126386761665344,
-0.32883957028388977,
-0.5158972144126892,
0.270603746175766,
-0.0225980281829834,
0.1473592072725296,
0.26585653424263,
-0.21367287635803223,
-0.0734487846493721,
-0.6746959090232849,
0.7131257057189941,
-0.8683090209960938,
0.6025091409683228,
0.5909990072250366,
-0.013223058544099331,
-0.026036882773041725,
-0.7504881024360657,
-0.568900465965271,
0.2631256878376007,
0.3204256296157837,
-0.08613518625497818,
0.14106673002243042,
-0.008079620078206062,
0.5193063020706177,
0.4023119807243347,
-0.40983498096466064,
0.16657109558582306,
-0.5846197605133057,
-0.10728489607572556,
0.6756983995437622,
0.2881181836128235,
0.13590185344219208,
0.40690740942955017,
0.008141132071614265,
-0.5542094111442566,
-1.250054121017456,
0.22365640103816986,
0.30814653635025024,
0.22782497107982635,
0.13592104613780975,
0.6746072173118591,
-0.4363063871860504,
0.4637865424156189,
0.3909757435321808,
-0.08436397463083267,
0.5502414703369141,
-0.22536571323871613,
-0.35054877400398254,
0.4493432939052582,
0.5525412559509277,
0.09653083235025406,
0.2690142095088959,
0.11260819435119629,
-0.30330702662467957,
0.07369886338710785,
0.2501077950000763,
-1.2214378118515015,
-0.1168200820684433,
-0.18174494802951813,
-0.1607365906238556,
-0.4571392834186554,
0.10051894932985306,
-0.35964253544807434,
-0.3696821630001068,
-0.2793736457824707,
0.6454287171363831,
-0.34902793169021606,
-0.005295774433761835,
0.42958691716194153,
0.4328418970108032,
0.1327468901872635,
0.43979084491729736,
-1.347012996673584,
0.48923343420028687,
1.185156226158142,
0.5601087808609009,
0.31430986523628235,
-0.18990497291088104,
-0.6755136251449585,
-0.40279266238212585,
-0.886258602142334,
0.2833262085914612,
-0.6087823510169983,
-0.3913050889968872,
-0.26960813999176025,
-0.16759182512760162,
0.16439661383628845,
-0.5238384008407593,
0.48225241899490356,
-1.1344255208969116,
0.21118701994419098,
-0.32844704389572144,
-0.45059728622436523,
-0.401589035987854,
-0.16412734985351562,
-0.6501327753067017,
0.7109326720237732,
-0.3005848526954651,
-0.6085190773010254,
0.1777055263519287,
-0.27729132771492004,
-0.6721116304397583,
-0.12657654285430908,
-0.21996097266674042,
-0.6289553046226501,
0.6331024765968323,
0.1727052479982376,
0.1787603199481964,
-0.062325477600097656,
-0.08761502057313919,
-0.1894698590040207,
-0.775882363319397,
-0.007875162176787853,
-0.7460749745368958,
0.8518424034118652,
-0.013964740559458733,
-0.4184739887714386,
0.1768994927406311,
-0.8269467949867249,
0.009219452738761902,
0.2425774782896042,
-0.4735986888408661,
-0.3549971282482147,
-0.11971260607242584,
-0.8184199929237366,
0.21717824041843414,
0.1729339063167572,
-0.4758944809436798,
0.26254963874816895,
-0.8732650876045227,
0.29348912835121155,
0.8848863244056702,
-0.04939386621117592,
0.9159348011016846,
-0.1503322571516037,
0.4495159983634949,
-0.1348559707403183,
-0.08022590726613998,
-0.2936064898967743,
-0.4301723539829254,
-0.9380031228065491,
-0.08961944282054901,
0.34443312883377075,
0.5429967641830444,
-0.8131391406059265,
0.3370357155799866,
-0.5771278142929077,
-0.3573923707008362,
-0.6911729574203491,
-0.040203992277383804,
0.6306246519088745,
0.46120935678482056,
0.44043415784835815,
-0.5877652168273926,
-0.5781818628311157,
-0.39621180295944214,
-0.08163785189390182,
-0.21708500385284424,
0.04060423746705055,
-0.13785286247730255,
0.12977319955825806,
-0.02263851836323738,
0.4019128084182739,
-0.6321592330932617,
0.11036782711744308,
-0.12666574120521545,
0.2365988790988922,
0.4197670817375183,
0.5369568467140198,
0.007919359020888805,
-0.9051979184150696,
-0.2243509143590927,
-0.19301685690879822,
-0.5170606970787048,
0.05496598407626152,
-0.09172657877206802,
-0.24797840416431427,
0.43805044889450073,
0.6300179362297058,
-0.47455906867980957,
0.6794440150260925,
0.3162072002887726,
-0.23335717618465424,
0.32346057891845703,
-0.2345835566520691,
0.1712370663881302,
-0.7551067471504211,
-0.2055543214082718,
-0.5606396794319153,
-0.3148897886276245,
-0.7185379266738892,
0.006528264842927456,
0.3005175292491913,
-0.06325217336416245,
-0.4063923954963684,
0.2323557734489441,
-0.35108333826065063,
-0.29423680901527405,
-0.04550940915942192,
-0.6563152074813843,
-0.021107913926243782,
0.5360273718833923,
0.08188597857952118,
0.9626936912536621,
0.16573481261730194,
-0.4890844225883484,
-0.20139466226100922,
0.0328984260559082,
-0.29195839166641235,
-0.07472258061170578,
-0.42482617497444153,
0.42950063943862915,
-0.1991214007139206,
0.13451053202152252,
-1.1196759939193726,
0.2552225589752197,
0.35061538219451904,
-0.8132169842720032,
0.5871526002883911,
-0.24688641726970673,
-0.4719052016735077,
-0.11712928116321564,
-0.3329450488090515,
0.8823281526565552,
0.7520959973335266,
-0.4119510352611542,
0.37316274642944336,
0.24282978475093842,
-0.5059567093849182,
-0.6754838228225708,
-0.3815549314022064,
-0.08878709375858307,
-0.14510928094387054,
-0.38247546553611755,
0.23820124566555023,
-0.13693350553512573,
-0.2924996614456177,
-0.6459256410598755,
-0.4836380183696747,
-0.07909813523292542,
0.22690729796886444,
0.18845951557159424,
0.22496800124645233,
-0.38769280910491943,
0.11021322011947632,
-0.043261073529720306,
-0.5353560447692871,
0.43478918075561523,
-0.40852683782577515,
0.7710818648338318,
-0.06977785378694534,
-0.41327184438705444,
-0.3317490220069885,
0.22701169550418854,
0.7843054533004761,
-0.3466132581233978,
0.5817304253578186,
0.3433920741081238,
-0.3879481256008148,
0.03665195778012276,
-0.2938813269138336,
-0.387448251247406,
-0.5805500149726868,
0.44960740208625793,
-0.424425333738327,
-0.46700409054756165,
0.21345394849777222,
0.004703974351286888,
0.21156634390354156,
0.12746264040470123,
0.633508563041687,
0.07525435090065002,
1.2271137237548828,
0.4632192850112915,
-0.18477165699005127,
0.6258280277252197,
-0.5546073317527771,
0.5143129825592041,
-0.2589972913265228,
-0.1998549997806549,
-0.3218952417373657,
-0.10057500749826431,
-0.4177148938179016,
-0.5493929982185364,
0.010982140898704529,
0.18429449200630188,
-0.4481586217880249,
0.12633103132247925,
-0.19860267639160156,
0.8190425634384155,
0.38804298639297485,
0.4908980131149292,
0.45736125111579895,
0.31666097044944763,
0.1258455067873001,
-0.12349283695220947,
-0.6206722259521484,
-0.3229852616786957,
1.1271215677261353,
0.14462684094905853,
0.7407093048095703,
0.21145759522914886,
1.4668928384780884,
0.1958840936422348,
0.505689263343811,
-0.9548742771148682,
0.8434300422668457,
-0.3866482079029083,
-0.13431577384471893,
-0.8049734830856323,
-0.6526421904563904,
-0.9780160784721375,
0.43862250447273254,
-0.03664692863821983,
-0.1243126168847084,
0.010354597121477127,
0.02608530968427658,
-0.38408204913139343,
0.24382933974266052,
-0.7741032838821411,
0.37537315487861633,
-0.2856866121292114,
-0.41473281383514404,
-0.5288258790969849,
-0.6145170331001282,
0.19869114458560944,
-0.14244715869426727,
0.5164746642112732,
0.17336907982826233,
-0.06662701815366745,
0.8097010850906372,
-1.0599509477615356,
0.7975115776062012,
-0.08735784888267517,
-0.42765718698501587,
0.07168059051036835,
0.39579084515571594,
0.5926652550697327,
-0.19186915457248688,
-0.023075498640537262,
0.10773274302482605,
-0.4862879514694214,
-0.53987717628479,
-0.5858084559440613,
0.7465537190437317,
-0.8798223733901978,
-0.7250857353210449,
-0.26653075218200684,
-0.09730067104101181,
-0.13905635476112366,
0.4935251772403717,
0.4572601616382599,
0.9953214526176453,
0.23628704249858856,
0.03673737868666649,
0.8725864887237549,
0.19239509105682373,
0.5178461074829102,
0.46226730942726135,
-0.032464563846588135,
-0.6587997674942017,
1.3071664571762085,
0.4711132347583771,
0.3009999990463257,
0.8857683539390564,
0.2016770839691162,
-0.5492995977401733,
-0.8362812399864197,
-0.43771740794181824,
0.1488281935453415,
-0.877941370010376,
-0.15878482162952423,
-0.38624727725982666,
0.1022954210639,
-0.5829561948776245,
-0.2523362934589386,
-0.4059488773345947,
-0.7746538519859314,
-0.39482179284095764,
-0.3833944797515869,
0.10787980258464813,
0.7584646940231323,
0.022937709465622902,
0.13208138942718506,
-0.9028862714767456,
0.6359401345252991,
0.42175447940826416,
0.3384992778301239,
0.2771291136741638,
-0.8134146928787231,
-0.2377612143754959,
0.13517117500305176,
0.026205282658338547,
-0.6278560161590576,
0.5363906621932983,
0.03159713000059128,
0.12441986054182053,
0.4048875868320465,
0.2146579623222351,
0.9251555800437927,
-0.8325045704841614,
0.16008904576301575,
0.4474911093711853,
-0.9589874744415283,
0.009722983464598656,
-0.013182519935071468,
0.10500335693359375,
0.7091115117073059,
0.2668326497077942,
-0.0971699133515358,
0.17671267688274384,
-0.7835291028022766,
-1.2733867168426514,
0.7355147004127502,
0.0886339619755745,
0.13073354959487915,
0.010096649639308453,
0.020413342863321304,
0.2271522879600525,
0.22745542228221893,
-0.30733954906463623,
-0.38445261120796204,
-0.12979210913181305,
-0.3188541531562805,
-0.4125814437866211,
-0.26265302300453186,
0.08368506282567978,
-0.25987356901168823,
0.49276435375213623,
0.09319070726633072,
0.22617565095424652,
-0.07350797206163406,
-0.4429972767829895,
-0.008987033739686012,
0.23524653911590576,
0.8645015358924866,
0.8506717085838318,
-0.1017320454120636,
0.32052555680274963,
0.333403080701828,
-0.8449404239654541,
0.2733370363712311,
-0.1901206076145172,
-0.14372572302818298,
-0.11089852452278137,
0.6441060900688171,
0.5734239220619202,
0.4793555736541748,
-0.22584936022758484,
0.45311757922172546,
-0.04314035922288895,
-0.13415896892547607,
-0.241168811917305,
-0.04844425991177559,
-0.06908179819583893,
0.010149648413062096,
0.6029574871063232,
0.26809656620025635,
0.245077982544899,
-0.36870455741882324,
0.3771823048591614,
-0.0707177147269249,
-0.03597034513950348,
-0.5594477653503418,
0.20525121688842773,
0.41263872385025024,
-0.7763849496841431,
0.6700918674468994,
-0.09216924011707306,
-0.5213983058929443,
0.7627259492874146,
0.6947019100189209,
0.8497925400733948,
-0.06230516731739044,
0.001341571449302137,
0.3398972749710083,
0.08424872159957886,
-0.31490379571914673,
0.5757982134819031,
-0.2132091373205185,
-0.6734542846679688,
-0.6403964757919312,
-0.3555927574634552,
-0.4090272784233093,
-0.3199409544467926,
-0.8608149290084839,
0.068292997777462,
-0.8308393955230713,
0.02528994157910347,
0.16218897700309753,
0.1552339345216751,
-0.5273694396018982,
0.2333250641822815,
0.4623558819293976,
0.9526546597480774,
-0.7620177865028381,
0.8465933799743652,
0.7003777027130127,
-0.2071927934885025,
-0.5758174061775208,
-0.14457885921001434,
-0.12335760146379471,
-1.2999370098114014,
0.7740392088890076,
0.34911394119262695,
-0.4975796937942505,
0.5729575753211975,
-0.7038423418998718,
-0.7939546704292297,
0.8752301931381226,
0.24842454493045807,
-0.6669662594795227,
0.11891064047813416,
0.23332370817661285,
0.44676828384399414,
-0.2943814992904663,
0.3714044392108917,
0.30880284309387207,
0.11056919395923615,
0.4098307490348816,
-0.5217417478561401,
0.03456049785017967,
-0.2068665623664856,
-0.23318134248256683,
0.5717446208000183,
-0.44577401876449585,
0.7531158924102783,
-0.7750800848007202,
-0.3371588885784149,
-0.05885066092014313,
0.5330896973609924,
0.46661344170570374,
0.5290727615356445,
0.4191293716430664,
0.8079628348350525,
0.683333694934845,
0.088704913854599,
0.9679877161979675,
-0.02212662249803543,
0.1563558727502823,
1.0178391933441162,
-0.09022697806358337,
1.0897908210754395,
0.6146961450576782,
-0.5255679488182068,
0.29814037680625916,
0.599596381187439,
0.6994132399559021,
0.6018312573432922,
0.28758978843688965,
-0.06282652914524078,
-0.49281731247901917,
0.35014814138412476,
-0.46274334192276,
0.11235972493886948,
0.22356843948364258,
-0.15163807570934296,
-0.02540069818496704,
-0.41674211621284485,
0.23833434283733368,
-0.09114090353250504,
-0.728742778301239,
1.0034407377243042,
0.11698949337005615,
-0.35719022154808044,
1.0359128713607788,
-0.15548072755336761,
0.46995535492897034,
-0.4449751675128937,
-0.3730202913284302,
-0.532117486000061,
0.49636971950531006,
-0.23615694046020508,
-0.629453718662262,
0.06095457449555397,
-0.24323001503944397,
-0.35318848490715027,
-0.48099279403686523,
0.23114578425884247,
-0.4052703082561493,
-0.8195410966873169,
-0.0858188197016716,
0.12925973534584045,
0.19192032516002655,
0.015175365842878819,
-0.368947297334671,
0.04555913805961609,
0.17620350420475006,
-0.1401975452899933,
0.5007153153419495,
0.5784664154052734,
-0.4453663229942322,
0.7397630214691162,
1.006148338317871,
-0.04826654493808746,
0.175079345703125,
0.27425417304039,
0.8483259677886963,
-0.8065963983535767,
-0.5580883622169495,
-1.0730483531951904,
0.34953615069389343,
0.2574530839920044,
-0.1964900642633438,
0.6400952935218811,
0.5258001089096069,
1.1626651287078857,
-0.19666941463947296,
0.36743292212486267,
0.3499198257923126,
0.13564233481884003,
-0.6332104802131653,
0.33774393796920776,
-0.18296286463737488,
0.5258840918540955,
-0.08225899189710617,
-0.6964089274406433,
-0.5958254933357239,
0.705345094203949,
-0.5178550481796265,
-0.13472072780132294,
0.3633699417114258,
0.7160810828208923,
0.2467467039823532,
0.08088420331478119,
0.3925324082374573,
0.18280400335788727,
0.06622582674026489,
0.42308005690574646,
0.8662042021751404,
-0.6305758357048035,
0.5066081285476685,
-0.3497127294540405,
-0.30580732226371765,
-0.38395240902900696,
-0.4911384880542755,
-0.595476508140564,
-0.09771114587783813,
-0.03717048838734627,
-0.199290931224823,
0.06210843101143837,
1.062752366065979,
0.5993537306785583,
-0.9841790199279785,
-0.24413904547691345,
-0.27557429671287537,
0.41847431659698486,
-0.239046111702919,
-0.0659317597746849,
0.35197827219963074,
-0.09744779765605927,
-0.6119433045387268,
0.19707751274108887,
0.1122576966881752,
0.22694820165634155,
0.23802374303340912,
-0.3223996162414551,
0.07175549119710922,
0.08700497448444366,
0.8798113465309143,
0.3380461037158966,
-0.5094044804573059,
0.007007373962551355,
0.36689096689224243,
-0.19732119143009186,
0.21222683787345886,
1.1519240140914917,
-0.8555818200111389,
0.36376604437828064,
1.1264256238937378,
0.7215604186058044,
0.46072614192962646,
0.4006657600402832,
0.5068050622940063,
-0.39348146319389343,
0.03635657578706741,
0.30438315868377686,
0.23415285348892212,
0.1428741067647934,
-0.2819138765335083,
0.5041372776031494,
0.24197718501091003,
-0.3170551061630249,
-0.7751389741897583,
0.1734251081943512,
-0.6566416025161743,
-0.08909960091114044,
0.985053539276123,
-0.12445027381181717,
-0.10827303677797318,
-0.033500850200653076,
-0.3822517991065979,
0.09285574406385422,
-0.5885940194129944,
0.8064194917678833,
0.22952589392662048,
-0.011370756663382053,
-0.15513426065444946,
0.1425011307001114,
0.321353018283844,
0.6230610609054565,
-0.4114381670951843,
0.2135537564754486,
0.2812535762786865,
0.13712818920612335,
0.2538297474384308,
0.8337421417236328,
-0.2126418501138687,
0.3158854842185974,
-0.0463610403239727,
-0.14980074763298035,
-0.15358467400074005,
-0.6202639937400818,
-0.7638775706291199,
0.024726172909140587,
0.19695203006267548,
-0.4576854109764099
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.05820v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.05820v2
|
An Audio-textual Diffusion Model For Converting Speech Signals Into Ultrasound Tongue Imaging Data
| 2024-03-09T06:59:47 | 2024-03-12T11:26:07 |
Yudong Yang, Rongfeng Su, Xiaokang Liu, Nan Yan, Lan Wang
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS
|
Acoustic-to-articulatory inversion (AAI) is to convert audio into articulator
movements, such as ultrasound tongue imaging (UTI) data. An issue of existing
AAI methods is only using the personalized acoustic information to derive the
general patterns of tongue motions, and thus the quality of generated UTI data
is limited. To address this issue, this paper proposes an audio-textual
diffusion model for the UTI data generation task. In this model, the inherent
acoustic characteristics of individuals related to the tongue motion details
are encoded by using wav2vec 2.0, while the ASR transcriptions related to the
universality of tongue motions are encoded by using BERT. UTI data are then
generated by using a diffusion module. Experimental results showed that the
proposed diffusion model could generate high-quality UTI data with clear tongue
contour that is crucial for the linguistic analysis and clinical assessment.
The project can be found on the
website\footnote{https://yangyudong2020.github.io/wav2uti/
|
[
-0.25310218334198,
-1.0106868743896484,
0.6459567546844482,
0.15130244195461273,
-0.18483245372772217,
-0.5701585412025452,
0.13552232086658478,
-0.28600838780403137,
0.19953995943069458,
0.5278214812278748,
-0.22293925285339355,
-0.5796025395393372,
-0.6035484671592712,
-0.367557555437088,
-0.8142690658569336,
0.7127495408058167,
0.12184581160545349,
0.28770723938941956,
0.4028560519218445,
-0.17666824162006378,
-0.7180786728858948,
0.1761680543422699,
-0.967215895652771,
-0.36296606063842773,
-0.08985129743814468,
0.03627444803714752,
0.30937206745147705,
0.7556775212287903,
-0.0902235135436058,
0.21087400615215302,
-0.060960713773965836,
-0.21783854067325592,
-0.1753513216972351,
0.14858567714691162,
0.1518210619688034,
-0.2514776587486267,
-0.46100249886512756,
0.09825357794761658,
0.7657061815261841,
0.7053759694099426,
-0.6107234358787537,
-0.03525886312127113,
0.0034154511522501707,
0.5229020118713379,
-0.19848768413066864,
-0.18643943965435028,
-0.13329392671585083,
-0.18943016231060028,
-0.11138104647397995,
-0.10332564264535904,
-0.5041043758392334,
-0.35590416193008423,
0.25893139839172363,
-0.5981019139289856,
-0.0010721033904701471,
-0.3012811839580536,
0.7289904952049255,
0.21664202213287354,
-0.7109455466270447,
-0.5122119188308716,
-0.8731147646903992,
0.43160566687583923,
-0.771192193031311,
0.7498564720153809,
0.12321636825799942,
-0.08139447867870331,
-0.08356098085641861,
-0.5599789619445801,
-0.4508175551891327,
-0.04344230890274048,
0.029814792796969414,
0.37612223625183105,
-0.19812628626823425,
-0.1639200896024704,
-0.38492217659950256,
0.008479434996843338,
-0.8556342720985413,
0.031907323747873306,
-0.2663494348526001,
0.022942954674363136,
0.5797027349472046,
0.14439606666564941,
0.5190422534942627,
-0.05114531144499779,
-0.303989440202713,
0.1559351086616516,
-0.40959617495536804,
0.00559706287458539,
0.48209258913993835,
0.0498976893723011,
-0.44566771388053894,
0.39359787106513977,
0.3088182806968689,
0.20233497023582458,
0.16934902966022491,
-0.3717873692512512,
0.5457061529159546,
-0.42298921942710876,
-0.22540070116519928,
0.22743919491767883,
0.8091157674789429,
0.3126167356967926,
0.055299900472164154,
-0.04845728725194931,
-0.1978471875190735,
-0.17444880306720734,
0.2758979797363281,
-0.6884483695030212,
-0.04042176902294159,
0.5101927518844604,
-0.6588461399078369,
-0.14353029429912567,
-0.11888190358877182,
-0.6856908202171326,
-0.36612918972969055,
-0.3761415183544159,
0.3781183660030365,
-0.7819033861160278,
-0.9269928932189941,
0.2318076640367508,
-0.38841357827186584,
0.34113651514053345,
0.024371495470404625,
-0.6582959294319153,
0.5082764029502869,
0.43932321667671204,
0.8349946737289429,
-0.2679067850112915,
0.03398619964718819,
-0.46725600957870483,
0.4952628016471863,
-0.35343095660209656,
0.5523696541786194,
-0.5381348729133606,
-0.9151595830917358,
0.11894740164279938,
-0.1322433352470398,
-0.09716366231441498,
-0.5275997519493103,
0.5080400705337524,
-0.20384842157363892,
-0.01708284020423889,
0.18186399340629578,
-0.7405561208724976,
-0.1743786484003067,
-0.4391036927700043,
-0.7238430976867676,
0.935126006603241,
0.07391777634620667,
-0.6148380637168884,
0.2578391432762146,
-0.9826616644859314,
-0.47693300247192383,
-0.05515630543231964,
-0.03603314608335495,
-0.3748042583465576,
0.03240641579031944,
-0.08088832348585129,
0.13047611713409424,
-0.053378477692604065,
0.5243258476257324,
0.18620194494724274,
-0.23048928380012512,
0.40001076459884644,
-0.41911354660987854,
0.7324002981185913,
0.4110069274902344,
-0.4666251838207245,
-0.17072108387947083,
-0.7535183429718018,
-0.2801044285297394,
-0.01734488271176815,
-0.5099440813064575,
-0.7057257294654846,
-0.23915903270244598,
0.3987036347389221,
-0.3774595856666565,
-0.12840262055397034,
-0.7436324954032898,
0.09371834248304367,
-0.6302843689918518,
0.3104066252708435,
0.3589990437030792,
0.27799856662750244,
0.7194666266441345,
-0.1263146698474884,
0.21455977857112885,
0.12699288129806519,
0.11504294723272324,
0.2045382410287857,
-1.0188111066818237,
-0.5266732573509216,
-0.2629634439945221,
0.3688509166240692,
0.5705839395523071,
-0.4026232659816742,
0.28652268648147583,
-0.4206186830997467,
-0.2774423062801361,
-1.201906681060791,
-0.148586705327034,
0.34898555278778076,
0.7914334535598755,
0.3294253349304199,
-0.28070560097694397,
-0.48454368114471436,
-0.7031825184822083,
0.10963551700115204,
-0.30011633038520813,
-0.32275938987731934,
0.5222849249839783,
0.208356112241745,
-0.3566480875015259,
0.8121521472930908,
-0.17359331250190735,
-0.336689829826355,
-0.11914357542991638,
0.8482593894004822,
0.08659322559833527,
0.7141313552856445,
0.5199359059333801,
-0.888913631439209,
-0.11805840581655502,
-0.0024520757142454386,
-0.6394785642623901,
-0.6004223227500916,
-0.09886892884969711,
-0.5181900858879089,
0.2375607043504715,
0.2742195725440979,
-0.5882182121276855,
0.5981912612915039,
0.4483279883861542,
-0.46878689527511597,
0.2401105910539627,
-0.1765214055776596,
0.4816571772098541,
-1.2138251066207886,
0.30131250619888306,
0.42980995774269104,
-0.06600738316774368,
-1.0021860599517822,
0.03208772838115692,
-0.06307724863290787,
0.0760243833065033,
-0.47808510065078735,
0.7037078738212585,
-0.3046099841594696,
0.18601654469966888,
-0.4368036687374115,
-0.034471187740564346,
-0.15422776341438293,
0.0005464472924359143,
0.3943311274051666,
0.7178341746330261,
0.6411354541778564,
-0.7793167233467102,
-0.08352377265691757,
0.33425623178482056,
0.12299814820289612,
0.6162951588630676,
-0.6068891286849976,
0.1063525453209877,
-0.03183051198720932,
0.1160493716597557,
-1.1866357326507568,
0.08227351307868958,
0.0034244428388774395,
-0.6487692594528198,
0.6009880900382996,
-0.48636335134506226,
0.07813827693462372,
-0.04865561053156853,
-0.3376961648464203,
0.5846678018569946,
0.9375165104866028,
-0.5092824101448059,
0.9271249771118164,
0.6641566753387451,
-0.36050277948379517,
-0.34506577253341675,
-0.8306822180747986,
-0.07750418782234192,
-0.3720654547214508,
-0.5882970094680786,
0.34177350997924805,
-0.07741954177618027,
-0.20463424921035767,
0.08355206996202469,
0.1532779335975647,
-0.25637221336364746,
-0.1421843320131302,
0.47018128633499146,
0.17603428661823273,
-0.4034298360347748,
-0.0049603586085140705,
0.5102964639663696,
-0.14175114035606384,
0.24281452596187592,
-0.4366496801376343,
0.4409720003604889,
0.4737516939640045,
-0.04140018671751022,
-0.9407294988632202,
0.701631486415863,
0.42937496304512024,
0.07715947180986404,
0.27912232279777527,
0.9238675236701965,
-0.3483375310897827,
0.2299363613128662,
-0.6885358691215515,
0.14255473017692566,
-0.40886780619621277,
0.20623165369033813,
-0.39127159118652344,
-0.25215384364128113,
0.2883010804653168,
-0.3927241563796997,
0.01217859610915184,
0.24185067415237427,
0.6708313226699829,
-0.3955456614494324,
1.1313793659210205,
0.4945823848247528,
-0.08368603885173798,
0.30903956294059753,
-0.705821692943573,
-0.07916149497032166,
-1.1144133806228638,
-0.3677322566509247,
-0.5444625020027161,
-0.20144642889499664,
-0.3308252692222595,
-0.1584339141845703,
0.35065218806266785,
-0.34543269872665405,
-0.0884041041135788,
-0.03492172062397003,
-0.36863961815834045,
-0.044419750571250916,
0.7219289541244507,
0.09117111563682556,
0.04011276364326477,
-0.04253259673714638,
-0.13518722355365753,
-0.03880363330245018,
-0.0010347713250666857,
-0.571217954158783,
1.174062967300415,
0.48898211121559143,
0.6528350114822388,
0.5172362923622131,
0.7051340937614441,
0.7348924875259399,
0.2640690207481384,
-0.7206102013587952,
0.44690170884132385,
-0.3166469931602478,
-0.31088972091674805,
-0.49744656682014465,
-0.16258862614631653,
-1.1896576881408691,
-0.07909409701824188,
-0.006305128801614046,
-0.7139159440994263,
0.25615325570106506,
-0.09524304419755936,
0.025718536227941513,
0.16607457399368286,
-1.0351659059524536,
0.4013623595237732,
0.2316528707742691,
-0.21093541383743286,
-0.125141441822052,
-0.5865025520324707,
0.18595200777053833,
-0.09124740213155746,
0.502855122089386,
0.11011620610952377,
-0.2141561359167099,
1.0857958793640137,
-0.47844746708869934,
0.6299189925193787,
-0.9202331900596619,
-0.32504042983055115,
0.45492810010910034,
0.2617003321647644,
0.21043714880943298,
0.24282795190811157,
-0.24509650468826294,
0.13104231655597687,
-0.313493013381958,
-0.20098716020584106,
-0.3264622092247009,
0.9018729329109192,
-0.7777832746505737,
-0.40791556239128113,
0.29924851655960083,
-0.25562918186187744,
-0.011464403942227364,
-0.13625115156173706,
0.2711005210876465,
0.44302454590797424,
-0.37709841132164,
-0.3567039668560028,
0.6114349365234375,
0.08295001834630966,
0.6463949084281921,
0.6376358270645142,
0.2532120943069458,
-0.2908470034599304,
0.8390064835548401,
-0.09243343770503998,
-0.14141742885112762,
0.07908293604850769,
0.26228198409080505,
-0.7550734877586365,
-1.1054201126098633,
-0.7269334197044373,
0.6478838920593262,
-0.43878892064094543,
0.07003439217805862,
-0.5332213044166565,
-0.1483415812253952,
-0.6372849941253662,
-0.010640976950526237,
-0.3766631484031677,
-0.17431841790676117,
-0.49407151341438293,
-0.10463493317365646,
0.34171804785728455,
0.8208630681037903,
-0.046581655740737915,
0.27543535828590393,
-0.6875377297401428,
0.40998512506484985,
0.15454789996147156,
0.0855267196893692,
-0.17521877586841583,
-0.9959629774093628,
-0.1447383612394333,
0.1411878913640976,
-0.15295252203941345,
-1.0060032606124878,
0.7204816341400146,
0.3430396616458893,
0.4230553209781647,
0.37504035234451294,
-0.2389499992132187,
0.7586683034896851,
-0.5842708945274353,
0.9396569728851318,
0.1327962726354599,
-1.0466578006744385,
0.8884276747703552,
-0.2491651326417923,
0.15981796383857727,
0.3667486906051636,
0.3763452172279358,
-0.23660902678966522,
-0.8759850263595581,
-0.366366446018219,
-1.0216022729873657,
0.307688444852829,
0.34361836314201355,
0.10755834728479385,
0.12243197858333588,
0.7778810262680054,
0.5338898301124573,
-0.18416829407215118,
-0.5910313129425049,
-0.3521857261657715,
-0.27996355295181274,
-0.6199949383735657,
0.381792813539505,
-0.28304192423820496,
-0.0413147397339344,
-0.2595504820346832,
0.8355876207351685,
0.04941176995635033,
0.5072342753410339,
0.34466353058815,
-0.24802349507808685,
-0.15209241211414337,
0.36618077754974365,
0.3169092833995819,
0.04325886815786362,
-0.08759324997663498,
-0.03466004878282547,
0.035757873207330704,
-1.041311502456665,
0.583046019077301,
0.05102236568927765,
-0.25643762946128845,
0.2392377406358719,
0.2775658965110779,
0.557775616645813,
-0.23054805397987366,
-0.3982881009578705,
0.773025631904602,
-0.2585412561893463,
-0.466641902923584,
-0.4651755690574646,
0.04783945530653,
0.163389652967453,
0.3309707045555115,
0.46006977558135986,
-0.22790884971618652,
0.8854832649230957,
-0.2257484495639801,
0.1441846638917923,
0.2809266448020935,
-0.2902858853340149,
-0.49184346199035645,
1.0873280763626099,
0.39658409357070923,
-0.26686981320381165,
0.8542715907096863,
0.013163364492356777,
0.3370402157306671,
0.35062500834465027,
0.5596950054168701,
0.8418586850166321,
-0.788085401058197,
-0.013406678102910519,
0.3801754415035248,
-0.09883932024240494,
0.20492199063301086,
0.480904757976532,
0.17784114181995392,
-0.4813450276851654,
-0.19252610206604004,
-0.5680801272392273,
0.2692627012729645,
0.4546164274215698,
-0.9446658492088318,
0.18753737211227417,
0.1536400467157364,
-0.33221060037612915,
0.24357248842716217,
-0.4998967945575714,
-0.44999226927757263,
0.49091318249702454,
0.42656975984573364,
0.7426150441169739,
-1.248769998550415,
1.210613489151001,
0.6653625965118408,
-0.2790858745574951,
-0.6716634631156921,
0.12199161946773529,
-0.022544942796230316,
-0.7407488822937012,
0.3332294523715973,
-0.10215887427330017,
-0.27101290225982666,
0.05513708293437958,
-0.3435039222240448,
-0.5361449122428894,
1.1177343130111694,
0.2145150899887085,
-0.33008667826652527,
-0.18260182440280914,
0.18524858355522156,
0.547747015953064,
-0.5773000717163086,
0.4382944405078888,
1.1028332710266113,
0.5338262915611267,
-0.0015515780542045832,
-0.9647184014320374,
0.09079471230506897,
-0.5166886448860168,
0.2953434884548187,
0.17402878403663635,
-0.11210483312606812,
0.41242820024490356,
-0.19875872135162354,
-0.23858653008937836,
0.4062129557132721,
0.39113476872444153,
0.09788906574249268,
0.47019681334495544,
0.6909334659576416,
0.6062578558921814,
0.5005555748939514,
-0.17869976162910461,
0.8058550357818604,
-0.020022092387080193,
-0.0010201598051935434,
0.6936241388320923,
-0.250139981508255,
0.9293618202209473,
0.5602268576622009,
0.22007973492145538,
0.5195984244346619,
0.5195207595825195,
0.1071915477514267,
0.7953478693962097,
-0.04605049639940262,
-0.2549796998500824,
0.1853516846895218,
-0.26421454548835754,
-0.26670026779174805,
0.5082640051841736,
0.5823796391487122,
-0.3393254280090332,
0.35500335693359375,
0.5043632388114929,
-0.13251978158950806,
-0.10747373849153519,
-0.049597982317209244,
1.179802417755127,
-0.39226844906806946,
-0.37914013862609863,
0.6865378618240356,
-0.14534436166286469,
0.7391760945320129,
-0.3711013197898865,
-0.3534509241580963,
-0.38775160908699036,
-0.37487778067588806,
-0.10419712215662003,
-0.9237269759178162,
0.25720375776290894,
-0.01329791359603405,
0.022460374981164932,
-0.05633869767189026,
0.3934846520423889,
-0.45975205302238464,
-0.08190180361270905,
0.5483155846595764,
0.4505559504032135,
0.5893610715866089,
0.4002869427204132,
-0.4129077196121216,
-0.07118140161037445,
0.009362716227769852,
-0.39241909980773926,
0.07766162604093552,
0.3726847171783447,
0.17184299230575562,
0.5689229965209961,
0.36080726981163025,
0.4068288207054138,
0.11795365065336227,
0.6618953347206116,
0.5797516107559204,
-0.6645568609237671,
-0.5095999836921692,
-0.5170899033546448,
0.8982987999916077,
0.0682484433054924,
-0.14924617111682892,
0.14892078936100006,
0.8981412649154663,
0.22353395819664001,
-0.1215977668762207,
0.9565269947052002,
0.19464384019374847,
0.6164299249649048,
-0.8320086002349854,
0.8438782095909119,
-0.7292197942733765,
0.23297260701656342,
-0.2721085250377655,
-0.2949819266796112,
0.07125553488731384,
0.37179481983184814,
0.2614826560020447,
0.1468653827905655,
0.7252537608146667,
0.7240301370620728,
-0.15885528922080994,
0.09799797087907791,
0.18397419154644012,
0.4836488962173462,
0.2594229578971863,
0.2355411797761917,
0.5389607548713684,
-0.6201464533805847,
0.548581063747406,
0.07481281459331512,
-0.3404180705547333,
-0.19378796219825745,
-0.24861380457878113,
-0.36410149931907654,
-0.9173478484153748,
-0.6690455675125122,
-0.35064002871513367,
0.09155203402042389,
0.3093944787979126,
1.0203689336776733,
-0.5857760906219482,
-0.338188499212265,
-0.31417158246040344,
-0.46125248074531555,
-0.13236784934997559,
-0.29584163427352905,
0.4825532138347626,
0.1669645756483078,
-0.9386550188064575,
0.6397093534469604,
0.181269109249115,
0.6107847094535828,
-0.036829132586717606,
-0.2743191421031952,
-0.13851429522037506,
0.20567335188388824,
0.191739022731781,
0.032107796519994736,
-0.843828558921814,
-0.2251756340265274,
-0.12552326917648315,
0.050778910517692566,
0.25694629549980164,
0.733919620513916,
-0.6256251335144043,
0.4864329993724823,
0.030796600505709648,
0.24775083363056183,
0.726267397403717,
0.06033099442720413,
0.4803412854671478,
-0.7511168122291565,
0.30920183658599854,
0.14551995694637299,
0.380656361579895,
0.15732043981552124,
-0.3986932337284088,
0.45658984780311584,
0.16167186200618744,
-0.3090541660785675,
-0.6687166094779968,
-0.11505429446697235,
-1.2151198387145996,
-0.24809019267559052,
1.4121594429016113,
0.0792069137096405,
-0.4222736954689026,
-0.55534428358078,
-0.44898760318756104,
0.4484623372554779,
-0.7498380541801453,
0.49434152245521545,
0.23243580758571625,
-0.31388697028160095,
-0.11828453838825226,
-0.4969269037246704,
0.250929594039917,
-0.04976809397339821,
-0.550409734249115,
-0.04476689547300339,
0.3718256652355194,
0.6404839158058167,
0.12435443699359894,
0.9026582837104797,
-0.2516537010669708,
0.3737960159778595,
0.1586420238018036,
0.26722249388694763,
0.17108473181724548,
-0.06039739027619362,
-0.46660128235816956,
0.0569070540368557,
0.1432606279850006,
-0.49229395389556885
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.05814v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.05814v1
|
MP2D: An Automated Topic Shift Dialogue Generation Framework Leveraging Knowledge Graphs
| 2024-03-09T06:28:48 | 2024-03-09T06:28:48 |
Yerin Hwang, Yongil Kim, Yunah Jang, Jeesoo Bang, Hyunkyung Bae, Kyomin Jung
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Despite advancements in on-topic dialogue systems, effectively managing topic
shifts within dialogues remains a persistent challenge, largely attributed to
the limited availability of training datasets. To address this issue, we
propose Multi-Passage to Dialogue (MP2D), a data generation framework that
automatically creates conversational question-answering datasets with natural
topic transitions. By leveraging the relationships between entities in a
knowledge graph, MP2D maps the flow of topics within a dialogue, effectively
mirroring the dynamics of human conversation. It retrieves relevant passages
corresponding to the topics and transforms them into dialogues through the
passage-to-dialogue method. Through quantitative and qualitative experiments,
we demonstrate MP2D's efficacy in generating dialogue with natural topic
shifts. Furthermore, this study introduces a novel benchmark for topic shift
dialogues, TS-WikiDialog. Utilizing the dataset, we demonstrate that even Large
Language Models (LLMs) struggle to handle topic shifts in dialogue effectively,
and we showcase the performance improvements of models trained on datasets
generated by MP2D across diverse topic shift dialogue tasks.
|
[
-0.2951197624206543,
-0.7445459365844727,
0.7225102782249451,
0.0812780112028122,
-0.32194557785987854,
-0.011322840116918087,
0.15513022243976593,
0.11020375043153763,
-0.25543758273124695,
0.7666037678718567,
-0.9066495895385742,
-0.2743746042251587,
-0.557965099811554,
-0.013155097141861916,
-0.32762518525123596,
0.8740741014480591,
0.19790515303611755,
0.05056313797831535,
-0.16840949654579163,
0.1087014302611351,
-0.37211933732032776,
0.044474776834249496,
-0.7191764116287231,
-0.27236002683639526,
0.319057434797287,
0.5078727006912231,
0.6603140234947205,
0.5509256720542908,
0.22487053275108337,
0.1384897530078888,
0.04409770295023918,
0.40345820784568787,
-0.31672441959381104,
0.20106060802936554,
-0.23523472249507904,
-0.42540210485458374,
-0.02041703090071678,
-0.2654004991054535,
0.6866041421890259,
0.7465170621871948,
-0.34154564142227173,
-0.06842470914125443,
-0.2225753515958786,
0.393515408039093,
-0.21468357741832733,
0.26798418164253235,
-0.756013035774231,
0.20516176521778107,
-0.3126395046710968,
-0.13332884013652802,
-0.41811642050743103,
-0.5330935120582581,
0.4228595793247223,
-0.631544291973114,
0.02716835029423237,
-0.18727093935012817,
0.7307137846946716,
0.4444347321987152,
-0.8566365838050842,
-0.21274934709072113,
-0.600386917591095,
0.25166210532188416,
-0.6483880281448364,
0.3280709683895111,
0.2114451676607132,
0.37108805775642395,
-0.14608235657215118,
-0.9783097505569458,
-0.7255740761756897,
0.21209268271923065,
0.13812142610549927,
-0.08248831331729889,
-0.11060336232185364,
-0.07897234708070755,
0.19773025810718536,
-0.10463036596775055,
-0.4521852731704712,
-0.19169780611991882,
-0.2486027330160141,
-0.07128110527992249,
0.4799366295337677,
0.4061903655529022,
0.311732679605484,
-0.24106524884700775,
-0.1042926162481308,
-0.17643462121486664,
-0.7387598156929016,
-0.09842308610677719,
0.4259311258792877,
0.3140062987804413,
0.04129418358206749,
0.4428914785385132,
-0.20495662093162537,
0.8848585486412048,
0.14855465292930603,
-0.2893774211406708,
0.08614382892847061,
-0.4794500470161438,
0.11843382567167282,
0.013167785480618477,
0.6427533626556396,
0.881741464138031,
0.040930405259132385,
-0.19650544226169586,
0.3289703130722046,
-0.18286581337451935,
0.2886360287666321,
-1.0580202341079712,
-0.4299151301383972,
0.057561419904232025,
-0.4404531419277191,
-0.4248230755329132,
-0.17776373028755188,
-1.0087013244628906,
-0.5116024613380432,
-0.2200217992067337,
0.0760069414973259,
-0.2608872056007385,
-0.5750083327293396,
-0.06306762248277664,
-0.24632909893989563,
0.3047354519367218,
0.4351534843444824,
-0.7096547484397888,
0.32114335894584656,
0.5878803730010986,
0.9751613736152649,
-0.515021026134491,
-0.1366453468799591,
-0.47911325097084045,
0.4891398549079895,
-0.46733611822128296,
0.8739034533500671,
-0.6349095106124878,
-0.7043492794036865,
0.04299135506153107,
0.030270887538790703,
-0.3592832684516907,
-0.4077746570110321,
0.22965353727340698,
-0.1984899491071701,
0.5301223397254944,
-0.14758825302124023,
-0.5664394497871399,
0.16505680978298187,
0.23785914480686188,
-0.3764464259147644,
0.846655547618866,
-0.01102796383202076,
-0.8546248078346252,
0.10537856072187424,
-1.1101714372634888,
-0.5334272980690002,
-0.2650541365146637,
-0.1505192071199417,
-0.29862552881240845,
-0.12664927542209625,
0.19839520752429962,
-0.028812170028686523,
-0.5155642628669739,
0.3280283510684967,
-0.1997028887271881,
0.15578694641590118,
0.5709725618362427,
-0.5529801845550537,
0.6166592836380005,
0.4876940846443176,
-0.2541794180870056,
-0.1427289843559265,
-0.4433099329471588,
0.0986490324139595,
0.029696131125092506,
-0.01130831241607666,
0.05399663373827934,
0.20468029379844666,
-0.07817206531763077,
0.5866831541061401,
-0.10278022289276123,
-0.32905808091163635,
0.3267607092857361,
-0.42153748869895935,
0.6149565577507019,
0.6552053689956665,
0.5586206912994385,
0.5071561336517334,
-0.2746752202510834,
0.40603819489479065,
0.39113086462020874,
-0.028601642698049545,
-0.19952568411827087,
-0.8216131925582886,
-0.7276726365089417,
0.28122296929359436,
0.19995513558387756,
0.7385730743408203,
-0.8988186120986938,
0.5047677755355835,
-0.08577292412519455,
-0.26944655179977417,
-0.4999488294124603,
-0.08751142770051956,
0.005840663332492113,
0.6387411952018738,
0.15309767425060272,
-0.07702099531888962,
0.01868683286011219,
-0.7201365232467651,
0.022353338077664375,
-0.48233872652053833,
0.0890997126698494,
0.4577469527721405,
0.03515832871198654,
-0.23602524399757385,
1.255422830581665,
-0.9417145848274231,
0.09962952882051468,
-0.2420714646577835,
0.5041025876998901,
-0.16944286227226257,
0.4244648218154907,
0.2479202151298523,
-0.9826787114143372,
-0.5338561534881592,
-0.2448011189699173,
-0.4433659017086029,
-0.33744901418685913,
-0.375288188457489,
-0.6726256012916565,
0.19938388466835022,
0.6668383479118347,
-0.8495047092437744,
0.28904858231544495,
0.32516610622406006,
-0.5247736573219299,
0.36563777923583984,
0.20383258163928986,
0.14193055033683777,
-1.7976988554000854,
0.06583331525325775,
-0.3308405876159668,
-0.04936517775058746,
-0.7680031657218933,
-0.5692077279090881,
-0.17582553625106812,
-0.5654820799827576,
-0.27687129378318787,
0.5725011825561523,
-0.07824037224054337,
-0.22132056951522827,
-0.05645390972495079,
0.15096205472946167,
-0.13641493022441864,
0.41635313630104065,
0.3968665301799774,
0.7477653622627258,
0.4816266596317291,
-0.5722107291221619,
0.3067222833633423,
0.7879370450973511,
-0.2720637619495392,
0.8136261105537415,
-0.344686895608902,
0.5383087992668152,
0.12081412225961685,
0.6084242463111877,
-1.2301286458969116,
-0.060326095670461655,
0.4208517074584961,
-0.22525760531425476,
0.23080794513225555,
-0.5727863311767578,
-0.3237234055995941,
-0.013418910093605518,
0.07657889276742935,
0.0689910501241684,
0.25981470942497253,
-0.1893291175365448,
0.30496102571487427,
0.39838698506355286,
-0.9416293501853943,
-0.22741368412971497,
-0.3253379464149475,
0.440605491399765,
-0.2663189768791199,
-0.9468687772750854,
0.3602711260318756,
-0.22583413124084473,
-0.3154449462890625,
-0.021589314565062523,
-0.1441182792186737,
-0.21265649795532227,
-0.019580360502004623,
0.08880989998579025,
0.01125546358525753,
-0.07595499604940414,
0.4718286693096161,
0.4329065680503845,
-0.26972004771232605,
0.17615316808223724,
-0.6147996187210083,
0.7182984948158264,
0.36422303318977356,
-0.3608796000480652,
-0.448409765958786,
0.5025379657745361,
0.6455796957015991,
-0.17206686735153198,
0.4987371861934662,
0.5382195711135864,
-0.11494636535644531,
-0.09681041538715363,
-0.3019733130931854,
-0.27111515402793884,
-0.4305349588394165,
0.45505717396736145,
-0.433989942073822,
-0.5833510756492615,
0.20516537129878998,
-0.6403823494911194,
0.32023748755455017,
0.29893043637275696,
0.5650393962860107,
-0.34912070631980896,
1.0254780054092407,
0.362904816865921,
0.24155598878860474,
0.6431354284286499,
-0.23450899124145508,
0.2532423138618469,
-0.6511951088905334,
-0.2063819020986557,
-0.47973740100860596,
-0.2630104422569275,
-0.5101800560951233,
-0.8168115019798279,
0.465692400932312,
-0.00554274907335639,
0.023725014179944992,
0.005143498536199331,
-0.24297098815441132,
0.2928982973098755,
0.2442113608121872,
-0.2109828144311905,
0.18659286201000214,
0.14999721944332123,
0.08747278153896332,
-0.33188554644584656,
-0.6087518930435181,
-0.3884877860546112,
1.235601544380188,
0.11765914410352707,
0.6426375508308411,
0.3004971444606781,
0.6396371126174927,
0.4218336343765259,
-0.06475985050201416,
-0.5060698390007019,
0.6806396245956421,
0.15176193416118622,
-0.501994788646698,
-0.6679596304893494,
-0.6933717131614685,
-0.717279314994812,
0.2006855309009552,
0.0013651648769155145,
-0.7935446500778198,
0.15555831789970398,
-0.197266086935997,
-0.1121772974729538,
0.306292861700058,
-0.7360759973526001,
0.9306237697601318,
-0.1290588676929474,
-0.18473057448863983,
-0.3593466877937317,
-0.977213442325592,
0.07050026208162308,
0.08438917249441147,
-0.13285160064697266,
-0.3463154733181,
0.16241751611232758,
0.6551733613014221,
-0.5104950070381165,
0.664943277835846,
-0.5775529146194458,
-0.27763310074806213,
0.38372907042503357,
0.22182224690914154,
0.6641699075698853,
0.4986683130264282,
0.08084309846162796,
-0.21063999831676483,
-0.06367199867963791,
-0.06324033439159393,
-0.847384512424469,
0.37859323620796204,
-0.823022723197937,
-0.509438157081604,
-0.15051718056201935,
-0.6013507843017578,
-0.6316812634468079,
-0.04424667730927467,
0.3335021138191223,
0.5203351974487305,
-0.41678887605667114,
-0.0796370655298233,
0.7815269827842712,
-0.2606039047241211,
0.2976504862308502,
0.552316427230835,
-0.09699051082134247,
-0.3898525536060333,
0.9707010984420776,
0.042931005358695984,
0.7052041888237,
0.3951408267021179,
0.1550779938697815,
-0.8154074549674988,
-0.3252015709877014,
-0.8810093402862549,
-0.06586111336946487,
-0.6352841854095459,
-0.017927218228578568,
-0.9721052646636963,
-0.2059377282857895,
-0.7688372135162354,
0.10785635560750961,
-0.23478733003139496,
-0.9576655626296997,
-0.2211867868900299,
-0.2544178366661072,
0.2962460219860077,
0.3720912039279938,
-0.06227673590183258,
0.1162279024720192,
-0.573576033115387,
0.5597474575042725,
0.8475738763809204,
-0.012521440163254738,
-0.5369307398796082,
-0.5755895972251892,
0.2021276205778122,
0.16516835987567902,
-0.5716158747673035,
-1.0089802742004395,
0.17728422582149506,
0.28729572892189026,
0.4598269462585449,
0.47237661480903625,
0.2817232012748718,
0.514239490032196,
-0.4659426808357239,
0.8356033563613892,
0.3074268400669098,
-0.6786385774612427,
0.7732174396514893,
-0.44546425342559814,
0.36546850204467773,
0.506094217300415,
0.142599955201149,
-0.953490138053894,
-0.35182854533195496,
-0.6166490316390991,
-0.6309216618537903,
0.9695118069648743,
0.43388137221336365,
0.04994819313287735,
0.23345443606376648,
0.05556047335267067,
0.14165791869163513,
0.36049094796180725,
-0.38696467876434326,
-0.28544268012046814,
-0.4324089586734772,
-0.14446353912353516,
0.0435049794614315,
0.023434018716216087,
-0.4145854115486145,
-0.14615176618099213,
0.45752355456352234,
-0.5171830058097839,
0.7857768535614014,
0.04361582547426224,
-0.1314719319343567,
0.012385550886392593,
0.45262882113456726,
0.7034290432929993,
0.6617633700370789,
-0.11615588515996933,
-0.020481251180171967,
0.21202561259269714,
-0.13958469033241272,
0.21545368432998657,
0.40791162848472595,
-0.24742746353149414,
0.21311281621456146,
-0.15067145228385925,
0.9623004794120789,
-0.046042732894420624,
-0.3411383330821991,
0.2978827655315399,
-0.076742984354496,
-0.09870021045207977,
0.04058998078107834,
0.12972360849380493,
0.4233934283256531,
0.14286933839321136,
0.21826043725013733,
0.03664726763963699,
0.28406670689582825,
-0.5956199169158936,
0.3294749855995178,
0.0002281524211866781,
-0.33368536829948425,
-0.08251244574785233,
0.38209593296051025,
0.6791701912879944,
-0.6551061868667603,
0.9729730486869812,
-0.28733596205711365,
-0.2811351716518402,
0.5529593229293823,
0.6286084651947021,
0.9973756670951843,
-0.03158772364258766,
0.8621119260787964,
0.14576752483844757,
-0.05233822762966156,
0.12809938192367554,
0.12703268229961395,
-0.4751538932323456,
-0.883083164691925,
-0.12356741726398468,
-0.29194483160972595,
-0.8259845972061157,
-0.07289841771125793,
-0.6314041614532471,
0.0921625867486,
-0.17643684148788452,
-0.24213807284832,
-0.03272932022809982,
-0.1971706748008728,
-0.2144501805305481,
-0.13679401576519012,
0.18205468356609344,
0.7393352389335632,
-0.6467588543891907,
0.8860669732093811,
0.48889341950416565,
0.07596282660961151,
-0.32524099946022034,
0.5048225522041321,
0.2505311369895935,
-0.35261964797973633,
0.30750325322151184,
0.012320919893682003,
-0.08423437178134918,
0.2800598442554474,
-0.5253798365592957,
-0.5179998278617859,
1.0562381744384766,
0.3961317837238312,
-0.3653842806816101,
-0.2789532542228699,
0.5891010761260986,
0.24924013018608093,
-0.38192692399024963,
0.09661156684160233,
0.6024372577667236,
0.44497600197792053,
0.31345322728157043,
-0.8233691453933716,
-0.34718087315559387,
-0.2678771913051605,
-0.043820157647132874,
0.36287063360214233,
-0.7759791612625122,
0.5527592897415161,
-0.18117083609104156,
-0.2047872245311737,
0.02719813585281372,
0.3190087378025055,
0.16133761405944824,
0.4412757158279419,
0.5855401754379272,
0.48632746934890747,
0.8356877565383911,
-0.368253231048584,
0.7237946391105652,
-0.4233541190624237,
0.012471914291381836,
1.1821109056472778,
-0.5689153075218201,
0.5609590411186218,
0.40102723240852356,
-0.047138117253780365,
0.4515886902809143,
0.4969962537288666,
0.10065320134162903,
0.8716990947723389,
0.09856574237346649,
-0.3304305672645569,
-0.6058696508407593,
-0.056025777012109756,
-0.44119709730148315,
0.24358388781547546,
0.6991520524024963,
-0.164079949259758,
-0.3045822083950043,
-0.0307886004447937,
-0.07183857262134552,
-0.22132441401481628,
0.22530300915241241,
1.2852141857147217,
0.031287726014852524,
-0.943257212638855,
0.04115696996450424,
0.11153460294008255,
0.21886710822582245,
-0.8727931976318359,
-0.18771147727966309,
-0.4755800664424896,
-0.033251915127038956,
0.12318647652864456,
-0.914299726486206,
0.19565026462078094,
-0.08244521915912628,
-0.03801487386226654,
-0.6226116418838501,
0.6645071506500244,
-0.6949438452720642,
-0.40529438853263855,
-0.18662552535533905,
0.6019396185874939,
0.09576620161533356,
0.20815569162368774,
-0.8500350117683411,
-0.15775898098945618,
0.283236563205719,
0.05724560469388962,
0.34362199902534485,
0.7272583842277527,
-0.21255560219287872,
0.6334501504898071,
0.5830869674682617,
-0.21148927509784698,
0.055462796241045,
0.12333416938781738,
0.6546755433082581,
-0.5900475382804871,
-0.860325276851654,
-0.3957193195819855,
0.4719386100769043,
-0.4581298828125,
-0.6665341854095459,
0.47017547488212585,
0.6411573886871338,
0.41764795780181885,
0.1361149400472641,
0.986513078212738,
-0.23644746840000153,
0.5065811276435852,
-0.6881755590438843,
0.6702821254730225,
-0.09775273501873016,
0.0265058446675539,
-0.3958693742752075,
-0.9047941565513611,
0.3630625903606415,
0.6435641646385193,
-0.06279949098825455,
-0.25246933102607727,
0.5409974455833435,
1.067232608795166,
0.008460345678031445,
0.2666373550891876,
0.09963805973529816,
0.08420204371213913,
0.7117148637771606,
0.5033785700798035,
1.2150790691375732,
-0.24207837879657745,
0.8023664355278015,
0.036397747695446014,
0.2864018976688385,
-0.11295339465141296,
-0.5389845371246338,
-0.8277279138565063,
-0.901954710483551,
-0.7952168583869934,
-0.3905007541179657,
0.358588844537735,
0.8278879523277283,
0.8847280144691467,
-0.6116377711296082,
-0.4094254672527313,
-0.4092476963996887,
0.20699211955070496,
-0.06216492876410484,
-0.28570112586021423,
0.2039765864610672,
-0.41861477494239807,
-0.6782727837562561,
0.5640669465065002,
0.27607911825180054,
0.0950365960597992,
-0.1664196103811264,
-0.23448316752910614,
-0.20584961771965027,
0.11279647052288055,
0.25221818685531616,
0.10836753994226456,
-0.442971408367157,
-0.1573392003774643,
-0.15837843716144562,
-0.12409871071577072,
0.0491841621696949,
1.3285740613937378,
-0.361543208360672,
0.5367422699928284,
0.4851318299770355,
0.6960926055908203,
1.0505588054656982,
0.07549361884593964,
0.967750608921051,
-0.8254756331443787,
0.01908086985349655,
0.03400528430938721,
-0.2732474207878113,
0.28944486379623413,
-0.08330805599689484,
0.6440066695213318,
0.5153077840805054,
-0.329854816198349,
-0.8273313641548157,
0.43791770935058594,
-0.7422685623168945,
-0.3233759105205536,
1.3270584344863892,
0.08146131038665771,
0.45557793974876404,
-0.5158113837242126,
-0.4946807622909546,
0.16749493777751923,
-0.5278924703598022,
0.6519359946250916,
0.8320492506027222,
-0.32787179946899414,
-0.31919065117836,
-0.3997245728969574,
0.8614402413368225,
0.2256043404340744,
-1.247563123703003,
0.31618741154670715,
0.5943651795387268,
0.423896849155426,
0.11298415064811707,
0.7740765810012817,
-0.007244138512760401,
0.27563509345054626,
0.11576555669307709,
-0.3795843720436096,
0.15683898329734802,
-0.4150845408439636,
-0.07002314925193787,
0.04167187958955765,
-0.21901611983776093,
-0.23809155821800232
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.05812v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.05812v1
|
Algorithmic progress in language models
| 2024-03-09T06:26:21 | 2024-03-09T06:26:21 |
Anson Ho, Tamay Besiroglu, Ege Erdil, David Owen, Robi Rahman, Zifan Carl Guo, David Atkinson, Neil Thompson, Jaime Sevilla
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We investigate the rate at which algorithms for pre-training language models
have improved since the advent of deep learning. Using a dataset of over 200
language model evaluations on Wikitext and Penn Treebank spanning 2012-2023, we
find that the compute required to reach a set performance threshold has halved
approximately every 8 months, with a 95% confidence interval of around 5 to 14
months, substantially faster than hardware gains per Moore's Law. We estimate
augmented scaling laws, which enable us to quantify algorithmic progress and
determine the relative contributions of scaling models versus innovations in
training algorithms. Despite the rapid pace of algorithmic progress and the
development of new architectures such as the transformer, our analysis reveals
that the increase in compute made an even larger contribution to overall
performance improvements over this time period. Though limited by noisy
benchmark data, our analysis quantifies the rapid progress in language
modeling, shedding light on the relative contributions from compute and
algorithms.
|
[
-0.3281382620334625,
-0.7451093196868896,
0.6656403541564941,
0.014924583025276661,
0.29838117957115173,
0.03600231185555458,
-0.3528968393802643,
-0.41689568758010864,
-0.12422815710306168,
0.3986560106277466,
-0.4394567310810089,
0.07640068978071213,
-0.8280669450759888,
-0.09813958406448364,
-0.500684916973114,
0.6810092329978943,
0.09836646169424057,
-0.09459072351455688,
-0.041058335453271866,
0.14846894145011902,
-0.4272248148918152,
-0.31074196100234985,
-0.6135928630828857,
-0.3247074484825134,
0.1512802541255951,
0.19688308238983154,
0.6887867450714111,
0.8846285939216614,
0.7236717939376831,
0.380342572927475,
-0.11899377405643463,
-0.39125287532806396,
-0.11497699469327927,
0.055618349462747574,
0.22846099734306335,
-0.5900557637214661,
-0.5335385799407959,
0.015587689355015755,
0.9461062550544739,
1.023598551750183,
-0.06947512924671173,
0.24322757124900818,
0.019071444869041443,
0.9593482613563538,
-0.45589643716812134,
0.26921144127845764,
-0.5192310810089111,
-0.19076143205165863,
-0.31389009952545166,
-0.019698450341820717,
-0.5236766934394836,
-0.24476738274097443,
0.007341040764003992,
-0.45975375175476074,
0.36821818351745605,
-0.23582160472869873,
0.6496246457099915,
0.1570158302783966,
0.082893967628479,
-0.44018828868865967,
-0.7035833597183228,
0.8255111575126648,
-0.7960890531539917,
0.7016947865486145,
0.201845183968544,
0.19021068513393402,
0.049119289964437485,
-1.0465906858444214,
-0.3000591993331909,
-0.6694018840789795,
0.27552035450935364,
-0.5252501964569092,
-0.4307446777820587,
-0.12582433223724365,
0.489895224571228,
0.5436060428619385,
-0.3581492006778717,
0.42480483651161194,
-0.5246340036392212,
-0.22792957723140717,
0.6123188138008118,
0.11636544018983841,
0.1724778711795807,
0.22746773064136505,
0.27773579955101013,
-0.31140774488449097,
-0.7279226779937744,
0.19809602200984955,
0.3435051143169403,
0.4645891487598419,
-0.1482897698879242,
0.27682310342788696,
-0.10298619419336319,
0.5685214400291443,
0.004491056315600872,
-0.1113048568367958,
0.37986043095588684,
-0.47951534390449524,
-0.07920949906110764,
-0.1026817336678505,
0.803429126739502,
-0.014837301336228848,
0.4069126546382904,
-0.1979181170463562,
-0.15107886493206024,
0.3574070334434509,
0.30766886472702026,
-1.0106407403945923,
-0.3719711899757385,
-0.12436828762292862,
-0.46997499465942383,
-0.233017697930336,
-0.22356487810611725,
-0.34760549664497375,
-0.46895140409469604,
-0.3575587868690491,
-0.017884476110339165,
-0.11064337939023972,
-0.593484103679657,
0.0422784760594368,
0.10983006656169891,
0.05953165888786316,
0.21534357964992523,
-0.8433122038841248,
0.5152275562286377,
0.967555582523346,
0.9478171467781067,
-0.06668438017368317,
-0.2825341820716858,
-0.2440306842327118,
-0.5914078950881958,
-0.840604305267334,
0.6194888353347778,
-0.5737554430961609,
-0.25577592849731445,
-0.050475265830755234,
0.03342224285006523,
0.0985722690820694,
-0.5163528323173523,
0.38915151357650757,
-0.7629294991493225,
-0.09720009565353394,
-0.12327664345502853,
-0.755556583404541,
0.05585220456123352,
-0.04375490918755531,
-0.8597015142440796,
0.9657213091850281,
0.040694866329431534,
-0.43183818459510803,
0.5056278705596924,
-0.8969783782958984,
-0.5119072794914246,
0.23359596729278564,
0.07506173104047775,
-0.46433067321777344,
0.49498316645622253,
0.13234326243400574,
0.3991168439388275,
-0.5064889788627625,
0.34385594725608826,
-0.35726630687713623,
-0.6678686141967773,
0.22525320947170258,
-0.4864063858985901,
0.8882745504379272,
0.24918656051158905,
-0.47046542167663574,
0.005066404119133949,
-0.8656624555587769,
-0.06795480102300644,
-0.005244283005595207,
-0.17075462639331818,
-0.06924629956483841,
0.12666155397891998,
-0.23167888820171356,
0.07510301470756531,
0.3029487729072571,
-0.5106255412101746,
0.17455792427062988,
-0.5837234258651733,
0.7227669954299927,
0.7527459859848022,
-0.3182770907878876,
0.5534587502479553,
-0.06571982055902481,
0.6060976386070251,
-0.2329920381307602,
0.09756029397249222,
-0.6097558736801147,
-0.5137238502502441,
-0.7031872868537903,
-0.009091269224882126,
0.469133585691452,
0.2728126347064972,
-0.25964128971099854,
0.15329129993915558,
-0.634894609451294,
-0.5469871163368225,
-0.7134393453598022,
0.08694001287221909,
0.16593940556049347,
0.43411657214164734,
0.2966103255748749,
-0.5491164326667786,
-0.49932175874710083,
-0.7389320135116577,
-0.25729337334632874,
-0.32482805848121643,
-0.1240319162607193,
0.2506350576877594,
0.17764385044574738,
-0.21150077879428864,
0.609940767288208,
-0.30461254715919495,
0.24018068611621857,
-0.12427525222301483,
0.3181249797344208,
0.49950486421585083,
0.43807268142700195,
0.4287444055080414,
-0.5336347222328186,
-0.5281035900115967,
0.08562503755092621,
-0.2526305913925171,
-0.1619795858860016,
0.21010437607765198,
0.33996638655662537,
0.2784496247768402,
0.8410419225692749,
-0.30465972423553467,
0.33862289786338806,
0.5751778483390808,
-0.1980658620595932,
0.6273713707923889,
-0.14201247692108154,
0.25813522934913635,
-0.6429704427719116,
-0.010702052153646946,
-0.21206390857696533,
-0.10578717291355133,
-0.8072559833526611,
-0.027669157832860947,
0.13672895729541779,
-0.02715119905769825,
-0.25622233748435974,
0.32300490140914917,
-0.2586538791656494,
-0.16070428490638733,
-0.45155632495880127,
-0.07682701200246811,
-0.42154794931411743,
0.2609720230102539,
-0.010863510891795158,
1.0210975408554077,
0.9262601733207703,
-0.8693601489067078,
0.07000267505645752,
-0.4309496581554413,
-0.46780818700790405,
0.1725725680589676,
-0.7526576519012451,
0.16691961884498596,
0.16638819873332977,
-0.18345575034618378,
-0.9077013731002808,
0.1968017965555191,
-0.27665770053863525,
-0.5116822123527527,
0.1858714520931244,
-0.03682749718427658,
-0.466327428817749,
-0.5888717770576477,
-0.15989264845848083,
0.45771560072898865,
0.6886790990829468,
-0.19871821999549866,
0.5868334770202637,
0.2659923732280731,
-0.09843681007623672,
-0.4655241370201111,
-0.684410572052002,
0.11974173039197922,
0.15369853377342224,
-0.5599687099456787,
0.319886714220047,
-0.132499560713768,
-0.4442042410373688,
-0.020914556458592415,
0.10047467052936554,
-0.29338595271110535,
0.38202348351478577,
0.18917861580848694,
0.05781710147857666,
-0.5098397135734558,
0.1204901933670044,
-0.32238712906837463,
-0.11883701384067535,
0.4579753577709198,
-0.27320441603660583,
0.7814043760299683,
-0.4606668949127197,
-0.16870887577533722,
-0.5114570260047913,
-0.19802559912204742,
0.4953303039073944,
-0.10868573188781738,
0.7494807839393616,
0.4450532793998718,
-0.10044422745704651,
0.012600712478160858,
-0.6754945516586304,
-0.10997982323169708,
-0.5161197185516357,
0.5266225337982178,
-0.5507062673568726,
-0.9788605570793152,
0.5224313735961914,
-0.1317000836133957,
0.28004178404808044,
0.9591741561889648,
0.6451248526573181,
0.08733147382736206,
0.9998671412467957,
1.0396885871887207,
-0.12663164734840393,
0.8448331356048584,
-0.20814183354377747,
0.12985870242118835,
-0.6530237793922424,
0.045381490141153336,
-0.6911986470222473,
-0.1176612377166748,
-1.1435664892196655,
-0.3194102346897125,
0.008080354891717434,
-0.03830883279442787,
-0.3636930286884308,
0.590021550655365,
-0.3121747374534607,
0.3696727752685547,
0.4131622910499573,
-0.1878299117088318,
0.2657001316547394,
-0.007314862683415413,
0.15214428305625916,
-0.09803147614002228,
-0.8187271952629089,
-0.13474884629249573,
1.3611153364181519,
0.5070062875747681,
0.5359085202217102,
-0.12477409839630127,
0.41489213705062866,
0.49984243512153625,
0.7549504041671753,
-0.543878436088562,
0.3260415196418762,
-0.22379465401172638,
-0.39107343554496765,
-0.4438523054122925,
-0.7472581267356873,
-0.964804470539093,
-0.10570405423641205,
0.2374938279390335,
-0.46297526359558105,
0.20662815868854523,
0.2785552740097046,
0.03288264572620392,
0.3218405842781067,
-0.614859402179718,
0.7907825708389282,
-0.062202926725149155,
-0.24998696148395538,
-0.5268216729164124,
-0.5128063559532166,
0.10326281189918518,
-0.15203523635864258,
0.35744941234588623,
-0.15686026215553284,
0.051362503319978714,
0.9516357183456421,
-0.4922429621219635,
0.48428288102149963,
-0.23680542409420013,
-0.09042938798666,
0.35245561599731445,
0.11010846495628357,
0.3920678198337555,
-0.43318089842796326,
-0.06444230675697327,
0.260810524225235,
-0.14269216358661652,
-0.5165123343467712,
-0.5552963018417358,
0.5235035419464111,
-0.6028648018836975,
-0.3623935282230377,
-0.1396879106760025,
-0.5903760194778442,
-0.18006747961044312,
0.27131983637809753,
0.015565663576126099,
0.46115922927856445,
-0.2124015837907791,
0.30178767442703247,
0.7079266309738159,
-0.02581159584224224,
0.7868497371673584,
0.55396968126297,
-0.2601170539855957,
-0.20635049045085907,
0.8952617645263672,
0.3436166048049927,
0.28518161177635193,
0.2347763627767563,
0.34206125140190125,
-0.24547845125198364,
-0.6453987956047058,
-0.3311925232410431,
0.24424521625041962,
-0.47604185342788696,
0.06930142641067505,
-0.4767753779888153,
-0.2119135558605194,
-0.6950249075889587,
-0.13540315628051758,
-0.672416627407074,
-0.3976134657859802,
0.1083882749080658,
0.055255647748708725,
0.21758538484573364,
0.9542206525802612,
0.026663580909371376,
0.42632389068603516,
-0.3802317678928375,
0.000649065594188869,
0.10162722319364548,
0.5672902464866638,
0.15248054265975952,
-0.7661871910095215,
-0.5251088738441467,
0.08765818178653717,
-0.13104365766048431,
-0.42759469151496887,
0.07409295439720154,
0.22232085466384888,
0.3521999418735504,
0.3028635084629059,
-0.4988076984882355,
0.8741095662117004,
-0.6823260188102722,
0.8419455885887146,
0.2256411612033844,
-0.9779835939407349,
0.3373207747936249,
0.1073005273938179,
0.6888688802719116,
0.37741878628730774,
0.12993869185447693,
-0.39227208495140076,
-0.2554873824119568,
-0.8044694662094116,
-0.542405903339386,
0.4898931384086609,
-0.057568807154893875,
0.3969232738018036,
0.3746282160282135,
0.41489654779434204,
-0.1493711769580841,
0.240141823887825,
-0.6247952580451965,
-0.19518981873989105,
-0.05036047473549843,
-0.043641332536935806,
-0.2434999793767929,
-0.2791929244995117,
0.322045236825943,
-0.40066006779670715,
0.5924834609031677,
-0.10494132339954376,
0.18166710436344147,
-0.3632206916809082,
-0.3574337065219879,
0.02082247845828533,
0.22045432031154633,
0.5146027207374573,
0.9653634428977966,
0.03026249073445797,
-0.06740131229162216,
0.1151157021522522,
-0.7264562845230103,
0.1379098743200302,
0.32733628153800964,
-0.20630179345607758,
-0.07760164886713028,
0.6908129453659058,
1.0260730981826782,
0.10835561156272888,
-0.6503479480743408,
0.4696134924888611,
-0.21253973245620728,
-0.26599135994911194,
-0.2120211273431778,
0.08338065445423126,
-0.09957166761159897,
0.15219952166080475,
0.34648510813713074,
0.13806915283203125,
0.2430710643529892,
-0.3219568729400635,
0.37349575757980347,
0.2360374629497528,
-0.5394331216812134,
-0.49386030435562134,
0.6505587100982666,
-0.17580848932266235,
-0.39252474904060364,
0.6972631216049194,
0.017037179321050644,
-0.27351269125938416,
0.6585541367530823,
0.3175375461578369,
0.9142165780067444,
-0.5316794514656067,
-0.038936179131269455,
0.30250686407089233,
0.586889386177063,
-0.2869144082069397,
0.032093312591314316,
-0.4223000407218933,
-0.5075695514678955,
-0.8708640336990356,
-0.7585514187812805,
-0.09541108459234238,
0.025217121466994286,
-0.4422059953212738,
0.10869215428829193,
-0.3139244019985199,
-0.35609087347984314,
0.20946204662322998,
0.28552213311195374,
-0.9418553113937378,
0.25056758522987366,
0.1273668259382248,
0.9603255391120911,
-0.878284752368927,
0.7138080596923828,
0.35324016213417053,
-0.09395944327116013,
-0.6517763733863831,
-0.18428808450698853,
-0.36951959133148193,
-0.720592737197876,
0.5402912497520447,
0.23829081654548645,
-0.17945696413516998,
-0.0578714944422245,
-0.4321986138820648,
-0.9553824663162231,
0.7381972670555115,
0.5228427648544312,
-0.8375497460365295,
0.10696747153997421,
0.2923838496208191,
0.9012519717216492,
-0.32865145802497864,
0.30313923954963684,
0.8823410272598267,
0.24128462374210358,
-0.10965318232774734,
-1.0304909944534302,
-0.25260278582572937,
-0.2867487072944641,
0.16344167292118073,
0.5452301502227783,
-0.20553357899188995,
1.1186853647232056,
-0.1485995352268219,
-0.15239548683166504,
-0.15917320549488068,
0.8765842914581299,
-0.09279033541679382,
0.06875696033239365,
0.5116446614265442,
0.6658810377120972,
0.687654972076416,
-0.1532697230577469,
1.2225366830825806,
-0.660465657711029,
0.14870798587799072,
0.9785799384117126,
0.021578434854745865,
0.8221980333328247,
0.14067916572093964,
-0.6260790824890137,
0.5453125238418579,
0.46323949098587036,
-0.08226125687360764,
0.2320759892463684,
0.21534383296966553,
-0.060526326298713684,
-0.07572674006223679,
-0.163987398147583,
-0.3185547888278961,
0.026498161256313324,
0.22906875610351562,
-0.5777090787887573,
0.09241033345460892,
0.06663300842046738,
0.1978311538696289,
-0.051229361444711685,
-0.5996685028076172,
0.7382020354270935,
-0.12312725931406021,
-0.6451843976974487,
0.48879581689834595,
-0.03891647979617119,
0.622300922870636,
-0.5513774752616882,
0.0800362378358841,
-0.11907655745744705,
0.2196425050497055,
0.07770957797765732,
-0.635159969329834,
0.3218371868133545,
0.056532539427280426,
-0.27791741490364075,
-0.3564853072166443,
0.46736639738082886,
-0.29323074221611023,
-0.8784201741218567,
0.271075040102005,
0.4326091408729553,
0.15932327508926392,
-0.01711786724627018,
-0.617981493473053,
0.4261619746685028,
-0.2747128903865814,
-0.23342715203762054,
0.11331966519355774,
0.27990594506263733,
-0.10772887617349625,
0.5850147604942322,
0.6502682566642761,
0.2954929769039154,
0.4663107097148895,
0.15401087701320648,
0.938774824142456,
-0.3702956438064575,
-0.3553489148616791,
-0.993645966053009,
0.2951699495315552,
0.13424894213676453,
-0.2746647000312805,
0.7111055850982666,
0.529853880405426,
0.9096740484237671,
0.291291207075119,
0.5519834756851196,
-0.2645765244960785,
0.3866855800151825,
-0.2954652011394501,
0.5864566564559937,
-0.43313518166542053,
0.28791573643684387,
-0.12297958880662918,
-0.8015289902687073,
-0.24727682769298553,
0.22048453986644745,
-0.3958759605884552,
0.16103754937648773,
0.4899989664554596,
0.9096643924713135,
0.06190113723278046,
-0.08669304847717285,
0.158153235912323,
0.3536282479763031,
0.4216029942035675,
0.1547991931438446,
0.3685268759727478,
-0.6008400321006775,
0.17557846009731293,
-0.44853895902633667,
-0.27023521065711975,
-0.041242219507694244,
-0.6867852210998535,
-0.49609559774398804,
-0.7075737118721008,
-0.39629706740379333,
-0.31935420632362366,
0.04418915510177612,
0.44441989064216614,
0.8380433320999146,
-1.0450469255447388,
-0.5819990038871765,
-0.614157497882843,
-0.06322697550058365,
-0.6007962226867676,
-0.2068859189748764,
0.4500739574432373,
-0.7020353674888611,
-0.6135462522506714,
0.5040111541748047,
0.07757361233234406,
-0.24390555918216705,
-0.4853636920452118,
-0.24680905044078827,
0.07036645710468292,
0.31074291467666626,
0.6052748560905457,
0.28661850094795227,
-0.4750783145427704,
0.19673608243465424,
0.11425430327653885,
-0.018470093607902527,
0.3018045425415039,
1.1186175346374512,
-0.8821864724159241,
0.705698549747467,
0.44640859961509705,
0.7916569113731384,
0.7306368350982666,
-0.3159664571285248,
0.5035649538040161,
-0.40497782826423645,
0.12438990920782089,
0.1978401392698288,
0.07769568264484406,
0.4169861078262329,
0.0356258824467659,
0.4627727270126343,
0.24324169754981995,
-0.6913231611251831,
-1.0949623584747314,
0.09581559151411057,
-0.1581762731075287,
-0.1705215871334076,
0.5013226270675659,
0.014197876676917076,
-0.34386759996414185,
0.13476690649986267,
0.3403351902961731,
0.1435849368572235,
-0.1927018165588379,
0.6481664180755615,
0.8103505373001099,
-0.43953514099121094,
-0.33045506477355957,
-0.7103184461593628,
0.6586488485336304,
0.405225545167923,
-0.6620573997497559,
0.11332051455974579,
0.3297862708568573,
0.15141908824443817,
0.36484307050704956,
0.5810019373893738,
-0.19286224246025085,
0.3894593119621277,
0.30656155943870544,
-0.04243721067905426,
0.07242093235254288,
-0.6196579933166504,
-0.5288234353065491,
0.3401111960411072,
0.31794992089271545,
0.27258190512657166
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.05802v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.05802v1
|
UniSparse: An Intermediate Language for General Sparse Format Customization
| 2024-03-09T05:38:45 | 2024-03-09T05:38:45 |
Jie Liu, Zhongyuan Zhao, Zijian Ding, Benjamin Brock, Hongbo Rong, Zhiru Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The ongoing trend of hardware specialization has led to a growing use of
custom data formats when processing sparse workloads, which are typically
memory-bound. These formats facilitate optimized software/hardware
implementations by utilizing sparsity pattern- or target-aware data structures
and layouts to enhance memory access latency and bandwidth utilization.
However, existing sparse tensor programming models and compilers offer little
or no support for productively customizing the sparse formats. Additionally,
because these frameworks represent formats using a limited set of per-dimension
attributes, they lack the flexibility to accommodate numerous new variations of
custom sparse data structures and layouts. To overcome this deficiency, we
propose UniSparse, an intermediate language that provides a unified abstraction
for representing and customizing sparse formats. Unlike the existing
attribute-based frameworks, UniSparse decouples the logical representation of
the sparse tensor (i.e., the data structure) from its low-level memory layout,
enabling the customization of both. As a result, a rich set of format
customizations can be succinctly expressed in a small set of well-defined
query, mutation, and layout primitives. We also develop a compiler leveraging
the MLIR infrastructure, which supports adaptive customization of formats, and
automatic code generation of format conversion and compute operations for
heterogeneous architectures. We demonstrate the efficacy of our approach
through experiments running commonly-used sparse linear algebra operations with
specialized formats on multiple different hardware targets, including an Intel
CPU, an NVIDIA GPU, an AMD Xilinx FPGA, and a simulated processing-in-memory
(PIM) device.
|
[
-0.29615136981010437,
-0.45613545179367065,
0.5194156169891357,
0.44672518968582153,
-0.1725730150938034,
0.23276486992835999,
-0.3179692327976227,
0.17682307958602905,
0.4894730746746063,
0.11311325430870056,
-0.5701785683631897,
-0.475661963224411,
-0.30998653173446655,
0.07569567114114761,
-0.22716979682445526,
0.8846103549003601,
-0.27296707034111023,
-0.05377994850277901,
-0.2608260214328766,
-0.29258525371551514,
-0.5846640467643738,
-0.34754979610443115,
-0.2812434136867523,
-0.06318654119968414,
0.25918692350387573,
0.3106319308280945,
0.7340691089630127,
0.8579199910163879,
0.4370824992656708,
0.42990991473197937,
0.09595052897930145,
0.07639691233634949,
-0.2648433744907379,
0.03049820102751255,
-0.3139655888080597,
-0.13124001026153564,
-0.48731860518455505,
-0.27495867013931274,
0.9684299826622009,
1.1083201169967651,
-0.20157885551452637,
0.35463637113571167,
0.2730747163295746,
0.7832265496253967,
-0.9522984623908997,
-0.15757083892822266,
-0.4255184829235077,
0.1982087641954422,
-0.4274213910102844,
-0.22776730358600616,
-0.1652592420578003,
0.1862712949514389,
-0.49679064750671387,
-0.8101675510406494,
0.374027281999588,
-0.21949502825737,
0.5109688639640808,
0.514012336730957,
0.12436093389987946,
0.06340329349040985,
-0.782129168510437,
0.9416024684906006,
-0.4428861737251282,
0.7298698425292969,
0.11169624328613281,
0.44030094146728516,
-0.4623538851737976,
-1.1879072189331055,
-0.2552963197231293,
0.2515947222709656,
-0.22763317823410034,
-0.2683275640010834,
-0.378380686044693,
0.24743695557117462,
0.14411112666130066,
0.387801855802536,
-0.72886061668396,
-0.2973424196243286,
-0.17678788304328918,
-0.06923302263021469,
0.1956317126750946,
0.4677155911922455,
0.22120849788188934,
0.1920822113752365,
-0.10669979453086853,
0.24234652519226074,
-0.713542640209198,
-0.1339278370141983,
0.46634018421173096,
0.2463611513376236,
-0.24087253212928772,
0.317861944437027,
-0.33044788241386414,
0.7418697476387024,
-0.04202215000987053,
0.20556534826755524,
-0.013079694472253323,
-0.07785661518573761,
-0.5791125297546387,
-0.12165989726781845,
0.7264671325683594,
-0.04043460637331009,
-0.3117784261703491,
-0.5108634233474731,
-0.5755547285079956,
0.14193426072597504,
0.14771592617034912,
-0.9278916120529175,
-0.5061014294624329,
0.13992878794670105,
-0.5593798160552979,
-0.006534988526254892,
-0.2410534769296646,
-0.6084103584289551,
0.004273355472832918,
-0.4429883658885956,
0.39512279629707336,
-0.32091784477233887,
0.2934255301952362,
0.3309080898761749,
-0.003484922694042325,
-0.2900751531124115,
0.3372753858566284,
-1.1435164213180542,
0.9333730340003967,
0.7438924312591553,
0.8392384052276611,
-0.2691959738731384,
-0.04190851375460625,
-0.8404845595359802,
0.40539196133613586,
-0.348442405462265,
0.8489587903022766,
-0.9708489179611206,
-0.2860841155052185,
-0.3429294526576996,
0.0344797782599926,
0.043920159339904785,
-0.42013803124427795,
0.48585349321365356,
-0.3029646873474121,
0.011925788596272469,
-0.26600173115730286,
-0.4305180609226227,
0.23218391835689545,
-0.15126816928386688,
-0.4102012515068054,
0.72707200050354,
0.46124401688575745,
-0.5150483846664429,
0.18621063232421875,
-0.7556523680686951,
-0.23642924427986145,
0.23627573251724243,
-0.7200313806533813,
-0.25863707065582275,
0.5192537307739258,
-0.0001135788406827487,
0.22069567441940308,
-0.3752632737159729,
0.22981855273246765,
-0.32440292835235596,
-0.9068611264228821,
0.08936937153339386,
-0.4302504360675812,
0.38924676179885864,
0.4539750814437866,
-0.0324392206966877,
0.0028385415207594633,
-0.8091416954994202,
-0.049400899559259415,
-0.007151971571147442,
-0.4457242786884308,
-0.31219929456710815,
0.16409505903720856,
0.2307228296995163,
-0.27620741724967957,
0.4589444100856781,
-0.9513457417488098,
0.47214922308921814,
0.0635019913315773,
0.3989807069301605,
0.8718335628509521,
-0.3726634681224823,
0.6105321049690247,
-0.010636926628649235,
0.31059354543685913,
-0.20358966290950775,
0.23044058680534363,
-0.18944765627384186,
-0.30881473422050476,
-0.6888845562934875,
-0.4253978431224823,
0.23613235354423523,
0.272733598947525,
-0.31804126501083374,
0.2131512463092804,
0.06570429354906082,
0.10337437689304352,
-0.4868476986885071,
0.3647284507751465,
0.41245144605636597,
0.586395800113678,
0.45811402797698975,
-0.29729095101356506,
-0.8304611444473267,
-1.0296763181686401,
-0.2022615224123001,
0.1419581025838852,
-0.1441013514995575,
-0.022123396396636963,
0.15946322679519653,
-0.27727827429771423,
0.8492584824562073,
-0.9837820529937744,
-0.5104584693908691,
-0.012570615857839584,
-0.08686110377311707,
0.23018766939640045,
0.9039053320884705,
0.584680438041687,
-0.5632190108299255,
-0.4701867699623108,
0.11443353444337845,
-0.49241745471954346,
-0.12936155498027802,
-0.048481956124305725,
-0.2799251675605774,
-0.012493696995079517,
0.5732147693634033,
-0.27220165729522705,
0.3452337682247162,
0.5133067965507507,
-0.4480002820491791,
0.36066651344299316,
-0.6136568784713745,
0.03528929501771927,
-0.9405834674835205,
0.2673813998699188,
-0.03557253256440163,
-0.08781184256076813,
-0.6304203867912292,
-0.010018701665103436,
-0.015330341644585133,
-0.07335992902517319,
-0.11579794436693192,
0.2716854214668274,
-0.3738972842693329,
-0.4158914089202881,
-0.12703153491020203,
-0.7585151791572571,
0.32731831073760986,
0.34387627243995667,
0.10951711237430573,
1.100709080696106,
0.41942307353019714,
-0.23844310641288757,
0.24635638296604156,
0.06705378741025925,
-0.0384221225976944,
0.5682570934295654,
-1.0494760274887085,
0.1733289361000061,
-0.3548603951931,
-0.22041592001914978,
-0.9446867108345032,
-0.3104844093322754,
-0.04166892543435097,
-0.3706642985343933,
0.6456643342971802,
-0.5072590112686157,
-0.6289494633674622,
0.2547592222690582,
-0.18007664382457733,
0.37486132979393005,
0.555639386177063,
-0.4625729024410248,
0.6830767393112183,
0.20462214946746826,
-0.08139520138502121,
-0.5578597187995911,
-0.7185115814208984,
0.15770657360553741,
-0.08535479754209518,
-0.6672681570053101,
0.46196553111076355,
-0.5025302171707153,
-0.09665992110967636,
0.20091792941093445,
0.0419289730489254,
-0.3428584933280945,
0.17177286744117737,
0.139388307929039,
0.41477587819099426,
-0.6886149048805237,
-0.34401318430900574,
0.6807859539985657,
-0.34515097737312317,
-0.2967851161956787,
-0.21836933493614197,
0.5328235626220703,
-0.5157783031463623,
-0.4276787340641022,
-0.411758691072464,
0.6286128163337708,
0.19364981353282928,
-0.06851508468389511,
0.4485580027103424,
0.5488957166671753,
-0.4845653474330902,
-0.09115822613239288,
-0.3701222240924835,
0.2860216200351715,
-0.6311658024787903,
0.3836090564727783,
-0.554242730140686,
-0.7955716848373413,
0.3117508888244629,
0.03146345913410187,
0.3007369041442871,
-0.08939272165298462,
0.40129727125167847,
-0.10387425124645233,
1.1731806993484497,
0.8513339757919312,
0.06009824573993683,
0.27503857016563416,
-0.15162914991378784,
0.010243657976388931,
-0.9083209037780762,
-0.21362769603729248,
-0.4419941306114197,
-0.6658607125282288,
-0.21005146205425262,
-0.42341750860214233,
0.30460357666015625,
0.026474274694919586,
-0.44155046343803406,
0.472318172454834,
-0.7485023140907288,
1.0198596715927124,
-0.07779186964035034,
-0.382036417722702,
0.21893681585788727,
0.4715646803379059,
0.10235832631587982,
-0.39747101068496704,
-0.3488291800022125,
-0.4909379184246063,
0.7027670741081238,
0.3821156919002533,
1.1191926002502441,
0.21831713616847992,
0.6218476295471191,
0.48323485255241394,
0.23417691886425018,
-0.34450939297676086,
0.250627338886261,
-0.8164807558059692,
0.05204356834292412,
-0.03560011088848114,
-0.29562491178512573,
-0.6390867233276367,
0.33910366892814636,
0.1548999845981598,
-0.8673311471939087,
0.6339855194091797,
0.17311425507068634,
-0.6079752445220947,
0.5229707360267639,
-1.0253942012786865,
1.0620776414871216,
0.28293946385383606,
-0.43623796105384827,
0.027953479439020157,
-0.28500616550445557,
0.23149079084396362,
-0.041353750973939896,
-0.06932401657104492,
-0.11590912193059921,
-0.5500861406326294,
0.5201493501663208,
-0.5137180685997009,
0.666240394115448,
0.058697134256362915,
0.4440445899963379,
-0.18985873460769653,
0.5819385647773743,
0.15362955629825592,
0.4478864371776581,
0.04630463942885399,
0.016544178128242493,
0.17145948112010956,
-0.5221253633499146,
-0.7582603693008423,
1.0844868421554565,
-0.841651201248169,
-0.3123563230037689,
-0.2216661125421524,
-0.8709456324577332,
-0.3332495093345642,
0.08231883496046066,
0.13957449793815613,
0.543352484703064,
-0.3039439022541046,
-0.02537447214126587,
0.760308027267456,
0.04604798182845116,
0.5305132865905762,
0.6242319941520691,
0.25586897134780884,
-0.45858949422836304,
1.2036267518997192,
-0.20757676661014557,
0.048961229622364044,
0.4216751754283905,
0.13102973997592926,
0.027852021157741547,
-0.4359546899795532,
-0.9006602764129639,
0.06890910863876343,
-0.4234423339366913,
-0.4780614674091339,
-0.5535909533500671,
-0.031326331198215485,
-0.41285964846611023,
-0.7361428737640381,
-0.6395705342292786,
-0.6364743113517761,
-0.4629587233066559,
0.4488779306411743,
0.10420557111501694,
0.866275429725647,
-0.3304804265499115,
0.5061147809028625,
-0.5858295559883118,
0.2723451852798462,
0.11864972859621048,
0.6706637144088745,
-0.3620976507663727,
-0.45232176780700684,
-0.16405005753040314,
-0.21494022011756897,
-0.2206447571516037,
-0.42315220832824707,
0.17538119852542877,
0.4369540512561798,
0.4103105664253235,
0.604591429233551,
-0.3556266725063324,
1.0749993324279785,
-0.5039845108985901,
0.34482452273368835,
0.3180007040500641,
-0.9577134847640991,
0.2586933672428131,
-0.023181667551398277,
-0.11105313152074814,
0.6218276619911194,
0.2400101274251938,
-0.5968776941299438,
0.07799006998538971,
-0.38333749771118164,
-0.3956587314605713,
0.8514676094055176,
0.258380651473999,
0.1727636605501175,
0.09156857430934906,
0.3232917785644531,
0.18080037832260132,
0.2260809689760208,
-0.11682625859975815,
-0.3546201288700104,
-0.20327439904212952,
-0.19868837296962738,
0.1231548860669136,
-0.3735640048980713,
-0.09453408420085907,
-0.41306963562965393,
0.30907538533210754,
-0.30417749285697937,
0.2746579349040985,
-0.030927550047636032,
0.08537548780441284,
-0.1338586062192917,
0.10943101346492767,
0.4425939917564392,
0.382583349943161,
-0.44061803817749023,
0.2365477830171585,
-0.034661732614040375,
-0.6883519291877747,
0.11359541118144989,
0.3437715470790863,
-0.5468792915344238,
0.2855469882488251,
-0.05053657665848732,
0.539799690246582,
0.09445890039205551,
-0.44901323318481445,
0.6483700275421143,
-0.4368853271007538,
0.21659107506275177,
-0.30766135454177856,
-0.06222401559352875,
-0.03317638486623764,
0.043229036033153534,
0.014187558554112911,
0.2874227464199066,
0.41596460342407227,
-0.29997700452804565,
0.2185479700565338,
0.3465767204761505,
-0.5079560279846191,
-0.6934349536895752,
0.8961387872695923,
-0.06448351591825485,
0.007695595268160105,
0.4322436451911926,
-0.5118128657341003,
0.31641843914985657,
0.36310067772865295,
0.740936815738678,
1.0127760171890259,
-0.44172418117523193,
0.19554972648620605,
0.17177841067314148,
0.29812902212142944,
0.3231101632118225,
0.3962230682373047,
-0.4230049252510071,
-0.35313108563423157,
-0.5895845890045166,
-1.232726812362671,
-0.017386453226208687,
0.10739836096763611,
-0.32376062870025635,
0.32963958382606506,
-0.9208500981330872,
0.22332614660263062,
0.0762169361114502,
-0.36786413192749023,
-0.3862304985523224,
-0.09810668230056763,
0.16518419981002808,
1.152961254119873,
-0.7879008650779724,
0.7071967124938965,
1.1290475130081177,
-0.49798139929771423,
-0.28815752267837524,
-0.2540658712387085,
-0.15328681468963623,
-0.5464380979537964,
0.6618849635124207,
-0.222283273935318,
0.20506657660007477,
-0.406521737575531,
-0.396707683801651,
-0.9778483510017395,
0.7554852366447449,
0.8448502421379089,
-0.1815485954284668,
-0.2431563287973404,
0.587590217590332,
0.3078870475292206,
-0.4293068051338196,
0.21164284646511078,
0.8432499170303345,
0.09459324181079865,
0.2944042384624481,
-0.539783775806427,
0.10818242281675339,
-0.2987729012966156,
0.40513157844543457,
0.41575613617897034,
-0.5401721596717834,
1.151594638824463,
-0.07840380072593689,
-0.11472827941179276,
0.5278552770614624,
1.124677062034607,
-0.04332473874092102,
-0.0024062765296548605,
0.3770790696144104,
0.676307737827301,
0.43339985609054565,
-0.03441822528839111,
0.6532322764396667,
-0.35498276352882385,
-0.005289926193654537,
0.8997876644134521,
-0.16606028378009796,
0.5650343298912048,
0.444987028837204,
-0.2614253759384155,
0.6302204728126526,
0.27277347445487976,
0.19141340255737305,
0.49636879563331604,
0.0972866341471672,
-0.6050180792808533,
-0.3646436929702759,
-0.2588421106338501,
-0.17176413536071777,
0.1560567021369934,
0.7630133628845215,
-0.06177074462175369,
-0.6896320581436157,
-0.30282869935035706,
0.18126237392425537,
0.07120449095964432,
-0.2728406488895416,
0.37569767236709595,
0.06662511825561523,
-0.1881209909915924,
0.44057735800743103,
0.34823840856552124,
0.6166418194770813,
-0.868341326713562,
-0.450480580329895,
-0.5735949277877808,
0.366304486989975,
-0.5913758873939514,
-0.9290906190872192,
0.7663286328315735,
0.01981057971715927,
-0.18276016414165497,
-0.09688510745763779,
0.5548974871635437,
-0.25197750329971313,
-0.4408567547798157,
-0.24819786846637726,
0.020601389929652214,
0.21451593935489655,
0.013052315451204777,
-0.7008066773414612,
0.5200737714767456,
-0.08620335161685944,
0.057838354259729385,
0.8319550156593323,
0.43731388449668884,
-0.0863710418343544,
0.33918049931526184,
0.8645592927932739,
0.08156465739011765,
0.057206492871046066,
-0.03888271376490593,
1.3342045545578003,
-0.30489498376846313,
-0.5126316547393799,
-0.3794550597667694,
0.32637685537338257,
-0.022967489436268806,
-0.28849148750305176,
0.40785837173461914,
1.1620985269546509,
0.6644250154495239,
0.05757472291588783,
0.5466166734695435,
-0.1675814986228943,
-0.003958475776016712,
-0.18956515192985535,
0.4975389242172241,
-0.5530853867530823,
0.31400808691978455,
-0.3129004240036011,
-0.927120566368103,
-0.28388261795043945,
0.3864762783050537,
0.028934748843312263,
-0.3533019721508026,
0.3407818078994751,
0.8427430987358093,
-0.6324527859687805,
-0.2754482328891754,
0.4750361442565918,
-0.2037132829427719,
0.207567036151886,
0.6876699924468994,
0.43878817558288574,
-0.24901869893074036,
0.43816137313842773,
-0.5647948384284973,
-0.3549444079399109,
0.4084480106830597,
-0.6051270365715027,
-0.6311445832252502,
-0.634404182434082,
-0.28578048944473267,
-0.32546111941337585,
0.048975858837366104,
0.8537894487380981,
0.4933696687221527,
-0.753116250038147,
-0.4309079349040985,
0.04792391136288643,
-0.07562710344791412,
0.29206356406211853,
-0.19308200478553772,
0.4736465513706207,
-0.7386615872383118,
-0.7985851168632507,
0.5189535617828369,
0.7221763134002686,
0.09806003421545029,
-0.3264159858226776,
-0.2920796871185303,
0.42674383521080017,
0.04360099881887436,
0.515552818775177,
0.8028775453567505,
-0.08241652697324753,
0.14033615589141846,
-0.01931173726916313,
0.044002167880535126,
0.15056559443473816,
1.154636025428772,
-0.8420601487159729,
0.20816338062286377,
0.6042793989181519,
0.8614940643310547,
-0.029653936624526978,
-0.14885151386260986,
0.28319859504699707,
-1.0347933769226074,
0.4980515241622925,
0.1011257916688919,
0.7815166115760803,
0.3733057677745819,
-0.44826874136924744,
0.3125913441181183,
0.4771744906902313,
-0.3174297511577606,
-0.8693892359733582,
0.2231018841266632,
-0.8435955047607422,
-0.30854249000549316,
0.916497528553009,
-0.12146257609128952,
-0.6569018363952637,
-0.24792779982089996,
-0.11103856563568115,
-0.25313636660575867,
-0.45562249422073364,
0.3953348696231842,
-0.039310164749622345,
-0.34935781359672546,
0.29221805930137634,
-0.26214486360549927,
0.5416290163993835,
0.315900593996048,
-0.43474316596984863,
0.12687020003795624,
0.41189688444137573,
0.2806839644908905,
-0.019129488617181778,
0.822686493396759,
-0.3039790093898773,
0.32800373435020447,
-0.044116001576185226,
0.09425875544548035,
-0.21900013089179993,
-0.1706140637397766,
-0.263092041015625,
-0.03760593757033348,
-0.07468719780445099,
-0.30612510442733765
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.05795v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.05795v1
|
ClinicalMamba: A Generative Clinical Language Model on Longitudinal Clinical Notes
| 2024-03-09T04:58:25 | 2024-03-09T04:58:25 |
Zhichao Yang, Avijit Mitra, Sunjae Kwon, Hong Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The advancement of natural language processing (NLP) systems in healthcare
hinges on language model ability to interpret the intricate information
contained within clinical notes. This process often requires integrating
information from various time points in a patient's medical history. However,
most earlier clinical language models were pretrained with a context length
limited to roughly one clinical document. In this study, We introduce
ClinicalMamba, a specialized version of the Mamba language model, pretrained on
a vast corpus of longitudinal clinical notes to address the unique linguistic
characteristics and information processing needs of the medical domain.
