id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09750v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09750v1
|
Meta-Cognitive Analysis: Evaluating Declarative and Procedural Knowledge in Datasets and Large Language Models
| 2024-03-14T05:34:35 | 2024-03-14T05:34:35 |
Zhuoqun Li, Hongyu Lin, Yaojie Lu, Hao Xiang, Xianpei Han, Le Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Declarative knowledge and procedural knowledge are two key parts in
meta-cognitive theory, and these two hold significant importance in
pre-training and inference of LLMs. However, a comprehensive analysis comparing
these two types of knowledge is lacking, primarily due to challenges in
definition, probing and quantitative assessment. In this paper, we explore from
a new perspective by providing ground-truth knowledge for LLMs and evaluating
the effective score. Through extensive experiments with widely-used datasets
and models, we get conclusions: (1) In most tasks, benefits from declarative
knowledge are greater than those from procedural knowledge. (2) Profits of
procedural knowledge are larger than declarative knowledge only in reasoning
tasks with simple logic. (3) As pre-training progresses and size increases,
model ability to utilize both kinds of knowledge significantly improves, but in
different speed. We do detailed analysis for the findings and this can provide
primary guidance for evaluation and enhancement of large language models.
|
[
-0.2402600198984146,
-0.9866336584091187,
1.0612547397613525,
0.04470760002732277,
-0.2398744523525238,
0.14530619978904724,
-0.5607975125312805,
-0.2588992416858673,
-0.037249743938446045,
0.6477038264274597,
-0.5247339010238647,
-0.6281396746635437,
-0.7416295409202576,
-0.02565283328294754,
-0.23365946114063263,
0.7177086472511292,
0.20602263510227203,
0.2152075469493866,
-0.6281277537345886,
0.048260144889354706,
-0.530918538570404,
-0.5208014249801636,
-0.48745331168174744,
-0.18031466007232666,
0.3958626091480255,
0.05271286517381668,
0.4893428683280945,
0.34681081771850586,
0.7897766828536987,
0.4173276722431183,
0.063182532787323,
0.08506529033184052,
-0.4839645326137543,
0.07389845699071884,
-0.36408287286758423,
-0.5172356367111206,
-0.3977837860584259,
0.17689886689186096,
0.747678279876709,
1.0439863204956055,
-0.24427297711372375,
0.20553739368915558,
0.05178111046552658,
0.7981699705123901,
-0.7291274070739746,
0.502722442150116,
-0.7290300130844116,
-0.03555753454566002,
-0.14218421280384064,
-0.23057791590690613,
-0.2949463725090027,
-0.6442371606826782,
0.3239760100841522,
-0.565342366695404,
-0.07925187051296234,
-0.44433116912841797,
0.3904776871204376,
0.4395791292190552,
-0.7485119700431824,
-0.6034631729125977,
-0.808944582939148,
0.9598450660705566,
-0.600548267364502,
0.5565814971923828,
0.2247261255979538,
0.34594765305519104,
0.03546274080872536,
-0.8614397644996643,
-0.3644337058067322,
-0.3539223372936249,
-0.08281106501817703,
0.28542497754096985,
0.08099842816591263,
0.3195939362049103,
0.33926156163215637,
0.40799522399902344,
-0.33924025297164917,
-0.09204315394163132,
-0.498271644115448,
-0.3523724675178528,
0.5958597660064697,
0.3677733242511749,
0.21536244451999664,
-0.06339044868946075,
-0.20575445890426636,
0.015991298481822014,
-0.5985434651374817,
-0.06372521817684174,
0.29845795035362244,
0.1660211682319641,
0.05623975768685341,
0.47920310497283936,
-0.14612795412540436,
1.0330415964126587,
0.0009867276530712843,
-0.5524378418922424,
0.31889498233795166,
-0.5721193552017212,
-0.16336463391780853,
-0.4594202935695648,
0.8959915041923523,
0.16554878652095795,
0.5356944799423218,
-0.2947457730770111,
0.059179604053497314,
0.10433745384216309,
0.2723679840564728,
-0.7495328187942505,
0.17341086268424988,
-0.06289887428283691,
-0.5930464863777161,
-0.25335440039634705,
0.21689318120479584,
-0.7213944792747498,
-0.25745609402656555,
-0.7958224415779114,
-0.08643174171447754,
-0.2972303032875061,
-0.44955623149871826,
0.24802610278129578,
-0.09968206286430359,
0.47209298610687256,
0.40708693861961365,
-0.6345254778862,
0.39909598231315613,
1.015709400177002,
0.6420150399208069,
-0.40009114146232605,
-0.17964261770248413,
-0.22944432497024536,
-0.10773122310638428,
-0.5083494186401367,
0.7518631219863892,
-0.8926368355751038,
-0.33709973096847534,
0.11446251720190048,
-0.04177020117640495,
-0.5063380002975464,
-0.5369330644607544,
0.569727897644043,
-0.7680421471595764,
0.3434286415576935,
-0.5737941265106201,
-0.5340220928192139,
-0.47108083963394165,
0.3738459646701813,
-0.6161289215087891,
0.6725537776947021,
0.08510146290063858,
-0.6693938374519348,
0.5565214157104492,
-0.546690821647644,
-0.5400162935256958,
-0.07592891156673431,
-0.3976115584373474,
0.1284433901309967,
0.4452531039714813,
-0.10929907858371735,
0.246288001537323,
-0.5250710248947144,
0.5393373370170593,
-0.3349388837814331,
-0.13278794288635254,
0.48630794882774353,
-0.44276562333106995,
0.8311120867729187,
0.13735537230968475,
-0.12576214969158173,
-0.21383443474769592,
-0.680174708366394,
0.2083563208580017,
-0.27424243092536926,
-0.5123846530914307,
-0.10285156965255737,
-0.11863614618778229,
-0.5261721014976501,
0.2609863877296448,
0.2623220980167389,
-0.26370730996131897,
0.03250713273882866,
-0.299444317817688,
0.3595810532569885,
0.5164869427680969,
0.24109405279159546,
0.5461554527282715,
-0.20535598695278168,
0.6401523947715759,
-0.24554502964019775,
0.16902193427085876,
0.053509898483753204,
-0.35089853405952454,
-0.6320071816444397,
-0.40617454051971436,
0.6632072329521179,
0.5503419637680054,
-0.7727481722831726,
0.5378050804138184,
-0.36289191246032715,
-0.274320513010025,
-0.2771977186203003,
0.08748529851436615,
0.3821307122707367,
0.5391051769256592,
0.27978289127349854,
-0.468173623085022,
-0.4667830467224121,
-0.7978132963180542,
-0.4142104387283325,
-0.08563437312841415,
-0.044628120958805084,
0.40987077355384827,
0.593618631362915,
-0.35921239852905273,
0.9017215371131897,
-0.5020841956138611,
-0.062305692583322525,
-0.05318479612469673,
0.2132018357515335,
0.29140764474868774,
0.1852429062128067,
0.3213273584842682,
-0.4185129404067993,
-0.368038147687912,
-0.27581995725631714,
-0.9780851006507874,
-0.15096595883369446,
-0.08301457017660141,
0.06227380782365799,
-0.0642552375793457,
0.456498384475708,
-0.7310549020767212,
0.24586035311222076,
0.3821437954902649,
-0.07117615640163422,
0.6372801065444946,
-0.23388376832008362,
0.30440783500671387,
-0.4142252504825592,
-0.005755636375397444,
-0.35330402851104736,
-0.2632063627243042,
-0.7305434942245483,
0.1760813444852829,
-0.11468345671892166,
0.1889515519142151,
-0.2943055331707001,
0.32476499676704407,
-0.5358339548110962,
-0.2530468702316284,
-0.3586593270301819,
0.274650901556015,
-0.06997765600681305,
0.5084482431411743,
0.4506285488605499,
0.6282333731651306,
0.5299513339996338,
-0.7344211935997009,
0.3293190598487854,
-0.03680289909243584,
-0.6283721923828125,
0.3191126585006714,
-0.718560516834259,
0.3035385310649872,
-0.003876646049320698,
0.14365100860595703,
-1.009972333908081,
0.03799876198172569,
0.12465674430131912,
-0.3628580570220947,
0.1688975840806961,
-0.02305207960307598,
-0.2760034501552582,
-0.2558932900428772,
-0.2667040228843689,
0.44866353273391724,
0.6059095859527588,
-0.019306505098938942,
0.7713024616241455,
0.28058528900146484,
-0.06003950163722038,
-0.4810779094696045,
-0.5336862206459045,
-0.1180686429142952,
-0.21897582709789276,
-0.5469346046447754,
0.19729523360729218,
-0.08826221525669098,
-0.7054407596588135,
-0.09658705443143845,
-0.21971961855888367,
-0.235415980219841,
0.08956041932106018,
0.23700977861881256,
0.10373791307210922,
-0.21925252676010132,
0.21718499064445496,
-0.16397899389266968,
-0.4202629029750824,
0.5142219066619873,
-0.14901965856552124,
0.48014211654663086,
-0.164560467004776,
-0.6491193175315857,
-0.1954544633626938,
-0.31205984950065613,
0.6338778138160706,
-0.3219340741634369,
0.7230605483055115,
0.394756019115448,
-0.13787022233009338,
0.18318282067775726,
-0.8518083095550537,
-0.20868176221847534,
-0.39613622426986694,
0.1733657270669937,
-0.3886987268924713,
-0.6183916926383972,
0.3429035544395447,
-0.32949626445770264,
-0.11964660882949829,
0.6406902074813843,
0.631736695766449,
-0.10186762362718582,
0.428878515958786,
0.30103638768196106,
0.26200395822525024,
0.3745041489601135,
-0.39830753207206726,
-0.03616856783628464,
-0.9260007739067078,
-0.34684985876083374,
-0.31143516302108765,
0.0495448000729084,
-0.5263521075248718,
-0.7994648218154907,
0.296453058719635,
-0.21266192197799683,
-0.24189560115337372,
0.004982319660484791,
-0.04331599548459053,
0.37804287672042847,
0.3688465654850006,
0.3281024396419525,
0.5456966161727905,
-0.2164611518383026,
0.015048819594085217,
-0.13413460552692413,
-0.428350567817688,
-0.5775871276855469,
1.4702012538909912,
0.33679428696632385,
0.484756201505661,
-0.060784436762332916,
0.44027194380760193,
0.18479427695274353,
0.051359597593545914,
-0.8772733211517334,
0.6193931102752686,
-0.08596111088991165,
-0.7652504444122314,
-0.3460969030857086,
-0.5538501143455505,
-0.7631694674491882,
0.4233165681362152,
-0.32008132338523865,
-0.14784064888954163,
0.15616099536418915,
-0.41488492488861084,
-0.41057637333869934,
-0.06263194233179092,
-0.4640817940235138,
0.6800037622451782,
-0.459168404340744,
-0.3664676249027252,
-0.48481085896492004,
-0.5824406147003174,
0.7675023674964905,
-0.24296113848686218,
0.4767502248287201,
0.1032058447599411,
-0.3741660714149475,
1.008547067642212,
-0.3122740387916565,
0.9805388450622559,
-0.1792774498462677,
-0.2587963044643402,
0.5851093530654907,
-0.08703846484422684,
0.2757536470890045,
0.060897234827280045,
-0.1924901306629181,
0.18599817156791687,
0.052308231592178345,
-0.2170756757259369,
-0.9230711460113525,
0.32340553402900696,
-0.6247332692146301,
-0.9210736155509949,
-0.4510156512260437,
-0.41562744975090027,
-0.3788522481918335,
0.21218101680278778,
0.05610284209251404,
0.3780558407306671,
-0.4969286620616913,
0.3643253445625305,
0.9898175597190857,
-0.12922517955303192,
0.23846746981143951,
0.8918982744216919,
-0.08255891501903534,
-0.5674018859863281,
0.5810825228691101,
0.24508856236934662,
0.3583081364631653,
0.4258524775505066,
0.30327320098876953,
-0.3996419310569763,
-0.6259512901306152,
0.12916049361228943,
0.4418223202228546,
-0.7674428224563599,
0.0004894744488410652,
-0.6771694421768188,
-0.2010173350572586,
-0.24897760152816772,
0.19458115100860596,
-0.283270001411438,
-0.41312700510025024,
-0.05053476616740227,
-0.2683939039707184,
-0.011529200710356236,
0.7334786653518677,
-0.17709407210350037,
0.27994632720947266,
-0.7201456427574158,
0.3696606159210205,
0.744652509689331,
0.00480803893879056,
-0.041106127202510834,
-0.6537202596664429,
-0.06350120157003403,
0.30528128147125244,
-0.21162866055965424,
-0.8885663747787476,
-0.11890119314193726,
0.09264221787452698,
0.8571957945823669,
0.7971445322036743,
-0.14972390234470367,
0.6693784594535828,
-0.42182451486587524,
0.6415229439735413,
0.17911697924137115,
-1.00180184841156,
0.29561111330986023,
-0.24163416028022766,
0.09634391218423843,
0.912712574005127,
0.402281790971756,
-0.2756747603416443,
-0.07569718360900879,
-0.7626891732215881,
-0.22831860184669495,
0.44382306933403015,
0.18073822557926178,
0.07102880626916885,
-0.0605405829846859,
0.5109233260154724,
0.14603641629219055,
0.5561632513999939,
-0.5338906049728394,
0.05366859957575798,
0.13330739736557007,
-0.10490819811820984,
-0.06618333607912064,
-0.4742853045463562,
-0.2625749707221985,
-0.359367311000824,
0.3328298330307007,
0.006403411738574505,
0.14807558059692383,
-0.13904719054698944,
-0.5090382099151611,
0.16047918796539307,
0.095304936170578,
0.598300576210022,
1.2194589376449585,
-0.05410582199692726,
0.2087114155292511,
0.622042179107666,
-0.5905694365501404,
0.023615222424268723,
-0.4041471481323242,
0.17557160556316376,
-0.2882198393344879,
1.3002692461013794,
0.5483589768409729,
0.3648262619972229,
-0.5647460222244263,
0.7089524269104004,
0.18704654276371002,
-0.388033390045166,
-0.28466224670410156,
0.13703271746635437,
0.12317174673080444,
0.21319204568862915,
0.02122759073972702,
-0.005157715640962124,
0.24082940816879272,
-0.9467793107032776,
0.10324068367481232,
0.6915433406829834,
-0.2979291081428528,
-0.4620770812034607,
-0.03810722753405571,
0.3591350018978119,
0.07250487059354782,
0.8352785706520081,
0.014970771037042141,
-0.6606857180595398,
0.6487114429473877,
0.24175742268562317,
0.7312187552452087,
-0.29123327136039734,
0.28510338068008423,
0.44422364234924316,
0.39158016443252563,
-0.06230137124657631,
0.11819151788949966,
-0.30071622133255005,
-0.7595105171203613,
-0.5735939145088196,
-0.5502954721450806,
-0.26280906796455383,
0.05554373562335968,
-0.6970325112342834,
0.1199435219168663,
-0.3853476345539093,
-0.21526296436786652,
-0.34779685735702515,
0.363817036151886,
-0.8911281228065491,
0.3262198269367218,
-0.14562028646469116,
0.7652591466903687,
-0.9426358342170715,
0.6281213760375977,
0.3596208989620209,
-0.501129686832428,
-0.3871805667877197,
-0.04681572690606117,
-0.3040759265422821,
-1.211248755455017,
1.0470881462097168,
-0.09256552904844284,
-0.12320062518119812,
-0.3824685215950012,
-0.07114925980567932,
-0.9814414381980896,
1.217441201210022,
0.2557489275932312,
-0.6934038400650024,
-0.12890590727329254,
0.47596585750579834,
0.7485688924789429,
-0.5917951464653015,
0.8020033836364746,
0.931636393070221,
0.9378182291984558,
0.33589595556259155,
-0.7920961380004883,
0.10528281331062317,
0.36874163150787354,
-0.08172520250082016,
-0.06799887120723724,
-0.5106209516525269,
0.7590460181236267,
-0.13307642936706543,
-0.34143105149269104,
-0.319938063621521,
0.5318533778190613,
0.14859025180339813,
0.29579463601112366,
0.6004450917243958,
0.6687994599342346,
0.9544848799705505,
-0.056942734867334366,
0.8199223875999451,
-0.446011483669281,
0.2884669601917267,
1.0136349201202393,
-0.24757815897464752,
0.4892638027667999,
0.27900415658950806,
-0.5843701958656311,
0.810213029384613,
0.6902278065681458,
0.1468568593263626,
0.619537889957428,
0.4141630530357361,
0.02867223508656025,
-0.6032761335372925,
0.20647461712360382,
-0.536772608757019,
0.497531920671463,
0.47775545716285706,
-0.345131516456604,
-0.19960381090641022,
-0.08554841578006744,
-0.050104256719350815,
-0.0010941863292828202,
-0.15409910678863525,
1.1634962558746338,
0.21259094774723053,
-0.5666297078132629,
0.48012733459472656,
-0.21332411468029022,
0.2259405106306076,
-0.6216277480125427,
0.0013108056737110019,
-0.1422577202320099,
-0.06822728365659714,
-0.22237062454223633,
-0.6443954706192017,
0.6340665221214294,
-0.05762333422899246,
-0.17526642978191376,
-0.06593703478574753,
0.8879868388175964,
-0.3448837995529175,
-0.5316943526268005,
0.20890547335147858,
0.9278216361999512,
0.1953020989894867,
-0.3924042284488678,
-0.7010825276374817,
0.0986182913184166,
-0.13173025846481323,
-0.2690221965312958,
0.00017989863408729434,
0.7328293323516846,
0.14455857872962952,
0.5400403738021851,
0.7046524882316589,
0.12232668697834015,
-0.09419804066419601,
0.06334076821804047,
0.8937851786613464,
-0.8040482401847839,
-0.011773006990551949,
-1.1444381475448608,
0.4570716917514801,
-0.10098274797201157,
0.08676347136497498,
0.8864260911941528,
0.554637610912323,
0.37665218114852905,
-0.1815054714679718,
0.8330131769180298,
0.060719121247529984,
0.2924979627132416,
-0.7653891444206238,
0.20410633087158203,
-0.15262161195278168,
0.392822265625,
-0.12178084254264832,
-1.1536756753921509,
0.013317096047103405,
0.5557639598846436,
-1.0643401145935059,
0.3196221590042114,
1.129815697669983,
0.4464429020881653,
-0.033764105290174484,
-0.12937769293785095,
0.33403149247169495,
0.215348482131958,
0.05256086215376854,
0.6124278903007507,
1.2270992994308472,
-0.25217655301094055,
0.28522390127182007,
0.060545165091753006,
-0.4942704737186432,
-0.07850702106952667,
-0.933210015296936,
-1.2899218797683716,
-0.4886404275894165,
-0.22712069749832153,
-0.021300287917256355,
-0.03378312662243843,
0.34992700815200806,
0.606998860836029,
-0.5451571345329285,
-0.3086586594581604,
-0.2681983709335327,
0.4262876808643341,
-0.16964654624462128,
-0.17341719567775726,
0.23535682260990143,
-0.7060526609420776,
-0.4720856249332428,
0.4227682948112488,
0.03144235536456108,
-0.20850186049938202,
-0.3398631513118744,
-0.04245912656188011,
-0.02417490817606449,
0.3603501617908478,
0.7182722091674805,
-0.13063772022724152,
-0.618736743927002,
0.030171768739819527,
0.13415783643722534,
0.062454704195261,
-0.19936974346637726,
1.2817462682724,
-0.816188633441925,
0.294470876455307,
0.6618626117706299,
0.4393636882305145,
0.5159242153167725,
0.17488746345043182,
0.595924437046051,
-0.1961490511894226,
-0.034602027386426926,
0.11860678344964981,
0.31547096371650696,
0.07790544629096985,
-0.21047036349773407,
0.7408537268638611,
0.3892538249492645,
-0.42347773909568787,
-0.5686553120613098,
0.423665314912796,
-0.6944873332977295,
-0.42418548464775085,
1.2824183702468872,
-0.24292589724063873,
-0.06646643579006195,
-0.047756072133779526,
-0.009615481831133366,
0.1951904147863388,
-0.04531298950314522,
0.6560075879096985,
0.9469079375267029,
0.016276890411973,
0.08192562311887741,
-0.6001462340354919,
0.6024900078773499,
0.05992864444851875,
-0.9298766255378723,
0.10182108730077744,
0.3829483389854431,
0.5022369623184204,
0.3413212299346924,
0.7467814683914185,
-0.20162302255630493,
0.15658420324325562,
-0.04636785760521889,
-0.23329462110996246,
-0.2370775043964386,
-0.5281714797019958,
-0.3318910002708435,
0.17358890175819397,
0.02265804074704647,
-0.12998801469802856
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09113v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09113v2
|
AutoLoRA: Automatically Tuning Matrix Ranks in Low-Rank Adaptation Based on Meta Learning
| 2024-03-14T05:29:35 | 2024-03-17T17:55:47 |
Ruiyi Zhang, Rushi Qiang, Sai Ashish Somayajula, Pengtao Xie
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large-scale pretraining followed by task-specific finetuning has achieved
great success in various NLP tasks. Since finetuning all parameters of large
pretrained models poses substantial computational and memory challenges,
several efficient finetuning methods have been developed. Among them, low-rank
adaptation (LoRA), which finetunes low-rank incremental update matrices on top
of frozen pretrained weights, has proven particularly effective. Nonetheless,
LoRA's uniform rank assignment across all layers, along with its reliance on an
exhaustive search to find the best rank, leads to high computation costs and
suboptimal finetuning performance. To address these limitations, we introduce
AutoLoRA, a meta learning based framework for automatically identifying the
optimal rank of each LoRA layer. AutoLoRA associates each rank-1 matrix in a
low-rank update matrix with a selection variable, which determines whether the
rank-1 matrix should be discarded. A meta learning based method is developed to
learn these selection variables. The optimal rank is determined by thresholding
the values of these variables. Our comprehensive experiments on natural
language understanding, generation, and sequence labeling demonstrate the
effectiveness of AutoLoRA.
|
[
-0.3851756453514099,
-0.5926418900489807,
0.2690619230270386,
0.24006886780261993,
-0.26935631036758423,
0.08750470727682114,
-0.22513192892074585,
-0.2606196105480194,
0.26890647411346436,
0.2933256924152374,
-0.48210078477859497,
-0.5211420655250549,
-0.6747616529464722,
0.20124727487564087,
-0.15965446829795837,
1.1697614192962646,
0.18451900780200958,
-0.10959433019161224,
0.19911834597587585,
-0.2792114317417145,
-0.867402970790863,
-0.19013750553131104,
-0.9006438851356506,
-0.18768224120140076,
0.8480236530303955,
0.7877079844474792,
0.5959851145744324,
0.790178120136261,
0.41862982511520386,
0.3190227448940277,
0.17303887009620667,
0.35184967517852783,
-0.8307995200157166,
0.08912757784128189,
-0.43032482266426086,
-0.47321173548698425,
-0.8063008189201355,
0.03471316397190094,
0.5620094537734985,
0.6169295907020569,
-0.23280782997608185,
0.7125339508056641,
0.48973697423934937,
0.7468333840370178,
-1.026007890701294,
0.040863774716854095,
-1.103884220123291,
0.253682017326355,
-0.20374704897403717,
-0.6748012900352478,
-0.3242605924606323,
-0.31037768721580505,
-0.056827791035175323,
-0.7058395743370056,
-0.06102239340543747,
-0.024786822497844696,
0.7301808595657349,
0.9325676560401917,
-0.2378574013710022,
-0.16764278709888458,
-0.7978132367134094,
0.5469261407852173,
-0.6040549278259277,
0.07549205422401428,
0.5108566284179688,
0.4831617474555969,
0.06562069058418274,
-0.3921787142753601,
-0.23623859882354736,
0.03573926165699959,
0.048616304993629456,
0.1517108529806137,
-0.21278969943523407,
0.007594774477183819,
0.0775899738073349,
0.309692919254303,
-0.6200299859046936,
0.45687180757522583,
-0.2692941427230835,
0.19289898872375488,
0.5083696246147156,
-0.042090121656656265,
0.22055886685848236,
-0.12753601372241974,
-0.1628655642271042,
-0.3030155897140503,
-0.4770849943161011,
-0.16789302229881287,
0.2681257128715515,
0.42216920852661133,
0.19678698480129242,
0.3019552528858185,
-0.07023116946220398,
0.8510984182357788,
0.508359432220459,
-0.019811632111668587,
0.2097219079732895,
-0.036480583250522614,
-0.5887143611907959,
0.31939172744750977,
0.499431312084198,
0.07959222048521042,
0.2592652440071106,
-0.07778577506542206,
-0.06201035529375076,
-0.20045165717601776,
0.36196377873420715,
-0.5504082441329956,
-0.44648972153663635,
-0.04159291461110115,
-0.44595223665237427,
-0.42067429423332214,
-0.17342904210090637,
-0.8404136300086975,
-0.32768556475639343,
-0.4763169586658478,
1.0050883293151855,
-0.10176775604486465,
0.05002863332629204,
0.09068241715431213,
0.3277603089809418,
0.3154848515987396,
0.3580269515514374,
-1.201486587524414,
0.34719574451446533,
0.34838947653770447,
0.7415285706520081,
-0.34678032994270325,
-0.4739069938659668,
-0.8968892693519592,
0.07408333569765091,
-0.39490851759910583,
0.8356744050979614,
-0.2180824875831604,
0.12922681868076324,
-0.3203490078449249,
-0.013884421437978745,
-0.4938533306121826,
-0.5830917358398438,
0.22103872895240784,
-0.46286892890930176,
0.23536284267902374,
-0.08115550130605698,
-0.1405135840177536,
-0.028564533218741417,
0.015005255118012428,
-0.7121254205703735,
0.9425635933876038,
0.28069940209388733,
-0.5601052641868591,
0.4233323037624359,
-0.8884105086326599,
-0.2761994004249573,
-0.15873295068740845,
0.25807449221611023,
-0.39137041568756104,
0.14930514991283417,
0.19510777294635773,
0.2730713188648224,
-0.18256604671478271,
-0.010866280645132065,
-0.14557795226573944,
-0.23986373841762543,
-0.03743512183427811,
-0.3173657953739166,
0.6133078336715698,
0.4315796196460724,
-0.5188268423080444,
0.2153109908103943,
-0.7914600372314453,
0.2126135230064392,
0.013250810094177723,
-0.3754005432128906,
-0.2517645061016083,
-0.0008059286628849804,
-0.177835151553154,
0.348499059677124,
0.22138237953186035,
-0.06028999760746956,
0.3656144142150879,
-0.5177237391471863,
0.37014931440353394,
0.897296667098999,
-0.02909664250910282,
0.5369093418121338,
-0.11232466250658035,
0.44617322087287903,
-0.13739199936389923,
0.3651701807975769,
0.3323372006416321,
-0.17152343690395355,
-1.2096338272094727,
-0.04611925035715103,
0.6484165191650391,
0.7617889642715454,
-0.6513715982437134,
0.7331144213676453,
-0.2577921450138092,
-0.5506654977798462,
-0.6839874982833862,
0.6340336203575134,
0.3050185739994049,
0.3351006507873535,
0.8982738852500916,
-0.329639732837677,
-0.5871769785881042,
-0.8360904455184937,
-0.33737754821777344,
0.2029334008693695,
-0.005180187523365021,
0.15722085535526276,
0.35282960534095764,
-0.3439665734767914,
1.1459879875183105,
-0.5891574025154114,
-0.9516823887825012,
-0.04762914776802063,
0.24512064456939697,
0.2386568784713745,
0.7026399374008179,
0.7065833210945129,
-0.43235233426094055,
-0.7815655469894409,
-0.14466354250907898,
-0.4730396568775177,
-0.3714595437049866,
-0.20688165724277496,
-0.32610607147216797,
0.15494199097156525,
0.6118004322052002,
-0.10823732614517212,
0.2093905806541443,
0.7953692674636841,
-0.18349020183086395,
0.10508032888174057,
-0.5127807259559631,
-0.19751593470573425,
-1.0180854797363281,
0.40471091866493225,
-0.2854587137699127,
-0.5836383104324341,
-0.47085705399513245,
-0.3045916259288788,
-0.1929493546485901,
-0.13423775136470795,
-0.18804173171520233,
0.33187100291252136,
-0.37122657895088196,
-0.3172701597213745,
-0.48755741119384766,
0.08118985593318939,
-0.03378433734178543,
0.7464733123779297,
-0.16264404356479645,
0.6308834552764893,
0.19439394772052765,
-0.7177298069000244,
0.016969885677099228,
0.2588890492916107,
-0.17749620974063873,
0.4586581289768219,
-0.4271998405456543,
0.2325199991464615,
-0.059025008231401443,
0.31328263878822327,
-0.7389223575592041,
0.03601345047354698,
0.3190556764602661,
-0.17301975190639496,
0.2534305453300476,
-0.38839608430862427,
-0.37621980905532837,
-0.05218973383307457,
-0.07317135483026505,
0.4595648944377899,
0.3147411048412323,
-0.5803672075271606,
0.42767783999443054,
0.5128394365310669,
-0.19880777597427368,
-0.6358962655067444,
-0.41557830572128296,
0.1802065372467041,
-0.278449147939682,
0.12599606812000275,
0.36006590723991394,
-0.26452773809432983,
0.15214872360229492,
-0.29519984126091003,
0.052708689123392105,
-0.0272419061511755,
0.4845235049724579,
-0.039762262254953384,
-0.11127293109893799,
-0.22242093086242676,
0.13883864879608154,
0.14357706904411316,
-0.5105939507484436,
-0.16543811559677124,
-0.49296286702156067,
0.533419668674469,
-0.16099803149700165,
-0.1810886412858963,
-0.3262536823749542,
-0.02932204306125641,
0.5115683674812317,
-0.29782968759536743,
0.653313398361206,
0.9185310006141663,
-0.28483089804649353,
-0.5894151926040649,
-0.3639736473560333,
-0.026512296870350838,
-0.49790826439857483,
0.27468109130859375,
-0.17908208072185516,
-0.38448238372802734,
0.3458116054534912,
-0.16982786357402802,
0.06504803895950317,
0.8101889491081238,
0.39506828784942627,
-0.13450594246387482,
1.132055401802063,
0.7725067138671875,
-0.2856769263744354,
0.6503260135650635,
-0.40899041295051575,
-0.12864013016223907,
-0.788796603679657,
0.16089066863059998,
-0.47578170895576477,
-0.763500452041626,
-0.6068853139877319,
-0.4308406710624695,
0.5330756306648254,
0.03771506994962692,
-0.34225472807884216,
0.3695870041847229,
-0.7236588597297668,
0.6397145390510559,
0.43178603053092957,
0.05662025138735771,
0.3792881369590759,
-0.07421890646219254,
0.06130087375640869,
0.14011923968791962,
-0.9142420291900635,
-0.16338138282299042,
1.0594580173492432,
0.312860369682312,
0.6729749441146851,
0.19362451136112213,
0.5694785714149475,
0.6748606562614441,
0.32526451349258423,
-0.5708920359611511,
0.20460084080696106,
-0.47984617948532104,
-0.35339078307151794,
-0.5225881934165955,
-0.31789496541023254,
-1.0689142942428589,
0.34928232431411743,
-0.5577335357666016,
-0.4440343677997589,
0.5708595514297485,
0.5464492440223694,
-0.7070976495742798,
0.20176121592521667,
-0.522663414478302,
0.99854975938797,
-0.27919313311576843,
-0.29865315556526184,
-0.3153962194919586,
-0.7424253225326538,
0.11816707253456116,
-0.2845316529273987,
-0.01140440721064806,
-0.005299663636833429,
0.11720036715269089,
0.9088089466094971,
-0.2800550162792206,
0.8476793766021729,
-0.2971343398094177,
-0.3695359528064728,
-0.03234650194644928,
0.08889035880565643,
0.4195311665534973,
0.1149400845170021,
-0.059349481016397476,
-0.15311063826084137,
0.20972850918769836,
-0.40019646286964417,
-0.5659267902374268,
0.6431636810302734,
-0.938119649887085,
-0.25514107942581177,
-0.4686254858970642,
-0.3029939532279968,
-0.3022780120372772,
0.3222818076610565,
0.3266138732433319,
0.25445637106895447,
-0.2597683072090149,
0.1815309077501297,
0.8084291815757751,
-0.4113484025001526,
0.2798016369342804,
0.5396891236305237,
-0.11738571524620056,
-0.5591070055961609,
1.219265341758728,
0.16365264356136322,
0.1699448823928833,
0.41273048520088196,
0.23876598477363586,
0.09592494368553162,
-0.5972657799720764,
-0.47536107897758484,
0.11586277931928635,
-0.7671931385993958,
-0.5123299360275269,
-0.4389728307723999,
-0.31677597761154175,
-0.20435407757759094,
-0.2036784291267395,
-0.5464240312576294,
-0.3291027247905731,
-0.5319099426269531,
0.12032489478588104,
0.06952623277902603,
0.7337784767150879,
-0.2916892170906067,
0.2867085933685303,
-0.4509035646915436,
0.5531865954399109,
0.6915110945701599,
0.36570030450820923,
0.018670108169317245,
-0.6301207542419434,
-0.49778029322624207,
-0.028777943924069405,
-0.22315280139446259,
-0.6468694806098938,
0.5721569657325745,
0.7149434685707092,
0.4304099678993225,
0.361240029335022,
0.09279008209705353,
0.7585126161575317,
-0.6544786691665649,
0.20014886558055878,
-0.2043912410736084,
-1.081106185913086,
0.5794371366500854,
-0.39835888147354126,
0.458553671836853,
1.128360390663147,
0.11880150437355042,
-0.4057685136795044,
-0.2043103724718094,
-0.4936739206314087,
-0.8146743774414062,
0.6524475812911987,
0.08222582191228867,
-0.029399104416370392,
0.27755922079086304,
0.5014060735702515,
0.22157639265060425,
0.1251257359981537,
-0.8793599605560303,
-0.3234870731830597,
-0.4896334707736969,
-0.3234729468822479,
-0.4917807877063751,
-0.12227604538202286,
-0.15117564797401428,
-0.5488247871398926,
0.6511625051498413,
-0.6805105209350586,
0.29858097434043884,
0.19854770600795746,
-0.8611262440681458,
-0.28269410133361816,
0.18438856303691864,
0.7973675727844238,
0.9074753522872925,
-0.45161423087120056,
0.15557298064231873,
0.7567300200462341,
-0.37546420097351074,
0.05043293535709381,
-0.044451165944337845,
0.0028899661265313625,
-0.15941180288791656,
0.2607020437717438,
0.8187621235847473,
0.6312636733055115,
-0.2424088418483734,
0.3030710816383362,
0.09064851701259613,
-0.18835677206516266,
-0.3183487057685852,
0.2872419059276581,
-0.25456079840660095,
0.02181962877511978,
0.5889105796813965,
0.13630494475364685,
0.060265395790338516,
-0.483163982629776,
0.1461765170097351,
0.35468918085098267,
-0.4320865273475647,
-0.2544747292995453,
0.5543015599250793,
0.24550315737724304,
-0.1305767297744751,
0.24602419137954712,
-0.0839107483625412,
-0.453361839056015,
0.4362007677555084,
0.5101509094238281,
0.8798118829727173,
-0.4837837219238281,
0.2912586033344269,
0.3522852063179016,
0.3439513146877289,
0.06005912274122238,
-0.06918219476938248,
-0.07018369436264038,
-0.3925427198410034,
-0.35341235995292664,
-0.9093388915061951,
-0.33015120029449463,
0.1734551042318344,
-0.6712996959686279,
0.28660255670547485,
-0.5862745046615601,
-0.09147550910711288,
-0.08367528021335602,
0.24288052320480347,
-0.6721153855323792,
0.2647060453891754,
0.39202597737312317,
0.8484158515930176,
-1.013638973236084,
0.9015397429466248,
0.3193272352218628,
-0.20437125861644745,
-0.4063957929611206,
-0.0542222298681736,
-0.24638979136943817,
-0.564838707447052,
0.8384240865707397,
-0.08167099952697754,
-0.3661867678165436,
0.6826156973838806,
-0.36232662200927734,
-1.2699494361877441,
1.3530925512313843,
0.631989061832428,
-0.16915284097194672,
-0.25556379556655884,
0.17114265263080597,
0.7058993577957153,
-0.5249048471450806,
0.16015031933784485,
0.4367366135120392,
0.6618427634239197,
-0.38195255398750305,
-1.1307449340820312,
-0.10981830209493637,
-0.13955466449260712,
-0.11330030113458633,
-0.11983239650726318,
-0.6739049553871155,
0.8529366254806519,
0.131080761551857,
-0.05285197123885155,
-0.12204523384571075,
0.6395470499992371,
-0.18134240806102753,
0.1748858541250229,
0.9097251892089844,
0.4119967222213745,
0.8120536208152771,
0.3347257077693939,
0.4316096007823944,
-0.282116562128067,
0.4014204740524292,
1.2213646173477173,
-0.14242343604564667,
0.9119539260864258,
0.0266815684735775,
0.08323574811220169,
0.89774090051651,
0.6721783876419067,
-0.15360033512115479,
0.594392716884613,
0.23766355216503143,
0.3122563362121582,
-0.3385401964187622,
0.23005983233451843,
-0.3379276990890503,
0.8325874209403992,
0.4390471875667572,
-0.42106616497039795,
-0.3692742884159088,
0.256684273481369,
-0.13621123135089874,
-0.20162664353847504,
-0.44797173142433167,
1.152681589126587,
0.03954499959945679,
-0.7920020818710327,
1.0170108079910278,
-0.05767213553190231,
0.4189622700214386,
-0.5292515754699707,
-0.011140740476548672,
-0.10266894102096558,
0.34318676590919495,
-0.2512381076812744,
-0.02449147403240204,
0.10975933074951172,
-0.12447717040777206,
-0.2135700136423111,
-0.38077110052108765,
0.6831815242767334,
-0.5221037268638611,
-0.3899764120578766,
0.3006244897842407,
0.5479925870895386,
-0.14424210786819458,
0.004380176775157452,
-0.9816622734069824,
-0.2413078099489212,
-0.34905868768692017,
-0.14214862883090973,
0.6047482490539551,
0.07925192266702652,
0.08429945260286331,
0.6719906330108643,
0.6997222900390625,
0.027623074129223824,
-0.06906414031982422,
-0.042101725935935974,
0.7862403988838196,
-0.4798603355884552,
-0.7516874670982361,
-0.6852245926856995,
-0.0005324498633854091,
-0.0050104279071092606,
-0.22119289636611938,
0.6304143667221069,
0.42040666937828064,
0.49091073870658875,
-0.057378169149160385,
0.4771607518196106,
0.24917158484458923,
0.39123156666755676,
-0.7992579340934753,
1.0785375833511353,
-0.6152917146682739,
0.13750997185707092,
-0.4105008840560913,
-1.3184535503387451,
-0.31612420082092285,
0.7181279063224792,
-0.300729364156723,
0.09703785181045532,
0.7612163424491882,
0.45928314328193665,
-0.39749541878700256,
-0.5703170299530029,
0.22166381776332855,
0.3491457402706146,
0.048240773379802704,
0.694602906703949,
0.27296125888824463,
-0.42627084255218506,
0.4623658359050751,
0.00012455512478481978,
-0.24377618730068207,
-0.6778386235237122,
-1.0758765935897827,
-0.7078544497489929,
-0.626006007194519,
-0.24083447456359863,
-0.1258339285850525,
0.2146679013967514,
1.0364570617675781,
0.8788855671882629,
-0.8491038084030151,
-0.21979160606861115,
0.055285923182964325,
0.10338879376649857,
-0.49350619316101074,
-0.19791483879089355,
0.6750156283378601,
-0.6598039269447327,
-0.6819041967391968,
0.5765354633331299,
0.13488107919692993,
-0.19663181900978088,
-0.4737952947616577,
0.019244186580181122,
-0.5368351340293884,
0.11998505145311356,
0.5946130752563477,
0.6735494136810303,
-0.23388223350048065,
-0.21014969050884247,
-0.311349093914032,
-0.2321806252002716,
0.16556401550769806,
0.6358998417854309,
-1.0202317237854004,
0.18456204235553741,
0.4792083203792572,
0.4794670343399048,
0.3688412010669708,
0.2326732724905014,
0.6371899247169495,
-0.6382830142974854,
-0.11867017298936844,
0.05017316713929176,
0.07624795287847519,
0.22317160665988922,
-0.2606813609600067,
0.5216707587242126,
-0.04717215895652771,
-0.6802183985710144,
-0.935248851776123,
0.003432683413848281,
-0.9492455720901489,
-0.2960895001888275,
1.0244879722595215,
0.24356000125408173,
-0.257874995470047,
-0.23315241932868958,
-0.1377459168434143,
0.3757841885089874,
0.07393696904182434,
1.0238887071609497,
0.15844355523586273,
0.09314005076885223,
-0.04364195093512535,
-0.7927318811416626,
1.1138633489608765,
0.7538529634475708,
-0.9417805671691895,
0.13102908432483673,
0.04642176628112793,
0.2604449987411499,
0.2014983743429184,
0.45291274785995483,
0.35045143961906433,
0.3169645667076111,
-0.7064134478569031,
-0.12162373960018158,
-0.07359343767166138,
-0.48431217670440674,
-0.5596113204956055,
0.13079029321670532,
0.32929301261901855,
-0.038039833307266235
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09097v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09097v1
|
AI on AI: Exploring the Utility of GPT as an Expert Annotator of AI Publications
| 2024-03-14T04:43:02 | 2024-03-14T04:43:02 |
Autumn Toney-Wails, Christian Schoeberl, James Dunham
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Identifying scientific publications that are within a dynamic field of
research often requires costly annotation by subject-matter experts. Resources
like widely-accepted classification criteria or field taxonomies are
unavailable for a domain like artificial intelligence (AI), which spans
emerging topics and technologies. We address these challenges by inferring a
functional definition of AI research from existing expert labels, and then
evaluating state-of-the-art chatbot models on the task of expert data
annotation. Using the arXiv publication database as ground-truth, we experiment
with prompt engineering for GPT chatbot models to identify an alternative,
automated expert annotation pipeline that assigns AI labels with 94% accuracy.
For comparison, we fine-tune SPECTER, a transformer language model pre-trained
on scientific publications, that achieves 96% accuracy (only 2% higher than
GPT) on classifying AI publications. Our results indicate that with effective
prompt engineering, chatbots can be used as reliable data annotators even where
subject-area expertise is required. To evaluate the utility of
chatbot-annotated datasets on downstream classification tasks, we train a new
classifier on GPT-labeled data and compare its performance to the arXiv-trained
model. The classifier trained on GPT-labeled data outperforms the arXiv-trained
model by nine percentage points, achieving 82% accuracy.
|
[
-0.3629376292228699,
-0.6037435531616211,
0.33562228083610535,
-0.06699053943157196,
0.0678875744342804,
0.3991134464740753,
-0.05207257345318794,
-0.6569553017616272,
-0.10848601162433624,
0.2172498106956482,
-0.17746324837207794,
-0.26996123790740967,
-0.7538489103317261,
0.2040334790945053,
-0.375955730676651,
1.170693039894104,
0.20210988819599152,
-0.15333078801631927,
-0.4305499494075775,
0.031890951097011566,
-0.3381257653236389,
-0.5973430275917053,
-0.710576057434082,
-0.32152777910232544,
0.5869594216346741,
0.10921965539455414,
0.8874699473381042,
0.6916244626045227,
0.7716844081878662,
0.3355776369571686,
0.0024698618799448013,
0.28004735708236694,
-0.1849370151758194,
-0.10011973977088928,
0.06288107484579086,
-0.43044278025627136,
-0.34566357731819153,
0.38941678404808044,
0.28154700994491577,
0.5044510364532471,
0.2673758268356323,
0.12670648097991943,
-0.05756712332367897,
0.36977335810661316,
-0.2671811878681183,
0.6490267515182495,
-0.6566990613937378,
0.05367431789636612,
-0.13425183296203613,
-0.19439274072647095,
-0.4855373501777649,
-0.3892272412776947,
0.26428481936454773,
-0.9377797245979309,
0.36113810539245605,
0.23545849323272705,
0.8945167660713196,
0.9035384058952332,
-0.14272291958332062,
-0.2672622501850128,
-0.9743823409080505,
0.4954904019832611,
-0.36482566595077515,
0.2577070891857147,
0.4956432282924652,
0.38515329360961914,
0.009925118647515774,
-0.5733067393302917,
-0.6775858402252197,
-0.6425543427467346,
-0.2272012084722519,
0.16962185502052307,
-0.23577234148979187,
0.15634380280971527,
0.2801177203655243,
0.02838117629289627,
-0.5283859968185425,
0.08149420469999313,
-0.38343167304992676,
-0.19446389377117157,
0.8522281050682068,
-0.21002912521362305,
0.3573795258998871,
0.1977415382862091,
-0.09552116692066193,
-0.13799439370632172,
-0.4045785963535309,
-0.11305797100067139,
0.34986674785614014,
0.2782435417175293,
0.31475630402565,
0.5648506283760071,
-0.07281424105167389,
0.5391486287117004,
0.06505192816257477,
0.24184024333953857,
0.2992638349533081,
-0.2397887110710144,
0.03512772172689438,
-0.09959276765584946,
0.9505168795585632,
0.06685085594654083,
0.3055826425552368,
-0.46784383058547974,
-0.015313999727368355,
-0.0625998005270958,
0.4030442237854004,
-0.43977436423301697,
-0.7061797976493835,
0.12182959914207458,
-0.16379927098751068,
-0.2864147126674652,
-0.04443404823541641,
-0.4156961441040039,
-0.7071866989135742,
-0.25227615237236023,
0.3248489201068878,
-0.314077228307724,
-0.23820888996124268,
-0.42074325680732727,
-0.2455078512430191,
0.023525603115558624,
0.5344412922859192,
-0.7752514481544495,
-0.15873338282108307,
0.7089331746101379,
0.9813814759254456,
-0.09473719447851181,
-0.3523908257484436,
-0.20339883863925934,
-0.030104631558060646,
-0.37815532088279724,
1.1459091901779175,
-0.7660312652587891,
-0.526311457157135,
-0.22020067274570465,
-0.2875513434410095,
-0.25680041313171387,
-0.2815764546394348,
0.5840452909469604,
-0.5763896703720093,
0.12601490318775177,
0.07139577716588974,
-0.6592357754707336,
-0.2237965613603592,
0.22583164274692535,
-0.6951338648796082,
0.8610152006149292,
0.16673199832439423,
-0.6287440061569214,
0.5705054402351379,
-1.116441249847412,
-0.10708676278591156,
0.44455522298812866,
-0.1932544708251953,
-0.3455326557159424,
-0.3065844178199768,
0.11482011526823044,
0.3246791958808899,
-0.16423819959163666,
0.30370011925697327,
-0.12514610588550568,
-0.16707153618335724,
0.3891196548938751,
-0.48439592123031616,
0.5831527709960938,
0.25889086723327637,
-0.26479199528694153,
0.2583516836166382,
-0.5376794934272766,
-0.2440451681613922,
-0.16634869575500488,
-0.2964177429676056,
-0.40361645817756653,
0.13672776520252228,
0.06667510420084,
-0.17011354863643646,
0.09212803095579147,
-0.5017154812812805,
0.539188027381897,
-0.20929601788520813,
0.5743780732154846,
0.6283650994300842,
-0.1524600237607956,
0.3137112557888031,
-0.30582359433174133,
0.357350617647171,
-0.42752233147621155,
0.10891935974359512,
-0.09423227608203888,
-0.9398137927055359,
-0.5261420011520386,
-0.40014171600341797,
0.6633772253990173,
0.7605542540550232,
-0.7094957232475281,
0.4731025695800781,
-0.14620356261730194,
-0.9335318207740784,
-0.7726857662200928,
-0.17437978088855743,
0.2038343995809555,
0.684160053730011,
0.464769184589386,
-0.14561279118061066,
-0.1539853811264038,
-0.8476196527481079,
-0.3808751404285431,
-0.5094687938690186,
-0.026347076520323753,
0.4440213143825531,
0.43443700671195984,
-0.3011816143989563,
1.185036540031433,
-0.24865777790546417,
-0.18142016232013702,
0.12529905140399933,
0.8156853318214417,
-0.04796144738793373,
0.4994279146194458,
0.3879612684249878,
-1.0527760982513428,
-0.5007154941558838,
0.1524188071489334,
-0.813963770866394,
-0.1144561618566513,
-0.2619298994541168,
0.04387751594185829,
0.20073294639587402,
0.32091888785362244,
-0.8739497065544128,
0.49758225679397583,
-0.11299195140600204,
-0.298517644405365,
0.3834336996078491,
-0.1758289933204651,
0.46758317947387695,
-0.5127263069152832,
0.42018523812294006,
0.31443050503730774,
0.0784403383731842,
-0.6674432754516602,
-0.21117906272411346,
-0.16905070841312408,
-0.22021451592445374,
-0.18630683422088623,
0.6905913352966309,
-0.2525683343410492,
0.23470236361026764,
-0.4491827189922333,
-0.13561023771762848,
-0.3123784363269806,
0.31838005781173706,
0.2098505049943924,
0.975029468536377,
0.4006919264793396,
-0.3846656084060669,
0.3925483524799347,
0.5869563221931458,
-0.09739910066127777,
0.19866393506526947,
-0.718073844909668,
0.4421018064022064,
-0.0003407397598493844,
0.19205524027347565,
-0.964561939239502,
-0.2417224794626236,
0.5612939596176147,
-0.6969044804573059,
0.2500070333480835,
-0.38181066513061523,
-0.6255288124084473,
-0.47493776679039,
0.13639898598194122,
0.1195511743426323,
0.5080252289772034,
-0.21293197572231293,
0.5824792981147766,
0.4811978042125702,
-0.3736012578010559,
-0.5579341650009155,
-0.5173243880271912,
0.12491590529680252,
-0.13856780529022217,
-0.2692500948905945,
0.1299140304327011,
-0.06487137824296951,
-0.24857178330421448,
0.18131540715694427,
0.05991051718592644,
-0.21916355192661285,
0.2950083911418915,
0.22536908090114594,
0.2588038146495819,
-0.058048147708177567,
0.4036458134651184,
-0.0948798805475235,
-0.3570365309715271,
0.16244648396968842,
-0.1513785570859909,
0.14970332384109497,
-0.15564250946044922,
-0.4493374526500702,
-0.5039222836494446,
0.09810902178287506,
0.37546753883361816,
-0.22955812513828278,
0.557786762714386,
0.7519844174385071,
-0.29388540983200073,
0.2059437483549118,
-0.43651384115219116,
-0.2166232168674469,
-0.43962106108665466,
0.4087631106376648,
-0.11932350695133209,
-0.6373582482337952,
0.25927165150642395,
-0.06560999155044556,
0.3597988486289978,
0.7444853186607361,
0.23714764416217804,
-0.18191444873809814,
1.0743889808654785,
0.7690085768699646,
-0.323678582906723,
0.5184833407402039,
-0.20440220832824707,
0.376239538192749,
-0.34725284576416016,
-0.16572551429271698,
-0.8834517598152161,
-0.15623176097869873,
-0.5599880218505859,
-0.21584446728229523,
0.3690360188484192,
-0.14015112817287445,
-0.33668002486228943,
0.09351639449596405,
-1.0657055377960205,
0.4527357816696167,
1.076586365699768,
0.01552677433937788,
0.3168503940105438,
-0.10654709488153458,
0.812417209148407,
0.19661551713943481,
-0.5567170977592468,
-0.8435786962509155,
1.1287362575531006,
0.2723294198513031,
0.5180966258049011,
-0.39215579628944397,
0.31764093041419983,
0.933489203453064,
0.7853574156761169,
-0.7792609930038452,
0.35826849937438965,
0.14669767022132874,
-0.7121787071228027,
-0.42420729994773865,
-0.26949238777160645,
-0.7679945826530457,
-0.2144039273262024,
-0.2640969753265381,
-0.6467443108558655,
0.15089140832424164,
0.30830568075180054,
-0.39005035161972046,
0.27331414818763733,
-0.8561866879463196,
0.8054203987121582,
-0.3502054214477539,
0.025415191426873207,
-0.05228075012564659,
-0.696302592754364,
0.0013567430432885885,
-0.245289608836174,
0.04886682704091072,
-0.11735300719738007,
-0.038721319288015366,
0.9713239073753357,
-0.2344052642583847,
0.9119939804077148,
-0.2833317518234253,
0.20551593601703644,
0.44609272480010986,
-0.27065014839172363,
0.3777490258216858,
-0.006341870408505201,
-0.15362900495529175,
0.41818320751190186,
-0.041810616850852966,
-0.2324332594871521,
-0.5688989162445068,
0.18565447628498077,
-1.0732976198196411,
-0.8100045919418335,
-0.6451722383499146,
-0.6212967038154602,
-0.3145124018192291,
0.17977356910705566,
0.1879873424768448,
0.06547588109970093,
0.057478632777929306,
-0.09782779216766357,
0.5408521294593811,
-0.009709584526717663,
0.19837458431720734,
0.2595483362674713,
0.2910113036632538,
-0.2796117663383484,
1.2191611528396606,
0.19174203276634216,
-0.16982504725456238,
0.401307076215744,
0.06521192193031311,
-0.15633217990398407,
-0.76189786195755,
-0.5299801230430603,
-0.12277857959270477,
-0.5563445687294006,
-0.19371402263641357,
-0.7951982021331787,
-0.46213096380233765,
-0.369953453540802,
-0.09860455989837646,
-0.1799408495426178,
-0.48594948649406433,
-0.41798534989356995,
0.0028967945836484432,
0.6981010437011719,
0.7965075373649597,
-0.10661118477582932,
0.3630900979042053,
-0.7730541825294495,
-0.06434408575296402,
0.1740090399980545,
0.016835715621709824,
-0.22147466242313385,
-0.33573073148727417,
-0.29078152775764465,
0.235921710729599,
-0.3758811354637146,
-0.7184329032897949,
0.26311710476875305,
0.31329816579818726,
0.7177485227584839,
0.2264118492603302,
0.1446637064218521,
0.11534059047698975,
-0.37774839997291565,
0.7975820899009705,
-0.23398691415786743,
-0.6632940173149109,
0.6476130485534668,
-0.4439774453639984,
-0.18787416815757751,
0.5169770121574402,
0.7930967807769775,
-0.3599199056625366,
-0.47186219692230225,
-0.7679958939552307,
-0.8855833411216736,
0.5688457489013672,
0.19868488609790802,
0.037703901529312134,
0.14292535185813904,
0.5216856002807617,
0.3989463150501251,
0.3886861503124237,
-0.42991891503334045,
-0.25337111949920654,
-0.3951752483844757,
-0.3534526228904724,
-0.15020257234573364,
0.18397361040115356,
-0.23488162457942963,
-0.035835180431604385,
0.8522467017173767,
-0.20673702657222748,
0.597988486289978,
0.24274864792823792,
-0.033405985683202744,
0.20572558045387268,
0.0762442946434021,
0.3587568998336792,
0.6387431621551514,
-0.1041419729590416,
-0.173904687166214,
-0.17964035272598267,
-0.5775651335716248,
-0.08927448838949203,
0.7249323725700378,
-0.5438407063484192,
-0.036987125873565674,
0.45050954818725586,
0.646605372428894,
-0.4493129849433899,
-0.5876777768135071,
0.1580159217119217,
0.07948317378759384,
-0.1316072791814804,
-0.1948748528957367,
0.3920544683933258,
-0.19955642521381378,
0.3913291096687317,
0.7639341354370117,
0.45185256004333496,
0.3128305673599243,
-0.25173136591911316,
0.14512795209884644,
0.4267738163471222,
-0.3961767256259918,
-0.2702754735946655,
0.9034419059753418,
0.40895238518714905,
-0.6383669972419739,
0.731050968170166,
-0.1624225229024887,
-0.588852047920227,
0.8553385138511658,
-0.01857070066034794,
0.771824300289154,
-0.00810006819665432,
0.30152854323387146,
0.039107855409383774,
0.3277360200881958,
0.01941160298883915,
-0.20092670619487762,
-0.19376614689826965,
-0.5793881416320801,
-0.2819557189941406,
-0.1976465880870819,
-1.0571049451828003,
-0.06943123042583466,
-0.19036076962947845,
0.12012124806642532,
-0.22939787805080414,
-0.3344862759113312,
0.39564862847328186,
0.09161525964736938,
-0.7187567353248596,
0.13980185985565186,
0.19269977509975433,
0.870287299156189,
-0.8352094292640686,
0.5999020338058472,
0.9403058290481567,
-0.7530807256698608,
-0.633729100227356,
-0.1624113917350769,
-0.09436830878257751,
-0.7803849577903748,
0.585268497467041,
0.1745387315750122,
0.2627793550491333,
0.27744972705841064,
-0.9016416668891907,
-0.6927073001861572,
0.974431037902832,
0.22175011038780212,
-0.41415339708328247,
0.09320992976427078,
0.046227388083934784,
0.8330391049385071,
-0.17686158418655396,
0.8484296202659607,
0.3730834126472473,
0.6667154431343079,
0.02554946392774582,
-1.037924885749817,
-0.23674510419368744,
-0.6279807686805725,
-0.3994053304195404,
-0.07048044353723526,
-0.7923845648765564,
0.36346158385276794,
-0.17826233804225922,
0.0369940847158432,
-0.036607079207897186,
0.7624127268791199,
0.0980147048830986,
0.5728792548179626,
0.4306897222995758,
0.15805436670780182,
1.1634985208511353,
-0.3075900375843048,
0.8100299835205078,
-0.2944587469100952,
0.24757307767868042,
0.8068899512290955,
-0.14679290354251862,
0.5102751851081848,
0.2015242874622345,
-0.2229989469051361,
0.1874561309814453,
0.9996591210365295,
-0.5288547277450562,
0.5548245906829834,
0.01643177680671215,
-0.18383796513080597,
-0.1505286544561386,
-0.2948455214500427,
-0.4172605276107788,
0.12122803181409836,
0.3592947721481323,
-0.20468537509441376,
0.252360075712204,
0.2328081727027893,
0.060748692601919174,
-0.18013380467891693,
-0.26507845520973206,
0.8318635821342468,
-0.23061750829219818,
-0.5936437249183655,
0.20528653264045715,
-0.3083455264568329,
0.5782711505889893,
-0.2547428607940674,
-0.1205650344491005,
-0.1250641942024231,
0.016993960365653038,
-0.09861909598112106,
-0.8599947690963745,
0.297848641872406,
0.1629146933555603,
-0.13292552530765533,
-0.16945436596870422,
0.7631388306617737,
-0.2466018944978714,
-0.5744364261627197,
-0.2682167887687683,
0.529216468334198,
0.42963463068008423,
-0.11046023666858673,
-0.7482448220252991,
-0.2794269621372223,
-0.17743337154388428,
-0.48742467164993286,
0.022044673562049866,
0.39484578371047974,
0.014740164391696453,
0.9287517666816711,
0.560602605342865,
0.008497980423271656,
-0.1049308031797409,
-0.15884488821029663,
0.8916683793067932,
-0.49365541338920593,
-0.24794001877307892,
-0.6391544938087463,
0.47304338216781616,
-0.16344712674617767,
-0.5450674891471863,
0.47827455401420593,
0.3884739577770233,
0.7834052443504333,
-0.014138235710561275,
1.4020161628723145,
-0.3335588872432709,
0.46332859992980957,
-0.08231310546398163,
1.095954418182373,
-0.31159600615501404,
0.10809264332056046,
0.011360631324350834,
-0.5744575262069702,
-0.4329420328140259,
0.5599878430366516,
-0.5934156775474548,
0.20099344849586487,
0.2848617136478424,
0.5580579042434692,
0.07399658113718033,
0.3088057041168213,
-0.03983420133590698,
0.16656018793582916,
0.6236690282821655,
0.07895615696907043,
0.8922419548034668,
-0.15279045701026917,
0.5542179346084595,
-0.1914159059524536,
-0.41084784269332886,
-0.16526834666728973,
-0.7540229558944702,
-1.0909066200256348,
-0.6525737047195435,
-0.6907841563224792,
-0.07737409323453903,
0.38758739829063416,
0.8679595589637756,
0.7045604586601257,
-0.8018651604652405,
0.2977689504623413,
-0.12088564038276672,
0.019269397482275963,
-0.28710976243019104,
-0.24286887049674988,
0.56940758228302,
-0.4906371533870697,
-0.7887604832649231,
0.3248552680015564,
-0.08143965899944305,
0.04226483404636383,
-0.24145743250846863,
0.11951184272766113,
-0.104228176176548,
-0.10560734570026398,
0.20810407400131226,
0.5682817101478577,
-0.4763345718383789,
-0.46789923310279846,
0.06369486451148987,
-0.061942070722579956,
0.1038452759385109,
0.6026672720909119,
-0.8246711492538452,
0.33755210041999817,
0.3120422661304474,
1.022713303565979,
0.12956136465072632,
0.1925438493490219,
0.4880158007144928,
-0.33177444338798523,
-0.03076065331697464,
0.5814803838729858,
0.10429997742176056,
0.3484174311161041,
-0.6393857598304749,
0.9412153959274292,
0.35190925002098083,
-1.0775344371795654,
-0.7911213040351868,
-0.3215736746788025,
-0.8216620683670044,
0.005413644015789032,
0.9723896384239197,
-0.35369035601615906,
-0.10520481318235397,
-0.3695816099643707,
-0.4355933964252472,
0.45707786083221436,
-0.7165676355361938,
1.1818764209747314,
0.716731071472168,
-0.44653967022895813,
-0.2600612938404083,
-0.7044879794120789,
0.6913666129112244,
0.17506110668182373,
-0.9559635519981384,
0.027198443189263344,
0.36793145537376404,
-0.07793313264846802,
0.5035638809204102,
0.5188166499137878,
0.37405338883399963,
0.13702179491519928,
0.03844581916928291,
0.3367820978164673,
-0.4280289113521576,
-0.33793866634368896,
0.10735771805047989,
0.0425846092402935,
0.1935999095439911,
-0.10129619389772415
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09092v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09092v1
|
MCFEND: A Multi-source Benchmark Dataset for Chinese Fake News Detection
| 2024-03-14T04:32:13 | 2024-03-14T04:32:13 |
Yupeng Li, Haorui He, Jin Bai, Dacheng Wen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The prevalence of fake news across various online sources has had a
significant influence on the public. Existing Chinese fake news detection
datasets are limited to news sourced solely from Weibo. However, fake news
originating from multiple sources exhibits diversity in various aspects,
including its content and social context. Methods trained on purely one single
news source can hardly be applicable to real-world scenarios. Our pilot
experiment demonstrates that the F1 score of the state-of-the-art method that
learns from a large Chinese fake news detection dataset, Weibo-21, drops
significantly from 0.943 to 0.470 when the test data is changed to multi-source
news data, failing to identify more than one-third of the multi-source fake
news. To address this limitation, we constructed the first multi-source
benchmark dataset for Chinese fake news detection, termed MCFEND, which is
composed of news we collected from diverse sources such as social platforms,
messaging apps, and traditional online news outlets. Notably, such news has
been fact-checked by 14 authoritative fact-checking agencies worldwide. In
addition, various existing Chinese fake news detection methods are thoroughly
evaluated on our proposed dataset in cross-source, multi-source, and unseen
source ways. MCFEND, as a benchmark dataset, aims to advance Chinese fake news
detection approaches in real-world scenarios.
|
[
-0.499320924282074,
-0.7465400695800781,
0.30675095319747925,
0.24690811336040497,
-0.39886409044265747,
0.09207132458686829,
0.11181017011404037,
-0.4271954596042633,
0.19992947578430176,
0.014095712453126907,
-0.37299564480781555,
-0.5326377749443054,
-0.412720650434494,
-0.05068093538284302,
-0.31329140067100525,
0.963109016418457,
-0.041875239461660385,
0.26714789867401123,
0.2948741018772125,
-0.49399226903915405,
0.2770842909812927,
-0.5103293061256409,
-0.5044546127319336,
0.1522556096315384,
0.675240695476532,
0.4535185694694519,
0.36725476384162903,
0.8148288130760193,
0.510077953338623,
0.12367068231105804,
0.34632566571235657,
0.5818185806274414,
-0.22633281350135803,
-0.4762992858886719,
-0.22242695093154907,
0.008271473459899426,
-0.15117909014225006,
0.3242020010948181,
0.6018804311752319,
0.09284918010234833,
-0.13672925531864166,
0.29875338077545166,
-0.11767452955245972,
0.21321415901184082,
-0.7498632073402405,
-0.33100974559783936,
-0.4641757607460022,
0.07212193310260773,
-0.6288606524467468,
-0.13278788328170776,
-0.31606030464172363,
-0.2649182081222534,
-0.41443872451782227,
-0.4425949454307556,
0.5572240948677063,
0.07507044821977615,
1.0060847997665405,
-0.39577344059944153,
-0.8639883995056152,
-0.10559536516666412,
-0.3864693343639374,
0.5250398516654968,
-0.4918643832206726,
0.4046943783760071,
-0.3089178502559662,
0.5056017637252808,
-0.05009135603904724,
-0.7018896341323853,
-0.8969435691833496,
-0.341671884059906,
0.028752494603395462,
0.0741012766957283,
0.20346443355083466,
-0.3528786599636078,
0.26630452275276184,
0.2441447228193283,
-0.6470514535903931,
-0.27256160974502563,
-0.3953106701374054,
-0.47261154651641846,
0.6082661151885986,
-0.22750277817249298,
0.48240557312965393,
-0.21549157798290253,
-0.6713468432426453,
-0.41955211758613586,
-0.6653264760971069,
0.00844954326748848,
0.5356748104095459,
0.4097593128681183,
-0.1807366907596588,
0.060043927282094955,
-0.43194419145584106,
0.3396894335746765,
-0.0490020252764225,
-0.23644709587097168,
0.658894956111908,
-0.34640178084373474,
-0.043628089129924774,
0.24012388288974762,
0.8142667412757874,
0.38382524251937866,
0.05072290822863579,
0.1214679479598999,
-0.13196071982383728,
0.2261868566274643,
0.156270831823349,
-0.7513622045516968,
-0.25675758719444275,
0.038245439529418945,
-0.5956403613090515,
-0.6258370876312256,
0.8778995871543884,
-0.5237979292869568,
-0.4409361183643341,
0.04421495273709297,
0.2461230307817459,
-0.11722108721733093,
-0.6657320261001587,
-0.3499903678894043,
-0.5305894613265991,
0.10568743944168091,
0.20307974517345428,
-0.1747308373451233,
0.17335209250450134,
0.5293909907341003,
0.9658893942832947,
-0.25532978773117065,
-0.6007142066955566,
-0.8264222145080566,
0.07269825041294098,
-0.6195452809333801,
0.861534595489502,
-0.24761900305747986,
-0.042083740234375,
-0.32316794991493225,
0.28996071219444275,
0.3158815801143646,
-0.5625073909759521,
0.8865370750427246,
-0.2654716968536377,
-0.10736727714538574,
-0.5063233375549316,
-0.08986157178878784,
-0.24730287492275238,
0.5461223721504211,
-0.7363399267196655,
0.8455358743667603,
-0.011635261587798595,
-0.9101628661155701,
0.5864485502243042,
-0.4933493435382843,
-0.7114143371582031,
-0.27106377482414246,
-0.031221669167280197,
-0.38032370805740356,
0.05277499184012413,
0.5679866671562195,
0.41789528727531433,
0.12562395632266998,
0.407469779253006,
-0.8610706329345703,
-0.32933470606803894,
0.0670510083436966,
-0.7340397238731384,
0.8369629383087158,
0.28324785828590393,
-0.21471695601940155,
-0.1597108542919159,
-0.6166531443595886,
-0.18178848922252655,
0.24929626286029816,
-0.1225924864411354,
-0.3595222234725952,
-0.16816656291484833,
0.3213365972042084,
0.7005733251571655,
-0.3234303891658783,
-0.9440433382987976,
-0.06554625183343887,
0.12048293650150299,
-0.038569554686546326,
0.8298054933547974,
0.18539461493492126,
-0.13221010565757751,
-0.7895117402076721,
0.14622355997562408,
0.6713939309120178,
0.09897875785827637,
-0.3773440718650818,
-0.25377389788627625,
-0.3522524833679199,
0.02016180194914341,
0.18582923710346222,
0.3872252404689789,
-0.9631230235099792,
-0.2709472179412842,
-0.19548194110393524,
-0.6185659170150757,
-0.37874892354011536,
0.1392790526151657,
0.4916565418243408,
0.3639563024044037,
0.3503287434577942,
0.02838473953306675,
-0.40488293766975403,
-0.6709738373756409,
-0.9005089998245239,
0.06896326690912247,
0.022117413580417633,
0.0319615975022316,
0.5781997442245483,
0.16760239005088806,
0.535878598690033,
-0.17736688256263733,
-0.3121532201766968,
0.13623948395252228,
0.010146268643438816,
-0.008032875135540962,
0.573606014251709,
0.7181013226509094,
-1.2564533948898315,
-0.5337918400764465,
0.1110772043466568,
-0.5723891854286194,
0.051613155752420425,
-0.22626884281635284,
-0.18192768096923828,
0.15214015543460846,
0.5298050045967102,
-0.4447194039821625,
0.16915187239646912,
0.8139814734458923,
-0.11569659411907196,
0.9432516098022461,
0.15773263573646545,
0.7011149525642395,
-1.0965813398361206,
0.05124060809612274,
0.332364946603775,
-0.28845271468162537,
-0.582338273525238,
0.2785925567150116,
0.49187448620796204,
-0.07238896191120148,
-0.9738100171089172,
0.8351063132286072,
-0.2848633825778961,
-0.06597466766834259,
-0.21783186495304108,
0.33082398772239685,
0.12213373184204102,
0.4111851155757904,
0.01876670867204666,
0.42471742630004883,
0.3620487451553345,
-0.7506716251373291,
0.7381219863891602,
-0.4148428738117218,
-0.612774133682251,
0.7190030217170715,
-0.4469365179538727,
-0.07402308285236359,
-0.06512876600027084,
0.6564626693725586,
-0.8445881605148315,
-0.38375458121299744,
0.5878399610519409,
-0.667589008808136,
-0.23094342648983002,
0.058158885687589645,
-0.6756731271743774,
-0.3853655755519867,
-0.550352931022644,
0.11843178421258926,
-0.28924375772476196,
-1.0375159978866577,
0.31665417551994324,
0.24419759213924408,
0.2095174640417099,
-0.6564006805419922,
-0.7937883734703064,
-0.015656964853405952,
0.015110227279365063,
-0.6953054666519165,
0.46448588371276855,
0.02974190004169941,
-0.15895991027355194,
0.21567416191101074,
-0.5318002700805664,
-0.06409835815429688,
-0.11940864473581314,
0.08496668189764023,
0.040888264775276184,
-0.48582303524017334,
0.3143867254257202,
0.2340894192457199,
0.08277328312397003,
0.034974534064531326,
-0.052779246121644974,
0.194365993142128,
0.06386015564203262,
-0.7441903352737427,
-0.5399786233901978,
0.16516873240470886,
0.5116687417030334,
-0.13925844430923462,
0.7207973599433899,
1.0021867752075195,
-0.615700364112854,
-0.5047490000724792,
-0.4170341193675995,
-0.1851767599582672,
-0.4493945837020874,
0.18073555827140808,
-0.5277997255325317,
-0.24864766001701355,
0.27994394302368164,
-0.15930362045764923,
0.21524760127067566,
0.5515764355659485,
0.27554234862327576,
0.22537396848201752,
1.146669864654541,
0.20229262113571167,
-0.2192254662513733,
0.3914295434951782,
-0.0236501507461071,
-0.07116224616765976,
-0.389335036277771,
-0.04268813505768776,
-0.25374096632003784,
-0.32405683398246765,
-0.5476557016372681,
-0.3598080277442932,
0.12105724960565567,
-0.31028175354003906,
-0.21272259950637817,
0.17965345084667206,
-0.37659087777137756,
0.570827305316925,
0.5493327975273132,
0.4810860753059387,
0.43435966968536377,
-0.017547182738780975,
-0.3670895993709564,
0.24205122888088226,
-0.5780453681945801,
-0.1876421570777893,
1.1172664165496826,
-0.018512815237045288,
0.40425220131874084,
0.16678808629512787,
0.4044936001300812,
0.6193139553070068,
0.8542398810386658,
-0.19951874017715454,
0.20322862267494202,
-0.22235092520713806,
-0.8397799134254456,
0.012931346893310547,
-0.7035388350486755,
-0.45205962657928467,
0.7180432677268982,
-0.04026006534695625,
-0.18715229630470276,
0.09644041955471039,
0.025021735578775406,
-0.22974151372909546,
0.6139103174209595,
-0.6818683743476868,
0.9555980563163757,
-0.3733638525009155,
-0.13504843413829803,
-0.08955633640289307,
-0.32989275455474854,
1.0317714214324951,
-0.27909520268440247,
0.5956845283508301,
-0.39016789197921753,
0.09217801690101624,
0.49366816878318787,
-0.3451237082481384,
0.395901083946228,
-0.38604670763015747,
0.14106982946395874,
0.07610046118497849,
-0.17384688556194305,
0.668858528137207,
0.4094715714454651,
-0.12234590947628021,
0.3035311698913574,
0.09712108224630356,
-0.6299535632133484,
-0.28216806054115295,
1.0334293842315674,
-0.48883530497550964,
-0.3233303725719452,
-0.7115218639373779,
-0.19776685535907745,
-0.050450630486011505,
0.3318214416503906,
0.3855706751346588,
0.45569831132888794,
-0.5344260931015015,
0.31598764657974243,
0.18689194321632385,
-0.19867035746574402,
0.44870615005493164,
0.6293156147003174,
-0.32485678791999817,
-0.2737540900707245,
1.0373462438583374,
0.23114046454429626,
0.09352223575115204,
0.0553206242620945,
0.2977859377861023,
-0.34956902265548706,
-0.05471692979335785,
-0.5561235547065735,
0.07311870157718658,
-0.6642633676528931,
0.014412244781851768,
-0.4492529332637787,
-0.42706653475761414,
-0.6440461874008179,
-0.010462264530360699,
-0.3867205083370209,
0.08411920070648193,
-0.0684436559677124,
-0.08904001861810684,
-0.048113055527210236,
0.20736023783683777,
-0.30826738476753235,
0.10168652981519699,
-0.8163480758666992,
1.0519706010818481,
0.13819296658039093,
0.3785417973995209,
-0.039270490407943726,
-0.31568336486816406,
-0.1856077015399933,
0.6286486983299255,
-0.4926436245441437,
-0.7804926037788391,
0.28968214988708496,
0.04441758245229721,
0.7763849496841431,
0.8590939044952393,
0.687785267829895,
0.5405088067054749,
-0.1187668889760971,
0.4306427240371704,
0.11970692873001099,
-0.8269938230514526,
0.37805795669555664,
-0.39029204845428467,
0.23399575054645538,
0.12503142654895782,
0.39583680033683777,
-0.6890982985496521,
-0.32960236072540283,
-0.7478940486907959,
-0.14959679543972015,
0.8901091814041138,
-0.051674045622348785,
0.23222266137599945,
0.11318719387054443,
-0.03170446306467056,
0.0941409096121788,
0.18217958509922028,
-0.8720413446426392,
-0.2957427501678467,
-0.37061548233032227,
0.005112151615321636,
-0.19717475771903992,
0.19373035430908203,
-0.16470319032669067,
-0.22368165850639343,
0.691307544708252,
-0.10751660913228989,
-0.07548082619905472,
0.2010527104139328,
-0.19548644125461578,
-0.10872332751750946,
-0.1297139674425125,
0.8147217035293579,
0.7171933650970459,
-0.023759882897138596,
0.22624421119689941,
0.0840916559100151,
-0.5353682041168213,
0.05319041758775711,
-0.051666151732206345,
0.019636182114481926,
0.36025315523147583,
0.016894381493330002,
0.4597803056240082,
-0.08522285521030426,
-0.6110962629318237,
0.7245824933052063,
0.14667339622974396,
-0.3873792886734009,
-0.22755227982997894,
0.09321817755699158,
-0.03124014474451542,
0.1411982625722885,
0.7209054827690125,
0.4591708183288574,
0.06718479841947556,
-0.707007646560669,
0.7008689641952515,
0.23960618674755096,
-0.31811630725860596,
-0.18709345161914825,
0.6512567400932312,
0.1656062752008438,
-0.0845668837428093,
0.37215134501457214,
-0.39153704047203064,
-0.402049720287323,
0.9853748679161072,
0.35066497325897217,
0.45785585045814514,
-0.39142754673957825,
0.6282407641410828,
0.20539692044258118,
0.5520344972610474,
-0.5065648555755615,
0.12481689453125,
0.1720656305551529,
-1.0170910358428955,
0.05265660956501961,
-0.2528340220451355,
-0.33138930797576904,
0.3454039692878723,
-0.394718199968338,
0.6083933711051941,
-0.574353039264679,
-0.045892998576164246,
0.12404078245162964,
0.19726938009262085,
-0.29369086027145386,
0.3929370939731598,
0.1317199170589447,
0.8872765302658081,
-0.7853646874427795,
0.9593049883842468,
0.42225226759910583,
-0.054065216332674026,
-0.48782968521118164,
0.4099119305610657,
0.7096804976463318,
-0.4803738594055176,
0.20947161316871643,
0.5770024657249451,
-0.11461010575294495,
-0.0630696713924408,
-0.6851579546928406,
-0.44771188497543335,
0.7693436741828918,
0.5182673335075378,
-0.4290907084941864,
0.4203484058380127,
-0.1417478621006012,
0.15863896906375885,
-0.34253671765327454,
-0.00048260754556395113,
0.11940367519855499,
0.6248515248298645,
0.02003195509314537,
-0.48665010929107666,
0.24828140437602997,
-0.4741222858428955,
-0.24940596520900726,
0.10997837781906128,
-1.0857659578323364,
1.2594362497329712,
-0.23828795552253723,
-0.5239347219467163,
-0.4333403706550598,
0.5056695938110352,
0.5764924883842468,
0.9226040244102478,
0.38896244764328003,
0.32407164573669434,
0.6045259237289429,
-0.11168315261602402,
0.9002193808555603,
-0.3093479573726654,
0.34738287329673767,
0.7508452534675598,
-0.1649346798658371,
0.6251630783081055,
0.0629747286438942,
0.11569514125585556,
0.5605301856994629,
0.7806611657142639,
-0.36441031098365784,
0.46004053950309753,
0.10655155777931213,
-0.11226692795753479,
-0.16462354362010956,
-0.09923940896987915,
-0.6053332686424255,
0.26920342445373535,
0.18432554602622986,
-0.2674248516559601,
-0.5289502739906311,
0.2795029282569885,
0.10181082785129547,
-0.018984276801347733,
-0.23345611989498138,
0.16032758355140686,
0.004588797222822905,
-0.28812503814697266,
0.33956071734428406,
0.48317497968673706,
0.6963426470756531,
-0.420974999666214,
-0.07130112498998642,
-0.2994045913219452,
0.25285032391548157,
-0.21018636226654053,
-0.43451932072639465,
0.20297160744667053,
-0.21660055220127106,
0.04105568677186966,
0.009691567160189152,
0.7889509201049805,
-0.2326020896434784,
-0.5244302153587341,
0.21254758536815643,
0.537495493888855,
0.0338502936065197,
-0.8425029516220093,
-0.6306190490722656,
-0.08705747127532959,
-0.2203344702720642,
-0.3685178756713867,
0.3863486349582672,
0.5663835406303406,
-0.17635980248451233,
0.602837860584259,
1.3297865390777588,
0.02938062511384487,
0.10148873180150986,
-0.13104793429374695,
0.8236270546913147,
-0.6641985177993774,
-0.6590803265571594,
-0.7329461574554443,
0.11412691324949265,
-0.5485172867774963,
-0.5039014220237732,
0.9547367691993713,
0.5750262141227722,
1.2066960334777832,
0.07434011995792389,
0.9788076877593994,
-0.07634937763214111,
0.6485059857368469,
-0.401027113199234,
0.9892579913139343,
-0.7724795937538147,
0.10444387048482895,
-0.3084542155265808,
-0.7466650009155273,
-0.17176426947116852,
0.17480167746543884,
0.19848491251468658,
0.27083009481430054,
0.6982227563858032,
0.8240710496902466,
-0.5091134309768677,
0.031645067036151886,
0.34847819805145264,
-0.10665257275104523,
0.3085499703884125,
0.25401949882507324,
0.6111485958099365,
-0.5838974714279175,
0.9560918807983398,
-0.4977108836174011,
0.014999840408563614,
-0.4410138428211212,
-0.763440728187561,
-0.8778494596481323,
-0.3401036262512207,
-0.12656410038471222,
-0.18210333585739136,
0.11251306533813477,
0.5508976578712463,
0.9301390647888184,
-1.01372230052948,
0.10141128301620483,
0.09825576096773148,
0.46725472807884216,
-0.7737390398979187,
-0.33997204899787903,
0.36483508348464966,
-0.09689493477344513,
-0.5742974877357483,
0.197457954287529,
0.03621484711766243,
0.025766311213374138,
-0.2300645411014557,
-0.14746394753456116,
-0.40738755464553833,
0.1882958710193634,
0.42037010192871094,
0.2958003878593445,
-0.6139806509017944,
-0.34172186255455017,
0.07856795191764832,
-0.4376525282859802,
-0.012791188433766365,
0.7687825560569763,
-0.6720011234283447,
0.1712699830532074,
0.4814237654209137,
0.3120606243610382,
0.3267151415348053,
0.367186576128006,
0.3584015965461731,
-1.0220239162445068,
0.26773110032081604,
-0.32847270369529724,
-0.01594252698123455,
0.15418030321598053,
-0.21993747353553772,
0.2843880355358124,
0.7768994569778442,
-0.0951993316411972,
-0.9717588424682617,
-0.11807882785797119,
-0.7591153979301453,
-0.6949995160102844,
1.0136557817459106,
-0.23374444246292114,
-0.05604436621069908,
-0.27488067746162415,
-0.09439090639352798,
0.26127463579177856,
-0.5704987049102783,
0.697784423828125,
0.939455509185791,
0.2653058171272278,
-0.5774056315422058,
-0.6422127485275269,
0.5022565722465515,
-0.28687307238578796,
-0.9499217867851257,
-0.0716925635933876,
0.39872971177101135,
0.34445294737815857,
0.12043546885251999,
0.5404623746871948,
0.07451525330543518,
0.6271565556526184,
0.5780120491981506,
-0.1665269285440445,
-0.37966227531433105,
-0.5404855608940125,
0.15778236091136932,
0.3652995228767395,
-0.7241648435592651,
-0.5239102244377136
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09085v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09085v1
|
Meaningful Learning: Advancing Abstract Reasoning in Large Language Models via Generic Fact Guidance
| 2024-03-14T04:06:13 | 2024-03-14T04:06:13 |
Kai Xiong, Xiao Ding, Ting Liu, Bing Qin, Dongliang Xu, Qing Yang, Hongtao Liu, Yixin Cao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) have developed impressive performance and strong
explainability across various reasoning scenarios, marking a significant stride
towards mimicking human-like intelligence. Despite this, when tasked with
simple questions supported by a generic fact, LLMs often fail to provide
consistent and precise answers, indicating a deficiency in abstract reasoning
abilities. This has sparked a vigorous debate about whether LLMs are genuinely
reasoning or merely memorizing. In light of this, we design a preliminary study
to quantify and delve into the abstract reasoning abilities of existing LLMs.
Our findings reveal a substantial discrepancy between their general reasoning
and abstract reasoning performances. To relieve this problem, we tailor an
abstract reasoning dataset (AbsR) together with a meaningful learning paradigm
to teach LLMs how to leverage generic facts for reasoning purposes. The results
show that our approach not only boosts the general reasoning performance of
LLMs but also makes considerable strides towards their capacity for abstract
reasoning, moving beyond simple memorization or imitation to a more nuanced
understanding and application of generic facts.
|
[
-0.045509275048971176,
-0.6513955593109131,
1.1837821006774902,
-0.3652592897415161,
-0.35509607195854187,
0.2092718631029129,
-0.16626712679862976,
-0.5443964600563049,
-0.2493552565574646,
0.37941405177116394,
-0.21963417530059814,
-0.8534535765647888,
-0.6073553562164307,
0.09066427499055862,
-0.29027503728866577,
0.8842888474464417,
0.2146763801574707,
-0.022371182218194008,
-0.43528565764427185,
-0.37144604325294495,
-0.38192951679229736,
-0.5610383749008179,
-0.720184862613678,
-0.5590383410453796,
0.659857988357544,
0.4485234022140503,
0.551615297794342,
0.756334125995636,
0.25691765546798706,
0.28034326434135437,
-0.15766072273254395,
0.3901822566986084,
-0.45317620038986206,
0.13392113149166107,
-0.645138680934906,
-0.7727090120315552,
-0.3097333610057831,
-0.2757633924484253,
0.7391374707221985,
1.062168836593628,
0.003528408706188202,
0.13922937214374542,
-0.08115457743406296,
0.637575626373291,
-0.526947557926178,
0.4895126521587372,
-0.806820273399353,
-0.08572615683078766,
-0.05671872943639755,
-0.011992473155260086,
-0.5381824374198914,
-0.6277158856391907,
0.14047914743423462,
-0.5808402895927429,
0.14536075294017792,
0.12149754166603088,
0.5526625514030457,
0.2528107762336731,
-0.5293152928352356,
-0.44431424140930176,
-0.6210243701934814,
1.0873711109161377,
-0.8612598776817322,
0.15019387006759644,
0.14665207266807556,
0.25575608015060425,
-0.16517147421836853,
-0.8947847485542297,
-0.46260377764701843,
-0.3110964298248291,
-0.06830199062824249,
-0.2447875440120697,
-0.12159425765275955,
0.15110978484153748,
0.5156051516532898,
0.32920679450035095,
-0.39427512884140015,
-0.01626351848244667,
-0.3157787024974823,
-0.21213069558143616,
0.69913250207901,
0.2973978519439697,
0.2183329463005066,
0.15693260729312897,
-0.12771983444690704,
0.03683939203619957,
-1.000636100769043,
0.19640496373176575,
0.018196864053606987,
0.21081672608852386,
-0.05450856685638428,
0.45335865020751953,
0.03908194974064827,
0.8417221903800964,
-0.25102341175079346,
-0.5555568337440491,
0.09682770818471909,
-0.050682250410318375,
0.2107662856578827,
0.14505061507225037,
0.22913812100887299,
0.1299188733100891,
0.545933187007904,
-0.2401173710823059,
-0.3762771487236023,
0.13366486132144928,
0.08792680501937866,
-0.6844392418861389,
-0.38128340244293213,
0.004665564280003309,
-0.42034029960632324,
0.17188674211502075,
0.03527747839689255,
-0.2580873966217041,
-0.010576467961072922,
-0.7773890495300293,
0.4752308130264282,
-0.5104436278343201,
-0.15457814931869507,
0.3314123749732971,
-0.2613893747329712,
0.30979618430137634,
0.6573747396469116,
-0.8529460430145264,
0.1593809723854065,
0.8730838298797607,
0.7362236380577087,
-0.22295832633972168,
-0.007050973363220692,
-0.18911337852478027,
0.29922884702682495,
-0.48839592933654785,
1.0112594366073608,
-0.8942822217941284,
-0.20698919892311096,
0.008890310302376747,
-0.280497282743454,
-0.02780536189675331,
-0.7080695629119873,
0.5843589305877686,
-0.619893491268158,
-0.09016818553209305,
-0.6199208498001099,
-0.7761896252632141,
-0.7571610808372498,
0.5634735822677612,
-0.5325441956520081,
0.6657045483589172,
0.047662071883678436,
-0.5656554102897644,
0.3729340136051178,
-0.4822908639907837,
-0.5436541438102722,
0.03200925514101982,
-0.5034360289573669,
-0.11858200281858444,
0.2305082231760025,
-0.18651273846626282,
0.5001774430274963,
-0.23750446736812592,
0.2118556946516037,
-0.45807015895843506,
-0.4679710566997528,
0.44757023453712463,
-0.2716539204120636,
0.2963813245296478,
0.17296136915683746,
-0.12417024374008179,
-0.04492499306797981,
-0.8996627926826477,
0.07131066173315048,
0.0867144837975502,
-0.4361112415790558,
-0.4578840732574463,
0.2129281908273697,
-0.4389925003051758,
0.22627422213554382,
0.18262960016727448,
-0.47075363993644714,
0.38538438081741333,
-0.2569189667701721,
0.4422939717769623,
0.7201929092407227,
0.05813382565975189,
0.39790305495262146,
-0.7147753834724426,
0.32130110263824463,
-0.18948279321193695,
-0.2518337666988373,
-0.08759748935699463,
-0.506804347038269,
-0.6174020171165466,
-0.38310158252716064,
0.3804055154323578,
0.2777583599090576,
-0.6596828699111938,
0.3681146204471588,
-0.3079494535923004,
-0.025339609012007713,
-0.3111511766910553,
0.1574127972126007,
0.40771108865737915,
0.7391505837440491,
0.424051970243454,
-0.11244286596775055,
-0.4922570586204529,
-0.8441727757453918,
-0.48319104313850403,
-0.2308906763792038,
-0.2410908043384552,
0.09908073395490646,
0.7214250564575195,
-0.20501179993152618,
0.9840216636657715,
-0.46136733889579773,
-0.03885684907436371,
-0.5039776563644409,
0.07474173605442047,
0.14100870490074158,
0.11271285265684128,
0.2984124720096588,
-0.5910024046897888,
-0.11328618973493576,
-0.11850790679454803,
-1.060283899307251,
-0.015741363167762756,
-0.051503945142030716,
0.2050936371088028,
0.1331164836883545,
0.5780023336410522,
-0.404672235250473,
0.0907452329993248,
0.31970661878585815,
-0.2737564146518707,
0.6531942486763,
-0.11269241571426392,
-0.08206665515899658,
-0.6064702272415161,
0.09380270540714264,
-0.16736817359924316,
-0.2728908360004425,
-0.4136269986629486,
-0.09083907306194305,
-0.18334786593914032,
0.2854135036468506,
-0.5228111743927002,
0.8153108358383179,
-0.39795467257499695,
-0.12806978821754456,
-0.5237430930137634,
0.06733012944459915,
0.09409958869218826,
0.32342132925987244,
0.1823379546403885,
0.606734037399292,
0.4461607038974762,
-0.9017496109008789,
0.007746192626655102,
0.003330252133309841,
-0.6208003163337708,
0.2773771584033966,
-0.671567440032959,
0.0010438923491165042,
-0.2000138759613037,
0.3086777627468109,
-0.8158493638038635,
-0.18494711816310883,
0.059368666261434555,
-0.29068875312805176,
0.17081181704998016,
-0.18067166209220886,
-0.5854963660240173,
0.19038811326026917,
0.01830725185573101,
0.6868770718574524,
0.7140482068061829,
-0.5933095216751099,
0.7868686318397522,
0.2685101628303528,
-0.2705264985561371,
-0.37976276874542236,
-0.5146883130073547,
0.04075423255562782,
-0.15873883664608002,
-0.579930305480957,
0.2815703749656677,
0.1271534562110901,
-0.6494396924972534,
0.12527574598789215,
-0.27475762367248535,
0.027642952278256416,
-0.05697159469127655,
-0.02498432993888855,
0.11028113216161728,
-0.22449371218681335,
0.47943782806396484,
0.15426477789878845,
-0.23285023868083954,
0.39427560567855835,
-0.20980003476142883,
0.23902074992656708,
-0.28877702355384827,
-0.5905683040618896,
-0.15110358595848083,
0.1314133256673813,
0.4060346484184265,
-0.03375346213579178,
0.7614100575447083,
0.26738211512565613,
-0.29995864629745483,
-0.411201149225235,
-0.5246323347091675,
-0.30176690220832825,
-0.4198276102542877,
0.3109501600265503,
-0.46772679686546326,
-1.0384327173233032,
0.5015172958374023,
-0.42858123779296875,
0.4000847637653351,
0.4137958288192749,
0.33938995003700256,
0.03968919813632965,
1.2729445695877075,
0.3869559168815613,
0.38418760895729065,
0.03132358565926552,
-0.34292230010032654,
0.15503159165382385,
-0.7173519134521484,
-0.745552122592926,
-0.29521214962005615,
-0.21285825967788696,
-0.178147554397583,
-0.5299668312072754,
0.280614972114563,
-0.025958549231290817,
-0.42208555340766907,
-0.36195969581604004,
-0.25023046135902405,
0.5846315026283264,
0.26306310296058655,
0.093321293592453,
0.7302730083465576,
-0.025121789425611496,
-0.21984033286571503,
0.013827216811478138,
-0.7625304460525513,
-0.9620709419250488,
1.0680068731307983,
0.30343469977378845,
0.8913736939430237,
0.20165257155895233,
0.4122237265110016,
0.34322020411491394,
0.46727705001831055,
-0.8779999017715454,
0.7732996344566345,
-0.18409323692321777,
-0.437809020280838,
-0.1506887823343277,
-0.679562509059906,
-0.8991460204124451,
0.4733145236968994,
-0.024944059550762177,
-0.33294782042503357,
-0.07554414123296738,
0.3344367444515228,
-0.1863875687122345,
0.5112631916999817,
-0.5334886908531189,
0.48256877064704895,
-0.3281403183937073,
-0.05356823280453682,
-0.40356191992759705,
-0.4985436499118805,
0.6732731461524963,
0.08880361914634705,
0.33618882298469543,
-0.27023833990097046,
-0.29042738676071167,
0.6248971223831177,
-0.17747731506824493,
0.9145336747169495,
-0.13993902504444122,
-0.16541728377342224,
0.30541813373565674,
0.026386084035038948,
0.2496148943901062,
0.03572102263569832,
-0.24111323058605194,
0.2036125659942627,
-0.16115744411945343,
-0.7088820934295654,
-0.7898927330970764,
0.5670256614685059,
-0.4482384920120239,
-0.7325965762138367,
-0.5237725377082825,
-0.6558454632759094,
-0.2812616229057312,
-0.087943434715271,
0.04970612749457359,
0.4937683641910553,
-0.23204585909843445,
0.21808725595474243,
1.1636992692947388,
-0.022911671549081802,
0.1258615255355835,
0.6346160173416138,
-0.061295539140701294,
-0.16852840781211853,
0.8890963792800903,
0.1141401156783104,
0.47076869010925293,
0.6036999821662903,
0.22156071662902832,
-0.7619873285293579,
-0.8140904903411865,
-0.216329887509346,
0.4356762766838074,
-1.0144643783569336,
-0.10188287496566772,
-0.6068171262741089,
-0.04955628141760826,
-0.11670295894145966,
-0.055617157369852066,
-0.1345277577638626,
-0.604164719581604,
-0.06118251755833626,
-0.16571663320064545,
0.31253600120544434,
0.8182797431945801,
-0.08870342373847961,
-0.17988811433315277,
-0.836204469203949,
0.33393624424934387,
0.5485181212425232,
0.10750521719455719,
0.2857120931148529,
-0.9818533658981323,
-0.04085024818778038,
0.13473348319530487,
-0.28161197900772095,
-0.46619951725006104,
0.001221893122419715,
0.3317209482192993,
0.7613800764083862,
0.7034443616867065,
0.17903275787830353,
0.3955637514591217,
-0.5111702084541321,
0.531984269618988,
0.10279848426580429,
-0.7774761915206909,
0.46210360527038574,
-0.18032300472259521,
0.49924105405807495,
0.4578250050544739,
0.4859044551849365,
-0.32034894824028015,
-0.29387912154197693,
-0.5485875010490417,
-0.6454439759254456,
0.30072396993637085,
-0.08676483482122421,
0.12461958080530167,
-0.13891750574111938,
0.5363795757293701,
0.29742780327796936,
0.15092939138412476,
-0.6667485237121582,
-0.1862463802099228,
-0.05384129285812378,
-0.30621761083602905,
-0.005091142375022173,
-0.22770562767982483,
-0.14430859684944153,
-0.4917331635951996,
0.5280259847640991,
-0.2022867500782013,
-0.04789476469159126,
0.08867254853248596,
-0.18162958323955536,
0.28375959396362305,
0.39657288789749146,
0.594388484954834,
1.059576153755188,
-0.12571440637111664,
0.37589746713638306,
0.4264035224914551,
-0.16220562160015106,
0.2420741766691208,
-0.1521487683057785,
-0.10229306668043137,
-0.01655510812997818,
0.6411162614822388,
0.49298593401908875,
0.445205956697464,
-1.1363446712493896,
0.27339670062065125,
0.027345027774572372,
-0.47437310218811035,
-0.32936668395996094,
0.387565553188324,
0.2713957726955414,
0.10210751742124557,
0.4768294095993042,
-0.06352058798074722,
0.07749202847480774,
-0.8857930302619934,
0.09879767894744873,
0.38138389587402344,
-0.10201497375965118,
-0.4153347909450531,
0.3782113790512085,
0.1648988276720047,
-0.08044644445180893,
0.7044203877449036,
-0.2701263427734375,
-0.5691869854927063,
0.46349552273750305,
0.5911077857017517,
0.5180857181549072,
-0.08864839375019073,
0.030675895512104034,
0.3812809884548187,
0.1343873292207718,
-0.3141342103481293,
0.1705256998538971,
-0.05357971414923668,
-0.7581745982170105,
-0.866735577583313,
-0.5461609959602356,
-0.5968425273895264,
0.24334079027175903,
-0.5620409846305847,
-0.08365930616855621,
-0.5711815357208252,
0.14151252806186676,
-0.13938294351100922,
-0.07329761236906052,
-0.43038180470466614,
0.21892598271369934,
0.000013051595487922896,
1.05709969997406,
-0.9071050882339478,
0.7344285249710083,
0.8464619517326355,
-0.3597899377346039,
-0.7168312072753906,
-0.12673868238925934,
-0.13110288977622986,
-0.7578408122062683,
0.6870683431625366,
0.2656967043876648,
-0.3253636658191681,
-0.19562691450119019,
-0.6752604246139526,
-0.625586986541748,
0.9219412803649902,
0.6409555673599243,
-0.5553971529006958,
-0.0335744209587574,
0.18798038363456726,
0.5948632955551147,
-0.46546703577041626,
0.13568934798240662,
0.6098771691322327,
0.5376337170600891,
0.5213721990585327,
-0.3573012053966522,
0.21120846271514893,
-0.016645999625325203,
-0.20140811800956726,
0.13613228499889374,
-0.4155523180961609,
0.6595281958580017,
-0.5573557615280151,
-0.22124899923801422,
-0.007364145014435053,
0.7526997923851013,
0.7326511144638062,
0.5303487777709961,
0.4657447934150696,
0.8391332030296326,
0.8957501649856567,
-0.07630255818367004,
1.1103618144989014,
-0.0054945023730397224,
-0.09380610287189484,
1.0029113292694092,
-0.256098210811615,
0.8078937530517578,
0.23517769575119019,
-0.06969443708658218,
0.9413661360740662,
0.4833436906337738,
0.21290050446987152,
0.35654953122138977,
0.33827298879623413,
-0.7868829965591431,
-0.7452600002288818,
0.033582307398319244,
-0.5001623630523682,
0.3640117347240448,
0.6580328941345215,
-0.33494821190834045,
-0.3992391526699066,
-0.11542646586894989,
0.025906352326273918,
0.43958163261413574,
-0.5262098908424377,
0.7726321816444397,
0.4260943830013275,
-0.7107897996902466,
0.6362549662590027,
0.05726425349712372,
0.48126059770584106,
-0.6112788915634155,
-0.6373754739761353,
-0.10769698768854141,
0.24409957230091095,
-0.2682165205478668,
-0.8302268385887146,
0.39687561988830566,
-0.027333706617355347,
-0.4031539857387543,
-0.08383665978908539,
0.5691442489624023,
-0.3411210775375366,
-0.40006330609321594,
0.1321180760860443,
0.43552690744400024,
0.3921135365962982,
0.002441062591969967,
-0.6538968682289124,
0.03645894676446915,
0.019765669479966164,
0.21079574525356293,
0.5959445834159851,
0.5962509512901306,
0.05577944219112396,
1.021044135093689,
0.7691767811775208,
0.09965240955352783,
-0.21448704600334167,
0.14467960596084595,
0.7868610620498657,
-0.8274844884872437,
-0.25876110792160034,
-0.8511533141136169,
0.45858830213546753,
-0.03785857930779457,
-0.20240841805934906,
0.7213583588600159,
0.6260906457901001,
0.893564760684967,
-0.06953268498182297,
0.9218499064445496,
0.22207579016685486,
0.7605482935905457,
-0.8631802201271057,
0.3240785300731659,
-0.31906867027282715,
0.7259975075721741,
0.21923525631427765,
-0.9133618474006653,
-0.3021939992904663,
0.7639618515968323,
-0.5123525261878967,
0.13880790770053864,
0.6030899286270142,
0.650785505771637,
-0.150001659989357,
0.035185202956199646,
0.4934980273246765,
0.33623868227005005,
0.33253389596939087,
0.624042809009552,
1.1894298791885376,
-0.029231633991003036,
0.5726370811462402,
0.12887372076511383,
-0.22586572170257568,
-0.011230739764869213,
-0.8993320465087891,
-1.0923855304718018,
-0.29771488904953003,
-0.3076537549495697,
-0.08051798492670059,
0.40475472807884216,
0.9109553098678589,
0.5468890070915222,
-0.7832858562469482,
-0.0030452366918325424,
-0.2916635572910309,
0.48763182759284973,
-0.025626853108406067,
-0.25420382618904114,
0.34572887420654297,
-0.5675251483917236,
-0.5249863266944885,
0.38845351338386536,
0.19254161417484283,
-0.10955258458852768,
-0.06126005947589874,
-0.31805849075317383,
-0.08917225152254105,
0.2078213095664978,
0.952345609664917,
0.59006267786026,
-0.9313340783119202,
-0.42593151330947876,
-0.31204500794410706,
0.13467015326023102,
-0.0366327203810215,
0.9138664603233337,
-0.9779195785522461,
0.06443329900503159,
0.4385637938976288,
0.6860249042510986,
0.19146910309791565,
0.17912724614143372,
0.5229184031486511,
-0.5585739016532898,
-0.1001080721616745,
0.588182270526886,
0.3984106779098511,
0.3991839289665222,
0.15486116707324982,
0.285013884305954,
0.20897018909454346,
-0.6501632332801819,
-0.7695879340171814,
0.4162340462207794,
-0.8068095445632935,
-0.6770032048225403,
1.2897334098815918,
-0.26423314213752747,
-0.004651766270399094,
-0.694470226764679,
-0.07653290033340454,
-0.10150449723005295,
-0.3846088647842407,
0.992358386516571,
0.4780985116958618,
-0.4305618703365326,
-0.13807082176208496,
-0.4004768133163452,
0.4667448103427887,
0.36875584721565247,
-0.8230065107345581,
-0.18329623341560364,
0.5232850313186646,
0.6037746071815491,
-0.054653067141771317,
0.4494994580745697,
-0.15355679392814636,
0.4185762405395508,
-0.12006068229675293,
-0.0758543387055397,
-0.03974571451544762,
-0.4499194920063019,
-0.295739084482193,
0.17580799758434296,
0.5290385484695435,
0.09293725341558456
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09077v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09077v1
|
Information Extraction: An application to the domain of hyper-local financial data on developing countries
| 2024-03-14T03:49:36 | 2024-03-14T03:49:36 |
Abuzar Royesh, Olamide Oladeji
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Despite the need for financial data on company activities in developing
countries for development research and economic analysis, such data does not
exist. In this project, we develop and evaluate two Natural Language Processing
(NLP) based techniques to address this issue. First, we curate a custom dataset
specific to the domain of financial text data on developing countries and
explore multiple approaches for information extraction. We then explore a
text-to-text approach with the transformer-based T5 model with the goal of
undertaking simultaneous NER and relation extraction. We find that this model
is able to learn the custom text structure output data corresponding to the
entities and their relations, resulting in an accuracy of 92.44\%, a precision
of 68.25\% and a recall of 54.20\% from our best T5 model on the combined task.
Secondly, we explore an approach with sequential NER and relation extration.
For the NER, we run pre-trained and fine-tuned models using SpaCy, and we
develop a custom relation extraction model using SpaCy's Dependency Parser
output and some heuristics to determine entity relationships \cite{spacy}. We
obtain an accuracy of 84.72\%, a precision of 6.06\% and a recall of 5.57\% on
this sequential task.
|
[
-0.30502188205718994,
-0.9394127726554871,
0.1469731330871582,
0.3034277856349945,
0.011189160868525505,
0.2081204056739807,
-0.29868167638778687,
-0.934691309928894,
0.13735397160053253,
0.8689623475074768,
-0.2152092456817627,
-0.5772289037704468,
-0.5960705876350403,
0.280233234167099,
-0.3480023741722107,
1.3026740550994873,
0.17705033719539642,
-0.22155378758907318,
0.15902245044708252,
0.14280863106250763,
-0.19990487396717072,
-0.5275588035583496,
-0.8781225681304932,
-0.1944487988948822,
-0.06303922832012177,
0.5779617428779602,
0.6268343925476074,
0.6133283376693726,
0.8573608994483948,
0.3083229064941406,
-0.06744597107172012,
0.10097087919712067,
-0.17496642470359802,
-0.09552041441202164,
-0.2801629900932312,
-0.3281668424606323,
-0.6159312725067139,
-0.1426527053117752,
0.2702024281024933,
0.4500816762447357,
-0.2364739328622818,
0.5664845705032349,
-0.04283273592591286,
0.6874271631240845,
-0.5310173034667969,
0.7879787683486938,
-0.5260888934135437,
0.09214942902326584,
-0.2021620273590088,
-0.16636121273040771,
-0.33993449807167053,
-0.2996658980846405,
0.8231228590011597,
-0.6780305504798889,
0.45966050028800964,
-0.027761664241552353,
1.357533574104309,
0.04074937105178833,
-0.42844271659851074,
-0.5580748319625854,
-1.0205892324447632,
0.9044339656829834,
-0.5993631482124329,
0.2778477668762207,
0.49294885993003845,
0.316930890083313,
0.12576128542423248,
-0.8514565229415894,
-0.2932370603084564,
0.14476382732391357,
-0.2556161880493164,
0.17215877771377563,
-0.27715110778808594,
-0.10215838998556137,
0.3569028377532959,
0.5267858505249023,
-0.11411520093679428,
-0.1719835251569748,
-0.5048103928565979,
-0.057149238884449005,
0.5982317328453064,
-0.0877060666680336,
0.06403489410877228,
-0.5301774740219116,
-0.5032726526260376,
-0.027402544394135475,
-0.5842114090919495,
-0.07260186225175858,
0.22735609114170074,
0.47456997632980347,
-0.29174813628196716,
0.6994001269340515,
-0.015191655606031418,
0.6476659178733826,
0.22319909930229187,
-0.41424500942230225,
0.19790193438529968,
-0.5460141897201538,
-0.37768423557281494,
0.0024387177545577288,
0.5689607262611389,
0.054611653089523315,
0.573050320148468,
-0.3063510060310364,
-0.4091835916042328,
-0.323988139629364,
0.03928035870194435,
-0.37980422377586365,
-0.2725464105606079,
-0.0058857412077486515,
-0.6867389678955078,
-0.3690050542354584,
0.17590421438217163,
-1.2627789974212646,
-0.10379087924957275,
-0.46544381976127625,
0.2046472430229187,
-0.19224078953266144,
-0.37073269486427307,
-0.25968754291534424,
-0.33283549547195435,
0.4215271770954132,
-0.1181531473994255,
-1.1716338396072388,
0.7675241231918335,
0.6032874584197998,
0.7721325159072876,
-0.27528417110443115,
0.2575444281101227,
-0.46219927072525024,
0.473248690366745,
0.22035032510757446,
0.7496969103813171,
-0.6152693033218384,
-0.28015249967575073,
-0.17786210775375366,
-0.09504212439060211,
-0.1430484652519226,
-0.9559018611907959,
0.5143856406211853,
-0.6469284892082214,
0.24733775854110718,
-0.1609605848789215,
-0.5422815084457397,
-0.12903092801570892,
0.15335001051425934,
-0.9466190338134766,
1.0729248523712158,
0.43771666288375854,
-0.9669962525367737,
0.5195153951644897,
-0.949941873550415,
-0.47151196002960205,
0.031196093186736107,
-0.0722755491733551,
-0.38967519998550415,
-0.08477699756622314,
0.48684191703796387,
0.2822946012020111,
-0.7269402742385864,
0.4836359918117523,
-0.06061837822198868,
-0.07888097316026688,
-0.035395245999097824,
-0.3429461121559143,
0.6663953065872192,
-0.02044258639216423,
-0.4753536880016327,
-0.2282896488904953,
-1.1672414541244507,
-0.20049898326396942,
0.24146951735019684,
-0.30278855562210083,
-0.6393315196037292,
-0.05377713963389397,
0.3436768352985382,
0.3734372854232788,
0.6470747590065002,
-0.5377715229988098,
0.2449849247932434,
-0.7177683711051941,
0.3423890769481659,
0.626249372959137,
0.336870402097702,
0.5069540739059448,
0.13630814850330353,
0.41974586248397827,
0.08267807960510254,
0.059611640870571136,
0.06714429706335068,
-0.32511335611343384,
-0.6913697719573975,
-0.031003437936306,
0.6622848510742188,
0.7790158987045288,
-0.7103844285011292,
0.3001851737499237,
-0.12535111606121063,
-0.20690038800239563,
-0.38411247730255127,
0.0355808399617672,
0.1434493213891983,
0.9274212718009949,
0.47727885842323303,
-0.193362757563591,
-0.9454935789108276,
-0.9859105944633484,
-0.19469010829925537,
0.029239654541015625,
0.07524765282869339,
0.12053382396697998,
0.5559989809989929,
-0.022981327027082443,
1.2584213018417358,
-0.8514476418495178,
-0.39036011695861816,
-0.48641666769981384,
0.18045039474964142,
0.5673377513885498,
0.3994460105895996,
0.4409778416156769,
-1.2839869260787964,
-0.36450111865997314,
0.2850063145160675,
-0.8388118147850037,
0.10116700828075409,
-0.15197910368442535,
0.03861336037516594,
0.21513544023036957,
0.054994046688079834,
-0.6513340473175049,
0.7460039258003235,
0.29761233925819397,
-0.24024668335914612,
0.403339147567749,
-0.3510667085647583,
-0.20386306941509247,
-1.252276062965393,
0.38836348056793213,
0.5051180720329285,
-0.10985192656517029,
-0.6520130038261414,
-0.21798451244831085,
-0.050403282046318054,
-0.04674312099814415,
0.07167403399944305,
0.726314902305603,
-0.5292184352874756,
-0.4543628692626953,
-0.18482758104801178,
0.2576216757297516,
0.030021846294403076,
0.44378456473350525,
0.24947501718997955,
0.7215561866760254,
0.3171253800392151,
-0.6352455615997314,
0.3466987907886505,
0.3296891450881958,
-0.33244404196739197,
0.2602940499782562,
-0.744202733039856,
-0.011980501003563404,
0.15152209997177124,
-0.28839924931526184,
-0.4241723418235779,
0.002422548597678542,
0.10200697183609009,
-0.15910668671131134,
0.3972386121749878,
-0.28867509961128235,
-0.5018311738967896,
-0.1293807476758957,
0.18032494187355042,
-0.12543119490146637,
0.3178437352180481,
-0.4811534881591797,
0.47834813594818115,
0.7563680410385132,
-0.602668046951294,
-0.7620286345481873,
-0.4900858402252197,
0.14571790397167206,
-0.393426775932312,
-0.4537757337093353,
0.4103470742702484,
0.5088056325912476,
-0.5471004247665405,
0.14928723871707916,
-0.32115262746810913,
-0.5647937059402466,
0.09821458160877228,
-0.00807050708681345,
0.6575902700424194,
-0.3327978551387787,
-0.02654988504946232,
-0.160868838429451,
-0.4449789226055145,
0.09445974230766296,
-0.18396279215812683,
0.24050581455230713,
0.0390116423368454,
0.19438716769218445,
-0.3301313519477844,
0.2965831160545349,
0.2273358702659607,
-0.40554144978523254,
0.8332136869430542,
0.49694788455963135,
-0.7265025973320007,
0.13074420392513275,
-0.537771999835968,
0.1347552239894867,
-0.4814737141132355,
0.1764799803495407,
-0.3783324360847473,
-0.4852933883666992,
0.6801491975784302,
-0.20642827451229095,
0.1390821635723114,
0.8830437660217285,
0.34316202998161316,
0.2666575014591217,
0.7574595808982849,
1.3538931608200073,
-0.2854330241680145,
0.5053435564041138,
-0.6341002583503723,
0.5589457750320435,
-0.6031450033187866,
-0.47938501834869385,
-0.7683722972869873,
-0.05840969458222389,
-0.6600303649902344,
0.12144757807254791,
0.24087466299533844,
0.1249370127916336,
0.0843200832605362,
0.7890608310699463,
-0.06063191965222359,
0.3908551335334778,
0.298318475484848,
-0.2437194287776947,
0.5293866991996765,
0.3045428693294525,
0.10934330523014069,
-0.5195090174674988,
-0.42710334062576294,
-0.5735808610916138,
0.9862337112426758,
0.20656991004943848,
0.6659063100814819,
-0.053728532046079636,
0.8244820833206177,
0.28281569480895996,
0.43709805607795715,
-0.6891158223152161,
0.12735460698604584,
-0.29148170351982117,
-0.38406792283058167,
-0.2551879286766052,
-0.7665009498596191,
-0.9809475541114807,
-0.15341816842556,
-0.15893884003162384,
-0.9091053605079651,
0.46650081872940063,
-0.22640201449394226,
-0.3250848054885864,
0.19134800136089325,
-0.8311977386474609,
0.7624104619026184,
-0.035203803330659866,
-0.2689448893070221,
0.09358537197113037,
-0.5063089728355408,
0.3767055571079254,
-0.23457004129886627,
0.3769167959690094,
0.09208434820175171,
0.019239630550146103,
0.6963717937469482,
-0.30800896883010864,
0.5157495737075806,
-0.2784615159034729,
-0.13120166957378387,
0.28842633962631226,
-0.10038155317306519,
0.4845755398273468,
0.25358307361602783,
-0.535828173160553,
0.06970228254795074,
-0.14270135760307312,
-0.25726643204689026,
-0.7342138290405273,
0.531420886516571,
-0.5000787377357483,
-0.2577151656150818,
-0.3578961193561554,
-0.6101648211479187,
-0.23400411009788513,
0.24974121153354645,
-0.017732292413711548,
0.37185701727867126,
-0.22057846188545227,
-0.05632143095135689,
0.31892096996307373,
-0.09019407629966736,
0.7291334867477417,
0.3434423506259918,
0.1169731616973877,
-0.557712197303772,
0.881232738494873,
0.2361857295036316,
0.07262307405471802,
0.542770504951477,
0.0718553438782692,
-0.4099702537059784,
-0.2263253778219223,
-0.39215418696403503,
0.3213217556476593,
-0.555021345615387,
-0.39171192049980164,
-0.614696204662323,
-0.30080822110176086,
-0.5820850729942322,
0.15328583121299744,
-0.2806106209754944,
-0.5750629901885986,
-0.1889519840478897,
-0.2752667963504791,
0.217962846159935,
0.9489986896514893,
-0.06668861955404282,
0.10787425935268402,
-1.231006145477295,
0.5433440804481506,
-0.10843979567289352,
-0.04030813276767731,
-0.06705813854932785,
-0.19423091411590576,
-0.6396268010139465,
-0.19947007298469543,
-0.23259174823760986,
-0.8792639374732971,
0.9538677930831909,
0.11283470690250397,
0.3648304045200348,
0.47182562947273254,
-0.07849452644586563,
1.1384068727493286,
0.08449827134609222,
0.3711943030357361,
-0.005869705229997635,
-0.9843546152114868,
0.7195043563842773,
-0.017801158130168915,
0.06980181485414505,
0.6127669215202332,
0.4696815311908722,
-0.402849018573761,
-0.17676600813865662,
-1.1451537609100342,
-1.1153032779693604,
0.7902603149414062,
0.33867567777633667,
-0.3239365220069885,
0.09002529829740524,
0.6530713438987732,
0.12685032188892365,
0.39400169253349304,
-0.701423704624176,
-0.321321964263916,
0.40140894055366516,
-0.227547749876976,
0.16569629311561584,
-0.09561045467853546,
0.22259703278541565,
-0.17627780139446259,
0.5906102657318115,
0.11957923322916031,
-0.036574967205524445,
0.4954719841480255,
-0.14801718294620514,
-0.0860530212521553,
0.022262385115027428,
0.10852955281734467,
1.1278201341629028,
-0.15877869725227356,
-0.052802592515945435,
0.16586828231811523,
-0.5892167091369629,
-0.1838139444589615,
0.30929234623908997,
-0.3295629024505615,
0.16948747634887695,
0.488633930683136,
0.3034844696521759,
0.21144777536392212,
-0.5710468292236328,
0.4376283884048462,
-0.20481888949871063,
0.11764378845691681,
-0.47965893149375916,
-0.21560950577259064,
-0.02664685994386673,
0.26411163806915283,
0.5637787580490112,
0.29386642575263977,
0.3024756610393524,
-0.49356064200401306,
0.36771342158317566,
-0.11620263755321503,
-0.3881765305995941,
-0.4602537155151367,
0.4251475930213928,
0.1357303410768509,
-0.15335536003112793,
0.94451904296875,
-0.2119874805212021,
-0.3110264539718628,
1.0040537118911743,
0.9941368103027344,
0.7553631663322449,
0.026341207325458527,
0.16206026077270508,
0.5485871434211731,
0.2286650389432907,
-0.06986453384160995,
0.5479862689971924,
-0.166483536362648,
-0.5845814347267151,
-0.7224709987640381,
-0.6201019287109375,
-0.4480959475040436,
0.2150680124759674,
-0.8889787197113037,
0.4595164358615875,
-0.39682549238204956,
-0.14429086446762085,
0.21010525524616241,
0.3660855293273926,
-0.7725822329521179,
0.2888495922088623,
-0.16944772005081177,
0.8355266451835632,
-0.5605183243751526,
0.8481616377830505,
0.5070409774780273,
-0.44564011693000793,
-0.7415306568145752,
-0.08389143645763397,
-0.27678564190864563,
-0.5214521288871765,
1.0241121053695679,
0.023650038987398148,
0.15101833641529083,
-0.11617078632116318,
-0.2870119512081146,
-1.056776523590088,
0.8800210356712341,
0.2924332618713379,
-0.6337680816650391,
-0.3327982425689697,
-0.00016811727255117148,
0.47260594367980957,
-0.48538973927497864,
0.10015583038330078,
0.9430481791496277,
0.6227453351020813,
-0.05018550902605057,
-0.8967386484146118,
-0.18201985955238342,
-0.30696162581443787,
-0.35802966356277466,
0.6225453019142151,
-0.3685780465602875,
0.7428268790245056,
-0.3143653869628906,
-0.26920273900032043,
-0.3160904049873352,
0.7766206860542297,
-0.03850701078772545,
0.4581422805786133,
0.28398144245147705,
0.35369324684143066,
0.855156421661377,
-0.06297401338815689,
0.8756662011146545,
-0.38838833570480347,
0.609201192855835,
1.2326834201812744,
-0.43971800804138184,
0.7582802772521973,
0.4892919063568115,
-0.08197620511054993,
0.42145732045173645,
0.5100235342979431,
-0.3028527796268463,
0.35030150413513184,
-0.02020081877708435,
-0.1374216079711914,
0.2062896490097046,
-0.21627742052078247,
-0.061439428478479385,
0.584890604019165,
0.4334309995174408,
-0.3888718783855438,
-0.11862173676490784,
-0.3653325140476227,
0.08475778251886368,
-0.1246538907289505,
-0.10512708872556686,
0.8842267990112305,
0.3716702461242676,
-0.47913858294487,
-0.16961178183555603,
0.43474075198173523,
0.5294866561889648,
-0.5745081305503845,
-0.3245646059513092,
-0.08139359951019287,
0.22935260832309723,
-0.38814690709114075,
-0.38087624311447144,
0.8576728701591492,
0.5543920993804932,
-0.30537331104278564,
-0.23752635717391968,
1.063788890838623,
-0.3267928659915924,
-0.5116345286369324,
0.3942019045352936,
0.7770882248878479,
-0.051262810826301575,
-0.01707017607986927,
-0.5616272687911987,
-0.6537151336669922,
-0.011952019296586514,
-0.29395100474357605,
0.15528038144111633,
0.7556305527687073,
-0.12392367422580719,
0.3221976161003113,
0.7298376560211182,
0.37039658427238464,
-0.2093876600265503,
0.18634386360645294,
0.5609616041183472,
-1.246846079826355,
-0.4270259141921997,
-1.043515682220459,
0.050114672631025314,
-0.5132046341896057,
-0.5378561615943909,
0.6347578763961792,
0.9500799775123596,
0.7304461002349854,
0.08369564265012741,
0.7674330472946167,
-0.18510690331459045,
0.2807995676994324,
-0.41281381249427795,
0.3839056193828583,
-0.006670818198472261,
0.2829456627368927,
-0.4408182203769684,
-1.1433807611465454,
-0.22507962584495544,
0.4799143671989441,
-0.432976096868515,
-0.260748028755188,
0.5965221524238586,
0.4116806387901306,
-0.18348202109336853,
0.22328157722949982,
-0.06291201710700989,
0.1511206328868866,
0.20511479675769806,
0.2989432215690613,
0.4029313027858734,
-0.6971288323402405,
0.6795346736907959,
-0.5207520127296448,
0.05757894739508629,
0.1663532555103302,
-0.7586802840232849,
-0.5524033904075623,
-0.28104087710380554,
-0.4007696807384491,
-0.21996814012527466,
-0.3296661376953125,
0.9116944074630737,
0.5015398859977722,
-0.7966562509536743,
-0.7172655463218689,
0.0398874431848526,
0.30763232707977295,
-0.25675395131111145,
-0.3925955891609192,
0.5434527397155762,
-0.24208486080169678,
-0.739642858505249,
0.4078221619129181,
0.5954980850219727,
0.25038760900497437,
0.005450850818306208,
0.23779648542404175,
-0.2712458372116089,
-0.3200739622116089,
0.5773743391036987,
0.13067685067653656,
-0.047080691903829575,
-0.14073693752288818,
0.18447162210941315,
0.029019752517342567,
0.2594664692878723,
0.9377631545066833,
-0.5882312059402466,
0.12120018154382706,
0.40374207496643066,
0.6728545427322388,
0.7750332951545715,
0.23306049406528473,
0.8695254325866699,
-0.5933997631072998,
0.03312378749251366,
0.13476167619228363,
0.19648034870624542,
0.21551842987537384,
-0.6317834258079529,
0.701093852519989,
0.3023131489753723,
-0.46124979853630066,
-0.3786885738372803,
-0.07492530345916748,
-0.8057505488395691,
0.13509486615657806,
0.7315133213996887,
-0.20379048585891724,
-0.5229303240776062,
-0.5126639008522034,
-0.2176753580570221,
0.4371236562728882,
-0.5977506637573242,
0.7626293897628784,
0.7867574691772461,
-0.27029407024383545,
0.14376965165138245,
-0.8141405582427979,
0.4463539123535156,
-0.027645017951726913,
-1.0209031105041504,
-0.002701789140701294,
0.06177274510264397,
0.21935929358005524,
0.3246561586856842,
0.6171234846115112,
-0.3300890326499939,
0.023151922971010208,
-0.08804953843355179,
0.142251655459404,
0.28916093707084656,
-0.3307119607925415,
-0.3123023211956024,
0.5499049425125122,
-0.32005247473716736,
0.13916495442390442
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09073v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09073v1
|
Large Language Models are Parallel Multilingual Learners
| 2024-03-14T03:33:46 | 2024-03-14T03:33:46 |
Yongyu Mu, Peinan Feng, Zhiquan Cao, Yuzhang Wu, Bei Li, Chenglong Wang, Tong Xiao, Kai Song, Tongran Liu, Chunliang Zhang, Jingbo Zhu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this study, we reveal an in-context learning (ICL) capability of
multilingual large language models (LLMs): by translating the input to several
languages, we provide Parallel Input in Multiple Languages (PiM) to LLMs, which
significantly enhances their comprehension abilities. To test this capability,
we design extensive experiments encompassing 8 typical datasets, 7 languages
and 8 state-of-the-art multilingual LLMs. Experimental results show that (1)
incorporating more languages help PiM surpass the conventional ICL further; (2)
even combining with the translations that are inferior to baseline performance
can also help. Moreover, by examining the activated neurons in LLMs, we
discover a counterintuitive but interesting phenomenon. Contrary to the common
thought that PiM would activate more neurons than monolingual input to leverage
knowledge learned from diverse languages, PiM actually inhibits neurons and
promotes more precise neuron activation especially when more languages are
added. This phenomenon aligns with the neuroscience insight about synaptic
pruning, which removes less used neural connections, strengthens remainders,
and then enhances brain intelligence.
|
[
-0.5456321835517883,
-0.7188087105751038,
0.7095827460289001,
0.435524046421051,
-0.2106025218963623,
0.1870322823524475,
-0.8268839120864868,
-0.4391072392463684,
-0.17109236121177673,
0.0983191505074501,
-0.326843798160553,
-0.2799924314022064,
-0.5780758261680603,
0.3062680959701538,
-0.16245520114898682,
0.8654680252075195,
0.02740688994526863,
0.5308998823165894,
-0.3301754593849182,
-0.4009149968624115,
-0.530182421207428,
-0.6188949942588806,
-0.6696211695671082,
-0.6396069526672363,
0.9356818795204163,
0.3856275677680969,
0.3098061978816986,
0.15343618392944336,
0.3342883288860321,
0.3064371645450592,
-0.237763449549675,
0.14334668219089508,
-0.32777419686317444,
0.05754386633634567,
-0.1698446273803711,
-0.7393816709518433,
-0.2639681100845337,
-0.2936308681964874,
0.9867390394210815,
0.9343152046203613,
-0.006183386314660311,
0.00931636244058609,
0.35527023673057556,
0.5978559255599976,
-0.5498548746109009,
0.24246421456336975,
-0.8039870858192444,
-0.05789436399936676,
-0.07436758279800415,
-0.0544186532497406,
-0.7699372172355652,
0.13894394040107727,
0.07052166759967804,
-0.34878161549568176,
-0.11455348134040833,
-0.19603942334651947,
0.3917992413043976,
0.07706820964813232,
-0.5847721695899963,
-0.09883496165275574,
-0.502119243144989,
0.7000313997268677,
-0.6111782193183899,
0.4819043278694153,
0.2217262238264084,
0.1670452207326889,
-0.06599519401788712,
-0.44335460662841797,
-0.7078237533569336,
-0.3710283935070038,
-0.2645467519760132,
-0.09092120826244354,
0.23753008246421814,
0.06432614475488663,
0.5384579300880432,
0.1368916779756546,
-0.5068906545639038,
0.2835122048854828,
-0.5053368806838989,
0.024638647213578224,
0.3326796293258667,
-0.03867208957672119,
0.6504607796669006,
0.22050867974758148,
-0.3693073093891144,
-0.12417580187320709,
-0.9101696610450745,
0.30362948775291443,
0.14372985064983368,
0.3451957404613495,
-0.18960990011692047,
0.3289492726325989,
0.1089414581656456,
0.8844841122627258,
-0.3304521441459656,
-0.38461360335350037,
0.32958152890205383,
-0.23210358619689941,
-0.07247639447450638,
0.11158322542905807,
0.7306329607963562,
0.08122587949037552,
0.47514480352401733,
-0.21869856119155884,
-0.12330304831266403,
-0.25502073764801025,
-0.1527339518070221,
-0.7507256269454956,
0.05916878581047058,
0.12064529210329056,
-0.2681002616882324,
0.2397056668996811,
-0.12686797976493835,
-0.4087451994419098,
-0.11865188181400299,
-0.3632729649543762,
0.24800433218479156,
-0.6918107271194458,
-0.3519800007343292,
0.13688936829566956,
-0.14732229709625244,
0.23603667318820953,
0.17035193741321564,
-1.0265424251556396,
0.2457973212003708,
0.6057392358779907,
0.8362422585487366,
-0.3401793837547302,
-0.9917047023773193,
-0.35558193922042847,
0.20323170721530914,
-0.43011680245399475,
0.5927524566650391,
-0.6145217418670654,
-0.1488703042268753,
-0.09801599383354187,
0.08531229943037033,
-0.3568611443042755,
-0.6553203463554382,
0.06278324872255325,
-0.6840416789054871,
-0.13638955354690552,
-0.4559989273548126,
-0.18288558721542358,
-0.4693882167339325,
0.3031053841114044,
-0.5345835089683533,
0.6149320006370544,
-0.2770073413848877,
-0.5738537907600403,
0.3962174952030182,
-0.4542284905910492,
-0.6629020571708679,
0.09904659539461136,
-0.21878409385681152,
-0.009937457740306854,
0.31562983989715576,
0.24051953852176666,
0.4770735502243042,
-0.258517324924469,
0.5443465709686279,
-0.3939245641231537,
-0.3304806053638458,
0.48926815390586853,
-0.4818818271160126,
0.8723935484886169,
-0.054323188960552216,
-0.15813681483268738,
0.21926559507846832,
-0.23655691742897034,
0.016735369339585304,
0.13692545890808105,
-0.5058021545410156,
-0.3798893094062805,
-0.035852186381816864,
-0.02872324548661709,
0.48985686898231506,
0.08241769671440125,
-0.528494119644165,
0.06579972058534622,
-0.4102775752544403,
0.6278136968612671,
0.4172361493110657,
-0.20768490433692932,
0.4955463707447052,
-0.3125919699668884,
0.351723849773407,
0.13015688955783844,
-0.2887619137763977,
-0.5335431098937988,
-0.33000415563583374,
-0.7173964381217957,
-0.36366400122642517,
0.14655089378356934,
0.40639638900756836,
-0.8047115802764893,
0.040201857686042786,
-0.27161431312561035,
-0.17729391157627106,
-0.10299468040466309,
0.39952152967453003,
0.27190011739730835,
0.4466038942337036,
0.30619344115257263,
-0.08541151881217957,
-0.10304294526576996,
-0.8397343754768372,
-0.2872568666934967,
0.15305715799331665,
0.07211991399526596,
0.26003891229629517,
0.5464299321174622,
0.08737889677286148,
0.5842629075050354,
0.05132872983813286,
-0.09964945167303085,
-0.5373260378837585,
-0.15262511372566223,
0.19749699532985687,
0.4015870690345764,
0.5503222346305847,
-0.8361432552337646,
-0.7917979955673218,
0.2200920432806015,
-0.8776755928993225,
0.33354052901268005,
-0.19257499277591705,
0.17412810027599335,
-0.029152076691389084,
0.6703160405158997,
-0.6143741607666016,
0.04367993772029877,
0.5093727707862854,
-0.0300831850618124,
0.36109232902526855,
-0.5579683780670166,
-0.08940371870994568,
-0.8544657826423645,
-0.036904022097587585,
-0.09827212244272232,
0.029511692002415657,
-0.6023459434509277,
0.14843721687793732,
0.580708920955658,
-0.25685733556747437,
-0.6606666445732117,
0.7389181852340698,
-0.6223088502883911,
-0.17032746970653534,
-0.418186217546463,
0.10232806950807571,
-0.060755278915166855,
0.6089922189712524,
0.2448570430278778,
0.7633333206176758,
0.9149733781814575,
-0.6018356680870056,
0.14944469928741455,
-0.03352782875299454,
-0.6478959321975708,
0.24393370747566223,
-0.6897975206375122,
-0.048047732561826706,
-0.3628343939781189,
0.34063732624053955,
-0.9822371602058411,
-0.40575769543647766,
-0.2649354934692383,
-0.2637757956981659,
0.49912598729133606,
0.13123475015163422,
-0.6794280409812927,
-0.10910553485155106,
0.14239972829818726,
0.7183657288551331,
0.30122682452201843,
-0.9110714197158813,
0.43567389249801636,
0.27129143476486206,
-0.2660890519618988,
-0.5007870197296143,
-0.9151381850242615,
0.11338299512863159,
-0.3900224268436432,
-0.4669114649295807,
0.1832648515701294,
-0.11800116300582886,
-0.3985773026943207,
-0.2429209053516388,
0.2527792155742645,
-0.09333537518978119,
0.25525206327438354,
-0.07239628583192825,
0.1194647029042244,
-0.26612627506256104,
0.4681079089641571,
0.07442693412303925,
0.03871450573205948,
0.0763104259967804,
-0.24654799699783325,
0.7689818143844604,
-0.24696341156959534,
-0.5023789405822754,
-0.439664751291275,
0.4668219983577728,
0.8858606219291687,
-0.6407228708267212,
0.9361255168914795,
0.3758610486984253,
-0.22669006884098053,
-0.37959927320480347,
-0.2736319899559021,
-0.37652167677879333,
-0.4428274631500244,
0.6200100183486938,
-0.7036951780319214,
-0.9049846529960632,
0.5741481184959412,
-0.2537725567817688,
-0.03130881488323212,
0.2489672750234604,
0.5934545397758484,
0.07286659628152847,
1.0731406211853027,
0.4897001087665558,
-0.09681853652000427,
0.5339570045471191,
-0.16240811347961426,
0.2905462682247162,
-0.9731642603874207,
-0.23227983713150024,
-0.2190018892288208,
-0.4734173119068146,
-0.31377801299095154,
-0.33583495020866394,
0.5092725157737732,
0.4029451608657837,
-0.1476055234670639,
-0.0416693240404129,
-0.03489011153578758,
0.792079746723175,
0.36274850368499756,
0.16016261279582977,
0.2224608063697815,
0.2522541880607605,
-0.4701649248600006,
0.024478597566485405,
-0.8841692805290222,
-0.21632236242294312,
1.013114094734192,
0.4052194058895111,
0.5100299715995789,
0.13281013071537018,
0.35932764410972595,
-0.4177663326263428,
0.43954241275787354,
-0.8809686303138733,
0.36424681544303894,
-0.21860286593437195,
-0.6493687629699707,
-0.2504301369190216,
-0.23971915245056152,
-0.6257355213165283,
0.66364985704422,
-0.12466488778591156,
-0.8224011659622192,
0.18836849927902222,
-0.07945159822702408,
-0.3081454336643219,
0.4833725690841675,
-0.7454656958580017,
0.6782057881355286,
-0.6908264756202698,
-0.5520621538162231,
-0.5475306510925293,
-0.29353469610214233,
0.4801536798477173,
-0.31845927238464355,
0.3036195933818817,
-0.0652199313044548,
-0.13101071119308472,
0.34272462129592896,
0.07263638824224472,
0.782667338848114,
0.07249649614095688,
-0.02940715290606022,
0.006646367255598307,
-0.031353093683719635,
0.2628788948059082,
0.3245312571525574,
-0.1992860734462738,
0.320392370223999,
-0.38922956585884094,
-0.506310224533081,
-0.5285719633102417,
1.0011839866638184,
-0.7141881585121155,
-0.7154352068901062,
-0.3147833049297333,
-1.138853907585144,
-0.40884724259376526,
0.2966306507587433,
0.19124257564544678,
0.35991987586021423,
0.001975168939679861,
0.481786847114563,
0.7658604979515076,
-0.37025368213653564,
0.7783358693122864,
0.5055092573165894,
-0.2712278962135315,
-0.29576635360717773,
0.7260865569114685,
0.15325041115283966,
0.5995423793792725,
0.2857254147529602,
0.17152340710163116,
-0.1323416829109192,
-0.6962432265281677,
-0.4883386492729187,
0.4140259325504303,
-0.720992386341095,
0.21767663955688477,
-0.7496406435966492,
-0.11266674101352692,
-0.18550385534763336,
-0.12301675230264664,
-0.10368391126394272,
-0.08555346727371216,
0.14811913669109344,
-0.09225951135158539,
0.03310322016477585,
0.6925097703933716,
0.026192298159003258,
0.46554240584373474,
-0.7636173367500305,
0.245503231883049,
0.3361840844154358,
0.27984827756881714,
0.32129451632499695,
-0.4316059947013855,
-0.3174741268157959,
0.13112635910511017,
-0.03547775745391846,
-0.7217640280723572,
0.45059919357299805,
0.4078350067138672,
0.8077648282051086,
0.34250253438949585,
-0.36749017238616943,
0.6454997062683105,
-0.7539986968040466,
0.510047435760498,
0.3489677309989929,
-0.7579684853553772,
0.05873359739780426,
-0.42503291368484497,
0.8266395926475525,
0.4473019540309906,
0.6731202006340027,
-0.5831083059310913,
-0.24640728533267975,
-0.23804360628128052,
-0.6991588473320007,
0.7875475287437439,
-0.37573400139808655,
0.30821341276168823,
-0.0859236866235733,
0.34222882986068726,
0.14319780468940735,
0.1604890525341034,
-0.9927451014518738,
-0.24567094445228577,
0.32254481315612793,
0.0878702700138092,
-0.5253611207008362,
-0.3323573172092438,
-0.11999331414699554,
-0.46512672305107117,
0.4121756851673126,
-0.23124974966049194,
-0.035566627979278564,
0.00782286748290062,
-0.3142516016960144,
0.10298958420753479,
0.19930477440357208,
0.5780269503593445,
1.0428640842437744,
0.18012173473834991,
0.2870927155017853,
0.6072540879249573,
-0.11844101548194885,
0.01625760644674301,
-0.21413205564022064,
-0.14257146418094635,
-0.09252431243658066,
0.547754168510437,
0.8871563076972961,
0.20100253820419312,
-0.7317119836807251,
0.33939212560653687,
-0.28492000699043274,
-0.13275130093097687,
-0.18676556646823883,
0.0023413083981722593,
0.43056127429008484,
0.2803231477737427,
0.4542013108730316,
0.21817350387573242,
-0.24208836257457733,
-0.6102473139762878,
0.2261885553598404,
0.5352038145065308,
-0.35385286808013916,
-0.24652759730815887,
0.4048100709915161,
0.04258716478943825,
-0.30640503764152527,
0.59856116771698,
-0.10864618420600891,
-0.7162027359008789,
0.7597171664237976,
0.9254403710365295,
0.5773885846138,
-0.17534677684307098,
-0.12084537744522095,
0.5870214700698853,
0.391874760389328,
-0.23328907787799835,
0.04952915757894516,
-0.24631404876708984,
-0.7949923872947693,
-0.8020011186599731,
-0.5488875508308411,
-0.029478128999471664,
0.24609121680259705,
-0.43567419052124023,
0.2850877046585083,
-0.36716991662979126,
0.1362583041191101,
-0.044139303267002106,
-0.3512369692325592,
-0.5836647152900696,
-0.10336412489414215,
0.27945563197135925,
0.9818952083587646,
-0.9543429017066956,
1.4753849506378174,
0.77167809009552,
-0.09942229837179184,
-0.7160844206809998,
0.1591378152370453,
-0.27470797300338745,
-0.4970393478870392,
1.0502184629440308,
0.4214961528778076,
0.09511231631040573,
-0.021388761699199677,
-0.33300262689590454,
-0.8561978340148926,
0.6583433747291565,
0.655353307723999,
-0.678304135799408,
0.09025826305150986,
0.256674200296402,
0.4306887090206146,
-0.4915151298046112,
0.40999835729599,
0.3593885004520416,
0.4029083847999573,
-0.171238511800766,
-0.9961116909980774,
-0.183724507689476,
-0.23054169118404388,
-0.12239422649145126,
0.11385563760995865,
-0.6446530818939209,
1.1014268398284912,
-0.35163962841033936,
-0.038915008306503296,
-0.1708041876554489,
0.5576470494270325,
0.3989122807979584,
0.1216491088271141,
0.5583833456039429,
0.31644269824028015,
0.7384279370307922,
0.03734366595745087,
1.181593418121338,
-0.5257843136787415,
0.031648457050323486,
1.2002063989639282,
-0.25088685750961304,
0.9439591765403748,
0.7590504884719849,
0.1550198197364807,
0.40628451108932495,
0.5502246618270874,
0.29811611771583557,
0.40923604369163513,
0.1359015852212906,
-0.4718957841396332,
-0.6112967133522034,
-0.153555765748024,
-0.22433225810527802,
0.3868139386177063,
0.6636859774589539,
-0.20635634660720825,
-0.2118242233991623,
0.6080304980278015,
-0.036998193711042404,
0.2672197222709656,
-0.31003913283348083,
0.5674288272857666,
0.4125705659389496,
-0.8805856108665466,
0.6063194274902344,
-0.11097274720668793,
0.6973378658294678,
-0.6690064072608948,
0.07539796829223633,
-0.16212144494056702,
0.3617016673088074,
-0.07784932851791382,
-0.6258610486984253,
0.17975156009197235,
-0.1985388994216919,
-0.24850040674209595,
-0.3364483416080475,
0.48419371247291565,
-0.6866169571876526,
-0.5052951574325562,
0.839417576789856,
0.477886438369751,
-0.025819089263677597,
-0.17504264414310455,
-0.5589205026626587,
0.06233767420053482,
-0.0038813932333141565,
-0.14281028509140015,
0.6698518991470337,
0.3301650583744049,
-0.23075273633003235,
0.8099103569984436,
0.5756955742835999,
0.2566623389720917,
0.13745497167110443,
-0.058673564344644547,
0.7365943789482117,
-0.5169376730918884,
-0.3896671533584595,
-1.0669100284576416,
0.42800864577293396,
0.02066696621477604,
-0.15468105673789978,
0.8353686928749084,
0.457975834608078,
1.227626919746399,
-0.04523172974586487,
0.8011665344238281,
0.06573605537414551,
0.1911027580499649,
-0.4264261722564697,
0.7368874549865723,
-0.654542863368988,
0.16707521677017212,
0.23797012865543365,
-0.8492510914802551,
-0.4042271375656128,
0.36532753705978394,
-0.7026007175445557,
-0.06411547213792801,
1.0083264112472534,
0.6680888533592224,
-0.20607072114944458,
-0.08922778815031052,
0.5544067025184631,
0.1402871012687683,
0.15632179379463196,
0.710972249507904,
0.9407016634941101,
-0.1403040885925293,
0.2981022298336029,
-0.4311659038066864,
-0.150421142578125,
0.1888595074415207,
-0.5386509299278259,
-1.3111202716827393,
-0.48486119508743286,
-0.02401144616305828,
-0.008256842382252216,
-0.1204509437084198,
0.761641800403595,
0.7272977232933044,
-0.8489987254142761,
-0.6341502070426941,
-0.11262389272451401,
0.2879839837551117,
-0.1479603350162506,
-0.10731369256973267,
0.25127267837524414,
-0.785558819770813,
-1.0255578756332397,
0.7777096033096313,
0.2828904688358307,
-0.27065038681030273,
-0.24713937938213348,
-0.19399455189704895,
-0.4589868187904358,
-0.39638423919677734,
0.7019107937812805,
0.19432751834392548,
-0.6667850017547607,
0.0760723128914833,
0.019949564710259438,
-0.16865479946136475,
0.02180499956011772,
0.9259250164031982,
-0.5958186388015747,
0.45468538999557495,
0.7014976739883423,
0.7068741917610168,
0.37514224648475647,
-0.3657020032405853,
0.7411465644836426,
-0.49828729033470154,
0.7392020225524902,
0.039936333894729614,
0.6675565838813782,
0.23327645659446716,
-0.22741764783859253,
-0.044073887169361115,
-0.08890453726053238,
-0.3136710226535797,
-0.6601619124412537,
0.1446608603000641,
-0.5123354196548462,
-0.6588597893714905,
1.2700579166412354,
-0.2694031596183777,
-0.3812978267669678,
0.014697265811264515,
-0.07253722846508026,
0.0874740332365036,
-0.04845106601715088,
0.4224011301994324,
0.8726840615272522,
-0.022327672690153122,
-0.21541930735111237,
-0.8193501830101013,
0.32058730721473694,
0.7595086097717285,
-0.5479655265808105,
-0.04035875201225281,
0.1705184429883957,
0.2242901623249054,
0.10628373175859451,
0.2889145612716675,
-0.14947758615016937,
0.4433687925338745,
-0.3153407871723175,
0.01918601617217064,
0.003487786278128624,
-0.6539737582206726,
-0.7453502416610718,
0.30743545293807983,
0.32604047656059265,
0.09033374488353729
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09072v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09072v1
|
UniCode: Learning a Unified Codebook for Multimodal Large Language Models
| 2024-03-14T03:29:58 | 2024-03-14T03:29:58 |
Sipeng Zheng, Bohan Zhou, Yicheng Feng, Ye Wang, Zongqing Lu
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
In this paper, we propose \textbf{UniCode}, a novel approach within the
domain of multimodal large language models (MLLMs) that learns a unified
codebook to efficiently tokenize visual, text, and potentially other types of
signals. This innovation addresses a critical limitation in existing MLLMs:
their reliance on a text-only codebook, which restricts MLLM's ability to
generate images and texts in a multimodal context. Towards this end, we propose
a language-driven iterative training paradigm, coupled with an in-context
pre-training task we term ``image decompression'', enabling our model to
interpret compressed visual data and generate high-quality images.The unified
codebook empowers our model to extend visual instruction tuning to
non-linguistic generation tasks. Moreover, UniCode is adaptable to diverse
stacked quantization approaches in order to compress visual signals into a more
compact token representation. Despite using significantly fewer parameters and
less data during training, Unicode demonstrates promising capabilities in
visual reconstruction and generation. It also achieves performances comparable
to leading MLLMs across a spectrum of VQA benchmarks.
|
[
-0.2798648178577423,
-0.5333564877510071,
-0.012597448192536831,
0.2182677686214447,
-0.3641184866428375,
0.1779624968767166,
-0.5028942823410034,
-0.1617143303155899,
0.18515382707118988,
0.5372777581214905,
-0.42099830508232117,
-0.6551299095153809,
-0.4628327488899231,
0.21961475908756256,
-0.29877880215644836,
0.7417919635772705,
0.13236477971076965,
0.09234178066253662,
-0.35811758041381836,
-0.19828163087368011,
-0.6977053284645081,
-0.8004158735275269,
-0.2633339762687683,
0.2866601049900055,
0.4481605589389801,
0.4377098083496094,
0.659172534942627,
0.48241227865219116,
0.38681864738464355,
0.3880652189254761,
0.4860870838165283,
0.24077798426151276,
-0.5296381711959839,
0.10015305876731873,
0.12662449479103088,
-0.27235931158065796,
-0.0992589220404625,
-0.4344620108604431,
0.9403395652770996,
0.7146462202072144,
0.014421596191823483,
0.09637561440467834,
0.07215426862239838,
0.5843082666397095,
-0.6507348418235779,
0.38549983501434326,
-0.6247482299804688,
0.051973607391119,
-0.2626049220561981,
-0.22217874228954315,
-0.8382406234741211,
0.03540860116481781,
-0.5280289053916931,
-0.722502589225769,
-0.07677704840898514,
0.017419228330254555,
0.7590076327323914,
0.14119037985801697,
-0.7884096503257751,
-0.06735959649085999,
-0.4162445068359375,
1.0003324747085571,
-0.13314001262187958,
0.796265184879303,
0.16946524381637573,
0.16047723591327667,
-0.0818689838051796,
-0.9806101322174072,
-0.3500717580318451,
-0.045685745775699615,
0.11322124302387238,
0.11398865282535553,
-0.16603976488113403,
-0.000627778354100883,
0.18263259530067444,
0.1609896570444107,
-0.7167342901229858,
0.05375470966100693,
-0.4043937623500824,
-0.42955631017684937,
0.4826905131340027,
0.0561300627887249,
0.734239935874939,
-0.14972302317619324,
-0.4223797917366028,
-0.2187120020389557,
-0.6291030645370483,
0.0767497643828392,
0.011244203895330429,
0.41536855697631836,
-0.07589320838451385,
0.35149434208869934,
0.05696646496653557,
0.7084444761276245,
-0.49244195222854614,
-0.024013042449951172,
0.2709329128265381,
-0.13244770467281342,
-0.31400951743125916,
-0.03431905433535576,
0.7807042598724365,
0.24248789250850677,
0.30897849798202515,
-0.035539958626031876,
-0.2415144145488739,
0.10778595507144928,
0.2654898166656494,
-1.0024409294128418,
-0.26912423968315125,
-0.09667079895734787,
-0.6996327638626099,
-0.04652044177055359,
0.06368215382099152,
-0.7345712780952454,
-0.3930976092815399,
-0.4012385606765747,
0.36840325593948364,
-0.5124624967575073,
-0.5428231358528137,
-0.25303971767425537,
-0.029010973870754242,
0.030223051086068153,
0.41071197390556335,
-1.0999497175216675,
-0.059963155537843704,
0.32722175121307373,
0.6572387218475342,
0.17254559695720673,
-0.3072669506072998,
-0.8290115594863892,
-0.04182342439889908,
-0.6313251852989197,
0.7193233370780945,
-0.864264190196991,
-0.5471025705337524,
0.22767330706119537,
-0.11021561920642853,
-0.12222457677125931,
-0.265375554561615,
0.2727387547492981,
-0.33892080187797546,
-0.27141842246055603,
-0.24432601034641266,
-0.4104529917240143,
-0.16890156269073486,
-0.08953915536403656,
-0.8787269592285156,
0.6741882562637329,
0.15744026005268097,
-0.5826104283332825,
0.5284618735313416,
-0.5699144005775452,
-0.4514594078063965,
0.4367842972278595,
-0.46071022748947144,
-0.24670244753360748,
0.3290373682975769,
0.29813629388809204,
0.4952443242073059,
-0.09320541471242905,
0.1575242131948471,
-0.4271436631679535,
-0.4604792892932892,
0.15996193885803223,
-0.607521116733551,
0.6517677307128906,
0.5446824431419373,
0.16008217632770538,
0.3498539328575134,
-0.7032736539840698,
0.29139530658721924,
0.21359901130199432,
-0.36993953585624695,
-0.41994500160217285,
-0.13458044826984406,
0.6601335406303406,
0.08297964185476303,
0.08317916095256805,
-0.4169045388698578,
0.626061737537384,
0.012833371758460999,
0.4918504059314728,
0.6540741920471191,
-0.3366580605506897,
0.51988685131073,
0.1274431198835373,
0.34969544410705566,
0.15765871107578278,
0.20894324779510498,
-0.8104733228683472,
-0.3358590602874756,
-0.6529021263122559,
-0.5768634080886841,
0.4860893785953522,
0.09340780973434448,
-1.1997555494308472,
0.015535162761807442,
-0.4601854681968689,
-0.2177337259054184,
-0.4146445095539093,
0.41681063175201416,
0.40284740924835205,
0.12212192267179489,
0.2615044116973877,
-0.3388557434082031,
-0.7061984539031982,
-0.5817743539810181,
-0.15720242261886597,
0.09046964347362518,
0.1983073204755783,
0.076618991792202,
0.5886064767837524,
-0.46312034130096436,
0.5627604126930237,
-0.03028566762804985,
-0.4269092082977295,
-0.4388889968395233,
0.3091070353984833,
-0.05991841480135918,
0.6272768974304199,
0.4203372895717621,
-1.193017840385437,
-0.4724138379096985,
0.06438557803630829,
-1.001609206199646,
0.3741869032382965,
-0.22267526388168335,
-0.07134874910116196,
0.6630113124847412,
0.717126190662384,
-0.21632790565490723,
0.39093372225761414,
0.6077167987823486,
-0.40609660744667053,
0.3626996874809265,
-0.25889068841934204,
0.17623992264270782,
-1.2403749227523804,
-0.003089339006692171,
0.053220488131046295,
-0.18812769651412964,
-0.5307961702346802,
0.2995613217353821,
0.5984209179878235,
-0.38036099076271057,
-0.3361359238624573,
0.5961400866508484,
-0.710110604763031,
-0.063583143055439,
-0.10484885424375534,
-0.29614612460136414,
-0.04004781320691109,
0.5559333562850952,
0.3501758873462677,
0.6571016907691956,
0.8343297839164734,
-0.38741201162338257,
0.23541224002838135,
0.41798165440559387,
-0.5006552934646606,
0.5015414953231812,
-0.14185179769992828,
-0.012975002638995647,
-0.32680743932724,
0.2101549357175827,
-0.8096383810043335,
-0.34684380888938904,
-0.2689340114593506,
-0.47264885902404785,
0.5922355651855469,
-0.19453217089176178,
-0.5779871940612793,
-0.3667614459991455,
-0.12818226218223572,
0.5093979239463806,
0.5937033295631409,
-0.6945528984069824,
0.6917107701301575,
0.2520783245563507,
-0.07100971788167953,
-0.7204188704490662,
-0.6637239456176758,
0.3915560841560364,
0.09485498815774918,
-0.40600377321243286,
-0.06812373548746109,
-0.24181218445301056,
-0.06613319367170334,
-0.0023632398806512356,
-0.007991684600710869,
-0.15531902015209198,
0.17603598535060883,
0.4399900734424591,
0.3317200839519501,
-0.3741905987262726,
0.5038812160491943,
0.11344963312149048,
-0.03307386860251427,
-0.31960204243659973,
-0.4929625988006592,
0.444467693567276,
-0.40413519740104675,
-0.21161076426506042,
-0.25692304968833923,
0.5546542406082153,
0.4769015312194824,
-0.6191625595092773,
0.5778561234474182,
0.7373184561729431,
-0.3414469361305237,
-0.2319488823413849,
-0.09520822018384933,
0.05294577777385712,
-0.4683764576911926,
0.6480893492698669,
-0.7084052562713623,
-0.6429134607315063,
0.10535485297441483,
-0.09149092435836792,
0.12304862588644028,
0.29485228657722473,
0.7046679258346558,
-0.013238845393061638,
1.1268020868301392,
0.920479953289032,
0.03856612741947174,
0.6119359731674194,
-0.39441773295402527,
-0.04074474051594734,
-0.5231484770774841,
-0.17734107375144958,
-0.4018515348434448,
-0.1131257489323616,
-0.4554886817932129,
-0.27051135897636414,
0.2288244366645813,
0.23737886548042297,
-0.30696314573287964,
0.2556951642036438,
-0.382913738489151,
0.6103575825691223,
0.6566435098648071,
-0.011576822027564049,
0.20235097408294678,
0.3248886168003082,
-0.23404884338378906,
0.043044161051511765,
-0.7277042865753174,
-0.32040220499038696,
1.2781420946121216,
0.02671535313129425,
0.9537339210510254,
0.10505513101816177,
0.7805635929107666,
0.36475011706352234,
0.4537697434425354,
-0.7011159658432007,
0.3483823835849762,
-0.27398067712783813,
-0.23281314969062805,
-0.15068668127059937,
-0.5744888186454773,
-1.01054847240448,
0.3017014265060425,
-0.35515403747558594,
-0.8371750116348267,
-0.004876596387475729,
0.03141046687960625,
-0.04379360377788544,
0.3251701593399048,
-0.855989396572113,
1.1139265298843384,
-0.16254322230815887,
-0.32207512855529785,
-0.025164267048239708,
-0.6046421527862549,
0.2836371958255768,
-0.20275254547595978,
0.40203359723091125,
0.17745333909988403,
0.018714645877480507,
0.620388925075531,
-0.2140413075685501,
0.7606972455978394,
-0.19695307314395905,
-0.18577715754508972,
0.15706734359264374,
0.35474643111228943,
0.12792044878005981,
-0.01866094022989273,
0.152434304356575,
0.366385281085968,
0.07095812261104584,
-0.5400063395500183,
-0.4623190462589264,
0.7560807466506958,
-0.7986859679222107,
-0.19593656063079834,
-0.175860196352005,
-0.8101711869239807,
-0.2158910036087036,
0.42983850836753845,
0.2194560170173645,
1.2211905717849731,
-0.05218395218253136,
0.4864795207977295,
0.3464577794075012,
-0.4475986957550049,
0.6610190272331238,
0.20134606957435608,
-0.3644316792488098,
-0.473215252161026,
1.4050620794296265,
-0.07021299749612808,
0.05160798877477646,
0.7186933159828186,
-0.17297734320163727,
-0.49575671553611755,
-0.3141115605831146,
-0.7593106627464294,
-0.04129043594002724,
-1.0476222038269043,
-0.30219513177871704,
-0.420384019613266,
-0.038125213235616684,
-0.5304365158081055,
-0.2528579831123352,
-0.3255976140499115,
-0.10638636350631714,
-0.30691882967948914,
0.2260173261165619,
0.0740765929222107,
0.7063892483711243,
0.020619530230760574,
0.04163329303264618,
-1.1291943788528442,
0.3533572852611542,
0.06193436682224274,
0.3412693440914154,
-0.06235707923769951,
-0.26808038353919983,
-0.43632200360298157,
0.2022591382265091,
-0.2541496157646179,
-0.5313352346420288,
0.5784391760826111,
0.4920918643474579,
0.4438149631023407,
0.5060526132583618,
0.09872427582740784,
0.725246012210846,
-0.4240623116493225,
0.7847313284873962,
0.615145742893219,
-1.0054622888565063,
0.31786784529685974,
-0.16167201101779938,
0.4259451925754547,
0.1460651010274887,
0.4173130989074707,
-0.6150893568992615,
-0.3152235746383667,
-0.3063633441925049,
-0.6931615471839905,
0.4521840512752533,
0.13910061120986938,
0.380504846572876,
0.02554740197956562,
-0.0898348018527031,
0.176096573472023,
0.21980492770671844,
-0.854680061340332,
-0.08622565120458603,
-0.6001893877983093,
-0.6472621560096741,
-0.20407307147979736,
-0.2398625910282135,
0.17384964227676392,
-0.25813373923301697,
0.2664420008659363,
-0.6052389740943909,
0.31548625230789185,
-0.009613006375730038,
-0.7504824995994568,
0.009256616234779358,
0.1436154842376709,
0.5361103415489197,
0.5727394819259644,
0.1474047601222992,
0.17144562304019928,
-0.4166352450847626,
-0.4414823651313782,
-0.009025299921631813,
-0.11687126755714417,
0.16908231377601624,
-0.18567264080047607,
0.5744604468345642,
0.9841423630714417,
0.26934814453125,
-0.8638027906417847,
0.5502870678901672,
-0.38739317655563354,
-0.30253317952156067,
-0.14011366665363312,
-0.18062126636505127,
-0.2311313897371292,
0.1760643869638443,
0.4542635381221771,
0.17997191846370697,
-0.03218328580260277,
-0.5953839421272278,
0.40011295676231384,
0.4837628901004791,
-0.40393301844596863,
-0.25718581676483154,
0.8586682677268982,
0.4197871685028076,
-0.09080792963504791,
0.8627387881278992,
-0.10437405854463577,
-0.2930575907230377,
0.5586597919464111,
0.7836542129516602,
0.658506453037262,
-0.027155939489603043,
0.3481389582157135,
0.4463254511356354,
0.17892631888389587,
0.23900935053825378,
0.37944266200065613,
-0.45585140585899353,
-0.627858579158783,
-0.40728437900543213,
-0.7854329347610474,
-0.08086308091878891,
-0.05809079855680466,
-0.6070339679718018,
0.26041534543037415,
-0.25550350546836853,
0.23660410940647125,
-0.03267139568924904,
-0.2070370614528656,
-0.6592483520507812,
0.19415222108364105,
0.6097152233123779,
0.8672898411750793,
-0.5538898706436157,
1.041823148727417,
0.7189823985099792,
-0.7126728296279907,
-0.7554482221603394,
-0.26633933186531067,
-0.09193464368581772,
-0.9117902517318726,
0.9327194094657898,
0.49713727831840515,
0.28531327843666077,
0.3839223086833954,
-0.6098659634590149,
-0.6538253426551819,
0.7058371901512146,
0.47337865829467773,
-0.6514285206794739,
0.180027574300766,
0.13644418120384216,
0.09313705563545227,
-0.16331833600997925,
0.36846303939819336,
0.10175539553165436,
0.39168041944503784,
0.09354318678379059,
-0.8010661005973816,
-0.0493600070476532,
-0.627940833568573,
0.35627150535583496,
0.3062613606452942,
-0.46650591492652893,
0.8812506794929504,
-0.44017282128334045,
-0.3890060484409332,
0.3797946274280548,
0.8138710856437683,
-0.15577483177185059,
-0.01666042022407055,
0.2892438769340515,
0.3805335462093353,
0.7260228991508484,
-0.16084891557693481,
1.1771957874298096,
-0.30797716975212097,
0.3544589579105377,
0.6475946307182312,
-0.18798154592514038,
0.8380811214447021,
0.43514400720596313,
0.2590404450893402,
0.4965039789676666,
0.5297773480415344,
-0.028734523802995682,
0.3906978368759155,
0.034949999302625656,
-0.1304592490196228,
-0.5468986630439758,
-0.1042492687702179,
-0.21880266070365906,
0.5634075999259949,
0.36739179491996765,
-0.15909193456172943,
-0.3586488962173462,
0.6687864065170288,
-0.21796071529388428,
0.1729838103055954,
-0.6413949728012085,
0.7589737772941589,
0.04528067633509636,
-0.47900572419166565,
1.0086042881011963,
-0.15839911997318268,
0.4391878843307495,
-0.691338837146759,
-0.2363474816083908,
-0.2972058951854706,
0.27148014307022095,
-0.06745699048042297,
-0.5514646172523499,
-0.06917528063058853,
-0.018141018226742744,
0.006085959263145924,
-0.35329267382621765,
0.6770472526550293,
-0.5551270246505737,
-0.6590384244918823,
0.006152706686407328,
0.2214239090681076,
0.06643813103437424,
-0.32027778029441833,
-0.5551260709762573,
0.5358874201774597,
0.007483325898647308,
-0.19766199588775635,
0.4036729335784912,
0.4304291903972626,
-0.2036818563938141,
0.7212544083595276,
0.6121653914451599,
-0.3061060607433319,
0.08142335712909698,
0.2736903727054596,
0.6890934705734253,
-0.7679443359375,
-0.5359057784080505,
-0.676134467124939,
0.6389613747596741,
0.04616892710328102,
-0.058461107313632965,
0.8111690878868103,
0.6203932762145996,
0.8580410480499268,
-0.3470771312713623,
0.9672480225563049,
-0.01016849186271429,
-0.39128372073173523,
-0.72507244348526,
0.7128159999847412,
-1.0105634927749634,
-0.26891958713531494,
-0.2227443903684616,
-0.6854878664016724,
-0.5590310096740723,
0.3805826008319855,
0.22074273228645325,
-0.022699331864714622,
0.7620292901992798,
0.6809734106063843,
-0.0439230315387249,
0.015635564923286438,
0.7431808114051819,
0.24597203731536865,
0.3649074137210846,
0.7013684511184692,
0.8013243079185486,
-0.4329865276813507,
0.7115235328674316,
0.14515750110149384,
-0.21341252326965332,
-0.2804999351501465,
-0.7115800976753235,
-0.932835042476654,
-1.051270842552185,
-0.14850544929504395,
-0.15016041696071625,
-0.22327746450901031,
1.0140458345413208,
0.8147489428520203,
-0.5971873998641968,
-0.22674232721328735,
-0.1339716613292694,
0.06051529571413994,
-0.19832292199134827,
-0.18503107130527496,
0.25455063581466675,
-0.696757972240448,
-0.9107507467269897,
0.23019157350063324,
0.3434208333492279,
0.03214534744620323,
-0.18232379853725433,
-0.14453895390033722,
0.2042212039232254,
-0.1322784274816513,
0.7885693311691284,
0.4250296652317047,
-0.4840657413005829,
0.04034063592553139,
-0.11022233963012695,
-0.11184804886579514,
-0.008260644041001797,
0.867825448513031,
-0.793195903301239,
0.8238866329193115,
0.12957021594047546,
0.6906264424324036,
0.19187502562999725,
-0.3546554744243622,
0.39483609795570374,
-0.8521429300308228,
0.5081563591957092,
0.02023310214281082,
0.7149935960769653,
0.28363218903541565,
-0.06622476130723953,
0.08951137214899063,
0.2231854647397995,
-0.252465158700943,
-0.933180570602417,
0.24337032437324524,
-1.0583109855651855,
-0.5669804811477661,
1.2436468601226807,
0.012603629380464554,
-0.5339998602867126,
0.18930450081825256,
-0.5025998950004578,
0.10655667632818222,
-0.3865625262260437,
0.4154789447784424,
0.2702920436859131,
0.48018231987953186,
-0.25666818022727966,
-0.2628304064273834,
0.26688703894615173,
-0.019219152629375458,
-0.7618158459663391,
0.19792769849300385,
0.6396607160568237,
0.05663875490427017,
0.020091943442821503,
0.565833568572998,
-0.07136369496583939,
0.4284351170063019,
0.27555057406425476,
0.4812402129173279,
-0.364475280046463,
-0.7293952107429504,
-0.2943101227283478,
0.26223376393318176,
-0.056712377816438675,
-0.20335496962070465
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09059v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09059v1
|
LAMP: A Language Model on the Map
| 2024-03-14T02:56:38 | 2024-03-14T02:56:38 |
Pasquale Balsebre, Weiming Huang, Gao Cong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are poised to play an increasingly important
role in our lives, providing assistance across a wide array of tasks. In the
geospatial domain, LLMs have demonstrated the ability to answer generic
questions, such as identifying a country's capital; nonetheless, their utility
is hindered when it comes to answering fine-grained questions about specific
places, such as grocery stores or restaurants, which constitute essential
aspects of people's everyday lives. This is mainly because the places in our
cities haven't been systematically fed into LLMs, so as to understand and
memorize them. This study introduces a novel framework for fine-tuning a
pre-trained model on city-specific data, to enable it to provide accurate
recommendations, while minimizing hallucinations. We share our model, LAMP, and
the data used to train it. We conduct experiments to analyze its ability to
correctly retrieving spatial objects, and compare it to well-known open- and
closed- source language models, such as GPT-4. Finally, we explore its emerging
capabilities through a case study on day planning.
|
[
-0.37691450119018555,
-0.9248991012573242,
1.0146944522857666,
0.18295757472515106,
0.07258223742246628,
-0.22601528465747833,
-0.5299365520477295,
-0.6749848127365112,
0.009715871885418892,
0.4616779088973999,
-0.3885299861431122,
-0.8479527831077576,
-0.3730739653110504,
-0.01745874248445034,
-0.5901687145233154,
0.6584436297416687,
-0.0594843290746212,
0.04261045530438423,
0.0556526817381382,
0.08254294842481613,
-0.5370474457740784,
-0.4515482485294342,
-0.47371581196784973,
-0.48095273971557617,
0.5321635603904724,
0.7863021492958069,
0.9417755603790283,
0.4741680920124054,
0.6298400163650513,
0.20942045748233795,
0.24649840593338013,
0.10203941911458969,
-0.6551215052604675,
-0.3158203363418579,
-0.2610158324241638,
-0.33226579427719116,
-0.3190579414367676,
-0.047974251210689545,
0.2571690082550049,
0.9845771193504333,
-0.2569669783115387,
0.23694173991680145,
-0.3232211470603943,
0.49602794647216797,
-0.3410925567150116,
0.19668634235858917,
-0.8005567789077759,
0.026857372373342514,
-0.28213050961494446,
-0.09768105298280716,
-0.15758316218852997,
-0.48669832944869995,
0.34317341446876526,
-0.482485294342041,
0.37473490834236145,
0.2945094406604767,
0.9514020681381226,
0.23562589287757874,
-0.169609934091568,
-0.28946632146835327,
-0.9548495411872864,
0.6480048894882202,
-0.3595081865787506,
0.309326171875,
0.7124068140983582,
0.5088528990745544,
-0.10038454830646515,
-0.49540475010871887,
-0.5406702756881714,
-0.29864493012428284,
-0.20330564677715302,
-0.22017759084701538,
0.10967985540628433,
-0.12448320537805557,
0.2656574547290802,
0.22872735559940338,
-0.5414532423019409,
-0.08777253329753876,
-0.4440038800239563,
0.276263564825058,
0.3683170974254608,
0.18395572900772095,
0.46146947145462036,
-0.28386613726615906,
-0.3498672842979431,
0.18191440403461456,
-0.9684085845947266,
-0.20278367400169373,
0.0026279324665665627,
0.2996172606945038,
-0.029409049078822136,
0.47893214225769043,
-0.15295328199863434,
0.8059583902359009,
-0.19396652281284332,
0.1908932328224182,
-0.030305759981274605,
-0.006381393875926733,
-0.2464100569486618,
-0.23164090514183044,
0.5064799785614014,
0.38950276374816895,
0.7276992201805115,
-0.27224135398864746,
-0.22971203923225403,
-0.012287449091672897,
0.16927574574947357,
-0.5540798902511597,
-0.8181993961334229,
0.23820196092128754,
-0.16932719945907593,
-0.07570165395736694,
-0.060975220054388046,
-0.6135087013244629,
-0.5251097679138184,
-0.3873625099658966,
0.10076248645782471,
-0.37876611948013306,
-0.3186599910259247,
0.3983333110809326,
0.32281315326690674,
0.2621921896934509,
0.33346736431121826,
-1.2357566356658936,
0.2151910364627838,
0.6279694437980652,
0.7763532400131226,
-0.3414500951766968,
-0.49141645431518555,
-0.038120996206998825,
0.3513450026512146,
-0.5317881107330322,
0.9074148535728455,
-0.667193591594696,
-0.4655334949493408,
0.09659961611032486,
-0.09128489345312119,
0.13903182744979858,
-0.5654942393302917,
0.2831457853317261,
-0.4678163528442383,
0.0819033831357956,
-0.5016376972198486,
-0.2286529392004013,
-0.0035705785267055035,
0.3811989724636078,
-0.5507265329360962,
1.1978957653045654,
0.24027836322784424,
-0.5357205867767334,
0.36364880204200745,
-0.6270691752433777,
-0.38477909564971924,
0.020034316927194595,
-0.35766172409057617,
-0.16285139322280884,
0.33993589878082275,
0.5951765775680542,
0.40105515718460083,
-0.19051063060760498,
0.4902733266353607,
-0.0995442271232605,
-0.4588555693626404,
0.14002561569213867,
-0.16420020163059235,
0.5584617257118225,
0.2597295045852661,
-0.15455828607082367,
0.253517210483551,
-0.9119682312011719,
-0.013996455818414688,
0.0683998167514801,
-0.27685800194740295,
-0.32732975482940674,
0.17253725230693817,
0.46867835521698,
-0.0565066821873188,
0.5335374474525452,
-0.37839239835739136,
0.27281635999679565,
-0.4667237401008606,
0.3000147044658661,
0.6931571960449219,
-0.4017413854598999,
0.5867614150047302,
-0.15830190479755402,
0.4988652169704437,
-0.2338642030954361,
0.1577504426240921,
-0.12988486886024475,
-0.3056993782520294,
-0.7849977612495422,
-0.08406797796487808,
-0.020887436345219612,
0.49081018567085266,
-0.6119582653045654,
0.16411028802394867,
-0.42131251096725464,
-0.6726648211479187,
-0.08907507359981537,
-0.000839704240206629,
0.008078284561634064,
0.3765249252319336,
0.3896847367286682,
-0.018170317634940147,
-0.7465847134590149,
-0.45468130707740784,
-0.05732015520334244,
0.07100501656532288,
-0.0025471425615251064,
0.5746040940284729,
0.2638937830924988,
-0.4213680326938629,
1.2703782320022583,
-0.9515952467918396,
-0.21122896671295166,
-0.47254639863967896,
-0.26920410990715027,
0.3897600471973419,
0.17792250216007233,
0.6878678798675537,
-0.6726160049438477,
-0.39507439732551575,
-0.13728678226470947,
-0.7295273542404175,
-0.40105438232421875,
-0.02495756559073925,
-0.23553434014320374,
-0.2068205028772354,
0.5463273525238037,
-0.7903004288673401,
0.2809622883796692,
0.6624794006347656,
-0.4637505114078522,
0.49145403504371643,
-0.517876386642456,
-0.0984041690826416,
-0.8455118536949158,
-0.06002788618206978,
-0.2593191862106323,
-0.2495439499616623,
-0.6509788632392883,
0.16528911888599396,
0.015296116471290588,
-0.49949613213539124,
-0.1887902170419693,
0.6557070016860962,
-0.49899426102638245,
-0.37164944410324097,
-0.3891753852367401,
0.1643444150686264,
-0.1550818234682083,
0.3250299096107483,
0.26732727885246277,
0.8568178415298462,
0.6068630218505859,
-0.44814106822013855,
0.3812706470489502,
0.10653606802225113,
-0.6654523015022278,
0.26337748765945435,
-0.5112160444259644,
0.17239657044410706,
-0.0961933508515358,
-0.03646256774663925,
-0.869308352470398,
-0.31262102723121643,
-0.08938506245613098,
0.19018977880477905,
-0.09054945409297943,
0.06436260789632797,
-0.6693195700645447,
-0.4287266135215759,
0.17717251181602478,
0.5185715556144714,
0.21887174248695374,
-0.6831197142601013,
0.662188708782196,
0.5862802267074585,
0.026676936075091362,
-0.09997902065515518,
-0.524365246295929,
0.2100064754486084,
-0.23186111450195312,
-0.37366873025894165,
0.05971057713031769,
-0.13670268654823303,
-0.3761804401874542,
-0.16101282835006714,
0.13709647953510284,
-0.3184955418109894,
0.15202978253364563,
0.4418649971485138,
0.149698868393898,
0.05837855488061905,
0.2579081952571869,
-0.8309644460678101,
-0.332354873418808,
-0.06922507286071777,
-0.40588441491127014,
0.8487123250961304,
-0.12374399602413177,
-0.6112916469573975,
-0.06871020048856735,
0.2177121788263321,
0.446138471364975,
-0.3495137691497803,
0.33125394582748413,
0.5603057742118835,
-0.4055272936820984,
-0.3349941074848175,
-0.5445613861083984,
-0.08611878752708435,
-0.5513016581535339,
0.46502313017845154,
-0.4505564868450165,
-0.6876426935195923,
0.46730268001556396,
-0.14842890202999115,
-0.06718266010284424,
-0.07261420786380768,
0.45924440026283264,
-0.17491453886032104,
0.5384248495101929,
1.0042755603790283,
-0.2743268311023712,
0.6602497696876526,
-0.09687928855419159,
0.6526086926460266,
-0.2952285408973694,
-0.12793736159801483,
-0.34645140171051025,
-0.39879754185676575,
-0.40997886657714844,
-0.6674004197120667,
0.3139970302581787,
-0.0207699965685606,
-0.16713066399097443,
0.38367462158203125,
-0.37475845217704773,
0.8555567264556885,
0.43803325295448303,
-0.047550905495882034,
0.35611358284950256,
-0.03388109430670738,
0.10342691838741302,
-0.07927747070789337,
-0.6139948964118958,
-0.5317786931991577,
0.9525383114814758,
0.20924639701843262,
1.1572626829147339,
-0.04886269569396973,
0.5088087320327759,
0.001407979871146381,
0.22556036710739136,
-0.4706362187862396,
0.7533088326454163,
-0.14520981907844543,
-0.583057701587677,
-0.40033525228500366,
-0.164705291390419,
-0.9811211824417114,
0.1655987650156021,
0.06694412976503372,
-0.6342299580574036,
0.12646549940109253,
0.10710914433002472,
-0.5647895336151123,
0.31083741784095764,
-0.7512935400009155,
0.7506603002548218,
-0.6762248277664185,
-0.08640775829553604,
-0.20551329851150513,
-0.0695241391658783,
-0.021536264568567276,
-0.08729130029678345,
0.49187013506889343,
-0.5639896392822266,
0.30630600452423096,
0.0750012919306755,
-0.019181016832590103,
0.7981116771697998,
-0.18053461611270905,
-0.2634963095188141,
0.0799664855003357,
0.1805030107498169,
0.4503033757209778,
-0.01307170931249857,
-0.1144229844212532,
0.4015462398529053,
-0.1260247528553009,
-0.30629584193229675,
-0.4444187581539154,
0.8738418817520142,
-0.872370183467865,
-0.5535295605659485,
-0.18582816421985626,
-0.8598940372467041,
-0.2565947473049164,
0.13483604788780212,
0.12366396933794022,
0.35402095317840576,
-0.25930821895599365,
-0.24315142631530762,
0.6937388181686401,
-0.39915674924850464,
0.33800041675567627,
0.6726088523864746,
-0.9380336403846741,
0.02465694583952427,
0.7835205793380737,
0.18294323980808258,
-0.1128360778093338,
0.39022067189216614,
0.16716408729553223,
-0.098285011947155,
-0.5285910367965698,
-0.0988697037100792,
0.09301778674125671,
-0.8070293068885803,
0.045015908777713776,
-0.3676254153251648,
0.07408380508422852,
-0.11433249711990356,
-0.4720531105995178,
-0.34934547543525696,
-0.2237754464149475,
-0.21822969615459442,
-0.4182986617088318,
0.3847769796848297,
1.1948221921920776,
0.13341884315013885,
0.2475617229938507,
-0.31337520480155945,
0.3911985456943512,
0.20819969475269318,
0.5691668391227722,
-0.1313265860080719,
-0.04610848054289818,
-0.5634076595306396,
-0.21816305816173553,
0.08419028669595718,
-0.7864546775817871,
0.4909120798110962,
0.047746431082487106,
0.1796591579914093,
0.43537771701812744,
-0.1168244481086731,
0.9701474905014038,
-1.0111371278762817,
0.7732024788856506,
-0.09826736897230148,
-0.7200913429260254,
0.7394866943359375,
-0.6534234881401062,
0.5326293706893921,
0.33608904480934143,
0.13606548309326172,
-0.5105945467948914,
-0.3249709904193878,
-0.26299554109573364,
-1.0379635095596313,
0.269352525472641,
-0.10890474170446396,
0.3237855136394501,
-0.19691509008407593,
0.5050650238990784,
-0.10922345519065857,
0.25660440325737,
-1.1218799352645874,
-0.007722747977823019,
-0.07000732421875,
-0.23853769898414612,
-0.3207559287548065,
-0.5242671966552734,
-0.2050720453262329,
-0.4313580095767975,
0.217015340924263,
0.11135721951723099,
0.05259492248296738,
0.10394055396318436,
-0.2938881814479828,
-0.29210832715034485,
0.19236396253108978,
0.4388330280780792,
1.2026718854904175,
-0.16050224006175995,
0.39712896943092346,
0.47383731603622437,
-0.347924143075943,
-0.13276438415050507,
-0.10183998942375183,
-0.2813519537448883,
0.06570176035165787,
0.19925732910633087,
0.5180349946022034,
0.5517939329147339,
-0.7489380836486816,
0.34292590618133545,
0.20496831834316254,
0.2973923087120056,
-0.7010316848754883,
0.09032687544822693,
0.03767981752753258,
0.34008923172950745,
0.41386878490448,
-0.07746902108192444,
-0.08446753770112991,
-0.5588475465774536,
0.14150170981884003,
0.4547336995601654,
-0.3160786032676697,
-0.3148850202560425,
0.5758278369903564,
0.202138289809227,
-0.25287002325057983,
0.4113492965698242,
-0.0065261730924248695,
-0.4525817632675171,
0.3233157694339752,
0.4378407895565033,
0.7680538892745972,
-0.042114246636629105,
0.027244724333286285,
0.187367781996727,
0.4349554181098938,
-0.18590985238552094,
0.5227834582328796,
0.13517168164253235,
-0.7885401844978333,
-0.32017189264297485,
-0.780464768409729,
-0.28740394115448,
0.08551496267318726,
-0.35453304648399353,
0.28265172243118286,
-0.5744118094444275,
-0.14608556032180786,
-0.6122872233390808,
0.09869591146707535,
-0.9312040209770203,
0.1443062722682953,
0.24874073266983032,
1.0479986667633057,
-0.8805375099182129,
1.0807448625564575,
0.6699698567390442,
-0.18052202463150024,
-0.7804186344146729,
0.21236290037631989,
-0.49033498764038086,
-0.930874764919281,
0.7075451612472534,
0.1459064781665802,
-0.3637368381023407,
0.024382760748267174,
-0.6618033051490784,
-1.2119746208190918,
1.0119988918304443,
0.44066908955574036,
-0.7692931890487671,
-0.2616153359413147,
0.3937808871269226,
0.6995335817337036,
-0.3320329785346985,
0.21548859775066376,
0.6089345216751099,
0.47144368290901184,
-0.2882058918476105,
-1.0720657110214233,
-0.14539019763469696,
0.23670893907546997,
0.2898702621459961,
-0.05199626460671425,
-0.45473337173461914,
1.0000277757644653,
-0.5274425745010376,
-0.1302831768989563,
0.11795803159475327,
0.49043527245521545,
0.06545457988977432,
0.08501087129116058,
0.30375662446022034,
0.6192085146903992,
0.9678202867507935,
-0.3905718922615051,
1.0945988893508911,
-0.5116979479789734,
0.381541907787323,
1.2827335596084595,
-0.5050672292709351,
1.1720139980316162,
0.408027321100235,
-0.13976505398750305,
0.7094934582710266,
0.6315754055976868,
-0.1460501253604889,
0.8379037976264954,
0.3581080138683319,
-0.04389761760830879,
-0.3237093389034271,
0.12542518973350525,
-0.3267904222011566,
0.5542352199554443,
0.2884202301502228,
0.025886576622724533,
-0.4514833390712738,
0.22969460487365723,
-0.1823730170726776,
0.2619646489620209,
-0.317350298166275,
0.6214266419410706,
0.01971343718469143,
-0.48290640115737915,
0.2797407805919647,
-0.09510701894760132,
0.3811761736869812,
-0.5793818831443787,
0.10999120026826859,
-0.26923778653144836,
0.3169363737106323,
-0.3139442205429077,
-0.7050002813339233,
0.23198242485523224,
-0.006261392496526241,
-0.4206743836402893,
-0.40663760900497437,
0.5305830836296082,
-0.6377212405204773,
-0.6284301280975342,
0.4225822389125824,
0.40270113945007324,
0.16281090676784515,
-0.07584818452596664,
-0.3460142910480499,
0.2631084620952606,
-0.18501602113246918,
-0.15797428786754608,
0.02454741671681404,
0.6646217703819275,
0.07869121432304382,
0.9433571696281433,
0.6375234723091125,
0.470744788646698,
0.046833161264657974,
0.3502645492553711,
0.6157592535018921,
-0.8432338237762451,
-0.6338620781898499,
-0.8213993906974792,
0.16711914539337158,
0.06051464006304741,
-0.10465201735496521,
0.9291713833808899,
0.5429251790046692,
0.8780096173286438,
-0.12090601027011871,
0.6425233483314514,
0.14444918930530548,
0.585139811038971,
-0.48613595962524414,
0.667602002620697,
-0.19938494265079498,
0.8041142821311951,
-0.09149651974439621,
-0.9554598331451416,
-0.3722683787345886,
1.0628632307052612,
-0.9678362011909485,
0.037511371076107025,
0.5482034087181091,
0.8797004818916321,
-0.08800143748521805,
-0.19114287197589874,
0.44381096959114075,
0.26971521973609924,
0.4662184417247772,
0.5813834071159363,
0.8740153312683105,
-0.05801791697740555,
0.6084157228469849,
0.022467996925115585,
-0.028425611555576324,
-0.20059236884117126,
-0.7905652523040771,
-0.9763579368591309,
-0.4481242001056671,
0.08176211267709732,
0.12461193650960922,
0.19193804264068604,
0.8248897194862366,
0.867939829826355,
-0.8891986608505249,
-0.584950864315033,
-0.265980988740921,
0.06123275309801102,
0.1271248608827591,
-0.16296006739139557,
0.4465823173522949,
-0.39468449354171753,
-0.6560301780700684,
0.48259592056274414,
0.4148407280445099,
0.034459054470062256,
-0.5227887034416199,
0.07541482150554657,
0.011315935291349888,
-0.08757217973470688,
0.5189072489738464,
-0.011779757216572762,
-0.801464855670929,
-0.5013022422790527,
-0.06117776781320572,
-0.2737515866756439,
0.1432770937681198,
0.9068660140037537,
-0.8346060514450073,
0.4580102562904358,
0.06045415252447128,
0.4380002021789551,
0.35631078481674194,
-0.047488946467638016,
0.7403185963630676,
-0.9672917723655701,
0.3768600523471832,
0.008632153272628784,
0.5377822518348694,
0.6404068470001221,
-0.30257314443588257,
0.5755195617675781,
-0.08475398272275925,
-0.6924595236778259,
-0.5570971369743347,
0.5014147162437439,
-0.5312100052833557,
-0.40433868765830994,
1.3869272470474243,
0.1466105729341507,
0.019755611196160316,
-0.20116324722766876,
-0.3791462182998657,
-0.11248347908258438,
-0.06607265770435333,
1.2372831106185913,
0.7454594969749451,
0.0066148885525763035,
-0.34478574991226196,
-0.865778386592865,
0.7172519564628601,
0.2606886923313141,
-0.8065829873085022,
0.27545541524887085,
0.6635687947273254,
0.4814073443412781,
0.13938787579536438,
0.9177274107933044,
0.25896915793418884,
-0.00645446078851819,
-0.3787304162979126,
-0.0002265035145683214,
0.11272186785936356,
-0.5349704027175903,
-0.1605314463376999,
0.3207474648952484,
0.4204882085323334,
0.028751511126756668
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09057v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09057v3
|
A Continued Pretrained LLM Approach for Automatic Medical Note Generation
| 2024-03-14T02:55:37 | 2024-04-03T18:08:30 |
Dong Yuan, Eti Rastogi, Gautam Naik, Sree Prasanna Rajagopal, Sagar Goyal, Fen Zhao, Bharath Chintagunta, Jeff Ward
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
LLMs are revolutionizing NLP tasks. However, the use of the most advanced
LLMs, such as GPT-4, is often prohibitively expensive for most specialized
fields. We introduce HEAL, the first continuously trained 13B LLaMA2-based LLM
that is purpose-built for medical conversations and measured on automated
scribing. Our results demonstrate that HEAL outperforms GPT-4 and PMC-LLaMA in
PubMedQA, with an accuracy of 78.4\%. It also achieves parity with GPT-4 in
generating medical notes. Remarkably, HEAL surpasses GPT-4 and Med-PaLM 2 in
identifying more correct medical concepts and exceeds the performance of human
scribes and other comparable models in correctness and completeness.
|
[
0.20647595822811127,
-0.6041238307952881,
0.9258191585540771,
0.44029510021209717,
-0.377023309469223,
0.23838678002357483,
-0.06836837530136108,
-0.6516748666763306,
0.5872258543968201,
0.47278329730033875,
-0.4670710861682892,
-0.7123004794120789,
-0.5551698803901672,
0.38593563437461853,
-0.09238433092832565,
1.4213694334030151,
0.007423328701406717,
0.3298853635787964,
-0.09663700312376022,
-0.2903735041618347,
-0.2625456154346466,
-0.45544594526290894,
-0.7743690609931946,
-0.5009422302246094,
0.7899669408798218,
0.17904672026634216,
0.3384091258049011,
0.8774356245994568,
0.8882092237472534,
0.27196913957595825,
0.15744197368621826,
0.5403715372085571,
-0.17172567546367645,
0.2160484939813614,
-0.03967467322945595,
-0.6302900314331055,
-1.0140224695205688,
0.281639039516449,
0.4759531021118164,
0.2929263114929199,
-0.42812293767929077,
0.08170916140079498,
-0.23604507744312286,
0.9038858413696289,
-0.027249369770288467,
-0.17470242083072662,
-0.7450158596038818,
0.11389747262001038,
-0.588157594203949,
-0.43991562724113464,
-0.4674401879310608,
-0.5485377907752991,
-0.04538387805223465,
-0.7516679763793945,
0.1353388875722885,
-0.09562066197395325,
1.018326997756958,
0.5365082025527954,
-0.16034895181655884,
-0.4142775237560272,
-0.3671002984046936,
0.3486815392971039,
-0.7533001899719238,
0.01756218820810318,
0.4258267283439636,
0.34099164605140686,
-0.20615260303020477,
-1.3240381479263306,
-0.12559910118579865,
-0.2682364284992218,
0.25266125798225403,
0.4783954322338104,
0.1578265279531479,
0.191407710313797,
0.11071464419364929,
0.5382320880889893,
-0.2631481885910034,
0.2118455320596695,
-0.2979288697242737,
0.10834639519453049,
0.5091403722763062,
0.35149118304252625,
0.34920012950897217,
0.045652344822883606,
-0.5774991512298584,
0.29980385303497314,
-0.948508620262146,
-0.32373854517936707,
-0.22333192825317383,
-0.19902093708515167,
0.06646442413330078,
0.41047996282577515,
0.2666577398777008,
0.5935229063034058,
0.16453354060649872,
-0.7596855759620667,
0.308194637298584,
-0.4206555485725403,
-0.36926761269569397,
0.10043857991695404,
0.9179897904396057,
0.6080829501152039,
0.1561678797006607,
0.05887996777892113,
-0.016046440228819847,
0.16732659935951233,
0.664918065071106,
-0.785394549369812,
-0.5410606861114502,
0.11377266049385071,
-0.337947279214859,
-0.529234766960144,
-0.42109131813049316,
-0.3144156038761139,
-0.49890777468681335,
-0.15432165563106537,
0.06240690127015114,
-0.3632015883922577,
-0.006059309467673302,
0.0980159118771553,
0.3659440279006958,
0.027110036462545395,
0.6063451170921326,
-1.0130354166030884,
0.37067627906799316,
0.5982069969177246,
0.9538037776947021,
-0.24936680495738983,
0.031578462570905685,
-0.39345595240592957,
0.26103588938713074,
-0.6140245199203491,
1.2887966632843018,
-0.07206110656261444,
-0.16847027838230133,
-0.3420135974884033,
-0.28315022587776184,
0.018114833161234856,
-0.8582552075386047,
0.4865475594997406,
-0.1513858586549759,
0.21116872131824493,
-0.11278466135263443,
-0.7027239799499512,
0.0629197284579277,
0.41595739126205444,
-0.3848622739315033,
1.0651509761810303,
0.3779672682285309,
-0.8124655485153198,
0.5017839074134827,
-0.6199968457221985,
-0.4511592388153076,
0.26968899369239807,
-0.2188749462366104,
-0.7777493596076965,
0.016292620450258255,
0.03483365848660469,
0.3957865238189697,
-0.5714108943939209,
0.43235382437705994,
0.07698136568069458,
-0.2933579683303833,
0.1293519139289856,
-0.33820685744285583,
0.46369507908821106,
0.006879149936139584,
-0.3430106043815613,
0.07846816629171371,
-0.8717478513717651,
0.08241498470306396,
0.15585601329803467,
-0.9184179902076721,
-0.0668049156665802,
-0.17202222347259521,
-0.32286685705184937,
0.1991901993751526,
0.025268444791436195,
-0.6404994130134583,
0.46736976504325867,
-0.738091766834259,
0.492459237575531,
0.6407561302185059,
0.10777077823877335,
0.1793511062860489,
-0.6021692156791687,
0.5861640572547913,
-0.21521253883838654,
-0.04171963408589363,
-0.27610841393470764,
-0.6299723386764526,
-0.6863624453544617,
-0.6967925429344177,
0.27762100100517273,
0.933136522769928,
-0.3300139904022217,
0.2550085186958313,
0.011908266693353653,
-0.9022115468978882,
-0.9889425039291382,
0.1993771642446518,
0.5806310772895813,
0.8625484704971313,
0.6496543288230896,
-0.45642393827438354,
-0.6973788738250732,
-0.7208059430122375,
-0.3146912753582001,
-0.3008004426956177,
-0.04105732962489128,
0.3818456530570984,
-0.0688692033290863,
-0.5265776515007019,
0.4281928241252899,
-0.3364047706127167,
-0.5185474753379822,
-0.0840722918510437,
-0.14470484852790833,
0.2852388322353363,
0.3555493652820587,
0.4496706426143646,
0.020781259983778,
-0.5977085828781128,
-0.2232855260372162,
-0.8142498135566711,
-0.4871051609516144,
-0.42760780453681946,
-0.20631909370422363,
0.36507147550582886,
0.1922619342803955,
-0.6776736974716187,
0.2381313592195511,
0.3453439176082611,
-0.20334723591804504,
0.3416379392147064,
-0.496456503868103,
0.07927487045526505,
-1.2788126468658447,
0.15873955190181732,
-0.1341366320848465,
-0.47874394059181213,
-0.4614552855491638,
-0.6054478287696838,
0.15484113991260529,
0.31548452377319336,
-0.19901980459690094,
0.5033719539642334,
-0.47872865200042725,
0.04565770924091339,
-0.3832879066467285,
0.1138368770480156,
-0.0552416667342186,
0.09351303428411484,
0.04042626917362213,
0.424381285905838,
0.189240500330925,
-0.39131632447242737,
0.4501980245113373,
0.4525156021118164,
-0.1558520793914795,
0.7960819602012634,
-0.6375779509544373,
0.2884538173675537,
0.32751572132110596,
0.5027679800987244,
-0.7262074947357178,
-0.24324187636375427,
0.2864541709423065,
-0.3849487602710724,
0.4272420406341553,
0.13006965816020966,
-0.29033565521240234,
-0.5690170526504517,
-0.09504889696836472,
-0.02626766264438629,
0.6105958223342896,
-0.48682546615600586,
0.3354035019874573,
0.3482082784175873,
-0.29102087020874023,
-0.5683380961418152,
-0.6535067558288574,
0.2871571481227875,
-0.1756558120250702,
-0.4729781746864319,
0.39732134342193604,
-0.07917622476816177,
-0.18807926774024963,
-0.504499614238739,
-0.30974000692367554,
0.021766895428299904,
0.2156347930431366,
0.5063169002532959,
0.46142062544822693,
-0.24754676222801208,
0.10285163670778275,
0.1518334448337555,
-0.47315600514411926,
0.1933191567659378,
-0.14880146086215973,
0.36070215702056885,
-0.08013048768043518,
-0.4936157166957855,
-0.6028131246566772,
0.046629659831523895,
0.37236636877059937,
-0.13823245465755463,
0.3087947964668274,
0.3025487959384918,
-0.21534550189971924,
0.0680098608136177,
-0.8338560461997986,
-0.014514108188450336,
-0.4524783790111542,
0.13579061627388,
0.030124297365546227,
-0.6098496317863464,
0.2432139813899994,
-0.3624934256076813,
0.39245378971099854,
0.4763258099555969,
0.7732687592506409,
-0.39290761947631836,
0.6620553135871887,
0.30580079555511475,
0.06007898226380348,
0.10750146210193634,
0.050802264362573624,
-0.05001663789153099,
-0.6010994911193848,
-0.46324166655540466,
-0.13653863966464996,
-0.2743172347545624,
-0.49506425857543945,
-0.38330861926078796,
0.5419480204582214,
0.010437460616230965,
-0.2598268687725067,
0.11844971030950546,
-0.8603361248970032,
0.3775472640991211,
0.7363531589508057,
0.37735694646835327,
0.40746253728866577,
-0.25898513197898865,
-0.016632456332445145,
0.00495608476921916,
-0.5530622601509094,
-0.6747182607650757,
1.2839161157608032,
0.4266605079174042,
0.5824044942855835,
-0.2912154197692871,
1.1260006427764893,
-0.09557703137397766,
1.1145235300064087,
-0.584430992603302,
0.3310980200767517,
-0.1126248687505722,
-0.47736161947250366,
-0.06932378560304642,
-0.0386534184217453,
-0.8110196590423584,
0.03859645128250122,
-0.2254270315170288,
-0.10728859901428223,
-0.659247636795044,
0.6200718283653259,
-0.5336431860923767,
0.35980552434921265,
-0.398913711309433,
0.5661965012550354,
-0.41212886571884155,
-0.2614538073539734,
-0.013333012349903584,
-1.0305793285369873,
0.3609426021575928,
-0.3878079950809479,
0.024988556280732155,
-0.271024614572525,
-0.25298693776130676,
0.552946150302887,
-0.7249512672424316,
0.7426966428756714,
-0.2804289162158966,
-0.15216517448425293,
0.2835623621940613,
-0.018597371876239777,
0.28617122769355774,
0.23343728482723236,
0.11988171190023422,
-0.0008578988490626216,
-0.10078892111778259,
-0.25371766090393066,
-0.30406588315963745,
0.5237898230552673,
-0.4007401466369629,
-0.6786252856254578,
-0.5180697441101074,
-0.3986077904701233,
-0.16737490892410278,
0.03180829808115959,
0.39760127663612366,
0.28437086939811707,
-0.0969596728682518,
-0.24078430235385895,
0.5141693949699402,
-0.2844540476799011,
0.34078449010849,
0.8734036087989807,
0.04158104211091995,
-0.8829607963562012,
0.5139673948287964,
-0.02180532179772854,
0.07565862685441971,
0.1635255068540573,
0.21058033406734467,
-0.15579333901405334,
-0.5378689765930176,
-0.6916612386703491,
0.5351507663726807,
-0.3508662283420563,
-0.6668192148208618,
-0.879376232624054,
-0.2993476092815399,
-0.050287649035453796,
-0.4113854467868805,
-0.4909082055091858,
-0.24930794537067413,
-0.5007286071777344,
-0.4871281087398529,
0.7113757729530334,
0.8647850751876831,
-0.47392791509628296,
0.2973487675189972,
-1.035449743270874,
0.38877686858177185,
0.08763092756271362,
0.3048928380012512,
-0.47164228558540344,
-0.3875397741794586,
-0.1604192852973938,
-0.35386788845062256,
-0.47026804089546204,
-0.9004554748535156,
0.4026336967945099,
0.36463871598243713,
0.37209057807922363,
0.519599974155426,
-0.32842981815338135,
0.5487878322601318,
-1.0533703565597534,
0.7936779856681824,
0.530484139919281,
-0.47552868723869324,
0.8505405783653259,
-0.37924766540527344,
0.11326217651367188,
0.7182347178459167,
0.14512111246585846,
-0.4602149724960327,
-0.6043581962585449,
-0.8126745820045471,
-0.7967302799224854,
0.3068277835845947,
-0.28868305683135986,
0.016865605488419533,
-0.5088126063346863,
0.7120305299758911,
0.28449463844299316,
0.04916449263691902,
-0.5544920563697815,
-0.19380931556224823,
-0.08172416687011719,
-0.5989111661911011,
0.04482927545905113,
-0.45221269130706787,
-0.15947100520133972,
-0.24606294929981232,
0.5412869453430176,
0.034190453588962555,
0.32124990224838257,
0.4163223206996918,
0.049459006637334824,
-0.022077856585383415,
-0.10401114076375961,
0.728811502456665,
0.5440120100975037,
-0.005527718458324671,
0.0242768507450819,
0.27805328369140625,
-0.8557451367378235,
0.4953124225139618,
0.09249885380268097,
0.01423321571201086,
0.17436440289020538,
0.497384250164032,
0.7467658519744873,
0.19460640847682953,
-0.7171527743339539,
0.4861032962799072,
0.20868951082229614,
-0.3403131067752838,
-0.3165169656276703,
0.1266103833913803,
0.4131128787994385,
0.20348013937473297,
-0.12469501048326492,
0.0658676028251648,
-0.015608149580657482,
-0.1894114464521408,
0.3717191517353058,
0.12549759447574615,
-0.33357730507850647,
-0.32963624596595764,
1.0079255104064941,
0.3197295367717743,
-0.41935691237449646,
0.6220702528953552,
0.34598344564437866,
-0.32195258140563965,
0.3418046832084656,
0.8847870826721191,
0.5751259326934814,
-0.6032817959785461,
0.12073396891355515,
0.3604029715061188,
0.17950719594955444,
-0.34572863578796387,
0.5074389576911926,
-0.0618521012365818,
-0.413219153881073,
-0.5115959644317627,
-0.5727258920669556,
-0.5505831241607666,
-0.061051007360219955,
-0.5825276374816895,
0.05012664198875427,
-0.6978790760040283,
-0.38255980610847473,
0.017948780208826065,
0.024750767275691032,
-0.330180823802948,
0.5195505023002625,
-0.15510286390781403,
0.8422265648841858,
-0.6278665065765381,
0.9553360342979431,
0.7046472430229187,
-0.3588045537471771,
-0.978314220905304,
-0.5161200761795044,
0.07231695204973221,
-1.1181089878082275,
0.5469032526016235,
0.20599834620952606,
-0.01316098589450121,
-0.04150303080677986,
-0.4140477180480957,
-0.5265862941741943,
1.3083819150924683,
0.35620152950286865,
-0.7478748559951782,
-0.044236935675144196,
-0.057453010231256485,
0.7997537851333618,
-0.13285720348358154,
0.3403397798538208,
0.7032002806663513,
0.24261757731437683,
-0.17324094474315643,
-1.1358089447021484,
-0.05389780178666115,
-0.39503470063209534,
-0.2974814474582672,
0.2661757469177246,
-0.6782488822937012,
0.5060808658599854,
-0.637130618095398,
0.04286709800362587,
0.2733490765094757,
0.369763046503067,
0.775166392326355,
0.4971168637275696,
0.19872501492500305,
0.8055740594863892,
1.2509890794754028,
-0.07365360856056213,
1.0183615684509277,
-0.3298152983188629,
-0.21296469867229462,
1.2848807573318481,
-0.3748409152030945,
0.5777397155761719,
0.2843148708343506,
-0.201130211353302,
0.5292666554450989,
0.8835522532463074,
-0.1434570997953415,
0.4231424331665039,
0.5864644646644592,
-0.5682730078697205,
-0.14874984323978424,
0.21549135446548462,
-0.4392310082912445,
0.251449316740036,
0.3742144703865051,
-0.8402107357978821,
0.19071738421916962,
0.015313363634049892,
0.4952397048473358,
0.1749773919582367,
-0.18795064091682434,
1.2241793870925903,
0.4291221499443054,
-0.6460237503051758,
0.6085379719734192,
-0.20747604966163635,
0.5418657064437866,
-0.6597021222114563,
-0.02512747049331665,
-0.46185705065727234,
0.25166767835617065,
-0.29294145107269287,
-0.5700001120567322,
0.2491832822561264,
0.2522595524787903,
-0.17139393091201782,
-0.38678160309791565,
0.8211880326271057,
-0.3991720676422119,
-0.2687374949455261,
0.030323823913931847,
0.5034239292144775,
0.5022655129432678,
0.15294693410396576,
-0.4350275993347168,
-0.3142227232456207,
0.022289101034402847,
-0.33917197585105896,
0.31888508796691895,
0.48970213532447815,
0.1648852676153183,
0.6876068115234375,
0.49761879444122314,
0.4109739363193512,
0.10468600690364838,
0.12368907034397125,
0.8318735361099243,
-0.6163291931152344,
-0.27706047892570496,
-0.9192817807197571,
0.3843342363834381,
0.03308863565325737,
-0.43813854455947876,
0.3286133408546448,
0.6420075297355652,
0.33251163363456726,
0.07012000679969788,
0.7361618280410767,
0.45110535621643066,
1.0656628608703613,
-0.6557425856590271,
0.9141390323638916,
-0.31208616495132446,
0.14596988260746002,
-0.3266559839248657,
-0.6962826251983643,
-0.589434027671814,
0.7408225536346436,
0.15815997123718262,
-0.22897587716579437,
0.774638831615448,
0.40491044521331787,
0.3005106449127197,
-0.007789986673742533,
-0.013175119645893574,
0.13290809094905853,
0.28176504373550415,
0.800976574420929,
0.6745244264602661,
-0.3029012382030487,
0.39179274439811707,
-0.0801149308681488,
-0.35995978116989136,
0.13315176963806152,
-0.727122962474823,
-0.7915475964546204,
-0.039773114025592804,
-0.2848847210407257,
-0.6140336990356445,
0.05882204324007034,
0.979918897151947,
0.4376266598701477,
-0.5683009624481201,
0.14041155576705933,
-0.10037314146757126,
-0.4848743975162506,
-0.10050613433122635,
-0.03780485317111015,
0.6132441759109497,
-0.28149715065956116,
-0.29821503162384033,
0.7637536525726318,
0.6179695129394531,
0.1633855104446411,
0.11021948605775833,
-0.10176101326942444,
0.05905244126915932,
0.0045014480128884315,
0.410503089427948,
0.1596449613571167,
-0.6936526298522949,
-0.10750942677259445,
0.06318376958370209,
-0.5108910799026489,
0.6796498894691467,
0.7404087781906128,
-0.7527192234992981,
0.2639358639717102,
-0.010185174643993378,
0.8391066789627075,
0.6018357872962952,
0.0384020134806633,
0.6149926781654358,
-0.40918004512786865,
-0.17458243668079376,
0.44338658452033997,
0.1994018703699112,
0.47551366686820984,
-0.4128267168998718,
0.9433581829071045,
0.3950202167034149,
-0.7558269500732422,
-0.7461878061294556,
-0.03767998144030571,
-0.9808468818664551,
0.20943699777126312,
0.941900908946991,
-0.376798540353775,
0.02307959645986557,
0.07202097028493881,
-0.6409788131713867,
0.4965818524360657,
-0.07316919416189194,
0.7498878836631775,
0.1922035664319992,
-0.4670775532722473,
-0.017264921218156815,
-0.5235856175422668,
0.7086970806121826,
0.44471266865730286,
-1.2820079326629639,
-0.26737716794013977,
0.483597069978714,
0.5487571358680725,
-0.11720924079418182,
1.4603217840194702,
-0.3530366122722626,
0.34579896926879883,
-0.09228099137544632,
0.1194274052977562,
-0.1590455025434494,
-0.2336302399635315,
0.09330994635820389,
-0.06212230771780014,
0.13084132969379425,
-0.11896248161792755
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09054v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09054v2
|
Keyformer: KV Cache Reduction through Key Tokens Selection for Efficient Generative Inference
| 2024-03-14T02:42:42 | 2024-04-06T00:22:37 |
Muhammad Adnan, Akhil Arunkumar, Gaurav Jain, Prashant J. Nair, Ilya Soloveychik, Purushotham Kamath
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.AR, cs.CL, 68U35, I.2.7; C.0
|
Transformers have emerged as the underpinning architecture for Large Language
Models (LLMs). In generative language models, the inference process involves
two primary phases: prompt processing and token generation. Token generation,
which constitutes the majority of the computational workload, primarily entails
vector-matrix multiplications and interactions with the Key-Value (KV) Cache.
This phase is constrained by memory bandwidth due to the overhead of
transferring weights and KV cache values from the memory system to the
computing units. This memory bottleneck becomes particularly pronounced in
applications that require long-context and extensive text generation, both of
which are increasingly crucial for LLMs.
This paper introduces "Keyformer", an innovative inference-time approach, to
mitigate the challenges associated with KV cache size and memory bandwidth
utilization. Keyformer leverages the observation that approximately 90% of the
attention weight in generative inference focuses on a specific subset of
tokens, referred to as "key" tokens. Keyformer retains only the key tokens in
the KV cache by identifying these crucial tokens using a novel score function.
This approach effectively reduces both the KV cache size and memory bandwidth
usage without compromising model accuracy. We evaluate Keyformer's performance
across three foundational models: GPT-J, Cerebras-GPT, and MPT, which employ
various positional embedding algorithms. Our assessment encompasses a variety
of tasks, with a particular emphasis on summarization and conversation tasks
involving extended contexts. Keyformer's reduction of KV cache reduces
inference latency by 2.1x and improves token generation throughput by 2.4x,
while preserving the model's accuracy.
|
[
-0.23677976429462433,
-0.5658324360847473,
0.5095613598823547,
0.3638058006763458,
-0.4032265245914459,
0.06599394232034683,
-0.2570359706878662,
0.009858873672783375,
-0.0587749145925045,
0.4281696081161499,
-0.36164987087249756,
-0.5225036144256592,
-0.5781415104866028,
-0.27265816926956177,
-0.366783082485199,
0.5891138911247253,
-0.036189693957567215,
0.048801105469465256,
-0.5157573223114014,
0.02563706412911415,
-0.3996127247810364,
-0.44404470920562744,
-0.8142216801643372,
-0.14316870272159576,
0.21099399030208588,
0.21169522404670715,
0.47645285725593567,
0.4498620331287384,
0.35995978116989136,
0.30218109488487244,
-0.42086318135261536,
-0.14704950153827667,
-0.4843648672103882,
0.6789255142211914,
0.17702879011631012,
-0.8950690627098083,
-0.39949116110801697,
-0.25835222005844116,
0.6089226603507996,
0.4175148010253906,
0.07282648235559464,
0.15303382277488708,
-0.22801299393177032,
0.693378746509552,
-1.0250723361968994,
0.5499691367149353,
-0.7729910612106323,
0.2043890655040741,
-0.3364521861076355,
0.23660646378993988,
-0.7134015560150146,
-0.21847262978553772,
-0.19179576635360718,
-0.5904797315597534,
0.5526502728462219,
-0.05581849068403244,
0.5053026080131531,
0.4784887731075287,
-0.24453718960285187,
0.027434198185801506,
-0.7751385569572449,
0.5971728563308716,
-0.7497780323028564,
0.5290238857269287,
0.2288120537996292,
0.41767194867134094,
-0.1987539678812027,
-0.8935133218765259,
-0.8884419202804565,
-0.13001522421836853,
0.03271040692925453,
0.4065524637699127,
-0.2212371826171875,
0.4797753095626831,
0.2995742857456207,
0.49973011016845703,
-0.4707510471343994,
0.16971375048160553,
-0.38998696208000183,
-0.28138378262519836,
0.15763679146766663,
0.10454630106687546,
0.025035353377461433,
-0.3381653130054474,
0.17495614290237427,
-0.35948050022125244,
-0.8204874992370605,
-0.005149582400918007,
0.257596880197525,
0.059809908270835876,
0.04621836915612221,
0.4709946811199188,
-0.08862528949975967,
0.5208227038383484,
0.22070132195949554,
-0.11983232945203781,
0.014935743995010853,
-0.01480899192392826,
-0.46758022904396057,
0.00455322302877903,
0.6421718001365662,
0.30153295397758484,
-0.03850218281149864,
-0.32860279083251953,
-0.12471040338277817,
0.445090115070343,
0.3126383125782013,
-1.040093183517456,
-0.32013627886772156,
0.19430990517139435,
-0.6689962148666382,
-0.4409944415092468,
0.0012542527401819825,
-0.8618289828300476,
-0.20105741918087006,
-0.01651761308312416,
0.27351418137550354,
-0.19881480932235718,
0.04091731831431389,
-0.21636562049388885,
-0.21472345292568207,
0.3515453338623047,
0.3593448996543884,
-0.8643534779548645,
0.4151744842529297,
0.7032203078269958,
0.9650324583053589,
-0.4781222641468048,
0.36192789673805237,
-0.6974025368690491,
0.23300336301326752,
-0.26178616285324097,
0.5962778925895691,
-0.7013646960258484,
-0.6676271557807922,
-0.19059085845947266,
-0.0762423574924469,
-0.20480498671531677,
-0.5586066246032715,
0.5537334084510803,
-0.9695996642112732,
0.14655479788780212,
-0.10508863627910614,
-0.6386783719062805,
-0.07816207408905029,
-0.03230009227991104,
-1.2163547277450562,
1.2015546560287476,
0.1362779289484024,
-0.32521477341651917,
0.5136213898658752,
-0.6906420588493347,
-0.5354308485984802,
0.06901899725198746,
-0.20239488780498505,
-0.6586781144142151,
0.4738256335258484,
0.4302132725715637,
0.38221895694732666,
-0.45184510946273804,
0.26829591393470764,
-0.12015305459499359,
-0.39825356006622314,
-0.052789852023124695,
-0.7041199803352356,
0.27169090509414673,
0.21027536690235138,
-0.5243834257125854,
0.24100790917873383,
-0.8437451124191284,
-0.09087490290403366,
0.013501817360520363,
-0.31040501594543457,
-0.12170311063528061,
0.13016758859157562,
0.3241346478462219,
0.21322572231292725,
-0.12034139782190323,
-0.5295149087905884,
0.278153657913208,
-0.44508111476898193,
0.7352319359779358,
0.6152641177177429,
-0.012066595256328583,
0.655742347240448,
-0.05489565059542656,
0.7463529109954834,
0.15374696254730225,
0.2735974192619324,
-0.21665658056735992,
-0.49639344215393066,
-1.0359336137771606,
-0.2744569480419159,
0.48866522312164307,
0.34775951504707336,
-0.47122064232826233,
0.3778317868709564,
-0.4810064435005188,
-0.4889083504676819,
-0.6541994214057922,
-0.0056747011840343475,
0.3757537603378296,
0.27215951681137085,
0.32580241560935974,
-0.25319528579711914,
-0.41288498044013977,
-0.7774791121482849,
-0.036781299859285355,
-0.3540469706058502,
-0.16638842225074768,
0.17911085486412048,
0.334564745426178,
0.028149036690592766,
0.9624249935150146,
-0.4805026948451996,
-0.02475338615477085,
-0.1884339302778244,
0.06586820632219315,
0.05553891882300377,
0.5113512873649597,
0.35504430532455444,
-0.9644314050674438,
-0.40894678235054016,
-0.36516422033309937,
-0.11260246485471725,
-0.14862829446792603,
-0.21916083991527557,
0.08498284220695496,
0.3339599072933197,
0.8319603800773621,
-0.9681582450866699,
0.5761435627937317,
0.6561965346336365,
-0.10697083920240402,
0.42201220989227295,
0.05397578328847885,
0.0027562507893890142,
-1.0476324558258057,
0.20191580057144165,
-0.5999762415885925,
-0.21741656959056854,
-0.45752036571502686,
-0.1570795327425003,
0.11586932837963104,
-0.126266211271286,
-0.21428285539150238,
0.662137508392334,
-0.4154934585094452,
0.015515399165451527,
-0.03925852105021477,
0.018413813784718513,
0.20433826744556427,
0.42462393641471863,
-0.118922159075737,
1.1107004880905151,
0.15592323243618011,
-0.4171912670135498,
-0.04199403524398804,
0.319474458694458,
-0.30234917998313904,
0.1631430685520172,
-0.6918194890022278,
0.23118390142917633,
-0.2526322603225708,
0.3771589696407318,
-1.4411404132843018,
-0.02104283683001995,
0.06661350280046463,
-0.35513752698898315,
0.42809218168258667,
-0.31737199425697327,
-0.5906362533569336,
-0.39638209342956543,
-0.17951703071594238,
0.5360645651817322,
0.6498477458953857,
-0.3948172926902771,
0.8870150446891785,
0.17812825739383698,
-0.13307197391986847,
-0.29751357436180115,
-0.5289947986602783,
0.09875142574310303,
-0.007195719517767429,
-0.5045679211616516,
0.7571824789047241,
0.06992599368095398,
-0.02332022413611412,
0.0006065249908715487,
-0.4547102749347687,
0.12056474387645721,
0.05039586126804352,
0.5105530023574829,
0.2227943390607834,
-0.322356641292572,
0.4755808711051941,
0.41575726866722107,
-0.2504461109638214,
0.024945829063653946,
-0.327249675989151,
0.6499965786933899,
0.06372044235467911,
-0.5675767660140991,
-0.2105449140071869,
0.26677206158638,
1.1138620376586914,
-0.3360747992992401,
0.9468984007835388,
0.5374463200569153,
-0.15205755829811096,
-0.10105585306882858,
-0.8879597187042236,
-0.13831274211406708,
-0.44088008999824524,
0.36144667863845825,
-0.5127382278442383,
-1.0463685989379883,
0.6206139326095581,
-0.12975984811782837,
0.0407097190618515,
0.7042092084884644,
0.6635307669639587,
0.37545815110206604,
0.9988526701927185,
0.2781950533390045,
-0.39682984352111816,
0.6241549849510193,
-0.26000621914863586,
0.3809567093849182,
-0.8502259850502014,
-0.1192953810095787,
-0.3114405870437622,
-0.3148394823074341,
-0.41660627722740173,
-0.8538570404052734,
0.39349302649497986,
0.25595909357070923,
-0.19261258840560913,
-0.06368828564882278,
-0.3932145833969116,
0.4367007911205292,
0.4501582086086273,
-0.07428397983312607,
0.24858973920345306,
-0.121261827647686,
-0.3720654845237732,
0.017193518579006195,
-0.6699119210243225,
-0.40214699506759644,
1.2225520610809326,
0.18182781338691711,
0.6961938142776489,
0.09277123957872391,
0.3331480920314789,
0.17990492284297943,
0.4509395360946655,
-0.8323386907577515,
0.4071718752384186,
-0.19304586946964264,
-0.5286287069320679,
-0.22782859206199646,
-0.21005022525787354,
-0.5928905010223389,
0.3690512776374817,
-0.0169190876185894,
-0.6685236692428589,
-0.18920792639255524,
0.28390470147132874,
-0.3835006654262543,
0.33532118797302246,
-0.5921481847763062,
0.9211979508399963,
0.10175307840108871,
-0.21780644357204437,
-0.31020402908325195,
-0.7242082357406616,
0.3194904327392578,
-0.010145352222025394,
-0.25003474950790405,
0.11944808065891266,
0.010889934375882149,
0.7822926640510559,
-0.48296433687210083,
0.9653191566467285,
-0.3624691069126129,
0.09570113569498062,
0.18885071575641632,
0.05646293982863426,
0.8212013840675354,
-0.02867976576089859,
-0.03387698903679848,
-0.12776991724967957,
-0.17274044454097748,
-0.1104685366153717,
-0.8895564675331116,
0.4466080069541931,
-0.625924289226532,
-0.5907700061798096,
0.16931430995464325,
-0.3091060519218445,
-0.25357648730278015,
0.09620320796966553,
0.333638995885849,
0.33011382818222046,
-0.23242305219173431,
0.32751911878585815,
0.7631174921989441,
-0.1950053572654724,
0.3624977171421051,
0.16526532173156738,
-0.03349883481860161,
-0.41893723607063293,
0.4746828079223633,
-0.12397904694080353,
0.557800829410553,
0.7870680093765259,
0.12150350958108902,
-0.3694804310798645,
-0.5793676972389221,
-0.23962484300136566,
0.10081271827220917,
-0.7652225494384766,
-0.3499865233898163,
-0.8718116283416748,
-0.33058133721351624,
-0.4356084167957306,
-0.10696812719106674,
-0.5382446646690369,
-0.7547507882118225,
-0.2656812071800232,
-0.16785494983196259,
0.5338298678398132,
0.35570916533470154,
0.31666451692581177,
0.9487199187278748,
-0.684863805770874,
0.3694465756416321,
0.30576372146606445,
0.3236928880214691,
0.276991605758667,
-0.3411629796028137,
0.08915714919567108,
-0.4239400029182434,
-0.37962430715560913,
-0.6860496997833252,
0.18226608633995056,
0.32065489888191223,
0.5500168204307556,
0.5862797498703003,
-0.13712213933467865,
0.7933056950569153,
-0.5139618515968323,
0.8493515253067017,
0.0005631526000797749,
-1.1629152297973633,
0.4023897349834442,
0.051626939326524734,
0.44231823086738586,
0.5926896333694458,
-0.06390839070081711,
-0.7671330571174622,
-0.45043250918388367,
-0.461897075176239,
-1.0856513977050781,
0.3657987713813782,
0.4585149586200714,
0.007087802514433861,
-0.17100326716899872,
0.4165358543395996,
0.009298393502831459,
0.28543758392333984,
-0.42391714453697205,
-0.3826766908168793,
-0.19786769151687622,
-0.3677830100059509,
-0.03743140026926994,
-0.36921456456184387,
0.31634074449539185,
-0.318761944770813,
0.4953029453754425,
-0.16530171036720276,
0.44533392786979675,
0.03566515073180199,
-0.41322097182273865,
-0.07544820010662079,
0.3577902019023895,
0.6715261340141296,
0.319446861743927,
-0.031154215335845947,
0.12972471117973328,
0.23900558054447174,
-0.7722631096839905,
0.08975621312856674,
0.06349609792232513,
-0.23818930983543396,
0.13765670359134674,
0.27165713906288147,
1.0124539136886597,
0.5306007862091064,
-0.502988338470459,
0.5894901752471924,
-0.25212445855140686,
-0.02682618796825409,
-0.2492036074399948,
0.07082687318325043,
0.22098924219608307,
0.18192386627197266,
0.1897498220205307,
0.00564822182059288,
0.06353121250867844,
0.13312572240829468,
0.0978652834892273,
0.4692830741405487,
-0.35901057720184326,
-0.3959674835205078,
1.0131665468215942,
0.15584754943847656,
-0.07480011880397797,
0.8018709421157837,
-0.1312081217765808,
-0.8048807382583618,
0.5930353999137878,
0.6466389894485474,
1.185071587562561,
-0.25136038661003113,
-0.0036403359845280647,
0.21721842885017395,
0.1135413870215416,
0.030257567763328552,
0.15889589488506317,
-0.5415427684783936,
-0.6315540075302124,
-0.7340869903564453,
-0.8595290184020996,
-0.189181849360466,
0.4482816755771637,
-0.6365390419960022,
-0.06143476814031601,
-0.2565949261188507,
-0.24000833928585052,
-0.021762166172266006,
-0.21894817054271698,
-0.7661266326904297,
-0.08882934600114822,
0.12339871376752853,
1.0274670124053955,
-0.8120111227035522,
0.6919121742248535,
0.35419249534606934,
-0.19739192724227905,
-0.5451260805130005,
-0.03556257486343384,
0.003089935053139925,
-0.7865758538246155,
1.005877137184143,
0.2599550783634186,
-0.0738292932510376,
0.10753608494997025,
-0.1767341047525406,
-0.8086639046669006,
1.118091106414795,
0.214338481426239,
-0.734132707118988,
-0.3534053564071655,
0.08388877660036087,
0.3200501501560211,
-0.10056912899017334,
0.2554868161678314,
0.6978287696838379,
0.5891547799110413,
0.26790526509284973,
-0.7070289850234985,
0.1641993522644043,
-0.35355910658836365,
0.3332902491092682,
0.5325245261192322,
-0.5547294020652771,
0.6968188285827637,
0.05635424703359604,
-0.2495502084493637,
0.28811943531036377,
0.7522171139717102,
0.293148010969162,
-0.18475396931171417,
0.594457745552063,
0.722545325756073,
0.6385511755943298,
-0.05874910205602646,
0.7294818758964539,
-0.5713966488838196,
0.20421382784843445,
0.8879786729812622,
-0.08800630271434784,
0.8134201169013977,
0.759242832660675,
-0.37341204285621643,
0.3945717513561249,
0.2648908793926239,
-0.0663098469376564,
0.5179996490478516,
0.3922105133533478,
-0.5704528093338013,
-0.24741151928901672,
0.3521745800971985,
-0.15104666352272034,
0.5978729724884033,
0.42380353808403015,
-0.5330593585968018,
-0.20669572055339813,
-0.07960516959428787,
0.09621219336986542,
-0.40934932231903076,
-0.18144656717777252,
0.7472447752952576,
0.0023243685718625784,
-0.7873844504356384,
0.1297493577003479,
-0.021943654865026474,
0.4704211950302124,
-0.507946252822876,
-0.10816004872322083,
-0.07402592897415161,
0.3985106945037842,
0.19260184466838837,
-0.20413954555988312,
0.10339287668466568,
-0.17655141651630402,
-0.46198931336402893,
-0.2081748992204666,
0.7052503824234009,
-0.3152145445346832,
-0.5708592534065247,
0.04579322785139084,
0.3066678047180176,
-0.13615325093269348,
-0.40894848108291626,
-0.34572553634643555,
0.1795264333486557,
-0.3324452340602875,
-0.4709293842315674,
0.05789429321885109,
0.28646862506866455,
-0.17042982578277588,
0.5151374340057373,
0.721183180809021,
0.1824774444103241,
0.17396728694438934,
0.41589558124542236,
0.977985143661499,
-0.5710873007774353,
-0.5951391458511353,
-0.8853992819786072,
0.3741070330142975,
-0.07353086024522781,
-0.28652113676071167,
0.5509300231933594,
0.7165499329566956,
0.49623915553092957,
-0.25285059213638306,
0.8709579706192017,
0.05652758479118347,
0.04835342615842819,
-0.759786069393158,
0.8351913094520569,
-0.18146799504756927,
0.055855780839920044,
-0.23092195391654968,
-0.9075009822845459,
-0.41001632809638977,
0.5367189049720764,
-0.36200374364852905,
0.042620155960321426,
0.5681554675102234,
0.8626641631126404,
-0.015447939746081829,
-0.02887043170630932,
0.35135793685913086,
0.10038663446903229,
0.7188817262649536,
0.4606146514415741,
0.6589917540550232,
-0.5979508757591248,
0.5459030270576477,
-0.027424009516835213,
-0.05253814160823822,
-0.3223739564418793,
-0.8997105956077576,
-0.9705328941345215,
-0.7000946998596191,
-0.023228507488965988,
-0.1410122662782669,
-0.011842924170196056,
0.6278964877128601,
0.7646923065185547,
-0.9612210392951965,
0.0782412514090538,
-0.45645734667778015,
0.04810257628560066,
-0.09166129678487778,
-0.3428376317024231,
0.5954874753952026,
-0.5242102742195129,
-0.4846099615097046,
0.2382185310125351,
0.45939183235168457,
0.036372698843479156,
-0.37033310532569885,
0.07769438624382019,
0.3671651780605316,
-0.07113941758871078,
0.8305712938308716,
0.016267837956547737,
-1.0024633407592773,
-0.11038557440042496,
0.1821596324443817,
0.028956223279237747,
0.18258781731128693,
1.1491862535476685,
-1.0063925981521606,
0.5742162466049194,
0.477324903011322,
0.7750685214996338,
1.0016975402832031,
-0.12926070392131805,
0.7054949998855591,
-0.6836296916007996,
0.1679757833480835,
0.3196156322956085,
0.3107832670211792,
0.15439081192016602,
-0.30565616488456726,
0.10660120099782944,
0.24026821553707123,
-0.42105600237846375,
-0.6235408782958984,
0.11065833270549774,
-1.0359759330749512,
-0.16487325727939606,
0.9903550744056702,
0.21709422767162323,
-0.39216774702072144,
-0.040290363132953644,
-0.11643610149621964,
0.4290754497051239,
-0.45311984419822693,
0.7814555764198303,
0.6997354626655579,
0.1286434829235077,
-0.24490441381931305,
-0.5245878100395203,
0.7127504348754883,
0.35858070850372314,
-0.6410372257232666,
0.1799636334180832,
0.3085247278213501,
0.14829981327056885,
0.1540696769952774,
0.5607197284698486,
-0.2088717669248581,
0.28333815932273865,
0.13825485110282898,
0.11592188477516174,
0.022947167977690697,
-0.1667458862066269,
-0.20004910230636597,
0.25868046283721924,
0.018551606684923172,
-0.20479658246040344
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09040v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09040v1
|
RAGGED: Towards Informed Design of Retrieval Augmented Generation Systems
| 2024-03-14T02:26:31 | 2024-03-14T02:26:31 |
Jennifer Hsia, Afreen Shaikh, Zhiruo Wang, Graham Neubig
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) greatly benefits language models (LMs)
by providing additional context for tasks such as document-based question
answering (DBQA). Despite its potential, the power of RAG is highly dependent
on its configuration, raising the question: What is the optimal RAG
configuration? To answer this, we introduce the RAGGED framework to analyze and
optimize RAG systems. On a set of representative DBQA tasks, we study two
classic sparse and dense retrievers, and four top-performing LMs in
encoder-decoder and decoder-only architectures. Through RAGGED, we uncover that
different models suit substantially varied RAG setups. While encoder-decoder
models monotonically improve with more documents, we find decoder-only models
can only effectively use < 5 documents, despite often having a longer context
window. RAGGED offers further insights into LMs' context utilization habits,
where we find that encoder-decoder models rely more on contexts and are thus
more sensitive to retrieval quality, while decoder-only models tend to rely on
knowledge memorized during training.
|
[
-0.7447075843811035,
-0.559921145439148,
0.562262237071991,
-0.011650888249278069,
-0.24195875227451324,
0.18782156705856323,
-0.11267752945423126,
-0.4124179482460022,
0.18824976682662964,
0.6219787001609802,
-0.5569210648536682,
0.03486340865492821,
-0.42237505316734314,
0.12164200842380524,
-0.47385454177856445,
1.1030676364898682,
0.1126742959022522,
-0.27218765020370483,
-0.3958026170730591,
-0.1367034912109375,
-0.564764678478241,
-0.3376282751560211,
-0.5489383339881897,
-0.29367613792419434,
0.3217625319957733,
0.3135417401790619,
0.8758156299591064,
0.773855447769165,
0.196823850274086,
0.23549912869930267,
-0.23389051854610443,
0.5137370824813843,
-0.7794021368026733,
0.5041561126708984,
-0.17444956302642822,
-0.26860159635543823,
-0.2036009132862091,
-0.2656688392162323,
0.5388909578323364,
0.7438569068908691,
-0.23836751282215118,
0.4960019290447235,
0.2514685392379761,
0.6604435443878174,
-1.054486632347107,
-0.6168509125709534,
-0.6964060068130493,
-0.08174674957990646,
-0.11713898181915283,
-0.3236052393913269,
-0.442095011472702,
-0.1852826029062271,
-0.04965114966034889,
-0.7803733348846436,
0.4277118444442749,
0.2784287631511688,
1.0145220756530762,
0.542670726776123,
-0.40351152420043945,
-0.3984206020832062,
-0.8008711934089661,
0.7860791087150574,
-0.2853175103664398,
0.8511260747909546,
0.5613691210746765,
0.15067242085933685,
-0.17342481017112732,
-0.7233479619026184,
-0.3950345516204834,
0.13268369436264038,
-0.23846444487571716,
0.22320234775543213,
0.04701743274927139,
0.10662099719047546,
0.23510000109672546,
0.48427334427833557,
-0.6406571269035339,
-0.2020995020866394,
-0.3439404368400574,
0.04776696860790253,
0.491580069065094,
0.1434876024723053,
0.045015692710876465,
-0.4220433235168457,
-0.552680492401123,
0.060622718185186386,
-0.5479159355163574,
-0.01858043670654297,
0.38749057054519653,
0.086164191365242,
0.283916175365448,
0.4903947412967682,
-0.07837982475757599,
1.0354734659194946,
0.4074929356575012,
0.026248997077345848,
-0.1408473700284958,
0.013041849248111248,
-0.3405854403972626,
-0.251547247171402,
0.3371928632259369,
0.07508165389299393,
-0.05084003135561943,
-0.5153415203094482,
-0.890262246131897,
-0.17287670075893402,
0.8741390705108643,
-0.44283825159072876,
-0.029150212183594704,
0.29153338074684143,
-0.3220131993293762,
-0.11105828732252121,
-0.19697792828083038,
-0.685578465461731,
-0.46989524364471436,
-0.5392372608184814,
0.4685058295726776,
-0.5734992027282715,
-0.1243392676115036,
0.16774483025074005,
-0.48181837797164917,
0.2109784185886383,
-0.0868183895945549,
-0.7952125072479248,
0.5673298239707947,
0.7426518797874451,
0.520336925983429,
0.13795016705989838,
0.14960555732250214,
-0.557101845741272,
0.11986008286476135,
-0.5997851490974426,
0.8879293203353882,
-0.42104852199554443,
-0.5893747806549072,
0.22866789996623993,
-0.25608891248703003,
-0.1450217366218567,
-0.5851171016693115,
1.1474733352661133,
-1.0368167161941528,
0.18218956887722015,
-0.45923954248428345,
-0.6790132522583008,
0.1492672860622406,
0.21019871532917023,
-0.8851460218429565,
1.3530645370483398,
0.4163799285888672,
-0.7275235652923584,
0.4456087648868561,
-0.39044705033302307,
-0.2629774510860443,
0.16052836179733276,
0.08670493960380554,
-0.16900092363357544,
0.4944838583469391,
0.111663319170475,
0.27103009819984436,
-0.24591417610645294,
0.17991100251674652,
-0.06152905896306038,
-0.6286411881446838,
0.10345309227705002,
-0.18720866739749908,
0.5006097555160522,
0.7992168068885803,
-0.049851275980472565,
-0.31339579820632935,
-0.869067370891571,
0.2495390772819519,
0.09988164156675339,
-0.7010310292243958,
-0.6466583609580994,
0.09292832762002945,
0.07766138017177582,
-0.05170461907982826,
0.30751141905784607,
-0.599175214767456,
0.06993990391492844,
-0.5486544966697693,
-0.05054202303290367,
0.7261649966239929,
0.13056716322898865,
0.7536210417747498,
-0.6478456258773804,
0.5802573561668396,
-0.458583265542984,
0.2803926467895508,
0.08865612000226974,
0.1553056538105011,
-1.0099937915802002,
-0.1894151270389557,
0.4153139889240265,
0.31435731053352356,
-0.9232271313667297,
0.04828328266739845,
-0.21002857387065887,
-0.11501994729042053,
-0.5385720133781433,
-0.1702503263950348,
0.5213689804077148,
0.40486690402030945,
0.26060888171195984,
-0.08659491688013077,
-0.7063400149345398,
-0.8271385431289673,
-0.4986772835254669,
0.1692492961883545,
0.05031411349773407,
0.5501363277435303,
0.15466953814029694,
-0.15321694314479828,
0.9958576560020447,
-0.46982964873313904,
0.1288691759109497,
-0.06470665335655212,
-0.4345778226852417,
0.28915053606033325,
0.21913540363311768,
0.41699132323265076,
-0.9967599511146545,
-0.23947983980178833,
-0.11972218006849289,
-0.37729841470718384,
-0.2233986258506775,
-0.11912992596626282,
-0.5540530681610107,
0.37542790174484253,
0.27475354075431824,
-0.6216714978218079,
0.2755791246891022,
0.4438614249229431,
-0.3028402328491211,
0.641520082950592,
-0.32483991980552673,
-0.004589254967868328,
-0.8908682465553284,
0.3055874705314636,
-0.27971234917640686,
-0.2015191912651062,
-0.7029953598976135,
0.27477630972862244,
0.2984624207019806,
0.07668495923280716,
0.1317036747932434,
0.7306938171386719,
-0.7548392415046692,
-0.19552604854106903,
-0.21888041496276855,
0.17206108570098877,
0.45713990926742554,
0.426125705242157,
-0.24301472306251526,
0.8335477113723755,
-0.18865041434764862,
-0.634637176990509,
-0.1580999195575714,
0.12740473449230194,
-0.24950391054153442,
0.442884624004364,
-0.6627967357635498,
0.44908076524734497,
-0.4049816429615021,
-0.057005152106285095,
-0.8883997797966003,
-0.4189249575138092,
-0.20605765283107758,
-0.4020535349845886,
0.7486340999603271,
-0.2748485505580902,
-0.3531818687915802,
-0.24167414009571075,
-0.19019576907157898,
0.3978246748447418,
0.5531502962112427,
-0.6763243079185486,
0.6954100131988525,
0.6647763252258301,
0.12283693253993988,
-1.0218440294265747,
-0.13994644582271576,
-0.15491804480552673,
-0.12502582371234894,
-0.6156673431396484,
0.4915972650051117,
0.0952233225107193,
-0.26459649205207825,
0.13470371067523956,
-0.27930396795272827,
-0.18771177530288696,
0.024806182831525803,
0.30912476778030396,
0.21737048029899597,
-0.10336044430732727,
0.4243350625038147,
0.3097924590110779,
0.2279997169971466,
-0.20264281332492828,
-0.3553626239299774,
0.6070802807807922,
0.05976512283086777,
-0.12373873591423035,
0.5546732544898987,
0.7119002938270569,
0.2857133150100708,
-0.4658820331096649,
0.7227901816368103,
0.4073374271392822,
-0.3671084940433502,
-0.5854024291038513,
-0.7945786118507385,
0.21367856860160828,
-0.517082154750824,
0.07768762856721878,
-0.642634391784668,
-0.7858054637908936,
0.5129597187042236,
-0.032585326582193375,
0.35747596621513367,
0.40669015049934387,
0.2761494219303131,
-0.03550711274147034,
0.9091842770576477,
0.8193461894989014,
0.22027261555194855,
0.4751451909542084,
-0.360857754945755,
0.014403258450329304,
-1.2068310976028442,
-0.2331087738275528,
-0.5287659168243408,
-0.07845854014158249,
-0.40425217151641846,
-0.3171710669994354,
0.5528729557991028,
0.39522096514701843,
-0.596123456954956,
0.0259102676063776,
-0.8105757832527161,
0.5944682955741882,
0.5478861927986145,
0.18507327139377594,
-0.06567957997322083,
0.014099190942943096,
-0.27982980012893677,
0.3846813142299652,
-1.11896812915802,
-0.6329666972160339,
0.8010088205337524,
0.1428092122077942,
0.6929425001144409,
0.10320193320512772,
0.9080733060836792,
0.1024351492524147,
-0.02296619303524494,
-0.747571587562561,
0.22542060911655426,
-0.2900192439556122,
-0.7587018013000488,
-0.09160222858190536,
-0.18724006414413452,
-1.1795158386230469,
0.1117524728178978,
-0.15881797671318054,
-0.29716232419013977,
0.45292046666145325,
0.10959511995315552,
-0.48834699392318726,
0.0032298811711370945,
-0.6537767648696899,
0.45885807275772095,
-0.029067551717162132,
-0.5085769891738892,
0.3172166645526886,
-0.6161513328552246,
0.35370469093322754,
0.07397834956645966,
0.3439795672893524,
0.3111710250377655,
-0.20599709451198578,
0.5444528460502625,
-0.2297874093055725,
0.391323059797287,
-0.2244037240743637,
0.06579817086458206,
0.4022333025932312,
0.37041598558425903,
0.51164311170578,
-0.15835559368133545,
-0.2555820643901825,
-0.3726319968700409,
0.29752352833747864,
-0.4556646943092346,
-0.5381941795349121,
0.6478937268257141,
-0.9248595833778381,
-0.5298465490341187,
-0.14907215535640717,
-0.5239153504371643,
-0.42111262679100037,
0.22362923622131348,
0.49687644839286804,
0.7763451933860779,
-0.21197032928466797,
0.009720453061163425,
1.1098694801330566,
-0.13363653421401978,
0.1656959354877472,
0.047809913754463196,
-0.14364442229270935,
-0.237273171544075,
0.6784813404083252,
0.24300405383110046,
0.2816409468650818,
0.2879578173160553,
-0.050199732184410095,
-0.4031955599784851,
-0.30242398381233215,
-0.7062265872955322,
0.15377210080623627,
-0.9053622484207153,
-0.43707406520843506,
-0.7494918704032898,
-0.2977254092693329,
-0.40072593092918396,
-0.21313832700252533,
-0.3689761757850647,
-0.5255143642425537,
-0.42918631434440613,
0.07498901337385178,
0.1993527114391327,
0.9396335482597351,
-0.03646941855549812,
0.10499177873134613,
-0.7544484734535217,
0.35132962465286255,
0.06126626580953598,
0.6079721450805664,
-0.0018640973139554262,
-0.6420820355415344,
-0.4146493375301361,
0.04961918666958809,
-0.2518470287322998,
-0.9050043225288391,
0.3569936454296112,
0.26182785630226135,
0.6276959180831909,
0.07542818039655685,
0.35505935549736023,
0.687604546546936,
-0.742658257484436,
0.7356279492378235,
-0.3765639364719391,
-0.6417797207832336,
0.16651637852191925,
-0.42071452736854553,
0.23468050360679626,
0.34967246651649475,
0.28854435682296753,
-0.512311577796936,
-0.11089438199996948,
-0.6417868733406067,
-1.0297846794128418,
0.5294568538665771,
-0.06309205293655396,
0.1607857644557953,
-0.12371107935905457,
0.7330086827278137,
0.24311529099941254,
-0.12817439436912537,
-0.2223987728357315,
-0.07656064629554749,
-0.2546946704387665,
-0.22233279049396515,
0.2663215100765228,
-0.6281459331512451,
-0.22072267532348633,
0.27124664187431335,
0.712881863117218,
-0.04089239239692688,
0.38998332619667053,
0.38397216796875,
-0.0689617320895195,
-0.2787981629371643,
0.27131521701812744,
0.4278900623321533,
0.5733125805854797,
-0.06651999801397324,
0.14285579323768616,
0.232488751411438,
-0.41836509108543396,
0.09149521589279175,
0.07364048808813095,
-0.13362577557563782,
0.2114008069038391,
0.22695282101631165,
0.8514964580535889,
0.05276753380894661,
-0.4811483323574066,
0.09389465302228928,
-0.12219780683517456,
-0.0005469764582812786,
-0.4089362621307373,
0.25413626432418823,
-0.13651755452156067,
0.31245845556259155,
0.4775386154651642,
0.012789854779839516,
0.430656373500824,
-0.10062849521636963,
0.1615772843360901,
0.6205278038978577,
-0.12686161696910858,
-0.05833936482667923,
0.4806053638458252,
-0.07178676128387451,
-0.41615647077560425,
0.38704559206962585,
-0.10325927287340164,
-0.5883596539497375,
0.33533018827438354,
0.5575665235519409,
0.7593810558319092,
-0.10554002970457077,
-0.04798377677798271,
0.38958093523979187,
0.16591203212738037,
0.0707407295703888,
0.22522351145744324,
-0.33442023396492004,
-0.6239912509918213,
-0.38733676075935364,
-1.2035022974014282,
-0.12062249332666397,
-0.08399158716201782,
-0.8675429821014404,
0.04039106145501137,
-0.10305457562208176,
-0.24722225964069366,
-0.16495920717716217,
0.2520325183868408,
-0.8419178128242493,
0.38052627444267273,
-0.13902969658374786,
0.9821006655693054,
-0.2685469388961792,
0.4533931612968445,
0.6767576932907104,
0.03124653548002243,
-1.182363748550415,
-0.12784899771213531,
-0.28504374623298645,
-0.7521040439605713,
0.4343017041683197,
-0.3021072745323181,
-0.2590799033641815,
0.022750528529286385,
-0.4762321412563324,
-1.1947325468063354,
0.8848293423652649,
0.218693345785141,
-0.32417577505111694,
-0.22436349093914032,
-0.22650235891342163,
0.4910575747489929,
-0.021181216463446617,
0.1330808848142624,
0.5709064602851868,
0.1655689924955368,
0.17118491232395172,
-0.9139887690544128,
-0.08207591623067856,
-0.3428109586238861,
0.21075156331062317,
0.7049976587295532,
-0.5084031224250793,
0.8135759830474854,
0.07319638133049011,
-0.6436560153961182,
0.33473050594329834,
0.27024441957473755,
0.17871037125587463,
0.20623540878295898,
0.3925432860851288,
0.6469444632530212,
0.655014157295227,
0.018537290394306183,
1.5769072771072388,
-0.3615509569644928,
0.2747640311717987,
0.9082310199737549,
-0.01784939505159855,
0.7722786068916321,
0.5081030130386353,
0.06593428552150726,
0.3097238540649414,
0.7655875086784363,
0.6151684522628784,
0.5683237314224243,
0.1056671291589737,
-0.3758832514286041,
-0.1400095820426941,
-0.1612677127122879,
-0.25970587134361267,
0.3312860429286957,
0.4725150763988495,
-0.36562490463256836,
-0.0536595918238163,
-0.13953474164009094,
-0.10992761701345444,
0.1352103054523468,
-0.16293476521968842,
1.0582900047302246,
-0.07160501927137375,
-1.112176537513733,
1.0763065814971924,
0.047019701451063156,
0.31664735078811646,
-0.37737852334976196,
0.11518571525812149,
-0.5008746385574341,
0.22026187181472778,
-0.2705477476119995,
-0.6657748222351074,
0.3991142809391022,
0.04819902032613754,
-0.5732104182243347,
-0.13881699740886688,
1.180895209312439,
-0.3815889358520508,
-0.2684690058231354,
-0.09214954823255539,
0.692498505115509,
-0.041813138872385025,
0.126623272895813,
-0.3400192856788635,
0.3473578691482544,
-0.22112835943698883,
-0.5279859304428101,
0.34164056181907654,
0.7749264240264893,
0.005312073510140181,
0.32082054018974304,
0.6385605335235596,
-0.008880884386599064,
0.3491239845752716,
-0.020699279382824898,
1.1276534795761108,
-0.4093901813030243,
-0.36080485582351685,
-0.38816967606544495,
0.6213502287864685,
-0.13915060460567474,
-0.1475110650062561,
0.6666648387908936,
0.561274528503418,
0.7229816317558289,
0.059583745896816254,
0.5739037394523621,
-0.10977980494499207,
0.7674046158790588,
-0.5592482089996338,
0.6989736557006836,
-0.7826604843139648,
0.27049487829208374,
-0.09995908290147781,
-0.8793202042579651,
0.010963843204081059,
0.46075648069381714,
-0.08118104189634323,
0.13922862708568573,
0.20419344305992126,
0.7190184593200684,
-0.07598838955163956,
0.07378207892179489,
0.3440907895565033,
-0.25579559803009033,
0.18687839806079865,
0.44765183329582214,
1.0730407238006592,
-0.3973136246204376,
0.3402286767959595,
-0.25911763310432434,
-0.2085215300321579,
-0.023840725421905518,
-0.5716718435287476,
-0.5157467126846313,
-0.7711898684501648,
0.3927472233772278,
-0.3578644394874573,
0.20403830707073212,
0.7997525334358215,
0.6406447291374207,
-0.21606211364269257,
-0.1241687536239624,
0.08515000343322754,
-0.02591322921216488,
0.1823723167181015,
-0.2289849817752838,
0.3522868752479553,
-0.7551446557044983,
-0.557277500629425,
0.17105022072792053,
0.10230211913585663,
-0.2569276988506317,
0.01965697854757309,
-0.107172891497612,
-0.31508874893188477,
0.43134355545043945,
0.7278201580047607,
0.19019271433353424,
-0.6372424364089966,
-0.4277653992176056,
0.48052704334259033,
-0.24773229658603668,
-0.17146597802639008,
0.7777932286262512,
-1.110756754875183,
0.5811657905578613,
0.4472622573375702,
0.9260473251342773,
0.4387566149234772,
0.2675079107284546,
0.38761574029922485,
-1.192861795425415,
-0.04767758026719093,
0.6081586480140686,
0.25800633430480957,
0.24019597470760345,
-0.5997477769851685,
0.5563177466392517,
-0.21286725997924805,
-1.0328209400177002,
-1.044787049293518,
0.11013619601726532,
-0.5905804634094238,
-0.496065229177475,
1.249511957168579,
0.03825581446290016,
-0.3741476237773895,
-0.19703249633312225,
-0.3997844457626343,
0.32142412662506104,
-0.07611087709665298,
0.5676349401473999,
0.5678901076316833,
-0.18761911988258362,
-0.03872290998697281,
-0.6557543873786926,
0.7567040920257568,
0.5202898383140564,
-0.3058089017868042,
-0.007169371470808983,
0.7655292749404907,
0.09989673644304276,
0.2902928292751312,
0.589215099811554,
0.13305369019508362,
0.29393842816352844,
0.09222626686096191,
-0.1707465797662735,
-0.09301825612783432,
-0.33833417296409607,
-0.16874168813228607,
0.2923144996166229,
0.12114628404378891,
-0.03334321826696396
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09037v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09037v1
|
The First to Know: How Token Distributions Reveal Hidden Knowledge in Large Vision-Language Models?
| 2024-03-14T02:25:35 | 2024-03-14T02:25:35 |
Qinyu Zhao, Ming Xu, Kartik Gupta, Akshay Asthana, Liang Zheng, Stephen Gould
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Large vision-language models (LVLMs), designed to interpret and respond to
human instructions, occasionally generate hallucinated or harmful content due
to inappropriate instructions. This study uses linear probing to shed light on
the hidden knowledge at the output layer of LVLMs. We demonstrate that the
logit distributions of the first tokens contain sufficient information to
determine whether to respond to the instructions, including recognizing
unanswerable visual questions, defending against multi-modal jailbreaking
attack, and identifying deceptive questions. Such hidden knowledge is gradually
lost in logits of subsequent tokens during response generation. Then, we
illustrate a simple decoding strategy at the generation of the first token,
effectively improving the generated content. In experiments, we find a few
interesting insights: First, the CLIP model already contains a strong signal
for solving these tasks, indicating potential bias in the existing datasets.
