id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11996v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11996v3
|
Accelerating Scientific Discovery with Generative Knowledge Extraction, Graph-Based Representation, and Multimodal Intelligent Graph Reasoning
| 2024-03-18T17:30:27 | 2024-06-10T19:06:26 |
Markus J. Buehler
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cond-mat.mes-hall, cond-mat.mtrl-sci, cond-mat.soft, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Leveraging generative Artificial Intelligence (AI), we have transformed a
dataset comprising 1,000 scientific papers into an ontological knowledge graph.
Through an in-depth structural analysis, we have calculated node degrees,
identified communities and connectivities, and evaluated clustering
coefficients and betweenness centrality of pivotal nodes, uncovering
fascinating knowledge architectures. The graph has an inherently scale-free
nature, is highly connected, and can be used for graph reasoning by taking
advantage of transitive and isomorphic properties that reveal unprecedented
interdisciplinary relationships that can be used to answer queries, identify
gaps in knowledge, propose never-before-seen material designs, and predict
material behaviors. We compute deep node embeddings for combinatorial node
similarity ranking for use in a path sampling strategy links dissimilar
concepts that have previously not been related. One comparison revealed
structural parallels between biological materials and Beethoven's 9th Symphony,
highlighting shared patterns of complexity through isomorphic mapping. In
another example, the algorithm proposed a hierarchical mycelium-based composite
based on integrating path sampling with principles extracted from Kandinsky's
'Composition VII' painting. The resulting material integrates an innovative set
of concepts that include a balance of chaos/order, adjustable porosity,
mechanical strength, and complex patterned chemical functionalization. We
uncover other isomorphisms across science, technology and art, revealing a
nuanced ontology of immanence that reveal a context-dependent heterarchical
interplay of constituents. Graph-based generative AI achieves a far higher
degree of novelty, explorative capacity, and technical detail, than
conventional approaches and establishes a widely useful framework for
innovation by revealing hidden connections.
|
[
-0.35417628288269043,
-0.7373046875,
0.9022023677825928,
0.019919713959097862,
0.1173233836889267,
0.689480721950531,
0.08498989790678024,
-0.5024591088294983,
0.2884962260723114,
0.1691284328699112,
-0.46939635276794434,
-0.6588528156280518,
-0.6603682041168213,
0.14766518771648407,
-0.29115191102027893,
0.6196665167808533,
0.11629602313041687,
-0.08999130874872208,
-0.7022666931152344,
-0.16145850718021393,
0.07607904076576233,
0.1936798095703125,
-0.17524777352809906,
-0.5373668074607849,
0.6543833017349243,
0.29644352197647095,
0.5341653227806091,
0.8944591283798218,
0.5557404160499573,
0.3617808520793915,
-0.1372177004814148,
0.42965006828308105,
-0.28101420402526855,
-0.11216532438993454,
-0.14125899970531464,
-0.5807642936706543,
-0.236331507563591,
0.02958722412586212,
0.4852338433265686,
0.7936411499977112,
0.3022162914276123,
0.07373490184545517,
-0.1992366462945938,
0.6287026405334473,
-0.26916399598121643,
0.7368624806404114,
-0.5008226037025452,
0.3606525659561157,
-0.36999329924583435,
-0.41345056891441345,
-0.18941009044647217,
-0.33228009939193726,
-0.0949573740363121,
-0.9739163517951965,
0.2407829910516739,
0.11804734170436859,
0.6336215734481812,
0.3266000747680664,
-0.25539082288742065,
-0.10934745520353317,
-0.6765360832214355,
0.420737624168396,
-0.15895508229732513,
0.32206130027770996,
0.025652404874563217,
0.3991977870464325,
-0.19930720329284668,
-1.086100697517395,
-0.7157769203186035,
-0.2657541334629059,