ClinicalMamba, with 130 million and 2.8 billion parameters, demonstrates a
superior performance in modeling clinical language across extended text lengths
compared to Mamba and clinical Llama. With few-shot learning, ClinicalMamba
achieves notable benchmarks in speed and accuracy, outperforming existing
clinical language models and general domain large models like GPT-4 in
longitudinal clinical notes information extraction tasks.
|
[
-0.20985597372055054,
-1.0556225776672363,
0.7442718744277954,
0.4270075857639313,
-0.5690430402755737,
-0.1558622568845749,
-0.22045721113681793,
-0.4770633280277252,
0.42548900842666626,
0.7341524958610535,
-0.4433513879776001,
-0.9559366703033447,
-0.86931312084198,
-0.14534707367420197,
-0.2111852765083313,
1.2096610069274902,
0.16561880707740784,
0.17506520450115204,
-0.12374693155288696,
-0.45541778206825256,
-0.4238332509994507,
-0.7073763608932495,
-0.5373201966285706,
-0.3765556812286377,
0.7584181427955627,
0.23455822467803955,
0.6191291213035583,
0.6893051862716675,
0.7531662583351135,
0.12009797245264053,
-0.027531949803233147,
0.19917245209217072,
-0.3486296236515045,
0.011917023919522762,
0.22641463577747345,
-0.5141673684120178,
-0.930233895778656,
-0.2502245008945465,
0.4253099262714386,
1.0776300430297852,
-0.6422072649002075,
0.11843600124120712,
-0.25659674406051636,
0.6005019545555115,
-0.5449135303497314,
0.1907784342765808,
-0.3160635530948639,
0.12073075771331787,
-0.5813934803009033,
-0.3678743243217468,
-0.6384507417678833,
-0.449747771024704,
0.1259848177433014,
-0.6278285384178162,
0.34269091486930847,
-0.44404855370521545,
0.7980311512947083,
-0.14998333156108856,
-0.5438827276229858,
-0.6198719143867493,
-0.5941537618637085,
0.4951068162918091,
-0.862170398235321,
0.14861011505126953,
0.7306687235832214,
0.6408276557922363,
-0.13975024223327637,
-1.1089861392974854,
-0.19386664032936096,
-0.45614543557167053,
0.02254483662545681,
0.15574365854263306,
0.1016470193862915,
0.18486285209655762,
0.10547583550214767,
0.11885370314121246,
-0.8160952925682068,
0.3105415105819702,
-0.5691861510276794,
0.039124324917793274,
0.43138208985328674,
0.5673446655273438,
0.26776644587516785,
-0.2603291869163513,
-0.2084866166114807,
0.22678758203983307,
-0.9115838408470154,
-0.15074469149112701,
-0.15059176087379456,
0.2816530168056488,
-0.19342058897018433,
0.5095470547676086,
0.005046346224844456,
0.9407893419265747,
-0.40229105949401855,
-0.5477765798568726,
0.1209622323513031,
0.05564676225185394,
-0.37646472454071045,
0.17962682247161865,
0.9139149785041809,
0.133065328001976,
-0.13975879549980164,
-0.11900240182876587,
0.2421804964542389,
0.13821573555469513,
0.6359801292419434,
-0.7724419236183167,
-0.364274799823761,
0.11669929325580597,
-0.6498711109161377,
-0.2645419239997864,
-0.24076113104820251,
-0.8783911466598511,
-0.6036210060119629,
-0.11685173213481903,
0.0747627317905426,
-0.7016722559928894,
0.04959263652563095,
0.25027063488960266,
0.3257671892642975,
-0.1679857224225998,
0.3924655616283417,
-1.0798388719558716,
0.31827956438064575,
0.6049237251281738,
0.8784753680229187,
-0.022686710581183434,
-0.03370771184563637,
-0.5192782282829285,
0.33880382776260376,
-0.3019578158855438,
0.8494846820831299,
-0.8786640167236328,
-0.9454071521759033,
0.051350679248571396,
-0.03202757239341736,
-0.1335621476173401,
-0.6896875500679016,
0.7071336507797241,
-0.4399021863937378,
0.10170406103134155,
0.0893217995762825,
-0.6298769116401672,
-0.07736031711101532,
-0.030286548659205437,
-0.4537845849990845,
0.5085134506225586,
0.3705432713031769,
-0.292989045381546,
0.5696949362754822,
-0.5885721445083618,
-0.7663081884384155,
0.2162889987230301,
-0.15534615516662598,
-0.7826095223426819,
0.1420779675245285,
0.2499307245016098,
0.47819194197654724,
-0.5456985831260681,
0.5384243130683899,
-0.4352678060531616,
-0.2892339527606964,
0.07474834471940994,
0.02815295197069645,
0.7236242890357971,
0.4717548191547394,
0.14516210556030273,
-0.02438068389892578,
-1.19436776638031,
-0.15576577186584473,
0.21319621801376343,
-0.5415788888931274,
-0.39631834626197815,
-0.2555988132953644,
0.10609783977270126,
0.1273147016763687,
-0.041234247386455536,
-0.23632466793060303,
0.4127615988254547,
-0.21598543226718903,
0.349617063999176,
0.20869183540344238,
0.33611777424812317,
0.22468039393424988,
-0.18562869727611542,
0.9617324471473694,
0.10832218080759048,
0.42427322268486023,
-0.5379078984260559,
-0.6682155132293701,
-0.5954481959342957,
-0.5674014091491699,
0.2753092348575592,
0.3089503049850464,
-0.15710465610027313,
0.2813664674758911,
-0.19780869781970978,
-0.6514583230018616,
-0.6617785096168518,
0.20906133949756622,
0.3897845149040222,
0.7586453557014465,
0.6401052474975586,
-0.48186933994293213,
-0.7941036820411682,
-0.8088815808296204,
0.0051043289713561535,
-0.24792048335075378,
-0.07533882558345795,
0.3538953363895416,
0.10246345400810242,
-0.5830252766609192,
0.7144321203231812,
-0.5959512591362,
-0.6445193886756897,
-0.5204166769981384,
0.5221190452575684,
0.16731174290180206,
0.24969525635242462,
0.4544576108455658,
-0.3058091998100281,
-0.20894207060337067,
0.10394034534692764,
-1.0883888006210327,
-0.25502634048461914,
-0.3662712275981903,
-0.0213606134057045,
-0.27781152725219727,
0.46277323365211487,
-0.6225230693817139,
0.38053098320961,
0.4978698492050171,
0.04904495179653168,
0.12626229226589203,
-0.5583689212799072,
-0.1893666684627533,
-1.0489904880523682,
0.2711513042449951,
-0.25346148014068604,
-0.1981448084115982,
-0.592465341091156,
-0.14166373014450073,
0.212729811668396,
-0.14616522192955017,
-0.22169996798038483,
0.27722275257110596,
-0.3950224220752716,
0.2124202400445938,
-0.35192063450813293,
0.27651870250701904,
0.09804127365350723,
0.33945146203041077,
-0.04015577584505081,
0.2181597352027893,
0.3282180726528168,
-0.6946973204612732,
0.2212977260351181,
0.521742582321167,
-0.4666282832622528,
0.5539287328720093,
-0.43139684200286865,
0.2685738205909729,
-0.09579966962337494,
0.2079666256904602,
-0.6244913339614868,
-0.16351181268692017,
-0.2750413715839386,
-0.3425044119358063,
0.45016059279441833,
-0.18981550633907318,
-0.3897719979286194,
-0.456651508808136,
0.29796525835990906,
0.15930859744548798,
0.6217169165611267,
-0.061658669263124466,
0.24585063755512238,
0.6679874062538147,
-0.479853093624115,
-0.3174491226673126,
-0.5131879448890686,
0.33573099970817566,
-0.1875348687171936,
-0.32621949911117554,
0.12493707239627838,
0.44870370626449585,
0.157547727227211,
-0.30068039894104004,
0.27952271699905396,
-0.34727743268013,
0.08748061954975128,
0.40427955985069275,
0.33679524064064026,
-0.6712793111801147,
0.3743574917316437,
0.35729944705963135,
-0.2468065619468689,
-0.09910892695188522,
0.12650170922279358,
0.6195665597915649,
0.18812543153762817,
-0.25433191657066345,
-0.2827887237071991,
0.38330820202827454,
0.477051317691803,
-0.0868191123008728,
1.0391734838485718,
0.26563283801078796,
-0.40159907937049866,
0.026646779850125313,
-0.4191000759601593,
0.10800899565219879,
-0.3396279215812683,
0.4853566288948059,
-0.29852792620658875,
-0.667472243309021,
0.39384692907333374,
-0.21010853350162506,
-0.17905069887638092,
0.27242717146873474,
0.6775045990943909,
-0.09624791890382767,
0.9680758118629456,
0.6782099008560181,
0.051796846091747284,
0.11210951954126358,
-0.05574190989136696,
0.10807612538337708,
-0.7032214999198914,
-0.48367515206336975,
-0.3371846377849579,
0.03250819817185402,
-0.20830197632312775,
-0.2530239224433899,
0.4509618580341339,
0.2103274017572403,
0.07177469879388809,
0.32988160848617554,
-0.0772804394364357,
0.05047376826405525,
0.04333790764212608,
0.4470100700855255,
0.39108774065971375,
-0.42946183681488037,
-0.24014262855052948,
-0.343180388212204,
-0.6539258360862732,
-0.6705746650695801,
1.2099779844284058,
0.3113401234149933,
0.7614931464195251,
0.10265213996171951,
0.4404398202896118,
0.10475573688745499,
0.8562745451927185,
-0.39113640785217285,
0.4973267614841461,
-0.250392884016037,
-0.5120888948440552,
-0.010926230810582638,
-0.09758364409208298,
-1.2040889263153076,
0.11080753058195114,
-0.06155863776803017,
-0.3993833065032959,
-0.08226218074560165,
0.017954891547560692,
-0.632135808467865,
-0.13525401055812836,
-0.4369334280490875,
0.8727704882621765,
-0.04534384235739708,
-0.07273335754871368,
-0.28167256712913513,
-0.9300639629364014,
0.603909432888031,
-0.4142343997955322,
0.10572682321071625,
-0.17956489324569702,
-0.07992143929004669,
0.5401660203933716,
-0.7238031029701233,
0.8321667909622192,
-0.16520147025585175,
0.047074589878320694,
0.2023751437664032,
0.1883048117160797,
0.2582819163799286,
0.13319484889507294,
0.19620446860790253,
0.09534098953008652,
-0.03336852788925171,
-0.46395784616470337,
-0.6017152070999146,
0.5311931371688843,
-0.4463980495929718,
-0.45363301038742065,
-0.19008037447929382,
-0.4016731083393097,
-0.5491276979446411,
0.09572869539260864,
0.2568974196910858,
0.6376739144325256,
-0.7101770043373108,
0.19385096430778503,
0.2208908349275589,
-0.584604799747467,
0.12036807090044022,
0.7654021382331848,
-0.35718631744384766,
-0.27100157737731934,
0.38641029596328735,
-0.1445758044719696,
0.16382308304309845,
0.45408883690834045,
0.08998853713274002,
-0.2407478243112564,
-0.6866992115974426,
-0.42929279804229736,
0.5420134663581848,
-0.8469040989875793,
-0.0545179508626461,
-1.1039313077926636,
-0.13372914493083954,
-0.4082815945148468,
-0.18163065612316132,
-0.3687359094619751,
-0.4863930344581604,
-0.40404000878334045,
-0.2326553910970688,
0.28649401664733887,
0.8056029677391052,
0.1295841783285141,
0.6731225848197937,
-1.177961826324463,
0.47682657837867737,
-0.018048785626888275,
0.09354788064956665,
-0.133321613073349,
-0.6279388070106506,
-0.4226212203502655,
-0.31771987676620483,
-0.39687976241111755,
-0.8540521860122681,
0.6560059785842896,
0.2484106570482254,
0.49449971318244934,
0.836122989654541,
-0.28242412209510803,
1.1129014492034912,
-0.7766765356063843,
0.6191627383232117,
0.23474949598312378,
-0.5733587145805359,
0.8377220034599304,
-0.3953021466732025,
0.4190685451030731,
0.673233151435852,
0.484435498714447,
-0.6213979125022888,
-0.5226085782051086,
-0.667743980884552,
-0.652592658996582,
0.47120362520217896,
-0.0778026133775711,
-0.07161478698253632,
-0.17724747955799103,
0.3953953683376312,
0.4574842154979706,
0.14841315150260925,
-0.3641764521598816,
0.07516970485448837,
0.02835099771618843,
-0.363203227519989,
-0.3907172679901123,
-0.4745654761791229,
-0.2706925570964813,
-0.02487931400537491,
0.19330227375030518,
0.07254741340875626,
0.17672036588191986,
0.06909698247909546,
-0.5131112933158875,
0.11990804970264435,
0.20371457934379578,
0.9677468538284302,
0.8437381982803345,
-0.2421427220106125,
0.09671381115913391,
0.10109659284353256,
-0.895250141620636,
0.12832561135292053,
0.029669037088751793,
0.1356588751077652,
0.2671547532081604,
0.6137845516204834,
0.9185023903846741,
0.3236597180366516,
-0.7846869826316833,
0.45908117294311523,
0.008334081619977951,
0.14137426018714905,
-0.21775853633880615,
-0.05889502167701721,
0.18760424852371216,
-0.18313097953796387,
-0.2378486692905426,
-0.02478124015033245,
0.21847321093082428,
-0.5108174085617065,
0.41156259179115295,
0.011968504637479782,
-0.5510400533676147,
-0.45306962728500366,
1.028695821762085,
0.04493117704987526,
-0.11094175279140472,
0.6273179650306702,
0.3877243101596832,
0.024597108364105225,
0.5443320870399475,
0.7016260027885437,
0.6264119148254395,
-0.3708532154560089,
0.43071913719177246,
0.27789074182510376,
0.007566396612673998,
-0.027619317173957825,
-0.08013997226953506,
-0.22093898057937622,
-0.23840926587581635,
-0.21395668387413025,
-0.6517459154129028,
-0.4249449372291565,
0.16173669695854187,
-0.866125762462616,
0.4926518201828003,
-0.8117154836654663,
-0.48874539136886597,
0.048831116408109665,
-0.41178181767463684,
-0.4209766983985901,
0.36313262581825256,
0.17365707457065582,
0.7211523056030273,
-0.6210179328918457,
1.3706278800964355,
0.4051433801651001,
-0.5290353298187256,
-0.3539701998233795,
-0.5072917342185974,
0.06531601399183273,
-0.9528664946556091,
0.8798145651817322,
0.14872929453849792,
0.1614188551902771,
-0.28075888752937317,
0.03561512380838394,
-0.29507535696029663,
0.8887213468551636,
0.32220712304115295,
-0.5635149478912354,
-0.0627729520201683,
0.5609845519065857,
0.9304956197738647,
-0.5175594687461853,
0.1996433436870575,
0.6979674100875854,
-0.02927626669406891,
-0.013139855116605759,
-0.802863359451294,
-0.009495672769844532,
-0.1718360185623169,
-0.058531299233436584,
0.24256974458694458,
-0.5045358538627625,
0.5576608180999756,
-0.43286436796188354,
0.02783821150660515,
0.3569454550743103,
0.5353859066963196,
0.43117135763168335,
0.43807896971702576,
0.07976001501083374,
0.5113798975944519,
1.0486992597579956,
0.12309818714857101,
1.3656959533691406,
0.01361717190593481,
0.1524292528629303,
1.0593196153640747,
-0.6348679065704346,
0.6471035480499268,
0.12021857500076294,
-0.22779950499534607,
0.7120401859283447,
0.5688197612762451,
0.25691667199134827,
0.7501814961433411,
-0.04518638923764229,
-0.563634991645813,
-0.16495411098003387,
0.10421111434698105,
-0.5290310978889465,
0.33089423179626465,
0.5163739919662476,
-0.6733360290527344,
0.06571891903877258,
0.25080186128616333,
0.4405670464038849,
0.005995157174766064,
0.012980446219444275,
0.7287583947181702,
0.5387977361679077,
-0.6688845157623291,
0.6811895966529846,
-0.03840480372309685,
-0.014109844341874123,
-1.0576930046081543,
0.13852721452713013,
-0.4000641107559204,
0.5421245694160461,
0.09019208699464798,
-0.2852339446544647,
0.41914165019989014,
-0.009466188959777355,
0.043784771114587784,
-0.030570603907108307,
0.34244710206985474,
-0.255730003118515,
-0.5206447839736938,
0.23258109390735626,
0.207743838429451,
0.010447893291711807,
0.19519083201885223,
-0.5655834674835205,
-0.03499144688248634,
-0.31728053092956543,
-0.056264374405145645,
0.38878926634788513,
0.5589958429336548,
0.01145974826067686,
0.723612904548645,
0.5496840476989746,
0.3608923852443695,
0.1787845939397812,
0.4425540268421173,
0.6483530402183533,
-0.937218427658081,
-0.7897468209266663,
-0.8689584136009216,
0.13404692709445953,
-0.14137881994247437,
-0.5875400900840759,
0.5187705755233765,
0.66713947057724,
0.1296914517879486,
-0.21326498687267303,
0.6431480050086975,
0.34760329127311707,
0.7546471357345581,
-0.7220367193222046,
0.7329682111740112,
-0.4998408555984497,
0.307121217250824,
-0.24367083609104156,
-0.513384222984314,
-0.7818427681922913,
0.5247899293899536,
-0.12591418623924255,
-0.12558820843696594,
0.917321503162384,
0.4711507558822632,
0.0274993684142828,
0.30474376678466797,
0.4907304346561432,
0.37662190198898315,
0.4913531243801117,
0.9088059067726135,
0.6439528465270996,
-0.34074369072914124,
0.46233657002449036,
-0.13248679041862488,
-0.14681732654571533,
-0.4213218092918396,
-0.6023337841033936,
-0.9805312752723694,
-0.40792375802993774,
-0.1867128163576126,
-0.3625311851501465,
0.0548030287027359,
0.565062403678894,
0.6840624809265137,
-0.7923470735549927,
-0.15861082077026367,
0.12893615663051605,
-0.5018443465232849,
-0.11381068825721741,
-0.12681947648525238,
0.4247724115848541,
-0.26233863830566406,
-0.294456422328949,
0.5492973327636719,
0.8661513924598694,
0.07496315240859985,
-0.08038788288831711,
0.015712715685367584,
-0.16649146378040314,
-0.06411084532737732,
0.6103295683860779,
0.46193066239356995,
-0.4570648670196533,
0.2383987158536911,
0.017241481691598892,
-0.5379912853240967,
0.42680004239082336,
1.3017992973327637,
-0.680178165435791,
0.6920203566551208,
0.12053892761468887,
0.5952818989753723,
0.9927311539649963,
-0.22201120853424072,
0.7360630035400391,
-0.42057251930236816,
0.6007503271102905,
0.3796471655368805,
0.4683491885662079,
0.3577777147293091,
-0.1740603893995285,
0.5537573099136353,
0.3276858329772949,
-0.2774493396282196,
-0.8409454226493835,
0.014451058581471443,
-1.159743309020996,
-0.19378253817558289,
0.8418959379196167,
-0.35122019052505493,
0.005650590173900127,
-0.3934263288974762,
-0.41588371992111206,
0.27383649349212646,
0.08096493035554886,
0.9267873167991638,
0.5227771997451782,
-0.2132299691438675,
-0.2503621280193329,
-0.8639153838157654,
0.3986870050430298,
0.3602555990219116,
-0.9396710991859436,
-0.2665988802909851,
0.34793227910995483,
-0.03432045131921768,
-0.05712272226810455,
1.0102839469909668,
-0.6092057824134827,
0.3884367048740387,
0.012745422311127186,
-0.11890538036823273,
0.08202625066041946,
-0.2256622612476349,
-0.28523021936416626,
0.3730512857437134,
-0.07635529339313507,
0.04860929399728775
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.05789v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.05789v1
|
ItD: Large Language Models Can Teach Themselves Induction through Deduction
| 2024-03-09T04:20:46 | 2024-03-09T04:20:46 |
Wangtao Sun, Haotian Xu, Xuanqing Yu, Pei Chen, Shizhu He, Jun Zhao, Kang Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Although Large Language Models (LLMs) are showing impressive performance on a
wide range of Natural Language Processing tasks, researchers have found that
they still have limited ability to conduct induction. Recent works mainly adopt
``post processes'' paradigms to improve the performance of LLMs on induction
(e.g., the hypothesis search & refinement methods), but their performance is
still constrained by the inherent inductive capability of the LLMs. In this
paper, we propose a novel framework, Induction through Deduction (ItD), to
enable the LLMs to teach themselves induction through deduction. The ItD
framework is composed of two main components: a Deductive Data Generation
module to generate induction data and a Naive Bayesian Induction module to
optimize the fine-tuning and decoding of LLMs. Our empirical results showcase
the effectiveness of ItD on two induction benchmarks, achieving relative
performance improvement of 36% and 10% compared with previous state-of-the-art,
respectively. Our ablation study verifies the effectiveness of two key modules
of ItD. We also verify the effectiveness of ItD across different LLMs and
deductors. The data and code of this paper can be found at
https://anonymous.4open.science/r/ItD-E844.
|
[
-0.16924136877059937,
-0.8148431777954102,
0.6208159923553467,
0.10332437604665756,
-0.4157613217830658,
-0.0778525099158287,
-0.3689911663532257,
-0.09992751479148865,
-0.1968519240617752,
0.5702846646308899,
-0.5229445695877075,
-0.5762475728988647,
-0.7119407653808594,
0.17203490436077118,
-0.46990761160850525,
0.46809929609298706,
0.12394048273563385,
0.0557953417301178,
-0.09877593070268631,
0.15639936923980713,
-0.216251939535141,
-0.3031064569950104,
-0.8160814642906189,
-0.46466004848480225,
0.15626206994056702,
0.4199484586715698,
0.4726544916629791,
0.885648787021637,
0.2643110752105713,
0.2687038779258728,
-0.007819855585694313,
0.28297919034957886,
-0.13636308908462524,
0.07308300584554672,
-0.6695692539215088,
-0.3020123541355133,
-0.21206673979759216,
-0.22071051597595215,
0.8490996360778809,
0.9557611346244812,
-0.31534820795059204,
-0.12838071584701538,
0.15584056079387665,
0.6947881579399109,
-0.6391588449478149,
0.4824790954589844,
-0.931579053401947,
-0.34522226452827454,
-0.09870174527168274,
-0.1397542804479599,
-0.6438010334968567,
-0.3251914083957672,
-0.11260408908128738,
-0.28692716360092163,
0.23557023704051971,
-0.37349817156791687,
0.35278594493865967,
0.41280651092529297,
-0.21528998017311096,
-0.3472531735897064,
-0.9367502927780151,
0.39172765612602234,
-1.0033085346221924,
0.34262168407440186,
0.29172584414482117,
0.13695110380649567,
-0.3418348729610443,
-0.49711543321609497,
-0.8345442414283752,
0.020122244954109192,
0.002556777326390147,
-0.29144155979156494,
0.05612628906965256,
0.08904466778039932,
0.5150524973869324,
0.5210244655609131,
-0.6038799285888672,
0.49419671297073364,
-0.18896529078483582,
0.31102654337882996,
0.6272234916687012,
0.12630878388881683,
0.049354683607816696,
0.11529258638620377,
-0.12162335962057114,
-0.09904496371746063,
-0.917269766330719,
-0.17771774530410767,
0.06274496763944626,
0.5207211375236511,
-0.07625845819711685,
0.6807963252067566,
-0.406333327293396,
0.5354630947113037,
0.09427885711193085,
-0.1959185004234314,
0.22488917410373688,
-0.02356913685798645,
-0.30831754207611084,
0.34580352902412415,
0.7257400155067444,
-0.024138953536748886,
0.3094615042209625,
-0.1599908322095871,
-0.19629615545272827,
0.5743348598480225,
-0.15136447548866272,
-0.9499784708023071,
-0.1204705610871315,
0.28633788228034973,
-0.14353011548519135,
-0.2322527915239334,
-0.2801060974597931,
-0.31168535351753235,
-0.5894695520401001,
-0.44786563515663147,
0.5042079091072083,
-0.5600630640983582,
-0.6976186037063599,
0.6820122003555298,
-0.01667063869535923,
0.21735437214374542,
0.15824605524539948,
-1.163387417793274,
0.25728505849838257,
0.8254525065422058,
0.42782488465309143,
-0.03674415871500969,
-0.24713701009750366,
-0.5801402926445007,
0.21027012169361115,
-0.399901807308197,
0.9798791408538818,
-0.7890620231628418,
-0.14360035955905914,
0.21900267899036407,
-0.13091793656349182,
-0.22048534452915192,
-0.6616491675376892,
0.4203222990036011,
-0.5635018944740295,
0.005227956455200911,
-0.026938481256365776,
-0.838391900062561,
-0.15535013377666473,
0.18108423054218292,
-0.5909349918365479,
0.856299877166748,
0.25542736053466797,
-0.6988399028778076,
0.5539059638977051,
-0.7026119828224182,
-0.7095268964767456,
0.011079403571784496,
-0.2432016134262085,
-0.1842847764492035,
0.11423292011022568,
0.2675107717514038,
0.7142287492752075,
-0.580220639705658,
0.6352639198303223,
-0.358325719833374,
-0.2534826397895813,
0.10346253216266632,
-0.32671207189559937,
0.8865209817886353,
0.25148263573646545,
-0.48460179567337036,
0.007330113556236029,
-1.1500953435897827,
-0.14172647893428802,
0.021587984636425972,
-0.3451775312423706,
-0.2554222345352173,
0.012967858463525772,
-0.6711792945861816,
0.23704536259174347,
-0.3690863251686096,
-0.5682501196861267,
0.5569702982902527,
-0.7444978952407837,
0.5305513739585876,
0.6306792497634888,
-0.013375530950725079,
0.7556356191635132,
-0.1288401484489441,
0.2505132257938385,
0.2883126735687256,
-0.40252551436424255,
-0.27737849950790405,
-0.1457366645336151,
-0.6089643836021423,
-0.5587177276611328,
0.3399067223072052,
0.4052011966705322,
-0.8748791217803955,
0.7450765371322632,
-0.21030248701572418,
-0.3686845898628235,
-0.7823488712310791,
0.31207039952278137,
0.10636559873819351,
0.5164211392402649,
0.38718077540397644,
-0.04163265973329544,
-0.46974417567253113,
-0.5931820273399353,
-0.1053529679775238,
-0.1859573870897293,
-0.1067814752459526,
-0.5007739067077637,
0.3367893099784851,
-0.38568565249443054,
0.42579513788223267,
-0.1311611384153366,
-0.19231288135051727,
-0.5049129724502563,
0.21962712705135345,
0.4472859501838684,
0.6783017516136169,
0.06807130575180054,
-0.2088603973388672,
-0.22844649851322174,
-0.1991558074951172,
-0.8624749779701233,
-0.24240800738334656,
-0.3381173014640808,
-0.1539275199174881,
0.3935384750366211,
0.41421031951904297,
-0.8343275189399719,
0.6067746877670288,
0.2221686989068985,
-0.3890696167945862,
0.3899684548377991,
-0.08363252133131027,
-0.0934324637055397,
-0.9548431038856506,
-0.16158883273601532,
-0.21247175335884094,
-0.11734701693058014,
-0.267267107963562,
-0.07362930476665497,
0.12075576186180115,
0.07076030224561691,
-0.24785444140434265,
0.5720568895339966,
-0.3622421622276306,
-0.23899656534194946,
-0.4020417034626007,
0.004703493323177099,
-0.10099313408136368,
0.24026328325271606,
0.43197691440582275,
0.5235001444816589,
0.8304821848869324,
-1.04692804813385,
0.30800649523735046,
0.37321701645851135,
-0.7034060955047607,
0.47030264139175415,
-0.3557564616203308,
-0.18651700019836426,
-0.26311013102531433,
0.18881700932979584,
-0.9987385869026184,
-0.0824413150548935,
0.3596078157424927,
-0.34473133087158203,
0.43900611996650696,
0.023899108171463013,
-0.7313584685325623,
-0.24945546686649323,
-0.21095618605613708,
0.23210740089416504,
0.6862631440162659,
-0.9618301391601562,
0.6501284241676331,
-0.11974161118268967,
-0.07844603806734085,
-0.5356292724609375,
-0.6079919338226318,
0.12014370411634445,
-0.17802897095680237,
-0.6527314782142639,
0.5171994566917419,
-0.15920531749725342,
-0.5799809098243713,
0.18924902379512787,
0.10998798161745071,
0.08066239207983017,
0.45460575819015503,
0.045644793659448624,
-0.14728249609470367,
-0.3326394855976105,
0.2680801749229431,
0.24717116355895996,
-0.35466888546943665,
0.11748582869768143,
-0.3669413924217224,
0.6876152157783508,
0.3849308490753174,
-0.5525464415550232,
-0.8874896168708801,
0.34110596776008606,
0.5486169457435608,
-0.226981520652771,
0.9088178873062134,
0.5082734823226929,
-0.4637422561645508,
-0.7816027998924255,
-0.5786523818969727,
-0.47967374324798584,
-0.4926469326019287,
-0.0788019523024559,
-0.5139038562774658,
-0.6030775904655457,
0.26904240250587463,
-0.20438960194587708,
0.07959173619747162,
0.46856462955474854,
0.7782629132270813,
0.26683810353279114,
1.0443731546401978,
0.6053365468978882,
0.13911163806915283,
0.23638617992401123,
-0.4319120943546295,
0.3201453387737274,
-0.8116218447685242,
-0.06021701171994209,
-0.5677499771118164,
0.02028963528573513,
-0.46587875485420227,
-0.3269227147102356,
-0.04377400502562523,
0.25775760412216187,
-0.3892953097820282,
0.21480870246887207,
-0.35844776034355164,
0.33996543288230896,
0.6068450808525085,
0.002657195320352912,
0.5044920444488525,
0.04045988991856575,
-0.3148205578327179,
0.18725475668907166,
-0.6808214783668518,
-0.6592905521392822,
1.151023507118225,
0.10901528596878052,
0.9076659679412842,
0.04128582403063774,
0.8984967470169067,
0.20953074097633362,
0.3730448782444,
-0.800902783870697,
0.5422694087028503,
-0.01381952129304409,
-0.5283636450767517,
-0.17311352491378784,
-0.25408145785331726,
-0.6423935890197754,
0.2249344140291214,
-0.15732908248901367,
-0.6738071441650391,
-0.05335655435919762,
0.018074149265885353,
-0.19435426592826843,
0.34385374188423157,
-0.485670268535614,
0.6652806997299194,
-0.03757014498114586,
-0.6332817077636719,
-0.3870641887187958,
-0.20271919667720795,
0.47676119208335876,
0.06120112165808678,
0.21491973102092743,
-0.1428953856229782,
0.5104203820228577,
0.4558373689651489,
-0.3693513870239258,
0.8602506518363953,
-0.40669482946395874,
-0.487211138010025,
0.3532358705997467,
0.2765413522720337,
0.5531728863716125,
0.35128846764564514,
-0.5595884919166565,
-0.22670280933380127,
-0.12298108637332916,
-0.18425659835338593,
-0.5410157442092896,
0.718371570110321,
-0.35724207758903503,
-0.7944186329841614,
-0.27953577041625977,
-0.5590111017227173,
-0.1820148080587387,
0.20429426431655884,
0.1925426870584488,
0.651692807674408,
0.10163088887929916,
0.1594645231962204,
0.8301699161529541,
-0.25930652022361755,
0.5396575927734375,
0.6869910359382629,
-0.1710897833108902,
-0.24320223927497864,
0.3397265076637268,
-0.040486983954906464,
0.3012281656265259,
0.5457994937896729,
0.28628775477409363,
-0.5491726994514465,
-0.7816793322563171,
-0.5166522264480591,
0.4071200489997864,
-0.8424493670463562,
-0.22496742010116577,
-0.7620837688446045,
-0.21366514265537262,
-0.7138038873672485,
-0.1299745738506317,
-0.4388115704059601,
-0.5418474078178406,
-0.1807212233543396,
-0.4173990786075592,
0.11847412586212158,
0.5294567942619324,
-0.44655662775039673,
0.37354299426078796,
-0.6140134334564209,
0.5564022660255432,
0.2251090258359909,
0.3344806134700775,
-0.10856027901172638,
-0.510680615901947,
0.04050253704190254,
0.12131205946207047,
-0.18633033335208893,
-0.4655809998512268,
0.3119017481803894,
0.2716190218925476,
0.6787269711494446,
0.7399460077285767,
0.44339215755462646,
0.4229545295238495,
-0.4937536120414734,
0.6305474042892456,
-0.03958170861005783,
-0.8479781746864319,
0.3834559917449951,
-0.12663032114505768,
0.24541640281677246,
0.4173133969306946,
0.3847561776638031,
-0.2361891269683838,
-0.42915424704551697,
-0.6311650276184082,
-0.6493490934371948,
0.5890770554542542,
-0.10610123723745346,
0.015463728457689285,
-0.40721622109413147,
0.358942449092865,
0.5315892100334167,
0.16855354607105255,
-0.6692695617675781,
0.040685463696718216,
0.3121837079524994,
-0.42848673462867737,
-0.11669985204935074,
-0.5185244679450989,
0.08848720043897629,
-0.4081037938594818,
0.8866782784461975,
-0.09402832388877869,
0.3633248209953308,
0.1204623132944107,
-0.3691331446170807,
-0.06675612181425095,
0.30562999844551086,
0.3224565386772156,
0.8755596280097961,
-0.13492877781391144,
0.4880806803703308,
-0.09113788604736328,
0.1981326788663864,
0.16906200349330902,
0.15263551473617554,
-0.07724373042583466,
-0.020230121910572052,
0.504909336566925,
0.5207616090774536,
-0.02808821201324463,
-0.540781557559967,
0.36144429445266724,
-0.007566080894321203,
-0.3704434931278229,
-0.3037474751472473,
0.3235931396484375,
0.3262362778186798,
0.5795016288757324,
0.15116798877716064,
-0.3187536597251892,
0.028234736993908882,
-0.5212773084640503,
0.2568190097808838,
0.5014673471450806,
0.1816014051437378,
-0.4657757580280304,
0.7227497696876526,
0.11090545356273651,
-0.2619453966617584,
0.6353463530540466,
-0.5284328460693359,
-0.564565122127533,
0.4122537672519684,
1.0696651935577393,
1.04885995388031,
-0.2867262065410614,
0.1585206240415573,
0.5981220602989197,
0.26137953996658325,
-0.24260681867599487,
0.49590152502059937,
-0.30370253324508667,
-1.0639479160308838,
-0.7618038058280945,
-0.7459468841552734,
-0.24988451600074768,
0.46046459674835205,
-0.3655005991458893,
0.45201191306114197,
-0.6151330471038818,
0.38405841588974,
0.19842222332954407,
-0.22772999107837677,
-0.8296576738357544,
0.04916222020983696,
0.31242990493774414,
0.9834374189376831,
-0.7846877574920654,
1.0256942510604858,
0.49335405230522156,
-0.3294857144355774,
-0.5450908541679382,
-0.2278328537940979,
-0.09338889271020889,
-0.7773100733757019,
0.8814211487770081,
0.4025774598121643,
-0.24925801157951355,
0.27991554141044617,
-0.46083182096481323,
-0.45653900504112244,
0.8195433020591736,
0.3115062415599823,
-0.40388762950897217,
0.08068916201591492,
0.28607943654060364,
0.2080107182264328,
-0.5466992855072021,
0.19754356145858765,
0.8584806323051453,
0.323214590549469,
0.26362377405166626,
-0.5727378129959106,
0.20266307890415192,
0.005601540207862854,
-0.13097956776618958,
0.024055063724517822,
-0.05241008475422859,
0.7871694564819336,
-0.3537059426307678,
-0.36151543259620667,
0.003577458206564188,
0.35935014486312866,
0.09880147129297256,
0.27724185585975647,
0.3393222391605377,
0.9173977375030518,
0.6442521214485168,
0.07100497931241989,
0.7614560127258301,
-0.3059859871864319,
-0.042339909821748734,
1.104060173034668,
-0.585811972618103,
0.7196347117424011,
0.3089272677898407,
-0.08813902735710144,
0.5969279408454895,
0.33837780356407166,
0.2982548177242279,
0.6921213865280151,
0.3310742974281311,
-0.549365222454071,
-0.3450811505317688,
-0.057153694331645966,
-0.3159542381763458,
0.4328315258026123,
0.6638765335083008,
-0.5955674052238464,
-0.48265716433525085,
0.15783627331256866,
0.1666175127029419,
0.5057140588760376,
-0.30770227313041687,
0.9746876955032349,
-0.09381675720214844,
-0.707714855670929,
0.8090035915374756,
0.1113663911819458,
0.5918310880661011,
-0.42181628942489624,
-0.23331177234649658,
-0.3323657214641571,
0.6476740837097168,
-0.23564878106117249,
-0.5593751668930054,
0.3742232918739319,
-0.013563058339059353,
-0.08638592809438705,
-0.2628786861896515,
0.7214561700820923,
-0.49772411584854126,
-0.39073842763900757,
0.19944527745246887,
0.4206964075565338,
-0.19310040771961212,
-0.12585020065307617,
-0.236662819981575,
0.10843053460121155,
-0.1178579181432724,
-0.23707470297813416,
0.16556993126869202,
0.7433274984359741,
0.1293184459209442,
0.7462575435638428,
0.5825344324111938,
0.1846832036972046,
-0.13285189867019653,
0.11099312454462051,
0.8810376524925232,
-0.7868378758430481,
-0.2865501046180725,
-1.1918781995773315,
0.6165627837181091,
0.03972848132252693,
0.03166591748595238,
0.5872452259063721,
0.3761855363845825,
1.1296312808990479,
-0.10354801267385483,
1.0220322608947754,
-0.06690336763858795,
0.7013623118400574,
-0.7946128845214844,
0.22631290555000305,
-0.10662572830915451,
0.6040406823158264,
-0.11673242598772049,
-0.9647018909454346,
-0.5320388078689575,
0.9081246852874756,
-0.3599591553211212,
-0.3542959690093994,
0.9250566959381104,
0.89026939868927,
0.14501230418682098,
0.07278312742710114,
0.2287747859954834,
0.1731158196926117,
0.6543461084365845,
0.5518468618392944,
1.1441340446472168,
-0.2094268947839737,
0.0750984251499176,
-0.5127728581428528,
-0.154533252120018,
-0.12445222586393356,
-1.0156053304672241,
-1.2145425081253052,
-0.5031330585479736,
-0.5946892499923706,
-0.340713769197464,
-0.16668559610843658,
1.127091646194458,
0.3201122581958771,
-0.6513184309005737,
-0.17353938519954681,
-0.4318124055862427,
0.2857046127319336,
-0.4452063739299774,
-0.21084189414978027,
0.3328852355480194,
-0.7193349599838257,
-0.6310688853263855,
0.545284628868103,
0.11473134905099869,
-0.28592050075531006,
-0.07562913000583649,
0.12251418828964233,
-0.39627307653427124,
-0.004680868703871965,
0.7992166876792908,
0.047717783600091934,
-0.4527701735496521,
-0.2547853887081146,
-0.42853742837905884,
-0.058285947889089584,
-0.0871911495923996,
0.6996416449546814,
-0.9797362089157104,
0.42536649107933044,
0.48538702726364136,
1.0630621910095215,
0.4994918406009674,
-0.13259920477867126,
0.5228285789489746,
-0.46627748012542725,
0.2531074285507202,
0.14789478480815887,
0.289803683757782,
0.4222191274166107,
-0.23557163774967194,
0.6578254699707031,
0.2554927468299866,
-0.3627146780490875,
-0.911770224571228,
0.3764771521091461,
-0.552719235420227,
-0.2736709415912628,
1.4930976629257202,
0.007210059091448784,
-0.17874084413051605,
-0.015263722278177738,
-0.10197171568870544,
0.39730867743492126,
-0.23761866986751556,
0.8021933436393738,
0.46329638361930847,
0.09174847602844238,
-0.06608351320028305,
-0.3693179786205292,
0.5624240636825562,
0.18725121021270752,
-0.7250397205352783,
0.4695631265640259,
0.5171195864677429,
0.3907541036605835,
-0.27211257815361023,
0.6034327149391174,
-0.20688867568969727,
0.041080232709646225,
0.047925908118486404,
0.15240328013896942,
-0.2209610491991043,
-0.3085959255695343,
-0.3429763615131378,
-0.029896672815084457,
0.5096349716186523,
-0.14016225934028625
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.05788v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.05788v1
|
On the Benefits of Fine-Grained Loss Truncation: A Case Study on Factuality in Summarization
| 2024-03-09T04:20:26 | 2024-03-09T04:20:26 |
Lorenzo Jaime Yu Flores, Arman Cohan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Text summarization and simplification are among the most widely used
applications of AI. However, models developed for such tasks are often prone to
hallucination, which can result from training on unaligned data. One efficient
approach to address this issue is Loss Truncation (LT) (Kang and Hashimoto,
2020), an approach to modify the standard log loss to adaptively remove noisy
examples during training. However, we find that LT alone yields a considerable
number of hallucinated entities on various datasets. We study the behavior of
the underlying losses between factual and non-factual examples, to understand
and refine the performance of LT. We demonstrate that LT's performance is
limited when the underlying assumption that noisy targets have higher NLL loss
is not satisfied, and find that word-level NLL among entities provides better
signal for distinguishing factuality. We then leverage this to propose a
fine-grained NLL loss and fine-grained data cleaning strategies, and observe
improvements in hallucination reduction across some datasets. Our work is
available at https://https://github.com/yale-nlp/fine-grained-lt.
|
[
-0.41144677996635437,
-0.9768465161323547,
0.5774009227752686,
-0.21161842346191406,
-0.21535561978816986,
-0.11458011716604233,
-0.35344091057777405,
-0.5800705552101135,
0.26926442980766296,
0.4157997667789459,
-0.3415207266807556,
-0.4970532953739166,
-0.48509305715560913,
-0.011548181995749474,
-0.7187702059745789,
1.6391552686691284,
0.22175438702106476,
-0.30794787406921387,
-0.28918975591659546,
-0.27758902311325073,
-0.5371274352073669,
-0.3609009087085724,
-0.6999988555908203,
-0.48832568526268005,
0.4714396595954895,
0.39256376028060913,
0.9402891397476196,
0.8044365644454956,
0.4936697483062744,
0.2581675052642822,
-0.33656054735183716,
0.3753452003002167,
-0.7443851232528687,
-0.03608782961964607,
0.023221172392368317,
-0.6549146175384521,
-0.23054057359695435,
-0.11608439683914185,
0.5082878470420837,
1.1141693592071533,
-0.1509905457496643,
0.1763211041688919,
0.27172136306762695,
0.929783046245575,
-0.7860351204872131,
0.06665074080228806,
-0.6026107668876648,
0.5367690920829773,
-0.02280712127685547,
-0.40250077843666077,
-0.48234349489212036,
-0.527125358581543,
0.22080540657043457,
-0.574029803276062,
0.677169680595398,
-0.030072873458266258,
1.1002960205078125,
0.7285756468772888,
-0.1310243457555771,
-0.25572729110717773,
-1.192819356918335,
0.6883836984634399,
-0.7598336338996887,
0.21520397067070007,
0.3096562922000885,
0.11079396307468414,
0.09191902726888657,
-0.5457283854484558,
-0.37783369421958923,
-0.10885359346866608,
-0.4927501082420349,
0.18157914280891418,
-0.02224375680088997,
0.2875928282737732,
0.36420708894729614,
0.5214386582374573,
-0.5770716071128845,
-0.09890983253717422,
-0.6159291863441467,
-0.3695887625217438,
0.5283567309379578,
0.1625489443540573,
0.011789880692958832,
-0.056248173117637634,
0.017933322116732597,
-0.02349145896732807,
-0.4337025284767151,
-0.12118935585021973,
0.191757932305336,
0.3862247169017792,
0.057531509548425674,
0.7189000844955444,
-0.18576756119728088,
0.3777484595775604,
-0.0469684936106205,
-0.3201330006122589,
-0.005012121517211199,
-0.19789831340312958,
-0.2571403682231903,
0.7617218494415283,
0.3502098023891449,
0.7567042708396912,
0.20004312694072723,
-0.4736100733280182,
-0.22508367896080017,
0.018989866599440575,
0.1450854241847992,
-0.8088425397872925,
-0.2143191695213318,
0.3048495948314667,
-0.6768426895141602,
-0.3424435257911682,
-0.043045200407505035,
-0.6055929064750671,
-0.6317564845085144,
-0.5234622955322266,
0.554182231426239,
-0.529106616973877,
0.2037878930568695,
0.3463706970214844,
-0.4340152144432068,
0.025047646835446358,
0.542659342288971,
-0.8324528932571411,
0.505534827709198,
0.6862662434577942,
1.1616820096969604,
-0.11180750280618668,
-0.08156028389930725,
-0.745482325553894,
0.25017639994621277,
-0.42671018838882446,
0.6908982992172241,
-0.12518593668937683,
-0.32926151156425476,
-0.1340671330690384,
-0.41527634859085083,
-0.05576884001493454,
-0.7394750714302063,
0.6093417406082153,
-0.12482699006795883,
0.17198704183101654,
-0.19390058517456055,
-0.5886476039886475,
-0.5246123671531677,
0.3427249789237976,
-0.8078479170799255,
0.7511091232299805,
-0.2248281091451645,
-0.8357297778129578,
0.2779119908809662,
-0.4294672906398773,
-0.765370786190033,
-0.30658257007598877,
0.11290378868579865,
-0.6492152214050293,
0.5890758633613586,
-0.03601842746138573,
0.4702844023704529,
0.052042506635189056,
0.2782163619995117,
-0.0909028872847557,
-0.5999923944473267,
-0.08803381770849228,
-0.506998598575592,
0.4303820729255676,
0.20289559662342072,
-0.4192388355731964,
0.034639179706573486,
-0.9537977576255798,
-0.09640026092529297,
-0.15766926109790802,
-0.23813559114933014,
-0.6715224385261536,
0.2660054564476013,
-0.07293018698692322,
-0.23806914687156677,
-0.14326412975788116,
-0.17190130054950714,
0.12403413653373718,
-0.6220784783363342,
0.14264558255672455,
0.43715518712997437,
0.06745518743991852,
0.27285051345825195,
-0.5817487835884094,
-0.002574493642896414,
0.025841379538178444,
-0.014629467390477657,
0.014778677374124527,
-0.08784584701061249,
-0.9425674080848694,
-0.170060396194458,
0.3917650878429413,
0.43255335092544556,
-0.6097427606582642,
0.30371540784835815,
-0.18105953931808472,
-0.3191720247268677,
-0.5756639242172241,
-0.27341583371162415,
0.2108660638332367,
0.7609147429466248,
0.5531356930732727,
-0.0991448387503624,
-0.636643648147583,
-0.8560158610343933,
-0.39966699481010437,
-0.150946244597435,
-0.01721937023103237,
-0.05403042957186699,
0.3719766438007355,
-0.1680903434753418,
0.9996894001960754,
-0.6448966860771179,
-0.5833841562271118,
-0.3350127339363098,
0.4463300108909607,
-0.05888410285115242,
0.4874267578125,
0.3363583981990814,
-0.7195910215377808,
-0.10211709141731262,
-0.021176856011152267,
-0.8337262868881226,
0.027992291375994682,
-0.5490565299987793,
0.2151600420475006,
0.35497066378593445,
0.39105433225631714,
-0.909993588924408,
0.8888001441955566,
0.1682969033718109,
-0.2137472927570343,
0.7429009675979614,
-0.2757384479045868,
0.1234990656375885,
-0.8344335556030273,
0.07732879370450974,
-0.1159290000796318,
-0.508606493473053,
-0.8213770389556885,
-0.2656029164791107,
-0.4460461139678955,
0.072880819439888,
-0.1760803759098053,
0.2614845633506775,
-0.1189943179488182,
-0.3188152313232422,
-0.2869730591773987,
0.42725980281829834,
0.3120536804199219,
0.42742210626602173,
0.10793912410736084,
0.7862158417701721,
0.12453927844762802,
-1.0039243698120117,
-0.03168822452425957,
0.34708938002586365,
-0.05256734415888786,
0.2168557494878769,
-0.7493358254432678,
-0.39418938755989075,
-0.5236163139343262,
0.23171305656433105,
-0.608134925365448,
-0.15105251967906952,
0.14623552560806274,
-0.24212010204792023,
0.24214906990528107,
0.23539872467517853,
-0.41121038794517517,
0.12488433718681335,
-0.7154769897460938,
0.28157833218574524,
0.3075762391090393,
-0.5126851201057434,
0.3335745632648468,
0.18246105313301086,
0.14669343829154968,
-0.4193519651889801,
-0.863219678401947,
0.17401517927646637,
-0.4448050558567047,
-0.3404824137687683,
0.45155981183052063,
-0.19189897179603577,
-0.38480958342552185,
0.08760415017604828,
-0.36123406887054443,
0.07758189737796783,
0.27359580993652344,
0.05718046799302101,
0.060949042439460754,
-0.1979292631149292,
0.48317664861679077,
0.03897399082779884,
0.015774156898260117,
0.10721448808908463,
-0.06478102505207062,
0.5729918479919434,
-0.3672219514846802,
0.02616717666387558,
-0.685189962387085,
0.13377170264720917,
0.19451643526554108,
0.04853011667728424,
0.8517711162567139,
0.8299691677093506,
-0.550175130367279,
-0.23285658657550812,
-0.4159471094608307,
-0.23269808292388916,
-0.38487157225608826,
0.4149295389652252,
-0.16793480515480042,
-0.5998327732086182,
0.622959554195404,
-0.058093808591365814,
0.07768944650888443,
0.7481611371040344,
0.3366909623146057,
-0.13897797465324402,
0.668297290802002,
0.7052885293960571,
0.04388308897614479,
0.1612928807735443,
-0.5378463864326477,
0.2946948707103729,
-0.6588313579559326,
-0.24768047034740448,
-0.5975711345672607,
-0.27021029591560364,
-0.6768653988838196,
-0.12789635360240936,
0.21207956969738007,
0.057393878698349,
0.15313822031021118,
0.026598036289215088,
-0.6184173226356506,
0.6340577602386475,
0.5071903467178345,
0.1920360028743744,
0.5562624931335449,
-0.07727225124835968,
0.3446708917617798,
-0.059483300894498825,
-0.6696786880493164,
-0.6165024042129517,
0.5956900119781494,
0.39645901322364807,
0.8202903866767883,
-0.030931975692510605,
0.7380310297012329,
0.6814615726470947,
-0.1619732677936554,
-1.1361197233200073,
0.4826452434062958,
-0.16376712918281555,
-0.3628096282482147,
-0.5741797685623169,
-0.6857184171676636,
-0.6902129054069519,
0.12328938394784927,
-0.3280107080936432,
-0.7073230147361755,
0.13161543011665344,
0.311795175075531,
-0.6322166919708252,
0.5422738194465637,
-0.6687501668930054,
0.6910382509231567,
0.2456117421388626,
-0.1454818695783615,
-0.27370685338974,
-0.7613030076026917,
0.5748915076255798,
-0.06946533173322678,
-0.003185766050592065,
0.039509840309619904,
0.18851663172245026,
0.8348161578178406,
-0.7034146189689636,
0.7700376510620117,
-0.07745987176895142,
-0.0980418249964714,
0.23907504975795746,
0.06800274550914764,
0.6207181811332703,
0.1346849650144577,
0.10356742888689041,
0.03990864381194115,
0.07134655863046646,
-0.03019617311656475,
-0.7526888251304626,
0.35119906067848206,
-0.504185676574707,
-0.49560219049453735,
-0.3280651569366455,
-0.7747129797935486,
-0.07272736728191376,
0.1428108513355255,
0.3460387587547302,
0.6453420519828796,
-0.09361477196216583,
0.3478502929210663,
0.9969046711921692,
-0.30864691734313965,
0.5656570196151733,
-0.15180540084838867,
0.049479369074106216,
-0.035776928067207336,
1.0292842388153076,
0.2399645894765854,
0.12230794876813889,
0.45714718103408813,
0.3389085531234741,
-0.13572098314762115,
-0.7148049473762512,
-0.12252302467823029,
0.2285001277923584,
-0.6826881766319275,
-0.26583200693130493,
-0.6528016924858093,
-0.4757586121559143,
-0.2697877585887909,
-0.22940517961978912,
-0.5268833637237549,
-0.9071071147918701,
-0.2744227349758148,
-0.16899190843105316,
0.2135402411222458,
0.5711422562599182,
-0.09368631988763809,
0.4285222291946411,
-0.7953585982322693,
0.5702527761459351,
0.0023249085061252117,
0.28302836418151855,
0.04542993754148483,
-0.48149362206459045,
-0.46649760007858276,
0.1231609657406807,
-0.17599503695964813,
-0.4202098548412323,
0.23085585236549377,
0.49982669949531555,
0.1541362702846527,
0.5557388663291931,
0.46066516637802124,
1.029193639755249,
-0.4890153110027313,
0.6839230060577393,
0.06329482793807983,
-0.9614031314849854,
0.4442678987979889,
-0.017849048599600792,
0.2177368700504303,
0.8488906621932983,
0.058552734553813934,
-0.5827878713607788,
-0.6501859426498413,
-0.6376250982284546,
-0.6725783348083496,
0.7120360136032104,
0.471579372882843,
-0.09047339856624603,
0.2877390682697296,
0.48591378331184387,
0.3366793394088745,
0.4447821080684662,
-0.6136608123779297,
-0.4554564356803894,
-0.27370578050613403,
-0.40240195393562317,
0.054664306342601776,
-0.4112372398376465,
-0.26997312903404236,
-0.18524937331676483,
0.9508368372917175,
0.053113844245672226,
0.05423855781555176,
0.4824276864528656,
-0.2729378044605255,
0.05570179596543312,
0.17928491532802582,
0.7978366017341614,
0.4268057942390442,
-0.4735816419124603,
0.37967249751091003,
0.19099648296833038,
-0.6207139492034912,
-0.06902586668729782,
0.03180994465947151,
-0.5663067102432251,
0.4423385560512543,
0.7588859796524048,
0.8141821622848511,
-0.027657190337777138,
-0.5998514890670776,
0.3407776951789856,
-0.10516809672117233,
-0.29716768860816956,
-0.08657105267047882,
0.11115363985300064,
-0.5128214955329895,
0.12248556315898895,
0.2558216452598572,
0.3816693425178528,
0.8403421640396118,
-0.6804496645927429,
0.34038299322128296,
0.22806088626384735,
-0.29179200530052185,
-0.20606555044651031,
0.6880010366439819,
-0.07134660333395004,
-0.04708796367049217,
0.4296906590461731,
-0.2668367624282837,
-0.39048904180526733,
0.4510156214237213,
0.36338773369789124,
0.8706156015396118,
0.1606910675764084,
0.5159238576889038,
0.36690452694892883,
0.5208513736724854,
-0.25454938411712646,
-0.3201850354671478,
-0.07299184054136276,
-0.3787442445755005,
-0.3980602025985718,
-0.45097705721855164,
-0.2902887463569641,
0.13001418113708496,
-0.6609358191490173,
0.2550077438354492,
-0.43017521500587463,
-0.07856392115354538,
0.10741344839334488,
0.14131125807762146,
-0.2536652684211731,
0.42838093638420105,
0.09759677946567535,
0.6567748188972473,
-0.7059147953987122,
0.28597766160964966,
0.22732175886631012,
-0.2663730978965759,
-0.6392273902893066,
0.3650498390197754,
-0.08324099332094193,
-0.3026728332042694,
0.25436723232269287,
0.5101560354232788,
-0.20928344130516052,
-0.22841858863830566,
-0.38298922777175903,
-0.6094034910202026,
0.9457635283470154,
0.39438629150390625,
-0.4213079810142517,
-0.2812497317790985,
0.3627967834472656,
0.5739485025405884,
0.04119154438376427,
-0.04752945154905319,
0.7147058844566345,
0.4234561324119568,
0.13229809701442719,
-0.6171343922615051,
0.13718187808990479,
0.17137469351291656,
0.04695463180541992,
0.2116914689540863,
-0.7540275454521179,
0.5816249847412109,
-0.4032782316207886,
-0.38197916746139526,
-0.11455785483121872,
0.7615579962730408,
-0.023458702489733696,
0.870819628238678,
0.5162802338600159,
0.5947114825248718,
1.0536075830459595,
-0.23777292668819427,
0.7984334826469421,
0.041182126849889755,
0.473077654838562,
1.3699545860290527,
0.013389992527663708,
0.3391343653202057,
0.4688497483730316,
0.06688810884952545,
0.09781260788440704,
0.5749033093452454,
-0.03683910146355629,
0.5773636698722839,
0.1270075887441635,
-0.0584494024515152,
0.049487579613924026,
-0.44146236777305603,
-0.18130066990852356,
0.431962251663208,
0.20753970742225647,
-0.04462265968322754,
-0.5320973992347717,
0.20221824944019318,
0.22199703752994537,
0.19531942903995514,
-0.34114691615104675,
0.8206964731216431,
-0.03946371749043465,
-0.3500688076019287,
0.7285887598991394,
-0.06998246163129807,
0.32441937923431396,
-0.3380383849143982,
-0.11871687322854996,
-0.3991348147392273,
0.04683920368552208,
-0.5331236124038696,
-0.4263816475868225,
0.9519398808479309,
-0.15647438168525696,
-0.35066351294517517,
0.20432879030704498,
0.6452817320823669,
-0.5434722900390625,
-0.2735053598880768,
0.025090770795941353,
0.1863461583852768,
0.44871383905410767,
-0.09237408638000488,
-0.3626663088798523,
0.11844934523105621,
0.04653673246502876,
-0.1382405161857605,
-0.10666817426681519,
0.7302228212356567,
0.02674410119652748,
0.6681625247001648,
0.2524860203266144,
0.20983529090881348,
-0.06801633536815643,
0.25122684240341187,
0.7570655941963196,
-0.6960617899894714,
-0.27465540170669556,
-0.9903484582901001,
0.4033544361591339,
-0.24003227055072784,
-0.11153940856456757,
0.7504160404205322,
0.979822039604187,
0.7003955245018005,
-0.07926923036575317,
0.6987413763999939,
-0.023324666544795036,
0.35370925068855286,
-0.8906950354576111,
0.6566138863563538,
-0.6783782243728638,
0.47101643681526184,
-0.2088899314403534,
-0.9624682068824768,
-0.6114968657493591,
0.48043209314346313,
0.05938546732068062,
-0.0718291848897934,
0.8783539533615112,
0.6486244797706604,
0.05584908276796341,
-0.06828290969133377,
0.532181978225708,
0.4157285690307617,
0.35086846351623535,
0.17131517827510834,
0.5021312236785889,
-0.7133861780166626,
0.717628538608551,
-0.45308828353881836,
0.059542011469602585,
-0.4213661849498749,
-0.6217236518859863,
-1.0403635501861572,
-0.4671211242675781,
-0.610222339630127,
-0.3151870667934418,
0.21990767121315002,
0.7442200779914856,
0.4750061631202698,
-0.7930359840393066,
0.12176036834716797,
-0.09619311988353729,
0.39029937982559204,
-0.28130364418029785,
-0.2695029079914093,
0.7024524807929993,
-0.5959910154342651,
-0.5686719417572021,
0.029243484139442444,
0.2599849998950958,
0.2984887361526489,
0.11819443851709366,
0.019584711641073227,
-0.06052112206816673,
0.12792710959911346,
0.755974531173706,
0.07168351113796234,
-0.5289838314056396,
-0.42752593755722046,
-0.433925062417984,
0.0629100352525711,
0.08580733835697174,
0.6068926453590393,
-0.7611885666847229,
0.21288304030895233,
0.265718013048172,
0.7453513741493225,
0.36077702045440674,
0.3543541133403778,
0.2735825479030609,
-1.0272583961486816,
0.24359603226184845,
0.11877553910017014,
0.09208367764949799,
0.35508787631988525,
-0.645183801651001,
0.7446507811546326,
0.24843642115592957,
-0.4076637327671051,
-1.0366544723510742,
-0.20537135004997253,
-1.0503143072128296,
-0.3879019021987915,
0.9289513826370239,
0.30522722005844116,
-0.2743939757347107,
0.009471946395933628,
-0.35627585649490356,
0.5291930437088013,
-0.37210318446159363,
1.273833155632019,
0.6919774413108826,
-0.031671009957790375,
0.0189113337546587,
-0.637363076210022,
0.977067232131958,
0.3741670846939087,
-0.9643222689628601,
0.43925654888153076,
0.5396379232406616,
-0.21308749914169312,
0.4121127128601074,
0.32499074935913086,
0.19193291664123535,
0.12249398231506348,
-0.1440129280090332,
0.09393993765115738,
0.00012676918413490057,
-0.5954200029373169,
-0.24024397134780884,
0.04782605171203613,
-0.11406785249710083,
-0.19259308278560638
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.07008v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.07008v2
|
AutoEval Done Right: Using Synthetic Data for Model Evaluation
| 2024-03-09T02:47:11 | 2024-05-28T04:38:41 |
Pierre Boyeau, Anastasios N. Angelopoulos, Nir Yosef, Jitendra Malik, Michael I. Jordan
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, stat.ME
|
The evaluation of machine learning models using human-labeled validation data
can be expensive and time-consuming. AI-labeled synthetic data can be used to
decrease the number of human annotations required for this purpose in a process
called autoevaluation. We suggest efficient and statistically principled
algorithms for this purpose that improve sample efficiency while remaining
unbiased. These algorithms increase the effective human-labeled sample size by
up to 50% on experiments with GPT-4.
|
[
-0.24462388455867767,
-0.6245412826538086,
0.24155861139297485,
0.13038372993469238,
-0.154346764087677,
0.38850492238998413,
-0.06064208596944809,
-0.45583575963974,
-0.3209887742996216,
0.30399903655052185,
-0.3229604959487915,
-0.3150957524776459,
-0.3333848714828491,
0.3689006567001343,
-0.5435294508934021,
0.8244073987007141,
-0.21111880242824554,
0.23218388855457306,
-0.3125508427619934,
-0.11118368059396744,
-0.4313339293003082,
-0.8860079646110535,
-0.4514530599117279,
-0.6087573766708374,
0.2869216799736023,
0.33325618505477905,
0.829479992389679,
1.1090598106384277,
0.6514659523963928,
0.4190610349178314,
0.49634259939193726,
0.22040458023548126,
-0.23507274687290192,
-0.01716957800090313,
0.06486067920923233,
-0.34468695521354675,
-0.5792956948280334,
0.6606931686401367,
0.5474251508712769,
0.5775966048240662,
-0.2488975077867508,
0.46355053782463074,
-0.027788516134023666,
0.6991825699806213,
-0.6910214424133301,
0.2448708862066269,
-0.3276713192462921,
0.10678903758525848,
0.02747548744082451,
-0.28524115681648254,
-0.44328585267066956,
-0.5886781215667725,
0.3704397678375244,
-0.7682211399078369,
0.505963921546936,
0.18888205289840698,
0.7896419763565063,
0.6353704929351807,
-0.12665602564811707,
-0.0924682766199112,
-0.8843206167221069,
0.8359732031822205,
-0.5371343493461609,
0.22570918500423431,
0.6596658825874329,
0.6939117312431335,
-0.001387916854582727,
-0.8607497215270996,
-0.4786694645881653,
-0.607528567314148,
-0.18118321895599365,
0.19665750861167908,
-0.030135897919535637,
0.15731412172317505,
0.44792667031288147,
0.28121986985206604,
-0.4430176019668579,
0.06142663210630417,
-0.7018092274665833,
-0.41034746170043945,
1.218047857284546,
0.06955523788928986,
0.4084656834602356,
-0.03267258033156395,
-0.2095082551240921,
-0.4420243203639984,
-0.5713025331497192,
-0.346346914768219,
0.409989595413208,
0.28534629940986633,
0.30388495326042175,
0.6670746803283691,
-0.44160333275794983,
0.8330195546150208,
0.34383532404899597,
0.260093629360199,
0.5851598978042603,
-0.5091196894645691,
-0.6301264762878418,
0.031498219817876816,
0.580990195274353,
0.27346888184547424,
0.27654409408569336,
-0.10788124054670334,
-0.3086513876914978,
0.20633569359779358,
0.5550082921981812,
-0.9509497880935669,
-0.7528589367866516,
0.09431838989257812,
-0.48579245805740356,
-0.6383089423179626,
0.05947224423289299,
-0.7165573835372925,
-0.11138909310102463,
-0.9124651551246643,
0.882951021194458,
-0.17274324595928192,
0.21677035093307495,
-0.17005768418312073,
-0.24954524636268616,
-0.04974969103932381,
0.41205930709838867,
-0.6971977353096008,
0.22949762642383575,
0.3161257207393646,
0.5820199251174927,
-0.10479064285755157,
-0.1466526836156845,
-0.5489401817321777,
-0.0987643152475357,
-0.7284383177757263,
0.6874837875366211,
-0.5244587063789368,
-0.48734214901924133,
-0.4764571189880371,
0.12922507524490356,
-0.1577460914850235,
-0.6138679385185242,
0.5550055503845215,
-0.3843359053134918,
0.5058771967887878,
-0.17179065942764282,
-0.6613482236862183,
-0.2592514157295227,
0.04185478389263153,
-0.638367235660553,
1.1128182411193848,
0.3150094151496887,
-0.18941816687583923,
0.7289759516716003,
-1.0303126573562622,
-0.46237239241600037,
0.12679077684879303,
-0.1744706630706787,
-0.728717029094696,
-0.00529744615778327,
0.39988306164741516,
0.3135510981082916,
-0.22396519780158997,
0.27999237179756165,
-0.13272987306118011,
-0.24443325400352478,
0.07409726828336716,
-0.559689462184906,
0.7221373319625854,
0.4564976692199707,
-0.5985395908355713,
0.18988966941833496,
-0.8540840744972229,
0.23247842490673065,
-0.017070040106773376,
-0.3507634997367859,
-0.27872368693351746,
-0.10686557739973068,
-0.16230268776416779,
0.15413475036621094,
-0.19325275719165802,
-0.6231265068054199,
0.27654585242271423,
-0.5259575247764587,
0.3064208924770355,
0.6691280603408813,
-0.062087107449769974,
0.369316041469574,
-0.4788602292537689,
0.6062633395195007,
-0.3085862100124359,
0.27855563163757324,
0.13458152115345,
-0.4991372525691986,
-0.7422841787338257,
-0.35233473777770996,
0.8556667566299438,
0.49616870284080505,
-0.5702202320098877,
0.5793430209159851,
0.13319183886051178,
-0.7228116989135742,
-0.9668684601783752,
0.21740101277828217,
0.4809210002422333,
0.708763837814331,
0.6414746642112732,
-0.24608570337295532,
-0.6818281412124634,
-1.222118616104126,
-0.42789965867996216,
-0.1506887823343277,
-0.1543714702129364,
0.11372753232717514,
0.6309416890144348,
-0.3562820851802826,
0.9782461524009705,
-0.30476996302604675,
-0.13079051673412323,
0.09115109592676163,
0.7921518087387085,
-0.2729070484638214,
0.8046002388000488,
0.6115038990974426,
-0.7573963403701782,
-0.6539385914802551,
-0.2901627719402313,
-0.6778785586357117,
-0.2714274227619171,
-0.09806343168020248,
-0.14078105986118317,
0.3267509341239929,
0.30322542786598206,
-0.2943452000617981,
0.9510339498519897,
0.11696925014257431,
0.026885518804192543,
0.5130318999290466,
-0.6679298877716064,
0.5889552235603333,
-0.5460344552993774,
0.0859452337026596,
0.014740684069693089,
-0.33418408036231995,
-0.623741626739502,
-0.23031030595302582,
0.17219723761081696,
-0.10517877340316772,
-0.1297234445810318,
0.5514529943466187,
-0.6178490519523621,
-0.06865575164556503,
-0.3528781533241272,
-0.0387360081076622,
0.07576330006122589,
0.010511324740946293,
0.21117600798606873,
0.8187036514282227,
0.1809619516134262,
-0.4621499180793762,
0.5873767733573914,
0.15434087812900543,
-0.11586648970842361,
0.35681986808776855,
-0.742250919342041,
0.3422287106513977,
-0.18907476961612701,
0.4460581839084625,
-1.1535249948501587,
-0.7332748174667358,
0.17318345606327057,
-0.5935242176055908,
0.36077049374580383,
-0.05977270379662514,
-0.4569554328918457,
-0.5522462129592896,
-0.25663506984710693,
0.42534512281417847,
0.7396497130393982,
-0.8351154923439026,
0.5704042315483093,
0.5232074856758118,
0.22485899925231934,
-0.2429324984550476,
-0.6738730072975159,
-0.08953609317541122,
-0.2885534167289734,
-0.3375730812549591,
0.37159815430641174,
-0.09108232706785202,
-0.23314161598682404,
-0.12913885712623596,
0.21373248100280762,
-0.0862940102815628,
0.11614895612001419,
0.2395765334367752,
0.617762565612793,
0.08631635457277298,
0.48115694522857666,
-0.10768821835517883,
-0.2937958836555481,
0.17604751884937286,
-0.17310388386249542,
0.1817564219236374,
-0.06232007220387459,
-0.2529333233833313,
-1.0411878824234009,
0.02622373402118683,
0.3239848017692566,
-0.11737844347953796,
0.42733290791511536,
0.5503298044204712,
-0.6598646640777588,
-0.10903289169073105,
-0.5136499404907227,
-0.26727190613746643,
-0.504830539226532,
0.19772692024707794,
-0.31514471769332886,
-0.16914071142673492,
0.012010553851723671,
-0.022729184478521347,
0.23414462804794312,
0.891035795211792,
0.8092660307884216,
-0.34000536799430847,
1.5232267379760742,
0.2392643839120865,
0.024969950318336487,
0.020216118544340134,
-0.3388274908065796,
0.10248763114213943,
-0.5157434344291687,
-0.20554912090301514,
-0.6441779136657715,
-0.3000487685203552,
-0.529919445514679,
-0.5918278694152832,
0.28941720724105835,
-0.17027051746845245,
-0.20077216625213623,
0.42027974128723145,
-1.1440609693527222,
0.34604117274284363,
0.6464906334877014,
0.07734768837690353,
0.2519724667072296,
-0.013442318886518478,
0.009230093099176884,
0.01811300776898861,
-0.5828050971031189,
-0.4866756200790405,
1.5600330829620361,
0.4009142816066742,
0.5544812083244324,
-0.4126136302947998,
0.6595633625984192,
0.7534406781196594,
0.9216057062149048,
-0.5635964870452881,
0.22231438755989075,
0.05124852806329727,
-0.9972633123397827,
-0.44196364283561707,
-0.2364989072084427,
-0.7871462106704712,
0.032072387635707855,
-0.22769300639629364,
-0.39940422773361206,
0.2350590080022812,
0.6505194902420044,
-0.6456659436225891,
-0.12093201279640198,
-0.9530593156814575,
0.6389803290367126,
-0.434517502784729,
-0.12208259105682373,
-0.2647089660167694,
-0.5564377307891846,
0.11695842444896698,
-0.5012016296386719,
0.11511176824569702,
0.1694345623254776,
0.03069787099957466,
1.1649844646453857,
-0.8371515870094299,
0.6800307631492615,
-0.41576749086380005,
0.29695451259613037,
0.5845320820808411,
-0.21906033158302307,
0.62703537940979,
-0.339478999376297,
-0.10928070545196533,
-0.07139084488153458,
0.023265058174729347,
-0.37740275263786316,
-0.8217609524726868,
0.4047745168209076,
-0.7964567542076111,
-0.3452264368534088,
-0.5980648994445801,
-0.3306693434715271,
-0.21969470381736755,
-0.18489395081996918,
0.3368220925331116,
0.2495592087507248,
0.06668785959482193,
0.17075124382972717,
0.133846253156662,
-0.07971703261137009,
0.2520415782928467,
0.3241862952709198,
-0.16071906685829163,
-0.6144039034843445,
0.8527065515518188,
0.4630032479763031,
0.3729095160961151,
-0.2989150285720825,
0.3789677321910858,
-0.5944181084632874,
-0.5417148470878601,
-0.6782845258712769,
0.06457075476646423,
-0.6103922128677368,
-0.11449848860502243,
-0.43819889426231384,
-0.3147827982902527,
-0.5260814428329468,
-0.05236593261361122,
-0.4582589566707611,
-0.7959209084510803,
-0.2921014726161957,
-0.3738437294960022,
0.19127807021141052,
0.5692914724349976,
-0.3474735915660858,
0.3733501136302948,
-0.6196736693382263,
0.5028129816055298,
0.3231089115142822,
-0.0709189847111702,
-0.22501014173030853,
-0.6916782855987549,
-0.15131378173828125,
0.22728805243968964,
-0.20234180986881256,
-0.6599363684654236,
0.6162722706794739,
0.33225002884864807,
0.69632887840271,
0.09821680188179016,
0.10256659984588623,
1.0689140558242798,
-0.3096635341644287,
0.4688715934753418,
-0.11252810060977936,
-0.9606841206550598,
0.7576078176498413,
-0.09082396328449249,
-0.10198462754487991,
0.6854687929153442,
0.5785585641860962,
-0.014901761896908283,
0.028411926701664925,
-0.8847795724868774,
-0.7067017555236816,
0.4322056472301483,
0.46083712577819824,
-0.2497398406267166,
0.19918470084667206,
0.6530249714851379,
0.015333889052271843,
0.1924862265586853,
-0.19559693336486816,
-0.05699259415268898,
-0.22657132148742676,
-0.4052203893661499,
-0.07352279126644135,
0.06444072723388672,
-0.19471430778503418,
-0.7760124802589417,
0.9630120992660522,
-0.18836607038974762,
0.1941797137260437,
0.5613146424293518,
-0.22728091478347778,
-0.22165116667747498,
-0.08424248546361923,
0.30133143067359924,
0.6723757386207581,
-0.19698728621006012,
-0.20693185925483704,
0.3363470733165741,
-0.3411600887775421,
0.39577344059944153,
0.29407262802124023,
-0.3564992845058441,
-0.234034463763237,
0.27894526720046997,
0.49274104833602905,
-0.32327863574028015,
-0.5332570672035217,
0.15539869666099548,
-0.07075903564691544,
-0.2983005940914154,
-0.4443293511867523,
0.2683138847351074,
-0.3588913381099701,
-0.03193473070859909,
0.42378416657447815,
0.15197056531906128,
0.45492982864379883,
-0.6573387384414673,
0.6004781126976013,
0.29011985659599304,
-0.3695935308933258,
-0.2017219364643097,
0.7991176247596741,
0.286361962556839,
-0.4836048185825348,
0.8543668389320374,
-0.06646189838647842,
-0.52874356508255,
0.7352203130722046,
0.32103344798088074,
0.8993558883666992,
-0.5897988677024841,
0.22017830610275269,
0.6344982385635376,
0.09004715085029602,
-0.1486254781484604,
0.09129822999238968,
-0.12071315944194794,
-0.4009580910205841,
-0.4661623239517212,
-0.6334609985351562,
-0.48024982213974,
-0.0640057697892189,
-0.5909926891326904,
0.1842161864042282,
-0.4082638621330261,
-0.4700475037097931,
0.3258972465991974,
0.14386692643165588,
-0.6211147904396057,
0.8924643993377686,
-0.022192183881998062,
0.6423624157905579,
-0.9466333389282227,
0.7969282865524292,
0.2868134677410126,
-0.24800410866737366,
-0.7474426031112671,
-0.4708584249019623,
0.24540337920188904,
-0.6252984404563904,
1.0239768028259277,
0.18751564621925354,
0.004306766204535961,
0.03231445327401161,
-0.6059693694114685,
-0.7636224627494812,
1.053333044052124,
-0.08011224865913391,
-0.610112190246582,
0.08887074142694473,
0.2513754367828369,
0.8070183396339417,
-0.5642560124397278,
0.45332208275794983,
0.9714241623878479,
0.8260496258735657,
0.10639921575784683,
-0.9451149702072144,
-0.048517946153879166,
-0.2664880156517029,
-0.12305261194705963,
-0.03531685471534729,
-0.3965170681476593,
0.5966178178787231,
-0.2153645008802414,
-0.17012226581573486,
0.07847699522972107,
0.7084648609161377,
0.2749600410461426,
0.38961896300315857,
0.7104196548461914,
0.44352206587791443,
1.0537159442901611,
-0.1699102371931076,
1.094099998474121,
-0.1168430969119072,
0.3716298043727875,
1.173499345779419,
-0.2345157265663147,
0.5715413689613342,
0.0334966778755188,
-0.2963322699069977,
0.18356415629386902,
1.0672295093536377,
-0.5050968527793884,
0.3237949311733246,
0.4931212365627289,
-0.03871118277311325,
-0.36618807911872864,
0.24349798262119293,
-0.07617983967065811,
0.548793613910675,
0.14917981624603271,
-0.6802902817726135,
-0.01706830970942974,
0.12878000736236572,
-0.14693531394004822,
-0.21174417436122894,
-0.05288469046354294,
0.6214255094528198,
-0.32126477360725403,
-0.8975638747215271,
0.8170050978660583,
-0.09681177884340286,
0.11374487727880478,
-0.058738816529512405,
-0.24132955074310303,
0.16782629489898682,
0.2113303393125534,
-0.3537040054798126,
-0.2683839499950409,
0.3941011130809784,
-0.0165211521089077,
0.13233692944049835,
-0.1782386600971222,
0.7655470371246338,
-0.3529675602912903,
-0.891339898109436,
0.0009861935395747423,
0.2506343722343445,
0.31749075651168823,
-0.07726350426673889,
-0.8066987991333008,
-0.3849200904369354,
-0.03172077238559723,
-0.32011717557907104,
0.09560079872608185,
-0.19366705417633057,
-0.28663891553878784,
0.8139130473136902,
0.944299578666687,
0.07156767696142197,
0.0879177376627922,
0.014234611764550209,
0.6934417486190796,
-0.6812530755996704,
-0.2297915369272232,
-0.8662726879119873,
0.5508312582969666,
-0.4220227897167206,
-0.08797500282526016,
0.8589059114456177,
0.7529647350311279,
0.5908235311508179,
0.09590708464384079,
1.0126092433929443,
0.2073677033185959,
0.7096880674362183,
-0.4001263976097107,
0.8154771327972412,
-0.37915119528770447,
0.2554405629634857,
-0.08350060135126114,
-0.7475185990333557,
-0.39067187905311584,
0.7359635829925537,
-0.38351383805274963,
0.31656286120414734,
0.3409055471420288,
0.6224766969680786,
0.09243537485599518,
0.18269328773021698,
0.16007405519485474,
0.18693555891513824,
0.5170046091079712,
0.09034974128007889,
0.7568345665931702,
-0.5227545499801636,
0.04339056834578514,
-0.6767919659614563,
-0.557710587978363,
-0.17965902388095856,
-0.7519729733467102,
-0.9327600598335266,
-0.499387264251709,
-0.7394718527793884,
-0.3725813329219818,
0.26929330825805664,
1.1049153804779053,
1.1290717124938965,
-0.8156712055206299,
-0.02607967145740986,
-0.05443943664431572,
-0.46401894092559814,
-0.07858754694461823,
-0.21228280663490295,
0.7349213361740112,
-0.5600517392158508,
-0.8629087209701538,
0.583565890789032,
0.1368415355682373,
0.32320770621299744,
-0.5168309807777405,
0.024706199765205383,
-0.02931978926062584,
0.27622783184051514,
0.3759033977985382,
0.21901530027389526,
-0.43417873978614807,
-0.3629874289035797,
-0.23537123203277588,
0.14924725890159607,
0.28802797198295593,
0.5960334539413452,
-1.1977351903915405,
0.8702853322029114,
0.6695994734764099,
0.6255121231079102,
0.4960331320762634,
0.8497271537780762,
0.9915086030960083,
-0.40892624855041504,
-0.14420974254608154,
0.41532087326049805,
0.12797331809997559,
0.2927993834018707,
-0.5025953650474548,
0.9030985236167908,
0.3123982846736908,
-0.9541333913803101,
-0.831679105758667,
-0.32952168583869934,
-0.4847114682197571,
-0.11151348799467087,
0.7882965803146362,
-0.12363848090171814,
-0.44860008358955383,
-0.178365558385849,
-0.13943275809288025,
0.4182722568511963,
-0.16948053240776062,
1.1698704957962036,
0.6654984354972839,
-0.676822304725647,
0.1929505616426468,
-0.7920073866844177,
1.0282729864120483,
0.38740378618240356,
-1.1491175889968872,
0.049553535878658295,
0.6697521805763245,
0.2607745826244354,
0.1765536516904831,
0.4593738615512848,
-0.2136019915342331,
0.33597010374069214,
-0.0900309830904007,
-0.19741660356521606,
-0.10830336809158325,
-0.46927642822265625,
-0.30499258637428284,
0.01676909253001213,
-0.26376873254776,
-0.3931814432144165
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.05767v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.05767v1
|
Extending Activation Steering to Broad Skills and Multiple Behaviours
| 2024-03-09T02:30:04 | 2024-03-09T02:30:04 |
Teun van der Weij, Massimo Poesio, Nandi Schoots
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY
|
Current large language models have dangerous capabilities, which are likely
to become more problematic in the future. Activation steering techniques can be
used to reduce risks from these capabilities. In this paper, we investigate the
efficacy of activation steering for broad skills and multiple behaviours.
First, by comparing the effects of reducing performance on general coding
ability and Python-specific ability, we find that steering broader skills is
competitive to steering narrower skills. Second, we steer models to become more
or less myopic and wealth-seeking, among other behaviours. In our experiments,
combining steering vectors for multiple different behaviours into one steering
vector is largely unsuccessful. On the other hand, injecting individual
steering vectors at different places in a model simultaneously is promising.
|
[
-0.2571418881416321,
-0.7460020780563354,
0.3537013530731201,
0.5426173210144043,
0.015356896445155144,
-0.09965331852436066,
-0.41601887345314026,
-0.5809610486030579,
0.08549335598945618,
0.1759817898273468,
-0.4137847423553467,
-0.08367352187633514,
-0.9081063270568848,
-0.19440631568431854,
-0.5092476606369019,
0.9244034886360168,
0.25075894594192505,
-0.07324912399053574,
0.2835063338279724,
-0.24863477051258087,
-0.6815117597579956,
-0.5478204488754272,
-0.6699295043945312,
-0.5400132536888123,
0.8122121691703796,
0.438617080450058,
1.057018518447876,
0.2594377100467682,
0.1283649504184723,
0.395896852016449,
-0.12362644821405411,
-0.324686199426651,
-0.6180090308189392,
0.1797718107700348,
-0.28652000427246094,
-0.5918759703636169,
-0.3795030415058136,
0.15604086220264435,
0.6489720344543457,
0.7496004700660706,
-0.1099555492401123,
-0.41259631514549255,
0.3202000558376312,
0.63216632604599,
-0.7773946523666382,
0.04265105724334717,
-0.47481051087379456,
-0.22370529174804688,
-0.016567056998610497,
-0.00935664214193821,
-0.3907255232334137,
-0.03984740376472473,
0.5216937065124512,
-0.6095396876335144,
-0.23209774494171143,
-0.21268117427825928,
0.5582416653633118,
0.10339329391717911,
-0.6426838636398315,
-0.38240405917167664,
-0.7844778895378113,
0.8924274444580078,
-0.49488335847854614,
0.3296284079551697,
0.37808114290237427,
0.1599309742450714,
0.186314657330513,
-0.41804438829421997,
-0.38281935453414917,
-0.3477018177509308,
0.1584463268518448,
0.0746513232588768,
-0.12141863256692886,
0.40275198221206665,
0.37698620557785034,
-0.21801480650901794,
-0.14115917682647705,
0.6054191589355469,
-0.8196136355400085,
-0.10857035219669342,
0.6983300447463989,
-0.025769656524062157,
0.27933579683303833,
0.10456862300634384,
-0.30681151151657104,
-0.22430162131786346,
-0.8233531713485718,
0.4006091058254242,
0.826208770275116,
0.36318492889404297,
-0.21621453762054443,
0.9696832895278931,
-0.5996680855751038,
0.6828343272209167,
0.11712201684713364,
-0.3835853636264801,
0.4470485746860504,
-0.3903065025806427,
-0.10468833148479462,
-0.1489429920911789,
0.5015225410461426,
0.2913929224014282,
0.4054059088230133,
-0.3149503767490387,
-0.08683063834905624,
-0.017588326707482338,
0.5919385552406311,
-0.35702604055404663,
0.13208170235157013,
0.5766275525093079,
-0.3666980564594269,
-0.40309029817581177,
-0.05396724492311478,
-0.7089903950691223,
-0.31827712059020996,
-0.23785558342933655,
0.5999283790588379,
-0.719680905342102,
-0.5714594721794128,
0.42185720801353455,
-0.6047412157058716,
0.7125399708747864,
0.1874426156282425,
-1.3043967485427856,
-0.05698486045002937,
0.8753493428230286,
0.7142836451530457,
-0.3867878019809723,
-0.6136991381645203,
-0.49710702896118164,
0.2899506688117981,
-0.2886185050010681,
0.45746880769729614,
-0.7535306215286255,
-0.19379130005836487,
0.2578752338886261,
-0.1959076225757599,
-0.28502631187438965,
-0.42860764265060425,
0.20511877536773682,
-0.6883071064949036,
-0.08251017332077026,
-0.09472508728504181,
-0.11455812305212021,
-0.5582597255706787,
0.07842767238616943,
-0.8481252789497375,
0.7387039661407471,
0.05057613179087639,
-0.3978573977947235,
0.6857604384422302,
-0.9109859466552734,
-0.9936386942863464,
-0.232513427734375,
0.055955540388822556,
-0.3592027723789215,
0.09385833144187927,
0.004383324179798365,
0.5758411884307861,
0.31368041038513184,
0.2919911742210388,
-0.3095063865184784,
-0.17130066454410553,
0.1757565438747406,
-0.4449176788330078,
0.6859954595565796,
-0.2367822229862213,
-0.47675520181655884,
0.5444929003715515,
-0.40699368715286255,
-0.13799406588077545,
-0.2630040645599365,
-0.50682532787323,
-0.32049885392189026,
0.05709875375032425,
-0.003038969589397311,
0.46821826696395874,
-0.03354412317276001,
-0.12224717438220978,
0.4059602618217468,
-0.5170610547065735,
0.29151853919029236,
0.6645056009292603,
0.053888022899627686,
1.01671302318573,
-0.5214134454727173,
0.7633376717567444,
-0.009145116433501244,
0.09663762152194977,
0.2613605856895447,
-1.0104267597198486,
-0.8102943301200867,
-0.36526232957839966,
-0.07353683561086655,
0.4582394063472748,
-1.0366475582122803,
0.3877231478691101,
-0.16297712922096252,
-0.4086453318595886,
-0.3935135006904602,
0.30803701281547546,
0.5169614553451538,
-0.024453120306134224,
0.5040525197982788,
-0.27822762727737427,
-0.10835295915603638,
-0.7352913618087769,
-0.23161955177783966,
-0.00420716917142272,
0.10366828739643097,
-0.015582025051116943,
0.43595924973487854,
-0.3562474548816681,
0.6628392338752747,
-0.09481669962406158,
-0.2050718367099762,
-0.6243764162063599,
0.27064281702041626,
0.03147684410214424,
0.6957839131355286,
0.6139594316482544,
-1.2135035991668701,
-0.2635776400566101,
0.040311671793460846,
-0.3784184455871582,
0.17608003318309784,
-0.5355430245399475,
-0.06494805961847305,
0.2634793221950531,
0.29649221897125244,
-0.6247633695602417,
0.6126102209091187,
0.6134270429611206,
-0.28569698333740234,
0.8302890658378601,
-0.15125040709972382,
0.13550356030464172,
-0.3823221027851105,
0.011014956049621105,
0.06920144706964493,
0.3075990080833435,
-1.1410118341445923,
0.09905651956796646,
0.16714775562286377,
0.17145994305610657,
-0.6412742733955383,
0.30580171942710876,
-0.4080509543418884,
0.14228543639183044,
-0.13389086723327637,
-0.054717905819416046,
-0.3197093605995178,
0.48193225264549255,
0.252755343914032,
0.6269561052322388,
0.9711436033248901,
-1.0671889781951904,
0.44915929436683655,
0.08880458772182465,
-0.3759615123271942,
0.4470336437225342,
-0.5748279690742493,
-0.3091677725315094,
-0.2491374909877777,
-0.6178208589553833,
-1.1620979309082031,
-0.04721426963806152,
0.010220272466540337,
-0.20575961470603943,
0.5123671293258667,
-0.06805261224508286,
0.1899988353252411,
-0.3348013758659363,
-0.45829448103904724,
0.11292557418346405,
0.5543410181999207,
-0.38009512424468994,
0.8627514839172363,
0.10541661083698273,
-0.43867769837379456,
-0.8464494943618774,
-0.6440250873565674,
-0.09981753677129745,
-0.6199120283126831,
-0.6384673118591309,
0.395443856716156,
0.13764700293540955,
-0.16721460223197937,
-0.11902513355016708,
0.017705416306853294,
0.12264521420001984,
0.14982905983924866,
0.2910041809082031,
0.12267372757196426,
-0.03833696246147156,
0.1831519901752472,
0.3128206431865692,
-0.3294917643070221,
-0.19033244252204895,
-0.18592630326747894,
0.5921398401260376,
0.12451773881912231,
-0.6124597787857056,
-0.29925084114074707,
0.3334629535675049,
0.7727924585342407,
-0.5501003861427307,
1.0851675271987915,
0.40407711267471313,
0.23913881182670593,
-0.1662747859954834,
-0.6045246124267578,
-0.29996195435523987,
-0.5769649744033813,
0.7603219747543335,
-0.503527045249939,
-0.714718759059906,
0.3951054811477661,
-0.1761341243982315,
0.20623204112052917,
0.29993218183517456,
0.6910334825515747,
0.012638604268431664,
1.0770888328552246,
1.0406206846237183,
-0.27567750215530396,
0.9750925302505493,
-0.6353052258491516,
0.30314454436302185,
-0.8283688426017761,
-0.37519925832748413,
-0.3572787940502167,
-0.46810993552207947,
-0.24145439267158508,
-0.48694905638694763,
0.4608970582485199,
0.09282714128494263,
-0.2561955153942108,
0.2591015696525574,
-0.29871866106987,
0.1133149117231369,
0.7413126826286316,
0.18574437499046326,
0.2361750602722168,
0.1094755306839943,
-0.14610809087753296,
0.17751017212867737,
-1.1158467531204224,
-0.28060436248779297,
1.2890217304229736,
0.3859356939792633,
0.8994178771972656,
0.07735592871904373,
0.3591923117637634,
-0.030489284545183182,
0.5120395421981812,
-0.9738912582397461,
0.2756749987602234,
0.178026020526886,
-0.7076860666275024,
-0.7646355628967285,
-0.13606442511081696,
-1.0236539840698242,
0.36824464797973633,
-0.7130275368690491,
-0.6389802098274231,
0.16304278373718262,
-0.07878850400447845,
-0.4000050127506256,
0.2624981999397278,
-0.9311893582344055,
0.9205918312072754,
-0.5037144422531128,
-0.5887287855148315,
-0.680454432964325,
-0.49710527062416077,
0.29740992188453674,
-0.029692837968468666,
0.2983265817165375,
-0.055492520332336426,
-0.37990802526474,
0.602684497833252,
0.11567077785730362,
1.1223715543746948,
-0.20721237361431122,
-0.1426190882921219,
0.23673895001411438,
-0.15789873898029327,
0.41936931014060974,
-0.305815190076828,
-0.4917348027229309,
0.03408467769622803,
-0.5034417510032654,
-0.3268665671348572,
-0.39576250314712524,
0.46480584144592285,
-0.7657523155212402,
-0.7428573369979858,
-0.13549461960792542,
-0.5926358699798584,
-0.11416192352771759,
0.17374484241008759,
0.07878591120243073,
0.46179860830307007,
-0.15048091113567352,
0.19728589057922363,
0.2652076184749603,
-0.06718361377716064,
0.6602190136909485,
0.37889865040779114,
0.09145970642566681,
-0.31803780794143677,
0.7586577534675598,
0.12928132712841034,
0.9057741165161133,
-0.06477917730808258,
0.04612448066473007,
-0.41252630949020386,
-0.9391524195671082,
-0.18032507598400116,
0.055904489010572433,
-0.5686529278755188,
-0.09377025067806244,
-0.48191899061203003,
0.04373076930642128,
-0.3652389645576477,
-0.5675458312034607,
-0.19570279121398926,
-0.5080596804618835,
-0.049072496592998505,
-0.30139845609664917,
0.3273437023162842,
0.8883106112480164,
-0.25038090348243713,
0.5974977612495422,
-0.3419174551963806,
0.4280560612678528,
0.6122931241989136,
0.32256245613098145,
0.24310357868671417,
-0.20602647960186005,
-0.242060586810112,
0.18874284625053406,
-0.4884966313838959,
-1.0508229732513428,
0.49127498269081116,
0.24805209040641785,
1.039754033088684,
0.8037723302841187,
-0.08096899092197418,
0.6256982088088989,
-0.3844990134239197,
0.5948749780654907,
0.5332599878311157,
-0.876427173614502,
0.30051833391189575,
-0.13669143617153168,
0.13951683044433594,
0.2680574357509613,
1.0126125812530518,
-0.4923558235168457,
-0.8236311078071594,
-0.4919658303260803,
-0.9710695147514343,
0.49659934639930725,
0.1529269516468048,
0.12241184711456299,
0.3077595829963684,
0.25786352157592773,
0.047923117876052856,
0.21346347033977509,
-0.647647500038147,
-0.22839239239692688,
-0.0033875531516969204,
0.03776483237743378,
-0.20203948020935059,
-0.3493732810020447,
-0.202504962682724,
-0.4758153557777405,
0.7908631563186646,
-0.23233738541603088,
0.003641777439042926,
-0.10897967964410782,
0.012258557602763176,
0.05864362791180611,
0.3753896653652191,
0.23174019157886505,
0.6563823819160461,
0.42013779282569885,
-0.09150169789791107,
0.20049667358398438,
-0.41516241431236267,
0.25522059202194214,
-0.15712621808052063,
-0.19932778179645538,
-0.5416882634162903,
0.5254532694816589,
0.48258012533187866,
0.41205573081970215,
-0.5114470720291138,
0.47948503494262695,
0.5085443258285522,
-0.24739961326122284,
0.21782724559307098,
0.41422414779663086,
0.17927274107933044,
0.3089967370033264,
0.3806684911251068,
0.2019447535276413,
0.0869738906621933,
-0.5807298421859741,
0.042416349053382874,
0.8006719350814819,
-0.46455225348472595,
-0.17522069811820984,
0.6347644925117493,
0.4937029778957367,
-0.08614836633205414,
0.6642541885375977,
-0.22314567863941193,
-0.7789039015769958,
0.7304316759109497,
0.5321540236473083,
0.7496337890625,
-0.14411714673042297,
0.13346228003501892,
0.2543807029724121,
0.5123063325881958,
-0.16239139437675476,
0.34970083832740784,
-0.05301361531019211,
-1.0542494058609009,
-0.9120584726333618,
-0.2061123549938202,
-0.3383811116218567,
-0.31175532937049866,
-0.6954938173294067,
0.21015243232250214,
-0.0883692055940628,
-0.3801300525665283,
0.10980091243982315,
-0.27238231897354126,
-0.5689229965209961,
-0.12261234223842621,
0.14152370393276215,
0.8134418725967407,
-1.1007708311080933,
0.996771514415741,
0.7927700281143188,
-0.519522488117218,
-0.6556025743484497,
-0.24893160164356232,
-0.04211346060037613,
-0.6146705150604248,
0.8056758642196655,
0.29843562841415405,
-0.05468340590596199,
-0.1526590883731842,
-0.6437124013900757,
-0.7669878005981445,
0.9822670817375183,
0.007141867186874151,
-0.29582279920578003,
-0.07909424602985382,
0.0928817167878151,
0.26047030091285706,
-0.28453630208969116,
0.004767720587551594,
0.8510133028030396,
0.7404075860977173,
0.14221890270709991,
-1.3193550109863281,
-0.2279645949602127,
0.07065916806459427,
-0.1398451328277588,
-0.06288809329271317,
-0.49053138494491577,
0.6974175572395325,
-0.750145435333252,
-0.10431470721960068,
0.18106622993946075,
0.5931960344314575,
0.1501733958721161,
-0.13385553658008575,
0.562900960445404,
0.32771962881088257,
0.6419916152954102,
-0.08416034281253815,
0.9166942834854126,
-0.5071438550949097,
0.017424769699573517,
0.5630295276641846,
-0.22351673245429993,
0.8689655065536499,
0.5827476978302002,
-0.06976442039012909,
0.6324995756149292,
-0.2729753851890564,
0.3259437680244446,
0.6536422967910767,
0.04518920183181763,
-0.3544488549232483,
-0.41460174322128296,
0.2999802827835083,
-0.24924597144126892,
0.5336651802062988,
0.7464870810508728,
0.060226283967494965,
0.02908819541335106,
0.5594080686569214,
-0.020003510639071465,
-0.06794323027133942,
-0.40607142448425293,
0.6925210356712341,
-0.09900866448879242,
-0.8352262377738953,
0.3980812132358551,
0.11213906109333038,
1.2165478467941284,
-1.061673641204834,
0.0026594821829348803,
0.34537652134895325,
0.21408291161060333,
-0.09882169961929321,
-1.0289227962493896,
0.33144086599349976,
-0.3815026879310608,
0.09157267957925797,
-0.5452849268913269,
0.9138075709342957,
-0.562238872051239,
-0.027002602815628052,
0.558057427406311,
0.5149760246276855,
-0.2717869281768799,
-0.2799285054206848,
-0.554472029209137,
-0.1873483508825302,
0.043414752930402756,
-0.42677003145217896,
0.1355290412902832,
0.3455135226249695,
0.0727446898818016,
1.1229050159454346,
0.7331168055534363,
0.26614975929260254,
0.4721232056617737,
-0.17729410529136658,
1.0698989629745483,
-0.7631328701972961,
-0.7229427099227905,
-0.6492642760276794,
0.7670890092849731,
-0.17553521692752838,
-0.3549206852912903,
0.8985153436660767,
0.45329809188842773,
0.6620959043502808,
-0.23445501923561096,
0.902336597442627,
-0.3682611584663391,
-0.22331583499908447,
-0.5180050730705261,
0.6612886190414429,
-0.37522822618484497,
-0.09338989108800888,
-0.01581631228327751,
-0.653634250164032,
-0.183111310005188,
0.7971183657646179,
-0.727074921131134,
0.07181379199028015,
0.5353229641914368,
0.7606896162033081,
0.12640440464019775,
-0.17620395123958588,
0.5300120711326599,
0.23652677237987518,
0.3855183720588684,
0.8551197052001953,
1.0059903860092163,
-0.06334686279296875,
0.42910847067832947,
-0.4491465091705322,
-0.5325794816017151,
-0.3504960834980011,
-0.8461184501647949,
-1.0671173334121704,
-0.45807185769081116,
-0.1698068529367447,
-0.3411867618560791,
0.03210528939962387,
0.5455433130264282,
1.0723005533218384,
-0.6965447068214417,
-0.24171623587608337,
0.32211098074913025,
0.5574103593826294,
-0.8048599362373352,
-0.15403425693511963,
0.023177413269877434,
-0.7075318694114685,
-0.7281198501586914,
0.46046632528305054,
0.39727479219436646,
0.08276467025279999,
-0.4007093012332916,
-0.22746840119361877,
-0.4401891231536865,
-0.2596999406814575,
0.8600085973739624,
0.5714833736419678,
-0.3537510931491852,
-0.3279847204685211,
-0.16609174013137817,
-0.10307078063488007,
-0.09478247910737991,
0.8402994275093079,
-0.8054277300834656,
0.30333033204078674,
0.5347497463226318,
0.2186872512102127,
0.449442058801651,
-0.028561312705278397,
0.7883148789405823,
-0.36716732382774353,
0.7262685298919678,
0.2459425926208496,
0.23795083165168762,
-0.08423727750778198,
-0.13542795181274414,
0.32140281796455383,
0.019876327365636826,
-0.21920332312583923,
-0.08526606857776642,
0.24154821038246155,
-0.8642187118530273,
-0.1628081053495407,
1.653567910194397,
0.15824705362319946,
-0.04047466814517975,
-0.5118840336799622,
-0.3822818398475647,
-0.12429232895374298,
-0.27688461542129517,
0.44288721680641174,
0.5467907190322876,
-0.16706153750419617,
0.35019683837890625,
-0.7049760222434998,
0.5374311208724976,
0.6854866743087769,
-0.4309910237789154,
0.06181139871478081,
0.34545254707336426,
0.28666287660598755,
0.32854050397872925,
0.4835585653781891,
-0.05515484884381294,
0.4556020200252533,
0.07166479527950287,
0.14595472812652588,
-0.05420757457613945,
-0.7586305141448975,
-0.7197462916374207,
0.45547112822532654,
0.2610519230365753,
0.084832563996315
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.05766v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.05766v3
|
FLAP: Flow-Adhering Planning with Constrained Decoding in LLMs
| 2024-03-09T02:27:45 | 2024-06-04T20:55:04 |
Shamik Roy, Sailik Sengupta, Daniele Bonadiman, Saab Mansour, Arshit Gupta
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Planning is a crucial task for agents in task oriented dialogs (TODs). Human
agents typically resolve user issues by following predefined workflows,
decomposing workflow steps into actionable items, and performing actions by
executing APIs in order; all of which require reasoning and planning. With the
recent advances in LLMs, there have been increasing attempts to use them for
task planning and API usage. However, the faithfulness of the plans to
predefined workflows and API dependencies, is not guaranteed with LLMs.