Second, we observe performance improvement by utilizing the first logit
distributions on three additional tasks, including indicting uncertainty in
math solving, mitigating hallucination, and image classification. Last, with
the same training data, simply finetuning LVLMs improve models' performance but
is still inferior to linear probing on these tasks.
|
[
-0.39847466349601746,
-0.6772537231445312,
0.4729604721069336,
-0.14223694801330566,
-0.4905049800872803,
-0.1171734482049942,
-0.009077982045710087,
-0.4196755290031433,
0.16738229990005493,
0.5989648103713989,
-0.6664718389511108,
-0.44794967770576477,
-0.6038897037506104,
-0.3889073431491852,
-0.6041320562362671,
0.843131959438324,
0.37642765045166016,
0.14195352792739868,
-0.13633336126804352,
-0.06131718307733536,
-0.3848428428173065,
-0.7167413234710693,
-0.6583166718482971,
-0.09504713863134384,
0.6968657374382019,
-0.04979022219777107,
0.45977097749710083,
0.6120359897613525,
0.5765599012374878,
0.18631218373775482,
-0.26228266954421997,
0.14261771738529205,
-0.7582215666770935,
-0.19551710784435272,
-0.1348743587732315,
-0.7594477534294128,
-0.12267282605171204,
-0.35682177543640137,
0.4847683012485504,
0.5545296669006348,
0.12734363973140717,
0.39494210481643677,
0.029190177097916603,
0.7020321488380432,
-0.6282843947410583,
0.11879872530698776,
-0.7050290107727051,
0.2371828407049179,
-0.1625295877456665,
-0.40032440423965454,
-0.8152713179588318,
-0.016633523628115654,
0.15706318616867065,
-0.43225011229515076,
0.35865387320518494,
0.091989666223526,
0.6803740859031677,
0.4208313226699829,
-0.42104464769363403,
-0.2227620929479599,
-0.5754948854446411,
0.7122024297714233,
-0.5506415963172913,
0.42952704429626465,
0.2922281324863434,
0.17336952686309814,
0.01122221164405346,
-0.7177935838699341,
-0.3832078278064728,
-0.12150565534830093,
-0.2307034432888031,
-0.2762667238712311,
-0.3116070330142975,
0.172920361161232,
0.2903411388397217,
0.05689297616481781,
-0.2655988037586212,
0.1281895637512207,
-0.7091618776321411,
-0.647797167301178,
0.4206914007663727,
0.2611614465713501,
0.009943637996912003,
-0.21568463742733002,
-0.5711642503738403,
-0.46462106704711914,
-0.7223590016365051,
0.33570361137390137,
0.25273188948631287,
0.06390684843063354,
0.1547003984451294,
0.6734499335289001,
0.1884685605764389,
0.5883088707923889,
-0.09122533351182938,
-0.05726151168346405,
0.022821007296442986,
-0.48402634263038635,
-0.2517465651035309,
-0.03742649406194687,
0.4834271967411041,
0.33565059304237366,
0.1430608630180359,
0.012888368219137192,
-0.48036205768585205,
0.06883608549833298,
0.2581612467765808,
-0.7273483276367188,
-0.3723326325416565,
0.01966134086251259,
-0.6152365207672119,
-0.5557276606559753,
0.09658921509981155,
-0.5318771600723267,
-0.5372714996337891,
-0.11524242907762527,
0.6731259226799011,
-0.3591769337654114,
-0.30069974064826965,
0.24954350292682648,
-0.2004997432231903,
0.39344605803489685,
0.3453119993209839,
-0.9662428498268127,
0.4855130612850189,
0.8074709177017212,
0.6408910751342773,
-0.1810898333787918,
-0.05551900714635849,
-0.9123443365097046,
-0.2045051008462906,
-0.5337448716163635,
0.39620548486709595,
-0.11393775790929794,
0.040407586842775345,
0.012753247283399105,
-0.08036203682422638,
0.09040140360593796,
-0.5920965075492859,
0.2775907516479492,
-0.5865838527679443,
-0.16475704312324524,
-0.4281076490879059,
-0.4610651731491089,
-0.10332980006933212,
0.07454529404640198,
-0.8000198602676392,
0.9380376935005188,
-0.07635557651519775,
-1.0221669673919678,
0.444290429353714,
-0.578762412071228,
-0.157852903008461,
0.0834905132651329,
-0.35272088646888733,
-0.22055363655090332,
0.4949876368045807,
0.26187238097190857,
0.537047803401947,
0.2672061324119568,
-0.018746791407465935,
-0.031858932226896286,
-0.38816705346107483,
0.48652276396751404,
-0.5915362238883972,
0.6625015735626221,
0.14470258355140686,
-0.3969641923904419,
0.1148364469408989,
-0.7215296626091003,
0.07690294086933136,
0.28571653366088867,
-0.19316543638706207,
-0.434364378452301,
-0.015429954044520855,
-0.12277299165725708,
-0.11715074628591537,
0.033341825008392334,
-0.4639463424682617,
0.048704687505960464,
-0.27263182401657104,
0.3385046720504761,
1.1682109832763672,
0.010660451836884022,
0.3108654022216797,
0.010901528410613537,
0.3738180994987488,
0.39306849241256714,
0.44565507769584656,
-0.4418897032737732,
-0.5058048367500305,
-0.8851966261863708,
-0.0063183121383190155,
0.12365718185901642,
0.4619119167327881,
-0.8627154231071472,
-0.12323979288339615,
-0.09967146068811417,
-0.19205868244171143,
-0.5406198501586914,
0.1281537413597107,
0.5747557878494263,
0.4566592574119568,
0.12577936053276062,
-0.2628801763057709,
-0.34061411023139954,
-1.0144188404083252,
-0.1730407178401947,
-0.24408301711082458,
0.012138715013861656,
0.31262683868408203,
0.6053067445755005,
-0.08610442280769348,
0.7066167593002319,
-0.64182448387146,
-0.09312089532613754,
-0.13999471068382263,
0.11995983868837357,
0.026917165145277977,
0.1702253520488739,
0.5579107403755188,
-0.8188164234161377,
0.012871469371020794,
0.07725922763347626,
-0.6274181604385376,
0.2736413776874542,
-0.10134691745042801,
-0.2470889836549759,
0.15433736145496368,
0.4707425832748413,
-0.5445603132247925,
0.708254337310791,
0.3818768560886383,
-0.4985540807247162,
0.5309407711029053,
-0.1544487178325653,
-0.31836530566215515,
-0.7111830711364746,
0.055683452636003494,
-0.342544823884964,
-0.4585559368133545,
-0.7648178935050964,
0.2227611094713211,
0.1636577993631363,
0.04899166151881218,
-0.5965132117271423,
0.5410922169685364,
-0.4123629629611969,
-0.1701524704694748,
-0.0188297051936388,
0.08949171006679535,
0.017078125849366188,
0.5862243175506592,
-0.10874223709106445,
0.805226743221283,
0.5817186236381531,
-0.6659243702888489,
0.22859305143356323,
0.11752140522003174,
-0.6357201933860779,
-0.13392376899719238,
-0.6532139778137207,
0.3169803321361542,
-0.48320215940475464,
-0.2676514685153961,
-1.1750785112380981,
-0.12794436514377594,
0.21328265964984894,
-0.6449356079101562,
0.24686434864997864,
-0.11098109930753708,
-0.4613417685031891,
-0.4371109902858734,
-0.29202133417129517,
0.5386245250701904,
0.6324694752693176,
-0.5136875510215759,
0.3595113158226013,
0.27571120858192444,
0.15846747159957886,
-0.8664504885673523,
-0.7924656867980957,
-0.15199612081050873,
-0.09213533252477646,
-0.5061120390892029,
-0.23151004314422607,
-0.08908305317163467,
-0.35073086619377136,
-0.07815945893526077,
-0.19089893996715546,
0.022175082936882973,
0.14574360847473145,
0.23911555111408234,
0.2750937044620514,
-0.4167846739292145,
0.3161729574203491,
-0.18740232288837433,
0.12253936380147934,
0.4209517538547516,
-0.5312554240226746,
0.7695706486701965,
-0.14533491432666779,
-0.6020715236663818,
-0.3638162910938263,
0.25503626465797424,
0.5667361617088318,
-0.3579026758670807,
0.8131380081176758,
0.6890315413475037,
-0.2191125750541687,
-0.18467484414577484,
-0.5572527050971985,
-0.6040947437286377,
-0.4922310709953308,
0.46443140506744385,
-0.4175652265548706,
-0.6574375033378601,
0.5932859182357788,
0.1038476973772049,
-0.06467728316783905,
0.19154849648475647,
0.4303009510040283,
0.06928631663322449,
1.0521920919418335,
0.9091348648071289,
0.01958576776087284,
0.5095893740653992,
-0.3791005611419678,
0.2945663630962372,
-0.4272461235523224,
-0.4594898223876953,
-0.05872998759150505,
-0.27320632338523865,
-0.23266835510730743,
-0.5956636071205139,
0.5185469388961792,
0.07927145063877106,
0.09293673932552338,
-0.055790115147829056,
-0.5278832912445068,
0.6344884037971497,
0.7408124804496765,
0.5105271935462952,
0.17914657294750214,
0.22905947268009186,
-0.25881609320640564,
0.06031588092446327,
-0.7428478598594666,
-0.19793233275413513,
1.1013931035995483,
0.6934366226196289,
0.9385535717010498,
-0.03478487208485603,
0.7417178750038147,
0.16710706055164337,
0.03680082783102989,
-0.7684375643730164,
0.5415331721305847,
0.0087116789072752,
-0.5182982683181763,
-0.4063260555267334,
-0.26438039541244507,
-0.739477813243866,
0.1793549656867981,
-0.1131758764386177,
-0.7069493532180786,
0.17891454696655273,
0.35461291670799255,
-0.3327525854110718,
0.4292636513710022,
-0.8058945536613464,
0.6787205934524536,
-0.25283393263816833,
-0.3307019770145416,
0.0008392466115765274,
-0.6750202178955078,
0.5476067662239075,
-0.055435046553611755,
0.2261422574520111,
0.32912778854370117,
0.05043727159500122,
0.8130730986595154,
-0.23146414756774902,
1.0220574140548706,
-0.34351757168769836,
-0.24030627310276031,
0.2677658200263977,
0.3009403347969055,
0.6319112181663513,
0.07129690796136856,
0.3201371133327484,
-0.1596391797065735,
0.07809058576822281,
-0.4275696277618408,
-0.7799972295761108,
0.24450430274009705,
-0.5609198212623596,
-0.7210525274276733,
0.03260618820786476,
-0.4628465473651886,
0.26195207238197327,
0.2546176016330719,
0.4089781641960144,
0.595201849937439,
0.04655195400118828,
0.29173195362091064,
1.278608798980713,
-0.24801407754421234,
0.24841856956481934,
0.0638895183801651,
-0.4954818785190582,
-0.08907653391361237,
0.7158640623092651,
-0.1972096860408783,
0.6008671522140503,
0.4487107992172241,
0.19390849769115448,
-0.2686123847961426,
-0.5643677115440369,
-0.48765867948532104,
0.23259341716766357,
-1.2093758583068848,
-0.06255275011062622,
-0.40356287360191345,
-0.24710462987422943,
-0.2582939863204956,
0.1488880217075348,
-0.444904088973999,
-0.3242683708667755,
-0.16018573939800262,
-0.386830598115921,
0.3183033764362335,
0.9774016737937927,
0.020497623831033707,
0.04420129582285881,
-0.5920988917350769,
0.21467985212802887,
0.4122830629348755,
0.1647387593984604,
0.1988353729248047,
-0.3961622714996338,
-0.3066199719905853,
0.1865117996931076,
0.11238919198513031,
-0.9391579031944275,
0.26217469573020935,
-0.003484041430056095,
0.5917451977729797,
0.7162680625915527,
0.010801569558680058,
0.5293655395507812,
-0.42372292280197144,
0.8495566248893738,
0.2700452208518982,
-0.8310135006904602,
0.5500496625900269,
-0.14547304809093475,
0.19045165181159973,
0.19938351213932037,
0.04555489867925644,
-0.2702748477458954,
-0.3434652090072632,
-0.2176392823457718,
-0.6579386591911316,
0.6020938754081726,
0.19260330498218536,
0.4982476532459259,
0.01219543069601059,
0.33394235372543335,
0.2004178762435913,
0.23067912459373474,
-0.9045591950416565,
-0.3871889114379883,
-0.2458019256591797,
-0.013297876343131065,
-0.0033594330307096243,
-0.4232170581817627,
-0.4499676525592804,
-0.4243958592414856,
-0.007593422196805477,
-0.18940655887126923,
0.5760772824287415,
0.26284900307655334,
-0.2365044206380844,
0.048629481345415115,
-0.006691483315080404,
0.9769828915596008,
0.8123458623886108,
-0.12754440307617188,
0.5247923135757446,
0.004522094968706369,
-0.6908286809921265,
-0.025546133518218994,
-0.4274541735649109,
-0.200137659907341,
0.16176816821098328,
0.5291200876235962,
1.2830181121826172,
0.013026188127696514,
-0.7956640720367432,
0.8455960154533386,
-0.20074476301670074,
-0.32298803329467773,
-0.3104739785194397,
0.13571050763130188,
-0.1494491547346115,
0.3010503649711609,
0.7038083076477051,
0.09940511733293533,
-0.030339600518345833,
-0.537179708480835,
0.3651660978794098,
0.610629141330719,
-0.205092191696167,
-0.3395458459854126,
0.763670027256012,
-0.21934983134269714,
-0.33088794350624084,
0.44648176431655884,
-0.08015360683202744,
-0.7089706659317017,
0.5637723803520203,
0.47300854325294495,
0.4347943961620331,
0.055274151265621185,
0.37530162930488586,
0.20479080080986023,
0.5144729614257812,
0.11296206712722778,
0.2292538732290268,
-0.27096492052078247,
-0.5904341340065002,
-0.3298164904117584,
-0.5669824481010437,
0.059554167091846466,
0.1752755492925644,
-0.9789108633995056,
0.2117341160774231,
-0.5101041197776794,
0.004178578499704599,
-0.06356042623519897,
-0.4002879559993744,
-1.0109745264053345,
-0.03221699222922325,
0.3386843502521515,
0.9927066564559937,
-0.7030032873153687,
0.7317041158676147,
0.20356479287147522,
-0.270874559879303,
-0.8821544051170349,
-0.08459300547838211,
-0.3075762689113617,
-1.1452224254608154,
1.1233400106430054,
0.1329367309808731,
-0.24528849124908447,
-0.053508736193180084,
-0.8208511471748352,
-0.7738412022590637,
0.9692391753196716,
0.3730517327785492,
-0.4055318534374237,
-0.23900696635246277,
0.3013565242290497,
0.4076330363750458,
-0.1700000762939453,
0.07743696123361588,
0.3862360119819641,
0.2121109813451767,
0.15651346743106842,
-0.8742673993110657,
0.029395628720521927,
-0.24684225022792816,
-0.1374550610780716,
0.37388235330581665,
-0.2911723554134369,
1.116591453552246,
-0.5836695432662964,
-0.32608214020729065,
-0.09210807085037231,
0.48587334156036377,
0.03186311945319176,
0.422714501619339,
0.5368174910545349,
0.2426837980747223,
0.8543353080749512,
0.06430863589048386,
1.1115769147872925,
-0.16431878507137299,
0.21635575592517853,
0.6987680196762085,
0.22311972081661224,
1.0000470876693726,
0.8571580052375793,
0.06330826133489609,
0.3415176570415497,
0.4507669508457184,
-0.004901097621768713,
0.769591748714447,
0.39624667167663574,
-0.2303948551416397,
-0.17823657393455505,
0.040198132395744324,
-0.2709897756576538,
0.36007562279701233,
0.3401491045951843,
-0.48269614577293396,
-0.01796053722500801,
0.40294569730758667,
-0.16010892391204834,
-0.2521663010120392,
-0.4686782956123352,
0.8949775695800781,
-0.03994617238640785,
-0.6016092300415039,
0.9701492190361023,
-0.30039164423942566,
0.4277418553829193,
-0.5180085301399231,
-0.03773439675569534,
-0.4039848744869232,
0.279020220041275,
-0.016285641118884087,
-0.8213652968406677,
0.004767224192619324,
-0.20818527042865753,
-0.14679262042045593,
-0.027182646095752716,
0.7578462958335876,
-0.257348895072937,
-0.47114133834838867,
0.33221516013145447,
0.3474467098712921,
0.3252839744091034,
-0.13267016410827637,
-0.20252284407615662,
0.22186055779457092,
0.1854979544878006,
-0.2407458871603012,
0.2831079065799713,
0.408644437789917,
-0.08036936819553375,
0.8351742625236511,
0.5983577370643616,
0.07103761285543442,
0.8670381307601929,
-0.028835149481892586,
1.1478055715560913,
-0.5026032328605652,
-0.39918509125709534,
-0.9322406053543091,
0.7062463164329529,
-0.0709800198674202,
-0.0447876863181591,
0.5755786299705505,
0.4900308847427368,
0.9371216297149658,
-0.37160739302635193,
0.5377320647239685,
0.3069794476032257,
0.18011535704135895,
-0.8338587284088135,
0.5332556962966919,
-0.5585801005363464,
0.2650277614593506,
-0.044381555169820786,
-0.6115602850914001,
-0.27323323488235474,
0.4567755460739136,
0.05012113228440285,
-0.4276942312717438,
0.7328911423683167,
0.9084939360618591,
-0.22010527551174164,
-0.3883535861968994,
0.543549120426178,
0.18354448676109314,
0.3311278820037842,
0.716264009475708,
0.8031448125839233,
-0.49763572216033936,
0.8033480644226074,
-0.24988409876823425,
-0.05879559740424156,
-0.21556785702705383,
-0.4683675467967987,
-1.2546658515930176,
-0.672736644744873,
0.19222566485404968,
-0.20523549616336823,
0.00026958563830703497,
0.4944442808628082,
0.7924599051475525,
-0.5939158797264099,
0.12394367903470993,
-0.11429476737976074,
0.05572532117366791,
-0.08333385735750198,
-0.20455746352672577,
0.39360326528549194,
-0.18496468663215637,
-0.3335685729980469,
0.2572839856147766,
0.1652400642633438,
0.16638420522212982,
-0.5827930569648743,
-0.07604249566793442,
0.30902713537216187,
0.14097662270069122,
0.7464298009872437,
-0.03076031431555748,
-1.0587331056594849,
-0.4767274856567383,
0.5068764686584473,
-0.05223006382584572,
0.006930012255907059,
1.0306856632232666,
-0.86521315574646,
0.47513943910598755,
0.5214976668357849,
0.6454163789749146,
0.6410637497901917,
-0.1289418637752533,
0.29935023188591003,
-0.9825394153594971,
0.40455323457717896,
0.20641250908374786,
0.14597828686237335,
0.003710040356963873,
-0.6097389459609985,
0.2054288238286972,
0.07675609737634659,
-0.2953283190727234,
-1.2104313373565674,
0.42278704047203064,
-0.8478050231933594,
-0.2767385244369507,
1.0113710165023804,
-0.04775925725698471,
-0.4898478388786316,
0.1036243885755539,
-0.4750328063964844,
-0.008842959068715572,
-0.0140845887362957,
0.6735451221466064,
0.7086540460586548,
0.020592590793967247,
-0.6255589723587036,
-0.7212615013122559,
0.6263286471366882,
0.5538758635520935,
-0.42280998826026917,
0.2122742235660553,
0.2823968827724457,
0.23954148590564728,
0.22699187695980072,
0.5845539569854736,
0.00943912472575903,
0.3306141197681427,
0.20595358312129974,
-0.2982443571090698,
-0.2364700436592102,
-0.4478049576282501,
-0.2493266761302948,
0.28994840383529663,
0.13475680351257324,
-0.4607014060020447
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09032v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09032v1
|
CodeUltraFeedback: An LLM-as-a-Judge Dataset for Aligning Large Language Models to Coding Preferences
| 2024-03-14T01:51:35 | 2024-03-14T01:51:35 |
Martin Weyssow, Aton Kamanda, Houari Sahraoui
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Evaluating the alignment of large language models (LLMs) with user-defined
coding preferences is a challenging endeavour that requires assessing intricate
textual LLMs' outputs. By relying on automated metrics and static analysis
tools, existing benchmarks fail to assess nuances in user instructions and LLM
outputs, highlighting the need for large-scale datasets and benchmarks for LLM
preference alignment. In this paper, we introduce CodeUltraFeedback, a
preference dataset of 10,000 complex instructions to tune and align LLMs to
coding preferences through AI feedback. We generate responses to the
instructions using a pool of 14 diverse LLMs, which we then annotate according
to their alignment with five coding preferences using the LLM-as-a-Judge
approach with GPT-3.5, producing both numerical and textual feedback. We also
present CODAL-Bench, a benchmark for assessing LLM alignment with these coding
preferences. Our results show that CodeLlama-7B-Instruct, aligned through
reinforcement learning from AI feedback (RLAIF) with direct preference
optimization (DPO) using CodeUltraFeedback's AI feedback data, outperforms 34B
LLMs on CODAL-Bench, validating the utility of CodeUltraFeedback for preference
tuning. Furthermore, we show our DPO-aligned CodeLlama model improves
functional correctness on HumanEval+ compared to the unaligned base model.
Therefore, our contributions bridge the gap in preference tuning of LLMs for
code and set the stage for further advancements in model alignment and RLAIF
for code intelligence. Our code and data are available at
https://github.com/martin-wey/CodeUltraFeedback.
|
[
-0.1454179286956787,
-0.13504928350448608,
0.28537654876708984,
0.33300158381462097,
-0.012111545540392399,
0.17464464902877808,
-0.6971673369407654,
-0.023494381457567215,
0.037431664764881134,
0.49005234241485596,
-0.5830667018890381,
-0.7057933807373047,
-0.4605603516101837,
0.09333392977714539,
-0.21115416288375854,
1.100748896598816,
-0.35785260796546936,
0.07362014055252075,
-0.4096921384334564,
-0.2257131189107895,
-0.7175065875053406,
-0.6249436736106873,
-0.033680692315101624,
-0.45243796706199646,
0.3473038673400879,
0.6991194486618042,
0.9033198356628418,
0.7042473554611206,
0.5948786735534668,
0.1912144422531128,
0.32919174432754517,
0.1183757483959198,
-0.34812045097351074,
-0.16926954686641693,
-0.0618264265358448,
-0.4028894007205963,
-0.4979441463947296,
0.011581086553633213,
0.2120504379272461,
0.20861704647541046,
-0.09425044804811478,
0.23990696668624878,
0.0639897882938385,
0.759080708026886,
-0.4916105568408966,
0.13699276745319366,
-0.32566940784454346,
0.09219218790531158,
0.05500312149524689,
-0.4368823766708374,
-0.5860368609428406,
-0.9399815201759338,
-0.12946932017803192,
-0.39164769649505615,
-0.20083686709403992,
0.029270727187395096,
0.716913104057312,
0.6817120313644409,
-0.37603288888931274,
-0.4032965898513794,
-0.4197533130645752,
0.7834869027137756,
-0.8187009692192078,
0.10307793319225311,
0.28379324078559875,
0.22681856155395508,
-0.08503197878599167,
-0.28864747285842896,
-0.5017044544219971,
-0.3721935749053955,
-0.03364886716008186,
0.16547921299934387,
-0.052458010613918304,
-0.033474139869213104,
0.25703948736190796,
0.3620281219482422,
-0.7583317756652832,
0.39991480112075806,
0.019364861771464348,
-0.26893192529678345,
0.7416436076164246,
0.16872212290763855,
0.13957267999649048,
-0.066314697265625,
-0.46292126178741455,
-0.2131378948688507,
-0.7626858949661255,
0.1921175867319107,
0.603843092918396,
0.16437089443206787,
-0.2044614553451538,
0.5884765982627869,
-0.06139096990227699,
0.8529496788978577,
0.18289828300476074,
-0.040816064924001694,
0.47649523615837097,
-0.09184690564870834,
-0.16118112206459045,
0.18751537799835205,
0.7660724520683289,
0.7538295388221741,
0.5125752091407776,
-0.04350518062710762,
-0.3098113238811493,
0.2023017853498459,
0.5101332068443298,
-0.6941991448402405,
-0.05942656099796295,
0.30008822679519653,
-0.4312756657600403,
-0.4943329095840454,
0.1608726680278778,
-0.636003315448761,
-0.43065571784973145,
-0.5308417677879333,
0.13952583074569702,
-0.21107496321201324,
-0.015192992985248566,
0.35757848620414734,
0.1727292537689209,
0.42824575304985046,
0.37280532717704773,
-1.0158506631851196,
-0.045144714415073395,
0.8758934140205383,
0.6688809394836426,
-0.5493192672729492,
-0.3941982686519623,
-0.6535080671310425,
-0.16956694424152374,
-0.27090421319007874,
0.6660779118537903,
-0.7658154368400574,
-0.23830126225948334,
0.2612978518009186,
0.07797297835350037,
-0.03874475881457329,
-0.4794602692127228,
0.6524906754493713,
-0.5907266139984131,
-0.10227295011281967,
-0.03697832301259041,
-0.6042132377624512,
-0.05029129609465599,
0.35586467385292053,
-0.4561161696910858,
0.8091098070144653,
0.14617452025413513,
-0.46686750650405884,
0.37477049231529236,
-0.33173325657844543,
-0.3894149363040924,
-0.053702402859926224,
-0.501725971698761,
-0.4176531434059143,
0.027310142293572426,
0.1505919098854065,
0.26466402411460876,
-0.20363172888755798,
0.6495777368545532,
-0.5103352069854736,
-0.6677905917167664,
0.3115209639072418,
-0.35897451639175415,
0.5091226100921631,
0.09371794760227203,
-0.5476258993148804,
0.4136125147342682,
-0.657151460647583,
0.11710677295923233,
-0.11680241674184799,
-0.6062012910842896,
0.02384655550122261,
0.09971007704734802,
0.0378628633916378,
0.07023037225008011,
0.2442392259836197,
-0.43903154134750366,
0.7674595713615417,
-0.14718332886695862,
0.6184470653533936,
0.9670552611351013,
-0.5180743336677551,
0.42510172724723816,
-0.41078105568885803,
0.7968250513076782,
-0.32321327924728394,
0.09963840246200562,
0.08113130927085876,
-0.07298646867275238,
-0.4669266641139984,
-0.1882571280002594,
0.3257334232330322,
0.4205319881439209,
-0.30738693475723267,
0.755646288394928,
-0.5214539170265198,
-0.09755410999059677,
-0.7218214273452759,
0.17708346247673035,
0.5386300683021545,
0.33125558495521545,
0.21858985722064972,
-0.28811320662498474,
-0.5502243638038635,
-1.0321505069732666,
-0.1843680590391159,
-0.24127133190631866,
0.014107432216405869,
0.4009609520435333,
0.2865005135536194,
-0.4286315143108368,
0.891032338142395,
-0.40359732508659363,
-0.08081474900245667,
-0.03707308694720268,
-0.08176636695861816,
0.3477191925048828,
0.5565714240074158,
0.3509744703769684,
-0.6131288409233093,
-0.2939276695251465,
0.027087755501270294,
-0.43878114223480225,
-0.3698399066925049,
0.026998279616236687,
-0.09013466536998749,
0.2860677242279053,
0.20856943726539612,
-0.2627381682395935,
0.23205538094043732,
0.8304997682571411,
-0.24173693358898163,
0.5400535464286804,
-0.029683303087949753,
0.5125359296798706,
-0.7888955473899841,
0.13104553520679474,
-0.2898438274860382,
-0.2917681932449341,
-0.05168700963258743,
0.07301654666662216,
0.39239197969436646,
0.14025607705116272,
-0.21122290194034576,
0.4054469168186188,
-0.21772883832454681,
-0.3896026611328125,
-0.3633202016353607,
-0.024185268208384514,
0.060664303600788116,
0.7700303792953491,
0.27439072728157043,
0.9745532870292664,
0.08992945402860641,
-0.23126643896102905,
0.4430430829524994,
0.47639700770378113,
-0.1992286592721939,
0.37219342589378357,
-0.4547187089920044,
0.47226589918136597,
0.30459409952163696,
0.2965035140514374,
-0.9998353719711304,
-0.09954356402158737,
0.0809781551361084,
-0.405630499124527,
0.3388839662075043,
-0.4299118220806122,
-0.2431754618883133,
-0.403886079788208,
-0.5553568601608276,
0.3688541352748871,
0.4906463623046875,
-0.7633726000785828,
0.39064180850982666,
0.15974436700344086,
0.010291293263435364,
-0.7780189514160156,
-0.45084214210510254,
-0.019769856706261635,
-0.13749012351036072,
-0.41181299090385437,
0.3059524893760681,
-0.36604273319244385,
-0.18711420893669128,
-0.3015742003917694,
-0.300508588552475,
0.3199057877063751,
0.01831304281949997,
0.5882323384284973,
0.4998601973056793,
-0.1437746286392212,
0.15308281779289246,
-0.10616473108530045,
-0.25268107652664185,
0.039331432431936264,
-0.39828747510910034,
0.5860663056373596,
-0.33654654026031494,
-0.36547040939331055,
-0.12014801800251007,
0.0031043447088450193,
0.5490312576293945,
-0.18675567209720612,
0.0532720610499382,
0.2146349400281906,
0.1594858467578888,
-0.08989477902650833,
-0.5425693392753601,
0.06661280989646912,
-0.3746882379055023,
0.18985508382320404,
-0.09029899537563324,
-0.9787106513977051,
0.11556146293878555,
0.05486149340867996,
0.202670156955719,
0.28615155816078186,
0.8346978425979614,
0.004544404335319996,
0.8715226650238037,
0.4942523241043091,
-0.4929784834384918,
0.3422958552837372,
-0.04542318359017372,
-0.00146967894397676,
-0.6866203546524048,
-0.12465132772922516,
-0.6254291534423828,
-0.5216525197029114,
-0.5183373689651489,
-0.21029934287071228,
-0.021062202751636505,
-0.05407649278640747,
-0.5050820112228394,
0.45820605754852295,
-0.6600350737571716,
0.41200193762779236,
0.46048861742019653,
0.07903852313756943,
0.45180436968803406,
-0.19588539004325867,
0.07776108384132385,
0.033077165484428406,
-0.5237985849380493,
-0.7509400248527527,
1.1226838827133179,
0.2355298548936844,
1.2172170877456665,
0.03694655001163483,
0.6251514554023743,
0.5381792187690735,
0.4524035155773163,
-0.9283801317214966,
0.267821341753006,
-0.09580758213996887,
-0.060501448810100555,
0.061800021678209305,
-0.17596974968910217,
-0.44029754400253296,
-0.15296706557273865,
-0.11119493097066879,
-0.4734167158603668,
0.21754184365272522,
0.3929613530635834,
-0.4604934751987457,
-0.05480136349797249,
-0.7400637269020081,
0.8679953217506409,
-0.5298892259597778,
-0.4969671070575714,
-0.12955094873905182,
-0.7301572561264038,
0.32400012016296387,
0.04647693783044815,
0.11319264024496078,
-0.13021928071975708,
-0.041432399302721024,
0.5563396215438843,
-0.4508373737335205,
0.8186805248260498,
0.04806163161993027,
-0.2648276686668396,
-0.18094944953918457,
0.09890031814575195,
0.4402511417865753,
0.1713000386953354,
-0.18610964715480804,
0.15214885771274567,
0.028202535584568977,
-0.18020887672901154,
-0.4471783936023712,
1.0321407318115234,
-0.9642475247383118,
-0.6609966158866882,
-0.3353959023952484,
-0.6285897493362427,
-0.3291626572608948,
0.0022915846202522516,
0.07440909743309021,
0.5718345642089844,
0.10922151058912277,
0.1723015308380127,
0.5828937292098999,
-0.3080553710460663,
0.42756614089012146,
0.6367222666740417,
-0.36428600549697876,
-0.3946637511253357,
0.8397494554519653,
-0.40368226170539856,
0.13285726308822632,
0.4966675043106079,
0.16899144649505615,
-0.2606392502784729,
-0.4843171536922455,
-0.7655037045478821,
-0.14910250902175903,
-0.5543729662895203,
-0.6175832152366638,
-0.41048628091812134,
-0.04758007079362869,
-0.21651853621006012,
-0.502081573009491,
-0.33676135540008545,
-0.2450268715620041,
-0.07608266174793243,
-0.07335919886827469,
0.5221959352493286,
0.5901399850845337,
0.17276576161384583,
0.013192081823945045,
-0.8939676880836487,
0.011639345437288284,
0.00272369640879333,
0.6246799826622009,
-0.09889382869005203,
-0.615068256855011,
-0.1523800939321518,
-0.05870991200208664,
-0.24963314831256866,
-0.509178102016449,
0.20450757443904877,
-0.11346127837896347,
0.2276245504617691,
0.2138509452342987,
0.0037571329157799482,
0.5553696155548096,
-0.38076990842819214,
0.6138509511947632,
0.00764435576274991,
-1.0548901557922363,
0.545897901058197,
-0.18222475051879883,
0.3292863368988037,
0.8384953737258911,
0.2085588276386261,
-0.3607691526412964,
-0.05709372088313103,
-0.2416597306728363,
-0.5115839242935181,
0.6910646557807922,
0.03397281840443611,
-0.05385027453303337,
0.11755775660276413,
0.4050087630748749,
0.34213507175445557,
0.35209959745407104,
-0.6049144864082336,
0.021967848762869835,
-0.26999038457870483,
-0.5056752562522888,
-0.20868714153766632,
-0.08158442378044128,
-0.21811005473136902,
-0.07270495593547821,
0.5223046541213989,
-0.4842335879802704,
0.14450760185718536,
0.006948965601623058,
-0.30105793476104736,
-0.12573230266571045,
0.38931187987327576,
0.6992767453193665,
0.6200528144836426,
-0.24411974847316742,
0.037172842770814896,
-0.20038142800331116,
-0.275098979473114,
0.39364075660705566,
0.10008295625448227,
-0.09419628232717514,
-0.3859679400920868,
0.5225375890731812,
0.6800776720046997,
0.3922401964664459,
-0.9063917398452759,
0.7220478057861328,
-0.2148910015821457,
-0.19765125215053558,
-0.07295569032430649,
0.14561372995376587,
-0.03225765377283096,
0.2685519754886627,
0.0738728791475296,
0.22508279979228973,
-0.007608690764755011,
-0.34800052642822266,
0.24622708559036255,
0.4635334014892578,
-0.4732132852077484,
-0.17548532783985138,
0.5730788111686707,
0.2290167659521103,
-0.4442124664783478,
0.6055537462234497,
0.2763209939002991,
-0.5019087195396423,
0.71539306640625,
0.39069467782974243,
0.8895418047904968,
0.09685185551643372,
0.1025829017162323,
0.2383810579776764,
0.07707890123128891,
-0.08629578351974487,
0.13922381401062012,
-0.2981131076812744,
-0.7456575632095337,
-0.3272366523742676,
-0.6647533774375916,
-0.48140719532966614,
-0.26786699891090393,
-0.8550697565078735,
0.2798628807067871,
-0.40276476740837097,
-0.03699411451816559,
-0.31488850712776184,
0.013810249976813793,
-0.5924089550971985,
-0.003602654440328479,
0.009416749700903893,
0.9482504725456238,
-0.5529353618621826,
0.9496415257453918,
0.5307466387748718,
-0.40426281094551086,
-0.9384716749191284,
0.15964707732200623,
0.20164531469345093,
-1.3472280502319336,
0.5250269770622253,
0.29343381524086,
-0.298393577337265,
-0.04099322110414505,
-0.701288104057312,
-0.6509513854980469,
1.017088532447815,
0.45303964614868164,
-1.0979979038238525,
0.18578724563121796,
-0.1146291196346283,
0.468731552362442,
-0.43054690957069397,
0.42021340131759644,
0.7132729887962341,
0.5071479082107544,
0.0542980395257473,
-0.6955380439758301,
0.07641293108463287,
-0.33065956830978394,
-0.015221848152577877,
0.32643923163414,
-0.8079723715782166,
0.10978420078754425,
-0.26201844215393066,
0.2245698720216751,
0.014849432744085789,
0.3376147150993347,
0.22195574641227722,
-0.08926009386777878,
0.4347177743911743,
0.45541298389434814,
0.35226795077323914,
-0.08171068876981735,
1.0754196643829346,
-0.4704170525074005,
0.3548210859298706,
1.0860477685928345,
-0.449308305978775,
0.8516964912414551,
0.5702524781227112,
-0.15915054082870483,
0.3866378366947174,
0.6245028376579285,
-0.07807446271181107,
0.4277389645576477,
0.4262568950653076,
0.35565122961997986,
-0.19402548670768738,
-0.06695221364498138,
-0.3679226338863373,
0.389974981546402,
-0.22304078936576843,
-0.21480080485343933,
0.1037125512957573,
-0.18301554024219513,
-0.14679302275180817,
0.20525091886520386,
-0.22647833824157715,
0.8320833444595337,
-0.04866768419742584,
-1.0220788717269897,
0.6913534998893738,
-0.2313028872013092,
0.8023524880409241,
-0.6161012649536133,
-0.11724663525819778,
-0.5207082033157349,
0.38398775458335876,
-0.4878935217857361,
-0.934043824672699,
0.07556743919849396,
0.17332300543785095,
-0.32136574387550354,
-0.27866142988204956,
0.2776097059249878,
-0.4805448055267334,
-0.11791054159402847,
0.4757367670536041,
-0.04961409792304039,
-0.28176531195640564,
0.3305560350418091,
-0.5693119168281555,
0.594840943813324,
0.27696266770362854,
-0.18613027036190033,
0.5196468234062195,
-0.09188984334468842,
-0.04427755996584892,
0.5227785110473633,
0.4114111363887787,
-0.0954170823097229,
-0.26498904824256897,
0.2725982964038849,
0.7920109033584595,
-0.6838201284408569,
-0.3455428183078766,
-0.9222539663314819,
0.303205668926239,
0.12953653931617737,
-0.41697508096694946,
0.637400209903717,
0.6328108906745911,
0.8673590421676636,
-0.1288469433784485,
0.7575114965438843,
0.06702417880296707,
0.12367306649684906,
-0.8283244967460632,
0.3142904043197632,
-0.3615693747997284,
0.455485999584198,
-0.21758010983467102,
-0.821433961391449,
-0.18688733875751495,
0.3699432611465454,
-0.3805408179759979,
-0.04296843707561493,
0.4579934775829315,
0.9610111713409424,
0.07320362329483032,
0.08492716401815414,
0.1379009485244751,
-0.004840211942791939,
0.28585273027420044,
0.8035350441932678,
0.8560578227043152,
-0.20189982652664185,
0.4805907905101776,
0.00025439137243665755,
-0.41291072964668274,
-0.43339452147483826,
-1.0180970430374146,
-0.6627147793769836,
-0.306275337934494,
-0.2833768427371979,
-0.4262934923171997,
0.2185119241476059,
1.4011956453323364,
0.5999063849449158,
-0.9604899883270264,
-0.40096375346183777,
-0.003563741222023964,
0.09333710372447968,
-0.3556878864765167,
-0.2070053219795227,
0.40038737654685974,
-0.2525268793106079,
-0.5662146210670471,
0.28453290462493896,
0.5886451005935669,
-0.2356601357460022,
-0.11918243765830994,
-0.44196024537086487,
0.03142520785331726,
-0.19044874608516693,
0.3486655652523041,
0.23636974394321442,
-0.7916269898414612,
-0.43216806650161743,
-0.008649416267871857,
-0.3670923411846161,
0.410258024930954,
1.1856203079223633,
-0.5842413902282715,
0.30041956901550293,
0.3299032151699066,
1.0176950693130493,
0.25550147891044617,
0.21099434792995453,
0.9639744162559509,
-0.48898905515670776,
-0.05452973023056984,
0.24353119730949402,
0.40470054745674133,
0.16431333124637604,
-0.47322678565979004,
0.4953322410583496,
-0.14484958350658417,
-0.7812070250511169,
-0.5183310508728027,
0.1373290866613388,
-1.061919093132019,
-0.0008204245241358876,
1.20696222782135,
-0.12176061421632767,
-0.06212620437145233,
0.26552844047546387,
-0.46047163009643555,
-0.20434211194515228,
-0.6665941476821899,
0.7284538149833679,
0.6804713606834412,
0.0021924960892647505,
-0.05443120002746582,
-0.19415460526943207,
0.6457507014274597,
0.5065827965736389,
-0.735482394695282,
0.4431760609149933,
0.7104037404060364,
0.17073018848896027,
-0.24704734981060028,
0.5566254258155823,
-0.10619623959064484,
0.4054178297519684,
-0.5519033670425415,
0.36471161246299744,
-0.16060775518417358,
-0.1968509554862976,
-0.8285094499588013,
-0.032999228686094284,
0.3242979347705841,
-0.11571848392486572
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09028v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09028v1
|
ChartInstruct: Instruction Tuning for Chart Comprehension and Reasoning
| 2024-03-14T01:40:23 | 2024-03-14T01:40:23 |
Ahmed Masry, Mehrad Shahmohammadi, Md Rizwan Parvez, Enamul Hoque, Shafiq Joty
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Charts provide visual representations of data and are widely used for
analyzing information, addressing queries, and conveying insights to others.
Various chart-related downstream tasks have emerged recently, such as
question-answering and summarization. A common strategy to solve these tasks is
to fine-tune various models originally trained on vision tasks language.
However, such task-specific models are not capable of solving a wide range of
chart-related tasks, constraining their real-world applicability. To overcome
these challenges, we introduce ChartInstruct: a novel chart-specific
vision-language Instruction-following dataset comprising 191K instructions
generated with 71K charts. We then present two distinct systems for instruction
tuning on such datasets: (1) an end-to-end model that connects a vision encoder
for chart understanding with a LLM; and (2) a pipeline model that employs a
two-step approach to extract chart data tables and input them into the LLM. In
experiments on four downstream tasks, we first show the effectiveness of our
model--achieving a new set of state-of-the-art results. Further evaluation
shows that our instruction-tuning approach supports a wide array of real-world
chart comprehension and reasoning scenarios, thereby expanding the scope and
applicability of our models to new kinds of tasks.
|
[
-0.1332533210515976,
-0.6941547989845276,
0.48649242520332336,
-0.21251773834228516,
-0.39095014333724976,
0.187494158744812,
-0.021810393780469894,
-0.3381694555282593,
-0.10990560799837112,
1.0309313535690308,
-0.7668119668960571,
-0.8228220343589783,
-0.6265866160392761,
-0.3272920846939087,
-0.5287995934486389,
0.8493413925170898,
-0.22179174423217773,
0.08182590454816818,
-0.237057164311409,
0.12656307220458984,
-0.8945243954658508,
-0.1235964223742485,
-0.677383542060852,
0.03730374947190285,
0.3511310815811157,
1.1533299684524536,
0.43050289154052734,
0.9106589555740356,
0.6694812178611755,
0.23053011298179626,
0.4749615490436554,
0.6891908645629883,
-0.7718360424041748,
0.28119510412216187,
0.0925227627158165,
-0.6505697965621948,
-0.3584948182106018,
0.0351477675139904,
0.3401128649711609,
0.8529371023178101,
0.17186902463436127,
0.45141834020614624,
0.22072792053222656,
1.048241376876831,
-0.8506461381912231,
0.7613113522529602,
-0.29717257618904114,
0.008395201526582241,
0.07522197812795639,
-0.4422706365585327,
-0.8954034447669983,
-0.4753572642803192,
0.22770433127880096,
-0.9387833476066589,
0.21583127975463867,
0.2082727998495102,
0.8832994699478149,
0.5183322429656982,
-0.5523906350135803,
-0.42441749572753906,
-0.3952217698097229,
0.4874332547187805,
-0.5268988609313965,
0.37594330310821533,
0.41627857089042664,
0.6066001057624817,
0.2377597689628601,
-1.084622859954834,
0.010683530010282993,
0.09461032599210739,
-0.11915742605924606,
0.519882321357727,
-0.003518500830978155,
0.18465282022953033,
0.2016741931438446,
0.16346865892410278,
-0.41702762246131897,
0.3187054395675659,
-0.6132732629776001,
0.03869109973311424,
0.5656886100769043,
0.591819167137146,
0.2918460965156555,
-0.04908430203795433,
-0.17466096580028534,
-0.3631853461265564,
-0.7180352210998535,
0.2605167031288147,
0.2708916962146759,
0.26727280020713806,
-0.20569097995758057,
0.42962920665740967,
-0.20804886519908905,
1.0111984014511108,
0.3802606761455536,
0.11015420407056808,
-0.14014005661010742,
-0.07330673187971115,
-0.38464856147766113,
0.14651696383953094,
0.15812526643276215,
0.7084307670593262,
0.571926474571228,
-0.14066027104854584,
-0.21002179384231567,
0.12281126528978348,
0.5559290647506714,
-0.6700605154037476,
-0.6054984927177429,
-0.06664954125881195,
-0.21088792383670807,
-0.20597943663597107,
0.013589726760983467,
-0.5020119547843933,
-0.556662380695343,
-0.8728523254394531,
0.514720618724823,
-0.6316193342208862,
0.3564237654209137,
0.05099334567785263,
-0.1344836950302124,
0.3183242976665497,
0.40288856625556946,
-1.0067863464355469,
0.15269890427589417,
0.8784936666488647,
0.5885230898857117,
-0.010440315119922161,
-0.1972493678331375,
-0.7771705985069275,
0.25140175223350525,
-0.811038613319397,
0.9077590107917786,
-0.8486161828041077,
-0.01219203695654869,
-0.12281288951635361,
0.25373390316963196,
-0.4079790413379669,
-0.550923764705658,
0.29705947637557983,
-0.5814183354377747,
-0.06106287240982056,
-0.20538035035133362,
-1.2781375646591187,
-0.5968309044837952,
0.039901237934827805,
-0.5825451612472534,
0.612845778465271,
0.26756802201271057,
-0.47746866941452026,
0.3953694701194763,
-0.6209093332290649,
-0.5929967164993286,
0.18188367784023285,
-0.3340856730937958,
-0.3768172860145569,
-0.070548877120018,
0.5187743902206421,
0.5727861523628235,
-0.18968823552131653,
-0.37752676010131836,
0.16941794753074646,
-0.7357566952705383,
-0.21531735360622406,
-0.19822724163532257,
0.7224066853523254,
0.07738552242517471,
-0.42638254165649414,
0.23273976147174835,
-0.573095977306366,
0.3137267827987671,
-0.015357454307377338,
-0.003816802753135562,
-0.13096269965171814,
0.21270222961902618,
-0.28247085213661194,
-0.4157610535621643,
0.0755915492773056,
-0.21846966445446014,
0.06198497489094734,
-0.47525089979171753,
0.4331493377685547,
0.7882141470909119,
0.18342693150043488,
0.5510867834091187,
-0.13646121323108673,
0.7806504368782043,
0.0178547166287899,
0.42428144812583923,
-0.5351897478103638,
-0.5600677728652954,
-1.1571496725082397,
-0.07548651844263077,
0.018699444830417633,
0.8044365644454956,
-0.808851957321167,
0.0319657027721405,
-0.2995811104774475,
-0.620785653591156,
-0.3791831135749817,
0.0020592359360307455,
0.45621591806411743,
0.9316394329071045,
0.4253995716571808,
-0.23944787681102753,
-0.4713517427444458,
-0.7684646844863892,
0.0024612252600491047,
0.31143271923065186,
0.03705428168177605,
0.31544774770736694,
0.15253029763698578,
0.24086584150791168,
0.5754808187484741,
-0.8489193916320801,
-0.11388763785362244,
-0.284480482339859,
-0.022370288148522377,
0.232776939868927,
0.3305852711200714,
0.5040895938873291,
-0.50896817445755,
-0.8664475679397583,
0.04086890071630478,
-0.7983137369155884,
-0.015183341689407825,
-0.16030709445476532,
-0.48218461871147156,
-0.04787963628768921,
0.7675772905349731,
-0.05013944208621979,
0.7219938635826111,
0.35750576853752136,
-0.5157195329666138,
0.5061324834823608,
-0.24404968321323395,
0.29623207449913025,
-0.7350159287452698,
-0.47524797916412354,
-0.1933152675628662,
-0.07453138381242752,
-0.536777675151825,
0.30529356002807617,
0.3675033748149872,
-0.28818708658218384,
-0.09784845262765884,
0.09720022231340408,
-0.5790908932685852,
0.03920155018568039,
-0.34464994072914124,
0.11106289178133011,
0.24422438442707062,
0.5200361013412476,
-0.1486300677061081,
0.6500950455665588,
0.9260358214378357,
-0.6888566613197327,
0.6194836497306824,
0.31271588802337646,
-0.6601775288581848,
0.6750468015670776,
-0.4076240658760071,
0.2832222282886505,
-0.3044549524784088,
-0.006412831600755453,
-0.98308926820755,
-0.29727140069007874,
0.43851548433303833,
-0.10764986276626587,
0.5637993216514587,
-0.5457332730293274,
-0.31764599680900574,
-0.2626650929450989,
0.08821573108434677,
-0.04850366339087486,
0.5621278882026672,
-0.6725285053253174,
0.579713761806488,
0.1776958703994751,
0.08792609721422195,
-0.4681912362575531,
-0.7415308356285095,
-0.04122733324766159,
-0.1728426218032837,
-0.6245867609977722,
-0.014011591672897339,
0.053663067519664764,
0.06740596890449524,
-0.029990648850798607,
-0.14251355826854706,
-0.13105781376361847,
-0.07902024686336517,
0.3668636083602905,
0.5034691095352173,
-0.4381412863731384,
0.10764158517122269,
0.32061758637428284,
-0.3351465165615082,
-0.048975709825754166,
-0.450971782207489,
0.14247272908687592,
0.12738551199436188,
-0.7326681613922119,
-0.559607207775116,
0.1815924346446991,
0.4134754240512848,
-0.48095783591270447,
0.40210381150245667,
0.3198862075805664,
-0.031175533309578896,
-0.4165990352630615,
-0.20259304344654083,
-0.4348425269126892,
-0.5720676183700562,
0.579334557056427,
-0.05558590963482857,
-0.47243672609329224,
0.1088705062866211,
-0.04468031972646713,
0.5237841606140137,
-0.04220530018210411,
0.2072049379348755,
-0.6875106692314148,
0.955220639705658,
0.4550969898700714,
0.3119424879550934,
0.5547305941581726,
-0.6883445382118225,
0.3222537338733673,
-0.6048304438591003,
-0.07161179184913635,
-0.029583927243947983,
-0.8365159630775452,
-0.3127547800540924,
-0.47040632367134094,
0.5143609642982483,
-0.16488684713840485,
-0.47194424271583557,
0.2799440324306488,
-0.7408621907234192,
0.8015665411949158,
0.7865828275680542,
0.5131298303604126,
0.11419776827096939,
0.131276473402977,
0.27111154794692993,
-0.09039051085710526,
-0.8583516478538513,
-0.5174314975738525,
1.2707180976867676,
-0.22798782587051392,
0.7741729021072388,
-0.32758575677871704,
0.46515434980392456,
0.09231676161289215,
0.20111826062202454,
-0.7726203203201294,
0.587135910987854,
-0.794086754322052,
-0.44988858699798584,
-0.45411568880081177,
-0.21448270976543427,
-1.0524296760559082,
-0.0007584296399727464,
0.027120525017380714,
-0.719788670539856,
-0.02325429953634739,
0.5421931743621826,
-0.11788440495729446,
0.39360931515693665,
-1.3551942110061646,
1.0981308221817017,
-0.4316994547843933,
-0.13915209472179413,
-0.2793617248535156,
-0.643490195274353,
0.2532670795917511,
0.26037609577178955,
0.12811815738677979,
-0.04893426597118378,
0.08376285433769226,
0.4821803569793701,
-0.4702056646347046,
1.0533474683761597,
-0.2765175402164459,
-0.0680350661277771,
0.5347734093666077,
0.09743289649486542,
0.5763152837753296,
-0.41569074988365173,
0.174434095621109,
-0.44380635023117065,
0.12596969306468964,
-0.4087774157524109,
-1.044081449508667,
0.46748802065849304,
-0.4953259229660034,
-0.5544317960739136,
0.22094091773033142,
-0.8740859031677246,
-0.4420614242553711,
0.006868753582239151,
0.3606323301792145,
0.9108123779296875,
0.3484019339084625,
0.18367868661880493,
0.5250931978225708,
-0.0776168629527092,
0.02372874692082405,
0.4043019413948059,
0.08623357862234116,
-0.08993217349052429,
1.1370782852172852,
0.2387014627456665,
0.45479997992515564,
0.5873191952705383,
-0.031966518610715866,
0.04237619787454605,
-0.44132307171821594,
-0.6276828646659851,
-0.1331489533185959,
-1.168045997619629,
-0.13571679592132568,
0.17235945165157318,
-0.21992021799087524,
-0.062434203922748566,
-0.3247074484825134,
-0.36348068714141846,
-0.37247103452682495,
-0.40864068269729614,
-0.17340713739395142,
0.5597015619277954,
0.738558292388916,
0.17237448692321777,
0.2336556315422058,
-0.7204573750495911,
0.26695558428764343,
0.4347798526287079,
0.3540244698524475,
0.22656424343585968,
-0.6460515260696411,
-0.6834161877632141,
0.2052784562110901,
-0.3861011564731598,
-0.8456982970237732,
-0.04391161724925041,
0.26602983474731445,
0.425954133272171,
0.6585063338279724,
0.27506351470947266,
0.8217645287513733,
-0.5546790361404419,
0.34294360876083374,
-0.0056970324367284775,
-0.6246469020843506,
0.5834851264953613,
0.1210605725646019,
0.4169447124004364,
0.26253750920295715,
0.2675635516643524,
-0.37844666838645935,
-0.6740942001342773,
-0.1912953406572342,
-0.8274673819541931,
0.855772852897644,
0.07842495292425156,
0.10623158514499664,
0.28406140208244324,
0.5601231455802917,
0.19393055140972137,
-0.21361592411994934,
-0.014023665338754654,
-0.4002695083618164,
-0.498679518699646,
-0.633951723575592,
-0.14270856976509094,
0.11709669977426529,
-0.09232981503009796,
-0.4622456729412079,
0.46318119764328003,
-0.29199784994125366,
-0.1622057408094406,
-0.1994669884443283,
-0.28280702233314514,
-0.016160035505890846,
-0.10876023024320602,
0.1751668006181717,
0.8693873882293701,
0.08148325979709625,
0.1434960961341858,
0.07662559300661087,
-0.7298300266265869,
-0.04190671816468239,
-0.004204974975436926,
-0.4967075288295746,
-0.3414018154144287,
0.6541746854782104,
1.2386269569396973,
0.647922694683075,
-0.8186343908309937,
0.11543448269367218,
0.11817697435617447,
-0.08116724342107773,
-0.018258031457662582,
0.554006814956665,
0.3302386999130249,
0.42750972509384155,
0.28626951575279236,
-0.07252029329538345,
0.03298827260732651,
-0.23145286738872528,
0.10422679781913757,
0.10623955726623535,
-0.4657159745693207,
-0.10211440920829773,
0.7474930286407471,
0.16224077343940735,
-0.18184123933315277,
0.9589864015579224,
-0.020556585863232613,
-0.26203712821006775,
1.1111994981765747,
0.24504396319389343,
0.6067157983779907,
0.18825769424438477,
0.39064928889274597,
0.47030794620513916,
0.4392879605293274,
0.5804369449615479,
0.36222201585769653,
-0.07629839330911636,
-0.5879168510437012,
-0.47791844606399536,
-0.046077486127614975,
-0.5962908267974854,
-0.168386310338974,
-0.8328683376312256,
0.19351641833782196,
-0.2956903576850891,
0.08307401090860367,
-0.015373815782368183,
-0.2584495544433594,
-0.7258617281913757,
0.32991522550582886,
0.27582910656929016,
0.664199709892273,
-0.4940711557865143,
0.4047767221927643,
0.6484197974205017,
-0.42110341787338257,
-1.0847870111465454,
-0.1476564258337021,
-0.0026352691929787397,
-1.070797085762024,
0.5783783793449402,
0.1822081357240677,
-0.0521681047976017,
0.2476026713848114,
-0.8269868493080139,
-0.6575415134429932,
1.2555782794952393,
0.7162970900535583,
-0.7514654397964478,
-0.08270260691642761,
0.1759672313928604,
0.3625216782093048,
-0.39978131651878357,
0.03719695284962654,
0.6078447103500366,
0.49835097789764404,
0.09974857419729233,
-0.5450423955917358,
-0.06167280301451683,
0.07093501091003418,
-0.45974624156951904,
0.1275883913040161,
-0.5497236847877502,
0.6018809080123901,
-0.5719841718673706,
-0.3259989619255066,
-0.17304779589176178,
0.4307166337966919,
0.18197257816791534,
0.48195573687553406,
0.5110401511192322,
0.42166954278945923,
0.7566890716552734,
-0.09912358969449997,
0.9569170475006104,
-0.6274828910827637,
0.08706720173358917,
1.4078916311264038,
0.14203906059265137,
0.6966459155082703,
0.1703205108642578,
0.044523779302835464,
0.5535302758216858,
0.8139880895614624,
-0.10261936485767365,
0.4712553322315216,
-0.09305623918771744,
0.23515403270721436,
-0.40556788444519043,
0.21991974115371704,
-0.16365814208984375,
0.6055377125740051,
0.4453217089176178,
-0.43566498160362244,
-0.13267438113689423,
-0.15950775146484375,
-0.23406794667243958,
0.18681713938713074,
-0.5267601013183594,
0.5506599545478821,
-0.03286447748541832,
-0.7205353379249573,
0.615271270275116,
-0.4077065587043762,
-0.09492851793766022,
-0.5866609215736389,
-0.2206439971923828,
-0.3262239098548889,
0.11802920699119568,
-0.20011240243911743,
-0.9903128147125244,
0.1455259770154953,
-0.0023986874148249626,
-0.006339277606457472,
-0.21184419095516205,
0.22201402485370636,
-0.23102907836437225,
-0.6917372345924377,
-0.06729647517204285,
0.2983742356300354,
0.000551966717466712,
0.07349192351102829,
-0.4362146258354187,
-0.24878749251365662,
0.14180715382099152,
-0.041352882981300354,
0.010872060433030128,
0.5659115314483643,
0.11317472159862518,
0.9650329947471619,
0.24687409400939941,
-0.2113349288702011,
0.2661631405353546,
0.48992279171943665,
0.6585623621940613,
-0.4160097539424896,
-0.6473836302757263,
-0.2709408104419708,
0.499022901058197,
-0.007536880671977997,
-0.21888841688632965,
0.6692834496498108,
0.6703752279281616,
0.7480697631835938,
-0.32920724153518677,
0.6026611328125,
0.33747705817222595,
0.47452178597450256,
-0.8996252417564392,
0.7195243239402771,
-0.6259545087814331,
0.1543702781200409,
-0.22676949203014374,
-0.6003707647323608,
-0.11914278566837311,
0.2896890938282013,
-0.5540544986724854,
-0.25946730375289917,
0.7794325947761536,
0.7794201970100403,
-0.288099467754364,
0.2566886246204376,
0.16283871233463287,
0.02789836935698986,
0.04553806781768799,
0.8127980828285217,
0.7295196652412415,
-0.2699792683124542,
0.8920835852622986,
-0.5528503656387329,
-0.22940485179424286,
0.023977356031537056,
-0.4061296582221985,
-0.7945842742919922,
-0.651729941368103,
-0.49689188599586487,
0.19205716252326965,
0.04002668336033821,
0.26070550084114075,
0.9415408968925476,
-0.8803536295890808,
-0.3523567318916321,
-0.2492244392633438,
0.03332345187664032,
-0.5834998488426208,
-0.2332811802625656,
0.7504533529281616,
-0.5784919857978821,
-0.750068187713623,
0.4131130576133728,
0.4854179620742798,
-0.12114986777305603,
-0.06238024681806564,
-0.1495893895626068,
0.2184811532497406,
0.06355170160531998,
0.4895154535770416,
0.0941120907664299,
-0.5321490168571472,
-0.5008143782615662,
0.1621115654706955,
0.0961470976471901,
0.26047489047050476,
0.8366948366165161,
-0.5325862169265747,
0.8239133358001709,
0.2474670112133026,
0.49652099609375,
0.7844122052192688,
-0.06762214750051498,
0.4803318381309509,
-0.5872145891189575,
0.055603623390197754,
0.11927340179681778,
0.33822759985923767,
0.34279993176460266,
-0.3695124089717865,
0.6615652441978455,
-0.04943103715777397,
-0.30080080032348633,
-0.508533239364624,
0.4933578670024872,
-0.6387684345245361,
-0.29022812843322754,
0.388985812664032,
-0.12413234263658524,
-0.016112148761749268,
-0.02577808126807213,
-0.32521215081214905,
0.42367860674858093,
0.006705750711262226,
0.7918097376823425,
0.5540124773979187,
-0.48639410734176636,
-0.4734973609447479,
-0.6331028342247009,
0.09549149125814438,
0.30260998010635376,
-0.8180620670318604,
0.11977628618478775,
0.5333382487297058,
0.06669817119836807,
-0.29992908239364624,
0.03508257865905762,
0.287378191947937,
0.5984015464782715,
0.28119051456451416,
-0.37408432364463806,
-0.2346840500831604,
-0.16397921741008759,
0.4809689521789551,
0.05196341127157211,
-0.10802817344665527,
-0.6333186030387878
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09024v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09024v1
|
Semiparametric Token-Sequence Co-Supervision
| 2024-03-14T01:28:13 | 2024-03-14T01:28:13 |
Hyunji Lee, Doyoung Kim, Jihoon Jun, Sejune Joo, Joel Jang, Kyoung-Woon On, Minjoon Seo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In this work, we introduce a semiparametric token-sequence co-supervision
training method. It trains a language model by simultaneously leveraging
supervision from the traditional next token prediction loss which is calculated
over the parametric token embedding space and the next sequence prediction loss
which is calculated over the nonparametric sequence embedding space. The
nonparametric sequence embedding space is constructed by a separate language
model tasked to condense an input text into a single representative embedding.
Our experiments demonstrate that a model trained via both supervisions
consistently surpasses models trained via each supervision independently.
Analysis suggests that this co-supervision encourages a broader generalization
capability across the model. Especially, the robustness of parametric token
space which is established during the pretraining step tends to effectively
enhance the stability of nonparametric sequence embedding space, a new space
established by another language model.
|
[
-0.04822343960404396,
-0.53742516040802,
0.24932682514190674,
0.17518702149391174,
-0.21463768184185028,
0.1483045220375061,
-0.04489786550402641,
-0.1241271123290062,
0.10656695812940598,
0.4056447744369507,
-0.2419750690460205,
-0.7566083669662476,
-0.5275539755821228,
-0.08206234127283096,
-0.6004328727722168,
0.9854766130447388,
0.03937531262636185,
0.46622246503829956,
-0.4950028955936432,
-0.1521790623664856,
-0.63442063331604,
-0.8508610725402832,
-0.7308516502380371,
-0.07399396598339081,
0.2282499372959137,
0.19946697354316711,
0.604951024055481,
0.4557639956474304,
0.34905219078063965,
0.2704452872276306,
0.10184131562709808,
-0.030340010300278664,
-0.22502464056015015,
-0.21756257116794586,
-0.009412757121026516,
-0.68172287940979,
-0.3735186457633972,
0.015676364302635193,
0.7156764268875122,
0.9790501594543457,
-0.3405055105686188,
0.19752267003059387,
0.21480467915534973,
0.042855601757764816,
-0.44915539026260376,
0.3838028907775879,
-0.2828923165798187,
0.35886508226394653,
-0.0570463202893734,
-0.2679905891418457,
-0.6909918189048767,
-0.11175514757633209,
0.20393656194210052,
-0.47967082262039185,
0.5411190986633301,
0.46231743693351746,
0.6130880117416382,
0.11447224020957947,
-0.4359035789966583,
0.18301944434642792,
-0.48816099762916565,
0.9795047640800476,
-0.7001261711120605,
0.566978394985199,
0.38357099890708923,
0.33764806389808655,
0.11093635112047195,
-0.7148774862289429,
-0.3277699947357178,
-0.12746520340442657,
-0.13017338514328003,
0.032868582755327225,
0.29474836587905884,
0.3525354862213135,
-0.02018461562693119,
0.40357688069343567,
-0.1567355990409851,
0.15093785524368286,
-0.29646292328834534,
-0.6173219680786133,
0.4145856499671936,
0.17068739235401154,
0.39119240641593933,
-0.12037372589111328,
-0.8183855414390564,
-0.14528344571590424,
-0.6134200096130371,
0.17776598036289215,
0.24357585608959198,
0.5246900320053101,
-0.5068910717964172,
0.49117472767829895,
0.21085110306739807,
0.4973195791244507,
0.1679680049419403,
0.04253121092915535,
0.16822932660579681,
-0.5349560976028442,
-0.1498124748468399,
0.19210182130336761,
0.795369029045105,
0.4116046130657196,
0.043382104486227036,
-0.5669141411781311,
-0.017298417165875435,
0.063243567943573,
0.10843948274850845,
-0.3256978988647461,
-0.19219043850898743,
-0.08299922198057175,
-0.40201231837272644,
-0.2342640459537506,
0.22906358540058136,
-0.6659543514251709,
-0.11624511331319809,
-0.3446815013885498,
0.17811423540115356,
-0.3531215190887451,
-0.0021972195245325565,
0.018594233319163322,
-0.2797631323337555,
0.1206185445189476,
0.047219064086675644,
-1.0971463918685913,
0.5925998687744141,
0.7441225051879883,
1.158229112625122,
-0.21181216835975647,
-0.427144855260849,
-0.7569345831871033,
0.4896324872970581,
-0.4882794916629791,
0.2753916382789612,
-0.6234750747680664,
-0.21573609113693237,
0.29087573289871216,
-0.08964812010526657,
0.025804132223129272,
-0.2719547748565674,
0.3137575387954712,
-0.5991913676261902,
0.3185894787311554,
0.06280913203954697,
-0.8405539989471436,
0.03904371336102486,
0.2522640526294708,
-0.6690587997436523,
1.1680428981781006,
0.13478600978851318,
-1.044064998626709,
0.7044852375984192,
-0.2785290479660034,
-0.2473868876695633,
-0.10601498186588287,
-0.311903178691864,
-0.8477233648300171,
0.10384953022003174,
0.3252018690109253,
0.5899959206581116,
-0.028775760903954506,
0.7659215331077576,
-0.802702784538269,
-0.3392035961151123,
-0.2835937738418579,
-0.14660267531871796,
0.6468634605407715,
-0.3068698048591614,
-0.1854548454284668,
0.12049355357885361,
-0.7689677476882935,
-0.18954943120479584,
-0.2087189257144928,
-0.4323299527168274,
-0.6229124069213867,
-0.2041066735982895,
0.09641106426715851,
0.1462835818529129,
0.3110145628452301,
-0.5527019500732422,
-0.04073118418455124,
-0.5438482165336609,
0.37358254194259644,
0.7364312410354614,
0.23350463807582855,
0.8779307007789612,
-0.07574030011892319,
0.5580984354019165,
0.216300830245018,
0.14266452193260193,
-0.16781753301620483,
-0.3556523621082306,
-0.6478468775749207,
-0.1155727207660675,
0.367153525352478,
0.43476027250289917,
-0.7577922344207764,
0.6406119465827942,
0.002499755471944809,
-0.2609471082687378,
-0.1364177018404007,
0.1665736585855484,
0.7116557359695435,
0.585213840007782,
0.39373067021369934,
-0.3703440725803375,
-0.954168438911438,
-0.6645130515098572,
-0.3570910096168518,
-0.256637841463089,
0.26348549127578735,
-0.09035006910562515,
0.28851351141929626,
0.12883348762989044,
0.8539496064186096,
-0.15647974610328674,
-0.2312893271446228,
-0.47514814138412476,
0.2530774474143982,
0.2497432380914688,
0.6278440952301025,
0.5355343818664551,
-0.5539417266845703,
-0.5229408740997314,
-0.2737806737422943,
-0.8011743426322937,
0.04473523423075676,
-0.15741288661956787,
-0.12623383104801178,
0.0613589733839035,
0.7728471755981445,
-0.2853088676929474,
0.4830857515335083,
0.6749323606491089,
-0.32803526520729065,
0.30076727271080017,
-0.3712520897388458,
-0.367000937461853,
-1.6047898530960083,
-0.11686281114816666,
-0.09796231240034103,
-0.44895175099372864,
-0.6584104299545288,
-0.07969503104686737,
0.10046893358230591,
-0.10229862481355667,
-0.3061179220676422,
0.3814162313938141,
-0.5271285176277161,
-0.28622132539749146,
0.2153911143541336,
-0.3509118854999542,
0.021268516778945923,
0.6016016006469727,
0.24983824789524078,
0.9101786017417908,
0.8171923160552979,
-0.589613676071167,
0.20379158854484558,
0.612280011177063,
-0.3015124499797821,
-0.06491563469171524,
-0.7126166224479675,
0.1841907501220703,
0.13899388909339905,
0.3097662627696991,
-1.1206934452056885,
0.05157598480582237,
0.03968651965260506,
-0.2532404065132141,
0.39494237303733826,
-0.10716920346021652,
-0.5974246263504028,
-0.26817190647125244,
-0.3938121497631073,
0.6348000764846802,
0.2690379023551941,
-0.5739338397979736,
0.24616581201553345,
0.38304072618484497,
-0.16409176588058472,
-0.7029942870140076,
-0.8909952044487,
0.21956636011600494,
-0.29600557684898376,
-0.3064412474632263,
0.2867285907268524,
0.45925989747047424,
0.1401633471250534,
-0.20159882307052612,
-0.12015337496995926,
0.022788148373365402,
-0.1258273422718048,
0.22924385964870453,
0.42275282740592957,
-0.00484544737264514,
0.10018014162778854,
0.2406119555234909,
-0.24775424599647522,
0.02410043589770794,
-0.7162132859230042,
0.7801043391227722,
0.10894160717725754,
-0.47891998291015625,
-0.7319128513336182,
0.5228061079978943,
0.05261106416583061,
-0.25644341111183167,
1.026199221611023,
0.30951929092407227,
-0.13479720056056976,
-0.22630494832992554,
-0.17688849568367004,
-0.01455971971154213,
-0.4716164767742157,
0.4759195148944855,
-0.21289196610450745,
-1.102989912033081,
0.5168720483779907,
0.03588386997580528,
-0.14498361945152283,
0.21184495091438293,
0.7529986500740051,
-0.021633686497807503,
0.9620351791381836,
1.0347124338150024,
-0.4115873873233795,
0.7513307929039001,
-0.4418131113052368,
0.3119185268878937,
-0.6101043820381165,
-0.5454844236373901,
-0.23071344196796417,
-0.11520805209875107,
-0.44952303171157837,
-0.5701850652694702,
0.3260717988014221,
0.04154744744300842,
-0.3845629394054413,
0.6345261335372925,
-0.18119940161705017,
0.1784612536430359,
0.8713399171829224,
0.06662624329328537,
0.037648506462574005,
0.08640797436237335,
-0.6140329241752625,
0.07272739708423615,
-0.7391182780265808,
-0.4628112316131592,
1.2480040788650513,
0.491377592086792,
0.9670814275741577,
-0.07974828779697418,
1.105352520942688,
0.5190193057060242,
-0.213980033993721,
-0.4043863117694855,
0.3792399764060974,
0.03371196240186691,
-0.6805707812309265,
-0.3908534049987793,
-0.28795480728149414,
-0.5622389912605286,
-0.10332285612821579,
0.11764618009328842,
-0.7099026441574097,
0.29778239130973816,
0.3381902277469635,
-0.45394060015678406,
0.35428598523139954,
-0.7838743329048157,
0.8251920938491821,
0.002877467079088092,
-0.4353046119213104,
0.03036426194012165,
-0.9039461016654968,
0.09886588901281357,
-0.07443584501743317,
0.029227351769804955,
0.3697928488254547,
-0.23922213912010193,
0.7936285138130188,
-0.6946676969528198,
1.3490581512451172,
-0.5868302583694458,
0.024135775864124298,
0.3802432119846344,
-0.19418711960315704,
0.4808874726295471,
0.36037370562553406,
0.13621531426906586,
0.22619208693504333,
0.12348418682813644,
-0.7393450140953064,
-0.4502708911895752,
0.033431049436330795,
-0.9118250608444214,
-0.4115440249443054,
-0.36709076166152954,
-0.5271864533424377,
-0.6133376955986023,
0.2762123942375183,
0.30560222268104553,
0.571143627166748,
-0.2236814796924591,
0.07984726876020432,
0.25232020020484924,
-0.3253933787345886,
0.602667510509491,
-0.06579145789146423,
-0.25286540389060974,
-0.4860035479068756,
0.4306451976299286,
-0.17938201129436493,
0.3627611994743347,
0.7822995781898499,
0.08154129981994629,
-0.6769453287124634,
-0.6621078252792358,
-0.17691680788993835,
0.010916706174612045,
-0.604368269443512,
-0.14982375502586365,
-0.6228032112121582,
-0.04136950150132179,
-0.6893720626831055,
0.0014838844072073698,
-0.11862367391586304,
-0.43007102608680725,
-0.06064682453870773,
-0.37357375025749207,
0.0028589118737727404,
0.5389984250068665,
0.006412281654775143,
0.4957260191440582,
-0.9196871519088745,
0.05010678991675377,
0.16037917137145996,
0.32850146293640137,
0.03196745738387108,
-0.55296391248703,
-0.45134207606315613,
-0.27722299098968506,
-0.059212807565927505,
-0.7605910897254944,
0.33139023184776306,
0.4651026725769043,
0.4988915026187897,
0.5435396432876587,
-0.03770945593714714,
0.7990044951438904,
-0.7139860987663269,
0.838636577129364,
0.5943753719329834,
-1.0128663778305054,
0.29545465111732483,
-0.4980158805847168,
0.033589329570531845,
0.6512448787689209,
-0.024984154850244522,
-0.46862316131591797,
-0.5253363251686096,
-0.49258336424827576,
-0.6720800399780273,
1.0035760402679443,
-0.0813511312007904,
0.490183562040329,
-0.19018977880477905,
0.3019160032272339,
0.26694872975349426,
0.37715673446655273,
-0.4762667119503021,
-0.0925133004784584,
-0.32903894782066345,
-0.35050755739212036,
-0.3523949980735779,
-0.27379345893859863,
-0.06347297132015228,
-0.4673573672771454,
0.5098760724067688,
-0.175587996840477,
0.6275555491447449,
-0.1564241647720337,
0.022283731028437614,
0.11857530474662781,
0.01929592899978161,
0.10745322704315186,
0.31226474046707153,
-0.04069656506180763,
0.2241881638765335,
0.4072636365890503,
-0.2562437057495117,
0.31109675765037537,
-0.08201026916503906,
0.060838501900434494,
0.09695493429899216,
0.8836369514465332,
0.9653388857841492,
0.5248120427131653,
-0.14981186389923096,
0.961523175239563,
0.07468345016241074,
-0.21933579444885254,
-0.3027759790420532,
-0.24484701454639435,
0.15149888396263123,
0.20558467507362366,
0.06532077491283417,
0.13618609309196472,
0.10673975199460983,
-0.6046783328056335,
0.6030386090278625,
0.17574691772460938,
-0.4209496080875397,
-0.6211500763893127,
0.9495649337768555,
-0.03194279596209526,
-0.17977584898471832,
0.4651237428188324,
-0.03786233440041542,
-0.4826723337173462,
0.5645531415939331,
0.9119474291801453,
0.7898290753364563,
-0.06811759620904922,
0.3277992308139801,
0.24445122480392456,
-0.19036349654197693,
-0.14541460573673248,
0.31641894578933716,
-0.3347105085849762,
-0.4762606918811798,
-0.4806075692176819,
-0.9050633311271667,
-0.453945517539978,
-0.3348063826560974,
-0.8944345712661743,
0.5260645151138306,
-0.8072622418403625,
-0.17381563782691956,
-0.19938039779663086,
-0.2496354728937149,
-0.45426705479621887,
0.3999437689781189,
0.10474951565265656,
1.009061574935913,
-1.1154735088348389,
1.0425840616226196,
0.8952580690383911,
-0.5719019174575806,
-1.1132169961929321,
0.15571191906929016,
-0.2861800193786621,
-1.1242244243621826,
0.5402920246124268,
0.28907203674316406,
0.1291883885860443,
-0.05405065789818764,
-0.4158564805984497,
-0.8025633692741394,
1.0726741552352905,
0.6121892929077148,
-0.6027174592018127,
-0.7422336935997009,
0.5306892991065979,
0.7437490224838257,
-0.2738903760910034,
-0.2307567447423935,
0.17996127903461456,
-0.030185021460056305,
0.12437841296195984,
-0.6254281997680664,
-0.027614369988441467,
-0.10436686128377914,
0.23241069912910461,
0.3979599177837372,
-0.8180198073387146,
0.8057751059532166,
0.053275804966688156,
-0.19833089411258698,
0.31272628903388977,
0.9075602889060974,
-0.007098805159330368,
0.40441077947616577,
0.488680362701416,
0.7655826210975647,
0.5973532199859619,
0.11585909873247147,
1.0137020349502563,
-0.553509533405304,
0.6776883602142334,
1.3643767833709717,
0.14768719673156738,
0.7623355388641357,
0.6651334762573242,
-0.3608708679676056,
0.4792082905769348,
0.7168728709220886,
-0.15517695248126984,
0.9737061262130737,
-0.1790938675403595,
-0.19324243068695068,
-0.4144970178604126,
-0.043719712644815445,
-0.1131201982498169,
0.435356467962265,
-0.10115712881088257,
-0.6922282576560974,
-0.3586694002151489,
0.08066711574792862,
-0.08155560493469238,
0.13326649367809296,
-0.15713778138160706,
0.7163108587265015,
0.2977202236652374,
-0.571951150894165,
0.26705485582351685,
0.03742596507072449,
0.40743687748908997,
-0.381003201007843,
0.1713404506444931,
-0.10537823289632797,
0.31773391366004944,
-0.11068479716777802,
-0.25920194387435913,
0.5173951983451843,
-0.1072835847735405,
0.09165073931217194,
-0.2959323823451996,
0.38009756803512573,
-0.4606260657310486,
-0.6240411996841431,
0.49281999468803406,
0.39955103397369385,
-0.10477183014154434,
0.345702588558197,
-0.5098837018013,
-0.47831296920776367,
-0.3269995152950287,
0.0009992832783609629,
0.2451365888118744,
0.38195666670799255,
-0.4101795256137848,
0.2511306405067444,
0.4564473628997803,
0.019707905128598213,
0.6411623358726501,
0.3888370990753174,
0.7552844285964966,
-0.6639485955238342,
-0.8377758860588074,
-1.040493130683899,
0.3110085427761078,
-0.14634878933429718,
-0.21807247400283813,
0.8247213959693909,
0.7522398829460144,
0.8729356527328491,
-0.05643419548869133,
0.8775650262832642,
-0.07048841565847397,
0.4349437654018402,
-0.4432513415813446,
0.3882474899291992,
-0.4787185788154602,
-0.02374693751335144,
-0.3487716615200043,
-0.7809426188468933,
-0.5249210000038147,
0.10966260731220245,
-0.44907769560813904,
0.13808171451091766,
0.7236394286155701,
0.6137489676475525,
-0.17036780714988708,
-0.015238182619214058,
0.4484645426273346,
-0.3156503736972809,
0.2615576684474945,
0.5891997814178467,
0.8319564461708069,
-0.34695321321487427,
0.2922530174255371,
-0.19217301905155182,
-0.08436159044504166,
0.07931733131408691,
-0.6733391284942627,
-1.4506529569625854,
-0.6215737462043762,
0.03797994554042816,
-0.01159458328038454,
0.02868102304637432,
0.7404044270515442,
0.7122960090637207,
-1.1795421838760376,
-0.1107141450047493,
-0.6110243797302246,
-0.42397263646125793,
-0.155021533370018,
-0.13124248385429382,
0.6301935315132141,
-0.8137391805648804,
-0.9505625367164612,
0.09627077728509903,
0.4400234818458557,
-0.007487781345844269,
-0.3242972195148468,
-0.15710976719856262,
-0.37604814767837524,
0.04734348878264427,
0.23185326159000397,
-0.1422961801290512,
-0.5429949760437012,
-0.36864134669303894,
-0.11022711545228958,
-0.021141180768609047,
0.1331017017364502,
0.748354434967041,
-0.45437055826187134,
0.5240454077720642,
0.5563561916351318,
1.0129294395446777,
0.44774454832077026,
0.08819465339183807,
0.8608422875404358,
-1.4044384956359863,
0.3610374927520752,
-0.03684919327497482,
0.5117189884185791,
0.3253577947616577,
-0.3354550004005432,
0.33159980177879333,
0.35235753655433655,
-0.1916358917951584,
-0.8047167062759399,
0.11961454153060913,
-0.8127502799034119,
0.33435526490211487,
0.9125299453735352,
-0.4776262044906616,
-0.2110096514225006,
-0.25232937932014465,
-0.13792213797569275,
0.9142035245895386,
-0.41598182916641235,
0.714104413986206,
0.7592908143997192,
0.00965581089258194,
-0.189861461520195,
-0.10089424252510071,
0.3388116955757141,
0.7463080883026123,
-0.49439334869384766,
-0.1911604255437851,
0.04638716205954552,
0.06571795046329498,
0.25044500827789307,
0.47493717074394226,
-0.2731904685497284,
0.15353171527385712,
0.20804502069950104,
-0.11198487877845764,
-0.2414611577987671,
-0.324016273021698,
-0.46241357922554016,
0.346436083316803,
0.17307205498218536,
-0.7141404151916504
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09017v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09017v2
|
AraTrust: An Evaluation of Trustworthiness for LLMs in Arabic
| 2024-03-14T00:45:24 | 2024-03-15T23:52:18 |
Emad A. Alghamdi, Reem I. Masoud, Deema Alnuhait, Afnan Y. Alomairi, Ahmed Ashraf, Mohamed Zaytoon
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The swift progress and widespread acceptance of artificial intelligence (AI)
systems highlight a pressing requirement to comprehend both the capabilities
and potential risks associated with AI. Given the linguistic complexity,
cultural richness, and underrepresented status of Arabic in AI research, there
is a pressing need to focus on Large Language Models (LLMs) performance and
safety for Arabic related tasks. Despite some progress in their development,
there is a lack of comprehensive trustworthiness evaluation benchmarks which
presents a major challenge in accurately assessing and improving the safety of
LLMs when prompted in Arabic. In this paper, we introduce AraTrust, the first
comprehensive trustworthiness benchmark for LLMs in Arabic. AraTrust comprises
516 human-written multiple-choice questions addressing diverse dimensions
related to truthfulness, ethics, safety, physical health, mental health,
unfairness, illegal activities, privacy, and offensive language. We evaluated a
set of LLMs against our benchmark to assess their trustworthiness. GPT-4 was
the most trustworthy LLM, while open-source models, particularly AceGPT 7B and
Jais 13B, struggled to achieve a score of 60% in our benchmark.
|
[
-0.29416531324386597,
-0.5822983384132385,
0.6783989667892456,
0.15973101556301117,
-0.23417380452156067,
0.27783429622650146,
0.17482790350914001,
-0.8234517574310303,
-0.3757038414478302,
0.350490927696228,
0.019829077646136284,
-0.6926813721656799,
-1.103712558746338,
0.14180228114128113,
-0.5148406624794006,
1.1362742185592651,
-0.5238699316978455,
0.0298670195043087,
-0.14901594817638397,
-0.4369847774505615,
0.08215004950761795,
-0.5153465867042542,
-0.8778049945831299,
-0.224705308675766,
0.18515831232070923,
0.21223746240139008,
1.0374811887741089,
0.5418883562088013,
0.7152808308601379,
0.36038702726364136,
-0.12856455147266388,
0.2130686342716217,
0.04114168882369995,
0.048553258180618286,
-0.14316865801811218,
-0.2442704141139984,
-0.44065991044044495,
0.33609768748283386,
0.5178355574607849,
0.23235581815242767,
-0.24833771586418152,
0.4944981336593628,
0.05664465203881264,
0.8370795845985413,
-0.7885656952857971,
0.08415432274341583,
-0.5112556219100952,
-0.11415661871433258,
-0.10052002221345901,
0.026148315519094467,
0.022811349481344223,
-0.6889868378639221,
0.20641879737377167,
-0.3203158974647522,
-0.5463143587112427,
0.4205980896949768,
0.832463264465332,
0.3578769564628601,
-0.577119767665863,
-0.5099091529846191,
-0.45633432269096375,
0.8021860122680664,
-0.4733814001083374,
0.29113882780075073,
0.8124078512191772,
0.3096081614494324,
-0.1466938555240631,
-0.6153297424316406,
-0.4572693109512329,
-0.8677430152893066,
0.23664434254169464,
-0.07568015903234482,
-0.424543172121048,
-0.23711907863616943,
-0.15419901907444,
0.12527699768543243,
-0.5205095410346985,
-0.10380864888429642,
-0.003812159178778529,
-0.6007099747657776,
0.6629669070243835,
0.055252235382795334,
0.4475875496864319,
0.4214106500148773,
-0.5753017663955688,
-0.23826918005943298,
-0.8193497061729431,
0.1259501427412033,
0.6071211695671082,
-0.24220669269561768,
-0.33045995235443115,
0.4515785276889801,
-0.15179632604122162,
0.26941123604774475,
-0.2211010903120041,
-0.40992939472198486,
0.0982314795255661,
-0.30767112970352173,
-0.07482181489467621,
0.29623693227767944,
0.8607137799263,
0.3460279703140259,
0.7190391421318054,
-0.2869010865688324,
-0.12833958864212036,
0.3330404758453369,
0.32802245020866394,
-0.6732113361358643,
0.14318686723709106,
0.3835091292858124,
-0.48259106278419495,
-0.45300450921058655,
-0.022986220195889473,
-0.22950002551078796,
-0.4806343615055084,
0.105930857360363,
0.3677646517753601,
-0.6084257364273071,
-0.08279620856046677,
0.0546577051281929,
0.2790936827659607,
0.229630708694458,
0.2825312614440918,
-0.22941991686820984,
0.4135212004184723,
0.6824684739112854,
0.8410245180130005,
-0.35307902097702026,
-0.6681068539619446,
-0.4455631375312805,
0.391264408826828,
-0.4648797810077667,
0.6336954236030579,
-0.6646333336830139,
-0.3412303328514099,
0.1332997828722,
-0.5420899987220764,
0.2710563838481903,
-0.49499741196632385,
0.9191004037857056,
-0.8156977891921997,
-0.40669846534729004,
0.21594078838825226,
-0.4773842692375183,
-0.3237082362174988,
0.6132016181945801,
-0.688560426235199,
0.7321426272392273,
-0.016758287325501442,
-0.6050569415092468,
0.2866532504558563,
-0.6383019685745239,
-0.5030795931816101,
-0.008628832176327705,
-0.20828433334827423,
-0.5330283045768738,
-0.3149349093437195,
0.25991031527519226,
0.14269770681858063,
-0.40840184688568115,
0.16654010117053986,
-0.3278219997882843,
-0.4492850601673126,
0.7592000961303711,
-0.816430926322937,
0.5562368631362915,
0.22918769717216492,
-0.5084786415100098,
0.1515037566423416,
-0.5742651224136353,
0.12143411487340927,
-0.09514383226633072,
-0.21835707128047943,
-0.26271459460258484,
-0.17250052094459534,
0.12588441371917725,
0.217875674366951,
0.7137206196784973,
-0.4827329218387604,
-0.35132572054862976,
-0.28634482622146606,
0.24146264791488647,
0.9846231937408447,
-0.14125026762485504,
0.28222349286079407,
-0.6493900418281555,
0.7222139835357666,
0.2919652760028839,
0.2683185338973999,
0.43095919489860535,
-0.5006170868873596,
-0.5627360343933105,
-0.1607203334569931,
0.40776780247688293,
0.5184898376464844,
-0.3959347903728485,
0.42178457975387573,
-0.03068673424422741,
-0.7857340574264526,
-0.724473237991333,
0.1920957863330841,
0.6422198414802551,
0.10753685981035233,
0.2493586391210556,
-0.4605104625225067,
-0.1360255926847458,
-1.1445157527923584,
-0.5468229651451111,
-0.39340099692344666,
0.3456786870956421,
0.49324148893356323,
0.6245994567871094,
-0.39205026626586914,
0.558783769607544,
-0.0662972629070282,
-0.37253639101982117,
0.016757242381572723,
0.01948012411594391,
-0.06546558439731598,
0.41668397188186646,
0.5333128571510315,
-0.7180358171463013,
-0.7540445327758789,
0.06496261805295944,
-0.5492934584617615,
0.3276784121990204,
0.34127771854400635,
-0.18891575932502747,
0.540958821773529,
0.310230553150177,
-0.7970725297927856,
0.521267294883728,
0.9190732836723328,
-0.618503749370575,
0.61332106590271,
-0.04289902374148369,
0.21985623240470886,
-0.9135340452194214,
0.2856379449367523,
-0.07066231220960617,
-0.2675468623638153,
-0.1795312464237213,
0.33799630403518677,
-0.2060859650373459,
0.16440290212631226,
-0.5945988297462463,
0.6789990067481995,
-0.2276095747947693,
-0.14811189472675323,
-0.21817903220653534,
-0.05572572350502014,
-0.3210325241088867,
-0.07748377323150635,
-0.45313742756843567,
1.3951268196105957,
0.768092691898346,
-0.5961741805076599,
0.16462117433547974,
0.29227378964424133,
-0.7090371251106262,
0.377074271440506,
-0.7316991686820984,
0.3155747950077057,
0.2644759714603424,
0.19820956885814667,
-0.6466755270957947,
0.019300786778330803,
0.37374043464660645,
-0.46891528367996216,
-0.11649462580680847,
0.012822606600821018,
-0.5677093863487244,
0.22569604218006134,
-0.24339641630649567,
0.6482203006744385,
0.572655200958252,
-0.3031254708766937,
0.8098384141921997,
0.5605491995811462,
-0.15372715890407562,
-0.8839991688728333,
-0.32978275418281555,
0.23249781131744385,
-0.4040638506412506,
-0.6504040360450745,
0.08737430721521378,
-0.1528783142566681,
-0.5451598167419434,
0.13424938917160034,
-0.31589826941490173,
-0.18454259634017944,
0.5363247990608215,
0.555394172668457,
0.11104970425367355,
0.0383162647485733,
-0.3872883915901184,
0.04884137958288193,
-0.43344447016716003,
0.384179949760437,
-0.13396136462688446,
0.4428767263889313,
-0.6722156405448914,
-0.38121673464775085,
-0.4981158971786499,
0.3806934356689453,
0.6246495842933655,
-0.4536767303943634,
1.1049777269363403,
0.6109524369239807,
-0.2772599160671234,
0.015395508147776127,
-0.5309847593307495,
0.033497344702482224,
-0.5316517353057861,
0.3228148818016052,
-0.2399812638759613,
-1.1643213033676147,
0.3419730067253113,
-0.3751029074192047,
-0.12748382985591888,
0.4116831421852112,
0.6550398468971252,
-0.015576592646539211,
1.015750527381897,
0.4388168752193451,
-0.6661074757575989,
-0.2529049515724182,
0.31990182399749756,
0.21379509568214417,
-0.4536832273006439,
-0.1682461053133011,
-0.5539896488189697,
-0.1388012319803238,
-0.8278763294219971,
-0.12312747538089752,
0.6412728428840637,
-0.11344381421804428,
-0.5443049073219299,
0.024587148800492287,
0.02994740754365921,
0.4788019061088562,
0.6382490992546082,
0.055056337267160416,
0.5486217737197876,
0.08774009346961975,
-0.21018482744693756,
0.31532350182533264,
-0.21033655107021332,
-1.1311702728271484,
1.2504791021347046,
0.5037097930908203,
0.6873149275779724,
0.6399791240692139,
0.8316082954406738,
0.6969183087348938,
0.34718915820121765,
-0.3305675983428955,
0.6472830772399902,
0.0038523313123732805,
-0.5461454391479492,
-0.3637237250804901,
-0.3178618550300598,
-0.9351004362106323,
-0.22955422103405,
-0.22043749690055847,
-0.692646324634552,
-0.49977341294288635,
0.08072812855243683,
-0.37458646297454834,
0.05574953928589821,
-0.3388291001319885,
0.5064529776573181,
-0.3271706998348236,
-0.34209027886390686,
-0.5273441672325134,
-0.5499676465988159,
0.27907076478004456,
-0.22160226106643677,
0.26452282071113586,
-0.2626725435256958,
-0.39652836322784424,
0.770717978477478,
-0.20966096222400665,
0.4280969798564911,
0.20271404087543488,
-0.05361694470047951,
0.29615145921707153,
0.3993362784385681,
0.5746833682060242,
0.1318432092666626,
-0.16656069457530975,
0.7105463743209839,
0.01423785649240017,
-0.32940930128097534,
-0.3822919428348541,
0.9352808594703674,
-1.3287588357925415,
-0.6800568103790283,
-0.9382784366607666,
-0.49958083033561707,
-0.5135214328765869,
0.2649916708469391,
-0.15832485258579254,
-0.08039906620979309,
-0.3379805088043213,
-0.020377902314066887,
0.4180782735347748,
-0.18044012784957886,
0.31263551115989685,
0.6424541473388672,
-0.023544808849692345,
-0.2996523380279541,
0.6047635078430176,
-0.33764684200286865,
-0.09234775602817535,
-0.056748103350400925,
0.08365710079669952,
-0.3525271415710449,
-0.9353512525558472,
-0.5452287197113037,
-0.02925826609134674,
-0.5103633999824524,
-0.2883448898792267,
-0.21530921757221222,
-0.4779091477394104,
-0.10533680021762848,
0.00438476400449872,
-0.49284306168556213,
-0.17761261761188507,
0.12676188349723816,
-0.13600292801856995,
0.47665202617645264,
0.855453610420227,
0.02810119092464447,
0.05334298312664032,
-1.0266000032424927,
0.147542342543602,
0.06264594197273254,
0.7325664162635803,
0.05665992200374603,
-0.43054625391960144,
-0.39292123913764954,
-0.18076136708259583,
-0.24627523124217987,
-0.5783731341362,
0.07011721283197403,
-0.03726915270090103,
0.5196805596351624,
0.465099960565567,
0.07661418616771698,
0.31958895921707153,
-0.7462694048881531,
0.6668146252632141,
0.004065746441483498,
-1.0434867143630981,
0.16612884402275085,
-0.06494225561618805,
-0.13800102472305298,
0.80044025182724,
0.7987189888954163,
-0.17615684866905212,
-0.3150343894958496,
-0.5525177121162415,
-0.8689987063407898,
0.280875563621521,
0.6255624890327454,
-0.11308992654085159,
0.08817636966705322,
0.33311888575553894,
0.19169403612613678,
0.23028914630413055,
-0.6124980449676514,
-0.5745874047279358,
0.08783933520317078,
-0.1830098032951355,
-0.12626363337039948,
-0.4466777443885803,
-0.3730972409248352,
0.18474945425987244,
0.8647997975349426,
0.22291506826877594,
0.021275274455547333,
0.010033538565039635,
-0.11267905682325363,
-0.14779803156852722,
0.4687435030937195,
0.49945858120918274,
0.6834664940834045,
-0.11052566021680832,
0.18089358508586884,
0.08422397822141647,
-0.7755496501922607,
0.5357846021652222,
0.24772506952285767,
-0.24009282886981964,
-0.49137380719184875,
0.4836307168006897,
0.36853542923927307,
-0.2995719611644745,
-0.8503198027610779,
0.4763328731060028,
-0.06352277845144272,
-0.09926857799291611,
-0.8183756470680237,
0.25416189432144165,
0.0410190187394619,
0.34255316853523254,
0.22648411989212036,
0.08857407420873642,
0.3428936004638672,
-0.4462929666042328,
0.2862248420715332,
0.4963807463645935,
-0.2968154549598694,
0.2171115279197693,
0.439695805311203,
0.1680660843849182,
-0.28735724091529846,
0.6391916275024414,
-0.0318530835211277,
-0.5007572770118713,
0.5265038013458252,
0.267013818025589,
0.930177628993988,
-0.2779548168182373,
0.06125759705901146,
0.10996334254741669,
0.6556330919265747,
0.13124102354049683,
0.3343581259250641,
0.17807067930698395,
-0.9094715714454651,
-0.10924513638019562,
-0.6594799757003784,
-0.7949184775352478,
0.03808409720659256,
-0.5264925360679626,
-0.4400770366191864,
-0.6480392813682556,
-0.3476497530937195,
-0.4674323797225952,
0.2651120722293854,
-0.599797248840332,
0.2838036119937897,
0.1179874986410141,
1.0294150114059448,
-0.6574147343635559,
0.699559211730957,
0.8634907007217407,
-0.23874440789222717,
-0.8747718334197998,
0.10694461315870285,
-0.23003721237182617,
-1.1876535415649414,
0.39320632815361023,
0.24138383567333221,
-0.6407111287117004,
-0.21224963665008545,
-0.6445640325546265,
-0.9817957282066345,
1.18118155002594,
0.35836249589920044,
-0.49623212218284607,
0.36570262908935547,
0.6018416285514832,
0.38405507802963257,
-0.21285836398601532,
0.33858394622802734,
0.6057494282722473,
0.6367793083190918,
-0.3166830241680145,
-0.9070119261741638,
0.2272326648235321,
-0.31768837571144104,
-0.09772315621376038,
0.004597269929945469,
-0.8894135355949402,
0.6309388279914856,
-0.01028555165976286,
0.08844161033630371,
0.4573637843132019,
0.6201518177986145,
0.8299222588539124,
0.4886331558227539,
0.5793724060058594,
0.6764564514160156,
0.48598894476890564,
0.2320377379655838,
1.1845182180404663,
-0.8230080604553223,
-0.06444385647773743,
0.9166411757469177,
-0.5202871561050415,
0.9863781332969666,
0.40911826491355896,
-0.22638140618801117,
0.6781205534934998,
0.32337847352027893,
0.2786027789115906,
0.5263845324516296,
0.1764610856771469,
-0.38288626074790955,
-0.40380704402923584,
-0.3656735122203827,
-0.42662379145622253,
0.7719713449478149,
0.07983651012182236,
-0.3452996611595154,
0.01323794573545456,
-0.4456483721733093,
0.25291919708251953,
0.16612955927848816,
-0.27775830030441284,
0.6012022495269775,
0.3016042411327362,
-0.5898022651672363,
0.06166521832346916,
0.4286904036998749,
0.32817792892456055,
-0.7993142604827881,
-0.13791924715042114,
-0.14178964495658875,
0.274924635887146,
0.018936362117528915,
-0.88057541847229,
0.10229049623012543,
0.19644451141357422,
0.22512035071849823,
0.12939980626106262,
0.5176916718482971,
-0.010069693438708782,
-0.5647674202919006,
0.41803425550460815,
0.5060876607894897,
0.2555517852306366,
-0.16718755662441254,
-0.8080463409423828,
0.3147891163825989,
-0.3044860064983368,
-0.05211002007126808,
0.6033775806427002,
0.14393974840641022,
-0.1342741698026657,
1.0379565954208374,
0.7836014628410339,
0.14182709157466888,
-0.2891017496585846,
-0.1867247074842453,
0.6932176947593689,
-0.6456518769264221,
-0.521619439125061,
-1.0859365463256836,
0.1340518593788147,
0.09951141476631165,
-0.4627701938152313,
0.9719598293304443,
0.5088968873023987,
0.6679015159606934,
0.22452682256698608,
0.9107476472854614,
0.4446258842945099,
0.23283514380455017,
-0.5139514207839966,
1.2671235799789429,
-0.42357051372528076,
0.1415845900774002,
-0.24915026128292084,
-0.8429083228111267,
0.06977052986621857,
0.6789519786834717,
-0.0513540618121624,
0.3633396625518799,
0.6337838172912598,
0.6096975207328796,
0.20117929577827454,
0.08858512341976166,
0.3177061975002289,
0.24977131187915802,
0.13936546444892883,
0.6639741659164429,
1.0052812099456787,
-0.43524977564811707,
0.6901373863220215,
-0.20534904301166534,
-0.22960835695266724,
0.07409033179283142,
-1.0189296007156372,
-0.9471471309661865,
-0.2866057753562927,
-0.29799965023994446,
-0.552707314491272,
0.4399440586566925,
0.9006783366203308,
0.4724268913269043,
-0.9856570363044739,
-0.3481858968734741,
0.09224055707454681,
-0.02044806443154812,
-0.15954308211803436,
-0.054739657789468765,
0.6623353958129883,
0.26881831884384155,
-0.362606018781662,
0.258291095495224,
0.2003062218427658,
0.0831957533955574,
-0.28695690631866455,
-0.5524292588233948,
0.01156698353588581,
0.25668278336524963,
0.3459901809692383,
-0.03939393535256386,
-0.7551516890525818,
-0.34076252579689026,
-0.2666066586971283,
-0.2418333888053894,
-0.24238350987434387,
0.33629557490348816,
-0.6501972079277039,
-0.17549698054790497,
-0.23068033158779144,
0.942398726940155,
0.04586412385106087,
-0.06251655519008636,
0.4259766638278961,
0.003483561798930168,
-0.05687349662184715,
0.3029720187187195,
0.3977387547492981,
0.15784874558448792,
-0.24736295640468597,
0.49433234333992004,
-0.41853445768356323,
-0.7120351791381836,
-0.41707488894462585,
0.38320839405059814,
-0.9590311050415039,
0.07031040638685226,
1.1105972528457642,
-0.34647276997566223,
-0.13780182600021362,
-0.32394522428512573,
-0.0950772687792778,
0.12456933408975601,
-0.6305080056190491,
1.1076339483261108,
0.8435250520706177,
0.10819289833307266,
0.07091141492128372,
-0.2358732521533966,
0.4991249442100525,
0.689068078994751,
-0.7216621041297913,
-0.3440702259540558,
0.21775420010089874,
0.22214853763580322,
0.0721493735909462,
0.44019195437431335,
-0.1555604785680771,
0.5779847502708435,
0.033744242042303085,
-0.2581106126308441,
-0.24404828250408173,
-0.41653627157211304,
-0.056500956416130066,
0.35010358691215515,
0.7408552765846252,
-0.061069026589393616
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09747v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09747v1
|
Re-Search for The Truth: Multi-round Retrieval-augmented Large Language Models are Strong Fake News Detectors
| 2024-03-14T00:35:39 | 2024-03-14T00:35:39 |
Guanghua Li, Wensheng Lu, Wei Zhang, Defu Lian, Kezhong Lu, Rui Mao, Kai Shu, Hao Liao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The proliferation of fake news has had far-reaching implications on politics,
the economy, and society at large. While Fake news detection methods have been
employed to mitigate this issue, they primarily depend on two essential
elements: the quality and relevance of the evidence, and the effectiveness of
the verdict prediction mechanism. Traditional methods, which often source
information from static repositories like Wikipedia, are limited by outdated or
incomplete data, particularly for emerging or rare claims. Large Language
Models (LLMs), known for their remarkable reasoning and generative
capabilities, introduce a new frontier for fake news detection. However, like
traditional methods, LLM-based solutions also grapple with the limitations of
stale and long-tail knowledge. Additionally, retrieval-enhanced LLMs frequently
struggle with issues such as low-quality evidence retrieval and context length
constraints. To address these challenges, we introduce a novel,
retrieval-augmented LLMs framework--the first of its kind to automatically and
strategically extract key evidence from web sources for claim verification.
Employing a multi-round retrieval strategy, our framework ensures the
acquisition of sufficient, relevant evidence, thereby enhancing performance.
Comprehensive experiments across three real-world datasets validate the
framework's superiority over existing methods. Importantly, our model not only
delivers accurate verdicts but also offers human-readable explanations to
improve result interpretability.
|
[
-0.19217582046985626,
-0.9196630716323853,
0.9888371825218201,
-0.04742089658975601,
-0.23258300125598907,
0.191401407122612,
-0.02686849795281887,
-0.40411463379859924,
0.37743425369262695,
0.4863522946834564,
-0.34999263286590576,
-0.4203920066356659,
-0.6681921482086182,
0.10502271354198456,
-0.6457112431526184,
0.6096577644348145,
0.09017083048820496,
-0.016560910269618034,
-0.12325041741132736,
0.0029164503794163465,
-0.039132073521614075,
-0.5549680590629578,
-0.22117304801940918,
-0.2232467234134674,
0.6022422313690186,
0.42473679780960083,
0.6128239035606384,
0.5953991413116455,
0.263912558555603,
0.2266778200864792,
0.06849485635757446,
0.5791601538658142,
-0.4907595217227936,
-0.16373266279697418,
-0.25788795948028564,
-0.4736217260360718,
-0.14070408046245575,
0.31819772720336914,
0.5631958246231079,
0.2714325487613678,
-0.36018577218055725,
0.13148465752601624,
-0.48523053526878357,
0.5732553601264954,
-0.7831790447235107,
-0.1376383751630783,
-0.9888975024223328,
-0.09018074721097946,
-0.3019525110721588,
-0.2774222195148468,
-0.5952622294425964,
-0.4787306785583496,
0.025885146111249924,
-0.656001091003418,
0.4206881523132324,
0.23082545399665833,
1.0110934972763062,
-0.05877268686890602,
-0.8585905432701111,
-0.3706311285495758,
-0.41741514205932617,
0.7141575217247009,
-0.8046779036521912,
0.580254077911377,
0.18266446888446808,
0.45819807052612305,
-0.4080096185207367,
-0.8005065321922302,
-0.9488843083381653,
-0.3420359492301941,
0.029330581426620483,
-0.13456501066684723,
-0.034810055047273636,
-0.1974298506975174,
0.1512967199087143,
0.5082949995994568,
-0.5380735993385315,
-0.03435911238193512,
-0.32914480566978455,
-0.7097412943840027,
0.482119083404541,
-0.22895145416259766,
0.3919652998447418,
-0.31364426016807556,
-0.4046323001384735,
0.10102484375238419,
-0.9161016345024109,
-0.37681570649147034,
0.48740893602371216,
0.41120991110801697,
0.1030605360865593,
0.7130537629127502,
-0.5029863119125366,
0.7395667433738708,
0.14769621193408966,
-0.49389082193374634,
0.2430320382118225,
-0.23821863532066345,
-0.025046564638614655,
0.13687556982040405,
0.6172181963920593,
0.1506616473197937,
-0.006161157973110676,
0.002870447002351284,
-0.4321734309196472,
0.06965102255344391,
0.3660256266593933,
-0.6705421209335327,
-0.017563575878739357,
0.08663737028837204,
-0.6042801141738892,
-0.4311070740222931,
0.1021447405219078,
-0.745210587978363,
-0.524652898311615,
-0.3932671844959259,
0.6397469639778137,
-0.2124752551317215,
-0.42628490924835205,
0.2642475366592407,
-0.25201597809791565,
0.13400150835514069,
0.5085048675537109,
-0.3111400902271271,
-0.010436631739139557,
0.6303139925003052,
0.7830544710159302,
-0.021239321678876877,
-0.0028683345299214125,
-0.9848362803459167,
-0.013242841698229313,
-0.5647748708724976,
0.9194779396057129,
-0.5415178537368774,
0.14104895293712616,
0.2984902262687683,
0.06405245512723923,
0.5512038469314575,
-0.6090279817581177,
0.8158376812934875,
-1.0339540243148804,
0.39825794100761414,
-0.3531903624534607,
-0.5863628387451172,
-0.32153546810150146,
0.5925424695014954,
-0.8917179703712463,
0.9609798789024353,
-0.12938347458839417,
-0.5356284379959106,
0.5638273358345032,
-0.3199578821659088,
-0.5171229243278503,
-0.10005911439657211,
-0.09159515053033829,
-0.39368319511413574,
0.3607419431209564,
0.4115963876247406,
0.23760615289211273,
-0.1786493957042694,
0.2931782901287079,
-0.4586455821990967,
-0.2655239403247833,
0.06568889319896698,
-0.6919826865196228,
0.5290992856025696,
0.10556112229824066,
-0.23718702793121338,
-0.04792047291994095,
-0.8396673798561096,
-0.12164373695850372,
0.3333752751350403,
-0.5753032565116882,
-0.26527026295661926,
-0.011084865778684616,
-0.0973883718252182,
0.29161593317985535,
0.23707064986228943,
-0.8028387427330017,
0.22600845992565155,
-0.28497782349586487,
0.29023751616477966,
0.7512388229370117,
-0.0992872342467308,
0.12854395806789398,
-0.345482736825943,
0.2342974692583084,
0.1418381631374359,
0.013649874366819859,
-0.3115347921848297,
-0.26523542404174805,
-0.6280952095985413,
-0.24345049262046814,
0.4675201177597046,
0.46797072887420654,
-0.9940071105957031,
0.211228609085083,
-0.43462514877319336,
-0.2504265010356903,
-0.5383085012435913,
0.06098172441124916,
0.1491471230983734,
0.3535272777080536,
0.5027186870574951,
0.02311912178993225,
-0.6545114517211914,
-0.9497125744819641,
-0.7184411883354187,
-0.008306176401674747,
0.0036997359711676836,
0.03001837059855461,
0.7013054490089417,
-0.053561050444841385,
1.0628880262374878,
-0.37203407287597656,
-0.18919354677200317,
-0.07312550395727158,
0.00658408273011446,
0.3298032283782959,
-0.017198150977492332,
0.1778084933757782,
-1.2530407905578613,
-0.2495051473379135,
-0.20718508958816528,
-0.8276710510253906,
-0.034808285534381866,
-0.13079644739627838,
0.09962285310029984,
0.3723343312740326,
0.38840800523757935,
-0.8052115440368652,
0.562805712223053,
0.45359545946121216,
-0.19503912329673767,
0.9084523916244507,
-0.023951169103384018,
0.32756268978118896,
-0.7582570910453796,
-0.09015421569347382,
0.04941247031092644,
-0.6546458601951599,
-0.4156436622142792,
0.04747900366783142,
0.2601683735847473,
0.10962192714214325,
-0.5108933448791504,
0.7836732864379883,
-0.5483763217926025,
-0.15651224553585052,
-0.5381101369857788,
0.3710661232471466,
0.3277416229248047,
0.17873744666576385,
-0.11648877710103989,
0.7474336624145508,
0.05061529949307442,
-0.514539361000061,
0.620652973651886,
-0.04413630813360214,
-0.5723848342895508,
0.687734842300415,
-0.5466446876525879,
-0.001504153828136623,
-0.21419930458068848,
0.6710061430931091,
-0.792908251285553,
-0.4679480493068695,
0.06906571239233017,
-0.6244689226150513,
0.23157179355621338,
-0.1789342164993286,
-0.9240355491638184,
-0.47383928298950195,
-0.2809937000274658,
0.18214848637580872,
0.2004064917564392,
-1.0652164220809937,
0.82309490442276,
0.489043265581131,
0.2034054398536682,
-0.8746687173843384,
-0.4727320373058319,
0.4017552137374878,
-0.033053264021873474,
-0.5782697796821594,
0.4197990298271179,
0.1289028376340866,
-0.3014010488986969,
-0.05995875969529152,
-0.4127299189567566,
0.049318522214889526,
-0.19067388772964478,
-0.08181440830230713,
0.0879068598151207,
-0.12076114863157272,
0.18578319251537323,
-0.0419883206486702,
0.06336468458175659,
-0.05366379767656326,
-0.3005930781364441,
0.3340306878089905,
-0.011813875287771225,
-0.5913196206092834,
-0.5424122214317322,
0.3026304244995117,
0.7839345932006836,
-0.10032546520233154,
0.7768835425376892,
0.5901287198066711,
-0.7330782413482666,
-0.18494144082069397,
-1.2819920778274536,
-0.2867945730686188,
-0.465298056602478,
0.24979539215564728,
-0.38363611698150635,
-0.9250204563140869,
0.30116963386535645,
-0.2672111392021179,
-0.01813512295484543,
0.4727219343185425,
0.5315304398536682,
0.24035905301570892,
1.033705234527588,
0.4651450216770172,
-0.17464259266853333,
0.30244383215904236,
0.1483665555715561,
0.3418998420238495,
-0.4721761643886566,
-0.2802606523036957,
-0.2814886271953583,
0.034140076488256454,
-0.19450323283672333,
-0.48256316781044006,
0.33223333954811096,
0.16234725713729858,
-0.17735956609249115,
-0.03032851219177246,
-0.39507198333740234,
0.6035417318344116,
0.5196249485015869,
0.3527055084705353,
0.7125177383422852,
0.26222747564315796,
-0.08862518519163132,
0.001490534981712699,
-0.556784451007843,
-0.5280645489692688,
1.1841304302215576,
0.3818504214286804,
0.47702455520629883,
0.3889055550098419,
0.3972984850406647,
0.7370061874389648,
0.5895097851753235,
-0.5560259819030762,
0.4504731297492981,
0.015361730940639973,
-1.006166696548462,
-0.08073681592941284,
-0.5767505168914795,
-0.6148599982261658,
0.5261750221252441,
-0.22735998034477234,
-0.30966877937316895,
0.03848448395729065,
0.0720706358551979,
-0.31456562876701355,
0.4860555827617645,
-0.5127288103103638,
0.48010092973709106,
-0.4109365940093994,
-0.37776321172714233,
-0.48137539625167847,
-0.3869626224040985,
0.6815307140350342,
-0.2262861728668213,
0.45796120166778564,
-0.16444069147109985,
-0.11282341927289963,
0.3551037907600403,
-0.4045078158378601,
0.8054826259613037,
-0.18966852128505707,
-0.2535533905029297,
0.301039457321167,
0.13188062608242035,
0.8781570196151733,
0.2256520688533783,
-0.056770093739032745,
0.13909673690795898,
-0.15991561114788055,
-0.5070986151695251,
-0.48882970213890076,
0.8366480469703674,
-0.3659806251525879,
-0.7756839990615845,
-0.6128150820732117,
-0.2704276144504547,
-0.010930335149168968,
0.42439237236976624,
0.08930260688066483,
0.2473890483379364,
-0.30752238631248474,
0.19840571284294128,
0.8955828547477722,
-0.4418196380138397,
0.07378610968589783,
0.8077602386474609,
-0.5784851312637329,
-0.4394069314002991,
0.8464908003807068,
0.13064496219158173,
0.06147456169128418,
0.283530056476593,
0.1429985612630844,
-0.5987671613693237,
-0.4516655206680298,
-0.596770703792572,
0.2669273018836975,
-0.672413170337677,
-0.37278470396995544,
-0.6448766589164734,
-0.05392513424158096,
-0.5265294909477234,
0.19008679687976837,
-0.4805394113063812,
-0.23835700750350952,
-0.1126008927822113,
-0.16301004588603973,
0.3210699260234833,
0.566379725933075,
-0.3593292832374573,
0.11046411842107773,
-0.723903238773346,
0.8870012164115906,
0.35766515135765076,
0.3783692419528961,
-0.24029438197612762,
-0.6625476479530334,
-0.15025345981121063,
0.3200621008872986,
-0.16912183165550232,
-0.9767377972602844,
0.4619327783584595,
0.006683004088699818,
0.5949330925941467,
0.2533698081970215,
0.1820898950099945,
0.48493900895118713,
-0.5625103712081909,
0.7220039367675781,
0.08464441448450089,
-0.7989838719367981,
0.44730496406555176,
-0.43890735507011414,
-0.1675795018672943,
0.22149227559566498,
0.4111732244491577,
-0.4083824157714844,
0.09712041169404984,
-0.5321413278579712,
-0.6526884436607361,
0.4268265962600708,
-0.056642964482307434,
0.2126026451587677,
-0.09469282627105713,
0.6255192160606384,
0.06777805835008621,
0.3892272114753723,
-0.9427608847618103,
-0.06456276774406433,
-0.18283069133758545,
-0.15226776897907257,
0.2925430238246918,
-0.47206151485443115,
-0.23634189367294312,
-0.07458743453025818,
0.8595558404922485,
-0.26533764600753784,
0.22340501844882965,
0.39394286274909973,
-0.43395593762397766,
-0.15271106362342834,
0.1637870818376541,
0.639875590801239,
0.7296725511550903,
-0.0028791443910449743,
0.15155929327011108,
0.16315321624279022,
-0.24079976975917816,
0.17720961570739746,
0.060116447508335114,
-0.17315058410167694,
0.32858172059059143,
0.3111015856266022,
0.46790972352027893,
0.09194831550121307,
-0.7631754875183105,
0.7771770358085632,
0.10352201014757156,
-0.14468947052955627,
-0.7574480175971985,
-0.2685852646827698,
-0.023384680971503258,
0.30454519391059875,
1.004647135734558,
-0.16653743386268616,
0.23373456299304962,
-0.6602110862731934,
0.5292904376983643,
0.6075872182846069,
-0.051088426262140274,
-0.13339799642562866,
0.4912225902080536,
0.03893733024597168,
-0.2668606638908386,
0.5794627666473389,
-0.2627556025981903,
-0.7745170593261719,
0.3748614490032196,
0.4651571214199066,
0.3068014979362488,
-0.02404831536114216,
0.3158618211746216,
0.19251826405525208,
0.4889681041240692,
-0.6335514783859253,
0.15038269758224487,
0.40900248289108276,
-0.8313165903091431,
-0.7447214126586914,
-0.6638628244400024,
-0.17008167505264282,
0.40589672327041626,
-0.358159601688385,
0.2474559247493744,
-0.3307740390300751,
-0.13002707064151764,
-0.14006036520004272,
0.13531610369682312,
-0.3590386211872101,
0.20575562119483948,
0.31437891721725464,
1.0913419723510742,
-0.611447811126709,
0.6712433099746704,
0.2317694127559662,
-0.3247396945953369,
-0.3973475396633148,
0.07913010567426682,
0.5301023721694946,
-0.763421356678009,
0.5029879212379456,
0.375910222530365,
-0.04472717270255089,
-0.03441441059112549,
-0.8461095690727234,
-0.9120811223983765,
0.8322380781173706,
0.5580262541770935,
-0.6660593152046204,
-0.1513855755329132,
0.04806702211499214,
0.3183194398880005,
-0.36944779753685,
0.04745911434292793,
0.3956725299358368,
0.6368148326873779,
0.0987134575843811,
-0.7639765739440918,
0.11145035177469254,
0.011627255007624626,
-0.15388602018356323,
0.14464625716209412,
-0.6832282543182373,
0.7124537229537964,
-0.2823704183101654,
-0.19344158470630646,
-0.046182334423065186,
1.0308116674423218,
0.5162022113800049,
0.4848790466785431,
0.49351605772972107,
0.7907754778862,
0.846508264541626,
-0.1203937754034996,
1.0806729793548584,
-0.20702140033245087,
0.3765915036201477,
1.070319414138794,
-0.2823983132839203,
0.8868376016616821,
0.375450998544693,
-0.08395065367221832,
0.7937554121017456,
0.572176992893219,
-0.010286545380949974,
0.30217716097831726,
0.36588647961616516,
-0.34631672501564026,
-0.6180468797683716,
-0.1296595185995102,
-0.2126614898443222,
0.2666418254375458,
0.46433499455451965,
-0.3256991505622864,
-0.25944966077804565,
0.04254056513309479,
0.08206461369991302,
0.28756293654441833,
-0.3035186529159546,
0.2705003321170807,
0.040749602019786835,
-0.5194515585899353,
0.4862491488456726,
0.1635931134223938,
0.9359153509140015,
-0.36851629614830017,
-0.3129579722881317,
-0.18551674485206604,
0.19527389109134674,
-0.22951236367225647,
-0.4800417721271515,
0.15898758172988892,
-0.15082640945911407,
-0.44424140453338623,
-0.014553803019225597,
0.897794246673584,
-0.4593644440174103,
-0.49676504731178284,
0.14234395325183868,
0.6576796174049377,
-0.007237907964736223,
-0.5357969999313354,
-0.6946994662284851,
0.21951520442962646,
-0.07891536504030228,
-0.5085399746894836,
0.2733147144317627,
0.5165365934371948,
-0.0728326290845871,
0.833897590637207,
1.1378388404846191,
0.048821307718753815,
0.12215492874383926,
-0.12724490463733673,
0.7555025815963745,
-0.48510050773620605,
-0.22103796899318695,
-0.7352990508079529,
0.26747867465019226,
-0.4161872863769531,
0.1134415939450264,
0.7538542747497559,
0.7415024042129517,
0.7521392703056335,
0.10756208747625351,
0.8231387138366699,
0.10537520051002502,
0.9743063449859619,
-0.6584194302558899,
0.6552597284317017,
-0.8369880318641663,
0.31251639127731323,
0.14682364463806152,
-0.7873033881187439,
-0.3089591860771179,
0.5582288503646851,
-0.21733145415782928,
0.09503094106912613,
0.47156214714050293,
0.9315610527992249,
-0.1419973373413086,
-0.13057760894298553,
0.2861917018890381,
0.3767939507961273,
0.47906848788261414,
0.24901528656482697,
0.8063608407974243,
-0.5508841276168823,
0.7550223469734192,
0.20881423354148865,
-0.08095061033964157,
-0.5071325302124023,
-0.9968355298042297,
-0.644088625907898,
-0.35141125321388245,
-0.1960829794406891,
-0.7608537077903748,
0.225137397646904,
0.7935865521430969,
0.8630771636962891,
-0.6647886037826538,
0.24267306923866272,
0.06619010120630264,
0.2691967487335205,
0.0564165897667408,
-0.2722741961479187,
0.28939110040664673,
-0.20518259704113007,
-0.555925726890564,
0.7434820532798767,
0.0758938267827034,
-0.09997627139091492,
-0.4193652868270874,
-0.08208143711090088,
-0.6048005819320679,
0.3499462604522705,
0.6442916393280029,
0.3505896329879761,
-1.0370196104049683,
-0.49906793236732483,
-0.06610624492168427,
-0.19256222248077393,
-0.06730592250823975,
0.7861341238021851,
-1.1450985670089722,
0.33335381746292114,
0.36101463437080383,
0.605593204498291,
0.5080721974372864,
0.05668935924768448,
0.5535776019096375,
-0.7825318574905396,
0.014975816942751408,
0.08165629953145981,
0.3667472004890442,
0.4310537278652191,
-0.3857446610927582,
0.4165325462818146,
0.6090229749679565,
-0.42849284410476685,
-1.1604561805725098,
0.3077820837497711,
-0.6602410078048706,
-0.4865792393684387,
1.1937204599380493,
0.04119843244552612,
-0.11676790565252304,
-0.24777910113334656,
-0.03256611526012421,
0.25612515211105347,
-0.46606549620628357,
1.007791519165039,
0.8534944653511047,
0.37040406465530396,
-0.2694934010505676,
-0.7090290188789368,
0.4065171182155609,
0.15715324878692627,
-0.6554473638534546,
-0.0821148082613945,
0.9398762583732605,
0.522929310798645,
0.3435097634792328,
0.4827694892883301,
-0.17434391379356384,
0.2780228555202484,
-0.18356923758983612,
0.030548011884093285,
-0.12607143819332123,
-0.4718380570411682,
-0.07719141989946365,
0.34088173508644104,
-0.27855977416038513,
0.1541578769683838
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08994v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08994v2
|
Ethos: Rectifying Language Models in Orthogonal Parameter Space
| 2024-03-13T23:25:30 | 2024-04-01T05:45:47 |
Lei Gao, Yue Niu, Tingting Tang, Salman Avestimehr, Murali Annavaram
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Language models (LMs) have greatly propelled the research on natural language
processing. However, LMs also raise concerns regarding the generation of biased
or toxic content and the potential disclosure of private information from the
training dataset. In this work, we present a new efficient approach, Ethos,
that rectifies LMs to mitigate toxicity and bias in outputs and avoid privacy
leakage. Ethos is built on task arithmetic. However, unlike current task
arithmetic algorithms, Ethos distinguishes general beneficial and undesired
knowledge when reconstructing task vectors. Specifically, Ethos first obtains a
set of principal components from the pre-trained models using singular value
decomposition. Then, by projecting the task vector onto principal components,
Ethos identifies the principal components that encode general or undesired
knowledge. Ethos performs negating using the task vector with undesired
knowledge only, thereby minimizing collateral damage on general model utility.
We demonstrate the efficacy of our approach on three different tasks:
debiasing, detoxification, and memorization unlearning. Evaluations show Ethos
is more effective in removing undesired knowledge and maintaining the overall
model performance compared to current task arithmetic methods.
|
[
-0.07909704744815826,
-0.8012187480926514,
0.597601592540741,
0.0607365220785141,
-0.27137887477874756,
-0.02671780250966549,
-0.47928065061569214,
-0.3846242129802704,
-0.012945418246090412,
0.6337082386016846,
-0.15435361862182617,
-0.5884063839912415,
-0.7672226428985596,
-0.27427026629447937,
-0.1974875032901764,
1.0758661031723022,
0.045723795890808105,
-0.046652473509311676,
-0.05614864081144333,
-0.17490921914577484,
-0.16767849028110504,
-0.542738676071167,
-0.9823254942893982,
-0.27530550956726074,
0.32052111625671387,
0.5167766213417053,
0.5207807421684265,
0.7168755531311035,
0.14907456934452057,
0.3485908806324005,
-0.12034234404563904,
0.45971664786338806,
-0.922590434551239,
0.26765507459640503,
-0.32345402240753174,
-0.20377494394779205,
-0.4514513909816742,
-0.15532127022743225,
0.4751241207122803,
0.9405419826507568,
-0.3102208077907562,
0.28763338923454285,
0.4811755120754242,
0.6693071126937866,
-0.746018648147583,
0.4267355799674988,
-0.7202132940292358,
0.0693591758608818,
-0.12429337948560715,
-0.5583987236022949,
-0.668450653553009,
-0.5443673729896545,
-0.08192959427833557,
-0.6743835806846619,
0.1328892856836319,
0.14811305701732635,
0.5543567538261414,
0.2693175971508026,
-0.29988110065460205,
-0.1073649525642395,
-1.1562840938568115,
1.2155818939208984,
-0.5189903378486633,
0.4167732000350952,
0.5987297892570496,
0.3482315242290497,
0.04024719446897507,
-0.34709858894348145,
-0.506787121295929,
-0.0828707367181778,
0.07296089082956314,
-0.2598792612552643,
-0.18679195642471313,
0.08919142186641693,
-0.07151543349027634,
0.5002862811088562,
-0.2935561239719391,
0.06756734848022461,
-0.7359206080436707,
-0.32511278986930847,
0.40230512619018555,
0.17110677063465118,
0.3643895387649536,
-0.06474518775939941,
-0.32902956008911133,
-0.0819319412112236,
-0.9767986536026001,
0.08339786529541016,
0.46610572934150696,
0.243734210729599,
0.1425061970949173,
0.5342687964439392,
-0.07804126292467117,
0.5288090109825134,
0.06411648541688919,
-0.13898634910583496,
0.10605619102716446,
0.09507463127374649,
-0.4172120988368988,
-0.13216306269168854,
0.49291685223579407,
0.244794100522995,
0.11506476998329163,
-0.25885191559791565,
0.03477839380502701,
0.08589620143175125,
0.5432495474815369,
-0.6186094880104065,
-0.07918770611286163,
0.21533983945846558,
-0.42671215534210205,
-0.3570832312107086,
-0.320065438747406,
-0.6537183523178101,
-0.278280109167099,
-0.49361124634742737,
0.4247388541698456,
-0.6989478468894958,
-0.3105171024799347,
0.2680110037326813,
0.10767495632171631,
-0.2080926150083542,
0.4393000900745392,
-0.71138995885849,
0.5201056599617004,
0.9814982414245605,
0.39727914333343506,
0.012506196275353432,
0.06974996626377106,
-0.5175753235816956,
0.28019440174102783,
-0.12230212986469269,
0.3364264965057373,
-0.6995271444320679,
-0.20450359582901,
-0.005765740294009447,
-0.12529732286930084,
-0.04230445995926857,
-0.4468996822834015,
0.8795086145401001,
-0.5398697257041931,
0.44703638553619385,
-0.3069241940975189,
-0.6141372919082642,
-0.5363419651985168,
0.15556275844573975,
-0.5586399435997009,
0.956058144569397,
-0.11094837635755539,
-0.7245907187461853,
-0.03799140453338623,
-0.3839449882507324,
-0.24987024068832397,
-0.25699540972709656,
-0.2785455286502838,
-0.4301220178604126,
0.09226801246404648,
0.14923647046089172,
0.5039969086647034,
-0.2585259675979614,
0.33463549613952637,
-0.29810386896133423,
-0.19076752662658691,
-0.2714694142341614,
-0.3617094159126282,
0.8574951887130737,
0.5112205147743225,
-0.3024734854698181,
-0.02222614735364914,
-0.9047443270683289,
0.0717461034655571,
0.15696945786476135,
-0.4011472761631012,
-0.9086300134658813,
0.176205575466156,
-0.28483346104621887,
0.029207609593868256,
-0.024660294875502586,
-0.8415796160697937,
-0.2087840884923935,
-0.6063523292541504,
0.24512313306331635,
0.8785802721977234,
0.06703140586614609,
0.6817356944084167,
-0.27611419558525085,
0.38618743419647217,
0.015716560184955597,
0.050591565668582916,
0.03019522875547409,
-0.54356449842453,
-0.9077406525611877,
-0.2538089454174042,
-0.339736670255661,
0.26826563477516174,
-0.7725698947906494,
0.2837977409362793,
-0.2744142413139343,
-0.4788172245025635,
-0.44222337007522583,
0.056418463587760925,
0.7962050437927246,
0.6735355257987976,
0.30134639143943787,
-0.04505425691604614,
-0.42472854256629944,
-0.7320417165756226,
-0.5064528584480286,
-0.0634700283408165,
-0.205288827419281,
0.2425469160079956,
0.11946123838424683,
0.22887255251407623,
0.548862099647522,
-0.6008882522583008,
-0.37462007999420166,
-0.16349194943904877,
0.135486900806427,
0.11537548899650574,
0.4660972058773041,
0.46579739451408386,
-0.33298054337501526,
-0.44833916425704956,
0.0639195516705513,
-0.6172348856925964,
-0.2120792120695114,
0.2827084958553314,
-0.10287977755069733,
0.06986285746097565,
0.33675119280815125,
-0.3907721936702728,
0.15327121317386627,
0.35622328519821167,
-0.23527640104293823,
0.061143405735492706,
-0.3039270043373108,
0.1938118189573288,
-0.7969309091567993,
0.11533354967832565,
-0.12311774492263794,
-0.5103304386138916,
-0.8189724683761597,
0.3539080321788788,
0.017095087096095085,
-0.31568416953086853,
-0.44133520126342773,
0.29653167724609375,
-0.47754499316215515,
0.3170698583126068,
-0.33221450448036194,
-0.013393227010965347,
0.22425846755504608,
0.9461181163787842,
0.05701775103807449,
0.27086663246154785,
0.38497665524482727,
-0.8810714483261108,
-0.17191053926944733,
-0.025823041796684265,
0.17757004499435425,
0.6268770694732666,
-0.5493937730789185,
0.5461553931236267,
-0.6365333795547485,
-0.00006989125540712848,
-0.930735170841217,
0.27633604407310486,
0.6225292682647705,
-0.4153331220149994,
0.347637802362442,
-0.037670865654945374,
-0.13006822764873505,
0.059150565415620804,
-0.5648851990699768,
0.5992976427078247,
0.4602915644645691,
-0.4208545386791229,
0.6627007722854614,
0.8500147461891174,
-0.3382500112056732,
-0.6267199516296387,
-0.2743734121322632,
-0.3568590581417084,
-0.26477745175361633,
-0.3923725485801697,
0.4830786883831024,
0.2593861222267151,
-0.31686657667160034,
0.05256380885839462,
-0.02409014292061329,
-0.24901548027992249,
-0.10763338953256607,
0.34065839648246765,
0.023963522166013718,
0.0378519743680954,
0.1843186467885971,
0.28419753909111023,
-0.26187971234321594,
0.21077032387256622,
-0.3441391885280609,
0.553144097328186,
0.019914209842681885,
-0.40545013546943665,
-0.11363334208726883,
0.5850295424461365,
0.224853515625,
-0.17108364403247833,
0.8558722734451294,
0.31136995553970337,
-0.738616943359375,
-0.46203145384788513,
-0.36772245168685913,
-0.10614089667797089,
-0.4550354778766632,
0.46002331376075745,
-0.018796611577272415,
-0.7849719524383545,
0.286763072013855,
-0.051083702594041824,
0.49201324582099915,
0.46349966526031494,
0.5389626026153564,
0.09272094815969467,
0.721296489238739,
0.8094740509986877,
-0.21423590183258057,
0.009867335669696331,
-0.1452140361070633,
0.5120471715927124,
-0.5723901987075806,
-0.2544613182544708,
-0.8136122226715088,
-0.1435425877571106,
-0.13782577216625214,
-0.7081480622291565,
0.5045055150985718,
-0.09064871817827225,
-0.2915578782558441,
0.3767663836479187,
-0.6260067820549011,
0.4356567859649658,
0.3732999265193939,
0.39189082384109497,
0.6196555495262146,
0.1959916055202484,
-0.11175813525915146,
-0.3102931082248688,
-0.46790504455566406,
-0.6229177117347717,
1.3321582078933716,
0.7051810026168823,
0.6522634029388428,
0.26151496171951294,
0.6330623626708984,
0.22506234049797058,
0.35650303959846497,
-0.3353174030780792,
0.6297501921653748,
-0.1225438043475151,
-0.5731790065765381,
-0.4753943085670471,
-0.5149983167648315,
-0.6940717101097107,
0.46048176288604736,
0.04024069383740425,
-0.7313264608383179,
0.15698154270648956,
0.41092318296432495,
-0.44386082887649536,
0.5739690661430359,
-0.4411493241786957,
0.32479357719421387,
0.22743944823741913,
-0.4962781071662903,
-0.6958269476890564,
-0.31450462341308594,
0.3878748416900635,
0.10225618630647659,
0.44541409611701965,
-0.03122616931796074,
0.0924324318766594,
0.6573761701583862,
-0.5709877610206604,
1.0399785041809082,
-0.29415765404701233,
-0.4350126087665558,
0.12084513157606125,
0.22754022479057312,
0.6731062531471252,
-0.12106435000896454,
-0.17251694202423096,
0.264177531003952,
-0.19902253150939941,
-0.14189252257347107,
-0.3092786967754364,
0.7327345609664917,
-0.653268575668335,
-0.40942278504371643,
-0.28519347310066223,
-0.451241135597229,
-0.29148247838020325,
0.09824199229478836,
0.3485828638076782,
0.38130810856819153,
-0.23672854900360107,
0.000875145080499351,
0.85448157787323,
-0.6969195604324341,
0.0957239493727684,
0.7163717150688171,
-0.2451792061328888,
-0.3094547688961029,
0.959961473941803,
-0.11084391921758652,
0.34646615386009216,
0.4452567994594574,
0.056767791509628296,
-0.12502285838127136,
-0.3524429500102997,
-0.1395110934972763,
-0.004519538953900337,
-0.8940277695655823,
-0.1975678652524948,
-0.8539162278175354,
-0.20148320496082306,
-0.21389606595039368,
0.1397916078567505,
-0.5905704498291016,
-0.6992413401603699,
0.02838265523314476,
-0.3565906882286072,
0.23279236257076263,
0.5976004600524902,
-0.17204131186008453,
0.10705316066741943,
-0.6419200301170349,
0.5674651861190796,
0.18296700716018677,
0.31143978238105774,
0.20086543262004852,
-0.6208713054656982,
-0.02647610381245613,
0.09381207078695297,
-0.5339467525482178,
-0.983320415019989,
0.5368698835372925,
0.4445347189903259,
0.47618377208709717,
0.4709123373031616,
0.2957150936126709,
0.5326375961303711,
-0.6938002109527588,
0.4124610126018524,
0.01422420796006918,
-0.8946487903594971,
0.2372673749923706,
-0.31129658222198486,
-0.3245633542537689,
0.4595187306404114,
0.3699435591697693,
-0.48483702540397644,
-0.8828324675559998,
-0.476199746131897,
-1.0697516202926636,
0.7494850754737854,
0.39379870891571045,
0.2873282730579376,
-0.05563126876950264,
0.1733182817697525,
0.3976747691631317,
0.44245076179504395,
-0.734487771987915,
-0.5225036144256592,
0.08488577604293823,
-0.21701842546463013,
0.2760644257068634,
-0.5040817856788635,
-0.0893627479672432,
-0.4150655269622803,
0.82126384973526,
0.36648932099342346,
0.38890349864959717,
0.009275225922465324,
-0.31068938970565796,
-0.3768627941608429,
0.46448543667793274,
0.3293355405330658,
0.4956822693347931,
-0.1282506138086319,
0.4143541157245636,
-0.043163180351257324,
-0.3641293942928314,
0.12132996320724487,
0.01318111177533865,
-0.18626509606838226,
0.13223803043365479,
0.06154046207666397,
0.5205807089805603,
0.45779410004615784,
-0.2367975264787674,
0.3988697826862335,
0.16644571721553802,
0.020756559446454048,
-0.3853019177913666,
0.04149318486452103,
0.014492406509816647,
-0.09234114736318588,
0.20360368490219116,
0.24542392790317535,
0.47159379720687866,
-0.5357699990272522,
0.13789133727550507,
0.1266138106584549,
-0.15317101776599884,
-0.3156638443470001,
0.8636103272438049,
0.47973671555519104,
-0.11712680757045746,
0.24505390226840973,
-0.15357226133346558,
-0.44190341234207153,
0.29284390807151794,
0.4099270701408386,
0.7112628817558289,
-0.5386538505554199,
0.25669312477111816,
0.4672374725341797,
0.29389670491218567,
0.13720151782035828,
0.5755382180213928,
-0.12268537282943726,
-0.7836814522743225,
-0.3920482397079468,
-0.5340678691864014,
-0.21728944778442383,
0.23690077662467957,
-0.7239934206008911,
-0.1821078658103943,
-0.6833709478378296,
0.03102654404938221,
0.017609555274248123,
-0.4390120804309845,
-0.7346403002738953,
0.013433595187962055,
0.1250164955854416,
0.4907900393009186,
-0.9025465846061707,
0.7800197005271912,
0.3578881621360779,
-0.19743265211582184,
-0.9477230906486511,
-0.20341332256793976,
0.13776370882987976,
-0.9568892121315002,
0.5718134641647339,
0.09942331910133362,
-0.19534163177013397,
-0.028627144172787666,
-0.14909330010414124,
-0.5347903966903687,
0.5435869097709656,
0.7606008648872375,
-0.6790995597839355,
0.3101029694080353,
0.6467632055282593,
0.465676486492157,
0.08126034587621689,
0.16297152638435364,
0.2096589356660843,
0.32791316509246826,
-0.34251365065574646,
-0.9342318773269653,
0.2590879499912262,
-0.5020312070846558,
-0.01570769026875496,
0.27518218755722046,
-0.17565982043743134,
0.9766585230827332,
-0.1225924864411354,
-0.3565995395183563,
-0.2611454427242279,
0.4648914039134979,
0.302832692861557,
0.18039673566818237,
0.6720349192619324,
0.6588120460510254,
0.8443647027015686,
0.03399357572197914,
0.8416197896003723,
-0.281385600566864,
0.42455437779426575,
1.002977967262268,
-0.24200880527496338,
0.6593208909034729,
0.6496646404266357,
-0.24286328256130219,
0.2402980923652649,
0.08747191727161407,
0.7118034958839417,
0.7631853818893433,
0.22560258209705353,
-0.32024314999580383,
-0.1440230756998062,
-0.07998289167881012,
-0.46233370900154114,
0.15181124210357666,
0.14657966792583466,
-0.6119887828826904,
-0.5970251560211182,
0.10407112538814545,
0.5455465912818909,
0.5493510365486145,
-0.3857402205467224,
0.5700302720069885,
0.3571942150592804,
-0.7059396505355835,
0.5282266736030579,
0.5045167803764343,
0.40655407309532166,
-0.5173259973526001,
-0.26822441816329956,
-0.06642291694879532,
0.6319829821586609,
-0.08051935583353043,
-0.4714619517326355,
0.7693345546722412,
0.06151001900434494,
-0.12836167216300964,
-0.5938196778297424,
0.9072305560112,
-0.6895425915718079,
-0.4562358558177948,
0.3124687373638153,
0.25971880555152893,
-0.034967534244060516,
-0.48356300592422485,
-0.32769352197647095,
-0.05527776852250099,
0.013020247220993042,
-0.09515541791915894,
0.24156934022903442,
0.4766583740711212,
0.0733695849776268,
0.5493822693824768,
0.5283089876174927,
0.00033848543534986675,
0.024189502000808716,
-0.016450533643364906,
1.001914381980896,
-0.46414172649383545,
-0.7051172256469727,
-0.8558853268623352,
0.5043264031410217,
-0.19934730231761932,
-0.12663006782531738,
0.8271322250366211,
0.31403452157974243,
0.6937760710716248,
-0.15516413748264313,
0.7103443145751953,
0.11779554188251495,
0.8432063460350037,
-0.45020028948783875,
0.6648501753807068,
-0.2536439895629883,
0.6923778057098389,
-0.23351867496967316,
-0.6726323366165161,
-0.09133165329694748,
0.6036335825920105,
-0.26232820749282837,
-0.1456655114889145,
0.6330050230026245,
0.5914590358734131,
-0.17495615780353546,
0.2293817549943924,
0.07613856345415115,
0.1659088283777237,
0.31452834606170654,
0.8534501791000366,
0.6498545408248901,
-0.2966265082359314,
0.3828355371952057,
-0.5147503018379211,
-0.27235567569732666,
-0.04710310697555542,
-0.8563210964202881,
-0.6486153602600098,
-0.40802380442619324,
-0.22133027017116547,
-0.0645088478922844,
0.27820783853530884,
0.8332862854003906,
0.6712048053741455,
-0.9347676634788513,
0.0314653217792511,
-0.02591397613286972,
0.12480157613754272,
-0.4444596767425537,
-0.2115485966205597,
0.4311756193637848,
-0.10828229784965515,
-0.7311189770698547,
0.2874377965927124,
0.38538578152656555,
-0.6898018717765808,
-0.355915904045105,
-0.19718074798583984,
0.3578167259693146,
0.07602348178625107,
0.6606632471084595,
0.2878476083278656,
-0.4224502742290497,
-0.4136481285095215,
-0.1650523841381073,
-0.1693345308303833,
-0.04985662177205086,
0.7014197707176208,
-0.5368008613586426,
0.22217842936515808,
0.5839053988456726,
0.685465395450592,
0.06459056586027145,
-0.22540846467018127,
1.0128804445266724,
-1.0112258195877075,
0.3549674451351166,
0.32119283080101013,
0.5118046402931213,
0.202196404337883,
-0.7084041833877563,
0.3649132549762726,
-0.15899987518787384,
-0.3770720660686493,
-0.7488892674446106,
0.179407000541687,
-0.8022907972335815,
-0.25389373302459717,
1.1486897468566895,
-0.3838966488838196,
-0.2199108600616455,
-0.441226065158844,
-0.22371956706047058,
0.3032233417034149,
-0.3536476492881775,
1.0046566724777222,
0.20237916707992554,
0.35821297764778137,
0.12630467116832733,
-0.592755913734436,
0.46449387073516846,
0.5451120138168335,
-0.7543671727180481,
0.1504463255405426,
0.5701788663864136,
0.4463772177696228,
-0.020852437242865562,
0.9454143047332764,
-0.4991268217563629,
0.025487396866083145,
-0.43796759843826294,
0.10901056975126266,
-0.38656085729599,
-0.3610858619213104,
-0.14246611297130585,
0.3921838104724884,
0.015733182430267334,
-0.5168090462684631
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09744v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09744v1
|
Evaluating the Application of Large Language Models to Generate Feedback in Programming Education
| 2024-03-13T23:14:35 | 2024-03-13T23:14:35 |
Sven Jacobs, Steffen Jaschke
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.HC
|
This study investigates the application of large language models,
specifically GPT-4, to enhance programming education. The research outlines the
design of a web application that uses GPT-4 to provide feedback on programming
tasks, without giving away the solution. A web application for working on
programming tasks was developed for the study and evaluated with 51 students
over the course of one semester. The results show that most of the feedback
generated by GPT-4 effectively addressed code errors. However, challenges with
incorrect suggestions and hallucinated issues indicate the need for further
improvements.
|
[
-0.32329607009887695,
-0.7321835160255432,
0.6684291362762451,
0.43809542059898376,
0.0791003629565239,
0.12049827724695206,
-0.336763858795166,
-0.40364348888397217,
-0.18133936822414398,
0.1046125590801239,
-0.32891976833343506,
-0.5003944039344788,
-0.34222903847694397,
0.14837300777435303,
-0.4692099690437317,
1.1793681383132935,
-0.09025919437408447,
0.31136026978492737,
0.08860336244106293,
0.47934696078300476,
-0.7323976755142212,
-0.7307425141334534,
-0.8987686038017273,
-0.11933678388595581,
0.3409057557582855,
0.4064405858516693,
0.5259401798248291,
-0.010486542247235775,
0.7700138092041016,
0.3355344831943512,
0.6047510504722595,
-0.5300528407096863,
-0.5281658172607422,
-0.29180437326431274,
-0.5186355113983154,
-0.36566340923309326,
-0.5852790474891663,
0.0941154882311821,
0.5112539529800415,
0.7379232048988342,
-0.3847269117832184,
0.18706394731998444,
0.15350845456123352,
0.6176287531852722,
-0.3202039897441864,
0.49049338698387146,
-0.08732446283102036,
0.02517213299870491,
-0.1684563010931015,
-0.1611539125442505,
-0.3755963444709778,
-0.7005583047866821,
0.2778257131576538,
-0.4616055488586426,
0.21154101192951202,
-0.37251096963882446,
0.5047367215156555,
0.001993168145418167,
-0.20124037563800812,
-0.6906504034996033,
-0.7672955989837646,
0.8252120018005371,
-0.9780160188674927,
0.4611099064350128,
0.5100563764572144,
0.29202601313591003,
-0.09193036705255508,
-0.5187108516693115,
-0.5449756383895874,
-0.45609086751937866,
0.3473059833049774,
0.24837042391300201,
0.0030540593434125185,
0.23420658707618713,
0.42986077070236206,
0.43005695939064026,
-0.7392011284828186,
-0.013703912496566772,
-0.6382510662078857,
-0.11528980731964111,
0.4619029462337494,
0.08303826302289963,
0.5125674605369568,
0.1467774361371994,
0.16581329703330994,
0.08040300011634827,
-0.6435087323188782,
-0.19655731320381165,
0.5850449204444885,
0.20595203340053558,
0.016324132680892944,
0.5040596127510071,
-0.09462148696184158,
0.9114124774932861,
-0.1908288151025772,
-0.12658360600471497,
0.3020491600036621,
-0.23219957947731018,
-0.21868446469306946,
-0.5432056188583374,
0.5148104429244995,
0.5435557961463928,
0.25559505820274353,
-0.21878555417060852,
-0.3695995509624481,
0.3705809712409973,
0.45823153853416443,
-0.8543148040771484,
-0.5027433037757874,
0.17320777475833893,
-0.4051394462585449,
-0.23581574857234955,
0.03613172471523285,
-0.9779834747314453,
-0.1921846866607666,
-0.41861334443092346,
0.4343068599700928,
-0.31207919120788574,
-0.42123088240623474,
0.10214877873659134,
-0.31827250123023987,
0.14999008178710938,
0.5549524426460266,
-1.1653584241867065,
0.39189833402633667,
0.608851432800293,
0.8851699233055115,
-0.2607840895652771,
-0.330858439207077,
-0.1858125776052475,
0.0618392676115036,
-0.25142720341682434,
0.5384092926979065,
-0.8988710045814514,
-0.49434971809387207,
0.13103504478931427,
-0.19169694185256958,
0.18221049010753632,
-0.3233170807361603,
0.262052983045578,
-0.4287430942058563,
0.22148007154464722,
-0.06144878640770912,
-0.7593128681182861,
-0.07779266685247421,
0.4749107360839844,
-0.5087141990661621,
0.6743845343589783,
0.6457046270370483,
-0.49985581636428833,
0.06038434058427811,
-1.0512027740478516,
-0.159415140748024,
0.3529348075389862,
-0.25611335039138794,
-0.16540271043777466,
0.18288850784301758,
0.07040725648403168,
0.16451312601566315,
-0.05569535866379738,
0.13294702768325806,
-0.16856080293655396,
-0.569706380367279,
0.03787664696574211,
-0.15425048768520355,
0.46070596575737,
0.09292259067296982,
-0.78532475233078,
0.19346857070922852,
-0.5125123858451843,
0.4669138789176941,
0.04476311057806015,
-0.8166696429252625,
-0.07421904802322388,
-0.3027646243572235,
0.07677970081567764,
0.04157187044620514,
0.14939254522323608,
-0.46903377771377563,
0.6969152688980103,
-0.19142982363700867,
0.4760628044605255,
0.7121260166168213,
0.011931085027754307,
0.29564884305000305,
-0.015713199973106384,
1.1102755069732666,
-0.35954827070236206,
0.1284061074256897,
0.15119002759456635,
-0.49282750487327576,
-0.5805582404136658,
0.28268399834632874,
0.2613966763019562,
0.3059272766113281,
-0.986716091632843,
-0.2416713833808899,
0.010930889286100864,
-0.41329479217529297,
-0.08390549570322037,
0.35479936003685,
0.462114155292511,
-0.04354904964566231,
0.17758287489414215,
-0.5250625610351562,
-0.618854284286499,
-0.5298103094100952,
-0.1371028870344162,
-0.08499143272638321,
-0.2268989384174347,
0.1135651245713234,
0.5578583478927612,
-0.5972903370857239,
0.6078271865844727,
-0.6133943200111389,
0.05082719027996063,
-0.3916460871696472,
0.14961740374565125,
0.19111844897270203,
0.5384456515312195,
0.6685208678245544,
-0.37433376908302307,
-0.6215406060218811,
-0.12075921148061752,
-0.5476056337356567,
-0.1588350087404251,
0.14382855594158173,
0.017899038270115852,
0.03914943337440491,
-0.09095495194196701,
-0.4704867899417877,
0.31835633516311646,
0.9675222635269165,
-0.2277972549200058,
0.8167684674263,
-0.1553785502910614,
0.25931838154792786,
-0.6339470148086548,
-0.036709535866975784,
0.08302503079175949,
-0.19530199468135834,
-0.3345089852809906,
0.239872545003891,
0.06527648866176605,
-0.6220863461494446,
0.12449932843446732,
0.16080252826213837,
-0.5753644704818726,
-0.08755369484424591,
-0.5825416445732117,
0.24652332067489624,
-0.17613911628723145,
0.28043192625045776,
-0.059806566685438156,
0.8867358565330505,
0.42276865243911743,
-0.33826449513435364,
0.6214199066162109,
-0.08459550142288208,
-0.16908718645572662,
0.4352635145187378,
-0.5754349827766418,
0.6060416102409363,
0.27580496668815613,
0.29583626985549927,
-0.7146867513656616,
-0.5395765900611877,
-0.04037005454301834,
-0.4950571060180664,
0.3364846706390381,
-0.20972971618175507,
-0.1325792819261551,
-1.1027624607086182,
-0.4667191207408905,
0.08726390451192856,
0.35621878504753113,
-0.34981298446655273,
0.13194014132022858,
0.3898310959339142,
-0.3057501018047333,
-0.3645625710487366,
-0.3679542541503906,
0.10991498082876205,
0.09921766817569733,
-0.382145494222641,
-0.16474466025829315,
-0.34222307801246643,
-0.15017744898796082,
0.03086134046316147,
-0.09311113506555557,
-0.33179953694343567,
-0.10868001729249954,
0.1975444257259369,
0.24180088937282562,
-0.27847060561180115,
0.12868739664554596,
-0.39683443307876587,
0.14382092654705048,
0.21209876239299774,
-0.5612514615058899,
0.6155482530593872,
-0.46001771092414856,
-0.462047278881073,
-0.6306330561637878,
0.4019261598587036,
0.43765389919281006,
0.028667638078331947,
0.3150757849216461,
0.40931931138038635,
-0.22335557639598846,
-0.31756892800331116,
-0.6088013648986816,
-0.24916483461856842,
-0.47931358218193054,
0.5402610898017883,
-0.3400794267654419,
-1.0299952030181885,
0.07982829213142395,
-0.22282391786575317,
0.024416988715529442,
0.020014887675642967,
0.7287721037864685,
0.164327472448349,
1.1919912099838257,
0.8732504844665527,
-0.23043282330036163,
0.6973028779029846,
-0.4156247079372406,
0.4559630751609802,
-0.6456180810928345,
-0.004598489962518215,
-0.572832465171814,
0.03421376645565033,
-0.2165927141904831,
-0.4027045667171478,
-0.10192000865936279,
0.0909544974565506,
-0.36097458004951477,
0.23007841408252716,
-0.689487874507904,
0.6694002747535706,
0.6259276270866394,
0.06126650422811508,
-0.03165397047996521,
-0.2583405077457428,
0.06521480530500412,
-0.003342814277857542,
-0.42782774567604065,
-0.5055737495422363,
1.265075922012329,
0.30914056301116943,
0.9675053358078003,
0.5486533045768738,
0.6151711344718933,
0.33554622530937195,
0.7091236114501953,
-0.7493104338645935,
0.3630060851573944,
0.19001169502735138,
-0.6622080206871033,
-0.4556429386138916,
-0.6238946318626404,
-0.664505124092102,
0.12214011698961258,
0.23343275487422943,
-0.894934356212616,
-0.3928379714488983,
0.35912251472473145,
-0.3446153402328491,
-0.007400963455438614,
-1.2917555570602417,
0.9920406937599182,
-0.3216109871864319,
-0.5580431222915649,
-0.377636194229126,
-0.21181175112724304,
0.3885782063007355,
-0.22247031331062317,
0.27409040927886963,
0.2734698951244354,
0.5050901770591736,
0.7702956795692444,
-0.7397769093513489,
0.9646963477134705,
-0.5500054359436035,
-0.32645183801651,
0.4397568702697754,
0.11343968659639359,
0.48626449704170227,
0.10058024525642395,
-0.14315888285636902,
-0.13217571377754211,
0.013552126474678516,
-0.3463383913040161,
-0.808824896812439,
1.115983486175537,
-0.8285819292068481,
-0.8674221634864807,
-0.43677517771720886,
-0.639588475227356,
-0.425245076417923,
0.29310092329978943,
-0.17800462245941162,
0.5464980006217957,
0.15429528057575226,
0.029071230441331863,
0.14495006203651428,
-0.3427312672138214,
0.4590500593185425,
0.6439079642295837,
-0.6416196823120117,
-0.25524985790252686,
0.9423136115074158,
0.0035520181991159916,
0.3154338598251343,
-0.11055860668420792,
0.32456231117248535,
-0.25726211071014404,
-0.6351544260978699,
-0.7504910230636597,
0.13031239807605743,
-0.8191325068473816,
-0.1599659025669098,
-0.21851195394992828,
0.03159422054886818,
-0.589765191078186,
-0.24789702892303467,
-0.22313737869262695,
-0.348411500453949,
0.3156015872955322,
-0.22735433280467987,
0.031263694167137146,
1.4613075256347656,
0.08256247639656067,
0.395087331533432,
-0.8243846893310547,
-0.06645813584327698,
0.3337356448173523,
0.733300507068634,
0.29127591848373413,
-0.17622889578342438,
-0.4197097718715668,
0.005233085248619318,
-0.6522057056427002,
-1.0700101852416992,
0.1801747828722,
0.007711315527558327,
0.4915061891078949,
0.23351402580738068,
-0.4827014207839966,
0.5177773833274841,
-0.47732776403427124,
1.1978585720062256,
0.44528263807296753,
-1.32445228099823,
0.7735852599143982,
-0.6980545520782471,
0.7475765943527222,
0.18785226345062256,
0.42774125933647156,
-0.3837474286556244,
-0.45928388833999634,
-0.28963756561279297,
-0.5619773268699646,
0.6101182699203491,
0.1372096836566925,
0.29704931378364563,
-0.08064333349466324,
0.4137411117553711,
0.04475805163383484,
0.3309577405452728,
-1.1052820682525635,
0.2483324557542801,
-0.555447518825531,
-0.11943439394235611,
0.2550497353076935,
-0.3481403887271881,
0.15317878127098083,
-0.3651929795742035,
0.7579439282417297,
-0.1380690336227417,
0.3639456033706665,
-0.3222508430480957,
0.09335561841726303,
-0.09458944201469421,
0.39514532685279846,
0.729711651802063,
1.3662666082382202,
0.04801551252603531,
0.07019005715847015,
-0.053199902176856995,
-0.8312466740608215,
-0.03099244087934494,
-0.2283220738172531,
0.09896772354841232,
-0.14518959820270538,
0.17908354103565216,
0.43568018078804016,
0.11785483360290527,
-0.6586523652076721,
0.6752234101295471,
-0.1626129001379013,
-0.004766605794429779,
-0.22211959958076477,
0.08726824074983597,
0.15165895223617554,
0.12997829914093018,
0.21916349232196808,
-0.3335448205471039,
0.4887810945510864,
-0.7616806626319885,
0.07613784074783325,
0.3006209135055542,
-0.21562756597995758,
-0.5228019952774048,
0.5526337623596191,
0.5103253126144409,
-0.2961318790912628,
0.7978396415710449,
-0.2383863776922226,
-0.8676903247833252,
0.4854886531829834,
1.19268000125885,
0.5237575173377991,
-0.5831901431083679,
0.3159324824810028,
0.5769343972206116,
0.14868752658367157,
-0.15268142521381378,
0.43071624636650085,
0.02501758188009262,
-0.22622184455394745,
-0.7823672294616699,
-0.721307635307312,
-0.6922756433486938,
0.22821933031082153,
-0.41351455450057983,
0.19568684697151184,
-0.5627288818359375,
-0.38069799542427063,
-0.08019247651100159,
-0.10793592780828476,
-0.6809470653533936,
0.259346604347229,
0.010513353161513805,
0.4054674506187439,
-0.633704423904419,
1.087368369102478,
0.9277106523513794,
-0.8640192151069641,
-1.4622892141342163,
-0.06584666669368744,
0.15227043628692627,
-0.3992939889431,
0.8982753753662109,
0.1977226883172989,
-0.1791607290506363,
0.1179124265909195,
-0.5432690382003784,
-0.8578339219093323,
0.4432801604270935,
0.238327756524086,
-0.7273736596107483,
-0.052640799432992935,
0.12371459603309631,
0.67597895860672,
0.02773483470082283,
0.457063227891922,
0.43479225039482117,
0.4587980806827545,
-0.10616236180067062,
-1.3061429262161255,
-0.13592568039894104,
-0.4713030755519867,
0.19890691339969635,
0.38796406984329224,
-0.44995248317718506,
0.8836047053337097,
-0.22574594616889954,
0.022876117378473282,
-0.04499540105462074,
0.3428194224834442,
-0.09542251378297806,
-0.060419902205467224,
0.19563773274421692,
0.4447488784790039,
0.8608777523040771,
-0.06835267692804337,
1.2380744218826294,
-0.2451404631137848,
0.8082225322723389,
1.162784218788147,
-0.2646638751029968,
0.7130753993988037,
0.34783586859703064,
-0.5675428509712219,
0.526273250579834,
0.40922823548316956,
-0.114456906914711,
0.32302069664001465,
0.7088143825531006,
-0.28221869468688965,
0.23422209918498993,
0.38019365072250366,
-0.5526139140129089,
0.25026801228523254,
0.4060267508029938,
-0.07704225927591324,
-0.11613140255212784,
0.3344916105270386,
0.09938881546258926,
-0.04400855675339699,
-0.4515317976474762,
0.38220474123954773,
0.07274916023015976,
-0.7488241791725159,
0.4706445038318634,
0.09257783740758896,
0.5132612586021423,
-0.5171092748641968,
-0.4623631238937378,
-0.18764252960681915,
0.6061175465583801,
-0.5246047973632812,
-0.7038494944572449,
0.32410380244255066,
0.35759180784225464,
-0.1716378927230835,
-0.07680521160364151,
0.3374861478805542,
-0.2518918812274933,
-0.3906789720058441,
0.23893575370311737,
0.16682112216949463,
0.30873793363571167,
0.10351280122995377,
-0.5056537985801697,
0.3989788889884949,
0.1815083622932434,
-0.25249627232551575,
0.2612004578113556,
0.31937164068222046,
-0.07447462528944016,
0.5393903851509094,
0.5772557854652405,
0.18456748127937317,
0.1848955899477005,
0.520211935043335,
0.8304436206817627,
-0.4887016713619232,
-0.4403165280818939,
-0.7967321276664734,
0.05839924514293671,
-0.2710725963115692,
-0.13258299231529236,
1.2939293384552002,
0.7241095900535583,
1.0226421356201172,
-0.4695453941822052,
1.2701478004455566,
-0.37155818939208984,
0.47917893528938293,
-0.3050510883331299,
0.4059423804283142,
-0.01863950863480568,
0.29976075887680054,
-0.7018799185752869,
-1.3207519054412842,
-0.4523426592350006,
0.8749035000801086,
-0.7035443186759949,
0.4201566278934479,
0.9605323076248169,
0.42521005868911743,
0.08766649663448334,
0.2553030252456665,
0.3586915135383606,
0.1291479915380478,
0.7284467220306396,
0.6254480481147766,
0.9606830477714539,
-0.018443306908011436,
0.31625643372535706,
-0.17467474937438965,
-0.5334513187408447,
-0.23582176864147186,
-0.5092481970787048,
-1.0474976301193237,
-0.23189318180084229,
-0.26995766162872314,
-0.4631800353527069,
0.3281799554824829,
0.7168754935264587,
0.6226553320884705,
-0.884478747844696,
-0.38695916533470154,
-0.19479277729988098,
-0.3353595435619354,
-0.11425371468067169,
-0.25998881459236145,
0.33113253116607666,
-0.5166255235671997,
-0.8065643310546875,
0.3680143654346466,
0.1779472529888153,
-0.15114924311637878,
-0.577539324760437,
-0.04145815968513489,
0.11178142577409744,
-0.22618524730205536,
0.7864724397659302,
0.11739905178546906,
-0.5161750912666321,
-0.693246066570282,
-0.14582447707653046,
-0.039283160120248795,
-0.15578697621822357,
1.0836801528930664,
-0.3589628338813782,
0.5338205099105835,
0.29339322447776794,
0.7628600001335144,
0.5524792075157166,
0.048435479402542114,
0.8387593626976013,
-0.4485011696815491,
0.06751418113708496,
0.1640123575925827,
0.32623806595802307,
0.43363314867019653,
-0.43950456380844116,
0.7715211510658264,
0.20293466746807098,
-0.9366671442985535,
-0.4478064477443695,
0.0167206060141325,
-0.6617947220802307,
-0.16813133656978607,
1.1315151453018188,
-0.40884873270988464,
0.09179452806711197,
-0.19506525993347168,
-0.45192044973373413,
-0.06170579046010971,
-0.38729745149612427,
0.8943820595741272,
1.0562188625335693,
-0.4374625086784363,
-0.12184197455644608,
-1.1369340419769287,
0.37501323223114014,
0.09608756750822067,
-1.0153539180755615,
-0.16764825582504272,
0.8975390791893005,
0.5823328495025635,
0.11860967427492142,
0.8733192086219788,
-0.15034633874893188,
0.3729866147041321,
0.22370976209640503,
0.3583049178123474,
0.23427966237068176,
-0.17860202491283417,
-0.1405862718820572,
0.2803371846675873,
0.5425724983215332,
0.1274707019329071
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08978v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08978v1
|
AutoGuide: Automated Generation and Selection of State-Aware Guidelines for Large Language Model Agents
| 2024-03-13T22:06:03 | 2024-03-13T22:06:03 |
Yao Fu, Dong-Ki Kim, Jaekyeom Kim, Sungryull Sohn, Lajanugen Logeswaran, Kyunghoon Bae, Honglak Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The primary limitation of large language models (LLMs) is their restricted
understanding of the world. This poses significant difficulties for LLM-based
agents, particularly in domains where pre-trained LLMs lack sufficient
knowledge. In this paper, we introduce a novel framework, called AutoGuide,
that bridges the knowledge gap in pre-trained LLMs by leveraging implicit
knowledge in offline experiences. Specifically, AutoGuide effectively extracts
knowledge embedded in offline data by extracting a set of state-aware
guidelines. Importantly, each state-aware guideline is expressed in concise
natural language and follows a conditional structure, clearly describing the
state where it is applicable. As such, the resulting guidelines enable a
principled way to provide helpful knowledge pertinent to an agent's current
decision-making process. We show that our approach outperforms competitive
LLM-based baselines by a large margin in sequential decision-making benchmarks.
|
[
-0.5534695982933044,
-0.5253989100456238,
0.8603376150131226,
-0.1570269763469696,
-0.023271795362234116,
-0.08434304594993591,
-0.1304367035627365,
-0.2734624445438385,
0.03408462926745415,
0.36868205666542053,
-0.7092215418815613,
-0.4174180030822754,
-0.3633011281490326,
0.19819270074367523,
-0.2832454442977905,
0.9027351140975952,
-0.26952818036079407,
-0.09622172266244888,
-0.35826918482780457,
0.2350902110338211,
-0.3166913390159607,
-0.11180056631565094,
-0.6570728421211243,
-0.5009461641311646,
0.3848317861557007,
0.2953045070171356,
0.6091907620429993,
0.756118893623352,
0.07940278202295303,
0.35098519921302795,
0.18525780737400055,
0.5001482963562012,
-0.400935560464859,
0.3233884274959564,
-0.4072401523590088,
-0.42857760190963745,
-0.5549402236938477,
-0.0510222427546978,
0.4720931947231293,
0.4418434202671051,
-0.21568453311920166,
0.06815776973962784,
0.17742952704429626,
0.49334684014320374,
-0.6922077536582947,
0.5013259649276733,
-0.6779807806015015,
0.11428913474082947,
-0.0022042719647288322,
-0.30965107679367065,
-0.25107067823410034,
-0.500998318195343,
0.469296932220459,
-1.0827748775482178,
0.028217215090990067,
0.25751006603240967,
0.8827545642852783,
0.7904623746871948,
-0.4804977476596832,
-0.41490206122398376,
-0.7056263089179993,
0.2836911082267761,
-0.4748999774456024,
0.4196995198726654,
0.5348562598228455,
0.5997763276100159,
-0.3844543695449829,
-0.7434304356575012,
-0.601256787776947,
-0.0802340880036354,
-0.2571902871131897,
0.050484396517276764,
-0.18856655061244965,
0.24247156083583832,
0.1339474618434906,
0.13884413242340088,
-0.46453914046287537,
0.007856559939682484,
-0.10363882035017014,
-0.1477348804473877,
0.4878181517124176,
0.0639253556728363,
0.09847790002822876,
-0.12223881483078003,
-0.16883805394172668,
0.07589306682348251,
-0.863582968711853,
-0.1153508722782135,
0.24155673384666443,
0.04945795610547066,
0.07251199334859848,
0.30776023864746094,
-0.21858441829681396,
0.8735986351966858,
0.45755016803741455,
-0.3538340926170349,
-0.01223006658256054,
-0.32787224650382996,
-0.30140140652656555,
0.14449304342269897,
0.5493673086166382,
0.3277519643306732,
0.2875065505504608,
-0.24529097974300385,
-0.33448904752731323,
-0.2567727565765381,
0.13573653995990753,
-0.7359495759010315,
-0.24635548889636993,
-0.07767102122306824,
-0.32600995898246765,
-0.0788550153374672,
-0.19770130515098572,
-0.6791690587997437,
-0.6566962599754333,
-0.44934719800949097,
0.4073554575443268,
-0.057102400809526443,
-0.2177613228559494,
-0.19667696952819824,
-0.21189063787460327,
0.4656113386154175,
0.44653111696243286,
-0.6355926990509033,
0.18574568629264832,
0.3496359586715698,
0.7840940356254578,
0.008569440804421902,
-0.142147034406662,
-0.4319489300251007,
0.4467090368270874,
-0.30599838495254517,
0.933049738407135,
-0.6293611526489258,
-0.4557194411754608,
-0.04961910471320152,
0.12982110679149628,
0.0798836424946785,
-0.29160282015800476,
0.13061903417110443,
-0.6184884309768677,
0.1347631961107254,
-0.3184126317501068,
-0.5748022198677063,
-0.2991252541542053,
0.1746244579553604,
-0.5913203954696655,
0.9690848588943481,
0.16861006617546082,
-0.36290132999420166,
0.7699282169342041,
-0.5463399887084961,
-0.48361894488334656,
0.050383295863866806,
-0.4412444829940796,
-0.1569368988275528,
-0.30937767028808594,
0.3124660849571228,
0.3105308711528778,
-0.49361076951026917,
0.2380572110414505,
-0.44314301013946533,
0.012044701725244522,
-0.3100181519985199,
-0.16252294182777405,
0.484341025352478,
0.18129239976406097,
-0.5652192234992981,
0.1358986794948578,
-0.526646614074707,
0.04481858015060425,
-0.014726686291396618,
-0.2940763533115387,
-0.4778396189212799,
0.32925644516944885,
-0.39735570549964905,
0.4893296957015991,
0.2605913579463959,
-0.3062402904033661,
0.30712202191352844,
-0.5156060457229614,
0.46483319997787476,
0.8586823344230652,
-0.0031092213466763496,
0.7369586229324341,
-0.2550481855869293,
0.6459059119224548,
-0.290205180644989,
0.39236316084861755,
-0.18212616443634033,
-0.23087173700332642,
-1.0219165086746216,
-0.20717744529247284,
-0.0628785490989685,
0.4722059965133667,
-1.0065710544586182,
0.7719265222549438,
-0.09168434888124466,
-0.45177239179611206,
-0.4311535358428955,
0.5120599269866943,
0.3140798807144165,
0.4818579852581024,
0.3551713228225708,
0.0926031693816185,
-0.6727737188339233,
-0.5776460766792297,
-0.03751154989004135,
-0.08892758935689926,
0.34259235858917236,
0.4911293685436249,
0.5554882287979126,
-0.40970611572265625,
1.4155811071395874,
-0.636433482170105,
-0.7299649715423584,
-0.3131701350212097,
-0.10084252804517746,
-0.10053420066833496,
0.14191746711730957,
0.3096182644367218,
-0.6895610690116882,
-0.6022291779518127,
-0.15134908258914948,
-0.9395409226417542,
-0.21955303847789764,
-0.1785437911748886,
-0.505918025970459,
0.2065034955739975,
0.8932744860649109,
-0.37324148416519165,
0.48709794878959656,
0.3358820974826813,
-0.4418569505214691,
0.026461726054549217,
-0.700351893901825,
-0.3433517515659332,
-1.017282485961914,
-0.005167834926396608,
0.1497115194797516,
-0.5405716896057129,
-0.1983494758605957,
-0.43841132521629333,
0.012351099401712418,
0.1396348476409912,
-0.14446061849594116,
0.9746809601783752,
-0.8689952492713928,
-0.1512359082698822,
-0.43661177158355713,
0.4296967387199402,
0.10469572991132736,
0.4277992844581604,
0.32916393876075745,
0.48366156220436096,
0.5377796292304993,
-0.7236916422843933,
0.5653677582740784,
0.4141649305820465,
-0.2697271704673767,
0.6387428641319275,
-0.4939422607421875,
-0.12070470303297043,
-0.305341511964798,
0.7226365208625793,
-0.5930942296981812,
-0.041732169687747955,
0.20727767050266266,
-0.10490802675485611,
0.16268672049045563,
-0.40573757886886597,
-0.3857496976852417,
-0.20865055918693542,
0.07203881442546844,
0.23108592629432678,
0.5564635396003723,
-0.4280269742012024,
0.972476065158844,
0.804906964302063,
-0.1715942621231079,
-0.27594271302223206,
-0.2457922250032425,
-0.03775027021765709,
-0.08872231841087341,
-0.2976434826850891,
0.1200127899646759,
-0.1895393580198288,
-0.23401033878326416,
0.07694453746080399,
-0.08031285554170609,
-0.1181468665599823,
0.08330469578504562,
0.5353773832321167,
0.24340829253196716,
0.028164513409137726,
0.1337311863899231,
0.11916673183441162,
-0.15859924256801605,
0.16792435944080353,
-0.7759087681770325,
0.3212779760360718,
-0.062129873782396317,
-0.31378263235092163,
-0.11160515248775482,
0.12853215634822845,
0.4565272629261017,
-0.3375009000301361,
0.4856503903865814,
0.33243870735168457,
-0.3146219253540039,
-0.8568083643913269,
-0.4721405506134033,
-0.16400359570980072,
-0.566616415977478,
0.14529885351657867,
-0.1763007491827011,
-0.5145248174667358,
0.1332746148109436,
-0.18565711379051208,
0.16358596086502075,
0.30865177512168884,
0.4203034043312073,
0.05584060773253441,
1.150228500366211,
0.9594057202339172,
0.041243527084589005,
0.4569590091705322,
-0.16769132018089294,
0.09862834960222244,
-0.6269522309303284,
-0.4637712836265564,
-0.2353249192237854,
0.02446993626654148,
-0.5182217359542847,
-0.4313887059688568,
0.6881800889968872,
-0.06301534920930862,
-0.20223811268806458,
0.09557686001062393,
-0.31849372386932373,
0.5270146131515503,
0.3602457344532013,
0.026719026267528534,
0.343858003616333,
-0.2946799397468567,
-0.3713698089122772,
0.35217204689979553,
-0.9369310736656189,
-0.47509706020355225,
1.098237156867981,
0.1671953946352005,
0.9510602951049805,
0.07612170279026031,
0.3802904486656189,
0.6162354350090027,
0.2580753564834595,
-0.7371106743812561,
0.5337803959846497,
0.1434117704629898,
-0.7643997073173523,
-0.38771623373031616,
-0.3707226812839508,
-0.8261479735374451,
0.040613576769828796,
-0.36112087965011597,
-0.2720218002796173,
0.24640938639640808,
0.4642099142074585,
-0.6502997875213623,
0.14945898950099945,
-0.5475221872329712,
0.5459831953048706,
-0.5480009913444519,
-0.25648683309555054,
-0.04970063269138336,
-0.46271026134490967,
0.025410030037164688,
-0.5353829860687256,
0.24900884926319122,
-0.1201695054769516,
-0.22589462995529175,
0.6530963778495789,
-0.7237598299980164,
0.7336245179176331,
-0.2557874321937561,
-0.328421413898468,
0.19756247103214264,
0.017375219613313675,
0.7930516600608826,
0.04980839788913727,
0.08197043836116791,
-0.14961735904216766,
0.00592923816293478,
-0.006288382224738598,
-0.5308033227920532,
0.5943693518638611,
-0.696603000164032,
-0.544549822807312,
-0.4959201216697693,
-0.2784733176231384,
-0.32914674282073975,
0.48583391308784485,
0.24744220077991486,
0.5210514068603516,
-0.09522157907485962,
-0.1920253485441208,
0.7366064786911011,
-0.33232635259628296,
0.503765344619751,
1.1414594650268555,
-0.30903467535972595,
-0.21343545615673065,
0.811587393283844,
0.2211926281452179,
0.11244235187768936,
0.23156513273715973,
0.121657595038414,
-0.7243487238883972,
-0.24409539997577667,
-0.6352695822715759,
0.15749670565128326,
-1.0891311168670654,
-0.0351785272359848,
-0.41418522596359253,
-0.11764318495988846,
-0.32944726943969727,
-0.31086403131484985,
-0.26393118500709534,
0.03238490968942642,
-0.11394891142845154,
-0.0637124553322792,
0.3592408001422882,
1.206432580947876,
-0.20600034296512604,
0.03391941636800766,
-0.6100968718528748,
0.25637754797935486,
0.4411426782608032,
0.34979602694511414,
-0.03665977716445923,
-0.37975743412971497,
-0.3159458637237549,
-0.12639977037906647,
0.069692462682724,
-0.765367865562439,
0.24996712803840637,
0.5330511331558228,
1.0129714012145996,
0.6543064117431641,
0.45338279008865356,
0.6866159439086914,
-0.5933008790016174,
0.3138873279094696,
-0.09891942143440247,
-0.8344727158546448,
0.691805362701416,
-0.3184502422809601,
0.24086834490299225,
0.5855770111083984,
0.581275224685669,
-0.2810014486312866,
-0.4149979054927826,
-0.31468716263771057,
-0.9719098210334778,
0.7098693251609802,
0.036703046411275864,
-0.23820041120052338,
0.15575982630252838,
0.3621896207332611,
0.09817363321781158,
0.3245830833911896,
-0.5026846528053284,
-0.5134873986244202,
-0.261787474155426,
-0.1932891607284546,
-0.05169764533638954,
0.11996299773454666,
-0.14793729782104492,
-0.276460736989975,
0.7508270740509033,
-0.355720579624176,
0.14506027102470398,
0.29709869623184204,
-0.6210448741912842,
-0.10523778945207596,
-0.09979745000600815,
0.31538596749305725,
0.9043526649475098,
-0.09600113332271576,
0.061962541192770004,
0.33311721682548523,
-0.3226221203804016,
0.23127266764640808,
0.39331239461898804,
-0.35430851578712463,
-0.12531571090221405,
0.1356256753206253,
0.5886077284812927,
0.19552816450595856,
-0.6074207425117493,
0.46976733207702637,
-0.29144856333732605,
-0.034882280975580215,
-0.7490914463996887,
0.2233649045228958,
-0.28370657563209534,
0.4302777647972107,
0.2901012897491455,
-0.1180746778845787,
-0.012371247634291649,
-0.33320778608322144,
0.4400525391101837,
0.47922423481941223,
-0.4008769392967224,
-0.039374466985464096,
0.5343291163444519,
0.8414658308029175,
0.12277370691299438,
0.21712663769721985,
-0.5214009284973145,
-0.4239093065261841,
0.34348851442337036,
0.2098175436258316,
0.7817349433898926,
0.06747841089963913,
0.13539694249629974,
0.24193355441093445,
0.2596065402030945,
-0.24602827429771423,
0.08643297851085663,
-0.36868393421173096,
-0.5743927359580994,
-0.32156580686569214,
-0.686438798904419,
-0.27233609557151794,
0.030574776232242584,
-0.5611007213592529,
0.3525887131690979,
-0.7610228061676025,
-0.19389669597148895,
-0.24755433201789856,
-0.05177342891693115,
-0.7655277848243713,
0.2559764087200165,
0.40302762389183044,
0.9835454225540161,
-0.5761920213699341,
1.038243293762207,
0.6363216042518616,
-0.40610772371292114,
-1.0340272188186646,
0.10464976727962494,
0.26872193813323975,
-0.7949053049087524,
0.6637663245201111,
-0.07787425071001053,
-0.627587080001831,
0.42246314883232117,
-0.15319286286830902,
-1.077958583831787,
1.2350633144378662,
0.22814083099365234,
-0.5011299848556519,
-0.4685373604297638,
-0.03836438059806824,
0.23992544412612915,
-0.3684886395931244,
0.7392064929008484,
0.7034934163093567,
0.723503589630127,
0.10735445469617844,
-1.0324536561965942,
0.18186916410923004,
-0.3117023706436157,
-0.2834639847278595,
0.22673164308071136,
-0.5383988618850708,
0.6438829898834229,
-0.160088911652565,
-0.2694897949695587,
-0.23245146870613098,
0.3810644745826721,
-0.10150926560163498,
0.04955402389168739,
0.8193489909172058,
0.32318025827407837,
0.8547404408454895,
0.01559658907353878,
0.7173194289207458,
-0.6465415954589844,
0.07510949671268463,
1.207712173461914,
-0.44238781929016113,
0.6062073707580566,
-0.061487749218940735,
0.2579241693019867,
0.7381314039230347,
0.7493383288383484,
-0.0718207061290741,
0.6134675145149231,
0.00856365542858839,
-0.2198820263147354,
-0.672644853591919,
-0.10284997522830963,
-0.4071349501609802,
0.5722689628601074,
0.2879560589790344,
-0.3649803698062897,
-0.5595294833183289,
-0.015651477500796318,
0.3366124927997589,
-0.2502862215042114,
-0.579002320766449,
1.0590825080871582,
0.13693280518054962,
-1.049949288368225,
0.5648426413536072,
-0.031548768281936646,
0.5996720194816589,
-0.943151593208313,
-0.23262925446033478,
-0.17787764966487885,
0.38207194209098816,
-0.3415631055831909,
-0.6971709132194519,
0.0681886225938797,
0.17790019512176514,
-0.18228957056999207,
-0.5753284692764282,
0.7216721177101135,
-0.4598774313926697,
-0.25116094946861267,
0.5083274841308594,
0.6509252786636353,
0.008107563480734825,
-0.09690570086240768,
-0.6920107007026672,
-0.3791215419769287,
-0.1044808104634285,
-0.18936662375926971,
0.08265624195337296,
0.45434409379959106,
-0.19962570071220398,
0.958991527557373,
0.6279341578483582,
0.4013921618461609,
-0.09842023998498917,
-0.2613498270511627,
1.0382003784179688,
-0.5761225819587708,
-0.9024524688720703,
-0.8731998801231384,
0.1797153502702713,
-0.14120551943778992,
-0.141482874751091,
0.8705412745475769,
0.3376563489437103,
0.8309546113014221,
0.46217265725135803,
1.267356514930725,
-0.10209930688142776,
0.3635486364364624,
-0.6490379571914673,
1.1439309120178223,
-0.7486507296562195,
0.4227272570133209,
0.11883249133825302,
-0.7396367788314819,
0.31940579414367676,
0.712971031665802,
-0.5732434391975403,
0.2395521104335785,
0.7158379554748535,
0.9771516919136047,
0.12236560136079788,
-0.4023444950580597,
0.14069966971874237,
0.17758014798164368,
0.3218422532081604,
0.6805741190910339,
0.7894410490989685,
0.11993125081062317,
0.9345995783805847,
0.17021682858467102,
-0.21517054736614227,
-0.18645451962947845,
-1.1377003192901611,
-1.175410270690918,
-0.6318596601486206,
-0.032596562057733536,
-0.20682582259178162,
0.10056496411561966,
1.2206122875213623,
1.123785376548767,
-0.3933892250061035,
-0.1460934579372406,
-0.19871552288532257,
0.21885815262794495,
0.29404813051223755,
-0.11202248930931091,
0.15676388144493103,
-0.2631610631942749,
-0.4381157457828522,
0.6331091523170471,
0.2102816104888916,
0.09379124641418457,
-0.6513579487800598,
-0.5366313457489014,
-0.08286885917186737,
0.3025030195713043,
0.3310178220272064,
0.4619719982147217,
-0.46603378653526306,
0.22117196023464203,
-0.2553822100162506,
-0.2127397358417511,
-0.18904148042201996,
0.8375301361083984,
-1.0265244245529175,
0.5913835167884827,
0.36569738388061523,
0.3190271854400635,
0.2797468900680542,
-0.08121054619550705,
1.108703851699829,
-0.5144017338752747,
0.08271683007478714,
0.06783415377140045,
0.3364521265029907,
0.23288272321224213,
-0.2512211203575134,
0.21321038901805878,
0.1624939888715744,
-0.502275824546814,
-0.4832201302051544,
0.2715005576610565,
-0.44738584756851196,
-0.4615640640258789,
1.597766399383545,
-0.3299259841442108,
-0.19248895347118378,
-0.6638526916503906,
-0.14341342449188232,
0.45381858944892883,
-0.5062562227249146,
0.5466972589492798,
0.26727959513664246,
0.003997130319476128,
-0.026447555050253868,
-0.6481324434280396,
1.2344657182693481,
-0.00997151993215084,
-1.1287000179290771,
-0.12809552252292633,
0.5658450722694397,
0.35002338886260986,
-0.27520832419395447,
0.591479480266571,
0.39749690890312195,
0.07399289309978485,
-0.23630250990390778,
-0.13139380514621735,
-0.5018930435180664,
-0.49129459261894226,
-0.07492022961378098,
-0.24879053235054016,
0.22956113517284393,
0.19120092689990997
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09743v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09743v1
|
The Human Factor in Detecting Errors of Large Language Models: A Systematic Literature Review and Future Research Directions
| 2024-03-13T21:39:39 | 2024-03-13T21:39:39 |
Christian A. Schiller
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
The launch of ChatGPT by OpenAI in November 2022 marked a pivotal moment for
Artificial Intelligence, introducing Large Language Models (LLMs) to the
mainstream and setting new records in user adoption. LLMs, particularly
ChatGPT, trained on extensive internet data, demonstrate remarkable
conversational capabilities across various domains, suggesting a significant
impact on the workforce. However, these models are susceptible to errors -
"hallucinations" and omissions, generating incorrect or incomplete information.
This poses risks especially in contexts where accuracy is crucial, such as
legal compliance, medicine or fine-grained process frameworks.
There are both technical and human solutions to cope with this isse. This
paper explores the human factors that enable users to detect errors in LLM
outputs, a critical component in mitigating risks associated with their use in
professional settings. Understanding these factors is essential for
organizations aiming to leverage LLM technology efficiently, guiding targeted
training and deployment strategies to enhance error detection by users. This
approach not only aims to optimize the use of LLMs but also to prevent
potential downstream issues stemming from reliance on inaccurate model
responses. The research emphasizes the balance between technological
advancement and human insight in maximizing the benefits of LLMs while
minimizing the risks, particularly in areas where precision is paramount.
This paper performs a systematic literature research on this research topic,
analyses and synthesizes the findings, and outlines future research directions.
Literature selection cut-off date is January 11th 2024.
|
[
-0.28383129835128784,
-0.7771180868148804,
0.5858598947525024,
0.20753343403339386,
0.05788199231028557,
0.051099687814712524,
-0.3161599636077881,
-0.6743419170379639,
-0.15281805396080017,
0.6605796813964844,
-0.4917174279689789,
-0.21063709259033203,
-0.5831664800643921,
0.22489354014396667,
-0.43742066621780396,
0.5381859540939331,
-0.22952242195606232,
0.2631934881210327,
-0.09751494973897934,
-0.03562216833233833,
-0.4450627267360687,
-0.8435350656509399,
-0.719433605670929,
-0.5842333436012268,
0.5872699618339539,
0.4113720953464508,
0.6251763105392456,
0.24162724614143372,
0.7042250633239746,
0.24532368779182434,
-0.009188001975417137,
0.37992921471595764,
-0.3450223505496979,
-0.034466080367565155,
0.05171443149447441,
-0.5035432577133179,
-0.6385375261306763,
-0.21923880279064178,
0.5590577125549316,
0.7956286072731018,
-0.26047980785369873,
-0.10696280002593994,
0.3571678102016449,
0.7035953402519226,
-0.3229784369468689,
0.40225356817245483,
-0.2997867465019226,
0.07497044652700424,
-0.3439432680606842,
-0.33142685890197754,
-0.31557798385620117,
-0.3783192038536072,
0.18930484354496002,
-0.28731128573417664,
0.3125914931297302,
0.25602617859840393,
0.6688327789306641,
0.25790658593177795,
-0.3559730052947998,
-0.40420618653297424,
-0.9527621269226074,
0.6671085953712463,
-0.9235242605209351,
0.33866792917251587,
0.4712931513786316,
0.16524876654148102,
-0.7242245078086853,
-0.3704158663749695,
-0.5816174745559692,
-0.1245311051607132,
-0.08634452521800995,
-0.1377696692943573,
-0.0027808235026896,
0.20083236694335938,
0.3574874997138977,
0.03173865005373955,
-0.5385154485702515,
0.35602080821990967,
-0.43377360701560974,
-0.3594498038291931,
0.7420433163642883,
0.23536868393421173,
0.5208849906921387,
0.020539073273539543,
0.15736132860183716,
-0.11305136978626251,
-0.8984249234199524,
-0.29655933380126953,
0.4849123954772949,
0.2632519602775574,
-0.008423653431236744,
0.5949033498764038,
-0.20531582832336426,
0.3587777018547058,
-0.24681368470191956,
-0.15834219753742218,
0.1972430944442749,
-0.2848069369792938,
-0.22483763098716736,
0.16779391467571259,
0.8288909792900085,
0.15799948573112488,
0.5201160907745361,
0.12260313332080841,
-0.39689844846725464,
-0.08250661939382553,
0.31712210178375244,
-0.600227952003479,
-0.11324987560510635,
0.20381972193717957,
-0.2903924882411957,
-0.34187281131744385,
0.11776132881641388,
-0.8077129125595093,
-0.8643869161605835,
-0.34424686431884766,
0.15527400374412537,
-0.18391700088977814,
-0.30234235525131226,
0.11529163271188736,
0.2940288484096527,
0.19101367890834808,
0.5759435296058655,
-0.7104472517967224,
0.21619153022766113,
0.6995168328285217,
0.7667974233627319,
-0.05587328225374222,
-0.3321135640144348,
-0.3174685835838318,
-0.11616425216197968,
-0.49212151765823364,
0.5715327858924866,
-0.06545820087194443,
-0.5328381061553955,
0.3862481415271759,
-0.09346774965524673,
-0.0038225383032113314,
-0.5719515681266785,
0.8271852731704712,
-0.40833044052124023,
0.2396104633808136,
-0.36359351873397827,
-0.4272969365119934,
-0.33103424310684204,
0.20147839188575745,
-0.5402884483337402,
0.7494245767593384,
0.05948664993047714,
-0.7216654419898987,
0.21671180427074432,
-0.890932559967041,
-0.3349393904209137,
0.07430759817361832,
-0.36039382219314575,
-0.5879402160644531,
0.12681230902671814,
0.19226309657096863,
0.4054195284843445,
-0.4617277979850769,
0.4539504945278168,
-0.25092393159866333,
-0.3848947286605835,
0.6245324611663818,
-0.5650177001953125,
0.7312160730361938,
0.09239408373832703,
-0.4049222469329834,
0.3219124376773834,
-0.5753939747810364,
-0.25564223527908325,
0.23052434623241425,
-0.3364352583885193,
0.011451096273958683,
0.385628879070282,
0.2536734938621521,
0.2182605266571045,
-0.15286843478679657,
-0.4009780287742615,
-0.1270672231912613,
-0.17341187596321106,
0.5922276973724365,
0.7655493021011353,
0.021817047148942947,
0.16149690747261047,
-0.37841522693634033,
0.5648722648620605,
-0.009882241487503052,
0.38049864768981934,
-0.2527286410331726,
-0.5190920233726501,
-0.641654908657074,
0.019397640600800514,
0.31635862588882446,
0.6248461008071899,
-0.5369542241096497,
0.6604419350624084,
-0.29022732377052307,
-0.43870383501052856,
-0.44982123374938965,
0.2582825720310211,
0.08991371095180511,
0.41910481452941895,
-0.1499354988336563,
-0.441401869058609,
-0.7605794668197632,
-0.6732107996940613,
-0.15281113982200623,
-0.5240775346755981,
-0.11101193726062775,
0.35978537797927856,
0.4346843659877777,
-0.633529782295227,
0.995770275592804,
-0.41223829984664917,
-0.46705833077430725,
-0.23409095406532288,
0.22703003883361816,
-0.00815300177782774,
0.37396544218063354,
0.20716984570026398,
-0.8096765279769897,
-0.13585443794727325,
0.07694640010595322,
-0.9512993693351746,
-0.27702316641807556,
-0.1788729429244995,
0.1771562397480011,
0.42882394790649414,
0.46688833832740784,
-0.6450793147087097,
0.44371527433395386,
0.4532918930053711,
-0.2064756602048874,
0.7116621136665344,
-0.3312140107154846,
0.14154402911663055,
-0.6735609173774719,
0.20356640219688416,
0.16519738733768463,
-0.059185583144426346,
-0.7135767936706543,
-0.23823025822639465,
0.03522346541285515,
-0.027864519506692886,
-0.2375335693359375,
0.5028473138809204,
-0.41301679611206055,
-0.17720922827720642,
-0.2986032962799072,
0.1311536729335785,
-0.22525426745414734,
0.32926589250564575,
-0.1173524409532547,
0.8009241819381714,
0.18193590641021729,
-0.36142629384994507,
0.22936129570007324,
0.19671349227428436,
-0.519153356552124,
0.5699300169944763,
-0.698438286781311,
0.04224604368209839,
-0.03727206587791443,
0.2615725100040436,
-0.9636063575744629,
-0.8229414224624634,
0.49797844886779785,
-0.6422106623649597,
0.2640394866466522,
0.17188334465026855,
-0.8500578999519348,
-0.3780045807361603,
-0.11942575871944427,
0.0055813174694776535,
0.6182157397270203,
-0.24156229197978973,
0.6500875353813171,
0.5486783385276794,
-0.14250753819942474,
-0.5189810395240784,
-0.7162472009658813,
0.3235521912574768,
-0.10372398048639297,
-0.8145483732223511,
-0.22201628983020782,
0.04751252755522728,
-0.3788120746612549,
-0.24394473433494568,
-0.00647406280040741,
-0.17782744765281677,
0.455131858587265,
0.3369864225387573,
0.5457128882408142,
-0.22833867371082306,
0.22761519253253937,
-0.5073817372322083,
0.004888695664703846,
0.3959534168243408,
-0.14205117523670197,
0.41247090697288513,
-0.05895773321390152,
-0.6432745456695557,
-0.4729378819465637,
0.08017478138208389,
0.7467244267463684,
-0.023459557443857193,
0.5674315690994263,
0.8862937688827515,
-0.48435020446777344,
0.08960708975791931,
-0.8241590261459351,
-0.45045846700668335,
-0.4258510172367096,
0.6625094413757324,
0.260512113571167,
-0.7172321081161499,
0.5475009083747864,
0.01200590468943119,
0.052720826119184494,
0.26008152961730957,
0.5941320657730103,
-0.28047069907188416,
0.9629095196723938,
0.6905404329299927,
-0.19886146485805511,
0.5019369721412659,
0.17697177827358246,
0.5181182622909546,
-0.814309298992157,
-0.1548631638288498,
-0.6988300681114197,
-0.020548980683088303,
-0.6537188291549683,
-0.38914549350738525,
0.6125977635383606,
-0.11195474863052368,
-0.22644996643066406,
-0.29432412981987,
-0.22346007823944092,
0.15660199522972107,
0.5099971294403076,
0.12243141978979111,
0.40094852447509766,
0.042207639664411545,
0.1467750370502472,
0.07051229476928711,
-0.6407068371772766,
-0.7251056432723999,
1.0412803888320923,
0.6231023073196411,
0.9468938708305359,
0.030155330896377563,
0.45064955949783325,
0.46370476484298706,
0.3714381754398346,
-0.6917631030082703,
0.5043056607246399,
0.3315442204475403,
-0.7962599992752075,
-0.5705214738845825,
-0.31144532561302185,
-0.8856161832809448,
0.21247157454490662,
-0.33255547285079956,
-0.6795446872711182,
0.06318382918834686,
0.3785560727119446,
-0.2101333886384964,
0.40888890624046326,
-0.6785401105880737,
0.7615557312965393,
-0.3747878968715668,
-0.3692656457424164,
-0.14841656386852264,
-0.6641396284103394,
0.4807499945163727,
-0.35048240423202515,
0.3752621114253998,
-0.17414560914039612,
-0.013970160856842995,
0.7740187644958496,
-0.06861132383346558,
1.2174593210220337,
-0.04782045632600784,
-0.1106598749756813,
0.2346382588148117,
-0.06601240485906601,
0.7458667755126953,
-0.3721716105937958,
0.06503546237945557,
0.353248655796051,
-0.2291431725025177,
-0.3385743498802185,
-0.3288779854774475,
0.29756227135658264,
-0.9199250936508179,
-0.5649932622909546,
-0.5740591287612915,
-0.37482374906539917,
-0.3128852844238281,
0.10343799740076065,
0.17605838179588318,
0.2850193381309509,
-0.2944052219390869,
0.11223874241113663,
0.8280526995658875,
-0.2824706733226776,
0.24459978938102722,
0.3612583875656128,
-0.28006690740585327,
-0.13475659489631653,
0.7090722322463989,
0.11527232825756073,
0.08500023931264877,
0.00586970429867506,
0.23868098855018616,
-0.16195878386497498,
-0.8637595176696777,
-0.36836618185043335,
0.4377366900444031,
-0.717605710029602,
0.13783127069473267,
-0.605278491973877,
-0.27353328466415405,
-0.3192571699619293,
0.05661295726895332,
-0.21477799117565155,
0.21173112094402313,
-0.5039250254631042,
0.10384106636047363,
0.13813920319080353,
0.8465315103530884,
0.11237242072820663,
0.5069222450256348,
-0.9627536535263062,
-0.12134420871734619,
0.0516357421875,
0.36154741048812866,
0.19239532947540283,
-0.4570276737213135,
-0.2501738369464874,
-0.020503345876932144,
-0.31118160486221313,
-0.6622474789619446,
0.4448273181915283,
-0.0717829018831253,
0.7132148146629333,
0.26878052949905396,
-0.10598354041576385,
0.4094262719154358,
-0.28559693694114685,
0.7379341125488281,
0.1674736589193344,
-0.8051918745040894,
0.3817136287689209,
-0.5615639686584473,
0.10853742063045502,
0.25397151708602905,
0.3901126980781555,
-1.2068802118301392,
-0.029611017554998398,
-0.39596009254455566,
-0.8095629811286926,
0.7222335934638977,
0.128199964761734,
-0.027645766735076904,
0.2093483954668045,
0.158468559384346,
-0.06632017344236374,
0.0843062549829483,
-0.45974645018577576,
0.14921343326568604,
0.4181287884712219,
-0.20230670273303986,
-0.13976161181926727,
-0.4546096920967102,
0.005499026272445917,
0.2608616054058075,
0.8420219421386719,
-0.34740859270095825,
0.13321222364902496,
0.38210994005203247,
-0.25845158100128174,
-0.4077673554420471,
0.34009915590286255,
0.7976533770561218,
0.9328724145889282,
-0.22387953102588654,
-0.10734868049621582,
0.16962113976478577,
-0.6148576736450195,
0.06742256134748459,
-0.2565162181854248,
-0.1808360069990158,
-0.08040968328714371,
0.5280763506889343,
0.6127470135688782,
0.1922810673713684,
-1.0386532545089722,
0.4210902750492096,
0.02586563304066658,
-0.12069442123174667,
-0.7332996129989624,
0.007204316556453705,
0.030607765540480614,
0.18995775282382965,
0.48593711853027344,
0.28497418761253357,
-0.0012524097692221403,
-0.500954270362854,
-0.021849006414413452,
0.11557471752166748,
-0.4096892774105072,
-0.3879409730434418,
0.4633791446685791,
0.4268037676811218,
-0.4265159070491791,
0.6751797795295715,
0.03979671001434326,
-0.528742790222168,
0.4984080195426941,
0.049001507461071014,
1.0043214559555054,
-0.28112971782684326,
-0.06525500863790512,
0.15228672325611115,
0.48198452591896057,
-0.5342119932174683,
0.08314386755228043,
0.5930852293968201,
-0.8260078430175781,
-0.5008398294448853,
-0.19062864780426025,
-0.7042034268379211,
0.08943889290094376,
-0.33698758482933044,
0.45080167055130005,
-0.4132867753505707,
-0.18001694977283478,
-0.09773176163434982,
-0.16091549396514893,
-0.6160759925842285,
-0.1456434577703476,
0.32441002130508423,
0.7032366991043091,
-0.8632948994636536,
0.7241358160972595,
0.5310693979263306,
-0.3093673884868622,
-0.5381201505661011,
-0.0201354268938303,
0.5124556422233582,
-0.6425139904022217,
0.664718747138977,
-0.03921917453408241,
-0.04286884143948555,
-0.36867350339889526,
-0.459420382976532,
-0.5880213975906372,
0.9250553846359253,
0.20741775631904602,
-0.7340895533561707,
-0.1293526589870453,
0.16050484776496887,
0.5965332388877869,
-0.26456090807914734,
0.2956504821777344,
0.6714538335800171,
0.5270758867263794,
0.006928068585693836,
-1.107377529144287,
-0.08711586892604828,
0.2057305872440338,
0.050455592572689056,
0.2038908302783966,
-0.3452621102333069,
0.6489105820655823,
-0.16802679002285004,
-0.19938263297080994,
-0.06673399358987808,
0.4049580693244934,
0.13362964987754822,
0.29451844096183777,
0.3422301709651947,
-0.057494305074214935,
0.9243758320808411,
-0.14354245364665985,
1.0712454319000244,
-0.000025902689230861142,
0.18013779819011688,
0.9654625654220581,
-0.5516526103019714,
0.8646551370620728,
0.47908419370651245,
-0.4263639450073242,
0.10547129064798355,
0.6638743281364441,
-0.007558214478194714,
-0.15295541286468506,
0.20233647525310516,
-0.15752719342708588,
-0.04623294621706009,
-0.09092451632022858,
-0.10308687388896942,
0.47197169065475464,
0.6356872916221619,
-0.3653581738471985,
-0.006575650069862604,
-0.04690244048833847,
0.13314540684223175,
0.10603728145360947,
-0.16276603937149048,
0.6754757165908813,
0.06955181062221527,
-0.7498284578323364,
0.37309888005256653,
0.06677578389644623,
0.8154373168945312,
-0.6124263405799866,
0.06302262842655182,
-0.2651709020137787,
0.35011059045791626,
-0.3590923845767975,
-0.7266615033149719,
0.2475360631942749,
-0.10035289824008942,
0.010038434527814388,
0.013272064737975597,
0.9797061085700989,
-0.12605449557304382,
-0.35549044609069824,
0.16869135200977325,
0.6577135324478149,
0.1955987960100174,
-0.2206389456987381,
-0.5633396506309509,
0.41192278265953064,
0.09198522567749023,
-0.07570613920688629,
0.3717076778411865,
0.2951866686344147,
-0.2983509600162506,
0.8778731226921082,
0.549338698387146,
0.2536211907863617,
-0.031103532761335373,
-0.030713025480508804,
0.537704586982727,
-0.6529362201690674,
-0.22490668296813965,
-0.9505971074104309,
0.288143515586853,
-0.15727882087230682,
-0.17661352455615997,
0.523084282875061,
0.12209677696228027,
0.7050424218177795,
-0.12013814598321915,
0.924560546875,
0.1870434731245041,
0.4248681962490082,
-0.3018660247325897,
0.7317899465560913,
-0.24840322136878967,
0.43122345209121704,
-0.15625426173210144,
-0.776363730430603,
-0.4091358780860901,
0.4227678179740906,
-0.4222937524318695,
0.10457079112529755,
0.593504786491394,
0.9914328455924988,
0.18476562201976776,
0.26083382964134216,
0.42036065459251404,
0.12696082890033722,
0.5905225276947021,
0.3508753776550293,
0.842269778251648,
-0.3917992115020752,
0.48317480087280273,
-0.01590835116803646,
-0.23342594504356384,
-0.844641387462616,
-0.9031432867050171,
-0.8950021862983704,
-0.4742869436740875,
-0.44259071350097656,
-0.3438231945037842,
0.05916939303278923,
1.124452829360962,
0.6487194299697876,
-0.8515693545341492,
-0.4910794794559479,
-0.029040366411209106,
0.22263860702514648,
0.04148847237229347,
-0.18100139498710632,
0.2667112946510315,
-0.5382596254348755,
-0.4763513207435608,
-0.11956548690795898,
0.292275607585907,
0.11166606843471527,
-0.5805090665817261,
-0.26191678643226624,
-0.1166752353310585,
0.042699895799160004,
0.5706394910812378,
0.35781362652778625,
-0.9102578163146973,
-0.2644057869911194,
-0.020024705678224564,
-0.28460341691970825,
0.16353878378868103,
0.9027398824691772,
-0.2559359669685364,
0.2816326320171356,
0.5783076286315918,
0.8106340169906616,
0.034309737384319305,
-0.36263856291770935,
0.7414619326591492,
-0.4605324864387512,
-0.18563590943813324,
0.24871893227100372,
0.562877357006073,
0.631550669670105,
-0.4736800789833069,
0.8821625709533691,
0.4470704197883606,
-0.890423595905304,
-0.8817005157470703,
-0.09185192734003067,
-0.7999529838562012,
-0.04572289064526558,
1.0654799938201904,
-0.13828130066394806,
-0.35397547483444214,
-0.394025981426239,
-0.5018662214279175,
0.12912499904632568,
-0.2911657691001892,
1.068051815032959,
0.9839914441108704,
-0.06919612735509872,
-0.11128729581832886,
-1.081787109375,
0.43366748094558716,
0.3034626841545105,
-0.8928434252738953,
0.4390164315700531,
0.5262395739555359,
0.18880964815616608,
0.21412703394889832,
0.5172321200370789,
-0.211064413189888,
0.40583378076553345,
-0.03713768720626831,
0.41521701216697693,
0.06102510541677475,
0.04348107799887657,
-0.49097663164138794,
-0.0930948480963707,
0.5517280697822571,
0.035550571978092194
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08946v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08946v1
|
Usable XAI: 10 Strategies Towards Exploiting Explainability in the LLM Era
| 2024-03-13T20:25:27 | 2024-03-13T20:25:27 |
Xuansheng Wu, Haiyan Zhao, Yaochen Zhu, Yucheng Shi, Fan Yang, Tianming Liu, Xiaoming Zhai, Wenlin Yao, Jundong Li, Mengnan Du, Ninghao Liu
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CY
|
Explainable AI (XAI) refers to techniques that provide human-understandable
insights into the workings of AI models. Recently, the focus of XAI is being
extended towards Large Language Models (LLMs) which are often criticized for
their lack of transparency. This extension calls for a significant
transformation in XAI methodologies because of two reasons. First, many
existing XAI methods cannot be directly applied to LLMs due to their complexity
advanced capabilities. Second, as LLMs are increasingly deployed across diverse
industry applications, the role of XAI shifts from merely opening the "black
box" to actively enhancing the productivity and applicability of LLMs in
real-world settings. Meanwhile, unlike traditional machine learning models that
are passive recipients of XAI insights, the distinct abilities of LLMs can
reciprocally enhance XAI. Therefore, in this paper, we introduce Usable XAI in
the context of LLMs by analyzing (1) how XAI can benefit LLMs and AI systems,
and (2) how LLMs can contribute to the advancement of XAI. We introduce 10
strategies, introducing the key techniques for each and discussing their
associated challenges. We also provide case studies to demonstrate how to
obtain and leverage explanations. The code used in this paper can be found at:
https://github.com/JacksonWuxs/UsableXAI_LLM.
|
[
-0.21631580591201782,
-0.2633793354034424,
0.8113479614257812,
0.041664183139801025,
-0.07856755703687668,
0.07147204875946045,
-0.20359709858894348,
-0.6609531044960022,
-0.08879761397838593,
0.47231659293174744,
-0.6128476858139038,
-0.32888931035995483,
-0.3385726511478424,
-0.12129465490579605,
-0.5353327393531799,
0.8821445107460022,
-0.20523323118686676,
-0.21230827271938324,
-0.1961590200662613,
-0.47680729627609253,
-0.2953318655490875,
-0.3176267147064209,
-0.8548974990844727,
-0.4668298661708832,
0.7309224009513855,
0.6015243530273438,
0.906515896320343,
0.8820350170135498,
0.21021009981632233,
0.4087294936180115,
-0.1455482393503189,
0.10129643976688385,
-0.4760635495185852,
0.008872549049556255,
0.004692559130489826,
-1.0259252786636353,
-0.35729870200157166,
-0.029313042759895325,
0.6955631971359253,
0.6715814471244812,
-0.19092637300491333,
0.03184639289975166,
0.16090436279773712,
0.3494843542575836,
-0.4879678189754486,
0.25978291034698486,
-0.5392844080924988,
0.0007816504803486168,
-0.25442081689834595,
-0.3255000114440918,
-0.23054192960262299,
0.10274593532085419,
0.09317024052143097,
-0.9520289301872253,
-0.19525355100631714,
0.06582561880350113,
0.5873209238052368,
0.16992135345935822,
-0.1846260279417038,
-0.5560598373413086,
-0.9253405928611755,
0.8624027371406555,
-0.7511873245239258,
0.19227254390716553,
0.0900765135884285,
0.6188792586326599,
-0.015887727960944176,
-0.9279228448867798,
-0.753719687461853,
-0.3030676245689392,
-0.1251026690006256,
-0.001530492678284645,
-0.3588431477546692,
0.0432540662586689,
0.27729082107543945,
0.5332699418067932,
-0.2978561520576477,
0.49538180232048035,
-0.0019814614206552505,
0.19079068303108215,
0.608435332775116,
0.23437871038913727,
0.491248220205307,
-0.006330461241304874,
-0.18201680481433868,
-0.13865317404270172,
-0.8019841909408569,
0.22956208884716034,
0.2449391782283783,
0.11340789496898651,
-0.11080034077167511,
0.43420591950416565,
0.006620131433010101,
0.3366723656654358,
-0.36521896719932556,
-0.29200905561447144,
0.1342008113861084,
-0.35212433338165283,
-0.15139374136924744,
-0.13789981603622437,
0.36567628383636475,
-0.047392405569553375,
0.10609849542379379,
-0.26493000984191895,
-0.30111420154571533,
-0.21982355415821075,
0.4147511124610901,
-0.4615758955478668,
0.03654706850647926,
0.3489818572998047,
-0.6300512552261353,
-0.4114248752593994,
-0.25481274724006653,
-0.5264383554458618,
-0.6266434788703918,
-0.25635647773742676,
0.373513400554657,
-0.2840062975883484,
-0.328986257314682,
-0.20800970494747162,
-0.31788766384124756,
0.7279780507087708,
0.38662806153297424,
-0.8426710367202759,
0.033097051084041595,
0.8145987391471863,
0.860741376876831,
-0.058587223291397095,
-0.22255364060401917,
-0.3733060956001282,
0.36282283067703247,
-0.1714537888765335,
0.4319990873336792,
-0.4509700536727905,
-0.39967289566993713,
-0.037038933485746384,
-0.28942203521728516,
0.08289723098278046,
-0.5695552229881287,
0.42891764640808105,
-0.4191361367702484,
0.051652487367391586,
-0.07839477807283401,
-0.33806100487709045,
-0.49648433923721313,
0.4653315544128418,
-0.6801828145980835,
0.3349405825138092,
0.17141211032867432,
-0.4559287130832672,
0.23027381300926208,
-1.2796101570129395,
-0.15509547293186188,
0.16400104761123657,
-0.29538506269454956,
-0.44416794180870056,
0.2934916615486145,
0.026195628568530083,
0.4434145390987396,
-0.012822005897760391,
0.0932120606303215,
-0.39475736021995544,
-0.1929865926504135,
0.5831634998321533,
-0.8229551315307617,
0.8484494686126709,
0.3739200234413147,
-0.689446747303009,
0.3748515844345093,
-0.9662985801696777,
0.0544930025935173,
0.24413037300109863,
-0.11124501377344131,
-0.28653255105018616,
0.051982730627059937,
-0.2008890062570572,
-0.09475404024124146,
-0.08165378868579865,
-0.266445517539978,
-0.01839010789990425,
-0.4721445143222809,
0.7252442836761475,
0.7964591979980469,
-0.44030410051345825,
0.4280228316783905,
-0.4712859094142914,
0.7720749378204346,
-0.16064700484275818,
0.17639362812042236,
-0.5841584801673889,
-0.25247445702552795,
-0.7303691506385803,
-0.3414357304573059,
0.03055642358958721,
0.4713074564933777,
-0.9937755465507507,
-0.20037421584129333,
-0.3349834382534027,
-0.4382743835449219,
-0.6698881387710571,
0.4323854148387909,
0.3055383861064911,
0.5048524737358093,
-0.003140845103189349,
0.1204298660159111,
-0.40660569071769714,
-0.6970252394676208,
-0.31746819615364075,
-0.46087074279785156,
-0.07967469096183777,
0.6029492020606995,
0.25550657510757446,
-0.35168126225471497,
0.6003708839416504,
-0.1682671755552292,
-0.013044379651546478,
-0.6917215585708618,
-0.04213394224643707,
0.03244129568338394,
0.1746220588684082,
0.3397766351699829,
-1.1028367280960083,
-0.15830497443675995,
0.3446482717990875,
-1.1788661479949951,
0.0727045089006424,
-0.40874183177948,
0.10729487985372543,
0.0804869681596756,
0.5125155448913574,
-0.36830630898475647,
0.6578924059867859,
0.41834133863449097,
-0.2746506333351135,
0.474647581577301,
-0.29760774970054626,
-0.012666813097894192,
-0.8441895842552185,
0.1977304220199585,
-0.02126162499189377,
-0.5772685408592224,
-0.7524026036262512,
0.6075649261474609,
-0.2134939581155777,
-0.24381297826766968,
-0.5926415920257568,
0.7828854918479919,
-0.6808458566665649,
0.056861720979213715,
-0.4765186905860901,
0.3311125934123993,
-0.110320545732975,
0.3445831835269928,
-0.14630085229873657,
0.6976417899131775,
0.5256803631782532,
-0.5981534719467163,
0.10235851258039474,
0.18155255913734436,
-0.3693026900291443,
0.2146781086921692,
-0.8814843893051147,
-0.15534880757331848,
-0.0953623503446579,
-0.012473499402403831,
-0.9417649507522583,
-0.10437507927417755,
0.45023274421691895,
-0.31925076246261597,
0.26263269782066345,
0.18217988312244415,
-0.27523842453956604,
-0.1215943917632103,
-0.4409176707267761,
0.5352766513824463,
0.6284688711166382,
-0.9936836957931519,
0.9040103554725647,
0.29797089099884033,
-0.11675414443016052,
-0.4337073564529419,
-0.7772504687309265,
0.4253338873386383,
-0.7151458263397217,
-0.7117955088615417,
0.41336771845817566,
-0.2632805407047272,
-0.5493764877319336,
-0.10114583373069763,
-0.13099895417690277,
0.049701523035764694,
0.6210733652114868,
0.4759345054626465,
0.012903090566396713,
-0.30644845962524414,
-0.1525108814239502,
-0.013415304012596607,
-0.4574108123779297,
0.12666495144367218,
-0.20633919537067413,
-0.006585096009075642,
-0.05734724551439285,
-0.3652927875518799,
-0.7266597747802734,
0.4679180383682251,
0.5232330560684204,
0.0937136635184288,
0.6566920280456543,
0.5476574301719666,
-0.22031410038471222,
-0.17248351871967316,
-0.22632990777492523,
0.09181948751211166,
-0.5188605785369873,
0.2565992772579193,
-0.3907473385334015,
-0.8919923305511475,
0.39990025758743286,
-0.1768675297498703,
0.344475656747818,
0.0035992925986647606,
0.48967432975769043,
-0.1450210064649582,
1.1910607814788818,
1.1601227521896362,
0.029861122369766235,
0.6097955703735352,
-0.41670942306518555,
0.3303046226501465,
-0.6908445358276367,
-0.2565758228302002,
-0.514073371887207,
-0.28166887164115906,
-0.651029109954834,
-0.12188009172677994,
0.32829150557518005,
-0.022463379427790642,
0.11050879955291748,
0.12462609261274338,
-0.13478636741638184,
0.41535210609436035,
0.7191056609153748,
-0.07451923936605453,
0.4949961006641388,
-0.0028285819571465254,
0.317659854888916,
0.34316831827163696,
-0.8159509301185608,
-0.805121660232544,
0.9036529064178467,
0.7433052659034729,
0.8125747442245483,
0.3025139570236206,
0.6322429776191711,
0.3415604531764984,
0.42201316356658936,
-0.8114132285118103,
0.527766227722168,
0.02787349745631218,
-0.39847394824028015,
-0.5168272256851196,
-0.5134099721908569,
-1.0660823583602905,
0.04478417709469795,
0.011084571480751038,
-0.7689826488494873,
0.07301318645477295,
0.3998928666114807,
-0.32149937748908997,
0.4785797595977783,
-0.8355509638786316,
0.6685576438903809,
-0.5437189340591431,
-0.1501873880624771,
-0.4068528115749359,
-0.46429866552352905,
0.3737521171569824,
0.0015108996303752065,
0.1828821748495102,
0.10549495369195938,
-0.3136059641838074,
0.5765945315361023,
-0.43935930728912354,
1.0012284517288208,
-0.15312792360782623,
-0.33473101258277893,
0.1406814157962799,
-0.31389081478118896,
0.2550887167453766,
0.09583478420972824,
-0.19992797076702118,
0.3894588351249695,
0.04012663662433624,
-0.5614376664161682,
-1.1562442779541016,
0.7015019059181213,
-0.8209720253944397,
-0.8777332901954651,
-0.15752391517162323,
-0.6296464204788208,
0.03575323894619942,
0.31352946162223816,
-0.031967345625162125,
0.41767558455467224,
-0.14234189689159393,
-0.04835362732410431,
0.6982969641685486,
-0.2354748696088791,
0.6227312684059143,
0.3697650730609894,
-0.1275385469198227,
-0.16623754799365997,
1.0341899394989014,
0.22718746960163116,
0.0857228934764862,
0.4294881522655487,
0.15520893037319183,
-0.25967392325401306,
-0.8356969952583313,
-0.29798078536987305,
0.19369269907474518,
-0.7355717420578003,
0.007090721745043993,
-0.3744727373123169,
-0.13359186053276062,
-0.2168969362974167,
-0.1507207304239273,
0.11075009405612946,
-0.5873476266860962,
-0.32075393199920654,
-0.0745229497551918,
-0.03603958338499069,
0.8452799916267395,
-0.18256822228431702,
0.6377900838851929,
-0.5935745239257812,
0.34700462222099304,
0.23881974816322327,
0.4822501540184021,
0.3502982258796692,
-0.48088809847831726,
-0.3072938323020935,
0.20717191696166992,
-0.2535415291786194,
-0.6269192695617676,
0.2812897562980652,
0.0831371396780014,
1.046738624572754,
0.7551435232162476,
0.07029444724321365,
0.5877390503883362,
-0.11605386435985565,
0.6192556023597717,
0.017869070172309875,
-0.9955434799194336,
0.4916810691356659,
-0.060661688446998596,
0.1590181291103363,
0.3397878110408783,
0.6358184218406677,
-0.39042750000953674,
-0.19692367315292358,
-0.5671626925468445,
-0.9873995184898376,
0.5637199878692627,
0.3660033345222473,
0.32583722472190857,
0.24433694779872894,
0.819785475730896,
0.38911786675453186,
0.13762325048446655,
-0.8799591064453125,
-0.4752272963523865,
-0.07651077210903168,
-0.15838108956813812,
-0.17560823261737823,
-0.34824639558792114,
-0.2825447618961334,
0.1596650630235672,
0.9087189435958862,
-0.14387840032577515,
0.2966327667236328,
0.020554985851049423,
-0.35537588596343994,
0.48936566710472107,
0.3728269934654236,
0.5825653076171875,
0.9279038906097412,
0.1533856987953186,
0.15929271280765533,
-0.05010122060775757,
-0.05976366996765137,
0.11234791576862335,
0.11169619113206863,
-0.2610860764980316,
-0.23302505910396576,
0.5596439242362976,
0.9650681018829346,
-0.08046352863311768,
-0.85722416639328,
0.1362716555595398,
-0.2640482783317566,
-0.03891231492161751,
-0.4853554666042328,
0.49807584285736084,
-0.12298189848661423,
0.5095873475074768,
0.17065653204917908,
-0.2649819254875183,
0.058761436492204666,
-0.8727533221244812,
-0.031028682366013527,
0.4533163905143738,
-0.5217615962028503,
-0.2496308982372284,
0.6971237659454346,
0.26876282691955566,
-0.5860592126846313,
0.640540361404419,
-0.10845666378736496,
-0.09949000179767609,
0.308468222618103,
0.5381978750228882,
0.8101977109909058,
0.22000952064990997,
0.2460433840751648,
-0.333467572927475,
0.15059521794319153,
0.3693351745605469,
0.09157466888427734,
-0.45560222864151,
-0.7375234961509705,
-0.42197224497795105,
0.062328752130270004,
-0.6834837794303894,
0.17681604623794556,
-0.6316309571266174,
0.10870680958032608,
-0.3667193353176117,
0.2184956818819046,
0.18218496441841125,
-0.05630340427160263,
-0.4452052116394043,
0.010448835790157318,
0.3486889600753784,
1.2888545989990234,
-0.5882139801979065,
0.5291604399681091,
0.6250960826873779,
-0.5300451517105103,
-0.7654013633728027,
0.047219958156347275,
0.17323923110961914,
-1.2176467180252075,
0.05307513102889061,
0.19492857158184052,
0.09801273047924042,
-0.10925120115280151,
-0.7381882667541504,
-0.49961698055267334,
1.31798255443573,
0.374428391456604,
-0.3539513647556305,
-0.11126493662595749,
0.20008715987205505,
0.40768182277679443,
-0.3811578154563904,
0.399557888507843,
0.7488751411437988,
0.6088002324104309,
-0.04629575461149216,
-0.4180622100830078,
0.06697741150856018,
-0.4505847692489624,
0.04007917270064354,
-0.0558784194290638,
-0.39638641476631165,
0.025809351354837418,
-0.48853084444999695,
-0.22958378493785858,
0.6011524200439453,
0.9346343278884888,
0.2649449408054352,
0.8567188382148743,
0.6663635969161987,
0.36507806181907654,
0.9338236451148987,
0.1257406324148178,
1.2837672233581543,
-0.027459735050797462,
-0.24320527911186218,
0.8768453001976013,
-0.1605721116065979,
0.6814964413642883,
0.5168985724449158,
0.13118121027946472,
0.6089332103729248,
0.306266725063324,
0.07271573692560196,
0.10485474765300751,
0.37756335735321045,
-0.4826916754245758,
-0.0286422036588192,
-0.11921026557683945,
-0.11637687683105469,
0.6323267221450806,
0.4182354509830475,
-0.3653082549571991,
-0.27803105115890503,
0.5026455521583557,
0.2933841347694397,
0.11604554206132889,
-0.515569806098938,
0.9626487493515015,
0.15917471051216125,
-0.46317002177238464,
0.4161580502986908,
0.014523515477776527,
0.5171107649803162,
-0.6946632862091064,
-0.3156101107597351,
-0.2869000732898712,
0.1723615527153015,
-0.22577466070652008,
-0.9005646705627441,
0.4577646553516388,
0.06008140370249748,
-0.4307318329811096,
-0.41873475909233093,
0.74979567527771,
-0.06399019062519073,
-0.3747186064720154,
0.25405246019363403,
0.5824973583221436,
0.45541536808013916,
-0.015370046719908714,
-0.6748173832893372,
0.08636204898357391,
0.3190133273601532,
0.013497723266482353,
0.46663135290145874,
0.5709701776504517,
-0.32985633611679077,
1.3032522201538086,
0.45501184463500977,
0.049352653324604034,
-0.21885034441947937,
-0.04510548338294029,
0.8153948783874512,
-0.8982275128364563,
-0.40123483538627625,
-0.7560603022575378,
0.7064273953437805,
-0.036129772663116455,
-0.0655084177851677,
0.801577091217041,
0.044527456164360046,
0.747732400894165,
0.338032066822052,
1.0435960292816162,
0.03188350424170494,
0.34914731979370117,
-0.49510377645492554,
0.851169764995575,
-0.6204987168312073,
0.7669516205787659,
-0.0619296133518219,
-0.5673421621322632,
-0.430901437997818,
0.3043893575668335,
-0.06365802884101868,
0.2761874198913574,
0.2781001925468445,
0.848181426525116,
-0.06206681951880455,
-0.016616521403193474,
0.6719756722450256,
0.3741999864578247,
0.6096512079238892,
0.21260473132133484,
0.9775223731994629,
-0.11599794775247574,
1.0383230447769165,
-0.2975223958492279,
-0.5562174916267395,
0.12649470567703247,
-1.0848827362060547,
-0.5384379029273987,
-0.3737349510192871,
-0.6077753901481628,
-0.2713679075241089,
0.1696261316537857,
0.39790815114974976,
0.9033727645874023,
-0.6083125472068787,
-0.28644421696662903,
-0.03467867150902748,
0.7324856519699097,
-0.39453136920928955,
-0.2044268697500229,
-0.004349631257355213,
-0.32172760367393494,
-0.6650080680847168,
0.5388684868812561,
0.33347707986831665,
0.04215378314256668,
-0.3674037456512451,
-0.22332389652729034,
0.28900301456451416,
0.07567229121923447,
0.6880502700805664,
0.7908006906509399,
-0.6192253828048706,
-0.199611634016037,
-0.13559654355049133,
0.5299636721611023,
0.08630430698394775,
0.9887639880180359,
-0.8748539090156555,
0.29882726073265076,
0.30445531010627747,
0.93067467212677,
0.09993816167116165,
-0.18281134963035583,
0.7902904152870178,
-0.42769739031791687,
-0.32042190432548523,
-0.17959974706172943,
0.39786192774772644,
0.38857775926589966,
-0.43133601546287537,
0.5605080127716064,
-0.13988594710826874,
-0.5364847183227539,
-0.9605635404586792,
0.2156076580286026,
-0.9247045516967773,
-0.31911009550094604,
0.9557775259017944,
-0.551214873790741,
-0.3074168264865875,
-0.202391117811203,
-0.1194913312792778,
0.030625157058238983,
-0.08569294214248657,
0.7350550293922424,
0.25299593806266785,
-0.34144365787506104,
-0.5180302262306213,
-0.37796929478645325,
0.15704305469989777,
0.34224122762680054,
-0.886200487613678,
0.06806488335132599,
-0.031096462160348892,
0.1814681589603424,
0.18503423035144806,
0.41937220096588135,
-0.2602733075618744,
0.27274948358535767,
-0.10493777692317963,
-0.153361514210701,
-0.2994441092014313,
-0.3214779496192932,
-0.8168271780014038,
0.13784247636795044,
0.4820561707019806,
-0.27453872561454773
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08943v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08943v1
|
LMStyle Benchmark: Evaluating Text Style Transfer for Chatbots
| 2024-03-13T20:19:30 | 2024-03-13T20:19:30 |
Jianlin Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Since the breakthrough of ChatGPT, large language models (LLMs) have garnered
significant attention in the research community. With the development of LLMs,
the question of text style transfer for conversational models has emerged as a
natural extension, where chatbots may possess their own styles or even
characters. However, standard evaluation metrics have not yet been established
for this new settings. This paper aims to address this issue by proposing the
LMStyle Benchmark, a novel evaluation framework applicable to chat-style text
style transfer (C-TST), that can measure the quality of style transfer for LLMs
in an automated and scalable manner. In addition to conventional style strength
metrics, LMStyle Benchmark further considers a novel aspect of metrics called
appropriateness, a high-level metrics take account of coherence, fluency and
other implicit factors without the aid of reference samples. Our experiments
demonstrate that the new evaluation methods introduced by LMStyle Benchmark
have a higher correlation with human judgments in terms of appropriateness.
Based on LMStyle Benchmark, we present a comprehensive list of evaluation
results for popular LLMs, including LLaMA, Alpaca, and Vicuna, reflecting their
stylistic properties, such as formality and sentiment strength, along with
their appropriateness.
|
[
-0.272746205329895,
-0.8149079084396362,
0.44130900502204895,
0.4881732165813446,
-0.4250403344631195,
0.3880271017551422,
-0.49702727794647217,
-0.5034251809120178,
0.3518792986869812,
0.2692793011665344,
-0.5612313747406006,
-0.5287319421768188,
-0.5718657970428467,
0.2729276716709137,
-0.5965626835823059,
0.9217783808708191,
-0.21835818886756897,
-0.13693025708198547,
-0.2219424694776535,
-0.09153316915035248,
-0.4043678641319275,
-0.458067923784256,
-0.4958142638206482,
-0.08530421555042267,
0.49250298738479614,
0.27543124556541443,
0.7972604036331177,
0.28622156381607056,
0.8241361379623413,
0.29071110486984253,
-0.07594072818756104,
0.20049729943275452,
-0.5327339172363281,
0.20554423332214355,
-0.20125262439250946,
-0.23793020844459534,
-0.7999985814094543,
-0.11088191717863083,
0.5589577555656433,
0.1899632215499878,
-0.045528165996074677,
0.3133581578731537,
0.2821483314037323,
0.7452704310417175,
-0.47417813539505005,
-0.03612399101257324,
-0.6357872486114502,
0.025528559461236,
-0.15679886937141418,
-0.43645718693733215,
-0.4088454246520996,
-0.6990706920623779,
0.13821588456630707,
-0.35644057393074036,
-0.10754408687353134,
0.005668099503964186,
0.691474199295044,
0.060099486261606216,
-0.2730713486671448,
-0.44598427414894104,
-0.624437153339386,
0.477645605802536,
-0.6229265332221985,
0.5411654114723206,
0.10158441960811615,
0.7341001629829407,
0.07271192967891693,
-0.793166995048523,
-0.5583926439285278,
-0.4555682837963104,
0.006008952856063843,
0.14391149580478668,
-0.1649228036403656,
-0.1831779181957245,
-0.06505580991506577,
0.19406382739543915,
-0.372988224029541,
0.12348667532205582,
-0.13762980699539185,
-0.1571529060602188,
0.7056596279144287,
0.13954627513885498,
0.2706160843372345,
-0.056251443922519684,
-0.5538936257362366,
-0.2160111963748932,
-0.3919084668159485,
0.23655244708061218,
0.21663466095924377,
0.45467543601989746,
-0.26150935888290405,
0.37561744451522827,
-0.32607150077819824,
0.4126843214035034,
-0.2160010039806366,
-0.41569188237190247,
0.28633150458335876,
-0.6691496968269348,
-0.035520005971193314,
-0.18416327238082886,
0.8493220210075378,
0.8578787446022034,
0.5047818422317505,
-0.2574971616268158,
-0.32036641240119934,
-0.15680183470249176,
0.30463382601737976,
-0.927824854850769,
-0.019666379317641258,
-0.02280185930430889,
-0.5655158162117004,
-0.4040253460407257,
-0.19388966262340546,
-1.0361709594726562,
-0.5419051647186279,
-0.2901747524738312,
0.5976239442825317,
-0.3254276216030121,
-0.201030433177948,
0.07028181850910187,
-0.08033277094364166,
0.28504735231399536,
0.5078880190849304,
-0.64225172996521,
0.28280505537986755,
0.7172586917877197,
1.0553679466247559,
-0.7462959289550781,
0.005699288100004196,
0.02765125036239624,
-0.26779860258102417,
-0.4102883040904999,
0.8048557043075562,
-0.4087306559085846,
-0.38746213912963867,
0.000284349313005805,
-0.06398189812898636,
-0.0449097603559494,
-0.2991524338722229,
0.7760757207870483,
-0.2414024919271469,
-0.11957426369190216,
-0.08985013514757156,
-0.4226562976837158,
0.15718860924243927,
0.14940305054187775,
-0.3422253429889679,
0.9405293464660645,
0.21761435270309448,
-0.45362982153892517,
0.368927925825119,
-0.6228206157684326,
-0.42261552810668945,
0.05515733361244202,
0.062081851065158844,
-0.513918399810791,
-0.25709396600723267,
0.10824219882488251,
0.6280703544616699,
-0.28353390097618103,
0.21216921508312225,
-0.6866344809532166,
-0.6348755359649658,
0.7231220602989197,
-0.591655433177948,
0.3669516444206238,
0.4017578363418579,
-0.17936652898788452,
0.3062181770801544,
-0.8335184454917908,
0.36967015266418457,
0.15838325023651123,
-0.1664970964193344,
-0.10796516388654709,
-0.25811123847961426,
0.2926020324230194,
0.1288779377937317,
0.41971176862716675,
-0.21903009712696075,
0.08731959760189056,
0.07843931019306183,
0.5933219194412231,
0.9557417035102844,
-0.15331561863422394,
0.4381480813026428,
-0.467175155878067,
0.5137638449668884,
-0.6121737360954285,
0.12337193638086319,
0.13606508076190948,
-0.10553444921970367,
-0.8857061266899109,
-0.6245508193969727,
0.07736807316541672,
0.6027489304542542,
-0.43120425939559937,
0.6148608922958374,
-0.3334057629108429,
-0.9614656567573547,
-0.4146950840950012,
-0.011455779895186424,
0.30075445771217346,
0.16079778969287872,
0.201043501496315,
-0.5004827976226807,
-0.48712411522865295,
-1.024256706237793,
-0.6030304431915283,
-0.05645962059497833,
-0.1117125004529953,
0.35340994596481323,
0.19930286705493927,
-0.07457398623228073,
0.8976691365242004,
-0.12149234116077423,
0.12984508275985718,
-0.230283722281456,
-0.0655251070857048,
0.16507746279239655,
0.32693609595298767,
0.7877190709114075,
-0.301086962223053,
-0.4389854669570923,
-0.07415233552455902,
-0.377318799495697,
-0.3508835434913635,
-0.10405626893043518,
-0.30875760316848755,
-0.018643692135810852,
0.5303605198860168,
-0.17762276530265808,
0.21873778104782104,
0.7724931240081787,
-0.33572548627853394,
0.6677163243293762,
0.08412951976060867,
0.3804689347743988,
-1.2829093933105469,
0.1548190712928772,
0.20092131197452545,
-0.467655211687088,
-0.48328661918640137,
-0.08493892103433609,
0.11051121354103088,
0.004951123148202896,
-0.533913254737854,
0.929161787033081,
-0.10870231688022614,
-0.34974434971809387,
-0.014418579638004303,
0.35876381397247314,
0.22684206068515778,
0.5300007462501526,
-0.10042483359575272,
1.0343482494354248,
0.29336294531822205,
-0.44492658972740173,
0.4561314880847931,
-0.02200733870267868,
-0.5285348892211914,
1.2513293027877808,
-0.8165063858032227,
0.5292122960090637,
0.1976914405822754,
0.35281452536582947,
-1.1844303607940674,
0.20908203721046448,
0.17227408289909363,
-0.20083126425743103,
0.06789541244506836,
-0.07472620904445648,
-0.6184664964675903,
-0.23696789145469666,
-0.21851004660129547,
0.23301932215690613,
0.6065719127655029,
-0.481361985206604,
0.1601083129644394,
0.06850140541791916,
-0.28767621517181396,
-0.293037474155426,
-0.23746447265148163,
0.2073432356119156,
-0.6193276643753052,
-0.5712883472442627,
0.33821189403533936,
-0.5380773544311523,
-0.19529449939727783,
-0.4828673005104065,
-0.0807662233710289,
-0.1386551409959793,
0.2512744665145874,
-0.027670621871948242,
0.35436758399009705,
-0.34437018632888794,
-0.15013183653354645,
-0.26620087027549744,
0.3446337580680847,
-0.11128149181604385,
0.1890236884355545,
0.7265917658805847,
-0.5452019572257996,
-0.38684648275375366,
-0.6361748576164246,
-0.26958343386650085,
0.5884106755256653,
-0.09284405410289764,
0.3117959499359131,
0.7566224336624146,
0.03757394477725029,
-0.15495960414409637,
-0.4220792353153229,
-0.11116451770067215,
-0.5307081937789917,
0.6357640624046326,
-0.46115341782569885,
-0.7903953790664673,
0.40209394693374634,
-0.032014504075050354,
0.0773845762014389,
0.352545827627182,
0.6090583801269531,
-0.104758620262146,
0.757014811038971,
0.5353116989135742,
-0.06089198216795921,
0.7809207439422607,
0.2616795301437378,
-0.027071736752986908,
-0.6760191917419434,
-0.08197370171546936,
-0.7125659584999084,
-0.42197757959365845,
-0.8172146081924438,
-0.44784629344940186,
0.12400465458631516,
0.029299136251211166,
-0.38072678446769714,
0.6816146373748779,
-0.3216751217842102,
0.4253932535648346,
0.25867870450019836,
0.2633124589920044,
0.4601114094257355,
0.03404286503791809,
-0.02007438801229,
-0.02777225896716118,
-0.2612124979496002,
-0.7081729173660278,
0.9523742198944092,
0.62982177734375,
0.7501481175422668,
0.25316154956817627,
0.5007660984992981,
0.5860705971717834,
0.3563196063041687,
-1.0470664501190186,
0.7040992975234985,
-0.1410064697265625,
-0.11962078511714935,
-0.3216928541660309,
-0.46309441328048706,
-0.8979148864746094,
0.25519368052482605,
-0.4520435631275177,
-1.0569359064102173,
-0.11341584473848343,
-0.06567800045013428,
-0.053378626704216,
0.13338109850883484,
-0.42950132489204407,
0.6532948613166809,
-0.36028218269348145,
-0.29666292667388916,
-0.054393015801906586,
-0.3662142753601074,
0.2041635513305664,
-0.10407056659460068,
0.22405971586704254,
-0.5431686639785767,
-0.21486493945121765,
0.8751856088638306,
-0.08009958267211914,
0.6637076735496521,
0.3840990662574768,
-0.364004909992218,
0.14384181797504425,
0.43995484709739685,
0.4160347282886505,
-0.10136161744594574,
-0.10138203948736191,
0.2814570963382721,
0.28215742111206055,
-0.18238720297813416,
-0.7239859700202942,
0.43294888734817505,
-0.7443740367889404,
-0.20132073760032654,
-0.05459671467542648,
-0.5296881794929504,
-0.6738818883895874,
0.3099505603313446,
0.0014966906746849418,
0.38168033957481384,
-0.6575459241867065,
0.354607492685318,
0.2146911472082138,
-0.04158775508403778,
0.3238070607185364,
0.4555644392967224,
-0.4339655637741089,
-0.4310591518878937,
0.7957981824874878,
-0.08194007724523544,
0.5481758117675781,
0.2586153447628021,
0.3099733293056488,
-0.38330748677253723,
-0.37100207805633545,
-0.5966818928718567,
-0.059948839247226715,
-0.7417688965797424,
-0.04270291328430176,
-0.2861061990261078,
-0.5037851929664612,
-0.2776927947998047,
-0.3282597064971924,
-0.544616162776947,
-0.41964980959892273,
-0.061705704778432846,
0.3030760884284973,
0.6483536958694458,
0.5401176810264587,
0.5614984035491943,
0.3641170561313629,
-0.6734603643417358,
0.10055346041917801,
0.16204728186130524,
0.6747004389762878,
-0.22690676152706146,
-0.9483894109725952,
0.17139092087745667,
-0.2508241534233093,
-0.28436288237571716,
-0.5998444557189941,
0.17415615916252136,
0.133330300450325,
0.6047747135162354,
0.22841207683086395,
-0.12328656762838364,
0.5571958422660828,
-0.3585362136363983,
0.4191877841949463,
0.34769967198371887,
-0.8206601738929749,
0.3350939154624939,
-0.4706171751022339,
0.1056232675909996,
0.7296042442321777,
0.1634812355041504,
-1.0287377834320068,
-0.29585397243499756,
-0.608650803565979,
-0.6499574780464172,
0.19384346902370453,
0.43353271484375,
0.38507360219955444,
0.1789003312587738,
0.16626513004302979,
0.20603351294994354,
0.27225300669670105,
-0.5033491253852844,
-0.08276358246803284,
-0.14902682602405548,
-0.22220273315906525,
-0.20445504784584045,
0.038255926221609116,
-0.07173646986484528,
0.09487660229206085,
0.2443801611661911,
-0.20735378563404083,
0.404190331697464,
-0.08945527672767639,
-0.06677912920713425,
0.18966630101203918,
0.6177278757095337,
0.6176311373710632,
0.6325947046279907,
-0.3939456641674042,
-0.0481003001332283,
0.2883302569389343,
-0.4064983129501343,
-0.005035410635173321,
-0.07820984721183777,
-0.020259013399481773,
-0.11438700556755066,
0.2807702124118805,
0.7239139080047607,
0.2663811445236206,
-0.6065114140510559,
0.6093257069587708,
-0.35736438632011414,
0.10305806249380112,
0.03561895340681076,
0.2201641947031021,
0.020695962011814117,
0.267415314912796,
0.021540826186537743,
0.15157608687877655,
0.18097525835037231,
-0.7241268754005432,
0.2237088531255722,
0.6266520619392395,
-0.48920655250549316,
-0.1568775177001953,
0.13736869394779205,
0.4766400456428528,
-0.5856232047080994,
0.013390692882239819,
0.0776967704296112,
-0.36348581314086914,
0.6197314262390137,
0.6213760375976562,
0.9127419590950012,
0.005392834078520536,
0.028054840862751007,
0.47524991631507874,
0.16367706656455994,
-0.05400209128856659,
-0.020503949373960495,
-0.17396457493305206,
-0.7418643832206726,
-0.031105967238545418,
-0.7281410694122314,
-0.7682655453681946,
0.010326642543077469,
-0.5366145372390747,
0.684942364692688,
-0.634736955165863,
-0.2508089244365692,
-0.19389407336711884,
-0.15214426815509796,
-0.8621324300765991,
0.07055380195379257,
0.13235369324684143,
0.9075500965118408,
-0.6601983904838562,
0.493265837430954,
0.27563467621803284,
-0.10303619503974915,
-0.4677579700946808,
0.13446612656116486,
0.08224115520715714,
-1.324886441230774,
0.17844387888908386,
0.1349775195121765,
-0.362973690032959,
-0.2539905607700348,
-0.33799925446510315,
-0.9698522686958313,
1.0697181224822998,
0.32089197635650635,
-0.8054057955741882,
0.15644466876983643,
0.030070846900343895,
0.6854279041290283,
-0.25438979268074036,
0.4747893512248993,
0.8246188163757324,
0.3601404130458832,
0.3176703155040741,
-1.369144082069397,
0.12423306703567505,
-0.25591641664505005,
0.0888257697224617,
-0.051809750497341156,
-0.9003763794898987,
0.37485402822494507,
0.006273664999753237,
-0.2635704278945923,
0.5990371704101562,
0.6381271481513977,
0.32457810640335083,
0.3171231746673584,
0.5144528150558472,
0.0463663674890995,
0.7065038084983826,
-0.046106595546007156,
0.863365650177002,
-0.30846506357192993,
0.26277753710746765,
0.9808943271636963,
-0.07772532105445862,
1.1247563362121582,
0.3000909388065338,
-0.45696210861206055,
0.4155694246292114,
0.6631380319595337,
0.029399868100881577,
0.3774993121623993,
0.538337230682373,
0.22688238322734833,
0.06910420209169388,
-0.2349376231431961,
-0.4730585217475891,
0.7592312693595886,
0.15372860431671143,
-0.3995407223701477,
0.04995805397629738,
-0.42749205231666565,
0.5335826277732849,
0.2138925939798355,
-0.24055911600589752,
0.730076789855957,
0.07317717373371124,
-0.5949707627296448,
0.6982206106185913,
-0.1674068570137024,
1.098291277885437,
-0.4989754557609558,
0.14845940470695496,
-0.3284343481063843,
0.0696830078959465,
-0.1332511305809021,
-1.1360924243927002,
0.02164553478360176,
-0.03814380615949631,
0.3178479075431824,
-0.21742501854896545,
0.8314886093139648,
-0.16394735872745514,
-0.6487401723861694,
0.1656825691461563,
0.5728844404220581,
0.29555657505989075,
0.18748067319393158,
-0.7637203931808472,
0.13978847861289978,
-0.4275619387626648,
-0.12069296091794968,
0.4362565279006958,
0.46139997243881226,
-0.06528416275978088,
0.699232280254364,
0.5847245454788208,
0.14544980227947235,
-0.3299846947193146,
0.3306189477443695,
0.4992515444755554,
-0.5105835795402527,
-0.36180493235588074,
-0.9418625831604004,
-0.0017585119931027293,
-0.07940215617418289,
-0.5268385410308838,
0.8079156279563904,
0.2720258831977844,
0.4532916247844696,
0.22754745185375214,
0.6881924271583557,
0.130052849650383,
0.3239801526069641,
-0.6321145296096802,
0.8940446972846985,
-0.4979558289051056,
0.14742085337638855,
-0.8551201224327087,
-1.1000174283981323,
0.04518038406968117,
0.48989227414131165,
-0.08704402297735214,
0.4672934412956238,
0.4441247880458832,
0.7125768661499023,
0.04708946868777275,
0.030227383598685265,
0.427890419960022,
-0.12795089185237885,
0.12789465487003326,
0.404142826795578,
0.9191398024559021,
-0.03572843223810196,
0.5793318152427673,
-0.2726689577102661,
-0.2551766335964203,
-0.48295384645462036,
-1.237959384918213,
-0.889443039894104,
-0.6036208868026733,
-0.11188958585262299,
-0.5544901490211487,
0.23244482278823853,
1.0861055850982666,
0.7895811796188354,
-0.2674797475337982,
-0.43475595116615295,
0.33818453550338745,
-0.10592666268348694,
-0.32016703486442566,
-0.19446486234664917,
0.37499770522117615,
-0.17873424291610718,
-0.7142519950866699,
0.2897532880306244,
0.18370969593524933,
0.28478124737739563,
-0.2985464930534363,
-0.060705892741680145,
0.4289778769016266,
0.34886857867240906,
0.8091781735420227,
0.11710067838430405,
-0.5713220238685608,
-0.49224069714546204,
0.08659768104553223,
-0.4557752013206482,
0.21855174005031586,
0.7190369963645935,
-0.3854796588420868,
0.3185189664363861,
0.40461647510528564,
0.6205074191093445,
0.1557452529668808,
-0.07177109271287918,
0.3981200158596039,
-0.7300076484680176,
-0.02365720272064209,
0.07184386253356934,
0.3623488247394562,
0.44854095578193665,
-0.18296374380588531,
0.6273196935653687,
-0.009853607974946499,
-0.48918503522872925,
-0.7749524116516113,
0.14293664693832397,
-1.2542937994003296,
0.08269426226615906,
1.4641902446746826,
-0.025572674348950386,
-0.14170265197753906,
0.2505127191543579,
-0.4928961992263794,
0.1780480593442917,
-0.48694583773612976,
0.748101532459259,
0.5806041955947876,
-0.16530252993106842,
-0.12635290622711182,
-0.5560700297355652,
0.5425972938537598,
0.39397725462913513,
-1.0344161987304688,
0.07462374866008759,
0.08466615527868271,
0.458446741104126,
-0.07055850327014923,
0.7247747182846069,
-0.11203770339488983,
0.26223665475845337,
-0.2686765789985657,
-0.05729103833436966,
0.24524658918380737,
-0.1832609921693802,
-0.00154170673340559,
-0.22037217020988464,
0.35926225781440735,
0.029580144211649895
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10557v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10557v1
|
Second-Order Information Matters: Revisiting Machine Unlearning for Large Language Models
| 2024-03-13T18:57:30 | 2024-03-13T18:57:30 |
Kang Gu, Md Rafi Ur Rashid, Najrin Sultana, Shagufta Mehnaz
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
With the rapid development of Large Language Models (LLMs), we have witnessed
intense competition among the major LLM products like ChatGPT, LLaMa, and
Gemini. However, various issues (e.g. privacy leakage and copyright violation)
of the training corpus still remain underexplored. For example, the Times sued
OpenAI and Microsoft for infringing on its copyrights by using millions of its
articles for training. From the perspective of LLM practitioners, handling such
unintended privacy violations can be challenging. Previous work addressed the
``unlearning" problem of LLMs using gradient information, while they mostly
introduced significant overheads like data preprocessing or lacked robustness.