0.048440366983413696,
0.3874374032020569,
0.014906849712133408,
0.10119660198688507,
0.2669975757598877,
0.31721505522727966,
-0.7808448672294617,
-0.03430666774511337,
-0.45003020763397217,
-0.30336153507232666,
0.5093076825141907,
-0.013847528025507927,
0.5885380506515503,
-0.15404477715492249,
-0.23950843513011932,
-0.3127157390117645,
-0.7633096575737,
-0.059196341782808304,
0.0982724204659462,
0.16599348187446594,
0.2187177985906601,
0.7718673944473267,
-0.1415809839963913,
0.42264091968536377,
-0.26480546593666077,
0.026089442893862724,
0.23296713829040527,
-0.46247968077659607,
0.24795910716056824,
0.06686907261610031,
0.9454837441444397,
0.052894312888383865,
-0.15219375491142273,
-0.43534696102142334,
0.23579610884189606,
0.16470572352409363,
0.014659996144473553,
-0.6871203184127808,
-0.4136399030685425,
-0.0008198292343877256,
-0.5107253193855286,
-0.2209293395280838,
0.15995170176029205,
-0.6949187517166138,
-0.5424003601074219,
-0.12298039346933365,
0.3731949031352997,
-0.5755890607833862,
-0.2601662278175354,
-0.18644465506076813,
-0.606377899646759,
-0.305359423160553,
0.4721047580242157,
-0.7513462901115417,
-0.0017490864265710115,
0.7427785396575928,
1.1001396179199219,
0.09366316348314285,
-0.29803267121315,
0.15550415217876434,
0.3565172553062439,
-0.47000715136528015,
0.8834986686706543,
-0.6097791194915771,
-0.4708101451396942,
-0.5390338897705078,
-0.09701817482709885,
0.11959975957870483,
-0.5511173605918884,
0.3314754366874695,
-0.6439106464385986,
-0.061841726303100586,
-0.1868254393339157,
-0.4434990882873535,
-0.43232792615890503,
0.045683156698942184,
-0.827688455581665,
0.7287542223930359,
0.4193638265132904,
-0.6828689575195312,
0.37920427322387695,
-1.1114280223846436,
-0.2958855926990509,
0.4830544590950012,
-0.4760762155056,
-0.2905253767967224,
0.005440646782517433,
-0.09785555303096771,
-0.015530422329902649,
-0.44642502069473267,
0.1427672952413559,
-0.5617416501045227,
-0.07781535387039185,
0.053019192069768906,
0.11030525714159012,
0.7483413815498352,
0.3159908354282379,
-0.18781810998916626,
0.23640383780002594,
-0.9024502635002136,
0.05309481546282768,
0.1564949005842209,
-0.05986485630273819,
-0.32874637842178345,
-0.08727442473173141,
-0.20610550045967102,
0.1560027152299881,
0.1847696602344513,
-0.8741315603256226,
0.4388731122016907,
-0.3225245773792267,
0.9588276147842407,
0.7557148337364197,
-0.07175824046134949,
0.41616031527519226,
-0.38118335604667664,
0.278288871049881,
-0.11306159943342209,
-0.0863504633307457,
-0.23531383275985718,
-0.632828950881958,
-0.41004300117492676,
-0.16121743619441986,
0.23938336968421936,
0.38306939601898193,
-0.7453755736351013,
0.4431314766407013,
-0.5172079205513,
-0.7836111783981323,
-0.36950546503067017,
0.077381931245327,
0.20573732256889343,
0.6597855687141418,
0.4363754689693451,
-0.42338016629219055,
-0.43697309494018555,
-0.5905097126960754,
0.12132678180932999,
-0.22554530203342438,
0.035552021116018295,
0.3516528606414795,
0.566268801689148,
-0.43200427293777466,
1.0959804058074951,
-0.742330014705658,
-0.19400881230831146,
0.31066572666168213,
0.44943445920944214,
0.253436803817749,
0.5118066668510437,
0.3407251238822937,
-0.8425260782241821,
-0.44207626581192017,
0.4777621328830719,
-1.2467490434646606,
0.147197887301445,
0.14656373858451843,
-0.17280182242393494,
-0.31297072768211365,
0.7783874273300171,
-0.6679642796516418,
0.2668897211551666,
0.11105761677026749,
-0.22311162948608398,
0.386991947889328,
-0.11842402070760727,
0.17665278911590576,
-0.7892950177192688,
0.09455642849206924,
-0.2899106442928314,
0.3105747401714325,
-0.33594226837158203,
-0.01598266512155533,
-0.23783358931541443,
-0.3140006363391876,
0.07276620715856552,
0.4114891290664673,
-0.4324887990951538,
-0.17362764477729797,
-0.22470739483833313,
-0.19542059302330017,
0.2445632815361023,
0.20150339603424072,
-0.2052566409111023,