Moreover, workflows in real life are often custom-defined and prone to changes;
hence, adaptation is desirable. To study this, we propose the problem of
faithful planning in TODs that needs to resolve user intents by following
predefined flows and preserving API dependencies. To solve this problem, we
propose FLAP, a Flow-Adhering Planning algorithm based on constrained decoding
with lookahead heuristic for LLMs. Our algorithm alleviates the need for
finetuning LLMs using domain specific (plan/dependency) data, enables quick
adaptation to predefined flows, and outperforms other decoding and
prompting-based baselines. Further, our algorithm empowers smaller LLMs (7B) to
perform at par larger LLMs (30B-40B).
|
[
-0.06315974146127701,
-0.31927061080932617,
0.45154961943626404,
0.36302074790000916,
-0.23106884956359863,
0.08629290759563446,
0.23272939026355743,
-0.49756404757499695,
0.5468862652778625,
1.1047335863113403,
-1.2038449048995972,
-0.5346656441688538,
-0.2539685368537903,
0.05079313740134239,
0.09174954891204834,
0.40053194761276245,
-0.43686479330062866,
-0.36384838819503784,
0.0016365631017833948,
0.0034396343398839235,
-0.5895198583602905,
-0.015337621793150902,
-0.46709251403808594,
-0.23835577070713043,
0.3775101602077484,
0.5232445001602173,
0.5630983114242554,
0.8873416781425476,
0.29448410868644714,
0.2611893117427826,
-0.19889754056930542,
0.6779643893241882,
-0.4407831132411957,
0.4150088131427765,
-0.2098984718322754,
-0.6169198751449585,
-0.6616591215133667,
-0.3395027816295624,
0.12323210388422012,
0.5512717366218567,
-0.35045450925827026,
0.026080988347530365,
0.10151484608650208,
0.8514297604560852,
-0.6563225984573364,
0.32431644201278687,
-0.7831800580024719,
0.0525272898375988,
-0.09813465923070908,
-0.6952744722366333,
-0.39027276635169983,
0.0329623706638813,
0.11972017586231232,
-0.8686081171035767,
-0.01277075707912445,
0.07166524231433868,
0.4762379825115204,
0.6218253970146179,
-0.11989819258451462,
-0.5975786447525024,
-0.7311773300170898,
0.4628829061985016,
-0.6105304956436157,
0.21631406247615814,
0.5023953914642334,
0.21505074203014374,
-0.7405250668525696,
-0.7336760759353638,
-0.15970970690250397,
0.27459341287612915,
0.1091751903295517,
0.07855374366044998,
-0.1551690250635147,
0.3365904986858368,
0.15421263873577118,
-0.18118718266487122,
-0.44934073090553284,
-0.062331244349479675,
-0.3353266716003418,
-0.6877850890159607,
0.4869335889816284,
0.5675942301750183,
-0.026944905519485474,
0.0033095688559114933,
-0.5055416226387024,
-0.022548820823431015,
-0.7957702279090881,
0.42146730422973633,
0.18867790699005127,
0.46106693148612976,
-0.09088534116744995,
0.4685782492160797,
-0.4320460855960846,
0.618901252746582,
0.10778238624334335,
-0.22290654480457306,
-0.15951567888259888,
-0.18847958743572235,
-0.17274610698223114,
-0.2899682819843292,
0.44295167922973633,
0.2190190851688385,
0.3297625184059143,
-0.03216053545475006,
-0.3378260135650635,
-0.4468168318271637,
0.46209242939949036,
-0.8159348368644714,
0.19100305438041687,
0.25745445489883423,
-0.5434611439704895,
0.07191941142082214,
-0.3683130145072937,
-0.4305538833141327,
-0.32757624983787537,
-0.2947852611541748,
0.22003227472305298,
-0.5884391069412231,
-0.03159743547439575,
0.2937755286693573,
0.029077084735035896,
0.3435135781764984,
0.6499315500259399,
-0.6088248491287231,
0.36133718490600586,
0.8444823026657104,
0.7695164084434509,
0.28011441230773926,
-0.54816073179245,
-0.7714483141899109,
0.4510835111141205,
-0.4717421233654022,
1.017520546913147,
-0.39080265164375305,
-0.6092490553855896,
0.36344361305236816,
-0.20413605868816376,
-0.16766010224819183,
-0.602375328540802,
0.9417490363121033,
-0.4364619851112366,
-0.3588487505912781,
-0.3604607582092285,
-0.4193006455898285,
-0.23131175339221954,
0.3704436123371124,
-0.48451948165893555,
0.22695167362689972,
0.1378634124994278,
-0.3515855073928833,
0.1821262240409851,
-0.5695878863334656,
-0.6404016017913818,
-0.09096614271402359,
-0.09185289591550827,
-0.18899767100811005,
0.0731225311756134,
0.29029950499534607,
0.4202663004398346,
0.07831938564777374,
-0.22100327908992767,
-0.10756608843803406,
-0.3007570803165436,
0.14275260269641876,
-0.12143302708864212,
0.7434419393539429,
0.23090843856334686,
0.06760938465595245,
0.5372409224510193,
-0.3788072168827057,
0.1287919580936432,
-0.21346287429332733,
-0.305624783039093,
-0.1019575372338295,
0.3557712435722351,
-0.27437636256217957,
0.005290783941745758,
-0.03088950179517269,
-0.37410128116607666,
0.61661297082901,
-0.6803669929504395,
0.6035305261611938,
0.9360184669494629,
-0.03697868436574936,
0.5812662243843079,
-0.6358811259269714,
0.732641875743866,
-0.17658473551273346,
0.19952857494354248,
-0.22929809987545013,
-0.36770522594451904,
-0.45325136184692383,
-0.3479609489440918,
-0.053679026663303375,
0.5056752562522888,
-0.9024503827095032,
-0.050983976572752,
-0.11657553911209106,
-0.20072150230407715,
-0.4627944231033325,
0.12152606248855591,
0.46433478593826294,
0.4567584991455078,
0.1092170923948288,
-0.08965491503477097,
-0.7210575938224792,
-0.5768991708755493,
-0.3889407813549042,
-0.3352084159851074,
-0.010239290073513985,
0.35725870728492737,
0.2232256978750229,
-0.3113056421279907,
0.7327623963356018,
-0.6567308306694031,
-0.7864606976509094,
-0.40302613377571106,
0.045308925211429596,
0.14699549973011017,
0.11800393462181091,
0.24293577671051025,
-0.5515256524085999,
-0.6291024088859558,
-0.28965482115745544,
-0.056735072284936905,
-0.17517507076263428,
-0.3169344961643219,
-0.5298950672149658,
0.4353918731212616,
0.5183550119400024,
-0.8761897683143616,
0.7937530875205994,
0.46612271666526794,
-0.6383729577064514,
0.6524816751480103,
-0.19407124817371368,
-0.3251070976257324,
-0.9995598793029785,
-0.3075077533721924,
-0.35152167081832886,
-0.5092490315437317,
-0.5020585060119629,
-0.16993893682956696,
0.020544838160276413,
-0.07206729054450989,
-0.27626973390579224,
0.8149547576904297,
-0.8368226885795593,
0.022509071975946426,
-0.5091650485992432,
-0.37840035557746887,
0.09868408739566803,
0.6572994589805603,
0.27517327666282654,
0.7389290928840637,
0.6307047009468079,
-0.6320807933807373,
-0.13986718654632568,
0.5700448155403137,
0.07387065887451172,
0.3569037914276123,
-0.21871764957904816,
0.15940819680690765,
0.21852843463420868,
0.5573843121528625,
-0.5393457412719727,
-0.19433008134365082,
0.6083309054374695,
-0.47725528478622437,
0.3775385320186615,
-0.5455484390258789,
-0.07996423542499542,
-0.23958659172058105,
-0.5618666410446167,
0.3036198914051056,
0.507095992565155,
-0.39205312728881836,
1.2068507671356201,
0.38325631618499756,
-0.04737003892660141,
-0.640415370464325,
-0.4938810169696808,
-0.08094360679388046,
0.11964917927980423,
-0.7642227411270142,
0.6853139400482178,
-0.02654840797185898,
-0.05560004338622093,
0.22893014550209045,
-0.5096322298049927,
-0.17502646148204803,
-0.33587485551834106,
0.5249249339103699,
0.1366586983203888,
0.017826363444328308,
-0.5697154998779297,
-0.0732572004199028,
-0.20582567155361176,
0.11924135684967041,
-0.3620215952396393,
0.48675793409347534,
0.13037607073783875,
-0.46812593936920166,
-0.5558063387870789,
0.3272285759449005,
0.8208151459693909,
-0.08162792026996613,
0.18496322631835938,
0.4726743996143341,
-0.3284640908241272,
-0.6878643035888672,
-0.30480465292930603,
-0.059070806950330734,
-0.5204747915267944,
0.04972327873110771,
-0.6938381195068359,
-0.558781087398529,
0.887313961982727,
-0.1676294207572937,
0.358444482088089,
-0.11683225631713867,
0.4916854500770569,
-0.44559407234191895,
0.6195501685142517,
0.892815887928009,
0.1115044504404068,
0.36575764417648315,
-0.4239652156829834,
-0.10078059136867523,
-1.1649048328399658,
-0.29278820753097534,
-0.47811445593833923,
-0.49263325333595276,
-0.40449708700180054,
-0.8505405187606812,
0.18218563497066498,
-0.03773633763194084,
0.46856561303138733,
0.4550781846046448,
-0.33524516224861145,
0.17111803591251373,
0.4053342640399933,
0.05661098286509514,
0.10609547793865204,
-0.08763282001018524,
-0.01651710830628872,
0.21659007668495178,
-0.6177701354026794,
-0.37897151708602905,
1.0252883434295654,
0.26358041167259216,
1.0871233940124512,
0.016479138284921646,
0.8794848322868347,
0.15308906137943268,
0.08982579410076141,
-1.165696382522583,
0.8489711880683899,
0.013662038370966911,
-0.24823594093322754,
-0.6037006378173828,
-0.23320840299129486,
-1.2158054113388062,
0.14855355024337769,
0.18995006382465363,
-0.7568446397781372,
0.38320931792259216,
0.3924007713794708,
-0.18058820068836212,
0.3276647627353668,
-0.43329954147338867,
0.2840380370616913,
0.04536807909607887,
-0.27953121066093445,
-0.26688507199287415,
-0.3512425422668457,
0.03293917700648308,
0.45325300097465515,
-0.00845060683786869,
-0.33706724643707275,
-0.28656530380249023,
0.7037283182144165,
-0.900436282157898,
1.0056313276290894,
-0.4019251763820648,
-0.14770083129405975,
0.7102773785591125,
0.4155891537666321,
1.0812991857528687,
-0.09666121751070023,
-0.07498794049024582,
-0.13246436417102814,
0.1569354087114334,
-0.3912206292152405,
-0.488286554813385,
0.3965386152267456,
-0.3189748227596283,
-0.8436933159828186,
-0.26161399483680725,
-0.9523313641548157,
-0.4792017936706543,
0.21048347651958466,
0.2197006344795227,
0.4997060000896454,
-0.09816469997167587,
-0.4369349479675293,
0.493772029876709,
0.23104195296764374,
0.7167062759399414,
0.6946619153022766,
-0.15939171612262726,
-0.23751413822174072,
0.7561411261558533,
0.08996772021055222,
0.0061262501403689384,
0.6506320238113403,
0.2580127418041229,
-0.4683213233947754,
-1.0910769701004028,
-0.4036172032356262,
0.2412085086107254,
-0.40703994035720825,
-0.4614548981189728,
-0.2802582383155823,
-0.3016553223133087,
-0.46342551708221436,
-0.389987587928772,
-0.46647828817367554,
-0.321875661611557,
-0.14742973446846008,
0.37413957715034485,
0.09264031052589417,
0.5726003646850586,
-0.23423519730567932,
-0.0034599690698087215,
-0.7993839979171753,
0.44213202595710754,
0.18010172247886658,
0.4723808169364929,
-0.27926596999168396,
-0.4827759265899658,
-0.08299073576927185,
-0.11614741384983063,
-0.37255704402923584,
-0.8067167401313782,
0.5458813905715942,
0.04400632902979851,
0.6627116203308105,
0.5352709889411926,
0.5862391591072083,
1.002132534980774,
-0.5009243488311768,
0.010623432695865631,
-0.1947755366563797,
-0.6690951585769653,
0.562033474445343,
-0.4630139470100403,
0.3887360990047455,
0.5681992769241333,
0.0851578563451767,
-0.3323214054107666,
-0.28069546818733215,
-0.3353103995323181,
-0.6747169494628906,
0.8225833773612976,
0.2875981330871582,
0.06579134613275528,
0.5279151201248169,
0.5969848036766052,
0.21655812859535217,
-0.10530444979667664,
-0.17423127591609955,
0.04557186737656593,
0.04393560811877251,
-0.14407044649124146,
0.4654996693134308,
-0.41896647214889526,
-0.36339807510375977,
0.03842240571975708,
0.3175866901874542,
-0.39066919684410095,
0.4486113488674164,
0.40583792328834534,
0.008917303755879402,
-0.28961873054504395,
0.24345475435256958,
0.824862003326416,
0.8857740163803101,
-0.3098459541797638,
-0.14108923077583313,
-0.1161729171872139,
-0.8392940163612366,
-0.13763859868049622,
0.0344635471701622,
-0.2950768768787384,
-0.08689039200544357,
0.664116621017456,
0.7249432802200317,
-0.14890335500240326,
-0.9689356684684753,
0.3704388439655304,
-0.12096129357814789,
-0.5434690713882446,
-0.18405194580554962,
0.20098023116588593,
0.012488773092627525,
0.5022730827331543,
0.20407924056053162,
0.3544078767299652,
0.15726467967033386,
-0.6451275944709778,
0.040466293692588806,
0.45709872245788574,
-0.470220148563385,
-0.4806654751300812,
0.19325388967990875,
0.5521236658096313,
-0.8323593735694885,
0.22183240950107574,
-0.3560427725315094,
-0.5796271562576294,
0.5755496621131897,
0.6538306474685669,
1.1591891050338745,
-0.0843232274055481,
0.3005997836589813,
0.08316333591938019,
0.389535516500473,
0.07875149697065353,
0.8176456689834595,
-0.16069820523262024,
-0.6697007417678833,
-0.5710604190826416,
-0.46712514758110046,
-0.5335824489593506,
0.009615594521164894,
-0.5463898777961731,
0.10244004428386688,
-0.4907662272453308,
0.1065693348646164,
-0.5952392816543579,
-0.03180953487753868,
-0.5588977336883545,
-0.22628569602966309,
-0.07647816836833954,
1.4233225584030151,
-0.14639891684055328,
0.7152910232543945,
0.8648517727851868,
0.22230257093906403,
-0.9830004572868347,
0.5930662751197815,
0.2932235300540924,
-1.079284429550171,
0.3293941915035248,
0.06983684748411179,
-0.4666140675544739,
-0.2067626416683197,
-0.12632031738758087,
-0.8951341509819031,
1.0895367860794067,
0.20774050056934357,
-0.7925660610198975,
-0.20236432552337646,
0.017725732177495956,
0.30063360929489136,
-0.3903682231903076,
-0.21206364035606384,
0.22124308347702026,
0.3843432366847992,
0.5744796991348267,
-0.9711949229240417,
0.2796834111213684,
0.12622961401939392,
-0.21065345406532288,
0.2964860796928406,
-0.5619233250617981,
0.3203492760658264,
-0.6386512517929077,
-0.3759470283985138,
0.19090679287910461,
0.5133049488067627,
0.23389677703380585,
0.4927033483982086,
0.6777839064598083,
0.33869946002960205,
0.6641212701797485,
0.12619496881961823,
0.6264660358428955,
-0.09529592096805573,
-0.23733781278133392,
1.0810556411743164,
-0.30767589807510376,
0.9987598061561584,
0.5829030275344849,
-0.09513118118047714,
0.26513993740081787,
0.6137416362762451,
0.5617152452468872,
0.8465584516525269,
0.22252467274665833,
0.031606484204530716,
-0.1435144543647766,
0.01392604224383831,
0.061658911406993866,
0.691922664642334,
0.5061439275741577,
0.21206000447273254,
-0.1775672435760498,
-0.0029238376300781965,
-0.14493635296821594,
-0.03690716624259949,
-0.6026166081428528,
0.7676500082015991,
0.038468826562166214,
-0.9877173900604248,
0.6865667700767517,
-0.24037936329841614,
0.45397382974624634,
-0.6656314730644226,
-0.09751465916633606,
-0.2174244374036789,
0.08371127396821976,
-0.1961771845817566,
-1.047844409942627,
0.6544356346130371,
-0.24290473759174347,
-0.14638899266719818,
-0.6110967397689819,
1.034621238708496,
-0.11519119888544083,
-0.17756733298301697,
0.38330376148223877,
0.450702041387558,
-0.05304046720266342,
-0.1748257726430893,
-0.6168736815452576,
0.23192204535007477,
0.31323307752609253,
-0.4296448230743408,
0.28288179636001587,
0.6100655198097229,
-0.19475124776363373,
1.2735918760299683,
0.5595016479492188,
0.32785531878471375,
0.0340714193880558,
0.05599820986390114,
1.077384352684021,
-0.7321147322654724,
-0.6386227011680603,
-0.4971697926521301,
0.6101263165473938,
0.25334402918815613,
-0.17068909108638763,
0.03780600428581238,
0.42245230078697205,
0.6566162109375,
0.04067722707986832,
0.4667119085788727,
0.0720328539609909,
0.4841584265232086,
-0.97723788022995,
0.27870607376098633,
-0.3797469735145569,
0.588903546333313,
0.15327048301696777,
-0.6040047407150269,
0.03625980392098427,
0.45258456468582153,
-0.045892659574747086,
-0.45579394698143005,
0.515720546245575,
0.885960578918457,
0.13546159863471985,
-0.4336256980895996,
0.287494957447052,
0.05027373507618904,
0.3586762845516205,
0.7405169010162354,
0.8879804611206055,
0.10551682114601135,
1.0445764064788818,
-0.23423834145069122,
-0.24414362013339996,
-0.6048284769058228,
-0.7171772718429565,
-0.9586988091468811,
-0.6341279149055481,
-0.1222778782248497,
-0.2697632610797882,
0.06684411317110062,
0.6255640983581543,
0.9831565618515015,
-0.28932642936706543,
-0.3605026602745056,
-0.26869750022888184,
0.5352010130882263,
-0.4975455105304718,
-0.16247928142547607,
0.2982630729675293,
-0.38344207406044006,
-0.5032064914703369,
0.4997900426387787,
0.570934534072876,
0.14421436190605164,
-0.16518183052539825,
-0.5452756881713867,
0.22142311930656433,
0.45499011874198914,
0.4313699007034302,
0.7712827324867249,
-0.8909884095191956,
-0.04621304199099541,
0.1613187938928604,
-0.11684773117303848,
0.04173288494348526,
1.1228655576705933,
-0.6504501700401306,
0.2951524555683136,
0.5194619297981262,
0.480875164270401,
0.7582560181617737,
0.036179885268211365,
0.6189395785331726,
-0.5447845458984375,
0.22309119999408722,
0.6403701305389404,
0.26315581798553467,
-0.39670664072036743,
-0.4846086800098419,
0.5582342147827148,
-0.19253583252429962,
-0.46890610456466675,
-0.6742212176322937,
0.6837494373321533,
-1.4451844692230225,
-0.43902522325515747,
0.9636586308479309,
-0.10738296806812286,
-0.39960023760795593,
-0.3709755539894104,
-0.5449716448783875,
-0.07936210930347443,
-0.5442048907279968,
0.6813459396362305,
0.2937396168708801,
-0.9735296964645386,
-0.1528470516204834,
-0.11521786451339722,
0.7694305181503296,
0.18195447325706482,
-0.7460418343544006,
0.42802694439888,
0.38301873207092285,
0.21482540667057037,
0.004966412205249071,
1.2005947828292847,
0.18715958297252655,
0.2436932772397995,
0.0987621620297432,
-0.2915641665458679,
-0.45647650957107544,
-0.46351078152656555,
0.2803976237773895,
0.10512675344944,
0.23696814477443695,
-0.5114051103591919
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.05750v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.05750v3
|
Decoding the AI Pen: Techniques and Challenges in Detecting AI-Generated Text
| 2024-03-09T01:13:54 | 2024-06-26T20:49:32 |
Sara Abdali, Richard Anarfi, CJ Barberan, Jia He
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have revolutionized the field of Natural
Language Generation (NLG) by demonstrating an impressive ability to generate
human-like text. However, their widespread usage introduces challenges that
necessitate thoughtful examination, ethical scrutiny, and responsible
practices. In this study, we delve into these challenges, explore existing
strategies for mitigating them, with a particular emphasis on identifying
AI-generated text as the ultimate solution. Additionally, we assess the
feasibility of detection from a theoretical perspective and propose novel
research directions to address the current limitations in this domain.
|
[
-0.13915564119815826,
-0.9500563144683838,
0.8901292681694031,
-0.11344266682863235,
-0.22932441532611847,
0.13553938269615173,
-0.2186533659696579,
-0.8045835494995117,
-0.2482433021068573,
0.9069857597351074,
-0.73273766040802,
-0.49242857098579407,
-0.8316173553466797,
0.7455856204032898,
-0.6058738827705383,
0.846422553062439,
0.034149568527936935,
-0.2791683077812195,
-0.2181382030248642,
0.2811724543571472,
-0.27986520528793335,
-0.6357924342155457,
-0.9303029179573059,
-0.30416470766067505,
0.25816166400909424,
0.4332068860530853,
0.30287566781044006,
0.8445658683776855,
0.7259175181388855,
0.30490347743034363,
0.01437914278358221,
0.44174593687057495,
-0.34279516339302063,
0.26147276163101196,
0.4585884213447571,
-0.5673766136169434,
-0.4261702299118042,
0.08644647896289825,
0.6576036810874939,
0.45346206426620483,
0.1449250429868698,
-0.004723038524389267,
0.006325554568320513,
0.6084100008010864,
-0.5519645810127258,
-0.036479175090789795,
-1.0375734567642212,
0.15196368098258972,
-0.6390091180801392,
-0.3217082619667053,
-0.8305008411407471,
0.022387491539120674,
0.053508460521698,
-0.651872456073761,
0.31328728795051575,
0.2663787603378296,
0.7042132019996643,
0.146267369389534,
-0.5119655728340149,
-0.8511719107627869,
-1.0703901052474976,
0.8047589659690857,
-0.8190984725952148,
-0.0412505678832531,
0.5135143995285034,
0.06918183714151382,
-0.36107930541038513,
-0.8354790806770325,
-0.9681903123855591,
-0.4630427360534668,
0.11760471016168594,
-0.06706210225820541,
-0.3630619943141937,
0.13156598806381226,
0.24534733593463898,
0.287738174200058,
-0.41336196660995483,
0.2551177740097046,
-0.08258437365293503,
-0.30594104528427124,
0.8985808491706848,
0.4457995891571045,
0.8307976722717285,
-0.15019182860851288,
-0.1337297260761261,
0.09579722583293915,
-0.9024463295936584,
-0.0466928705573082,
0.8288009166717529,
0.21410301327705383,
0.1530599296092987,
0.6611655950546265,
0.286181777715683,
0.5283254384994507,
-0.21052473783493042,
-0.03273926302790642,
-0.21442921459674835,
-0.22732649743556976,
-0.08431628346443176,
0.1377648413181305,
0.9745333194732666,
0.24629607796669006,
0.6834353804588318,
0.11428777873516083,
-0.29544734954833984,
-0.03523031249642372,
0.46488848328590393,
-0.424557089805603,
-0.07951376587152481,
0.24360480904579163,
-0.4345749318599701,
-0.6221812963485718,
-0.08065140247344971,
-0.3311923146247864,
-0.6212165951728821,
-0.08349001407623291,
0.054616209119558334,
-0.3431664705276489,
-0.27375608682632446,
0.2946169674396515,
-0.1991964876651764,
0.5375918745994568,
0.5194945931434631,
-1.105668544769287,
0.0308692529797554,
0.9601069688796997,
0.578048050403595,
-0.14837121963500977,
-0.12283965200185776,
-0.3326643407344818,
0.3320921063423157,
-0.5194244980812073,
1.021702527999878,
-0.34063777327537537,
-0.3826136589050293,
0.11036774516105652,
-0.2101231962442398,
0.05074042081832886,
-0.7078690528869629,
0.6823031902313232,
-0.2290753275156021,
0.20670245587825775,
-0.274565726518631,
-0.6873735785484314,
0.20800894498825073,
0.5382986068725586,
-0.8366385698318481,
0.9936093688011169,
-0.08637841045856476,
-0.9085918068885803,
0.3166491389274597,
-0.6801549792289734,
-0.49830061197280884,
0.3652206063270569,
-0.2974065840244293,
-0.7693904042243958,
0.09200508147478104,
0.2169414907693863,
0.5342679619789124,
-0.28558260202407837,
0.19612233340740204,
0.02500917948782444,
-0.4015412926673889,
0.3623883128166199,
-0.8232185244560242,
0.909152626991272,
0.1199488490819931,
-0.4094287157058716,
0.0034868400543928146,
-0.8110003471374512,
-0.47936946153640747,
0.4720178544521332,
-0.43771615624427795,
-0.11365599185228348,
0.25126737356185913,
0.08503521978855133,
-0.41457507014274597,
0.23875051736831665,
-0.6449219584465027,
0.12443997710943222,
-0.22150811553001404,
0.5246334671974182,
0.8112978935241699,
0.03692951798439026,
0.28579211235046387,
-0.3317588269710541,
0.5683749318122864,
-0.14354631304740906,
0.10590654611587524,
-0.44673341512680054,
-0.6153523325920105,
-0.8078451156616211,
-0.11320195347070694,
-0.05482975021004677,
0.6764915585517883,
-0.6996174454689026,
0.5664811730384827,
0.05455021932721138,
-0.2828220725059509,
-0.8039475679397583,
0.339199423789978,
0.13245344161987305,
0.5750561356544495,
0.127296581864357,
0.2125813364982605,
-0.29986444115638733,
-0.897031307220459,
-0.4728109836578369,
-0.3110194206237793,
-0.15837211906909943,
0.30954012274742126,
0.5494978427886963,
-0.23084284365177155,
0.7702687978744507,
-0.1468791365623474,
-0.2971119284629822,
-0.6009155511856079,
0.36157071590423584,
-0.09000718593597412,
0.41712915897369385,
0.504465639591217,
-0.6770049333572388,
-0.5868076086044312,
-0.027481326833367348,
-1.0537241697311401,
-0.21353724598884583,
-0.5149289965629578,
0.33599987626075745,
0.40079259872436523,
1.0606017112731934,
-0.6769685745239258,
0.6803943514823914,
0.10313133895397186,
-0.3070885241031647,
0.791886031627655,
-0.26710960268974304,
0.037435516715049744,
-0.7539539933204651,
0.3430245816707611,
-0.07243454456329346,
-0.3358969986438751,
-0.8765808939933777,
0.1552886813879013,
-0.03757118806242943,
-0.010905059054493904,
-0.3260897696018219,
0.42408329248428345,
-0.5976102352142334,
0.16363200545310974,
-0.7271270751953125,
0.12544286251068115,
0.10252592712640762,
-0.08366615325212479,
0.06237974390387535,
0.8466882109642029,
0.040703002363443375,
-0.38453570008277893,
0.5187742114067078,
0.17443422973155975,
-0.41855308413505554,
0.46668219566345215,
-0.7026813626289368,
0.3938068747520447,
-0.4838341176509857,
0.3112470805644989,
-1.065062165260315,
-0.08961394429206848,
0.4584231376647949,
-0.6928667426109314,
0.3512575030326843,
0.041501011699438095,
-0.7544498443603516,
-0.3425443768501282,
-0.4832197427749634,
0.3496702313423157,
0.4305608570575714,
-0.3951437771320343,
0.6136749386787415,
0.23522722721099854,
-0.20668591558933258,
-0.8034526109695435,
-0.6426215171813965,
0.6156054735183716,
-0.39866897463798523,
-0.5940288305282593,
0.1292656809091568,
-0.027983708307147026,
-0.6076071858406067,
-0.2379353642463684,
0.3193795382976532,
0.49124613404273987,
0.48877957463264465,
-0.13740073144435883,
0.14724673330783844,
-0.2872445285320282,
-0.15297816693782806,
-0.07862972468137741,
-0.25988849997520447,
0.47727730870246887,
0.03538414090871811,
0.5380980372428894,
0.2102946788072586,
-0.31830310821533203,
-0.7170336842536926,
0.6644404530525208,
0.6421107053756714,
-0.26432037353515625,
0.660348653793335,
0.8607185482978821,
-0.4844623804092407,
-0.49093565344810486,
-0.593592643737793,
-0.2346605807542801,
-0.5877789258956909,
0.293516606092453,
-0.0793972983956337,
-0.740510106086731,
0.5201929807662964,
-0.026695024222135544,
0.05943966284394264,
0.2595694661140442,
0.681480348110199,
-0.42242392897605896,
0.959721565246582,
0.8179590702056885,
-0.08145350962877274,
0.3834834396839142,
-0.1350300908088684,
0.5872141718864441,
-0.8591256141662598,
-0.2964887320995331,
-0.6063567399978638,
-0.15445010364055634,
-0.43841299414634705,
0.0153252137824893,
0.40943050384521484,
-0.056030143052339554,
-0.005195064004510641,
0.0055329566821455956,
-0.5311541557312012,
0.6577705144882202,
0.8048921823501587,
-0.08604689687490463,
0.46767035126686096,
-0.05674267187714577,
0.18974009156227112,
0.05149584263563156,
-0.39810800552368164,
-0.9744437336921692,
1.292393445968628,
0.44337084889411926,
0.31558308005332947,
-0.08897286653518677,
0.6810691356658936,
0.6803740859031677,
0.30811524391174316,
-0.7504990696907043,
0.7877687811851501,
-0.22705727815628052,
-0.6329843997955322,
-0.248684823513031,
-0.10776638984680176,
-1.3973628282546997,
-0.021450160071253777,
-0.5835844278335571,
-0.8936113119125366,
-0.43921777606010437,
0.08231700211763382,
-0.2542691230773926,
0.621088981628418,
-0.33011311292648315,
0.6160433292388916,
-0.2095412313938141,
-0.16775211691856384,
-0.009262125007808208,
-0.5229836702346802,
0.4497307538986206,
0.05959707498550415,
0.0863850936293602,
-0.21822434663772583,
-0.03751745447516441,
0.6261339783668518,
-0.3751961588859558,
0.8497503995895386,
0.1419653743505478,
-0.5105330944061279,
0.708746612071991,
0.07220759242773056,
0.6391935348510742,
-0.10358064621686935,
0.1567634791135788,
-0.11044318228960037,
-0.39051175117492676,
-0.3453100323677063,
-0.20967544615268707,
0.2836124897003174,
-0.6759341955184937,
-0.7221861481666565,
-0.41306009888648987,
-0.6860166788101196,
0.10005523264408112,
0.33021438121795654,
0.6430614590644836,
0.20183628797531128,
-0.23046302795410156,
-0.15478527545928955,
0.8042939305305481,
-0.6486120223999023,
0.6484414935112,
0.2702166438102722,
-0.07128892093896866,
-0.14098255336284637,
0.9214047193527222,
-0.31789660453796387,
0.0325704887509346,
0.16659900546073914,
0.1498119980096817,
-0.17588987946510315,
-1.1598701477050781,
-0.6615983247756958,
0.3422996997833252,
-0.6294857263565063,
-0.17457181215286255,
-0.5412985682487488,
-0.35966262221336365,
-0.42913827300071716,
-0.2495887130498886,
-0.1268007457256317,
0.12187271565198898,
-0.92399662733078,
-0.22373326122760773,
0.3102157711982727,
1.1478215456008911,
0.12444940954446793,
0.5817801356315613,
-0.752993643283844,
0.41030827164649963,
0.06147594749927521,
0.05781926214694977,
-0.005136722233146429,
-0.24387165904045105,
0.08722860366106033,
-0.1368861198425293,
-0.20156164467334747,
-0.7796587347984314,
0.3742865025997162,
-0.14311814308166504,
0.37065771222114563,
0.5536760091781616,
0.163109689950943,
0.020560991019010544,
-0.6552861928939819,
0.8832238912582397,
-0.12798482179641724,
-0.9011878371238708,
0.6021037101745605,
-0.8522720336914062,
0.006222537253051996,
0.34990331530570984,
0.2659648656845093,
-0.5106412768363953,
-0.6685094833374023,
-0.46502044796943665,
-1.011170506477356,
0.4965495467185974,
0.34143126010894775,
0.45644399523735046,
-0.07292740792036057,
0.6504409313201904,
0.12097059935331345,
0.06392563879489899,
-0.9764953255653381,
-0.0730561688542366,
0.37258246541023254,
-0.41653868556022644,
0.11005979776382446,
-0.2595883905887604,
0.1207602322101593,
0.15382537245750427,
0.3540256917476654,
-0.016157710924744606,
0.32731491327285767,
0.15833987295627594,
-0.13792037963867188,
-0.11717060953378677,
0.11146026104688644,
0.9623611569404602,
0.22217664122581482,
-0.1244460865855217,
-0.03298601880669594,
-0.1899598091840744,
-0.670505166053772,
-0.020724190399050713,
-0.24007080495357513,
-0.4237397611141205,
-0.030318675562739372,
0.9962849617004395,
0.5512295365333557,
-0.46103936433792114,
-0.9711982011795044,
0.7105385065078735,
-0.1511496752500534,
-0.34143054485321045,
-0.8002170920372009,
0.07999776303768158,
-0.04073071479797363,
0.11937267333269119,
0.7136825323104858,
-0.2991379201412201,
0.12197774648666382,
-0.6082163453102112,
0.12481146305799484,
0.9379060864448547,
0.07791208475828171,
-0.21968962252140045,
0.6241504549980164,
0.384002685546875,
-0.7795374393463135,
0.9570438861846924,
-0.18063488602638245,
-0.7804641127586365,
0.9491698741912842,
0.7352145910263062,
0.8403907418251038,
-0.005939170252531767,
0.05355990305542946,
-0.011535382829606533,
0.8232778906822205,
0.08747806400060654,
0.2683407664299011,
0.014801525510847569,
-1.0418987274169922,
-0.28015825152397156,
-0.24660873413085938,
-0.5445720553398132,
0.612771213054657,
-0.49681541323661804,
0.2707764208316803,
-0.6925965547561646,
-0.2240895926952362,
0.000008436314601567574,
0.006063203793019056,
-0.45089834928512573,
-0.14844563603401184,
0.7323622703552246,
0.7031888961791992,
-0.8721668720245361,
0.5662741661071777,
0.39376190304756165,
0.010089854709804058,
-0.3854159414768219,
0.07516217976808548,
0.21037693321704865,
-0.9787969589233398,
0.31977739930152893,
0.3896254897117615,
-0.25900328159332275,
0.0859244093298912,
-0.9245100021362305,
-0.274671345949173,
0.9690550565719604,
0.31149300932884216,
-0.2925085127353668,
-0.14608655869960785,
0.6765486001968384,
0.5124132633209229,
-0.2567373812198639,
0.10695315152406693,
0.8965610265731812,
0.6263636946678162,
-0.43474745750427246,
-0.8675168752670288,
-0.08706071227788925,
-0.3664693832397461,
-0.23858940601348877,
0.1873830258846283,
-0.4387842118740082,
0.8706688284873962,
-0.19847752153873444,
-0.33360451459884644,
0.23080788552761078,
0.5799804329872131,
0.36764535307884216,
0.5851088166236877,
0.21789970993995667,
0.4202396869659424,
0.6654596328735352,
0.048931460827589035,
0.9573786854743958,
0.03648622706532478,
-0.04146185517311096,
0.595591127872467,
-0.45679771900177,
0.713081955909729,
0.4872538149356842,
0.011072888039052486,
0.40837568044662476,
0.37811827659606934,
-0.3177490234375,
-0.055514197796583176,
0.3447111248970032,
-0.5728008151054382,
-0.2740360200405121,
-0.2157224416732788,
-0.08621431142091751,
0.7954105734825134,
0.7516990900039673,
-0.4155535399913788,
-0.06794784218072891,
0.11925482749938965,
0.1469353586435318,
0.48205995559692383,
-0.35186833143234253,
0.9953209757804871,
-0.006830292288213968,
-0.5311198830604553,
0.19793683290481567,
0.26510968804359436,
0.9356359243392944,
-0.40410569310188293,
-0.23816654086112976,
-0.12136491388082504,
0.24189992249011993,
0.1045089140534401,
-0.6894537210464478,
0.2655304968357086,
0.19523459672927856,
0.1276014894247055,
-0.35104209184646606,
1.065025806427002,
-0.3772250711917877,
-0.5481333136558533,
0.12276684492826462,
0.478452205657959,
0.08831823617219925,
-0.05727147310972214,
-0.5592621564865112,
0.41529402136802673,
-0.0731596052646637,
-0.2321702539920807,
0.05309884995222092,
0.46045809984207153,
0.15008525550365448,
0.9480193853378296,
0.5830946564674377,
-0.0003174281446263194,
0.10656563192605972,
-0.35590335726737976,
0.3451203405857086,
-0.6024316549301147,
-0.28077754378318787,
-1.2341259717941284,
0.2844755947589874,
0.022294802591204643,
-0.15156951546669006,
0.6202154159545898,
0.23730935156345367,
0.7299636006355286,
-0.07428102940320969,
1.03018057346344,
0.33802351355552673,
0.2369513213634491,
-0.6634437441825867,
1.0840461254119873,
-0.2920502722263336,
0.4540020525455475,
-0.2681477665901184,
-0.6211974024772644,
-0.5081000328063965,
0.732624888420105,
0.005857918411493301,
0.022296544164419174,
0.4585878551006317,
0.39952102303504944,
0.14300093054771423,
0.11384686082601547,
0.17562241852283478,
-0.16499286890029907,
0.6552696228027344,
0.6589871644973755,
1.133849859237671,
-0.4205940365791321,
0.5863118171691895,
0.08831571042537689,
-0.02176067605614662,
-0.24362540245056152,
-1.1335055828094482,
-1.2443562746047974,
-0.5664451718330383,
-0.2557810842990875,
-0.3555563986301422,
-0.1723923683166504,
0.7297653555870056,
0.3913423717021942,
-0.6278352737426758,
-0.31095901131629944,
-0.36207059025764465,
0.09947939962148666,
0.20275385677814484,
-0.17593812942504883,
0.36065250635147095,
-0.20669429004192352,
-0.9433332085609436,
0.31409507989883423,
0.2638196051120758,
0.384075403213501,
-0.3472655415534973,
0.22859317064285278,
-0.09238196909427643,
0.32899266481399536,
0.6418306231498718,
0.27347269654273987,
-0.7315704822540283,
-0.3987694978713989,
0.07548123598098755,
-0.22122620046138763,
-0.029804883524775505,
1.2056910991668701,
-0.47287967801094055,
0.11279580742120743,
0.4152669906616211,
0.9005201458930969,
0.14707240462303162,
-0.17218855023384094,
0.7751389741897583,
-0.700993537902832,
-0.08397326618432999,
0.5930564403533936,
0.29708102345466614,
0.39384764432907104,
-0.6618980169296265,
0.289034366607666,
0.2711142897605896,
-0.5580228567123413,
-1.1447598934173584,
0.5402445793151855,
-0.8412876725196838,
-0.40939319133758545,
0.9991284012794495,
-0.1136719286441803,
-0.30004242062568665,
-0.3823692500591278,
-0.29892221093177795,
0.22575749456882477,
-0.14039869606494904,
0.8611170053482056,
0.8223344683647156,
-0.26638612151145935,
-0.3341192901134491,
-0.5040141344070435,
0.7096174955368042,
0.25649356842041016,
-1.0244063138961792,
0.41121068596839905,
0.405822217464447,
0.21428313851356506,
0.1335168331861496,
0.9457762241363525,
0.08767364174127579,
0.31483688950538635,
0.05311943590641022,
-0.09759271889925003,
-0.22288915514945984,
-0.41632193326950073,
-0.3015455901622772,
-0.01219024695456028,
0.2129429429769516,
0.11419834941625595
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09706v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09706v1
|
Schema-Aware Multi-Task Learning for Complex Text-to-SQL
| 2024-03-09T01:13:37 | 2024-03-09T01:13:37 |
Yangjun Wu, Han Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DB
|
Conventional text-to-SQL parsers are not good at synthesizing complex SQL
queries that involve multiple tables or columns, due to the challenges inherent
in identifying the correct schema items and performing accurate alignment
between question and schema items. To address the above issue, we present a
schema-aware multi-task learning framework (named MTSQL) for complicated SQL
queries. Specifically, we design a schema linking discriminator module to
distinguish the valid question-schema linkings, which explicitly instructs the
encoder by distinctive linking relations to enhance the alignment quality. On
the decoder side, we define 6-type relationships to describe the connections
between tables and columns (e.g., WHERE_TC), and introduce an operator-centric
triple extractor to recognize those associated schema items with the predefined
relationship. Also, we establish a rule set of grammar constraints via the
predicted triples to filter the proper SQL operators and schema items during
the SQL generation. On Spider, a cross-domain challenging text-to-SQL
benchmark, experimental results indicate that MTSQL is more effective than
baselines, especially in extremely hard scenarios. Moreover, further analyses
verify that our approach leads to promising improvements for complicated SQL
queries.
|
[
-0.014674997888505459,
-0.8312255144119263,
0.5382415056228638,
0.21973395347595215,
-0.31681692600250244,
0.13532431423664093,
-0.13387440145015717,
-0.23834683001041412,
0.007386034354567528,
0.6321632266044617,
-0.544680118560791,
-0.4883659780025482,
-0.44879233837127686,
0.41839054226875305,
-0.31417906284332275,
1.1241390705108643,
0.12869690358638763,
0.11966408789157867,
-0.42555102705955505,
-0.17113669216632843,
-0.5467232465744019,
-0.5203710794448853,
-0.4413871467113495,
0.13487794995307922,
0.3815462291240692,
0.3487330675125122,
0.2770913541316986,
0.817915141582489,
0.4797544479370117,
0.17891710996627808,
-0.06715605407953262,
0.7507846355438232,
-0.2817353308200836,
0.631799578666687,
-0.4576186537742615,
-0.6020099520683289,
-0.48418810963630676,
-0.6457235813140869,
0.28127583861351013,
0.846405029296875,
-0.49988535046577454,
0.17517304420471191,
0.17723432183265686,
0.8406513333320618,
-0.6746432185173035,
0.5236395597457886,
-0.8956466317176819,
0.03742091357707977,
-0.6173362135887146,
-0.19886831939220428,
-0.531658411026001,
-0.1565752923488617,
-0.15722154080867767,
-0.802669882774353,
0.34874990582466125,
0.4668538570404053,
0.5789885520935059,
0.2943761348724365,
-0.9201081395149231,
-0.4400494396686554,
-0.534008800983429,
0.4242047667503357,
-0.17610028386116028,
0.664646565914154,
0.28558215498924255,
0.3927988111972809,
-0.3085733652114868,
-0.4661916196346283,
-0.6477108001708984,
0.20548461377620697,
-0.26817217469215393,
-0.0729597881436348,
0.2735535800457001,
-0.055601395666599274,
0.4261363744735718,
0.21767306327819824,
-0.5699607133865356,
-0.3196554183959961,
-0.2886333763599396,
-0.018086159601807594,
0.1817878633737564,
0.5037268996238708,
0.04169461503624916,
-0.3285682499408722,
-0.2900806963443756,
0.41359949111938477,
-0.8764995336532593,
-0.09035812318325043,
-0.00997198186814785,
0.6516807675361633,
0.3282003700733185,
0.7916046380996704,
-0.30480101704597473,
1.0129649639129639,
0.3247336149215698,
0.040042124688625336,
0.11837883293628693,
-0.4730706810951233,
0.01087190117686987,
-0.13101963698863983,
0.7900834083557129,
0.2388281375169754,
-0.1407487392425537,
-0.3592788577079773,
-0.11367500573396683,
0.06231597438454628,
0.40287449955940247,
-0.48852571845054626,
-0.08738484233617783,
0.38528624176979065,
-0.16382968425750732,
-0.1415572315454483,
-0.23272685706615448,
-0.746536910533905,
-0.5880467295646667,
-0.3171215057373047,
0.3119446933269501,
-0.6424561738967896,
-0.2039644569158554,
-0.17750194668769836,
0.0904817208647728,
0.20442676544189453,
0.24877037107944489,
-0.9465526938438416,
0.439485639333725,
0.5445831418037415,
0.4016393721103668,
-0.48644450306892395,
-0.2807598412036896,
-0.7105617523193359,
0.884487509727478,
-0.25014370679855347,
0.8547253012657166,
-0.32817259430885315,
-0.0994439348578453,
-0.015535520389676094,
0.08865918219089508,
-0.2752422094345093,
-0.4820663630962372,
0.4526630938053131,
-0.47599565982818604,
0.22957223653793335,
-0.539920449256897,
-0.4468943178653717,
0.1799442619085312,
0.39298370480537415,
-0.6320534944534302,
1.3404998779296875,
0.19068285822868347,
-0.8352317810058594,
0.5083091259002686,
-0.7050358653068542,
-0.8586992621421814,
0.07852645963430405,
-0.270295649766922,
-0.3983805775642395,
-0.06682301312685013,
0.1837797909975052,
0.5079293847084045,
-0.5438368916511536,
0.37696367502212524,
-0.19523203372955322,
-0.22913728654384613,
-0.12365350872278214,
0.2307853400707245,
0.6300070881843567,
0.20764528214931488,
-0.23456673324108124,
0.27419430017471313,
-0.8334102630615234,
-0.07059594988822937,
0.16156893968582153,
-0.36099526286125183,
-0.21630844473838806,
0.291971355676651,
-0.17043399810791016,
0.326019823551178,
0.0934385359287262,
-0.5494723320007324,
0.20319271087646484,
-0.24266277253627777,
0.48703664541244507,
0.43356382846832275,
-0.15343324840068817,
0.4261932969093323,
-0.044013023376464844,
0.15202875435352325,
0.3031879663467407,
0.1390865445137024,
-0.03429974243044853,
0.025097137317061424,
-0.919815182685852,
-0.21147377789020538,
0.03948576748371124,
0.7217802405357361,
-1.0907152891159058,
0.45435041189193726,
-0.3067556619644165,
-0.3591192364692688,
-0.3247261643409729,
0.02435668185353279,
0.5263932943344116,
0.5376055240631104,
0.768943727016449,
0.016954589635133743,
-0.48708656430244446,
-0.5999131798744202,
-0.7542492151260376,
0.22035236656665802,
-0.009259384125471115,
0.3215743899345398,
0.5745823383331299,
0.31233125925064087,
0.7234720587730408,
-0.7518378496170044,
-0.7488591074943542,
-0.2527932822704315,
-0.20210854709148407,
-0.09016355872154236,
0.5134826898574829,
0.32467177510261536,
-0.6254410743713379,
-0.7673614621162415,
0.11474209278821945,
-0.7949007153511047,
0.3137490153312683,
0.18649178743362427,
-0.1980753242969513,
0.403460294008255,
0.5425417423248291,
-1.1369119882583618,
0.007851595059037209,
-0.055398885160684586,
-0.434337854385376,
0.5221485495567322,
-0.008846326731145382,
0.11505357921123505,
-1.320167899131775,
0.04016941040754318,
-0.08303932100534439,
-0.0936063677072525,
-0.7090139985084534,
0.11399184912443161,
0.42066264152526855,
-0.201408252120018,
-0.3153828978538513,
-0.20920422673225403,
-0.668337881565094,
-0.006855917163193226,
0.3362487256526947,
0.06233828142285347,
0.09272132068872452,
0.5680925250053406,
-0.039270974695682526,
0.6936256289482117,
0.5126023292541504,
-0.6203977465629578,
0.35826200246810913,
0.33289188146591187,
-0.074715755879879,
1.285141110420227,
-0.41403383016586304,
0.08921739459037781,
-0.1775674819946289,
0.4626404643058777,
-0.9541797041893005,
-0.33351564407348633,
0.28828752040863037,
-0.219136580824852,
0.4580029845237732,
-0.34058359265327454,
-0.6334604620933533,
-0.22779278457164764,
0.03280103579163551,
0.2057523876428604,
-0.15433426201343536,
-0.4137008786201477,
1.164201021194458,
0.3178168833255768,
0.012726990506052971,
-0.846056342124939,
-0.5503572225570679,
0.09346400946378708,
-0.11814118921756744,
-0.4839833974838257,
0.4761452078819275,
0.2005307674407959,
0.16058668494224548,
-0.08270340412855148,
-0.36481714248657227,
-0.4009615182876587,
-0.14578744769096375,
0.2895609140396118,
0.2550121247768402,
-0.06348628550767899,
0.2956959009170532,
0.40251925587654114,
0.011623215861618519,
0.04031344875693321,
-0.320862740278244,
0.436762273311615,
-0.02685968577861786,
-0.35028088092803955,
-0.2799901068210602,
0.6592584848403931,
0.6123069524765015,
-0.6120749115943909,
0.7219538688659668,
0.37463557720184326,
-0.3937220871448517,
-0.1732601374387741,
-0.6422674059867859,
-0.18692666292190552,
-0.41808268427848816,
0.4092855155467987,
-0.8569470047950745,
-0.876158595085144,
0.24718010425567627,
-0.11675845831632614,
-0.06022780016064644,
0.6956414580345154,
0.08582992106676102,
-0.36272546648979187,
0.9235936999320984,
0.3202991485595703,
0.5180561542510986,
0.05255310609936714,
-0.0040149386040866375,
0.2136358916759491,
-0.8008061647415161,
-0.5633677244186401,
-0.6476342082023621,
0.2918858528137207,
-0.1119578555226326,
-0.4511265456676483,
0.14878079295158386,
-0.2535564601421356,
-0.5246881246566772,
0.6278948187828064,
-0.6099389791488647,
0.6519860625267029,
0.2778782844543457,
0.20106379687786102,
0.35027849674224854,
0.008312146179378033,
-0.116836316883564,
-0.13363833725452423,
-0.47777020931243896,
-0.022621504962444305,
0.9238420724868774,
-0.3637423515319824,
0.4365820288658142,
0.24282272160053253,
0.5213919878005981,
0.041109904646873474,
-0.08461716771125793,
-0.43411752581596375,
0.5463752150535583,
-0.26025211811065674,
-0.8945996165275574,
-0.12354064732789993,
-0.5932559967041016,
-0.7413439154624939,
0.47764846682548523,
-0.7363885045051575,
-0.4076941907405853,
0.040492091327905655,
0.205496147274971,
-0.12496358156204224,
0.17755454778671265,
-0.6185455322265625,
1.0409133434295654,
-0.17323940992355347,
-0.5318721532821655,
-0.08117500692605972,
-0.9655981659889221,
0.25217610597610474,
-0.11021935939788818,
0.26083654165267944,
0.04532669112086296,
-0.0903804823756218,
0.4473109245300293,
-0.26239147782325745,
0.6800122857093811,
-0.12085531651973724,
0.17903392016887665,
-0.02670411765575409,
0.3517591655254364,
0.6274169683456421,
-0.35535842180252075,
-0.12798359990119934,
-0.014653539285063744,
0.28687584400177,
-0.3427736461162567,
-0.49560466408729553,
0.5886510610580444,
-0.2923460602760315,
-0.46143242716789246,
-0.4980691075325012,
-0.7202832102775574,
-0.4066621959209442,
0.49467846751213074,
0.15469850599765778,
0.29378044605255127,
0.07452244311571121,
0.36278197169303894,
0.6173754334449768,
0.2172275185585022,
0.011096454225480556,
0.5562114715576172,
0.10742931813001633,
-0.4001260995864868,
0.9326233267784119,
0.3024817705154419,
0.2264070063829422,
0.5921381115913391,
-0.25673407316207886,
-0.3933998942375183,
-0.4770963490009308,
-0.6400208473205566,
0.17977017164230347,
-0.5403091907501221,
-0.5314836502075195,
-0.7965500950813293,
0.18336348235607147,
-0.28550514578819275,
0.19227978587150574,
-0.2605414092540741,
-0.6042158007621765,
-0.2761196792125702,
0.020327525213360786,
0.23926040530204773,
0.5259426236152649,
0.6421180367469788,
0.23807866871356964,
-0.7533828020095825,
0.3121456801891327,
0.12596715986728668,
0.6430350542068481,
-0.32537513971328735,
-0.09960741549730301,
-0.10362526029348373,
-0.25227728486061096,
-0.36141714453697205,
-0.9972149133682251,
-0.005581339821219444,
0.34966006875038147,
0.4321441054344177,
0.10889654606580734,
0.394422709941864,
0.7366425395011902,
-0.676366925239563,
0.5725297927856445,
0.16201187670230865,
-1.019349455833435,
0.5366923809051514,
-0.35880398750305176,
-0.09318172186613083,
0.5951246619224548,
0.4060727059841156,
-0.2082676887512207,
-0.35959672927856445,
-0.1983029842376709,
-0.8751891851425171,
0.7477085590362549,
0.16598311066627502,
-0.3302561044692993,
-0.1364438682794571,
0.47185176610946655,
0.33015334606170654,
0.3909495770931244,
-0.7434355020523071,
-0.43028926849365234,
-0.17983883619308472,
-0.33516624569892883,
0.30846694111824036,
-0.30355870723724365,
-0.28320351243019104,
-0.07876667380332947,
0.3026348948478699,
-0.29146355390548706,
0.01262451708316803,
-0.1131855845451355,
-0.39284300804138184,
-0.0655212253332138,
0.46229633688926697,
0.1836594194173813,
0.7012567520141602,
-0.1546897292137146,
0.26138317584991455,
0.3461833894252777,
-0.2856476902961731,
-0.17294469475746155,
0.3372570276260376,
0.0947938933968544,
-0.2248534858226776,
-0.10862964391708374,
0.48286864161491394,
0.006885632872581482,
-0.5659165382385254,
0.6010087132453918,
-0.07352116703987122,
-0.18748393654823303,
0.1224394217133522,
-0.06715457886457443,
0.3378220200538635,
0.08194618672132492,
0.4509398639202118,
0.18150028586387634,
0.24931973218917847,
-0.28889772295951843,
0.05310793220996857,
0.506693422794342,
-0.45936623215675354,
-0.0481729619204998,
0.882682740688324,
0.40749579668045044,
-0.21943902969360352,
0.5700554847717285,
-0.2053060382604599,
-0.5328988432884216,
0.2691769003868103,
0.7273148894309998,
0.3142482340335846,
-0.35890886187553406,
-0.17414039373397827,
0.3078559637069702,
0.3051426112651825,
-0.041048813611269,
0.6819218993186951,
-0.2823704779148102,
-0.3250950276851654,
-0.3930332064628601,
-0.28226178884506226,
-0.346607506275177,
-0.5011833906173706,
-0.6690424680709839,
0.3416280448436737,
-0.1821838915348053,
0.04355546087026596,
0.15164615213871002,
-0.20175105333328247,
-0.3794342577457428,
0.22471415996551514,
-0.69718337059021,
0.5862855911254883,
-0.7724024653434753,
0.8719164133071899,
0.553834855556488,
-0.45367729663848877,
-0.6395151019096375,
-0.3480011224746704,
-0.06874729692935944,
-0.3258756399154663,
0.41814228892326355,
0.14935332536697388,
-0.013319326564669609,
-0.011377004906535149,
-0.14175842702388763,
-0.6663593053817749,
1.0640101432800293,
0.580529510974884,
-0.39000383019447327,
-0.20527276396751404,
0.3804861903190613,
0.4205576479434967,
-0.35084179043769836,
0.10702557861804962,
0.46943292021751404,
0.13076558709144592,
-0.017756367102265358,
-0.8042510747909546,
0.40990594029426575,
-0.14189064502716064,
-0.17845430970191956,
0.8665177822113037,
-0.37883564829826355,
0.8957504630088806,
-0.25113382935523987,
-0.16374091804027557,
-0.30692341923713684,
0.6517377495765686,
0.16822530329227448,
0.4129674434661865,
0.7536216378211975,
0.4338357448577881,
0.6316975355148315,
-0.36210373044013977,
0.7232140898704529,
-0.3662550449371338,
0.26961737871170044,
1.2638074159622192,
-0.5447412729263306,
1.0157055854797363,
0.6769574880599976,
-0.3141281306743622,
0.5336509346961975,
0.4472762644290924,
0.06425552070140839,
0.380462646484375,
0.03873908519744873,
-0.1818864494562149,
-0.44742074608802795,
-0.19238734245300293,
-0.46771931648254395,
0.26627397537231445,
0.7159180045127869,
-0.15843771398067474,
-0.25732091069221497,
-0.29723161458969116,
-0.1253296583890915,
0.140407994389534,
0.052741266787052155,
0.8603305816650391,
-0.22579552233219147,
-0.5599069595336914,
0.30199921131134033,
-0.3313511312007904,
0.38845834136009216,
-0.5552271604537964,
-0.07941815257072449,
0.047079287469387054,
0.12542365491390228,
-0.515678346157074,
-0.8357338309288025,
0.485266774892807,
-0.29719534516334534,
-0.2123679667711258,
0.17270050942897797,
0.6261957287788391,
-0.78425532579422,
0.004679473582655191,
0.005240707658231258,
0.454318106174469,
-0.14617116749286652,
-0.28966736793518066,
-0.533379316329956,
-0.09942610561847687,
-0.11720236390829086,
-0.0017335006268694997,
0.45624348521232605,
0.65108722448349,
0.11408145725727081,
0.6312779784202576,
0.8000099062919617,
-0.1855769008398056,
0.03092951886355877,
-0.25225865840911865,
0.8722306489944458,
-0.6257450580596924,
-0.4380975663661957,
-0.5772055983543396,
0.5151429772377014,
-0.3940092623233795,
-0.10806309431791306,
0.611034095287323,
0.9151619076728821,
0.45085182785987854,
-0.3197306990623474,
0.4425925612449646,
-0.0922774076461792,
0.671695351600647,
-0.2621838450431824,
0.570612907409668,
-0.5002012252807617,
0.37671974301338196,
-0.12931956350803375,
-1.0747686624526978,
-0.6393738389015198,
0.30067557096481323,
0.144573375582695,
-0.29919934272766113,
1.064135193824768,
0.8033933043479919,
0.017906667664647102,
0.14039891958236694,
-0.09976111352443695,
0.10723508149385452,
0.2295868843793869,
0.4852510392665863,
0.6527212858200073,
-0.31542545557022095,
1.1557483673095703,
-0.13339461386203766,
0.03321380168199539,
-0.14623108506202698,
-0.8498591184616089,
-0.8478161096572876,
-0.8203108310699463,
-0.18038445711135864,
-0.6014269590377808,
0.35242247581481934,
0.922302782535553,
0.4849262535572052,
-0.674950897693634,
-0.25945061445236206,
-0.10106254369020462,
0.19660881161689758,
-0.551956057548523,
-0.19319604337215424,
0.7542791962623596,
-0.4752744734287262,
-0.4272165894508362,
0.12318352609872818,
0.4322770833969116,
-0.42112839221954346,
0.19192229211330414,
0.4322825074195862,
-0.3450038433074951,
-0.1452660858631134,
0.9629905223846436,
0.07147849351167679,
-0.612392783164978,
-0.12011921405792236,
0.09395958483219147,
-0.4185066521167755,
0.015602143481373787,
0.6221228241920471,
-0.35766667127609253,
0.35450679063796997,
0.4679431915283203,
0.5754061341285706,
0.6633369326591492,
-0.2046438753604889,
0.30290675163269043,
-0.830077588558197,
-0.37258201837539673,
0.182863250374794,
0.36543989181518555,
0.28780192136764526,
-0.4427884817123413,
0.6281357407569885,
0.3530421555042267,
-0.4719947576522827,
-0.8860477209091187,
0.3173302710056305,
-1.2562233209609985,
-0.18456481397151947,
0.8960089683532715,
0.10140862315893173,
-0.2649539113044739,
-0.6470200419425964,
-0.39157822728157043,
0.20985311269760132,
-0.3180233836174011,
0.6099424958229065,
0.38967615365982056,
-0.2644060552120209,
0.025784190744161606,
-0.2102832943201065,
0.6581708788871765,
0.4049779176712036,
-0.9521204233169556,
0.494482159614563,
0.5954546332359314,
0.4011537730693817,
0.0681982934474945,
0.2637048363685608,
-0.2010771632194519,
0.28439587354660034,
-0.0593753419816494,
0.002731899730861187,
-0.1029914990067482,
-0.21800458431243896,
0.2174401879310608,
0.5797326564788818,
-0.24061448872089386,
-0.199081152677536
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09705v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09705v1
|
A Novel Nuanced Conversation Evaluation Framework for Large Language Models in Mental Health
| 2024-03-08T23:46:37 | 2024-03-08T23:46:37 |
Alexander Marrapese, Basem Suleiman, Imdad Ullah, Juno Kim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.ET
|
Understanding the conversation abilities of Large Language Models (LLMs) can
help lead to its more cautious and appropriate deployment. This is especially
important for safety-critical domains like mental health, where someone's life
may depend on the exact wording of a response to an urgent question. In this
paper, we propose a novel framework for evaluating the nuanced conversation
abilities of LLMs. Within it, we develop a series of quantitative metrics
developed from literature on using psychotherapy conversation analysis
literature. While we ensure that our framework and metrics are transferable by
researchers to relevant adjacent domains, we apply them to the mental health
field. We use our framework to evaluate several popular frontier LLMs,
including some GPT and Llama models, through a verified mental health dataset.
Our results show that GPT4 Turbo can perform significantly more similarly to
verified therapists than other selected LLMs. We conduct additional analysis to
examine how LLM conversation performance varies across specific mental health
topics. Our results indicate that GPT4 Turbo performs well in achieving high
correlation with verified therapists in particular topics such as Parenting and
Relationships. We believe our contributions will help researchers develop
better LLMs that, in turn, will more positively support people's lives.
|
[
-0.3348706364631653,
-0.8698208928108215,
0.9314388632774353,
0.4029069244861603,
-0.1323927789926529,
0.28618377447128296,
-0.4573352038860321,
-0.3736100196838379,
0.05684966593980789,
0.3555929660797119,
-0.5132953524589539,
-0.5595266222953796,
-0.6854040622711182,
0.00198534713126719,
-0.31115904450416565,
1.0933939218521118,
0.2726295292377472,
0.2046031951904297,
-0.1350512057542801,
0.003954168409109116,
-0.579250156879425,
-0.4512415826320648,
-0.8097733855247498,
-0.37226247787475586,
0.4579176902770996,
0.1761021614074707,
0.9423458576202393,
0.1457659900188446,
0.6745941638946533,
0.30296459794044495,
-0.33290085196495056,
-0.08973310142755508,
-0.7081709504127502,
0.09035566449165344,
-0.19091375172138214,
-0.3297047019004822,
-0.8602687120437622,
-0.27976667881011963,
0.4566906988620758,
0.8607277870178223,
-0.3408821225166321,
0.03732147440314293,
0.22278252243995667,
0.27907609939575195,
-0.3781122863292694,
0.22371523082256317,
-0.6958174705505371,
0.1898890733718872,
0.08083270490169525,
-0.14761093258857727,
-0.2293573021888733,
-0.4018270671367645,
0.06611865758895874,
-0.20113839209079742,
-0.016476068645715714,
-0.3078901469707489,
0.4922015070915222,
0.11472000926733017,
-0.7015237212181091,
0.03897428512573242,
-0.7825380563735962,
0.4987258017063141,
-1.1885294914245605,
0.2943296432495117,
0.35022854804992676,
0.3666171133518219,
-0.38600796461105347,
-0.6462279558181763,
-0.40448781847953796,
-0.08401086926460266,
0.06885388493537903,
0.026322366669774055,
-0.3089061677455902,
0.2768930196762085,
0.30540016293525696,
0.49125632643699646,
-0.4814399480819702,
0.13485951721668243,
-0.10923517495393753,
-0.026261379942297935,
0.5120983123779297,
0.6415531635284424,
0.27005118131637573,
0.12400344759225845,
-0.039316024631261826,
0.2841005027294159,
-0.34212490916252136,
-0.037388939410448074,
-0.1351853311061859,
0.05284646153450012,
-0.4218860864639282,
0.3481666147708893,
-0.16708512604236603,
0.47496864199638367,
0.02796921506524086,
-0.6545590758323669,
0.13982592523097992,
-0.2361585646867752,
-0.09345574676990509,
-0.25071534514427185,
0.9688566327095032,
0.7817644476890564,
0.24275030195713043,
-0.3839070796966553,
-0.010633145458996296,
-0.1401551216840744,
0.35742202401161194,
-1.1226969957351685,
-0.0534408837556839,
0.2103247344493866,
-0.2653791308403015,
-0.15638549625873566,
-0.2593925893306732,
-0.740479052066803,
-0.5939696431159973,
-0.08429780602455139,
0.03315213695168495,
-0.5363278985023499,
-0.5700815916061401,
0.33087119460105896,
0.15589825809001923,
0.26776644587516785,
0.26574549078941345,
-0.9127732515335083,
0.3166731595993042,
1.167281150817871,
1.0153452157974243,
-0.040008656680583954,
-0.039473503828048706,
-0.4224410951137543,
0.007565733976662159,
-0.41366031765937805,
0.7244794964790344,
-0.5715623497962952,
-0.4723283350467682,
0.044820576906204224,
-0.14550600945949554,
0.0092729851603508,
-0.20128141343593597,
0.5554941296577454,
-0.37146487832069397,
0.09015300124883652,
-0.3961999714374542,
-0.4664941132068634,
-0.09599396586418152,
0.5668134689331055,
-0.28957974910736084,
0.5694381594657898,
0.23641632497310638,
-0.9111260771751404,
0.2032371610403061,
-0.46820515394210815,
-0.44315269589424133,
0.47167471051216125,
-0.3598245680332184,
-0.20316292345523834,
0.15835098922252655,
-0.017645670101046562,
0.5840849280357361,
-0.6766107678413391,
0.7481510639190674,
-0.7851665616035461,
-0.49205759167671204,
0.6888150572776794,
-0.5710745453834534,
0.6529983878135681,
0.05977135896682739,
-0.3122608959674835,
0.0711032971739769,
-0.5463041663169861,
0.4492846429347992,
-0.05987561121582985,
-0.08588292449712753,
-0.15972666442394257,
-0.14779524505138397,
-0.08282168954610825,
0.25350221991539,
0.12949270009994507,
-0.40564388036727905,
-0.12424373626708984,
-0.6020944118499756,
0.722012996673584,
0.2916748523712158,
0.36712446808815,
0.08232242614030838,
-0.3009594976902008,
0.7335453629493713,
-0.3464987874031067,
0.20271116495132446,
-0.046774182468652725,
-0.5656558275222778,
-0.3382188677787781,
-0.5792036056518555,
0.007147526368498802,
0.4443627893924713,
-0.47556599974632263,
0.8046419024467468,
-0.4839108884334564,
-0.5767031908035278,
-0.4144325852394104,
0.03671671450138092,
0.36578214168548584,
0.4475839138031006,
0.0010691015049815178,
-0.34564340114593506,
-0.22374111413955688,
-0.8905031681060791,
-0.18257316946983337,
-0.31629493832588196,
-0.05761290341615677,
0.2911565899848938,
0.26611611247062683,
-0.403631329536438,
0.9202116131782532,
-0.45851966738700867,
0.10643386840820312,
-0.2611735165119171,
0.32257261872291565,
0.17407560348510742,
0.13650333881378174,
0.4754427969455719,
-0.3464715778827667,
-0.4236431419849396,
0.009039051830768585,
-0.8711471557617188,
-0.21015353500843048,
0.24611249566078186,
-0.11109131574630737,
-0.2783736288547516,
0.19131149351596832,
-0.585825502872467,
0.2905731499195099,
0.5561599731445312,
-0.37586238980293274,
0.33736979961395264,
-0.17944547533988953,
0.21543855965137482,
-0.915383517742157,
0.06692252308130264,
-0.025638366118073463,
-0.19151906669139862,
-0.8344604969024658,
-0.12461674213409424,
-0.20516735315322876,
-0.034690018743276596,
-0.32330968976020813,
0.17231003940105438,
-0.0743793472647667,
0.027518700808286667,
-0.3017796277999878,
0.09735754877328873,
-0.10408325493335724,
0.3646538257598877,
-0.19195185601711273,
0.7689213752746582,
0.4183740019798279,
-0.20017263293266296,
0.2877591848373413,
0.247791588306427,
-0.39568185806274414,
1.0515729188919067,
-0.7505502104759216,
0.427591472864151,
0.12045938521623611,
0.4246538281440735,
-1.0582705736160278,
-0.2264285832643509,
-0.02581099420785904,
-0.25465813279151917,
0.1181051954627037,
0.009835463017225266,
-0.3624744415283203,
-0.3021933138370514,
-0.21716903150081635,
0.4150618612766266,
0.20719055831432343,
0.05223030224442482,
0.24540184438228607,
0.6681830286979675,
-0.5376437902450562,
-0.34679892659187317,
-0.4332917630672455,
0.5108115077018738,
-0.664208710193634,
-0.6374374032020569,
0.21760240197181702,
-0.2966524362564087,
-0.38508448004722595,
-0.3265330493450165,
0.0594174787402153,
-0.21416574716567993,
0.45059844851493835,
0.2796402871608734,
0.11983571201562881,
-0.28764188289642334,
0.155144602060318,
-0.08878619968891144,
-0.18882934749126434,
0.5035036206245422,
0.19471870362758636,
0.5935651659965515,
-0.6007236242294312,
-0.31743404269218445,
-0.23738932609558105,
0.42983582615852356,
0.7278718948364258,
-0.15482044219970703,
0.7003078460693359,
0.7356125116348267,
-0.3865380883216858,
0.16259752213954926,
-0.6517835855484009,
-0.32500913739204407,
-0.44212090969085693,
0.6223688721656799,
-0.3503882884979248,
-1.1760233640670776,
0.476543128490448,
-0.14605261385440826,
0.03371310606598854,
0.04221184179186821,
0.7402135133743286,
0.06281764060258865,
1.2341585159301758,
0.6013434529304504,
-0.014400389976799488,
0.2367076873779297,
-0.08819802850484848,
0.7366520762443542,
-0.8583952188491821,
-0.051202382892370224,
-0.27293333411216736,
-0.12959378957748413,
-0.4883333146572113,
-0.4453265964984894,
0.5354769825935364,
-0.0082825543358922,
-0.5867148041725159,
-0.11553165316581726,
-0.3097813129425049,
0.20207419991493225,
-0.2515750229358673,
0.11765772104263306,
0.4993053078651428,
-0.22373376786708832,
-0.001051593804731965,
-0.4536311626434326,
-0.5169329643249512,
-0.8148897886276245,
0.8065084218978882,
0.7309318780899048,
0.6030824780464172,
0.3074733316898346,
0.3001188337802887,
0.06541784107685089,
0.6998916268348694,
-1.0188517570495605,
0.6716880798339844,
0.16718968749046326,
-0.648257851600647,
-0.4230167865753174,
-0.5352303981781006,
-0.8418067097663879,
0.3923795819282532,
-0.2760121822357178,
-1.141221046447754,
-0.1911264955997467,
-0.34589555859565735,
-0.521725058555603,
0.1784777194261551,
-0.3567875921726227,
0.7873315215110779,
-0.5228075385093689,
-0.20142734050750732,
-0.2976515293121338,
-0.5931639671325684,
0.7000383138656616,
-0.504840075969696,
0.19505734741687775,
-0.6448045372962952,
-0.054929979145526886,
0.7246794104576111,
-0.21568894386291504,
0.7684678435325623,
0.04715779423713684,
-0.39119839668273926,
-0.09915001690387726,
0.051728446036577225,
0.024231182411313057,
0.2417220175266266,
-0.21224156022071838,
0.32835862040519714,
0.40183889865875244,
-0.07778970897197723,
-0.9996483325958252,
0.7004121541976929,
-0.6138143539428711,
-0.8176459074020386,
-0.24029992520809174,
-0.6392950415611267,
-0.7728416919708252,
0.23558837175369263,
-0.06551869213581085,
0.19421274960041046,
-0.5692520141601562,
0.39228108525276184,
0.5309388637542725,
-0.3712216317653656,
0.10614368319511414,
0.9531859755516052,
-0.38935211300849915,
-0.5398568511009216,
0.5269404053688049,
-0.021787377074360847,
0.1771969497203827,
0.1306350976228714,
0.35663101077079773,
-0.23450298607349396,
-0.4953409731388092,
-0.06241605430841446,
0.46889954805374146,
-0.7431193590164185,
-0.3373185694217682,
-0.7738444805145264,
-0.4581926465034485,
-0.5001517534255981,
-0.020138483494520187,
-0.3257232904434204,
-0.07934169471263885,
0.15162105858325958,
-0.36958998441696167,
0.5424588918685913,
0.7085705399513245,
0.16892334818840027,
0.39988771080970764,
-0.7348482012748718,
0.056848108768463135,
0.33714818954467773,
0.5263347029685974,
0.2696625888347626,
-0.6546903252601624,
-0.21057480573654175,
0.12646673619747162,
-0.40166527032852173,
-1.0045298337936401,
0.46073606610298157,
0.03546742722392082,
0.55816251039505,
0.5634720325469971,
0.17157195508480072,
0.869867205619812,
-0.5113618969917297,
0.6683374643325806,
0.3439652621746063,
-0.9039143919944763,
0.3262103796005249,
-0.4551985561847687,
0.18797454237937927,
0.866253137588501,
0.23851823806762695,
-0.6815627813339233,
-0.49503472447395325,
-0.7783656716346741,
-0.847709059715271,
0.443593829870224,
0.1650351583957672,
0.3346962332725525,
-0.023655245080590248,
0.3539062738418579,
-0.2058495283126831,
0.35513386130332947,
-0.49496740102767944,
-0.0644063800573349,
0.20706439018249512,
-0.26369890570640564,
-0.10346369445323944,
-0.4366118311882019,
-0.5947332382202148,
-0.2568911910057068,
0.38576287031173706,
-0.21705873310565948,
0.4140129089355469,
-0.21684299409389496,
0.37025126814842224,
-0.07236242294311523,
0.5767615437507629,
0.30726248025894165,
0.6683463454246521,
-0.430448055267334,
0.256335586309433,
0.47072935104370117,
-0.3473358154296875,
0.29520753026008606,
-0.03591814637184143,
0.28405895829200745,
-0.2568743824958801,
0.38993361592292786,
0.7123132944107056,
0.5778008699417114,
-0.6921406984329224,
0.7185564637184143,
-0.26566752791404724,
0.026178253814578056,
-0.11184704303741455,
0.19018590450286865,
0.3629777729511261,
0.3735980689525604,
-0.02781996689736843,
-0.41542482376098633,
0.3213636577129364,
-0.5446194410324097,
0.20414680242538452,
0.5105910301208496,
-0.43860453367233276,
-0.40696898102760315,
0.2649640440940857,
0.288446843624115,
-0.6040176153182983,
0.4973662793636322,
-0.02195882983505726,
-0.36577093601226807,
0.3904651403427124,
0.7492570281028748,
0.9594146013259888,
-0.08162172883749008,
0.1994779258966446,
0.11142302304506302,
0.15743035078048706,
-0.06536450982093811,
0.17224904894828796,
0.01870952732861042,
-0.7738626003265381,
-0.5735176205635071,
-0.40395987033843994,
-0.6364510655403137,
0.5725603699684143,
-0.919724702835083,
-0.01789088360965252,
-0.5030052661895752,
-0.7987545132637024,
-0.09617912769317627,
0.11756054311990738,
-0.678135097026825,
-0.004961072467267513,
0.30334359407424927,
0.6321588158607483,
-0.8159265518188477,
0.7468580603599548,
0.5869730114936829,
0.0437547042965889,
-0.7809668183326721,
0.1772041767835617,
0.10991954803466797,
-0.704233705997467,
0.22404631972312927,
0.22921858727931976,
-0.34712278842926025,
-0.11564832180738449,
-0.2598702013492584,
-0.7764520049095154,
1.1681759357452393,
0.9268106818199158,
-0.3936633765697479,
0.05137940123677254,
0.323893666267395,
0.9340701699256897,
-0.4489748179912567,
0.6966123580932617,
0.9384583830833435,
0.507634699344635,
0.24225744605064392,
-1.013469934463501,
0.1287534236907959,
-0.28604233264923096,
0.21867644786834717,
-0.24417522549629211,
-0.7753400206565857,
0.31632134318351746,
-0.176918625831604,
-0.23768112063407898,
0.02295871451497078,
0.5657709836959839,
0.5642068982124329,
0.3586074709892273,
0.45051029324531555,
0.3572777509689331,
0.913187563419342,
0.07878938317298889,
0.8307496309280396,
-0.5940365195274353,
0.26622602343559265,
1.229219675064087,
-0.664013683795929,
0.7627866268157959,
0.13483618199825287,
-0.39646151661872864,
0.22152912616729736,
0.31766074895858765,
0.21994058787822723,
0.2601624131202698,
0.3060583472251892,
-0.38187089562416077,
-0.246906116604805,
-0.21615910530090332,
-0.4159415662288666,
0.4704627990722656,
0.6624988913536072,
-0.1341785341501236,
-0.16921959817409515,
-0.0009518678998574615,
0.4814205765724182,
-0.048830680549144745,
0.13644039630889893,
0.7997214794158936,
0.528070867061615,
-0.5538591146469116,
0.6164909601211548,
0.15897689759731293,
0.44239333271980286,
-0.5738995671272278,
0.13345852494239807,
-0.39437490701675415,
0.12090256065130234,
-0.24413028359413147,
-0.9655167460441589,
0.42377281188964844,
0.27241021394729614,
0.0651407316327095,
-0.04947146400809288,
0.5093973278999329,
-0.284003347158432,
-0.5048246383666992,
0.42042604088783264,
0.6308538317680359,
0.3442666232585907,
-0.03089793398976326,
-0.8019526600837708,
0.17751041054725647,
-0.1755426824092865,
-0.1606689840555191,
0.55301433801651,
0.9286976456642151,
0.06183353438973427,
0.710753321647644,
0.3640962243080139,
0.22713860869407654,
-0.4230313301086426,
0.25612953305244446,
0.7416502833366394,
-0.7798096537590027,
-0.497342973947525,
-0.8217730522155762,
0.34379807114601135,
-0.13669465482234955,
-0.3606872260570526,
0.8333017826080322,
0.2539338171482086,
0.0901499018073082,
0.43344712257385254,
0.6985614895820618,
0.2619258463382721,
0.3108313977718353,
-0.1458955556154251,
0.6030803918838501,
-0.07041607797145844,
0.5485775470733643,
-0.4074598550796509,
-0.7824966907501221,
-0.34935253858566284,
0.8311386108398438,
-0.7656944990158081,
0.0820092260837555,
0.6332407593727112,
0.846716046333313,
0.20271672308444977,
0.29569971561431885,
0.6078503131866455,
0.3508879244327545,
0.7250856757164001,
0.7458362579345703,
1.0382317304611206,
-0.05796302482485771,
0.2248484492301941,
-0.07076133042573929,
-0.36071813106536865,
0.015186790376901627,
-1.0226401090621948,
-0.9136318564414978,
-0.22336392104625702,
-0.3645297586917877,
-0.3098753094673157,
-0.04071260616183281,
0.7948383092880249,
0.6850948333740234,
-0.4537270963191986,
-0.27822524309158325,
0.22603757679462433,
-0.09586907178163528,
-0.1938190460205078,
-0.2670325040817261,
-0.000571021402720362,
-0.18051129579544067,
-0.28778889775276184,
0.35091421008110046,
0.5913217663764954,
-0.12422570586204529,
-0.5526683330535889,
-0.062251608818769455,
0.26004427671432495,
0.23623651266098022,
0.6612786650657654,
-0.002810735022649169,
-0.6130544543266296,
-0.2071608006954193,
-0.33475032448768616,
-0.3023712933063507,
0.22021205723285675,
0.8921035528182983,
-0.48640647530555725,
0.18906986713409424,
0.11792175471782684,
0.7419750094413757,
0.28273284435272217,
-0.11173612624406815,
0.6953848600387573,
-0.328709214925766,
0.0015382980927824974,
0.39462748169898987,
0.27750638127326965,
0.5785459876060486,
-0.4889424741268158,
0.5259695053100586,
-0.045088991522789,
-0.591313898563385,
-0.8835152983665466,
0.055291954427957535,
-0.9407925605773926,
-0.00001734606848913245,
1.3994090557098389,
-0.44953399896621704,
0.08489829301834106,
-0.35221511125564575,
-0.25240787863731384,
0.07945379614830017,
-0.36755719780921936,
0.8887858986854553,
0.6987072229385376,
-0.08162444829940796,
-0.2213028520345688,
-0.7585906982421875,
0.27293500304222107,
0.33613118529319763,
-0.8151347637176514,
0.18109449744224548,
0.3189079761505127,
0.43334832787513733,
-0.06802841275930405,
0.9980989694595337,
-0.2758379280567169,
-0.002462988020852208,
-0.333447128534317,
-0.1694098860025406,
0.1820698380470276,
0.013489083386957645,
-0.5206462144851685,
0.14096495509147644,
0.3156300485134125,
0.5008984208106995
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.05720v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.05720v1
|
A Benchmark of Domain-Adapted Large Language Models for Generating Brief Hospital Course Summaries
| 2024-03-08T23:17:55 | 2024-03-08T23:17:55 |
Asad Aali, Dave Van Veen, Yamin Ishraq Arefeen, Jason Hom, Christian Bluethgen, Eduardo Pontes Reis, Sergios Gatidis, Namuun Clifford, Joseph Daws, Arash S. Tehrani, Jangwon Kim, Akshay S. Chaudhari
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Brief hospital course (BHC) summaries are common clinical documents generated
by summarizing clinical notes. While large language models (LLMs) depict
remarkable capabilities in automating real-world tasks, their capabilities for
healthcare applications such as BHC synthesis have not been shown. To enable
the adaptation of LLMs for BHC synthesis, we introduce a novel benchmark
consisting of a pre-processed dataset extracted from MIMIC-IV notes,
encapsulating clinical note, and brief hospital course (BHC) pairs. We assess
the performance of two general-purpose LLMs and three healthcare-adapted LLMs
to improve BHC synthesis from clinical notes. Using clinical notes as input for
generating BHCs, we apply prompting-based (using in-context learning) and
fine-tuning-based adaptation strategies to three open-source LLMs
(Clinical-T5-Large, Llama2-13B, FLAN-UL2) and two proprietary LLMs (GPT-3.5,
GPT-4). We quantitatively evaluate the performance of these LLMs across varying
context-length inputs using conventional natural language similarity metrics.
We further perform a qualitative study where five diverse clinicians blindly
compare clinician-written BHCs and two LLM-generated BHCs for 30 samples across
metrics of comprehensiveness, conciseness, factual correctness, and fluency.
Overall, we present a new benchmark and pre-processed dataset for using LLMs in
BHC synthesis from clinical notes. We observe high-quality summarization
performance for both in-context proprietary and fine-tuned open-source LLMs
using both quantitative metrics and a qualitative clinical reader study. We
propose our work as a benchmark to motivate future works to adapt and assess
the performance of LLMs in BHC synthesis.
|
[
-0.020696792751550674,
-0.6026244759559631,
0.8714699745178223,
0.08002906292676926,
-0.1699363738298416,
-0.04791698977351189,
-0.5369620323181152,
-0.38267770409584045,
0.11144860088825226,
0.4469066262245178,
-0.34672972559928894,
-0.81809002161026,
-0.28941279649734497,
0.30357542634010315,
-0.22263218462467194,
1.0157713890075684,
-0.24288374185562134,
0.08060841262340546,
-0.1648901402950287,
-0.3636997640132904,
-0.3437429666519165,
-0.5052417516708374,
-0.32655587792396545,
-0.15085594356060028,
0.6343294382095337,
0.3688192665576935,
0.3681781589984894,
0.4933243691921234,
0.6815129518508911,
0.18989714980125427,
0.07879221439361572,
0.1801266074180603,
-0.4111292362213135,
0.09039779007434845,
-0.16039703786373138,
-0.2427758425474167,
-0.8196941018104553,
-0.2041395604610443,
0.9213272929191589,
0.8347374200820923,
-0.1298770010471344,
0.341814249753952,
0.0283245500177145,
0.7828195095062256,
-0.6880019307136536,
0.07819795608520508,
-0.6430268287658691,
-0.08176365494728088,
-0.1178952306509018,
-0.38195618987083435,
-0.6011322736740112,
-0.5309712886810303,
0.34764379262924194,
-0.4685256779193878,
0.37795546650886536,
0.07760442048311234,
0.6503480076789856,
-0.12231927365064621,
-0.1611025035381317,
-0.5620216131210327,
-0.3761892020702362,
0.6423262357711792,
-1.1593225002288818,
0.26968738436698914,
-0.018128840252757072,
0.5946125984191895,
-0.18925544619560242,
-0.9260189533233643,
-0.33329519629478455,
-0.32993221282958984,
-0.10154221951961517,
0.3608599305152893,
-0.03806117922067642,
0.16412734985351562,
0.4097687900066376,
0.4603419601917267,
-0.6671715974807739,
0.13935726881027222,
-0.29862770438194275,
-0.19999577105045319,
0.5545178651809692,
0.5187452435493469,
0.06359981745481491,
-0.15503282845020294,
0.024994684383273125,
-0.027725404128432274,
-0.8974239826202393,
-0.01954754628241062,
-0.14388775825500488,
0.3568326532840729,
-0.3604534864425659,
0.46973735094070435,
-0.07821853458881378,
0.5782628655433655,
-0.19205698370933533,
-0.5653366446495056,
0.2517739534378052,
-0.21329492330551147,
-0.41847968101501465,
0.24952760338783264,
0.8297176957130432,
0.7318383455276489,
0.2562658488750458,
-0.04783320426940918,
-0.20356109738349915,
-0.048766445368528366,
0.24480389058589935,
-0.8989306688308716,
-0.22845548391342163,
0.18440459668636322,
-0.6843969821929932,
-0.08843709528446198,
-0.544166088104248,
-0.5967062711715698,
-0.27456769347190857,
-0.4121822416782379,
0.2418500781059265,
-0.359247088432312,
0.23081372678279877,
0.10816982388496399,
0.11912255734205246,
0.08779889345169067,
0.5632458329200745,
-0.6883836984634399,
0.6205279231071472,
0.43625763058662415,
1.0312999486923218,
-0.4664691984653473,
-0.32242345809936523,
-0.7649613618850708,
0.4698121249675751,
-0.3418303430080414,
0.6496666073799133,
-0.057243749499320984,
-0.5403974652290344,
0.3297570049762726,
0.08554156124591827,
-0.004703621380031109,
-0.8533615469932556,
0.44969525933265686,
0.07001873105764389,
0.08848850429058075,
-0.036560263484716415,
-0.6796647906303406,
0.13970129191875458,
0.14178410172462463,
-0.4533945620059967,
0.47830256819725037,
0.49824464321136475,
-0.6353157758712769,
0.39941367506980896,
-0.30919066071510315,
-0.8295914530754089,
0.014484621584415436,
-0.12054897099733353,
-0.5225405693054199,
0.3423095643520355,
0.25951293110847473,
0.5356021523475647,
-0.4519541263580322,
0.26629939675331116,
-0.0920790284872055,
-0.524695634841919,
0.23836873471736908,
-0.11377239972352982,
0.44104883074760437,
-0.042812466621398926,
0.017715439200401306,
0.14952033758163452,
-0.9635173082351685,
-0.12565988302230835,
-0.14174886047840118,
-0.3752133846282959,
-0.20023459196090698,
-0.10322979092597961,
0.27748021483421326,
0.10291185975074768,
0.09078349173069,
-0.05792687088251114,
0.07705260813236237,
-0.4579131603240967,
0.37313106656074524,
0.4310101866722107,
0.2696415185928345,
0.1419478803873062,
-0.7665954828262329,
0.5469626188278198,
-0.06525043398141861,
-0.05167442932724953,
-0.31226223707199097,
-0.16925466060638428,
-0.445429265499115,
-0.4894181489944458,
0.19433359801769257,
0.35102832317352295,
-0.36833563446998596,
0.12115015089511871,
-0.41391369700431824,
-0.3858209550380707,
-0.7071853280067444,
-0.17966105043888092,
0.5345309376716614,
0.888976514339447,
0.6204093098640442,
-0.4715890884399414,
-0.6846730709075928,
-0.7781981825828552,
-0.3711015582084656,
-0.22132961452007294,
-0.1760052591562271,
0.4162605106830597,
0.32494571805000305,
-0.2778403162956238,
0.5215905904769897,
-0.5053589344024658,
-0.3845890164375305,
-0.3820265531539917,
-0.038078512996435165,
0.5321331024169922,
0.21851219236850739,
0.5539863705635071,
-0.040255628526210785,
-0.5283312201499939,
-0.007882739417254925,
-0.7398331761360168,
-0.2975503206253052,
-0.16701535880565643,
0.06881475448608398,
0.2862298786640167,
0.5398883819580078,
-0.4633203148841858,
0.41495010256767273,
0.3315697908401489,
0.23630847036838531,
0.8290214538574219,
-0.6352152228355408,
0.15182584524154663,
-1.2559490203857422,
0.41110795736312866,
-0.07800827920436859,
-0.3394398093223572,
-0.541938841342926,
-0.05361880734562874,
0.2124711275100708,
-0.034777648746967316,
-0.4176775813102722,
0.7131000757217407,
-0.5028098821640015,
-0.16574548184871674,
-0.0463232696056366,
0.3290180563926697,
0.01710663177073002,
0.30254262685775757,
0.11872103810310364,
0.47877737879753113,
0.5272495746612549,
-0.637247622013092,
0.12863273918628693,
0.44739195704460144,
-0.4947889447212219,
0.6345282793045044,
-0.6316569447517395,
-0.2163536101579666,
0.0886893942952156,
0.42324867844581604,
-0.6225574612617493,
-0.3291094899177551,
-0.2302790731191635,
-0.15784983336925507,
0.2764136791229248,
-0.1916697919368744,
-0.5521973371505737,
-0.26209694147109985,
-0.27830973267555237,
0.15147213637828827,
0.8111987709999084,
-0.06490235030651093,
0.35193702578544617,
0.08859970420598984,
-0.5035380721092224,
-0.11384128779172897,
-0.7836875915527344,
0.21040168404579163,
-0.022927330806851387,
-0.21730397641658783,
0.31646862626075745,
-0.27609017491340637,
-0.1605624109506607,
-0.28524935245513916,
-0.12391937524080276,
0.10248506814241409,
-0.051526520401239395,
0.20497499406337738,
0.27135396003723145,
-0.6712678074836731,
-0.08528084307909012,
0.40699610114097595,
0.13815240561962128,
0.15030480921268463,
-0.012239541858434677,
0.18356220424175262,
0.11624874919652939,
-0.2264394611120224,
-0.47622066736221313,
0.3400105834007263,
0.750946581363678,
0.05989069119095802,
0.38239777088165283,
0.12200015783309937,
-0.3738265931606293,
-0.3542047142982483,
-0.5571025609970093,
-0.15085874497890472,
-0.40323349833488464,
0.254239946603775,
-0.21222956478595734,
-0.8384941220283508,
0.4924534559249878,
-0.25165149569511414,
0.27483826875686646,
0.21988655626773834,
0.9506463408470154,
-0.02879238687455654,
0.5251466631889343,
0.1336105316877365,
-0.0972268134355545,
0.09985195845365524,
-0.03635738790035248,
-0.01326453872025013,
-0.9350481033325195,
0.018890516832470894,
-0.40682336688041687,
-0.02877301350235939,
-0.7767742276191711,
-0.40353119373321533,
0.8213940262794495,
-0.24506869912147522,
0.01206315215677023,
0.08766253292560577,
-0.12464489042758942,
0.07072321325540543,
0.23425951600074768,
0.08428635448217392,
0.3565709590911865,
-0.04479582980275154,
-0.16367512941360474,
-0.018607571721076965,
-0.48635798692703247,
-0.40931224822998047,
1.2590217590332031,
0.3106427788734436,
0.5370617508888245,
0.24394088983535767,
0.7061395049095154,
0.2679850161075592,
0.600829005241394,
-0.5108206868171692,
0.5252424478530884,
-0.34353572130203247,
-0.13972263038158417,
-0.1482398360967636,
-0.41998031735420227,
-0.7670968174934387,
0.09162174165248871,
-0.2667410969734192,
-0.483954519033432,
-0.28925368189811707,
0.22556711733341217,
-0.3609367609024048,
-0.05871790647506714,
-0.5789709091186523,
0.7473904490470886,
0.11831921339035034,
-0.4745047986507416,
-0.17937113344669342,
-0.7253841757774353,
0.22573420405387878,
-0.2025028020143509,
0.3385729491710663,
-0.12967322766780853,
0.10734977573156357,
0.2978721857070923,
-0.46643608808517456,
0.5387184619903564,
0.0489334762096405,
-0.07771395891904831,
0.12410437315702438,
0.2371443212032318,
0.3257431983947754,
0.3003847301006317,
-0.19208118319511414,
-0.07979050278663635,
0.037475839257240295,
-0.297516405582428,
-0.40299904346466064,
0.7801072001457214,
-0.4427311420440674,
-0.5874568223953247,
-0.1567380577325821,
-0.7236866354942322,
-0.5822872519493103,
0.3633255958557129,
0.27838781476020813,
1.000163197517395,
-0.530565083026886,
0.027843190357089043,
0.39553385972976685,
-0.43754976987838745,
0.43297064304351807,
0.8493940830230713,
-0.009055365808308125,
-0.46145641803741455,
0.6714053750038147,
-0.17024819552898407,
0.3474312126636505,
0.6884682178497314,
0.4158322215080261,
-0.18519936501979828,
-0.9605917930603027,
-0.629133939743042,
0.4361359179019928,
-0.6440596580505371,
-0.11568804085254669,
-0.7166401743888855,
-0.3765389025211334,
-0.7338557243347168,
-0.570780336856842,
0.020382272079586983,
-0.38651758432388306,
-0.1607935130596161,
0.0204082690179348,
0.25460267066955566,
0.548549234867096,
0.09967001527547836,
0.1692851036787033,
-0.9916234612464905,
0.4162602126598358,
0.04800496622920036,
0.29433736205101013,
0.04786863550543785,
-0.7154105305671692,
-0.3928217589855194,
-0.270073801279068,
-0.14822016656398773,
-0.6451704502105713,
0.34769949316978455,
0.21202543377876282,
0.4439001977443695,
0.17427320778369904,
-0.07717370986938477,
0.6422082781791687,
-0.9951667785644531,
0.7587202787399292,
0.2520735561847687,
-0.8760012984275818,
0.6786016225814819,
-0.5523109436035156,
0.6325234770774841,
0.8760613799095154,
0.283352792263031,
-0.4402731955051422,
-0.672358512878418,
-0.44048959016799927,
-0.7711682915687561,
0.5614316463470459,
0.16025884449481964,
-0.23977535963058472,
-0.03832945600152016,
0.3610362410545349,
0.27230721712112427,
0.30105242133140564,
-0.29433730244636536,
-0.14768359065055847,
0.1432478427886963,
-0.5006753206253052,
-0.3711096942424774,
-0.3382095396518707,
-0.0357477068901062,
-0.03131388500332832,
0.4761049151420593,
-0.24086232483386993,
-0.11509355157613754,
0.32418715953826904,
-0.2946138381958008,
-0.12102207541465759,
0.3098040223121643,
0.8079906702041626,
0.9950971603393555,
-0.5000081062316895,
0.029409147799015045,
0.2803962230682373,
-0.600122332572937,
-0.04559522122144699,
0.09711126238107681,
-0.16795489192008972,
0.34196069836616516,
0.8725638389587402,
0.6796624660491943,
0.4271189272403717,
-0.9978512525558472,
0.6020496487617493,
-0.16528929769992828,
-0.15962523221969604,
-0.18212313950061798,
0.11426569521427155,
-0.029263408854603767,
-0.13088667392730713,
-0.1326381415128708,
-0.29644525051116943,
0.4480656087398529,
-0.6742021441459656,
0.27551743388175964,
-0.14107578992843628,
-0.3390662968158722,
-0.39829879999160767,
0.5638322830200195,
0.08224612474441528,
-0.2061580866575241,
0.25020572543144226,
0.17897158861160278,
0.10109326243400574,
0.26348602771759033,
0.7054606080055237,
0.8636505007743835,
-0.2730630040168762,
0.059646811336278915,
0.6621124148368835,
0.029161619022488594,
-0.18175823986530304,
0.2939121425151825,
-0.004546926822513342,
-0.13671889901161194,
-0.3711470663547516,
-0.592018723487854,
-0.6874602437019348,
0.20581284165382385,
-0.8636960983276367,
0.417591392993927,
-0.6090601682662964,
0.08794243633747101,
0.14449359476566315,
-0.0864698514342308,
-0.4990459978580475,
0.3297134339809418,
-0.09899156540632248,
0.9911404848098755,
-0.6053041815757751,
0.6880700588226318,
0.7870849370956421,
-0.20709139108657837,
-0.683814525604248,
0.12832900881767273,
-0.096138134598732,
-0.5673863887786865,
-0.07382690161466599,
0.0009269607835449278,
0.13833415508270264,
-0.28515365719795227,
-0.0799383744597435,
-0.19452591240406036,
1.0033625364303589,
0.1975461095571518,
-0.9302685260772705,
-0.3235298693180084,
0.33190029859542847,
0.9092604517936707,
-0.4684559106826782,
0.2884041368961334,
0.5741795897483826,
0.06453579664230347,
-0.0680944174528122,
-1.181045413017273,
0.31809714436531067,
0.03796253353357315,
-0.07988053560256958,
-0.029507847502827644,
-0.5784545540809631,
0.5334757566452026,
-0.28162768483161926,
0.04939689487218857,
0.2904190123081207,
0.4139581322669983,
0.578078031539917,
0.62613445520401,
0.08102244138717651,
0.1908911168575287,
0.7083051800727844,
0.20061689615249634,
1.0423493385314941,
-0.27384883165359497,
0.010789155028760433,
1.3009488582611084,
-0.7435621619224548,
0.716386079788208,
0.3266146183013916,
-0.09695019572973251,
0.5770266056060791,
0.12326420843601227,
0.18989332020282745,
0.5827344655990601,
0.530173122882843,
-0.21170362830162048,
0.147516131401062,
0.032894570380449295,
-0.5152184963226318,
0.0776604488492012,
0.45502087473869324,
-0.5904891490936279,
-0.13196103274822235,
-0.1548563688993454,
0.12046191096305847,
0.2449728548526764,
-0.32790568470954895,
1.0411698818206787,
0.441325843334198,
-0.8451666235923767,
0.751420259475708,
-0.13559463620185852,
-0.024883998557925224,
-0.7491165995597839,
-0.019017348065972328,
-0.4312021732330322,
0.29174017906188965,
-0.08640065044164658,
-0.5485888719558716,
0.09703359752893448,
0.10138455033302307,
-0.3332885801792145,
-0.10499701648950577,
0.2801496684551239,
-0.4350501000881195,
-0.5170372724533081,
-0.015299919992685318,
0.30785518884658813,
0.1483220010995865,
0.31096595525741577,
-0.2596105933189392,
0.11129496991634369,
-0.12816967070102692,
0.09434938430786133,
0.4704418182373047,
0.8295350074768066,
-0.12247804552316666,
0.42300301790237427,
0.5027757287025452,
0.6621054410934448,
-0.31579962372779846,
0.5943934321403503,
0.7662988305091858,
-0.7135944366455078,
-0.593494176864624,
-0.6431080102920532,
0.2786773443222046,
-0.006061534862965345,
-0.5094633102416992,
0.5533702373504639,
0.8980618715286255,
0.6081162095069885,
-0.3031964898109436,
0.9507443308830261,
0.30258846282958984,
0.8627803921699524,
-0.7698708772659302,
0.7445583939552307,
-0.609636664390564,
0.11663582921028137,
-0.6398013234138489,
-0.6756771206855774,
-0.28415924310684204,
0.21300698816776276,
-0.03312792256474495,
-0.2777012586593628,
0.9295002818107605,
0.6173700094223022,
-0.07390502840280533,
-0.10248059034347534,
0.4373687207698822,
0.396973580121994,
0.422241747379303,
0.9344369173049927,
0.5797873139381409,
-0.29238492250442505,
0.20078425109386444,
-0.005148482043296099,
-0.29768654704093933,
-0.5062376260757446,
-1.0151340961456299,
-1.2119836807250977,
-0.46023112535476685,
-0.4224182665348053,
-0.4722445607185364,
0.29705286026000977,
0.8674671649932861,
0.472597599029541,
-1.0534768104553223,
-0.33387765288352966,
0.20439453423023224,
-0.17827585339546204,
-0.24190428853034973,
-0.1278761923313141,
0.7947576642036438,
-0.053120873868465424,
-0.31009551882743835,
0.38945698738098145,
0.619617223739624,
0.06777825206518173,
0.056803878396749496,
-0.01916561648249626,
0.11858868598937988,
0.11461598426103592,
0.6352958083152771,
0.006264573894441128,
-0.5922605395317078,
-0.1379377841949463,
-0.16701734066009521,
-0.3021788001060486,
0.12011905014514923,
1.2039179801940918,
-0.5054246783256531,
0.3424150347709656,
0.2667171061038971,
0.5257007479667664,
0.4701063632965088,
-0.23002202808856964,
0.5080319046974182,
-0.6503255367279053,
0.05601958930492401,
0.4101634621620178,
0.38591915369033813,
0.39545825123786926,
-0.07723464071750641,
0.2922753393650055,
0.14808501303195953,
-0.4045315384864807,
-0.9527091979980469,
0.11979955434799194,
-1.1929502487182617,
-0.08624937385320663,
1.1578395366668701,
-0.24082377552986145,
-0.2743590176105499,
-0.04785580933094025,
-0.26361945271492004,
0.22161880135536194,
-0.19731950759887695,
0.791570246219635,
0.2759104371070862,
-0.04243682324886322,
0.032310642302036285,
-0.5003125667572021,
0.6510525941848755,
0.129516139626503,
-0.985661506652832,
0.18815305829048157,
0.7251256108283997,
0.4118020832538605,
-0.28091251850128174,
1.0150514841079712,
-0.29610294103622437,
0.6432580351829529,
-0.3168601393699646,
-0.1147301197052002,
0.11939241737127304,
-0.20029282569885254,
-0.13983556628227234,
0.042816124856472015,
0.11734966188669205,
0.3139498829841614
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.05700v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.05700v1
|
DADIT: A Dataset for Demographic Classification of Italian Twitter Users and a Comparison of Prediction Methods
| 2024-03-08T22:18:13 | 2024-03-08T22:18:13 |
Lorenzo Lupo, Paul Bose, Mahyar Habibi, Dirk Hovy, Carlo Schwarz
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Social scientists increasingly use demographically stratified social media
data to study the attitudes, beliefs, and behavior of the general public. To
facilitate such analyses, we construct, validate, and release publicly the
representative DADIT dataset of 30M tweets of 20k Italian Twitter users, along
with their bios and profile pictures. We enrich the user data with high-quality
labels for gender, age, and location. DADIT enables us to train and compare the
performance of various state-of-the-art models for the prediction of the gender
and age of social media users. In particular, we investigate if tweets contain
valuable information for the task, since popular classifiers like M3 don't
leverage them. Our best XLM-based classifier improves upon the commonly used
competitor M3 by up to 53% F1. Especially for age prediction, classifiers
profit from including tweets as features. We also confirm these findings on a
German test set.