In this paper, contrasting with the methods based on first-order information,
we revisit the unlearning problem via the perspective of second-order
information (Hessian). Our unlearning algorithms, which are inspired by classic
Newton update, are not only data-agnostic/model-agnostic but also proven to be
robust in terms of utility preservation or privacy guarantee. Through a
comprehensive evaluation with four NLP datasets as well as a case study on
real-world datasets, our methods consistently show superiority over the
first-order methods.
|
[
-0.053699277341365814,
-0.41311943531036377,
0.2188509702682495,
-0.14395581185817719,
-0.23054787516593933,
0.2495332658290863,
-0.3354431390762329,
-0.46418407559394836,
-0.24977628886699677,
0.6353101134300232,
-0.3223448097705841,
-0.31560829281806946,
-0.8016713261604309,
-0.5673249363899231,
-0.4704059362411499,
1.1967360973358154,
0.1066986620426178,
0.32440659403800964,
-0.18941277265548706,
-0.4186610281467438,
0.18986038863658905,
-0.7266127467155457,
-0.7591010332107544,
-0.5156772136688232,
0.6060556173324585,
0.2766837477684021,
0.7430398464202881,
0.7911524176597595,
0.2943468391895294,
0.27819085121154785,
-0.4578074514865875,
0.19774878025054932,
-0.618983805179596,
0.16068889200687408,
-0.3249894678592682,
-0.5560874938964844,
-0.008322354406118393,
-0.05612296983599663,
0.5814584493637085,
0.8591461181640625,
-0.34535837173461914,
0.4437960386276245,
0.354479044675827,
1.134819746017456,
-0.8485863208770752,
0.19486933946609497,
-0.6851553320884705,
0.21948811411857605,
-0.07618967443704605,
-0.10188190639019012,
-0.45925623178482056,
-0.1472962200641632,
0.07763452082872391,
-0.5277203917503357,
0.30194854736328125,
-0.11503951251506805,
0.6511355638504028,
0.4233696758747101,
-0.15769733488559723,
-0.3385566771030426,
-0.9238488078117371,
0.9323883652687073,
-0.6339121460914612,
0.3994782269001007,
0.3352489173412323,
0.17504142224788666,
-0.5262218713760376,
-0.7135329842567444,
-0.2657915949821472,
0.09998171776533127,
-0.05400382727384567,
-0.006839785724878311,
-0.48776891827583313,
-0.13221096992492676,
0.29451578855514526,
0.10963023453950882,
-0.2775276005268097,
0.5950560569763184,
-0.5179056525230408,
0.057682160288095474,
0.633010983467102,
-0.15815062820911407,
-0.11483314633369446,
0.19518807530403137,
-0.38265261054039,
-0.16581670939922333,
-1.0584466457366943,
0.07193943113088608,
0.6311490535736084,
0.0928998664021492,
0.07530931383371353,
0.7651121616363525,
0.03966468200087547,
0.2723202705383301,
-0.07230443507432938,
0.06140316650271416,
0.31259581446647644,
0.1575699895620346,
-0.28409722447395325,
-0.15329132974147797,
0.7845556139945984,
0.127767413854599,
0.5447887182235718,
-0.3686199188232422,
-0.41074779629707336,
-0.316975474357605,
0.10512252897024155,
-0.6317488551139832,
0.00786090362817049,
0.30797702074050903,
-0.5257238149642944,
-0.24431200325489044,
0.025192152708768845,
-0.9478899836540222,
-0.7144457697868347,
-0.5541113615036011,
0.15921586751937866,
-0.06506659090518951,
-0.27365249395370483,
-0.1600584089756012,
0.2129918485879898,
0.039935510605573654,
0.2615882158279419,
-0.9556262493133545,
0.18326638638973236,
0.995397686958313,
0.6171374917030334,
-0.05159168317914009,
-0.17173409461975098,
-0.5147102475166321,
-0.07008731365203857,
-0.34355756640434265,
0.3469145596027374,
-0.373681902885437,
-0.41139528155326843,
0.32334616780281067,
-0.043584056198596954,
0.25531965494155884,
-0.7727883458137512,
0.46115124225616455,
-0.8744431138038635,
0.392622709274292,
-0.13424310088157654,
-0.5313438773155212,
-0.17396827042102814,
-0.26290085911750793,
-0.2845688760280609,
0.9741113781929016,
-0.03623141348361969,
-0.9054646492004395,
0.2096909135580063,
-0.4120628237724304,
-0.40371671319007874,
-0.24286285042762756,
-0.46148574352264404,
-0.5343219637870789,
0.42477846145629883,
-0.054821476340293884,
0.47020503878593445,
-0.2864282727241516,
0.442558228969574,
-0.3203921914100647,
-0.21658729016780853,
0.37568122148513794,
-0.6656721830368042,
0.880124568939209,
0.3642923831939697,
-0.3802576959133148,
-0.21236030757427216,
-0.8270018100738525,
0.037684954702854156,
0.3212931454181671,
-0.5061695575714111,
-0.30796006321907043,
0.1938803642988205,
-0.16235370934009552,
0.13379478454589844,
0.305086612701416,
-0.5141918659210205,
0.012630045413970947,
-0.3741784989833832,
0.4148159921169281,
0.9843836426734924,
-0.3052005469799042,
0.6377185583114624,
-0.2752131521701813,
0.40072306990623474,
0.13842712342739105,
0.21176663041114807,
0.027258364483714104,
-0.3855360150337219,
-0.8487952947616577,
0.11783292889595032,
0.4659571051597595,
0.590842068195343,
-0.3865310847759247,
-0.017843417823314667,
-0.24501344561576843,
-0.41902682185173035,
-0.5919143557548523,
0.2813473045825958,
0.6771757006645203,
0.43420901894569397,
0.4012150168418884,
-0.007380783092230558,
-0.4795759618282318,
-0.87492835521698,
-0.4773862063884735,
-0.2922256588935852,
-0.28114426136016846,
0.36076101660728455,
0.2140941619873047,
-0.38109418749809265,
0.7653295397758484,
-0.401617169380188,
-0.1439734697341919,
0.03771134093403816,
0.3563578426837921,
0.19970083236694336,
0.4769744873046875,
0.2849106192588806,
-0.656358540058136,
-0.21968938410282135,
0.09992623329162598,
-0.8393292427062988,
-0.0341956727206707,
0.03451773524284363,
0.13340625166893005,
0.7342073917388916,
0.5462648272514343,
-0.4597093164920807,
0.5353487133979797,
0.5962536334991455,
0.17692166566848755,
0.2806762456893921,
-0.6764344573020935,
-0.3921869993209839,
-0.982260525226593,
0.08306805789470673,
-0.06508750468492508,
-0.06645198911428452,
-0.7439530491828918,
-0.08400046080350876,
-0.06750161945819855,
0.07753127068281174,
-0.46117904782295227,
0.412463515996933,
-0.6263463497161865,
-0.3637159466743469,
-0.5743247866630554,
-0.05556607246398926,
-0.1530422419309616,
0.6168637871742249,
0.017593776807188988,
0.7254635691642761,
0.2561803460121155,
-0.5533345937728882,
-0.17500180006027222,
-0.047432489693164825,
-0.32894596457481384,
0.04443350061774254,
-0.5916081666946411,
0.4536266624927521,
-0.6603260636329651,
-0.07240285724401474,
-0.8653748035430908,
0.09409408271312714,
0.19696317613124847,
-0.47976717352867126,
0.6667102575302124,
-0.4657316207885742,
-0.5542221665382385,
0.047902192920446396,
-0.25624480843544006,
0.26443707942962646,
0.7311604022979736,
-0.9271893501281738,
0.29951390624046326,
0.7417130470275879,
-0.1008666604757309,
-1.300311803817749,
-0.667309582233429,
-0.13649390637874603,
-0.19444185495376587,
-0.2671372592449188,
0.2312324196100235,
0.04503535106778145,
-0.4137275815010071,
-0.15774472057819366,
-0.26337775588035583,
-0.34751638770103455,
0.1707412302494049,
0.40162593126296997,
0.04960585758090019,
-0.035776469856500626,
0.11916924268007278,
0.031077181920409203,
-0.20949488878250122,
0.19297251105308533,
-0.4043115973472595,
0.4797499179840088,
0.025505276396870613,
-0.24314340949058533,
-0.37293556332588196,
0.31814536452293396,
0.53470778465271,
0.05329715460538864,
0.8297301530838013,
0.6497141718864441,
-0.5387588143348694,
-0.23962609469890594,
-0.506618320941925,
-0.057553961873054504,
-0.4883768856525421,
0.33602648973464966,
0.16926345229148865,
-0.8310483694076538,
0.21697106957435608,
-0.161054328083992,
0.5731262564659119,
0.23736438155174255,
0.4946112334728241,
-0.4024127125740051,
0.7747528553009033,
0.8109176158905029,
-0.4234708249568939,
0.5558062791824341,
-0.23066388070583344,
0.1825193464756012,
-0.6713701486587524,
-0.46594417095184326,
-0.6135632395744324,
-0.36117851734161377,
-0.7110821008682251,
-0.14810483157634735,
0.16948732733726501,
0.4127410352230072,
-0.36937862634658813,
0.23094230890274048,
-0.17499153316020966,
0.595319926738739,
0.5483407974243164,
0.03724119812250137,
0.3807556927204132,
0.4953893721103668,
0.07085883617401123,
-0.032340407371520996,
-0.596269428730011,
-0.5432940721511841,
1.3815420866012573,
0.4076074957847595,
0.9248798489570618,
0.3373454213142395,
0.5816351175308228,
0.22868551313877106,
0.33410829305648804,
-0.7217851877212524,
0.32281503081321716,
-0.43128496408462524,
-0.3748379051685333,
-0.21277809143066406,
-0.5503819584846497,
-1.2646623849868774,
0.48535534739494324,
-0.09204918891191483,
-0.8812240958213806,
0.3066830337047577,
0.20416244864463806,
-0.11114420741796494,
0.38955578207969666,
-0.6595465540885925,
0.367266982793808,
-0.29299014806747437,
-0.5720877051353455,
-0.17769446969032288,
-0.6927809119224548,
0.22107596695423126,
-0.31416982412338257,
0.4650774896144867,
0.03181455284357071,
-0.22821341454982758,
0.9197442531585693,
-0.6209989190101624,
0.9425672292709351,
-0.2712741792201996,
-0.37152400612831116,
0.15227912366390228,
0.07445954531431198,
0.6763829588890076,
0.18327948451042175,
0.01843070052564144,
0.3781457245349884,
-0.07913088798522949,
-0.3004370927810669,
-0.708477795124054,
0.5514249205589294,
-0.9101169109344482,
-0.5989182591438293,
-0.33590346574783325,
-0.25794246792793274,
-0.2712717652320862,
0.1451387107372284,
0.5344291925430298,
0.37873154878616333,
0.09131132811307907,
0.10361738502979279,
0.7395723462104797,
-0.11380141228437424,
0.7009546160697937,
0.8061954379081726,
-0.19390560686588287,
-0.3324621021747589,
0.8041701316833496,
0.17403042316436768,
0.15569226443767548,
0.4686829745769501,
0.196994811296463,
-0.45758411288261414,
-0.7908469438552856,
-0.40109655261039734,
0.3875810205936432,
-0.7457514405250549,
-0.1234508529305458,
-0.5487398505210876,
-0.056127600371837616,
-0.19780780375003815,
0.18327242136001587,
-0.6271486282348633,
-0.4957773685455322,
-0.6179705858230591,
0.24270769953727722,
0.053379498422145844,
0.9383779764175415,
-0.19129496812820435,
0.3386935591697693,
-0.7586667537689209,
0.06701761484146118,
0.003829238237813115,
0.2028682678937912,
-0.1118139922618866,
-0.8695812225341797,
-0.17991116642951965,
0.22446587681770325,
-0.2205430120229721,
-0.4647989869117737,
0.2441233992576599,
-0.018969526514410973,
0.45491546392440796,
0.5504764914512634,
-0.1301594078540802,
0.4139540493488312,
-0.5719248652458191,
0.42984023690223694,
0.3023833930492401,
-0.7014013528823853,
0.1200254037976265,
-0.1894300878047943,
-0.10202718526124954,
0.5579271912574768,
0.41258320212364197,
-0.6019947528839111,
0.1567005068063736,
-0.8125877976417542,
-0.9271621704101562,
0.6807594895362854,
0.04127882793545723,
0.14621183276176453,
0.4706416726112366,
0.6802397966384888,
0.113803431391716,
0.6301376223564148,
-0.5558798909187317,
-0.4604754149913788,
0.16206367313861847,
-0.22905874252319336,
-0.28028586506843567,
-0.47995081543922424,
-0.0711594745516777,
-0.035169657319784164,
0.6922069191932678,
0.030092034488916397,
0.14460495114326477,
-0.2211664468050003,
-0.23150359094142914,
-0.04796888306736946,
0.4635853171348572,
0.5157584547996521,
0.6299881339073181,
0.16084501147270203,
0.14101332426071167,
0.10711553692817688,
-0.41308677196502686,
0.22302548587322235,
-0.08971774578094482,
-0.4272909462451935,
-0.07263477146625519,
0.1502799242734909,
0.3990724980831146,
0.08141395449638367,
-0.7106987237930298,
0.7493367195129395,
0.06407913565635681,
-0.07012566179037094,
-0.47935986518859863,
0.012522132135927677,
-0.08692655712366104,
0.367560476064682,
0.12680131196975708,
0.1542932093143463,
-0.024532301351428032,
-0.3639366626739502,
0.14298738539218903,
0.49364134669303894,
-0.47058504819869995,
-0.32239389419555664,
0.5020692348480225,
-0.25070083141326904,
-0.29931995272636414,
0.5249985456466675,
0.004295691382139921,
-0.28550347685813904,
0.3398973047733307,
0.3588913679122925,
0.7203971743583679,
-0.2957226037979126,
0.242615208029747,
0.02011454477906227,
0.35113009810447693,
-0.444634348154068,
0.12945041060447693,
-0.04942786321043968,
-0.7223793268203735,
-0.34078389406204224,
-0.42750903964042664,
-0.5420656204223633,
0.5765519142150879,
-0.7351202368736267,
-0.08935621380805969,
-0.8757310509681702,
-0.05933095142245293,
-0.11641520261764526,
-0.08834318816661835,
-0.5364508032798767,
-0.029863519594073296,
0.06418585032224655,
0.5072742104530334,
-0.333849161863327,
0.824130117893219,
0.6206339597702026,
-0.1144728884100914,
-0.304511696100235,
0.014029699377715588,
0.1796073317527771,
-0.9103134870529175,
0.6460489630699158,
0.011515957303345203,
-0.3349340558052063,
-0.21340179443359375,
-0.5141608119010925,
-0.862794816493988,
0.793425977230072,
0.6698158979415894,
-0.8156415224075317,
0.15461201965808868,
0.2821459472179413,
0.5721814632415771,
-0.11163853108882904,
0.12907370924949646,
0.4430629312992096,
0.125922292470932,
-0.02205066569149494,
-0.3200480043888092,
-0.2934303283691406,
-0.14591620862483978,
0.010927071794867516,
0.2030286341905594,
-0.7384955286979675,
0.7468288540840149,
-0.4830861985683441,
-0.4391961693763733,
0.04255738481879234,
0.7090364694595337,
-0.16599765419960022,
0.19637981057167053,
0.42183253169059753,
0.38742437958717346,
1.1253021955490112,
0.13812081515789032,
0.6858152747154236,
-0.12711066007614136,
0.5022831559181213,
1.3768340349197388,
-0.2669883370399475,
0.9580087661743164,
0.52110356092453,
-0.33960020542144775,
0.20052556693553925,
0.6015791893005371,
0.10567880421876907,
0.4553653597831726,
0.5747912526130676,
-0.2339812070131302,
0.1665903627872467,
-0.20318573713302612,
-0.28428128361701965,
0.4635361433029175,
0.1865795999765396,
-0.48572808504104614,
-0.309371680021286,
-0.3181236684322357,
0.5334979891777039,
0.05784422159194946,
-0.18523505330085754,
0.9043331146240234,
0.19880174100399017,
-0.4421774446964264,
0.7358800768852234,
0.2305852174758911,
0.5894731283187866,
-0.26192376017570496,
0.2539232671260834,
-0.3770006597042084,
0.5540780425071716,
-0.25327709317207336,
-0.5308734774589539,
0.1621282398700714,
0.28919750452041626,
-0.15966744720935822,
-0.1473352611064911,
0.45705363154411316,
-0.4826117753982544,
-0.22707442939281464,
0.5329002141952515,
0.5511730313301086,
0.184262216091156,
0.023028694093227386,
-0.7233489751815796,
-0.08737356215715408,
-0.10427705943584442,
-0.3257352113723755,
0.656082272529602,
0.1222962960600853,
0.23636244237422943,
0.6584176421165466,
0.5905135273933411,
-0.13853377103805542,
-0.05070529878139496,
0.08527204394340515,
0.8087717294692993,
-0.3893860876560211,
-0.13656389713287354,
-0.913417398929596,
0.18078283965587616,
0.020893627777695656,
-0.2688060700893402,
0.5290610790252686,
0.6474278569221497,
0.9849164485931396,
0.2493383139371872,
0.8761584758758545,
0.5629227161407471,
0.5531014204025269,
-0.7769887447357178,
0.7667737007141113,
-0.6137211918830872,
0.5917013883590698,
0.0487242229282856,
-0.808891236782074,
-0.31821075081825256,
0.25504809617996216,
-0.05134815722703934,
0.11638764292001724,
0.5516554117202759,
0.7035450339317322,
-0.03123573586344719,
0.39811819791793823,
0.17294584214687347,
0.16397371888160706,
0.1445387750864029,
0.4518526494503021,
0.8868431448936462,
-0.2848057150840759,
0.3840120732784271,
-0.3768412470817566,
-0.2348562479019165,
-0.03462944179773331,
-0.7569053173065186,
-0.9177651405334473,
-0.39607906341552734,
-0.22206757962703705,
-0.5122819542884827,
0.14608526229858398,
0.9375479817390442,
0.43668681383132935,
-0.8811786770820618,
-0.3126547932624817,
-0.1602809876203537,
0.13102510571479797,
0.04374220222234726,
-0.07052340358495712,
0.47310882806777954,
-0.3086507022380829,
-0.6632154583930969,
0.5217217206954956,
0.08822204917669296,
0.3416866362094879,
-0.3844251036643982,
0.022035926580429077,
0.28030234575271606,
-0.03274695202708244,
0.5759082436561584,
0.5741270780563354,
-0.4483751654624939,
-0.10486986488103867,
-0.31693774461746216,
-0.012648400850594044,
0.25324419140815735,
1.0513889789581299,
-0.6110830903053284,
0.02341179922223091,
0.30024608969688416,
1.068365454673767,
0.4633634388446808,
0.0581032857298851,
0.3122102916240692,
-0.7218916416168213,
0.19765247404575348,
-0.058646172285079956,
0.5286544561386108,
0.3518107831478119,
-0.3706597685813904,
0.5191274881362915,
0.20731890201568604,
-0.5368835926055908,
-0.8286653757095337,
0.34171023964881897,
-0.581322431564331,
-0.3663118779659271,
1.3099181652069092,
-0.32948628067970276,
-0.25144362449645996,
-0.08915834873914719,
0.11638814955949783,
0.27364611625671387,
-0.37761208415031433,
0.7121012806892395,
0.43706950545310974,
0.07357227057218552,
-0.003113706596195698,
-0.6050761342048645,
0.5076991319656372,
0.5883690118789673,
-0.6977097392082214,
0.4704778492450714,
0.33895280957221985,
0.23322629928588867,
0.04082265868782997,
0.435692697763443,
-0.27649614214897156,
-0.10120241343975067,
-0.39357396960258484,
-0.24332837760448456,
-0.13991938531398773,
-0.6172653436660767,
-0.9310343861579895,
0.23319630324840546,
0.07456253468990326,
-0.2035587728023529
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08904v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08904v1
|
Detecting Hallucination and Coverage Errors in Retrieval Augmented Generation for Controversial Topics
| 2024-03-13T18:47:00 | 2024-03-13T18:47:00 |
Tyler A. Chang, Katrin Tomanek, Jessica Hoffmann, Nithum Thain, Erin van Liemt, Kathleen Meier-Hellstern, Lucas Dixon
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We explore a strategy to handle controversial topics in LLM-based chatbots
based on Wikipedia's Neutral Point of View (NPOV) principle: acknowledge the
absence of a single true answer and surface multiple perspectives. We frame
this as retrieval augmented generation, where perspectives are retrieved from a
knowledge base and the LLM is tasked with generating a fluent and faithful
response from the given perspectives. As a starting point, we use a
deterministic retrieval system and then focus on common LLM failure modes that
arise during this approach to text generation, namely hallucination and
coverage errors. We propose and evaluate three methods to detect such errors
based on (1) word-overlap, (2) salience, and (3) LLM-based classifiers. Our
results demonstrate that LLM-based classifiers, even when trained only on
synthetic errors, achieve high error detection performance, with ROC AUC scores
of 95.3% for hallucination and 90.5% for coverage error detection on
unambiguous error cases. We show that when no training data is available, our
other methods still yield good results on hallucination (84.0%) and coverage
error (85.2%) detection.
|
[
-0.6481373906135559,
-1.1654351949691772,
0.6964148283004761,
0.2982015907764435,
-0.08354615420103073,
0.2397996187210083,
-0.010721172206103802,
-0.34724369645118713,
0.4753434956073761,
0.6003803014755249,
-0.457213819026947,
-0.5261475443840027,
-0.5893211960792542,
0.26030224561691284,
-0.6909598112106323,
0.8793518543243408,
-0.1529880315065384,
-0.09088654071092606,
-0.5010449290275574,
-0.004055174998939037,
-0.5077505111694336,
-0.5445803999900818,
-0.22758501768112183,
-0.14944398403167725,
0.5909027457237244,
0.6038705110549927,
0.5227477550506592,
0.3789651691913605,
0.4071182608604431,
0.28068551421165466,
-0.21406221389770508,
0.7670729160308838,
-0.5261998176574707,
0.401519238948822,
0.028333941474556923,
-0.4274159073829651,
-0.19245362281799316,
-0.241927832365036,
0.622855544090271,
0.6592482924461365,
-0.03422986716032028,
-0.3723547160625458,
0.014374718070030212,
0.6749566197395325,
-0.6717404127120972,
-0.2300599366426468,
-1.0863138437271118,
0.2553887367248535,
0.03360633924603462,
-0.4736484885215759,
-0.6083076000213623,
-0.39446336030960083,
-0.007033475674688816,
-0.5539917349815369,
0.580690860748291,
0.013664644211530685,
0.7879761457443237,
0.422609806060791,
-0.26235640048980713,
-0.4964301884174347,
-0.8593599200248718,
0.7922013401985168,
-0.5325429439544678,
0.17891226708889008,
0.5690019726753235,
0.23947308957576752,
-0.33962514996528625,
-0.2583754360675812,
-1.020004391670227,
-0.26891639828681946,
-0.08207178115844727,
0.12019374966621399,
-0.17875343561172485,
0.13735522329807281,
0.28421780467033386,
0.2915157973766327,
-0.36285147070884705,
-0.08952708542346954,
-0.3645668029785156,
-0.6002079844474792,
0.6046184301376343,
0.030631287023425102,
0.2087278962135315,
-0.5080206394195557,
-0.304587721824646,
0.06696546077728271,
-0.5920417904853821,
-0.39384499192237854,
0.7226752638816833,
0.046765610575675964,
0.18543373048305511,
0.8856968283653259,
-0.4468325674533844,
0.7218186855316162,
0.10321808606386185,
0.023307792842388153,
0.34923964738845825,
-0.2930852174758911,
-0.12228641659021378,
0.14395219087600708,
0.7350193858146667,
0.27205604314804077,
0.08301704376935959,
-0.28428012132644653,
-0.14038704335689545,
0.08080342411994934,
0.5649413466453552,
-0.47779950499534607,
-0.07448437064886093,
0.43923649191856384,
-0.0543866828083992,
-0.5258679389953613,
0.02518959902226925,
-0.6979437470436096,
-0.6351336240768433,
-0.10394991189241409,
0.6335657835006714,
-0.3413151204586029,
-0.19462715089321136,
-0.008088544011116028,
-0.09000920504331589,
0.3837815225124359,
0.5979686975479126,
-0.682200014591217,
0.09212817996740341,
0.5571051239967346,
0.8766714334487915,
-0.4543437063694,
-0.3144320249557495,
-0.4746382236480713,
-0.11763572692871094,
-0.537036120891571,
1.117213249206543,
-0.041361004114151,
-0.5075217485427856,
0.03621215373277664,
-0.15477171540260315,
0.10566066950559616,
-0.5984519124031067,
0.35271015763282776,
-0.5060383081436157,
0.39502695202827454,
-0.21275115013122559,
-0.6195994019508362,
-0.17909514904022217,
0.6932451128959656,
-0.6493674516677856,
0.8756796717643738,
0.04862765967845917,
-1.1190788745880127,
0.18368107080459595,
-0.2900032103061676,
-0.4172225892543793,
-0.1164550632238388,
-0.4808045029640198,
-0.5377740263938904,
0.039083994925022125,
-0.1077391654253006,
0.37298640608787537,
0.07601521164178848,
0.3775346279144287,
-0.10480482876300812,
-0.5724989771842957,
0.6064313650131226,
-0.5440415143966675,
0.4804132580757141,
-0.12599298357963562,
-0.6379141807556152,
0.2416323870420456,
-0.8781136274337769,
0.014600766822695732,
-0.15077516436576843,
-0.33146077394485474,
-0.18654562532901764,
0.13312286138534546,
0.006111196707934141,
-0.0587577149271965,
0.06629261374473572,
-0.48787716031074524,
-0.01879107765853405,
-0.35878971219062805,
-0.04790256544947624,
0.7979633212089539,
0.19587484002113342,
0.23928311467170715,
-0.5054686665534973,
0.3391609787940979,
0.24613279104232788,
0.026059526950120926,
-0.001561965560540557,
-0.5220138430595398,
-1.1428958177566528,
0.16123001277446747,
-0.009836808778345585,
0.7234991788864136,
-1.1038166284561157,
0.49961724877357483,
0.061913494020700455,
-0.571772575378418,
-0.42002660036087036,
0.20862622559070587,
0.4910074770450592,
0.8984167575836182,
0.508098840713501,
-0.14645478129386902,
-0.6135475039482117,
-0.9801157712936401,
-0.29290062189102173,
-0.49564307928085327,
0.14099183678627014,
0.6532739400863647,
0.4101155996322632,
-0.512351930141449,
0.8844504356384277,
-0.38581836223602295,
-0.12298542261123657,
-0.12062425911426544,
0.19746026396751404,
-0.05271701514720917,
0.36590927839279175,
0.1338396966457367,
-1.0963605642318726,
-0.3822662830352783,
-0.10441861301660538,
-0.9884137511253357,
-0.08892747759819031,
-0.21172493696212769,
-0.16441722214221954,
0.6139906048774719,
0.417085200548172,
-0.5700604915618896,
0.5257179737091064,
0.28340739011764526,
-0.1937682330608368,
0.6043071150779724,
-0.041706398129463196,
0.3059214651584625,
-1.0219762325286865,
-0.2733170688152313,
-0.18387790024280548,
-0.14249397814273834,
-0.8969973921775818,
-0.2845614552497864,
-0.11506465822458267,
0.4987483620643616,
-0.5825292468070984,
0.29682838916778564,
-0.19182740151882172,
0.0868501216173172,
-0.7142022848129272,
0.46871110796928406,
0.0006544660427607596,
0.30071038007736206,
0.11188073456287384,
0.6280349493026733,
0.3465692102909088,
-0.6754076480865479,
0.49671047925949097,
0.3135928213596344,
-0.17796126008033752,
0.475015252828598,
-0.5964906811714172,
0.30136364698410034,
-0.35684093832969666,
0.0195873212069273,
-1.1206425428390503,
-0.6104477643966675,
0.6754204034805298,
-0.7403842806816101,
0.16543537378311157,
0.031090406700968742,
-0.4419505298137665,
-0.03156234696507454,
-0.3162150979042053,
0.2990269362926483,
0.2759617865085602,
-0.541737973690033,
0.5010315179824829,
0.4930991530418396,
0.10989327728748322,
-1.0034739971160889,
-0.7371122241020203,
-0.06483916938304901,
-0.1217108741402626,
-0.4975995421409607,
0.279691219329834,
-0.1569012701511383,
-0.4676240384578705,
-0.08625397086143494,
-0.16524505615234375,
-0.00315191806294024,
0.2547890245914459,
0.4408709704875946,
0.25737088918685913,
0.000051085033192066476,
0.1864902228116989,
0.07418368011713028,
0.1175420731306076,
0.18714450299739838,
0.08594639599323273,
0.7646453976631165,
-0.16974006593227386,
-0.5831462144851685,
-0.1852012723684311,
0.1890001744031906,
0.3631914258003235,
0.3414421081542969,
0.6587883234024048,
0.308575302362442,
-0.5558933615684509,
-0.18177397549152374,
-0.8998861908912659,
-0.2562141716480255,
-0.4367176592350006,
0.35487765073776245,
-0.1446467489004135,
-0.7904476523399353,
0.6877946853637695,
0.40235698223114014,
-0.09370781481266022,
0.6329201459884644,
0.640038788318634,
-0.20697897672653198,
0.6987876296043396,
0.63092440366745,
0.13660122454166412,
0.2709502875804901,
-0.0677524283528328,
-0.04975707828998566,
-0.6888628005981445,
-0.537345826625824,
-0.46993306279182434,
-0.2172674834728241,
-0.866171658039093,
-0.5846351981163025,
0.2602890133857727,
0.18570686876773834,
-0.04031236097216606,
0.15216019749641418,
-0.6788843870162964,
0.42939049005508423,
0.5638185143470764,
0.30887821316719055,
0.5330461859703064,
0.27934107184410095,
0.09015468508005142,
-0.1777336299419403,
-0.41986414790153503,
-0.5227680206298828,
0.9996129274368286,
0.15534034371376038,
0.634153425693512,
0.0744175910949707,
0.8937829732894897,
0.38130465149879456,
0.42640766501426697,
-0.9282822012901306,
0.5771489143371582,
0.458711713552475,
-0.6914520859718323,
-0.5250410437583923,
-0.6517900824546814,
-0.654693067073822,
0.33686256408691406,
-0.2596716284751892,
-0.44707220792770386,
0.28399235010147095,
0.16122475266456604,
-0.03430912271142006,
0.4942796230316162,
-0.42584142088890076,
0.555063009262085,
-0.17484700679779053,
-0.4246639609336853,
-0.0011480635730549693,
-0.6658401489257812,
0.6078270673751831,
-0.25291502475738525,
0.09453964233398438,
-0.05306306853890419,
0.06450498849153519,
0.5874030590057373,
-0.13053110241889954,
0.7875246405601501,
-0.1596771478652954,
-0.06609410047531128,
0.48104819655418396,
0.1038435697555542,
0.27725255489349365,
0.27021947503089905,
0.06623023748397827,
0.13577258586883545,
-0.34562474489212036,
-0.25114667415618896,
-0.6275462508201599,
0.5890041589736938,
-0.8310751914978027,
-0.8525487184524536,
-0.6079807281494141,
-0.6645720601081848,
-0.28571245074272156,
0.16588464379310608,
0.4976637363433838,
-0.031373340636491776,
-0.20439811050891876,
0.1234830692410469,
1.0928051471710205,
-0.43965187668800354,
0.013207362033426762,
0.44410136342048645,
-0.40175890922546387,
-0.3007161617279053,
0.9872174263000488,
0.053537145256996155,
0.3245096802711487,
0.3537251651287079,
0.0006791026680730283,
0.0006716122152283788,
-0.742160975933075,
-0.41906440258026123,
0.0680454894900322,
-0.8757564425468445,
-0.32747480273246765,
-1.0032721757888794,
-0.69254469871521,
-0.19835413992404938,
0.09841562062501907,
-0.35912394523620605,
-0.3770289719104767,
-0.47208529710769653,
-0.1514069139957428,
0.5126690864562988,
0.5303837656974792,
-0.12761585414409637,
0.18676330149173737,
-0.5069761276245117,
0.47785961627960205,
0.06160356104373932,
0.04242047294974327,
-0.3057350516319275,
-0.6358217597007751,
0.15041957795619965,
0.09771808236837387,
-0.4988802969455719,
-1.0481008291244507,
0.316182941198349,
-0.25784391164779663,
0.512536346912384,
0.23530356585979462,
0.19453828036785126,
0.4337806701660156,
-0.39365285634994507,
0.5753680467605591,
0.10502801090478897,
-0.7618127465248108,
0.7179857492446899,
-0.07794689387083054,
-0.15476775169372559,
0.6731401681900024,
0.5184189081192017,
-0.6409633755683899,
-0.74261873960495,
-0.6441856026649475,
-0.8276391625404358,
0.4197984039783478,
0.32466980814933777,
0.35058489441871643,
-0.25462380051612854,
0.40265506505966187,
0.24121510982513428,
0.39027801156044006,
-0.8244403004646301,
-0.3546290695667267,
-0.3048316240310669,
0.020520979538559914,
0.22222855687141418,
-0.42286548018455505,
-0.25448718667030334,
0.07801762223243713,
0.7288553714752197,
-0.2688869833946228,
0.2366633266210556,
0.6116634607315063,
-0.18647481501102448,
-0.06506878137588501,
0.32126960158348083,
0.8265507817268372,
0.7031059861183167,
-0.31205499172210693,
0.23880423605442047,
0.1183670163154602,
-0.6154273152351379,
0.18808794021606445,
0.14839567244052887,
-0.5720381736755371,
0.39540591835975647,
0.24099494516849518,
0.6345616579055786,
-0.020337555557489395,
-0.6757432818412781,
0.4474017024040222,
0.02522352710366249,
-0.32108578085899353,
-0.5117847919464111,
0.15510033071041107,
-0.17598313093185425,
0.17266257107257843,
0.5194200873374939,
0.1314912885427475,
0.25316327810287476,
-0.40986281633377075,
0.3583807945251465,
0.5711426138877869,
-0.43855467438697815,
0.05512293800711632,
0.47191423177719116,
-0.0612129382789135,
-0.3102247714996338,
0.623658299446106,
-0.32500162720680237,
-0.6870858073234558,
0.6943827867507935,
0.2678746283054352,
0.7125695943832397,
-0.014540858566761017,
0.5536070466041565,
0.13662473857402802,
0.39225637912750244,
-0.07877988368272781,
0.3290357291698456,
-0.06605469435453415,
-1.1400201320648193,
-0.4093441069126129,
-0.40846407413482666,
-0.8593521118164062,
0.12571126222610474,
-0.5615272521972656,
0.19017143547534943,
-0.4211852550506592,
0.03390439227223396,
-0.1267537623643875,
0.06062823906540871,
-0.32809221744537354,
0.07648678123950958,
-0.09331932663917542,
0.7139491438865662,
-0.6737545728683472,
0.4832758903503418,
0.4228803515434265,
-0.37237364053726196,
-0.45986494421958923,
0.24073733389377594,
0.019030839204788208,
-0.6877325773239136,
0.6045363545417786,
0.26560312509536743,
-0.2261858582496643,
-0.2373621016740799,
-0.5190587043762207,
-0.5430954694747925,
1.0043141841888428,
0.10973009467124939,
-0.6195214986801147,
-0.08605031669139862,
0.2003307342529297,
0.47190752625465393,
-0.07146576792001724,
0.1935506910085678,
0.319316029548645,
0.362384170293808,
0.34417402744293213,
-0.6287031173706055,
-0.023857606574892998,
0.038637757301330566,
-0.2232864797115326,
-0.06237872689962387,
-0.6108543276786804,
0.6672192811965942,
-0.2503666579723358,
-0.14956240355968475,
0.10701499879360199,
0.7293311953544617,
0.7241336107254028,
0.7106291651725769,
0.5364688038825989,
0.3251546323299408,
0.9490614533424377,
-0.15587320923805237,
0.9485957622528076,
-0.09471388161182404,
0.2727137506008148,
0.8951342105865479,
-0.09779305756092072,
0.758918046951294,
0.7527608871459961,
0.06353044509887695,
0.322664737701416,
0.6508569121360779,
-0.08446408063173294,
0.48703381419181824,
0.35920998454093933,
-0.4130867123603821,
-0.12192787975072861,
-0.10031990706920624,
-0.4113242030143738,
0.2664736807346344,
0.37710845470428467,
-0.23900054395198822,
-0.03505130484700203,
0.11430208384990692,
-0.040542662143707275,
0.1753942370414734,
-0.12116477638483047,
0.696407675743103,
-0.02518155425786972,
-0.7088249921798706,
0.5734211802482605,
-0.07611917704343796,
0.8255890607833862,
-0.13109034299850464,
-0.18053507804870605,
-0.6053088903427124,
0.05191648006439209,
-0.4111335277557373,
-0.7754021883010864,
0.4528767168521881,
-0.045147694647312164,
-0.3822876214981079,
-0.01385707501322031,
1.0937591791152954,
-0.33176282048225403,
-0.5335316061973572,
0.14941762387752533,
0.6547880172729492,
0.45487430691719055,
-0.1536036878824234,
-0.33993983268737793,
0.3190901577472687,
0.16751396656036377,
-0.13422612845897675,
0.0481535829603672,
0.4451321065425873,
0.052169349044561386,
0.5343716740608215,
0.5053554773330688,
0.09340917319059372,
0.11935766786336899,
-0.11760587990283966,
0.9142656922340393,
-0.6280047297477722,
-0.000751093786675483,
-0.9299629926681519,
0.37455058097839355,
-0.2738302946090698,
-0.22523079812526703,
0.8974794149398804,
0.5724902749061584,
0.9950451254844666,
0.08428396284580231,
0.8586111068725586,
0.0798758715391159,
0.6619349718093872,
-0.55451500415802,
0.7503687143325806,
-0.45069366693496704,
0.5303066968917847,
-0.30661651492118835,
-0.9087511897087097,
-0.41713666915893555,
0.8563668131828308,
-0.21043220162391663,
-0.0035082469694316387,
0.3850131332874298,
0.8642177581787109,
0.09472745656967163,
0.032222017645835876,
0.4241569936275482,
0.3138848543167114,
0.3099074363708496,
0.39090558886528015,
1.2522178888320923,
-0.5116682052612305,
0.6387205123901367,
-0.3936682343482971,
-0.1786956787109375,
-0.42258599400520325,
-0.6370298266410828,
-0.9942464232444763,
-0.6078345775604248,
-0.42513543367385864,
-0.9744541049003601,
-0.061986684799194336,
0.4620983302593231,
0.331707626581192,
-0.8178159594535828,
0.11394502222537994,
-0.421956866979599,
0.7047020196914673,
0.2638692557811737,
-0.35475045442581177,
0.27785393595695496,
-0.5058653354644775,
-0.6926473379135132,
0.2986578643321991,
0.24070902168750763,
0.1202860027551651,
-0.5778428912162781,
-0.1555715799331665,
-0.0282222218811512,
0.05830089747905731,
0.47678518295288086,
0.3521467447280884,
-0.8679852485656738,
-0.39305707812309265,
0.3725655972957611,
-0.24219733476638794,
0.10479752719402313,
0.6651251912117004,
-0.8658208250999451,
0.5706982612609863,
0.4411132037639618,
0.8830683827400208,
0.4433661699295044,
-0.02631688304245472,
0.2510059177875519,
-0.5391889810562134,
0.02790842391550541,
0.465008407831192,
0.04327654838562012,
0.5871180295944214,
-0.5327324271202087,
0.43340587615966797,
0.5983619689941406,
-0.5992058515548706,
-1.1971255540847778,
0.3404325246810913,
-0.9462980628013611,
-0.21100249886512756,
1.2029790878295898,
0.21279168128967285,
-0.15112324059009552,
-0.231130450963974,
-0.25679436326026917,
0.30636486411094666,
0.014548493549227715,
1.3278300762176514,
0.9371744990348816,
-0.30265846848487854,
-0.028242439031600952,
-0.7427056431770325,
0.544746994972229,
0.4142688512802124,
-0.979775071144104,
-0.14694425463676453,
0.647655725479126,
0.1939210146665573,
0.7002552151679993,
0.6270118355751038,
-0.019887130707502365,
0.3945711553096771,
-0.02967999503016472,
-0.027914082631468773,
0.21564780175685883,
-0.5045536756515503,
-0.07928763329982758,
0.017368195578455925,
-0.08673100918531418,
-0.1678188443183899
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08890v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08890v1
|
From "um" to "yeah": Producing, predicting, and regulating information flow in human conversation
| 2024-03-13T18:20:24 | 2024-03-13T18:20:24 |
Claire Augusta Bergey, Simon DeDeo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IT, math.IT, q-bio.NC
|
Conversation demands attention. Speakers must call words to mind, listeners
must make sense of them, and both together must negotiate this flow of
information, all in fractions of a second. We used large language models to
study how this works in a large-scale dataset of English-language conversation,
the CANDOR corpus. We provide a new estimate of the information density of
unstructured conversation, of approximately 13 bits/second, and find
significant effects associated with the cognitive load of both retrieving, and
presenting, that information. We also reveal a role for backchannels -- the
brief yeahs, uh-huhs, and mhmms that listeners provide -- in regulating the
production of novelty: the lead-up to a backchannel is associated with
declining information rate, while speech downstream rebounds to previous rates.
Our results provide new insights into long-standing theories of how we respond
to fluctuating demands on cognitive resources, and how we negotiate those
demands in partnership with others.
|
[
-0.640536367893219,
-0.9606702923774719,
0.6096802949905396,
0.2124660313129425,
-0.09792067110538483,
-0.2521248161792755,
-0.21091075241565704,
-0.6325588226318359,
0.4517463743686676,
0.701702892780304,
-0.6858535408973694,
-0.07220850884914398,
-0.5227286219596863,
-0.2859298288822174,
-0.5312747359275818,
1.111085295677185,
0.7043224573135376,
-0.056178878992795944,
-0.1034720316529274,
0.051615696400403976,
-0.8009094595909119,
-0.5999522805213928,
-0.7346601486206055,
-0.39391008019447327,
0.7782588601112366,
0.47133705019950867,
0.7997857332229614,
0.7195859551429749,
0.3897804915904999,
0.33342498540878296,
-0.21358045935630798,
-0.34141162037849426,
-0.7719247937202454,
0.4478035569190979,
-0.22955118119716644,
-0.6606807112693787,
-0.07971333712339401,
0.06695596873760223,
0.6815086603164673,
1.1395506858825684,
-0.2946104407310486,
-0.08135642111301422,
0.11623343080282211,
0.47159701585769653,
-0.32851728796958923,
0.1348361223936081,
-0.703711986541748,
-0.15440650284290314,
-0.2551305592060089,
-0.6777063012123108,
-0.254384845495224,
-0.2663500905036926,
0.5095030665397644,
-0.4717922508716583,
0.09018228948116302,
0.11514067649841309,
0.7449817061424255,
0.31639543175697327,
-0.49036434292793274,
-0.49707984924316406,
-0.8738595247268677,
0.7042056918144226,
-0.29062420129776,
0.3417470157146454,
0.45641279220581055,
0.10819541662931442,
-0.3721764087677002,
-0.8552002906799316,
-0.593099057674408,
-0.02663940191268921,
0.09967900067567825,
0.029366154223680496,
-0.29589706659317017,
-0.052141252905130386,
0.1193263903260231,
0.2822871804237366,
0.031664151698350906,
-0.14056865870952606,
-0.6424595713615417,
-0.09853186458349228,
0.5023883581161499,
0.30924826860427856,
0.3351217806339264,
-0.0016131593147292733,
-0.2317592203617096,
-0.003082385053858161,
-0.3418225646018982,
0.22489821910858154,
0.3356361389160156,
0.08388028293848038,
-0.11163871735334396,
0.40358421206474304,
-0.22807899117469788,
0.3294052481651306,
0.14667995274066925,
0.06586890667676926,
-0.11799220740795135,
-0.25427359342575073,
-0.2383255809545517,
-0.037061434239149094,
0.671085774898529,
0.48442867398262024,
0.18223132193088531,
-0.17758843302726746,
0.2661057710647583,
0.06621669977903366,
0.42744526267051697,
-0.5538783073425293,
-0.37549909949302673,
0.274607390165329,
-0.23838019371032715,
-0.21388626098632812,
0.16121968626976013,
-0.7692890167236328,
-0.3916918635368347,
-0.34847426414489746,
0.289792537689209,
-0.28930068016052246,
-0.3369726240634918,
0.292292058467865,
-0.40059658885002136,
0.25086891651153564,
0.3771548569202423,
-0.7890109419822693,
0.4988495707511902,
0.3990824520587921,
0.6840359568595886,
-0.05022331699728966,
-0.21967683732509613,
-0.5748348236083984,
0.16650022566318512,
-0.4757995307445526,
0.9542670845985413,
-0.289993017911911,
-0.6198486685752869,
-0.2521292269229889,
-0.23143039643764496,
0.14368878304958344,
-0.27627962827682495,
0.5526576638221741,
-0.4319794476032257,
0.2763134241104126,
-0.2749249041080475,
-0.32207128405570984,
-0.12838183343410492,
-0.15032048523426056,
-0.5847855806350708,
0.5784026980400085,
-0.20372648537158966,
-0.7531905174255371,
0.21934880316257477,
-0.42130064964294434,
-0.6404010653495789,
0.34945961833000183,
-0.43416067957878113,
0.10805879533290863,
0.39562106132507324,
-0.41705557703971863,
0.3738569915294647,
-0.31371384859085083,
0.15419606864452362,
-0.2685360610485077,
-0.07910745590925217,
1.0080246925354004,
-0.45932382345199585,
0.6306131482124329,
0.26988646388053894,
-0.1658502072095871,
-0.20518982410430908,
-0.8172448873519897,
0.06771790236234665,
-0.10133816301822662,
-0.596136212348938,
-0.2714066803455353,
0.22445420920848846,
-0.2688996195793152,
0.09052325040102005,
0.05691225081682205,
-0.512610137462616,
-0.050339359790086746,
-0.25995951890945435,
0.6882060766220093,
0.5787402391433716,
0.34254908561706543,
0.3759963810443878,
-0.53678959608078,
0.11021091043949127,
-0.019285591319203377,
-0.0553031750023365,
-0.3213156759738922,
-0.8667960166931152,
-0.9007202982902527,
-0.1290939599275589,
0.013036757707595825,
0.4253625273704529,
-0.3743428885936737,
0.12337698042392731,
-0.2712784707546234,
-0.3344583809375763,
-0.5785008668899536,
-0.12058617919683456,
0.055253054946660995,
0.4533924162387848,
0.05608716234564781,
-0.590662956237793,
-0.4783937335014343,
-0.5987983345985413,
-0.06202983483672142,
-0.1865682750940323,
-0.2882981598377228,
0.22923970222473145,
-0.010774768888950348,
0.05343474820256233,
0.9088706970214844,
-0.41980770230293274,
-0.3195424973964691,
-0.1081530824303627,
0.7454490661621094,
0.2303415983915329,
0.271729052066803,
0.10939744859933853,
-0.7676894068717957,
0.006926615256816149,
-0.1081468015909195,
-0.4611304700374603,
-0.1433670073747635,
-0.20804260671138763,
-0.1305621862411499,
-0.10460959374904633,
0.6131715178489685,
-0.5602397322654724,
0.46932873129844666,
0.4408074915409088,
-0.2506244480609894,
0.15271446108818054,
-0.4505766034126282,
0.14866124093532562,
-0.8500787019729614,
-0.17075106501579285,
-0.31561827659606934,
0.05011506751179695,
-0.7271867394447327,
-0.23902317881584167,
-0.2706741392612457,
-0.13883447647094727,
-0.5540730357170105,
0.26506587862968445,
-0.6235405802726746,
0.12148860841989517,
-0.479896605014801,
0.3108595013618469,
0.06655512750148773,
0.5171505212783813,
-0.07128572463989258,
0.4383576810359955,
0.6927314400672913,
-1.06222665309906,
0.5080625414848328,
0.09960799664258957,
-0.547973096370697,
0.9245242476463318,
-0.5961151123046875,
0.3668493926525116,
-0.37159252166748047,
0.30378249287605286,
-1.4510301351547241,
-0.6239991784095764,
-0.19542436301708221,
-0.6723863482475281,
0.17647762596607208,
-0.0847858116030693,
-0.18054254353046417,
-0.2981317639350891,
-0.11263742297887802,
0.08734577149152756,
0.34599557518959045,
0.008537350222468376,
0.6545296907424927,
0.9357743859291077,
-0.5549394488334656,
-0.1123746782541275,
-1.4085217714309692,
0.15040968358516693,
-0.042723797261714935,
-0.8146591186523438,
0.3378455638885498,
-0.2877572476863861,
-0.5115481019020081,
-0.02176312915980816,
0.03542204573750496,
-0.17269818484783173,
0.22062039375305176,
0.4077937602996826,
0.009398954920470715,
-0.04811421409249306,
0.3148135840892792,
-0.2446439564228058,
-0.024024734273552895,
0.282121479511261,
-0.4730713665485382,
0.5071448087692261,
0.08156614750623703,
-0.1457650363445282,
-0.6724600791931152,
0.7633458375930786,
0.5695660710334778,
0.2059062421321869,
0.7308844327926636,
0.39715376496315,
-0.10381937026977539,
0.2382371425628662,
-0.625052273273468,
-0.39072665572166443,
-0.42270728945732117,
0.30114465951919556,
-0.4632379412651062,
-0.9548176527023315,
0.39521485567092896,
0.2845444977283478,
0.13380897045135498,
0.27571722865104675,
0.7226788401603699,
-0.35955342650413513,
0.9543407559394836,
0.6228841543197632,
0.19447050988674164,
0.4986960291862488,
0.08404003083705902,
0.15578126907348633,
-0.4027870297431946,
-0.2532505393028259,
-0.5662888288497925,
-0.45240283012390137,
-0.8283101320266724,
-0.29975682497024536,
0.33927658200263977,
0.014540276490151882,
0.24847093224525452,
0.03217665106058121,
-0.1368628442287445,
0.5062901973724365,
0.6730341911315918,
-0.2260776311159134,
0.3416256904602051,
-0.32502856850624084,
0.2602696418762207,
0.11826059967279434,
-0.5441204309463501,
-0.37109312415122986,
1.0189639329910278,
0.35346463322639465,
0.9886749386787415,
0.24430227279663086,
0.493595689535141,
0.3118707835674286,
0.03937548026442528,
-0.855146586894989,
0.6106549501419067,
0.24847497045993805,
-0.6013692021369934,
-0.2378387749195099,
-0.469014972448349,
-1.3000141382217407,
0.021518882364034653,
-0.1915500909090042,
-1.101792335510254,
0.27509865164756775,
0.21200735867023468,
-0.5481751561164856,
-0.00956726260483265,
-1.0259863138198853,
0.524307370185852,
-0.16501638293266296,
-0.36990198493003845,
-0.487236350774765,
-0.8348273038864136,
0.16015851497650146,
0.2950437664985657,
0.4595339298248291,
-0.26428714394569397,
-0.09014292806386948,
0.677790105342865,
-0.0020758849568665028,
0.8257592916488647,
0.27115175127983093,
-0.177724227309227,
0.6266382932662964,
0.08785580098628998,
0.28520435094833374,
0.08940815925598145,
0.25639981031417847,
0.28179726004600525,
0.14478756487369537,
-0.36430689692497253,
-0.4211995303630829,
0.5728369355201721,
-0.8267077207565308,
-0.6752977967262268,
-0.06423579156398773,
-0.7518932223320007,
0.08977676928043365,
0.04738390073180199,
0.6783115267753601,
0.43789100646972656,
-0.3527469336986542,
0.5798735022544861,
0.8424298167228699,
0.17201578617095947,
0.26820024847984314,
0.45129260420799255,
-0.159508615732193,
-0.16016070544719696,
0.9102921485900879,
0.39553219079971313,
0.4289774000644684,
0.5128670930862427,
0.3599047362804413,
-0.23828327655792236,
-0.2762295603752136,
0.0501546673476696,
0.17588403820991516,
-0.6987029910087585,
0.09574972838163376,
-0.9602729678153992,
-0.034665871411561966,
-0.6490416526794434,
0.21737538278102875,
-0.21163035929203033,
-0.5039404034614563,
-0.3102477192878723,
0.016170989722013474,
0.17388002574443817,
1.0151187181472778,
-0.2553810775279999,
0.3870246410369873,
-0.5858229398727417,
0.3373998999595642,
0.8488564491271973,
0.20106568932533264,
-0.09213117510080338,
-0.5486064553260803,
-0.30332860350608826,
0.11819041520357132,
-0.5497974753379822,
-1.0177021026611328,
0.2183419167995453,
0.18412087857723236,
0.5305233597755432,
0.22941485047340393,
-0.05502944439649582,
0.2671481668949127,
-0.2763034403324127,
0.7301243543624878,
0.13094064593315125,
-0.8466632962226868,
0.35537728667259216,
-0.4322989881038666,
0.3828364908695221,
0.24159307777881622,
0.10775171965360641,
-0.843167781829834,
-0.6399303078651428,
-0.8105366826057434,
-0.9928736686706543,
0.6932091116905212,
0.11790462583303452,
0.47967883944511414,
-0.2564105689525604,
-0.2371908724308014,
-0.02328522689640522,
0.5074604749679565,
-0.48712900280952454,
-0.04062316566705704,
-0.0844971314072609,
0.17909793555736542,
0.16288365423679352,
-0.2120783030986786,
-0.18573586642742157,
0.05264541506767273,
0.2545677125453949,
0.1355808824300766,
0.5492013096809387,
0.1799229383468628,
0.10090891271829605,
-0.4040328562259674,
0.6999516487121582,
0.6740221381187439,
0.4064784348011017,
-0.1698446422815323,
0.3275930881500244,
-0.054571542888879776,
-0.4326004385948181,
-0.1867000162601471,
-0.1949693262577057,
0.026383081451058388,
-0.13818004727363586,
-0.06914074718952179,
0.9711259603500366,
0.38953763246536255,
-0.5184938311576843,
0.32187291979789734,
-0.17703945934772491,
-0.2843078076839447,
-0.21879935264587402,
0.40405887365341187,
0.15256847441196442,
0.37598180770874023,
0.4545046389102936,
0.10784222930669785,
0.10313310474157333,
-1.1362608671188354,
0.19546958804130554,
0.2198694497346878,
-0.3517097532749176,
-0.3493324816226959,
0.5894480347633362,
0.3291654586791992,
-0.5001452565193176,
0.44284725189208984,
0.04958121106028557,
-0.02323577180504799,
0.36222293972969055,
0.23224110901355743,
0.818223774433136,
-0.012604658491909504,
-0.09695052355527878,
-0.11667098104953766,
-0.05275976285338402,
-0.10570643842220306,
0.4369427561759949,
-0.19695062935352325,
-0.7358912825584412,
-0.5102106332778931,
-0.3404664993286133,
-0.5506648421287537,
0.29846546053886414,
-0.8366797566413879,
0.08494861423969269,
-0.4951532185077667,
-0.6291607618331909,
0.27498260140419006,
-0.22514386475086212,
-0.9092410802841187,
-0.0472688153386116,
0.43188756704330444,
0.6754749417304993,
-0.5255782604217529,
0.7227389216423035,
0.5004039406776428,
-0.4328341782093048,
-0.693412721157074,
0.19655561447143555,
0.1502799540758133,
-0.6562814712524414,
0.3917161524295807,
0.11648677289485931,
-0.43842220306396484,
0.3182886242866516,
-0.7160651087760925,
-0.9323564171791077,
0.7528076171875,
0.26388198137283325,
-0.4367566704750061,
-0.03465087339282036,
-0.08539669960737228,
0.6468375325202942,
-0.3745118975639343,
0.09093774855136871,
0.7335448265075684,
0.34709230065345764,
0.1827848106622696,
-0.604789674282074,
-0.4057410657405853,
-0.21145842969417572,
-0.04637277126312256,
0.31223610043525696,
-0.6712559461593628,
0.9265445470809937,
-0.4660625457763672,
-0.6140977144241333,
0.23563198745250702,
0.8405250906944275,
-0.2684541642665863,
0.18101631104946136,
0.2641874849796295,
0.4010743498802185,
0.8325120806694031,
-0.09363053739070892,
1.0219647884368896,
-0.0246362816542387,
-0.12294280529022217,
1.1038320064544678,
-0.08025044202804565,
0.9403939843177795,
0.7381719350814819,
-0.07116477936506271,
0.5636720061302185,
0.2039370983839035,
0.35320669412612915,
0.3914962112903595,
0.40050673484802246,
-0.025624126195907593,
-0.023156430572271347,
-0.5355314612388611,
-0.13641607761383057,
0.4386722445487976,
0.6755518913269043,
-0.11287057399749756,
0.17524351179599762,
0.1618071347475052,
-0.054083652794361115,
-0.07623528689146042,
-0.20351053774356842,
0.9994627237319946,
0.05624254420399666,
-1.0342472791671753,
0.37883344292640686,
-0.4075410068035126,
0.4664430022239685,
-0.6676129102706909,
0.2962982952594757,
-0.2382478415966034,
-0.02210150472819805,
0.043336424976587296,
-1.162494421005249,
0.16336403787136078,
-0.1605520397424698,
-0.2491440773010254,
-0.34110498428344727,
0.47686657309532166,
-0.6703647971153259,
0.03497463837265968,
0.34958791732788086,
0.47689029574394226,
0.4802721440792084,
0.03047356568276882,
-0.29037556052207947,
0.19961486756801605,
-0.1043999195098877,
-0.20218069851398468,
0.36861974000930786,
0.9286400675773621,
0.15691561996936798,
0.5301493406295776,
0.6034861207008362,
0.39932218194007874,
0.3761836588382721,
0.25898823142051697,
0.6412171721458435,
-0.668708324432373,
-0.8161706924438477,
-0.5367389917373657,
0.5060029625892639,
-0.08380545675754547,
-0.5315232872962952,
0.30320072174072266,
-0.04031798616051674,
0.9054598808288574,
0.29004186391830444,
0.7146034836769104,
-0.13010771572589874,
0.6523590087890625,
-0.5148047208786011,
0.4895651638507843,
-0.433887243270874,
0.1396821141242981,
-0.046398889273405075,
-0.5160908102989197,
0.1237565353512764,
0.3161467909812927,
-0.3134140968322754,
-0.24386052787303925,
0.7311442494392395,
0.6054434180259705,
0.12278562039136887,
0.39841943979263306,
0.5932283401489258,
0.4841143786907196,
0.1848985105752945,
0.443918377161026,
0.9949994087219238,
-0.04069167748093605,
1.0718156099319458,
-0.16098366677761078,
-0.13595029711723328,
-0.40767818689346313,
-0.6968423128128052,
-0.5435360074043274,
-0.7645525932312012,
-0.26534417271614075,
-0.29755088686943054,
-0.24432609975337982,
0.8098039031028748,
0.7035999894142151,
-0.519583523273468,
-0.6137548685073853,
-0.19147205352783203,
-0.014218980446457863,
-0.1604415327310562,
-0.2652447819709778,
-0.13598214089870453,
-0.5357232093811035,
-0.6124204993247986,
0.32020115852355957,
0.5814046859741211,
0.39864581823349,
-0.2613902688026428,
0.21458537876605988,
-0.22848276793956757,
0.38002899289131165,
0.39238354563713074,
0.5457773208618164,
-0.6086103320121765,
-0.23812004923820496,
-0.125,
-0.494377076625824,
0.2505495846271515,
1.072002649307251,
-0.5427144169807434,
0.5404815077781677,
0.5988036394119263,
0.6855503916740417,
0.4325092136859894,
-0.20975889265537262,
0.7884936928749084,
-0.8674095869064331,
0.3441052734851837,
0.1985170543193817,
0.21038344502449036,
0.39847877621650696,
-0.2768787145614624,
0.16426587104797363,
0.3892698585987091,
-0.5687684416770935,
-0.45691534876823425,
0.4827541708946228,
-0.809249997138977,
-0.23267288506031036,
0.8104714751243591,
0.16416847705841064,
-0.5270112752914429,
-0.5247963666915894,
-0.44997674226760864,
0.39767006039619446,
-0.7199583053588867,
1.0168516635894775,
1.0731183290481567,
-0.2822135090827942,
-0.24808214604854584,
-0.6100766062736511,
0.42838677763938904,
0.5038630366325378,
-0.7575513124465942,
0.1573261022567749,
0.5257362127304077,
-0.09714659303426743,
0.5404115915298462,
0.9440344572067261,
0.21182896196842194,
0.24063588678836823,
0.06372801959514618,
-0.337128221988678,
0.5153141617774963,
-0.520760178565979,
0.07410864531993866,
0.23819999396800995,
-0.022319376468658447,
-0.32433176040649414
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09738v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09738v4
|
Evaluating Large Language Models as Generative User Simulators for Conversational Recommendation
| 2024-03-13T18:16:21 | 2024-03-25T23:53:01 |
Se-eun Yoon, Zhankui He, Jessica Maria Echterhoff, Julian McAuley
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
Synthetic users are cost-effective proxies for real users in the evaluation
of conversational recommender systems. Large language models show promise in
simulating human-like behavior, raising the question of their ability to
represent a diverse population of users. We introduce a new protocol to measure
the degree to which language models can accurately emulate human behavior in
conversational recommendation. This protocol is comprised of five tasks, each
designed to evaluate a key property that a synthetic user should exhibit:
choosing which items to talk about, expressing binary preferences, expressing
open-ended preferences, requesting recommendations, and giving feedback.
Through evaluation of baseline simulators, we demonstrate these tasks
effectively reveal deviations of language models from human behavior, and offer
insights on how to reduce the deviations with model selection and prompting
strategies.
|
[
-0.4161350727081299,
-0.8043354153633118,
0.5229936838150024,
0.3842785060405731,
0.02822260744869709,
0.15507657825946808,
-0.38724830746650696,
-0.3772304952144623,
0.3235326111316681,
0.6232807040214539,
-0.5727475881576538,
-0.23464861512184143,
0.05898141488432884,
-0.03301632031798363,
-0.44730958342552185,
0.7324906587600708,
0.182204008102417,
0.1008264496922493,
-0.46826303005218506,
0.3166665732860565,
-0.5371075868606567,
-0.6835557818412781,
-0.63536536693573,
-0.6077656149864197,
0.41155892610549927,
0.2540431320667267,
0.8426521420478821,
0.209849551320076,
0.22040237486362457,
0.38138872385025024,
-0.08680032938718796,
-0.022306358441710472,
-0.6560214757919312,
0.10871545225381851,
-0.2649277150630951,
-0.28839316964149475,
-0.36670541763305664,
0.11293566972017288,
0.5575350522994995,
0.7727963924407959,
-0.4165348708629608,
0.17604751884937286,
-0.09679918736219406,
0.29919567704200745,
-0.4490409195423126,
0.03819655999541283,
-0.31977590918540955,
-0.10260878503322601,
-0.000021550995370489545,
-0.040615592151880264,
-0.6774933934211731,
-0.3429366648197174,
0.4455321431159973,
-0.5792983770370483,
0.3395307660102844,
0.37430498003959656,
0.3682967722415924,
-0.5057834982872009,
-0.44102224707603455,
-0.0516008697450161,
-1.081742763519287,
0.7554047703742981,
-0.6554746627807617,
0.49517783522605896,
0.49840354919433594,
0.6632385849952698,
-0.3691367506980896,
-0.690942108631134,
-0.7491012215614319,
-1.0204832553863525,
-0.13711440563201904,
-0.1120503768324852,
-0.22098803520202637,
0.1682545244693756,
0.49402081966400146,
0.417042076587677,
-0.4250561594963074,
-0.16917216777801514,
-0.41542384028434753,
-0.33135202527046204,
0.7027274966239929,
0.2504911720752716,
0.5411655306816101,
-0.01586644910275936,
-0.14850208163261414,
-0.27834436297416687,
-0.5166646242141724,
-0.2717812955379486,
0.7072146534919739,
0.16419698297977448,
-0.2672450542449951,
0.6909961104393005,
-0.3652391731739044,
0.6607608199119568,
0.01790609024465084,
0.1193607747554779,
0.2106320559978485,
-0.5563890337944031,
-0.11559773236513138,
-0.2661260664463043,
0.736335813999176,
0.6170654296875,
0.6349446773529053,
-0.33820873498916626,
-0.13538265228271484,
0.1622040569782257,
0.4745935797691345,
-0.7759842276573181,
-0.32330864667892456,
0.04154108464717865,
-0.520002543926239,
-0.2231488972902298,
0.03002064861357212,
-0.7509714365005493,
-0.39781180024147034,
-0.34094730019569397,
0.3091607987880707,
-0.41310301423072815,
-0.38715824484825134,
0.2527995705604553,
-0.37150081992149353,
-0.06282635033130646,
0.4493907690048218,
-1.29317307472229,
0.7349783182144165,
0.5779094696044922,
0.7023209929466248,
-0.08532287925481796,
-0.44300398230552673,
-0.3840901255607605,
-0.06747816503047943,
-0.25156059861183167,
0.6855335235595703,
-0.6002232432365417,
-0.8479650020599365,
-0.0018278670031577349,
-0.15846291184425354,
0.0726814866065979,
-0.6958047151565552,
0.5329168438911438,
-0.42055052518844604,
-0.0169555451720953,
-0.4755428731441498,
-0.4962339699268341,
0.005482826381921768,
0.3626977503299713,
-0.5370277166366577,
0.7694903612136841,
0.4227398633956909,
-0.30345726013183594,
0.21002601087093353,
-0.6821991801261902,
-0.1990824192762375,
0.2396705448627472,
0.25261661410331726,
0.09148366749286652,
0.16889001429080963,
0.14527063071727753,
0.32995307445526123,
-0.3225208818912506,
0.21960052847862244,
-0.4784415662288666,
-0.45076367259025574,
0.5561529397964478,
-0.36798155307769775,
0.6667159795761108,
0.2898988127708435,
0.28330671787261963,
0.4787352681159973,
-0.511310338973999,
0.060040850192308426,
0.1859174519777298,
-0.23400412499904633,
-0.3700927793979645,
0.019883375614881516,
0.6418278217315674,
-0.010785495862364769,
0.07146298140287399,
-0.6822197437286377,
0.4747300446033478,
-0.6149418354034424,
0.5471874475479126,
0.4764358103275299,
0.1276707947254181,
0.440944641828537,
-0.5987942218780518,
0.6677879691123962,
-0.2794966697692871,
0.19564522802829742,
-0.16361571848392487,
-0.42370444536209106,
-0.8057999014854431,
-0.10785698145627975,
0.2650301456451416,
0.07998348772525787,
-0.37873247265815735,
0.3911859095096588,
-0.06709406524896622,
-0.7649504542350769,
-0.42645490169525146,
0.1482192724943161,
0.3684539794921875,
-0.004660445731133223,
0.046440206468105316,
-0.4472127854824066,
-0.609309196472168,
-0.9008193612098694,
-0.3544940948486328,
-0.48711058497428894,
-0.25431621074676514,
0.38202720880508423,
0.5965986251831055,
-0.5037368535995483,
0.8790537118911743,
-0.36030399799346924,
0.08593588322401047,
-0.43224939703941345,
0.3222029209136963,
-0.21430842578411102,
0.44194841384887695,
0.71220463514328,
-0.5734042525291443,
-0.3293814957141876,
-0.08374841511249542,
-0.2936055064201355,
-0.06008801981806755,
-0.19609850645065308,
-0.13798481225967407,
-0.1590936779975891,
0.3083234429359436,
-0.5995251536369324,
0.04749263823032379,
0.6853399872779846,
-0.477295845746994,
0.7422555088996887,
-0.5035480856895447,
0.1881537139415741,
-0.961915135383606,
0.13089396059513092,
0.24120764434337616,
-0.3332359194755554,
-0.5620552897453308,
0.06719247251749039,
-0.17718006670475006,
-0.23575450479984283,
-0.3136235773563385,
0.8592081069946289,
-0.2663939595222473,
-0.2153962105512619,
-0.0681784451007843,
-0.02956218086183071,
-0.12488120794296265,
0.18927158415317535,
-0.04366648942232132,
0.7479124069213867,
0.32435762882232666,
-0.41711172461509705,
0.6759743094444275,
0.21737907826900482,
-0.6601060032844543,
0.4920271635055542,
-0.9395766854286194,
0.4423072934150696,
0.04415474086999893,
0.4996802508831024,
-1.026528239250183,
-0.35418763756752014,
0.11335945874452591,
-0.3194703161716461,
-0.3164580464363098,
-0.10627530515193939,
-0.610804557800293,
-0.4483988285064697,
-0.16129888594150543,
0.3555387556552887,
0.7169824838638306,
-0.35234978795051575,
0.6378360390663147,
0.35974985361099243,
0.11411355435848236,
-0.05372798442840576,
-0.11196419596672058,
0.22246164083480835,
-0.03992022946476936,
-0.5272098183631897,
0.37530800700187683,
-0.3906020224094391,
-0.45299965143203735,
-0.23378773033618927,
0.3634333908557892,
0.1315881311893463,
0.14220905303955078,
0.34715035557746887,
0.15669669210910797,
-0.006339121609926224,
-0.20757266879081726,
-0.16284479200839996,
0.015375600196421146,
0.21356117725372314,
-0.2265409678220749,
1.0067716836929321,
-0.2057279497385025,
-0.5034982562065125,
-0.6935117840766907,
0.19179002940654755,
0.7029711008071899,
-0.15542848408222198,
0.4960643947124481,
0.5098929405212402,
-0.2797432541847229,
-0.18851828575134277,
-0.7001405954360962,
-0.5482463240623474,
-0.4900949001312256,
0.41957300901412964,
-0.41939204931259155,
-0.658601701259613,
0.4195951223373413,
-0.11968697607517242,
0.06509935855865479,
0.13025425374507904,
0.8740100264549255,
-0.007035844027996063,
1.3928180932998657,
0.48888877034187317,
0.10402882099151611,
0.3528040647506714,
-0.19821317493915558,
0.24272418022155762,
-0.6489136815071106,
-0.38161250948905945,
-0.527079701423645,
-0.17190071940422058,
-0.3634316921234131,
-0.44097891449928284,
0.14348094165325165,
0.013403824530541897,
-0.06478609889745712,
0.34934911131858826,
-0.011516355909407139,
0.44021135568618774,
0.7949689626693726,
0.08389392495155334,
0.18657349050045013,
0.0453219935297966,
-0.2156834900379181,
-0.0026557594537734985,
-0.2961887717247009,
-0.6073064208030701,
0.8352111577987671,
0.34792646765708923,
0.8139503598213196,
-0.024425523355603218,
0.2914430797100067,
0.596975564956665,
0.338296502828598,
-1.0463111400604248,
0.7948380708694458,
0.08373608440160751,
-0.559520423412323,
-0.229145348072052,
-0.3084207773208618,
-0.781495213508606,
0.11682691425085068,
-0.4006754457950592,
-1.0371668338775635,
-0.09527383744716644,
0.5813287496566772,
-0.2762988209724426,
0.009751023724675179,
-0.7506303191184998,
0.9504245519638062,
-0.12224628031253815,
-0.062486663460731506,
-0.6478697061538696,
-0.23133257031440735,
0.30377939343452454,
0.07701054215431213,
-0.10126883536577225,
-0.07359205186367035,
0.511398196220398,
0.6600553393363953,
-0.22798991203308105,
0.8844756484031677,
-0.1381136029958725,
0.13327156007289886,
0.1907883733510971,
0.5785351395606995,
0.3713793456554413,
-0.08173144608736038,
-0.17647428810596466,
0.147477924823761,
0.24364882707595825,
-0.14326322078704834,
-0.8592188358306885,
0.7008597254753113,
-0.7398961782455444,
-0.6148611307144165,
-0.1976993829011917,
-0.48059186339378357,
-0.25040170550346375,
-0.06179273501038551,
-0.2726711928844452,
0.246270552277565,
-0.9498322606086731,
0.35293257236480713,
0.013832966797053814,
-0.2493276745080948,
-0.05505004897713661,
0.5023310780525208,
-0.5966958403587341,
-0.2696608304977417,
0.8373554348945618,
-0.2695716917514801,
0.34977537393569946,
0.13482852280139923,
0.48967626690864563,
-0.3780525326728821,
-0.3441210389137268,
-0.6430283188819885,
0.2145117223262787,
-0.37343642115592957,
0.34315225481987,
-0.7326036691665649,
0.0384044386446476,
-0.5308839678764343,
-0.18671168386936188,
-0.26147449016571045,
-0.2090446501970291,
0.03653046861290932,
-0.1894630640745163,
0.14293481409549713,
0.7849064469337463,
0.30070486664772034,
0.5010417103767395,
-0.6212119460105896,
0.27074623107910156,
0.5268875956535339,
0.24220922589302063,
0.16878440976142883,
-0.4116474688053131,
-0.029049545526504517,
0.40265846252441406,
-0.2841546833515167,
-0.6720166206359863,
0.5842937231063843,
0.11274413764476776,
0.6224644184112549,
0.7059952020645142,
-0.02145559899508953,
0.4940544366836548,
-0.47111546993255615,
0.8333368897438049,
0.22144317626953125,
-1.1041144132614136,
0.4242253303527832,
-0.4409346580505371,
0.03075382299721241,
0.2977239489555359,
0.23369938135147095,
-0.939979612827301,
-0.12367641180753708,
-0.4392393231391907,
-0.37331199645996094,
0.6889661550521851,
0.31254976987838745,
0.72685307264328,
-0.12887895107269287,
0.319439560174942,
-0.09402967244386673,
0.08208159357309341,
-0.42567282915115356,
-0.016887038946151733,
-0.01937898062169552,
-0.014143817126750946,
-0.28148508071899414,
-0.598412811756134,
-0.13997679948806763,
-0.21638162434101105,
0.26586633920669556,
-0.08237229287624359,
0.12641125917434692,
-0.22598055005073547,
0.21102359890937805,
-0.2208888828754425,
0.15595056116580963,
0.5216397047042847,
0.6679565906524658,
-0.37110957503318787,
-0.05703439936041832,
0.1789988875389099,
-0.30002376437187195,
0.17898143827915192,
-0.21540004014968872,
-0.21678222715854645,
-0.2062464952468872,
0.0045575289987027645,
0.7565170526504517,
0.23620863258838654,
-1.0655938386917114,
0.4345117509365082,
-0.301302045583725,
-0.12090229243040085,
-0.3811211585998535,
0.31498947739601135,
0.2779703736305237,
0.007326909340918064,
-0.08819147199392319,
0.07591809332370758,
0.37474146485328674,
-0.9582836627960205,
-0.028187647461891174,
0.44079917669296265,
-0.4884803593158722,
-0.7342327237129211,
0.4707135558128357,
0.5205380916595459,
-0.837152361869812,
0.8246361613273621,
0.04180573299527168,
-0.3226393163204193,
0.4980890452861786,
1.0248063802719116,
0.8540686964988708,
-0.32412153482437134,
0.5040552020072937,
0.36001530289649963,
0.036957789212465286,
-0.4971938729286194,
0.15633122622966766,
-0.12113580107688904,
-0.9623686671257019,
-0.06414119899272919,
-0.698871910572052,
-0.6378463506698608,
0.039397306740283966,
-0.5633372664451599,
0.43149328231811523,
-0.31366971135139465,
-0.30364009737968445,
0.3073437511920929,
-0.2894105613231659,
-0.5484639406204224,
-0.12214205414056778,
-0.011543503031134605,
0.7298027276992798,
-0.8682350516319275,
0.8034933805465698,
0.8638507723808289,
-0.39138028025627136,
-0.44216516613960266,
-0.03239672631025314,
-0.043765630573034286,
-0.5794087648391724,
0.7576161623001099,
0.06805165112018585,
-0.15668517351150513,
-0.03520714491605759,
-0.36823639273643494,
-0.39405491948127747,
0.5351905822753906,
0.5567178130149841,
-0.6063703894615173,
-0.06907366961240768,
0.02903735265135765,
0.7857628464698792,
-0.4038228392601013,
0.549938976764679,
0.5833728909492493,
0.36232563853263855,
0.23873364925384521,
-1.1844364404678345,
0.005820609629154205,
-0.24964645504951477,
0.35402974486351013,
-0.050199780613183975,
-0.46759673953056335,
0.6452981233596802,
-0.4005580246448517,
-0.16050536930561066,
0.42152971029281616,
0.508699357509613,
0.3995290994644165,
0.08151359111070633,
0.8953197598457336,
0.18121442198753357,
0.4321320354938507,
0.22796547412872314,
1.2396461963653564,
-0.2966693639755249,
0.21970397233963013,
0.8247181177139282,
-0.6896762251853943,
0.8883842825889587,
0.5113112926483154,
-0.23474332690238953,
0.4561587870121002,
0.4106900095939636,
-0.11086396127939224,
0.23394054174423218,
0.6860190629959106,
-0.3599740266799927,
-0.41644486784935,
-0.3358224332332611,
0.05617939680814743,
0.6082341074943542,
0.3364517092704773,
-0.23854582011699677,
0.03023175150156021,
0.06613468378782272,
-0.17169013619422913,
0.17913192510604858,
0.18611207604408264,
0.8610239028930664,
-0.04702974110841751,
-0.9496030807495117,
0.4890836477279663,
0.2689017951488495,
0.40118518471717834,
-0.5905783772468567,
-0.4085034132003784,
-0.06810696423053741,
0.11241903156042099,
0.14497239887714386,
-0.4947875142097473,
-0.020420560613274574,
-0.07320374995470047,
-0.15987829864025116,
-0.289933443069458,
0.5144990086555481,
-0.3289352059364319,
-0.4753081798553467,
0.35631829500198364,
0.36756274104118347,
0.2701236307621002,
-0.1873723864555359,
-0.5154924392700195,
-0.1354251354932785,
-0.06655951589345932,
-0.20135743916034698,
0.2947973608970642,
-0.07212331146001816,
-0.3946673572063446,
0.9719699621200562,
0.9750075936317444,
0.30497434735298157,
-0.27320656180381775,
0.5462340712547302,
0.6499674320220947,
-0.4959726929664612,
-0.47673994302749634,
-0.7799371480941772,
0.2250988930463791,
-0.21500056982040405,
-0.3321254253387451,
0.7764849066734314,
0.545361340045929,
0.965283989906311,
-0.36381375789642334,
0.6631874442100525,
0.02877107262611389,
0.3327306807041168,
-0.28257957100868225,
0.6961740255355835,
-0.24774976074695587,
0.3474244475364685,
-0.12278703600168228,
-1.1441214084625244,
0.023947378620505333,
0.6312941312789917,
-0.19163860380649567,
0.3081301748752594,
0.3244292438030243,
0.9970738291740417,
-0.2510056495666504,
0.014328387565910816,
0.588371217250824,
0.1181027963757515,
0.39931339025497437,
0.13019198179244995,
1.1653742790222168,
-0.07717172056436539,
0.20796184241771698,
-0.24902434647083282,
-0.13304156064987183,
-0.47611576318740845,
-0.6552667617797852,
-1.06466543674469,
-0.49905866384506226,
-0.19394604861736298,
-0.38233938813209534,
0.13716301321983337,
1.399863600730896,
1.0846368074417114,
-0.8347781896591187,
-0.7147745490074158,
-0.027400141581892967,
-0.2544597089290619,
-0.3772980570793152,
-0.24458925426006317,
-0.05062444508075714,
0.0036684663500636816,
-1.019775629043579,
0.4843882620334625,
0.07231364399194717,
0.22179804742336273,
-0.7729559540748596,
-0.11380819231271744,
0.3476006090641022,
0.09979904443025589,
0.6187441349029541,
0.18040652573108673,
-0.9401952028274536,
-0.24896283447742462,
0.03271202743053436,
-0.06460972130298615,
-0.40208879113197327,
1.151644229888916,
-0.7490500211715698,
0.7863276600837708,
0.6005352139472961,
0.2499271035194397,
0.5038465857505798,
0.22643010318279266,
1.063906192779541,
-0.5968254208564758,
0.23967596888542175,
0.24690549075603485,
0.3124135136604309,
0.23691041767597198,
-0.10051953792572021,
0.10795920342206955,
0.1259007304906845,
-0.469109445810318,
-0.833472490310669,
0.1611710637807846,
-1.0784437656402588,
0.027637047693133354,
1.2374752759933472,
-0.23194797337055206,
0.08728708326816559,
-0.17880450189113617,
-0.6945164203643799,
-0.13720716536045074,
-0.5981348156929016,
0.9834060072898865,
0.5511434674263,
0.011211743578314781,
-0.03404852747917175,
-0.625383198261261,
0.42990735173225403,
0.1646440178155899,
-0.7217800617218018,
0.3180806040763855,
0.6484276652336121,
0.21588222682476044,
0.05051182210445404,
0.6938307285308838,
0.12532386183738708,
0.1731511652469635,
-0.020854255184531212,
0.20263583958148956,
0.04766365513205528,
-0.1896458864212036,
-0.0025659438688308,
-0.04393194615840912,
0.28241053223609924,
0.15627421438694
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08851v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08851v1
|
PAPERCLIP: Associating Astronomical Observations and Natural Language with Multi-Modal Models
| 2024-03-13T18:00:00 | 2024-03-13T18:00:00 |
Siddharth Mishra-Sharma, Yiding Song, Jesse Thaler
|
astro-ph.IM
|
astro-ph.IM, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
We present PAPERCLIP (Proposal Abstracts Provide an Effective Representation
for Contrastive Language-Image Pre-training), a method which associates
astronomical observations imaged by telescopes with natural language using a
neural network model. The model is fine-tuned from a pre-trained Contrastive
Language-Image Pre-training (CLIP) model using successful observing proposal
abstracts and corresponding downstream observations, with the abstracts
optionally summarized via guided generation using large language models (LLMs).
Using observations from the Hubble Space Telescope (HST) as an example, we show
that the fine-tuned model embodies a meaningful joint representation between
observations and natural language through tests targeting image retrieval
(i.e., finding the most relevant observations using natural language queries)
and description retrieval (i.e., querying for astrophysical object classes and
use cases most relevant to a given observation). Our study demonstrates the
potential for using generalist foundation models rather than task-specific
models for interacting with astronomical data by leveraging text as an
interface.
|
[
-0.4690874516963959,
-0.6087735295295715,
0.7095267176628113,
0.20362445712089539,
-0.399069219827652,
-0.1925199031829834,
-0.47197622060775757,
-0.7739771604537964,
0.6734262704849243,
0.6637322902679443,
-0.3951038420200348,
-0.4965362846851349,
-0.5426763892173767,
-0.011719862930476665,
-0.6436739563941956,
1.3816797733306885,
-0.0375853031873703,
-0.2067258358001709,
-0.5263513326644897,
0.10854744166135788,
-0.12109741568565369,
-0.2160354107618332,
-0.2656218409538269,
-0.18106108903884888,
0.5244104266166687,
0.14629702270030975,
0.8578605651855469,
0.8511918783187866,
1.0972038507461548,
0.32234057784080505,
0.03978169709444046,
0.2626846134662628,
0.015823498368263245,
-0.4300526976585388,
-0.18872353434562683,
-0.33338993787765503,
-0.34579914808273315,
0.24859516322612762,
0.46439528465270996,
1.0843462944030762,
0.05331283062696457,
0.1505458652973175,
-0.03199214115738869,
0.3170792758464813,
-0.6256045699119568,
0.31161972880363464,
-0.5702548623085022,
-0.16287095844745636,
-0.2557697594165802,
-0.3281603753566742,
-0.09050055593252182,
-0.1082332506775856,
0.4314889907836914,
-0.9666746258735657,
0.20973673462867737,
0.057200878858566284,
0.9234675765037537,
0.08495936542749405,
-0.3264203667640686,
-0.7167329788208008,
-0.7461957931518555,
0.7884714007377625,
-0.7546184659004211,
0.2764829099178314,
0.5535627007484436,
0.3079645037651062,
0.1600707620382309,
-0.8297697305679321,
-0.6743009686470032,
-0.46951666474342346,
-0.2175956666469574,
0.16266855597496033,
0.06411564350128174,
0.06486089527606964,
-0.20543134212493896,
0.20069192349910736,
-0.44283008575439453,
-0.23568108677864075,
-0.37832221388816833,
-0.0629991814494133,
0.28394079208374023,
0.16976326704025269,
0.03630496934056282,
-0.46883416175842285,
-0.23876935243606567,
-0.15272043645381927,
-0.45006436109542847,
-0.0906982421875,
0.4161530137062073,
0.4623713195323944,
-0.44024306535720825,
0.6543026566505432,
0.0015217806212604046,
0.9502873420715332,
0.043935611844062805,
-0.11586610972881317,
-0.008466937579214573,
-0.6376306414604187,
-0.01660129800438881,
-0.41362130641937256,
0.7151039242744446,
0.5774973630905151,
-0.06706248968839645,
-0.25691717863082886,
-0.015822043642401695,
0.41364139318466187,
0.045525070279836655,
-0.7424139976501465,
-0.324593186378479,
-0.1826268881559372,
-0.4616950750350952,
-0.27877533435821533,
0.47383764386177063,
-0.8853929042816162,
-0.14519114792346954,
-0.7180296182632446,
0.3269340693950653,
-0.2089676409959793,
-0.1390681117773056,
0.2235863357782364,
-0.05067828670144081,
-0.21524500846862793,
0.35556432604789734,
-1.0151548385620117,
0.6050944328308105,
0.8581331372261047,
0.8041270971298218,
0.07862654328346252,
-0.5135632157325745,
-0.27147313952445984,
0.36584338545799255,
-0.09749208390712738,
0.9979416728019714,
-0.8504238724708557,
-0.4413205087184906,
-0.14001397788524628,
-0.06924059242010117,
-0.02212211675941944,
-0.20226258039474487,
0.629409909248352,
-0.4235129654407501,
0.6604803204536438,
-0.008156063966453075,
-0.45403239130973816,
-0.35868459939956665,
0.24858704209327698,
-0.5565497279167175,
0.5161433219909668,
-0.2670353353023529,
-0.8549681901931763,
0.34532031416893005,
-1.0920203924179077,
-0.24708862602710724,
-0.14590656757354736,
-0.4117232859134674,
-0.143392875790596,
0.015554865822196007,
0.3879343271255493,
0.2774316966533661,
-0.27092573046684265,
0.43787816166877747,
-0.3772069215774536,
-0.06618670374155045,
0.20613707602024078,
-0.24033482372760773,
0.228702113032341,
0.19981446862220764,
-0.07674439251422882,
0.2193632572889328,
-0.5843234062194824,
-0.1762319654226303,
-0.19955258071422577,
-0.28250253200531006,
-0.5674389004707336,
0.25905632972717285,
0.5257253050804138,
-0.06847531348466873,
0.43719959259033203,
-0.4817906618118286,
0.35207581520080566,
-0.43325838446617126,
0.4177335798740387,
0.3052099645137787,
-0.1534620076417923,
0.5660083293914795,
-0.20462355017662048,
0.2928709089756012,
-0.0776747316122055,
0.11729463934898376,
-0.6603374481201172,
-0.22202904522418976,
-0.6196886301040649,
-0.16814929246902466,
0.1591057926416397,
0.3669213056564331,
-0.4153687655925751,
0.1911611258983612,
-0.4013175368309021,
-0.4673509895801544,
-0.3104458153247833,
0.14544178545475006,
0.5179982781410217,
0.8165245652198792,
0.32108351588249207,
-0.1917426586151123,
-0.643639326095581,
-1.1515229940414429,
-0.20613911747932434,
-0.15033341944217682,
-0.14196118712425232,
0.48802244663238525,
0.788436233997345,
-0.19101381301879883,
0.8953314423561096,
-0.533810019493103,
-0.18091954290866852,
0.1594834178686142,
0.5996765494346619,
0.5318857431411743,
0.3234042227268219,
0.6009129881858826,
-1.029782772064209,
-0.37058061361312866,
0.14091627299785614,
-0.7357490658760071,
-0.018455391749739647,
-0.010201972909271717,
0.12789879739284515,
-0.05668193846940994,
0.48100724816322327,
-0.4569072127342224,
0.4232795536518097,
0.7260946035385132,
-0.396573930978775,
0.45009109377861023,
-0.19400128722190857,
0.22243303060531616,
-1.1337147951126099,
0.4611750543117523,
0.039852675050497055,
-0.18603715300559998,
-0.42049315571784973,
-0.0435798354446888,
-0.028715286403894424,
-0.2580580711364746,
-0.392911434173584,
0.4448077380657196,
-0.5444457530975342,
-0.2577604055404663,
-0.8147513270378113,
0.1283704787492752,
0.20918604731559753,
0.1682383418083191,
0.5360562801361084,
0.9108931422233582,
0.37249699234962463,
-0.4045146405696869,
-0.21251524984836578,
0.4188108444213867,
-0.33801713585853577,
0.5293199419975281,
-0.795702338218689,
0.01107391994446516,
-0.28497833013534546,
0.13383911550045013,
-0.7873548269271851,
-0.5008144974708557,
0.04920149967074394,
-0.25113680958747864,
0.030517295002937317,
0.02562587708234787,
-0.21377450227737427,
-0.30149924755096436,
-0.24038074910640717,
0.3759689927101135,
-0.09019917994737625,
-0.4705064594745636,
0.6892692446708679,
0.477609246969223,
-0.2926754951477051,
-0.40691691637039185,
-0.5573628544807434,
0.36270350217819214,
-0.17124035954475403,
-0.5234273076057434,
0.8201125264167786,
0.01640966720879078,
-0.09843133389949799,
0.1868617683649063,
0.2369941622018814,
-0.1506267935037613,
-0.07449476420879364,
0.49379509687423706,
0.39314842224121094,
-0.16105660796165466,
-0.07969021052122116,
-0.26307904720306396,
-0.03307292237877846,
-0.030898546800017357,
-0.12451794743537903,
0.47779369354248047,
-0.6835214495658875,
-0.3629538118839264,
-0.4722208082675934,
0.5279824137687683,
0.44760608673095703,
-0.12415178120136261,
0.270656943321228,
0.3151762783527374,
-0.36024513840675354,
0.5119680166244507,
-0.3688865900039673,
-0.33086711168289185,
-0.4557819068431854,
0.43529799580574036,
-0.22291024029254913,
-0.6469982266426086,
0.46726351976394653,
-0.03261768817901611,
0.09221020340919495,
0.2854829430580139,
0.24831846356391907,
-0.4132997393608093,
0.8921582102775574,
0.9410614371299744,
-0.0701107308268547,
0.6290701031684875,
-0.24316929280757904,
-0.17879755795001984,
-1.0272058248519897,
-0.05695555359125137,
-0.6350163817405701,
-0.2338647097349167,
-0.2940407693386078,
-0.38028231263160706,
0.4037999212741852,
0.1962297409772873,
-0.16753213107585907,
0.5237234234809875,
-0.5470664501190186,
0.689338743686676,
0.552287757396698,
0.0351593904197216,
0.40718042850494385,
-0.1667451709508896,
0.04736650735139847,
-0.4194409251213074,
-0.3833639919757843,
-0.8567373752593994,
1.1220794916152954,
-0.027861662209033966,
0.865263044834137,
-0.1707150638103485,
0.45309460163116455,
-0.0575593076646328,
0.5742790699005127,
-0.3065272271633148,
0.4027300179004669,
-0.377629816532135,
-0.5513994693756104,
0.1436040848493576,
-0.21281398832798004,
-0.8285912275314331,
0.16596248745918274,
-0.3592050075531006,
-0.7435734272003174,
0.20624254643917084,
0.21943818032741547,
-0.21179170906543732,
0.12001392245292664,
-0.5234919190406799,
0.807392418384552,
-0.438180148601532,
-0.23003360629081726,
-0.2391592413187027,
-0.7281160354614258,
0.44560208916664124,
-0.008504346944391727,
0.359456330537796,
0.07914479076862335,
-0.14352066814899445,
0.914415180683136,
-0.1271483600139618,
1.13863205909729,
0.03763910382986069,
0.27038684487342834,
0.20184047520160675,
0.026330089196562767,
0.21021591126918793,
0.19179648160934448,
-0.013342631049454212,
0.009272265248000622,
0.16293150186538696,
-0.1287594884634018,
-0.43936240673065186,
0.6853787899017334,
-0.8518128991127014,
-0.4155082106590271,
-0.32768115401268005,
-0.8466455936431885,
-0.015611094422638416,
0.2853741943836212,
0.02777920849621296,
0.5999036431312561,
-0.22674503922462463,
0.17805127799510956,
-0.23083028197288513,
-0.0501323826611042,
0.6964970231056213,
0.5335977673530579,
-0.732561469078064,
-0.6391969323158264,
0.651984453201294,
-0.11907686293125153,
0.08856068551540375,
0.5323208570480347,
0.2526650130748749,
-0.3092021644115448,
-0.5468765497207642,
0.03373495116829872,
0.37896889448165894,
-0.5598687529563904,
-0.12401530146598816,
-0.5664079189300537,
0.0751928836107254,
-0.1663041114807129,
-0.4229603409767151,
-0.39111655950546265,
-0.5120577216148376,
-0.3140929341316223,
0.1340734362602234,
0.21225817501544952,
0.5062514543533325,
-0.13277889788150787,
0.7660810351371765,
-0.6547679901123047,
0.34133127331733704,
0.07758846879005432,
0.3395092487335205,
-0.3200938105583191,
-0.27737829089164734,
-0.4228321313858032,
0.13276121020317078,
-0.49371573328971863,
-0.6430092453956604,
0.37761133909225464,
0.6042375564575195,
0.3406941890716553,
0.5927342772483826,
-0.2909266948699951,
0.9007688164710999,
-0.4141424298286438,
0.7211416363716125,
0.44486284255981445,
-0.9270208477973938,
0.6892789602279663,
-0.8446639776229858,
0.5006749629974365,
0.8572438955307007,
0.2567984461784363,
-0.4392799437046051,
-0.4977843463420868,
-0.4553394615650177,
-0.6378864049911499,
0.38460952043533325,
-0.21971459686756134,
0.15859626233577728,
-0.07143224775791168,
0.411266565322876,
0.23867283761501312,
0.6835393309593201,
-0.9411739706993103,
0.24515387415885925,
-0.4941524863243103,
-0.2245989292860031,
-0.007084478158503771,
0.11084470897912979,
-0.4058417081832886,
-0.20832552015781403,
0.12327690422534943,
-0.395561158657074,
0.32908323407173157,
0.2737756669521332,
-0.04303010553121567,
0.0026168443728238344,
0.032246269285678864,
0.8338713049888611,
0.9145579934120178,
-0.3971506655216217,
0.42931151390075684,
-0.43397456407546997,
-0.5945241451263428,
-0.42683497071266174,
0.32048481702804565,
-0.3141801655292511,
0.03726436570286751,
0.6082065105438232,
0.890356183052063,
0.4806579053401947,
-0.5715218186378479,
0.5068981051445007,
0.13399535417556763,
-0.3126918375492096,
-0.2755061686038971,
-0.30254077911376953,
0.3189384639263153,
0.10129668563604355,
0.3643210828304291,
0.427795946598053,
0.33232763409614563,
-0.54341721534729,
0.3048652112483978,
0.5824422836303711,
-0.3117135465145111,
-0.8608411550521851,
1.0003660917282104,
0.2506783604621887,
-0.21917837858200073,
0.20939354598522186,
0.12169159203767776,
-0.567197322845459,
0.5548596978187561,
0.5736439824104309,
0.5602954030036926,
0.2641144394874573,
0.27560025453567505,
0.08989601582288742,
0.2263830155134201,
0.10953701287508011,
0.2986808121204376,
-0.09634269773960114,
-0.5341561436653137,
-0.654523491859436,
-0.5126247406005859,
-0.6759066581726074,
0.00614597462117672,
-0.6438074707984924,
0.2779366970062256,
-0.45297688245773315,
-0.27146127820014954,
0.3615976870059967,
-0.002640789607539773,
-0.7769904136657715,
-0.025527622550725937,
0.215426966547966,
0.7998956441879272,
-0.8229677081108093,
0.6260032057762146,
0.8630623817443848,
-0.45403650403022766,
-0.4959106743335724,
-0.23470519483089447,
-0.04459301009774208,
-0.49293026328086853,
0.8976553082466125,
0.3066954016685486,
-0.22651681303977966,
-0.3402014970779419,
-0.5517802238464355,
-0.8236989378929138,
0.7830484509468079,
0.37001124024391174,
-0.4986199140548706,
0.06378651410341263,
0.10039301216602325,
0.6056386828422546,
-0.6912973523139954,
0.4315548837184906,
0.07072418928146362,
0.6942285299301147,
-0.03254302591085434,
-1.1306687593460083,
-0.3560773432254791,
-0.29502353072166443,
-0.13906288146972656,
0.4658415615558624,
-0.47099605202674866,
1.0101549625396729,
-0.15206654369831085,
-0.12375462800264359,
0.22856773436069489,
0.8846129179000854,
0.08465735614299774,
0.5279343128204346,
0.5881520509719849,
0.4770272374153137,
0.43965035676956177,
0.019752226769924164,
1.0129103660583496,
-0.45359790325164795,
0.39574167132377625,
1.2593798637390137,
-0.440918505191803,
1.0272282361984253,
1.155604362487793,
-0.0961833968758583,
0.3778245449066162,
0.3362005650997162,
-0.11060307919979095,
0.9216408133506775,
-0.1586020588874817,
-0.18006813526153564,
-0.041102755814790726,
-0.46409255266189575,
-0.31050628423690796,
0.6398616433143616,
0.38500508666038513,
-0.20509205758571625,
-0.6185161471366882,
0.2454180270433426,
-0.036520060151815414,
0.5562371611595154,
-0.22444865107536316,
0.6614940762519836,
-0.05856006592512131,
-0.6965149641036987,
0.19093139469623566,
-0.08139215409755707,
0.9345245957374573,
-0.6312763094902039,
-0.06736535578966141,
0.20611290633678436,
0.0651150718331337,
-0.25818565487861633,
-0.6878562569618225,
0.7442770004272461,
-0.05177717283368111,
-0.42900875210762024,
-0.1274239420890808,
0.44622641801834106,
-0.47030696272850037,
-0.7673419713973999,
0.11433680355548859,
0.2737889885902405,
0.12736918032169342,
0.17897234857082367,
-0.4656473398208618,
-0.04294240102171898,
-0.222609743475914,
-0.23158839344978333,
0.09321136027574539,
-0.05363326519727707,
-0.00508294440805912,
0.391703337430954,
0.8470616340637207,
0.28587135672569275,
-0.018630297854542732,
-0.09973210096359253,
1.0102496147155762,
-0.7708044648170471,
-0.6634988784790039,
-0.5413710474967957,
0.29304274916648865,
-0.1728626936674118,
-0.5115495324134827,
0.49107491970062256,
0.6719530820846558,
0.49837788939476013,
-0.1944008767604828,
0.625490665435791,
-0.08875226229429245,
0.8359503746032715,
-0.5243174433708191,
0.3110133409500122,
-0.4211995601654053,
0.20255602896213531,
-0.30994465947151184,
-0.9477797746658325,
-0.5216681957244873,
0.5753962993621826,
-0.7099440693855286,
-0.11035051196813583,
0.672164797782898,
0.6788508892059326,
-0.40688595175743103,
0.1638614684343338,
-0.0447315089404583,
-0.18562215566635132,
0.4013601243495941,
0.4548739194869995,
0.7926024198532104,
-0.4173918664455414,
0.7025485038757324,
-0.25952258706092834,
-0.14171485602855682,
-0.16835202276706696,
-1.2880834341049194,
-0.8969839215278625,
-0.6303486227989197,
-0.27811744809150696,
0.2105841189622879,
-0.0077362521551549435,
0.7075762152671814,
0.8395593762397766,
-0.621551513671875,
-0.4476557672023773,
-0.25350889563560486,
-0.3878806531429291,
0.0774015262722969,
-0.20815697312355042,
0.6399682760238647,
-0.07106316834688187,
-0.8019049167633057,
0.49436309933662415,
0.31950128078460693,
0.1098288968205452,
-0.17031559348106384,
0.1356186866760254,
-0.26672932505607605,
-0.19368377327919006,
0.29894495010375977,
0.42553016543388367,
-0.6826738715171814,
-0.46762698888778687,
0.26979705691337585,
0.051638271659612656,
-0.07643651217222214,
0.8612397909164429,
-0.6409836411476135,
0.3976175785064697,
0.23746651411056519,
0.7122968435287476,
0.7380746603012085,
0.10590420663356781,
0.6038805246353149,
-0.6102877259254456,
0.6099551916122437,
0.2487046718597412,
0.3370268940925598,
0.4331981837749481,
-0.06330887228250504,
0.3714490234851837,
0.04330391064286232,
-0.6353685855865479,
-0.7854679822921753,
0.23165173828601837,
-1.2701876163482666,
-0.15722407400608063,
0.6506839990615845,
0.06861350685358047,
-0.27193915843963623,
0.14117562770843506,
-0.2752545475959778,
-0.14227932691574097,
-0.3050324320793152,
0.9655188918113708,
0.7613789439201355,
-0.2127397656440735,
-0.30747517943382263,
-0.6609675884246826,
0.23337726294994354,
0.43776121735572815,
-0.9103232026100159,
-0.20526021718978882,
0.4738630950450897,
0.023721523582935333,
0.7466603517532349,
0.3690991997718811,
-0.23885071277618408,
0.19275297224521637,
-0.18985766172409058,
0.13874728977680206,
-0.3634352684020996,
-0.4353395104408264,
-0.0583854615688324,
0.15986356139183044,
-0.05661246180534363,
-0.2577665150165558
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08763v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08763v3
|
Simple and Scalable Strategies to Continually Pre-train Large Language Models
| 2024-03-13T17:58:57 | 2024-03-26T17:58:48 |
Adam Ibrahim, Benjamin Thérien, Kshitij Gupta, Mats L. Richter, Quentin Anthony, Timothée Lesort, Eugene Belilovsky, Irina Rish
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) are routinely pre-trained on billions of tokens,
only to start the process over again once new data becomes available. A much
more efficient solution is to continually pre-train these models, saving
significant compute compared to re-training. However, the distribution shift
induced by new data typically results in degraded performance on previous data
or poor adaptation to the new data. In this work, we show that a simple and
scalable combination of learning rate (LR) re-warming, LR re-decaying, and
replay of previous data is sufficient to match the performance of fully
re-training from scratch on all available data, as measured by the final loss
and the average score on several language model (LM) evaluation benchmarks.
Specifically, we show this for a weak but realistic distribution shift between
two commonly used LLM pre-training datasets (English$\rightarrow$English) and a
stronger distribution shift (English$\rightarrow$German) at the $405$M
parameter model scale with large dataset sizes (hundreds of billions of
tokens). Selecting the weak but realistic shift for larger-scale experiments,
we also find that our continual learning strategies match the re-training
baseline for a 10B parameter LLM. Our results demonstrate that LLMs can be
successfully updated via simple and scalable continual learning strategies,
matching the re-training baseline using only a fraction of the compute.
Finally, inspired by previous work, we propose alternatives to the cosine
learning rate schedule that help circumvent forgetting induced by LR re-warming
and that are not bound to a fixed token budget.
|
[
-0.21889878809452057,
-0.5576915144920349,
0.3577520251274109,
0.14229172468185425,
-0.38370826840400696,
0.02155238576233387,
-0.635266125202179,
0.009320525452494621,
0.19089479744434357,
0.40376144647598267,
-0.5472318530082703,
-0.2174040526151657,
-0.4094177186489105,
-0.029357755556702614,
-0.20141012966632843,
0.8540974259376526,
-0.12260175496339798,
0.049622539430856705,
0.055529456585645676,
-0.13977105915546417,
-0.3413022756576538,
-0.5660576820373535,
-1.1641687154769897,
-0.43893712759017944,
0.7255702018737793,
0.3696255385875702,
0.5006546378135681,
0.6196943521499634,
0.4696267247200012,
0.1735754907131195,
0.02551610954105854,
-0.07805667817592621,
-0.9245033860206604,
0.13252103328704834,
-0.03929858282208443,
-0.5343570113182068,
-0.20903116464614868,
-0.14526817202568054,
0.9769602417945862,
0.7977423667907715,
-0.462318480014801,
0.25490787625312805,
0.022252151742577553,
0.6100364327430725,
-0.6411630511283875,
0.11718804389238358,
-0.9317169785499573,
-0.004298817832022905,
-0.30354607105255127,
-0.2620800733566284,
-0.7678585648536682,
-0.3086033761501312,
-0.08591800183057785,
-0.4644472897052765,
0.11528035998344421,
-0.11410515755414963,
0.7431932687759399,
0.21365594863891602,
-0.14683997631072998,
-0.017481885850429535,
-0.7278298139572144,
0.8477451205253601,
-0.6594435572624207,
0.7860385775566101,
0.18868274986743927,
0.2804966866970062,
-0.10883981734514236,
-0.7087208032608032,
-0.39485132694244385,
-0.4579432010650635,
0.2705111503601074,
-0.022872330620884895,
0.030249007046222687,
-0.4130386412143707,
0.17056706547737122,
0.15622316300868988,
-0.1800900250673294,
0.4028756022453308,
-0.06447866559028625,
-0.1637943685054779,
0.5557872653007507,
0.2136220782995224,
0.032550934702157974,
0.4857482612133026,
-0.25912046432495117,
-0.6141413450241089,
-1.0217547416687012,
0.0003605915408115834,
0.2398364096879959,
0.43429285287857056,
-0.03707081824541092,
0.13736680150032043,
0.17720025777816772,
0.5064840912818909,
0.19587348401546478,
-0.270645409822464,
0.4667806327342987,
-0.3526325225830078,
0.02697164937853813,
-0.18223349750041962,
0.5463554859161377,
0.12037455290555954,
0.43205398321151733,
-0.27581921219825745,
-0.4695441424846649,
-0.18480853736400604,
0.2533031702041626,
-0.7164233326911926,
-0.2368350327014923,
-0.20916013419628143,
-0.19906441867351532,
-0.02602062188088894,
-0.336813747882843,
-0.5754638910293579,
-0.05774901434779167,
-0.4751124382019043,
0.48692524433135986,
-0.28603336215019226,
-0.3353586792945862,
0.28897711634635925,
0.20788909494876862,
0.4021381735801697,
0.39778590202331543,
-1.049782395362854,
0.27024179697036743,
0.4350578486919403,
0.802016019821167,
-0.3429100215435028,
-0.43945035338401794,
-0.6380225419998169,
0.005357489921152592,
-0.6642147898674011,
0.6242356896400452,
-0.2880707383155823,
-0.18095330893993378,
0.10567720979452133,
0.09896837919950485,
-0.158472940325737,
-0.5593447089195251,
0.21963092684745789,
-0.6706846356391907,
0.09717529267072678,
-0.3190489709377289,
-0.49391478300094604,
0.35092371702194214,
0.29201358556747437,
-0.7864805459976196,
0.9401296973228455,
0.08600937575101852,
-0.7039122581481934,
0.6053004860877991,
-0.33027034997940063,
-0.46664535999298096,
-0.1614503562450409,
0.21821099519729614,
-0.7318746447563171,
0.11599181592464447,
0.0881940945982933,
0.42490747570991516,
-0.135438933968544,
0.10305364429950714,
-0.36627626419067383,
-0.4026311933994293,
0.03760628402233124,
-0.5907213687896729,
0.5030945539474487,
0.13952895998954773,
-0.24210847914218903,
-0.03016616590321064,
-0.5891754031181335,
0.05769369378685951,
0.17523662745952606,
-0.6550158262252808,
-0.19618816673755646,
0.08339601755142212,
0.0399760976433754,
-0.026211917400360107,
0.2617868185043335,
-0.20816506445407867,
0.34318482875823975,
-0.39701440930366516,
0.2918678820133209,
0.8496355414390564,
-0.022164039313793182,
0.5008412599563599,
-0.37669408321380615,
0.44065818190574646,
0.06074245646595955,
0.08193899691104889,
-0.306571900844574,
0.16099628806114197,
-0.8963753581047058,
-0.305105984210968,
0.2147563248872757,
0.5267823934555054,
-0.6593853831291199,
0.3549741208553314,
-0.6350492835044861,
-0.5327852964401245,
-0.47465696930885315,
0.30196481943130493,
0.1895115226507187,
0.3042643666267395,
0.4293877184391022,
-0.2396889477968216,
-0.5259135961532593,
-0.5503374338150024,
-0.2541840076446533,
-0.015718910843133926,
0.04576963558793068,
0.017574412748217583,
0.3508662283420563,
-0.15039120614528656,
0.7472591996192932,
-0.36357253789901733,
0.1809069663286209,
-0.438993364572525,
-0.03550463169813156,
0.3182361125946045,
0.33868157863616943,
0.2801848351955414,
-0.43875551223754883,
-0.5420272350311279,
-0.033365264534950256,
-0.4471263587474823,
-0.05105157569050789,
-0.33714917302131653,
-0.029778581112623215,
0.3310849964618683,
0.8363472819328308,
-0.4488690197467804,
0.04231823980808258,
0.4783448874950409,
0.033310048282146454,
0.5979196429252625,
-0.32453227043151855,
-0.12231730669736862,
-1.0709095001220703,
-0.08861668407917023,
-0.2770775556564331,
-0.35028910636901855,
-0.6112227439880371,
-0.10920652747154236,
0.13406088948249817,
-0.04528116062283516,
-0.6051795482635498,
0.8602669835090637,
-0.6060746312141418,
0.13407988846302032,
-0.10526973754167557,
0.043300483375787735,
-0.326234370470047,
0.285452663898468,
0.10490204393863678,
0.709080696105957,
0.577764630317688,
-0.7707237601280212,
0.11882216483354568,
-0.06212908402085304,
-0.3316057622432709,
0.27071377635002136,
-0.5865027904510498,
0.26551353931427,
-0.16735681891441345,
0.3845854103565216,
-0.7293230891227722,
0.14439602196216583,
0.022948114201426506,
-0.00787638034671545,
0.5827013254165649,
-0.03597040846943855,
-0.5099312663078308,
-0.28225839138031006,
-0.30902114510536194,
0.330234557390213,
0.771674394607544,
-0.7086510062217712,
0.5047935843467712,
0.08714020997285843,
-0.09920630604028702,
-0.6113183498382568,
-0.46841174364089966,
0.05147065222263336,
-0.4009130597114563,
-0.2964317500591278,
0.19682863354682922,
-0.1769740879535675,
-0.038338664919137955,
-0.19289153814315796,
-0.0874827429652214,
0.22267884016036987,
0.2212934046983719,
-0.10719306766986847,
0.08661886304616928,
-0.21427325904369354,
0.31223371624946594,
-0.38600245118141174,
-0.2797930836677551,
-0.09466425329446793,
-0.46941810846328735,
0.908062219619751,
-0.049652282148599625,
-0.35778024792671204,
-0.3245599865913391,
-0.0778822973370552,
0.6157670617103577,
-0.03625135496258736,
1.0310368537902832,
0.5920240879058838,
-0.21572217345237732,
-0.17308194935321808,
-0.7198400497436523,
-0.31779029965400696,
-0.4062880873680115,
0.6054568290710449,
-0.4856263995170593,
-0.7442631125450134,
0.5111772418022156,
-0.17013214528560638,
0.24669165909290314,
0.2832894027233124,
0.6959801316261292,
-0.058057088404893875,
0.5885934829711914,
0.7895386815071106,
-0.4500647783279419,
0.7829114198684692,
-0.06213155388832092,
0.17795442044734955,
-0.5511366128921509,
0.015453333035111427,
-0.33389121294021606,
-0.08662804961204529,
-0.3111029267311096,
-0.4200984239578247,
0.21014033257961273,
0.28018108010292053,
-0.5829533338546753,
0.1963745653629303,
0.03459281101822853,
0.5556719303131104,
0.30207908153533936,
0.01865130290389061,
0.060342852026224136,
0.2222096174955368,
0.10975431650876999,
0.008199193514883518,
-0.8717526197433472,
-0.1969260573387146,
1.3644558191299438,
0.48803508281707764,
1.0069780349731445,
-0.00621397141367197,
0.9609155654907227,
0.023802440613508224,
0.6409122943878174,
-0.4466399848461151,
0.3813278079032898,
-0.17629499733448029,
-0.1251668632030487,
-0.6172600984573364,
-0.6938988566398621,
-1.1202583312988281,
0.1424838900566101,
-0.16903716325759888,
-0.2575867176055908,
-0.0785745158791542,
0.43707144260406494,
-0.005302142817527056,
0.47980713844299316,
-0.6953954100608826,
0.7250081300735474,
-0.33202609419822693,
-0.30544111132621765,
-0.2604840397834778,
-0.3677162528038025,
0.18671828508377075,
-0.49810072779655457,
0.2542839050292969,
0.0317034088075161,
-0.07757595181465149,
0.7026436924934387,
-0.2715568542480469,
0.8614799380302429,
-0.24520625174045563,
-0.10181494057178497,
0.04633883386850357,
-0.000943890365306288,
0.7863497138023376,
-0.05303080752491951,
0.009235990233719349,
0.1468401700258255,
-0.1853424608707428,
-0.6406657099723816,
-0.5285991430282593,
0.4536536931991577,
-0.8859111070632935,
-0.5189657807350159,
-0.1578735113143921,
-0.4615837335586548,
-0.1999611109495163,
0.2103138118982315,
0.32021868228912354,
0.3182610869407654,
-0.2820266783237457,
0.3115188479423523,
0.7529880404472351,
-0.1516318917274475,
0.4085487723350525,
0.49188441038131714,
-0.31441447138786316,
-0.36459118127822876,
0.7599945664405823,
0.10376547276973724,
0.7670329809188843,
0.415406733751297,
0.3544880449771881,
-0.43482494354248047,
-0.4998186528682709,
-0.16579458117485046,
0.3296096920967102,
-0.6026383638381958,
-0.05560683831572533,
-0.4888511896133423,
-0.12337695062160492,
-0.3868198096752167,
-0.3860953450202942,
-0.5397762656211853,
-0.007819073274731636,
-0.04837389662861824,
0.011502964422106743,
0.31793877482414246,
0.2736814320087433,
-0.1676308810710907,
0.40366730093955994,
-0.4077203869819641,
0.06278625130653381,
0.2324993759393692,
0.240219846367836,
0.1775800585746765,
-0.8203531503677368,
-0.41206490993499756,
0.11132648587226868,
0.09158558398485184,
-0.42299577593803406,
0.30549097061157227,
0.3816036880016327,
0.6563591957092285,
0.16266845166683197,
-0.2220740020275116,
0.7311474680900574,
-0.7891972064971924,
0.5864114165306091,
0.47612643241882324,
-0.7319502830505371,
0.20791766047477722,
-0.06324021518230438,
0.5774186253547668,
0.6540600061416626,
0.49235105514526367,
-0.6558883786201477,
-0.22763539850711823,
-0.5287331342697144,
-0.8934248089790344,
0.353666752576828,
-0.2886744439601898,
0.45152169466018677,
-0.1191740483045578,
0.49061068892478943,
0.06665448844432831,
0.09714268147945404,
-0.820980429649353,
-0.13261249661445618,
-0.2551729083061218,
-0.14322447776794434,
-0.5815911889076233,
-0.2311921864748001,
0.05493445694446564,
-0.28789618611335754,
0.5543710589408875,
-0.12830287218093872,
-0.04446727782487869,
-0.20795680582523346,
-0.25111743807792664,
0.08824742585420609,
0.2943582534790039,
0.36696353554725647,
0.7470578551292419,
-0.2932019829750061,
0.15899668633937836,
0.5820272564888,
-0.5270921587944031,
0.4664761424064636,
-0.2219693511724472,
-0.17843541502952576,
-0.08135288953781128,
0.5996738076210022,
0.9108396768569946,
0.6539657711982727,
-0.6398445963859558,
0.3397112488746643,
0.03871830552816391,
-0.04624186456203461,
-0.5383104681968689,
-0.00023418782802764326,
0.36710691452026367,
-0.038753002882003784,
0.2398281842470169,
-0.09691685438156128,
-0.7557114362716675,
-0.7170241475105286,
0.41833776235580444,
0.36687445640563965,
-0.17997218668460846,
-0.28504589200019836,
0.40620025992393494,
-0.05521921440958977,
-0.31440430879592896,
0.8218246102333069,
-0.1971205174922943,
-0.4097038507461548,
0.2220040112733841,
0.704491138458252,
0.7034761905670166,
-0.5125880837440491,
0.17041048407554626,
0.4489707052707672,
0.30933862924575806,
-0.7270736694335938,
0.0691804364323616,
0.1203022375702858,
-0.8993598818778992,
-0.5022295713424683,
-0.7071853876113892,
-0.19286759197711945,
0.13623835146427155,
-0.6441431641578674,
0.42268428206443787,
-0.556726336479187,
-0.03959031403064728,
-0.34275075793266296,
-0.012043901719152927,
-0.9047913551330566,
0.1415928155183792,
0.07111245393753052,
1.0710362195968628,
-0.9817023277282715,
1.01776921749115,
0.3066188395023346,
-0.30435383319854736,
-0.8498429656028748,
0.02524164691567421,
-0.2983661890029907,
-0.9838613867759705,
0.7330988645553589,
-0.12744441628456116,
-0.11957679688930511,
0.16464440524578094,
-0.5042884349822998,
-1.0925891399383545,
0.9614720940589905,
0.5386627316474915,
-1.0051381587982178,
-0.019179189577698708,
-0.05575200542807579,
0.6143015623092651,
-0.37039488554000854,
0.15132595598697662,
0.6038861870765686,
0.2668363153934479,
0.1751805990934372,
-0.7185727953910828,
-0.11632755398750305,
0.09706290811300278,
-0.12386689335107803,
0.4250407814979553,
-0.5774917602539062,
0.973597526550293,
-0.3101089596748352,
-0.2586585283279419,
-0.24319568276405334,
0.5095705986022949,
0.2507513761520386,
0.1744939088821411,
0.7492058277130127,
0.7977673411369324,
0.8065884113311768,
0.027244416996836662,
0.9562249779701233,
-0.2678837776184082,
0.48932966589927673,
1.0590277910232544,
-0.42455199360847473,
1.3021764755249023,
0.4522622227668762,
-0.24600718915462494,
0.2235856056213379,
0.5847551226615906,
-0.003484461223706603,
0.6101677417755127,
0.5050398707389832,
-0.21732518076896667,
-0.5288957357406616,
0.2819163501262665,
-0.4348239600658417,
0.037211380898952484,
0.09546102583408356,
0.09289658814668655,
-0.3760369122028351,
0.17843623459339142,
0.37054479122161865,
-0.11411821097135544,
-0.37876230478286743,
0.6384865045547485,
0.1955716460943222,
-0.4707527458667755,
0.9561307430267334,
-0.3532290756702423,
0.6992998123168945,
-0.8931972980499268,
0.35989803075790405,
-0.44367197155952454,
0.3644596040248871,
0.13014306128025055,
-0.35238906741142273,
0.19039960205554962,
-0.1824866682291031,
-0.2576274573802948,
-0.38207510113716125,
0.18255484104156494,
-0.5505543947219849,
-0.6497979760169983,
0.20936012268066406,
0.2905759811401367,
0.07642856985330582,
0.23310908675193787,
-0.593847930431366,
0.3164326846599579,
0.036957964301109314,
-0.3525455892086029,
0.6380258798599243,
0.3418259620666504,
-0.12984636425971985,
0.9089469313621521,
0.8800714612007141,
0.39975255727767944,
0.17992746829986572,
0.24824918806552887,
0.7303123474121094,
-0.6816241145133972,
-0.3914823830127716,
-0.7918863892555237,
0.17322491109371185,
0.13767015933990479,
-0.33043330907821655,
0.5950324535369873,
0.3678903579711914,
0.89703768491745,
-0.08973310887813568,
0.5764511823654175,
0.39406535029411316,
0.38309693336486816,
-0.8253452181816101,
0.5152295827865601,
-0.5490467548370361,
0.3190195560455322,
-0.01016487181186676,
-1.1027289628982544,
-0.13319659233093262,
0.4250546991825104,
-0.34480854868888855,
0.09125296026468277,
0.7194639444351196,
0.665336012840271,
0.024652745574712753,
-0.5763795971870422,
0.2869817316532135,
0.399277001619339,
0.5333274602890015,
0.6749131083488464,
0.6790981292724609,
-0.21624842286109924,
0.3281269967556,
0.03645740821957588,
-0.0915178507566452,
-0.12826025485992432,
-0.9701352119445801,
-0.7200238704681396,
-0.47691893577575684,
-0.41756898164749146,
-0.28760555386543274,
0.30357417464256287,
0.8017971515655518,
0.6677186489105225,
-0.659228503704071,
-0.27587592601776123,
-0.017832178622484207,
-0.24952784180641174,
-0.32613542675971985,
-0.1512640118598938,
0.6093695163726807,
-0.8338661193847656,
-0.40813592076301575,
0.32425639033317566,
0.13996759057044983,
-0.013088037259876728,
-0.30300483107566833,
-0.16751185059547424,
-0.13680493831634521,
0.13182799518108368,
0.5067333579063416,
0.4549960494041443,
-0.4959033727645874,
-0.4041053354740143,
-0.029623446986079216,
-0.05747227370738983,
-0.05169900506734848,
0.7712855339050293,
-0.6816659569740295,
0.25648486614227295,
0.2708722949028015,
1.0339950323104858,
0.730537474155426,
-0.15302059054374695,
0.5947587490081787,
-0.5705616474151611,
0.23481379449367523,
0.09432028979063034,
0.23377472162246704,
0.43590599298477173,
-0.10841277986764908,
0.2767268419265747,
0.2578043043613434,
-0.5943511724472046,
-1.0123207569122314,
0.12935569882392883,
-0.7072256803512573,
-0.15565375983715057,
1.0138545036315918,
-0.2254014015197754,
-0.12326040863990784,
-0.01127484068274498,
0.1674310863018036,
0.0007661388372071087,
0.005058075301349163,
0.7685019373893738,
0.7562602758407593,
0.24988287687301636,
-0.3583720624446869,
-0.3950912356376648,
0.4638672173023224,
0.519233226776123,
-0.6486626863479614,
0.28070229291915894,
0.20504644513130188,
0.7208825349807739,
-0.07649737596511841,
0.8390100002288818,
0.07152844965457916,
0.039668213576078415,
0.08360621333122253,
0.11449559777975082,
0.1160634383559227,
-0.45848044753074646,
-0.46923837065696716,
-0.015182489529252052,
0.2564050853252411,
-0.03876124322414398
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08755v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08755v2
|
DAM: Dynamic Adapter Merging for Continual Video QA Learning
| 2024-03-13T17:53:47 | 2024-04-22T19:17:49 |
Feng Cheng, Ziyang Wang, Yi-Lin Sung, Yan-Bo Lin, Mohit Bansal, Gedas Bertasius
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We present a parameter-efficient method for continual video
question-answering (VidQA) learning. Our method, named DAM, uses the proposed
Dynamic Adapter Merging to (i) mitigate catastrophic forgetting, (ii) enable
efficient adaptation to continually arriving datasets, (iii) handle inputs from
unknown datasets during inference, and (iv) enable knowledge sharing across
similar dataset domains. Given a set of continually streaming VidQA datasets,
we sequentially train dataset-specific adapters for each dataset while freezing
the parameters of a large pretrained video-language backbone. During inference,
given a video-question sample from an unknown domain, our method first uses the
proposed non-parametric router function to compute a probability for each
adapter, reflecting how relevant that adapter is to the current video-question
input instance. Subsequently, the proposed dynamic adapter merging scheme
aggregates all the adapter weights into a new adapter instance tailored for
that particular test sample to compute the final VidQA prediction, mitigating
the impact of inaccurate router predictions and facilitating knowledge sharing
across domains. Our DAM model outperforms prior state-of-the-art continual
learning approaches by 9.1% while exhibiting 1.9% less forgetting on 6 VidQA
datasets spanning various domains. We further extend DAM to continual image
classification and image QA and outperform prior methods by a large margin. The
code is publicly available at: https://github.com/klauscc/DAM
|
[
-0.5996203422546387,
-0.6542360186576843,
0.3057604134082794,
0.16111621260643005,
-0.45718914270401,
0.13889308273792267,
0.17985916137695312,
0.045483481138944626,
-0.17165789008140564,
0.28559446334838867,
-0.4076307415962219,
-0.08669663965702057,
-0.6249731779098511,
-0.35176771879196167,
-0.4877455234527588,
0.7400872707366943,
-0.4070751667022705,
0.04931803047657013,
-0.5680403709411621,
-0.38755765557289124,
-0.6835449934005737,
0.004787326790392399,
-0.7813090085983276,
-0.04587014392018318,
0.5557968020439148,
0.5572730302810669,
0.4348107576370239,
0.44340118765830994,
0.5528648495674133,
0.3144693374633789,
0.07698255032300949,
0.27398252487182617,
-0.7716958522796631,
0.41630229353904724,
-0.1133330687880516,
-0.0923033133149147,
-0.03553631901741028,
-0.3650604784488678,
1.066941738128662,
0.3999304175376892,
-0.3811779320240021,
0.4969625771045685,
-0.044997602701187134,
0.7244977355003357,
-0.9245036840438843,
0.08346341550350189,
-0.7421253323554993,
-0.02139369212090969,
0.28095027804374695,
-0.26326537132263184,
-0.18865104019641876,
-0.5595543384552002,
0.1992582380771637,
-0.5268428921699524,
0.15354733169078827,
-0.09095318615436554,
0.9976890087127686,
0.932910144329071,
-0.5133278369903564,
0.14371709525585175,
-0.9384564161300659,
0.6478961110115051,
-0.32637181878089905,
0.4970889389514923,
-0.01331047248095274,
0.7897689342498779,
-0.05480208620429039,
-0.9256541132926941,
-1.0284861326217651,
0.12978136539459229,
0.6129879951477051,
0.2480919361114502,
-0.24770928919315338,
0.01258467510342598,
0.25449588894844055,
0.5588884949684143,
-0.4211823344230652,
-0.07385966926813126,
-0.5154556035995483,
0.01736091822385788,
0.4464876055717468,
0.08553525805473328,
0.37682637572288513,
0.06672186404466629,
-0.4438762664794922,
-0.19705191254615784,
-0.5445733666419983,
0.38132449984550476,
-0.00856369361281395,
-0.3460632264614105,
-0.05147774890065193,
0.32166755199432373,
-0.19344502687454224,
0.7017069458961487,
0.39434629678726196,
-0.07275018095970154,
0.2199903130531311,
-0.06754305213689804,
-0.2655748426914215,
0.005383439362049103,
0.5277270674705505,
0.4338945746421814,
0.15337547659873962,
-0.1561548262834549,
-0.01904788240790367,
-0.17174974083900452,
0.6248419880867004,
-0.8434126377105713,
-0.7437249422073364,
0.20812878012657166,
-0.20758028328418732,
-0.10911968350410461,
0.022352438420057297,
-0.8418035507202148,
-0.31831467151641846,
-0.16140994429588318,
0.8600630164146423,
-0.31716397404670715,
-0.23198170959949493,
-0.16214245557785034,
-0.26185962557792664,
0.6368894577026367,
0.43000951409339905,
-0.5586145520210266,
0.3228834569454193,
0.19568361341953278,
0.747175395488739,
-0.26728129386901855,
-0.38372567296028137,
-1.1798592805862427,
0.2501949369907379,
-0.3498026132583618,
0.7620843052864075,
-0.24596841633319855,
-0.1558723896741867,
0.015484454110264778,
-0.0033386305440217257,
-0.1398407369852066,
-0.7080442309379578,
0.12279187142848969,
-1.1379153728485107,
0.06656660884618759,
-0.18615654110908508,
-0.5422224998474121,
-0.5731968879699707,
0.2726303040981293,
-0.8413918018341064,
0.8668020367622375,
0.2724301815032959,
-0.5350256562232971,
0.44454413652420044,
-0.4029035270214081,
0.0415206104516983,
0.17902341485023499,
0.0627555400133133,
-0.9091858863830566,
-0.22986532747745514,
-0.03339808061718941,
0.1428384929895401,
-0.030359163880348206,
0.40364667773246765,
-0.4744977653026581,
-0.42607754468917847,
0.14242292940616608,
-0.4538411498069763,
0.3393505811691284,
0.024711446836590767,
-0.3397354483604431,
0.13526678085327148,
-0.6283414959907532,
0.018413901329040527,
-0.21483011543750763,
-0.35446152091026306,
-0.02947336807847023,
-0.019953079521656036,
-0.16689859330654144,
0.4487859606742859,
0.148351788520813,
-0.3755733370780945,
0.03576752915978432,
0.25711822509765625,
0.17163927853107452,
0.755477786064148,
0.4128151535987854,
0.3769647181034088,
-0.40352973341941833,
0.6961033940315247,
0.3020350933074951,
0.32844793796539307,
-0.031017450615763664,
-0.43846774101257324,
-0.8809821605682373,
-0.2516076862812042,
0.48175445199012756,
0.644074022769928,
-1.0375360250473022,
0.0833398774266243,
-0.4384315609931946,
-0.6790727376937866,
-0.29072311520576477,
0.36238527297973633,
0.3043570816516876,
0.7989901304244995,
0.6421561241149902,
-0.4938797056674957,
-0.4381493628025055,
-0.4770947992801666,
0.18288643658161163,
-0.33958837389945984,
-0.16410976648330688,
0.26468586921691895,
0.2723537087440491,
-0.037562496960163116,
0.8601409196853638,
-0.49010366201400757,
-0.20568175613880157,
-0.010981627739965916,
0.18095101416110992,
-0.04785561561584473,
0.4568364918231964,
0.5469578504562378,
-1.2012507915496826,
-0.6166841387748718,
-0.2801641821861267,
-0.9296217560768127,
0.24323691427707672,
-0.2616319954395294,
-0.1827191859483719,
-0.24436400830745697,
0.36314666271209717,
-0.36471304297447205,
0.400619775056839,
0.6570097804069519,
0.04184988886117935,
0.6654835939407349,
-0.30815058946609497,
0.3404448628425598,
-1.0168631076812744,
-0.2970302700996399,
-0.2347881942987442,
-0.03268418833613396,
-0.42241808772087097,
-0.029990924522280693,
0.10699793696403503,
-0.09032312780618668,
-0.6408024430274963,
0.5016564130783081,
-0.31626737117767334,
0.22565867006778717,
-0.28940725326538086,
0.02988380752503872,
-0.2538740634918213,
0.7248332500457764,
-0.2268732488155365,
0.8005399107933044,
1.0557186603546143,
-1.1750296354293823,
0.8110567331314087,
0.44350385665893555,
-0.20819410681724548,
0.4523140788078308,
-0.5973095297813416,
-0.004799640737473965,
-0.2054578810930252,
0.30738916993141174,
-1.0854007005691528,
-0.14060132205486298,
0.18181484937667847,
-0.42832353711128235,
0.3102024495601654,
-0.35818666219711304,
-0.07713450491428375,
-0.40922480821609497,
-0.19925300776958466,
0.6519126296043396,
0.7258458137512207,
-0.6907403469085693,
0.8682277798652649,
0.5497466325759888,
-0.18710550665855408,
-0.5432822704315186,
-0.4496847987174988,
0.0807308629155159,
-0.5029672384262085,
-0.5289250016212463,
0.33619868755340576,
-0.34561046957969666,
0.0847642719745636,
0.21089968085289001,
-0.3966215252876282,
-0.6960177421569824,
-0.21181152760982513,
0.46966660022735596,
0.4183928966522217,
-0.2008669525384903,
0.1523023098707199,
0.18770040571689606,
0.15359073877334595,
0.09507586061954498,
-0.4843887686729431,
0.12401293963193893,
0.012910837307572365,
-0.3240680396556854,
-0.4348699450492859,
0.42785441875457764,
0.7284418940544128,
-0.1678386777639389,
0.8489755988121033,
0.7402332425117493,
-0.27281299233436584,
-0.015658719465136528,
-0.8176082968711853,
0.09770045429468155,
-0.48955485224723816,
0.29648926854133606,
-0.34728145599365234,
-0.9258744716644287,
0.6588642597198486,
-0.20125769078731537,
0.18353359401226044,
0.10179763287305832,
0.41176536679267883,
-0.38767433166503906,
0.6258875727653503,
0.7965914011001587,
-0.006916017271578312,
0.7771912813186646,
-0.5469173789024353,
0.3291459381580353,
-0.7595339417457581,
-0.2581007778644562,
0.06282727420330048,
-0.44690245389938354,
-0.5374987125396729,
-0.5272756218910217,
0.5470069646835327,
0.09605073183774948,
-0.5226859450340271,
0.11594673991203308,
-0.10429401695728302,
0.3240744173526764,
0.46381300687789917,
0.2793472707271576,
0.025876155123114586,
0.047449324280023575,
0.05615749955177307,
0.10863064974546432,
-0.9514381885528564,
-0.01758013293147087,
0.9103995561599731,
0.05992342531681061,
0.5839149951934814,
0.26052868366241455,
0.4885389506816864,
0.3568481504917145,
0.12121263146400452,
-0.7717078924179077,
0.6081181764602661,
-0.021938269957900047,
-0.1500239223241806,
-0.5191987752914429,
-0.47128960490226746,
-0.8900704383850098,
-0.03479931503534317,
-0.0204131118953228,
-0.356478750705719,
0.3708569407463074,
0.5466113686561584,
-0.49445730447769165,
0.6520959734916687,
-0.536065936088562,
0.7984175086021423,
0.004632770083844662,
-0.6023426651954651,
-0.473064124584198,
-0.6144358515739441,
0.6595631241798401,
-0.3842368423938751,
-0.06267734616994858,
0.24336518347263336,
0.0057850368320941925,
0.7232285737991333,
-0.35160863399505615,
0.3858833909034729,
-0.33087942004203796,
0.06614847481250763,
0.6568073034286499,
0.01686871610581875,
0.23268480598926544,
0.23459689319133759,
0.3086380958557129,
-0.06706179678440094,
-0.06766203045845032,
-0.6769902110099792,
-0.843917191028595,
0.5491480827331543,
-0.6544201374053955,
-0.4716116189956665,
-0.2934306859970093,
-0.6244823336601257,
-0.3192192316055298,
0.042278140783309937,
-0.11112936586141586,
0.6638488173484802,
0.14800198376178741,
0.36434316635131836,
1.1357500553131104,
-0.222841277718544,
0.27490517497062683,
0.6296289563179016,
0.1795942783355713,
-0.7535563707351685,
1.1686605215072632,
-0.029340356588363647,
0.32079702615737915,
0.4481262266635895,
-0.1146007627248764,
-0.19421382248401642,
-0.6556748151779175,
-0.3818320333957672,
0.2192944586277008,
-0.710307776927948,
-0.32297107577323914,
-0.5907882452011108,
-0.48836660385131836,
-0.17037472128868103,
0.1258298009634018,
-0.18302622437477112,
-0.11986003071069717,
0.021329378709197044,
-0.051368653774261475,
0.47565343976020813,
0.3020665645599365,
-0.23019391298294067,
0.423405259847641,
-1.0467296838760376,
0.8045850396156311,
0.9765506386756897,
0.4552967846393585,
0.043817613273859024,
-0.9400133490562439,
-0.35334861278533936,
-0.07180248945951462,
-0.5639756917953491,
-0.9227023720741272,
0.162819042801857,
0.4976784884929657,
0.6758637428283691,
0.5525851845741272,
0.3243756592273712,
0.9857310652732849,
-0.6228298544883728,
0.8753457069396973,
0.28260406851768494,
-0.6176540851593018,
0.33873337507247925,
-0.14732976257801056,
0.40448611974716187,
0.7197344899177551,
0.5946575999259949,
-0.3674299120903015,
-0.3303970694541931,
-0.6054797768592834,
-0.9389268159866333,
0.144941508769989,
0.03687756508588791,
0.1764390766620636,
0.18118463456630707,
0.31447193026542664,
-0.1281365305185318,
0.0921662449836731,
-0.3007543385028839,
-0.1836024969816208,
-0.31200337409973145,
-0.04201781377196312,
0.14569878578186035,
-0.24917593598365784,
-0.17526476085186005,
-0.5100556015968323,
0.7281211018562317,
-0.2330455482006073,
0.14210177958011627,
-0.10140103101730347,
-0.26390907168388367,
-0.16401714086532593,
-0.09411760419607162,
0.2748311460018158,
0.8885812759399414,
-0.22555717825889587,
0.014742005616426468,
0.5858697891235352,
-0.7508984208106995,
0.29523545503616333,
0.05853056535124779,
-0.26151663064956665,
0.04914388433098793,
-0.026829149574041367,
0.9129855036735535,
0.39955323934555054,
-0.857315182685852,
0.39334216713905334,
-0.4048454463481903,
-0.5182429552078247,
-0.5161773562431335,
0.26950690150260925,
-0.09117617458105087,
0.39125731587409973,
0.36974576115608215,
0.2682133615016937,
0.06554465740919113,
-0.21829256415367126,
0.7007709741592407,
0.2822609543800354,
-0.5769377946853638,
-0.1045929417014122,
0.7805300354957581,
0.1770029366016388,
-0.07975495606660843,
0.905143678188324,
-0.21617913246154785,
-0.5929045081138611,
0.48862582445144653,
-0.03366292640566826,
0.9141632318496704,
-0.33318373560905457,
0.2533561587333679,
0.5798227190971375,
-0.15290521085262299,
-0.13406683504581451,
0.2139558345079422,
-0.5342251658439636,
-0.5693197250366211,
-0.6877818703651428,
-0.5372865200042725,
-0.6999965310096741,
0.08649991452693939,
-0.7872747182846069,
0.4648835062980652,
-0.08464526385068893,
0.11108851432800293,
-0.46474626660346985,
-0.043657124042510986,
-0.5543401837348938,
0.38639330863952637,
0.17029082775115967,
0.9693754315376282,
-0.6299885511398315,
0.9722798466682434,
0.7185306549072266,
-0.581866443157196,
-1.0031633377075195,
0.20569299161434174,
-0.22710049152374268,
-0.4342421591281891,
0.5106529593467712,
-0.14035820960998535,
-0.10138478130102158,
0.19946737587451935,
-0.5108097195625305,
-0.9008886814117432,
1.2682039737701416,
0.3007639944553375,
-0.30187535285949707,
-0.09346602112054825,
-0.21418632566928864,
0.1980694830417633,
-0.02145162597298622,
0.12825384736061096,
0.34327247738838196,
0.29348108172416687,
0.6680464744567871,
-0.7159299850463867,
-0.22581897675991058,
-0.3769645392894745,
-0.227985680103302,
0.1228003203868866,
-0.6231471300125122,
0.3626861870288849,
-0.506361186504364,
-0.061458390206098557,
-0.0028509858530014753,
1.1222208738327026,
0.36429744958877563,
0.5690003633499146,
0.9146721959114075,
0.4829697012901306,
0.7858484387397766,
0.07221359759569168,
0.513282060623169,
-0.3025626540184021,
0.3144768476486206,
1.1240129470825195,
0.052600763738155365,
0.9090750813484192,
0.5478213429450989,
-0.13724660873413086,
0.8045070767402649,
0.6948511004447937,
-0.11212275922298431,
0.658775806427002,
0.146166130900383,
-0.5751447677612305,
-0.4598354399204254,
0.13865990936756134,
-0.3355962932109833,
0.3156379461288452,
0.06667941808700562,
0.1712689995765686,
-0.2775001525878906,
0.14988884329795837,
-0.30932095646858215,
-0.14538761973381042,
-0.3202248215675354,
0.9739865660667419,
-0.04720310866832733,
-0.8225756287574768,
0.8241930603981018,
-0.7098331451416016,
0.4116174876689911,
-0.7287495136260986,
-0.13832269608974457,
-0.2516929507255554,
0.18884599208831787,
-0.0702461525797844,
-0.777641236782074,
0.42486050724983215,
0.11699327081441879,
-0.32458245754241943,
-0.02950901910662651,
0.32150891423225403,
-0.7143005728721619,
-0.12713110446929932,
-0.08276340365409851,
0.19355376064777374,
0.20443816483020782,
-0.10643427073955536,
-0.5316986441612244,
-0.15139342844486237,
-0.11621519178152084,
0.11569145321846008,
0.4621065557003021,
0.5114767551422119,
0.046395011246204376,
1.0414897203445435,
0.4521372616291046,
0.03497103974223137,
0.38164761662483215,
-0.024312926456332207,
1.134190320968628,
-0.42367053031921387,
-0.5117232799530029,
-0.2837122678756714,
0.6929685473442078,
-0.10453731566667557,
-0.05528195574879646,
0.478899210691452,
0.5430458784103394,
0.7868208289146423,
-0.17541518807411194,
0.7729707360267639,
-0.04911567643284798,
0.001096515217795968,
-0.3848470151424408,
0.6205834746360779,
-0.6713411211967468,
0.12340492755174637,
-0.03950147330760956,
-0.8655279278755188,
-0.03979331627488136,
0.09571108967065811,
-0.18472567200660706,
-0.1688471883535385,
0.7517978549003601,
0.5558385848999023,
-0.19894272089004517,
-0.25831735134124756,
0.34575939178466797,
0.01924702525138855,
0.44562840461730957,
0.6797932386398315,
0.7194142937660217,
-0.6514512896537781,
1.0717368125915527,
-0.3243996500968933,
-0.3560561239719391,
0.06678406894207001,
-0.8092008829116821,
-0.5965193510055542,
-0.8288393020629883,
-0.8364261388778687,
-0.31392785906791687,
0.20706990361213684,
0.3483314514160156,
0.6459084749221802,
-0.8524630665779114,
-0.03679037094116211,
-0.09123460948467255,
0.2535038888454437,
-0.6095520257949829,
-0.26617246866226196,
0.2569214701652527,
-0.31677842140197754,
-0.7108110785484314,
0.07383088767528534,
0.29131510853767395,
-0.16624175012111664,
-0.26816821098327637,
-0.1377614289522171,
-0.1738160401582718,
0.16801919043064117,
0.4605603814125061,
0.5995671153068542,
-0.43822312355041504,
-0.23880527913570404,
-0.05661572515964508,
0.2548040449619293,
0.08809541165828705,
0.7222145795822144,
-1.1875146627426147,
0.6802470088005066,
0.6330122351646423,
0.9877175092697144,
0.54925936460495,
0.11888374388217926,
0.5983126759529114,
-0.32300111651420593,
-0.13186250627040863,
0.05835975706577301,
0.19565972685813904,
0.3732748031616211,
-0.1690356582403183,
0.16144652664661407,
0.2459244281053543,
-0.7380446791648865,
-0.933440625667572,
0.2206510305404663,
-1.2814127206802368,
0.06603936105966568,
0.9144864082336426,
-0.29562637209892273,
-0.22745026648044586,
-0.2883610427379608,
-0.0184248685836792,
0.6520469784736633,
-0.18018202483654022,
1.150660514831543,
0.3308144807815552,
-0.056822098791599274,
-0.7399255633354187,
-0.5609077215194702,
0.47259965538978577,
0.2596001625061035,
-0.6698598265647888,
-0.2490343302488327,
0.31896379590034485,
0.5054365992546082,
-0.15792915225028992,
0.2775249481201172,
0.11300723999738693,
0.874829113483429,
-0.07960441708564758,
0.015038357116281986,
-0.13202020525932312,
-0.37969186902046204,
-0.4051947295665741,
0.30278483033180237,
-0.12022798508405685,
-0.7462994456291199
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08743v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08743v1
|
Steering LLMs Towards Unbiased Responses: A Causality-Guided Debiasing Framework
| 2024-03-13T17:46:28 | 2024-03-13T17:46:28 |
Jingling Li, Zeyu Tang, Xiaoyu Liu, Peter Spirtes, Kun Zhang, Liu Leqi, Yang Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) can easily generate biased and discriminative
responses. As LLMs tap into consequential decision-making (e.g., hiring and
healthcare), it is of crucial importance to develop strategies to mitigate
these biases. This paper focuses on social bias, tackling the association
between demographic information and LLM outputs. We propose a causality-guided
debiasing framework that utilizes causal understandings of (1) the
data-generating process of the training corpus fed to LLMs, and (2) the
internal reasoning process of LLM inference, to guide the design of prompts for
debiasing LLM outputs through selection mechanisms. Our framework unifies
existing de-biasing prompting approaches such as inhibitive instructions and
in-context contrastive examples, and sheds light on new ways of debiasing by
encouraging bias-free reasoning. Our strong empirical performance on real-world
datasets demonstrates that our framework provides principled guidelines on
debiasing LLM outputs even with only the black-box access.
|
[
-0.09817298501729965,
-0.6536795496940613,
0.8087421655654907,
0.21805311739444733,
-0.30826178193092346,
-0.2294098436832428,
-0.17290779948234558,
-0.03759719803929329,
0.03621707484126091,
0.693073034286499,
-0.6253538727760315,
-0.5712583065032959,
-0.6320403814315796,
-0.0442618727684021,
-0.10521773993968964,
0.6824791431427002,
0.2773187458515167,
0.58528733253479,
-0.4059247672557831,
0.05396443232893944,
-0.43934497237205505,
-0.6063258051872253,
-0.9555840492248535,
-0.6779736280441284,
0.7209866046905518,
0.6080583930015564,
0.6047645211219788,
0.5730971097946167,
0.14500048756599426,
0.13226404786109924,
-0.19288237392902374,
0.02370712347328663,
-0.7338960766792297,
0.29639700055122375,
-0.22785894572734833,
-0.5645188689231873,
-0.07633472979068756,
0.11514073610305786,
0.3929951786994934,
0.9478142261505127,
0.026169294491410255,
0.385798841714859,
0.3458409607410431,
0.9422425031661987,
-0.7115095257759094,
0.17074328660964966,
-0.6147491931915283,
-0.07427357137203217,
-0.10554993152618408,
-0.3074106276035309,
-0.610427975654602,
-0.5284703969955444,
-0.1309848129749298,
-0.2745146155357361,
0.31130698323249817,
-0.044241175055503845,
0.12374380230903625,
0.4495117664337158,
-0.7385575175285339,
-0.00715592922642827,
-0.7458364963531494,
0.7282024025917053,
-0.5556997060775757,
0.3393232226371765,
0.7170085906982422,
0.13563190400600433,
-0.20780032873153687,
-0.12613774836063385,
-0.20100589096546173,
-0.1583615243434906,
-0.029245393350720406,
0.02242249995470047,
0.0017751953564584255,
0.013896001502871513,
0.2852948307991028,
-0.2512299716472626,
-0.29639720916748047,
0.47362786531448364,
-0.5406059622764587,
0.12546397745609283,
0.6659418940544128,
-0.006335859186947346,
-0.10168977081775665,
-0.0029523291159421206,
-0.23664513230323792,
0.069416344165802,
-1.1617944240570068,
-0.33048033714294434,
0.6806423664093018,
0.2703845500946045,
-0.27399739623069763,
0.6791487336158752,
-0.23781564831733704,
0.43723657727241516,
0.4778174161911011,
0.316520631313324,
-0.0351744182407856,
0.10118812322616577,
-0.1691829115152359,
0.4084160327911377,
0.5811002254486084,
0.5949413180351257,
0.4011213183403015,
-0.21372324228286743,
-0.022694753482937813,
0.4888732135295868,
0.1638565957546234,
-0.6874097585678101,
0.3097871243953705,
0.3478575348854065,
-0.5130318403244019,
-0.5085363984107971,
-0.21949993073940277,
-1.0434215068817139,
-0.8925286531448364,
-0.4874567687511444,
-0.16856110095977783,
0.02252713218331337,
-0.041138894855976105,
0.1523548811674118,
-0.07551062852144241,
0.10666419565677643,
0.2999921441078186,
-0.8152267932891846,
-0.03703278675675392,
0.530561625957489,
0.36850738525390625,
-0.18835632503032684,
0.1995728313922882,
-0.6664012670516968,
0.5145930051803589,
-0.31025025248527527,
0.6322354078292847,
-0.6261073350906372,
-0.44856491684913635,
0.36942991614341736,
-0.18864485621452332,
0.11028262227773666,
-0.5711230039596558,
0.4745699167251587,
-0.5786015391349792,
0.09027497470378876,
-0.5806002616882324,
-0.22330127656459808,
-0.017676889896392822,
-0.04925348609685898,
-0.5440143942832947,
0.9172928929328918,
-0.13791942596435547,
-0.8673999905586243,
0.9188593626022339,
-0.2231866419315338,
-0.08489902317523956,
-0.26712265610694885,
-0.4788927733898163,
-0.2832695245742798,
0.09890184551477432,
0.32672587037086487,
0.4360208213329315,
-0.7686144709587097,
0.8950973749160767,
-1.0357996225357056,
-0.23729422688484192,
0.15099188685417175,
-0.6385354399681091,
1.028876781463623,
0.30781713128089905,
-0.5797622799873352,
0.3009023368358612,
-0.6756855249404907,
-0.5464737415313721,
0.021883130073547363,
-0.19384630024433136,
-0.5408517122268677,
0.2668967843055725,
-0.35149478912353516,
0.3287718892097473,
-0.15825632214546204,
-0.4140048027038574,
-0.08531410992145538,
-0.031699519604444504,
0.19837768375873566,
1.0727241039276123,
0.07301956415176392,
0.6527757048606873,
-0.2969365417957306,
0.26807600259780884,
0.1744910180568695,
0.3401801586151123,
0.5006793141365051,
-0.08530158549547195,
-0.5408625602722168,
-0.1678619533777237,
-0.22694428265094757,
0.40552443265914917,
-0.7861599922180176,
0.4180644452571869,
0.0068428851664066315,
-0.22980636358261108,
-0.2915756106376648,
0.31262436509132385,
0.2721503973007202,
0.5202165246009827,
0.11601431667804718,
0.0024108444340527058,
-0.5078046321868896,
-0.9104621410369873,
-0.21510417759418488,
-0.4031139016151428,
-0.09545779228210449,
0.08485843241214752,
0.2767288386821747,
-0.37098222970962524,
0.5879573225975037,
-0.42451488971710205,
-0.14407548308372498,
-0.09603030979633331,
0.024222740903496742,
0.16566315293312073,
0.32876962423324585,
0.4446122944355011,
-0.6510002613067627,
0.16295228898525238,
-0.485042005777359,
-0.9351027011871338,
-0.6815381050109863,
-0.1408725082874298,
-0.45544546842575073,
-0.06546533107757568,
0.6942766308784485,
-0.4684736728668213,
0.3601682186126709,
0.16512331366539001,
-0.5413164496421814,
0.3141769766807556,
-0.06334488093852997,
-0.00738088833168149,
-0.949707567691803,
-0.02770909108221531,
0.41374117136001587,
0.08841761946678162,
-0.12567344307899475,
-0.2604193091392517,
-0.32550251483917236,
0.10301797837018967,
-0.36576327681541443,
0.7431538701057434,
-0.47392717003822327,
0.0989668071269989,
0.07929132133722305,
0.3438505530357361,
-0.20011314749717712,
0.2392459660768509,
-0.06180530786514282,
0.3213616907596588,
0.3295725882053375,
-0.6075096726417542,
0.15990330278873444,
0.4194871187210083,
-0.2905611991882324,
0.8144625425338745,
-0.6042656302452087,
-0.08258526027202606,
-0.7354035973548889,
0.4530813694000244,
-0.834170401096344,
-0.11607616394758224,
0.178776815533638,
-0.27119919657707214,
0.007494468241930008,
-0.16319826245307922,
-0.2543712854385376,
-0.4332999587059021,
-0.4924145042896271,
0.4317338466644287,
0.29862168431282043,
-0.4466695487499237,
0.1735246479511261,
0.5309516191482544,
-0.09270332753658295,
-0.7443612217903137,
-0.8000997304916382,
-0.2560873329639435,
-0.4593973457813263,
-0.287463515996933,
0.11667145043611526,
-0.0032500969246029854,
-0.7412652969360352,
-0.12556524574756622,
-0.009214549325406551,
-0.0027441817801445723,
0.08787558972835541,
0.4198504686355591,
0.42021697759628296,
0.11479683220386505,
0.15132124722003937,
0.242980495095253,
-0.22024033963680267,
0.43918079137802124,
-0.285780668258667,
0.3919336497783661,
0.7904046177864075,
-0.7499268054962158,
-0.07086918503046036,
0.2982500195503235,
0.6059694290161133,
0.09851275384426117,
0.6096600294113159,
0.3475874662399292,
-0.19757318496704102,
-0.21053995192050934,
-0.752875030040741,
-0.5162351727485657,
-0.39651522040367126,
0.038602184504270554,
0.40153059363365173,
-0.9424307942390442,
0.34966158866882324,
0.05415619537234306,
0.07362111657857895,
0.21348261833190918,
0.9953373074531555,
0.219521164894104,
1.0290498733520508,
0.257879376411438,
-0.24948596954345703,
0.5215545892715454,
0.026524871587753296,
0.10632844269275665,
-0.6299726366996765,
-0.2831360399723053,
-0.5973652005195618,
-0.1950426995754242,
-0.5996837019920349,
-0.46495291590690613,
0.285065233707428,
0.02963128685951233,
-0.5864309072494507,
-0.3677102029323578,
-0.493415504693985,
0.2149023413658142,
0.667234480381012,
0.3028424382209778,
0.02153085358440876,
-0.08342339098453522,
-0.32893410325050354,
0.1421840488910675,
-0.6087228655815125,
-0.5909197926521301,
1.1267131567001343,
0.2539835572242737,
1.189501404762268,
0.03629394993185997,
0.5889677405357361,
0.5596761107444763,
0.516944944858551,
-0.2518971264362335,
0.4748142957687378,
0.0067729344591498375,
-0.873361349105835,
-0.22767949104309082,
-0.46477755904197693,
-0.8272491097450256,
0.3459828197956085,
-0.3800186812877655,
-0.7055635452270508,
0.5801743865013123,
0.30419549345970154,
-0.28295019268989563,
0.24469216167926788,
-0.4513552486896515,
0.4846360981464386,
-0.18699492514133453,
-0.9019240140914917,
-0.3900548815727234,
-0.5303018093109131,
0.5512515306472778,
-0.039047595113515854,
0.36356866359710693,
-0.5086803436279297,
0.2717522382736206,
0.5850621461868286,
-0.00997844710946083,
1.4474934339523315,
-0.5172568559646606,
-0.0410851389169693,
0.3430015742778778,
-0.004812891595065594,
0.3005344271659851,
0.3468771278858185,
-0.462484210729599,
0.13427048921585083,
-0.061831872910261154,
-0.2941689193248749,
-0.2751215994358063,
0.8038845658302307,
-0.6611456871032715,
-0.7407785654067993,
-0.16949337720870972,
-0.42339256405830383,
-0.41755157709121704,
0.0023323572240769863,
0.02687542885541916,
0.32873430848121643,
-0.3818706274032593,
0.22866438329219818,
0.6799989938735962,
-0.38178879022598267,
0.023002447560429573,
0.5909863710403442,
-0.08645247668027878,
-0.3568316698074341,
0.1774480640888214,
0.14333167672157288,
0.25688105821609497,
0.2902749180793762,
0.3290904462337494,
-0.48627665638923645,
-0.21063099801540375,
-0.41763418912887573,
0.21193982660770416,
-0.697053074836731,
-0.21945184469223022,
-0.3889386057853699,
0.23990097641944885,
-0.6294637322425842,
-0.23799557983875275,
0.12255095690488815,
-0.17183297872543335,
-0.24168884754180908,
-0.43641582131385803,
0.21756583452224731,
0.8424221873283386,
-0.2333480268716812,
0.29304230213165283,
-0.41204312443733215,
0.3364325761795044,
0.39403748512268066,
0.021241389214992523,
0.17658957839012146,
-0.27884945273399353,
-0.017653215676546097,
0.21898330748081207,
-0.333943247795105,
-1.0371692180633545,
0.16623760759830475,
-0.45215079188346863,
0.7613493204116821,
0.5452364683151245,
0.4099637269973755,
0.2642163336277008,
-0.41752734780311584,
0.6821944117546082,
0.1722998470067978,
-0.5006492137908936,
0.4635743498802185,
-0.5583009123802185,
0.04544349014759064,
0.5824918746948242,
0.40742698311805725,
-0.3805697560310364,
-0.5370928645133972,
-0.49303579330444336,
-0.8645914196968079,
0.5190138816833496,
-0.14177215099334717,
-0.03378082811832428,
-0.42317667603492737,
0.36887767910957336,
0.00618775887414813,
0.2661607563495636,
-0.5881738662719727,
-0.21741311252117157,
0.2851775586605072,
-0.3445189297199249,
-0.023388059809803963,
-0.7304130792617798,
-0.3891080319881439,
-0.13238057494163513,
0.6637860536575317,
-0.21446843445301056,
0.07599597424268723,
0.190440371632576,
-0.1480182260274887,
-0.32319360971450806,
0.3497403860092163,
0.4312067925930023,
0.6991094350814819,
-0.19436056911945343,
0.3407505452632904,
0.09734488278627396,
-0.05179140716791153,
0.3611193001270294,
0.029616285115480423,
-0.530139148235321,
-0.2223130613565445,
0.2460033893585205,
0.6160228848457336,
0.3342871367931366,
-0.2578897178173065,
0.49838608503341675,
0.1992112100124359,
-0.08497737348079681,
-0.22178642451763153,
-0.11776842176914215,
0.09527745842933655,
0.3081773817539215,
0.2733288109302521,
-0.4704556465148926,
-0.04199555516242981,
-0.2536461353302002,
0.19356831908226013,
0.7051039934158325,
-0.5816051363945007,
-0.17220626771450043,
1.1185106039047241,
0.39873260259628296,
0.2370711714029312,
0.3330717086791992,
0.08978022634983063,
-0.04283740743994713,
0.5976136326789856,
0.6438978314399719,
1.0072375535964966,
-0.22060516476631165,
0.38776999711990356,
0.33358556032180786,
0.24019484221935272,
-0.21676383912563324,
0.15881669521331787,
0.06404335051774979,
-0.8490082025527954,
-0.452789843082428,
-0.49585896730422974,
-0.3741084039211273,
0.10225094109773636,
-0.8091080188751221,
0.32445111870765686,
-0.40794846415519714,
-0.2026136815547943,
-0.0864643007516861,
-0.42130324244499207,
-0.7321697473526001,
0.25946757197380066,
0.27351856231689453,
0.7486949563026428,
-1.1035772562026978,
0.650148332118988,
0.36847957968711853,
-0.4405517578125,
-0.41852039098739624,
-0.1428678035736084,
0.5740978121757507,
-1.1652562618255615,
0.9975924491882324,
-0.0837140902876854,
-0.2187950164079666,
-0.48586228489875793,
-0.692936897277832,
-0.6127046346664429,
0.8616580367088318,
0.9023985266685486,
-0.4819968640804291,
-0.08738740533590317,
0.11534913629293442,
0.07997903227806091,
-0.400568425655365,
0.40178993344306946,
0.4940266013145447,
0.5805264115333557,
-0.08803769946098328,
-0.39674580097198486,
0.2764511704444885,
0.159123957157135,
0.021866945549845695,
-0.004967001266777515,
-0.5150170922279358,
0.5397639870643616,
-0.28229326009750366,
-0.03640000894665718,
-0.4593408405780792,
0.38791951537132263,
0.3601672351360321,
0.38453060388565063,
0.5255141854286194,
0.22507837414741516,
0.6975409984588623,
0.12602998316287994,
0.9146376848220825,
-0.3947301208972931,
0.012553212232887745,
1.062216877937317,
-0.662847101688385,
0.3338196873664856,
0.6662526726722717,
-0.11197162419557571,
0.40364304184913635,
0.6884064674377441,
0.3280823528766632,
0.43083006143569946,
0.4791778326034546,
-0.36179083585739136,
-0.2847534120082855,
-0.4956820607185364,
-0.05873534455895424,
0.20274212956428528,
0.27125096321105957,
-0.701794445514679,
-0.429662823677063,
-0.22262069582939148,
0.33170220255851746,
0.23517529666423798,
-0.261691153049469,
0.7168322801589966,
0.28387996554374695,
-0.6386299729347229,
0.3796454966068268,
-0.2554621994495392,
0.6021384000778198,
-0.6745156645774841,
-0.11037616431713104,
-0.3068752884864807,
0.1675085574388504,
-0.2164088487625122,
-0.580411970615387,
0.2779451012611389,
-0.04230724647641182,
-0.5764519572257996,
-0.45479705929756165,
0.7774229049682617,
-0.4980054795742035,
-0.3970845937728882,
0.6060059666633606,
0.7941325902938843,
-0.18000979721546173,
0.08453831821680069,
-0.488452672958374,
0.09334104508161545,
0.1832982450723648,
-0.26998868584632874,
0.4326240122318268,
0.5653573274612427,
-0.4590536057949066,
0.5913320183753967,
0.7330273985862732,
0.36418667435646057,
-0.20762412250041962,
0.45542147755622864,
0.780068039894104,
-0.5179724097251892,
-0.3765493929386139,
-1.0806329250335693,
0.21612685918807983,
-0.3135085105895996,
-0.1341736614704132,
0.6390765309333801,
0.2887307405471802,
0.7339508533477783,
0.049780525267124176,
0.8059688806533813,
0.34402331709861755,
0.3157288134098053,
-0.5601400136947632,
0.5362318158149719,
-0.24573034048080444,
0.29480960965156555,
-0.27675291895866394,
-0.7566384673118591,
-0.22307948768138885,
0.4951806664466858,
-0.6815908551216125,
0.02207355387508869,
0.35344889760017395,
0.9237726926803589,
0.28485459089279175,
-0.22595101594924927,
0.3080046474933624,
0.018518073484301567,
0.3713643252849579,
0.36090904474258423,
0.6868301033973694,
0.29892200231552124,
0.16255103051662445,
0.019226133823394775,
-0.3776780962944031,
-0.08035872876644135,
-1.0596712827682495,
-0.9790732860565186,
-0.25488072633743286,
-0.14887230098247528,
-0.4377671480178833,
0.11957794427871704,
1.161190390586853,
0.530614972114563,
-0.6080401539802551,
-0.3410419821739197,
0.1983400285243988,
0.3894031345844269,
0.021114131435751915,
-0.20253191888332367,
0.21209844946861267,
-0.31531068682670593,
-0.3881789445877075,
0.14128394424915314,
0.1896071583032608,
-0.25981605052948,
-0.4611446261405945,
0.013473611325025558,
-0.1686430126428604,
0.2591473162174225,
0.5971412062644958,
-0.06229668855667114,
-0.5305613279342651,
-0.26861336827278137,
-0.414882093667984,
-0.12021621316671371,
-0.24267682433128357,
1.0572271347045898,
-0.6844707727432251,
0.14698825776576996,
0.3767824172973633,
0.5786798000335693,
0.2704616189002991,
-0.10950881242752075,
0.7961106896400452,
-0.5759027004241943,
0.40046533942222595,
0.07342340797185898,
0.5406742691993713,
0.4209933578968048,
-0.6641950011253357,
0.6656609773635864,
0.148947075009346,
-0.5653160810470581,
-0.7400856018066406,
0.29848429560661316,
-0.5519564747810364,
-0.357726126909256,
1.6671545505523682,
0.3562428951263428,
-0.1941877156496048,
-0.21379990875720978,
-0.26925432682037354,
0.42996037006378174,
-0.5085667371749878,
0.9162892699241638,
0.4679330289363861,
0.07847283035516739,
0.12937504053115845,
-0.6867936253547668,
0.46558764576911926,
0.44631052017211914,
-0.732140064239502,
0.5647119283676147,
0.964155375957489,
0.10588022321462631,
-0.26598578691482544,
0.8611867427825928,
-0.2707445025444031,
-0.021136503666639328,
-0.14216235280036926,
0.06880500912666321,
0.10243918001651764,
-0.04623809829354286,
-0.29872459173202515,
-0.12348881363868713,
0.21969741582870483,
-0.10098525136709213
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08739v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08739v1
|
The Garden of Forking Paths: Observing Dynamic Parameters Distribution in Large Language Models
| 2024-03-13T17:42:32 | 2024-03-13T17:42:32 |
Carlo Nicolini, Jacopo Staiano, Bruno Lepri, Raffaele Marino
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cond-mat.dis-nn, cond-mat.stat-mech, cs.AI
|
A substantial gap persists in understanding the reasons behind the
exceptional performance of the Transformer architecture in NLP. A particularly
unexplored area involves the mechanistic description of how the distribution of
parameters evolves over time during training. In this work we suggest that
looking at the time evolution of the statistic distribution of model
parameters, and specifically at bifurcation effects, can help understanding the
model quality, potentially reducing training costs and evaluation efforts and
empirically showing the reasons behind the effectiveness of weights
sparsification.
|
[
-0.5533800721168518,
-0.8028590083122253,
0.6773254871368408,
0.2286015897989273,
-0.2432163655757904,
-0.13901400566101074,
0.10793079435825348,
-0.4983369708061218,
-0.04696449264883995,
0.3569397032260895,
-0.8868515491485596,
0.03470931574702263,
-0.7911006808280945,
-0.06812430918216705,
-0.8944947123527527,
1.0200185775756836,
-0.21584217250347137,
-0.01233269739896059,
0.17659492790699005,
-0.34599384665489197,
-0.16696615517139435,
-0.21544773876667023,
-0.6304394006729126,
-0.8028766512870789,
0.7799301147460938,
-0.2854384779930115,
1.1181561946868896,
0.9239594340324402,
0.1362418234348297,
0.30142417550086975,
-0.3870640993118286,
-0.33833086490631104,
-0.2306724488735199,
0.6244722604751587,
-0.3143840432167053,
-0.6557615995407104,
0.35621094703674316,
-0.00234800623729825,
0.9405786395072937,
1.229799509048462,
-0.11627022176980972,
0.12304605543613434,
0.18729253113269806,
0.7337008118629456,
-0.429680198431015,
0.17108164727687836,
-0.3398225009441376,
0.3671773672103882,
-0.35807567834854126,
-0.43693050742149353,
-0.3592012822628021,
-0.25359079241752625,
0.5343956351280212,
-0.2519450783729553,
0.34986168146133423,
0.016048617660999298,
1.1132707595825195,
0.39745232462882996,
-0.28036734461784363,
-0.37634211778640747,
-1.1560591459274292,
0.8282553553581238,
-0.41298916935920715,
0.6753941178321838,
0.007051617372781038,
0.5379934906959534,
-0.24135823547840118,
-0.7119990587234497,
-0.4372006952762604,
0.08947200328111649,
0.1055665835738182,
-0.18971183896064758,
-0.27530384063720703,
-0.06345326453447342,
0.3177826404571533,
0.3838396966457367,
-0.32785600423812866,
0.05728832259774208,
-0.11841271072626114,
0.288110613822937,
0.45826756954193115,
0.293842077255249,
0.2869028151035309,
-0.19670967757701874,
-0.160226508975029,
-0.6844492554664612,
-0.40417611598968506,
0.27543196082115173,
0.8073623180389404,
0.2208183854818344,
-0.08955378830432892,
0.3589501976966858,
0.12444975972175598,
0.5867651104927063,
-0.030465366318821907,
0.39077022671699524,
0.15748602151870728,
-0.34188324213027954,
-0.09774854779243469,
-0.20922380685806274,
0.759268581867218,
0.23794563114643097,
0.14229832589626312,
-0.5344624519348145,
-0.15964651107788086,
-0.1990184336900711,
0.4054407775402069,
-0.639930009841919,
-0.6136610507965088,
0.03167472779750824,
-0.611088216304779,
-0.46387597918510437,
0.17598024010658264,
-0.9753047823905945,
-0.42600181698799133,
-0.1380394995212555,
0.14911974966526031,
-0.42227110266685486,
-0.6600350737571716,
0.09047825634479523,
-0.6066837906837463,
0.36922702193260193,
0.07302393764257431,
-1.0277763605117798,
0.37927010655403137,
0.5588419437408447,
1.0885461568832397,
-0.06286261230707169,
-0.5253804922103882,
-0.3428521752357483,
0.018337439745664597,
-0.48873838782310486,
0.6936301589012146,
-0.5579861998558044,
-0.04811455309391022,
0.10381843149662018,
0.35323113203048706,
-0.07961247861385345,
-0.5417512655258179,
0.22156527638435364,
-0.6904026865959167,
-0.032825227826833725,
-0.26769283413887024,
-0.2640441060066223,
-0.39452823996543884,
-0.048122987151145935,
-0.7914511561393738,
1.074562668800354,
0.3788004219532013,
-0.8921452760696411,
0.590400755405426,
-0.7470125555992126,
-0.3385060429573059,
0.02731885388493538,
-0.04957820102572441,
-0.38517558574676514,
0.21177570521831512,
-0.1049344539642334,
0.448018878698349,
-0.17290271818637848,
0.3583161532878876,
-0.28291139006614685,
-0.12612846493721008,
0.34123194217681885,
-0.9810115694999695,
1.1028573513031006,
0.20876018702983856,
-0.6056629419326782,
0.04650415480136871,
-0.5987449288368225,
-0.32767558097839355,
0.13446828722953796,
-0.35175788402557373,
-0.50364089012146,
0.5141338109970093,
0.08993077278137207,
0.15000368654727936,
-0.37536951899528503,
-0.029845060780644417,
0.13732993602752686,
-0.8486123085021973,
0.4461899697780609,
0.725299596786499,
0.5215258002281189,
0.5139989256858826,
-0.05383025482296944,
0.3772905766963959,
0.4503922760486603,
0.5273861885070801,
-0.04656265303492546,
-0.49673405289649963,
-0.8260450959205627,
0.3549385666847229,
0.40797027945518494,
0.1046108677983284,
-0.707584798336029,
0.22417546808719635,
-0.07965720444917679,
-0.6030030250549316,
-0.42016637325286865,
-0.13255254924297333,
0.09126903861761093,
0.002100184792652726,
0.3082696497440338,
-0.09979748725891113,
-0.22080391645431519,
-0.832888662815094,
-0.2736411690711975,
-0.08574726432561874,
-0.06712226569652557,
0.007794980891048908,
0.5788992643356323,
-0.353014200925827,
0.8131656050682068,
-0.405091792345047,
0.4861532151699066,
-0.132407546043396,
0.5595327019691467,
0.38812825083732605,
0.36688101291656494,
0.9382770657539368,
-0.7493709325790405,
-0.3873918652534485,
-0.16147269308567047,
-0.4158879220485687,
-0.15877366065979004,
-0.26663917303085327,
-0.32616686820983887,
0.18343348801136017,
0.2822217643260956,
-0.560012698173523,
0.34580692648887634,
0.8388801217079163,
-0.32515931129455566,
0.8869713544845581,
-0.2831895649433136,
-0.10361748188734055,
-1.031068205833435,
-0.07732101529836655,
0.31460806727409363,
-0.18051393330097198,
-0.4700184166431427,
-0.033412571996450424,
-0.3645668029785156,
0.16047945618629456,
-0.17700816690921783,
0.27290183305740356,
-0.6649206280708313,
-0.20617583394050598,
-0.03147554770112038,
0.06533068418502808,
-0.1378239244222641,
0.3184368908405304,
-0.35474327206611633,
0.5001915097236633,
0.7387697696685791,
-0.7523177862167358,
0.4880199134349823,
-0.06640563160181046,
-0.2734621465206146,
0.33128443360328674,
-0.6866725087165833,
-0.3871493339538574,
-0.0545622743666172,
-0.15168800950050354,
-1.0604993104934692,
0.05313814803957939,
0.35189542174339294,
-0.26167434453964233,
0.41618743538856506,
-0.39330682158470154,
-0.6340555548667908,
-0.3238934576511383,
-0.34905821084976196,
0.1598178744316101,
0.45260319113731384,
-0.6691015958786011,
0.5258669853210449,
0.2345731109380722,
0.04483740031719208,
-0.5208384394645691,
-0.581977903842926,
-0.09914781153202057,
-0.28784993290901184,
-0.5085755586624146,
-0.02109266072511673,
0.13300028443336487,
-0.3035288453102112,
0.09208343178033829,
-0.23780076205730438,
0.08636510372161865,
0.21793673932552338,
0.4763948321342468,
-0.1801239550113678,
-0.1569894701242447,
0.11995313316583633,
0.4108293354511261,
-0.18288640677928925,
0.5912042856216431,
-0.35162436962127686,
0.9077056646347046,
0.20752091705799103,
-0.34528490900993347,
-0.2556473910808563,
0.19414016604423523,
0.6412009000778198,
-0.09495548158884048,
1.125740647315979,
0.2732008397579193,
-0.17633946239948273,
-0.5577031373977661,
-0.15672385692596436,
-0.06330646574497223,
-0.5681326985359192,
0.36403635144233704,
-0.2096138298511505,
-0.3605342209339142,
0.6217257976531982,
-0.3846895098686218,
0.10165739804506302,
0.5769438743591309,
0.5425933003425598,
-0.24484381079673767,
1.2248440980911255,
0.6638085246086121,
-0.07392504811286926,
0.7040655016899109,
-0.5727044939994812,
0.18846558034420013,
-0.7742373943328857,
-0.20749244093894958,
-0.5339959263801575,
-0.4972904622554779,
-0.932728111743927,
-0.5602656602859497,
0.3615768253803253,
0.19184811413288116,
-0.36842575669288635,
0.08256655931472778,
-0.569003701210022,
0.3253866136074066,
0.4852035939693451,
-0.15550148487091064,
-0.09895801544189453,
-0.055783189833164215,
-0.41872549057006836,
0.2158418446779251,
-0.6806634664535522,
-0.4030914902687073,
0.5313857793807983,
0.6421063542366028,
0.687768816947937,
0.01143685169517994,
0.3336319923400879,
0.216964989900589,
-0.015758512541651726,
-0.6296535730361938,
0.27258121967315674,
-0.03770185261964798,
-0.4825300872325897,
-0.5334173440933228,
-0.42219680547714233,
-1.278329610824585,
0.11944462358951569,
-0.19562314450740814,
-0.8049192428588867,
0.27626723051071167,
0.2099163830280304,
-0.050197750329971313,
0.5669366121292114,
-0.4791966676712036,
0.9946650862693787,
-0.27543267607688904,
-0.27291956543922424,
-0.04227897524833679,
-0.8131916522979736,
0.0895932987332344,
0.1721518337726593,
0.019080428406596184,
0.2235778421163559,
0.20975658297538757,
0.9003451466560364,
-0.5055264830589294,
0.6367620229721069,
-0.44737324118614197,
0.1751580685377121,
0.046495016664266586,
0.3407783508300781,
0.6010546088218689,
-0.211101233959198,
-0.11957747489213943,
0.11317234486341476,
0.3272489011287689,
-0.22434461116790771,
-0.7883619070053101,
0.72587651014328,
-0.9852507710456848,
-0.46643775701522827,
-0.3926210105419159,
-0.6208198070526123,
-0.24542874097824097,
0.10559546202421188,
0.1817166954278946,
0.36991086602211,
0.3236808776855469,
0.45375847816467285,
0.6908905506134033,
-0.4365510940551758,
0.7542251944541931,
0.035028643906116486,
-0.2933790683746338,
0.03859497606754303,
0.422270804643631,
0.5277538299560547,
0.3530410826206207,
0.04715409502387047,
0.5342990159988403,
-0.3789006471633911,
-0.7356916666030884,
-0.5666715502738953,
0.5253866314888,
-0.7203453779220581,
0.1707654744386673,
-0.6074864268302917,
-0.2855454683303833,
0.037641387432813644,
-0.1851194053888321,
-0.41781747341156006,
-0.07559182494878769,
-0.22435401380062103,
-0.33003726601600647,
0.5331801772117615,
1.052435040473938,
0.3621584177017212,
0.616806149482727,
-0.6038438081741333,
-0.24805249273777008,
-0.0235268697142601,
0.7584776282310486,
0.5629479885101318,
-0.4444287121295929,
-0.3681464195251465,
0.09413217753171921,
-0.4512815475463867,
-1.3885540962219238,
0.2836386263370514,
-0.24549110233783722,
0.6147749423980713,
0.6919552087783813,
-0.10686283558607101,
0.6494234204292297,
-0.568245530128479,
1.0823115110397339,
0.3997339606285095,
-0.9054605960845947,
0.3799329400062561,
-0.37281206250190735,
0.16535718739032745,
0.06521164625883102,
0.671773374080658,
-0.6944281458854675,
-0.49052587151527405,
-0.5751956105232239,
-1.2500100135803223,
0.777036190032959,
0.011657209135591984,
0.36268389225006104,
0.2563566267490387,
0.6387198567390442,
0.249130979180336,
-0.09715926647186279,
-0.7721637487411499,
-0.38581186532974243,
-0.39918503165245056,
-0.04841960221529007,
-0.04566745460033417,
-0.34818804264068604,
-0.013139156624674797,
-0.38771238923072815,
0.5322585105895996,
0.1674610823392868,
0.09270967543125153,
-0.21301281452178955,
0.1402183324098587,
-0.5787138342857361,
-0.0851578637957573,
0.28749746084213257,
0.7451848983764648,
0.12063291668891907,
0.40668603777885437,
0.12495105713605881,
-0.26326391100883484,
0.07938703149557114,
0.007750941440463066,
-0.23842044174671173,
0.22299468517303467,
0.43836709856987,
1.133640170097351,
0.1649394929409027,
-0.3639698624610901,
0.4133839011192322,
0.31569546461105347,
-0.36676251888275146,
-0.2798313498497009,
0.425873726606369,
0.3106118440628052,
0.7315691113471985,
0.34681984782218933,
-0.06856831908226013,
0.30379006266593933,
-0.45492997765541077,
0.24995781481266022,
0.3446565270423889,
-0.6437855362892151,
-0.6769285798072815,
0.5786970853805542,
-0.16382284462451935,
-0.5740686655044556,
0.7415698170661926,
-0.09356369823217392,
-0.49802544713020325,
0.303379625082016,
0.377757728099823,
0.7586798667907715,
-0.3600575029850006,
0.46767181158065796,
0.12967705726623535,
0.36026713252067566,
-0.20031245052814484,
-0.05472956597805023,
0.06631537526845932,
-0.45559656620025635,
-0.34516921639442444,
-0.9632346034049988,
-0.17377249896526337,
0.11190984398126602,
-0.6272319555282593,
0.2510330379009247,
-0.21696072816848755,
-0.1820109486579895,
0.30214792490005493,
-0.2834473252296448,
-0.5529812574386597,
0.06673502922058105,
-0.0804281011223793,
0.8939211964607239,
-1.3097513914108276,
0.5661448240280151,
0.6339849233627319,
-0.6927645802497864,
-1.0112751722335815,
0.2726026773452759,
-0.38046178221702576,
-0.39660197496414185,
0.7696123719215393,
-0.15476316213607788,
-0.184083953499794,
-0.18791039288043976,
-0.452589213848114,
-0.8669467568397522,
1.0444777011871338,
0.21837197244167328,
-0.5356675982475281,
-0.36611050367355347,
0.48761001229286194,
0.7442615628242493,
0.20645703375339508,
0.12420781701803207,
0.48586505651474,
0.47028717398643494,
0.1263069361448288,
-0.5607417225837708,
-0.052585262805223465,
-0.14178159832954407,
0.47776365280151367,
0.8014658689498901,
-0.3558979630470276,
0.9865297079086304,
0.2799084782600403,
-0.31816813349723816,
-0.23254740238189697,
0.24258337914943695,
-0.13802604377269745,
0.13649731874465942,
0.7881349325180054,
0.36520472168922424,
0.4579254984855652,
-0.34499478340148926,
1.1693572998046875,
-0.4171854853630066,
0.5009214282035828,
0.6072025895118713,
0.10636072605848312,
0.8182166218757629,
0.9160314798355103,
-0.5782721638679504,
0.7281197309494019,
0.8002102375030518,
-0.19877968728542328,
0.560811460018158,
0.5379260182380676,
0.07317425310611725,
0.17678150534629822,
0.2906486690044403,
-0.04296605661511421,
0.1168617382645607,
0.0963231697678566,
-0.5794687867164612,
-0.4312431216239929,
0.06050672009587288,
-0.059179794043302536,
-0.26501157879829407,
0.0677383542060852,
0.4801514446735382,
-0.11060795187950134,
-0.5553080439567566,
0.34975099563598633,
-0.1808921992778778,
0.44733497500419617,
-0.6633590459823608,
-0.09243862330913544,
-0.0751805379986763,
0.2140495479106903,
-0.044298335909843445,
-1.0073351860046387,
0.6894354820251465,
-0.2037959098815918,
-0.3365013301372528,
-0.2569632828235626,
0.23245017230510712,
-0.08659674972295761,
-0.26716628670692444,
0.7618836164474487,
0.3117891848087311,
0.21498991549015045,
0.006272026337683201,
-0.8467711210250854,
0.24283729493618011,
-0.4098983407020569,
-0.8618200421333313,
0.1377003788948059,
0.8153960704803467,
0.08459068089723587,
0.7133538722991943,
0.5401173233985901,
0.17681939899921417,
0.4251576364040375,
0.1790962517261505,
0.9375725388526917,
-0.5464066863059998,
-0.37096884846687317,
-0.9901296496391296,
0.7311265468597412,
-0.036590367555618286,
-0.28265413641929626,
0.6662402749061584,
0.42536497116088867,
0.7286301851272583,
-0.0707239955663681,
0.533284068107605,
0.0583389550447464,
0.32834598422050476,
-0.4264218807220459,
0.9027135372161865,
-0.7083890438079834,
0.2987808585166931,
-0.3117220103740692,
-0.9968166947364807,
-0.08923447877168655,
0.49932217597961426,
-0.4017920196056366,
0.14484655857086182,
0.7343183755874634,
0.5862195491790771,
-0.11753339320421219,
-0.061638254672288895,
0.24348071217536926,
0.34615015983581543,
0.46843183040618896,
0.04039209708571434,
1.0217729806900024,
-0.4558814465999603,
0.33873799443244934,
-0.22189977765083313,
-0.12340981513261795,
-0.28996527194976807,
-0.8407265543937683,
-0.6715568900108337,
-0.9785858392715454,
-0.20875968039035797,
-0.4388192296028137,
0.15813501179218292,
0.7090050578117371,
0.7047715783119202,
-0.6934376955032349,
-0.45653122663497925,
-0.37585946917533875,
0.09660477936267853,
-0.6595199704170227,
-0.28939881920814514,
0.30544427037239075,
-0.44497835636138916,
-0.529020369052887,
-0.16131417453289032,
0.4460965096950531,
-0.012019882909953594,
-0.8102712035179138,
-0.1464308798313141,
-0.40999943017959595,
0.3019983470439911,
0.45518195629119873,
-0.09863393008708954,
-0.7292271852493286,
-0.47899580001831055,
0.06930286437273026,
0.38313114643096924,
-0.01611953414976597,
0.5851406455039978,
-0.19019435346126556,
0.4927772283554077,
0.5555048584938049,
0.5381624102592468,
0.5876663327217102,
-0.28595396876335144,
0.6106491684913635,
-0.6342771649360657,
-0.10100902616977692,
-0.006554342340677977,
0.3052786886692047,
0.10738348215818405,
-0.10897788405418396,
0.4170309901237488,
0.3594071865081787,
-0.6304653882980347,
-1.1309210062026978,
0.19543208181858063,
-0.7718565464019775,
-0.3343983590602875,
1.0016118288040161,
-0.010228333063423634,
-0.48317378759384155,
-0.13404390215873718,
0.10063230991363525,
0.8063998818397522,
0.11276516318321228,
0.9310210943222046,
1.076444149017334,
-0.42027217149734497,
-0.536325991153717,
-0.6863280534744263,
0.5462141036987305,
0.11546750366687775,
-0.6427314281463623,
0.3184741735458374,
0.3234340250492096,
0.4564262926578522,
0.37273523211479187,
-0.16615740954875946,
-0.04494830593466759,
-0.08872883766889572,
0.21451956033706665,
-0.15108734369277954,
0.16324442625045776,
-0.4610566794872284,
-0.12094804644584656,
0.21244968473911285,
0.3419506847858429,
-0.18061727285385132
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08738v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08738v1
|
Improving Acoustic Word Embeddings through Correspondence Training of Self-supervised Speech Representations
| 2024-03-13T17:42:03 | 2024-03-13T17:42:03 |
Amit Meghanani, Thomas Hain
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Acoustic word embeddings (AWEs) are vector representations of spoken words.
An effective method for obtaining AWEs is the Correspondence Auto-Encoder
(CAE). In the past, the CAE method has been associated with traditional MFCC
features. Representations obtained from self-supervised learning (SSL)-based
speech models such as HuBERT, Wav2vec2, etc., are outperforming MFCC in many
downstream tasks. However, they have not been well studied in the context of
learning AWEs. This work explores the effectiveness of CAE with SSL-based
speech representations to obtain improved AWEs. Additionally, the capabilities
of SSL-based speech models are explored in cross-lingual scenarios for
obtaining AWEs. Experiments are conducted on five languages: Polish,
Portuguese, Spanish, French, and English. HuBERT-based CAE model achieves the
best results for word discrimination in all languages, despite Hu-BERT being
pre-trained on English only. Also, the HuBERT-based CAE model works well in
cross-lingual settings. It outperforms MFCC-based CAE models trained on the
target languages when trained on one source language and tested on target
languages.
|
[
-0.3617309331893921,
-0.518334150314331,
0.30011609196662903,
0.23123109340667725,
-0.17407214641571045,
0.11177419126033783,
-0.15699468553066254,
-0.7289438247680664,
0.5719795823097229,
0.22331655025482178,
-0.4249686598777771,
-0.6067153215408325,
-0.6578742265701294,
0.24179388582706451,
-0.3597049117088318,
0.376743346452713,
-0.11858390271663666,
0.3635242283344269,
0.05731634050607681,
-0.21936407685279846,
-0.5716015100479126,
-0.6348257660865784,
-0.4674689471721649,
-0.24981167912483215,
0.2945595383644104,
-0.008167589083313942,
0.48108699917793274,
0.8264560699462891,
0.11467281728982925,
0.35212743282318115,
0.20076026022434235,
0.11768370866775513,
-0.5086485147476196,
0.06326144933700562,
0.05329287052154541,
-0.366550087928772,
0.021190956234931946,
0.17509624361991882,
0.5848650932312012,
0.6695258617401123,
-0.41243624687194824,
-0.18628732860088348,
0.3648918867111206,
0.3194020986557007,
-0.7128615379333496,
0.40879082679748535,
-0.7005670070648193,
0.37623295187950134,
-0.04751015827059746,
-0.18382182717323303,
-0.42000946402549744,
0.05709083750844002,
0.29262417554855347,
-0.7119379043579102,
0.016608037054538727,
0.10565261542797089,
0.6863723397254944,
0.13625630736351013,
-0.15891033411026,
-0.5748750567436218,
-0.6033642292022705,
0.7638542652130127,
-0.8264448642730713,
1.2323427200317383,
0.5286208987236023,
0.1364305466413498,
-0.12456034123897552,
-0.36608758568763733,
-0.3567158877849579,
-0.3356163799762726,
0.03977152332663536,
0.3480845093727112,
-0.11727724969387054,
0.11118391156196594,
-0.0970764234662056,
0.44962039589881897,
-0.3646213710308075,
0.3019315004348755,
-0.21197015047073364,
-0.5149379968643188,
0.6226116418838501,
-0.15719754993915558,
0.28687232732772827,
-0.09708087146282196,
-0.379243940114975,
-0.2910781502723694,
-0.5812028646469116,
0.034804992377758026,
0.40729597210884094,
0.41086888313293457,
-0.34656286239624023,
0.3592027425765991,
0.11198168992996216,
0.634525716304779,
0.22582590579986572,
-0.19559767842292786,
0.3211425244808197,
-0.13907137513160706,
-0.08540921658277512,
0.3758712410926819,
0.7418813705444336,
-0.22988161444664001,
0.35833194851875305,
-0.3155708909034729,
-0.16812218725681305,
0.11214953660964966,
-0.08787588030099869,
-0.1613408327102661,
-0.3120429217815399,
-0.2049570083618164,
-0.3491467833518982,
-0.023930804803967476,
0.09411473572254181,
-0.20328496396541595,
0.18786492943763733,
-0.6261322498321533,
0.6147010922431946,
-0.4068654775619507,
-0.18099765479564667,
0.09194185584783554,
-0.11042255908250809,
0.3889182507991791,
0.017719745635986328,
-1.141463279724121,
0.2656901478767395,
0.3594694435596466,
0.6967568397521973,
-0.0440424382686615,
-0.31328365206718445,
-0.6338216066360474,
0.4631301760673523,
-0.5452147126197815,
0.6424039006233215,
-0.4836965501308441,
-0.6796903014183044,
0.31131935119628906,
-0.2057417631149292,
-0.2787618935108185,
-0.5008578896522522,
0.385137677192688,
-0.1730584353208542,
0.3986789584159851,
-0.18764029443264008,
-0.9514254331588745,
0.034689340740442276,
-0.23255188763141632,
-0.5388467311859131,
1.1060253381729126,
0.017460249364376068,
-0.5500216484069824,
0.21801698207855225,
-0.37916505336761475,
-0.48289984464645386,
-0.20679596066474915,
-0.5260311365127563,
-0.1697075217962265,
0.13302767276763916,
0.5002851486206055,
0.47525012493133545,
0.07089593261480331,
-0.13774098455905914,
-0.261029452085495,
-0.2645696699619293,
-0.027695849537849426,
-0.4138076901435852,
0.6318286657333374,
0.19105909764766693,
-0.41704320907592773,
-0.2784493863582611,
-0.45238807797431946,
-0.25716233253479004,
0.0552687905728817,
-0.26626038551330566,
-0.6066579818725586,
-0.188412144780159,
-0.002500015078112483,
0.22071322798728943,
0.1711483895778656,
-0.8958593606948853,
-0.3268028795719147,
-0.7273507714271545,
0.33527469635009766,
0.6679046154022217,
-0.1758025735616684,
0.23782940208911896,
-0.10842955112457275,
0.39994123578071594,
0.15400992333889008,
0.03781343251466751,
-0.2078171819448471,
-0.49597224593162537,
-0.584203839302063,
-0.1799192577600479,
0.5764672756195068,
0.622488260269165,
-0.705802857875824,
0.5749967694282532,
0.02571682818233967,
-0.27066197991371155,
-1.1252361536026,
0.32729852199554443,
0.5500715970993042,
0.3670668601989746,
0.6132698655128479,
-0.4463646411895752,
-0.4335399866104126,
-0.9584947228431702,
-0.2266392707824707,
-0.29539474844932556,
-0.037914350628852844,
0.4499993920326233,
0.0621565505862236,
0.03818327188491821,
0.8660922646522522,
-0.30818819999694824,
-0.6602261662483215,
0.0866616889834404,
0.22735103964805603,
-0.14473891258239746,
0.5055431127548218,
0.5916203260421753,
-0.5082735419273376,
-0.6351311206817627,
-0.13588951528072357,
-0.7279925346374512,
-0.23114100098609924,
-0.027250047773122787,
0.05642169341444969,
0.1906222701072693,
0.7447277903556824,
0.0040173898451030254,
0.4425787329673767,
0.8799262046813965,
-0.029192110523581505,
0.43812549114227295,
-0.2830057144165039,
0.1031656414270401,
-0.9266471862792969,
-0.5181334018707275,
0.1257890909910202,
-0.3545153737068176,
-0.48712044954299927,
-0.1662745326757431,
-0.02085396833717823,
-0.18266698718070984,
-0.6049691438674927,
0.4060520827770233,
-0.7144225835800171,
-0.079685740172863,
-0.2946414649486542,
0.41481977701187134,
-0.08334982395172119,
0.4767039716243744,
0.36288273334503174,
0.8336411714553833,
0.8752766251564026,
-0.5719928741455078,
0.2178097665309906,
0.4376048743724823,
-0.1606106460094452,
0.4716792404651642,
-0.5959150195121765,
0.2186347246170044,
0.004174288362264633,
0.16428913176059723,
-0.9727514982223511,
0.25087952613830566,
-0.10161823034286499,
-0.43055474758148193,
0.6627466082572937,
0.09910949319601059,
-0.23900407552719116,
-0.22439271211624146,
-0.11531133204698563,
0.39437738060951233,
0.29819008708000183,
-1.0177658796310425,
0.7534509301185608,
0.7183578610420227,
-0.034100066870450974,
-0.41146090626716614,
-0.9587901830673218,
0.1410369873046875,
-0.08947819471359253,
-0.5779761672019958,
0.4245024621486664,
0.010034596547484398,
0.07392235845327377,
-0.13011698424816132,
-0.02424091100692749,
0.11359699815511703,
-0.2657664120197296,
0.08203047513961792,
-0.052078619599342346,
-0.3333743214607239,
0.17210856080055237,
0.09719295799732208,
-0.03416239470243454,
0.009250457398593426,
-0.23763376474380493,
0.40745848417282104,
0.03299384564161301,
-0.5892957448959351,
-0.6581544280052185,
0.6275176405906677,
0.12631870806217194,
-0.45914626121520996,
0.45416802167892456,
0.7426466941833496,
-0.40397000312805176,
-0.31254398822784424,
-0.9182302355766296,
-0.34965384006500244,
-0.5061666369438171,
0.17133760452270508,
-0.5754998326301575,
-1.0167847871780396,
0.5875656008720398,
-0.13113035261631012,
0.1418142169713974,
0.5002322793006897,
0.2771868407726288,
-0.2975456714630127,
0.9209317564964294,
0.5869006514549255,
-0.5919814705848694,
0.5878592133522034,
-0.3488319516181946,
0.019591407850384712,
-0.9986738562583923,
-0.09540078788995743,
-0.4991929233074188,
0.0845385491847992,
-0.6147111654281616,
-0.4413203001022339,
0.27050167322158813,
-0.09256108105182648,
0.33504408597946167,
0.656150758266449,
-0.1628616452217102,
0.18987540900707245,
0.3710775077342987,
-0.00608239509165287,
0.02434750273823738,
0.1845124065876007,
-0.6500417590141296,
-0.22282066941261292,
-0.9412772059440613,
-0.07819341123104095,
0.7395771741867065,
0.6671639680862427,
0.851495623588562,
-0.14879800379276276,
1.1434171199798584,
0.3910196125507355,
-0.0497797429561615,
-0.737213134765625,
0.2345912754535675,
-0.38738784193992615,
-0.3645970821380615,
-0.4549465775489807,
-0.3657734990119934,
-0.9686627388000488,
0.4222017824649811,
-0.35535046458244324,
-0.5120130181312561,
0.62445068359375,
0.12474159896373749,
-0.1036871150135994,
0.2117081880569458,
-0.3998415172100067,
0.5073408484458923,
-0.12790001928806305,
-0.2295387238264084,
-0.5266938805580139,
-0.3903309404850006,
-0.15938138961791992,
-0.09377922862768173,
0.4384027421474457,
0.026302779093384743,
0.23258085548877716,
0.8667011857032776,
-0.28139546513557434,
0.7653541564941406,
-0.2087724655866623,
-0.7404761910438538,
0.4310787320137024,
-0.016531629487872124,
0.6025005578994751,
-0.21086426079273224,
-0.19009502232074738,
0.6394076347351074,
-0.21207743883132935,
-0.192726269364357,
-0.5366835594177246,
0.7496050596237183,
-0.7913771271705627,
-0.5555010437965393,
-0.21048325300216675,
-0.28538990020751953,
-0.4992397427558899,
-0.21083056926727295,
0.22657491266727448,
0.773266613483429,
-0.4902815520763397,
0.05675129219889641,
0.4521070718765259,
-0.1959517002105713,
0.4769018888473511,
0.7632192373275757,
-0.06556590646505356,
-0.411360502243042,
0.8213834762573242,
0.3233107924461365,
0.20891845226287842,
0.45254597067832947,
0.28614574670791626,
-0.6732763051986694,
-0.4304164946079254,
-0.45252105593681335,
0.4654541015625,
-0.7722282409667969,
0.0025791109073907137,
-0.5270336270332336,
-0.2873079776763916,
-0.7144892811775208,
-0.19159764051437378,
-0.560049295425415,
-0.37238526344299316,
-0.3746359348297119,
-0.14192143082618713,
0.05634624883532524,
0.681282639503479,
-0.6115267872810364,
0.2583749294281006,
-0.6445326805114746,
0.3691369891166687,
0.492919921875,
0.15465131402015686,
-0.09995106607675552,
-0.845101535320282,
-0.5233585834503174,
0.2271007001399994,
-0.1296256184577942,
-0.9319632053375244,
0.3704708218574524,
0.6408959627151489,
0.8072624206542969,
0.4119691848754883,
-0.052908703684806824,
0.9113758206367493,
-0.6625739932060242,
0.6685813069343567,
0.2627268433570862,
-1.1610718965530396,
0.6087653040885925,
-0.31881240010261536,
0.1741008162498474,
0.5063921809196472,
0.3027687668800354,
-0.5363454222679138,
-0.8071804046630859,
-0.5946254730224609,
-0.6028956770896912,
0.34588319063186646,
0.3315717279911041,
0.250192791223526,
-0.2652026116847992,
0.255935937166214,
-0.061036039143800735,
-0.069078229367733,
-0.555387020111084,
-0.3972177505493164,
-0.3941744863986969,
-0.20994913578033447,
-0.08039422333240509,
-0.0065234643407166,
0.24490056931972504,
-0.22505870461463928,
0.9223101735115051,
-0.079920195043087,
0.2749030292034149,
0.5683892965316772,
-0.19227993488311768,
-0.19975656270980835,
0.027754195034503937,
0.2668018639087677,
0.16556105017662048,
0.09336768090724945,
-0.03640502318739891,
0.4825897812843323,
-0.32990941405296326,
0.003858359530568123,
0.05740439146757126,
0.16413480043411255,
0.34057459235191345,
0.5483306646347046,
0.8303633332252502,
0.5847148895263672,
-0.181054949760437,
0.5824347734451294,
0.013089239597320557,
-0.15086013078689575,
-0.41766589879989624,
0.08445654809474945,
0.13498835265636444,
-0.011263889260590076,
0.19248273968696594,
-0.36176785826683044,
0.4778771698474884,
-0.5456520915031433,
0.33794450759887695,
0.6798366904258728,
-0.5753123164176941,
-0.11899413913488388,
0.6179781556129456,
0.29492929577827454,
-0.1601262390613556,
0.5379060506820679,
0.2480802834033966,
-0.44560572504997253,
0.36513811349868774,
0.9324233531951904,
0.8622811436653137,
-1.0082123279571533,
-0.07943661510944366,
0.44477158784866333,
0.28924793004989624,
0.15685953199863434,
0.2698405385017395,
-0.3156939148902893,
-0.7070871591567993,
-0.4056535065174103,
-0.6844643950462341,
-0.33469700813293457,
-0.12473876029253006,
-0.8321014642715454,
0.14590448141098022,
-0.06001269072294235,
-0.14092838764190674,
-0.14696434140205383,
-0.23375675082206726,
-0.848301351070404,
0.16614693403244019,
0.47041481733322144,
0.78484708070755,
-1.0184760093688965,
1.028307557106018,
0.3572854697704315,
-0.04833921045064926,
-1.1800044775009155,
-0.1839638650417328,
-0.12182499468326569,
-0.9511311650276184,
0.5123476982116699,
0.07646942138671875,
-0.5674850344657898,
0.13911648094654083,
-0.20205393433570862,
-1.0133581161499023,
0.8735665678977966,
0.3663957118988037,
-0.9691942930221558,
0.17936956882476807,
0.5371612310409546,
0.5730204582214355,
-0.6647773385047913,
0.050927430391311646,
0.2868170738220215,
0.38261377811431885,
-0.1669488102197647,
-1.3524236679077148,
-0.3911210000514984,
-0.03057745285332203,
0.09055826812982559,
-0.0012406952446326613,
-0.478721559047699,
0.381706565618515,
0.02012566849589348,
-0.29245561361312866,
-0.13890303671360016,
1.1736806631088257,
0.10120204836130142,
-0.015985889360308647,
0.7581618428230286,
0.673396110534668,
0.6123008131980896,
-0.0066598583944141865,
0.7868658304214478,
-0.523309051990509,
0.17519450187683105,
1.148200511932373,
-0.11932943761348724,
1.1418627500534058,
0.2537212371826172,
-0.17815625667572021,
0.6765086650848389,
0.4321014881134033,
-0.0968402847647667,
0.6306830644607544,
0.19028407335281372,
-0.21562600135803223,
-0.34194299578666687,
-0.31754857301712036,
-0.5750967264175415,
0.9486364722251892,
0.4816841781139374,
-0.46945783495903015,
-0.07090391218662262,
0.342062771320343,
-0.3715616762638092,
0.20618459582328796,
-0.25115278363227844,
1.0313624143600464,
0.5885907411575317,
-0.20299676060676575,
0.6948227882385254,
-0.09972972422838211,
0.7841890454292297,
-0.7554662823677063,
-0.143772155046463,
-0.01839706487953663,
-0.22811152040958405,
-0.11479102075099945,
-0.40761303901672363,
0.11448314785957336,
-0.37168458104133606,
0.14148786664009094,
-0.060930561274290085,
0.6569944024085999,
-1.018980860710144,
-0.432415246963501,
0.9104411602020264,
0.487231969833374,
0.20811884105205536,
0.23391543328762054,
-0.7957703471183777,
0.00018291349988430738,
-0.09824211150407791,
0.08227626234292984,
0.20668253302574158,
0.3130266070365906,
0.2841308116912842,
0.48441213369369507,
0.6239097118377686,
0.28342920541763306,
0.21718080341815948,
0.42473283410072327,
0.550603449344635,
-0.41887086629867554,
-1.0077407360076904,
-0.59391188621521,
0.051178328692913055,
0.3017348349094391,
0.007523101754486561,
0.9861091375350952,
0.6875454187393188,
0.8693740367889404,
-0.23467783629894257,
0.6376476883888245,
0.5289292335510254,
0.4645364284515381,
-0.7528663277626038,
0.5562681555747986,
-0.5392564535140991,
0.11681131273508072,
-0.45123520493507385,
-0.8441586494445801,
0.029534704983234406,
1.0778645277023315,
-0.031481917947530746,
0.041815392673015594,
0.5673934817314148,
0.7211312055587769,
-0.16244344413280487,
0.2515183389186859,
0.5916684865951538,
0.13091959059238434,
0.19679152965545654,
0.376959890127182,
0.6591896414756775,
-0.5809855461120605,
0.26520395278930664,
-0.4347679018974304,
-0.15673258900642395,
0.10678666830062866,
-0.6795323491096497,
-0.8723738193511963,
-0.7663258910179138,
-0.5545173287391663,
-0.11466249078512192,
0.23788881301879883,
0.9560367465019226,
0.867084264755249,
-0.8640480637550354,
-0.5167186856269836,
0.1311160773038864,
-0.3049732744693756,
-0.25655224919319153,
-0.17328491806983948,
0.6901422142982483,
-0.35460031032562256,
-0.6141814589500427,
1.0103731155395508,
0.28200581669807434,
0.33657145500183105,
-0.5191577076911926,
-0.2106441706418991,
-0.15355747938156128,
0.2840389907360077,
0.6635198593139648,
0.31803226470947266,
-0.7664541006088257,
-0.31127485632896423,
-0.19488239288330078,
0.010673407465219498,
0.2502402067184448,
0.6482036113739014,
-0.803392767906189,
0.5689992308616638,
0.21536695957183838,
0.5343486070632935,
0.3357696831226349,
-0.1611856371164322,
0.7724774479866028,
-0.819055438041687,
0.106120765209198,
0.0320751927793026,
0.7956350445747375,
0.5752855539321899,
-0.389413446187973,
0.2987581193447113,
0.06445103138685226,
-0.42217040061950684,
-0.3817324936389923,
0.11627320200204849,
-0.7822644710540771,
-0.18478171527385712,
1.1533026695251465,
-0.25116443634033203,
-0.1263318955898285,
-0.4679219424724579,
-0.1124863401055336,
0.4644913971424103,
-0.4302208423614502,
0.7900946140289307,
0.6903270483016968,
-0.048565905541181564,
0.03141451254487038,
-0.2785945236682892,
0.5044050812721252,
0.6113705635070801,
-0.42694351077079773,
0.05661877244710922,
0.29074445366859436,
0.17155490815639496,
0.3395024836063385,
0.47130057215690613,
-0.3021046221256256,
0.1181488037109375,
-0.08654104173183441,
0.007187580224126577,
-0.06933477520942688,
-0.32110416889190674,
-0.37043967843055725,
-0.04436087980866432,
0.04791860654950142,
-0.24451370537281036
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08737v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08737v1
|
ILCiteR: Evidence-grounded Interpretable Local Citation Recommendation
| 2024-03-13T17:38:05 | 2024-03-13T17:38:05 |
Sayar Ghosh Roy, Jiawei Han
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
Existing Machine Learning approaches for local citation recommendation
directly map or translate a query, which is typically a claim or an entity
mention, to citation-worthy research papers. Within such a formulation, it is
challenging to pinpoint why one should cite a specific research paper for a
particular query, leading to limited recommendation interpretability. To
alleviate this, we introduce the evidence-grounded local citation
recommendation task, where the target latent space comprises evidence spans for
recommending specific papers. Using a distantly-supervised evidence retrieval
and multi-step re-ranking framework, our proposed system, ILCiteR, recommends
papers to cite for a query grounded on similar evidence spans extracted from
the existing research literature. Unlike past formulations that simply output
recommendations, ILCiteR retrieves ranked lists of evidence span and
recommended paper pairs. Secondly, previously proposed neural models for
citation recommendation require expensive training on massive labeled data,
ideally after every significant update to the pool of candidate papers. In
contrast, ILCiteR relies solely on distant supervision from a dynamic evidence
database and pre-trained Transformer-based Language Models without any model
training. We contribute a novel dataset for the evidence-grounded local
citation recommendation task and demonstrate the efficacy of our proposed
conditional neural rank-ensembling approach for re-ranking evidence spans.
|
[
-0.046876829117536545,
-0.4372203052043915,
0.7224975824356079,
0.09459076076745987,
-0.13680526614189148,
-0.1274193972349167,
-0.018554801121354103,
-0.48502013087272644,
0.4707548916339874,
0.4316156506538391,
-0.044388797134160995,
-0.2591334283351898,
-0.6655590534210205,
0.007899974472820759,
-0.3160954415798187,
1.1683992147445679,
-0.08876088261604309,
0.3234463632106781,
-0.5649287104606628,
-0.21131010353565216,
-0.3060592710971832,
-0.3878600597381592,
-0.5891370177268982,
-0.5478987097740173,
1.0687066316604614,
0.30385085940361023,
0.40186330676078796,
0.23564451932907104,
0.5518038272857666,
0.1352471560239792,
-0.1375422328710556,
0.14244841039180756,
-0.2808053493499756,
0.18188253045082092,
-0.40967074036598206,
-0.49217307567596436,
-0.3069588840007782,
0.0030662778299301863,
0.383030503988266,
0.8135362267494202,
0.0960250198841095,
-0.013696965761482716,
-0.0007249780464917421,
0.5253119468688965,
-0.7473071217536926,
-0.07432838529348373,
-0.8199788928031921,
0.060446128249168396,
-0.2363467663526535,
-0.2603389024734497,
-0.5099075436592102,
-0.768609344959259,
0.12771889567375183,
-0.375761479139328,
0.2819640040397644,
0.1744440197944641,
0.6738698482513428,
0.13523565232753754,
-0.5647802948951721,
-0.06598421186208725,
-0.4596427083015442,
0.5073142051696777,
-0.5081508159637451,
0.10680167376995087,
0.6715003252029419,
0.20070098340511322,
-0.01218660268932581,
-0.9705708622932434,
-0.053084392100572586,
-0.2997819185256958,
-0.5417612195014954,
0.06879671663045883,
-0.13509269058704376,
-0.13740602135658264,
0.08690457791090012,
0.2818480432033539,
-0.40714409947395325,
-0.336965948343277,
-0.3551521301269531,
-0.11079461872577667,
0.22808991372585297,
-0.2297571450471878,
-0.09240397065877914,
-0.08161342889070511,
-0.3019365072250366,
0.25385406613349915,
-0.8167877793312073,
-0.01493426039814949,
0.2146170288324356,
0.4956599175930023,
0.36594143509864807,
0.5089448094367981,
-0.2831343114376068,
0.6494864821434021,
0.5058789849281311,
0.23514819145202637,
0.11449597030878067,
-0.20397570729255676,
-0.019447438418865204,
0.43734291195869446,
0.49355068802833557,
0.09635554999113083,
-0.25921308994293213,
-0.5876278281211853,
-0.03728734701871872,
-0.4124595522880554,
0.3789884150028229,
-1.0479960441589355,
-0.19396395981311798,
0.0033126925118267536,
-0.7674959897994995,
-0.28154081106185913,
0.024114668369293213,
-0.4226571321487427,
-0.5483514666557312,
-0.3949967324733734,
0.5137496590614319,
-0.38771262764930725,
-0.3307112753391266,
-0.19809386134147644,
0.0017706789076328278,
-0.18146367371082306,
0.3437046408653259,
-0.6954821944236755,
0.06765108555555344,
0.39069515466690063,
0.9986218810081482,
-0.15042848885059357,
-0.2418946474790573,
-0.5963228940963745,
-0.05486001446843147,
-0.03777946159243584,
1.1068869829177856,
-0.9018039703369141,
-0.16039986908435822,
0.16205866634845734,
0.26050615310668945,
-0.34572693705558777,
-0.6532890200614929,
1.0575244426727295,
-0.6257479190826416,
0.24706631898880005,
-0.32846108078956604,
-0.6093251705169678,
-0.0832008421421051,
0.23982137441635132,
-0.41041678190231323,
0.830129861831665,
-0.08823366463184357,
-1.1292229890823364,
0.7483260631561279,
-0.6657484173774719,
-0.5294855833053589,
-0.10319307446479797,
-0.05813112109899521,
-0.2285640686750412,
0.17577695846557617,
0.28212276101112366,
0.25695016980171204,
-0.16044673323631287,
0.7931394577026367,
-0.41696617007255554,
-0.4264783263206482,
-0.3395273983478546,
-0.22852495312690735,
0.6448955535888672,
0.5582139492034912,
-0.3718721866607666,
0.35080891847610474,
-0.8376356363296509,
-0.035606272518634796,
-0.2039531022310257,
-0.2767358422279358,
-0.7190395593643188,
0.2741428017616272,
0.09379281103610992,
-0.0680449828505516,
0.20308475196361542,
-0.48085322976112366,
0.3584633469581604,
-0.2582431137561798,
0.24942824244499207,
0.2802821397781372,
0.07317359000444412,
0.599465012550354,
-0.4074544906616211,
0.3816114366054535,
-0.18880170583724976,
-0.3583247661590576,
-0.3158826231956482,
-0.3239315450191498,
-0.6648926138877869,
-0.30367791652679443,
0.37269484996795654,
0.20073950290679932,
-0.4702121615409851,
0.4514760375022888,
-0.5715113878250122,
-0.36857104301452637,
-0.31627362966537476,
-0.19456875324249268,
-0.009057627059519291,
0.5426865816116333,
0.607343316078186,
0.21161092817783356,
-0.6639208793640137,
-0.9097035527229309,
-0.5591918230056763,
-0.09096914529800415,
-0.13632969558238983,
0.25849899649620056,
0.537157416343689,
-0.009935177862644196,
1.1832739114761353,
-0.1699291318655014,
-0.4387173056602478,
0.17216043174266815,
0.5625603795051575,
0.5705183148384094,
0.5800655484199524,
0.37031781673431396,
-0.7179928421974182,
-0.36181169748306274,
-0.04064404219388962,
-0.9226998686790466,
-0.07745026797056198,
-0.2888032793998718,
-0.2183886617422104,
-0.4218931794166565,
0.7062677145004272,
-0.39728081226348877,
0.4792807400226593,
0.07798779010772705,
-0.5714030265808105,
0.08444076776504517,
-0.2374134063720703,
0.22308380901813507,
-0.9455723166465759,
0.2835778295993805,
-0.26496922969818115,
-0.11126109957695007,
-0.11081323027610779,
-0.13285480439662933,
0.038584645837545395,
-0.0529235303401947,
0.04255284368991852,
0.5815930962562561,
-0.41612982749938965,
0.10006407648324966,
-0.45712244510650635,
-0.26752719283103943,
0.11178438365459442,
0.04685046151280403,
0.2862018346786499,
0.5290321707725525,
0.2902394235134125,
-0.08637001365423203,
-0.2022116631269455,
0.1634700894355774,
-0.4667115807533264,
0.8335577249526978,
-0.6731786131858826,
0.06665574759244919,
-0.03941509872674942,
0.44597649574279785,
-0.6275253295898438,
0.03496174141764641,
-0.04896172881126404,
-0.08217845857143402,
0.31420254707336426,
-0.7477013468742371,
-0.2371310591697693,
0.16507916152477264,
0.054804444313049316,
0.5786275863647461,
-0.005542457103729248,
-0.9138981103897095,
0.7485116720199585,
0.024373600259423256,
-0.1541157215833664,
-0.5432897210121155,
-0.3753501772880554,
0.21936196088790894,
-0.3860970139503479,
-0.5941624641418457,
0.8109278678894043,
0.127767413854599,
-0.3009776175022125,
0.32937899231910706,
-0.12373042106628418,
-0.033212851732969284,
0.004167749080806971,
0.6572945713996887,
-0.1468481868505478,
-0.38892897963523865,
0.1995873898267746,
0.08396445214748383,
0.053043823689222336,
0.20607642829418182,
-0.4562080204486847,
0.0714392215013504,
-0.12929944694042206,
-0.40190961956977844,
0.00776006979867816,
0.4714829921722412,
0.6142837405204773,
-0.025272320955991745,
0.7284931540489197,
0.679004430770874,
-0.40523889660835266,
0.29274818301200867,
-0.5482454895973206,
-0.17705164849758148,
-0.3447814881801605,
0.076268270611763,
-0.37005433440208435,
-0.7310776114463806,
0.26026415824890137,
-0.25110194087028503,
-0.018400372937321663,
0.4092368185520172,
0.49502843618392944,
-0.05028465390205383,
0.6507394909858704,
0.34166786074638367,
-0.28356650471687317,
0.6186046004295349,
-0.09245902299880981,
0.28724053502082825,
-0.6947904825210571,
-0.37708523869514465,
-0.8023961186408997,
-0.30181488394737244,
-0.20849603414535522,
-0.2831973433494568,
0.10837798565626144,
0.3266003727912903,
-0.4588683545589447,
0.05640145763754845,
-0.6371167302131653,
0.4229865074157715,
0.6231845021247864,
0.049828533083200455,
0.29461774230003357,
0.41252294182777405,
-0.48490849137306213,
-0.18709754943847656,
-0.5616372227668762,
-0.4043092727661133,
0.8490039706230164,
-0.0376463308930397,
0.7607003450393677,
-0.15535572171211243,
0.8198031187057495,
0.6022075414657593,
0.6796233057975769,
-0.5412044525146484,
0.07778581976890564,
0.288167804479599,
-0.9052435755729675,
0.19608165323734283,
-0.12506452202796936,
-1.2332351207733154,
0.4699060916900635,
-0.3890003561973572,
-0.7884933948516846,
0.5724299550056458,
-0.2553209066390991,
-0.10617194324731827,
0.3612152338027954,
-0.5455122590065002,
0.71393883228302,
-0.29155057668685913,
-0.7737686634063721,
-0.18690623342990875,
-0.4241408407688141,
0.17672516405582428,
0.07153722643852234,
0.11804983019828796,
0.05347185209393501,
0.44700944423675537,
0.7134851217269897,
-0.37783727049827576,
0.6868008375167847,
-0.6470324397087097,
0.24396218359470367,
0.12270089983940125,
0.011465289629995823,
0.7474696040153503,
0.36434945464134216,
-0.5055531859397888,
0.15386585891246796,
-0.13823802769184113,
-0.34026846289634705,
-0.49234622716903687,
1.05752432346344,
-0.49105823040008545,
-0.5876270532608032,
-0.7937681078910828,
-0.4988863468170166,
-0.18459491431713104,
0.37253355979919434,
0.3272130489349365,
0.188479483127594,
-0.079051673412323,
0.5870147347450256,
0.29546236991882324,
0.03951827809214592,
0.17733846604824066,
0.28185513615608215,
-0.14778368175029755,
-0.8009328842163086,
0.7920689582824707,
-0.03848990425467491,
-0.4927804172039032,
0.6091575026512146,
-0.07778435945510864,
-0.2990889847278595,
-0.8955585360527039,
-0.08760011196136475,
0.05066922307014465,
-0.7267144918441772,
-0.25531572103500366,
-0.7155656218528748,
0.05029648542404175,
-0.2760534882545471,
-0.24366344511508942,
-0.32170844078063965,
-0.44480088353157043,
-0.256966233253479,
-0.04787862300872803,
0.2908014953136444,
0.5131068229675293,
-0.06425812095403671,
-0.04568766802549362,
-0.31776660680770874,
0.08011635392904282,
-0.021102478727698326,
0.4171737730503082,
-0.12281829863786697,
-0.6286237239837646,
-0.4555850028991699,
-0.12447253614664078,
-0.0650077685713768,
-0.4768401086330414,
0.30218684673309326,
0.12223940342664719,
0.707865834236145,
0.6284988522529602,
0.3071390688419342,
0.8417759537696838,
-0.6450142860412598,
0.4700152575969696,
0.01222984679043293,
-0.3892788589000702,
0.7529208660125732,
-0.5137578845024109,
0.022744590416550636,
0.9428189992904663,
0.6787206530570984,
0.09908527880907059,
-0.10991306602954865,
-0.48036396503448486,
-1.1201530694961548,
0.47425031661987305,
0.28153738379478455,
-0.0872010588645935,
0.04871406406164169,
0.6000970602035522,
0.1516050100326538,
-0.05368248373270035,
-0.8420830368995667,
-0.20974262058734894,
-0.4318802058696747,
-0.0697891116142273,
0.033074937760829926,
-0.25516241788864136,
-0.3439493477344513,
-0.3628826141357422,
0.5968668460845947,
-0.2730337679386139,
0.5114926695823669,
0.571387529373169,
-0.20392294228076935,
-0.04493793845176697,
0.23713195323944092,
0.46937280893325806,
0.7898204922676086,
-0.7628756761550903,
0.29755309224128723,
-0.073057159781456,
-0.1714814305305481,
0.07365347445011139,
0.5119080543518066,
-0.5702024102210999,
0.2436951845884323,
0.3099331259727478,
0.5238427519798279,
0.3202330470085144,
-0.1827400177717209,
0.2391539067029953,
-0.18504181504249573,
-0.2443324476480484,
-0.5792890787124634,
-0.3125412166118622,
0.18281656503677368,
0.2719389796257019,
0.7407591342926025,
0.5679080486297607,
0.22791141271591187,
-0.2973877787590027,
0.14915424585342407,
0.38113418221473694,
-0.7024754881858826,
-0.20590823888778687,
0.8500983119010925,
0.0845300704240799,
-0.08290109783411026,
0.4460272192955017,
0.11362244933843613,
-0.1374581903219223,
0.2698696255683899,
0.5954838991165161,
0.7677860856056213,
0.4078054130077362,
-0.033701635897159576,
0.6663233637809753,
0.1353331059217453,
-0.11829043924808502,
-0.09935938566923141,
-0.32691124081611633,
-0.517012357711792,
-0.2976420819759369,
-0.6137422323226929,
-0.30956119298934937,
0.15345977246761322,
-0.9054373502731323,
0.06277712434530258,
-0.2977454662322998,
-0.24053606390953064,
0.12174060195684433,
-0.11024800688028336,
-0.33504852652549744,
0.08507984131574631,
-0.06980948150157928,
0.8877575993537903,
-0.6093011498451233,
1.0473711490631104,
0.8468614220619202,
-0.5854702591896057,
-0.41778624057769775,
-0.009909103624522686,
-0.26307597756385803,
-0.26748237013816833,
1.0127992630004883,
0.11134606599807739,
-0.23640023171901703,
-0.3496588468551636,
-0.42607876658439636,
-0.9869982600212097,
1.0555245876312256,
0.5584080815315247,
-0.1241341233253479,
0.12495215237140656,
-0.5130399465560913,
0.39124447107315063,
-0.6614029407501221,
0.772001326084137,
-0.023265838623046875,
0.4334777593612671,
0.12226758897304535,
-0.4191787540912628,
0.2768845856189728,
-0.5948192477226257,
-0.2656691372394562,
0.025303484871983528,
-0.36936041712760925,
0.618572473526001,
-0.1890878677368164,
0.19528184831142426,
0.24097749590873718,
0.8789370656013489,
0.2849026918411255,
0.7043649554252625,
0.44637352228164673,
0.4054371416568756,
0.8597136735916138,
-0.07398167997598648,
0.9475278854370117,
-0.24723787605762482,
0.17966969311237335,
1.4812779426574707,
-0.5524901747703552,
0.976433515548706,
0.712737500667572,
-0.12107248604297638,
0.9139509797096252,
0.6882094144821167,
-0.18737870454788208,
0.8142367601394653,
0.009187394753098488,
-0.29298076033592224,
-0.3314974308013916,
-0.4937204122543335,
-0.6758249998092651,
0.16566357016563416,
0.042594533413648605,
-0.7356752157211304,
-0.2908780574798584,
-0.17191296815872192,
0.061859384179115295,
0.04844134673476219,
-0.01786494068801403,
0.361426442861557,
-0.032957524061203,
-1.0058743953704834,
0.6199657917022705,
-0.21101334691047668,
0.7619812488555908,
-0.5464200377464294,
-0.1752213090658188,
-0.5876468420028687,
0.2861759066581726,
-0.49916619062423706,
-0.025532249361276627,
0.27126893401145935,
0.05510740354657173,
-0.6475536227226257,
-0.4104025065898895,
0.808229923248291,
-0.04867073893547058,
-0.588364839553833,
0.2414291501045227,
0.38410884141921997,
0.14376913011074066,
-0.1690087765455246,
-0.4954659640789032,
-0.5014629364013672,
-0.04994839429855347,
-0.25109824538230896,
0.7421701550483704,
0.5015441179275513,
0.007241062819957733,
0.5364625453948975,
0.905890703201294,
0.13967202603816986,
-0.17006944119930267,
0.16970489919185638,
0.8154597282409668,
-0.6977319717407227,
-0.22230373322963715,
-0.44258826971054077,
0.24611619114875793,
-0.23387141525745392,
-0.10416242480278015,
0.8189622163772583,
0.7313429117202759,
0.5313059091567993,
0.17868700623512268,
0.6651082038879395,
-0.2851090431213379,
0.48651251196861267,
-0.3789858818054199,
0.7953801155090332,
-0.6268904209136963,
0.4716915786266327,
-0.018027326092123985,
-0.7106137871742249,
-0.44285017251968384,
0.9961965084075928,
-0.6292890906333923,
0.1652916967868805,
0.8393619656562805,
0.6680445671081543,
-0.13493874669075012,
0.11934154480695724,
0.08380913734436035,
0.15840129554271698,
0.16160883009433746,
0.22549059987068176,
1.013954758644104,
-0.3510405719280243,
0.6331760883331299,
0.018914952874183655,
0.22650213539600372,
-0.3099448084831238,
-1.1679883003234863,
-0.8517221212387085,
-0.3485836684703827,
-0.431901216506958,
-0.5329353213310242,
0.15058594942092896,
0.8663315773010254,
0.9771236777305603,
-1.0356247425079346,
0.12544837594032288,
-0.27095842361450195,
0.238502636551857,
-0.2227693498134613,
-0.2857070565223694,
0.6507106423377991,
-0.42377227544784546,
-0.5372923612594604,
0.8169119358062744,
0.0479263961315155,
-0.4730580747127533,
0.18201862275600433,
-0.07576793432235718,
-0.6220060586929321,
-0.4370403587818146,
0.28641578555107117,
0.24248714745044708,
-0.7684393525123596,
-0.1304922252893448,
-0.00884634256362915,
0.016709694638848305,
0.20553788542747498,
1.2198405265808105,
-1.240604281425476,
0.48302048444747925,
0.43888482451438904,
0.5945223569869995,
0.9114320278167725,
-0.11334501951932907,
0.4654861390590668,
-0.4118809998035431,
0.14558041095733643,
0.30738237500190735,
0.8322885036468506,
0.21048972010612488,
-0.3353080153465271,
0.7852086424827576,
0.10613033175468445,
-0.7871901988983154,
-0.8224402070045471,
-0.24107106029987335,
-0.817486047744751,
-0.20323804020881653,
0.9813422560691833,
-0.6785523295402527,
0.2432411164045334,
-0.356198787689209,
-0.1617116928100586,
-0.004321026615798473,
-0.4821377694606781,
0.7978804707527161,
0.44789889454841614,
-0.08785298466682434,
-0.0467643104493618,
-0.21283306181430817,
0.18849237263202667,
0.5767136216163635,
-0.5643388628959656,
-0.04370381683111191,
0.4810592532157898,
0.39735090732574463,
0.4111435115337372,
0.44908085465431213,
-0.07110622525215149,
0.06346848607063293,
0.23834486305713654,
-0.03360798582434654,
-0.17302006483078003,
-0.18964116275310516,
-0.3396943509578705,
0.5347163677215576,
0.25586655735969543,
0.2095334678888321
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08730v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08730v2
|
Strengthening Multimodal Large Language Model with Bootstrapped Preference Optimization
| 2024-03-13T17:29:45 | 2024-04-03T15:22:23 |
Renjie Pi, Tianyang Han, Wei Xiong, Jipeng Zhang, Runtao Liu, Rui Pan, Tong Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs) excel in generating responses based
on visual inputs. However, they often suffer from a bias towards generating
responses similar to their pretraining corpus, overshadowing the importance of
visual information. We treat this bias as a "preference" for pretraining
statistics, which hinders the model's grounding in visual input. To mitigate
this issue, we propose Bootstrapped Preference Optimization (BPO), which
conducts preference learning with datasets containing negative responses
bootstrapped from the model itself. Specifically, we propose the following two
strategies: 1) using distorted image inputs to the MLLM for eliciting responses
that contain signified pretraining bias; 2) leveraging text-based LLM to
explicitly inject erroneous but common elements into the original response.
Those undesirable responses are paired with original annotated responses from
the datasets to construct the preference dataset, which is subsequently
utilized to perform preference learning. Our approach effectively suppresses
pretrained LLM bias, enabling enhanced grounding in visual inputs. Extensive
experimentation demonstrates significant performance improvements across
multiple benchmarks, advancing the state-of-the-art in multimodal
conversational systems.
|
[
-0.5945349931716919,
-0.6282122731208801,
0.5180578231811523,
0.2668730318546295,
-0.4629146158695221,
-0.09023870527744293,
-0.5606721043586731,
-0.25098106265068054,
0.3512793183326721,
0.5264403820037842,
-0.595037579536438,
-0.27646782994270325,
-0.6184579133987427,
-0.15345671772956848,
0.09764230996370316,
1.084211826324463,
0.13888098299503326,
0.4663180708885193,
-0.4146246910095215,
-0.12816764414310455,
-0.41126468777656555,
-0.663653552532196,
-0.5426036715507507,
-0.4849313497543335,
0.7325222492218018,
0.494450181722641,
0.6229322552680969,
0.3598974347114563,
0.21476499736309052,
0.2864078879356384,
0.3281533420085907,
0.2695378363132477,
-0.6019322872161865,
0.3045913577079773,
0.1829376369714737,
-0.3548879325389862,
-0.36720210313796997,
-0.0841061994433403,
0.5114178657531738,
0.5865506529808044,
0.1243724599480629,
0.15402129292488098,
-0.0004536361084319651,
0.7514410018920898,
-0.8807117342948914,
0.31214439868927,
-0.8849515914916992,
0.028210211545228958,
-0.004360312595963478,
-0.593825101852417,
-0.6364973187446594,
-0.1555761694908142,
0.16798144578933716,
-0.46708834171295166,
0.023912644013762474,
0.10972729325294495,
0.792310357093811,
0.20432385802268982,
-0.3012603521347046,
0.14445562660694122,
-0.49611178040504456,
1.0237194299697876,
-0.5413124561309814,
0.4831998944282532,
0.6365264058113098,
0.08900126814842224,
0.012414529919624329,
-0.09379629790782928,
-0.43665653467178345,
-0.4198754131793976,
0.01707272417843342,
0.02814408950507641,
0.14981769025325775,
0.20104630291461945,
0.11047052592039108,
-0.0015366582665592432,
-0.488932728767395,
0.25083452463150024,
-0.2020237147808075,
-0.33432719111442566,
0.328637957572937,
-0.1722979098558426,
-0.016909653320908546,
-0.05094379186630249,
-0.3847166895866394,
-0.33958619832992554,
-0.6568619608879089,
0.09728850424289703,
0.3956769108772278,
0.4630131721496582,
-0.011623640544712543,
0.6897473931312561,
-0.09376142919063568,
0.7763592004776001,
0.16605450212955475,
-0.30852043628692627,
0.7508854866027832,
-0.04828032851219177,
-0.36375191807746887,
0.003554773051291704,
0.705693244934082,
0.8109714388847351,
0.4712906777858734,
-0.07785296440124512,
-0.3859077990055084,
0.11785586923360825,
0.27607461810112,
-0.950887143611908,
0.013878888450562954,
0.42786675691604614,
-0.41785839200019836,
-0.4590241312980652,
-0.22655490040779114,
-0.815222442150116,
-0.5359706282615662,
-0.5994223952293396,
0.3351267874240875,
-0.44001829624176025,
-0.17459405958652496,
0.031112616881728172,
0.07493739575147629,
-0.08277155458927155,
0.4051527678966522,
-1.1997034549713135,
-0.08620411157608032,
0.21971292793750763,
0.6433555483818054,
-0.07071185857057571,
-0.22832167148590088,
-0.8214868307113647,
0.06794015318155289,
-0.2936457395553589,
0.6980513334274292,
-0.7070052623748779,
-0.13366465270519257,
0.09605839848518372,
0.09235340356826782,
0.27262645959854126,
-0.5785691738128662,
0.3021973967552185,
-0.6870567798614502,
0.1277029812335968,
-0.23597946763038635,
-0.15303657948970795,
0.07043305039405823,
0.5256161689758301,
-0.5459536910057068,
0.8640927672386169,
-0.11440248787403107,
-0.6447989344596863,
0.7767835855484009,
-0.5780652165412903,
-0.35940054059028625,
-0.21132299304008484,
-0.31265535950660706,
-0.5538566708564758,
0.002206217497587204,
0.4386991858482361,
0.7888883948326111,
-0.1720162332057953,
0.4365237355232239,
-0.6640796661376953,
-0.014860516414046288,
0.16202843189239502,
-0.3892677426338196,
0.3488677740097046,
0.16372662782669067,
-0.2750733196735382,
0.637890100479126,
-0.9888615608215332,
0.1424044519662857,
0.14841130375862122,
-0.4320652186870575,
-0.4203264117240906,
0.1004982739686966,
0.4436413645744324,
0.29145678877830505,
0.12603433430194855,
-0.46859243512153625,
0.012955522164702415,
-0.33208349347114563,
0.2675122618675232,
1.1993571519851685,
-0.2853181064128876,
0.5296810865402222,
-0.14707966148853302,
0.2985304296016693,
0.30473268032073975,
0.09459958225488663,
-0.36262014508247375,
-0.03753044828772545,
-0.955374002456665,
-0.4331607520580292,
0.024433933198451996,
0.11587512493133545,
-0.909634530544281,
0.36602213978767395,
-0.22866348922252655,
-0.2440493255853653,
-0.46623316407203674,
0.24716030061244965,
0.3788761794567108,
0.5742896795272827,
0.586300253868103,
-0.39780735969543457,
-0.6166554093360901,
-1.2736643552780151,
0.06926748156547546,
-0.1082099974155426,
-0.001184043358080089,
0.41254866123199463,
0.14061875641345978,
-0.2666183114051819,
0.8186159729957581,
-0.486919641494751,
-0.1398327797651291,
-0.24584373831748962,
0.027000902220606804,
-0.06880391389131546,
0.470397025346756,
0.7319971919059753,
-0.9343979954719543,
-0.35076674818992615,
-0.11904610693454742,
-0.43972060084342957,
0.010149977169930935,
-0.11911213397979736,
-0.21930530667304993,
0.2917139232158661,
0.20101851224899292,
-0.4461432695388794,
0.05953991413116455,
0.6123102903366089,
-0.05381719768047333,
0.5984057188034058,
-0.061899349093437195,
0.21689626574516296,
-1.054194688796997,
0.005959650967270136,
0.2207217812538147,
-0.4388776123523712,
-0.5118803977966309,
-0.13988995552062988,
0.18071971833705902,
-0.07379040867090225,
-0.4122358560562134,
0.3717409372329712,
-0.46355947852134705,
0.13405323028564453,
-0.2678431272506714,
-0.11365058273077011,
-0.015711693093180656,
0.608291745185852,
0.36036866903305054,
0.7600501179695129,
0.6591777801513672,
-0.5644275546073914,
0.39412710070610046,
0.03485000506043434,
-0.23707562685012817,
0.42746007442474365,
-0.5292091369628906,
0.13520677387714386,
-0.5325837135314941,
0.16318988800048828,
-1.0806884765625,
-0.34558215737342834,
0.14377368986606598,
-0.3038397431373596,
0.5419159531593323,
-0.1991511434316635,
-0.4110174775123596,
-0.15054722130298615,
-0.6043335199356079,
0.4556054472923279,
0.25173720717430115,
-0.6147205233573914,
0.43816110491752625,
0.35925692319869995,
-0.05676696449518204,
-0.9987810254096985,
-0.45106807351112366,
-0.08849086612462997,
-0.20425154268741608,
-0.4823487102985382,
0.07757610082626343,
-0.14477680623531342,
-0.028105175122618675,
-0.475162535905838,
0.08875627815723419,
0.12289562076330185,
-0.15749399363994598,
0.22229234874248505,
0.5716261267662048,
-0.16217947006225586,
0.41247543692588806,
-0.2201775759458542,
-0.17583605647087097,
-0.039434198290109634,
-0.31382039189338684,
1.103593111038208,
-0.0508255735039711,
-0.2925952076911926,
-0.1536436378955841,
0.14432670176029205,
0.9039300680160522,
-0.39514532685279846,
0.7974790334701538,
0.7175493836402893,
0.0032884276006370783,
-0.01169223990291357,
-0.8100733757019043,
-0.41464734077453613,
-0.47885313630104065,
0.6673016548156738,
-0.25160834193229675,
-0.8068673014640808,
0.03897043690085411,
-0.01401909813284874,
-0.06446856260299683,
-0.1080830916762352,
0.8816710114479065,
-0.09365937858819962,
0.8133083581924438,
0.6051279306411743,
-0.33323490619659424,
0.7582353353500366,
0.011072647757828236,
0.027768218889832497,
-0.618323564529419,
-0.28115546703338623,
-0.23485514521598816,
-0.3203698992729187,
-0.47035619616508484,
-0.4001874327659607,
0.388410359621048,
-0.36021462082862854,
-0.242051899433136,
-0.04592585563659668,
-0.21711847186088562,
0.3721873462200165,
0.7249219417572021,
0.35993292927742004,
0.051175374537706375,
0.33539003133773804,
-0.18058350682258606,
-0.22770191729068756,
-0.5055743455886841,
-0.49860185384750366,
1.388426423072815,
0.32863426208496094,
0.9914754033088684,
-0.22112376987934113,
0.4686354100704193,
-0.10272327065467834,
0.327097624540329,
-0.8749405741691589,
0.443915992975235,
0.19319379329681396,
-0.5776012539863586,
-0.28151729702949524,
-0.44992658495903015,
-0.6946266293525696,
0.4961232542991638,
-0.7379759550094604,
-0.6185107231140137,
0.11722643673419952,
0.5216644406318665,
-0.19119413197040558,
0.22623902559280396,
-0.9558809995651245,
0.7676925659179688,
-0.4384792149066925,
-0.8397804498672485,
-0.1297389417886734,
-0.8205398917198181,
0.34921517968177795,
-0.12648022174835205,
0.25909560918807983,
-0.05151120200753212,
0.12319853901863098,
0.4805794656276703,
-0.20597293972969055,
0.8385434746742249,
-0.2289659082889557,
-0.08566179871559143,
-0.2579011619091034,
-0.18843083083629608,
0.3946656584739685,
0.09325950592756271,
-0.00428265705704689,
-0.06730077415704727,
-0.23010319471359253,
-0.5549909472465515,
-0.5653995275497437,
0.6146964430809021,
-0.8775779008865356,
-0.4423373341560364,
-0.21636074781417847,
-0.5338136553764343,
-0.7045047283172607,
0.25159355998039246,
0.23165057599544525,
0.5399925708770752,
-0.11177187412977219,
0.40398159623146057,
0.5212923288345337,
-0.24901741743087769,
0.44291606545448303,
0.3312600255012512,
-0.4234720766544342,
-0.45018112659454346,
0.8677244782447815,
-0.11353962868452072,
0.608660876750946,
0.4397740662097931,
0.08310316503047943,
-0.2719547748565674,
-0.4807944595813751,
-0.5130555033683777,
0.12153374403715134,
-0.5631327033042908,
-0.0779290646314621,
-0.628387451171875,
0.18309001624584198,
-0.3794187605381012,
-0.10410581529140472,
-0.5555721521377563,
-0.13027822971343994,
-0.20693187415599823,
-0.15398456156253815,
0.03481324389576912,
0.15010195970535278,
0.12277273088693619,
0.21674105525016785,
-0.5349196195602417,
0.41747868061065674,
0.273691862821579,
0.3969976603984833,
0.1475573033094406,
-0.2734343409538269,
-0.2671082019805908,
0.07623490691184998,
-0.36093229055404663,
-0.5592008829116821,
0.4795718193054199,
-0.02184046432375908,
0.29538267850875854,
0.7961102724075317,
-0.03337951749563217,
0.8238713145256042,
-0.8077374696731567,
0.4429425597190857,
0.6733434796333313,
-0.6222077012062073,
0.608880877494812,
-0.3748481571674347,
0.2664169371128082,
0.6069347262382507,
0.5923547148704529,
-0.3166849911212921,
-0.09327806532382965,
-0.23778820037841797,
-0.8471552729606628,
0.5980638265609741,
0.03581743314862251,
0.4110371768474579,
0.03473996743559837,
-0.08932556211948395,
0.19916415214538574,
0.5645287036895752,
-1.1337254047393799,
-0.3508670926094055,
-0.40785518288612366,
0.04839443042874336,
-0.3672514259815216,
-0.5307984948158264,
-0.32192179560661316,
-0.25373250246047974,
0.7267386317253113,
-0.3174258768558502,
0.001257212134078145,
-0.11423990875482559,
-0.17331479489803314,
-0.0813683494925499,
0.4057285785675049,
0.6920243501663208,
0.6616429090499878,
-0.44435355067253113,
0.30369219183921814,
-0.23311710357666016,
-0.4371839463710785,
0.31411367654800415,
-0.10403026640415192,
-0.15350441634655,
-0.0827353224158287,
0.10064572840929031,
1.0389997959136963,
0.03733339160680771,
-0.78854900598526,
0.610822856426239,
0.12495195120573044,
0.06276118010282516,
-0.1721602827310562,
-0.23801515996456146,
-0.1081884577870369,
0.04282386228442192,
0.38235053420066833,
0.470691978931427,
-0.010190737433731556,
-0.6325932741165161,
0.03991962969303131,
0.7479450106620789,
-0.4278872311115265,
-0.14978404343128204,
0.4030968248844147,
0.30665624141693115,
0.008379098027944565,
0.21939219534397125,
0.07990197092294693,
-0.5004891753196716,
0.2822178304195404,
0.689214825630188,
0.5430669784545898,
-0.1382664293050766,
0.2650962173938751,
0.3142339885234833,
0.4364715814590454,
0.07178416848182678,
-0.04502179101109505,
-0.09548722952604294,
-1.0776793956756592,
-0.349216490983963,
-0.6070986390113831,
-0.20723381638526917,
0.5418320298194885,
-0.671193540096283,
0.5667141079902649,
-0.5282485485076904,
-0.3821742832660675,
-0.09468663483858109,
-0.5141733884811401,
-0.6624104380607605,
0.489963561296463,
0.26697292923927307,
0.32756975293159485,
-0.7348223924636841,
0.7051311135292053,
0.7016683220863342,
-0.5374628305435181,
-0.4660264551639557,
-0.024716757237911224,
-0.039629314094781876,
-1.0476908683776855,
0.86565101146698,
0.28560274839401245,
-0.22654244303703308,
-0.19409838318824768,
-0.7797890901565552,
-0.6914229393005371,
0.6875696778297424,
0.6552115678787231,
-0.5242370367050171,
0.10778793692588806,
-0.0029110084287822247,
0.21977046132087708,
-0.5360279083251953,
0.46607887744903564,
0.19286218285560608,
0.37397125363349915,
0.10036090016365051,
-0.89626544713974,
-0.04411466419696808,
-0.207210972905159,
0.0937652513384819,
0.12710997462272644,
-0.7618561387062073,
0.5488782525062561,
-0.22766585648059845,
0.10366087406873703,
-0.2998005151748657,
0.34995517134666443,
0.25614550709724426,
0.12609907984733582,
0.6181212067604065,
0.4397311210632324,
0.5801801681518555,
0.1137082427740097,
0.9193339943885803,
-0.23371678590774536,
0.20161773264408112,
1.19498872756958,
-0.24922455847263336,
0.9635915160179138,
0.9846071004867554,
-0.02444932423532009,
0.2861814498901367,
0.6790514588356018,
0.07929156720638275,
0.703804612159729,
0.10955315828323364,
-0.24440696835517883,
-0.5602618455886841,
-0.128575399518013,
-0.4524764120578766,
0.4903605282306671,
0.00906242337077856,
-0.6546860933303833,
-0.06032554432749748,
0.12772949039936066,
0.06788521260023117,
-0.0031597681809216738,
-0.23914308845996857,
0.6117712259292603,
-0.14157667756080627,
-0.5110745429992676,
0.7969571948051453,
-0.05180245637893677,
0.9292991161346436,
-0.7637408971786499,
0.13158324360847473,
-0.01133229024708271,
0.03803279995918274,
-0.21640221774578094,
-0.23950807750225067,
-0.18891911208629608,
-0.1251872330904007,
-0.5435534715652466,
-0.34277549386024475,
0.6503919959068298,
-0.6228122711181641,
-0.514437735080719,
0.27096059918403625,
0.407245934009552,
-0.08611385524272919,
-0.10704851150512695,
-0.4752046465873718,
0.23888391256332397,
0.02905638888478279,
-0.28039366006851196,
0.5859623551368713,
0.14434757828712463,
0.11419575661420822,
0.7973292469978333,
0.8616304397583008,
0.13858579099178314,
-0.04886021465063095,
0.3031826317310333,
1.131662368774414,
-0.3031272888183594,
-0.4329195022583008,
-1.108686089515686,
0.568179190158844,
-0.24747294187545776,
-0.2042364478111267,
0.6446353197097778,
0.7076245546340942,
0.9202926754951477,
-0.5033109188079834,
0.8628051280975342,
0.2938247323036194,
0.15671373903751373,
-0.8032748699188232,
0.7821179628372192,
-0.6770645976066589,
0.09380496293306351,
-0.5177534818649292,
-1.176910400390625,
-0.21894332766532898,
0.6707910895347595,
-0.5213358402252197,
0.17610080540180206,
0.6902228593826294,
0.9317181706428528,
-0.1874966323375702,
-0.34273430705070496,
0.6260576248168945,
0.054176442325115204,
0.18028567731380463,
0.49083128571510315,
0.8023386001586914,
-0.06405901908874512,
0.3324087858200073,
-0.06181899830698967,
-0.4287834167480469,
-0.18157397210597992,
-0.9595550298690796,
-1.1901390552520752,
-0.5828355550765991,
0.0005195601843297482,
-0.4686480760574341,
-0.004101586528122425,
1.503366231918335,
1.1466015577316284,
-0.7928411960601807,
-0.3080996572971344,
0.2574605345726013,
-0.240697979927063,
0.3792223334312439,
-0.2133224904537201,
0.062380097806453705,
-0.6874483227729797,
-0.7046193480491638,
0.20181113481521606,
0.39934149384498596,
0.11396913975477219,
-0.38398709893226624,
-0.10839539766311646,
-0.1504075825214386,
-0.10689402371644974,
1.0282082557678223,
-0.006880682893097401,
-0.7273858189582825,
-0.29553496837615967,
-0.08418987691402435,
0.054822131991386414,
0.41886264085769653,
0.805866539478302,
-0.7126801013946533,
0.7187811136245728,
0.06560167670249939,
0.8069602847099304,
0.6808112263679504,
0.04083479568362236,
0.7575666308403015,
-0.8038095235824585,
0.5904225707054138,
0.17870771884918213,
0.41166573762893677,
0.5918086171150208,
-0.17803242802619934,
0.13165999948978424,
0.2541155517101288,
-0.3056350648403168,
-0.7229985594749451,
0.3513639569282532,
-1.0179978609085083,
-0.16968749463558197,
1.3317636251449585,
0.16853110492229462,
-0.14353014528751373,
0.06900149583816528,
-0.4915233254432678,
-0.1765921264886856,
-0.7402614951133728,
0.8839106559753418,
0.8608236908912659,
0.014165637083351612,
-0.293765664100647,
-0.3913910388946533,
0.4899836480617523,
0.6577335596084595,
-0.7030360102653503,
-0.008776083588600159,
0.8802502751350403,
0.19004960358142853,
0.2167930006980896,
0.7132024765014648,
-0.045390535145998,
0.09247012436389923,
-0.3477863073348999,
0.2959541082382202,
-0.13341660797595978,
-0.4774945378303528,
-0.16083669662475586,
0.27727028727531433,
0.21335910260677338,
-0.2922172546386719
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08715v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08715v3
|
SOTOPIA-$π$: Interactive Learning of Socially Intelligent Language Agents
| 2024-03-13T17:17:48 | 2024-04-25T20:23:41 |
Ruiyi Wang, Haofei Yu, Wenxin Zhang, Zhengyang Qi, Maarten Sap, Graham Neubig, Yonatan Bisk, Hao Zhu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Humans learn social skills through both imitation and social interaction.