0.6517890095710754,
0.4630046784877777,
-0.28666800260543823,
0.5208925008773804,
0.4717669188976288,
-0.4209490418434143,
0.11891419440507889,
-0.5763253569602966,
0.2511100172996521,
-0.3786737024784088,
0.21449454128742218,
-0.8953884243965149,
-0.06309258192777634,
0.2130066305398941,
-0.6363947987556458,
0.22987975180149078,
-0.0029765188228338957,
-0.732347309589386,
-0.43841561675071716,
-0.051478393375873566,
0.6119846105575562,
0.14092889428138733,
-0.3726879954338074,
0.9390932321548462,
0.13790635764598846,
-0.4877711832523346,
-0.17058990895748138,
-0.34299182891845703,
0.20023241639137268,
-0.051255084574222565,
-0.9513682723045349,
0.7592160701751709,
-0.3293233811855316,
-0.3637382686138153,
0.34583672881126404,
-0.09784270077943802,
0.14487603306770325,
0.18210963904857635,
0.3176269233226776,
0.12682609260082245,
-0.17584793269634247,
0.45114853978157043,
0.17303431034088135,
-0.19549734890460968,
0.11534847319126129,
-0.7052452564239502,
0.5726180672645569,
-0.2149014174938202,
-0.47874969244003296,
-0.2046118825674057,
0.36683210730552673,
0.9400546550750732,
-0.10510998219251633,
0.425184965133667,
0.691127359867096,
-0.3135826587677002,
0.03720511496067047,
-0.039827484637498856,
-0.3460961878299713,
-0.43632203340530396,
0.3646221458911896,
-0.5166972875595093,
-0.7391946315765381,
0.5724697709083557,
-0.4835066497325897,
-0.012624450959265232,
0.6522818207740784,
0.21094727516174316,
-0.2558954358100891,
1.1274381875991821,
0.4749959707260132,
0.1748335212469101,
0.44231271743774414,
-0.6865261197090149,
0.3873158097267151,
-0.6695853471755981,
-0.6995521783828735,
-0.5160252451896667,
-0.20778794586658478,
-0.6343445181846619,
-0.6158843040466309,
0.8206086754798889,
0.13788431882858276,
-0.36813172698020935,
0.03918803855776787,
-0.6690213084220886,
0.2938178777694702,
0.7715771794319153,
0.24820590019226074,
0.49867403507232666,
0.10442992299795151,
-0.11968465149402618,
0.28141292929649353,
-0.8000109195709229,
-0.3953758478164673,
1.161281943321228,
-0.030313124880194664,
0.6964794397354126,
-0.08823878318071365,
0.6104004383087158,
0.5561351776123047,
0.34782227873802185,
-0.7213892936706543,
0.42474478483200073,
-0.09966256469488144,
-0.4077014923095703,
-0.4164399206638336,
-0.5269525051116943,
-0.982336163520813,
0.0012244191020727158,
-0.3928283751010895,
-0.5030359029769897,
0.23315487802028656,
0.03937193751335144,
-0.19282227754592896,
0.3631282448768616,
-0.6392942070960999,
0.5746038556098938,
-0.30420878529548645,
-0.2761349678039551,
-0.47970783710479736,
-0.897535502910614,
0.21552391350269318,
-0.013572252355515957,
0.40096113085746765,
-0.013845186680555344,
0.32818838953971863,
0.6455507278442383,
-0.20889903604984283,
0.6265190839767456,
0.09500324726104736,
0.17519916594028473,
0.4755125045776367,
0.04875493794679642,
0.21392922103405,
0.02213802933692932,
-0.016164086759090424,
0.2554546296596527,
-0.1007065400481224,
-0.4394187927246094,
-0.915751039981842,
0.601473331451416,
-0.9660732746124268,
-0.7132405638694763,
-0.09812277555465698,
-0.8925914168357849,
-0.04416162148118019,
0.47910311818122864,
0.33950185775756836,
0.3086734712123871,
-0.1676686406135559,
0.24298736453056335,
0.6048352122306824,
0.06318382173776627,
0.1993919014930725,
0.049976326525211334,
-0.004746673628687859,
-0.3410951793193817,
1.374219536781311,
0.37761300802230835,
0.03796553984284401,
0.6898574829101562,
0.42631226778030396,
-0.28657081723213196,
-0.6004602909088135,
-0.4153195321559906,
0.10978426039218903,
-0.6627995371818542,
-0.219382643699646,
-0.7917059659957886,
-0.2676405608654022,
-0.6058315634727478,
-0.08241454511880875,
-0.13480724394321442,
-0.768212616443634,
-0.3194460868835449,
-0.3217775225639343,
0.3376895785331726,
0.8812257647514343,
-0.2790462374687195,
-0.12418173998594284,
-0.7393800616264343,
0.2614577114582062,
0.3550424575805664,
0.14640545845031738,