|
[
-0.40075698494911194,
-0.17224034667015076,
0.1980735808610916,
0.13314808905124664,
-0.336635947227478,
0.4331081509590149,
-0.0968010425567627,
-0.4157046675682068,
0.11637640744447708,
0.10323139280080795,
-0.6945008635520935,
-0.7354162335395813,
-0.7452009320259094,
-0.0729968249797821,
-0.41040128469467163,
0.5450116395950317,
0.29952195286750793,
0.37967509031295776,
-0.10548870265483856,
-0.0150262750685215,
-0.21587137877941132,
-0.23870053887367249,
-1.0807571411132812,
-0.14454945921897888,
0.5864161849021912,
0.565024197101593,
0.2915786802768707,
0.18296599388122559,
0.38014188408851624,
0.2646052837371826,
-0.19001051783561707,
0.23441429436206818,
-0.7001073956489563,
-0.09773949533700943,
-0.33129411935806274,
-0.48599010705947876,
-0.2727174162864685,
0.16850024461746216,
0.26260894536972046,
0.4125228822231293,
0.04753514379262924,
0.4535406231880188,
-0.15032066404819489,
0.6026028990745544,
-0.46936577558517456,
0.2399986833333969,
-0.4707367718219757,
0.05938352271914482,
-0.08775565028190613,
-0.440498411655426,
-0.23455941677093506,
-0.8155823945999146,
-0.16174563765525818,
0.06225581467151642,
0.5724388957023621,
0.007691037375479937,
0.5296340584754944,
0.015590481460094452,
-0.6322615146636963,
0.03638269752264023,
-0.8493912816047668,
0.5889295935630798,
-0.17820589244365692,
0.4350776970386505,
0.4840840697288513,
0.6544246673583984,
-0.1578541249036789,
-0.18985117971897125,
-0.3901931345462799,
-0.23684333264827728,
0.017635809257626534,
0.20237849652767181,
-0.03519846871495247,
-0.36565279960632324,
0.1561889797449112,
0.05755230784416199,
-0.4480057954788208,
0.035784561187028885,
-0.9106232523918152,
0.13918536901474,
0.9574095010757446,
-0.161875918507576,
0.5542436242103577,
0.0086073512211442,
-0.49591484665870667,
-0.17856810986995697,
-0.8286159038543701,
-0.14091360569000244,
0.6182630658149719,
0.2954680323600769,
-0.23442065715789795,
0.7300540208816528,
-0.16004511713981628,
0.15787017345428467,
0.15759827196598053,
0.037746611982584,
0.3748668432235718,
0.0934324637055397,
-0.0017953773494809866,
0.22649583220481873,
0.9263112545013428,
0.7662849426269531,
0.8202069997787476,
-0.20015256106853485,
-0.0841318890452385,
-0.09889478236436844,
0.16056939959526062,
-0.9728103876113892,
0.28765401244163513,
0.21623185276985168,
-0.2114655077457428,
-0.39218753576278687,
0.49754902720451355,
-0.650993824005127,
-0.5056908130645752,
-0.10683014988899231,
0.048200108110904694,
-0.5573936700820923,
-0.24391719698905945,
-0.20515020191669464,
-0.46173733472824097,
-0.28188061714172363,
0.7018512487411499,
-0.7257037162780762,
-0.0662715956568718,
0.708244264125824,
0.7957372069358826,
0.04457380995154381,
-0.012114564888179302,
-0.08404360711574554,
0.22006626427173615,
-0.5940811038017273,
0.8342720866203308,
-0.44306084513664246,
-0.6002569794654846,
0.06800363212823868,
-0.19209152460098267,
-0.24723561108112335,
-0.6581447124481201,
0.48360127210617065,
-0.4326995313167572,
0.3915988802909851,
-0.1884239912033081,
-0.41380736231803894,
-0.023338885977864265,
-0.1273098886013031,
-0.5549952387809753,
0.9573822021484375,
0.25728198885917664,
-0.8886422514915466,
0.9793860912322998,
-0.9169596433639526,
-0.21395893394947052,
0.2520397901535034,
-0.07439237833023071,
-0.2001180499792099,
0.21322712302207947,
0.07007282227277756,
0.7456932067871094,
-0.3931175172328949,
0.31833356618881226,
-0.5368294715881348,
-0.48395389318466187,
0.1873065084218979,
-0.13931095600128174,
1.1940639019012451,
0.5257208347320557,
-0.2359834462404251,
-0.09369568526744843,
-0.5205021500587463,
-0.383293092250824,
0.18909195065498352,
0.044973112642765045,
-0.23055291175842285,
0.07409980893135071,
0.12146136909723282,
0.19898168742656708,
0.008040942251682281,
-0.9406168460845947,
0.07663758844137192,
0.11922655999660492,
0.7797743082046509,
0.5697625875473022,
-0.006927119567990303,
0.22075560688972473,
-0.5406871438026428,
0.5517404079437256,
0.15485818684101105,
0.15536075830459595,
0.37924179434776306,
-0.3664882779121399,
-0.22799377143383026,
-0.32370176911354065,
0.3905448317527771,
0.6091695427894592,
-0.6278736591339111,
0.6522032618522644,
-0.656445324420929,
-0.9036115407943726,
-0.03505225107073784,
0.06626687943935394,
-0.058079637587070465,
0.2207854986190796,
-0.035890884697437286,
0.131389781832695,
-0.49592551589012146,
-0.9986274242401123,
0.08730921149253845,
-0.7672346234321594,
-0.3186008036136627,
0.3775321841239929,
0.6907566785812378,
-0.22213521599769592,
0.7964827418327332,
-0.3214077949523926,
-0.09999106824398041,
-0.35724809765815735,
0.4068925380706787,
-0.24060223996639252,
0.5811100006103516,
0.8358839750289917,
-1.2293667793273926,
-0.39464113116264343,
-0.004836388397961855,
-0.698913037776947,
-0.04136314615607262,
0.42604324221611023,
-0.21897371113300323,
-0.10019301623106003,
0.24163435399532318,
-0.44335874915122986,
0.33417510986328125,
0.2958323657512665,
-0.3878118097782135,
0.024004913866519928,
0.3371308445930481,
0.6264446973800659,
-1.349402904510498,
0.03630321845412254,
0.4498329758644104,
-0.4102820158004761,
-0.43773749470710754,
-0.2996119558811188,
0.06634760648012161,
-0.13037841022014618,
-0.7509705424308777,
0.5780358910560608,
0.02775428257882595,
0.0767773985862732,
0.14574335515499115,
-0.35331273078918457,
-0.5891537070274353,
-0.1517837941646576,
-0.31486982107162476,
1.3309218883514404,
0.18801340460777283,
-0.05180077254772186,
0.0842721238732338,
0.17370302975177765,
-0.3657224178314209,
0.5602211356163025,
-0.45695531368255615,
0.2707439363002777,
-0.40330925583839417,
0.2659088671207428,
-1.2747225761413574,
-0.38011470437049866,
0.2854198217391968,
-1.0719313621520996,
0.06261222064495087,
-0.20294934511184692,
-0.6913440227508545,
-0.5158587098121643,
-0.472916841506958,
0.11241110414266586,
0.5188320279121399,
-0.1754329651594162,
0.7738800644874573,
0.4621060788631439,
-0.2751081883907318,
-0.3610503673553467,
-0.5602497458457947,
0.05699140205979347,
-0.6224096417427063,
-0.6138355731964111,
0.1962885558605194,
0.05603509396314621,
-0.21258464455604553,
0.1364474594593048,
-0.0021065769251435995,
-0.36903050541877747,
0.23015464842319489,
0.40972840785980225,
0.22392331063747406,
-0.07525278627872467,
0.19774465262889862,
0.02689962461590767,
-0.05171120911836624,
-0.21651174128055573,
-0.007075222674757242,
0.757964551448822,
-0.0626884251832962,
0.15826423466205597,
-0.5212916135787964,
0.263966828584671,
0.5402851104736328,
0.15714885294437408,
1.028991937637329,
0.7393855452537537,
-0.5344420671463013,
-0.21003350615501404,
-0.4951322078704834,
-0.15687590837478638,
-0.3991377055644989,
-0.06945201754570007,
-0.2955673635005951,
-0.9561543464660645,
0.6054814457893372,
0.03392142429947853,
0.07549214363098145,
0.616132915019989,
0.3169407546520233,
-0.6157400608062744,
1.2305710315704346,
0.6346297860145569,
-0.055537156760692596,
0.6672847270965576,
-0.3916850984096527,
0.030841583386063576,
-0.2282831072807312,
-0.04186929017305374,
-0.7600674629211426,
-0.38538888096809387,
-0.7967161536216736,
-0.035080716013908386,
0.12483298778533936,
-0.1195899248123169,
-0.45370182394981384,
0.4609098434448242,
-0.19855175912380219,
0.44131413102149963,
0.66064453125,
0.2814667522907257,
-0.02675020694732666,
0.23243209719657898,
0.3451857268810272,
-0.08666954189538956,
-0.55113285779953,
-0.7248713970184326,
0.8809568285942078,
0.042911455035209656,
0.6161044836044312,
0.1780405193567276,
0.6750714182853699,
0.9263720512390137,
0.8702428936958313,
-0.5740095973014832,
0.647376298904419,
-0.7613770365715027,
-1.110504388809204,
-0.13385117053985596,
-0.8162923455238342,
-0.6118728518486023,
-0.2162148654460907,
-0.36243027448654175,
-0.9556171298027039,
0.3523704409599304,
0.11474625766277313,
-0.1632102131843567,
0.4076053500175476,
-1.0350912809371948,
0.4645596742630005,
-0.17381983995437622,
-0.3166640102863312,
-0.1858368068933487,
-0.371493399143219,
0.2541602551937103,
-0.24396111071109772,
-0.015796596184372902,
-0.6868103742599487,
-0.005744344554841518,
1.046939730644226,
-0.2022048681974411,
0.8897833228111267,
-0.3483932614326477,
0.4023016691207886,
0.025588393211364746,
-0.21344207227230072,
-0.3499637544155121,
-0.06310223042964935,
-0.23277245461940765,
0.33078238368034363,
0.13133041560649872,
-0.36375322937965393,
-0.35231512784957886,
0.552855372428894,
-0.8957533240318298,
-0.6573963165283203,
-0.4498153030872345,
-0.2055099904537201,
-0.26150500774383545,
0.1274769902229309,
0.3265286087989807,
0.19090425968170166,
-0.22847484052181244,
0.7192833423614502,
0.15743586421012878,
0.0565778911113739,
0.12902000546455383,
-0.057843223214149475,
0.029545245692133904,
-0.42080503702163696,
0.5195538997650146,
0.5239124894142151,
0.014918018132448196,
0.25450363755226135,
0.3090437054634094,
-0.3247353136539459,
-0.2952599823474884,
-0.4728710651397705,
0.20330318808555603,
-0.5333217978477478,
-0.10587820410728455,
-0.25806742906570435,
-0.3452381193637848,
-0.3870295286178589,
-0.13466300070285797,
-0.21345199644565582,
-0.4518912434577942,
0.05427880212664604,
-0.31094199419021606,
0.1850680708885193,
0.6274542212486267,
0.04710055887699127,
0.6961178183555603,
-0.38573500514030457,
0.12518250942230225,
0.18669869005680084,
0.18636098504066467,
-0.3415725529193878,
0.01745002530515194,
-0.002542148344218731,
0.05481129512190819,
-0.1572512984275818,
-0.899616003036499,
0.17153958976268768,
0.2379879504442215,
0.316996306180954,
0.6346125602722168,
0.10888614505529404,
0.5017752647399902,
-0.23320923745632172,
0.4841996729373932,
0.29012447595596313,
-0.5189650058746338,
0.6318261027336121,
-0.6829436421394348,
-0.3065212368965149,
0.9446467161178589,
0.7073569297790527,
-0.49139901995658875,
-0.18040530383586884,
-0.7015641927719116,
-0.6146443486213684,
0.7346269488334656,
0.38983088731765747,
0.343179851770401,
0.14620591700077057,
0.4371795058250427,
0.2495870143175125,
0.5382711291313171,
-0.10326588153839111,
-0.13086208701133728,
0.020031645894050598,
-0.6748661994934082,
-0.24835383892059326,
-0.3654022812843323,
-0.16131645441055298,
-0.3001983165740967,
0.4334896206855774,
0.10568227618932724,
0.6317634582519531,
-0.12288662046194077,
0.1526240110397339,
-0.30202338099479675,
0.06969106942415237,
0.40443432331085205,
1.3297908306121826,
-0.8706313967704773,
0.16123928129673004,
0.10450639575719833,
-0.44056737422943115,
0.44118446111679077,
0.1246316134929657,
-0.5947579741477966,
-0.08403471857309341,
0.3062889873981476,
0.5436358451843262,
-0.19468826055526733,
-0.5726166367530823,
0.4215485155582428,
-0.45552337169647217,
-0.4664551615715027,
-0.7382607460021973,
0.43110981583595276,
0.2819564640522003,
0.10628624260425568,
0.7274827361106873,
0.11705164611339569,
0.0796053484082222,
-0.7853999137878418,
0.1344861537218094,
0.10916215181350708,
-0.5641331672668457,
-0.44247329235076904,
0.9007145166397095,
0.1720614731311798,
-0.584969699382782,
0.2025749385356903,
0.009291206486523151,
-0.5779852867126465,
0.7449089884757996,
0.0659683421254158,
0.9372129440307617,
-0.3495302200317383,
0.6138849854469299,
0.39369848370552063,
0.1360761672258377,
-0.03235512971878052,
0.2278444766998291,
0.012273432686924934,
-1.145558476448059,
-0.013678820803761482,
-0.2875155806541443,
-0.3648182451725006,
-0.036968570202589035,
-0.5360947251319885,
0.5657753944396973,
-0.6855844259262085,
-0.7623205780982971,
0.5056287050247192,
0.047557707875967026,
-0.779037594795227,
0.4721604883670807,
0.050836533308029175,
1.0309107303619385,
-1.1908591985702515,
0.5510322451591492,
1.0602507591247559,
-0.3641955852508545,
-0.22358639538288116,
0.28156495094299316,
0.16876593232154846,
-0.7002854943275452,
0.9669578671455383,
0.45722055435180664,
-0.34165918827056885,
-0.08137645572423935,
-0.8578452467918396,
-0.28270530700683594,
0.9862635135650635,
0.4144872725009918,
-0.3080986738204956,
0.17622169852256775,
0.00563479820266366,
0.46808332204818726,
-0.6917678713798523,
0.35808175802230835,
0.3158371150493622,
0.3287700414657593,
0.46594300866127014,
-0.43441319465637207,
-0.3407164216041565,
-0.41883066296577454,
0.10760782659053802,
-0.009873208589851856,
-0.8708541393280029,
0.4989718794822693,
-0.0654243603348732,
-0.542575478553772,
-0.3604593575000763,
0.4765107333660126,
0.12755455076694489,
0.7010828852653503,
1.0987123250961304,
0.1492784470319748,
0.48978954553604126,
-0.48744744062423706,
0.8645044565200806,
-0.3598599433898926,
0.3648347854614258,
0.6523717641830444,
-0.15795105695724487,
0.8362205624580383,
0.17241822183132172,
-0.29605409502983093,
0.09974919259548187,
1.0075956583023071,
0.07243555039167404,
0.3400314152240753,
-0.23004724085330963,
-0.2358621507883072,
-0.14743107557296753,
-0.3595914840698242,
-0.18828146159648895,
0.27477529644966125,
0.2802966237068176,
-0.2468620091676712,
-0.07540547847747803,
0.07745664566755295,
0.5231651067733765,
-0.10008486360311508,
-0.12405087053775787,
0.7846938967704773,
-0.0727461650967598,
-0.21616016328334808,
0.08365348726511002,
-0.026005705818533897,
0.4418153166770935,
-0.2524765133857727,
0.2004317194223404,
-0.330305814743042,
0.19680887460708618,
-0.06928333640098572,
-0.8002548813819885,
0.29639312624931335,
0.1535636931657791,
0.12143120914697647,
-0.1271969974040985,
0.7886186838150024,
-0.23423954844474792,
-0.8929745554924011,
0.38720840215682983,
0.7546883225440979,
-0.03831388056278229,
0.07632344961166382,
-0.6123995780944824,
-0.44181352853775024,
0.053571417927742004,
-0.1307683140039444,
-0.1679937243461609,
0.17604561150074005,
-0.30436834692955017,
1.0297273397445679,
0.5372799634933472,
0.35745736956596375,
-0.03596866503357887,
0.09445793926715851,
0.7035925984382629,
-0.6439218521118164,
-0.32055214047431946,
-0.7712621688842773,
0.33400198817253113,
-0.4866524338722229,
-0.5213972926139832,
0.5240522027015686,
0.5558465123176575,
0.9676022529602051,
0.016787439584732056,
0.8433380722999573,
-0.3772246539592743,
0.7805455327033997,
-0.1383984088897705,
0.5997710824012756,
-0.8705459833145142,
-0.06693276017904282,
0.24648016691207886,
-0.8173523545265198,
-0.31662434339523315,
0.4607148766517639,
-0.7113615870475769,
0.49848276376724243,
0.35100239515304565,
0.5670258402824402,
-0.28125137090682983,
0.1705048829317093,
0.14642058312892914,
0.024264145642518997,
0.3443634808063507,
0.059320118278265,
0.8815170526504517,
-0.05938158556818962,
0.054865188896656036,
-0.5330802798271179,
-0.19767141342163086,
-0.5222840309143066,
-0.40602976083755493,
-1.2423018217086792,
-0.5811572670936584,
-0.15505284070968628,
-0.08569425344467163,
0.5833617448806763,
1.2684228420257568,
1.1057887077331543,
-1.0151304006576538,
-0.22910518944263458,
0.4142903983592987,
-0.06627636402845383,
-0.09946038573980331,
-0.21378353238105774,
0.29464828968048096,
0.283131867647171,
-0.9865093231201172,
-0.14785136282444,
-0.08504538983106613,
0.15303552150726318,
-0.05558576434850693,
0.2353595793247223,
-0.008711435832083225,
-0.024375000968575478,
0.44178810715675354,
-0.28330668807029724,
-0.16950227320194244,
-0.4658690392971039,
-0.0927203968167305,
-0.09015069901943207,
0.3279575705528259,
0.5878598690032959,
0.0074821170419454575,
-0.005430048331618309,
0.8810397386550903,
0.30158543586730957,
0.5717717409133911,
0.6210924983024597,
0.5835219025611877,
-0.4715300500392914,
0.12093253433704376,
0.2916402220726013,
0.43555331230163574,
0.44561856985092163,
-0.4320882558822632,
0.9559892416000366,
0.2681373059749603,
-0.11875169724225998,
-0.6532889604568481,
-0.154681995511055,
-0.9227345585823059,
-0.21482975780963898,
0.8561698794364929,
0.03503233939409256,
-0.3078432083129883,
0.10190051048994064,
-0.2553882896900177,
0.18232455849647522,
-0.957794725894928,
1.0241527557373047,
0.7788856029510498,
0.24552428722381592,
-0.4990610182285309,
-0.9416862726211548,
0.2254084348678589,
-0.1365547925233841,
-0.7571415901184082,
-0.34765905141830444,
0.2505098581314087,
0.424044668674469,
0.15389661490917206,
0.40906912088394165,
-0.025576187297701836,
0.15329237282276154,
-0.30710309743881226,
-0.03726863116025925,
-0.14509317278862,
-0.34522929787635803,
0.2442639321088791,
0.38238999247550964,
-0.14637799561023712,
-0.14762918651103973
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.05696v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.05696v1
|
SeeGULL Multilingual: a Dataset of Geo-Culturally Situated Stereotypes
| 2024-03-08T22:09:58 | 2024-03-08T22:09:58 |
Mukul Bhutani, Kevin Robinson, Vinodkumar Prabhakaran, Shachi Dave, Sunipa Dev
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
While generative multilingual models are rapidly being deployed, their safety
and fairness evaluations are largely limited to resources collected in English.
This is especially problematic for evaluations targeting inherently
socio-cultural phenomena such as stereotyping, where it is important to build
multi-lingual resources that reflect the stereotypes prevalent in respective
language communities. However, gathering these resources, at scale, in varied
languages and regions pose a significant challenge as it requires broad
socio-cultural knowledge and can also be prohibitively expensive. To overcome
this critical gap, we employ a recently introduced approach that couples LLM
generations for scale with culturally situated validations for reliability, and
build SeeGULL Multilingual, a global-scale multilingual dataset of social
stereotypes, containing over 25K stereotypes, spanning 20 languages, with human
annotations across 23 regions, and demonstrate its utility in identifying gaps
in model evaluations. Content warning: Stereotypes shared in this paper can be
offensive.
|
[
-0.35916668176651,
-0.2924489676952362,
0.17553101480007172,
0.6345843076705933,
-0.037173666059970856,
0.20379933714866638,
-0.21511614322662354,
-0.8109121322631836,
0.16127312183380127,
0.31084367632865906,
-0.42006027698516846,
-0.5613029599189758,
-0.6207848787307739,
0.18574859201908112,
0.06801695376634598,
1.0645371675491333,
0.035153839737176895,
0.25377604365348816,
-0.29532673954963684,
-0.5271241664886475,
-0.18885722756385803,
-0.7686148881912231,
-0.4719567596912384,
-0.17084938287734985,
0.4956175982952118,
0.48809272050857544,
0.860862135887146,
0.3636665940284729,
0.4763771593570709,
0.20489512383937836,
-0.45711424946784973,
0.3717746138572693,
-0.7078712582588196,
0.08527706563472748,
-0.07545240223407745,
-0.19522960484027863,
-0.34959885478019714,
0.11855486780405045,
0.39975705742836,
0.9511083364486694,
-0.05949711054563522,
0.5103567838668823,
0.23502814769744873,
0.4477700889110565,
-0.5436253547668457,
0.4329874515533447,
-0.4213184714317322,
0.22166460752487183,
-0.2679917812347412,
0.28517085313796997,
-0.15464600920677185,
-0.6561663746833801,
0.02083415538072586,
-0.40512609481811523,
0.1979379802942276,
0.23565040528774261,
0.6731414198875427,
-0.03209609165787697,
-0.6961620450019836,
-0.21058526635169983,
-0.5287761688232422,
0.7524393200874329,
-0.5912564396858215,
0.5161463022232056,
0.5688599348068237,
0.3665752708911896,
0.09638711810112,
-0.48705121874809265,
-0.1995144635438919,
-0.2519204020500183,
-0.27343565225601196,
0.015099331736564636,
0.21343162655830383,
-0.35342586040496826,
0.24507765471935272,
0.17680324614048004,
-0.6504990458488464,
0.16591832041740417,
-0.5327455997467041,
-0.3596595525741577,
0.7070758938789368,
0.05435839295387268,
0.307683527469635,
-0.5524670481681824,
-0.36687198281288147,
0.10985874384641647,
-0.9599186778068542,
0.06197809800505638,
0.5949594974517822,
0.4504288136959076,
-0.5636310577392578,
0.332770973443985,
-0.03888479247689247,
0.5321240425109863,
-0.21425709128379822,
-0.16478531062602997,
0.5979534387588501,
-0.4357333779335022,
0.1595020592212677,
0.06832121312618256,
0.6760485172271729,
0.6164361238479614,
0.6003270745277405,
0.08553770184516907,
-0.08534210920333862,
-0.009698096662759781,
-0.106942318379879,
-0.5574440956115723,
-0.07241612672805786,
0.09816626459360123,
-0.4554315507411957,
-0.4003760516643524,
-0.14327065646648407,
-1.0938466787338257,
-0.6324691772460938,
0.09156236797571182,
-0.38145384192466736,
-0.3225485384464264,
-0.38567033410072327,
-0.06416982412338257,
0.1169668436050415,
0.18875934183597565,
0.04117896035313606,
-0.7645233869552612,
-0.2549994885921478,
0.44948726892471313,
0.8324912190437317,
0.4904594421386719,
-0.5049024820327759,
-0.28579965233802795,
0.10834775865077972,
-0.3821798861026764,
0.6610413789749146,
-0.6411985158920288,
-0.5008290410041809,
0.3989182114601135,
0.11980468779802322,
0.23570187389850616,
-0.5357121229171753,
0.535456657409668,
-0.5267353057861328,
0.07172336429357529,
-0.5014677047729492,
0.15875963866710663,
-0.13454823195934296,
0.5018829703330994,
-0.8162891268730164,
1.0639207363128662,
0.09480278193950653,
-0.8921903967857361,
0.7734534740447998,
-0.3209734559059143,
-0.6355118751525879,
0.18953566253185272,
-0.1441342830657959,
-0.08084704726934433,
0.02088119462132454,
0.3863310217857361,
0.383474200963974,
-0.3816041052341461,
0.5202201008796692,
-0.683095395565033,
-0.1378624588251114,
0.05541394278407097,
-0.4684484601020813,
1.0128899812698364,
0.5890240669250488,
-0.16199690103530884,
-0.08863438665866852,
-0.8768411874771118,
-0.265436053276062,
0.14558012783527374,
-0.36150914430618286,
-0.5901154279708862,
0.12985338270664215,
0.33040639758110046,
0.4286056160926819,
0.5289578437805176,
-0.4132104516029358,
-0.20311754941940308,
-0.07105420529842377,
0.2106940597295761,
0.710013747215271,
-0.37223371863365173,
0.10196485370397568,
-0.22792021930217743,
0.7277200222015381,
0.11950866132974625,
0.3646145164966583,
0.27373620867729187,
-0.3757898509502411,
-0.541448175907135,
-0.25271597504615784,
0.11928169429302216,
0.5696143507957458,
-0.942675769329071,
0.1961737722158432,
-0.3833160996437073,
-0.49062347412109375,
-0.5218797922134399,
0.1875421553850174,
0.5816243886947632,
0.34032711386680603,
-0.10075495392084122,
0.012219585478305817,
-0.6420202255249023,
-0.9837605953216553,
-0.165398970246315,
-0.4947997033596039,
-0.02456580102443695,
0.3974694609642029,
0.27308574318885803,
-0.017875412479043007,
0.6087231040000916,
-0.2888530194759369,
-0.08716970682144165,
-0.18977008759975433,
-0.10866399854421616,
0.18359306454658508,
0.1305588334798813,
0.7872571349143982,
-0.8668080568313599,
-0.4254577159881592,
0.15197737514972687,
-1.3141565322875977,
-0.13549195230007172,
0.30618444085121155,
0.013142965734004974,
0.0979451835155487,
0.48996666073799133,
-0.2543432414531708,
-0.0724901631474495,
0.8809720873832703,
-0.5244025588035583,
0.5738611221313477,
-0.24611099064350128,
0.44805264472961426,
-0.8762535452842712,
-0.2369329184293747,
0.26038867235183716,
-0.23925454914569855,
-0.3228210210800171,
0.2856203615665436,
-0.008102938532829285,
-0.3629857897758484,
-0.5823590755462646,
0.5886056423187256,
-0.5258972644805908,
0.061793357133865356,
0.5115966200828552,
0.372187077999115,
-0.048677220940589905,
0.12113428860902786,
0.03117329254746437,
0.7668563723564148,
0.47614774107933044,
-0.3204311728477478,
0.27268531918525696,
0.184378519654274,
-0.6058435440063477,
0.8794158101081848,
-0.26298636198043823,
0.023562392219901085,
-0.2725552022457123,
-0.03517597168684006,
-0.7733939290046692,
-0.4249603748321533,
0.007605407387018204,
-0.06472757458686829,
-0.02082234062254429,
-0.24349582195281982,
-0.5507774353027344,
-0.3131938874721527,
-0.3995782136917114,
0.6891888380050659,
0.4260498285293579,
-0.8569215536117554,
0.2982766032218933,
0.6564749479293823,
-0.3832513391971588,
-0.7967488169670105,
-0.6262736320495605,
0.07522259652614594,
-0.6080592274665833,
-1.0164536237716675,
-0.3229960799217224,
0.09850502759218216,
-0.6676491498947144,
-0.10173021256923676,
0.06780042499303818,
0.06863366067409515,
0.04218766838312149,
-0.014274190180003643,
0.18835076689720154,
-0.1389188915491104,
0.014728314243257046,
-0.1559215784072876,
0.07839203625917435,
0.02611427754163742,
-0.2898411750793457,
0.30404016375541687,
-0.28500762581825256,
-0.3015420734882355,
0.6275154948234558,
0.4649212956428528,
0.6818793416023254,
-0.2863377630710602,
0.8636428713798523,
0.550463855266571,
-0.37659385800361633,
-0.10505878925323486,
-0.5876604914665222,
0.35003402829170227,
-0.4267761707305908,
0.5193477272987366,
-0.3432003855705261,
-1.0784523487091064,
0.806111752986908,
0.053347259759902954,
0.10075221955776215,
0.20175257325172424,
0.4618193805217743,
-0.04126463457942009,
0.7114368677139282,
0.6027206778526306,
-0.14617714285850525,
0.06464958935976028,
0.2797512114048004,
0.35752570629119873,
-0.4728015065193176,
-0.5178158283233643,
-0.46959176659584045,
-0.1907372623682022,
-0.7885010242462158,
-0.5847588777542114,
0.6899080276489258,
0.058738816529512405,
-0.3426321744918823,
-0.061691123992204666,
-0.11266687512397766,
0.45135271549224854,
0.34170764684677124,
-0.06930626928806305,
0.41432446241378784,
0.2556447684764862,
-0.27028390765190125,
-0.3168739080429077,
-0.8088597655296326,
-0.7960346937179565,
1.0208526849746704,
0.18070490658283234,
0.7646325826644897,
0.44254645705223083,
0.48234623670578003,
0.4426797032356262,
0.5206029415130615,
-0.39625290036201477,
0.5602426528930664,
-0.41296085715293884,
-0.6885080933570862,
-0.11993362009525299,
-0.43444597721099854,
-0.7795268893241882,
0.424054890871048,
-0.1422104686498642,
-0.7829481363296509,
0.2048758864402771,
0.26399773359298706,
-0.12616902589797974,
0.4068911671638489,
-0.6722761988639832,
0.7128252983093262,
-0.3161914348602295,
-0.37656235694885254,
-0.057450443506240845,
-0.6118807792663574,
0.6696969270706177,
-0.31547853350639343,
0.9721741676330566,
-0.28659576177597046,
0.31100910902023315,
0.5098721981048584,
-0.41186466813087463,
0.9570667147636414,
-0.06263437122106552,
-0.3561462461948395,
0.25300583243370056,
0.15197867155075073,
0.38849523663520813,
0.06418758630752563,
-0.3417194187641144,
0.6711437106132507,
0.008369224146008492,
-0.5413443446159363,
-0.22867627441883087,
0.7370619773864746,
-0.8518932461738586,
-0.4041561484336853,
-0.3585865795612335,
-0.5620675086975098,
-0.4431600868701935,
-0.14301015436649323,
0.2659890353679657,
0.3343764543533325,
-0.5537909865379333,
-0.15487748384475708,
0.46464258432388306,
-0.6046964526176453,
0.16911634802818298,
0.2694588303565979,
-0.6173439621925354,
-0.30511802434921265,
0.9171341061592102,
0.25353360176086426,
0.2104310840368271,
-0.07557037472724915,
0.07184769213199615,
-0.3476867973804474,
-0.22009097039699554,
-0.36318159103393555,
0.2294185757637024,
-0.9436925649642944,
0.007646410726010799,
-0.3242379426956177,
-0.17183995246887207,
-0.5704517960548401,
-0.471716970205307,
-0.12680684030056,
-0.09238032251596451,
0.27382543683052063,
-0.441860169172287,
0.3560808598995209,
0.8433215022087097,
-0.4708435535430908,
0.10042177140712738,
-0.5876873731613159,
0.20710816979408264,
0.13224530220031738,
0.4345627427101135,
-0.013157542794942856,
-0.2868940830230713,
-0.3171612024307251,
-0.19838383793830872,
0.20597052574157715,
-0.7117593884468079,
0.4200689196586609,
-0.08830494433641434,
0.5544015765190125,
0.40765342116355896,
0.043557729572057724,
0.5462988615036011,
-0.5764430165290833,
0.9128592014312744,
0.23258869349956512,
-0.5360449552536011,
0.33811670541763306,
-0.49240732192993164,
0.08969338983297348,
0.38161328434944153,
0.5522546172142029,
-0.864357590675354,
-0.5385066866874695,
-0.445756196975708,
-1.0738426446914673,
0.48549559712409973,
-0.057248275727033615,
0.13299839198589325,
-0.29768264293670654,
-0.013048496097326279,
0.1298476755619049,
0.13403107225894928,
-1.0428869724273682,
-0.3200191855430603,
-0.38077905774116516,
-0.22610653936862946,
-0.38262325525283813,
-0.7216731905937195,
-0.3923467993736267,
0.034354519098997116,
0.4992826581001282,
0.03860573470592499,
-0.3304676115512848,
-0.028172019869089127,
-0.3503015637397766,
0.22865307331085205,
0.4450753331184387,
0.2829477787017822,
0.6322445869445801,
-0.24418582022190094,
0.45527681708335876,
0.19996584951877594,
-0.35443058609962463,
0.3487173616886139,
0.1354696899652481,
-0.27588069438934326,
-0.06680600345134735,
0.4978683292865753,
0.5855191349983215,
0.29195332527160645,
-0.6679313778877258,
0.20055140554904938,
0.07870731502771378,
-0.05312233045697212,
-0.43946200609207153,
-0.5088691115379333,
0.19403570890426636,
0.41317859292030334,
-0.0032850599382072687,
-0.16034387052059174,
-0.04230313003063202,
-0.38199126720428467,
0.1170312836766243,
0.34243249893188477,
-0.5970443487167358,
-0.15329119563102722,
0.7177742719650269,
0.40599697828292847,
-0.13353288173675537,
0.7757634520530701,
-0.3992650806903839,
-0.331156849861145,
0.5432227849960327,
0.42079290747642517,
0.6722884774208069,
-0.11434654146432877,
0.46870142221450806,
0.41462135314941406,
0.808789074420929,
0.023712892085313797,
0.2663225531578064,
0.38875070214271545,
-0.9455338716506958,
-0.2333231270313263,
-0.8762844204902649,
-0.06925442069768906,
-0.04870140925049782,
-0.5599409341812134,
0.21517571806907654,
-0.5299782156944275,
-0.14877593517303467,
-0.49637603759765625,
-0.4573463797569275,
-0.916540801525116,
0.046606164425611496,
0.4711349308490753,
0.7346705198287964,
-1.2559608221054077,
0.4170684218406677,
0.8581917881965637,
-0.35104840993881226,
-0.7338697910308838,
-0.09746871143579483,
0.5034192204475403,
-1.0334975719451904,
0.8733817934989929,
0.16272391378879547,
-0.3207317888736725,
-0.4506693184375763,
-0.36804863810539246,
-0.7254053354263306,
0.7407492399215698,
0.533810555934906,
-0.5252038240432739,
0.05801812559366226,
0.25964516401290894,
0.6049606800079346,
-0.44456425309181213,
0.17001394927501678,
0.468919962644577,
0.5714462399482727,
0.008272169157862663,
-0.900766909122467,
0.05109211802482605,
-0.3230462074279785,
0.1695602685213089,
-0.20241209864616394,
-0.8543198704719543,
0.6963405013084412,
-0.25522640347480774,
-0.19685865938663483,
-0.3851526975631714,
0.5206053256988525,
0.5987892150878906,
0.19524100422859192,
0.5753493905067444,
0.2978377342224121,
0.9596919417381287,
-0.0120328888297081,
1.2362024784088135,
-0.4469555914402008,
0.39901435375213623,
1.0412299633026123,
-0.5546087026596069,
0.3826923370361328,
0.28164130449295044,
-0.3208460807800293,
0.3301841914653778,
0.8798359036445618,
0.11155951023101807,
0.41913676261901855,
0.3359390199184418,
-0.5555074214935303,
-0.42463141679763794,
-0.5532086491584778,
-0.36017680168151855,
0.4473263621330261,
0.2494891732931137,
-0.08914274722337723,
-0.5388767719268799,
-0.07581499963998795,
0.3058761656284332,
0.22359172999858856,
-0.4780268371105194,
0.19551753997802734,
0.18166039884090424,
-0.3410261571407318,
0.3562411069869995,
-0.19135333597660065,
0.8632688522338867,
-0.6063427925109863,
0.06502664089202881,
-0.5687355399131775,
-0.1327463686466217,
-0.2936655580997467,
-0.5769409537315369,
0.21383018791675568,
0.21721504628658295,
-0.19828595221042633,
-0.19538596272468567,
0.6481326818466187,
-0.5044925808906555,
-0.9978349208831787,
0.7164594531059265,
0.7798123359680176,
0.4031490683555603,
0.4215826690196991,
-0.4504377543926239,
-0.09173232316970825,
0.06523510068655014,
-0.17014998197555542,
0.3084111511707306,
0.6262220144271851,
-0.4158604145050049,
0.8189773559570312,
0.45543497800827026,
0.3482745289802551,
0.2296501249074936,
0.3973133862018585,
0.4359382390975952,
-0.6099942326545715,
-0.3926233947277069,
-0.8450852036476135,
0.5049137473106384,
-0.14945216476917267,
-0.14542533457279205,
0.8697437644004822,
0.47812411189079285,
1.1087034940719604,
-0.062311407178640366,
1.0844768285751343,
-0.2608420252799988,
0.17103548347949982,
-0.5576176643371582,
0.9281984567642212,
-0.623136579990387,
0.39129918813705444,
-0.2748156189918518,
-0.8987587094306946,
-0.22052395343780518,
0.5957493185997009,
-0.2952357530593872,
0.22243106365203857,
0.5658597946166992,
0.7729489803314209,
-0.01857427880167961,
-0.10976122319698334,
0.6637202501296997,
0.19078920781612396,
0.2038518488407135,
0.44694140553474426,
1.0893889665603638,
0.06475653499364853,
0.5982481241226196,
-0.036087874323129654,
-0.29735493659973145,
0.0998472198843956,
-1.0690879821777344,
-0.7822788953781128,
-0.3816293776035309,
-0.1902172714471817,
-0.610744059085846,
0.008539889007806778,
0.7341707944869995,
0.6342786550521851,
-0.599905252456665,
-0.5600062608718872,
0.8254063725471497,
0.4230801463127136,
-0.1875317245721817,
-0.2061178982257843,
0.1672893911600113,
-0.3520931005477905,
-0.7580341696739197,
0.1695013791322708,
0.28479430079460144,
-0.13386154174804688,
-0.5329210162162781,
-0.03868170455098152,
-0.05226164311170578,
-0.08565689623355865,
0.9592117667198181,
0.09264538437128067,
-0.5742789506912231,
-0.686633288860321,
-0.3266010284423828,
-0.09366896748542786,
0.02293039672076702,
0.6884719133377075,
-0.4333016872406006,
0.37179380655288696,
0.1878703534603119,
0.28479936718940735,
0.2886391878128052,
-0.3719359338283539,
0.6717764139175415,
-1.0039429664611816,
0.5085030198097229,
-0.11407652497291565,
0.6543610692024231,
0.7204281091690063,
-0.41001492738723755,
0.7967305183410645,
0.2799689471721649,
-0.2967473864555359,
-0.7038256525993347,
0.5249339938163757,
-0.6948966979980469,
-0.12767177820205688,
1.3424497842788696,
-0.45744144916534424,
0.12712343037128448,
-0.3318309783935547,
0.24553686380386353,
0.122746042907238,
-0.08425058424472809,
0.8703407645225525,
1.0337682962417603,
0.2443675994873047,
-0.06822385638952255,
-0.7270926237106323,
0.3921166658401489,
0.18791024386882782,
-0.6256454586982727,
0.24801287055015564,
0.9405587315559387,
0.4940711557865143,
0.1514061689376831,
0.6849665641784668,
-0.39592376351356506,
-0.30203425884246826,
0.2940700352191925,
0.21783968806266785,
0.0920879989862442,
-0.2759471833705902,
-0.23024633526802063,
0.37285491824150085,
0.30643051862716675,
0.1462169885635376
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09704v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09704v1
|
Alignment Studio: Aligning Large Language Models to Particular Contextual Regulations
| 2024-03-08T21:26:49 | 2024-03-08T21:26:49 |
Swapnaja Achintalwar, Ioana Baldini, Djallel Bouneffouf, Joan Byamugisha, Maria Chang, Pierre Dognin, Eitan Farchi, Ndivhuwo Makondo, Aleksandra Mojsilovic, Manish Nagireddy, Karthikeyan Natesan Ramamurthy, Inkit Padhi, Orna Raz, Jesus Rios, Prasanna Sattigeri, Moninder Singh, Siphiwe Thwala, Rosario A. Uceda-Sosa, Kush R. Varshney
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
The alignment of large language models is usually done by model providers to
add or control behaviors that are common or universally understood across use
cases and contexts. In contrast, in this article, we present an approach and
architecture that empowers application developers to tune a model to their
particular values, social norms, laws and other regulations, and orchestrate
between potentially conflicting requirements in context. We lay out three main
components of such an Alignment Studio architecture: Framers, Instructors, and
Auditors that work in concert to control the behavior of a language model. We
illustrate this approach with a running example of aligning a company's
internal-facing enterprise chatbot to its business conduct guidelines.
|
[
-0.15885214507579803,
-0.6025840640068054,
0.3167058527469635,
0.23463693261146545,
0.040966201573610306,
0.07925720512866974,
-0.15095461905002594,
-0.479859858751297,
0.1328875571489334,
0.807927131652832,
-0.3793047368526459,
-0.303382933139801,
-0.2155669629573822,
-0.24332942068576813,
-0.5725968480110168,
1.0150624513626099,
-0.26453402638435364,
0.0827634334564209,
-0.2422792762517929,
-0.3618161976337433,
-1.1743450164794922,
-0.2906801104545593,
-0.17901821434497833,
-0.3545509874820709,
0.03998076543211937,
0.44005078077316284,
1.1797733306884766,
0.8958804607391357,
0.6190629005432129,
0.37028878927230835,
-0.18816132843494415,
-0.19387486577033997,
-0.34750038385391235,
0.09917183965444565,
-0.4757958948612213,
-0.2671423852443695,
-0.7009263038635254,
-0.10960162431001663,
0.4175565242767334,
0.5834774971008301,
-0.3615395426750183,
0.3073195219039917,
0.2216046303510666,
0.5888088941574097,
-0.7190190553665161,
0.07492898404598236,
-0.2440677136182785,
-0.28372880816459656,
-0.10970912128686905,
-0.12095247954130173,
-0.42839115858078003,
-0.35921671986579895,
0.1437729001045227,
-0.3305515646934509,
-0.27038392424583435,
0.2287238985300064,
1.1348334550857544,
0.42833685874938965,
-0.6004400849342346,
-0.3474937081336975,
-0.7646446824073792,
0.6909593343734741,
-0.4503105580806732,
0.535587728023529,
-0.032433539628982544,
0.35732579231262207,
-0.1404915302991867,
-0.4170806407928467,
-0.43351975083351135,
0.24547125399112701,
-0.2121681123971939,
-0.008453979156911373,
-0.11117091029882431,
0.08626236766576767,
0.02253080904483795,
0.10769150406122208,
-0.580507755279541,
0.30639544129371643,
-0.5533850789070129,
-0.09686000645160675,
0.5707622170448303,
0.3887057304382324,
0.5754207968711853,
0.08144348859786987,
-0.28275927901268005,
0.1345326453447342,
-0.7814193964004517,
-0.010476280003786087,
0.3031512200832367,
0.28731146454811096,
-0.20813894271850586,
0.6314428448677063,
0.049979306757450104,
1.0802959203720093,
0.29572832584381104,
0.013642721809446812,
0.14813020825386047,
-0.2949565351009369,
-0.4078906178474426,
0.5617451071739197,
0.3790803849697113,
0.4337860941886902,
0.006098893005400896,
-0.07387394458055496,
-0.42862561345100403,
0.13169753551483154,
0.6999696493148804,
-0.4141950011253357,
0.07831832021474838,
0.4588070809841156,
-0.435499906539917,
-0.15988388657569885,
-0.24817796051502228,
-0.4793111979961395,
-0.43305131793022156,
-1.2473349571228027,
0.44704362750053406,
-0.06400981545448303,
-0.27000609040260315,
-0.054682403802871704,
-0.1960667371749878,
0.8487969636917114,
0.3170863091945648,
-1.0999616384506226,
0.3422918915748596,
1.2261172533035278,
0.8042464256286621,
-0.07544369250535965,
-0.23139043152332306,
-0.39442670345306396,
0.511685848236084,
-0.6197158694267273,
0.24996258318424225,
-0.7206475734710693,
-0.07776577770709991,
0.088721863925457,
0.011154347099363804,
0.08772838115692139,
-0.1787436455488205,
0.18092934787273407,
-0.7315782308578491,
0.12744078040122986,
0.1664685755968094,
-0.9704461097717285,
-0.09708713740110397,
0.169796422123909,
-0.5594210624694824,
0.5132959485054016,
0.1621227115392685,
-0.29677537083625793,
0.25608760118484497,
-0.6588625907897949,
-0.2565041482448578,
0.1988743543624878,
-0.5951409339904785,
-0.23761330544948578,
0.1239793673157692,
-0.14278164505958557,
0.35056623816490173,
-0.18019363284111023,
0.5028351545333862,
-0.12999506294727325,
-0.38178032636642456,
0.09641549736261368,
0.17795884609222412,
1.21388840675354,
0.45233431458473206,
-0.39220061898231506,
0.705116331577301,
-0.573583722114563,
-0.04825153946876526,
-0.27954283356666565,
-0.2466302365064621,
-0.5034234523773193,
0.05448542907834053,
0.18846388161182404,
0.14923883974552155,
0.37371817231178284,
-0.0287664532661438,
0.2731991112232208,
-0.11207590252161026,
0.5790821313858032,
0.8260821104049683,
-0.3349960446357727,
0.929367184638977,
-0.3548543155193329,
0.7225008606910706,
-0.24561405181884766,
0.019239235669374466,
0.015209199860692024,
-0.22001251578330994,
-0.529048502445221,
-0.1927037090063095,
0.2384929358959198,
0.5957373380661011,
-0.05162839964032173,
0.8457179069519043,
-0.4732220768928528,
-0.5035526752471924,
-0.9404813051223755,
0.5270419120788574,
0.43493446707725525,
0.44115909934043884,
-0.0856996551156044,
-0.2894352674484253,
-0.706535816192627,
-0.86856609582901,
-0.1195058599114418,
0.21772663295269012,
0.023738935589790344,
0.16121521592140198,
0.3185373544692993,
-0.23650158941745758,
1.1970945596694946,
-0.1599324345588684,
-0.305141806602478,
-0.1495094895362854,
-0.1164015457034111,
0.16197381913661957,
0.8274948596954346,
0.6637091040611267,
-1.0595614910125732,
-0.6613802313804626,
0.28487977385520935,
-0.5412471890449524,
-0.3100265562534332,
-0.09034263342618942,
-0.5847986936569214,
0.2539535164833069,
0.9312658905982971,
-0.3637045919895172,
0.23226113617420197,
0.9250440001487732,
-0.5487390756607056,
0.3382717967033386,
0.09793788194656372,
-0.011591613292694092,
-1.3479907512664795,
0.28999805450439453,
-0.14271008968353271,
-0.41481882333755493,
-0.6313177943229675,
0.26941078901290894,
0.14841017127037048,
-0.3470444083213806,
-0.21974478662014008,
0.5526107549667358,
-0.40003061294555664,
-0.13465210795402527,
-0.2050267606973648,
0.44183945655822754,
0.18186722695827484,
0.1549403816461563,
0.2017422914505005,
0.7295327186584473,
0.6099375486373901,
-0.5890316963195801,
0.420308381319046,
0.6360911130905151,
-0.7448844313621521,
1.1762504577636719,
-0.5610772967338562,
0.09219935536384583,
-0.1427682638168335,
0.07539884001016617,
-0.7273387312889099,
-0.441638708114624,
-0.10062383115291595,
-0.24614539742469788,
0.3507530391216278,
-0.20325464010238647,
-0.1832580417394638,
0.029699847102165222,
0.30446696281433105,
0.029434507712721825,
0.5589426159858704,
-0.37603458762168884,
0.9680627584457397,
0.7625249028205872,
0.0009277172503061593,
-0.4871787130832672,
-0.7744304537773132,
0.06427332758903503,
-0.536802351474762,
-0.6805617213249207,
0.3677826523780823,
-0.13036157190799713,
-0.5148874521255493,
0.12557081878185272,
0.00019465955847408623,
-0.24932490289211273,
0.33443373441696167,
0.4833929240703583,
0.42067041993141174,
-0.49931320548057556,
-0.06956075131893158,
-0.16958069801330566,
0.0584227554500103,
-0.08422428369522095,
-0.09954342991113663,
0.451386958360672,
-0.133292555809021,
-0.340213418006897,
-0.5326474905014038,
0.3701169490814209,
0.7037636637687683,
-0.3518606126308441,
0.7955352663993835,
0.1641082912683487,
-0.1959218531847,
0.09993734210729599,
-0.6709079742431641,
0.22187890112400055,
-0.5344998836517334,
0.22467833757400513,
-0.3499103784561157,
-0.9590324759483337,
0.6117767691612244,
0.027893446385860443,
0.39392706751823425,
0.029291385784745216,
0.7625905275344849,
0.18958166241645813,
1.342776894569397,
0.9631819725036621,
-0.3778749108314514,
0.8766774535179138,
0.45508089661598206,
0.40463823080062866,
-0.9586977958679199,
-0.034463971853256226,
-0.8400480151176453,
-0.46199753880500793,
-0.4053727984428406,
0.119867704808712,
0.08065598458051682,
0.3993959128856659,
-0.5780101418495178,
0.7750242352485657,
-0.6453540921211243,
0.8013731837272644,
0.49293848872184753,
-0.2830509543418884,
0.06776811927556992,
-0.5469226837158203,
0.12398014217615128,
0.1760440468788147,
-0.5682617425918579,
-0.9447121620178223,
0.69801926612854,
0.3276742100715637,
0.825537383556366,
0.7246317863464355,
0.6877939105033875,
-0.19516709446907043,
0.4746515452861786,
-0.7055709362030029,
0.2535286843776703,
0.15970709919929504,
-1.0039180517196655,
-0.1251925528049469,
-0.13798651099205017,
-0.7368678450584412,
0.07724402099847794,
-0.020275864750146866,
-1.1223645210266113,
0.2470259666442871,
0.45539966225624084,
-0.4382472336292267,
-0.18012090027332306,
-1.1490527391433716,
1.3815821409225464,
-0.34937813878059387,
-0.32920369505882263,
-0.16908687353134155,
-0.6992922425270081,
0.2895983159542084,
-0.0755104124546051,
0.3663405478000641,
-0.060650184750556946,
0.0730924904346466,
0.2831755578517914,
-0.20194239914417267,
0.9340608716011047,
0.1518983095884323,
-0.23549632728099823,
0.27475064992904663,
0.3176550269126892,
0.43075886368751526,
-0.3671248257160187,
0.023837629705667496,
-0.21399043500423431,
0.3149893283843994,
-0.20943234860897064,
-0.42266201972961426,
0.668234646320343,
-0.7370417714118958,
-0.7414118051528931,
-0.02741607464849949,
-0.5831342935562134,
-0.0983462929725647,
0.39630335569381714,
-0.14940471947193146,
0.16272084414958954,
-0.38150542974472046,
0.4959586262702942,
0.3016919195652008,
0.07546024769544601,
0.22335946559906006,
0.6261352896690369,
-0.17896267771720886,
-0.07347321510314941,
0.527573823928833,
-0.23027104139328003,
0.4449700713157654,
0.35415154695510864,
0.07108267396688461,
-0.14397530257701874,
-0.11779569089412689,
-0.43272867798805237,
-0.3922681510448456,
-0.8693508505821228,
-0.3485376834869385,
-0.05008424073457718,
-0.20580258965492249,
-0.6863033771514893,
-0.8197181820869446,
-0.2619026303291321,
-0.12823320925235748,
-0.3011300265789032,
0.13957083225250244,
0.16730909049510956,
0.6580581665039062,
0.2267533540725708,
0.4820095896720886,
-0.9822953939437866,
-0.2193843126296997,
0.076348215341568,
0.46915149688720703,
-0.2162056416273117,
-0.44188249111175537,
-0.3774568438529968,
-0.06982646137475967,
-0.3277614116668701,
-0.7033524513244629,
0.1746853142976761,
0.06562264263629913,
0.46960505843162537,
0.6116797924041748,
-0.22169968485832214,
1.014967679977417,
-0.7005620002746582,
0.7144186496734619,
0.18917302787303925,
-1.519984245300293,
0.6108635067939758,
-0.1588229387998581,
0.2699704170227051,
0.5635296702384949,
0.23278675973415375,
-0.8291432857513428,
-0.5308856964111328,
-0.37912529706954956,
-0.5938267707824707,
0.7326805591583252,
-0.03878188133239746,
0.49847301840782166,
0.27629631757736206,
0.4236241281032562,
-0.350837767124176,
0.2829287648200989,
-0.7077721357345581,
0.2634275555610657,
-0.00045576062984764576,
-0.6696439981460571,
0.04160928726196289,
0.0380130335688591,
-0.6812567114830017,
-0.08890040963888168,
0.7133923768997192,
-0.05105164647102356,
-0.3362096846103668,
-0.19412146508693695,
-0.10982777178287506,
-0.16338419914245605,
0.39372310042381287,
0.5348826050758362,
0.9582353830337524,
0.1351803094148636,
-0.06342631578445435,
-0.2617497146129608,
-0.14785580337047577,
0.04486255720257759,
-0.19738441705703735,
-0.12201236188411713,
-0.36808326840400696,
0.21919213235378265,
0.8668020963668823,
0.3782227337360382,
-0.6877681612968445,
0.5542826056480408,
0.2576661705970764,
0.011409278027713299,
-0.19448864459991455,
0.41101494431495667,
0.2933047115802765,
0.5598909258842468,
-0.3893122673034668,
-0.14696180820465088,
-0.1027202233672142,
-0.573992133140564,
0.13717326521873474,
0.4818241596221924,
-0.5484111905097961,
-0.18774808943271637,
0.903327465057373,
0.4266272485256195,
-0.47901418805122375,
0.5221155881881714,
0.11738934367895126,
-0.46644827723503113,
0.6944811344146729,
0.7416933178901672,
0.8570632934570312,
-0.4089944064617157,
-0.1734098196029663,
0.07592111825942993,
0.17674751579761505,
-0.3610592186450958,
0.11113342642784119,
0.13205324113368988,
-0.9525818228721619,
-0.635390043258667,
-0.4656125605106354,
-0.47777894139289856,
-0.21711763739585876,
-0.7674260139465332,
0.6373623609542847,
-0.33821961283683777,
0.08521487563848495,
0.43702054023742676,
-0.406897634267807,
-0.4649300277233124,
-0.25108709931373596,
0.09511303901672363,
0.8575700521469116,
-0.8424867391586304,
0.7905964851379395,
0.9208343625068665,
-0.4373558461666107,
-1.0191755294799805,
-0.4032381474971771,
0.6138879656791687,
-0.5919963717460632,
0.5502734184265137,
0.041065752506256104,
-0.12409688532352448,
-0.07163383811712265,
-0.750528872013092,
-0.9058853983879089,
1.0242537260055542,
0.3036991357803345,
-0.8922158479690552,
0.04089249297976494,
-0.22368809580802917,
0.5853414535522461,
-0.6320018768310547,
-0.4456964433193207,
0.7753503918647766,
0.3664062023162842,
0.1525159329175949,
-1.247207760810852,
-0.02544931322336197,
-0.09098073840141296,
0.001948676654137671,
0.597710132598877,
-0.5425562262535095,
0.47081926465034485,
0.20450244843959808,
-0.21113453805446625,
0.09465700387954712,
0.34495869278907776,
-0.10035914182662964,
-0.08128426223993301,
0.34025782346725464,
0.3986890912055969,
0.736676037311554,
-0.03306395933032036,
0.6272998452186584,
-0.9209555387496948,
0.2095322459936142,
1.5515655279159546,
-0.5607409477233887,
0.8210549354553223,
0.5886074304580688,
0.24245965480804443,
0.4804920256137848,
0.4767116606235504,
-0.14181633293628693,
0.2471025139093399,
-0.1013617143034935,
0.07242804765701294,
-0.17346131801605225,
-0.09741920977830887,
-0.09416147321462631,
0.8881681561470032,
0.35547366738319397,
-0.31417566537857056,
0.21078263223171234,
-0.3803461790084839,
0.0009252429008483887,
0.256198525428772,
-0.3425501585006714,
1.0254201889038086,
-0.11726602911949158,
-0.9323669075965881,
0.08390447497367859,
-0.08062241971492767,
0.028607890009880066,
-0.5845983624458313,
0.06221354007720947,
0.2122369110584259,
0.3764316737651825,
-0.37102076411247253,
-0.8830889463424683,
0.7493347525596619,
-0.10532227158546448,
0.1478620022535324,
-0.39544448256492615,
0.17396843433380127,
-0.5468327403068542,
-0.04223710671067238,
0.08629404008388519,
0.06808227300643921,
-0.17126405239105225,
0.34400105476379395,
-0.6807109117507935,
0.2569723129272461,
-0.2086402177810669,
0.06236835569143295,
0.1395891010761261,
0.4312131404876709,
-0.21889297664165497,
0.410310834646225,
0.2704068720340729,
-0.018611935898661613,
-0.20089705288410187,
-0.02540299855172634,
0.5534158945083618,
-0.5349596738815308,
-0.8186293244361877,
-0.7680222392082214,
0.5884057879447937,
-0.23456859588623047,
-0.38962921500205994,
0.6855142116546631,
0.6944096684455872,
0.9395986795425415,
0.27677714824676514,
0.35127848386764526,
-0.39922788739204407,
0.10065930336713791,
-0.5869520306587219,
0.5368048548698425,
-0.5281668305397034,
0.29590362310409546,
-0.3237690031528473,
-0.9979663491249084,
-0.4254085123538971,
0.7415236830711365,
-0.10749071836471558,
-0.24256673455238342,
0.2568868100643158,
0.8363924026489258,
-0.18782281875610352,
0.06984001398086548,
0.08283838629722595,
0.15804541110992432,
0.4026724696159363,
0.24111919105052948,
0.5184232592582703,
0.1409577876329422,
0.4012134075164795,
-0.01778227463364601,
-0.2871001660823822,
-0.2212253361940384,
-1.0506585836410522,
-0.6608594655990601,
-0.6438841819763184,
-0.5576379299163818,
-0.46078020334243774,
-0.31500759720802307,
1.1559003591537476,
0.8662765622138977,
-0.9586583971977234,
-0.5917026400566101,
-0.1525963842868805,
0.15088443458080292,
-0.38742727041244507,
-0.2565930187702179,
0.18049296736717224,
-0.5132565498352051,
-0.8018017411231995,
0.1764703243970871,
0.41448578238487244,
0.15269918739795685,
-0.4296624958515167,
-0.13815747201442719,
-0.03766839578747749,
0.23619019985198975,
0.2976548373699188,
0.35802775621414185,
-0.6939639449119568,
-0.47881147265434265,
-0.28057584166526794,
-0.44149789214134216,
0.13079628348350525,
0.9186583161354065,
-0.06629544496536255,
0.668799638748169,
0.43903952836990356,
0.6659195423126221,
-0.08216103911399841,
0.033632975071668625,
1.042775273323059,
-0.8654164671897888,
0.21400576829910278,
0.1557682603597641,
0.45170536637306213,
0.13491179049015045,
-0.3645103871822357,
0.4777206480503082,
-0.5923662185668945,
-0.8779244422912598,
-0.6140475869178772,
0.397340327501297,
-0.9017053842544556,
-0.33122482895851135,
0.8372183442115784,
0.12766660749912262,
-0.34058821201324463,
-0.13990464806556702,
-0.2786552906036377,
0.11488151550292969,
-0.11209462583065033,
0.8621208071708679,
1.0849432945251465,
-0.08849368244409561,
0.019548429176211357,
-0.7893984317779541,
0.6119836568832397,
0.293959379196167,
-0.6726697087287903,
0.24994322657585144,
0.8392429947853088,
0.3063991069793701,
0.4404161274433136,
0.3717364966869354,
-0.1984909027814865,
0.17344211041927338,
-0.3677061200141907,
0.14289595186710358,
0.5057631731033325,
-0.17384882271289825,
-0.5933439135551453,
-0.2960602939128876,
0.09620983153581619,
0.043386466801166534
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.05680v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.05680v2
|
How Well Do Multi-modal LLMs Interpret CT Scans? An Auto-Evaluation Framework for Analyses
| 2024-03-08T21:16:28 | 2024-06-18T12:43:18 |
Qingqing Zhu, Benjamin Hou, Tejas S. Mathai, Pritam Mukherjee, Qiao Jin, Xiuying Chen, Zhizheng Wang, Ruida Cheng, Ronald M. Summers, Zhiyong Lu
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Automatically interpreting CT scans can ease the workload of radiologists.
However, this is challenging mainly due to the scarcity of adequate datasets
and reference standards for evaluation. This study aims to bridge this gap by
introducing a novel evaluation framework, named ``GPTRadScore''. This framework
assesses the capabilities of multi-modal LLMs, such as GPT-4 with Vision
(GPT-4V), Gemini Pro Vision, LLaVA-Med, and RadFM, in generating descriptions
for prospectively-identified findings. By employing a decomposition technique
based on GPT-4, GPTRadScore compares these generated descriptions with
gold-standard report sentences, analyzing their accuracy in terms of body part,
location, and type of finding. Evaluations demonstrated a high correlation with
clinician assessments and highlighted its potential over traditional metrics,
such as BLEU, METEOR, and ROUGE. Furthermore, to contribute to future studies,
we plan to release a benchmark dataset annotated by clinicians. Using
GPTRadScore, we found that while GPT-4V and Gemini Pro Vision fare better,
their performance revealed significant areas for improvement, primarily due to
limitations in the dataset used for training these models. To demonstrate this
potential, RadFM was fine-tuned and it resulted in significant accuracy
improvements: location accuracy rose from 3.41\% to 12.8\%, body part accuracy
from 29.12\% to 53\%, and type accuracy from 9.24\% to 30\%, thereby validating
our hypothesis.
|
[
-0.1887548714876175,
-0.22183115780353546,
0.9059470295906067,
0.08292573690414429,
-0.5604559183120728,
0.005184693727642298,
-0.021329347044229507,
-0.5574427843093872,
-0.051043231040239334,
0.16860002279281616,
-0.38540536165237427,
-0.6874140501022339,
-0.8265842795372009,
0.5407630205154419,
-0.3465498387813568,
0.844843327999115,
-0.100193552672863,
0.455975741147995,
-0.24320989847183228,
-0.3890155255794525,
-0.5317175984382629,
-0.1591799259185791,
-0.279276967048645,
-0.2564164400100708,
0.4729883074760437,
-0.15387609601020813,
0.9964142441749573,
0.8932565450668335,
0.802646279335022,
0.3264213502407074,
0.12582378089427948,
0.21760666370391846,
-0.10018762946128845,
-0.09780358523130417,
0.0254124253988266,
-0.17653784155845642,
-0.5752054452896118,
0.05078146979212761,
0.4973222017288208,
0.3685871362686157,
-0.10386442393064499,
-0.12159592658281326,
-0.014199449680745602,
0.44036751985549927,
-0.600020170211792,
0.2980002760887146,
-0.20785236358642578,
0.07536965608596802,
0.0036810508463531733,
-0.573437511920929,
-0.17396527528762817,
-0.3357732892036438,
0.22766469419002533,
-0.507010281085968,
0.21781028807163239,
-0.3081372380256653,
0.703571081161499,
0.4075535535812378,
-0.6962087750434875,
-0.48388031125068665,
-0.3405887186527252,
0.4822433292865753,
-0.3266606032848358,
0.4807854890823364,
0.10958857089281082,
0.6015600562095642,
0.12556548416614532,
-0.7371729016304016,
-0.04371777921915054,
-0.38215264678001404,
-0.2529579699039459,
0.5322859287261963,
-0.20470307767391205,
0.2887130081653595,
0.1310456395149231,
0.5426803827285767,
-0.8067508935928345,
-0.06605356931686401,
-0.3602428436279297,
-0.5728051066398621,
0.6687183976173401,
0.5770666003227234,
0.35816943645477295,
-0.30031949281692505,
-0.7362304329872131,
-0.08794752508401871,
-0.43216803669929504,
-0.3830385208129883,
0.0778321698307991,
0.05358356982469559,
-0.2208470106124878,
0.6132131814956665,
-0.18167182803153992,
0.8472234010696411,
0.17858949303627014,
-0.3879159688949585,
0.7204214334487915,
-0.809084415435791,
-0.4571889340877533,
-0.3245784342288971,
0.5871286988258362,
0.5229208469390869,
-0.11305661499500275,
-0.07522814720869064,
-0.4180873930454254,
0.14460481703281403,
0.26242634654045105,
-0.517369270324707,
-0.17066173255443573,
0.15545548498630524,
-0.8262538313865662,
-0.40747374296188354,
0.023633314296603203,
-0.43247294425964355,
-0.4485247731208801,
-0.4107339680194855,
0.4858728349208832,
-0.5479620099067688,
-0.23275215923786163,
0.40714091062545776,
-0.08558572828769684,
0.24442490935325623,
0.660560667514801,
-0.43952158093452454,
0.18060225248336792,
0.5242385864257812,
1.0249440670013428,
-0.3177817165851593,
-0.12202814221382141,
-0.41299495100975037,
0.021891508251428604,
-0.16045355796813965,
1.0564672946929932,
-0.5112270712852478,
-0.56770920753479,
-0.3080802261829376,
0.08761563897132874,
-0.41090884804725647,
-0.5550744533538818,
0.6103525757789612,
-0.22565409541130066,
0.3261053264141083,
-0.27663376927375793,
-0.10889782011508942,
-0.22966201603412628,
0.6330135464668274,
-0.7742986679077148,
0.8263817429542542,
0.4188515543937683,
-0.5898038148880005,
0.5985856652259827,
-0.6157875061035156,
-0.3419678807258606,
0.11254647374153137,
-0.5604851245880127,
-0.1693752557039261,
0.3016831874847412,
0.49046778678894043,
0.3184175491333008,
-0.494832843542099,
0.1989467591047287,
-0.021900339052081108,
-0.287002295255661,
0.14554743468761444,
-0.44684290885925293,
0.5762122273445129,
0.2513083815574646,
-0.2633243799209595,
0.2516282796859741,
-0.37029263377189636,
0.06232466176152229,
-0.19739721715450287,
-0.34445202350616455,
0.10603302717208862,
-0.2697544991970062,
0.037029705941677094,
0.38355308771133423,
0.18775884807109833,
-0.41694724559783936,
0.12394650280475616,
-0.3309192657470703,
0.2297329157590866,
0.7062828540802002,
-0.04911213368177414,
0.1828911155462265,
-0.45005789399147034,
1.0076731443405151,
0.2158593237400055,
0.5579506158828735,
-0.0435379296541214,
-0.4819231331348419,
-0.3376959562301636,
-0.6211453080177307,
0.010561013594269753,
0.3163543939590454,
-0.7961843609809875,
0.28505179286003113,
-0.45156922936439514,
-0.513340175151825,
-0.31037086248397827,
-0.15114560723304749,
0.47564512491226196,
0.5597668886184692,
0.349244624376297,
-0.6548277139663696,
-0.21089032292366028,
-1.0701265335083008,
-0.01464280765503645,
0.019655469805002213,
-0.005160635337233543,
0.2564285099506378,
0.4442218840122223,
-0.42544499039649963,
0.5760647654533386,
-0.37718284130096436,
-0.4943864345550537,
-0.24584373831748962,
0.1791902333498001,
0.2862420976161957,
0.154872864484787,
0.634535014629364,
-0.6911170482635498,
-0.3751301169395447,
-0.07888175547122955,
-0.7797476649284363,
-0.027335265651345253,
-0.13586510717868805,
0.1958991438150406,
0.14159683883190155,
-0.006609270349144936,
-0.35512688755989075,
0.636612594127655,
0.5640694499015808,
-0.20629768073558807,
0.626004159450531,
-0.6001178622245789,
0.45452550053596497,
-0.7218632102012634,
0.03343500941991806,
0.10310617834329605,
-0.21700049936771393,
-0.14541234076023102,
0.0648820772767067,
0.13255511224269867,
0.013115402311086655,
-0.41401487588882446,
0.31707724928855896,
-0.7981053590774536,
-0.6247837543487549,
-0.15314491093158722,
-0.06567782163619995,
0.05244102701544762,
-0.04842240363359451,
0.17358845472335815,
0.8578429818153381,
0.6672276258468628,
-0.23360387980937958,
0.41341811418533325,
-0.031183429062366486,
-0.3674217164516449,
0.7298538684844971,
-0.6011497378349304,
0.14481447637081146,
-0.026301732286810875,
0.41946473717689514,
-0.9710484743118286,
-0.22949527204036713,
0.1302962303161621,
-0.3031731843948364,
0.281075119972229,
-0.11895033717155457,
-0.5506870150566101,
-0.450432151556015,
-0.5706766843795776,
0.5757524371147156,
-0.0033231619745492935,
-0.28670600056648254,
0.9711233377456665,
0.1991516500711441,
0.38497811555862427,
-0.5769110918045044,
-0.599591076374054,
0.2959132492542267,
-0.2173055112361908,
-0.616761326789856,
0.19445818662643433,
-0.21659886837005615,
-0.043252814561128616,
-0.11427685618400574,
-0.2685388922691345,
-0.2998688817024231,
0.0304567813873291,
0.29016730189323425,
0.41698580980300903,
-0.14992882311344147,
0.0015789493918418884,
-0.15024614334106445,
-0.5169011354446411,
0.08580179512500763,
-0.06514212489128113,
0.3571651577949524,
-0.3834194540977478,
-0.5003171563148499,
-0.5960179567337036,
-0.01815655641257763,
0.7047711610794067,
-0.10773401707410812,
-0.09712023288011551,
0.9059244394302368,
-0.41002652049064636,
0.1565607339143753,
-0.545708954334259,
-0.08542794734239578,
-0.4025222063064575,
0.4081425666809082,
-0.6629538536071777,
-0.5434563159942627,
0.5331649780273438,
0.21854399144649506,
-0.29155266284942627,
0.5740312337875366,
0.8831794261932373,
-0.0762774646282196,
1.11860191822052,
0.4017288386821747,
0.0760888010263443,
0.01978256367146969,
-0.12674757838249207,
-0.1100136786699295,
-1.0058543682098389,
-0.41815927624702454,
-0.29670509696006775,
-0.16993403434753418,
-0.3717222511768341,
-0.6246785521507263,
0.7794230580329895,
-0.4845072627067566,
0.08927997946739197,
0.14240920543670654,
-0.8693256378173828,
0.33164823055267334,
0.11388632655143738,
0.43939146399497986,
0.41426438093185425,
-0.05397946015000343,
-0.22347009181976318,
-0.07953817397356033,
-0.663339376449585,
-0.48045846819877625,
1.5214428901672363,
0.3741508722305298,
0.6983427405357361,
-0.11252353340387344,
0.5739272832870483,
0.4358840584754944,
0.5772355198860168,
-0.854108989238739,
0.3736223578453064,
-0.2449740469455719,
-0.614277720451355,
0.1468660831451416,
-0.17129680514335632,
-0.7644041180610657,
0.4468436539173126,
-0.15765801072120667,
-0.3274497985839844,
0.13843585550785065,
-0.10463716834783554,
-0.5611678957939148,
-0.015799859538674355,
-0.3792582154273987,
0.7316877841949463,
-0.74467533826828,
-0.23476974666118622,
-0.35988450050354004,
-0.6454763412475586,
0.4031843841075897,
-0.19592206180095673,
0.2678552567958832,
-0.24811723828315735,
-0.34721750020980835,
0.32640212774276733,
-0.2309396117925644,
0.5591807961463928,
-0.1090589389204979,
-0.16609904170036316,
0.043059706687927246,
0.15240611135959625,
0.04489930719137192,
0.3199135661125183,
-0.21490682661533356,
0.3811036944389343,
0.4113388657569885,
-0.09864900261163712,
-0.4848293364048004,
0.6592089533805847,
-0.8290901184082031,
-0.25185349583625793,
-0.792058527469635,
-0.6704685091972351,
-0.14358802139759064,
0.01382383331656456,
0.25277984142303467,
0.7821038961410522,
-0.0430586002767086,
-0.056235987693071365,
0.22041501104831696,
-0.18169602751731873,
0.177250936627388,
0.3901166319847107,
0.17459304630756378,
-0.6076656579971313,
0.5108123421669006,
0.04533037915825844,
0.10397809743881226,
0.32464125752449036,
0.24944907426834106,
-0.7196420431137085,
-0.9662243127822876,
-0.6485986113548279,
0.351922869682312,
-0.9574514627456665,
-0.29734042286872864,
-0.3170563578605652,
0.08137223869562149,
-0.3033014237880707,
-0.12612135708332062,
-0.24422046542167664,
-0.0145547641441226,
-0.16586820781230927,
-0.030994202941656113,
-0.1074170246720314,
0.8082255125045776,
-0.34738829731941223,
0.12503066658973694,
-0.733775794506073,
0.06950441747903824,
-0.015596393495798111,
0.2514137327671051,
-0.3936903774738312,
-0.49670735001564026,
-0.35459280014038086,
-0.2009698897600174,
-0.06197356805205345,
-0.6408162117004395,
0.34068232774734497,
-0.08064156770706177,
0.7057278156280518,
0.36513733863830566,
-0.18811747431755066,
0.9587286114692688,
0.010611144825816154,
0.694391667842865,
0.4484831988811493,
-0.8297574520111084,
0.4800892472267151,
-0.38587814569473267,
0.33835384249687195,
0.6527204513549805,
-0.029667306691408157,
-0.028319591656327248,
-0.16016785800457,
-0.47275760769844055,
-0.5514127016067505,
0.6498668789863586,
0.13161341845989227,
-0.15769708156585693,
-0.10684698075056076,
0.5763274431228638,
0.2430245280265808,
-0.009340090677142143,
-0.7526343464851379,
-0.04825036972761154,
-0.21773576736450195,
-0.36031806468963623,
-0.09939351677894592,
-0.21488554775714874,
-0.4804792106151581,
-0.2782357633113861,
0.043194759637117386,
-0.4801354706287384,
0.664415717124939,
0.30339401960372925,
-0.3776871860027313,
0.029879042878746986,
-0.005749095231294632,
0.7317649126052856,
1.2379732131958008,
-0.2527092397212982,
0.3153053820133209,
0.2232031226158142,
-0.6694312691688538,
-0.1116286963224411,
-0.08928603678941727,
0.31654101610183716,
0.08640922605991364,
0.6871134638786316,
0.20372259616851807,
0.09077892452478409,
-0.48702114820480347,
0.8601526021957397,
-0.21810734272003174,
-0.3370722234249115,
-0.2843865752220154,
0.053759582340717316,
-0.2417488694190979,
0.27147963643074036,
0.4678210914134979,
0.20138083398342133,
0.3194657564163208,
-0.26544347405433655,
0.3321200907230377,
0.41878023743629456,
-0.41832655668258667,
-0.5452516078948975,
0.674860954284668,
0.20046229660511017,
0.4841127097606659,
0.564339280128479,
0.1348220854997635,
-0.3597141206264496,
0.7653995156288147,
0.23910143971443176,
1.0120033025741577,
-0.11809636652469635,
0.1917244791984558,
0.4291348457336426,
0.43895766139030457,
-0.04601467028260231,
0.37321242690086365,
-0.1799096316099167,
-0.6736299991607666,
-0.4898837208747864,
-0.3732820749282837,
-0.23686154186725616,
0.03180499002337456,
-0.9871676564216614,
0.28165221214294434,
-0.47456926107406616,
-0.3444957137107849,
-0.16415603458881378,
0.015266424044966698,
-0.9345566034317017,
0.7637647390365601,
0.21434645354747772,
0.8483002781867981,
-0.7422679662704468,
0.9222524762153625,
0.7112292051315308,
-0.6140120625495911,
-0.6191641688346863,
-0.06771816313266754,
0.3309841752052307,
-1.27924382686615,
0.7652863264083862,
0.37248480319976807,
-0.33207809925079346,
-0.21571733057498932,
-0.1567675620317459,
-0.7560876607894897,
1.4620872735977173,
0.26634496450424194,
-0.2613619565963745,
-0.1569206863641739,
0.18284639716148376,
0.583713710308075,
-0.6237037777900696,
0.8916933536529541,
0.500781774520874,
0.6657698154449463,
0.03923190385103226,
-1.2031484842300415,
0.2745417654514313,
-0.00970082450658083,
-0.04408193752169609,
-0.19979438185691833,
-0.4315106272697449,
0.666002094745636,
-0.18915894627571106,
-0.33345091342926025,
-0.000012200572200526949,
0.16419368982315063,
0.08347555249929428,
0.3530583083629608,
0.7523672580718994,
0.4193582534790039,
0.5129196643829346,
-0.25947105884552,
1.1187024116516113,
-0.6104938387870789,
0.4632708728313446,
0.9105476140975952,
-0.26596876978874207,
0.23119981586933136,
0.29364094138145447,
-0.13475462794303894,
0.39170533418655396,
0.833210289478302,
-0.13050122559070587,
0.6064128875732422,
-0.0024472216609865427,
-0.1968047320842743,
-0.5624940991401672,
0.27554774284362793,
-0.48045647144317627,
0.8512341976165771,
0.4208996593952179,
-0.5396573543548584,
-0.6229235529899597,
0.09801577776670456,
-0.32890787720680237,
-0.2149733603000641,
-0.22171533107757568,
0.6516721248626709,
-0.07730607688426971,
-0.23299792408943176,
0.587068498134613,
-0.08046168088912964,
0.6203835606575012,
-0.6143547892570496,
0.19497598707675934,
-0.19821637868881226,
0.2333320826292038,
-0.5361870527267456,
-0.6929855346679688,
0.5463792681694031,
-0.2313106209039688,
0.1344996839761734,
-0.3615999221801758,
0.44839152693748474,
0.14562317728996277,
-0.41212013363838196,
0.3315638601779938,
0.6755608320236206,
0.3324611485004425,
-0.11374527961015701,
-1.0069139003753662,
0.3237016797065735,
-0.012352515012025833,
-0.17536042630672455,
0.2778070867061615,
0.2280520796775818,
-0.0952381044626236,
0.7150909900665283,
0.43233948945999146,
0.09343966841697693,
-0.3692896068096161,
0.07460569590330124,
1.0555927753448486,
-0.65123450756073,
-0.3960760235786438,
-0.5992333889007568,
0.4082146883010864,
0.1909390091896057,
-0.5055772066116333,
0.6225478053092957,
0.8965297341346741,
0.5262510180473328,
0.15275312960147858,
0.7426761388778687,
0.04504077509045601,
0.20555712282657623,
-0.5096117258071899,
0.5117462277412415,
-0.6675443053245544,
0.3995847702026367,
0.033238742500543594,
-0.6738172173500061,
-0.517664909362793,
0.6871486306190491,
-0.5094550848007202,
0.15369677543640137,
1.0651135444641113,
0.8065466284751892,
-0.1352814882993698,
-0.09249816089868546,
0.37415438890457153,
0.08308988809585571,
0.21798697113990784,
0.5759512782096863,
0.8704656362533569,
-0.3365599811077118,
0.6066937446594238,
-0.11078639328479767,
-0.31854671239852905,
-0.14786958694458008,
-0.718347430229187,
-0.6490925550460815,
-0.3749939203262329,
-0.5221455693244934,
-0.4294300675392151,
0.07701240479946136,
0.42357510328292847,
0.8391627669334412,
-0.35099419951438904,
-0.1440654695034027,
0.313459187746048,
-0.20370469987392426,
-0.2370160073041916,
-0.16101574897766113,
0.8076483011245728,
-0.2502572238445282,
-0.6565326452255249,
0.5755867958068848,
0.7014217972755432,
-0.13421358168125153,
-0.34077218174934387,
-0.03629451245069504,
0.34343773126602173,
-0.4551612436771393,
0.5650773048400879,
-0.3089095950126648,
-0.8264045715332031,
-0.5309022665023804,
0.041640911251306534,
-0.30670320987701416,
0.3968326151371002,
0.7506259083747864,
-0.9212368726730347,
0.898568868637085,
0.22969365119934082,
0.2523021996021271,
0.5295077562332153,
0.0934656485915184,
0.4770834445953369,
-0.12772026658058167,
0.01866096630692482,
0.422242671251297,
0.44176608324050903,
0.17972753942012787,
-0.32007449865341187,
0.5683618187904358,
0.4443967044353485,
-0.3560657203197479,
-0.6021632552146912,
0.05398747697472572,
-1.329959511756897,
-0.08072467893362045,
1.1379265785217285,
-0.2534392476081848,
-0.20894299447536469,
-0.4214099049568176,
-0.060484036803245544,
0.031620822846889496,
-0.06933676451444626,
0.668792724609375,
0.3713533282279968,
-0.5991347432136536,
-0.18665263056755066,
-0.4885672926902771,
0.4980626106262207,
0.10606243461370468,
-0.7030712366104126,
-0.469286173582077,
0.9072583913803101,
0.7636299133300781,
-0.015807777643203735,
0.8956828117370605,
-0.563603401184082,
0.6624948382377625,
-0.29877233505249023,
-0.006902752444148064,
-0.44838157296180725,
-0.029140841215848923,
-0.6811457872390747,
0.2177412062883377,
-0.18759489059448242,
-0.40428948402404785
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.05676v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.05676v1
|
PipeRAG: Fast Retrieval-Augmented Generation via Algorithm-System Co-design
| 2024-03-08T21:09:20 | 2024-03-08T21:09:20 |
Wenqi Jiang, Shuai Zhang, Boran Han, Jie Wang, Bernie Wang, Tim Kraska
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) can enhance the generation quality of
large language models (LLMs) by incorporating external token databases.
However, retrievals from large databases can constitute a substantial portion
of the overall generation time, particularly when retrievals are periodically
performed to align the retrieved content with the latest states of generation.