This social learning process is largely understudied by existing research on
building language agents. Motivated by this gap, we propose an interactive
learning method, SOTOPIA-$\pi$, improving the social intelligence of language
agents. This method leverages behavior cloning and self-reinforcement training
on filtered social interaction data according to large language model (LLM)
ratings. We show that our training method allows a 7B LLM to reach the social
goal completion ability of an expert model (GPT-4-based agent), while improving
the safety of language agents and maintaining general QA ability on the MMLU
benchmark. We also find that this training paradigm uncovers some difficulties
in LLM-based evaluation of social intelligence: LLM-based evaluators
overestimate the abilities of the language agents trained specifically for
social interaction.
|
[
-0.2300092577934265,
-1.0275590419769287,
0.7281749844551086,
0.24759699404239655,
-0.12758752703666687,
0.6823554635047913,
-0.4423782229423523,
-0.40130749344825745,
0.7442148923873901,
0.27361005544662476,
-0.35426148772239685,
-0.2792423963546753,
-0.5062887072563171,
-0.09557517617940903,
0.05223693326115608,
0.8472940325737,
0.3710833489894867,
0.25699254870414734,
-0.006059706211090088,
0.22391751408576965,
0.17126719653606415,
-0.43663549423217773,
-1.058462142944336,
-0.22837716341018677,
0.6205703616142273,
0.541096568107605,
0.7007317543029785,
0.3457854688167572,
0.2529684603214264,
0.4885087013244629,
0.005650574341416359,
0.5104995369911194,
-0.7742984890937805,
-0.0071844542399048805,
-0.49460920691490173,
-0.5906223058700562,
-0.5544689297676086,
0.31580889225006104,
0.678776204586029,
0.5846118330955505,
-0.22714093327522278,
-0.12744362652301788,
-0.13408179581165314,
0.6198514699935913,
-0.3588615655899048,
0.45890364050865173,
-0.6530469655990601,
-0.12948736548423767,
-0.038134824484586716,
-0.22460922598838806,
-0.5394611358642578,
-0.5784075260162354,
-0.19985225796699524,
-0.7001355886459351,
-0.005033886060118675,
-0.06543107330799103,
0.5410359501838684,
0.017616072669625282,
-0.1973259299993515,
-0.3923134207725525,
-0.7037287354469299,
0.5572065711021423,
-0.4459448456764221,
0.04217490181326866,
0.46900323033332825,
0.3766182065010071,
-0.4744522273540497,
-0.4396135210990906,
-0.7850230932235718,
-0.5312535762786865,
0.2789008617401123,
0.14659054577350616,
0.21506552398204803,
0.2161254733800888,
0.26235243678092957,
-0.026364436373114586,
-0.002079445868730545,
-0.13540753722190857,
-0.760046124458313,
0.0615108385682106,
0.9970729351043701,
-0.009917364455759525,
0.5162334442138672,
-0.3325253129005432,
-0.23253943026065826,
-0.3134387135505676,
-0.4411056935787201,
0.10696131736040115,
0.7340930104255676,
0.1846528798341751,
0.1021813377737999,
0.3295418322086334,
-0.4897752106189728,
0.16149917244911194,
0.27278029918670654,
-0.2898850440979004,
0.49428585171699524,
0.019338935613632202,
0.14617986977100372,
-0.15413573384284973,
0.7997996211051941,
0.1977275311946869,
0.6652846932411194,
-0.23793020844459534,
-0.04266047105193138,
-0.13272665441036224,
0.42040085792541504,
-0.3898758888244629,
-0.14174936711788177,
-0.11334706097841263,
-0.2195633351802826,
-0.6812755465507507,
0.2924567759037018,
-0.8078423738479614,
-0.43185797333717346,
-0.2803364098072052,
0.4617723822593689,
-0.6251097917556763,
-0.614276111125946,
-0.09454236924648285,
-0.1403937190771103,
0.5083688497543335,
0.5140039324760437,
-1.1261690855026245,
0.4851679503917694,
0.8061230778694153,
0.5821431279182434,
-0.24590511620044708,
-0.7861137986183167,
-0.8287922143936157,
0.29501503705978394,
-0.31518709659576416,
0.8207234740257263,
-0.7386051416397095,
-0.601655900478363,
-0.08129099756479263,
0.14985421299934387,
-0.22487133741378784,
-0.13618986308574677,
-0.04181584343314171,
-0.4430685043334961,
-0.06320414692163467,
-0.3248351812362671,
-0.5462993383407593,
-0.2374664843082428,
0.16606874763965607,
-0.30430108308792114,
0.8451265096664429,
0.11831619590520859,
-0.3261049687862396,
0.14058908820152283,
-0.5514272451400757,
-0.34742921590805054,
0.36863380670547485,
-0.2471899539232254,
-0.21205729246139526,
0.032447345554828644,
0.008364717476069927,
0.6157873272895813,
0.21769753098487854,
0.3154786229133606,
-0.8618968725204468,
-0.5556562542915344,
0.4056054949760437,
-0.2695550322532654,
0.8528349995613098,
0.03251410648226738,
-0.32297202944755554,
0.4095012843608856,
-0.8238229751586914,
0.08531705290079117,
0.23462006449699402,
-0.20317046344280243,
-0.3455049395561218,
-0.10565576702356339,
-0.3861047029495239,
0.08309536427259445,
0.15626506507396698,
-0.6347179412841797,
0.39372584223747253,
-0.18449519574642181,
0.3657284080982208,
1.0264464616775513,
0.22876620292663574,
0.5215062499046326,
-0.5111421346664429,
0.5552042722702026,
-0.7222729325294495,
0.4542867839336395,
0.45307183265686035,
-0.5124344229698181,
-0.7291698455810547,
-0.4927692115306854,
-0.05510318651795387,
0.37428367137908936,
-1.057773470878601,
0.3237006366252899,
-0.3397591710090637,
-0.840600311756134,
-0.4213688373565674,
0.3896709680557251,
0.3841851055622101,
-0.15681198239326477,
0.21620678901672363,
-0.25658395886421204,
-0.27932530641555786,
-0.3237866759300232,
-0.10889200121164322,
-0.4234763979911804,
0.12034028768539429,
0.18506549298763275,
0.47893011569976807,
-0.26260972023010254,
0.5434654951095581,
-0.09421525150537491,
-0.14333684742450714,
-0.6094480156898499,
0.03019130788743496,
-0.1383122354745865,
0.3343677222728729,
0.38018468022346497,
-0.44817835092544556,
-0.7854973673820496,
-0.019977157935500145,
-0.7208732962608337,
0.038340017199516296,
0.01973656751215458,
-0.19174198806285858,
0.010826816782355309,
0.7821357250213623,
-0.5797238945960999,
0.3274170458316803,
0.20927214622497559,
-0.11490798741579056,
0.29040563106536865,
-0.45205315947532654,
0.35355597734451294,
-0.8440496325492859,
-0.2909029722213745,
-0.33687207102775574,
-0.32469069957733154,
-0.7247021794319153,
0.07665075361728668,
0.127524271607399,
-0.07770796120166779,
-0.6703291535377502,
0.7986639738082886,
-0.5282464623451233,
-0.05527020990848541,
-0.4028951823711395,
0.3485875427722931,
-0.38178491592407227,
0.9811738133430481,
0.07362323999404907,
0.5248079299926758,
0.4073488116264343,
-0.49991554021835327,
0.6468243598937988,
0.008982357569038868,
-0.13441431522369385,
0.6908114552497864,
-0.7085402607917786,
0.434766560792923,
-0.1427924931049347,
-0.05151517316699028,
-0.9074377417564392,
-0.48199886083602905,
0.41222527623176575,
-0.5717328190803528,
0.23842963576316833,
-0.08252450823783875,
-0.317042738199234,
-0.02997661381959915,
-0.6509236097335815,
-0.030917659401893616,
0.6825310587882996,
-0.5523377060890198,
0.727609395980835,
0.5889864563941956,
-0.1935426890850067,
-0.1740776151418686,
-0.14880457520484924,
-0.29465532302856445,
-0.17708520591259003,
-0.5628775954246521,
0.06974620372056961,
0.10147774964570999,
-0.2624708116054535,
-0.1354529708623886,
0.32493090629577637,
0.33513209223747253,
0.1659824550151825,
0.30745911598205566,
0.1287546306848526,
0.26184678077697754,
0.16937464475631714,
0.15752273797988892,
-0.13019832968711853,
0.1909819394350052,
0.40889135003089905,
0.6016136407852173,
-0.4497371315956116,
-0.6349358558654785,
-0.2992038428783417,
-0.09895147383213043,
0.4257403016090393,
-0.16915535926818848,
0.6615408658981323,
0.5358676314353943,
-0.1413465142250061,
-0.1496526300907135,
-0.5299291014671326,
-0.04484367370605469,
-0.511738657951355,
0.30755046010017395,
-0.4228852093219757,
-0.48731204867362976,
0.24681873619556427,
-0.1440603882074356,
-0.09179362654685974,
0.09491544961929321,
0.338512122631073,
-0.23110133409500122,
0.8088705539703369,
0.44430282711982727,
0.07173371315002441,
0.9479734897613525,
-0.2228780835866928,
-0.03101385571062565,
-0.9443466663360596,
-0.4256390333175659,
-0.1564328968524933,
0.023848388344049454,
-0.4999975860118866,
-0.5378493070602417,
0.21118439733982086,
-0.09484363347291946,
-0.04519062489271164,
0.16802260279655457,
-0.11379020661115646,
0.493942528963089,
0.6362402439117432,
0.6392871737480164,
0.32608312368392944,
0.09410464018583298,
0.24398207664489746,
0.2517464756965637,
-0.39544677734375,
-0.5217428207397461,
1.200531005859375,
0.35838577151298523,
0.999164879322052,
0.2869226634502411,
1.020127534866333,
0.443846732378006,
0.4471006393432617,
-0.6082247495651245,
0.8606386184692383,
0.22892208397388458,
-0.27931612730026245,
-0.8148100972175598,
-0.34177008271217346,
-0.8358024954795837,
0.29262790083885193,
-0.310138463973999,
-0.7660857439041138,
0.03569099307060242,
-0.01479102112352848,
-0.13572262227535248,
0.09791995584964752,
-0.782708466053009,
0.513149619102478,
-0.3712943494319916,
-0.5875629782676697,
-0.7349767088890076,
-0.47062957286834717,
0.11109686642885208,
0.20081570744514465,
0.2807202935218811,
-0.4211038053035736,
-0.016767174005508423,
0.4626055359840393,
-0.40397122502326965,
1.0727792978286743,
-0.42567428946495056,
0.2838803231716156,
0.17064212262630463,
0.03354732319712639,
0.7280400395393372,
0.12465111166238785,
-0.14181406795978546,
-0.15552343428134918,
-0.07551821321249008,
-0.6457496881484985,
-0.8985447883605957,
0.5479027628898621,
-0.9254503846168518,
-0.8725951313972473,
-0.5301279425621033,
-0.09756293147802353,
-0.3090704381465912,
-0.03078644722700119,
-0.14835231006145477,
0.031555384397506714,
-0.3893040120601654,
0.3227832317352295,
0.7027416825294495,
-0.04083643853664398,
0.2628900408744812,
0.6272714138031006,
-0.4622008502483368,
-0.6386828422546387,
1.1020138263702393,
0.10290129482746124,
0.6182408332824707,
0.1272628903388977,
0.1325034350156784,
-0.07910284399986267,
-0.21193571388721466,
-0.2120152860879898,
0.5474745035171509,
-0.6807251572608948,
0.22823438048362732,
-0.7160341143608093,
-0.3791486620903015,
-0.3177567720413208,
-0.24704650044441223,
-0.3777467608451843,
-0.17878508567810059,
0.005136456340551376,
-0.29954591393470764,
0.41274893283843994,
0.8637242317199707,
-0.35369443893432617,
0.3624317944049835,
-0.3059060573577881,
0.23894988000392914,
0.6549994945526123,
0.24116523563861847,
0.17863772809505463,
-0.4138203263282776,
0.014371334575116634,
0.12192101776599884,
-0.030055373907089233,
-0.9674466252326965,
0.08643677085638046,
0.22044460475444794,
0.950982391834259,
0.41179534792900085,
-0.0481901541352272,
0.4694024622440338,
-0.2780906558036804,
0.3020501434803009,
-0.009520024061203003,
-0.904597282409668,
0.6463517546653748,
-0.36008545756340027,
-0.00989729817956686,
0.6484501957893372,
0.4973709285259247,
-0.4424571394920349,
-0.6266743540763855,
-0.9003317356109619,
-0.37080684304237366,
0.608722448348999,
0.1009315624833107,
0.32937148213386536,
-0.2705884277820587,
0.35852041840553284,
0.03803935647010803,
0.15391097962856293,
-0.8450347185134888,
0.23839551210403442,
-0.10134010016918182,
-0.21956871449947357,
0.029721949249505997,
-0.23378582298755646,
0.21886023879051208,
-0.39441967010498047,
0.9714949727058411,
-0.20713847875595093,
0.03698447719216347,
0.09002340584993362,
-0.3037060499191284,
-0.023162564262747765,
-0.016466502100229263,
0.2876231372356415,
0.6677573323249817,
-0.14814330637454987,
-0.0071343122981488705,
0.34258708357810974,
-0.4108071029186249,
0.19471001625061035,
-0.15087197721004486,
-0.04509368911385536,
-0.40885084867477417,
0.306109219789505,
0.7090868949890137,
0.3527452051639557,
-0.6955596208572388,
0.5993022322654724,
-0.20014609396457672,
-0.023138385266065598,
-0.6010337471961975,
0.7473117709159851,
0.03485069423913956,
0.37511584162712097,
0.20616020262241364,
-0.24058374762535095,
0.08657584339380264,
-1.0037505626678467,
0.055096615105867386,
0.4967958331108093,
-0.41779014468193054,
-0.30169081687927246,
0.3167676329612732,
0.5599141120910645,
-0.7437585592269897,
0.5150468349456787,
-0.5506085157394409,
-0.576328456401825,
0.5273599624633789,
0.22624452412128448,
0.6291499137878418,
-0.4872121214866638,
0.6468071341514587,
0.16662196815013885,
0.29706788063049316,
-0.005776111502200365,
0.4610426127910614,
-0.36750805377960205,
-0.6799205541610718,
-0.11819520592689514,
-0.45665639638900757,
-0.8485233783721924,
-0.11092308908700943,
-0.47272229194641113,
0.41977035999298096,
-0.6484874486923218,
0.0628526583313942,
-0.07974161207675934,
0.16413243114948273,
-0.5168240666389465,
-0.17726686596870422,
-0.1725798398256302,
0.46982085704803467,
-0.8463415503501892,
1.2561389207839966,
0.6085565686225891,
-0.6207213997840881,
-0.7590256333351135,
-0.14952532947063446,
-0.22340302169322968,
-0.9312536716461182,
0.34572163224220276,
0.14525429904460907,
-0.37832316756248474,
0.1461651623249054,
-0.5708019137382507,
-0.8204138875007629,
0.8681414127349854,
0.22777511179447174,
-0.26435860991477966,
-0.051611702889204025,
-0.0387447327375412,
0.8014277219772339,
-0.2644259035587311,
0.4444200098514557,
0.40750637650489807,
0.18217185139656067,
-0.03938669711351395,
-0.5587839484214783,
0.060362983494997025,
-0.5321922898292542,
0.20186229050159454,
-0.1757700890302658,
-1.1055090427398682,
0.38360437750816345,
-0.44906172156333923,
0.02539220079779625,
0.11942104995250702,
0.8605054020881653,
0.46311700344085693,
0.15272021293640137,
0.6466283202171326,
-0.10871090739965439,
0.9557191729545593,
0.016210665926337242,
0.8817799687385559,
-0.09673658013343811,
0.2797289192676544,
1.054443120956421,
-0.25590723752975464,
0.8825015425682068,
0.4444653391838074,
-0.23962529003620148,
0.5198668837547302,
0.6463916301727295,
-0.008020678535103798,
0.49747925996780396,
0.24039950966835022,
-0.2324657440185547,
-0.3443051278591156,
0.21292243897914886,
-0.1571875810623169,
0.3308764100074768,
0.4660123288631439,
-0.03859834745526314,
0.29174643754959106,
0.29326575994491577,
0.01431527640670538,
0.3142893612384796,
-0.16401594877243042,
0.951819658279419,
-0.10535935312509537,
-0.6457305550575256,
0.05937425047159195,
-0.2899242639541626,
0.5084315538406372,
-0.5649482011795044,
-0.20304246246814728,
-0.3347691595554352,
0.15581014752388,
-0.04059438034892082,
-0.6612074971199036,
0.08291494101285934,
-0.23701965808868408,
0.27823391556739807,
-0.06394975632429123,
0.703729510307312,
-0.48133742809295654,
-0.3670215904712677,
0.5479332804679871,
0.38713353872299194,
0.609383225440979,
0.03294402360916138,
-0.48334214091300964,
-0.0010241877753287554,
-0.003686606651172042,
-0.30058324337005615,
0.31414973735809326,
0.6103939414024353,
-0.009095102548599243,
0.890750527381897,
0.6520312428474426,
0.14971788227558136,
0.1688433438539505,
0.1717914640903473,
0.7160077095031738,
-0.6558074951171875,
-0.4095827341079712,
-0.698857843875885,
0.268932580947876,
-0.6162003874778748,
-0.04631376639008522,
0.5568215250968933,
0.10856637358665466,
0.9681383371353149,
-0.1710965931415558,
0.6971591114997864,
-0.18988516926765442,
0.5330796837806702,
-0.5414613485336304,
0.6397097706794739,
-0.314704567193985,
0.2592579126358032,
-0.35588663816452026,
-0.8711944222450256,
0.35720720887184143,
0.7822757959365845,
-0.48929381370544434,
0.29254186153411865,
0.576869547367096,
0.7096481323242188,
-0.043380074203014374,
-0.030676092952489853,
0.65040123462677,
0.06338955461978912,
0.3765503764152527,
0.34805139899253845,
1.0387381315231323,
-0.08405083417892456,
0.49760952591896057,
-0.5597814917564392,
-0.6267251968383789,
-0.35235363245010376,
-0.4544207751750946,
-1.4146324396133423,
-0.5418679714202881,
-0.11664321273565292,
-0.28985241055488586,
0.4679661691188812,
1.2587110996246338,
0.6430103182792664,
-0.4775315523147583,
-0.2738727927207947,
0.0669848769903183,
0.3776523172855377,
-0.25060054659843445,
-0.2490301877260208,
0.19204342365264893,
-0.6232283115386963,
-1.0311498641967773,
0.45554786920547485,
0.29909899830818176,
0.0015167172532528639,
-0.5605001449584961,
-0.3318965435028076,
-0.26572519540786743,
0.17128607630729675,
0.5384388566017151,
0.41281408071517944,
-0.619953453540802,
-0.4354117810726166,
-0.02408192865550518,
-0.26192012429237366,
-0.08379136025905609,
0.194902703166008,
-0.5236952900886536,
0.538840115070343,
0.45464223623275757,
0.5672581791877747,
0.6719306111335754,
-0.01264814380556345,
0.6064940690994263,
-0.2719583809375763,
0.18939246237277985,
-0.21204499900341034,
0.27862000465393066,
0.23233161866664886,
-0.55771404504776,
0.7414544820785522,
0.25517916679382324,
-0.4065895080566406,
-0.47969183325767517,
0.107151098549366,
-0.8978573083877563,
-0.06853579729795456,
1.3951709270477295,
-0.2692759931087494,
-0.5494019389152527,
-0.11674366891384125,
-0.5050807595252991,
0.2823612093925476,
-0.604020893573761,
1.1184370517730713,
0.6301400065422058,
-0.23068077862262726,
-0.1768486648797989,
-0.30760064721107483,
0.5361314415931702,
0.19865211844444275,
-1.1177847385406494,
-0.29145485162734985,
0.07894077897071838,
0.41159746050834656,
0.1763671189546585,
0.9948856234550476,
-0.010938307270407677,
0.6573165655136108,
0.006205211393535137,
0.3147448003292084,
-0.10557568818330765,
-0.5059928894042969,
-0.14782309532165527,
-0.00659094238653779,
0.252362459897995,
-0.08268193155527115
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08694v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08694v2
|
TeaMs-RL: Teaching LLMs to Teach Themselves Better Instructions via Reinforcement Learning
| 2024-03-13T16:57:57 | 2024-05-03T22:44:24 |
Shangding Gu, Alois Knoll, Ming Jin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The development of Large Language Models (LLMs) often confronts challenges
stemming from the heavy reliance on human annotators in the reinforcement
learning with human feedback (RLHF) framework, or the frequent and costly
external queries tied to the self-instruct paradigm. In this work, we pivot to
Reinforcement Learning (RL) -- but with a twist. Diverging from the typical
RLHF, which refines LLMs following instruction data training, we use RL to
directly generate the foundational instruction dataset that alone suffices for
fine-tuning. Our method, TeaMs-RL, uses a suite of textual operations and
rules, prioritizing the diversification of training datasets. It facilitates
the generation of high-quality data without excessive reliance on external
advanced models, paving the way for a single fine-tuning step and negating the
need for subsequent RLHF stages. Our findings highlight key advantages of our
approach: reduced need for human involvement and fewer model queries (only
$5.73\%$ of WizardLM's total), along with enhanced capabilities of LLMs in
crafting and comprehending complex instructions compared to strong baselines,
and substantially improved model privacy protection.
|
[
-0.29047441482543945,
-0.5582225322723389,
0.12650597095489502,
0.18110164999961853,
-0.03307933732867241,
0.4221952557563782,
-0.31808751821517944,
-0.15619173645973206,
-0.2235797792673111,
0.9206556677818298,
-0.8874773979187012,
-0.5615185499191284,
-0.33871105313301086,
0.012315156869590282,
-0.2523892819881439,
1.3490959405899048,
-0.00011530815390869975,
0.030901988968253136,
-0.058744948357343674,
-0.11406230926513672,
-0.3642145097255707,
-0.4641318917274475,
-0.8532567620277405,
-0.6289411783218384,
0.8391126990318298,
0.7784922122955322,
0.5902168154716492,
0.7518402338027954,
0.19490307569503784,
0.2641696631908417,
0.26051437854766846,
0.6628603339195251,
-0.7573024034500122,
0.4115660786628723,
-0.11779741197824478,
-0.4061846435070038,
-0.20077386498451233,
-0.0015876978868618608,
0.35877713561058044,
0.6983824372291565,
-0.49470481276512146,
0.2016332596540451,
0.018275711685419083,
1.0482639074325562,
-0.39998161792755127,
0.3393096923828125,
-0.36859479546546936,
0.28805065155029297,
0.2333422303199768,
-0.35442838072776794,
-0.8444205522537231,
-0.36338135600090027,
0.16777311265468597,
-0.6860641837120056,
0.2540956735610962,
0.34291017055511475,
0.6132439970970154,
0.441626638174057,
-0.2668437361717224,
-0.2224501371383667,
-0.7161157131195068,
0.8423945307731628,
-0.4859171509742737,
0.2621691823005676,
0.31404542922973633,
0.33683717250823975,
-0.3997427821159363,
-0.43718191981315613,
-0.06263650208711624,
-0.42553192377090454,
0.05896131694316864,
0.08101107180118561,
0.37072131037712097,
0.13120137155056,
0.2162228226661682,
0.17323113977909088,
-0.3708784580230713,
0.3890630304813385,
-0.5192539095878601,
-0.04080658406019211,
0.9500125646591187,
0.36045461893081665,
0.23966963589191437,
0.28629645705223083,
-0.4218859076499939,
-0.341217964887619,
-1.0116358995437622,
-0.07771095633506775,
0.24094149470329285,
0.5514972805976868,
0.060148824006319046,
0.34062638878822327,
-0.26202675700187683,
0.5518900156021118,
0.3261661231517792,
-0.1361771672964096,
0.016493486240506172,
-0.012759513221681118,
-0.1401190459728241,
0.11001250892877579,
0.6971396207809448,
0.25519639253616333,
0.4192018210887909,
-0.5021753907203674,
-0.5124593377113342,
-0.16749224066734314,
0.3146582543849945,
-0.7711902856826782,
-0.5003853440284729,
-0.021149856969714165,
-0.24337883293628693,
-0.3643081784248352,
-0.039181239902973175,
-0.44165799021720886,
-0.5183169841766357,
-0.4908604323863983,
0.3381004333496094,
-0.3022734820842743,
-0.18423886597156525,
0.11607833951711655,
0.07154975831508636,
0.2518227994441986,
0.5156072974205017,
-1.099662184715271,
0.5348383784294128,
0.7236291766166687,
0.401661217212677,
-0.41443976759910583,
-0.4488532841205597,
-0.9240908622741699,
0.20920607447624207,
-0.6556605100631714,
0.7767221331596375,
-0.2906346917152405,
-0.6338157653808594,
-0.022174641489982605,
-0.22955778241157532,
0.12928174436092377,
-0.7152983546257019,
-0.004712777677923441,
-0.5815606117248535,
0.44961419701576233,
-0.18976490199565887,
-0.6863710880279541,
0.0146112609654665,
0.18688271939754486,
-0.6322823166847229,
1.0382508039474487,
0.03471507132053375,
-0.2729019820690155,
0.46442630887031555,
-0.7265256643295288,
-0.6509645581245422,
0.13207994401454926,
-0.30668318271636963,
-0.44068703055381775,
-0.1444721519947052,
0.26965031027793884,
0.5775120854377747,
-0.1322326362133026,
0.23932482302188873,
-0.09989385306835175,
-0.2356899231672287,
0.15850232541561127,
-0.26292628049850464,
0.3768395483493805,
0.018920497968792915,
-0.2759193181991577,
0.5295535326004028,
-0.5154678821563721,
0.08400708436965942,
0.04383692890405655,
-0.6582669615745544,
-0.1339184194803238,
0.12222032248973846,
-0.14919030666351318,
0.2642962634563446,
-0.016358036547899246,
-0.09466657042503357,
0.3423243761062622,
-0.44676148891448975,
0.24015390872955322,
0.8786036372184753,
-0.002594488672912121,
0.6509583592414856,
-0.4115201234817505,
0.6224506497383118,
-0.22283165156841278,
0.3065516948699951,
-0.05905870720744133,
-0.2971045672893524,
-0.7700775861740112,
-0.06413904577493668,
0.0929749384522438,
0.38405051827430725,
-0.9374827146530151,
0.09706656634807587,
-0.09613553434610367,
-0.34771159291267395,
-0.5403111577033997,
0.37190842628479004,
0.805725634098053,
0.4414203464984894,
0.4671752452850342,
-0.1706165075302124,
-0.3818527162075043,
-0.7504279017448425,
-0.09937843680381775,
-0.08415026217699051,
0.14005407691001892,
0.20923632383346558,
0.33114829659461975,
0.04040226712822914,
0.8036321401596069,
-0.31327587366104126,
-0.06563276797533035,
-0.5776769518852234,
0.29803937673568726,
-0.07684636861085892,
0.3594973683357239,
-0.08261304348707199,
-0.6620849370956421,
-0.6582042574882507,
-0.08167030662298203,
-0.5909993648529053,
-0.08759599179029465,
-0.10595624893903732,
-0.13518624007701874,
0.5460628271102905,
0.631945788860321,
-0.2647678554058075,
0.20459091663360596,
0.3847839832305908,
-0.34232038259506226,
0.4786367416381836,
-0.4344736933708191,
-0.04709206894040108,
-0.6941971182823181,
-0.39665812253952026,
-0.20488117635250092,
-0.4412955641746521,
-0.4917444884777069,
0.06994324922561646,
-0.01129851397126913,
0.028982114046812057,
-0.4284088611602783,
0.5453954339027405,
-0.6153461933135986,
-0.1992211937904358,
-0.33392637968063354,
0.0761188194155693,
-0.040187470614910126,
0.7937556505203247,
0.12467467039823532,
0.9598152041435242,
0.06674379855394363,
-0.8330053091049194,
0.3743346929550171,
0.08795547485351562,
-0.12450999021530151,
0.2736481726169586,
-0.45915788412094116,
0.1711723655462265,
-0.03882208094000816,
0.3791579604148865,
-0.5095801949501038,
-0.13472026586532593,
0.4305962026119232,
-0.22174182534217834,
0.4877556264400482,
-0.2279023677110672,
-0.5217059850692749,
-0.07767846435308456,
-0.17481115460395813,
-0.05561576783657074,
0.5680252909660339,
-0.7678090333938599,
0.43049782514572144,
0.4384078085422516,
0.2149987816810608,
-0.5981631278991699,
-0.5226835012435913,
-0.016240622848272324,
-0.16632908582687378,
-0.33099812269210815,
0.21573764085769653,
-0.07602954655885696,
-0.15921343863010406,
0.12178128212690353,
-0.19133363664150238,
-0.16503220796585083,
0.2958957254886627,
0.35761353373527527,
0.23248064517974854,
-0.10240789502859116,
0.4361235499382019,
-0.13922515511512756,
-0.30648449063301086,
-0.010439787060022354,
-0.2784241735935211,
0.4687747061252594,
-0.10827869176864624,
-0.3426509201526642,
-0.318765789270401,
0.2280859798192978,
0.31645286083221436,
-0.33291345834732056,
0.7833890914916992,
0.36022770404815674,
-0.012800711207091808,
-0.860167384147644,
-0.3075912594795227,
-0.40132007002830505,
-0.4687855839729309,
0.4613916575908661,
-0.05609689652919769,
-0.9495711326599121,
0.16907446086406708,
-0.07942578196525574,
0.5249312520027161,
0.1975914090871811,
0.41462478041648865,
-0.2189248949289322,
0.9613200426101685,
0.5216262340545654,
-0.11334922909736633,
0.5872318148612976,
-0.18599174916744232,
-0.13587260246276855,
-0.6735677719116211,
-0.3685441315174103,
-0.024870559573173523,
-0.13112622499465942,
-0.3676950931549072,
-0.5478377938270569,
0.23724019527435303,
-0.00481308251619339,
-0.5653164982795715,
0.16968828439712524,
-0.5295931696891785,
0.7166092991828918,
0.6273613572120667,
0.33342066407203674,
0.28742727637290955,
-0.054185107350349426,
0.08620952814817429,
0.13051195442676544,
-0.9137265682220459,
-0.4726208448410034,
1.2698599100112915,
0.3292575180530548,
1.0003505945205688,
0.03421836346387863,
1.1645536422729492,
0.3748028576374054,
0.5392684936523438,
-0.6323261260986328,
0.5990582704544067,
-0.08663918077945709,
-0.3663376271724701,
-0.6161842346191406,
-0.5789837837219238,
-1.0181019306182861,
0.3058204650878906,
-0.2778322100639343,
-0.22297969460487366,
-0.3708328306674957,
0.37294134497642517,
-0.610491931438446,
0.16929638385772705,
-0.8769860863685608,
0.7945063710212708,
-0.4102809429168701,
-0.5592355132102966,
-0.4669228494167328,
-0.46949151158332825,
0.48299917578697205,
0.23743346333503723,
0.21867050230503082,
-0.08046657592058182,
-0.1410113126039505,
0.6584156155586243,
-0.5132657289505005,
0.9944891333580017,
-0.1681590974330902,
-0.28596386313438416,
0.17114759981632233,
0.05342203751206398,
0.5671581625938416,
0.03135763108730316,
0.08964592963457108,
-0.5890879034996033,
-0.2671533524990082,
-0.3186928927898407,
-0.7389565110206604,
0.5092074871063232,
-0.7421578764915466,
-0.6193679571151733,
-0.2529910206794739,
-0.6652213335037231,
-0.33204385638237,
-0.08838965743780136,
-0.10629275441169739,
0.5755143761634827,
0.020552385598421097,
0.024069255217909813,
1.135495901107788,
-0.42202723026275635,
0.2985377907752991,
0.6275652050971985,
-0.5739374756813049,
-0.3087519705295563,
1.105124592781067,
0.06436531245708466,
0.5881988406181335,
0.5274481773376465,
0.18845786154270172,
-0.1902921497821808,
-0.5103469491004944,
-0.4416208863258362,
0.1014072448015213,
-0.7250552177429199,
-0.09220106899738312,
-0.3018772304058075,
-0.15365895628929138,
-0.18143793940544128,
0.022577283903956413,
-0.6232250332832336,
-0.3445183336734772,
-0.28515881299972534,
-0.09970996528863907,
0.39293378591537476,
0.9238754510879517,
0.04548925161361694,
0.15986984968185425,
-0.7048925161361694,
0.24607792496681213,
0.4741904139518738,
0.3896278440952301,
0.016569528728723526,
-0.46279242634773254,
-0.509282648563385,
-0.13663256168365479,
-0.15306662023067474,
-0.6670018434524536,
0.44756388664245605,
0.1290806531906128,
0.5831812620162964,
-0.002997505711391568,
0.20367498695850372,
0.6351425051689148,
-0.6563774347305298,
0.45945215225219727,
0.08116868138313293,
-0.6036853194236755,
0.4459262788295746,
-0.2747448980808258,
0.12649157643318176,
0.5867531895637512,
0.014493454247713089,
-0.6540249586105347,
-0.36680731177330017,
-0.5784832239151001,
-0.9817343950271606,
0.9024001955986023,
-0.2880658805370331,
-0.08192653954029083,
0.09252005815505981,
0.3485596477985382,
0.12893140316009521,
0.21334010362625122,
-0.566423773765564,
-0.3294808566570282,
-0.016068005934357643,
-0.2517194151878357,
0.04783228784799576,
0.007785923779010773,
-0.20753121376037598,
-0.16400380432605743,
0.8558120727539062,
-0.1423025280237198,
0.008426615968346596,
0.04447526857256889,
-0.30977433919906616,
-0.12639786303043365,
0.11512874811887741,
0.6882297396659851,
0.49325257539749146,
0.04925497993826866,
-0.032627008855342865,
0.2572702467441559,
-0.024179870262742043,
0.03201158717274666,
-0.2555330991744995,
0.029495935887098312,
-0.4029442071914673,
0.533831000328064,
0.9636414051055908,
0.5969272255897522,
-0.8115671277046204,
0.2557328939437866,
-0.09429771453142166,
-0.3023400604724884,
-0.22512881457805634,
0.5387193560600281,
0.18176381289958954,
0.39162883162498474,
0.23457767069339752,
-0.15617866814136505,
-0.011488694697618484,
-0.38367027044296265,
0.461830198764801,
0.1948716640472412,
-0.29623326659202576,
-0.09313340485095978,
0.22680538892745972,
0.4089129567146301,
-0.48283955454826355,
0.5528877973556519,
-0.3659740388393402,
-0.5859408974647522,
0.6393378376960754,
0.3474426567554474,
0.7257469296455383,
-0.1391724795103073,
0.5338767170906067,
0.2178945243358612,
0.2106810212135315,
-0.4867393672466278,
0.02797381393611431,
-0.11858440935611725,
-0.48769089579582214,
-0.6445662975311279,
-0.28782564401626587,
-0.8627585172653198,
0.025710010901093483,
-0.6828818321228027,
0.0768464133143425,
-0.8087570071220398,
0.33419471979141235,
-0.43979817628860474,
0.12896497547626495,
-0.4543790817260742,
0.1295524686574936,
0.3171030879020691,
0.6504690051078796,
-0.5921910405158997,
0.9859240651130676,
0.46448439359664917,
-0.5799515247344971,
-1.138688087463379,
-0.10865625739097595,
-0.13807325065135956,
-0.9186300039291382,
0.9657492637634277,
0.11061681807041168,
-0.20536816120147705,
0.052330706268548965,
-0.6668670773506165,
-0.5686719417572021,
1.0453717708587646,
0.18374305963516235,
-0.6790114641189575,
-0.15354229509830475,
-0.052691519260406494,
0.5388122200965881,
-0.4280547499656677,
0.1218891367316246,
0.27704620361328125,
0.22514361143112183,
0.08850415796041489,
-0.6823222041130066,
-0.03276248648762703,
0.09621662646532059,
-0.1664053350687027,
0.23721876740455627,
-0.6834540367126465,
0.7738801836967468,
-0.30180904269218445,
-0.3215339183807373,
-0.2990346848964691,
0.8785242438316345,
0.31633543968200684,
0.03200380876660347,
0.4933137893676758,
0.3856750726699829,
0.8975715637207031,
0.14869892597198486,
1.019655704498291,
-0.08062963932752609,
0.24155476689338684,
1.5397307872772217,
-0.20038451254367828,
0.868292510509491,
0.4123462736606598,
-0.15007179975509644,
0.41868123412132263,
0.6257734894752502,
0.060545966029167175,
0.536138653755188,
0.5852541923522949,
-0.19468510150909424,
-0.5906217694282532,
0.13418827950954437,
-0.09022661298513412,
0.05746108666062355,
0.39696428179740906,
-0.10071561485528946,
-0.3857082426548004,
-0.097983717918396,
-0.12025737762451172,
0.4307400584220886,
-0.4133012890815735,
0.8863503932952881,
0.09756921231746674,
-0.8365890383720398,
0.4877101480960846,
-0.19459623098373413,
0.7282481789588928,
-0.3930075764656067,
-0.12468280643224716,
-0.3036772310733795,
0.268067866563797,
-0.2033189833164215,
-0.7292992472648621,
0.13323840498924255,
0.013884090818464756,
-0.19949176907539368,
-0.5847644805908203,
0.4578130543231964,
-0.753240704536438,
-0.20448683202266693,
0.33317190408706665,
0.2982833981513977,
0.03744228929281235,
0.2286846786737442,
-0.8252308368682861,
-0.1391165554523468,
-0.02160162478685379,
-0.3680786192417145,
0.46579068899154663,
0.3812773525714874,
-0.1064017191529274,
1.0707693099975586,
0.5302802920341492,
0.06732167303562164,
0.2708147168159485,
0.19993238151073456,
0.7446710467338562,
-0.644926130771637,
-0.22439511120319366,
-0.751677393913269,
0.4371102452278137,
-0.1565500795841217,
-0.32904818654060364,
0.6101301312446594,
0.37136077880859375,
0.9213986396789551,
0.009678252041339874,
0.8722577691078186,
0.3278731405735016,
0.6467609405517578,
-0.6561876535415649,
0.6444488167762756,
-0.29318663477897644,
0.36299169063568115,
0.14101898670196533,
-0.3964979946613312,
-0.36880236864089966,
0.5736756324768066,
-0.44728517532348633,
0.05484217777848244,
0.5115617513656616,
0.737159252166748,
0.17011120915412903,
0.011109150014817715,
0.29546496272087097,
-0.09708400070667267,
0.5727861523628235,
0.6438941955566406,
0.9972830414772034,
-0.1904529631137848,
0.6682664752006531,
-0.2501939833164215,
-0.04738021269440651,
-0.28073373436927795,
-0.7276890277862549,
-1.268010139465332,
-0.27698490023612976,
-0.46076449751853943,
-0.22943969070911407,
0.35030508041381836,
1.4550343751907349,
0.7055021524429321,
-0.721164345741272,
-0.46014100313186646,
-0.27729344367980957,
0.43958741426467896,
-0.2858175039291382,
-0.1444324553012848,
0.2385954111814499,
-0.9008572697639465,
-0.48451104760169983,
0.6087440252304077,
0.17780844867229462,
-0.16254501044750214,
-0.5119251608848572,
-0.6588823795318604,
-0.13642078638076782,
-0.15954403579235077,
0.4876442551612854,
0.4928549528121948,
-0.7502556443214417,
-0.2188008427619934,
-0.033127520233392715,
-0.42156529426574707,
0.002051811432465911,
0.6032088994979858,
-0.7598041892051697,
0.2209426909685135,
0.20653168857097626,
0.9297369718551636,
0.44287562370300293,
-0.22359971702098846,
0.8308865427970886,
-0.5821856260299683,
-0.26544734835624695,
0.190242201089859,
-0.033201757818460464,
0.3805931508541107,
-0.173396036028862,
0.5146434903144836,
-0.007936086505651474,
-0.658525824546814,
-0.879762589931488,
0.2728297710418701,
-0.5130732655525208,
-0.27117422223091125,
1.2267873287200928,
-0.1248508021235466,
-0.34850016236305237,
-0.1427895426750183,
-0.34820640087127686,
0.32706353068351746,
-0.6530328989028931,
0.8730736374855042,
0.5027650594711304,
-0.23154237866401672,
-0.344607949256897,
-0.5124644637107849,
0.6790982484817505,
0.39707091450691223,
-0.8872824311256409,
0.3015022277832031,
0.4738888442516327,
0.3392137289047241,
-0.23662731051445007,
0.5274726748466492,
0.18242959678173065,
0.22746014595031738,
-0.24059247970581055,
0.2256014496088028,
-0.3775523602962494,
-0.5784677863121033,
-0.16693338751792908,
0.12391317635774612,
0.266489714384079,
-0.3337874114513397
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08693v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08693v1
|
Do Language Models Care About Text Quality? Evaluating Web-Crawled Corpora Across 11 Languages
| 2024-03-13T16:56:33 | 2024-03-13T16:56:33 |
Rik van Noord, Taja Kuzman, Peter Rupnik, Nikola Ljubešić, Miquel Esplà-Gomis, Gema Ramírez-Sánchez, Antonio Toral
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large, curated, web-crawled corpora play a vital role in training language
models (LMs). They form the lion's share of the training data in virtually all
recent LMs, such as the well-known GPT, LLaMA and XLM-RoBERTa models. However,
despite this importance, relatively little attention has been given to the
quality of these corpora. In this paper, we compare four of the currently most
relevant large, web-crawled corpora (CC100, MaCoCu, mC4 and OSCAR) across
eleven lower-resourced European languages. Our approach is two-fold: first, we
perform an intrinsic evaluation by performing a human evaluation of the quality
of samples taken from different corpora; then, we assess the practical impact
of the qualitative differences by training specific LMs on each of the corpora
and evaluating their performance on downstream tasks. We find that there are
clear differences in quality of the corpora, with MaCoCu and OSCAR obtaining
the best results. However, during the extrinsic evaluation, we actually find
that the CC100 corpus achieves the highest scores. We conclude that, in our
experiments, the quality of the web-crawled corpora does not seem to play a
significant role when training LMs.
|
[
-0.3981366753578186,
-0.30384549498558044,
0.5515694618225098,
0.055578384548425674,
-0.26541081070899963,
0.22360123693943024,
-0.48890212178230286,
-0.7616710066795349,
0.05366906896233559,
0.15395760536193848,
-0.18172620236873627,
-0.6521509289741516,
-0.6458762288093567,
0.43949928879737854,
-0.7803742289543152,
0.8479660153388977,
0.08011527359485626,
0.27045199275016785,
-0.34962359070777893,
-0.12431458383798599,
0.14970731735229492,
-0.8957681655883789,
-0.5108826756477356,
-0.11257816851139069,
0.7283498048782349,
0.08369623124599457,
0.7470411062240601,
0.5941348671913147,
0.7245171070098877,
0.27340811491012573,
-0.3737109303474426,
0.25757402181625366,
-0.6566992998123169,
-0.14118117094039917,
-0.3749745488166809,
-0.44039252400398254,
-0.2539350092411041,
0.2540625035762787,
0.4931241571903229,
0.8990824222564697,
0.043683234602212906,
0.22324812412261963,
0.12203171849250793,
0.6062857508659363,
-0.6534932255744934,
-0.15252265334129333,
-0.5974511504173279,
0.031917352229356766,
-0.059156350791454315,
-0.27754124999046326,
-0.5374530553817749,
-0.23894533514976501,
0.08437870442867279,
-0.46301040053367615,
0.4700286388397217,
0.01409590058028698,
1.0873838663101196,
0.056808292865753174,
-0.27106282114982605,
-0.6220114231109619,
-0.5202902555465698,
0.8906530737876892,
-0.7050468921661377,
0.6085436940193176,
0.5611921548843384,
-0.15915656089782715,
0.05519125983119011,
-0.38438674807548523,
-0.30008766055107117,
-0.30231839418411255,
-0.06970071792602539,
0.1642027199268341,
-0.2857665717601776,
-0.015260904096066952,
-0.14945149421691895,
0.5422631502151489,
-0.6083647012710571,
0.5720065236091614,
-0.5314235091209412,
-0.4407191276550293,
0.3998582363128662,
-0.07263394445180893,
0.3289746940135956,
0.16648836433887482,
-0.29538387060165405,
-0.32198038697242737,
-0.8160431385040283,
0.2571517527103424,
0.7754202485084534,
0.31209999322891235,
0.1049465462565422,
0.47940826416015625,
-0.060731589794158936,
0.4962462782859802,
-0.1268659383058548,
-0.26482656598091125,
0.15841428935527802,
-0.28447383642196655,
-0.05935565382242203,
-0.07993462681770325,
0.947507381439209,
0.02559017948806286,
0.5088744163513184,
-0.46899789571762085,
-0.4581233859062195,
0.4825281500816345,
0.5023400187492371,
-0.660808801651001,
-0.21913044154644012,
0.21121430397033691,
-0.4075436592102051,
-0.31025710701942444,
0.13184738159179688,
-0.24808351695537567,
0.027150137349963188,
-0.36826711893081665,
0.2712456285953522,
-0.43521204590797424,
-0.14813752472400665,
0.09723781794309616,
-0.13046333193778992,
0.02163787931203842,
0.36826634407043457,
-0.8990079164505005,
0.4428878724575043,
0.7764974236488342,
0.719797670841217,
-0.525395393371582,
-0.2186484932899475,
-0.5621660351753235,
-0.31629857420921326,
-0.7641276121139526,
0.955379068851471,
-0.7669599056243896,
-0.24465110898017883,
0.3381648063659668,
0.04444286599755287,
-0.033032920211553574,
-0.6660330295562744,
0.7552093863487244,
-0.6102352142333984,
0.2926299273967743,
-0.3351963460445404,
-0.5138689875602722,
-0.12119022011756897,
0.3403502404689789,
-0.7415221333503723,
1.0908018350601196,
0.20279279351234436,
-0.8031968474388123,
0.5126522183418274,
-0.1895666867494583,
-0.3362644910812378,
-0.10995692014694214,
0.06330952793359756,
-0.12832343578338623,
0.2975239157676697,
0.05250188335776329,
0.6230910420417786,
-0.07490096241235733,
0.09314008057117462,
-0.3938685357570648,
-0.49663472175598145,
0.4864674210548401,
-0.4071674644947052,
0.31247344613075256,
0.20326094329357147,
-0.2076829969882965,
-0.15956464409828186,
-0.8463430404663086,
0.1313435137271881,
-0.32156726717948914,
-0.6011585593223572,
-0.4876478612422943,
0.04538858309388161,
0.22247417271137238,
0.47686243057250977,
0.20606859028339386,
-0.6334730982780457,
-0.1154104471206665,
-0.39137551188468933,
0.5520370006561279,
0.664393424987793,
-0.35769692063331604,
0.4590776264667511,
-0.1463736593723297,
0.604697048664093,
0.00738538010045886,
0.08607930690050125,
0.15040303766727448,
-0.3683767318725586,
-0.8608896732330322,
-0.24790771305561066,
0.5333808064460754,
0.19237849116325378,
-0.3859368860721588,
0.202860027551651,
-0.2591005861759186,
-0.7487877607345581,
-0.8882601857185364,
0.2456216812133789,
0.5101420283317566,
0.004865057300776243,
0.3522421419620514,
-0.5142008662223816,
-0.1314106434583664,
-0.8990813493728638,
-0.11079303920269012,
-0.26054617762565613,
0.05448915809392929,
0.09322190284729004,
0.39131638407707214,
-0.22340553998947144,
0.730940580368042,
0.062388330698013306,
-0.11462157219648361,
-0.20910191535949707,
0.05054774507880211,
-0.12219050526618958,
0.13921935856342316,
0.5335060954093933,
-0.6679048538208008,
-0.233534574508667,
0.037755999714136124,
-0.48099806904792786,
-0.13768665492534637,
0.13952909409999847,
-0.06782729923725128,
0.4882553219795227,
0.27530401945114136,
-0.4562532305717468,
0.06310971081256866,
1.084557056427002,
-0.11860834062099457,
0.4611039161682129,
-0.3210581839084625,
0.12210985273122787,
-0.6435591578483582,
0.2842847406864166,
-0.048380833119153976,
-0.46781203150749207,
-0.5299285054206848,
0.19716189801692963,
0.21249471604824066,
0.06046833470463753,
-0.6860397458076477,
0.5795609354972839,
-0.3976372182369232,
-0.4479208290576935,
-0.23621395230293274,
0.6200140118598938,
0.15111617743968964,
0.30486732721328735,
0.2549506723880768,
0.8488215804100037,
0.19848191738128662,
-0.8129606246948242,
-0.16239137947559357,
-0.012863430194556713,
-0.49852311611175537,
0.25631919503211975,
-0.5422235727310181,
0.22880682349205017,
0.131189227104187,
-0.07504800707101822,
-0.8590845465660095,
0.1338128000497818,
-0.14655360579490662,
-0.7224825024604797,
0.24164733290672302,
0.012088601477444172,
-0.5689563751220703,
-0.1438411921262741,
-0.17254319787025452,
0.07059644162654877,
0.24092157185077667,
-0.4926660358905792,
-0.044032253324985504,
0.4963952302932739,
-0.1501462459564209,
-0.51004558801651,
-0.5940636992454529,
0.07267240434885025,
-0.06570736318826675,
-0.466683566570282,
0.222394660115242,
-0.08458408713340759,
-0.3544355034828186,
0.08541850000619888,
-0.11218098551034927,
-0.11233742535114288,
0.323896586894989,
0.03175417333841324,
0.10577074438333511,
-0.08787515014410019,
0.1710391640663147,
-0.08291807025671005,
-0.024635907262563705,
-0.07879628986120224,
-0.2740781307220459,
0.763724148273468,
-0.18096671998500824,
-0.35649213194847107,
-0.4395332336425781,
0.1950761079788208,
0.22806085646152496,
-0.37132906913757324,
0.8024052381515503,
0.6832484602928162,
-0.14189399778842926,
-0.058672863990068436,
-0.6051586866378784,
-0.014340830035507679,
-0.42652997374534607,
0.13273662328720093,
-0.2936229705810547,
-1.1224651336669922,
0.31712856888771057,
0.20947636663913727,
0.11537310481071472,
0.6853055357933044,
0.6397015452384949,
-0.4424106180667877,
1.0761070251464844,
0.7906776070594788,
-0.17318463325500488,
0.3601777255535126,
-0.4306585490703583,
0.05156201869249344,
-0.7782552242279053,
-0.0645117238163948,
-0.8570680022239685,
-0.19220036268234253,
-0.9204934239387512,
-0.2652280032634735,
0.14039556682109833,
0.10219118744134903,
-0.005782124120742083,
0.48631298542022705,
-0.42587989568710327,
0.1213206946849823,
0.44699856638908386,
-0.15128843486309052,
0.4526199400424957,
0.16907905042171478,
-0.1042819693684578,
0.07454052567481995,
-0.7765793800354004,
-1.0955872535705566,
0.8073849678039551,
0.40811237692832947,
0.7092671990394592,
0.00877205841243267,
0.7531179189682007,
0.28631338477134705,
0.3309161961078644,
-0.836069643497467,
0.36048486828804016,
-0.39243170619010925,
-0.6092597842216492,
-0.1994364857673645,
-0.6610892415046692,
-1.3019813299179077,
0.31199055910110474,
0.02614208683371544,
-0.5160196423530579,
0.312335342168808,
0.1830855756998062,
-0.10501249134540558,
0.2183089703321457,
-0.45048898458480835,
0.6448271870613098,
-0.2368362694978714,
-0.19490736722946167,
-0.4572473168373108,
-0.2584281861782074,
0.04115721210837364,
-0.14589078724384308,
0.615756094455719,
-0.294092059135437,
-0.26716914772987366,
0.9348903298377991,
-0.24533452093601227,
0.6251181364059448,
0.21858730912208557,
-0.341276615858078,
0.344357967376709,
0.28442808985710144,
0.19005735218524933,
-0.13605618476867676,
0.00903551746159792,
0.37726250290870667,
0.43539825081825256,
-0.6060773134231567,
-0.1025291234254837,
0.669283926486969,
-0.9286675453186035,
-0.29568254947662354,
-0.5405706167221069,
0.021836204454302788,
-0.21230950951576233,
0.009555120021104813,
0.3831581771373749,
0.5480538010597229,
-0.3151000738143921,
0.3426772654056549,
0.5714716911315918,
-0.45015618205070496,
0.5277855396270752,
0.5708788633346558,
0.0847739726305008,
-0.2619885504245758,
0.8881925940513611,
0.039849281311035156,
0.7162103652954102,
0.5349555611610413,
0.08964808285236359,
-0.15990392863750458,
-0.5042318105697632,
-0.4208226799964905,
0.30612221360206604,
-0.7089958786964417,
-0.16349905729293823,
-0.8127576112747192,
-0.015856435522437096,
-0.3030490279197693,
-0.022449791431427002,
-0.5915089249610901,
-0.3416750133037567,
-0.48459479212760925,
-0.06046071648597717,
0.1670195311307907,
0.7409183382987976,
-0.0997142642736435,
0.1324692815542221,
-1.0493285655975342,
0.135504350066185,
0.010839719325304031,
0.2323487102985382,
-0.083065465092659,
-0.6913912296295166,
-0.500034749507904,
0.15616710484027863,
-0.1471947282552719,
-0.5368146896362305,
0.5994428992271423,
0.25222575664520264,
0.5447893142700195,
0.4875122606754303,
-0.19790737330913544,
0.4483506381511688,
-0.4974384903907776,
0.8314216136932373,
-0.0012168321991339326,
-0.7949488759040833,
0.24382631480693817,
-0.1645093709230423,
0.10079833120107651,
0.7757658958435059,
0.7425763010978699,
-0.7912885546684265,
-0.6328694224357605,
-0.6326360106468201,
-0.706851601600647,
0.5550767183303833,
0.16997769474983215,
0.3843531906604767,
-0.3744645118713379,
0.09166979044675827,
0.22084186971187592,
0.2573069930076599,
-0.708265483379364,
0.14973890781402588,
0.08908895403146744,
-0.06070201098918915,
-0.06636126339435577,
-0.20805223286151886,
0.14092838764190674,
0.3229033648967743,
0.6682028770446777,
-0.12909343838691711,
0.22049038112163544,
0.2134087234735489,
-0.4900979697704315,
-0.09664691984653473,
0.35231640934944153,
0.3955627381801605,
0.7701064348220825,
-0.18242573738098145,
0.15347011387348175,
-0.015189049765467644,
-0.7032474875450134,
0.14902439713478088,
-0.3971215486526489,
0.06289605051279068,
0.22014570236206055,
0.6436474323272705,
0.5496129989624023,
0.47567319869995117,
-0.8730100393295288,
0.5134070515632629,
-0.19475893676280975,
0.022218646481633186,
-0.2582172453403473,
0.1823643296957016,
0.03890345245599747,
-0.15301324427127838,
0.13365422189235687,
-0.09611640870571136,
0.1934601217508316,
-0.9449453353881836,
-0.22957634925842285,
0.3192426264286041,
-0.5502231121063232,
-0.4421441853046417,
0.2734847068786621,
0.11946485936641693,
-0.23199059069156647,
0.6779384016990662,
-0.34750813245773315,
-0.6390069127082825,
0.39076507091522217,
0.17766961455345154,
0.4020422399044037,
-0.0800246074795723,
0.24961896240711212,
0.22986967861652374,
0.5129097700119019,
-0.2316959649324417,
0.20978575944900513,
0.19416117668151855,
-0.6840215921401978,
-0.5768317580223083,
-1.0267695188522339,
-0.6432240009307861,
0.07871551066637039,
-0.7709107398986816,
0.21153247356414795,
-0.17482012510299683,
-0.18984714150428772,
-0.13522447645664215,
0.2423652857542038,
-1.0251954793930054,
0.47950854897499084,
0.25572508573532104,
1.0258325338363647,
-0.761737048625946,
0.7505103349685669,
0.44938820600509644,
-0.3929985463619232,
-0.5083189010620117,
-0.29913029074668884,
-0.26544642448425293,
-0.6377781629562378,
0.7339653372764587,
0.19271613657474518,
-0.14904819428920746,
-0.18143565952777863,
-0.3667796552181244,
-1.0553662776947021,
0.7286725044250488,
0.35874810814857483,
-0.8086166381835938,
0.0315098911523819,
0.20592652261257172,
0.9467154145240784,
-0.14519894123077393,
0.38673922419548035,
0.3910216987133026,
0.20496055483818054,
-0.30454328656196594,
-1.017492651939392,
-0.5263051986694336,
-0.15867190062999725,
-0.013740764930844307,
0.07315260171890259,
-0.7169244289398193,
0.5507448315620422,
-0.03232318162918091,
-0.477950781583786,
0.15197713673114777,
0.43727442622184753,
0.1279248297214508,
-0.08611234277486801,
0.38310059905052185,
0.5480164289474487,
0.7891114950180054,
-0.18444645404815674,
1.4053704738616943,
-0.4241597056388855,
0.3048921823501587,
0.8877613544464111,
-0.1753596067428589,
1.3482694625854492,
0.156088724732399,
-0.3053992986679077,
0.34638798236846924,
1.0626837015151978,
0.23262105882167816,
0.4134078323841095,
0.280844509601593,
0.1334676295518875,
-0.3639063835144043,
0.06506478786468506,
-0.18976929783821106,
0.5559422373771667,
0.3315121829509735,
-0.44910088181495667,
0.003169318661093712,
-0.037887752056121826,
0.23759444057941437,
0.21274177730083466,
-0.21973630785942078,
0.8472244739532471,
0.19094745814800262,
-0.6806484460830688,
0.6519328951835632,
0.25715094804763794,
0.5896005034446716,
-0.377431184053421,
0.30725815892219543,
-0.5670112371444702,
0.06448622047901154,
-0.19703082740306854,
-0.6207703948020935,
0.04507027193903923,
0.4073902666568756,
-0.14667554199695587,
-0.18183308839797974,
0.36696749925613403,
-0.3917362689971924,
-0.5321521162986755,
0.5954548716545105,
0.5149022936820984,
0.5983073711395264,
-0.2505478262901306,
-0.37220102548599243,
0.30909574031829834,
-0.3547804057598114,
-0.29224953055381775,
0.6485391855239868,
0.5172571539878845,
0.06875677406787872,
0.6810054779052734,
0.8579085469245911,
0.2606179714202881,
-0.011326884850859642,
0.26930567622184753,
0.7894725799560547,
-0.47338512539863586,
-0.17961499094963074,
-0.687695324420929,
0.17894431948661804,
0.01917339116334915,
-0.518596351146698,
0.5768781304359436,
0.7026143074035645,
1.1397812366485596,
0.12514135241508484,
0.4932950735092163,
0.3492427170276642,
0.6381451487541199,
-0.6220663785934448,
0.7027716636657715,
-0.4732101857662201,
0.10231427103281021,
-0.3168359398841858,
-1.2362425327301025,
-0.10344488173723221,
0.7189510464668274,
-0.23050621151924133,
-0.0068513983860611916,
0.8184477090835571,
0.533070981502533,
-0.12595508992671967,
-0.2625441253185272,
0.6018102765083313,
0.08482983708381653,
0.41048842668533325,
0.3019852638244629,
0.9231511950492859,
-0.3594168722629547,
0.7032588124275208,
-0.17366573214530945,
0.05931929126381874,
-0.07537733763456345,
-0.7380121350288391,
-0.7581474184989929,
-0.5790676474571228,
-0.1688140332698822,
-0.07527655363082886,
0.19763000309467316,
0.8944836258888245,
0.6997607350349426,
-0.8374528884887695,
-0.16210219264030457,
0.20093147456645966,
-0.3409724235534668,
-0.07915513962507248,
-0.15170063078403473,
0.5194546580314636,
-0.7669323086738586,
-0.8070991635322571,
0.35262495279312134,
0.31210190057754517,
-0.3261234760284424,
-0.5072657465934753,
-0.02319960668683052,
-0.1185062974691391,
0.09754486382007599,
0.8202275037765503,
-0.14158622920513153,
-0.7545182108879089,
-0.30557170510292053,
0.2689201533794403,
-0.5131224989891052,
0.22978509962558746,
0.6242921352386475,
-0.8437398076057434,
0.23594526946544647,
0.3283274471759796,
0.5828136801719666,
0.358565092086792,
-0.16615396738052368,
0.2903936207294464,
-0.539550244808197,
-0.057014986872673035,
0.26583895087242126,
0.5976231098175049,
0.8213751316070557,
-0.1353714019060135,
0.63858562707901,
-0.05168087035417557,
-0.6030570864677429,
-0.7644053101539612,
-0.225347638130188,
-0.8535510301589966,
-0.17218473553657532,
1.5102652311325073,
-0.41604143381118774,
-0.25120559334754944,
0.07602827996015549,
-0.1054743230342865,
0.12244883924722672,
-0.30972227454185486,
0.8467615246772766,
1.070517897605896,
0.24960972368717194,
-0.09975676983594894,
-0.6780450940132141,
0.44912928342819214,
0.2627682089805603,
-0.8124697208404541,
-0.18295606970787048,
0.36563506722450256,
0.2727823555469513,
0.2998019754886627,
0.29650789499282837,
-0.3019082844257355,
0.26964545249938965,
-0.2713674306869507,
0.1349935680627823,
0.39105311036109924,
-0.41321974992752075,
-0.3188205361366272,
-0.005259797442704439,
0.3467884659767151,
0.21580110490322113
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08688v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08688v1
|
Token Alignment via Character Matching for Subword Completion
| 2024-03-13T16:44:39 | 2024-03-13T16:44:39 |
Ben Athiwaratkun, Shiqi Wang, Mingyue Shang, Yuchen Tian, Zijian Wang, Sujan Kumar Gonugondla, Sanjay Krishna Gouda, Rob Kwiatowski, Ramesh Nallapati, Bing Xiang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Generative models, widely utilized in various applications, can often
struggle with prompts corresponding to partial tokens. This struggle stems from
tokenization, where partial tokens fall out of distribution during inference,
leading to incorrect or nonsensical outputs. This paper examines a technique to
alleviate the tokenization artifact on text completion in generative models,
maintaining performance even in regular non-subword cases. The method, termed
token alignment, involves backtracking to the last complete tokens and ensuring
the model's generation aligns with the prompt. This approach showcases marked
improvement across many partial token scenarios, including nuanced cases like
space-prefix and partial indentation, with only a minor time increase. The
technique and analysis detailed in this paper contribute to the continuous
advancement of generative models in handling partial inputs, bearing relevance
for applications like code completion and text autocompletion.
|
[
0.03453498333692551,
-0.5867021083831787,
0.5781511664390564,
0.03260297700762749,
-0.46723535656929016,
0.37865597009658813,
0.12804710865020752,
-0.17030590772628784,
0.2857673764228821,
0.37719449400901794,
-0.6529272794723511,
-0.5761188864707947,
-0.3690696656703949,
0.29784664511680603,
-0.43522700667381287,
0.9006252288818359,
-0.258304625749588,
-0.06126994267106056,
-0.6085678935050964,
-0.19336555898189545,
-0.9920580983161926,
-0.7367105484008789,
-0.6737241148948669,
-0.40448471903800964,
0.4939073622226715,
0.2206256240606308,
0.8141494989395142,
0.9506840109825134,
0.5877176523208618,
0.22560159862041473,
-0.3297894597053528,
0.22435466945171356,
-0.2653258740901947,
0.1988535374403,
-0.08761860430240631,
-0.5952926874160767,
-0.22677257657051086,
-0.10860848426818848,
0.5719928741455078,
0.6968599557876587,
-0.1214924082159996,
-0.03362850472331047,
0.002193421358242631,
0.3153349757194519,
-0.5109549164772034,
-0.17474597692489624,
-0.5394145250320435,
0.38542184233665466,
-0.64455246925354,
-0.2529195547103882,
-0.48293250799179077,
-0.17815278470516205,
-0.1547912359237671,
-0.7615354061126709,
0.6585148572921753,
0.2932630777359009,
0.9246009588241577,
0.39327436685562134,
-0.2503965198993683,
-0.10518144071102142,
-0.4597732126712799,
0.5531792044639587,
-0.7307757139205933,
0.3036719560623169,
0.17171812057495117,
0.0730154886841774,
-0.3738589584827423,
-0.7238840460777283,
-0.8650559186935425,
-0.05306997895240784,
-0.3566737473011017,
0.2995155155658722,
-0.058074429631233215,
0.38044843077659607,
0.5191043019294739,
0.5564923882484436,
-0.6352511644363403,
0.2816013991832733,
-0.004234496969729662,
-0.5056940317153931,
-0.0017844225512817502,
0.25711795687675476,
0.6501168608665466,
-0.30368369817733765,
-0.5018550157546997,
-0.052124764770269394,
-0.9214965105056763,
-0.1507093757390976,
0.46984416246414185,
0.45977625250816345,
-0.06590759009122849,
1.143747329711914,
0.11657783389091492,
0.8393407464027405,
0.3226991891860962,
0.3267727494239807,
0.2884870171546936,
-0.9451425075531006,
-0.3679041862487793,
0.06774790585041046,
0.48576265573501587,
0.20017971098423004,
0.027587883174419403,
-0.13933691382408142,
-0.17992007732391357,
-0.018022993579506874,
0.24043942987918854,
-0.4224758446216583,
-0.17965202033519745,
0.28378209471702576,
-0.6506995558738708,
-0.0722309798002243,
-0.00875342357903719,
-0.6721361875534058,
-0.7129777669906616,
-0.2911360561847687,
0.19627778232097626,
-0.3923492133617401,
-0.09687741100788116,
-0.261748731136322,
-0.4676402509212494,
0.290918231010437,
0.19675464928150177,
-1.064631700515747,
-0.002623082837089896,
0.9066389203071594,
1.2600494623184204,
-0.2974735200405121,
-0.014002981595695019,
-0.9083811044692993,
0.10964503139257431,
-0.5518631935119629,
0.5148719549179077,
-0.6931018829345703,
-0.4757159650325775,
0.05756903812289238,
-0.17788998782634735,
-0.13560454547405243,
-0.4807398319244385,
0.5851399302482605,
-0.5071722269058228,
0.23757998645305634,
-0.3257814049720764,
-0.8876331448554993,
0.23039127886295319,
0.07857869565486908,
-0.6593297123908997,
1.154759168624878,
0.1300010234117508,
-1.053666591644287,
0.5050128102302551,
-0.520117998123169,
-0.533848226070404,
0.2775992751121521,
-0.282895028591156,
-0.4784683585166931,
0.4926019310951233,
0.32760167121887207,
0.10456862300634384,
-0.11663994938135147,
-0.04674109071493149,
-0.1516212522983551,
-0.6477494835853577,
0.09173498302698135,
-0.1688869297504425,
0.5535756349563599,
0.03376743942499161,
-0.26167023181915283,
0.31970465183258057,
-0.4722481667995453,
-0.09974317252635956,
-0.125194251537323,
-0.1033550426363945,
-0.4847983419895172,
-0.18366563320159912,
0.12432939559221268,
0.05764845758676529,
0.5016559362411499,
-0.6405975222587585,
0.4660966992378235,
-0.5106698274612427,
0.3689481317996979,
0.8179841637611389,
-0.19542568922042847,
0.6256427764892578,
-0.08512178063392639,
0.7939258217811584,
0.24092186987400055,
0.17826491594314575,
-0.40677157044410706,
-0.3516574800014496,
-0.865094780921936,
-0.649910032749176,
1.1198906898498535,
0.5454531908035278,
-1.018072485923767,
0.654678225517273,
-0.2710469365119934,
-0.17894093692302704,
-0.5484054684638977,
-0.06501031666994095,
0.5737045407295227,
0.5602365732192993,
0.29667675495147705,
-0.5133025050163269,
-0.7465989589691162,
-0.6614326238632202,
-0.19138620793819427,
-0.24249078333377838,
-0.12440543621778488,
0.08786517381668091,
0.25958138704299927,
-0.1289411038160324,
1.150664210319519,
-0.31167393922805786,
-0.31732165813446045,
-0.15420088171958923,
0.30229881405830383,
0.21580055356025696,
0.7687546610832214,
0.4579330086708069,
-0.7675076127052307,
-0.3967951834201813,
0.12349048256874084,
-0.535513699054718,
-0.3205350637435913,
-0.3597702085971832,
-0.47169551253318787,
0.2181812822818756,
0.6340546607971191,
-0.8389881253242493,
0.6976935267448425,
0.3809378445148468,
-0.49079135060310364,
0.19546669721603394,
-0.19961121678352356,
-0.005933616776019335,
-1.2446709871292114,
0.3768308460712433,
-0.29043957591056824,
-0.5202741622924805,
-0.3775695264339447,
0.08458668738603592,
0.1515720933675766,
-0.13636955618858337,
0.028660738840699196,
0.6434974074363708,
-0.581416666507721,
-0.16658915579319,
-0.20992307364940643,
0.05006823688745499,
0.09102436900138855,
0.2311064898967743,
-0.028946878388524055,
1.1126925945281982,
0.2683057188987732,
-0.18788574635982513,
0.23991860449314117,
0.363768070936203,
-0.035805292427539825,
0.5319892168045044,
-0.6985673308372498,
0.33496683835983276,
-0.24180422723293304,
0.29407790303230286,
-1.3329699039459229,
-0.009481416083872318,
0.4041798710823059,
-0.37391191720962524,
0.42253100872039795,
-0.3052120506763458,
-0.6766392588615417,
-0.21180297434329987,
-0.15387532114982605,
0.7283102869987488,
0.5529226660728455,
-0.5900284647941589,
0.9195190668106079,
-0.07454121857881546,
-0.23083339631557465,
-0.584567666053772,
-0.4667384922504425,
0.27225932478904724,
-0.21834559738636017,
-0.21624164283275604,
0.7009457349777222,
0.03949844464659691,
0.19176135957241058,
-0.013847357593476772,
-0.1886412799358368,
0.24951164424419403,
-0.029859788715839386,
0.11902520060539246,
0.48233526945114136,
-0.13903087377548218,
-0.0041530984453856945,
0.35302767157554626,
-0.14686381816864014,
-0.582268238067627,
-0.37219154834747314,
0.8164455890655518,
0.6240243315696716,
-0.5530250668525696,
-0.5790103673934937,
0.624768853187561,
0.6763244867324829,
-0.3023143410682678,
0.7448883056640625,
0.22583778202533722,
-0.4652036130428314,
0.24846376478672028,
-0.5502771735191345,
0.05097560957074165,
-0.4180923104286194,
0.27780842781066895,
-0.6159806847572327,
-0.5590432286262512,
0.7639296650886536,
0.19043776392936707,
0.15542075037956238,
0.48517224192619324,
0.33927667140960693,
-0.12300028651952744,
1.1944937705993652,
0.77468341588974,
0.08493716269731522,
0.9391759634017944,
0.1909932792186737,
0.3233347237110138,
-0.9968277215957642,
-0.33720505237579346,
-0.5961865186691284,
-0.2099897414445877,
-0.30813834071159363,
-0.4592946171760559,
-0.03965073823928833,
0.23438233137130737,
0.16708992421627045,
0.5626956224441528,
-0.5057825446128845,
0.4507136642932892,
0.5132527947425842,
-0.07723242789506912,
0.1619212031364441,
0.08011274039745331,
-0.6306187510490417,
-0.19577065110206604,
-0.651170551776886,
-0.23946982622146606,
0.5723710656166077,
0.15190449357032776,
0.44358667731285095,
0.12881794571876526,
0.8285578489303589,
0.44001585245132446,
0.3031098246574402,
-0.664831817150116,
0.22019046545028687,
-0.2318221777677536,
-0.2633471190929413,
-0.1626737415790558,
-0.5675792694091797,
-0.7575652003288269,
0.07072974741458893,
-0.0760699138045311,
-0.4643879234790802,
0.4131518602371216,
0.3203474283218384,
-0.595902144908905,
-0.13428084552288055,
-0.6391394138336182,
0.9740117788314819,
0.052324406802654266,
0.14407145977020264,
0.14606784284114838,
-0.6897314786911011,
-0.045235201716423035,
-0.16692490875720978,
-0.2571117877960205,
0.1907775104045868,
-0.11140561103820801,
0.5959634780883789,
-0.888497531414032,
0.7719029188156128,
-0.28559964895248413,
-0.12470432370901108,
-0.0225811917334795,
-0.05475074425339699,
0.7135888338088989,
-0.34856048226356506,
0.007780992425978184,
0.14180506765842438,
-0.008276708424091339,
-0.6891195774078369,
-0.8575810194015503,
0.34083566069602966,
-0.4315468668937683,
-0.3333112895488739,
-0.4761616885662079,
-0.2849082052707672,
-0.045255549252033234,
0.3061937689781189,
0.6601776480674744,
0.3577582538127899,
0.08637918531894684,
-0.14108791947364807,
0.5797128081321716,
-0.11789008975028992,
0.4856991469860077,
0.022553494200110435,
-0.11585380136966705,
-0.6002627015113831,
0.6262975931167603,
0.13330577313899994,
0.0798230990767479,
0.48130500316619873,
-0.036686189472675323,
-0.8056675791740417,
-0.663969874382019,
-0.7105867862701416,
0.18404936790466309,
-0.8025530576705933,
-0.47708457708358765,
-0.5541543364524841,
-0.15252739191055298,
-0.5190643072128296,
-0.09179683774709702,
0.014944273978471756,
-0.4528621435165405,
-0.49116769433021545,
-0.2606234550476074,
0.23708634078502655,
0.38780492544174194,
0.3018375337123871,
0.3302432596683502,
-0.7696380615234375,
0.17806942760944366,
-0.00803215242922306,
0.1898697316646576,
0.04765404015779495,
-0.5820546746253967,
-0.07262484729290009,
-0.08983583748340607,
-0.077589251101017,
-0.7525232434272766,
0.001671397010795772,
0.16239358484745026,
0.30000168085098267,
0.057743169367313385,
-0.06456310302019119,
1.219338297843933,
-0.6586872935295105,
0.9016619920730591,
0.5639771819114685,
-1.374947190284729,
0.2940313220024109,
-0.19964531064033508,
0.34343838691711426,
0.5846320390701294,
-0.21716400980949402,
-1.0531765222549438,
-0.2795817255973816,
-0.2977733910083771,
-1.0661553144454956,
0.4222492277622223,
0.5296863317489624,
0.32052484154701233,
-0.2536070644855499,
0.7633818984031677,
0.27121639251708984,
0.24175824224948883,
-0.40453213453292847,
-0.1290511041879654,
-0.27779778838157654,
-0.8740002512931824,
0.10775699466466904,
-0.2301693707704544,
0.04265919327735901,
-0.06973052024841309,
0.5887334942817688,
-0.2506830394268036,
0.3486446142196655,
0.21649792790412903,
-0.07641743123531342,
-0.012666849419474602,
-0.19613555073738098,
0.7766186594963074,
0.5553364753723145,
0.4831950068473816,
-0.026300495490431786,
-0.1022081971168518,
-0.4362657368183136,
0.08246614784002304,
0.15230891108512878,
-0.3097173571586609,
0.28330984711647034,
0.4080706238746643,
0.6552858948707581,
-0.046920664608478546,
-0.5678654909133911,
0.7466188669204712,
-0.19439050555229187,
0.3035966753959656,
-0.19856193661689758,
-0.2641463875770569,
-0.3057599365711212,
0.1110089123249054,
0.5373842120170593,
0.23882445693016052,
-0.008178284391760826,
-0.27970510721206665,
0.1423814296722412,
0.5875419974327087,
-0.37509387731552124,
-0.15897688269615173,
0.7832257151603699,
0.1915864646434784,
-0.39803341031074524,
0.8820651173591614,
0.1213071197271347,
-0.5755418539047241,
0.721373975276947,
0.6223359107971191,
1.0557045936584473,
0.2357824295759201,
0.10741735994815826,
-0.000412896421039477,
0.052625179290771484,
-0.1526864767074585,
0.2353646457195282,
-0.24679963290691376,
-0.5248289704322815,
-0.6382744908332825,
-0.6603995561599731,
-0.1991657316684723,
-0.2972811758518219,
-0.4483506381511688,
0.20057730376720428,
-0.3812914788722992,
-0.3912295699119568,
-0.09241802990436554,
-0.23720158636569977,
-0.5367143154144287,
0.17188961803913116,
0.088749460875988,
0.9464308619499207,
-0.9232572317123413,
0.6264532208442688,
0.6167087554931641,
-0.5963433384895325,
-0.6817030310630798,
0.400124192237854,
-0.3548588752746582,
-0.7029754519462585,
0.5557793974876404,
0.12428323924541473,
0.07840734720230103,
0.12626208364963531,
-0.28244999051094055,
-1.0496474504470825,
0.8122020363807678,
0.46859464049339294,
-0.6575647592544556,
-0.2720519006252289,
0.07073502987623215,
0.6232139468193054,
-0.08448803424835205,
0.09038708359003067,
0.3261721432209015,
0.3292180895805359,
0.40918973088264465,
-0.9174720644950867,
0.41497722268104553,
-0.3235057592391968,
0.551712155342102,
0.4726438820362091,
-0.49863067269325256,
0.6049066781997681,
0.28520187735557556,
-0.4573873281478882,
0.9653830528259277,
1.021785855293274,
0.17621776461601257,
0.1524275839328766,
0.43969160318374634,
0.7182966470718384,
1.0135972499847412,
-0.2541565001010895,
0.9127837419509888,
-0.16334040462970734,
0.4445640444755554,
0.9199792146682739,
-0.4162513017654419,
0.5715022087097168,
0.737250566482544,
-0.01902206428349018,
0.4063078761100769,
0.9831852316856384,
0.017195427790284157,
0.6359986662864685,
0.2288375198841095,
-0.1580742448568344,
-0.25816962122917175,
-0.23257623612880707,
-0.19367583096027374,
0.25602465867996216,
0.0026548535097390413,
-0.37222233414649963,
0.10524425655603409,
0.06516886502504349,
-0.13552764058113098,
0.09985429048538208,
-0.14553840458393097,
0.8550220131874084,
-0.1664198487997055,
-0.9289440512657166,
0.2839904725551605,
0.038949284702539444,
0.654861569404602,
-0.2698880136013031,
-0.26732197403907776,
-0.6525304317474365,
-0.10520680993795395,
-0.26930510997772217,
-0.2709662616252899,
0.2652941048145294,
-0.014807578176259995,
-0.4087580740451813,
-0.11318840086460114,
0.2973417043685913,
-0.46037307381629944,
-0.5162010788917542,
-0.05173720791935921,
0.019660979509353638,
-0.07641202956438065,
0.2117961347103119,
-0.45312994718551636,
0.11629530042409897,
-0.19554704427719116,
0.3041633367538452,
0.014306050725281239,
0.4793654978275299,
-0.14800049364566803,
0.0702308639883995,
0.5827733278274536,
-0.0267637912184,
0.37726885080337524,
0.2249940037727356,
0.5926156640052795,
-0.5901930928230286,
-0.44023382663726807,
-1.1565742492675781,
0.41257670521736145,
-0.4276076555252075,
-0.4211638271808624,
0.6588444709777832,
0.7394998669624329,
0.6657170057296753,
0.07638677209615707,
0.7720929384231567,
-0.2509888708591461,
0.22003324329853058,
-0.8244720697402954,
0.40594249963760376,
-0.5599380135536194,
0.07230877131223679,
-0.34127023816108704,
-0.9709685444831848,
-0.5371655225753784,
0.40709948539733887,
-0.0715893879532814,
0.03373422101140022,
0.720461368560791,
0.5650936961174011,
-0.07253644615411758,
-0.24933993816375732,
0.2924870550632477,
-0.12202172726392746,
0.30368268489837646,
0.14420077204704285,
0.8629328608512878,
-0.42552635073661804,
0.20840992033481598,
0.214336097240448,
-0.14036549627780914,
-0.11723969876766205,
-0.8729114532470703,
-0.823032021522522,
-0.5266261696815491,
-0.4164678454399109,
-0.3404943645000458,
0.03323104605078697,
0.8692596554756165,
0.5367900133132935,
-0.7921835780143738,
0.4190601408481598,
-0.5051255226135254,
0.1748010367155075,
-0.3202519714832306,
-0.2349867820739746,
0.4422833025455475,
-0.453495591878891,
-0.8736872673034668,
0.12602145969867706,
0.3674283027648926,
0.364227831363678,
0.024138832464814186,
0.28814730048179626,
-0.015229545533657074,
0.30493515729904175,
0.20645062625408173,
0.2686866819858551,
-0.8305624127388,
-0.44054490327835083,
0.13058164715766907,
-0.1283101588487625,
0.24129198491573334,
1.2566558122634888,
-0.6887613534927368,
0.4606062173843384,
0.7034897804260254,
0.797935426235199,
0.2761407494544983,
0.4510060250759125,
0.8307252526283264,
-1.4456852674484253,
0.08772286027669907,
0.1430479884147644,
0.5082288384437561,
0.6176390051841736,
-0.7183499932289124,
0.27024737000465393,
0.39617493748664856,
-0.20982888340950012,
-0.999251127243042,
0.43105024099349976,
-0.7534437775611877,
-0.07477722316980362,
0.7839456796646118,
-0.22998663783073425,
-0.1907927691936493,
-0.1607593297958374,
-0.5058367848396301,
0.6613680124282837,
-0.16975778341293335,
0.7321981191635132,
0.8524158000946045,
-0.048094701021909714,
-0.028586305677890778,
0.20548294484615326,
0.45360541343688965,
0.8916181921958923,
-0.520770788192749,
0.25929343700408936,
0.4080064594745636,
0.09890802949666977,
0.37599796056747437,
0.6479571461677551,
-0.16909600794315338,
0.26178640127182007,
-0.13582433760166168,
0.004423513077199459,
0.20068475604057312,
-0.13556009531021118,
-0.5077537298202515,
0.02470136620104313,
0.015482211485505104,
-0.5586994886398315
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08664v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08664v2
|
Zero-shot and Few-shot Generation Strategies for Artificial Clinical Records
| 2024-03-13T16:17:09 | 2024-03-14T15:57:59 |
Erlend Frayling, Jake Lever, Graham McDonald
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The challenge of accessing historical patient data for clinical research,
while adhering to privacy regulations, is a significant obstacle in medical
science. An innovative approach to circumvent this issue involves utilising
synthetic medical records that mirror real patient data without compromising
individual privacy. The creation of these synthetic datasets, particularly
without using actual patient data to train Large Language Models (LLMs),
presents a novel solution as gaining access to sensitive patient information to
train models is also a challenge. This study assesses the capability of the
Llama 2 LLM to create synthetic medical records that accurately reflect real
patient information, employing zero-shot and few-shot prompting strategies for
comparison against fine-tuned methodologies that do require sensitive patient
data during training. We focus on generating synthetic narratives for the
History of Present Illness section, utilising data from the MIMIC-IV dataset
for comparison. In this work introduce a novel prompting technique that
leverages a chain-of-thought approach, enhancing the model's ability to
generate more accurate and contextually relevant medical narratives without
prior fine-tuning. Our findings suggest that this chain-of-thought prompted
approach allows the zero-shot model to achieve results on par with those of
fine-tuned models, based on Rouge metrics evaluation.
|
[
0.03313499316573143,
-0.7522485852241516,
0.8480414152145386,
-0.2202826887369156,
-0.2877708971500397,
0.13404758274555206,
0.13227732479572296,
-0.5720521211624146,
0.3476771414279938,
0.4832168221473694,
-0.7978495955467224,
-0.6094204187393188,
-0.16243970394134521,
0.33186978101730347,
-0.42693617939949036,
1.172453761100769,
-0.14312274754047394,
0.22747837007045746,
0.06823709607124329,
-0.17220427095890045,
-0.5052101612091064,
-0.8147577047348022,
-0.3096236288547516,
-0.502314567565918,
0.8746542930603027,
0.2838308811187744,
0.41069480776786804,
0.8708646893501282,
0.37400972843170166,
0.07296726852655411,
0.26635491847991943,
0.4572485685348511,
-0.6539555788040161,
0.38974568247795105,
-0.021851908415555954,
-0.7441622018814087,
-0.6917118430137634,
-0.12239252775907516,
0.48275667428970337,
0.2939188480377197,
0.007660964969545603,
0.32210686802864075,
-0.4316367506980896,
0.4190620481967926,
-0.6198315620422363,
-0.3392784595489502,
-0.7510986328125,
0.456943541765213,
-0.2895798087120056,
-0.57512366771698,
-0.4880036413669586,
-0.2965872585773468,
-0.10334967821836472,
-0.5898131728172302,
0.44903263449668884,
-0.08662024140357971,
0.739871084690094,
0.11889656633138657,
-0.22574695944786072,
-0.29335489869117737,
-0.9197345972061157,
0.40766409039497375,
-0.7445232272148132,
0.0032871069852262735,
0.4338904023170471,
0.42159703373908997,
-0.11562132835388184,
-0.7822272181510925,
-0.7098614573478699,
-0.28525903820991516,
0.12492062896490097,
0.2616833448410034,
-0.16394467651844025,
-0.1312713623046875,
0.32564327120780945,
0.20884107053279877,
-0.6034876704216003,
0.31487685441970825,
-0.3963765799999237,
-0.11117354780435562,
0.6766406297683716,
0.6665144562721252,
0.15508216619491577,
-0.10666555911302567,
-0.3632391691207886,
-0.08747465908527374,
-1.077836513519287,
-0.33199581503868103,
0.19398391246795654,
0.307020366191864,
-0.20866729319095612,
0.7544413208961487,
-0.3597511351108551,
0.3332451581954956,
0.0675131157040596,
-0.4485272467136383,
0.2205268293619156,
-0.27053162455558777,
-0.11756523698568344,
0.34216296672821045,
0.841374933719635,
0.43018651008605957,
0.24976412951946259,
-0.08289960026741028,
-0.000596835685428232,
0.4143819212913513,
0.5303919315338135,
-0.7402437329292297,
-0.014435285702347755,
0.4951864778995514,
-0.36042800545692444,
-0.6373694539070129,
-0.2618674039840698,
-0.6990541219711304,
-0.4885125160217285,
-0.12508833408355713,
0.4557749629020691,
-0.4255473017692566,
-0.1514570564031601,
0.03949202969670296,
0.03954467549920082,
0.2071053832769394,
0.2868076264858246,
-0.7402812242507935,
0.2652646601200104,
0.6639251112937927,
0.9457961916923523,
-0.19280162453651428,
-0.05791240930557251,
-0.5647228360176086,
0.426168829202652,
-0.5786914825439453,
0.6876388192176819,
-0.14471600949764252,
-0.5127525329589844,
0.19282285869121552,
-0.1934841126203537,
0.27790164947509766,
-0.6314671635627747,
0.142406165599823,
-0.07286400347948074,
0.11940112709999084,
-0.15829557180404663,
-0.44174548983573914,
0.17420217394828796,
0.4084841310977936,
-0.3126661777496338,
0.7061827778816223,
0.24698716402053833,
-0.5146629810333252,
0.39213958382606506,
-0.29806727170944214,
-0.4594605267047882,
0.17592979967594147,
-0.710827648639679,
-0.5483136177062988,
0.08348593860864639,
0.18970222771167755,
0.4242115318775177,
-0.23946136236190796,
0.2415095418691635,
-0.12793739140033722,
-0.22899724543094635,
0.31371116638183594,
-0.4436715245246887,
0.36651113629341125,
0.11215785145759583,
-0.2445755898952484,
-0.12698103487491608,
-0.7930092215538025,
0.02148314379155636,
0.44668906927108765,
-0.09145068377256393,
-0.07763639837503433,
-0.34864524006843567,
-0.34546148777008057,
0.1282050460577011,
-0.06792629510164261,
-0.5040802955627441,
0.5362679958343506,
-0.5199447274208069,
0.20012393593788147,
0.5034187436103821,
0.449459433555603,
0.06689698994159698,
-0.8117102384567261,
0.8508569002151489,
0.10130726546049118,
0.2541584372520447,
-0.5850974321365356,
-0.45433542132377625,
-0.670048177242279,
-0.1552632600069046,
0.12499526888132095,
0.6988359093666077,
-0.5029676556587219,
-0.08792378008365631,
-0.18962381780147552,
-0.47358793020248413,
-0.833445131778717,
0.026573482900857925,
0.5375874638557434,
0.9390915632247925,
0.4336441159248352,
-0.33958157896995544,
-0.6788446307182312,
-0.8624247908592224,
0.05843774974346161,
-0.32915377616882324,
-0.14697255194187164,
0.5265359878540039,
0.4675266146659851,
-0.30158531665802,
0.70023113489151,
-0.5064130425453186,
-0.31000179052352905,
-0.3227125406265259,
0.03769424930214882,
0.23165857791900635,
0.3872690200805664,
0.361772358417511,
-0.12054085731506348,
-0.27126631140708923,
0.12512506544589996,
-1.1204274892807007,
0.06162417307496071,
-0.5128954648971558,
-0.11320967972278595,
0.1838071495294571,
0.06352836638689041,
-0.6986820101737976,
0.6358528137207031,
0.08986206352710724,
0.17371231317520142,
0.40929490327835083,
-0.2994467616081238,
0.09372375905513763,
-1.0893774032592773,
0.21712709963321686,
-0.2904268205165863,
-0.29541292786598206,
-0.8916736841201782,
-0.12347476184368134,
-0.004991179797798395,
-0.08962776511907578,
-0.7111619710922241,
0.589322030544281,
-0.27085554599761963,
0.28190675377845764,
-0.08608021587133408,
-0.03583964332938194,
0.0129998242482543,
0.302634060382843,
0.10898357629776001,
0.43287503719329834,
0.5045924782752991,
-0.4461738169193268,
0.2552153766155243,
0.5076021552085876,
-0.0031623945105820894,
0.5763744711875916,
-0.38533011078834534,
0.5854324102401733,
-0.15731056034564972,
0.3164796829223633,
-0.6121423244476318,
-0.6170739531517029,
0.3837485909461975,
-0.427621990442276,
0.41122740507125854,
0.030126692727208138,
-0.42154017090797424,
-0.5130850076675415,
-0.36419224739074707,
0.38411563634872437,
0.8679397106170654,
-0.2615896761417389,
0.10007215291261673,
0.09769551455974579,
-0.05364274978637695,
-0.4169639050960541,
-0.8702832460403442,
0.2877712547779083,
-0.26523569226264954,
-0.2304820567369461,
0.30113139748573303,
0.10221853107213974,
-0.20321767032146454,
-0.3736933767795563,
-0.1183243915438652,
-0.07324600219726562,
-0.28267374634742737,
0.3502765893936157,
0.5348598957061768,
-0.3509405553340912,
0.043113432824611664,
0.3010697066783905,
-0.1281738132238388,
-0.013304261490702629,
-0.015305713750422001,
0.4681429862976074,
0.32588398456573486,
-0.3805815279483795,
-0.8683848977088928,
0.4180630147457123,
0.37481486797332764,
0.23909913003444672,
0.534159243106842,
0.10568661987781525,
-0.4573778212070465,
-0.4259931445121765,
-0.6710931062698364,
-0.43167638778686523,
-0.41227078437805176,
0.0261208675801754,
-0.08588223904371262,
-0.6136701703071594,
0.358822762966156,
-0.18311452865600586,
-0.05802053213119507,
0.06091158092021942,
0.9762977361679077,
-0.16190674901008606,
0.836867094039917,
0.09280028194189072,
0.04947492852807045,
-0.10734668374061584,
-0.2937287986278534,
0.21365933120250702,
-0.6546234488487244,
-0.37811923027038574,
-0.22449229657649994,
-0.18135714530944824,
-0.3637387454509735,
-0.39475515484809875,
0.8098222613334656,
-0.017096122726798058,
-0.22577062249183655,
0.08159945905208588,
-0.532963216304779,
0.3756290674209595,
0.2791059911251068,
0.515345573425293,
0.4679255187511444,
0.05629875138401985,
0.08969201147556305,
0.04870954900979996,
-0.7449288368225098,
-0.6382384300231934,
1.3300518989562988,
0.2844960689544678,
0.767157793045044,
-0.22670738399028778,
0.9235801100730896,
0.287612646818161,
0.19149260222911835,
-0.6904571652412415,
0.3674631714820862,
0.12479168176651001,
-0.5398975610733032,
-0.013329898938536644,
-0.06844659149646759,
-0.9598888754844666,
-0.15889114141464233,
-0.2891457974910736,
-0.6585302352905273,
0.03185323625802994,
0.41958507895469666,
-0.977288007736206,
0.24022702872753143,
-0.3186318874359131,
0.3731844425201416,
-0.3312050700187683,
-0.4601474702358246,
0.09737617522478104,
-0.851032018661499,
0.492351770401001,
-0.32071468234062195,
-0.10827908664941788,
0.08178811520338058,
-0.09522148221731186,
0.2618071436882019,
-0.6373693346977234,
1.0613353252410889,
0.09349767118692398,
-0.019887054339051247,
0.38813960552215576,
0.4396255314350128,
0.5657621026039124,
0.09588254243135452,
-0.06786120682954788,
0.4119710326194763,
0.0048040053807199,
-0.08495695143938065,
-0.4596262574195862,
0.5816041827201843,
-0.5941337943077087,
-0.6737915873527527,
-0.49326491355895996,
-0.5768641829490662,
-0.41859808564186096,
0.000641634629573673,
0.41323211789131165,
0.39542266726493835,
-0.2163238376379013,
-0.14071892201900482,
0.2906855046749115,
-0.41579675674438477,
0.23637229204177856,
0.6794502139091492,
0.07300407439470291,
-0.24992649257183075,
0.6283648014068604,
0.18477760255336761,
0.41333335638046265,
0.23070847988128662,
0.2747737765312195,
-0.12525968253612518,
-0.5012807846069336,
-0.6468352675437927,
0.5015038847923279,
-0.26337718963623047,
-0.5040809512138367,
-0.57129967212677,
-0.4358811676502228,
-0.41921788454055786,
-0.27313342690467834,
-0.30115318298339844,
-0.34100818634033203,
-0.46889618039131165,
-0.2958846986293793,
0.5126124620437622,
0.79912930727005,
-0.04728473722934723,
0.2528488337993622,
-0.7461157441139221,
0.5389730334281921,
-0.0029876981861889362,
0.050145428627729416,
-0.007092747371643782,
-0.45623400807380676,
0.01786191202700138,
0.07776493579149246,
-0.47026941180229187,
-0.9807472825050354,
0.6248546242713928,
0.012048917822539806,
0.28756529092788696,
0.43524909019470215,
0.030993374064564705,
0.9071221351623535,
-0.8845546245574951,
0.8363332152366638,
0.3658149838447571,
-0.5994516015052795,
0.9631627202033997,
-0.5489553213119507,
0.03656211122870445,
0.6180904507637024,
0.4149199426174164,
-0.3330920934677124,
-0.42880335450172424,
-0.6596900820732117,
-0.5095977187156677,
0.5853545665740967,
0.23584727942943573,
0.2587524354457855,
-0.19178253412246704,
0.7995147109031677,
0.37844938039779663,
0.25296279788017273,
-0.4855175018310547,
-0.14260171353816986,
0.01602991856634617,
-0.22605328261852264,
0.2833906412124634,
-0.11873740702867508,
-0.31377145648002625,
-0.11438728123903275,
0.3615630865097046,
-0.11412578076124191,
0.09877701103687286,
0.6060048341751099,
0.32179802656173706,
-0.40785863995552063,
0.11714378744363785,
0.5249556303024292,
0.5571591854095459,
-0.036500509828329086,
0.0887969359755516,
0.41869667172431946,
-0.4467042088508606,
0.3285709321498871,
-0.6002539396286011,
-0.49974796175956726,
0.08373010903596878,
0.47410476207733154,
0.8218495845794678,
-0.1790340393781662,
-0.8276227116584778,
0.4900510013103485,
0.2964126467704773,
-0.23421943187713623,
-0.3289211392402649,
0.39429572224617004,
-0.12686552107334137,
0.1520560085773468,
0.033645134419202805,
-0.1990775465965271,
-0.07323074340820312,
-0.6741206049919128,
0.2985086441040039,
0.2741546034812927,
-0.09475518763065338,
-0.44753074645996094,
0.7796332836151123,
-0.12459293752908707,
-0.5783172845840454,
0.6587595343589783,
0.2175409197807312,
0.08699461817741394,
0.5176305770874023,
1.0043721199035645,
0.5632895231246948,
-0.44582033157348633,
0.44298163056373596,
0.5096251368522644,
0.032923899590969086,
-0.2582671046257019,
0.28818705677986145,
0.04862236604094505,
-0.5317497849464417,
-0.20156191289424896,
-0.29669255018234253,
-0.5646671056747437,
0.4503710865974426,
-0.8225212097167969,
0.39996832609176636,
-0.6629255414009094,
-0.24292749166488647,
-0.15424604713916779,
-0.38208451867103577,
-0.5341718792915344,
0.17523442208766937,
0.30299270153045654,
0.6365931630134583,
-0.6161759495735168,
0.9192441701889038,
-0.032457273453474045,
-0.46703431010246277,
-0.8402402997016907,
-0.05695418268442154,
0.291346937417984,
-1.0991355180740356,
0.3736262023448944,
0.0682668536901474,
0.014266316778957844,
-0.22532640397548676,
-0.46565982699394226,
-0.33826005458831787,
1.1249748468399048,
0.5541500449180603,
-0.9121890068054199,
-0.1918623298406601,
0.608558714389801,
0.8496291041374207,
-0.4197087585926056,
-0.029419438913464546,
0.6066840887069702,
0.05524025857448578,
0.22566813230514526,
-0.8410331010818481,
0.11854997277259827,
-0.07374893873929977,
-0.21927547454833984,
0.0446019284427166,
-0.5621131658554077,
0.6717191934585571,
-0.5053873062133789,
-0.2608315348625183,
0.23772357404232025,
0.17906154692173004,
0.5540279746055603,
0.6688138246536255,
0.03481028228998184,
0.40849021077156067,
0.903710663318634,
0.23668597638607025,
1.3829659223556519,
-0.15071478486061096,
-0.05680727958679199,
1.2132949829101562,
-0.8872506618499756,
0.8136122226715088,
0.4168548882007599,
-0.15219943225383759,
0.47249025106430054,
0.2885393500328064,
-0.15853694081306458,
0.41276246309280396,
0.2818792760372162,
-0.5850710868835449,
-0.15078017115592957,
-0.29083696007728577,
-0.3820722997188568,
0.362476646900177,
0.1894412338733673,
-0.5043668746948242,
-0.02687610127031803,
-0.0845102071762085,
0.2886265516281128,
-0.05063283070921898,
-0.07994498312473297,
0.9968045353889465,
0.2495921403169632,
-0.6564626097679138,
0.7899721264839172,
-0.35359907150268555,
0.1831352561712265,
-0.771435558795929,
-0.2527633011341095,
-0.2923385798931122,
-0.059654805809259415,
-0.17666812241077423,
-0.44084951281547546,
0.13127312064170837,
0.48076990246772766,
-0.0643281638622284,
-0.09305965900421143,
0.4960244596004486,
-0.22718963027000427,
-0.6568237543106079,
-0.07315429300069809,
0.6242383718490601,
0.2805788815021515,
0.27330532670021057,
-0.4206749200820923,
0.04810739681124687,
-0.027466952800750732,
-0.00803836528211832,
0.32956624031066895,
0.2764233946800232,
-0.2809973657131195,
0.49386653304100037,
0.7848620414733887,
0.7095030546188354,
-0.17890465259552002,
0.21887709200382233,
0.6515926122665405,
-0.6736977696418762,
-0.3556782603263855,
-0.9760072827339172,
0.30779415369033813,
0.012244649231433868,
-0.5112181901931763,
0.4482786953449249,
0.6469053030014038,
0.5295880436897278,
-0.06003555282950401,
0.8511272072792053,
0.4538433253765106,
0.8050776124000549,
-0.4311230182647705,
0.6910304427146912,
-0.45005470514297485,
0.1529707908630371,
-0.04440681263804436,
-0.2947780191898346,
-0.5251806378364563,
0.4623260498046875,
0.08255185186862946,
-0.379332959651947,
0.6186261773109436,
1.045788288116455,
0.09283378720283508,
-0.15210196375846863,
0.3680865466594696,
0.5088699460029602,
0.25322839617729187,
0.6838484406471252,
0.7906901836395264,
-0.4041754901409149,
0.16619755327701569,
-0.15012307465076447,
-0.09527154266834259,
0.010556996800005436,
-0.7391049265861511,
-0.925518810749054,
-0.14920221269130707,
-0.23882684111595154,
-0.4679664075374603,
0.3655753433704376,
0.8759323358535767,
0.6513059735298157,
-0.7522658705711365,
-0.07568851113319397,
-0.06682436168193817,
-0.40829846262931824,
0.0026903238613158464,
-0.09855412691831589,
0.42742615938186646,
0.048319362103939056,
-0.32721269130706787,
0.6799502968788147,
0.5812937021255493,
0.35055819153785706,
-0.3167501986026764,
-0.13812850415706635,
0.14203687012195587,
0.227447971701622,
0.3468669056892395,
0.46781471371650696,
-0.7927790880203247,
-0.06363514810800552,
-0.042127568274736404,
-0.14120887219905853,
0.3677927851676941,
0.9554619193077087,
-1.1092313528060913,
0.560669481754303,
0.1414373517036438,
0.4482555091381073,
0.682580292224884,
0.14263659715652466,
0.5435706377029419,
-0.6239591240882874,
0.24041074514389038,
0.5603013634681702,
0.01723899319767952,
0.21604153513908386,
-0.7729306817054749,
0.6187496185302734,
0.01033895555883646,
-0.2934669554233551,
-1.1597834825515747,
0.12606126070022583,
-1.0040127038955688,
-0.06140873208642006,
1.1164214611053467,
-0.002455783076584339,
-0.18900595605373383,
-0.029376976191997528,
-0.35516151785850525,
0.3803328573703766,
-0.1480780839920044,
0.9551898241043091,
0.11747634410858154,
-0.6260233521461487,
0.0906476080417633,
-0.7539082169532776,
0.4196603000164032,
0.2435051053762436,
-0.9166531562805176,
-0.19603747129440308,
0.48689258098602295,
0.18938486278057098,
-0.166259303689003,
0.8643036484718323,
-0.24968793988227844,
0.24838455021381378,
0.06808307766914368,
-0.3242341876029968,
-0.2529154121875763,
-0.3905746638774872,
-0.26477137207984924,
0.13676799833774567,
-0.43776828050613403,
-0.055556461215019226
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15430v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15430v1
|
Distilling Named Entity Recognition Models for Endangered Species from Large Language Models
| 2024-03-13T15:38:55 | 2024-03-13T15:38:55 |
Jesse Atuhurra, Seiveright Cargill Dujohn, Hidetaka Kamigaito, Hiroyuki Shindo, Taro Watanabe
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Natural language processing (NLP) practitioners are leveraging large language
models (LLM) to create structured datasets from semi-structured and
unstructured data sources such as patents, papers, and theses, without having
domain-specific knowledge. At the same time, ecological experts are searching
for a variety of means to preserve biodiversity. To contribute to these
efforts, we focused on endangered species and through in-context learning, we
distilled knowledge from GPT-4. In effect, we created datasets for both named
entity recognition (NER) and relation extraction (RE) via a two-stage process:
1) we generated synthetic data from GPT-4 of four classes of endangered
species, 2) humans verified the factual accuracy of the synthetic data,
resulting in gold data. Eventually, our novel dataset contains a total of 3.6K
sentences, evenly divided between 1.8K NER and 1.8K RE sentences. The
constructed dataset was then used to fine-tune both general BERT and
domain-specific BERT variants, completing the knowledge distillation process
from GPT-4 to BERT, because GPT-4 is resource intensive. Experiments show that
our knowledge transfer approach is effective at creating a NER model suitable
for detecting endangered species from texts.
|
[
-0.4415343105792999,
-0.7613261342048645,
0.6044156551361084,
0.07611948996782303,
-0.4643179476261139,
0.11236286908388138,
-0.36625438928604126,
-0.8048152327537537,
0.16088785231113434,
0.7078182697296143,
-0.27980661392211914,
-0.2658400535583496,
-0.6111164689064026,
0.6984480619430542,
-0.46460965275764465,
1.187730073928833,
0.12833468616008759,
-0.420064777135849,
0.10596070438623428,
-0.07076699286699295,
-0.2656170427799225,
-0.6396991610527039,
-0.6775346994400024,
-0.27104172110557556,
0.6948434710502625,
0.19937880337238312,
0.3885534107685089,
0.720609188079834,
0.5356265902519226,
0.25483018159866333,
-0.5760721564292908,
0.262287437915802,
-0.5641415119171143,
0.09057014435529709,
-0.4685196578502655,
-0.2449333220720291,
-0.29704418778419495,
0.005909556522965431,
0.5709162950515747,
0.6287000179290771,
-0.09932603687047958,
0.026291193440556526,
0.20362725853919983,
0.6208010911941528,
-0.43560877442359924,
0.24370092153549194,
-1.0920298099517822,
-0.043246153742074966,
-0.40622445940971375,
-0.34567904472351074,
-0.45115160942077637,
-0.17442576587200165,
0.7154908776283264,
-0.6421385407447815,
0.21928761899471283,
-0.001518571050837636,
1.0080350637435913,
0.37621188163757324,
-0.416920006275177,
-0.3960215747356415,
-0.8638368248939514,
0.8653496503829956,
-0.8482068777084351,
0.16886365413665771,
0.43225741386413574,
-0.15140707790851593,
-0.5174392461776733,
-0.8326596021652222,
-0.6866771578788757,
-0.13760854303836823,
0.02308710105717182,
-0.18911944329738617,
-0.5124868750572205,
-0.00971902348101139,
0.4802040755748749,
0.3509569764137268,
-0.4237745702266693,
0.1497814953327179,
-0.2839359939098358,
-0.055156409740448,
0.7538970112800598,
-0.31473755836486816,
0.15521012246608734,
-0.3237939476966858,
-0.46484261751174927,
0.03771460801362991,
-0.8453219532966614,
-0.2891066372394562,
0.3783692717552185,
0.5813819766044617,
0.38571012020111084,
0.45770737528800964,
-0.002136880299076438,
0.7023580074310303,
-0.03841491788625717,
-0.08979874849319458,
0.1695508360862732,
-0.15536350011825562,
-0.0780072882771492,
0.23693229258060455,
0.6484763622283936,
0.4096439778804779,
0.3322162330150604,
-0.3051295578479767,
-0.27630141377449036,
-0.29634517431259155,
0.18831968307495117,
-0.7181764245033264,
-0.42524832487106323,
-0.06848164647817612,
-0.3756310045719147,
-0.11368288099765778,
-0.3439527153968811,
-0.9307181239128113,
-0.2970583140850067,
-0.46435976028442383,
0.421953946352005,
-0.44480234384536743,
-0.33830127120018005,
0.09558603912591934,
-0.3276972770690918,
0.1232677772641182,
0.14777955412864685,
-1.0611720085144043,
0.23006126284599304,
0.6151447296142578,
0.953732967376709,
-0.1569640189409256,
-0.11283858120441437,
-0.3226661682128906,
0.2923446595668793,
-0.13185980916023254,
0.8533461689949036,
-0.5752270817756653,
-0.39374732971191406,
-0.37173473834991455,
0.2007914036512375,
0.07753365486860275,
-0.7096982598304749,
0.7766323089599609,
-0.7176576852798462,
0.05041452869772911,
-0.48694732785224915,
-0.6690265536308289,
-0.538565993309021,
0.27191272377967834,
-0.8927591443061829,
0.91372150182724,
-0.06459291279315948,
-1.0085214376449585,
0.5545786023139954,
-0.6868025064468384,
-0.3058112859725952,
0.27484190464019775,
0.1333904266357422,
-0.47937309741973877,
0.03363371640443802,
0.29375356435775757,
0.4005690813064575,
-0.32527974247932434,
0.19400322437286377,
-0.4696952700614929,
-0.005611155182123184,
0.10652824491262436,
-0.3074107766151428,
0.7628993391990662,
0.07913021743297577,
-0.3215506374835968,
-0.4212684631347656,
-0.731525719165802,
-0.15195296704769135,
0.1197168380022049,
-0.598822295665741,
-0.9617739915847778,
0.27960672974586487,
0.015124539844691753,
-0.002573145553469658,
0.07577209174633026,
-0.6621741056442261,
0.2519621253013611,
-0.31952378153800964,
0.8459333181381226,
0.6617797017097473,
0.35721808671951294,
0.1706053763628006,
-0.12687742710113525,
0.20628511905670166,
-0.09739796072244644,
-0.16731324791908264,
0.1569734364748001,
-0.523191511631012,
-0.6865033507347107,
-0.09549688547849655,
0.4060104489326477,
0.33136820793151855,
-0.5708447694778442,
0.5194298624992371,
-0.411237895488739,
-0.39934319257736206,
-0.1511659473180771,
-0.1114606112241745,
0.050642699003219604,
0.6367670893669128,
0.5326496958732605,
-0.24117539823055267,
-0.6840345859527588,
-0.9354800581932068,
-0.2600357234477997,
-0.313834011554718,
0.001333153573796153,
0.27492696046829224,
0.7559497952461243,
-0.34381577372550964,
1.2360682487487793,
-0.4712770879268646,
-0.33885082602500916,
-0.11316242814064026,
0.4162921607494354,
0.12606801092624664,
0.42993059754371643,
0.6655921936035156,
-0.993950366973877,
-0.5258288383483887,
0.036853574216365814,
-0.6933795213699341,
0.04741263389587402,
-0.01603688672184944,
-0.043575286865234375,
0.16201728582382202,
0.2969905734062195,
-0.42565983533859253,
0.14299339056015015,
0.35688865184783936,
0.13311469554901123,
0.26961418986320496,
-0.056510791182518005,
-0.10547230392694473,
-1.2524687051773071,
0.22129224240779877,
0.12256595492362976,
-0.09694556146860123,
-0.6102954149246216,
-0.29992544651031494,
-0.07054272294044495,
0.1585691124200821,
-0.15014547109603882,
0.26885029673576355,
-0.8234512805938721,
-0.1028343141078949,
-0.15090203285217285,
0.05113915726542473,
-0.19079697132110596,
0.19023384153842926,
0.4516043961048126,
0.5974701046943665,
0.40714192390441895,
-0.5648146867752075,
0.26989346742630005,
0.44427767395973206,
-0.210032120347023,
0.359915554523468,
-0.5474005937576294,
0.19910651445388794,
-0.07837343215942383,
0.23892717063426971,
-0.3309076428413391,
-0.2301357388496399,
0.10507012158632278,
-0.04495330527424812,
0.4813774824142456,
-0.5519473552703857,
-0.3684740960597992,
-0.41191914677619934,
-0.011367818340659142,
0.14479219913482666,
0.2219400256872177,
-0.565617561340332,
0.5519774556159973,
0.8381836414337158,
-0.6767721772193909,
-0.6868836879730225,
-0.6842275857925415,
0.5618051290512085,
-0.5995387434959412,
-0.2342344969511032,
0.41507697105407715,
0.03111380711197853,
-0.1011737585067749,
0.3497682213783264,
-0.11572238802909851,
-0.28080102801322937,
0.24895289540290833,
0.012079951353371143,
0.3419992923736572,
-0.19341252744197845,
0.3653212785720825,
-0.03623171150684357,
-0.023806056007742882,
0.028102006763219833,
-0.36681243777275085,
0.31109341979026794,
-0.05477191135287285,
0.0036462927237153053,
-0.17558132112026215,
0.28274181485176086,
0.43949365615844727,
-0.2681821584701538,
0.7489029765129089,
0.22251957654953003,
-0.6777340769767761,
-0.27842575311660767,
-0.3774474859237671,
-0.09717711061239243,
-0.399996817111969,
0.3290553390979767,
-0.26589909195899963,
-1.0929429531097412,
0.3932301700115204,
-0.3291829228401184,
0.245657816529274,
0.6438605785369873,
0.1990921050310135,
0.18407613039016724,
0.6355132460594177,
0.8402839303016663,
-0.3161242604255676,
0.5665858387947083,
-0.25928184390068054,
0.5043380260467529,
-0.8218124508857727,
-0.18314407765865326,
-0.4908554255962372,
-0.27974027395248413,
-0.5835090279579163,
-0.1299412101507187,
0.13100504875183105,
0.15007418394088745,
0.02422185428440571,
0.6960058212280273,
-0.7740894556045532,
0.6810712218284607,
0.45706942677497864,
0.006197224371135235,
0.4890414774417877,
0.1433483511209488,
0.13641414046287537,
-0.11239395290613174,
-0.27850037813186646,
-0.9932510256767273,
1.2330352067947388,
0.22568179666996002,
0.45271122455596924,
0.02532307617366314,
0.9551728367805481,
0.3028031289577484,
0.5338780879974365,
-0.7816009521484375,
0.5426322817802429,
-0.25336137413978577,
-0.7849752902984619,
-0.45607152581214905,
-0.64287930727005,
-0.9962702393531799,
0.029074842110276222,
-0.1710948497056961,
-0.7562426328659058,
0.44866010546684265,
-0.003740383544936776,
-0.5220805406570435,
0.3790881633758545,
-0.7036080956459045,
0.6938311457633972,
-0.3568863570690155,
-0.05231126397848129,
-0.00850605871528387,
-0.6442811489105225,
0.4503760039806366,
-0.6434757113456726,
-0.03896940499544144,
-0.3064393699169159,
-0.18066783249378204,
0.8960891962051392,
-0.21620096266269684,
0.5643417239189148,
-0.022021785378456116,
-0.20887702703475952,
0.35787564516067505,
-0.13868574798107147,
0.5504598021507263,
0.05235666409134865,
-0.33210626244544983,
0.18827013671398163,
-0.15012773871421814,
0.06314802914857864,
-0.2296810746192932,
0.6400666832923889,
-0.6265696287155151,
-0.44176048040390015,
-0.6417540311813354,
-0.3563161790370941,
-0.043055932968854904,
0.4518502950668335,
0.236349955201149,
0.12173642218112946,
-0.4017864167690277,
0.37848758697509766,
0.6262946724891663,
-0.18542172014713287,
0.6140101552009583,
0.76483553647995,
0.3229271471500397,
-0.4317508637905121,
0.768802285194397,
0.4181252717971802,
0.05062185972929001,
0.4686194658279419,
-0.018667973577976227,
-0.48144087195396423,
-0.9321340918540955,
-0.14031632244586945,
0.20976006984710693,
-0.5300661325454712,
-0.36565929651260376,
-1.0529268980026245,
-0.328888863325119,
-0.09062670171260834,
0.23138359189033508,
-0.22500008344650269,
-0.20473213493824005,
-0.7033153772354126,
-0.1993764042854309,
0.6340823173522949,
0.9107453227043152,
-0.31841611862182617,
0.14079223573207855,
-1.0889155864715576,
0.27993157505989075,
0.40771570801734924,
0.22190333902835846,
-0.23311522603034973,
-0.5092068910598755,
-0.020828019827604294,
0.1849576085805893,
-0.27755141258239746,
-0.8953046202659607,
0.7425482273101807,
0.7558141946792603,
0.5963513851165771,
0.3686543405056,
0.3945755064487457,
0.8367857933044434,
-0.5535110831260681,
0.6735525727272034,
-0.07528337836265564,
-0.8033843636512756,
0.4600279927253723,
-0.2760269343852997,
-0.5212786793708801,
0.47231706976890564,
0.6505152583122253,
-0.49464237689971924,
-0.255801796913147,
-0.6052482724189758,
-1.1455188989639282,
0.7934154272079468,
0.3415711522102356,
0.16007164120674133,
-0.16198712587356567,
0.4425239861011505,
0.24280022084712982,
0.22360847890377045,
-0.9960991740226746,
0.04260251671075821,
0.1749792993068695,
-0.024023162201046944,
-0.15378232300281525,
-0.3596276342868805,
-0.0753224715590477,
-0.03553875908255577,
0.7989041209220886,
0.04762471839785576,
-0.0038998390082269907,
0.3030606508255005,
-0.2541176974773407,
-0.09650592505931854,
0.41869786381721497,
0.24165591597557068,
0.39515578746795654,
-0.3519092798233032,
0.37848222255706787,
0.13944397866725922,
-0.5907942652702332,
0.04185604676604271,
0.5606659650802612,
-0.17525000870227814,
0.025116782635450363,
0.35527855157852173,
0.5552113652229309,
0.033577125519514084,
-0.5559945106506348,
0.15169565379619598,
-0.1134769544005394,
-0.08159130811691284,
-0.3286552429199219,
-0.07750652730464935,
0.30206575989723206,
0.3035621643066406,
0.5449997186660767,
0.006397047080099583,
0.36497655510902405,
-0.4545767605304718,
0.43305671215057373,
0.2694896459579468,
0.16720926761627197,
-0.3396987020969391,
0.589073896408081,
0.2507772445678711,
0.04252123460173607,
0.7504725456237793,
-0.24625717103481293,
-0.5873304009437561,
0.4933371841907501,
0.4232868254184723,
1.0091776847839355,
-0.03749259561300278,
0.18678930401802063,
0.601923942565918,
0.3148612678050995,
-0.431257963180542,
0.006439639255404472,
-0.03620060160756111,
-0.768139123916626,
-0.3319758176803589,
-0.9827930927276611,
-0.4268726408481598,
0.5057215094566345,
-0.6903327703475952,
0.13720670342445374,
-0.18314851820468903,
-0.4171378016471863,
0.6201638579368591,
0.047693539410829544,
-0.3118818998336792,
-0.14639614522457123,
0.27628976106643677,
0.7309331893920898,
-1.0760011672973633,
0.6274913549423218,
0.580783486366272,
-0.552517294883728,
-0.9028867483139038,
0.1556025594472885,
-0.1270836740732193,
-0.34868544340133667,
0.7754184603691101,
0.18388281762599945,
0.15011101961135864,
0.2872132956981659,
-0.5280154347419739,
-1.1605541706085205,
0.8526187539100647,
0.659078061580658,
-0.8651083707809448,
0.031162787228822708,
-0.04673059657216072,
0.6857284307479858,
-0.20634247362613678,
-0.1593153476715088,
0.7937688827514648,
0.44797810912132263,
0.13138172030448914,
-1.0273065567016602,
-0.07050302624702454,
-0.27926528453826904,
0.08251623064279556,
0.24833138287067413,
-0.2695246636867523,
0.9035145044326782,
-0.1913602352142334,
-0.5079236030578613,
-0.04546911269426346,
0.49136728048324585,
0.12722158432006836,
0.07121171802282333,
0.6320371031761169,
0.7586655616760254,
0.9495642185211182,
-0.1251092255115509,
0.5276150703430176,
-0.019178587943315506,
0.48016709089279175,
1.3415106534957886,
-0.6528173685073853,
1.1479570865631104,
0.5013865828514099,
-0.3246409595012665,
0.5109288692474365,
1.0356148481369019,
-0.18988706171512604,
0.586514413356781,
0.09359259158372879,
-0.4855089783668518,
-0.1619551181793213,
-0.30083200335502625,
-0.33797532320022583,
0.45689287781715393,
0.4338124096393585,
-0.5120753049850464,
-0.3555128276348114,
-0.07232072949409485,
-0.01872176304459572,
-0.1999133825302124,
-0.057845864444971085,
0.9685297608375549,
0.14013439416885376,
-0.6628708839416504,
0.6172866225242615,
-0.2772883176803589,
0.5558045506477356,
-0.41541656851768494,
-0.20518547296524048,
-0.014070824719965458,
0.23349629342556,
-0.24043279886245728,
-0.9444701671600342,
0.39146706461906433,
0.3496893048286438,
-0.3854917585849762,
-0.2148740291595459,
0.6668720841407776,
-0.6677044630050659,
-0.24685609340667725,
0.3174208700656891,
0.25810378789901733,
0.5698370933532715,
-0.21605311334133148,
-0.5952340960502625,
-0.3493809700012207,
0.1874435842037201,
-0.41298386454582214,
0.13773052394390106,
0.6973068118095398,
-0.20993728935718536,
0.6618406772613525,
0.9003340601921082,
0.31647422909736633,
0.07003825902938843,
-0.08357151597738266,
1.0693495273590088,
-0.49320369958877563,
-0.26542723178863525,
-0.9623802900314331,
0.28024348616600037,
-0.3826747536659241,
-0.1172240749001503,
0.7120841145515442,
0.7705807685852051,
0.7648264765739441,
-0.10128192603588104,
0.8847262263298035,
-0.2545207142829895,
0.7262424826622009,
-0.27048149704933167,
0.6749370694160461,
-0.5298556685447693,
0.26248621940612793,
-0.39724016189575195,
-1.0059131383895874,
-0.3773253560066223,
0.5736691355705261,
-0.3239908516407013,
-0.19405288994312286,
0.47008246183395386,
0.6641854643821716,
-0.001142688444815576,
-0.07621068507432938,
-0.011799603700637817,
0.22717098891735077,
0.41600269079208374,
0.5073243379592896,
0.9112465381622314,
-0.11064127832651138,
0.6380859613418579,
-0.12320714443922043,
-0.155837744474411,
-0.18061436712741852,
-1.2862416505813599,
-0.5767263770103455,
-0.5638797283172607,
-0.4066203832626343,
0.10004326701164246,
0.04058537259697914,
0.8667230010032654,
0.5086869597434998,
-0.9159384369850159,
0.18258272111415863,
-0.3253449499607086,
-0.06518347561359406,
-0.008407396264374256,
-0.17609281837940216,
0.3966122567653656,
-0.019368695095181465,
-0.7051883339881897,
0.3657255470752716,
0.38682588934898376,
0.4434470534324646,
0.14499175548553467,
0.01473764143884182,
-0.31548479199409485,
-0.08163700252771378,
0.5495725870132446,
0.5833056569099426,
-0.7505452632904053,
-0.4277503490447998,
-0.19776210188865662,
0.005259249825030565,
-0.177935391664505,
0.37827011942863464,
-0.5298315286636353,
0.46250519156455994,
0.2735756039619446,
0.5767619609832764,
0.33319470286369324,
0.02829945646226406,
0.5277373790740967,
-0.5144773721694946,
0.021843232214450836,
0.5504333972930908,
0.5277076959609985,
0.5128057599067688,
-0.3237115144729614,
0.7066248059272766,
0.37906062602996826,
-0.7824504971504211,
-1.0644994974136353,
0.05631139501929283,
-1.0712400674819946,
0.04818432405591011,
1.1235761642456055,
-0.4425944685935974,
-0.133671835064888,
-0.3090868294239044,
-0.2508385181427002,
0.3602822721004486,
-0.4616001844406128,
0.8936375379562378,
0.6367882490158081,
-0.08951955288648605,
-0.09371162205934525,
-0.44826066493988037,
0.7278793454170227,
-0.10271064937114716,
-0.9313446879386902,
0.3850767910480499,
0.5493863224983215,
0.5405676960945129,
0.3542613089084625,
0.4976274073123932,
-0.016464807093143463,
-0.2109414041042328,
-0.13355125486850739,
0.2114849090576172,
0.12806247174739838,
-0.14896990358829498,
-0.16796930134296417,
-0.03746723383665085,
0.09038523584604263,
-0.11526355147361755
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08607v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08607v1
|
MedInsight: A Multi-Source Context Augmentation Framework for Generating Patient-Centric Medical Responses using Large Language Models
| 2024-03-13T15:20:30 | 2024-03-13T15:20:30 |
Subash Neupane, Shaswata Mitra, Sudip Mittal, Noorbakhsh Amiri Golilarz, Shahram Rahimi, Amin Amirlatifi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown impressive capabilities in generating
human-like responses. However, their lack of domain-specific knowledge limits
their applicability in healthcare settings, where contextual and comprehensive
responses are vital. To address this challenge and enable the generation of
patient-centric responses that are contextually relevant and comprehensive, we
propose MedInsight:a novel retrieval augmented framework that augments LLM
inputs (prompts) with relevant background information from multiple sources.
MedInsight extracts pertinent details from the patient's medical record or
consultation transcript. It then integrates information from authoritative
medical textbooks and curated web resources based on the patient's health
history and condition. By constructing an augmented context combining the
patient's record with relevant medical knowledge, MedInsight generates
enriched, patient-specific responses tailored for healthcare applications such
as diagnosis, treatment recommendations, or patient education. Experiments on
the MTSamples dataset validate MedInsight's effectiveness in generating
contextually appropriate medical responses. Quantitative evaluation using the
Ragas metric and TruLens for answer similarity and answer correctness
demonstrates the model's efficacy. Furthermore, human evaluation studies
involving Subject Matter Expert (SMEs) confirm MedInsight's utility, with
moderate inter-rater agreement on the relevance and correctness of the
generated responses.
|
[
-0.18816561996936798,
-0.6083716750144958,
0.8960406184196472,
-0.03520208224654198,
-0.26432380080223083,
-0.08879544585943222,
-0.18940487504005432,
-0.5047510266304016,
0.5280943512916565,
0.5332698225975037,
-0.7735540270805359,
-0.3442842960357666,
-0.31235864758491516,
0.1912071853876114,
-0.16833004355430603,
0.8916269540786743,
0.203468918800354,
0.46913328766822815,
-0.4690530002117157,
-0.28006067872047424,
-0.5272612571716309,
-0.48182034492492676,
-0.4618367850780487,
-0.19295410811901093,
0.7387180924415588,
0.6119959354400635,
0.2699774503707886,
0.12089693546295166,
0.7933259010314941,
0.290208637714386,
0.2244480699300766,
0.5774475336074829,
-0.16733558475971222,
0.5455901026725769,
-0.21686747670173645,
-0.20011821389198303,
-0.2986421287059784,
-0.2306988686323166,
0.325676828622818,
0.6793845295906067,
-0.2407521903514862,
0.2182290405035019,
0.0800316259264946,
0.5150772333145142,
-0.6074090600013733,
-0.29764190316200256,
-0.512721061706543,
0.12970255315303802,
-0.011545201763510704,
-0.746910572052002,
-0.3827452063560486,
-0.11938402056694031,
0.48998311161994934,
-0.5971903204917908,
0.039611391723155975,
-0.0021927603520452976,
0.6341122984886169,
0.34562361240386963,
-0.4456782341003418,
-0.06999024003744125,
-0.25243136286735535,
0.6011768579483032,
-0.9183862209320068,
0.29314371943473816,
0.2874869406223297,
0.6135431528091431,
-0.02549663931131363,
-1.003950595855713,
-0.2342708706855774,
-0.1852007955312729,
-0.40545356273651123,
0.4034879207611084,
0.13118118047714233,
-0.04438875615596771,
0.07410918176174164,
0.2916848659515381,
-0.5071853399276733,
-0.11457674950361252,
-0.21573318541049957,
-0.18294578790664673,
0.4152145981788635,
0.4753204584121704,
0.445798397064209,
-0.3951161503791809,
-0.4439779818058014,
0.2028178870677948,
-0.6218729019165039,
-0.1974756270647049,
-0.43062824010849,
0.29945167899131775,
-0.06872659176588058,
0.864213764667511,
-0.13871797919273376,
0.9934926629066467,
0.27244850993156433,
-0.5364769697189331,
0.5281305313110352,
-0.26550567150115967,
-0.27315396070480347,
0.20474514365196228,
0.5596470236778259,
0.6977369785308838,
-0.26385390758514404,
-0.2358095645904541,
-0.06865249574184418,
0.019724341109395027,
0.3267853260040283,
-1.0620814561843872,
0.01391848549246788,
0.6354860663414001,
-0.6147472262382507,
-0.3509936034679413,
-0.14307299256324768,
-0.7112274169921875,
-0.6779058575630188,
-0.48799410462379456,
0.3240404725074768,
-0.6069053411483765,
-0.15357747673988342,
0.07810211926698685,
-0.20781391859054565,
0.03757534176111221,
0.4037855863571167,
-0.5506223440170288,
-0.19137215614318848,
0.4361390173435211,
0.6191050410270691,
-0.23441529273986816,
-0.18464438617229462,
-0.8069872260093689,
0.19703900814056396,
-0.12876708805561066,
0.8202092051506042,
-0.6322122812271118,
-0.2976153790950775,
0.10232996195554733,
0.07564648240804672,
0.11703938245773315,
-0.6289235949516296,
0.38768815994262695,
-0.5089259147644043,
0.5573415160179138,
-0.12227199971675873,
-0.658630907535553,
0.15626658499240875,
0.43149542808532715,
-0.3830917477607727,
0.4981144666671753,
0.3228985369205475,
-0.9942575693130493,
0.5128889083862305,
-0.7030086517333984,
-0.645466685295105,
0.5242100954055786,
-0.707493782043457,
-0.2665853202342987,
0.3282649517059326,
0.4212464690208435,
0.5053967833518982,
-0.3351607322692871,
0.515489399433136,
-0.1520661860704422,
-0.16827082633972168,
0.5257776379585266,
-0.5568076372146606,
0.4327608048915863,
0.2039722055196762,
-0.08871917426586151,
0.30536511540412903,
-0.9479081630706787,
0.13604100048542023,
0.02492658421397209,
-0.36184656620025635,
-0.5011786818504333,
0.061206184327602386,
0.2561573386192322,
0.3819831311702728,
0.19640089571475983,
-0.6697351932525635,
-0.07082414627075195,
-0.6605062484741211,
0.3276605010032654,
0.5546745657920837,
0.3623584508895874,
0.20944051444530487,
-0.19574971497058868,
0.3525635600090027,
0.18899711966514587,
0.28118863701820374,
-0.5290464758872986,
-0.2643226087093353,
-0.12067148089408875,
-0.4474969208240509,
-0.10814467072486877,
0.5023652911186218,
-1.051578164100647,
0.1975022703409195,
-0.26210349798202515,
-0.2171134501695633,
-0.735906183719635,
-0.24521280825138092,
0.21605367958545685,
1.1851005554199219,
0.5047162175178528,
0.02050176076591015,
-0.6365315914154053,
-1.045647382736206,
-0.40903061628341675,
0.17721019685268402,
-0.3963891267776489,
0.8509111404418945,
0.10118720680475235,
-0.6523374319076538,
0.9745835065841675,
-0.749159038066864,
-0.28557050228118896,
-0.13730156421661377,
-0.12425724416971207,
0.23457713425159454,
0.2951599955558777,
0.5626522898674011,
-1.006784439086914,
-0.36823132634162903,
0.1964627504348755,
-0.8106529712677002,
-0.05284006521105766,
0.06943105906248093,
-0.11241082847118378,
-0.14813987910747528,
0.2908017039299011,
-0.28536921739578247,
0.3409148156642914,
0.49135681986808777,
-0.6200903058052063,
0.42764580249786377,
-0.11821384727954865,
0.564063310623169,
-1.805655837059021,
0.525859534740448,
-0.1410192996263504,
-0.40587353706359863,
-0.5854354500770569,
0.08356406539678574,
0.08411569893360138,
-0.5122798681259155,
-0.4445776045322418,
0.7618032693862915,
-0.10302327573299408,
0.11573389172554016,
-0.3580034673213959,
0.10196192562580109,
0.2746352255344391,
0.12850870192050934,
-0.1617760956287384,
1.0155746936798096,
0.4109356105327606,
-0.36832746863365173,
0.3568907678127289,
0.37595778703689575,
-0.40531983971595764,
1.1847368478775024,
-0.6445680856704712,
-0.15255093574523926,
-0.2886465787887573,
0.0050894394516944885,
-0.7332108020782471,
-0.937297523021698,
0.03874831274151802,
-0.5628498196601868,
0.20494680106639862,
0.13262216746807098,
-0.2911648750305176,
-0.46297788619995117,
-0.11418815702199936,
0.5173057317733765,
0.19057776033878326,
-0.6177381277084351,
0.8495553731918335,
0.3003987967967987,
-0.43204227089881897,
-0.5803542733192444,
-0.9629955887794495,
0.28288567066192627,
-0.054077278822660446,
-0.5561531782150269,
0.41677746176719666,
-0.30320557951927185,
-0.13064274191856384,
0.014783830381929874,
0.12901605665683746,
-0.17977142333984375,
-0.11519402265548706,
0.23565034568309784,
0.5635831356048584,
-0.24356909096240997,
0.39783310890197754,
0.26709166169166565,
0.09392831474542618,
0.034319065511226654,
-0.12853756546974182,
0.37235745787620544,
0.2415652722120285,
-0.6603063344955444,
-0.39745521545410156,
0.7661522626876831,
0.8431521654129028,
-0.3614959716796875,
0.6128782629966736,
0.4851688742637634,
-0.4529724717140198,
0.19383803009986877,
-0.7740188241004944,
-0.7215585708618164,
-0.445166677236557,
0.7134253978729248,
-0.30109333992004395,
-1.0846500396728516,
0.39751991629600525,
-0.14313958585262299,
0.15600013732910156,
0.33146926760673523,
0.6118354201316833,
0.12109366059303284,
1.4076155424118042,
0.3583662807941437,
0.11924643069505692,
0.24825233221054077,
0.22668933868408203,
0.05584368854761124,
-0.9873815774917603,
-0.5588685870170593,
-0.24666757881641388,
-0.14061026275157928,
-0.3074151873588562,
-0.12383028119802475,
0.7621595859527588,
-0.5210572481155396,
-0.06909845024347305,
-0.26342713832855225,
-0.6868918538093567,
0.07190489023923874,
0.38766035437583923,
0.7185667157173157,
0.22766120731830597,
0.1902254819869995,
-0.16957442462444305,
-0.27919936180114746,
-0.7036949396133423,
-0.00971654150635004,
0.9567683339118958,
0.18433460593223572,
0.7627903819084167,
0.12469317764043808,
0.4190295338630676,
0.14010968804359436,
0.6769523620605469,
-0.8862362504005432,
0.2048272043466568,
-0.1659686118364334,
-0.6332269310951233,
0.08331505954265594,
-0.6116922497749329,
-0.7628762125968933,
0.19375860691070557,
-0.3376103341579437,
-0.4247210621833801,
0.28909116983413696,
0.14497517049312592,
-0.7544510364532471,
-0.06557498127222061,
-0.6534566879272461,
0.5674723982810974,
-0.33293357491493225,
-0.4728792607784271,
-0.0690656453371048,
-0.7712277770042419,
0.16315048933029175,
-0.15392032265663147,
0.024797851219773293,
0.15991529822349548,
-0.10410959273576736,
0.5050256848335266,
-0.5629060864448547,
0.5831529498100281,
-0.19798842072486877,
0.08685643970966339,
-0.05719905346632004,
-0.22931388020515442,
0.19513431191444397,
0.23729942739009857,
-0.023789336904883385,
-0.39312300086021423,
0.0813349261879921,
-0.31665366888046265,
-0.6258717179298401,
0.9746983647346497,
-0.3684660792350769,
-0.38867104053497314,
-0.21338798105716705,
-0.6079729795455933,
-0.716371476650238,
0.3835048973560333,
0.4055975377559662,
1.0668361186981201,
-0.027486011385917664,
0.1582188904285431,
0.5034856796264648,
-0.4508403539657593,
-0.014111262746155262,
0.8397108316421509,
-0.17734035849571228,
-0.6839805841445923,
0.5011136531829834,
-0.15701746940612793,
0.04785123094916344,
0.29548054933547974,
0.25950029492378235,
-0.20144590735435486,
-0.13857287168502808,
-0.6078459620475769,
0.10318256914615631,
-0.7028201222419739,
-0.5517850518226624,
-0.5123810768127441,
-0.1917528659105301,
-0.24148714542388916,
-0.08032619208097458,
0.020687444135546684,
0.12213580310344696,
-0.2357749193906784,
-0.02857855148613453,
0.5593218207359314,
0.47088250517845154,
0.14169244468212128,
0.14231029152870178,
-0.9938661456108093,
0.27402350306510925,
0.4056490659713745,
0.5016775131225586,
-0.07658499479293823,
-0.4218216836452484,
-0.37516847252845764,
-0.00008050735050346702,
0.09265957772731781,
-1.1030446290969849,
0.3893747925758362,
0.11145665496587753,
0.4744229316711426,
0.5561860203742981,
0.021017886698246002,
0.7845712304115295,
-0.9712204933166504,
0.7561673521995544,
0.47929608821868896,
-0.41007933020591736,
0.7758634686470032,
-0.03393825516104698,
0.452457070350647,
0.8794721364974976,
0.07822249084711075,
-0.4403862953186035,
-0.15045364201068878,
-0.2962569296360016,
-0.9618277549743652,
0.4291668236255646,
-0.21646209061145782,
0.12966760993003845,
-0.1893928498029709,
0.6064700484275818,
0.011318089440464973,
0.2758839428424835,
-0.23235367238521576,
-0.2431180477142334,
0.008278182707726955,
-0.5400820374488831,
0.03417013958096504,
-0.3579210340976715,
-0.4918261766433716,
-0.0989525243639946,
0.43859198689460754,
-0.36638909578323364,
0.2347959578037262,
0.7941532135009766,
0.008082992397248745,
-0.1759309023618698,
0.3069274425506592,
0.5241735577583313,
0.8969431519508362,
-0.280897319316864,
0.14313067495822906,
-0.029166750609874725,
-0.5406274199485779,
-0.12371709942817688,
0.4217236340045929,
0.03299251198768616,
0.21328787505626678,
0.3311524987220764,
0.5654256939888,
0.23916040360927582,
-1.0101838111877441,
0.7631300091743469,
-0.25773394107818604,
0.0842701643705368,
-0.12683610618114471,
-0.3505588173866272,
-0.2002163529396057,
0.22717203199863434,
0.7006010413169861,
0.34469074010849,
0.6933061480522156,
-0.20913834869861603,
0.4661630094051361,
0.46997183561325073,
-0.6648287177085876,
-0.03307882696390152,
0.6140879392623901,
0.3319432735443115,
-0.09643655270338058,
0.39479976892471313,
0.36480528116226196,
-0.3173060417175293,
0.2375868260860443,
0.6293845176696777,
0.6406310200691223,
-0.2742474675178528,
0.03623875975608826,
0.3317823112010956,
-0.18127013742923737,
0.2845284342765808,
0.39236295223236084,
0.06503941118717194,
-0.27235740423202515,
-0.922404944896698,
-0.3584069311618805,
-0.2782992720603943,
0.2636823058128357,
-0.7542779445648193,
-0.003669196739792824,
-0.1431242823600769,
-0.4735964238643646,
-0.009977856650948524,
-0.172259122133255,
-0.6738632917404175,
0.372335284948349,
-0.048084598034620285,
1.0448867082595825,
-0.6391619443893433,
0.4069674015045166,
1.0664303302764893,
-0.40255483984947205,
-0.7809951305389404,
0.10449730604887009,
-0.1345922350883484,
-0.765282928943634,
0.4360181391239166,
0.27791449427604675,
-0.1242409497499466,
-0.2413027435541153,
-0.668007493019104,
-0.601662278175354,
1.0902382135391235,
0.3718993067741394,
-0.5631991028785706,
-0.008182421326637268,
-0.13095606863498688,
0.49372872710227966,
-0.40769216418266296,
0.21029825508594513,
0.22164808213710785,
0.23780684173107147,
0.1080872043967247,
-0.7052656412124634,
0.15970277786254883,
-0.4390113353729248,
-0.1172710508108139,
-0.022345811128616333,
-0.2076316773891449,
0.5681625008583069,
-0.23946461081504822,
-0.11822785437107086,
0.19794633984565735,
0.33459457755088806,
0.5117509961128235,
0.5086656212806702,
0.1719978004693985,
0.46602389216423035,
0.6265766024589539,
0.16929487884044647,
1.3301111459732056,
-0.6173927187919617,
0.08825904130935669,
1.1122733354568481,
-0.2684405446052551,
0.8338583111763,
0.7636595368385315,
0.13227614760398865,
0.5889177322387695,
0.45344460010528564,
0.3917604982852936,
0.7301694750785828,
-0.28300634026527405,
-0.606637716293335,
-0.17925278842449188,
-0.44274216890335083,
-0.6852880120277405,
0.09917785227298737,
0.44172316789627075,
-0.6245463490486145,
-0.06039977818727493,
0.45726579427719116,
0.016583584249019623,
0.049234338104724884,
-0.23326647281646729,
0.9448032975196838,
0.12820808589458466,
-0.7680031657218933,
0.2909924387931824,
-0.09575710445642471,
0.6340675354003906,
-0.7429566383361816,
-0.2012939304113388,
-0.31362393498420715,
0.2644312083721161,
-0.34389397501945496,
-0.7764459252357483,
0.0427992008626461,
-0.008003320544958115,
-0.5145241022109985,
0.34626975655555725,
0.8648767471313477,
-0.4068685472011566,
-0.5147106051445007,
0.0766729786992073,
0.5357397198677063,
-0.12785184383392334,
-0.08621396124362946,
-0.71653813123703,
-0.16278566420078278,
-0.014989274553954601,
-0.1054726168513298,
0.25273606181144714,
0.4766075611114502,
0.38622498512268066,
0.5498918890953064,
0.6933946013450623,
0.2741599380970001,
-0.42899444699287415,
0.33126300573349,
1.0394551753997803,
-0.23467326164245605,
-0.3907746374607086,
-0.7027339339256287,
0.6155336499214172,
-0.49277299642562866,
-0.26299214363098145,
0.7274040579795837,
0.5515536069869995,
0.10702655464410782,
-0.21300117671489716,
0.7441182136535645,
0.09988104552030563,
0.9666824340820312,
-0.29044389724731445,
0.7089502215385437,
-0.9991470575332642,
0.10963782668113708,
-0.10853516310453415,
-0.4342779219150543,
-0.4824862480163574,
0.44677114486694336,
-0.1997770220041275,
-0.013859512284398079,
0.4179905951023102,
0.646411120891571,
-0.17539185285568237,
-0.40416160225868225,
0.3754861056804657,
0.2353709489107132,
0.21914160251617432,
0.4844239354133606,
0.629763126373291,
-0.21248246729373932,
0.1498394012451172,
0.036245197057724,
-0.4917365312576294,
-0.5153695940971375,
-0.576556384563446,
-0.7589001059532166,
-0.4970296323299408,
0.007818341255187988,
-0.46400558948516846,
0.09689339995384216,
1.1440094709396362,
0.9117811322212219,
-0.7951141595840454,
0.35380953550338745,
0.15428605675697327,
-0.4586428999900818,
0.05955206975340843,
-0.3372439742088318,
0.5401065945625305,
-0.40530791878700256,
-0.2931044399738312,
0.5923761129379272,
0.5643102526664734,
-0.13876761496067047,
-0.36828479170799255,
-0.033423859626054764,
0.04587457329034805,
0.06671174615621567,
0.8916262984275818,
-0.000645740597974509,
-0.6414045095443726,
-0.0579787977039814,
0.3370946943759918,
-0.327604204416275,
0.03501424193382263,
0.7554113864898682,
-1.003806471824646,
0.7712737917900085,
0.38305890560150146,
0.8845406770706177,
-0.06959307938814163,
0.1558428257703781,
0.5041115283966064,
-0.862858235836029,
0.1323441118001938,
0.5370773673057556,
0.44304192066192627,
0.5715148448944092,
-0.6010156869888306,
0.1030787006020546,
-0.006418476812541485,
-0.5535095930099487,
-0.7065169811248779,
0.348919153213501,
-0.7593205571174622,
-0.5498083829879761,
0.9503128528594971,
-0.01775859296321869,
-0.2190106362104416,
0.04007243737578392,
-0.6402778625488281,
-0.06446091085672379,
-0.3805789351463318,
0.5880073308944702,
0.027800824493169785,
-0.20582959055900574,
-0.0042162989266216755,
-0.49318206310272217,
0.4674895107746124,
0.5649505257606506,
-0.9940733909606934,
-0.2818925678730011,
0.8093914985656738,
0.3296056091785431,
0.15171927213668823,
0.5726789236068726,
-0.29762905836105347,
0.41420814394950867,
-0.39625248312950134,
-0.23824052512645721,
-0.03409465402364731,
-0.1736937016248703,
-0.10011684149503708,
0.2072669118642807,
0.0320822075009346,
-0.12411846965551376
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08604v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08604v2
|
DevBench: A Comprehensive Benchmark for Software Development
| 2024-03-13T15:13:44 | 2024-03-15T13:23:34 |
Bowen Li, Wenhan Wu, Ziwei Tang, Lin Shi, John Yang, Jinyang Li, Shunyu Yao, Chen Qian, Binyuan Hui, Qicheng Zhang, Zhiyin Yu, He Du, Ping Yang, Dahua Lin, Chao Peng, Kai Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SE
|
Recent advancements in large language models (LLMs) have significantly
enhanced their coding capabilities. However, existing benchmarks predominantly
focused on simplified or isolated aspects of programming, such as single-file
code generation or repository issue debugging, falling short of measuring the
full spectrum of challenges raised by real-world programming activities. To
this end, we propose DevBench, a comprehensive benchmark that evaluates LLMs
across various stages of the software development lifecycle, including software
design, environment setup, implementation, acceptance testing, and unit
testing. DevBench features a wide range of programming languages and domains,
high-quality data collection, and carefully designed and verified metrics for
each task. Empirical studies show that current LLMs, including GPT-4-Turbo,
fail to solve the challenges presented within DevBench. Analyses reveal that
models struggle with understanding the complex structures in the repository,
managing the compilation process, and grasping advanced programming concepts.
Our findings offer actionable insights for the future development of LLMs
toward real-world programming applications. Our benchmark is available at
https://github.com/open-compass/DevBench
|
[
-0.5216963887214661,
-0.3780938386917114,
0.40639686584472656,
0.36713066697120667,
-0.10231731086969376,
0.5300461053848267,
-0.3068607747554779,
-0.4561322033405304,
-0.16747915744781494,
0.3513154983520508,
-0.6026152968406677,
-0.7312839031219482,
-0.20820389688014984,
0.04887760058045387,
-0.5933164954185486,
0.6788645386695862,
-0.15581806004047394,
-0.06168924644589424,
-0.2296905219554901,
0.0019189128652215004,
-0.6250668168067932,
-0.3122779428958893,
-0.29423534870147705,
-0.12153171002864838,
0.21178454160690308,
0.4151955246925354,
0.5304972529411316,
0.618478000164032,
0.7256985306739807,
0.23890109360218048,
0.10416487604379654,
-0.45327410101890564,
-0.48597317934036255,
0.48382696509361267,
-0.048995740711688995,
-0.3130941689014435,
-0.5550975203514099,
0.060152020305395126,
0.444062739610672,
0.7189356088638306,
-0.18822292983531952,
0.6434326767921448,
-0.02823685295879841,
0.6837599277496338,
-0.6495823264122009,
0.13418805599212646,
-0.35154518485069275,
0.16328884661197662,
-0.46026793122291565,
0.2786654829978943,
-0.07250844687223434,
-0.7469912767410278,
-0.27284756302833557,
-0.22109267115592957,
0.29981717467308044,
-0.14430764317512512,
0.6127027273178101,
0.30699849128723145,
-0.21231140196323395,
-0.09106028825044632,
-0.6570735573768616,
0.6886803507804871,
-0.7388292551040649,
0.6567122936248779,
-0.05592234060168266,
0.48296186327934265,
-0.32318517565727234,
-0.767544150352478,
-0.33226877450942993,
-0.3346511125564575,
0.41543933749198914,
-0.015428490936756134,
0.12103717774152756,
-0.09931078553199768,
0.410797655582428,
0.5806944370269775,
-0.7623081207275391,
0.020123716443777084,
-0.42012566328048706,
-0.22105534374713898,
0.433838427066803,
0.26096829771995544,
0.327243834733963,
0.05172464996576309,
-0.19608783721923828,
-0.0674876943230629,
-0.9116696715354919,
-0.15196511149406433,
0.38235023617744446,
0.20235739648342133,
-0.17893266677856445,
0.40927577018737793,
-0.03095201589167118,
0.7943433523178101,
-0.500832736492157,
0.12020758539438248,
0.3245847523212433,
-0.4345557391643524,
0.05259095877408981,
-0.336182564496994,
0.4298368990421295,
0.36605966091156006,
0.28201428055763245,
-0.4490765333175659,
-0.32420819997787476,
0.4397793710231781,
0.41317838430404663,
-0.8540728092193604,
-0.30855849385261536,
0.5001770853996277,
-0.20738357305526733,
-0.47042298316955566,
-0.1779036670923233,
-0.9370772242546082,
-0.7774179577827454,
-0.06475122272968292,
-0.2727467119693756,
0.040456827729940414,
-0.5875266194343567,
-0.18126629292964935,
-0.14120276272296906,
0.6287469267845154,
0.0797000601887703,
-0.4640933871269226,
0.4350810945034027,
1.0984123945236206,
0.934648334980011,
-0.3881584703922272,
-0.3229921758174896,
-0.5338762998580933,
-0.036723487079143524,
-0.5943074822425842,
0.8778693079948425,
-0.3828998804092407,
-0.5565733313560486,
-0.22945155203342438,
-0.21474526822566986,
0.520633339881897,
-0.8710602521896362,
0.2787303328514099,
-0.36130771040916443,
-0.48166292905807495,
-0.0824432224035263,
-0.5033263564109802,
0.22360511124134064,
0.636883020401001,
-0.6969952583312988,
1.121946096420288,
0.501132607460022,
-0.40218648314476013,
0.3897559344768524,
-0.26893407106399536,
-0.22140075266361237,
0.15207593142986298,
-0.3799413740634918,
-0.36518383026123047,
0.338393896818161,
-0.37350308895111084,
0.030742954462766647,
-0.7747880816459656,
0.48791149258613586,
-0.6890558004379272,
-0.5346529483795166,
0.1363675445318222,
0.02650374174118042,
0.5125263929367065,
0.23039616644382477,
-0.4412310719490051,
0.14304226636886597,
-0.916113555431366,
0.4489598870277405,
0.022647639736533165,
-0.48678648471832275,
0.21770673990249634,
-0.0009990623220801353,
0.009186293929815292,
0.28972581028938293,
0.1625271588563919,
-0.691777765750885,
0.2877071499824524,
-0.08293823897838593,
0.5009080171585083,
0.72383713722229,
-0.20187120139598846,
0.1966724693775177,
-0.0064152078703045845,
0.9386408925056458,
-0.2428838461637497,
0.17498531937599182,
-0.07377999275922775,
-0.27735012769699097,
-0.5555804967880249,
-0.11160855740308762,
0.5881157517433167,
0.4590213894844055,
0.01609371416270733,
0.2581871449947357,
-0.23591342568397522,
-0.7054107189178467,
-0.49470236897468567,
0.5121955275535583,
0.4714687168598175,
0.33541861176490784,
0.11816512793302536,
-0.6690809726715088,
-0.5427588224411011,
-0.7882675528526306,
-0.3651029169559479,
-0.23066644370555878,
-0.17182159423828125,
0.10740979760885239,
0.3412380516529083,
-0.2163264900445938,
0.8339473009109497,
-0.4337393343448639,
-0.06933709979057312,
-0.4299227297306061,
0.05927206203341484,
0.17344361543655396,
0.40046367049217224,
0.4699385464191437,
-0.6097909808158875,
-0.2715655267238617,
-0.1500052958726883,
-0.6802068948745728,
-0.3753792643547058,
0.15316596627235413,
-0.051805756986141205,
-0.041880086064338684,
0.6316103339195251,
-0.4296191930770874,
0.2916930019855499,
0.7855199575424194,
-0.2332872599363327,
0.6720739006996155,
0.01811257191002369,
-0.13475988805294037,
-0.5073681473731995,
0.3205762505531311,
-0.34832748770713806,
-0.13678263127803802,
-0.2400234043598175,
0.35176557302474976,
0.45294296741485596,
-0.515468418598175,
-0.253072589635849,
0.4932146966457367,
-0.5411103367805481,
-0.7612754106521606,
-0.05886812508106232,
0.3472815752029419,
0.17308102548122406,
0.0554216206073761,
-0.42366868257522583,
1.0479960441589355,
0.42710644006729126,
-0.3513910472393036,
0.6093186736106873,
-0.10354361683130264,
-0.5647658109664917,
0.43063482642173767,
-0.8415255546569824,
0.2943881154060364,
0.21799518167972565,
0.192509263753891,
-0.8708799481391907,
-0.11331187188625336,
-0.31933486461639404,
-0.2484569251537323,
0.084446981549263,
-0.1852971762418747,
-0.7378236055374146,
-0.7091922760009766,
-0.476929247379303,
0.18429383635520935,
0.5785694122314453,
-0.294106662273407,
0.4395115077495575,
0.37695902585983276,
-0.26372483372688293,
-0.38983073830604553,
-0.7316615581512451,
0.214889794588089,
-0.04322199523448944,
-0.5809682607650757,
0.3099154829978943,
-0.1686144769191742,
-0.36307230591773987,
-0.04243909567594528,
-0.42270153760910034,
-0.15048056840896606,
0.49610793590545654,
0.3555828332901001,
0.17512957751750946,
-0.31703999638557434,
0.1552312672138214,
-0.4271724820137024,
-0.39299431443214417,
0.18691986799240112,
0.007568126544356346,
0.46519219875335693,
-0.2769964933395386,
-0.49047499895095825,
0.11955880373716354,
0.11426639556884766,
0.6100857853889465,
-0.4936525523662567,
0.2930275797843933,
0.258899450302124,
-0.09324304014444351,
-0.39493459463119507,
-0.6027978658676147,
-0.0484401099383831,
-0.42911630868911743,
0.34104257822036743,
-0.6183911561965942,
-0.5699229836463928,
0.7671905755996704,
-0.5490718483924866,
0.28291189670562744,
0.06419771164655685,
0.34490302205085754,
0.31462228298187256,
0.8502212762832642,
0.785049319267273,
-0.1435532122850418,
0.27880483865737915,
-0.1273767352104187,
0.30277684330940247,
-0.7795736789703369,
-0.020335962995886803,
-0.685484766960144,
-0.32733815908432007,
-0.43030408024787903,
-0.45945093035697937,
0.17621861398220062,
0.4877924621105194,
-0.6060696244239807,
0.3434971868991852,
-0.4891514182090759,
0.7431055903434753,
0.19950276613235474,
-0.3909660279750824,
0.44759297370910645,
-0.49130064249038696,
-0.22858700156211853,
-0.04439474642276764,
-0.3549385964870453,
-0.4674942195415497,
1.1548320055007935,
0.30168625712394714,
0.7994483709335327,
0.3195848762989044,
0.7203819751739502,
0.2812248468399048,
0.656223714351654,
-0.4134989380836487,
0.5526852011680603,
0.0718352273106575,
-0.7621739506721497,
0.034789882600307465,
-0.3457844853401184,
-0.6836817264556885,
0.3158261775970459,
0.3203270435333252,
-0.5221590399742126,
-0.07704020291566849,
0.08596014976501465,
-0.27720731496810913,
0.1853829026222229,
-0.7459730505943298,
1.4041935205459595,
-0.522881031036377,
-0.5433298945426941,
-0.23466989398002625,
-0.35501500964164734,
0.3435571491718292,
-0.26342877745628357,
0.3849871754646301,
-0.5411945581436157,
-0.3089689314365387,
0.35581934452056885,
-0.39671123027801514,
0.5562297105789185,
-0.23128356039524078,
-0.18358199298381805,
0.3060881197452545,
0.5355382561683655,
0.41677555441856384,
0.07179133594036102,
-0.44301751255989075,
0.05594998225569725,
-0.05330586060881615,
-0.4042603075504303,
-0.3748951256275177,
0.9522746205329895,
-0.5570455193519592,
-0.4696454703807831,
-0.3904982805252075,
-0.25985634326934814,
-0.4001488983631134,
0.2914368808269501,
-0.17925046384334564,
0.3920283913612366,
-0.5482062101364136,
0.02885330095887184,
0.2627706825733185,
-0.4141921401023865,
0.2878214716911316,
0.7716566324234009,
-0.6137619614601135,
-0.15422262251377106,
0.7246438264846802,
-0.11942468583583832,
0.274183988571167,
-0.3585836589336395,
-0.12434198707342148,
-0.007308855652809143,
-0.7928832769393921,
-0.5690224170684814,
0.012889090925455093,
-0.807593584060669,
-0.45365461707115173,
-0.3239628076553345,
-0.02851785346865654,
-0.1835116595029831,
-0.2282710075378418,
-0.7291586995124817,
-0.22496385872364044,
0.19099844992160797,
-0.14912432432174683,
0.242409348487854,
1.0044926404953003,
0.17383719980716705,
-0.1885266751050949,
-0.959067165851593,
0.36554569005966187,
-0.04003944620490074,
0.8888880610466003,
-0.04305383563041687,
-0.18341736495494843,
0.02234593778848648,
-0.39290881156921387,
-0.5441585779190063,
-0.5675044655799866,
0.10325942933559418,
-0.0320560522377491,
0.5295247435569763,
-0.10559042543172836,
0.028405962511897087,
0.5630089640617371,
-0.29855191707611084,
0.8447710275650024,
-0.15184418857097626,
-0.9646744132041931,
0.6709266304969788,
-0.3317248821258545,
0.5918808579444885,
0.8635075688362122,
-0.09112407267093658,
-0.46153613924980164,
-0.4875270128250122,
-0.3934362828731537,
-0.8716296553611755,
0.3541450500488281,
-0.08595400303602219,
-0.022893376648426056,
0.08984402567148209,
0.2487994283437729,
0.14117953181266785,
0.3282381296157837,
-0.6548431515693665,
0.06503137946128845,
0.09257737547159195,
-0.01836509071290493,
0.040838610380887985,
-0.03381165862083435,
0.033439189195632935,
-0.17683926224708557,
0.20018483698368073,
-0.12395519018173218,
-0.03449656069278717,
-0.32146093249320984,
-0.2975600063800812,
-0.08261013776063919,
0.4246895909309387,
0.47534605860710144,
1.034711241722107,
-0.3184303641319275,
0.15242040157318115,
0.11878874152898788,
-0.41606971621513367,
0.21443471312522888,
0.10426469892263412,
0.15936924517154694,
-0.28043457865715027,
0.3825514316558838,
0.33164340257644653,
0.31231188774108887,
-0.9931658506393433,
0.5384240746498108,
-0.0851089209318161,
0.15613454580307007,
-0.3959825932979584,
0.16022297739982605,
0.42045480012893677,
0.22623039782047272,
0.09372449666261673,
-0.1453147679567337,
0.07940727472305298,
-0.6006278991699219,
0.052879448980093,
0.26456066966056824,
-0.2723469138145447,
-0.3691110610961914,
0.6807982325553894,
0.4946916103363037,
-0.13625681400299072,
0.8650362491607666,
-0.3562360405921936,
-0.3797912001609802,
1.0317435264587402,
0.4577751159667969,
1.0863019227981567,
-0.033732328563928604,
0.0810953825712204,
0.33119097352027893,
0.24540415406227112,
-0.05914352461695671,
0.6405056118965149,
-0.043433163315057755,
-0.2975999414920807,
-0.40606677532196045,
-0.7659668326377869,
-0.7304110527038574,
-0.09204861521720886,
-0.3687640130519867,
0.29026126861572266,
-0.5974523425102234,
-0.14169195294380188,
-0.03148031607270241,
0.02957695908844471,
-0.6616098284721375,
-0.21815653145313263,
0.2857298254966736,
1.1682790517807007,
-0.518560528755188,
0.7947519421577454,
0.6773741841316223,
-0.2793823182582855,
-0.5483443140983582,
-0.18529130518436432,
0.25352147221565247,
-0.5314196348190308,
0.7065770626068115,
0.30389779806137085,
-0.2105342149734497,
0.008823208510875702,
-0.2875416874885559,
-0.8769413232803345,
0.9658234715461731,
0.45589980483055115,
-0.7359994053840637,
0.15696309506893158,
0.20599031448364258,
0.6250307559967041,
-0.3200717568397522,
0.3072640895843506,
0.8368794918060303,
0.6145130395889282,
-0.32113760709762573,
-0.916703462600708,
0.019504031166434288,
-0.34335628151893616,
0.2841334939002991,
0.5324342846870422,
-0.5946398973464966,
1.0397257804870605,
-0.3699418902397156,
-0.2275957465171814,
0.11554217338562012,
0.1435392200946808,
0.3180089592933655,
0.017184335738420486,
0.30960923433303833,
0.48573967814445496,
0.5557081699371338,
-0.34993913769721985,
1.2248505353927612,
-0.7990075349807739,
0.2504924535751343,
0.9718724489212036,
-0.7613930106163025,
0.9182171821594238,
0.20425277948379517,
-0.5095314979553223,
0.583814263343811,
0.6560409069061279,
-0.20758500695228577,
0.27968522906303406,
0.8737509846687317,
-0.07538457959890366,
-0.08918203413486481,
0.003103601513430476,
-0.6243512630462646,
0.21304666996002197,
0.21210287511348724,
0.03129390627145767,
-0.4365019202232361,
-0.13849085569381714,
-0.09065790474414825,
-0.07762335985898972,
-0.1280556470155716,
0.5701692700386047,
0.18494442105293274,
-0.6687514781951904,
0.6813318729400635,
-0.15924200415611267,
0.47341975569725037,
-0.6333051323890686,
0.010391335003077984,
-0.5613545775413513,
0.7028952240943909,
-0.09597219526767731,
-0.986399233341217,
0.25766345858573914,
0.29206666350364685,
0.02844705432653427,
-0.16246360540390015,
0.5087383389472961,
0.027163352817296982,
-0.307691752910614,
0.6280454397201538,
0.6300879120826721,
0.17291025817394257,
-0.13710860908031464,
-0.7079607248306274,
0.7703757882118225,
-0.23394672572612762,
-0.43150460720062256,
0.40593791007995605,
0.36035677790641785,
0.03904521465301514,
0.8283239603042603,
0.34087908267974854,
0.18261262774467468,
0.022663692012429237,
0.2873845398426056,
1.0308752059936523,
-1.035800576210022,
-0.3163835406303406,
-0.7567402720451355,
0.250457227230072,
-0.12274041026830673,
-0.44469720125198364,
0.7205187082290649,
0.7991043329238892,
0.7914037108421326,
0.058201853185892105,
0.7652915716171265,
-0.22627493739128113,
0.5734213590621948,
0.013240702450275421,
0.415489137172699,
-0.3386620879173279,
0.4818253219127655,
-0.27728208899497986,
-1.250839352607727,
-0.4582499563694,
0.22224588692188263,
-0.14712145924568176,
0.20603911578655243,
0.592673122882843,
0.8291863799095154,
0.012922490946948528,
0.0290693249553442,
0.18490959703922272,
0.09473956376314163,
0.4224924147129059,
0.528873085975647,
0.9172787666320801,
-0.10104591399431229,
0.7486964464187622,
-0.22913174331188202,
-0.23145225644111633,
-0.08258479833602905,
-0.9660866260528564,
-0.7173182368278503,
-0.08503007888793945,
-0.39082613587379456,
-0.28054216504096985,
0.11591169983148575,
0.47348272800445557,
0.5340316295623779,
-0.845935583114624,
-0.4790160655975342,
-0.479482501745224,
0.039109718054533005,
-0.3266299366950989,
-0.1787905991077423,
-0.14308135211467743,
-0.5155330300331116,
-0.21575309336185455,
0.3955082595348358,
0.3771117031574249,
-0.055703435093164444,
-0.8014469146728516,
-0.026886962354183197,
0.20037516951560974,
-0.29017481207847595,
0.31037405133247375,
0.4182943105697632,
-0.4434623420238495,
-0.047875743359327316,
0.07517258077859879,
-0.43212389945983887,
0.06376006454229355,
1.0466415882110596,
-0.8567984700202942,
0.4024507701396942,
0.507636547088623,
0.6205112338066101,
0.5159086585044861,
0.0035436770413070917,
0.8402301669120789,
-0.6098182797431946,
0.07134366035461426,
0.2896519601345062,
0.08404523879289627,
0.47276318073272705,
0.07656823843717575,
1.0113939046859741,
-0.1197386234998703,
-0.6362488269805908,
-1.137609601020813,
0.25421109795570374,
-0.5010078549385071,
-0.27956750988960266,
0.7465956807136536,
-0.21844181418418884,
-0.03412576764822006,
-0.24598626792430878,
0.1072627604007721,
-0.1340118944644928,
-0.1707361340522766,
0.540611207485199,
0.8323004841804504,
-0.10867349803447723,
-0.20892514288425446,
-1.0076757669448853,
0.4084365665912628,
0.31881552934646606,
-1.0279616117477417,
0.5860365033149719,
0.5662375092506409,
0.4277266561985016,
0.03297591954469681,
0.5987820029258728,
-0.2687097191810608,
0.33038562536239624,
0.3383398652076721,
0.5629305839538574,
0.0363745242357254,
-0.18173056840896606,
-0.27622660994529724,
0.2489471435546875,
0.6032866835594177,
0.16753046214580536
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08593v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08593v2
|
Call Me When Necessary: LLMs can Efficiently and Faithfully Reason over Structured Environments
| 2024-03-13T14:59:07 | 2024-07-03T15:23:59 |
Sitao Cheng, Ziyuan Zhuang, Yong Xu, Fangkai Yang, Chaoyun Zhang, Xiaoting Qin, Xiang Huang, Ling Chen, Qingwei Lin, Dongmei Zhang, Saravan Rajmohan, Qi Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown potential in reasoning over
structured environments, e.g., knowledge graph and table. Such tasks typically
require multi-hop reasoning, i.e., match natural language utterance with
instances in the environment. Previous methods leverage LLMs to incrementally
build a reasoning path, where the LLMs either invoke tools or pick up schemas
by step-by-step interacting with the environment. We propose
Reasoning-Path-Editing (Readi), a novel framework where LLMs can efficiently
and faithfully reason over structured environments. In Readi, LLMs initially
generate a reasoning path given a query, and edit the path only when necessary.
We instantiate the path on structured environments and provide feedback to edit
the path if anything goes wrong. Experimental results on three KGQA and two
TableQA datasets show the effectiveness of Readi, significantly surpassing
previous LLM-based methods (by 9.1% Hit@1 on WebQSP, 12.4% on MQA-3H and 9.5%
on WTQ), comparable with state-of-the-art fine-tuned methods (67% on CWQ and
74.7% on WebQSP) and substantially boosting the vanilla LLMs (by 14.9% on CWQ).
Our code will be available on https://aka.ms/readi.
|
[
-0.09580124914646149,
-0.8370131850242615,
0.9973279237747192,
0.459973007440567,
-0.0637388825416565,
0.00009594732546247542,
-0.19070562720298767,
-0.5432037115097046,
-0.1700325757265091,
0.48968324065208435,
-0.7778279185295105,
-0.6870845556259155,
-0.10789115726947784,
0.216888427734375,
-0.16653649508953094,
0.3787582218647003,
-0.19014279544353485,
-0.04753617197275162,
-0.4312947392463684,
-0.10626243054866791,
-0.27383723855018616,
-0.2277003675699234,
-0.4507266581058502,
-0.375620037317276,
0.7378456592559814,
0.4281863272190094,
0.7555930614471436,
0.9049779176712036,
0.3239036798477173,
0.39253976941108704,
-0.3289872705936432,
0.7441341876983643,
-0.16570115089416504,
0.6986091136932373,
-0.435381680727005,
-0.38713717460632324,
-0.650761604309082,
-0.056912582367658615,
0.5862627625465393,
0.7309073209762573,
-0.1410350203514099,
-0.0748695656657219,
0.03069264255464077,
0.5121119022369385,
-0.5832010507583618,
0.03794386610388756,
-0.7293493747711182,
0.04140874370932579,
-0.1739353984594345,
-0.4747016727924347,
-0.5571600794792175,
-0.45167502760887146,
-0.11945248395204544,
-0.8022609949111938,
-0.24874021112918854,
0.25423192977905273,
0.5666902661323547,
0.36975932121276855,
-0.5314601063728333,
-0.2593991160392761,
-0.7330256700515747,
0.6207998991012573,
-0.8073515295982361,
0.6553871631622314,
0.1881328672170639,
0.21165134012699127,
-0.5832801461219788,
-0.7979638576507568,
-0.5659492015838623,
-0.1912674903869629,
-0.1566687971353531,
0.020400773733854294,
-0.08020466566085815,
0.11218743026256561,
0.5061798095703125,
0.011783408932387829,
-0.3470250964164734,
-0.03157170116901398,
-0.09277065843343735,
-0.06027887389063835,
0.4692584276199341,
0.3336716592311859,
0.24850988388061523,
-0.1697697788476944,
-0.13970746099948883,
0.2114039957523346,
-0.9285992980003357,
0.05855818837881088,
0.2562037408351898,
0.3002885580062866,
0.3748055398464203,
0.698272705078125,
-0.3954574167728424,
1.0349180698394775,
-0.26664215326309204,
-0.37757760286331177,
-0.046694569289684296,
-0.49504369497299194,
-0.10864488035440445,
-0.05587038770318031,
0.6410050988197327,
0.31652945280075073,
0.30502140522003174,
-0.34535473585128784,
-0.20083890855312347,
-0.10136301070451736,
0.28808754682540894,
-0.7940956354141235,
-0.24892456829547882,
0.5034571886062622,
-0.16939899325370789,
-0.13779877126216888,
-0.24996532499790192,
-0.3794512450695038,
-0.4950577914714813,
-0.5186184048652649,
0.10163313150405884,
-0.6553639769554138,
0.07292009145021439,
0.0992707759141922,
-0.08496616780757904,
0.3512624204158783,
0.7971328496932983,
-0.40639305114746094,
0.08629627525806427,
0.7957412600517273,
1.0464028120040894,
0.08472264558076859,
-0.25792065262794495,
-0.7349093556404114,
0.4756196141242981,
-0.49078452587127686,
1.0993907451629639,
-0.598106861114502,
-0.34004274010658264,
-0.110524982213974,
-0.11908478289842606,
-0.02807583101093769,
-0.41017815470695496,
0.7795323133468628,
-0.4929135739803314,
-0.025037718936800957,
-0.13452103734016418,
-0.6181309223175049,
0.1951996386051178,
0.6580196022987366,
-0.3244769275188446,
0.8808065056800842,
-0.13062624633312225,
-0.6819649934768677,
0.3957495391368866,
-0.8313228487968445,
-0.7407221794128418,
-0.09514567255973816,
0.28078988194465637,
-0.1549096554517746,
-0.3070165514945984,
0.44004473090171814,
0.19012461602687836,
0.25206053256988525,
0.21148870885372162,
-0.5508033037185669,
-0.4046934247016907,
0.17702355980873108,
-0.1979459822177887,
0.8300621509552002,
0.17253926396369934,
-0.21923202276229858,
0.33762723207473755,
-0.7769702076911926,
0.5203485488891602,
-0.0580742321908474,
-0.6588587760925293,
-0.444825142621994,
0.4198530614376068,
-0.2368462085723877,
0.40025702118873596,
0.04776928946375847,
-0.7254409193992615,
0.5457913875579834,
-0.5238539576530457,
0.7876557111740112,
0.8939817547798157,
-0.09830689430236816,
0.38675373792648315,
-0.32177549600601196,
0.4662761092185974,
-0.14143893122673035,
0.17366112768650055,
-0.23239393532276154,
-0.2584806978702545,
-0.8044672608375549,
-0.3281773328781128,
0.06971745938062668,
0.8452879786491394,
-0.6686963438987732,
0.32044175267219543,
-0.2982572019100189,
-0.6875047087669373,
-0.443181574344635,
0.1246546134352684,
0.19383467733860016,
0.6311965584754944,
0.5424229502677917,
0.5898243188858032,
-0.5722811818122864,
-0.558764636516571,
-0.6606738567352295,
-0.23215733468532562,
-0.16333547234535217,
0.6271809935569763,
0.32129383087158203,
-0.4128965139389038,
1.062537431716919,
-0.3924458622932434,
-0.06630117446184158,
-0.1395336091518402,
-0.3462337553501129,
0.32365572452545166,
0.3492407202720642,
-0.05868375673890114,
-0.5127375721931458,
-0.28072282671928406,
-0.08257538080215454,
-0.8322111964225769,
-0.5816487669944763,
-0.20071597397327423,
-0.5491044521331787,
0.04105155169963837,
0.7500461935997009,
-0.8052197098731995,
0.1878490298986435,
0.1495516151189804,
-0.5932255983352661,
0.5330957770347595,
-0.2276349663734436,
0.15800580382347107,
-0.981498658657074,
-0.008315430954098701,
-0.05184702202677727,
-0.622515857219696,
-0.22331269085407257,
0.17640185356140137,
-0.11514631658792496,
0.1525479406118393,
-0.34319862723350525,
0.5750966668128967,
-0.5447836518287659,
-0.0481264665722847,
0.003797629615291953,
0.40069833397865295,
0.28873977065086365,
0.28875812888145447,
0.03919189050793648,
0.6418486833572388,
0.4767908453941345,
-0.7289746403694153,
0.42737796902656555,
0.556545615196228,
-0.4111522138118744,
0.5841302871704102,
-0.7566013932228088,
0.400992751121521,
0.14876899123191833,
0.6450155377388,
-0.6396171450614929,
-0.026746777817606926,
0.3532336950302124,
-0.07547267526388168,
-0.08472094684839249,
-0.31358766555786133,
-0.5433464050292969,
-0.09681818634271622,
-0.16032502055168152,
0.04682852700352669,
0.06165838986635208,
-0.8524834513664246,
0.9823545217514038,
0.05555015057325363,
-0.043385863304138184,
-0.36920562386512756,
-0.6532464027404785,
0.39845404028892517,
-0.1703348606824875,
-1.0083692073822021,
0.5288236737251282,
-0.3086918294429779,
-0.6429047584533691,
-0.018154233694076538,
-0.1584143489599228,
0.0844893828034401,
0.19223131239414215,
0.49124017357826233,
0.22783665359020233,
-0.13185054063796997,
0.03835615515708923,
0.07349444925785065,
-0.11958477646112442,
0.11797486245632172,
-0.4908865690231323,
0.19074948132038116,
-0.35586443543434143,
-0.5032637715339661,
-0.16686809062957764,
0.4049817621707916,
0.5564689636230469,
-0.3512158989906311,
0.5891497731208801,
0.20983728766441345,
-0.37780869007110596,
-0.4740908741950989,
-0.28289228677749634,
-0.042096517980098724,
-0.5257794857025146,
0.05034084618091583,
-0.5674182772636414,
-1.0465638637542725,
0.15226416289806366,
-0.4905484616756439,
0.44763651490211487,
0.05889047682285309,
0.3040005564689636,
-0.4663695693016052,
1.0076565742492676,
0.17287255823612213,
0.3313194215297699,
0.24593764543533325,
-0.04722597822546959,
0.404110848903656,
-0.8774305582046509,
-0.43472230434417725,
-0.5744268298149109,
-0.3527258336544037,
-0.5041379928588867,
-0.49480104446411133,
0.5771309733390808,
0.21343861520290375,
-0.29356345534324646,
0.09998462349176407,
-0.3605731725692749,
0.5686056613922119,
0.4728821814060211,
0.2000274658203125,
0.6657702326774597,
-0.33682891726493835,
-0.3276834189891815,
0.02837374247610569,
-0.65607750415802,
-0.6483567357063293,
0.5862337946891785,
0.13087961077690125,
0.7194097638130188,
0.24308715760707855,
0.6369056105613708,
0.3019370436668396,
0.3530554175376892,
-0.8371737599372864,
0.7827341556549072,
0.2968294024467468,
-0.22349639236927032,
-0.40828683972358704,
-0.6214079260826111,
-0.78707355260849,
0.5027981400489807,
-0.3240228593349457,
-0.6141823530197144,
0.04362327978014946,
0.3594904839992523,
-0.1931893676519394,
0.43792685866355896,
-0.5584689378738403,
0.776058554649353,
-0.2844182550907135,
-0.48739397525787354,
-0.1363661289215088,
-0.5479010343551636,
0.29671257734298706,
0.21902596950531006,
0.3894040882587433,
-0.013446534052491188,
-0.118512824177742,
0.20032058656215668,
-0.8807714581489563,
0.5179961323738098,
-0.10931670665740967,
-0.1387229710817337,
0.3022337257862091,
0.38597166538238525,
0.7692307829856873,
0.24480699002742767,
-0.29324936866760254,
0.0683571845293045,
0.23371124267578125,
-0.21948060393333435,
-0.919714629650116,
0.5793664455413818,
-0.2986505329608917,
-0.811911940574646,
-0.4643971025943756,
-0.5384123921394348,
-0.5809623599052429,
0.20953649282455444,
-0.07972972840070724,
0.5116589665412903,
-0.06641920655965805,
-0.027008945122361183,
0.522824764251709,
0.017324376851320267,
0.3350903391838074,
0.6546371579170227,
-0.40538427233695984,
-0.12246982008218765,
0.571085512638092,
-0.012792143039405346,
0.09622599184513092,
0.2765423059463501,
0.36729636788368225,
-0.324067085981369,
-0.6080442070960999,
-0.5154944062232971,
0.011894193477928638,
-0.7460448741912842,
-0.22583653032779694,
-0.9051470160484314,
-0.14909230172634125,
-0.13386136293411255,
-0.2796376347541809,
-0.1400882750749588,
-0.38977232575416565,
0.02556578814983368,
-0.14413738250732422,
0.4989401400089264,
0.6273856163024902,
-0.13144788146018982,
-0.01624523289501667,
-0.9736461043357849,
0.08406742662191391,
0.29685866832733154,
0.4166830778121948,
-0.3011636734008789,
-0.3733360767364502,
0.03692862391471863,
0.0028430938255041838,
-0.12549513578414917,
-0.8586446642875671,
0.3097541928291321,
0.3900953233242035,
0.4294387400150299,
0.07817254960536957,
0.12983767688274384,
0.923553466796875,
-0.6786486506462097,
0.39045387506484985,
-0.4222085773944855,
-1.0825300216674805,
0.8811381459236145,
-0.525048017501831,
0.46102064847946167,
0.486075222492218,
-0.012813546694815159,
-0.7136446237564087,
-0.6337767243385315,
-0.28417375683784485,
-0.9114626049995422,
0.5323720574378967,
0.15038368105888367,
-0.12668068706989288,
0.0186252873390913,
0.5765088200569153,
-0.23703543841838837,
-0.07947574555873871,
-0.6448168158531189,
0.15516407787799835,
-0.043542925268411636,
0.07555744051933289,
0.4756729006767273,
-0.15174120664596558,
-0.05771777778863907,
-0.4268295168876648,
0.8441335558891296,
-0.3731464147567749,
-0.0009170286357402802,
0.5553129315376282,
-0.16748133301734924,
-0.049822308123111725,
0.6192048192024231,
0.18873444199562073,
1.0235334634780884,
-0.16233018040657043,
0.3403836786746979,
0.28499481081962585,
-0.13585251569747925,
0.1070980578660965,
0.09483606368303299,
-0.27520376443862915,
-0.21883422136306763,
0.6205150485038757,
0.5184560418128967,
0.07698218524456024,
-0.921984851360321,
0.20978832244873047,
-0.08026725053787231,
-0.10631128400564194,
-0.18012350797653198,
0.33721020817756653,
0.3412516415119171,
0.5602976679801941,
-0.23643097281455994,
0.2601577639579773,
0.14822901785373688,
-0.4321461319923401,
0.17532828450202942,
0.29349789023399353,
-0.2532675564289093,
-0.004985312465578318,
0.47779151797294617,
0.2236373871564865,
-0.5071713924407959,
1.034438967704773,
-0.19984209537506104,
-0.5608370900154114,
0.2750462293624878,
0.6688259243965149,
0.49623167514801025,
0.0011632427340373397,
0.14391982555389404,
0.3373410105705261,
0.3415183424949646,
0.08417343348264694,
0.3017529845237732,
-0.05661524459719658,
-0.9384448528289795,
-0.5954740643501282,
-0.6532316207885742,
-0.6338294744491577,
-0.06345150619745255,
-0.16703452169895172,
0.031864192336797714,
-0.5191531777381897,
0.09678910672664642,
-0.051709722727537155,
-0.34056520462036133,
-0.3173312842845917,
0.1056816354393959,
-0.025773877277970314,
1.2348581552505493,
-0.4830324649810791,
0.6994578242301941,
0.8589933514595032,
0.03773152828216553,
-0.8942908644676208,
0.004914227873086929,
0.07028840482234955,
-0.30864259600639343,
0.30450305342674255,
0.1817733496427536,
-0.4650793671607971,
-0.07742337137460709,
-0.7529634237289429,
-0.7332274317741394,
1.1450531482696533,
0.486632764339447,
-0.6868858337402344,
0.09708289057016373,
-0.1369217336177826,
0.46256354451179504,
-0.22199293971061707,
0.15305739641189575,
0.5737672448158264,
0.7656302452087402,
0.18955367803573608,
-0.4888569116592407,
0.12230490148067474,
-0.4095035791397095,
-0.22456476092338562,
0.2212451845407486,
-0.4658418297767639,
0.4261184334754944,
-0.5015883445739746,
-0.16247591376304626,
-0.0625302791595459,
0.6663588285446167,
0.7058733701705933,
0.15132425725460052,
0.8838790655136108,
0.6316316723823547,
1.0014644861221313,
-0.09528020024299622,
1.0363539457321167,
-0.18001563847064972,
-0.08120866119861603,
1.2075904607772827,
-0.45171067118644714,
0.7856831550598145,
0.38627859950065613,
-0.19586895406246185,
0.7538361549377441,
0.8326780200004578,
0.298210084438324,
0.22421862185001373,
0.25917336344718933,
-0.31485122442245483,
-0.8734946250915527,
-0.18844835460186005,
0.046858157962560654,
0.40955522656440735,
0.28293731808662415,
0.056674081832170486,
-0.1946798413991928,
-0.30102279782295227,
0.2584724426269531,
0.22427579760551453,
-0.22927644848823547,
0.5141804218292236,
0.1425653100013733,
-0.7924662232398987,
0.170950785279274,
0.16170823574066162,
0.34545376896858215,
-0.6888530850410461,
-0.3729601800441742,
-0.17426669597625732,
0.202442929148674,
-0.4098450839519501,
-0.9415689706802368,
0.610119104385376,
0.13776472210884094,
-0.12448390573263168,
-0.6169487237930298,
0.8820282816886902,
-0.4053081274032593,
-0.4281415343284607,
0.40529921650886536,
0.7118537425994873,
-0.08452468365430832,
-0.16145382821559906,
-0.6778566241264343,
-0.15794280171394348,
-0.11282089352607727,
-0.44391822814941406,
0.09171675145626068,
0.6217215061187744,
-0.19938990473747253,
1.070017695426941,
1.0246474742889404,
0.041659701615571976,
-0.059948451817035675,
0.18554405868053436,
0.877513587474823,
-0.6873793005943298,
-0.5755121111869812,
-1.0268564224243164,
0.4922376573085785,
-0.19631807506084442,
-0.22672460973262787,
0.6483541131019592,
0.6044384837150574,
0.4537198543548584,
0.2752701938152313,
0.6160931587219238,
0.021603748202323914,
0.4230042099952698,
-0.8716027140617371,
0.5126738548278809,
-0.48758968710899353,
0.35140061378479004,
-0.14585864543914795,
-0.965535044670105,
-0.3544568717479706,
0.628126323223114,
-0.2164442241191864,
0.04715221747756004,
0.696877658367157,
0.9077510833740234,
0.09002450853586197,
0.0221205223351717,
0.048383403569459915,
0.4743797183036804,
0.5016807317733765,
0.4218812584877014,
1.1183135509490967,
0.18658775091171265,
0.6255763173103333,
0.12774358689785004,
-0.144317165017128,
0.3200795650482178,
-1.2240185737609863,
-0.6364772319793701,
-0.11383499950170517,
-0.4149348735809326,
-0.6656852960586548,
0.20889398455619812,
0.8475599884986877,
0.6915888786315918,
-0.4888046681880951,
0.0979965478181839,
-0.25503864884376526,
0.5956826210021973,
-0.3298659920692444,
-0.22475232183933258,
0.23625697195529938,
-0.3085145652294159,
-0.46177229285240173,
1.0394734144210815,
0.6381534337997437,
-0.43416836857795715,
-0.24809707701206207,
-0.10065779089927673,
-0.4572896659374237,
0.34173068404197693,
0.6180877089500427,
0.06650622934103012,
-0.7453041076660156,
-0.4252101182937622,
0.08462820947170258,
-0.217793270945549,
0.2493036389350891,
0.889024019241333,
-0.84698486328125,
0.4211467504501343,
0.5180168747901917,
0.4773080050945282,
0.3605169355869293,
0.08637125790119171,
0.6022012829780579,
-0.6238958835601807,
-0.2738141119480133,
0.24695149064064026,
0.6440138816833496,
0.5050801634788513,
-0.4753226935863495,
0.7206729054450989,
0.29173895716667175,
-0.6693760752677917,
-0.5501409769058228,
0.3275485634803772,
-1.07920241355896,
-0.31838035583496094,
1.4402633905410767,
-0.2989133894443512,
-0.40363189578056335,
-0.25512999296188354,
-0.2524140775203705,
-0.022191084921360016,
-0.183567613363266,
0.4526512920856476,
0.5325987935066223,
-0.2938445806503296,
-0.16065213084220886,
-0.25600871443748474,
0.48796936869621277,
0.06897863000631332,
-1.2723177671432495,
0.2109782099723816,
0.8708322048187256,
0.3896538317203522,
-0.015491417609155178,
0.7127054333686829,
-0.04110288619995117,
-0.060305848717689514,
-0.14822670817375183,
-0.19903738796710968,
-0.4992981553077698,
-0.3324052691459656,
0.07567950338125229,
0.04912491515278816,
0.0030563909094780684,
0.10529450327157974
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08564v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08564v1
|
Non-discrimination Criteria for Generative Language Models
| 2024-03-13T14:19:08 | 2024-03-13T14:19:08 |
Sara Sterlie, Nina Weng, Aasa Feragen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC
|
Within recent years, generative AI, such as large language models, has
undergone rapid development. As these models become increasingly available to
the public, concerns arise about perpetuating and amplifying harmful biases in
applications. Gender stereotypes can be harmful and limiting for the
individuals they target, whether they consist of misrepresentation or
discrimination. Recognizing gender bias as a pervasive societal construct, this
paper studies how to uncover and quantify the presence of gender biases in
generative language models. In particular, we derive generative AI analogues of
three well-known non-discrimination criteria from classification, namely
independence, separation and sufficiency. To demonstrate these criteria in
action, we design prompts for each of the criteria with a focus on occupational
gender stereotype, specifically utilizing the medical test to introduce the
ground truth in the generative AI context. Our results address the presence of
occupational gender bias within such conversational language models.
|
[
-0.1863820105791092,
-0.7185103893280029,
0.5753690004348755,
0.2826659679412842,
0.19668005406856537,
-0.20135068893432617,
0.07791716605424881,
-0.39423996210098267,
-0.1562674641609192,
0.4727623760700226,
-0.3694138824939728,
-0.506243884563446,
-0.7519584894180298,
0.39378103613853455,
-0.6418539881706238,
0.7750564217567444,
0.1434285044670105,
0.14066433906555176,
-0.7489176988601685,
-0.2758135199546814,
-0.571578323841095,
-0.6591341495513916,
-0.23893442749977112,
-0.1780630499124527,
0.06520085781812668,
0.08893245458602905,
0.5716040134429932,
0.35701683163642883,
0.12844932079315186,
0.2792375385761261,
-0.16268357634544373,
-0.1274784803390503,
-0.16588382422924042,
0.3530275821685791,
0.07395109534263611,
-0.8244929313659668,
-0.10117979347705841,
0.3968149721622467,
0.39331451058387756,
0.8837074041366577,
-0.13383188843727112,
0.16226549446582794,
-0.04902388155460358,
0.6237843036651611,
-0.642996609210968,
0.36109909415245056,
-0.48389559984207153,
0.21549415588378906,
-0.40017279982566833,
0.19196593761444092,
-0.4910751283168793,
-0.5778982639312744,
0.07576242834329605,
-0.2659980356693268,
0.731484055519104,
0.05089254677295685,
0.7913997173309326,
0.17577512562274933,
-0.41495561599731445,
-0.20391063392162323,
-0.6442819833755493,
0.8209520578384399,
-0.47185736894607544,
0.6213098168373108,
0.8443054556846619,
0.2477712482213974,
0.1583755910396576,
-0.07395990937948227,
-0.4801539182662964,
-0.6880295276641846,
-0.1412171870470047,
-0.0265288595110178,
-0.35012686252593994,
0.1745368093252182,
0.3785861134529114,
0.35552677512168884,
-0.3713375926017761,
0.2057640701532364,
-0.48470503091812134,
0.06493883579969406,
0.39036333560943604,
-0.06043054535984993,
0.8195129036903381,
-0.12050088495016098,
0.026486167684197426,
0.2107580006122589,
-0.8335599303245544,
-0.5201279520988464,
0.700404703617096,
0.18568822741508484,
-0.4589571952819824,
0.6623373031616211,
0.02884139120578766,
0.5046371221542358,
0.056249286979436874,
-0.014183670282363892,
0.39292898774147034,
-0.008342772722244263,
-0.015728162601590157,
-0.03659554570913315,
0.5661633014678955,
0.3499114215373993,
0.20705369114875793,
-0.32863542437553406,
-0.15191887319087982,
0.4009898602962494,
0.3153083324432373,
-0.43459051847457886,
0.07011721283197403,
0.0766512006521225,
-0.6911347508430481,
-0.3985446095466614,
-0.34317803382873535,
-0.793616771697998,
-0.5992451906204224,
-0.003320305375382304,
-0.11541920155286789,
-0.2541915476322174,
-0.4352491796016693,
-0.3057946562767029,
-0.49257466197013855,
0.15239804983139038,
0.05011351779103279,
-1.1877312660217285,
-0.045815713703632355,
0.5257675647735596,
0.754869818687439,
0.0632045567035675,
0.0702970027923584,
-0.22286735475063324,
-0.15159602463245392,
-0.5948126912117004,
0.6012415289878845,
-0.7169352769851685,
-0.6276108026504517,
-0.09933347254991531,
-0.24226020276546478,
-0.0024123499169945717,
-0.975697934627533,
0.4899156093597412,
-0.11985725909471512,
0.5066751837730408,
-0.1473011076450348,
-0.30550146102905273,
-0.1761808544397354,
0.05111528933048248,
-0.4754878878593445,
0.63027423620224,
0.41417551040649414,
-0.7660456895828247,
0.5967909693717957,
-0.8265926241874695,
-0.48094356060028076,
0.17980602383613586,
-0.8058332204818726,
-0.4682207405567169,
0.257515013217926,
-0.11117894947528839,
-0.006789540871977806,
-0.693633496761322,
0.5139974355697632,
-0.3545645475387573,
0.13253499567508698,
0.07546798139810562,
-0.6539827585220337,
1.1268202066421509,
0.28448137640953064,
-0.4098285734653473,
0.15522994101047516,
-0.40944811701774597,
-0.39932364225387573,
-0.0012343729613348842,
-0.24101606011390686,
-0.5042491555213928,
0.14256004989147186,
-0.1937563270330429,
0.12850356101989746,
-0.1463201493024826,
-0.5147588849067688,
-0.3165673315525055,
-0.29231059551239014,
0.22085444629192352,
0.8965867161750793,
-0.42094525694847107,
0.25038421154022217,
-0.4316840171813965,
0.732042133808136,
0.050140563398599625,
0.25091683864593506,
0.3976368308067322,
-0.6665513515472412,
-0.7063100934028625,
-0.40208062529563904,
0.14682328701019287,
0.4971727430820465,
-1.0107851028442383,
0.7611292004585266,
0.12073270231485367,
-0.42129719257354736,
-0.6360914707183838,
0.23773923516273499,
0.6343986392021179,
0.7049639225006104,
0.078429214656353,
-0.2551574110984802,
-0.6173229217529297,
-1.2835168838500977,
-0.27151918411254883,
-0.5570294857025146,
-0.2529551088809967,
0.34094294905662537,
0.5033355951309204,
-0.20336101949214935,
0.9685230851173401,
-0.20040030777454376,
-0.21772898733615875,
-0.27454903721809387,
0.3584735691547394,
0.07035636901855469,
0.31634533405303955,
0.8443228006362915,
-0.6964370608329773,
-0.04598396643996239,
-0.417351096868515,
-1.263474941253662,
-0.6459895968437195,
0.2221028208732605,
-0.14017902314662933,
0.10536551475524902,
0.38812515139579773,
-0.5647415518760681,
0.6396145820617676,
0.5884537696838379,
-0.5704654455184937,
0.6679450273513794,
-0.028854776173830032,
-0.07653329521417618,
-0.5545462369918823,
0.023165013641119003,
0.408589243888855,
-0.1349382996559143,
-0.6188801527023315,
0.13419218361377716,
-0.27694109082221985,
0.06396666914224625,
-0.33011823892593384,
0.2934819757938385,
-0.3956283628940582,
0.04970329999923706,
-0.1380179077386856,
-0.15026521682739258,
-0.11790044605731964,
-0.17939169704914093,
0.1600462645292282,
0.7876710295677185,
0.7592461705207825,
-0.9083078503608704,
0.012510750442743301,
0.5314570665359497,
-0.45323407649993896,
0.7585897445678711,
-0.6937745213508606,
0.09932844340801239,
-0.7428784370422363,
0.2680298388004303,
-0.5382376909255981,
0.15131038427352905,
0.3491289019584656,
-0.4184911251068115,
-0.3094262182712555,
-0.18616338074207306,
-0.36742377281188965,
-0.19811201095581055,
-0.0187816321849823,
0.6675819158554077,
0.7793270945549011,
-0.48637181520462036,
0.38257500529289246,
0.5122390389442444,
0.0783219262957573,
-0.31612810492515564,
-0.719260036945343,
-0.2591097056865692,
-0.38336601853370667,
-0.41646191477775574,
0.16757352650165558,
0.0887039378285408,
-0.7049882411956787,
-0.304174542427063,
-0.0022434249985963106,
-0.01692945323884487,
0.17163172364234924,
0.3762373626232147,
0.5359440445899963,
0.030686115846037865,
0.04645026847720146,
-0.043304283171892166,
-0.12350565940141678,
0.08677367120981216,
0.1659291535615921,
0.48867806792259216,
0.24584698677062988,
-0.4170636236667633,
-0.19432789087295532,
0.4733086824417114,
0.719121515750885,
-0.10337206721305847,
0.7963238954544067,
0.43074363470077515,
-0.3991713225841522,
0.09436960518360138,
-0.5452348589897156,
-0.22319911420345306,
-0.4406192898750305,
0.414692223072052,
0.018311215564608574,
-0.7613845467567444,
0.22720272839069366,
0.2769220173358917,
0.06621409207582474,
0.4337535798549652,
0.6304433941841125,
0.1530904918909073,
1.2076321840286255,
0.4230235517024994,
-0.03369433432817459,
0.4804833233356476,
0.3030585050582886,
0.3865082859992981,
-0.8513725996017456,
-0.20553003251552582,
-0.8661932349205017,
0.1806328296661377,
-0.8423088192939758,
-0.2948992848396301,
0.5617626309394836,
-0.1002507135272026,
-0.22187797725200653,
-0.015913568437099457,
-0.40343746542930603,
0.38262850046157837,
0.5203624963760376,
-0.16078051924705505,
-0.07094947248697281,
-0.19732306897640228,
-0.14748992025852203,
-0.056928567588329315,
-0.48806819319725037,
-0.551102340221405,
0.9479984045028687,
0.4432617127895355,
0.5284755229949951,
0.43813464045524597,
0.4468183219432831,
0.6580310463905334,
0.7307376861572266,
-0.3319908380508423,
0.5011071562767029,
-0.583659827709198,
-1.1561306715011597,
-0.06784437596797943,
-0.7298619747161865,
-0.8413218855857849,
0.31541264057159424,
-0.28870517015457153,
-0.8554561138153076,
0.48277848958969116,
0.0532381497323513,
0.07646394520998001,
0.20299549400806427,
-0.6392589807510376,
0.6358213424682617,
-0.2885386347770691,
-0.10711468756198883,
0.08797312527894974,
-0.3148101270198822,
0.6204172968864441,
0.13083188235759735,
0.35293519496917725,
-0.5647144317626953,
0.44100862741470337,
0.5385575890541077,
-0.5002482533454895,
1.1049665212631226,
-0.4609558582305908,
-0.19706417620182037,
0.16971538960933685,
0.02611229196190834,
0.13508687913417816,
-0.2715829014778137,
-0.2432405799627304,
0.5382370948791504,
-0.2778688967227936,
-0.3390435576438904,
-0.15323786437511444,
0.12137826532125473,
-0.796082079410553,
-0.7146351933479309,
-0.38117659091949463,
-0.2857966423034668,
-0.3052521049976349,
0.2043171525001526,
0.417657732963562,
0.11977361887693405,
-0.40278175473213196,
0.13476701080799103,
0.5317299962043762,
-0.9785255789756775,
-0.10654067248106003,
0.5504984855651855,
-0.42866984009742737,
0.16783706843852997,
0.7609613537788391,
-0.09886288642883301,
0.48583757877349854,
0.1299387812614441,
0.3107345700263977,
-0.4586372375488281,
-0.33838140964508057,
-0.4005436599254608,
0.06530078500509262,
-0.6159666180610657,
0.05021144449710846,
-0.4950413405895233,
-0.26020151376724243,
-0.7074821591377258,
0.16816571354866028,
-0.11048981547355652,
-0.10820003598928452,
-0.29928651452064514,
-0.29513853788375854,
0.12747713923454285,
0.6236878037452698,
0.032106976956129074,
0.03327285125851631,
-0.4473358392715454,
0.8699557781219482,
0.341043084859848,
0.25843319296836853,
-0.12084897607564926,
-0.3499082326889038,
0.43543359637260437,
-0.12643621861934662,
-0.35588881373405457,
-0.8666601777076721,
0.29554760456085205,
-0.0011762274662032723,
0.8680210113525391,
0.5453940629959106,
0.28265246748924255,
0.0284800473600626,
-0.23906345665454865,
0.8160009980201721,
0.47528472542762756,
-1.052959680557251,
0.5951915979385376,
-0.43730980157852173,
-0.1791653037071228,
0.42180636525154114,
0.27275076508522034,
-0.6953714489936829,
-0.7843361496925354,
-0.42289531230926514,
-0.7785226702690125,
0.617861807346344,
0.5840825438499451,
0.3633795976638794,
-0.5940690040588379,
0.17548459768295288,
0.40381279587745667,
0.28787481784820557,
-0.7395321726799011,
-0.4905112683773041,
-0.3011505901813507,
-0.279580682516098,
0.2819778621196747,
-0.29748213291168213,
-0.18183445930480957,
-0.16169969737529755,
0.4545353055000305,
0.08209768682718277,
0.5200411677360535,
-0.06256987154483795,
-0.13484136760234833,
0.17948290705680847,
0.5449079871177673,
0.49654555320739746,
0.4560948312282562,
-0.029633337631821632,
0.255081444978714,
0.04565631225705147,
-0.25537416338920593,
0.4048672616481781,
0.08340328186750412,
-0.6553731560707092,
0.17807117104530334,
0.25316351652145386,
0.8107122778892517,
-0.4637626111507416,
-0.6422827839851379,
0.523664653301239,
-0.05213165283203125,
-0.26433849334716797,
-0.4205986261367798,
0.23199081420898438,
-0.23243524134159088,
-0.03174687922000885,
0.06720240414142609,
0.019833210855722427,
0.2784600555896759,
-0.6257656812667847,
-0.03537265956401825,
0.6011945009231567,
-0.46249231696128845,
-0.11223725974559784,
0.9823687672615051,
0.39653801918029785,
-0.2163984477519989,
0.8672711253166199,
-0.3068937063217163,
-0.4065505266189575,
0.6909651160240173,
0.6589553356170654,
1.0737333297729492,
-0.35705265402793884,
0.552811324596405,
0.24825485050678253,
0.38674196600914,
-0.007108902093023062,
0.14224863052368164,
0.1755778193473816,
-0.9982876777648926,
0.06652785837650299,
-0.4431058168411255,
-0.13099630177021027,
0.02939954213798046,
-0.6021513342857361,
0.10934332758188248,
-0.6366754174232483,
-0.3820343315601349,
0.15867574512958527,
-0.9710985422134399,
-0.4918423891067505,
0.1577301025390625,
0.28618505597114563,
0.4857276380062103,
-1.1805769205093384,
0.4267304241657257,
0.36149147152900696,
-0.5666870474815369,
-0.04012145474553108,
0.12504364550113678,
0.18851514160633087,
-0.9739816784858704,
0.8031532168388367,
0.2304248809814453,
-0.1377953588962555,
-0.609462559223175,
-0.3836107552051544,
-0.33082857728004456,
0.533454954624176,
0.7467199563980103,
-0.3627299964427948,
-0.18159642815589905,
0.323233038187027,
0.39170601963996887,
-0.19903866946697235,
0.5112161636352539,
0.7222089171409607,
0.5584524273872375,
-0.29329612851142883,
-0.9310120940208435,
0.09874054789543152,
-0.4593484699726105,
0.3142049312591553,
-0.03542596846818924,
-0.4735264778137207,
0.9913856387138367,
0.039004549384117126,
-0.29673486948013306,
0.05596721172332764,
0.3920988440513611,
0.6012940406799316,
0.1604669839143753,
0.8486977219581604,
0.2828767001628876,
0.7336050868034363,
-0.18030747771263123,
1.1200491189956665,
-0.08524521440267563,
0.07639557868242264,
0.6695769429206848,
-0.263847678899765,
0.022964034229516983,
0.23728375136852264,
-0.3939981460571289,
0.5725859999656677,
0.22153769433498383,
0.008920944295823574,
0.3159085512161255,
0.48252221941947937,
-0.6326792240142822,
-0.201356440782547,
-0.6734170317649841,
-0.561403751373291,
0.632575511932373,
0.4331226944923401,
-0.8914551138877869,
-0.16133257746696472,
0.04129321873188019,
0.07126052677631378,
0.004900873173028231,
0.04731043428182602,
0.5855462551116943,
0.09459491819143295,
-0.6092507243156433,
0.42522257566452026,
0.260284960269928,
0.8031730055809021,
-0.43866094946861267,
-0.18955689668655396,
-0.23390254378318787,
-0.0902370885014534,
-0.2643990218639374,
-0.3103902041912079,
0.40261179208755493,
0.32572034001350403,
-0.4921105206012726,
-0.22980952262878418,
0.5398725867271423,
-0.3214203715324402,
-0.6152278780937195,
0.12560798227787018,
0.529466450214386,
0.17664499580860138,
0.09157411754131317,
-0.5882644057273865,
-0.1909106820821762,
0.12023742496967316,
0.41969001293182373,
0.23054419457912445,
0.03519456833600998,
-0.29391220211982727,
0.6848818063735962,
0.44284239411354065,
0.09071500599384308,
-0.020440682768821716,
0.525824785232544,
0.21157124638557434,
-0.444294273853302,
-0.6637595295906067,
-0.9118131995201111,
0.0733257532119751,
0.15073809027671814,
-0.24441392719745636,
0.7052122950553894,
0.4259698688983917,
0.30037105083465576,
-0.025229983031749725,
1.230370283126831,
-0.27513694763183594,
0.32625725865364075,
-0.4911807179450989,
0.7214459180831909,
-0.36910492181777954,
0.256687194108963,
-0.33503371477127075,
-0.6309933066368103,
-0.16455329954624176,
0.8421846628189087,
-0.5367516875267029,
0.6775659322738647,
0.3142675459384918,
0.7016016840934753,
0.2581075429916382,
0.31811991333961487,
0.3192530572414398,
0.07241281121969223,
0.3950009346008301,
0.29013165831565857,
1.1736072301864624,
0.11101024597883224,
0.16118451952934265,
-0.008856192231178284,
-0.36340010166168213,
-0.10812155157327652,
-0.7937248349189758,
-0.8488239049911499,
-0.43638890981674194,
-0.6472472548484802,
-0.48460784554481506,
0.08312952518463135,
0.7030916810035706,
0.9051522016525269,
-0.7046499848365784,
-0.11487622559070587,
-0.38488954305648804,
0.4668847322463989,
-0.09603758901357651,
-0.28287065029144287,
0.04539402574300766,
-0.11723372340202332,
-0.6361383199691772,
0.13522687554359436,
-0.007912554778158665,
0.1808163821697235,
-0.4623362123966217,
-0.00801416952162981,
0.16798169910907745,
0.0369485542178154,
0.5488601326942444,
0.24316105246543884,
-0.7009122967720032,
-0.32574501633644104,
-0.521174430847168,
0.12657316029071808,
0.13466492295265198,
0.8005126118659973,
-0.3958580493927002,
0.584439218044281,
0.4900892972946167,
0.1565375179052353,
-0.05301233008503914,
0.0203354861587286,
0.9317952990531921,
-1.0039674043655396,
0.1488729566335678,
0.1889350265264511,
0.36133113503456116,
0.5078991651535034,
-0.4422728717327118,
0.42809823155403137,
0.3743896782398224,
-0.14882026612758636,
-0.8189109563827515,
0.583667516708374,
-0.22563178837299347,
-0.38256824016571045,
1.1776574850082397,
-0.04428358003497124,
0.020657068118453026,
-0.49815115332603455,
-0.0192538034170866,
0.3193398416042328,
-0.30696865916252136,
1.102871298789978,
0.5478426218032837,
-0.32609492540359497,
-0.17356979846954346,
-0.7938343286514282,
0.43036937713623047,
0.4377097189426422,
-0.950948178768158,
0.21422134339809418,
0.687160849571228,
0.33382448554039,
0.12054788321256638,
0.7650842070579529,
-0.450431227684021,
0.21431803703308105,
0.28506508469581604,
0.2732580304145813,
0.2907438576221466,
-0.06638657301664352,
-0.05656241998076439,
-0.08462084084749222,
0.3675658404827118,
-0.38919439911842346
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08540v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08540v2
|
Language models scale reliably with over-training and on downstream tasks
| 2024-03-13T13:54:00 | 2024-06-14T20:21:05 |
Samir Yitzhak Gadre, Georgios Smyrnis, Vaishaal Shankar, Suchin Gururangan, Mitchell Wortsman, Rulin Shao, Jean Mercat, Alex Fang, Jeffrey Li, Sedrick Keh, Rui Xin, Marianna Nezhurina, Igor Vasiljevic, Jenia Jitsev, Luca Soldaini, Alexandros G. Dimakis, Gabriel Ilharco, Pang Wei Koh, Shuran Song, Thomas Kollar, Yair Carmon, Achal Dave, Reinhard Heckel, Niklas Muennighoff, Ludwig Schmidt
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Scaling laws are useful guides for derisking expensive training runs, as they
predict performance of large models using cheaper, small-scale experiments.
However, there remain gaps between current scaling studies and how language
models are ultimately trained and evaluated. For instance, scaling is usually
studied in the compute-optimal training regime (i.e., "Chinchilla optimal"
regime). In contrast, models are often over-trained to reduce inference costs.
Moreover, scaling laws mostly predict loss on next-token prediction, but models
are usually compared on downstream task performance. To address both
shortcomings, we create a testbed of 104 models with 0.011B to 6.9B parameters
trained with various numbers of tokens on three data distributions. First, we
fit scaling laws that extrapolate in both the amount of over-training and the
number of model parameters. This enables us to predict the validation loss of a
1.4B parameter, 900B token run (i.e., 32$\times$ over-trained) and a 6.9B
parameter, 138B token run (i.e., a compute-optimal run)$\unicode{x2014}$each
from experiments that take 300$\times$ less compute. Second, we relate the
perplexity of a language model to its downstream task performance by proposing
a power law. We use this law to predict top-1 error averaged over downstream
tasks for the two aforementioned models, using experiments that take 20$\times$
less compute. Our experiments are available at
https://github.com/mlfoundations/scaling.
|
[
-0.2855994701385498,
-0.4569387435913086,
0.5057592988014221,
0.32050621509552,
0.0022129646968096495,
-0.3026268482208252,
-0.4322151839733124,
-0.22956900298595428,
-0.14173553884029388,
0.6675022840499878,
-0.4563458263874054,
0.2321486622095108,
-0.7730011343955994,
-0.13675163686275482,
-0.4781361520290375,
0.9424710869789124,
0.05623256042599678,
0.2813524603843689,
-0.11063771694898605,
-0.22030845284461975,
-0.2793477773666382,
-0.5139224529266357,
-0.6538318991661072,
-0.5568239092826843,
0.4645894765853882,
0.22806024551391602,
0.8313984274864197,
0.9616777300834656,
0.6080121397972107,
0.225944384932518,
-0.15505827963352203,
-0.3520864248275757,
-0.5516151785850525,
-0.031929899007081985,
-0.09768600761890411,
-0.6210161447525024,
-0.28188154101371765,
0.08776914328336716,
0.7279183864593506,
0.865516722202301,
-0.30576011538505554,
0.2598017454147339,
-0.1625094711780548,
0.6094469428062439,
-0.6442580819129944,
0.20524920523166656,
-0.6435524225234985,
-0.1678943634033203,
-0.11499302089214325,
0.05094560608267784,
-0.6672754883766174,
-0.15478326380252838,
-0.15754413604736328,
-0.4011111259460449,
0.043799761682748795,
0.2200789451599121,
1.0155757665634155,
0.5099597573280334,
-0.39360639452934265,
-0.1674835979938507,
-0.5865584015846252,
0.9673909544944763,
-0.9606533050537109,
0.49085867404937744,
0.42115479707717896,
0.34211465716362,
0.1198037788271904,
-0.7725757360458374,
-0.43561238050460815,
-0.4303950369358063,
-0.1253681182861328,
-0.23562951385974884,
-0.4825606048107147,
0.09947297722101212,
0.6417249441146851,
0.4176453649997711,
-0.4400646388530731,
0.3618863821029663,
-0.3830215334892273,
-0.04796129837632179,
0.5532276034355164,
0.3054657578468323,
0.19712629914283752,
0.053789734840393066,
-0.09761524200439453,
-0.16408437490463257,
-0.7507948279380798,
0.1797567903995514,
0.28648698329925537,
0.7117598056793213,
-0.05200159549713135,
0.45846983790397644,
-0.10936817526817322,
0.540632963180542,
0.2601900100708008,
-0.11065296828746796,
0.31791508197784424,
-0.37794196605682373,
-0.3367862403392792,
-0.11585348099470139,
0.7392472624778748,
0.3272913992404938,
0.6688134670257568,
-0.2655423879623413,
-0.2847612202167511,
-0.3357993960380554,
0.4889587461948395,
-1.14240300655365,
-0.04608333110809326,
-0.0022541447542607784,
-0.3606182634830475,
-0.2043222337961197,
-0.5064684152603149,
-0.26856616139411926,
-0.4653310775756836,
-0.42778822779655457,
0.6657686233520508,
-0.19754630327224731,
-0.4688778221607208,
0.06636345386505127,
-0.0023384580854326487,
0.1444476693868637,
0.13498543202877045,
-1.3089618682861328,
0.5948869585990906,
0.7516588568687439,
0.9239595532417297,
0.20627284049987793,
-0.4106055200099945,
-0.5338714122772217,
-0.38776662945747375,
-0.42419397830963135,
0.3166491687297821,
-0.29264596104621887,
-0.03010294958949089,
-0.03771253675222397,
-0.031098784878849983,
-0.3735160827636719,
-0.4993722140789032,
0.3004899322986603,
-0.4518987536430359,
-0.20566082000732422,
-0.38487136363983154,
-0.7581194043159485,
0.0865330919623375,
0.08577926456928253,
-0.7873866558074951,
0.7568092346191406,
0.18218082189559937,
-0.8756442666053772,
0.6491261124610901,
-0.4855349361896515,
-0.552085816860199,
-0.16869592666625977,
0.06615696847438812,
-0.49011126160621643,
0.29927828907966614,
-0.07325997948646545,
0.556733250617981,
-0.6250640153884888,
0.12580525875091553,
-0.4007675349712372,
-0.3404165208339691,
-0.01377171277999878,
-0.32770442962646484,
0.929936408996582,
0.1217309758067131,
-0.5423631072044373,
0.0927579402923584,
-0.7426799535751343,
0.15555447340011597,
0.0726916715502739,
-0.34238559007644653,
-0.23679637908935547,
0.08835265785455704,
0.002196740126237273,
0.06462696939706802,
0.046227648854255676,
-0.7480860352516174,
0.0992848202586174,
-0.36389896273612976,
0.684516191482544,
0.5517838001251221,
-0.4010133445262909,
0.5511553287506104,
-0.15651530027389526,
0.5475749373435974,
-0.27869299054145813,
0.27282050251960754,
-0.08582764863967896,
-0.3781709671020508,
-0.6391312479972839,
-0.1197090819478035,
0.2655772864818573,
0.4119528830051422,
-0.18481265008449554,
0.14186155796051025,
-0.5133272409439087,
-0.7789759039878845,
-0.352776437997818,
0.04608183726668358,
0.33767661452293396,
0.3898240327835083,
0.38572442531585693,
-0.2668825387954712,
-0.4242548644542694,
-0.813352644443512,
-0.38747406005859375,
-0.29671311378479004,
-0.17593540251255035,
0.2560366988182068,
0.47593146562576294,
0.06128104031085968,
0.9938603043556213,
-0.11139411479234695,
-0.05707261711359024,
-0.49252861738204956,
0.2619321644306183,
0.20305775105953217,
0.5233872532844543,
0.5679886341094971,
-0.7690486907958984,
-0.4248928725719452,
0.15660718083381653,
-0.31050145626068115,
-0.19607609510421753,
-0.1210247054696083,
0.40689581632614136,
0.1936219334602356,
0.695218026638031,
-0.5573531985282898,
0.1701093465089798,
0.591521143913269,
-0.26587000489234924,
0.6664402484893799,
-0.34050923585891724,
-0.06683345884084702,
-0.8643034100532532,
0.07885702699422836,
0.013266460038721561,
-0.20227743685245514,
-0.7965688705444336,
0.10328436642885208,
0.35645362734794617,
0.245835542678833,
-0.17702032625675201,
0.5216718316078186,
-0.21758708357810974,
-0.08264997601509094,
-0.25935763120651245,
-0.31248483061790466,
-0.13503924012184143,
0.5542543530464172,
-0.03264852985739708,
0.7172563672065735,
0.6507757902145386,
-0.30430468916893005,
0.09076153486967087,
-0.5172273516654968,
-0.34817826747894287,
0.23183651268482208,
-0.8689566254615784,
-0.15974190831184387,
0.10945718735456467,
0.07782284915447235,
-1.1259403228759766,
-0.10940909385681152,
-0.42009785771369934,
-0.33667275309562683,
0.5061070919036865,
-0.268074631690979,
-0.6813450455665588,
-0.22536158561706543,
-0.0884142816066742,
0.4811398386955261,
0.8116666674613953,
-0.3759015202522278,
0.7497722506523132,
0.387281596660614,
0.1891997903585434,
-0.5360460877418518,
-1.0316919088363647,
-0.15719082951545715,
-0.3694313168525696,
-0.4569249451160431,
-0.005564852152019739,
0.05668841674923897,
-0.3792613744735718,
-0.2370016723871231,
-0.08508462458848953,
-0.29098668694496155,
0.14916056394577026,
0.4571385085582733,
-0.12762537598609924,
-0.4596322178840637,
0.05110906437039375,
-0.20201726257801056,
0.1284908652305603,
0.4523026645183563,
-0.2791976034641266,
0.5540893077850342,
-0.26295289397239685,
-0.2858552932739258,
-0.2103106528520584,
-0.08373001217842102,
1.0180504322052002,
-0.16554878652095795,
0.9327865839004517,
0.37685835361480713,
-0.29695188999176025,
0.034088846296072006,
-0.6484876871109009,
-0.07417672127485275,
-0.4473985731601715,
0.42792484164237976,
-0.5355370044708252,
-0.6752845644950867,
0.8694717884063721,
0.1330115646123886,
0.32326623797416687,
0.5562980771064758,
0.6781580448150635,
0.282868355512619,
1.1041359901428223,
0.8733764886856079,
-0.200748011469841,
0.5079260468482971,
-0.22081436216831207,
0.2925647795200348,
-0.7187137007713318,
0.13375712931156158,
-0.6311757564544678,
-0.07371736317873001,
-0.8927730321884155,
-0.37046873569488525,
0.060342755168676376,
0.11700490117073059,
-0.502801775932312,
0.6894651055335999,
-0.10294333100318909,
0.5192086100578308,
0.5345354676246643,
-0.1421499252319336,
0.1438939869403839,
-0.007758088875561953,
-0.19944502413272858,
0.014721890911459923,
-0.8570974469184875,
-0.29051050543785095,
1.380265474319458,
0.6125602126121521,
0.8352066278457642,
-0.1020858958363533,
0.6207800507545471,
0.11801525950431824,
0.6571858525276184,
-0.8603193759918213,
0.307455837726593,
-0.27999553084373474,
-0.8676592111587524,
-0.741774320602417,
-0.7207981944084167,
-0.8172361254692078,
0.31716397404670715,
0.27287232875823975,
-0.7730501294136047,
0.05604339763522148,
0.2335948497056961,
-0.3527846336364746,
0.6119179725646973,
-0.7460164427757263,
0.9744021892547607,
0.07382877171039581,
-0.3234531581401825,
-0.38182201981544495,
-0.7908411622047424,
0.11807556450366974,
-0.2501908242702484,
0.45499321818351746,
0.018476970493793488,
0.011930880136787891,
0.7209956645965576,
-0.7644567489624023,
0.8085693120956421,
-0.1793743371963501,
-0.21257410943508148,
0.21289591491222382,
0.033633753657341,
0.3554028868675232,
-0.41649195551872253,
-0.10131518542766571,
0.19156189262866974,
0.014409991912543774,
-0.558405876159668,
-0.6358201503753662,
0.5204470157623291,
-0.70729660987854,
-0.3807121515274048,
-0.06553170830011368,
-0.5810069441795349,
-0.1280621588230133,
0.22403854131698608,
0.4199255108833313,
0.614848256111145,
0.25234630703926086,
0.30406129360198975,
0.5423988699913025,
0.219000443816185,
0.40215519070625305,
0.4878741204738617,
-0.21839381754398346,
-0.1264205127954483,
0.9094076156616211,
0.4420616030693054,
0.8677043914794922,
0.2685663402080536,
0.45763301849365234,
-0.3006713092327118,
-0.6803256869316101,
-0.6445380449295044,
0.1435040831565857,
-0.706549882888794,
0.06214214861392975,
-0.5194553732872009,
-0.19928236305713654,
-0.4606645703315735,
-0.09140334278345108,
-0.701854407787323,
-0.46785637736320496,
0.060566481202840805,
-0.009859458543360233,
0.24821089208126068,
0.5731930136680603,
-0.22015777230262756,
0.2342597097158432,
-0.3631027042865753,
-0.13176952302455902,
0.2131849229335785,
0.4009998142719269,
0.1629156470298767,
-1.0845248699188232,
-0.394742488861084,
-0.010524646379053593,
-0.006794170942157507,
-0.5572469234466553,
0.20033816993236542,
0.21268655359745026,
0.46963682770729065,
0.31212881207466125,
-0.07722986489534378,
0.6132566332817078,
-0.8086852431297302,
0.6614052057266235,
0.3295631408691406,
-0.9620540142059326,
0.20875245332717896,
-0.2152182012796402,
0.3144018054008484,
0.5018803477287292,
0.44022464752197266,
-0.4189870059490204,
-0.7129684090614319,
-0.7281795740127563,
-0.8297871947288513,
0.5787107944488525,
0.24126066267490387,
0.47483816742897034,
0.2277422845363617,
0.4548162519931793,
0.037413422018289566,
0.05337871238589287,
-0.7234243750572205,
-0.17533771693706512,
-0.2234552949666977,
-0.05770324543118477,
-0.24436207115650177,
-0.06255212426185608,
0.22678273916244507,
-0.24795636534690857,
0.5033252239227295,
-0.1324979066848755,
-0.18293899297714233,
-0.1354021430015564,
0.004393932409584522,
-0.36653435230255127,
0.16941794753074646,
0.6006484627723694,
0.7666196227073669,
-0.20083318650722504,
0.09195533394813538,
0.20269697904586792,
-0.6699537634849548,
0.20916436612606049,
0.08499274402856827,
-0.02643069438636303,
-0.06972254067659378,
0.5720665454864502,
0.874066948890686,
0.2314450889825821,
-0.8659934997558594,
0.5308177471160889,
-0.11487472057342529,
-0.21625250577926636,
-0.14276883006095886,
0.12288933247327805,
0.14502812922000885,
0.22263774275779724,
0.4064001142978668,
-0.005570122506469488,
0.04193082079291344,
-0.5336647629737854,
0.2418675422668457,
0.29271599650382996,
-0.39848291873931885,
-0.29977643489837646,
0.7178564071655273,
0.0025159551296383142,
-0.2802174389362335,
0.592719554901123,
-0.30095064640045166,
-0.4637446701526642,
0.9065065383911133,
0.29740360379219055,
0.6706376671791077,
-0.17456071078777313,
-0.16110362112522125,
0.522500216960907,
0.6311512589454651,
-0.4159628748893738,
-0.06013582646846771,
0.003010889980942011,
-0.5859971642494202,
-0.7299282550811768,
-0.7094865441322327,
-0.4141795337200165,
0.20782050490379333,
-0.82242751121521,
0.05509919300675392,
-0.5030344128608704,
-0.3815923035144806,
0.28373339772224426,
0.13662129640579224,
-0.4713081121444702,
0.3812887370586395,
0.09521903842687607,
0.913631796836853,
-0.9149814248085022,
0.7696628570556641,
0.5173075199127197,
-0.42318981885910034,
-1.046417236328125,
-0.0682184249162674,
-0.0679122656583786,
-0.8324258923530579,
0.8287443518638611,
0.22339273989200592,
-0.051414381712675095,
0.020999835804104805,
-0.2663114368915558,
-1.0733222961425781,
0.8351168036460876,
0.5720394849777222,
-0.6337608098983765,
0.01789751462638378,
0.17328912019729614,
0.736667275428772,
-0.34724533557891846,
0.4143058657646179,
0.6259728074073792,
0.25671592354774475,
0.15301476418972015,
-1.5466464757919312,
0.17875239253044128,
-0.023052053526043892,
-0.1713249832391739,
0.45877373218536377,
-0.5834642648696899,
1.2847956418991089,
-0.5036658644676208,
-0.11983926594257355,
0.014782874844968319,
0.44246551394462585,
-0.08131180703639984,
0.20206552743911743,
0.7366999983787537,
0.6638795733451843,
0.5332868695259094,
-0.023605596274137497,
1.2687633037567139,
-0.26201871037483215,
0.7478868365287781,
1.1464405059814453,
-0.26055219769477844,
0.9762812256813049,
0.5636537671089172,
-0.4196031391620636,
0.3797987997531891,
0.6192594170570374,
-0.03917240723967552,
0.34831342101097107,
0.6167494058609009,
0.279287725687027,
-0.2934309244155884,
-0.09071523696184158,
-0.03075988218188286,
0.2267751544713974,
0.006706126034259796,
-0.4227108657360077,
-0.24759040772914886,
0.048594340682029724,
0.2273954451084137,
-0.09412245452404022,
-0.4938640594482422,
0.4567829966545105,
-0.08822426944971085,
-0.6448277831077576,
0.8843971490859985,
-0.11156991124153137,
0.41386014223098755,
-0.500325083732605,
0.3905927836894989,
-0.36176061630249023,
0.31231948733329773,
0.008827900514006615,
-0.573213517665863,
0.19826936721801758,
0.005602641496807337,
-0.20775164663791656,
-0.3208346366882324,
0.437198668718338,
-0.2484443336725235,
-0.4661358594894409,
0.2949901819229126,
0.197520911693573,
0.28549885749816895,
-0.26108527183532715,
-0.5062984824180603,
-0.01127608958631754,
-0.13138869404792786,
-0.5877455472946167,
0.4488937258720398,
0.36117544770240784,
-0.06017804518342018,
0.9382838606834412,
0.24785670638084412,
0.2818719744682312,
0.3864876925945282,
0.3997938930988312,
0.7006173729896545,
-0.30657660961151123,
-0.3866303563117981,
-0.9990053772926331,
0.2979603111743927,
-0.08045008033514023,
-0.3415943384170532,
0.7239900231361389,
0.49284112453460693,
0.7848247289657593,
0.2337571233510971,
0.5207591652870178,
-0.19564753770828247,
0.2637615203857422,
-0.4029961824417114,
0.6396663784980774,
-0.8503418564796448,
-0.02472609281539917,
0.10935208201408386,
-0.5557149052619934,
-0.1823710799217224,
0.3402400016784668,
-0.40995991230010986,
0.304503858089447,
0.5870847702026367,
0.7468339800834656,
-0.11266815662384033,
-0.10835883766412735,
0.458514004945755,
0.2161421775817871,
0.2883385419845581,
0.534711480140686,
0.35261988639831543,
-0.4217935800552368,
0.5309255123138428,
-0.29437118768692017,
-0.23468030989170074,
-0.29464367032051086,
-0.6530857682228088,
-0.9720597863197327,
-0.4820224642753601,
-0.38217833638191223,
-0.2481136918067932,
-0.12182436138391495,
0.6110267639160156,
1.0778942108154297,
-0.764677107334137,
-0.47055837512016296,
-0.4424496591091156,
-0.17788194119930267,
-0.39739730954170227,
-0.20694726705551147,
0.17947649955749512,
-0.8114679455757141,
-0.5259384512901306,
-0.08524282276630402,
0.027619170024991035,
-0.02898424118757248,
-0.6542613506317139,
-0.08445463329553604,
0.014584043063223362,
0.41389238834381104,
0.3275805413722992,
0.24204035103321075,
-0.7473549246788025,
-0.18755513429641724,
-0.06140775978565216,
-0.43065640330314636,
-0.0724206194281578,
1.0933032035827637,
-0.3980104625225067,
0.3744010627269745,
0.4756051003932953,
0.7069471478462219,
0.4772203266620636,
-0.3399110734462738,
0.6861579418182373,
-0.7057035565376282,
-0.07782470434904099,
0.04944050312042236,
0.33409425616264343,
0.3098355531692505,
-0.23244594037532806,
0.5330404043197632,
0.02475699968636036,
-0.6842755675315857,
-1.0933510065078735,
0.09716945141553879,
-0.5177338123321533,
-0.24849916994571686,
1.1163172721862793,
-0.46732616424560547,
-0.1789129674434662,
0.21952442824840546,
0.13399198651313782,
0.10656861960887909,
-0.08330781757831573,
0.642098069190979,
1.058943271636963,
-0.1597943753004074,
-0.11884288489818573,
-0.8774233460426331,
0.5954592227935791,
0.8163227438926697,
-0.5388099551200867,
0.6451745629310608,
0.14931108057498932,
0.39715003967285156,
0.40013816952705383,
0.35707706212997437,
0.19890321791172028,
0.25618332624435425,
0.25565865635871887,
-0.20175398886203766,
0.15096622705459595,
-0.13818193972110748,
-0.4312500059604645,
0.2504040002822876,
0.24095949530601501,
-0.0049890996888279915
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08495v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08495v2
|
Automatic Interactive Evaluation for Large Language Models with State Aware Patient Simulator
| 2024-03-13T13:04:58 | 2024-03-14T08:05:08 |
Yusheng Liao, Yutong Meng, Yuhao Wang, Hongcheng Liu, Yanfeng Wang, Yu Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable proficiency in
human interactions, yet their application within the medical field remains
insufficiently explored. Previous works mainly focus on the performance of
medical knowledge with examinations, which is far from the realistic scenarios,
falling short in assessing the abilities of LLMs on clinical tasks. In the
quest to enhance the application of Large Language Models (LLMs) in healthcare,
this paper introduces the Automated Interactive Evaluation (AIE) framework and
the State-Aware Patient Simulator (SAPS), targeting the gap between traditional
LLM evaluations and the nuanced demands of clinical practice. Unlike prior
methods that rely on static medical knowledge assessments, AIE and SAPS provide
a dynamic, realistic platform for assessing LLMs through multi-turn
doctor-patient simulations. This approach offers a closer approximation to real
clinical scenarios and allows for a detailed analysis of LLM behaviors in
response to complex patient interactions. Our extensive experimental validation
demonstrates the effectiveness of the AIE framework, with outcomes that align
well with human evaluations, underscoring its potential to revolutionize
medical LLM testing for improved healthcare delivery.
|
[
-0.19934597611427307,
-0.7300561666488647,
0.9848757386207581,
0.3595789968967438,
-0.10761546343564987,
0.15386518836021423,
-0.3773684501647949,
-0.5447847843170166,
0.2766561210155487,
0.3451053500175476,
-0.45047441124916077,
-0.38599085807800293,
-0.5974863767623901,
0.1443515568971634,
-0.4342076778411865,
0.5216178297996521,
-0.33424142003059387,
0.4704741835594177,
-0.4394480884075165,
0.057791516184806824,
-0.23573273420333862,
-0.4931910037994385,
-0.6775880455970764,
-0.3928380608558655,
0.14469373226165771,
-0.04776953160762787,
0.5057872533798218,
0.3608701527118683,
0.64549720287323,
0.407525897026062,
0.15769490599632263,
0.09109777957201004,
-0.13709668815135956,
0.2058245986700058,
-0.04982054606080055,
-0.19111096858978271,
-0.5538472533226013,
-0.11124479025602341,
0.8335228562355042,
0.5635414719581604,
-0.37715446949005127,
0.03923337161540985,
-0.3137173652648926,
0.31627175211906433,
-0.5215004086494446,
0.3693768382072449,
-0.37184539437294006,
0.13303270936012268,
0.17828823626041412,
-0.14190080761909485,
-0.3760489821434021,
-0.3805575370788574,
0.32702580094337463,
-0.4235454499721527,
-0.30036836862564087,
0.06472977250814438,
0.6131066083908081,
0.3205599784851074,
-0.7309675216674805,
-0.20019616186618805,
-0.8259841799736023,
0.45312583446502686,
-0.9261323809623718,
0.6127521991729736,
-0.03310328722000122,
0.5539146661758423,
-0.3509105443954468,
-0.7960253357887268,
-0.722465455532074,
-0.8456213474273682,
-0.0672658160328865,
0.2435668706893921,
-0.2317969799041748,
0.4558884799480438,
0.33280202746391296,
0.21799170970916748,
-0.2902265787124634,
0.4137614071369171,
-0.13230156898498535,
-0.198608860373497,
0.689350962638855,
0.5968124270439148,
0.773734986782074,
-0.2067735195159912,
-0.5010632276535034,
0.07389414310455322,
-0.4078300893306732,
0.0630725547671318,
-0.3132830262184143,
-0.11884640902280807,
-0.3083725869655609,
0.5956748127937317,
0.11287321895360947,
0.6474629044532776,
-0.16431500017642975,
-0.37711629271507263,
0.14978675544261932,
-0.07765524089336395,
-0.40615493059158325,
-0.06742869317531586,
1.0195597410202026,
0.47992846369743347,
0.06689900159835815,
-0.008636021986603737,
-0.22102150321006775,
0.14133337140083313,
0.42783159017562866,
-0.9120373129844666,
-0.031890735030174255,
0.558809757232666,
-0.3740544319152832,
-0.11819276213645935,
-0.1089816465973854,
-0.7100677490234375,
-0.6944093704223633,
-0.45416900515556335,
0.3969746530056,
-0.5780177712440491,
-0.1826634258031845,
0.18652790784835815,
0.2559295892715454,
0.07690229266881943,
0.7184139490127563,
-0.6218321323394775,
0.7982280254364014,
0.7096357941627502,
0.49781548976898193,
-0.46057701110839844,
-0.270773321390152,
-0.7060249447822571,
0.16025219857692719,
-0.4426397681236267,
0.6176892518997192,
-0.47671744227409363,
-0.4308846890926361,
-0.1424465775489807,
-0.08134792745113373,
-0.3274132013320923,
-0.6258379220962524,
0.38553062081336975,
-0.39873579144477844,
-0.020047686994075775,
-0.043197646737098694,
-0.9070167541503906,
-0.07586302608251572,
0.38533562421798706,
-0.5499086380004883,
0.7578815817832947,
0.17560546100139618,
-0.43185335397720337,
0.4774940311908722,
-1.0499359369277954,
-0.46143510937690735,
0.2471756935119629,
-0.5224009156227112,
-0.33275097608566284,
0.11114021390676498,
0.2125980705022812,
0.4385736584663391,
-0.4255088269710541,
0.3723464608192444,
-0.20848211646080017,
-0.43668878078460693,
0.36645200848579407,
-0.2746568024158478,
0.5225176215171814,
-0.03346506506204605,
-0.25824153423309326,
0.5785025358200073,
-0.4933588206768036,
0.0692080408334732,
0.030083831399679184,
-0.3931730389595032,
-0.18641570210456848,
0.1775677353143692,
0.04910872504115105,
0.2667701840400696,
0.14965170621871948,
-0.595124363899231,
0.26631495356559753,
-0.576585054397583,
0.3191036283969879,
0.41533342003822327,
0.29651591181755066,
0.29344257712364197,
-0.14973950386047363,
0.9840021133422852,
0.0007217873353511095,
0.5808621048927307,
-0.046559616923332214,
-0.2778668701648712,
-0.5566415190696716,
-0.658473014831543,
0.3661189377307892,
0.762913167476654,
-0.4892711639404297,
0.4253877103328705,
-0.3060867488384247,
-0.4467141330242157,
-0.8683632016181946,
-0.08917661756277084,
0.0804663747549057,
0.49286821484565735,
0.2272292524576187,
-0.4099982976913452,
-0.3393351137638092,
-0.9041640758514404,
-0.11991170793771744,
-0.3377684950828552,
-0.02223947085440159,
0.4968084692955017,
0.565670371055603,
-0.4560452997684479,
0.7894376516342163,
-0.2146013379096985,
-0.2194865494966507,
-0.3389813005924225,
-0.12239925563335419,
-0.17042331397533417,
0.3638642430305481,
0.4522620737552643,
-0.475423127412796,
-0.3380659222602844,
0.10144668817520142,
-0.699982225894928,
0.05072221904993057,
-0.1475868821144104,
0.1393103003501892,
0.08620147407054901,
0.509235680103302,
-0.4236357510089874,
0.44401466846466064,
0.6437824964523315,
-0.3108755052089691,
0.5714992880821228,
-0.5987265706062317,
0.522525429725647,
-0.8488370776176453,
0.06448820233345032,
0.02087985910475254,
-0.3287011384963989,
-0.5523785352706909,
0.05930904299020767,
0.1851368099451065,
-0.18096038699150085,
-0.4500833749771118,
1.009224772453308,
-0.5276721119880676,
-0.2338799387216568,
-0.1526506394147873,
0.19280777871608734,
0.007664918899536133,
-0.06771410256624222,
0.12313883006572723,
0.7138078808784485,
0.6282574534416199,
-0.4244275391101837,
0.4620598554611206,
0.06654174625873566,
-0.8322950601577759,
0.42613685131073,
-0.5683158040046692,
-0.08952321857213974,
0.11797913908958435,
0.4264926314353943,
-0.5615293979644775,
-0.3550788164138794,
-0.016515564173460007,
-0.14580309391021729,
0.1912759244441986,
-0.09435989707708359,
-0.7084821462631226,
-0.5857638716697693,
0.0008417669450864196,
0.3341943919658661,
0.6070059537887573,
-0.18641701340675354,
0.9181385040283203,
0.5744683146476746,
-0.3137994110584259,
-0.21869124472141266,
-0.45482370257377625,
0.34831130504608154,
-0.10961438715457916,
-0.5501068830490112,
0.06633564829826355,
-0.022031579166650772,
-0.520226776599884,
-0.21389339864253998,
0.19919444620609283,
-0.2739674150943756,
0.35255154967308044,
0.2908031940460205,
0.5839430689811707,
-0.10171185433864594,
0.21181558072566986,
0.31046348810195923,
0.04446837678551674,
0.3251919150352478,
0.07815951108932495,
0.5986241102218628,
-0.284596711397171,
-0.9560315012931824,
-0.8211731910705566,
0.3542943298816681,
0.9514032602310181,
-0.45142215490341187,
0.5352450609207153,
0.46387335658073425,
-0.7110991477966309,
0.15966174006462097,
-0.6869694590568542,
-0.4285641312599182,
-0.4125421643257141,
0.7616578340530396,
-0.15919065475463867,
-0.8058170676231384,
0.5254946947097778,
-0.4177161157131195,
0.1336999386548996,
0.2739494740962982,
0.7634662985801697,
-0.18970757722854614,
1.3212265968322754,
0.2639372646808624,
0.07413046807050705,
0.05334408953785896,
0.14309699833393097,
0.3149131238460541,
-0.9501766562461853,
-0.48896312713623047,
-0.27168378233909607,
-0.08394255489110947,
-0.4274214208126068,
-0.7016572952270508,
0.9571474194526672,
-0.05091526731848717,
-0.1681995689868927,
-0.18110206723213196,
-0.07523978501558304,
0.1940840184688568,
0.04672769457101822,
0.24483782052993774,
0.3976096510887146,
-0.22246649861335754,
-0.264226496219635,
-0.2150030881166458,
-0.6522880792617798,
-0.5932449698448181,
0.7206807732582092,
0.607333779335022,
0.7414095401763916,
-0.01873619109392166,
0.6256408095359802,
0.27653270959854126,
0.7339718341827393,
-1.0724068880081177,
0.6549855470657349,
-0.11681832373142242,
-0.38652822375297546,
-0.31939154863357544,
-0.3998072147369385,
-0.865835964679718,
0.17606422305107117,
-0.5543063879013062,
-0.812662661075592,
-0.20919330418109894,
0.26760008931159973,
-0.5875734686851501,
0.35227298736572266,
-0.6819654107093811,
0.7074044942855835,
-0.5768585205078125,
0.02368328347802162,
-0.5454144477844238,
-0.49032238125801086,
0.20420372486114502,
-0.11432839930057526,
0.3647192120552063,
-0.19347673654556274,
-0.29270824790000916,
0.5333940982818604,
-0.48357829451560974,
0.7629188895225525,
-0.22892554104328156,
-0.1908901184797287,
-0.005515384022146463,
0.41280320286750793,
0.3578360378742218,
0.10318249464035034,
-0.2447844296693802,
-0.15268899500370026,
0.1483445018529892,
-0.1886516660451889,
-0.8370678424835205,
0.7027347087860107,
-0.49687233567237854,
-0.5772124528884888,
-0.37959837913513184,
-0.6024569869041443,
-0.6863468289375305,
0.2791030704975128,
-0.2583887577056885,
0.49985605478286743,
-0.594440221786499,
-0.4202410578727722,
0.4558508098125458,
-0.5532383322715759,
-0.03325358033180237,
0.9406498074531555,
-0.57101970911026,
-0.2092849612236023,
0.60308837890625,
-0.26991522312164307,
0.2147485315799713,
0.06584654748439789,
0.38420742750167847,
-0.4367073178291321,
-0.5795435309410095,
-0.769891083240509,
0.34553083777427673,
-0.5442445278167725,
0.1991347372531891,
-0.6445435881614685,
-0.19106991589069366,
-0.241794154047966,
-0.21859566867351532,
-0.30852651596069336,
0.010943650268018246,
-0.0297702606767416,
0.007182968780398369,
0.3392530381679535,
1.0292150974273682,
0.21860770881175995,
0.06953583657741547,
-0.8694695234298706,
0.1721189320087433,
0.16126635670661926,
0.5893279910087585,
0.17117169499397278,
-0.30408620834350586,
-0.09731367230415344,
-0.20273074507713318,
0.20900234580039978,
-0.8285406231880188,
0.16666963696479797,
0.0018869374180212617,
0.7556312680244446,
0.4420279562473297,
-0.09711121767759323,
0.5104945302009583,
-0.7723129987716675,
0.6614304780960083,
0.4478362798690796,
-1.022647738456726,
0.4036686420440674,
-0.23372919857501984,
0.18879593908786774,
0.7184378504753113,
0.24282357096672058,
-0.6901181936264038,
-0.3856477737426758,
-0.5037297606468201,
-0.7884327173233032,
0.34299206733703613,
-0.21395333111286163,
0.01822722889482975,
-0.0954609364271164,
0.3743072748184204,
-0.05728320777416229,
0.12192324548959732,
-0.4438403248786926,
-0.026733724400401115,
0.5261123776435852,
-0.4330780506134033,
0.21357017755508423,
-0.11618992686271667,
-0.22395950555801392,
-0.24471160769462585,
0.5675623416900635,
-0.009861341677606106,
0.27733510732650757,
0.284283846616745,
-0.10602060705423355,
-0.16999031603336334,
0.31659790873527527,
0.3786025643348694,
0.6580649018287659,
-0.04847116768360138,
-0.17115283012390137,
0.4732372760772705,
-0.4123200476169586,
0.12768875062465668,
0.22278541326522827,
-0.043342746794223785,
-0.19095300137996674,
0.41668134927749634,
0.9637537598609924,
0.3085651695728302,
-1.1580243110656738,
0.7457020282745361,
-0.22178710997104645,
0.056704726070165634,
-0.399519681930542,
0.12126830965280533,
0.24698613584041595,
0.19443614780902863,
-0.07308386266231537,
-0.024760620668530464,
0.30484676361083984,
-0.48682859539985657,
0.3180679380893707,
0.39097458124160767,
-0.6958151459693909,
-0.06573863327503204,
0.5339855551719666,
0.33172762393951416,
-0.3321875333786011,
0.6503008604049683,
0.023855265229940414,
-0.528723418712616,
0.8150091171264648,
0.4625340402126312,
0.5801940560340881,
-0.42489615082740784,
0.000020821224097744562,
0.20413649082183838,
0.36044666171073914,
0.006390540860593319,
0.3627181947231293,
0.426557332277298,
-0.42360931634902954,
-0.7737909555435181,
-0.41097572445869446,
-0.7553445100784302,
0.10307421535253525,
-0.8152241110801697,
0.38981297612190247,
-0.538338840007782,
-0.1683606058359146,
-0.21650005877017975,
-0.04688262939453125,
-0.6985215544700623,
0.387667179107666,
0.24818740785121918,
1.1462199687957764,
-0.7260505557060242,
0.7769986987113953,
0.9440290927886963,
0.03145071119070053,
-0.9071365594863892,
0.13339129090309143,
0.00826775562018156,
-0.9872983694076538,
0.3176955580711365,
-0.022364528849720955,
-0.14633768796920776,
-0.19160933792591095,
-0.09627965837717056,
-0.4417191445827484,
0.9553662538528442,
0.5260125398635864,
-0.6737060546875,
0.06252223253250122,
0.10722163319587708,
0.8634928464889526,
-0.4610094726085663,
0.6663764715194702,
0.6455156207084656,
0.5473119020462036,
-0.3259540796279907,
-1.3125643730163574,
0.1282549947500229,
-0.20541492104530334,
-0.19665488600730896,
0.22814764082431793,
-0.6471157073974609,
0.3804064691066742,
-0.4908027946949005,
0.05676105245947838,
-0.05988812446594238,
0.5236928462982178,
0.3355214297771454,
0.20738106966018677,
0.9397975206375122,
0.2784540057182312,
0.9143139123916626,
0.049295824021101,
1.3819361925125122,
-0.41972050070762634,
0.19958069920539856,
1.0335484743118286,
-0.8268364667892456,
0.9314457774162292,
0.2880215048789978,
-0.26789718866348267,
0.6302838921546936,
0.4459921419620514,
0.005246948916465044,
-0.06556635349988937,
0.5536670088768005,
-0.6046054363250732,
-0.44640839099884033,
-0.15456071496009827,
-0.15707841515541077,
0.5851487517356873,
0.5072112083435059,
-0.21359281241893768,
-0.14231720566749573,
0.17491133511066437,
0.07044459879398346,
0.1459174007177353,
-0.28048941493034363,
0.8418758511543274,
0.11866403371095657,
-0.5487696528434753,
0.20896132290363312,
-0.034607525914907455,
0.2572789192199707,
-0.8380836844444275,
-0.1272522658109665,
0.1143910363316536,
-0.038985248655080795,
-0.07692106068134308,
-0.6889561414718628,
0.014958896674215794,
0.16769738495349884,
-0.007181708235293627,
0.10441403836011887,
0.695716142654419,
-0.40877822041511536,
-0.5974133014678955,
0.5815361738204956,
0.45997223258018494,
0.252458781003952,
0.19979272782802582,
-0.8309878706932068,
0.14074894785881042,
-0.13109472393989563,
-0.30516573786735535,
0.44462817907333374,
0.21210482716560364,
-0.2653653025627136,
0.9998842477798462,
0.41612672805786133,
0.40268397331237793,
-0.159759059548378,
0.4642082750797272,
0.7321985960006714,
-0.4792991578578949,
-0.49158674478530884,
-0.7410182952880859,
0.34764406085014343,
-0.06848350167274475,
-0.06616584211587906,
0.31880971789360046,
0.5819502472877502,
0.2138955444097519,
0.01889961212873459,
1.0021981000900269,
0.022430697456002235,
0.661242663860321,
-0.4395916759967804,
0.9041621088981628,
-0.7086301445960999,
0.3071098029613495,
-0.25885581970214844,
-0.3351670801639557,
-0.2372456192970276,
0.4594532251358032,
-0.3723055124282837,
0.06085316836833954,
0.592897891998291,
0.31055817008018494,
-0.020750585943460464,
-0.05303080752491951,
0.33093246817588806,
0.548823893070221,
0.35765284299850464,
0.4998595118522644,
0.8120428323745728,
-0.11905331164598465,
0.051478154957294464,
-0.17521560192108154,
-0.53143709897995,
-0.18439537286758423,
-1.0029842853546143,
-0.7534382343292236,
-0.3184286653995514,
-0.30750998854637146,
-0.2660568058490753,
-0.017703067511320114,
1.413688063621521,
0.6627822518348694,
-0.8208764791488647,
-0.2903498709201813,
0.4235422611236572,
-0.37643152475357056,
-0.13605749607086182,
-0.1857825517654419,
0.5016778707504272,
0.031217040494084358,
-0.8267858028411865,
0.7123941779136658,
0.5652832388877869,
0.19075356423854828,
-0.49482059478759766,
-0.02890816330909729,
0.09793448448181152,
0.17878396809101105,
0.6081163883209229,
0.11314108967781067,
-0.6554529666900635,
-0.03391854092478752,
-0.07313421368598938,
-0.32921552658081055,
0.0262224730104208,
0.9203643798828125,
-0.9339181780815125,
0.5274398326873779,
0.13276614248752594,
0.6954374313354492,
0.22522802650928497,
0.05109328776597977,
0.7201834917068481,
0.03392278030514717,
0.06954582780599594,
0.6147012114524841,
0.5150636434555054,
0.19703233242034912,
-0.39015230536460876,
0.037447333335876465,
-0.1693427860736847,
-0.41424834728240967,
-0.7499098777770996,
0.12577399611473083,
-1.1116442680358887,
-0.12185120582580566,
1.066090703010559,
-0.3783913850784302,
-0.019815849140286446,
-0.12447649240493774,
-0.15322968363761902,
0.1367855668067932,
-0.33455708622932434,
0.8432204723358154,
0.4894074499607086,
-0.46937820315361023,
0.16688352823257446,
-0.7921582460403442,
0.41084322333335876,
0.6576696038246155,
-1.3324514627456665,
-0.05899260193109512,
0.4851889908313751,
0.4663914740085602,
-0.3040851950645447,
0.8568356037139893,
-0.3592325747013092,
0.31461745500564575,
-0.462764710187912,
0.3094032108783722,
0.0931018590927124,
-0.20590342581272125,
-0.3263600170612335,
-0.1728697568178177,
0.2389276623725891,
0.22496479749679565
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08492v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08492v2
|
Rich Semantic Knowledge Enhanced Large Language Models for Few-shot Chinese Spell Checking
| 2024-03-13T12:55:43 | 2024-06-07T08:41:58 |
Ming Dong, Yujing Chen, Miao Zhang, Hao Sun, Tingting He
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Chinese Spell Checking (CSC) is a widely used technology, which plays a vital
role in speech to text (STT) and optical character recognition (OCR). Most of
the existing CSC approaches relying on BERT architecture achieve excellent
performance. However, limited by the scale of the foundation model, BERT-based
method does not work well in few-shot scenarios, showing certain limitations in
practical applications. In this paper, we explore using an in-context learning
method named RS-LLM (Rich Semantic based LLMs) to introduce large language
models (LLMs) as the foundation model. Besides, we study the impact of
introducing various Chinese rich semantic information in our framework. We
found that by introducing a small number of specific Chinese rich semantic
structures, LLMs achieve better performance than the BERT-based model on
few-shot CSC task. Furthermore, we conduct experiments on multiple datasets,
and the experimental results verified the superiority of our proposed
framework.
|
[
0.04631277918815613,
-0.7598717212677002,
0.5482991337776184,
0.018213575705885887,
-0.3009035289287567,
-0.2730821371078491,
-0.4793236553668976,
-0.7468376755714417,
-0.03439357131719589,
0.6497029662132263,
-0.4629081189632416,
-0.7612907290458679,
-0.5886713862419128,
0.2975284457206726,
-0.28889068961143494,
0.5913910269737244,
-0.08419249206781387,
0.2750603258609772,
0.28712475299835205,
0.03905953839421272,
-0.26363471150398254,
-0.2686644196510315,
-0.4648491144180298,
-0.3089534044265747,
0.4017234742641449,
0.5791712999343872,
0.569237470626831,
0.5570296049118042,
0.44562387466430664,
0.2713751792907715,
-0.4859437644481659,
0.5727777481079102,
-0.5333161354064941,
-0.20606975257396698,
0.02192472107708454,
-0.5598410367965698,
-0.29100334644317627,
-0.31745439767837524,
0.9259495735168457,
0.7191170454025269,
0.12130460143089294,
-0.21233591437339783,
0.38395076990127563,
0.4277738034725189,
-0.7760618925094604,
-0.08134327083826065,
-0.9023041725158691,
0.2030453234910965,
-0.32465651631355286,
-0.1174992173910141,
-0.5756905674934387,
-0.12169336527585983,
0.2996509075164795,
-0.5384909510612488,
0.14959457516670227,
-0.1207037940621376,
0.9278799295425415,
-0.018184317275881767,
-0.5167763233184814,
-0.3260290026664734,
-0.6391928195953369,
0.8895377516746521,
-1.0796884298324585,
0.41148310899734497,
0.5733094811439514,
0.27965420484542847,
-0.45713889598846436,
-0.5465786457061768,
-0.7770546078681946,
-0.28095656633377075,
-0.06281270831823349,
0.07753799855709076,
0.3647313416004181,
0.2860785126686096,
0.234266459941864,
0.22521059215068817,
-0.49528631567955017,
0.3296201527118683,
-0.08339768648147583,
-0.4125334918498993,
0.232744961977005,
0.23755310475826263,
0.35462772846221924,
-0.37807169556617737,
-0.4986693561077118,
-0.005559473764151335,
-1.0049554109573364,
0.03225554898381233,
-0.07753954082727432,
0.7204703092575073,
-0.16632774472236633,
0.5157530903816223,
-0.43606269359588623,
0.888703465461731,
-0.12765085697174072,
-0.5957948565483093,
-0.14741531014442444,
-0.35156750679016113,
-0.2527884840965271,
0.2584286332130432,
0.37480446696281433,
-0.2128077745437622,
0.19563718140125275,
-0.02379055693745613,
-0.3358176350593567,
-0.057842645794153214,
-0.30302971601486206,
-0.8437691330909729,
0.0013861561892554164,
0.004764729645103216,
-0.5046661496162415,
0.024450495839118958,
0.0723780170083046,
-0.26669836044311523,
-0.532698929309845,
-0.25691086053848267,
0.4053112268447876,
-0.639737606048584,
0.02318885177373886,
0.0672023594379425,
0.19295533001422882,
0.5885849595069885,
0.6339804530143738,
-0.9311696290969849,
-0.009069864638149738,
0.7615706324577332,
0.7821866869926453,
-0.16176290810108185,
-0.46852314472198486,
-0.686577320098877,
0.23035547137260437,
-0.4105551838874817,
0.9751189351081848,
-0.30725231766700745,
-0.20729507505893707,
0.2881694436073303,
-0.06298457086086273,
0.09666352719068527,
-0.4745835065841675,
0.47337689995765686,
-0.676729142665863,
-0.015168947167694569,
-0.3865109086036682,
-0.592104434967041,
-0.07080340385437012,
0.5670852065086365,
-0.5709861516952515,
1.104538083076477,
-0.03676316514611244,
-0.7300061583518982,
0.5705676674842834,
-0.2989754378795624,
-0.7947943806648254,
0.44208940863609314,
-0.12238050252199173,
-0.20659825205802917,
-0.09347889572381973,
0.16594843566417694,
0.7480027675628662,
-0.051198337227106094,
-0.08151043951511383,
-0.3804910182952881,
-0.6215559840202332,
0.08507251739501953,
-0.4180554449558258,
0.7796585559844971,
0.1646045595407486,
-0.3358157277107239,
0.0628901943564415,
-1.0219682455062866,
0.16433003544807434,
-0.08279899507761002,
-0.6341612935066223,
-0.5270538330078125,
0.058078013360500336,
0.10633953660726547,
0.3458148241043091,
0.2528286576271057,
-0.650170624256134,
0.07448035478591919,
-0.8212330937385559,
0.3608470559120178,
0.6735225319862366,
-0.2664368450641632,
0.373878538608551,
0.08481059223413467,
-0.09754757583141327,
0.0665612742304802,
-0.0005498337559401989,
-0.01963886246085167,
-0.3390102982521057,
-0.8550930619239807,
-0.502329409122467,
0.37599626183509827,
0.6676681637763977,
-0.9443364143371582,
0.44222721457481384,
-0.22927412390708923,
-0.24409987032413483,
-0.16019421815872192,
0.5076289176940918,
0.30158472061157227,
0.33832547068595886,
0.2307184487581253,
-0.33120185136795044,
-0.3222089111804962,
-0.504635751247406,
-0.1893673539161682,
-0.1580112725496292,
-0.0800229087471962,
0.3832564055919647,
0.49872833490371704,
-0.2916950583457947,
0.9508543014526367,
-0.4114660322666168,
-0.6679955720901489,
-0.5807182788848877,
-0.0972243994474411,
0.16354988515377045,
0.18614952266216278,
0.26918718218803406,
-0.5006535649299622,
-0.6528753638267517,
0.1656283736228943,
-0.49771174788475037,
0.0016810190863907337,
-0.07791736721992493,
-0.17918060719966888,
0.3304719030857086,
0.1459168791770935,
-0.23198091983795166,
0.5618876218795776,
0.4606703519821167,
-0.35258185863494873,
0.5627672672271729,
-0.25178685784339905,
0.21125200390815735,
-1.0528690814971924,
-0.11623431742191315,
0.011873145587742329,
-0.1800294667482376,
-0.701431930065155,
0.10525017231702805,
0.45155999064445496,
0.044710878282785416,
-0.853864848613739,
0.5265519022941589,
-0.37165534496307373,
-0.2013072371482849,
-0.5429298877716064,
0.5081197023391724,
-0.08588971942663193,
0.4044780135154724,
0.36143210530281067,
0.47731202840805054,
0.35079535841941833,
-0.8442532420158386,
0.2388734221458435,
0.27798667550086975,
-0.6916552186012268,
0.5488858222961426,
-0.4536168575286865,
-0.1027507334947586,
0.1821642816066742,
0.25201407074928284,
-1.0144894123077393,
-0.25756555795669556,
-0.09340467303991318,
-0.323234885931015,
0.2639782428741455,
0.08046198636293411,
-0.9621829390525818,
-0.1797727793455124,
-0.11334355175495148,
0.05754203349351883,
0.20782612264156342,
-1.058886170387268,
0.7670266032218933,
-0.17878073453903198,
0.19294962286949158,
-0.5501924753189087,
-1.0580754280090332,
0.09119146317243576,
0.09510175883769989,
-1.026150107383728,
0.40661919116973877,
0.13182146847248077,
-0.03810981661081314,
-0.16531552374362946,
0.1282489001750946,
-0.4079684615135193,
0.24749504029750824,
-0.012390850111842155,
0.4525831639766693,
-0.43909457325935364,
0.12399566173553467,
0.0346248485147953,
0.06355060636997223,
-0.5103667378425598,
-0.10870634764432907,
0.26588791608810425,
0.022564580664038658,
-0.41837480664253235,
-0.4917027950286865,
0.2454766035079956,
0.3188299536705017,
-0.2890786826610565,
0.9310011863708496,
0.5215099453926086,
-0.5655021071434021,
-0.7317765951156616,
-0.6216662526130676,
-0.4081108272075653,
-0.4595016837120056,
0.4948461353778839,
-0.29695022106170654,
-1.1860706806182861,
0.66737300157547,
-0.21812871098518372,
0.07993205636739731,
0.37425681948661804,
0.5221831202507019,
0.0015575402649119496,
0.7894216775894165,
0.7981727719306946,
-0.2207411676645279,
0.5774418711662292,
-0.006994114723056555,
0.23513643443584442,
-0.5411444306373596,
0.15442201495170593,
-0.44448259472846985,
-0.06806611269712448,
-0.25070905685424805,
-0.3547517657279968,
0.3883380889892578,
0.31789466738700867,
-0.02948109246790409,
0.4966478943824768,
-0.17164863646030426,
0.3954835832118988,
0.3584055006504059,
0.34262174367904663,
0.4562991261482239,
-0.003110787132754922,
-0.4644019901752472,
-0.026641307398676872,
-0.7216521501541138,
-0.47174501419067383,
0.7724443078041077,
0.29749178886413574,
0.7607373595237732,
0.15001504123210907,
0.5760723352432251,
-0.06004868820309639,
0.09075887501239777,
-0.9047131538391113,
0.6696718335151672,
-0.5200753808021545,
-0.6264302134513855,
-0.442028284072876,
-0.2914285659790039,
-0.5340720415115356,
0.4106267988681793,
-0.6088438034057617,
-0.5177420377731323,
0.07179354131221771,
0.1384086161851883,
-0.5839946866035461,
0.4257350564002991,
-0.5849873423576355,
0.5722517371177673,
-0.4838092029094696,
-0.5635272264480591,
-0.35831499099731445,
-0.6309391856193542,
0.5400954484939575,
-0.07545121759176254,
-0.05417269468307495,
0.11199203878641129,
0.17776411771774292,
0.47888994216918945,
-0.5638731122016907,
1.2082401514053345,
0.12232482433319092,
-0.3783612847328186,
0.4344656467437744,
-0.12667202949523926,
0.9259068369865417,
-0.33450210094451904,
-0.21726152300834656,
0.3374454081058502,
-0.017205972224473953,
-0.3680957853794098,
-0.40571025013923645,
0.7550469636917114,
-0.6939431428909302,
-0.1671452671289444,
-0.30006012320518494,
-0.26683133840560913,
-0.20622478425502777,
0.34780552983283997,
0.18558984994888306,
0.36429768800735474,
-0.27560222148895264,
0.2600301206111908,
0.9301096796989441,
-0.4732390344142914,
0.3312920331954956,
0.9578239917755127,
0.2892225384712219,
-0.22660386562347412,
0.5960147976875305,
0.23343200981616974,
0.42156970500946045,
0.6024765968322754,
0.3488205373287201,
0.12316468358039856,
-0.5730239748954773,
-0.4041784703731537,
0.16962476074695587,
-0.983573853969574,
-0.13461484014987946,
-0.3560187816619873,
-0.22155942022800446,
-0.7178575992584229,
-0.1968650072813034,
-0.4208407402038574,
0.08808106929063797,
-0.42708951234817505,
0.25110238790512085,
0.19072653353214264,
0.5999539494514465,
0.1323285847902298,
0.5726955533027649,
-0.8723697066307068,
0.354057252407074,
0.32940685749053955,
0.609562873840332,
0.1499246507883072,
-0.627403974533081,
-0.5593106746673584,
-0.08334165811538696,
-0.20184887945652008,
-0.6257399320602417,
0.29966455698013306,
0.29339760541915894,
0.5656043291091919,
0.787948727607727,
0.06873363256454468,
0.9098504781723022,
-0.6182878017425537,
0.9752296805381775,
-0.12308669835329056,
-1.067389965057373,
0.3435429036617279,
-0.04664624482393265,
0.3565528690814972,
0.4687005579471588,
-0.023252278566360474,
-0.8053825497627258,
-0.08804459869861603,
-0.07343415170907974,
-0.700442910194397,
0.7751724123954773,
-0.06374047696590424,
-0.13309481739997864,
0.019950704649090767,
0.40972697734832764,
-0.025265585631132126,
-0.3648312985897064,
-0.7400307655334473,
-0.05057506635785103,
0.11148203909397125,
-0.10155419260263443,
0.2234053760766983,
-0.6075771450996399,
0.30636072158813477,
0.07601164281368256,
0.8758695125579834,
-0.2493782937526703,
-0.11929088085889816,
0.30803242325782776,
-0.4224667549133301,
-0.028593044728040695,
0.5034310221672058,
0.7342355251312256,
0.13868272304534912,
0.07351646572351456,
0.13629259169101715,
0.6990441083908081,
-0.4234730005264282,
-0.41034698486328125,
-0.22930966317653656,
-0.050839170813560486,
-0.15293504297733307,
0.7616017460823059,
0.6877660751342773,
0.5620299577713013,
-0.6360338926315308,
0.5325031876564026,
0.24753358960151672,
-0.19063961505889893,
-0.18002162873744965,
-0.09625514596700668,
-0.05495435371994972,
0.23843248188495636,
0.2824214696884155,
-0.31457772850990295,
0.021379360929131508,
-0.3141206204891205,
0.13995325565338135,
0.6532862186431885,
-0.30496054887771606,
0.005968471523374319,
0.15491138398647308,
0.28049004077911377,
0.1994558721780777,
0.5857281684875488,
-0.017162969335913658,
-0.9844534397125244,
0.44761183857917786,
0.5996442437171936,
0.6974151134490967,
-0.18721410632133484,
-0.1999242752790451,
0.4490569829940796,
0.4255323112010956,
-0.48440825939178467,
0.006115845870226622,
-0.41973379254341125,
-0.9196639657020569,
-0.584463357925415,
-0.4527703523635864,
-0.5149949193000793,
-0.01464381068944931,
-0.11054549366235733,
0.7227194905281067,
-0.5144813656806946,
0.16577140986919403,
-0.4312940239906311,
0.34539151191711426,
-0.6094493269920349,
0.28399813175201416,
0.5765082836151123,
0.9099646806716919,
-0.8820213675498962,
1.215289831161499,
0.3578353524208069,
-0.040082842111587524,
-1.1208237409591675,
0.019807374104857445,
0.1522078812122345,
-0.9008522629737854,
1.0387581586837769,
0.09239280223846436,
-0.35591796040534973,
-0.19643819332122803,
-0.7179206013679504,
-0.857151448726654,
1.104651927947998,
-0.026949839666485786,
-0.580782413482666,
0.14560279250144958,
0.34441059827804565,
0.6925767064094543,
-0.21505510807037354,
0.2829747796058655,
0.3968889117240906,
0.44442033767700195,
0.41426873207092285,
-0.9314946532249451,
-0.22847974300384521,
0.12233004719018936,
0.2323095053434372,
-0.24013447761535645,
-0.5090324282646179,
0.7196179628372192,
-0.21769921481609344,
-0.5172176957130432,
0.3110620379447937,
1.0387717485427856,
0.36363157629966736,
0.1368671953678131,
0.5016290545463562,
0.38176751136779785,
0.6146798133850098,
0.12174713611602783,
0.8068366050720215,
-0.31765100359916687,
0.28908228874206543,
1.0630638599395752,
-0.644014835357666,
1.2587320804595947,
0.29652246832847595,
-0.07020680606365204,
0.5359484553337097,
0.5426478385925293,
-0.014162015169858932,
0.37910154461860657,
0.2539377510547638,
-0.3130684494972229,
-0.6074899435043335,
-0.03954119235277176,
-0.15949709713459015,
0.549260675907135,
0.4532354474067688,
-0.34396764636039734,
-0.4126824736595154,
0.08555696904659271,
-0.2580952048301697,
0.19500839710235596,
-0.4237951338291168,
0.8380332589149475,
0.12402962893247604,
-0.27316126227378845,
0.4717288613319397,
0.36173832416534424,
1.325830101966858,
-0.900422990322113,
-0.13711656630039215,
-0.11732065677642822,
0.4034567177295685,
-0.3937698304653168,
-0.47731050848960876,
-0.08328341692686081,
0.08569328486919403,
-0.14525777101516724,
0.05310158431529999,
1.1336714029312134,
-0.6394674181938171,
-0.3355216681957245,
0.3249548077583313,
0.1551549732685089,
0.1338900327682495,
0.05598832666873932,
-0.5093518495559692,
0.013345127925276756,
-0.1353478580713272,
-0.10163503885269165,
0.3591950237751007,
0.5524855852127075,
-0.09296126663684845,
0.4820506274700165,
0.5825270414352417,
0.24670733511447906,
0.05671364441514015,
0.029560890048742294,
0.5930569767951965,
-0.636570394039154,
-0.6914181709289551,
-0.788837730884552,
0.21002988517284393,
0.18155740201473236,
-0.14753791689872742,
0.9426134824752808,
0.30316677689552307,
0.8788561820983887,
-0.03916294127702713,
0.6336132884025574,
0.20625147223472595,
0.6394913792610168,
-0.5698705911636353,
0.9690456986427307,
-0.5596557855606079,
0.36003783345222473,
-0.5282182097434998,
-0.732366144657135,
-0.6693689823150635,
0.6891982555389404,
-0.4424927234649658,
-0.09827923029661179,
0.711779773235321,
0.9588737487792969,
0.1714259386062622,
0.05470488592982292,
0.7671202421188354,
0.11388102918863297,
0.19460377097129822,
0.9467239379882812,
0.7247400283813477,
-0.40058431029319763,
0.47272956371307373,
-0.3404494822025299,
-0.2943013608455658,
-0.43241697549819946,
-0.9441447854042053,
-1.1788272857666016,
-0.37581896781921387,
-0.09461484104394913,
-0.5959888696670532,
-0.13224296271800995,
1.0828191041946411,
0.5646451711654663,
-0.9349263310432434,
0.054534912109375,
0.2597500681877136,
0.22251075506210327,
-0.23966343700885773,
-0.1809884011745453,
0.5783111453056335,
-0.21724121272563934,
-0.6886687874794006,
0.3999772369861603,
0.24934132397174835,
0.00563026312738657,
-0.24095945060253143,
-0.09762724488973618,
-0.21094849705696106,
0.06996578723192215,
0.9391974806785583,
0.28901976346969604,
-0.9477226734161377,
-0.4166891574859619,
0.05647754296660423,
-0.6492226719856262,
-0.19901148974895477,
0.700872004032135,
-0.7511786818504333,
0.4432242512702942,
0.7565951347351074,
0.8336856961250305,
0.03836777061223984,
-0.3381815552711487,
0.15640577673912048,
-0.5478476881980896,
0.07373970001935959,
-0.11055062711238861,
0.45245376229286194,
0.4356756806373596,
-0.5479374527931213,
0.09979117661714554,
0.19604100286960602,
-0.3037578761577606,
-0.5408215522766113,
0.09973219037055969,
-0.9818229675292969,
-0.4089612066745758,
1.4178996086120605,
-0.27036625146865845,
-0.3848436772823334,
-0.09071605652570724,
-0.2669130265712738,
0.32223522663116455,
-0.13308922946453094,
0.6876186728477478,
0.7668095827102661,
0.2012602537870407,
0.09614810347557068,
-0.17555364966392517,
0.3630375266075134,
0.6135869026184082,
-0.6290158629417419,
0.10496052354574203,
0.4720821678638458,
0.42116647958755493,
-0.07563856989145279,
0.2664029896259308,
-0.13576416671276093,
0.33590754866600037,
-0.1764199435710907,
0.25078025460243225,
0.0232807919383049,
-0.15121443569660187,
-0.39811062812805176,
0.19188569486141205,
0.07984767854213715,
0.15690363943576813
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08484v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08484v1
|
Data-oriented Dynamic Fine-tuning Parameter Selection Strategy for FISH Mask based Efficient Fine-tuning
| 2024-03-13T12:50:23 | 2024-03-13T12:50:23 |
Ming Dong, Kang Xue, Bolong Zheng, Tingting He
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In view of the huge number of parameters of Large language models (LLMs) ,
tuning all parameters is very costly, and accordingly fine-tuning specific
parameters is more sensible. Most of parameter efficient fine-tuning (PEFT)
concentrate on parameter selection strategies, such as additive method,
selective method and reparametrization-based method. However, there are few
methods that consider the impact of data samples on parameter selecting, such
as Fish Mask based method. Fish Mask randomly choose a part of data samples and
treat them equally during parameter selection, which is unable to dynamically
select optimal parameters for inconstant data distributions. In this work, we
adopt a data-oriented perspective, then proposing an IRD ($\mathrm{\underline
I}$terative sample-parameter $\mathrm{\underline R}$ange $\mathrm{\underline
D}$ecreasing) algorithm to search the best setting of sample-parameter pair for
FISH Mask. In each iteration, by searching the set of samples and parameters
with larger Fish information, IRD can find better sample-parameter pair in most
scale. We demonstrate the effectiveness and rationality of proposed strategy by
conducting experiments on GLUE benchmark. Experimental results show our
strategy optimizes the parameter selection and achieves preferable performance.
|
[
-0.8289414644241333,
-1.2100906372070312,
0.33634206652641296,
0.03246123716235161,
-0.7536880970001221,
0.1713128536939621,
-0.41363149881362915,
-0.4397662580013275,
0.4165040850639343,
0.46405264735221863,
-0.6201951503753662,
-0.4039023518562317,
-0.38336077332496643,
0.08102595061063766,
-0.030119389295578003,
0.701081395149231,
-0.05802636593580246,
-0.22576986253261566,
0.09648334234952927,
-0.12494293600320816,
-0.4392144978046417,
0.0486176572740078,
-0.8808633685112,
-0.14050863683223724,
0.7101913690567017,
0.6547544598579407,
0.4368021488189697,
1.381530523300171,
0.641381025314331,
0.25504231452941895,
-0.22197778522968292,
0.5185850858688354,
-0.5154111981391907,
0.40485963225364685,
-0.27160772681236267,
-0.5240463018417358,
-0.273233026266098,
0.2037694901227951,
0.5390905737876892,
0.5567572116851807,
-0.13439370691776276,
0.3570895493030548,
-0.0591093972325325,
0.8276264071464539,
-0.7231323719024658,
0.03951604664325714,
-0.7289313673973083,
0.15996162593364716,
-0.7132759094238281,
-0.6112978458404541,
-0.24828775227069855,
-0.08941284567117691,
-0.1252615600824356,
-0.5147981643676758,
-0.03919633850455284,
0.1584353744983673,
0.8591625094413757,
0.28249886631965637,
-0.16315585374832153,
-0.0008604978793300688,
-0.866981565952301,
0.8386674523353577,
-0.6878822445869446,
0.4288187623023987,
0.41416963934898376,
0.1975264549255371,
-0.24913527071475983,
-0.5978156328201294,
-0.2877822518348694,
0.036913689225912094,
0.322981059551239,
-0.10534816980361938,
0.3972429037094116,
0.06071573495864868,
0.23386293649673462,
0.39537742733955383,
-0.43262210488319397,
0.30885106325149536,
-0.05875437334179878,
-0.05349168926477432,
0.712181568145752,
0.008710631169378757,
0.08906272053718567,
0.39950013160705566,
-0.5654546022415161,
-0.40471962094306946,
-0.6845782399177551,
0.07202577590942383,
0.6391032338142395,
0.5733386278152466,
0.04668913036584854,
0.3796333968639374,
-0.5529428124427795,
0.9414858222007751,
0.5198774933815002,
-0.396538108587265,
0.1276380568742752,
0.04143616557121277,
-0.21076300740242004,
-0.008927213959395885,
0.2921370267868042,
0.2583276629447937,
0.22356049716472626,
0.11888676136732101,
-0.5087080597877502,
-0.06328530609607697,
-0.0591026246547699,
-0.6771379113197327,
-0.23362384736537933,
0.24949787557125092,
-0.5213800668716431,
-0.5029747486114502,
-0.07930854707956314,
-0.93657386302948,
-0.17438696324825287,
-0.6266610026359558,
0.5822897553443909,
-0.19980570673942566,
-0.2852720022201538,
0.14819662272930145,
0.08209678530693054,
0.23323558270931244,
0.3148098587989807,
-0.8748835921287537,
0.18622536957263947,
0.6222416162490845,
0.6728507280349731,
-0.4852354824542999,
-0.017575522884726524,
-1.0293341875076294,
0.30945777893066406,
-0.21751423180103302,
1.2904577255249023,
-1.013094425201416,
-0.00547014269977808,
-0.40608686208724976,
-0.12514172494411469,
-0.2382226288318634,
-0.7249883413314819,
0.4116149842739105,
-0.6660158634185791,
-0.01504380814731121,
-0.013069281354546547,
-0.7177698612213135,
-0.27497223019599915,
0.12130307406187057,
-0.7189775109291077,
0.6011144518852234,
0.07286158204078674,
-0.6124923229217529,
0.5564326643943787,
-0.7095832228660583,
-0.30824851989746094,
0.23949095606803894,
-0.26811620593070984,
-0.7011222839355469,
-0.09999193996191025,
0.26364102959632874,
0.5182194709777832,
-0.252830445766449,
0.3040158748626709,
-0.754466712474823,
-0.6692063212394714,
0.18924134969711304,
-0.516450822353363,
0.3360801041126251,
0.6440211534500122,
-0.5803745985031128,
-0.0662192702293396,
-0.6960954070091248,
0.3903456926345825,
-0.02639106474816799,
-0.5781846046447754,
-0.23705370724201202,
0.1942671239376068,
0.15953943133354187,
-0.23823665082454681,
-0.005619420669972897,
-0.41618895530700684,
0.20541039109230042,
-0.2796129882335663,
0.24590903520584106,
1.0239012241363525,
0.2577202022075653,
0.2778545916080475,
-0.44017717242240906,
0.5977981686592102,
-0.11828172951936722,
0.3094201385974884,
0.04626022279262543,
-0.17676317691802979,
-0.3478802442550659,
-0.7543083429336548,
0.7455684542655945,
0.4533338248729706,
-0.6120103597640991,
0.33484071493148804,
0.26379045844078064,
-0.4374614953994751,
-0.3080486059188843,
0.3180982172489166,
0.3905247747898102,
0.41919341683387756,
-0.0143591882660985,
-0.20922885835170746,
-0.2686551511287689,
-0.9461098313331604,
-0.5101643800735474,
0.1469201147556305,
0.15349169075489044,
0.40916576981544495,
-0.040960606187582016,
-0.055093009024858475,
0.7029449343681335,
-0.8717423677444458,
-0.4304506182670593,
-0.05979127436876297,
-0.2369755208492279,
0.5169051885604858,
0.540653645992279,
0.6536430716514587,
-1.1422749757766724,
-0.823464572429657,
-0.0077636209316551685,
-0.1695961207151413,
-0.1522650569677353,
-0.07758639007806778,
-0.30589425563812256,
0.18478474020957947,
0.5090163946151733,
-0.2260058969259262,
0.18937690556049347,
0.45885899662971497,
-0.34536126255989075,
0.1766025871038437,
-0.20348118245601654,
0.09104632586240768,
-0.6813828349113464,
0.15312570333480835,
0.1854071170091629,
-0.17610369622707367,
-0.3917207419872284,
0.3024378716945648,
0.05365777760744095,
0.1269662231206894,
-0.2978988587856293,
0.4592066705226898,
-0.46858227252960205,
0.3913421034812927,
-0.34715110063552856,
-0.1622970849275589,
-0.21041052043437958,
0.5512415170669556,
0.024283921346068382,
0.5314593315124512,
0.658168375492096,
-0.5362442135810852,
0.4544212520122528,
-0.14988696575164795,
-0.37370505928993225,
0.6156896352767944,
-0.41738927364349365,
0.19856953620910645,
-0.10082069784402847,
0.03203209117054939,
-0.8810135126113892,
-0.23641809821128845,
0.3569537401199341,
-0.08087410777807236,
0.7195509076118469,
-0.2386271208524704,
-0.47849041223526,
0.04365502670407295,
-0.61442631483078,
0.5178682804107666,
0.3056918978691101,
-0.5329950451850891,
0.2726723551750183,
0.6225795745849609,
-0.387643963098526,
-0.24358099699020386,
-0.38543784618377686,
-0.07706540077924728,
-0.7328605055809021,
-0.43689295649528503,
0.4015760123729706,
-0.48481112718582153,
-0.15780675411224365,
-0.377201646566391,
-0.3789937496185303,
-0.04176591709256172,
0.017501894384622574,
-0.3203086256980896,
0.20422311127185822,
-0.38071906566619873,
-0.07744012773036957,
0.24115142226219177,
-0.36729779839515686,
-0.43175652623176575,
-0.1752588003873825,
0.6600369215011597,
0.02991092950105667,
-0.4788830876350403,
-0.2279791235923767,
0.34116172790527344,
0.539566695690155,
-0.5019201636314392,
0.399393767118454,
0.5765772461891174,
-0.06647982448339462,
-0.43577054142951965,
-0.9222081899642944,
-0.300309956073761,
-0.5692469477653503,
0.21538586914539337,
-0.308861643075943,
-0.5759710669517517,
0.6485719084739685,
-0.3804016411304474,
-0.09371666610240936,
0.06366974115371704,
0.25011155009269714,
-0.14173883199691772,
0.9544086456298828,
0.33265653252601624,
0.05379565805196762,
0.6559966206550598,
-0.2558281719684601,
0.07893545180559158,
-0.7907279133796692,
-0.07757554203271866,
-0.34515437483787537,
-0.9007925987243652,
-0.7254058122634888,
-0.19839222729206085,
0.5752336978912354,
0.07102002948522568,
-0.10451038926839828,
0.027110010385513306,
-0.666403591632843,
0.635205090045929,
0.7381809949874878,
0.43463656306266785,
0.3000270426273346,
0.3189062774181366,
-0.09632112830877304,
0.11230931431055069,
-0.5078353881835938,
-0.23989257216453552,
1.0782984495162964,
0.29975202679634094,
0.9624478220939636,
-0.13560286164283752,
0.6270304322242737,
0.16260749101638794,
-0.35259801149368286,
-0.4816162586212158,
0.6162333488464355,
-0.27654358744621277,
-0.4341622292995453,
-0.5064679980278015,
-0.24674510955810547,
-0.915908694267273,
0.2022642195224762,
-0.08827601373195648,
-0.6432608962059021,
0.6267812848091125,
0.24424254894256592,
-0.24291713535785675,
0.4889233410358429,
-0.7040525674819946,
0.37513062357902527,
-0.1611563116312027,
-0.40948235988616943,
-0.12335469573736191,
-0.5442758798599243,
0.04065767675638199,
-0.5444873571395874,
0.18857085704803467,
-0.3453715443611145,
-0.33017832040786743,
0.6664153337478638,
-0.19716283679008484,
0.5477604269981384,
-0.5044159293174744,
-0.2541990280151367,
0.0806221142411232,
0.06139327213168144,
0.9017224311828613,
0.37863337993621826,
-0.33037859201431274,
-0.1045132502913475,
0.0860310047864914,
-0.2643906772136688,
-0.41733357310295105,
0.8174405097961426,
-0.44200965762138367,
-0.5878767967224121,
-0.11174473166465759,
-0.5387781858444214,
-0.4003876745700836,
0.2774583101272583,
0.23437562584877014,
0.572600781917572,
0.500091552734375,
0.5204449892044067,
0.9842315912246704,
-0.17682626843452454,
0.5395464897155762,
0.9057798385620117,
0.08028999716043472,
-0.5299663543701172,
0.9432551860809326,
0.35956496000289917,
0.3543582260608673,
0.49435266852378845,
0.23177506029605865,
-0.08633140474557877,
-0.64149409532547,
-0.34900590777397156,
0.32415688037872314,
-0.32175344228744507,
-0.5062583684921265,
-0.12398480623960495,
-0.1608707755804062,
0.043014708906412125,
-0.05671340599656105,
-0.5587945580482483,
-0.08556479215621948,
-0.18620213866233826,
0.2031897008419037,
0.5881282687187195,
0.03925333544611931,
-0.200190007686615,
-0.014597692526876926,
-0.36542725563049316,
0.6970871686935425,
0.287356436252594,
1.1026055812835693,
-0.21764686703681946,
-0.29949522018432617,
-0.19470569491386414,
0.3451753854751587,
-0.25554367899894714,
-0.5123887658119202,
0.17803549766540527,
0.4961773455142975,
0.678646981716156,
0.5997523665428162,
0.43961551785469055,
0.8007996678352356,
-0.13930028676986694,
0.15462787449359894,
-0.35776081681251526,
-0.5438634157180786,
0.7459086179733276,
-0.6457982659339905,
0.19026285409927368,
0.5942196846008301,
-0.13752739131450653,
-0.15808740258216858,
-0.546097457408905,
-0.5720511674880981,
-0.9555540680885315,
0.8777517080307007,
0.12562832236289978,
-0.06636670976877213,
0.2637229263782501,
0.5566021203994751,
0.29293179512023926,
0.050262950360774994,
-0.2752206027507782,
-0.4232189357280731,
0.5090072751045227,
0.08305393159389496,
-0.07470443844795227,
-0.07991094142198563,
0.05159956216812134,
-0.6055439710617065,
0.5511335134506226,
-0.29984548687934875,
0.3035052418708801,
0.01016556192189455,
0.32835668325424194,
-0.6473350524902344,
0.013713222928345203,
0.7438255548477173,
0.6662309765815735,
-0.4665108919143677,
-0.034235041588544846,
0.018688460811972618,
-0.6618397235870361,
0.0627204105257988,
0.04927739128470421,
-0.2469143569469452,
-0.04781746864318848,
0.048283252865076065,
0.7046380639076233,
0.07314404100179672,
-0.6979950070381165,
0.2972409129142761,
0.22271086275577545,
-0.27463433146476746,
-0.018234742805361748,
0.5703509449958801,
0.007683142088353634,
0.55427086353302,
0.4968726336956024,
0.1462610512971878,
0.027500981464982033,
-0.40173524618148804,
0.32200250029563904,
0.624710202217102,
-0.06596245616674423,
-0.019503846764564514,
0.5330683588981628,
-0.10557630658149719,
-0.3100638687610626,
0.4846751391887665,
0.16772378981113434,
-0.0526939295232296,
0.789714515209198,
0.4223474860191345,
0.6885437965393066,
-0.44925856590270996,
0.22943860292434692,
0.018846936523914337,
-0.09952378273010254,
-0.11258642375469208,
0.525934100151062,
-0.08034410327672958,
-0.49567076563835144,
-0.47650688886642456,
-0.6022027134895325,
-0.2053695172071457,
0.4716370701789856,
-0.7848162651062012,
0.6175581216812134,
-0.34249070286750793,
0.07264084368944168,
-0.011328605003654957,
0.32695549726486206,
-0.3841829299926758,
0.21873459219932556,
0.03642473369836807,
1.0344548225402832,
-0.6499449014663696,
0.934222400188446,
0.7114448547363281,
0.011273777112364769,
-0.8252210021018982,
0.047187600284814835,
-0.11561623960733414,
-0.8127843141555786,
0.39607253670692444,
-0.320950984954834,
0.12448908388614655,
0.09952528029680252,
-0.7184737324714661,
-1.2311490774154663,
1.071711778640747,
0.7041134834289551,
-0.7034472227096558,
0.30440419912338257,
0.0730222836136818,
0.3564087152481079,
-0.3315681517124176,
-0.004986973479390144,
0.5023117065429688,
0.7923469543457031,
0.4027816653251648,
-1.0338778495788574,
-0.027557017281651497,
-0.3543873131275177,
0.18030132353305817,
0.4943138360977173,
-0.8872624039649963,
0.8068988919258118,
0.11007988452911377,
-0.1123569905757904,
-0.1250520646572113,
0.22333015501499176,
0.4399842619895935,
0.3973290026187897,
0.7402161359786987,
0.26729825139045715,
0.5941959023475647,
0.2061927765607834,
0.5592896938323975,
-0.30932310223579407,
0.4548704922199249,
0.9001024961471558,
-0.2081623375415802,
0.9750270247459412,
0.7389611005783081,
-0.21225175261497498,
0.12059164047241211,
0.8778772950172424,
-0.42304959893226624,
1.034306526184082,
0.2654964327812195,
-0.14368870854377747,
-0.3080272674560547,
0.07560838013887405,
-0.4216175377368927,
0.6281682848930359,
0.2958819270133972,
-0.28854426741600037,
-0.2892340421676636,
0.28939878940582275,
-0.15173879265785217,
-0.014751262031495571,
-0.2034708708524704,
1.008012294769287,
-0.1577366292476654,
-0.7446981072425842,
0.8544502258300781,
-0.03849649056792259,
0.7365120649337769,
-0.47391098737716675,
-0.0834740474820137,
-0.47336435317993164,
0.4326914846897125,
-0.1879642903804779,
-0.7396186590194702,
0.09356871992349625,
-0.2615807354450226,
-0.1609564870595932,
-0.2478967010974884,
0.7185272574424744,
-0.5437434911727905,
-0.3213730454444885,
-0.13882210850715637,
0.12636393308639526,
-0.11299610882997513,
-0.2029007524251938,
-0.5691147446632385,
0.4010274410247803,
0.10610959678888321,
-0.5623781681060791,
0.6044692397117615,
0.32050254940986633,
0.05374867841601372,
0.8673227429389954,
0.6384705901145935,
0.5836219787597656,
-0.35184210538864136,
-0.38840919733047485,
0.9254345893859863,
-0.48265132308006287,
-0.6173812747001648,
-0.8284023404121399,
0.3683103322982788,
0.08556121587753296,
-0.08371244370937347,
0.35360223054885864,
0.6063113212585449,
0.8129288554191589,
-0.16027222573757172,
0.37487488985061646,
0.0367351695895195,
0.842266321182251,
-0.6861230134963989,
0.638625979423523,
-0.556474506855011,
0.5815650820732117,
-0.6520600318908691,
-1.376390814781189,
-0.43564629554748535,
0.6418232917785645,
-0.02233077771961689,
0.0775943249464035,
0.3602936863899231,
1.0057917833328247,
-0.3795105516910553,
0.026017431169748306,
0.16198082268238068,
0.08653968572616577,
0.22661490738391876,
0.35497474670410156,
0.4338214099407196,
-0.185252383351326,
0.3215426504611969,
-0.34453174471855164,
-0.22297094762325287,
-0.31829023361206055,
-0.9923095703125,
-0.5977046489715576,
-0.7226521968841553,
-0.7224701046943665,
0.21948374807834625,
-0.007104760035872459,
0.9309355616569519,
0.8812052607536316,
-0.7005756497383118,
-0.20332880318164825,
0.058324184268713,
-0.04115278646349907,
-0.35985100269317627,
-0.2818189561367035,
0.42444536089897156,
-0.33952566981315613,
-0.7211331129074097,
0.18586337566375732,
0.4509211480617523,
-0.018632881343364716,
-0.04103048890829086,
0.08291185647249222,
-0.20220240950584412,
0.18837036192417145,
0.39562898874282837,
0.2600973844528198,
-0.7459961175918579,
-0.37619736790657043,
-0.13454274833202362,
0.3282028138637543,
0.018407925963401794,
0.43707355856895447,
-0.7541698217391968,
0.5180167555809021,
0.35797736048698425,
0.40565207600593567,
0.569549560546875,
-0.16133883595466614,
0.6778969764709473,
-0.558140754699707,
0.038474515080451965,
0.06910930573940277,
-0.025109821930527687,
-0.1738666594028473,
-0.5966774821281433,
0.6058417558670044,
0.08140773326158524,
-0.48970332741737366,
-1.1172109842300415,
-0.009951325133442879,
-1.0140182971954346,
-0.4116995632648468,
1.2346477508544922,
0.05584777891635895,
-0.011903236620128155,
0.05002511665225029,
-0.38365763425827026,
0.06037133187055588,
-0.28723660111427307,
0.8297791481018066,
0.34483203291893005,
-0.3213033974170685,
-0.34595614671707153,
-0.34829992055892944,
0.5600922107696533,
0.22847211360931396,
-0.5846026539802551,
-0.06697378307580948,
0.12323939800262451,
0.42752838134765625,
-0.2630937397480011,
0.17229075729846954,
0.00700516439974308,
0.11871695518493652,
-0.38101643323898315,
-0.6264181733131409,
-0.18945738673210144,
-0.09992397576570511,
-0.001741955173201859,
0.1505541056394577,
0.18835483491420746,
-0.2959822714328766
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08462v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08462v1
|
Authorship Verification based on the Likelihood Ratio of Grammar Models
| 2024-03-13T12:25:47 | 2024-03-13T12:25:47 |
Andrea Nini, Oren Halvani, Lukas Graner, Valerio Gherardi, Shunichi Ishihara
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Authorship Verification (AV) is the process of analyzing a set of documents
to determine whether they were written by a specific author. This problem often
arises in forensic scenarios, e.g., in cases where the documents in question
constitute evidence for a crime. Existing state-of-the-art AV methods use
computational solutions that are not supported by a plausible scientific
explanation for their functioning and that are often difficult for analysts to
interpret. To address this, we propose a method relying on calculating a
quantity we call $\lambda_G$ (LambdaG): the ratio between the likelihood of a
document given a model of the Grammar for the candidate author and the
likelihood of the same document given a model of the Grammar for a reference
population. These Grammar Models are estimated using $n$-gram language models
that are trained solely on grammatical features. Despite not needing large
amounts of data for training, LambdaG still outperforms other established AV
methods with higher computational complexity, including a fine-tuned Siamese
Transformer network. Our empirical evaluation based on four baseline methods
applied to twelve datasets shows that LambdaG leads to better results in terms
of both accuracy and AUC in eleven cases and in all twelve cases if considering
only topic-agnostic methods. The algorithm is also highly robust to important
variations in the genre of the reference population in many cross-genre
comparisons. In addition to these properties, we demonstrate how LambdaG is
easier to interpret than the current state-of-the-art. We argue that the
advantage of LambdaG over other methods is due to fact that it is compatible
with Cognitive Linguistic theories of language processing.