0.0988854467868805,
0.1332087367773056,
-0.296633243560791,
-0.06799434125423431,
-0.4569912552833557,
-0.5793071389198303,
0.11491983383893967,
0.3100109100341797,
0.6236922144889832,
0.7176687717437744,
-0.13026219606399536,
0.31130266189575195,
-0.3919205367565155,
0.353625625371933,
0.19096823036670685,
-0.5120730996131897,
0.6216620802879333,
-0.4322811961174011,
-0.06053866446018219,
0.2635119557380676,
0.6326620578765869,
-0.15644687414169312,
-0.04037715122103691,
-0.9081096649169922,
-0.8293877840042114,
0.20675159990787506,
-0.01691448502242565,
-0.3218698501586914,
0.16846272349357605,
0.25063657760620117,
0.29960307478904724,
0.16824865341186523,
-0.5250554084777832,
-0.009386982768774033,
-0.6607394814491272,
-0.28632333874702454,
-0.010496492497622967,
0.25525277853012085,
-0.7552505135536194,
-0.3746240735054016,
0.4539323151111603,
-0.44219568371772766,
0.36962413787841797,
0.11911674588918686,
0.09333988279104233,
0.05094693601131439,
-0.040862761437892914,
0.37790778279304504,
0.6475229859352112,
-0.10866452008485794,
0.3086784780025482,
-0.28160107135772705,
-0.447671502828598,
0.03898957371711731,
0.4381275773048401,
-0.41778039932250977,
-0.33073511719703674,
0.537916362285614,
0.6807621717453003,
-0.5631945729255676,
-0.7299696803092957,
-0.09879294782876968,
0.19741083681583405,
-0.26369526982307434,
-0.008128994144499302,
0.08139095455408096,
0.01695079728960991,
0.5170812606811523,
0.5024194121360779,
0.3491002917289734,
0.2988852560520172,
-0.8452988266944885,
0.05039270594716072,
0.4974789023399353,
-0.41423001885414124,
-0.5173872709274292,
0.5897937417030334,
-0.038847558200359344,
-0.1996048092842102,
0.6139452457427979,
-0.28215739130973816,
-0.3808688819408417,
0.9445131421089172,
0.4399320185184479,
0.5890191197395325,
0.11672050505876541,
0.2962883412837982,
0.2004930078983307,
0.10865365713834763,
0.3678169846534729,
0.0031042026821523905,
-0.3443116247653961,
-0.865202784538269,
0.053494252264499664,
-0.504448652267456,
-0.3113764226436615,
-0.29297059774398804,
-0.15228886902332306,
-0.08001843839883804,
-0.635890543460846,
-0.03167649731040001,
0.3747227191925049,
0.013380342163145542,
-0.34265661239624023,
0.042470064014196396,
-0.2528255879878998,
0.7984095215797424,
-1.1036335229873657,
0.443063884973526,
0.675216794013977,
-0.6027116179466248,
-0.5487594604492188,
-0.4170183837413788,
0.16489392518997192,
-0.976931095123291,
0.8551957607269287,
0.09283983707427979,
-0.10973555594682693,
0.28956469893455505,
-0.722900390625,
-1.0318350791931152,
1.518778920173645,
0.24144324660301208,
-0.27189353108406067,
0.11640235036611557,
-0.14185099303722382,
0.6267709136009216,
-0.36175575852394104,
0.27678149938583374,
0.3048716187477112,
0.645624577999115,
0.4779922664165497,
-0.24790135025978088,
0.0563875250518322,
-0.6591451168060303,
-0.17429937422275543,
0.22264663875102997,
-0.7612704038619995,
0.9000284671783447,
-0.3632987141609192,
-0.49891990423202515,
0.10804782807826996,
0.7741917371749878,
0.3525642454624176,
0.562981903553009,
0.40796026587486267,
0.8843340277671814,
0.9527933597564697,
-0.256443589925766,
0.7884970307350159,
-0.30492541193962097,
0.06422083079814911,
0.5835665464401245,
-0.17767482995986938,
0.13341905176639557,
0.45717644691467285,
-0.24398639798164368,
1.059762716293335,
0.5795308351516724,
-0.29878881573677063,
0.5804519653320312,
0.31185272336006165,
-0.4652749001979828,
-0.07777422666549683,
-0.7038424611091614,
-0.5163537859916687,
0.36175087094306946,
0.5977566838264465,
-0.22400903701782227,
-0.1281188577413559,
0.1967601776123047,
-0.14018350839614868,
0.1564938724040985,
-0.21826496720314026,
0.7093431949615479,
-0.05621051415801048,
-0.5794307589530945,
0.10529298335313797,
-0.28252312541007996,
0.2234257608652115,
-0.5150859951972961,
-0.5005216002464294,
0.07041170448064804,
-0.16791202127933502,