In this paper, we introduce PipeRAG, a novel algorithm-system co-design
approach to reduce generation latency and enhance generation quality. PipeRAG
integrates (1) pipeline parallelism to enable concurrent retrieval and
generation processes, (2) flexible retrieval intervals to maximize the
efficiency of pipeline parallelism, and (3) a performance model to
automatically balance retrieval quality and latency based on the generation
states and underlying hardware. Our evaluation shows that, by combining the
three aforementioned methods, PipeRAG achieves up to 2.6$\times$ speedup in
end-to-end generation latency while improving generation quality. These
promising results showcase the effectiveness of co-designing algorithms with
underlying systems, paving the way for the adoption of PipeRAG in future RAG
systems.
|
[
-0.5075260400772095,
-0.6674854755401611,
0.1603238582611084,
0.3429880738258362,
-0.5012190341949463,
0.7912523746490479,
-0.04207891970872879,
-0.34496963024139404,
0.5513325333595276,
0.222190260887146,
-0.12057365477085114,
-0.21094532310962677,
-0.2839466333389282,
-0.16074807941913605,
-0.23974229395389557,
0.5636906027793884,
0.17182870209217072,
-0.11701054126024246,
0.050975169986486435,
0.1415432244539261,
-0.6196219325065613,
-0.32557976245880127,
-0.7534970045089722,
-0.23826943337917328,
0.6647453904151917,
0.5614546537399292,
0.7943949699401855,
0.6182518601417542,
0.5822288990020752,
0.1646512746810913,
-0.21022097766399384,
0.2728153169155121,
-0.781988263130188,
0.6072299480438232,
-0.18829765915870667,
-0.35133180022239685,
-0.6432965993881226,
-0.4901474714279175,
0.6090294718742371,
0.5004724860191345,
0.015219581313431263,
0.31877511739730835,
0.20796741545200348,
0.5944714546203613,
-0.8806124925613403,
-0.05593673139810562,
-0.743651807308197,
0.009141444228589535,
-0.522297203540802,
-0.6136475801467896,
-0.519325852394104,
-0.4223214089870453,
-0.15732383728027344,
-0.5820847749710083,
0.32529324293136597,
0.5539794564247131,
0.8135627508163452,
0.1402350217103958,
-0.07594453543424606,
-0.330972820520401,
-0.47572237253189087,
0.8314019441604614,
-0.41956445574760437,
0.39375385642051697,
-0.09461943060159683,
0.37257257103919983,
-0.5989050269126892,
-0.8469027280807495,
-0.4375765025615692,
0.18854396045207977,
-0.1357443481683731,
-0.10807769000530243,
0.08439633995294571,
0.010426759719848633,
0.107363760471344,
0.6255102157592773,
-0.7569224238395691,
0.02841784618794918,
-0.2456309050321579,
-0.38795173168182373,
0.6565690040588379,
0.05942973494529724,
0.10056890547275543,
-0.38204118609428406,
-0.22389067709445953,
-0.06228585168719292,
-0.9023852348327637,
-0.09528352320194244,
0.4288718104362488,
0.4484967887401581,
0.25513365864753723,
0.46424925327301025,
-0.2238280028104782,
0.5078427195549011,
0.2705168128013611,
0.038435522466897964,
0.1910213828086853,
-0.5580476522445679,
-0.10337427258491516,
0.1565103381872177,
0.7146319150924683,
0.03331778571009636,
-0.26569607853889465,
-0.1525358259677887,
-0.3258413076400757,
0.23450233042240143,
-0.02315278723835945,
-0.8841986060142517,
-0.1424226462841034,
0.3077741265296936,
-0.45866161584854126,
-0.36996757984161377,
-0.3149290382862091,
-1.0522525310516357,
-0.25431516766548157,
-0.036411914974451065,
0.2871714234352112,
-0.3179646134376526,
-0.2882530689239502,
-0.21981818974018097,
-0.24759727716445923,
0.38877636194229126,
-0.07020604610443115,
-0.6766188144683838,
0.26567766070365906,
1.014356017112732,
1.0873922109603882,
-0.1943397969007492,
0.21815726161003113,
-1.4018436670303345,
0.2471332997083664,
-0.6230444312095642,
0.8043339848518372,
-0.7921292185783386,
-0.571697473526001,
-0.19540803134441376,
-0.4200592637062073,
0.33046165108680725,
-0.5327867865562439,
0.6041749715805054,
-1.0874395370483398,
0.189025416970253,
-0.23942066729068756,
-0.4747850000858307,
0.2603250741958618,
-0.322567880153656,
-0.5394978523254395,
1.0285507440567017,
-0.0823013186454773,
-0.8083153963088989,
0.42826181650161743,
-0.5039315223693848,
-0.3743076026439667,
0.5113425850868225,
-0.26452288031578064,
-0.7077816724777222,
0.28634706139564514,
0.2289937436580658,
0.24096064269542694,
-0.420181542634964,
0.5870668292045593,
-0.2839551270008087,
-0.6422116756439209,
-0.3314945697784424,
-0.11062317341566086,
0.8776770830154419,
0.9293119311332703,
-0.12019485980272293,
-0.13952721655368805,
-0.8452199101448059,
0.40365371108055115,
-0.032045550644397736,
-0.5206964612007141,
-0.4491698741912842,
-0.1142207533121109,
0.0003387266187928617,
0.028903432190418243,
0.43300071358680725,
-0.3775066137313843,
0.26291948556900024,
-0.41381561756134033,
-0.07967332005500793,
0.6404324769973755,
-0.05506400018930435,
0.6296793818473816,
-0.4589301645755768,
0.6846592426300049,
-0.23766838014125824,
-0.10845877230167389,
-0.3468746542930603,
-0.3456900417804718,
-0.9109743237495422,
-0.4655018150806427,
0.5508339405059814,
0.17045998573303223,
-1.0357604026794434,
0.4933393895626068,
-0.270285040140152,
-0.5358485579490662,
-0.6213814616203308,
0.10787627846002579,
0.7881274223327637,
0.3200262784957886,
0.13899871706962585,
-0.9549919366836548,
-0.8085794448852539,
-0.4348270893096924,
-0.46202459931373596,
0.00920839048922062,
0.027878817170858383,
0.36537644267082214,
0.05498102307319641,
-0.0347328744828701,
0.9682955741882324,
-0.3743307590484619,
0.1650274395942688,
0.12380426377058029,
0.47790929675102234,
0.32496464252471924,
0.5094704031944275,
0.4554976224899292,
-0.5546842217445374,
-0.7583658695220947,
-0.012787580490112305,
-0.6148442029953003,
-0.6833562254905701,
0.31824350357055664,
-0.31078964471817017,
0.4650340974330902,
0.4423075020313263,
-0.22855225205421448,
0.3482417166233063,
0.6261072754859924,
-0.36224472522735596,
0.6140027046203613,
-0.30357620120048523,
0.052484557032585144,
-0.986346960067749,
0.22289451956748962,
-0.5957803726196289,
-0.3261357247829437,
-0.3797289729118347,
0.41012969613075256,
-0.08583185821771622,
-0.3056281507015228,
-0.3891597390174866,
0.5190845131874084,
-0.7552111744880676,
-0.5256837606430054,
-0.36719638109207153,
-0.1588917374610901,
0.24275392293930054,
0.31319281458854675,
-0.5108627676963806,
1.323348879814148,
0.4451953172683716,
-0.6994300484657288,
0.22523973882198334,
-0.06579264253377914,
-0.31507933139801025,
0.7785791158676147,
-0.6676907539367676,
0.5137220621109009,
-0.1988876760005951,
0.2642655074596405,
-0.7907993793487549,
-0.2714252769947052,
0.04497852921485901,
-0.46800121665000916,
0.2566782832145691,
-0.16326601803302765,
-0.6892590522766113,
0.006457317620515823,
-0.15673114359378815,
0.5043255686759949,
0.6523275971412659,
-0.7722834348678589,
0.4331582188606262,
0.5254056453704834,
-0.346889853477478,
-0.5361604690551758,
-0.25914639234542847,
0.3429740071296692,
-0.22988393902778625,
-0.7712454199790955,
0.5636991858482361,
0.016470354050397873,
-0.2697148025035858,
-0.020334873348474503,
0.23588021099567413,
0.015974119305610657,
0.014869129285216331,
-0.19895663857460022,
0.03775005042552948,
-0.018537238240242004,
0.48116543889045715,
0.31534722447395325,
-0.20065553486347198,
-0.4258376657962799,
-0.499248206615448,
0.9184812307357788,
0.14037922024726868,
-0.16640321910381317,
-0.3071933388710022,
0.5168673992156982,
0.27580034732818604,
-0.5292724967002869,
0.5114725232124329,
0.5930663347244263,
0.06193718686699867,
-0.27887600660324097,
-0.3519153892993927,
0.04116228222846985,
-0.5149075984954834,
-0.05672512203454971,
-0.7746316194534302,
-0.6989700198173523,
0.4704584777355194,
-0.2715390622615814,
0.0838785469532013,
0.22953106462955475,
0.5542107224464417,
-0.047606322914361954,
0.8598729968070984,
0.5146588087081909,
0.09075625240802765,
0.788053572177887,
-0.3112029731273651,
0.18056543171405792,
-0.8024151921272278,
-0.02879798598587513,
-0.6367385983467102,
-0.3097385764122009,
-0.8271985650062561,
-0.6795876026153564,
0.5322980284690857,
0.2882555425167084,
-0.3742195963859558,
0.15091398358345032,
-0.7957828044891357,
0.2594977021217346,
0.8419027328491211,
-0.12577824294567108,
0.5939863920211792,
0.3062562644481659,
-0.5124760866165161,
0.05796937271952629,
-1.0688210725784302,
-0.36996176838874817,
1.2504974603652954,
0.01821776106953621,
0.8556973934173584,
0.3487513065338135,
1.11627197265625,
0.3986244201660156,
-0.0799388587474823,
-0.41257208585739136,
0.5907383561134338,
-0.14406660199165344,
-0.5377210378646851,
-0.051878441125154495,
-0.49390920996665955,
-1.2628952264785767,
0.21371150016784668,
-0.09597872942686081,
-0.27600252628326416,
0.3322131633758545,
0.15005244314670563,
-0.22191129624843597,
-0.05049394443631172,
-0.8619271516799927,
0.1699642390012741,
-0.2754381000995636,
-1.0067460536956787,
-0.48783114552497864,
-0.39009523391723633,
0.3182731866836548,
-0.16872699558734894,
0.29602372646331787,
0.18975360691547394,
-0.07560349255800247,
0.6447471380233765,
-0.7621713876724243,
0.18463978171348572,
-0.322610080242157,
-0.13121838867664337,
0.5296476483345032,
0.14538803696632385,
0.8524007201194763,
-0.05161289498209953,
-0.21340994536876678,
-0.09556117653846741,
-0.21533171832561493,
-0.6233122944831848,
-0.5978472232818604,
0.9835143685340881,
-0.5383599400520325,
-0.5701383352279663,
-0.5393851399421692,
-0.4986759424209595,
0.15419518947601318,
0.35451066493988037,
-0.08612366020679474,
0.40250328183174133,
0.06457898020744324,
0.19079118967056274,
0.47439855337142944,
-0.4339931607246399,
0.44333046674728394,
0.23952889442443848,
-0.51181960105896,
-0.5573041439056396,
1.1591497659683228,
0.37753042578697205,
0.27364110946655273,
0.19072982668876648,
0.18064236640930176,
-0.30350789427757263,
-0.5347339510917664,
-0.08285194635391235,
0.28278207778930664,
-0.2466520220041275,
-0.16167543828487396,
-0.4161689877510071,
-0.05219141021370888,
-0.6320861577987671,
-0.13836044073104858,
-0.24531103670597076,
-0.4675139784812927,
-0.2512277364730835,
0.5681400895118713,
0.43921545147895813,
0.49297577142715454,
-0.3224773108959198,
0.4697171151638031,
-0.6053065657615662,
0.49484220147132874,
0.20006534457206726,
0.849956214427948,
-0.07273450493812561,
-0.4009239077568054,
-0.2771461606025696,
-0.21190457046031952,
-0.5050201416015625,
-0.5184924006462097,
0.5552777647972107,
0.25314491987228394,
0.3201962411403656,
-0.06938064843416214,
0.14535728096961975,
0.9072533845901489,
-0.6012322306632996,
0.4944387674331665,
0.03656730800867081,
-0.856411874294281,
0.3275260627269745,
-0.39758577942848206,
0.29952362179756165,
0.17304150760173798,
0.016188109293580055,
-0.4096379280090332,
-0.17303986847400665,
-0.5579927563667297,
-0.8709990978240967,
0.3862878382205963,
0.3581620156764984,
-0.318673312664032,
0.1439075618982315,
0.29118478298187256,
0.14951977133750916,
0.22187922894954681,
0.018462494015693665,
-0.04359831288456917,
0.022587817162275314,
-0.09138958901166916,
-0.02266460284590721,
-0.27670925855636597,
-0.046692222356796265,
0.0876857116818428,
0.7481523156166077,
-0.2784286439418793,
0.4434564411640167,
0.07756494730710983,
0.01711495965719223,
-0.19688569009304047,
0.3911609649658203,
0.14436261355876923,
0.6200708150863647,
-0.2962006628513336,
0.0431511364877224,
-0.12182480096817017,
-0.2072494626045227,
0.34483009576797485,
0.18780408799648285,
-0.3805357813835144,
0.3563039302825928,
-0.09610715508460999,
0.567289412021637,
-0.11260837316513062,
-0.44186046719551086,
0.19375045597553253,
-0.28601619601249695,
0.20836760103702545,
-0.299672931432724,
0.14634793996810913,
-0.038692839443683624,
0.4230386018753052,
0.5411218404769897,
-0.08240290731191635,
0.19071388244628906,
-0.49319955706596375,
0.45676228404045105,
0.6535806059837341,
0.22972649335861206,
-0.17094044387340546,
0.839747965335846,
0.4191897511482239,
-0.7895725965499878,
0.05635116621851921,
-0.5061325430870056,
-0.1033715009689331,
0.22805695235729218,
0.24366945028305054,
0.8638104200363159,
-0.07014048844575882,
-0.046957917511463165,
0.25372087955474854,
-0.2450972944498062,
0.14034302532672882,
0.5242738127708435,
-0.18749500811100006,
-0.19369399547576904,
-0.7158183455467224,
-0.8847405314445496,
-0.4370463192462921,
-0.11626948416233063,
-0.41438135504722595,
0.5851409435272217,
-0.3587159514427185,
-0.17729558050632477,
-0.2234497219324112,
0.435324490070343,
-0.7381393313407898,
0.07923194020986557,
-0.20976974070072174,
0.6400138139724731,
-0.30739864706993103,
0.7484499216079712,
0.2735137641429901,
-0.3437122702598572,
-0.5907473564147949,
-0.09950393438339233,
-0.2023378610610962,
-0.6750614643096924,
0.7859225869178772,
-0.22551481425762177,
-0.3208461105823517,
0.20573312044143677,
-0.4218989908695221,
-1.123751163482666,
1.1115200519561768,
0.43744319677352905,
-0.8858619332313538,
-0.13395707309246063,
-0.0626671090722084,
0.6978447437286377,
-0.3455013036727905,
0.4398793876171112,
0.44691723585128784,
0.13501635193824768,
0.2557562291622162,
-1.0650153160095215,
-0.08611802756786346,
-0.1810273826122284,
0.1869833618402481,
0.105186328291893,
-0.9349450469017029,
0.8555887341499329,
0.0794767513871193,
-0.5634775757789612,
0.21218855679035187,
0.7532888054847717,
0.7935507893562317,
0.49712708592414856,
0.385932058095932,
0.7130420207977295,
0.9151322841644287,
0.062142182141542435,
0.9226235747337341,
-0.7384077310562134,
0.4349760413169861,
1.1724908351898193,
-0.12312597781419754,
0.8123061060905457,
0.7528179883956909,
-0.04240282624959946,
0.5219525694847107,
0.4062047302722931,
0.5643025636672974,
0.6457743644714355,
0.3458823263645172,
-0.540932297706604,
0.06885223090648651,
-0.5571955442428589,
-0.5500175952911377,
0.38897576928138733,
0.310726135969162,
-0.3989522159099579,
-0.1647714376449585,
-0.2681054472923279,
0.03822315111756325,
0.10354136675596237,
-0.1516517698764801,
0.7195798754692078,
-0.11608078330755234,
-1.049455165863037,
1.0144433975219727,
-0.13790898025035858,
0.8314502239227295,
-0.027584608644247055,
-0.2037821263074875,
-0.34818100929260254,
0.18311844766139984,
-0.12755148112773895,
-0.38773390650749207,
0.39588436484336853,
0.03420567512512207,
0.057514872401952744,
-0.3287440240383148,
0.7998613715171814,
-0.3550699055194855,
-0.4384085237979889,
0.2284737378358841,
0.5605295300483704,
0.29113033413887024,
0.30706027150154114,
-0.5410058498382568,
0.49470266699790955,
-0.4821620583534241,
0.05980139970779419,
0.2231370210647583,
0.4515824019908905,
-0.0779770240187645,
0.48803022503852844,
0.689512312412262,
0.4320552945137024,
0.4596613645553589,
-0.09364922344684601,
1.0675640106201172,
-0.5386176109313965,
-0.6199113130569458,
-0.2551940679550171,
0.21855857968330383,
-0.12302926927804947,
0.3302314281463623,
0.6072770357131958,
0.7192105650901794,
0.8789666295051575,
0.239190474152565,
1.0139594078063965,
-0.28975528478622437,
0.9206792116165161,
-0.41011327505111694,
0.5699731111526489,
-0.5708715915679932,
0.5359585285186768,
-0.28374674916267395,
-0.8856425881385803,
-0.2928549349308014,
0.20304808020591736,
-0.2280646711587906,
-0.07454849034547806,
0.5367729663848877,
1.33146333694458,
-0.012856623157858849,
-0.4155593514442444,
0.3196461796760559,
0.033676858991384506,
1.0043781995773315,
0.5958989262580872,
0.520124614238739,
-0.6989578008651733,
0.7251802682876587,
0.0377841480076313,
-0.23476868867874146,
-0.48368263244628906,
-0.7305242419242859,
-0.5365780591964722,
-0.43715816736221313,
0.06717408448457718,
-0.36512136459350586,
0.6319787502288818,
0.8073880672454834,
0.6124956011772156,
-0.564489483833313,
-0.39166611433029175,
-0.4986328184604645,
0.08466228097677231,
0.0273283701390028,
-0.2661852538585663,
0.3033604025840759,
-0.920822262763977,
-0.9308648109436035,
0.4003303349018097,
0.19247685372829437,
-0.34331879019737244,
-0.5426627397537231,
-0.3690413236618042,
-0.4882211983203888,
0.06911527365446091,
0.4798297882080078,
0.296785831451416,
-0.5246752500534058,
-0.49165841937065125,
0.010221595875918865,
-0.12057933956384659,
0.23489797115325928,
0.9441778659820557,
-1.2840510606765747,
1.0838918685913086,
1.057377815246582,
0.8178231120109558,
0.5321780443191528,
0.05292944982647896,
0.7439007759094238,
-0.8358433246612549,
0.1960611641407013,
0.14101329445838928,
0.24023346602916718,
0.28562918305397034,
-0.29459622502326965,
0.34605348110198975,
0.39632725715637207,
-0.8884055018424988,
-0.7668611407279968,
0.36447301506996155,
-0.5440046787261963,
0.00507438275963068,
0.9841498732566833,
-0.09640525281429291,
-0.33939433097839355,
-0.3989270031452179,
-0.34751319885253906,
0.48771631717681885,
-0.6965714693069458,
0.8526310920715332,
0.3951801359653473,
-0.12933871150016785,
-0.259086549282074,
-0.14993755519390106,
0.4562458395957947,
0.7372850179672241,
-0.507447361946106,
-0.2355310469865799,
0.6132732033729553,
-0.09502176195383072,
0.3391585946083069,
0.7252413630485535,
-0.08883314579725266,
0.4025611877441406,
0.11874065548181534,
0.05866246297955513,
-0.0340835303068161,
-0.3164623975753784,
-0.30217376351356506,
0.5602492094039917,
0.1911526322364807,
-0.2823488712310791
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.05640v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.05640v1
|
Generating Hard-Negative Out-of-Scope Data with ChatGPT for Intent Classification
| 2024-03-08T19:25:00 | 2024-03-08T19:25:00 |
Zhijian Li, Stefan Larson, Kevin Leach
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Intent classifiers must be able to distinguish when a user's utterance does
not belong to any supported intent to avoid producing incorrect and unrelated
system responses. Although out-of-scope (OOS) detection for intent classifiers
has been studied, previous work has not yet studied changes in classifier
performance against hard-negative out-of-scope utterances (i.e., inputs that
share common features with in-scope data, but are actually out-of-scope). We
present an automated technique to generate hard-negative OOS data using
ChatGPT. We use our technique to build five new hard-negative OOS datasets, and
evaluate each against three benchmark intent classifiers. We show that
classifiers struggle to correctly identify hard-negative OOS utterances more
than general OOS utterances. Finally, we show that incorporating hard-negative
OOS data for training improves model robustness when detecting hard-negative
OOS data and general OOS data. Our technique, datasets, and evaluation address
an important void in the field, offering a straightforward and inexpensive way
to collect hard-negative OOS data and improve intent classifiers' robustness.
|
[
-0.3700646460056305,
-0.5735160708427429,
0.6017062067985535,
-0.4466283619403839,
-0.07398296147584915,
-0.3058723509311676,
-0.24309644103050232,
-0.3679918050765991,
-0.0259078498929739,
0.5985682606697083,
-0.6004099249839783,
-0.6102178692817688,
-0.5092629194259644,
-0.2026905119419098,
-0.42747366428375244,
1.2277281284332275,
0.13615652918815613,
-0.12678951025009155,
-0.06794212013483047,
-0.16893696784973145,
-0.9296523928642273,
-0.5687567591667175,
-0.4806680977344513,
-0.2971574664115906,
-0.04128069430589676,
1.0352427959442139,
0.4267892837524414,
0.0021006951574236155,
0.5755984783172607,
0.20122654736042023,
0.2664163410663605,
0.03967069461941719,
-0.7364638447761536,
0.2331816405057907,
0.011600234545767307,
-0.26733630895614624,
-0.5103193521499634,
-0.008320886641740799,
0.37874284386634827,
0.49379774928092957,
-0.1735639125108719,
0.32265928387641907,
-0.040776051580905914,
0.47885504364967346,
-0.6262937784194946,
0.39999645948410034,
-0.7532405257225037,
0.14347606897354126,
-0.48684123158454895,
-0.2511926293373108,
-0.568505048751831,
-0.27575933933258057,
0.3282310664653778,
-0.43012985587120056,
0.4054833948612213,
-0.14462082087993622,
0.7101877927780151,
0.09628543257713318,
-0.2675026059150696,
-0.6843627691268921,
-0.7574777603149414,
0.7523549199104309,
-0.7366716861724854,
0.4329560399055481,
0.4777557849884033,
0.41267454624176025,
-0.40615782141685486,
-0.19782184064388275,
-0.4952598810195923,
-0.3590961694717407,
-0.0046000005677342415,
0.19692362844944,
-0.033873941749334335,
0.1490539014339447,
0.280577152967453,
0.35092517733573914,
-0.4267880916595459,
-0.10328309237957001,
-0.5438007116317749,
-0.13179756700992584,
0.703960657119751,
0.0436147004365921,
0.059217579662799835,
-0.22124794125556946,
-0.14087867736816406,
-0.23419371247291565,
-0.6601276397705078,
0.03619150072336197,
0.48975807428359985,
0.5884963870048523,
0.09312774240970612,
1.0832494497299194,
-0.3626566231250763,
0.39228591322898865,
0.1777781993150711,
-0.0576794296503067,
0.44965672492980957,
0.02189532108604908,
-0.11349700391292572,
0.41453924775123596,
0.6809977889060974,
0.2447649985551834,
0.018976911902427673,
-0.42639318108558655,
-0.2691252529621124,
0.2111230194568634,
0.15355104207992554,
-0.828803300857544,
0.11144731193780899,
0.32599765062332153,
-0.2578980624675751,
-0.29199379682540894,
0.09094664454460144,
-0.37745416164398193,
-0.5795498490333557,
-0.19129684567451477,
0.6563054323196411,
-0.5310195088386536,
-0.15283255279064178,
0.3629625737667084,
-0.29263728857040405,
0.21964585781097412,
0.14739130437374115,
-0.7286196351051331,
0.4002104103565216,
0.7302502989768982,
0.675305187702179,
-0.05020320042967796,
-0.2015533596277237,
-0.8454281091690063,
-0.12529829144477844,
-0.15357591211795807,
0.5700772404670715,
-0.39476877450942993,
-0.3481910824775696,
-0.14157643914222717,
-0.12431806325912476,
-0.1186947226524353,
-0.4719209671020508,
0.8348664045333862,
-0.5611070990562439,
0.5562343001365662,
0.03289150446653366,
-0.9012226462364197,
-0.4045107960700989,
0.3318188786506653,
-0.3113441467285156,
0.7277961373329163,
0.12029312551021576,
-0.4258955419063568,
0.7329501509666443,
-1.1405266523361206,
-0.39145427942276,
0.24437537789344788,
-0.3797588348388672,
-0.7377089262008667,
0.14459627866744995,
-0.1270330548286438,
0.588716983795166,
-0.15139126777648926,
0.26225489377975464,
-0.4942207634449005,
-0.5154123902320862,
0.28089675307273865,
-0.6366993188858032,
0.6047630906105042,
0.03349708393216133,
-0.46156254410743713,
-0.2353082150220871,
-0.7279635667800903,
0.150589719414711,
-0.005767388269305229,
-0.2078789919614792,
-0.36358731985092163,
0.2943752706050873,
-0.2322455197572708,
0.0709981843829155,
0.060720134526491165,
-0.9271682500839233,
0.2756927013397217,
-0.3286082446575165,
0.50443035364151,
0.48900988698005676,
-0.10513615608215332,
0.4302610456943512,
-0.23994670808315277,
0.2956315875053406,
0.013187343254685402,
0.24954910576343536,
0.04231351241469383,
-0.7593762874603271,
-0.5355342030525208,
-0.01305944100022316,
-0.03253660723567009,
0.4959432780742645,
-0.5020592212677002,
0.5112799406051636,
-0.4898689389228821,
-0.4258924126625061,
-0.09796198457479477,
0.1226605698466301,
0.3796063959598541,
0.8508940935134888,
0.3818167746067047,
-0.6214597225189209,
-0.27193862199783325,
-0.30849263072013855,
0.008882765658199787,
-0.3679491877555847,
-0.0804753229022026,
0.8395406007766724,
0.49627357721328735,
-0.33033767342567444,
1.1465779542922974,
-0.7322219610214233,
-0.6541677117347717,
0.034953612834215164,
0.37485837936401367,
0.25109919905662537,
0.22893714904785156,
0.2566549479961395,
-0.9459766149520874,
-0.19628086686134338,
-0.16099512577056885,
-0.5240416526794434,
-0.05351127311587334,
0.07625783234834671,
0.06990387290716171,
0.14721666276454926,
0.528014063835144,
-0.561303436756134,
0.42269471287727356,
0.4425065219402313,
-0.545894205570221,
0.31202709674835205,
0.006805467419326305,
0.15176378190517426,
-0.747525155544281,
0.03710328787565231,
-0.2860371172428131,
-0.10346958041191101,
-0.6900432109832764,
-0.3801785409450531,
0.00175357679836452,
-0.3853199779987335,
-0.8320016264915466,
0.38106587529182434,
-0.2114471197128296,
0.026391243562102318,
-0.023236550390720367,
0.051828861236572266,
-0.04383952170610428,
0.5295581221580505,
0.35242587327957153,
0.5776039361953735,
0.32984843850135803,
-0.644111692905426,
0.3275195062160492,
0.28492066264152527,
-0.28792768716812134,
0.5157268643379211,
-0.31575480103492737,
0.24059493839740753,
-0.10348633676767349,
0.39138439297676086,
-1.2229949235916138,
-0.5960845351219177,
0.7330011129379272,
-0.3967285454273224,
0.2105547934770584,
-0.690513551235199,
-0.06104940548539162,
-0.2972111999988556,
-0.46227186918258667,
0.607705295085907,
0.45779314637184143,
-0.5216975212097168,
0.24979017674922943,
0.5523455142974854,
0.1811554729938507,
-0.3319399952888489,
-0.7784017324447632,
-0.03308485075831413,
-0.49255838990211487,
-0.49198833107948303,
0.24047888815402985,
0.15242093801498413,
0.10050541907548904,
-0.09150242805480957,
0.2432134747505188,
-0.2508503794670105,
-0.21269187331199646,
0.5678023099899292,
0.14740419387817383,
-0.2658272385597229,
0.44289538264274597,
-0.18203239142894745,
-0.06516575813293457,
0.04442058131098747,
-0.347817063331604,
0.6719173789024353,
-0.2991575300693512,
-0.7863478660583496,
-0.42409664392471313,
0.19113104045391083,
0.6173065304756165,
0.19930008053779602,
0.3297436833381653,
0.47733208537101746,
-0.188455268740654,
0.12461164593696594,
-0.5450376272201538,
-0.29076358675956726,
-0.4914807975292206,
0.15579134225845337,
-0.02716841548681259,
-0.45619648694992065,
0.2071685940027237,
0.1252290904521942,
0.0645872950553894,
0.152723029255867,
0.2149803787469864,
0.04570424556732178,
0.9377790689468384,
0.4072849154472351,
0.08265727013349533,
0.7221764922142029,
-0.3561563193798065,
0.11480585485696793,
-0.7923234701156616,
0.16780735552310944,
-0.18150240182876587,
-0.07868315279483795,
-0.709873616695404,
-0.20570605993270874,
0.36480802297592163,
-0.25950488448143005,
-0.22739554941654205,
0.4456891715526581,
-0.7237786054611206,
0.5187063813209534,
0.5396865010261536,
0.37757089734077454,
0.30640774965286255,
-0.1868378221988678,
0.6826754808425903,
0.21241538226604462,
-0.4444916248321533,
-0.4773738384246826,
1.4726886749267578,
0.2519500255584717,
0.7811988592147827,
0.3195606470108032,
1.020874261856079,
0.37275081872940063,
0.5056886076927185,
-1.371350646018982,
0.3947787284851074,
-0.3768717050552368,
-0.8411905169487,
-0.6395044922828674,
-0.5395272374153137,
-0.8317574262619019,
-0.041268471628427505,
0.064523845911026,
-0.7663130164146423,
0.362454891204834,
0.3289673626422882,
-0.5547471046447754,
0.17367441952228546,
-1.4169074296951294,
0.899593710899353,
-0.020628446713089943,
0.0040982007049024105,
0.3562512695789337,
-0.39968129992485046,
0.38248008489608765,
0.005120500922203064,
-0.07118991762399673,
-0.21054162085056305,
0.2756252586841583,
0.7689133286476135,
-0.37748420238494873,
1.062114953994751,
-0.5398960113525391,
-0.23374634981155396,
0.7693700790405273,
-0.01066482812166214,
0.5562322735786438,
0.2482302486896515,
-0.0505792461335659,
0.4346812963485718,
-0.24888768792152405,
-0.031974829733371735,
-0.185988187789917,
0.3261880576610565,
-0.6190594434738159,
-0.25757238268852234,
-0.3173833191394806,
-0.34104064106941223,
-0.4267233908176422,
0.3811485171318054,
0.6316502690315247,
0.5272611379623413,
-0.243934765458107,
0.24428650736808777,
0.532849133014679,
-0.05991210415959358,
0.1794660985469818,
0.5068386793136597,
0.1479029655456543,
0.07736081629991531,
1.1978994607925415,
0.34076908230781555,
0.1737387776374817,
0.3121315836906433,
0.34149113297462463,
-0.5172292590141296,
-0.4881371259689331,
-0.6131789684295654,
-0.26681721210479736,
-0.47521069645881653,
-0.3917616307735443,
-0.2894804775714874,
-0.35243991017341614,
-0.3750978410243988,
-0.06923647969961166,
-0.4717746078968048,
-0.3382645547389984,
-0.14477278292179108,
0.40799352526664734,
0.30289849638938904,
0.5733791589736938,
-0.04402593895792961,
0.39658522605895996,
-0.7464987635612488,
0.41053304076194763,
0.4307001233100891,
0.38931652903556824,
-0.3418637812137604,
-0.45528584718704224,
0.15232130885124207,
0.3727826774120331,
-0.5830119252204895,
-0.714459240436554,
0.2780061662197113,
0.4156445860862732,
-0.011109240353107452,
0.44835880398750305,
0.20254409313201904,
0.4865831434726715,
-0.4813764989376068,
0.6619200110435486,
0.2355240285396576,
-1.0640069246292114,
0.5169435739517212,
-0.5457203388214111,
0.19322074949741364,
0.6884835362434387,
0.12248525023460388,
-0.6093615293502808,
-0.3462371230125427,
-0.49061688780784607,
-0.9323065280914307,
1.3443995714187622,
0.45699194073677063,
0.19706173241138458,
0.002199906390160322,
0.20273591578006744,
0.398055762052536,
0.2320774495601654,
-0.6697384119033813,
0.09631741046905518,
-0.24653561413288116,
-0.08836153149604797,
-0.2026452124118805,
0.031998757272958755,
-0.19322188198566437,
0.17077498137950897,
0.711018443107605,
-0.23721885681152344,
0.4395217001438141,
0.17422902584075928,
-0.2532340884208679,
-0.1311120092868805,
0.5769045948982239,
0.5857810378074646,
0.20554114878177643,
-0.6529914736747742,
-0.22027908265590668,
0.3156900703907013,
-0.9206799268722534,
0.2808343768119812,
0.02818954363465309,
-0.1099223643541336,
-0.1858665645122528,
0.009730496443808079,
0.44026994705200195,
-0.18805472552776337,
-0.7103236317634583,
1.002751350402832,
-0.5440064072608948,
-0.17865806818008423,
-0.5033320784568787,
0.2783275842666626,
-0.39779388904571533,
0.05051681026816368,
0.17655740678310394,
0.3416087031364441,
0.5825720429420471,
-0.41108354926109314,
0.031413543969392776,
0.34888654947280884,
-0.45764464139938354,
-0.23109954595565796,
0.10124450922012329,
0.29411864280700684,
-0.14527612924575806,
0.6182782053947449,
-0.6606924533843994,
-0.32889804244041443,
0.5591338872909546,
0.3111236095428467,
0.9848224520683289,
0.18568994104862213,
0.34100770950317383,
0.025973716750741005,
-0.014100312255322933,
0.0005521130515262485,
0.3300974667072296,
-0.32045215368270874,
-0.8188318610191345,
-0.32392290234565735,
-0.167825385928154,
-0.7246763706207275,
0.5968589782714844,
-0.7688509225845337,
0.6838939189910889,
-0.10992538183927536,
-0.3034193217754364,
0.03125275671482086,
-0.10474894195795059,
-0.7877347469329834,
0.22369970381259918,
0.4235740005970001,
0.2932117283344269,
-0.6949016451835632,
0.4746737778186798,
0.5545870065689087,
-0.04133142530918121,
-0.5743898153305054,
0.2451428920030594,
0.13858987390995026,
-0.7990850806236267,
0.6117671132087708,
0.44498926401138306,
-0.47441744804382324,
-0.19764681160449982,
-0.30573588609695435,
-0.7472193241119385,
0.9538503885269165,
0.27899232506752014,
-0.6730964183807373,
0.1833946406841278,
0.4186752736568451,
0.405719518661499,
-0.026110148057341576,
0.3735392093658447,
0.18939918279647827,
0.3185889720916748,
0.1993112415075302,
-0.8130581378936768,
0.0376310795545578,
0.10606551170349121,
-0.5486294031143188,
0.5539379119873047,
-0.46281641721725464,
0.7934779524803162,
-0.15938150882720947,
-0.5399752855300903,
-0.21648558974266052,
0.11102037876844406,
-0.12300942838191986,
0.6520058512687683,
0.6050213575363159,
0.5382100939750671,
0.6582789421081543,
-0.16530680656433105,
0.4668472707271576,
-0.06825070083141327,
0.6351468563079834,
1.189611554145813,
-0.4275398850440979,
0.7831758260726929,
0.3099275529384613,
0.13828246295452118,
0.08813624829053879,
0.354474276304245,
0.190131276845932,
0.6608797311782837,
0.049522075802087784,
-0.31944915652275085,
-0.07178390026092529,
0.026681900024414062,
-0.5646838545799255,
0.9779951572418213,
0.5871616005897522,
-0.11035747826099396,
-0.44079428911209106,
0.08633322268724442,
-0.21161220967769623,
-0.6610314846038818,
-0.15303292870521545,
0.9327468872070312,
-0.16025526821613312,
-0.8551051616668701,
0.7023542523384094,
-0.2235678732395172,
0.8159368634223938,
-0.460891455411911,
-0.042829062789678574,
0.00396358547732234,
0.5433329343795776,
-0.39698469638824463,
-0.9795494079589844,
0.37444406747817993,
0.12723127007484436,
-0.012302644550800323,
-0.08317529410123825,
0.8463878631591797,
-0.3004988729953766,
-0.10630181431770325,
0.1253976672887802,
0.3222897946834564,
0.30176854133605957,
-0.16542068123817444,
-0.42322683334350586,
-0.2641054093837738,
-0.23277360200881958,
-0.2808631956577301,
0.014375710859894753,
0.5886567831039429,
-0.14152109622955322,
0.4100940227508545,
0.7485706806182861,
-0.13925737142562866,
-0.07422272861003876,
0.0891004353761673,
0.8587461113929749,
-0.5328466296195984,
-0.405637264251709,
-0.8570974469184875,
0.12005499750375748,
-0.04775305092334747,
-0.6931140422821045,
0.564970850944519,
0.4541749060153961,
0.9236231446266174,
0.0458778440952301,
0.8799798488616943,
-0.49990612268447876,
0.4777742028236389,
-0.2900073230266571,
0.629709780216217,
-0.4337044060230255,
0.2408466637134552,
-0.21244078874588013,
-0.6395960450172424,
-0.2667348086833954,
0.32446083426475525,
-0.8071208000183105,
0.07402107864618301,
0.14640465378761292,
0.7682544589042664,
-0.6287480592727661,
0.2355547696352005,
0.23045377433300018,
0.0331139899790287,
0.6482996940612793,
0.696449339389801,
1.003039002418518,
-0.7470840215682983,
0.9205177426338196,
-0.31549060344696045,
-0.392646461725235,
-0.5642661452293396,
-0.9417299032211304,
-0.8388156294822693,
-0.5557888746261597,
-0.22847473621368408,
-0.27390843629837036,
-0.032348647713661194,
0.7298527956008911,
0.9950172305107117,
-0.9196502566337585,
-0.21986399590969086,
-0.71144700050354,
0.04387024790048599,
0.0038144364953041077,
-0.36454761028289795,
0.23853106796741486,
-0.45129701495170593,
-0.47634202241897583,
0.2636720538139343,
0.13138937950134277,
0.05529990792274475,
0.00615445151925087,
-0.2042204588651657,
0.17840194702148438,
0.09411595016717911,
0.6781915426254272,
0.568506121635437,
-0.12269532680511475,
-0.4229484498500824,
-0.030062329024076462,
-0.016558639705181122,
0.15467427670955658,
0.5917063355445862,
-0.5681396722793579,
0.4801635444164276,
0.41796618700027466,
0.15550237894058228,
0.4026351273059845,
-0.013689938001334667,
0.23326405882835388,
-1.031084418296814,
0.047140609472990036,
0.6563223004341125,
0.10691981762647629,
0.24066105484962463,
-0.5679882168769836,
0.36029931902885437,
-0.057803720235824585,
-0.6800240278244019,
-0.979434609413147,
0.19250142574310303,
-0.8437209725379944,
0.014669445343315601,
1.2761038541793823,
-0.041446503251791,
-0.17983904480934143,
-0.38154688477516174,
-0.526631236076355,
0.10401878505945206,
-0.780042290687561,
1.1389135122299194,
0.5852760672569275,
-0.6374139189720154,
0.6543484926223755,
-0.2852354049682617,
0.4762440323829651,
0.28465110063552856,
-0.7689664959907532,
0.21718847751617432,
0.40805384516716003,
0.22368177771568298,
0.4789619743824005,
0.7053461074829102,
-0.09053575247526169,
0.34662380814552307,
-0.10010857880115509,
-0.03736665099859238,
0.024515239521861076,
-0.20312446355819702,
0.046911366283893585,
0.13749177753925323,
-0.13940571248531342,
-0.703669011592865
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.05636v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.05636v1
|
Tuning-Free Accountable Intervention for LLM Deployment -- A Metacognitive Approach
| 2024-03-08T19:18:53 | 2024-03-08T19:18:53 |
Zhen Tan, Jie Peng, Tianlong Chen, Huan Liu
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have catalyzed transformative advances across a
spectrum of natural language processing tasks through few-shot or zero-shot
prompting, bypassing the need for parameter tuning. While convenient, this
modus operandi aggravates ``hallucination'' concerns, particularly given the
enigmatic ``black-box'' nature behind their gigantic model sizes. Such concerns
are exacerbated in high-stakes applications (e.g., healthcare), where
unaccountable decision errors can lead to devastating consequences. In
contrast, human decision-making relies on nuanced cognitive processes, such as
the ability to sense and adaptively correct misjudgments through conceptual
understanding. Drawing inspiration from human cognition, we propose an
innovative \textit{metacognitive} approach, dubbed \textbf{CLEAR}, to equip
LLMs with capabilities for self-aware error identification and correction. Our
framework facilitates the construction of concept-specific sparse subnetworks
that illuminate transparent decision pathways. This provides a novel interface
for model \textit{intervention} after deployment. Our intervention offers
compelling advantages: (\textit{i})~at deployment or inference time, our
metacognitive LLMs can self-consciously identify potential mispredictions with
minimum human involvement, (\textit{ii})~the model has the capability to
self-correct its errors efficiently, obviating the need for additional tuning,
and (\textit{iii})~the rectification procedure is not only self-explanatory but
also user-friendly, enhancing the interpretability and accessibility of the
model. By integrating these metacognitive features, our approach pioneers a new
path toward engendering greater trustworthiness and accountability in the
deployment of LLMs.
|
[
-0.20837467908859253,
-0.6807442903518677,
0.6315944194793701,
0.28561896085739136,
-0.1406961977481842,
-0.0836939886212349,
-0.1991766095161438,
-0.3006844222545624,
0.1622675210237503,
0.7082319855690002,
-0.7644646167755127,
-0.5309231281280518,
-0.48971372842788696,
-0.004093250259757042,
-0.33689019083976746,
0.9979389309883118,
-0.15252605080604553,
-0.404784232378006,
-0.06057699769735336,
-0.11273393034934998,
-0.9879502654075623,
-0.10707995295524597,
-0.7652011513710022,
-0.44530418515205383,
0.5461727976799011,
0.6642800569534302,
0.6632229089736938,
0.7262455821037292,
0.3509923219680786,
0.29212862253189087,
0.020440079271793365,
0.5219871997833252,
-0.3822958171367645,
-0.05621828883886337,
-0.4664094150066376,
-0.419732928276062,
-0.741239070892334,
-0.0025805465411394835,
0.4474927484989166,
0.7151261568069458,
-0.6830845475196838,
0.20327551662921906,
0.33996134996414185,
0.6838365793228149,
-1.1125805377960205,
0.0820121318101883,
-0.8714276552200317,
0.0418841652572155,
0.21965014934539795,
-0.23058205842971802,
-0.540481686592102,
-0.0836837887763977,
-0.14251819252967834,
-0.9151557683944702,
0.4046008586883545,
-0.027976542711257935,
0.4743625521659851,
0.731218695640564,
-0.5133575797080994,
-0.3284528851509094,
-0.9799795746803284,
0.7174801230430603,
-0.5433716177940369,
0.3368279039859772,
0.435251384973526,
0.3338615596294403,
-0.2910561263561249,
-0.6645610928535461,
-0.432600736618042,
0.026544561609625816,
-0.08273711055517197,
0.23397763073444366,
-0.17043271660804749,
0.3340756893157959,
0.23404210805892944,
0.07696837931871414,
-0.40967658162117004,
0.3304188847541809,
-0.29249319434165955,
-0.5056545734405518,
0.6368135809898376,
0.19406749308109283,
-0.015774069353938103,
-0.06711473315954208,
-0.2345939427614212,
0.2708282768726349,
-0.6221467852592468,
-0.3759671449661255,
-0.02319108508527279,
0.257318913936615,
-0.08690663427114487,
0.5567679405212402,
-0.43667951226234436,
0.5497477650642395,
0.3381193280220032,
0.09131236374378204,
0.14693346619606018,
-0.26701006293296814,
-0.576350212097168,
0.29335489869117737,
0.6985813975334167,
0.3214157819747925,
0.4278295338153839,
-0.01487055979669094,
-0.3858436644077301,
0.18242697417736053,
0.7544785737991333,
-0.4862685203552246,
-0.18428751826286316,
0.3325698673725128,
-0.3499755561351776,
-0.30192315578460693,
-0.2900662422180176,
-0.5948553085327148,
-0.693919837474823,
-0.25605544447898865,
0.5881760716438293,
-0.386963427066803,
-0.40432047843933105,
0.3793672025203705,
0.1966371387243271,
0.06109479442238808,
0.37320783734321594,
-1.0138638019561768,
0.014178943820297718,
0.7986997365951538,
0.7679761648178101,
0.21642380952835083,
-0.15852750837802887,
-0.40352416038513184,
0.4783489406108856,
-0.5852777361869812,
0.6081564426422119,
-0.24364246428012848,
-0.4145241975784302,
0.10551363974809647,
-0.022820157930254936,
-0.218341663479805,
-0.639323890209198,
0.8374387621879578,
-0.2675277292728424,
0.0326763316988945,
-0.05778397247195244,
-0.4247933626174927,
-0.3009360730648041,
0.32449761033058167,
-0.5686704516410828,
0.7321886420249939,
-0.016252722591161728,
-0.6710229516029358,
0.42786550521850586,
-0.9141667485237122,
-0.12137998640537262,
0.1094571202993393,
-0.15646883845329285,
-0.43295928835868835,
0.3725196123123169,
0.21903680264949799,
0.43870025873184204,
0.009466000832617283,
0.31427648663520813,
-0.23214736580848694,
-0.36092063784599304,
0.1163928210735321,
-0.4009915888309479,
0.5672898292541504,
0.2616409957408905,
-0.4858785569667816,
0.2753170132637024,
-0.8406387567520142,
0.12358295172452927,
-0.1332380324602127,
0.03668848052620888,
-0.43831974267959595,
-0.026900630444288254,
-0.33917805552482605,
0.05901488661766052,
0.17109933495521545,
-0.2510107755661011,
0.04788915812969208,
-0.5190265774726868,
0.387166291475296,
0.9177127480506897,
0.12885522842407227,
0.46187686920166016,
-0.15453489124774933,
0.5140465497970581,
0.08627890795469284,
0.5245159864425659,
-0.2881389260292053,
-0.21405044198036194,
-0.8990263342857361,
-0.4606722891330719,
0.15853817760944366,
0.5765112042427063,
-0.6454655528068542,
0.5391781330108643,
-0.1662614494562149,
-0.27353525161743164,
-0.8042411804199219,
0.2780751585960388,
0.4762188792228699,
0.7327382564544678,
0.4022683799266815,
-0.02525164745748043,
-0.5955047011375427,
-1.0001308917999268,
-0.2662573754787445,
-0.10633865743875504,
0.0640658289194107,
0.23028212785720825,
0.6482371687889099,
-0.7119248509407043,
0.8469176888465881,
-0.5405140519142151,
-0.5793270468711853,
0.02292364090681076,
0.3716300129890442,
0.11431831121444702,
0.6222890615463257,
-0.04402212053537369,
-0.6245418787002563,
-0.17563457787036896,
-0.017088159918785095,
-0.8466677069664001,
-0.17949864268302917,
-0.26995784044265747,
-0.040223050862550735,
0.28707289695739746,
0.7025005221366882,
-0.6433507800102234,
0.3354780375957489,
0.5592895746231079,
-0.23299148678779602,
0.45505666732788086,
-0.5997208952903748,
-0.12063375860452652,
-0.9797464609146118,
0.10447404533624649,
-0.45005571842193604,
-0.06842605024576187,
-0.6465162634849548,
0.04603424668312073,
0.30504530668258667,
0.11556989699602127,
-0.27070939540863037,
0.4895803928375244,
-0.5521343946456909,
0.1567813903093338,
-0.2544337213039398,
0.26031509041786194,
-0.08215030282735825,
0.33292141556739807,
-0.02687845379114151,
0.7875560522079468,
0.28059104084968567,
-0.743217945098877,
0.08978569507598877,
0.234577938914299,
-0.30566734075546265,
0.8426938056945801,
-0.6170420050621033,
0.13341575860977173,
-0.3043883442878723,
0.1530955582857132,
-0.9622445106506348,
-0.2580389082431793,
0.46949195861816406,
-0.23686449229717255,
0.27151066064834595,
0.035136617720127106,
-0.2186923325061798,
-0.14861752092838287,
-0.10204746574163437,
0.4732396900653839,
0.11553705483675003,
-0.3155353367328644,
0.7957737445831299,
0.10405774414539337,
0.1932590901851654,
-0.7861320376396179,
-0.8194015622138977,
0.1745642125606537,
-0.11365349590778351,
-0.35803067684173584,
0.1356322020292282,
-0.08652142435312271,
0.005628319922834635,
-0.09495820850133896,
-0.29092079401016235,
-0.011146476492285728,
0.4475988447666168,
0.3893585503101349,
0.12080423533916473,
0.0026792834978550673,
0.4650645852088928,
0.17225605249404907,
-0.46589675545692444,
-0.04612273722887039,
-0.3516274690628052,
0.046237628906965256,
-0.056107643991708755,
-0.4695636034011841,
-0.42861291766166687,
0.24800588190555573,
0.6947342753410339,
-0.32716605067253113,
0.7646401524543762,
0.5874601006507874,
-0.46961724758148193,
-0.3927154839038849,
-0.845786452293396,
-0.21039170026779175,
-0.5205010771751404,
0.23983576893806458,
-0.1929120272397995,
-0.8062988519668579,
0.3318374454975128,
-0.351468950510025,
0.0686337947845459,
0.3863590657711029,
0.37787842750549316,
-0.2780705690383911,
0.9244776964187622,
0.9255172610282898,
0.17226716876029968,
0.4111144542694092,
-0.2760814130306244,
0.2363598346710205,
-1.0657646656036377,
-0.39888080954551697,
-0.4082600772380829,
-0.16061705350875854,
-0.5733535885810852,
-0.4453578591346741,
0.5043511986732483,
0.16554109752178192,
-0.3390181362628937,
0.006004573777318001,
-0.6438056826591492,
0.30714747309684753,
0.28186091780662537,
0.13203482329845428,
0.45633435249328613,
-0.31225869059562683,
-0.24129503965377808,
-0.015598457306623459,
-0.787006676197052,
-0.4259014129638672,
1.0703169107437134,
0.24407878518104553,
0.7589625120162964,
-0.023974584415555,
0.8303517699241638,
0.3148144483566284,
0.5588266849517822,
-0.8226475119590759,
0.5011729001998901,
0.11533411592245102,
-0.6285756230354309,
-0.3390553593635559,
-0.4590291976928711,
-1.0873512029647827,
0.2356071025133133,
-0.470796674489975,
-0.5243449807167053,
0.25975659489631653,
0.5395926833152771,
-0.43323084712028503,
0.0380275622010231,
-0.8071582913398743,
1.0354282855987549,
-0.14142702519893646,
-0.1344204694032669,
-0.5888053178787231,
-0.4850141704082489,
0.6061972975730896,
-0.35894015431404114,
0.4370115399360657,
-0.02659447118639946,
-0.3276481628417969,
0.36881500482559204,
-0.13138733804225922,
1.065982699394226,
-0.3037954866886139,
-0.27873092889785767,
0.08222470432519913,
0.11830867826938629,
0.8040742874145508,
-0.2960973083972931,
-0.08343333005905151,
0.049517203122377396,
-0.16340525448322296,
-0.2633683681488037,
-0.8847212195396423,
0.43705952167510986,
-0.5986295342445374,
-0.5525611042976379,
-0.27458497881889343,
-0.5565666556358337,
-0.25237107276916504,
0.33477479219436646,
0.1375223994255066,
0.183279886841774,
-0.39800187945365906,
0.02723890170454979,
1.0639448165893555,
-0.32492995262145996,
0.3491749167442322,
0.9125809073448181,
-0.22535797953605652,
-0.49588873982429504,
0.6124286651611328,
0.16877010464668274,
0.3758545219898224,
0.386369526386261,
0.17072241008281708,
-0.3503933846950531,
-0.7279975414276123,
-0.1673073172569275,
0.37002408504486084,
-0.6349754333496094,
-0.30703017115592957,
-0.5495057702064514,
-0.1732114553451538,
-0.27250921726226807,
-0.12199375033378601,
-0.44044584035873413,
-0.3191865086555481,
-0.3962705135345459,
-0.32374510169029236,
0.11363295465707779,
0.6340196132659912,
-0.15608051419258118,
0.5496159791946411,
-0.676543653011322,
0.3673448860645294,
0.27389025688171387,
0.5462028980255127,
-0.021365653723478317,
-0.5115519762039185,
-0.5221191644668579,
0.21481464803218842,
-0.34089595079421997,
-0.7128540873527527,
0.1698380708694458,
0.22185195982456207,
0.6482077240943909,
0.5012222528457642,
0.012544143944978714,
0.8219776749610901,
-0.5118502974510193,
0.5025039315223694,
0.16957077383995056,
-1.1408289670944214,
0.79319167137146,
-0.29267212748527527,
0.37119555473327637,
0.6642975807189941,
0.22815683484077454,
-0.7336578965187073,
-0.520960807800293,
-0.5758781433105469,
-0.6300829648971558,
0.5179284811019897,
-0.07746833562850952,
0.09992683678865433,
-0.04215668886899948,
0.7640722990036011,
-0.27324992418289185,
0.37074410915374756,
-0.5625607371330261,
-0.07544001191854477,
-0.2983255982398987,
-0.30683034658432007,
-0.2685355842113495,
-0.4372102618217468,
-0.28779247403144836,
-0.024993181228637695,
0.7494088411331177,
-0.49454182386398315,
0.05689198151230812,
0.42984694242477417,
-0.36609137058258057,
-0.1494227945804596,
0.5116608142852783,
0.8738706111907959,
0.6915079355239868,
-0.07906652241945267,
0.20444847643375397,
0.35741767287254333,
-0.3326094448566437,
0.16732405126094818,
-0.3304232656955719,
-0.3247418999671936,
-0.18966351449489594,
0.5108112692832947,
0.7106719613075256,
0.4411585032939911,
-0.5170381665229797,
0.4548507332801819,
0.18347398936748505,
-0.28853705525398254,
-0.19853058457374573,
0.15147490799427032,
0.08968629688024521,
0.29834187030792236,
0.03987910598516464,
0.11276798695325851,
0.2385728359222412,
-0.4516315460205078,
0.13517944514751434,
0.6312970519065857,
-0.5418480634689331,
-0.07675345987081528,
0.6446634531021118,
0.36695513129234314,
-0.29819774627685547,
0.6667377352714539,
-0.07819462567567825,
-0.24408607184886932,
0.3144208788871765,
0.5354806184768677,
1.3466806411743164,
-0.5509857535362244,
0.4666728377342224,
0.3221494257450104,
0.7178503274917603,
-0.24978576600551605,
0.16161079704761505,
-0.06306204199790955,
-0.9738336205482483,
-0.6217086315155029,
-0.378961980342865,
-0.3227664828300476,
0.05555043742060661,
-0.7054703235626221,
0.054865848273038864,
-0.7006285786628723,
-0.1555902361869812,
-0.3318181335926056,
-0.13207267224788666,
-0.48627984523773193,
0.30671894550323486,
0.10197232663631439,
1.1170564889907837,
-0.858293890953064,
0.7059204578399658,
0.3484247922897339,
-0.21779319643974304,
-0.7841924428939819,
-0.028707008808851242,
-0.002842790214344859,
-0.8618411421775818,
0.33875322341918945,
0.09592106938362122,
-0.41086629033088684,
-0.11972660571336746,
-0.3799954950809479,
-0.636269211769104,
1.2717602252960205,
0.5722225308418274,
-0.8625801801681519,
-0.017006102949380875,
0.03291822969913483,
0.5962700843811035,
-0.36293932795524597,
0.25570887327194214,
0.6387899518013,
0.6469569802284241,
-0.022807806730270386,
-1.0649144649505615,
0.33981186151504517,
0.2784438133239746,
0.005639933981001377,
0.36381110548973083,
-0.6627330183982849,
0.4047348201274872,
-0.3930266499519348,
-0.36820894479751587,
-0.11975111067295074,
0.5555375814437866,
0.05836104229092598,
0.3010708689689636,
0.6850668787956238,
0.5364044904708862,
1.2405478954315186,
0.2244056612253189,
0.7996675372123718,
-0.18506848812103271,
0.27527329325675964,
1.3278123140335083,
-0.10726772993803024,
0.7300230264663696,
0.5491418838500977,
0.3244672417640686,
0.5954001545906067,
0.31395262479782104,
0.09826420247554779,
0.5874320268630981,
-0.0140602458268404,
-0.32790470123291016,
-0.38313204050064087,
-0.1680440902709961,
-0.1303456723690033,
0.49770551919937134,
0.47521504759788513,
-0.3924294710159302,
-0.21029047667980194,
-0.019148504361510277,
-0.012052253820002079,
0.15374767780303955,
-0.537833034992218,
0.9304652810096741,
0.20782795548439026,
-0.7926813960075378,
0.764629602432251,
0.07680264115333557,
0.48253217339515686,
-0.7250862717628479,
-0.03267988562583923,
-0.09713214635848999,
0.3161967694759369,
-0.5417880415916443,
-0.559283971786499,
0.6581048965454102,
-0.2567243278026581,
-0.40369606018066406,
-0.415371298789978,
0.5350901484489441,
-0.45414188504219055,
-0.4661223292350769,
0.3032781481742859,
0.42661693692207336,
-0.12835213541984558,
-0.31257522106170654,
-0.7515034079551697,
0.05252876132726669,
-0.013458741828799248,
0.2520430088043213,
-0.05949501693248749,
0.6008621454238892,
-0.22046683728694916,
1.0061001777648926,
0.4383825361728668,
0.13837023079395294,
-0.15370073914527893,
0.15231433510780334,
0.5067397952079773,
-0.7196905612945557,
-0.3792329430580139,
-0.8336086273193359,
0.5718316435813904,
0.10530751198530197,
-0.12506064772605896,
0.5297859907150269,
0.36246272921562195,
0.518352746963501,
0.06927921622991562,
0.6729113459587097,
0.42453786730766296,
0.4303184449672699,
-0.5446171760559082,
0.5618330836296082,
-0.583766520023346,
0.40354323387145996,
-0.18734623491764069,
-0.6112188696861267,
-0.42064160108566284,
0.5855217576026917,
-0.25605857372283936,
-0.035425055772066116,
0.6832045316696167,
1.0138098001480103,
-0.07446151971817017,
-0.16150231659412384,
0.38308700919151306,
0.5166863799095154,
0.29371345043182373,
0.5628346800804138,
0.8315113186836243,
-0.2529014050960541,
0.5681918859481812,
0.08486997336149216,
-0.3989832401275635,
-0.3198336064815521,
-1.1559861898422241,
-0.6632872819900513,
-0.3155401647090912,
-0.3086108863353729,
-0.2349998950958252,
0.10446174442768097,
0.8424344658851624,
0.7034159302711487,
-0.7294402122497559,
-0.053956158459186554,
-0.3335822522640228,
0.5281032919883728,
-0.5186024308204651,
-0.1811193823814392,
0.08642356842756271,
-0.5837898850440979,
-0.33219364285469055,
0.3858139216899872,
0.39567217230796814,
-0.02129492722451687,
-0.4364325702190399,
-0.04614697024226189,
0.028419919312000275,
0.3460463583469391,
0.525094211101532,
0.08218131214380264,
-0.7334388494491577,
-0.46277129650115967,
-0.2574334144592285,
-0.05935768410563469,
-0.022242676466703415,
0.8791211843490601,
-0.7436507940292358,
0.6908617615699768,
0.04249736666679382,
0.5289728045463562,
0.504523754119873,
-0.15113148093223572,
0.6802119612693787,
-0.650389552116394,
-0.04268204793334007,
0.12639181315898895,
0.17086338996887207,
0.4120583236217499,
-0.5740829706192017,
0.5905225276947021,
0.03669920936226845,
-0.4827885329723358,
-0.879109799861908,
0.433169960975647,
-0.7889989018440247,
-0.18533743917942047,
0.8845489025115967,
-0.03132394328713417,
0.02730332501232624,
-0.2371193915605545,
-0.33727532625198364,
0.3074065148830414,
-0.12432079017162323,
1.0545647144317627,
0.6010079383850098,
0.0961943045258522,
-0.25882360339164734,
-0.45122653245925903,
0.5629558563232422,
0.5435815453529358,
-0.8850647807121277,
0.454532653093338,
0.47810712456703186,
0.4055636525154114,
0.22247852385044098,
0.7486152052879333,
0.12625710666179657,
0.2592293918132782,
-0.15517762303352356,
0.12203363329172134,
-0.23626139760017395,
-0.5422238111495972,
-0.7701476216316223,
-0.008290927857160568,
0.07904922962188721,
-0.41516050696372986
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09703v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09703v2
|
Concept-aware Data Construction Improves In-context Learning of Language Models
| 2024-03-08T19:07:47 | 2024-06-28T08:03:19 |
Michal Štefánik, Marek Kadlčík, Petr Sojka
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Many recent language models (LMs) are capable of in-context learning (ICL),
manifested in the LMs' ability to perform a new task solely from
natural-language instruction. Previous work curating in-context learners
assumes that ICL emerges from a vast over-parametrization or the scale of
multi-task training. However, recent theoretical work attributes the ICL
ability to concept-dependent training data and creates functional in-context
learners even in small-scale, synthetic settings.
In this work, we practically explore this newly identified axis of ICL
quality. We propose Concept-aware Training (CoAT), a framework for constructing
training scenarios that make it beneficial for the LM to learn to utilize the
analogical reasoning concepts from demonstrations. We find that by using CoAT,
pre-trained transformers can learn to better utilise new latent concepts from
demonstrations and that such ability makes ICL more robust to the functional
deficiencies of the previous models. Finally, we show that concept-aware
in-context learning is more effective for a majority of new tasks when compared
to traditional instruction tuning, resulting in a performance comparable to the
previous in-context learners using magnitudes of more training data.
|
[
-0.47567978501319885,
-0.8097357749938965,
0.27070093154907227,
-0.311417818069458,
-0.11128079891204834,
0.24220703542232513,
-0.15996840596199036,
-0.47014495730400085,
-0.08420019596815109,
0.16257081925868988,
-0.30795350670814514,
-0.4402781128883362,
-0.17953160405158997,
-0.20673319697380066,
-0.5296087265014648,
0.8150858283042908,
-0.030726047232747078,
-0.11087816953659058,
-0.5610295534133911,
-0.009915530681610107,
-0.29902324080467224,
-0.6472905874252319,
-0.5309622287750244,
-0.45766496658325195,
0.0000858669081935659,
0.7222576141357422,
0.4938162565231323,
0.7653511166572571,
0.07199907302856445,
0.22868160903453827,
0.17441828548908234,
0.3546959459781647,
-0.27511510252952576,
0.08857474476099014,
-0.3607344925403595,
-0.5297228693962097,
-0.3222178816795349,
0.2838559150695801,
0.5425078868865967,
0.7921134829521179,
-0.19238236546516418,
-0.018421510234475136,
0.2395329475402832,
0.6048296093940735,
-0.8351912498474121,
0.19669371843338013,
-0.8854135274887085,
-0.04186924546957016,
-0.05442864075303078,
-0.18992261588573456,
-0.4767461121082306,
0.2722320556640625,
0.2646567225456238,
-0.9398311376571655,
0.4067007601261139,
-0.049407392740249634,
0.7957532405853271,
0.12986725568771362,
-0.2378324568271637,
-0.32303106784820557,
-0.582411527633667,
0.6694967746734619,
-0.6067461967468262,
0.7202190160751343,
0.8158438801765442,
0.17593194544315338,
-0.06299734860658646,
-0.9433110356330872,
-0.7772913575172424,
-0.24811296164989471,
-0.2908645272254944,
0.11023500561714172,
0.37398961186408997,
-0.15907599031925201,
0.2923884391784668,
0.17380428314208984,
-0.09197860956192017,
0.2484757900238037,
-0.26632368564605713,
-0.17644189298152924,
0.4715346097946167,
0.08716236799955368,
0.18625137209892273,
-0.10072635859251022,
-0.4127424955368042,
-0.04644393175840378,
-0.9940972924232483,
0.36247897148132324,
-0.019151199609041214,
0.46177008748054504,
-0.26126331090927124,
0.2964558005332947,
-0.2535839080810547,
0.7115764021873474,
0.12797749042510986,
-0.2176697552204132,
0.30522605776786804,
-0.2150987684726715,
-0.06621109694242477,
0.1232176274061203,
0.277548611164093,
0.2673248052597046,
0.09832582622766495,
-0.3062998056411743,
-0.3685093820095062,
0.07941128313541412,
0.3299124538898468,
-0.8472482562065125,
-0.2801702916622162,
0.14445742964744568,
-0.13002248108386993,
-0.14609211683273315,
0.2277827113866806,
-0.11364356428384781,
-0.2079702615737915,
-0.9060115814208984,
0.5252925753593445,
-0.7751261591911316,
-0.30354368686676025,
0.37511077523231506,
-0.07928440719842911,
0.2946900427341461,
0.32566332817077637,
-0.9046933054924011,
0.43773123621940613,
0.6524333953857422,
0.6962466835975647,
-0.14970560371875763,
-0.21460483968257904,
-0.7088062763214111,
0.3933367133140564,
-0.6119009256362915,
0.5857827067375183,
-0.4155898988246918,
-0.3225909173488617,
-0.10396677255630493,
-0.21745572984218597,
-0.2682531177997589,
-0.7064971327781677,
0.14722386002540588,
-0.4530195891857147,
0.17922960221767426,
-0.11446667462587357,
-0.9049686193466187,
0.14066459238529205,
0.30918118357658386,
-0.42942845821380615,
0.9832112193107605,
0.3519626557826996,
-0.9598603248596191,
0.6442627310752869,
-0.8024101853370667,
-0.6376298069953918,
0.0910896509885788,
-0.38295111060142517,
-0.24682869017124176,
0.04569182172417641,
0.04358351230621338,
0.814332127571106,
-0.090325266122818,
0.08936312794685364,
-0.23761607706546783,
-0.4120510518550873,
0.43075433373451233,
0.1918562948703766,
0.2631336748600006,
0.17071031033992767,
-0.3856146037578583,
0.058106131851673126,
-0.7157963514328003,
0.13975702226161957,
-0.14510324597358704,
-0.02085750177502632,
-0.5649001002311707,
0.10932520776987076,
-0.17594978213310242,
0.4062472879886627,
-0.09845983237028122,
-0.6020045280456543,
-0.18759113550186157,
-0.701890230178833,
0.5007923245429993,
0.6323390603065491,
-0.15388797223567963,
0.6705807447433472,
-0.4736497402191162,
0.41789817810058594,
0.1579040139913559,
-0.06303718686103821,
-0.16379521787166595,
0.07331144064664841,
-0.9049017429351807,
-0.5362737774848938,
0.1465594619512558,
0.28906944394111633,
-1.0386922359466553,
0.3455667197704315,
-0.14439141750335693,
-0.40497303009033203,
-0.3331409692764282,
0.02471633441746235,
0.343902051448822,
0.8116028904914856,
0.3114291727542877,
-0.4233874976634979,
-0.40575161576271057,
-0.7795067429542542,
0.11644187569618225,
-0.08548048883676529,
0.06832624226808548,
0.1292162835597992,
0.46536579728126526,
-0.0037182404194027185,
1.3489824533462524,
-0.32931607961654663,
-0.13174185156822205,
-0.3478265702724457,
-0.14325740933418274,
-0.04171792417764664,
0.604264497756958,
0.38083314895629883,
-0.7863913774490356,
-0.7027552723884583,
0.13613273203372955,
-0.6736564040184021,
0.34846410155296326,
-0.004754668101668358,
-0.13665615022182465,
0.07692287117242813,
1.1196216344833374,
-0.4959883987903595,
0.26631051301956177,
0.09479188919067383,
-0.11510778963565826,
0.46977919340133667,
-0.2499917596578598,
-0.19024673104286194,
-1.1484547853469849,
0.12491066008806229,
0.05883943289518356,
-0.22738192975521088,
-0.9453639388084412,
0.2294769585132599,
0.3682176172733307,
0.016423793509602547,
-0.5680403709411621,
0.8508439064025879,
-0.18342000246047974,
0.13417577743530273,
-0.21338357031345367,
0.07099926471710205,
-0.035418394953012466,
0.31174537539482117,
0.3893086910247803,
0.920848548412323,
0.7669703364372253,
-0.940542459487915,
-0.24274420738220215,
0.34629589319229126,
-0.778483510017395,
0.5805498361587524,
-0.4434402287006378,
0.197127565741539,
-0.10374648123979568,
0.09308785945177078,
-0.5338292717933655,
-0.33788856863975525,
0.21296733617782593,
-0.09266231209039688,
0.573532223701477,
0.05259145423769951,
-0.6378053426742554,
0.09304673969745636,
-0.13390275835990906,
0.287750780582428,
0.2687891721725464,
-0.7468103766441345,
0.31138643622398376,
0.39173614978790283,
0.19193975627422333,
-0.492139995098114,
-0.5112800598144531,
-0.2753121554851532,
-0.44318702816963196,
-0.17782293260097504,
0.5792372822761536,
-0.26602664589881897,
-0.11473499238491058,
-0.16006827354431152,
-0.313709020614624,
-0.1847609281539917,
0.46065691113471985,
0.06730108708143234,
0.11511611938476562,
-0.02626054920256138,
0.4494919776916504,
-0.09115217626094818,
-0.06739649176597595,
0.049643561244010925,
-0.27531078457832336,
0.45438340306282043,
-0.08912038058042526,
-0.5111185908317566,
-0.3921705186367035,
0.17932963371276855,
0.3875330686569214,
-0.4491397440433502,
0.8017426133155823,
0.40964406728744507,
-0.3201245963573456,
-0.7576431035995483,
-0.1546252816915512,
-0.41621556878089905,
-0.5030614733695984,
0.46126702427864075,
-0.5985448360443115,
-0.8610448837280273,
0.2218087911605835,
-0.0900728777050972,
0.05905192345380783,
0.036520589143037796,
0.10593747347593307,
-0.38799843192100525,
0.7907435297966003,
0.8369672894477844,
0.15989908576011658,
0.6705822348594666,
-0.5390876531600952,
0.2819922864437103,
-0.9235936999320984,
-0.24738569557666779,
-0.2633827030658722,
-0.10258213430643082,
-0.3881244361400604,
-0.439421683549881,
0.39079517126083374,
0.4067043364048004,
-0.44161656498908997,
0.35480624437332153,
-0.2705342471599579,
0.46091198921203613,
0.5592915415763855,
0.41569215059280396,
0.20950916409492493,
0.1256313920021057,
-0.1930849403142929,
-0.03358922153711319,
-0.9662638902664185,
-0.5155174732208252,
1.1397939920425415,
0.2934054732322693,
0.5882511734962463,
-0.2632748484611511,
0.6988814473152161,
-0.027159618213772774,
0.45315197110176086,
-0.8120771646499634,
0.4404027462005615,
-0.09914298355579376,
-0.46499988436698914,
-0.3009422719478607,
-0.11937875300645828,
-0.6093859076499939,
0.040481243282556534,
-0.19835679233074188,
-0.6289047002792358,
0.12481318414211273,
0.3553789556026459,
-0.08603013306856155,
0.2487322837114334,
-0.7051325440406799,
0.6456263661384583,
0.010366050526499748,
-0.3150777816772461,
-0.3339826166629791,
-0.6488397121429443,
0.18768000602722168,
-0.30535075068473816,
0.3836171329021454,
0.047774557024240494,
-0.09160180389881134,
0.3673418462276459,
-0.37556523084640503,
1.0047557353973389,
-0.12235688418149948,
-0.28992506861686707,
0.3107905089855194,
0.03233627602458,
0.4053739607334137,
-0.01833665929734707,
-0.10629290342330933,
-0.3336491584777832,
-0.17284101247787476,
-0.3244757056236267,
-0.8225573897361755,
0.4228869080543518,
-0.560199499130249,
-0.48769351840019226,
-0.12405253201723099,
-0.6794081330299377,
-0.6418613195419312,
-0.1994674652814865,
0.33911484479904175,
0.8003337383270264,
-0.12502658367156982,
0.31100600957870483,
0.8864040970802307,
-0.003137506078928709,
0.20383697748184204,
0.7026156187057495,
0.08829480409622192,
0.0808395966887474,
1.0693119764328003,
0.1321999728679657,
0.6888301968574524,
0.7797292470932007,
0.032209280878305435,
-0.2037571668624878,
-0.5728938579559326,
-0.17611755430698395,
-0.19433383643627167,
-0.8464431166648865,
-0.1792149394750595,
-0.5280929803848267,
-0.4897812306880951,
0.20586463809013367,
-0.25751325488090515,
-0.37592804431915283,
-0.5381186008453369,
-0.15066233277320862,
-0.19288583099842072,
0.18901918828487396,
0.4771307706832886,
-0.005854766815900803,
0.48942330479621887,
-0.28563883900642395,
0.16256004571914673,
0.3746316134929657,
0.48371070623397827,
0.08087282627820969,
-0.6437769532203674,
-0.7537699937820435,
0.2676304578781128,
-0.2795460522174835,
-0.16934335231781006,
0.11312615126371384,
0.5986247062683105,
0.7526033520698547,
0.410491019487381,
0.1161007210612297,
0.5403464436531067,
-0.4752236008644104,
0.4819713830947876,
0.08231747895479202,
-1.070087194442749,
0.5970521569252014,
-0.18929976224899292,
0.15765416622161865,
0.35072046518325806,
0.4606713354587555,
-0.5465013384819031,
-0.5052545070648193,
-0.8220115900039673,
-0.5697587728500366,
0.8320100903511047,
-0.028815556317567825,
0.3184885084629059,
-0.2155696153640747,
0.3368065357208252,
0.3958837687969208,
0.32834163308143616,
-0.4980664849281311,
-0.21116624772548676,
-0.4407508075237274,
-0.16220873594284058,
-0.3144901394844055,
0.029847614467144012,
-0.022406302392482758,
-0.44723033905029297,
0.705547571182251,
-0.5505822896957397,
0.04521464928984642,
0.036376357078552246,
-0.4237997829914093,
0.19788812100887299,
0.24961145222187042,
0.4006066918373108,
0.7165093421936035,
-0.20877547562122345,
0.1861775666475296,
0.15082918107509613,
-0.15534283220767975,
0.14049386978149414,
-0.047482606023550034,
-0.13140727579593658,
-0.18993505835533142,
0.5510278344154358,
0.8991592526435852,
0.3899673819541931,
-0.8884234428405762,
0.5106602311134338,
0.12619151175022125,
-0.21071785688400269,
-0.020671533420681953,
0.43108224868774414,
0.09343841671943665,
0.049019210040569305,
0.05879290774464607,
0.09498020261526108,
0.0438416413962841,
-0.7116752862930298,
0.5344049334526062,
0.5326272249221802,
-0.4064479172229767,
-0.35203373432159424,
0.3722507059574127,
-0.03595323860645294,
-0.0036788189318031073,
0.6190524101257324,
-0.23674708604812622,
-0.37127500772476196,
0.5686593651771545,
0.7812135219573975,
0.4963412880897522,
-0.3021187484264374,
0.37686797976493835,
0.43175122141838074,
-0.017101453617215157,
0.004826262127608061,
0.1821739822626114,
-0.25399431586265564,
-1.2178215980529785,
-0.3555462062358856,
-0.47847598791122437,
-0.32766228914260864,
0.2528289556503296,
-0.6376258134841919,
0.2916536331176758,
-0.6098225116729736,
0.13293445110321045,
-0.12696433067321777,
-0.23617538809776306,
-0.817913830280304,
0.42794549465179443,
-0.10356231033802032,
1.0665404796600342,
-0.8770850300788879,
1.0632444620132446,
0.883841872215271,
-0.2571009695529938,
-0.9106121063232422,
0.016293203458189964,
-0.3500354290008545,
-0.6648094654083252,
0.7069605588912964,
0.3203643262386322,
-0.03591128811240196,
0.10145965963602066,
-0.5169047117233276,
-0.7416707277297974,
1.0743917226791382,
0.5494082570075989,
-0.2851834297180176,
0.22285552322864532,
0.1100657507777214,
0.5270516276359558,
-0.7346054315567017,
0.07695192098617554,
0.5379915237426758,
-0.0711110457777977,
0.03721833601593971,
-0.7896973490715027,
-0.15330301225185394,
-0.32024437189102173,
-0.14439821243286133,
0.08504565060138702,
-0.2518210709095001,
0.5169201493263245,
-0.19040408730506897,
-0.4015306830406189,
0.11731336265802383,
0.6742193698883057,
0.2555142939090729,
0.29533883929252625,
0.6796666979789734,
0.40037429332733154,
0.7188149690628052,
-0.0012078216532245278,
1.1082141399383545,
-0.21207831799983978,
-0.12042352557182312,
1.4218100309371948,
-0.1476268768310547,
0.977584719657898,
0.4327186346054077,
0.13908086717128754,
0.6069729924201965,
0.6242254972457886,
0.5179299712181091,
0.8019750118255615,
0.1851889044046402,
-0.3910805284976959,
-0.46763500571250916,
-0.45113417506217957,
-0.32982999086380005,
0.5669621825218201,
0.7127174139022827,
-0.07253421097993851,
-0.034284576773643494,
0.21238508820533752,
-0.30240145325660706,
0.41790732741355896,
-0.16635727882385254,
0.7843422889709473,
0.1467805653810501,
-0.28840240836143494,
0.6563524603843689,
-0.11269959807395935,
0.5269772410392761,
-0.7504381537437439,
0.003070601960644126,
-0.2129732072353363,
0.04430544376373291,
-0.1201440840959549,
-0.6354418396949768,
0.20171552896499634,
-0.30869102478027344,
-0.27607256174087524,
-0.266356885433197,
0.40261656045913696,
-0.6352167725563049,
-0.15103621780872345,
0.08031059801578522,
0.7438594102859497,
-0.07924827188253403,
0.05859304219484329,
-0.4792470335960388,
-0.2940637469291687,
-0.3062237799167633,
0.035927243530750275,
0.6117920875549316,
0.5073946118354797,
-0.34147101640701294,
1.0405311584472656,
0.46070167422294617,
-0.059738002717494965,
-0.29150503873825073,
0.1238926351070404,
0.9083482623100281,
-0.3172917664051056,
-0.5822768807411194,
-0.46991971135139465,
0.6699522137641907,
-0.14733746647834778,
-0.1594500094652176,
0.5108131766319275,
0.6120777130126953,
1.4480531215667725,
-0.1622653752565384,
0.7805173397064209,
-0.16654199361801147,
0.6129023432731628,
-0.7552230358123779,
0.624849259853363,
-0.6019917726516724,
0.34833040833473206,
-0.24564975500106812,
-0.5384698510169983,
-0.08664942532777786,
0.7782017588615417,
-0.11395737528800964,
-0.13099627196788788,
0.7882858514785767,
1.0304272174835205,
-0.59056556224823,
0.07684456557035446,
0.2999894917011261,
-0.20748251676559448,
0.25555896759033203,
0.18199987709522247,
1.0737245082855225,
-0.2640970051288605,
-0.16991791129112244,
-0.6042776107788086,
-0.025695789605379105,
0.24269437789916992,
-0.9765153527259827,
-0.9753002524375916,
-1.0244733095169067,
-0.4730404019355774,
0.05099869146943092,
-0.11202381551265717,
1.2204899787902832,
1.1322764158248901,
-0.8755823969841003,
-0.38623377680778503,
-0.3008198142051697,
-0.03143472224473953,
-0.33972886204719543,
-0.1902318000793457,
0.6419259309768677,
-0.7652825117111206,
-0.5591303110122681,
0.594233512878418,
0.05037638917565346,
0.044634416699409485,
0.1311793029308319,
-0.3234471380710602,
-0.07040625810623169,
-0.11754244565963745,
0.9478932023048401,
0.14117944240570068,
-0.5814554691314697,
-0.4166940748691559,
-0.2534712255001068,
-0.029948901385068893,
0.0179278627038002,
0.8964364528656006,
-0.9800727367401123,
0.6804690361022949,
0.06625160574913025,
0.7444735169410706,
0.4166279137134552,
-0.2609095275402069,
0.7946949601173401,
-1.05369234085083,
0.36569541692733765,
0.011710976250469685,
0.3077089488506317,
0.552860677242279,
-0.15807631611824036,
0.4722408354282379,
0.1641901433467865,
0.06249785050749779,
-0.5956345200538635,
0.35488152503967285,
-0.5207198858261108,
-0.37339454889297485,
0.7891033291816711,
-0.059469517320394516,
0.31613054871559143,
-0.14522302150726318,
-0.14043095707893372,
0.1987128108739853,
-0.19948513805866241,
0.8461554050445557,
0.5400255918502808,
-0.015193251892924309,
0.012932663783431053,
-0.7086588740348816,
0.9214649796485901,
0.42122331261634827,
-1.0389397144317627,
0.04659399017691612,
0.06726868450641632,
0.3138037621974945,
-0.16177581250667572,
0.45760300755500793,
0.10945918411016464,
0.2320990413427353,
-0.409029483795166,
-0.2049291431903839,
-0.23607492446899414,
-0.4707984924316406,
0.1055811271071434,
-0.08060935139656067,
0.2411542683839798,
-0.13240838050842285
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.05535v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.05535v3
|
Tell, Don't Show!: Language Guidance Eases Transfer Across Domains in Images and Videos
| 2024-03-08T18:58:46 | 2024-06-06T01:44:48 |
Tarun Kalluri, Bodhisattwa Prasad Majumder, Manmohan Chandraker
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
We introduce LaGTran, a novel framework that utilizes text supervision to
guide robust transfer of discriminative knowledge from labeled source to
unlabeled target data with domain gaps. While unsupervised adaptation methods
have been established to address this problem, they show limitations in
handling challenging domain shifts due to their exclusive operation within the
pixel-space. Motivated by our observation that semantically richer text
modality has more favorable transfer properties, we devise a transfer mechanism
to use a source-trained text-classifier to generate predictions on the target
text descriptions, and utilize these predictions as supervision for the
corresponding images. Our approach driven by language guidance is surprisingly
easy and simple, yet significantly outperforms all prior approaches on
challenging datasets like GeoNet and DomainNet, validating its extreme
effectiveness. To further extend the scope of our study beyond images, we
introduce a new benchmark called Ego2Exo to study ego-exo transfer in videos
and find that our language-aided approach LaGTran yields significant gains in
this highly challenging and non-trivial transfer setting. Code, models, and
proposed datasets are publicly available at
https://tarun005.github.io/lagtran/.
|
[
-0.23962117731571198,
-0.491329550743103,
0.46717050671577454,
0.009824518114328384,
-0.26955196261405945,
0.02613239176571369,
-0.42402711510658264,
-0.4097532629966736,
-0.1444079875946045,
0.5545177459716797,
-0.37829411029815674,
-0.436551570892334,
-0.9805353283882141,
-0.4221133291721344,
-0.5353149175643921,
1.1165865659713745,
-0.3982759416103363,
-0.0381225161254406,
0.08773026615381241,
-0.028435714542865753,
-0.1849682480096817,
-0.09363406151533127,
-0.6887441873550415,
-0.2688123285770416,
0.3596843183040619,
0.4330517649650574,
0.5388219952583313,
0.8137698173522949,
0.5966124534606934,
0.12262434512376785,
0.2636505663394928,
0.42610374093055725,
-0.42259135842323303,
-0.08303327858448029,
-0.35633763670921326,
-0.5190538167953491,
-0.013583032414317131,
-0.47934871912002563,
0.4073947072029114,
0.57340407371521,
0.14055447280406952,
0.06616507470607758,
-0.03989855945110321,
0.6790367364883423,
-0.6097299456596375,
0.252156525850296,
-0.613857090473175,
-0.006289498880505562,
-0.2541474997997284,
-0.3381641209125519,
-0.43417370319366455,
-0.34662139415740967,
0.3228672742843628,
-0.9279621243476868,
0.34050610661506653,
0.06792975217103958,
0.9246622323989868,
0.601098358631134,
-0.4780274033546448,
-0.23806603252887726,
-0.795115053653717,
0.4921538531780243,
0.02946232631802559,
0.26325544714927673,
0.6509331464767456,
0.6274340748786926,
0.19280029833316803,
-0.8342685699462891,
-0.43205565214157104,
-0.03685195744037628,
0.11112168431282043,
0.06064402312040329,
-0.5234853625297546,
-0.06190811097621918,
-0.07918661832809448,
-0.08401928097009659,
-0.4585365056991577,
0.08293195813894272,
-0.5743895769119263,
-0.07198233902454376,
0.40719032287597656,
-0.6399899125099182,
0.44962722063064575,
0.22545841336250305,
-0.551249623298645,
-0.5172849297523499,
-0.6349754929542542,
-0.06450463831424713,
0.09161588549613953,
0.14636366069316864,
-0.015767348930239677,
0.45348620414733887,
0.0958777666091919,
0.49955639243125916,
0.26835986971855164,
0.2627161145210266,
-0.09195929765701294,
0.029422322288155556,
-0.23313479125499725,
0.29194575548171997,
0.7381129860877991,
0.7281709313392639,
0.5373737812042236,
-0.13930341601371765,
0.16572295129299164,
0.20190145075321198,
0.1377328336238861,
-0.7206977605819702,
-0.493584007024765,
-0.465825617313385,
-0.25513458251953125,
-0.07647308707237244,
0.06730367243289948,
-0.9232631325721741,
-0.664503276348114,
-0.046336572617292404,
0.686671793460846,
-0.40324312448501587,
-0.10569828748703003,
0.2009839117527008,
-0.0015679302159696817,
0.40625,
0.6210499405860901,
-0.8526410460472107,
0.5259308815002441,
0.4709673225879669,
0.9740803241729736,
-0.32625943422317505,
-0.04302253574132919,
-0.6196020841598511,
0.3583274185657501,
-0.39800211787223816,
0.9665141105651855,
-0.36749085783958435,
-0.05589275807142258,
0.12994170188903809,
0.15624532103538513,
-0.006984788924455643,
-0.4769039750099182,
0.5903484225273132,
-0.2060673087835312,
0.12032941728830338,
-0.04655769467353821,
-0.3399321734905243,
-0.3261689245700836,
-0.27585113048553467,
-0.5096858143806458,
0.863244354724884,
0.10377620160579681,
-0.3021917939186096,
0.35814303159713745,
-0.5005035996437073,
-0.44547951221466064,
-0.03183605521917343,
-0.2074349820613861,
-0.17945270240306854,
-0.08689858764410019,
0.47867655754089355,
0.41043975949287415,
-0.029567690566182137,
0.3244146704673767,
-0.07417216897010803,
-0.29284605383872986,
0.15210485458374023,
-0.37854865193367004,
0.2415774017572403,
0.2302556037902832,
-0.6707199811935425,
-0.1203385517001152,
-0.4615638554096222,
-0.0332208089530468,
-0.02973628230392933,
0.3111720383167267,
-0.4996525049209595,
-0.1412588208913803,
0.01847626268863678,
0.1868293583393097,
-0.11161042749881744,
-0.17956168949604034,
0.38190966844558716,
-0.061596471816301346,
0.20820754766464233,
0.9736420512199402,
-0.25279462337493896,
0.8744290471076965,
-0.1894088089466095,
0.6432356238365173,
-0.20006245374679565,
-0.013910790905356407,
-0.2979183495044708,
-0.4973968267440796,
-0.8388320803642273,
0.043818846344947815,
0.08113748580217361,
0.5932475924491882,
-1.2016329765319824,
0.0747746005654335,
-0.4394310414791107,
-0.34777870774269104,
-0.5720846652984619,
0.19649431109428406,
0.5349982380867004,
0.40355411171913147,
0.32832252979278564,
-0.20503534376621246,
-0.37490183115005493,
-1.0685237646102905,
-0.46922335028648376,
-0.21793600916862488,
0.12480753660202026,
0.33662351965904236,
0.4516252875328064,
0.16527807712554932,
0.4016677737236023,
-0.6528679728507996,
-0.6809965968132019,
-0.15114358067512512,
0.06054333224892616,
-0.1041577160358429,
0.36203423142433167,
0.7490887641906738,
-0.7871630787849426,
-0.8842268586158752,
0.5915282964706421,
-0.866337776184082,
-0.3474285900592804,
-0.3162737190723419,
-0.3626742362976074,
0.03990975394845009,
0.7200846672058105,
-0.237844318151474,
0.504455029964447,
0.7475224137306213,
-0.42313554883003235,
0.03382033482193947,
-0.2743827998638153,
0.15370695292949677,
-0.9324281215667725,
-0.04116068780422211,
0.10731081664562225,
-0.6965081691741943,
-0.5688480138778687,
-0.3234080672264099,
-0.00589429447427392,
0.04094438999891281,
-0.41220623254776,
0.8652929663658142,
-0.3842499852180481,
0.0827496200799942,
-0.17948013544082642,
0.23981398344039917,
0.05959301441907883,
0.6865723729133606,
0.07675135135650635,
0.8580058813095093,
1.113728642463684,
-0.4848118722438812,
0.1581605225801468,
0.49599769711494446,
-0.4623278081417084,
0.858502209186554,
-0.3716202676296234,
0.2576737403869629,
-0.22698667645454407,
0.15240657329559326,
-0.7473737597465515,
-0.16035151481628418,
0.6021763682365417,
-0.4544314444065094,
0.43105149269104004,
-0.33356067538261414,
-0.3062046468257904,
0.1348222941160202,
-0.2184576392173767,
0.25696292519569397,
0.6617833375930786,
-0.8559223413467407,
0.320604532957077,
0.11028365045785904,
-0.11443574726581573,
-0.5745447278022766,
-0.9533669948577881,
0.16920453310012817,
-0.44964930415153503,
-0.4296673536300659,
0.5371946692466736,
-0.03237104043364525,
-0.2775537073612213,
0.24031852185726166,
-0.34333372116088867,
-0.5315207839012146,
-0.13371118903160095,
0.4212118089199066,
0.02563735470175743,
0.09357009828090668,
0.0750839039683342,
0.3587867021560669,
0.19227398931980133,
-0.045494552701711655,
-0.5125630497932434,
-0.052815668284893036,
0.07446008175611496,
-0.24078379571437836,
-0.5714335441589355,
0.30832862854003906,
0.25547561049461365,
0.18086037039756775,
0.5502696633338928,
0.7427959442138672,
-0.2817620635032654,
-0.6297944188117981,
-0.10617973655462265,
0.09347867965698242,
-0.4742984175682068,
0.5717014074325562,
-0.20173820853233337,
-0.8436115384101868,
0.17195552587509155,
-0.3138602375984192,
-0.2951459288597107,
0.08997948467731476,
0.13462305068969727,
-0.058544840663671494,
0.7731855511665344,
1.0090662240982056,
0.2718604505062103,
0.838727593421936,
-0.29802143573760986,
0.13335464894771576,
-0.5748017430305481,
-0.33334800601005554,
-0.15709590911865234,
-0.24110127985477448,
-0.3862784206867218,
-0.789119303226471,
0.28575608134269714,
0.37368249893188477,
-0.015882348641753197,
0.6275017261505127,
-0.40030986070632935,
0.7071381211280823,
0.31053969264030457,
0.1835249811410904,
0.3793247938156128,
0.36430564522743225,
0.3919318616390228,
-0.3102008104324341,
-0.5370995402336121,
-0.3796716630458832,
0.9637784361839294,
0.14816956222057343,
0.937109649181366,
0.338413268327713,
0.30217090249061584,
0.9303557276725769,
0.35436564683914185,
-0.9014678001403809,
0.6562946438789368,
-0.4744076728820801,
-0.14966201782226562,
0.023718737065792084,
-0.44037190079689026,
-0.8919002413749695,
0.08764775097370148,
0.14000272750854492,
-0.8374024629592896,
0.18509875237941742,
0.12219374626874924,
0.07236238569021225,
0.5065027475357056,
-0.8772279620170593,
0.5313946604728699,
-0.48680299520492554,
-0.6857184767723083,
0.1170055940747261,
-0.5458127856254578,
0.16731278598308563,
-0.3542015254497528,
0.2239377349615097,
0.06607310473918915,
-0.10287145525217056,
0.7050480246543884,
-0.37969279289245605,
0.8722547292709351,
-0.3058358132839203,
-0.2652900815010071,
0.32221171259880066,
0.3236568868160248,
0.48568058013916016,
-0.25794732570648193,
0.37149226665496826,
0.14234372973442078,
-0.18212848901748657,
-0.11857327818870544,
-0.8293317556381226,
0.6703886389732361,
-0.8154009580612183,
-0.24146738648414612,
-0.2407231628894806,
-0.21650949120521545,
-0.16195952892303467,
0.3951624035835266,
0.3684956729412079,
0.20032699406147003,
-0.14664503931999207,
-0.0016239533433690667,
0.7064450979232788,
-0.3623273968696594,
0.3847423493862152,
0.13100749254226685,
-0.4291422963142395,
-0.3723340630531311,
1.0314898490905762,
-0.12421497702598572,
0.4077776372432709,
0.49647828936576843,
-0.022554390132427216,
-0.42811712622642517,
-0.29133427143096924,
-0.7584441304206848,
0.21034836769104004,
-1.1041843891143799,
-0.19486325979232788,
-0.2385326623916626,
-0.034396156668663025,
-0.32892927527427673,
-0.5051233768463135,
-0.4920819103717804,
-0.5673360228538513,
-0.2316184639930725,
-0.059784624725580215,
0.5030296444892883,
0.7587572932243347,
-0.06455858051776886,
0.726222574710846,
-0.47124436497688293,
0.28761276602745056,
0.3583749234676361,
0.3873007893562317,
-0.43454810976982117,
-0.8354318737983704,
-0.2684401571750641,
-0.17239338159561157,
-0.24338124692440033,
-0.7303227186203003,
0.4871940314769745,
0.7442227602005005,
0.400432825088501,
0.4036930799484253,
0.09198280423879623,
0.7631884813308716,
-0.45990753173828125,
0.6814799904823303,
0.3455057144165039,
-1.1646443605422974,
0.7128345370292664,
-0.4317968785762787,
0.03190700709819794,
0.3637462258338928,
0.3391874432563782,
-0.39247971773147583,
0.06651654094457626,
-0.4223327040672302,
-0.7671109437942505,
0.7555219531059265,
0.36391404271125793,
0.04198775067925453,
0.4232841432094574,
0.42874211072921753,
0.17722614109516144,
0.06513138115406036,
-0.7149249911308289,
-0.34910714626312256,
-0.30239951610565186,
-0.044147081673145294,
0.1006062775850296,
0.3107578456401825,
-0.18554151058197021,
0.04321333020925522,
0.44625094532966614,
-0.4772340953350067,
0.4018271565437317,
0.5627565383911133,
-0.49246877431869507,
-0.05500726029276848,
0.1554887443780899,
0.6544292569160461,
0.3951612114906311,
-0.007561979349702597,
0.273676335811615,
-0.15295085310935974,
-0.5665180087089539,
0.10832585394382477,
0.1410548985004425,
-0.08566481620073318,
0.10847293585538864,
0.42438259720802307,
1.2319996356964111,
-0.04633444920182228,
-0.5674400925636292,
0.783800482749939,
-0.08685894310474396,
-0.6679437756538391,
-0.29598677158355713,
-0.03533307835459709,
-0.61357581615448,
0.2838851809501648,
0.22400866448879242,
0.37421244382858276,
-0.040683064609766006,
-0.3004429340362549,
0.17823554575443268,
0.012956463731825352,
-0.6371831297874451,
-0.7372488975524902,
0.8724629878997803,
-0.03946708142757416,
-0.16712796688079834,
0.036667585372924805,
-0.10849934816360474,
-0.37656137347221375,
0.4627072215080261,
0.520161509513855,
0.8539277911186218,
-0.06661050021648407,
0.5444026589393616,
0.17219536006450653,
0.23990508913993835,
-0.5282624959945679,
0.010514477267861366,
-0.23945628106594086,
-0.6597914099693298,
-0.6172145009040833,
-0.1584063619375229,
-0.3148525357246399,
0.06113942712545395,
-0.749055027961731,
0.23630771040916443,
-0.5123793482780457,
0.054024193435907364,
-0.03802898898720741,
-0.5496331453323364,
-0.6512454748153687,
-0.015736063942313194,
0.5423810482025146,
0.742901086807251,
-0.8769360780715942,
0.9081745147705078,
0.6652430891990662,
-0.024420421570539474,
-0.5156939029693604,
-0.015522664412856102,
-0.04296899959445,
-0.9386385083198547,
0.82261061668396,
0.22336745262145996,
-0.46018123626708984,
-0.04593391716480255,
-0.7681475877761841,
-0.7016811370849609,
0.9538207650184631,
0.6400976181030273,
-0.5125671625137329,
-0.04491611570119858,
0.030271710827946663,
0.5257840752601624,
-0.1279844045639038,
-0.03214867785573006,
0.31325602531433105,
0.6976161599159241,
0.31220316886901855,
-1.0124622583389282,
-0.06459016352891922,
-0.2267298698425293,
-0.3440927267074585,
0.1614810675382614,
-0.6021249294281006,
0.34991392493247986,
-0.36170944571495056,
-0.3700343668460846,
0.1226295530796051,
0.36838898062705994,
-0.3267959654331207,
0.44972461462020874,
0.420268714427948,
0.27569854259490967,
0.6494637131690979,
-0.13925333321094513,
0.9661284685134888,
0.051226530224084854,
0.25947877764701843,
1.244093894958496,
-0.3096589744091034,
0.6148576140403748,
0.6106416583061218,
-0.0779319480061531,
0.4769512116909027,
0.2924842834472656,
-0.07800688594579697,
0.925361156463623,
0.23378939926624298,
-0.2153199315071106,
-0.10135123133659363,
-0.6978012919425964,
-0.17954488098621368,
0.5807842016220093,
0.34139829874038696,
-0.41988885402679443,
-0.22514156997203827,
0.20222081243991852,
0.23524294793605804,
0.3974997103214264,
-0.5034130215644836,
0.555075466632843,
0.20493054389953613,
-0.6773253083229065,
0.5604474544525146,
-0.429778128862381,
0.7207013368606567,
-0.7479763627052307,
-0.3357510268688202,
-0.17562894523143768,
0.491603821516037,
-0.29225701093673706,
-0.9093289971351624,
0.3314613103866577,
0.08582344651222229,
0.09384115785360336,
-0.718592643737793,
0.8371441960334778,
-0.5109973549842834,
-0.25502637028694153,
0.43678468465805054,
0.5381375551223755,
0.4355033338069916,
-0.05535009130835533,
-0.4667734205722809,
-0.1876935213804245,
0.25137415528297424,
0.07572793960571289,
0.348660409450531,
0.5294197797775269,
-0.49252191185951233,
0.6894738674163818,
0.45730045437812805,
0.2897363305091858,
0.0032752968836575747,
0.09459222108125687,
0.7595068216323853,
-0.4643351435661316,
-0.1262129843235016,
-0.7061171531677246,
0.19405782222747803,
0.10616106539964676,
-0.21517536044120789,
0.8003374934196472,
0.2865613102912903,
1.0256779193878174,
-0.07470761984586716,
0.9471049904823303,
-0.13556653261184692,
-0.07505904883146286,
-0.6743184328079224,
0.6127931475639343,
-0.5659853219985962,
0.14732486009597778,
-0.31858694553375244,
-0.7423686385154724,
-0.4983043670654297,
0.5562034249305725,
-0.17716926336288452,
-0.13371437788009644,
0.8242312073707581,
0.7816153764724731,
-0.12453343719244003,
-0.42713290452957153,
0.4326934814453125,
0.09070155769586563,
0.3647642731666565,
0.6591984033584595,
0.9890163540840149,
-0.47382277250289917,
0.8627046942710876,
-0.1864398717880249,
-0.2114124447107315,
0.0737147405743599,
-0.9752152562141418,
-0.9220763444900513,
-0.562397837638855,
-0.5996460318565369,
-0.26471859216690063,
0.2830650210380554,
0.5463041663169861,
0.975705087184906,
-0.3768702745437622,
-0.062274690717458725,
-0.2707652151584625,
-0.17376923561096191,
-0.30978143215179443,
-0.20176036655902863,
0.6884342432022095,
0.3233027458190918,
-0.8077343106269836,
0.4510123133659363,
0.1896376758813858,
0.11498385667800903,
-0.01828906126320362,
0.004622226115316153,
0.109747014939785,
-0.2647874653339386,
0.3201088309288025,
0.40159863233566284,
-0.5550886392593384,
-0.25123560428619385,
0.09696654230356216,
0.17269185185432434,
0.07032040506601334,
0.91943359375,
-0.7125201225280762,
0.5105704665184021,
0.25318315625190735,
0.7140340209007263,
0.6595706939697266,
-0.041301190853118896,
0.5410114526748657,
-0.9056499004364014,
0.16625961661338806,
-0.18690712749958038,
0.0889599621295929,
0.5465685129165649,
-0.5342310667037964,
0.72073894739151,
0.18674203753471375,
-0.4920447766780853,
-0.6826152801513672,
0.23824666440486908,
-1.2424713373184204,
-0.2528954744338989,
1.2895739078521729,
-0.32206910848617554,
-0.3103001117706299,
-0.043970443308353424,
-0.4124961495399475,
0.2750452160835266,
-0.4967130124568939,
0.4465709626674652,
0.27361536026000977,
-0.19909252226352692,
-0.5412117838859558,
-0.9127911329269409,
0.6354427337646484,
0.4165119528770447,
-0.8148573040962219,
0.06204284727573395,
0.3393312096595764,
0.27633488178253174,
-0.06646772474050522,
0.5433239340782166,
0.0952400267124176,
0.03334515169262886,
-0.2099076211452484,
0.013740047812461853,
-0.1791776716709137,
-0.5193176865577698,
-0.5879004001617432,
-0.286880761384964,
-0.04136728122830391,
-0.42464813590049744
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.05534v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.05534v1
|
Bayesian Preference Elicitation with Language Models
| 2024-03-08T18:57:52 | 2024-03-08T18:57:52 |
Kunal Handa, Yarin Gal, Ellie Pavlick, Noah Goodman, Jacob Andreas, Alex Tamkin, Belinda Z. Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Aligning AI systems to users' interests requires understanding and
incorporating humans' complex values and preferences. Recently, language models
(LMs) have been used to gather information about the preferences of human
users. This preference data can be used to fine-tune or guide other LMs and/or
AI systems. However, LMs have been shown to struggle with crucial aspects of
preference learning: quantifying uncertainty, modeling human mental states, and
asking informative questions. These challenges have been addressed in other
areas of machine learning, such as Bayesian Optimal Experimental Design (BOED),
which focus on designing informative queries within a well-defined feature
space. But these methods, in turn, are difficult to scale and apply to
real-world problems where simply identifying the relevant features can be
difficult. We introduce OPEN (Optimal Preference Elicitation with Natural
language) a framework that uses BOED to guide the choice of informative
questions and an LM to extract features and translate abstract BOED queries
into natural language questions. By combining the flexibility of LMs with the
rigor of BOED, OPEN can optimize the informativity of queries while remaining
adaptable to real-world domains. In user studies, we find that OPEN outperforms
existing LM- and BOED-based methods for preference elicitation.