|
[
-0.29147571325302124,
-0.645398736000061,
0.7613937854766846,
-0.0950457900762558,
-0.03990120068192482,
-0.12418895959854126,
-0.22040687501430511,
-0.32110145688056946,
0.06833082437515259,
0.3786873519420624,
-0.392137736082077,
-0.41999951004981995,
-0.8860098719596863,
0.4768631160259247,
-0.543015718460083,
0.707054615020752,
0.42012926936149597,
0.12479163706302643,
-0.7298124432563782,
-0.16616369783878326,
-0.18107613921165466,
-0.7147394418716431,
-0.6711097955703735,
-0.11263781785964966,
0.3751823306083679,
-0.12857183814048767,
0.45424091815948486,
0.8217730522155762,
0.7032150030136108,
0.30820032954216003,
-0.05905010923743248,
0.16886653006076813,
-0.26166045665740967,
0.03380466252565384,
-0.043477121740579605,
-0.44154712557792664,
-0.4807637333869934,
0.09300782531499863,
0.4601985812187195,
0.6831098794937134,
0.2614956796169281,
0.29806190729141235,
-0.08466070890426636,
0.5938001871109009,
-0.9511035680770874,
0.07059229910373688,
-0.428906112909317,
-0.18817411363124847,
-0.31910571455955505,
-0.27478471398353577,
-0.6732013821601868,
-0.5059185028076172,
-0.17791041731834412,
-0.4824579954147339,
0.5536989569664001,
-0.1449955850839615,
0.5493027567863464,
0.11591705679893494,
-0.7356026768684387,
-0.44111305475234985,
-0.7748922109603882,
0.678542971611023,
-0.7320701479911804,
0.16400682926177979,
0.7568077445030212,
0.0778050497174263,
-0.2420540153980255,
-0.7596666216850281,
-0.6593005061149597,
-0.4099308252334595,
-0.28205594420433044,
-0.1270265281200409,
-0.13274399936199188,
0.20191454887390137,
0.26897352933883667,
0.7859389781951904,
-0.5796132683753967,
-0.2082827240228653,
-0.4851493835449219,
-0.4531310498714447,
0.7674915194511414,
-0.2124014049768448,
0.45857730507850647,
-0.11334651708602905,
-0.062456078827381134,
0.1103232130408287,
-0.8340537548065186,
0.32996031641960144,
0.6633129715919495,
0.23441100120544434,
0.23543690145015717,
0.6022404432296753,
0.12205293774604797,
0.7759031653404236,
0.2718437910079956,
-0.09579577296972275,
0.114570751786232,
-0.4612964987754822,
-0.15472836792469025,
0.05579569190740585,
0.8330079913139343,
-0.043876077979803085,
0.2061292827129364,
-0.0899886041879654,
0.06778404861688614,
0.027586162090301514,
0.4586881995201111,
-0.3036107122898102,
0.03024549037218094,
0.14813081920146942,
-0.3926340639591217,
-0.29476606845855713,
0.5172200202941895,
-0.41163235902786255,
-0.5327095985412598,
-0.3440679907798767,
0.35771259665489197,
-0.3937697410583496,
-0.12810195982456207,
-0.16025321185588837,
0.10609699785709381,
0.1948584020137787,
0.27431896328926086,
-0.9804974794387817,
0.18065017461776733,
1.123197317123413,
0.7425068020820618,
0.17815692722797394,
-0.17896750569343567,
-0.9816662073135376,
-0.2590632140636444,
-0.49350208044052124,
0.3802136778831482,
-0.4372267425060272,
-0.045753587037324905,
0.2255357801914215,
-0.0032207148615270853,
-0.05432693660259247,
-0.20564725995063782,
0.864502489566803,
-0.4156256914138794,
0.2607274651527405,
-0.4448775053024292,
-0.9692943096160889,
-0.21167775988578796,
0.02930683083832264,
-0.8554717898368835,
1.1916142702102661,
0.13580970466136932,
-0.6126828789710999,
0.5253073573112488,
-0.04574233293533325,
-0.28743216395378113,
0.22586742043495178,
-0.34378960728645325,
-0.4602351784706116,
0.40353357791900635,
0.5131607055664062,
0.5787332653999329,
-0.3961705267429352,
0.40821385383605957,
-0.2022201269865036,
-0.157098650932312,
0.33438318967819214,
-0.015412157401442528,
1.2587268352508545,
0.16048257052898407,
-0.1187753975391388,
-0.08496009558439255,
-0.8933005332946777,
-0.23633389174938202,
-0.21398155391216278,
-0.16707615554332733,
-0.3906463086605072,
0.11246949434280396,
-0.21772213280200958,
-0.2125551551580429,
0.05061599239706993,
-0.693688154220581,
0.20589683949947357,
-0.25546377897262573,
0.07457549124956131,
0.6322193145751953,
0.031729668378829956,
0.4222853183746338,
-0.5443094372749329,
0.7429071664810181,
-0.5965732932090759,
-0.08691519498825073,
-0.2212335765361786,
-0.6050288081169128,
-0.5316981077194214,
-0.578400731086731,
0.5226818323135376,
0.32167211174964905,
-0.455966591835022,
0.8491341471672058,
-0.2289016842842102,
-0.42997127771377563,
-0.6289129853248596,
0.2696886658668518,
0.4415985643863678,
0.4915771484375,
0.13445688784122467,
-0.30729570984840393,
-0.684479296207428,
-0.7133649587631226,
-0.33614808320999146,
-0.6290266513824463,
-0.3744586408138275,
0.18245196342468262,
0.38263341784477234,
0.12996426224708557,
1.1808868646621704,
-0.0477476604282856,
-0.3536154329776764,
-0.20861545205116272,
0.4294625520706177,
0.3493003845214844,
0.3979831337928772,
0.8639959692955017,
-0.48242098093032837,
-0.46279236674308777,
0.03423267602920532,
-1.1119776964187622,
-0.4796481728553772,
-0.10165447741746902,
0.1075078547000885,
0.27254852652549744,
0.9461088180541992,
-0.2315836101770401,
0.5029834508895874,
0.4940224587917328,
-0.41768813133239746,
0.6822764873504639,
-0.1186671331524849,
0.2695271670818329,
-0.7607957720756531,
0.2492835521697998,
0.15644030272960663,
-0.5171484351158142,
-0.7413305640220642,
0.3905269205570221,
0.012518210336565971,
0.1842135190963745,
-0.35175344347953796,
0.44767531752586365,
-0.5800327062606812,
0.28852230310440063,
-0.1527189165353775,
-0.2299538254737854,
-0.23184391856193542,
0.39355477690696716,
-0.3771716356277466,
0.7586966753005981,
0.6641722917556763,
-0.5636303424835205,
0.5027781128883362,
-0.06492388993501663,
-0.5057103633880615,
0.7570292353630066,
-0.561381995677948,
0.31853795051574707,
-0.2902510166168213,
0.24339260160923004,
-1.1141258478164673,
-0.07275976985692978,
0.015326885506510735,
-0.7291250824928284,
0.03655066341161728,
-0.332038015127182,
-0.45403534173965454,
-0.08173613250255585,
-0.12283530831336975,
0.7405058741569519,
0.4598104655742645,
-0.4245828688144684,
1.0386275053024292,
0.1879754364490509,
-0.3551970422267914,
-0.6442594528198242,
-0.28277620673179626,
0.09108489006757736,
-0.15640386939048767,
-0.7101748585700989,
0.25441789627075195,
0.29796814918518066,
-0.497622013092041,
-0.029288770630955696,
-0.026133932173252106,
-0.11333775520324707,
-0.08426278829574585,
0.15770162642002106,
0.3062650263309479,
-0.16644643247127533,
0.2020191252231598,
-0.2120560258626938,
-0.0669121965765953,
0.20939034223556519,
-0.3261445462703705,
0.07861649990081787,
-0.052605051547288895,
-0.2778623402118683,
-0.3039092421531677,
0.3273978531360626,
0.661328136920929,
-0.32509633898735046,
0.6895614862442017,
0.6610354781150818,
-0.38001498579978943,
-0.05231153592467308,
-0.7028502225875854,
-0.23395530879497528,
-0.3718808591365814,
0.07236611843109131,
-0.23846672475337982,
-0.8237497806549072,
0.7475716471672058,
0.26447543501853943,
-0.08979775756597519,
0.6796471476554871,
0.5235472917556763,
0.11403675377368927,
0.49852755665779114,
0.7093523144721985,
-0.21369625627994537,
0.38419678807258606,
-0.011246927082538605,
0.31886059045791626,
-0.6713840961456299,
-0.05893777310848236,
-0.8033884167671204,
-0.14770613610744476,
-0.5334903001785278,
-0.21782447397708893,
0.5518702268600464,
-0.05326247960329056,
0.048128075897693634,
0.3531549572944641,
-0.25173377990722656,
0.46876630187034607,
0.7729082107543945,
-0.02900414541363716,
0.4041227698326111,
-0.1424655169248581,
-0.15627343952655792,
0.09779025614261627,
-0.43352752923965454,
-0.6130467653274536,
1.6161713600158691,
0.15184535086154938,
0.45444008708000183,
0.3975249230861664,
0.6320323944091797,
0.7877622246742249,
0.15119041502475739,
-0.6494712233543396,
0.5735052824020386,
-0.2038470357656479,
-0.8641462922096252,
-0.5029976963996887,
-0.45446324348449707,
-0.8887346982955933,
0.3545204997062683,
-0.5005276799201965,
-0.9387078285217285,
0.38441288471221924,
0.14464108645915985,
-0.38839417695999146,
0.04569264128804207,
-0.3260290026664734,
0.5373613834381104,
-0.03678000718355179,
-0.45360058546066284,
0.028979824855923653,
-0.615421712398529,
0.38068950176239014,
-0.1727161705493927,
0.3989636301994324,
0.05377698317170143,
0.352790892124176,
0.7285268902778625,
-0.9051593542098999,
0.5943570733070374,
0.002638987498357892,
-0.14783073961734772,
0.45627596974372864,
0.1256304681301117,
0.5334810018539429,
0.2561791241168976,
-0.29262834787368774,
0.22922341525554657,
-0.06583687663078308,
-0.2630259394645691,
-0.7827792763710022,
0.3424522280693054,
-0.6240602135658264,
-0.5006815791130066,
-0.7016008496284485,
-0.31335344910621643,
-0.03741464763879776,
0.16052280366420746,
0.6709299683570862,
0.46419259905815125,
-0.4233391582965851,
0.6134094595909119,
0.2183040976524353,
-0.0011292786803096533,
0.2744573652744293,
0.06858903169631958,
-0.06931081414222717,
-0.59454345703125,
0.4803631007671356,
-0.1390955001115799,
0.13190673291683197,
0.4759984314441681,
0.16306494176387787,
-0.31009238958358765,
-0.32083457708358765,
-0.23375745117664337,
0.3096828758716583,
-0.6299911141395569,
0.00042830323218367994,
-0.6206739544868469,
-0.15835070610046387,
-0.5460880398750305,
-0.2941161096096039,
-0.1461181640625,
-0.49192318320274353,
-0.21925121545791626,
-0.04540197178721428,
0.05971021577715874,
0.4115465581417084,
0.0018471828661859035,
0.2802664637565613,
-0.34552326798439026,
0.3575318157672882,
0.49817386269569397,
0.0471881739795208,
-0.137642964720726,
-0.685529351234436,
-0.22564160823822021,
-0.08299900591373444,
-0.19673790037631989,
-0.8846420049667358,
0.1990070343017578,
0.35415294766426086,
0.5637423396110535,
0.46518924832344055,
-0.012262081727385521,
0.39852967858314514,
-0.2665209174156189,
0.8380287885665894,
-0.11128362268209457,
-1.3180407285690308,
0.375342458486557,
-0.4532533288002014,
-0.10380547493696213,
0.7334396243095398,
0.07240496575832367,
-0.4208747148513794,
-0.8134258389472961,
-0.662093997001648,
-0.8621717691421509,
0.5990413427352905,
0.6774688363075256,
-0.07818326354026794,
0.17635691165924072,
0.5432179570198059,
0.18563111126422882,
-0.01703776605427265,
-0.8217352032661438,
-0.1350783407688141,
0.036967337131500244,
-0.11489350348711014,
-0.39297372102737427,
-0.33725446462631226,
-0.08828302472829819,
-0.32559043169021606,
0.8485865592956543,
-0.0912536084651947,
0.20698882639408112,
0.2881453335285187,
-0.16150052845478058,
0.05331522226333618,
0.17687247693538666,
0.6180647015571594,
0.8335580229759216,
-0.3845354914665222,
0.29030218720436096,
-0.16487203538417816,
-0.4141969680786133,
0.4622928500175476,
-0.11570826172828674,
-0.19474060833454132,
0.23265843093395233,
1.0479172468185425,
0.510205864906311,
-0.30184292793273926,
-0.2908484935760498,
0.8248294591903687,
-0.045589908957481384,
-0.48155486583709717,
-0.554267942905426,
0.00345696322619915,
-0.3403609097003937,
-0.020243650302290916,
0.6535285115242004,
-0.05892886221408844,
0.17180286347866058,
-0.40168190002441406,
0.17071063816547394,
0.35823729634284973,
-0.11970074474811554,
-0.19484634697437286,
0.6667400598526001,
0.129163920879364,
-0.41113555431365967,
0.6358599662780762,
-0.21933630108833313,
-0.17254513502120972,
1.03286874294281,
0.300382137298584,
1.2528343200683594,
-0.26546403765678406,
0.2701420187950134,
0.5843473076820374,
0.4888649880886078,
-0.3004952371120453,
-0.13363948464393616,
-0.08889857679605484,
-0.5545104742050171,
-0.5541108250617981,
-0.5315449833869934,
-0.28707990050315857,
0.21306903660297394,
-0.7133870124816895,
0.1807364821434021,
-0.3439747095108032,
-0.332623153924942,
0.3386526107788086,
-0.22066640853881836,
-0.3743060529232025,
0.0764196589589119,
0.025666268542408943,
0.4946717321872711,
-1.17877197265625,
0.4931066036224365,
0.636428713798523,
-0.2396674007177353,
-0.6764318943023682,
-0.061313826590776443,
0.5216330885887146,
-0.5096533298492432,
0.4788370132446289,
0.025556614622473717,
-0.0033630814868956804,
-0.0835200622677803,
-0.48604515194892883,
-0.7360202670097351,
0.827293872833252,
0.6782365441322327,
-0.3161720335483551,
0.2973802983760834,
-0.09428395330905914,
0.7171483039855957,
-0.4364590346813202,
0.1344393789768219,
0.15045928955078125,
0.3178628087043762,
0.3002144992351532,
-0.9186010956764221,
0.12737537920475006,
-0.5380106568336487,
0.06986536085605621,
0.08382473140954971,
0.033813122659921646,
0.985190749168396,
0.044860366731882095,
-0.08107349276542664,
0.1044696792960167,
0.8109501600265503,
0.13012133538722992,
0.22578014433383942,
0.4204642176628113,
0.3678451180458069,
1.0154426097869873,
-0.09396632760763168,
1.154650330543518,
-0.34930455684661865,
0.5746309757232666,
0.8568360209465027,
-0.04900223761796951,
0.40022820234298706,
0.43455904722213745,
-0.40113332867622375,
0.5112795829772949,
0.22695356607437134,
-0.1588984876871109,
0.2185911238193512,
0.09467637538909912,
-0.503621518611908,
-0.3036906123161316,
0.08599890768527985,
-0.3015807867050171,
0.6362605094909668,
-0.09215600788593292,
-0.8096522688865662,
0.03440902382135391,
0.04345240071415901,
0.01818467304110527,
0.269015371799469,
-0.3004792034626007,
0.8507483601570129,
-0.08381742238998413,
-1.0452592372894287,
0.5332261323928833,
0.13957791030406952,
0.2640334665775299,
-0.440054714679718,
0.0678904801607132,
-0.14657384157180786,
0.2962029278278351,
-0.39581698179244995,
-0.34881842136383057,
0.2757759988307953,
0.09480314701795578,
-0.12184901535511017,
-0.10323969274759293,
0.49027615785598755,
-0.37952277064323425,
-0.9872856140136719,
-0.1945655792951584,
0.4117772579193115,
0.06483394652605057,
-0.1484265774488449,
0.19107528030872345,
-0.15872734785079956,
-0.19005407392978668,
0.21385326981544495,
-0.17045307159423828,
0.3997171223163605,
-0.09579452127218246,
0.4284113049507141,
0.6152017116546631,
0.22371891140937805,
0.060422834008932114,
-0.14327049255371094,
0.32070866227149963,
-0.3652423918247223,
-0.6529605984687805,
-1.2564839124679565,
0.4074348211288452,
0.06999704241752625,
-0.23438775539398193,
0.7767873406410217,
0.5949673652648926,
0.7253047823905945,
-0.1385897696018219,
1.0122566223144531,
-0.31142857670783997,
0.20001251995563507,
-0.6604337096214294,
0.510313868522644,
-0.4880508780479431,
0.2808712422847748,
-0.5566607713699341,
-0.7679175138473511,
-0.6512003540992737,
0.7173053026199341,
-0.23888938128948212,
0.21604549884796143,
0.9098676443099976,
0.8005700707435608,
-0.08811600506305695,
-0.004543655551970005,
0.17816150188446045,
-0.18392230570316315,
0.5457854270935059,
0.5328286290168762,
0.4396411180496216,
-0.4179716110229492,
0.1538521945476532,
-0.07632526010274887,
-0.5445172190666199,
-0.403083473443985,
-1.1096713542938232,
-0.956253170967102,
-0.8895092010498047,
-0.3748812675476074,
-0.471714049577713,
0.0559750497341156,
0.8399502635002136,
0.7288920879364014,
-0.6286343932151794,
-0.24221378564834595,
-0.3685120940208435,
0.11317987740039825,
-0.7344034314155579,
-0.14786142110824585,
0.4577810764312744,
-0.2167772352695465,
-0.6421114206314087,
0.05141223967075348,
0.20903024077415466,
-0.28345242142677307,
-0.19283215701580048,
-0.06495838612318039,
-0.2900592088699341,
0.3697565197944641,
0.34736132621765137,
0.4348453879356384,
-0.9393940567970276,
-0.19632260501384735,
-0.10971230268478394,
-0.2427973598241806,
0.14068828523159027,
1.088571310043335,
-0.5436243414878845,
0.7963216304779053,
0.624302864074707,
0.7842612266540527,
0.36112090945243835,
0.4826671779155731,
0.7374338507652283,
-0.9379780888557434,
-0.14262540638446808,
0.13175152242183685,
0.5388780236244202,
0.09367282688617706,
-0.6377036571502686,
0.5680356621742249,
0.3683258593082428,
-0.684615969657898,
-0.6846226453781128,
0.2815106511116028,
-1.182460904121399,
-0.010742755606770515,
1.1612722873687744,
-0.21887515485286713,
-0.20475608110427856,
-0.17078402638435364,
0.012904438190162182,
0.13552223145961761,
-0.22874268889427185,
1.0672457218170166,
1.1508452892303467,
0.003219630103558302,
-0.2743588984012604,
-0.18601591885089874,
0.47317737340927124,
0.3188254237174988,
-0.6429586410522461,
0.024479016661643982,
0.7077307105064392,
0.005654554348438978,
0.2981022000312805,
1.0259060859680176,
-0.24163149297237396,
0.5545522570610046,
-0.06170815974473953,
0.1538856476545334,
-0.4024142622947693,
-0.28017351031303406,
-0.48745763301849365,
0.5097066164016724,
-0.02690133824944496,
-0.17279355227947235
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08424v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08424v1
|
Tastle: Distract Large Language Models for Automatic Jailbreak Attack
| 2024-03-13T11:16:43 | 2024-03-13T11:16:43 |
Zeguan Xiao, Yan Yang, Guanhua Chen, Yun Chen
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have achieved significant advances in recent
days. Extensive efforts have been made before the public release of LLMs to
align their behaviors with human values. The primary goal of alignment is to
ensure their helpfulness, honesty and harmlessness. However, even meticulously
aligned LLMs remain vulnerable to malicious manipulations such as jailbreaking,
leading to unintended behaviors. The jailbreak is to intentionally develop a
malicious prompt that escapes from the LLM security restrictions to produce
uncensored detrimental contents. Previous works explore different jailbreak
methods for red teaming LLMs, yet they encounter challenges regarding to
effectiveness and scalability. In this work, we propose Tastle, a novel
black-box jailbreak framework for automated red teaming of LLMs. We designed
malicious content concealing and memory reframing with an iterative
optimization algorithm to jailbreak LLMs, motivated by the research about the
distractibility and over-confidence phenomenon of LLMs. Extensive experiments
of jailbreaking both open-source and proprietary LLMs demonstrate the
superiority of our framework in terms of effectiveness, scalability and
transferability. We also evaluate the effectiveness of existing jailbreak
defense methods against our attack and highlight the crucial need to develop
more effective and practical defense strategies.
|
[
-0.16427873075008392,
-1.1026142835617065,
0.39406561851501465,
0.387432336807251,
-0.14920146763324738,
0.516888439655304,
-0.39180609583854675,
-0.6336246728897095,
0.5214448571205139,
0.7571849226951599,
-0.3329252302646637,
-0.4683286249637604,
-0.7687541842460632,
-0.07139772176742554,
-0.6043543815612793,
0.9473691582679749,
-0.14073172211647034,
-0.46431100368499756,
0.2356046587228775,
-0.1873062551021576,
-0.8823463320732117,
-0.41923704743385315,
-0.38789209723472595,
-0.09493334591388702,
0.3431044816970825,
0.3639160394668579,
0.5022030472755432,
0.5487813949584961,
0.4001429080963135,
0.35972195863723755,
-0.027400095015764236,
0.023433418944478035,
-0.5606135129928589,
0.4137151837348938,
-0.3272416889667511,
-0.2970695197582245,
-0.1421445608139038,
-0.11439792811870575,
0.27566972374916077,
0.08964835107326508,
-0.1465756595134735,
0.10401955246925354,
-0.28270578384399414,
0.6640800833702087,
-0.9000117182731628,
-0.31751543283462524,
-0.8765740394592285,
-0.19005431234836578,
-0.3215002119541168,
0.05616955831646919,
-0.673443615436554,
-0.23592905700206757,
-0.20775823295116425,
-0.23090246319770813,
-0.21794399619102478,
0.08842054754495621,
0.7262837886810303,
0.5579459071159363,
-0.07970397174358368,
-0.14738886058330536,
-0.4801238775253296,
0.8092109560966492,
-0.6404080986976624,
-0.024336254224181175,
0.40143319964408875,
0.24281254410743713,
-0.3301272988319397,
-0.37977197766304016,
-0.2323145866394043,
-0.5261722803115845,
0.18990381062030792,
-0.26900798082351685,
-0.4376940131187439,
0.051896169781684875,
0.05419471114873886,
0.07845676690340042,
-0.22039178013801575,
0.30224883556365967,
-0.3514375686645508,
-0.1652374565601349,
0.587290346622467,
0.16094911098480225,
0.49876999855041504,
0.19025814533233643,
-0.6400370001792908,
0.37331652641296387,
-0.5217642784118652,
-0.176181361079216,
0.22534869611263275,
0.26667118072509766,
-0.3098272383213043,
0.523518979549408,
-0.018253972753882408,
0.6589728593826294,
0.21304188668727875,
-0.18079201877117157,
0.02183181792497635,
-0.2866877019405365,
-0.1974969208240509,
-0.018752336502075195,
0.9641682505607605,
0.2941303849220276,
0.37722766399383545,
-0.5105029940605164,
-0.31808334589004517,
-0.14595086872577667,
0.6418793797492981,
-0.6957839131355286,
-0.1607784777879715,
0.6069146990776062,
-0.07063838094472885,
-0.7763758897781372,
-0.086922787129879,
-0.6464056968688965,
-0.7020407915115356,
0.39071109890937805,
0.4547807574272156,
-0.615604817867279,
-0.2163642793893814,
0.0683237761259079,
-0.09629013389348984,
0.030029399320483208,
0.25304746627807617,
-0.8132573366165161,
0.36069217324256897,
0.6382273435592651,
0.9853798151016235,
-0.30194100737571716,
-0.36551570892333984,
-0.7533894777297974,
0.4529555141925812,
-0.1291131228208542,
0.500046968460083,
-0.26633328199386597,
-0.20556224882602692,
-0.17978627979755402,
-0.19609826803207397,
0.12262161076068878,
-0.5790061950683594,
0.08275788277387619,
-0.6220847368240356,
-0.26490306854248047,
0.17818708717823029,
-0.46355488896369934,
-0.15277232229709625,
0.4466397762298584,
-0.8335286378860474,
0.6391842365264893,
0.11605145782232285,
-0.6963276863098145,
0.23286759853363037,
-0.5911586284637451,
-0.565825343132019,
0.31906333565711975,
0.009590127505362034,
-0.6046716570854187,
0.055179063230752945,
0.02956525608897209,
0.18516668677330017,
-0.15253546833992004,
0.41752609610557556,
-0.3778027296066284,
-0.49480101466178894,
0.3408065438270569,
0.042906440794467926,
0.9978077411651611,
0.28053930401802063,
-0.6824385523796082,
0.2797490954399109,
-0.2983713746070862,
0.01665155030786991,
0.36161577701568604,
-0.16533958911895752,
-0.524247407913208,
-0.05665977671742439,
-0.12292727082967758,
0.031142698600888252,
0.3542623817920685,
-0.6884738802909851,
0.3049805164337158,
-0.32017454504966736,
0.6161876916885376,
0.6588680744171143,
0.07436680048704147,
0.41006141901016235,
-0.26724740862846375,
0.7026290893554688,
-0.1933966428041458,
0.08828645199537277,
-0.18417099118232727,
-0.11128277331590652,
-0.18281212449073792,
-0.6025469899177551,
0.18893267214298248,
0.6183027029037476,
-0.5689444541931152,
0.3559795320034027,
0.1928342878818512,
-0.4518970251083374,
-0.6502788662910461,
0.44271090626716614,
0.5816648006439209,
0.3643534183502197,
0.3772912621498108,
-0.18774595856666565,
-0.6238999366760254,
-0.7752604484558105,
-0.5373448729515076,
0.14995157718658447,
0.291972815990448,
-0.003913616295903921,
0.5485967397689819,
-0.22500000894069672,
0.7732489109039307,
-0.26010674238204956,
-0.42781731486320496,
-0.5977882742881775,
-0.18436115980148315,
0.05399259552359581,
0.5344226956367493,
0.6413756012916565,
-0.49036523699760437,
-0.4330918788909912,
-0.31405603885650635,
-0.5721494555473328,
-0.37353426218032837,
-0.22835293412208557,
0.17985308170318604,
0.453380823135376,
0.6582497358322144,
-0.44488057494163513,
0.4935995936393738,
0.4987679421901703,
-0.6733092665672302,
0.8823186755180359,
0.06355003267526627,
-0.03948674350976944,
-0.8336242437362671,
-0.06246313080191612,
0.22503620386123657,
-0.4155466556549072,
-0.6312942504882812,
0.4188610315322876,
0.17045821249485016,
0.052776142954826355,
-0.6074379682540894,
0.7844792604446411,
-0.4145813584327698,
0.0770835280418396,
-0.3527408540248871,
0.2029339075088501,
-0.08865786343812943,
0.22994618117809296,
-0.3269951045513153,
0.9682127237319946,
0.16576384007930756,
-0.26527276635169983,
0.37632209062576294,
0.022755978628993034,
-0.3712686002254486,
0.27030569314956665,
-0.7274786233901978,
0.11673934012651443,
0.26131170988082886,
0.03828434646129608,
-0.876800537109375,
-0.09019739180803299,
0.16678284108638763,
-0.4395623803138733,
0.4664123058319092,
-0.40362122654914856,
-0.5948805212974548,
-0.18878436088562012,
-0.3737916946411133,
0.4077613651752472,
0.41411110758781433,
-0.38758769631385803,
0.2346283197402954,
0.7369586825370789,
-0.007984180003404617,
-0.8047020435333252,
-0.7166140675544739,
0.4876111149787903,
-0.5505675673484802,
-0.619625985622406,
0.37341785430908203,
0.159279465675354,
-0.7331844568252563,
-0.23113545775413513,
-0.06643654406070709,
-0.24514977633953094,
0.5319437384605408,
0.1994798481464386,
0.39774367213249207,
0.21743172407150269,
-0.17102769017219543,
-0.3286360204219818,
0.07049064338207245,
0.25949347019195557,
-0.37466832995414734,
0.672749400138855,
-0.10744504630565643,
-0.02561170794069767,
-0.521090567111969,
0.2268400937318802,
0.6206122636795044,
-0.2136225402355194,
1.0201466083526611,
0.4283048212528229,
0.006692326162010431,
-0.48924311995506287,
-0.806081235408783,
-0.008423404768109322,
-0.5359448194503784,
0.5486104488372803,
-0.06387253850698471,
-1.037692904472351,
0.4631355404853821,
-0.007147011812776327,
0.1834738701581955,
-0.14309507608413696,
0.7336515784263611,
-0.056702859699726105,
0.4230765998363495,
0.8554004430770874,
-0.44504329562187195,
0.7396596074104309,
0.027597062289714813,
-0.04165202006697655,
-0.5051217079162598,
-0.20995044708251953,
-0.3415784537792206,
-0.45872926712036133,
-0.2585345506668091,
-0.25569450855255127,
-0.053485650569200516,
0.021170521154999733,
-0.34873393177986145,
0.6089621782302856,
-0.6278567910194397,
0.9011802077293396,
0.33604609966278076,
0.0031697500962764025,
0.1862093061208725,
-0.23424403369426727,
-0.21700941026210785,
0.0144319674000144,
-0.33170849084854126,
-0.34716179966926575,
1.0442657470703125,
0.5364876389503479,
0.8766194581985474,
0.2148279845714569,
1.1027462482452393,
0.4390939474105835,
0.22294391691684723,
-0.7735608816146851,
0.5015112161636353,
0.001952619757503271,
-0.6478633284568787,
-0.40750646591186523,
-0.30756786465644836,
-0.796539843082428,
0.09489098936319351,
-0.045591894537210464,
-1.2224268913269043,
-0.4356507956981659,
0.08423689752817154,
-0.277961403131485,
0.6179585456848145,
-0.9002132415771484,
0.842076301574707,
-0.2740030586719513,
-0.7520018219947815,
-0.13839039206504822,
-0.6722804307937622,
0.8353033661842346,
-0.3029888868331909,
0.46347805857658386,
-0.14164096117019653,
-0.1277313232421875,
0.749457836151123,
-0.7384036183357239,
1.0165374279022217,
-0.29700538516044617,
-0.14529582858085632,
0.29044052958488464,
0.6227267384529114,
0.6348300576210022,
-0.03719450533390045,
0.011154825799167156,
0.014444074593484402,
-0.26206088066101074,
-0.5001748204231262,
-0.28618407249450684,
0.6652378439903259,
-0.566716730594635,
-0.8763267993927002,
-0.07262058556079865,
-0.878572404384613,
0.00833497941493988,
0.43350493907928467,
0.09494847804307938,
-0.04043934866786003,
0.06910911202430725,
-0.001428381772711873,
0.5975335240364075,
-0.27589288353919983,
0.6971448063850403,
0.44213899970054626,
-0.2916681468486786,
-0.5128174424171448,
0.7333237528800964,
-0.1805868297815323,
0.5209084153175354,
0.07194991409778595,
0.01969991624355316,
-0.04222751036286354,
-0.8623515963554382,
-0.15353387594223022,
0.3908112049102783,
-0.2344948947429657,
-0.31524622440338135,
-0.3900444209575653,
-0.11655066162347794,
-0.23272445797920227,
-0.4847062826156616,
-0.5225642919540405,
-0.42338797450065613,
0.12158135324716568,
0.08040045946836472,
0.5736219882965088,
0.7484121322631836,
0.18264256417751312,
0.33105823397636414,
-0.7961118221282959,
0.27353399991989136,
-0.12557783722877502,
0.3995216190814972,
-0.11053713411092758,
-0.6683076024055481,
-0.3844963312149048,
-0.3169877827167511,
-0.39051705598831177,
-0.9763644337654114,
0.6604483127593994,
-0.3939627707004547,
0.48895859718322754,
0.10300049930810928,
0.38477829098701477,
0.5697587132453918,
-0.3984486758708954,
0.39345699548721313,
0.330820769071579,
-0.9924297332763672,
0.680130660533905,
-0.3949930965900421,
0.16537566483020782,
0.8379451632499695,
-0.03540835157036781,
-0.23164500296115875,
-0.8968245387077332,
-0.6284977197647095,
-0.9219354391098022,
0.6117407083511353,
0.13238948583602905,
-0.1271977573633194,
-0.011667036451399326,
0.2972812354564667,
-0.06529550999403,
0.2674944996833801,
-1.0510728359222412,
-0.3025164008140564,
0.03154035657644272,
-0.10678413510322571,
0.18633253872394562,
-0.14955946803092957,
-0.3000660240650177,
0.023832431063055992,
0.2935485541820526,
0.4319554269313812,
-0.04991621524095535,
-0.0788927748799324,
-0.3637332320213318,
-0.06205329671502113,
0.30601149797439575,
0.699517011642456,
0.33626121282577515,
-0.20149151980876923,
-0.01577121391892433,
0.14357095956802368,
-0.707050621509552,
0.3946229815483093,
-0.32567742466926575,
-0.24532298743724823,
-0.1699993908405304,
0.3338058292865753,
0.3523983657360077,
0.1001354232430458,
-0.928776741027832,
0.6785750389099121,
0.16128160059452057,
-0.1403542011976242,
-0.5089024901390076,
0.34045496582984924,
0.061713915318250656,
0.41837278008461,
0.11227122694253922,
-0.07404938340187073,
-0.33024856448173523,
-0.4968358278274536,
0.35301727056503296,
0.6467645168304443,
-0.3977438807487488,
-0.14219625294208527,
0.737988293170929,
0.28899335861206055,
-0.6280445456504822,
0.5545189380645752,
-0.25463178753852844,
-0.5752051472663879,
0.7951905131340027,
0.7849634289741516,
1.0410809516906738,
-0.18147873878479004,
-0.06503690779209137,
0.1048303171992302,
0.5716463327407837,
-0.022431040182709694,
0.026374133303761482,
-0.0020906405989080667,
-0.6518800854682922,
-0.6786708831787109,
-0.25224146246910095,
-0.39371049404144287,
0.2967939078807831,
-0.48445695638656616,
0.37765997648239136,
-0.8256475329399109,
-0.14330188930034637,
-0.24263019859790802,
0.10252740979194641,
-0.00966372899711132,
-0.2732914388179779,
0.18194694817066193,
1.106256365776062,
-0.4087817668914795,
1.1780391931533813,
0.45762336254119873,
-0.2871672809123993,
-0.6982823610305786,
-0.022688662633299828,
0.42846015095710754,
-0.8446570634841919,
0.768872082233429,
0.26257795095443726,
-0.14995808899402618,
-0.1546468436717987,
-0.8165861964225769,
-0.6148765683174133,
0.8991729617118835,
0.26870065927505493,
-0.5626800060272217,
-0.11820248514413834,
-0.27065742015838623,
0.10066790133714676,
-0.35170990228652954,
-0.11804350465536118,
0.8806699514389038,
0.4738759696483612,
0.11539297550916672,
-0.8818569183349609,
0.34277665615081787,
-0.1168113723397255,
-0.431262344121933,
0.726605236530304,
-0.737909734249115,
0.6353662610054016,
-0.8533830642700195,
-0.01908225566148758,
0.042156022042036057,
0.2520269751548767,
0.7551485300064087,
0.07627775520086288,
0.27690431475639343,
0.6593379378318787,
0.48311060667037964,
0.1184624657034874,
0.8687052130699158,
-0.252431184053421,
0.07357560843229294,
1.3913719654083252,
-0.2722238302230835,
0.6627897620201111,
0.6870166659355164,
-0.013484545983374119,
0.4143545925617218,
-0.02219744771718979,
-0.3374290466308594,
0.5001270174980164,
0.4527648985385895,
-0.20828789472579956,
-0.05841677635908127,
0.15274430811405182,
-0.0149119533598423,
0.43460148572921753,
0.3732817471027374,
-0.20355841517448425,
-0.2282842993736267,
-0.13115935027599335,
0.5491744875907898,
0.32043886184692383,
-0.35636845231056213,
0.7143760919570923,
-0.003881140612065792,
-0.5042455792427063,
0.7730631828308105,
0.2227284461259842,
0.9230406284332275,
-0.46242809295654297,
0.3312588036060333,
-0.14604374766349792,
0.09519687294960022,
-0.3625941872596741,
-0.7905390858650208,
0.4599078297615051,
0.3780597746372223,
0.061628591269254684,
-0.05456900596618652,
0.7007532119750977,
-0.19257403910160065,
0.1302667111158371,
0.5131810903549194,
0.17389878630638123,
-0.03129936009645462,
-0.08627669513225555,
-0.7517362833023071,
0.3603520691394806,
0.20361851155757904,
-0.1639823168516159,
0.6566963195800781,
0.2625921368598938,
-0.0633481964468956,
1.0584330558776855,
0.48856860399246216,
0.4039744734764099,
-0.00994902290403843,
-0.11114025115966797,
0.9002704620361328,
-1.0739465951919556,
-0.5369718074798584,
-1.3457229137420654,
0.4278636872768402,
-0.11240677535533905,
0.08591456711292267,
0.7829614877700806,
0.3910730183124542,
0.5613014698028564,
0.24499920010566711,
0.6614553332328796,
-0.002078007673844695,
0.342291921377182,
-0.3615988492965698,
0.9591412544250488,
-0.2687363028526306,
0.6788520216941833,
-0.5707429647445679,
-0.5610718131065369,
-0.33780020475387573,
0.25443413853645325,
-0.40483182668685913,
-0.15206106007099152,
0.5939224362373352,
0.4742834270000458,
0.3677107095718384,
-0.3429657220840454,
0.40989452600479126,
0.30878934264183044,
0.4487217962741852,
0.7649215459823608,
0.7610399127006531,
-0.15585465729236603,
0.8245225548744202,
-0.24997557699680328,
-0.29053646326065063,
-0.2845936119556427,
-0.8624955415725708,
-1.124804139137268,
-0.1473488062620163,
-0.34734752774238586,
-0.51826411485672,
0.1713009923696518,
0.9416168928146362,
0.5103168487548828,
-0.6103588938713074,
-0.4183075726032257,
-0.05748813599348068,
0.30307862162590027,
0.03475652262568474,
-0.2745519280433655,
-0.1372109353542328,
-0.5908414721488953,
-0.414224773645401,
0.5988988280296326,
0.4932548701763153,
0.1307757943868637,
-0.10596685111522675,
0.130968376994133,
-0.2177358865737915,
-0.0825318917632103,
0.304730623960495,
0.6083234548568726,
-0.7904767394065857,
-0.21577611565589905,
-0.2574084401130676,
-0.30344367027282715,
0.013242598623037338,
0.7004663348197937,
-0.9212456941604614,
0.28021788597106934,
0.05318141728639603,
0.7389019131660461,
0.2462659329175949,
0.2242540866136551,
0.6590586304664612,
-0.8432072401046753,
0.5429695248603821,
0.41376516222953796,
0.351299524307251,
-0.09414403140544891,
-0.3573494255542755,
0.3704112470149994,
0.009255281649529934,
-0.5323880910873413,
-1.0012270212173462,
0.2360069453716278,
-0.8440701365470886,
-0.686606764793396,
1.1583549976348877,
-0.14967724680900574,
-0.4369664788246155,
-0.5176733136177063,
-0.06176868453621864,
-0.08498450368642807,
-0.6641098260879517,
0.9640470147132874,
0.5858469009399414,
0.1199912428855896,
-0.22978892922401428,
-0.583981454372406,
0.4030782878398895,
0.3155801594257355,
-0.6590802669525146,
0.40754449367523193,
0.3272537887096405,
0.549892783164978,
0.03745391592383385,
0.48196616768836975,
-0.31549912691116333,
0.37665238976478577,
-0.10615698248147964,
0.2586294710636139,
-0.7108314037322998,
-0.359734445810318,
-0.40850508213043213,
0.4282734990119934,
0.11955747753381729,
-0.14717504382133484
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08391v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08391v2
|
Misinformation is not about Bad Facts: An Analysis of the Production and Consumption of Fringe Content
| 2024-03-13T10:10:07 | 2024-05-26T06:15:33 |
JooYoung Lee, Emily Booth, Hany Farid, Marian-Andrei Rizoiu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
What if misinformation is not an information problem at all? To understand
the role of news publishers in potentially unintentionally propagating
misinformation, we examine how far-right and fringe online groups share and
leverage established legacy news media articles to advance their narratives.
Our findings suggest that online fringe ideologies spread through the use of
content that is consensus-based and "factually correct". We found that
Australian news publishers with both moderate and far-right political leanings
contain comparable levels of information completeness and quality; and
furthermore, that far-right Twitter users often share from moderate sources.
However, a stark difference emerges when we consider two additional factors: 1)
the narrow topic selection of articles by far-right users, suggesting that they
cherry pick only news articles that engage with their preexisting worldviews
and specific topics of concern, and 2) the difference between moderate and
far-right publishers when we examine the writing style of their articles.
Furthermore, we can identify users prone to sharing misinformation based on
their communication style. These findings have important implications for
countering online misinformation, as they highlight the powerful role that
personal biases towards specific topics and publishers' writing styles have in
amplifying fringe ideologies online.
|
[
-0.5260584950447083,
-0.7061673402786255,
0.5898624062538147,
0.3158707320690155,
-0.18700237572193146,
-0.05629163980484009,
-0.08604485541582108,
-0.6128214001655579,
0.6256579756736755,
0.5561277866363525,
-0.496436208486557,
-0.11483214050531387,
-0.867945671081543,
0.20308707654476166,
-0.4278353750705719,
1.1727889776229858,
0.4072892367839813,
-0.35405710339546204,
0.11395324766635895,
-0.27331727743148804,
-0.13543926179409027,
-0.3417075574398041,
0.05952434241771698,
-0.0284297913312912,
0.5844791531562805,
0.5240918397903442,
1.3303762674331665,
0.5034955143928528,
0.1620998978614807,
0.09992030262947083,
-0.10378104448318481,
0.0760585144162178,
-0.7669927477836609,
-0.27115318179130554,
-0.6607905626296997,
-0.5002204775810242,
0.38194501399993896,
0.3287985622882843,
0.4938907325267792,
0.6082280874252319,
-0.12485165148973465,
0.3439130485057831,
0.15308192372322083,
0.7597604393959045,
-0.7380422353744507,
-0.5325327515602112,
-0.3934716582298279,
0.09673018008470535,
-0.5057252645492554,
-0.3983336091041565,
-0.41469472646713257,
-0.573713481426239,
-0.06857771426439285,
-0.8640678524971008,
0.3491453528404236,
0.26558730006217957,
0.9493236541748047,
0.08243099600076675,
-0.6048383116722107,
-0.5849109888076782,
-0.9015792012214661,
0.5713312029838562,
-0.4987235367298126,
0.43067818880081177,
0.43012434244155884,
-0.031008340418338776,
-0.11036534607410431,
-0.342087984085083,
-0.6308810710906982,
0.5525006651878357,
-0.12481989711523056,
0.07930566370487213,
-0.6617249250411987,
-0.1899426281452179,
0.2528589963912964,
0.2226714938879013,
-0.30513039231300354,
-0.13073164224624634,
-0.7352811694145203,
-0.303375780582428,
0.5834764242172241,
-0.18564243614673615,
0.3229847252368927,
-0.40207940340042114,
-0.5117371678352356,
0.2427375316619873,
-0.9099547863006592,
-0.14807134866714478,
0.7951040863990784,
0.20353448390960693,
-0.11147093772888184,
0.687915563583374,
0.04472528398036957,
0.5444665551185608,
0.5631269216537476,
-0.19431620836257935,
0.17050033807754517,
-0.43820443749427795,
-0.03607186675071716,
0.33375993371009827,
0.5396981239318848,
0.8658235669136047,
-0.1274348646402359,
0.12078634649515152,
0.11421409994363785,
-0.34347641468048096,
0.3218194842338562,
-0.3829430043697357,
0.002407836727797985,
-0.0570182129740715,
-0.633398711681366,
-0.09680388867855072,
0.28491824865341187,
-0.9493227005004883,
-1.0049937963485718,
-0.0024020338896661997,
0.495998740196228,
-0.13851016759872437,
-0.26059016585350037,
-0.08757104724645615,
-0.8515398502349854,
-0.2838810086250305,
0.3655179440975189,
-0.5868602991104126,
0.0854172334074974,
0.508915901184082,
0.6445953249931335,
0.1923387199640274,
-0.07513970881700516,
-0.25662219524383545,
0.4191134572029114,
-0.702807605266571,
0.6021921634674072,
-0.27274003624916077,
0.07628268748521805,
0.2761153280735016,
-0.05276144668459892,
0.2401321977376938,
-0.3769981563091278,
0.49496886134147644,
-0.4000060260295868,
0.365078330039978,
-0.7132153511047363,
-0.4990135729312897,
-0.358318954706192,
0.03777328506112099,
-0.7301719188690186,
0.7026157975196838,
0.14219199120998383,
-1.1794655323028564,
0.8030520081520081,
-0.21372708678245544,
-0.33433011174201965,
-0.12340801954269409,
-0.1811564862728119,
-0.16802187263965607,
0.2799745202064514,
0.07693861424922943,
0.3203544318675995,
0.041478049010038376,
0.21003270149230957,
-0.22973011434078217,
-0.47163599729537964,
0.46169590950012207,
-0.46586310863494873,
0.27995821833610535,
0.2168886661529541,
-0.44143980741500854,
-0.3881967067718506,
-0.4398976266384125,
-0.5420259833335876,
-0.19558873772621155,
-0.14934659004211426,
-0.6634217500686646,
0.21564210951328278,
-0.10913597792387009,
0.43828633427619934,
-0.15429085493087769,
-0.5056645274162292,
-0.07348067313432693,
0.32627472281455994,
0.06068933755159378,
0.5489466190338135,
0.43325474858283997,
0.4549272358417511,
-0.9555461406707764,
-0.11728359758853912,
0.2652806341648102,
0.5447291135787964,
0.01289168931543827,
-0.5356382131576538,
-0.597206711769104,
0.1050674170255661,
0.05354982614517212,
0.4030783474445343,
-0.518415093421936,
0.26008498668670654,
0.12024558335542679,
-0.460647314786911,
-0.4120917022228241,
0.01905602030456066,
-0.12048806995153427,
0.3021157681941986,
0.3795397877693176,
0.16357475519180298,
-0.35989415645599365,
-1.0050737857818604,
-0.944733738899231,
0.017820168286561966,
0.2533527612686157,
0.04665795713663101,
-0.09432841837406158,
-0.12291937321424484,
0.8996701836585999,
-0.27038633823394775,
-0.300214558839798,
-0.2637941241264343,
0.5589129328727722,
0.32847753167152405,
0.02324521541595459,
0.5808751583099365,
-1.1271806955337524,
-0.28444167971611023,
-0.31550177931785583,
-0.4275933504104614,
-0.2085985392332077,
-0.4457589387893677,
0.19230955839157104,
0.24369414150714874,
0.23937129974365234,
-0.361258327960968,
0.5796140432357788,
0.5055611729621887,
-0.5774502754211426,
0.33849194645881653,
0.10443133115768433,
0.5365813970565796,
-0.7860079407691956,
-0.13932247459888458,
0.10876688361167908,
-0.27787911891937256,
-0.6473253965377808,
-0.24785806238651276,
-0.10394768416881561,
0.0812075287103653,
-0.6278943419456482,
0.017006726935505867,
-0.34067171812057495,
0.1355929672718048,
-0.24683551490306854,
0.2554936110973358,
0.23047059774398804,
-0.13143546879291534,
-0.09128440171480179,
0.499985009431839,
0.2069769948720932,
-0.7241373658180237,
-0.14157648384571075,
0.10576790571212769,
-0.36359113454818726,
0.41616156697273254,
0.05168408155441284,
-0.4096742272377014,
-0.46861422061920166,
0.37499579787254333,
-0.7079079747200012,
-0.30409783124923706,
0.7094922661781311,
-0.4946231544017792,
-0.17193572223186493,
-0.06458967179059982,
-0.5212588310241699,
-0.1350989043712616,
-0.29687070846557617,
0.030940836295485497,
0.16805730760097504,
-0.34665417671203613,
0.31705835461616516,
0.43603256344795227,
-0.0630638599395752,
-0.7725910544395447,
-1.236160159111023,
0.021393101662397385,
-0.3655107319355011,
-0.5803037881851196,
0.11983287334442139,
0.25525790452957153,
-0.5738538503646851,
0.4524773955345154,
-0.35093751549720764,
-0.12525279819965363,
-0.272234171628952,
0.17335601150989532,
-0.34669408202171326,
-0.18508055806159973,
0.6977174282073975,
0.11244441568851471,
0.1939947009086609,
-0.2007545381784439,
-0.15667647123336792,
0.22011849284172058,
0.33541446924209595,
-0.2917936444282532,
-0.6115208268165588,
0.7276053428649902,
0.10306645929813385,
0.15066339075565338,
0.8583418130874634,
0.39175739884376526,
-0.33380821347236633,
-0.48457571864128113,
-0.9773525595664978,
-0.08716319501399994,
-0.36401495337486267,
-0.005644620396196842,
0.3645663857460022,
-0.497246652841568,
0.15331318974494934,
0.04573492705821991,
0.12850959599018097,
0.7993040084838867,
0.03198513388633728,
-0.17284491658210754,
0.25443166494369507,
0.8800843954086304,
0.1578286737203598,
0.4095447361469269,
-0.028215544298291206,
0.31733083724975586,
0.07216975837945938,
-0.16375115513801575,
-0.5004594922065735,
-0.18102170526981354,
-0.43178147077560425,
-0.6740913391113281,
0.04141734167933464,
0.3225134611129761,
-0.1598094403743744,
0.03861672058701515,
-0.3810977637767792,
0.5781578421592712,
0.3259259760379791,
-0.12573908269405365,
0.5860345959663391,
0.025200096890330315,
0.6025230884552002,
-0.054606564342975616,
-0.8114723563194275,
-0.5467771887779236,
0.7328181862831116,
0.5695335268974304,
1.1738609075546265,
0.19020256400108337,
0.6146660447120667,
1.0011204481124878,
0.22762343287467957,
-0.5221295952796936,
-0.13858158886432648,
-0.09666804224252701,
-0.8445696830749512,
-0.02316351979970932,
-0.26237761974334717,
-0.30989617109298706,
0.12108781188726425,
-0.36636441946029663,
-0.594520628452301,
0.7236555218696594,
0.0349561832845211,
-0.33658915758132935,
0.7085636258125305,
-0.4853357672691345,
0.3685484528541565,
-0.06301113218069077,
-0.25774675607681274,
-0.5262689590454102,
-0.6680809259414673,
0.16886411607265472,
-0.11316651850938797,
0.78260737657547,
-0.1101435199379921,
-0.16360296308994293,
0.9224112033843994,
0.10346224904060364,
0.8411971926689148,
-0.039220359176397324,
0.20172905921936035,
0.7397618889808655,
0.19491051137447357,
0.10314957052469254,
0.1404663473367691,
0.07143290340900421,
0.342445433139801,
0.10309435427188873,
-0.33184725046157837,
-0.23311418294906616,
0.12446287274360657,
-1.0028966665267944,
-0.8073804974555969,
-0.6891367435455322,
-0.2486148327589035,
-0.04420590028166771,
0.2816489040851593,
0.6851664781570435,
0.4668756127357483,
-0.21876083314418793,
0.3036327362060547,
0.7091778516769409,
0.09174586087465286,
0.4904826879501343,
0.3659062683582306,
-0.2788316309452057,
-0.36638614535331726,
0.7202782034873962,
0.5971925258636475,
0.5590760111808777,
0.41722485423088074,
0.3618299067020416,
-0.1564655900001526,
-0.25916898250579834,
-0.5631011128425598,
0.2712472081184387,
-1.0420565605163574,
-0.17578968405723572,
-0.400704026222229,
-0.1595747172832489,
0.021071817725896835,
-0.17909061908721924,
-0.3810769021511078,
-0.39757898449897766,
-0.49903640151023865,
-0.13371260464191437,
0.23715706169605255,
1.1932058334350586,
-0.563156008720398,
0.6621763706207275,
-1.058251976966858,
0.20529918372631073,
0.08037582039833069,
0.12154045701026917,
-0.3974609375,
-0.19215065240859985,
-0.285948246717453,
0.367147296667099,
-0.724329948425293,
-1.2914085388183594,
-0.12287244200706482,
-0.14924053847789764,
0.5165504217147827,
0.7022229433059692,
0.2726607024669647,
0.35374927520751953,
-0.12328888475894928,
1.0658177137374878,
0.3371885418891907,
-0.9887893795967102,
0.15735825896263123,
-0.5367611050605774,
-0.2876873016357422,
0.6837446689605713,
0.9504460692405701,
-0.9445777535438538,
-0.5872452855110168,
-0.9341712594032288,
-0.4324607849121094,
0.6483355164527893,
-0.13555088639259338,
0.15206381678581238,
-0.13171125948429108,
-0.12593162059783936,
0.6981695294380188,
0.336568683385849,
-0.8569201827049255,
-0.34207087755203247,
-0.5575948357582092,
0.17229393124580383,
0.02007194422185421,
-0.4134158790111542,
-0.6150526404380798,
0.2869589328765869,
0.5406126976013184,
-0.06526581197977066,
0.2171519249677658,
0.6932470202445984,
-0.09600920975208282,
-0.5866987705230713,
0.344735324382782,
0.35706719756126404,
1.1164547204971313,
-0.06905197352170944,
0.1975584179162979,
-0.49896854162216187,
-0.2612598240375519,
-0.12099048495292664,
-0.13060180842876434,
-0.3464202880859375,
0.43282002210617065,
0.29636049270629883,
0.6560990810394287,
-0.08499807119369507,
-0.14874309301376343,
1.065413236618042,
0.12307409942150116,
-0.2189616560935974,
-0.36422842741012573,
-0.20293378829956055,
0.0845368355512619,
0.3084244430065155,
0.9102106690406799,
0.4718819856643677,
0.13550511002540588,
-0.8495891094207764,
0.2621389925479889,
0.057243525981903076,
-0.3336416482925415,
-0.2138005495071411,
0.3066596984863281,
0.30425623059272766,
-0.03850423917174339,
0.25309810042381287,
0.01159031130373478,
-0.27475637197494507,
0.3653997778892517,
0.678291380405426,
0.21722820401191711,
0.06661362946033478,
0.5964131355285645,
-0.058745019137859344,
0.4740954339504242,
-0.051134251058101654,
-0.0004642080457415432,
0.14450427889823914,
-0.6575387120246887,
-0.2399500608444214,
-0.19125309586524963,
-0.3156687021255493,
0.021801339462399483,
-0.24603530764579773,
0.3794490694999695,
-0.41135987639427185,
-0.30350562930107117,
-0.09064216166734695,
-0.06844141334295273,
-0.33311235904693604,
0.2844862639904022,
0.27815088629722595,
1.105570673942566,
-1.0919016599655151,
0.13820700347423553,
0.23367808759212494,
-0.5356507301330566,
-0.5939062237739563,
0.9621068835258484,
0.25920751690864563,
-0.08527529239654541,
0.15099048614501953,
0.19839423894882202,
0.04499099403619766,
-0.5752148628234863,
-0.4104297161102295,
-0.9342825412750244,
0.7073661684989929,
0.14555659890174866,
-0.5470775961875916,
0.03694126009941101,
0.4435569941997528,
-0.0038837918546050787,
-0.24472936987876892,
0.0848814845085144,
-0.03478430584073067,
0.5166119933128357,
0.12724286317825317,
-0.8120057582855225,
0.033664360642433167,
0.4503851532936096,
-0.5215390920639038,
0.42823320627212524,
-0.9882611036300659,
0.8813138604164124,
-0.07029283791780472,
-0.44718337059020996,
-0.39222192764282227,
0.44993287324905396,
-0.3900405764579773,
0.5436834692955017,
0.3186682164669037,
0.21493148803710938,
0.7302860617637634,
-0.03069116733968258,
0.7620973587036133,
-0.1446438431739807,
0.25661584734916687,
0.4772934317588806,
0.3525906205177307,
0.5647270679473877,
0.6414263248443604,
0.0001022515571094118,
0.5351109504699707,
0.6698935031890869,
0.1421901285648346,
0.6673865914344788,
-0.07049831002950668,
-0.004405631683766842,
-0.19007593393325806,
-0.30073246359825134,
-0.6487076878547668,
0.2120404988527298,
0.5802382826805115,
-0.4485383927822113,
-0.438541978597641,
-0.0834140032529831,
0.21453844010829926,
0.3951226770877838,
-0.5008384585380554,
0.6161267757415771,
0.15544027090072632,
-0.3842841386795044,
0.3764648735523224,
0.01585977151989937,
0.6944167017936707,
-0.5168545842170715,
0.13112546503543854,
0.10569252073764801,
0.16511760652065277,
-0.7767444849014282,
-1.056442379951477,
0.8940541744232178,
-0.4145925045013428,
-0.39846181869506836,
-0.05728966370224953,
0.88750159740448,
-0.230699360370636,
-0.12276621162891388,
0.3114203214645386,
0.6807934641838074,
-0.09171351045370102,
-0.24426594376564026,
-0.3199092149734497,
0.3063936233520508,
0.1369287669658661,
0.13085491955280304,
0.18255075812339783,
0.3872436285018921,
-0.09557212144136429,
0.37469482421875,
0.43481358885765076,
0.18220658600330353,
0.10627661645412445,
-0.32774442434310913,
0.8524354696273804,
-0.7797866463661194,
-0.628655731678009,
-0.5828991532325745,
0.42181283235549927,
-0.23444852232933044,
-0.6165555119514465,
0.8493550419807434,
0.5008834004402161,
0.7989869117736816,
0.021488673985004425,
1.0213408470153809,
-0.24273276329040527,
0.7984153628349304,
-0.2165045291185379,
0.8809748291969299,
-0.4801512062549591,
-0.1470290869474411,
-0.24094296991825104,
-0.8131471872329712,
-0.1343318372964859,
0.0825570747256279,
-0.24095478653907776,
-0.2818828523159027,
0.6336454153060913,
0.5866374969482422,
-0.20552974939346313,
0.6817898750305176,
0.0598347932100296,
0.0620705671608448,
0.022171758115291595,
0.029285738244652748,
1.2346150875091553,
-0.06346890330314636,
0.4366767406463623,
-0.6376259326934814,
-0.3803524076938629,
-0.35655730962753296,
-0.8393465280532837,
-0.6443355679512024,
-0.5128828883171082,
-0.12091739475727081,
-0.3971812427043915,
0.30800357460975647,
0.875480592250824,
0.4266350567340851,
-0.25684696435928345,
0.03964047506451607,
0.19174687564373016,
0.43560662865638733,
-0.17044560611248016,
-0.24206137657165527,
0.05206004157662392,
0.01255654077976942,
-0.3657781481742859,
-0.044261299073696136,
0.11623473465442657,
-0.30118417739868164,
-0.07233908027410507,
0.3175758719444275,
-0.41313034296035767,
0.5503131151199341,
0.28948357701301575,
0.28940874338150024,
-0.6660277843475342,
-0.3727020025253296,
-0.3242514133453369,
-0.18482069671154022,
0.3041022717952728,
0.7171701192855835,
-0.5456728339195251,
0.24461770057678223,
0.4453786015510559,
0.4250389337539673,
0.03678235784173012,
0.5694875121116638,
0.2734755277633667,
-0.5367797613143921,
0.1245415061712265,
0.25648775696754456,
-0.13654161989688873,
0.6502060890197754,
-0.7336016893386841,
-0.1149943545460701,
0.60658198595047,
-0.484512597322464,
-0.36136215925216675,
-0.00625073816627264,
-0.47160041332244873,
-0.4627489149570465,
1.3040176630020142,
0.2713433504104614,
-0.22442755103111267,
-0.35401830077171326,
-0.19335657358169556,
0.18241293728351593,
-0.6479671597480774,
0.5276929140090942,
0.7633745670318604,
-0.3829759359359741,
0.17825685441493988,
-0.5646240711212158,
0.6786530017852783,
-0.05566553398966789,
-0.3995839059352875,
0.12531569600105286,
0.6674832701683044,
0.641005277633667,
0.4984677731990814,
0.5812219381332397,
0.028933264315128326,
0.2423182874917984,
0.32802698016166687,
-0.3767903745174408,
0.0392611026763916,
-0.4892188012599945,
-0.06719186902046204,
0.1319483518600464,
-0.23355287313461304,
-0.1808929592370987
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09734v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09734v2
|
Do Large Language Models Solve ARC Visual Analogies Like People Do?
| 2024-03-13T09:48:13 | 2024-05-13T11:20:23 |
Gustaw Opiełka, Hannes Rosenbusch, Veerle Vijverberg, Claire E. Stevenson
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The Abstraction Reasoning Corpus (ARC) is a visual analogical reasoning test
designed for humans and machines (Chollet, 2019). We compared human and large
language model (LLM) performance on a new child-friendly set of ARC items.
Results show that both children and adults outperform most LLMs on these tasks.
Error analysis revealed a similar "fallback" solution strategy in LLMs and
young children, where part of the analogy is simply copied. In addition, we
found two other error types, one based on seemingly grasping key concepts
(e.g., Inside-Outside) and the other based on simple combinations of analogy
input matrices. On the whole, "concept" errors were more common in humans, and
"matrix" errors were more common in LLMs. This study sheds new light on LLM
reasoning ability and the extent to which we can use error analyses and
comparisons with human development to understand how LLMs solve visual
analogies.
|
[
-0.39044898748397827,
-0.6900755167007446,
0.6192708015441895,
0.05701032280921936,
-0.066006138920784,
0.4059723913669586,
-0.24848490953445435,
-0.6516200304031372,
-0.09830629825592041,
0.40298107266426086,
-0.47560492157936096,
-0.4414520263671875,
-0.5203211307525635,
0.2849486768245697,
-0.6692790985107422,
0.19940297305583954,
-0.42033901810646057,
0.07224154472351074,
-0.49942371249198914,
0.021576102823019028,
-0.22608597576618195,
-0.5113254189491272,
-0.8104828000068665,
-0.553084135055542,
0.5425622463226318,
0.5596997141838074,
0.7365060448646545,
0.736793041229248,
0.7662328481674194,
0.26755571365356445,
-0.14182274043560028,
0.04875106364488602,
-0.36063632369041443,
-0.11660967022180557,
-0.3729414939880371,
-0.49038928747177124,
-0.3490656316280365,
-0.14420221745967865,
0.49167880415916443,
1.097641110420227,
-0.11028075963258743,
0.04021750018000603,
0.02084069326519966,
0.8922428488731384,
-0.5604901909828186,
0.31617969274520874,
-0.5374706387519836,
-0.06607065349817276,
-0.09565073996782303,
0.0366051085293293,
-0.5941164493560791,
-0.3234655261039734,
0.13343840837478638,
-0.6255963444709778,
0.12092213332653046,
0.4606119692325592,
0.8367056250572205,
0.31099528074264526,
-0.2478586584329605,
-0.3534286320209503,
-0.8241331577301025,
0.8021645545959473,
-0.6716870665550232,
0.11034193634986877,
0.16756358742713928,
0.21230177581310272,
-0.45385390520095825,
-0.6562725305557251,
-1.0424726009368896,
-0.302957683801651,
-0.03147108480334282,
-0.19428285956382751,
-0.539816677570343,
0.13010485470294952,
0.3595536947250366,
0.043787918984889984,
-0.5956966876983643,
0.3864166736602783,
-0.56793612241745,
-0.04383939504623413,
0.6119132041931152,
0.41384923458099365,
0.6698150038719177,
-0.0642613098025322,
-0.33929604291915894,
-0.3603556156158447,
-0.9610732793807983,
0.12272469699382782,
0.14609530568122864,
-0.10293222218751907,
-0.1001436859369278,
0.7814096808433533,
-0.18578514456748962,
0.7530978322029114,
0.020236670970916748,
-0.10695553570985794,
0.1068682074546814,
-0.051860567182302475,
-0.021874263882637024,
-0.01952521502971649,
0.5436457395553589,
0.7088744044303894,
0.8385810852050781,
-0.028434397652745247,
-0.26174429059028625,
0.3921584486961365,
0.09951791167259216,
-0.45109933614730835,
-0.23677679896354675,
-0.10048680007457733,
-0.5057548880577087,
0.067026287317276,
-0.08362478017807007,
-0.6688505411148071,
-0.5268044471740723,
-0.5614879131317139,
0.3778550624847412,
-0.4718893766403198,
-0.10056113451719284,
0.3358498215675354,
0.01520355325192213,
0.43961647152900696,
0.4384825527667999,
-0.7456809878349304,
0.5640221834182739,
0.7995761632919312,
0.5737682580947876,
-0.5541059374809265,
-0.7062612175941467,
-0.22685378789901733,
-0.16236749291419983,
-0.6464633345603943,
1.0814567804336548,
-0.48433154821395874,
-0.1925249844789505,
-0.2953382134437561,
-0.3232972025871277,
-0.2748768627643585,
-0.9670851826667786,
0.21664607524871826,
-0.4013911783695221,
-0.21194221079349518,
-0.16875790059566498,
-0.3797668516635895,
-0.30493125319480896,
0.16215120255947113,
-0.7144610285758972,
0.7664909362792969,
0.2192550003528595,
-0.6776511669158936,
0.3079991042613983,
-0.5425475239753723,
-0.20441694557666779,
-0.2655292749404907,
-0.2743476927280426,
-0.2543124556541443,
0.18193988502025604,
0.1589852124452591,
0.3271026015281677,
-0.5626992583274841,
-0.04018501192331314,
-0.3724607229232788,
-0.6634458899497986,
0.47451409697532654,
-0.24406230449676514,
0.6475995779037476,
0.09447313100099564,
-0.34010976552963257,
0.16464248299598694,
-0.5358885526657104,
0.006930289790034294,
0.30889102816581726,
-0.22682099044322968,
-0.24266788363456726,
0.14575567841529846,
-0.26967161893844604,
0.45539793372154236,
0.0044912006705999374,
-0.4281260073184967,
0.21423161029815674,
-0.3123941719532013,
0.6653368473052979,
0.5776731967926025,
-0.10946053266525269,
0.27833291888237,
-0.38856375217437744,
0.5282596349716187,
0.13210034370422363,
-0.08622509241104126,
-0.14212484657764435,
-0.6456348299980164,
-1.0951792001724243,
-0.1187688559293747,
0.09447337687015533,
0.41387566924095154,
-0.7489737272262573,
0.28271010518074036,
-0.3799961507320404,
-0.401256263256073,
-0.21940699219703674,
0.15107084810733795,
0.4002881646156311,
0.5733930468559265,
0.10572376102209091,
-0.4827442467212677,
-0.6267911791801453,
-1.0704360008239746,
0.02010256238281727,
-0.5621927976608276,
-0.025573281571269035,
0.23522767424583435,
0.8117302060127258,
-0.2670706808567047,
1.0814824104309082,
-0.26232224702835083,
-0.028828086331486702,
-0.36032915115356445,
0.2025751918554306,
0.040674008429050446,
0.09103262424468994,
0.4914553463459015,
-0.5127126574516296,
-0.14244845509529114,
0.015485292300581932,
-0.9459478259086609,
-0.12072434276342392,
-0.012859816662967205,
0.1418066918849945,
0.19167564809322357,
0.6398626565933228,
-0.5802558064460754,
0.634292721748352,
0.5474052429199219,
-0.4932801127433777,
0.8257619142532349,
-0.2206716239452362,
-0.040374308824539185,
-0.5342593193054199,
-0.06494417041540146,
0.0344364307820797,
-0.05508507415652275,
-0.21962803602218628,
0.27635669708251953,
-0.03449278324842453,
0.006629087496548891,
-0.7303680181503296,
0.6091020107269287,
-0.44186845421791077,
-0.4455684423446655,
-0.19583475589752197,
0.10464931279420853,
0.020024539902806282,
0.44157683849334717,
0.18080197274684906,
1.0043060779571533,
0.7042139768600464,
-0.46417203545570374,
0.6230118274688721,
-0.2049844115972519,
-0.514215886592865,
0.8495720624923706,
-0.8594769239425659,
0.1526261270046234,
-0.30210447311401367,
0.35117289423942566,
-1.063360333442688,
-0.35875701904296875,
0.06348571926355362,
-0.24429649114608765,
0.038492362946271896,
0.39561596512794495,
-0.5681447386741638,
-0.7416031360626221,
-0.2524412274360657,
0.5440062880516052,
0.5680246949195862,
-0.6086412072181702,
0.8599098324775696,
0.1181764081120491,
-0.17197474837303162,
-0.63506680727005,
-0.7361822724342346,
0.35859018564224243,
-0.3273608684539795,
-0.8540401458740234,
-0.17205233871936798,
-0.056674402207136154,
-0.8257313966751099,
0.14218255877494812,
0.08383011817932129,
-0.24169602990150452,
0.0964275673031807,
0.17178992927074432,
0.32595381140708923,
-0.493478924036026,
0.01748064160346985,
-0.2569325864315033,
-0.1271921843290329,
0.20088502764701843,
0.15404252707958221,
0.6381089687347412,
-0.5224228501319885,
-0.7558140158653259,
-0.5029084086418152,
0.32291674613952637,
0.7576131224632263,
0.11136038601398468,
0.636478841304779,
-0.1523803323507309,
-0.3509465157985687,
-0.15899188816547394,
-0.3844850957393646,
-0.2408982813358307,
-0.4118485450744629,
0.5108705163002014,
-0.414555162191391,
-0.445069283246994,
0.6354473829269409,
-0.033388901501894,
-0.03968178108334541,
0.42337632179260254,
0.6374495625495911,
-0.5547779202461243,
0.7537751197814941,
0.29295796155929565,
0.171208456158638,
-0.0654778927564621,
-0.49114659428596497,
0.10674653947353363,
-0.8709203600883484,
-0.1937321424484253,
-0.3868556320667267,
-0.6983510255813599,
-0.026444312185049057,
-0.4929644465446472,
0.0910947322845459,
0.31247958540916443,
-0.5646495819091797,
0.3595382571220398,
-0.3905647397041321,
0.6307812333106995,
0.5127726793289185,
-0.015171762555837631,
0.6882558465003967,
-0.02551386132836342,
-0.07660383731126785,
-0.22570928931236267,
-0.6850854158401489,
-0.722567081451416,
1.1322122812271118,
0.3290746808052063,
1.1958264112472534,
0.0630287453532219,
0.5471801161766052,
0.10268660634756088,
0.6338707804679871,
-0.8435778617858887,
0.7878571152687073,
-0.1447162926197052,
-0.5218327641487122,
-0.23398782312870026,
-0.20407310128211975,
-1.061602234840393,
0.24269427359104156,
-0.22575640678405762,
-0.9500641822814941,
0.3028787672519684,
0.14740005135536194,
-0.010765713639557362,
0.5474767684936523,
-1.0219796895980835,
0.7152034640312195,
-0.15753266215324402,
0.14542272686958313,
-0.3025214374065399,
-0.6574616432189941,
0.5446080565452576,
-0.2100321352481842,
0.20915837585926056,
-0.1403018683195114,
-0.1166151687502861,
0.6285120248794556,
-0.13442084193229675,
0.9765986204147339,
0.379885196685791,
0.07144873589277267,
0.6448082327842712,
0.2999962270259857,
0.2946694493293762,
-0.47059357166290283,
0.008705547079443932,
0.26101794838905334,
-0.3523487150669098,
-0.3818633556365967,
-0.8874420523643494,
0.5803403258323669,
-0.9032791256904602,
-0.6843271255493164,
-0.46619364619255066,
-0.5201799273490906,
0.04670426622033119,
-0.043145667761564255,
0.0871577113866806,
0.2768137753009796,
-0.07882154732942581,
0.2797152101993561,
0.6782715916633606,
-0.13273048400878906,
0.48629695177078247,
0.3718422055244446,
-0.3162713348865509,
0.09162731468677521,
0.6808007955551147,
-0.1492830365896225,
0.7003412842750549,
0.1978016048669815,
0.2502441704273224,
-0.15690520405769348,
-0.5986603498458862,
-0.7270022034645081,
0.3922230899333954,
-0.9258027672767639,
0.05933478847146034,
-0.352568119764328,
-0.3114964962005615,
0.19401268661022186,
-0.24280671775341034,
-0.39409828186035156,
-0.42680445313453674,
-0.10445021092891693,
0.010266730561852455,
0.14891795814037323,
0.7253937721252441,
0.14117585122585297,
0.13611970841884613,
-0.36815980076789856,
0.427392840385437,
0.6829147934913635,
0.19693990051746368,
0.48289763927459717,
-0.2980952560901642,
0.09936702251434326,
0.022344302386045456,
-0.4711128771305084,
-0.5718587636947632,
-0.004071875475347042,
0.13388946652412415,
0.46457087993621826,
0.33072924613952637,
-0.12876221537590027,
0.5101202726364136,
-0.56992107629776,
0.8090313673019409,
0.40958836674690247,
-0.8398433923721313,
0.03129224479198456,
-0.23298339545726776,
0.22292055189609528,
0.2546556293964386,
0.12115544825792313,
-0.6439820528030396,
-0.3209077715873718,
-0.5063062310218811,
-0.722292959690094,
0.518502414226532,
0.2618272304534912,
0.05312058702111244,
0.09085192531347275,
0.21044562757015228,
0.014126976951956749,
-0.08351345360279083,
-0.652894914150238,
-0.41062667965888977,
0.18062260746955872,
-0.2491353303194046,
-0.018932340666651726,
-0.0031787476036697626,
-0.016704194247722626,
-0.31441038846969604,
0.1287216991186142,
-0.08040553331375122,
0.28898972272872925,
-0.03964480757713318,
-0.10767697542905807,
-0.4913780093193054,
0.20984210073947906,
0.6248376965522766,
1.2164931297302246,
0.08911044150590897,
0.393642783164978,
0.3109624981880188,
-0.34724023938179016,
0.3459582030773163,
-0.3144530951976776,
-0.09843407571315765,
-0.20448808372020721,
0.7965763807296753,
0.631098747253418,
0.3242332935333252,
-1.2721381187438965,
0.5028613805770874,
-0.08826565742492676,
-0.22792477905750275,
-0.49737808108329773,
0.21139580011367798,
0.5398125648498535,
0.13124296069145203,
0.5275117754936218,
0.2831827998161316,
-0.19633527100086212,
-0.8578653335571289,
0.17053334414958954,
0.22619546949863434,
-0.04239679127931595,
-0.20943023264408112,
0.7171556353569031,
0.15361566841602325,
-0.7482001185417175,
0.7441710233688354,
0.12602519989013672,
-0.36570799350738525,
0.9533984065055847,
0.45353972911834717,
0.7030560970306396,
0.08539775758981705,
0.08657804131507874,
0.08520451188087463,
0.2961486876010895,
-0.27873918414115906,
0.04711465165019035,
0.3581194579601288,
-0.949428915977478,
-0.8044936656951904,
-0.3352123200893402,
-0.6708887815475464,
-0.1376473754644394,
-0.4914019703865051,
0.29674816131591797,
-0.34186312556266785,
0.26919862627983093,
0.16052740812301636,
-0.46759507060050964,
-0.775780439376831,
0.2211398184299469,
0.28782811760902405,
0.8812840580940247,
-0.8829670548439026,
0.6953693628311157,
0.7007960081100464,
-0.40217721462249756,
-0.979917049407959,
-0.10832704603672028,
-0.05604758858680725,
-1.0429413318634033,
1.0910180807113647,
-0.02390957809984684,
-0.39522573351860046,
-0.2856990098953247,
-0.5868692994117737,
-0.888687789440155,
0.8893111348152161,
0.5725191235542297,
-0.676519513130188,
-0.3506992757320404,
0.1863981932401657,
0.8075785636901855,
-0.6780655980110168,
0.2960996925830841,
0.8874362707138062,
0.4576016962528229,
0.32345324754714966,
-1.1482187509536743,
-0.14763350784778595,
0.008559882640838623,
0.021567808464169502,
0.036150503903627396,
-0.3722675144672394,
1.03867769241333,
-0.5647830963134766,
-0.15173526108264923,
0.25806277990341187,
0.5955048203468323,
0.5024648308753967,
0.5663106441497803,
0.5550980567932129,
0.7627145648002625,
0.38231444358825684,
-0.06059693917632103,
1.387369155883789,
0.0845487043261528,
0.277715265750885,
1.0073298215866089,
-0.29820695519447327,
1.037703275680542,
0.5274701118469238,
-0.35506126284599304,
0.7358621954917908,
0.6206762194633484,
0.42095983028411865,
0.1332816630601883,
0.46141472458839417,
0.06688939034938812,
-0.2971436083316803,
0.2920856773853302,
-0.17635773122310638,
0.43012112379074097,
0.49688154458999634,
-0.38780874013900757,
-0.2871662378311157,
-0.1420959234237671,
-0.08708414435386658,
0.40246912837028503,
-0.4372178912162781,
0.6761402487754822,
0.3924599289894104,
-0.6171274781227112,
0.8750869035720825,
-0.08824148029088974,
0.5193288922309875,
-0.13882367312908173,
-0.12083516269922256,
-0.08596237003803253,
0.24403485655784607,
-0.09584565460681915,
-1.1180752515792847,
0.31352123618125916,
-0.06144491210579872,
-0.06635847687721252,
0.18075351417064667,
0.4481225907802582,
-0.18586212396621704,
-0.5772685408592224,
0.21966774761676788,
0.5317143201828003,
0.38721802830696106,
0.1263662576675415,
-0.6760653257369995,
-0.004607024136930704,
-0.11840490996837616,
-0.03370518237352371,
0.11523458361625671,
0.3265331983566284,
-0.5199152827262878,
1.2648457288742065,
0.2900314927101135,
0.270795077085495,
0.2563299536705017,
-0.0628068670630455,
0.8133618831634521,
-0.7708688974380493,
-0.19535446166992188,
-0.8737706542015076,
0.3810613751411438,
-0.08393549919128418,
-0.4000062048435211,
0.4066617786884308,
0.39370158314704895,
0.8406808376312256,
-0.20844291150569916,
0.47624436020851135,
0.2813788652420044,
0.5938245058059692,
-0.435482919216156,
0.3646834194660187,
-0.4031817317008972,
0.2171226143836975,
-0.48422208428382874,
-1.393627643585205,
-0.44805237650871277,
0.7690525054931641,
-0.49882635474205017,
-0.052857376635074615,
1.0954419374465942,
0.657810389995575,
-0.11632019281387329,
-0.06555531919002533,
0.27713942527770996,
0.26552000641822815,
0.2470722645521164,
0.9707533717155457,
1.2206695079803467,
-0.06285260617733002,
0.5641205310821533,
-0.06068791076540947,
-0.1180691048502922,
-0.28923818469047546,
-0.7584956884384155,
-0.9479212164878845,
-0.3542706072330475,
-0.2436145544052124,
-0.27888768911361694,
0.1278240978717804,
0.8865371942520142,
0.5986062288284302,
-0.6370110511779785,
-0.33379051089286804,
-0.08778680115938187,
0.26309385895729065,
-0.3453337252140045,
-0.1748744249343872,
0.5251320004463196,
0.2775416374206543,
-0.7457401156425476,
0.0026297203730791807,
0.2359417825937271,
-0.0035748279187828302,
-0.6358294486999512,
-0.22252704203128815,
0.11735639721155167,
0.1845853179693222,
0.43373745679855347,
0.32044246792793274,
-1.170049786567688,
-0.5824387073516846,
-0.03402763977646828,
-0.29040026664733887,
0.36849814653396606,
0.961414098739624,
-0.861802339553833,
0.5168602466583252,
0.4132467806339264,
0.5092428922653198,
0.44897204637527466,
0.08656884729862213,
0.46026167273521423,
-0.2782328724861145,
0.26579055190086365,
0.28989148139953613,
0.5405951142311096,
0.46307334303855896,
-0.04872001335024834,
0.4239075481891632,
0.26595810055732727,
-0.3846312463283539,
-0.5573664307594299,
0.4692554473876953,
-1.0560798645019531,
-0.2997363805770874,
1.1715489625930786,
-0.13052533566951752,
-0.4286019802093506,
-0.2710442841053009,
-0.42442676424980164,
-0.30897098779678345,
-0.40149205923080444,
1.009254813194275,
0.8771976232528687,
-0.38131681084632874,
-0.3731901943683624,
-0.19268111884593964,
-0.01101356279104948,
0.1589532494544983,
-0.8158485889434814,
-0.08509042859077454,
0.3215060830116272,
0.34436407685279846,
0.24939237534999847,
0.3077367842197418,
0.02414504438638687,
0.6555663347244263,
0.06649374961853027,
0.20190472900867462,
0.013334282673895359,
-0.15167821943759918,
-0.13142584264278412,
-0.03272789344191551,
0.4409410357475281,
-0.01620323769748211
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08377v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08377v1
|
Learning to Describe for Predicting Zero-shot Drug-Drug Interactions
| 2024-03-13T09:42:46 | 2024-03-13T09:42:46 |
Fangqi Zhu, Yongqi Zhang, Lei Chen, Bing Qin, Ruifeng Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Adverse drug-drug interactions~(DDIs) can compromise the effectiveness of
concurrent drug administration, posing a significant challenge in healthcare.
As the development of new drugs continues, the potential for unknown adverse
effects resulting from DDIs becomes a growing concern. Traditional
computational methods for DDI prediction may fail to capture interactions for
new drugs due to the lack of knowledge. In this paper, we introduce a new
problem setup as zero-shot DDI prediction that deals with the case of new
drugs. Leveraging textual information from online databases like DrugBank and
PubChem, we propose an innovative approach TextDDI with a language model-based
DDI predictor and a reinforcement learning~(RL)-based information selector,
enabling the selection of concise and pertinent text for accurate DDI
prediction on new drugs. Empirical results show the benefits of the proposed
approach on several settings including zero-shot and few-shot DDI prediction,
and the selected texts are semantically relevant. Our code and data are
available at \url{https://github.com/zhufq00/DDIs-Prediction}.
|
[
-0.010176796466112137,
-0.7987199425697327,
0.9634804129600525,
-0.03616437688469887,
0.05956589803099632,
0.09226467460393906,
0.1838085800409317,
-0.6209947466850281,
0.41016867756843567,
0.4717724025249481,
-0.67109215259552,
-0.5668485164642334,
-0.7339820861816406,
0.1648203432559967,
-0.12671127915382385,
1.3758623600006104,
-0.22335588932037354,
0.13935695588588715,
-0.15624424815177917,
0.06520780175924301,
-0.7616778016090393,
-0.2464226633310318,
-0.6104730367660522,
-0.5844880938529968,
0.7675124406814575,
0.2763604521751404,
0.12123356759548187,
0.23240986466407776,
0.4978890120983124,
0.3264046907424927,
0.026792673394083977,
-0.24785205721855164,
-0.4514845609664917,
0.37794989347457886,
-0.16817519068717957,
-0.3386510908603668,
-0.3773305416107178,
-0.03187791630625725,
0.1972908079624176,
0.5226122140884399,
-0.1621386706829071,
-0.1899840235710144,
-0.517136812210083,
0.42105457186698914,
-0.9050004482269287,
0.19142191112041473,
-0.4969313442707062,
0.38861027359962463,
0.04507603868842125,
-0.2739052474498749,
-0.35292425751686096,
0.07709157466888428,
0.3719584345817566,
-0.8691827058792114,
-0.2411908507347107,
-0.14899711310863495,
0.8961502313613892,
0.12325828522443771,
-0.5441769957542419,
-0.3992184102535248,
-0.679656982421875,
0.7079382538795471,
-0.6877288818359375,
-0.017861656844615936,
0.2553134262561798,
0.6505528092384338,
-0.3465386927127838,
-0.4570218622684479,
-0.8258761763572693,
0.13993589580059052,
-0.1793891191482544,
0.15324503183364868,
-0.0157807357609272,
0.23182110488414764,
-0.11865711212158203,
0.13913726806640625,
-0.3617672324180603,
0.2695300579071045,
-0.49095210433006287,
-0.012934528291225433,
0.5671360492706299,
0.5067636966705322,
0.40609294176101685,
-0.48319804668426514,
-0.567836344242096,
0.3849049508571625,
-0.41640010476112366,
-0.07446493208408356,
-0.0738651230931282,
0.3839499056339264,
-0.2758693993091583,
0.5968001484870911,
-0.20681454241275787,
0.5863426923751831,
0.41959890723228455,
-0.059825263917446136,
0.42688092589378357,
-0.390188992023468,
-0.445616215467453,
0.18118424713611603,
1.017090916633606,
0.630569338798523,
0.14119549095630646,
-0.2458273321390152,
-0.030120374634861946,
-0.09261158108711243,
0.13119661808013916,
-1.0174304246902466,
-0.18333593010902405,
0.8195228576660156,
-0.34086117148399353,
-0.8178022503852844,
-0.11226736754179001,
-1.1705292463302612,
-0.7695766091346741,
-0.10253261774778366,
0.7451503276824951,
-0.6655294895172119,
-0.19573014974594116,
-0.003866290207952261,
-0.29390406608581543,
0.201090008020401,
0.2013096958398819,
-0.8170191049575806,
0.3213808834552765,
0.422873318195343,
0.6985443234443665,
-0.3466286063194275,
-0.5163236260414124,
-0.7228728532791138,
0.550499439239502,
-0.2607589364051819,
1.0887902975082397,
-0.3247039318084717,
-0.3723343312740326,
0.21272340416908264,
-0.08536086976528168,
-0.14042136073112488,
-0.3473023772239685,
0.5885069370269775,
-0.24747145175933838,
0.212144136428833,
0.05856495723128319,
-0.7047135233879089,
0.011436082422733307,
0.18376895785331726,
-0.7058503031730652,
0.0715794786810875,
-0.009600848890841007,
-1.0978434085845947,
0.6035104990005493,
-0.570441722869873,
-0.41914573311805725,
0.08185399323701859,
-0.17604385316371918,
-0.7032495737075806,
0.08470523357391357,
0.01440846361219883,
0.5073555111885071,
0.26195278763771057,
0.48708784580230713,
-0.5966835618019104,
-0.5348323583602905,
0.644680917263031,
-0.04620884731411934,
0.5459023118019104,
0.2482958883047104,
0.05221683531999588,
0.3080354630947113,
-0.8828292489051819,
0.0057168882340192795,
0.03285800665616989,
-0.18570488691329956,
-0.2206222116947174,
-0.3364764153957367,
0.06089666485786438,
0.331695556640625,
0.019981369376182556,
-0.8213457465171814,
0.03368329629302025,
-0.4495142102241516,
0.12260618805885315,
0.687896728515625,
0.6138062477111816,
0.4994148910045624,
-0.329397052526474,
0.32300764322280884,
0.16006208956241608,
0.3049315810203552,
-0.2013750821352005,
-0.4329926669597626,
-0.27590444684028625,
-0.05759255960583687,
0.543775737285614,
0.688928484916687,
-1.0202025175094604,
0.05964922904968262,
-0.26196911931037903,
-0.20784637331962585,
-0.1427951157093048,
-0.11313099414110184,
0.5084660053253174,
0.30403801798820496,
0.25498780608177185,
-0.011208703741431236,
-0.6876600384712219,
-0.3255871832370758,
-0.11358526349067688,
-0.08513913303613663,
-0.2668624222278595,
0.4453028738498688,
0.36400288343429565,
-0.47166404128074646,
0.8190333843231201,
-0.8131812214851379,
-0.6559803485870361,
-0.37919315695762634,
0.44941118359565735,
0.07880128920078278,
0.030517207458615303,
0.41184523701667786,
-0.39654475450515747,
-0.4976325035095215,
0.03549669310450554,
-0.8113517761230469,
-0.056676045060157776,
-0.2545500099658966,
-0.07907022535800934,
0.1526653915643692,
0.412476122379303,
-0.43236953020095825,
0.4251731038093567,
0.40766867995262146,
-0.3379449248313904,
0.10413657873868942,
-0.44268491864204407,
0.2724055349826813,
-1.1189934015274048,
-0.08856061846017838,
0.4483112096786499,
0.448954701423645,
-0.9982199668884277,
-0.501085102558136,
0.03838026151061058,
-0.17282766103744507,
-0.6289066076278687,
0.8692631721496582,
-0.21010690927505493,
0.3725273609161377,
-0.2656783163547516,
0.0553746223449707,
-0.09767797589302063,
0.5063883066177368,
0.17015203833580017,
0.3920612037181854,
0.580244779586792,
-0.6471417546272278,
0.058663830161094666,
0.3351043462753296,
-0.07658941298723221,
0.5084211826324463,
-0.4897351562976837,
-0.5485146045684814,
-0.26551130414009094,
0.2661804258823395,
-0.5895509123802185,
-0.38453108072280884,
0.3965935707092285,
-0.6796627640724182,
0.6470963954925537,
-0.23417852818965912,
0.0870376005768776,
-0.2080874741077423,
-0.6157723069190979,
0.3453274071216583,
0.09368482232093811,
-0.2860630750656128,
0.545293390750885,
0.7915458679199219,
-0.1516551822423935,
-0.7209628224372864,
-0.5621430277824402,
0.14523549377918243,
0.01774001307785511,
0.11376959830522537,
0.4279678463935852,
-0.13244035840034485,
-0.023702338337898254,
0.12784233689308167,
0.16121891140937805,
-0.7030977010726929,
-0.1445397436618805,
0.5461020469665527,
0.6829436421394348,
0.3209448456764221,
0.30056852102279663,
0.11738857626914978,
-0.35810983180999756,
0.02602108009159565,
0.1438141167163849,
0.033560026437044144,
0.33147957921028137,
0.23235557973384857,
-0.5451573133468628,
0.3174482583999634,
0.4550579786300659,
0.05402194336056709,
0.6284639835357666,
0.3547211289405823,
-0.279509574174881,
-0.14950412511825562,
-0.12550821900367737,
0.07436130940914154,
-0.4217582941055298,
0.367227703332901,
-0.35957783460617065,
-0.32506513595581055,
0.041458938270807266,
-0.19076085090637207,
-0.35463953018188477,
0.09620314836502075,
0.4261392056941986,
0.04518096148967743,
0.6731452941894531,
0.776713490486145,
0.0021287845447659492,
0.44846609234809875,
-0.24429473280906677,
0.38619092106819153,
-0.7513299584388733,
-0.5635541677474976,
0.0012597095919772983,
-0.09335633367300034,
-0.6801836490631104,
-0.4850885570049286,
0.2858993709087372,
-0.07578481733798981,
-0.2326546460390091,
0.3320712149143219,
-0.22278887033462524,
0.5057365298271179,
0.03878257796168327,
-0.031749628484249115,
0.11220186948776245,
-0.022364763543009758,
-0.174076646566391,
0.05380808189511299,
-0.40018323063850403,
0.04303821548819542,
1.481226921081543,
0.20896930992603302,
0.764360785484314,
0.06800120323896408,
0.8000141978263855,
0.11246988922357559,
0.2725940942764282,
-0.6610397696495056,
0.3905412554740906,
-0.16159670054912567,
-0.31191587448120117,
-0.20909030735492706,
-0.6305840015411377,
-1.1587148904800415,
-0.2568896412849426,
-0.8115702271461487,
-0.6960107088088989,
0.23783205449581146,
-0.4838293790817261,
-0.8498259782791138,
0.2116423398256302,
-0.8827435970306396,
0.6828552484512329,
-0.24507588148117065,
-0.2680571675300598,
-0.06676801294088364,
-0.6499211192131042,
0.3429531455039978,
-0.049567293375730515,
0.39991405606269836,
-0.22856177389621735,
-0.025660960003733635,
0.33565157651901245,
-0.2788268029689789,
0.7797634601593018,
-0.13755887746810913,
-0.12453393638134003,
0.12465324252843857,
-0.02641097642481327,
-0.037959519773721695,
0.13521748781204224,
-0.04900587350130081,
0.3538849651813507,
0.1763422191143036,
-0.3543471097946167,
-0.8603637218475342,
1.0294122695922852,
-0.6565859317779541,
0.08423059433698654,
-0.5645171403884888,
-0.21293427050113678,
-0.12925191223621368,
0.15669652819633484,
0.2013324648141861,
0.20288266241550446,
-0.47099465131759644,
-0.7819797396659851,
0.589942991733551,
-0.6087172627449036,
0.47880232334136963,
1.0185277462005615,
-0.28021562099456787,
-0.7182213664054871,
1.098702073097229,
0.20141419768333435,
-0.09128111600875854,
0.7512320876121521,
0.00464017316699028,
-0.18929387629032135,
-0.5791727900505066,
-0.5113895535469055,
0.23833781480789185,
-0.30092117190361023,
-0.39635783433914185,
-0.6462880969047546,
-0.4320168197154999,
-0.5158257484436035,
0.07416316121816635,
0.07086460292339325,
-0.3782626688480377,
-0.15632417798042297,
-0.32595589756965637,
0.454796701669693,
1.0550227165222168,
0.019686182960867882,
0.0011029228335246444,
-0.793725848197937,
0.29138290882110596,
0.27740800380706787,
1.0378227233886719,
-0.20985837280750275,
-0.15622134506702423,
-0.24328698217868805,
-0.20031799376010895,
-0.35232439637184143,
-1.0729303359985352,
0.4667183756828308,
0.16969768702983856,
0.5926511883735657,
0.5397570729255676,
0.35088402032852173,
0.2570256292819977,
-0.723905086517334,
0.26299259066581726,
0.40075409412384033,
-0.626878023147583,
0.8717643022537231,
-0.2543564438819885,
-0.06396567076444626,
0.45391809940338135,
0.5785924792289734,
-0.5897767543792725,
-0.24340975284576416,
-0.3451818823814392,
-0.765981137752533,
0.7031686902046204,
0.2368522733449936,
-0.10209706425666809,
-0.32624197006225586,
0.5165166854858398,
0.15702596306800842,
0.25130802392959595,
-0.5912857055664062,
-0.40839219093322754,
0.03836701437830925,
-0.3847588300704956,
0.11466647684574127,
-0.43040379881858826,
0.19427935779094696,
-0.15958382189273834,
0.742274284362793,
0.0815061628818512,
0.292733758687973,
0.04295264557003975,
0.10733742266893387,
-0.521721601486206,
0.5026476979255676,
0.2727951109409332,
0.3378799259662628,
-0.6150383353233337,
-0.18947571516036987,
0.06230777129530907,
-0.44852736592292786,
0.21085062623023987,
0.31303003430366516,
-0.15815557539463043,
-0.08449714630842209,
0.12097309529781342,
0.9079519510269165,
0.2613154947757721,
-1.0848753452301025,
0.8016741871833801,
-0.22881612181663513,
-0.22798670828342438,
-0.44344237446784973,
-0.0477893091738224,
-0.5038427114486694,
0.25431373715400696,
0.014203537255525589,
-0.022628195583820343,
0.3388471305370331,
-0.6074923872947693,
0.6731595396995544,
0.27661728858947754,
-0.7870301008224487,
-0.2198621779680252,
0.4442031979560852,
0.3227958679199219,
-0.28110069036483765,
0.12282508611679077,
-0.37053292989730835,
-0.17005589604377747,
0.3078921139240265,
0.20084531605243683,
0.7371658682823181,
-0.20177976787090302,
0.7878613471984863,
0.6286104917526245,
-0.534108579158783,
0.4611321985721588,
-0.015777800232172012,
0.33538615703582764,
-0.7283933758735657,
-0.40512824058532715,
-0.42855605483055115,
-0.4525716304779053,
0.15375743806362152,
-0.28840941190719604,
0.674373984336853,
-0.6079197525978088,
-0.09166719764471054,
0.40880468487739563,
0.4414774477481842,
-0.05515381321310997,
0.14829611778259277,
0.24819526076316833,
0.270469605922699,
-1.0674341917037964,
0.8969256281852722,
0.4928452670574188,
-0.880908727645874,
-0.37844234704971313,
0.2108563482761383,
0.050072457641363144,
-0.38367486000061035,
0.4665776491165161,
0.19449657201766968,
0.24974098801612854,
-0.43416815996170044,
-0.07370680570602417,
-0.697260320186615,
1.2311773300170898,
-0.028280826285481453,
-0.23050591349601746,
0.004702352918684483,
0.12030379474163055,
0.5390305519104004,
-0.28101983666419983,
0.5132096409797668,
0.4215835928916931,
0.1486475169658661,
0.5170960426330566,
-0.6071602702140808,
0.05591276288032532,
-0.4290176033973694,
-0.1482866108417511,
0.35797566175460815,
-0.03990890458226204,
0.9220849871635437,
-0.7225881218910217,
-0.33926835656166077,
0.19492556154727936,
0.22215832769870758,
0.10724476724863052,
0.6911078095436096,
0.07615983486175537,
0.6078527569770813,
0.5083500742912292,
0.2819836437702179,
1.1130319833755493,
-0.20196793973445892,
0.3585607409477234,
1.1887776851654053,
-0.6379122138023376,
1.0447521209716797,
0.3391178846359253,
-0.18320418894290924,
0.8320029377937317,
0.46861106157302856,
-0.22275161743164062,
0.7608301043510437,
0.2508953809738159,
-0.544387698173523,
0.2423533946275711,
-0.1625223308801651,
0.09150475263595581,
0.1793670654296875,
0.2934076189994812,
0.12734772264957428,
-0.43220242857933044,
0.33725327253341675,
-0.24957212805747986,
0.15475377440452576,
-0.039523765444755554,
1.2197487354278564,
-0.38931745290756226,
-0.3952833116054535,
0.45130008459091187,
0.03519813343882561,
0.8130466341972351,
-0.3484102487564087,
-0.2884203791618347,
-0.05659807473421097,
0.34229379892349243,
-0.1263372302055359,
-0.8369099497795105,
0.2184751331806183,
-0.3678049147129059,
-0.4856637418270111,
0.29183366894721985,
0.7683051824569702,
-0.6457127332687378,
-0.452085942029953,
0.5496246814727783,
0.40267351269721985,
-0.048834178596735,
0.05255403742194176,
-0.6897649765014648,
-0.07048191875219345,
-0.07423914968967438,
0.33203238248825073,
0.8686367869377136,
0.8114557266235352,
0.1256381869316101,
0.6825459599494934,
0.3780573308467865,
0.37748417258262634,
-0.3267956078052521,
-0.11106210947036743,
0.5838180780410767,
-0.698052704334259,
-0.19933225214481354,
-0.47705793380737305,
0.3997613489627838,
-0.30656230449676514,
-0.12201663106679916,
0.2595351040363312,
0.49963322281837463,
0.33312147855758667,
0.05286349356174469,
0.7814470529556274,
0.20481842756271362,
0.8996240496635437,
-0.32448193430900574,
0.8837642073631287,
-0.21550698578357697,
0.4172944724559784,
-0.29833221435546875,
-0.21791325509548187,
-0.280496209859848,
0.20690935850143433,
-0.36901575326919556,
-0.15054184198379517,
0.8374212980270386,
0.5080031156539917,
0.31563451886177063,
-0.1961774230003357,
0.37792614102363586,
0.4268152117729187,
0.10686177015304565,
0.8359866738319397,
0.3588697612285614,
-0.7485935091972351,
0.6876731514930725,
-0.4642173647880554,
-0.402694433927536,
0.04398764669895172,
-0.7687581777572632,
-0.8860812783241272,
-0.45293325185775757,
-0.4187420904636383,
-0.19903169572353363,
0.2008402794599533,
0.6878632307052612,
0.452770859003067,
-1.092775583267212,
-0.0021286215633153915,
-0.3422434628009796,
0.4069201350212097,
-0.00008763714868109673,
-0.25519195199012756,
0.21271765232086182,
-0.3885282278060913,
-0.6147075891494751,
0.19910790026187897,
0.4902803599834442,
0.39006224274635315,
0.05706718564033508,
-0.18718774616718292,
-0.4124298095703125,
0.35167163610458374,
0.5568149089813232,
0.31937041878700256,
-0.5110774636268616,
0.2577070891857147,
-0.17866873741149902,
-0.05674196034669876,
-0.17566001415252686,
0.9709863066673279,
-1.1487447023391724,
0.45481687784194946,
0.12844328582286835,
0.6057459712028503,
0.3466914892196655,
-0.35498490929603577,
0.7678154706954956,
-0.432181179523468,
-0.042365074157714844,
0.1484164148569107,
0.08239603787660599,
0.02701343595981598,
-0.5418424606323242,
0.16066576540470123,
0.0680437758564949,
-0.34805411100387573,
-0.4086163640022278,
0.1583181470632553,
-0.7750227451324463,
-0.9047805070877075,
0.8936986327171326,
-0.15254557132720947,
-0.4836737811565399,
-0.30484700202941895,
-0.20753668248653412,
0.07150490581989288,
-0.5175976753234863,
1.0294055938720703,
0.19986048340797424,
-0.10664864629507065,
-0.3106118440628052,
-0.742323100566864,
0.6830315589904785,
-0.02941312827169895,
-0.7801194787025452,
0.11726266145706177,
0.5778330564498901,
0.3198504149913788,
-0.030869556590914726,
0.8635454773902893,
-0.04162052646279335,
0.01907714083790779,
-0.021276285871863365,
0.033588655292987823,
-0.009487860836088657,
-0.22866494953632355,
-0.28650304675102234,
-0.02856077440083027,
-0.29512646794319153,
-0.2961965799331665
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08375v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08375v1
|
Translating between SQL Dialects for Cloud Migration
| 2024-03-13T09:38:39 | 2024-03-13T09:38:39 |
Ran Zmigrod, Salwa Alamir, Xiaomo Liu
|
cs.DB
|
cs.DB, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.SE
|
Migrations of systems from on-site premises to the cloud has been a
fundamental endeavor by many industrial institutions. A crucial component of
such cloud migrations is the transition of databases to be hosted online. In
this work, we consider the difficulties of this migration for SQL databases.
While SQL is one of the prominent methods for storing database procedures,
there are a plethora of different SQL dialects (e.g., MySQL, Postgres, etc.)
which can complicate migrations when the on-premise SQL dialect differs to the
dialect hosted on the cloud. Tools exist by common cloud provides such as AWS
and Azure to aid in translating between dialects in order to mitigate the
majority of the difficulties. However, these tools do not successfully
translate $100\%$ of the code. Consequently, software engineers must manually
convert the remainder of the untranslated database. For large organizations,
this task quickly becomes intractable and so more innovative solutions are
required. We consider this challenge a novel yet vital industrial research
problem for any large corporation that is considering cloud migrations.
Furthermore, we introduce potential avenues of research to tackle this
challenge that have yielded promising preliminary results.
|
[
-0.7084816694259644,
-0.6605381965637207,
0.7164124846458435,
0.4440094530582428,
-0.2841298580169678,
0.0806097611784935,
-0.19260627031326294,
-0.46394431591033936,
0.17412453889846802,
0.896070659160614,
-0.7481891512870789,
-0.1428837776184082,
-0.11045809090137482,
0.2488684505224228,
-0.6338681578636169,
0.773291826248169,
0.010467401705682278,
0.12887462973594666,
-0.3058122992515564,
-0.10255714505910873,
-0.32829007506370544,
-0.9976239800453186,
-0.26559221744537354,
0.19736720621585846,
-0.19926410913467407,
0.2848651111125946,
0.7717838287353516,
0.5067241787910461,
0.6764721274375916,
0.30874761939048767,
-0.012574260123074055,
0.032731011509895325,
-0.21506784856319427,
-0.06988959014415741,
-0.1815492808818817,
-0.4419839084148407,
-0.054782699793577194,
-0.8081415891647339,
0.23445548117160797,
0.9618119597434998,
-0.5441649556159973,
0.16046014428138733,
-0.036951515823602676,
1.0194604396820068,
-0.506625235080719,
0.038716282695531845,
-0.8706750273704529,
0.09237045049667358,
-0.2922964096069336,
0.16802333295345306,
-0.07391529530286789,
-0.2948943078517914,
-0.23694553971290588,
-0.42567163705825806,
0.27166739106178284,
0.003666820703074336,
0.6353833079338074,
0.024301547557115555,
-0.4794234335422516,
-0.08638393878936768,
-1.178955078125,
0.7420371174812317,
-0.6817712783813477,
0.48912501335144043,
0.0723445937037468,
0.5425639748573303,
-0.21714653074741364,
-0.7251958250999451,
-0.37273234128952026,
0.04338008910417557,
0.11832854151725769,
-0.1645214706659317,
-0.11385191977024078,
-0.23247450590133667,
0.13662011921405792,
0.44727060198783875,
-0.13474561274051666,
0.07502110302448273,
-0.4942818284034729,
-0.09709874540567398,
0.8135785460472107,
0.22602039575576782,
0.03261401504278183,
0.09723697602748871,
-0.20894339680671692,
0.10253018885850906,
-0.7376821637153625,
-0.02610834501683712,
0.07347029447555542,
0.5155666470527649,
0.15480443835258484,
0.24273034930229187,
-0.32165929675102234,
0.5177662372589111,
-0.07460858672857285,
0.36328938603401184,
0.14495867490768433,
-0.7121942043304443,
-0.14740140736103058,
0.1704736202955246,
0.28751683235168457,
0.1974942684173584,
-0.11731820553541183,
-0.41270843148231506,
-0.3638550639152527,
-0.17218010127544403,
0.5066215991973877,
-0.5961045026779175,
-0.10056333243846893,
0.49784329533576965,
-0.5173748135566711,
0.10702487081289291,
0.002653895178809762,
-0.8929847478866577,
-0.6882011890411377,
-0.28908446431159973,
0.2976033687591553,
-0.1759485900402069,
-0.4495801329612732,
0.19555890560150146,
0.14675754308700562,
0.5697155594825745,
0.6521990299224854,
-0.6516612768173218,
0.5022339224815369,
0.9454343914985657,
0.9697544574737549,
-0.1433171033859253,
0.15346132218837738,
-0.15546993911266327,
0.07274721562862396,
-0.5512681603431702,
0.527120053768158,
0.08872047811746597,
-0.5636767745018005,
0.37424248456954956,
0.21993625164031982,
-0.038305751979351044,
-0.6779135465621948,
0.4302070438861847,
-0.4567922055721283,
0.06823541224002838,
-0.5418562889099121,
-0.2487797737121582,
0.0114150270819664,
0.08225686103105545,
-0.552313506603241,
0.6454662084579468,
0.38576680421829224,
-0.042842742055654526,
0.03266432136297226,
-0.5372559428215027,
-0.5016506910324097,
0.2959015667438507,
-0.09715326130390167,
-0.2891818881034851,
0.320657879114151,
0.33597588539123535,
0.10751455277204514,
-0.839199960231781,
0.08267032355070114,
-0.3997126519680023,
-0.030587758868932724,
0.2638719379901886,
0.34975942969322205,
1.1084351539611816,
0.6061281561851501,
-0.3740237355232239,
-0.2893972396850586,
-0.5684922337532043,
0.22418630123138428,
-0.10210077464580536,
0.18248280882835388,
-0.32708439230918884,
0.2976773679256439,
0.1615733951330185,
0.22789983451366425,
0.22653290629386902,
-0.4734659790992737,
0.26326704025268555,
-0.25173234939575195,
0.7386865615844727,
0.2748943865299225,
0.11614098399877548,
0.5086923241615295,
-0.037844374775886536,
0.5500794649124146,
0.012903353199362755,
0.5135104060173035,
0.18721598386764526,
-0.20143036544322968,
-0.9512551426887512,
-0.10524670034646988,
0.13263177871704102,
0.7611121535301208,
-0.7966558337211609,
0.45330357551574707,
-0.584219753742218,
-0.5435655117034912,
-0.7637006640434265,
0.28558143973350525,
-0.046801261603832245,
0.04134005680680275,
0.6561641693115234,
-0.4026585817337036,
-0.4787334203720093,
-1.1093755960464478,
-0.2468196302652359,
-0.06668663024902344,
-0.09621211886405945,
0.15966306626796722,
0.31813931465148926,
-0.24137969315052032,
0.9547339081764221,
-0.5542330741882324,
-0.815829336643219,
-0.08682241290807724,
-0.11941982060670853,
0.25108832120895386,
0.405961275100708,
0.6782999038696289,
-0.8284537196159363,
-0.38914892077445984,
0.5031195878982544,
-0.606391966342926,
-0.18870937824249268,
-0.4627165198326111,
-0.06402260065078735,
0.36693355441093445,
0.7860060930252075,
-0.6383252143859863,
0.13696251809597015,
0.3280268609523773,
-0.008251143619418144,
0.561198353767395,
0.02618977054953575,
0.39121872186660767,
-1.1176401376724243,
0.14461028575897217,
-0.3942374885082245,
-0.03623754903674126,
-0.6730368137359619,
0.3777329623699188,
0.06269977986812592,
-0.42079851031303406,
-0.6101481914520264,
-0.123920738697052,
-0.9372743368148804,
-0.23345886170864105,
0.20947058498859406,
-0.19558386504650116,
-0.15071995556354523,
0.03636481985449791,
-0.1443505734205246,
0.7896546125411987,
0.4806719124317169,
-0.8798944354057312,
0.5527999401092529,
0.599860429763794,
-0.39688998460769653,
0.7649169564247131,
-0.0937068983912468,
0.29258787631988525,
0.20896859467029572,
0.07974141091108322,
-0.5852072238922119,
0.09117221087217331,
-0.2120906412601471,
-0.20848101377487183,
-0.10685614496469498,
-0.5983684062957764,
-0.339994877576828,
-0.3116167485713959,
0.022614343091845512,
-0.33031928539276123,
0.713588535785675,
-0.25726068019866943,
0.4847375452518463,
0.22548271715641022,
-0.29639625549316406,
-0.22199054062366486,
-1.2595603466033936,
0.6398210525512695,
-0.4209147095680237,
-0.7699396014213562,
0.48228147625923157,
0.3087843358516693,
-0.5874060988426208,
0.1724306046962738,
-0.21115444600582123,
-0.5792790055274963,
0.13651326298713684,
-0.02053087390959263,
0.04246790334582329,
-0.5185420513153076,
-0.22611454129219055,
0.06438211351633072,
0.2961539328098297,
0.3820904493331909,
-0.505338728427887,
0.18998095393180847,
-0.09853686392307281,
-0.27517426013946533,
-0.10985971242189407,
0.777350664138794,
0.9053986668586731,
-0.335997998714447,
1.3016011714935303,
0.33298438787460327,
-0.2600041925907135,
-0.46552425622940063,
-0.6240909099578857,
-0.10835505276918411,
-0.48988717794418335,
0.5115360617637634,
-0.41757145524024963,
-0.2967129647731781,
0.6481908559799194,
-0.526604413986206,
0.015336738899350166,
0.3498421609401703,
0.011936238966882229,
-0.2568329870700836,
0.7317286133766174,
0.7481431365013123,
0.29201382398605347,
0.6237638592720032,
-0.17635035514831543,
0.38926035165786743,
-0.44679754972457886,
-0.15403889119625092,
-0.9219914674758911,
0.03200162947177887,
-0.3301495313644409,
-0.33289387822151184,
0.6317967176437378,
0.18503880500793457,
-0.01196654699742794,
0.7161296010017395,
-0.2220000922679901,
0.23066391050815582,
-0.06799483299255371,
-0.061149995774030685,
0.2406196892261505,
0.4201948940753937,
0.3000108003616333,
-0.11459298431873322,
-0.5916817784309387,
-0.22828173637390137,
0.648359477519989,
-0.027346614748239517,
0.3555212616920471,
0.7223357558250427,
0.7917078137397766,
0.5132429599761963,
0.14765335619449615,
-0.37741249799728394,
0.672951877117157,
-0.4279495179653168,
-0.7320088148117065,
-0.27407142519950867,
-0.5534915924072266,
-0.9736663103103638,
0.22694097459316254,
-0.5388402342796326,
-0.4925019145011902,
0.4939054250717163,
0.06378936022520065,
-0.037363264709711075,
0.4168853759765625,
-0.7365913987159729,
0.9067373871803284,
-0.6744246482849121,
-0.42942821979522705,
-0.39843034744262695,
-0.7362064123153687,
-0.07368900626897812,
-0.49572521448135376,
0.7520864605903625,
0.2452099323272705,
-0.11294496804475784,
0.2892584502696991,
-0.866808295249939,
0.36625856161117554,
-0.23755262792110443,
0.06188281625509262,
0.19731874763965607,
0.3795774281024933,
0.341341108083725,
-0.4814442992210388,
-0.4415763318538666,
0.5613200068473816,
0.28614386916160583,
-0.4437391459941864,
-0.635593831539154,
0.5968416929244995,
-0.5632844567298889,
-0.5546920299530029,
-0.4334259629249573,
0.14807718992233276,
-0.49518924951553345,
0.18689222633838654,
0.2931903600692749,
0.032582659274339676,
-0.5194522142410278,
0.4380459189414978,
0.5227558612823486,
0.11532972753047943,
0.3199312686920166,
0.5778040289878845,
-0.1389094442129135,
-0.3916715681552887,
0.5966207981109619,
0.30578505992889404,
0.477974534034729,
0.34692758321762085,
-0.14653202891349792,
-0.6568366885185242,
-0.9125201106071472,
-0.7564464211463928,
0.14054462313652039,
-0.7070185542106628,
-0.03013807162642479,
-0.2550543546676636,
0.014539510011672974,
-0.5112048983573914,
-0.458800345659256,
-0.5406463146209717,
-0.7023857831954956,
-0.4300205409526825,
0.2028626650571823,
0.308122843503952,
0.5668569207191467,
0.321323424577713,
0.10693776607513428,
-1.1425175666809082,
-0.12352010607719421,
-0.018671896308660507,
0.25678735971450806,
-0.3152301609516144,
-0.5777034163475037,
-0.45539551973342896,
0.10462380200624466,
-0.028805429115891457,
-1.2339056730270386,
0.5438931584358215,
0.35358157753944397,
0.5276951789855957,
0.07737017422914505,
0.3897523581981659,
1.0185960531234741,
-0.38775214552879333,
0.7576801776885986,
-0.03669445589184761,
-1.1898152828216553,
0.42421233654022217,
-0.3273639678955078,
-0.3497481048107147,
1.0289568901062012,
0.5463696718215942,
-0.8303821086883545,
0.08491935580968857,
-0.5560210943222046,
-1.2978366613388062,
0.5618114471435547,
0.37795260548591614,
0.044005636125802994,
0.5199461579322815,
0.4514590799808502,
0.05712288245558739,
0.607296347618103,
-0.24298174679279327,
-0.19416791200637817,
-0.12670432031154633,
0.16570594906806946,
-0.35717469453811646,
0.4364660382270813,
-0.14705497026443481,
-0.14983904361724854,
0.49782612919807434,
0.15086296200752258,
0.008843879215419292,
0.15052859485149384,
-0.38600093126296997,
0.22269193828105927,
0.545495867729187,
0.07847600430250168,
0.5850805044174194,
-0.03218038007616997,
-0.016551541164517403,
0.2989984154701233,
-0.11748895049095154,
0.14662858843803406,
-0.03689347580075264,
-0.4742943048477173,
0.07716052979230881,
-0.039904240518808365,
0.6970378756523132,
-0.25288665294647217,
-0.4707798957824707,
0.4586787521839142,
0.27105513215065,
-0.054011035710573196,
-0.6489260792732239,
-0.19531705975532532,
0.26764172315597534,
-0.09029493480920792,
0.4747191369533539,
0.0026640307623893023,
0.23209983110427856,
-0.7192511558532715,
0.07041601836681366,
0.3684997856616974,
-0.22612737119197845,
-0.1146647036075592,
0.5242036581039429,
0.5734151601791382,
-0.5508962273597717,
0.8169252872467041,
-0.16000373661518097,
-0.48166418075561523,
0.6875207424163818,
0.6049157381057739,
1.1713584661483765,
-0.15382732450962067,
0.019787956029176712,
0.20443673431873322,
0.5267261862754822,
-0.4618363082408905,
0.1495271921157837,
0.05821119248867035,
-0.3044314384460449,
0.06077151000499725,
-0.40001562237739563,
-0.5517601370811462,
-0.181914284825325,
-0.7978508472442627,
0.3029668629169464,
-0.44550758600234985,
-0.2059212028980255,
-0.3542219400405884,
-0.44282737374305725,
-0.43966424465179443,
-0.07686787098646164,
0.3182685375213623,
0.7653998732566833,
-1.2801637649536133,
0.496380478143692,
0.9950759410858154,
-0.355629026889801,
-0.1462257206439972,
-0.16616494953632355,
-0.09824628382921219,
-0.3604527711868286,
0.014542029239237309,
-0.2827015817165375,
-0.22988557815551758,
0.16655756533145905,
-0.4139227569103241,
-0.7012197971343994,
0.7515329718589783,
0.6278073191642761,
-0.5146459937095642,
0.2730289697647095,
0.5221306085586548,
0.8774100542068481,
-0.1425987184047699,
-0.04871251434087753,
0.5377170443534851,
0.3503849506378174,
-0.3521455228328705,
-0.9813546538352966,
-0.044291991740465164,
-0.09610246121883392,
0.18106290698051453,
0.45219939947128296,
-0.5469570159912109,
0.9006668925285339,
0.05507659539580345,
-0.3173947334289551,
-0.29600685834884644,
0.6002906560897827,
-0.418170303106308,
0.16896162927150726,
0.5661236643791199,
0.020349951460957527,
0.5062022805213928,
-0.03289671987295151,
0.8845856189727783,
-0.26259931921958923,
0.4394538402557373,
0.6176995038986206,
-0.5850248336791992,
1.041007161140442,
0.7451470494270325,
-0.7074202299118042,
0.7031184434890747,
0.4468599259853363,
0.07533733546733856,
0.1780017763376236,
0.0920625850558281,
-0.3895995020866394,
-0.5719998478889465,
0.032705336809158325,
-0.6098410487174988,
0.1738695353269577,
0.45251941680908203,
0.05972447246313095,
0.026129262521862984,
-0.36201778054237366,
-0.027783451601862907,
0.32353726029396057,
-0.3835391104221344,
0.9018452763557434,
0.12480642646551132,
-0.6609647274017334,
0.7444044351577759,
0.15746530890464783,
0.2945941388607025,
-1.0660927295684814,
0.1771208643913269,
-0.4366438388824463,
0.27285751700401306,
-0.5887706875801086,
-0.5947368741035461,
0.7612130045890808,
-0.2803417146205902,
0.3081735372543335,
-0.5223084688186646,
0.22598852217197418,
-0.3621561527252197,
-0.26579466462135315,
0.3662247061729431,
0.6102145910263062,
0.2790660262107849,
-0.4764590859413147,
-0.6738847494125366,
-0.08471005409955978,
0.23447777330875397,
0.30167996883392334,
0.5367019176483154,
0.4615311026573181,
-0.4618569612503052,
0.6875084638595581,
0.7229300737380981,
0.26749247312545776,
0.30502572655677795,
-0.33038434386253357,
0.5441767573356628,
-0.6224706172943115,
-0.8397270441055298,
-0.5681256651878357,
0.24496270716190338,
-0.16354522109031677,
-0.05253756418824196,
0.7308984398841858,
0.6980565786361694,
0.5330852270126343,
-0.7256572246551514,
0.7478294372558594,
-0.40518784523010254,
0.1687580794095993,
-0.6469074487686157,
0.8092560768127441,
-0.6934813857078552,
0.27673715353012085,
-0.19788888096809387,
-1.0344102382659912,
-0.1047745943069458,
0.44362393021583557,
0.1070408895611763,
-0.4095999598503113,
1.0185081958770752,
0.8501845598220825,
0.11516765505075455,
-0.02098722569644451,
0.15218126773834229,
0.24026282131671906,
0.28712213039398193,
0.5238644480705261,
0.48775774240493774,
-0.3021683692932129,
0.8090344071388245,
-0.3675588071346283,
0.010694959200918674,
-0.28786420822143555,
-1.1820917129516602,
-0.03484827280044556,
-0.6504731774330139,
-0.5749524235725403,
-0.6131529808044434,
0.10954397916793823,
0.8764570951461792,
0.5476085543632507,
-1.278332233428955,
-0.7948358058929443,
-0.15231576561927795,
-0.21739165484905243,
-0.8354366421699524,
-0.07619023323059082,
0.08707387745380402,
-0.09697948396205902,
-0.2407919019460678,
0.3751924932003021,
-0.05106824263930321,
-0.038309164345264435,
-0.2727651000022888,
0.33044978976249695,
0.12288334220647812,
-0.0003063849580939859,
0.2835298180580139,
0.6676220893859863,
-0.38158881664276123,
0.01453245710581541,
-0.06491421163082123,
-0.2284328192472458,
0.22453083097934723,
0.9122377634048462,
-0.45074838399887085,
0.2495025098323822,
0.5508950352668762,
1.0451070070266724,
0.8724320530891418,
0.2752375602722168,
0.5117383599281311,
-0.7386104464530945,
0.11755207926034927,
0.2984461188316345,
0.19445675611495972,
0.4493306279182434,
-0.45909973978996277,
0.6321778893470764,
0.5390323996543884,
-0.4110366404056549,
-0.955237865447998,
0.3152385950088501,
-1.0906113386154175,
-0.2946520149707794,
1.177832841873169,
0.2359364628791809,
-0.10806777328252792,
-0.6958390474319458,
-0.1998169720172882,
-0.0354594886302948,
0.0605296790599823,
0.6420363783836365,
0.6334472894668579,
-0.3130088150501251,
0.019347570836544037,
-0.5258871912956238,
0.43964698910713196,
0.5008994340896606,
-1.0319969654083252,
0.3077486455440521,
0.6113229393959045,
0.20340320467948914,
0.2659763991832733,
0.5974725484848022,
-0.12402377277612686,
0.1227581799030304,
0.20347125828266144,
0.5479698181152344,
-0.006993964314460754,
-0.09489893168210983,
-0.7615299224853516,
0.24375507235527039,
0.1862003654241562,
-0.19705826044082642
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08370v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08370v1
|
SMART: Submodular Data Mixture Strategy for Instruction Tuning
| 2024-03-13T09:31:50 | 2024-03-13T09:31:50 |
H S V N S Kowndinya Renduchintala, Sumit Bhatia, Ganesh Ramakrishnan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Instruction Tuning involves finetuning a language model on a collection of
instruction-formatted datasets in order to enhance the generalizability of the
model to unseen tasks. Studies have shown the importance of balancing different
task proportions during finetuning, but finding the right balance remains
challenging. Unfortunately, there's currently no systematic method beyond
manual tuning or relying on practitioners' intuition. In this paper, we
introduce SMART (Submodular data Mixture strAtegy for instRuction Tuning) - a
novel data mixture strategy which makes use of a submodular function to assign
importance scores to tasks which are then used to determine the mixture
weights. Given a fine-tuning budget, SMART redistributes the budget among tasks
and selects non-redundant samples from each task. Experimental results
demonstrate that SMART significantly outperforms traditional methods such as
examples proportional mixing and equal mixing. Furthermore, SMART facilitates
the creation of data mixtures based on a few representative subsets of tasks
alone and through task pruning analysis, we reveal that in a limited budget
setting, allocating budget among a subset of representative tasks yields
superior performance compared to distributing the budget among all tasks. The
code for reproducing our results is open-sourced at
https://github.com/kowndinya-renduchintala/SMART.
|
[
-0.4597442150115967,
-0.8373636603355408,
-0.021273693069815636,
0.06446867436170578,
-0.46900591254234314,
0.0976405218243599,
-0.2143002599477768,
0.11665709316730499,
0.08703234791755676,
0.3359849452972412,
-0.8029032945632935,
-0.2915300726890564,
-0.4589766561985016,
-0.4263967275619507,
-0.37152227759361267,
1.0744708776474,
0.19875389337539673,
0.3057810962200165,
-0.5418417453765869,
0.07611584663391113,
-1.0066726207733154,
-0.09443605691194534,
-0.16370674967765808,
-0.4819009304046631,
0.37840166687965393,
0.8832300305366516,
0.4873148500919342,
1.0988332033157349,
0.48139309883117676,
0.34555724263191223,
0.326641321182251,
0.4225936233997345,
-0.47778046131134033,
0.06436740607023239,
-0.42350465059280396,
-0.699370801448822,
-0.5054132342338562,
-0.06904060393571854,
0.2314961552619934,
0.4706647992134094,
-0.283791720867157,
0.18890677392482758,
-0.020446067675948143,
0.7642288208007812,
-0.8155240416526794,
0.11350630223751068,
-0.5004958510398865,
0.0630197525024414,
-0.5415562391281128,
-0.6386309266090393,
-0.09001270681619644,
-0.2811358869075775,
-0.02681051380932331,
-0.469233900308609,
0.31674787402153015,
0.05531392619013786,
0.469950795173645,
0.5327516794204712,
-0.07745269685983658,
-0.13164092600345612,
-0.6363010406494141,
1.2367273569107056,
-0.6587421894073486,
0.3362349271774292,
0.3656463921070099,
0.19010138511657715,
-0.07788043469190598,
-0.3922474682331085,
-0.43651914596557617,
0.22150902450084686,
0.17086458206176758,
0.3261469602584839,
0.2864943742752075,
0.09927880018949509,
0.05446581542491913,
0.35798710584640503,
-0.2344697117805481,
0.09713320434093475,
-0.5403182506561279,
-0.10059373080730438,
0.5538823008537292,
0.17947398126125336,
0.22903896868228912,
0.14808595180511475,
-0.23066842555999756,
-0.04449506476521492,
-0.2916221022605896,
0.03427746519446373,
0.814800500869751,
0.26399707794189453,
0.006047606933861971,
0.6404334902763367,
-0.33409926295280457,
0.9174689054489136,
0.43733617663383484,
-0.5411772131919861,
0.15069906413555145,
-0.6082537174224854,
-0.17613035440444946,
0.28900185227394104,
0.2776404917240143,
0.46975263953208923,
0.6405889391899109,
0.005415860563516617,
-0.4043762981891632,
-0.0115866893902421,
0.44711238145828247,
-0.7250826358795166,
-0.7354440689086914,
0.19980227947235107,
-0.22097896039485931,
-0.1882961541414261,
0.0751461386680603,
-0.6295713186264038,
-0.2673790454864502,
-0.7198442220687866,
0.46295616030693054,
-0.5708404779434204,
0.009771927259862423,
0.008674770593643188,
-0.054601650685071945,
0.05279636010527611,
0.10369547456502914,
-1.4092859029769897,
0.3931046724319458,
1.0307828187942505,
0.5177313685417175,
-0.1603746861219406,
-0.12293168157339096,
-0.6249357461929321,
0.003278630319982767,
-0.3331413269042969,
0.9169380068778992,
-0.5914615392684937,
-0.40830153226852417,
-0.43965083360671997,
-0.11461465060710907,
-0.4935947358608246,
-0.9427282214164734,
0.2802136540412903,
-0.25133079290390015,
0.10832436382770538,
-0.10430119186639786,
-0.6573782563209534,
-0.05749615281820297,
-0.036361247301101685,
-0.5838257670402527,
0.9220373034477234,
0.3645865321159363,
-0.6266170144081116,
0.4206579029560089,
-0.37543559074401855,
-0.7955008149147034,
0.21885399520397186,
-0.258364200592041,
-0.5796319842338562,
0.24358664453029633,
0.16454260051250458,
0.37740451097488403,
-0.24115046858787537,
0.23166683316230774,
-0.028428368270397186,
-0.6550516486167908,
0.08395382016897202,
-0.29430362582206726,
0.5093494057655334,
0.1811991184949875,
-0.42358800768852234,
0.30337798595428467,
-0.4594980478286743,
0.4454423487186432,
-0.2130155861377716,
-0.265198677778244,
-0.5240706205368042,
0.19117707014083862,
-0.06312835216522217,
-0.14699889719486237,
0.5010830163955688,
-0.3613525331020355,
0.17103202641010284,
-0.28391507267951965,
0.3765450417995453,
0.8093140721321106,
-0.15277664363384247,
0.6371694207191467,
-0.689125120639801,
0.49514245986938477,
0.22775308787822723,
0.38649341464042664,
0.012244964018464088,
-0.3096054494380951,
-0.768153965473175,
-0.5421961545944214,
0.8429386615753174,
1.0640208721160889,
-0.6371681690216064,
0.7086859345436096,
-0.09322769194841385,
-0.3894384205341339,
-0.834806501865387,
0.4694140553474426,
0.48841702938079834,
0.600913405418396,
0.48051971197128296,
-0.3833140432834625,
-0.4803520441055298,
-1.0421682596206665,
-0.04859817400574684,
0.43422946333885193,
0.2548386752605438,
0.241732656955719,
0.17003518342971802,
-0.1876540333032608,
1.0168027877807617,
-0.35634979605674744,
-0.3152545988559723,
-0.45964011549949646,
0.03382786735892296,
0.031564731150865555,
0.990557849407196,
0.22626447677612305,
-0.8746774792671204,
-0.342427521944046,
0.01576882228255272,
-0.09979279339313507,
-0.1872459053993225,
-0.10708144307136536,
-0.15870781242847443,
0.13013017177581787,
0.2682684063911438,
-0.3112013041973114,
0.16196198761463165,
0.5055160522460938,
0.11034843325614929,
0.3152194321155548,
-0.2286200076341629,
0.10718045383691788,
-0.9853370189666748,
-0.21034377813339233,
-0.23374125361442566,
-0.10020114481449127,
-0.26680120825767517,
-0.0030986936762928963,
0.22889243066310883,
0.16989973187446594,
-0.40306100249290466,
0.10788198560476303,
-0.15589968860149384,
0.19618389010429382,
-0.30427250266075134,
-0.23101107776165009,
-0.0978187695145607,
0.4815976917743683,
-0.32001277804374695,
0.748516321182251,
0.5489234328269958,
-0.48451536893844604,
0.6170470118522644,
-0.30830463767051697,
-0.5643783211708069,
0.644500195980072,
-0.6837378740310669,
0.024684812873601913,
-0.010580357164144516,
-0.09644325822591782,
-0.7644054889678955,
-0.2301553338766098,
0.1777193248271942,
-0.00748996390029788,
0.5154368877410889,
-0.2051759660243988,
-0.37549588084220886,
0.016039565205574036,
-0.22010275721549988,
0.510770857334137,
0.5401132106781006,
-0.07525668293237686,
0.5718996524810791,
0.5274021029472351,
-0.302650511264801,
-0.2665848433971405,
-0.7842975854873657,
-0.5842958688735962,
-0.3035474121570587,
-0.49737077951431274,
0.5524837374687195,
-0.14184722304344177,
-0.22533676028251648,
0.1992388367652893,
-0.6339441537857056,
-0.0908311977982521,
0.2124525010585785,
0.04300136864185333,
0.2284555584192276,
-0.11444663256406784,
-0.11485374718904495,
0.4326585829257965,
-0.42345350980758667,
-0.36786988377571106,
-0.433836966753006,
0.5459559559822083,
0.21777349710464478,
-0.40575698018074036,
-0.3887009024620056,
0.5517812967300415,
0.5218513011932373,
-0.3313681185245514,
0.6272690892219543,
0.6194467544555664,
-0.24600155651569366,
-0.5660340189933777,
-0.45093393325805664,
-0.30374062061309814,
-0.5155730843544006,
0.5290547609329224,
-0.12074103206396103,
-0.39545565843582153,
0.278145968914032,
-0.2409793734550476,
0.398286372423172,
-0.026768643409013748,
0.504406750202179,
-0.1924527883529663,
1.172441840171814,
0.5701720714569092,
-0.1058376207947731,
0.8238622546195984,
-0.3606458008289337,
0.4350663423538208,
-0.5291131138801575,
-0.4114709496498108,
-0.2848665118217468,
-0.8747961521148682,
-0.5814089775085449,
-0.5209311246871948,
0.28928279876708984,
0.19054268300533295,
0.09753584861755371,
0.11660405248403549,
-0.5027797818183899,
0.7287085652351379,
1.0687713623046875,
0.15378712117671967,
0.04272536188364029,
-0.08089924603700638,
0.06692475825548172,
-0.10698556154966354,
-0.9412239789962769,
-0.16701237857341766,
0.8305309414863586,
-0.11257470399141312,
0.9780563712120056,
-0.26342034339904785,
0.8716294169425964,
0.2847431004047394,
-0.11761432141065598,
-0.9665896892547607,
0.6370730996131897,
-0.6498140692710876,
-0.2577340304851532,
-0.18874819576740265,
-0.5783469080924988,
-0.7153244614601135,
0.05202704668045044,
-0.13493257761001587,
-0.2191937267780304,
0.091738760471344,
0.425228476524353,
-0.6206591129302979,
-0.07748040556907654,
-1.2232834100723267,
0.9141964316368103,
-0.47456371784210205,
-0.15721780061721802,
-0.3047927916049957,
-0.3550895154476166,
0.11857724189758301,
-0.12356528639793396,
0.17083168029785156,
-0.032176658511161804,
-0.02697143889963627,
0.8561188578605652,
-0.42781904339790344,
0.5461537837982178,
-0.15601423382759094,
0.009566811844706535,
0.25187185406684875,
-0.07143353670835495,
0.41025808453559875,
-0.03518855944275856,
0.0957883968949318,
-0.24349205195903778,
0.09532041102647781,
-0.6769174933433533,
-0.7721631526947021,
0.9979936480522156,
-0.6257633566856384,
-0.4631000757217407,
-0.05600903928279877,
-1.1698282957077026,
-0.345412015914917,
0.2720208764076233,
0.29507961869239807,
0.7418327331542969,
0.47564971446990967,
0.533485472202301,
1.114833116531372,
0.13924258947372437,
0.21887575089931488,
0.29776012897491455,
0.5341764688491821,
-0.24064823985099792,
1.545876145362854,
0.5277810096740723,
0.24799427390098572,
0.5466411113739014,
0.398599773645401,
0.00885641761124134,
-0.5783056020736694,
-0.3909232020378113,
-0.2799646556377411,
-0.35346341133117676,
-0.16377514600753784,
-0.25857216119766235,
-0.1116073727607727,
-0.4006511867046356,
-0.17143729329109192,
-0.6339893937110901,
-0.42091381549835205,
-0.22692161798477173,
-0.032316904515028,
0.24849896132946014,
0.11521844565868378,
0.16613158583641052,
0.22343964874744415,
-0.5414873361587524,
0.33089637756347656,
0.6449390649795532,
0.14812937378883362,
-0.331275075674057,
-0.12027984112501144,
-0.5522222518920898,
0.2756258547306061,
-0.31388527154922485,
-0.565800666809082,
0.21213972568511963,
0.14803214371204376,
0.7248787879943848,
0.23374007642269135,
0.23192906379699707,
1.0107295513153076,
-0.3308573365211487,
0.3543902337551117,
-0.19112528860569,
-0.8640428185462952,
0.40759530663490295,
-0.30517223477363586,
0.5458983182907104,
0.7755423784255981,
0.0494619719684124,
0.0927174836397171,
-0.2979733943939209,
-0.5232601761817932,
-1.1897646188735962,
0.7465178966522217,
-0.18001511693000793,
-0.038475580513477325,
0.24989677965641022,
-0.12244300544261932,
0.04780569300055504,
0.44749248027801514,
-0.03792594000697136,
-0.21325348317623138,
-0.26981788873672485,
-0.846346914768219,
0.11096785217523575,
0.1938791126012802,
-0.36418044567108154,
-0.511023223400116,
0.6419569849967957,
-0.12745097279548645,
0.21570926904678345,
-0.21723830699920654,
0.07770567387342453,
-0.08653329312801361,
0.172261044383049,
0.7597509026527405,
0.6914520263671875,
-0.10809478908777237,
0.10633523762226105,
-0.011742464266717434,
-0.7131844162940979,
-0.2506576478481293,
0.2531758248806,
-0.3831678628921509,
-0.2879140377044678,
0.23912078142166138,
0.6264092326164246,
0.40588444471359253,
-0.9523935317993164,
0.1789141446352005,
0.20903126895427704,
-0.2453821748495102,
0.2766555845737457,
0.742277204990387,
0.059222184121608734,
0.30554309487342834,
0.3901039958000183,
0.3469364643096924,
-0.05848471075296402,
-0.5215317606925964,
0.18227458000183105,
0.2925950884819031,
-0.24391543865203857,
-0.04869319126009941,
0.16522404551506042,
0.19262050092220306,
-0.34426602721214294,
0.5711945295333862,
-0.1810344010591507,
-0.3398110270500183,
0.9480588436126709,
0.47418105602264404,
0.6810120940208435,
-0.09513568878173828,
0.17320358753204346,
-0.18386954069137573,
0.2848197817802429,
-0.022420497611165047,
0.6271136403083801,
-0.20198380947113037,
-0.3810950517654419,
-0.29787251353263855,
-0.3431837558746338,
-0.41489797830581665,
0.03049863502383232,
-0.6037620306015015,
0.05412083491683006,
-0.474147230386734,
0.09268566220998764,
-0.2401318997144699,
0.3097788095474243,
-0.427810937166214,
0.3940187394618988,
-0.1993444859981537,
0.6245652437210083,
-0.752236545085907,
0.9847142100334167,
0.6767801642417908,
0.2283855825662613,
-0.8626464605331421,
0.0009581281337887049,
-0.13480333983898163,
-0.5112191438674927,
0.2040175050497055,
-0.04402090981602669,
0.03213120996952057,
0.06971239298582077,
-0.19318316876888275,
-0.6632067561149597,
1.0074050426483154,
0.42463958263397217,
-0.769395112991333,
0.21880289912223816,
-0.1170935109257698,
0.25773879885673523,
-0.19237485527992249,
-0.14310741424560547,
0.5504752397537231,
0.49804699420928955,
0.008018036372959614,
-0.6204114556312561,
-0.1858554184436798,
-0.3002163767814636,
-0.23711320757865906,
0.5464416742324829,
-0.6393685340881348,
1.0789856910705566,
-0.08910557627677917,
-0.11595473438501358,
0.04331904649734497,
0.702194094657898,
0.2259765863418579,
0.5022710561752319,
0.5819542407989502,
0.5918002128601074,
0.7376896142959595,
-0.22838455438613892,
0.7797815799713135,
-0.47051337361335754,
0.10908173024654388,
1.0993595123291016,
0.018475394695997238,
0.3512568771839142,
0.5558633208274841,
0.15630899369716644,
0.37793153524398804,
0.5695343613624573,
-0.016981814056634903,
1.0726290941238403,
0.21181589365005493,
-0.14301697909832,
-0.31228724122047424,
-0.21929198503494263,
-0.2868012487888336,
0.260257363319397,
0.35216042399406433,
-0.07447317987680435,
-0.12104379385709763,
0.029042992740869522,
-0.21766681969165802,
0.03856363892555237,
-0.47274062037467957,
0.5650379657745361,
-0.20966985821723938,
-1.0160099267959595,
0.3863310217857361,
0.15979327261447906,
0.6836169958114624,
-0.7749989628791809,
-0.0012060516746714711,
-0.2864989638328552,
0.7086973786354065,
-0.39627695083618164,
-0.5060824155807495,
0.19006481766700745,
-0.28971192240715027,
-0.38132360577583313,
-0.4099712669849396,
0.4709716737270355,
-0.7370678186416626,
-0.4475802779197693,
-0.4555104970932007,
0.25126010179519653,
-0.3007759153842926,
0.38005658984184265,
-0.7314071655273438,
-0.06627996265888214,
-0.0041375961154699326,
-0.07340248674154282,
0.6743094325065613,
0.5082741975784302,
-0.3450588881969452,
0.4906761944293976,
0.5618755221366882,
0.05221369490027428,
0.22036463022232056,
0.05632541701197624,
0.8036021590232849,
-0.26896029710769653,
-0.6132911443710327,
-0.6819007992744446,
0.40076500177383423,
0.1874082237482071,
-0.5467987656593323,
0.8757938742637634,
0.5852674245834351,
1.0770833492279053,
-0.15963034331798553,
0.5562812685966492,
-0.14768274128437042,
0.2823152244091034,
-0.6395825743675232,
0.3006238043308258,
-0.41492003202438354,
0.05302983149886131,
-0.14841164648532867,
-0.7263510227203369,
0.13922889530658722,
0.6518325805664062,
-0.3182620704174042,
0.224813312292099,
0.3760930597782135,
0.9609760642051697,
-0.4035404920578003,
0.046312037855386734,
0.05256187543272972,
-0.27074557542800903,
-0.16045647859573364,
0.5143335461616516,
0.36318469047546387,
-0.11640666425228119,
0.21249724924564362,
-0.7378445863723755,
-0.311636745929718,
-0.2762755751609802,
-0.7065684795379639,
-0.6920452117919922,
-0.34437090158462524,
-0.5706831812858582,
0.15192657709121704,
0.1525295525789261,
0.9440810084342957,
1.177444338798523,
-0.9492882490158081,
-0.06777536123991013,
-0.3371472656726837,
0.31459346413612366,
-0.9238221049308777,
-0.31239083409309387,
0.10291970521211624,
-0.2543235421180725,
-0.9985907077789307,
0.5203206539154053,
0.10219872742891312,
-0.12832003831863403,
-0.23219291865825653,
0.09904104471206665,
-0.14628729224205017,
0.3670737147331238,
0.10697370022535324,
0.18219555914402008,
-0.21316219866275787,
0.079953134059906,
0.041525598615407944,
-0.09733222424983978,
-0.5677217245101929,
1.030556321144104,
-0.683017909526825,
0.500515878200531,
0.8926860094070435,
0.8023375868797302,
0.0813741683959961,
0.36492013931274414,
0.45670637488365173,
-0.9777958393096924,
0.1603652983903885,
0.3334527015686035,
0.1332259476184845,
0.19239208102226257,
-0.46295541524887085,
0.17261941730976105,
0.46044039726257324,
-0.5276081562042236,
-0.6763585805892944,
0.0698772594332695,
-1.1452597379684448,
-0.2866075932979584,
0.8151739835739136,
0.12246043235063553,
-0.23732106387615204,
-0.10817492008209229,
-0.36348867416381836,
0.1527438759803772,
-0.395600825548172,
0.9411916732788086,
0.4215925633907318,
-0.20165641605854034,
0.028905289247632027,
-0.6347613334655762,
0.19910703599452972,
0.8967458605766296,
-0.6738384962081909,
-0.3180476129055023,
0.2852739989757538,
0.1884864866733551,
0.052799973636865616,
0.28231340646743774,
0.1861368864774704,
0.44943585991859436,
-0.14853258430957794,
-0.4669785797595978,
-0.5774754285812378,
-0.6263038516044617,
0.2871047258377075,
0.2241661697626114,
-0.564142644405365,
-0.7685133218765259
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08358v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08358v1
|
Log Summarisation for Defect Evolution Analysis
| 2024-03-13T09:18:46 | 2024-03-13T09:18:46 |
Rares Dolga, Ran Zmigrod, Rui Silva, Salwa Alamir, Sameena Shah
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.CL
|
Log analysis and monitoring are essential aspects in software maintenance and
identifying defects. In particular, the temporal nature and vast size of log
data leads to an interesting and important research question: How can logs be
summarised and monitored over time? While this has been a fundamental topic of
research in the software engineering community, work has typically focused on
heuristic-, syntax-, or static-based methods. In this work, we suggest an
online semantic-based clustering approach to error logs that dynamically
updates the log clusters to enable monitoring code error life-cycles. We also
introduce a novel metric to evaluate the performance of temporal log clusters.
We test our system and evaluation metric with an industrial dataset and find
that our solution outperforms similar systems. We hope that our work encourages
further temporal exploration in defect datasets.
|
[
-0.03638620674610138,
-0.46337375044822693,
0.5270354151725769,
0.42415758967399597,
-0.3607683479785919,
0.47843289375305176,
0.26355060935020447,
-0.6120198369026184,
0.382073312997818,
0.024522220715880394,
-0.8513305187225342,
-0.7369533181190491,
-0.10820446908473969,
-0.015347716398537159,
-0.5319846272468567,
1.236663579940796,
-0.08928482979536057,
-0.28037959337234497,
-0.3093257546424866,
-0.3567034900188446,
-0.5969658493995667,
-0.36275342106819153,
-0.6086606383323669,
0.13890516757965088,
0.4239514470100403,
0.1094268187880516,
0.248183473944664,
0.5010216236114502,
0.5082126259803772,
0.26526495814323425,
-0.42210015654563904,
0.18348117172718048,
-0.3135972321033478,
0.20683057606220245,
0.32706311345100403,
-0.8132742643356323,
-0.7247418165206909,
-0.5633753538131714,
0.5024440884590149,
0.732166051864624,
-0.24280846118927002,
0.2608257532119751,
-0.050222739577293396,
0.6077704429626465,
-0.3976778984069824,
0.537833034992218,
-0.5784757137298584,
0.5295010209083557,
-0.046318259090185165,
-0.37132397294044495,
-0.15318883955478668,
-0.49569636583328247,
-0.10061641037464142,
-0.5667971968650818,
0.4773976504802704,
-0.017770512029528618,
0.5832474231719971,
0.5155898332595825,
-0.05440133810043335,
-0.20857428014278412,
-0.6939365863800049,
0.8726320862770081,
-1.1511532068252563,
0.09611063450574875,
-0.07290507107973099,
0.47375360131263733,
-0.24458719789981842,
-0.6997376680374146,
-0.04582838714122772,
-0.023163096979260445,
-0.41087886691093445,
0.2273954153060913,
0.17629671096801758,
-0.3100896179676056,
-0.04476436227560043,
0.5949922800064087,
-0.7281240224838257,
0.29645249247550964,
-0.29869410395622253,
-0.13854560256004333,
0.7339813709259033,
0.7455742359161377,
0.35907602310180664,
0.035854436457157135,
-0.05511768162250519,
0.10323328524827957,
-0.28116318583488464,
-0.16976851224899292,
0.20886148512363434,
-0.06958566606044769,
-0.050844572484493256,
0.15245263278484344,
-0.3767821490764618,
0.8169179558753967,
-0.3408386707305908,
-0.3137589991092682,
0.2666527330875397,
-0.38683417439460754,
-0.026041757315397263,
0.22928908467292786,
0.3149069547653198,
0.6393124461174011,
-0.3003355860710144,
-0.38076716661453247,
-0.15532855689525604,
0.3672209680080414,
0.27397966384887695,
-0.5145062208175659,
-0.4666282534599304,
0.571186900138855,
-0.5647890567779541,
-0.6545233726501465,
0.11054547876119614,
-1.0484473705291748,
-0.5399456024169922,
0.24476490914821625,
0.07321470230817795,
-0.09356153756380081,
-0.49050384759902954,
0.12450892478227615,
-0.5519315600395203,
-0.03312503919005394,
0.3014106750488281,
-0.48418259620666504,
0.17456366121768951,
0.8670718669891357,
0.8929431438446045,
-0.3180679678916931,
-0.18312005698680878,
-0.6444665193557739,
0.3277178108692169,
-0.5324372053146362,
0.8300608992576599,
-0.39477431774139404,
-0.6022080183029175,
-0.1186811551451683,
0.08959248661994934,
0.044153980910778046,
-0.8274903893470764,
0.17532305419445038,
-0.46057209372520447,
0.2625942826271057,
0.4289756119251251,
-0.3975546360015869,
-0.22145217657089233,
0.20613670349121094,
-0.5238268375396729,
1.3026628494262695,
0.47245222330093384,
-0.8362212181091309,
0.5888060927391052,
-0.8196834325790405,
-0.23352499306201935,
-0.07482220977544785,
-0.0875149592757225,
-0.8858392834663391,
0.34356218576431274,
0.023282648995518684,
0.34341323375701904,
0.1547170877456665,
0.0924186035990715,
-0.35082417726516724,
-0.28469592332839966,
0.2763473093509674,
0.10554470866918564,
0.649247944355011,
0.21868564188480377,
-0.6086835861206055,
0.26203179359436035,
-1.1434389352798462,
0.04510262981057167,
0.024512657895684242,
-0.15529337525367737,
-0.4247165322303772,
0.5994813442230225,
-0.35589107871055603,
0.02913457714021206,
0.34484514594078064,
-0.626092791557312,
0.18804121017456055,
-0.3589043915271759,
0.29645809531211853,
0.48861172795295715,
0.5785849690437317,
-0.09556975215673447,
-0.3027384579181671,
0.36309337615966797,
0.3629951477050781,
0.7130542993545532,
-0.43504539132118225,
-0.505278468132019,
-0.7840726375579834,
-0.0001274673850275576,
0.03581266477704048,
0.6937640905380249,
-0.07390778511762619,
0.5202529430389404,
-0.37150838971138,
-0.6115033626556396,
-0.08125422894954681,
0.14306892454624176,
0.1873229444026947,
0.1495223492383957,
0.3636316955089569,
-0.5792348384857178,
-0.37696367502212524,
-0.5715214014053345,
-0.23577238619327545,
-0.5027759075164795,
-0.26945680379867554,
0.14839708805084229,
-0.04082249104976654,
-0.49260959029197693,
1.1635736227035522,
-1.059194564819336,
-0.31274881958961487,
0.006186703685671091,
0.44276919960975647,
0.31289321184158325,
0.30041640996932983,
0.6311998963356018,
-0.6581839919090271,
-0.34507983922958374,
0.3403344452381134,
-0.8418183326721191,
-0.22560329735279083,
-0.3904661536216736,
0.20207355916500092,
0.5114279985427856,
0.8012185096740723,
-0.26293057203292847,
0.4877997040748596,
0.4114665389060974,
-0.7285704016685486,
0.5417414903640747,
-0.1455245018005371,
0.19116681814193726,
-0.7536845803260803,
0.03240858390927315,
-0.37213635444641113,
-0.3509063422679901,
-0.37634381651878357,
-0.019819481298327446,
-0.19085805118083954,
-0.05589855834841728,
-0.3861472010612488,
0.010379117913544178,
-0.3574017584323883,
-0.5341494083404541,
-0.015714649111032486,
0.13748414814472198,
-0.1631377637386322,
0.4261295795440674,
-0.4592384696006775,
0.27041009068489075,
0.3659741282463074,
-0.7758220434188843,
0.6676093935966492,
0.0036929945927113295,
-0.2911436855792999,
0.4623216688632965,
-0.5320022702217102,
-0.15980929136276245,
-0.12433101236820221,
0.15748433768749237,
-0.9654203057289124,
-0.23526988923549652,
0.021290205419063568,
-0.6735324263572693,
0.21403561532497406,
-0.1407664269208908,
-0.3830888271331787,
-0.2796226739883423,
-0.5080583691596985,
0.14736531674861908,
0.510997474193573,
-0.38780251145362854,
0.7094041705131531,
0.19102327525615692,
-0.3039132058620453,
-0.16434797644615173,
-0.5326747894287109,
-0.03153286501765251,
-0.7157106399536133,
-0.7186980247497559,
0.20356641709804535,
-0.01633634977042675,
-0.5187353491783142,
0.5057918429374695,
-0.625187873840332,
-0.2877228856086731,
0.4750179350376129,
0.2043263018131256,
0.21616524457931519,
-0.3329769968986511,
0.12493260949850082,
-0.04675448313355446,
-0.4341985285282135,
0.06030463054776192,
-0.3286420404911041,
0.3623978793621063,
-0.1092008650302887,
-0.344088077545166,
-0.29921790957450867,
0.2715149521827698,
0.8241859078407288,
-0.08638294786214828,
0.6641989946365356,
0.4733135402202606,
-0.3720051646232605,
-0.23065027594566345,
-0.5023896098136902,
0.0308547206223011,
-0.4210936725139618,
0.39425021409988403,
0.24832883477210999,
-0.7033959627151489,
0.8656094074249268,
-0.3232596814632416,
0.575546145439148,
0.8658068180084229,
0.032401178032159805,
-0.31161442399024963,
1.0242468118667603,
0.7893506288528442,
-0.10834155976772308,
0.3071317672729492,
-0.10022266209125519,
0.210338294506073,
-0.4737117290496826,
-0.30453726649284363,
-0.5399174690246582,
-0.12397260218858719,
-0.4781717360019684,
-0.21515265107154846,
0.7762156128883362,
0.3045329451560974,
0.14562314748764038,
0.11944545805454254,
-0.35510730743408203,
0.3345242440700531,
-0.17094187438488007,
-0.10397977381944656,
0.5134676098823547,
-0.07646642625331879,
0.222738116979599,
-0.003537645097821951,
-0.6840033531188965,
-0.19357319176197052,
0.4049515128135681,
0.3061375916004181,
0.5901894569396973,
0.2256898283958435,
0.6337667107582092,
0.5566763281822205,
0.10634827613830566,
-0.39490410685539246,
0.2937029004096985,
0.053730450570583344,
-0.30825096368789673,
-0.6533284783363342,
-0.464835524559021,
-0.9218128323554993,
-0.04688042029738426,
0.20416127145290375,
-0.7827942967414856,
0.04596014320850372,
0.5294151306152344,
-0.32676392793655396,
0.4036712944507599,
-0.7531026601791382,
1.0737844705581665,
-0.20458368957042694,
0.21621952950954437,
-0.7208272814750671,
-0.6248236894607544,
0.12017226219177246,
-0.29282715916633606,
0.4326893091201782,
0.0422934889793396,
-0.14737188816070557,
0.7510022521018982,
-0.7970868945121765,
1.1500709056854248,
-0.3196035921573639,
-0.042699914425611496,
0.3627362549304962,
0.12820133566856384,
0.6729798913002014,
0.008846275508403778,
0.21441996097564697,
-0.006756434217095375,
0.35433030128479004,
-0.5514227747917175,
-0.8643667101860046,
0.6240130662918091,
-0.3359430432319641,
-0.2971554398536682,
-0.5764490365982056,
-0.07851553708314896,
-0.22521057724952698,
-0.044505342841148376,
-0.08271000534296036,
0.6997858285903931,
-0.0406743548810482,
0.06460943818092346,
0.5393742918968201,
-0.5193317532539368,
0.8930965065956116,
0.6261547207832336,
-0.4015306532382965,
0.015133236534893513,
1.1853370666503906,
0.20466481149196625,
0.19191236793994904,
0.27589771151542664,
0.19985659420490265,
0.05072934553027153,
-0.45904579758644104,
-0.38106223940849304,
0.12741689383983612,
-0.7411815524101257,
-0.21492193639278412,
-0.7190974354743958,
-0.02009551227092743,
0.16552244126796722,
-0.32235187292099,
-0.30426082015037537,
-0.7483381032943726,
-0.11046470701694489,
-0.1766732931137085,
0.7387140393257141,
1.040351390838623,
0.11496184021234512,
0.30684521794319153,
-1.2540372610092163,
-0.1003592237830162,
0.3230538070201874,
0.7057044506072998,
0.15198037028312683,
0.000154650115291588,
-0.43808773159980774,
-0.3381987512111664,
-0.1571781188249588,
-0.7926169633865356,
0.32782790064811707,
0.16074611246585846,
0.7113571763038635,
0.09868118911981583,
0.12518972158432007,
0.673303484916687,
-0.32807713747024536,
1.2921528816223145,
0.08593453466892242,
-0.7605664730072021,
0.7648717761039734,
-0.3667922616004944,
0.36819106340408325,
0.13729016482830048,
0.11693135648965836,
-0.8805336952209473,
-0.7555000185966492,
-0.9148496389389038,
-1.1802153587341309,
0.5179848670959473,
-0.039313118904829025,
-0.3319088816642761,
0.30502787232398987,
0.21745294332504272,
0.11064248532056808,
-0.00836394913494587,
-0.259852796792984,
-0.1958114057779312,
-0.08166936039924622,
-0.09373845160007477,
-0.015118786133825779,
-0.21810117363929749,
-0.0034130162093788385,
-0.02888401225209236,
0.6693035960197449,
-0.1799793243408203,
0.2897687554359436,
0.06721799075603485,
-0.3659992814064026,
-0.035866715013980865,
0.1633748710155487,
0.7165888547897339,
1.2312235832214355,
-0.2915774881839752,
-0.07456860691308975,
0.7745197415351868,
-0.42888298630714417,
-0.12081683427095413,
-0.3875269591808319,
0.14588965475559235,
0.4854303300380707,
0.5162099599838257,
0.535323977470398,
0.26898738741874695,
-0.7415744662284851,
0.2487829178571701,
0.0820343866944313,
0.2784314453601837,
-0.6497939229011536,
0.1518937647342682,
0.061444640159606934,
0.2265859842300415,
0.5753868818283081,
-0.21707212924957275,
0.27890151739120483,
-0.34343281388282776,
0.14170217514038086,
-0.13568273186683655,
-0.4798290729522705,
-0.25654467940330505,
0.36668071150779724,
0.1565409153699875,
-0.2503908574581146,
0.47512608766555786,
-0.19802655279636383,
-0.41135722398757935,
1.0024034976959229,
0.28205808997154236,
0.9059104323387146,
-0.22461675107479095,
0.16185098886489868,
0.1931801736354828,
0.18691027164459229,
0.2485705316066742,
0.07717166095972061,
0.16400152444839478,
0.060284942388534546,
-0.6470256447792053,
-0.587515652179718,
-0.2989402711391449,
-0.16322171688079834,
-0.5193727612495422,
0.3215057849884033,
-0.20842866599559784,
0.18167246878147125,
-0.17397423088550568,
-0.3440459966659546,
-0.07117639482021332,
0.309505432844162,
-0.4588746130466461,
0.7461329102516174,
-0.9601372480392456,
0.13704797625541687,
0.4698225259780884,
-0.09101104736328125,
-0.22903290390968323,
-0.005186004564166069,
0.17565764486789703,
-0.37380287051200867,
0.44015073776245117,
0.003992214798927307,
0.0712265819311142,
-0.06518799066543579,
-0.13078856468200684,
-0.6956566572189331,
1.1832479238510132,
-0.2833017110824585,
-0.359234482049942,
-0.03158963844180107,
-0.15204022824764252,
0.7445389032363892,
-0.13776901364326477,
0.014095251448452473,
0.4080686569213867,
0.3194733262062073,
-0.34358659386634827,
-0.8992415070533752,
-0.30263781547546387,
-0.24876996874809265,
0.1360417753458023,
0.7395351529121399,
-0.7087098360061646,
0.30379024147987366,
0.0562618188560009,
-0.42295634746551514,
-0.37573719024658203,
0.5736322402954102,
-0.2487417310476303,
0.519393265247345,
0.7239962816238403,
0.6412084102630615,
0.7247373461723328,
-0.20339414477348328,
1.0135256052017212,
-0.37774020433425903,
0.43629345297813416,
0.8270789384841919,
0.11353526264429092,
0.6434046030044556,
0.08635609596967697,
-0.46295878291130066,
0.8575339317321777,
0.8179283738136292,
-0.00921081192791462,
0.37568342685699463,
0.2406606525182724,
-0.42825886607170105,
0.019213590770959854,
0.006805832497775555,
-0.5341997146606445,
-0.09717241674661636,
0.4766499400138855,
0.0701368972659111,
-0.38343361020088196,
-0.3173537850379944,
-0.013343382626771927,
-0.2684789001941681,
-0.37234947085380554,
1.0939915180206299,
-0.05794646590948105,
-0.46946999430656433,
0.25846096873283386,
-0.07301498204469681,
0.4241120517253876,
-0.6233745813369751,
-0.032925985753536224,
-0.4910636246204376,
0.30030661821365356,
-0.7017690539360046,
-0.4350960850715637,
1.0649361610412598,
0.01697547174990177,
-0.058615487068891525,
0.16890554130077362,
0.4130975008010864,
0.07099649310112,
-0.3995501399040222,
0.22143055498600006,
0.171677827835083,
0.22575753927230835,
0.3987668454647064,
-0.11481713503599167,
0.1646769940853119,
-0.013622180558741093,
0.05439344793558121,
0.2364174723625183,
0.37726134061813354,
-0.46221065521240234,
0.6824930310249329,
0.2881438136100769,
-0.14380516111850739,
0.4612146019935608,
-0.15678048133850098,
0.9323875308036804,
-0.8319770097732544,
-0.7764857411384583,
-0.8724343776702881,
1.084026575088501,
-0.40626460313796997,
-0.2475391924381256,
0.6771615743637085,
0.8041682839393616,
0.7641451358795166,
-0.19905954599380493,
0.7952929735183716,
-0.03827366232872009,
0.686294436454773,
-0.5652743577957153,
0.4567280411720276,
-0.489894837141037,
0.35002270340919495,
-0.33152949810028076,
-1.045117735862732,
-0.45181775093078613,
0.33934473991394043,
0.27172398567199707,
-0.38789257407188416,
0.919628381729126,
0.7773734927177429,
0.07947683334350586,
0.1073564887046814,
0.04722532629966736,
0.4707994759082794,
0.42222192883491516,
0.3305802643299103,
0.8990399837493896,
-0.18686118721961975,
0.6277391314506531,
-0.03243254870176315,
-0.4372618496417999,
-0.4239150881767273,
-1.2047241926193237,
-0.5699869394302368,
-0.5557540655136108,
-0.7001085877418518,
-0.3925912380218506,
0.08768302947282791,
0.536500096321106,
0.3017180562019348,
-1.0097529888153076,
-0.24484021961688995,
-0.16955336928367615,
-0.037907809019088745,
-0.5846940279006958,
-0.22622334957122803,
0.3000040650367737,
-0.7939285039901733,
-0.20153594017028809,
0.36142683029174805,
0.5944213271141052,
-0.04177207872271538,
-0.43406012654304504,
0.04071073979139328,
0.2955572009086609,
-0.35932406783103943,
0.7123386859893799,
0.4038292169570923,
-0.37259501218795776,
-0.33159831166267395,
0.05007876828312874,
0.27371907234191895,
-0.03540579974651337,
0.9034079909324646,
-0.46713346242904663,
0.3999667167663574,
0.6484222412109375,
0.6498052477836609,
0.8688884377479553,
-0.29843249917030334,
0.5117123126983643,
-0.760108232498169,
0.025278765708208084,
0.06373433023691177,
0.19060304760932922,
0.1839941442012787,
-0.534098744392395,
0.8237343430519104,
0.6137726902961731,
-0.4847370982170105,
-0.9710842370986938,
0.11360688507556915,
-0.8716024160385132,
-0.38193246722221375,
0.8394108414649963,
-0.21072494983673096,
-0.0987994372844696,
-0.46037256717681885,
-0.04969223588705063,
0.1747903972864151,
0.026372143998742104,
1.1173434257507324,
0.5742313265800476,
-0.5497536063194275,
0.19419147074222565,
-0.3618828058242798,
0.4704282879829407,
0.24738341569900513,
-1.3230458498001099,
0.007398799527436495,
0.6652265191078186,
0.3933132588863373,
0.5221685767173767,
0.3060288727283478,
-0.4267895817756653,
0.3417053520679474,
0.14179183542728424,
-0.3071594834327698,
0.2151450663805008,
-0.2981950342655182,
-0.5446407794952393,
0.06798325479030609,
0.2472836971282959,
-0.18151453137397766
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08345v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08345v1
|
From human experts to machines: An LLM supported approach to ontology and knowledge graph construction
| 2024-03-13T08:50:15 | 2024-03-13T08:50:15 |
Vamsi Krishna Kommineni, Birgitta König-Ries, Sheeba Samuel
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The conventional process of building Ontologies and Knowledge Graphs (KGs)
heavily relies on human domain experts to define entities and relationship
types, establish hierarchies, maintain relevance to the domain, fill the ABox
(or populate with instances), and ensure data quality (including amongst others
accuracy and completeness). On the other hand, Large Language Models (LLMs)
have recently gained popularity for their ability to understand and generate
human-like natural language, offering promising ways to automate aspects of
this process. This work explores the (semi-)automatic construction of KGs
facilitated by open-source LLMs. Our pipeline involves formulating competency
questions (CQs), developing an ontology (TBox) based on these CQs, constructing
KGs using the developed ontology, and evaluating the resultant KG with minimal
to no involvement of human experts. We showcase the feasibility of our
semi-automated pipeline by creating a KG on deep learning methodologies by
exploiting scholarly publications. To evaluate the answers generated via
Retrieval-Augmented-Generation (RAG) as well as the KG concepts automatically
extracted using LLMs, we design a judge LLM, which rates the generated content
based on ground truth. Our findings suggest that employing LLMs could
potentially reduce the human effort involved in the construction of KGs,
although a human-in-the-loop approach is recommended to evaluate automatically
generated KGs.
|
[
-0.5632548928260803,
-0.49090859293937683,
0.7750365138053894,
-0.5580683350563049,
0.21773551404476166,
0.33557140827178955,
-0.08150374889373779,
-0.42171111702919006,
0.018197812139987946,
0.9815283417701721,
-0.34708717465400696,
-0.7091093063354492,
-0.44607818126678467,
0.24213644862174988,
-0.12937819957733154,
0.6497301459312439,
-0.12176605314016342,
-0.15958072245121002,
-0.41203543543815613,
0.08310985565185547,
-0.12805674970149994,
-0.3524608314037323,
-0.3668276369571686,
-0.5783674716949463,
0.41775771975517273,
0.5375878214836121,
0.8929526805877686,
0.8020735383033752,
0.16638757288455963,
0.36478617787361145,
0.10621526092290878,
0.587071418762207,
-0.4383201599121094,
0.050359103828668594,
-0.39065659046173096,
-0.4144887924194336,
-0.6415053606033325,
0.18511396646499634,
0.40124791860580444,
0.8845916390419006,
0.0190721545368433,
0.23235249519348145,
0.07838309556245804,
0.8057788014411926,
-0.33493056893348694,
0.34895795583724976,
-0.752415657043457,
0.2936343848705292,
-0.15976127982139587,
-0.20610611140727997,
-0.21574944257736206,
-0.17207393050193787,
0.06157336384057999,
-0.8246015310287476,
0.03995111957192421,
0.3723495900630951,
0.6329978108406067,
0.3351762890815735,
-0.45088231563568115,
-0.6319946050643921,
-0.41818028688430786,
0.718180775642395,
-0.7312719225883484,
0.5120776891708374,
0.3894539177417755,
0.4228232800960541,
-0.41353580355644226,
-0.8626763820648193,
-0.6355827450752258,
-0.2952820360660553,
-0.20960772037506104,
0.13503043353557587,
0.12598714232444763,
0.10427642613649368,
0.0585174560546875,
0.0697413980960846,
-0.44949600100517273,
0.34586456418037415,
-0.21461273729801178,
-0.35801178216934204,
0.7526256442070007,
0.43705087900161743,
0.21837139129638672,
-0.5056408643722534,
-0.12219509482383728,
0.28855815529823303,
-0.8492133617401123,
-0.4321552515029907,
0.44480323791503906,
0.40985023975372314,
0.3955947756767273,
0.9337949752807617,
-0.3605329394340515,
0.7687495946884155,
-0.17366032302379608,
-0.3945428431034088,
-0.10947366058826447,
-0.17987191677093506,
-0.17494039237499237,
-0.005638140253722668,
0.9222841262817383,
0.12310840934515,
0.5279278755187988,
-0.6833568811416626,
-0.1917267143726349,
-0.04309304431080818,
0.4859274625778198,
-0.3385261297225952,
-0.3984009325504303,
0.20121799409389496,
-0.23316453397274017,
-0.46803855895996094,
-0.12995940446853638,
-0.3446097671985626,
-0.5081782341003418,
-0.5948432683944702,
0.32335084676742554,
-0.36767834424972534,
-0.008335394784808159,
-0.12941904366016388,
0.07595063000917435,
-0.09785874933004379,
0.41034919023513794,
-0.4496535360813141,
0.1454322785139084,
0.4102679193019867,
0.377186119556427,
0.06514737755060196,
-0.13462130725383759,
-0.19071926176548004,
0.6540489792823792,
-0.4532485604286194,
0.7492513060569763,
-0.2115418165922165,
-0.3582523763179779,
-0.06763453036546707,
-0.23671801388263702,
0.3963906466960907,
-0.521568238735199,
0.4827229380607605,
-1.079891562461853,
0.22010266780853271,
-0.16564905643463135,
-0.9173469543457031,
-0.060320887714624405,
0.6704752445220947,
-0.4160110056400299,
0.922890841960907,
0.3300442397594452,
-0.8423211574554443,
0.3723108470439911,
-0.778052806854248,
-0.32228201627731323,
0.3252558708190918,
-0.35878705978393555,
-0.11687947809696198,
-0.4444390833377838,
0.1023082286119461,
0.7159212827682495,
-0.5754491090774536,
0.08760719746351242,
-0.3020956516265869,
0.2658146321773529,
0.1926015317440033,
0.2013425976037979,
0.7405509948730469,
0.3534775972366333,
-0.08265592902898788,
-0.17638269066810608,
-0.7187721133232117,
0.36321261525154114,
-0.0493803545832634,
-0.502918541431427,
-0.0676683560013771,
0.16378043591976166,
-0.5424435138702393,
0.23840779066085815,
0.18670986592769623,
-0.37208107113838196,
0.3744514286518097,
-0.37925058603286743,
0.4349632263183594,
0.7659008502960205,
-0.19062498211860657,
0.38803061842918396,
-0.12115132063627243,
0.4044381082057953,
-0.28603410720825195,
-0.08770565688610077,
0.16011330485343933,
-0.6087964773178101,
-0.6866119503974915,
-0.11644169688224792,
0.4787828326225281,
0.6341171264648438,
-1.0136055946350098,
0.6618280410766602,
-0.33809569478034973,
-0.6185399293899536,
-0.5287346243858337,
0.6837901473045349,
0.4332299828529358,
0.9531662464141846,
0.26207974553108215,
-0.363772451877594,
-0.5350887775421143,
-0.5745165944099426,
0.020688679069280624,
-0.4865599274635315,
-0.26482072472572327,
0.5417014360427856,
0.3302042782306671,
-0.3369210362434387,
1.5225485563278198,
-0.7981377243995667,
-0.5824339389801025,
-0.04596720635890961,
0.013754760846495628,
-0.06269235163927078,
0.10870061814785004,
0.1678657978773117,
-0.694123387336731,
-0.5351734161376953,
0.3211502134799957,
-1.156112551689148,
-0.26844513416290283,
0.4839271903038025,
-0.19911979138851166,
0.33957067131996155,
0.5127518773078918,
-0.588984489440918,
0.2242162674665451,
0.09835870563983917,
-0.26288658380508423,
0.5909805297851562,
-0.16306988894939423,
-0.027309319004416466,
-1.1599743366241455,
0.26991936564445496,
-0.1908130794763565,
-0.43225595355033875,
-0.4538732171058655,
0.0746782049536705,
-0.18985626101493835,
0.014835892245173454,
-0.3311448097229004,
0.6620746850967407,
-0.32470017671585083,
-0.27122974395751953,
-0.16235433518886566,
0.606787383556366,
-0.02166132628917694,
0.384257048368454,
-0.07021120935678482,
0.37066978216171265,
0.21955488622188568,
-0.7081226706504822,
0.5355724096298218,
0.5648587942123413,
-0.3256757855415344,
0.424183189868927,
-0.5375818610191345,
0.2704866826534271,
0.14462201297283173,
0.06022285670042038,
-0.8168495297431946,
-0.4635581970214844,
0.45273295044898987,
-0.6988298892974854,
0.23553143441677094,
-0.410992294549942,
-0.9854683876037598,
-0.5768676400184631,
0.11923984438180923,
-0.17214344441890717,
0.7229630351066589,
-0.30415111780166626,
0.5720126032829285,
0.8507100939750671,
-0.09962061047554016,
-0.4362303912639618,
-0.6723513007164001,
0.40370112657546997,
0.219285249710083,
-1.1342439651489258,
0.31762948632240295,
0.1402936428785324,
-0.4103539288043976,
0.3457299768924713,
0.16131646931171417,
-0.07438603788614273,
0.1337861567735672,
0.11210664361715317,
0.10682231932878494,
-0.025472542271018028,
0.3413221538066864,
-0.0773598849773407,
-0.20207294821739197,
0.1346358209848404,
-0.7876043915748596,
0.24155578017234802,
0.2243165224790573,
-0.406444251537323,
-0.22952944040298462,
-0.09930646419525146,
0.39074835181236267,
-0.09574788808822632,
0.5151038765907288,
0.3572523891925812,
-0.17314468324184418,
-0.3727918863296509,
-0.5594974756240845,
-0.14017073810100555,
-0.4755379259586334,
0.1360214352607727,
-0.22765062749385834,
-1.0423091650009155,
0.3803553879261017,
-0.2658144533634186,
0.13784748315811157,
0.5229663252830505,
0.7322143316268921,
-0.2623121738433838,
0.9580315947532654,
0.4619240164756775,
0.15202440321445465,
-0.19679148495197296,
-0.3051542341709137,
0.10820678621530533,
-0.5841846466064453,
-0.34692642092704773,
-0.4886978566646576,
-0.07532345503568649,
-0.5091472268104553,
-0.5692721009254456,
0.6032329201698303,
0.047101181000471115,
-0.2572917938232422,
0.11900560557842255,
-0.4850943982601166,
0.1709998995065689,
0.4400826096534729,
0.0355134978890419,
0.561853289604187,
-0.036247652024030685,
-0.332394540309906,
0.18838100135326385,
-0.9998815059661865,
-0.9224103093147278,
1.2634340524673462,
0.1829841285943985,
0.6619331240653992,
-0.05452803522348404,
0.5911059379577637,
0.6395948529243469,
0.5325090289115906,
-0.7930798530578613,
0.8227634429931641,
-0.10235656052827835,
-0.708771288394928,
-0.5256507992744446,
-0.5951801538467407,
-0.8559163808822632,
-0.12347466498613358,
-0.43345874547958374,
-0.3301958739757538,
-0.42373815178871155,
0.261212557554245,
-0.18256525695323944,
0.4971214532852173,
-0.4242137670516968,
0.5974128246307373,
-0.11401275545358658,
-0.39714911580085754,
-0.03087705373764038,
-0.9355325698852539,
0.25192949175834656,
-0.30882272124290466,
0.32472148537635803,
0.003175565740093589,
-0.2149631828069687,
0.769798219203949,
-0.7728851437568665,
1.0859639644622803,
-0.22963808476924896,
-0.3199577033519745,
0.7646487355232239,
0.007861217483878136,
0.6096764206886292,
0.01661839708685875,
-0.3712676465511322,
0.0002809502766467631,
-0.4672016501426697,
-0.3853026330471039,
-0.6107462048530579,
0.39666664600372314,
-1.0674937963485718,
-0.5874195694923401,
0.17564134299755096,
-0.5967985987663269,
-0.38139858841896057,
0.4824831187725067,
-0.10708426684141159,
0.19029085338115692,
-0.11075333505868912,
-0.2365991324186325,
0.6859143376350403,
-0.08711040019989014,
-0.09513511508703232,
0.6768342852592468,
-0.27394068241119385,
-0.5304099917411804,
0.7804738283157349,
0.5514513850212097,
0.17611443996429443,
0.3601812422275543,
0.26467975974082947,
-0.28343433141708374,
-0.589074432849884,
-0.6502806544303894,
0.03844912722706795,
-0.8026813268661499,
-0.3023134768009186,
-0.8180492520332336,
-0.2860291302204132,
-0.7090688347816467,
-0.19107428193092346,
-0.21191637217998505,
-0.4425949454307556,
-0.21070516109466553,
0.018846776336431503,
0.45574668049812317,
1.1440098285675049,
0.03801451623439789,
0.0327146090567112,
-1.1809608936309814,
0.1987277865409851,
0.6626627445220947,
0.2503349184989929,
0.11345266550779343,
-0.42209598422050476,
-0.4913673996925354,
0.012677661143243313,
-0.36782127618789673,
-0.5189240574836731,
0.3039223849773407,
-0.14514672756195068,
0.7227034568786621,
0.35972508788108826,
0.32981324195861816,
0.2856062948703766,
-0.5657184720039368,
0.6553806662559509,
0.04892180114984512,
-0.7796130776405334,
0.3757030665874481,
-0.47805288434028625,
-0.20304977893829346,
0.41141533851623535,
0.4972357749938965,
-0.16177797317504883,
-0.46209755539894104,
-0.5237691402435303,
-0.6830373406410217,
0.6471393704414368,
0.2732729911804199,
-0.11280155181884766,
0.1034390851855278,
0.6078237891197205,
0.22924518585205078,
0.21393544971942902,
-0.3731997311115265,
-0.026658546179533005,
-0.03762451559305191,
-0.22482779622077942,
0.2008829265832901,
-0.04017762839794159,
-0.33346807956695557,
0.10019077360630035,
0.681610107421875,
-0.37537363171577454,
-0.16718542575836182,
0.16205564141273499,
-0.2457749992609024,
-0.07749806344509125,
0.18715085089206696,
-0.16186900436878204,
0.6256452202796936,
-0.05842151120305061,
0.20161192119121552,
0.272482693195343,
-0.05079466477036476,
0.1398126780986786,
-0.02951706200838089,
-0.28555166721343994,
-0.4837818443775177,
0.3821273446083069,
0.44179069995880127,
-0.14837586879730225,
-0.7737715244293213,
0.17482289671897888,
0.414550244808197,
-0.4159533381462097,
-0.35565656423568726,
0.17254342138767242,
0.37579047679901123,
0.3269284665584564,
0.2797701060771942,
-0.22260744869709015,
-0.23953154683113098,
-0.40332016348838806,
0.23016919195652008,
0.3757479190826416,
-0.3923698365688324,
-0.21689888834953308,
0.6237549781799316,
0.4011734426021576,
-0.2696654498577118,
0.7841935157775879,
-0.5091017484664917,
-0.6727150082588196,
0.35536113381385803,
0.10364725440740585,
0.4441353976726532,
0.004517429508268833,
0.11925357580184937,
0.051858652383089066,
0.2083691656589508,
0.06343653798103333,
0.15274018049240112,
-0.039516475051641464,
-0.9873496294021606,
-0.6968034505844116,
-0.6135240197181702,
-0.6056540608406067,
-0.4603268504142761,
-0.20655295252799988,
0.35573679208755493,
-0.21699240803718567,
-0.14504893124103546,
-0.019369186833500862,
0.31978315114974976,
-0.5368045568466187,
0.4650830626487732,
0.18675898015499115,
0.9004517793655396,
-0.6941742897033691,
0.8114439845085144,
1.087085247039795,
-0.42106130719184875,
-0.8835761547088623,
-0.21522949635982513,
-0.1532474011182785,
-0.9226940274238586,
0.9839360117912292,
-0.1834314614534378,
-0.12323033064603806,
0.26020556688308716,
-0.5397588610649109,
-0.6338441967964172,
1.4435096979141235,
0.3258991539478302,
-0.1576339602470398,
-0.23337826132774353,
0.46632906794548035,
0.6506802439689636,
-0.240396648645401,
0.028008535504341125,
0.20442834496498108,
0.7042869329452515,
0.2616266906261444,
-0.7747050523757935,
0.12864179909229279,
0.04154356196522713,
-0.33682602643966675,
0.2438715100288391,
-0.5725332498550415,
0.6575361490249634,
-0.29163187742233276,
-0.0974147841334343,
0.014899896457791328,
0.6851232647895813,
0.29521358013153076,
0.2337951362133026,
0.5592990517616272,
0.917220413684845,
0.9149155020713806,
0.3464391827583313,
0.9684445261955261,
-0.6291696429252625,
0.16918164491653442,
0.7295963168144226,
-0.4656983017921448,
0.44051387906074524,
0.2801525592803955,
-0.5315736532211304,
0.44818562269210815,
0.4636669456958771,
-0.07406925410032272,
0.19414810836315155,
0.3823661804199219,
-0.05761951580643654,
-0.5521796941757202,
-0.2614024877548218,
-0.15517288446426392,
0.46106070280075073,
0.4096062481403351,
-0.36939501762390137,
-0.23150958120822906,
-0.23709630966186523,
0.07374922931194305,
0.1372203677892685,
-0.4352762997150421,
0.8216792345046997,
0.17667199671268463,
-0.701140284538269,
0.24361401796340942,
0.01220747735351324,
0.2987689673900604,
-0.5941525101661682,
0.14404313266277313,
0.14419537782669067,
-0.06343898177146912,
-0.41842761635780334,
-1.1755383014678955,
0.3373035490512848,
0.12055543065071106,
-0.28786027431488037,
-0.30323463678359985,
1.0046143531799316,
-0.2300274670124054,
-0.4909376800060272,
0.32730305194854736,
0.8911951780319214,
0.22013330459594727,
0.1518692523241043,
-0.47522157430648804,
-0.532517671585083,
-0.14798302948474884,
-0.42689117789268494,
0.4067577123641968,
0.7113020420074463,
-0.07602845132350922,
0.8241303563117981,
0.6405451893806458,
-0.07904628664255142,
-0.11125238984823227,
-0.10661149770021439,
1.14143967628479,
-0.43076878786087036,
-0.26677802205085754,
-0.6530666351318359,
0.49836084246635437,
-0.04776967689394951,
0.060176003724336624,
0.8167767524719238,
0.466193288564682,
0.7990737557411194,
0.19224311411380768,
1.209842562675476,
-0.390766978263855,
0.6864092350006104,
-0.6267105937004089,
1.1082050800323486,
-0.7033495306968689,
0.31416434049606323,
-0.27737221121788025,
-0.5035814642906189,
-0.36569851636886597,
0.07552926242351532,
-0.23704871535301208,
-0.04288313165307045,
0.17648066580295563,
0.9041407108306885,
0.08256960660219193,
-0.25130900740623474,
0.33977848291397095,
0.18413083255290985,
0.3020915687084198,
0.26438620686531067,
0.7443424463272095,
0.021614333614706993,
0.9439584016799927,
0.026091663166880608,
-0.22348324954509735,
-0.05796400085091591,
-0.9961341023445129,
-0.9751806855201721,
-0.28831595182418823,
-0.19495537877082825,
-0.47086644172668457,
-0.07733502238988876,
0.890687108039856,
0.6301229000091553,
-0.5519816875457764,
-0.25580254197120667,
-0.13832375407218933,
0.3170570135116577,
0.37495091557502747,
-0.17642159759998322,
0.48895958065986633,
-0.5099807381629944,
-0.45935484766960144,
0.2982882559299469,
0.2193586677312851,
-0.23441627621650696,
-0.6485230326652527,
-0.4274405241012573,
-0.01347940694540739,
-0.07953744381666183,
0.7201860547065735,
0.15284651517868042,
-0.5621013641357422,
-0.21391475200653076,
0.15880908071994781,
-0.19642703235149384,
0.006280773319303989,
0.6223942041397095,
-1.0707842111587524,
0.5680071711540222,
0.6260386109352112,
0.7415204048156738,
0.2015826404094696,
-0.18967314064502716,
0.6172142624855042,
-0.6582711338996887,
-0.34253570437431335,
0.26421239972114563,
0.16062016785144806,
0.4172935485839844,
-0.148932546377182,
0.8782395124435425,
0.49582624435424805,
-0.7159898281097412,
-0.7392692565917969,
0.30352669954299927,
-0.6202210783958435,
-0.2530645430088043,
1.048689842224121,
-0.20951232314109802,
-0.16717006266117096,
-0.5648464560508728,
-0.14640918374061584,
0.49478426575660706,
-0.019646864384412766,
0.9278818964958191,
0.49498066306114197,
-0.33791786432266235,
0.36846306920051575,
-0.47808727622032166,
0.22318632900714874,
0.04723318666219711,
-0.8655478954315186,
-0.05741089582443237,
0.31839659810066223,
0.3374044597148895,
0.40130555629730225,
0.7067655324935913,
-0.08301390707492828,
-0.18736588954925537,
-0.11335622519254684,
0.4586646854877472,
-0.4324398934841156,
-0.01870439201593399,
0.5940586924552917,
0.46616852283477783,
0.27714651823043823,
0.39061275124549866
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08332v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08332v1
|
Autoregressive Score Generation for Multi-trait Essay Scoring
| 2024-03-13T08:34:53 | 2024-03-13T08:34:53 |
Heejin Do, Yunsu Kim, Gary Geunbae Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recently, encoder-only pre-trained models such as BERT have been successfully
applied in automated essay scoring (AES) to predict a single overall score.
However, studies have yet to explore these models in multi-trait AES, possibly
due to the inefficiency of replicating BERT-based models for each trait.
Breaking away from the existing sole use of encoder, we propose an
autoregressive prediction of multi-trait scores (ArTS), incorporating a
decoding process by leveraging the pre-trained T5. Unlike prior regression or
classification methods, we redefine AES as a score-generation task, allowing a
single model to predict multiple scores. During decoding, the subsequent trait
prediction can benefit by conditioning on the preceding trait scores.
Experimental results proved the efficacy of ArTS, showing over 5% average
improvements in both prompts and traits.
|
[
-0.39854001998901367,
-0.6238120794296265,
0.48326575756073,
0.38732895255088806,
0.04507190361618996,
0.10854949802160263,
0.014652479439973831,
-0.659827470779419,
0.5785341858863831,
0.37432488799095154,
-0.6557364463806152,
-0.5052924156188965,
-0.7557393908500671,
0.26878198981285095,
-0.36280399560928345,
1.0244975090026855,
-0.0701775848865509,
0.05150723457336426,
-0.2558550536632538,
-0.117591992020607,
-0.26593294739723206,
-0.5616195201873779,
-0.7840659022331238,
-0.10709976404905319,
0.6984186172485352,
0.43611910939216614,
0.1405695080757141,
0.36064034700393677,
0.629035472869873,
0.290218710899353,
0.6569506525993347,
0.2091751992702484,
-0.2259373515844345,
0.5439651012420654,
0.456913024187088,
-0.34432151913642883,
-0.5599055290222168,
0.35194140672683716,
0.5732771754264832,
0.3735707104206085,
0.14190703630447388,
0.2944056987762451,
0.22719506919384003,
0.48395201563835144,
-0.6802650094032288,
0.2063155323266983,
-0.3392605185508728,
0.2523057758808136,
0.0804021954536438,
-0.1333141028881073,
-0.6749217510223389,
-0.9124869704246521,
-0.10563655197620392,
-0.43699848651885986,
0.34495413303375244,
-0.026171347126364708,
0.5658129453659058,
0.2143174111843109,
-0.4683611989021301,
0.05388176441192627,
-0.5621755123138428,
1.060347557067871,
-0.4332725703716278,
-0.015746964141726494,
0.5216636061668396,
0.2641356885433197,
0.16261225938796997,
-0.5225598812103271,
-0.34896963834762573,
-0.06264420598745346,
-0.11062874644994736,
0.33814895153045654,
0.16944393515586853,
0.30461353063583374,
0.15762224793434143,
0.47773095965385437,
-0.4120156466960907,
-0.10198438912630081,
-0.37336575984954834,
-0.2984393835067749,
0.9336074590682983,
0.2656240165233612,
0.00176214927341789,
-0.06412287801504135,
-0.12859821319580078,
-0.27571606636047363,
-0.3424530029296875,
0.5006082057952881,
0.4194525182247162,
0.09727616608142853,
0.2529298663139343,
0.28305327892303467,
0.22260241210460663,
0.503482460975647,
0.4579760432243347,
-0.03725225478410721,
0.3280569911003113,
0.032968323677778244,
0.05542467162013054,
-0.15050365030765533,
0.9697934985160828,
0.33988332748413086,
0.11587011069059372,
0.019349202513694763,
-0.26750409603118896,
0.27382925152778625,
0.3463270664215088,
-0.7272276282310486,
-0.5105705261230469,
0.04536108300089836,
-0.7876788377761841,
-0.5590198636054993,
-0.06106583774089813,
-1.0324122905731201,
-0.1053876131772995,
-0.16135647892951965,
0.589431881904602,
-0.6766898036003113,
-0.031007077544927597,
-0.10641364008188248,
-0.2319767326116562,
0.40470781922340393,
0.2989726960659027,
-0.7933168411254883,
0.14412911236286163,
-0.03327413648366928,
0.6114874482154846,
-0.18105362355709076,
-0.6633215546607971,
-0.5634135603904724,
-0.13371294736862183,
-0.5001108646392822,
0.985339879989624,
-0.8448766469955444,
-0.5276901721954346,
-0.030650783330202103,
-0.07715977728366852,
-0.33957386016845703,
0.14989489316940308,
0.7930980920791626,
-0.20746664702892303,
0.2514345645904541,
-0.47490447759628296,
-0.7750402688980103,
-0.2832971513271332,
0.2228570133447647,
-1.0330181121826172,
1.0074424743652344,
0.030306288972496986,
-0.42068180441856384,
0.5875452160835266,
-0.8512728810310364,
-0.6206170320510864,
-0.3129688501358032,
-0.07313846796751022,
-0.7786160111427307,
0.37804412841796875,
0.5802129507064819,
0.5528226494789124,
0.08690938353538513,
-0.05559587851166725,
-0.748944103717804,
-0.3246892988681793,
0.16551727056503296,
-0.5258926153182983,
0.2839677035808563,
0.0746210366487503,
-0.27207091450691223,
-0.18798038363456726,
-0.7145302295684814,
0.47570088505744934,
-0.20438578724861145,
-0.4880295693874359,
0.06016062572598457,
-0.021133236587047577,
-0.042537104338407516,
0.31173017621040344,
0.16928397119045258,
-0.8260868191719055,
0.21637281775474548,
0.032873570919036865,
0.04423639923334122,
0.9038534164428711,
0.022183043882250786,
0.2284451574087143,
-0.8307738900184631,
0.7200644016265869,
-0.23244613409042358,
0.24389530718326569,
-0.4638393521308899,
-0.5036782026290894,
-0.7887852787971497,
-0.4936719834804535,
0.0301683209836483,
0.26116910576820374,
-0.45938640832901,
0.6029572486877441,
0.1694914698600769,
-0.5778120756149292,
-1.1113250255584717,
-0.16972368955612183,
0.44743049144744873,
0.1812766045331955,
0.7607700824737549,
-0.20904625952243805,
-0.4670335352420807,
-0.6836816072463989,
-0.5680374503135681,
-0.13725022971630096,
0.29761993885040283,
0.04244910925626755,
0.4040968418121338,
0.14165671169757843,
0.737409234046936,
-0.7436557412147522,
-0.5031378269195557,
-0.3217148184776306,
0.8964452743530273,
-0.14474095404148102,
0.7319240570068359,
0.9024745225906372,
-0.4129622280597687,
-0.732576310634613,
-0.6414299011230469,
-0.544588565826416,
-0.13174127042293549,
-0.006732277572154999,
-0.07964041084051132,
0.32326412200927734,
0.3516753613948822,
-0.29537224769592285,
0.7021112442016602,
0.672220766544342,
-0.38610538840293884,
0.8257297277450562,
-0.08861199021339417,
0.8438817262649536,
-0.9892815351486206,
-0.10648135840892792,
0.05496259406208992,
-0.09377285838127136,
-0.36813971400260925,
-0.14570140838623047,
-0.16646510362625122,
-0.06462537497282028,
0.2898761034011841,
0.3147483170032501,
-0.3481641411781311,
0.11290282756090164,
-0.23499983549118042,
-0.9027072787284851,
0.6172780990600586,
0.6064904928207397,
0.1812281608581543,
0.5821078419685364,
0.6029753088951111,
-0.39482465386390686,
0.23731277883052826,
0.16162683069705963,
-0.32470184564590454,
0.45501887798309326,
-0.6036398410797119,
0.3264204263687134,
-0.4447263479232788,
0.24003440141677856,
-1.2176390886306763,
-0.11819160729646683,
-0.4092065393924713,
-0.6873869895935059,
0.5317938327789307,
0.1213303878903389,
-0.009455213323235512,
-0.5130612254142761,
-0.5990270972251892,
0.3462180495262146,
0.5231653451919556,
-0.4849519729614258,
1.1098978519439697,
0.10508402436971664,
-0.27874425053596497,
-0.47183898091316223,
-0.8108645081520081,
-0.26307550072669983,
-0.22015096247196198,
-0.48713818192481995,
0.266222208738327,
-0.49501657485961914,
0.2168315201997757,
0.123603455722332,
0.26275545358657837,
-0.12127574533224106,
-0.012632996775209904,
0.13583894073963165,
0.20703953504562378,
-0.19511258602142334,
0.34431537985801697,
0.20777878165245056,
0.09800976514816284,
0.2370695322751999,
-0.33012959361076355,
0.043329283595085144,
0.0023829296696931124,
-0.5734038949012756,
-0.30612972378730774,
1.213417649269104,
0.9575667977333069,
-0.5331190228462219,
0.8345893025398254,
0.6907534003257751,
-0.20250225067138672,
-0.41088372468948364,
-0.9187799692153931,
-0.3287639021873474,
-0.4326882064342499,
0.18247783184051514,
-0.6003131866455078,
-0.5494786500930786,
0.5023263692855835,
0.11245058476924896,
0.32250726222991943,
0.528692901134491,
0.12795346975326538,
-0.5452410578727722,
1.387809157371521,
0.7967246770858765,
-0.2062404900789261,
0.5382919907569885,
-0.3294483423233032,
0.1367405205965042,
-0.5118085145950317,
-0.17745527625083923,
-0.6214932203292847,
-0.5264396071434021,
-0.43925052881240845,
-0.04747362807393074,
0.7379528284072876,
-0.2438044548034668,
-0.20794375240802765,
-0.16430994868278503,
-0.5335933566093445,
0.5098861455917358,
0.7458601593971252,
0.2270859330892563,
-0.02503301575779915,
-0.06244763359427452,
-0.35203930735588074,
-0.19256003201007843,
-0.4089510440826416,
-0.1784970462322235,
1.5861573219299316,
0.09466593712568283,
0.8610501289367676,
0.05047974735498428,
1.0500847101211548,
0.6077221035957336,
0.532571017742157,
-0.601701557636261,
0.1704358011484146,
-0.6381531357765198,
-0.4401969611644745,
-0.47325706481933594,
-0.09385061264038086,
-0.5561179518699646,
0.007303175982087851,
-0.45908448100090027,
-0.49879342317581177,
0.29432886838912964,
0.38461747765541077,
-0.6712918281555176,
0.15432310104370117,
-0.6965673565864563,
0.9012067914009094,
-0.37609976530075073,
-0.4613976776599884,
-0.1725238412618637,
-0.3979541063308716,
0.35227683186531067,
-0.2271534949541092,
0.007765947375446558,
0.06370246410369873,
0.6013030409812927,
0.8233781456947327,
-0.19467850029468536,
0.9572358131408691,
-0.2840753495693207,
0.22812104225158691,
0.32678505778312683,
-0.040965549647808075,
0.5631418824195862,
-0.27179139852523804,
-0.6363377571105957,
-0.23827147483825684,
-0.07569797337055206,
-0.3269803524017334,
-0.5797715187072754,
0.6604089140892029,
-1.03510320186615,
-0.3419916033744812,
-0.42321690917015076,
-0.10512953251600266,
-0.29299628734588623,
-0.1681669056415558,
0.5957857966423035,
0.5926756262779236,
-0.44614192843437195,
-0.05834149196743965,
0.793582558631897,
-0.053762175142765045,
0.8047690391540527,
0.5371296405792236,
0.19250184297561646,
-0.6100655794143677,
0.7787677645683289,
0.005409544333815575,
0.08357846736907959,
0.3896132707595825,
0.18728651106357574,
-0.47555190324783325,
-0.1908571422100067,
-0.11637280136346817,
-0.13152764737606049,
-0.8184251189231873,
-0.3561023771762848,
-0.7423670291900635,
-0.17084573209285736,
-0.7293586730957031,
-0.5405037999153137,
-0.2987959682941437,
-0.23653940856456757,
-0.36912423372268677,
-0.35792839527130127,
0.4150729179382324,
0.9788310527801514,
-0.35241949558258057,
0.009675121866166592,
-0.9337887763977051,
0.2672460377216339,
0.40377187728881836,
0.5160419940948486,
-0.04983050748705864,
-0.573380708694458,
-0.24223603308200836,
-0.2188168615102768,
-0.5265017151832581,
-0.8832691311836243,
0.5369595289230347,
0.7190210819244385,
0.6335136890411377,
0.6225932836532593,
0.22144965827465057,
0.6745028495788574,
-0.4099230170249939,
0.6937316060066223,
0.30166611075401306,
-0.9078695774078369,
0.6123937964439392,
0.042585499584674835,
0.4247945547103882,
0.8199785351753235,
0.5372194647789001,
-0.17785586416721344,
-0.7391647696495056,
-0.4126476049423218,
-0.5133672952651978,
0.6401892304420471,
-0.2753556966781616,
0.10731867700815201,
-0.027134953066706657,
0.14326639473438263,
0.6441653370857239,
0.08602119237184525,
-0.96428382396698,
-0.04079053923487663,
-0.8167476058006287,
-0.6677417755126953,
-0.3900553584098816,
-0.4007917642593384,
0.23314546048641205,
-0.620007336139679,
0.796593964099884,
-0.2215743213891983,
0.6115589141845703,
0.17757415771484375,
0.03289461508393288,
-0.33761119842529297,
0.18905383348464966,
0.24558232724666595,
-0.13716766238212585,
-0.25747424364089966,
-0.2511208951473236,
-0.13752596080303192,
-0.5294933915138245,
0.2897365689277649,
0.2922046184539795,
-0.012322907336056232,
-0.019341887906193733,
0.6020695567131042,
0.9041906595230103,
-0.14897894859313965,
-0.049789365381002426,
0.6665698885917664,
-0.1902431696653366,
-0.4729045033454895,
-0.7791813611984253,
-0.04267999529838562,
-0.4077564775943756,
0.1153620034456253,
0.4353334307670593,
0.3275759220123291,
0.22900265455245972,
-0.4821120798587799,
0.3390085697174072,
0.25249984860420227,
-0.29524773359298706,
-0.2891285717487335,
0.6772379875183105,
0.4962405562400818,
0.17588478326797485,
0.6544354557991028,
-0.2886625826358795,
-0.6246135234832764,
0.7686852812767029,
0.37617504596710205,
1.2953956127166748,
-0.7426357865333557,
0.2708365321159363,
0.6465969681739807,
0.28459587693214417,
-0.12051953375339508,
0.733895480632782,
-0.013928335160017014,
-0.7355290651321411,
-0.589621901512146,
-1.1592600345611572,
-0.1253582090139389,
0.1701284497976303,
-0.7363793253898621,
0.14367419481277466,
-0.09474030137062073,
-0.32543879747390747,
-0.10537198185920715,
-0.015258166939020157,
-0.8009390830993652,
0.5236180424690247,
0.14778827130794525,
0.6284489035606384,
-1.2764769792556763,
0.8301629424095154,
0.8418777585029602,
-0.5825720429420471,
-1.0310301780700684,
0.23063968122005463,
-0.1886255294084549,
-0.45017117261886597,
0.6600280404090881,
0.3863401710987091,
-0.3604639768600464,
0.06284043937921524,
-0.2534230351448059,
-1.003872036933899,
0.8817957639694214,
0.217470183968544,
-0.16406618058681488,
-0.08979324996471405,
0.041901860386133194,
0.5577134490013123,
-0.6262344717979431,
0.728427529335022,
0.4728584885597229,
0.6586230397224426,
-0.013361704535782337,
-0.5881473422050476,
-0.3028937876224518,
-0.5133755803108215,
-0.3401508629322052,
0.17806263267993927,
-0.5886987447738647,
1.200055718421936,
-0.3463742733001709,
0.012308593839406967,
-0.007405590265989304,
0.6873660087585449,
-0.3596043884754181,
0.1210702583193779,
0.3280636668205261,
0.6997554898262024,
0.6317328214645386,
-0.07816132158041,
0.8790348768234253,
-0.5331118702888489,
0.08026120066642761,
0.7677459716796875,
-0.08700140565633774,
0.6476642489433289,
0.032591644674539566,
-0.031040383502840996,
0.9143572449684143,
0.4997999370098114,
-0.07649704813957214,
0.6905314922332764,
-0.00884864293038845,
-0.4610227644443512,
-0.6033926606178284,
0.20375819504261017,
-0.17528074979782104,
1.058570384979248,
0.4164520502090454,
-0.7000853419303894,
0.08522994071245193,
0.2682987451553345,
-0.36025509238243103,
0.2672135531902313,
-0.43846696615219116,
0.8811058402061462,
-0.11585996299982071,
-1.2983624935150146,
0.26367321610450745,
-0.055031973868608475,
0.645878255367279,
-0.7195755243301392,
-0.39838314056396484,
-0.32133010029792786,
0.20413830876350403,
-0.040323592722415924,
-0.6661006808280945,
0.2631990611553192,
-0.1641518622636795,
-0.5373506546020508,
-0.5087453126907349,
0.7617028951644897,
-0.7031010389328003,
-0.9003008008003235,
0.3667535185813904,
0.46023744344711304,
-0.03609059005975723,
0.14586685597896576,
-0.38291797041893005,
-0.22606246173381805,
-0.1999291479587555,
-0.3072579801082611,
0.17581482231616974,
0.3562085032463074,
0.17110660672187805,
0.47981196641921997,
0.35662969946861267,
-0.07414959371089935,
0.1246381476521492,
0.040473055094480515,
0.617942750453949,
-0.7414631843566895,
-0.7617022395133972,
-0.6197344064712524,
0.40251651406288147,
-0.05112127587199211,
-0.28994327783584595,
0.42267516255378723,
0.35969337821006775,
0.479415625333786,
-0.25993597507476807,
1.332298755645752,
0.0217457115650177,
0.775384247303009,
-0.5300045609474182,
0.7612109780311584,
-0.5775606036186218,
-0.1601150780916214,
-0.3620706796646118,
-0.5084468722343445,
0.11044768244028091,
0.5955448150634766,
-0.24560177326202393,
0.22992369532585144,
1.0746039152145386,
0.4546676576137543,
0.2698272168636322,
0.23573948442935944,
0.2587827146053314,
-0.14717508852481842,
0.10999488830566406,
0.9454953074455261,
0.7340458631515503,
-0.32783859968185425,
0.42949429154396057,
-0.299615740776062,
-0.31765133142471313,
-0.16112713515758514,
-0.8828656077384949,
-0.9188687801361084,
-0.7117281556129456,
-0.16178801655769348,
-0.15926378965377808,
0.15779240429401398,
0.7255722284317017,
0.3877342641353607,
-0.8522785305976868,
-0.03153125196695328,
0.24844489991664886,
-0.22038868069648743,
-0.682951807975769,
-0.2683085501194,
0.3876965641975403,
-0.7052553296089172,
-0.6869797110557556,
0.34204259514808655,
0.0004003973735962063,
-0.003032539738342166,
-0.3653486967086792,
0.05514448881149292,
-0.13560296595096588,
0.34272879362106323,
0.4971526563167572,
0.17833878099918365,
-0.33131781220436096,
-0.5084972381591797,
-0.01863129623234272,
-0.16327115893363953,
-0.020229358226060867,
0.8503510355949402,
-0.8814395666122437,
0.3050732910633087,
0.35987958312034607,
0.4147420823574066,
0.29211845993995667,
0.1332872062921524,
0.9333345293998718,
-0.6757165789604187,
-0.3666352331638336,
0.5466474890708923,
0.614945650100708,
0.25417348742485046,
-0.5408211946487427,
0.026457680389285088,
0.1379966288805008,
-0.6266414523124695,
-0.20273920893669128,
0.3211039900779724,
-0.4658410847187042,
-0.3120987117290497,
0.7207602262496948,
-0.5190162658691406,
-0.03083239682018757,
-0.20552243292331696,
0.18753710389137268,
0.1834845244884491,
-0.5634667277336121,
1.2553647756576538,
0.8043493032455444,
-0.44006580114364624,
-0.2904800772666931,
-0.023463280871510506,
0.8287197351455688,
0.5254590511322021,
-0.8033710718154907,
-0.18802616000175476,
0.7317333817481995,
0.13393722474575043,
-0.03433329239487648,
0.7311109304428101,
0.03472239896655083,
0.48159515857696533,
0.20737066864967346,
0.45783668756484985,
-0.1087198406457901,
-0.47826582193374634,
-0.16902761161327362,
0.4977003037929535,
0.20352166891098022,
-0.40405070781707764
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08319v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08319v2
|
Knowledge Conflicts for LLMs: A Survey
| 2024-03-13T08:02:23 | 2024-06-22T08:31:40 |
Rongwu Xu, Zehan Qi, Zhijiang Guo, Cunxiang Wang, Hongru Wang, Yue Zhang, Wei Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
This survey provides an in-depth analysis of knowledge conflicts for large
language models (LLMs), highlighting the complex challenges they encounter when
blending contextual and parametric knowledge. Our focus is on three categories
of knowledge conflicts: context-memory, inter-context, and intra-memory
conflict. These conflicts can significantly impact the trustworthiness and
performance of LLMs, especially in real-world applications where noise and
misinformation are common. By categorizing these conflicts, exploring the
causes, examining the behaviors of LLMs under such conflicts, and reviewing
available solutions, this survey aims to shed light on strategies for improving
the robustness of LLMs, thereby serving as a valuable resource for advancing
research in this evolving area.
|
[
-0.5132271647453308,
-0.7296680212020874,
0.8325102925300598,
0.23113860189914703,
-0.015003502368927002,
0.29930633306503296,
-0.26079097390174866,
-0.7661440968513489,
-0.23447823524475098,
0.6822196245193481,
-0.2498941719532013,
-0.36684563755989075,
-0.8115570545196533,
-0.22758054733276367,
-0.4694225490093231,
0.5997825264930725,
-0.425963819026947,
0.17408621311187744,
-0.669366180896759,
-0.4133129119873047,
-0.5321812033653259,
-0.8558449149131775,
-0.6523706912994385,
-0.30867141485214233,
0.49424681067466736,
0.3335355222225189,
0.46750426292419434,
0.09420692175626755,
0.6547932624816895,
0.3393486440181732,
-0.2727607488632202,
0.2832171320915222,
-0.41131260991096497,
0.66608726978302,
-0.22690829634666443,
-0.3940928280353546,
-0.2457997351884842,
-0.04478760063648224,
0.5886874794960022,
0.48597127199172974,
-0.1369694173336029,
0.23104271292686462,
0.10906805098056793,
0.5856834053993225,
-0.7395684123039246,
0.11713492125272751,
-0.6400127410888672,
-0.06421788036823273,
-0.4576519727706909,
-0.17444245517253876,
0.07000286877155304,
-0.5924357771873474,
0.3868846893310547,
-0.3340565860271454,
-0.11905506998300552,
0.1943049430847168,
0.8430222868919373,
0.3706420660018921,
-0.6698133945465088,
-0.5182571411132812,
-0.7900537848472595,
0.7761797308921814,
-0.7456874251365662,
0.4467787444591522,
0.5229296684265137,
0.2101728618144989,
-0.15927065908908844,
-0.5322505235671997,
-0.48984426259994507,
0.062411610037088394,
0.08855969458818436,
-0.07705405354499817,
-0.23572036623954773,
-0.24688515067100525,
0.28710392117500305,
0.16058459877967834,
-0.40619024634361267,
0.3535478115081787,
-0.40085211396217346,
-0.21224123239517212,
0.5078608989715576,
0.3782031536102295,
0.3837992250919342,
0.0858304351568222,
-0.18043825030326843,
0.030485935509204865,
-1.1039179563522339,
0.038389019668102264,
0.43565165996551514,
-0.21248747408390045,
0.04311515763401985,
0.46398311853408813,
-0.05233898386359215,
0.9761632084846497,
-0.23552581667900085,
-0.3585895597934723,
-0.1732109934091568,
-0.2752537131309509,
0.058743882924318314,
0.07076968997716904,
0.9103477001190186,
0.5669336318969727,
0.09165319055318832,
-0.023439187556505203,
-0.29602909088134766,
-0.21106503903865814,
0.009143538773059845,
-0.413495272397995,
0.23822753131389618,
0.28320521116256714,
-0.3167808949947357,
-0.14661318063735962,
-0.1438184231519699,
-0.7550956010818481,
-0.6445470452308655,
-0.2916099429130554,
0.3975764811038971,
-0.4073737859725952,
-0.38426530361175537,
-0.019572308287024498,
-0.11328034847974777,
0.1370101273059845,
0.34713634848594666,
-0.5851811170578003,
0.04635373875498772,
0.6124182343482971,
0.5684220194816589,
-0.13966131210327148,
-0.3373331129550934,
-0.11011770367622375,
0.5091004371643066,
-0.24779008328914642,
0.7713074088096619,
-0.5091019868850708,
-0.42224350571632385,
0.29469531774520874,
-0.35275164246559143,
-0.25970518589019775,
-0.9104325175285339,
0.2731828987598419,
-0.6782112717628479,
0.4164297580718994,
-0.6626275777816772,
-0.778018593788147,
-0.103180892765522,
0.5877712965011597,
-0.6428889036178589,
1.2096953392028809,
0.19472451508045197,
-0.8124650716781616,
0.36850470304489136,
-0.3857843279838562,
-0.1560392677783966,
-0.06553827971220016,
-0.49168577790260315,
-0.12242848426103592,
0.00975851435214281,
-0.17707425355911255,
0.5852407813072205,
-0.7834944725036621,
0.5342292785644531,
-0.22593893110752106,
-0.20239900052547455,
0.3746947646141052,
-0.15321987867355347,
0.46640723943710327,
0.404354453086853,
-0.19548453390598297,
0.17944613099098206,
-0.7529816627502441,
-0.33292365074157715,
0.10906699299812317,
-0.46455225348472595,
-0.616605818271637,
0.1712036430835724,
-0.4299808144569397,
0.4104694426059723,
0.6797187924385071,
-0.37759697437286377,
0.11194952577352524,
0.18287242949008942,
0.38349685072898865,
0.6449129581451416,
0.20288114249706268,
0.30132076144218445,
-0.5671359896659851,
0.5250356793403625,
0.5618429183959961,
0.2982959747314453,
0.18942278623580933,
-0.5527904033660889,
-0.785394549369812,
0.4114943742752075,
-0.01141095720231533,
0.4741487205028534,
-0.7577369809150696,
0.11971302330493927,
-0.09145325422286987,
-0.3570868670940399,
-0.16440747678279877,
0.24714770913124084,
0.3182474970817566,
0.6462780237197876,
0.25430867075920105,
0.11099182069301605,
-0.41295066475868225,
-0.8664124011993408,
-0.38430482149124146,
-0.3153921663761139,
0.27148181200027466,
0.41860780119895935,
0.2162650227546692,
-0.31086084246635437,
1.0455772876739502,
-0.36216020584106445,
-0.28612178564071655,
-0.07936365157365799,
0.19696390628814697,
-0.27954038977622986,
0.33923032879829407,
0.6379996538162231,
-0.6372646689414978,
-0.4871070384979248,
0.055019572377204895,
-0.7694175839424133,
-0.04966377094388008,
0.2930704951286316,
0.21560056507587433,
0.40203821659088135,
1.0372743606567383,
-0.6065931916236877,
0.10831025242805481,
0.7113135457038879,
-0.24121835827827454,
0.46319469809532166,
0.05120598152279854,
0.1691388338804245,
-1.1786409616470337,
-0.22752073407173157,
0.11408670246601105,
0.16953378915786743,
-0.4220457375049591,
0.007807693909853697,
0.1307995468378067,
0.27025699615478516,
-0.6513894200325012,
0.6523202657699585,
-0.5442543029785156,
0.12196711450815201,
0.14693902432918549,
0.25477343797683716,
-0.1817196011543274,
0.05477872118353844,
0.0023947765585035086,
0.8473089337348938,
0.628673791885376,
-0.738595724105835,
0.4072967767715454,
0.04541248828172684,
-0.6225801706314087,
0.4829998314380646,
-0.27214497327804565,
-0.05113697052001953,
-0.14104799926280975,
0.03722165524959564,
-0.8580238819122314,
-0.3216700255870819,
0.25676479935646057,
-0.11757989972829819,
0.2673727571964264,
-0.0515667162835598,
-0.7169981002807617,
-0.07008174806833267,
-0.13960371911525726,
0.7016304731369019,
0.41814130544662476,
-0.28752249479293823,
0.49836787581443787,
0.482709139585495,
-0.191349595785141,
-0.7196742296218872,
-0.586797833442688,
0.03890232369303703,
-0.5502188205718994,
-0.5169548392295837,
0.10862099379301071,
-0.06560016423463821,
-0.6429679989814758,
0.20577427744865417,
-0.16235999763011932,
-0.35993504524230957,
-0.20190292596817017,
0.09247630089521408,
0.07498505711555481,
-0.32025817036628723,
0.15970584750175476,
-0.09819052368402481,
0.29622483253479004,
0.23160420358181,
0.057176943868398666,
0.6015797257423401,
-0.20508228242397308,
-0.6000078320503235,
-0.02195758931338787,
0.21068380773067474,
0.7691448926925659,
0.011211131699383259,
0.8622465133666992,
0.5369468331336975,
-0.3146350681781769,
-0.04721943289041519,
-1.2151048183441162,
0.07719293236732483,
-0.47910892963409424,
0.3273908495903015,
-0.2806376814842224,
-1.4720531702041626,
0.8346814513206482,
-0.35394856333732605,
-0.10572469234466553,
0.27312609553337097,
0.5110232830047607,
-0.10458718240261078,
0.813374936580658,
0.497005820274353,
-0.39570489525794983,
0.4132254719734192,
0.15955626964569092,
0.2817499041557312,
-0.8274045586585999,
-0.651161789894104,
-0.5206440091133118,
-0.26211249828338623,
-0.27796849608421326,
-0.4772526025772095,
0.3516375422477722,
0.1997259259223938,
-0.30194607377052307,
0.4376857578754425,
-0.15789806842803955,
0.4225216209888458,
0.22659070789813995,
-0.40362659096717834,
0.39875730872154236,
-0.3131673336029053,
-0.2717193067073822,
-0.13760906457901,
-0.8712351322174072,
-0.5747376680374146,
0.9707819819450378,
0.4487391412258148,
0.7981441617012024,
0.5673642158508301,
0.6481069922447205,
-0.17988765239715576,
0.20056626200675964,
-0.5847557783126831,
0.6394730806350708,
0.1565220057964325,
-0.6852558851242065,
-0.26820752024650574,
-0.574830949306488,
-0.9441531896591187,
0.07600487768650055,
-0.057053547352552414,
-1.002414345741272,
0.196328267455101,
-0.09425949305295944,
-0.2505360245704651,
0.5486700534820557,
-0.4749438166618347,
0.6770485043525696,
-0.4080207943916321,
-0.23631566762924194,
-0.11066216230392456,
-0.5344600677490234,
0.8311110138893127,
-0.28470325469970703,
0.2891722023487091,
-0.17231953144073486,
0.0006119500030763447,
0.8879688382148743,
-0.1470160037279129,
0.6966646909713745,
0.07381533831357956,
-0.5524531006813049,
0.4104645550251007,
0.21062582731246948,
0.40698423981666565,
0.03587896749377251,
0.11960455775260925,
0.1949727088212967,
0.38460519909858704,
-0.0751303881406784,
-0.3789948523044586,
0.8066815137863159,
-0.8512584567070007,
-0.7684444785118103,
-0.48715707659721375,
-0.796113133430481,
-0.8399884700775146,
0.09601783752441406,
0.3523620069026947,
0.20652806758880615,
-0.23197020590305328,
0.3029780387878418,
1.263318419456482,
-0.3196069598197937,
0.5450056195259094,
0.738730788230896,
-0.3914198875427246,
0.023941226303577423,
0.8832707405090332,
0.2816186547279358,
0.2918708324432373,
0.24595029652118683,
0.035809505730867386,
-0.23963913321495056,
-0.7337470650672913,
0.07411298900842667,
0.15481029450893402,
-0.7569663524627686,
-0.32278916239738464,
-0.5262390375137329,
-0.3505606949329376,
-0.4436379671096802,
0.1190737932920456,
-0.3804340362548828,
-0.15302957594394684,
-0.4075492024421692,
0.27529022097587585,
0.33314600586891174,
1.1304731369018555,
0.1956712305545807,
0.4389400780200958,
-1.042461633682251,
0.09384382516145706,
0.35665902495384216,
0.409132182598114,
-0.07165218889713287,
-0.4525408446788788,
-0.3606351912021637,
-0.39412379264831543,
-0.3506391644477844,
-1.0827640295028687,
0.12593549489974976,
-0.29598867893218994,
0.8116641044616699,
0.6328680515289307,
0.07326333969831467,
0.7692033052444458,
-0.10476484149694443,
1.0470106601715088,
0.2624243497848511,
-0.7804564237594604,
0.19127076864242554,
-0.4812155067920685,
0.10216163843870163,
0.4855765998363495,
0.6482416987419128,
-0.6232536435127258,
-0.5817650556564331,
-0.5524165034294128,
-0.8923061490058899,
0.5582207441329956,
-0.23359864950180054,
-0.2795080542564392,
0.0058581032790243626,
0.33031314611434937,
-0.3416249752044678,
0.24080614745616913,
-0.5494949817657471,
-0.19391053915023804,
0.3650294840335846,
-0.12354744225740433,
0.05937515199184418,
-0.5276756286621094,
-0.6084288358688354,
-0.37516626715660095,
0.5196369886398315,
0.15922695398330688,
-0.0330687053501606,
-0.0677485466003418,
-0.2149428129196167,
-0.29549267888069153,
0.29922381043434143,
0.9103410840034485,
1.02875816822052,
-0.008186999708414078,
0.3516443371772766,
0.418338418006897,
-0.27019867300987244,
0.22143495082855225,
-0.22554491460323334,
0.04570040851831436,
-0.307736337184906,
0.3662930428981781,
0.69026118516922,
0.4201568365097046,
-0.8604527115821838,
0.6105446815490723,
-0.2462143748998642,
-0.44130808115005493,
-0.2946297228336334,
0.04720050469040871,
0.509838342666626,
0.3450009822845459,
0.1558070331811905,
0.12545901536941528,
-0.14177094399929047,
-0.5066917538642883,
-0.038292188197374344,
0.5478205680847168,
-0.3707002103328705,
0.07568545639514923,
0.3227909803390503,
-0.04451104626059532,
-0.019398652017116547,
0.3575601577758789,
-0.031294260174036026,
-0.5233936905860901,
0.4076007008552551,
0.4348621368408203,
0.5017737150192261,
-0.22075612843036652,
0.0034561739303171635,
-0.04633698612451553,
0.28570663928985596,
-0.2490207552909851,
0.1156848594546318,
0.017465630546212196,
-0.962597131729126,
-0.2465232014656067,
-0.5631694793701172,
-0.6709761023521423,
0.602761447429657,
-0.6387622952461243,
0.04198814928531647,
-0.4209068715572357,
-0.29611971974372864,
-0.5072407126426697,
-0.0025875354185700417,
-0.578118085861206,
-0.07830753922462463,
0.05631279945373535,
0.8162639141082764,
-0.6042435169219971,
0.9197971224784851,
0.8551486134529114,
-0.25436991453170776,
-0.7901076078414917,
0.09746911376714706,
0.10323711484670639,
-0.6678434610366821,
0.843497633934021,
-0.4420720338821411,
-0.20879347622394562,
-0.41341257095336914,
-0.45272648334503174,
-1.0504639148712158,
1.1814194917678833,
0.36069777607917786,
-0.49645721912384033,
0.027493836358189583,
0.3554457426071167,
0.3884809613227844,
-0.26969113945961,
-0.0954119935631752,
0.7290387749671936,
0.713168740272522,
-0.025358224287629128,
-1.0087553262710571,
-0.07151739299297333,
0.08246322721242905,
0.10969541221857071,
0.13645072281360626,
-1.091972827911377,
1.0078474283218384,
0.391872763633728,
-0.16108503937721252,
-0.08425217121839523,
0.5525603890419006,
0.5206153392791748,
0.412640780210495,
0.3435676693916321,
0.7018736600875854,
0.6259600520133972,
-0.20360931754112244,
0.5686511397361755,
-0.6138258576393127,
0.12720651924610138,
1.2110024690628052,
-0.48720479011535645,
0.6998974084854126,
0.7323300242424011,
-0.31573736667633057,
0.45410147309303284,
0.7265475988388062,
0.2892308235168457,
0.029169701039791107,
0.0996057316660881,
-0.5165522694587708,
-0.09288344532251358,
0.005001547746360302,
-0.6937214136123657,
0.4158838987350464,
0.5944886803627014,
-0.12857668101787567,
-0.3643469512462616,
-0.26996347308158875,
0.19363297522068024,
-0.02249963767826557,
0.0034712394699454308,
0.8040634989738464,
-0.03731483966112137,
-0.7423381209373474,
0.2585684359073639,
0.051625125110149384,
0.8493542671203613,
-0.7388830780982971,
0.19033680856227875,
-0.02444165199995041,
0.04770594462752342,
-0.2617381513118744,
-1.0036031007766724,
0.3441358804702759,
-0.26586800813674927,
-0.16340585052967072,
-0.26780518889427185,
0.8493095636367798,
-0.7102789282798767,
-0.03508567437529564,
0.5174787044525146,
0.9430853128433228,
0.022106753662228584,
-0.06929101794958115,
-0.5558241605758667,
0.5557958483695984,
-0.27000507712364197,
-0.29703444242477417,
0.818931519985199,
0.5769849419593811,
-0.18948404490947723,
0.8002291321754456,
0.40369996428489685,
0.1572342813014984,
0.41762858629226685,
0.045197829604148865,
0.9169811606407166,
-0.5967857241630554,
-0.0036557249259203672,
-0.8397594690322876,
0.13358165323734283,
-0.07685600966215134,
-0.35322105884552,
1.0775741338729858,
0.6172725558280945,
0.7490364909172058,
-0.06121392548084259,
0.7666587829589844,
0.06656546145677567,
0.5197250843048096,
-0.5080843567848206,
0.9105401039123535,
-0.5285289287567139,
0.40196850895881653,
-0.2781696319580078,
-0.8608527183532715,
-0.16096794605255127,
0.3314772844314575,
-0.33705174922943115,
0.002596362493932247,
0.7752453088760376,
0.6852843165397644,
0.09387824684381485,
0.03602363169193268,
0.5239328145980835,
0.12567707896232605,
0.15417996048927307,
0.707149863243103,
1.4395263195037842,
-0.27146705985069275,
0.47041425108909607,
-0.21691645681858063,
0.13745439052581787,
-0.12124600261449814,
-0.9969226121902466,
-0.7903889417648315,
-0.929908812046051,
-0.38810035586357117,
-0.18624497950077057,
-0.08239126205444336,
0.6827725768089294,
0.5077947974205017,
-0.7103124856948853,
-0.6206626892089844,
0.15115207433700562,
0.4642869532108307,
0.2789032757282257,
-0.24460043013095856,
-0.053824495524168015,
-0.5307400822639465,
-0.6625360250473022,
0.38619276881217957,
0.11985082924365997,
0.18536213040351868,
-0.39725613594055176,
-0.20120714604854584,
-0.168671116232872,
0.08468735218048096,
0.7734964489936829,
0.4677868187427521,
-0.8481151461601257,
-0.3045096695423126,
-0.28367483615875244,
-0.13680586218833923,
-0.33415499329566956,
1.2227180004119873,
-0.5154565572738647,
0.10011371970176697,
0.5024707913398743,
0.6039389967918396,
0.30027341842651367,
-0.20950022339820862,
0.44620388746261597,
-0.7607228755950928,
0.04302261769771576,
0.14061616361141205,
0.5056112408638,
0.14076168835163116,
-0.5403957962989807,
0.20223282277584076,
0.1546885222196579,
-0.7843162417411804,
-0.8903084993362427,
0.25171464681625366,
-0.9330999851226807,
-0.4561377465724945,
1.424142837524414,
0.059468574821949005,
0.21915169060230255,
-0.3730369806289673,
-0.0036004309076815844,
0.2009126991033554,
-0.16858915984630585,
0.5962386727333069,
1.2566503286361694,
-0.41322168707847595,
-0.1645745486021042,
-0.7234483361244202,
0.9123227000236511,
0.2900729179382324,
-0.6697921752929688,
-0.029338447377085686,
0.6862645149230957,
0.5142760276794434,
0.1083536222577095,
0.5268667936325073,
-0.3635829985141754,
-0.16311460733413696,
-0.4004158675670624,
-0.17534320056438446,
0.0037266367580741644,
-0.39884722232818604,
-0.30199122428894043,
0.46523967385292053,
0.350385457277298,
0.39073023200035095
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09733v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09733v1
|
OverleafCopilot: Empowering Academic Writing in Overleaf with Large Language Models
| 2024-03-13T07:52:31 | 2024-03-13T07:52:31 |
Haomin Wen, Zhenjie Wei, Yan Lin, Jiyuan Wang, Yuxuan Liang, Huaiyu Wan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The rapid development of Large Language Models (LLMs) has facilitated a
variety of applications from different domains. In this technical report, we
explore the integration of LLMs and the popular academic writing tool,
Overleaf, to enhance the efficiency and quality of academic writing. To achieve
the above goal, there are three challenges: i) including seamless interaction
between Overleaf and LLMs, ii) establishing reliable communication with the LLM
provider, and iii) ensuring user privacy. To address these challenges, we
present OverleafCopilot, the first-ever tool (i.e., a browser extension) that
seamlessly integrates LLMs and Overleaf, enabling researchers to leverage the
power of LLMs while writing papers. Specifically, we first propose an effective
framework to bridge LLMs and Overleaf. Then, we developed PromptGenius, a
website for researchers to easily find and share high-quality up-to-date
prompts. Thirdly, we propose an agent command system to help researchers
quickly build their customizable agents. OverleafCopilot
(https://chromewebstore.google.com/detail/overleaf-copilot/eoadabdpninlhkkbhngoddfjianhlghb
) has been on the Chrome Extension Store, which now serves thousands of
researchers. Additionally, the code of PromptGenius is released at
https://github.com/wenhaomin/ChatGPT-PromptGenius. We believe our work has the
potential to revolutionize academic writing practices, empowering researchers
to produce higher-quality papers in less time.
|
[
-0.3826114237308502,
-0.6191869974136353,
0.8856218457221985,
0.15429429709911346,
0.2580290734767914,
0.7449838519096375,
-0.29835352301597595,
-0.6831699013710022,
0.3165002763271332,
0.5697121024131775,
-0.5656630396842957,
-0.7653606534004211,
-0.2327958047389984,
-0.02115979604423046,
-0.3974241614341736,
0.8746778964996338,
-0.30870428681373596,
-0.11234623938798904,
-0.7332584857940674,
-0.03636221960186958,
0.00022033389541320503,
-0.5457755923271179,
-0.5286082029342651,
-0.12128276377916336,
1.043393611907959,
0.43335938453674316,
0.503573477268219,
0.27487289905548096,
0.6148185133934021,
0.3342205584049225,
0.1267223358154297,
0.1858266294002533,
-0.5667571425437927,
0.3454159200191498,
-0.284589558839798,
-0.48363953828811646,
-0.6434410214424133,
-0.03459949418902397,
0.5718880295753479,
0.46843111515045166,
-0.022984826937317848,
0.06411661207675934,
0.1916872262954712,
0.4525319039821625,
-0.5800535082817078,
0.040431007742881775,
-0.05078420415520668,
-0.20887506008148193,
-0.41902169585227966,
-0.4263698160648346,
-0.2734842300415039,
-0.8660159111022949,
-0.003852189052850008,
-0.9007478356361389,
0.0007973311585374177,
0.4034994840621948,
0.4763191044330597,
0.07514192909002304,
-0.3374096155166626,
-0.5757659673690796,
-0.47601401805877686,
0.7029321193695068,
-0.5042186975479126,
0.11868873983621597,
0.06143662706017494,
0.48421144485473633,
-0.4180503487586975,
-1.0548207759857178,
-0.6183608174324036,
-0.40455761551856995,
0.005064419936388731,
0.34301429986953735,
-0.27746719121932983,
0.13330060243606567,
0.21850676834583282,
0.2097001075744629,
-0.7977015972137451,
0.44227176904678345,
-0.22585994005203247,
0.09045945107936859,
0.5678620934486389,
0.3879747986793518,
0.2702695429325104,
0.20537379384040833,
0.03472915664315224,
-0.007888964377343655,
-0.563297688961029,
0.0559920072555542,
0.6315641403198242,
0.2800239026546478,
0.11555713415145874,
0.5458233952522278,
0.14075101912021637,
0.43074294924736023,
-0.33078908920288086,
0.08265762776136398,
0.050251640379428864,
0.04807865992188454,
0.008693711832165718,
0.061613451689481735,
0.7639714479446411,
0.36687716841697693,
0.07919829338788986,
-0.13553495705127716,
0.06753720343112946,
0.03588223084807396,
0.23051564395427704,
-0.7249781489372253,
0.076324462890625,
0.6309130787849426,
-0.20521488785743713,
-0.2330412119626999,
-0.10920393466949463,
-0.8445396423339844,
-0.9485771059989929,
-0.37343576550483704,
0.11097501963376999,
-0.4083065688610077,
-0.15780001878738403,
-0.01706118881702423,
-0.2432691603899002,
0.0728849321603775,
0.5702895522117615,
-0.7760504484176636,
0.5987751483917236,
1.1023746728897095,
1.0797786712646484,
-0.3750820457935333,
-0.5227344632148743,
-0.3926908075809479,
0.0370328426361084,
-0.1892080157995224,
0.6189950108528137,
-0.34145185351371765,
-0.5877334475517273,
0.4589484930038452,
-0.10566231608390808,
0.004168197046965361,
0.036282334476709366,
0.5274512767791748,
-0.4927680194377899,
0.3261457681655884,
-0.2820315659046173,
-0.8730027079582214,
-0.05949821695685387,
0.29639339447021484,
-0.6878049373626709,
0.7959156632423401,
0.21880461275577545,
-0.5715547204017639,
0.0045097460970282555,
-0.877147912979126,
-0.2743108570575714,
0.2992876470088959,
-0.12459053844213486,
-0.23905616998672485,
-0.02830319292843342,
-0.25842830538749695,
0.3455325663089752,
-0.4928421676158905,
0.2767305374145508,
-0.3965741991996765,
-0.0564422607421875,
0.4690426290035248,
-0.07891461253166199,
0.8524511456489563,
0.19688567519187927,
0.04345862194895744,
0.4098278284072876,
-0.7735403180122375,
0.06945561617612839,
-0.08069690316915512,
-0.06919992715120316,
0.003016779897734523,
-0.22316433489322662,
0.49139219522476196,
-0.296151340007782,
0.5122118592262268,
-0.8651497960090637,
0.6422618627548218,
0.09421483427286148,
0.5552302598953247,
0.3644573390483856,
-0.2409716099500656,
0.2827909290790558,
-0.5371929407119751,
0.8997352123260498,
-0.970504105091095,
0.17615766823291779,
-0.17911799252033234,
-0.27844980359077454,
-0.5144591331481934,
-0.4420132339000702,
0.4500068128108978,
0.5574526786804199,
-0.4522069990634918,
0.44515642523765564,
-0.28950434923171997,
-0.7301227450370789,
-0.494049072265625,
0.09432124346494675,
0.09792077541351318,
0.14981438219547272,
0.17184628546237946,
-0.03739576414227486,
-0.3952507972717285,
-0.3805001676082611,
-0.08857382088899612,
0.07420965284109116,
-0.22927159070968628,
-0.07326814532279968,
0.5759198665618896,
-0.1927194595336914,
1.1882401704788208,
-0.6551109552383423,
-0.6002238988876343,
-0.6752980947494507,
0.5131980776786804,
0.05818292871117592,
0.431816041469574,
0.7181230187416077,
-0.5684665441513062,
-0.8031055927276611,
0.12009114027023315,
-0.4967498779296875,
-0.4838644862174988,
-0.2788149416446686,
-0.07207081466913223,
0.36090123653411865,
0.8141090273857117,
-0.5679631233215332,
0.14333447813987732,
0.6475271582603455,
-0.22926482558250427,
0.501848578453064,
-0.3138432502746582,
0.0395788848400116,
-0.9494189620018005,
0.5130457878112793,
0.16021324694156647,
-0.35383090376853943,
-0.5035298466682434,
0.16876858472824097,
0.07791128754615784,
-0.2574528455734253,
-0.19657227396965027,
0.7176139950752258,
-0.48742231726646423,
0.18703408539295197,
-0.40390363335609436,
0.3266052305698395,
0.2211225926876068,
0.3794921338558197,
-0.012695771642029285,
0.6258757710456848,
0.5380738973617554,
0.07287024706602097,
0.4294697642326355,
0.1834724396467209,
-0.17404451966285706,
0.543378472328186,
-0.7486412525177002,
0.02408425137400627,
-0.15237239003181458,
0.3884115219116211,
-0.8882282972335815,
-0.4550212025642395,
0.08700303733348846,
-0.5198161005973816,
0.39971527457237244,
0.14628076553344727,
-0.6258490681648254,
-0.18759550154209137,
-0.6228746771812439,
-0.08933480829000473,
0.49410051107406616,
-0.381170392036438,
0.8606974482536316,
0.28438153862953186,
-0.4461006820201874,
-0.08201273530721664,
-0.5342754125595093,
0.24209091067314148,
-0.12246041744947433,
-0.48480668663978577,
0.4415249526500702,
-0.0604374036192894,
-0.19906890392303467,
0.054418567568063736,
0.28203877806663513,
0.05145193263888359,
-0.10735023021697998,
0.4796154797077179,
0.15782685577869415,
0.14338544011116028,
0.12921608984470367,
0.08327537029981613,
-0.02614065632224083,
0.15439556539058685,
-0.21069759130477905,
0.38712355494499207,
0.06678824126720428,
-0.3850790560245514,
-0.3795289695262909,
0.6156411170959473,
0.7109403610229492,
-0.2806871235370636,
0.5740711092948914,
0.4209553301334381,
0.009533882141113281,
-0.3685484230518341,
-0.47626519203186035,
-0.0180498119443655,
-0.5182226896286011,
0.09107956290245056,
-0.14966954290866852,
-0.8455185294151306,
0.539718508720398,
-0.1839071363210678,
0.42256999015808105,
0.14615939557552338,
0.16884389519691467,
-0.1637047827243805,
0.629069983959198,
0.8426390290260315,
0.05647820234298706,
0.5978694558143616,
-0.4213513731956482,
0.04019065573811531,
-0.9076770544052124,
-0.26950761675834656,
-0.8084168434143066,
-0.3197484612464905,
-0.5993430018424988,
-0.2665684223175049,
0.2950185239315033,
-0.2725914418697357,
0.03898196294903755,
0.11276412755250931,
-0.28527945280075073,
0.47899267077445984,
0.956539511680603,
-0.23343314230442047,
0.14044365286827087,
-0.1891399323940277,
0.12263581901788712,
-0.15498395264148712,
-0.7173128724098206,
-0.6797409057617188,
0.9620531797409058,
0.4549896717071533,
0.9426400661468506,
0.09305930137634277,
0.585533618927002,
0.3662310838699341,
0.38736748695373535,
-0.6207329630851746,
0.5574783682823181,
-0.12283699959516525,
-0.532863974571228,
-0.4280763864517212,
-0.14447608590126038,
-1.015194296836853,
0.06982727348804474,
-0.2474702149629593,
-0.938541054725647,
0.22056180238723755,
0.17039084434509277,
-0.5266587734222412,
0.09062767773866653,
-0.38875439763069153,
0.9394853115081787,
-0.48105359077453613,
-0.7776020765304565,
-0.12403759360313416,
-0.6188511252403259,
-0.041841961443424225,
-0.08001194894313812,
0.06101885065436363,
0.10475383698940277,
0.014444759115576744,
0.6992809772491455,
-0.4182073473930359,
1.008818507194519,
0.20657406747341156,
-0.05279988422989845,
0.4007924199104309,
0.07763306796550751,
0.44564810395240784,
-0.10206746309995651,
-0.09985018521547318,
0.1438017636537552,
0.10335516184568405,
-0.16425511240959167,
-0.7234066724777222,
1.0551942586898804,
-0.6529279947280884,
-0.37796539068222046,
-0.9398521780967712,
-0.5194196701049805,
-0.05491173639893532,
0.27924489974975586,
0.09003356844186783,
0.7401986718177795,
-0.41365692019462585,
0.38218605518341064,
0.35407716035842896,
-0.26812630891799927,
0.39180901646614075,
0.7188551425933838,
-0.624133288860321,
-0.4790414273738861,
0.9893913865089417,
0.27570316195487976,
0.24262641370296478,
0.4302898943424225,
0.0747547447681427,
-0.5147979855537415,
-0.6252657771110535,
-0.12479177862405777,
0.20878346264362335,
-0.794509768486023,
0.10299447178840637,
-0.7609602212905884,
-0.18390482664108276,
-0.5781998634338379,
-0.733966588973999,
-0.008358055725693703,
-0.5660550594329834,
-0.4769243896007538,
-0.06267455965280533,
0.5694619417190552,
0.5901505947113037,
-0.12332756072282791,
0.8047826886177063,
-0.6350326538085938,
-0.020513838157057762,
0.01693219505250454,
0.15839363634586334,
-0.04795897379517555,
-0.19841189682483673,
-0.13593660295009613,
-0.4338234066963196,
-0.5954342484474182,
-0.5528746843338013,
0.5385836958885193,
-0.08661365509033203,
0.41105931997299194,
0.24199436604976654,
0.10499665886163712,
0.26049721240997314,
-0.41393306851387024,
0.727810263633728,
0.1739867478609085,
-0.9814239740371704,
0.12278565764427185,
-0.5570826530456543,
0.36405763030052185,
0.7428507804870605,
0.705322265625,
-0.7473215460777283,
-0.7363430857658386,
-0.3689396381378174,
-0.9191567897796631,
0.3766644597053528,
0.09586808830499649,
-0.2450050413608551,
0.35887765884399414,
-0.007004921790212393,
0.38853225111961365,
0.4522659182548523,
-0.409195214509964,
0.03939836844801903,
-0.14682799577713013,
-0.39813801646232605,
-0.4125345051288605,
-0.13945728540420532,
-0.1648288071155548,
-0.04791978374123573,
0.515998125076294,
-0.09539689123630524,
-0.2971988618373871,
0.18379975855350494,
0.07046027481555939,
-0.07454634457826614,
0.2924700081348419,
0.5557272434234619,
0.970314621925354,
-0.47027528285980225,
0.03072427399456501,
-0.11773782223463058,
-0.44035428762435913,
-0.26859334111213684,
0.34547168016433716,
-0.2520277798175812,
0.03759891912341118,
0.7544914484024048,
0.6656590700149536,
-0.05634497106075287,
-0.6768080592155457,
0.2836705148220062,
-0.07809033244848251,
-0.17335164546966553,
-0.5579964518547058,
0.15909796953201294,
0.06305607408285141,
0.2954306900501251,
0.4184296131134033,
-0.31996163725852966,
0.2784253656864166,
-0.6736477613449097,
-0.26237085461616516,
0.5033918023109436,
-0.20761501789093018,
-0.22329573333263397,
0.7290456891059875,
0.5854741334915161,
-0.4532056450843811,
0.17119820415973663,
-0.10067683458328247,
-0.5883469581604004,
0.5074366331100464,
0.36973321437835693,
0.9221623539924622,
0.04390789568424225,
0.4055097997188568,
-0.042670682072639465,
0.205070361495018,
0.02427035942673683,
0.42255693674087524,
0.07316382974386215,
0.020524466410279274,
-0.3905719220638275,
-0.45179587602615356,
-0.9758814573287964,
-0.029132993891835213,
-0.4105962812900543,
0.2972245514392853,
-0.5122033357620239,
-0.2881665527820587,
0.20296500623226166,
0.2812061309814453,
-0.29631465673446655,
-0.15144185721874237,
-0.13757386803627014,
1.101845145225525,
-0.6497960686683655,
0.6582604050636292,
0.7148723602294922,
-0.27560749650001526,
-0.2790916860103607,
-0.2752131521701813,
0.2356862872838974,
-0.3259909749031067,
0.25902310013771057,
0.22094213962554932,
-0.309571772813797,
0.20362648367881775,
-0.6304334402084351,
-0.5189026594161987,
1.096521258354187,
0.04775899276137352,
-0.9343217015266418,
0.2018180638551712,
0.2655065059661865,
0.8360417485237122,
-0.20749300718307495,
0.45548418164253235,
0.3513459265232086,
0.6020480394363403,
0.30044153332710266,
-0.7296239137649536,
0.08000333607196808,
-0.07153566181659698,
-0.22353266179561615,
0.36571305990219116,
-0.6733620762825012,
0.7021024227142334,
0.1264767348766327,
-0.19236929714679718,
0.30169984698295593,
0.5864453315734863,
-0.009333478286862373,
0.5949224829673767,
-0.026896344497799873,
0.25803905725479126,
0.9268627762794495,
-0.05212501809000969,
1.0609917640686035,
-0.3161308467388153,
0.1702953428030014,
1.1668493747711182,
-0.661354124546051,
0.6984027624130249,
0.5551364421844482,
-0.0462576225399971,
0.4552046060562134,
0.25089845061302185,
-0.06762989610433578,
0.27857762575149536,
0.41507139801979065,
-0.3176945745944977,
0.14386923611164093,
-0.389146625995636,
-0.37122800946235657,
-0.1625482439994812,
0.27859553694725037,
-0.07365380227565765,
-0.24927152693271637,
0.1664866805076599,
0.22186043858528137,
0.44469478726387024,
-0.20000223815441132,
0.5430800914764404,
0.16436415910720825,
-0.6861666440963745,
0.1301003396511078,
-0.0902324840426445,
0.37818649411201477,
-0.9646075367927551,
0.14613470435142517,
-0.21843363344669342,
0.07052385061979294,
-0.258342981338501,
-1.0984810590744019,
0.11204106360673904,
0.1395624428987503,
0.07229023426771164,
-0.4686408042907715,
0.3930514454841614,
-0.45467716455459595,
-0.5189337730407715,
0.23806725442409515,
0.3152373731136322,
-0.012626521289348602,
0.06456299871206284,
-0.22056904435157776,
0.6108262538909912,
-0.33397242426872253,
-0.2709648013114929,
0.17672781646251678,
0.4715903699398041,
-0.004255648702383041,
0.8837825059890747,
0.6217673420906067,
0.40612608194351196,
-0.09399553388357162,
0.11403073370456696,
0.8295190334320068,
-0.5531489849090576,
-0.6260508894920349,
-0.6793314218521118,
0.507887601852417,
-0.4798504412174225,
-0.38359782099723816,
1.0951564311981201,
0.6216539740562439,
0.2893120050430298,
0.05744774639606476,
1.1373765468597412,
-0.23111601173877716,
0.6903284788131714,
-0.35734617710113525,
0.7845351696014404,
-0.6024110317230225,
-0.08000442385673523,
-0.11078814417123795,
-0.9450585842132568,
-0.5402755737304688,
0.10499352216720581,
-0.5027180314064026,
-0.3557923138141632,
0.9967829585075378,
0.6097240447998047,
0.011987186037003994,
-0.14054545760154724,
0.2327253371477127,
-0.023564789444208145,
0.6895439624786377,
0.35270625352859497,
0.7114039063453674,
0.237436443567276,
0.46045613288879395,
-0.015584048815071583,
-0.48282819986343384,
-0.37655821442604065,
-1.04643976688385,
-1.2790262699127197,
-0.49115774035453796,
-0.36053383350372314,
-0.14486631751060486,
0.16721190512180328,
0.8653593063354492,
0.29746729135513306,
-0.6928753852844238,
-0.41187599301338196,
-0.319991797208786,
-0.06105256453156471,
0.13994628190994263,
-0.18873050808906555,
0.4118445813655853,
-0.169135183095932,
-0.8891672492027283,
0.20395934581756592,
0.24575403332710266,
0.14806096255779266,
-0.7302709221839905,
0.0040536243468523026,
0.06424682587385178,
0.11967062950134277,
0.325519859790802,
0.7114087343215942,
-0.32691648602485657,
0.11920257657766342,
0.09004844725131989,
-0.18961627781391144,
-0.17593692243099213,
1.0004582405090332,
-0.34168726205825806,
0.3392120599746704,
0.6706598997116089,
0.5516014099121094,
0.40572723746299744,
0.1789582073688507,
0.7509090304374695,
-0.3489536941051483,
-0.0141220698133111,
0.30144500732421875,
0.24996457993984222,
0.36389583349227905,
-0.292990118265152,
0.40106961131095886,
-0.3584090769290924,
-0.9156326651573181,
-0.954513669013977,
0.15876461565494537,
-1.0447239875793457,
-0.49352458119392395,
1.046746850013733,
-0.17354492843151093,
-0.27751249074935913,
0.0005697758169844747,
-0.7262874245643616,
0.054337602108716965,
-0.6591368317604065,
0.8399898409843445,
0.6748865246772766,
-0.0839110016822815,
-0.03824760019779205,
-0.5949996709823608,
0.607890784740448,
0.16822785139083862,
-1.0736101865768433,
0.10540497303009033,
0.6249034404754639,
-0.10655254870653152,
0.5207916498184204,
0.5025160908699036,
0.49631065130233765,
0.18684041500091553,
-0.03737121820449829,
0.3188339173793793,
-0.4762203097343445,
-0.5332867503166199,
-0.33713796734809875,
0.36620384454727173,
0.10669496655464172,
-0.033684711903333664
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08314v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08314v1
|
Is Context Helpful for Chat Translation Evaluation?
| 2024-03-13T07:49:50 | 2024-03-13T07:49:50 |
Sweta Agrawal, Amin Farajian, Patrick Fernandes, Ricardo Rei, André F. T. Martins
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Despite the recent success of automatic metrics for assessing translation
quality, their application in evaluating the quality of machine-translated
chats has been limited. Unlike more structured texts like news, chat
conversations are often unstructured, short, and heavily reliant on contextual
information. This poses questions about the reliability of existing
sentence-level metrics in this domain as well as the role of context in
assessing the translation quality. Motivated by this, we conduct a
meta-evaluation of existing sentence-level automatic metrics, primarily
designed for structured domains such as news, to assess the quality of
machine-translated chats. We find that reference-free metrics lag behind
reference-based ones, especially when evaluating translation quality in
out-of-English settings. We then investigate how incorporating conversational
contextual information in these metrics affects their performance. Our findings
show that augmenting neural learned metrics with contextual information helps
improve correlation with human judgments in the reference-free scenario and
when evaluating translations in out-of-English settings. Finally, we propose a
new evaluation metric, Context-MQM, that utilizes bilingual context with a
large language model (LLM) and further validate that adding context helps even
for LLM-based evaluation metrics.