-0.2539322078227997,
-0.7863995432853699,
0.14091576635837555,
-0.7211490273475647,
-0.5081008076667786,
-0.20948989689350128,
0.6230228543281555,
-0.1549115777015686,
-0.4192260503768921,
0.1993936449289322,
0.5014144778251648,
-0.12906613945960999,
0.16025562584400177,
-0.2681712210178375,
-0.08160100877285004,
-0.2541252672672272,
0.14800404012203217,
0.2289777398109436,
0.6867431402206421,
-0.30311670899391174,
0.8615004420280457,
0.9343515634536743,
0.002186919329687953,
-0.06002373248338699,
0.0156765915453434,
1.1852859258651733,
-0.6781523823738098,
-0.32518234848976135,
-0.5105803608894348,
0.23583251237869263,
-0.17101110517978668,
-0.012133796699345112,
0.5729960799217224,
0.6969620585441589,
0.8034420013427734,
-0.0457112118601799,
0.9985219240188599,
-0.282027006149292,
0.12965555489063263,
-0.4869503676891327,
0.675869882106781,
-0.4695725739002228,
0.08741366118192673,
-0.2736266255378723,
-0.546123206615448,
-0.32190486788749695,
0.36044561862945557,
-0.030830295756459236,
-0.024620214477181435,
0.6416186690330505,
0.731367290019989,
0.15704144537448883,
0.15762406587600708,
-0.060483645647764206,
0.4482358694076538,
0.5725782513618469,
0.2725929021835327,
0.8915399312973022,
-0.0008415902848355472,
0.5636568665504456,
-0.0822182148694992,
-0.5501730442047119,
-0.04018158093094826,
-0.6435080170631409,
-0.48870113492012024,
-0.7724215984344482,
-0.20526368916034698,
-0.29122430086135864,
-0.06864196062088013,
0.5154273509979248,
0.6631824970245361,
-0.5101493000984192,
-0.03082575462758541,
-0.6850519180297852,
0.38987162709236145,
-0.23580487072467804,
-0.2707193195819855,
0.5926236510276794,
-0.13433341681957245,
-0.5134559273719788,
0.6699668169021606,
0.6734829545021057,
0.236685648560524,
-0.3061813712120056,
0.03872327134013176,
-0.08678070455789566,
-0.22248172760009766,
0.6714933514595032,
0.6238659620285034,
-0.3912496268749237,
-0.09894964098930359,
0.15212048590183258,
0.1701170653104782,
0.26602011919021606,
0.7494385242462158,
-0.6801344156265259,
0.7841681838035583,
1.007040023803711,
0.6379722356796265,
0.7727360129356384,
-0.02707858383655548,
0.4274718463420868,
-0.3681849241256714,
0.006830025929957628,
0.5406434535980225,
0.3111881911754608,
0.25151747465133667,
-0.34265613555908203,
0.6364116072654724,
0.8328893184661865,
-0.4821542799472809,
-0.544904351234436,
0.47705405950546265,
-1.145298719406128,
-0.5227260589599609,
0.3449679911136627,
-0.10978977382183075,
-0.19280190765857697,
-0.1751059740781784,
0.0033080987632274628,
0.33302366733551025,
-0.22124139964580536,
1.2311145067214966,
0.49025270342826843,
-0.6530004739761353,
-0.20791295170783997,
-0.08442633599042892,
0.37240034341812134,
0.08828325569629669,
-1.0334006547927856,
-0.4043636918067932,
0.2658821642398834,
-0.007185100577771664,
0.9668399691581726,
0.46576568484306335,
-0.31655579805374146,
0.1436150223016739,
0.22412902116775513,
-0.046619754284620285,
-0.45678141713142395,
-0.6954792141914368,
0.31406667828559875,
0.4019613265991211,
0.05283002182841301,
0.1254855841398239
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11984v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11984v1
|
Using Generative Text Models to Create Qualitative Codebooks for Student Evaluations of Teaching
| 2024-03-18T17:21:35 | 2024-03-18T17:21:35 |
Andrew Katz, Mitchell Gerhardt, Michelle Soledad
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC
|
Feedback is a critical aspect of improvement. Unfortunately, when there is a
lot of feedback from multiple sources, it can be difficult to distill the
information into actionable insights. Consider student evaluations of teaching
(SETs), which are important sources of feedback for educators. They can give
instructors insights into what worked during a semester. A collection of SETs
can also be useful to administrators as signals for courses or entire programs.