|
[
-0.6024542450904846,
-1.0798695087432861,
0.42860740423202515,
-0.10139212757349014,
0.1221795603632927,
-0.423949658870697,
-0.5721961855888367,
-0.2722521126270294,
-0.11379283666610718,
0.5906606316566467,
-0.31132233142852783,
-0.408658504486084,
-0.17145927250385284,
-0.26921314001083374,
0.23291948437690735,
1.0214836597442627,
-0.1539933681488037,
-0.14006398618221283,
-0.1600111424922943,
-0.3992120325565338,
-0.12736989557743073,
-0.5867111086845398,
-0.845817506313324,
-0.21186286211013794,
0.46419936418533325,
0.4883052408695221,
1.108091950416565,
0.2096979022026062,
0.4606882929801941,
0.15585079789161682,
0.09124301373958588,
0.19482047855854034,
-0.2765730321407318,
0.33093562722206116,
-0.3511292338371277,
-0.7093750834465027,
-0.15442664921283722,
0.04280431196093559,
0.3517523407936096,
1.1163219213485718,
-0.18431824445724487,
0.17342203855514526,
0.04915482923388481,
0.8589500188827515,
-0.7940143346786499,
0.3994820713996887,
-0.6762987971305847,
-0.03184584155678749,
-0.06251587718725204,
-0.008255325257778168,
-0.23488223552703857,
-0.7307304739952087,
0.6230319142341614,
-0.49104923009872437,
0.04754634574055672,
0.27447181940078735,
0.7691065669059753,
0.20575617253780365,
-0.20398348569869995,
-0.25890570878982544,
-0.8256638050079346,
0.6784719228744507,
-0.6855003833770752,
0.2748926877975464,
0.6145998239517212,
0.38151252269744873,
-0.47758230566978455,
-0.10846466571092606,
-0.6203024983406067,
-0.2648076117038727,
0.009157728403806686,
0.07914701849222183,
-0.386991411447525,
0.2548121213912964,
0.19730497896671295,
0.1972712278366089,
-0.7745327949523926,
0.3387853503227234,
-0.22673794627189636,
0.1384236216545105,
0.6629654765129089,
-0.1281895488500595,
0.2830860912799835,
0.051464375108480453,
-0.08026746660470963,
-0.3449079990386963,
-0.4944821298122406,
0.4976913332939148,
0.4802972376346588,
0.6432763338088989,
0.048239123076200485,
0.8314494490623474,
-0.4395245313644409,
0.9582003951072693,
0.06704016029834747,
0.28495845198631287,
0.1518060266971588,
0.18849386274814606,
-0.2997058629989624,
-0.06677847355604172,
0.8513428568840027,
0.4069075286388397,
0.630760669708252,
0.012174220755696297,
-0.07162455469369888,
0.11273069679737091,
0.24205400049686432,
-0.6928973197937012,
-0.1285199075937271,
0.7089692950248718,
-0.40691086649894714,
-0.1410752534866333,
0.12970474362373352,
-0.7348291873931885,
-0.28236159682273865,
-0.39269736409187317,
0.5834428071975708,
-0.4392997920513153,
-0.40404656529426575,
0.4109450578689575,
-0.04191718250513077,
0.007164536509662867,
0.20094838738441467,
-1.2651922702789307,
0.27043479681015015,
0.32099151611328125,
0.6808134913444519,
-0.09541179984807968,
0.12072097510099411,
-0.3694652020931244,
0.1852007955312729,
-0.438867449760437,
0.7224954962730408,
-0.6685512661933899,
-0.3627921938896179,
0.1069827526807785,
-0.2686559855937958,
0.15879562497138977,
-0.651930570602417,
0.3670196235179901,
-0.45053336024284363,
0.6441695690155029,
-0.11331766098737717,
-0.46871882677078247,
-0.19202539324760437,
0.029242778196930885,
-0.5252021551132202,
0.8195950388908386,
0.28879979252815247,
-0.6590257883071899,
0.5136464238166809,
-1.0839519500732422,
-0.09141327440738678,
-0.029134633019566536,
-0.306549072265625,
-0.26946085691452026,
0.38198551535606384,
0.3129580318927765,
0.36311614513397217,
-0.10110339522361755,
0.3253779411315918,
-0.6393434405326843,
-0.023037351667881012,
0.36791688203811646,
-0.24796044826507568,
0.6682239770889282,
0.4827219247817993,
-0.17519386112689972,
0.3808300495147705,
-0.5250832438468933,
0.15340405702590942,
0.1554303914308548,
-0.34756043553352356,
-0.7066437602043152,
0.21293772757053375,
-0.23963594436645508,
-0.2838633358478546,
0.3054112195968628,
-0.5684553980827332,
0.27523189783096313,
-0.8340362906455994,
0.28685832023620605,
0.7552724480628967,
-0.15754875540733337,
0.8269696235656738,
-0.3348655104637146,
0.38213998079299927,
0.03202227130532265,
0.07263080775737762,
0.04237174987792969,
-0.5743910074234009,
-0.5234338045120239,
-0.2023191750049591,
0.1783609390258789,
0.48829230666160583,
-0.4007524251937866,
0.5257855653762817,
0.14074738323688507,
-0.38773810863494873,
-0.9555251002311707,
-0.22432056069374084,
-0.03976660221815109,
0.34068563580513,
0.2710997760295868,
-0.2404724806547165,
-0.08137461543083191,
-1.1254299879074097,
-0.21248410642147064,
-0.5423844456672668,
-0.3119542598724365,
0.5606572031974792,
-0.01770021580159664,
0.06022491678595543,
1.397417426109314,
-0.7209227681159973,
0.26480695605278015,
-0.07760223746299744,
0.31871268153190613,
0.35163500905036926,
0.24816802144050598,
0.47064054012298584,
-1.0757075548171997,
-0.3806709945201874,
0.2928982377052307,
-0.558506965637207,
-0.3049442768096924,
0.2204313725233078,
-0.3220594525337219,
0.26191216707229614,
-0.17057663202285767,
-0.5980098247528076,
0.5601454973220825,
0.29710566997528076,
0.03930136188864708,
0.279028981924057,
-0.30456581711769104,
0.2126280516386032,
-0.8630351424217224,
0.22812588512897491,
0.1612968146800995,
0.06709792464971542,
-0.5535470843315125,
0.04684143885970116,
0.11845166236162186,
-0.2511564791202545,
-0.2917137145996094,
0.9088598489761353,
-0.3950018584728241,
-0.051883112639188766,
-0.3288840055465698,
0.05102661997079849,
-0.1563403308391571,
0.41067594289779663,
0.39529767632484436,
0.6050447225570679,
0.5280936360359192,
-0.7169067859649658,
0.08593226969242096,
0.24161209166049957,
-0.2504653036594391,
0.4957823157310486,
-0.5518016815185547,
-0.0008755218586884439,
-0.43139928579330444,
-0.10891559720039368,
-1.0742595195770264,
-0.41391023993492126,
0.2506442964076996,
-0.6041265726089478,
0.098758764564991,
-0.1629791557788849,
-0.34632086753845215,
-0.21257014572620392,
-0.2333790808916092,
0.33287882804870605,
0.6524099707603455,
-0.505784809589386,
0.12323909252882004,
0.47437784075737,
-0.34886279702186584,
-0.48239055275917053,
-0.29086074233055115,
-0.4073624312877655,
-0.220371276140213,
-0.5759653449058533,
0.19279612600803375,
-0.25732308626174927,
-0.4582589566707611,
0.027370847761631012,
-0.10593678802251816,
-0.16292251646518707,
0.23407162725925446,
0.3569079041481018,
0.2580271363258362,
-0.3047797381877899,
0.15670053660869598,
0.3991566598415375,
-0.12984012067317963,
-0.14545489847660065,
-0.41710364818573,
0.4338128864765167,
-0.1520228236913681,
-0.4813493490219116,
-0.055671095848083496,
0.5786619186401367,
0.29732269048690796,
-0.2520813047885895,
0.6658486127853394,
0.3795420229434967,
-0.5541813373565674,
-0.3869116008281708,
-0.4070543348789215,
-0.268537312746048,
-0.41838347911834717,
0.12941768765449524,
-0.3943137526512146,
-1.1599693298339844,
0.15583769977092743,
-0.027219168841838837,
0.25036925077438354,
0.04920244216918945,
0.684577465057373,
-0.2802400588989258,
1.3643555641174316,
0.743026614189148,
-0.27018579840660095,
0.5321208238601685,
0.10119494795799255,
0.309741348028183,
-0.40232810378074646,
0.0753498300909996,
-0.7094129323959351,
-0.3325231969356537,
-0.4970345199108124,
-0.013167641125619411,
0.6301518678665161,
0.3073934018611908,
-0.268210768699646,
0.08883894979953766,
-0.48177874088287354,
0.28355368971824646,
0.8705926537513733,
0.2043786495923996,
0.04233304038643837,
0.1075964942574501,
-0.3079155683517456,
-0.02075691521167755,
-0.6095470786094666,
-0.7626938819885254,
1.1583939790725708,
0.13863873481750488,
0.9158723950386047,
0.2445928007364273,
0.5273314714431763,
-0.06439674645662308,
0.23957984149456024,
-0.704312264919281,
0.31157195568084717,
0.2136070728302002,
-0.8131638765335083,
-0.5710471868515015,
-0.31373682618141174,
-1.142020344734192,
0.3138785660266876,
-0.34106191992759705,
-1.065345287322998,
0.2001790851354599,
0.3504756987094879,
-0.4617592692375183,
0.24019409716129303,
-0.7487983107566833,
0.8980773687362671,
-0.27335354685783386,
-0.49760204553604126,
-0.006183082703500986,
-0.8291662931442261,
0.08699221163988113,
0.10191290080547333,
0.22626306116580963,
-0.16018830239772797,
-0.021938230842351913,
0.29312992095947266,
-0.13784918189048767,
0.6948323249816895,
-0.07087940722703934,
0.09096386283636093,
0.03357818350195885,
0.16013595461845398,
0.0703902393579483,
0.04091412574052811,
-0.41106322407722473,
-0.10609722882509232,
0.016120897606015205,
-0.3351859450340271,
-0.7637514472007751,
0.4183749556541443,
-0.7879453301429749,
-0.6908008456230164,
-0.3862803280353546,
-0.5555540323257446,
-0.4950107932090759,
0.05452674254775047,
0.07038436830043793,
0.2285192310810089,
-0.38268208503723145,
-0.08758414536714554,
0.82505202293396,
-0.41295892000198364,
0.30586686730384827,
0.5949506163597107,
-0.48936542868614197,
-0.1784452348947525,
0.7224672436714172,
-0.11911382526159286,
0.407139390707016,
0.6887243986129761,
0.46182629466056824,
-0.26044777035713196,
-0.5911368131637573,
-0.6269805431365967,
0.12729740142822266,
-0.19895532727241516,
0.15691833198070526,
-0.4664766490459442,
-0.054100941866636276,
-0.40822574496269226,
-0.2763727307319641,
-0.0666511058807373,
-0.30840057134628296,
-0.3392792046070099,
-0.1731322854757309,
0.23820851743221283,
0.3397468626499176,
-0.13158541917800903,
0.2510131001472473,
-0.7065916657447815,
0.3742581903934479,
0.17186342179775238,
0.32245853543281555,
-0.2156568020582199,
-0.19063401222229004,
-0.03765948489308357,
0.25423941016197205,
-0.3207435607910156,
-0.8899111747741699,
0.5968068242073059,
-0.10195580124855042,
0.8598901629447937,
0.6936861276626587,
0.3431926369667053,
0.26711052656173706,
-0.30061468482017517,
0.6320645809173584,
-0.05358835682272911,
-0.45959752798080444,
1.0022460222244263,
-0.4397124648094177,
0.13405059278011322,
0.712620735168457,
1.0853650569915771,
-0.3603738248348236,
-0.16349773108959198,
-0.4455145299434662,
-0.6739951372146606,
0.7041532397270203,
0.13558542728424072,
-0.09210555255413055,
-0.13950508832931519,
0.3193691074848175,
0.5613545179367065,
0.5583543181419373,
-0.511634111404419,
-0.0960550382733345,
0.054574381560087204,
-0.5468382239341736,
-0.10109846293926239,
-0.019403764978051186,
-0.05510513111948967,
-0.004494302906095982,
0.47181007266044617,
-0.307813435792923,
0.1591932624578476,
0.05875880643725395,
0.12434009462594986,
-0.2109471708536148,
0.4562433362007141,
0.11199882626533508,
0.5861884951591492,
-0.68521648645401,
-0.04487012326717377,
-0.25249385833740234,
0.06074673682451248,
0.0013911757851019502,
0.04966738447546959,
-0.4579070508480072,
-0.26995334029197693,
-0.30492380261421204,
0.8932528495788574,
-0.04896274954080582,
-0.8165337443351746,
0.3837396204471588,
0.03625495731830597,
-0.0005660764873027802,
0.030394062399864197,
0.37712767720222473,
-0.09189528226852417,
0.13809390366077423,
0.15339180827140808,
0.005736640654504299,
0.1795017421245575,
-0.8181029558181763,
-0.08071108162403107,
0.7788868546485901,
-0.513189435005188,
-0.2452075481414795,
0.563500165939331,
0.0612839013338089,
-0.5033475160598755,
0.36501380801200867,
0.13187092542648315,
-0.1798734962940216,
0.2650885283946991,
0.513243556022644,
0.8261695504188538,
-0.268907368183136,
0.19862216711044312,
0.2724619507789612,
0.18772630393505096,
-0.02105417661368847,
0.5226365923881531,
-0.20072747766971588,
-0.9776038527488708,
0.14432135224342346,
-0.6648367047309875,
-0.7897136211395264,
0.04965686425566673,
-0.806094765663147,
0.2394608110189438,
-0.3364008367061615,
-0.30197563767433167,
-0.0661989375948906,
-0.22712503373622894,
-0.5240528583526611,
0.1398461014032364,
0.06833720207214355,
0.7073773741722107,
-0.6722697019577026,
0.5905735492706299,
0.9681968092918396,
-0.5579813122749329,
-0.4974442422389984,
-0.08348259329795837,
-0.06324611604213715,
-0.6887145638465881,
0.29915183782577515,
0.07648967951536179,
0.1998465657234192,
0.04712597653269768,
-0.7658758759498596,
-0.5749651193618774,
0.6223430037498474,
0.36334162950515747,
-0.16214437782764435,
-0.01469181478023529,
0.1527344435453415,
0.41090232133865356,
-0.489579975605011,
0.6005778908729553,
0.3727465867996216,
0.5527780055999756,
-0.30105331540107727,
-0.8504279851913452,
-0.23162828385829926,
-0.2032860517501831,
-0.19499187171459198,
0.43115246295928955,
-0.5949224233627319,
0.5427359938621521,
-0.3657580316066742,
-0.09624442458152771,
-0.01071988232433796,
0.6330726742744446,
0.26103469729423523,
0.34720173478126526,
0.46453869342803955,
0.3976007103919983,
0.7887020707130432,
0.07653649896383286,
0.8629818558692932,
-0.07017717510461807,
-0.01759018562734127,
0.9302945137023926,
-0.5468935370445251,
1.145646572113037,
0.427828311920166,
-0.34042292833328247,
0.2787148654460907,
0.819994330406189,
0.43985775113105774,
0.49380940198898315,
0.3852919340133667,
-0.35008859634399414,
-0.14139729738235474,
-0.03921980410814285,
-0.2425018697977066,
0.24313077330589294,
0.5163660645484924,
-0.026586970314383507,
-0.12239589542150497,
0.06815380603075027,
-0.15767152607440948,
0.26877716183662415,
-0.018744714558124542,
0.9283236861228943,
-0.07933434098958969,
-0.8566985130310059,
0.11774727702140808,
0.06223466247320175,
0.5134455561637878,
-0.8222736716270447,
-0.08162664622068405,
-0.28104689717292786,
-0.08000218868255615,
-0.03490041196346283,
-0.8316612839698792,
-0.0508013516664505,
-0.10619302839040756,
-0.3775162696838379,
0.005349775310605764,
0.667838990688324,
-0.5379810929298401,
-0.21481189131736755,
0.1171291321516037,
0.6671952605247498,
0.315834641456604,
-0.202048197388649,
-0.5360018014907837,
-0.2719935178756714,
-0.037078652530908585,
-0.3056608736515045,
0.5918205976486206,
0.4085649847984314,
-0.2155790477991104,
0.8100783228874207,
0.8455855846405029,
0.25395703315734863,
-0.16497038304805756,
-0.039663489907979965,
0.5938627123832703,
-0.5850732326507568,
-0.4927266240119934,
-0.6973126530647278,
0.4650292694568634,
-0.014557844959199429,
-0.22444719076156616,
0.5711623430252075,
0.6153960227966309,
1.0078638792037964,
-0.07322343438863754,
1.202742338180542,
0.07614798843860626,
0.5960668325424194,
-0.5052564740180969,
0.5869308710098267,
-0.4676538407802582,
0.049404583871364594,
-0.16140690445899963,
-0.9706692695617676,
-0.2115318775177002,
0.7282201647758484,
-0.3197624385356903,
0.009095137007534504,
0.5281258821487427,
0.8422378301620483,
-0.1898130625486374,
0.30608099699020386,
0.26579973101615906,
-0.04625527188181877,
0.26799923181533813,
0.6538094878196716,
0.7973209023475647,
0.22036100924015045,
0.12212948501110077,
-0.20162402093410492,
-0.81540447473526,
-0.23262614011764526,
-0.7774508595466614,
-0.9563205242156982,
-0.6387804746627808,
-0.15048454701900482,
0.01402959693223238,
0.19551970064640045,
1.330419659614563,
0.6243398189544678,
-0.8572790026664734,
-0.5503925681114197,
0.04181855916976929,
0.1398354470729828,
-0.01962273195385933,
-0.2818773090839386,
0.19246111810207367,
-0.3924828767776489,
-0.8422295451164246,
0.2872735261917114,
0.3073502779006958,
0.13451772928237915,
-0.24602721631526947,
0.16232435405254364,
0.010636762715876102,
0.2377343624830246,
0.4105507731437683,
0.4388257563114166,
-0.6890057325363159,
-0.45535925030708313,
-0.09375512599945068,
-0.046846214681863785,
0.1395806074142456,
0.6705021262168884,
-0.7801625728607178,
0.6632153391838074,
0.6389778852462769,
0.8678112626075745,
0.4158863425254822,
0.13597510755062103,
0.9368361830711365,
-0.31327366828918457,
-0.09065115451812744,
0.17561106383800507,
0.2163611501455307,
0.033043693751096725,
-0.23384924232959747,
0.5606661438941956,
-0.06954400986433029,
-0.5635307431221008,
-0.7078327536582947,
0.2862979769706726,
-1.172733187675476,
-0.43848562240600586,
1.0672783851623535,
-0.05989043042063713,
-0.1862810105085373,
-0.10145015269517899,
-0.5578906536102295,
0.05002046003937721,
-0.6581529974937439,
0.6108943819999695,
0.616509735584259,
-0.36233624815940857,
0.14714579284191132,
-0.6426795721054077,
0.47580063343048096,
0.4434017241001129,
-0.7594166398048401,
0.08023200929164886,
0.7163097858428955,
0.07141447812318802,
-0.13741356134414673,
0.6072287559509277,
0.060225822031497955,
0.04075906053185463,
-0.38231390714645386,
0.18535569310188293,
0.001669428776949644,
-0.22847583889961243,
-0.2477046549320221,
0.503046989440918,
0.3031003475189209,
-0.28937679529190063
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.05530v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.05530v3
|
Gemini 1.5: Unlocking multimodal understanding across millions of tokens of context
| 2024-03-08T18:54:20 | 2024-06-14T10:14:10 |
Gemini Team, Petko Georgiev, Ving Ian Lei, Ryan Burnell, Libin Bai, Anmol Gulati, Garrett Tanzer, Damien Vincent, Zhufeng Pan, Shibo Wang, Soroosh Mariooryad, Yifan Ding, Xinyang Geng, Fred Alcober, Roy Frostig, Mark Omernick, Lexi Walker, Cosmin Paduraru, Christina Sorokin, Andrea Tacchetti, Colin Gaffney, Samira Daruki, Olcan Sercinoglu, Zach Gleicher, Juliette Love, Paul Voigtlaender, Rohan Jain, Gabriela Surita, Kareem Mohamed, Rory Blevins, Junwhan Ahn, Tao Zhu, Kornraphop Kawintiranon, Orhan Firat, Yiming Gu, Yujing Zhang, Matthew Rahtz, Manaal Faruqui, Natalie Clay, Justin Gilmer, JD Co-Reyes, Ivo Penchev, Rui Zhu, Nobuyuki Morioka, Kevin Hui, Krishna Haridasan, Victor Campos, Mahdis Mahdieh, Mandy Guo, Samer Hassan, Kevin Kilgour, Arpi Vezer, Heng-Tze Cheng, Raoul de Liedekerke, Siddharth Goyal, Paul Barham, DJ Strouse, Seb Noury, Jonas Adler, Mukund Sundararajan, Sharad Vikram, Dmitry Lepikhin, Michela Paganini, Xavier Garcia, Fan Yang, Dasha Valter, Maja Trebacz, Kiran Vodrahalli, Chulayuth Asawaroengchai, Roman Ring, Norbert Kalb, Livio Baldini Soares, Siddhartha Brahma, David Steiner, Tianhe Yu, Fabian Mentzer, Antoine He, Lucas Gonzalez, Bibo Xu, Raphael Lopez Kaufman, Laurent El Shafey, Junhyuk Oh, Tom Hennigan, George van den Driessche, Seth Odoom, Mario Lucic, Becca Roelofs, Sid Lall, Amit Marathe, Betty Chan, Santiago Ontanon, Luheng He, Denis Teplyashin, Jonathan Lai, Phil Crone, Bogdan Damoc, Lewis Ho, Sebastian Riedel, Karel Lenc, Chih-Kuan Yeh, Aakanksha Chowdhery, Yang Xu, Mehran Kazemi, Ehsan Amid, Anastasia Petrushkina, Kevin Swersky, Ali Khodaei, Gowoon Chen, Chris Larkin, Mario Pinto, Geng Yan, Adria Puigdomenech Badia, Piyush Patil, Steven Hansen, Dave Orr, Sebastien M. R. Arnold, Jordan Grimstad, Andrew Dai, Sholto Douglas, Rishika Sinha, Vikas Yadav, Xi Chen, Elena Gribovskaya, Jacob Austin, Jeffrey Zhao, Kaushal Patel, Paul Komarek, Sophia Austin, Sebastian Borgeaud, Linda Friso, Abhimanyu Goyal, Ben Caine, Kris Cao, Da-Woon Chung, Matthew Lamm, Gabe Barth-Maron, Thais Kagohara, Kate Olszewska, Mia Chen, Kaushik Shivakumar, Rishabh Agarwal, Harshal Godhia, Ravi Rajwar, Javier Snaider, Xerxes Dotiwalla, Yuan Liu, Aditya Barua, Victor Ungureanu, Yuan Zhang, Bat-Orgil Batsaikhan, Mateo Wirth, James Qin, Ivo Danihelka, Tulsee Doshi, Martin Chadwick, Jilin Chen, Sanil Jain, Quoc Le, Arjun Kar, Madhu Gurumurthy, Cheng Li, Ruoxin Sang, Fangyu Liu, Lampros Lamprou, Rich Munoz, Nathan Lintz, Harsh Mehta, Heidi Howard, Malcolm Reynolds, Lora Aroyo, Quan Wang, Lorenzo Blanco, Albin Cassirer, Jordan Griffith, Dipanjan Das, Stephan Lee, Jakub Sygnowski, Zach Fisher, James Besley, Richard Powell, Zafarali Ahmed, Dominik Paulus, David Reitter, Zalan Borsos, Rishabh Joshi, Aedan Pope, Steven Hand, Vittorio Selo, Vihan Jain, Nikhil Sethi, Megha Goel, Takaki Makino, Rhys May, Zhen Yang, Johan Schalkwyk, Christina Butterfield, Anja Hauth, Alex Goldin, Will Hawkins, Evan Senter, Sergey Brin, Oliver Woodman, Marvin Ritter, Eric Noland, Minh Giang, Vijay Bolina, Lisa Lee, Tim Blyth, Ian Mackinnon, Machel Reid, Obaid Sarvana, David Silver, Alexander Chen, Lily Wang, Loren Maggiore, Oscar Chang, Nithya Attaluri, Gregory Thornton, Chung-Cheng Chiu, Oskar Bunyan, Nir Levine, Timothy Chung, Evgenii Eltyshev, Xiance Si, Timothy Lillicrap, Demetra Brady, Vaibhav Aggarwal, Boxi Wu, Yuanzhong Xu, Ross McIlroy, Kartikeya Badola, Paramjit Sandhu, Erica Moreira, Wojciech Stokowiec, Ross Hemsley, Dong Li, Alex Tudor, Pranav Shyam, Elahe Rahimtoroghi, Salem Haykal, Pablo Sprechmann, Xiang Zhou, Diana Mincu, Yujia Li, Ravi Addanki, Kalpesh Krishna, Xiao Wu, Alexandre Frechette, Matan Eyal, Allan Dafoe, Dave Lacey, Jay Whang, Thi Avrahami, Ye Zhang, Emanuel Taropa, Hanzhao Lin, Daniel Toyama, Eliza Rutherford, Motoki Sano, HyunJeong Choe, Alex Tomala, Chalence Safranek-Shrader, Nora Kassner, Mantas Pajarskas, Matt Harvey, Sean Sechrist, Meire Fortunato, Christina Lyu, Gamaleldin Elsayed, Chenkai Kuang, James Lottes, Eric Chu, Chao Jia, Chih-Wei Chen, Peter Humphreys, Kate Baumli, Connie Tao, Rajkumar Samuel, Cicero Nogueira dos Santos, Anders Andreassen, Nemanja Rakićević, Dominik Grewe, Aviral Kumar, Stephanie Winkler, Jonathan Caton, Andrew Brock, Sid Dalmia, Hannah Sheahan, Iain Barr, Yingjie Miao, Paul Natsev, Jacob Devlin, Feryal Behbahani, Flavien Prost, Yanhua Sun, Artiom Myaskovsky, Thanumalayan Sankaranarayana Pillai, Dan Hurt, Angeliki Lazaridou, Xi Xiong, Ce Zheng, Fabio Pardo, Xiaowei Li, Dan Horgan, Joe Stanton, Moran Ambar, Fei Xia, Alejandro Lince, Mingqiu Wang, Basil Mustafa, Albert Webson, Hyo Lee, Rohan Anil, Martin Wicke, Timothy Dozat, Abhishek Sinha, Enrique Piqueras, Elahe Dabir, Shyam Upadhyay, Anudhyan Boral, Lisa Anne Hendricks, Corey Fry, Josip Djolonga, Yi Su, Jake Walker, Jane Labanowski, Ronny Huang, Vedant Misra, Jeremy Chen, RJ Skerry-Ryan, Avi Singh, Shruti Rijhwani, Dian Yu, Alex Castro-Ros, Beer Changpinyo, Romina Datta, Sumit Bagri, Arnar Mar Hrafnkelsson, Marcello Maggioni, Daniel Zheng, Yury Sulsky, Shaobo Hou, Tom Le Paine, Antoine Yang, Jason Riesa, Dominika Rogozinska, Dror Marcus, Dalia El Badawy, Qiao Zhang, Luyu Wang, Helen Miller, Jeremy Greer, Lars Lowe Sjos, Azade Nova, Heiga Zen, Rahma Chaabouni, Mihaela Rosca, Jiepu Jiang, Charlie Chen, Ruibo Liu, Tara Sainath, Maxim Krikun, Alex Polozov, Jean-Baptiste Lespiau, Josh Newlan, Zeyncep Cankara, Soo Kwak, Yunhan Xu, Phil Chen, Andy Coenen, Clemens Meyer, Katerina Tsihlas, Ada Ma, Juraj Gottweis, Jinwei Xing, Chenjie Gu, Jin Miao, Christian Frank, Zeynep Cankara, Sanjay Ganapathy, Ishita Dasgupta, Steph Hughes-Fitt, Heng Chen, David Reid, Keran Rong, Hongmin Fan, Joost van Amersfoort, Vincent Zhuang, Aaron Cohen, Shixiang Shane Gu, Anhad Mohananey, Anastasija Ilic, Taylor Tobin, John Wieting, Anna Bortsova, Phoebe Thacker, Emma Wang, Emily Caveness, Justin Chiu, Eren Sezener, Alex Kaskasoli, Steven Baker, Katie Millican, Mohamed Elhawaty, Kostas Aisopos, Carl Lebsack, Nathan Byrd, Hanjun Dai, Wenhao Jia, Matthew Wiethoff, Elnaz Davoodi, Albert Weston, Lakshman Yagati, Arun Ahuja, Isabel Gao, Golan Pundak, Susan Zhang, Michael Azzam, Khe Chai Sim, Sergi Caelles, James Keeling, Abhanshu Sharma, Andy Swing, YaGuang Li, Chenxi Liu, Carrie Grimes Bostock, Yamini Bansal, Zachary Nado, Ankesh Anand, Josh Lipschultz, Abhijit Karmarkar, Lev Proleev, Abe Ittycheriah, Soheil Hassas Yeganeh, George Polovets, Aleksandra Faust, Jiao Sun, Alban Rrustemi, Pen Li, Rakesh Shivanna, Jeremiah Liu, Chris Welty, Federico Lebron, Anirudh Baddepudi, Sebastian Krause, Emilio Parisotto, Radu Soricut, Zheng Xu, Dawn Bloxwich, Melvin Johnson, Behnam Neyshabur, Justin Mao-Jones, Renshen Wang, Vinay Ramasesh, Zaheer Abbas, Arthur Guez, Constant Segal, Duc Dung Nguyen, James Svensson, Le Hou, Sarah York, Kieran Milan, Sophie Bridgers, Wiktor Gworek, Marco Tagliasacchi, James Lee-Thorp, Michael Chang, Alexey Guseynov, Ale Jakse Hartman, Michael Kwong, Ruizhe Zhao, Sheleem Kashem, Elizabeth Cole, Antoine Miech, Richard Tanburn, Mary Phuong, Filip Pavetic, Sebastien Cevey, Ramona Comanescu, Richard Ives, Sherry Yang, Cosmo Du, Bo Li, Zizhao Zhang, Mariko Iinuma, Clara Huiyi Hu, Aurko Roy, Shaan Bijwadia, Zhenkai Zhu, Danilo Martins, Rachel Saputro, Anita Gergely, Steven Zheng, Dawei Jia, Ioannis Antonoglou, Adam Sadovsky, Shane Gu, Yingying Bi, Alek Andreev, Sina Samangooei, Mina Khan, Tomas Kocisky, Angelos Filos, Chintu Kumar, Colton Bishop, Adams Yu, Sarah Hodkinson, Sid Mittal, Premal Shah, Alexandre Moufarek, Yong Cheng, Adam Bloniarz, Jaehoon Lee, Pedram Pejman, Paul Michel, Stephen Spencer, Vladimir Feinberg, Xuehan Xiong, Nikolay Savinov, Charlotte Smith, Siamak Shakeri, Dustin Tran, Mary Chesus, Bernd Bohnet, George Tucker, Tamara von Glehn, Carrie Muir, Yiran Mao, Hideto Kazawa, Ambrose Slone, Kedar Soparkar, Disha Shrivastava, James Cobon-Kerr, Michael Sharman, Jay Pavagadhi, Carlos Araya, Karolis Misiunas, Nimesh Ghelani, Michael Laskin, David Barker, Qiujia Li, Anton Briukhov, Neil Houlsby, Mia Glaese, Balaji Lakshminarayanan, Nathan Schucher, Yunhao Tang, Eli Collins, Hyeontaek Lim, Fangxiaoyu Feng, Adria Recasens, Guangda Lai, Alberto Magni, Nicola De Cao, Aditya Siddhant, Zoe Ashwood, Jordi Orbay, Mostafa Dehghani, Jenny Brennan, Yifan He, Kelvin Xu, Yang Gao, Carl Saroufim, James Molloy, Xinyi Wu, Seb Arnold, Solomon Chang, Julian Schrittwieser, Elena Buchatskaya, Soroush Radpour, Martin Polacek, Skye Giordano, Ankur Bapna, Simon Tokumine, Vincent Hellendoorn, Thibault Sottiaux, Sarah Cogan, Aliaksei Severyn, Mohammad Saleh, Shantanu Thakoor, Laurent Shefey, Siyuan Qiao, Meenu Gaba, Shuo-yiin Chang, Craig Swanson, Biao Zhang, Benjamin Lee, Paul Kishan Rubenstein, Gan Song, Tom Kwiatkowski, Anna Koop, Ajay Kannan, David Kao, Parker Schuh, Axel Stjerngren, Golnaz Ghiasi, Gena Gibson, Luke Vilnis, Ye Yuan, Felipe Tiengo Ferreira, Aishwarya Kamath, Ted Klimenko, Ken Franko, Kefan Xiao, Indro Bhattacharya, Miteyan Patel, Rui Wang, Alex Morris, Robin Strudel, Vivek Sharma, Peter Choy, Sayed Hadi Hashemi, Jessica Landon, Mara Finkelstein, Priya Jhakra, Justin Frye, Megan Barnes, Matthew Mauger, Dennis Daun, Khuslen Baatarsukh, Matthew Tung, Wael Farhan, Henryk Michalewski, Fabio Viola, Felix de Chaumont Quitry, Charline Le Lan, Tom Hudson, Qingze Wang, Felix Fischer, Ivy Zheng, Elspeth White, Anca Dragan, Jean-baptiste Alayrac, Eric Ni, Alexander Pritzel, Adam Iwanicki, Michael Isard, Anna Bulanova, Lukas Zilka, Ethan Dyer, Devendra Sachan, Srivatsan Srinivasan, Hannah Muckenhirn, Honglong Cai, Amol Mandhane, Mukarram Tariq, Jack W. Rae, Gary Wang, Kareem Ayoub, Nicholas FitzGerald, Yao Zhao, Woohyun Han, Chris Alberti, Dan Garrette, Kashyap Krishnakumar, Mai Gimenez, Anselm Levskaya, Daniel Sohn, Josip Matak, Inaki Iturrate, Michael B. Chang, Jackie Xiang, Yuan Cao, Nishant Ranka, Geoff Brown, Adrian Hutter, Vahab Mirrokni, Nanxin Chen, Kaisheng Yao, Zoltan Egyed, Francois Galilee, Tyler Liechty, Praveen Kallakuri, Evan Palmer, Sanjay Ghemawat, Jasmine Liu, David Tao, Chloe Thornton, Tim Green, Mimi Jasarevic, Sharon Lin, Victor Cotruta, Yi-Xuan Tan, Noah Fiedel, Hongkun Yu, Ed Chi, Alexander Neitz, Jens Heitkaemper, Anu Sinha, Denny Zhou, Yi Sun, Charbel Kaed, Brice Hulse, Swaroop Mishra, Maria Georgaki, Sneha Kudugunta, Clement Farabet, Izhak Shafran, Daniel Vlasic, Anton Tsitsulin, Rajagopal Ananthanarayanan, Alen Carin, Guolong Su, Pei Sun, Shashank V, Gabriel Carvajal, Josef Broder, Iulia Comsa, Alena Repina, William Wong, Warren Weilun Chen, Peter Hawkins, Egor Filonov, Lucia Loher, Christoph Hirnschall, Weiyi Wang, Jingchen Ye, Andrea Burns, Hardie Cate, Diana Gage Wright, Federico Piccinini, Lei Zhang, Chu-Cheng Lin, Ionel Gog, Yana Kulizhskaya, Ashwin Sreevatsa, Shuang Song, Luis C. Cobo, Anand Iyer, Chetan Tekur, Guillermo Garrido, Zhuyun Xiao, Rupert Kemp, Huaixiu Steven Zheng, Hui Li, Ananth Agarwal, Christel Ngani, Kati Goshvadi, Rebeca Santamaria-Fernandez, Wojciech Fica, Xinyun Chen, Chris Gorgolewski, Sean Sun, Roopal Garg, Xinyu Ye, S. M. Ali Eslami, Nan Hua, Jon Simon, Pratik Joshi, Yelin Kim, Ian Tenney, Sahitya Potluri, Lam Nguyen Thiet, Quan Yuan, Florian Luisier, Alexandra Chronopoulou, Salvatore Scellato, Praveen Srinivasan, Minmin Chen, Vinod Koverkathu, Valentin Dalibard, Yaming Xu, Brennan Saeta, Keith Anderson, Thibault Sellam, Nick Fernando, Fantine Huot, Junehyuk Jung, Mani Varadarajan, Michael Quinn, Amit Raul, Maigo Le, Ruslan Habalov, Jon Clark, Komal Jalan, Kalesha Bullard, Achintya Singhal, Thang Luong, Boyu Wang, Sujeevan Rajayogam, Julian Eisenschlos, Johnson Jia, Daniel Finchelstein, Alex Yakubovich, Daniel Balle, Michael Fink, Sameer Agarwal, Jing Li, Dj Dvijotham, Shalini Pal, Kai Kang, Jaclyn Konzelmann, Jennifer Beattie, Olivier Dousse, Diane Wu, Remi Crocker, Chen Elkind, Siddhartha Reddy Jonnalagadda, Jong Lee, Dan Holtmann-Rice, Krystal Kallarackal, Rosanne Liu, Denis Vnukov, Neera Vats, Luca Invernizzi, Mohsen Jafari, Huanjie Zhou, Lilly Taylor, Jennifer Prendki, Marcus Wu, Tom Eccles, Tianqi Liu, Kavya Kopparapu, Francoise Beaufays, Christof Angermueller, Andreea Marzoca, Shourya Sarcar, Hilal Dib, Jeff Stanway, Frank Perbet, Nejc Trdin, Rachel Sterneck, Andrey Khorlin, Dinghua Li, Xihui Wu, Sonam Goenka, David Madras, Sasha Goldshtein, Willi Gierke, Tong Zhou, Yaxin Liu, Yannie Liang, Anais White, Yunjie Li, Shreya Singh, Sanaz Bahargam, Mark Epstein, Sujoy Basu, Li Lao, Adnan Ozturel, Carl Crous, Alex Zhai, Han Lu, Zora Tung, Neeraj Gaur, Alanna Walton, Lucas Dixon, Ming Zhang, Amir Globerson, Grant Uy, Andrew Bolt, Olivia Wiles, Milad Nasr, Ilia Shumailov, Marco Selvi, Francesco Piccinno, Ricardo Aguilar, Sara McCarthy, Misha Khalman, Mrinal Shukla, Vlado Galic, John Carpenter, Kevin Villela, Haibin Zhang, Harry Richardson, James Martens, Matko Bosnjak, Shreyas Rammohan Belle, Jeff Seibert, Mahmoud Alnahlawi, Brian McWilliams, Sankalp Singh, Annie Louis, Wen Ding, Dan Popovici, Lenin Simicich, Laura Knight, Pulkit Mehta, Nishesh Gupta, Chongyang Shi, Saaber Fatehi, Jovana Mitrovic, Alex Grills, Joseph Pagadora, Dessie Petrova, Danielle Eisenbud, Zhishuai Zhang, Damion Yates, Bhavishya Mittal, Nilesh Tripuraneni, Yannis Assael, Thomas Brovelli, Prateek Jain, Mihajlo Velimirovic, Canfer Akbulut, Jiaqi Mu, Wolfgang Macherey, Ravin Kumar, Jun Xu, Haroon Qureshi, Gheorghe Comanici, Jeremy Wiesner, Zhitao Gong, Anton Ruddock, Matthias Bauer, Nick Felt, Anirudh GP, Anurag Arnab, Dustin Zelle, Jonas Rothfuss, Bill Rosgen, Ashish Shenoy, Bryan Seybold, Xinjian Li, Jayaram Mudigonda, Goker Erdogan, Jiawei Xia, Jiri Simsa, Andrea Michi, Yi Yao, Christopher Yew, Steven Kan, Isaac Caswell, Carey Radebaugh, Andre Elisseeff, Pedro Valenzuela, Kay McKinney, Kim Paterson, Albert Cui, Eri Latorre-Chimoto, Solomon Kim, William Zeng, Ken Durden, Priya Ponnapalli, Tiberiu Sosea, Christopher A. Choquette-Choo, James Manyika, Brona Robenek, Harsha Vashisht, Sebastien Pereira, Hoi Lam, Marko Velic, Denese Owusu-Afriyie, Katherine Lee, Tolga Bolukbasi, Alicia Parrish, Shawn Lu, Jane Park, Balaji Venkatraman, Alice Talbert, Lambert Rosique, Yuchung Cheng, Andrei Sozanschi, Adam Paszke, Praveen Kumar, Jessica Austin, Lu Li, Khalid Salama, Wooyeol Kim, Nandita Dukkipati, Anthony Baryshnikov, Christos Kaplanis, XiangHai Sheng, Yuri Chervonyi, Caglar Unlu, Diego de Las Casas, Harry Askham, Kathryn Tunyasuvunakool, Felix Gimeno, Siim Poder, Chester Kwak, Matt Miecnikowski, Vahab Mirrokni, Alek Dimitriev, Aaron Parisi, Dangyi Liu, Tomy Tsai, Toby Shevlane, Christina Kouridi, Drew Garmon, Adrian Goedeckemeyer, Adam R. Brown, Anitha Vijayakumar, Ali Elqursh, Sadegh Jazayeri, Jin Huang, Sara Mc Carthy, Jay Hoover, Lucy Kim, Sandeep Kumar, Wei Chen, Courtney Biles, Garrett Bingham, Evan Rosen, Lisa Wang, Qijun Tan, David Engel, Francesco Pongetti, Dario de Cesare, Dongseong Hwang, Lily Yu, Jennifer Pullman, Srini Narayanan, Kyle Levin, Siddharth Gopal, Megan Li, Asaf Aharoni, Trieu Trinh, Jessica Lo, Norman Casagrande, Roopali Vij, Loic Matthey, Bramandia Ramadhana, Austin Matthews, CJ Carey, Matthew Johnson, Kremena Goranova, Rohin Shah, Shereen Ashraf, Kingshuk Dasgupta, Rasmus Larsen, Yicheng Wang, Manish Reddy Vuyyuru, Chong Jiang, Joana Ijazi, Kazuki Osawa, Celine Smith, Ramya Sree Boppana, Taylan Bilal, Yuma Koizumi, Ying Xu, Yasemin Altun, Nir Shabat, Ben Bariach, Alex Korchemniy, Kiam Choo, Olaf Ronneberger, Chimezie Iwuanyanwu, Shubin Zhao, David Soergel, Cho-Jui Hsieh, Irene Cai, Shariq Iqbal, Martin Sundermeyer, Zhe Chen, Elie Bursztein, Chaitanya Malaviya, Fadi Biadsy, Prakash Shroff, Inderjit Dhillon, Tejasi Latkar, Chris Dyer, Hannah Forbes, Massimo Nicosia, Vitaly Nikolaev, Somer Greene, Marin Georgiev, Pidong Wang, Nina Martin, Hanie Sedghi, John Zhang, Praseem Banzal, Doug Fritz, Vikram Rao, Xuezhi Wang, Jiageng Zhang, Viorica Patraucean, Dayou Du, Igor Mordatch, Ivan Jurin, Lewis Liu, Ayush Dubey, Abhi Mohan, Janek Nowakowski, Vlad-Doru Ion, Nan Wei, Reiko Tojo, Maria Abi Raad, Drew A. Hudson, Vaishakh Keshava, Shubham Agrawal, Kevin Ramirez, Zhichun Wu, Hoang Nguyen, Ji Liu, Madhavi Sewak, Bryce Petrini, DongHyun Choi, Ivan Philips, Ziyue Wang, Ioana Bica, Ankush Garg, Jarek Wilkiewicz, Priyanka Agrawal, Xiaowei Li, Danhao Guo, Emily Xue, Naseer Shaik, Andrew Leach, Sadh MNM Khan, Julia Wiesinger, Sammy Jerome, Abhishek Chakladar, Alek Wenjiao Wang, Tina Ornduff, Folake Abu, Alireza Ghaffarkhah, Marcus Wainwright, Mario Cortes, Frederick Liu, Joshua Maynez, Slav Petrov, Yonghui Wu, Demis Hassabis, Koray Kavukcuoglu, Jeffrey Dean, Oriol Vinyals
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In this report, we introduce the Gemini 1.5 family of models, representing
the next generation of highly compute-efficient multimodal models capable of
recalling and reasoning over fine-grained information from millions of tokens
of context, including multiple long documents and hours of video and audio. The
family includes two new models: (1) an updated Gemini 1.5 Pro, which exceeds
the February version on the great majority of capabilities and benchmarks; (2)
Gemini 1.5 Flash, a more lightweight variant designed for efficiency with
minimal regression in quality. Gemini 1.5 models achieve near-perfect recall on
long-context retrieval tasks across modalities, improve the state-of-the-art in
long-document QA, long-video QA and long-context ASR, and match or surpass
Gemini 1.0 Ultra's state-of-the-art performance across a broad set of
benchmarks. Studying the limits of Gemini 1.5's long-context ability, we find
continued improvement in next-token prediction and near-perfect retrieval
(>99%) up to at least 10M tokens, a generational leap over existing models such
as Claude 3.0 (200k) and GPT-4 Turbo (128k). Finally, we highlight real-world
use cases, such as Gemini 1.5 collaborating with professionals on completing
their tasks achieving 26 to 75% time savings across 10 different job
categories, as well as surprising new capabilities of large language models at
the frontier; when given a grammar manual for Kalamang, a language with fewer
than 200 speakers worldwide, the model learns to translate English to Kalamang
at a similar level to a person who learned from the same content.
|
[
-0.522882878780365,
-0.43199846148490906,
0.4236488938331604,
0.36266112327575684,
-0.22991548478603363,
-0.25820499658584595,
-0.035886406898498535,
-0.5919262766838074,
0.10991354286670685,
0.5180525779724121,
-0.8583506941795349,
-0.46405187249183655,
-0.7155023813247681,
-0.10166362673044205,
-0.6997359991073608,
0.9017400741577148,
0.25864526629447937,
-0.16353082656860352,
-0.317719042301178,
-0.20686623454093933,
-0.42655864357948303,
-0.4829769730567932,
-0.6329421997070312,
0.07056935131549835,
0.7122495174407959,
0.4809184670448303,
0.7346494197845459,
0.5114331245422363,
0.6397339701652527,
0.2391803115606308,
-0.21757163107395172,
-0.055641282349824905,
-0.4205480217933655,
0.07324942201375961,
-0.25344860553741455,
-0.11321408301591873,
-0.638240396976471,
0.1028519719839096,
0.5879676342010498,
0.6977539658546448,
0.01278902217745781,
0.26837313175201416,
-0.42030030488967896,
0.6664217710494995,
-0.725673496723175,
0.3152927756309509,
-0.5285090208053589,
-0.04628164693713188,
-0.07032322883605957,
0.021876731887459755,
-0.4661197066307068,
0.34112539887428284,
0.2988151013851166,
-0.8947887420654297,
-0.008463689126074314,
-0.06680546700954437,
0.5621995329856873,
0.3868734538555145,
-0.7263584136962891,
-0.2800893187522888,
-0.5448827147483826,
0.6137004494667053,
-0.513762354850769,
0.5076895356178284,
0.2336696982383728,
0.5269954204559326,
0.003880705451592803,
-1.3164560794830322,
-0.637472927570343,
-0.23690466582775116,
0.10228880494832993,
0.3964060842990875,
-0.06434593349695206,
0.09159214049577713,
0.18875423073768616,
0.27624690532684326,
-0.2867022454738617,
-0.046356797218322754,
-0.5457431077957153,
-0.06734155118465424,
0.2572627365589142,
0.2362860143184662,
-0.06346318870782852,
-0.530556857585907,
-0.43214619159698486,
-0.08156291395425797,
-0.5924992561340332,
0.07336222380399704,
-0.06970448791980743,
0.10006724298000336,
-0.1686359941959381,
0.2628307640552521,
-0.14741146564483643,
0.5870402455329895,
-0.1899423450231552,
-0.1830216944217682,
-0.031674325466156006,
-0.673891544342041,
-0.15773726999759674,
-0.2147451788187027,
0.4788301885128021,
0.20944084227085114,
-0.10182881355285645,
-0.11372314393520355,
-0.1369716227054596,
0.05889522284269333,
0.2793635129928589,
-0.6889562010765076,
-0.03268439695239067,
0.2557249069213867,
-0.7645586729049683,
-0.03410254046320915,
0.26979923248291016,
-0.2634589374065399,
-0.4029504358768463,
-0.4297869801521301,
0.5224286913871765,
-0.680928647518158,
-0.3082740604877472,
0.1390104442834854,
-0.30371272563934326,
0.2273339033126831,
0.4855605959892273,
-1.0155189037322998,
0.2430764138698578,
1.1062228679656982,
0.7079184651374817,
-0.0693126991391182,
-0.36238110065460205,
-0.437325119972229,
0.005599916912615299,
-0.21129897236824036,
0.3687642514705658,
-0.5536931753158569,
-0.4394192695617676,
-0.19363176822662354,
-0.14093747735023499,
-0.011500310152769089,
-0.4268561899662018,
0.5766705870628357,
-0.33972984552383423,
0.28991618752479553,
-0.29146283864974976,
-0.44265520572662354,
-0.14775213599205017,
0.3623681664466858,
-0.7048386931419373,
0.9966511130332947,
0.4053455889225006,
-0.6687644720077515,
0.4820030927658081,
-0.9762629270553589,
-0.26890578866004944,
-0.1516779512166977,
0.11324616521596909,
-0.007418052759021521,
0.2693154215812683,
0.13008658587932587,
0.4135068356990814,
-0.19615969061851501,
0.21361050009727478,
-0.11034300923347473,
-0.4413032531738281,
0.18960745632648468,
-0.5102153420448303,
0.4862027168273926,
0.47577914595603943,
-0.14364251494407654,
0.4247657060623169,
-0.575774073600769,
-0.40219050645828247,
-0.31608250737190247,
-0.2962858974933624,
-0.11725073307752609,
0.03978946805000305,
0.38523340225219727,
0.7132143378257751,
0.30772262811660767,
-0.6375367045402527,
0.26713827252388,
-0.2413983792066574,
0.5948806405067444,
0.7455662488937378,
-0.44923877716064453,
0.37807828187942505,
-0.1432274878025055,
0.5327053666114807,
0.542808473110199,
0.8348960876464844,
-1.0413258075714111,
-0.4221956431865692,
-0.7246692776679993,
-0.5160514712333679,
0.44084253907203674,
0.1773616522550583,
-0.7713451981544495,
-0.03344915807247162,
-0.5483852028846741,
-0.30161944031715393,
-0.6262179613113403,
-0.08716954290866852,
0.4293237328529358,
0.5314407348632812,
0.39127886295318604,
-0.29747042059898376,
-0.4930267035961151,
-0.9885293841362,
-0.06513369828462601,
0.02540328912436962,
0.1491570621728897,
0.4382208287715912,
0.6464129686355591,
-0.4212161600589752,
1.0850942134857178,
-0.04893583059310913,
-0.014942561276257038,
-0.19186100363731384,
0.17100147902965546,
0.31935495138168335,
0.3767172396183014,
0.5303409695625305,
-1.1001323461532593,
-0.4010792374610901,
-0.04483772814273834,
-0.6470518112182617,
0.435345858335495,
-0.2696310579776764,
-0.049285776913166046,
0.45622718334198,
0.6293551325798035,
-0.5919579863548279,
0.28398919105529785,
0.6835130453109741,
-0.6985073089599609,
0.3706527650356293,
-0.254753440618515,
-0.1065976545214653,
-1.3700810670852661,
0.3891286551952362,
-0.10580769926309586,
-0.32185131311416626,
-0.579897940158844,
0.13683077692985535,
0.4887891411781311,
-0.09978604316711426,
-0.7032819986343384,
0.9206010699272156,
-0.420297771692276,
-0.10387256741523743,
-0.12547674775123596,
0.22059224545955658,
-0.35435375571250916,
0.3066295087337494,
-0.1954875886440277,
0.7086586356163025,
0.6537720561027527,
-0.5868309140205383,
0.3009628355503082,
0.19022363424301147,
-0.4404216706752777,
0.3440259099006653,
-0.36675623059272766,
0.06527489423751831,
-0.5525732636451721,
0.472126841545105,
-1.059566617012024,
-0.2935861349105835,
0.014134068973362446,
-0.6006744503974915,
0.24299190938472748,
-0.10257841646671295,
-0.3651933968067169,
-0.5188086032867432,
-0.360277384519577,
0.189875528216362,
0.35230815410614014,
-0.7720849514007568,
0.9845050573348999,
0.21133337914943695,
-0.16867123544216156,
-1.0428460836410522,
-0.45138418674468994,
0.28354427218437195,
0.05575603246688843,
-0.9015799760818481,
0.6423414945602417,
0.08262133598327637,
-0.11950056254863739,
-0.04086247831583023,
-0.46268612146377563,
0.14313474297523499,
0.2821149528026581,
0.4002262353897095,
0.4828735291957855,
-0.04981207847595215,
0.19455739855766296,
0.19424523413181305,
-0.41021814942359924,
-0.019796213135123253,
-0.42766886949539185,
0.3930351138114929,
-0.06418628245592117,
-0.19734956324100494,
-0.29943379759788513,
0.28560781478881836,
1.1026510000228882,
-0.2988741993904114,
0.9651170372962952,
0.8109850883483887,
-0.3924080729484558,
0.1382799744606018,
-0.5670216679573059,
-0.1177777424454689,
-0.47624528408050537,
0.4920240044593811,
-0.6371711492538452,
-0.8595117330551147,
0.7200678586959839,
-0.030348846688866615,
0.24268941581249237,
0.5284113883972168,
0.211899071931839,
0.05348464474081993,
1.0380414724349976,
0.8306129574775696,
-0.2759297788143158,
0.8875859379768372,
-0.41556045413017273,
-0.046200286597013474,
-0.8718369007110596,
-0.502737283706665,
-0.2442452758550644,
-0.440611332654953,
-0.4123057425022125,
-0.4222484230995178,
0.6805272698402405,
-0.037353336811065674,
-0.08191590011119843,
0.24962849915027618,
-0.20054872334003448,
0.516922116279602,
0.9119870066642761,
0.06507151573896408,
0.30434203147888184,
-0.3184957206249237,
-0.13194547593593597,
0.16971606016159058,
-0.8756710886955261,
-0.35088321566581726,
1.340590476989746,
0.3463190197944641,
0.5841749906539917,
0.1988331526517868,
0.427109956741333,
-0.040661927312612534,
0.8271507024765015,
-0.6981982588768005,
0.44003474712371826,
-0.5053679347038269,
-1.1572331190109253,
-0.10441620647907257,
-0.4633568525314331,
-0.8125512599945068,
0.4224521815776825,
-0.45945030450820923,
-0.4965590834617615,
-0.18719260394573212,
0.029680529609322548,
-0.33700570464134216,
0.002210692735388875,
-0.6372216939926147,
1.2501639127731323,
-0.21559634804725647,
-0.45207226276397705,
-0.5551192164421082,
-1.0926377773284912,
0.4093500077724457,
0.035875651985406876,
0.13680259883403778,
-0.05213334038853645,
-0.1346762776374817,
0.5346017479896545,
-0.04665597155690193,
0.532381534576416,
-0.22661073505878448,
0.19674202799797058,
0.12224781513214111,
-0.1039043590426445,
0.24122877418994904,
0.08404894173145294,
-0.12938393652439117,
-0.06882788985967636,
0.4314417839050293,
-0.3931090235710144,
-0.40656521916389465,
0.7347710728645325,
-0.6151303052902222,
-0.3505564033985138,
-0.2914399206638336,
-0.6815550327301025,
0.05044234171509743,
0.1298353523015976,
0.0672042965888977,
0.7450069785118103,
-0.3453207314014435,
0.5339534282684326,
0.47814643383026123,
-0.3355783224105835,
0.5999804139137268,
0.5069084763526917,
-0.3720112442970276,
-0.3991350829601288,
0.6322720050811768,
-0.03413014113903046,
0.30836862325668335,
0.513170063495636,
-0.05631569027900696,
-0.47081977128982544,
-0.29704299569129944,
-0.3751581907272339,
0.24061556160449982,
-0.8607171773910522,
0.015318346209824085,
-0.7029432058334351,
0.13761071860790253,
-0.6166994571685791,
-0.00526661891490221,
-0.5520221590995789,
-0.7336869835853577,
-0.1381598263978958,
0.12816499173641205,
-0.0353764072060585,
0.7818660736083984,
0.1514904946088791,
0.3356491029262543,
-0.9130531549453735,
0.3382190763950348,
0.1302180141210556,
0.3898976147174835,
-0.1522376984357834,
-0.5279129147529602,
-0.4451141655445099,
-0.16436991095542908,
-0.5853443741798401,
-0.6559377312660217,
0.3190942704677582,
-0.08995562046766281,
0.5328816175460815,
0.5757935643196106,
-0.3215941786766052,
0.7298489809036255,
-0.04053712636232376,
0.8819464445114136,
0.2993593215942383,
-1.1778552532196045,
0.29194164276123047,
-0.6206055283546448,
0.5258323550224304,
0.4974307417869568,
0.37216290831565857,
-1.1131203174591064,
0.11917334794998169,
-0.6462066769599915,
-0.8953699469566345,
0.963712215423584,
0.19839921593666077,
0.24016648530960083,
-0.24315054714679718,
0.6897163987159729,
0.3377918601036072,
0.1826479732990265,
-0.5103312730789185,
-0.27601945400238037,
-0.4148108661174774,
-0.49080148339271545,
-0.2646953761577606,
-0.11467195302248001,
0.16975295543670654,
-0.48149242997169495,
0.35942542552948,
-0.24748225510120392,
0.3333509862422943,
0.24403882026672363,
-0.016273075714707375,
0.2111584097146988,
0.17601916193962097,
0.7041628360748291,
0.9538353681564331,
-0.18166875839233398,
0.07317745685577393,
0.11278586834669113,
-0.4379872977733612,
-0.3831615746021271,
0.20217253267765045,
0.2356298863887787,
-0.11420042812824249,
0.2506100535392761,
0.8008714914321899,
0.47939950227737427,
-0.7744566202163696,
0.542754054069519,
-0.06766609847545624,
-0.1324950009584427,
-0.4694385528564453,
0.03164738416671753,
0.2657093107700348,
0.1904117912054062,
0.31178733706474304,
0.17569676041603088,
0.11555812507867813,
-1.1346033811569214,
0.06151807680726051,
0.5144926905632019,
-0.3313002586364746,
-0.3076968491077423,
0.939524233341217,
0.4132257103919983,
-0.030305689200758934,
0.9060891270637512,
0.02180079184472561,
-0.4916606843471527,
0.6653966307640076,
0.5361360907554626,
0.5432868003845215,
-0.03228209540247917,
0.050526779145002365,
0.45678240060806274,
0.10636963695287704,
-0.3987329602241516,
0.33750250935554504,
-0.28489139676094055,
-0.5068513751029968,
-0.3849708139896393,
-0.3977774977684021,
-0.6675540208816528,
-0.22689436376094818,
-0.4802835285663605,
0.18459773063659668,
-0.4642469584941864,
-0.29517021775245667,
0.07687687128782272,
-0.09237459301948547,
-0.5832872986793518,
0.17889174818992615,
0.44165217876434326,
1.4578932523727417,
-0.3271927833557129,
1.0023897886276245,
0.6645411252975464,
-0.3181404173374176,
-0.5228825807571411,
-0.4254562258720398,
0.021127834916114807,
-0.38877514004707336,
0.637298583984375,
0.4183681905269623,
-0.04428139328956604,
-0.009560244157910347,
-0.49505001306533813,
-0.9155411124229431,
1.5382874011993408,
0.2905749976634979,
-0.4660291075706482,
-0.08416301757097244,
-0.06883116811513901,
0.3959113657474518,
-0.5034207701683044,
0.5246763229370117,
0.47790560126304626,
0.5665748119354248,
0.242655411362648,
-1.1174366474151611,
-0.17596930265426636,
-0.40863943099975586,
-0.14062084257602692,
0.39112555980682373,
-0.7276095151901245,
1.1641544103622437,
-0.24390210211277008,
-0.19961632788181305,
0.40551888942718506,
0.6261420249938965,
0.04893868416547775,
0.6360426545143127,
0.3026725947856903,
0.33732959628105164,
0.6723999381065369,
-0.27653366327285767,
1.4022122621536255,
-0.6401448845863342,
0.25715112686157227,
0.9070169925689697,
0.16283033788204193,
0.9060789942741394,
0.6443977952003479,
0.16972586512565613,
0.45018741488456726,
0.4184318482875824,
0.4695713222026825,
0.32883813977241516,
-0.17995548248291016,
-0.4227767884731293,
-0.3361292779445648,
0.10908811539411545,
-0.18541282415390015,
0.38797834515571594,
0.4681623578071594,
-0.5611617565155029,
0.25576093792915344,
0.040302351117134094,
0.05499482899904251,
-0.32384899258613586,
-0.4856868386268616,
0.5443527102470398,
0.03166615962982178,
-1.1200393438339233,
0.24433431029319763,
0.30819544196128845,
0.9279426336288452,
-0.7440815567970276,
0.22310982644557953,
-0.3563143014907837,
0.5859784483909607,
-0.09848245233297348,
-0.592832624912262,
0.21696718037128448,
-0.19634298980236053,
-0.07682324200868607,
-0.35655587911605835,
0.684398353099823,
-0.17259332537651062,
-0.4145404100418091,
0.22175586223602295,
0.3906221091747284,
-0.07436256855726242,
-0.4179011583328247,
-0.5169095993041992,
0.03167695179581642,
-0.3533603549003601,
-0.2732822299003601,
0.13842105865478516,
0.2380146086215973,
0.038622308522462845,
0.9573748111724854,
0.6124976873397827,
-0.38118818402290344,
0.39706116914749146,
0.044192057102918625,
0.8713378310203552,
-1.0714842081069946,
-0.44984081387519836,
-0.5856524109840393,
0.635758638381958,
-0.15440723299980164,
-0.7258445620536804,
0.6658008694648743,
0.5660656690597534,
0.9453224539756775,
-0.16907957196235657,
0.5112476944923401,
-0.14444193243980408,
0.2151883989572525,
-0.38696515560150146,
0.4311036765575409,
-0.7596422433853149,
0.05659805238246918,
-0.23760630190372467,
-0.7120429873466492,
-0.31378310918807983,
0.47162386775016785,
-0.1726214438676834,
0.1477411687374115,
0.8212244510650635,
0.7523934841156006,
-0.3216750919818878,
0.20137737691402435,
0.3483660817146301,
0.16679930686950684,
0.3280552625656128,
0.6540940999984741,
0.9164091944694519,
-0.606157124042511,
0.7163631319999695,
-0.15243197977542877,
-0.2121511697769165,
-0.12745165824890137,
-0.605130136013031,
-0.8271179795265198,
-0.6064878106117249,
0.05475376546382904,
-0.09605459868907928,
-0.0430818647146225,
1.1135295629501343,
1.1449192762374878,
-0.4282815754413605,
-0.06284555047750473,
0.019302278757095337,
-0.1318843960762024,
-0.25638994574546814,
-0.14088335633277893,
-0.05401471629738808,
-0.21316805481910706,
-0.740760087966919,
0.46062421798706055,
0.5638974905014038,
-0.17685115337371826,
-0.393595427274704,
-0.4350649118423462,
-0.057178132236003876,
0.1988174468278885,
0.9317201972007751,
0.1460408866405487,
-0.779628336429596,
-0.16504646837711334,
0.3001093566417694,
-0.13736984133720398,
-0.09343834221363068,
0.8652591705322266,
-0.9870081543922424,
0.4235145151615143,
0.5190395712852478,
0.24673211574554443,
1.0266718864440918,
0.014044751413166523,
0.20815777778625488,
-0.44362688064575195,
0.1561889946460724,
0.05149178206920624,
0.4862145483493805,
0.13859347999095917,
-0.04531533643603325,
0.5852876901626587,
0.12135854363441467,
-0.28700992465019226,
-0.4953656494617462,
0.4022529423236847,
-1.2973793745040894,
-0.667473316192627,
0.8327010273933411,
0.05825256183743477,
-0.1921020746231079,
-0.029077135026454926,
-0.3132079839706421,
0.22170668840408325,
-0.2729170024394989,
0.9694200754165649,
0.7858383059501648,
0.015330045484006405,
-0.28703686594963074,
-0.5355409383773804,
0.18260909616947174,
0.661194920539856,
-0.7907395958900452,
-0.0006550216930918396,
0.5228656530380249,
0.3661446273326874,
0.15689630806446075,
0.7746312022209167,
-0.47100919485092163,
0.6381489038467407,
0.16372178494930267,
-0.16022036969661713,
-0.47772836685180664,
-0.8155786991119385,
-0.24545550346374512,
0.3019808828830719,
-0.21165573596954346,
0.047201238572597504
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.05527v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.05527v2
|
GEAR: An Efficient KV Cache Compression Recipe for Near-Lossless Generative Inference of LLM
| 2024-03-08T18:48:30 | 2024-03-11T18:55:40 |
Hao Kang, Qingru Zhang, Souvik Kundu, Geonhwa Jeong, Zaoxing Liu, Tushar Krishna, Tuo Zhao
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Key-value (KV) caching has become the de-facto to accelerate generation speed
for large language models (LLMs) inference. However, the growing cache demand
with increasing sequence length has transformed LLM inference to be a memory
bound problem, significantly constraining the system throughput. Existing
methods rely on dropping unimportant tokens or quantizing all entries
uniformly. Such methods, however, often incur high approximation errors to
represent the compressed matrices. The autoregressive decoding process further
compounds the error of each step, resulting in critical deviation in model
generation and deterioration of performance. To tackle this challenge, we
propose GEAR, an efficient KV cache compression framework that achieves
near-lossless high-ratio compression. GEAR first applies quantization to
majority of entries of similar magnitudes to ultra-low precision. It then
employs a low rank matrix to approximate the quantization error, and a sparse
matrix to remedy individual errors from outlier entries. By adeptly integrating
three techniques, GEAR is able to fully exploit their synergistic potentials.
Our experiments demonstrate that compared to alternatives, GEAR achieves
near-lossless 4-bit KV cache compression with up to 2.38x throughput
improvement, while reducing peak-memory size up to 2.29x. Our code is publicly
available at https://github.com/HaoKang-Timmy/GEAR.
|
[
-0.12669096887111664,
-0.31152215600013733,
0.5209661722183228,
0.2592839300632477,
-0.3762967884540558,
0.20844529569149017,
-0.3779914975166321,
-0.11301596462726593,
0.15666815638542175,
0.4310258626937866,
-0.8082747459411621,
-0.587457537651062,
-0.30105945467948914,
-0.2111203819513321,
-0.46576201915740967,
0.43356385827064514,
0.19700127840042114,
-0.07749788463115692,
-0.12323229014873505,
-0.06091269850730896,
-0.5890437960624695,
-0.5421919822692871,
-0.42043164372444153,
-0.12602300941944122,
0.3471221923828125,
0.39071330428123474,
0.4301007091999054,
0.7332208156585693,
0.46409523487091064,
0.24182778596878052,
0.070914126932621,
0.1416786015033722,
-0.5595059394836426,
0.570772647857666,
0.424796998500824,
-0.6599454283714294,
-0.7091119289398193,
-0.09203996509313583,
0.5911029577255249,
0.28274375200271606,
-0.3012363314628601,
0.1173601895570755,
-0.1268189698457718,
0.7968562841415405,
-0.9756478667259216,
0.17149966955184937,
-0.7457084655761719,
0.25659915804862976,
-0.4558253288269043,
-0.04317884519696236,
-0.4102649688720703,
-0.22100162506103516,
-0.5497815012931824,
-1.0219793319702148,
0.3621632754802704,
0.06426441669464111,
0.6988170146942139,
0.6373644471168518,
0.2460787296295166,
0.11835575103759766,
-0.6939035058021545,
0.8505206108093262,
-0.6840021014213562,
0.694805920124054,
0.5186570882797241,
0.2303933948278427,
-0.13359041512012482,
-0.8093370795249939,
-0.9045904874801636,
0.490797221660614,
0.47214511036872864,
0.22770607471466064,
-0.00003057890717172995,
0.1657053679227829,
0.21102666854858398,
0.7302005887031555,
-0.4020002782344818,
0.05545945465564728,
-0.16158874332904816,
-0.12206139415502548,
0.29746586084365845,
0.21179650723934174,
0.0774778351187706,
-0.20164436101913452,
-0.10149269551038742,
-0.7585897445678711,
-1.1006373167037964,
-0.15189144015312195,
0.6932263374328613,
0.22385694086551666,
0.07942639291286469,
0.35232052206993103,
-0.38684749603271484,
0.5910032987594604,
0.21991631388664246,
-0.17589642107486725,
0.0149961207062006,
-0.08753160387277603,
-0.45612022280693054,
0.16916649043560028,
0.6317436099052429,
0.5914320349693298,
-0.07313796132802963,
-0.5012738704681396,
-0.12241218984127045,
0.23240624368190765,
0.45317208766937256,
-0.7961359620094299,
-0.3700656592845917,
0.1451943963766098,
-0.35311007499694824,
-0.494236558675766,
0.03749045357108116,
-0.7569878101348877,
-0.26226603984832764,
0.07362453639507294,
0.4256134033203125,
0.002290196716785431,
0.0050596268847584724,
0.4368971586227417,
-0.1541648507118225,
0.3761027157306671,
0.26022401452064514,
-0.8216438293457031,
0.24731004238128662,
0.6030595302581787,
0.9917910695075989,
-0.1942761093378067,
0.14756761491298676,
-0.8515129685401917,
0.3228663504123688,
-0.35201185941696167,
0.6891356706619263,
-0.34183868765830994,
-0.36241665482521057,
0.04882870614528656,
0.10634423792362213,
0.4023703634738922,
-0.5250584483146667,
0.5918264389038086,
-1.0723869800567627,
-0.36043354868888855,
-0.5406642556190491,
-0.33883827924728394,
0.0895967036485672,
0.13011512160301208,
-0.865385115146637,
1.061354637145996,
0.21053367853164673,
-0.16367274522781372,
0.6443403363227844,
-0.11613303422927856,
-0.641948938369751,
-0.092533178627491,
0.1501997709274292,
-0.33156347274780273,
0.2020845264196396,
0.21153178811073303,
0.35215649008750916,
-0.5778415203094482,
0.2074143886566162,
-0.5616424679756165,
-0.3820147216320038,
-0.23225000500679016,
-0.5360248684883118,
0.27712228894233704,
0.12197229266166687,
-0.13842494785785675,
-0.1549435406923294,
-0.7795652747154236,
0.3437635600566864,
0.012026221491396427,
-0.4151187837123871,
-0.29280173778533936,
-0.02463464066386223,
-0.19686757028102875,
0.35281479358673096,
-0.006349328905344009,
-0.31985875964164734,
0.5695892572402954,
-0.338019460439682,
0.4344680607318878,
0.9164285659790039,
-0.2975260615348816,
0.6873703002929688,
-0.13550545275211334,
0.5661930441856384,
-0.07036687433719635,
0.23532676696777344,
0.01115233451128006,
-0.2896118462085724,
-1.0849413871765137,
0.02948818728327751,
0.40866172313690186,
0.21984735131263733,
-0.7801690101623535,
0.3306899964809418,
-0.6529203057289124,
-0.21088352799415588,
-0.7864439487457275,
0.21542701125144958,
0.3333367705345154,
0.4652861952781677,
0.4130541980266571,
-0.5110093951225281,
-0.5472180247306824,
-0.6187577247619629,
-0.09619347751140594,
-0.3370956480503082,
-0.2342289388179779,
0.10687468945980072,
0.07506358623504639,
0.11783062666654587,
0.6935739517211914,
-0.5124258995056152,
-0.16301460564136505,
0.0707356259226799,
0.22111305594444275,
0.2926783561706543,
0.4689136743545532,
-0.24793174862861633,
-0.33006221055984497,
-0.18281808495521545,
-0.2645684778690338,
-0.6037778854370117,
-0.3689548671245575,
0.08338909596204758,
-0.3283102810382843,
0.20473894476890564,
0.4021751880645752,
-0.6727294921875,
0.36777642369270325,
0.652704119682312,
0.2250921130180359,
0.47949424386024475,
-0.1946118026971817,
0.14331287145614624,
-0.913436770439148,
-0.017605189234018326,
-0.40225574374198914,
-0.2574393153190613,
-0.2890704870223999,
-0.16105495393276215,
0.20862138271331787,
0.1426302045583725,
-0.20769010484218597,
0.4286379814147949,
-0.3496226370334625,
-0.28498485684394836,
-0.12130054086446762,
-0.177019402384758,
0.29642677307128906,
0.4975106120109558,
-0.032697197049856186,
1.1404391527175903,
0.016893086954951286,
-0.7927457690238953,
0.17536687850952148,
0.18552416563034058,
-0.418061763048172,
0.49418479204177856,
-0.5120896100997925,
0.3480473756790161,
0.17561021447181702,
0.41179248690605164,
-0.4670865833759308,
-0.27534112334251404,
0.0405617319047451,
-0.10043833404779434,
0.6402406096458435,
-0.5298638939857483,
-0.8804347515106201,
-0.3682262897491455,
-0.5219352841377258,
0.4783782362937927,
0.8011929392814636,
-0.699399471282959,
0.2390819638967514,
0.5175216197967529,
0.2199549823999405,
-0.5609859824180603,
-0.8815913200378418,
0.176723450422287,
-0.16212411224842072,
-0.6349177956581116,
0.5836191177368164,
-0.28868263959884644,
-0.030276816338300705,
-0.22560833394527435,
-0.5300641059875488,
-0.08354200422763824,
-0.25148144364356995,
0.12126284837722778,
0.08910440653562546,
-0.3122417628765106,
0.44664502143859863,
0.16130976378917694,
-0.293427973985672,
-0.04086679592728615,
-0.7781617641448975,
0.8603269457817078,
-0.24907070398330688,
-0.2478833645582199,
-0.16056784987449646,
0.09385814517736435,
0.7541197538375854,
0.18885749578475952,
0.40505698323249817,
0.4112401008605957,
-0.06354431807994843,
-0.24532181024551392,
-0.6925830841064453,
-0.1810639500617981,
-0.5318804383277893,
-0.05150789022445679,
-0.17454779148101807,
-0.6037306785583496,
0.5444930791854858,
-0.17964766919612885,
-0.20852483808994293,
0.4550498127937317,
0.4281630516052246,
-0.15193168818950653,
0.7661064863204956,
0.11211178451776505,
-0.27861878275871277,
0.20054824650287628,
-0.6001790165901184,
0.2436937838792801,
-1.0111712217330933,
-0.004438194911926985,
-0.22801925241947174,
-0.4742053747177124,
-0.4413250982761383,
-0.9380426406860352,
0.5928534865379333,
0.3102630376815796,
-0.3452543020248413,
0.20616893470287323,
-0.4722658097743988,
0.4655338227748871,
0.568063497543335,
0.0704391673207283,
0.45700255036354065,
0.008282260037958622,
-0.006872213911265135,
-0.05386330559849739,
-1.0656558275222778,
-0.1783420294523239,
0.9647204875946045,
-0.11515376716852188,
1.2549039125442505,
0.010289245285093784,
0.3544708490371704,
0.3622249960899353,
0.0366511233150959,
-0.749112606048584,
0.3880128264427185,
-0.1643475890159607,
-0.4359606206417084,
-0.12894071638584137,
-0.2005549669265747,
-0.6189180612564087,
-0.005845263134688139,
-0.09188105165958405,
-0.41145315766334534,
0.18658915162086487,
0.33419468998908997,
-0.45675620436668396,
0.6185270547866821,
-0.4516512155532837,
0.5403238534927368,
0.04045628011226654,
-0.595503032207489,
-0.08561510592699051,
-0.8515642881393433,
0.49887698888778687,
-0.01046596560627222,
-0.1371515691280365,
0.22765862941741943,
0.0979795902967453,
0.7095288038253784,
-0.8893383741378784,
0.9055854082107544,
0.09007373452186584,
-0.15867964923381805,
0.1579156368970871,
0.06999903172254562,
0.8809279799461365,
0.07029513269662857,
-0.0450812429189682,
0.2866446077823639,
-0.2759559750556946,
-0.4052511155605316,
-0.9274458885192871,
0.7665225863456726,
-0.47044697403907776,
-0.469117134809494,
-0.13916641473770142,
-0.5716280937194824,
-0.26744842529296875,
0.1164487972855568,
0.3414228856563568,
0.4233704209327698,
0.18240734934806824,
0.16488119959831238,
0.99969482421875,
-0.20149418711662292,
0.47846299409866333,
0.2564184367656708,
0.2466070055961609,
-0.4092054069042206,
0.9496427774429321,
0.035805944353342056,
0.5346307158470154,
0.4112933576107025,
0.004434508737176657,
-0.2724556028842926,
-0.2526188790798187,
-0.7507266998291016,
0.002219649264588952,
-0.7987142205238342,
-0.7467830777168274,
-0.6944991946220398,
-0.09977401793003082,
-0.18177081644535065,
-0.4971838891506195,
-0.7890565395355225,
-0.6242527961730957,
-0.16613364219665527,
0.25840693712234497,
0.5410217046737671,
0.520829439163208,
-0.015904000028967857,
0.7402371764183044,
-0.6224223971366882,
0.20247267186641693,
0.4126741886138916,
0.4193800091743469,
0.21605078876018524,
-0.23864726722240448,
-0.23454509675502777,
-0.09868268668651581,
-0.3713815212249756,
-0.5584899187088013,
0.4794155955314636,
0.18579043447971344,
0.032923001796007156,
0.5061026811599731,
0.29851558804512024,
1.268795132637024,
-0.3611135184764862,
0.8186017870903015,
0.10062474012374878,
-0.8973225951194763,
0.2644452452659607,
-0.18703065812587738,
0.411489337682724,
0.6221819519996643,
-0.13733746111392975,
-0.6082739233970642,
-0.39683398604393005,
-0.7414882183074951,
-1.0883197784423828,
0.5175247192382812,
0.13462324440479279,
-0.05598223954439163,
-0.15970851480960846,
0.2805998921394348,
0.06898514181375504,
0.5203582644462585,
-0.5141783952713013,
-0.22740720212459564,
-0.11399252712726593,
-0.20936831831932068,
0.13490183651447296,
-0.09925387799739838,
0.22656656801700592,
-0.3258489668369293,
0.7976455092430115,
-0.20473794639110565,
0.5920796394348145,
0.14365924894809723,
-0.4346815049648285,
-0.44904929399490356,
0.05996420606970787,
0.5200210809707642,
0.12062013894319534,
-0.10850083082914352,
0.418181836605072,
0.3531312942504883,
-0.6049562096595764,
0.21923130750656128,
-0.24387583136558533,
-0.15764476358890533,
-0.13407619297504425,
0.27180835604667664,
0.5787397027015686,
0.5479164719581604,
-0.4200306832790375,
0.4610239565372467,
-0.27433663606643677,
0.2109059989452362,
-0.04971197247505188,
0.10293953120708466,
0.013628081418573856,
0.24156291782855988,
0.17917586863040924,
-0.1093459278345108,
-0.02019622176885605,
-0.1554717719554901,
-0.052407365292310715,
0.4516476094722748,
-0.29233530163764954,
-0.4291324019432068,
0.7629953622817993,
-0.007616308517754078,
-0.016285451129078865,
0.8449456691741943,
-0.29157283902168274,
-0.5969933271408081,
0.2600858509540558,
0.47916296124458313,
0.9395995140075684,
-0.09632714092731476,
-0.16182857751846313,
0.41409724950790405,
0.3726046681404114,
-0.3599082827568054,
0.15276192128658295,
-0.3888600170612335,
-0.5102645754814148,
-0.6186011433601379,
-1.000398874282837,
-0.006341957021504641,
0.3454750180244446,
-0.6060365438461304,
0.1695745587348938,
-0.18278157711029053,
0.10170137137174606,
-0.48892927169799805,
-0.11459945142269135,
-0.6425219774246216,
0.04772533103823662,
-0.376716673374176,
0.769648015499115,
-0.5257427096366882,
0.990573525428772,
-0.05218835175037384,
-0.38770511746406555,
-0.5040996670722961,
0.060409534722566605,
-0.06458490341901779,
-0.9686381220817566,
0.8013953566551208,
-0.05517728254199028,
-0.1485445499420166,
0.17991751432418823,
-0.44397756457328796,
-0.8085504770278931,
1.192602276802063,
0.38968345522880554,
-0.6759450435638428,
-0.21087491512298584,
-0.08289855718612671,
0.10130642354488373,
0.027209173887968063,
-0.06488335132598877,
0.39622318744659424,
0.6887252926826477,
0.19996583461761475,
-0.5392053723335266,
0.04298550635576248,
-0.09885337948799133,
-0.0020818710327148438,
0.6212323307991028,
-0.5413621068000793,
0.6008424162864685,
-0.02507675066590309,
-0.23353801667690277,
0.13971924781799316,
0.661486804485321,
0.17078347504138947,
0.09455765038728714,
0.571856677532196,
1.0334537029266357,
0.9275136590003967,
-0.048634231090545654,
1.2530763149261475,
-0.527114748954773,
0.2619543671607971,
0.9608205556869507,
-0.10206557810306549,
0.6529194116592407,
0.5571301579475403,
-0.2769544720649719,
0.3155909478664398,
0.48218318819999695,
0.2133810669183731,
0.7455859780311584,
0.29655200242996216,
-0.6766762137413025,
-0.5103010535240173,
0.13451454043388367,
-0.3822801113128662,
0.2112893909215927,
0.26590269804000854,
-0.2582184970378876,
-0.12605035305023193,
-0.42093145847320557,
0.017155537381768227,
-0.68717360496521,
-0.18362659215927124,
0.498244047164917,
0.03443531692028046,
-0.6896601915359497,
0.6929308772087097,
-0.17225122451782227,
0.640444815158844,
-0.5102909207344055,
-0.16343998908996582,
-0.11506755650043488,
-0.0026109409518539906,
0.1599777638912201,
-0.4022267162799835,
0.12463858723640442,
-0.15794628858566284,
-0.5516484379768372,
-0.4871279001235962,
0.9187278747558594,
-0.37024348974227905,
-0.3834724426269531,
-0.2560938000679016,
0.23348189890384674,
0.09262322634458542,
-0.1524597406387329,
-0.072957344353199,
0.32172009348869324,
-0.49709513783454895,
-0.09951537102460861,
0.44946280121803284,
0.19445131719112396,
-0.12163125723600388,
0.5105173587799072,
0.9319145679473877,
0.23105119168758392,
0.20654785633087158,
-0.11701633781194687,
0.9986720681190491,
-0.5518253445625305,
-0.43750470876693726,
-0.626813530921936,
0.289033979177475,
-0.1093958243727684,
-0.30263617634773254,
0.34416723251342773,
0.5389280319213867,
0.7480603456497192,
-0.09875738620758057,
0.611899733543396,
-0.0030011548660695553,
-0.3348233997821808,
-0.8834026455879211,
0.7777007222175598,
-0.6268436908721924,
0.39872872829437256,
-0.1600506454706192,
-0.6122339367866516,
-0.28375616669654846,
0.7377663850784302,
0.0684666857123375,
0.10281464457511902,
0.6890268921852112,
0.8387015461921692,
-0.3065251410007477,
-0.11636205017566681,
0.5242781043052673,
0.30498477816581726,
0.2097940295934677,
0.5482127666473389,
0.5763418078422546,
-0.7274279594421387,
0.5146159529685974,
-0.2763189673423767,
0.1327841579914093,
-0.23526524007320404,
-1.153960943222046,
-0.39424097537994385,
-0.698035478591919,
-0.045625489205121994,
-0.5785865783691406,
0.30960899591445923,
0.5666798949241638,
1.1742722988128662,
-0.40341678261756897,
-0.06804877519607544,
-0.552855908870697,
0.20867833495140076,
-0.13129779696464539,
-0.23912496864795685,
0.30904415249824524,
-0.5304985642433167,
-0.5419188141822815,
0.5888631939888,
0.5435543060302734,
-0.16678915917873383,
-0.46098852157592773,
-0.3870573937892914,
0.1805325746536255,
-0.25945866107940674,
0.7491955161094666,
0.2562108039855957,
-0.7685990929603577,
-0.1283443421125412,
0.22631897032260895,
0.17156097292900085,
0.2467717081308365,
1.144513726234436,
-1.1049816608428955,
0.7306052446365356,
0.4161871373653412,
0.5956368446350098,
0.9158254265785217,
-0.37959232926368713,
0.8285735249519348,
-0.9921704530715942,
0.10068449378013611,
0.15175890922546387,
0.14073392748832703,
0.17565126717090607,
-0.39345818758010864,
0.4561081528663635,
0.4828066825866699,
-0.5342428684234619,
-0.8732278943061829,
0.14856664836406708,
-1.0989820957183838,
0.02990293689072132,
1.2043814659118652,
0.11434143781661987,
-0.5360687375068665,
0.08397479355335236,
0.20017953217029572,
0.5405892133712769,
-0.5067451596260071,
0.8002141714096069,
0.8157707452774048,
0.22605201601982117,
-0.14222858846187592,
-0.890657901763916,
0.5846050381660461,
0.1997227519750595,
-0.5820088982582092,
0.27238625288009644,
0.28836753964424133,
-0.04680496081709862,
-0.09866508096456528,
0.4335560202598572,
-0.0988256186246872,
0.3828029930591583,
-0.08012495189905167,
0.38786864280700684,
0.043357670307159424,
-0.2626783847808838,
-0.2686968445777893,
0.08846230059862137,
-0.11130329966545105,
0.0033486553002148867
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.05519v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.05519v1
|
Authorship Attribution in Bangla Literature (AABL) via Transfer Learning using ULMFiT
| 2024-03-08T18:42:59 | 2024-03-08T18:42:59 |
Aisha Khatun, Anisur Rahman, Md Saiful Islam, Hemayet Ahmed Chowdhury, Ayesha Tasnim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Authorship Attribution is the task of creating an appropriate
characterization of text that captures the authors' writing style to identify
the original author of a given piece of text. With increased anonymity on the
internet, this task has become increasingly crucial in various security and
plagiarism detection fields. Despite significant advancements in other
languages such as English, Spanish, and Chinese, Bangla lacks comprehensive
research in this field due to its complex linguistic feature and sentence
structure. Moreover, existing systems are not scalable when the number of
author increases, and the performance drops for small number of samples per
author. In this paper, we propose the use of Average-Stochastic Gradient
Descent Weight-Dropped Long Short-Term Memory (AWD-LSTM) architecture and an
effective transfer learning approach that addresses the problem of complex
linguistic features extraction and scalability for authorship attribution in
Bangla Literature (AABL). We analyze the effect of different tokenization, such
as word, sub-word, and character level tokenization, and demonstrate the
effectiveness of these tokenizations in the proposed model. Moreover, we
introduce the publicly available Bangla Authorship Attribution Dataset of 16
authors (BAAD16) containing 17,966 sample texts and 13.4+ million words to
solve the standard dataset scarcity problem and release six variations of
pre-trained language models for use in any Bangla NLP downstream task. For
evaluation, we used our developed BAAD16 dataset as well as other publicly
available datasets. Empirically, our proposed model outperformed
state-of-the-art models and achieved 99.8% accuracy in the BAAD16 dataset.
Furthermore, we showed that the proposed system scales much better even with an
increasing number of authors, and performance remains steady despite few
training samples.
|
[
0.14289864897727966,
-0.6220636367797852,
0.20051316916942596,
0.27861687541007996,
-0.2872573435306549,
0.0727318525314331,
-0.13027247786521912,
-0.5803884863853455,
0.10302097350358963,
0.5392810106277466,
-0.11334196478128433,
-0.15364901721477509,
-0.6284077167510986,
0.19388912618160248,
-0.5167586207389832,
1.0958504676818848,
-0.19051654636859894,
-0.3844926655292511,
-0.2406245768070221,
-0.2300054132938385,
-0.3389052748680115,
-0.3460571765899658,
-0.8316097259521484,
-0.28839626908302307,
0.6347677707672119,
0.08971985429525375,
0.3056776821613312,
0.6448450684547424,
0.599736750125885,
0.18791884183883667,
0.012350441887974739,
0.14091841876506805,
-0.33717676997184753,
-0.06022818386554718,
-0.38271111249923706,
-0.3778122663497925,
-0.21264486014842987,
-0.07308090478181839,
0.8666533827781677,
0.49718499183654785,
-0.2649264335632324,
0.4449799060821533,
-0.009375227615237236,
0.7761673331260681,
-0.7105646133422852,
0.12586773931980133,
-0.5122689008712769,
-0.27237576246261597,
-0.3965916633605957,
-0.22016587853431702,
-0.6075803637504578,
-0.8206157088279724,
-0.28000330924987793,
-0.2723831236362457,
-0.10035029798746109,
0.35193413496017456,
0.665417492389679,
0.11209926009178162,
-0.6033069491386414,
-0.7075074315071106,
-0.4046162962913513,
0.9330048561096191,
-0.7306036353111267,
0.0920303612947464,
0.5838101506233215,
0.052015434950590134,
0.03896312043070793,
-0.3406650125980377,
-0.44306471943855286,
-0.03423740342259407,
-0.25463205575942993,
-0.1819562315940857,
-0.13103130459785461,
-0.20539501309394836,
-0.21538005769252777,
0.3608219027519226,
-0.4575566351413727,
0.3215152323246002,
-0.5889403223991394,
-0.16683568060398102,
0.7278227806091309,
-0.09590829163789749,
0.17886531352996826,
-0.3782772719860077,
-0.5242912769317627,
-0.01054400485008955,
-0.6983864903450012,
0.43647634983062744,
0.5714130997657776,
0.5434873700141907,
-0.04696718230843544,
0.2660728991031647,
0.3436947166919708,
0.5342878103256226,
-0.08911097794771194,
-0.09121179580688477,
0.2101229727268219,
-0.5879002809524536,
0.06051460653543472,
0.24502401053905487,
0.7666494846343994,
-0.12546832859516144,
0.34849441051483154,
-0.022840389981865883,
-0.11587842553853989,
-0.4569225311279297,
0.2186514139175415,
-0.7121979594230652,
-0.3306347727775574,
0.059444379061460495,
-0.8723847270011902,
-0.3961851894855499,
0.14675898849964142,
-0.6705053448677063,
-0.5754284858703613,
-0.09217184036970139,
0.4314083158969879,
-0.5829083919525146,
-0.3101349174976349,
-0.2087297886610031,
0.3908119797706604,
0.3482722043991089,
0.147299125790596,
-0.85484379529953,
0.1862630844116211,
0.14864426851272583,
1.0289621353149414,
-0.6916859745979309,
-0.4067905843257904,
-0.6017486453056335,
0.38177844882011414,
-0.31024909019470215,
0.648652195930481,
-0.3374178111553192,
-0.2457616627216339,
0.005313062574714422,
-0.16231031715869904,
-0.3956645131111145,
-0.39589667320251465,
0.3928736448287964,
-0.5643957257270813,
-0.01105629000812769,
-0.15140393376350403,
-0.6138420104980469,
-0.13960672914981842,
-0.37421298027038574,
-0.4972931742668152,
0.8229138851165771,
0.10701388865709305,
-0.5965311527252197,
0.23301416635513306,
-0.8644522428512573,
-0.543079137802124,
0.14696356654167175,
0.05845494195818901,
-0.586183488368988,
-0.008485912345349789,
0.28021058440208435,
0.6396653056144714,
-0.04048102721571922,
0.18890175223350525,
0.21049654483795166,
-0.5479658842086792,
0.44834190607070923,
-0.1704191118478775,
1.3043311834335327,
0.3576340973377228,
-0.03639819473028183,
0.06622686982154846,
-0.7890917062759399,
-0.19285517930984497,
-0.040692899376153946,
-0.5373743772506714,
-0.3563101291656494,
-0.24113468825817108,
0.39201050996780396,
-0.22630321979522705,
0.12704221904277802,
-0.6002496480941772,
0.30448758602142334,
-0.2551201283931732,
0.03997614607214928,
0.9625542163848877,
0.04467904567718506,
0.45030704140663147,
-0.4079170525074005,
0.7065171599388123,
-0.24363908171653748,
-0.23739205300807953,
-0.22573751211166382,
-0.5373291373252869,
-0.2780109941959381,
-0.881643533706665,
0.5891191959381104,
0.5958983898162842,
-0.5046322345733643,
0.6486836671829224,
-0.2309311181306839,
-0.433876633644104,
-0.8899220824241638,
0.35519343614578247,
0.4853575527667999,
0.2754315137863159,
0.4341835379600525,
-0.20831556618213654,
-0.30183225870132446,
-0.7751106023788452,
-0.3978253901004791,
-0.5335419774055481,
-0.10514795780181885,
0.0810060203075409,
0.6025233864784241,
-0.11266936361789703,
1.1400474309921265,
-0.4667382538318634,
-0.6467007398605347,
-0.3570610582828522,
0.5367323160171509,
0.1026339903473854,
0.6865047812461853,
0.636198878288269,
-0.6818403601646423,
-0.5823379158973694,
0.10879937559366226,
-0.6666032075881958,
-0.4708118736743927,
-0.31117773056030273,
-0.10046640783548355,
0.3153422176837921,
0.6757030487060547,
-0.4372835159301758,
0.5867119431495667,
0.2285490483045578,
-0.4781671464443207,
0.8543698787689209,
0.040810853242874146,
0.2501455545425415,
-1.2801445722579956,
0.4219169616699219,
-0.37353014945983887,
-0.13571812212467194,
-0.33085495233535767,
0.23518666625022888,
0.13441170752048492,
0.07818564772605896,
-0.3487916588783264,
0.847130298614502,
-0.5385213494300842,
0.19545215368270874,
-0.37484562397003174,
-0.42902159690856934,
-0.3774356544017792,
0.43933096528053284,
-0.26943346858024597,
0.6250973343849182,
0.3428579568862915,
-0.4165709614753723,
0.5954638719558716,
0.4047378599643707,
-0.6226158142089844,
0.5229940414428711,
-0.38372811675071716,
-0.10245908051729202,
-0.038096196949481964,
0.4231106638908386,
-1.1728919744491577,
-0.03662271797657013,
0.10161988437175751,
-0.47629180550575256,
0.3716554045677185,
-0.1522931605577469,
-0.6305395364761353,
-0.10877714306116104,
-0.2449449896812439,
0.5935759544372559,
0.4431416690349579,
-0.4525265693664551,
0.7549517750740051,
-0.02909693866968155,
-0.5513472557067871,
-0.6144319772720337,
-0.7889390587806702,
0.1841278076171875,
-0.42688989639282227,
-0.19532565772533417,
0.2529448866844177,
0.039478909224271774,
-0.13349387049674988,
0.07659824937582016,
0.29898858070373535,
-0.26586517691612244,
0.022541778162121773,
0.023916495963931084,
0.14627055823802948,
0.12727271020412445,
0.08734501898288727,
0.19585257768630981,
0.06051335483789444,
0.025515137240290642,
0.214381605386734,
0.1343287229537964,
-0.028882645070552826,
-0.29468148946762085,
-0.3704456686973572,
0.5770695209503174,
0.16041134297847748,
-0.10554371774196625,
1.087139368057251,
1.0271092653274536,
-0.30986711382865906,
-0.25955328345298767,
-0.5288475155830383,
-0.11805126816034317,
-0.39028045535087585,
0.38395729660987854,
-0.1451127678155899,
-0.6839388608932495,
0.8769287467002869,
0.17928481101989746,
0.09126098453998566,
0.278865247964859,
0.6480016112327576,
0.01207716204226017,
0.17574681341648102,
0.7668087482452393,
-0.26627683639526367,
0.4879932403564453,
-0.010976451449096203,
0.41513895988464355,
-0.7325849533081055,
-0.1206439658999443,
-0.43320780992507935,
-0.3185981512069702,
-0.3956039547920227,
-0.21636931598186493,
0.01862124167382717,
0.0046298629604279995,
0.020869912579655647,
0.4512408375740051,
-0.2672693729400635,
0.40176647901535034,
0.7020797729492188,
0.07965949922800064,
0.4409427344799042,
-0.04196527227759361,
0.07728886604309082,
0.0688389390707016,
-0.2719734013080597,
-0.2859571576118469,
1.1589374542236328,
0.1469222903251648,
0.829574465751648,
0.48473599553108215,
0.6270833015441895,
0.8378705978393555,
0.17715077102184296,
-0.5357894897460938,
0.4897131621837616,
0.07179607450962067,
-0.7139920592308044,
-0.4244633913040161,
-0.4682002663612366,
-0.9362388253211975,
0.10380291193723679,
-0.2053089290857315,
-0.9013754725456238,
0.37960299849510193,
-0.08254662901163101,
-0.33775731921195984,
0.3713994324207306,
-0.6797825694084167,
0.45990490913391113,
0.1750677525997162,
-0.41343140602111816,
-0.0272202268242836,
-0.9035665988922119,
0.3277846872806549,
-0.6317296028137207,
0.46239590644836426,
0.17869271337985992,
-0.004305006004869938,
1.2639795541763306,
-0.30916357040405273,
0.7955230474472046,
-0.1971854716539383,
-0.22316144406795502,
0.2709866464138031,
0.005712683778256178,
0.5953178405761719,
-0.1721140742301941,
-0.29086846113204956,
0.054459817707538605,
-0.21340326964855194,
-0.5996479392051697,
-0.17991755902767181,
0.5911353230476379,
-0.645432710647583,
0.025954021140933037,
-0.5048104524612427,
-0.6968512535095215,
-0.020648442208766937,
0.27339914441108704,
0.34674856066703796,
0.2708800733089447,
0.15153609216213226,
0.4963527321815491,
0.22236718237400055,
-0.1374683827161789,
0.6733039617538452,
0.2696761190891266,
-0.1907130777835846,
-0.16863296926021576,
0.9241212010383606,
0.042608100920915604,
-0.057179972529411316,
0.12290769815444946,
0.12808722257614136,
-0.329509973526001,
-0.8257036209106445,
-0.47698619961738586,
0.36724570393562317,
-0.6615126729011536,
-0.3798157274723053,
-0.6540470719337463,
-0.28393420577049255,
-0.47445499897003174,
-0.7780407667160034,
-0.3630804419517517,
-0.34673210978507996,
-0.32900092005729675,
-0.0342722162604332,
0.5529860854148865,
0.6229565143585205,
-0.0884174108505249,
0.5865703821182251,
-0.5420731902122498,
0.0806821957230568,
0.17943134903907776,
0.05877644941210747,
0.3716995120048523,
-1.136205792427063,
-0.7170878648757935,
-0.27850669622421265,
-0.26923051476478577,
-0.6010451316833496,
0.41996559500694275,
0.5246394872665405,
0.44679245352745056,
0.34675469994544983,
0.12543214857578278,
0.597832977771759,
-0.2450931966304779,
0.8315878510475159,
0.16593880951404572,
-0.7992392778396606,
0.4216453731060028,
-0.538499653339386,
0.1735231876373291,
0.7871965169906616,
0.5547816753387451,
-0.1435263305902481,
-0.462844580411911,
-0.28629186749458313,
-1.0936366319656372,
0.6228401064872742,
0.47218218445777893,
-0.10787010937929153,
0.3630964457988739,
0.43639254570007324,
0.4738421142101288,
0.221420019865036,
-1.0901013612747192,
-0.2733440399169922,
0.19458264112472534,
-0.35146698355674744,
-0.05050735920667648,
-0.17137068510055542,
0.2537725269794464,
-0.38677263259887695,
0.7450098991394043,
-0.015450947917997837,
0.33198320865631104,
-0.1318080574274063,
-0.316718190908432,
0.011374881491065025,
0.15834099054336548,
0.2832946479320526,
0.9412575960159302,
-0.35231301188468933,
-0.12692014873027802,
-0.09604159742593765,
-0.5664440393447876,
0.2619684338569641,
0.15516896545886993,
-0.14348405599594116,
-0.0816340446472168,
0.8436102271080017,
0.5474876761436462,
-0.007136269472539425,
-0.4997057616710663,
0.6645135283470154,
0.4390789866447449,
-0.17168325185775757,
-0.1662491112947464,
-0.24429014325141907,
0.21194158494472504,
0.12732230126857758,
0.9545199275016785,
0.044108666479587555,
0.2697083353996277,
-0.44829222559928894,
0.26610735058784485,
0.21159547567367554,
-0.022149719297885895,
-0.2781059741973877,
0.654278576374054,
0.15349288284778595,
-0.14391770958900452,
0.5124021172523499,
-0.25090670585632324,
-0.3106997311115265,
0.4097912013530731,
0.6861005425453186,
0.6988204717636108,
-0.6060975193977356,
0.07789455354213715,
0.2690621614456177,
0.12773999571800232,
0.0623074509203434,
-0.24046671390533447,
-0.05094021558761597,
-0.6116254329681396,
-0.43666157126426697,
-0.9933146238327026,
-0.251811146736145,
-0.06959967315196991,
-0.5721843242645264,
0.14184734225273132,
-0.14544208347797394,
0.10505646467208862,
-0.18996725976467133,
0.2058219462633133,
-0.2182939499616623,
-0.12966005504131317,
-0.029771102592349052,
0.134547159075737,
-1.2350796461105347,
0.7401435375213623,
0.7761616110801697,
-0.39256778359413147,
-0.5342971086502075,
-0.26744338870048523,
0.03705254942178726,
-0.8286858201026917,
0.6305122375488281,
0.09207490086555481,
-0.10691086947917938,
0.280068039894104,
-0.3643110692501068,
-0.7586536407470703,
1.0652440786361694,
0.2713031470775604,
0.03588380292057991,
-0.1748027503490448,
-0.1726655215024948,
0.328148752450943,
-0.5537527799606323,
0.12895217537879944,
0.26158925890922546,
0.3311099112033844,
0.20304372906684875,
-0.8779473304748535,
0.27984172105789185,
-0.24614714086055756,
-0.021180571988224983,
0.07674923539161682,
-0.5858508944511414,
0.8770042061805725,
-0.10196705162525177,
0.02509712614119053,
0.10892046242952347,
0.8398021459579468,
0.38950997591018677,
0.15279458463191986,
0.41486868262290955,
0.23574833571910858,
0.765067994594574,
0.4952317178249359,
0.6696869730949402,
0.13773271441459656,
0.271167129278183,
0.9009604454040527,
-0.03875342383980751,
0.8635604977607727,
0.6932075619697571,
-0.4773002862930298,
0.6914882659912109,
0.4986596405506134,
-0.11494282633066177,
0.5928131937980652,
0.40432852506637573,
-0.18621014058589935,
0.14573723077774048,
-0.33168768882751465,
-0.3139243721961975,
0.5112730860710144,
0.0759623721241951,
-0.49517348408699036,
0.02737269550561905,
0.3915553092956543,
0.12977921962738037,
0.2525545656681061,
-0.361336886882782,
0.6358152031898499,
0.19534751772880554,
-0.13496382534503937,
0.5289733409881592,
-0.11293035745620728,
1.1158744096755981,
-0.6755753755569458,
0.1506088823080063,
-0.1404353529214859,
0.18565768003463745,
-0.425485223531723,
-0.43224453926086426,
0.4169953465461731,
-0.007488104980438948,
-0.17923666536808014,
-0.4720621407032013,
0.7820650339126587,
-0.5083456039428711,
-0.8396727442741394,
0.15127745270729065,
0.5233103632926941,
0.5200308561325073,
0.16421163082122803,
-0.4660341739654541,
-0.06610693037509918,
0.09116286784410477,
-0.3818534016609192,
0.45544302463531494,
0.2434094399213791,
-0.04898111894726753,
0.7414902448654175,
0.6620129942893982,
0.6378676891326904,
0.04335584491491318,
-0.3027289807796478,
0.4696899950504303,
-0.4970170855522156,
-0.6515204906463623,
-0.9033008813858032,
0.20896494388580322,
-0.0046057808212935925,
-0.1676872819662094,
0.8811092376708984,
0.5162407755851746,
0.5146259069442749,
-0.07376664876937866,
0.7015947699546814,
-0.2504321336746216,
0.612210214138031,
-0.5047290921211243,
1.1606026887893677,
-0.5892332196235657,
0.083266980946064,
-0.5445508360862732,
-1.0990314483642578,
-0.28600114583969116,
0.7401684522628784,
0.05103406310081482,
0.23008836805820465,
0.8317995071411133,
0.43552452325820923,
0.004100100602954626,
-0.24586424231529236,
0.0686066597700119,
0.025066787376999855,
0.43816354870796204,
0.3626917898654938,
0.2802211046218872,
-0.5345814824104309,
0.553472101688385,
0.08433480560779572,
-0.5483219623565674,
-0.5317887663841248,
-1.0057055950164795,
-0.8432866334915161,
-0.7891548871994019,
-0.400730162858963,
0.001982819987460971,
0.1635931134223938,
0.8978503942489624,
0.4063214063644409,
-0.8701813220977783,
-0.4103330969810486,
0.17979615926742554,
0.012072146870195866,
-0.30235037207603455,
-0.30172237753868103,
0.9591646194458008,
-0.08823685348033905,
-0.514422595500946,
0.11869736015796661,
-0.15524207055568695,
-0.17980040609836578,
-0.06856773048639297,
0.22450745105743408,
-0.8223502039909363,
0.2074669450521469,
0.5447710156440735,
0.17999789118766785,
-0.5080713033676147,
-0.23165616393089294,
-0.46711716055870056,
-0.0186997652053833,
-0.1770908087491989,
0.6539486646652222,
-0.5064885020256042,
0.29329821467399597,
0.21858280897140503,
0.9283210635185242,
0.29348090291023254,
0.43559330701828003,
0.46523037552833557,
-0.7866756916046143,
-0.016733121126890182,
0.20094281435012817,
0.16124694049358368,
0.3885398507118225,
-0.5651493072509766,
0.4952845275402069,
0.3195933699607849,
-0.9142825603485107,
-0.9279306530952454,
0.025186525657773018,
-1.0371644496917725,
-0.30199360847473145,
1.2587321996688843,
-0.31222066283226013,
-0.15967033803462982,
-0.433165580034256,
-0.07288310676813126,
0.26172032952308655,
-0.6618056893348694,
0.7578725814819336,
0.9321653842926025,
-0.19229277968406677,
-0.050491344183683395,
-0.29061180353164673,
0.5247992277145386,
0.47969427704811096,
-0.4722921848297119,
0.49248912930488586,
0.2819361388683319,
-0.160169318318367,
0.14887818694114685,
1.0342680215835571,
-0.022565511986613274,
0.08761195093393326,
-0.12255129218101501,
0.3180684745311737,
-0.3592052757740021,
-0.12249989807605743,
-0.2059192955493927,
0.18013082444667816,
-0.07577099651098251,
-0.11494433879852295
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.05518v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.05518v1
|
Bias-Augmented Consistency Training Reduces Biased Reasoning in Chain-of-Thought
| 2024-03-08T18:41:42 | 2024-03-08T18:41:42 |
James Chua, Edward Rees, Hunar Batra, Samuel R. Bowman, Julian Michael, Ethan Perez, Miles Turpin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
While chain-of-thought prompting (CoT) has the potential to improve the
explainability of language model reasoning, it can systematically misrepresent
the factors influencing models' behavior--for example, rationalizing answers in
line with a user's opinion without mentioning this bias. To mitigate this
biased reasoning problem, we introduce bias-augmented consistency training
(BCT), an unsupervised fine-tuning scheme that trains models to give consistent
reasoning across prompts with and without biasing features. We construct a
suite testing nine forms of biased reasoning on seven question-answering tasks,
and find that applying BCT to GPT-3.5-Turbo with one bias reduces the rate of
biased reasoning by 86% on held-out tasks. Moreover, this model generalizes to
other forms of bias, reducing biased reasoning on held-out biases by an average
of 37%. As BCT generalizes to held-out biases and does not require gold labels,
this method may hold promise for reducing biased reasoning from as-of-yet
unknown biases and on tasks where supervision for ground truth reasoning is
unavailable.