|
[
-0.25025075674057007,
-0.6469220519065857,
0.4254472851753235,
0.4540862441062927,
-0.5804663300514221,
-0.0651736930012703,
-0.5132750272750854,
-0.5049406886100769,
0.16620853543281555,
0.09380578994750977,
-0.27041390538215637,
-0.3589816093444824,
-0.49138814210891724,
0.11177584528923035,
-0.43459999561309814,
1.0515209436416626,
0.20396019518375397,
0.30989232659339905,
-0.6225511431694031,
-0.4035530388355255,
-0.9546087384223938,
-0.6920517683029175,
-0.5580340027809143,
-0.23294492065906525,
0.3272188603878021,
0.39891988039016724,
0.883732795715332,
0.3273283839225769,
0.5751140117645264,
0.30282554030418396,
-0.08257924020290375,
0.4214461147785187,
-0.4412361681461334,
0.1630035638809204,
-0.13839377462863922,
-0.4767667055130005,
-0.5541772246360779,
0.11250291019678116,
0.6427783370018005,
0.8112180829048157,
0.048348989337682724,
0.16334742307662964,
0.395001083612442,
0.6894923448562622,
-0.5287304520606995,
0.2280060201883316,
-0.5002842545509338,
0.027283692732453346,
0.09374067932367325,
-0.6934638023376465,
-0.41648468375205994,
-0.04554753005504608,
0.3740846812725067,
-0.3142271637916565,
-0.09150218218564987,
0.05209191143512726,
0.7211490273475647,
0.33087337017059326,
-0.8222860097885132,
-0.286559522151947,
-0.7402094006538391,
0.7247999906539917,
-0.6727837324142456,
0.542057991027832,
0.35726338624954224,
0.43401214480400085,
-0.25431135296821594,
-0.3497672379016876,
-0.3012043833732605,
-0.213096022605896,
-0.42527371644973755,
0.2846134305000305,
-0.12904053926467896,
-0.17811833322048187,
-0.2686658799648285,
0.3244994580745697,
-0.2294049859046936,
-0.07285270094871521,
-0.3852652907371521,
-0.20827427506446838,
0.5783348083496094,
0.3151420056819916,
0.5567410588264465,
-0.41581788659095764,
-0.3487114906311035,
-0.06425222009420395,
-0.4584376811981201,
0.1827654093503952,
0.06889833509922028,
0.2506842315196991,
-0.2406388521194458,
0.3062092661857605,
-0.19189533591270447,
0.7456753253936768,
-0.24678076803684235,
-0.390774130821228,
0.40873607993125916,
-0.8166887164115906,
-0.06911632418632507,
-0.3440965414047241,
0.8601577877998352,
0.9569430947303772,
0.06547145545482635,
-0.29499131441116333,
0.04044492915272713,
-0.2840854227542877,
0.22027917206287384,
-0.6953195333480835,
0.1724196970462799,
0.02126387692987919,
-0.5248575210571289,
-0.06423617154359818,
0.05125904083251953,
-0.4678110182285309,
0.038015685975551605,
-0.2885318994522095,
0.16219636797904968,
-0.3945024609565735,
0.040032315999269485,
-0.18526270985603333,
-0.249195858836174,
0.17190685868263245,
0.5419620871543884,
-0.6605545878410339,
0.000561076623853296,
0.4552794396877289,
0.8350952863693237,
-0.3893541395664215,
-0.234657883644104,
-0.6095376014709473,
-0.17315208911895752,
-0.5615507364273071,
0.585058867931366,
-0.4659186899662018,
-0.43929407000541687,
-0.1517195701599121,
-0.06472437083721161,
-0.1634795367717743,
-0.3853089213371277,
0.7596628069877625,
-0.4465402662754059,
0.5596080422401428,
-0.03253861889243126,
-0.41673752665519714,
-0.09397760778665543,
0.28461751341819763,
-0.3112999498844147,
0.8579103350639343,
0.10948460549116135,
-0.6502225995063782,
0.5129640102386475,
-0.5335176587104797,
-0.6441981792449951,
0.09278389066457748,
-0.08158715814352036,
0.007525165565311909,
0.27637457847595215,
0.19213922321796417,
0.3096883296966553,
-0.27107274532318115,
0.28422439098358154,
-0.037165138870477676,
-0.5994522571563721,
0.5753117799758911,
-0.6202359199523926,
0.33404430747032166,
0.3347690999507904,
-0.03632505238056183,
0.080906942486763,
-0.36090216040611267,
0.2724899351596832,
-0.47646448016166687,
-0.46575120091438293,
-0.46776220202445984,
0.07457692176103592,
-0.07261694222688675,
0.413442462682724,
0.03911924362182617,
-0.3000028133392334,
-0.2983098030090332,
-0.5261496901512146,
0.5552942752838135,
0.10463196784257889,
0.031431879848241806,
0.7144120335578918,
-0.1735513061285019,
0.21502754092216492,
0.09887292981147766,
0.12018362432718277,
-0.3936578333377838,
-0.5581569075584412,
-0.8627226948738098,
-0.05751051753759384,
0.3276270031929016,
0.5932477116584778,
-0.6450881361961365,
0.7812442779541016,
-0.5001316666603088,
-0.3723776638507843,
-0.32817542552948,
0.20243439078330994,
0.507660984992981,
0.6111544966697693,
0.36680611968040466,
-0.6072094440460205,
-0.4007813632488251,
-0.8085129261016846,
-0.3081745207309723,
-0.05549309402704239,
-0.2411661297082901,
0.615830659866333,
0.3631442189216614,
-0.30501818656921387,
1.0338832139968872,
-0.09798026829957962,
-0.37992408871650696,
-0.10914276540279388,
0.04654065519571304,
0.10979409515857697,
0.4746723771095276,
0.5491116046905518,
-0.5998399257659912,
-0.5385156273841858,
-0.1475236564874649,
-0.636260449886322,
-0.11499270796775818,
-0.17003276944160461,
-0.3600691854953766,
0.08583170175552368,
0.4365851879119873,
-0.5262326002120972,
0.38924291729927063,
0.7318477034568787,
-0.44416213035583496,
0.2796904742717743,
-0.3090696334838867,
0.6036878824234009,
-1.2267072200775146,
0.17199411988258362,
-0.22413964569568634,
-0.4836292564868927,
-0.6619978547096252,
-0.13561856746673584,
0.15481352806091309,
-0.00520208477973938,
-0.7059364318847656,
0.6964041590690613,
-0.2528887391090393,
-0.2584846317768097,
-0.3732030689716339,
0.6687705516815186,
0.24438925087451935,
0.37905436754226685,
-0.07469546794891357,
1.1070979833602905,
0.09477676451206207,
-0.6210881471633911,
0.1681809425354004,
0.4192033112049103,
-0.6325967907905579,
0.8432193994522095,
-0.3819338381290436,
0.1394236832857132,
-0.017329365015029907,
0.49547523260116577,
-1.058731198310852,
-0.05714960768818855,
0.13567106425762177,
-0.79416823387146,
0.21309563517570496,
0.0881267860531807,
-0.4037252366542816,
-0.0073042334988713264,
0.061251480132341385,
0.358675092458725,
0.30241572856903076,
-0.331323504447937,
0.054486144334077835,
0.3770482540130615,
0.17001676559448242,
-0.5385298728942871,
-0.8345668911933899,
0.4425774812698364,
-0.18784822523593903,
-0.7127390503883362,
0.3890421688556671,
-0.10077372193336487,
-0.13874544203281403,
-0.11368127167224884,
-0.21388067305088043,
-0.16942228376865387,
0.39057162404060364,
0.02954717166721821,
0.032821353524923325,
-0.12615984678268433,
0.29239702224731445,
0.0004514171159826219,
-0.1476559340953827,
0.039492856711149216,
-0.20338749885559082,
0.31979647278785706,
-0.39652693271636963,
-0.25108638405799866,
-0.4875001907348633,
0.2444610297679901,
0.5465491414070129,
0.0534709133207798,
0.8842809200286865,
0.5166898369789124,
-0.10451406985521317,
0.1270943135023117,
-0.4666496217250824,
-0.1605221927165985,
-0.3691115379333496,
0.4440666735172272,
-0.25886163115501404,
-0.9427269101142883,
0.4459003508090973,
0.1759035438299179,
-0.14260707795619965,
0.42051827907562256,
0.4224558174610138,
-0.3376055657863617,
1.037411093711853,
0.39463159441947937,
-0.06749485433101654,
0.6549914479255676,
0.08667562156915665,
0.272706538438797,
-1.0527052879333496,
-0.006628294941037893,
-0.32119306921958923,
-0.4372844696044922,
-0.4196712076663971,
-0.585055947303772,
0.5442221164703369,
0.2502588629722595,
0.22344249486923218,
0.39805829524993896,
-0.03152047097682953,
0.5267763137817383,
0.3045352101325989,
0.07025088369846344,
0.5302895307540894,
-0.20681507885456085,
-0.10510484129190445,
-0.19969940185546875,
-0.690668523311615,
-0.6927627921104431,
0.811752438545227,
0.33591970801353455,
0.29182231426239014,
-0.04464409500360489,
0.29809337854385376,
0.23111334443092346,
0.6764695048332214,
-0.8522089123725891,
0.23009032011032104,
-0.04975045844912529,
-0.5835800766944885,
-0.23510807752609253,
-0.6985146999359131,
-0.8553459644317627,
0.6098610162734985,
-0.15263721346855164,
-0.692298948764801,
-0.05292700231075287,
-0.04492797330021858,
-0.25572195649147034,
-0.13430273532867432,
-0.7918317317962646,
0.8630461096763611,
-0.41500645875930786,
-0.13805928826332092,
-0.3043075501918793,
-0.5590258836746216,
0.336734801530838,
-0.062145162373781204,
0.4247831404209137,
-0.2880346477031708,
-0.1765352189540863,
0.714005172252655,
-0.340268611907959,
0.6119735836982727,
0.17349298298358917,
0.005193052813410759,
0.3243945837020874,
0.07421933114528656,
-0.048346128314733505,
0.35422638058662415,
0.013858001679182053,
0.41325637698173523,
0.28513064980506897,
-0.3319871723651886,
-0.9390451908111572,
0.6503963470458984,
-0.7742848992347717,
-0.5873841047286987,
0.02696954272687435,
-0.6161330342292786,
-0.3931931257247925,
0.06954159587621689,
0.12421734631061554,
0.34530776739120483,
-0.3836926221847534,
0.8246583938598633,
0.1161780059337616,
-0.2967151999473572,
0.3512466549873352,
0.6074058413505554,
0.06559227406978607,
-0.48891034722328186,
0.5162475109100342,
-0.15393146872520447,
0.3897884786128998,
0.48808351159095764,
0.19047686457633972,
-0.1686139851808548,
-0.14856117963790894,
-0.6569504737854004,
-0.16613012552261353,
-0.8745702505111694,
-0.3811732828617096,
-0.4324926435947418,
-0.11721827834844589,
-0.04921678081154823,
0.004651828669011593,
-0.4483468532562256,
-0.3867332637310028,
-0.07743601500988007,
0.01419149525463581,
-0.08194330334663391,
0.10169867426156998,
0.16117316484451294,
0.42284247279167175,
-1.149810552597046,
-0.15466849505901337,
0.133855402469635,
0.20396234095096588,
-0.0946778878569603,
-0.7176038026809692,
-0.5410281419754028,
0.4317728281021118,
-0.2752991318702698,
-0.8683103322982788,
0.4451790452003479,
0.30931055545806885,
0.6030018329620361,
0.217396542429924,
-0.09851840883493423,
0.7400057315826416,
-0.5492332577705383,
0.9253472685813904,
0.14399166405200958,
-1.0265570878982544,
0.42688995599746704,
-0.24895529448986053,
0.40622401237487793,
0.775807797908783,
0.08721894025802612,
-0.9721172451972961,
-0.5585025548934937,
-0.33216404914855957,
-0.614544153213501,
0.5040229558944702,
0.485953688621521,
0.6884138584136963,
-0.1745072305202484,
0.5236407518386841,
-0.20891083776950836,
0.4200706481933594,
-0.6457789540290833,
-0.2805139124393463,
-0.13099786639213562,
0.12158992141485214,
-0.42726993560791016,
-0.21903187036514282,
-0.11884523928165436,
-0.47303101420402527,
0.22291243076324463,
-0.0996723547577858,
0.3259640634059906,
0.2540375292301178,
-0.3604598641395569,
-0.012067394331097603,
0.44363313913345337,
0.6618168354034424,
0.7589262127876282,
-0.17787082493305206,
-0.09980829060077667,
0.5369840264320374,
-0.0646255686879158,
0.0010670666815713048,
-0.4490908086299896,
0.019104328006505966,
0.2013038843870163,
0.3738424479961395,
0.7948603630065918,
0.6378690004348755,
-0.5120829343795776,
0.8020837306976318,
-0.29145127534866333,
0.06732747703790665,
-0.09391806274652481,
0.08106891810894012,
0.07023411989212036,
0.07528017461299896,
0.2798099219799042,
0.178338423371315,
0.10404213517904282,
-0.747429609298706,
0.2670568823814392,
0.5451073050498962,
-0.738898515701294,
-0.2862953245639801,
0.3348640203475952,
0.7438265681266785,
-0.38749000430107117,
0.5752999782562256,
-0.017319563776254654,
-0.5654321908950806,
0.4054734706878662,
0.4473450481891632,
0.7822595238685608,
-0.19148552417755127,
-0.04166431352496147,
0.4440661370754242,
0.2233503758907318,
0.24727816879749298,
-0.15250876545906067,
-0.39046111702919006,
-0.866851270198822,
-0.6156805753707886,
-0.46864157915115356,
-0.5197663903236389,
-0.045069511979818344,
-0.35640057921409607,
0.20586887001991272,
0.11147453635931015,
-0.3446645736694336,
-0.4763169586658478,
-0.009804357774555683,
-0.7220268845558167,
0.18502576649188995,
0.04667707532644272,
0.8008243441581726,
-0.6847575902938843,
0.7592487931251526,
0.45160990953445435,
-0.2299918234348297,
-0.30488714575767517,
-0.02290583960711956,
-0.21676205098628998,
-0.41992393136024475,
0.6925318241119385,
0.34309646487236023,
-0.21690528094768524,
-0.27285656332969666,
-0.08354706317186356,
-1.0538400411605835,
1.048079490661621,
0.272832453250885,
-0.15554961562156677,
0.12457828223705292,
0.10222147405147552,
0.9840943813323975,
-0.5386925339698792,
0.6814689040184021,
0.5127261281013489,
0.3446026146411896,
-0.038384780287742615,
-1.2756686210632324,
-0.0731518566608429,
-0.4516056180000305,
0.03503547981381416,
0.03274161368608475,
-0.6605085730552673,
0.38281866908073425,
0.0987863540649414,
-0.4399257004261017,
-0.061297569423913956,
0.64896559715271,
-0.34262189269065857,
0.11492466181516647,
0.532462477684021,
0.11903317272663116,
0.5441125631332397,
-0.15197992324829102,
0.9933615922927856,
-0.7141152024269104,
0.1498001515865326,
1.2631462812423706,
0.08443844318389893,
1.0622282028198242,
0.5638171434402466,
0.1885380744934082,
0.5769133567810059,
0.48870599269866943,
0.3484111726284027,
0.3463073670864105,
-0.019971748813986778,
0.054421134293079376,
-0.07778410613536835,
-0.035137418657541275,
-0.2539651095867157,
0.6705389022827148,
0.5716725587844849,
-0.4511033594608307,
-0.3191923499107361,
0.02295796200633049,
0.02633734419941902,
-0.021945323795080185,
0.1889725774526596,
0.8330804705619812,
0.2321358323097229,
-1.0555976629257202,
0.5976619720458984,
0.25554731488227844,
0.551575779914856,
-0.24428798258304596,
0.2326304316520691,
-0.5122172832489014,
0.13803160190582275,
-0.2200828492641449,
-0.6311402320861816,
0.8209525346755981,
-0.13542750477790833,
0.007847250439226627,
-0.38824859261512756,
0.4649168848991394,
-0.5326399803161621,
0.02049584873020649,
0.3720325231552124,
0.9155443906784058,
0.265156090259552,
-0.1121516078710556,
-0.6182799935340881,
-0.13499082624912262,
-0.3639023005962372,
-0.17478488385677338,
0.38855457305908203,
0.40289223194122314,
-0.09131770581007004,
0.5693674087524414,
0.7194736003875732,
-0.2324487715959549,
-0.3422403931617737,
0.0143131660297513,
0.609391450881958,
-0.6048361659049988,
-0.5477793216705322,
-0.9796989560127258,
0.373557448387146,
-0.1105085089802742,
-0.4944981038570404,
0.9413250684738159,
0.5094260573387146,
0.8835640549659729,
0.15230324864387512,
0.3786115348339081,
0.2167411893606186,
0.3269537091255188,
-0.3986983299255371,
0.8269698023796082,
-0.6122276782989502,
0.23503507673740387,
-0.22108927369117737,
-0.977673351764679,
-0.2835567891597748,
0.540710985660553,
-0.4096875786781311,
-0.12265843152999878,
0.9165578484535217,
0.43364763259887695,
-0.07367635518312454,
-0.09507543593645096,
0.5679861903190613,
-0.18873661756515503,
0.2840796709060669,
0.5423361659049988,
0.9999880194664001,
-0.6543595194816589,
0.7600364685058594,
-0.022607548162341118,
-0.25565260648727417,
-0.3699056804180145,
-1.1060961484909058,
-0.9106994867324829,
-0.6487619280815125,
-0.140096053481102,
-0.2647523880004883,
-0.1158086508512497,
0.7975202798843384,
0.9203690886497498,
-0.6252686977386475,
-0.43516454100608826,
0.178011953830719,
0.15571539103984833,
-0.09491173923015594,
-0.24451255798339844,
0.13311366736888885,
-0.8417875170707703,
-0.7662917971611023,
0.6447869539260864,
0.369022399187088,
-0.11266501992940903,
-0.10668585449457169,
-0.18683631718158722,
0.055837664753198624,
0.06556440889835358,
0.8524787425994873,
-0.08297056704759598,
-0.6342074275016785,
-0.41089436411857605,
-0.03584999218583107,
-0.522825300693512,
0.3116876780986786,
0.7330312132835388,
-0.6102167963981628,
0.5618632435798645,
0.6786653995513916,
0.5914897918701172,
0.3380669951438904,
0.2127687633037567,
1.031237006187439,
-0.9390137195587158,
0.3425266146659851,
-0.006908000912517309,
0.3752395212650299,
0.4903307259082794,
-0.3461746573448181,
0.4647049605846405,
0.17690062522888184,
-0.48296695947647095,
-0.5772361159324646,
-0.07053835690021515,
-0.4764443635940552,
-0.07923530787229538,
1.2272154092788696,
-0.21441951394081116,
-0.27813735604286194,
0.016882313415408134,
-0.263772577047348,
0.17998793721199036,
-0.21701984107494354,
0.7883851528167725,
0.9942649602890015,
-0.07236507534980774,
-0.0508008673787117,
-0.8068640828132629,
0.6507624387741089,
0.6470090746879578,
-0.8441036343574524,
-0.3179365396499634,
0.3975212574005127,
0.19353772699832916,
0.3032592535018921,
0.6711565852165222,
-0.09551656991243362,
0.31946083903312683,
-0.4609642028808594,
-0.35974499583244324,
0.2138383984565735,
-0.23107941448688507,
-0.11729434132575989,
-0.31264403462409973,
-0.09365447610616684,
-0.16384373605251312
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08312v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08312v1
|
StreamingDialogue: Prolonged Dialogue Learning via Long Context Compression with Minimal Losses
| 2024-03-13T07:44:14 | 2024-03-13T07:44:14 |
Jia-Nan Li, Quan Tu, Cunli Mao, Zhengtao Yu, Ji-Rong Wen, Rui Yan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Standard Large Language Models (LLMs) struggle with handling dialogues with
long contexts due to efficiency and consistency issues. According to our
observation, dialogue contexts are highly structured, and the special token of
\textit{End-of-Utterance} (EoU) in dialogues has the potential to aggregate
information. We refer to the EoU tokens as ``conversational attention sinks''
(conv-attn sinks). Accordingly, we introduce StreamingDialogue, which
compresses long dialogue history into conv-attn sinks with minimal losses, and
thus reduces computational complexity quadratically with the number of sinks
(i.e., the number of utterances). Current LLMs already demonstrate the ability
to handle long context window, e.g., a window size of 200k or more. To this
end, by compressing utterances into EoUs, our method has the potential to
handle more than 200k of utterances, resulting in a prolonged dialogue
learning. In order to minimize information losses from reconstruction after
compression, we design two learning strategies of short-memory reconstruction
(SMR) and long-memory reactivation (LMR). Our method outperforms strong
baselines in dialogue tasks and achieves a 4 $\times$ speedup while reducing
memory usage by 18 $\times$ compared to dense attention recomputation.
|
[
-0.387474000453949,
-0.902891218662262,
0.5709739923477173,
-0.0662553533911705,
-0.547551691532135,
0.29021987318992615,
-0.4909718334674835,
-0.2613425552845001,
0.4471982717514038,
0.6197149753570557,
-0.6671581268310547,
-0.15501393377780914,
-0.5145730376243591,
-0.019505538046360016,
-0.2446049004793167,
0.7884030342102051,
0.19222986698150635,
-0.12371601164340973,
-0.33422088623046875,
-0.2277383953332901,
-0.44883376359939575,
-0.5019114017486572,
-1.1767704486846924,
-0.20410150289535522,
0.5177732110023499,
0.33054664731025696,
0.32427623867988586,
0.3264949917793274,
0.06234312057495117,
0.37462371587753296,
-0.25165843963623047,
0.19852612912654877,
-1.258470058441162,
0.37610289454460144,
0.3988126516342163,
-0.35312142968177795,
-0.08531972765922546,
-0.336936891078949,
0.6416361927986145,
0.7811922430992126,
-0.30968043208122253,
0.11083774268627167,
0.3356384038925171,
0.7557598948478699,
-0.5897570848464966,
0.4874548316001892,
-0.3822685182094574,
0.03272818401455879,
-0.025557199493050575,
-0.6801978349685669,
-0.621921718120575,
-0.12197741121053696,
0.375507116317749,
-0.5078450441360474,
0.036749616265296936,
0.1346106380224228,
0.49068060517311096,
0.6491053104400635,
-0.45515450835227966,
-0.047534070909023285,
-0.8326135873794556,
0.8957677483558655,
-0.5869321227073669,
0.48579075932502747,
0.4007359743118286,
0.2719356417655945,
-0.15325604379177094,
-0.646405816078186,
-0.3545345664024353,
-0.04484991356730461,
0.09994231909513474,
0.2989390194416046,
-0.05053551867604256,
0.3728078603744507,
0.4392869472503662,
0.23198038339614868,
-0.434356689453125,
0.03382953628897667,
-0.45853230357170105,
-0.3406623899936676,
0.2242092341184616,
0.21629095077514648,
-0.02131725288927555,
0.020345915108919144,
-0.4393600523471832,
0.2063366025686264,
-0.8810111284255981,
0.25117483735084534,
0.10620387643575668,
0.0791645497083664,
-0.0508568175137043,
0.12525874376296997,
-0.255045622587204,
0.5669078230857849,
-0.06403602659702301,
-0.4263467788696289,
0.04171755164861679,
-0.04085255786776543,
-0.3807154893875122,
0.19243258237838745,
0.6028415560722351,
0.4043462574481964,
-0.04128347337245941,
0.03794580325484276,
-0.006061893422156572,
-0.19776734709739685,
0.10957381129264832,
-1.0130736827850342,
-0.1158294528722763,
0.15609948337078094,
-0.35039469599723816,
-0.07414846122264862,
-0.6049880385398865,
-0.5537243485450745,
-0.13782894611358643,
-0.5753675103187561,
0.25384029746055603,
-0.2384277880191803,
0.056490007787942886,
0.02896873839199543,
0.01912667229771614,
0.10795040428638458,
0.6794036626815796,
-0.6636282801628113,
0.4809078872203827,
0.5283443331718445,
0.8987176418304443,
-0.2014726996421814,
0.16564227640628815,
-0.9170440435409546,
0.1775045096874237,
0.06361889094114304,
0.6477953195571899,
-0.4734918177127838,
-0.584318220615387,
0.1285288780927658,
0.032624900341033936,
0.08622033149003983,
-0.5103800296783447,
0.48018550872802734,
-0.41402533650398254,
0.2902163565158844,
-0.03666044399142265,
-0.9050626754760742,
-0.42574959993362427,
0.031974151730537415,
-0.6179998517036438,
0.6780411601066589,
0.012565738521516323,
-0.45828044414520264,
0.007649383507668972,
-0.40105828642845154,
-0.34529560804367065,
0.1921585649251938,
-0.2395971417427063,
-0.27601444721221924,
0.13362623751163483,
0.09552662819623947,
0.49520376324653625,
-0.23192434012889862,
0.16112342476844788,
-0.20184151828289032,
-0.46694278717041016,
0.08427964895963669,
-0.6546736359596252,
0.5591662526130676,
0.1803237795829773,
-0.224364772439003,
-0.06702994555234909,
-0.36500826478004456,
-0.19565609097480774,
-0.11110883206129074,
-0.42701324820518494,
-0.23377324640750885,
0.2841508984565735,
-0.0678233727812767,
-0.11674974113702774,
-0.16488495469093323,
-0.5557714104652405,
0.01435554027557373,
-0.3088805079460144,
0.8407633304595947,
0.8021804690361023,
-0.01669982261955738,
0.36270421743392944,
-0.24187584221363068,
0.4470118582248688,
0.07428748160600662,
-0.05011693388223648,
-0.5403856039047241,
-0.2693215012550354,
-1.0626423358917236,
-0.418702095746994,
0.1332489252090454,
0.4777591824531555,
-0.9014468193054199,
0.1854410022497177,
-0.6423436403274536,
0.028185879811644554,
-0.20485325157642365,
0.36748331785202026,
0.3650386929512024,
0.7066078186035156,
0.29404738545417786,
-0.3992106318473816,
-0.4906686842441559,
-0.7723814249038696,
0.1621108502149582,
-0.11974309384822845,
-0.03340468183159828,
0.7972997426986694,
0.010980911552906036,
-0.22259388864040375,
0.7901536822319031,
-0.6109464764595032,
-0.21750152111053467,
-0.4465068578720093,
0.18294692039489746,
0.1748722642660141,
0.32315218448638916,
0.2940431833267212,
-0.6176311373710632,
-0.44209417700767517,
-0.40002045035362244,
-0.5970597863197327,
0.08769980818033218,
-0.3386499881744385,
-0.0739036276936531,
0.2843739688396454,
0.7436214089393616,
-0.801604688167572,
0.43454107642173767,
0.6549289226531982,
0.0875191017985344,
0.22115181386470795,
-0.0003654384636320174,
0.06633476167917252,
-1.1089328527450562,
-0.26933276653289795,
-0.16262120008468628,
-0.870983898639679,
-0.7002528309822083,
-0.28277722001075745,
-0.13869597017765045,
-0.5287848114967346,
-0.6998187303543091,
0.6398943066596985,
-0.4609096348285675,
0.19521386921405792,
-0.2940492331981659,
0.2636321187019348,
-0.08413518965244293,
0.974884569644928,
0.30107560753822327,
0.7386883497238159,
0.3670572340488434,
-0.7268974184989929,
0.4200625717639923,
0.05135283246636391,
-0.3630710244178772,
0.2056943029165268,
-0.5854690074920654,
0.3758400082588196,
-0.337264746427536,
0.8324765563011169,
-1.094437837600708,
-0.13590756058692932,
0.05735974758863449,
-0.34627798199653625,
0.5964594483375549,
-0.23686908185482025,
0.020398082211613655,
-0.04707736521959305,
-0.34457966685295105,
0.7055988311767578,
0.6953146457672119,
-0.6368911266326904,
0.7044076323509216,
0.4222638010978699,
-0.6129188537597656,
-0.5042133927345276,
-0.3726098835468292,
0.08867674320936203,
-0.3585469722747803,
-0.5229547023773193,
0.22027745842933655,
-0.19578959047794342,
0.038651637732982635,
-0.3512716293334961,
-0.15797506272792816,
0.005210032686591148,
-0.09400170296430588,
0.3118956983089447,
0.17674371600151062,
-0.07457662373781204,
0.19555851817131042,
0.023165034130215645,
-0.1771157830953598,
-0.07647005468606949,
-0.22834475338459015,
0.671829879283905,
0.14038518071174622,
-0.013554250821471214,
-0.5635392069816589,
0.5102387070655823,
0.4581039845943451,
0.23514945805072784,
0.6183708310127258,
0.3734264671802521,
-0.27035054564476013,
-0.06261695176362991,
-0.7233192324638367,
-0.2731323540210724,
-0.49244165420532227,
0.3144800066947937,
-0.20920991897583008,
-1.4017387628555298,
0.4806283712387085,
-0.2883320450782776,
0.19200417399406433,
0.018951015546917915,
0.32935234904289246,
-0.3845670223236084,
0.7450243830680847,
0.43097275495529175,
-0.44228875637054443,
0.7830885648727417,
-0.4609168469905853,
0.29090356826782227,
-0.9870445728302002,
0.10641619563102722,
-0.20605045557022095,
-0.3366377651691437,
-0.2493356317281723,
-0.6849203705787659,
0.37362730503082275,
-0.05022221431136131,
-0.15112581849098206,
0.13818661868572235,
-0.030280787497758865,
0.5559253096580505,
0.27787622809410095,
0.4100915491580963,
0.07209331542253494,
0.12208011746406555,
0.37896302342414856,
-0.08844196796417236,
-0.671850323677063,
-0.19821462035179138,
0.8775716423988342,
0.4200724959373474,
0.8455632328987122,
0.17444562911987305,
0.8560785055160522,
0.364003986120224,
0.013355318456888199,
-1.1605629920959473,
0.7206814289093018,
0.07960710674524307,
-0.20264463126659393,
-0.4378880262374878,
-0.6549504995346069,
-1.0547300577163696,
0.03390879929065704,
0.22572435438632965,
-0.8564362525939941,
-0.14389269053936005,
0.31561803817749023,
-0.6588824987411499,
0.052127111703157425,
-0.7313681244850159,
0.4291404187679291,
0.03222791850566864,
-0.6294325590133667,
-0.5644040107727051,
-0.716491162776947,
0.24773874878883362,
0.18169905245304108,
0.177071675658226,
-0.07280801981687546,
-0.0270468071103096,
0.6292226314544678,
-0.46688225865364075,
0.9653542041778564,
-0.26195207238197327,
0.08813345432281494,
0.39685311913490295,
0.1305694282054901,
0.5285158157348633,
0.27755382657051086,
0.5330010652542114,
-0.11498168855905533,
-0.2538684904575348,
-0.5006315112113953,
-0.6918507814407349,
0.6471309065818787,
-0.6068695783615112,
-0.6304823756217957,
-0.2725158631801605,
-0.23546452820301056,
-0.18576869368553162,
-0.16044239699840546,
0.1414698362350464,
1.0759137868881226,
-0.25258922576904297,
0.4989674389362335,
1.0574649572372437,
-0.2232666313648224,
0.6847400665283203,
0.22747986018657684,
-0.1492915153503418,
-0.3489089906215668,
0.9562019109725952,
-0.06403535604476929,
0.4047635793685913,
0.43946707248687744,
0.034227270632982254,
-0.2831307053565979,
-0.45230042934417725,
-0.31129637360572815,
0.21506141126155853,
-0.6551067233085632,
-0.36014774441719055,
-0.5835775136947632,
-0.3164951205253601,
-0.1057085171341896,
-0.14666202664375305,
-0.3577739894390106,
-0.35443732142448425,
-0.3155254125595093,
-0.10973718017339706,
0.19097471237182617,
0.20321398973464966,
0.2247985303401947,
0.32500791549682617,
-0.9795828461647034,
0.4064958095550537,
0.5414495468139648,
0.049015164375305176,
-0.016668979078531265,
-0.6929982900619507,
-0.33858436346054077,
0.08492176234722137,
-0.2575320303440094,
-0.570861279964447,
0.42070692777633667,
0.5826499462127686,
0.44816669821739197,
0.7030810117721558,
0.009719714522361755,
0.8944203853607178,
-0.5652624368667603,
0.9533588886260986,
0.400505006313324,
-0.7997375726699829,
0.2867942154407501,
-0.3726787567138672,
0.6342169046401978,
0.5790248513221741,
0.34793156385421753,
-0.7065723538398743,
-0.25738725066185,
-0.5187445282936096,
-1.031822919845581,
0.42929312586784363,
0.23348502814769745,
0.42056068778038025,
-0.04473087191581726,
0.23559559881687164,
0.12910571694374084,
0.22067980468273163,
-0.472023606300354,
-0.0917770117521286,
0.03252897784113884,
-0.027691399678587914,
-0.4238657057285309,
-0.472876638174057,
-0.20019368827342987,
-0.3127564489841461,
0.7100514769554138,
-0.31889399886131287,
0.6111112236976624,
0.22823582589626312,
-0.50001060962677,
0.2865225076675415,
0.19113844633102417,
0.8396837115287781,
0.3987928032875061,
-0.2274497002363205,
0.011589600704610348,
0.2130419760942459,
-0.409441739320755,
0.03848327323794365,
-0.14442098140716553,
-0.032642267644405365,
0.04112839326262474,
0.23385824263095856,
1.1711620092391968,
0.6645100116729736,
-0.7963414788246155,
0.3659631907939911,
-0.3498501479625702,
-0.12096458673477173,
-0.6988955736160278,
-0.1403297483921051,
0.1515641063451767,
0.09227469563484192,
0.337430864572525,
-0.1183050125837326,
0.34415203332901,
-0.690520703792572,
0.03886581212282181,
0.2190333604812622,
-0.3505045175552368,
-0.03397710248827934,
0.30543240904808044,
0.8366819620132446,
-0.21338653564453125,
0.8290855884552002,
-0.07158157229423523,
-0.5827829241752625,
0.17273829877376556,
0.25859928131103516,
0.9021396040916443,
-0.11783435940742493,
-0.00008477409573970363,
0.38096755743026733,
-0.3024836778640747,
0.015263541601598263,
-0.022015489637851715,
-0.6607493162155151,
-0.5695643424987793,
-0.7205319404602051,
-0.5456820726394653,
-0.4021010100841522,
0.2431592494249344,
-0.640880286693573,
-0.028847573325037956,
-0.3706773817539215,
-0.23692837357521057,
-0.30400389432907104,
-0.09196775406599045,
-0.5967935919761658,
-0.04541072994470596,
0.4156937003135681,
0.7815952897071838,
-0.408198744058609,
0.7308552265167236,
0.14246545732021332,
0.06321357935667038,
-0.456703245639801,
-0.2759767174720764,
0.22739197313785553,
-0.6094688177108765,
0.5199735760688782,
0.53594571352005,
-0.5034646391868591,
0.1687532216310501,
-0.6505425572395325,
-0.8406589031219482,
0.9887898564338684,
0.2592054605484009,
-0.9397189617156982,
-0.08679404854774475,
-0.11355112493038177,
0.2832600772380829,
-0.3716456890106201,
0.335603803396225,
0.577451765537262,
0.02483305335044861,
0.20979812741279602,
-0.842365026473999,
-0.21515429019927979,
-0.057933904230594635,
-0.006353170145303011,
0.4019688665866852,
-0.8698514699935913,
0.2630297839641571,
0.01141041424125433,
-0.3880082070827484,
0.11051861941814423,
0.7127130031585693,
-0.06747828423976898,
0.27108803391456604,
0.6024826169013977,
0.644400954246521,
0.6502093076705933,
-0.192596897482872,
0.9237455129623413,
-0.16707146167755127,
0.2948943078517914,
1.2853375673294067,
-0.07138167321681976,
0.996580183506012,
0.7523897886276245,
-0.011832823976874352,
0.38274386525154114,
0.7101070880889893,
0.5899461507797241,
0.6233301162719727,
0.2919866740703583,
-0.6550278067588806,
-0.41347089409828186,
-0.23409825563430786,
-0.042276859283447266,
0.3838580846786499,
0.606874942779541,
-0.1273471862077713,
0.04526396840810776,
0.2713976502418518,
0.1523137390613556,
-0.21198563277721405,
-0.3184034824371338,
1.0788565874099731,
0.36928585171699524,
-0.7257540822029114,
0.8342083692550659,
-0.6727903485298157,
0.6083760261535645,
-0.5953110456466675,
0.06420958042144775,
-0.4221959412097931,
0.08875224739313126,
0.038019370287656784,
-0.33529338240623474,
0.015831593424081802,
-0.21949200332164764,
0.006022776011377573,
-0.35165759921073914,
0.4515264928340912,
-0.6414915919303894,
-0.15689873695373535,
0.24365867674350739,
0.41592493653297424,
0.354419469833374,
0.046461693942546844,
-0.4951026439666748,
0.24832768738269806,
0.18682464957237244,
-0.4604036509990692,
0.37363603711128235,
0.07692976295948029,
0.35241174697875977,
0.9315122365951538,
0.48095226287841797,
-0.162926584482193,
0.004498298745602369,
0.24354545772075653,
1.034115195274353,
-0.6630629301071167,
-0.4462409019470215,
-0.6011819243431091,
0.4990536570549011,
-0.26546624302864075,
-0.04872576519846916,
0.3511233627796173,
0.7004550099372864,
0.8080641627311707,
0.09494296461343765,
0.698725700378418,
0.1781635731458664,
0.4621346592903137,
-0.8656732439994812,
0.32024163007736206,
-0.4743511974811554,
0.04644648730754852,
0.10499168187379837,
-0.9183472990989685,
0.07086985558271408,
0.49164220690727234,
0.0028474139980971813,
-0.23939621448516846,
0.871282160282135,
0.6443905830383301,
-0.05033189803361893,
0.0855649784207344,
0.3887556493282318,
0.14916227757930756,
0.36995023488998413,
0.9311215281486511,
0.9256780743598938,
-0.27381524443626404,
0.5762881636619568,
-0.15794934332370758,
-0.1861732006072998,
-0.4259171783924103,
-0.7165276408195496,
-0.9925310015678406,
-0.5090630650520325,
-0.4009847939014435,
-0.18011413514614105,
0.14409087598323822,
1.0306711196899414,
0.9281460642814636,
-0.48662668466567993,
-0.44473108649253845,
0.0654635801911354,
-0.13968154788017273,
-0.010696347802877426,
-0.18560068309307098,
0.1615980714559555,
-0.42035365104675293,
-0.8508471250534058,
0.5324947237968445,
0.40543466806411743,
0.05549420043826103,
-0.2240377813577652,
-0.3366759717464447,
0.019588520750403404,
0.17815442383289337,
0.8860834836959839,
0.47993382811546326,
-0.6424891352653503,
-0.41241729259490967,
-0.208787739276886,
0.06588968634605408,
0.219646155834198,
1.0961283445358276,
-0.9349222779273987,
0.6172771453857422,
0.5259021520614624,
0.7390092611312866,
1.0369328260421753,
0.11919128149747849,
0.6971936225891113,
-0.6356852054595947,
0.4900043308734894,
0.3280816078186035,
0.5572589635848999,
0.26617881655693054,
-0.23659683763980865,
0.38028663396835327,
0.09458676725625992,
-0.8005106449127197,
-0.7697429060935974,
0.3115319609642029,
-1.3427495956420898,
-0.20268474519252777,
1.104216456413269,
-0.2768286466598511,
-0.24908971786499023,
-0.2059197872877121,
-0.4365960657596588,
0.27342212200164795,
-0.785754919052124,
0.692390501499176,
0.6934624314308167,
-0.3103466331958771,
-0.5344838500022888,
-0.7284179329872131,
0.7357507944107056,
0.5125051736831665,
-0.5619538426399231,
0.15076960623264313,
0.7363274097442627,
0.12312602996826172,
-0.017872728407382965,
0.7322455048561096,
0.33596089482307434,
0.2856355905532837,
-0.2033700942993164,
-0.4562477767467499,
0.046613529324531555,
-0.4021756947040558,
-0.21388694643974304,
0.006770150735974312,
-0.1778513342142105,
-0.007201131898909807
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08305v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08305v1
|
Towards Personalized Evaluation of Large Language Models with An Anonymous Crowd-Sourcing Platform
| 2024-03-13T07:31:20 | 2024-03-13T07:31:20 |
Mingyue Cheng, Hao Zhang, Jiqian Yang, Qi Liu, Li Li, Xin Huang, Liwei Song, Zhi Li, Zhenya Huang, Enhong Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language model evaluation plays a pivotal role in the enhancement of
its capacity. Previously, numerous methods for evaluating large language models
have been proposed in this area. Despite their effectiveness, these existing
works mainly focus on assessing objective questions, overlooking the capability
to evaluate subjective questions which is extremely common for large language
models. Additionally, these methods predominantly utilize centralized datasets
for evaluation, with question banks concentrated within the evaluation
platforms themselves. Moreover, the evaluation processes employed by these
platforms often overlook personalized factors, neglecting to consider the
individual characteristics of both the evaluators and the models being
evaluated. To address these limitations, we propose a novel anonymous
crowd-sourcing evaluation platform, BingJian, for large language models that
employs a competitive scoring mechanism where users participate in ranking
models based on their performance. This platform stands out not only for its
support of centralized evaluations to assess the general capabilities of models
but also for offering an open evaluation gateway. Through this gateway, users
have the opportunity to submit their questions, testing the models on a
personalized and potentially broader range of capabilities. Furthermore, our
platform introduces personalized evaluation scenarios, leveraging various forms
of human-computer interaction to assess large language models in a manner that
accounts for individual user preferences and contexts. The demonstration of
BingJian can be accessed at https://github.com/Mingyue-Cheng/Bingjian.
|
[
-0.39034661650657654,
-0.6051298975944519,
0.45860862731933594,
0.47992071509361267,
-0.09152856469154358,
0.3223647177219391,
-0.8421448469161987,
-0.33269768953323364,
0.2011837363243103,
0.6450811624526978,
-0.3482717275619507,
-0.7161107659339905,
-0.2573257088661194,
0.014582451432943344,
-0.37598463892936707,
0.9330300092697144,
0.23446327447891235,
0.06842715293169022,
-0.18837817013263702,
-0.4094981849193573,
-0.36228692531585693,
-0.41166403889656067,
-0.7342290878295898,
0.11726927012205124,
0.3848694860935211,
0.323750376701355,
0.5697481036186218,
0.40196582674980164,
0.32602593302726746,
0.42204079031944275,
0.1032646968960762,
-0.049388375133275986,
-0.5947162508964539,
0.3246689736843109,
-0.5093997120857239,
-0.1425960659980774,
-0.20321296155452728,
0.04475737735629082,
0.7148428559303284,
0.8308058381080627,
-0.231207013130188,
0.7504955530166626,
0.13936516642570496,
0.5415395498275757,
-0.7419402599334717,
0.1902482509613037,
-0.7609367370605469,
-0.17669503390789032,
-0.39029771089553833,
0.10501225292682648,
-0.5709161758422852,
-0.5650772452354431,
0.30788740515708923,
-0.38097938895225525,
-0.0037731884513050318,
0.14949990808963776,
0.6485385298728943,
-0.168181911110878,
-0.2549043595790863,
-0.2527677118778229,
-0.6419621706008911,
0.6642226576805115,
-0.5775729417800903,
0.33475300669670105,
0.4569363594055176,
0.7192198634147644,
0.17627477645874023,
-0.7452082633972168,
-0.3178820312023163,
-0.8086544871330261,
-0.03792460635304451,
0.05867648124694824,
-0.39339491724967957,
-0.11627281457185745,
-0.20559468865394592,
0.2127407342195511,
-0.8707609176635742,
0.25505581498146057,
-0.2591319680213928,
-0.1825798898935318,
0.6192784905433655,
0.1833738088607788,
0.25138723850250244,
-0.16277781128883362,
-0.2764948010444641,
0.20255045592784882,
-0.18360386788845062,
0.09979158639907837,
0.6825791001319885,
0.5237852931022644,
-0.02850046008825302,
0.36035099625587463,
-0.5298553705215454,
0.8809425234794617,
0.25192371010780334,
0.27913105487823486,
0.23622077703475952,
-0.14582420885562897,
-0.11766363680362701,
-0.08330003172159195,
0.8815091252326965,
0.020107831805944443,
0.10279981046915054,
-0.32897937297821045,
-0.237176313996315,
-0.4321640729904175,
0.0979667603969574,
-0.8207201361656189,
-0.18109643459320068,
0.23583099246025085,
-0.8006972670555115,
-0.6446985602378845,
0.22804445028305054,
-0.8255276679992676,
-0.7434552311897278,
-0.16590674221515656,
0.3948705494403839,
0.08494347333908081,
-0.3301841616630554,
0.08498122543096542,
-0.033146265894174576,
-0.22217456996440887,
0.47090792655944824,
-0.8095129728317261,
0.5701531767845154,
0.7162856459617615,
0.9227902293205261,
-0.16954010725021362,
-0.2648310661315918,
-1.1060643196105957,
-0.09744301438331604,
-0.30769455432891846,
0.5677514672279358,
-1.038267731666565,
-0.1269288808107376,
0.030776020139455795,
-0.05108052119612694,
0.17858882248401642,
-0.693337619304657,
0.40579769015312195,
-0.7164938449859619,
0.29031726717948914,
-0.29379913210868835,
-0.28272882103919983,
-0.13437557220458984,
0.2897147238254547,
-0.668767511844635,
0.7083901762962341,
0.10084991157054901,
-0.5611470937728882,
0.1886572241783142,
-0.7743185758590698,
-0.1273970603942871,
0.6685113310813904,
-0.14465932548046112,
-0.013976462185382843,
0.02800247259438038,
0.17965470254421234,
0.5529661774635315,
-0.4767604470252991,
0.6232298612594604,
-0.7345440983772278,
-0.3681275248527527,
0.32999932765960693,
-0.45311957597732544,
0.9370750188827515,
0.3319622874259949,
-0.6026151180267334,
0.6711225509643555,
-0.8272897601127625,
0.08507075160741806,
0.11069698631763458,
-0.43036624789237976,
-0.6153548359870911,
-0.1812708079814911,
0.4836067259311676,
0.028888242319226265,
0.5613707900047302,
-0.4654976725578308,
0.18262061476707458,
-0.4033510386943817,
0.33915475010871887,
1.2439988851547241,
-0.14423929154872894,
0.2571166753768921,
0.08972588181495667,
0.647034227848053,
-0.4174245595932007,
0.1980055719614029,
-0.046760477125644684,
-0.38253509998321533,
-0.6955008506774902,
-0.03850456699728966,
0.44809600710868835,
0.30232760310173035,
-0.37289050221443176,
0.5658453106880188,
-0.31206968426704407,
-0.7959152460098267,
-0.6779063940048218,
0.40002667903900146,
0.4058474600315094,
0.2230752557516098,
0.01620504818856716,
-0.34143832325935364,
-0.44513019919395447,
-0.8664819002151489,
-0.34315061569213867,
-0.22328634560108185,
-0.23145537078380585,
0.6602226495742798,
0.34562376141548157,
0.007329155225306749,
0.8382218480110168,
-0.4931289255619049,
-0.22609075903892517,
-0.34103819727897644,
0.018101586028933525,
0.13388028740882874,
0.33833858370780945,
0.3632720410823822,
-0.6987349987030029,
-0.7428774237632751,
0.41874685883522034,
-0.4771360456943512,
-0.3657938241958618,
-0.04868703335523605,
-0.22777995467185974,
-0.14865069091320038,
0.33117151260375977,
-0.38972747325897217,
-0.0834851935505867,
0.9553682208061218,
-0.45267805457115173,
0.8368244767189026,
-0.06225156411528587,
0.14447061717510223,
-1.0543296337127686,
0.5680546164512634,
-0.020450813695788383,
-0.4093298316001892,
-0.33409836888313293,
0.4625452160835266,
-0.13426364958286285,
-0.43054771423339844,
-0.23682984709739685,
1.008676290512085,
-0.2729427218437195,
-0.21149559319019318,
-0.11450100690126419,
0.614065408706665,
-0.11454075574874878,
0.29619574546813965,
-0.1368960440158844,
0.5689387321472168,
0.5098379850387573,
-0.21110840141773224,
0.6482800245285034,
0.0884135439991951,
-0.7409095764160156,
0.3234715163707733,
-0.8636505603790283,
0.42223504185676575,
0.15863198041915894,
0.357710599899292,
-0.8888578414916992,
-0.3117452561855316,
0.2534550428390503,
-0.42938539385795593,
-0.05739400163292885,
-0.23683850467205048,
-0.27255117893218994,
-0.22182899713516235,
-0.32532384991645813,
0.2039211392402649,
0.28580430150032043,
-0.7748153805732727,
0.25032946467399597,
0.44385284185409546,
-0.28341004252433777,
-0.5807792544364929,
-0.3759818375110626,
0.5528034567832947,
-0.2606934607028961,
-0.8788758516311646,
0.06329454481601715,
-0.20249611139297485,
-0.5311623811721802,
0.06211415305733681,
0.25886908173561096,
-0.08377061784267426,
0.20450982451438904,
0.12850846350193024,
0.10235879570245743,
-0.265261173248291,
0.1755097508430481,
0.00794961117208004,
-0.059191372245550156,
-0.1334497183561325,
-0.5956055521965027,
0.779914915561676,
-0.4875985085964203,
-0.2407190203666687,
-0.3612285256385803,
0.1447886973619461,
0.4820520877838135,
-0.8020497560501099,
0.6626284122467041,
0.8674893975257874,
-0.32354578375816345,
-0.3740484118461609,
-0.8465448617935181,
0.09516850858926773,
-0.5506505966186523,
0.6075935959815979,
-0.17534179985523224,
-1.1930348873138428,
0.45598432421684265,
-0.04398547112941742,
-0.0494573675096035,
0.2576410174369812,
1.056392788887024,
0.41663312911987305,
1.0430936813354492,
0.49592509865760803,
-0.31925928592681885,
0.18889884650707245,
0.07501862943172455,
-0.028377091512084007,
-0.6761635541915894,
-0.2081371694803238,
-0.7169249057769775,
-0.22440288960933685,
-0.45990902185440063,
-0.39484795928001404,
0.280156672000885,
-0.1339762955904007,
-0.30656296014785767,
0.15821340680122375,
-0.36541610956192017,
0.49013805389404297,
0.5545937418937683,
-0.03423301503062248,
0.4028465151786804,
-0.1481076031923294,
-0.1388479620218277,
0.1442200094461441,
-0.2674926221370697,
-0.643548309803009,
0.9874472618103027,
0.34153902530670166,
0.6839576959609985,
0.15559382736682892,
0.5613332986831665,
0.50863116979599,
0.44689279794692993,
-0.6323389410972595,
0.6567925214767456,
-0.1952279508113861,
-0.7208155393600464,
-0.49221935868263245,
-0.6340606808662415,
-0.9985688328742981,
0.3992036283016205,
0.004211812280118465,
-1.0425115823745728,
-0.046996183693408966,
-0.07717227935791016,
-0.4268966615200043,
0.22640174627304077,
-0.7501937747001648,
1.1001496315002441,
-0.3333517611026764,
-0.37059053778648376,
-0.3646717667579651,
-0.4319738745689392,
0.5903391242027283,
-0.19494116306304932,
0.1491500586271286,
-0.004172078799456358,
-0.11603232473134995,
0.6424680352210999,
-0.4445703625679016,
0.8258311748504639,
-0.41267716884613037,
0.20707225799560547,
0.16823866963386536,
0.3133164048194885,
0.5832858681678772,
0.26065701246261597,
-0.38803863525390625,
0.3066592514514923,
-0.2624792754650116,
-0.21905231475830078,
-0.6851649880409241,
1.2226579189300537,
-0.6623846292495728,
-0.6804847717285156,
-0.01058046892285347,
-0.09721090644598007,
-0.4437968134880066,
0.41477441787719727,
-0.057556331157684326,
0.2849600911140442,
-0.38172855973243713,
0.42550867795944214,
0.0850776806473732,
-0.5898961424827576,
0.21402029693126678,
0.6333333849906921,
-0.5892691612243652,
-0.4886128604412079,
0.9868696331977844,
-0.16305963695049286,
0.04005987197160721,
0.26372572779655457,
0.7086023688316345,
-0.2355058640241623,
-0.5059508085250854,
-0.6714216470718384,
-0.00009626510291127488,
-0.7124388813972473,
0.09258940070867538,
-0.5947483777999878,
0.2151283174753189,
-0.4437532424926758,
-0.09128442406654358,
-0.4721815288066864,
-0.16661794483661652,
0.1273839771747589,
-0.11898616701364517,
-0.09951329976320267,
0.5854783654212952,
0.13077232241630554,
-0.16666071116924286,
-0.8209760785102844,
0.01502997800707817,
0.4303135275840759,
0.671392560005188,
0.46901533007621765,
-0.3963322043418884,
-0.25086167454719543,
-0.10845009982585907,
-0.01420834194868803,
-0.5847838521003723,
0.16184543073177338,
0.090786874294281,
0.5274368524551392,
0.7130484580993652,
0.00733551662415266,
0.7075303196907043,
-0.39518168568611145,
0.7574177980422974,
0.03734506294131279,
-1.3025624752044678,
0.35412970185279846,
-0.46525445580482483,
0.09920050203800201,
0.8472000360488892,
0.2356986701488495,
-0.8642439842224121,
-0.3970341384410858,
-0.21757404506206512,
-0.6637250781059265,
0.7306843996047974,
0.15272147953510284,
0.39593929052352905,
0.2609700560569763,
0.10586971789598465,
0.3802616596221924,
0.2962547242641449,
-0.8645707964897156,
-0.002960272366181016,
-0.009502655826508999,
-0.07559740543365479,
-0.1459454596042633,
-0.05232774466276169,
0.05798700824379921,
-0.1574193388223648,
0.5661739110946655,
-0.023576965555548668,
-0.38499516248703003,
-0.21314683556556702,
-0.08494683355093002,
-0.1399301141500473,
0.19019298255443573,
0.31614458560943604,
0.7551178932189941,
-0.20877741277217865,
-0.1644441932439804,
0.08480294793844223,
-0.37639671564102173,
-0.09734182059764862,
0.13231945037841797,
-0.27746227383613586,
0.03162943571805954,
0.2657164931297302,
0.7965441346168518,
0.13733994960784912,
-1.100645899772644,
0.7131072878837585,
-0.1646374762058258,
0.15073157846927643,
-0.4860735535621643,
-0.1701778620481491,
0.2623167932033539,
0.3083478808403015,
0.33992135524749756,
0.1255805641412735,
0.35828372836112976,
-0.336182564496994,
-0.04083054140210152,
0.3213598132133484,
-0.5775769352912903,
-0.4156253933906555,
0.698152482509613,
0.4489328861236572,
-0.2785494029521942,
0.6014247536659241,
-0.26699909567832947,
-0.3247016966342926,
0.31186822056770325,
0.2886927127838135,
1.2824757099151611,
-0.416398823261261,
0.5057279467582703,
0.3265242278575897,
0.346262127161026,
0.22161194682121277,
-0.24835573136806488,
-0.18759727478027344,
-0.36738213896751404,
-0.30615586042404175,
-0.8090042471885681,
-0.35967427492141724,
0.5470167994499207,
-0.5009901523590088,
0.5617629885673523,
-0.5270913243293762,
0.09305670857429504,
-0.09971702843904495,
-0.0567312054336071,
-0.46447035670280457,
0.020381666719913483,
0.31247633695602417,
0.8437582850456238,
-0.40201473236083984,
0.6117640733718872,
0.7229118347167969,
-0.24615898728370667,
-0.6301432251930237,
0.1388472020626068,
-0.11081493645906448,
-0.7048599720001221,
0.7179577946662903,
0.3170839846134186,
-0.11420098692178726,
-0.2239556759595871,
-0.47743353247642517,
-0.8558692932128906,
0.7556731104850769,
0.4801783263683319,
-0.5418652892112732,
0.12936636805534363,
0.01618315652012825,
0.6498544216156006,
-0.28539904952049255,
0.37716934084892273,
0.2273101508617401,
0.7150775194168091,
-0.22511669993400574,
-0.9967206716537476,
0.25969260931015015,
-0.5347151160240173,
-0.029768381267786026,
-0.148047536611557,
-0.9262357354164124,
0.6504278182983398,
-0.14896151423454285,
-0.12859125435352325,
0.23226265609264374,
0.39762964844703674,
0.1886979341506958,
0.3078274130821228,
0.7491434812545776,
0.14609922468662262,
0.857906699180603,
0.34866994619369507,
1.0159034729003906,
-0.4043196439743042,
0.47189775109291077,
1.1971555948257446,
-0.46029385924339294,
0.9963731169700623,
-0.061968784779310226,
-0.17774395644664764,
0.5187433958053589,
0.5557371973991394,
-0.2294292002916336,
0.3185168206691742,
0.5303216576576233,
-0.18015839159488678,
-0.40666407346725464,
-0.0882115364074707,
-0.2194487750530243,
0.8526157140731812,
-0.018362414091825485,
-0.3678261935710907,
-0.26335373520851135,
0.05949562415480614,
0.028512397781014442,
0.20717790722846985,
-0.3186163604259491,
0.44604411721229553,
-0.22562433779239655,
-0.6231956481933594,
0.42308568954467773,
0.6085677146911621,
0.5247459411621094,
-0.7955933213233948,
0.14573872089385986,
-0.2242542952299118,
0.11184953153133392,
-0.1798553168773651,
-0.30241039395332336,
0.04734883829951286,
0.2790795564651489,
0.18204769492149353,
-0.1698041558265686,
0.7831432819366455,
-0.3613846004009247,
-0.5393458604812622,
0.3100156784057617,
0.35436785221099854,
0.15545357763767242,
-0.4726557433605194,
-0.8019334673881531,
0.23591382801532745,
-0.10878060758113861,
-0.5188130140304565,
0.4726737141609192,
0.06071322411298752,
-0.22330942749977112,
0.8425808548927307,
0.8093030452728271,
0.028036028146743774,
-0.25576719641685486,
0.3905426263809204,
0.7721083760261536,
-0.4354444146156311,
-0.7602022290229797,
-0.8734357953071594,
0.27533382177352905,
-0.1621956080198288,
-0.5478441119194031,
1.0287773609161377,
0.8967035412788391,
0.8284488320350647,
-0.19223009049892426,
1.147628903388977,
0.020836839452385902,
0.5453464984893799,
-0.18278329074382782,
1.123498558998108,
-0.5231077671051025,
0.28374871611595154,
-0.5982547402381897,
-0.9692605137825012,
-0.09058098495006561,
0.3353443443775177,
-0.39008888602256775,
0.2350134551525116,
0.2896289825439453,
0.5654088258743286,
-0.04536963626742363,
-0.10782646387815475,
0.4542476534843445,
0.4815292954444885,
0.5165098309516907,
0.3095678985118866,
0.8967418074607849,
0.09836620837450027,
0.7599081993103027,
-0.24073253571987152,
-0.5383875370025635,
-0.3071994185447693,
-0.6343110799789429,
-0.9953058958053589,
-0.7705237865447998,
-0.09022274613380432,
-0.28255459666252136,
0.0019142435630783439,
1.2383495569229126,
0.8126590251922607,
-0.8342373371124268,
-0.6383209824562073,
0.15559302270412445,
-0.027452411130070686,
-0.04107324779033661,
-0.34976857900619507,
0.4879467785358429,
-0.2181747704744339,
-0.9719854593276978,
0.4977182447910309,
0.5393420457839966,
-0.6002576351165771,
-0.8563625812530518,
-0.014771486632525921,
0.17898708581924438,
-0.009695912711322308,
0.5679857134819031,
0.06394370645284653,
-0.7392054796218872,
-0.12814198434352875,
0.1122685894370079,
-0.03551550954580307,
-0.43928050994873047,
0.8023666739463806,
-0.8452330827713013,
0.7916105389595032,
0.31303441524505615,
0.8188056945800781,
0.35150185227394104,
0.19300881028175354,
0.4819093644618988,
-0.4240737557411194,
0.04870005324482918,
0.36540064215660095,
0.14417755603790283,
0.3959347903728485,
-0.39663204550743103,
0.24037761986255646,
0.1542426198720932,
-0.42343366146087646,
-0.9093015789985657,
-0.0738644152879715,
-0.9209213852882385,
-0.28130754828453064,
1.3178125619888306,
-0.48907241225242615,
0.029337482526898384,
-0.06715958565473557,
-0.335595965385437,
-0.20359565317630768,
-0.4338710308074951,
1.139744758605957,
0.8625912070274353,
0.31008389592170715,
0.3452998995780945,
-0.671004056930542,
0.09760869294404984,
0.24332231283187866,
-0.8349935412406921,
0.33218711614608765,
0.43154558539390564,
0.34590157866477966,
0.009513488039374352,
0.5656768083572388,
-0.06862730532884598,
0.14774109423160553,
-0.17130175232887268,
-0.1558697521686554,
-0.20759141445159912,
-0.08579056710004807,
-0.3707592785358429,
0.4766882658004761,
0.08587219566106796,
-0.0371742807328701
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08295v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08295v4
|
Gemma: Open Models Based on Gemini Research and Technology
| 2024-03-13T06:59:16 | 2024-04-16T12:52:47 |
Gemma Team, Thomas Mesnard, Cassidy Hardin, Robert Dadashi, Surya Bhupatiraju, Shreya Pathak, Laurent Sifre, Morgane Rivière, Mihir Sanjay Kale, Juliette Love, Pouya Tafti, Léonard Hussenot, Pier Giuseppe Sessa, Aakanksha Chowdhery, Adam Roberts, Aditya Barua, Alex Botev, Alex Castro-Ros, Ambrose Slone, Amélie Héliou, Andrea Tacchetti, Anna Bulanova, Antonia Paterson, Beth Tsai, Bobak Shahriari, Charline Le Lan, Christopher A. Choquette-Choo, Clément Crepy, Daniel Cer, Daphne Ippolito, David Reid, Elena Buchatskaya, Eric Ni, Eric Noland, Geng Yan, George Tucker, George-Christian Muraru, Grigory Rozhdestvenskiy, Henryk Michalewski, Ian Tenney, Ivan Grishchenko, Jacob Austin, James Keeling, Jane Labanowski, Jean-Baptiste Lespiau, Jeff Stanway, Jenny Brennan, Jeremy Chen, Johan Ferret, Justin Chiu, Justin Mao-Jones, Katherine Lee, Kathy Yu, Katie Millican, Lars Lowe Sjoesund, Lisa Lee, Lucas Dixon, Machel Reid, Maciej Mikuła, Mateo Wirth, Michael Sharman, Nikolai Chinaev, Nithum Thain, Olivier Bachem, Oscar Chang, Oscar Wahltinez, Paige Bailey, Paul Michel, Petko Yotov, Rahma Chaabouni, Ramona Comanescu, Reena Jana, Rohan Anil, Ross McIlroy, Ruibo Liu, Ryan Mullins, Samuel L Smith, Sebastian Borgeaud, Sertan Girgin, Sholto Douglas, Shree Pandya, Siamak Shakeri, Soham De, Ted Klimenko, Tom Hennigan, Vlad Feinberg, Wojciech Stokowiec, Yu-hui Chen, Zafarali Ahmed, Zhitao Gong, Tris Warkentin, Ludovic Peran, Minh Giang, Clément Farabet, Oriol Vinyals, Jeff Dean, Koray Kavukcuoglu, Demis Hassabis, Zoubin Ghahramani, Douglas Eck, Joelle Barral, Fernando Pereira, Eli Collins, Armand Joulin, Noah Fiedel, Evan Senter, Alek Andreev, Kathleen Kenealy
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This work introduces Gemma, a family of lightweight, state-of-the art open
models built from the research and technology used to create Gemini models.
Gemma models demonstrate strong performance across academic benchmarks for
language understanding, reasoning, and safety. We release two sizes of models
(2 billion and 7 billion parameters), and provide both pretrained and
fine-tuned checkpoints. Gemma outperforms similarly sized open models on 11 out
of 18 text-based tasks, and we present comprehensive evaluations of safety and
responsibility aspects of the models, alongside a detailed description of model
development. We believe the responsible release of LLMs is critical for
improving the safety of frontier models, and for enabling the next wave of LLM
innovations.
|
[
-0.08597706258296967,
-0.8411914110183716,
0.46627846360206604,
0.3799554705619812,
0.047411464154720306,
-0.3956616222858429,
-0.0542803592979908,
-0.6518766283988953,
0.25338515639305115,
0.6182271242141724,
-0.3858691155910492,
-0.5242089033126831,
-0.8522762060165405,
-0.10174747556447983,
-0.6736708283424377,
0.9222484827041626,
-0.11722110211849213,
0.4544222354888916,
-0.1819925457239151,
0.07380779832601547,
-0.24416224658489227,
-0.42351382970809937,
-0.8215594291687012,
-0.2544157803058624,
0.6302109956741333,
0.3289715051651001,
1.2974010705947876,
0.6571367979049683,
0.9458072781562805,
0.17833834886550903,
-0.5274950265884399,
0.17114874720573425,
-0.5990703701972961,
-0.19701087474822998,
-0.2929236888885498,
-0.48423972725868225,
-0.6968175768852234,
0.21121203899383545,
0.5206020474433899,
0.5796725749969482,
-0.13023710250854492,
0.3469466269016266,
0.13653315603733063,
0.3686240613460541,
-0.9513925313949585,
0.20356722176074982,
-0.4311150014400482,
0.11222546547651291,
-0.37933430075645447,
-0.04917740821838379,
-0.6935649514198303,
-0.25429946184158325,
-0.14959226548671722,
-0.7489103674888611,
0.18667414784431458,
0.08282099664211273,
0.8223996758460999,
0.27602243423461914,
-0.4786916673183441,
-0.34259963035583496,
-0.7852198481559753,
0.7264325618743896,
-0.43093928694725037,
0.129875048995018,
0.11539211869239807,
0.4605444669723511,
-0.5406633615493774,
-1.310651421546936,
-0.26296499371528625,
-0.34125953912734985,
0.13672684133052826,
0.11111008375883102,
0.001310724182985723,
0.03774247691035271,
-0.3072512447834015,
0.5764663219451904,
-0.24328447878360748,
0.298181414604187,
-0.6412832140922546,
-0.002924367319792509,
0.5228191614151001,
0.6038914918899536,
0.29066336154937744,
0.3354814052581787,
-0.4967665672302246,
0.07480611652135849,
-1.137986421585083,
-0.22137868404388428,
0.22392232716083527,
0.3631919324398041,
-0.415005087852478,
1.029478669166565,
-0.03417770937085152,
0.6151471138000488,
0.06532372534275055,
-0.16121044754981995,
-0.20610707998275757,
-0.24458065629005432,
-0.3887858986854553,
-0.11700859665870667,
0.8895047903060913,
0.050201285630464554,
0.07304783910512924,
-0.2650160491466522,
0.06191180646419525,
-0.05703582987189293,
0.5730432868003845,
-0.9508728384971619,
-0.1202237606048584,
0.38024887442588806,
-0.8426685333251953,
-0.6154443621635437,
0.0744781419634819,
-0.4563499689102173,
-0.466404527425766,
-0.045678965747356415,
0.7497367262840271,
-0.3347717523574829,
-0.4688757658004761,
0.6484959721565247,
0.07764291763305664,
0.1704598367214203,
0.49023887515068054,
-1.1908326148986816,
0.4811168313026428,
0.7913749814033508,
0.9033567905426025,
-0.14935219287872314,
-0.3201022744178772,
-0.47331756353378296,
0.15169179439544678,
-0.6594769954681396,
0.3378840684890747,
-0.41390886902809143,
-0.8983059525489807,
-0.05296146497130394,
-0.06563545018434525,
-0.12240602821111679,
-0.4402242600917816,
0.585906982421875,
-0.5256683230400085,
0.11813125014305115,
-0.1345306783914566,
-0.2661762237548828,
-0.019892005249857903,
0.1783444583415985,
-0.6600648164749146,
1.1900827884674072,
0.0750260204076767,
-0.9895825386047363,
0.4016852378845215,
-0.8963149785995483,
0.010267142206430435,
0.02759520523250103,
-0.04415135830640793,
-0.21511994302272797,
0.25430235266685486,
0.035951439291238785,
0.4384395182132721,
-0.5772054195404053,
0.35987380146980286,
-0.2871190905570984,
-0.30860358476638794,
0.1933562010526657,
-0.389136403799057,
1.0198593139648438,
0.5668719410896301,
-0.17743489146232605,
0.48361679911613464,
-0.5158807635307312,
-0.26680585741996765,
0.18381036818027496,
-0.37849581241607666,
0.1518084853887558,
0.03266309201717377,
0.12771007418632507,
0.14183929562568665,
0.6480159759521484,
-0.6764012575149536,
-0.10687386244535446,
-0.0707491859793663,
0.3287094235420227,
0.3826231062412262,
-0.28723248839378357,
0.2516910433769226,
-0.4258838891983032,
0.5310421586036682,
0.21994102001190186,
0.7163071036338806,
-0.16040350496768951,
-0.9198965430259705,
-0.7467279434204102,
-0.6496871709823608,
0.26259490847587585,
0.21957987546920776,
-0.3543775975704193,
0.23827284574508667,
-0.035030804574489594,
-0.8253469467163086,
-0.6714744567871094,
-0.1571914404630661,
0.5338286757469177,
0.37359392642974854,
0.35149896144866943,
-0.4125423729419708,
-0.02452564425766468,
-0.7049139738082886,
-0.07725687325000763,
-0.39911559224128723,
0.05579112842679024,
0.17268724739551544,
0.5260978937149048,
-0.3280079960823059,
0.9753318428993225,
-0.46701475977897644,
-0.06571578234434128,
-0.3141994774341583,
0.031679630279541016,
0.0611516609787941,
0.4219364523887634,
0.6685876846313477,
-0.7932198643684387,
-0.041587889194488525,
0.003563469974324107,
-1.0756887197494507,
0.3934890031814575,
0.21770194172859192,
-0.12753544747829437,
0.0010778708383440971,
0.488561749458313,
-0.9296189546585083,
0.5319648385047913,
0.6777466535568237,
-0.5863491296768188,
0.6709140539169312,
-0.36710307002067566,
-0.0342431403696537,
-1.2839224338531494,
0.08662109822034836,
-0.022255051881074905,
-0.13085928559303284,
-0.5012872219085693,
0.7776291370391846,
0.20312952995300293,
-0.29534390568733215,
-1.0453770160675049,
0.8059386014938354,
-0.5151006579399109,
-0.15873423218727112,
-0.08958606421947479,
0.11120864748954773,
0.037823233753442764,
-0.08978835493326187,
0.09850780665874481,
0.8543031215667725,
0.7963795065879822,
-0.7228531837463379,
0.1829862892627716,
0.4379107356071472,
-0.37652871012687683,
-0.09244338423013687,
-0.8701338171958923,
-0.10934808105230331,
-0.16511009633541107,
-0.13331836462020874,
-0.7240269184112549,
-0.397102415561676,
0.1052592545747757,
-0.5617597103118896,
0.31779834628105164,
-0.09267278015613556,
-0.5908138751983643,
-0.252832293510437,
-0.10374991595745087,
0.2745322287082672,
0.5072876811027527,
-0.837120771408081,
0.7976210713386536,
0.5737272500991821,
-0.030404193326830864,
-0.6686204671859741,
-0.537506639957428,
0.09386121481657028,
-0.16718043386936188,
-1.0197365283966064,
0.48611876368522644,
0.08018330484628677,
-0.6059746146202087,
0.09119424223899841,
0.18539370596408844,
-0.19076362252235413,
0.2534388303756714,
0.5083878040313721,
0.46958011388778687,
-0.3011743426322937,
0.02345539629459381,
-0.17044521868228912,
-0.17835204303264618,
0.2021414041519165,
-0.1388157308101654,
0.47028887271881104,
-0.27707555890083313,
-0.31712806224823,
-0.38156425952911377,
-0.1116199865937233,
0.6889504194259644,
-0.21453586220741272,
1.4284234046936035,
0.5550285577774048,
-0.40585947036743164,
-0.07657422125339508,
-0.15810437500476837,
0.03471582755446434,
-0.5407699942588806,
0.19444188475608826,
-0.4748835563659668,
-0.9305835366249084,
0.4115402400493622,
0.07844602316617966,
0.3829335868358612,
0.5613726377487183,
0.9162505269050598,
0.3176156282424927,
0.7378916144371033,
0.9125377535820007,
-0.021733570843935013,
0.14092497527599335,
-0.1377294361591339,
0.14910387992858887,
-0.6102429032325745,
-0.5458242297172546,
-0.8826535940170288,
0.2503274977207184,
-0.35499250888824463,
-0.7646613121032715,
0.4980297088623047,
0.28744685649871826,
-0.3462248146533966,
0.3920482397079468,
-0.45712265372276306,
0.32268112897872925,
0.6120743751525879,
0.14592938125133514,
0.44938337802886963,
-0.4881186783313751,
-0.4260440468788147,
0.26865220069885254,
-0.6601731181144714,
-0.9273631572723389,
1.4168583154678345,
0.6799695491790771,
1.160914421081543,
0.3847247362136841,
0.6077726483345032,
0.0450705960392952,
0.6777616143226624,
-0.7409003973007202,
0.6229976415634155,
-0.11678750813007355,
-1.2033792734146118,
-0.20359916985034943,
-0.4199781119823456,
-0.8126758337020874,
0.1385824978351593,
-0.4328152537345886,
-0.6260722279548645,
-0.2317402958869934,
0.16615767776966095,
-0.11505580693483353,
0.5369538068771362,
-0.3352307081222534,
0.7295069098472595,
0.07492144405841827,
-0.5426045656204224,
-0.4649389386177063,
-0.46005478501319885,
0.8762232065200806,
-0.029522482305765152,
-0.028215555474162102,
-0.05646303668618202,
0.024307748302817345,
0.5096274018287659,
-0.6019492149353027,
0.7939016222953796,
0.08662205934524536,
-0.13693273067474365,
0.695290744304657,
0.2612876296043396,
0.4187997877597809,
0.14519353210926056,
-0.2668198049068451,
0.32398077845573425,
0.06489778310060501,
-0.33777090907096863,
-0.1556001752614975,
0.6584112644195557,
-0.9878577589988708,
-0.5666537880897522,
-0.2504938840866089,
-0.4971734881401062,
0.05799423158168793,
0.03450654074549675,
0.32545652985572815,
0.5880377292633057,
-0.5620323419570923,
0.1560366302728653,
0.7430301308631897,
-0.4370401203632355,
0.5120607614517212,
0.5044012665748596,
-0.6660322546958923,
-0.28950250148773193,
0.39709100127220154,
-0.27701452374458313,
0.37853631377220154,
0.4282310903072357,
0.016344381496310234,
-0.20798064768314362,
-0.9508966207504272,
-0.5410323739051819,
0.22176934778690338,
-0.5382490158081055,
0.2239193469285965,
-0.6462674140930176,
-0.4007837176322937,
-0.325175404548645,
-0.19348172843456268,
-0.734050452709198,
-0.753314733505249,
-0.6265596151351929,
-0.08165287226438522,
0.20248837769031525,
1.2060588598251343,
0.07199779897928238,
0.5017319917678833,
-0.9798443913459778,
0.3744628131389618,
0.04445941001176834,
0.2751413583755493,
-0.21856358647346497,
-0.43238839507102966,
-0.4862685799598694,
-0.1057276800274849,
-0.8861663341522217,
-0.35285019874572754,
0.36586374044418335,
-0.29912304878234863,
0.4323016107082367,
0.6355879902839661,
-0.14530763030052185,
0.6105044484138489,
-0.3746964931488037,
1.173984408378601,
0.45705679059028625,
-0.90299391746521,
0.2770654559135437,
-0.6849435567855835,
-0.08152361959218979,
0.35213208198547363,
0.6197880506515503,
-0.06736661493778229,
-0.3049202859401703,
-0.591866672039032,
-0.48185354471206665,
0.36064666509628296,
0.3324836492538452,
0.07517531514167786,
-0.44694983959198,
0.5387134552001953,
0.1563846319913864,
-0.06659290939569473,
-0.5934431552886963,
-0.15187875926494598,
0.005750251468271017,
-0.28701886534690857,
-0.19298888742923737,
-0.2946664094924927,
-0.0999113917350769,
0.18280518054962158,
0.748557448387146,
-0.12708960473537445,
0.3472282290458679,
0.14338119328022003,
0.11308339983224869,
-0.2667352557182312,
-0.11005492508411407,
0.4663608968257904,
0.6674664616584778,
-0.3087814748287201,
-0.2096356600522995,
0.008881713263690472,
-0.956868588924408,
0.008100563660264015,
-0.21391533315181732,
-0.008390714414417744,
-0.13405731320381165,
0.35558050870895386,
0.267527312040329,
0.1331411451101303,
-0.6946793794631958,
0.6194490790367126,
-0.250906378030777,
-0.12547577917575836,
-0.6664609909057617,
0.5255967378616333,
0.26496925950050354,
0.14372986555099487,
-0.047552693635225296,
0.2405150830745697,
-0.006180265918374062,
-0.7163909077644348,
0.03132365271449089,
0.5272654891014099,
-0.636597216129303,
-0.36934491991996765,
1.3775471448898315,
0.32438424229621887,
-0.21891190111637115,
0.5603742003440857,
0.2279835045337677,
0.3784291446208954,
0.7693931460380554,
0.5794117450714111,
0.8212882280349731,
-0.04208369180560112,
0.17586666345596313,
0.2486676573753357,
0.35708725452423096,
-0.6162064671516418,
0.4636521637439728,
0.4039953351020813,
-0.838739275932312,
-0.3544877767562866,
-0.7586789727210999,
-0.9106091260910034,
-0.047413479536771774,
-0.8997009992599487,
0.6676872968673706,
-0.8425714373588562,
-0.47363603115081787,
-0.1205967590212822,
-0.1391196846961975,
-0.46219101548194885,
0.4181891977787018,
-0.046604156494140625,
1.785908579826355,
-0.42984411120414734,
0.888521671295166,
0.5220575928688049,
-0.4157510995864868,
-0.7260750532150269,
-0.1996210515499115,
0.24969170987606049,
-0.8480907678604126,
0.7275606989860535,
0.20115232467651367,
-0.3862912952899933,
-0.1343492865562439,
-0.4891451597213745,
-1.036482572555542,
1.478710412979126,
0.4596518278121948,
-0.36439114809036255,
-0.27302008867263794,
0.08240038901567459,
0.4054436981678009,
-0.676288366317749,
0.4549410343170166,
0.12987196445465088,
0.1899736225605011,
0.2321150153875351,
-1.064221978187561,
-0.3161905109882355,
-0.19305618107318878,
-0.1727885901927948,
0.43083158135414124,
-1.0309691429138184,
1.2532265186309814,
-0.5370559692382812,
-0.07214979082345963,
0.7395535707473755,
0.6233398914337158,
0.5103405117988586,
0.29145437479019165,
-0.1235940232872963,
0.7120397686958313,
0.5763353705406189,
-0.044308967888355255,
1.2882806062698364,
-0.5432725548744202,
0.2060542106628418,
0.9965619444847107,
-0.5038285851478577,
0.8995063900947571,
0.16116829216480255,
0.044716089963912964,
0.39561763405799866,
0.6662271618843079,
0.4223921597003937,
0.4103701114654541,
0.04118465632200241,
-0.5724156498908997,
-0.02146534062922001,
-0.20453380048274994,
-0.07888232916593552,
0.43160948157310486,
0.5330982804298401,
-0.6417926549911499,
-0.03290750831365585,
-0.4164506494998932,
0.3842281997203827,
-0.0900893583893776,
-0.7366290092468262,
0.49197959899902344,
0.21291399002075195,
-0.5576242804527283,
0.31939929723739624,
0.5023746490478516,
0.306205689907074,
-0.6461235880851746,
0.18400010466575623,
0.08376088738441467,
0.3071591854095459,
-0.2310558259487152,
-0.7072504162788391,
0.42984580993652344,
0.02489304170012474,
0.14375793933868408,
-0.10453367233276367,
0.6998919248580933,
0.14715202152729034,
-0.4634883999824524,
0.6335785984992981,
0.35070645809173584,
0.3602900207042694,
0.25753089785575867,
-0.3237069845199585,
-0.06785370409488678,
-0.326980859041214,
-0.29364141821861267,
0.32833030819892883,
0.30190345644950867,
-0.029166407883167267,
1.1227779388427734,
0.450111448764801,
0.13450175523757935,
0.3207950294017792,
-0.13912448287010193,
0.9349303841590881,
-0.8917161226272583,
-0.2658189833164215,
-0.6866253614425659,
0.7606671452522278,
0.26877561211586,
-0.763441264629364,
0.6980735659599304,
0.6176801323890686,
0.5935110449790955,
-0.1211334690451622,
0.5227113962173462,
0.0669742226600647,
0.3090348541736603,
-0.8329944014549255,
0.6991406083106995,
-0.317716121673584,
0.19178713858127594,
-0.03418103978037834,
-0.866097092628479,
-0.39033564925193787,
0.05857441946864128,
-0.12886835634708405,
0.050789497792720795,
0.7443603277206421,
1.113671898841858,
-0.09785376489162445,
0.3230295181274414,
0.5004234910011292,
0.1253124624490738,
0.32462769746780396,
0.48292165994644165,
0.892501950263977,
-0.3861846923828125,
0.3847339451313019,
0.18370510637760162,
-0.3560146987438202,
-0.24288417398929596,
-0.7505480051040649,
-1.3129020929336548,
-0.2813095450401306,
-0.1648327112197876,
-0.36255887150764465,
0.14672480523586273,
0.6665984392166138,
0.9191439747810364,
-0.42311033606529236,
-0.12973448634147644,
-0.274295449256897,
-0.25568145513534546,
0.06034351512789726,
-0.2058180272579193,
0.09078233689069748,
-0.4590352773666382,
-0.583040714263916,
0.7442463040351868,
0.4799433648586273,
0.11932265013456345,
-0.5030975937843323,
-0.34134113788604736,
0.29087555408477783,
0.4787386655807495,
0.4368588924407959,
-0.030078018084168434,
-0.48618778586387634,
-0.3254258632659912,
-0.16736353933811188,
-0.2865619361400604,
-0.09047650545835495,
0.7259045243263245,
-0.663556694984436,
0.10251016169786453,
0.2931172251701355,
0.4358939826488495,
0.7351855039596558,
-0.17439775168895721,
0.6325556635856628,
-0.24191169440746307,
0.305277019739151,
0.05111076682806015,
0.737589955329895,
0.11839088052511215,
-0.49932539463043213,
0.84456866979599,
-0.2631000280380249,
-0.6821944713592529,
-0.5448022484779358,
0.41471266746520996,
-0.8704745769500732,
-0.3779393434524536,
0.8189456462860107,
-0.41874897480010986,
-0.19427092373371124,
-0.049592964351177216,
0.03811438009142876,
0.07660062611103058,
0.09458159655332565,
1.0552483797073364,
0.5687839388847351,
0.08907783031463623,
-0.04711836203932762,
-0.555820882320404,
0.1858094334602356,
0.1865236461162567,
-0.9250327944755554,
-0.17695368826389313,
0.29704129695892334,
0.4087629020214081,
0.25842320919036865,
0.5635330677032471,
-0.924105167388916,
0.42713314294815063,
0.426316499710083,
0.27374467253685,
-0.20815525949001312,
-0.9450488090515137,
-0.2498214989900589,
0.3776301145553589,
0.5684667229652405,
-0.18395575881004333
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08293v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08293v3
|
Generative Pretrained Structured Transformers: Unsupervised Syntactic Language Models at Scale
| 2024-03-13T06:54:47 | 2024-06-17T16:22:52 |
Xiang Hu, Pengyu Ji, Qingyang Zhu, Wei Wu, Kewei Tu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
A syntactic language model (SLM) incrementally generates a sentence with its
syntactic tree in a left-to-right manner. We present Generative Pretrained
Structured Transformers (GPST), an unsupervised SLM at scale capable of being
pre-trained from scratch on raw texts with high parallelism. GPST circumvents
the limitations of previous SLMs such as relying on gold trees and sequential
training. It consists of two components, a usual SLM supervised by a
uni-directional language modeling loss, and an additional composition model,
which induces syntactic parse trees and computes constituent representations,
supervised by a bi-directional language modeling loss. We propose a
representation surrogate to enable joint parallel training of the two models in
a hard-EM fashion. We pre-train GPST on OpenWebText, a corpus with $9$ billion
tokens, and demonstrate the superiority of GPST over GPT-2 with a comparable
size in numerous tasks covering both language understanding and language
generation. Meanwhile, GPST also significantly outperforms existing
unsupervised SLMs on left-to-right grammar induction, while holding a
substantial acceleration on training.
|
[
-0.12164922058582306,
-0.5353397130966187,
0.6778988838195801,
0.30291613936424255,
-0.3675895929336548,
0.07932078093290329,
-0.5550925731658936,
0.04858452454209328,
0.23946477472782135,
0.5043213367462158,
-0.5248664617538452,
-0.4423281252384186,
-0.48847153782844543,
-0.05288148298859596,
-0.7014211416244507,
1.3739864826202393,
-0.06541335582733154,
-0.12592458724975586,
-0.31332927942276,
0.019967827945947647,
-0.20548199117183685,
-0.6555531024932861,
-0.2629411816596985,
-0.2927245497703552,
0.16496402025222778,
0.1373930722475052,
0.8687687516212463,
0.4586676359176636,
0.31722596287727356,
0.4094599187374115,
0.23965221643447876,
-0.19394172728061676,
-0.25928303599357605,
-0.021231364458799362,
-0.1460770219564438,
-0.3046324849128723,
-0.5015440583229065,
0.12587414681911469,
0.8494661450386047,
0.9153264164924622,
-0.5652428269386292,
0.21774137020111084,
0.08047396689653397,
0.4705173075199127,
-0.20496025681495667,
0.4043734073638916,
-0.6629244685173035,
0.022805478423833847,
-0.401056706905365,
0.05757448449730873,
-0.6018968820571899,
-0.05164535343647003,
-0.014724820852279663,
-0.6768380999565125,
0.4148097038269043,
-0.23367325961589813,
0.731207549571991,
0.3194604218006134,
-0.29883795976638794,
0.136027991771698,
-0.9382369518280029,
0.4179551899433136,
-0.4930565357208252,
0.3968513011932373,
-0.10980576276779175,
0.3296903669834137,
-0.021470919251441956,
-1.3250036239624023,
-0.39014896750450134,
-0.26115843653678894,
-0.30090978741645813,
0.25448012351989746,
-0.2069309651851654,
0.22969798743724823,
0.3018602132797241,
0.3790065348148346,
-0.9444259405136108,
0.04593374952673912,
-0.14149923622608185,
0.038117628544569016,
0.22299639880657196,
-0.05986432731151581,
0.27054938673973083,
0.025197414681315422,
-0.5024270415306091,
-0.19397658109664917,
-0.7618563771247864,
-0.4492339491844177,
0.30365049839019775,
0.39795345067977905,
-0.0034515217412263155,
0.4741266667842865,
0.02604546584188938,
0.5462424755096436,
0.06981729716062546,
0.2566611170768738,
0.19046078622341156,
-0.38896840810775757,
-0.3421403765678406,
0.0562337227165699,
0.9259403347969055,
-0.127762109041214,
0.4798514246940613,
-0.3624245822429657,
-0.3183973431587219,
0.17726711928844452,
0.6000877618789673,
-0.832417368888855,
-0.3591313362121582,
-0.34373965859413147,
-0.24308732151985168,
0.01211387850344181,
0.20953074097633362,
-0.4198896884918213,
0.15426930785179138,
-0.3182222843170166,
0.33574342727661133,
-0.10143885761499405,
-0.4287244975566864,
0.3412785530090332,
0.18612195551395416,
-0.010531188920140266,
0.09619849920272827,
-1.1226979494094849,
0.3107990324497223,
0.5381597876548767,
0.6574335098266602,
0.0781516581773758,
-0.3649301528930664,
-0.25999152660369873,
0.23694372177124023,
-0.13743995130062103,
0.8057727813720703,
-0.39489689469337463,
-0.19986847043037415,
0.15534840524196625,
0.06714341044425964,
-0.3505108654499054,
-0.3541734218597412,
0.47658687829971313,
-0.44826048612594604,
0.39875584840774536,
0.23739022016525269,
-0.25301870703697205,
0.1332080066204071,
0.16790536046028137,
-0.5121663212776184,
1.1887691020965576,
0.5697306990623474,
-0.8537419438362122,
0.35469087958335876,
-0.5465296506881714,
-0.5439870953559875,
0.5174940824508667,
-0.35592907667160034,
-0.5136764049530029,
0.3061632215976715,
0.19305065274238586,
0.31590408086776733,
-0.24638134241104126,
0.5810331702232361,
0.0882808193564415,
-0.29031482338905334,
-0.18121950328350067,
-0.4236404597759247,
0.44257470965385437,
-0.13378362357616425,
-0.35141345858573914,
0.4050951600074768,
-0.6675972938537598,
0.12394717335700989,
0.38653576374053955,
-0.29705488681793213,
-0.16455359756946564,
0.0209865253418684,
0.1354144811630249,
0.14070989191532135,
0.32725828886032104,
-0.57646244764328,
0.2665327191352844,
-0.37347185611724854,
0.6397286653518677,
0.5453569889068604,
-0.40006938576698303,
0.42736315727233887,
0.20126403868198395,
0.6265659928321838,
-0.05392102152109146,
0.029466604813933372,
-0.2713486850261688,
-0.15555986762046814,
-0.8694218993186951,
0.02723301574587822,
0.18467526137828827,
0.30626195669174194,
-0.8083269596099854,
0.6324794292449951,
-0.6938686370849609,
-0.32183393836021423,
-0.41812756657600403,
-0.0735895112156868,
0.28141912817955017,
0.32233962416648865,
0.5210913419723511,
-0.3645150661468506,
-0.5097603797912598,
-0.950113832950592,
-0.37593257427215576,
-0.24261654913425446,
-0.26475390791893005,
-0.2735508680343628,
0.28246235847473145,
-0.23009511828422546,
0.9064237475395203,
-0.38345491886138916,
-0.2831524908542633,
-0.5555256009101868,
0.35060396790504456,
0.028551341965794563,
0.46791625022888184,
0.32462722063064575,
-0.6404672861099243,
-0.545220136642456,
-0.008600552566349506,
-0.44855228066444397,
-0.13442756235599518,
-0.2500447928905487,
0.18038608133792877,
0.15750455856323242,
0.6737219095230103,
-1.1448532342910767,
0.3233095705509186,
0.6325443387031555,
-0.2041308432817459,
0.49028196930885315,
-0.4973999261856079,
-0.42336660623550415,
-1.2037142515182495,
-0.05566006526350975,
-0.15788590908050537,
-0.5700554251670837,
-0.6104152798652649,
0.12365046888589859,
0.17438483238220215,
-0.27013617753982544,
-0.2505147457122803,
-0.07653157413005829,
-0.5442786812782288,
-0.3893904685974121,
-0.12520435452461243,
0.0923532024025917,
-0.14500778913497925,
0.6025192737579346,
0.1630953848361969,
0.9988804459571838,
0.3027077913284302,
0.0012418325059115887,
0.1593649834394455,
0.12088040262460709,
-0.5458515882492065,
-0.011395696550607681,
-0.663018524646759,
0.3132915794849396,
-0.19839344918727875,
0.512467086315155,
-0.6165745854377747,
-0.03270129859447479,
-0.147645965218544,
-0.05627281591296196,
0.45341038703918457,
-0.16430877149105072,
-0.8297374844551086,
-0.44924667477607727,
-0.03322698920965195,
0.5439570546150208,
0.5337508916854858,
-0.5409608483314514,
0.4866712689399719,
0.1614212989807129,
-0.27547961473464966,
-0.17808328568935394,
-0.6376316547393799,
0.07740791887044907,
-0.04837664216756821,
-0.35408714413642883,
0.4378809928894043,
0.28190839290618896,
0.12767954170703888,
0.10331474989652634,
-0.08368265628814697,
0.3042680025100708,
-0.08028542250394821,
0.21895723044872284,
0.06944424659013748,
-0.42169544100761414,
0.23615795373916626,
-0.02740265429019928,
-0.43072301149368286,
0.19494199752807617,
-0.8375536203384399,
0.8989022970199585,
-0.5073513388633728,
-0.46265709400177,
-0.2169785052537918,
0.2796163558959961,
0.4855615496635437,
-0.4583558440208435,
0.6581694483757019,
0.6195617318153381,
-0.16721315681934357,
-0.27374330163002014,
-0.17237523198127747,
-0.021188270300626755,
-0.4828554093837738,
0.6421071290969849,
-0.27929773926734924,
-0.9040051698684692,
0.13925784826278687,
-0.15487030148506165,
-0.07501907646656036,
0.5517043471336365,
0.5948320031166077,
0.14464882016181946,
1.0293387174606323,
0.7499614953994751,
-0.007551668211817741,
0.5136414766311646,
-0.19223962724208832,
0.4194543957710266,
-0.47785457968711853,
-0.12999117374420166,
-0.4371272027492523,
-0.031331174075603485,
-0.8096401691436768,
-0.5211717486381531,
0.3669664263725281,
0.12462067604064941,
-0.4865323603153229,
0.6614312529563904,
-0.5027651786804199,
0.5791349411010742,
0.5801098942756653,
-0.17750504612922668,
0.2935076355934143,
0.13185453414916992,
-0.1637723743915558,
0.06587636470794678,
-0.692944347858429,
-0.626891553401947,
0.9476329684257507,
0.29462456703186035,
0.7056330442428589,
-0.051891885697841644,
0.4733782112598419,
-0.018104474991559982,
0.5154873728752136,
-0.6472077369689941,
0.6325003504753113,
-0.47573548555374146,
-0.2909258306026459,
-0.28275302052497864,
-0.27220144867897034,
-0.6707975268363953,
0.21735043823719025,
0.02333366684615612,
-0.5025973320007324,
-0.3968745470046997,
0.11229570209980011,
-0.20872822403907776,
0.3543158173561096,
-0.8080407977104187,
1.0323331356048584,
-0.18492011725902557,
-0.10014300048351288,
-0.053274791687726974,
-0.8047429919242859,
0.04810791462659836,
-0.11176282167434692,
-0.27354180812835693,
0.17969422042369843,
0.21453925967216492,
0.5674402117729187,
-0.589924156665802,
0.7839462757110596,
-0.19736187160015106,
-0.04986240714788437,
0.3063370883464813,
0.047007039189338684,
0.6555399894714355,
0.03498820215463638,
0.3119983375072479,
0.14137667417526245,
-0.29313796758651733,
-0.3576635718345642,
-0.7075637578964233,
0.5953448414802551,
-0.6182416081428528,
-0.8318854570388794,
-0.35352611541748047,
-0.7012810111045837,
-0.20297417044639587,
0.3843705654144287,
0.2223018854856491,
0.3298104405403137,
-0.2129189670085907,
0.1628967821598053,
0.2633967697620392,
0.024048566818237305,
0.5475063323974609,
0.22707512974739075,
-0.16616331040859222,
-0.06760773807764053,
0.6467969417572021,
-0.09017544984817505,
0.31671589612960815,
0.5594724416732788,
0.0391739197075367,
-0.471047043800354,
-0.6602012515068054,
-0.6361168026924133,
0.11628362536430359,
-0.4409382939338684,
-0.20423239469528198,
-0.5918639302253723,
-0.44742581248283386,
-0.3729606866836548,
0.0965825542807579,
-0.6485083103179932,
-0.5259401202201843,
-0.12257705628871918,
-0.4177810251712799,
0.03769133985042572,
0.9201412796974182,
0.18910418450832367,
0.676648736000061,
-0.5971478223800659,
0.036239881068468094,
0.25576701760292053,
0.3095150291919708,
-0.3513335883617401,
-0.3724477291107178,
-0.3005957305431366,
-0.0020883602555841208,
-0.3514707386493683,
-0.4677371084690094,
0.4261641502380371,
0.0830695629119873,
0.10533596575260162,
0.400494784116745,
-0.18687282502651215,
0.7221477627754211,
-0.8219463229179382,
0.6681543588638306,
0.2700551152229309,
-0.7589163780212402,
0.20147041976451874,
-0.44639283418655396,
0.4856542646884918,
0.5526383519172668,
0.20177707076072693,
-0.4156726002693176,
-0.4440139830112457,
-0.5363934636116028,
-0.6383987665176392,
0.7862911224365234,
0.19285602867603302,
0.3007814586162567,
-0.11631853878498077,
0.2889310419559479,
0.17144683003425598,
0.22097380459308624,
-1.0200669765472412,
0.04098694771528244,
-0.6661835312843323,
-0.3164878487586975,
-0.4339821934700012,
-0.2087114155292511,
0.19213853776454926,
-0.20358772575855255,
0.45358631014823914,
-0.12988342344760895,
0.24333061277866364,
-0.025329716503620148,
-0.2776600420475006,
-0.031620074063539505,
0.4655839800834656,
0.48369696736335754,
0.42911943793296814,
-0.12484756112098694,
0.5435556769371033,
-0.18154598772525787,
-0.505424976348877,
0.06894902884960175,
0.44248679280281067,
-0.23912908136844635,
0.03570593148469925,
0.4343714118003845,
0.9084857702255249,
0.18281489610671997,
-0.40262359380722046,
0.6427738070487976,
0.05258379131555557,
-0.20632430911064148,
-0.30447790026664734,
-0.4040926396846771,
0.26936742663383484,
0.006504348013550043,
0.15706348419189453,
0.024840688332915306,
-0.22271230816841125,
-0.47947925329208374,
0.17724837362766266,
0.41928598284721375,
-0.3108614385128021,
-0.7669119834899902,
0.6759998798370361,
0.1065438762307167,
-0.22415757179260254,
0.8925110101699829,
-0.18928848206996918,
-0.7736957669258118,
0.2304815798997879,
1.015173077583313,
0.9939444661140442,
-0.25382572412490845,
0.4619874358177185,
0.17340955138206482,
0.5205708146095276,
-0.23868964612483978,
-0.12218297272920609,
-0.21283920109272003,
-0.6401159763336182,
-0.5896914601325989,
-0.7999275326728821,
0.0001404769136570394,
0.329814076423645,
-0.6657001376152039,
0.0015016759280115366,
-0.32198476791381836,
0.012464847415685654,
-0.13134410977363586,
-0.1319570392370224,
-0.5738780498504639,
-0.08786284923553467,
-0.08677911013364792,
0.6942029595375061,
-0.8996830582618713,
1.1401110887527466,
0.9236767292022705,
-0.4628866910934448,
-0.8698567748069763,
0.26455792784690857,
-0.44579508900642395,
-0.8149111270904541,
0.6035823822021484,
0.4383402466773987,
-0.07625361531972885,
0.3202162981033325,
-0.22357068955898285,
-0.6027752161026001,
0.9463127255439758,
0.6926407217979431,
-0.7116031050682068,
-0.3995112478733063,
0.6646189093589783,
0.7435519099235535,
-0.30529382824897766,
0.2262778878211975,
0.6266517639160156,
0.1748204082250595,
-0.16722877323627472,
-0.9634202718734741,
0.14222313463687897,
0.005787214729934931,
0.2810131013393402,
0.6667888760566711,
-0.400214821100235,
1.0180602073669434,
-0.06636907160282135,
-0.6583161950111389,
0.11684327572584152,
0.5792278051376343,
-0.09908747673034668,
-0.19124825298786163,
0.5808579325675964,
0.9525526762008667,
0.2465014010667801,
-0.19304201006889343,
0.889991044998169,
-0.2622695863246918,
0.5531831979751587,
1.2506506443023682,
-0.3307037651538849,
0.6209538578987122,
0.43851032853126526,
-0.2507786452770233,
0.6741475462913513,
0.3757822513580322,
0.20429690182209015,
0.51936936378479,
0.2673742175102234,
-0.4909593462944031,
-0.4562532603740692,
-0.10986864566802979,
-0.3526202440261841,
0.5363351702690125,
0.22186866402626038,
-0.24868783354759216,
-0.660558819770813,
0.002958820667117834,
-0.16844439506530762,
0.4555423855781555,
-0.15616288781166077,
0.6750600934028625,
0.01773647405207157,
-0.6521133184432983,
0.33822885155677795,
0.16195447742938995,
0.3393612802028656,
-0.6644058227539062,
0.17899255454540253,
-0.29765942692756653,
0.36333367228507996,
0.013658964075148106,
-0.5630024075508118,
0.3911537826061249,
0.015439159236848354,
-0.04629053547978401,
-0.8449189066886902,
0.7280911803245544,
-0.7762362360954285,
-0.4754951596260071,
0.2560420036315918,
0.5204740762710571,
0.12310217320919037,
-0.40313583612442017,
-0.4943743050098419,
-0.25582361221313477,
-0.2682112157344818,
-0.42767757177352905,
0.3666418194770813,
0.4682622253894806,
-0.4376216232776642,
0.3857556879520416,
0.5150973796844482,
0.019000647589564323,
0.03783074766397476,
0.41629859805107117,
1.0950844287872314,
-0.6261587738990784,
-0.41521018743515015,
-0.7092218399047852,
0.3055780529975891,
0.22736026346683502,
0.06608179956674576,
0.6396409869194031,
0.7339537739753723,
1.0958682298660278,
-0.25982189178466797,
0.5091940760612488,
0.02336740493774414,
0.28372642397880554,
-0.47512009739875793,
0.6504668593406677,
-0.2702474594116211,
-0.047297053039073944,
0.143514484167099,
-1.0995094776153564,
-0.3448982536792755,
0.4804984927177429,
-0.18159689009189606,
0.18274761736392975,
0.8377805948257446,
0.5939708948135376,
-0.2036304920911789,
0.020238714292645454,
0.2555583715438843,
0.22857192158699036,
0.2750643491744995,
0.6278296709060669,
0.7503494620323181,
-0.29271170496940613,
0.5960069298744202,
-0.03529984503984451,
0.003389339428395033,
0.2038363665342331,
-0.7641044855117798,
-0.9765391945838928,
-0.6326757669448853,
-0.10571331530809402,
-0.02539936639368534,
-0.0735798329114914,
0.7321441173553467,
0.6799799799919128,
-0.501805305480957,
-0.11706791818141937,
-0.7912405729293823,
-0.25833460688591003,
0.01751515083014965,
-0.19552329182624817,
0.47184476256370544,
-0.5098409652709961,
-0.7259759902954102,
0.5495116114616394,
0.3796013295650482,
0.14710383117198944,
-0.49665316939353943,
0.12093190103769302,
-0.10289495438337326,
-0.3692018389701843,
0.7050294280052185,
0.09437867254018784,
-0.5172795057296753,
-0.3106561303138733,
-0.3167458474636078,
-0.13529519736766815,
0.08166307955980301,
1.1827975511550903,
-0.9282306432723999,
0.20660200715065002,
0.21743053197860718,
0.5670096278190613,
0.8256834745407104,
0.2495996505022049,
0.6249395608901978,
-1.191515564918518,
0.46726956963539124,
0.29246294498443604,
0.27846941351890564,
0.33256205916404724,
-0.06011207029223442,
0.2492116540670395,
0.2761865556240082,
-0.3086978793144226,
-0.6923458576202393,
0.3118405044078827,
-0.9112118482589722,
-0.06467124819755554,
0.9330570101737976,
-0.24376077950000763,
0.0926668792963028,
0.11933495104312897,
0.2121303826570511,
0.3727732300758362,
-0.08388165384531021,
0.3374049663543701,
0.43946102261543274,
0.24801890552043915,
-0.10857751220464706,
-0.41171330213546753,
0.506166934967041,
0.5961778163909912,
-0.8843305110931396,
0.3647709786891937,
0.2224646359682083,
0.11064044386148453,
0.22466690838336945,
0.551742434501648,
-0.37044474482536316,
-0.11389950662851334,
0.0202937088906765,
0.3213159441947937,
-0.2766088545322418,
-0.608704686164856,
-0.32606926560401917,
0.18014267086982727,
0.023874925449490547,
-0.22053270041942596
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08281v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08281v4
|
Mastering Text, Code and Math Simultaneously via Fusing Highly Specialized Language Models
| 2024-03-13T06:18:48 | 2024-03-26T09:29:51 |
Ning Ding, Yulin Chen, Ganqu Cui, Xingtai Lv, Weilin Zhao, Ruobing Xie, Bowen Zhou, Zhiyuan Liu, Maosong Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Underlying data distributions of natural language, programming code, and
mathematical symbols vary vastly, presenting a complex challenge for large
language models (LLMs) that strive to achieve high performance across all three
domains simultaneously. Achieving a very high level of proficiency for an LLM
within a specific domain often requires extensive training with relevant
corpora, which is typically accompanied by a sacrifice in performance in other
domains. In this paper, we propose to fuse models that are already
highly-specialized directly. The proposed fusing framework, UltraFuser,
consists of three distinct specialists that are already sufficiently trained on
language, coding, and mathematics. A token-level gating mechanism is introduced
to blend the specialists' outputs. A two-stage training strategy accompanied by
balanced sampling is designed to ensure stability. To effectively train the
fused model, we further construct a high-quality supervised instruction tuning
dataset, UltraChat 2, which includes text, code, and mathematical content. This
dataset comprises approximately 300,000 instructions and covers a wide range of
topics in each domain. Experiments show that our model could simultaneously
achieve mastery of the three crucial domains.
|
[
-0.22084487974643707,
-0.9465478658676147,
0.2887517213821411,
0.3358399569988251,
-0.0583401583135128,
0.5795779228210449,
-0.18772970139980316,
-0.3626527488231659,
-0.2977331280708313,
0.8587282299995422,
-0.40483418107032776,
-0.4111931025981903,
-0.411132276058197,
-0.22292082011699677,
-0.5109973549842834,
1.2452856302261353,
-0.055611077696084976,
0.045986901968717575,
-0.39186257123947144,
0.07739309221506119,
-0.7096134424209595,
-0.789533257484436,
-0.3355712890625,
-0.731918215751648,
-0.01736648567020893,
0.3941999673843384,
0.7869561910629272,
0.6609139442443848,
0.5252171158790588,
0.26643654704093933,
0.26781463623046875,
0.43622082471847534,
-0.8373432159423828,
-0.1227838471531868,
-0.2986392378807068,
-0.560559868812561,
-0.40826117992401123,
-0.11242377758026123,
0.5322604179382324,
0.8616653084754944,
-0.05204657092690468,
-0.18653173744678497,
0.20354323089122772,
0.46194806694984436,
-0.4061485826969147,
0.0485551655292511,
-0.8449907302856445,
-0.11882622539997101,
-0.0237930528819561,
-0.18380016088485718,
-0.5333913564682007,
-0.12473536282777786,
-0.2098073661327362,
-0.630282998085022,
0.2594543695449829,
-0.06342275440692902,
0.8648514747619629,
0.15945090353488922,
-0.44116127490997314,
0.047167740762233734,
-0.9292202591896057,
0.8671921491622925,
-0.48694169521331787,
0.25984859466552734,
0.3135403096675873,
-0.0073209479451179504,
0.18418258428573608,
-0.41133996844291687,
-0.4499400556087494,
0.2860734164714813,
-0.10564111918210983,
0.10469292104244232,
-0.22420190274715424,
-0.03518885374069214,
0.09519225358963013,
0.31708189845085144,
-0.5596603751182556,
0.30350127816200256,
-0.27011728286743164,
-0.191465824842453,
0.5367621779441833,
0.38107097148895264,
0.45912426710128784,
0.1597452163696289,
-0.41197818517684937,
-0.18955102562904358,
-0.6936033368110657,
-0.29051464796066284,
0.3061787486076355,
0.06593974679708481,
-0.19406729936599731,
0.6969672441482544,
0.19119632244110107,
0.6505560278892517,
-0.25124770402908325,
-0.0013141985982656479,
-0.04220276325941086,
-0.5112231969833374,
-0.3601517379283905,
-0.275142639875412,
0.7913621068000793,
0.17153407633304596,
0.4542139768600464,
-0.25442782044410706,
-0.2988201081752777,
0.43054038286209106,
0.30762895941734314,
-0.5494168996810913,
-0.5957802534103394,
0.02987034060060978,
-0.08417706936597824,
-0.3457086682319641,
0.022634467110037804,
-0.7153434157371521,
-0.09867117553949356,
-0.4511486291885376,
0.3299826383590698,
-0.45803773403167725,
-0.31456154584884644,
0.2431098222732544,
0.11531496047973633,
-0.0032653931993991137,
-0.0942579060792923,
-1.327688217163086,
0.35026052594184875,
0.9290356636047363,
0.6098789572715759,
-0.39632683992385864,
-0.4296981394290924,
-0.28428491950035095,
0.5588579773902893,
-0.5313823819160461,
0.7529159188270569,
-0.9574110507965088,
-0.38528236746788025,
0.14368215203285217,
-0.27732107043266296,
-0.33570748567581177,
-0.48564526438713074,
0.43484172224998474,
-0.6553052663803101,
-0.10835544019937515,
0.2421490103006363,
-0.8008642196655273,
0.04936718940734863,
-0.0711943581700325,
-0.5441023707389832,
1.2407584190368652,
0.511341392993927,
-0.5648784637451172,
0.021035639569163322,
-0.3821667730808258,
-0.5472404956817627,
0.23770378530025482,
-0.16926881670951843,
-0.4147067368030548,
0.170771524310112,
0.3011408746242523,
0.4917341470718384,
-0.28932201862335205,
0.412811815738678,
-0.0917772427201271,
-0.5638163089752197,
0.2407303899526596,
-0.44694972038269043,
0.6635974049568176,
-0.061497218906879425,
-0.1899518519639969,
0.10810963809490204,
-0.57391756772995,
0.05415578931570053,
-0.04056045785546303,
-0.3251001536846161,
-0.4334331154823303,
-0.28637635707855225,
0.3052808344364166,
0.15947268903255463,
0.2380528450012207,
-0.1569705754518509,
0.4011977016925812,
-0.47064968943595886,
0.37773197889328003,
0.7903631329536438,
-0.1386639028787613,
0.5614777207374573,
-0.19303882122039795,
0.4773486256599426,
0.001709792879410088,
-0.06756969541311264,
-0.4357626438140869,
-0.31971418857574463,
-0.9898658990859985,
-0.27241000533103943,
0.3580740690231323,
0.7248407602310181,
-0.7641844749450684,
0.6302887797355652,
-0.35170039534568787,
-0.32973870635032654,
-0.6509884595870972,
0.5870118141174316,
0.6418629288673401,
0.30879858136177063,
0.35621652007102966,
-0.005917176138609648,
-0.4296713173389435,
-0.8085922598838806,
-0.23716223239898682,
0.12248430401086807,
-0.10407844930887222,
0.17532268166542053,
0.4335457980632782,
-0.3836387097835541,
0.7519497871398926,
-0.7183775901794434,
-0.4687463641166687,
-0.32611989974975586,
0.22973205149173737,
0.1736730933189392,
0.6830736398696899,
0.27253222465515137,
-0.7867633104324341,
-0.5629956126213074,
0.38452744483947754,
-0.8888928294181824,
-0.047863300889730453,
-0.26584678888320923,
-0.3844509720802307,
0.1285124570131302,
0.6073522567749023,
-0.13131491839885712,
0.14574670791625977,
0.6008318066596985,
-0.08823695033788681,
0.39471685886383057,
-0.30114561319351196,
0.03254302591085434,
-1.0811095237731934,
-0.06990474462509155,
-0.13864371180534363,
-0.12903127074241638,
-0.6699567437171936,
0.4147150218486786,
0.29893019795417786,
-0.19864898920059204,
-0.23048369586467743,
0.4462832510471344,
-0.5371870994567871,
0.30058589577674866,
-0.46478700637817383,
-0.03817348927259445,
-0.18345148861408234,
0.6579344272613525,
-0.08931511640548706,
0.9222860932350159,
0.8181930184364319,
-0.5498760342597961,
0.4980754852294922,
0.24892380833625793,
-0.18187174201011658,
0.470406711101532,
-0.7401792407035828,
0.21941356360912323,
0.28930366039276123,
-0.05792100355029106,
-0.8005383014678955,
-0.3548772633075714,
-0.4707133173942566,
-0.31852030754089355,
0.29945844411849976,
-0.17510169744491577,
-0.7560004591941833,
-0.42826175689697266,
-0.005552522372454405,
0.4895796477794647,
0.6297240853309631,
-0.34940916299819946,
0.6696575880050659,
0.608582615852356,
-0.15687742829322815,
-0.3729632794857025,
-0.6832497715950012,
0.060263581573963165,
0.08493119478225708,
-0.618841826915741,
0.4006207287311554,
-0.023400448262691498,
0.14817310869693756,
0.020230870693922043,
-0.07424884289503098,
-0.182966947555542,
0.08508101850748062,
0.19489452242851257,
0.7241309285163879,
0.02834145911037922,
-0.10314078629016876,
0.2879873216152191,
-0.4245065748691559,
-0.0929986834526062,
-0.6165327429771423,
0.7837197184562683,
0.09468559920787811,
-0.6221871972084045,
-0.28508132696151733,
0.5743587017059326,
0.4431583881378174,
-0.4888896644115448,
0.7700472474098206,
0.5465006232261658,
-0.39902812242507935,
-0.383880615234375,
-0.6024503707885742,
-0.0700417086482048,
-0.4698486030101776,
0.49466922879219055,
-0.49989229440689087,
-1.1893855333328247,
0.4403742253780365,
-0.11536405235528946,
0.3908427059650421,
0.30680587887763977,
0.6623309850692749,
0.0011712805135175586,
1.3957654237747192,
1.22382390499115,
-0.2858893573284149,
0.20106002688407898,
-0.4501314163208008,
0.4124499261379242,
-0.7083473801612854,
-0.3917537331581116,
-0.4950807988643646,
-0.05109763517975807,
-0.25146615505218506,
-0.47292518615722656,
0.5785514116287231,
0.11926205456256866,
0.05148536339402199,
0.3754536509513855,
-0.4389986991882324,
0.9737509489059448,
0.45960837602615356,
-0.12967945635318756,
0.3231596052646637,
0.5205455422401428,
-0.3405816853046417,
0.017286669462919235,
-0.7496119737625122,
-0.4285765290260315,
1.082226276397705,
0.14882217347621918,
1.0272352695465088,
0.0031987710390239954,
0.5068243145942688,
-0.0813140720129013,
-0.0417584590613842,
-0.403329074382782,
0.40940791368484497,
-0.5277208685874939,
-0.4947812855243683,
-0.07576775550842285,
-0.6150691509246826,
-0.6681963801383972,
0.16199250519275665,
-0.3494754731655121,
-0.48300549387931824,
-0.24591168761253357,
0.05231422930955887,
-0.30039334297180176,
0.4004116952419281,
-0.6026977300643921,
0.6406559348106384,
-0.10442538559436798,
-0.5956557393074036,
-0.4069400131702423,
-0.6095556020736694,
0.5652209520339966,
-0.46863552927970886,
0.39154869318008423,
-0.02487669140100479,
0.06637093424797058,
0.648847758769989,
-0.022255806252360344,
0.8335930109024048,
0.4684751033782959,
-0.23018638789653778,
0.009381773881614208,
0.41717082262039185,
0.18439894914627075,
0.1346954107284546,
0.029501546174287796,
0.1295221745967865,
-0.1919211596250534,
-0.6352545022964478,
-0.5535894632339478,
1.004145622253418,
-0.9505791068077087,
-0.3808259069919586,
-0.23198702931404114,
-0.8506693243980408,
-0.46669521927833557,
0.3108311891555786,
0.06989952176809311,
0.49899759888648987,
-0.11860646307468414,
0.054862380027770996,
1.0021532773971558,
0.1932438313961029,
0.41056928038597107,
0.36400559544563293,
-0.0539652444422245,
-0.44670215249061584,
1.113553524017334,
-0.30746784806251526,
0.5442408919334412,
0.5025374293327332,
-0.18300840258598328,
-0.11317197233438492,
-0.3755052089691162,
-0.4938370883464813,
0.304851233959198,
-0.6035980582237244,
-0.3386324942111969,
-0.9031822681427002,
-0.4443826377391815,
-0.4776802957057953,
-0.4475471079349518,
-0.21207295358181,
-0.1009080559015274,
-0.3143804967403412,
-0.009650489315390587,
0.2533726990222931,
0.7249370813369751,
0.14081791043281555,
0.5162055492401123,
-1.0707205533981323,
0.4687226712703705,
0.363752156496048,
0.43199777603149414,
-0.11504236608743668,
-0.38962459564208984,
-0.5064566135406494,
0.23576466739177704,
-0.3240332007408142,
-0.6076751947402954,
0.2638697624206543,
0.20358587801456451,
0.5763759613037109,
0.28088563680648804,
-0.37502163648605347,
0.8390665650367737,
-0.4162566065788269,
0.7127928733825684,
0.2806244492530823,
-1.0880942344665527,
0.37369534373283386,
-0.4219399094581604,
0.21987779438495636,
0.6019931435585022,
0.343485951423645,
-0.47212690114974976,
-0.6074520349502563,
-0.5105821490287781,
-0.7981289029121399,
0.8186380863189697,
0.24200187623500824,
0.5043944716453552,
0.20983867347240448,
0.14096494019031525,
0.12887541949748993,
0.057210978120565414,
-0.5969133973121643,
-0.15292251110076904,
0.06191500648856163,
-0.4127548933029175,
-0.0070656463503837585,
-0.15757450461387634,
-0.3948596715927124,
-0.5109346508979797,
0.7114772200584412,
-0.3256082534790039,
0.10678815841674805,
-0.4701743721961975,
-0.2737753093242645,
0.025373151525855064,
-0.03907874971628189,
0.13847392797470093,
0.7915148735046387,
0.36561062932014465,
0.28013360500335693,
0.02029370702803135,
-0.4748518168926239,
0.0896206870675087,
-0.0021758766379207373,
-0.08700378239154816,
-0.3506987690925598,
0.7003291845321655,
0.7641289234161377,
0.6360341906547546,
-0.7092152237892151,
0.3980330228805542,
0.24275362491607666,
-0.27223700284957886,
0.2576417624950409,
0.385469913482666,
0.27786457538604736,
-0.2386060506105423,
0.34350135922431946,
0.1377689242362976,
-0.24413618445396423,
-0.5597617030143738,
0.33941924571990967,
0.42368146777153015,
-0.20710675418376923,
-0.21519897878170013,
0.6567797660827637,
0.26669561862945557,
-0.06846596300601959,
0.8619815111160278,
0.06524316221475601,
-0.7375261187553406,
0.49971964955329895,
0.9484174251556396,
0.5490928292274475,
-0.20325182378292084,
0.16418910026550293,
0.042028337717056274,
0.20317763090133667,
-0.13990968465805054,
0.12798644602298737,
0.0031652282923460007,
-0.5940390825271606,
-0.4936886429786682,
-0.8182231783866882,
-0.2554294466972351,
-0.1962798535823822,
-0.4251760244369507,
0.357389360666275,
-0.26406949758529663,
0.24616479873657227,
0.0440458282828331,
-0.046998463571071625,
-0.4916576147079468,
0.08745273947715759,
-0.15162420272827148,
0.6188005208969116,
-1.1420172452926636,
0.9143298268318176,
0.7149649858474731,
-0.34889331459999084,
-0.8812304735183716,
-0.2595847249031067,
-0.16891911625862122,
-0.8994147181510925,
0.14733220636844635,
-0.009454998187720776,
-0.13577982783317566,
0.24803760647773743,
-0.5506450533866882,
-0.5028780102729797,
0.6849648356437683,
0.42945387959480286,
-0.590791642665863,
-0.18806850910186768,
0.33504220843315125,
0.4213000535964966,
-0.4636637568473816,
0.24293768405914307,
0.8841784000396729,
0.07217758893966675,
0.26483580470085144,
-0.9545031189918518,
-0.3659859001636505,
-0.33572953939437866,
0.0701311007142067,
0.4484630227088928,
-0.6721900701522827,
0.8146588802337646,
-0.039153534919023514,
-0.18083806335926056,
-0.15766899287700653,
0.7645362019538879,
0.24160440266132355,
-0.07768101245164871,
0.17410796880722046,
0.6046877503395081,
0.7123254537582397,
-0.17185768485069275,
0.6291525363922119,
-0.5152661204338074,
0.46164047718048096,
0.8170479536056519,
-0.38700583577156067,
0.5870921015739441,
0.17337465286254883,
-0.17338024079799652,
0.42558833956718445,
0.34657713770866394,
-0.17747648060321808,
0.2961685061454773,
-0.07489310204982758,
-0.36712339520454407,
-0.55544114112854,
-0.09843746572732925,
-0.35266056656837463,
0.4245888590812683,
0.34743180871009827,
-0.005894057918339968,
-0.106613889336586,
0.13043911755084991,
0.12585413455963135,
0.39943596720695496,
-0.10204942524433136,
0.9699397087097168,
0.021023817360401154,
-0.6615546941757202,
0.6899447441101074,
0.15616589784622192,
0.7403980493545532,
-0.6474029421806335,
-0.05594588816165924,
-0.24805304408073425,
0.2989627420902252,
-0.18298228085041046,
-0.8887876868247986,
0.2924598157405853,
0.13305877149105072,
-0.146286278963089,
-0.24726317822933197,
0.47980383038520813,
-0.676033616065979,
-0.902263343334198,
0.2595633268356323,
0.4255549907684326,
0.06783255189657211,
0.1985948085784912,
-0.5442588925361633,
0.228254497051239,
0.045281872153282166,
0.3652251660823822,
0.3280909061431885,
0.38958466053009033,
-0.18537291884422302,
0.6191322803497314,
0.9220781326293945,
0.051130250096321106,
0.09790609776973724,
0.37626421451568604,
1.2927428483963013,
-0.4174305498600006,
-0.48162806034088135,
-0.9948285222053528,
0.25080615282058716,
-0.15684588253498077,
-0.2557483911514282,
0.6792824268341064,
0.9281115531921387,
0.9162207245826721,
0.014402109198272228,
0.8098338842391968,
0.2688589096069336,
0.08754708617925644,
-0.5760958790779114,
0.7156733870506287,
-0.4458613097667694,
0.28175365924835205,
-0.28894126415252686,
-1.0009046792984009,
-0.3293112516403198,
0.379720002412796,
0.23176737129688263,
0.03883103281259537,
0.6754230856895447,
0.7402603626251221,
-0.43525430560112,
0.11653952300548553,
0.3392770290374756,
-0.007991465739905834,
0.47775623202323914,
0.9777365922927856,
0.3610926866531372,
-0.317661315202713,
0.5629363059997559,
-0.14922340214252472,
-0.5808369517326355,
-0.13083800673484802,
-0.5784982442855835,
-1.2132424116134644,
-0.5100395083427429,
-0.2004292756319046,
-0.06228701397776604,
-0.02872529998421669,
0.589090883731842,
0.8623581528663635,
-0.6826128959655762,
-0.382800430059433,
-0.11272447556257248,
0.0641627162694931,
-0.3409760892391205,
-0.20465195178985596,
0.2864969074726105,
-0.43229004740715027,
-0.8503759503364563,
0.35322293639183044,
0.3738957941532135,
-0.02144249901175499,
-0.3830873668193817,
0.22272753715515137,
-0.0018129853997379541,
0.2913643419742584,
0.47780972719192505,
-0.04900844767689705,
-0.4513635039329529,
0.2275625318288803,
0.2572792172431946,
-0.3266381025314331,
-0.1522883027791977,
1.1220264434814453,
-0.7215592861175537,
0.3633113503456116,
0.30329811573028564,
0.7692617177963257,
0.4609367847442627,
-0.0192281324416399,
0.6125234961509705,
-0.7860931158065796,
0.09371361881494522,
0.15906479954719543,
0.10374701768159866,
0.38084807991981506,
-0.4295503795146942,
0.37754520773887634,
0.23861569166183472,
-0.48450493812561035,
-0.9403913617134094,
0.26746630668640137,
-0.6754589676856995,
-0.34448766708374023,
1.0228480100631714,
0.09947968274354935,
-0.006945327389985323,
-0.16373933851718903,
-0.12951348721981049,
0.32351481914520264,
-0.023728175088763237,
0.49730315804481506,
0.8085144758224487,
-0.09433210641145706,
0.040959618985652924,
-0.4768390655517578,
0.30930382013320923,
0.6265881061553955,
-0.850695788860321,
0.3858841359615326,
0.39152517914772034,
0.1419362872838974,
0.13411355018615723,
0.47385066747665405,
-0.24845489859580994,
0.20529070496559143,
-0.08425431698560715,
0.022050844505429268,
-0.2683161497116089,
-0.6867441534996033,
-0.343872994184494,
0.2555692493915558,
-0.353269100189209,
0.2780693471431732
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08272v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08272v1
|
RECIPE4U: Student-ChatGPT Interaction Dataset in EFL Writing Education
| 2024-03-13T05:51:57 | 2024-03-13T05:51:57 |
Jieun Han, Haneul Yoo, Junho Myung, Minsun Kim, Tak Yeon Lee, So-Yeon Ahn, Alice Oh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The integration of generative AI in education is expanding, yet empirical
analyses of large-scale and real-world interactions between students and AI
systems still remain limited. Addressing this gap, we present RECIPE4U (RECIPE
for University), a dataset sourced from a semester-long experiment with 212
college students in English as Foreign Language (EFL) writing courses. During
the study, students engaged in dialogues with ChatGPT to revise their essays.
RECIPE4U includes comprehensive records of these interactions, including
conversation logs, students' intent, students' self-rated satisfaction, and
students' essay edit histories. In particular, we annotate the students'
utterances in RECIPE4U with 13 intention labels based on our coding schemes. We
establish baseline results for two subtasks in task-oriented dialogue systems
within educational contexts: intent detection and satisfaction estimation. As a
foundational step, we explore student-ChatGPT interaction patterns through
RECIPE4U and analyze them by focusing on students' dialogue, essay data
statistics, and students' essay edits. We further illustrate potential
applications of RECIPE4U dataset for enhancing the incorporation of LLMs in
educational frameworks. RECIPE4U is publicly available at
https://zeunie.github.io/RECIPE4U/.
|
[
-0.08177746832370758,
-0.9600279331207275,
0.5614625215530396,
0.15175756812095642,
0.48873022198677063,
0.08824983984231949,
-0.05608363449573517,
-0.35942837595939636,
0.23712274432182312,
0.426226943731308,
-0.7221662998199463,
-0.6348589658737183,
-0.13317283987998962,
0.21753345429897308,
-0.39858391880989075,
1.1575639247894287,
-0.22269099950790405,
0.11682471632957458,
-0.7002310156822205,
0.2667934000492096,
-0.49380019307136536,
-0.6835973262786865,
-0.8934628963470459,
-0.27024510502815247,
0.6758898496627808,
0.8038845658302307,
0.13914376497268677,
0.1877644956111908,
0.4888246953487396,
0.287960946559906,
0.4467273950576782,
-0.12024485319852829,
-0.7868078947067261,
0.23350082337856293,
0.13238650560379028,
-0.40416470170021057,
-0.5549831986427307,
0.3656352460384369,
0.5781418681144714,
0.5574882626533508,
-0.13778139650821686,
0.01919286511838436,
0.35907649993896484,
0.33307039737701416,
-0.2839558720588684,
0.4601973593235016,
-0.20772425830364227,
0.40437471866607666,
-0.269365131855011,
-0.11501407623291016,
-0.635406494140625,
-0.31552889943122864,
0.05666645988821983,
-0.7834419012069702,
0.19693630933761597,
-0.14200329780578613,
0.379778116941452,
0.1275106966495514,
-0.1256406009197235,
-0.4228774905204773,
-0.5963039994239807,
0.7442181706428528,
-0.8478522896766663,
0.39947476983070374,
0.411149263381958,
0.18985643982887268,
-0.6597906947135925,
-0.9943334460258484,
-0.7717325091362,
0.13589723408222198,
-0.2143898755311966,
0.5154765844345093,
0.0989968404173851,
0.30737268924713135,
0.09566933661699295,
0.32739129662513733,
-0.47624626755714417,
0.07915449887514114,
-0.22647418081760406,
-0.13023139536380768,
0.38698726892471313,
0.4316469728946686,
0.6379274725914001,
0.12121571600437164,
-0.23076678812503815,
0.0483611635863781,
-0.7348042726516724,
0.23264998197555542,
0.6189191937446594,
0.013562053442001343,
-0.0413471981883049,
0.6923495531082153,
-0.007185241673141718,
0.719221293926239,
-0.22386465966701508,
-0.09037113189697266,
0.12281831353902817,
-0.5301178693771362,
-0.24760816991329193,
0.08578844368457794,
0.8319025039672852,
0.45162925124168396,
0.07063817977905273,
0.06516838818788528,
-0.137241393327713,
0.07633168995380402,
0.12307419627904892,
-0.895512580871582,
-0.5264779925346375,
0.2566186487674713,
0.20761922001838684,
-0.3274644911289215,
-0.008394639939069748,
-0.7334588170051575,
-0.13005003333091736,
-0.3516344130039215,
0.2944405674934387,
-0.3474787473678589,
-0.1322275549173355,
-0.06448657065629959,
-0.20195581018924713,
0.5802242159843445,
0.31121036410331726,
-0.9776749610900879,
0.4794831871986389,
0.9313466548919678,
0.6662047505378723,
-0.3367098271846771,
-0.7828951478004456,
-0.4870201051235199,
0.278323233127594,
-0.2355393022298813,
0.6649093627929688,
-0.7363796830177307,
-0.47419071197509766,
0.2143043875694275,
-0.07269225269556046,
-0.3455881178379059,
-0.3055981695652008,
0.6790659427642822,
-0.07902239263057709,
0.38055458664894104,
-0.2176724374294281,
-1.0747054815292358,
0.02975732833147049,
0.35602036118507385,
-0.6719838976860046,
1.0671019554138184,
0.02526608109474182,
-0.32801830768585205,
0.1538819968700409,
-0.8160116076469421,
-0.5794534683227539,
0.15150031447410583,
-0.6178231835365295,
-0.4193934500217438,
-0.2481447160243988,
-0.05723819136619568,
0.5836858153343201,
-0.11901982128620148,
0.37420207262039185,
0.011852568946778774,
-0.4734998941421509,
0.47956934571266174,
-0.4447551369667053,
0.3973560929298401,
0.049012381583452225,
-0.18754899501800537,
0.10644015669822693,
-0.5853665471076965,
-0.1511961668729782,
0.1417534202337265,
-0.6012707948684692,
0.07164167612791061,
-0.1644478589296341,
0.1509188413619995,
-0.274871289730072,
0.14953866600990295,
-0.4360094964504242,
0.23053620755672455,
-0.15745161473751068,
0.5813937783241272,
0.7379043698310852,
0.03624048829078674,
0.23740923404693604,
-0.40897560119628906,
0.49617278575897217,
0.07682009041309357,
0.11859180778265,
-0.38094398379325867,
-0.7815409302711487,
-0.8783584237098694,
0.0170734915882349,
0.07770400494337082,
0.36774972081184387,
-0.5375546813011169,
0.1330963522195816,
0.02019331231713295,
-0.1934994012117386,
-0.5575328469276428,
0.1779884696006775,
0.3495715856552124,
0.480347216129303,
0.18749547004699707,
-0.05929401144385338,
-0.6847477555274963,
-0.5842452645301819,
-0.3312174379825592,
-0.06493901461362839,
-0.0714120864868164,
0.26472747325897217,
0.2767575979232788,
-0.20438537001609802,
0.9715240597724915,
-0.47158485651016235,
-0.3848514258861542,
-0.6507928967475891,
0.14824248850345612,
0.16923411190509796,
0.6657034754753113,
0.460920125246048,
-0.5348740220069885,
-0.7748862504959106,
-0.07672405242919922,
-0.9071927070617676,
-0.2042149156332016,
-0.29228946566581726,
-0.4323410093784332,
0.1652965098619461,
0.44348159432411194,
-0.4985998570919037,
0.41303551197052,
0.43055278062820435,
-0.38036391139030457,
0.5339040160179138,
0.15340843796730042,
0.39195716381073,
-1.0868713855743408,
-0.3417453169822693,
0.19115306437015533,
0.009316634386777878,
-0.8596674799919128,
-0.1875649392604828,
-0.11423585563898087,
-0.1207723617553711,
-0.3631763160228729,
0.4316735863685608,
-0.2823887765407562,
-0.04343369975686073,
0.1306810826063156,
0.09418748319149017,
0.22475090622901917,
0.6126623153686523,
-0.021279480308294296,
0.8473619818687439,
0.2246493250131607,
0.0299737136811018,
0.2457401603460312,
0.24174939095973969,
-0.26407286524772644,
0.607722282409668,
-0.5254553556442261,
0.2486378699541092,
0.31041815876960754,
0.3281278610229492,
-1.0821764469146729,
-0.5617774128913879,
0.5377706289291382,
-0.3599155843257904,
0.04780825227499008,
-0.12468444555997849,
-0.21306446194648743,
0.020589742809534073,
-0.3010255992412567,
0.4121323525905609,
0.26573461294174194,
-0.5682575702667236,
0.8107288479804993,
0.1753070205450058,
-0.24927976727485657,
-0.23151370882987976,
-0.4308241009712219,
0.32159867882728577,
-0.13072367012500763,
-0.36054179072380066,
0.28494328260421753,
-0.46144822239875793,
-0.14517757296562195,
0.10710670053958893,
0.2016182839870453,
-0.14167167246341705,
-0.1674714982509613,
0.36665186285972595,
0.3640616834163666,
-0.2612038850784302,
-0.18111580610275269,
0.21596816182136536,
0.12632720172405243,
0.27285653352737427,
-0.08968493342399597,
0.4509177505970001,
-0.12547153234481812,
-0.30641013383865356,
-0.8143215179443359,
0.1943425089120865,
0.46774837374687195,
0.12105898559093475,
0.535992443561554,
0.37718021869659424,
-0.22182409465312958,
-0.2292158007621765,
-0.5034222602844238,
-0.25369027256965637,
-0.48510444164276123,
0.08086813241243362,
-0.5810952186584473,
-0.5909873247146606,
0.32622966170310974,
0.04045160114765167,
0.36471274495124817,
0.030999884009361267,
0.21947866678237915,
-0.34441518783569336,
0.4058786630630493,
0.2175937443971634,
-0.07325657457113266,
0.3690424859523773,
-0.33111661672592163,
0.24849654734134674,
-0.8158590793609619,
-0.4291985332965851,
-0.2018827348947525,
-0.36630797386169434,
-0.17502601444721222,
-0.37048545479774475,
0.3202432096004486,
-0.31351590156555176,
-0.03967680037021637,
-0.05701703205704689,
-0.16678543388843536,
0.8181964159011841,
0.50469970703125,
-0.010243799537420273,
0.3325645625591278,
-0.036016590893268585,
-0.1128045842051506,
-0.24032077193260193,
-0.6839174628257751,
-0.3213931620121002,
1.079016923904419,
0.0487423874437809,
0.5780078768730164,
0.26084551215171814,
0.8405856490135193,
0.5146534442901611,
0.4294339418411255,
-0.888529896736145,
0.748162567615509,
0.17628061771392822,
-0.2226903736591339,
-0.4186282753944397,
-0.37518224120140076,
-0.9003525376319885,
0.0012019505957141519,
-0.1777224838733673,
-0.3954565227031708,
-0.3544190227985382,
0.12239233404397964,
-0.10931472480297089,
0.07749243080615997,
-1.0142439603805542,
1.0918512344360352,
-0.2913151979446411,
-0.7542281150817871,
0.2714693248271942,
-0.3527720272541046,
0.09164417535066605,
-0.059792306274175644,
0.13454006612300873,
0.22503800690174103,
0.5259521007537842,
0.9131054282188416,
-0.4741056263446808,
1.3275444507598877,
0.13216915726661682,
-0.07150609791278839,
0.39581283926963806,
0.003152079414576292,
0.4709436595439911,
-0.012413720600306988,
-0.15031513571739197,
0.16247260570526123,
-0.03570733591914177,
-0.3906841278076172,
-0.6020112633705139,
1.1241405010223389,
-0.8815230131149292,
-0.8514519333839417,
-0.6398465037345886,
-0.4597392678260803,
-0.036733612418174744,
0.11150923371315002,
0.021293168887495995,
0.3456108570098877,
-0.5529927015304565,
-0.05136813223361969,
0.29608389735221863,
-0.06907504051923752,
0.3497582972049713,
0.43913230299949646,
-0.3279411792755127,
-0.11208008974790573,
1.1950515508651733,
0.13069382309913635,
0.1316901594400406,
0.07819318026304245,
0.30892524123191833,
-0.03832090646028519,
-0.1411924511194229,
-0.6647873520851135,
0.08763845264911652,
-0.7002648711204529,
0.031104838475584984,
-0.5828523635864258,
-0.4448101222515106,
-0.5252602100372314,
-0.49938273429870605,
-0.1667114645242691,
-0.1554272472858429,
-0.3830072581768036,
-0.37673014402389526,
0.19639970362186432,
1.0535024404525757,
0.20837265253067017,
0.2268717736005783,
-0.40986379981040955,
-0.2296234518289566,
0.1644633263349533,
0.18312767148017883,
0.01929602213203907,
-0.2766764163970947,
-0.16927191615104675,
-0.054773490875959396,
-0.4789813756942749,
-0.779310941696167,
0.2726588845252991,
0.5386117100715637,
0.4881443977355957,
0.43413814902305603,
-0.16518695652484894,
0.41341301798820496,
-0.5531166791915894,
0.9776973724365234,
0.17565415799617767,
-0.7825769186019897,
0.5622955560684204,
-0.2532366216182709,
0.19050419330596924,
0.2748793661594391,
0.5057918429374695,
-0.7376586198806763,
-0.5864534974098206,
-0.3530701696872711,
-0.7772719264030457,
0.6505526304244995,
0.3744265139102936,
0.15097244083881378,
0.04989246279001236,
0.56932532787323,
0.38786906003952026,
0.012695825658738613,
-0.6817811727523804,
-0.21487891674041748,
-0.2983511984348297,
-0.7535057663917542,
0.011958098970353603,
-0.2083008587360382,
-0.16627444326877594,
-0.4086359143257141,
0.7624630331993103,
0.13415423035621643,
-0.017835043370723724,
-0.08015770465135574,
0.17089508473873138,
0.08453914523124695,
0.19786402583122253,
0.2757582664489746,
0.5228389501571655,
-0.055218037217855453,
0.1363399773836136,
-0.12976667284965515,
-0.7757701873779297,
0.11068447679281235,
0.00499336700886488,
-0.02470933459699154,
-0.23999910056591034,
0.36376503109931946,
0.49759191274642944,
0.37798944115638733,
-0.6665539145469666,
0.46137702465057373,
-0.4990956485271454,
-0.1642579734325409,
-0.7446185350418091,
0.4004015028476715,
0.11398403346538544,
0.019392386078834534,
0.08377546072006226,
-0.3940776586532593,
0.41721436381340027,
-0.565125048160553,
0.11486203223466873,
0.04674246162176132,
-0.20266683399677277,
-0.5970907807350159,
0.4554787278175354,
0.631653904914856,
-0.4153168499469757,
0.7955722808837891,
0.004931407980620861,
-0.2800831198692322,
0.5625386238098145,
0.7857196927070618,
0.6963464617729187,
-0.32750874757766724,
0.5277774930000305,
0.2093188315629959,
0.08781258761882782,
0.21630817651748657,
0.12744206190109253,
0.030493631958961487,
-0.9523212909698486,
-0.13841120898723602,
-0.6122151017189026,
-0.799988329410553,
0.3993159234523773,
-0.36861661076545715,
0.27069950103759766,
-0.3163307011127472,
0.1862349808216095,
0.19704703986644745,
-0.3384862542152405,
-0.847454309463501,
0.05866464599967003,
-0.31795433163642883,
0.10285941511392593,
-0.9150486588478088,
0.7308006286621094,
0.9395794868469238,
-0.3827235996723175,
-0.8054873943328857,
-0.046748533844947815,
0.4367028772830963,
-0.4691556692123413,
0.4906778931617737,
0.3971599042415619,
-0.0330076664686203,
0.2467058002948761,
-0.31378206610679626,
-0.37943723797798157,
0.8035953640937805,
0.02638630010187626,
-0.633478045463562,
0.19675509631633759,
0.8023887872695923,
0.48144805431365967,
-0.416057825088501,
0.21708305180072784,
0.8352120518684387,
0.3418382406234741,
0.2767446041107178,
-0.25537070631980896,
-0.20607808232307434,
-0.5104128122329712,
-0.45230475068092346,
0.07781259715557098,
-0.501229465007782,
0.4160926342010498,
-0.1538172960281372,
-0.1138250008225441,
-0.0865289568901062,
0.5951072573661804,
0.03453037887811661,
0.7632677555084229,
0.07066609710454941,
0.7105128169059753,
0.5774818062782288,
-0.35596033930778503,
0.6237613558769226,
-0.17457497119903564,
0.07554209977388382,
1.3233623504638672,
-0.4470014274120331,
0.7429767847061157,
0.6715426445007324,
-0.2323935627937317,
0.40768611431121826,
0.781558632850647,
0.075159952044487,
0.16151049733161926,
0.19653472304344177,
-0.6167887449264526,
0.04305734857916832,
-0.07972199469804764,
-0.15353038907051086,
0.3132320046424866,
0.5822043418884277,
-0.1821715533733368,
0.3468288481235504,
0.052669376134872437,
0.2725164592266083,
-0.08521881699562073,
0.08231494575738907,
1.016161561012268,
-0.0622875951230526,
-0.8775404095649719,
0.25679418444633484,
-0.2828536629676819,
0.27250272035598755,
-0.26319339871406555,
-0.6050694584846497,
-0.68473219871521,
-0.12279234081506729,
-0.36658355593681335,
-1.0290929079055786,
-0.14659906923770905,
-0.005225734319537878,
0.027177032083272934,
-0.014065142720937729,
0.4678681790828705,
-0.6793164610862732,
-0.7498968839645386,
0.004278840031474829,
0.5074203610420227,
0.4631017744541168,
0.5395615100860596,
-0.2689434587955475,
0.3299669027328491,
0.04995209351181984,
-0.3137679994106293,
0.3331207036972046,
0.5560230612754822,
0.3318830132484436,
0.22882673144340515,
0.6988570094108582,
-0.07854010909795761,
0.045711737126111984,
0.3052849769592285,
0.8085905313491821,
-0.4962151050567627,
-0.20720355212688446,
-0.6901494860649109,
0.3978308439254761,
-0.05803999304771423,
-0.3299078643321991,
0.756460428237915,
0.7917771339416504,
1.2145562171936035,
-0.11431270092725754,
1.2485582828521729,
-0.004221114329993725,
-0.026578379794955254,
-0.6251079440116882,
0.4377751648426056,
-0.3699864149093628,
0.5648768544197083,
-0.171365886926651,
-0.9737391471862793,
-0.13528504967689514,
0.5890274047851562,
-0.3272072672843933,
-0.016619203612208366,
0.5840059518814087,
0.6991679668426514,
-0.13877372443675995,
0.43231794238090515,
0.6111345291137695,
0.29656025767326355,
0.6751598119735718,
0.4204995930194855,
0.883250892162323,
-0.23958444595336914,
0.17054659128189087,
-0.20673532783985138,
-0.4356619417667389,
-0.2001306265592575,
-0.5963574647903442,
-1.0730574131011963,
-0.5829964280128479,
-0.11131873726844788,
-0.006191641092300415,
0.3429313004016876,
0.8604424595832825,
-0.010955709032714367,
-0.6834704875946045,
-0.5499798059463501,
-0.26294219493865967,
0.012760411947965622,
-0.11998395621776581,
-0.2960700988769531,
0.19519926607608795,
-0.5318658351898193,
-1.0083158016204834,
0.44056323170661926,
0.21928925812244415,
0.10263171792030334,
-0.1825266182422638,
-0.30323830246925354,
-0.05559308081865311,
0.2720149755477905,
0.6600446105003357,
0.16560260951519012,
-0.6085453629493713,
-0.18091091513633728,
-0.05504453182220459,
0.14491680264472961,
0.20067164301872253,
0.9183791875839233,
-0.25739219784736633,
0.6464304327964783,
0.1436857432126999,
0.7627549171447754,
0.4055991470813751,
-0.09551218152046204,
0.5988664031028748,
-0.7125845551490784,
-0.24086885154247284,
-0.03229963406920433,
0.3282431662082672,
0.41723963618278503,
-0.4624713659286499,
0.6416187882423401,
0.3647664785385132,
-0.8960011005401611,
-0.524407148361206,
-0.09179317951202393,
-0.8389771580696106,
-0.04333717003464699,
1.0968462228775024,
-0.5645170211791992,
-0.03072502836585045,
-0.013394107110798359,
-0.3117160201072693,
0.23090103268623352,
-0.633616030216217,
0.7577502727508545,
0.792118489742279,
-0.6469754576683044,
-0.16230948269367218,
-0.8274692296981812,
0.6410425901412964,
0.4234224855899811,
-1.2288762331008911,
-0.08637028932571411,
0.8254972100257874,
0.20806056261062622,
-0.1412612795829773,
0.6837655305862427,
0.25109001994132996,
0.0908520445227623,
-0.16238296031951904,
0.22617892920970917,
0.06380970031023026,
-0.5735114812850952,
0.34879183769226074,
-0.04439520090818405,
0.06728464365005493,
0.08024293929338455
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14683v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14683v1
|
A Moral Imperative: The Need for Continual Superalignment of Large Language Models
| 2024-03-13T05:44:50 | 2024-03-13T05:44:50 |
Gokul Puthumanaillam, Manav Vora, Pranay Thangeda, Melkior Ornik
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
This paper examines the challenges associated with achieving life-long
superalignment in AI systems, particularly large language models (LLMs).
Superalignment is a theoretical framework that aspires to ensure that
superintelligent AI systems act in accordance with human values and goals.
Despite its promising vision, we argue that achieving superalignment requires
substantial changes in the current LLM architectures due to their inherent
limitations in comprehending and adapting to the dynamic nature of these human
ethics and evolving global scenarios. We dissect the challenges of encoding an
ever-changing spectrum of human values into LLMs, highlighting the
discrepancies between static AI models and the dynamic nature of human
societies. To illustrate these challenges, we analyze two distinct examples:
one demonstrates a qualitative shift in human values, while the other presents
a quantifiable change. Through these examples, we illustrate how LLMs,
constrained by their training data, fail to align with contemporary human
values and scenarios. The paper concludes by exploring potential strategies to
address and possibly mitigate these alignment discrepancies, suggesting a path
forward in the pursuit of more adaptable and responsive AI systems.
|
[
0.00030821003019809723,
-0.16444936394691467,
0.6187556385993958,
-0.29728028178215027,
-0.039328683167696,
0.25335991382598877,
0.016092432662844658,
-0.5238940715789795,
-0.23658442497253418,
0.3479437232017517,
-0.6668298244476318,
0.07112153619527817,
-0.5495750904083252,
-0.038406018167734146,
-0.2166069895029068,
1.216386318206787,
0.24314762651920319,
0.21573038399219513,
-0.3718891739845276,
-0.6486355066299438,
-0.5648953914642334,
-0.6550751328468323,
-0.5908608436584473,
-0.5844719409942627,
0.2608563005924225,
0.41979220509529114,
1.413066029548645,
0.8467683792114258,
0.49358004331588745,
0.24462048709392548,
-0.08141060173511505,
0.14698036015033722,
-0.6745782494544983,
0.3809988498687744,
-0.3681863844394684,
-0.5871897339820862,
-0.2853967547416687,
0.17400048673152924,
0.8340846300125122,
0.5349937081336975,
-0.22850632667541504,
0.16743654012680054,
-0.10718855261802673,
0.8811001777648926,
-0.3735191524028778,
-0.05951666086912155,
-0.405839741230011,
-0.14999428391456604,
-0.2603284418582916,
0.20168781280517578,
0.10264576226472855,
-0.4613257646560669,
0.1352575272321701,
-0.7692012786865234,
-0.22204376757144928,
0.05397431552410126,
1.2470837831497192,
0.7235716581344604,
-0.1528029590845108,
-0.02942207269370556,
-0.8690186142921448,
0.9994747638702393,
-0.6831779479980469,
0.6017006635665894,
0.1484333872795105,
0.15923649072647095,
-0.2969595789909363,
-0.3614784777164459,
-0.7428722977638245,
-0.21817290782928467,
0.24848146736621857,
-0.07692191004753113,
0.17156553268432617,
-0.24676935374736786,
0.15703921020030975,
0.1301121860742569,
-0.34590643644332886,
0.3784538209438324,
-0.19052240252494812,
0.012247294187545776,
0.7505881786346436,
0.5778438448905945,
0.5218946933746338,
0.23867051303386688,
-0.253807932138443,
-0.1821502298116684,
-1.1839038133621216,
0.09853208065032959,
0.4071730971336365,
0.10191402584314346,
-0.12229269742965698,
0.20730279386043549,
0.3588833212852478,
0.20478442311286926,
0.24865411221981049,
-0.15628857910633087,
-0.08988052606582642,
-0.2736835777759552,
-0.043891921639442444,
0.21136464178562164,
0.4347373843193054,
0.663407564163208,
0.6809052228927612,
0.08039923012256622,
-0.172614187002182,
0.16210249066352844,
0.5128386616706848,
-0.32699447870254517,
0.14413277804851532,
0.25482821464538574,
-0.21583253145217896,
-0.11503931134939194,
-0.057102665305137634,
-0.2765327990055084,
-0.6764030456542969,
-0.7755712270736694,
-0.08284802734851837,
-0.544069766998291,
-0.22803984582424164,
0.31444379687309265,
0.23029235005378723,
0.7375203967094421,
0.2513008117675781,
-1.2018576860427856,
-0.20251582562923431,
0.9690194725990295,
0.7190842032432556,
0.2256973534822464,
-0.3240417242050171,
-0.09609592705965042,
0.5109811425209045,
-0.65946364402771,
0.5070155262947083,
-0.9765653014183044,
-0.46083635091781616,
-0.083625428378582,
0.07265977561473846,
-0.0406588539481163,
-0.5722677707672119,
0.34554702043533325,
-0.5009403228759766,
-0.010265655815601349,
-0.38252395391464233,
-0.5403091311454773,
0.06039298698306084,
0.23777936398983002,
-0.3793622851371765,
0.9448144435882568,
0.09436951577663422,
-0.3939174711704254,
0.25241366028785706,
-0.5360226035118103,
-0.30551642179489136,
0.46683862805366516,
-0.509961724281311,
-0.39784833788871765,
0.2837671935558319,
-0.06721793860197067,
0.39715760946273804,
-0.4410642981529236,
0.7094867825508118,
-0.327942430973053,
-0.5946907997131348,
0.26557230949401855,
-0.5954169631004333,
1.0064839124679565,
-0.036021582782268524,
-0.44876545667648315,
0.04794212430715561,
-0.5369272828102112,
-0.22271913290023804,
0.15707552433013916,
-0.45696499943733215,
-0.33861103653907776,
0.481050968170166,
-0.24287834763526917,
0.2516418993473053,
0.4639275372028351,
-0.3784409165382385,
0.514908492565155,
-0.454988569021225,
0.8070214986801147,
1.3172872066497803,
-0.5476593971252441,
0.2640027105808258,
-0.6382916569709778,
0.5059884786605835,
-0.4335338771343231,
0.36333751678466797,
0.18990139663219452,
-0.06484761089086533,
-0.9395960569381714,
0.25364959239959717,
-0.07803724706172943,
0.8223816156387329,
-0.4238113760948181,
0.5884822607040405,
-0.7232319116592407,
-0.2519555389881134,
-0.8186113238334656,
0.08288541436195374,
0.4272686541080475,
0.11184567958116531,
0.3428826332092285,
-0.04574669897556305,
-0.4242432415485382,
-0.7904072403907776,
-0.21450313925743103,
-0.4348362684249878,
0.17619499564170837,
0.19238296151161194,
0.5369504690170288,
-0.4084717631340027,
0.7364935278892517,
0.009009788744151592,
-0.05645313113927841,
-0.13553699851036072,
-0.1328132599592209,
-0.028322981670498848,
0.7679715752601624,
0.22947043180465698,
-1.0180659294128418,
-0.015366209670901299,
0.1288386881351471,
-1.0299311876296997,
0.21674232184886932,
-0.47866585850715637,
0.06445576250553131,
0.38710981607437134,
1.1831668615341187,
-0.6727591753005981,
0.1300225853919983,
0.46066462993621826,
-0.07810318470001221,
0.9154402613639832,
-0.20795443654060364,
-0.11762472987174988,
-0.8542167544364929,
0.14544247090816498,
-0.08529459685087204,
-0.10722554475069046,
-0.426694393157959,
0.3776545524597168,
-0.17819184064865112,
0.039976272732019424,
-0.5726547241210938,
0.513238787651062,
-0.28335368633270264,
0.12902720272541046,
0.03229617327451706,
0.09925533831119537,
-0.18465012311935425,
-0.06524984538555145,
-0.398882657289505,
0.9628174304962158,
0.4660477042198181,
-0.7315835952758789,
0.5298348665237427,
0.22970131039619446,
-0.179361492395401,
1.1381486654281616,
-0.737724781036377,
0.2577468752861023,
-0.3089979887008667,
0.5992614030838013,
-0.6770318150520325,
-0.3276728391647339,
0.11554796993732452,
-0.31432804465293884,
0.394292414188385,
0.04205424338579178,
-0.3960932493209839,
-0.13216742873191833,
-0.17486466467380524,
0.8134366869926453,
0.264437735080719,
-0.2805512547492981,
0.5186776518821716,
0.49918293952941895,
-0.3539382219314575,
-0.6600045561790466,
-0.6162995100021362,
0.49356094002723694,
-0.3669704794883728,
-0.7567414045333862,
0.4867924153804779,
-0.12166905403137207,
-0.2405795305967331,
-0.03086189553141594,
-0.23829501867294312,
0.7611287236213684,
0.21899467706680298,
0.35926172137260437,
0.41134727001190186,
-0.2887745201587677,
0.4216287434101105,
-0.3673313856124878,
-0.6505956053733826,
-0.01195889338850975,
-0.691839873790741,
0.4713801145553589,
-0.5512480735778809,
-0.3381797671318054,
-0.8098559379577637,
0.4296892583370209,
1.1558806896209717,
-0.219345360994339,
0.9287724494934082,
0.3333185315132141,
-0.4166024923324585,
0.3987573981285095,
-0.6379337906837463,
0.2599204182624817,
-0.4914880692958832,
0.20616167783737183,
0.12199842929840088,
-1.2609553337097168,
0.288924902677536,
-0.045292582362890244,
0.309207022190094,
0.37808582186698914,
0.417217880487442,
-0.45889416337013245,
1.3638865947723389,
0.9311169385910034,
-0.32379573583602905,
0.4741503596305847,
-0.16519929468631744,
0.4638355076313019,
-0.9501283764839172,
-0.2901975214481354,
-0.4660778343677521,
-0.503043532371521,
-0.7246177792549133,
-0.19429132342338562,
0.41470447182655334,
-0.015184411779046059,
-0.8605563044548035,
0.012646147981286049,
-0.41160669922828674,
0.6739300489425659,
0.43196603655815125,
-0.32474005222320557,
-0.004619506187736988,
-0.31600573658943176,
-0.03864455223083496,
-0.008145377039909363,
-0.5286023616790771,
-1.0051440000534058,
0.6994965672492981,
0.23545804619789124,
0.7445856332778931,
0.3135742247104645,
0.40072187781333923,
0.07627841830253601,
0.31873923540115356,
-0.5867888331413269,
0.7594103217124939,
-0.4857816994190216,
-0.48415669798851013,
-0.559240996837616,
-0.15573754906654358,
-1.0338225364685059,
-0.119393490254879,
-0.12753988802433014,
-0.8942349553108215,
0.1594005674123764,
0.167455792427063,
-0.7901933193206787,
0.17641371488571167,
-0.22007519006729126,
0.7086337804794312,
-0.5059268474578857,
-0.4855966866016388,
-0.341717004776001,
-1.062696099281311,
0.1051204577088356,
0.171352356672287,
0.2608081102371216,
-0.3764905333518982,
-0.03892308473587036,
0.4855513572692871,
-0.3194756507873535,
0.9512753486633301,
0.08839510381221771,
-0.35625430941581726,
-0.051682427525520325,
0.07679841667413712,
0.45801809430122375,
-0.015213126316666603,
-0.06561195105314255,
0.09146448969841003,
0.11052750051021576,
-0.6300117373466492,
-0.39937207102775574,
0.8067121505737305,
-0.9950549602508545,
-1.160058856010437,
-0.514462411403656,
-0.8532437682151794,
-0.2801794111728668,
0.17907074093818665,
0.03304824233055115,
0.3696850836277008,
-0.2222518026828766,
0.258832186460495,
0.8017122745513916,
-0.19521379470825195,
0.4924911856651306,
0.15145865082740784,
0.14257307350635529,
-0.18220965564250946,
1.0587698221206665,
0.24861536920070648,
0.4438683092594147,
0.0005153678357601166,
0.2596699297428131,
-0.5519670844078064,
-0.41376081109046936,
-0.6504535675048828,
0.5025477409362793,
-0.4668073058128357,
-0.01874077133834362,
-0.10156670212745667,
-0.23336182534694672,
-0.5852147936820984,
-0.7083204388618469,
-0.35675790905952454,
-0.22338762879371643,
-0.5620582103729248,
0.004742578603327274,
0.11640208214521408,
0.8979983329772949,
-0.23213203251361847,
0.12737658619880676,
-1.041896939277649,
0.1214836984872818,
0.286762535572052,
0.37391412258148193,
-0.10995279252529144,
-0.6069144010543823,
-0.23640845715999603,
0.30031606554985046,
-0.2217392474412918,
-0.26673662662506104,
-0.06350694596767426,
0.2127881795167923,
0.6049295663833618,
0.4809686243534088,
0.07205909490585327,
0.9744452238082886,
-0.5874627828598022,
0.910222589969635,
0.2083623856306076,
-0.9356296062469482,
0.37720364332199097,
-0.4098549485206604,
0.42881304025650024,
0.6982856392860413,
0.579876720905304,
-1.0366514921188354,
-0.28292474150657654,
-0.525082528591156,
-1.048747181892395,
0.5336662530899048,
-0.16757802665233612,
0.5493295788764954,
0.09985044598579407,
0.6622578501701355,
-0.20451898872852325,
-0.035420309752225876,
-0.6350459456443787,
0.0272339079529047,
-0.06223683059215546,
-0.29837432503700256,
-0.12926343083381653,
0.028107505291700363,
-0.3084295392036438,
-0.20742300152778625,
0.8130907416343689,
-0.16526278853416443,
-0.12615247070789337,
0.062216561287641525,
-0.056837297976017,
-0.11899666488170624,
0.25745469331741333,
0.8185591697692871,
0.7653501033782959,
0.13465669751167297,
0.02039453759789467,
0.06766662001609802,
-0.33121809363365173,
0.7036533355712891,
-0.18014408648014069,
-0.079086534678936,
-0.7401010990142822,
0.29436740279197693,
0.5504117608070374,
0.15574316680431366,
-0.5847662091255188,
0.3307153582572937,
0.19643929600715637,
0.09422069042921066,
-0.3088947534561157,
0.26804429292678833,
0.2569420337677002,
0.4590217173099518,
0.20299021899700165,
-0.014401767402887344,
-0.6069073677062988,
-0.7654641270637512,
0.04054640978574753,
0.526909351348877,
-0.5731832385063171,
-0.16884049773216248,
0.6703538298606873,
0.17603689432144165,
-0.635260820388794,
0.8833719491958618,
-0.2923172414302826,
-0.5839603543281555,
0.5013440251350403,
0.542251706123352,
0.6466782689094543,
-0.5934345126152039,
0.09181337803602219,
-0.152587428689003,
0.3933618366718292,
-0.45652592182159424,
0.10529913008213043,
0.27011144161224365,
-1.0226645469665527,
-0.42552658915519714,
-0.5278522372245789,
-0.3482745289802551,
0.11173038184642792,
-0.542578399181366,
-0.06491982936859131,
-0.712087869644165,
-0.1433596909046173,
-0.2747146487236023,
-0.25775355100631714,
-0.33740630745887756,
0.17466077208518982,
0.3280208706855774,
0.48175346851348877,
-0.7362757325172424,
0.6076091527938843,
0.8568812608718872,
-0.22507166862487793,
-0.727570116519928,
0.3269364833831787,
0.3699367940425873,
-0.952431321144104,
0.39790841937065125,
0.369250625371933,
-0.6928935050964355,
0.1716991662979126,
-0.934415876865387,
-0.988387942314148,
0.977264404296875,
0.8297472596168518,
-0.6009242534637451,
-0.30868518352508545,
0.3077218532562256,
0.6300792694091797,
-0.32137665152549744,
-0.38032838702201843,
0.9702296257019043,
0.5706203579902649,
-0.1717969924211502,
-0.7574308514595032,
0.17321786284446716,
-0.21947719156742096,
0.14220145344734192,
0.3537099361419678,
-1.1808594465255737,
0.5286094546318054,
-0.388827383518219,
-0.6491336822509766,
0.11967355012893677,
0.43166330456733704,
0.3859449028968811,
-0.047851789742708206,
0.47236737608909607,
0.8486089706420898,
0.7859122157096863,
-0.022811248898506165,
0.8674243092536926,
-0.36286962032318115,
0.24573127925395966,
0.7629551887512207,
-0.5203579068183899,
0.6425821781158447,
0.4074644446372986,
-0.20240412652492523,
0.6259814500808716,
0.5388925075531006,
0.04563580080866814,
-0.028675906360149384,
0.23110289871692657,
-0.24433675408363342,
-0.7202329635620117,
-0.5817752480506897,
-0.6037840247154236,
0.5996364951133728,
0.7878838777542114,
0.2463260143995285,
0.028776053339242935,
-0.2993597686290741,
0.23931778967380524,
0.030268438160419464,
-0.3066318929195404,
0.4177384376525879,
0.17260873317718506,
-0.7645033001899719,
0.7115868330001831,
-0.2760227620601654,
0.4764392673969269,
-0.3762591779232025,
0.013431155122816563,
-0.25684720277786255,
0.26660412549972534,
-0.15433131158351898,
-0.7077757716178894,
0.3528018295764923,
-0.22742098569869995,
-0.09054479748010635,
-0.5657846927642822,
0.2544441521167755,
-0.0007983371615409851,
-0.5596908926963806,
0.23557597398757935,
0.20627963542938232,
0.10169035196304321,
0.4375344514846802,
-0.9649739265441895,
0.22405365109443665,
-0.1501842886209488,
0.08511784672737122,
0.2904239296913147,
0.3697671592235565,
-0.29486051201820374,
1.0099009275436401,
0.8477041125297546,
-0.04369049519300461,
-0.23406001925468445,
0.13169261813163757,
0.7220398783683777,
-0.8428966999053955,
-0.5737423300743103,
-1.1352617740631104,
0.4810056686401367,
0.25369420647621155,
-0.6820421814918518,
0.20262107253074646,
0.12463047355413437,
0.8802130222320557,
0.5427218079566956,
0.6828105449676514,
0.17440392076969147,
-0.16323676705360413,
-0.6614050269126892,
0.6438730359077454,
-0.743666410446167,
0.4697604775428772,
-0.013051156885921955,
-0.6214632987976074,
-0.5508185029029846,
0.7086872458457947,
-0.2239837795495987,
-0.002703453879803419,
0.35483482480049133,
0.8398849964141846,
0.23150818049907684,
0.032143447548151016,
0.34512993693351746,
0.2997257113456726,
0.4721330404281616,
0.71454256772995,
1.2104640007019043,
-0.04807504639029503,
0.5534347891807556,
0.5665729641914368,
-0.010410553775727749,
-0.43173477053642273,
-0.9358463883399963,
-0.18768085539340973,
-0.49265143275260925,
-0.31431373953819275,
-0.2097214311361313,
0.42063915729522705,
1.0231558084487915,
0.8402299284934998,
-0.7075772285461426,
-0.24131575226783752,
-0.25617146492004395,
0.11306203901767731,
-0.13547635078430176,
-0.17141053080558777,
0.23000480234622955,
-0.28181031346321106,
-0.6191127300262451,
0.3544808030128479,
0.6766610145568848,
0.2932835817337036,
-0.5894208550453186,
-0.10239386558532715,
-0.41161537170410156,
0.3074055314064026,
0.30327001214027405,
0.5998897552490234,
-0.9130955934524536,
-1.0372726917266846,
-0.1550547480583191,
-0.24295122921466827,
0.2054852396249771,
0.9255394339561462,
-0.5598288774490356,
0.13874492049217224,
0.05269036069512367,
0.9081276655197144,
-0.22762441635131836,
0.07462567090988159,
0.8147135376930237,
-0.5038561224937439,
-0.23393334448337555,
0.391833633184433,
0.29222744703292847,
0.5994777679443359,
-0.45866674184799194,
0.294973760843277,
0.30874571204185486,
-1.0154176950454712,
-0.7899913191795349,
0.7405617833137512,
-0.48855817317962646,
-0.22104915976524353,
0.9018111228942871,
-0.17356587946414948,
0.027698103338479996,
-0.6193828582763672,
-0.030605163425207138,
0.30736199021339417,
-0.21412751078605652,
0.8474996089935303,
0.8826082348823547,
-0.3922800123691559,
0.007488425821065903,
-0.5531085729598999,
0.33851104974746704,
0.8320274949073792,
-0.6514325737953186,
0.39412808418273926,
0.5766253471374512,
0.1726033240556717,
0.3535480201244354,
0.3633143901824951,
-0.05813005566596985,
0.30620077252388,
-0.21904288232326508,
-0.1846591830253601,
0.2691197991371155,
-0.5385165214538574,
-0.5646819472312927,
-0.09747947007417679,
-0.09813476353883743,
0.07989729940891266
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15426v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15426v1
|
A Three-Phases SFT Hybrid Model Integrated Strong Prior Module and Data Overlap Estimation in the Eduation Context
| 2024-03-13T05:38:39 | 2024-03-13T05:38:39 |
Zhangquan Chen, Chunjiang Liu, Haobin Duan
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, I.2.7
|
In this paper, we propose an end-to-end prior-based three-phases supervised
fine-tuned model, which is proved more competitive than traditional fine-tuning
method. More specifically, our model realizes the structural disassembly and
incremental guided output of educational knowledge. To this end, we robustify
data classification of three types via a sampler and overlap estimation neural
network, and inject the preprocessing datasets into pre-trained model in three
batches for LORA fine-tuning. Then, we design a prior module couples system
prompt, vector databases, and abstract syntax tree task segmentation. Finally,
the compression method and regularization constraint are applied to the
prior-based fine-tuned model, followed by text filter at the output end to
obtain incremental guided results. Our model represents the first research
effort to truly embody the tutor role with the features of abundant educational
knowledge, step-by-step incremental guided outputs and non-disclosure of
answers. Extensive experiments report that our model also achieves
state-of-the-art in code abilities compared to open-source models, reaching an
impressive 75.10% on the HumanEval (@pass 1) benchmark. Additionally, our model
maintains strong conversational capabilities, with the 13B quantized version
achieving scores of 56.34, 50.60, and 45.27 respectively on the MMLU, C-Eval,
and AGIEval (5 shot) dialogue evaluation benchmarks.
|
[
-0.3527757227420807,
-1.3164398670196533,
0.51227867603302,
-0.08347222954034805,
-0.13911643624305725,
0.1515118032693863,
-0.1584194004535675,
-0.44451451301574707,
-0.16751068830490112,
0.4866003394126892,
-0.5007984638214111,
-0.5923584699630737,
-0.40108469128608704,
-0.12633170187473297,
-0.5394830107688904,
0.7875413298606873,
-0.13348594307899475,
0.04095069319009781,
-0.123918317258358,
0.37189561128616333,
-0.5462218523025513,
-0.22951149940490723,
-0.5466018915176392,
-0.2773919701576233,
0.03990073502063751,
0.5219674110412598,
0.2992313504219055,
0.41797277331352234,
0.30223244428634644,
0.32751503586769104,
-0.3796732425689697,
0.19097885489463806,
-0.3935856521129608,
-0.3642856180667877,
-0.11973728239536285,
-0.6317564845085144,
-0.6808063387870789,
0.05974297598004341,
0.6079399585723877,
0.8509112000465393,
-0.17700228095054626,
-0.10675662755966187,
0.5010756254196167,
0.5903622508049011,
-0.5185830593109131,
0.01909145899116993,
-0.5518466234207153,
0.09409438073635101,
0.08562791347503662,
-0.23610468208789825,
-0.32480260729789734,
-0.41390687227249146,
0.264148086309433,
-0.7214894890785217,
0.15150301158428192,
-0.45740142464637756,
0.6570329666137695,
0.47152987122535706,
-0.6470375657081604,
0.2978689968585968,
-0.615487277507782,
0.5802812576293945,
-0.7793800234794617,
0.40542569756507874,
0.42956089973449707,
0.32220929861068726,
-0.26740190386772156,
-0.7360084056854248,
-0.6886270046234131,
0.006261785048991442,
0.04717407375574112,
0.4092130661010742,
0.1022416278719902,
0.4535856544971466,
0.08808509260416031,
0.48589572310447693,
-0.3378058969974518,
0.31770023703575134,
-0.728006899356842,
0.0415584035217762,
0.20290248095989227,
0.15719684958457947,
-0.08329328894615173,
-0.2097848653793335,
-0.6299367547035217,
0.12000472843647003,
-0.5802637934684753,
0.16679471731185913,
0.7273693680763245,
0.3192571997642517,
-0.18608145415782928,
0.557021975517273,
-0.42008644342422485,
0.9945364594459534,
0.22554993629455566,
0.02347378246486187,
0.0579090416431427,
-0.5248463153839111,
-0.2763088643550873,
-0.21846114099025726,
0.7658571600914001,
0.08426470309495926,
0.4000808298587799,
0.2776656150817871,
-0.025300201028585434,
0.22869864106178284,
0.1851004809141159,
-0.6798638105392456,
-0.2854086756706238,
0.2559148371219635,
-0.13277371227741241,
-0.2410329431295395,
0.09280510991811752,
-0.5289309620857239,
0.05820669233798981,
-0.7797161936759949,
0.7033491134643555,
-0.7988263964653015,
-0.4662177860736847,
0.5408896803855896,
0.3743176758289337,
-0.15372222661972046,
0.39775681495666504,
-0.7228809595108032,
0.6204976439476013,
0.8224179148674011,
0.8895649909973145,
-0.3819701373577118,
-0.4405333995819092,
-0.23330672085285187,
0.005662428215146065,
-0.15847979485988617,
0.5812761187553406,
-0.5820879340171814,
-0.14604823291301727,
-0.08783122897148132,
0.02527058869600296,
-0.4409060776233673,
-0.24679724872112274,
0.36073175072669983,
-0.3006133437156677,
0.5434106588363647,
0.3871900737285614,
-0.7576722502708435,
-0.41622838377952576,
0.11279495060443878,
-0.39319202303886414,
1.2307870388031006,
0.46550366282463074,
-0.6497054100036621,
0.27532583475112915,
-0.6378553509712219,
-0.340328574180603,
0.08782530575990677,
-0.14574019610881805,
-0.2012435644865036,
-0.3473650813102722,
0.27462056279182434,
0.6623163819313049,
0.10478735715150833,
0.7074328064918518,
-0.15309415757656097,
-0.8290712237358093,
-0.1822056621313095,
-0.28914153575897217,
0.6980944275856018,
-0.1546504646539688,
-0.2971264719963074,
0.3229372501373291,
-0.9318456649780273,
-0.06928396224975586,
-0.32111355662345886,
-0.30993252992630005,
-0.5293105840682983,
-0.32463571429252625,
-0.04624539613723755,
0.20836956799030304,
0.43965256214141846,
-0.4962173402309418,
0.1416993886232376,
-0.5420268774032593,
0.6037855744361877,
0.8887507915496826,
0.06556018441915512,
0.23136842250823975,
-0.18523454666137695,
0.6982941031455994,
0.32827430963516235,
0.37701812386512756,
-0.3573055565357208,
-0.41318854689598083,
-0.7260937690734863,
-0.29601070284843445,
0.4049927890300751,
0.4164085388183594,
-0.6795569658279419,
0.758281946182251,
-0.10448437184095383,
-0.2542773485183716,
-0.31588494777679443,
0.0027992415707558393,
0.2081381380558014,
0.6470614671707153,
0.3998132348060608,
-0.0028985533863306046,
-0.5010972619056702,
-0.9170543551445007,
0.1294998675584793,
-0.03181370347738266,
0.1388678252696991,
0.005177149083465338,
0.7370842695236206,
-0.05901772156357765,
1.0572497844696045,
-0.5832411646842957,
-0.4345759451389313,
0.10539359599351883,
0.03637685626745224,
0.4323202073574066,
0.8850516080856323,
0.3783717453479767,
-0.7390396595001221,
-0.4613037109375,
0.1378970593214035,
-0.5566744804382324,
0.14817599952220917,
0.06112262234091759,
-0.4370546340942383,
-0.28601181507110596,
0.41317108273506165,
-0.3053743839263916,
0.2891535460948944,
0.4130484163761139,
-0.3255341947078705,
0.3946113586425781,
-0.003104627598077059,
0.3030795753002167,
-1.314929485321045,
-0.2340233325958252,
0.0758800134062767,
-0.21226805448532104,
-0.49472296237945557,
0.03581079840660095,
0.21128806471824646,
0.04044348746538162,
-0.23567380011081696,
0.2111460566520691,
-0.22097091376781464,
0.22461481392383575,
-0.2026005983352661,
0.2983956038951874,
-0.03851079195737839,
0.8498427271842957,
-0.01398343127220869,
0.8059030175209045,
0.4994681179523468,
-0.47363796830177307,
-0.026661673560738564,
0.264311283826828,
-0.478790283203125,
0.9224806427955627,
-0.9314144849777222,
0.07660727947950363,
0.2544478178024292,
0.07905256748199463,
-0.9226475358009338,
-0.1677146553993225,
0.09353046119213104,
-0.170602947473526,
0.23348844051361084,
-0.3913472294807434,
-0.4088835120201111,
-0.566981315612793,
-0.29677972197532654,
0.338420033454895,
0.18210813403129578,
-0.530884325504303,
0.6356125473976135,
0.09450247138738632,
-0.3044993579387665,
-0.48057734966278076,
-0.3375900387763977,
-0.41838833689689636,
-0.12939271330833435,
-0.6957168579101562,
0.43698856234550476,
-0.19481103122234344,
0.30821919441223145,
-0.013328992761671543,
-0.16440311074256897,
-0.3950728178024292,
0.09027514606714249,
0.2814261317253113,
0.4777003228664398,
-0.4010277986526489,
-0.2148021012544632,
0.5229213237762451,
0.1267743706703186,
-0.14970573782920837,
-0.33727145195007324,
0.5181493759155273,
-0.1233239620923996,
-0.6097266674041748,
-0.5949375629425049,
0.055984772741794586,
0.3777852952480316,
-0.13922333717346191,
0.47911107540130615,
0.5996654033660889,
-0.6123825311660767,
-0.16596931219100952,
-0.5422137975692749,
-0.13987143337726593,
-0.5339913368225098,
0.488857626914978,
-0.3933662474155426,
-1.224616289138794,
0.42177465558052063,
0.08643373101949692,
0.02387293241918087,
0.19741295278072357,
0.04535778984427452,
0.19170372188091278,
0.9416378736495972,
0.9468156695365906,
0.26658961176872253,
0.8093422055244446,
-0.4454677999019623,
-0.13591815531253815,
-1.010778546333313,
-0.24085450172424316,
-0.09995301812887192,
-0.228763610124588,
-0.05875517800450325,
-0.145843967795372,
0.455112099647522,
0.5801961421966553,
-0.3575209379196167,
0.43022146821022034,
-0.593429684638977,
0.5147645473480225,
0.5638946890830994,
0.5956546068191528,
0.380665123462677,
-0.046063974499702454,
0.02503749541938305,
0.046621616929769516,
-0.6080985069274902,
-0.20479318499565125,
1.227403998374939,
0.3371376097202301,
0.44193804264068604,
-0.018206829205155373,
0.6406629681587219,
0.16780009865760803,
-0.007854633033275604,
-0.5557852387428284,
0.5020893216133118,
0.04795306548476219,
-0.43591567873954773,
-0.2720491290092468,
-0.40626341104507446,
-0.5801505446434021,
0.36536943912506104,
-0.05196008458733559,
-0.9489266872406006,
0.07210078835487366,
-0.009786182083189487,
-0.715643584728241,
0.0879710242152214,
-0.965481698513031,
0.7484574317932129,
0.0044280048459768295,
-0.735770046710968,
-0.2652041018009186,
-0.44673898816108704,
0.7198277115821838,
-0.44048169255256653,
-0.03041497804224491,
-0.00014741615450475365,
0.2582337558269501,
1.0500047206878662,
-0.48595112562179565,
1.010682463645935,
-0.16928264498710632,
-0.16030952334403992,
0.3452645242214203,
-0.09236542880535126,
0.4928208887577057,
-0.15317703783512115,
0.0664464682340622,
0.0036008378956466913,
0.3171331584453583,
-0.25484776496887207,
-0.6194365620613098,
0.7466073632240295,
-0.6920791864395142,
-0.5339511036872864,
0.07372686266899109,
-0.515926718711853,
-0.38049599528312683,
0.23579591512680054,
0.0008467158768326044,
0.5410279035568237,
-0.02220410853624344,
0.11442860960960388,
0.5289875268936157,
-0.013315177522599697,
0.16588695347309113,
0.7995507717132568,
-0.13101129233837128,
-0.480446994304657,
0.8149466514587402,
0.11178981512784958,
0.3805946409702301,
0.3127470016479492,
0.1394805908203125,
-0.07609912753105164,
-0.5113927125930786,
-0.2571670711040497,
0.08313605189323425,
-0.5626622438430786,
-0.2651507258415222,
-0.8343281149864197,
-0.2996298670768738,
-0.43805190920829773,
-0.3320573568344116,
-0.369201123714447,
-0.4394882023334503,
-0.38595321774482727,
-0.3181115388870239,
0.5857014656066895,
1.1060670614242554,
-0.005999712273478508,
0.8484131693840027,
-0.3580835461616516,
0.20446240901947021,
0.131898894906044,
0.6116380095481873,
-0.04470575973391533,
-0.6988462805747986,
-0.4536506235599518,
0.11116145551204681,
-0.3304385244846344,
-0.7855158448219299,
-0.005343648139387369,
0.14800779521465302,
0.4914275109767914,
0.4925040304660797,
-0.15535087883472443,
0.7337158918380737,
-0.2140461653470993,
0.8254033327102661,
0.17832663655281067,
-0.8626418709754944,
0.6234673261642456,
-0.6754593849182129,
0.15510566532611847,
0.5927950143814087,
0.224242702126503,
0.10142240673303604,
-0.2924611568450928,
-0.6528632044792175,
-0.9576893448829651,
0.8959087133407593,
0.09487313032150269,
-0.2038869708776474,
0.18373259902000427,
0.25320354104042053,
0.4045540988445282,
0.3715124726295471,
-0.6083611845970154,
-0.10305235534906387,
-0.14659559726715088,
-0.47166672348976135,
0.25484344363212585,
-0.21292635798454285,
-0.010170304216444492,
-0.521413266658783,
0.6548231244087219,
-0.3088254928588867,
-0.052798885852098465,
-0.14159783720970154,
0.07701433449983597,
-0.027959534898400307,
0.30317550897598267,
0.398030549287796,
0.6528415083885193,
-0.3934321105480194,
-0.22444528341293335,
0.0872935876250267,
-0.7382245659828186,
-0.017902208492159843,
0.6233665943145752,
-0.13392192125320435,
-0.30237525701522827,
0.18139488995075226,
0.7054821252822876,
0.6114774346351624,
-0.29386648535728455,
0.6610999703407288,
0.2799634337425232,
-0.3201040029525757,
-0.29939332604408264,
0.26933911442756653,
-0.35423895716667175,
0.3906366229057312,
0.2574491798877716,
0.015247938223183155,
0.2063678354024887,
-0.08969234675168991,
0.33522552251815796,
0.2732149660587311,
-0.3293733596801758,
-0.369424432516098,
0.9288225769996643,
0.3266511559486389,
0.03646388277411461,
0.205937460064888,
0.36263543367385864,
-0.5938246846199036,
0.6908130645751953,
0.5621461272239685,
0.627118706703186,
-0.20299872756004333,
0.2992052137851715,
0.4440214931964874,
0.19156119227409363,
-0.26862066984176636,
0.5443770289421082,
-0.3929184675216675,
-0.5821624398231506,
-0.49224117398262024,
-0.5812817811965942,
-0.2982291281223297,
0.14319156110286713,
-0.8807113170623779,
0.5216274857521057,
-0.49645137786865234,
-0.03499263897538185,
-0.09753180295228958,
0.0045664808712899685,
-0.6431296467781067,
0.30748066306114197,
-0.2559050917625427,
0.8646125793457031,
-0.8495152592658997,
0.7962541580200195,
0.6246190667152405,
-0.47750186920166016,
-0.933593213558197,
-0.3531179428100586,
-0.24136778712272644,
-0.5426984429359436,
0.2422453761100769,
0.2674869894981384,
-0.11743884533643723,
0.42886099219322205,
-0.5645138025283813,
-0.7966323494911194,
1.1888381242752075,
0.2910594642162323,
-0.8097103834152222,
-0.21026121079921722,
-0.08836077153682709,
0.48472678661346436,
-0.3024975657463074,
0.5190221071243286,
0.8015463352203369,
0.12020479887723923,
-0.00500184902921319,
-0.8428385257720947,
-0.2584703862667084,
-0.36679133772850037,
-0.22508303821086884,
0.26466119289398193,
-0.5888410210609436,
0.9381240010261536,
-0.06875652074813843,
-0.15142814815044403,
0.18507875502109528,
0.7403355836868286,
0.143052339553833,
0.1560210883617401,
0.6181442141532898,
0.3799603283405304,
0.6648054122924805,
-0.13315165042877197,
0.604446530342102,
-0.6392690539360046,
0.264339804649353,
1.3495584726333618,
0.03469720855355263,
0.9032831788063049,
0.3843599855899811,
-0.3940441608428955,
0.5029693841934204,
0.8219152092933655,
0.05454909801483154,
0.4263857901096344,
-0.15985634922981262,
-0.05610223859548569,
-0.25049325823783875,
-0.07381591200828552,
-0.7109298706054688,
0.2372591644525528,
0.3962917625904083,
-0.16283242404460907,
0.13624036312103271,
0.18227210640907288,
-0.2981535792350769,
0.1868855506181717,
-0.1137901246547699,
0.43169599771499634,
-0.005273144692182541,
-0.583689272403717,
0.5571883916854858,
-0.18194060027599335,
1.0008385181427002,
-0.7421082854270935,
-0.16942648589611053,
-0.19154894351959229,
0.07903369516134262,
-0.3953678011894226,
-0.9423927068710327,
-0.1988418698310852,
-0.19308622181415558,
0.0075718555599451065,
0.047980111092329025,
0.43692976236343384,
-0.783039927482605,
-0.30263692140579224,
0.21389320492744446,
0.4734375476837158,
0.09110500663518906,
-0.023507868871092796,
-0.3250327706336975,
-0.19557252526283264,
-0.009185830131173134,
-0.29044845700263977,
0.03262099623680115,
0.4078233540058136,
0.038688987493515015,
0.3761286437511444,
0.5902353525161743,
-0.02462604269385338,
0.1175081878900528,
0.29998064041137695,
0.993954598903656,
-0.37869253754615784,
-0.7600616812705994,
-0.5619938969612122,
0.5740333199501038,
-0.015690144151449203,
-0.585058867931366,
0.4891364276409149,
0.5615254640579224,
0.983716607093811,
0.1927834153175354,
0.751587450504303,
0.16414837539196014,
0.46478956937789917,
-0.770409345626831,
0.36499303579330444,
-0.6216987371444702,
0.2420773208141327,
-0.7533238530158997,
-0.8860964179039001,
0.16297517716884613,
0.5321378707885742,
-0.3740026354789734,
0.190687894821167,
0.6459079384803772,
0.5914913415908813,
-0.3728834092617035,
0.5281363725662231,
0.33953455090522766,
0.21126236021518707,
-0.050429463386535645,
0.7123932838439941,
1.0167385339736938,
-0.6040248274803162,
0.2650037705898285,
-0.5089746117591858,
-0.362659752368927,
0.04170002415776253,
-0.31524479389190674,
-1.160014033317566,
-0.6591107249259949,
-0.3642725348472595,
-0.08062312006950378,
0.012889042496681213,
0.8075743317604065,
0.7966217994689941,
-0.6504117250442505,
-0.009776225313544273,
-0.2704057991504669,
-0.10447237640619278,
-0.283332884311676,
-0.2881115674972534,
0.3759254217147827,
0.18229296803474426,
-0.9147226214408875,
0.6521156430244446,
0.047470029443502426,
0.3117265999317169,
-0.3904911279678345,
0.16352099180221558,
-0.2942149341106415,
-0.21321673691272736,
0.5589235424995422,
-0.11203814297914505,
-0.6457797884941101,
-0.2642238438129425,
0.028932640329003334,
0.07337669283151627,
-0.05680607631802559,
0.6255061030387878,
-1.0035594701766968,
0.45580875873565674,
0.10499492287635803,
0.4852973520755768,
0.42574575543403625,
0.26974788308143616,
0.7505896091461182,
-0.5774394869804382,
0.28710803389549255,
-0.001030832645483315,
0.4909089505672455,
0.2943437099456787,
-0.7689207792282104,
0.7418856620788574,
0.03908104449510574,
-0.3789491653442383,
-0.7693888545036316,
0.08328645676374435,
-0.9332579374313354,
-0.2302941530942917,
0.9912816286087036,
-0.07807786017656326,
0.0864282175898552,
-0.14406771957874298,
-0.32504042983055115,
0.38769033551216125,
-0.39582183957099915,
0.635901153087616,
0.5904316306114197,
-0.08858907222747803,
-0.05969078838825226,
-0.6167837381362915,
0.1541389375925064,
0.48221009969711304,
-0.8134951591491699,
-0.2845337986946106,
0.6060411334037781,
0.24524681270122528,
-0.17658697068691254,
0.5397965908050537,
0.07104001939296722,
0.11908846348524094,
-0.055888403207063675,
-0.0673689991235733,
-0.47945621609687805,
-0.5870316028594971,
-0.23809026181697845,
0.22018282115459442,
-0.3763349950313568,
-0.29788294434547424
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08258v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08258v2
|
Skipformer: A Skip-and-Recover Strategy for Efficient Speech Recognition
| 2024-03-13T05:20:45 | 2024-05-21T02:06:26 |
Wenjing Zhu, Sining Sun, Changhao Shan, Peng Fan, Qing Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Conformer-based attention models have become the de facto backbone model for
Automatic Speech Recognition tasks. A blank symbol is usually introduced to
align the input and output sequences for CTC or RNN-T models. Unfortunately,
the long input length overloads computational budget and memory consumption
quadratically by attention mechanism. In this work, we propose a
"Skip-and-Recover" Conformer architecture, named Skipformer, to squeeze
sequence input length dynamically and inhomogeneously. Skipformer uses an
intermediate CTC output as criteria to split frames into three groups: crucial,
skipping and ignoring. The crucial group feeds into next conformer blocks and
its output joint with skipping group by original temporal order as the final
encoder output. Experiments show that our model reduces the input sequence
length by 31 times on Aishell-1 and 22 times on Librispeech corpus. Meanwhile,
the model can achieve better recognition accuracy and faster inference speed
than recent baseline models. Our code is open-sourced and available online.
|
[
-0.23083913326263428,
-0.38731029629707336,
0.5016865730285645,
0.10039115697145462,
-0.1782616525888443,
-0.06565117090940475,
0.05621853098273277,
-0.3274986445903778,
0.023304367437958717,
0.13934749364852905,
-0.31146833300590515,
0.09372398257255554,
-0.8887653946876526,
-0.03511488065123558,
-0.562128484249115,
0.5834194421768188,
0.017736142501235008,
-0.008069979026913643,
0.40366414189338684,
-0.08950521796941757,
-0.6719869375228882,
-0.11100255697965622,
-0.9241405725479126,
-0.0496147982776165,
0.5602321028709412,
0.26818931102752686,
0.38575318455696106,
1.1047122478485107,
0.19230493903160095,
0.28399965167045593,
-0.4992164373397827,
-0.2641938626766205,
-0.5541127920150757,
0.09893185645341873,
0.27368685603141785,
-0.05817011743783951,
-0.5379253029823303,
-0.024989275261759758,
0.8070987462997437,
0.4888373613357544,
-0.1360357701778412,
0.18677093088626862,
0.04474393278360367,
0.5978365540504456,
-0.8420740962028503,
0.11561872810125351,
-0.5752871036529541,
-0.1504148244857788,
-0.18260562419891357,
0.1938760131597519,
-0.4830557107925415,
-0.6138994693756104,
0.06941208243370056,
-0.2255101352930069,
0.26523658633232117,
-0.23633253574371338,
0.5687869787216187,
0.5572470426559448,
0.07004819065332413,
-0.11428125202655792,
-0.881544291973114,
0.413629412651062,
-0.6653167605400085,
1.0769357681274414,
0.30798399448394775,
0.5455994009971619,
0.12695954740047455,
-0.5863725543022156,
-0.6622127890586853,
-0.050665341317653656,
0.10863897949457169,
0.1465420126914978,
-0.23234118521213531,
-0.04552857577800751,
0.2754054367542267,
0.3307359516620636,
-0.7035133242607117,
0.027549944818019867,
-0.7430708408355713,
-0.3622227609157562,
0.22902637720108032,
-0.0913686528801918,
0.1313026398420334,
0.1407240629196167,
-0.02030457742512226,
0.09344566613435745,
-0.5027793645858765,
0.2566428482532501,
0.07274658977985382,
0.28184518218040466,
-0.09623529016971588,
0.3813369572162628,
0.02818448469042778,
1.0153785943984985,
0.7168298959732056,
-0.08168567717075348,
0.06358808279037476,
-0.14743956923484802,
-0.3339999318122864,
0.41532567143440247,
0.35025250911712646,
-0.15781810879707336,
0.20064924657344818,
-0.21691200137138367,
-0.109473817050457,
0.08495532721281052,
0.3221544027328491,
-0.7127800583839417,
-0.34427863359451294,
0.2910608649253845,
-0.3763945400714874,
0.04564153030514717,
-0.04164222255349159,
-0.4652765393257141,
0.020625442266464233,
-0.26964491605758667,
0.3363642394542694,
-0.5993044376373291,
0.2567664384841919,
-0.028308935463428497,
-0.14600835740566254,
0.27138447761535645,
0.492527037858963,
-0.577502965927124,
0.47363564372062683,
0.3521174490451813,
1.068757176399231,
-0.3871653079986572,
0.17920447885990143,
-1.2296175956726074,
0.2118435502052307,
-0.02871556021273136,
0.4943392276763916,
-0.4772818684577942,
-0.5820616483688354,
-0.47739240527153015,
0.036301374435424805,
-0.22123168408870697,
-0.4811033308506012,
0.3372320830821991,
-0.7583335041999817,
0.2846132218837738,
0.17911991477012634,
-0.6921058297157288,
-0.350666880607605,
0.04605980962514877,
-1.0566142797470093,
0.4519396424293518,
-0.08739784359931946,
-0.46612006425857544,
0.3056543469429016,
-0.5962098836898804,
-0.18208570778369904,
0.13574835658073425,
0.16816438734531403,
-0.536716103553772,
0.04348015785217285,
0.22877253592014313,
0.18442708253860474,
-0.03430265188217163,
-0.0034052645787596703,
-0.42826834321022034,
-0.496766597032547,
0.02631089836359024,
-0.5359872579574585,
0.646785318851471,
0.1062871441245079,
-0.21604809165000916,
0.14242073893547058,
-1.1150909662246704,
-0.10719785839319229,
-0.004592776298522949,
-0.821006715297699,
-0.19685178995132446,
-0.05317804217338562,
0.38498052954673767,
0.3640880286693573,
-0.03976894170045853,
-0.7568113207817078,
-0.12129943072795868,
-0.5171517729759216,
0.5358166098594666,
0.6675023436546326,
-0.07964707165956497,
0.7271468639373779,
-0.26935335993766785,
0.3964819014072418,
-0.011748396791517735,
0.05496056377887726,
-0.3005308210849762,
0.013470802456140518,
-0.7616109848022461,
-0.7269564867019653,
0.5117077231407166,
0.6371837854385376,
-0.07325063645839691,
0.5040084719657898,
-0.3002053201198578,
-0.3583774268627167,
-0.6177313923835754,
-0.09455038607120514,
0.39458921551704407,
0.6252524852752686,
0.40658068656921387,
-0.24069514870643616,
-0.53512042760849,
-0.6820865869522095,
-0.2522636651992798,
-0.03538397699594498,
-0.283353328704834,
0.14519833028316498,
0.06931885331869125,
-0.04595504328608513,
1.039039969444275,
-0.3615856170654297,
-0.371473103761673,
-0.2877446413040161,
-0.3402925729751587,
0.34803763031959534,
0.5587276220321655,
0.10774878412485123,
-0.7800130248069763,
-0.3190903961658478,
-0.2802572250366211,
-0.08512021601200104,
0.11488986760377884,
-0.02106425166130066,
0.14083430171012878,
0.13545000553131104,
0.2713764011859894,
-0.332271546125412,
0.6566774845123291,
0.31430763006210327,
-0.03162937983870506,
0.16353657841682434,
0.20997445285320282,
-0.1829918622970581,
-0.7527822256088257,
0.2852744162082672,
-0.25966382026672363,
-0.4811878204345703,
-0.7291415929794312,
-0.5555641651153564,
0.23343749344348907,
-0.1946651041507721,
-0.5624744296073914,
0.7205929160118103,
-0.53448486328125,
0.07395102828741074,
-0.30030369758605957,
0.02102348394691944,
-0.24688337743282318,
0.4972328841686249,
0.19966508448123932,
0.771815836429596,
0.34174662828445435,
-0.9073673486709595,
-0.19326311349868774,
0.3733915090560913,
0.2188856452703476,
0.1913648098707199,
-0.9320142865180969,
0.4941422641277313,
-0.3170589506626129,
0.23003728687763214,
-1.0886629819869995,
-0.2791316509246826,
0.19309388101100922,
-0.5732235908508301,
0.5663233995437622,
-0.2691574692726135,
-0.030737558379769325,
-0.36479514837265015,
-0.13179540634155273,
0.7353746891021729,
0.6460654735565186,
-0.5814223885536194,
0.8891754150390625,
0.4276275634765625,
-0.23924608528614044,
-0.2726220190525055,
-0.5259829163551331,
-0.34086719155311584,
-0.11026790738105774,
-0.28299686312675476,
0.2850169241428375,
-0.17520259320735931,
0.0923851951956749,
-0.24110864102840424,
-0.5065562725067139,
-0.20892813801765442,
-0.3128230571746826,
0.433856338262558,
0.23616214096546173,
-0.07188794761896133,
-0.06778336316347122,
-0.031927142292261124,
0.027708396315574646,
-0.4008842408657074,
-0.5726639628410339,
0.482097864151001,
0.025006961077451706,
-0.09074436128139496,
-0.5753260254859924,
0.24359345436096191,
0.5940094590187073,
-0.3069106638431549,
0.21681101620197296,
0.3200153112411499,
-0.5408216714859009,
0.16704390943050385,
-0.7969372868537903,
0.015045837499201298,
-0.43960872292518616,
0.4092054069042206,
-0.09340203553438187,
-0.9026106595993042,
0.2695838212966919,
0.20986150205135345,
0.37809523940086365,
0.27085810899734497,
0.47899895906448364,
0.0948842391371727,
0.5307212471961975,
0.6101259589195251,
-0.17932432889938354,
0.5156606435775757,
-0.048818983137607574,
0.07206636667251587,
-0.8389211297035217,
-0.10727287083864212,
-0.32902437448501587,
-0.4129607677459717,
0.06454327702522278,
-0.4889223873615265,
0.3883380889892578,
-0.014695036225020885,
-0.18127822875976562,
0.452759325504303,
-0.4472016394138336,
0.37785497307777405,
0.248472660779953,
0.009911518543958664,
0.12837280333042145,
-0.2805175483226776,
0.06786374747753143,
-0.027573343366384506,
-0.6399673819541931,
-0.28999775648117065,
0.6817463040351868,
0.4130631387233734,
0.804499089717865,
0.08281832933425903,
0.8689303994178772,
0.25406283140182495,
0.19792376458644867,
-0.9718486070632935,
0.42080923914909363,
-0.23712190985679626,
-0.3019542098045349,
-0.40936365723609924,
-0.21152687072753906,
-0.7047326564788818,
0.019506195560097694,
0.370223730802536,
-0.6774237155914307,
0.46188223361968994,
0.5497390627861023,
-0.6693488955497742,
0.1653522551059723,
-0.31416594982147217,
0.5072728991508484,
0.16367106139659882,
-0.2634561359882355,
-0.028149133548140526,
-0.8225374817848206,
0.5165117979049683,
-0.24130472540855408,
0.0746164545416832,
0.11173345148563385,
0.018957218155264854,
0.8441521525382996,
-0.31726643443107605,
0.6288628578186035,
-0.2981686294078827,
0.09896162897348404,
0.13080139458179474,
0.26438552141189575,
0.36593717336654663,
-0.08879423886537552,
0.14840087294578552,
0.05704030767083168,
-0.3318268656730652,
-0.13045306503772736,
-0.46008744835853577,
0.356330007314682,
-0.38643401861190796,
-0.32785579562187195,
-0.1846534013748169,
-0.5646400451660156,
-0.2402818351984024,
0.34006553888320923,
0.269682914018631,
0.5352931022644043,
-0.4970199465751648,
-0.03258009999990463,
0.7654406428337097,
0.1765146404504776,
0.8982316255569458,
0.6481369137763977,
0.2548274099826813,
-0.7379270195960999,
0.6215595006942749,
0.14959616959095,
0.23960375785827637,
0.47224751114845276,
-0.04309719428420067,
-0.4427323043346405,
-0.3475482761859894,
-0.2985267639160156,
0.3542337119579315,
-0.35787421464920044,
-0.13980227708816528,
-0.9583097100257874,
-0.42577552795410156,
-0.5806366205215454,
0.0008615977130830288,
-0.48421868681907654,
-0.6747874617576599,
-0.3560979962348938,
0.0769224464893341,
0.13373705744743347,
0.4410221576690674,
-0.18253430724143982,
0.48858797550201416,
-1.0457863807678223,
0.44734498858451843,
0.43042075634002686,
0.283418208360672,
0.22101226449012756,
-0.8290051221847534,
-0.0991891622543335,
-0.3979750871658325,
-0.3034228980541229,
-0.9129509329795837,
0.4771922528743744,
0.37362053990364075,
0.46380916237831116,
0.5069857239723206,
-0.21451935172080994,
0.8703560829162598,
-0.8985753059387207,
0.25825902819633484,
0.16660116612911224,
-1.0597174167633057,
0.48267966508865356,
-0.009201720356941223,
0.6999255418777466,
0.37443169951438904,
0.2496233582496643,
-0.5064785480499268,
-0.3142361640930176,
-0.47242113947868347,
-0.8311171531677246,
0.8346017003059387,
0.21756447851657867,
-0.3946034610271454,
0.04104774072766304,
0.2593880295753479,
0.11728967726230621,
-0.08145607262849808,
-0.5192629098892212,
0.11142374575138092,
-0.24791918694972992,
-0.39224526286125183,
-0.002916341181844473,
-0.23671264946460724,
0.1074495017528534,
-0.053512707352638245,
0.6051511764526367,
0.11012032628059387,
0.30663391947746277,
0.26271435618400574,
-0.429777592420578,
0.20527009665966034,
0.3223438560962677,
0.570319652557373,
0.1498280018568039,
-0.11858057230710983,
-0.12091826647520065,
0.11794334650039673,
-0.7334903478622437,
0.29711949825286865,
0.3608754873275757,
-0.2556532919406891,
0.16113239526748657,
0.13656918704509735,
0.7674662470817566,
0.20018945634365082,
-0.4822844862937927,
0.200714111328125,
-0.18178096413612366,
-0.10965167731046677,
-0.5226162075996399,
0.07780967652797699,
-0.03259909525513649,
0.2254505604505539,
0.19682157039642334,
0.46047869324684143,
0.5243703722953796,
0.024111732840538025,
0.48663005232810974,
0.15623995661735535,
-0.6507375836372375,
-0.32722586393356323,
1.029362678527832,
0.05272698774933815,
-0.5497581958770752,
0.5487391948699951,
0.2836955189704895,
-0.2597862780094147,
0.4683605134487152,
0.4021430015563965,
1.1378350257873535,
-0.6073101758956909,
-0.36065903306007385,
0.41915246844291687,
-0.005125598981976509,
-0.25703901052474976,
0.1859060823917389,
-0.37454986572265625,
-0.34196436405181885,
-0.26279550790786743,
-0.5707262754440308,
-0.06336377561092377,
0.13046015799045563,
-0.7401848435401917,
0.35251423716545105,
-0.5656662583351135,
-0.10453197360038757,
0.08651383221149445,
-0.7179094552993774,
-0.6115437150001526,
0.20458461344242096,
0.4298112988471985,
0.9860032796859741,
-0.31940674781799316,
0.9373854994773865,
0.17494700849056244,
-0.1261395364999771,
-0.7818120121955872,
0.31429556012153625,
0.2966797351837158,
-0.5280439257621765,
0.794859766960144,
0.4345438778400421,
-0.325184166431427,
0.07162207365036011,
-0.24721771478652954,
-1.171066403388977,
0.789706826210022,
0.042612090706825256,
-0.9568982124328613,
-0.4100549519062042,
-0.43086132407188416,
0.04212832823395729,
-0.24106112122535706,
0.008395075798034668,
0.6079673171043396,
0.38595178723335266,
0.24924525618553162,
-1.0152513980865479,
0.009055792354047298,
-0.1547168493270874,
0.20568719506263733,
0.21473459899425507,
-0.4900946021080017,
0.6431202292442322,
-0.36469948291778564,
-0.28814396262168884,
0.16913577914237976,
0.7509937882423401,
0.4572227895259857,
0.010609743185341358,
0.8826654553413391,
0.3206378221511841,
0.4694374203681946,
0.12722338736057281,
0.5730137825012207,
-0.012641966342926025,
0.015350673347711563,
1.1823333501815796,
-0.2867778539657593,
0.8246560096740723,
0.2726450264453888,
0.03023449331521988,
0.1832515299320221,
0.34288477897644043,
0.0348544605076313,
0.6965426206588745,
0.2437673807144165,
0.11383847147226334,
-0.1890971064567566,
0.4089580774307251,
-0.06139655038714409,
0.6831121444702148,
0.215769961476326,
-0.3053484559059143,
-0.19651679694652557,
0.2171649932861328,
0.02946740761399269,
-0.2194128930568695,
-0.4078412353992462,
0.9114155769348145,
-0.1079312339425087,
-0.43214499950408936,
0.7455271482467651,
-0.2009180337190628,
0.5550593733787537,
-0.5944806337356567,
-0.15507425367832184,
-0.13953818380832672,
0.41527873277664185,
0.13248787820339203,
-0.2415127456188202,
0.5218403935432434,
-0.008676812052726746,
-0.6187946200370789,
-0.05603266507387161,
0.5286664962768555,
-0.6635752320289612,
-0.4598444700241089,
0.1112443283200264,
0.10962492227554321,
0.06348109990358353,
0.02182706631720066,
-0.36881303787231445,
0.1906411498785019,
-0.16071125864982605,
-0.05063561350107193,
-0.047566138207912445,
0.08109737932682037,
-0.05535033717751503,
0.49228450655937195,
0.40537750720977783,
0.017406614497303963,
0.3446342647075653,
0.05672074854373932,
0.8340047001838684,
-0.6848344206809998,
-0.9373499751091003,
-0.8014172315597534,
0.5804818272590637,
0.06947199255228043,
0.03073681890964508,
0.42131924629211426,
0.802212655544281,
0.5347357392311096,
-0.23858189582824707,
0.7259947657585144,
0.022556032985448837,
0.8854923844337463,
-0.45706722140312195,
0.7832290530204773,
-0.4716721177101135,
-0.03037123568356037,
-0.28245946764945984,
-0.5940032005310059,
-0.3385123610496521,
0.4579659104347229,
-0.0008098548278212547,
0.037120550870895386,
0.328647255897522,
0.4348291754722595,
-0.24727217853069305,
0.0317305289208889,
0.2782121002674103,
0.36675310134887695,
0.3979749381542206,
0.7492039799690247,
0.47660017013549805,
-0.43820083141326904,
0.5793048143386841,
0.1646156758069992,
-0.46410423517227173,
-0.018886912614107132,
-0.5098886489868164,
-0.7062872648239136,
-0.43765875697135925,
-0.3303857147693634,
-0.4229656159877777,
0.2179112285375595,
0.7039715051651001,
0.7976076602935791,
-0.9049766063690186,
-0.1724133938550949,
0.01911948435008526,
-0.10420633852481842,
-0.2910537123680115,
-0.24192233383655548,
0.30109208822250366,
-0.18207329511642456,
-0.8755124807357788,
0.6110736131668091,
0.6398026347160339,
0.3906768262386322,
0.0956939235329628,
-0.008096284233033657,
-0.03979887068271637,
0.16793620586395264,
0.33906248211860657,
0.6536633968353271,
-0.866432249546051,
-0.0124916210770607,
0.23931950330734253,
0.20383301377296448,
0.07079742103815079,
0.9458945393562317,
-1.1430761814117432,
0.2875082492828369,
0.4140152633190155,
0.7946657538414001,
0.5001606345176697,
-0.04189139977097511,
0.6659511923789978,
-0.4618060886859894,
0.18512125313282013,
0.5247904062271118,
0.4353981614112854,
0.1903490573167801,
-0.483233243227005,
0.26516297459602356,
0.23143655061721802,
-0.5370397567749023,
-0.6602290868759155,
0.2412998080253601,
-1.279161810874939,
0.021564967930316925,
0.8488014340400696,
-0.0029492205940186977,
-0.2773827612400055,
-0.2609208822250366,
-0.243093803524971,
0.41666650772094727,
-0.6692948341369629,
0.718142569065094,
0.36402392387390137,
-0.2956462800502777,
-0.3934994041919708,
-0.0744369626045227,
0.4608074128627777,
0.08852440118789673,
-0.3614109754562378,
0.1836467832326889,
0.6857225298881531,
0.5702159404754639,
0.164844810962677,
0.9182048439979553,
-0.3746509850025177,
0.6117986440658569,
-0.1722613275051117,
-0.06457096338272095,
-0.3069154918193817,
-0.46001604199409485,
-0.6873578429222107,
0.36418232321739197,
-0.4282684922218323,
-0.6160671710968018
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08229v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08229v1
|
Boosting Disfluency Detection with Large Language Model as Disfluency Generator
| 2024-03-13T04:14:33 | 2024-03-13T04:14:33 |
Zhenrong Cheng, Jiayan Guo, Hao Sun, Yan Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Current disfluency detection methods heavily rely on costly and scarce
human-annotated data. To tackle this issue, some approaches employ heuristic or
statistical features to generate disfluent sentences, partially improving
detection performance. However, these sentences often deviate from real-life
scenarios, constraining overall model enhancement. In this study, we propose a
lightweight data augmentation approach for disfluency detection, utilizing the
superior generative and semantic understanding capabilities of large language
model (LLM) to generate disfluent sentences as augmentation data. We leverage
LLM to generate diverse and more realistic sentences guided by specific
prompts, without the need for fine-tuning the LLM. Subsequently, we apply an
uncertainty-aware data filtering approach to improve the quality of the
generated sentences, utilized in training a small detection model for improved
performance. Experiments using enhanced data yielded state-of-the-art results.
The results showed that using a small amount of LLM-generated enhanced data can
significantly improve performance, thereby further enhancing
cost-effectiveness.
|
[
-0.3339953124523163,
-1.0295761823654175,
0.6011868715286255,
0.10234029591083527,
-0.23729366064071655,
0.0632684975862503,
-0.12414747476577759,
-0.7224539518356323,
0.12765009701251984,
0.26466065645217896,
-0.7496194839477539,
-0.3125593662261963,
-0.7065805792808533,
0.19749490916728973,
-0.4107446074485779,
0.8155585527420044,
0.1449604630470276,
0.024500610306859016,
-0.10870498418807983,
0.039701830595731735,
-0.43447577953338623,
-0.22198760509490967,
-0.5265436768531799,
-0.37126171588897705,
0.1875317394733429,
0.5927421450614929,
0.9123411774635315,
0.5341538786888123,
0.42853623628616333,
0.44351285696029663,
-0.3577190041542053,
0.2801433503627777,
-0.4070568382740021,
0.19794882833957672,
-0.0027697659097611904,
-0.3681817054748535,
-0.5347206592559814,
-0.48981666564941406,
0.5389531254768372,
0.5943887233734131,
-0.1504790186882019,
-0.2193727195262909,
0.03402101621031761,
0.6286048889160156,
-0.46719250082969666,
0.08995777368545532,
-0.8807962536811829,
0.25485920906066895,
-0.22050851583480835,
0.29463762044906616,
-0.13703399896621704,
-0.08624998480081558,
-0.2701489329338074,
-0.5456082224845886,
0.3889443576335907,
-0.014487392269074917,
0.7074907422065735,
0.5066994428634644,
-0.22340235114097595,
-0.1751473844051361,
-0.4919239580631256,
0.4574829041957855,
-0.9154817461967468,
0.24569953978061676,
0.4256357252597809,
0.16053667664527893,
-0.34790465235710144,
-0.5010477900505066,
-0.9990191459655762,
-0.4451209306716919,
-0.15890364348888397,
-0.050199657678604126,
-0.2245446741580963,
0.14738450944423676,
0.5871712565422058,
0.7052217125892639,
-0.43393296003341675,
0.6307231187820435,
0.01803453266620636,
-0.387243390083313,
0.5883458852767944,
0.24939686059951782,
0.360842764377594,
-0.30546966195106506,
-0.41957736015319824,
-0.3007294535636902,
-0.4461411237716675,
-0.3646734654903412,
0.4934293329715729,
0.25931859016418457,
0.014312069863080978,
0.5473905801773071,
-0.6095120310783386,
0.6809806823730469,
-0.0525088831782341,
-0.30876168608665466,
0.3704903721809387,
-0.3660069406032562,
-0.12787777185440063,
0.12727579474449158,
0.5951423645019531,
0.2395181655883789,
0.06149812415242195,
-0.09092135727405548,
-0.5145331621170044,
0.22200407087802887,
0.14458027482032776,
-0.937745988368988,
-0.2376612424850464,
0.131656214594841,
-0.25964659452438354,
-0.5552039742469788,
-0.08305124193429947,
-0.9673276543617249,
-0.8424081206321716,
-0.3266356289386749,
0.28980690240859985,
-0.6734224557876587,
-0.3926331102848053,
0.23733766376972198,
-0.004396701231598854,
-0.19567403197288513,
0.2667623460292816,
-0.834933876991272,
0.004338230472058058,
0.44314226508140564,
0.8129585981369019,
-0.1844748705625534,
0.11871536076068878,
-0.7192714810371399,
-0.005661751609295607,
-0.17075009644031525,
0.6330555081367493,
-0.15221813321113586,
-0.11729274690151215,
0.10411188006401062,
-0.08779626339673996,
0.5657498836517334,
-0.7102596759796143,
0.9136190414428711,
-0.14153125882148743,
-0.014305301010608673,
0.05214496701955795,
-0.43325257301330566,
0.16633941233158112,
0.19272632896900177,
-0.8384758830070496,
1.041380763053894,
0.4881908595561981,
-0.8579376935958862,
0.7148292660713196,
-0.36988577246665955,
-0.6324999928474426,
0.46429315209388733,
-0.05157461017370224,
-0.8544864654541016,
0.19555918872356415,
0.6370159983634949,
0.5921810865402222,
-0.10396260768175125,
0.5968565344810486,
-0.7108548879623413,
-0.29754701256752014,
0.31145036220550537,
-0.7073217034339905,
0.5857853889465332,
0.15053343772888184,
-0.2549644708633423,
-0.1033465638756752,
-1.0825327634811401,
-0.4158843159675598,
0.13174660503864288,
-0.2879808247089386,
-0.3304974436759949,
-0.049458861351013184,
0.2820174992084503,
0.1787610948085785,
0.14712516963481903,
-0.7105530500411987,
0.1802573800086975,
-0.5596465468406677,
0.1457992047071457,
0.6975865960121155,
-0.08560974150896072,
0.1970469355583191,
-0.22571849822998047,
0.3194008469581604,
0.2656477987766266,
0.06671038269996643,
-0.010246455669403076,
-0.17670316994190216,
-0.6544498205184937,
-0.5782120227813721,
0.0765829011797905,
0.3333357870578766,
-1.2121741771697998,
0.6774985194206238,
-0.2024780809879303,
-0.09181274473667145,
-0.4855215847492218,
0.28565946221351624,
0.21364019811153412,
0.9517486691474915,
0.46144452691078186,
0.006552122998982668,
-0.6252231001853943,
-0.8697070479393005,
-0.031387411057949066,
-0.21649070084095,
-0.15061621367931366,
-0.08832445740699768,
0.4584314525127411,
-0.3053969144821167,
0.825381875038147,
-0.7781887054443359,
-0.4922540783882141,
-0.2893112301826477,
0.20548146963119507,
-0.11368237435817719,
0.49834126234054565,
0.4548735022544861,
-0.9103533625602722,
-0.11206948757171631,
-0.10020577162504196,
-0.5798396468162537,
-0.361221581697464,
-0.27951499819755554,
0.17527823150157928,
0.30893251299858093,
0.5271094441413879,
-0.5871356129646301,
0.48346298933029175,
0.4584876596927643,
-0.3697896897792816,
0.6050662398338318,
-0.2785087823867798,
0.1711997538805008,
-1.309321403503418,
-0.14007315039634705,
0.10949084907770157,
-0.5510562658309937,
-0.4817740321159363,
-0.1082177460193634,
0.10165338963270187,
-0.023393651470541954,
-0.25914818048477173,
0.0593971349298954,
-0.40920257568359375,
-0.07762099802494049,
-0.4129786193370819,
0.25073862075805664,
0.0920896902680397,
0.040058452636003494,
0.03687265142798424,
0.5657041072845459,
0.49134019017219543,
-0.4067245423793793,
0.520597517490387,
0.2886701822280884,
-0.5516517758369446,
0.5731307864189148,
-0.621571958065033,
-0.3114469647407532,
-0.18397602438926697,
0.2545555531978607,
-1.1974626779556274,
-0.564068615436554,
0.18280301988124847,
-0.18630798161029816,
0.3753032982349396,
-0.14094354212284088,
-0.8786439299583435,
-0.47770005464553833,
-0.37649208307266235,
0.06787960231304169,
0.45808422565460205,
-0.761726438999176,
0.11584527045488358,
0.16295088827610016,
-0.2684042453765869,
-0.4832267463207245,
-0.8914901614189148,
0.19665071368217468,
-0.46412143111228943,
-0.7089996337890625,
0.694927990436554,
-0.09796427190303802,
-0.16720055043697357,
-0.2579435706138611,
-0.1674903780221939,
-0.18323253095149994,
0.43286776542663574,
0.22467781603336334,
0.4930798411369324,
-0.1435185968875885,
0.5532304644584656,
0.20962810516357422,
-0.03620321303606033,
-0.15485309064388275,
0.1442941427230835,
0.4967457950115204,
0.1306132823228836,
-0.5074286460876465,
-0.4499250650405884,
0.2390073835849762,
0.508649468421936,
0.08636028319597244,
0.652698278427124,
0.8884409070014954,
-0.5732260346412659,
-0.27574363350868225,
-0.5475518107414246,
-0.5036565661430359,
-0.5422780513763428,
0.6874451041221619,
-0.20173043012619019,
-0.9523605108261108,
0.4592376947402954,
-0.21092890202999115,
-0.2710624635219574,
0.20100565254688263,
0.5566970705986023,
-0.049393173307180405,
1.0451356172561646,
0.45712023973464966,
-0.3884505033493042,
0.7868786454200745,
0.18493345379829407,
0.08864478766918182,
-0.616155207157135,
0.1341077983379364,
-0.2921912968158722,
-0.2028491050004959,
-0.3550484776496887,
-0.4696105718612671,
0.30295494198799133,
0.2851960361003876,
0.1478259116411209,
0.13990290462970734,
-0.6057488918304443,
0.2744949460029602,
-0.008492332883179188,
0.5822142362594604,
0.5755433440208435,
0.13973037898540497,
0.3378945291042328,
-0.14763480424880981,
-0.44292598962783813,
-0.3841058611869812,
0.7701056599617004,
0.4447987973690033,
0.8997591137886047,
0.17456458508968353,
0.47682762145996094,
0.3629777729511261,
0.15703213214874268,
-0.641964852809906,
0.31382986903190613,
-0.13144555687904358,
-0.26472678780555725,
-0.2747615575790405,
-0.7033056020736694,
-0.706531822681427,
0.2589873969554901,
-0.5597731471061707,
-0.7654035687446594,
0.18274010717868805,
0.27860137820243835,
-0.15826749801635742,
0.25924041867256165,
-0.5798658132553101,
0.6046120524406433,
-0.15838223695755005,
-0.2746412456035614,
-0.20934799313545227,
-0.2874622941017151,
0.7260965704917908,
-0.15652690827846527,
0.07317791134119034,
-0.04068199545145035,
0.06485924869775772,
0.39514222741127014,
-0.6321761608123779,
0.848287045955658,
-0.2453209012746811,
-0.3694417476654053,
0.053017787635326385,
-0.13122089207172394,
0.8352310657501221,
0.2984221279621124,
-0.09694228321313858,
-0.20108942687511444,
-0.5104441046714783,
-0.12537020444869995,
-0.5533278584480286,
0.6292345523834229,
-0.32503682374954224,
-0.49771445989608765,
-0.12642955780029297,
-0.9150963425636292,
-0.3488999307155609,
-0.052819665521383286,
0.18898512423038483,
0.4116881489753723,
-0.1449410766363144,
0.15560932457447052,
0.9093651175498962,
-0.24371017515659332,
0.6466098427772522,
0.4410421550273895,
-0.15979452431201935,
-0.13626129925251007,
0.7710862755775452,
-0.05039845407009125,
0.36168742179870605,
0.25177666544914246,
0.1415664106607437,
-0.4277242422103882,
-0.8215280771255493,
-0.6288008093833923,
-0.048626452684402466,
-0.5350426435470581,
-0.4422047436237335,
-0.68791663646698,
0.20700675249099731,
-0.6106111407279968,
0.12768498063087463,
-0.1739690750837326,
-0.5049267411231995,
-0.25472113490104675,
-0.3233184814453125,
0.8239580988883972,
0.4108591079711914,
-0.051404718309640884,
0.4829646944999695,
-0.5513709187507629,
0.7706456184387207,
0.2817228436470032,
0.2619278132915497,
-0.19843825697898865,
-0.6024037003517151,
-0.08727490901947021,
0.24114952981472015,
-0.3074958622455597,
-0.7880653142929077,
0.44647160172462463,
0.18493050336837769,
0.34168511629104614,
0.3406287729740143,
0.33503103256225586,
0.9060299396514893,
-0.24770207703113556,
0.6075834035873413,
0.3297552168369293,
-0.9013268947601318,
0.6763319969177246,
-0.10818761587142944,
0.13583165407180786,
0.5525256991386414,
0.05529555678367615,
-0.14728766679763794,
-0.5841197967529297,
-0.41618356108665466,
-1.0685741901397705,
0.914307713508606,
0.13617347180843353,
0.11108489334583282,
0.2173243910074234,
0.2810721695423126,
0.025806399062275887,
0.10043125599622726,
-0.8048446178436279,
-0.0045085484161973,
-0.006190641317516565,
-0.41716331243515015,
0.011666483245790005,
-0.1382649689912796,
-0.04047750309109688,
-0.20048290491104126,
0.6365949511528015,
-0.28578779101371765,
-0.05352145805954933,
0.18166473507881165,
-0.5498877167701721,
-0.15689148008823395,
0.23988671600818634,
0.4543096125125885,
0.2157163918018341,
-0.03893820941448212,
-0.11441955715417862,
0.323923796415329,
-0.4553467929363251,
0.15509292483329773,
0.47785577178001404,
-0.0722435861825943,
0.15099892020225525,
0.38027575612068176,
0.9563178420066833,
-0.1136394664645195,
-0.9097126126289368,
0.66730797290802,
-0.016759827733039856,
-0.044160857796669006,
-0.16831821203231812,
0.05821877345442772,
0.07744529843330383,
0.3031661808490753,
0.298809677362442,
-0.20718492567539215,
0.4821041524410248,
-0.38087329268455505,
0.5137768387794495,
0.5059192180633545,
-0.2363189309835434,
0.0887349396944046,
0.4950713515281677,
0.0027118949219584465,
-0.08006159216165543,
0.6117359399795532,
-0.15094304084777832,
-0.4486692547798157,
0.5885363817214966,
0.7014410495758057,
0.4913422465324402,
-0.23305457830429077,
0.26944997906684875,
0.04735222086310387,
0.26573610305786133,
-0.17468655109405518,
0.14358755946159363,
-0.06789500266313553,
-0.7648530602455139,
-0.5809292793273926,
-0.6655296683311462,
-0.10957317054271698,
0.46183085441589355,
-0.6801504492759705,
0.25934967398643494,
-0.2646484673023224,
-0.028728092089295387,
0.07633164525032043,
-0.2376365065574646,
-0.4127068817615509,
0.2687043845653534,
0.33229899406433105,
0.5796094536781311,
-1.1749299764633179,
0.7195273637771606,
0.5183283686637878,
-0.6005628705024719,
-0.6071780920028687,
0.29585421085357666,
-0.0726315900683403,
-0.6963993906974792,
0.609528660774231,
0.33018457889556885,
0.05982491374015808,
-0.3353199064731598,
-0.341063529253006,
-0.43739286065101624,
1.039680004119873,
0.8659589290618896,
-0.8675841093063354,
0.09834904223680496,
0.22772982716560364,
0.6100705862045288,
-0.1710406243801117,
0.15796180069446564,
0.509552538394928,
0.3344203233718872,
0.07899884879589081,
-0.5569814443588257,
0.36874768137931824,
0.009668142534792423,
0.1698204129934311,
0.20000478625297546,
-0.26928481459617615,
0.7373186349868774,
0.006997421383857727,
-0.22103723883628845,
-0.0653526708483696,
0.6528922319412231,
0.21820512413978577,
0.3281060755252838,
0.7441948652267456,
0.8326885104179382,
0.8612868785858154,
-0.07461528480052948,
1.1513803005218506,
0.02388404868543148,
0.23364607989788055,
1.0956835746765137,
-0.2730666995048523,
0.5107187628746033,
0.4319429397583008,
-0.13871869444847107,
0.4262750744819641,
0.5030853152275085,
-0.08107142150402069,
0.24288025498390198,
0.3461882472038269,
-0.547310471534729,
-0.34291401505470276,
-0.20438486337661743,
-0.2186020463705063,
0.37782958149909973,
0.4478457272052765,
-0.4917047917842865,
-0.27373749017715454,
0.40617835521698,
-0.04039023816585541,
0.13995295763015747,
-0.27786678075790405,
0.894943356513977,
-0.1882183998823166,
-0.3327151834964752,
0.7383500337600708,
-0.13151827454566956,
1.0083110332489014,
-0.3224516808986664,
-0.18595418334007263,
-0.2717443108558655,
0.342157781124115,
-0.39827653765678406,
-0.738446056842804,
0.33293023705482483,
0.07600244134664536,
-0.2908075153827667,
-0.12309848517179489,
1.0764135122299194,
-0.5801428556442261,
-0.5451552271842957,
0.13484372198581696,
0.3793956935405731,
0.028112933039665222,
-0.27290135622024536,
-0.647635817527771,
0.1635095179080963,
-0.048528704792261124,
-0.132928267121315,
0.616881251335144,
0.5905349850654602,
-0.06435006856918335,
0.6027421355247498,
0.5677966475486755,
0.18308931589126587,
-0.21426889300346375,
0.29672133922576904,
1.0931651592254639,
-0.04344065487384796,
-0.30421382188796997,
-0.983367383480072,
0.6147396564483643,
-0.5646096467971802,
-0.22331461310386658,
0.47741246223449707,
0.23782996833324432,
0.6883081793785095,
-0.14205755293369293,
0.6671773791313171,
-0.270254909992218,
0.40209928154945374,
-0.5244424343109131,
0.6382355690002441,
-0.5694588422775269,
0.3282568156719208,
-0.4446949064731598,
-0.7130333185195923,
-0.22604703903198242,
0.6871170401573181,
-0.002681192010641098,
-0.0305270254611969,
0.3230210840702057,
1.0625227689743042,
-0.21935613453388214,
-0.09965327382087708,
0.5368616580963135,
0.3317480981349945,
0.2599797248840332,
0.4002898633480072,
0.694296658039093,
-0.3620721697807312,
0.5647435784339905,
-0.29727503657341003,
-0.2858157157897949,
-0.2870519161224365,
-0.8621755838394165,
-0.685018002986908,
-0.4850156009197235,
-0.5157102346420288,
-0.2614413797855377,
-0.09703431278467178,
0.6866357922554016,
0.6970832347869873,
-0.6581049561500549,
0.4718207120895386,
-0.5468800663948059,
0.1281900256872177,
-0.1555289477109909,
-0.3236098885536194,
0.16424863040447235,
-0.5056949257850647,
-0.771818995475769,
0.5622615814208984,
0.006044140551239252,
0.22584545612335205,
-0.3216046094894409,
0.13419389724731445,
-0.01912316121160984,
-0.3480475842952728,
0.6521055698394775,
-0.13771501183509827,
-0.4847579598426819,
-0.38511091470718384,
-0.44619137048721313,
-0.05457001551985741,
0.019957536831498146,
0.6738060712814331,
-0.8454171419143677,
0.4850853979587555,
0.3469103276729584,
0.8428082466125488,
0.3945581912994385,
0.0781652107834816,
0.47081512212753296,
-1.1752946376800537,
0.36308836936950684,
0.32283255457878113,
0.5522127151489258,
0.6926631331443787,
-0.8059804439544678,
0.3145465552806854,
0.3927389085292816,
-0.3748838007450104,
-1.1136136054992676,
0.43460872769355774,
-0.8223385214805603,
-0.5071033239364624,
1.052758812904358,
-0.31765347719192505,
0.04419804364442825,
-0.1618489921092987,
-0.3622484803199768,
0.48633548617362976,
-0.4956287741661072,
0.9889550805091858,
0.583006739616394,
-0.07846001535654068,
-0.1979307383298874,
-0.31353551149368286,
0.548653781414032,
0.534785270690918,
-1.046525239944458,
0.3419358730316162,
0.8830793499946594,
0.1754898577928543,
0.060874324291944504,
0.1663798838853836,
0.017223555594682693,
0.07991998642683029,
0.12262177467346191,
0.1114414781332016,
-0.2672346234321594,
0.01848525181412697,
-0.5150094628334045,
0.07053889334201813,
0.010666316375136375,
-0.13588044047355652
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08217v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08217v1
|
Research on the Application of Deep Learning-based BERT Model in Sentiment Analysis
| 2024-03-13T03:31:26 | 2024-03-13T03:31:26 |
Yichao Wu, Zhengyu Jin, Chenxi Shi, Penghao Liang, Tong Zhan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
This paper explores the application of deep learning techniques, particularly
focusing on BERT models, in sentiment analysis. It begins by introducing the
fundamental concept of sentiment analysis and how deep learning methods are
utilized in this domain. Subsequently, it delves into the architecture and
characteristics of BERT models. Through detailed explanation, it elucidates the
application effects and optimization strategies of BERT models in sentiment
analysis, supported by experimental validation. The experimental findings
indicate that BERT models exhibit robust performance in sentiment analysis
tasks, with notable enhancements post fine-tuning. Lastly, the paper concludes
by summarizing the potential applications of BERT models in sentiment analysis
and suggests directions for future research and practical implementations.
|
[
-0.5270707011222839,
-0.7493038773536682,
0.3720935583114624,
0.3616696298122406,
-0.5039708018302917,
0.0036638902965933084,
-0.3399351239204407,
-0.5147637724876404,
-0.08421070128679276,
0.23276127874851227,
-0.9020677804946899,
-0.49561986327171326,
-0.3888424038887024,
-0.4411296844482422,
-0.24345605075359344,
0.9252597093582153,
0.2521921694278717,
0.6993083357810974,
0.06735600531101227,
0.02255144901573658,
-0.5081428289413452,
-0.5426746606826782,
-0.6682658791542053,
-0.282968133687973,
0.6370887160301208,
0.1775655448436737,
0.6673781275749207,
-0.31473103165626526,
0.8385229706764221,
0.2755815386772156,
-0.22838231921195984,
-0.11970185488462448,
-0.36907947063446045,
0.250074177980423,
0.15400968492031097,
-0.3291037976741791,
-0.39670974016189575,
0.2455953061580658,
0.6321412920951843,
0.8584751486778259,
0.24404588341712952,
-0.010303002782166004,
0.21041005849838257,
0.6660326719284058,
-0.32994726300239563,
0.09333706647157669,
-0.624864399433136,
0.40327778458595276,
0.07777846604585648,
0.14996977150440216,
-0.3993033766746521,
-0.7510790824890137,
0.6249334812164307,
0.10600949078798294,
0.2868678569793701,
-0.3147432208061218,
0.9356164932250977,
0.049540549516677856,
-0.08023015409708023,
-0.4686904847621918,
-0.6358282566070557,
1.2250478267669678,
-1.2645632028579712,
0.3596058785915375,
-0.29825446009635925,
0.29862135648727417,
0.19398850202560425,
-0.5187397003173828,
-0.5368841290473938,
-0.29752421379089355,
0.1330195665359497,
0.23506106436252594,
0.23019222915172577,
0.1728154718875885,
-0.2589137852191925,
0.7424625754356384,
-0.33806800842285156,
0.31122609972953796,
-0.01480186264961958,
0.21783636510372162,
0.5927145481109619,
0.25474196672439575,
-0.19288554787635803,
-0.28883734345436096,
-0.4542523920536041,
-0.1643635779619217,
-0.04635894298553467,
0.3995897173881531,
0.2537855803966522,
0.783723771572113,
0.12075376510620117,
0.19721052050590515,
-0.02090122178196907,
0.5268537998199463,
-0.15325669944286346,
0.3969089686870575,
0.4492848515510559,
0.21122874319553375,
-0.6868931651115417,
-0.34607112407684326,
0.5429980158805847,
0.36611172556877136,
0.29722148180007935,
0.17060105502605438,
-0.29416394233703613,
-0.03958028927445412,
0.4689435064792633,
-0.7480881810188293,
-0.24065740406513214,
0.22681035101413727,
-1.2050631046295166,
-0.8642631769180298,
-0.2573484778404236,
-0.8734191656112671,
-0.48695293068885803,
-0.3982457220554352,
0.32703572511672974,
-0.4908464550971985,
-0.42504584789276123,
0.12070906162261963,
-0.2399318963289261,
0.6051933169364929,
0.3561204969882965,
-0.5743535757064819,
0.22855523228645325,
0.9162930846214294,
0.6181028485298157,
0.06887085735797882,
-0.05645401403307915,
0.11891886591911316,
-0.7067583203315735,
-0.4907273054122925,
0.4610215127468109,
-0.5572826266288757,
-0.34679609537124634,
0.4038727879524231,
-0.24167433381080627,
0.2339075356721878,
-0.27494552731513977,
0.8447345495223999,
-0.8848642706871033,
-0.15807265043258667,
-0.4523926377296448,
-0.9721803069114685,
-0.6938721537590027,
0.537699818611145,
-0.4876086413860321,
0.6215019226074219,
-0.2468031346797943,
-0.5204315185546875,
0.47470879554748535,
-0.7811866998672485,
-0.5868344306945801,
-0.23752909898757935,
0.35509538650512695,
-0.6443657279014587,
0.9484421610832214,
0.37155765295028687,
1.053983211517334,
0.1735120564699173,
0.11761277914047241,
-0.6875389814376831,
-0.2777494192123413,
0.5670645236968994,
-0.38986101746559143,
1.1471062898635864,
0.6121265292167664,
-0.14594517648220062,
-0.13911673426628113,
-0.36143073439598083,
0.20313125848770142,
0.010675942525267601,
-0.18174222111701965,
-0.44794225692749023,
0.3133988678455353,
0.2131788432598114,
-0.14297057688236237,
0.4628300070762634,
-0.6621126532554626,
0.22417297959327698,
-0.48819127678871155,
0.24283264577388763,
0.7584822773933411,
0.03316180035471916,
0.3135211169719696,
0.1803189516067505,
0.11186972260475159,
-0.045990172773599625,
0.45727160573005676,
0.12586171925067902,
-0.3966762125492096,
-0.9257538914680481,
-0.16286103427410126,
0.8549767136573792,
0.28389254212379456,
-0.11880072206258774,
0.6516717076301575,
0.019591642543673515,
-0.6086426973342896,
-0.7653993964195251,
-0.05134492367506027,
-0.16669851541519165,
0.43685629963874817,
0.17084677517414093,
-0.4532356560230255,
-0.6542193293571472,
-0.8968048095703125,
-0.30351513624191284,
0.03442817181348801,
0.4273649752140045,
0.3174111545085907,
0.22678883373737335,
-0.3834224045276642,
0.8809391856193542,
-0.41853415966033936,
-0.0999484583735466,
-0.384996622800827,
0.6876423358917236,
0.5151954889297485,
0.4337627589702606,
0.7932943105697632,
-0.6537483334541321,
-0.358234167098999,
-0.21638274192810059,
-0.8017980456352234,
0.40828630328178406,
-0.11975019425153732,
-0.04879376292228699,
0.10663197934627533,
0.04136274755001068,
-0.2653757631778717,
0.2222345620393753,
0.4643888771533966,
0.112433061003685,
0.3390677869319916,
0.14133363962173462,
-0.19832588732242584,
-0.6412738561630249,
-0.16633127629756927,
0.2524208724498749,
-0.12374739348888397,
-0.6097692251205444,
0.28591644763946533,
-0.13140243291854858,
-0.24388544261455536,
-0.2701038718223572,
0.05003412440419197,
0.0004105157277081162,
0.05829109996557236,
-0.4927913248538971,
-0.4272424578666687,
-0.012810159474611282,
0.37503182888031006,
0.1690477579832077,
0.27011266350746155,
0.629670262336731,
-0.3522510528564453,
0.4193003475666046,
-0.0703660324215889,
-0.6097664833068848,
0.07869566231966019,
-0.47824627161026,
0.03567830100655556,
-0.13200490176677704,
-0.20425233244895935,
-1.4550114870071411,
0.18512049317359924,
0.0988977700471878,
-0.7686560153961182,
0.4221900403499603,
0.21136711537837982,
-0.5033547878265381,
-0.5857673287391663,
-0.7035967111587524,
-0.14482872188091278,
0.8916024565696716,
-0.6509943008422852,
0.5819668769836426,
0.1747373640537262,
-0.2834565341472626,
-0.6205740571022034,
-0.7610958814620972,
-0.02748231776058674,
-0.19814066588878632,
-0.42443594336509705,
-0.0030893643852323294,
-0.030429890379309654,
-0.21154120564460754,
0.05003656819462776,
0.34088459610939026,
-0.2528156638145447,
0.30398455262184143,
0.004844144452363253,
0.10938804596662521,
-0.2997722327709198,
0.385166734457016,
0.21021287143230438,
0.26547181606292725,
0.33259299397468567,
0.10166060924530029,
0.40901637077331543,
-0.4412734806537628,
0.014710603281855583,
-0.6127800941467285,
0.5156726241111755,
0.43144625425338745,
-0.026998596265912056,
0.5297242999076843,
0.8630865216255188,
-0.23304152488708496,
-0.2768339216709137,
-0.7441904544830322,
-0.22336208820343018,
-0.4643140435218811,
0.4797195494174957,
-0.0070251342840492725,
-0.5707058310508728,
0.460873544216156,
-0.47606855630874634,
-0.003919447306543589,
0.45860326290130615,
0.7101040482521057,
-0.9316596388816833,
1.0571625232696533,
0.9039669632911682,
-0.7091805338859558,
0.7488973140716553,
-0.4395797848701477,
0.4653664827346802,
-0.7063816785812378,
0.05912706255912781,
-0.4335194230079651,
-0.6631118655204773,
-0.4002928137779236,
0.08643922954797745,
-0.04155433550477028,
0.056864701211452484,
-0.2788754403591156,
-0.2901119589805603,
-0.639671802520752,
-0.04143946245312691,
0.6829720139503479,
0.39151376485824585,
-0.3117291331291199,
0.1526125967502594,
-0.22036920487880707,
-0.30058348178863525,
-0.3380657732486725,
-0.4233439266681671,
0.9961472153663635,
0.8598616719245911,
0.9485448598861694,
-0.3069722056388855,
0.7653613090515137,
0.8484571576118469,
0.21081247925758362,
-1.1161974668502808,
0.54326331615448,
-0.4636787176132202,
-0.6248416304588318,
-0.2969411313533783,
-0.03341861069202423,
-0.519055962562561,
-0.00783900823444128,
-0.014688166789710522,
-0.2663429081439972,
0.500752866268158,
-0.04553772881627083,
-0.38579219579696655,
0.1681201308965683,
-0.7178571820259094,
0.5862541198730469,
-0.5430879592895508,
0.042828839272260666,
-0.4209796190261841,
-0.6967419385910034,
0.20132307708263397,
0.28465914726257324,
0.09481556713581085,
-0.06028095632791519,
0.4722265899181366,
0.7213688492774963,
-0.1478901505470276,
1.4586085081100464,
-0.8471875786781311,
-0.21141913533210754,
0.4485975205898285,
-0.20618607103824615,
0.3857978284358978,
0.06789099425077438,
-0.4220486283302307,
0.3425019085407257,
-0.6240520477294922,
-0.1748906821012497,
-0.45821860432624817,
0.817733883857727,
-0.920782208442688,
-0.28405413031578064,
-0.2692852020263672,
-0.6097898483276367,
-0.4251065254211426,
0.015612618066370487,
-0.22457027435302734,
0.13767017424106598,
-0.2978401482105255,
0.18907056748867035,
0.8330398201942444,
-0.2105693370103836,
0.7345322966575623,
0.04213029146194458,
-0.10123313963413239,
-0.431230366230011,
0.8140363097190857,
0.057038795202970505,
-0.15798643231391907,
0.3778421878814697,
0.3722592294216156,
-0.19925470650196075,
-0.7294774651527405,
-0.1451609581708908,
-0.01784324273467064,
-0.6599265336990356,
-0.2895641326904297,
-0.33549264073371887,
-0.16524812579154968,
-0.46080830693244934,
-0.3474646210670471,
-0.2853909432888031,
-0.32256823778152466,
-0.2836698591709137,
-0.1298023760318756,
0.40256810188293457,
0.5450810194015503,
-0.10209044069051743,
0.3558022081851959,
-0.698126494884491,
0.24796684086322784,
0.7826168537139893,
0.48392245173454285,
0.4552392065525055,
-0.07505025714635849,
-0.24747629463672638,
0.22809626162052155,
-0.37362390756607056,
-0.7514828443527222,
0.5415864586830139,
0.11457492411136627,
0.5452142953872681,
0.49541544914245605,
-0.12485634535551071,
0.4697358012199402,
-0.2275269627571106,
1.000373125076294,
0.03952491655945778,
-1.214471697807312,
0.7251291871070862,
-0.2960260808467865,
-0.170848548412323,
0.5413212776184082,
0.3099828362464905,
-0.06639426201581955,
-0.14949743449687958,
-0.2579585313796997,
-0.5717649459838867,
0.3292081356048584,
-0.03190933167934418,
0.6699067950248718,
0.19491389393806458,
0.5377331972122192,
0.2037556916475296,
0.4014590084552765,
-0.6872743368148804,
-0.09599439054727554,
-0.43960824608802795,
-0.42452314496040344,
0.03202264755964279,
-0.7141571640968323,
0.13132122159004211,
-0.6408913731575012,
0.6993508338928223,
-0.012458155862987041,
0.6351208090782166,
0.12175960093736649,
-0.04083907976746559,
-0.0038949386216700077,
0.17136390507221222,
0.3229748606681824,
0.1251564472913742,
-0.6074883341789246,
-0.454280823469162,
0.2973093092441559,
-0.1141500249505043,
-0.42940330505371094,
0.11679324507713318,
-0.013522754423320293,
0.18099531531333923,
0.3640787601470947,
0.5212901830673218,
-0.048533085733652115,
-0.4234316349029541,
0.5611920356750488,
-0.06805265694856644,
-0.11725614219903946,
-0.3964540958404541,
-0.1823001503944397,
0.12023405730724335,
0.5720880627632141,
0.39554497599601746,
0.2521648705005646,
0.5907367467880249,
-0.6560320258140564,
-0.18525075912475586,
0.9430016279220581,
-0.8442791104316711,
-0.09303422272205353,
0.06390931457281113,
0.27110716700553894,
0.05025620386004448,
0.9088514447212219,
0.10745201259851456,
-0.6995760798454285,
0.704067587852478,
0.05143299326300621,
0.9359222650527954,
-0.0788351371884346,
0.04487796500325203,
-0.17660486698150635,
0.13252678513526917,
0.41276615858078003,
0.8751935958862305,
-0.04068024456501007,
-0.752505362033844,
-0.49491867423057556,
-0.7079039812088013,
-0.49115046858787537,
0.14472177624702454,
-0.8159621357917786,
0.12432478368282318,
-0.5186437368392944,
-0.4690572917461395,
0.17831234633922577,
0.25973987579345703,
-0.8496448397636414,
0.7315957546234131,
0.5804594159126282,
0.9451914429664612,
-0.8392760157585144,
0.9216276407241821,
0.6756036281585693,
-0.18662230670452118,
-0.5400803685188293,
0.025069033727049828,
-0.40537914633750916,
-0.8614479899406433,
1.0045855045318604,
0.16857358813285828,
-0.03452359512448311,
-0.3355939984321594,
-1.0246127843856812,
-0.30068737268447876,
0.6053962707519531,
-0.16450677812099457,
-0.3908410370349884,
0.17033623158931732,
0.007407438475638628,
0.8861108422279358,
-0.5026615858078003,
-0.11619139462709427,
0.37566500902175903,
0.5105118155479431,
-0.20987482368946075,
-0.35435566306114197,
-0.3323453664779663,
-0.2336721420288086,
0.19164258241653442,
-0.11482734978199005,
-0.731441855430603,
1.1330606937408447,
-0.018208332359790802,
0.5234785676002502,
0.3305923342704773,
0.9525915384292603,
-0.23351095616817474,
0.16213810443878174,
0.33263877034187317,
0.7187114357948303,
0.6473585963249207,
-0.06826114654541016,
0.7617373466491699,
0.03396836295723915,
0.8529617786407471,
0.7193981409072876,
-0.38283342123031616,
0.921963632106781,
0.3453422486782074,
-0.07648876309394836,
0.8025093674659729,
0.5660405158996582,
-0.5419595241546631,
1.1268600225448608,
0.18562284111976624,
-0.1900084763765335,
-0.22450648248195648,
0.022243350744247437,
-0.4692382216453552,
0.3917928636074066,
0.6686049699783325,
-0.8632160425186157,
-0.029515720903873444,
0.3232937455177307,
-0.2235182225704193,
-0.21620193123817444,
-0.6931049823760986,
0.8117406964302063,
0.0257212333381176,
-0.1449468582868576,
0.13808859884738922,
-0.07089950889348984,
0.8829545974731445,
-0.39182141423225403,
-0.07449138909578323,
0.003979945555329323,
0.5427443385124207,
-0.012778756208717823,
-0.9095261096954346,
0.23038427531719208,
-0.22083790600299835,
-0.26204946637153625,
-0.2584427297115326,
1.1151641607284546,
0.27262768149375916,
-0.8479406833648682,
0.44729846715927124,
0.3520829379558563,
-0.20247089862823486,
-0.12776446342468262,
-0.9724090695381165,
0.09808618575334549,
0.0676279291510582,
-0.4390355348587036,
0.01109570637345314,
0.6851810812950134,
0.42550286650657654,
0.33384808897972107,
0.5059106349945068,
-0.017651231959462166,
0.08308065682649612,
0.4255611002445221,
1.007676601409912,
-0.9602222442626953,
-0.21238140761852264,
-1.0208854675292969,
0.6190454363822937,
-0.2095051258802414,
-0.0809895470738411,
0.8437583446502686,
0.29722756147384644,
0.5742871165275574,
-0.5730304718017578,
1.1537591218948364,
-0.033076897263526917,
0.9077411890029907,
-0.29738107323646545,
0.8241161704063416,
-0.3595953583717346,
-0.1425570398569107,
-0.5177849531173706,
-0.43646422028541565,
-0.664695143699646,
0.8408663868904114,
-0.5098931193351746,
0.22145581245422363,
0.23514819145202637,
0.23339858651161194,
0.16229748725891113,
0.40536314249038696,
0.09030423313379288,
0.225526824593544,
0.16712135076522827,
0.13046392798423767,
1.1093895435333252,
-0.4622834026813507,
0.05511168763041496,
-0.6264132857322693,
0.08298858255147934,
-0.6774144172668457,
-0.8635337948799133,
-1.1710327863693237,
-0.31287309527397156,
-0.07497701793909073,
-0.03338449075818062,
0.13772810995578766,
0.5534893870353699,
0.8034138679504395,
-0.9763053059577942,
-0.10481741279363632,
-0.08907485753297806,
-0.03404557704925537,
-0.5392310619354248,
-0.3271268606185913,
0.3794134855270386,
-1.0806292295455933,
-0.6593931317329407,
0.050952162593603134,
-0.23269367218017578,
-0.04854729026556015,
-0.4585006535053253,
0.20340092480182648,
-0.1448686420917511,
0.2821163237094879,
0.8075308203697205,
-0.2375984638929367,
-0.6646690368652344,
-0.25341254472732544,
-0.007995971478521824,
0.08902842551469803,
-0.014194359071552753,
0.9368739724159241,
-1.0208159685134888,
0.39011600613594055,
0.6778654456138611,
0.756805419921875,
0.28548362851142883,
-0.0755588710308075,
0.4793465733528137,
-0.8946762681007385,
-0.14215697348117828,
0.5552312135696411,
0.47804921865463257,
0.2536616921424866,
-0.49552351236343384,
0.2114957571029663,
-0.2386181801557541,
-0.557345986366272,
-0.6772310733795166,
-0.10065516829490662,
-1.2365639209747314,
-0.6202198266983032,
0.5740340948104858,
-0.14728260040283203,
0.0806654840707779,
0.19190473854541779,
-0.2740575075149536,
0.24311178922653198,
-0.5823795199394226,
1.0475939512252808,
0.765359103679657,
-0.30732959508895874,
-0.20050546526908875,
-0.33418428897857666,
0.23028945922851562,
0.6322717070579529,
-0.33974403142929077,
-0.1572479009628296,
0.04160548374056816,
0.016925323754549026,
0.17980080842971802,
0.015010075643658638,
0.03781980648636818,
-0.07229628413915634,
-0.3036148250102997,
0.2770925760269165,
0.13982875645160675,
-0.1029510498046875,
-0.6755313277244568,
0.577583909034729,
0.3183387219905853,
-0.4736662209033966
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08213v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08213v1
|
Can Large Language Models Identify Authorship?
| 2024-03-13T03:22:02 | 2024-03-13T03:22:02 |
Baixiang Huang, Canyu Chen, Kai Shu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The ability to accurately identify authorship is crucial for verifying
content authenticity and mitigating misinformation. Large Language Models
(LLMs) have demonstrated exceptional capacity for reasoning and
problem-solving. However, their potential in authorship analysis, encompassing
authorship verification and attribution, remains underexplored. This paper
conducts a comprehensive evaluation of LLMs in these critical tasks.