|
[
-0.7449673414230347,
-0.8914221525192261,
0.6473444104194641,
-0.02046841010451317,
-0.14615723490715027,
-0.14221209287643433,
-0.4117862582206726,
-0.2202187329530716,
-0.0369243323802948,
0.5308728218078613,
-0.7634786367416382,
-0.13189853727817535,
-0.5426947474479675,
-0.060074079781770706,
-0.12115804105997086,
1.2885302305221558,
-0.3461402654647827,
0.11554574221372604,
-0.14849501848220825,
-0.08239643275737762,
-0.8539295792579651,
-0.45416849851608276,
-0.5260323882102966,
-0.5054289102554321,
0.4897221326828003,
0.21106187999248505,
0.5726767182350159,
0.5250965356826782,
0.060948166996240616,
0.05178007856011391,
-0.17300954461097717,
0.616676926612854,
-0.2915414869785309,
0.18710246682167053,
-0.7325563430786133,
-0.1791980117559433,
-0.41561830043792725,
0.01554945483803749,
0.27581754326820374,
0.8439027667045593,
-0.02465759590268135,
0.03248725086450577,
0.27366092801094055,
0.8291612863540649,
-1.0343189239501953,
0.08201875537633896,
-0.7843158841133118,
-0.24420776963233948,
0.13437502086162567,
-0.18575419485569,
-0.6114505529403687,
-0.4593914747238159,
0.22723975777626038,
-0.5775588154792786,
0.45428571105003357,
-0.012129941023886204,
0.7327108383178711,
0.36799222230911255,
-0.3530846834182739,
0.1484425812959671,
-0.46676522493362427,
0.623397171497345,
-0.42400407791137695,
0.5039743185043335,
0.6104041337966919,
-0.15808148682117462,
-0.16249734163284302,
-0.08870545774698257,
-0.616790771484375,
0.07955033332109451,
0.1470453143119812,
0.08144577592611313,
0.11061569303274155,
0.3690820634365082,
0.6372661590576172,
0.08202889561653137,
-0.4889368414878845,
-0.38902169466018677,
-0.1251208484172821,
-0.38580864667892456,
0.4019888639450073,
-0.22748373448848724,
-0.04723362624645233,
0.22811725735664368,
-0.16199520230293274,
-0.03779067471623421,
-0.6933926343917847,
-0.06289117783308029,
0.22300192713737488,
0.2999284565448761,
0.4218691289424896,
0.4169555902481079,
-0.34462830424308777,
0.8535308837890625,
0.6600188612937927,
0.22033201158046722,
-0.05724527686834335,
-0.06785964220762253,
-0.4033684730529785,
0.22628054022789001,
0.35034626722335815,
0.42624571919441223,
0.44097191095352173,
-0.1853354424238205,
-0.13683103024959564,
0.4477732479572296,
0.3028598725795746,
-0.5877588391304016,
-0.42542964220046997,
0.13578996062278748,
-0.2254118025302887,
-0.08939525485038757,
0.036695756018161774,
-0.24553591012954712,
-0.2744293808937073,
-0.48983389139175415,
0.43009307980537415,
-0.5386289358139038,
-0.18058493733406067,
0.23072317242622375,
-0.1517585813999176,
0.08799336850643158,
0.5471757054328918,
-1.0252153873443604,
0.36858364939689636,
0.6371129751205444,
0.5593933463096619,
-0.14395174384117126,
-0.2237490713596344,
-0.6672132611274719,
0.16313359141349792,
-0.5265506505966187,
0.9629101753234863,
-0.38572409749031067,
0.036432113498449326,
-0.04172726348042488,
0.027598578482866287,
-0.025491487234830856,
-0.5209916234016418,
0.44069841504096985,
-0.41189172863960266,
0.08870761841535568,
-1.1431527137756348,
-0.5434759259223938,
-0.11137470602989197,
0.6325306296348572,
-0.31809937953948975,
0.9981203675270081,
0.022314446046948433,
-1.0033879280090332,
0.9590889811515808,
-0.29403918981552124,
-0.34102314710617065,
-0.40670159459114075,
-0.013999215327203274,
-0.3009328544139862,
-0.09015119820833206,
0.7573145627975464,
0.10876189917325974,
-0.02106243371963501,
0.33980926871299744,
-0.3923797309398651,
-0.6487252712249756,
-0.1136966347694397,
-0.40533339977264404,
0.7179157733917236,
0.1693378984928131,
-0.5416842103004456,
-0.09757516533136368,
-0.427152544260025,
0.24557271599769592,
-0.3133357763290405,
-0.14091747999191284,
-0.3974168300628662,
-0.18495884537696838,
-0.323423832654953,
0.2505428194999695,
-0.021211663261055946,
-0.6521553993225098,
0.5940826535224915,
-0.2862359881401062,
0.07049157470464706,
0.8485181331634521,
0.1283721774816513,
0.3444805145263672,
-0.38586708903312683,
0.062164999544620514,
0.419182687997818,
-0.00403821375221014,
0.10183125734329224,
-0.4831625521183014,
-1.0484486818313599,
-0.11684328317642212,
0.24192756414413452,
0.45814457535743713,
-0.9143657088279724,
0.3814704120159149,
0.17043082416057587,
-0.03659161925315857,
-0.5760818719863892,
0.10354244709014893,
0.6120063066482544,
0.7999851107597351,
0.6185540556907654,
-0.4678158760070801,
-0.5839203596115112,
-0.7524256110191345,
-0.6753345727920532,
-0.1738787144422531,
0.23261544108390808,
-0.23427976667881012,
0.5156902074813843,
-0.18955308198928833,
1.1386433839797974,
-0.2687523066997528,
0.1884208768606186,
-0.1349850445985794,
0.3379093408584595,
-0.12013834714889526,
0.6592031121253967,
0.0890791118144989,
-0.2840571701526642,
-0.30806806683540344,
-0.11520441621541977,
-0.504808247089386,
-0.23545308411121368,
-0.2058609575033188,
-0.3392367959022522,
0.2388300597667694,
0.18154577910900116,
-0.8152139186859131,
0.6834830641746521,
0.09386278688907623,
-0.26216697692871094,
0.6694698929786682,
-0.19234733283519745,
0.32464757561683655,
-0.6855568289756775,
-0.21637707948684692,
0.012469988316297531,
-0.36174556612968445,
-0.4113653600215912,
-0.2882581353187561,
0.22820185124874115,
0.196536585688591,
-0.09421487897634506,
0.36105450987815857,
-0.5177534222602844,
0.14800545573234558,
-0.5065925121307373,
0.056848954409360886,
0.3525300621986389,
0.639683723449707,
0.23832052946090698,
0.9656069874763489,
0.5614655017852783,
-0.791252851486206,
0.0793987512588501,
0.4815036356449127,
-0.09063870459794998,
0.6929188370704651,
-0.4491349756717682,
0.5009059309959412,
-0.205694779753685,
0.4654490649700165,
-0.5858120322227478,
-0.012360376305878162,
0.14573964476585388,
-0.19421611726284027,
0.09215301275253296,
-0.26959028840065,
-0.34706249833106995,
-0.3664107918739319,
-0.24937549233436584,
0.48888418078422546,
0.31256818771362305,
-0.9103007912635803,
0.23700563609600067,
-0.08544950187206268,
0.25169336795806885,
-0.960525631904602,
-0.7597097158432007,
-0.5374903082847595,
0.16017186641693115,
-0.37918519973754883,
0.13784244656562805,
0.00798898097127676,
-0.21326039731502533,
-0.13085658848285675,
-0.6880732178688049,
-0.15083524584770203,
-0.22684237360954285,
-0.10218117386102676,
0.11048909276723862,
0.109633669257164,
0.3017236590385437,
0.4056941270828247,
0.10365928709506989,
0.13681866228580475,
-0.8584673404693604,
0.5217797160148621,
-0.2895326316356659,
-0.5566499829292297,
-0.5602289438247681,
0.22948771715164185,
0.2642401158809662,
-0.01990378275513649,
0.8069470524787903,
0.4905107915401459,
-0.2743149995803833,
-0.2714802622795105,
-0.779360294342041,
-0.39869990944862366,
-0.3843943774700165,
0.15392008423805237,
-0.38084694743156433,
-0.7871673107147217,
0.464240163564682,
0.0300521869212389,
-0.022999415174126625,
0.23857314884662628,
0.6136085391044617,
0.03387480974197388,
1.3406621217727661,
0.4922671914100647,
-0.16496866941452026,
0.38895589113235474,
-0.10525006800889969,
0.3607240319252014,
-0.8496693968772888,
-0.1808214783668518,
-0.04503779113292694,
-0.026239490136504173,
-0.4861154854297638,
-0.17210295796394348,
0.07319304347038269,
0.13814765214920044,
-0.740480899810791,
0.20957887172698975,
-0.9398499131202698,
0.6516507267951965,
0.6010919213294983,
0.6641883254051208,
0.282930850982666,
-0.26195162534713745,
-0.23614291846752167,
0.17021556198596954,
-0.7329889535903931,
-0.2966845631599426,
0.9574494957923889,
0.05953161418437958,
0.7210172414779663,
-0.2716730237007141,
0.5733000636100769,
0.34388118982315063,
0.16375981271266937,
-0.47926464676856995,
0.328762024641037,
0.3824153244495392,
-0.8329630494117737,
-0.06037279963493347,
-0.4927169680595398,
-0.40566137433052063,
0.0843934714794159,
-0.11874360591173172,
-0.7381933927536011,
0.295105904340744,
0.6178985834121704,
-0.3957289159297943,
0.5352860689163208,
-0.8394198417663574,
0.618074893951416,
0.06121480464935303,
-0.5947878360748291,
-0.037749383598566055,
-0.6155687570571899,
0.46057721972465515,
0.2398100048303604,
-0.19099222123622894,
0.09204687923192978,
0.5803529620170593,
0.6250070929527283,
-0.8400390148162842,
0.6587011814117432,
-0.27029913663864136,
0.09442626684904099,
0.4768180251121521,
0.32998126745224,
0.7669026851654053,
0.2561033368110657,
0.14161504805088043,
-0.10269008576869965,
-0.10726086050271988,
-0.752636730670929,
-0.9053521752357483,
0.5065346360206604,
-0.6166628003120422,
-0.6072084307670593,
-0.48140257596969604,
-0.9669342041015625,
-0.5873837471008301,
0.09868708997964859,
0.4729975759983063,
0.30610230565071106,
0.022131800651550293,
-0.3371752202510834,
1.1987801790237427,
0.24289776384830475,
-0.0008435892523266375,
-0.13973812758922577,
0.05907388776540756,
-0.32051345705986023,
0.5146900415420532,
-0.0400252528488636,
0.521367609500885,
0.10972585529088974,
-0.06715533882379532,
-0.23650237917900085,
-0.37478846311569214,
-0.3929780125617981,
0.0015171613777056336,
-0.8273979425430298,
-0.1359144002199173,
-0.5358709096908569,
-0.049129702150821686,
-0.46854743361473083,
-0.3240932524204254,
-0.5144929885864258,
-0.5542072653770447,
0.05760332569479942,
-0.25163882970809937,
0.45990121364593506,
0.668080747127533,
0.03831864148378372,
0.3462871313095093,
-0.16466565430164337,
0.14013734459877014,
0.6420629620552063,
0.46907946467399597,
-0.018083680421113968,
-0.5331682562828064,
-0.11044907569885254,
0.3029125928878784,
-0.47461774945259094,
-0.7555946111679077,
0.13730357587337494,
-0.2138804942369461,
0.2919886112213135,
0.4810342788696289,
0.045754365622997284,
1.0144554376602173,
-0.3145618736743927,
0.7099288702011108,
0.3001404404640198,
-1.2015975713729858,
0.7299133539199829,
-0.5601412057876587,
0.34006810188293457,
0.8167296648025513,
0.09983883798122406,
-0.2649618089199066,
-0.37947016954421997,
-0.651343822479248,
-0.4977354407310486,
0.5563269853591919,
0.19697147607803345,
-0.39986535906791687,
-0.3973003625869751,
0.47295746207237244,
0.18690690398216248,
0.2603716254234314,
-0.6534634828567505,
-0.13222961127758026,
-0.49044379591941833,
-0.21142257750034332,
0.4011392593383789,
-0.17426469922065735,
-0.20299364626407623,
-0.6845448017120361,
0.9759566783905029,
-0.27375760674476624,
0.19930095970630646,
0.508398711681366,
-0.2106354832649231,
-0.11702392995357513,
0.36122164130210876,
0.5484122633934021,
0.6616778373718262,
-0.36113670468330383,
0.3806520104408264,
0.48089003562927246,
-0.5945672988891602,
0.11844117939472198,
-0.08664816617965698,
-0.4589329957962036,
-0.1351662129163742,
-0.02364419586956501,
0.8663428425788879,
-0.2779054641723633,
-0.3393084704875946,
0.44800493121147156,
0.21960587799549103,
-0.2909959554672241,
0.1167207807302475,
0.010113991796970367,
-0.3030637502670288,
0.15225642919540405,
0.012403389438986778,
0.581220269203186,
0.10789390653371811,
-0.5732861757278442,
0.188984215259552,
0.5346301794052124,
-0.6756830811500549,
-0.11140783131122589,
0.6846737265586853,
0.05894341319799423,
0.10699347406625748,
0.5930678248405457,
-0.29717597365379333,
-0.6139023900032043,
0.2599569261074066,
0.6366134285926819,
0.8341888189315796,
0.09986668080091476,
0.14033113420009613,
0.2604261636734009,
0.43421533703804016,
-0.6933554410934448,
0.3126479685306549,
-0.3388173580169678,
-0.9224491119384766,
-0.5643464922904968,
-0.07269714027643204,
-0.6341477632522583,
0.028823060914874077,
-0.7993395328521729,
0.24163098633289337,
-0.6555382609367371,
-0.27378079295158386,
-0.3600013554096222,
-0.0017204242758452892,
-0.6523184776306152,
0.35693076252937317,
0.06516680866479874,
0.9328794479370117,
-0.9049327969551086,
0.7881226539611816,
0.5948729515075684,
-0.5774921178817749,
-0.9967519640922546,
0.28187161684036255,
-0.13729780912399292,
-0.5705987811088562,
0.38950490951538086,
0.16195973753929138,
-0.21701711416244507,
-0.23031650483608246,
-0.8636490702629089,
-0.6467092633247375,
0.767486035823822,
0.5915311574935913,
-0.4668079912662506,
0.10534566640853882,
-0.2703683376312256,
0.21990561485290527,
-0.33535873889923096,
0.5966262221336365,
0.8109146952629089,
0.4134700894355774,
-0.13110913336277008,
-1.1454049348831177,
0.17207428812980652,
-0.0011589180212467909,
-0.0014256060821935534,
0.1532006561756134,
-0.5575462579727173,
0.7813996076583862,
-0.34942662715911865,
0.24259939789772034,
-0.21525534987449646,
0.5819180607795715,
0.7403881549835205,
0.33577993512153625,
0.44461125135421753,
0.7282439470291138,
1.206737756729126,
-0.2972699999809265,
0.7966613173484802,
0.08213209360837936,
0.4382651448249817,
1.1082087755203247,
-0.38543012738227844,
0.28211709856987,
0.6694965362548828,
0.238387331366539,
0.8018560409545898,
0.6590738296508789,
0.2589885890483856,
0.764467179775238,
-0.11094397306442261,
-0.40659648180007935,
-0.6467360258102417,
-0.0004971351008862257,
-0.31316500902175903,
-0.022651266306638718,
0.03702779859304428,
-0.20923155546188354,
-0.06974602490663528,
0.1590026319026947,
0.15425194799900055,
0.18496884405612946,
-0.6221122741699219,
0.5466220378875732,
-0.0967608243227005,
-0.9877288341522217,
0.9579935073852539,
-0.5008798241615295,
0.473030149936676,
-0.18687720596790314,
-0.06865962594747543,
-0.1576899141073227,
0.37340205907821655,
-0.27666619420051575,
-0.7527052164077759,
0.20034730434417725,
-0.010938139632344246,
-0.622231662273407,
-0.3572274446487427,
0.7032743096351624,
-0.4894614815711975,
-0.11215852946043015,
0.009819730184972286,
0.5185509920120239,
0.03585180640220642,
-0.3965371251106262,
-0.5163326859474182,
-0.11325737088918686,
0.015822552144527435,
-0.2619076669216156,
0.16530683636665344,
0.691217303276062,
-0.3246380388736725,
0.6956703662872314,
0.5657660365104675,
0.1270473301410675,
-0.061787787824869156,
0.2928568124771118,
1.2347418069839478,
-0.5308341383934021,
-0.4027043879032135,
-0.7751811146736145,
0.32268592715263367,
-0.2690221667289734,
-0.24046385288238525,
0.5974159240722656,
0.48833805322647095,
0.9494048357009888,
-0.08695247769355774,
1.1258488893508911,
0.04220352694392204,
0.4550209641456604,
-0.5066931843757629,
0.5653309226036072,
-0.15469954907894135,
0.25971344113349915,
-0.4163808524608612,
-0.9056985974311829,
-0.14968395233154297,
0.8038143515586853,
-0.5457878112792969,
0.27660784125328064,
1.0093498229980469,
0.5085882544517517,
-0.18432091176509857,
0.22383707761764526,
0.19075670838356018,
0.03955238312482834,
0.04540691152215004,
0.5719442367553711,
0.6716520190238953,
-0.4049170911312103,
0.3284550607204437,
-0.24973823130130768,
-0.2551784813404083,
0.18568788468837738,
-0.7151394486427307,
-1.2578673362731934,
-0.27596405148506165,
-0.36720871925354004,
-0.7730631232261658,
0.576921284198761,
1.0748569965362549,
0.8730013966560364,
-1.0921140909194946,
0.2250194251537323,
-0.7246570587158203,
0.2616775929927826,
-0.6447102427482605,
-0.16051286458969116,
0.31438761949539185,
-0.5438703894615173,
-0.22717100381851196,
0.12042364478111267,
0.1508491188287735,
-0.38563117384910583,
0.000709429441485554,
0.0218086875975132,
-0.30855417251586914,
0.21063636243343353,
0.3256787955760956,
0.2818906307220459,
-0.7660050988197327,
-0.7486599683761597,
0.041584745049476624,
0.18082201480865479,
0.17370876669883728,
0.9348011612892151,
-1.0402143001556396,
0.5940878987312317,
0.43139007687568665,
0.47328081727027893,
0.6291207671165466,
0.43316295742988586,
0.6784406900405884,
-0.8914200067520142,
0.3371697664260864,
0.2557225823402405,
0.29416048526763916,
0.18838828802108765,
-0.5318446755409241,
0.2153916358947754,
0.468637079000473,
-0.7816718220710754,
-0.6409515142440796,
0.39174917340278625,
-1.1462481021881104,
-0.11965753138065338,
1.1844028234481812,
0.022795390337705612,
-0.22879920899868011,
-0.5133476853370667,
-0.4147343635559082,
0.47836458683013916,
-0.47574472427368164,
0.9779859781265259,
0.876959502696991,
-0.2903558313846588,
-0.29783931374549866,
-0.26799869537353516,
0.7752045392990112,
0.8056482076644897,
-0.5775666236877441,
0.35373803973197937,
0.38395801186561584,
0.41713574528694153,
-0.0727664902806282,
0.7477125525474548,
0.11515125632286072,
0.5203270316123962,
-0.12898392975330353,
0.2801540195941925,
-0.024765880778431892,
-0.39997929334640503,
-0.04690762981772423,
-0.2568513751029968,
0.05625239387154579,
-0.0933704599738121
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.05612v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.05612v2
|
Unfamiliar Finetuning Examples Control How Language Models Hallucinate
| 2024-03-08T18:28:13 | 2024-05-28T23:56:14 |
Katie Kang, Eric Wallace, Claire Tomlin, Aviral Kumar, Sergey Levine
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large language models are known to hallucinate when faced with unfamiliar
queries, but the underlying mechanism that govern how models hallucinate are
not yet fully understood. In this work, we find that unfamiliar examples in the
models' finetuning data -- those that introduce concepts beyond the base
model's scope of knowledge -- are crucial in shaping these errors. In
particular, we find that an LLM's hallucinated predictions tend to mirror the
responses associated with its unfamiliar finetuning examples. This suggests
that by modifying how unfamiliar finetuning examples are supervised, we can
influence a model's responses to unfamiliar queries (e.g., say ``I don't
know''). We empirically validate this observation in a series of controlled
experiments involving SFT, RL, and reward model finetuning on TriviaQA and
MMLU. Our work further investigates RL finetuning strategies for improving the
factuality of long-form model generations. We find that, while hallucinations
from the reward model can significantly undermine the effectiveness of RL
factuality finetuning, strategically controlling how reward models hallucinate
can minimize these negative effects. Leveraging our previous observations on
controlling hallucinations, we propose an approach for learning more reliable
reward models, and show that they improve the efficacy of RL factuality
finetuning in long-form biography and book/movie plot generation tasks.
|
[
-0.4656476676464081,
-1.1043617725372314,
0.7216264605522156,
0.032753441482782364,
-0.08084239810705185,
-0.21808119118213654,
-0.2043713480234146,
-0.49238482117652893,
0.14908576011657715,
0.7284426093101501,
-0.6778029799461365,
-0.20110845565795898,
-0.5335132479667664,
0.03051702305674553,
-0.3808997571468353,
1.284151554107666,
0.11405626684427261,
-0.040674664080142975,
-0.10200390219688416,
-0.07046516239643097,
-0.4865843951702118,
-0.6157305836677551,
-0.6154354214668274,
-0.40419062972068787,
0.7111429572105408,
0.3382740914821625,
0.8602852821350098,
0.4453730285167694,
0.2757112681865692,
0.19483038783073425,
0.0931805670261383,
0.4262773096561432,
-1.0733894109725952,
0.18756207823753357,
-0.2791699469089508,
-0.9551317095756531,
0.03193846717476845,
0.006153501570224762,
0.37692582607269287,
0.8840905427932739,
-0.1475127637386322,
-0.1312115341424942,
0.21807095408439636,
0.7612342834472656,
-0.5651627779006958,
0.2257370948791504,
-0.7961477637290955,
0.14440107345581055,
-0.06345127522945404,
-0.5396202802658081,
-0.5989505052566528,
-0.5150171518325806,
0.011311614885926247,
-0.4147740602493286,
0.5016272664070129,
0.15288472175598145,
0.8258333206176758,
0.5095498561859131,
-0.16500268876552582,
-0.4625036120414734,
-1.0446339845657349,
0.563313901424408,
-0.6419029831886292,
0.4626643657684326,
0.5085842609405518,
0.35779497027397156,
-0.4130520224571228,
-0.5025014877319336,
-0.5413909554481506,
-0.5147370100021362,
-0.30842816829681396,
-0.14917737245559692,
0.028321709483861923,
0.11234253644943237,
0.33723220229148865,
0.24090586602687836,
-0.30212512612342834,
0.1371045708656311,
-0.48150599002838135,
-0.21293321251869202,
0.40883979201316833,
0.20530205965042114,
0.16281194984912872,
-0.24099719524383545,
-0.18432699143886566,
-0.07655593007802963,
-0.8720436692237854,
-0.003694069804623723,
0.26411738991737366,
0.46709391474723816,
0.08692125231027603,
0.8564084768295288,
-0.35319647192955017,
0.5947842001914978,
0.30349624156951904,
0.14397378265857697,
-0.0006606330862268806,
-0.04947196692228317,
-0.263557493686676,
0.27410003542900085,
0.39309296011924744,
0.5395039319992065,
0.4848189949989319,
-0.4164412319660187,
-0.405638724565506,
0.12237178534269333,
0.23458530008792877,
-0.7042143940925598,
-0.3769241273403168,
0.33953186869621277,
-0.3196636438369751,
-0.40672191977500916,
0.09961891174316406,
-0.6167610287666321,
-0.8084728717803955,
-0.4469594657421112,
0.7718830108642578,
-0.46707648038864136,
-0.05437949299812317,
0.1733967512845993,
-0.0429847314953804,
0.2891981303691864,
0.30749937891960144,
-1.0756117105484009,
0.4350893199443817,
0.7115491628646851,
0.597689688205719,
-0.35112228989601135,
-0.3944765627384186,
-0.9343116879463196,
0.020382026210427284,
-0.4062725901603699,
0.6988862752914429,
-0.11775704473257065,
-0.05800912156701088,
0.01193237490952015,
0.13283856213092804,
0.07468497008085251,
-0.6933280229568481,
0.29666846990585327,
-0.5235157012939453,
0.3169955611228943,
-0.2158435434103012,
-0.46770530939102173,
-0.27094966173171997,
0.1398315131664276,
-0.6950652599334717,
0.3735440671443939,
-0.07687491923570633,
-0.5573176741600037,
0.3993380665779114,
-0.27957746386528015,
-0.3420635163784027,
-0.24325895309448242,
-0.35949623584747314,
-0.20386184751987457,
0.4430735111236572,
0.06751344352960587,
0.7876369953155518,
0.0018672625301405787,
0.4595937430858612,
-0.10223852097988129,
-0.5360716581344604,
0.38465550541877747,
-0.5666136145591736,
0.5102967619895935,
0.20138609409332275,
-0.4387688934803009,
0.056576166301965714,
-0.7897590398788452,
-0.2514892816543579,
0.21148501336574554,
-0.11004414409399033,
-0.5962327122688293,
-0.1940106749534607,
-0.12571001052856445,
-0.05705546215176582,
-0.03588411957025528,
-0.23460084199905396,
0.16535070538520813,
-0.5762752294540405,
0.16081061959266663,
0.7916890978813171,
0.36579573154449463,
0.26555848121643066,
-0.7488635182380676,
0.3530840575695038,
0.11036866903305054,
-0.18151262402534485,
0.12000066787004471,
-0.13152861595153809,
-1.0562132596969604,
0.35273614525794983,
0.24621915817260742,
0.4883268177509308,
-0.703761875629425,
-0.05141301080584526,
-0.04255930706858635,
-0.41761142015457153,
-0.6553560495376587,
0.002366573316976428,
0.18236449360847473,
0.3007217049598694,
0.4071674644947052,
0.00682293763384223,
-0.38484248518943787,
-0.9180565476417542,
-0.4161093533039093,
0.09067430347204208,
-0.018978377804160118,
0.34985581040382385,
0.28425487875938416,
-0.1421959549188614,
0.5990105271339417,
-0.5899357199668884,
-0.29595643281936646,
-0.10516899824142456,
0.35149192810058594,
0.09902380406856537,
0.6259787678718567,
0.47499150037765503,
-0.7738664746284485,
-0.06413011252880096,
-0.17902669310569763,
-0.5908803343772888,
0.19416020810604095,
-0.7242741584777832,
0.13938367366790771,
0.3426963984966278,
0.7025632858276367,
-0.6734336614608765,
0.044058907777071,
0.3983977138996124,
-0.39806288480758667,
0.6509518623352051,
-0.2803361415863037,
0.052762340754270554,
-0.761326014995575,
-0.3209608495235443,
-0.17022189497947693,
-0.19719572365283966,
-0.592857837677002,
0.14692729711532593,
-0.07917490601539612,
0.3837897777557373,
-0.36786410212516785,
0.4160323739051819,
-0.1988798826932907,
0.14203986525535583,
-0.10043177753686905,
0.1182476282119751,
-0.0421043299138546,
0.5993673205375671,
0.006449763663113117,
0.6742275953292847,
0.33587008714675903,
-0.8667066693305969,
0.1181524470448494,
0.132277250289917,
-0.553155779838562,
0.23391783237457275,
-0.45109012722969055,
-0.022913917899131775,
-0.5277738571166992,
-0.17139646410942078,
-0.9337437748908997,
-0.48986726999282837,
0.18182379007339478,
-0.4250251352787018,
0.4838740825653076,
0.03817160800099373,
-0.28959333896636963,
0.059174325317144394,
-0.056997768580913544,
0.15460360050201416,
0.33681637048721313,
-0.6985865831375122,
0.49544090032577515,
0.0795554593205452,
-0.17934906482696533,
-0.576192319393158,
-0.9624503254890442,
-0.07118168473243713,
-0.35435137152671814,
-0.13582563400268555,
0.18968534469604492,
-0.30795031785964966,
-0.4734499156475067,
-0.22588880360126495,
-0.0994759127497673,
-0.002787741832435131,
0.22313885390758514,
0.35322555899620056,
0.1158820316195488,
-0.23938007652759552,
0.24353086948394775,
0.19164510071277618,
0.12302710860967636,
0.34834545850753784,
-0.017820078879594803,
0.7850925326347351,
0.046062175184488297,
-0.2303575724363327,
-0.33567947149276733,
-0.021032828837633133,
0.4976193308830261,
0.04057791456580162,
0.7956846952438354,
0.4402782917022705,
-0.46111229062080383,
-0.4295910894870758,
-0.8215797543525696,
-0.7609776854515076,
-0.4204934239387512,
0.36566948890686035,
-0.5540279746055603,
-0.8539943695068359,
0.5437456369400024,
0.16446790099143982,
-0.16495974361896515,
0.43280014395713806,
0.5445227026939392,
0.04859733581542969,
0.833705484867096,
0.6348856687545776,
0.12334387749433517,
0.19561053812503815,
-0.21299776434898376,
-0.05695914104580879,
-0.460213840007782,
-0.23425382375717163,
-0.3349945545196533,
-0.09145466238260269,
-0.7828705310821533,
-0.2740307152271271,
-0.023743072524666786,
0.04984981566667557,
-0.0821259394288063,
0.01947450265288353,
-0.3174099028110504,
0.6653640270233154,
0.40902748703956604,
0.30257555842399597,
0.4187067747116089,
0.07131653279066086,
-0.16738660633563995,
-0.0058732954785227776,
-0.6930230855941772,
-0.3984726369380951,
1.003853440284729,
0.38851600885391235,
1.0070875883102417,
0.08201821148395538,
0.8020003437995911,
0.22626525163650513,
0.1046442836523056,
-0.7374716997146606,
0.19030719995498657,
0.01990783028304577,
-0.6104587912559509,
-0.41894233226776123,
-0.3760318458080292,
-0.6631189584732056,
0.037173207849264145,
-0.3616807460784912,
-0.6946339011192322,
0.4739561676979065,
0.12732654809951782,
-0.9185393452644348,
0.22110676765441895,
-0.767575204372406,
0.6787184476852417,
-0.14959704875946045,
-0.52602219581604,
-0.1494382619857788,
-0.5140203833580017,
0.7362816333770752,
-0.21441403031349182,
0.22195090353488922,
0.15276820957660675,
0.4393858015537262,
0.6344109773635864,
0.07170690596103668,
1.0836278200149536,
-0.020950449630618095,
-0.2452322542667389,
0.1312035173177719,
0.6887542605400085,
0.6888594627380371,
0.18755704164505005,
-0.0220654159784317,
-0.18041008710861206,
0.06731998175382614,
-0.0913967564702034,
-0.6565583944320679,
0.8585234880447388,
-0.6656146049499512,
-0.8659077286720276,
-0.17115925252437592,
-0.8028008341789246,
-0.3359140157699585,
0.14692793786525726,
0.3650147318840027,
0.2993394434452057,
-0.26597559452056885,
0.318972110748291,
0.8727801442146301,
-0.23002295196056366,
-0.028107693418860435,
0.2608225345611572,
-0.3348406255245209,
0.04351770877838135,
0.9104855060577393,
0.12250743061304092,
0.7004921436309814,
0.38999423384666443,
0.27860674262046814,
-0.1395615041255951,
-0.5425989627838135,
-0.05283570662140846,
0.30185091495513916,
-0.8473241329193115,
-0.1542941927909851,
-0.6723686456680298,
-0.37642666697502136,
-0.3467569053173065,
-0.036662738770246506,
-0.2596566081047058,
-0.5996465086936951,
-0.40446072816848755,
-0.32445675134658813,
0.36882802844047546,
0.9231445789337158,
-0.12505017220973969,
0.24299629032611847,
-0.390255331993103,
0.5137989521026611,
0.49928784370422363,
0.42316722869873047,
0.17471815645694733,
-0.5054216980934143,
-0.013345086947083473,
0.21081431210041046,
-0.08336727321147919,
-0.5391660928726196,
0.26291385293006897,
0.021827638149261475,
0.48403969407081604,
0.6097698211669922,
0.36718297004699707,
0.5594004988670349,
-0.45514535903930664,
0.6101208925247192,
-0.10777697712182999,
-0.587486743927002,
0.23411814868450165,
-0.2393570989370346,
0.05182826891541481,
0.5703886151313782,
0.38024279475212097,
-0.5562940835952759,
-0.7799175977706909,
-0.5975413918495178,
-0.2751796543598175,
0.5873774886131287,
0.1277347207069397,
0.31003451347351074,
0.00547397043555975,
0.522117555141449,
0.48889005184173584,
0.18941861391067505,
-1.188183069229126,
-0.23869144916534424,
-0.2545124590396881,
-0.010728588327765465,
-0.3127037584781647,
-0.5270639061927795,
-0.23383507132530212,
-0.13823696970939636,
0.3938348591327667,
0.0423479899764061,
0.04497262462973595,
0.27201759815216064,
-0.09898782521486282,
-0.41354966163635254,
0.241224467754364,
0.9638887643814087,
0.5301644206047058,
-0.502079427242279,
0.39583125710487366,
0.12025453895330429,
-0.20580242574214935,
-0.14656494557857513,
-0.00011138017725897953,
-0.3343150019645691,
-0.10497809946537018,
0.23573139309883118,
0.8878988027572632,
0.08869825303554535,
-0.5030335783958435,
0.1283617913722992,
0.09270608425140381,
-0.3151739835739136,
-0.3061749041080475,
0.3982653319835663,
0.0818425863981247,
0.41446152329444885,
0.18642491102218628,
0.1227537989616394,
0.08166012167930603,
-0.7416996955871582,
0.3843611776828766,
0.578389048576355,
-0.472598135471344,
-0.007816454395651817,
0.7986823320388794,
-0.3193724751472473,
-0.24687205255031586,
0.502408504486084,
-0.2775002121925354,
-0.45539870858192444,
0.5578676462173462,
0.7328692078590393,
0.5958063006401062,
-0.1301020085811615,
0.15098583698272705,
0.2382550984621048,
0.42781513929367065,
-0.14864805340766907,
0.043323393911123276,
0.17790120840072632,
-0.9400560259819031,
-0.2653336524963379,
-0.5347760319709778,
-0.1478388011455536,
0.4974459409713745,
-0.590994656085968,
0.3424466550350189,
-0.43292197585105896,
0.238206148147583,
-0.00021103759354446083,
-0.22294636070728302,
-0.6503966450691223,
0.19058413803577423,
0.19429850578308105,
0.5723944902420044,
-0.8864415287971497,
0.7925425171852112,
0.0809548869729042,
-0.7001357078552246,
-0.7945302128791809,
0.15813229978084564,
-0.19045740365982056,
-0.8388960957527161,
0.7461559772491455,
0.08145558089017868,
-0.07675889134407043,
0.2698320150375366,
-0.6360991597175598,
-0.6416928172111511,
0.8792787194252014,
0.010017632506787777,
-0.4920654892921448,
-0.2915797233581543,
0.34100914001464844,
0.3507087528705597,
-0.43959254026412964,
-0.14257486164569855,
0.7104882597923279,
0.3992450535297394,
0.1114223301410675,
-0.7135577201843262,
0.3255922794342041,
0.34656640887260437,
-0.45447343587875366,
-0.009541784413158894,
-0.3771497905254364,
0.9065371155738831,
-0.6378571391105652,
-0.13368307054042816,
0.2799724340438843,
0.6398467421531677,
0.37258484959602356,
0.291183203458786,
0.47971323132514954,
0.11456100642681122,
0.8945668339729309,
0.10060319304466248,
0.9292353987693787,
-0.08841235935688019,
0.23762860894203186,
1.3478496074676514,
0.051646679639816284,
0.745942234992981,
0.8042075037956238,
0.2284894734621048,
0.3566338121891022,
0.5079746246337891,
-0.3456941843032837,
0.6447833776473999,
0.35604098439216614,
0.16358453035354614,
-0.2910333573818207,
-0.13118931651115417,
-0.3114296793937683,
0.3689156174659729,
0.5042003393173218,
-0.35335585474967957,
-0.2589782476425171,
0.32944098114967346,
-0.06137002632021904,
0.20636174082756042,
-0.33419063687324524,
0.6858369708061218,
0.08869726955890656,
-0.7407492995262146,
1.023489236831665,
-0.18053872883319855,
0.5495477914810181,
-0.4200665354728699,
-0.19446003437042236,
-0.40948817133903503,
0.13907520473003387,
-0.19392764568328857,
-0.5218404531478882,
0.29320621490478516,
-0.31842294335365295,
-0.18961691856384277,
0.09270479530096054,
0.5153892040252686,
-0.562828540802002,
-0.37902653217315674,
-0.056656286120414734,
0.6053160429000854,
0.23461008071899414,
-0.21785961091518402,
-0.29720622301101685,
-0.12178819626569748,
0.23391816020011902,
-0.08642106503248215,
0.17102961242198944,
0.6647211909294128,
-0.053876738995313644,
0.7848996520042419,
0.4339860677719116,
0.2478472739458084,
-0.010277874767780304,
0.04145904257893562,
0.6518804430961609,
-0.6581366658210754,
-0.3109971582889557,
-0.8586005568504333,
0.2784114181995392,
0.23582777380943298,
-0.044304557144641876,
0.7244188189506531,
0.5432306528091431,
1.0172743797302246,
-0.4976903796195984,
0.5107341408729553,
0.25845658779144287,
0.41854560375213623,
-0.945115327835083,
1.1186256408691406,
-0.661819577217102,
0.2262384295463562,
-0.2732289433479309,
-0.8172539472579956,
-0.42420846223831177,
0.5647026300430298,
-0.2231176793575287,
-0.07035733759403229,
0.8206033110618591,
0.921919584274292,
-0.1247728019952774,
-0.1176178902387619,
0.5544980764389038,
0.7224345207214355,
0.16720730066299438,
0.3585061728954315,
0.8546287417411804,
-0.17449109256267548,
0.4518640637397766,
-0.6512104868888855,
0.08793820440769196,
-0.29960617423057556,
-0.7731764316558838,
-1.0133477449417114,
-0.6139208078384399,
-0.20398686826229095,
-0.45654305815696716,
0.05615365505218506,
0.9763187766075134,
0.4207572042942047,
-1.1569238901138306,
-0.24519029259681702,
-0.257811963558197,
0.28316789865493774,
-0.1401977241039276,
-0.29818299412727356,
0.3792915642261505,
-0.5502637028694153,
-0.5854254961013794,
0.22358651459217072,
-0.1841888576745987,
0.5004110932350159,
-0.38579490780830383,
0.005076981149613857,
0.01820169761776924,
0.08680016547441483,
0.551721453666687,
0.23951131105422974,
-0.9935446381568909,
-0.46378520131111145,
-0.03717458248138428,
-0.10304228216409683,
-0.08036529272794724,
0.6899239420890808,
-0.9202014803886414,
0.2500388026237488,
0.0905706137418747,
0.5570967793464661,
0.23643805086612701,
0.0742584764957428,
0.6165555715560913,
-0.48424670100212097,
0.204758882522583,
0.1518043875694275,
0.18689319491386414,
0.2568112015724182,
-0.6726064085960388,
0.33277052640914917,
0.04295333847403526,
-0.4404379725456238,
-0.9459837675094604,
0.23020879924297333,
-0.8408267498016357,
-0.5876477956771851,
1.1634007692337036,
0.4295830726623535,
-0.10696732997894287,
0.08822274953126907,
-0.34479406476020813,
0.3239006996154785,
-0.039646100252866745,
1.3577154874801636,
0.8632851243019104,
-0.02166491001844406,
-0.10692328959703445,
-0.9914078116416931,
1.016017198562622,
0.50724858045578,
-0.5214203596115112,
0.519853949546814,
0.5395939350128174,
0.26226115226745605,
0.10716630518436432,
0.16122451424598694,
0.16883857548236847,
0.12537263333797455,
-0.2399083375930786,
-0.10015297681093216,
-0.02965421788394451,
-0.5748274922370911,
-0.4027753174304962,
0.1567854881286621,
0.4669019877910614,
0.1937650591135025
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.05493v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.05493v1
|
To Err Is Human, but Llamas Can Learn It Too
| 2024-03-08T18:04:03 | 2024-03-08T18:04:03 |
Agnes Luhtaru, Taido Purason, Martin Vainikko, Maksym Del, Mark Fishel
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This study explores enhancing grammatical error correction (GEC) through
artificial error generation (AEG) using language models (LMs). Specifically, we
fine-tune Llama 2-based LMs for error generation and find that this approach
yields synthetic errors akin to human errors. Next, we train GEC Llama models
with the help of these artificial errors and outperform previous
state-of-the-art error correction models, with gains ranging between 0.8 and 6
F0.5 points across all tested languages (German, Ukrainian, and Estonian).
Moreover, we demonstrate that generating errors by fine-tuning smaller
sequence-to-sequence models and prompting large commercial LMs (GPT-3.5 and
GPT-4) also results in synthetic errors beneficially affecting error generation
models.
|
[
0.2216772884130478,
-1.0655664205551147,
0.644310474395752,
0.15923023223876953,
0.002105831867083907,
0.30436500906944275,
-0.3762984275817871,
-0.5605463981628418,
0.04797937721014023,
0.27163371443748474,
-0.5709719061851501,
-0.41970333456993103,
-0.5357556939125061,
0.6945343613624573,
-0.4729413688182831,
0.9658880829811096,
-0.05522926151752472,
0.17425647377967834,
-0.05134439840912819,
0.15674999356269836,
-0.5325616598129272,
-0.5535774230957031,
-0.7991304397583008,
-0.14683552086353302,
0.5816429853439331,
0.7772760391235352,
0.6965600252151489,
0.5412750840187073,
0.16395875811576843,
0.3687824606895447,
-0.003306745085865259,
0.8402787446975708,
-0.3233870267868042,
-0.2790047526359558,
-0.08917607367038727,
-0.7453497648239136,
-0.5790198445320129,
-0.2991613447666168,
0.5338844656944275,
0.4438406229019165,
-0.5437209606170654,
-0.012073132209479809,
-0.04798610880970955,
0.6289368271827698,
-0.3404749035835266,
0.15785782039165497,
-0.8235225081443787,
-0.018992772325873375,
-0.22245362401008606,
0.007114281877875328,
-0.4616643190383911,
-0.48468396067619324,
-0.24226737022399902,
-0.7292062044143677,
0.3437899947166443,
0.10517903417348862,
1.008241891860962,
0.49657705426216125,
0.022374624386429787,
-0.5064948201179504,
-0.7215986847877502,
0.6121020317077637,
-1.1490894556045532,
0.05477747321128845,
0.4727436602115631,
0.07061248272657394,
-0.5953836441040039,
-0.5365943908691406,
-0.940181314945221,
-0.2717718482017517,
0.0006852018414065242,
-0.057345252484083176,
-0.3801439702510834,
0.2079584300518036,
0.09131509810686111,
0.08744591474533081,
-0.12400349229574203,
0.25881868600845337,
-0.5165159106254578,
-0.17393769323825836,
0.8370866179466248,
0.034307584166526794,
0.5241575241088867,
-0.11103050410747528,
0.20088139176368713,
-0.08952535688877106,
-0.9426019191741943,
-0.07817956805229187,
0.7403467297554016,
0.43509727716445923,
-0.09327959269285202,
0.5931498408317566,
-0.034009747207164764,
0.6982653141021729,
0.2845930755138397,
-0.1288723349571228,
0.07270460575819016,
-0.06291481852531433,
-0.21728219091892242,
0.17678990960121155,
0.6338139176368713,
0.3113306164741516,
0.6463667750358582,
-0.17372320592403412,
-0.3604598045349121,
0.69707190990448,
0.5388441681861877,
-0.16208019852638245,
-0.21684467792510986,
-0.1776357889175415,
0.05918388441205025,
-0.5353545546531677,
-0.002116152551025152,
-0.8556410670280457,
-0.2668542265892029,
-0.37042754888534546,
0.49016278982162476,
-0.15151150524616241,
0.10020510852336884,
0.33118513226509094,
0.1956610232591629,
0.036901190876960754,
0.3508678078651428,
-0.9186594486236572,
0.5536521673202515,
0.4218292236328125,
0.5342337489128113,
0.13739363849163055,
-0.5557345747947693,
-0.5644363760948181,
-0.058759234845638275,
-0.8278923034667969,
0.9019112586975098,
-0.21371805667877197,
-0.7082606554031372,
0.06872408092021942,
0.02418198436498642,
-0.054291192442178726,
-0.6517093181610107,
0.6990000009536743,
-0.41848134994506836,
0.07241947948932648,
-0.2913965880870819,
-0.29608431458473206,
-0.4717486500740051,
-0.1515033096075058,
-0.5102961659431458,
1.1982465982437134,
0.06312111765146255,
-0.3522491157054901,
0.12587232887744904,
-0.7595524787902832,
-0.6699591875076294,
-0.3281940519809723,
-0.15292398631572723,
-0.4455636441707611,
0.3437904119491577,
0.3245132565498352,
0.3890441060066223,
-0.2612350285053253,
0.32800331711769104,
0.14409813284873962,
-0.4593055546283722,
0.2841067612171173,
-0.38399118185043335,
0.30602318048477173,
-0.034491512924432755,
-0.5129353404045105,
0.018598567694425583,
-1.191449761390686,
-0.08737540245056152,
0.3967936933040619,
-0.9187923669815063,
-0.12685106694698334,
0.47068706154823303,
-0.392805814743042,
0.06915295124053955,
-0.06781843304634094,
-0.40701183676719666,
0.05297623947262764,
-0.3540896475315094,
0.5307359099388123,
0.968717098236084,
-0.3646569848060608,
0.21366602182388306,
-0.4409424662590027,
0.5721831321716309,
-0.1320124715566635,
-0.2384106069803238,
-0.00908645149320364,
-0.4870392978191376,
-1.3649590015411377,
0.21358844637870789,
0.20917654037475586,
0.8943629860877991,
-0.6416110992431641,
0.4543641209602356,
-0.20205049216747284,
-0.47290870547294617,
-0.8423691987991333,
0.577646017074585,
0.48356446623802185,
0.6726319193840027,
0.2957330048084259,
-0.3145310580730438,
-0.8845109343528748,
-0.6950498819351196,
-0.35717159509658813,
-0.6803119778633118,
0.1933262199163437,
0.28207170963287354,
0.33379533886909485,
-0.5683987736701965,
0.880693793296814,
-0.17135131359100342,
-0.09866127371788025,
-0.2219509333372116,
-0.01899457909166813,
0.0558001734316349,
0.28877782821655273,
0.4297032654285431,
-0.2696964740753174,
-0.05846504122018814,
0.18586398661136627,
-0.6251228451728821,
-0.4996218979358673,
-0.15871328115463257,
-0.012696643359959126,
0.5496268272399902,
0.4299688935279846,
-0.7118473649024963,
0.3148627281188965,
0.6120191216468811,
-0.4404873549938202,
0.6987923979759216,
-0.4971708357334137,
0.029899070039391518,
-0.9227612018585205,
-0.2646835148334503,
-0.0033636942971497774,
-0.2465061992406845,
-0.6357893943786621,
-0.2538997232913971,
0.01959386095404625,
0.474003404378891,
-0.33595067262649536,
0.24028052389621735,
-0.24708731472492218,
-0.10385356098413467,
-0.22791869938373566,
-0.1279950737953186,
-0.09145652502775192,
0.3922121226787567,
-0.2887546420097351,
0.9964985847473145,
0.12177275866270065,
-0.7720356583595276,
0.17463742196559906,
0.21734581887722015,
-0.03292880579829216,
0.3704020082950592,
-0.7108064293861389,
0.45122233033180237,
-0.31039005517959595,
0.03457857295870781,
-1.0419445037841797,
-0.8339813351631165,
0.3894192576408386,
-0.5451682806015015,
0.4746682047843933,
0.18269354104995728,
-0.38844239711761475,
-0.4455582797527313,
-0.25566524267196655,
0.08188004791736603,
0.6834051012992859,
-0.8250809907913208,
0.6932370662689209,
0.20122763514518738,
-0.3771764934062958,
-0.6436923146247864,
-0.9903271794319153,
0.3548141419887543,
-0.22998885810375214,
-0.612521767616272,
0.13883276283740997,
0.04150737449526787,
-0.5550363659858704,
-0.20735108852386475,
0.4375210702419281,
0.40842074155807495,
0.16649575531482697,
0.2790912091732025,
0.3950332999229431,
-0.2096318006515503,
0.2809944450855255,
0.03560156747698784,
0.112081378698349,
0.06934932619333267,
-0.141871839761734,
0.3705119490623474,
-0.44900938868522644,
-0.45097815990448,
-0.4145214557647705,
0.11503318697214127,
0.4168548285961151,
0.1478770673274994,
0.2946814298629761,
-0.1226780116558075,
-0.5325765609741211,
-0.24035020172595978,
-0.8226824998855591,
-0.05778259411454201,
-0.5166460275650024,
0.648723304271698,
-0.03281150385737419,
-0.5205005407333374,
0.4700981676578522,
0.03341662883758545,
0.10013887286186218,
0.5078002214431763,
0.5233345031738281,
-0.32125574350357056,
0.8736724853515625,
0.7343432307243347,
-0.1912798136472702,
0.20776870846748352,
0.03696533292531967,
0.013439665548503399,
-0.4726547598838806,
-0.1544341892004013,
-0.5872329473495483,
-0.2773411273956299,
-0.5518089532852173,
-0.543449342250824,
0.1726144552230835,
0.22571209073066711,
-0.44537127017974854,
0.22553017735481262,
-0.1120949387550354,
0.5884795784950256,
0.5736417770385742,
0.09068959206342697,
0.37084728479385376,
0.5161620378494263,
-0.2215503454208374,
-0.2796038091182709,
-0.8814007639884949,
-0.9641895890235901,
1.0577893257141113,
0.3859173357486725,
0.9724876284599304,
0.08708319813013077,
0.6199173927307129,
0.42189016938209534,
0.4551234245300293,
-0.7118647694587708,
0.44533851742744446,
-0.2541547417640686,
-0.22219808399677277,
-0.1639218032360077,
-0.09987052530050278,
-0.6430622935295105,
0.012238601222634315,
-0.13534465432167053,
-0.6137770414352417,
0.03396562859416008,
0.6012572646141052,
-0.46619629859924316,
0.4745822250843048,
-0.7892642617225647,
0.4138953685760498,
-0.4744526147842407,
-0.2953113615512848,
-0.11487580090761185,
-0.5317717790603638,
0.2961655557155609,
-0.23932407796382904,
0.4467543363571167,
0.14041094481945038,
-0.2197568714618683,
0.6222051382064819,
-0.4824591875076294,
1.4236233234405518,
0.10997499525547028,
-0.46551749110221863,
0.7111106514930725,
0.24729517102241516,
0.9956793785095215,
-0.4000999927520752,
-0.15021313726902008,
0.24161143600940704,
-0.8028075695037842,
-0.2327483743429184,
-0.2673264443874359,
0.4098467230796814,
-1.0623855590820312,
-0.647570013999939,
-0.3176925778388977,
-0.2982645034790039,
-0.21610617637634277,
-0.26299071311950684,
0.34805241227149963,
-0.1903076171875,
-0.21428370475769043,
-0.5010801553726196,
0.16317185759544373,
-0.26710155606269836,
0.5392854809761047,
0.5804516077041626,
0.08833209425210953,
-0.5554637312889099,
0.7304149866104126,
0.13354332745075226,
0.2939113676548004,
-0.28616443276405334,
0.0841595008969307,
-0.3138086795806885,
-0.5026459693908691,
-0.8956863880157471,
0.5071156620979309,
-0.9141649007797241,
-0.3301680386066437,
-0.3896760046482086,
0.01307961717247963,
-0.12345458567142487,
-0.1921619027853012,
-0.4318365752696991,
-0.32622140645980835,
-0.7967822551727295,
-0.5172380208969116,
0.6316633224487305,
1.1515541076660156,
-0.2572218179702759,
0.7588952779769897,
-0.83859783411026,
-0.08216764777898788,
0.3118785619735718,
0.1441950649023056,
-0.03274480625987053,
-0.8200559020042419,
0.03388622775673866,
0.13030701875686646,
-0.487456738948822,
-0.9270957708358765,
0.5760592818260193,
0.6169600486755371,
0.22514058649539948,
0.13620229065418243,
-0.5285515785217285,
1.0043333768844604,
-0.8789042830467224,
0.8791925311088562,
0.14638136327266693,
-1.107160210609436,
0.7136175036430359,
-0.4736260771751404,
-0.1630883663892746,
0.2332613170146942,
-0.14596819877624512,
-0.714165449142456,
-0.11936085671186447,
-0.7810333967208862,
-0.737899124622345,
0.6308589577674866,
0.02036849595606327,
0.4353945255279541,
-0.38381144404411316,
0.693099856376648,
0.09524203091859818,
0.04185815528035164,
-0.9141336679458618,
0.1778266280889511,
0.1350490301847458,
-0.435886412858963,
-0.2669450640678406,
-0.38622307777404785,
-0.022147418931126595,
-0.04545361548662186,
1.0541868209838867,
-0.4320868253707886,
-0.02754507213830948,
0.3784608244895935,
-0.18660442531108856,
-0.7890311479568481,
0.41385316848754883,
0.8602328896522522,
0.45699888467788696,
0.3985444903373718,
0.03447122126817703,
0.9032564759254456,
-0.378286749124527,
0.4301162362098694,
-0.09336019307374954,
-0.306122362613678,
0.0638413280248642,
0.35434091091156006,
0.714815616607666,
0.18905852735042572,
-0.9267095923423767,
0.10123990476131439,
0.2303106188774109,
-0.02172384038567543,
-0.4848565459251404,
0.19911590218544006,
0.2698560655117035,
0.15454727411270142,
0.15306812524795532,
0.3795243501663208,
-0.17866575717926025,
-0.3525078594684601,
-0.017121685668826103,
0.06275693327188492,
0.0453253798186779,
-0.6687933802604675,
0.8675085306167603,
0.3189256489276886,
-0.5764985084533691,
0.43886274099349976,
-0.1993981897830963,
-0.5725862979888916,
0.6871412992477417,
0.81574946641922,
0.6852557063102722,
-0.4959816336631775,
0.20803068578243256,
0.37240317463874817,
0.3430279791355133,
-0.5457855463027954,
0.3771439492702484,
0.423236221075058,
-0.8417806029319763,
-0.6558932662010193,
-0.6141453385353088,
-0.2806277573108673,
-0.11590255051851273,
-0.1909765750169754,
0.4317556917667389,
-0.5352981090545654,
-0.21577315032482147,
-0.3448133170604706,
-0.4813467264175415,
-0.46454671025276184,
0.2545349597930908,
0.28173765540122986,
0.4117552936077118,
-0.7917259335517883,
0.49633991718292236,
0.9586244225502014,
-0.21301379799842834,
-1.039139747619629,
-0.27870628237724304,
0.15194527804851532,
-0.871117353439331,
0.6441381573677063,
-0.0299469456076622,
-0.37274467945098877,
-0.03643424063920975,
-0.4500228762626648,
-0.677362859249115,
0.9316569566726685,
0.5803171992301941,
-1.1301242113113403,
-0.20519648492336273,
0.4880655109882355,
0.7490496635437012,
-0.24656060338020325,
-0.12056335061788559,
0.9581937193870544,
0.27144789695739746,
-0.2710692882537842,
-1.0643974542617798,
-0.1460077464580536,
-0.13900887966156006,
0.24153929948806763,
-0.08486415445804596,
-0.6440037488937378,
0.9996996521949768,
-0.7378186583518982,
-0.3107696771621704,
0.29328200221061707,
0.6678186655044556,
0.28953513503074646,
0.12099526077508926,
0.40239712595939636,
0.7083557844161987,
1.1466429233551025,
-0.17611311376094818,
1.2160847187042236,
0.17748358845710754,
0.07824420183897018,
1.115331768989563,
-0.264295756816864,
1.0639771223068237,
0.6049849987030029,
-0.4608926475048065,
0.6754024624824524,
0.7551317811012268,
0.12635347247123718,
0.22264906764030457,
0.41790342330932617,
-0.34701499342918396,
-0.14647218585014343,
0.17872244119644165,
-0.04662929102778435,
0.434343546628952,
0.6342539191246033,
-0.4626385569572449,
-0.02621202915906906,
-0.3002399206161499,
0.3453354239463806,
0.4735561013221741,
-0.4195515215396881,
0.7516399621963501,
0.06796399503946304,
-0.7688258290290833,
0.6904518008232117,
0.29723110795021057,
1.0351351499557495,
-0.3392534554004669,
-0.19594167172908783,
-0.29485809803009033,
0.4245266616344452,
-0.364882230758667,
-0.26055097579956055,
0.11493225395679474,
0.5186001062393188,
-0.07521406561136246,
0.5117886662483215,
0.9048622846603394,
-0.4020935297012329,
-0.7876871824264526,
0.26107069849967957,
0.40233930945396423,
0.08915520459413528,
0.22005850076675415,
-0.2993277907371521,
0.005329405888915062,
0.10395878553390503,
0.03495687246322632,
-0.13432273268699646,
0.036627162247896194,
-0.3475097417831421,
0.6903717517852783,
0.7284742593765259,
0.4161629378795624,
0.4774336516857147,
-0.043896496295928955,
0.5870063304901123,
-0.6550869941711426,
-0.43616625666618347,
-1.1088957786560059,
0.5751649737358093,
0.22999440133571625,
-0.3116059899330139,
0.3830215632915497,
0.09493029862642288,
1.1171643733978271,
-0.4637291431427002,
1.0540798902511597,
0.19062824547290802,
0.5085574984550476,
-0.6465161442756653,
0.35581114888191223,
-0.35568001866340637,
0.5809751749038696,
-0.22645124793052673,
-0.6984342932701111,
-0.2652200758457184,
0.87083899974823,
-0.16470295190811157,
0.010668810456991196,
0.27961209416389465,
1.171626329421997,
0.287508100271225,
-0.05349646508693695,
0.3029157221317291,
0.35340186953544617,
0.3028395175933838,
0.47914624214172363,
1.1406092643737793,
-0.6392490863800049,
0.3674301207065582,
-0.09088214486837387,
0.015678975731134415,
-0.24084489047527313,
-0.7926726937294006,
-0.6009932160377502,
-0.08994979411363602,
-0.3292304575443268,
-0.5682594180107117,
0.5313742756843567,
1.3023958206176758,
0.3007121980190277,
-0.804057776927948,
-0.26598307490348816,
-0.45501014590263367,
-0.19890636205673218,
0.09213846176862717,
-0.13339805603027344,
0.22301192581653595,
-0.5889156460762024,
-0.9043912887573242,
0.46322640776634216,
-0.022330578416585922,
0.6560257077217102,
0.07443809509277344,
-0.6787033081054688,
0.019360674545168877,
0.35033220052719116,
0.5927244424819946,
0.43617483973503113,
-1.0877940654754639,
-0.5899638533592224,
-0.018210574984550476,
-0.05209612473845482,
0.2001371681690216,
0.503247857093811,
-0.7102692127227783,
0.3229304850101471,
0.10114791244268417,
0.7778513431549072,
-0.15573233366012573,
0.0752183198928833,
0.809958279132843,
-0.8772025108337402,
0.17132776975631714,
0.055299386382102966,
0.559249222278595,
0.8003503084182739,
-0.50611811876297,
0.7104147672653198,
0.3531959056854248,
-0.5105056166648865,
-0.6399887204170227,
-0.11903534829616547,
-0.5723124742507935,
0.11497261375188828,
1.3121460676193237,
-0.11172622442245483,
-0.40696021914482117,
0.15322844684123993,
-0.6540161371231079,
0.33378785848617554,
-0.23897649347782135,
1.1756362915039062,
0.9926224946975708,
-0.054547347128391266,
0.17468106746673584,
-0.733218789100647,
0.7639709115028381,
0.831960916519165,
-1.0899879932403564,
-0.03623443841934204,
0.7875282764434814,
0.5300366878509521,
0.19783367216587067,
0.3702015280723572,
-0.1404585987329483,
0.7935337424278259,
0.030785206705331802,
0.2787270247936249,
0.14215120673179626,
-0.32166188955307007,
-0.663032054901123,
-0.5614961385726929,
0.47183260321617126,
-0.09227155148983002
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.05488v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.05488v1
|
FFSTC: Fongbe to French Speech Translation Corpus
| 2024-03-08T17:53:58 | 2024-03-08T17:53:58 |
D. Fortune Kponou, Frejus A. A. Laleye, Eugene C. Ezin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this paper, we introduce the Fongbe to French Speech Translation Corpus
(FFSTC) for the first time. This corpus encompasses approximately 31 hours of
collected Fongbe language content, featuring both French transcriptions and
corresponding Fongbe voice recordings. FFSTC represents a comprehensive dataset
compiled through various collection methods and the efforts of dedicated
individuals. Furthermore, we conduct baseline experiments using Fairseq's
transformer_s and conformer models to evaluate data quality and validity. Our
results indicate a score of 8.96 for the transformer_s model and 8.14 for the
conformer model, establishing a baseline for the FFSTC corpus.
|
[
-0.28423452377319336,
-0.5336686968803406,
0.3971860408782959,
0.4253855347633362,
-0.14333954453468323,
0.03141789883375168,
-0.216257706284523,
-0.2767488956451416,
-0.12302687019109726,
0.5746093988418579,
-0.5567976832389832,
-0.5108240842819214,
-0.8262382745742798,
0.3651163578033447,
-1.0088518857955933,
0.8311218023300171,
0.19721178710460663,
-0.14907719194889069,
0.2091887891292572,
-0.05522114410996437,
-0.1389935314655304,
-0.24950164556503296,
-0.8875162601470947,
0.00081675685942173,
0.3155142664909363,
0.3886758089065552,
0.7860279679298401,
0.1518680900335312,
0.14673365652561188,
0.24099141359329224,
-0.0819859430193901,
-0.06962428987026215,
-0.8153425455093384,
-0.41400229930877686,
-0.21561338007450104,
-0.4652005434036255,
-0.4235992133617401,
0.03172535076737404,
0.8368797302246094,
0.5000626444816589,
-0.1873445063829422,
0.1721380352973938,
-0.0177244171500206,
0.46062174439430237,
-0.27887606620788574,
0.34145277738571167,
-0.39756301045417786,
-0.08485924452543259,
-0.31344178318977356,
-0.1357550024986267,
-0.7651669979095459,
-0.601184070110321,
-0.06614242494106293,
-0.36764541268348694,
0.2533988058567047,
-0.28137505054473877,
0.6435248255729675,
0.13174673914909363,
-0.8852042555809021,
-0.11579734832048416,
-0.9227436184883118,
0.8871793746948242,
-0.548338770866394,
0.9389629364013672,
0.4070311188697815,
0.4945265054702759,
-0.04051414504647255,
-1.2175047397613525,
-0.722394585609436,
-0.10783636569976807,
0.05357475206255913,
0.15851250290870667,
-0.6023502349853516,
-0.1527208387851715,
0.027684662491083145,
0.6347203254699707,
-0.6448733806610107,
-0.19200246036052704,
-0.8043308258056641,
-0.4187641441822052,
0.8731830716133118,
-0.053010474890470505,
0.24167780578136444,
-0.11957620084285736,
-0.35097041726112366,
-0.289323091506958,
-0.2928365468978882,
0.24498075246810913,
0.19168421626091003,
0.5267758369445801,
-0.19231249392032623,
0.38886165618896484,
-0.14127184450626373,
0.5695202946662903,
0.017824847251176834,
-0.30046600103378296,
0.39181941747665405,
-0.5126856565475464,
-0.18095999956130981,
0.28768670558929443,
0.944539487361908,
0.5253469944000244,
0.3960861265659332,
-0.15251927077770233,
-0.3952491283416748,
-0.30182066559791565,
0.4745085537433624,
-0.8581894040107727,
-0.2562609612941742,
0.26688605546951294,
-0.5874220728874207,
-0.32389453053474426,
0.1661107987165451,
-0.6196348071098328,
0.30979999899864197,
-0.25963324308395386,
0.07505057007074356,
-0.48948368430137634,
-0.2084333896636963,
-0.19808270037174225,
0.27992987632751465,
0.47717520594596863,
0.4380311667919159,
-0.6746196150779724,
0.3442491888999939,
0.3776794970035553,
1.0051437616348267,
-0.4134272634983063,
-0.10329298675060272,
-0.6833921074867249,
-0.30634620785713196,
-0.45878836512565613,
0.6179926991462708,
-0.17883677780628204,
-0.945655107498169,
0.18766823410987854,
0.7161178588867188,
-0.07492108643054962,
-0.2493250072002411,
1.1181533336639404,
-0.38961830735206604,
0.08747141808271408,
0.12229751795530319,
-0.6698589324951172,
-0.2613914906978607,
-0.5563892126083374,
-0.9926108717918396,
0.9478204250335693,
0.7766044735908508,
-0.3578890562057495,
0.02652091532945633,
-0.18676507472991943,
-0.5214536786079407,
0.051148559898138046,
-0.025624770671129227,
0.01798880100250244,
0.025882381945848465,
0.3554404079914093,
0.5044968128204346,
-0.5109054446220398,
0.2894475758075714,
0.22739015519618988,
-0.212874174118042,
0.5726982951164246,
-0.5327060222625732,
0.9527449607849121,
0.7188770771026611,
-0.0006689965957775712,
-0.09040152281522751,
-0.6258043646812439,
0.03270166367292404,
0.18725979328155518,
-0.17935991287231445,
0.18358474969863892,
-0.27611401677131653,
0.5694223046302795,
0.35932740569114685,
-0.08040881156921387,
-0.7304151058197021,
-0.23956824839115143,
-0.4019850790500641,
0.8171671032905579,
0.5094746947288513,
-0.04826769977807999,
0.5354753732681274,
-0.44338542222976685,
0.5021603107452393,
-0.23976287245750427,
0.016762783750891685,
-0.042694319039583206,
-0.6260135769844055,
0.03231120482087135,
-0.08363158255815506,
0.5691027641296387,
0.8769254684448242,
-0.5855669975280762,
0.3823772668838501,
-0.5475075244903564,
-0.6184489727020264,
-0.633881151676178,
-0.3301279842853546,
0.0060875304043293,
0.3984330892562866,
0.5630791187286377,
-0.08486364036798477,
-0.052851352840662,
-0.8801527619361877,
0.006997869815677404,
-0.10983525961637497,
-0.4860687851905823,
0.33432334661483765,
0.33250728249549866,
-0.17732571065425873,
0.6047824025154114,
-0.3383222222328186,
-0.2680746018886566,
-0.25628113746643066,
-0.06239283084869385,
0.31273022294044495,
0.501876175403595,
1.085107684135437,
-0.8038669228553772,
-0.30144864320755005,
-0.15099522471427917,
-0.20713257789611816,
-0.2603835463523865,
-0.13580825924873352,
-0.14406588673591614,
0.08057807385921478,
0.6822261214256287,
-0.0850803405046463,
0.5364339351654053,
0.860083818435669,
-0.17008699476718903,
0.3767196834087372,
0.35461243987083435,
0.820953905582428,
-1.0951735973358154,
0.08787702023983002,
-0.15526610612869263,
-0.6537840962409973,
-0.6680285334587097,
-0.40722033381462097,
0.05394156277179718,
-0.12058009952306747,
-0.7693713307380676,
0.7403287291526794,
0.18366000056266785,
0.39157673716545105,
-0.1122063547372818,
0.3712049424648285,
-0.1126888170838356,
0.2778654396533966,
0.025085289031267166,
0.9688634276390076,
0.12753446400165558,
-0.45394784212112427,
0.4915284812450409,
0.6984060406684875,
-0.4073399305343628,
0.5793431997299194,
-0.7112341523170471,
0.08390229195356369,
0.3648715615272522,
0.26764217019081116,
-1.1702055931091309,
-0.22324857115745544,
0.08383727073669434,
-0.7787702679634094,
0.2122219204902649,
-0.0322384275496006,
-0.17447473108768463,
-0.41432181000709534,
0.13200317323207855,
0.5001451373100281,
0.5212397575378418,
-0.5018166899681091,
0.259866327047348,
0.48766133189201355,
-0.4860207736492157,
-0.3069017827510834,
-1.1979856491088867,
-0.14250938594341278,
0.07485014945268631,
-0.7832993865013123,
0.6640720963478088,
0.11843454837799072,
0.09321647137403488,
-0.25773659348487854,
-0.3455175757408142,
-0.2905339300632477,
-0.38066747784614563,
0.04452478885650635,
-0.0014944362919777632,
-0.5943112373352051,
0.004457702860236168,
0.2752859890460968,
0.05225934460759163,
0.020035410299897194,
-0.3968524634838104,
0.31505605578422546,
-0.12224877625703812,
-0.08109331130981445,
-0.5581572651863098,
0.5027387738227844,
0.35286372900009155,
-0.05818747356534004,
0.7152976393699646,
0.5339797139167786,
-0.39304158091545105,
-0.07345539331436157,
-0.4055575430393219,
-0.22551928460597992,
-0.3942541778087616,
0.19262786209583282,
-0.5928210616111755,
-1.085611343383789,
0.4505264163017273,
-0.25350984930992126,
0.08834446966648102,
0.563489556312561,
0.5112550854682922,
0.017381614074110985,
0.5635673403739929,
0.4112222194671631,
-0.1675489991903305,
0.5379884243011475,
-0.07036817818880081,
0.16880029439926147,
-0.4607135057449341,
0.07782916724681854,
-0.680945634841919,
-0.027361463755369186,
-0.6499488353729248,
-0.7318331003189087,
-0.046547263860702515,
0.3437768816947937,
-0.045712199062108994,
0.5957227349281311,
-0.3692636787891388,
0.17039307951927185,
0.3535867929458618,
0.09936826676130295,
0.3171482980251312,
0.01333355251699686,
-0.034996211528778076,
-0.1377885490655899,
-0.4944605529308319,
-0.7115362882614136,
1.1002110242843628,
0.4161408841609955,
0.32941001653671265,
0.22277432680130005,
0.4526114761829376,
0.2820771038532257,
0.08781275898218155,
-0.7044344544410706,
0.2937527596950531,
-0.616022527217865,
-0.6117479205131531,
-0.4040822684764862,
-0.43287959694862366,
-0.80757075548172,
-0.04739346727728844,
-0.0012307798024266958,
-0.8030538558959961,
0.3264995515346527,
-0.07646459341049194,
-0.4131655991077423,
0.233350470662117,
-0.30590611696243286,
1.0688399076461792,
-0.13919632136821747,
-0.2624465823173523,
-0.041239965707063675,
-0.6945422887802124,
0.4070768654346466,
-0.08793745189905167,
0.35326844453811646,
-0.06876790523529053,
0.2256629467010498,
0.6808490753173828,
-0.33002185821533203,
0.2548406720161438,
0.04776515066623688,
-0.38303157687187195,
0.5816542506217957,
0.13145674765110016,
0.367309033870697,
0.49130430817604065,
-0.2509981393814087,
0.4577527344226837,
0.317828893661499,
-0.45976248383522034,
-0.27522268891334534,
0.4490008056163788,
-0.6509385108947754,
0.004009876865893602,
-0.34791967272758484,
-0.20598925650119781,
-0.0915047898888588,
0.0953567698597908,
0.4857475757598877,
0.4442217946052551,
-0.9469757080078125,
0.5519536137580872,
0.50433748960495,
-0.28517597913742065,
0.15049748122692108,
0.48097437620162964,
-0.5221014618873596,
-0.5631231069564819,
0.6013736724853516,
-0.1437012404203415,
0.35642650723457336,
0.6278883814811707,
-0.04267878457903862,
-0.5018569231033325,
-0.48251160979270935,
-0.4707128405570984,
0.2788126766681671,
-0.552466869354248,
-0.21229957044124603,
-0.6466706991195679,
-0.5876787304878235,
-0.8233584761619568,
-0.18015016615390778,
-0.6432852149009705,
-0.5611162781715393,
-0.2232855260372162,
-0.28155821561813354,
0.518467128276825,
0.29128900170326233,
-0.2291724681854248,
0.7019339799880981,
-1.198610782623291,
0.4570218324661255,
0.19016872346401215,
-0.09503048658370972,
-0.5476359724998474,
-0.9130541086196899,
-0.08929666131734848,
0.39321714639663696,
-0.013712258078157902,
-1.039405345916748,
0.40681517124176025,
0.3110972046852112,
0.5775905251502991,
0.16614730656147003,
0.16029365360736847,
0.1078604981303215,
-0.5862938165664673,
1.088098168373108,
0.11042475700378418,
-1.1391664743423462,
0.6948400139808655,
-0.31646597385406494,
0.38599979877471924,
0.4300139844417572,
0.453962504863739,
-0.7367280125617981,
-0.3577801287174225,
-0.5629454255104065,
-0.8208192586898804,
0.9580146074295044,
0.7553899884223938,
-0.10842974483966827,
-0.02562471479177475,
0.33671656250953674,
0.11116956174373627,
0.25310125946998596,
-0.30628347396850586,
-0.23275761306285858,
-0.5958139300346375,
-0.12004465609788895,
-0.40792015194892883,
-0.0689825639128685,
-0.16042612493038177,
-0.22240972518920898,
0.5770968198776245,
-0.17889685928821564,
0.5786296129226685,
0.30861523747444153,
-0.1817575991153717,
-0.022264746949076653,
0.4240637421607971,
0.7395191788673401,
0.3314286172389984,
-0.16713286936283112,
-0.18321706354618073,
0.3855817914009094,
-0.6778711676597595,
0.050763003528118134,
0.34926196932792664,
0.04206632077693939,
0.14389537274837494,
0.4786060154438019,
0.8921449780464172,
0.23749326169490814,
-0.519598662853241,
0.6076667904853821,
-0.18447628617286682,
-0.443606972694397,
-0.3786087930202484,
-0.011367090046405792,
0.2522706091403961,
0.25152701139450073,
0.23344403505325317,
-0.04923897609114647,
0.07467534393072128,
-0.21766184270381927,
0.7009240984916687,
-0.2776830792427063,
-0.6198314428329468,
-0.2470753788948059,
0.9526036381721497,
0.25522518157958984,
0.07485026866197586,
0.8224892616271973,
-0.03034842759370804,
-0.20644797384738922,
0.39375755190849304,
0.34605512022972107,
0.9723640084266663,
-0.9686010479927063,
0.3996504843235016,
0.7237896919250488,
0.5354192852973938,
-0.14390221238136292,
0.31990012526512146,
-0.040388911962509155,
-0.5047328472137451,
-0.4651055335998535,
-0.9314212799072266,
-0.11358579993247986,
-0.006218532100319862,
-0.8856342434883118,
0.1548025757074356,
0.27451092004776,
-0.24751919507980347,
-0.00157528358977288,
-0.2842702865600586,
-0.6028205156326294,
0.297934889793396,
0.10281920433044434,
0.9754501581192017,
-0.7655787467956543,
1.3249375820159912,
0.3266422152519226,
-0.4457648694515228,
-1.015263319015503,
-0.054262109100818634,
0.1322813481092453,
-0.47884562611579895,
0.5104475021362305,
-0.21646712720394135,
-0.35120001435279846,
0.24344411492347717,
-0.3947080969810486,
-0.5687553882598877,
1.120881199836731,
0.32172486186027527,
-0.921002209186554,
0.14393529295921326,
0.48087260127067566,
0.43663328886032104,
-0.5234147310256958,
0.09969054162502289,
0.884209394454956,
0.4579748511314392,
0.1483573466539383,
-1.3364266157150269,
-0.0426098108291626,
-0.016540318727493286,
-0.056705292314291,
-0.10276494175195694,
-0.6843237280845642,
1.01996648311615,
0.0727580264210701,
-0.4989875853061676,
0.15367001295089722,
0.9045714139938354,
-0.20818400382995605,
0.21203722059726715,
0.5975030660629272,
0.022881140932440758,
0.7541654109954834,
-0.3058933615684509,
0.8728161454200745,
-0.32980892062187195,
0.3778180480003357,
1.203914761543274,
-0.18753525614738464,
0.8238497972488403,
0.22074554860591888,
-0.5758082866668701,
0.057607028633356094,
0.5052153468132019,
0.18838053941726685,
0.5293757319450378,
0.17974057793617249,
-0.22302281856536865,
-0.18093623220920563,
-0.06319744884967804,
-0.44454121589660645,
0.44416844844818115,
0.6236302852630615,
-0.36798617243766785,
0.007143632508814335,
0.2909572720527649,
-0.1846865564584732,
0.2417408972978592,
-0.1440795511007309,
0.583415150642395,
0.5993496775627136,
-0.3737308382987976,
0.7072997689247131,
-0.09524000436067581,
0.3059847354888916,
-0.49180611968040466,
0.15758752822875977,
-0.21073676645755768,
0.15729831159114838,
-0.2443169355392456,
-1.0413233041763306,
0.6738694906234741,
-0.07243844121694565,
-0.0868694931268692,
-0.33321693539619446,
0.47421586513519287,
-0.65108323097229,
-0.35219770669937134,
0.5530637502670288,
0.6159647107124329,
0.2733277380466461,
-0.22847770154476166,
-0.5716780424118042,
0.017047960311174393,
0.4213480055332184,
-0.12894080579280853,
-0.06349379569292068,
0.5591577887535095,
-0.005145454313606024,
0.24905502796173096,
0.4286448657512665,
-0.101840540766716,
0.26101016998291016,
0.08843369781970978,
0.5535771250724792,
-0.638276994228363,
-0.40230655670166016,
-0.2477327436208725,
0.420170396566391,
0.09848661720752716,
-0.3280245065689087,
0.344343364238739,
0.5207658410072327,
1.0590574741363525,
-0.3532070815563202,
0.8367339372634888,
-0.13781748712062836,
0.7424688935279846,
-0.6753509640693665,
0.6132947206497192,
-0.5994619727134705,
-0.14348579943180084,
-0.33578941226005554,
-0.8318684101104736,
0.0014446028508245945,
0.8704532980918884,
-0.007535058539360762,
-0.33781254291534424,
0.9285063743591309,
0.7862705588340759,
-0.19227713346481323,
0.6701071262359619,
0.42341428995132446,
0.18463099002838135,
0.3556477427482605,
0.705333948135376,
0.6667482256889343,
-0.9396145343780518,
0.7769644856452942,
-0.5749943852424622,
-0.21818898618221283,
-0.25381141901016235,
-0.6064624786376953,
-0.5792484283447266,
-0.9233911037445068,
-0.41215190291404724,
-0.594730019569397,
-0.023791596293449402,
0.8539307713508606,
0.3358811140060425,
-1.4116921424865723,
-0.3882586359977722,
0.16558405756950378,
-0.16544510424137115,
-0.4935624301433563,
-0.3059970736503601,
0.23930880427360535,
-0.0066255806013941765,
-1.1183671951293945,
0.7049492001533508,
-0.21024399995803833,
0.19509494304656982,
0.22315233945846558,
-0.10021379590034485,
-0.3064389228820801,
0.1457725465297699,
0.6732686161994934,
0.24136827886104584,
-0.7371059656143188,
-0.4205301105976105,
0.20562098920345306,
-0.3086335361003876,
0.024569282308220863,
0.9965746998786926,
-0.4381089210510254,
0.21244220435619354,
0.7044007182121277,
0.41067489981651306,
0.6721257567405701,
-0.040610674768686295,
0.9286344647407532,
-0.8025361895561218,
0.39511367678642273,
0.45183420181274414,
0.2936423718929291,
0.06305284053087234,
-0.02213098295032978,
0.6962705850601196,
-0.033732153475284576,
-0.8415302634239197,
-0.7255805730819702,
0.07402738183736801,
-1.3608818054199219,
-0.13840804994106293,
0.9056154489517212,
-0.20178693532943726,
-0.19899065792560577,
0.007212447933852673,
-0.337597519159317,
0.6155298948287964,
-0.8254146575927734,
0.055078499019145966,
0.773212730884552,
0.08555474877357483,
-0.13096286356449127,
-1.253018856048584,
0.7272750735282898,
-0.058759041130542755,
-0.3578760027885437,
0.033212337642908096,
0.47741398215293884,
0.2098427414894104,
0.2257346659898758,
0.7926141619682312,
-0.43791162967681885,
0.27499935030937195,
0.23912407457828522,
-0.04682724177837372,
0.47056832909584045,
-0.15694944560527802,
-0.30677348375320435,
0.20848865807056427,
-0.2625660300254822,
-0.06664490699768066
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.05468v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.05468v1
|
Will GPT-4 Run DOOM?
| 2024-03-08T17:30:41 | 2024-03-08T17:30:41 |
Adrian de Wynter
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV
|
We show that GPT-4's reasoning and planning capabilities extend to the 1993
first-person shooter Doom. This large language model (LLM) is able to run and
play the game with only a few instructions, plus a textual
description--generated by the model itself from screenshots--about the state of
the game being observed. We find that GPT-4 can play the game to a passable
degree: it is able to manipulate doors, combat enemies, and perform pathing.
More complex prompting strategies involving multiple model calls provide better
results. While further work is required to enable the LLM to play the game as
well as its classical, reinforcement learning-based counterparts, we note that
GPT-4 required no training, leaning instead on its own reasoning and
observational capabilities. We hope our work pushes the boundaries on
intelligent, LLM-based agents in video games. We conclude by discussing the
ethical implications of our work.
|
[
-0.28910231590270996,
-0.6960455775260925,
1.2597039937973022,
0.020463719964027405,
-0.18314236402511597,
0.002434792462736368,
-0.02885701321065426,
-0.44358429312705994,
-0.4832673668861389,
0.654573380947113,
-0.7818647623062134,
-0.36805060505867004,
-0.562726616859436,
0.23687787353992462,
0.06836598366498947,
1.3226546049118042,
0.09373249858617783,
-0.08441879600286484,
0.11221292614936829,
0.39496469497680664,
-0.4368494153022766,
-0.3837452828884125,
-0.8376612663269043,
-0.5072365403175354,
0.30080291628837585,
0.11665486544370651,
0.9096782803535461,
0.9131281971931458,
0.5011074542999268,
0.41550400853157043,
0.37774839997291565,
-0.5140184760093689,
-0.8688864707946777,
0.12506195902824402,
-0.4485529959201813,
-0.6866773962974548,
-0.19664722681045532,
0.16157767176628113,
0.5300447344779968,
-0.156747505068779,
0.08165495842695236,
-0.14500391483306885,
-0.20564432442188263,
0.08446647971868515,
0.0024121743626892567,
0.20103947818279266,
-0.2476395219564438,
0.0630265325307846,
-0.04804902523756027,
-0.23786883056163788,
-0.1272328794002533,
-0.23222683370113373,
0.10101532191038132,
-1.0081336498260498,
0.16226792335510254,
-0.06344494968652725,
0.5965715050697327,
0.6060185432434082,
-0.19354909658432007,
-0.16941329836845398,
-1.0714573860168457,
0.814081072807312,
-0.6508721709251404,
0.2078395038843155,
0.18152080476284027,
0.36996543407440186,
-0.4544091820716858,
-0.7460784912109375,
-0.3786062002182007,
-0.6573910713195801,
0.49643057584762573,
0.13312958180904388,
-0.4274698793888092,
0.5215937495231628,
0.8759013414382935,
0.23156596720218658,
-0.40086567401885986,
-0.10318517684936523,
-0.7078537344932556,
-0.16853968799114227,
0.5133721828460693,
0.2762365937232971,
0.4040133059024811,
0.09215528517961502,
-0.7386369705200195,
0.14927449822425842,
-0.5104294419288635,
0.16781629621982574,
0.6365986466407776,
0.14077763259410858,
-0.06155261769890785,
0.46652016043663025,
0.11618532240390778,
0.35218900442123413,
0.06620409339666367,
-0.46063244342803955,
-0.22176970541477203,
0.03854113817214966,
-0.1341366320848465,
0.1270226538181305,
0.7367932200431824,
0.36262398958206177,
0.328723669052124,
-0.3115171790122986,
-0.19711245596408844,
0.2384074181318283,
0.6720387935638428,
-0.7159873843193054,
-0.5052179098129272,
0.2118401676416397,
-0.2359866201877594,
-0.0992279127240181,
-0.15745866298675537,
-0.6976174116134644,
-0.4659203886985779,
-0.1588393747806549,
0.5824827551841736,
-0.7320607304573059,
-0.2364477664232254,
0.26390209794044495,
-0.31898483633995056,
0.3713986575603485,
0.23064203560352325,
-0.7471572756767273,
0.5448653101921082,
1.0327200889587402,
0.6572575569152832,
-0.16197063028812408,
-0.5400476455688477,
-0.4104231297969818,
0.45572102069854736,
-0.323606014251709,
0.6142486929893494,
-0.559333324432373,
-0.6940422654151917,
-0.4154003858566284,
-0.24954795837402344,
0.5516344308853149,
-0.11813940852880478,
0.5214319229125977,
-0.4016953408718109,
0.03766001760959625,
-0.5240959525108337,
-0.4537193179130554,
-0.3835315704345703,
0.5580334663391113,
-0.5625270009040833,
0.5113396048545837,
0.17681527137756348,
-0.7043218612670898,
0.40344974398612976,
-0.8231330513954163,
-0.6309873461723328,
0.3829820156097412,
-0.4720841646194458,
0.12788976728916168,
0.24505849182605743,
-0.023528262972831726,
-0.011143652722239494,
-0.34052523970603943,
0.04649502784013748,
-0.4781495928764343,
-0.6316216588020325,
-0.3073948323726654,
-0.4529842734336853,
0.7401884198188782,
0.09548241645097733,
-0.8442041873931885,
-0.13329683244228363,
-0.39797016978263855,
0.11969999223947525,
0.2755734324455261,
-0.3259020149707794,
0.10430116206407547,
0.3481003940105438,
-0.4422755539417267,
0.3737817704677582,
0.3306468427181244,
-0.5980409979820251,
0.403945654630661,
-0.1773892194032669,
0.3394392728805542,
0.8690324425697327,
0.047138676047325134,
0.40862196683883667,
-0.44215887784957886,
1.1402223110198975,
-0.5073065757751465,
0.4951719343662262,
0.1399175524711609,
-0.9107380509376526,
-0.22082048654556274,
-0.2768796384334564,
-0.2460867315530777,
0.9277076721191406,
-0.7832712531089783,
-0.3155701458454132,
0.05827685818076134,
-0.2695215940475464,
-0.0012858171248808503,
-0.3152834475040436,
0.41074514389038086,
0.41326451301574707,
0.25692611932754517,
-0.0663842111825943,
-0.5967568755149841,
-0.8486747145652771,
-0.3617747128009796,
-0.5629013776779175,
0.08292212337255478,
0.3784566819667816,
0.3572077751159668,
-0.16136135160923004,
0.8868672251701355,
-0.4739178419113159,
-0.030893957242369652,
-0.5976823568344116,
0.03146488592028618,
0.0979093462228775,
0.259021133184433,
0.38526272773742676,
-0.5695141553878784,
0.05565673112869263,
-0.10468074679374695,
-0.8294941782951355,
-0.09943118691444397,
0.07617221772670746,
-0.011585824191570282,
-0.36663636565208435,
0.25013917684555054,
-0.6738091111183167,
0.4066876769065857,
0.17312242090702057,
-0.18129870295524597,
0.5740402936935425,
-0.552948534488678,
0.32361409068107605,
-0.7730726599693298,
-0.25327566266059875,
-0.004529878031462431,
-0.19739742577075958,
-0.6664704084396362,
0.2537069022655487,
-0.5690099596977234,
-0.24409492313861847,
-0.26977717876434326,
0.5217284560203552,
-0.2668176293373108,
-0.43918272852897644,
-0.5180680751800537,
-0.01059835683554411,
-0.2582780122756958,
0.31155696511268616,
0.004548836965113878,
0.6831422448158264,
0.6587069034576416,
-0.7140526175498962,
0.5531907081604004,
0.028292149305343628,
-0.0839008316397667,
0.5460461378097534,
-0.6642526388168335,
0.20289058983325958,
0.013670578598976135,
0.2729742228984833,
-0.7035273313522339,
-0.2164580523967743,
0.35879769921302795,
-0.2660009264945984,
0.025669218972325325,
-0.13861580193042755,
-0.3089010715484619,
-0.48039570450782776,
0.02352900616824627,
0.23512545228004456,
0.6908881068229675,
-0.010164480656385422,
0.8289020657539368,
0.41508185863494873,
-0.070437952876091,
-0.4889172315597534,
-0.6895226836204529,
0.14221395552158356,
-0.4974183738231659,
-0.2948313057422638,
0.30474942922592163,
-0.131373792886734,
-0.41625767946243286,
-0.050940025597810745,
0.16932633519172668,
-0.11648206412792206,
0.05921731889247894,
0.527350902557373,
0.06968329101800919,
-0.15401816368103027,
-0.19289661943912506,
-0.396173894405365,
-0.23144099116325378,
0.24643589556217194,
-0.34251004457473755,
0.21602794528007507,
-0.3515370786190033,
-0.3132669925689697,
-0.22863830626010895,
0.4148055911064148,
0.43578723073005676,
-0.09665165841579437,
-0.26247745752334595,
0.3055427670478821,
-0.3409082889556885,
-0.16299334168434143,
-0.3745620548725128,
-0.20806798338890076,
-0.5055974125862122,
0.5074986219406128,
-0.4761650562286377,
-0.9682484865188599,
0.5452125668525696,
-0.16282470524311066,
0.08841012418270111,
0.280674546957016,
0.5648593306541443,
0.26839399337768555,
1.2278138399124146,
0.8751571774482727,
-0.06694484502077103,
0.12705473601818085,
-0.04291275143623352,
0.38549545407295227,
-0.37554240226745605,
-0.14245255291461945,
-0.1341352015733719,
-0.3358854055404663,
-0.8396491408348083,
-0.3866480886936188,
0.4073002338409424,
-0.20221760869026184,
-0.7724010944366455,
0.08721421658992767,
-0.6222037672996521,
0.6578518152236938,
0.6258785724639893,
0.11650532484054565,
0.35806944966316223,
-0.32578587532043457,
0.01906166970729828,
0.0020498447120189667,
-0.6037115454673767,
-0.6241025328636169,
0.8742191791534424,
0.5383185148239136,
0.8424338698387146,
0.2298348993062973,
0.9911839962005615,
0.1401098072528839,
0.32670480012893677,
-0.4729706346988678,
0.785509467124939,
0.151298388838768,
-1.1916759014129639,
-0.38865381479263306,
-0.35044190287590027,
-0.5939466953277588,
-0.13154925405979156,
0.17870962619781494,
-0.8418895602226257,
-0.2952161729335785,
-0.031924981623888016,
-0.8210994601249695,
0.4691694378852844,
-0.7500301599502563,
0.8398059010505676,
-0.6209161877632141,
-0.3550868630409241,
-0.05164390429854393,
-0.5912030935287476,
0.8051857948303223,
0.0690605416893959,
0.12935662269592285,
-0.11504451930522919,
-0.2554638385772705,
0.48987138271331787,
-0.0704774558544159,
0.5777541399002075,
-0.3231271207332611,
-0.22826173901557922,
0.5545376539230347,
0.49605968594551086,
0.442844957113266,
0.2587611675262451,
0.2663564383983612,
0.020427679643034935,
0.1360071897506714,
-0.16665399074554443,
-0.5348995327949524,
0.667539119720459,
-0.7128661870956421,
-0.9647577404975891,
-0.7860535383224487,
-0.8732519149780273,
-0.3126610219478607,
0.35010766983032227,
0.49614235758781433,
0.18546052277088165,
-0.5155069231987,
-0.37650009989738464,
0.5214671492576599,
-0.25282448530197144,
0.27236756682395935,
0.4854584038257599,
-0.3944408893585205,
-0.19687378406524658,
0.7757323980331421,
-0.0308463666588068,
0.11217370629310608,
0.016044067218899727,
0.33640915155410767,
-0.45723801851272583,
-0.5506675839424133,
-0.2997521162033081,
0.08756913244724274,
-0.5220929384231567,
0.09958649426698685,
-0.4600546360015869,
0.17418111860752106,
0.05221064016222954,
-0.12689200043678284,
-0.26431217789649963,
0.08936041593551636,
-0.12344466894865036,
-0.2810485064983368,
0.42218852043151855,
1.4992916584014893,
-0.38739335536956787,
0.2841920852661133,
-0.39356157183647156,
0.441027969121933,
0.4755348861217499,
0.544349193572998,
-0.3920050859451294,
-0.31856513023376465,
0.1770225614309311,
-0.05930256471037865,
-0.44545823335647583,
-0.939719021320343,
-0.020757852122187614,
-0.06006501987576485,
0.5566049218177795,
0.33972397446632385,
-0.09418626874685287,
0.5112103223800659,
-1.0045287609100342,
1.022625207901001,
0.0964084342122078,
-0.7800484299659729,
0.3734460473060608,
-0.8924486637115479,
0.2931584119796753,
0.5251126885414124,
0.41536951065063477,
0.08346837759017944,
-0.4679347276687622,
-0.9411394000053406,
-0.07324244827032089,
0.9053442478179932,
0.0066574811935424805,
0.12860821187496185,
-0.17219939827919006,
0.468292236328125,
-0.01614629663527012,
0.1180952861905098,
-0.6623935103416443,
0.0406685471534729,
-0.25890448689460754,
0.1547764539718628,
-0.32207220792770386,
-0.11213754862546921,
-0.24013034999370575,
-0.1543162614107132,
0.40877634286880493,
0.08927659690380096,
0.5654551982879639,
0.09575183689594269,
0.4083220064640045,
-0.09065623581409454,
0.19767704606056213,
0.7370803952217102,
0.7768983244895935,
-0.1274813711643219,
0.11073045432567596,
0.11853742599487305,
-0.6345616579055786,
0.5380530953407288,
0.34917205572128296,
-0.08049466460943222,
-0.3749234676361084,
0.14207424223423004,
0.7587945461273193,
0.5336713790893555,
-0.6576113700866699,
0.5607191324234009,
-0.037741124629974365,
-0.33331534266471863,
-0.15550091862678528,
0.31539711356163025,
-0.21372759342193604,
0.8931133151054382,
0.31233087182044983,
-0.18868063390254974,
0.27078208327293396,
-0.7624891400337219,
0.5055648684501648,
0.3916044533252716,
-0.3271036446094513,
-0.4584681987762451,
0.9725818037986755,
-0.2856127619743347,
-0.48297715187072754,
0.359468013048172,
-0.5071898698806763,
-0.8540757894515991,
0.49556708335876465,
0.8531782031059265,
0.8196633458137512,
-0.41038239002227783,
0.3510309159755707,
0.16994962096214294,
0.6374857425689697,
-0.5596903562545776,
0.5556913018226624,
0.2832290232181549,
-0.5291057825088501,
-0.7284207940101624,
-0.20402242243289948,
-0.5511349439620972,
0.24875931441783905,
-0.16931945085525513,
0.10625310242176056,
-0.8819175362586975,
-0.4305810034275055,
-0.35253551602363586,
0.07953104376792908,
-0.5815849900245667,
0.2732529938220978,
0.2756645679473877,
0.6059257388114929,
-0.43618160486221313,
0.44536471366882324,
0.5366281867027283,
-0.5819326043128967,
-1.0681774616241455,
0.055316537618637085,
-0.0056975120678544044,
-0.6006530523300171,
0.6253370642662048,
-0.020121784880757332,
-0.23067565262317657,
0.3884570300579071,
-0.9103394150733948,
-0.8162853717803955,
0.9996679425239563,
0.8350952863693237,
-0.24161234498023987,
-0.4211447834968567,
-0.04671969637274742,
0.4117491543292999,
-0.28601813316345215,
0.2238699197769165,
0.7028344869613647,
0.6019957661628723,
0.06510096043348312,
-0.7443543076515198,
-0.12468533217906952,
0.1582680642604828,
-0.18885982036590576,
0.041876744478940964,
-0.4694311022758484,
1.0895577669143677,
-0.7040299773216248,
-0.3246181011199951,
-0.047943245619535446,
0.6411678194999695,
0.4066828489303589,
0.20285315811634064,
0.3312914967536926,
0.8250995874404907,
0.56319659948349,
-0.21079200506210327,
1.5536389350891113,
-0.2722623944282532,
0.13834872841835022,
0.959847629070282,
-0.5853866338729858,
0.391824334859848,
0.028952408581972122,
-0.3445326089859009,
0.35977715253829956,
0.6020245552062988,
-0.009823065251111984,
0.5746151208877563,
0.1957164704799652,
-0.3306574821472168,
-0.36517277359962463,
0.2912733256816864,
-0.273396372795105,
0.5810663104057312,
0.1275596022605896,
-0.016621334478259087,
-0.5592814683914185,
0.12973490357398987,
-0.02461724728345871,
-0.23979289829730988,
-0.4489505887031555,
0.6141478419303894,
0.19435513019561768,
-0.708846390247345,
0.20071938633918762,
-0.042434047907590866,
0.400967538356781,
-0.7796220183372498,
-0.1595139354467392,
0.19921623170375824,
0.2417333424091339,
-0.01027179230004549,
-0.7722405195236206,
-0.1542401909828186,
0.19912739098072052,
-0.017779501155018806,
-0.024038827046751976,
0.6944907903671265,
0.004144849721342325,
-0.3429904878139496,
0.2772540748119354,
0.4516833424568176,
0.4712514579296112,
-0.17058458924293518,
-0.8457704186439514,
0.21814598143100739,
0.08392386138439178,
-0.12492813915014267,
0.287503182888031,
0.6613182425498962,
0.08319969475269318,
0.7056093215942383,
0.32013413310050964,
0.06868086755275726,
0.36557477712631226,
-0.32118192315101624,
0.6576981544494629,
-0.5799232125282288,
-0.793720006942749,
-1.0712889432907104,
0.23360702395439148,
0.10732202976942062,
-0.4376995861530304,
0.7107622027397156,
0.6666350960731506,
0.6183371543884277,
0.010639544576406479,
1.235310673713684,
-0.05233750119805336,
0.28747355937957764,
-0.32591718435287476,
0.24933581054210663,
-0.13902068138122559,
-0.002009271876886487,
-0.334384948015213,
-1.1107505559921265,
-0.141459122300148,
0.7625022530555725,
-0.7638616561889648,
0.5065143704414368,
0.5704972743988037,
0.4267224073410034,
-0.06671134382486343,
0.2523156404495239,
0.496621310710907,
0.129706472158432,
0.528749406337738,
0.9241841435432434,
1.0190300941467285,
-0.1465337723493576,
0.47842714190483093,
-0.07037584483623505,
-0.5756979584693909,
0.19271628558635712,
-0.9871448278427124,
-0.7221219539642334,
-0.31584763526916504,
0.026272324845194817,
-0.3161017596721649,
0.21784549951553345,
0.7298360466957092,
0.34102219343185425,
-0.16609390079975128,
-0.14441384375095367,
-0.27027225494384766,
-0.08042042702436447,
-0.2345876842737198,
-0.13346262276172638,
-0.07846208661794662,
-0.2418508678674698,
-0.6029204726219177,
0.6766088604927063,
0.5082144141197205,
-0.03068850375711918,
-0.5984461903572083,
-0.2608805000782013,
0.03829953819513321,
0.12191560864448547,
0.45134106278419495,
0.6640388369560242,
-0.8363271355628967,
-0.5695386528968811,
-0.12367493659257889,
0.08322835713624954,
0.0743863508105278,
1.098159909248352,
-0.6618014574050903,
0.4728834629058838,
0.15770946443080902,
0.6514574885368347,
0.3548794090747833,
0.2803475856781006,
1.0213927030563354,
-0.10358971357345581,
0.13036669790744781,
0.5890191197395325,
-0.03338516131043434,
0.17910327017307281,
-0.5768448114395142,
0.37472543120384216,
0.184699147939682,
-0.9381332397460938,
-0.5044493675231934,
0.49742990732192993,
-0.7661771774291992,
-0.13104316592216492,
1.424826979637146,
-0.012819764204323292,
-0.23922567069530487,
-0.3149929344654083,
-0.41031837463378906,
0.18112187087535858,
-0.397317111492157,
0.4385336637496948,
0.8572478890419006,
-0.4360927939414978,
-0.39902424812316895,
-1.3220504522323608,
1.0255459547042847,
-0.3176919221878052,
-0.6534444689750671,
-0.13670141994953156,
0.6118945479393005,
0.4331185221672058,
0.05663064867258072,
0.9907470345497131,
-0.13045817613601685,
0.40196534991264343,
0.08889331668615341,
0.08651759475469589,
-0.2472493052482605,
-0.3195798099040985,
-0.2494712471961975,
0.1358833760023117,
0.0888727605342865,
-0.0608389787375927
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.05434v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.05434v2
|
Cost-Performance Optimization for Processing Low-Resource Language Tasks Using Commercial LLMs
| 2024-03-08T16:37:36 | 2024-04-18T18:35:07 |
Arijit Nag, Animesh Mukherjee, Niloy Ganguly, Soumen Chakrabarti
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) exhibit impressive zero/few-shot inference and
generation quality for high-resource languages (HRLs). A few of them have been
trained on low-resource languages (LRLs) and give decent performance. Owing to
the prohibitive costs of training LLMs, they are usually used as a network
service, with the client charged by the count of input and output tokens. The
number of tokens strongly depends on the script and language, as well as the
LLM's subword vocabulary. We show that LRLs are at a pricing disadvantage,
because the well-known LLMs produce more tokens for LRLs than HRLs. This is
because most currently popular LLMs are optimized for HRL vocabularies. Our
objective is to level the playing field: reduce the cost of processing LRLs in
contemporary LLMs while ensuring that predictive and generative qualities are
not compromised. As means to reduce the number of tokens processed by the LLM,
we consider code-mixing, translation, and transliteration of LRLs to HRLs. We
perform an extensive study using the IndicXTREME classification and six
generative tasks dataset, covering 15 Indic and 3 other languages, while using
GPT-4 (one of the costliest LLM services released so far) as a commercial LLM.