Traditional studies have depended on hand-crafted stylistic features, whereas
state-of-the-art approaches leverage text embeddings from pre-trained language
models. These methods, which typically require fine-tuning on labeled data,
often suffer from performance degradation in cross-domain applications and
provide limited explainability. This work seeks to address three research
questions: (1) Can LLMs perform zero-shot, end-to-end authorship verification
effectively? (2) Are LLMs capable of accurately attributing authorship among
multiple candidates authors (e.g., 10 and 20)? (3) How can LLMs provide
explainability in authorship analysis, particularly through the role of
linguistic features? Moreover, we investigate the integration of explicit
linguistic features to guide LLMs in their reasoning processes. Our extensive
assessment demonstrates LLMs' proficiency in both tasks without the need for
domain-specific fine-tuning, providing insights into their decision-making via
a detailed analysis of linguistic features. This establishes a new benchmark
for future research on LLM-based authorship analysis. The code and data are
available at https://github.com/baixianghuang/authorship-llm.
|
[
-0.09310603886842728,
-0.7424179315567017,
1.0982035398483276,
0.13292740285396576,
0.006257173139601946,
0.13885705173015594,
-0.6463845372200012,
-0.5078502297401428,
0.01810590736567974,
0.7203373908996582,
-0.3168640732765198,
-0.4393550753593445,
-0.8780182003974915,
0.40320414304733276,
-0.47871941328048706,
0.6641280651092529,
-0.13150803744792938,
-0.14344671368598938,
-0.6328251957893372,
-0.01859583519399166,
-0.36020371317863464,
-0.40759700536727905,
-0.502676248550415,
-0.3144467771053314,
0.8871265053749084,
0.20058628916740417,
0.4042935371398926,
0.7095317244529724,
0.2998732328414917,
0.3456259071826935,
-0.16089433431625366,
0.15549635887145996,
-0.5740281939506531,
0.026979776099324226,
-0.13561388850212097,
-0.35331010818481445,
-0.5125392079353333,
0.07983016967773438,
0.6889321804046631,
0.6807286739349365,
0.1484661102294922,
0.4339894652366638,
0.060515161603689194,
0.2240365445613861,
-0.7160552144050598,
0.14872942864894867,
-0.7007027268409729,
-0.3446893095970154,
-0.25125357508659363,
-0.361213743686676,
-0.768197774887085,
-0.6084827780723572,
-0.08445946127176285,
-0.35721293091773987,
-0.019554905593395233,
0.03629958629608154,
0.5956825017929077,
0.193989098072052,
-0.6134485602378845,
-0.5358743071556091,
-0.5425997376441956,
0.9670988917350769,
-0.8018116354942322,
0.06712925434112549,
0.19111254811286926,
0.05785593017935753,
-0.01820097304880619,
-0.35549917817115784,
-0.6151824593544006,
-0.2718279957771301,
-0.28941109776496887,
-0.20533931255340576,
0.10065773129463196,
-0.20735694468021393,
0.1416449248790741,
0.44392403960227966,
-0.6083937287330627,
0.5656015872955322,
-0.01826287992298603,
-0.1707330048084259,
0.7598516345024109,
-0.01751115545630455,
0.5329328775405884,
-0.04895620048046112,
-0.2940340042114258,
0.21242736279964447,
-0.7597683072090149,
0.021459948271512985,
0.6754414439201355,
0.34246623516082764,
-0.15809926390647888,
0.6620921492576599,
0.05806930363178253,
0.6583930253982544,
-0.16570281982421875,
-0.03833429887890816,
0.0023844235111027956,
-0.07829263061285019,
-0.0489635244011879,
0.15219512581825256,
0.8669516444206238,
-0.05960998311638832,
0.6179110407829285,
-0.27407801151275635,
-0.12775647640228271,
-0.3570452928543091,
0.10039455443620682,
-0.5405884385108948,
0.05715048313140869,
0.358807235956192,
-0.3371846675872803,
-0.33793899416923523,
0.2929074466228485,
-0.28170129656791687,
-0.6574887633323669,
-0.36997729539871216,
0.4303210377693176,
-0.07015255093574524,
-0.4377991855144501,
0.11167992651462555,
0.005632009357213974,
0.4438991844654083,
0.31665483117103577,
-0.7583314180374146,
0.17995627224445343,
1.0669512748718262,
0.6085249781608582,
-0.30317142605781555,
-0.5936599969863892,
-0.5060018301010132,
0.08928386121988297,
-0.5395308136940002,
0.4708186686038971,
-0.47668805718421936,
0.33210983872413635,
0.18216286599636078,
0.028633952140808105,
-0.20371320843696594,
-0.3712637722492218,
0.3100910186767578,
-0.6106802821159363,
0.1082117035984993,
-0.41227298974990845,
-0.7807866930961609,
0.03134382143616676,
0.18214507400989532,
-0.6086715459823608,
0.6874111294746399,
-0.07536964118480682,
-0.49445071816444397,
0.3103896379470825,
-0.334083616733551,
-0.397817462682724,
0.17254216969013214,
-0.102232925593853,
-0.36921778321266174,
0.22619611024856567,
0.17742294073104858,
0.9409404397010803,
-0.5260961651802063,
0.439726859331131,
-0.29648327827453613,
-0.34593331813812256,
0.6721463799476624,
-0.12274261564016342,
1.0104236602783203,
-0.06236623227596283,
-0.07635345309972763,
0.04174986854195595,
-0.6968223452568054,
0.020480595529079437,
0.30739787220954895,
-0.09539829939603806,
-0.1272890269756317,
-0.13782934844493866,
0.029396384954452515,
-0.17616833746433258,
0.47395023703575134,
-0.5739704966545105,
0.12410236150026321,
-0.07269203662872314,
0.2352018505334854,
0.6688843965530396,
-0.0980372205376625,
0.24518834054470062,
-0.2654492259025574,
0.6859397292137146,
-0.685266375541687,
-0.15280187129974365,
-0.376674622297287,
-0.46976757049560547,
-0.3532728850841522,
-0.6084457635879517,
0.4224894940853119,
0.5811280608177185,
-0.4567919671535492,
0.6060251593589783,
-0.3831094801425934,
-0.5040724873542786,
-0.3383193016052246,
0.4282470643520355,
0.6502813696861267,
0.17915113270282745,
0.19270388782024384,
-0.07451432198286057,
-0.30594027042388916,
-0.7113407850265503,
-0.6456933617591858,
-0.0410529263317585,
-0.17800548672676086,
0.24602161347866058,
0.6766895651817322,
0.3018318712711334,
0.7298566102981567,
-0.487698495388031,
-0.12286224216222763,
-0.47218814492225647,
0.2675345838069916,
0.32137128710746765,
0.2653871476650238,
0.4632570147514343,
-0.4695538878440857,
-0.613347589969635,
0.14582887291908264,
-1.0593026876449585,
-0.4825671911239624,
-0.309162974357605,
0.07014459371566772,
-0.09189969301223755,
0.6881859302520752,
-0.6771950125694275,
0.24292495846748352,
0.38976576924324036,
-0.41168856620788574,
0.6960000991821289,
-0.15330015122890472,
0.2038990706205368,
-0.6163336634635925,
0.32989808917045593,
-0.03859604150056839,
-0.1575935333967209,
-0.5458235144615173,
0.2689768075942993,
0.08844096213579178,
0.09645136445760727,
-0.167281374335289,
0.6041273474693298,
-0.8559785485267639,
-0.08737900108098984,
-0.17837615311145782,
0.18023188412189484,
-0.09110023826360703,
0.49101898074150085,
-0.15901578962802887,
0.3551335632801056,
0.4768102467060089,
-0.1651354432106018,
0.49909958243370056,
0.11008347570896149,
-0.7256526947021484,
0.5729787349700928,
-0.7484265565872192,
0.16400206089019775,
-0.074024498462677,
0.1655666083097458,
-1.1555278301239014,
-0.3616181015968323,
-0.0936155840754509,
-0.6039738655090332,
0.42453619837760925,
-0.3773614168167114,
-0.867595911026001,
0.023867959156632423,
-0.22387216985225677,
0.3349648118019104,
0.3197086751461029,
-0.2649289071559906,
0.6691651940345764,
0.07791703194379807,
-0.5233755111694336,
-0.5594789981842041,
-0.442828893661499,
0.3213183283805847,
-0.23590728640556335,
-0.5632476210594177,
0.23713625967502594,
0.2355324625968933,
-0.39452657103538513,
-0.10327102988958359,
0.36403438448905945,
-0.10540366917848587,
0.2530093193054199,
0.08189196139574051,
0.1954822987318039,
-0.14373880624771118,
-0.0476175919175148,
-0.08010435849428177,
-0.17119182646274567,
0.136662557721138,
-0.00849291030317545,
0.19506655633449554,
0.21807768940925598,
-0.3802507817745209,
-0.4053996503353119,
0.25295230746269226,
0.7526103854179382,
-0.42175161838531494,
0.9153102040290833,
0.5037751197814941,
-0.3092980682849884,
-0.3601229190826416,
-0.7333621978759766,
-0.04185905680060387,
-0.36514580249786377,
0.24315130710601807,
-0.0975259467959404,
-0.8952696919441223,
0.7098604440689087,
0.14058439433574677,
0.004076952114701271,
0.47326943278312683,
0.6361094117164612,
0.018387367948889732,
0.4360008239746094,
0.6245108246803284,
0.029445847496390343,
0.05768604949116707,
-0.05140318349003792,
0.3135187327861786,
-0.7701889276504517,
-0.2450571060180664,
-0.6357120275497437,
-0.22978192567825317,
-0.4407566487789154,
-0.2906780540943146,
0.16911858320236206,
-0.23831269145011902,
-0.20019201934337616,
0.34421658515930176,
-0.3064475357532501,
0.6380626559257507,
0.25502991676330566,
-0.14906522631645203,
0.3147258460521698,
-0.3108276128768921,
0.1742781102657318,
0.09460736811161041,
-0.19370529055595398,
-0.7507262229919434,
1.146758794784546,
0.353518545627594,
0.6558847427368164,
0.309314489364624,
0.4375097453594208,
0.45810604095458984,
0.10913892835378647,
-0.5118971467018127,
0.6332457661628723,
-0.17354820668697357,
-0.6774947643280029,
-0.5661914348602295,
-0.3388479948043823,
-0.6157150268554688,
0.21578449010849,
-0.3222101926803589,
-0.9570819139480591,
-0.03299693390727043,
-0.041652388870716095,
-0.3128061592578888,
0.28579163551330566,
-0.5034512877464294,
0.8805941939353943,
-0.40852564573287964,
-0.5011863112449646,
0.029865536838769913,
-0.5528209209442139,
0.26189133524894714,
-0.40982481837272644,
0.2282031923532486,
-0.150051087141037,
0.044091250747442245,
0.6650404334068298,
-0.18352511525154114,
0.9312185645103455,
-0.12178327143192291,
-0.5637795329093933,
0.015355449169874191,
0.13339971005916595,
0.3983689546585083,
-0.025720005854964256,
-0.3600904047489166,
0.24062480032444,
-0.10643468052148819,
-0.23890899121761322,
-0.64401775598526,
0.8442906737327576,
-0.5344374179840088,
-0.39344245195388794,
-0.22641459107398987,
-0.32131701707839966,
-0.170001819729805,
0.20892362296581268,
0.14031843841075897,
0.3911423981189728,
-0.08897221088409424,
0.5329292416572571,
0.488770455121994,
-0.5487197637557983,
0.22402235865592957,
0.234342560172081,
-0.1382727175951004,
-0.2833109200000763,
0.8701195120811462,
0.059479814022779465,
0.219017893075943,
0.5177956819534302,
0.2512946128845215,
-0.12144576758146286,
-0.6763213872909546,
-0.5007454752922058,
0.5104123950004578,
-0.5836101174354553,
0.1449335217475891,
-0.6141467094421387,
-0.021793395280838013,
-0.2695486545562744,
-0.4313693046569824,
-0.28371384739875793,
-0.2744910418987274,
-0.23920327425003052,
0.07302422821521759,
0.042866144329309464,
0.7656501531600952,
0.368561714887619,
0.39630237221717834,
-0.3479871153831482,
0.3256925046443939,
0.18906953930854797,
0.2608749568462372,
0.3295113444328308,
-0.6902487277984619,
-0.30627092719078064,
-0.24058587849140167,
-0.04954037070274353,
-0.7135491967201233,
0.0469442680478096,
0.06255651265382767,
0.6917934417724609,
0.2962675988674164,
-0.19148759543895721,
0.3562554717063904,
-0.41609126329421997,
0.9139121174812317,
-0.07622751593589783,
-1.0509449243545532,
0.25915029644966125,
-0.48131856322288513,
0.11761051416397095,
0.38413819670677185,
0.3807334899902344,
-0.3122839629650116,
-0.4808884859085083,
-0.2675114870071411,
-0.708884060382843,
0.6215560436248779,
0.27923592925071716,
0.1092725396156311,
0.30007174611091614,
0.548222005367279,
0.34060099720954895,
0.12514962255954742,
-0.8136897087097168,
-0.01760111376643181,
0.40207067131996155,
-0.14319276809692383,
-0.301159143447876,
-0.5403240919113159,
0.04792095720767975,
-0.13211502134799957,
0.6118913292884827,
-0.1636287420988083,
0.06461024284362793,
-0.11940185725688934,
-0.28830575942993164,
0.04897242411971092,
0.3289766311645508,
0.5637521743774414,
1.0029383897781372,
-0.021580079570412636,
0.011121731251478195,
0.11158965528011322,
0.07295357435941696,
0.00006758912786608562,
0.0005132912774570286,
0.08596246689558029,
-0.13641610741615295,
1.1974059343338013,
0.4629440903663635,
0.08647710084915161,
-0.4853353798389435,
0.9063448905944824,
0.2260921150445938,
-0.2348024845123291,
-0.3972568213939667,
-0.09775132685899734,
0.265753835439682,
0.27218762040138245,
0.4247739315032959,
-0.4636402428150177,
-0.0916983038187027,
-0.5271545648574829,
-0.12688438594341278,
0.44732582569122314,
-0.13019801676273346,
-0.4266141355037689,
0.5411046743392944,
0.04515664279460907,
-0.1193249374628067,
0.4096680283546448,
0.08487758785486221,
-0.455282062292099,
0.8479801416397095,
0.2949182987213135,
1.0605908632278442,
-0.08883663266897202,
0.06828029453754425,
0.1396595686674118,
0.40604162216186523,
-0.026840422302484512,
0.06681954115629196,
-0.08273278176784515,
-0.6835103631019592,
-0.830024242401123,
-0.5325984954833984,
-0.53128582239151,
-0.02200016938149929,
-0.5231267809867859,
0.3095274865627289,
-0.3302467465400696,
0.11580891907215118,
0.435743510723114,
-0.1614282876253128,
-0.4404415488243103,
0.01753998175263405,
0.3166193962097168,
0.3386131823062897,
-1.0408549308776855,
0.3819252848625183,
0.5260769724845886,
-0.06240048259496689,
-0.45944738388061523,
-0.09956343472003937,
0.30655017495155334,
-0.8454957008361816,
0.6087857484817505,
0.21203067898750305,
-0.22836799919605255,
-0.12912517786026,
-0.8033139109611511,
-0.5000935792922974,
1.0048902034759521,
0.6974009871482849,
-0.2696283459663391,
0.11856677383184433,
0.26507696509361267,
0.552123486995697,
-0.4339759945869446,
0.3772665560245514,
0.10898204147815704,
0.5368634462356567,
0.14181432127952576,
-1.0406930446624756,
0.19706545770168304,
-0.025809481739997864,
-0.1384003460407257,
0.05484237149357796,
-0.4168201982975006,
0.7633078098297119,
-0.28843045234680176,
0.09815593808889389,
0.1444423645734787,
0.35715195536613464,
0.1601332277059555,
0.22384296357631683,
0.36017364263534546,
0.2926498353481293,
0.7054778933525085,
-0.04891311377286911,
0.8965782523155212,
-0.24533461034297943,
0.382362425327301,
1.1024434566497803,
-0.5261107087135315,
0.6799041032791138,
0.41167810559272766,
-0.14133934676647186,
0.5568033456802368,
0.0985967293381691,
-0.21139466762542725,
0.15095651149749756,
0.45692601799964905,
-0.03642657399177551,
-0.47152411937713623,
-0.08703779429197311,
-0.0681038573384285,
0.6467593312263489,
0.009658938273787498,
-0.6403025388717651,
0.07238400727510452,
0.015136927366256714,
0.22521542012691498,
0.22443436086177826,
0.0187020655721426,
0.7433203458786011,
0.1859743595123291,
-0.5829007029533386,
0.3714112639427185,
-0.024614645168185234,
0.544513463973999,
-0.5599613785743713,
-0.00385743728838861,
0.14120395481586456,
0.21596765518188477,
-0.38538411259651184,
-0.9127298593521118,
0.0376485139131546,
0.25269630551338196,
-0.03919898346066475,
-0.5441756844520569,
0.5728574395179749,
-0.37753722071647644,
-0.4882887601852417,
0.20835617184638977,
0.6110373735427856,
0.23665323853492737,
-0.18455606698989868,
-0.06730755418539047,
0.20006433129310608,
-0.11576803773641586,
-0.26873472332954407,
0.07506401836872101,
0.6859190464019775,
-0.025395624339580536,
0.6590281128883362,
0.6394352912902832,
0.3745349645614624,
-0.22222863137722015,
0.09662884473800659,
0.3720836341381073,
-0.7010064125061035,
-0.10972122102975845,
-1.217145562171936,
0.4882553219795227,
-0.10955439507961273,
-0.3238748013973236,
0.8430459499359131,
0.5690174698829651,
0.7052494287490845,
-0.20621535181999207,
0.7647156715393066,
-0.13826356828212738,
0.396244078874588,
-0.6076844930648804,
0.9537383913993835,
-0.7259742021560669,
0.26018577814102173,
-0.5127323865890503,
-0.8528105020523071,
-0.530707597732544,
0.2680255174636841,
-0.3454257845878601,
0.2862682342529297,
0.6066260933876038,
0.5818538665771484,
0.0157383494079113,
-0.12208325415849686,
0.4354340434074402,
0.19699913263320923,
0.3908841609954834,
0.4079935848712921,
0.9591696858406067,
-0.19113674759864807,
0.25662165880203247,
-0.03281937912106514,
-0.3450052738189697,
-0.2397255003452301,
-1.2261388301849365,
-1.1116607189178467,
-0.5229222178459167,
-0.5042709708213806,
0.11994138360023499,
-0.09421643614768982,
0.6344451308250427,
0.4588954746723175,
-0.5727977156639099,
-0.28978103399276733,
0.3704221546649933,
0.22319179773330688,
-0.21498320996761322,
-0.12285096943378448,
0.4684230387210846,
-0.009765233844518661,
-0.5283500552177429,
0.12983126938343048,
0.26962313055992126,
-0.3686148524284363,
-0.354349285364151,
0.01157864648848772,
-0.1662239283323288,
0.20290490984916687,
0.5822775363922119,
0.04027242586016655,
-0.9936724901199341,
-0.20848087966442108,
0.021939944475889206,
-0.07195489853620529,
-0.24401502311229706,
0.8371384739875793,
-0.23062629997730255,
0.4363604485988617,
0.4107709228992462,
0.6668249368667603,
0.12229961156845093,
0.028621584177017212,
0.4894248843193054,
-0.5129457116127014,
-0.44444572925567627,
0.09689804911613464,
0.4441365599632263,
0.3647632598876953,
-0.5612583160400391,
0.3925879895687103,
-0.01115449983626604,
-0.8461199998855591,
-0.8140447735786438,
-0.04671068489551544,
-1.0831589698791504,
-0.17835836112499237,
1.2717101573944092,
-0.30281969904899597,
0.0003674211329780519,
-0.04648633301258087,
0.024179717525839806,
0.10509486496448517,
-0.07164613902568817,
0.5587260723114014,
1.0495113134384155,
0.10854870826005936,
-0.29230013489723206,
-0.5999227166175842,
0.16496743261814117,
0.3075249195098877,
-0.718313455581665,
0.480383962392807,
0.4798726737499237,
0.26302316784858704,
0.10067728161811829,
0.5292612314224243,
-0.27931299805641174,
0.13328833878040314,
-0.41353800892829895,
0.18314306437969208,
-0.3303864300251007,
-0.35595086216926575,
-0.24058674275875092,
0.24551549553871155,
0.2403401881456375,
0.12788204848766327
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08211v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08211v2
|
Large Language Models are Contrastive Reasoners
| 2024-03-13T03:15:05 | 2024-05-22T21:06:37 |
Liang Yao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Prompting methods play a crucial role in enhancing the capabilities of
pre-trained large language models (LLMs). We explore how contrastive prompting
(CP) significantly improves the ability of large language models to perform
complex reasoning. We demonstrate that LLMs are decent contrastive reasoners by
simply adding "Let's give a correct and a wrong answer." before LLMs provide
answers. Experiments on various large language models show that zero-shot
contrastive prompting improves performance on a range of arithmetic,
commonsense, and symbolic reasoning tasks without any hand-crafted few-shot
examples, such as increasing the accuracy on GSM8K from 35.9% to 88.8% and
AQUA-RAT from 41.3% to 62.2% with the state-of-the-art GPT-4 model. Our method
not only surpasses zero-shot CoT and few-shot CoT in most arithmetic and
commonsense reasoning tasks but also can seamlessly integrate with existing
prompting methods, resulting in improved or comparable results when compared to
state-of-the-art methods. Our code is available at
https://github.com/yao8839836/cp
|
[
-0.4031762480735779,
-0.7715035080909729,
0.9124550223350525,
0.19489365816116333,
-0.3369120955467224,
-0.24432051181793213,
-0.3546445369720459,
-0.22721286118030548,
-0.24404503405094147,
0.333135187625885,
-0.3453773260116577,
-0.355435848236084,
-0.5959526300430298,
0.19172915816307068,
-0.23978561162948608,
0.7877886295318604,
0.09757651388645172,
0.34479838609695435,
0.02045942284166813,
0.058308668434619904,
-0.48816633224487305,
-0.38949063420295715,
-0.9486923813819885,
-0.5428194999694824,
0.9625479578971863,
0.490342915058136,
0.570614755153656,
0.3812565803527832,
0.041445378214120865,
0.35975778102874756,
-0.29995450377464294,
0.13606339693069458,
-0.513812243938446,
0.22811469435691833,
-0.38357314467430115,
-0.7366136312484741,
-0.07347260415554047,
0.011197271756827831,
0.24534310400485992,
0.6717903017997742,
0.05235554277896881,
-0.23176440596580505,
0.08462102711200714,
0.6326212286949158,
-0.8071343898773193,
0.11772287636995316,
-0.7075353860855103,
-0.23342008888721466,
0.1352796107530594,
-0.400116503238678,
-0.6486718058586121,
-0.37585121393203735,
0.11625858396291733,
-0.534107506275177,
0.22367483377456665,
-0.13357974588871002,
0.7126015424728394,
0.20113645493984222,
-0.3774835467338562,
-0.17663928866386414,
-0.4522983133792877,
0.9699481725692749,
-0.8312792181968689,
0.2033241093158722,
0.3587084114551544,
0.2519646883010864,
-0.03256092220544815,
-0.47393882274627686,
-0.9267796277999878,
-0.4359045922756195,
-0.10168317705392838,
0.20311538875102997,
-0.23102010786533356,
0.17219336330890656,
0.512722373008728,
0.3417643904685974,
-0.3590317666530609,
0.17645618319511414,
-0.3799804151058197,
-0.07163696736097336,
0.2331811785697937,
0.15412069857120514,
0.21116477251052856,
0.06281525641679764,
-0.04262533783912659,
-0.03329642489552498,
-1.1319159269332886,
0.08180391043424606,
0.2670736014842987,
0.29181233048439026,
-0.36915889382362366,
0.4597015380859375,
-0.26611390709877014,
1.079465389251709,
0.3783700466156006,
0.1572062224149704,
-0.13232262432575226,
-0.2814575433731079,
-0.18087925016880035,
-0.12816712260246277,
0.5519654750823975,
0.4532615542411804,
0.5396729707717896,
0.33510053157806396,
-0.26799294352531433,
0.06179644539952278,
-0.1400514841079712,
-1.0378319025039673,
-0.6005700826644897,
0.3461064100265503,
-0.17504075169563293,
-0.1993551403284073,
-0.29537612199783325,
-0.5276646614074707,
-0.5607390999794006,
-0.6757663488388062,
0.5775676369667053,
-0.5576639175415039,
-0.15204200148582458,
0.41873225569725037,
-0.21000276505947113,
0.5742071866989136,
0.8278498649597168,
-1.0800585746765137,
-0.14269745349884033,
0.7927706241607666,
0.659756600856781,
0.21433131396770477,
-0.3166623115539551,
-0.8611838221549988,
-0.1837538331747055,
-0.7692393660545349,
1.0116209983825684,
-0.6914346814155579,
-0.2402327060699463,
0.09478602558374405,
-0.25091007351875305,
0.0031307670287787914,
-0.8424922823905945,
0.6291228532791138,
-0.5561012625694275,
0.3572121858596802,
-0.7470947504043579,
-0.36266595125198364,
-0.22208446264266968,
0.7163110375404358,
-0.4732373356819153,
0.6759496331214905,
-0.09962876886129379,
-0.6172874569892883,
0.15423448383808136,
-0.48848921060562134,
-0.24620594084262848,
0.1484222263097763,
-0.23488646745681763,
-0.021738944575190544,
0.10318872332572937,
0.7284055948257446,
0.5411685705184937,
-0.3102247416973114,
0.25116172432899475,
-0.2708057165145874,
-0.4750794768333435,
0.3158491849899292,
-0.5297139286994934,
0.8097807765007019,
0.12028076499700546,
-0.25952428579330444,
0.29092133045196533,
-0.4929546117782593,
-0.02058766782283783,
0.30418336391448975,
-0.3529009222984314,
-0.10532225668430328,
-0.3064139783382416,
-0.5128477811813354,
0.37113550305366516,
0.10899258404970169,
-0.36010995507240295,
0.0995522141456604,
-0.45921745896339417,
0.4383474290370941,
0.7507644295692444,
-0.07897166907787323,
0.2894359827041626,
-0.5382799506187439,
0.4912610650062561,
0.18323487043380737,
-0.18319353461265564,
-0.8312402367591858,
-0.3532921075820923,
-0.9211339950561523,
-0.4155897796154022,
0.2296457588672638,
0.5413724780082703,
-1.005496859550476,
0.2580966651439667,
0.07465669512748718,
-0.41279542446136475,
-0.4364705979824066,
-0.019987400621175766,
0.602335512638092,
0.9149754047393799,
0.4170624315738678,
0.3247331380844116,
-0.34339189529418945,
-0.6018648147583008,
-0.07939611375331879,
-0.10672400891780853,
-0.20400582253932953,
0.31606611609458923,
0.24397115409374237,
0.28451666235923767,
0.4629727303981781,
-0.3981892764568329,
0.25838735699653625,
-0.4770001471042633,
0.19981329143047333,
0.4811607301235199,
0.3046940863132477,
0.37942808866500854,
-0.6899265050888062,
-0.662554919719696,
-0.1413554847240448,
-0.662328839302063,
-0.47358566522598267,
-0.12483959645032883,
0.046912431716918945,
0.13529998064041138,
0.5801997184753418,
-0.7633394598960876,
0.00714521761983633,
0.6266347169876099,
-0.37810567021369934,
0.8883912563323975,
-0.2726622521877289,
0.40285298228263855,
-0.8613653779029846,
0.1593603640794754,
-0.0909581333398819,
-0.16691376268863678,
-0.6981560587882996,
0.21181721985340118,
0.02900543436408043,
-0.194424107670784,
-0.6637910008430481,
0.6527467370033264,
-0.4010375738143921,
0.2913483679294586,
-0.3923407793045044,
0.38524413108825684,
0.3382621109485626,
0.2360236495733261,
0.013990049250423908,
0.899969756603241,
0.891247034072876,
-0.9080817103385925,
0.3948941230773926,
0.04178290441632271,
-0.22715094685554504,
0.8684389591217041,
-0.9679985642433167,
-0.020485064014792442,
-0.24668750166893005,
0.47120803594589233,
-1.238407850265503,
-0.2884875237941742,
0.1635097861289978,
-0.45973068475723267,
0.33109599351882935,
-0.16207225620746613,
-0.270006000995636,
-0.32139143347740173,
-0.43208974599838257,
0.43557414412498474,
0.4261702001094818,
-1.0457754135131836,
0.4736443758010864,
-0.25172391533851624,
-0.4027113616466522,
-0.7426639199256897,
-0.497163325548172,
0.0898701623082161,
0.03390640765428543,
-0.5059167742729187,
0.04999600350856781,
-0.40557006001472473,
-0.3343903720378876,
-0.2784454822540283,
-0.0042772055603563786,
0.01671474613249302,
-0.05284794047474861,
-0.05065440386533737,
0.7115808725357056,
-0.42690959572792053,
0.1585657298564911,
-0.1761334389448166,
-0.356500506401062,
0.1013655960559845,
-0.16167518496513367,
0.8997654318809509,
-0.14791978895664215,
-0.4139454960823059,
-0.8001217842102051,
0.16420431435108185,
0.3897266387939453,
-0.2776815891265869,
0.5773935914039612,
0.21358519792556763,
-0.08183159679174423,
-0.02037542313337326,
-0.8301663398742676,
-0.38134682178497314,
-0.5077548027038574,
0.0734475776553154,
-0.4832639992237091,
-1.1913262605667114,
0.32466447353363037,
-0.004819647874683142,
0.07364365458488464,
0.3135184645652771,
0.6519938111305237,
0.017305156216025352,
1.1442521810531616,
0.18018095195293427,
0.08199144154787064,
0.4800574779510498,
0.07476368546485901,
0.4411337077617645,
-0.722360372543335,
-0.11962255835533142,
-0.695056140422821,
-0.06706170737743378,
-0.2632632553577423,
-0.534275233745575,
0.1325404793024063,
0.3337183892726898,
-0.4596056044101715,
-0.17816224694252014,
-0.5418614149093628,
1.0767569541931152,
0.3048535883426666,
0.10721714794635773,
0.11370798200368881,
-0.18483737111091614,
-0.12157842516899109,
-0.057093195617198944,
-0.572032630443573,
-0.4026513397693634,
0.7904888987541199,
0.09117837995290756,
0.7499935626983643,
0.02257070504128933,
0.8055042028427124,
-0.27850794792175293,
0.4065101444721222,
-1.0692834854125977,
0.649681568145752,
-0.08094923198223114,
-0.468544065952301,
-0.30084937810897827,
-0.5368648767471313,
-0.9582247138023376,
0.4749397933483124,
-0.1760810762643814,
-0.5471382737159729,
0.19490498304367065,
0.5582480430603027,
-0.6194785237312317,
0.11611759662628174,
-0.8165095448493958,
0.603500247001648,
-0.14812301099300385,
-0.5435207486152649,
-0.2937602996826172,
-0.3673783838748932,
0.4665411710739136,
0.09107524901628494,
-0.07586851716041565,
0.02329072915017605,
-0.14472472667694092,
0.3206467926502228,
-0.33433160185813904,
0.9117414951324463,
-0.19369684159755707,
-0.27780067920684814,
0.2944885492324829,
0.35058334469795227,
0.7447801828384399,
-0.2813985347747803,
-0.4115225672721863,
-0.10513392090797424,
-0.31672778725624084,
-0.5640207529067993,
-0.7856603264808655,
0.8373286128044128,
-0.3884322941303253,
-0.9714115858078003,
-0.20697620511054993,
-0.4725034832954407,
-0.24248652160167694,
0.2568148970603943,
0.38687795400619507,
0.36438602209091187,
0.17533709108829498,
0.29577797651290894,
1.059085488319397,
-0.39396265149116516,
0.44302868843078613,
0.6767875552177429,
-0.10267137736082077,
-0.3631512224674225,
0.719429612159729,
-0.12471405416727066,
0.5683008432388306,
0.5020638704299927,
0.6443101763725281,
-0.4118300974369049,
-0.5821408629417419,
-0.3801027834415436,
0.4482514560222626,
-1.0161089897155762,
-0.242288276553154,
-0.7178916931152344,
-0.08177400380373001,
-0.313005268573761,
-0.6427251696586609,
-0.0885266661643982,
-0.3122452199459076,
-0.11527890712022781,
-0.21953043341636658,
0.09615384042263031,
0.7778974771499634,
-0.07796104997396469,
0.21543586254119873,
-0.8414266109466553,
0.30141425132751465,
0.7662494778633118,
0.1292814314365387,
0.23613499104976654,
-0.7423446178436279,
0.21300500631332397,
-0.18177153170108795,
-0.24837204813957214,
-0.6890556812286377,
0.20089687407016754,
-0.15307487547397614,
0.5876943469047546,
0.4787231981754303,
0.054967910051345825,
0.7651634812355042,
-0.47045350074768066,
1.153072476387024,
0.5051978826522827,
-1.1264424324035645,
0.43314146995544434,
-0.5752202868461609,
0.6644460558891296,
0.4478822350502014,
0.37305447459220886,
-0.48512643575668335,
-0.27483347058296204,
-0.4027807414531708,
-0.7035617232322693,
0.7104207277297974,
-0.1252894401550293,
0.405337393283844,
-0.1221088096499443,
0.3261398673057556,
-0.10257788747549057,
-0.036214519292116165,
-0.9436348676681519,
0.00006240700895432383,
-0.19170686602592468,
-0.015120330266654491,
0.045464176684617996,
-0.4790312349796295,
-0.21375544369220734,
-0.15029124915599823,
0.7647654414176941,
-0.30205774307250977,
-0.02011270448565483,
0.20425522327423096,
0.14067210257053375,
-0.18779875338077545,
0.6532875299453735,
0.8034462928771973,
0.8243805170059204,
0.10991799086332321,
0.468878835439682,
0.4555582106113434,
0.13269539177417755,
0.03849579766392708,
0.08032052218914032,
-0.11178719252347946,
-0.23427355289459229,
0.5222577452659607,
0.643292248249054,
0.23733144998550415,
-0.6357548236846924,
0.7660835385322571,
0.019842201843857765,
-0.3723851144313812,
0.19242824614048004,
0.17169548571109772,
0.35783252120018005,
0.26278257369995117,
0.07922070473432541,
-0.23823228478431702,
0.053270384669303894,
-0.4360203742980957,
-0.14468833804130554,
0.3364822268486023,
-0.25498077273368835,
-0.13699090480804443,
0.42490366101264954,
0.2683371603488922,
-0.16149616241455078,
0.5409440994262695,
-0.08046035468578339,
-0.7477723360061646,
0.4851522147655487,
0.9539039134979248,
0.4929347634315491,
-0.5839021801948547,
0.22320742905139923,
0.7436115145683289,
0.05919496715068817,
-0.26270467042922974,
0.3438407778739929,
-0.2765393853187561,
-0.7623494863510132,
-0.7356066703796387,
-0.32390648126602173,
-0.6313475966453552,
0.3386157155036926,
-0.3443818986415863,
0.28670427203178406,
-0.6063623428344727,
0.4639880359172821,
0.22863440215587616,
-0.20069582760334015,
-0.4164407551288605,
0.33144569396972656,
0.2970031499862671,
0.991871178150177,
-0.7437834739685059,
0.6263288259506226,
0.41398873925209045,
-0.3744639754295349,
-1.1300358772277832,
0.07368282228708267,
0.0903361514210701,
-0.936301589012146,
0.6909987926483154,
0.43149736523628235,
-0.30739980936050415,
-0.16913455724716187,
-0.9867022037506104,
-0.46353378891944885,
0.6268961429595947,
0.6167731285095215,
-0.8878987431526184,
0.30980584025382996,
-0.09582927078008652,
0.5685642957687378,
-0.22015118598937988,
0.4177132844924927,
0.38718506693840027,
0.614036500453949,
0.7126287817955017,
-0.6161031126976013,
0.30471426248550415,
-0.17085351049900055,
-0.1305283159017563,
0.2566879391670227,
-0.39971399307250977,
1.051253080368042,
-0.6748634576797485,
-0.032410286366939545,
0.13482527434825897,
0.2965615689754486,
0.8847841024398804,
0.35482585430145264,
0.601427435874939,
0.388933002948761,
0.8517979979515076,
-0.1416311413049698,
1.2070941925048828,
-0.19927896559238434,
-0.0802590399980545,
1.2255104780197144,
-0.4196385443210602,
0.9863193035125732,
0.4061092734336853,
0.09315275400876999,
0.4907318353652954,
0.4162618815898895,
0.11807916313409805,
0.21850469708442688,
0.19790427386760712,
-0.6068071126937866,
-0.7693406343460083,
-0.10255734622478485,
-0.2570250630378723,
0.14555439352989197,
0.39132076501846313,
-0.24319599568843842,
-0.38118061423301697,
-0.3077941834926605,
0.21918614208698273,
0.2625202238559723,
-0.4101949632167816,
0.7314682006835938,
0.31647008657455444,
-1.1830031871795654,
0.9219600558280945,
-0.30835017561912537,
0.6337915062904358,
-0.6069387197494507,
-0.24575088918209076,
-0.2071952372789383,
0.0994546040892601,
-0.31758788228034973,
-1.0575181245803833,
0.060744158923625946,
-0.05966019257903099,
-0.10073185712099075,
-0.14551804959774017,
0.6573240160942078,
-0.5408533811569214,
0.033955734223127365,
0.17963232100009918,
0.38278359174728394,
0.07600405812263489,
-0.22120364010334015,
-0.8457494378089905,
-0.12032093107700348,
0.0718114823102951,
-0.03828498348593712,
0.12107235193252563,
0.6977208256721497,
-0.007391426246613264,
0.6825371384620667,
0.9567131996154785,
0.0566471703350544,
-0.32786911725997925,
0.46281132102012634,
1.009743094444275,
-0.869889497756958,
-0.43059319257736206,
-1.111625075340271,
0.6148321628570557,
-0.12538108229637146,
-0.09522617608308792,
0.5771111249923706,
0.30202654004096985,
0.5637580156326294,
-0.10409549623727798,
0.6822775602340698,
0.1996942013502121,
0.48428475856781006,
-0.6778724789619446,
0.37521395087242126,
-0.3470638394355774,
0.4022381901741028,
0.05916333943605423,
-0.8151318430900574,
-0.6573735475540161,
0.5838841795921326,
-0.7218791842460632,
0.1482759416103363,
0.7373756170272827,
1.1547975540161133,
0.07364017516374588,
0.050336092710494995,
0.804095447063446,
0.35043275356292725,
0.4799550771713257,
0.5984234809875488,
1.2643680572509766,
0.10489998757839203,
0.6654047966003418,
0.06767334789037704,
-0.2903279662132263,
-0.255336195230484,
-0.9867081046104431,
-1.124151587486267,
-0.17910748720169067,
-0.14641469717025757,
-0.5042995810508728,
-0.017019236460328102,
0.9608439207077026,
0.6691334843635559,
-0.8801817297935486,
0.09491149336099625,
-0.23515470325946808,
0.14387814700603485,
0.06613481789827347,
-0.22329942882061005,
0.17077012360095978,
-0.6723417043685913,
-0.7867196798324585,
0.4202309846878052,
0.38344475626945496,
0.10665851086378098,
-0.016352275386452675,
-0.2142297625541687,
-0.04610120505094528,
0.4528907239437103,
0.7318019270896912,
0.35280343890190125,
-0.7891323566436768,
-0.28660425543785095,
-0.23377801477909088,
-0.21038426458835602,
0.1478538066148758,
0.9013413786888123,
-0.7973368167877197,
0.5510402321815491,
0.6919444799423218,
0.44621095061302185,
0.351992666721344,
-0.029019862413406372,
0.6410397887229919,
-0.4366040825843811,
0.1340552568435669,
0.33698949217796326,
0.5948157906532288,
0.678448498249054,
-0.38917556405067444,
0.23840194940567017,
-0.006292812526226044,
-0.6902998089790344,
-0.5126348733901978,
0.45499885082244873,
-0.9395594000816345,
-0.3402673900127411,
1.225868582725525,
-0.30989184975624084,
-0.18506987392902374,
-0.1292235553264618,
-0.6831110119819641,
-0.01704215258359909,
-0.5281078815460205,
0.7960740327835083,
0.7434399127960205,
-0.14888514578342438,
-0.6402056813240051,
-0.14547370374202728,
0.3774934709072113,
0.7643898725509644,
-0.9954375624656677,
0.31498661637306213,
0.6852988004684448,
0.35721921920776367,
0.16094304621219635,
0.7160738706588745,
-0.250282883644104,
0.6876213550567627,
0.0016894567525014281,
-0.26091691851615906,
-0.06130266189575195,
-0.19728271663188934,
-0.784292995929718,
0.10689158737659454,
0.39798393845558167,
0.15692220628261566
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.13002v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.13002v3
|
AutoTRIZ: Artificial Ideation with TRIZ and Large Language Models
| 2024-03-13T02:53:36 | 2024-05-23T02:19:12 |
Shuo Jiang, Jianxi Luo
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL, I.2.7; I.2.1
|
Researchers and innovators have made enormous efforts in developing ideation
methods, such as morphological analysis and design-by-analogy, to aid
engineering design ideation for problem solving and innovation. Among these,
the Theory of Inventive Problem Solving (TRIZ) stands out as one of the most
well-known approaches, widely applied for systematic innovation. However, the
complexity of TRIZ resources and concepts, coupled with its reliance on users'
knowledge, experience, and reasoning capabilities, limits its practicality.
Therefore, we explore the recent advances of large language models (LLMs) for a
generative approach to bridge this gap. This paper proposes AutoTRIZ, an
artificial ideation tool that uses LLMs to automate and enhance the TRIZ
methodology. By leveraging the broad knowledge and advanced reasoning
capabilities of LLMs, AutoTRIZ offers a novel approach for design automation
and interpretable ideation with artificial intelligence. AutoTRIZ takes a
problem statement from the user as its initial input, and automatically
generates a solution report after the reasoning process. We demonstrate and
evaluate the effectiveness of AutoTRIZ through consistency experiments in
contradiction detection, and a case study comparing solutions generated by
AutoTRIZ with the experts' analyses from the textbook. Moreover, the proposed
LLM-based framework holds the potential for extension to automate other
knowledge-based ideation methods, including SCAMPER, Design Heuristics, and
Design-by-Analogy, paving the way for a new era of artificial ideation for
design innovation.
|
[
-0.4981329143047333,
-0.8953154683113098,
0.8094068169593811,
0.2004697173833847,
-0.23311299085617065,
0.4376154839992523,
-0.11987116187810898,
-0.44820648431777954,
0.06783723086118698,
0.22847524285316467,
-0.48569977283477783,
-0.4724544882774353,
-0.17595218122005463,
0.18281394243240356,
-0.6466880440711975,
0.3722379207611084,
-0.613779604434967,
-0.34831222891807556,
-0.18273614346981049,
0.23013073205947876,
-0.5451328158378601,
-0.21242181956768036,
-0.4169726073741913,
-0.37881606817245483,
0.07642842829227448,
0.5621647834777832,
0.7080078125,
0.7090857028961182,
0.37504372000694275,
0.42558741569519043,
0.1038830578327179,
0.2090599685907364,
0.14987926185131073,
0.051442574709653854,
0.021522490307688713,
-0.5295747518539429,
-0.2835967540740967,
-0.08931513130664825,
0.5891014933586121,
0.4322298765182495,
-0.2998156249523163,
0.2572619915008545,
0.04077102988958359,
0.49342408776283264,
-0.37986457347869873,
0.29790470004081726,
-0.6349785923957825,
0.31485381722450256,
-0.19921740889549255,
-0.17274141311645508,
-0.15700624883174896,
-0.552916407585144,
-0.05191827192902565,
-0.5609923005104065,
0.1339408904314041,
0.23203825950622559,
0.6610425114631653,
0.6946538686752319,
0.3425830900669098,
-0.5974622964859009,
-1.062684416770935,
0.5005014538764954,
-1.204545021057129,
0.23305024206638336,
-0.220770001411438,
0.43815603852272034,
-0.5327811241149902,
-0.4785629212856293,
-1.137537956237793,
-0.3325270116329193,
0.05765226110816002,
0.0356682725250721,
-0.34802868962287903,
0.04718630760908127,
0.22453737258911133,
0.2790457308292389,
-0.6771891713142395,
0.18311507999897003,
-0.007277610246092081,
0.06414350122213364,
0.7916654348373413,
0.3965129256248474,
0.5092716217041016,
-0.14776922762393951,
-0.4736916422843933,
0.0790545791387558,
-0.5584104061126709,
-0.058285582810640335,
0.17045731842517853,
0.018785856664180756,
-0.06437080353498459,
0.5741774439811707,
-0.415057510137558,
0.8520066738128662,
0.07976808398962021,
0.26814666390419006,
0.3532676100730896,
-0.3025536835193634,
-0.32303646206855774,
-0.027351005002856255,
1.0213292837142944,
-0.15084975957870483,
0.38581985235214233,
-0.3014535903930664,
-0.23127205669879913,
0.0018460014835000038,
0.19287577271461487,
-0.4074334502220154,
-0.26321035623550415,
0.2990334630012512,
-0.3107260465621948,
-0.17894014716148376,
-0.06094815582036972,
-0.6687093377113342,
-0.2208683341741562,
-0.5013022422790527,
0.5854722857475281,
-0.20390069484710693,
-0.24413850903511047,
0.4698999226093292,
-0.050169866532087326,
0.278459370136261,
0.19719649851322174,
-0.5154085755348206,
-0.013372109271585941,
0.41456303000450134,
0.6777527332305908,
-0.11665643006563187,
-0.3327922523021698,
0.2774663269519806,
0.28921449184417725,
-0.7162052392959595,
1.1607446670532227,
-0.2548414468765259,
-0.4210093915462494,
-0.2421620488166809,
-0.4079013764858246,
0.20523186028003693,
-0.5507301092147827,
0.14444918930530548,
-0.31778958439826965,
0.014960027299821377,
0.1661156266927719,
-0.3552751839160919,
-0.2441205084323883,
-0.02837676741182804,
-0.715437650680542,
0.856783926486969,
0.12979622185230255,
-0.540155291557312,
0.3056336045265198,
-0.9337679147720337,
-0.3482564687728882,
0.6224379539489746,
-0.6854842901229858,
-0.6191139817237854,
0.0959777683019638,
-0.10571605712175369,
-0.0271746963262558,
-0.6045446395874023,
0.4652157425880432,
-0.42698749899864197,
-0.11568567156791687,
0.3437425494194031,
-0.2522573173046112,
0.9413846135139465,
0.35323888063430786,
-0.5676296353340149,
0.15460164844989777,
-0.5241159796714783,
0.45157670974731445,
0.3783071041107178,
-0.038476552814245224,
-0.02921845018863678,
-0.02951367199420929,
-0.35909825563430786,
0.4787212312221527,
0.20540083944797516,
-0.6446604132652283,
0.23604336380958557,
-0.5391044020652771,
0.4831300377845764,
0.408855676651001,
0.03162449225783348,
0.3821539580821991,
-0.3907189965248108,
0.47159355878829956,
-0.4023768901824951,
0.3338358700275421,
0.2531401216983795,
-0.32482388615608215,
-1.1253429651260376,
0.07042448967695236,
0.1095021665096283,
0.598457932472229,
-0.8899027705192566,
0.4283408522605896,
0.09723468869924545,
-0.6102738976478577,
-0.4585413634777069,
0.4143322706222534,
0.28807708621025085,
0.37733185291290283,
0.19575640559196472,
-0.19654837250709534,
-0.5750626921653748,
-1.1385951042175293,
-0.5423222184181213,
-0.1542956382036209,
-0.2051508128643036,
0.16463735699653625,
0.5725238919258118,
-0.14589828252792358,
1.5043809413909912,
-0.5881849527359009,
-0.35898908972740173,
-0.4074987769126892,
0.7395842671394348,
0.24335232377052307,
0.3072497844696045,
0.5574360489845276,
-0.7315346002578735,
-0.6322831511497498,
-0.29770156741142273,
-0.8705544471740723,
-0.4025367796421051,
-0.21602967381477356,
-0.17464767396450043,
0.07662566006183624,
0.515314519405365,
-0.8073459267616272,
0.6196108460426331,
-0.025642329826951027,
-0.15337145328521729,
0.624847412109375,
-0.11077166348695755,
-0.1729724109172821,
-1.1304211616516113,
0.0006633835146203637,
-0.055036790668964386,
0.30301278829574585,
-0.39668604731559753,
-0.2853555977344513,
0.004832414910197258,
-0.04687407240271568,
-0.36385253071784973,
0.7439045906066895,
-0.4528539180755615,
-0.048295922577381134,
-0.47809359431266785,
0.10348337888717651,
0.06410423666238785,
0.29664695262908936,
-0.019008660688996315,
0.8562963008880615,
0.12602132558822632,
-0.570285439491272,
1.0044059753417969,
0.4471156597137451,
-0.42650115489959717,
0.33504965901374817,
-0.7410275340080261,
0.24510034918785095,
-0.03909850865602493,
0.15314781665802002,
-0.9597613215446472,
-0.19283361732959747,
0.4780021905899048,
-0.4566851854324341,
-0.05029302090406418,
0.15416783094406128,
-0.9608606696128845,
-0.8296094536781311,
-0.012575131841003895,
0.5385244488716125,
0.21144697070121765,
-0.3721434473991394,
0.8530659675598145,
0.43443524837493896,
-0.6284392476081848,
-0.2182994931936264,
-0.6463586091995239,
0.44241389632225037,
-0.3247053027153015,
-0.49046745896339417,
0.6356998085975647,
-0.4307616055011749,
-0.4797615110874176,
0.2978857755661011,
0.16039851307868958,
-0.23757393658161163,
0.029026057571172714,
-0.0069574336521327496,
0.3514222502708435,
0.07814756780862808,
0.2564711570739746,
-0.12321555614471436,
-0.19641681015491486,
0.336264967918396,
-0.4340682923793793,
0.5090861916542053,
-0.4098946750164032,
-0.46976763010025024,
-0.43287286162376404,
0.3615947365760803,
0.4907689392566681,
-0.43648967146873474,
0.2945252060890198,
0.32987481355667114,
-0.46428364515304565,
-0.8651069402694702,
-0.5674057006835938,
0.17931166291236877,
-0.55795818567276,
0.2123790830373764,
-0.3692303001880646,
-0.41809454560279846,
0.47470927238464355,
-0.2237149178981781,
0.3188337981700897,
0.35286062955856323,
0.8482810258865356,
-0.3763904571533203,
0.7926837205886841,
0.8842653632164001,
0.1139398142695427,
0.5675297379493713,
-0.32708531618118286,
0.5063133239746094,
-0.6230254769325256,
-0.3070836067199707,
-0.4996901750564575,
-0.2557196021080017,
-0.14319074153900146,
-0.21872588992118835,
0.4727707505226135,
-0.2264394909143448,
-0.30879679322242737,
0.4454517960548401,
-0.4795357882976532,
0.42882511019706726,
0.42213186621665955,
-0.11612557619810104,
0.3682740330696106,
-0.1924181431531906,
-0.35763898491859436,
0.38184911012649536,
-1.1844642162322998,
-0.37348034977912903,
0.8782274127006531,
0.1231396272778511,
0.8987851738929749,
-0.15652120113372803,
0.6822795271873474,
0.399804949760437,
0.43951156735420227,
-0.8322526216506958,
0.5304295420646667,
0.2688380181789398,
-0.5224481225013733,
-0.5264151096343994,
-0.23153901100158691,
-0.5760683417320251,
-0.25807857513427734,
-0.16591580212116241,
-0.4257155954837799,
0.1728600114583969,
0.25636616349220276,
-0.7881338596343994,
0.33897513151168823,
-0.6521210670471191,
0.6265901923179626,
-0.6995709538459778,
-0.2420906275510788,
-0.09602992981672287,
-0.4476276934146881,
0.020122162997722626,
-0.3545167148113251,
0.5144935250282288,
0.116083525121212,
0.271642804145813,
0.7894930839538574,
-0.10275143384933472,
0.7387059926986694,
0.1874479502439499,
-0.48304182291030884,
0.8617156147956848,
0.29634329676628113,
0.3540340065956116,
-0.0750381201505661,
0.06402751803398132,
-0.05080494284629822,
-0.43845197558403015,
0.059037238359451294,
-0.8630825877189636,
0.3287282884120941,
-0.42521893978118896,
-0.7605913877487183,
-0.1657259464263916,
-0.9786465764045715,
-0.1232055127620697,
0.29601988196372986,
0.1733257919549942,
0.2751418352127075,
-0.07896757125854492,
-0.1471962332725525,
0.5000615119934082,
-0.24540691077709198,
0.7193847298622131,
0.671373724937439,
-0.02205967716872692,
-0.3047175109386444,
0.7885461449623108,
0.06304898113012314,
0.0870356634259224,
0.02941337414085865,
0.08285737037658691,
-0.35538506507873535,
-0.6087720990180969,
-0.8214325308799744,
0.24917687475681305,
-0.631479799747467,
-0.38197070360183716,
-0.3210989832878113,
-0.5390141010284424,
-0.10430146753787994,
-0.1474432647228241,
-0.5225932002067566,
-0.3059156537055969,
0.03031141310930252,
0.244437575340271,
0.13411392271518707,
0.9095143675804138,
-0.14346636831760406,
0.059783052653074265,
-0.5906175971031189,
0.5401018857955933,
0.3930237293243408,
0.6683065891265869,
0.14325040578842163,
-0.33010146021842957,
-0.4784732460975647,
0.010131833143532276,
-0.24194608628749847,
-0.7562261819839478,
0.4496009647846222,
-0.13788336515426636,
0.792388916015625,
0.2250054031610489,
0.10352808237075806,
0.2529325783252716,
-0.532239556312561,
0.2217908501625061,
0.02315179817378521,
-0.9768338799476624,
0.4572524130344391,
-0.20783010125160217,
0.23807473480701447,
0.2947114408016205,
0.16490131616592407,
-0.4535728693008423,
-0.3468305170536041,
-0.6520566940307617,
-0.7543143033981323,
0.2617690861225128,
0.32622310519218445,
-0.23120786249637604,
0.2735109329223633,
0.39437586069107056,
0.12937842309474945,
0.34657594561576843,
-0.7002811431884766,
0.017559658735990524,
-0.01306210644543171,
-0.6597726941108704,
0.09724787622690201,
-0.0454033762216568,
-0.16338934004306793,
-0.25913891196250916,
0.48868319392204285,
0.07756263017654419,
0.4917190372943878,
0.04561114311218262,
-0.1524166762828827,
-0.42486506700515747,
0.3943405747413635,
0.35832905769348145,
0.6884998083114624,
0.14319966733455658,
0.17324909567832947,
0.3432428240776062,
-0.06790238618850708,
0.34168776869773865,
0.121060311794281,
-0.3993885815143585,
0.01601625233888626,
-0.000627090921625495,
0.3223596513271332,
-0.15043289959430695,
-0.5495105385780334,
0.00020457932259887457,
0.1131831482052803,
-0.28651511669158936,
-0.7787017822265625,
0.2911629378795624,
0.1455107033252716,
0.5540486574172974,
0.4188298285007477,
-0.2709031403064728,
0.139912411570549,
-0.25827571749687195,
0.238642156124115,
0.7070037126541138,
0.04101046919822693,
-0.011624973267316818,
0.5275998115539551,
0.19628207385540009,
-0.8216627836227417,
0.30585789680480957,
-0.23254382610321045,
-0.7482295036315918,
0.9211055636405945,
0.6690508127212524,
1.0548518896102905,
-0.2838403582572937,
0.15642543137073517,
0.024205490946769714,
0.2792951762676239,
0.073274165391922,
0.30219566822052,
-0.0552874431014061,
-0.8047308325767517,
-0.3539782762527466,
-0.5899758338928223,
-0.48290666937828064,
0.21921706199645996,
-0.13875283300876617,
0.3385246992111206,
-0.3972221314907074,
-0.09146886318922043,
0.04913564398884773,
-0.06609644740819931,
-0.5777084231376648,
0.2134639173746109,
0.383279025554657,
0.723013162612915,
-0.7795025706291199,
0.48640668392181396,
0.7247301936149597,
-0.3947959840297699,
-0.8212023377418518,
0.052555933594703674,
-0.05735776573419571,
-0.5634932518005371,
0.6913801431655884,
-0.19531932473182678,
-0.617570161819458,
0.4024368226528168,
-0.6730211973190308,
-1.0492745637893677,
1.0690727233886719,
0.03525383770465851,
-0.5883644223213196,
-0.3677912950515747,
0.5743860602378845,
0.35493913292884827,
-0.5970134735107422,
0.011736049316823483,
0.5245862603187561,
0.5035072565078735,
-0.003236806020140648,
-1.1052417755126953,
0.013817987404763699,
-0.4538947343826294,
-0.09556835144758224,
0.33995187282562256,
-0.5862652063369751,
0.8395119905471802,
-0.31738460063934326,
-0.3498583734035492,
0.07941990345716476,
0.5572578310966492,
0.1997939646244049,
0.2642708420753479,
0.5044153332710266,
0.6905813813209534,
0.30106469988822937,
0.1908155232667923,
0.47942492365837097,
-0.37155070900917053,
0.38194313645362854,
0.962167501449585,
-0.01949174329638481,
0.42935335636138916,
0.28882649540901184,
-0.1275297850370407,
0.6764437556266785,
0.3900207579135895,
-0.3194882869720459,
0.29438406229019165,
0.41544535756111145,
-0.21719896793365479,
-0.36979058384895325,
0.10511068999767303,
-0.28659090399742126,
0.610248327255249,
0.5684782266616821,
-0.18813323974609375,
-0.4878763258457184,
0.0998418927192688,
-0.07933132350444794,
0.04072542116045952,
-0.11974462121725082,
0.6101882457733154,
0.2840571403503418,
-0.29948362708091736,
0.7071947455406189,
0.029245976358652115,
0.2657175064086914,
-0.1913827657699585,
-0.30406224727630615,
0.04187024012207985,
0.158990740776062,
-0.07102532684803009,
-1.0239577293395996,
0.37882575392723083,
0.11219382286071777,
-0.009032774716615677,
-0.1349014937877655,
0.6823063492774963,
-0.2686285972595215,
-0.5647121071815491,
0.05123869702219963,
0.8678233623504639,
-0.041994355618953705,
0.10702545195817947,
-0.7881793975830078,
-0.17249256372451782,
-0.2595300078392029,
0.20094746351242065,
-0.32997679710388184,
0.6310910582542419,
-0.11931160092353821,
1.2024701833724976,
0.40991342067718506,
0.15178947150707245,
-0.17944326996803284,
-0.1754627823829651,
1.0086259841918945,
-0.7099357843399048,
-0.6605533361434937,
-0.9182143807411194,
0.24021266400814056,
0.08143067359924316,
0.11704649776220322,
0.6545513868331909,
0.46331632137298584,
0.9069205522537231,
0.056990813463926315,
1.2018989324569702,
-0.12733088433742523,
0.5500516295433044,
-0.3716564178466797,
0.8789165019989014,
-0.33702731132507324,
0.24119901657104492,
-0.4745316207408905,
-0.9029028415679932,
-0.318565309047699,
0.6698613166809082,
-0.5182614922523499,
0.02506442740559578,
0.5800020694732666,
0.39870378375053406,
0.05748184770345688,
-0.04463396593928337,
-0.13330551981925964,
0.45855987071990967,
0.378338098526001,
0.8701767325401306,
1.162394404411316,
0.15430830419063568,
0.5933874845504761,
-0.1324947327375412,
-0.45255231857299805,
-0.2549700438976288,
-0.86869877576828,
-0.8349146842956543,
-0.6116007566452026,
-0.00238553574308753,
0.031780779361724854,
-0.019135423004627228,
1.0866059064865112,
0.2066364288330078,
-0.5319265723228455,
-0.428975373506546,
-0.6689175367355347,
0.01704895868897438,
0.21923211216926575,
-0.16570189595222473,
0.2661232650279999,
-0.39325639605522156,
-0.3812093436717987,
0.24589648842811584,
0.26895269751548767,
0.25066515803337097,
-0.4764571487903595,
0.2021678239107132,
0.09632552415132523,
0.35692307353019714,
0.26237982511520386,
0.5153371095657349,
-0.6593876481056213,
-0.18797065317630768,
0.05982382595539093,
-0.03771756961941719,
0.12697450816631317,
0.7611305713653564,
-1.1244981288909912,
0.45452019572257996,
0.24134241044521332,
0.46768489480018616,
0.15707994997501373,
0.12772159278392792,
0.8149925470352173,
-0.016753965988755226,
0.130202054977417,
0.5019232034683228,
0.1243569552898407,
0.11337558180093765,
-0.22357133030891418,
0.14737634360790253,
0.21226151287555695,
-0.30317190289497375,
-0.562411904335022,
0.6755479574203491,
-0.3804894983768463,
-0.4129672050476074,
0.9952017664909363,
0.15319329500198364,
-0.28001412749290466,
-0.4002276659011841,
-0.2060195952653885,
0.6535394787788391,
0.005630997940897942,
1.576875925064087,
0.5485772490501404,
-0.4940643906593323,
-0.10370108485221863,
-0.6714123487472534,
0.7350349426269531,
0.4947904944419861,
-1.1060380935668945,
0.2078605443239212,
0.12368439137935638,
0.2214653640985489,
0.2164621651172638,
0.2665223777294159,
-0.06016770750284195,
0.26867109537124634,
-0.12617142498493195,
0.42152300477027893,
-0.37162867188453674,
-0.6774827241897583,
0.13814301788806915,
-0.04466479644179344,
0.19565731287002563,
-0.0204636100679636
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08198v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08198v1
|
Validating and Exploring Large Geographic Corpora
| 2024-03-13T02:46:17 | 2024-03-13T02:46:17 |
Jonathan Dunn
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper investigates the impact of corpus creation decisions on large
multi-lingual geographic web corpora. Beginning with a 427 billion word corpus
derived from the Common Crawl, three methods are used to improve the quality of
sub-corpora representing specific language-country pairs like New Zealand
English: (i) the agreement of independent language identification systems, (ii)
hash-based deduplication, and (iii) location-specific outlier detection. The
impact of each of these steps is then evaluated at the language level and the
country level by using corpus similarity measures to compare each resulting
corpus with baseline data sets. The goal is to understand the impact of
upstream data cleaning decisions on downstream corpora with a specific focus on
under-represented languages and populations. The evaluation shows that the
validity of sub-corpora is improved with each stage of cleaning but that this
improvement is unevenly distributed across languages and populations. This
result shows how standard corpus creation techniques can accidentally exclude
under-represented populations.
|
[
-0.8731857538223267,
-0.46351954340934753,
0.5987690687179565,
0.13825005292892456,
-0.09412731975317001,
0.31702494621276855,
-0.6029214262962341,
-0.5552829504013062,
0.35083693265914917,
0.5661329030990601,
-0.1600174456834793,
-0.8004001379013062,
-0.46314337849617004,
0.6125948429107666,
-0.5556728839874268,
0.826575756072998,
0.033877912908792496,
-0.20107486844062805,
-0.04226589575409889,
-0.14237815141677856,
-0.4495580494403839,
-0.6068457365036011,
-0.4948986768722534,
0.09385056048631668,
0.49993154406547546,
0.772907018661499,
0.9386845827102661,
0.4787904918193817,
0.48290055990219116,
0.33428138494491577,
-0.2986111342906952,
0.5577232837677002,
-0.6651954650878906,
-0.0475141666829586,
-0.3221464157104492,
-0.42589032649993896,
0.012922180816531181,
-0.11373534798622131,
0.7301707863807678,
1.0176883935928345,
-0.06542669236660004,
0.18552769720554352,
-0.02992306649684906,
0.5612397193908691,
-0.7561832666397095,
-0.12641316652297974,
-0.6521701216697693,
-0.24864058196544647,
-0.409296452999115,
-0.17044107615947723,
-0.2563909888267517,
-0.4050932228565216,
0.10705546289682388,
-0.7683768272399902,
0.48660406470298767,
0.15890176594257355,
0.7508972883224487,
0.04987769201397896,
-0.46427664160728455,
-0.5301439762115479,
-0.5982850193977356,
0.8159543871879578,
-0.35558101534843445,
0.32972636818885803,
0.6438944935798645,
0.05105282738804817,
-0.4481077194213867,
-0.40847402811050415,
-0.34462687373161316,
0.12311747670173645,
-0.3474179208278656,
0.06231933459639549,
-0.38870564103126526,
-0.43642333149909973,
0.144302636384964,
0.0920039713382721,
-0.6762556433677673,
0.44893747568130493,
-0.9751793742179871,
-0.23157671093940735,
0.5438347458839417,
-0.11046434938907623,
0.4933072626590729,
-0.32346054911613464,
-0.1909622997045517,
-0.12130870670080185,
-1.1913164854049683,
-0.11318724602460861,
0.8912193775177002,
0.6080729365348816,
0.03515410050749779,
0.5406522750854492,
-0.32956263422966003,
0.301425576210022,
-0.09491445869207382,
0.14822959899902344,
0.43679124116897583,
-0.2398509532213211,
-0.010303674265742302,
0.3134916424751282,
0.5377432703971863,
0.31955137848854065,
0.5676588416099548,
-0.2648434042930603,
-0.042329929769039154,
0.09665197879076004,
0.3796263635158539,
-0.36930325627326965,
-0.059360258281230927,
0.4582589268684387,
-0.3295328915119171,
0.012294059619307518,
0.24720211327075958,
-0.9302847385406494,
-0.37652090191841125,
-0.5307461023330688,
-0.14929696917533875,
-0.5916760563850403,
-0.5505834221839905,
0.2875410318374634,
-0.3842434287071228,
-0.01940727047622204,
0.3627468943595886,
-0.8907555937767029,
0.19020405411720276,
1.0248359441757202,
0.7712844610214233,
-0.1983807384967804,
-0.49103525280952454,
-0.3158305883407593,
-0.00804955419152975,
-0.7472807168960571,
0.972891092300415,
-0.42856618762016296,
-0.392813116312027,
0.27657297253608704,
0.07874429225921631,
0.07008326053619385,
-0.9172831177711487,
0.3479491174221039,
-0.9521256685256958,
0.15783202648162842,
-0.4761982560157776,
-0.27456149458885193,
-0.4963819980621338,
0.4178268313407898,
-0.876500129699707,
1.135425090789795,
0.32921937108039856,
-0.561335563659668,
0.6157873868942261,
-0.6122291684150696,
-0.4260180592536926,
0.1839217096567154,
0.20818011462688446,
-0.047251783311367035,
0.18875624239444733,
0.3142714202404022,
0.07969040423631668,
-0.121603824198246,
0.2244722992181778,
-0.10513715445995331,
-0.5432141423225403,
-0.05954195186495781,
-0.08776687830686569,
1.10273277759552,
0.46176877617836,
-0.46597450971603394,
-0.10202737897634506,
-0.9461198449134827,
0.2609398365020752,
-0.3713797926902771,
-0.3614465594291687,
-0.7353538274765015,
-0.13387717306613922,
0.05775892361998558,
-0.07474508136510849,
0.19333291053771973,
-0.6353675127029419,
0.1011691763997078,
-0.15530097484588623,
0.37396374344825745,
0.2813138961791992,
0.14358562231063843,
0.41538023948669434,
-0.07064640522003174,
0.6142877340316772,
-0.03818177804350853,
0.21104079484939575,
-0.012787669897079468,
-0.46009010076522827,
-0.43617767095565796,
-0.5486494898796082,
0.7181575894355774,
0.422297865152359,
-0.41905614733695984,
0.3674766421318054,
-0.6797129511833191,
-0.6775197386741638,
-0.36181044578552246,
0.09649529308080673,
0.13414950668811798,
0.05495261773467064,
0.5433967709541321,
-0.38889122009277344,
-0.8588950634002686,
-0.7004209756851196,
0.41174250841140747,
-0.19289547204971313,
-0.16371476650238037,
-0.22731894254684448,
0.6004502773284912,
-0.7008017301559448,
1.2023372650146484,
-0.29993191361427307,
-0.14994435012340546,
-0.006707348860800266,
0.28814443945884705,
-0.13151800632476807,
0.29888537526130676,
0.5566136240959167,
-0.8837624192237854,
-0.28266283869743347,
-0.13194631040096283,
-0.5448529720306396,
-0.34411218762397766,
0.16647885739803314,
-0.42541563510894775,
0.4910901188850403,
0.6617556214332581,
-0.5534754991531372,
0.3662901818752289,
0.6669378876686096,
-0.14184564352035522,
0.4959564805030823,
-0.39659976959228516,
0.4752124845981598,
-0.4990485906600952,
0.042621973901987076,
-0.21045273542404175,
0.02243814803659916,
-0.2052520513534546,
0.3329029083251953,
0.18909965455532074,
-0.005265094339847565,
-0.5106812715530396,
0.07903491705656052,
-0.6404858231544495,
-0.3704511523246765,
-0.17110031843185425,
0.5058097839355469,
-0.003235063748434186,
-0.0409318171441555,
0.05513621121644974,
0.732683002948761,
0.17636382579803467,
-0.5143566131591797,
0.08612633496522903,
0.3318145275115967,
-0.6809397339820862,
0.3672643303871155,
-0.42496228218078613,
-0.005880151409655809,
-0.2798870801925659,
0.3798076808452606,
-1.208207368850708,
-0.01780722662806511,
-0.28411608934402466,
-0.4101049304008484,
-0.008667843416333199,
-0.15017352998256683,
-0.726905345916748,
-0.20615550875663757,
-0.338410884141922,
0.4189094305038452,
0.2719300091266632,
-0.7689499855041504,
0.13732050359249115,
0.5583171844482422,
-0.157693549990654,
-0.49493923783302307,
-0.7664526700973511,
0.37581688165664673,
-0.5354120135307312,
-0.71131432056427,
0.17176085710525513,
0.1427544802427292,
-0.5832223892211914,
0.08142036944627762,
0.3115629255771637,
0.05468258634209633,
0.09097465127706528,
0.14648663997650146,
0.034537311643362045,
-0.15014657378196716,
0.16765977442264557,
-0.2667454481124878,
0.033699166029691696,
0.01650039665400982,
-0.23968783020973206,
0.749821662902832,
-0.03743962571024895,
-0.2907351553440094,
0.24593636393547058,
0.5652530193328857,
0.46554630994796753,
-0.49923962354660034,
0.5008068084716797,
0.5110576152801514,
-0.2788256108760834,
-0.053939253091812134,
-0.5474145412445068,
0.2706943452358246,
-0.42460450530052185,
0.12887440621852875,
-0.29389986395835876,
-0.7993367314338684,
0.6704774498939514,
-0.0954267755150795,
-0.023035427555441856,
0.647533655166626,
0.34605228900909424,
-0.000470053986646235,
0.6619993448257446,
0.5934682488441467,
-0.0979841873049736,
0.011123600415885448,
-0.34925466775894165,
0.32857784628868103,
-0.6512722969055176,
-0.09085897356271744,
-0.7271994352340698,
-0.25688794255256653,
-1.2764657735824585,
-0.43818825483322144,
0.3434572219848633,
0.17697826027870178,
-0.449987530708313,
0.5500048995018005,
-0.358452171087265,
0.4545672535896301,
0.9966853260993958,
-0.29778945446014404,
0.32541945576667786,
0.2292037308216095,
-0.17607717216014862,
0.0816086009144783,
-0.6340477466583252,
-0.807498037815094,
1.0439509153366089,
-0.048490267246961594,
0.433478444814682,
0.5176649689674377,
0.9265126585960388,
0.2702324688434601,
0.2556364834308624,
-0.5721306204795837,
0.32762661576271057,
-0.26136207580566406,
-0.689284086227417,
-0.5066180229187012,
-0.3299201726913452,
-1.4216607809066772,
0.30586758255958557,
-0.25316086411476135,
-0.520953357219696,
0.2304614782333374,
-0.36768287420272827,
-0.4076356589794159,
0.21021009981632233,
-0.8767369389533997,
0.47369739413261414,
-0.17880238592624664,
-0.09870725125074387,
-0.2266867607831955,
-0.46544551849365234,
0.10767009854316711,
-0.3894539177417755,
0.6935941576957703,
0.08375349640846252,
-0.10022572427988052,
0.4731469750404358,
-0.39715978503227234,
0.7613911628723145,
-0.10173673182725906,
-0.3139568567276001,
0.7064410448074341,
0.11400879919528961,
0.053961511701345444,
-0.10302244126796722,
-0.15510565042495728,
0.6327928900718689,
0.13307815790176392,
-0.3289428651332855,
-0.38193756341934204,
0.6866750717163086,
-0.7788124680519104,
-0.4161589741706848,
-0.2574957013130188,
-0.28709322214126587,
-0.1369158774614334,
0.3173198699951172,
0.24771858751773834,
0.45091015100479126,
-0.12239938229322433,
0.23911058902740479,
0.49503079056739807,
-0.5769108533859253,
0.37295305728912354,
0.5974851250648499,
-0.14151610434055328,
-0.53959059715271,
0.5965994000434875,
0.2252902388572693,
0.03222469612956047,
0.351771742105484,
0.15320707857608795,
-0.4655514359474182,
-0.5042853355407715,
-0.3877377212047577,
0.15011709928512573,
-0.729270875453949,
-0.24841412901878357,
-0.42776504158973694,
0.37686485052108765,
-0.6996498107910156,
-0.17545175552368164,
-0.0846007764339447,
-0.21525318920612335,
-0.020449809730052948,
-0.11977527290582657,
0.24830032885074615,
0.8550909757614136,
-0.43191540241241455,
0.3048945367336273,
-0.9007851481437683,
0.06887228041887283,
-0.2836085557937622,
0.1076197624206543,
-0.25091344118118286,
-0.09235090017318726,
-0.3061668276786804,
0.013617263175547123,
-0.001311231986619532,
-0.5794968605041504,
0.4557664096355438,
-0.21596136689186096,
0.365717351436615,
0.22938404977321625,
0.06820455938577652,
0.9569451808929443,
-0.669301450252533,
0.8842940330505371,
-0.04341057315468788,
-0.7221582531929016,
0.31129249930381775,
-0.3798615634441376,
0.5919554233551025,
0.7313975691795349,
0.7092077136039734,
-0.6844005584716797,
-0.6060896515846252,
-0.6485803723335266,
-1.1455327272415161,
-0.05039357393980026,
-0.10739213973283768,
-0.0052483160980045795,
-0.3871145248413086,
0.2600145936012268,
0.1384512037038803,
-0.03800991550087929,
-0.1361483335494995,
0.019592268392443657,
0.2628437578678131,
-0.1474704146385193,
-0.1257171630859375,
-0.22308294475078583,
-0.06270287930965424,
0.14743264019489288,
0.7559701800346375,
-0.043438974767923355,
-0.16701330244541168,
0.2189946323633194,
-0.32841411232948303,
-0.14841212332248688,
0.32496902346611023,
0.5625659227371216,
0.957000732421875,
0.04335356131196022,
0.39624083042144775,
0.12686321139335632,
-0.668924868106842,
-0.030695419758558273,
-0.08888359367847443,
-0.30373746156692505,
0.17925190925598145,
0.5161658525466919,
0.03228536993265152,
0.3700287640094757,
-0.8545448184013367,
0.21028073132038116,
-0.046070825308561325,
-0.266475111246109,
-0.5343675017356873,
-0.3766205310821533,
0.07758890837430954,
0.15983866155147552,
0.46877598762512207,
-0.028142563998699188,
0.20586371421813965,
-0.4881137013435364,
0.301405668258667,
0.29730382561683655,
0.12162339687347412,
-0.038209374994039536,
0.3023316562175751,
-0.12856857478618622,
0.03062491863965988,
0.9701275825500488,
-0.4711982309818268,
-0.674917995929718,
0.6322852969169617,
0.21010346710681915,
0.2583652436733246,
0.04519883170723915,
0.13995760679244995,
0.7362858653068542,
0.5237815380096436,
-0.08088033646345139,
0.17517529428005219,
0.1525435596704483,
-0.7114582657814026,
-0.5294033885002136,
-0.44385606050491333,
-0.4223329722881317,
0.14596383273601532,
-0.5753698945045471,
0.487060546875,
-0.11207608878612518,
-0.1876867264509201,
0.0787857249379158,
0.279786080121994,
-0.6801216006278992,
0.4268110990524292,
0.3031056523323059,
0.8470112085342407,
-0.8308795690536499,
0.27480626106262207,
0.6175227761268616,
-0.36597079038619995,
-0.6584718227386475,
-0.11795444786548615,
0.15903601050376892,
-0.7717885375022888,
0.8564934730529785,
0.20245355367660522,
-0.30947768688201904,
-0.4012594223022461,
-0.4345182478427887,
-1.4509985446929932,
0.7465738654136658,
0.02433377504348755,
-0.5542837381362915,
0.38491782546043396,
0.36659112572669983,
0.856235921382904,
-0.005729706026613712,
0.27708977460861206,
0.4874914884567261,
0.6102504730224609,
-0.21689733862876892,
-1.0021523237228394,
0.04866338148713112,
0.027243616059422493,
-0.05791711434721947,
0.4051533043384552,
-0.45898982882499695,
0.79682457447052,
-0.26907965540885925,
-0.49799028038978577,
0.002595747821033001,
0.5285860896110535,
0.337980717420578,
-0.021005284041166306,
0.8701658248901367,
0.5760435461997986,
1.1228759288787842,
-0.02348547801375389,
0.8317219018936157,
-0.39567649364471436,
0.18797962367534637,
1.0819859504699707,
-0.4488283395767212,
1.0736969709396362,
0.31158745288848877,
-0.08727113902568817,
0.7124385833740234,
0.819130003452301,
-0.17591604590415955,
0.4067668616771698,
0.6482541561126709,
-0.04655974730849266,
0.1817469298839569,
-0.05307353660464287,
-0.1978381872177124,
1.034895420074463,
0.29556551575660706,
-0.0440087616443634,
-0.5015177726745605,
-0.051832567900419235,
0.17733198404312134,
0.26027441024780273,
-0.3452009856700897,
0.4252922832965851,
-0.4750739336013794,
-1.1337389945983887,
0.48391109704971313,
0.020662622526288033,
0.8233881592750549,
-0.3023701012134552,
0.09239383041858673,
-0.20669247210025787,
0.09002172946929932,
-0.5867745280265808,
-0.7290587425231934,
0.48220518231391907,
0.3080909848213196,
-0.22006462514400482,
-0.268113374710083,
0.49342653155326843,
-0.5119015574455261,
-0.21456657350063324,
0.5134487748146057,
0.5743887424468994,
0.4674217998981476,
-0.12173617631196976,
-0.01923241652548313,
0.16941384971141815,
-0.180729940533638,
-0.16615191102027893,
0.2351779043674469,
0.7296643257141113,
-0.5253827571868896,
0.09518397599458694,
0.9131563305854797,
0.24449677765369415,
0.05409812927246094,
0.4962460398674011,
0.2909042239189148,
-0.5197362303733826,
-0.49863481521606445,
-0.625691294670105,
0.14949451386928558,
-0.16883769631385803,
-0.21711359918117523,
0.9490280747413635,
1.0812791585922241,
1.1961854696273804,
0.18492068350315094,
0.850206732749939,
-0.07659866660833359,
0.6284160017967224,
-0.35877111554145813,
0.510855495929718,
-0.2714287042617798,
0.0415535569190979,
-0.13302966952323914,
-0.735345721244812,
-0.3667173385620117,
0.34401267766952515,
-0.40705370903015137,
-0.1520465910434723,
0.7662109732627869,
0.8584457635879517,
-0.037508513778448105,
0.14033108949661255,
0.23595193028450012,
-0.17346680164337158,
0.314912885427475,
0.17872627079486847,
0.9407006502151489,
-0.2919293940067291,
0.6598966121673584,
-0.203518345952034,
-0.2973034083843231,
0.16237439215183258,
-1.0252577066421509,
-0.2501380443572998,
-0.5966129302978516,
-0.35363879799842834,
-0.24886029958724976,
-0.23625898361206055,
0.6649712324142456,
0.5488981008529663,
-0.8557949662208557,
-0.1645878702402115,
0.11327999085187912,
-0.15757764875888824,
-0.19865338504314423,
-0.31296902894973755,
0.4466588795185089,
-0.5431297421455383,
-0.8839725255966187,
0.488457053899765,
-0.039163555949926376,
-0.2908332943916321,
-0.3543320894241333,
0.3402326703071594,
-0.18303893506526947,
-0.33017051219940186,
0.8640205264091492,
0.19788791239261627,
-0.41161274909973145,
-0.40366771817207336,
0.03588147088885307,
-0.15444889664649963,
0.019237779080867767,
0.8277006149291992,
-0.6555817723274231,
0.19466067850589752,
0.3627709150314331,
0.45063620805740356,
0.5095313787460327,
0.18033833801746368,
0.4182230830192566,
-0.7770007848739624,
-0.045095544308423996,
-0.10243397951126099,
0.5009927153587341,
0.7244918346405029,
-0.46239757537841797,
0.7746656537055969,
-0.0894041657447815,
-0.6257778406143188,
-0.4846118986606598,
-0.05149779096245766,
-0.6861112117767334,
-0.4964042901992798,
1.6943868398666382,
-0.06262239813804626,
-0.207170307636261,
-0.4196683466434479,
-0.16882796585559845,
0.19208486378192902,
-0.21763373911380768,
0.904301643371582,
0.8776578903198242,
-0.016386473551392555,
0.5546392798423767,
-0.554373562335968,
0.24016042053699493,
0.19722844660282135,
-0.6490280032157898,
-0.02106376737356186,
0.9146189093589783,
0.5167043805122375,
0.8416637778282166,
0.5720129609107971,
-0.3136991560459137,
0.060291778296232224,
-0.11801256239414215,
0.0956219732761383,
0.22149017453193665,
-0.24333709478378296,
-0.1608526110649109,
0.3873232901096344,
-0.25355231761932373,
-0.13895735144615173
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08196v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08196v1
|
SpeechColab Leaderboard: An Open-Source Platform for Automatic Speech Recognition Evaluation
| 2024-03-13T02:41:53 | 2024-03-13T02:41:53 |
Jiayu Du, Jinpeng Li, Guoguo Chen, Wei-Qiang Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, eess.AS
|
In the wake of the surging tide of deep learning over the past decade,
Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) has garnered substantial attention, leading
to the emergence of numerous publicly accessible ASR systems that are actively
being integrated into our daily lives. Nonetheless, the impartial and
replicable evaluation of these ASR systems encounters challenges due to various
crucial subtleties. In this paper we introduce the SpeechColab Leaderboard, a
general-purpose, open-source platform designed for ASR evaluation. With this
platform: (i) We report a comprehensive benchmark, unveiling the current
state-of-the-art panorama for ASR systems, covering both open-source models and
industrial commercial services. (ii) We quantize how distinct nuances in the
scoring pipeline influence the final benchmark outcomes. These include nuances
related to capitalization, punctuation, interjection, contraction, synonym
usage, compound words, etc. These issues have gained prominence in the context
of the transition towards an End-to-End future. (iii) We propose a practical
modification to the conventional Token-Error-Rate (TER) evaluation metric, with
inspirations from Kolmogorov complexity and Normalized Information Distance
(NID). This adaptation, called modified-TER (mTER), achieves proper
normalization and symmetrical treatment of reference and hypothesis. By
leveraging this platform as a large-scale testing ground, this study
demonstrates the robustness and backward compatibility of mTER when compared to
TER. The SpeechColab Leaderboard is accessible at
https://github.com/SpeechColab/Leaderboard
|
[
-0.22153282165527344,
-0.5527872443199158,
0.03968137875199318,
0.6642587184906006,
-0.1399417668581009,
0.43846502900123596,
-0.4620298147201538,
-0.3110405206680298,
0.05703754350543022,
0.06792329996824265,
-0.01815093867480755,
-0.6582709550857544,
-0.7084508538246155,
-0.09238814562559128,
-0.4747922122478485,
0.8690126538276672,
-0.04958273470401764,
0.12405836582183838,
-0.12225403636693954,
-0.2994691729545593,
-0.6015644669532776,
-0.49782636761665344,
-0.6922929883003235,
-0.467012494802475,
0.39046576619148254,
0.3147903084754944,
0.4110041558742523,
0.5192883014678955,
0.8573898673057556,
0.2738666236400604,
-0.13693827390670776,
-0.278184711933136,
-0.14477720856666565,
0.24077297747135162,
0.038516297936439514,
-0.06779053807258606,
-0.6657789349555969,
0.017527198418974876,
0.7629967331886292,
0.8039882183074951,
-0.32507607340812683,
0.43268099427223206,
0.4120113253593445,
0.4710608422756195,
-0.6957272887229919,
0.39014989137649536,
-0.4401369094848633,
0.0849037617444992,
-0.2665702700614929,
-0.19041460752487183,
-0.2711012661457062,
-0.6521715521812439,
0.12050767242908478,
-0.21156662702560425,
0.06134979426860809,
-0.12465272098779678,
0.3603394031524658,
0.43994978070259094,
-0.09451133757829666,
-0.49212682247161865,
-0.752332329750061,
0.49851658940315247,
-0.2889021933078766,
0.6606168746948242,
0.18349216878414154,
0.8366553783416748,
0.056494567543268204,
-0.9938085675239563,
-0.37955501675605774,
-0.36718931794166565,
0.3745218515396118,
0.23186913132667542,
-0.5578229427337646,
-0.10624026507139206,
0.01760118640959263,
0.4882933795452118,
-0.6989045739173889,
0.314300537109375,
-0.4755438566207886,
-0.17794805765151978,
0.2718062698841095,
0.049461301416158676,
0.06832189112901688,
0.07022310048341751,
-0.08529304713010788,
-0.1817908138036728,
-0.3362255394458771,
0.3241518437862396,
0.23426228761672974,
0.5032895803451538,
-0.0838845744729042,
0.4665497839450836,
-0.2577350437641144,
0.4752798080444336,
0.08779650926589966,
0.39789658784866333,
0.5947559475898743,
0.12106668949127197,
-0.3492147624492645,
0.5434396266937256,
0.9640957117080688,
0.39895039796829224,
-0.024163253605365753,
-0.41257572174072266,
-0.04170503094792366,
0.40524598956108093,
0.1549564003944397,
-0.805004358291626,
-0.509269654750824,
0.3009985685348511,
-0.3232257068157196,
-0.31300950050354004,
0.19172050058841705,
-0.679326057434082,
-0.41830340027809143,
-0.127289280295372,
0.5072335600852966,
-0.37957432866096497,
-0.01868116669356823,
0.015487590804696083,
-0.1419185847043991,
0.3008772134780884,
0.3484387695789337,
-0.5044006705284119,
0.4943940341472626,
0.8607545495033264,
1.091930627822876,
-0.2947429418563843,
-0.31013184785842896,
-0.9509866237640381,
-0.1983482986688614,
-0.35529977083206177,
0.7836592197418213,
-0.56669682264328,
-0.5422893166542053,
-0.29413846135139465,
-0.2943982481956482,
-0.11773565411567688,
-0.8186449408531189,
0.7194955348968506,
-0.3325144052505493,
0.10788401961326599,
-0.11254968494176865,
-0.46789824962615967,
0.08011604845523834,
0.24292100965976715,
-0.5391467809677124,
0.7555195093154907,
-0.3491029739379883,
-0.43819645047187805,
0.39743509888648987,
-1.0376118421554565,
-0.4406387209892273,
0.2574310600757599,
-0.19457417726516724,
-0.38524654507637024,
-0.03850428760051727,
0.07300607860088348,
0.12807554006576538,
-0.3387286961078644,
0.19636262953281403,
-0.0834643766283989,
-0.4807100296020508,
0.31268712878227234,
-0.4458792805671692,
0.8553745746612549,
0.2920900583267212,
-0.44032737612724304,
0.41118156909942627,
-0.8822541832923889,
0.2027900218963623,
-0.34248676896095276,
-0.4696807563304901,
0.03215767815709114,
-0.11352609843015671,
0.24933713674545288,
-0.04934544488787651,
0.06646471470594406,
-0.6133870482444763,
-0.2529335916042328,
-0.18740276992321014,
0.7308089733123779,
0.7893132567405701,
-0.17738622426986694,
0.2142980992794037,
-0.2046613246202469,
0.5036546587944031,
-0.19422388076782227,
0.2829235792160034,
0.039633072912693024,
-0.5999575257301331,
-0.6394065022468567,
-0.4897935688495636,
0.6659043431282043,
0.6372377872467041,
-0.1251053363084793,
0.8612313866615295,
-0.488567054271698,
-0.6618462204933167,
-0.9989492893218994,
-0.062387194484472275,
0.3936338722705841,
0.6410678029060364,
0.45544320344924927,
-0.39755553007125854,
-0.5724321603775024,
-0.5717030167579651,
-0.2386665791273117,
-0.14436542987823486,
-0.281084805727005,
0.1278683841228485,
0.2707519829273224,
-0.24668803811073303,
0.8299116492271423,
-0.11162292212247849,
-0.690021276473999,
-0.04777125269174576,
0.24842625856399536,
0.2553843855857849,
0.6549267768859863,
0.18787817656993866,
-0.6270273327827454,
-0.656526505947113,
0.08633309602737427,
-0.5965025424957275,
-0.19115957617759705,
0.28918975591659546,
0.2875001132488251,
-0.06599941849708557,
0.5063672661781311,
-0.31369343400001526,
0.34230124950408936,
0.5915263891220093,
-0.21208375692367554,
0.5813395977020264,
-0.252029150724411,
0.30012694001197815,
-0.6865941882133484,
0.39377060532569885,
-0.3034420907497406,
-0.06570953875780106,
-0.4581933915615082,
-0.0028735289815813303,
-0.08462684601545334,
-0.1288813203573227,
-0.2531563639640808,
0.4836426079273224,
0.017425142228603363,
-0.22896580398082733,
-0.10905354470014572,
0.2069675326347351,
-0.13347631692886353,
0.007836363278329372,
-0.3675419092178345,
0.7278339266777039,
0.6493065357208252,
-0.4410308003425598,
0.4751155972480774,
0.27381646633148193,
-0.5420448780059814,
0.7696008086204529,
-0.8926717638969421,
0.31626561284065247,
0.09506328403949738,
0.08718448132276535,
-0.829608142375946,
0.05891239643096924,
0.16160018742084503,
-0.7833356261253357,
0.07281830906867981,
-0.01761951856315136,
-0.5799464583396912,
-0.3370461165904999,
-0.2303818166255951,
0.16394458711147308,
0.6401835680007935,
-0.5604934692382812,
0.41045570373535156,
0.4864594340324402,
-0.19645419716835022,
-0.4284273386001587,
-0.7326557040214539,
0.41224756836891174,
-0.19374194741249084,
-0.418296217918396,
0.25333371758461,
-0.35508495569229126,
-0.3689432144165039,
-0.08918777853250504,
-0.20509682595729828,
0.01747145503759384,
0.02012951858341694,
0.49114009737968445,
-0.004836656618863344,
-0.2826470136642456,
-0.08867247402667999,
-0.12931518256664276,
-0.3169606924057007,
-0.07170248031616211,
-0.24866563081741333,
0.6044631600379944,
-0.6772733330726624,
-0.27435624599456787,
-0.6867532134056091,
0.01175338588654995,
0.5584781169891357,
-0.39900273084640503,
0.20152264833450317,
0.7352237701416016,
-0.3727771043777466,
0.036304473876953125,
-0.5526289343833923,
0.07784776389598846,
-0.4255366027355194,
0.1792534440755844,
-0.44676095247268677,
-0.741158664226532,
0.5384803414344788,
0.07719686627388,
-0.10841810703277588,
0.22219215333461761,
0.5858544111251831,
-0.2502238154411316,
0.6205102801322937,
0.49073222279548645,
-0.0423443540930748,
0.24579490721225739,
-0.1904095560312271,
0.12359731644392014,
-0.9493122100830078,
-0.43923071026802063,
-0.6633909940719604,
-0.48225638270378113,
-0.6024492979049683,
-0.49671241641044617,
0.34375283122062683,
-0.0828806608915329,
-0.24135757982730865,
0.2452983856201172,
-0.6402439475059509,
0.41226866841316223,
0.7062941193580627,
-0.01852305419743061,
0.43446046113967896,
-0.16344942152500153,
0.010592292994260788,
-0.2112785428762436,
-0.3875510096549988,
-0.46910783648490906,
1.0175974369049072,
0.20024921000003815,
0.5591592788696289,
0.06436559557914734,
0.5324968695640564,
0.7168649435043335,
0.20922216773033142,
-0.7926389575004578,
0.4348716735839844,
-0.41920241713523865,
-0.18526659905910492,
-0.1735326647758484,
-0.36488330364227295,
-0.8238124251365662,
0.19004946947097778,
-0.018580418080091476,
-0.740905225276947,
0.32436224818229675,
0.10450926423072815,
-0.4128771722316742,
0.05373779684305191,
-0.5891796350479126,
0.9484918117523193,
-0.22026757895946503,
-0.05080689117312431,
-0.12715554237365723,
-0.5797416567802429,
-0.23066776990890503,
-0.04770296439528465,
0.0384114645421505,
0.12377181649208069,
0.18809370696544647,
0.8999767303466797,
-0.12526565790176392,
0.6142501831054688,
-0.3229024112224579,
0.4032976031303406,
0.13683922588825226,
0.08968088030815125,
0.07438148558139801,
-0.2650283873081207,
-0.3343403935432434,
0.3852534592151642,
-0.19236642122268677,
-0.1234876811504364,
-0.5255870819091797,
0.7630335092544556,
-0.7408716082572937,
-0.07395268231630325,
-0.4698835611343384,
-0.2516801059246063,
-0.25436607003211975,
0.32482239603996277,
0.17894183099269867,
0.4754999279975891,
-0.5783979892730713,
0.7316032648086548,
0.3593263328075409,
-0.15642772614955902,
0.26194044947624207,
0.2945514917373657,
-0.17970730364322662,
-0.7214012742042542,
0.8833385705947876,
0.19639086723327637,
-0.20916548371315002,
0.33852535486221313,
0.24743428826332092,
-0.29834145307540894,
-0.7277528643608093,
-0.3131195306777954,
-0.2496558129787445,
-0.6360782980918884,
-0.04688992723822594,
-0.6454595923423767,
-0.2381415218114853,
-0.5052738785743713,
-0.16149769723415375,
-0.4363638162612915,
-0.5061872601509094,
-0.15748170018196106,
-0.27747997641563416,
0.07080947607755661,
0.342007040977478,
-0.28064194321632385,
0.41972219944000244,
-0.177249938249588,
0.28083184361457825,
0.2709212601184845,
0.6157746911048889,
-0.2120615839958191,
-0.6649723052978516,
0.07679027318954468,
-0.01845565252006054,
-0.2596927881240845,
-0.35658159852027893,
0.12627781927585602,
0.4958288073539734,
0.5488609671592712,
0.25228726863861084,
0.05459931865334511,
0.7985792756080627,
-0.5977059006690979,
0.522371232509613,
0.21365737915039062,
-1.1093982458114624,
0.5376886129379272,
0.02658148854970932,
0.2086840122938156,
0.6520786881446838,
0.13040317595005035,
-0.5806677937507629,
-0.41358280181884766,
-0.3550775945186615,
-0.8498804569244385,
0.3144119083881378,
0.29539796710014343,
-0.13775277137756348,
0.13300175964832306,
-0.041698601096868515,
0.2795649766921997,
0.5067756772041321,
-0.3702815771102905,
-0.09306816756725311,
-0.5887738466262817,
-0.3229595422744751,
-0.2134651094675064,
0.07362648844718933,
-0.05700567737221718,
-0.17492546141147614,
0.5337380766868591,
0.08565022796392441,
0.11446551978588104,
0.10704559832811356,
-0.3732759654521942,
0.12605838477611542,
0.40796393156051636,
0.2692241370677948,
0.6108937859535217,
-0.4994189143180847,
0.04586115851998329,
-0.05698405206203461,
-0.5702934861183167,
-0.1297650784254074,
0.4489764869213104,
-0.267764687538147,
-0.019116468727588654,
0.2153700739145279,
0.9090443253517151,
0.11931321024894714,
-0.6940059065818787,
0.5438166260719299,
-0.08911040425300598,
-0.03848186135292053,
-0.34629493951797485,
-0.07733381539583206,
-0.15210022032260895,
0.4659503698348999,
0.5108720064163208,
0.24163655936717987,
0.4854339361190796,
-0.5276839733123779,
0.37467700242996216,
0.33490970730781555,
-0.8263435959815979,
-0.33145999908447266,
0.7913660407066345,
0.16528965532779694,
-0.6563655734062195,
0.5522304773330688,
-0.22207136452198029,
-0.3301279842853546,
0.42163360118865967,
0.23045755922794342,
1.0988496541976929,
-0.46702244877815247,
0.3033434748649597,
0.10364258289337158,
0.44789955019950867,
0.15235799551010132,
0.13455766439437866,
-0.2654535174369812,
-0.38474971055984497,
-0.1093171089887619,
-0.7344432473182678,
-0.6751693487167358,
-0.029094429686665535,
-0.8180885910987854,
0.3887837529182434,
-0.7692064046859741,
-0.36561068892478943,
0.17043405771255493,
-0.11060547083616257,
-0.4956061542034149,
0.21399745345115662,
0.14294980466365814,
0.8227468132972717,
-0.41124770045280457,
0.5901340842247009,
0.641274631023407,
-0.3415299355983734,
-0.21673311293125153,
-0.06451213359832764,
-0.06933603435754776,
-0.6308454275131226,
0.5790836215019226,
0.3993690311908722,
-0.34543925523757935,
0.02187289111316204,
-0.1114128828048706,
-0.37840735912323,
1.1533113718032837,
0.37651774287223816,
-0.39934012293815613,
0.05574524402618408,
0.18964935839176178,
0.832270622253418,
-0.22314999997615814,
0.2330564558506012,
0.4201260507106781,
0.40662556886672974,
0.2570735216140747,
-1.252968668937683,
-0.11199844628572464,
-0.375520795583725,
-0.10700984299182892,
-0.22260938584804535,
-0.5565227270126343,
0.6391656398773193,
-0.2012832760810852,
-0.12430965900421143,
0.07482419908046722,
0.4501775801181793,
0.2028864026069641,
0.565644383430481,
0.2365320771932602,
0.46657589077949524,
0.832817792892456,
-0.21791882812976837,
0.5070356726646423,
-0.20073352754116058,
0.1946823000907898,
1.3552190065383911,
-0.3132976293563843,
1.0882631540298462,
0.3704824447631836,
-0.11190841346979141,
0.5293871164321899,
0.2226812243461609,
-0.34181344509124756,
0.660889208316803,
0.18915174901485443,
0.018462928012013435,
0.11236988753080368,
-0.011100509203970432,
-0.4928855895996094,
0.7041336297988892,
0.19017209112644196,
-0.2715364396572113,
-0.21272669732570648,
0.16754655539989471,
-0.17416471242904663,
0.04388467222452164,
-0.26702994108200073,
0.8320156335830688,
0.09289522469043732,
-0.10260550677776337,
0.4637434780597687,
-0.12041525542736053,
0.5495973229408264,
-0.4831066131591797,
0.1408868283033371,
-0.0013891552807763219,
0.494347482919693,
-0.22892023622989655,
-0.6938464641571045,
0.39186495542526245,
0.22120223939418793,
-0.005512420553714037,
-0.21975578367710114,
0.3139038681983948,
-0.1545589566230774,
-0.4836162328720093,
0.3931540250778198,
0.30754658579826355,
0.21462811529636383,
-0.32256683707237244,
-0.6671910881996155,
0.49340084195137024,
-0.3643065392971039,
0.1382370889186859,
0.15006627142429352,
0.2249618023633957,
0.15725083649158478,
0.7730567455291748,
0.703923761844635,
0.26112100481987,
0.16217653453350067,
0.25265881419181824,
0.5988392233848572,
-0.46825364232063293,
-0.8642411828041077,
-0.7131277322769165,
0.4968690574169159,
-0.1383265107870102,
-0.17421454191207886,
0.7016905546188354,
0.868760347366333,
0.6509885787963867,
0.21403004229068756,
0.8108456134796143,
-0.17674478888511658,
0.4683573842048645,
-0.031960513442754745,
0.9938758611679077,
-0.20043645799160004,
0.23645271360874176,
-0.4221480190753937,
-0.8768689632415771,
-0.7188156843185425,
0.723061203956604,
-0.3918754756450653,
-0.1746458113193512,
0.5040760040283203,
0.5063307285308838,
-0.045027151703834534,
0.13717494904994965,
0.26518794894218445,
0.4770912826061249,
0.5005591511726379,
0.25464221835136414,
0.7153540253639221,
-0.6091592311859131,
0.8801432251930237,
-0.1448279172182083,
-0.605934202671051,
-0.3295336067676544,
-0.7337806224822998,
-0.54619300365448,
-0.6886642575263977,
-0.5593162775039673,
-0.34442389011383057,
0.5726107954978943,
0.9641920328140259,
0.4004337191581726,
-0.9666914343833923,
-0.504976212978363,
-0.06704580038785934,
-0.17324182391166687,
-0.3239384591579437,
-0.21273407340049744,
0.36321017146110535,
-0.14468593895435333,
-0.6177248358726501,
0.3999898135662079,
0.4602928161621094,
-0.26982805132865906,
0.030336709693074226,
-0.05236794799566269,
0.22829914093017578,
-0.3361246883869171,
0.6111130118370056,
0.35957178473472595,
-0.5589067935943604,
-0.23446421325206757,
0.05946435034275055,
0.09901531040668488,
0.2973380386829376,
0.54018634557724,
-0.8228421807289124,
0.6213928461074829,
0.29429900646209717,
0.6855957508087158,
0.3334142863750458,
-0.08373218029737473,
0.3090202510356903,
-0.30407458543777466,
-0.09854499995708466,
0.4972238540649414,
0.19611264765262604,
0.5883749127388,
0.21532411873340607,
0.3978140950202942,
0.17390120029449463,
-0.6065035462379456,
-1.212609887123108,
-0.1014489233493805,
-0.9720577597618103,
0.2160714566707611,
0.7976608276367188,
-0.01730051450431347,
0.022383423522114754,
0.11211646348237991,
-0.0962875634431839,
0.22684773802757263,
-0.5925076007843018,
1.0691437721252441,
0.4004304111003876,
-0.18084312975406647,
-0.04603367671370506,
-0.33494481444358826,
0.18448175489902496,
0.017444385215640068,
-0.6226394772529602,
0.1144413948059082,
0.4613107740879059,
0.38884085416793823,
0.2727491557598114,
0.7223613858222961,
-0.23859938979148865,
0.34000688791275024,
-0.005391850136220455,
0.057774078100919724,
-0.16403861343860626,
-0.40283939242362976,
-0.6029039025306702,
0.3152396082878113,
0.04692207649350166,
-0.5212686061859131
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09732v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09732v4
|
PET-SQL: A Prompt-Enhanced Two-Round Refinement of Text-to-SQL with Cross-consistency
| 2024-03-13T02:32:41 | 2024-06-02T02:58:53 |
Zhishuai Li, Xiang Wang, Jingjing Zhao, Sun Yang, Guoqing Du, Xiaoru Hu, Bin Zhang, Yuxiao Ye, Ziyue Li, Rui Zhao, Hangyu Mao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recent advancements in Text-to-SQL (Text2SQL) emphasize stimulating the large
language models (LLM) on in-context learning, achieving significant results.
Nevertheless, they face challenges when dealing with verbose database
information and complex user intentions. This paper presents a two-stage
framework to enhance the performance of current LLM-based natural language to
SQL systems. We first introduce a novel prompt representation, called
reference-enhanced representation, which includes schema information and
randomly sampled cell values from tables to instruct LLMs in generating SQL
queries. Then, in the first stage, question-SQL pairs are retrieved as few-shot
demonstrations, prompting the LLM to generate a preliminary SQL (PreSQL). After
that, the mentioned entities in PreSQL are parsed to conduct schema linking,
which can significantly compact the useful information. In the second stage,
with the linked schema, we simplify the prompt's schema information and
instruct the LLM to produce the final SQL. Finally, as the post-refinement
module, we propose using cross-consistency across different LLMs rather than
self-consistency within a particular LLM. Our methods achieve new SOTA results
on the Spider benchmark, with an execution accuracy of 87.6%.
|
[
-0.16100262105464935,
-0.8110294938087463,
0.6070505976676941,
0.015466284938156605,
-0.4496004283428192,
0.030819514766335487,
-0.44094881415367126,
-0.36784347891807556,
0.07311674952507019,
0.5823370814323425,
-0.6283842921257019,
-0.500367283821106,
0.008978691883385181,
0.5458095073699951,
-0.03223063051700592,
0.9095445275306702,
0.2644660770893097,
0.36115214228630066,
-0.17004434764385223,
-0.08276256173849106,
-0.30476537346839905,
-0.4248276650905609,
-0.5283306837081909,
-0.21236906945705414,
0.35007956624031067,
0.5258333683013916,
0.6871885657310486,
0.4998677968978882,
0.26218000054359436,
0.08423490077257156,
-0.05328622832894325,
0.4604814648628235,
-0.49679267406463623,
0.42170247435569763,
-0.7130482792854309,
-0.4770417809486389,
-0.44075828790664673,
-0.36117246747016907,
0.7429561018943787,
0.4931567907333374,
-0.21509337425231934,
-0.4120247960090637,
0.19867753982543945,
0.6970386505126953,
-0.44244247674942017,
0.07665292918682098,
-0.8568421602249146,
-0.1624111533164978,
-0.25410494208335876,
-0.2773353159427643,
-0.6684545874595642,
-0.35962948203086853,
-0.034879088401794434,
-0.8767868280410767,
0.1220838725566864,
0.23272506892681122,
0.9726289510726929,
0.12278499454259872,
-0.4013268053531647,
-0.1571177840232849,
-0.4699467122554779,
0.5233181118965149,
-0.46560245752334595,
0.4773275852203369,
0.3372405469417572,
0.5164682865142822,
-0.6698782444000244,
-0.8058856725692749,
-0.5900914669036865,
-0.44316530227661133,
-0.36541786789894104,
-0.25197458267211914,
0.36716124415397644,
0.030344178900122643,
0.33366501331329346,
0.23905330896377563,
-0.473419725894928,
-0.002276808023452759,
-0.003315381705760956,
-0.13662560284137726,
0.5921695828437805,
0.27769792079925537,
-0.07540907710790634,
-0.03435513749718666,
-0.443326860666275,
0.07924151420593262,
-1.0718055963516235,
-0.10664333403110504,
0.027339819818735123,
0.7036858201026917,
0.32133784890174866,
0.7263455390930176,
-0.3267912268638611,
0.5627844929695129,
0.463894784450531,
0.26714271306991577,
0.14576776325702667,
-0.8019863963127136,
0.017750181257724762,
-0.10112649947404861,
0.9004691243171692,
0.36738765239715576,
0.1947009116411209,
-0.12424764037132263,
-0.12791796028614044,
-0.1261109709739685,
0.16077318787574768,
-0.8386805057525635,
-0.04344690591096878,
0.3387705981731415,
-0.2957843542098999,
-0.12605679035186768,
-0.33155566453933716,
-0.6617463231086731,
-0.7000450491905212,
-0.3009802997112274,
0.42666107416152954,
-0.6912223100662231,
-0.2692539095878601,
-0.04982464388012886,
0.12241897732019424,
0.4684228301048279,
0.5859836935997009,
-0.8318852186203003,
0.5203630924224854,
0.7618991136550903,
0.5287531614303589,
-0.24011455476284027,
-0.15641337633132935,
-0.6707342863082886,
0.37825071811676025,
-0.5392559170722961,
0.8421618342399597,
-0.6354649066925049,
-0.3868798315525055,
-0.14633530378341675,
0.1908055692911148,
0.3759865164756775,
-0.5528825521469116,
0.28108280897140503,
-0.37138527631759644,
0.5109072923660278,
-0.6371408700942993,
-0.6200407147407532,
0.17501376569271088,
0.3083517849445343,
-0.43351247906684875,
1.6006242036819458,
0.11429829895496368,
-0.5779480338096619,
0.5785666704177856,
-0.37409865856170654,
-0.40789794921875,
0.12716306746006012,
-0.5462008118629456,
-0.448184609413147,
-0.020636970177292824,
-0.09170275181531906,
0.34163033962249756,
-0.49681776762008667,
0.3062845468521118,
-0.2060668170452118,
-0.5704620480537415,
-0.09334947168827057,
0.33255496621131897,
0.46546366810798645,
-0.013384118676185608,
-0.20402009785175323,
0.1002439633011818,
-0.977173388004303,
0.1524837762117386,
0.01365046575665474,
-0.2285185009241104,
-0.22958792746067047,
-0.02173524722456932,
-0.11577443033456802,
0.27813753485679626,
0.30853456258773804,
-0.5221909284591675,
0.3973715901374817,
-0.4600870907306671,
0.3239615857601166,
0.2421312779188156,
-0.0063192336820065975,
0.5580641627311707,
0.019251035526394844,
0.12867270410060883,
-0.053970176726579666,
-0.03747370466589928,
-0.42593395709991455,
-0.28730374574661255,
-0.6045835018157959,
-0.09834583103656769,
0.21958473324775696,
0.49752870202064514,
-0.6376718282699585,
0.620528519153595,
0.02559073083102703,
-0.4670203626155853,
-0.12887197732925415,
-0.3069932460784912,
0.35362207889556885,
0.5920283198356628,
0.5475121736526489,
-0.4336257874965668,
-0.6199914813041687,
-0.8213904500007629,
-0.3807844817638397,
-0.1539790779352188,
-0.1840292513370514,
0.4623474180698395,
0.24339017271995544,
0.09429929405450821,
1.1177177429199219,
-0.16928371787071228,
-0.18521343171596527,
-0.08965758234262466,
0.06214134767651558,
0.1138669103384018,
0.6488286256790161,
0.2511657774448395,
-0.2873705327510834,
-0.6896317601203918,
0.0526200532913208,
-0.540463924407959,
-0.14309896528720856,
-0.1860380917787552,
-0.4112836718559265,
0.4426180124282837,
0.6071412563323975,
-0.7436085343360901,
0.35566484928131104,
-0.16735024750232697,
-0.5364223122596741,
0.9309831261634827,
-0.2266903519630432,
0.22415480017662048,
-1.102314829826355,
0.1634349226951599,
-0.23617856204509735,
-0.4111442565917969,
-0.6506819128990173,
-0.26520127058029175,
0.22000932693481445,
-0.15010210871696472,
-0.26236385107040405,
0.41879913210868835,
-0.7246741652488708,
-0.29193881154060364,
-0.22536374628543854,
0.29150691628456116,
0.25634756684303284,
0.28212496638298035,
0.5281505584716797,
1.0651390552520752,
0.6334422826766968,
-0.6532682776451111,
0.18943801522254944,
0.27377474308013916,
0.12554924190044403,
0.9839577674865723,
-0.6370020508766174,
0.23001667857170105,
-0.03465760499238968,
0.5550938248634338,
-0.9980962872505188,
-0.04056473448872566,
0.21386374533176422,
-0.4035494327545166,
0.4298967123031616,
-0.03796497359871864,
-0.5050125122070312,
0.07818315178155899,
-0.39811164140701294,
-0.00657394714653492,
0.4343271255493164,
-0.3711819648742676,
0.8018919229507446,
-0.15049749612808228,
-0.13229432702064514,
-0.5622682571411133,
-0.6069136261940002,
0.3101777136325836,
0.10487176477909088,
-0.5305824279785156,
0.6647689342498779,
0.2934137284755707,
0.05292979255318642,
-0.08889945596456528,
-0.049647483974695206,
-0.12851928174495697,
-0.3089240491390228,
-0.19679416716098785,
0.19309310615062714,
-0.3138667047023773,
0.5013917088508606,
-0.15839934349060059,
-0.14729706943035126,
-0.14939367771148682,
-0.29487890005111694,
0.6431846618652344,
-0.05103243887424469,
-0.09452233463525772,
-0.5436087846755981,
0.539268434047699,
0.2527608573436737,
-0.2638627886772156,
0.6652631759643555,
0.37177297472953796,
-0.29071229696273804,
-0.22557823359966278,
-0.40024250745773315,
-0.6882595419883728,
-0.42804601788520813,
0.4504832327365875,
-0.7536035776138306,
-0.714625358581543,
0.4647664725780487,
-0.35690173506736755,
0.06248445436358452,
0.402995228767395,
0.37848955392837524,
-0.19289253652095795,
0.7165424227714539,
0.6369794011116028,
0.7724365592002869,
0.5227540135383606,
0.3133687973022461,
-0.045006074011325836,
-0.795317530632019,
-0.6470399498939514,
-0.7332049608230591,
0.2586599290370941,
-0.37317395210266113,
-0.7352920770645142,
0.06781935691833496,
0.3445960581302643,
-0.48828479647636414,
0.5179669857025146,
-0.5588316321372986,
0.6248040795326233,
0.26956936717033386,
0.10994581878185272,
0.363050639629364,
0.2372942417860031,
-0.44044604897499084,
-0.2506193518638611,
-0.364244669675827,
-0.6346856951713562,
1.0498108863830566,
0.10933532565832138,
0.7423341274261475,
-0.07781659811735153,
0.5236573219299316,
0.092422716319561,
-0.10856857150793076,
-0.465530127286911,
0.7382875084877014,
-0.011705241166055202,
-0.4932228922843933,
-0.32100313901901245,
-0.1822887510061264,
-0.7450602054595947,
0.43665769696235657,
-0.43855342268943787,
-0.8226605653762817,
0.20914682745933533,
0.15958943963050842,
-0.2820882797241211,
-0.059332914650440216,
-0.5090214610099792,
0.7610086798667908,
-0.18759414553642273,
-1.104115605354309,
-0.42812860012054443,
-0.8437144160270691,
0.19506026804447174,
0.014173195697367191,
-0.3562787175178528,
-0.17931818962097168,
-0.4095675051212311,
0.3269732892513275,
-0.9120053648948669,
0.543082058429718,
-0.1858343631029129,
-0.050480347126722336,
0.26233604550361633,
0.07102120667695999,
1.0886369943618774,
0.09215569496154785,
-0.4536512792110443,
-0.08811111003160477,
-0.01165411714464426,
-0.28080013394355774,
-0.8480574488639832,
0.2812255620956421,
-0.13487987220287323,
-0.5851345062255859,
-0.5186576247215271,
-0.15600797533988953,
-0.49457550048828125,
0.24353106319904327,
-0.008534069173038006,
0.2819759249687195,
-0.2710149884223938,
0.23249994218349457,
0.7545750141143799,
-0.28836607933044434,
0.10972881317138672,
0.9150229692459106,
-0.2907988429069519,
-0.34895360469818115,
0.486053466796875,
-0.1697571575641632,
0.38046717643737793,
0.38111385703086853,
0.09943027049303055,
-0.9246602654457092,
-0.29771944880485535,
-0.5721966624259949,
0.3437007665634155,
-0.4888177514076233,
-0.07960981875658035,
-0.5813204646110535,
0.11711762100458145,
-0.3144327998161316,
-0.10968832671642303,
-0.46359607577323914,
-0.5512477159500122,
-0.33263763785362244,
0.19496379792690277,
0.640868067741394,
0.5647474527359009,
0.14913389086723328,
0.2931167185306549,
-0.5680859088897705,
0.03376419097185135,
-0.04670887067914009,
0.4740981459617615,
-0.4179984927177429,
-0.40543580055236816,
-0.005969188176095486,
-0.2570973336696625,
0.08751999586820602,
-1.1633458137512207,
-0.17230241000652313,
0.391287624835968,
0.3869481682777405,
0.11148770153522491,
0.06012239679694176,
0.6805804967880249,
-0.6437397599220276,
0.859920859336853,
0.3191603422164917,
-0.8406941890716553,
0.8197047710418701,
-0.422540545463562,
0.03884683921933174,
0.9497195482254028,
0.2243504673242569,
-0.5183592438697815,
-0.14027494192123413,
-0.526870608329773,
-0.797255277633667,
0.9024853706359863,
0.0659327432513237,
-0.2595069408416748,
0.14325261116027832,
0.5941153764724731,
0.2865815758705139,
0.30907168984413147,
-0.5228843688964844,
-0.07398390769958496,
-0.054128922522068024,
-0.08164948970079422,
0.2350534200668335,
-0.4099797010421753,
0.11157875508069992,
-0.25595080852508545,
0.5925722122192383,
-0.34655970335006714,
0.0621354877948761,
0.26293623447418213,
0.23675204813480377,
0.1297280490398407,
0.36552128195762634,
0.3225543797016144,
0.6035798192024231,
-0.3031793534755707,
0.1068655252456665,
0.4028114676475525,
-0.33181238174438477,
0.14294195175170898,
0.04854055866599083,
-0.2295827716588974,
0.2044783979654312,
-0.11502187699079514,
0.5383396148681641,
0.10806552320718765,
-0.6632815599441528,
0.4390982985496521,
-0.09392774850130081,
0.1930929273366928,
0.005465125199407339,
-0.04031899943947792,
0.11346028000116348,
0.0008462585974484682,
0.2750670611858368,
-0.135746031999588,
0.21688388288021088,
-0.7225509285926819,
0.5641744136810303,
0.48621514439582825,
-0.24839550256729126,
-0.15828226506710052,
0.50551837682724,
0.3785255551338196,
-0.3460082411766052,
0.44721126556396484,
-0.38420140743255615,
-0.3098822236061096,
0.2677861750125885,
0.7339327931404114,
0.7802776098251343,
-0.37379026412963867,
-0.025243256241083145,
0.6230111718177795,
0.06774459034204483,
-0.1181211993098259,
0.8803877234458923,
-0.30713343620300293,
-0.29899489879608154,
-0.3702736794948578,
-0.41731083393096924,
-0.5824435353279114,
-0.1551956832408905,
-0.4290887117385864,
0.7665960788726807,
-0.5490344166755676,
-0.1142243966460228,
-0.21298901736736298,
0.20107701420783997,
-0.17322079837322235,
0.2610515058040619,
-0.35603371262550354,
1.0417232513427734,
-0.5779207348823547,
1.062513828277588,
0.7711297869682312,
-0.45661675930023193,
-0.8590208888053894,
-0.07118939608335495,
-0.20464308559894562,
-0.5040490627288818,
0.3201638460159302,
0.09956855326890945,
-0.09593949466943741,
-0.12252507358789444,
-0.23733583092689514,
-0.7509558796882629,
0.9585619568824768,
0.29513564705848694,
-1.0418919324874878,
-0.08613494038581848,
0.37471824884414673,
0.6633093953132629,
-0.5241166353225708,
0.7189315557479858,
0.7295103669166565,
0.2992272675037384,
0.3445897698402405,
-0.9802035093307495,
0.4016820192337036,
-0.014579183422029018,
0.07539525628089905,
0.1795143038034439,
-0.5797255039215088,
0.708362877368927,
-0.3529909551143646,
-0.2871476709842682,
-0.06036284193396568,
0.6842061877250671,
0.6938979029655457,
0.15567617118358612,
0.46538910269737244,
0.3231104612350464,
1.0520812273025513,
-0.23746652901172638,
0.7077600359916687,
-0.3488859236240387,
0.13036519289016724,
1.4183838367462158,
-0.7103673219680786,
1.1387298107147217,
0.5987444519996643,
-0.40570512413978577,
0.6462651491165161,
0.7413427829742432,
0.017831062898039818,
0.5195649266242981,
0.2803225517272949,
-0.23212671279907227,
-0.41510990262031555,
-0.41977766156196594,
-0.6823012828826904,
0.18469396233558655,
0.41083991527557373,
-0.29040855169296265,
-0.4908803105354309,
-0.4365847706794739,
0.022035803645849228,
0.2566247582435608,
-0.029336057603359222,
0.7725408673286438,
-0.05922078341245651,
-0.6693790555000305,
0.6289811730384827,
-0.14523310959339142,
0.5619173645973206,
-0.7130329608917236,
-0.24809563159942627,
-0.2296813279390335,
0.04697125405073166,
-0.31206756830215454,
-0.876842737197876,
0.4025331139564514,
-0.0035445853136479855,
-0.18628305196762085,
0.043339960277080536,
0.8639107346534729,
-0.7863335013389587,
0.017129849642515182,
0.04483431205153465,
0.12589702010154724,
0.4698154032230377,
-0.2723411023616791,
-0.6632991433143616,
0.04562821239233017,
-0.04739847779273987,
-0.16445763409137726,
0.11035050451755524,
0.6218344569206238,
-0.13431353867053986,
0.47140926122665405,
0.4611298143863678,
0.010222063399851322,
-0.11073172837495804,
0.16303986310958862,
0.8933730721473694,
-0.765783965587616,
-0.6682162284851074,
-0.8139059543609619,
0.4895347058773041,
-0.4614544212818146,
-0.20682170987129211,
0.6694326400756836,
0.9721324443817139,
0.3668902516365051,
0.08743388205766678,
0.4616766571998596,
-0.10780863463878632,
0.6924715638160706,
-0.49578365683555603,
0.37705475091934204,
-0.5578211545944214,
0.375378280878067,
0.11049024760723114,
-0.9612149596214294,
-0.08294068276882172,
0.4870617091655731,
-0.05332737788558006,
0.08764232695102692,
1.0184745788574219,
1.2118054628372192,
0.31777113676071167,
0.10738489031791687,
0.13666366040706635,
0.06805714219808578,
0.07837522774934769,
0.6194037795066833,
0.8663098812103271,
-0.4749355614185333,
0.46810588240623474,
0.1275535523891449,
-0.13691431283950806,
-0.30531197786331177,
-0.9125115275382996,
-0.7766349911689758,
-0.46133941411972046,
-0.39647889137268066,
-0.7870833873748779,
0.4096176326274872,
0.9433876872062683,
0.8066340684890747,
-0.8422333002090454,
-0.023709766566753387,
-0.3923095166683197,
-0.20140217244625092,
-0.0014592850347980857,
-0.2121805101633072,
0.46186181902885437,
-0.7374826073646545,
-0.5295659303665161,
0.5089190006256104,
0.5536884069442749,
-0.10111359506845474,
-0.3586117923259735,
-0.14934387803077698,
-0.2430400848388672,
0.19012843072414398,
0.45164474844932556,
0.25700363516807556,
-0.6929165720939636,
-0.07739495486021042,
-0.006357815116643906,
-0.6363927721977234,
0.3610730767250061,
0.7307525277137756,
-1.0405402183532715,
0.38044485449790955,
0.6739957332611084,
0.40497249364852905,
0.5884068012237549,
0.2725898325443268,
0.8210064768791199,
-0.8808209896087646,
0.03753490373492241,
0.41701069474220276,
0.14143671095371246,
0.3816923201084137,
-0.6464786529541016,
0.6769306063652039,
0.2674514949321747,
-0.3980078101158142,
-0.7456993460655212,
0.3969982862472534,
-0.9125437140464783,
-0.262275755405426,
1.1912262439727783,
0.02953585609793663,
-0.3181719481945038,
-0.32627126574516296,
-0.44183072447776794,
0.15544794499874115,
-0.6086128950119019,
0.3762059211730957,
0.46093618869781494,
-0.2596614956855774,
-0.18941085040569305,
0.027584951370954514,
1.0659629106521606,
0.6740832328796387,
-1.0302457809448242,
0.434207558631897,
0.6574756503105164,
0.4180814325809479,
-0.1014602780342102,
0.8645220994949341,
-0.351509153842926,
0.3698049485683441,
0.16619783639907837,
0.20173142850399017,
0.0239219069480896,
-0.26397982239723206,
-0.3287490904331207,
0.08117178082466125,
0.02628149837255478,
-0.04805683717131615
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08192v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08192v1
|
MoleculeQA: A Dataset to Evaluate Factual Accuracy in Molecular Comprehension
| 2024-03-13T02:26:16 | 2024-03-13T02:26:16 |
Xingyu Lu, He Cao, Zijing Liu, Shengyuan Bai, Leqing Chen, Yuan Yao, Hai-Tao Zheng, Yu Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, q-bio.BM
|
Large language models are playing an increasingly significant role in
molecular research, yet existing models often generate erroneous information,
posing challenges to accurate molecular comprehension. Traditional evaluation
metrics for generated content fail to assess a model's accuracy in molecular
understanding. To rectify the absence of factual evaluation, we present
MoleculeQA, a novel question answering (QA) dataset which possesses 62K QA
pairs over 23K molecules. Each QA pair, composed of a manual question, a
positive option and three negative options, has consistent semantics with a
molecular description from authoritative molecular corpus. MoleculeQA is not
only the first benchmark for molecular factual bias evaluation but also the
largest QA dataset for molecular research. A comprehensive evaluation on
MoleculeQA for existing molecular LLMs exposes their deficiencies in specific
areas and pinpoints several particularly crucial factors for molecular
understanding.
|
[
-0.3018662929534912,
-0.8065915107727051,
0.7664874196052551,
-0.07601945102214813,
-0.14402763545513153,
0.3752334415912628,
0.21377161145210266,
-0.11775432527065277,
0.014122777618467808,
0.4059411585330963,
-0.5823044180870056,
-0.47537723183631897,
-0.3553081750869751,
0.38689643144607544,
-0.5367436408996582,
0.9105651378631592,
0.16464368999004364,
0.4692438840866089,
-0.7006645202636719,
-0.32796576619148254,
-0.06583011150360107,
-0.26002374291419983,
-0.32054394483566284,
0.051582761108875275,
0.6116209626197815,
0.6050947904586792,
0.6929121613502502,
0.4144815504550934,
0.7070325613021851,
0.29016223549842834,
-0.2805829644203186,
0.11446698009967804,
-0.7532585859298706,
-0.17562976479530334,
-0.34584373235702515,
-0.5275349617004395,
-0.5132479667663574,
0.15146227180957794,
0.6676076054573059,
0.8435865640640259,
-0.04181098937988281,
0.38492637872695923,
-0.4214728772640228,
0.8280671834945679,
-0.5645627379417419,
-0.1807636171579361,
-0.7009584307670593,
0.09727410972118378,
0.032741717994213104,
-0.0021476929541677237,
-0.19793134927749634,
-0.4257177710533142,
0.49553197622299194,
-0.7823504209518433,
0.4199303686618805,
0.0767250806093216,
0.8489750623703003,
0.33234745264053345,
-0.8953384160995483,
-0.4609663188457489,
-0.39532312750816345,
0.41613858938217163,
-0.6064832210540771,
0.4421495199203491,
0.08900762349367142,
0.4876415431499481,
-0.33432522416114807,
-0.6594681143760681,
-0.8730735182762146,
-0.49715456366539,
0.22538377344608307,
0.21378450095653534,
-0.05816709250211716,
0.1691826581954956,
0.12738966941833496,
0.6531973481178284,
-0.9070901870727539,
-0.5059658885002136,
-0.6596069931983948,
-0.3557654023170471,
0.3060288429260254,
0.031279195100069046,
0.44024714827537537,
-0.41165822744369507,
-0.5363419055938721,
0.01053550560027361,
-0.6714322566986084,
-0.05632094293832779,
0.2632262110710144,
0.06496285647153854,
0.23994475603103638,
0.993256688117981,
-0.26678746938705444,
0.6018446087837219,
0.07964328676462173,
0.21280649304389954,
0.10826592892408371,
-0.6313797235488892,
-0.4152255058288574,
0.2928020656108856,
0.3834006190299988,
0.29821333289146423,
0.21386030316352844,
-0.23246417939662933,
0.1714845597743988,
-0.029978066682815552,
0.3739323019981384,
-0.806678056716919,
-0.4083770215511322,
0.7649004459381104,
-0.16294756531715393,
-0.24974411725997925,
0.2585870623588562,
-0.9121286869049072,
-0.48846837878227234,
-0.15742944180965424,
0.6953412294387817,
-0.3462027311325073,
-0.016648396849632263,
0.16326159238815308,
-0.6031172871589661,
0.07679545879364014,
0.1592269390821457,
-0.39721906185150146,
0.13364291191101074,
0.596491813659668,
0.7598567008972168,
-0.2099193036556244,
0.0029175649397075176,
-0.36927297711372375,
-0.012846014462411404,
-0.43728286027908325,
0.763666033744812,
-0.5459535717964172,
-0.3881721794605255,
-0.5083866715431213,
0.0447593592107296,
0.05947573110461235,
-0.8622472882270813,
0.3873867392539978,
-0.7453337907791138,
0.22674262523651123,
-0.5361827611923218,
-0.9437307715415955,
-0.4396621882915497,
0.1611226201057434,
-0.8917214274406433,
0.5890828967094421,
0.4636281728744507,
-0.509548544883728,
0.657353937625885,
-0.4351656436920166,
0.17119793593883514,
0.080199234187603,
-0.12837475538253784,
-0.2942158281803131,
-0.17865091562271118,
0.1482892632484436,
0.15349875390529633,
-0.22295716404914856,
0.32195746898651123,
-0.427769273519516,
-0.08475391566753387,
0.7655096650123596,
-0.40667298436164856,
0.8644453287124634,
0.01160618755966425,
-0.19436980783939362,
-0.01017675269395113,
-1.0562076568603516,
0.1345321536064148,
-0.2077755182981491,
-0.3637181520462036,
0.17473620176315308,
-0.47010311484336853,
-0.19855062663555145,
0.31866300106048584,
0.17992009222507477,
-0.6532334089279175,
0.1973700374364853,
-0.3071700930595398,
0.3660552203655243,
0.6744397878646851,
0.35371455550193787,
0.387789785861969,
-0.40310508012771606,
0.8239047527313232,
0.21115177869796753,
-0.20137743651866913,
0.2182721644639969,
-0.6274536848068237,
-0.8141161203384399,
-0.2789752781391144,
0.6128530502319336,
0.5246376395225525,
-0.6456243991851807,
0.282033771276474,
-0.32456400990486145,
-0.5552230477333069,
-0.5169256925582886,
0.3753141760826111,
0.4566516578197479,
0.7510421276092529,
0.5117825865745544,
-0.30610209703445435,
-0.5151931047439575,
-1.0542142391204834,
-0.3090285360813141,
-0.32845839858055115,
-0.1436324268579483,
0.4223468601703644,
0.8005542159080505,
-0.18981781601905823,
0.8721486330032349,
-0.18128421902656555,
0.129976287484169,
-0.015442178584635258,
-0.03991588205099106,
0.035539742559194565,
0.2722449004650116,
0.13788115978240967,
-0.8483116626739502,
-0.0157177671790123,
-0.390572726726532,
-0.5647380352020264,
0.15582722425460815,
-0.1775551289319992,
-0.6481948494911194,
0.014849052764475346,
0.30787980556488037,
-0.7284315228462219,
0.21381589770317078,
0.46574100852012634,
-0.6875863671302795,
0.5004511475563049,
0.20645084977149963,
0.22887282073497772,
-0.7631117701530457,
0.4086657464504242,
0.024323390796780586,
-0.2792164385318756,
-0.5425770282745361,
-0.03537561371922493,
0.030009064823389053,
0.1246514692902565,
-0.6151115894317627,
0.5840575695037842,
-0.17409048974514008,
-0.024509483948349953,
0.00857391394674778,
0.27062293887138367,
0.426564484834671,
0.3070092797279358,
-0.12768863141536713,
1.022009015083313,
0.15077818930149078,
-0.4984954297542572,
0.6138352155685425,
0.7240546345710754,
-0.4805816411972046,
0.4415360987186432,
-0.7627652883529663,
0.1253974437713623,
-0.06317172199487686,
0.4247239828109741,
-1.0747164487838745,
-0.4252060055732727,
0.38889962434768677,
-0.6528728604316711,
-0.03500829264521599,
-0.2324366420507431,
-0.048839882016181946,
-0.3030586838722229,
-0.08742611110210419,
0.42001020908355713,
0.2251712679862976,
-0.4054047465324402,
0.30007079243659973,
0.38819897174835205,
0.011522342450916767,
-0.6940093636512756,
-0.6841157674789429,
-0.005799184553325176,
-0.152792289853096,
-0.6380866765975952,
-0.04983476921916008,
-0.06848569959402084,
-0.3339933156967163,
0.1140337586402893,
-0.6463286876678467,
-0.3649284541606903,
-0.08522132784128189,
0.12598690390586853,
0.3059331178665161,
-0.4305369555950165,
0.21285420656204224,
-0.2825111746788025,
0.10676681995391846,
0.37962642312049866,
-0.20625410974025726,
0.17176778614521027,
-0.18651911616325378,
0.051650520414114,
-0.20952680706977844,
-0.0005500862025655806,
0.5682846307754517,
-0.02477096952497959,
0.712571382522583,
0.33710893988609314,
-0.20643126964569092,
-0.06825221329927444,
-0.10645557940006256,
-0.1666136384010315,
-0.45807522535324097,
0.47990089654922485,
-0.3589363098144531,
-0.8810926675796509,
0.3462236821651459,
0.18560388684272766,
-0.35145413875579834,
0.5313451886177063,
0.5428287982940674,
-0.2516528069972992,
0.5647964477539062,
0.11984468251466751,
0.2946750819683075,
-0.3379307687282562,
-0.11197984963655472,
0.21353879570960999,
-0.7397415637969971,
-0.5149040818214417,
-0.35879355669021606,
-0.1693636029958725,
-0.5498449206352234,
-0.8077796101570129,
0.49766042828559875,
0.19379284977912903,
-0.41469305753707886,
0.10526242852210999,
-0.17233465611934662,
0.5259603261947632,
0.6474044322967529,
0.4070649743080139,
0.2211400270462036,
-0.04392051324248314,
-0.022416701540350914,
0.4916072189807892,
-0.8360734581947327,
-0.7817946672439575,
1.4219774007797241,
0.1705167442560196,
0.2806779444217682,
0.4112969636917114,
0.12158659845590591,
0.31649672985076904,
-0.14670181274414062,
-0.8877570629119873,
0.5735938549041748,
0.17393308877944946,
-1.1940473318099976,
-0.41539326310157776,
-0.9319618940353394,
-0.8334155082702637,
-0.09444732964038849,
-0.37250158190727234,
-0.43995943665504456,
0.39004313945770264,
0.28114041686058044,
-0.6755443215370178,
0.12415235489606857,
-0.5635011196136475,
1.1571043729782104,
-0.03973636031150818,
-0.19299963116645813,
-0.04562726244330406,
-0.8249397873878479,
0.6713321208953857,
-0.15934313833713531,
-0.24625210464000702,
-0.2975523769855499,
-0.08158234506845474,
0.8110221028327942,
-0.422705739736557,
0.08964213728904724,
0.040271926671266556,
-0.058474522083997726,
0.4963621199131012,
0.26735720038414,
-0.10379530489444733,
0.3346489369869232,
-0.08008796721696854,
0.04128396138548851,
0.5670546889305115,
-0.9045073986053467,
-0.8657386302947998,
0.35851117968559265,
-0.5342093110084534,
-0.41984784603118896,
-0.4240162968635559,
-0.26073792576789856,
-0.5968993902206421,
-0.012888908386230469,
0.17384573817253113,
0.522739827632904,
-0.33416691422462463,
0.15142133831977844,
0.8369753956794739,
-0.390901118516922,
-0.21746893227100372,
0.39071139693260193,
-0.2427905648946762,
-0.41518914699554443,
1.0607287883758545,
-0.17679463326931,
0.4331289529800415,
0.5005289912223816,
-0.06613779067993164,
-0.5298279523849487,
-0.5402514934539795,
-0.7055067420005798,
-0.05380559340119362,
-0.9151432514190674,
-0.18240833282470703,
-0.5698243975639343,
-0.1739117056131363,
-0.21250797808170319,
0.26434949040412903,
-0.22233347594738007,
-0.9153071641921997,
-0.04079858958721161,
-0.3922186493873596,
0.4464128315448761,
0.7426449656486511,
-0.06414613127708435,
-0.05663803219795227,
-0.9896350502967834,
0.9417638778686523,
0.5750169157981873,
0.1430884748697281,
-0.3617278039455414,
-0.5863577127456665,
-0.13816186785697937,
0.33541950583457947,
-0.12505479156970978,
-1.0561660528182983,
-0.021331649273633957,
0.46703553199768066,
0.41026127338409424,
0.25591421127319336,
-0.2786572277545929,
0.4477786123752594,
-0.2674301266670227,
0.8350356817245483,
-0.3899519145488739,
-1.11491858959198,
0.35735687613487244,
-0.25474685430526733,
0.2787221074104309,
0.8522202372550964,
0.6394688487052917,
-0.5102947354316711,
-0.17354433238506317,
-0.6688868403434753,
-0.7546018362045288,
0.38317230343818665,
0.5310568809509277,
-0.34558966755867004,
0.07126451283693314,
0.6357676982879639,
0.07357608526945114,
0.3739511966705322,
-0.31972000002861023,
-0.39011266827583313,
-0.3076085150241852,
-0.33791449666023254,
-0.1266082227230072,
-0.22741985321044922,
-0.20431558787822723,
-0.28646132349967957,
0.9024357795715332,
-0.031045304611325264,
0.3873036205768585,
0.49584972858428955,
-0.3409217298030853,
0.041825275868177414,
0.1684206873178482,
0.5473226308822632,
0.9089581966400146,
-0.6034368276596069,
0.16405247151851654,
0.09318749606609344,
-0.6706241369247437,
0.3997832238674164,
-0.22931021451950073,
0.053861070424318314,
-0.1365368366241455,
0.39486703276634216,
0.4095678925514221,
-0.2550791800022125,
-1.0679975748062134,
0.359142541885376,
-0.09307920932769775,
-0.13813666999340057,
0.17205475270748138,
0.24989531934261322,
0.1550796627998352,
0.017134172841906548,
0.23256932199001312,
0.22570711374282837,
0.6320186853408813,
-0.7536596059799194,
0.6461998820304871,
0.2855333387851715,
-0.5032207369804382,
-0.01496851909905672,
0.40589049458503723,
0.13947707414627075,
0.36499685049057007,
0.8185630440711975,
-0.24776379764080048,
-0.7130160331726074,
1.0823787450790405,
-0.07613913714885712,
0.5283063650131226,
-0.056934162974357605,
0.6080309748649597,
0.4825756847858429,
0.38089463114738464,
0.4869627058506012,
0.5284551978111267,
0.19247351586818695,
-0.8314805626869202,
-0.16623589396476746,
-0.6559509634971619,
-0.6186293363571167,
0.16685578227043152,
-0.5706838369369507,
-0.08755672723054886,
-0.4716717004776001,
0.14497217535972595,
0.29717686772346497,
0.16002622246742249,
-0.370609849691391,
0.6421210765838623,
0.09794899821281433,
1.1130342483520508,
-0.5397934317588806,
0.5797886848449707,
0.5685848593711853,
-0.3977161645889282,
-0.6619857549667358,
-0.1423010528087616,
0.23794271051883698,
-0.7104802131652832,
0.5547847151756287,
0.167636439204216,
-0.06158517301082611,
-0.04453876614570618,
-0.5890294909477234,
-0.859130859375,
0.7626847624778748,
0.3566431999206543,
-0.6160208582878113,
0.20733366906642914,
0.5577637553215027,
0.5369340777397156,
-0.02810158208012581,
0.3258613049983978,
1.0208683013916016,
0.6584216356277466,
0.17555545270442963,
-0.5587499141693115,
0.1773419827222824,
-0.5027141571044922,
-0.3066195547580719,
-0.1395169347524643,
-0.5691189169883728,
0.38789796829223633,
-0.1611451655626297,
-0.268757700920105,
0.29873839020729065,
0.6222796440124512,
0.4087047576904297,
0.4353208839893341,
0.3084527552127838,
0.5600600242614746,
1.0828970670700073,
-0.18695774674415588,
0.8616967797279358,
-0.2604260742664337,
0.13644587993621826,
1.0711252689361572,
-0.015330672264099121,
0.6356514692306519,
0.4438479542732239,
-0.4158206582069397,
0.2771616280078888,
0.9413009285926819,
-0.07673849165439606,
0.20202301442623138,
0.6955193281173706,
-0.4396858215332031,
-0.5098209977149963,
0.11471232026815414,
-0.24959425628185272,
0.6164843440055847,
0.4395720362663269,
-0.02065981738269329,
0.03709596395492554,
-0.20234131813049316,
-0.3295252025127411,
0.005537835881114006,
-0.30034640431404114,
0.720772385597229,
-0.014557989314198494,
-0.3905216455459595,
0.5087266564369202,
-0.10334840416908264,
0.10456729680299759,
-0.24437540769577026,
-0.22678576409816742,
-0.3118986487388611,
-0.20159150660037994,
-0.21447277069091797,
-0.8297834992408752,
0.19002534449100494,
-0.029964376240968704,
-0.19144059717655182,
0.5117775797843933,
0.2689230144023895,
-0.5593189001083374,
-0.6299905776977539,
-0.16042965650558472,
0.5299422740936279,
0.2868056297302246,
-0.24668173491954803,
-0.8479337692260742,
-0.36917608976364136,
0.027723250910639763,
-0.1577358990907669,
-0.2787352204322815,
0.5357589721679688,
0.41884011030197144,
0.8932645320892334,
0.48468488454818726,
-0.2072802633047104,
0.3350588083267212,
-0.42798343300819397,
0.6538329124450684,
-0.9403083324432373,
0.08193542808294296,
-0.5986799001693726,
0.35170331597328186,
0.05918167158961296,
-0.5343812704086304,
0.8319500684738159,
0.8817650675773621,
0.7505136728286743,
-0.061835262924432755,
0.8198390007019043,
0.18316230177879333,
0.6217650771141052,
-0.9163699150085449,
0.5896759033203125,
-0.4661480486392975,
0.1913042813539505,
0.09895700216293335,
-0.9468276500701904,
-0.06704161316156387,
0.36263221502304077,
-0.022881781682372093,
0.3286777138710022,
0.795899510383606,
0.9741244912147522,
-0.14708319306373596,
0.2888566851615906,
0.23270605504512787,
0.6524752974510193,
0.10938049107789993,
0.7100028395652771,
1.1394579410552979,
-0.6230339407920837,
0.38662564754486084,
-0.21271491050720215,
0.14324256777763367,
-0.16870006918907166,
-0.6392177939414978,
-0.9379183053970337,
-0.5637197494506836,
-0.25074589252471924,
-0.7631475329399109,
0.29048478603363037,
0.9926982522010803,
0.6832069754600525,
-1.157128095626831,
-0.08068744838237762,
-0.40128448605537415,
0.13206830620765686,
0.3307817578315735,
-0.2795763909816742,
0.3374975919723511,
-0.04606824368238449,
-0.6584348082542419,
0.7101104259490967,
0.20183663070201874,
0.17979376018047333,
-0.3844362199306488,
0.07301229238510132,
-0.2756213843822479,
0.41167765855789185,
0.375308632850647,
0.37582990527153015,
-0.47127431631088257,
0.01082382071763277,
0.0921844020485878,
-0.23558762669563293,
0.3153616786003113,
0.5785142779350281,
-0.8097687363624573,
0.5296913981437683,
0.4349696934223175,
0.7913621068000793,
0.17107827961444855,
0.2430572658777237,
0.857161283493042,
-0.4157053828239441,
-0.25717782974243164,
0.4472777545452118,
0.06534796208143234,
0.42331114411354065,
-0.49153631925582886,
0.4122277498245239,
0.27199339866638184,
-0.6627270579338074,
-0.557549774646759,
0.07706920802593231,
-1.4185433387756348,
-0.54112708568573,
1.085605502128601,
0.03547123447060585,
-0.42496851086616516,
-0.2549750506877899,
-0.22515136003494263,
0.15726225078105927,
-0.46994906663894653,
0.7213249802589417,
0.9113428592681885,
0.07242882251739502,
0.0261114202439785,
-0.517325222492218,
0.7944663166999817,
0.7632383108139038,
-0.8612325191497803,
-0.1000923290848732,
0.7451084852218628,
0.12483681738376617,
-0.13273577392101288,
0.24720171093940735,
0.1106022298336029,
0.6716921925544739,
0.10801536589860916,
-0.17918288707733154,
0.1649724841117859,
-0.6972941160202026,
-0.40825504064559937,
0.04081857204437256,
-0.09873449802398682,
0.04830189049243927
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08189v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08189v1
|
Embedded Translations for Low-resource Automated Glossing
| 2024-03-13T02:23:13 | 2024-03-13T02:23:13 |
Changbing Yang, Garrett Nicolai, Miikka Silfverberg
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We investigate automatic interlinear glossing in low-resource settings. We
augment a hard-attentional neural model with embedded translation information
extracted from interlinear glossed text. After encoding these translations
using large language models, specifically BERT and T5, we introduce a
character-level decoder for generating glossed output. Aided by these
enhancements, our model demonstrates an average improvement of 3.97\%-points
over the previous state of the art on datasets from the SIGMORPHON 2023 Shared
Task on Interlinear Glossing. In a simulated ultra low-resource setting,
trained on as few as 100 sentences, our system achieves an average 9.78\%-point
improvement over the plain hard-attentional baseline. These results highlight
the critical role of translation information in boosting the system's
performance, especially in processing and interpreting modest data sources. Our
findings suggest a promising avenue for the documentation and preservation of
languages, with our experiments on shared task datasets indicating significant
advancements over the existing state of the art.
|
[
-0.3817272186279297,
-0.49101346731185913,
0.5985413193702698,
0.41636618971824646,
-0.32633641362190247,
0.08645301312208176,
-0.598965585231781,
-0.7129412889480591,
0.3993895351886749,
0.45397111773490906,
-0.2605900466442108,
-0.3514423072338104,
-0.7763741612434387,
-0.038711536675691605,
-0.5082421898841858,
0.9835332632064819,
-0.018311450257897377,
0.02023049257695675,
-0.18454541265964508,
-0.07773236930370331,
-0.0294644758105278,
-0.5185456871986389,
-0.5502511262893677,
-0.13309045135974884,
0.5657941699028015,
0.480863481760025,
0.9861558079719543,
0.6852706670761108,
0.598660945892334,
0.1708197146654129,
-0.06821952760219574,
0.29602089524269104,
-0.40224140882492065,
-0.01765586994588375,
-0.19075734913349152,
-0.2915572226047516,
-0.8014064431190491,
-0.09321549534797668,
0.5272774696350098,
0.7469485998153687,
0.09411121159791946,
0.14039579033851624,
0.33711373805999756,
0.3767261207103729,
-0.6870535016059875,
0.4205935001373291,
-0.6068165898323059,
-0.10920427739620209,
-0.323571115732193,
-0.15327657759189606,
-0.3228302597999573,
-0.25946786999702454,
0.1457691341638565,
-0.7224582433700562,
0.1644105613231659,
-0.08621763437986374,
0.9383408427238464,
0.6439296007156372,
0.011177519336342812,
-0.4761830270290375,
-0.7661171555519104,
0.6739775538444519,
-0.8816376328468323,
0.12260289490222931,
0.5818997621536255,
0.062242068350315094,
0.21547286212444305,
-0.796258807182312,
-0.46584445238113403,
-0.25198736786842346,
-0.27931734919548035,
0.35426804423332214,
-0.15734532475471497,
0.33628496527671814,
0.14834783971309662,
0.5358784794807434,
-0.05094154179096222,
0.20656563341617584,
-0.3534398674964905,
0.0688469335436821,
0.554867148399353,
0.07984882593154907,
0.3045797646045685,
-0.11133868992328644,
-0.024726152420043945,
-0.16099289059638977,
-0.4897535443305969,
-0.2844110131263733,
-0.033355507999658585,
0.5452955961227417,
-0.1321137398481369,
0.5497052669525146,
-0.19432812929153442,
0.32395708560943604,
0.14020584523677826,
0.0734548270702362,
0.12339562177658081,
-0.5156984925270081,
-0.020782971754670143,
0.08828897029161453,
0.7940806150436401,
0.28592145442962646,
0.3377396762371063,
-0.4273332357406616,
-0.5883901715278625,
-0.24976640939712524,
0.29795899987220764,
-0.6333365440368652,
-0.14665749669075012,
0.025490328669548035,
-0.260935515165329,
0.09469593316316605,
-0.21143990755081177,
-0.429950475692749,
-0.2926286458969116,
-0.2877158224582672,
0.35369738936424255,
-0.6277264952659607,
0.13394488394260406,
-0.19796136021614075,
0.21493418514728546,
0.036568570882081985,
0.5251556634902954,
-1.245367169380188,
0.5070726871490479,
0.5266044735908508,
1.118219017982483,
-0.19715222716331482,
-0.027174316346645355,
-0.6105596423149109,
0.2579552233219147,
-0.31273704767227173,
0.6705210208892822,
-0.28629955649375916,
-0.2223682552576065,
0.022938009351491928,
0.022689279168844223,
-0.042047400027513504,
-0.6875686049461365,
0.4378373920917511,
-0.5856178402900696,
-0.059732139110565186,
-0.06679749488830566,
-0.4541260302066803,
-0.01548881083726883,
-0.1102660596370697,
-0.7098810076713562,
1.0457249879837036,
0.12251012027263641,
-0.28549325466156006,
0.27036553621292114,
-0.9056156873703003,
-0.4780752956867218,
0.35700181126594543,
0.0486106313765049,
-0.1624719649553299,
0.39043697714805603,
0.38796716928482056,
0.3513737916946411,
-0.3420698642730713,
0.10819891840219498,
-0.17041176557540894,
-0.46922141313552856,
0.05488245561718941,
-0.34758248925209045,
0.3863135874271393,
0.2803455591201782,
-0.432034432888031,
0.1134382039308548,
-0.33825284242630005,
0.21031010150909424,
-0.16455653309822083,
-0.5600520968437195,
-0.48904532194137573,
-0.12709657847881317,
0.3880845904350281,
0.14510926604270935,
0.8506222367286682,
-0.47977718710899353,
0.19159887731075287,
-0.5542638897895813,
0.15873542428016663,
0.6547242999076843,
-0.27915021777153015,
0.6587514877319336,
-0.047410376369953156,
0.5201793313026428,
0.013777265325188637,
0.27364158630371094,
0.1301165074110031,
-0.4257737994194031,
-1.0612061023712158,
-0.14600183069705963,
0.6285223960876465,
0.6187127232551575,
-0.949087917804718,
0.3666996955871582,
-0.4559458792209625,
-0.1264290064573288,
-0.9684216976165771,
0.21280604600906372,
0.5693625211715698,
0.16543473303318024,
0.6444716453552246,
-0.23712638020515442,
-0.07808587700128555,
-1.199164628982544,
0.08387133479118347,
0.19386178255081177,
-0.14979588985443115,
0.5107414126396179,
0.1750970482826233,
-0.2789134085178375,
0.7121049165725708,
-0.3093845546245575,
-0.31180185079574585,
-0.18110768496990204,
0.31413504481315613,
0.1493205577135086,
0.5764065980911255,
0.42707890272140503,
-0.6822004318237305,
-0.9052311182022095,
0.14508546888828278,
-0.7977592945098877,
-0.27942171692848206,
-0.009710276499390602,
-0.11864873021841049,
0.339588463306427,
0.6609997749328613,
-0.09587162733078003,
0.2767711877822876,
0.7255266308784485,
-0.11923440545797348,
-0.07140453159809113,
-0.6131544709205627,
0.00984224770218134,
-1.032477617263794,
0.21812215447425842,
-0.10886162519454956,
-0.3224819600582123,
-0.5134066939353943,
-0.01935732178390026,
0.07714313268661499,
0.010081867687404156,
-0.2798413932323456,
0.551866888999939,
-0.6733757853507996,
-0.5091002583503723,
-0.5153247714042664,
0.2721717655658722,
-0.26124313473701477,
0.5605431199073792,
0.0021660246420651674,
1.2661970853805542,
0.2210703045129776,
-0.5266425013542175,
0.1429661363363266,
0.3619438707828522,
-0.41309410333633423,
0.2962943911552429,
-0.6452565789222717,
0.14720876514911652,
-0.026812808588147163,
-0.07285585254430771,
-0.6675216555595398,
-0.4739603102207184,
0.13831762969493866,
-0.18419523537158966,
0.24714073538780212,
-0.061156339943408966,
-0.7869049906730652,
0.02483941614627838,
-0.012219591066241264,
0.17615340650081635,
0.5522642731666565,
-0.4962794780731201,
0.3268490135669708,
0.6971485018730164,
-0.4184529185295105,
-0.39032888412475586,
-0.8135955333709717,
0.4245651364326477,
0.03395156189799309,
-0.5009898543357849,
0.6784499287605286,
-0.05177408456802368,
-0.26344504952430725,
0.1513345092535019,
0.059199679642915726,
-0.2697906792163849,
0.30223023891448975,
0.18829262256622314,
0.03504527360200882,
-0.30678561329841614,
0.3774441182613373,
0.20519904792308807,
-0.03590221703052521,
-0.2868650555610657,
-0.3937196433544159,
0.451413631439209,
-0.47640717029571533,
-0.049634262919425964,
-0.43439656496047974,
0.5166018009185791,
0.6431217789649963,
-0.10215189307928085,
0.867450475692749,
0.5795183777809143,
-0.4272761344909668,
0.016195455566048622,
-0.24858777225017548,
-0.17470678687095642,
-0.46899881958961487,
0.16826432943344116,
-0.4043688178062439,
-0.6656849980354309,
0.5579961538314819,
-0.08802620321512222,
0.02903743088245392,
0.3997804522514343,
0.25644952058792114,
-0.40293100476264954,
1.1293045282363892,
0.9449790120124817,
0.23509228229522705,
0.8333069682121277,
-0.23987619578838348,
-0.06730002164840698,
-0.9879662990570068,
0.05184313654899597,
0.07967319339513779,
-0.4866834878921509,
-0.5796589255332947,
-0.6448559165000916,
0.736009955406189,
0.25948625802993774,
0.19938962161540985,
0.38253673911094666,
-0.4680585265159607,
0.4936113953590393,
0.8574426770210266,
0.3211440443992615,
0.24769292771816254,
-0.14144793152809143,
0.12769444286823273,
-0.07937484979629517,
-0.7474841475486755,
-0.7129039168357849,
0.8772128820419312,
0.11847571283578873,
0.8031948208808899,
0.12546072900295258,
0.6851842999458313,
0.5341178178787231,
0.3481030762195587,
-1.0035136938095093,
0.50838702917099,
-0.7328137755393982,
-0.32561177015304565,
-0.41071122884750366,
-0.13108967244625092,
-0.7505333423614502,
0.06694333255290985,
-0.2200666069984436,
-0.5211183428764343,
0.29690226912498474,
0.37169793248176575,
-0.5159320831298828,
-0.09744854271411896,
-0.8343075513839722,
0.7402506470680237,
-0.41626545786857605,
-0.43747758865356445,
-0.2889361083507538,
-0.6639299392700195,
0.13890604674816132,
-0.2458767294883728,
-0.08702731877565384,
-0.06404908001422882,
-0.2918354868888855,
0.7303054332733154,
-0.4007928669452667,
0.7556905150413513,
-0.1587875932455063,
-0.27897152304649353,
-0.030858708545565605,
-0.188276007771492,
0.5273007750511169,
-0.10934300720691681,
-0.15511639416217804,
0.2298918217420578,
-0.1285540908575058,
-0.5475441813468933,
-0.5144230723381042,
0.6714721322059631,
-0.7448067665100098,
-0.5324490070343018,
-0.3292516767978668,
-0.8748506307601929,
-0.3093208372592926,
0.1684262752532959,
0.13602475821971893,
0.26440396904945374,
-0.10535167157649994,
0.21772600710391998,
0.7660598754882812,
-0.17755593359470367,
0.5355961322784424,
0.3979092836380005,
0.0616862028837204,
-0.4050244688987732,
0.8243924975395203,
0.2334146797657013,
0.5743675231933594,
0.40320202708244324,
-0.10195745527744293,
-0.09964899718761444,
-0.7291364073753357,
-0.6041882634162903,
0.34615352749824524,
-0.7930788993835449,
-0.0313333198428154,
-0.815245509147644,
-0.20640234649181366,
-0.3355361521244049,
-0.2468959540128708,
-0.48788726329803467,
-0.6619707345962524,
-0.44723379611968994,
0.18934346735477448,
0.3633483052253723,
0.9664474129676819,
-0.31999027729034424,
0.7451028227806091,
-0.8745371699333191,
0.2752160131931305,
0.14268505573272705,
0.17763462662696838,
-0.1461305320262909,
-0.425898939371109,
-0.9193076491355896,
0.06023448333144188,
0.15872439742088318,
-0.4663434326648712,
0.6042677164077759,
0.3682011365890503,
0.48375317454338074,
0.16227930784225464,
0.12730929255485535,
0.6876237988471985,
-0.555861234664917,
0.6286918520927429,
-0.2128017693758011,
-1.1683598756790161,
0.4297764301300049,
-0.29511216282844543,
0.6927953958511353,
0.8066887855529785,
0.23590593039989471,
-0.5898951888084412,
-0.6258552670478821,
-0.4570183753967285,
-1.0968362092971802,
1.1357148885726929,
0.05663937330245972,
0.12886062264442444,
0.03273368254303932,
0.3186604082584381,
-0.018063275143504143,
0.1837882548570633,
-0.6343174576759338,
-0.05076748505234718,
-0.034227777272462845,
-0.4497720003128052,
-0.1352778673171997,
-0.22169768810272217,
-0.18101190030574799,
-0.09603552520275116,
0.8277056217193604,
-0.44416025280952454,
0.30611085891723633,
0.005426955875009298,
-0.4910372793674469,
0.05399684980511665,
0.18315407633781433,
0.5713200569152832,
0.385471373796463,
-0.4017443060874939,
0.3341350257396698,
0.2044447958469391,
-0.5189640522003174,
-0.19783371686935425,
0.3864642381668091,
-0.24629901349544525,
-0.08451984077692032,
0.15231487154960632,
0.8178858757019043,
0.3831239342689514,
-0.5789387822151184,
0.4227672517299652,
-0.05721254646778107,
0.29539403319358826,
-0.2680419087409973,
-0.11892502754926682,
0.1280006319284439,
0.2337016761302948,
0.2859048545360565,
0.13240863382816315,
0.14451058208942413,
-0.4827696681022644,
0.26705262064933777,
0.28203284740448,
-0.5700333118438721,
-0.41427740454673767,
0.7046447396278381,
0.4521825313568115,
0.04191845282912254,
0.5012927651405334,
-0.18132717907428741,
-0.3297862708568573,
0.41297101974487305,
0.3811831474304199,
0.8698818683624268,
-0.01291999313980341,
0.024899832904338837,
0.22911562025547028,
0.37842386960983276,
0.09387281537055969,
0.1280311942100525,
-0.3371076285839081,
-0.3932754099369049,
-0.3056774139404297,
-0.7673230767250061,
-0.5596894025802612,
0.15516801178455353,
-0.5937843322753906,
0.09255954623222351,
-0.3731008768081665,
-0.07889746874570847,
0.014859962277114391,
-0.26294541358947754,
-0.3867797255516052,
0.09467799216508865,
0.5567788481712341,
0.6663575172424316,
-0.6362695693969727,
0.9728734493255615,
0.5493186712265015,
-0.6727783679962158,
-0.2780923545360565,
0.5795562863349915,
-0.49900171160697937,
-0.8420448899269104,
0.941484272480011,
-0.03241533786058426,
-0.34710583090782166,
0.10926844924688339,
-0.5535923838615417,
-1.3048323392868042,
0.999839186668396,
0.4164733290672302,
-0.43097254633903503,
-0.28349748253822327,
0.16730907559394836,
0.6811037063598633,
-0.27559491991996765,
0.147827610373497,
0.5013728141784668,
0.42910036444664,
-0.2299860566854477,
-1.3335658311843872,
0.11016741394996643,
-0.3134436309337616,
0.1609988808631897,
0.1681441366672516,
-0.5470721125602722,
1.0483078956604004,
-0.025411469861865044,
-0.6424073576927185,
0.10836157947778702,
0.7045074701309204,
-0.41790497303009033,
-0.023715587332844734,
0.4326966404914856,
0.26464036107063293,
0.7090290188789368,
-0.05267203971743584,
1.2093093395233154,
-0.7753928899765015,
0.1343650370836258,
1.3347458839416504,
-0.08992762863636017,
0.8014046549797058,
0.5631706714630127,
0.23590458929538727,
0.32961180806159973,
0.48938649892807007,
0.2734125256538391,
0.8061707615852356,
-0.0630851686000824,
-0.5497331619262695,
-0.2946990728378296,
-0.5174200534820557,
-0.0951065942645073,
0.4234253168106079,
0.7633744478225708,
-0.5644831657409668,
-0.19839425384998322,
0.25304895639419556,
-0.053561121225357056,
0.05090071260929108,
-0.3434930145740509,
1.028198480606079,
0.08338980376720428,
-0.7531276345252991,
0.8509750962257385,
-0.04278828203678131,
0.9252230525016785,
-0.5084578990936279,
-0.13194015622138977,
-0.26137346029281616,
0.4097210168838501,
-0.14088334143161774,
-0.8618512749671936,
0.3568766713142395,
0.16351568698883057,
-0.2525172531604767,
-0.5863767266273499,
0.47886428236961365,
-0.6558839082717896,
-0.15092647075653076,
0.46587133407592773,
0.5266799926757812,
0.32854294776916504,
0.0069405571557581425,
-0.6377813220024109,
-0.2128223180770874,
-0.11255479604005814,
0.05804712697863579,
0.20520098507404327,
0.3288448452949524,
-0.19381722807884216,
0.3289763331413269,
0.3487169146537781,
0.11898154020309448,
0.34961915016174316,
0.0657687559723854,
0.9006748795509338,
-0.6343224048614502,
-0.45433858036994934,
-0.4011116921901703,
0.25341084599494934,
-0.2599220871925354,
-0.11361946165561676,
0.7132517695426941,
0.5831618905067444,
0.7222343683242798,
-0.16706985235214233,
0.9507526755332947,
-0.09947885572910309,
0.3024572432041168,
-0.6682668924331665,
0.8543708920478821,
-0.5846529006958008,
0.14876973628997803,
0.11579586565494537,
-0.7760012149810791,
-0.17387256026268005,
0.38101083040237427,
-0.43397849798202515,
-0.43221357464790344,
0.6399387121200562,
0.5650742053985596,
-0.44047826528549194,
-0.3853074908256531,
0.3815598487854004,
0.1749567836523056,
0.178221195936203,
0.5042353868484497,
0.7028732895851135,
-0.5629698038101196,
0.6395933628082275,
-0.44788113236427307,
-0.2539782226085663,
-0.4534895718097687,
-0.5461415648460388,
-0.5501991510391235,
-0.6792876720428467,
-0.1526963710784912,
-0.21960009634494781,
0.21092283725738525,
0.9718179702758789,
0.698824942111969,
-0.9840407967567444,
-0.2898767292499542,
-0.1766800582408905,
-0.23225976526737213,
-0.12210879474878311,
-0.24165812134742737,
0.20645034313201904,
-0.6282680034637451,
-1.267337679862976,
0.731727659702301,
0.3375576436519623,
0.28836140036582947,
-0.2657679319381714,
-0.0002373219031142071,
-0.324331670999527,
0.2640789747238159,
0.6283470988273621,
0.23434537649154663,
-0.8029149174690247,
-0.3029090166091919,
-0.06447795778512955,
-0.5562559962272644,
0.26250380277633667,
0.46493950486183167,
-0.6973713636398315,
0.41811996698379517,
0.3964332640171051,
0.6301894783973694,
0.7544213533401489,
0.03134723752737045,
0.7466762065887451,
-0.9162407517433167,
0.22979314625263214,
0.5344341993331909,
0.3636559844017029,
0.5639681220054626,
-0.4610554277896881,
0.6581565737724304,
-0.06850378960371017,
-0.41959473490715027,
-0.6455835700035095,
0.05594230443239212,
-1.091970682144165,
-0.09531135857105255,
1.0264815092086792,
-0.36987200379371643,
-0.3471940755844116,
0.009549364447593689,
0.0445941798388958,
0.35948681831359863,
-0.5568397641181946,
0.8227325081825256,
0.6176393032073975,
-0.2563135623931885,
0.03517981618642807,
-0.5964376926422119,
0.6888102293014526,
0.4427795112133026,
-1.109952688217163,
0.20292630791664124,
0.5420702695846558,
-0.04533529281616211,
0.5330848097801208,
0.6215212345123291,
0.014156559482216835,
0.25483134388923645,
-0.011499390937387943,
0.3340395987033844,
0.22200925648212433,
-0.234437957406044,
-0.39812639355659485,
-0.1214912086725235,
-0.00944532174617052,
-0.18814879655838013
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08187v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08187v1
|
Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) for the Diagnosis of pronunciation of Speech Sound Disorders in Korean children
| 2024-03-13T02:20:05 | 2024-03-13T02:20:05 |
Taekyung Ahn, Yeonjung Hong, Younggon Im, Do Hyung Kim, Dayoung Kang, Joo Won Jeong, Jae Won Kim, Min Jung Kim, Ah-ra Cho, Dae-Hyun Jang, Hosung Nam
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS, I.2.7
|
This study presents a model of automatic speech recognition (ASR) designed to
diagnose pronunciation issues in children with speech sound disorders (SSDs) to
replace manual transcriptions in clinical procedures. Since ASR models trained
for general purposes primarily predict input speech into real words, employing
a well-known high-performance ASR model for evaluating pronunciation in
children with SSDs is impractical. We fine-tuned the wav2vec 2.0 XLS-R model to
recognize speech as pronounced rather than as existing words. The model was
fine-tuned with a speech dataset from 137 children with inadequate speech
production pronouncing 73 Korean words selected for actual clinical diagnosis.
The model's predictions of the pronunciations of the words matched the human
annotations with about 90% accuracy. While the model still requires improvement
in recognizing unclear pronunciation, this study demonstrates that ASR models
can streamline complex pronunciation error diagnostic procedures in clinical
fields.
|
[
0.07702065259218216,
-0.27215033769607544,
0.21334798634052277,
0.05698255077004433,
-0.2682414650917053,
0.11900141835212708,
-0.10400643199682236,
-0.5104703307151794,
-0.07297684252262115,
0.5083475708961487,
-0.33514901995658875,
-0.35042378306388855,
-0.7184526920318604,
0.11058348417282104,
-0.3836285471916199,
0.47711217403411865,
-0.08986137807369232,
0.657809853553772,
0.1641222983598709,
-0.014897664077579975,
-0.4460371732711792,
-0.25896745920181274,
-1.2333641052246094,
-0.4097122251987457,
0.11290621757507324,
0.5542262196540833,
0.7127439975738525,
1.1472724676132202,
0.5780932307243347,
0.3566839396953583,
-0.2853007912635803,
-0.06707914173603058,
-0.2072003334760666,
0.2634313106536865,
0.0874180719256401,
0.040010035037994385,
-0.564356803894043,
-0.09452162683010101,
0.5399033427238464,
0.9364007711410522,
-0.24470631778240204,
-0.0339445099234581,
0.050617821514606476,
0.5501953363418579,
-0.07623176276683807,
-0.007650664076209068,
-0.22171980142593384,
0.3030953109264374,
-0.0661257728934288,
0.023354241624474525,
-0.031173555180430412,
-0.265953004360199,
0.34833434224128723,
-0.5764656066894531,
0.5402891635894775,
-0.28795069456100464,
0.614793598651886,
0.5098217725753784,
-0.4008104205131531,
-0.7280357480049133,
-1.0899075269699097,
0.40438568592071533,
-0.5299455523490906,
0.6819404363632202,
0.5576971173286438,
0.485259473323822,
-0.032210879027843475,
-0.5225825309753418,
-0.4917011260986328,
-0.20851561427116394,
0.14996932446956635,
0.14059828221797943,
-0.1979469656944275,
0.3539249897003174,
0.3812246322631836,
0.11778639256954193,
-0.9717702269554138,
0.24661089479923248,
-0.7392927408218384,
-0.4098304212093353,
0.7131766676902771,
0.1936674416065216,
0.612825870513916,
-0.3193507790565491,
-0.1016746461391449,
-0.0808965265750885,
-0.28406792879104614,
0.3203035593032837,
0.2355155348777771,
0.7656446099281311,
-0.01888243295252323,
0.3961356282234192,
-0.38717105984687805,
0.5376067757606506,
0.2400139421224594,
-0.4284757673740387,
0.3448372185230255,
-0.07826541364192963,
-0.15483024716377258,
0.6354929208755493,
0.5565785765647888,
0.11111975461244583,
0.23699022829532623,
-0.047796763479709625,
-0.39682525396347046,
0.3832970857620239,
0.2206926941871643,
-0.5007917284965515,
-0.6269901990890503,
0.15627217292785645,
-0.7208356857299805,
-0.2069467455148697,
-0.009866022504866123,
-0.44553592801094055,
-0.3995048403739929,
-0.6873627305030823,
0.7952501773834229,
-0.3323709964752197,
-0.42703452706336975,
0.08651313185691833,
-0.3620242178440094,
-0.3217439651489258,
-0.14252124726772308,
-0.6052786111831665,
0.5519111752510071,
0.17316637933254242,
0.40012678503990173,
-0.016576025635004044,
0.10617875307798386,
-0.461404412984848,
-0.025854820385575294,
-0.39419299364089966,
0.872943103313446,
-0.5717974901199341,
-0.9264217615127563,
-0.12436151504516602,
0.16050751507282257,
-0.34503403306007385,
-0.9977739453315735,
0.652604341506958,
-0.08426835387945175,
-0.41243237257003784,
-0.2210894227027893,
-0.6268703937530518,
0.007598403375595808,
-0.524664044380188,
-0.4870467483997345,
0.6916689276695251,
0.303567111492157,
-0.11306487768888474,
0.626558780670166,
-0.5279080271720886,
-0.5604429244995117,
0.24999210238456726,
0.0358818843960762,
-0.32487204670906067,
0.0029664631001651287,
0.004401980899274349,
0.24600276350975037,
0.020813781768083572,
0.09898331016302109,
0.16252464056015015,
-0.32781338691711426,
0.06651479005813599,
-0.4547993838787079,
0.5328739285469055,
0.5037587285041809,
0.017910506576299667,
0.06938696652650833,
-1.1237716674804688,
0.5199046730995178,
-0.09754014015197754,
-0.4831872582435608,
-0.19083115458488464,
-0.0916450172662735,
0.08528608083724976,
0.2687819302082062,
0.08432802557945251,
-0.4684480130672455,
-0.1294931024312973,
-0.5848087668418884,
0.31575942039489746,
-0.007335782982409,
0.04820358008146286,
0.1839422583580017,
-0.3106246590614319,
0.6303071975708008,
0.151447132229805,
0.15209604799747467,
0.023528102785348892,
-0.4277687668800354,
-0.6647168397903442,
-0.4550696015357971,
0.4602656066417694,
0.7226759791374207,
-0.5065528750419617,
0.4176473617553711,
-0.06846511363983154,
-0.4382089674472809,
-0.9659563899040222,
-0.12132994830608368,
0.7742464542388916,
0.7590555548667908,
0.3779573440551758,
-0.16670852899551392,
-1.0247403383255005,
-0.7053783535957336,
-0.22343340516090393,
-0.1854047030210495,
-0.19074377417564392,
0.43070217967033386,
0.15278251469135284,
-0.4552667438983917,
0.4720221161842346,
-0.014747126959264278,
-0.5001753568649292,
-0.0056704930029809475,
0.16203418374061584,
-0.11212294548749924,
0.4654560089111328,
-0.0974072590470314,
-0.6766992807388306,
-0.6765757203102112,
0.12532645463943481,
-0.5362420082092285,
-0.35981157422065735,
0.5841529965400696,
0.6016607880592346,
0.19601655006408691,
0.7817254066467285,
-0.40633660554885864,
0.579194962978363,
0.3955652415752411,
-0.5473682284355164,
0.5441252589225769,
-0.38534924387931824,
0.2251322716474533,
-0.47668883204460144,
-0.09140864759683609,
-0.14982537925243378,
-0.2760249376296997,
-0.8189404010772705,
-0.3665444254875183,
0.05563588812947273,
-0.3421876132488251,
-0.15566101670265198,
0.28491848707199097,
-0.32852092385292053,
-0.045574843883514404,
-0.4702307879924774,
0.17867223918437958,
0.0014667910290881991,
-0.3624826967716217,
0.06917820125818253,
0.662452220916748,
0.7042283415794373,
-0.8260553479194641,
0.5437356233596802,
0.12659481167793274,
-0.09856097400188446,
0.6157740354537964,
-0.8165491819381714,
0.04341976344585419,
0.04415089264512062,
0.05938980355858803,
-1.0476258993148804,
-0.41569700837135315,
0.14949461817741394,
-0.8438869714736938,
0.723414957523346,
-0.2431531399488449,
-0.0849367082118988,
-0.8115066289901733,
0.3751107156276703,
0.323713093996048,
0.499335378408432,
-0.6010433435440063,
0.433959424495697,
0.6714674234390259,
-0.44325539469718933,
-0.16679541766643524,
-0.36923643946647644,
-0.1220938190817833,
-0.16072873771190643,
-0.5114473104476929,
0.3752218782901764,
0.1438581645488739,
-0.19768409430980682,
0.08209273219108582,
-0.2112802267074585,
-0.5298153162002563,
-0.22434186935424805,
0.2363249659538269,
0.09797947108745575,
-0.5927296280860901,
0.2115582823753357,
0.09949254989624023,
-0.4312363862991333,
-0.2658821940422058,
0.0592447854578495,
0.35941314697265625,
0.0776764377951622,
-0.1311403214931488,
-0.7938164472579956,
0.1551152914762497,
0.4566101133823395,
0.2604554295539856,
-0.04481729120016098,
0.44665348529815674,
-0.8489024043083191,
-0.1036190390586853,
-0.5604240894317627,
-0.03480338305234909,
-0.4988740384578705,
0.35935989022254944,
-0.6278983354568481,
-0.30042868852615356,
0.6625247001647949,
-0.06565462052822113,
-0.7479708790779114,
0.4430307447910309,
0.19495877623558044,
-0.40379661321640015,
1.4231812953948975,
0.31479835510253906,
0.14379557967185974,
-0.07175315171480179,
-0.0036587987560778856,
0.23033127188682556,
-0.9160369038581848,
-0.1778363436460495,
-0.6795231103897095,
-0.04730600491166115,
-0.5187650918960571,
-0.22470378875732422,
0.288368284702301,
0.17799580097198486,
-0.12932467460632324,
0.08201277256011963,
-0.8351368308067322,
0.5046391487121582,
0.32945704460144043,
0.02274424023926258,
0.15432001650333405,
-0.27630940079689026,
-0.17114698886871338,
-0.4289495348930359,
-0.5789955854415894,
-0.680566132068634,
0.9542378783226013,
0.2678961753845215,
0.3645112216472626,
-0.10059495270252228,
0.3977854549884796,
0.4124501049518585,
-0.14363543689250946,
-1.130162239074707,
0.2276526838541031,
-0.8122966885566711,
-0.2926015853881836,
-0.6076218485832214,
-0.24672450125217438,
-0.9926965236663818,
0.07647368311882019,
0.1211467981338501,
-0.6307655572891235,
0.39843812584877014,
0.23018549382686615,
-0.8778590559959412,
-0.109471395611763,
-0.609081506729126,
0.7615772485733032,
-0.16903115808963776,
0.40098774433135986,
-0.12990377843379974,
-0.5862661004066467,
0.21042370796203613,
0.011437855660915375,
0.10787833482027054,
0.07875953614711761,
0.2120131254196167,
0.926155149936676,
-0.5292096138000488,
0.37335479259490967,
-0.645739734172821,
0.17820443212985992,
0.11820469051599503,
-0.127333402633667,
0.33889099955558777,
-0.32470273971557617,
-0.047777026891708374,
-0.020339779555797577,
0.1241263896226883,
0.15933479368686676,
-0.46816474199295044,
0.5551254749298096,
-0.8733962774276733,
-0.09764336049556732,
-0.43282783031463623,
-0.24070484936237335,
-0.4046342372894287,
0.032355256378650665,
0.42898789048194885,
0.6687785983085632,
-0.20854970812797546,
-0.05643504858016968,
0.7728872895240784,
-0.16741611063480377,
0.13426010310649872,
0.7382259368896484,
0.08864683657884598,
-0.4270600378513336,
1.0921645164489746,
0.6649340987205505,
0.07295811921358109,
-0.35400351881980896,
0.2464057058095932,
-0.43861544132232666,
-0.6137502193450928,
-0.4734530746936798,
0.18351560831069946,
-0.6002631783485413,
-0.026616787537932396,
-0.6247549653053284,
-0.7970103621482849,
-0.628883957862854,
-0.09829387068748474,
-0.5690736770629883,
-0.4506078362464905,
-0.5417748093605042,
-0.0650104284286499,
0.3187218904495239,
0.9902656078338623,
-0.43815767765045166,
0.3253825008869171,
-0.5901771783828735,
0.9286995530128479,
0.18932978808879852,
0.366325318813324,
0.013084686361253262,
-1.1486027240753174,
-0.057081595063209534,
0.23793171346187592,
-0.24083642661571503,
-0.502942681312561,
0.8292045593261719,
0.40802109241485596,
0.2499711960554123,
0.5869466662406921,
0.14717592298984528,
1.2492183446884155,
-0.7031548023223877,
0.6843635439872742,
0.05933316424489021,
-0.9116332530975342,
0.6437790989875793,
-0.22225967049598694,
0.06099061667919159,
0.27395129203796387,
0.2629660367965698,
-0.7620269656181335,
-0.25164616107940674,
-0.7309705018997192,
-0.8993242979049683,
0.8270722031593323,
-0.19690236449241638,
-0.3036733865737915,
0.12881380319595337,
0.32870373129844666,
0.17235396802425385,
-0.10373542457818985,
0.167334645986557,
-0.2952865660190582,
-0.17602728307247162,
-0.4915735423564911,
-0.07697799056768417,
-0.4805741310119629,
-0.014919607900083065,
-0.6716486215591431,
0.7850929498672485,
0.23854151368141174,
0.34142136573791504,
0.3885873556137085,
-0.014865219593048096,
-0.6296899318695068,
-0.047533322125673294,
0.4537103474140167,
0.3794780671596527,
0.10458216071128845,
-0.06974481046199799,
0.06456569582223892,
-0.7731159329414368,
0.2560734152793884,
0.45566341280937195,
-0.05529934912919998,
0.30961400270462036,
-0.10823872685432434,
0.9291435480117798,
0.2747802138328552,
-0.6742991805076599,
0.5270152688026428,
-0.24348479509353638,
-0.3979395031929016,
-0.6390235424041748,
0.2531401216983795,
0.10132542997598648,
0.4724496603012085,
0.365048885345459,
0.17707617580890656,
0.4313424527645111,
-0.2675008177757263,
0.36781519651412964,
0.3660919666290283,
-0.757724404335022,
-0.36022239923477173,
0.7620648741722107,
0.1337711215019226,
-0.83174067735672,
0.8011787533760071,
-0.23904648423194885,
-0.6343635320663452,
0.8529403209686279,
0.6988958120346069,
0.6904011368751526,
-0.7406514286994934,
0.19442451000213623,
0.3447805941104889,
0.012143164873123169,
-0.47080162167549133,
0.5318661332130432,
0.15004052221775055,
-0.7315986752510071,
0.10520115494728088,
-0.4270727038383484,
-0.21580542623996735,
0.5234178900718689,
-1.0153330564498901,
0.4914880394935608,
-0.25227102637290955,
-0.374725341796875,
0.3012928366661072,
0.07882986962795258,
-0.45740363001823425,
0.7319391369819641,
0.3458091616630554,
0.1687324196100235,
-0.6920038461685181,
0.7649931311607361,
0.6125527024269104,
-0.15920957922935486,
-0.8819575309753418,
0.06449277698993683,
0.153590589761734,
-0.6120244264602661,
0.7612491250038147,
0.04505771026015282,
-0.18376991152763367,
0.3575502634048462,
-0.18282374739646912,
-1.16824471950531,
0.827463686466217,
-0.0011723601492121816,
-0.6372804045677185,
0.31598854064941406,
0.19462613761425018,
0.7637596726417542,
-0.2564331889152527,
0.06808390468358994,
0.8029151558876038,
0.4194973111152649,
0.10568874329328537,
-1.616509199142456,
-0.229093998670578,
-0.2431069165468216,
0.06862042099237442,
-0.06577404588460922,
-0.18425971269607544,
0.5563626885414124,
-0.46761569380760193,
-0.49210113286972046,
0.2235623002052307,
0.36259764432907104,
0.3998996913433075,
0.7515600323677063,
0.402254194021225,
0.4169518053531647,
1.1340858936309814,
0.045533597469329834,
0.7410862445831299,
-0.38542914390563965,
-0.11637803912162781,
0.7267946004867554,
-0.21819746494293213,
0.870242714881897,
-0.0011468532029539347,
-0.19945238530635834,
-0.2362755835056305,
0.601452648639679,
0.21316438913345337,
0.551832914352417,
0.13941283524036407,
-0.2868174910545349,
-0.02551361173391342,
-0.21654397249221802,
-0.2968887984752655,
0.5858588218688965,
0.8647560477256775,
-0.34249651432037354,
0.3718908727169037,
0.25850674510002136,
-0.08108857274055481,
0.25206926465034485,
-0.4855251610279083,
0.9521879553794861,
0.1515134871006012,
-0.3047879636287689,
0.8221142888069153,
-0.09737368673086166,
0.4832149147987366,
-0.35688072443008423,
0.03212101012468338,
0.33940520882606506,
0.30891677737236023,
-0.24497847259044647,
-0.3277425467967987,
0.4722228944301605,
-0.027625558897852898,
-0.5933107733726501,
0.003710020100697875,
0.8220240473747253,
-0.6514750719070435,
-0.5927114486694336,
0.19785389304161072,
0.24788765609264374,
0.4659823775291443,
0.1674887239933014,
-0.524535596370697,
0.14088645577430725,
-0.19697043299674988,
0.11028920859098434,
0.12130501866340637,
0.535950779914856,
-0.029495969414711,
0.6682419180870056,
0.4904537498950958,
0.562097430229187,
0.1066652312874794,
0.4495280385017395,
0.2851529121398926,
-0.4994909465312958,
-0.35626012086868286,
-0.4275534749031067,
0.433380663394928,
0.16358232498168945,
-0.35256704688072205,
0.2658570408821106,
0.41472959518432617,
0.5917729735374451,
-0.16457499563694,
0.9191384315490723,
0.26935523748397827,
1.353914737701416,
-0.2880989611148834,
1.051831841468811,
-0.49421432614326477,
-0.015597266145050526,
-0.1994120180606842,
-0.25226184725761414,
-0.40543293952941895,
1.0518684387207031,
-0.04232732579112053,
0.11752437055110931,
0.6360344290733337,
0.8622819781303406,
-0.04973572865128517,
0.25648945569992065,
0.5100420117378235,
0.5120717883110046,
-0.09723934531211853,
-0.020912090316414833,
0.6278265118598938,
-0.5498769879341125,
0.33863717317581177,
-0.3177591860294342,
-0.08991649746894836,
-0.4266829490661621,
-0.2083757370710373,
-0.28731319308280945,
-0.5039564371109009,
-0.5750730633735657,
-0.2169003039598465,
0.5764749050140381,
1.0184416770935059,
0.5741177797317505,
-0.9080311059951782,
-0.17852149903774261,
0.051140595227479935,
-0.1351657211780548,
-0.6149775385856628,
-0.25630247592926025,
0.44999390840530396,
-0.06641047447919846,
-0.5759015679359436,
0.9206993579864502,
-0.009691319428384304,
0.2458650916814804,
0.14095379412174225,
-0.1677081435918808,
0.5866813063621521,
-0.030490994453430176,
0.37558430433273315,
0.49710097908973694,
-0.746701717376709,
-0.24329295754432678,
-0.21454869210720062,
-0.23925122618675232,
0.0771498829126358,
0.4966428577899933,
-0.7377748489379883,
0.6714496612548828,
0.23079149425029755,
0.20315678417682648,
-0.08096714317798615,
0.2072087824344635,
0.49573665857315063,
-0.26777273416519165,
-0.08038700371980667,
0.5494150519371033,
0.07648477703332901,
0.4873673915863037,
-0.3902917206287384,
0.2064719796180725,
0.21846383810043335,
-0.6532044410705566,
-1.1632976531982422,
-0.09490679204463959,
-0.580445408821106,
0.1214112937450409,
1.1886074542999268,
0.0181738194078207,
0.07775719463825226,
-0.8785421848297119,
-0.2871749997138977,
0.545058012008667,
-0.5564022660255432,
0.7011561989784241,
0.38214370608329773,
-0.34761810302734375,
0.12995174527168274,
-0.6901021599769592,
0.8573054671287537,
-0.0753791481256485,
0.08542211353778839,
0.016529807820916176,
0.3879634141921997,
0.3979601263999939,
-0.18228663504123688,
0.6043866276741028,
-0.18260395526885986,
0.5061354637145996,
0.2865366041660309,
0.0864986851811409,
0.09654045850038528,
-0.35430988669395447,
-0.6724560856819153,
-0.24716304242610931,
0.08668386936187744,
-0.298152893781662
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08174v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08174v1
|
Rethinking Loss Functions for Fact Verification
| 2024-03-13T01:56:32 | 2024-03-13T01:56:32 |
Yuta Mukobara, Yutaro Shigeto, Masashi Shimbo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We explore loss functions for fact verification in the FEVER shared task.
While the cross-entropy loss is a standard objective for training verdict
predictors, it fails to capture the heterogeneity among the FEVER verdict
classes. In this paper, we develop two task-specific objectives tailored to
FEVER. Experimental results confirm that the proposed objective functions
outperform the standard cross-entropy. Performance is further improved when
these objectives are combined with simple class weighting, which effectively
overcomes the imbalance in the training data. The souce code is available at
https://github.com/yuta-mukobara/RLF-KGAT
|
[
0.02063732221722603,
-0.2529647648334503,
0.6831229329109192,
0.28744858503341675,
-0.29029902815818787,
-0.18029053509235382,
-0.0948626920580864,
-0.2863888740539551,
0.19939300417900085,
0.3040504455566406,
-0.704310953617096,
-0.29352903366088867,
-0.9348737001419067,
0.02353178896009922,
-0.5451179146766663,
1.4121506214141846,
-0.210042342543602,
0.015580819919705391,
-0.7777209281921387,
-0.25517764687538147,
-0.33463042974472046,
-0.5071825981140137,
-0.3145464062690735,
-0.9476248621940613,
0.7171123623847961,
0.6514841914176941,
0.7723602056503296,
0.412857323884964,
0.5171298384666443,
0.12874065339565277,
0.4477994740009308,
0.02346671372652054,
-0.7218459844589233,
0.08172997087240219,
-0.15126696228981018,
-0.8247970342636108,
0.1615883708000183,
0.08985905349254608,
0.34909170866012573,
0.30508357286453247,
-0.22833706438541412,
0.2237614542245865,
0.016811015084385872,
0.570720374584198,
-1.0659034252166748,
0.22070756554603577,
-0.3249313235282898,
0.495400995016098,
-0.2230641096830368,
-0.5047237277030945,
-0.5044063925743103,
-0.2595895826816559,
0.22336465120315552,
-0.4301799237728119,
0.4881974458694458,
0.1332017481327057,
0.9996751546859741,
0.5189334154129028,
-0.6294198036193848,
-0.06514821946620941,
-0.7409653663635254,
0.8445794582366943,
-0.13731373846530914,
0.657443642616272,
0.27195653319358826,
0.10253843665122986,
-0.03760974854230881,
-0.5692199468612671,
-0.3090354800224304,
0.021321354433894157,
-0.12672927975654602,
0.14274628460407257,
-0.04709729924798012,
-0.23610098659992218,
-0.01235897745937109,
0.3224712908267975,
-0.30772361159324646,
-0.6892250180244446,
-0.29359710216522217,
-0.5874857306480408,
0.9646968245506287,
0.4053574800491333,
0.2405831217765808,
0.13338474929332733,
-0.46676698327064514,
0.08378476649522781,
-0.6369669437408447,
0.250835120677948,
0.09847249835729599,
0.22064842283725739,
-0.3841569721698761,
0.4654037356376648,
-0.22150097787380219,
0.5424138307571411,
0.16318386793136597,
-0.4718857407569885,
0.38146117329597473,
-0.20734646916389465,
-0.20587031543254852,
0.3603324294090271,
0.2182459533214569,
0.7395537495613098,
-0.07875865697860718,
-0.3427366316318512,
-0.2173040360212326,
-0.497487872838974,
0.07940524071455002,
-0.9084709286689758,
-0.30793890357017517,
-0.015200864523649216,
-0.6518499851226807,
-0.42637187242507935,
-0.022549651563167572,
-0.47259843349456787,
-0.7847257256507874,
-0.2662336230278015,
0.8171432018280029,
-0.4131937623023987,
-0.14707393944263458,
0.23846228420734406,
-0.564119279384613,
0.13784515857696533,
0.32134661078453064,
-0.47449055314064026,
0.20341047644615173,
0.6038350462913513,
0.7975645661354065,
-0.07855338603258133,
-0.31444817781448364,
-0.8004743456840515,
-0.20068518817424774,
0.010099181905388832,
0.7188296318054199,
-0.744775652885437,
-0.17943134903907776,
-0.06605049222707748,
-0.32181093096733093,
-0.38273361325263977,
-0.20133765041828156,
0.6103699803352356,
-0.3998621702194214,
0.17715072631835938,
-0.6177127361297607,
-0.36310452222824097,
-0.45024389028549194,
0.24142226576805115,
-0.28671467304229736,
0.7127575278282166,
-0.021969905123114586,
-1.256640911102295,
0.7148060202598572,
-0.21480946242809296,
-0.8927860856056213,
-0.34422850608825684,
-0.05832093954086304,
-0.9313728213310242,
0.19549991190433502,
-0.15876196324825287,
0.5756640434265137,
-0.547362208366394,
0.2895162105560303,
-0.4946819841861725,
-0.5352292656898499,
0.20575067400932312,
-0.05336447060108185,
0.7360267639160156,
0.43377721309661865,
-0.4491591453552246,
0.10673654079437256,
-0.6938662528991699,
0.0011367467232048512,
0.10652977228164673,
-0.4482528567314148,
-0.4209620952606201,
0.16670122742652893,
-0.08839214593172073,
-0.3417414426803589,
-0.09759450703859329,
-0.8666825890541077,
0.08108397573232651,
-0.002967746462672949,
0.013918940909206867,
0.22422659397125244,
0.018017956987023354,
0.205412819981575,
-0.6967159509658813,
0.38526949286460876,
0.024027429521083832,
0.3291763365268707,
0.5558702349662781,
-0.4392538070678711,
-0.5106884837150574,
-0.6354227662086487,
0.4199029207229614,
0.802591860294342,
-0.8328343033790588,
0.0685238242149353,
0.16104213893413544,
-0.6866177916526794,
-0.22190049290657043,
-0.12941521406173706,
0.267423540353775,
0.39468351006507874,
0.3637659549713135,
-0.0778549313545227,
-0.9982967972755432,
-0.7060759663581848,
-0.5755672454833984,
-0.07581114023923874,
0.22696296870708466,
0.031742941588163376,
0.38317322731018066,
-0.38081124424934387,
0.9000348448753357,
-0.5378778576850891,
-0.32560762763023376,
-0.5293483138084412,
0.15077917277812958,
0.30567145347595215,
0.47452160716056824,
0.6978516578674316,
-0.8820232152938843,
-0.314346581697464,
-0.20227870345115662,
-0.773098886013031,
-0.26129916310310364,
-0.035514649003744125,
0.24941383302211761,
0.17885522544384003,
0.40877172350883484,
-0.35113513469696045,
0.9276320934295654,
0.48995235562324524,
-0.5600911974906921,
0.5137566328048706,
0.05316071957349777,
0.5053406953811646,
-0.449874609708786,
-0.10134050250053406,
0.021032612770795822,
-0.40043628215789795,
-0.7207832932472229,
0.0032021033111959696,
-0.004213633947074413,
0.13768433034420013,
-0.4865855276584625,
0.2364131212234497,
-0.2268953025341034,
0.0843590721487999,
-0.35837677121162415,
-0.5421756505966187,
0.05481379106640816,
0.2978008985519409,
0.031933046877384186,
0.31596750020980835,
0.9408798813819885,
-0.7601698637008667,
0.44973522424697876,
-0.31249839067459106,
-0.04060724377632141,
0.5559191107749939,
-0.6776903867721558,
-0.3419610559940338,
-0.4533088803291321,
0.24763990938663483,
-0.6134923696517944,
-0.12234935164451599,
0.7642025947570801,
-0.42498263716697693,
0.383683443069458,
-0.13496887683868408,
0.002801518188789487,
-0.13519808650016785,
-0.4536580443382263,
0.62281334400177,
0.360969603061676,
-0.3225729167461395,
0.9300440549850464,
0.33887791633605957,
0.37507620453834534,
-0.8999265432357788,
-0.6786904335021973,
-0.24694043397903442,
-0.36228299140930176,
-0.6200666427612305,
0.39862653613090515,
0.04145216569304466,
-0.38771504163742065,
0.08495891094207764,
-0.43897587060928345,
0.11999339610338211,
0.1629687398672104,
0.5348904728889465,
0.03400840237736702,
-0.11562935262918472,
0.34581252932548523,
-0.16611245274543762,
0.1761111170053482,
0.20499427616596222,
-0.28679245710372925,
0.45554542541503906,
-0.13091899454593658,
-0.3262598216533661,
-0.28836750984191895,
0.4264500141143799,
0.1691025346517563,
-0.07749072462320328,
0.8057528734207153,
0.7762049436569214,
-0.4873776137828827,
-0.1104314848780632,
-0.5353491902351379,
-0.15680746734142303,
-0.38646864891052246,
0.3030387759208679,
-0.6679649353027344,
-0.6748653650283813,
0.6802801489830017,
0.3551291227340698,
0.1430341750383377,
0.8189407587051392,
0.644741952419281,
0.019713887944817543,
0.5646705627441406,
0.9895386695861816,
0.17397530376911163,
0.348359078168869,
-0.08479392528533936,
0.22869530320167542,
-0.42062726616859436,
-0.6615074276924133,
-0.5861350893974304,
-0.30319827795028687,
-0.08057496696710587,
-0.44281652569770813,
0.6239222288131714,
-0.1282932311296463,
0.03279184177517891,
-0.025298144668340683,
-0.3748539984226227,
0.40597033500671387,
0.8247899413108826,
0.5210592746734619,
0.06251854449510574,
-0.0672125518321991,
0.0553906075656414,
0.27158817648887634,
-0.9721560478210449,
0.017231734469532967,
1.2731142044067383,
0.33521953225135803,
1.0227599143981934,
-0.12583541870117188,
1.4991415739059448,
0.6174049377441406,
0.482208788394928,
-0.7485295534133911,
0.32976359128952026,
-0.1709921956062317,
-0.7905244827270508,
-0.6577675938606262,
-0.6251243352890015,
-0.8106979131698608,
0.23632830381393433,
-0.27702417969703674,
-0.5284256935119629,
0.5347995162010193,
0.39439335465431213,
-0.4584890305995941,
0.3821749687194824,
-0.5483742952346802,
0.9008969068527222,
0.06467089056968689,
-0.4682294726371765,
-0.4399711489677429,
-0.6323041915893555,
0.6217781901359558,
0.107948437333107,
0.244929239153862,
-0.16819117963314056,
0.17854538559913635,
1.1500167846679688,
-0.7685441374778748,
0.9073742032051086,
-0.40827676653862,
0.09574580937623978,
0.5736085176467896,
-0.15313927829265594,
0.27039679884910583,
0.37361228466033936,
-0.4279312193393707,
0.09535663574934006,
0.4148622751235962,
-0.320099800825119,
-0.2880866229534149,
0.36872947216033936,
-0.8618312478065491,
-0.8013666868209839,
-0.9597588777542114,
-0.5585299134254456,
0.05395786836743355,
0.12477603554725647,
0.6441641449928284,
0.6577997207641602,
0.01901509054005146,
0.31171292066574097,
0.8543835282325745,
-0.09702908247709274,
0.06172133609652519,
0.44087499380111694,
-0.11858536303043365,
-0.18061749637126923,
1.0145503282546997,
0.013536425307393074,
-0.02476499229669571,
0.5863763689994812,
0.6456835269927979,
-0.011158034205436707,
-0.6194101572036743,
-0.3014567792415619,
0.0066175321117043495,
-0.8751155734062195,
-0.5953608751296997,
-0.64739590883255,
-0.1512228399515152,
-0.7542243003845215,
0.13721689581871033,
-0.18818175792694092,
-0.21074368059635162,
-0.14549115300178528,
0.14791527390480042,
0.4246915578842163,
0.46451032161712646,
-0.7366746068000793,
0.0759914368391037,
-0.8326385021209717,
0.35194313526153564,
0.2050757110118866,
0.3206322491168976,
-0.4067167043685913,
-0.6678500771522522,
-0.4285321533679962,
0.16962988674640656,
-0.1279565393924713,
-0.8964529037475586,
0.07553958892822266,
0.5366328954696655,
0.8172565698623657,
0.3060128688812256,
0.6938701272010803,
0.37635648250579834,
-0.0557268001139164,
0.42378470301628113,
0.46782436966896057,
-1.0783641338348389,
0.3036700189113617,
0.2652131915092468,
-0.005526067689061165,
0.5533434748649597,
0.385980486869812,
-0.6370044350624084,
-0.42280423641204834,
-0.4471687972545624,
-0.25888991355895996,
1.0268219709396362,
0.11391002684831619,
-0.2013883888721466,
0.36938753724098206,
0.37369996309280396,
0.2711503505706787,
-0.022026579827070236,
-0.6314255595207214,
-0.5287973880767822,
-0.6122410893440247,
-0.31982898712158203,
-0.048015423119068146,
-0.3376341462135315,
-0.4326830506324768,
-0.35491782426834106,
0.9356409311294556,
-0.03077627345919609,
0.2416519969701767,
0.782541811466217,
-0.05854552611708641,
-0.5458282232284546,
0.062112681567668915,
0.6622496247291565,
0.36930444836616516,
-0.4485844671726227,
0.4451737105846405,
0.19381392002105713,
-0.574671745300293,
0.2801787257194519,
0.18581832945346832,
-0.2153984010219574,
0.06835946440696716,
0.79847651720047,
0.595797598361969,
0.024749837815761566,
-0.451977014541626,
0.7123776078224182,
-0.3601303696632385,
-0.511857807636261,
0.1414494812488556,
0.25755393505096436,
-0.17041662335395813,
0.5404795408248901,
0.339668333530426,
0.4728565216064453,
0.6847232580184937,
-0.9272785186767578,
0.5055792927742004,
0.33021876215934753,
-0.39344486594200134,
-0.17603693902492523,
0.5619018077850342,
0.21178153157234192,
0.08700127899646759,
0.357673704624176,
-0.42452186346054077,
-1.0008379220962524,
0.7309289574623108,
0.32838308811187744,
0.8567150235176086,
-0.10747525840997696,
0.3894153833389282,
0.15886268019676208,
0.323897123336792,
-0.19426047801971436,
0.5640954971313477,
0.053069036453962326,
-0.7349969148635864,
-0.08994004875421524,
-0.6041756868362427,
-0.39466556906700134,
-0.43677449226379395,
-0.48573192954063416,
0.2745555639266968,
-0.33798933029174805,
-0.24148546159267426,
0.1194739118218422,
0.06889553368091583,
-0.8283823728561401,
0.4942052364349365,
0.12755073606967926,
0.6790935397148132,
-1.0445225238800049,
0.7126004695892334,
0.6874375939369202,
-0.27490341663360596,
-0.8392477631568909,
0.1697651743888855,
0.19435922801494598,
-1.0385907888412476,
0.840225338935852,
0.06622524559497833,
-0.17536383867263794,
-0.639417827129364,
-0.5592693090438843,
-1.053856372833252,
0.7540237307548523,
0.3938586115837097,
-0.355150043964386,
0.17087583243846893,
-0.01651259884238243,
0.11222217231988907,
-0.4223651885986328,
-0.1241965964436531,
0.4696562588214874,
0.5901885032653809,
0.6176210641860962,
-0.9326685667037964,
0.22797060012817383,
-0.0026994263753294945,
-0.5512337684631348,
0.2400732934474945,
-0.5775211453437805,
1.032759189605713,
-0.7780359983444214,
-0.22360318899154663,
-0.3237026035785675,
0.8850612044334412,
-0.05533403903245926,
1.3515247106552124,
0.7671141624450684,
0.4587130844593048,
0.7312405109405518,
-0.2596531808376312,
1.1085479259490967,
-0.004736036062240601,
0.4628373682498932,
1.040045976638794,
-0.2385987937450409,
0.29802069067955017,
0.5814126133918762,
-0.07018588483333588,
0.208111971616745,
0.5587127208709717,
-0.030354181304574013,
0.8068246841430664,
0.5806726813316345,
0.003422811394557357,
-0.6703866720199585,
-0.19619034230709076,
-0.45212656259536743,
0.396935373544693,
0.05647160857915878,
-0.12881776690483093,
-0.1759059727191925,
0.32202720642089844,
0.0759897530078888,
-0.21353836357593536,
-0.4500153064727783,
0.3828514814376831,
-0.09901012480258942,
-0.7959592342376709,
0.6894165277481079,
0.1950211226940155,
0.566203773021698,
-0.24987593293190002,
0.16184790432453156,
-0.13994117081165314,
0.34633001685142517,
-0.6481831073760986,
-0.6717361211776733,
0.669939398765564,
-0.40600430965423584,
-0.2624804675579071,
-0.00982619822025299,
1.037290096282959,
-0.4698793590068817,
-0.5446560978889465,
-0.14324474334716797,
0.21939441561698914,
0.1890781670808792,
-0.2610442042350769,
-0.4209999740123749,
0.46770045161247253,
0.3094719350337982,
-0.1252572387456894,
-0.1741069108247757,
0.5331711769104004,
0.07841178774833679,
0.8819366693496704,
0.01113495696336031,
-0.13312263786792755,
0.020645499229431152,
-0.04118833690881729,
0.5179196000099182,
-0.5443597435951233,
-0.22307871282100677,
-0.843599259853363,
0.12064995616674423,
0.0787874087691307,
-0.2577432692050934,
0.6178791522979736,
0.6868199110031128,
0.5875486731529236,
-0.35050687193870544,
0.752543032169342,
-0.47597798705101013,
0.3989942669868469,
-0.537930428981781,
0.6320325136184692,
-0.9219735264778137,
0.08819379657506943,
0.024854334071278572,
-0.42796531319618225,
-0.5308783650398254,
0.3263500928878784,
-0.2320774793624878,
-0.1722460687160492,
0.7533103823661804,
0.6369056701660156,
0.05417395383119583,
0.12325873225927353,
0.3848040699958801,
-0.2431369125843048,
0.2121327966451645,
0.7228775024414062,
0.8301738500595093,
-0.7240259647369385,
0.6347136497497559,
-0.5599021911621094,
-0.5141252875328064,
-0.8287394642829895,
-0.809403121471405,
-1.159897804260254,
-0.5059170722961426,
-1.0080190896987915,
-0.36430805921554565,
0.5109598636627197,
1.142521858215332,
0.9490856528282166,
-0.892673671245575,
-0.03566338121891022,
0.39135000109672546,
0.6367493867874146,
-0.6111623048782349,
-0.1341715008020401,
0.26391318440437317,
-0.43697038292884827,
-0.3636242151260376,
-0.013229956850409508,
0.014430215582251549,
-0.15333643555641174,
0.25559648871421814,
-0.36517471075057983,
-0.2649245858192444,
0.27258649468421936,
0.44652262330055237,
0.2687796652317047,
-0.4725176990032196,
-0.6179063320159912,
-0.29349398612976074,
-0.09036065638065338,
-0.2432762086391449,
1.1126075983047485,
-0.736511766910553,
-0.002702160505577922,
0.8003039956092834,
0.7026543617248535,
0.36762621998786926,
-0.4268420338630676,
0.6695809960365295,
-0.6957445740699768,
-0.21002653241157532,
0.13767023384571075,
0.6134998798370361,
0.08516225963830948,
-0.5714999437332153,
0.565166175365448,
0.6678841710090637,
-0.3446950316429138,
-1.1101213693618774,
0.07248888164758682,
-0.9221525192260742,
-0.20896731317043304,
0.9570814371109009,
-0.1354905068874359,
-0.3747836947441101,
-0.11927755922079086,
-0.08818649500608444,
0.5458102226257324,
-0.43654128909111023,
1.015332818031311,
0.5387370586395264,
-0.26388266682624817,
-0.14874407649040222,
0.15890765190124512,
0.8260458111763,
0.5633766055107117,
-0.5776423215866089,
0.17788879573345184,
0.302742600440979,
0.6006153225898743,
0.2796642482280731,
0.48676827549934387,
0.3225192129611969,
0.6753914952278137,
0.0804489403963089,
0.2136719524860382,
-0.14681968092918396,
-0.5859992504119873,
0.16115137934684753,
0.3981879651546478,
-0.03146471828222275,
-0.38638806343078613
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08167v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08167v2
|
MolBind: Multimodal Alignment of Language, Molecules, and Proteins
| 2024-03-13T01:38:42 | 2024-04-03T01:00:53 |
Teng Xiao, Chao Cui, Huaisheng Zhu, Vasant G. Honavar
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, q-bio.QM
|
Recent advancements in biology and chemistry have leveraged multi-modal
learning, integrating molecules and their natural language descriptions to
enhance drug discovery. However, current pre-training frameworks are limited to
two modalities, and designing a unified network to process different modalities
(e.g., natural language, 2D molecular graphs, 3D molecular conformations, and
3D proteins) remains challenging due to inherent gaps among them. In this work,
we propose MolBind, a framework that trains encoders for multiple modalities
through contrastive learning, mapping all modalities to a shared feature space
for multi-modal semantic alignment. To facilitate effective pre-training of
MolBind on multiple modalities, we also build and collect a high-quality
dataset with four modalities, MolBind-M4, including graph-language,
conformation-language, graph-conformation, and conformation-protein paired
data. MolBind shows superior zero-shot learning performance across a wide range
of tasks, demonstrating its strong capability of capturing the underlying
semantics of multiple modalities.
|
[
-0.22244329750537872,
-0.37193605303764343,
0.12463714182376862,
-0.08897236734628677,
-0.15443088114261627,
0.027145635336637497,
-0.03451205790042877,
-0.17239387333393097,
0.4745243191719055,
0.1493261158466339,
-0.47374606132507324,
-0.40168297290802,
-0.5630623698234558,
0.07239644974470139,
0.12489710003137589,
1.0659171342849731,
-0.11655960232019424,
0.44674861431121826,
-0.21948134899139404,
-0.6115484237670898,
-0.1968034952878952,
-0.05645489692687988,
0.03348616510629654,
-0.4304196238517761,
0.8791465759277344,
0.08348162472248077,
0.47120898962020874,
0.5257763862609863,
0.9128108620643616,
0.24672596156597137,
0.4034651815891266,
0.2574525475502014,
-0.5199782848358154,
0.2308470606803894,
-0.3552434742450714,
-0.2796010375022888,
-0.5757683515548706,
0.004281793255358934,
0.3543964624404907,
0.777914822101593,
0.014532682485878468,
-0.06678922474384308,
-0.17262275516986847,
0.5416701436042786,
-0.9036847949028015,
0.1933339536190033,
-0.3219994604587555,
0.1772780865430832,
-0.48971909284591675,
-0.291617751121521,
0.01994454674422741,
0.06054084748029709,
0.1221129521727562,
-0.936046838760376,
0.25064218044281006,
0.04841535538434982,
1.1105023622512817,
0.3006007969379425,
-1.048439860343933,
-0.30819013714790344,
0.08397990465164185,
0.5667454600334167,
-0.5100310444831848,
0.6787155866622925,
0.0635237768292427,
0.3586167097091675,
-0.1226699948310852,
-0.4124200940132141,
-0.6474565863609314,
0.009975079447031021,
-0.24083906412124634,
0.46608665585517883,
0.4129031002521515,
0.38494977355003357,
-0.08046413958072662,
0.48403429985046387,
-0.817640483379364,
-0.09905027598142624,
-0.5290986895561218,
-0.6316184997558594,
0.08426422625780106,
0.09952770918607712,
0.14094151556491852,
-0.2548154592514038,
-0.5651051998138428,
-0.2190013974905014,
-0.5426800847053528,
-0.27247154712677,
0.21921105682849884,
0.4550826847553253,
-0.10724104940891266,
0.6875561475753784,
-0.013820112682878971,
0.8183936476707458,
0.1595785915851593,
-0.24389635026454926,
0.8123313784599304,
-0.9225607514381409,
-0.3298165798187256,
0.09501913189888,
0.9190122485160828,
0.34370896220207214,
-0.43030285835266113,
0.08920109272003174,
-0.07939401268959045,
0.21695229411125183,
0.029862545430660248,
-1.0315237045288086,
-0.3370903432369232,
0.21583615243434906,
-0.4557126760482788,
-0.17145058512687683,
0.0074797640554606915,
-0.8912060856819153,
-0.6589714288711548,
-0.2588757574558258,
0.6444220542907715,
-0.7864423394203186,
-0.2782277464866638,
0.26893675327301025,
-0.3261018395423889,
0.2565903663635254,
0.10163524746894836,
-1.0685350894927979,
-0.2007369101047516,
0.25745609402656555,
0.734623908996582,
-0.21160347759723663,
-0.38056066632270813,
-0.528198778629303,
0.7533612251281738,
-0.15216423571109772,
0.5575641393661499,
-0.7656630873680115,
-0.26480039954185486,
-0.14118120074272156,
-0.045115627348423004,
-0.23191766440868378,
-0.38953229784965515,
0.08427388966083527,
-0.3753524720668793,
0.30970248579978943,
-0.15826860070228577,
-0.4001750349998474,
-0.32172611355781555,
0.49898257851600647,
-0.684766411781311,
0.32691630721092224,
-0.01212971843779087,
-0.6754231452941895,
0.4906843304634094,
-0.937568724155426,
-0.580805242061615,
-0.05042189359664917,
-0.7680258750915527,
-0.05834196135401726,
0.21144765615463257,
0.23296383023262024,
0.2478172779083252,
-0.16602112352848053,
0.19251824915409088,
-0.1973259449005127,
-0.03473735228180885,
0.23059335350990295,
-0.29776448011398315,
0.6185889840126038,
0.35123106837272644,
-0.07007119059562683,
0.13231681287288666,
-0.7568845748901367,
-0.036803264170885086,
-0.47970375418663025,
-0.5352362394332886,
-0.009445731528103352,
-0.5629905462265015,
0.10227677971124649,
0.29476815462112427,
0.2560241222381592,
-0.5555021166801453,
0.2937479317188263,
-0.2587665319442749,
0.42581403255462646,
0.6588476896286011,
-0.09579788893461227,
0.5917375683784485,
-0.20161820948123932,
0.4642193615436554,
0.6642846465110779,
-0.1302860677242279,
-0.45630311965942383,
-0.05545971915125847,
-0.6305476427078247,
-0.6402079463005066,
0.39017805457115173,
0.23523005843162537,
-0.885920524597168,
0.20814739167690277,
-0.546119213104248,
-0.2628954350948334,
-0.5608770251274109,
0.3580613434314728,
0.6685663461685181,
0.4596560001373291,
0.5056068897247314,
-0.5632301568984985,
-0.38338136672973633,
-1.1048420667648315,
0.09973926842212677,
0.07952679693698883,
0.07474254071712494,
0.3055832087993622,
0.5428861975669861,
-0.8189986944198608,
0.6776032447814941,
-0.308027446269989,
-0.7217379212379456,
0.06272347271442413,
0.40993672609329224,
0.18409106135368347,
0.6879860758781433,
0.34026017785072327,
-1.0069562196731567,
-0.2703910171985626,
0.34548303484916687,
-0.867293119430542,
-0.044678185135126114,
-0.12327950447797775,
-0.517341673374176,
-0.13352841138839722,
0.4887460470199585,
-0.38861143589019775,
0.004042497836053371,
0.8165491819381714,
-0.111301489174366,
0.11541727185249329,
-0.08899369090795517,
0.4533008933067322,
-1.3053309917449951,
0.26300325989723206,
-0.06552539765834808,
0.055847346782684326,
-0.44846513867378235,
-0.12144658714532852,
0.2080514132976532,
-0.24985848367214203,
-0.43821981549263,
0.4946941137313843,
-0.7089211940765381,
0.29323267936706543,
0.04239622503519058,
-0.024419264867901802,
0.3661506474018097,
0.6490356922149658,
-0.12814787030220032,
0.6948424577713013,
0.6410399079322815,
-0.41691386699676514,
0.35926225781440735,
0.4396046996116638,
-0.1301129162311554,
0.8917350769042969,
-0.3553706109523773,
-0.2837429642677307,
-0.14657734334468842,
0.19889973104000092,
-0.726707935333252,
-0.6565963625907898,
0.3373262882232666,
-0.41530218720436096,
0.5836828947067261,
0.179977685213089,
0.005220837891101837,
0.11518712341785431,
-0.41692230105400085,
0.8297899961471558,
-0.10453660786151886,
-0.2949707806110382,
1.1126056909561157,
0.3679278492927551,
0.24694566428661346,
-0.7382240891456604,
-0.7914907932281494,
-0.22198334336280823,
0.1766311079263687,
-0.5648350715637207,
0.39799779653549194,
-0.03798647224903107,
0.2138063758611679,
0.06353794783353806,
-0.41207894682884216,
-0.21812960505485535,
-0.35481879115104675,
0.5571924448013306,
0.08115999400615692,
-0.3267911374568939,
0.4118575155735016,
-0.0719640925526619,
-0.211317241191864,
-0.5017486214637756,
-0.3033474385738373,
0.400987446308136,
-0.23586928844451904,
-0.5757678151130676,
-0.10992681980133057,
0.3515360355377197,
0.6313570737838745,
-0.4394550919532776,
0.5455270409584045,
0.6533592343330383,
-0.15717025101184845,
0.32177677750587463,
-0.2559261918067932,
-0.11262495070695877,
-0.47449225187301636,
0.5243062376976013,
-0.4011986553668976,
-0.7476323246955872,
0.16689136624336243,
-0.15481746196746826,
-0.13554447889328003,
0.05747739225625992,
0.46036985516548157,
-0.134159654378891,
0.8481162786483765,
0.7625681161880493,
0.20535939931869507,
0.49277353286743164,
-0.1517036110162735,
0.5833582282066345,
-0.8965519070625305,
-0.46801266074180603,
-0.01436995156109333,
-0.6729505062103271,
-0.2192048728466034,
-0.6641230583190918,
0.48848822712898254,
0.12757624685764313,
-0.2613048255443573,
0.31531134247779846,
-0.27502545714378357,
0.5480598211288452,
0.5135038495063782,
0.21738947927951813,
-0.06873157620429993,
0.139942929148674,
-0.4049616754055023,
-0.15966905653476715,
-0.4332650303840637,
-0.10502439737319946,
1.101532220840454,
-0.16420194506645203,
1.0442839860916138,
0.3653143048286438,
0.5421972870826721,
-0.04680190235376358,
0.19680437445640564,
-0.6306303143501282,
0.40361231565475464,
-0.03740330785512924,
-0.83000648021698,
0.002943541621789336,
-0.4604066014289856,
-0.8108803629875183,
0.4492710530757904,
-0.5852822661399841,
-0.17092320322990417,
0.5919649600982666,
0.21575327217578888,
-0.33563271164894104,
0.02201991342008114,
-0.7385402321815491,
1.0899055004119873,
-0.617588460445404,
-0.4371511936187744,
-0.15793265402317047,
-0.9948389530181885,
0.27814731001853943,
-0.15008731186389923,
0.09078580886125565,
-0.1641278862953186,
-0.22970275580883026,
0.5303635597229004,
-0.20375864207744598,
0.7274541854858398,
-0.008587602525949478,
0.06265507638454437,
-0.2517468333244324,
0.21435177326202393,
-0.2942611873149872,
-0.11328436434268951,
0.08634490519762039,
0.1724310964345932,
0.05600380152463913,
-0.6129577159881592,
-0.5378908514976501,
0.6584462523460388,
-0.5740288496017456,
-0.27435266971588135,
-0.5415592789649963,
-0.7664497494697571,
-0.3029487431049347,
0.544008195400238,
0.3958677053451538,
0.7545486092567444,
-0.015846600756049156,
0.4942626655101776,
0.6312943696975708,
-0.058711834251880646,
0.13947291672229767,
0.42936721444129944,
-0.22172139585018158,
-0.7040265798568726,
1.199404239654541,
-0.030688868835568428,
0.31235453486442566,
0.7973925471305847,
-0.05326472222805023,
-0.1183803379535675,
-0.4215530455112457,
-0.1790565550327301,
0.36142468452453613,
-0.7504907250404358,
-0.46417391300201416,
-0.5758535861968994,
-0.005270970985293388,
-0.6242946982383728,
-0.5315032005310059,
-0.31211575865745544,
-0.24388596415519714,
0.05551193282008171,
-0.1754627227783203,
-0.00297391414642334,
0.13533486425876617,
-0.4071659743785858,
0.10989587754011154,
-0.9606161117553711,
0.4961189031600952,
0.27704209089279175,
0.23520180583000183,
-0.5287498235702515,
-0.1241699680685997,
-0.42878592014312744,
0.27463075518608093,
-0.42992544174194336,
-0.7126591205596924,
0.23536063730716705,
0.7183035612106323,
0.7104869484901428,
0.7640273571014404,
-0.263192743062973,
0.7819859385490417,
-0.3069336414337158,
0.6820005774497986,
0.7944873571395874,
-0.7126280069351196,
0.5315433144569397,
-0.28105953335762024,
0.37328672409057617,
0.8642419576644897,
0.5760323405265808,
-0.5725820064544678,
-0.01821470633149147,
-0.08387023955583572,
-0.8575447797775269,
0.21791595220565796,
-0.0645543560385704,
-0.057857852429151535,
-0.052585817873477936,
-0.13690489530563354,
0.5130664110183716,
0.6303060054779053,
-0.8029333353042603,
-0.07250966131687164,
-0.7185318470001221,
-0.6913427114486694,
-0.06391901522874832,
0.055645909160375595,
-0.7264087200164795,
-0.174066424369812,
0.596520721912384,
-0.4999723732471466,
0.27639079093933105,
-0.08143220096826553,
-0.5901380181312561,
0.24362169206142426,
0.2412724643945694,
0.6015208959579468,
0.5495401620864868,
-0.28363218903541565,
0.5562691688537598,
-0.3881210684776306,
-0.5251713991165161,
0.2541615962982178,
0.09036000072956085,
0.18132072687149048,
-0.2686934769153595,
0.5284174084663391,
0.829529345035553,
0.21194103360176086,
-0.9049525856971741,
0.6985332369804382,
0.18855337798595428,
-0.1852579265832901,
0.3622712790966034,
0.025993572548031807,
-0.011780211701989174,
0.31360331177711487,
-0.09918226301670074,
0.3691871166229248,
0.14574724435806274,
-0.6227822303771973,
0.14844219386577606,
0.40186071395874023,
-0.5324631929397583,
-0.4305708110332489,
0.6159529089927673,
0.4534483253955841,
0.11248856037855148,
0.569903552532196,
0.052363596856594086,
-0.3727276027202606,
0.2217080146074295,
0.41611358523368835,
0.6304286122322083,
-0.06438087671995163,
0.1296912431716919,
0.22255657613277435,
-0.08721697330474854,
0.3579302132129669,
0.0754285603761673,
-0.1605377495288849,
-0.9660950303077698,
0.1514759510755539,
-0.6776960492134094,
-0.140056312084198,
-0.2565270960330963,
-0.5635950565338135,
0.3008812963962555,
-0.2684919834136963,
-0.09019044786691666,
0.1324901431798935,
-0.2669137716293335,
-0.6042780876159668,
-0.07138685137033463,
0.11834852397441864,
0.6187913417816162,
-0.7927713394165039,
0.8381802439689636,
0.8606083989143372,
-0.9469303488731384,
-0.31244030594825745,
-0.21175788342952728,
0.34366390109062195,
-0.719854474067688,
0.9034213423728943,
0.5270678400993347,
-0.35912445187568665,
-0.2687259614467621,
-0.479425311088562,
-0.7812386155128479,
1.2277848720550537,
0.2842646837234497,
-0.49181067943573,
0.056565020233392715,
0.00887025985866785,
0.4309157729148865,
-0.4683307409286499,
0.19730564951896667,
0.2688361704349518,
0.4447841942310333,
0.1775309443473816,
-0.7777273654937744,
-0.14413702487945557,
-0.6393735408782959,
-0.16093844175338745,
0.366333931684494,
-0.5563542246818542,
1.0276577472686768,
0.010732618160545826,
-0.256175696849823,
-0.280241996049881,
0.4686431586742401,
0.1401919275522232,
0.009167962707579136,
0.16391649842262268,
0.5969290137290955,
0.7551076412200928,
-0.06872522830963135,
0.659355103969574,
-0.2766416370868683,
-0.034219756722450256,
1.0018385648727417,
-0.5356892943382263,
0.5015963315963745,
0.8529619574546814,
0.1919538527727127,
0.42989081144332886,
0.42506837844848633,
-0.10477268695831299,
0.9191445708274841,
0.035515196621418,
-0.2336297184228897,
-0.3842253088951111,
-0.25838521122932434,
-0.5599964261054993,
0.3218633532524109,
0.519819438457489,
-0.006980137899518013,
-0.4349926710128784,
0.517827033996582,
-0.37025579810142517,
-0.07750799506902695,
-0.1003180593252182,
0.5495237708091736,
-0.1799883097410202,
-0.07899545133113861,
0.40964773297309875,
-0.38637635111808777,
0.9301614761352539,
-0.9560989141464233,
-0.12312236428260803,
-0.2923349142074585,
0.2590811550617218,
-0.2621099352836609,
-0.4640442728996277,
-0.19961853325366974,
-0.7337396144866943,
-0.3368016481399536,
-0.06502531468868256,
0.26020047068595886,
-0.736017107963562,
-0.22520677745342255,
0.2872098982334137,
0.3219476640224457,
-0.030505044385790825,
0.42877528071403503,
-0.5343155860900879,
0.023683082312345505,
0.0394795760512352,
-0.06941954046487808,
0.4489971995353699,
0.6063565015792847,
0.26315683126449585,
0.5729801058769226,
0.4419880211353302,
-0.06487342715263367,
0.14315038919448853,
-0.1751069277524948,
0.9902623891830444,
-0.6886202692985535,
-0.17103512585163116,
-0.5076950192451477,
0.49705904722213745,
-0.1723027527332306,
-0.43741005659103394,
0.5642721652984619,
0.8679381012916565,
0.97803795337677,
-0.0565447174012661,
0.6677614450454712,
-0.24598848819732666,
0.11197546869516373,
-0.6398438811302185,
0.434520423412323,
-0.7758904099464417,
-0.006913569290190935,
0.2983013093471527,
-0.7771092057228088,
-0.4350723326206207,
0.7691978216171265,
0.0644216313958168,
-0.10703432559967041,
0.9623582363128662,
1.394696831703186,
-0.3590216338634491,
-0.22068621218204498,
0.2618914842605591,
0.19010905921459198,
0.6293092966079712,
0.7558417320251465,
0.518556535243988,
-0.46538227796554565,
0.6031759977340698,
-0.0309648085385561,
-0.15050889551639557,
-0.3473260700702667,
-0.8987367153167725,
-0.8098535537719727,
-0.6652352809906006,
-0.19014416635036469,
-0.2481202781200409,
-0.10941917449235916,
1.073811650276184,
0.8121146559715271,
-0.9854474067687988,
-0.2058788239955902,
0.17759712040424347,
-0.23489119112491608,
-0.14104235172271729,
-0.14000627398490906,
0.22502155601978302,
-0.36250773072242737,
-0.6425268650054932,
0.5694336295127869,
0.7230430841445923,
0.13919292390346527,
-0.11379905045032501,
-0.2665712535381317,
-0.5624462366104126,
-0.0876501053571701,
0.2872960567474365,
0.4559847116470337,
-0.5347640514373779,
-0.11060165613889694,
-0.05801650136709213,
-0.564203143119812,
0.24542416632175446,
1.0174989700317383,
-0.6059837937355042,
0.9755114912986755,
0.6709802746772766,
0.825412929058075,
0.327574223279953,
-0.2306360900402069,
0.8978300094604492,
-0.6316129565238953,
0.37604328989982605,
0.2683326005935669,
0.43195202946662903,
0.33791857957839966,
0.024624649435281754,
0.6023032665252686,
0.24655787646770477,
-0.39834555983543396,
-0.6604140400886536,
0.41892877221107483,
-1.2677806615829468,
-0.3632621169090271,
0.8862835168838501,
0.16920939087867737,
-0.2660452425479889,
-0.08883034437894821,
-0.3492164611816406,
0.17837904393672943,
-0.3472321629524231,
0.40553948283195496,
0.6244775652885437,
-0.22789596021175385,
0.11070497334003448,
-0.3101036846637726,
0.35974371433258057,
0.3658902049064636,
-0.5778263211250305,
-0.18472354114055634,
0.9420512318611145,
0.0669161006808281,
0.5121782422065735,
0.629719614982605,
-0.2584286332130432,
0.11486183851957321,
0.21580643951892853,
0.23456844687461853,
-0.41327160596847534,
-0.4698810279369354,
-0.3125598430633545,
0.2456253170967102,
-0.41947370767593384,
-0.32563650608062744
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08140v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08140v2
|
BAGEL: Bootstrapping Agents by Guiding Exploration with Language
| 2024-03-12T23:59:15 | 2024-06-09T01:12:26 |
Shikhar Murty, Christopher Manning, Peter Shaw, Mandar Joshi, Kenton Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Following natural language instructions by executing actions in digital
environments (e.g. web-browsers and REST APIs) is a challenging task for
language model (LM) agents. Unfortunately, LM agents often fail to generalize
to new environments without human demonstrations. This work presents BAGEL, a
method for bootstrapping LM agents without human supervision. BAGEL converts a
seed set of randomly explored trajectories or synthetic instructions, into
demonstrations, via round-trips between two noisy LM components: an LM labeler
which converts a trajectory into a synthetic instruction, and a zero-shot LM
agent which maps the synthetic instruction into a refined trajectory. By
performing these round-trips iteratively, BAGEL quickly converts the initial
distribution of trajectories towards those that are well-described by natural
language. We use BAGEL demonstrations to adapt a zero shot LM agent at test
time via in-context learning over retrieved demonstrations, and find
improvements of over 2-13% absolute on ToolQA and MiniWob++, with up to 13x
reduction in execution failures.
|
[
-0.2410789579153061,
-0.7254481911659241,
0.6106991171836853,
0.169378861784935,
0.3211827576160431,
0.4211931824684143,
-0.36836645007133484,
-0.40056827664375305,
0.13173992931842804,
0.28342223167419434,
-0.6447545289993286,
-0.6448141932487488,
-0.274532675743103,
-0.24887622892856598,
-0.5624918341636658,
1.198646068572998,
-0.16299471259117126,
-0.13195811212062836,
-0.112233966588974,
0.3984580636024475,
-0.29256317019462585,
-0.12247245758771896,
-0.6894224286079407,
-0.4317936301231384,
0.6069402694702148,
0.4375440180301666,
0.47344526648521423,
0.42483606934547424,
-0.06263036280870438,
0.27191516757011414,
0.28723207116127014,
0.1818317174911499,
-0.4609387218952179,
0.11379136890172958,
-0.29968202114105225,
-0.47490057349205017,
-0.1066511869430542,
-0.066456638276577,
0.42821550369262695,
0.8208840489387512,
-0.1381770521402359,
0.11768689006567001,
-0.02848079800605774,
0.5488722920417786,
-0.7396766543388367,
0.2120540291070938,
-0.37785986065864563,
-0.12042400985956192,
0.18869967758655548,
-0.2842671573162079,
-0.5262505412101746,
-0.35964351892471313,
0.002907412126660347,
-0.8308536410331726,
0.3490256667137146,
0.33417636156082153,
0.7493108510971069,
-0.06547027826309204,
-0.16998068988323212,
-0.6402543187141418,
-1.1190489530563354,
0.8339753150939941,
-0.3896370232105255,
0.14719213545322418,
0.6079572439193726,
0.6765260100364685,
-0.4261802136898041,
-0.6975390911102295,
-0.5663402080535889,
-0.3482823967933655,
-0.1985873132944107,
-0.28461411595344543,
-0.11683621257543564,
-0.12708450853824615,
0.08906646072864532,
-0.16699744760990143,
-0.5525989532470703,
0.04710732027888298,
-0.4493753910064697,
-0.31913745403289795,
0.7080371975898743,
0.005470454227179289,
0.37063682079315186,
0.22738035023212433,
-0.40315377712249756,
-0.6896364092826843,
-0.5497726798057556,
0.3466373383998871,
0.28271183371543884,
0.5134376883506775,
-0.1877603381872177,
0.0662556141614914,
-0.18891307711601257,
0.7930354475975037,
0.050561387091875076,
-0.01725604757666588,
0.12892785668373108,
-0.12321612983942032,
-0.092039555311203,
0.1803521066904068,
0.5778502821922302,
0.2687910199165344,
0.17676019668579102,
-0.42997467517852783,
-0.5527506470680237,
-0.2062603086233139,
0.4810900390148163,
-0.8233217597007751,
-0.38829755783081055,
0.3038017749786377,
0.03456888347864151,
-0.3694424629211426,
-0.05945412069559097,
-0.9243179559707642,
-0.5454659461975098,
-0.03553535416722298,
0.6212433576583862,
-0.4724849760532379,
-0.03205885738134384,
0.0702044889330864,
-0.2897581458091736,
0.48674476146698,
0.37547844648361206,
-0.9769768118858337,
0.7171949148178101,
0.5432311296463013,
0.8791942596435547,
0.16267529129981995,
-0.2388194501399994,
-0.7712144255638123,
0.36674636602401733,
-0.6023845076560974,
1.033176064491272,
-0.6179138422012329,
-0.44040408730506897,
0.2457098811864853,
0.1071084663271904,
-0.06607939302921295,
-0.40963584184646606,
0.3856007158756256,
-0.3270638883113861,
0.282819539308548,
-0.11343586444854736,
-0.46827152371406555,
-0.4099777638912201,
0.3899516463279724,
-0.32578375935554504,
0.7500999569892883,
0.1428699791431427,
-0.11835426837205887,
0.1813926100730896,
-1.1390867233276367,
-0.6306303143501282,
0.1157858669757843,
-0.299913227558136,
0.05324915796518326,
-0.12160897254943848,
0.4476955235004425,
0.333513081073761,
0.1671494096517563,
-0.23168820142745972,
-0.03908606618642807,
-0.6818251609802246,
0.13150626420974731,
-0.04534177482128143,
0.592246949672699,
-0.12665146589279175,
-0.5320562720298767,
0.2060975879430771,
-0.7849184274673462,
0.15992502868175507,
0.4415596127510071,
-0.20920602977275848,
-0.42644691467285156,
0.12853001058101654,
0.2517288625240326,
-0.03947688266634941,
-0.09974750131368637,
-0.33983924984931946,
0.7592545747756958,
-0.641968309879303,
0.14229002594947815,
0.8605033755302429,
0.0984422117471695,
0.8726277947425842,
-0.5940021276473999,
0.771996021270752,
-0.36968040466308594,
-0.09467189759016037,
-0.5890620946884155,
-0.3387848734855652,
-1.0034945011138916,
-0.1122099757194519,
0.2807775139808655,
0.45665115118026733,
-0.7418966889381409,
0.1736152321100235,
-0.3394003212451935,
-0.43538203835487366,
-0.6804631948471069,
0.18602746725082397,
0.17158903181552887,
0.1473679542541504,
0.3436901867389679,
0.07800562679767609,
-0.3587181270122528,
-0.8121237754821777,
-0.07226400822401047,
-0.132953479886055,
-0.4430100917816162,
-0.07683439552783966,
0.4033223092556,
-0.2624552845954895,
0.738743007183075,
-0.2820972800254822,
-0.0980108305811882,
-0.44070082902908325,
0.5448321104049683,
-0.06751827150583267,
0.4817556142807007,
0.5168218612670898,
-0.3625577986240387,
-0.4636724293231964,
0.16888836026191711,
-0.32016119360923767,
-0.24279208481311798,
-0.5496688485145569,
-0.17586390674114227,
0.16115249693393707,
0.2678549587726593,
-0.42320019006729126,
0.530468761920929,
0.42172732949256897,
-0.11625315248966217,
0.45095062255859375,
-0.17058603465557098,
0.11200210452079773,
-0.7165402770042419,
-0.05323851853609085,
-0.12714903056621552,
-0.6083426475524902,
-0.7688129544258118,
0.2123338133096695,
0.05533211678266525,
-0.06887076795101166,
-0.39243873953819275,
0.928535521030426,
-0.612855851650238,
-0.04892534390091896,
-0.5194608569145203,
0.3587700426578522,
0.0822094976902008,
0.6545098423957825,
0.07125471532344818,
0.7321286201477051,
0.7261580228805542,
-0.8368101119995117,
0.2610526382923126,
-0.08090833574533463,
-0.20296591520309448,
0.26525208353996277,
-0.4399629533290863,
0.528691291809082,
-0.10696359723806381,
0.3140610456466675,
-0.8853784799575806,
-0.07097649574279785,
0.5079182982444763,
-0.3473588526248932,
0.2939976751804352,
-0.15114961564540863,
-0.5839424133300781,
-0.077195905148983,
-0.4708501696586609,
0.018145836889743805,
0.6729095578193665,
-0.49442344903945923,
0.41753339767456055,
-0.11580691486597061,
0.15278148651123047,
-0.2817685306072235,
-0.5324104428291321,
0.1095450296998024,
0.02867610566318035,
-0.2870703339576721,
0.26242613792419434,
-0.3629228472709656,
-0.36737632751464844,
-0.20516625046730042,
0.0024102162569761276,
0.05039995163679123,
-0.008495700545608997,
0.3583469092845917,
-0.0802273228764534,
0.04305030032992363,
0.2635272145271301,
-0.06097349151968956,
0.09904412925243378,
0.06617658585309982,
-0.3412986397743225,
0.7574238181114197,
-0.11880490183830261,
-0.3725806176662445,
-0.5170519948005676,
0.4013785421848297,
0.32792332768440247,
0.1595875471830368,
0.6101511716842651,
0.7151772379875183,
-0.49015969038009644,
-0.6571858525276184,
-0.2760995626449585,
-0.5204549431800842,
-0.54637610912323,
0.06258104741573334,
-0.27116355299949646,
-0.2937677502632141,
0.2529968023300171,
-0.21147520840168,
0.23707939684391022,
-0.1512581706047058,
0.26416662335395813,
-0.4647130072116852,
0.6650971174240112,
0.8061205744743347,
0.029478153213858604,
0.24516889452934265,
-0.37734249234199524,
0.3914090096950531,
-0.33652716875076294,
-0.17663884162902832,
-0.39450064301490784,
-0.780925452709198,
-0.37015530467033386,
-0.4730341136455536,
0.3340584933757782,
-0.00463394820690155,
0.022718288004398346,
0.40985041856765747,
-0.2963530123233795,
0.6853910684585571,
0.6303021907806396,
-0.13216152787208557,
0.17092552781105042,
0.13170641660690308,
-0.2454022914171219,
0.18279409408569336,
-0.7355789542198181,
-0.7173068523406982,
0.9457221627235413,
0.1499260663986206,
0.8845444917678833,
0.03447609767317772,
0.9071075320243835,
0.5962342023849487,
0.390818327665329,
-0.7540403604507446,
0.6454987525939941,
0.67755526304245,
-0.5652463436126709,
-0.30188268423080444,
-0.11599383503198624,
-1.0145424604415894,
-0.034390706568956375,
-0.0477372445166111,
-1.0973302125930786,
-0.11540506035089493,
0.20316308736801147,
-0.386344850063324,
0.21775822341442108,
-0.8238220810890198,
0.8416876792907715,
-0.3708588480949402,
-0.43190163373947144,
-0.10120334476232529,
-0.4942897856235504,
0.1475464552640915,
0.159462571144104,
0.6248306035995483,
0.15601646900177002,
-0.1265629380941391,
0.5253977179527283,
-0.2368411123752594,
1.0412780046463013,
-0.24741417169570923,
-0.3375532031059265,
0.23977555334568024,
0.6466143727302551,
0.8458200693130493,
-0.30806586146354675,
0.22263631224632263,
-0.1763879954814911,
0.09973052144050598,
-0.6756203770637512,
-1.1628440618515015,
0.6951092481613159,
-0.43633171916007996,
-0.5517327785491943,
-0.3430594503879547,
-0.5191020369529724,
-0.24311229586601257,
-0.01787145622074604,
-0.13154861330986023,
0.22004608809947968,
-0.1624167412519455,
-0.08583453297615051,
0.1345311999320984,
-0.17839238047599792,
0.841526210308075,
0.7147194743156433,
-0.8334389925003052,
0.14821259677410126,
0.8780291080474854,
-0.16401232779026031,
0.3928363621234894,
0.5740566849708557,
0.18992352485656738,
-0.19809767603874207,
-0.35568180680274963,
-0.685222864151001,
-0.1007365956902504,
-0.6312461495399475,
0.12821322679519653,
-0.44881683588027954,
-0.056297287344932556,
-0.3300917446613312,
-0.5380305051803589,
-0.4480516016483307,
-0.4687631130218506,
0.10182344913482666,
-0.1310349851846695,
0.10251305252313614,
0.7849244475364685,
-0.02113584242761135,
0.5365675687789917,
-0.6015238165855408,
-0.12157335132360458,
0.1902109980583191,
-0.09556359052658081,
0.04921705648303032,
-0.395516037940979,
-0.4030626118183136,
0.17148907482624054,
-0.4512949585914612,
-1.0547187328338623,
0.3867757320404053,
0.10722498595714569,
0.3484482765197754,
0.5883294939994812,
0.1601668745279312,
0.8042199015617371,
-0.521774411201477,
0.7547866702079773,
-0.07034900784492493,
-0.8533250093460083,
0.7499000430107117,
-0.39491507411003113,
0.3381344974040985,
0.2592442035675049,
0.5745834708213806,
-0.6727581024169922,
-0.4148273468017578,
-0.3819783627986908,
-0.6124584078788757,
0.47510117292404175,
0.2712923288345337,
0.25258809328079224,
0.23284852504730225,
0.02464146725833416,
0.21114251017570496,
0.19401521980762482,
-0.8683598637580872,
-0.027399398386478424,
0.0003981849586125463,
0.041251085698604584,
-0.027451124042272568,
0.2098124921321869,
-0.3435584008693695,
-0.324099063873291,
0.7959182262420654,
-0.20586135983467102,
0.30277109146118164,
0.06677226722240448,
-0.318481981754303,
-0.15245507657527924,
0.47336268424987793,
0.864130437374115,
0.7248218655586243,
-0.26280397176742554,
0.3534509241580963,
-0.006175112910568714,
0.025350788608193398,
0.2445642650127411,
-0.049730535596609116,
-0.39463940262794495,
0.035873692482709885,
0.5714856386184692,
0.7237737774848938,
0.41615378856658936,
-0.983351469039917,
0.5313199758529663,
0.020260434597730637,
-0.016228007152676582,
-0.4418187439441681,
0.2319057285785675,
0.16551117599010468,
0.20622071623802185,
0.4811655879020691,
-0.04945801943540573,
0.07095719873905182,
-0.6370179057121277,
0.22494389116764069,
0.3232327401638031,
-0.37606915831565857,
-0.4808119833469391,
0.31220442056655884,
0.19656416773796082,
-0.9176748394966125,
0.18640075623989105,
-0.8506798148155212,
-0.2924860119819641,
0.2657338082790375,
0.6997261643409729,
0.9509714245796204,
-0.11283370107412338,
0.49892616271972656,
0.22676371037960052,
0.6731650233268738,
0.21835577487945557,
-0.18435561656951904,
-0.37460362911224365,
-0.6243880391120911,
-0.14409585297107697,
-0.5825499296188354,
-0.25983917713165283,
0.2855722904205322,
-0.3135782778263092,
0.24110007286071777,
-0.5881384015083313,
0.3274945616722107,
-0.2855665981769562,
-0.18276941776275635,
-0.6944109201431274,
-0.22334074974060059,
0.14912745356559753,
0.7731020450592041,
-0.7413000464439392,
0.6984996199607849,
0.7967870831489563,
-0.4342552423477173,
-0.4957411587238312,
0.4603078365325928,
0.05437174439430237,
-0.8649731874465942,
0.4843268394470215,
0.3388153314590454,
-0.3905784487724304,
-0.08101358264684677,
-0.7810809016227722,
-0.31343507766723633,
0.9827909469604492,
0.18880793452262878,
-0.6002715826034546,
-0.20946857333183289,
0.10763732343912125,
0.4246315062046051,
-0.43445470929145813,
0.3728332221508026,
0.16984309256076813,
0.5470157265663147,
0.08227191865444183,
-0.6632885336875916,
0.039481859654188156,
-0.07372993975877762,
-0.1806117743253708,
-0.01620379649102688,
-0.4701143801212311,
0.28539586067199707,
-0.30402785539627075,
-0.4695696234703064,
0.0380074679851532,
0.5235171914100647,
-0.028258072212338448,
0.4265629053115845,
0.5412575602531433,
0.09918273240327835,
0.6537741422653198,
0.19250674545764923,
1.1263197660446167,
-0.19286507368087769,
0.18252789974212646,
1.1478625535964966,
-0.3668253421783447,
0.9019600749015808,
0.6792548298835754,
-0.07946252077817917,
1.0041230916976929,
0.49898815155029297,
0.29610881209373474,
0.5191227197647095,
0.45503172278404236,
-0.44079169631004333,
-0.28249436616897583,
-0.051449622958898544,
0.06356240808963776,
0.45733943581581116,
0.3032630980014801,
-0.19326139986515045,
-0.49934741854667664,
0.07962974160909653,
0.16264589130878448,
0.5028513669967651,
-0.14212164282798767,
0.5268771052360535,
-0.17921289801597595,
-0.5189443826675415,
0.8330466747283936,
0.1256878525018692,
0.37907254695892334,
-0.6655715703964233,
-0.43296802043914795,
-0.21413938701152802,
0.060801662504673004,
0.08607834577560425,
-0.28401458263397217,
0.12564796209335327,
-0.0060140169225633144,
0.1165316253900528,
-0.5916587710380554,
0.6730754375457764,
-0.4068993926048279,
-0.7257756590843201,
0.3922576308250427,
0.4288640022277832,
0.3793070614337921,
0.06946148723363876,
-0.35030171275138855,
0.08427908271551132,
-0.09477970749139786,
-0.34034407138824463,
0.3791571855545044,
0.04770604521036148,
0.11984498798847198,
0.9643594026565552,
0.5110313892364502,
0.01524276938289404,
0.12066203355789185,
-0.08915220201015472,
0.737082302570343,
-0.6054282188415527,
-0.3243961036205292,
-0.7852885127067566,
0.568734884262085,
-0.2562844455242157,
0.27976956963539124,
0.5743234157562256,
0.5129517912864685,
1.1061244010925293,
-0.3019182085990906,
0.9117814898490906,
-0.03523080423474312,
0.3382062017917633,
-0.6922794580459595,
0.8353154063224792,
-0.4549635946750641,
0.3743789792060852,
0.1282825917005539,
-0.760517418384552,
-0.012447498738765717,
0.7987346053123474,
-0.24979406595230103,
0.06365814059972763,
0.811660647392273,
1.0718295574188232,
-0.32249051332473755,
-0.2314012050628662,
0.461254358291626,
0.08033759891986847,
0.49555107951164246,
0.6261702179908752,
0.7431988716125488,
-0.33285048604011536,
0.6212782859802246,
-0.3553319275379181,
-0.2405761182308197,
-0.015087252482771873,
-0.8781346678733826,
-1.076219081878662,
-0.5719680190086365,
-0.3042353689670563,
-0.08832669258117676,
0.2979956865310669,
1.2251988649368286,
1.0883911848068237,
-0.8657066226005554,
-0.5361508727073669,
-0.057014863938093185,
0.15842939913272858,
-0.5030615925788879,
-0.31641846895217896,
-0.06277230381965637,
-0.7123121023178101,
-0.9569284319877625,
0.9979448914527893,
0.16348692774772644,
0.033358942717313766,
-0.6147168278694153,
-0.2391759306192398,
-0.2501331865787506,
0.1892029196023941,
0.28657829761505127,
0.46126440167427063,
-0.6853987574577332,
-0.4670576751232147,
-0.10954726487398148,
0.11090588569641113,
0.06506803631782532,
0.8016297817230225,
-0.8881343007087708,
0.5900872349739075,
0.07083569467067719,
0.8669105172157288,
0.6711711287498474,
-0.21119245886802673,
0.7458341121673584,
-1.150368332862854,
0.17124609649181366,
0.19503091275691986,
-0.05360318347811699,
0.33870261907577515,
-0.05997799336910248,
0.3537912368774414,
0.21387675404548645,
-0.40055227279663086,
-0.7635130882263184,
0.2928566038608551,
-0.8557219505310059,
-0.283161461353302,
1.357848882675171,
-0.00943412259221077,
-0.45805254578590393,
0.20624525845050812,
-0.33831164240837097,
-0.06594865024089813,
-0.5910772681236267,
1.0176770687103271,
0.7038467526435852,
-0.08208116888999939,
-0.29427337646484375,
-0.8532909750938416,
0.4212436079978943,
0.1228872612118721,
-0.8404262065887451,
0.056574832648038864,
0.27655091881752014,
0.24876201152801514,
0.32001402974128723,
0.589629054069519,
0.4046207666397095,
-0.06392411142587662,
-0.04788287729024887,
0.39932242035865784,
-0.0028439336456358433,
-0.387909859418869,
-0.16844429075717926,
0.05498873442411423,
0.0013474919833242893,
-0.586406946182251
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08137v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08137v1
|
From Paper to Card: Transforming Design Implications with Generative AI
| 2024-03-12T23:47:28 | 2024-03-12T23:47:28 |
Donghoon Shin, Lucy Lu Wang, Gary Hsieh
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL, H.5.2; I.2.7
|
Communicating design implications is common within the HCI community when
publishing academic papers, yet these papers are rarely read and used by
designers. One solution is to use design cards as a form of translational
resource that communicates valuable insights from papers in a more digestible
and accessible format to assist in design processes. However, creating design
cards can be time-consuming, and authors may lack the resources/know-how to
produce cards. Through an iterative design process, we built a system that
helps create design cards from academic papers using an LLM and text-to-image
model. Our evaluation with designers (N=21) and authors of selected papers
(N=12) revealed that designers perceived the design implications from our
design cards as more inspiring and generative, compared to reading original
paper texts, and the authors viewed our system as an effective way of
communicating their design implications. We also propose future enhancements
for AI-generated design cards.
|
[
-0.18869277834892273,
-0.29771503806114197,
0.741409957408905,
0.15507327020168304,
-0.6565498113632202,
0.026363102719187737,
-0.018688833341002464,
-0.7878501415252686,
0.36677324771881104,
0.18243616819381714,
-0.36400216817855835,
-0.5174042582511902,
-0.5051403045654297,
0.02014857530593872,
-0.30042892694473267,
1.0912330150604248,
-0.44137921929359436,
-0.320444256067276,
-0.727444589138031,
0.22187362611293793,
-0.5354956388473511,
-0.05540021136403084,
-0.6760748028755188,
-0.5068552494049072,
0.696183443069458,
0.4234836995601654,
0.6533172726631165,
0.693794310092926,
0.7230210304260254,
0.2261553853750229,
-0.0006855030078440905,
0.05302465334534645,
-0.23343709111213684,
0.03194066509604454,
-0.013228964991867542,
-0.6142249703407288,
-0.6483554244041443,
0.19792798161506653,
0.3351605534553528,
0.37038493156433105,
0.03944934904575348,
0.39249739050865173,
0.3002946078777313,
0.8367655873298645,
-0.4023335874080658,
0.46627646684646606,
-0.1095806211233139,
0.21644224226474762,
-0.49023252725601196,
-0.52513188123703,
-0.7751923203468323,
-0.25423482060432434,
-0.38259458541870117,
-0.9465538263320923,
-0.021652447059750557,
-0.14089184999465942,
0.6565121412277222,
0.2784608006477356,
0.09208604693412781,
-0.5980392694473267,
-1.1608381271362305,
0.2135738879442215,
-0.5122202038764954,
0.12102748453617096,
-0.08675213158130646,
0.3785400092601776,
-0.10816964507102966,
-0.712348461151123,
-0.6760171055793762,
0.20689424872398376,
-0.3032468855381012,
0.5014529824256897,
-0.05622453615069389,
0.03459431976079941,
0.17959028482437134,
0.35842615365982056,
-0.3341827094554901,
-0.06158751994371414,
-0.2640138566493988,
0.32446616888046265,
1.02918541431427,
0.2268257439136505,
0.32888686656951904,
0.005225908476859331,
0.05530327185988426,
-0.4444308876991272,
-0.48541054129600525,
-0.03576178848743439,
0.40939784049987793,
0.05363893136382103,
-0.38343364000320435,
0.489473432302475,
0.30934542417526245,
0.5970971584320068,
0.09457205981016159,
-0.10266980528831482,
0.14766953885555267,
-0.04485591873526573,
-0.018816381692886353,
-0.13728009164333344,
0.6254376769065857,
0.25860607624053955,
-0.31066831946372986,
-0.29831549525260925,
-0.16739137470722198,
-0.0033420573454350233,
0.5738832950592041,
-0.6626192331314087,
-0.19474729895591736,
0.33491799235343933,
-1.0606642961502075,
-0.28766271471977234,
0.22899828851222992,
-1.048041820526123,
-0.5003902316093445,
-0.6572667360305786,
0.09411969780921936,
0.24071452021598816,
-0.4107896089553833,
-0.30397361516952515,
-0.508637011051178,
0.21021385490894318,
0.6594253182411194,
-0.8365546464920044,
-0.3861568570137024,
0.5168484449386597,
0.5987415909767151,
-0.4612164795398712,
0.11364905536174774,
-0.24289970099925995,
0.5155317187309265,
-0.6204384565353394,
1.0149680376052856,
-0.4014512598514557,
-0.9964434504508972,
0.19440457224845886,
-0.4357784390449524,
0.31186988949775696,
-0.5384930372238159,
0.8622356057167053,
-0.280164510011673,
-0.09346113353967667,
-0.1675870418548584,
-0.14592300355434418,
0.29739028215408325,
0.22667917609214783,
-0.8045619130134583,
0.4082891345024109,
-0.12358537316322327,
-0.6581496000289917,
0.4404769837856293,
-0.9151790142059326,
-0.6540769934654236,
0.45908015966415405,
-0.7384818196296692,
-0.7152071595191956,
0.5949826240539551,
-0.01280816551297903,
0.14696311950683594,
-0.5120488405227661,
0.2806496322154999,
-0.2810696065425873,
-0.21810388565063477,
0.06844078004360199,
-0.2987161874771118,
0.6409994959831238,
0.4278971254825592,
-0.18940414488315582,
0.24161088466644287,
-0.7644428014755249,
0.0749506950378418,
0.13835979998111725,
-0.8592236042022705,
-0.05993298441171646,
0.16804596781730652,
0.4251517951488495,
0.13598597049713135,
0.07740885019302368,
-0.398021936416626,
0.18433983623981476,
0.09504690766334534,
0.3862403333187103,
0.6432106494903564,
-0.2756864130496979,
0.7573357820510864,
-0.6468530297279358,
0.5002584457397461,
-0.18806028366088867,
0.30042076110839844,
-0.26438960433006287,
-0.6372982859611511,
-0.7796759009361267,
-0.06864934414625168,
0.09288834035396576,
0.3296027183532715,
-0.8561197519302368,
0.3002956807613373,
-0.42048540711402893,
-0.6192066669464111,
-0.6061288118362427,
-0.04657014086842537,
0.03503319248557091,
0.3239210247993469,
0.17271947860717773,
-0.13354666531085968,
-0.1458238959312439,
-0.7186771035194397,
-0.1998770534992218,
-0.5406848192214966,
-0.3586709797382355,
0.3975529074668884,
0.46556445956230164,
-0.47971266508102417,
0.5504403710365295,
-0.4200066030025482,
-0.54173743724823,
0.02384834550321102,
0.6434422731399536,
0.1824319064617157,
0.5178868770599365,
0.28985875844955444,
-0.7933164238929749,
-0.6538205742835999,
0.21251550316810608,
-1.0406235456466675,
-0.010387441143393517,
-0.9285658597946167,
-0.41501104831695557,
0.156754732131958,
0.47980085015296936,
-0.6431636810302734,
1.0068682432174683,
0.08881843090057373,
-0.10414359718561172,
0.18546468019485474,
-0.3298163414001465,
0.053222257643938065,
-0.9760497808456421,
0.5077418684959412,
-0.15357504785060883,
0.4413057267665863,
-0.3902098834514618,
0.29154449701309204,
0.015434208326041698,
-0.47347214818000793,
0.0434899665415287,
0.8677461743354797,
-0.6734111309051514,
0.040286194533109665,
-0.33287274837493896,
-0.10068777948617935,
0.44054970145225525,
0.1726069152355194,
0.337088018655777,
0.6785939931869507,
0.0467585027217865,
-0.3372885286808014,
-0.02624364197254181,
0.507610023021698,
-0.17459924519062042,
0.9922677278518677,
-0.652468204498291,
0.2098095417022705,
-0.5898086428642273,
0.16823537647724152,
-0.8886563181877136,
-0.0880417600274086,
0.5086835026741028,
-0.3753242790699005,
0.6047354936599731,
0.1610570251941681,
-0.6975845098495483,
-0.6945995688438416,
-0.12067911773920059,
0.4497493803501129,
0.49417373538017273,
-0.864597499370575,
1.1314036846160889,
0.3568984568119049,
-0.04308495298027992,
0.10989399254322052,
-0.8469938635826111,
0.401197224855423,
-0.24196714162826538,
-0.6282708048820496,
1.0074913501739502,
-0.3773941099643707,
-0.36534467339515686,
0.16731654107570648,
0.14389173686504364,
0.24935756623744965,
-0.05405201390385628,
0.5438448786735535,
0.2941090762615204,
0.000451988133136183,
0.41382211446762085,
0.14726106822490692,
-0.25372514128685,
0.167705237865448,
-0.13489317893981934,
-0.07301869243383408,
0.14906850457191467,
-0.3470994532108307,
-0.7583154439926147,
0.8835327625274658,
0.6075109243392944,
-0.21955041587352753,
0.4288504719734192,
0.45206689834594727,
-0.34434565901756287,
-0.06265862286090851,
-0.4052990674972534,
0.15041501820087433,
-0.424568772315979,
-0.3638158142566681,
-0.6220831274986267,
-0.09564930945634842,
0.4624006748199463,
-0.2435922622680664,
0.5746192932128906,
0.5703677535057068,
0.2575075030326843,
-0.5301929116249084,
0.9219886064529419,
0.7284042835235596,
0.12808293104171753,
0.6527069807052612,
-0.2558152675628662,
0.22400929033756256,
-0.8512460589408875,
-0.5116081833839417,
-0.6712467670440674,
-0.5060837268829346,
-0.5555785298347473,
-0.20922233164310455,
0.41932380199432373,
-0.03226339817047119,
0.03547964245080948,
0.016160273924469948,
-0.8468008041381836,
0.2538517713546753,
0.6504632234573364,
0.21617233753204346,
0.3520427942276001,
0.4375969469547272,
0.3436475396156311,
0.04787074774503708,
-0.5308904051780701,
-0.6514672040939331,
0.8434178233146667,
0.38755080103874207,
1.0546977519989014,
0.04311296343803406,
1.113722801208496,
0.3903502821922302,
1.135288953781128,
-0.6492947340011597,
0.26424640417099,
-0.33247295022010803,
-0.37042921781539917,
-0.04985671490430832,
0.013376275077462196,
-0.737243115901947,
-0.13482466340065002,
-0.6609222292900085,
-0.3401123285293579,
0.49064213037490845,
0.053181201219558716,
-0.2758767902851105,
0.31745877861976624,
-0.5407939553260803,
0.4949829876422882,
-0.5125126242637634,
-0.7496933937072754,
-0.236846923828125,
-0.3746376633644104,
0.07877817004919052,
-0.020857345312833786,
0.21781273186206818,
0.3150947690010071,
0.258745938539505,
0.8053311705589294,
-0.33030086755752563,
0.9443476796150208,
0.1742822229862213,
-0.30486205220222473,
0.6954965591430664,
-0.26794567704200745,
0.44428443908691406,
0.17367513477802277,
-0.45567288994789124,
0.27410975098609924,
-0.14519110321998596,
-0.3072472810745239,
-0.6389294266700745,
0.3492380380630493,
-0.786520779132843,
-0.8397301435470581,
-0.21533934772014618,
-0.5037251710891724,
0.27060508728027344,
0.1856655776500702,
0.29509979486465454,
0.15824057161808014,
-0.24371881783008575,
-0.07842780649662018,
0.24412012100219727,
-0.2696557939052582,
0.5144345760345459,
0.04287799447774887,
0.12290265411138535,
-0.37242618203163147,
0.6029132604598999,
-0.12573416531085968,
-0.24777357280254364,
0.5224025845527649,
0.24909691512584686,
-0.4128480553627014,
-0.4872625172138214,
-0.8396209478378296,
0.3065555989742279,
-0.7068767547607422,
-0.11075214296579361,
-0.07938896864652634,
-0.3170829713344574,
-0.45436450839042664,
-0.45648032426834106,
-0.0534922294318676,
0.0014381574001163244,
-0.8207188248634338,
0.21389524638652802,
-0.14643988013267517,
0.9629782438278198,
-0.30513542890548706,
0.36678773164749146,
-0.7174433469772339,
0.06518936902284622,
0.3710276484489441,
0.40860655903816223,
0.03189415484666824,
-0.28298303484916687,
-0.015146350488066673,
0.06885644793510437,
-0.585611879825592,
-0.7875733971595764,
0.16017144918441772,
0.016471588984131813,
0.6703463792800903,
0.6921164989471436,
0.03320825845003128,
0.6884265542030334,
-0.4938182532787323,
0.3278397023677826,
0.4241598844528198,
-0.5666928291320801,
0.7440349459648132,
-0.43052607774734497,
0.28364506363868713,
0.47045791149139404,
0.3038736581802368,
-0.3978082835674286,
0.105157770216465,
-0.784585177898407,
-0.551405131816864,
0.1812986582517624,
0.0586090125143528,
0.31076014041900635,
0.02609463967382908,
0.8689693808555603,
0.19030484557151794,
0.10653581470251083,
-0.5116482377052307,
-0.1651417315006256,
-0.1651068925857544,
-0.16275480389595032,
0.039999306201934814,
-0.5110399127006531,
-0.3504212498664856,
-0.12727844715118408,
0.27941203117370605,
-0.10325981676578522,
0.7413961887359619,
-0.06766774505376816,
0.520663321018219,
-0.15578320622444153,
0.18890692293643951,
0.686998188495636,
0.6175693869590759,
0.2607726454734802,
0.05588173121213913,
-0.5063589811325073,
-0.018705379217863083,
-0.03663283959031105,
0.14843295514583588,
-0.4991251826286316,
-0.0026620980352163315,
0.43732690811157227,
0.6438317894935608,
-0.6147322058677673,
-0.1852065920829773,
0.16663748025894165,
-0.20088417828083038,
-0.31731411814689636,
-0.4003792405128479,
-0.15452875196933746,
0.12390176951885223,
0.16454890370368958,
0.08013994991779327,
0.03935886546969414,
0.09087992459535599,
-0.6739585399627686,
0.16364042460918427,
0.3463023602962494,
0.01774928905069828,
-0.24585244059562683,
1.2208367586135864,
0.7951486706733704,
-0.9261357188224792,
0.7204846739768982,
-0.044503264129161835,
0.12740904092788696,
0.6024577617645264,
0.7571435570716858,
0.9026238918304443,
0.06694287806749344,
0.646658718585968,
0.45261967182159424,
-0.11097806692123413,
0.10166623443365097,
0.17969472706317902,
-0.5128117799758911,
-0.14722250401973724,
-0.0738539919257164,
-0.23244968056678772,
-0.33945149183273315,
0.03606612980365753,
-0.8389407396316528,
0.25301116704940796,
-0.44599881768226624,
-0.333176851272583,
-0.025417517870664597,
-0.27581560611724854,
-0.6475850343704224,
0.17959271371364594,
0.2640050947666168,
0.7051543593406677,
-0.7736133933067322,
0.40934234857559204,
0.8752023577690125,
-0.7694435119628906,
-0.3937217891216278,
0.17958593368530273,
-0.03393852710723877,
-0.6811798214912415,
0.5938334465026855,
-0.00397450989112258,
0.15781773626804352,
-0.2123458981513977,
-0.4054741859436035,
-0.4357092082500458,
1.113219141960144,
-0.09069415181875229,
-0.7178719639778137,
-0.07328449934720993,
0.5211274027824402,
0.820870578289032,
-0.3816739022731781,
0.14254984259605408,
0.15214551985263824,
0.4768528342247009,
0.34174060821533203,
-0.2762937545776367,
0.03200933337211609,
-0.6759994626045227,
0.08525324612855911,
0.08698774874210358,
-0.4426516592502594,
0.5191856026649475,
-0.34447693824768066,
-0.58490389585495,
0.17698557674884796,
0.772066593170166,
0.21066506206989288,
0.518234133720398,
0.11938921362161636,
0.4555530846118927,
0.8581019043922424,
0.07901947945356369,
0.9723221063613892,
-0.19157014787197113,
-0.42251232266426086,
1.0351941585540771,
0.19387362897396088,
0.797184407711029,
0.8564273715019226,
0.12787768244743347,
0.49624502658843994,
0.5974273085594177,
0.028143543750047684,
0.3860573470592499,
0.4454827606678009,
-0.45561325550079346,
-0.2123490273952484,
-0.48777908086776733,
-0.41772910952568054,
0.2675054669380188,
0.6028374433517456,
-0.35065510869026184,
-0.18611660599708557,
0.007557959295809269,
-0.191630020737648,
0.35639530420303345,
-0.160627081990242,
0.7094200849533081,
0.12086479365825653,
-0.8039448857307434,
0.04260101914405823,
-0.13652335107326508,
0.3576717972755432,
0.071942038834095,
-0.46240130066871643,
-0.38291212916374207,
0.230180025100708,
-0.24278156459331512,
-1.0913348197937012,
0.763353168964386,
-0.2423250377178192,
-0.27304404973983765,
-0.7715466022491455,
0.5832818150520325,
-0.16319072246551514,
-0.6815197467803955,
0.11506768316030502,
0.5651106834411621,
0.2172033190727234,
0.19890569150447845,
-0.7469207048416138,
0.4645611345767975,
-0.13534334301948547,
0.2844351828098297,
0.024771282449364662,
0.34161707758903503,
-0.19898435473442078,
0.39928343892097473,
0.34999018907546997,
0.09551424533128738,
-0.4017140567302704,
-0.008073833771049976,
0.6451953649520874,
-0.2591739296913147,
-0.360507607460022,
-0.5456531643867493,
0.8473740220069885,
-0.27812227606773376,
-0.33713892102241516,
0.08114694058895111,
0.5296071171760559,
0.6551858186721802,
-0.19038930535316467,
1.0614197254180908,
-0.18322154879570007,
-0.14712072908878326,
-0.33819544315338135,
0.962995707988739,
-0.7240753769874573,
0.2610408067703247,
-0.13238288462162018,
-0.6599953174591064,
-0.5596709251403809,
0.6173465251922607,
-0.19246765971183777,
-0.20507675409317017,
0.3861761689186096,
0.3920387029647827,
0.28616032004356384,
-0.01160482969135046,
0.15866857767105103,
-0.4460700750350952,
0.8932794332504272,
0.4530894160270691,
0.5581701397895813,
-0.4990294277667999,
0.6039329171180725,
-0.26629284024238586,
-0.28985127806663513,
-0.047802433371543884,
-1.083701491355896,
-1.1818830966949463,
-0.9235756397247314,
-0.534747302532196,
-0.29558855295181274,
-0.041614849120378494,
0.21662965416908264,
0.6094303131103516,
-0.38856226205825806,
-0.23114614188671112,
-0.2534843683242798,
0.1857343167066574,
0.06769295781850815,
-0.1466241180896759,
0.5335759520530701,
-0.025264598429203033,
-0.5568748712539673,
-0.1504756510257721,
0.23139595985412598,
0.45225006341934204,
-0.020967446267604828,
0.014877344481647015,
0.4561678171157837,
-0.22007502615451813,
0.7057390213012695,
0.49880385398864746,
-0.5517554879188538,
-0.20561343431472778,
-0.16956840455532074,
-0.08561477065086365,
0.37105488777160645,
0.9708380699157715,
-0.3861171305179596,
0.460841566324234,
0.764353334903717,
0.9736655354499817,
0.47976022958755493,
0.0473313108086586,
0.6230761408805847,
-0.04917497932910919,
-0.19384190440177917,
-0.06394446641206741,
0.05204456299543381,
0.19996854662895203,
-0.5420806407928467,
0.5962036848068237,
0.07056570798158646,
-0.43759921193122864,
-0.3502935767173767,
0.27059146761894226,
-0.840379536151886,
-0.1678692102432251,
0.9364019632339478,
0.01794012077152729,
-0.37059712409973145,
0.2294027954339981,
-0.27361464500427246,
0.18425773084163666,
-0.21837638318538666,
1.2916781902313232,
0.40420424938201904,
-0.36005568504333496,
-0.14038342237472534,
-0.388130784034729,
0.4680115580558777,
0.010347801260650158,
-1.596069097518921,
-0.06633241474628448,
0.23719124495983124,
-0.23219254612922668,
0.6665152907371521,
0.8484363555908203,
-0.2182018756866455,
0.2273261994123459,
0.38285031914711,
0.3372388482093811,
0.14771081507205963,
-0.46777454018592834,
0.12739267945289612,
-0.1405061036348343,
0.3186524510383606,
-0.247101292014122
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08115v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08115v2
|
Legally Binding but Unfair? Towards Assessing Fairness of Privacy Policies
| 2024-03-12T22:53:32 | 2024-05-08T14:47:39 |
Vincent Freiberger, Erik Buchmann
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL, K.4.m
|
Privacy policies are expected to inform data subjects about their data
protection rights and should explain the data controller's data management
practices. Privacy policies only fulfill their purpose, if they are correctly
interpreted, understood, and trusted by the data subject. This implies that a
privacy policy is written in a fair way, e.g., it does not use polarizing
terms, does not require a certain education, or does not assume a particular
social background. We outline our approach to assessing fairness in privacy
policies. We identify from fundamental legal sources and fairness research, how
the dimensions informational fairness, representational fairness and ethics /
morality are related to privacy policies. We propose options to automatically
assess policies in these fairness dimensions, based on text statistics,
linguistic methods and artificial intelligence. We conduct initial experiments
with German privacy policies to provide evidence that our approach is
applicable. Our experiments indicate that there are issues in all three
dimensions of fairness. This is important, as future privacy policies may be
used in a corpus for legal artificial intelligence models.
|
[
-0.398832768201828,
-0.6022464036941528,
0.7037925124168396,
0.3819151222705841,
-0.06239304319024086,
-0.39685001969337463,
-0.1626964509487152,
-0.4325231909751892,
-0.2599617540836334,
0.456567645072937,
-0.3485443890094757,
-0.4149129390716553,
-0.5761796832084656,
-0.15300162136554718,
-0.05878550931811333,
1.1924878358840942,
0.1759398728609085,
0.6201589107513428,
-0.6041789054870605,
-0.3274397850036621,
-0.34135159850120544,
-0.518388032913208,
-0.31262242794036865,
-0.2010325789451599,
0.30844563245773315,
0.0744110718369484,
1.0791226625442505,
0.6415405869483948,
0.5790110230445862,
0.38030704855918884,
-0.4412110149860382,
-0.5835320353507996,
-0.33862894773483276,
-0.3868376612663269,
-0.5528622269630432,
-0.5452926754951477,
-0.5698263049125671,
0.4601449966430664,
0.5497251152992249,
0.8855533599853516,
-0.33445215225219727,
0.369854211807251,
0.05787082016468048,
0.8299791812896729,
-0.7710473537445068,
-0.08265765756368637,
-0.19112780690193176,
0.6402928829193115,
-0.11259439587593079,
0.01282686460763216,
-0.21926023066043854,
-0.8556327223777771,
-0.09791315346956253,
-0.042973097413778305,
0.25655683875083923,
0.17291845381259918,
0.6156674027442932,
0.24357746541500092,
-0.7601752877235413,
-0.23725968599319458,
-0.5615120530128479,
0.7262214422225952,
-0.5664218068122864,
0.6417965888977051,
0.5483995079994202,
0.47302281856536865,
-0.11643274873495102,
-0.5868197679519653,
-0.6973351836204529,
-0.2642776370048523,
-0.19790376722812653,
0.0607437789440155,
-0.2452903836965561,
0.2523265480995178,
0.76523756980896,
0.24412594735622406,
-0.40200451016426086,
0.20238617062568665,
-0.5008999705314636,
-0.3866320550441742,
0.9140208959579468,
0.07044582068920135,
0.013947893865406513,
-0.20911338925361633,
0.11082145571708679,
0.1523643136024475,
-0.31209397315979004,
0.4280756413936615,
1.2213987112045288,
0.031474966555833817,
-0.19550733268260956,
0.5284345149993896,
-0.14166876673698425,
0.5826967358589172,
0.21500319242477417,
-0.060959767550230026,
0.48562556505203247,
0.02336217276751995,
0.0265307929366827,
0.17211078107357025,
0.5826190114021301,
0.7425614595413208,
0.3025550842285156,
-0.5312994718551636,
-0.15847963094711304,
-0.2015034556388855,
0.2520361840724945,
-0.5072604417800903,
0.3202867805957794,
0.4108503460884094,
-0.9917318820953369,
-0.45853403210639954,
0.41696566343307495,
-0.7828003168106079,
-0.5438574552536011,
-0.42427530884742737,
0.17715786397457123,
0.3642849326133728,
0.10415798425674438,
0.17645995318889618,
-0.1699475646018982,
0.33800971508026123,
0.08239787817001343,
-0.7407329678535461,
0.5216255784034729,
0.6666523814201355,
0.10357970744371414,
0.10848105698823929,
-0.22948043048381805,
-0.49317270517349243,
0.1505003571510315,
-0.09891936182975769,
0.20229698717594147,
-0.43300923705101013,
-0.16519948840141296,
0.20390087366104126,
0.26316362619400024,
0.4642173647880554,
-0.24242377281188965,
0.6645370721817017,
-0.5738247036933899,
0.779564619064331,
-0.37829622626304626,
-0.6655282974243164,
-0.47978612780570984,
0.03927085921168327,
-0.8724233508110046,
0.21184812486171722,
0.04083649441599846,
-0.8465936779975891,
0.8870218992233276,
-0.8299449682235718,
-0.6618114113807678,
-0.16686980426311493,
-0.33230748772621155,
-0.28575751185417175,
0.09870781749486923,
-0.1461854875087738,
0.3659234046936035,
-0.11178088188171387,
0.6935312747955322,
-0.7885473370552063,
-0.020596714690327644,
0.5204195380210876,
-0.6464655995368958,
1.3040779829025269,
0.3438947796821594,
-0.7315694093704224,
-0.21846668422222137,
-0.6610015630722046,
0.188820019364357,
-0.034612733870744705,
-0.04448087140917778,
0.2674497365951538,
0.09024389088153839,
0.07381656765937805,
0.3659956455230713,
0.6213955879211426,
-0.5792936682701111,
-0.24846932291984558,
-0.23218263685703278,
0.23435711860656738,
1.0912681818008423,
-0.4107036888599396,
0.932294487953186,
-0.26417094469070435,
0.5883846879005432,
-0.1323813796043396,
0.702358067035675,
0.7886990308761597,
-0.3260669410228729,
-0.05550319701433182,
0.2440289556980133,
0.7528645992279053,
0.6850118637084961,
0.03578227758407593,
0.6844447255134583,
-0.1945941150188446,
-0.06196749955415726,
-0.5679160952568054,
-0.09314867854118347,
0.36107829213142395,
0.4462578594684601,
-0.14502570033073425,
-0.43562692403793335,
-0.0288506131619215,
-1.1622403860092163,
-0.6186485886573792,
-0.13983482122421265,
0.27856025099754333,
0.6719294786453247,
0.5671406388282776,
0.1358906775712967,
1.1363457441329956,
-0.23337945342063904,
-0.23851117491722107,
0.14944249391555786,
-0.3127007484436035,
0.1367470622062683,
0.3303844630718231,
0.6124491095542908,
-1.375253677368164,
-0.1224687322974205,
-0.10609011352062225,
-1.098839282989502,
-0.06964484602212906,
0.2965524196624756,
0.1076454296708107,
0.26063674688339233,
0.05477285012602806,
-0.19162693619728088,
0.8185685276985168,
0.1313238888978958,
-0.8396875858306885,
-0.06891529262065887,
-0.4039558172225952,
0.4364359676837921,
-0.15837524831295013,
0.03228820487856865,
-0.2087322324514389,
-0.6893338561058044,
-0.4597257971763611,
0.025544073432683945,
0.004990866873413324,
-0.158786803483963,
-0.8348215818405151,
0.6384884119033813,
0.09160592406988144,
-0.5253154039382935,
-0.2900276482105255,
-0.09751381725072861,
-0.0322512723505497,
0.4597155451774597,
-0.4272695481777191,
0.28679248690605164,
0.32407745718955994,
-0.5618107914924622,
0.11143559217453003,
0.050251755863428116,
0.03455290570855141,
1.0200941562652588,
-0.1585635542869568,
0.10878603160381317,
-0.44563642144203186,
0.30474209785461426,
-0.04869770258665085,
-0.23001135885715485,
0.623683750629425,
-0.4773755669593811,
-0.2682274878025055,
-0.06720218062400818,
-0.5261139273643494,
-0.2583359479904175,
-0.2058364450931549,
0.5505161881446838,
0.5406153798103333,
-0.44454425573349,
0.8880655169487,
1.0143415927886963,
0.03312632068991661,
-0.5858139395713806,
-0.7748964428901672,
-0.007228853181004524,
-0.6625739336013794,
-0.512044370174408,
0.30331629514694214,
-0.030182750895619392,
-0.5491960644721985,
0.4205268621444702,
0.05321879684925079,
-0.4462459087371826,
0.19867834448814392,
0.40426111221313477,
-0.18128466606140137,
0.3214036524295807,
-0.3827664852142334,
0.09848032146692276,
-0.2011134922504425,
0.2971983850002289,
-0.19875673949718475,
0.19892455637454987,
-0.38775816559791565,
-0.3533361852169037,
-0.7837612628936768,
0.3382199704647064,
0.1706455498933792,
0.13376924395561218,
0.2844659984111786,
0.32429376244544983,
-0.5475848913192749,
0.28510159254074097,
-0.6369460821151733,
0.1125572919845581,
-0.42117205262184143,
-0.17023450136184692,
-0.20071959495544434,
-0.6317206025123596,
0.8627949953079224,
0.2746630907058716,
0.09157516062259674,
0.40220704674720764,
0.529938817024231,
-0.076945960521698,
1.1783912181854248,
0.9492220878601074,
-0.03418358042836189,
0.20433232188224792,
0.2111590951681137,
0.35408324003219604,
0.04108509421348572,
-0.39456644654273987,
-0.7001992464065552,
-0.36479252576828003,
-1.278582215309143,
0.3544948399066925,
0.07334735989570618,
0.11688388884067535,
-0.3597763478755951,
-0.04534492269158363,
-0.35725247859954834,
0.6267795562744141,
0.6891379356384277,
0.3691627085208893,
0.3652195930480957,
-0.12565378844738007,
0.1734558492898941,
-0.03317873924970627,
-0.47651809453964233,
-0.6329401731491089,
1.1310679912567139,
0.47564008831977844,
0.5710992217063904,
0.22305828332901,
0.7913455367088318,
0.7420852184295654,
-0.011036938056349754,
-0.37252575159072876,
0.5057167410850525,
-0.4048381447792053,
-0.6295198202133179,
-0.1897318959236145,
-0.7472348213195801,
-0.9388154745101929,
-0.11199302226305008,
-0.08801101893186569,
-0.7733408808708191,
0.6084268093109131,
0.2203146368265152,
-0.026141347363591194,
0.20886382460594177,
-0.7907028198242188,
0.846289873123169,
-0.49913498759269714,
-0.5581870675086975,
-0.38339763879776,
-0.8687074184417725,
0.2574726641178131,
0.04831460118293762,
0.5440210103988647,
-0.3232395648956299,
-0.009527506306767464,
0.800423800945282,
-0.435424268245697,
0.40386489033699036,
-0.8012766242027283,
0.03547808900475502,
0.10696991533041,
-0.10772132128477097,
0.11159887909889221,
-0.006161354947835207,
-0.25000110268592834,
0.49165961146354675,
0.2086714804172516,
-0.48715105652809143,
-0.7843034863471985,
0.5832739472389221,
-0.5096395015716553,
-0.25620317459106445,
-0.6282517910003662,
-0.41207435727119446,
-0.08928465843200684,
0.3556140661239624,
-0.06200997158885002,
-0.01269693672657013,
-0.3865495026111603,
-0.017918860539793968,
0.365021675825119,
-0.14037321507930756,
0.15257476270198822,
0.6754158735275269,
-0.2852693796157837,
-0.18803063035011292,
0.9148229956626892,
0.31485024094581604,
-0.24996381998062134,
-0.24363189935684204,
0.3033917248249054,
-0.6346041560173035,
-0.164363831281662,
-0.16869668662548065,
-0.13292253017425537,
-0.9475405812263489,
-0.02053092233836651,
-0.4405567944049835,
-0.05014415085315704,
-0.512529730796814,
-0.08936499804258347,
0.11080854386091232,
-0.7069585919380188,
0.16892336308956146,
-0.024606140330433846,
0.4510557949542999,
0.6657997369766235,
-0.7696874737739563,
0.13621433079242706,
-0.21413972973823547,
0.6851528286933899,
0.06543172895908356,
0.6349349617958069,
-0.37766510248184204,
-0.31588730216026306,
0.35099002718925476,
0.044094279408454895,
-0.15843424201011658,
-0.6934002041816711,
-0.19117504358291626,
-0.14769135415554047,
0.5336394906044006,
0.2446134239435196,
-0.18548116087913513,
0.1567656546831131,
-0.859310507774353,
0.5606520175933838,
0.053330905735492706,
-0.9739266633987427,
0.33171308040618896,
-0.051930978894233704,
-0.372283011674881,
1.0030543804168701,
0.3553611934185028,
-0.2063596546649933,
-0.5353322625160217,
-1.2413718700408936,
-0.5961765050888062,
0.6303724646568298,
0.1914791315793991,
0.24582026898860931,
0.47263479232788086,
0.4746406376361847,
0.16013267636299133,
0.6087242364883423,
-0.9173367619514465,
-0.35945889353752136,
-0.09403946250677109,
-0.3362840414047241,
0.2860254645347595,
0.17598335444927216,
-0.3393573462963104,
-0.15283556282520294,
0.3642330765724182,
0.25421586632728577,
0.15616437792778015,
-0.30484747886657715,
0.042457465082407,
0.20825202763080597,
0.37637951970100403,
0.3032733201980591,
0.9305667877197266,
-0.23046645522117615,
-0.19175726175308228,
0.10018705576658249,
-0.31925007700920105,
0.3229011297225952,
0.545109212398529,
-0.6210653781890869,
-0.09972764551639557,
-0.26937925815582275,
0.3562373220920563,
-0.1669367402791977,
-0.376411110162735,
1.0219483375549316,
-0.44298869371414185,
-0.412691205739975,
-0.48912522196769714,
0.17760595679283142,
-0.434560090303421,
0.17266623675823212,
-0.22316943109035492,
-0.037388574331998825,
0.6758584976196289,
-0.3944339454174042,
0.4389500319957733,
0.33228060603141785,
-0.5201323628425598,
0.1827860325574875,
0.782974123954773,
0.13156253099441528,
-0.5606526136398315,
0.26218315958976746,
-0.5180078744888306,
-0.34053120017051697,
0.5154923796653748,
-0.03922221437096596,
0.625231146812439,
0.10579162836074829,
0.14335298538208008,
-0.2854645252227783,
0.1872103214263916,
-0.1965717375278473,
0.433536171913147,
-0.07839719206094742,
-0.35828134417533875,
-0.028071939945220947,
-0.22515952587127686,
-0.3575997054576874,
-0.33636730909347534,
-1.046230673789978,
0.13863816857337952,
-0.6020102500915527,
-0.3255128562450409,
-0.08208150416612625,
0.22654204070568085,
-1.1223894357681274,
0.3843442499637604,
-0.18939398229122162,
0.7582660913467407,
-0.7934141755104065,
0.2359578162431717,
0.26655563712120056,
-0.42554572224617004,
-0.4014788568019867,
0.12147838622331619,
0.18709008395671844,
-0.8796690702438354,
0.35648226737976074,
0.06171419471502304,
0.049378640949726105,
-0.4442036747932434,
-0.7700582146644592,
-0.2746993899345398,
0.6776419878005981,
0.7659409642219543,
-0.5202741026878357,
0.04728090390563011,
0.6270711421966553,
0.42666420340538025,
0.06933526694774628,
0.11221978068351746,
0.7547721266746521,
0.7470031976699829,
-0.4474300146102905,
-0.9300597310066223,
-0.10150596499443054,
0.04787486791610718,
-0.32624733448028564,
-0.01494080200791359,
-0.5488404631614685,
0.33232465386390686,
-0.06419872492551804,
-0.05805078521370888,
-0.31485515832901,
0.7880794405937195,
0.016528353095054626,
0.745034396648407,
0.6438189148902893,
0.6576986312866211,
1.1051470041275024,
-0.031823545694351196,
1.3203909397125244,
-0.441094309091568,
0.46841347217559814,
1.0400093793869019,
-0.5883532166481018,
0.25195276737213135,
0.4137642979621887,
-0.20093759894371033,
0.2557814121246338,
0.6161932945251465,
-0.2188640981912613,
0.6132319569587708,
0.38913872838020325,
-0.13115452229976654,
0.25873956084251404,
-0.43660691380500793,
-0.31158727407455444,
0.46995124220848083,
-0.17180363833904266,
-0.1974223405122757,
-0.3238992989063263,
0.43239274621009827,
0.03212793916463852,
0.4120026230812073,
-0.5682520270347595,
0.8186442255973816,
0.044146578758955,
-0.4316789507865906,
-0.41782641410827637,
0.45429375767707825,
0.3477700650691986,
-0.20315083861351013,
-0.035126786679029465,
-0.07138221710920334,
0.0707307830452919,
-0.44936829805374146,
-1.228306770324707,
0.2584088444709778,
0.4327106773853302,
-0.28657057881355286,
-0.4105358421802521,
0.5290505886077881,
0.016173232346773148,
-0.35819482803344727,
0.29108014702796936,
0.32693907618522644,
0.40926870703697205,
0.4444800913333893,
-1.228993535041809,
-0.15410877764225006,
-0.0712369903922081,
-0.13260342180728912,
0.3581468462944031,
0.48615720868110657,
-0.16682441532611847,
0.5286431908607483,
0.2897529900074005,
0.17747855186462402,
0.18283769488334656,
0.27969950437545776,
0.38213610649108887,
-0.8555209040641785,
-0.8638014197349548,
-0.6006191968917847,
0.4837763011455536,
-0.24471545219421387,
-0.1644252985715866,
0.5563235878944397,
0.5770136713981628,
0.9126461744308472,
0.6119036078453064,
0.7415726780891418,
-0.44176480174064636,
0.4442357122898102,
-0.8623982071876526,
0.6984719634056091,
-0.45014289021492004,
-0.012599820271134377,
0.14418046176433563,
-1.0151869058609009,
-0.2158135026693344,
0.6826896071434021,
-0.5474250316619873,
0.6493858695030212,
0.25835496187210083,
0.5452134013175964,
-0.08896093815565109,
0.1533605456352234,
0.03520523011684418,
-0.07388444989919662,
0.22456087172031403,
0.20456244051456451,
0.4728666841983795,
-0.42588964104652405,
0.3063816428184509,
-0.4598958492279053,
-0.25828585028648376,
0.35145142674446106,
-1.070023536682129,
-0.5496559143066406,
-0.12958283722400665,
-0.0955270454287529,
-0.6541464328765869,
0.031988345086574554,
0.5743300318717957,
0.5209077596664429,
-0.5902441143989563,
-0.16260991990566254,
0.018495110794901848,
0.4474334716796875,
0.10844344645738602,
-0.31283777952194214,
0.3440885841846466,
-0.08747461438179016,
-0.505466878414154,
-0.19361555576324463,
-0.05855831503868103,
-0.04927757382392883,
-0.19257546961307526,
-0.17452669143676758,
0.3467743992805481,
-0.28567084670066833,
0.1856801062822342,
0.40727943181991577,
-0.34163612127304077,
-0.32000985741615295,
-0.6083788871765137,
-0.336397647857666,
0.12459734827280045,
0.9078647494316101,
-0.3997451961040497,
0.2543465197086334,
0.4929913580417633,
0.598608672618866,
0.09961721301078796,
-0.10745704174041748,
0.44144687056541443,
-0.2058006376028061,
0.4875178337097168,
0.6377477645874023,
0.3109959661960602,
-0.07622473686933517,
-0.5744550228118896,
0.3542291224002838,
-0.27040761709213257,
-0.6732470393180847,
-0.9550142288208008,
0.1535055935382843,
-0.6618496179580688,
-0.2826252579689026,
0.7210724353790283,
0.08076038956642151,
-0.4778723120689392,
-0.17353275418281555,
0.11213624477386475,
-0.2246752232313156,
-0.3287719488143921,
0.8115629553794861,
0.4592626392841339,
-0.10546299815177917,
0.4364888668060303,
-1.0215891599655151,
0.5560442209243774,
0.17969408631324768,
-0.8299919366836548,
-0.11789926141500473,
0.5443045496940613,
0.09567814320325851,
-0.10294273495674133,
0.9222861528396606,
-0.509912371635437,
0.5227181315422058,
-0.5299758315086365,
-0.1486268937587738,
0.3995850384235382,
-0.30934664607048035,
-0.7900675535202026,
0.04306655749678612,
-0.12895983457565308,
0.20498797297477722
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08111v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08111v1
|
AI-Assisted Causal Pathway Diagram for Human-Centered Design
| 2024-03-12T22:36:27 | 2024-03-12T22:36:27 |
Ruican Zhong, Donghoon Shin, Rosemary Meza, Predrag Klasnja, Lucas Colusso, Gary Hsieh
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL, H.5.2; I.2.7
|
This paper explores the integration of causal pathway diagrams (CPD) into
human-centered design (HCD), investigating how these diagrams can enhance the
early stages of the design process. A dedicated CPD plugin for the online
collaborative whiteboard platform Miro was developed to streamline diagram
creation and offer real-time AI-driven guidance. Through a user study with
designers (N=20), we found that CPD's branching and its emphasis on causal
connections supported both divergent and convergent processes during design.