We observe and analyze interesting patterns involving token count, cost, and
quality across a multitude of languages and tasks. We show that choosing the
best policy to interact with the LLM can reduce cost by 90% while giving better
or comparable performance compared to communicating with the LLM in the
original LRL.
|
[
-0.3936283588409424,
-0.4392183721065521,
0.20094546675682068,
0.21642504632472992,
-0.2794078290462494,
0.22395853698253632,
-0.4640699028968811,
-0.6220442652702332,
0.019499152898788452,
0.6843804717063904,
-0.5068212151527405,
-0.5231659412384033,
-0.22828488051891327,
0.20762352645397186,
0.03423783928155899,
0.7686974406242371,
-0.04237541928887367,
-0.04132738709449768,
-0.11085609346628189,
-0.2568908631801605,
-0.2080157995223999,
-0.6249175071716309,
-1.0038751363754272,
-0.42400631308555603,
0.7093572020530701,
0.3634258508682251,
0.5644142627716064,
0.8941753506660461,
0.6147770285606384,
0.2522909641265869,
-0.346510648727417,
0.3403960168361664,
-0.6435067653656006,
0.16876862943172455,
-0.03902001678943634,
-0.6253027319908142,
-0.3734566271305084,
-0.07664860039949417,
0.49390023946762085,
0.6727757453918457,
-0.1165948361158371,
0.37128978967666626,
0.06318291276693344,
0.7147945761680603,
-0.6890907883644104,
0.1340600997209549,
-0.7414444088935852,
0.13252075016498566,
-0.5410265326499939,
-0.3069485127925873,
-0.3830726742744446,
-0.1700872778892517,
-0.2015858292579651,
-0.38202932476997375,
0.048039063811302185,
0.2122318297624588,
0.6462278366088867,
0.39717286825180054,
0.15458431839942932,
-0.1629783660173416,
-0.6945914626121521,
0.9382750391960144,
-0.716401219367981,
0.35368576645851135,
0.26155540347099304,
-0.08182697743177414,
-0.08569667488336563,
-0.5040918588638306,
-0.36058488488197327,
-0.29089444875717163,
-0.014965868555009365,
0.028602683916687965,
-0.34079328179359436,
0.38077428936958313,
0.465304970741272,
0.4134025275707245,
-0.5744599103927612,
0.6394954323768616,
-0.32663148641586304,
-0.19729922711849213,
0.4266631007194519,
0.2791141867637634,
0.015452147461473942,
-0.013612314127385616,
-0.34926047921180725,
0.10752888023853302,
-1.0412161350250244,
0.19522811472415924,
0.48505622148513794,
0.4660632312297821,
-0.10469714552164078,
0.6224339604377747,
-0.29928675293922424,
0.4565497636795044,
-0.15963327884674072,
-0.40456247329711914,
0.04650257155299187,
-0.4500580132007599,
-0.32151180505752563,
-0.15453805029392242,
0.6360769271850586,
0.12550276517868042,
0.2519644796848297,
-0.24179373681545258,
-0.5102021098136902,
0.07946259528398514,
0.06589386612176895,
-0.7808799147605896,
0.30076882243156433,
0.06357449293136597,
-0.4929485321044922,
-0.232866108417511,
-0.7637391686439514,
-0.4431021213531494,
-0.22815699875354767,
-0.41851121187210083,
0.13573384284973145,
-0.22803498804569244,
0.06551077961921692,
-0.11984717845916748,
0.28155115246772766,
0.10382918268442154,
0.30742642283439636,
-0.771739661693573,
0.47402486205101013,
0.5979161262512207,
1.1068189144134521,
-0.28105971217155457,
0.03109232895076275,
-0.7956739068031311,
-0.08605269342660904,
-0.4498771131038666,
0.6534705758094788,
-0.22486776113510132,
-0.6136650443077087,
0.09328606724739075,
-0.3783026933670044,
0.08598435670137405,
-0.8511600494384766,
0.554415225982666,
-0.7597108483314514,
-0.07717853039503098,
-0.2881126403808594,
-0.5375386476516724,
0.24229146540164948,
0.17969857156276703,
-0.756226658821106,
0.9255689978599548,
0.16661660373210907,
-0.5062503814697266,
0.3366871178150177,
-0.757398247718811,
-0.5229679942131042,
0.5488744378089905,
-0.24402734637260437,
-0.1366066187620163,
0.09890074282884598,
-0.00731493579223752,
0.2533615827560425,
-0.709038496017456,
-0.16784913837909698,
0.051093894988298416,
-0.5014520883560181,
0.19237825274467468,
-0.44147321581840515,
0.49200439453125,
0.7703384757041931,
-0.23477087914943695,
0.05464772507548332,
-0.4925338327884674,
-0.012397912330925465,
-0.05152236670255661,
-0.8956336975097656,
-0.07048036903142929,
0.0431014709174633,
0.08924844861030579,
0.1051604226231575,
0.329822301864624,
-0.45071130990982056,
-0.014375374652445316,
-0.747678279876709,
0.3373318910598755,
0.7814100384712219,
-0.23726043105125427,
0.5256240367889404,
-0.1722525656223297,
0.8874297738075256,
-0.12076060473918915,
0.4263189136981964,
0.08843275159597397,
-0.26772087812423706,
-0.7631078362464905,
-0.4334336817264557,
0.04344767704606056,
0.29099223017692566,
-0.8908089399337769,
-0.11662459373474121,
-0.15324068069458008,
-0.2991982400417328,
-0.765769362449646,
0.47342583537101746,
0.6050660014152527,
0.26818791031837463,
0.1972580850124359,
-0.206603541970253,
-0.2742639183998108,
-1.016459345817566,
-0.3103705942630768,
-0.11577005684375763,
0.3029201328754425,
0.316695898771286,
0.04352186247706413,
0.11982381343841553,
0.8539772033691406,
-0.3874955475330353,
-0.20526935160160065,
-0.5751257538795471,
0.06584042310714722,
0.4964156150817871,
0.3376457691192627,
0.4620385468006134,
-0.5710399150848389,
-0.6590319871902466,
0.1981685310602188,
-0.1858844757080078,
-0.28808292746543884,
-0.011121168732643127,
0.047340698540210724,
0.8429252505302429,
0.40344852209091187,
-0.6211473345756531,
0.04976075887680054,
0.6910201907157898,
0.11769669502973557,
0.40222278237342834,
-0.3164057433605194,
-0.27290835976600647,
-0.6816940307617188,
0.12179715186357498,
0.08594436943531036,
-0.1905452460050583,
-0.4689960777759552,
0.21483369171619415,
-0.2991301417350769,
-0.2334076315164566,
-0.6539041996002197,
0.7150436043739319,
-0.5195871591567993,
-0.29871290922164917,
-0.2466987520456314,
-0.0030959041323512793,
-0.09593617916107178,
0.7099376320838928,
-0.04434407874941826,
1.3660573959350586,
0.26006069779396057,
-0.4663770794868469,
0.22475770115852356,
-0.2577284574508667,
-0.5130664110183716,
0.35186219215393066,
-0.5151676535606384,
0.07381980121135712,
-0.16081327199935913,
-0.1294219195842743,
-0.595527708530426,
0.21697548031806946,
0.21648728847503662,
-0.008188292384147644,
0.2679229974746704,
-0.41295406222343445,
-0.7500306963920593,
-0.16968949139118195,
-0.147102490067482,
0.45853886008262634,
0.7116405963897705,
-0.48050299286842346,
0.2250290811061859,
0.25917336344718933,
-0.06009513884782791,
-0.7205017805099487,
-0.725861668586731,
0.19679462909698486,
-0.28193429112434387,
-0.21875648200511932,
0.3701215982437134,
0.010894040577113628,
-0.1554674655199051,
0.13174223899841309,
-0.15514695644378662,
0.1339566707611084,
0.0347873717546463,
-0.0013661476550623775,
0.1852930337190628,
-0.23077507317066193,
-0.01290594507008791,
-0.27441734075546265,
-0.2627599835395813,
-0.26057395339012146,
-0.5584304928779602,
0.7510111927986145,
-0.0898759588599205,
-0.5323116779327393,
-0.403739869594574,
0.18138515949249268,
0.5986165404319763,
-0.2955252528190613,
0.6874688267707825,
0.5516894459724426,
-0.20656485855579376,
-0.28572967648506165,
-0.7093564867973328,
0.2406093180179596,
-0.5107569694519043,
0.4950923025608063,
-0.41472145915031433,
-0.9072602987289429,
0.4159672260284424,
0.03755718469619751,
0.19338560104370117,
0.20740796625614166,
0.6631712913513184,
-0.0683467909693718,
0.7338453531265259,
0.32061275839805603,
-0.32825979590415955,
0.5117399096488953,
-0.3419528603553772,
0.33548232913017273,
-0.5897786021232605,
-0.1634065806865692,
-0.5196068286895752,
-0.350452721118927,
-1.0586600303649902,
-0.7604820728302002,
0.5472310185432434,
0.07558974623680115,
-0.2931423485279083,
0.37463659048080444,
-0.4493754804134369,
0.6546855568885803,
0.8114381432533264,
-0.08512643724679947,
0.38650575280189514,
0.2535633146762848,
-0.05273330211639404,
0.029268281534314156,
-0.9017286896705627,
-0.49583494663238525,
0.8328946828842163,
0.4024254083633423,
1.1009234189987183,
0.17424340546131134,
0.8120943307876587,
0.2527610659599304,
0.3253428041934967,
-0.851136326789856,
0.6187562346458435,
-0.49622368812561035,
-0.2933467626571655,
-0.3403477966785431,
-0.7232077717781067,
-0.8675087094306946,
0.3186359703540802,
-0.05801995471119881,
-0.6136376261711121,
0.11392302811145782,
0.24054984748363495,
-0.24162253737449646,
0.39548084139823914,
-0.44903886318206787,
0.696800172328949,
-0.45554739236831665,
-0.4311407506465912,
-0.629337728023529,
-0.20121173560619354,
0.1487007886171341,
-0.040330976247787476,
0.20182697474956512,
-0.21857023239135742,
-0.2420511394739151,
0.5454264879226685,
-0.41017356514930725,
0.8614124655723572,
-0.0666550025343895,
-0.09225723892450333,
0.18490636348724365,
0.13676252961158752,
0.7270345687866211,
-0.25610804557800293,
-0.2094261795282364,
0.11175733804702759,
-0.106687992811203,
-0.4485606253147125,
-0.22159112989902496,
0.8457229137420654,
-0.7878910899162292,
-0.4752641022205353,
-0.12453953176736832,
-0.5574655532836914,
-0.16082961857318878,
0.08261808007955551,
0.4148555397987366,
0.4305184483528137,
0.004218431655317545,
-0.011171653866767883,
0.5064334869384766,
-0.4836037755012512,
0.5529271960258484,
0.21244224905967712,
0.0854637399315834,
-0.35786205530166626,
0.8871868252754211,
0.2300567626953125,
0.6132291555404663,
0.5360245108604431,
0.21034406125545502,
-0.42445260286331177,
-0.8882351517677307,
-0.2485353648662567,
0.2702125608921051,
-0.7630835175514221,
-0.363055020570755,
-0.44797149300575256,
-0.09951844811439514,
-0.08450689166784286,
-0.12773634493350983,
-0.5141084790229797,
-0.31037437915802,
-0.36906686425209045,
0.13157440721988678,
0.34144049882888794,
0.3162566125392914,
-0.049376230686903,
0.3885175883769989,
-0.7272266745567322,
-0.03678297623991966,
-0.05953308939933777,
0.5148516297340393,
0.13200609385967255,
-0.36637431383132935,
-0.6515589356422424,
-0.23248320817947388,
-0.24186824262142181,
-0.21155740320682526,
0.42410290241241455,
0.04155838117003441,
0.5637306571006775,
0.45203232765197754,
0.10589804500341415,
0.7369775176048279,
-0.4586159586906433,
0.6275381445884705,
0.42281749844551086,
-0.8973755836486816,
0.1259971261024475,
-0.103517547249794,
0.11190246045589447,
0.4203454852104187,
0.14656950533390045,
-0.7686173319816589,
-0.2937183678150177,
-0.3827471435070038,
-0.9391555786132812,
0.9548109769821167,
0.21726326644420624,
0.3152726888656616,
-0.1906026005744934,
0.44070926308631897,
-0.18916097283363342,
0.24433395266532898,
-0.6625346541404724,
-0.250759094953537,
0.367200642824173,
-0.13819782435894012,
0.08393824100494385,
-0.4087704122066498,
-0.14595021307468414,
0.10709645599126816,
0.4596990942955017,
-0.1285824030637741,
0.09784737229347229,
-0.17247283458709717,
-0.018598347902297974,
-0.1947312355041504,
0.2508115768432617,
0.6440200805664062,
0.3807825744152069,
0.008739957585930824,
0.10116755962371826,
0.39655712246894836,
-0.05095328763127327,
0.09525812417268753,
-0.34353765845298767,
-0.09774427115917206,
0.0009847203036770225,
0.4457916021347046,
0.9138280749320984,
0.10333454608917236,
-0.9077816009521484,
0.31924667954444885,
0.3200031518936157,
-0.005184543319046497,
-0.16508716344833374,
0.08125398308038712,
0.20715881884098053,
0.4663388431072235,
-0.007224203087389469,
-0.00618013646453619,
0.05943188816308975,
-0.28536999225616455,
-0.24365532398223877,
0.6387238502502441,
-0.017607633024454117,
-0.1978941261768341,
0.4392129182815552,
0.3936203718185425,
-0.30814066529273987,
0.47892409563064575,
-0.27818113565444946,
-0.37736865878105164,
0.4887638986110687,
0.46226754784584045,
0.834796667098999,
0.16612136363983154,
0.06848542392253876,
0.12125631421804428,
0.3395710289478302,
-0.11116517335176468,
0.21008440852165222,
-0.054443810135126114,
-0.7051302790641785,
-0.8408125638961792,
-0.8106978535652161,
-0.5844604969024658,
0.2688160836696625,
-0.46409446001052856,
0.20794153213500977,
-0.5003020167350769,
-0.42019280791282654,
-0.33527758717536926,
0.20124927163124084,
-1.0119898319244385,
-0.012904629111289978,
0.2823067009449005,
0.8383697867393494,
-0.351606547832489,
0.6845031976699829,
0.42168983817100525,
-0.5501865744590759,
-0.5814991593360901,
-0.249508798122406,
-0.2358911782503128,
-1.1107240915298462,
1.2625250816345215,
-0.2816420793533325,
-0.3442699909210205,
0.026032285764813423,
-0.1331445574760437,
-0.9271131753921509,
0.7788097858428955,
0.6769255995750427,
-0.765564501285553,
-0.20169468224048615,
0.5092464089393616,
0.4540538787841797,
-0.15010367333889008,
0.005482048261910677,
0.4475155174732208,
0.2961782217025757,
0.09143899381160736,
-0.9396957159042358,
-0.013706746511161327,
0.24266791343688965,
0.3952483832836151,
0.29390501976013184,
-0.5634775161743164,
0.8988962769508362,
-0.1654369980096817,
-0.5210206508636475,
0.029236260801553726,
0.2769290804862976,
0.21719267964363098,
0.11326605826616287,
0.4461408257484436,
0.3837493360042572,
0.6466955542564392,
0.11137563735246658,
1.0983179807662964,
-0.5031390190124512,
0.3860180377960205,
0.7359263300895691,
-0.4588293731212616,
0.7362169027328491,
0.6875691413879395,
-0.4186711609363556,
0.05913057178258896,
0.7362220287322998,
0.10557134449481964,
0.49344995617866516,
0.6158875823020935,
-0.46075356006622314,
-0.2002103328704834,
-0.4145323634147644,
0.021196404471993446,
0.28992393612861633,
0.031129179522395134,
-0.14636676013469696,
-0.2769940495491028,
-0.20018501579761505,
0.000845954054966569,
0.01487113256007433,
-0.31159597635269165,
0.7896167039871216,
0.16768018901348114,
-0.43039730191230774,
0.7760081887245178,
0.18950146436691284,
0.7715505957603455,
-0.4432312250137329,
0.3499424159526825,
-0.57984858751297,
0.09968782216310501,
-0.1202927678823471,
-0.4875304400920868,
0.2226027399301529,
0.3027927875518799,
-0.05246301740407944,
-0.4783363342285156,
0.3647518455982208,
-0.3465918302536011,
-0.3434755206108093,
0.41940218210220337,
0.6801878809928894,
0.26764246821403503,
0.05463917553424835,
-0.5647710561752319,
0.175850510597229,
-0.20162340998649597,
-0.2209843099117279,
0.5868091583251953,
0.36381712555885315,
-0.03626713156700134,
0.6776351928710938,
0.9302517175674438,
0.788421630859375,
-0.1625441461801529,
0.3504360616207123,
0.8041545748710632,
-0.5542287230491638,
-0.49849000573158264,
-0.9007434844970703,
0.08873763680458069,
0.027621788904070854,
-0.19556517899036407,
0.19568902254104614,
0.6019553542137146,
1.078678846359253,
0.021164698526263237,
0.7250468730926514,
0.3380475342273712,
0.22870878875255585,
-0.855542778968811,
0.5280863046646118,
-0.6910510063171387,
0.5056121349334717,
0.037209443747997284,
-0.9115391969680786,
-0.1493583619594574,
0.39060643315315247,
-0.1529642641544342,
-0.16658787429332733,
0.5151389241218567,
0.893216609954834,
0.14543648064136505,
-0.4310459494590759,
0.6158735752105713,
-0.2815338671207428,
0.40918052196502686,
0.4360935688018799,
0.8444702625274658,
0.0235887560993433,
0.7558021545410156,
-0.28522035479545593,
0.028587648645043373,
-0.28737354278564453,
-0.8103128671646118,
-0.607870876789093,
-0.2216976135969162,
-0.21894356608390808,
-0.18949097394943237,
0.00024094409309327602,
1.4206894636154175,
0.6401717066764832,
-0.6658869981765747,
-0.663818895816803,
-0.04995439946651459,
0.19026659429073334,
-0.30040329694747925,
-0.20369701087474823,
0.23215410113334656,
-0.9272529482841492,
-0.9199993014335632,
0.42729684710502625,
0.43525147438049316,
-0.08133979886770248,
-0.30865874886512756,
-0.2003929764032364,
0.28995394706726074,
0.054618168622255325,
0.7905485033988953,
0.24404276907444,
-0.9085234999656677,
-0.04550647363066673,
0.14465337991714478,
-0.3955511748790741,
0.1416098028421402,
1.0840858221054077,
-0.3550315797328949,
0.12617728114128113,
0.32599011063575745,
0.9535180926322937,
0.5053800344467163,
-0.21702753007411957,
0.3872004449367523,
-0.8122267723083496,
0.15392886102199554,
0.39704421162605286,
0.324640691280365,
0.25771352648735046,
-0.4568822681903839,
0.4788559675216675,
0.2090146541595459,
-0.43162453174591064,
-0.8785820603370667,
0.39347609877586365,
-0.737227737903595,
-0.22480233013629913,
1.1698402166366577,
-0.012170136906206608,
0.03538631275296211,
-0.045039135962724686,
-0.033251263201236725,
0.1459350734949112,
-0.4468342661857605,
0.358587384223938,
0.4107941687107086,
-0.42778074741363525,
-0.25606483221054077,
-0.4922821819782257,
0.7241744995117188,
0.4677604138851166,
-0.639929473400116,
0.27595874667167664,
0.4296586811542511,
0.1280810534954071,
-0.01118508167564869,
0.8163504004478455,
0.05208516865968704,
-0.03395460546016693,
-0.19975344836711884,
0.35359981656074524,
-0.14024250209331512,
-0.034295544028282166,
-0.20395462214946747,
0.042191654443740845,
0.6618068814277649,
-0.42660635709762573
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.05396v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.05396v2
|
HistGen: Histopathology Report Generation via Local-Global Feature Encoding and Cross-modal Context Interaction
| 2024-03-08T15:51:43 | 2024-06-18T05:58:43 |
Zhengrui Guo, Jiabo Ma, Yingxue Xu, Yihui Wang, Liansheng Wang, Hao Chen
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Histopathology serves as the gold standard in cancer diagnosis, with clinical
reports being vital in interpreting and understanding this process, guiding
cancer treatment and patient care. The automation of histopathology report
generation with deep learning stands to significantly enhance clinical
efficiency and lessen the labor-intensive, time-consuming burden on
pathologists in report writing. In pursuit of this advancement, we introduce
HistGen, a multiple instance learning-empowered framework for histopathology
report generation together with the first benchmark dataset for evaluation.
Inspired by diagnostic and report-writing workflows, HistGen features two
delicately designed modules, aiming to boost report generation by aligning
whole slide images (WSIs) and diagnostic reports from local and global
granularity. To achieve this, a local-global hierarchical encoder is developed
for efficient visual feature aggregation from a region-to-slide perspective.
Meanwhile, a cross-modal context module is proposed to explicitly facilitate
alignment and interaction between distinct modalities, effectively bridging the
gap between the extensive visual sequences of WSIs and corresponding highly
summarized reports. Experimental results on WSI report generation show the
proposed model outperforms state-of-the-art (SOTA) models by a large margin.
Moreover, the results of fine-tuning our model on cancer subtyping and survival
analysis tasks further demonstrate superior performance compared to SOTA
methods, showcasing strong transfer learning capability. Dataset, model
weights, and source code are available in
https://github.com/dddavid4real/HistGen.
|
[
-0.17612521350383759,
-0.328962117433548,
0.622028648853302,
-0.15378409624099731,
-0.17052394151687622,
0.01616697758436203,
-0.1419023871421814,
-0.35571813583374023,
-0.014099516905844212,
0.4932612478733063,
-0.48730671405792236,
-0.4679626524448395,
-0.531334400177002,
0.14911486208438873,
-0.22773660719394684,
1.0810022354125977,
0.19468729197978973,
0.14006181061267853,
-0.4696047902107239,
-0.37122514843940735,
-0.22082501649856567,
-0.19102060794830322,
-0.480214923620224,
-0.16959720849990845,
0.7888408899307251,
0.5447463393211365,
0.5897442102432251,
0.9783060550689697,
0.7814090251922607,
0.32007911801338196,
0.2570502758026123,
0.09776504337787628,
-0.4118014872074127,
0.42360052466392517,
-0.05805158615112305,
-0.29635536670684814,
-0.3816578984260559,
-0.19909149408340454,
0.20606717467308044,
0.5853882431983948,
-0.2080071121454239,
0.0012557520531117916,
-0.14676575362682343,
0.31257206201553345,
-0.7039432525634766,
-0.008308922871947289,
-0.389150470495224,
0.30849727988243103,
-0.21840672194957733,
-0.36160290241241455,
-0.2208092361688614,
-0.27722594141960144,
0.2691292464733124,
-0.4009314179420471,
0.34972086548805237,
-0.4167652428150177,
0.5492197275161743,
0.0469832569360733,
-0.6024702191352844,
-0.06321384757757187,
-0.3977604806423187,
0.5679068565368652,
-0.7412552833557129,
0.2248370200395584,
0.08381636440753937,
0.900527834892273,
0.22737908363342285,
-1.2251282930374146,
0.10438739508390427,
-0.22524598240852356,
0.03615202382206917,
0.3691396713256836,
0.0014477517688646913,
-0.17791104316711426,
-0.00017135356029029936,
0.6664741635322571,
-0.6233952045440674,
0.2863149344921112,
-0.4635635018348694,
-0.37547406554222107,
0.6488533020019531,
0.5438462495803833,
0.21578700840473175,
-0.3355720639228821,
-0.5543221235275269,
-0.10241664201021194,
-0.6974526047706604,
-0.21189472079277039,
-0.3166450560092926,
0.4965812861919403,
-0.1553933322429657,
0.132604718208313,
-0.4618731737136841,
0.5258999466896057,
-0.055471718311309814,
-0.5214002132415771,
0.3642510771751404,
-0.5568836331367493,
-0.16991759836673737,
0.4077739119529724,
0.7226272821426392,
0.11960514634847641,
-0.3390638828277588,
-0.2708994746208191,
0.3205356001853943,
-0.013877500779926777,
0.598376989364624,
-1.1429330110549927,
0.005658613983541727,
0.15166975557804108,
-0.5507636666297913,
-0.6995676159858704,
-0.2766415476799011,
-0.8021270036697388,
-0.551419198513031,
-0.035077329725027084,
0.40554359555244446,
-0.5467895865440369,
-0.16406923532485962,
-0.13531483709812164,
-0.05733250826597214,
-0.2738039791584015,
0.43878403306007385,
-0.453490674495697,
-0.03986115753650665,
0.098255455493927,
0.5472365617752075,
-0.06933058053255081,
-0.46227675676345825,
-0.9034798741340637,
0.6244263052940369,
-0.18080054223537445,
0.7185474634170532,
-0.9147982001304626,
-0.26887184381484985,
0.08015701174736023,
0.02276482619345188,
0.08152163773775101,
-0.20409630239009857,
0.3254651427268982,
-0.07513203471899033,
0.4146474003791809,
-0.4045848548412323,
-0.49646854400634766,
-0.024894731119275093,
0.056626733392477036,
-0.3344182074069977,
0.8655761480331421,
0.40716060996055603,
-0.6816926002502441,
0.7596146464347839,
-0.4658188223838806,
-0.23155471682548523,
0.3819786608219147,
-0.4844355583190918,
-0.43410512804985046,
0.06376827508211136,
0.1570596545934677,
0.7242776155471802,
-0.4377073049545288,
0.31061699986457825,
-0.12553800642490387,
0.07795576006174088,
-0.12413991987705231,
-0.10446062684059143,
0.4292064309120178,
0.23542508482933044,
-0.5261568427085876,
0.33503013849258423,
-0.5159341096878052,
0.006822074763476849,
0.20911695063114166,
-0.09992833435535431,
0.11895070225000381,
-0.17126953601837158,
-0.4088860750198364,
0.3113200068473816,
-0.04132620990276337,
-0.7440999746322632,
0.29066213965415955,
-0.11037634313106537,
0.18072549998760223,
0.3006792664527893,
0.07872562110424042,
0.2624296247959137,
-0.3263494670391083,
0.28871485590934753,
0.406127393245697,
0.13005901873111725,
-0.5577970147132874,
-0.5149344205856323,
-0.029592959210276604,
-0.2572675049304962,
0.4843134880065918,
0.4063940644264221,
-0.5880870819091797,
0.31202247738838196,
-0.44133856892585754,
-0.5897290706634521,
-0.22293487191200256,
0.03665987029671669,
0.5025567412376404,
0.8538224101066589,
0.2723800837993622,
-0.6807689666748047,
-0.5410487651824951,
-1.0210708379745483,
0.38704195618629456,
0.3409498929977417,
-0.0454239547252655,
0.35579702258110046,
0.45330068469047546,
-0.33680787682533264,
0.6417877674102783,
-0.7145808935165405,
-0.6967877149581909,
-0.5514931678771973,
0.2211267054080963,
-0.312619686126709,
0.41893303394317627,
0.5526210069656372,
-0.47772160172462463,
-0.22877776622772217,
0.3461498022079468,
-0.9857626557350159,
-0.08629831671714783,
-0.19025708734989166,
-0.22895090281963348,
0.08052565157413483,
0.6204375624656677,
-0.22351878881454468,
0.6359118223190308,
0.3183935880661011,
-0.20461983978748322,
0.3024689555168152,
-0.5925398468971252,
0.5643690228462219,
-1.224409580230713,
-0.08700206130743027,
0.23149219155311584,
-0.37060824036598206,
-0.3725743293762207,
0.14957395195960999,
-0.013797762803733349,
-0.23410509526729584,
-0.3728019893169403,
0.0993386059999466,
-0.20287781953811646,
-0.30269232392311096,
-0.11560869961977005,
-0.024621356278657913,
0.16108281910419464,
0.34472861886024475,
0.09144610911607742,
0.5634861588478088,
0.7191494703292847,
-0.5295103788375854,
0.23411762714385986,
0.4129318594932556,
-0.09389306604862213,
0.30776387453079224,
-0.17157550156116486,
-0.06774333864450455,
-0.003407039912417531,
0.3779459595680237,
-0.6308450698852539,
-0.5085057616233826,
-0.1812257617712021,
-0.38350552320480347,
0.3511506915092468,
-0.24119871854782104,
-0.31860408186912537,
-0.3517383635044098,
-0.25828102231025696,
0.13928958773612976,
0.6829046010971069,
-0.3805151581764221,
0.4317795932292938,
0.22046059370040894,
-0.3075060546398163,
-0.10051851719617844,
-0.8141220808029175,
0.24060340225696564,
-0.029582157731056213,
-0.7468926310539246,
0.5491520166397095,
-0.049788977950811386,
0.13942070305347443,
-0.07953152805566788,
0.04267442598938942,
-0.2142808884382248,
-0.4014492332935333,
0.16142749786376953,
-0.2680565416812897,
-0.4956608712673187,
-0.11786772310733795,
0.07930514216423035,
-0.16878841817378998,
-0.38913553953170776,
0.1718595027923584,
0.2797577977180481,
-0.12358825653791428,
-0.5742391347885132,
-0.33609601855278015,
0.441559374332428,
0.6417100429534912,
-0.34116023778915405,
0.26532843708992004,
0.845795750617981,
-0.5257348418235779,
-0.07084152102470398,
-0.35346338152885437,
-0.21557585895061493,
-0.40230950713157654,
0.39829644560813904,
-0.3947421908378601,
-0.5384027361869812,
0.5519073605537415,
-0.2884889841079712,
0.07338455319404602,
0.5079130530357361,
0.8961626887321472,
0.045920830219984055,
1.1178137063980103,
0.6391671299934387,
0.11484796553850174,
0.1935255229473114,
-0.24324917793273926,
0.012084268033504486,
-0.6666106581687927,
-0.1497543454170227,
-0.2831440269947052,
-0.09319019317626953,
-0.3934386372566223,
-0.46368011832237244,
0.6649695634841919,
-0.335864394903183,
-0.05970369651913643,
0.14727504551410675,
-0.7176074981689453,
0.3586547374725342,
0.36214834451675415,
0.4207146167755127,
0.1667829006910324,
0.00796744879335165,
0.13319356739521027,
-0.5165575742721558,
-1.0625299215316772,
-0.33657559752464294,
1.0854179859161377,
0.10683044046163559,
0.3118552267551422,
0.10190466046333313,
0.9334555864334106,
0.36984214186668396,
0.15791934728622437,
-0.3274953067302704,
0.1932602971792221,
-0.5737705826759338,
-0.271635502576828,
-0.3819683790206909,
-0.366030752658844,
-1.0506073236465454,
0.2870402932167053,
-0.033697184175252914,
-0.6827712655067444,
0.11842663586139679,
-0.09028096497058868,
-0.6219483017921448,
0.4154106378555298,
-0.3663138449192047,
1.0400539636611938,
-0.2912444770336151,
-0.5961304306983948,
-0.16466599702835083,
-0.779069721698761,
0.3813055753707886,
0.21037894487380981,
0.059342414140701294,
0.03161689639091492,
0.07021123170852661,
0.5261497497558594,
-0.4364747107028961,
1.0531913042068481,
-0.1324339061975479,
-0.02664581499993801,
0.07763916999101639,
0.3383723199367523,
0.19574691355228424,
0.26786118745803833,
-0.02282807230949402,
-0.20057827234268188,
-0.13868913054466248,
-0.37431278824806213,
-0.14667923748493195,
0.8673887252807617,
-0.23374983668327332,
-0.016721831634640694,
-0.06901146471500397,
-0.6900988817214966,
-0.17064596712589264,
0.27907416224479675,
0.6790889501571655,
1.038981556892395,
-0.15810321271419525,
0.10215018689632416,
0.7846367359161377,
-0.33000582456588745,
0.38346943259239197,
0.028804589062929153,
0.2146599441766739,
-0.18091340363025665,
1.3445165157318115,
0.07250463962554932,
-0.007495720870792866,
0.11567914485931396,
0.45273107290267944,
0.13263164460659027,
-0.6404047012329102,
-0.9154115915298462,
-0.4255806803703308,
-0.757392406463623,
-0.6698458194732666,
-0.5584153532981873,
-0.25843143463134766,
-0.3174022138118744,
-0.6356081366539001,
-0.5655209422111511,
0.07468333095312119,
0.0128361526876688,
-0.09894084930419922,
0.49674832820892334,
0.6447091698646545,
-0.3572826683521271,
0.22540032863616943,
-0.9646556973457336,
0.30175313353538513,
0.23874662816524506,
0.2909910976886749,
-0.22001872956752777,
-0.33752143383026123,
-0.3182010352611542,
-0.1605307161808014,
-0.34460100531578064,
-0.799070417881012,
0.571239709854126,
0.3791581690311432,
0.5969479084014893,
0.4158332347869873,
-0.0555875338613987,
0.6177456974983215,
-0.2728079855442047,
0.6356295943260193,
0.22482194006443024,
-0.5488457083702087,
0.7562335133552551,
-0.5705385208129883,
0.26640573143959045,
0.7491399645805359,
0.2919095754623413,
-0.3114970922470093,
-0.7210407257080078,
-0.9768730998039246,
-0.8597212433815002,
0.8402026891708374,
0.20465722680091858,
-0.24036365747451782,
0.20934975147247314,
0.10775613784790039,
0.7817301154136658,
0.07694264501333237,
-0.419370174407959,
-0.0009830897906795144,
-0.3125454783439636,
-0.3936091363430023,
-0.020083466544747353,
-0.16667775809764862,
-0.709200918674469,
-0.30983665585517883,
0.22284314036369324,
-0.4572125971317291,
0.4718022346496582,
0.475952684879303,
-0.391376256942749,
-0.004467457067221403,
-0.030321873724460602,
0.6533478498458862,
0.7282280325889587,
-0.2557656168937683,
0.0035319810267537832,
0.21000449359416962,
-0.18010570108890533,
-0.2777133584022522,
-0.14204086363315582,
0.25214850902557373,
-0.01627405919134617,
0.6774293780326843,
0.5037804245948792,
0.27962857484817505,
-0.43511906266212463,
0.6239869594573975,
-0.08430463075637817,
-0.536560595035553,
0.16564463078975677,
0.10632927715778351,
0.010194055736064911,
0.12284920364618301,
0.42376717925071716,
0.09184972196817398,
0.5760339498519897,
-0.32865044474601746,
0.6942850351333618,
0.004182990174740553,
-0.6663800477981567,
-0.20840796828269958,
0.555107057094574,
0.4554261267185211,
0.33767440915107727,
0.4830624759197235,
-0.2832580804824829,
-0.36734774708747864,
0.9691178798675537,
0.47445133328437805,
0.7050862312316895,
-0.04158564284443855,
0.36133119463920593,
0.5035934448242188,
0.06440944969654083,
0.25312089920043945,
0.10812006145715714,
0.0841435119509697,
-0.3700300455093384,
-0.26774856448173523,
-0.3269800841808319,
-0.4446747899055481,
0.13751617074012756,
-0.6106228828430176,
-0.05569595471024513,
-0.37498170137405396,
0.24123169481754303,
0.298438161611557,
-0.08658555150032043,
-0.3431580364704132,
0.4547378718852997,
0.429174542427063,
0.8290426135063171,
-0.8782035708427429,
0.599704921245575,
0.3696396052837372,
-0.5435320138931274,
-0.29234692454338074,
-0.03992786630988121,
0.30118048191070557,
-0.5366194248199463,
0.48424139618873596,
0.39506611227989197,
0.22448430955410004,
-0.2082543671131134,
-0.32858771085739136,
-0.8577749133110046,
1.1778912544250488,
0.17090700566768646,
-0.333711177110672,
0.39628496766090393,
-0.04524865373969078,
0.5739797949790955,
-0.9425435662269592,
0.30946779251098633,
0.4988928735256195,
0.4135853350162506,
0.1580214500427246,
-0.8029667139053345,
0.3259066641330719,
-0.04000901058316231,
-0.042715638875961304,
0.15415483713150024,
-0.5384408235549927,
0.6028844714164734,
-0.44226786494255066,
0.1022612527012825,
-0.07007509469985962,
0.46291816234588623,
0.006963169202208519,
0.45644456148147583,
0.025046637281775475,
0.7653390765190125,
0.5663942098617554,
-0.2095150500535965,
1.3438349962234497,
-0.3893742263317108,
-0.09278208017349243,
0.5660922527313232,
-0.3480917513370514,
0.4012359380722046,
-0.029135696589946747,
0.09308052808046341,
0.46762630343437195,
0.6882952451705933,
-0.1088949665427208,
0.6295509934425354,
-0.12704132497310638,
-0.09365594387054443,
-0.4818662703037262,
0.04549802467226982,
-0.670714259147644,
0.5737389326095581,
0.30351653695106506,
-0.3151402175426483,
-0.5628470182418823,
0.26805126667022705,
-0.2703845500946045,
-0.22199511528015137,
-0.23520776629447937,
0.8987149000167847,
-0.434845894575119,
-0.15753452479839325,
0.48318490386009216,
-0.09354215860366821,
0.689791738986969,
-0.7694454789161682,
0.013444611802697182,
-0.37069880962371826,
0.105886310338974,
-0.49497419595718384,
-0.6964971423149109,
0.5341264009475708,
-0.18316711485385895,
-0.1327517032623291,
0.047178614884614944,
0.5452069640159607,
-0.3242742717266083,
-0.5386653542518616,
0.1429159939289093,
0.8018175959587097,
0.002155147260054946,
0.2024499624967575,
-0.5337633490562439,
0.02189100906252861,
0.1613825112581253,
-0.29527223110198975,
0.757586658000946,
0.5224151015281677,
-0.3554379940032959,
0.6979262828826904,
0.49398404359817505,
-0.16017568111419678,
-0.13083206117153168,
0.2734510004520416,
0.8396297693252563,
-0.6619663834571838,
-0.32682979106903076,
-0.43445223569869995,
0.676010251045227,
-0.3238322138786316,
-0.6724177002906799,
0.33484044671058655,
0.7031517624855042,
0.5651454925537109,
0.037648290395736694,
0.8616120219230652,
-0.28367355465888977,
0.2125266194343567,
-0.31758812069892883,
0.6335853934288025,
-0.7099208831787109,
-0.08473720401525497,
0.0130320368334651,
-0.2013608068227768,
-0.2736382782459259,
0.04701303690671921,
-0.09232563525438309,
0.179377481341362,
0.7953410148620605,
0.56343674659729,
-0.32584941387176514,
-0.28083673119544983,
0.41950422525405884,
0.18943443894386292,
0.1720283180475235,
0.5089996457099915,
0.3269978165626526,
-0.40064236521720886,
0.7765914797782898,
-0.709834098815918,
-0.40299469232559204,
-0.3916601240634918,
-0.6621766686439514,
-0.6488751173019409,
-0.6683791279792786,
-0.6603457927703857,
-0.15209108591079712,
0.19593168795108795,
0.22544458508491516,
1.1132452487945557,
-0.5755851864814758,
-0.1433631330728531,
0.040154099464416504,
-0.15039372444152832,
-0.18691515922546387,
-0.17544884979724884,
0.36759132146835327,
-0.6339899301528931,
-0.5924933552742004,
0.6400477290153503,
0.6451655626296997,
-0.19756285846233368,
0.005506235174834728,
-0.04546903818845749,
-0.0001220318372361362,
-0.42210444808006287,
0.8186404705047607,
0.3072078824043274,
-0.2469881772994995,
0.11546995490789413,
-0.30013585090637207,
-0.47464147210121155,
0.5457714200019836,
0.8084509372711182,
-0.9823523163795471,
0.32083678245544434,
0.37664610147476196,
0.7094188928604126,
0.5378249287605286,
-0.3366781175136566,
0.8581132292747498,
-0.8815130591392517,
0.03889188915491104,
0.3831058442592621,
0.37844911217689514,
0.2981010973453522,
-0.6867507696151733,
0.620357871055603,
0.06774000078439713,
-0.4378255307674408,
-0.9820591807365417,
0.3574685752391815,
-0.9567270278930664,
-0.4980940520763397,
0.8363161087036133,
0.07631158083677292,
-0.2523669898509979,
0.08155736327171326,
-0.25702303647994995,
0.21019931137561798,
-0.42214706540107727,
0.7181646227836609,
-0.19357235729694366,
-0.7145435214042664,
-0.37401115894317627,
-0.41212669014930725,
0.8084261417388916,
0.3423713743686676,
-1.0542614459991455,
-0.038063567131757736,
0.5258156657218933,
0.30524155497550964,
0.07860400527715683,
0.44907039403915405,
-0.21165664494037628,
0.7885085940361023,
0.29009971022605896,
0.2636033296585083,
-0.2751411497592926,
-0.33150696754455566,
-0.16029323637485504,
0.4626123607158661,
-0.21526534855365753,
-0.19819454848766327
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.05365v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.05365v1
|
The Impact of Quantization on the Robustness of Transformer-based Text Classifiers
| 2024-03-08T14:55:05 | 2024-03-08T14:55:05 |
Seyed Parsa Neshaei, Yasaman Boreshban, Gholamreza Ghassem-Sani, Seyed Abolghasem Mirroshandel
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Transformer-based models have made remarkable advancements in various NLP
areas. Nevertheless, these models often exhibit vulnerabilities when confronted
with adversarial attacks. In this paper, we explore the effect of quantization
on the robustness of Transformer-based models. Quantization usually involves
mapping a high-precision real number to a lower-precision value, aiming at
reducing the size of the model at hand. To the best of our knowledge, this work
is the first application of quantization on the robustness of NLP models. In
our experiments, we evaluate the impact of quantization on BERT and DistilBERT
models in text classification using SST-2, Emotion, and MR datasets. We also
evaluate the performance of these models against TextFooler, PWWS, and PSO
adversarial attacks. Our findings show that quantization significantly improves
(by an average of 18.68%) the adversarial accuracy of the models. Furthermore,
we compare the effect of quantization versus that of the adversarial training
approach on robustness. Our experiments indicate that quantization increases
the robustness of the model by 18.80% on average compared to adversarial
training without imposing any extra computational overhead during training.
Therefore, our results highlight the effectiveness of quantization in improving
the robustness of NLP models.
|
[
-0.25473371148109436,
-0.6659896969795227,
0.13913889229297638,
0.06973876059055328,
-0.11370332539081573,
-0.11408853530883789,
-0.09415549039840698,
-0.2825423777103424,
-0.5753197073936462,
0.11645849794149399,
0.027746502310037613,
-0.3578367233276367,
-0.9580548405647278,
0.09394337981939316,
-0.6305748224258423,
1.3415920734405518,
0.43232637643814087,
-0.012070034630596638,
0.0004795693384949118,
-0.13766299188137054,
-0.21002396941184998,
-1.0571752786636353,
-0.5288608074188232,
0.025993211194872856,
0.30009469389915466,
-0.6193272471427917,
1.3419380187988281,
0.39364251494407654,
0.8208892345428467,
0.42905059456825256,
-0.5147162675857544,
-0.4623843729496002,
-0.1989666372537613,
0.31824758648872375,
0.1045532077550888,
-1.011343002319336,
-0.3882029056549072,
-0.15362444519996643,
0.5369452834129333,
0.27726826071739197,
-0.18545743823051453,
-0.0840386375784874,
0.11032073944807053,
0.6719245314598083,
-0.6903406977653503,
-0.05139242857694626,
-0.7428333163261414,
0.1326873004436493,
-0.05048903822898865,
0.10596831142902374,
-0.6248430013656616,
-0.41754865646362305,
0.3395022451877594,
-0.4713969826698303,
0.3959159255027771,
-0.20935295522212982,
1.0650370121002197,
0.7154107689857483,
-0.4734840393066406,
-0.2733464539051056,
-0.9637144804000854,
0.860489010810852,
-0.7362203001976013,
0.16676996648311615,
0.29369279742240906,
0.30365726351737976,
0.19520950317382812,
-0.8438776135444641,
-0.4162856936454773,
0.05951058492064476,
-0.3271488547325134,
0.008232595399022102,
-0.7732793092727661,
0.1736667901277542,
0.6112621426582336,
0.5495434403419495,
-0.6741987466812134,
-0.07325981557369232,
-0.06307221204042435,
-0.09359673410654068,
0.28422170877456665,
-0.05842844769358635,
0.3017593324184418,
-0.2680133283138275,
-0.28808385133743286,
-0.6113584637641907,
-0.20367436110973358,
0.266396164894104,
0.3487006723880768,
0.19475004076957703,
0.22265556454658508,
0.2887628376483917,
0.2304784506559372,
0.49411025643348694,
-0.05769817903637886,
-0.06740433722734451,
-0.3020666539669037,
-0.22699345648288727,
-0.3187294900417328,
-0.2747906744480133,
0.9483510255813599,
-0.03218840807676315,
0.37251678109169006,
-0.2263505756855011,
-0.2161528766155243,
0.34720513224601746,
0.6382552981376648,
-0.9666784405708313,
-0.48993241786956787,
0.23410965502262115,
-0.6273179650306702,
-0.8513807058334351,
0.060895536094903946,
-0.5059579610824585,
-0.222573384642601,
0.13094283640384674,
0.7219243049621582,
-0.7127841114997864,
0.016186019405722618,
0.10852374136447906,
-0.15693412721157074,
0.000028776890758308582,
0.17213159799575806,
-0.9443560838699341,
0.2699390649795532,
0.7839669585227966,
0.8309795260429382,
0.26219311356544495,
0.07461634278297424,
-0.2994885742664337,
-0.11161494255065918,
-0.10297457873821259,
0.3826633095741272,
-0.007677907589823008,
-0.3863236904144287,
-0.050904661417007446,
-0.25571349263191223,
0.06340181082487106,
-0.38905400037765503,
0.6515977382659912,
-0.7081058621406555,
0.27749398350715637,
0.10724326223134995,
-0.40300557017326355,
-0.14177332818508148,
0.2691050171852112,
-1.014678716659546,
0.8098778128623962,
0.06119028851389885,
-1.1022497415542603,
0.24927350878715515,
-0.4195094406604767,
-0.5358179807662964,
-0.15517526865005493,
0.37210965156555176,
-1.036275863647461,
0.26346123218536377,
0.35376471281051636,
0.3290277421474457,
-0.07210222631692886,
0.3217712342739105,
-0.24725519120693207,
-0.3757290244102478,
0.71583092212677,
-1.056069016456604,
1.0497812032699585,
0.060932911932468414,
-0.4313504695892334,
-0.13412164151668549,
-0.7763310670852661,
0.160583958029747,
0.16641859710216522,
-0.2506939470767975,
-0.5989359021186829,
0.07633308321237564,
-0.026707977056503296,
0.114760622382164,
-0.024715671315789223,
-0.09543715417385101,
0.22952255606651306,
-0.7614659070968628,
0.5621530413627625,
0.6606956720352173,
-0.15500055253505707,
0.5574184060096741,
-0.2162998467683792,
0.6174755692481995,
-0.09000659734010696,
0.430934876203537,
-0.20212754607200623,
-0.37213972210884094,
-0.6920803785324097,
-0.35852447152137756,
0.9582943320274353,
0.5797979831695557,
-0.8718637824058533,
0.5344955325126648,
-0.3654433488845825,
-0.45492687821388245,
-0.39225685596466064,
-0.46819308400154114,
0.31709936261177063,
0.10865344107151031,
0.25863707065582275,
0.1583835631608963,
-0.3079909682273865,
-0.5746004581451416,
-0.3957298696041107,
-0.3174842894077301,
-0.49446186423301697,
-0.3341449201107025,
0.5355693101882935,
-0.07643163204193115,
1.0143412351608276,
-0.49286529421806335,
-0.1859171837568283,
0.14302845299243927,
0.32589638233184814,
0.008777490817010403,
0.4371401071548462,
0.7042278051376343,
-1.1613103151321411,
-0.4332713484764099,
-0.3118784725666046,
-0.5467244982719421,
0.20575812458992004,
-0.16517779231071472,
-0.02158910036087036,
0.22701044380664825,
-0.0016523981466889381,
-0.5262392163276672,
0.9072579741477966,
0.4687143862247467,
-0.24593593180179596,
0.20898908376693726,
-0.043650850653648376,
0.007039791438728571,
-1.0476018190383911,
0.051977258175611496,
0.10518296808004379,
-0.32205095887184143,
-0.783328652381897,
0.12328246980905533,
0.16649256646633148,
-0.31097838282585144,
-0.3873260021209717,
0.05577719584107399,
0.15960794687271118,
0.17416387796401978,
-0.21015127003192902,
-0.2261824607849121,
0.4483736455440521,
0.404967725276947,
-0.025685051456093788,
0.6721351146697998,
0.46121567487716675,
-0.41141071915626526,
0.17214782536029816,
0.3588627278804779,
-0.10259850323200226,
0.5757268667221069,
-0.9971248507499695,
-0.034588366746902466,
-0.06883727014064789,
0.25094643235206604,
-0.6236874461174011,
0.27600446343421936,
0.005904208403080702,
-0.6992759108543396,
0.4612431824207306,
-0.18399183452129364,
-0.6972981095314026,
-0.109797403216362,
-0.5215124487876892,
0.23493514955043793,
0.5195578932762146,
-0.6154242753982544,
0.7189661860466003,
0.08682464808225632,
0.04003942757844925,
-0.47033894062042236,
-0.7523707151412964,
0.027360700070858,
-0.4475440979003906,
-0.6783871650695801,
0.32871243357658386,
0.07034080475568771,
-0.260707825422287,
-0.16151250898838043,
-0.11766918748617172,
-0.19439473748207092,
0.5193290114402771,
0.29011061787605286,
0.31773316860198975,
0.06884580850601196,
0.11886776983737946,
-0.13806717097759247,
-0.44523394107818604,
0.16423125565052032,
-0.2925450801849365,
0.3271918296813965,
-0.5155027508735657,
-0.03367340564727783,
-0.5071409940719604,
0.2056901752948761,
0.4595739245414734,
-0.38692575693130493,
1.123184084892273,
0.8693774342536926,
-0.4730818569660187,
-0.16265925765037537,
0.036106280982494354,
-0.2093018889427185,
-0.5314486622810364,
0.324888676404953,
-0.27899405360221863,
-0.8521575331687927,
0.2766297459602356,
0.026053912937641144,
-0.26777225732803345,
0.5044766664505005,
0.31171438097953796,
-0.2557324767112732,
1.2868329286575317,
0.66695237159729,
-0.12965187430381775,
0.4012143313884735,
-0.39336299896240234,
0.4028182625770569,
-0.6514600515365601,
0.09262054413557053,
-0.8124756217002869,
-0.22830995917320251,
-0.914196789264679,
-0.07260248810052872,
0.5224938988685608,
0.08852417021989822,
-0.052090130746364594,
0.5317218899726868,
-0.7610849142074585,
0.2599538564682007,
0.7492814064025879,
0.19711315631866455,
0.10721941292285919,
-0.04954180121421814,
0.5504773855209351,
-0.373644083738327,
-0.8583371043205261,
-0.5945273637771606,
1.1070325374603271,
0.5727304220199585,
0.75718754529953,
0.36920490860939026,
0.32328489422798157,
0.3427165150642395,
0.16877347230911255,
-0.8066128492355347,
0.20465609431266785,
-0.5880877375602722,
-0.37696900963783264,
-0.4285348057746887,
-0.6156246066093445,
-0.8809604048728943,
0.3914221227169037,
-0.44366276264190674,
-0.3752662241458893,
0.28013914823532104,
0.0267954021692276,
-0.5385719537734985,
0.3341161608695984,
-0.556479811668396,
0.7962601780891418,
-0.15324309468269348,
0.13493657112121582,
0.1894402801990509,
-0.7425745725631714,
0.15530012547969818,
-0.3320496380329132,
0.253423810005188,
0.41648879647254944,
0.1271151751279831,
0.6549209356307983,
-0.4970512390136719,
0.8696386814117432,
0.019494399428367615,
-0.31582173705101013,
0.11253304779529572,
0.06371328234672546,
0.7211475372314453,
0.11631100624799728,
-0.019773518666625023,
0.5075020790100098,
0.11473581194877625,
-0.32005763053894043,
-0.8919700384140015,
0.21134701371192932,
-0.7110320329666138,
-0.3893934190273285,
-0.6769977807998657,
-0.5246089100837708,
-0.023798856884241104,
-0.09607086330652237,
0.5305384397506714,
0.4954979717731476,
0.05635325238108635,
0.5194586515426636,
1.0481172800064087,
-0.38708215951919556,
0.6342949271202087,
0.2652158737182617,
0.2319326251745224,
-0.7365508079528809,
0.818832278251648,
0.040188781917095184,
0.4794469475746155,
0.7040843367576599,
0.26006901264190674,
-0.24550344049930573,
-0.4221189320087433,
-0.10195249319076538,
-0.34418320655822754,
-0.6050117015838623,
-0.6971871852874756,
-0.6236351728439331,
-0.24614214897155762,
-0.4659017026424408,
-0.14873918890953064,
-0.2518142759799957,
-0.7816482782363892,
-0.3892281651496887,
0.09567911177873611,
0.3307320475578308,
0.18592557311058044,
0.17508564889431,
0.7383078932762146,
-0.8453376293182373,
0.3523911237716675,
0.5537057518959045,
0.07689277827739716,
-0.08799009770154953,
-0.5644426345825195,
-0.448594868183136,
0.0658109188079834,
-0.49259084463119507,
-0.6961884498596191,
0.4179129898548126,
0.3390144407749176,
-0.15475697815418243,
0.4084136486053467,
0.2783554792404175,
0.2532648742198944,
-0.3176979720592499,
0.6390421390533447,
-0.025476783514022827,
-1.3634854555130005,
0.662440836429596,
-0.15687257051467896,
0.30942004919052124,
0.3431541621685028,
0.2930049002170563,
-0.14075307548046112,
-0.5568619966506958,
-0.7437263131141663,
-0.7369141578674316,
0.7516855001449585,
0.6955618262290955,
0.0037041620817035437,
0.19490578770637512,
0.25848597288131714,
-0.22430419921875,
0.24815714359283447,
-0.9968032836914062,
-0.3173086941242218,
-0.5201747417449951,
-0.3405451476573944,
0.29436394572257996,
-0.31772279739379883,
0.03782881423830986,
-0.029441118240356445,
0.6155182719230652,
-0.006005425937473774,
0.06972242891788483,
-0.12208068370819092,
0.004728544969111681,
0.18198296427726746,
0.26179224252700806,
0.3918802738189697,
-0.11704748868942261,
-0.12994584441184998,
0.31518325209617615,
0.1253819763660431,
-0.6225094795227051,
0.2434280514717102,
0.20020723342895508,
-0.5388118028640747,
0.1553507149219513,
0.5667545795440674,
0.8168321251869202,
0.15849657356739044,
-0.33929744362831116,
0.8047342300415039,
-0.45810431241989136,
0.052815575152635574,
-0.07682971656322479,
0.004225214011967182,
-0.44976988434791565,
0.26922938227653503,
0.3090890049934387,
0.4699788987636566,
0.3288651704788208,
-0.16438429057598114,
0.14750976860523224,
0.739377498626709,
-0.13107232749462128,
-0.3451469838619232,
0.982200026512146,
-0.1542138159275055,
-0.37672340869903564,
0.3123299479484558,
0.061671968549489975,
-0.9735791087150574,
0.7803481817245483,
0.4921184778213501,
0.8341540694236755,
-0.40280985832214355,
0.1117694228887558,
0.1395353227853775,
0.6165952086448669,
-0.18266712129116058,
-0.2720623314380646,
-0.04903334379196167,
-0.36452749371528625,
-0.3152846097946167,
-0.6585341691970825,
-0.3641584515571594,
-0.16725796461105347,
-1.038071870803833,
0.18917836248874664,
-0.2826046347618103,
-0.701871931552887,
0.010939031839370728,
-0.2072169929742813,
-0.290523499250412,
0.6088446974754333,
0.06655900180339813,
0.43195655941963196,
-0.7602251172065735,
0.7598565816879272,
0.5196202397346497,
-0.11781628429889679,
-0.5192596316337585,
0.27655133605003357,
-0.30469051003456116,
-0.3565727770328522,
0.5344929695129395,
0.06364292651414871,
0.21211212873458862,
0.08176962286233902,
-0.20416682958602905,
-0.7587547302246094,
1.0126702785491943,
0.3638157546520233,
-0.4929133951663971,
-0.012054389342665672,
0.487827330827713,
0.9188497066497803,
0.585159182548523,
0.2048983871936798,
0.24778003990650177,
0.17465932667255402,
-0.15224020183086395,
-0.7372673153877258,
-0.07651491463184357,
-0.1465183049440384,
0.5772227048873901,
0.6605565547943115,
-0.6029941439628601,
0.6717318892478943,
0.06410921365022659,
-0.37862280011177063,
0.05671272799372673,
0.6569972634315491,
-0.08186444640159607,
0.11543896049261093,
0.484046071767807,
0.774394690990448,
0.6119835376739502,
-0.44488030672073364,
1.1084989309310913,
-0.31754446029663086,
0.6523929238319397,
0.7720071077346802,
0.14984385669231415,
0.6888232231140137,
0.18570533394813538,
-0.6865784525871277,
0.21990184485912323,
0.14368905127048492,
-0.3176073431968689,
0.6656008958816528,
0.16879455745220184,
-0.22742480039596558,
0.18408648669719696,
0.20844516158103943,
-0.19449719786643982,
0.2838796079158783,
0.09895100444555283,
-0.21028581261634827,
0.06189385801553726,
0.444882333278656,
0.09179970622062683,
0.16095060110092163,
-0.01566896215081215,
0.7474973201751709,
0.018412278965115547,
-0.13326801359653473,
0.6086733937263489,
0.1470586359500885,
0.9394946098327637,
-0.4756096303462982,
0.2837633192539215,
0.038644395768642426,
0.27714478969573975,
-0.17677855491638184,
-0.3830052316188812,
0.5601640939712524,
0.17862845957279205,
-0.4468497335910797,
-0.28258955478668213,
0.6670814752578735,
-0.14464502036571503,
-0.6741162538528442,
-0.14105387032032013,
-0.06402499973773956,
-0.36665382981300354,
-0.5914504528045654,
-0.4157152771949768,
0.10565569251775742,
-0.03288313001394272,
-0.27132463455200195,
0.46229517459869385,
0.6985068917274475,
0.04739423841238022,
0.6591415405273438,
0.6161132454872131,
-0.09618058800697327,
-0.062293753027915955,
-0.026208018884062767,
0.64462810754776,
-0.47196441888809204,
-0.36929845809936523,
-1.2368669509887695,
0.5848733186721802,
0.1712830364704132,
-0.061630528420209885,
0.7681140899658203,
0.4303235411643982,
0.5912073850631714,
-0.02304253727197647,
0.7227784991264343,
0.04824581369757652,
0.22438064217567444,
-0.3225226104259491,
0.9589807987213135,
-0.1870807260274887,
0.46245479583740234,
-0.27125051617622375,
-0.7178451418876648,
-0.5424304604530334,
0.6413496732711792,
-0.06308402121067047,
0.04217595234513283,
0.5283938050270081,
0.3881698250770569,
0.43050554394721985,
0.13704994320869446,
0.3448448181152344,
0.015959804877638817,
0.4520512521266937,
0.5022200345993042,
0.7632569670677185,
-1.0373201370239258,
0.9605149030685425,
-0.7111614346504211,
-0.26650407910346985,
0.05472327023744583,
-0.7033616304397583,
-1.068856120109558,
-0.5876561403274536,
-0.5524734258651733,
-0.4561784267425537,
0.028839876875281334,
0.0970328226685524,
0.6075032353401184,
-0.7797776460647583,
0.45146143436431885,
-0.17220616340637207,
-0.011863750405609608,
-0.10980764031410217,
-0.3300391137599945,
0.6636660099029541,
-0.2180957794189453,
-0.7999392151832581,
-0.0757390484213829,
0.2160269170999527,
0.5069235563278198,
-0.22528456151485443,
0.3261406421661377,
0.3436422348022461,
0.11488169431686401,
0.6548230648040771,
-0.16342663764953613,
-0.45371872186660767,
-0.00043157621985301375,
0.17726856470108032,
-0.24950860440731049,
-0.0882115438580513,
0.5646824240684509,
-0.9166034460067749,
0.24440036714076996,
0.19423678517341614,
0.4681132435798645,
0.11606492102146149,
0.27288517355918884,
0.46878981590270996,
-0.8339419364929199,
0.3086947202682495,
0.43680036067962646,
0.09073279798030853,
0.31412577629089355,
-0.5517098903656006,
0.5681925415992737,
0.032607994973659515,
-0.6900781989097595,
-1.0794709920883179,
-0.031059743836522102,
-0.6077995896339417,
-0.29796868562698364,
0.7332146763801575,
-0.2975682020187378,
-0.054377928376197815,
0.2694169580936432,
-0.19898752868175507,
0.4141739308834076,
-0.0071231587789952755,
1.1400911808013916,
0.6741656064987183,
0.33739686012268066,
0.025266505777835846,
-0.26032745838165283,
0.49696215987205505,
0.4768710434436798,
-0.8307338953018188,
-0.18592166900634766,
-0.04018991440534592,
-0.2582024335861206,
0.2608185410499573,
-0.09225191920995712,
-0.08640602231025696,
0.10566132515668869,
0.11805394291877747,
-0.024799883365631104,
0.12761491537094116,
-0.04842323809862137,
-0.7804396152496338,
0.35847893357276917,
-0.16425226628780365,
-0.17446361482143402
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.05338v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.05338v1
|
Explaining Pre-Trained Language Models with Attribution Scores: An Analysis in Low-Resource Settings
| 2024-03-08T14:14:37 | 2024-03-08T14:14:37 |
Wei Zhou, Heike Adel, Hendrik Schuff, Ngoc Thang Vu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Attribution scores indicate the importance of different input parts and can,
thus, explain model behaviour. Currently, prompt-based models are gaining
popularity, i.a., due to their easier adaptability in low-resource settings.
However, the quality of attribution scores extracted from prompt-based models
has not been investigated yet. In this work, we address this topic by analyzing
attribution scores extracted from prompt-based models w.r.t. plausibility and
faithfulness and comparing them with attribution scores extracted from
fine-tuned models and large language models. In contrast to previous work, we
introduce training size as another dimension into the analysis. We find that
using the prompting paradigm (with either encoder-based or decoder-based
models) yields more plausible explanations than fine-tuning the models in
low-resource settings and Shapley Value Sampling consistently outperforms
attention and Integrated Gradients in terms of leading to more plausible and
faithful explanations.
|
[
-0.27810490131378174,
-0.6653639674186707,
0.9773951172828674,
0.35350850224494934,
-0.24116994440555573,
-0.3466055691242218,
-0.46685683727264404,
-0.2005532830953598,
-0.08148600906133652,
0.16226156055927277,
-0.6670001745223999,
-0.020949291065335274,
-0.4756168723106384,
0.15864044427871704,
-0.3519211709499359,
0.831733226776123,
-0.1703042834997177,
0.011889178305864334,
-0.5103894472122192,
-0.046859439462423325,
-0.6360105872154236,
-0.380923330783844,
-0.8423715233802795,
-0.4492843449115753,
0.8180119395256042,
0.41671037673950195,
0.8263023495674133,
0.8675611019134521,
0.22040647268295288,
0.27224764227867126,
0.13880862295627594,
-0.23665226995944977,
-0.4411166310310364,
-0.04034961387515068,
-0.1780909299850464,
-0.5093916654586792,
-0.18212556838989258,
0.5110867023468018,
0.6226304769515991,
0.7509735226631165,
0.003105132607743144,
0.3990015983581543,
0.4600958228111267,
0.2765716016292572,
-0.6635908484458923,
0.1388952136039734,
-0.4570121169090271,
-0.23938773572444916,
0.057422395795583725,
-0.3576412498950958,
-0.6532654166221619,
-0.611370325088501,
-0.006347304210066795,
-0.6200971007347107,
0.3427908420562744,
0.07124635577201843,
0.8458662033081055,
0.3271019756793976,
-0.26234695315361023,
-0.44442784786224365,
-0.5399630665779114,
1.2116903066635132,
-0.5522041916847229,
0.22864572703838348,
0.5232758522033691,
0.29791951179504395,
0.20609979331493378,
-0.4999707341194153,
-0.5296891331672668,
-0.3245494067668915,
-0.40557774901390076,
-0.09007024765014648,
-0.1403317153453827,
-0.1517823487520218,
0.481314480304718,
0.4351794421672821,
-0.4549647867679596,
0.40499040484428406,
-0.17830392718315125,
-0.29424989223480225,
0.4957648515701294,
0.13857847452163696,
0.011366600170731544,
-0.22979483008384705,
-0.13950790464878082,
-0.09054987132549286,
-0.6713863611221313,
0.5859069228172302,
0.4838941693305969,
0.5342326760292053,
-0.26438581943511963,
0.39571577310562134,
0.015282752923667431,
0.8171637058258057,
0.20781153440475464,
0.09479627758264542,
-0.2907354235649109,
-0.46755528450012207,
-0.10558896511793137,
0.06980695575475693,
0.9704200625419617,
0.13686154782772064,
0.5669982433319092,
0.04276953265070915,
-0.3191624581813812,
0.03701753914356232,
0.20526745915412903,
-0.8256248235702515,
-0.1698344647884369,
0.0010979165090247989,
-1.014203429222107,
-0.5057143568992615,
-0.2582011818885803,
-0.7131348848342896,
-0.4266152083873749,
-0.28997740149497986,
0.49714675545692444,
-0.3158279359340668,
-0.32460400462150574,
-0.015698669478297234,
0.10978126525878906,
0.38139641284942627,
0.5265206098556519,
-0.860416829586029,
0.14959774911403656,
0.40415266156196594,
1.0338748693466187,
-0.23873379826545715,
-0.27394503355026245,
-0.6536591053009033,
-0.4421297311782837,
-0.387626588344574,
0.8201825022697449,
-0.7113025188446045,
-0.3701964020729065,
-0.020690545439720154,
0.005941856186836958,
-0.08328896015882492,
-0.4229109287261963,
0.4954829514026642,
-0.45439913868904114,
0.531274676322937,
-0.6832245588302612,
-0.4193919599056244,
-0.07182951271533966,
0.19633905589580536,
-0.7412002086639404,
0.7159088253974915,
0.2616279423236847,
-0.40219393372535706,
0.45935437083244324,
-0.8561432957649231,
-0.20996606349945068,
-0.11957812309265137,
-0.012021346017718315,
0.014691703021526337,
0.42348629236221313,
0.36329376697540283,
0.444630891084671,
-0.5019793510437012,
0.30643153190612793,
-0.16405275464057922,
-0.3263196349143982,
0.8165271282196045,
-0.9589415788650513,
1.1415891647338867,
0.3831585645675659,
0.1416441798210144,
0.11081624031066895,
-0.5678989887237549,
0.119839608669281,
0.24116088449954987,
-0.426014244556427,
-0.14466916024684906,
-0.216840460896492,
-0.27331310510635376,
0.2674809694290161,
0.2835480868816376,
-0.4294649064540863,
-0.020951656624674797,
-0.1846129298210144,
0.5137709975242615,
0.6827911138534546,
0.01387240830808878,
0.5747546553611755,
-0.28323596715927124,
0.896999716758728,
-0.09977994859218597,
0.19567373394966125,
-0.4709760546684265,
-0.19141805171966553,
-0.3710970878601074,
-0.30147698521614075,
0.37732958793640137,
0.25366055965423584,
-0.5558194518089294,
0.07983975112438202,
-0.23208962380886078,
-0.4172477126121521,
-0.7806008458137512,
-0.07988236099481583,
0.4530487656593323,
0.7181169986724854,
0.266087144613266,
-0.3504452109336853,
-0.16251789033412933,
-0.862727701663971,
-0.6764828562736511,
-0.35815978050231934,
-0.21501238644123077,
0.45132189989089966,
0.39932554960250854,
0.3377299904823303,
1.0827285051345825,
-0.2880402207374573,
0.3295569121837616,
-0.37363046407699585,
0.10556592047214508,
0.380220890045166,
0.541532576084137,
0.6001428961753845,
-0.5396705269813538,
-0.5196225047111511,
-0.4479748606681824,
-0.598639965057373,
-0.1650715321302414,
-0.2404482364654541,
0.22324571013450623,
-0.1800699383020401,
0.51422518491745,
-0.4901353716850281,
0.22265319526195526,
0.517052412033081,
-0.4363144338130951,
0.9612680673599243,
-0.11626400053501129,
0.46540045738220215,
-0.7561398148536682,
0.01082647405564785,
0.011771407909691334,
-0.39823776483535767,
-0.47786271572113037,
-0.15097938477993011,
-0.05727452039718628,
-0.4094702899456024,
-0.46338388323783875,
0.6439973711967468,
-0.41930699348449707,
-0.1422388106584549,
-0.12598292529582977,
-0.06261669099330902,
0.3007039427757263,
0.4213731586933136,
-0.12138644605875015,
0.9679446816444397,
0.4640170931816101,
-0.6294375658035278,
0.5269283056259155,
0.2226768285036087,
-0.5318279266357422,
0.3438214957714081,
-1.0392824411392212,
-0.07353576272726059,
0.008239931426942348,
0.08413730561733246,
-1.1460782289505005,
-0.3813565671443939,
-0.04448139667510986,
-0.6559657454490662,
0.09884007275104523,
-0.4120151996612549,
-0.49944397807121277,
-0.18009059131145477,
-0.1720699816942215,
0.6263077855110168,
0.7198134064674377,
-0.709886372089386,
0.4962012767791748,
-0.20069235563278198,
-0.26568153500556946,
-0.300140380859375,
-0.4764763414859772,
-0.312406986951828,
-0.5667217373847961,
-0.40602946281433105,
0.07271161675453186,
0.013759703375399113,
-0.4987356662750244,
-0.036787278950214386,
0.14103399217128754,
-0.16103394329547882,
0.424207866191864,
0.20932216942310333,
0.18020905554294586,
-0.6254004836082458,
0.08617204427719116,
-0.34832724928855896,
-0.2651998698711395,
0.4086628258228302,
0.05084779113531113,
0.5686935782432556,
-0.15791058540344238,
-0.512843132019043,
-0.6857120990753174,
0.4235544204711914,
0.5487383604049683,
-0.33946770429611206,
1.159864068031311,
0.2920406460762024,
-0.23460279405117035,
-0.0026330247055739164,
-0.2791001796722412,
-0.6964934468269348,
-0.49416640400886536,
0.11382091045379639,
-0.2557443380355835,
-0.6585572361946106,
0.7880481481552124,
0.10609754174947739,
-0.17014291882514954,
0.44896602630615234,
0.5058369636535645,
-0.11250544339418411,
1.1358562707901,
0.593480110168457,
0.1362714320421219,
0.7864089012145996,
0.2547186017036438,
0.12972915172576904,
-0.3128300607204437,
0.035139136016368866,
-0.6848984956741333,
-0.1290416568517685,
-0.5139046311378479,
-0.03718843683600426,
0.10989434272050858,
0.2125307321548462,
-0.27269360423088074,
0.07717999070882797,
-0.2704117000102997,
0.7400451898574829,
0.6059627532958984,
0.0011028655571863055,
0.05255095288157463,
-0.055538956075906754,
0.35139578580856323,
0.0010711413342505693,
-0.8066545128822327,
-0.7285085320472717,
0.8621934056282043,
0.5579977035522461,
0.7582825422286987,
0.11441414803266525,
0.39726847410202026,
0.16389991343021393,
0.1490432620048523,
-0.9648364186286926,
0.3425391614437103,
-0.10871387273073196,
-0.6429720520973206,
-0.4685404598712921,
-0.4354571998119354,
-0.8470088839530945,
-0.01583712361752987,
-0.35795438289642334,
-0.7242322564125061,
0.09207020699977875,
0.5358755588531494,
-0.9220210313796997,
-0.17818398773670197,
-1.0319733619689941,
1.261723279953003,
-0.201602041721344,
-0.338833749294281,
-0.15799106657505035,
-0.36490413546562195,
0.46788913011550903,
-0.10319536924362183,
0.20385326445102692,
-0.06209823489189148,
0.3087499141693115,
0.9985823631286621,
-0.4243077039718628,
0.7908267378807068,
-0.3765600323677063,
-0.14103516936302185,
0.3863930106163025,
0.14420190453529358,
0.5164320468902588,
0.02603081613779068,
-0.25103306770324707,
-0.0938967764377594,
-0.035794056951999664,
-0.45420727133750916,
-0.9164595007896423,
0.6399656534194946,
-0.666893482208252,
-0.47944769263267517,
-0.01706017553806305,
-0.47894373536109924,
-0.2605902850627899,
0.07903984189033508,
0.5453260540962219,
0.8259966373443604,
0.08887270838022232,
0.22990475594997406,
0.8806802034378052,
-0.5322591066360474,
0.40531912446022034,
0.5126038789749146,
-0.06462056189775467,
0.1866125911474228,
0.8959071636199951,
0.03062247298657894,
0.4045674502849579,
-0.1595805138349533,
0.4516698122024536,
-0.4590025246143341,
-0.41771960258483887,
-0.282489150762558,
0.19819006323814392,
-0.7305137515068054,
-0.0425562784075737,
-0.2717065215110779,
0.05455514043569565,
-0.3187415897846222,
-0.4198845624923706,
-0.5337177515029907,
-0.07665973156690598,
-0.5880232453346252,
0.06444697827100754,
0.4232560992240906,
0.5696215629577637,
0.11072299629449844,
0.7956426739692688,
-0.6777300834655762,
0.13254685699939728,
0.37264755368232727,
0.498996764421463,
0.2647551894187927,
-1.0270339250564575,
-0.3304671347141266,
0.01166516076773405,
0.03189738467335701,
-1.0378800630569458,
0.20405416190624237,
0.15791650116443634,
0.5772570967674255,
0.5121221542358398,
-0.0006032432429492474,
0.6172309517860413,
-0.3390730321407318,
1.0364534854888916,
0.2270360291004181,
-0.9847187995910645,
0.7163686156272888,
-0.33183860778808594,
0.3015008568763733,
0.6113219857215881,
0.4860636293888092,
-0.3175426125526428,
-0.13621366024017334,
-0.7555737495422363,
-0.5325615406036377,
0.990496814250946,
-0.13379530608654022,
0.17179293930530548,
0.19998200237751007,
0.5688192248344421,
0.48396652936935425,
-0.05627403408288956,
-0.7616441249847412,
-0.06886252760887146,
-0.34086447954177856,
-0.4415614604949951,
-0.35213911533355713,
-0.45666760206222534,
0.0997987613081932,
-0.07524707913398743,
0.5580511689186096,
-0.025546832010149956,
0.4508156180381775,
-0.32253652811050415,
-0.3161381781101227,
-0.03970314934849739,
0.2773475646972656,
0.4529046416282654,
0.7706326842308044,
0.08437757194042206,
0.2355477213859558,
-0.003521890379488468,
-0.17880120873451233,
0.20740585029125214,
-0.05637074261903763,
0.1095719113945961,
0.014909480698406696,
0.9133091568946838,
1.0235837697982788,
-0.06611661612987518,
-0.36557111144065857,
0.9254458546638489,
-0.11963119357824326,
-0.0016333700623363256,
-0.05401340872049332,
0.26232367753982544,
-0.13766738772392273,
0.25472432374954224,
0.1381346434354782,
-0.12081091105937958,
0.032061006873846054,
-0.6370313763618469,
-0.09932194650173187,
0.35169774293899536,
-0.6209479570388794,
-0.5172819495201111,
0.45014727115631104,
0.10100016742944717,
-0.2757871747016907,
0.777909517288208,
-0.10484667867422104,
-0.31508395075798035,
0.4638608992099762,
0.4861561357975006,
0.54754239320755,
-0.25885507464408875,
0.3410681188106537,
0.4960264265537262,
0.1475396454334259,
-0.4182819724082947,
0.022471986711025238,
-0.12125871330499649,
-0.7944948077201843,
-0.8274277448654175,
-0.7168486714363098,
-0.12197205424308777,
0.28394463658332825,
-1.0052917003631592,
-0.004841579124331474,
-0.2100757211446762,
-0.037140101194381714,
0.18923288583755493,
-0.210641548037529,
-0.8274890184402466,
0.17855577170848846,
0.011750738136470318,
0.8137129545211792,
-1.3857910633087158,
0.6452917456626892,
0.524087131023407,
-0.6066374182701111,
-1.1882870197296143,
-0.011103211902081966,
-0.2182101309299469,
-1.0958276987075806,
0.5610130429267883,
0.22566725313663483,
0.01749446988105774,
0.1827884018421173,
-0.8335811495780945,
-0.7530496120452881,
0.7465043663978577,
0.825593888759613,
-0.1975557804107666,
0.03526295721530914,
-0.1275814026594162,
0.3718130886554718,
-0.36415451765060425,
0.31672993302345276,
0.7693685293197632,
0.37367749214172363,
-0.15276581048965454,
-0.8525474667549133,
0.17924706637859344,
0.05998745933175087,
-0.13321083784103394,
-0.20346865057945251,
-0.09452951699495316,
0.9502722024917603,
-0.2090529352426529,
-0.2964106798171997,
-0.16812533140182495,
0.6525917053222656,
0.31303325295448303,
0.10369665175676346,
0.6332300305366516,
-0.14652642607688904,
0.6573066115379333,
-0.14731231331825256,
1.3097279071807861,
-0.032976873219013214,
0.24028244614601135,
0.9551830887794495,
0.17843177914619446,
0.542145311832428,
0.6905726194381714,
-0.2879966199398041,
0.5684073567390442,
0.8941705226898193,
0.14004693925380707,
0.6896219253540039,
0.005743424873799086,
-0.034106701612472534,
-0.4613788425922394,
-0.43514835834503174,
-0.007684684824198484,
0.5615037679672241,
0.17288029193878174,
-0.6313905119895935,
-0.21853107213974,
0.27842238545417786,
-0.24102793633937836,
0.1368352472782135,
-0.6985253095626831,
0.7603527307510376,
0.1388207972049713,
-0.7134321928024292,
0.6533430814743042,
-0.2031506597995758,
0.42092740535736084,
-0.5719994306564331,
0.06945247948169708,
-0.1397412121295929,
-0.002461174502968788,
-0.08744829893112183,
-0.9527584314346313,
0.11259542405605316,
0.2438807636499405,
-0.6429688334465027,
-0.6830992102622986,
0.6520690321922302,
-0.3893396854400635,
-0.24176417291164398,
-0.18009577691555023,
0.7581357359886169,
0.37851184606552124,
-0.317389577627182,
-0.5627722144126892,
-0.027377337217330933,
-0.035240501165390015,
-0.42627838253974915,
0.1798691749572754,
0.7817617058753967,
-0.15972332656383514,
0.5555965304374695,
0.5404833555221558,
0.09003311395645142,
-0.166157066822052,
-0.060346003621816635,
0.6332249045372009,
-0.5370842218399048,
-0.5923178791999817,
-1.1850420236587524,
0.5309078693389893,
0.1479896754026413,
-0.3311016261577606,
0.746487557888031,
0.16210909187793732,
0.4159770607948303,
-0.2760704457759857,
0.7119005918502808,
0.15767571330070496,
0.5420593619346619,
-0.6916320323944092,
0.7035738825798035,
-0.5240545272827148,
0.11757641285657883,
0.04324355348944664,
-0.840889573097229,
0.07358035445213318,
0.7862263917922974,
-0.6101889610290527,
0.18176297843456268,
0.5182381868362427,
0.5855492353439331,
-0.18030984699726105,
-0.013387775048613548,
0.2667900025844574,
0.13946174085140228,
0.22502869367599487,
0.3296876847743988,
1.0849665403366089,
0.017803145572543144,
0.4797716736793518,
0.1588985174894333,
-0.292501837015152,
-0.3347363770008087,
-1.0760612487792969,
-0.695667028427124,
-0.5595179200172424,
-0.20768478512763977,
-0.3413037061691284,
-0.3489013910293579,
0.7307071685791016,
0.4217435419559479,
-0.8920401930809021,
0.1263606697320938,
0.04802336543798447,
-0.011490274220705032,
-0.2532721757888794,
-0.26087498664855957,
0.3497491478919983,
-0.40299054980278015,
-0.28421100974082947,
0.32705098390579224,
-0.2766517102718353,
0.2532409727573395,
-0.37900426983833313,
-0.1869441717863083,
0.3220583498477936,
0.16449953615665436,
0.4441680908203125,
0.1982676088809967,
-0.7218313813209534,
-0.4500714838504791,
-0.036161020398139954,
-0.18902701139450073,
-0.17229825258255005,
1.042466402053833,
-0.8565757274627686,
0.11190633475780487,
0.32653823494911194,
0.47616323828697205,
0.026596665382385254,
0.20545101165771484,
0.8603397011756897,
-0.8505391478538513,
-0.014173179864883423,
0.15542075037956238,
0.36185699701309204,
0.5386521220207214,
-0.3476685881614685,
0.03894541412591934,
0.015046931803226471,
-0.47759419679641724,
-0.9354541301727295,
0.43301594257354736,
-0.6298730969429016,
-0.3038785755634308,
1.249750018119812,
-0.38286662101745605,
-0.21571215987205505,
-0.058742716908454895,
-0.015416352078318596,
0.42838937044143677,
-0.3856273591518402,
0.7034866809844971,
0.9587602615356445,
-0.05876215919852257,
-0.27515143156051636,
-0.6134775280952454,
0.8278149962425232,
0.32626742124557495,
-0.5660403370857239,
0.5618820786476135,
0.5532809495925903,
0.2858559489250183,
0.0672735646367073,
0.630352258682251,
0.047769010066986084,
0.2777858376502991,
0.09382542222738266,
-0.28398364782333374,
-0.34629425406455994,
-0.21159033477306366,
-0.7118070721626282,
0.11641689389944077,
0.3782675862312317,
-0.18552269041538239
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.05330v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.05330v2
|
Consecutive Model Editing with Batch alongside HooK Layers
| 2024-03-08T14:07:44 | 2024-04-17T07:23:35 |
Shuaiyi Li, Yang Deng, Deng Cai, Hongyuan Lu, Liang Chen, Wai Lam
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
As the typical retraining paradigm is unacceptably time- and
resource-consuming, researchers are turning to model editing in order to seek
an effective, consecutive, and batch-supportive way to edit the model behavior
directly. Despite all these practical expectations, existing model editing
methods fail to realize all of them. Furthermore, the memory demands for such
succession-supportive model editing approaches tend to be prohibitive,
frequently necessitating an external memory that grows incrementally over time.
To cope with these challenges, we propose COMEBA-HK, a model editing method
that is both consecutive and batch-supportive. COMEBA-HK is memory-friendly as
it only needs a small amount of it to store several hook layers with updated
weights. Experimental results demonstrate the superiority of our method over
other batch-supportive model editing methods under both single-round and
consecutive batch editing scenarios. Extensive analyses of COMEBA-HK have been
conducted to verify the stability of our method over 1) the number of
consecutive steps and 2) the number of editing instance.
|
[
-0.041033465415239334,
-0.8518540859222412,
0.41309648752212524,
0.5924234986305237,
-0.14346720278263092,
-0.10423475503921509,
-0.169368177652359,
-0.33309662342071533,
0.04055475816130638,
0.6589160561561584,
-0.8528825640678406,
-0.41813430190086365,
-0.10544871538877487,
0.10930223017930984,
-0.37108615040779114,
0.8591979146003723,
-0.47277194261550903,
0.27104002237319946,
-0.1345512866973877,
-0.45463255047798157,
-1.1097419261932373,
-0.5583768486976624,
-1.06868314743042,
-0.24996770918369293,
0.7582446336746216,
0.22433660924434662,
0.6048809885978699,
0.9309553503990173,
0.6101025938987732,
0.24267417192459106,
-0.2555524408817291,
0.20554107427597046,
-0.24542440474033356,
0.26438814401626587,
-0.22869211435317993,
-0.44213953614234924,
-1.0005803108215332,
-0.03370391204953194,
0.8192195892333984,
0.6672112941741943,
-0.40711498260498047,
0.2993498146533966,
-0.2082969844341278,
0.9315570592880249,
-0.596446692943573,
-0.38421541452407837,
-0.6260666847229004,
0.22152425348758698,
-0.20369571447372437,
0.04453759640455246,
-0.8923991918563843,
-0.046864353120326996,
-0.15130001306533813,
-0.9051988124847412,
0.3518255650997162,
-0.15106238424777985,
0.5956853032112122,
0.3429781496524811,
-0.041407860815525055,
0.3328979015350342,
-0.6847149729728699,
0.6529911756515503,
-0.9817708134651184,
0.5990972518920898,
0.1422770768404007,
0.18006190657615662,
-0.4358954131603241,
-1.1297557353973389,
-0.24216537177562714,
-0.20798347890377045,
0.3981361389160156,
0.12091652303934097,
0.4368947148323059,
-0.004919544328004122,
0.4810449182987213,
0.12647297978401184,
-0.14870673418045044,
0.3739268183708191,
-0.17220325767993927,
-0.0021617612801492214,
0.5373588800430298,
0.4332761764526367,
0.40184858441352844,
0.15621104836463928,
-0.5149964690208435,
0.029628388583660126,
-0.9442039728164673,
0.20065093040466309,
0.21731789410114288,
0.41822347044944763,
0.07975722849369049,
0.49634480476379395,
0.057437580078840256,
0.85981285572052,
0.40065476298332214,
0.2570302188396454,
-0.05540916696190834,
-0.290548175573349,
-0.44384750723838806,
-0.06779810041189194,
0.5484294891357422,
0.4836977422237396,
-0.0661756694316864,
0.07130107283592224,
-0.23361799120903015,
-0.32755306363105774,
0.8895648121833801,
-0.9340993762016296,
-0.3662263751029968,
0.32619190216064453,
-0.6967511773109436,
-0.2927805185317993,
-0.13694357872009277,
-0.43622997403144836,
-0.32528311014175415,
-0.24350199103355408,
0.3428477346897125,
-0.6060664057731628,
-0.020129889249801636,
-0.024724923074245453,
-0.3666279911994934,
-0.20065854489803314,
0.9626092910766602,
-0.6924877166748047,
0.13206705451011658,
0.5476197004318237,
1.1130506992340088,
0.02288844995200634,
-0.49582281708717346,
-0.37163323163986206,
0.3614680767059326,
-0.8309375047683716,
0.5427122116088867,
-0.658226728439331,
-0.6494844555854797,
-0.3165576756000519,
0.24715648591518402,
0.17253559827804565,
-0.6412681341171265,
0.1840611696243286,
-0.59048992395401,
0.0923951119184494,
-0.40821975469589233,
-0.7702128887176514,
-0.13415102660655975,
-0.015658045187592506,
-0.744343101978302,
0.9099380970001221,
0.11720746755599976,
-0.5708646774291992,
0.6564105749130249,
-0.39107629656791687,
-0.2958907186985016,
-0.31887322664260864,
0.2147340476512909,
-0.8105193972587585,
0.14575277268886566,
0.32707706093788147,
0.3133215606212616,
0.14355938136577606,
0.3542441725730896,
-0.7368865013122559,
-0.20729896426200867,
0.16197466850280762,
0.0026237862184643745,
0.7405409812927246,
-0.08281910419464111,
0.19081707298755646,
0.5134860277175903,
-0.9135139584541321,
-0.2695918679237366,
0.057822518050670624,
-0.2784164845943451,
-0.4509349465370178,
0.0027399531099945307,
-0.1947166472673416,
0.294107049703598,
0.24310998618602753,
-0.49470090866088867,
0.6468303799629211,
0.24203085899353027,
0.18232999742031097,
1.2721996307373047,
0.4115402400493622,
0.10327477753162384,
-0.6974968314170837,
0.4235314130783081,
0.3142412602901459,
0.27247366309165955,
-0.47557780146598816,
-0.4420541524887085,
-0.691077709197998,
-0.23808324337005615,
0.31059202551841736,
0.38627889752388,
-0.477591872215271,
0.001355774817056954,
0.22057440876960754,
-0.6717174649238586,
-0.45369309186935425,
0.4461071193218231,
0.2579804062843323,
0.7652148008346558,
0.5163229703903198,
-0.8683344721794128,
-0.6882532238960266,
-0.7027324438095093,
-0.3643780052661896,
0.12910273671150208,
0.0539088137447834,
-0.0448080450296402,
0.3362358808517456,
0.08832550793886185,
0.7156277894973755,
-0.323411762714386,
-0.0827636569738388,
0.09460335969924927,
0.018975388258695602,
0.2040485143661499,
0.90427565574646,
0.5860233306884766,
-0.4342508316040039,
-0.2769744098186493,
-0.249359130859375,
-0.9309929609298706,
0.054838258773088455,
-0.7759441137313843,
-0.42005184292793274,
0.19748368859291077,
0.6023412942886353,
-0.548664927482605,
0.436261922121048,
0.028324440121650696,
-0.17537657916545868,
0.8681102991104126,
-0.48915883898735046,
0.15834058821201324,
-0.9236059188842773,
0.02064952254295349,
0.10066737979650497,
-0.4458421468734741,
-0.6796759366989136,
0.2139667421579361,
0.31862813234329224,
-0.02529500052332878,
-0.5133739113807678,
0.5510004162788391,
-0.5043453574180603,
0.13206887245178223,
-0.1948866993188858,
-0.19858059287071228,
-0.07647056132555008,
0.5459979772567749,
0.212837353348732,
0.4700668752193451,
0.42756325006484985,
-0.777506947517395,
0.31575003266334534,
0.4146769046783447,
-0.26565468311309814,
0.4899401068687439,
-0.619213342666626,
0.6750949621200562,
0.06290663778781891,
0.664933979511261,
-0.6651082038879395,
-0.09379888325929642,
0.21771349012851715,
-0.09133031219244003,
0.599504292011261,
-0.2401946634054184,
-0.1784367710351944,
-0.19687731564044952,
-0.6958428621292114,
0.2242242991924286,
0.17038007080554962,
-0.5670785903930664,
0.32298779487609863,
0.09022953361272812,
-0.18310046195983887,
-0.6828915476799011,
-0.7484556436538696,
-0.03929416462779045,
-0.23887108266353607,
-0.5821346044540405,
0.40487679839134216,
-0.125341534614563,
-0.05231066048145294,
0.0886017456650734,
-0.5157509446144104,
-0.1299487203359604,
-0.030254367738962173,
0.29128482937812805,
0.7506484389305115,
-0.1801067590713501,
-0.24827978014945984,
0.15913625061511993,
-0.11910280585289001,
-0.23130656778812408,
-0.2560793161392212,
0.09869173169136047,
0.43477609753608704,
-0.04814452677965164,
-0.6475918292999268,
0.10034830123186111,
0.6419806480407715,
-0.05221546068787575,
0.8890945911407471,
0.3262043297290802,
-0.5401197671890259,
-0.48673510551452637,
-0.44359642267227173,
-0.011300470679998398,
-0.4735463261604309,
0.3654659390449524,
-0.5641589760780334,
-0.6254462599754333,
0.7636265158653259,
-0.11783472448587418,
0.5754510164260864,
0.27970951795578003,
0.4447101354598999,
-0.04012829437851906,
0.6704081892967224,
0.5496015548706055,
0.19538365304470062,
0.745884120464325,
-0.0268307626247406,
-0.20412904024124146,
-1.2162703275680542,
-0.050568025559186935,
-0.14698892831802368,
-0.3976411819458008,
-0.3335067927837372,
-0.32540571689605713,
0.17469874024391174,
0.12644816935062408,
-0.6189876794815063,
0.5038729906082153,
-0.33719658851623535,
0.10285738855600357,
0.4044229984283447,
0.521162211894989,
0.13700249791145325,
-0.39709585905075073,
0.13732004165649414,
-0.18411678075790405,
-0.7102996110916138,
-0.1857798844575882,
1.2367416620254517,
0.288849800825119,
0.793016791343689,
-0.0871657058596611,
0.6525546312332153,
0.21993450820446014,
0.3558107614517212,
-0.32858121395111084,
0.8191021680831909,
-0.43069329857826233,
-0.6631447076797485,
-0.23831963539123535,
-0.2669737637042999,
-0.41872167587280273,
0.05814250558614731,
0.11583935469388962,
-0.6845192909240723,
0.33981022238731384,
0.5740833282470703,
-0.44973912835121155,
0.756201982498169,
-0.5929915308952332,
0.9617200493812561,
0.031398527324199677,
-0.7182133793830872,
-0.4650297462940216,
-0.6969643831253052,
0.5132689476013184,
-0.3402319550514221,
0.08526716381311417,
0.09851222485303879,
-0.18760931491851807,
0.9170017838478088,
-1.1234443187713623,
0.7071136832237244,
-0.440978467464447,
-0.053559474647045135,
0.30539801716804504,
0.3789340853691101,
0.6647205948829651,
0.005123618524521589,
-0.09361234307289124,
0.0823553204536438,
-0.07457368075847626,
-0.23512640595436096,
-0.9313682317733765,
0.4529576599597931,
-0.4216032028198242,
-0.586694061756134,
-0.09600220620632172,
-0.6684480309486389,
-0.33793509006500244,
0.17938639223575592,
-0.0008336842874996364,
0.7349179983139038,
-0.006757844239473343,
0.06869339197874069,
0.2496860921382904,
-0.37802454829216003,
0.4468991458415985,
0.17262686789035797,
-0.7207245230674744,
-0.29514607787132263,
0.8087410926818848,
0.5378966927528381,
0.5686356425285339,
0.1400737315416336,
0.1607470065355301,
0.23054422438144684,
-0.5396820902824402,
-0.4093780219554901,
-0.04885721579194069,
-0.5512669682502747,
0.0151759572327137,
-0.471031129360199,
-0.13346707820892334,
-0.32444024085998535,
-0.6082401275634766,
-0.8752768039703369,
-0.7129086256027222,
0.07860487699508667,
0.05540592223405838,
0.5031306743621826,
0.6279271245002747,
-0.44945427775382996,
0.3371685743331909,
-0.7581362128257751,
0.6579969525337219,
0.025192763656377792,
0.5449373722076416,
0.21523350477218628,
-0.685452938079834,
-0.5054295063018799,
-0.17564870417118073,
-0.3061361610889435,
-0.7146908044815063,
0.21746748685836792,
0.034072957932949066,
0.28092214465141296,
0.216960608959198,
-0.1901661604642868,
1.1678651571273804,
-0.7650381326675415,
0.7941348552703857,
0.029977548867464066,
-0.8958457708358765,
0.5354825258255005,
-0.47477370500564575,
0.3166002035140991,
0.42702341079711914,
0.1451915055513382,
-0.6756414175033569,
-0.5756664276123047,
-0.5711178183555603,
-0.99103182554245,
0.9872100949287415,
-0.20156408846378326,
-0.09149393439292908,
0.31380850076675415,
0.5960055589675903,
0.46555131673812866,
0.41324901580810547,
-0.43108272552490234,
-0.29337871074676514,
-0.33837658166885376,
0.21532516181468964,
0.3837061822414398,
-0.3735174238681793,
0.20452910661697388,
-0.4645106792449951,
1.0696594715118408,
0.4734312891960144,
0.1948998123407364,
0.16178448498249054,
0.03746573254466057,
-0.26817768812179565,
0.07708892971277237,
0.34838974475860596,
0.946098804473877,
-0.8477394580841064,
-0.32026469707489014,
0.2396581470966339,
-0.6623900532722473,
0.39356663823127747,
-0.43090254068374634,
-0.37326228618621826,
-0.015356423333287239,
0.3241969347000122,
0.9595840573310852,
0.3986189067363739,
-0.1665005385875702,
-0.26462462544441223,
0.09713943302631378,
0.04467045143246651,
-0.13915127515792847,
0.16037611663341522,
-0.06843075901269913,
0.016951706260442734,
-0.02690715901553631,
0.36965569853782654,
-0.2454773634672165,
-0.5002236366271973,
0.38639020919799805,
-0.06888741999864578,
-0.09007682651281357,
-0.06113581731915474,
0.8757695555686951,
-0.06364826112985611,
-0.3979746699333191,
0.8952759504318237,
0.1505638211965561,
-0.00955697987228632,
0.6052280068397522,
0.6817690134048462,
1.0905879735946655,
-0.5434770584106445,
-0.06879483163356781,
0.6789581775665283,
0.16143307089805603,
-0.4575839936733246,
-0.023455986753106117,
0.21454572677612305,
-0.796329140663147,
-0.31038782000541687,
-0.1795198619365692,
-0.8066636919975281,
0.1742151975631714,
-0.945266604423523,
0.46407970786094666,
-1.1766374111175537,
-0.47123563289642334,
0.03610125556588173,
-0.3888340890407562,
-0.2263566553592682,
0.4309777319431305,
-0.13573741912841797,
1.1797069311141968,
-0.28815844655036926,
0.8655043840408325,
0.7787561416625977,
-0.43344923853874207,
-0.7491195797920227,
-0.15429621934890747,
0.41127437353134155,
-0.5238316059112549,
0.34392988681793213,
0.38738134503364563,
0.06587479263544083,
0.009321792982518673,
-0.6112114787101746,
-0.4800633490085602,
0.9955570697784424,
0.25151288509368896,
-0.7592175006866455,
-0.1691347360610962,
-0.6635076999664307,
0.2013336718082428,
-0.2994060814380646,
-0.10171394795179367,
0.1951490044593811,
0.3997792899608612,
0.09853272885084152,
-0.6091797351837158,
0.1553177535533905,
-0.3461512327194214,
0.1841937154531479,
0.12891076505184174,
-0.9130419492721558,
0.980377733707428,
-0.2825879752635956,
-0.0261670034378767,
0.23689569532871246,
0.9110238552093506,
0.42036664485931396,
0.1945076286792755,
0.5675644874572754,
0.779531717300415,
0.7150954604148865,
0.26622432470321655,
0.9827736020088196,
-0.25688132643699646,
0.14974825084209442,
1.646209955215454,
-0.5140655040740967,
0.8781416416168213,
0.27506205439567566,
-0.29995134472846985,
0.7683185935020447,
0.8337706923484802,
-0.1616543084383011,
0.419023334980011,
0.02085396647453308,
-0.1278100162744522,
-0.36122220754623413,
0.15476825833320618,
-0.24869321286678314,
0.12057717889547348,
-0.020927639678120613,
0.010825562290847301,
0.037729661911726,
0.023840663954615593,
0.40185773372650146,
-0.2533791959285736,
-0.5022058486938477,
0.35430338978767395,
0.35600072145462036,
-0.5288362503051758,
0.13360171020030975,
0.14629457890987396,
0.42697444558143616,
-0.839421808719635,
-0.044625651091337204,
-0.18255244195461273,
0.385021448135376,
-0.12137891352176666,
-0.6344267129898071,
0.4208010137081146,
0.2564104199409485,
-0.0834074541926384,
-0.3329356014728546,
0.6446595788002014,
-0.30333659052848816,
-0.6555363535881042,
0.28411903977394104,
0.20122945308685303,
-0.19450464844703674,
0.16130952537059784,
-0.7312279939651489,
0.10445201396942139,
-0.1258794367313385,
-0.6624087691307068,
0.43734249472618103,
0.25642096996307373,
-0.262124627828598,
0.7756026387214661,
0.7653040885925293,
0.1998116821050644,
0.15638411045074463,
0.1590053141117096,
0.5096320509910583,
-1.0120811462402344,
-0.5961008071899414,
-1.11414635181427,
0.8161705136299133,
0.02651541493833065,
-0.22788557410240173,
0.7842833399772644,
0.3700874149799347,
0.8892948627471924,
-0.12032271921634674,
0.7169239521026611,
-0.049038756638765335,
0.1837688684463501,
-0.8629903197288513,
0.6140909194946289,
-0.5829574465751648,
-0.0059426650404930115,
-0.4747192859649658,
-0.6922515034675598,
-0.32464897632598877,
0.4261746406555176,
-0.04299873113632202,
0.037523385137319565,
0.6812750101089478,
0.6956109404563904,
-0.02769060619175434,
0.07298583537340164,
0.07625861465930939,
0.46826714277267456,
0.2587142884731293,
0.5413339138031006,
0.6210987567901611,
-0.25792306661605835,
-0.3746086657047272,
-0.5532509088516235,
-0.020382462069392204,
0.23513874411582947,
-1.005152940750122,
-0.821596622467041,
-0.49767953157424927,
-0.5980976819992065,
-0.33498671650886536,
0.18337871134281158,
1.163630723953247,
0.5459328889846802,
-0.6507743000984192,
-0.39937853813171387,
-0.033279187977313995,
0.050867579877376556,
-0.7628182172775269,
-0.13241668045520782,
0.38081368803977966,
-0.47503194212913513,
-0.4157952070236206,
0.5964825749397278,
0.41493144631385803,
-0.11782073974609375,
0.07233282923698425,
0.10725678503513336,
-0.5077022910118103,
0.08059143275022507,
0.28093937039375305,
0.41790634393692017,
-0.24514076113700867,
-0.30029356479644775,
-0.3285791873931885,
0.2928495407104492,
0.19977304339408875,
0.9477328062057495,
-0.6739005446434021,
0.9105467200279236,
0.25034064054489136,
0.7357192635536194,
0.5072565674781799,
0.11316103488206863,
0.9618650674819946,
-0.7532694935798645,
0.34000784158706665,
-0.3810707926750183,
0.47410643100738525,
0.4104899764060974,
-0.33685120940208435,
0.6520025730133057,
0.5414788126945496,
-0.5291432738304138,
-1.0031421184539795,
-0.16958779096603394,
-1.08128821849823,
-0.30293336510658264,
0.6066629886627197,
-0.5275787711143494,
-0.30207929015159607,
0.30094772577285767,
-0.22765426337718964,
0.7136934995651245,
-0.20771397650241852,
0.6575374007225037,
0.9283962845802307,
-0.2540156841278076,
-0.20704799890518188,
-0.8073210716247559,
0.20538774132728577,
0.3463357388973236,
-0.6716522574424744,
0.33013349771499634,
0.7472400665283203,
0.18469968438148499,
-0.1489093154668808,
0.7694317698478699,
-0.13312216103076935,
0.5604498982429504,
0.22888243198394775,
0.08170472085475922,
-0.6310042142868042,
-0.5860087275505066,
-0.35116949677467346,
0.02878071367740631,
0.04692574217915535,
-0.3199237585067749
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.