CPD can also facilitate communication among stakeholders. Additionally, we
found our plugin significantly reduces designers' cognitive workload and
increases their creativity during brainstorming, highlighting the implications
of AI-assisted tools in supporting creative work and evidence-based designs.
|
[
-0.6191243529319763,
-0.6098796129226685,
0.7352331876754761,
0.42756175994873047,
-0.7501697540283203,
-0.0034831471275538206,
0.2842775285243988,
-0.6387951374053955,
0.25698336958885193,
0.25605663657188416,
-0.9259778261184692,
-0.5423120856285095,
-0.28929638862609863,
-0.04829610884189606,
0.16954787075519562,
0.6084798574447632,
-0.039881639182567596,
0.2126486897468567,
-0.19545838236808777,
0.19717097282409668,
-0.9531478881835938,
-0.09794091433286667,
-0.9803946018218994,
-0.3157142996788025,
1.0161925554275513,
0.673210620880127,
0.728852391242981,
0.4614320695400238,
0.5958114862442017,
0.16639339923858643,
-0.04224501922726631,
-0.06179267168045044,
-0.14477777481079102,
0.21275390684604645,
-0.20623581111431122,
-0.15295544266700745,
-0.7143775224685669,
0.05139290913939476,
-0.11565890908241272,
0.929979145526886,
-0.15258662402629852,
0.24314633011817932,
0.36617788672447205,
0.9031370282173157,
-0.5506106615066528,
0.42863479256629944,
0.16747890412807465,
0.25833597779273987,
-0.302636057138443,
-0.2061740607023239,
-0.47660136222839355,
-0.29006335139274597,
0.20151035487651825,
-0.9912086129188538,
-0.09088381379842758,
0.03152651712298393,
0.3402845859527588,
0.5314275622367859,
-0.4399842321872711,
-0.3225390613079071,
-0.9242691993713379,
0.2225920557975769,
-0.6202226281166077,
0.2060653418302536,
0.04185597971081734,
0.3875027894973755,
-0.2598436772823334,
-0.6467026472091675,
-0.23725026845932007,
0.11138385534286499,
-0.2961825430393219,
0.037486232817173004,
0.010603869333863258,
0.49023115634918213,
0.392300546169281,
-0.21188004314899445,
-0.5294572710990906,
0.36800694465637207,
-0.45829451084136963,
-0.0884312316775322,
0.9002375602722168,
0.3333989083766937,
0.585771381855011,
-0.09313468635082245,
-0.2937191128730774,
0.024846574291586876,
-0.7743883728981018,
-0.018794341012835503,
0.10726950317621231,
0.15468236804008484,
-0.22101663053035736,
0.4169713258743286,
0.025082705542445183,
0.7263200283050537,
0.019267920404672623,
0.03515084087848663,
-0.13503967225551605,
-0.1704951971769333,
-0.09467887878417969,
0.10197161138057709,
0.6382262110710144,
0.46791812777519226,
0.06773173063993454,
-0.18928781151771545,
0.1986461877822876,
-0.11394797265529633,
0.5939403176307678,
-0.6304313540458679,
-0.5354391932487488,
0.17054827511310577,
-0.6145349144935608,
-0.18771278858184814,
0.23872168362140656,
-0.6001108288764954,
-0.4370739161968231,
-0.9113894104957581,
0.33549490571022034,
-0.018472889438271523,
-0.06082824990153313,
-0.20943796634674072,
-0.44986167550086975,
0.07274259626865387,
0.6200487613677979,
-0.48441624641418457,
0.08427638560533524,
0.7149157524108887,
0.9068846106529236,
-0.17821897566318512,
-0.0768897756934166,
-0.24701428413391113,
0.3046899139881134,
-0.46945613622665405,
0.8333876729011536,
-0.12831853330135345,
-0.6987925171852112,
-0.3294955790042877,
-0.2874763309955597,
0.2744445502758026,
-0.4132026135921478,
0.9482851028442383,
-0.4695740342140198,
0.21884584426879883,
-0.4528909921646118,
-0.3969876766204834,
-0.29460686445236206,
-0.1473502814769745,
-0.8089982271194458,
0.1754412204027176,
0.013656504452228546,
-0.9816761612892151,
0.724619448184967,
-0.9686112999916077,
-0.7200892567634583,
0.27071982622146606,
-0.5782634615898132,
-0.4774138927459717,
-0.022395670413970947,
0.07304207980632782,
0.43217629194259644,
-0.37137946486473083,
0.5005594491958618,
-0.5464113354682922,
-0.4321576654911041,
-0.1900385618209839,
-0.12275152653455734,
1.3163045644760132,
0.3766767978668213,
-0.5603466033935547,
0.6874025464057922,
-0.7868378758430481,
-0.1558275669813156,
-0.09709766507148743,
-0.07549235224723816,
-0.3092455267906189,
0.2149564027786255,
0.18164999783039093,
0.6326430439949036,
-0.19289667904376984,
-0.14872989058494568,
0.19855384528636932,
0.14057466387748718,
0.2403407096862793,
1.1779711246490479,
0.3102620840072632,
0.46936967968940735,
-0.5602781176567078,
0.6051920056343079,
-0.06260378658771515,
0.478630006313324,
-0.056093260645866394,
-1.1703318357467651,
-0.7027240991592407,
-0.23565664887428284,
-0.3466625213623047,
0.3393956422805786,
-0.4909214675426483,
0.9104841947555542,
0.21797172725200653,
-0.5932143330574036,
-0.3958657681941986,
-0.039955031126737595,
0.15285052359104156,
0.7609518766403198,
0.10552288591861725,
-0.5078189969062805,
-0.3246298134326935,
-0.7900429964065552,
0.20684948563575745,
-0.4186173379421234,
-0.4245515763759613,
0.46186563372612,
0.19088956713676453,
-0.2941902279853821,
0.8405137062072754,
-0.7830044627189636,
-0.49719202518463135,
-0.005905881989747286,
0.7051258683204651,
0.16699258983135223,
0.653571605682373,
0.5742062330245972,
-0.7415412664413452,
-0.7759930491447449,
-0.31049397587776184,
-0.726518452167511,
-0.3800092339515686,
-0.49509990215301514,
-0.696520984172821,
-0.09849759191274643,
0.3825867474079132,
-0.654644250869751,
0.8078322410583496,
-0.09795580804347992,
-0.7968723177909851,
0.6117004752159119,
-0.2884403467178345,
0.35960474610328674,
-0.9505866765975952,
0.5430842041969299,
-0.23773087561130524,
0.3568461239337921,
-0.7248673439025879,
-0.020040199160575867,
-0.060629379004240036,
-0.32424506545066833,
-0.49814701080322266,
0.2585415244102478,
-0.20357410609722137,
0.025487145408988,
-0.08420874923467636,
0.11381757259368896,
0.14722104370594025,
0.6753687858581543,
-0.07827705144882202,
0.4797539710998535,
0.5262327790260315,
-0.6375962495803833,
0.06948476284742355,
0.4443473219871521,
0.01889909617602825,
0.9609334468841553,
-0.8238812685012817,
0.23978619277477264,
-0.2908894419670105,
0.2633644640445709,
-0.8647226691246033,
-0.14619043469429016,
0.5105958580970764,
-0.3281737267971039,
0.10021151602268219,
0.08531051874160767,
-0.44510817527770996,
-0.5365574955940247,
-0.3687240481376648,
0.6011923551559448,
0.4110899865627289,
-0.6086862087249756,
0.5503854751586914,
0.3825409710407257,
-0.07659981399774551,
0.16310222446918488,
-0.5697596073150635,
0.02172013372182846,
-0.3545358180999756,
-1.192236304283142,
0.5711134672164917,
-0.5616915225982666,
-0.41448256373405457,
-0.13273712992668152,
0.44124698638916016,
0.004433488007634878,
0.46840018033981323,
0.6720542907714844,
0.5942777991294861,
-0.16037699580192566,
0.011300353333353996,
0.10222761332988739,
-0.351211279630661,
0.4646528661251068,
-0.21987049281597137,
0.320751816034317,
0.4859595000743866,
-0.7601925730705261,
-1.39837646484375,
0.6521365642547607,
1.1644562482833862,
0.10947597771883011,
0.7449156045913696,
0.6272613406181335,
-0.4443505108356476,
0.15013664960861206,
-0.2259124368429184,
-0.05956924706697464,
-0.41977888345718384,
-0.4199543297290802,
0.02923029474914074,
-0.700514554977417,
0.6564579010009766,
-0.13888564705848694,
0.18601419031620026,
0.5363566875457764,
0.39682769775390625,
-0.20837441086769104,
1.395524024963379,
0.7903187274932861,
-0.262930303812027,
0.5351485013961792,
-0.21403059363365173,
0.2231365144252777,
-1.0363221168518066,
-0.4936521649360657,
-0.4758565425872803,
-0.5018948316574097,
-0.45782285928726196,
-0.2043420970439911,
0.5298876762390137,
0.3670875132083893,
-0.6115778088569641,
0.008946161717176437,
-0.8057681918144226,
0.06507690995931625,
0.7146801948547363,
0.18279875814914703,
0.3012302815914154,
-0.4819785952568054,
-0.20866255462169647,
-0.1551085263490677,
-0.8051960468292236,
-0.2525428235530853,
0.8687211275100708,
0.1222185492515564,
0.8282843828201294,
0.034680355340242386,
0.6994492411613464,
0.5532014966011047,
0.7232494354248047,
-0.5961613655090332,
0.2176571637392044,
0.4640760123729706,
-0.619500458240509,
-0.2861877977848053,
-0.020626865327358246,
-0.7813163995742798,
0.06107860431075096,
-0.542595624923706,
-0.7487315535545349,
0.5427970290184021,
0.37732359766960144,
-0.48314425349235535,
0.1409451961517334,
-1.0519074201583862,
0.7517168521881104,
-0.3163549304008484,
-0.7347293496131897,
-0.5899637937545776,
-0.6821545362472534,
0.5762789845466614,
-0.20757177472114563,
0.1683170199394226,
0.09990180283784866,
0.515525221824646,
0.9254538416862488,
-0.6527578234672546,
0.8228674530982971,
-0.10434585809707642,
0.15662781894207,
0.5354506969451904,
0.0033345790579915047,
0.495407372713089,
0.011828488670289516,
0.09474015980958939,
-0.11783129721879959,
-0.5073562264442444,
-0.2983474135398865,
-0.5954126119613647,
0.6161232590675354,
-0.6236602663993835,
-0.7609911561012268,
-0.12687107920646667,
-0.19116830825805664,
0.2020757496356964,
0.34016451239585876,
0.06850317865610123,
0.2017633616924286,
-0.2508888840675354,
-0.05840982496738434,
0.05068977177143097,
-0.19571757316589355,
0.3718099594116211,
0.09064659476280212,
0.09998518973588943,
-0.4033207595348358,
0.3294713497161865,
-0.18304914236068726,
0.2334812581539154,
-0.02148265764117241,
0.27770060300827026,
-0.08122798800468445,
-0.1143050268292427,
-0.48219776153564453,
0.09792865067720413,
-0.6723748445510864,
-0.014106698334217072,
-0.16601696610450745,
-0.22077450156211853,
-0.5143306851387024,
-0.7721035480499268,
-0.03532303869724274,
-0.4720156192779541,
-0.8337299823760986,
-0.10229410231113434,
0.13124831020832062,
1.1398175954818726,
-0.26270604133605957,
-0.04046974331140518,
-0.6241978406906128,
0.27033641934394836,
0.4432218074798584,
0.27630919218063354,
0.5859473347663879,
0.18635761737823486,
-0.25032585859298706,
-0.1565018892288208,
-0.7262367606163025,
-0.8631786704063416,
0.2058035284280777,
-0.3310876190662384,
0.6102756857872009,
1.057175636291504,
0.18314866721630096,
0.7553613781929016,
-0.6500620245933533,
0.6918524503707886,
0.5321803689002991,
-0.5492104291915894,
0.8000783324241638,
-0.38267621397972107,
0.31398633122444153,
0.25457414984703064,
0.7547745704650879,
-0.6501871943473816,
-0.10889388620853424,
-0.7664496898651123,
-0.7722764015197754,
0.4667394757270813,
0.23123016953468323,
-0.6283806562423706,
0.09364638477563858,
0.3955242335796356,
-0.024120911955833435,
-0.2464386224746704,
-0.11029233038425446,
-0.2712007462978363,
0.04748936742544174,
-0.10127027332782745,
0.24109339714050293,
-0.01220250315964222,
-0.3471798300743103,
-0.48497381806373596,
0.34574973583221436,
0.05503126606345177,
0.3066677451133728,
0.366160124540329,
0.2180587351322174,
-0.4226098358631134,
-0.019794438034296036,
0.7264596223831177,
0.880086362361908,
0.007523152511566877,
0.08819395303726196,
-0.29032018780708313,
-0.12324357777833939,
-0.08501371741294861,
0.026639223098754883,
-0.21045657992362976,
-0.44871652126312256,
0.6030946373939514,
0.48443371057510376,
0.05238480120897293,
-0.3357815444469452,
0.2753203809261322,
-0.2851255536079407,
-0.04482497274875641,
-0.004182714503258467,
0.31635862588882446,
0.09015747159719467,
0.5160479545593262,
0.37597978115081787,
0.16773691773414612,
0.4326745569705963,
-0.4077235460281372,
0.6090301871299744,
0.4271993637084961,
-0.39913293719291687,
-0.4053287208080292,
1.3306565284729004,
0.591582179069519,
-1.0586762428283691,
0.766428530216217,
0.030882269144058228,
-0.36497750878334045,
0.7670966386795044,
0.3812270760536194,
1.1198819875717163,
0.1378210335969925,
0.3915258049964905,
0.4556836783885956,
-0.08244795352220535,
0.36694732308387756,
0.04563528671860695,
-0.562971830368042,
-0.08685582876205444,
-0.3355690836906433,
-0.06144047901034355,
-0.5177628397941589,
-0.4385235011577606,
-0.724747896194458,
0.5850760340690613,
-0.546221137046814,
-0.2656327784061432,
-0.062468864023685455,
-0.17741736769676208,
-0.5581357479095459,
0.04265882819890976,
0.22534023225307465,
0.5920358896255493,
-0.7808927893638611,
0.27650827169418335,
0.4444969594478607,
-0.7296791672706604,
-0.6292974352836609,
-0.14346128702163696,
0.44145017862319946,
-0.31986570358276367,
0.7340947389602661,
-0.1284581869840622,
-0.221575528383255,
-0.03483021631836891,
-0.44044017791748047,
-0.5351644158363342,
1.6504640579223633,
-0.050766974687576294,
-0.2599068284034729,
0.057140741497278214,
0.10714849829673767,
0.6354614496231079,
-0.4096808135509491,
0.16141986846923828,
0.06229393184185028,
0.3855535089969635,
0.3112884759902954,
-0.5416385531425476,
0.37489035725593567,
-0.27400532364845276,
-0.1958068609237671,
-0.029486067593097687,
-0.5964590907096863,
0.6757778525352478,
-0.5643300414085388,
-0.4908584654331207,
-0.02655559964478016,
0.5757503509521484,
0.43888387084007263,
0.35524502396583557,
0.43502098321914673,
0.44348400831222534,
0.7065131068229675,
0.26291730999946594,
0.7386220097541809,
-0.5862208008766174,
0.08146145939826965,
0.8568050861358643,
0.24585546553134918,
0.5226796269416809,
0.5618294477462769,
0.1349370926618576,
0.6520941257476807,
0.5677065253257751,
0.3861798942089081,
0.5520890951156616,
0.13800711929798126,
-0.29932257533073425,
-0.10637316852807999,
-0.23968994617462158,
-0.21720153093338013,
-0.32256239652633667,
0.15364862978458405,
-0.19534389674663544,
-0.06375782191753387,
-0.15368196368217468,
-0.06458866596221924,
-0.1528807282447815,
-0.09803088754415512,
0.6108275651931763,
0.13550683856010437,
-0.7546046376228333,
0.1764877438545227,
-0.2606653869152069,
0.24838301539421082,
-0.11785051971673965,
-0.3924437165260315,
-0.20654985308647156,
0.1055871769785881,
-0.14612726867198944,
-0.9163456559181213,
0.4196210205554962,
-0.2777599096298218,
0.2589644193649292,
-0.4722194969654083,
0.6228030920028687,
-0.04518173262476921,
-0.2089419662952423,
0.3598870635032654,
0.4190081059932709,
-0.29179853200912476,
0.013208208605647087,
-0.7324709892272949,
0.03177148476243019,
-0.26107168197631836,
0.1715688556432724,
-0.006543000228703022,
0.5279204249382019,
-0.25133854150772095,
0.8148482441902161,
0.7147604823112488,
-0.3086305558681488,
-0.2729761600494385,
0.41245225071907043,
1.0241130590438843,
-0.7599483728408813,
-0.5816460251808167,
-0.7397948503494263,
0.9842351675033569,
-0.17119888961315155,
-0.3754110336303711,
0.3987126648426056,
0.40804150700569153,
0.7346702814102173,
-0.06941314041614532,
0.38660457730293274,
-0.09479232132434845,
-0.047607313841581345,
-0.38903817534446716,
1.1136635541915894,
-0.47451773285865784,
0.14475490152835846,
-0.6766495704650879,
-0.5718004703521729,
-0.8745220303535461,
0.6396107077598572,
0.18663367629051208,
-0.3052060604095459,
0.7316268682479858,
0.6048951148986816,
0.03773096203804016,
0.12795186042785645,
-0.010250936262309551,
-0.12251555174589157,
0.9882873296737671,
0.3826141357421875,
0.8252267241477966,
0.03345246985554695,
0.030281320214271545,
-0.5687210559844971,
-0.4495834410190582,
-0.3827929198741913,
-0.7829076647758484,
-0.9922858476638794,
-0.8490469455718994,
-0.3552098572254181,
0.04095549136400223,
-0.27048784494400024,
0.7461470365524292,
0.8476080298423767,
-0.394340842962265,
-0.3401646614074707,
-0.6020200252532959,
0.5923926830291748,
-0.0006398137775249779,
-0.2678411602973938,
0.5486575961112976,
-0.1458398997783661,
-0.13347649574279785,
-0.10105469822883606,
0.5439102053642273,
0.06294721364974976,
-0.52762770652771,
-0.31098389625549316,
-0.20266225934028625,
-0.1409670114517212,
0.7609608173370361,
0.1251431256532669,
-0.43354901671409607,
-0.4312129616737366,
-0.1755864918231964,
0.031069327145814896,
0.10079026967287064,
1.3578391075134277,
-0.5705727338790894,
0.4690264165401459,
0.9258114695549011,
0.32972368597984314,
0.2923026382923126,
0.13476310670375824,
0.8184571862220764,
-0.015441573224961758,
0.10131094604730606,
0.057654302567243576,
0.27214938402175903,
0.05615974962711334,
-0.5754026770591736,
0.5488881468772888,
0.46745985746383667,
-0.7557215690612793,
-0.24047546088695526,
0.0950099527835846,
-1.026485800743103,
-0.2676091194152832,
0.48247188329696655,
0.07286964356899261,
-0.22770389914512634,
-0.35554784536361694,
-0.6025567650794983,
0.2682647109031677,
-0.176986962556839,
1.1074272394180298,
0.5060649514198303,
-0.9595152139663696,
0.23959431052207947,
-0.29856231808662415,
0.478415310382843,
-0.08066719025373459,
-1.0731176137924194,
-0.10799634456634521,
0.765923798084259,
-0.10496831685304642,
0.3030957579612732,
0.7973834872245789,
0.13334758579730988,
0.4007548689842224,
-0.15824492275714874,
-0.03189928084611893,
0.20829342305660248,
-0.5850300788879395,
0.036637209355831146,
-0.1438288688659668,
0.2828531265258789,
0.00013893702998757362
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08103v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08103v2
|
Contextual Clarity: Generating Sentences with Transformer Models using Context-Reverso Data
| 2024-03-12T22:23:08 | 2024-03-14T10:47:32 |
Ruslan Musaev
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In the age of information abundance, the ability to provide users with
contextually relevant and concise information is crucial. Keyword in Context
(KIC) generation is a task that plays a vital role in and generation
applications, such as search engines, personal assistants, and content
summarization. In this paper, we present a novel approach to generating
unambiguous and brief sentence-contexts for given keywords using the T5
transformer model, leveraging data obtained from the Context-Reverso API. The
code is available at https://github.com/Rusamus/word2context/tree/main .
|
[
-0.15867048501968384,
-0.38744592666625977,
0.5218039751052856,
0.04861665144562721,
-0.5505706667900085,
-0.32372570037841797,
-0.19321128726005554,
-0.10483800619840622,
-0.09423539787530899,
0.7294742465019226,
-0.8210054039955139,
-0.7331704497337341,
-0.31701600551605225,
0.13492630422115326,
-0.6960507035255432,
1.1222610473632812,
0.21600918471813202,
-0.4773919880390167,
-0.11721537262201309,
-0.307122141122818,
-0.8744363188743591,
0.0721932053565979,
-0.30417656898498535,
-0.3760615885257721,
0.24238376319408417,
0.958867609500885,
0.5311603546142578,
0.2134680300951004,
0.14936785399913788,
0.21466052532196045,
0.04592016339302063,
-0.011289723217487335,
-0.5404626727104187,
0.6113066077232361,
-0.35733628273010254,
-0.38136282563209534,
0.07413043826818466,
-0.4137355387210846,
0.4923572540283203,
0.8407320976257324,
0.051080744713544846,
0.14098167419433594,
0.17556218802928925,
0.45351433753967285,
-0.6990911960601807,
0.020815175026655197,
-1.3018105030059814,
-0.11027596145868301,
-0.03563854098320007,
-0.2509399652481079,
-0.5510249137878418,
-0.031206956133246422,
0.21291491389274597,
-0.5371130704879761,
0.599860668182373,
-0.061783578246831894,
1.1589070558547974,
0.22109003365039825,
-0.7514877915382385,
-0.4785422384738922,
-0.7375090718269348,
0.5877915024757385,
-0.8564993143081665,
0.40320271253585815,
0.07318640500307083,
0.31612589955329895,
-0.04254944249987602,
-1.3104201555252075,
-0.7597306966781616,
0.10227295756340027,
-0.30401161313056946,
0.27213889360427856,
0.12220199406147003,
-0.013662145473062992,
0.05030219629406929,
0.2680177092552185,
-0.3317469358444214,
-0.286965012550354,
-0.4430898427963257,
-0.004361626226454973,
0.370504230260849,
0.2534749507904053,
0.17343638837337494,
-0.5750651955604553,
-0.13817812502384186,
0.09784793853759766,
-0.7988441586494446,
0.1425415277481079,
0.24424277245998383,
0.3929139971733093,
-0.049057699739933014,
0.7130719423294067,
-0.3336600959300995,
0.4355272948741913,
-0.016913726925849915,
-0.21368396282196045,
0.10505971312522888,
-0.6882274150848389,
-0.10344287753105164,
0.09501082450151443,
0.6626931428909302,
0.6009865999221802,
0.005857808515429497,
-0.6347581744194031,
-0.32332560420036316,
0.181574746966362,
0.6168949007987976,
-1.1179457902908325,
-0.1996181458234787,
0.2277814894914627,
-0.5074176788330078,
-0.6964351534843445,
0.24871672689914703,
-0.6715574264526367,
0.10227572172880173,
0.03185597062110901,
0.38165196776390076,
-0.13905544579029083,
0.06843257695436478,
-0.09971244633197784,
-0.2782554030418396,
0.45072656869888306,
-0.22065110504627228,
-0.716234028339386,
0.015206348150968552,
0.46519243717193604,
0.7424045205116272,
0.10292373597621918,
0.008126835338771343,
-0.23467998206615448,
0.3088706135749817,
-0.20973969995975494,
0.5477671027183533,
-0.5962913632392883,
-0.8882585763931274,
0.12811444699764252,
0.10154803097248077,
0.1638554334640503,
-0.34576958417892456,
0.8058266043663025,
-0.5568509101867676,
0.628088116645813,
-0.07010161876678467,
-0.46269235014915466,
-0.1645391881465912,
0.17278103530406952,
-0.4273979365825653,
0.7275031805038452,
0.07481271028518677,
-0.7990546226501465,
0.5319734811782837,
-0.9055343270301819,
-0.7970576882362366,
0.2520599663257599,
-0.2377789467573166,
-0.6052199006080627,
0.3152943551540375,
0.1567646861076355,
0.35437750816345215,
-0.16062447428703308,
0.5188459157943726,
-0.1390451043844223,
-0.0375189483165741,
0.26912152767181396,
-0.33261004090309143,
0.37363457679748535,
0.435291051864624,
-0.3683326244354248,
0.12397553771734238,
-0.6250486969947815,
0.04753929749131203,
0.14449068903923035,
-0.16726413369178772,
-0.2234574854373932,
0.09609145671129227,
0.34002137184143066,
0.23719798028469086,
0.2073100060224533,
-0.4508717656135559,
0.20131975412368774,
-0.5574775338172913,
0.8574779033660889,
0.25484126806259155,
0.2528957426548004,
0.5149425268173218,
0.09771057963371277,
0.30933642387390137,
0.24261587858200073,
-0.051360685378313065,
-0.7104191184043884,
-0.41903185844421387,
-0.5797396302223206,
0.27227213978767395,
0.4256833791732788,
0.2760322690010071,
-0.8797927498817444,
0.5704855918884277,
-0.7090566754341125,
-0.28785440325737,
-0.38223162293434143,
-0.04651345685124397,
0.23600256443023682,
1.1075358390808105,
0.16451556980609894,
0.02607402205467224,
-0.5707128643989563,
-1.063237190246582,
-0.361031174659729,
0.1276475340127945,
-0.2090698480606079,
0.6421985030174255,
0.4241567850112915,
-0.4369443953037262,
1.4918622970581055,
-0.7891556024551392,
-0.19005991518497467,
-0.4756399095058441,
0.3051983118057251,
0.08463027328252792,
0.35339903831481934,
0.31797876954078674,
-1.2935539484024048,
-0.27064719796180725,
-0.22948022186756134,
-0.49598923325538635,
-0.3429563641548157,
-0.12535567581653595,
-0.09501958638429642,
0.13092848658561707,
0.7430063486099243,
-0.5899441838264465,
0.41414302587509155,
0.38316088914871216,
-0.45748576521873474,
0.01676402986049652,
-0.08771630376577377,
0.045825473964214325,
-2.016213893890381,
0.7565714120864868,
-0.4426034688949585,
-0.29170840978622437,
-0.8833397030830383,
-0.1131552904844284,
0.12205479294061661,
-0.35341089963912964,
-0.3146941363811493,
0.43791529536247253,
-0.2129603922367096,
0.06160383298993111,
-0.4739561080932617,
0.4010937213897705,
0.22702957689762115,
0.23214852809906006,
-0.09101276099681854,
0.6953877806663513,
0.17937175929546356,
-0.5729163885116577,
-0.09653598815202713,
0.2769106924533844,
-0.23414945602416992,
0.27650925517082214,
-0.7942655682563782,
0.012209027074277401,
-0.21182845532894135,
0.36275389790534973,
-1.355768084526062,
-0.5806865096092224,
-0.10174807906150818,
-0.5762345790863037,
0.04781436175107956,
0.03800959512591362,
-0.5339242815971375,
-0.29435691237449646,
-0.15422120690345764,
0.7170232534408569,
0.5944916605949402,
-0.5904731154441833,
0.5393310189247131,
0.32379865646362305,
0.07534848153591156,
-0.4564112722873688,
-0.6630931496620178,
0.313711941242218,
-0.4644608795642853,
-0.6546039581298828,
0.7685166001319885,
0.11338828504085541,
0.08375141769647598,
0.11989718675613403,
-0.07086652517318726,
0.0362299308180809,
0.2584091126918793,
0.384278804063797,
0.09415724128484726,
0.1399490088224411,
0.33816373348236084,
0.30453330278396606,
0.08493076264858246,
-0.10739827156066895,
-0.30340486764907837,
0.6375946998596191,
-0.05652862414717674,
0.06754699349403381,
-0.21980616450309753,
0.30179208517074585,
0.5399489402770996,
-0.039974868297576904,
0.5189512968063354,
0.5161986351013184,
-0.36207878589630127,
-0.23061855137348175,
-0.19661836326122284,
-0.4159603714942932,
-0.46140244603157043,
0.2523888945579529,
-0.5097917914390564,
-0.8480771780014038,
0.6404860615730286,
-0.2884199619293213,
0.2072470635175705,
0.6224027872085571,
0.3599165380001068,
0.04277804493904114,
1.059893012046814,
0.7344072461128235,
0.1528148353099823,
0.42754611372947693,
-0.08303233236074448,
0.6555289626121521,
-0.7031221985816956,
-0.29330533742904663,
-0.3923355042934418,
-0.4737716019153595,
-0.8012481331825256,
0.2543504536151886,
0.42479178309440613,
0.4650585353374481,
0.06826236099004745,
0.49751678109169006,
-0.6489114165306091,
0.3707381784915924,
0.5064207315444946,
-0.1184600368142128,
0.2509562373161316,
-0.18864557147026062,
-0.12399893254041672,
0.11891183257102966,
-0.6746090650558472,
-0.6868453025817871,
1.0490672588348389,
0.05123188719153404,
0.5085487365722656,
0.03199702128767967,
0.6088841557502747,
0.04419282078742981,
0.14956296980381012,
-0.8694786429405212,
0.5349932312965393,
-0.24478031694889069,
-0.48748934268951416,
-0.015291624702513218,
-0.20350350439548492,
-1.2273519039154053,
-0.0002615138073451817,
-0.23604492843151093,
-0.7148798704147339,
-0.07655858993530273,
0.14450277388095856,
-0.40407678484916687,
0.04174238443374634,
-0.6829769015312195,
1.1276153326034546,
0.23233333230018616,
-0.10454460233449936,
-0.037216413766145706,
-1.151261568069458,
0.30200138688087463,
0.01139671728014946,
-0.1009453684091568,
0.11900588124990463,
-0.1937609761953354,
0.5567074418067932,
-0.5738388895988464,
0.6698497533798218,
-0.13229678571224213,
0.11046203970909119,
0.49188101291656494,
-0.030037298798561096,
0.4792037308216095,
0.2902074456214905,
0.4453526437282562,
-0.10572240501642227,
-0.223790243268013,
0.009256702847778797,
-0.5335361361503601,
0.6812739372253418,
-0.33421170711517334,
-0.2523716986179352,
0.22597606480121613,
-0.6677325367927551,
-0.19828416407108307,
0.5420551300048828,
0.7512542605400085,
0.4707701802253723,
-0.1946868896484375,
0.6035488247871399,
0.4240350127220154,
0.026267116889357567,
0.7640189528465271,
0.36159729957580566,
-0.0752098336815834,
-0.48338961601257324,
0.5925855040550232,
-0.024151813238859177,
0.021983405575156212,
0.46825599670410156,
0.26944074034690857,
-0.5596592426300049,
-0.26596125960350037,
-0.294213205575943,
-0.007275242358446121,
-0.530529797077179,
-0.33132919669151306,
-0.6926547884941101,
-0.09633272886276245,
-0.7118118405342102,
-0.3407346308231354,
-0.1216326504945755,
-0.4938182234764099,
-0.31451964378356934,
0.03205569460988045,
0.04528214409947395,
0.7008310556411743,
0.44901585578918457,
0.6645386815071106,
-0.7039188742637634,
0.4444754123687744,
0.18588808178901672,
0.009786691516637802,
-0.3103387951850891,
-0.49292096495628357,
-0.04366631433367729,
0.062063418328762054,
-0.567105770111084,
-0.9655370116233826,
0.388796865940094,
0.13985346257686615,
0.11281609535217285,
0.49825623631477356,
0.19535619020462036,
0.5641782879829407,
-0.4681088328361511,
1.1605039834976196,
0.2068893015384674,
-1.1462901830673218,
0.9398188591003418,
-0.1874801516532898,
0.8424910306930542,
0.7993240356445312,
-0.1080339327454567,
-0.8314036130905151,
-0.3304065763950348,
-0.9658448100090027,
-1.3958663940429688,
0.5475296378135681,
0.493831068277359,
0.2257857620716095,
0.05880127474665642,
0.486056387424469,
0.17334818840026855,
0.5569389462471008,
-0.715188205242157,
-0.07925992459058762,
-0.5831019878387451,
-0.7104396224021912,
-0.0076826466247439384,
-0.22748558223247528,
-0.12950803339481354,
0.3240836560726166,
0.6067962646484375,
-0.42891567945480347,
0.09113384038209915,
0.26232385635375977,
-0.24774320423603058,
0.21344499289989471,
0.6297554969787598,
1.0640007257461548,
0.2831474244594574,
0.05698174610733986,
0.3319244682788849,
0.22287732362747192,
-0.47019028663635254,
-0.25182995200157166,
-0.09188326448202133,
-0.541890561580658,
0.24377305805683136,
0.29132404923439026,
0.839841365814209,
0.37082573771476746,
-0.7341204881668091,
0.6684183478355408,
-0.09931548684835434,
-0.11739714443683624,
-0.2935626804828644,
-0.04343396797776222,
0.1481095552444458,
0.14831815659999847,
0.297093003988266,
0.04352268576622009,
0.36005139350891113,
-0.45355767011642456,
0.1520295888185501,
0.4749472141265869,
-0.1559453308582306,
-0.49393418431282043,
0.7800687551498413,
0.3375965356826782,
-0.1928681582212448,
0.8419852256774902,
-0.0832674652338028,
-0.4563634693622589,
0.4214446544647217,
0.6897434592247009,
1.2904653549194336,
0.07067006826400757,
-0.17691296339035034,
0.3460097014904022,
0.036459751427173615,
0.09223205596208572,
0.22962254285812378,
-0.5879054069519043,
-0.7704451084136963,
-0.08537191897630692,
-0.35420235991477966,
-0.024838093668222427,
0.27561521530151367,
-0.6016098260879517,
0.3783378601074219,
-0.03507380932569504,
-0.2556518614292145,
-0.1598484069108963,
-0.23779165744781494,
-0.5813215374946594,
0.3315300941467285,
0.037024058401584625,
0.7825398445129395,
-0.8569019436836243,
0.8367390632629395,
0.6755884289741516,
-0.3438686430454254,
-0.8641692996025085,
0.2723388671875,
-0.5574193000793457,
-0.4928536117076874,
0.5611850023269653,
0.489053338766098,
-0.16575603187084198,
-0.027225786820054054,
-0.778120219707489,
-0.4779880940914154,
1.5398590564727783,
0.0752185806632042,
-0.4194532036781311,
-0.40023669600486755,
0.5070679783821106,
0.4992977976799011,
-0.7256233096122742,
0.07441804558038712,
0.3891688287258148,
0.4292517602443695,
0.3175472319126129,
-0.7650764584541321,
0.08947286754846573,
-0.13621273636817932,
0.43520495295524597,
0.15354791283607483,
-0.4065462052822113,
0.5110710263252258,
-0.24252326786518097,
-0.714759349822998,
0.08902588486671448,
0.8130822777748108,
0.005997353699058294,
0.378348708152771,
0.5806577801704407,
0.6974256038665771,
0.42033350467681885,
-0.1444714516401291,
0.7083213925361633,
-0.8606311678886414,
0.5553987622261047,
1.2668267488479614,
-0.04238042235374451,
0.7322660684585571,
0.6862654685974121,
0.4726725220680237,
0.3827302157878876,
0.35837340354919434,
0.12541359663009644,
0.9281061887741089,
-0.25623106956481934,
-0.3471432030200958,
-0.06979405134916306,
-0.3437131345272064,
-0.11393525451421738,
0.5161753296852112,
0.2514592111110687,
-0.7125675082206726,
-0.38124436140060425,
-0.08184383809566498,
0.06730134785175323,
0.05399071052670479,
-0.25115349888801575,
0.9284948110580444,
0.15080499649047852,
-0.8784493803977966,
0.1626269817352295,
0.12481812387704849,
0.6853650808334351,
-0.4532659351825714,
0.050411272794008255,
-0.24241113662719727,
0.21116292476654053,
-0.39676937460899353,
-1.0142700672149658,
0.5490040183067322,
-0.07787295430898666,
-0.3100202977657318,
-0.2108510434627533,
0.9457199573516846,
-0.7608413696289062,
-0.3062163293361664,
-0.18274252116680145,
0.13338883221149445,
-0.08011620491743088,
0.06287922710180283,
-0.4042830467224121,
-0.1319822371006012,
0.033397942781448364,
-0.10306650400161743,
-0.40653616189956665,
0.41825732588768005,
0.10382190346717834,
0.45496228337287903,
0.2850061357021332,
-0.38224929571151733,
-0.09295767545700073,
0.27449992299079895,
0.6201854348182678,
-0.7342124581336975,
-0.4796454906463623,
-0.7688822150230408,
0.6597386598587036,
-0.13179051876068115,
-0.6213729977607727,
0.5756980776786804,
0.6993849277496338,
0.7902972102165222,
-0.155042365193367,
0.7873090505599976,
-0.33423539996147156,
0.2854582369327545,
-0.2192114293575287,
0.7261842489242554,
-0.6489095687866211,
-0.00582535145804286,
0.025667918846011162,
-0.7734822630882263,
-0.2328496277332306,
0.16254407167434692,
-0.09959091991186142,
0.1488010585308075,
0.6237853169441223,
0.8589462637901306,
-0.2184719294309616,
0.10975911468267441,
0.27423471212387085,
0.1978805959224701,
0.4856397807598114,
0.3899662494659424,
0.3022347390651703,
-0.9086248278617859,
0.7073029279708862,
-0.2033473402261734,
0.34478679299354553,
-0.2653082311153412,
-0.8085823655128479,
-0.751605212688446,
-0.9930142760276794,
-0.09698738157749176,
-0.5743682384490967,
-0.2257249802350998,
0.6604906916618347,
0.5336582064628601,
-0.7425203323364258,
0.03207871690392494,
-0.7175527811050415,
-0.025656523182988167,
0.16652540862560272,
-0.3324210047721863,
0.21047930419445038,
-0.5497744083404541,
-0.7265001535415649,
0.3640361726284027,
0.013708843849599361,
0.058578070253133774,
-0.05692727491259575,
0.05537646636366844,
0.17116603255271912,
0.11022458225488663,
0.6708815693855286,
0.0386057011783123,
-0.7436798810958862,
-0.5026887059211731,
-0.07178229093551636,
-0.17866955697536469,
-0.03283553943037987,
1.1151742935180664,
-0.9460265636444092,
0.4486118257045746,
0.8044719099998474,
0.41330549120903015,
0.4206942617893219,
0.24737806618213654,
0.5033653378486633,
-0.9947578310966492,
-0.08587465435266495,
0.14550469815731049,
0.3086082339286804,
0.4072599411010742,
-0.17148061096668243,
0.4943219721317291,
0.34353727102279663,
-0.45541146397590637,
-0.883536696434021,
0.5151366591453552,
-1.0863605737686157,
-0.4094206392765045,
1.1378434896469116,
0.2804790139198303,
-0.25863340497016907,
0.1579170972108841,
-0.16203564405441284,
0.5650171041488647,
-0.2865607738494873,
0.7526043653488159,
0.4498482644557953,
0.19079919159412384,
0.033414654433727264,
-0.22479945421218872,
0.45135417580604553,
0.4698029160499573,
-0.7378389835357666,
-0.0485708974301815,
0.32172927260398865,
0.5217246413230896,
0.22891899943351746,
0.18176352977752686,
-0.07264028489589691,
-0.029421502724289894,
0.009162881411612034,
0.1985737681388855,
0.11004937440156937,
-0.3636687994003296,
-0.2162238210439682,
0.5713050365447998,
-0.18427956104278564,
-0.2347421944141388
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09728v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09728v1
|
Simulating Weighted Automata over Sequences and Trees with Transformers
| 2024-03-12T21:54:34 | 2024-03-12T21:54:34 |
Michael Rizvi, Maude Lizaire, Clara Lacroce, Guillaume Rabusseau
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CC
|
Transformers are ubiquitous models in the natural language processing (NLP)
community and have shown impressive empirical successes in the past few years.
However, little is understood about how they reason and the limits of their
computational capabilities. These models do not process data sequentially, and
yet outperform sequential neural models such as RNNs. Recent work has shown
that these models can compactly simulate the sequential reasoning abilities of
deterministic finite automata (DFAs). This leads to the following question: can
transformers simulate the reasoning of more complex finite state machines? In
this work, we show that transformers can simulate weighted finite automata
(WFAs), a class of models which subsumes DFAs, as well as weighted tree
automata (WTA), a generalization of weighted automata to tree structured
inputs. We prove these claims formally and provide upper bounds on the sizes of
the transformer models needed as a function of the number of states the target
automata. Empirically, we perform synthetic experiments showing that
transformers are able to learn these compact solutions via standard
gradient-based training.
|
[
-0.3921229839324951,
-0.6637601256370544,
0.7734857797622681,
0.14704222977161407,
0.11364404857158661,
0.1366177797317505,
-0.08237339556217194,
-0.3071647882461548,
-0.015424561686813831,
0.10513745993375778,
-0.6749441623687744,
0.040351707488298416,
-0.5166913270950317,
0.3810215890407562,
-0.8914809823036194,
0.6865391731262207,
-0.10647045820951462,
-0.06680997461080551,
-0.16917763650417328,
-0.1806032955646515,
-0.2319657951593399,
-0.3633153736591339,
-0.5305617451667786,
-0.679492712020874,
0.4169994592666626,
-0.007257037330418825,
0.9053752422332764,
0.3480452299118042,
0.43864092230796814,
0.5277588367462158,
0.054486144334077835,
-0.1656530201435089,
-0.04304961860179901,
0.12332921475172043,
0.007589186541736126,
-0.7536847591400146,
-0.04229646548628807,
0.2999877333641052,
0.6753717064857483,
0.7084273099899292,
-0.3811556100845337,
0.27314987778663635,
-0.30490514636039734,
0.42426878213882446,
-0.4421673119068146,
0.12449605762958527,
-0.5687174797058105,
0.381704181432724,
0.14772170782089233,
-0.1859809309244156,
-0.7730557322502136,
-0.27460792660713196,
0.061357684433460236,
-0.6258218288421631,
0.1638401746749878,
-0.023660704493522644,
0.7663090825080872,
0.830564022064209,
-0.45932796597480774,
-0.11998830735683441,
-1.3317416906356812,
0.8477274775505066,
-0.7793242335319519,
0.2443631887435913,
0.0596698597073555,
0.5125871896743774,
-0.19351324439048767,
-0.8776606321334839,
-0.7759726047515869,
-0.20860780775547028,
-0.4781256318092346,
0.03412036970257759,
-0.6379141807556152,
0.19760584831237793,
0.8704748749732971,
0.4100925922393799,
-0.45495665073394775,
0.12885892391204834,
0.050698693841695786,
0.13784092664718628,
0.4962190091609955,
0.21771714091300964,
0.14156848192214966,
-0.10520858317613602,
-0.2956942021846771,
-0.44335588812828064,
-0.09753190726041794,
0.11531487107276917,
0.2803635895252228,
-0.06088807061314583,
-0.0894254520535469,
0.5794753432273865,
-0.03998503461480141,
0.7502751350402832,
0.2548350691795349,
-0.19951218366622925,
0.04826345667243004,
0.024341732263565063,
-0.6497989296913147,
-0.27591705322265625,
0.8510246872901917,
0.03541204333305359,
0.6695113778114319,
-0.26205089688301086,
-0.22430196404457092,
0.2312736213207245,
0.3402267098426819,
-0.8959554433822632,
-0.0838804766535759,
0.25212955474853516,
-0.5780726671218872,
-0.21985985338687897,
-0.19914016127586365,
-0.45189833641052246,
0.024629943072795868,
-0.5066602230072021,
0.5394132137298584,
-0.36364123225212097,
-0.090957410633564,
0.26669514179229736,
-0.2762500047683716,
0.40030598640441895,
0.16169129312038422,
-0.9299484491348267,
0.6994551420211792,
0.6671664118766785,
0.5984094738960266,
0.13031308352947235,
-0.1915963590145111,
-0.3621808588504791,
-0.2527548372745514,
-0.27698466181755066,
0.46390435099601746,
-0.5265730023384094,
-0.2745344340801239,
-0.10423842817544937,
-0.3167831599712372,
-0.17267385125160217,
-0.36940306425094604,
0.32183316349983215,
-0.5328646898269653,
0.2771944999694824,
-0.07691207528114319,
-0.4502128064632416,
-0.16068437695503235,
0.09328646212816238,
-0.7923668026924133,
0.9746313095092773,
0.4069613218307495,
-0.8350043892860413,
0.4345853626728058,
-0.5277250409126282,
-0.7917517423629761,
-0.2512170076370239,
-0.07633420079946518,
-0.3285258710384369,
0.38495951890945435,
0.0059648179449141026,
0.31708577275276184,
-0.5039080381393433,
0.5147116184234619,
-0.23938174545764923,
-0.5456321239471436,
0.1269499659538269,
-0.6534439921379089,
0.8278277516365051,
0.335222989320755,
-0.6135096549987793,
0.10251963138580322,
-0.53704434633255,
-0.09713164716959,
0.24798539280891418,
0.030891990289092064,
-0.32143324613571167,
0.1826411783695221,
-0.17339564859867096,
0.37774351239204407,
-0.023523883894085884,
-0.7898167967796326,
0.5258156657218933,
-0.3545539677143097,
0.46876978874206543,
0.4566987454891205,
-0.206577330827713,
0.7393652200698853,
-0.3375035524368286,
0.5457490682601929,
-0.031075946986675262,
0.20591089129447937,
0.0816265270113945,
-0.49349135160446167,
-0.8232656717300415,
-0.13024753332138062,
0.43076154589653015,
0.5000829100608826,
-0.8158240914344788,
0.4592064917087555,
-0.255653977394104,
-0.5414990782737732,
-0.39628109335899353,
-0.4836181104183197,
-0.07360098510980606,
0.3960174322128296,
0.47026127576828003,
-0.27166512608528137,
-0.6069720387458801,
-0.8572428226470947,
-0.15706130862236023,
-0.17284533381462097,
-0.3860361874103546,
0.02492322400212288,
0.5952606201171875,
0.0003627215337473899,
1.364762544631958,
-0.4819415211677551,
-0.2307506650686264,
-0.19741781055927277,
0.3618490397930145,
0.20151233673095703,
0.37798362970352173,
0.6169242858886719,
-0.6823546290397644,
-0.22161617875099182,
-0.40357401967048645,
-0.6739239692687988,
0.20312201976776123,
-0.5276746153831482,
0.2845725119113922,
-0.05652252212166786,
0.39122921228408813,
-0.9371240139007568,
0.46851810812950134,
0.6188934445381165,
-0.2796004116535187,
0.35607683658599854,
-0.1762896627187729,
-0.14264772832393646,
-0.9938912391662598,
0.13618966937065125,
0.00207244954071939,
-0.41539376974105835,
-0.48065659403800964,
0.059405844658613205,
-0.31181779503822327,
-0.02167344279587269,
-0.009040292352437973,
0.40171241760253906,
-0.07107055187225342,
-0.35668498277664185,
-0.35026785731315613,
-0.2513161599636078,
-0.11748058348894119,
0.712518572807312,
0.05762000381946564,
0.7559527158737183,
0.5335065126419067,
-0.5388765335083008,
0.15506401658058167,
0.03173540160059929,
-0.3575284481048584,
0.45478737354278564,
-0.8567368984222412,
-0.3867422342300415,
-0.33626070618629456,
0.7402157783508301,
-0.670576810836792,
0.14093898236751556,
-0.25168099999427795,
-0.2364392727613449,
0.14671027660369873,
0.013132249936461449,
-0.7136361002922058,
-0.6276313066482544,
0.007350176107138395,
0.4367000162601471,
1.017503261566162,
-0.48609107732772827,
1.183266043663025,
0.2213945984840393,
0.5032118558883667,
-0.6273359060287476,
-0.6307652592658997,
-0.16829529404640198,
-0.20887142419815063,
-0.17217589914798737,
0.4428819417953491,
-0.09890001267194748,
-0.36650925874710083,
0.040257129818201065,
-0.04325011000037193,
0.055254872888326645,
0.5575293302536011,
0.4261164665222168,
-0.231783926486969,
-0.02186555415391922,
0.05829915776848793,
-0.163583442568779,
-0.1773172914981842,
0.13237370550632477,
-0.541837751865387,
0.7179021239280701,
-0.2590811252593994,
-0.5272278785705566,
-0.617994487285614,
0.2561112940311432,
0.6911755204200745,
-0.32698220014572144,
0.7181095480918884,
0.6559839248657227,
-0.6727325320243835,
-0.43370115756988525,
-0.17843353748321533,
-0.503179132938385,
-0.5227857828140259,
0.10273221135139465,
-0.5096492171287537,
-0.7208923101425171,
0.4062075614929199,
-0.10575973242521286,
0.5943552851676941,
0.6762005686759949,
0.6642095446586609,
-0.1845027357339859,
1.2307642698287964,
0.6308354139328003,
-0.09807990491390228,
0.3197094798088074,
-0.5302339792251587,
0.17672282457351685,
-0.46487197279930115,
-0.007060360163450241,
-0.5877276062965393,
-0.8253019452095032,
-0.6287498474121094,
-0.6161865592002869,
0.17028047144412994,
-0.22252888977527618,
-0.41281381249427795,
0.6235384941101074,
-0.31939685344696045,
0.36389264464378357,
0.5956287980079651,
-0.2873537540435791,
0.34174811840057373,
-0.09762853384017944,
-0.3577767014503479,
0.2256491333246231,
-0.7149989008903503,
-0.30327901244163513,
0.47587814927101135,
0.3803981840610504,
0.6460586190223694,
-0.22155334055423737,
0.532089114189148,
0.26083308458328247,
0.6971210837364197,
-1.0041332244873047,
0.5338279604911804,
-0.2617102563381195,
-0.5754384994506836,
-0.40200167894363403,
-0.7348456382751465,
-0.954910159111023,
0.13231346011161804,
-0.09243452548980713,
-0.3529168367385864,
0.18269257247447968,
0.05455164983868599,
-0.4038921892642975,
0.7108268141746521,
-0.35553109645843506,
0.5237970352172852,
0.13698488473892212,
0.3493334650993347,
-0.3359067440032959,
-0.4753635823726654,
0.4185592830181122,
0.03988960012793541,
0.19688226282596588,
-0.11133569478988647,
0.1362767368555069,
0.5205131769180298,
-0.6351524591445923,
0.8200968503952026,
-0.3357907235622406,
-0.3732755184173584,
0.5295506715774536,
0.33599355816841125,
0.3779362142086029,
-0.10993869602680206,
-0.10214293003082275,
-0.06968417763710022,
-0.14930766820907593,
-0.28938454389572144,
-0.8666008710861206,
0.3206009268760681,
-0.5666054487228394,
-0.42982587218284607,
-0.43661484122276306,
-0.721167802810669,
-0.28029319643974304,
0.012995125725865364,
-0.01240104902535677,
0.41688472032546997,
-0.014093801379203796,
0.07214239984750748,
0.37642207741737366,
0.07477982342243195,
0.8028505444526672,
0.44591638445854187,
-0.05401747673749924,
0.02935786359012127,
0.4644775688648224,
0.10982579737901688,
0.173212930560112,
0.6081334948539734,
0.32994821667671204,
-0.12128553539514542,
-0.3309977948665619,
-0.5369278788566589,
-0.11910045146942139,
-0.4242591857910156,
-0.29879167675971985,
-0.6305001378059387,
-0.25723615288734436,
0.2034902125597,
-0.03747716173529625,
-0.29291075468063354,
-0.8283727169036865,
0.16795200109481812,
-0.24357591569423676,
0.5217704176902771,
0.8517377376556396,
0.08466632664203644,
0.4111178517341614,
-0.501573383808136,
0.3474029004573822,
0.5807910561561584,
0.6031227707862854,
0.5268531441688538,
-0.37536463141441345,
0.07737483084201813,
0.0009137533488683403,
-0.10068737715482712,
-0.5723522901535034,
0.19290493428707123,
0.12475095689296722,
0.30321067571640015,
0.17443889379501343,
-0.009334402158856392,
0.6317751407623291,
-0.9717283248901367,
0.5728498101234436,
-0.015401589684188366,
-0.8006545901298523,
-0.13283568620681763,
-0.1769419014453888,
0.35322433710098267,
0.5575321912765503,
0.5309234261512756,
-0.37676292657852173,
-0.43618088960647583,
-0.8078302145004272,
-0.3142571449279785,
0.35981032252311707,
0.39690807461738586,
0.204182431101799,
-0.11793269217014313,
0.2787957191467285,
-0.2756415903568268,
-0.023294171318411827,
-0.6586527228355408,
-0.3488338887691498,
-0.1309254914522171,
-0.6263180375099182,
0.038672130554914474,
0.2077014148235321,
0.09557607769966125,
-0.19770707190036774,
0.4932129383087158,
-0.21324849128723145,
0.07854368537664413,
0.3026805818080902,
0.01800868846476078,
-0.2218339443206787,
-0.02658795937895775,
0.3821275234222412,
0.00597430719062686,
0.11312646418809891,
0.19278927147388458,
0.3247103691101074,
-0.40888074040412903,
0.4769492447376251,
0.026309428736567497,
-0.5526045560836792,
0.028277521952986717,
0.2800869345664978,
0.640881359577179,
0.47637611627578735,
-0.6985828876495361,
0.3623531758785248,
-0.4421547055244446,
-0.33818015456199646,
-0.3408733010292053,
0.018041566014289856,
0.32362598180770874,
0.15726208686828613,
0.5546730160713196,
0.4519962966442108,
0.028791088610887527,
-0.5037230253219604,
0.5619778633117676,
0.581782877445221,
-0.4442049562931061,
-0.2770976424217224,
0.8218875527381897,
0.03758568316698074,
-0.4164429008960724,
0.6352670192718506,
-0.2284466028213501,
-0.4713647663593292,
0.825556218624115,
0.4240318834781647,
0.7911707758903503,
-0.025807105004787445,
0.13727492094039917,
0.6144384741783142,
0.4602482318878174,
-0.2451097071170807,
0.12552186846733093,
-0.1896628588438034,
-0.6312007308006287,
-0.7988190650939941,
-1.0387567281723022,
-0.36752912402153015,
-0.1950981765985489,
-0.45005515217781067,
0.035196755081415176,
-0.5898340940475464,
-0.36809074878692627,
-0.0285987239331007,
-0.09478408098220825,
-0.7019246220588684,
0.2099093198776245,
0.1078549399971962,
1.2408618927001953,
-0.8816084861755371,
0.8201116323471069,
0.13276787102222443,
-0.27257299423217773,
-1.015735149383545,
0.13438916206359863,
-0.3508313000202179,
-0.5887491106987,
0.45684561133384705,
0.19784696400165558,
-0.12328663468360901,
0.2327548861503601,
-0.3076639473438263,
-0.9555832743644714,
1.0161046981811523,
0.33729174733161926,
-0.46121662855148315,
-0.29607605934143066,
0.14586155116558075,
0.7367537021636963,
-0.09418371319770813,
0.5316309332847595,
0.7138566970825195,
0.5178930759429932,
0.01602560095489025,
-0.9755434393882751,
-0.022469010204076767,
0.033402279019355774,
-0.15430289506912231,
0.23508292436599731,
-0.6033602356910706,
0.9353582262992859,
-0.2914610803127289,
-0.34707576036453247,
0.270113468170166,
0.8734576106071472,
0.11224886029958725,
-0.16871050000190735,
1.0280778408050537,
0.9956599473953247,
0.48199331760406494,
-0.16393236815929413,
1.367167592048645,
-0.17248252034187317,
0.35330480337142944,
0.9973035454750061,
-0.5429453253746033,
0.7255467176437378,
0.19623258709907532,
-0.4642256498336792,
1.0933469533920288,
0.33029618859291077,
-0.22661417722702026,
0.00990361999720335,
0.46993640065193176,
-0.14722004532814026,
-0.2819102108478546,
-0.04931339994072914,
0.08561807125806808,
0.783632218837738,
0.088874451816082,
-0.09930051863193512,
-0.36732032895088196,
-0.03479594737291336,
-0.16878272593021393,
0.27827513217926025,
-0.2336329221725464,
0.7066683173179626,
0.08398771286010742,
-0.6752021908760071,
0.4898374080657959,
0.3579600155353546,
0.7702601552009583,
-0.6641401648521423,
-0.018221020698547363,
0.039698731154203415,
0.050628576427698135,
-0.174949049949646,
-0.48084959387779236,
0.5085816979408264,
0.05865953862667084,
-0.16028302907943726,
-0.5414428114891052,
0.41577088832855225,
-0.29302096366882324,
-0.6464981436729431,
0.15537744760513306,
0.24637046456336975,
-0.07522191852331161,
0.11237411201000214,
-0.42685553431510925,
-0.5043338537216187,
-0.41639038920402527,
-0.3809107840061188,
0.20495133101940155,
0.2872055172920227,
-0.19735807180404663,
0.8255331516265869,
0.5338512063026428,
-0.1543443650007248,
0.10306695103645325,
0.349577397108078,
0.5257295966148376,
-0.42747142910957336,
-0.27686479687690735,
-0.9100301861763,
0.3193073868751526,
0.01237366534769535,
0.12164416909217834,
0.682864248752594,
0.545869767665863,
0.7104861736297607,
-0.22184817492961884,
0.4313841164112091,
-0.2447255253791809,
0.2020687460899353,
-0.3171037435531616,
0.5606508255004883,
-0.5019471645355225,
-0.30042147636413574,
-0.04748949781060219,
-0.7829598188400269,
-0.1883964091539383,
0.6452089548110962,
0.0107806995511055,
0.28056952357292175,
0.5609965324401855,
0.16683226823806763,
-0.13608349859714508,
0.20121954381465912,
0.23911380767822266,
0.25574377179145813,
0.2780643701553345,
0.6976121068000793,
0.5932838916778564,
-0.4901631772518158,
0.42132481932640076,
-0.4362763464450836,
-0.1129768043756485,
0.15715977549552917,
-0.8478554487228394,
-0.7627135515213013,
-0.6627910137176514,
0.07740069925785065,
-0.05271327868103981,
-0.6893714070320129,
0.7950177192687988,
0.7488346695899963,
-0.7913493514060974,
-0.11529365181922913,
-0.397430419921875,
0.32840070128440857,
-0.4299943149089813,
-0.20329540967941284,
0.08223041146993637,
-0.30114853382110596,
-0.9227086901664734,
0.3795666992664337,
0.057545486837625504,
0.3081284165382385,
-0.6691504716873169,
0.1394375115633011,
-0.15314997732639313,
0.40430712699890137,
0.6505768299102783,
0.16620533168315887,
-0.48171189427375793,
-0.23463226854801178,
0.02051130123436451,
-0.12242771685123444,
-0.17834973335266113,
1.15432608127594,
-1.4754154682159424,
-0.1066766083240509,
0.4821362793445587,
0.5651558041572571,
0.3591406047344208,
0.13361366093158722,
0.7323033213615417,
-0.8758729696273804,
0.32869595289230347,
0.44377246499061584,
0.6387698650360107,
0.13708393275737762,
0.013633178547024727,
0.43614766001701355,
0.08780408650636673,
-0.22843040525913239,
-0.7112799882888794,
0.6772593855857849,
-0.6591084599494934,
-0.28368210792541504,
0.7833391427993774,
0.07490803301334381,
-0.021700184792280197,
0.06173446774482727,
0.16128821671009064,
0.31022289395332336,
0.1322934925556183,
0.6603742837905884,
0.3410096764564514,
0.10844790190458298,
0.22654518485069275,
-0.36261284351348877,
0.7614603638648987,
0.5938625931739807,
-0.7067238688468933,
0.1179945319890976,
0.04777922108769417,
0.2235945463180542,
0.3500874638557434,
0.47624289989471436,
-0.02524547278881073,
0.12945877015590668,
-0.033424727618694305,
-0.03283751383423805,
0.11264598369598389,
-0.5543068051338196,
-0.3755835294723511,
0.3109213411808014,
-0.06338296830654144,
0.27239271998405457
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08081v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08081v1
|
Mechanics of Next Token Prediction with Self-Attention
| 2024-03-12T21:15:38 | 2024-03-12T21:15:38 |
Yingcong Li, Yixiao Huang, M. Emrullah Ildiz, Ankit Singh Rawat, Samet Oymak
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, math.OC
|
Transformer-based language models are trained on large datasets to predict
the next token given an input sequence. Despite this simple training objective,
they have led to revolutionary advances in natural language processing.
Underlying this success is the self-attention mechanism. In this work, we ask:
$\textit{What}$ $\textit{does}$ $\textit{a}$ $\textit{single}$
$\textit{self-attention}$ $\textit{layer}$ $\textit{learn}$ $\textit{from}$
$\textit{next-token}$ $\textit{prediction?}$ We show that training
self-attention with gradient descent learns an automaton which generates the
next token in two distinct steps: $\textbf{(1)}$ $\textbf{Hard}$
$\textbf{retrieval:}$ Given input sequence, self-attention precisely selects
the $\textit{high-priority}$ $\textit{input}$ $\textit{tokens}$ associated with
the last input token. $\textbf{(2)}$ $\textbf{Soft}$ $\textbf{composition:}$ It
then creates a convex combination of the high-priority tokens from which the
next token can be sampled. Under suitable conditions, we rigorously
characterize these mechanics through a directed graph over tokens extracted
from the training data. We prove that gradient descent implicitly discovers the
strongly-connected components (SCC) of this graph and self-attention learns to
retrieve the tokens that belong to the highest-priority SCC available in the
context window. Our theory relies on decomposing the model weights into a
directional component and a finite component that correspond to hard retrieval
and soft composition steps respectively. This also formalizes a related
implicit bias formula conjectured in [Tarzanagh et al. 2023]. We hope that
these findings shed light on how self-attention processes sequential data and
pave the path toward demystifying more complex architectures.
|
[
-0.23222889006137848,
-0.4798722565174103,
0.632481038570404,
0.0381617471575737,
-0.0029933792538940907,
0.03872642293572426,
0.002100614132359624,
-0.3629476726055145,
0.25790876150131226,
0.4510555863380432,
-1.0219253301620483,
-0.3236805498600006,
-0.5009159445762634,
0.10209470987319946,
-0.6030622720718384,
1.2099841833114624,
-0.03037986159324646,
-0.19546601176261902,
-0.22938238084316254,
-0.0502764917910099,
-0.5383222699165344,
-0.6571926474571228,
-0.6775163412094116,
-0.2809024751186371,
0.7328575253486633,
0.25861600041389465,
0.4939747154712677,
1.1427851915359497,
0.5464510321617126,
0.41838717460632324,
0.06364352256059647,
-0.6231375932693481,
-0.4857276380062103,
0.3447611629962921,
-0.15580157935619354,
-0.5266997218132019,
-0.3160945475101471,
0.18313489854335785,
0.6789313554763794,
0.7037643194198608,
0.14250481128692627,
0.25375857949256897,
0.19945894181728363,
0.5980783700942993,
-0.404069185256958,
0.3537156581878662,
-0.5206475257873535,
0.42179134488105774,
-0.3286867141723633,
-0.14240965247154236,
-0.23611712455749512,
0.2961292862892151,
0.10346472263336182,
-0.3587176501750946,
0.48734161257743835,
0.051517244428396225,
0.4819057881832123,
0.6664530038833618,
-0.38868895173072815,
-0.023970263078808784,
-0.6268321871757507,
0.6169036030769348,
-0.288909912109375,
0.47003594040870667,
0.27965909242630005,
0.26321616768836975,
-0.044369082897901535,
-1.0844086408615112,
-0.46242713928222656,
-0.20403870940208435,
-0.046494010835886,
0.27025800943374634,
0.0894133448600769,
0.26849421858787537,
0.23767518997192383,
0.3433179557323456,
-0.5353190302848816,
0.2053869664669037,
-0.3775423467159271,
-0.35927724838256836,
0.3323402404785156,
0.3378651440143585,
0.03732140734791756,
-0.22539477050304413,
-0.8177965879440308,
-0.13462308049201965,
-0.5123720765113831,
0.08407115936279297,
0.23829643428325653,
0.2417629063129425,
-0.0756186693906784,
0.5601617097854614,
-0.2164938598871231,
0.4118659198284149,
0.5293197631835938,
0.15247228741645813,
0.33731240034103394,
-0.4326428771018982,
-0.20331671833992004,
0.10405715554952621,
0.8844385147094727,
-0.015692828223109245,
0.23896563053131104,
-0.23966853320598602,
-0.3073788583278656,
-0.09947879612445831,
0.39780139923095703,
-0.6244866251945496,
-0.2261093109846115,
0.2842124104499817,
-0.640530526638031,
-0.37808993458747864,
-0.08988235890865326,
-0.392940491437912,
-0.060726363211870193,
-0.5213149785995483,
0.36087965965270996,
-0.10121852159500122,
-0.20765627920627594,
-0.06980708986520767,
0.3308296501636505,
0.17749419808387756,
-0.09699393808841705,
-1.1072098016738892,
0.28770163655281067,
0.7508248090744019,
0.9060236215591431,
-0.37488678097724915,
-0.6089518666267395,
-0.7400466203689575,
0.10653073340654373,
-0.18586039543151855,
0.9148657917976379,
-0.43065571784973145,
-0.08633863925933838,
-0.04236156493425369,
0.07249850034713745,
-0.2278396189212799,
-0.21029803156852722,
0.504635751247406,
-0.48754972219467163,
0.3017394542694092,
-0.22133874893188477,
-0.5275202989578247,
-0.04829525947570801,
0.011467133648693562,
-0.7189506888389587,
1.08402419090271,
-0.03977126255631447,
-0.8450452089309692,
0.27544206380844116,
-0.6673583984375,
-0.7817431688308716,
-0.012270395644009113,
-0.19551454484462738,
-0.3532669246196747,
0.17401055991649628,
-0.017483243718743324,
0.7027567028999329,
-0.1278902292251587,
0.11801067739725113,
-0.5383924841880798,
-0.2658611834049225,
0.21701756119728088,
-0.5220355987548828,
0.4903181493282318,
0.013025892898440361,
-0.8016408085823059,
0.20036551356315613,
-0.6478726267814636,
-0.23768077790737152,
0.08811358362436295,
-0.032768040895462036,
0.1367155760526657,
-0.07168586552143097,
-0.2971128821372986,
0.7246184945106506,
0.3585124611854553,
-0.40216541290283203,
0.02135450951755047,
-0.6153039932250977,
0.4337499439716339,
1.315826416015625,
-0.14405615627765656,
0.6492071151733398,
0.30725425481796265,
0.6057243943214417,
0.03295690193772316,
0.40430477261543274,
-0.4267965853214264,
-0.12975071370601654,
-0.8062400817871094,
0.1929607093334198,
0.2673700153827667,
0.14927150309085846,
-0.36226531863212585,
0.33629852533340454,
-0.03166140243411064,
-0.021956440061330795,
-0.291069895029068,
0.08028759062290192,
0.5836766362190247,
0.7975983023643494,
0.36410853266716003,
-0.40176957845687866,
-0.4056991636753082,
-0.859901487827301,
-0.16740812361240387,
-0.3060886561870575,
0.2631537914276123,
0.3271767199039459,
0.2636503279209137,
-0.0641695186495781,
0.9129953384399414,
-0.5066947340965271,
-0.5606158971786499,
-0.1099400743842125,
0.25771254301071167,
0.23973801732063293,
0.45209231972694397,
0.4357348084449768,
-0.5048999190330505,
-0.44499269127845764,
-0.14615774154663086,
-0.6746240258216858,
0.0511995330452919,
-0.07950901985168457,
-0.2498086541891098,
0.28200963139533997,
0.9480360746383667,
-0.5183331370353699,
0.39090225100517273,
0.4225243926048279,
-0.27249935269355774,
0.42554813623428345,
0.02640753984451294,
-0.4633965492248535,
-0.95384681224823,
0.13528014719486237,
-0.09851721674203873,
-0.18105380237102509,
-0.4974638819694519,
-0.22690235078334808,
-0.15249845385551453,
0.019829878583550453,
-0.4351741671562195,
0.6971589922904968,
-0.5530552864074707,
-0.4862549602985382,
-0.47574734687805176,
-0.04191945120692253,
-0.3306419253349304,
0.9727792739868164,
-0.01953214779496193,
0.7243512272834778,
0.7631050944328308,
-0.6852851510047913,
0.26559942960739136,
0.03851570934057236,
0.08414389938116074,
0.27543905377388,
-0.8786417841911316,
0.35048118233680725,
-0.313300758600235,
0.2230670005083084,
-1.3135697841644287,
-0.04904213547706604,
0.2730100750923157,
-0.5588370561599731,
0.4714873433113098,
-0.22659529745578766,
-0.368621826171875,
-0.8104063272476196,
-0.09330336004495621,
0.5797045826911926,
0.1513623148202896,
-0.6313953399658203,
0.7633882164955139,
0.41791224479675293,
-0.20541119575500488,
-0.9108628034591675,
-0.6156781911849976,
0.018489403650164604,
0.18429528176784515,
-0.34018072485923767,
0.1121453195810318,
-0.22870567440986633,
0.22679805755615234,
0.10448964685201645,
-0.20843137800693512,
0.1646668016910553,
0.21456895768642426,
0.36566779017448425,
0.1488776057958603,
-0.03891044482588768,
0.23777201771736145,
-0.011283034458756447,
-0.5992390513420105,
0.4711279273033142,
-0.8667874932289124,
0.7501055598258972,
-0.10826169699430466,
-0.4517821669578552,
-0.5512605905532837,
0.12142059952020645,
0.7005791068077087,
-0.48998212814331055,
0.37395527958869934,
0.9384147524833679,
-0.19028545916080475,
0.09282512217760086,
-0.5644797682762146,
-0.5065932273864746,
-0.5245003700256348,
0.5205069184303284,
-0.6027176976203918,
-0.754867672920227,
0.7705402970314026,
0.24959540367126465,
-0.1139257475733757,
0.8436636328697205,
0.7242897748947144,
-0.17809319496154785,
1.3839174509048462,
0.6775637269020081,
-0.41347965598106384,
0.7820965647697449,
-0.477783203125,
0.05512761324644089,
-0.7872371673583984,
-0.42688432335853577,
-0.36399132013320923,
-0.4870331585407257,
-0.5990130305290222,
-0.14446809887886047,
0.3660055696964264,
-0.34091925621032715,
-0.2976905405521393,
0.3665177524089813,
-0.5073866248130798,
0.42646169662475586,
0.7335271835327148,
-0.15847419202327728,
-0.08568892627954483,
0.038075558841228485,
-0.5330058336257935,
0.022467011585831642,
-0.7956615090370178,
0.16053564846515656,
1.1464271545410156,
0.5081313252449036,
0.7268624901771545,
-0.34035199880599976,
0.8183112144470215,
0.20214639604091644,
0.1972326934337616,
-0.780212938785553,
0.5284177660942078,
-0.0111729446798563,
-0.6206115484237671,
-0.4106164276599884,
-0.27354738116264343,
-1.0906833410263062,
0.07409705221652985,
0.10228613764047623,
-0.6022199988365173,
0.21199312806129456,
0.22457487881183624,
-0.3556014895439148,
0.0753401443362236,
-0.5168009400367737,
1.0785945653915405,
-0.31298333406448364,
-0.5435194969177246,
-0.2998073995113373,
-1.1139150857925415,
0.20126867294311523,
0.1491282731294632,
-0.06249529868364334,
-0.07475880533456802,
0.13712741434574127,
0.7327605485916138,
-0.3131498694419861,
1.0656923055648804,
-0.1858968436717987,
-0.14072473347187042,
0.3717016279697418,
0.16080287098884583,
0.5913837552070618,
-0.001863335957750678,
0.23999908566474915,
0.0013754963874816895,
-0.5226413607597351,
-0.30800893902778625,
-0.63935786485672,
0.5864168405532837,
-0.7743755578994751,
-0.6629749536514282,
-0.39388057589530945,
-0.191947340965271,
-0.03054407238960266,
0.4355209767818451,
0.1878882348537445,
0.733439564704895,
0.10422451049089432,
0.09723877161741257,
0.4935306906700134,
0.41165652871131897,
0.7869042754173279,
0.3238348066806793,
0.08762093633413315,
-0.35090914368629456,
0.9531022906303406,
0.11306028068065643,
0.07239066064357758,
0.35665687918663025,
0.18939709663391113,
-0.7555578947067261,
-0.32856088876724243,
-0.28403839468955994,
0.38018473982810974,
-0.7489128112792969,
-0.39793410897254944,
-1.0104743242263794,
-0.3675629794597626,
-0.48508691787719727,
0.21239778399467468,
-0.54375159740448,
-0.4035618305206299,
-0.501201331615448,
-0.36922815442085266,
-0.025519337505102158,
0.9468654990196228,
-0.12073858082294464,
0.05131106451153755,
-0.5578967332839966,
0.26893672347068787,
0.5030459761619568,
0.5968565344810486,
0.24674507975578308,
-0.5697399377822876,
-0.5163464546203613,
-0.34528231620788574,
-0.14747962355613708,
-0.5196815133094788,
0.1715477854013443,
0.004261497873812914,
0.7318011522293091,
0.5300589203834534,
-0.15684981644153595,
0.4208697974681854,
-0.7523674964904785,
0.5261491537094116,
0.3200100064277649,
-0.8534542918205261,
0.44451114535331726,
-0.25838807225227356,
0.23385366797447205,
0.6824900507926941,
0.15761055052280426,
-0.5650290250778198,
-0.47791895270347595,
-0.8004613518714905,
-0.7306426167488098,
0.9863448739051819,
0.06254325807094574,
0.21059609949588776,
-0.2686239778995514,
0.5712133646011353,
0.12826645374298096,
0.2462446689605713,
-0.8444565534591675,
-0.4941243827342987,
-0.30434584617614746,
-0.3397092819213867,
-0.11450963467359543,
-0.3726676404476166,
0.14578737318515778,
-0.16293425858020782,
0.41729736328125,
-0.45314091444015503,
0.6318466067314148,
0.2491540014743805,
0.024958284571766853,
-0.210553377866745,
-0.37862691283226013,
0.46502652764320374,
0.23385655879974365,
0.10599838197231293,
0.07491528242826462,
-0.0707552507519722,
-0.455983966588974,
0.13485267758369446,
0.13667021691799164,
-0.05458175018429756,
-0.23927105963230133,
0.3435620665550232,
1.0953551530838013,
0.30928727984428406,
-0.20618179440498352,
0.7117592692375183,
-0.07292937487363815,
-0.17028377950191498,
-0.34988299012184143,
-0.05345862731337547,
-0.37692853808403015,
0.3272305130958557,
0.5984078645706177,
0.1599983125925064,
0.47703638672828674,
-0.3860875964164734,
0.332923948764801,
0.44051358103752136,
-0.706279456615448,
-0.6830321550369263,
1.0397043228149414,
0.20668058097362518,
-0.16322408616542816,
0.3283992111682892,
-0.02596251852810383,
-0.9078249931335449,
0.7430514097213745,
0.5000336766242981,
1.378187894821167,
-0.34081363677978516,
0.17921875417232513,
0.40816816687583923,
0.08322836458683014,
0.0021342586260288954,
0.00962908286601305,
-0.4005138576030731,
-0.44235679507255554,
-0.6729174852371216,
-0.5464571118354797,
-0.08045025169849396,
-0.11964274197816849,
-0.43129879236221313,
0.14778833091259003,
-0.43793874979019165,
-0.21077166497707367,
-0.2646488845348358,
-0.07080696523189545,
-0.8174765706062317,
0.4103250503540039,
0.22816716134548187,
0.3876505494117737,
-0.6687729954719543,
0.49646326899528503,
0.474807471036911,
-0.36005455255508423,
-0.9082413911819458,
0.34199002385139465,
-0.21851840615272522,
-0.9796141386032104,
0.9183337092399597,
0.4626307189464569,
-0.32053837180137634,
0.20951874554157257,
-0.37552616000175476,
-1.5608736276626587,
0.9679375886917114,
0.2801576256752014,
-0.43364831805229187,
-0.2467004507780075,
0.023587893694639206,
0.5353668332099915,
-0.23682801425457,
0.37486621737480164,
0.24908976256847382,
0.2920052707195282,
0.14073970913887024,
-0.6484540700912476,
0.0932697132229805,
-0.1788325309753418,
-0.15675871074199677,
0.0799565240740776,
-1.0402252674102783,
1.0571261644363403,
-0.24863672256469727,
-0.3452877402305603,
-0.15693877637386322,
1.1782324314117432,
-0.25968846678733826,
0.1391734629869461,
0.6430088877677917,
0.47925519943237305,
0.5388435125350952,
0.1390082836151123,
1.2245477437973022,
-0.7572427988052368,
0.5403510332107544,
1.127842903137207,
-0.07330503314733505,
0.49740833044052124,
0.35806694626808167,
-0.21907220780849457,
0.7796140313148499,
0.5722164511680603,
0.18644873797893524,
0.6208644509315491,
-0.08865545690059662,
0.056474268436431885,
-0.2018692046403885,
-0.06565927714109421,
-0.2577172815799713,
0.6739944815635681,
0.01851075328886509,
-0.4418277144432068,
0.06555845588445663,
0.11298759281635284,
-0.3058416247367859,
-0.2487121820449829,
-0.38719436526298523,
0.9656211137771606,
-0.04702560231089592,
-0.9007234573364258,
0.453592449426651,
-0.2721470296382904,
0.2751190960407257,
-0.25273460149765015,
0.2231605052947998,
-0.27280721068382263,
0.1960384100675583,
0.03433609381318092,
-0.8523266911506653,
0.019469035789370537,
-0.45457854866981506,
-0.24313966929912567,
-0.1730891615152359,
0.8662002682685852,
-0.4030047357082367,
-0.4213707745075226,
0.44723576307296753,
0.37926602363586426,
-0.09119649976491928,
-0.0721593052148819,
-0.8374625444412231,
-0.1609693467617035,
-0.18618395924568176,
-0.5065882802009583,
0.18869154155254364,
0.4037229120731354,
0.17073024809360504,
0.857864499092102,
0.6003073453903198,
-0.2923150658607483,
0.30396953225135803,
0.3173042833805084,
0.9843626022338867,
-0.622370183467865,
-0.7538122534751892,
-0.8629140257835388,
0.3840547502040863,
0.12330383062362671,
-0.2861785590648651,
0.49160274863243103,
0.4559652507305145,
0.7673484683036804,
0.12402503937482834,
0.5476606488227844,
0.3276740610599518,
0.29936525225639343,
-0.5564524531364441,
0.2830633223056793,
-0.6108946204185486,
-0.19218352437019348,
-0.19102811813354492,
-0.9473810195922852,
-0.14688146114349365,
0.48689427971839905,
-0.27785560488700867,
0.34420761466026306,
0.8663046956062317,
0.4322698414325714,
-0.03237172216176987,
-0.32411831617355347,
0.1396714597940445,
0.4610309302806854,
0.08671731501817703,
0.4414200782775879,
0.5216196775436401,
-0.3780900537967682,
0.7070023417472839,
-0.2257111519575119,
0.0822402611374855,
-0.3568081855773926,
-0.5104525685310364,
-1.0559420585632324,
-0.770370364189148,
-0.04460357502102852,
-0.43171337246894836,
-0.08929581195116043,
0.7466244697570801,
0.7518296837806702,
-0.6903761625289917,
0.05428621545433998,
-0.5990168452262878,
0.09142618626356125,
-0.11109156161546707,
-0.28516969084739685,
0.4769380986690521,
-0.8440058827400208,
-0.8345804214477539,
0.26597583293914795,
0.5102244019508362,
0.19404828548431396,
-0.6631168723106384,
0.016551325097680092,
0.09741611033678055,
-0.20366814732551575,
0.5230716466903687,
0.40441250801086426,
-0.5885880589485168,
-0.26076027750968933,
0.2765718698501587,
-0.312309205532074,
0.1742098331451416,
1.0390373468399048,
-1.0453728437423706,
0.355234295129776,
0.3022089898586273,
0.8143588304519653,
0.9678282141685486,
-0.034222859889268875,
0.624238133430481,
-0.7909488677978516,
0.13410815596580505,
0.16612091660499573,
0.46106594800949097,
0.1491558849811554,
-0.6682630777359009,
0.44315117597579956,
0.49443894624710083,
-0.5366060733795166,
-0.5687060952186584,
0.41317179799079895,
-0.6856679320335388,
0.03189266473054886,
1.0343542098999023,
0.09375941753387451,
-0.6272963881492615,
0.009046873077750206,
-0.11037888377904892,
0.3624551594257355,
-0.31850466132164,
0.7764900922775269,
0.4509749412536621,
-0.18661241233348846,
-0.21164457499980927,
-0.0942641869187355,
0.5228467583656311,
0.9442798495292664,
-0.36564087867736816,
0.18508575856685638,
0.17666824162006378,
0.16025154292583466,
0.18966738879680634,
0.6479302048683167,
0.013180694542825222,
0.34442201256752014,
-0.25672978162765503,
0.020950665697455406,
-0.11762942373752594,
-0.7596951127052307,
-0.49250999093055725,
0.1671287715435028,
-0.1779051572084427,
-0.33956998586654663
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09727v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09727v1
|
Investigating the performance of Retrieval-Augmented Generation and fine-tuning for the development of AI-driven knowledge-based systems
| 2024-03-12T21:06:31 | 2024-03-12T21:06:31 |
Robert Lakatos, Peter Pollner, Andras Hajdu, Tamas Joo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
The development of generative large language models (G-LLM) opened up new
opportunities for the development of new types of knowledge-based systems
similar to ChatGPT, Bing, or Gemini. Fine-tuning (FN) and Retrieval-Augmented
Generation (RAG) are the techniques that can be used to implement domain
adaptation for the development of G-LLM-based knowledge systems. In our study,
using ROUGE, BLEU, METEOR scores, and cosine similarity, we compare and examine
the performance of RAG and FN for the GPT-J-6B, OPT-6.7B, LlaMA, LlaMA-2
language models. Based on measurements shown on different datasets, we
demonstrate that RAG-based constructions are more efficient than models
produced with FN. We point out that connecting RAG and FN is not trivial,
because connecting FN models with RAG can cause a decrease in performance.
Furthermore, we outline a simple RAG-based architecture which, on average,
outperforms the FN models by 16% in terms of the ROGUE score, 15% in the case
of the BLEU score, and 53% based on the cosine similarity. This shows the
significant advantage of RAG over FN in terms of hallucination, which is not
offset by the fact that the average 8% better METEOR score of FN models
indicates greater creativity compared to RAG.
|
[
-0.5740560293197632,
-0.8254178762435913,
0.4156718850135803,
-0.0824233740568161,
-0.12302843481302261,
0.23320835828781128,
-0.3463160991668701,
-0.6151280403137207,
-0.03781506419181824,
0.5082167983055115,
-0.14445821940898895,
-0.2704445719718933,
-0.3513711988925934,
0.060711819678545,
-0.454679936170578,
0.9971994757652283,
0.2551251947879791,
-0.2679107189178467,
-0.0013131126761436462,
-0.09852252900600433,
-0.4753223657608032,
-0.40335121750831604,
-0.8351632356643677,
-0.3498823940753937,
0.5029929876327515,
0.1387043595314026,
0.9423736929893494,
0.5607045292854309,
0.64292973279953,
0.2571026384830475,
-0.17591160535812378,
0.5300630331039429,
-0.6692399978637695,
0.007148591335862875,
-0.5942307114601135,
-0.32820644974708557,
-0.4570647180080414,
-0.1465250700712204,
0.2953754961490631,
0.3240538239479065,
-0.007672633044421673,
0.3187040388584137,
0.11839888989925385,
0.9140626788139343,
-0.6721349358558655,
0.16901899874210358,
-0.8771091103553772,
-0.36916759610176086,
-0.21022973954677582,
-0.39554187655448914,
-0.4888221025466919,
-0.3111898601055145,
-0.017140191048383713,
-0.8130199909210205,
0.41722920536994934,
0.3705105185508728,
0.9611985683441162,
0.5348426699638367,
-0.05748018994927406,
-0.4935350716114044,
-0.9153803586959839,
0.728944718837738,
-0.5782893300056458,
0.4938187897205353,
0.23540790379047394,
0.3052310645580292,
-0.37072229385375977,
-0.4586140811443329,
-0.5419317483901978,
-0.29300281405448914,
-0.10614575445652008,
0.1576952189207077,
0.05223396047949791,
-0.08355233818292618,
0.308703750371933,
0.5577864646911621,
-0.680647611618042,
0.2564389407634735,
-0.36707642674446106,
-0.052953604608774185,
0.9532774686813354,
0.217167466878891,
-0.08591244369745255,
-0.30308571457862854,
-0.1377560943365097,
-0.14617691934108734,
-0.8795824646949768,
-0.31719306111335754,
0.19105158746242523,
0.465861052274704,
0.022890077903866768,
0.6063337326049805,
-0.3227112591266632,
0.8521967530250549,
0.3081333637237549,
-0.18612533807754517,
0.046219948679208755,
-0.2099180966615677,
-0.32365432381629944,
-0.469062477350235,
0.5942634344100952,
0.3602346181869507,
0.5461099147796631,
-0.4718377888202667,
-0.48542141914367676,
0.1031445786356926,
0.38972797989845276,
-0.5811777114868164,
-0.2742284834384918,
-0.21925264596939087,
-0.45652949810028076,
-0.23096609115600586,
-0.28605571389198303,
-0.3990572392940521,
-0.4961974024772644,
-0.7362582087516785,
0.7789567708969116,
-0.5557329654693604,
-0.14329023659229279,
-0.0269464123994112,
-0.28163230419158936,
0.40574735403060913,
0.43300771713256836,
-0.7558283805847168,
0.3207477033138275,
0.9033822417259216,
0.7040629982948303,
-0.3150673508644104,
-0.16710719466209412,
-0.4173804819583893,
-0.027477772906422615,
-0.5678892135620117,
0.7326310873031616,
-0.4585311710834503,
-0.44862100481987,
-0.13883255422115326,
-0.3734927773475647,
-0.18320778012275696,
-0.9684776663780212,
0.4274306893348694,
-0.938225269317627,
-0.07157932966947556,
-0.11440039426088333,
-0.6729059815406799,
-0.28339630365371704,
0.19127647578716278,
-0.5639899373054504,
0.9216961860656738,
0.4433523416519165,
-0.46165305376052856,
0.443998783826828,
-0.5217125415802002,
-0.3916013538837433,
0.13295969367027283,
-0.11603536456823349,
-0.1510331630706787,
0.4573310911655426,
0.013796164654195309,
0.4416862428188324,
-0.6942934989929199,
0.1793656349182129,
-0.09366799890995026,
-0.6646332740783691,
-0.09926298260688782,
-0.35533320903778076,
0.24359293282032013,
0.392577201128006,
-0.3185979425907135,
-0.19419369101524353,
-0.8849748969078064,
0.11279883980751038,
-0.008974332362413406,
-0.5854597091674805,
-0.47640565037727356,
0.10989134013652802,
-0.05190107598900795,
-0.028357021510601044,
0.17081868648529053,
-0.04504881426692009,
0.20784415304660797,
-0.5563690662384033,
-0.1269834041595459,
0.6990246176719666,
-0.11106850951910019,
0.3798510432243347,
-0.6715612411499023,
0.2750351130962372,
-0.13721124827861786,
-0.06771621108055115,
0.04998581111431122,
-0.3658960163593292,
-0.9432173371315002,
0.008648457936942577,
0.47980573773384094,
0.523912787437439,
-0.9686429500579834,
0.18672075867652893,
-0.3071586489677429,
-0.5818330645561218,
-0.5351563096046448,
0.015383286401629448,
0.5994747281074524,
0.4795626103878021,
0.485461950302124,
-0.289276123046875,
-0.2771775424480438,
-0.8771176338195801,
-0.5423945188522339,
-0.012867884710431099,
0.07032463699579239,
0.7398461699485779,
0.426329106092453,
-0.12440670281648636,
0.5700262784957886,
-0.34913650155067444,
-0.03918125107884407,
-0.044911619275808334,
-0.007038240786641836,
0.3017272353172302,
0.29525282979011536,
0.7192761898040771,
-0.7863833904266357,
-0.7259858846664429,
0.4264400899410248,
-0.5546486377716064,
0.017513016238808632,
0.0657716616988182,
0.04783295467495918,
0.6363931894302368,
0.24318942427635193,
-0.5496793389320374,
0.5988733768463135,
0.4823407232761383,
-0.3418649733066559,
0.802514910697937,
-0.24175754189491272,
0.33359649777412415,
-1.0261900424957275,
0.27115723490715027,
-0.13586363196372986,
-0.11418631672859192,
-0.6502038240432739,
0.3583734333515167,
-0.10153839737176895,
0.1716524213552475,
-0.26090505719184875,
0.8171431422233582,
-0.43074506521224976,
-0.18058092892169952,
-0.33351001143455505,
0.2033671736717224,
-0.04657924920320511,
0.48316770792007446,
-0.2575709819793701,
1.169424057006836,
0.3620227575302124,
-1.0378549098968506,
0.09271756559610367,
0.10888886451721191,
-0.5456437468528748,
0.3866022527217865,
-0.50807785987854,
0.26158472895622253,
-0.016660040244460106,
-0.28542089462280273,
-0.4180997312068939,
-0.27139776945114136,
-0.056458331644535065,
-0.3734256327152252,
0.3946479856967926,
-0.16368238627910614,
-0.4201655685901642,
-0.1850219964981079,
0.05211981013417244,
0.3656421899795532,
0.635022759437561,
-0.6280482411384583,
0.5614633560180664,
0.1638680398464203,
0.004395290277898312,
-0.438016414642334,
-0.27147001028060913,
-0.09010984748601913,
-0.36033913493156433,
-0.5687339901924133,
0.4631982147693634,
-0.04693972319364548,
-0.410248726606369,
-0.0038462048396468163,
-0.016446733847260475,
0.3098198175430298,
0.24923698604106903,
0.11478225141763687,
0.08803464472293854,
-0.41427865624427795,
0.2045169174671173,
0.01184794120490551,
0.03380551561713219,
-0.30636563897132874,
-0.2099633663892746,
0.737899124622345,
-0.010371631942689419,
-0.3025051951408386,
-0.05554821714758873,
-0.009227958507835865,
0.4737546741962433,
-0.2921544015407562,
0.7863544821739197,
0.3611826002597809,
-0.18365556001663208,
-0.39127618074417114,
-0.73649001121521,
-0.038502249866724014,
-0.48367008566856384,
0.21311970055103302,
-0.6221182942390442,
-0.9822856783866882,
0.5935437083244324,
-0.22347785532474518,
-0.026607032865285873,
0.7244736552238464,
0.5173367261886597,
0.07486510276794434,
0.7008950114250183,
0.509763240814209,
-0.2259276807308197,
0.3923599123954773,
-0.38953807950019836,
0.006104263477027416,
-0.9791949391365051,
-0.07287851721048355,
-0.5458605289459229,
-0.33888930082321167,
-0.8922151923179626,
-0.5666878819465637,
0.3577427566051483,
0.40629151463508606,
-0.4257791042327881,
0.18808621168136597,
-0.4397938549518585,
0.44402214884757996,
0.6524527668952942,
-0.04798289015889168,
0.3625181019306183,
0.10686773806810379,
-0.11507879942655563,
0.2920849621295929,
-0.7758804559707642,
-0.41306549310684204,
1.2053298950195312,
-0.05374488979578018,
0.8144444227218628,
0.25741779804229736,
0.7015219330787659,
0.27547118067741394,
0.38198184967041016,
-0.6587463021278381,
0.5145831108093262,
-0.6916264891624451,
-0.4549140930175781,
-0.30634263157844543,
-0.5180994868278503,
-0.9180343151092529,
0.14682631194591522,
-0.22301331162452698,
-0.6219351291656494,
0.12518900632858276,
0.17007997632026672,
-0.294301301240921,
0.12325795739889145,
-0.7188234925270081,
0.41858622431755066,
-0.15267471969127655,
-0.39214983582496643,
-0.5337044596672058,
-0.16337119042873383,
0.2027778923511505,
-0.17673803865909576,
0.22923356294631958,
0.09120073169469833,
0.3029022812843323,
0.5432015657424927,
-0.12936392426490784,
0.3423422574996948,
-0.1813424825668335,
-0.028563808649778366,
0.4249159097671509,
0.2211376428604126,
0.5407918095588684,
0.006202523596584797,
-0.48404014110565186,
-0.1385636329650879,
-0.3091430366039276,
-0.024569706991314888,
-0.7557610869407654,
0.8629032969474792,
-0.8605300188064575,
-0.9760234355926514,
-0.03814367204904556,
-0.7212173342704773,
-0.17859689891338348,
0.2730619013309479,
0.051444195210933685,
0.5812011957168579,
-0.22081810235977173,
0.23192495107650757,
0.6076847910881042,
-0.31351473927497864,
0.25917601585388184,
0.6076473593711853,
-0.41229256987571716,
-0.3050890862941742,
1.0231226682662964,
0.2498188018798828,
0.38935497403144836,
0.4639333188533783,
0.13819348812103271,
-0.08237158507108688,
-0.6531175374984741,
-0.6106171011924744,
0.22201567888259888,
-0.3015754818916321,
-0.4905351400375366,
-0.23827359080314636,
-0.4574984610080719,
-0.27532893419265747,
-0.07391675561666489,
-0.2701195478439331,
-0.5774451494216919,
-0.23452208936214447,
0.24978332221508026,
0.6604951024055481,
1.0098274946212769,
-0.08886267989873886,
0.15916754305362701,
-0.6221852898597717,
0.5133110284805298,
0.0916326716542244,
0.5080676078796387,
0.16318365931510925,
-0.672556459903717,
-0.5429475903511047,
0.11115147173404694,
-0.399190753698349,
-0.48944610357284546,
0.2318139225244522,
0.3090344965457916,
0.4109969735145569,
0.0685434490442276,
-0.167732372879982,
0.782914400100708,
-0.49361082911491394,
0.609220564365387,
-0.4002079963684082,
-0.6444112658500671,
0.44150564074516296,
-0.6049472093582153,
0.14624957740306854,
0.43151554465293884,
0.15329526364803314,
-0.2719448506832123,
-0.32633042335510254,
-0.6004437208175659,
-0.5859029293060303,
0.7646487355232239,
0.0689980536699295,
-0.14263539016246796,
0.08225597441196442,
0.8474957942962646,
0.1853449046611786,
0.14164750277996063,
-0.11667923629283905,
-0.2969021201133728,
0.09368794411420822,
-0.03567206859588623,
-0.4024640619754791,
-0.016994545236229897,
0.03463037684559822,
-0.08385249227285385,
0.6358026266098022,
-0.169773131608963,
0.12387950718402863,
0.06958454102277756,
-0.1399298906326294,
-0.04038926213979721,
0.1265910267829895,
0.5807640552520752,
0.5450136065483093,
-0.0004315603291615844,
-0.14759725332260132,
0.24364301562309265,
-0.4477277398109436,
-0.03192313760519028,
0.1486063450574875,
-0.5781205296516418,
-0.2203274667263031,
0.21712695062160492,
1.0434691905975342,
-0.11861088126897812,
-0.23652587831020355,
0.0015507349744439125,
0.13646253943443298,
-0.04077176749706268,
0.030362192541360855,
0.7757859826087952,
0.007626303471624851,
0.4822813868522644,
0.30266809463500977,
0.24316014349460602,
0.24051670730113983,
-0.6095252633094788,
0.02226215787231922,
0.5495370626449585,
0.1408475935459137,
-0.25152865052223206,
0.46510154008865356,
-0.04448350891470909,
-0.6179971694946289,
0.5313117504119873,
-0.32079994678497314,
-0.33864349126815796,
0.5871444940567017,
0.589815080165863,
0.6023043394088745,
-0.26351627707481384,
0.14252255856990814,
0.46930134296417236,
0.10820690542459488,
-0.12349187582731247,
0.3896859586238861,
0.04181810840964317,
-0.6726033687591553,
-0.5054710507392883,
-1.0491465330123901,
-0.25302815437316895,
0.2639833092689514,
-0.5692327618598938,
0.13874542713165283,
-0.249937504529953,
-0.1472456455230713,
-0.12472793459892273,
0.24421820044517517,
-1.0142673254013062,
0.5003288388252258,
-0.22864215075969696,
0.9793636202812195,
-0.4465583562850952,
0.5870018601417542,
0.7412205338478088,
-0.24283766746520996,
-1.2260584831237793,
0.0452248752117157,
-0.2400771826505661,
-0.6193828582763672,
0.5553192496299744,
-0.19783438742160797,
-0.1613474041223526,
0.13659566640853882,
-0.13036008179187775,
-1.0800025463104248,
1.228119969367981,
0.3097754716873169,
-0.6626004576683044,
-0.1828523874282837,
0.21717001497745514,
0.9356772899627686,
-0.23732657730579376,
0.09236199408769608,
0.7147846221923828,
0.37723633646965027,
-0.07315891981124878,
-1.3876835107803345,
-0.18796999752521515,
0.011135728098452091,
0.10944247990846634,
0.3500162661075592,
-0.9542191624641418,
0.7889305353164673,
-0.21622861921787262,
-0.25078243017196655,
0.3819948136806488,
0.43386730551719666,
0.3801940977573395,
0.26717695593833923,
0.2114889770746231,
0.7335890531539917,
0.7223349809646606,
-0.19535169005393982,
1.135682463645935,
-0.4357783794403076,
0.33250054717063904,
0.996056854724884,
-0.060988083481788635,
0.944914698600769,
0.20165564119815826,
-0.11622986197471619,
0.4887382984161377,
0.2080598622560501,
0.01574454829096794,
0.540256679058075,
0.2669302821159363,
-0.030486933887004852,
-0.07315504550933838,
0.013610473833978176,
-0.3945649564266205,
0.627606213092804,
0.549061119556427,
-0.2704697251319885,
-0.024860676378011703,
-0.16469700634479523,
-0.22647583484649658,
0.1431107521057129,
-0.5644282102584839,
1.0884737968444824,
0.19475014507770538,
-0.989717423915863,
0.9000993967056274,
-0.03446226939558983,
0.5320017337799072,
-0.20249798893928528,
0.037890154868364334,
-0.4169789254665375,
0.29133108258247375,
-0.17550648748874664,
-0.6597984433174133,
0.47233256697654724,
0.11355195939540863,
-0.3385806977748871,
0.1632263958454132,
0.9415555596351624,
-0.14958420395851135,
-0.40447738766670227,
0.37395966053009033,
0.6582467555999756,
0.13936424255371094,
0.13363872468471527,
-0.40205201506614685,
0.10993365198373795,
-0.10909801721572876,
-0.3069624900817871,
0.36103111505508423,
0.5967416763305664,
-0.1975480616092682,
0.7002301216125488,
0.5091853737831116,
0.21192939579486847,
0.12085343897342682,
0.26647889614105225,
0.9189053773880005,
-0.6613189578056335,
-0.02547173574566841,
-0.6722701787948608,
0.35175859928131104,
0.18087351322174072,
-0.190644770860672,
0.7147773504257202,
0.7269040942192078,
0.9705294370651245,
-0.24375343322753906,
0.7291547060012817,
-0.20138132572174072,
0.7973642945289612,
-0.6541351079940796,
0.8685866594314575,
-0.7856831550598145,
0.17171522974967957,
-0.31398651003837585,
-1.1610753536224365,
-0.16375768184661865,
0.366639643907547,
-0.3020510673522949,
0.25712719559669495,
0.29547059535980225,
1.0787041187286377,
-0.11132216453552246,
-0.10526934266090393,
0.3888031542301178,
0.208628848195076,
0.3192344605922699,
0.4493260085582733,
0.829917311668396,
-0.5859717130661011,
0.17912429571151733,
-0.061705488711595535,
-0.05740595608949661,
-0.26352658867836,
-0.5073859095573425,
-0.8759993314743042,
-0.550084114074707,
0.026996340602636337,
-0.20459403097629547,
0.4135631322860718,
0.44778597354888916,
0.4107736349105835,
-0.8058034777641296,
-0.1352338343858719,
-0.09398315846920013,
0.1193775087594986,
-0.0035885281395167112,
-0.22351810336112976,
0.45640718936920166,
-0.44116151332855225,
-0.6370531320571899,
0.5098121166229248,
0.22194434702396393,
-0.1275070160627365,
-0.1373252421617508,
-0.2993643581867218,
-0.02800634689629078,
0.15790913999080658,
0.7471819519996643,
0.10096509009599686,
-0.7356936931610107,
-0.607956051826477,
0.22116166353225708,
0.019891059026122093,
-0.11161492019891739,
0.47066184878349304,
-1.09694504737854,
0.18435260653495789,
0.4517726004123688,
0.6659557223320007,
0.42158129811286926,
0.2312190681695938,
0.4875589907169342,
-0.43942007422447205,
-0.10956542938947678,
0.10151831805706024,
0.049509283155202866,
0.36025097966194153,
-0.2580867409706116,
0.6428920030593872,
-0.03327937796711922,
-0.9823268055915833,
-0.5892063975334167,
0.23837587237358093,
-0.6152343153953552,
0.06190098449587822,
1.1987038850784302,
0.23186315596103668,
0.04718506708741188,
-0.08154913038015366,
-0.2785232663154602,
0.2722192406654358,
-0.16935132443904877,
1.0311142206192017,
0.417620450258255,
-0.24951504170894623,
0.15416255593299866,
-0.3559902012348175,
0.80348140001297,
0.38777956366539,
-0.5874530076980591,
-0.03208472207188606,
0.46821367740631104,
0.20912639796733856,
0.47767916321754456,
0.42777177691459656,
0.1210973933339119,
0.4573311507701874,
-0.07122842967510223,
-0.22726956009864807,
-0.12014017254114151,
-0.5722826719284058,
-0.06777293235063553,
0.09148366749286652,
0.4019099771976471,
0.31587356328964233
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08059v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08059v2
|
FluoroSAM: A Language-aligned Foundation Model for X-ray Image Segmentation
| 2024-03-12T20:11:38 | 2024-03-28T00:59:37 |
Benjamin D. Killeen, Liam J. Wang, Han Zhang, Mehran Armand, Russell H. Taylor, Dave Dreizin, Greg Osgood, Mathias Unberath
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Automated X-ray image segmentation would accelerate research and development
in diagnostic and interventional precision medicine. Prior efforts have
contributed task-specific models capable of solving specific image analysis
problems, but the utility of these models is restricted to their particular
task domain, and expanding to broader use requires additional data, labels, and
retraining efforts. Recently, foundation models (FMs) -- machine learning
models trained on large amounts of highly variable data thus enabling broad
applicability -- have emerged as promising tools for automated image analysis.
Existing FMs for medical image analysis focus on scenarios and modalities where
objects are clearly defined by visually apparent boundaries, such as surgical
tool segmentation in endoscopy. X-ray imaging, by contrast, does not generally
offer such clearly delineated boundaries or structure priors. During X-ray
image formation, complex 3D structures are projected in transmission onto the
imaging plane, resulting in overlapping features of varying opacity and shape.
To pave the way toward an FM for comprehensive and automated analysis of
arbitrary medical X-ray images, we develop FluoroSAM, a language-aligned
variant of the Segment-Anything Model, trained from scratch on 1.6M synthetic
X-ray images. FluoroSAM is trained on data including masks for 128 organ types
and 464 non-anatomical objects, such as tools and implants. In real X-ray
images of cadaveric specimens, FluoroSAM is able to segment bony anatomical
structures based on text-only prompting with 0.51 and 0.79 DICE with
point-based refinement, outperforming competing SAM variants for all
structures. FluoroSAM is also capable of zero-shot generalization to segmenting
classes beyond the training set thanks to its language alignment, which we
demonstrate for full lung segmentation on real chest X-rays.
|
[
-0.2903706431388855,
-0.7469476461410522,
0.3258618712425232,
-0.04460923373699188,
-0.5078147649765015,
-0.09937647730112076,
0.12753522396087646,
-0.5642566680908203,
0.12216406315565109,
0.5086809992790222,
-0.3723216950893402,
-0.4352516829967499,
-0.5736026167869568,
0.17021608352661133,
-0.7258871793746948,
0.8168601393699646,
-0.05764970928430557,
0.26658910512924194,
0.08425941318273544,
-0.2686101496219635,
-0.19835396111011505,
-0.020275231450796127,
-0.6904300451278687,
-0.2576550245285034,
0.2520335018634796,
0.15091118216514587,
1.152045488357544,
1.216528058052063,
0.562147855758667,
0.34287703037261963,
0.2660941183567047,
-0.27339881658554077,
-0.1830095797777176,
-0.3137763440608978,
-0.02488134428858757,
-0.4753863215446472,
-0.20422884821891785,
-0.21038272976875305,
0.6173912882804871,
0.972166895866394,
0.02356204390525818,
-0.28048163652420044,
-0.6721107959747314,
0.625204861164093,
-0.44239550828933716,
-0.17285841703414917,
-0.3371027410030365,
0.352398157119751,
-0.14208519458770752,
-0.1186068207025528,
0.21066588163375854,
-0.26927733421325684,
0.6130949854850769,
-0.5308651924133301,
0.16080957651138306,
-0.2128789871931076,
1.1535999774932861,
0.2685280442237854,
-0.35330119729042053,
-0.34932902455329895,
-0.18715421855449677,
0.6872219443321228,
-0.13094370067119598,
0.6317989230155945,
0.05827130749821663,
0.554918110370636,
0.009259562939405441,
-0.83507239818573,
0.05283817648887634,
-0.08715054392814636,
-0.19548329710960388,
-0.28478410840034485,
-0.1358109712600708,
0.2584688067436218,
-0.24007777869701385,
0.7909314036369324,
-0.7594988942146301,
-0.08874744921922684,
-0.5265890955924988,
-0.08304440975189209,
0.7169449925422668,
0.06208610534667969,
0.48365023732185364,
-0.13547049462795258,
-0.8626948595046997,
-0.07960556447505951,
-0.6507778763771057,
-0.3321774899959564,
-0.2664283215999603,
-0.15947915613651276,
-0.044161226600408554,
0.14392182230949402,
-0.10576646029949188,
1.1174641847610474,
0.09750721603631973,
-0.3182419538497925,
0.10606206953525543,
0.011399340815842152,
-0.8569273352622986,
0.25563156604766846,
0.7869372963905334,
0.010806478559970856,
0.12938474118709564,
0.1646500527858734,
-0.3083304464817047,
0.08028747141361237,
0.035974085330963135,
-0.7817871570587158,
-0.3953239619731903,
0.2999284863471985,
-0.5756219625473022,
-0.755348801612854,
0.1718074530363083,
-0.351544052362442,
-0.2871299088001251,
-0.1571970134973526,
0.5043694376945496,
-0.5809491872787476,
-0.13220568001270294,
0.46653491258621216,
-0.01625095307826996,
0.06833647191524506,
0.22502762079238892,
-0.7747418284416199,
0.4447360336780548,
0.5380096435546875,
0.9592333436012268,
0.008932714350521564,
0.12970399856567383,
-0.5153371691703796,
0.06329898536205292,
-0.5282647013664246,
0.8181728720664978,
-0.7297518253326416,
-0.7089134454727173,
-0.31809762120246887,
0.2181173413991928,
-0.09064606577157974,
-0.5921178460121155,
0.11926600337028503,
-0.3333256244659424,
0.2301175594329834,
0.0028976595494896173,
-0.4444988965988159,
-0.3912496566772461,
0.36350324749946594,
-0.8136857748031616,
0.5218037962913513,
0.5871334671974182,
-0.2548774480819702,
0.44873684644699097,
-0.626227080821991,
-0.4576263427734375,
-0.13763190805912018,
-0.8826568126678467,
-0.36191338300704956,
0.015388929285109043,
0.24303479492664337,
0.44865885376930237,
-0.5401631593704224,
0.5017246007919312,
-0.020791415125131607,
-0.2017546147108078,
0.288705974817276,
-0.26349499821662903,
0.8392226099967957,
0.21613089740276337,
-0.479085773229599,
0.36576199531555176,
-0.8518849611282349,
0.002470756648108363,
0.20804080367088318,
-0.0024653642904013395,
-0.20210912823677063,
-0.3033188283443451,
0.10199398547410965,
0.25331804156303406,
-0.026115726679563522,
-0.6462134718894958,
0.1754569113254547,
-0.44266894459724426,
0.2501295804977417,
0.4641902446746826,
-0.06314816325902939,
0.18729794025421143,
-0.5493738651275635,
0.7877376675605774,
-0.02714160457253456,
0.1838892698287964,
-0.429205983877182,
-0.47495827078819275,
-0.5463842153549194,
-0.7264828085899353,
0.46283310651779175,
0.42803388833999634,
-0.14772972464561462,
0.28358960151672363,
-0.13264380395412445,
-0.4279000163078308,
-0.4191366136074066,
-0.06690530478954315,
0.4297899603843689,
0.6525313258171082,
0.128479465842247,
-0.533481240272522,
-0.7757512331008911,
-1.015467643737793,
0.33195120096206665,
0.09667673707008362,
-0.005030496511608362,
0.007051792927086353,
0.3113517761230469,
-0.31473177671432495,
0.8848468065261841,
-0.9072510600090027,
-0.5975791215896606,
0.18663613498210907,
0.00951007567346096,
-0.007777647115290165,
0.6495343446731567,
0.7473662495613098,
-1.1707006692886353,
-0.7161205410957336,
0.432935893535614,
-0.7707359790802002,
-0.12748368084430695,
-0.20293886959552765,
-0.19790415465831757,
0.03480121120810509,
0.5622419118881226,
-0.17046457529067993,
0.34431472420692444,
0.3134204149246216,
-0.05699270963668823,
0.30413031578063965,
0.13986660540103912,
0.1957961469888687,
-0.727895200252533,
0.414294958114624,
0.17226409912109375,
-0.45886966586112976,
-0.6206662058830261,
0.17732349038124084,
0.10206195712089539,
-0.2325107902288437,
-0.37644630670547485,
0.7132803797721863,
-0.5262097120285034,
-0.08684055507183075,
-0.2530446946620941,
-0.16279128193855286,
0.2043704092502594,
0.14384803175926208,
0.7442162036895752,
0.43565836548805237,
0.65755295753479,
-0.17223571240901947,
0.013417534530162811,
0.1805289387702942,
-0.3769325911998749,
0.7772888541221619,
-0.6465114951133728,
-0.03772607445716858,
0.2831449508666992,
0.09551157057285309,
-0.7525700330734253,
-0.42600059509277344,
0.20626726746559143,
-0.15687288343906403,
0.36924082040786743,
-0.0799388438463211,
0.025608208030462265,
0.06098847836256027,
-0.30209535360336304,
0.4521889090538025,
0.3939260244369507,
-0.4166530966758728,
0.43210551142692566,
0.40799885988235474,
0.05710715055465698,
-0.5292105078697205,
-0.5913485884666443,
-0.17327576875686646,
-0.00043957759044133127,
-0.9327811002731323,
0.7500910758972168,
0.03271742910146713,
-0.3305647075176239,
0.1736060231924057,
-0.2938079535961151,
-0.6498374342918396,
0.07009926438331604,
0.2912645936012268,
0.18133626878261566,
-0.4596661329269409,
-0.11051810532808304,
0.272626668214798,
-0.3911210894584656,
-0.08137544244527817,
-0.3864942193031311,
0.26624879240989685,
-0.14585958421230316,
-0.23679693043231964,
-0.25033724308013916,
0.3585285544395447,
0.5963682532310486,
-0.10879573971033096,
0.1086374819278717,
0.38406604528427124,
-0.7780719995498657,
0.18700151145458221,
-0.37849682569503784,
0.12658163905143738,
-0.4713079035282135,
0.46959710121154785,
-0.35829198360443115,
-0.7271081805229187,
0.16085787117481232,
0.2018245905637741,
0.1962897926568985,
0.2816503345966339,
0.3222050964832306,
0.029858214780688286,
1.2617290019989014,
0.7039810419082642,
0.11534390598535538,
0.3957246243953705,
-0.3505323827266693,
-0.11162606626749039,
-0.5408550500869751,
-0.1492059826850891,
-0.3057537078857422,
-0.1738184094429016,
0.03760800510644913,
-0.21278761327266693,
0.4012417793273926,
-0.1403300166130066,
0.20246689021587372,
-0.02997557446360588,
-0.6799750328063965,
0.5664148330688477,
-0.09111631661653519,
-0.06937527656555176,
0.18011847138404846,
0.16307415068149567,
0.03141878545284271,
0.29266658425331116,
-0.5082641243934631,
-0.3756331503391266,
0.9235842227935791,
0.2836933135986328,
0.568421483039856,
-0.31506335735321045,
0.776709794998169,
0.30600497126579285,
0.44331854581832886,
-0.88429856300354,
0.33069756627082825,
-0.3406829535961151,
-0.9263818264007568,
-0.18342545628547668,
-0.0802651047706604,
-1.1681694984436035,
0.40787726640701294,
0.06527913361787796,
-0.4587278366088867,
0.43938031792640686,
0.11992102116346359,
-0.7877786159515381,
0.17362290620803833,
-0.4861096143722534,
0.9072003960609436,
-0.4303329288959503,
0.06164032965898514,
-0.030740218237042427,
-0.8885744214057922,
0.4193952977657318,
-0.4138806462287903,
0.34819120168685913,
-0.08871051669120789,
-0.18020470440387726,
0.6056411862373352,
-0.7150191068649292,
0.7228412628173828,
-0.08531858026981354,
-0.3504181206226349,
0.06798996776342392,
0.09959909319877625,
-0.1505601406097412,
0.05172749236226082,
-0.09488213062286377,
0.03821723535656929,
0.5830015540122986,
-0.3106519877910614,
-0.5970612168312073,
0.5348129868507385,
-0.5075013637542725,
-0.5058076977729797,
-0.4123653769493103,
-0.44691580533981323,
0.03500593826174736,
0.3996357321739197,
0.3595389425754547,
0.6307487487792969,
-0.44840410351753235,
0.2063102275133133,
0.5578789710998535,
0.21313482522964478,
-0.13960058987140656,
0.29989635944366455,
-0.35893115401268005,
-0.6513079404830933,
0.9481586217880249,
0.2651589512825012,
0.019686955958604813,
0.7478681206703186,
0.4037295877933502,
-0.07087092101573944,
-0.5315877795219421,
-0.6391121745109558,
0.1363876610994339,
-0.7528800368309021,
-0.3588795065879822,
-0.4485803544521332,
-0.05098646879196167,
-0.0834418535232544,
-0.8660513758659363,
-0.14356650412082672,
-0.4611496031284332,
-0.20732316374778748,
0.0871976986527443,
0.1437583565711975,
0.3314827084541321,
-0.19373077154159546,
0.4616413712501526,
-0.9899591207504272,
0.2830568552017212,
0.018521904945373535,
0.17388522624969482,
-0.30393725633621216,
-0.11613935232162476,
-0.2922545075416565,
-0.26025986671447754,
-0.017790233716368675,
-0.8665124177932739,
0.1886027753353119,
0.3269602954387665,
0.34510505199432373,
0.905203104019165,
-0.2752652168273926,
0.7455129623413086,
-0.014885308220982552,
0.3359997272491455,
0.24429762363433838,
-0.863961935043335,
0.4941168427467346,
-0.2349855899810791,
0.1259148120880127,
0.5182034373283386,
0.3291301131248474,
-0.454997181892395,
0.001167098875157535,
-0.6389914751052856,
-0.4746089577674866,
0.6245859265327454,
-0.0063591692596673965,
-0.3362100422382355,
-0.28210315108299255,
0.3567551076412201,
0.5315625071525574,
0.273298054933548,
-0.37004518508911133,
0.12782591581344604,
-0.14863884449005127,
-0.6097389459609985,
0.4888431131839752,
0.0979406088590622,
-0.41800519824028015,
-0.18423062562942505,
0.6169009208679199,
-0.24913617968559265,
0.07004965096712112,
0.3671714663505554,
-0.5259398818016052,
-0.2701418399810791,
-0.14610211551189423,
0.6011040210723877,
0.49460095167160034,
-0.15160639584064484,
-0.01018273364752531,
-0.16634659469127655,
-0.6128915548324585,
0.45847633481025696,
0.21184919774532318,
-0.012726415880024433,
-0.06260266155004501,
0.2462008148431778,
0.4370516836643219,
0.3797420859336853,
-0.818623960018158,
0.349626749753952,
-0.031517814844846725,
-0.3660757839679718,
-0.2606229782104492,
0.5053407549858093,
-0.28709957003593445,
0.08253330737352371,
0.36647069454193115,
0.2089632898569107,
0.21238629519939423,
-0.2607955038547516,
0.5254805684089661,
0.4350968897342682,
-0.6662676930427551,
-0.2578026354312897,
0.34636959433555603,
0.27568289637565613,
0.06027804687619209,
0.546665608882904,
0.15505053102970123,
-0.2095923274755478,
0.9460555911064148,
0.3254730999469757,
0.843473494052887,
-0.44013017416000366,
0.2169814556837082,
0.018890036270022392,
0.208902046084404,
0.18253448605537415,
0.3620245158672333,
-0.1771061271429062,
-0.5309592485427856,
-0.037586942315101624,
-0.5024730563163757,
-0.10190065205097198,
0.1312912553548813,
-0.5904148817062378,
0.4849061965942383,
-0.8897703289985657,
-0.03736337646842003,
0.14519883692264557,
-0.033775445073843,
-0.185852512717247,
1.0308870077133179,
0.0064908224157989025,
1.1599663496017456,
-0.7260390520095825,
0.824435293674469,
0.7664212584495544,
-0.27115878462791443,
-0.3039538264274597,
-0.25147557258605957,
0.2515977919101715,
-0.9122766256332397,
0.1153968796133995,
0.527381420135498,
-0.07891112565994263,
0.16162842512130737,
-0.17940464615821838,
-0.9120816588401794,
1.117147445678711,
0.3967546820640564,
-0.4332151412963867,
-0.10926826298236847,
0.11999978125095367,
0.2591162323951721,
-0.6401280164718628,
-0.06700961291790009,
0.8496707677841187,
0.3773850202560425,
0.05359579622745514,
-0.6325596570968628,
0.31288444995880127,
-0.2942230701446533,
-0.15287892520427704,
0.5766796469688416,
-0.41002845764160156,
0.6481484174728394,
-0.1535581350326538,
-0.23037661612033844,
0.31741446256637573,
0.5457181930541992,
0.18221616744995117,
0.1370953768491745,
0.8186047673225403,
0.4147467017173767,
0.7316803932189941,
-0.168196901679039,
0.7940919995307922,
-0.3133195638656616,
-0.00955311581492424,
0.423944354057312,
-0.2011345475912094,
0.19022969901561737,
0.33212926983833313,
-0.01751215010881424,
0.5321499109268188,
0.8285954594612122,
-0.32680147886276245,
0.47613292932510376,
-0.0940980315208435,
-0.18208229541778564,
-0.19376637041568756,
0.0699843317270279,
-0.49317196011543274,
0.5401300191879272,
0.7756182551383972,
-0.596851110458374,
-0.1890808343887329,
0.12494407594203949,
0.041708219796419144,
-0.3834058940410614,
-0.18667292594909668,
0.4905196726322174,
0.1191876009106636,
-0.3638685345649719,
0.7865007519721985,
0.18214382231235504,
0.4771219491958618,
-1.0152896642684937,
-0.013415772467851639,
0.002874455414712429,
-0.012753704562783241,
-0.6417109966278076,
-0.4607298672199249,
0.6890310049057007,
-0.2923811376094818,
0.024643216282129288,
0.4457549750804901,
0.5642722845077515,
-0.22433814406394958,
-0.4634671211242676,
-0.00980380829423666,
0.008365367539227009,
0.11262920498847961,
-0.0007951658917590976,
-0.8212129473686218,
0.359608918428421,
0.1730974316596985,
-0.06596031785011292,
0.3347029685974121,
0.17677977681159973,
-0.4616166651248932,
0.4503494203090668,
0.44441893696784973,
-0.2846049666404724,
-0.24464136362075806,
-0.35413774847984314,
0.7160618901252747,
-0.40838104486465454,
-0.6542103290557861,
-0.5796937942504883,
0.5487735867500305,
-0.0449252650141716,
-0.31661874055862427,
0.04776078462600708,
0.571906566619873,
0.8347620368003845,
0.06417682021856308,
0.7766324877738953,
-0.10986993461847305,
-0.11729557067155838,
-0.5953552722930908,
0.5829763412475586,
-0.8535983562469482,
-0.06429210305213928,
-0.24825213849544525,
-0.48471108078956604,
-0.7267204523086548,
1.0262000560760498,
-0.1618172973394394,
0.09968402236700058,
0.7441732883453369,
0.769569456577301,
-0.36163029074668884,
0.04651434347033501,
0.40060076117515564,
-0.2000521421432495,
0.2831074595451355,
0.19548925757408142,
0.41452306509017944,
-0.26172569394111633,
0.5656500458717346,
-0.4874306321144104,
-0.5603827834129333,
-0.3510236442089081,
-0.4736904799938202,
-0.5849476456642151,
-0.5543860197067261,
-0.6889516115188599,
0.05245274677872658,
0.035534974187612534,
0.8170135021209717,
1.1249163150787354,
-0.642276406288147,
-0.38128429651260376,
-0.08513767272233963,
0.010527562350034714,
-0.32140353322029114,
-0.1738465279340744,
0.681735098361969,
-0.05369366332888603,
-0.7018696665763855,
0.5659478902816772,
0.6838268041610718,
0.12442148476839066,
-0.3400774598121643,
-0.0046716053038835526,
-0.010796708054840565,
0.20331355929374695,
0.2762453556060791,
0.6737826466560364,
-0.5929029583930969,
-0.049183424562215805,
0.12326043099164963,
-0.031518206000328064,
0.5715233683586121,
0.7478755712509155,
-0.7239440083503723,
0.6557927131652832,
0.39594149589538574,
0.47856318950653076,
0.16905967891216278,
-0.12753571569919586,
0.7742153406143188,
-0.5860939025878906,
0.1419326663017273,
0.10579134523868561,
0.5905076265335083,
0.400714248418808,
-0.5245442390441895,
0.5958623290061951,
0.11965131014585495,
-0.2535153329372406,
-0.9166436195373535,
0.2373145967721939,
-0.6218292117118835,
-0.4727430045604706,
0.6299583911895752,
-0.05749158188700676,
-0.6010245084762573,
-0.19972895085811615,
-0.5088711380958557,
0.19497595727443695,
-0.005617741961032152,
0.5996145606040955,
0.29762476682662964,
-0.3116084039211273,
-0.22003374993801117,
0.10375877469778061,
0.471608430147171,
0.39320695400238037,
-0.7764703631401062,
-0.41283419728279114,
0.5227547883987427,
0.5674191117286682,
0.25619253516197205,
0.8506416082382202,
-0.5582293272018433,
0.8035666942596436,
-0.23270201683044434,
-0.13800832629203796,
-0.22532503306865692,
-0.3209793269634247,
-0.6088238954544067,
0.4965205192565918,
-0.05798919126391411,
-0.4093140661716461
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08058v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08058v2
|
CHAI: Clustered Head Attention for Efficient LLM Inference
| 2024-03-12T20:10:04 | 2024-04-27T22:45:39 |
Saurabh Agarwal, Bilge Acun, Basil Hosmer, Mostafa Elhoushi, Yejin Lee, Shivaram Venkataraman, Dimitris Papailiopoulos, Carole-Jean Wu
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) with hundreds of billions of parameters have
transformed the field of machine learning. However, serving these models at
inference time is both compute and memory intensive, where a single request can
require multiple GPUs and tens of Gigabytes of memory. Multi-Head Attention is
one of the key components of LLMs, which can account for over 50% of LLMs
memory and compute requirement. We observe that there is a high amount of
redundancy across heads on which tokens they pay attention to. Based on this
insight, we propose Clustered Head Attention (CHAI). CHAI combines heads with a
high amount of correlation for self-attention at runtime, thus reducing both
memory and compute. In our experiments, we show that CHAI is able to reduce the
memory requirements for storing K,V cache by up to 21.4% and inference time
latency by up to 1.73x without any fine-tuning required. CHAI achieves this
with a maximum 3.2% deviation in accuracy across 3 different models (i.e.
OPT-66B, LLAMA-7B, LLAMA-33B) and 5 different evaluation datasets.
|
[
-0.4154319763183594,
-0.7908406257629395,
0.6549482345581055,
0.5634788870811462,
-0.19751064479351044,
-0.12347947806119919,
-0.3434222936630249,
-0.3670586943626404,
0.2723064124584198,
0.5182948112487793,
-0.6155771017074585,
-0.420083224773407,
-0.5386146903038025,
-0.23880434036254883,
-0.34543925523757935,
0.6640023589134216,
0.44475606083869934,
-0.13811510801315308,
-0.3948233127593994,
-0.1856931447982788,
-0.5124125480651855,
-0.3465704023838043,
-0.8970781564712524,
-0.2626328766345978,
1.018998146057129,
0.3017132580280304,
0.3900534510612488,
0.9296702742576599,
0.6214916706085205,
0.2792414128780365,
0.0009092674590647221,
0.3352646231651306,
-0.6694174408912659,
0.07422598451375961,
-0.13110396265983582,
-0.4929627478122711,
-0.7083671689033508,
-0.12639249861240387,
0.601473867893219,
0.6798588633537292,
-0.15346689522266388,
0.07441017031669617,
-0.02897639200091362,
0.8128174543380737,
-1.3078001737594604,
0.09104380756616592,
-0.8086984753608704,
-0.10678454488515854,
-0.3114590644836426,
-0.0696391686797142,
-0.4820910394191742,
0.11416663229465485,
0.11221383512020111,
-0.47938966751098633,
0.37755274772644043,
0.03760671615600586,
0.5260079503059387,
0.7070024609565735,
-0.16801424324512482,
0.3370782434940338,
-0.39488860964775085,
1.286800503730774,
-0.6750168800354004,
0.4999818801879883,
0.35289767384529114,
0.1669410914182663,
-0.02270890213549137,
-0.5292875170707703,
-0.6182762384414673,
0.17224472761154175,
-0.04713491350412369,
0.40333977341651917,
-0.09138382226228714,
0.005034499801695347,
0.11338701844215393,
0.23663708567619324,
-0.4433080852031708,
0.19916172325611115,
0.03543875738978386,
-0.035569630563259125,
0.5740380883216858,
0.1673911064863205,
-0.07029516994953156,
0.3259415626525879,
-0.1907479465007782,
-0.16030223667621613,
-0.6358740925788879,
-0.5129574537277222,
-0.047897908836603165,
0.388705849647522,
-0.2290724515914917,
0.23756518959999084,
-0.26961129903793335,
1.0673691034317017,
0.3164055645465851,
-0.31287920475006104,
0.06454510986804962,
-0.3188665211200714,
-0.4297487437725067,
-0.017371678724884987,
0.8194546699523926,
0.22254832088947296,
0.35602933168411255,
-0.34888777136802673,
0.0557435005903244,
0.2549470067024231,
0.4830523729324341,
-0.687092125415802,
-0.0963045135140419,
0.5617008805274963,
-0.2639347314834595,
-0.1700868457555771,
-0.1870063990354538,
-0.8733857870101929,
-0.37949666380882263,
-0.33549681305885315,
-0.18494239449501038,
-0.2133604884147644,
0.009758793748915195,
0.01878751814365387,
0.1097414568066597,
0.4927516579627991,
0.3888578712940216,
-0.8706655502319336,
0.20514275133609772,
0.6905344128608704,
0.8949266076087952,
-0.7773013710975647,
-0.4264677166938782,
-0.7489401698112488,
0.6514162421226501,
-0.0937022939324379,
0.9656974673271179,
-0.6452720165252686,
-0.3301221430301666,
-0.26697298884391785,
-0.1523989737033844,
-0.4072616696357727,
-0.6288537383079529,
0.3954698443412781,
-0.5881836414337158,
-0.34339383244514465,
-0.16248095035552979,
-0.4469415545463562,
-0.1725505143404007,
0.049528561532497406,
-0.6101511120796204,
0.8722754716873169,
-0.007865450344979763,
-0.9126924276351929,
-0.020087281242012978,
-0.2561268210411072,
-0.5837905406951904,
-0.013384796679019928,
-0.23723651468753815,
-0.679927408695221,
0.19640254974365234,
0.5582533478736877,
0.6913309097290039,
-0.5933564901351929,
0.24986931681632996,
-0.7046419978141785,
-0.3422345817089081,
0.053660549223423004,
-0.054286688566207886,
0.47049587965011597,
0.26992267370224,
-0.36262401938438416,
0.18278668820858002,
-0.7638435363769531,
-0.020104428753256798,
0.04116860777139664,
0.10307571291923523,
-0.41983893513679504,
0.12037433683872223,
0.11878050863742828,
-0.005378689616918564,
0.2764279842376709,
-0.3169095814228058,
-0.1227610632777214,
-0.1673182249069214,
0.5217971205711365,
0.5993062853813171,
-0.004308043047785759,
0.19930116832256317,
-0.1281111091375351,
0.28635236620903015,
0.4198872148990631,
-0.174784317612648,
-0.1503058820962906,
-0.2469216138124466,
-1.1419413089752197,
-0.5363098382949829,
0.08569911867380142,
0.48711249232292175,
-0.16733643412590027,
0.5376448035240173,
-0.26517435908317566,
-0.5147364139556885,
-0.6356810331344604,
0.16188393533229828,
0.5312958359718323,
0.550589382648468,
0.15982015430927277,
-0.13695590198040009,
-0.48727327585220337,
-1.2011135816574097,
-0.2239866554737091,
0.020794443786144257,
0.0496755950152874,
0.5049185156822205,
0.2591060996055603,
-0.4084465801715851,
0.9798531532287598,
-0.5243691205978394,
-0.2856476306915283,
-0.18265247344970703,
-0.06432496011257172,
0.05792921036481857,
0.366089791059494,
0.3763909637928009,
-0.5823918581008911,
-0.5012710094451904,
0.2344977855682373,
-0.6535109281539917,
-0.38303297758102417,
-0.26933372020721436,
-0.3989007771015167,
0.04851304739713669,
0.44184011220932007,
-0.6402794122695923,
0.2104804813861847,
0.4417279064655304,
0.15601278841495514,
0.25898751616477966,
0.12446253001689911,
0.03922013193368912,
-0.9242630004882812,
0.20156234502792358,
0.290961891412735,
-0.3230811059474945,
-0.5564886331558228,
0.167311429977417,
0.26174837350845337,
0.1123114600777626,
-0.4960877597332001,
0.7206779718399048,
-0.5927549004554749,
-0.2239995151758194,
-0.4515988528728485,
0.4593808054924011,
-0.17507418990135193,
0.8713592886924744,
0.2319391965866089,
1.1365768909454346,
0.7156025171279907,
-1.032644271850586,
0.05136384069919586,
0.05593918636441231,
-0.053443796932697296,
0.7365520000457764,
-0.853249728679657,
0.4829976260662079,
-0.0033416382502764463,
0.11472510546445847,
-0.9028077125549316,
-0.3665735721588135,
-0.035892389714717865,
-0.20825988054275513,
0.28145939111709595,
0.25514495372772217,
-0.19084355235099792,
-0.2745929956436157,
-0.26253029704093933,
0.6408329606056213,
0.2186359167098999,
-0.6261951923370361,
0.5814818143844604,
0.9248416423797607,
0.0230206660926342,
-0.5892265439033508,
-0.8834524750709534,
-0.08318542689085007,
-0.4201928675174713,
-0.3876146674156189,
0.33450397849082947,
0.050651662051677704,
-0.23468512296676636,
-0.12036221474409103,
-0.11710144579410553,
-0.20192860066890717,
-0.16765791177749634,
0.16280433535575867,
0.10219553858041763,
-0.0828598365187645,
0.06281132996082306,
-0.09810727089643478,
-0.29479920864105225,
-0.2366165667772293,
-0.41658642888069153,
0.5690271258354187,
-0.09381068497896194,
-0.3837951719760895,
-0.6748532652854919,
0.5320741534233093,
0.870717465877533,
-0.460534006357193,
0.7107259035110474,
0.6684826612472534,
-0.4025537669658661,
-0.03922788426280022,
-1.0577279329299927,
-0.13430088758468628,
-0.4218076765537262,
0.5127229690551758,
-0.4286637604236603,
-1.0097324848175049,
0.6065524816513062,
0.0864824503660202,
0.008136679418385029,
0.4655970633029938,
0.9972838163375854,
-0.042067140340805054,
0.8496042490005493,
0.31931206583976746,
-0.6868948936462402,
0.3876553177833557,
-0.07109145075082779,
0.2370012402534485,
-1.0008422136306763,
-0.037048228085041046,
-0.39228785037994385,
-0.32582634687423706,
-0.3413250148296356,
-0.5998143553733826,
0.3627232611179352,
-0.24662961065769196,
-0.19345620274543762,
0.16961440443992615,
-0.45810848474502563,
0.5601823329925537,
0.6518446803092957,
0.2952001988887787,
0.11047245562076569,
0.050604887306690216,
0.2691662311553955,
-0.014756186865270138,
-0.7697670459747314,
-0.13568559288978577,
0.8926587700843811,
0.19219085574150085,
0.8789571523666382,
-0.18064549565315247,
0.4209691882133484,
0.2431221902370453,
-0.023393291980028152,
-0.7493340969085693,
0.6668784618377686,
-0.10980399698019028,
-0.18959619104862213,
-0.2442268580198288,
-0.39958369731903076,
-1.0768592357635498,
0.43513837456703186,
0.2767580449581146,
-0.6638897061347961,
0.04365890845656395,
0.35223284363746643,
-0.473620742559433,
0.1152961403131485,
-0.793053150177002,
0.7287534475326538,
0.06132447347044945,
-0.6502702236175537,
-0.7251663208007812,
-0.5993266701698303,
0.6230157613754272,
-0.22008463740348816,
0.0109044024720788,
0.03892022743821144,
-0.20515675842761993,
0.7420669198036194,
-0.27048930525779724,
1.189237356185913,
0.09848859906196594,
0.03304562345147133,
0.5256929397583008,
-0.34057092666625977,
0.756740152835846,
-0.04256565868854523,
0.1878339946269989,
0.32854074239730835,
-0.19936427474021912,
-0.6605305075645447,
-0.6372140645980835,
1.1189148426055908,
-0.8540100455284119,
-0.681155264377594,
-0.30218952894210815,
-0.8022210597991943,
-0.3638092875480652,
0.17407122254371643,
-0.16265438497066498,
0.03557589650154114,
0.0815482810139656,
0.12149089574813843,
0.8562974333763123,
0.01322745718061924,
0.4347517192363739,
0.2664444148540497,
0.13201592862606049,
-0.5302448272705078,
0.8715028762817383,
-0.10981889069080353,
0.2517319321632385,
0.4682207703590393,
0.11658509075641632,
-0.15752960741519928,
-0.5981400012969971,
-0.1648804396390915,
0.7509461045265198,
-0.38417866826057434,
-0.17210111021995544,
-1.072728157043457,
-0.16919776797294617,
-0.5471258759498596,
0.03057216852903366,
-0.6777715086936951,
-0.278788685798645,
-0.25498613715171814,
0.2940729856491089,
0.3334820866584778,
0.2863524854183197,
0.3645883798599243,
0.9681257605552673,
-0.6402742266654968,
0.3722555339336395,
0.41392678022384644,
0.2501928210258484,
0.360357403755188,
-0.40209221839904785,
-0.43461066484451294,
-0.2803723216056824,
-0.19792069494724274,
-0.6454268097877502,
0.440481960773468,
0.08752500265836716,
0.5825686454772949,
0.7500985860824585,
-0.09084539115428925,
1.2173192501068115,
-0.48727819323539734,
0.3995310068130493,
0.0569818876683712,
-0.7868995666503906,
0.5015712380409241,
-0.4688850939273834,
0.7045309543609619,
0.5719477534294128,
0.07022735476493835,
-0.4338253438472748,
-0.49074217677116394,
-0.40128204226493835,
-0.5845736265182495,
0.7594868540763855,
0.057310789823532104,
-0.3830075263977051,
-0.1890440136194229,
0.494657039642334,
-0.0811372920870781,
0.20858751237392426,
-0.541869044303894,
-0.3352791666984558,
0.3932171165943146,
-0.12261962890625,
-0.0936511754989624,
-0.40696248412132263,
-0.024769648909568787,
-0.21574831008911133,
0.7656648755073547,
-0.1722596138715744,
0.45373213291168213,
0.0946037769317627,
-0.15500600636005402,
0.10105212032794952,
-0.13672403991222382,
0.5629070997238159,
0.5592016577720642,
0.029809337109327316,
0.35635167360305786,
0.37168586254119873,
-0.5438260436058044,
-0.17302362620830536,
-0.4413260817527771,
-0.0993606448173523,
-0.35970446467399597,
0.420894056558609,
0.906484842300415,
0.2849165201187134,
-0.6621928811073303,
0.1589401811361313,
0.05985471233725548,
0.12482790648937225,
-0.23561185598373413,
0.17070336639881134,
0.3636617064476013,
0.15954558551311493,
-0.09766140580177307,
-0.07533577084541321,
0.02935107611119747,
-0.14662855863571167,
0.24771130084991455,
0.6401621103286743,
-0.3171986937522888,
-0.17754152417182922,
0.6288448572158813,
0.17146001756191254,
-0.044981587678194046,
0.5034999847412109,
0.11265022307634354,
-0.263395220041275,
0.510612964630127,
0.5698010325431824,
1.1710412502288818,
-0.42077895998954773,
-0.2800212502479553,
0.4900034964084625,
0.11768932640552521,
0.04476774111390114,
-0.07016360759735107,
-0.16549740731716156,
-0.6757630705833435,
-0.5472842454910278,
-0.5953091979026794,
-0.4005512595176697,
0.3295343816280365,
-0.6546947360038757,
0.1972895860671997,
-0.3193514049053192,
-0.16318157315254211,
-0.012345593422651291,
-0.15186920762062073,
-0.45927366614341736,
0.23640131950378418,
0.11824272572994232,
0.5368999242782593,
-0.7410938739776611,
1.0953259468078613,
0.4720544219017029,
0.11996084451675415,
-0.12558665871620178,
0.03591896593570709,
-0.08227314054965973,
-0.9312662482261658,
0.4077354669570923,
0.2851904630661011,
-0.5620235800743103,
0.18388094007968903,
-0.47616687417030334,
-0.9927843809127808,
0.8986971974372864,
0.39727655053138733,
-0.9567088484764099,
0.09850285202264786,
-0.02977128140628338,
0.20677712559700012,
-0.5666927099227905,
0.41663655638694763,
0.9058879613876343,
0.4642404019832611,
0.22171691060066223,
-0.5111042857170105,
-0.22336386144161224,
-0.04042091965675354,
0.22420987486839294,
0.07561272382736206,
-1.2227704524993896,
0.7025539875030518,
-0.27530503273010254,
-0.3394099175930023,
-0.30837661027908325,
1.115315556526184,
0.6176159977912903,
0.31801027059555054,
0.6984373927116394,
0.7819414734840393,
0.7958936095237732,
0.11259707808494568,
1.1511056423187256,
-0.5118743181228638,
0.2250344306230545,
1.2780121564865112,
-0.3454524874687195,
0.8697772026062012,
0.8427708148956299,
-0.34186631441116333,
0.053819719702005386,
0.9000254273414612,
0.26060375571250916,
0.6310817003250122,
0.053247880190610886,
-0.3378494083881378,
-0.6159555315971375,
-0.15689069032669067,
-0.12377206981182098,
0.34143945574760437,
0.36512425541877747,
0.014379548840224743,
-0.04767381772398949,
-0.14581574499607086,
-0.0064161098562181,
-0.07777781784534454,
-0.3079114556312561,
0.5912577509880066,
0.21335674822330475,
-0.8896492719650269,
0.52616947889328,
-0.1430458426475525,
0.5586649179458618,
-0.5522607564926147,
0.25138524174690247,
-0.3289025127887726,
0.6202155351638794,
-0.05872006714344025,
-0.1408059298992157,
0.3992050290107727,
-0.17596064507961273,
-0.4454220235347748,
0.20501258969306946,
0.6513375639915466,
-0.559533953666687,
-0.690040647983551,
0.4025748670101166,
0.42163944244384766,
0.2348690927028656,
-0.4321954548358917,
-0.5836889743804932,
0.347574919462204,
-0.023716242983937263,
-0.3569931983947754,
0.49181124567985535,
0.2562572956085205,
-0.21618333458900452,
0.9926441311836243,
0.457821249961853,
0.07851006835699081,
0.24152155220508575,
0.26351654529571533,
0.8248005509376526,
-0.7373806834220886,
-0.6773127317428589,
-1.113084077835083,
0.013118582777678967,
-0.1446092426776886,
-0.029331045225262642,
0.7374072074890137,
0.5801982879638672,
0.5501663684844971,
-0.23861470818519592,
0.8623232245445251,
0.30937057733535767,
0.5253099799156189,
-0.442859411239624,
0.5763295292854309,
-0.5712148547172546,
0.055365968495607376,
-0.14129148423671722,
-1.0897271633148193,
-0.5300806760787964,
0.6791796684265137,
-0.14968439936637878,
0.2158893644809723,
0.8818736672401428,
0.8032941818237305,
-0.22626610100269318,
-0.09652620553970337,
0.4146644175052643,
0.20335210859775543,
0.15471799671649933,
0.828140377998352,
0.3762136995792389,
-0.19563888013362885,
0.12018902599811554,
-0.16989994049072266,
-0.27782848477363586,
-0.031645823270082474,
-0.7832509875297546,
-1.1420871019363403,
-0.32851147651672363,
-0.7176747918128967,
0.04640353098511696,
0.03537096083164215,
0.5240746736526489,
0.967193067073822,
-1.086739420890808,
-0.5000224709510803,
-0.21700797975063324,
-0.052121903747320175,
-0.44757723808288574,
-0.18251709640026093,
0.6371164917945862,
-0.7210963368415833,
-1.1007293462753296,
0.3771107792854309,
0.5473876595497131,
-0.28179556131362915,
-0.43735140562057495,
0.020850805565714836,
-0.3336145877838135,
0.04642442613840103,
0.6853097677230835,
0.0753883644938469,
-1.0631023645401,
-0.1821981519460678,
-0.09612435102462769,
-0.1876552850008011,
0.06197460740804672,
0.8496384620666504,
-0.8236179947853088,
0.30586326122283936,
0.28518107533454895,
1.1415239572525024,
0.9674986600875854,
0.021250931546092033,
0.5402818918228149,
-0.6418246626853943,
0.43099603056907654,
-0.006774252280592918,
0.2670817971229553,
0.17780563235282898,
-0.4605827331542969,
0.6558769345283508,
0.485939085483551,
-0.6263195872306824,
-0.6661098003387451,
0.09407927095890045,
-1.5454727411270142,
-0.0337916761636734,
1.1691107749938965,
-0.06383710354566574,
-0.7325634956359863,
0.12491049617528915,
-0.013865546323359013,
0.3248597979545593,
-0.33939769864082336,
0.7863774299621582,
0.7033061385154724,
-0.2450399249792099,
-0.5290322303771973,
-0.5719400644302368,
0.058676306158304214,
0.8079326152801514,
-0.8072364926338196,
0.4441983997821808,
0.18312881886959076,
-0.1546170860528946,
0.10890600085258484,
0.5212785601615906,
0.05986250191926956,
0.08630803972482681,
0.04672614857554436,
0.24871517717838287,
0.12860023975372314,
-0.41813820600509644,
-0.13622932136058807,
0.17092984914779663,
-0.33361926674842834,
-0.5080472230911255
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08053v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08053v1
|
Generating Clarification Questions for Disambiguating Contracts
| 2024-03-12T19:57:39 | 2024-03-12T19:57:39 |
Anmol Singhal, Chirag Jain, Preethu Rose Anish, Arkajyoti Chakraborty, Smita Ghaisas
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Enterprises frequently enter into commercial contracts that can serve as
vital sources of project-specific requirements. Contractual clauses are
obligatory, and the requirements derived from contracts can detail the
downstream implementation activities that non-legal stakeholders, including
requirement analysts, engineers, and delivery personnel, need to conduct.
However, comprehending contracts is cognitively demanding and error-prone for
such stakeholders due to the extensive use of Legalese and the inherent
complexity of contract language. Furthermore, contracts often contain
ambiguously worded clauses to ensure comprehensive coverage. In contrast,
non-legal stakeholders require a detailed and unambiguous comprehension of
contractual clauses to craft actionable requirements. In this work, we
introduce a novel legal NLP task that involves generating clarification
questions for contracts. These questions aim to identify contract ambiguities
on a document level, thereby assisting non-legal stakeholders in obtaining the
necessary details for eliciting requirements. This task is challenged by three
core issues: (1) data availability, (2) the length and unstructured nature of
contracts, and (3) the complexity of legal text. To address these issues, we
propose ConRAP, a retrieval-augmented prompting framework for generating
clarification questions to disambiguate contractual text. Experiments conducted
on contracts sourced from the publicly available CUAD dataset show that ConRAP
with ChatGPT can detect ambiguities with an F2 score of 0.87. 70% of the
generated clarification questions are deemed useful by human evaluators.
|
[
-0.5424075126647949,
-0.8795916438102722,
0.6571464538574219,
0.1791827529668808,
-0.5304875373840332,
-0.016880089417099953,
0.03203972801566124,
-0.61049884557724,
0.26535600423812866,
0.7876880168914795,
-0.5367688536643982,
-0.500129759311676,
-0.6002960205078125,
-0.04611368477344513,
-0.2893578112125397,
0.9509172439575195,
-0.09671667218208313,
-0.6383187174797058,
-0.1329413801431656,
-0.30138516426086426,
-0.6913145184516907,
-0.29511985182762146,
-0.4411821961402893,
-0.33176612854003906,
0.3754797577857971,
0.7893404364585876,
0.884780764579773,
0.13360673189163208,
0.16032855212688446,
0.3059796988964081,
-0.2600668668746948,
0.47538378834724426,
0.14102576673030853,
0.30983930826187134,
-0.3269655108451843,
-0.35469165444374084,
-0.0039032294880598783,
-0.06481847167015076,
0.14250445365905762,
0.9113803505897522,
-0.3043575882911682,
0.5120143890380859,
0.04772193357348442,
0.8287444710731506,
-0.7646355032920837,
0.11266869306564331,
-0.8842395544052124,
-0.06987642496824265,
-0.0482136569917202,
-0.4165005385875702,
-0.3262443244457245,
-0.12967173755168915,
0.18910501897335052,
-0.8191530108451843,
0.3299895226955414,
0.13179589807987213,
1.3424758911132812,
0.5376340746879578,
-0.8010621666908264,
-0.9297437071800232,
-0.3073536157608032,
0.3086603879928589,
-0.3765389919281006,
0.28843507170677185,
0.41353461146354675,
0.13796158134937286,
-0.2316889613866806,
-0.9255408048629761,
-0.43014687299728394,
-0.39028021693229675,
-0.406858891248703,
0.23474296927452087,
-0.33074307441711426,
0.26001086831092834,
0.5327563285827637,
0.11621459573507309,
-0.49155497550964355,
-0.11661326140165329,
-0.5295491814613342,
-0.07800740748643875,
0.6706435680389404,
-0.18094545602798462,
0.22743795812129974,
-0.34717676043510437,
-0.20622065663337708,
0.48926839232444763,
-0.5097812414169312,
0.26173391938209534,
0.6719011664390564,
-0.09585289657115936,
-0.06814564764499664,
0.6822589635848999,
-0.25042402744293213,
0.5637337565422058,
0.3016119599342346,
0.33417272567749023,
0.29022490978240967,
-0.17543067038059235,
-0.21961989998817444,
0.19876165688037872,
0.3116515278816223,
0.22498799860477448,
0.2060086578130722,
-0.21781419217586517,
0.01731874980032444,
-0.19481968879699707,
0.3618384301662445,
-0.15675722062587738,
-0.057032715529203415,
0.8444080948829651,
-0.07388588786125183,
0.21811211109161377,
-0.0006158935138955712,
-0.48693832755088806,
-0.4600871205329895,
-0.6792054176330566,
0.07234770059585571,
-0.3268742561340332,
-0.20167770981788635,
0.36466535925865173,
-0.39394131302833557,
0.391074001789093,
0.2763597369194031,
-0.8252594470977783,
-0.20420238375663757,
0.5584644079208374,
0.4178306758403778,
0.7273810505867004,
-0.026323268190026283,
-0.5732951760292053,
0.261061429977417,
-0.1598074585199356,
0.4359033703804016,
-0.26465722918510437,
-0.23712009191513062,
0.12420845031738281,
-0.24484851956367493,
-0.03598661348223686,
-0.4794965386390686,
0.3938765227794647,
-0.41246217489242554,
0.035144031047821045,
-0.03757941722869873,
-0.4137038588523865,
-0.08689212054014206,
0.577864408493042,
-0.5791545510292053,
0.7080934643745422,
0.1455295830965042,
-0.8360965251922607,
0.6707838177680969,
-0.6588040590286255,
-0.24990801513195038,
0.6424767374992371,
-0.6517464518547058,
-0.5811194181442261,
0.14165782928466797,
0.02788158692419529,
0.16019949316978455,
-0.33848288655281067,
0.4631047248840332,
0.17881381511688232,
0.07063725590705872,
0.5059120655059814,
-0.002276734448969364,
0.8166311383247375,
0.433229923248291,
-0.3911306858062744,
-0.010484466329216957,
-0.7144787907600403,
0.17128296196460724,
-0.2550898790359497,
-0.47639578580856323,
-0.1795748621225357,
-0.18509197235107422,
-0.40565067529678345,
0.10830720514059067,
0.48991167545318604,
-0.3255068361759186,
-0.1534082591533661,
-0.3789077401161194,
0.5731167197227478,
0.3089354336261749,
0.6131373047828674,
0.3418748378753662,
-0.2154334932565689,
0.7696979641914368,
-0.05440421774983406,
0.18800599873065948,
-0.01567348837852478,
-0.5599406957626343,
-0.6448947787284851,
-0.17996220290660858,
0.47776731848716736,
0.46372079849243164,
-0.9533098340034485,
0.1347438097000122,
0.09612151980400085,
-0.438331663608551,
-0.8047446608543396,
0.2708102762699127,
0.47220778465270996,
0.3194430470466614,
0.38547465205192566,
0.3825688660144806,
-0.673480212688446,
-1.0466172695159912,
-0.43215128779411316,
-0.3552666902542114,
-0.0032742831390351057,
0.15286828577518463,
0.5313789248466492,
0.0009056070703081787,
0.8733265399932861,
-0.45432940125465393,
-0.15800966322422028,
-0.3817136883735657,
0.37724897265434265,
0.3436180353164673,
0.34296560287475586,
0.38074374198913574,
-1.2334356307983398,
-0.48102015256881714,
0.11990521103143692,
-0.5041738748550415,
-0.08599377423524857,
-0.5340116620063782,
-0.17630895972251892,
-0.0389358326792717,
0.779013991355896,
-0.9311825037002563,
0.29508647322654724,
0.06094760075211525,
-0.5698712468147278,
0.5556008219718933,
-0.631436824798584,
-0.0746447965502739,
-0.792521059513092,
0.4208410382270813,
-0.22148557007312775,
-0.32434704899787903,
-0.4636969566345215,
0.4085865914821625,
0.030599374324083328,
0.010177381336688995,
-0.5874359011650085,
0.0983717143535614,
-0.583793044090271,
0.2569315731525421,
0.06553322076797485,
0.4865824580192566,
0.33417725563049316,
0.33102652430534363,
-0.23465847969055176,
0.3422453701496124,
0.24850629270076752,
-1.0238826274871826,
0.19358313083648682,
0.550818681716919,
-0.27244269847869873,
0.6381351351737976,
-0.538195013999939,
-0.06716299057006836,
-0.3301941156387329,
-0.07402963191270828,
-0.45011475682258606,
-0.15140751004219055,
0.3532892167568207,
-0.40634992718696594,
0.040378838777542114,
-0.6015491485595703,
-0.5777175426483154,
-0.2774321138858795,
0.06451773643493652,
0.30088332295417786,
0.3255200684070587,
-0.20977148413658142,
0.40834641456604004,
0.6002533435821533,
0.22261564433574677,
-0.8765118718147278,
-0.7918347716331482,
0.11337979137897491,
-0.42059728503227234,
-0.5623525381088257,
0.17089083790779114,
0.335054486989975,
-0.2657873034477234,
-0.01421473827213049,
-0.222731351852417,
-0.20646409690380096,
0.46667706966400146,
0.4669684171676636,
-0.1850970834493637,
0.20018038153648376,
0.19236591458320618,
0.20829308032989502,
-0.13179557025432587,
0.42843762040138245,
-0.10602419078350067,
0.23933956027030945,
0.13652564585208893,
-0.29784542322158813,
0.07926961779594421,
0.5422535538673401,
0.37336400151252747,
-0.4937264025211334,
0.10495906323194504,
0.22581136226654053,
-0.41668379306793213,
-0.5641070008277893,
-0.4120379090309143,
0.32247427105903625,
-0.4901054799556732,
0.017444375902414322,
-0.5522997975349426,
-0.8037217259407043,
0.5106740593910217,
-0.2715682089328766,
0.11371172964572906,
0.29766416549682617,
0.5123394131660461,
-0.18917779624462128,
0.33428338170051575,
0.3954389691352844,
0.655206024646759,
0.10838957875967026,
-0.24707970023155212,
0.157892107963562,
-0.43240106105804443,
-0.5919955372810364,
-0.6649760603904724,
-0.28056150674819946,
-0.7810681462287903,
-0.200089231133461,
0.3183302581310272,
0.07480891793966293,
0.19612260162830353,
0.5098226070404053,
-0.563478946685791,
0.4658757448196411,
0.6240795254707336,
0.13316400349140167,
0.25582221150398254,
-0.3652566373348236,
-0.3853689730167389,
0.27418872714042664,
-0.4229480028152466,
-0.6366549730300903,
0.5385861396789551,
0.16576986014842987,
0.2070486694574356,
0.36992204189300537,
0.8131043910980225,
0.3969936966896057,
-0.2628158628940582,
-0.49433425068855286,
0.4848952293395996,
0.03908277302980423,
-0.9872546195983887,
-0.3044200539588928,
-0.2636058032512665,
-1.6207889318466187,
0.2114250659942627,
-0.3276787996292114,
-0.5453324317932129,
0.48215627670288086,
0.36062175035476685,
-0.41838324069976807,
-0.21114212274551392,
-0.6667594909667969,
1.0001777410507202,
-0.07075755298137665,
-0.23473772406578064,
-0.22626054286956787,
-0.8576055765151978,
0.15940912067890167,
-0.11342315375804901,
0.3272897005081177,
-0.4112273156642914,
-0.2528248131275177,
0.2971000373363495,
-0.7134829163551331,
0.5116257667541504,
-0.47492867708206177,
-0.04349745437502861,
0.8826308250427246,
0.03148911893367767,
0.2739284932613373,
0.5143612027168274,
-0.20401406288146973,
-0.43293070793151855,
0.3581179976463318,
-0.4013425409793854,
-0.5507717728614807,
0.346439003944397,
-0.32673364877700806,
-0.5891567468643188,
-0.33418717980384827,
-0.5523073673248291,
-0.340955525636673,
0.19937622547149658,
0.16632142663002014,
-0.014802267774939537,
0.1525777131319046,
0.035965610295534134,
0.38447049260139465,
-0.2295401692390442,
0.20410092175006866,
0.7016935348510742,
0.10382869094610214,
-0.008442875929176807,
0.38817688822746277,
0.3435201048851013,
0.02098936028778553,
0.2001059204339981,
-0.09373024851083755,
-0.5934805274009705,
-0.7658660411834717,
-0.27459290623664856,
0.33846113085746765,
-0.9127448201179504,
-0.327141672372818,
-0.3133929371833801,
-0.03742232918739319,
-0.07063228636980057,
-0.26077625155448914,
0.13416558504104614,
-0.510357141494751,
-0.19895075261592865,
-0.35242071747779846,
0.37440216541290283,
0.6236554384231567,
0.11433521658182144,
-0.029551008716225624,
-0.8016921281814575,
0.4638862907886505,
-0.07046988606452942,
0.12781710922718048,
-0.6501390337944031,
-0.25034600496292114,
-0.3415874242782593,
-0.017815764993429184,
-0.35003551840782166,
-1.0610023736953735,
0.1153787150979042,
-0.04836625978350639,
0.6022855639457703,
-0.0021018506959080696,
0.6171584129333496,
0.6267234683036804,
-0.273425817489624,
0.7869740128517151,
0.16573378443717957,
-1.066260814666748,
0.6978812217712402,
-0.15186992287635803,
0.2835465967655182,
0.9370025396347046,
0.2663498520851135,
-0.42621445655822754,
-0.8557458519935608,
-1.0882266759872437,
-1.3282760381698608,
0.38802412152290344,
0.4421500563621521,
0.19440820813179016,
-0.16817428171634674,
0.936709463596344,
0.04774231091141701,
0.5246363282203674,
-0.4617578387260437,
-0.19211852550506592,
0.24850143492221832,
-0.07812241464853287,
0.41879740357398987,
-0.23236727714538574,
-0.1323772817850113,
0.2618686258792877,
0.5928142666816711,
0.08015595376491547,
-0.23620757460594177,
0.4469883143901825,
-0.3105888068675995,
0.256722092628479,
0.6896704435348511,
0.43947094678878784,
1.0144100189208984,
-0.055744100362062454,
0.3999353349208832,
0.1593024879693985,
-0.251230925321579,
0.22963795065879822,
0.09118203818798065,
-0.39260733127593994,
0.5949432849884033,
0.03245003521442413,
0.4234223961830139,
-0.11063957214355469,
-0.73003751039505,
0.40183576941490173,
0.23576833307743073,
-0.7122512459754944,
-0.7182547450065613,
-0.19110020995140076,
0.07432933151721954,
0.34927916526794434,
0.17945747077465057,
-0.1706743836402893,
0.14816083014011383,
-0.18226248025894165,
0.4853326678276062,
0.35566315054893494,
-0.1890944093465805,
0.20123150944709778,
0.6699544191360474,
0.27610403299331665,
0.01658954657614231,
0.5418499708175659,
-0.37168529629707336,
-0.07821665704250336,
0.6643667221069336,
0.05770313739776611,
0.5758827924728394,
0.3723721504211426,
0.4249151945114136,
0.3274027407169342,
0.49019166827201843,
0.17243294417858124,
0.540867269039154,
-0.09006182849407196,
-0.2860942482948303,
-0.585788369178772,
-0.11165038496255875,
-0.5397660136222839,
0.1032184585928917,
-0.7292457222938538,
0.5866678357124329,
-0.5525060892105103,
-0.36072516441345215,
0.17064404487609863,
0.007268156390637159,
-0.7023279666900635,
0.27202022075653076,
-0.04190686345100403,
0.882659912109375,
-0.5244578719139099,
0.6931880116462708,
0.8627444505691528,
-1.0476055145263672,
-0.89680415391922,
-0.0841417908668518,
-0.42059436440467834,
-0.4198239743709564,
0.4614669978618622,
-0.039546649903059006,
0.061455804854631424,
-0.11186748743057251,
-0.5603437423706055,
-0.2680738568305969,
1.1801259517669678,
0.8010507225990295,
-0.5533552169799805,
-0.35801735520362854,
0.7019047737121582,
0.5307229161262512,
0.22376881539821625,
0.04549538716673851,
0.508822500705719,
0.6070055961608887,
0.02192314900457859,
-0.6751476526260376,
0.38139504194259644,
-0.16672897338867188,
-0.47132039070129395,
0.3313150107860565,
-0.31001248955726624,
0.4094301760196686,
-0.08904697746038437,
-0.3256385028362274,
-0.146962970495224,
0.45992207527160645,
0.3724766969680786,
0.731195330619812,
0.5563777089118958,
0.27041512727737427,
1.0564422607421875,
-0.010528981685638428,
0.8473004698753357,
-0.44520071148872375,
0.17676688730716705,
1.241776466369629,
0.16767293214797974,
0.5682544112205505,
1.0192508697509766,
0.03663088008761406,
0.4008549153804779,
0.5816984176635742,
-0.052306316792964935,
-0.043682996183633804,
0.8128407001495361,
-0.0010254575172439218,
-0.3586141765117645,
-0.27587053179740906,
-0.25103235244750977,
0.2359894961118698,
0.3707946836948395,
-0.2293241024017334,
-0.36477401852607727,
-0.21850259602069855,
0.11900535970926285,
0.481357604265213,
-0.13091979920864105,
0.7220231294631958,
0.2550636827945709,
-0.9711964130401611,
0.397588849067688,
0.2641138732433319,
0.16357500851154327,
-0.8155774474143982,
-0.11500510573387146,
-0.13236762583255768,
0.04476607218384743,
-0.5684698820114136,
-0.9244934320449829,
0.673014223575592,
0.0893154889345169,
-0.028892673552036285,
-0.21138505637645721,
0.14864297211170197,
-0.512393057346344,
-0.07982181757688522,
0.1563611924648285,
0.38505131006240845,
0.330098420381546,
-0.20253853499889374,
-1.132830262184143,
-0.27885010838508606,
0.1556432843208313,
0.11743537336587906,
-0.07579193264245987,
1.0434396266937256,
-0.10046730190515518,
0.5507062077522278,
0.39510974287986755,
0.02255486324429512,
0.2989896237850189,
-0.013553779572248459,
0.6766009330749512,
-0.34729674458503723,
-0.5614646673202515,
-0.5788392424583435,
1.0375334024429321,
-0.09243758022785187,
-0.4634137749671936,
0.7194088101387024,
0.6816457509994507,
0.6215486526489258,
-0.07167308777570724,
0.6626189947128296,
-0.2917008697986603,
0.31066465377807617,
-0.8358342051506042,
0.3519459366798401,
-0.47035786509513855,
0.5809850096702576,
0.031955353915691376,
-0.5180125832557678,
-0.4076799750328064,
0.2086932212114334,
-0.07945648580789566,
-0.3763306438922882,
0.7616957426071167,
0.4983169436454773,
-0.03863950073719025,
-0.2524709403514862,
0.1279321163892746,
-0.138240247964859,
0.38763415813446045,
0.530003547668457,
0.7739166617393494,
-0.5135085582733154,
1.1094778776168823,
-0.09673354774713516,
0.16145378351211548,
-0.13919873535633087,
-0.895833432674408,
-0.5682109594345093,
-0.767859935760498,
-0.9728778600692749,
-0.6706451177597046,
-0.10736209899187088,
0.8797667026519775,
0.36524540185928345,
-0.6158269643783569,
-0.1384565681219101,
-0.3879212439060211,
0.35517263412475586,
-0.08568423241376877,
-0.15601341426372528,
0.2772178053855896,
-0.8540394306182861,
-0.5446560382843018,
0.1319684386253357,
-0.038645654916763306,
0.038914140313863754,
0.06624608486890793,
-0.125733882188797,
-0.5223366022109985,
0.2902023494243622,
-0.01668466627597809,
0.42493653297424316,
-0.5337684750556946,
-0.18383467197418213,
-0.5620079040527344,
0.004436205606907606,
-0.19869978725910187,
1.0093536376953125,
-0.18319156765937805,
0.3886162042617798,
0.464068740606308,
0.5772523283958435,
0.6375494599342346,
0.12249460816383362,
0.4260607063770294,
-1.2489666938781738,
0.3108800947666168,
0.3039426803588867,
0.44039011001586914,
0.09176160395145416,
-0.5680965781211853,
0.618556797504425,
-0.2052428424358368,
-0.5128865838050842,
-0.552740752696991,
0.49279168248176575,
-1.0480403900146484,
-0.411737859249115,
1.0505419969558716,
-0.1566932201385498,
-0.07696250081062317,
-0.8224183320999146,
-0.43090131878852844,
0.20553508400917053,
-0.28350403904914856,
0.5998166799545288,
0.5336484909057617,
-0.0030159284360706806,
-0.027450839057564735,
-0.6759741306304932,
0.7629187703132629,
0.4398294687271118,
-0.5777314901351929,
0.1272251456975937,
0.5697953701019287,
0.013712973333895206,
0.31953904032707214,
0.5741581916809082,
-0.05840504169464111,
0.36633849143981934,
-0.005367306526750326,
-0.03897138312458992,
-0.20843838155269623,
0.19254636764526367,
0.10678114742040634,
0.550652801990509,
0.5083245038986206,
-0.4962329864501953
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08046v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08046v1
|
Big City Bias: Evaluating the Impact of Metropolitan Size on Computational Job Market Abilities of Language Models
| 2024-03-12T19:40:18 | 2024-03-12T19:40:18 |
Charlie Campanella, Rob van der Goot
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, I.2.7
|
Large language models (LLMs) have emerged as a useful technology for job
matching, for both candidates and employers. Job matching is often based on a
particular geographic location, such as a city or region. However, LLMs have
known biases, commonly derived from their training data. In this work, we aim
to quantify the metropolitan size bias encoded within large language models,
evaluating zero-shot salary, employer presence, and commute duration
predictions in 384 of the United States' metropolitan regions. Across all
benchmarks, we observe negative correlations between the metropolitan size and
the performance of the LLMS, indicating that smaller regions are indeed
underrepresented. More concretely, the smallest 10 metropolitan regions show
upwards of 300% worse benchmark performance than the largest 10.
|
[
-0.5299028158187866,
-0.5576282143592834,
1.0704816579818726,
0.07113688439130783,
0.14903967082500458,
-0.19687463343143463,
-0.23559696972370148,
-0.7191739678382874,
0.4165383577346802,
0.4311651587486267,
-0.3653465807437897,
-0.33211907744407654,
-0.5830575227737427,
0.019373632967472076,
-0.4009879529476166,
0.3901863396167755,
0.37466374039649963,
0.38438454270362854,
-0.280337929725647,
0.17896313965320587,
-0.6101387739181519,
-0.6261704564094543,
-0.41308996081352234,
-0.5254101157188416,
0.26423224806785583,
0.4902411103248596,
0.8623441457748413,
0.9483591318130493,
0.39886173605918884,
0.2567276060581207,
-0.021149294450879097,
-0.4062090218067169,
-0.4462369978427887,
-0.14602136611938477,
-0.21182017028331757,
-0.6412858366966248,
-0.29958099126815796,
0.13154691457748413,
0.6051290035247803,
1.1095927953720093,
-0.16274285316467285,
0.301478773355484,
-0.24649330973625183,
0.5931764841079712,
-0.7445512413978577,
-0.015814775601029396,
-0.8176001310348511,
-0.00300524546764791,
-0.48386022448539734,
-0.10325190424919128,
-0.09388434141874313,
-0.45735791325569153,
0.16575458645820618,
-0.1782330870628357,
0.43170613050460815,
0.27650541067123413,
0.5802294015884399,
0.31942713260650635,
-0.6827149987220764,
-0.11262685805559158,
-0.8225328326225281,
0.9964838624000549,
-0.5035431385040283,
0.35284149646759033,
0.60918128490448,
0.5698323249816895,
-0.10632912814617157,
0.034226033836603165,
-0.4062725007534027,
0.01961337774991989,
-0.12410762906074524,
-0.04825025796890259,
-0.16643178462982178,
0.09068363904953003,
0.5695690512657166,
0.44755542278289795,
-0.4590455889701843,
0.5687425136566162,
-0.5885322093963623,
0.1316661238670349,
0.5459190607070923,
0.5196735858917236,
0.04403838515281677,
0.18734101951122284,
0.1341356337070465,
0.04225078225135803,
-0.8933469653129578,
-0.18682317435741425,
0.43134257197380066,
0.24965590238571167,
-0.08514586836099625,
0.5870608687400818,
-0.32309797406196594,
0.6145327091217041,
-0.01816128008067608,
-0.22474601864814758,
0.20894800126552582,
-0.2882029414176941,
-0.37837398052215576,
0.08488421142101288,
0.7559508681297302,
0.375645250082016,
0.30406954884529114,
-0.12928271293640137,
-0.16701966524124146,
-0.19918031990528107,
0.2603675425052643,
-0.6439518928527832,
0.16993001103401184,
0.2291211485862732,
-0.35384929180145264,
0.04889388382434845,
-0.2240218073129654,
-0.8596011400222778,
-0.7922831177711487,
-0.25989457964897156,
-0.13887295126914978,
0.3716863989830017,
0.08564929664134979,
0.06768789887428284,
-0.3465891480445862,
0.2930614948272705,
0.18974773585796356,
-1.0757615566253662,
0.1125808134675026,
0.6241661310195923,
0.7473494410514832,
0.07126971334218979,
-0.4006866216659546,
-0.1275390386581421,
0.08984425663948059,
-0.5525557994842529,
0.7508947253227234,
-0.6175214052200317,
-0.34115612506866455,
0.14959187805652618,
-0.2444143146276474,
-0.09254691004753113,
-0.9880449175834656,
0.3085760474205017,
-0.3576616048812866,
-0.19759774208068848,
-0.4043734669685364,
-0.06808219105005264,
0.1458565592765808,
0.288492351770401,
-0.6079253554344177,
0.884452223777771,
0.24402564764022827,
-0.6546766757965088,
0.5763474106788635,
-0.6458103060722351,
-0.3690859377384186,
-0.23444700241088867,
-0.3200288414955139,
-0.29591137170791626,
0.3614617586135864,
0.38690322637557983,
0.3409980237483978,
-0.5853770971298218,
0.18105104565620422,
-0.6781333684921265,
-0.6558425426483154,
0.42903590202331543,
-0.2738996148109436,
0.787472665309906,
0.13738366961479187,
-0.3398769497871399,
-0.24045152962207794,
-0.6094465851783752,
-0.44407519698143005,
0.05569285526871681,
-0.21024952828884125,
-0.4253728985786438,
-0.018063917756080627,
-0.322343111038208,
0.3787482678890228,
0.18841233849525452,
-0.9745870232582092,
0.19943134486675262,
-0.5453972816467285,
0.2484857439994812,
0.5797474384307861,
-0.20896080136299133,
0.8808499574661255,
-0.300902783870697,
0.7485352158546448,
0.0519537553191185,
0.08195409178733826,
0.30322128534317017,
-0.11398191004991531,
-0.544572114944458,
-0.2516930103302002,
0.03718893975019455,
0.3012211322784424,
-0.7188811302185059,
-0.01339240837842226,
-0.5503025650978088,
-0.6807782649993896,
-0.35091432929039,
-0.18244725465774536,
-0.16162793338298798,
0.12431512027978897,
0.02793407440185547,
0.07023709267377853,
-0.8653755784034729,
-1.2832181453704834,
-0.26630958914756775,
0.3685738742351532,
-0.35131320357322693,
0.2757662534713745,
0.6255540251731873,
-0.2400779277086258,
1.157573938369751,
-0.6344727277755737,
-0.42071640491485596,
-0.1898423284292221,
-0.47904691100120544,
0.6653181910514832,
0.13667377829551697,
0.7555252909660339,
-0.1002863347530365,
-0.5344362258911133,
-0.28428685665130615,
-0.37276723980903625,
-0.3912096917629242,
0.15003003180027008,
-0.034887298941612244,
-0.03090541623532772,
0.5285205841064453,
-0.5837985873222351,
0.4180680215358734,
1.012363076210022,
-0.3612053692340851,
0.7794749140739441,
-0.07631043344736099,
-0.042809560894966125,
-0.8414621949195862,
0.09685327857732773,
0.4150528609752655,
-0.18210646510124207,
-0.487919420003891,
-0.33096691966056824,
-0.3961304724216461,
-0.3843216300010681,
-0.14730843901634216,
0.6595538258552551,
-0.5018804669380188,
-0.7725666165351868,
-0.35914885997772217,
0.27873295545578003,
-0.20227406919002533,
0.12638019025325775,
0.14795473217964172,
0.8281297087669373,
0.33559849858283997,
-0.32170483469963074,
0.08109981566667557,
-0.007020412012934685,
-0.8317127227783203,
0.5262335538864136,
-0.5661396980285645,
-0.06592495739459991,
-0.1523473709821701,
0.7866058349609375,
-0.6779443621635437,
-0.09290524572134018,
-0.3930280804634094,
-0.10457140952348709,
-0.304573655128479,
-0.18872636556625366,
-0.7540448904037476,
-0.6363571882247925,
-0.17275667190551758,
0.49566027522087097,
0.2616283893585205,
-0.39443206787109375,
0.09751194715499878,
0.6005089282989502,
-0.1504511684179306,
-0.48030030727386475,
-1.2426222562789917,
0.1505700647830963,
-0.17447660863399506,
-0.3444378077983856,
-0.013349350541830063,
0.02056601457297802,
-0.5858845114707947,
-0.42852792143821716,
0.3323533236980438,
-0.5414390563964844,
0.1393931359052658,
0.3741726875305176,
0.1785326600074768,
0.089240163564682,
-0.27507609128952026,
-0.308437317609787,
-0.10995815694332123,
0.24788694083690643,
-0.11769431829452515,
0.5483530759811401,
0.37010329961776733,
-0.31729114055633545,
-0.08230981230735779,
0.18315304815769196,
0.8865430355072021,
0.03913555666804314,
0.9261180758476257,
0.4681333601474762,
-0.22875072062015533,
-0.1437501609325409,
-0.5024408102035522,
-0.21248368918895721,
-0.45081475377082825,
0.3748965859413147,
-0.1057438775897026,
-1.0171239376068115,
0.5163145065307617,
0.22553130984306335,
-0.010023160837590694,
0.44916975498199463,
0.7267194390296936,
0.18731389939785004,
1.0136817693710327,
0.5615086555480957,
-0.2853988707065582,
0.4819343090057373,
-0.05471616983413696,
0.40563732385635376,
-0.7104502320289612,
0.05496518686413765,
-0.8810951113700867,
-0.5941484570503235,
-0.6699930429458618,
-0.4861415922641754,
0.5160061717033386,
-0.28870663046836853,
-0.5002641677856445,
0.12578535079956055,
-0.3697896897792816,
0.6828349828720093,
0.8637572526931763,
-0.35328152775764465,
0.06190633401274681,
0.07160180062055588,
-0.00042941764695569873,
-0.16541986167430878,
-0.7952644228935242,
-0.186958447098732,
1.2266688346862793,
0.5996513962745667,
0.4965057373046875,
0.2597173750400543,
0.28498539328575134,
0.1407446712255478,
0.18985262513160706,
-0.6348608136177063,
0.32833126187324524,
-0.2223931849002838,
-0.9257319569587708,
-0.21791663765907288,
-0.5420967936515808,
-1.1194145679473877,
0.2684333622455597,
-0.4595244824886322,
-0.9510458707809448,
0.44473177194595337,
-0.1055789366364479,
-0.31251874566078186,
0.2765938937664032,
-0.5106400847434998,
0.5640634894371033,
0.09563054889440536,
-0.005108899436891079,
-0.3196076452732086,
0.007309585344046354,
0.3956843316555023,
-0.40343719720840454,
0.7511007785797119,
-0.255534291267395,
0.1460782289505005,
0.47611746191978455,
-0.4467580020427704,
0.8154255151748657,
-0.17540350556373596,
-0.04500724375247955,
-0.062334585934877396,
0.11244646459817886,
0.4949921667575836,
-0.33602413535118103,
-0.5621635913848877,
0.8187904953956604,
0.2187356799840927,
-0.5538961887359619,
-0.24447710812091827,
0.8180794715881348,
-0.7779677510261536,
-0.22827047109603882,
-0.3321642577648163,
-0.8528643250465393,
-0.42023077607154846,
0.2505408823490143,
0.32085344195365906,
0.47785302996635437,
0.009886919520795345,
0.21920576691627502,
0.215217724442482,
-0.3274466395378113,
0.4309792220592499,
0.6954800486564636,
-0.41104748845100403,
-0.3111495077610016,
0.44728702306747437,
0.4413158595561981,
-0.05145011842250824,
0.12511663138866425,
0.252191960811615,
-0.3690611720085144,
-0.5453671216964722,
-0.08211236447095871,
0.20501254498958588,
-0.3761313855648041,
-0.04892214760184288,
-0.2191815972328186,
-0.03195079416036606,
-0.48771706223487854,
-0.44777119159698486,
-0.5058289766311646,
-0.059779755771160126,
0.16946639120578766,
0.09969216585159302,
-0.33334118127822876,
1.164136290550232,
-0.00134859059471637,
0.4582672119140625,
-0.4122973680496216,
-0.1855681836605072,
0.08246563374996185,
0.60844886302948,
0.1440756916999817,
-0.34331944584846497,
-0.9855439066886902,
0.2520096004009247,
-0.1536387950181961,
-0.4512314200401306,
0.3589235544204712,
-0.41843754053115845,
0.46820926666259766,
0.3033615052700043,
-0.09044835716485977,
0.6209642291069031,
-0.5063093900680542,
0.9451490044593811,
0.2630730867385864,
-0.5612422823905945,
0.21516157686710358,
-0.6882572770118713,
0.8544617295265198,
0.47013550996780396,
0.20699453353881836,
-0.44955766201019287,
-0.47661319375038147,
-0.4632994532585144,
-0.3744524121284485,
0.6511699557304382,
0.06559150665998459,
0.055176880210638046,
-0.3146519958972931,
0.3161503076553345,
-0.11860089749097824,
0.34439530968666077,
-0.6748670339584351,
-0.45733729004859924,
0.3673335313796997,
0.023383205756545067,
-0.2669790983200073,
-0.5929548144340515,
0.0003699050866998732,
-0.2532055974006653,
0.3671817183494568,
0.13564583659172058,
0.43945860862731934,
0.05483388900756836,
0.14727506041526794,
-0.19748638570308685,
0.3372078239917755,
0.8654555678367615,
0.9139545559883118,
-0.13746561110019684,
0.2230413556098938,
0.48218005895614624,
-0.36615437269210815,
-0.06735065579414368,
-0.16369420289993286,
-0.19475358724594116,
0.1574738472700119,
0.4478978216648102,
0.4155852794647217,
-0.022527744993567467,
-0.7840424180030823,
0.6697960495948792,
0.030729109421372414,
-0.3968379497528076,
-0.6709462404251099,
-0.22563695907592773,
-0.037526294589042664,
0.4404064118862152,
0.5347760915756226,
-0.12005190551280975,
0.1537606418132782,
-0.6995028257369995,
-0.34156298637390137,
0.5321646332740784,
-0.5831395983695984,
-0.10003958642482758,
0.5127609968185425,
0.18423232436180115,
0.10391610115766525,
0.5202479362487793,
-0.11617793142795563,
-0.6009126901626587,
0.7137818932533264,
0.5163429975509644,
0.6621384620666504,
0.01217644102871418,
-0.3703591823577881,
0.4964657425880432,
0.5125497579574585,
-0.15148916840553284,
-0.255672812461853,
0.4669477343559265,
-0.7598927617073059,
-0.658425509929657,
-0.5872278809547424,
-0.22668489813804626,
0.1871054768562317,
-0.28754130005836487,
0.22820116579532623,
-0.5776503682136536,
-0.41619452834129333,
-0.1567135602235794,
0.08730234950780869,
-0.8879644274711609,
0.26735538244247437,
0.45072123408317566,
0.7989648580551147,
-0.8905502557754517,
0.8005598187446594,
0.8323560357093811,
0.025702042505145073,
-0.5741857290267944,
0.11529722809791565,
0.2518492043018341,
-0.7134985327720642,
0.7086520195007324,
0.13781897723674774,
0.14124435186386108,
-0.3768225312232971,
-0.3379337787628174,
-1.117111086845398,
1.105699062347412,
0.5575041174888611,
-0.8236668705940247,
0.014767252840101719,
0.6933541297912598,
0.5255077481269836,
-0.48189371824264526,
0.6439759731292725,
0.7343986630439758,
0.25539013743400574,
-0.14067983627319336,
-1.4654426574707031,
-0.15692280232906342,
0.41661229729652405,
0.13588888943195343,
0.17869466543197632,
-0.5706437826156616,
0.7373737692832947,
0.12951089441776276,
-0.04588602855801582,
-0.32645556330680847,
0.04434036836028099,
0.09156065434217453,
0.2661624848842621,
0.36795103549957275,
0.7370895147323608,
0.6284966468811035,
-0.1082206442952156,
1.1889102458953857,
-0.4861961007118225,
0.5165595412254333,
1.018511414527893,
-0.19961915910243988,
0.7842051386833191,
0.22464007139205933,
-0.3271034359931946,
0.6214839816093445,
0.43870729207992554,
-0.05823339521884918,
0.23954807221889496,
0.40787577629089355,
0.04219433292746544,
-0.1524008810520172,
-0.34835758805274963,
-0.08561652898788452,
0.6320647597312927,
0.08808492869138718,
-0.19177256524562836,
-0.36191245913505554,
-0.06188305839896202,
0.05214031785726547,
0.09127988666296005,
-0.6598412394523621,
0.4771307706832886,
0.09969253838062286,
-0.4741807281970978,
0.3347083032131195,
0.0503292977809906,
0.6893181204795837,
-0.28012147545814514,
0.17167335748672485,
-0.3439136743545532,
0.23780222237110138,
-0.33204150199890137,
-0.8880753517150879,
0.6299259066581726,
-0.12563493847846985,
-0.538428544998169,
-0.11151925474405289,
0.5038273930549622,
-0.3491542637348175,
-0.23714235424995422,
0.24807719886302948,
0.24147620797157288,
0.23658041656017303,
-0.43055033683776855,
-0.5995079874992371,
0.328379362821579,
-0.07527337223291397,
-0.026865212246775627,
0.6197364926338196,
0.27654746174812317,
0.14063940942287445,
0.8343300223350525,
0.6133442521095276,
0.2156955599784851,
-0.22868044674396515,
0.08531288057565689,
0.2838280200958252,
-0.6802389025688171,
-0.6040300726890564,
-0.9769599437713623,
0.09558090567588806,
-0.1480800062417984,
0.0520600900053978,
0.9385607242584229,
0.7253202795982361,
0.5034080147743225,
0.07808699458837509,
0.7558527588844299,
0.14211581647396088,
0.7652478814125061,
-0.2312309592962265,
0.4203612804412842,
-0.366056889295578,
0.4708647131919861,
-0.11224471032619476,
-1.3421181440353394,
-0.0628657341003418,
0.42741256952285767,
-1.1182612180709839,
0.29760614037513733,
0.748818039894104,
0.791317343711853,
-0.08702386170625687,
-0.4166507124900818,
0.6524184346199036,
0.3083430528640747,
0.13233694434165955,
0.4512043595314026,
0.577655017375946,
-0.10069228708744049,
0.4192507565021515,
-0.2521648108959198,
-0.03261234983801842,
-0.5433750152587891,
-0.6987498998641968,
-0.916184663772583,
-0.1562272310256958,
-0.1154894158244133,
-0.4327087700366974,
-0.3466509282588959,
0.6183347105979919,
0.8874789476394653,
-0.4270778298377991,
-0.5364931225776672,
0.18557485938072205,
0.07680574804544449,
0.16516904532909393,
-0.2875523865222931,
0.020184215158224106,
0.17190611362457275,
-0.7195141315460205,
0.4117293953895569,
0.25415298342704773,
-0.020679138600826263,
-0.6122981309890747,
0.22655877470970154,
0.05447281524538994,
0.2717801034450531,
0.6735667586326599,
-0.028080688789486885,
-0.4352046549320221,
-0.3457416296005249,
-0.17223230004310608,
-0.5956381559371948,
-0.14148400723934174,
0.769787073135376,
-0.5294669270515442,
0.1937538981437683,
0.22019170224666595,
0.3055422604084015,
0.44680893421173096,
0.03561745211482048,
0.7844956517219543,
-0.7861610054969788,
0.26978302001953125,
-0.2415437400341034,
0.3997122049331665,
0.2821734547615051,
-0.1627514511346817,
0.5293292999267578,
0.1539476066827774,
-0.9917342066764832,
-0.45945361256599426,
0.0859978124499321,
-0.5669922828674316,
-0.511624276638031,
1.414903163909912,
0.4805727005004883,
-0.16584253311157227,
-0.24932318925857544,
0.13137651979923248,
-0.31354498863220215,
-0.31664639711380005,
0.7884202599525452,
0.6355375051498413,
0.20547984540462494,
-0.07266806811094284,
-1.2163456678390503,
0.12706413865089417,
0.15630388259887695,
-0.4021162688732147,
0.1847200244665146,
0.8775417804718018,
0.4003848433494568,
0.04139799624681473,
0.805290162563324,
0.2715170979499817,
0.15332689881324768,
0.3018617630004883,
0.26394137740135193,
0.10507336258888245,
0.1156994178891182,
-0.49263617396354675,
-0.0005079437396489084,
0.45323657989501953,
0.1136162057518959
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08043v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08043v1
|
Authorship Style Transfer with Policy Optimization
| 2024-03-12T19:34:54 | 2024-03-12T19:34:54 |
Shuai Liu, Shantanu Agarwal, Jonathan May
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Authorship style transfer aims to rewrite a given text into a specified
target while preserving the original meaning in the source. Existing approaches
rely on the availability of a large number of target style exemplars for model
training. However, these overlook cases where a limited number of target style
examples are available. The development of parameter-efficient transfer
learning techniques and policy optimization (PO) approaches suggest lightweight
PO is a feasible approach to low-resource style transfer. In this work, we
propose a simple two step tune-and-optimize technique for low-resource textual
style transfer. We apply our technique to authorship transfer as well as a
larger-data native language style task and in both cases find it outperforms
state-of-the-art baseline models.
|
[
0.017875492572784424,
-0.5604320168495178,
0.5696821808815002,
0.10941627621650696,
-0.22836044430732727,
-0.10289780795574188,
-0.6036409139633179,
-0.33682358264923096,
0.3547917604446411,
0.8651559948921204,
-0.724510133266449,
0.021334266290068626,
-0.5578176975250244,
0.21346883475780487,
0.016373157501220703,
1.305319905281067,
-0.143084317445755,
-0.45703864097595215,
-0.11497456580400467,
0.09616082906723022,
-0.367963045835495,
0.11753097921609879,
-0.9679204821586609,
-0.24495068192481995,
0.46214357018470764,
0.8183770179748535,
0.6450104117393494,
0.7015179991722107,
0.682885468006134,
0.19380739331245422,
-0.00918587762862444,
0.217218279838562,
-0.8234109878540039,
-0.05178514122962952,
-0.3524284064769745,
-0.2739236056804657,
-0.6542578935623169,
0.056499287486076355,
0.4618337154388428,
0.5594326257705688,
-0.011659876443445683,
0.42161640524864197,
0.12293734401464462,
0.6838548183441162,
-1.0878260135650635,
-0.03629916533827782,
-0.6256804466247559,
-0.13952629268169403,
-0.08795256912708282,
-0.4042556583881378,
-0.7449246048927307,
-0.6898470520973206,
0.1998298317193985,
-0.9441447257995605,
0.011509411036968231,
0.16194559633731842,
0.5371480584144592,
-0.04487396776676178,
-0.3954637348651886,
-0.1666387915611267,
-0.7042929530143738,
1.1249933242797852,
-0.5302674174308777,
-0.1757446527481079,
0.4187507629394531,
0.09918385744094849,
0.2525424063205719,
-0.6201736330986023,
-0.5554190874099731,
-0.19895337522029877,
-0.2922036945819855,
-0.029478326439857483,
-0.0012060279259458184,
-0.08420848846435547,
0.03224373981356621,
0.09873861074447632,
-0.4442150890827179,
0.12070387601852417,
-0.4654361605644226,
-0.16014185547828674,
0.9616973400115967,
-0.14043080806732178,
0.12344593554735184,
-0.2020357847213745,
-0.5480150580406189,
-0.2903232276439667,
-0.43341168761253357,
0.28742074966430664,
0.45492658019065857,
0.541720986366272,
-0.12016334384679794,
0.10460267215967178,
-0.19200389087200165,
0.5093671679496765,
0.09478511661291122,
-0.4921170473098755,
0.006474114488810301,
-0.7260279059410095,
0.200443297624588,
0.18287762999534607,
0.7067446112632751,
0.3686184585094452,
0.43782442808151245,
-0.24653005599975586,
-0.24405743181705475,
-0.47074753046035767,
0.39486223459243774,
-0.6493326425552368,
0.00812724232673645,
-0.43306389451026917,
-0.5813275575637817,
-0.5567498207092285,
0.06281924247741699,
-1.0844806432724,
-0.31151798367500305,
-0.7387900352478027,
0.6630455255508423,
-0.35303109884262085,
-0.15668386220932007,
0.0721166729927063,
-0.06542740017175674,
0.4450833797454834,
0.507196843624115,
-1.1688952445983887,
0.33564212918281555,
0.5843291878700256,
0.8373886942863464,
-0.4636615216732025,
-0.1615511178970337,
-0.864413857460022,
0.28783658146858215,
-0.550979495048523,
0.4002053439617157,
-0.3874518871307373,
-0.37707850337028503,
0.06631885468959808,
0.018620073795318604,
-0.20666499435901642,
0.04033161699771881,
0.4884718954563141,
-0.14767742156982422,
0.08362817019224167,
-0.44579437375068665,
-0.1847430169582367,
0.28771713376045227,
-0.352436900138855,
-0.5345767736434937,
0.9152257442474365,
0.334335595369339,
-0.25131332874298096,
0.3926145136356354,
-0.6690086722373962,
-0.9508577585220337,
-0.1531585156917572,
0.44245028495788574,
-0.49330681562423706,
0.15653611719608307,
0.12207625806331635,
0.47730642557144165,
-0.2426176220178604,
-0.08115951716899872,
-0.23036201298236847,
-0.5710582733154297,
-0.07041121274232864,
0.13809669017791748,
0.8298520445823669,
0.5005828142166138,
-0.2439841330051422,
-0.1308501660823822,
-0.6093153357505798,
0.014041697606444359,
0.13848671317100525,
-0.26831746101379395,
-0.5350607633590698,
-0.3376465141773224,
0.3597947061061859,
-0.15200397372245789,
0.49852022528648376,
-0.5145717859268188,
0.7336026430130005,
-0.025736143812537193,
0.4517267346382141,
0.7488541603088379,
0.096822090446949,
0.9977718591690063,
-0.5718504190444946,
0.6006371974945068,
-1.0972130298614502,
0.2761603593826294,
0.26448774337768555,
-0.17870411276817322,
-0.35802337527275085,
-0.2392992377281189,
0.03897324204444885,
0.7391051054000854,
-0.8162570595741272,
0.2949300706386566,
-0.39813175797462463,
-0.4829331040382385,
-0.5478914976119995,
0.46544069051742554,
0.534940779209137,
0.5167863965034485,
0.4292762577533722,
-0.1554161161184311,
-0.1916314661502838,
-0.9071246385574341,
-0.7028025388717651,
-0.07112821936607361,
0.21020875871181488,
0.12060851603746414,
0.4607822299003601,
0.4368646740913391,
0.727384626865387,
-0.6144037842750549,
-0.4178190231323242,
-0.6149637699127197,
0.4320654273033142,
-0.011983778327703476,
0.9152200222015381,
0.9181234836578369,
-0.603935718536377,
-0.7756624221801758,
0.20329000055789948,
-0.4184055030345917,
-0.2278888076543808,
-0.5216806530952454,
-0.5290659666061401,
0.09530040621757507,
0.8683030009269714,
-0.15709878504276276,
0.1596505492925644,
0.37406042218208313,
-0.2246406227350235,
0.4628552198410034,
-0.1395329087972641,
0.3015792667865753,
-1.211225152015686,
0.2904197871685028,
-0.08722478151321411,
-0.17705358564853668,
-0.5809826254844666,
-0.008135734125971794,
-0.004841510206460953,
-0.35943472385406494,
-0.3599228858947754,
0.6980029344558716,
-0.6930622458457947,
0.11945746839046478,
-0.1345805674791336,
-0.14235837757587433,
0.1500006914138794,
0.6854164600372314,
-0.04935261607170105,
0.8268862962722778,
0.4006016254425049,
-0.186191588640213,
0.1419903039932251,
0.28212085366249084,
-0.32190099358558655,
1.1358256340026855,
-0.49774599075317383,
0.6768690943717957,
-0.3070259988307953,
0.014835180714726448,
-1.054713487625122,
0.01790769398212433,
0.11698087304830551,
0.06300035119056702,
0.8405821323394775,
-0.5751582980155945,
-0.5025357007980347,
0.11716783791780472,
-0.4190695583820343,
0.2675931453704834,
0.753284215927124,
-0.22916963696479797,
0.4727628827095032,
-0.04684245586395264,
-0.4930064380168915,
-0.36255499720573425,
-0.5507670640945435,
0.033311571925878525,
-0.40013405680656433,
-0.399778813123703,
0.8843062520027161,
0.25883468985557556,
-0.057496052235364914,
0.034394457936286926,
-0.041981201618909836,
-0.15416771173477173,
0.03127565234899521,
-0.4920729994773865,
0.21793869137763977,
-0.16470561921596527,
-0.21962328255176544,
0.38768768310546875,
0.13499636948108673,
-0.204557865858078,
-0.08606381714344025,
-0.02562102861702442,
0.13035038113594055,
0.11815318465232849,
-0.7631884217262268,
0.35020023584365845,
0.6322242617607117,
-0.30541229248046875,
0.8328673839569092,
0.7375005483627319,
0.08474137634038925,
-0.6291096806526184,
-0.3166365325450897,
-0.39518630504608154,
-0.46842771768569946,
0.2397950440645218,
-0.2651980221271515,
-0.5069089531898499,
0.03822541981935501,
-0.15650473535060883,
0.24240267276763916,
0.2818434536457062,
0.008510289713740349,
0.06320042163133621,
0.29177772998809814,
1.004010796546936,
-0.20323793590068817,
0.9988116025924683,
-0.28751564025878906,
0.010861532762646675,
-0.7335594892501831,
0.01785522699356079,
-0.6765400171279907,
-0.6373063325881958,
-0.5820823311805725,
-0.1748291254043579,
0.405750036239624,
0.017027830705046654,
-0.12725764513015747,
0.9477761387825012,
-0.5720653533935547,
0.5556345582008362,
0.722204864025116,
0.21602582931518555,
0.2516945004463196,
0.12190669029951096,
0.3213372528553009,
-0.07795107364654541,
-0.47119051218032837,
-0.4188268780708313,
1.139616847038269,
-0.1345914602279663,
0.9682946801185608,
0.29700514674186707,
0.8893402218818665,
0.4796680808067322,
0.015137013047933578,
-0.7213467955589294,
0.5573288202285767,
-0.5682101249694824,
-0.2393251657485962,
-0.7569470405578613,
-0.42461201548576355,
-0.7886114716529846,
0.09074307233095169,
-0.5151191353797913,
-0.8153647184371948,
0.5270932912826538,
0.24434097111225128,
-0.058922555297613144,
0.2773016095161438,
-0.6023523807525635,
0.9286492466926575,
-0.0404258668422699,
-0.6683034300804138,
-0.03243798390030861,
-0.7270796298980713,
0.27410954236984253,
-0.14842942357063293,
0.14631526172161102,
-0.06699388474225998,
-0.1641836166381836,
0.9073549509048462,
-0.39838290214538574,
0.6678852438926697,
-0.11292418837547302,
-0.1575690656900406,
0.1514802724123001,
0.29837289452552795,
1.0070818662643433,
-0.3355691134929657,
-0.2496928721666336,
-0.24559734761714935,
-0.013673592358827591,
-0.49001452326774597,
-0.5863420367240906,
0.39453861117362976,
-0.6502599120140076,
-0.12012019008398056,
-0.032709937542676926,
-0.4886939823627472,
-0.3049205243587494,
0.306162029504776,
0.5871527194976807,
0.3758808672428131,
-0.0736483633518219,
0.5348597168922424,
0.4760884940624237,
0.0416056290268898,
0.4241345226764679,
0.3817531168460846,
0.4328540861606598,
-0.17094357311725616,
0.9284700155258179,
0.10744594037532806,
0.6190976500511169,
0.5920836329460144,
0.4455879032611847,
-0.20917381346225739,
-0.4241480529308319,
-0.4634372591972351,
0.19393649697303772,
-0.4458884596824646,
0.07643081247806549,
-0.18738514184951782,
0.15213708579540253,
-0.5879319906234741,
-0.8760077357292175,
-0.42556050419807434,
-0.3600241243839264,
-0.3173452913761139,
0.45279189944267273,
0.5813692212104797,
0.277940571308136,
0.1331266611814499,
0.6648809313774109,
-0.2369799017906189,
0.4036540389060974,
0.3159743845462799,
0.1461285650730133,
-0.3392011523246765,
-0.8824206590652466,
-0.06400496512651443,
-0.42895880341529846,
-0.19315198063850403,
-0.8789079189300537,
0.10464698821306229,
0.660297691822052,
0.40336546301841736,
0.3948304355144501,
0.5941847562789917,
0.36582738161087036,
-0.34511905908584595,
0.31521695852279663,
0.09889336675405502,
-0.9490858316421509,
0.7355538606643677,
-0.4463863968849182,
0.06037326529622078,
1.2073125839233398,
0.22200576961040497,
-0.3636380136013031,
-0.040896154940128326,
-0.3279797434806824,
-0.6384941935539246,
0.9191721081733704,
0.280364066362381,
0.2310044765472412,
0.5364512205123901,
0.5851907730102539,
0.2617894411087036,
0.25440648198127747,
-0.4328170716762543,
0.03917645663022995,
0.07775585353374481,
0.003479935461655259,
-0.109023317694664,
-0.0009390974882990122,
-0.060879867523908615,
-0.06267665326595306,
0.6625685095787048,
-0.46106046438217163,
0.14795872569084167,
0.1810045689344406,
-0.10329051315784454,
-0.08738098293542862,
0.4717416763305664,
0.6336289644241333,
0.6834893822669983,
-0.2515571117401123,
-0.19164787232875824,
0.008521727286279202,
-0.5018048882484436,
0.20724086463451385,
-0.011778275482356548,
-0.4381330907344818,
-0.11898716539144516,
0.6008273363113403,
0.8504369258880615,
0.4021005630493164,
-0.15503448247909546,
0.7099881768226624,
0.417156845331192,
-0.45339423418045044,
-0.06315319240093231,
0.06994994729757309,
-0.3141319751739502,
-0.09880082309246063,
0.12200488895177841,
0.23462608456611633,
0.2565031349658966,
-0.6482621431350708,
0.05846509337425232,
0.39659833908081055,
-0.18704526126384735,
-0.26927679777145386,
0.7434751391410828,
0.2485255002975464,
-0.21781094372272491,
0.2770041227340698,
-0.2737807333469391,
-0.06530105322599411,
0.5303208231925964,
0.5472520589828491,
0.9026937484741211,
-0.06466545909643173,
0.3655696511268616,
0.33702191710472107,
0.5279421210289001,
-0.38753601908683777,
0.22929738461971283,
-0.18799421191215515,
-0.45910823345184326,
-0.6842172145843506,
-0.6641225218772888,
-0.5923491716384888,
-0.10917415469884872,
-1.0480070114135742,
0.5856009721755981,
-0.6658023595809937,
0.05188342183828354,
-0.007703959010541439,
0.04239119216799736,
-0.5945214629173279,
-0.24926133453845978,
-0.149680495262146,
0.5146207809448242,
-1.1401575803756714,
0.5877479314804077,
0.6837666630744934,
-0.283120334148407,
-0.7670269012451172,
-0.0506371334195137,
0.21058136224746704,
-0.8702731728553772,
0.32190051674842834,
-0.23319277167320251,
-0.37095633149147034,
0.18101619184017181,
-0.6660133600234985,
-0.9112111926078796,
0.9287640452384949,
0.7317204475402832,
-0.4828428030014038,
-0.05656177178025246,
-0.3866399824619293,
0.3213215172290802,
-0.19578352570533752,
-0.494935542345047,
0.5509309768676758,
0.5589151382446289,
0.28136390447616577,
-1.1201388835906982,
0.3514224886894226,
0.030269034206867218,
0.06012287363409996,
0.3128719627857208,
-0.6483954191207886,
0.9173571467399597,
-0.19787365198135376,
0.033695634454488754,
0.24929659068584442,
0.5211020708084106,
-0.09747422486543655,
0.2116818130016327,
0.5340399146080017,
0.25952669978141785,
0.5016540884971619,
0.130838081240654,
1.131456971168518,
-0.115519680082798,
0.31173956394195557,
0.9503248333930969,
-0.33568108081817627,
0.769780695438385,
0.5552771687507629,
-0.2568269670009613,
0.6185487508773804,
0.09164419025182724,
-0.13925689458847046,
0.6397929787635803,
0.21380271017551422,
0.02595170959830284,
-0.09839634597301483,
-0.37359511852264404,
-0.16019240021705627,
0.7071384191513062,
-0.35620853304862976,
-0.3079884946346283,
0.10955417156219482,
0.04975559189915657,
0.6422555446624756,
0.3395368754863739,
-0.4028662145137787,
0.9603039026260376,
-0.11269212514162064,
-0.8612098097801208,
0.3845230042934418,
-0.03705906122922897,
0.7387187480926514,
-0.7272858619689941,
-0.19006183743476868,
-0.216853529214859,
-0.02847561426460743,
-0.16306167840957642,
-0.4408957064151764,
0.10935766994953156,
-0.23469416797161102,
-0.032656606286764145,
-0.9458269476890564,
0.784845232963562,
-0.5197280645370483,
-0.5501524209976196,
-0.11268901824951172,
0.3919506072998047,
0.19353033602237701,
0.008542071096599102,
-0.3964219391345978,
-0.32313916087150574,
-0.16947472095489502,
-0.21270982921123505,
0.5740808248519897,
0.4632519781589508,
-0.18301260471343994,
0.2852100431919098,
0.7493683099746704,
0.6089797616004944,
-0.3993588089942932,
-0.21963335573673248,
0.32117390632629395,
-0.3381490707397461,
-0.8540906310081482,
-0.5909085273742676,
0.1305118054151535,
-0.12209513038396835,
-0.5776507258415222,
0.49623286724090576,
0.2294931262731552,
0.6661292314529419,
-0.22094778716564178,
0.6777761578559875,
-0.29386964440345764,
0.22859738767147064,
-0.8996437191963196,
0.9146994948387146,
-0.8419169783592224,
-0.1493920236825943,
-0.8646935224533081,
-1.0894979238510132,
0.12081649899482727,
0.61075758934021,
-0.3064539432525635,
0.13035190105438232,
0.7153435945510864,
0.5947787165641785,
-0.06381316483020782,
-0.26029592752456665,
0.1612403690814972,
-0.5226998329162598,
-0.13600575923919678,
0.5432314276695251,
0.22356975078582764,
-0.0818224772810936,
0.7517136335372925,
-0.6827420592308044,
-0.3487887680530548,
-0.4287518262863159,
-1.2546179294586182,
-0.47452327609062195,
-0.5741683840751648,
-0.5333823561668396,
-0.12257811427116394,
0.1095651313662529,
0.8838838934898376,
1.0540632009506226,
-0.4568639099597931,
-0.3133074641227722,
0.08080937713384628,
0.028928598389029503,
-0.7636878490447998,
-0.28792884945869446,
0.6166898608207703,
-0.35335609316825867,
-0.8057911992073059,
0.3615010976791382,
0.04313010722398758,
-0.18946054577827454,
0.05039257928729057,
0.038672059774398804,
-0.03662408888339996,
-0.004883888643234968,
0.5551081299781799,
0.3243867754936218,
-0.44110214710235596,
-0.3005705177783966,
-0.08392219990491867,
-0.20784297585487366,
-0.24106743931770325,
1.1671674251556396,
-0.2555772066116333,
0.4063384532928467,
0.569905161857605,
0.7929708361625671,
0.352014422416687,
0.3384312391281128,
0.49497467279434204,
-0.9759364128112793,
-0.0035004313103854656,
0.16863034665584564,
0.24599935114383698,
0.12324138730764389,
-0.6426083445549011,
0.5831198692321777,
0.3676307499408722,
-0.402361124753952,
-0.5933897495269775,
0.12165509909391403,
-1.292215347290039,
-0.42592936754226685,
1.228075385093689,
-0.01702261157333851,
-0.1149943470954895,
0.13541656732559204,
-0.3648391366004944,
-0.026027394458651543,
-0.6210309863090515,
0.4036889672279358,
0.4348822236061096,
-0.2926598787307739,
-0.23037229478359222,
-0.6427857875823975,
0.7922263145446777,
0.4786284565925598,
-0.7919295430183411,
0.02230210416018963,
0.2606702148914337,
0.18103912472724915,
0.14096179604530334,
0.8413000106811523,
0.1277281492948532,
0.34494292736053467,
-0.021261747926473618,
0.05622568726539612,
-0.16314703226089478,
-0.5518359541893005,
-0.011833610944449902,
0.1219300851225853,
-0.010708720423281193,
-0.22670035064220428
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08035v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08035v1
|
Harnessing Artificial Intelligence to Combat Online Hate: Exploring the Challenges and Opportunities of Large Language Models in Hate Speech Detection
| 2024-03-12T19:12:28 | 2024-03-12T19:12:28 |
Tharindu Kumarage, Amrita Bhattacharjee, Joshua Garland
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) excel in many diverse applications beyond
language generation, e.g., translation, summarization, and sentiment analysis.
One intriguing application is in text classification. This becomes pertinent in
the realm of identifying hateful or toxic speech -- a domain fraught with
challenges and ethical dilemmas. In our study, we have two objectives: firstly,
to offer a literature review revolving around LLMs as classifiers, emphasizing
their role in detecting and classifying hateful or toxic content. Subsequently,
we explore the efficacy of several LLMs in classifying hate speech: identifying
which LLMs excel in this task as well as their underlying attributes and
training. Providing insight into the factors that contribute to an LLM
proficiency (or lack thereof) in discerning hateful content. By combining a
comprehensive literature review with an empirical analysis, our paper strives
to shed light on the capabilities and constraints of LLMs in the crucial domain
of hate speech detection.
|
[
-0.3737671375274658,
-0.826195478439331,
0.4292435348033905,
-0.18979963660240173,
-0.012008583173155785,
0.33169102668762207,
-0.2890952527523041,
-0.8412768244743347,
-0.03348764032125473,
0.5333929061889648,
-0.356120228767395,
-0.4037476181983948,
-0.9347973465919495,
0.14280298352241516,
-0.7574473023414612,
1.1027576923370361,
0.3130945861339569,
0.24393899738788605,
-0.12111826241016388,
-0.12048932909965515,
0.02521429769694805,
-0.8405173420906067,
-0.8447443246841431,
-0.3678029179573059,
1.0013833045959473,
0.18363448977470398,
0.52167147397995,
0.5136333703994751,
0.6308179497718811,
0.37368133664131165,
-0.17296241223812103,
0.04548534005880356,
-0.6437071561813354,
0.2846784293651581,
-0.03827337175607681,
-0.4499577283859253,
-0.045235391706228256,
0.1340693086385727,
0.36469992995262146,
0.26503434777259827,
-0.010474668815732002,
0.04578974470496178,
-0.0824253186583519,
0.30309540033340454,
-0.3963273763656616,
-0.31166863441467285,
-0.9836764931678772,
0.12130739539861679,
-0.3874306082725525,
-0.03492046892642975,
-0.4184589684009552,
-0.5023537278175354,
0.01459494698792696,
-0.3233257234096527,
-0.029446735978126526,
0.15359275043010712,
0.4433734118938446,
0.35736024379730225,
-0.42388981580734253,
-0.6963350176811218,
-0.9313727021217346,
0.9973704814910889,
-0.7597317099571228,
0.3146553635597229,
0.2671772241592407,
0.1718321591615677,
0.0675993338227272,
-0.4244537651538849,
-0.7179478406906128,
-0.36137625575065613,
0.18483516573905945,
-0.13703201711177826,
-0.29087477922439575,
0.14063400030136108,
0.14377255737781525,
0.343286395072937,
-0.4773249626159668,
0.8909414410591125,
-0.369827002286911,
-0.34407365322113037,
1.0090924501419067,
0.3319399356842041,
0.4975430965423584,
-0.011635917238891125,
-0.15435849130153656,
0.30561476945877075,
-0.4141530394554138,
-0.2640792429447174,
0.7022917866706848,
0.37868115305900574,
0.16635528206825256,
0.4365319013595581,
0.2502315640449524,
0.44646772742271423,
-0.3069588243961334,
-0.42111414670944214,
0.211869016289711,
0.3188367784023285,
-0.08714204281568527,
0.21511197090148926,
0.8290913105010986,
0.3247717022895813,
0.5475948452949524,
-0.0858687236905098,
-0.23432907462120056,
0.4801442325115204,
0.6446420550346375,
-0.8623838424682617,
0.10086275637149811,
0.13476336002349854,
-0.49009475111961365,
-0.6030940413475037,
-0.3133574426174164,
-0.8163979649543762,
-0.9814466238021851,
-0.26603421568870544,
0.22890684008598328,
-0.12132824957370758,
-0.22700141370296478,
-0.3111221194267273,
-0.22698459029197693,
0.13671265542507172,
0.46070152521133423,
-0.6775951385498047,
0.4030243158340454,
0.7686582803726196,
0.7375146150588989,
-0.5483302474021912,
-0.0623481459915638,
-0.3969723880290985,
-0.0981762483716011,
-0.14251288771629333,
0.4717787206172943,
-0.7160768508911133,
-0.11222901195287704,
0.38546091318130493,
-0.3404729962348938,
0.24141743779182434,
-0.7885671257972717,
0.7986950278282166,
-0.8372940421104431,
-0.024397941306233406,
0.2077651023864746,
-0.7140969038009644,
-0.34702545404434204,
0.40369880199432373,
-0.4468063414096832,
0.7290216684341431,
0.012303035706281662,
-0.6882468461990356,
0.011407981626689434,
-0.568760097026825,
-0.5359790325164795,
0.2652399241924286,
-0.0582270585000515,
-0.6062932014465332,
0.10188354551792145,
-0.3221448063850403,
0.523901641368866,
-0.36313000321388245,
0.02062157914042473,
-0.5781543254852295,
-0.1268002688884735,
0.5213140845298767,
-0.28434693813323975,
0.839871883392334,
0.549056887626648,
-0.43431416153907776,
0.3502175509929657,
-0.6063507199287415,
-0.3307217061519623,
0.46662384271621704,
-0.23226821422576904,
-0.5641894340515137,
0.31609341502189636,
0.4453585147857666,
0.22767728567123413,
-0.06635012477636337,
-0.7213346362113953,
-0.3580704629421234,
-0.29821836948394775,
0.4787411093711853,
1.0194984674453735,
-0.33928897976875305,
0.05903679504990578,
-0.46975797414779663,
0.6972963213920593,
-0.10103805363178253,
0.13088572025299072,
0.39171120524406433,
-0.5000713467597961,
-0.6439566016197205,
-0.19622525572776794,
-0.06047803908586502,
0.7081473469734192,
-0.3434325158596039,
0.30025994777679443,
0.1773618757724762,
-0.6865866780281067,
-0.31601932644844055,
0.23315969109535217,
0.2817317545413971,
0.3635008931159973,
0.24543321132659912,
0.034064196050167084,
-0.8670648336410522,
-0.8091512322425842,
-0.4032922387123108,
-0.24134217202663422,
0.053884610533714294,
0.43097415566444397,
0.42896297574043274,
-0.42814645171165466,
0.7045829892158508,
-0.18158754706382751,
-0.3034352660179138,
-0.4076981246471405,
0.09740129858255386,
-0.20426513254642487,
-0.008376111276447773,
0.6066193580627441,
-1.0640066862106323,
-0.656893789768219,
-0.09295745193958282,
-0.6577144265174866,
-0.44177940487861633,
0.2047557383775711,
0.15027348697185516,
0.043996211141347885,
0.5444314479827881,
-0.12192080169916153,
0.23165954649448395,
0.42803752422332764,
-0.16470161080360413,
0.5700453519821167,
0.44140470027923584,
0.21054503321647644,
-0.7411919832229614,
-0.18019801378250122,
0.23099036514759064,
-0.21909375488758087,
-1.0438454151153564,
0.15168678760528564,
-0.35727769136428833,
0.06926148384809494,
-0.6777005791664124,
0.32259729504585266,
0.06070234254002571,
0.1973094493150711,
-0.557838499546051,
0.23697267472743988,
-0.5722196698188782,
0.06954943388700485,
-0.08017731457948685,
0.3875871002674103,
0.19090351462364197,
-0.6604713201522827,
0.6029049754142761,
0.14964056015014648,
-0.3496554493904114,
0.6934471130371094,
-0.2357870191335678,
0.0576789490878582,
-0.12454050779342651,
-0.0554315447807312,
-0.7188795804977417,
-0.20018498599529266,
0.35309121012687683,
-0.4334513545036316,
0.06680913269519806,
-0.01946803741157055,
-0.5863154530525208,
-0.5136381387710571,
-0.30799996852874756,
0.5574605464935303,
0.5177560448646545,
-0.2979591190814972,
0.6055569648742676,
1.0157102346420288,
-0.32234957814216614,
-0.3762514889240265,
-0.6868449449539185,
0.13400952517986298,
-0.7314061522483826,
-0.24440406262874603,
0.3070242702960968,
-0.2791208326816559,
-0.7719020843505859,
-0.31951838731765747,
0.21943630278110504,
-0.17999783158302307,
0.3444397449493408,
0.43627241253852844,
0.1278819888830185,
0.01704542338848114,
0.1474071890115738,
-0.31665709614753723,
0.251754492521286,
0.45722147822380066,
-0.09100750833749771,
0.5753865838050842,
0.22119911015033722,
-0.11469073593616486,
-0.4487535357475281,
0.2606813311576843,
0.7910362482070923,
0.07044099271297455,
0.6403078436851501,
0.5738277435302734,
-0.4120303988456726,
-0.4601205587387085,
-0.7426416277885437,
0.17922049760818481,
-0.449772447347641,
0.5285176038742065,
0.30761611461639404,
-1.2938705682754517,
0.42487674951553345,
0.22284933924674988,
0.04822701960802078,
0.5347927808761597,
0.8213810920715332,
0.017143717035651207,
1.064601182937622,
0.580657422542572,
-0.48844465613365173,
0.5899158120155334,
0.19945400953292847,
0.33269330859184265,
-0.505050539970398,
-0.2702828347682953,
-0.7656052708625793,
-0.16866716742515564,
-0.5382624864578247,
-0.2059045135974884,
0.44438034296035767,
-0.416420042514801,
-0.48364803194999695,
-0.12758591771125793,
-0.5630050301551819,
0.4736991822719574,
0.19110094010829926,
-0.0874636173248291,
0.24373802542686462,
0.21908040344715118,
0.28492018580436707,
-0.15799561142921448,
-0.41438528895378113,
-0.529224157333374,
0.9902524352073669,
0.7144789695739746,
0.6124379634857178,
0.13986444473266602,
0.36564481258392334,
0.7165960073471069,
0.6129863262176514,
-1.0861616134643555,
0.6439253687858582,
-0.23776517808437347,
-0.8365315794944763,
-0.14816507697105408,
-0.5349804759025574,
-0.7045465707778931,
0.14267301559448242,
-0.14606671035289764,
-0.7469142079353333,
-0.45998212695121765,
-0.006023831199854612,
-0.2564516067504883,
0.7005431652069092,
-0.2952219247817993,
0.5657373666763306,
-0.6097960472106934,
-0.21658731997013092,
-0.5710201263427734,
-0.31191688776016235,
0.39708173274993896,
-0.40978509187698364,
0.7314579486846924,
-0.1309337317943573,
-0.2164754718542099,
1.0293850898742676,
-0.17081741988658905,
0.9076442718505859,
-0.04023468866944313,
-0.31950774788856506,
0.28438180685043335,
0.03794107213616371,
0.1799369752407074,
-0.6095678806304932,
-0.3304949402809143,
0.3975219130516052,
-0.4085746705532074,
-0.0428258441388607,
-0.17325259745121002,
0.6013256907463074,
-0.8252864480018616,
-0.6274287700653076,
-0.4678065776824951,
-0.6245852708816528,
-0.16015857458114624,
0.20554324984550476,
-0.054539285600185394,
0.060836758464574814,
-0.3310930132865906,
0.044230107218027115,
0.7774839401245117,
-0.5067234039306641,
0.22123418748378754,
0.4435904920101166,
-0.525587797164917,
-0.32076531648635864,
1.210245132446289,
0.13698475062847137,
0.2515822649002075,
0.2610012888908386,
0.33349382877349854,
-0.3161265552043915,
-1.0710099935531616,
-0.3082541525363922,
0.18302179872989655,
-0.7473345994949341,
-0.21813495457172394,
-0.8128700256347656,
-0.4754912853240967,
-0.4302619695663452,
-0.1474284678697586,
-0.043134599924087524,
0.04704103246331215,
-0.40012457966804504,
0.08885625004768372,
0.4489138424396515,
1.3439332246780396,
0.005429691169410944,
0.3998590111732483,
-0.5871877670288086,
0.26716214418411255,
0.3555944859981537,
0.25511911511421204,
0.2057276964187622,
-0.9397225379943848,
-0.16840292513370514,
-0.11715222150087357,
-0.3027268946170807,
-0.9878412485122681,
0.5841295123100281,
-0.13975898921489716,
0.5297157168388367,
0.5205234289169312,
0.11368080973625183,
0.3397262990474701,
-0.5083417892456055,
0.6978064179420471,
0.08799097687005997,
-0.6990068554878235,
0.3631976246833801,
-0.27277877926826477,
-0.3175380229949951,
0.24821731448173523,
1.0386651754379272,
-0.6375569701194763,
-0.7072131037712097,
-0.47027358412742615,
-0.6585106253623962,
0.8115596175193787,
0.15187060832977295,
0.18221411108970642,
-0.023441124707460403,
0.07631678134202957,
0.05155900493264198,
0.3116941452026367,
-0.9945049285888672,
-0.46689578890800476,
0.038437239825725555,
-0.2928778827190399,
0.010569790378212929,
-0.4871867299079895,
-0.1211157888174057,
-0.21458008885383606,
0.8577843308448792,
0.2388797253370285,
-0.06727218627929688,
-0.27577659487724304,
-0.28069862723350525,
-0.1441226452589035,
0.25540193915367126,
0.5031726956367493,
0.31438878178596497,
0.14905734360218048,
-0.016049809753894806,
0.31696924567222595,
-0.4165298640727997,
0.1983845978975296,
-0.09647995233535767,
-0.2395705133676529,
-0.161033496260643,
0.31336820125579834,
0.4805164039134979,
-0.03175445646047592,
-0.9931917786598206,
0.5872633457183838,
0.05807426571846008,
-0.26726052165031433,
-0.6138054728507996,
0.12736721336841583,
-0.08917390555143356,
0.3067094385623932,
0.3625586926937103,
-0.3439747095108032,
0.22782933712005615,
-0.42381495237350464,
0.06932611763477325,
0.665214478969574,
-0.1665516495704651,
0.006471873261034489,
0.48509588837623596,
0.21308575570583344,
-0.6676670908927917,
0.4793921113014221,
-0.2425556629896164,
-1.1664531230926514,
0.6079591512680054,
0.5902724862098694,
0.6724777817726135,
-0.4212469458580017,
0.1714426875114441,
0.15408727526664734,
0.23111705482006073,
0.42679363489151,
-0.22711189091205597,
0.12715668976306915,
-0.9562785625457764,
-0.09644175320863724,
-1.0170973539352417,
-0.5200197100639343,
0.5587438344955444,
-0.3191831111907959,
0.09271660447120667,
-0.859019935131073,
-0.00967084988951683,
0.35707446932792664,
-0.10718820244073868,
-0.3192535638809204,
0.10179854184389114,
0.8984856009483337,
0.6307222247123718,
-0.780565083026886,
0.4137677252292633,
0.4781159460544586,
-0.1819155365228653,
-0.4529899060726166,
-0.08947531878948212,
0.5312422513961792,
-0.7392333149909973,
0.7398110032081604,
0.39629918336868286,
-0.24242962896823883,
0.025472834706306458,
-0.7212290167808533,
-0.47454071044921875,
0.35654518008232117,
0.048542361706495285,
-0.6114220023155212,
0.10727951675653458,
0.4076651632785797,
0.7401684522628784,
-0.5408072471618652,
0.3277541697025299,
0.5855521559715271,
0.411081999540329,
0.031082212924957275,
-0.8555680513381958,
-0.13319019973278046,
-0.20747274160385132,
-0.07456708699464798,
0.18248063325881958,
-0.6004304885864258,
0.6575821042060852,
0.05587371811270714,
-0.15147915482521057,
-0.07200364023447037,
0.4733143746852875,
-0.07477649301290512,
0.3298231363296509,
0.6793264746665955,
0.5848442912101746,
0.6404032111167908,
0.17745326459407806,
0.7927770018577576,
0.10853096842765808,
-0.014483192935585976,
0.7969741225242615,
-0.3881717622280121,
0.7143663763999939,
0.009815921075642109,
-0.2639840841293335,
0.6022300720214844,
0.5185965895652771,
-0.2695216238498688,
0.02395789884030819,
0.6495698094367981,
-0.5488967895507812,
-0.3467027544975281,
-0.549439549446106,
-0.06225946173071861,
0.5119126439094543,
0.6524022817611694,
-0.4479828476905823,
-0.1245102658867836,
0.4090627133846283,
0.05312991887331009,
0.4525092542171478,
-0.8124850392341614,
0.7776713967323303,
0.06654763966798782,
-0.25810500979423523,
0.34047552943229675,
0.1710289716720581,
1.0622471570968628,
-0.46584683656692505,
0.23329240083694458,
0.4088987112045288,
0.27066993713378906,
-0.37520745396614075,
-0.7201155424118042,
0.5216670036315918,
0.4955994188785553,
-0.1706240326166153,
-0.31189730763435364,
0.6823902130126953,
-0.22996078431606293,
-0.20117685198783875,
0.6050476431846619,
0.20267903804779053,
0.30798664689064026,
-0.20848260819911957,
-0.9261577725410461,
0.5629410147666931,
0.034349389374256134,
-0.028150813654065132,
0.49724432826042175,
0.16379404067993164,
0.03836051747202873,
0.8737879991531372,
0.6426639556884766,
0.1903689205646515,
0.057503558695316315,
0.26132720708847046,
0.8190648555755615,
-0.6640706658363342,
-0.4162740409374237,
-1.119566798210144,
0.12094245851039886,
-0.12805145978927612,
-0.2765113115310669,
0.7531960010528564,
0.5662240982055664,
1.1380150318145752,
0.21915306150913239,
0.9864391684532166,
-0.1398172229528427,
0.919021487236023,
-0.1736207753419876,
0.8356503844261169,
-0.6147867441177368,
0.09488844126462936,
-0.2943008244037628,
-0.5630545020103455,
-0.6221144199371338,
0.6093931794166565,
-0.5451512932777405,
0.03873038664460182,
0.4431452751159668,
0.9068107008934021,
0.29678088426589966,
0.2179853767156601,
0.49270978569984436,
0.5477645397186279,
0.5013442635536194,
0.30013757944107056,
1.2625291347503662,
-0.10949178785085678,
0.6729735136032104,
-0.04858727380633354,
-0.2006869912147522,
-0.2818657159805298,
-0.637434720993042,
-1.147605299949646,
-0.35488104820251465,
-0.20677171647548676,
-0.4184238314628601,
0.057620223611593246,
1.1360466480255127,
0.43822887539863586,
-0.9497449994087219,
-0.4275819957256317,
0.1912330985069275,
0.3147734999656677,
0.32392165064811707,
-0.28341323137283325,
-0.24548816680908203,
-0.22438612580299377,
-0.8698475360870361,
0.31994137167930603,
0.2315797507762909,
-0.10997314006090164,
-0.35800567269325256,
-0.2249981313943863,
-0.3095538914203644,
0.146662637591362,
0.9458901882171631,
0.2337968945503235,
-0.9604528546333313,
-0.17579105496406555,
-0.5409815311431885,
-0.26647159457206726,
-0.17055457830429077,
0.8965329527854919,
-0.5080010890960693,
0.010820697993040085,
0.24326656758785248,
1.1312670707702637,
0.009794446639716625,
-0.24571597576141357,
0.1869664341211319,
-0.20135542750358582,
-0.0444195494055748,
0.7698521018028259,
0.17275111377239227,
0.33661630749702454,
-0.34905609488487244,
0.2780291736125946,
0.4104902446269989,
-0.8766409158706665,
-1.1037094593048096,
0.3522190749645233,
-0.7951405048370361,
-0.3525318205356598,
1.2757880687713623,
0.21611416339874268,
-0.11792545020580292,
-0.42380088567733765,
-0.2562304139137268,
0.22155967354774475,
-0.3353368043899536,
0.8365853428840637,
0.6460482478141785,
-0.01891196519136429,
-0.06582843512296677,
-0.5319938063621521,
0.6043335199356079,
0.3346607983112335,
-0.8801392912864685,
0.210738867521286,
0.749894917011261,
0.17827872931957245,
0.17664581537246704,
0.4176591634750366,
0.02517341822385788,
0.07760049402713776,
-0.3481307029724121,
-0.023945335298776627,
0.100639708340168,
-0.3787088394165039,
-0.5238533616065979,
0.3259088099002838,
0.11057743430137634,
0.35964614152908325
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08011v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08011v1
|
Gujarati-English Code-Switching Speech Recognition using ensemble prediction of spoken language
| 2024-03-12T18:21:20 | 2024-03-12T18:21:20 |
Yash Sharma, Basil Abraham, Preethi Jyothi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
An important and difficult task in code-switched speech recognition is to
recognize the language, as lots of words in two languages can sound similar,
especially in some accents. We focus on improving performance of end-to-end
Automatic Speech Recognition models by conditioning transformer layers on
language ID of words and character in the output in an per layer supervised
manner. To this end, we propose two methods of introducing language specific
parameters and explainability in the multi-head attention mechanism, and
implement a Temporal Loss that helps maintain continuity in input alignment.
Despite being unable to reduce WER significantly, our method shows promise in
predicting the correct language from just spoken data. We introduce
regularization in the language prediction by dropping LID in the sequence,
which helps align long repeated output sequences.
|
[
-0.334834486246109,
-0.4462284445762634,
0.13781903684139252,
0.17405717074871063,
-0.2272193282842636,
0.2736985683441162,
-0.4301016926765442,
-0.4398420751094818,
-0.09187980741262436,
0.47437044978141785,
-0.4880940020084381,
-0.08968830108642578,
-0.5735847353935242,
0.09276677668094635,
-0.4703218936920166,
0.9381743669509888,
0.055649302899837494,
0.22875425219535828,
0.06209762766957283,
0.08835993707180023,
-0.5426658391952515,
-0.409955233335495,
-0.970044732093811,
-0.5953011512756348,
0.3974577486515045,
0.4102095663547516,
0.43734022974967957,
0.5098534822463989,
0.3699692189693451,
0.29184359312057495,
-0.04617103934288025,
-0.22355683147907257,
-0.37090861797332764,
-0.06266114860773087,
0.052995726466178894,
-0.6363827586174011,
-0.02893802896142006,
-0.28757408261299133,
0.7953372597694397,
0.6159717440605164,
-0.2264866828918457,
-0.09880146384239197,
0.013149507343769073,
0.4163379371166229,
-0.4381510019302368,
0.41944634914398193,
-0.7621607184410095,
0.1617814302444458,
-0.38168343901634216,
-0.3775399625301361,
-0.6509379744529724,
-0.09335682541131973,
-0.0667707771062851,
-0.20674575865268707,
0.1808941513299942,
-0.03320905566215515,
0.7578396797180176,
0.4371693432331085,
-0.23482908308506012,
0.06015237793326378,
-0.9798892140388489,
0.9148802757263184,
-0.43945562839508057,
0.6906483769416809,
0.5781117081642151,
0.616901695728302,
0.36686721444129944,
-0.39992034435272217,
-0.5652895569801331,
-0.12518036365509033,
-0.1500411331653595,
0.41964614391326904,
-0.02392440475523472,
0.10815904289484024,
-0.004846673924475908,
0.23025184869766235,
-0.5131582617759705,
-0.04473239183425903,
-0.5152812004089355,
-0.4668258726596832,
0.7044752240180969,
-0.13564512133598328,
0.321460485458374,
0.3221922516822815,
0.010162326507270336,
-0.11368345469236374,
-0.41781893372535706,
0.23972520232200623,
0.3301882743835449,
0.41342422366142273,
-0.0726161003112793,
0.2073448896408081,
-0.05109770596027374,
0.5803695917129517,
0.5032508969306946,
-0.27656450867652893,
0.36405518651008606,
0.00548340380191803,
-0.26481643319129944,
0.3584274649620056,
0.41556090116500854,
0.19866633415222168,
0.2422671765089035,
-0.383743017911911,
-0.04298761487007141,
0.2537303566932678,
0.008837085217237473,
-0.4625661075115204,
-0.021555142477154732,
0.15441487729549408,
-0.3430929481983185,
-0.14312005043029785,
-0.046303801238536835,
-0.620090901851654,
0.0089182760566473,
-0.25701066851615906,
0.2143128514289856,
-0.5606883764266968,
-0.2519446015357971,
0.04102066904306412,
-0.12565232813358307,
0.4760388135910034,
0.07029121369123459,
-0.8966121077537537,
0.4942868947982788,
0.30666980147361755,
0.6519194841384888,
-0.36563676595687866,
-0.3838389813899994,
-0.6495234966278076,
0.39666905999183655,
-0.23025068640708923,
0.6284714937210083,
-0.8425509333610535,
-0.3533267378807068,
-0.06628097593784332,
0.09216782450675964,
-0.33425986766815186,
-0.32883238792419434,
0.38769352436065674,
-0.4108339250087738,
0.37182286381721497,
0.30653515458106995,
-0.2780356705188751,
-0.2432217299938202,
-0.04484901577234268,
-0.5338596701622009,
0.7527613043785095,
-0.1278674453496933,
-0.5295796990394592,
0.2815389633178711,
-0.37743982672691345,
-0.6631600260734558,
0.17520779371261597,
0.015595298260450363,
-0.632979154586792,
-0.031741999089717865,
0.38079869747161865,
0.3836762309074402,
-0.04764902591705322,
0.16632361710071564,
0.21971623599529266,
-0.4275742173194885,
0.11597654968500137,
-0.3262650966644287,
0.6711671948432922,
0.3486906588077545,
-0.1584496796131134,
-0.030811576172709465,
-0.8933560252189636,
0.22355665266513824,
-0.09507927298545837,
-0.31494173407554626,
-0.15854470431804657,
0.20996803045272827,
0.4365231692790985,
0.13489672541618347,
0.10617434233427048,
-0.45284581184387207,
0.18718822300434113,
-0.46209973096847534,
0.46033602952957153,
0.38902947306632996,
-0.17211021482944489,
0.5462054014205933,
-0.164899080991745,
0.8540130853652954,
0.1936717927455902,
0.027909111231565475,
-0.02798190712928772,
-0.5574732422828674,
-0.698470950126648,
-0.1440141499042511,
0.3950788974761963,
0.8927441835403442,
-0.6940327286720276,
0.30478039383888245,
-0.06508001685142517,
-0.37015461921691895,
-0.6221081018447876,
-0.11683368682861328,
0.887465238571167,
0.25244659185409546,
0.24376319348812103,
-0.5702046751976013,
-0.8554849028587341,
-0.8326800465583801,
-0.33681556582450867,
-0.26381632685661316,
0.007753561716526747,
0.31352749466896057,
0.06064370647072792,
-0.3703634738922119,
0.7942189574241638,
-0.33710843324661255,
-0.16873611509799957,
-0.48489734530448914,
0.253702312707901,
0.18062737584114075,
0.4809455871582031,
0.2485799938440323,
-0.8349414467811584,
-0.6332525610923767,
0.40704214572906494,
-0.05573740974068642,
-0.16047579050064087,
-0.3266455829143524,
0.08363472670316696,
0.2697010636329651,
0.6487458348274231,
-0.14673098921775818,
0.3235439658164978,
0.802923858165741,
0.07868403941392899,
0.3249792158603668,
0.16997939348220825,
0.28889673948287964,
-1.0998839139938354,
-0.22019147872924805,
-0.14058713614940643,
-0.18103928864002228,
-0.8553454279899597,
-0.2313353568315506,
0.07321658730506897,
-0.2382929027080536,
-0.44636112451553345,
0.41932255029678345,
-0.5759527087211609,
-0.13790997862815857,
-0.14856547117233276,
-0.3368104100227356,
-0.24267131090164185,
0.7460346221923828,
0.4051109254360199,
0.9799095392227173,
0.9253754615783691,
-0.6296663880348206,
0.17315168678760529,
0.19523371756076813,
-0.1716141551733017,
0.3156096935272217,
-0.4869123697280884,
0.3702394366264343,
-0.16559751331806183,
0.21855852007865906,
-1.107622504234314,
-0.19329187273979187,
-0.025950493291020393,
-0.8435137867927551,
0.7669409513473511,
-0.38182902336120605,
0.13601531088352203,
-0.22563569247722626,
-0.013306642882525921,
0.6103748083114624,
0.5985531806945801,
-0.3611878454685211,
0.5766903758049011,
0.5160377025604248,
-0.2512568533420563,
-0.4304565489292145,
-1.119882583618164,
0.20514625310897827,
-0.248917818069458,
-0.4852593243122101,
0.5634025931358337,
0.06510113924741745,
-0.07933173328638077,
-0.15973468124866486,
-0.004910407122224569,
-0.5826238989830017,
-0.30923739075660706,
0.14150267839431763,
-0.01445328164845705,
-0.10036806017160416,
0.24821628630161285,
0.11993317306041718,
-0.3098122179508209,
-0.17409397661685944,
-0.3843425214290619,
0.6308472752571106,
-0.10628356784582138,
-0.15492546558380127,
-0.5260357856750488,
0.4485008716583252,
0.44524624943733215,
-0.5449806451797485,
0.5246275663375854,
0.706112802028656,
-0.43211880326271057,
-0.02558232471346855,
-0.41687315702438354,
0.05724463239312172,
-0.401809960603714,
0.6158171892166138,
-0.6149377822875977,
-0.6520767211914062,
0.7029430270195007,
0.07716912031173706,
-0.253773957490921,
0.40027061104774475,
0.7059797048568726,
0.038857802748680115,
1.1996185779571533,
0.7322604656219482,
-0.4180688261985779,
0.607515811920166,
-0.05145382508635521,
0.5754813551902771,
-0.710716962814331,
-0.07592932134866714,
-0.6160130500793457,
0.030470123514533043,
-0.6851126551628113,
-0.2772480547428131,
0.2720164656639099,
-0.09320779144763947,
0.173511803150177,
0.5450015664100647,
-0.6367524862289429,
0.5353170037269592,
0.4387267231941223,
0.17332452535629272,
0.05461198091506958,
-0.13286082446575165,
0.04948176071047783,
0.11220695078372955,
-0.5138604640960693,
-0.030847586691379547,
0.8609874844551086,
0.21343453228473663,
0.9985296130180359,
-0.04889354109764099,
0.8973337411880493,
0.11987283080816269,
-0.39194631576538086,
-0.8195319771766663,
0.32003507018089294,
-0.13678067922592163,
-0.26176610589027405,
-0.48139670491218567,
-0.2295536994934082,
-0.9208311438560486,
-0.12729056179523468,
0.23049940168857574,
-0.6011466383934021,
0.2321218103170395,
0.2812798321247101,
-0.25302591919898987,
-0.04395485296845436,
-1.0214511156082153,
0.32002758979797363,
-0.11498832702636719,
-0.055699169635772705,
-0.27484574913978577,
-0.842975914478302,
0.28256118297576904,
0.03065703809261322,
0.16483427584171295,
0.3455873727798462,
0.07928638160228729,
0.6301507353782654,
-0.2233625054359436,
0.7816332578659058,
-0.011824526824057102,
0.15731698274612427,
0.15427513420581818,
-0.20408585667610168,
0.3361613154411316,
-0.110246442258358,
0.023210737854242325,
0.2707999348640442,
-0.07910850644111633,
-0.3280753791332245,
-0.44191697239875793,
0.4737802743911743,
-0.7960465550422668,
-0.463381290435791,
-0.3302975296974182,
-0.6061611771583557,
-0.45836496353149414,
0.02287234365940094,
0.5282962322235107,
0.452911376953125,
-0.05325215309858322,
0.0666174441576004,
0.688676118850708,
-0.06064356118440628,
0.5111274123191833,
0.2586428225040436,
-0.17383532226085663,
-0.29293811321258545,
0.9801992177963257,
0.15716125071048737,
0.3462284207344055,
0.7239925265312195,
0.2516273558139801,
-0.20206749439239502,
-0.5432358384132385,
-0.32053080201148987,
-0.10448428988456726,
-0.45346683263778687,
-0.018208296969532967,
-0.5294264554977417,
-0.5311546921730042,
-0.6598925590515137,
-0.2527465522289276,
-0.22414420545101166,
-0.5524060130119324,
0.12126878648996353,
0.1046275645494461,
0.27326342463493347,
0.37760117650032043,
0.10029661655426025,
0.3530692160129547,
-0.7062488794326782,
0.2083674967288971,
0.5032540559768677,
0.4644070863723755,
-0.41031691431999207,
-0.8381292223930359,
-0.5186440944671631,
-0.13335995376110077,
0.0034846446942538023,
-0.9844580292701721,
0.4706217050552368,
0.6134326457977295,
0.6209641098976135,
0.5000368356704712,
-0.38956230878829956,
0.6247528195381165,
-0.6326767206192017,
0.5813866257667542,
0.24226050078868866,
-1.1371934413909912,
0.6383678913116455,
-0.2373226135969162,
0.5974155068397522,
0.309682697057724,
0.07153329253196716,
-0.731971025466919,
-0.5127348303794861,
-0.3814392685890198,
-0.5942736268043518,
0.9073908925056458,
0.2291390597820282,
-0.14887100458145142,
0.07247023284435272,
-0.007459244225174189,
0.10020003467798233,
0.0299640242010355,
-0.6005749702453613,
-0.25216859579086304,
-0.31610074639320374,
-0.15194186568260193,
-0.14533546566963196,
-0.10877031087875366,
0.1539895385503769,
-0.3827449083328247,
0.7461482286453247,
-0.0644121766090393,
0.5873479247093201,
-0.14976412057876587,
-0.18361085653305054,
-0.2562924325466156,
0.5403757095336914,
0.6460216045379639,
0.4453549087047577,
-0.18171118199825287,
-0.07632549852132797,
0.34292373061180115,
-0.6171318292617798,
0.034297727048397064,
-0.008684588596224785,
-0.10760802030563354,
0.09458420425653458,
0.27602434158325195,
0.9871910810470581,
0.05867849290370941,
-0.4835958480834961,
0.17446526885032654,
0.05256827175617218,
-0.13486133515834808,
-0.4601305425167084,
0.014457065612077713,
0.09519872069358826,
-0.06319791823625565,
0.2831442654132843,
0.3258189558982849,
0.34160101413726807,
-0.7601004838943481,
0.2528665363788605,
0.2398453950881958,
-0.38690170645713806,
-0.12545615434646606,
0.49675172567367554,
0.36955082416534424,
-0.5187374353408813,
0.33529847860336304,
-0.10970067232847214,
-0.7622416019439697,
0.9422884583473206,
0.6983340382575989,
1.2268640995025635,
-0.8583620190620422,
-0.11553065478801727,
0.37395045161247253,
0.2185007482767105,
0.03389403969049454,
0.12421215325593948,
-0.1437808722257614,
-0.7460112571716309,
-0.5084251165390015,
-0.30424314737319946,
-0.5428317189216614,
-0.07658487558364868,
-1.0072461366653442,
0.5067364573478699,
-0.2882039248943329,
0.11818619817495346,
-0.010844158940017223,
-0.2531081438064575,
-0.5481334924697876,
0.450050413608551,
0.3852517604827881,
0.42178457975387573,
-0.9462214112281799,
1.2229634523391724,
0.528976321220398,
-0.48309582471847534,
-0.63185054063797,
0.23489749431610107,
0.021930383518338203,
-1.063974380493164,
0.40803784132003784,
0.18615075945854187,
-0.4467902183532715,
-0.0362740084528923,
-0.4875664710998535,
-0.9906701445579529,
0.7948374152183533,
0.038025688380002975,
-0.9417807459831238,
0.09770634770393372,
-0.0001831159897847101,
0.43509387969970703,
-0.3448169231414795,
0.3475395739078522,
0.7897878289222717,
0.36795076727867126,
0.14294491708278656,
-1.1315118074417114,
-0.45686623454093933,
-0.36385637521743774,
0.23972982168197632,
0.43779870867729187,
-0.755730152130127,
0.8298234939575195,
-0.21322788298130035,
-0.36183303594589233,
-0.2746969163417816,
0.5335168242454529,
-0.17615854740142822,
0.383735328912735,
0.5685378909111023,
0.3914400041103363,
0.5177696347236633,
-0.01567758619785309,
0.8733410239219666,
-0.49884772300720215,
0.2258201390504837,
1.0431467294692993,
-0.2428618222475052,
0.8686708211898804,
0.5723051428794861,
-0.4561695456504822,
0.34605905413627625,
0.5072106122970581,
0.058393657207489014,
0.8603971600532532,
0.010517711751163006,
-0.05847511813044548,
-0.12995773553848267,
0.0683392658829689,
-0.46540653705596924,
0.7609203457832336,
0.3260018527507782,
-0.16093230247497559,
0.1232556626200676,
0.211627796292305,
-0.1097252145409584,
0.01829572394490242,
-0.4126388132572174,
0.8407673835754395,
-0.31676098704338074,
-0.8532145619392395,
0.701561450958252,
-0.02797066792845726,
0.833873450756073,
-0.5493119359016418,
-0.11181771010160446,
-0.18344224989414215,
0.15330712497234344,
-0.33022749423980713,
-0.4952305555343628,
0.4851384460926056,
-0.1667330265045166,
-0.4354535639286041,
-0.2700580954551697,
0.6565243601799011,
-0.9186814427375793,
-0.6953882575035095,
0.1925634741783142,
0.03714297339320183,
0.37457987666130066,
0.14358748495578766,
-0.5070282220840454,
0.01143981609493494,
0.0919426828622818,
0.02664966508746147,
0.3222544193267822,
0.150903582572937,
-0.1503000110387802,
0.5966811180114746,
0.3361613154411316,
0.1043497622013092,
0.32581374049186707,
0.44806042313575745,
0.5466374754905701,
-0.5094871520996094,
-0.6537749767303467,
-0.4581011235713959,
0.24485260248184204,
0.019748253747820854,
-0.29810091853141785,
0.3805651366710663,
0.5809087157249451,
0.9372376203536987,
-0.2551719844341278,
1.1196335554122925,
-0.03584467992186546,
0.721817135810852,
-0.602441132068634,
0.6007476449012756,
-0.34505271911621094,
0.11720342189073563,
-0.21095901727676392,
-0.7061370611190796,
-0.28147223591804504,
0.5376551151275635,
-0.10152443498373032,
0.2108663022518158,
0.9583258032798767,
0.9721108675003052,
0.04933115467429161,
-0.27916422486305237,
0.6258111596107483,
0.16626204550266266,
0.1015455573797226,
0.8992903828620911,
0.3820703327655792,
-0.542671799659729,
0.8041402697563171,
-0.20674258470535278,
-0.32058069109916687,
-0.22587794065475464,
-0.5709825158119202,
-0.7331740856170654,
-0.8503313064575195,
-0.47855234146118164,
-0.09963399171829224,
0.42228299379348755,
0.509385883808136,
0.7146837711334229,
-1.1845237016677856,
-0.40284526348114014,
-0.18896706402301788,
-0.027976229786872864,
-0.6642293930053711,
-0.23020775616168976,
0.14200712740421295,
-0.40770411491394043,
-0.9656251072883606,
0.33004897832870483,
0.44924378395080566,
-0.26909032464027405,
-0.19916650652885437,
-0.2600202262401581,
-0.2778073847293854,
0.1462259441614151,
0.3733977675437927,
0.5016387701034546,
-0.8875864148139954,
-0.2923988103866577,
-0.16172006726264954,
-0.11282020807266235,
0.12552718818187714,
0.8651009798049927,
-0.7155965566635132,
0.5263040661811829,
0.6038904786109924,
0.7824827432632446,
0.5794627666473389,
-0.13507215678691864,
0.7450072169303894,
-0.7573061585426331,
0.31317952275276184,
0.364031583070755,
0.4507189989089966,
0.250331848859787,
-0.47430598735809326,
0.4567285478115082,
0.039617788046598434,
-0.5883661508560181,
-0.5924894213676453,
0.33511433005332947,
-1.2078609466552734,
0.036487143486738205,
1.1347345113754272,
0.02925451286137104,
-0.20424409210681915,
-0.3939894735813141,
-0.4840543866157532,
0.4654969274997711,
-0.45871832966804504,
0.7571424841880798,
0.7609995007514954,
-0.24021397531032562,
-0.7618800401687622,
-0.03585254028439522,
0.5262717008590698,
0.568085253238678,
-0.6897268891334534,
-0.18342076241970062,
0.19419018924236298,
0.08021312952041626,
0.1676163673400879,
0.5605173707008362,
-0.01422787830233574,
0.5459632277488708,
0.04172423109412193,
0.4204084873199463,
0.09964433312416077,
-0.33942991495132446,
-0.6363412141799927,
-0.21776524186134338,
-0.013644099235534668,
-0.7729132175445557
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.