However, on a large scale as in high-enrollment courses or administrative
records over several years, the volume of SETs can render them difficult to
analyze. In this paper, we discuss a novel method for analyzing SETs using
natural language processing (NLP) and large language models (LLMs). We
demonstrate the method by applying it to a corpus of 5,000 SETs from a large
public university. We show that the method can be used to extract, embed,
cluster, and summarize the SETs to identify the themes they express. More
generally, this work illustrates how to use the combination of NLP techniques
and LLMs to generate a codebook for SETs. We conclude by discussing the
implications of this method for analyzing SETs and other types of student
writing in teaching and research settings.
|
[
-0.32611072063446045,
-0.5936484932899475,
0.234728142619133,
-0.0038468455895781517,
-0.12655065953731537,
0.36943507194519043,
-0.5966349244117737,
-0.11078735440969467,
0.006752484478056431,
0.5253103375434875,
-0.20134486258029938,
-0.6670356392860413,
-0.3315894901752472,
0.32225650548934937,
-0.8727861642837524,
1.2361871004104614,
0.018957918509840965,
0.24314825236797333,
-0.48830825090408325,
-0.17972135543823242,
-0.7522978186607361,
-0.4645223617553711,
-0.3126040995121002,
-0.45237603783607483,
0.17809851467609406,
0.3448040187358856,
0.5369797945022583,
0.25199922919273376,
0.631790816783905,
0.3005535304546356,
-0.00926542840898037,
0.13455918431282043,
-0.30323830246925354,
0.04348111152648926,
-0.2379898577928543,
-0.4015399217605591,
-0.027890341356396675,
-0.05499543994665146,
1.0863114595413208,
0.8514942526817322,
-0.0958094373345375,
0.2258797436952591,
0.23367241024971008,
0.5075830817222595,
-0.5384635925292969,
0.003612366272136569,
-0.20271769165992737,
0.3094944357872009,
0.04861798509955406,
-0.34563401341438293,
-0.7639461159706116,
-0.7674738764762878,
0.15640033781528473,
-0.4282665550708771,
0.33738529682159424,
-0.4949324131011963,
0.5687310099601746,
-0.029056888073682785,
-0.19731806218624115,
-0.44800493121147156,
-0.6935931444168091,
1.0381582975387573,
-0.9184976816177368,
-0.007706375792622566,
0.36297646164894104,
0.08142387121915817,
-0.16375434398651123,
-0.5110184550285339,
-0.48146891593933105,
-0.21440385282039642,
-0.08226966112852097,
0.30688753724098206,
0.17989392578601837,
-0.17143358290195465,
0.30348849296569824,
0.7758334279060364,
-0.2838903069496155,
0.17439313232898712,
-0.3459750711917877,
0.1779681295156479,
0.6311639547348022,
0.279278427362442,
0.4569006860256195,
-0.4513605535030365,
-0.19171211123466492,
-0.23398663103580475,
-0.4747444689273834,
-0.004263300448656082,
0.34362661838531494,
0.34473565220832825,
-0.01338102761656046,
0.6084651350975037,
0.06905435025691986,
1.0170689821243286,
-0.40051019191741943,
-0.2182038575410843,
-0.09448643028736115,
-0.36039289832115173,
-0.12867827713489532,
-0.16406407952308655,
0.7110542058944702,
0.3534088134765625,
0.22460824251174927,
-0.2585664987564087,
-0.3645861744880676,
0.4312469959259033,
0.4511638283729553,
-0.6483359336853027,
-0.315735787153244,
0.21863935887813568,
-0.5217816233634949,
-0.5497210621833801,
0.1614769697189331,
-1.0602186918258667,
-0.47236204147338867,
-0.8117521405220032,
0.23293964564800262,
-0.46377333998680115,
-0.36254429817199707,
0.03596138954162598,
-0.1632714718580246,
0.18047398328781128,
0.32839035987854004,
-0.908643901348114,
0.3828771114349365,
0.6162141561508179,
0.7386434078216553,
-0.20602034032344818,
-0.3255757987499237,
-0.34655556082725525,
-0.02034318819642067,
-0.5024185180664062,
0.878888726234436,
-0.9274744987487793,
-0.6944579482078552,
0.5771578550338745,
-0.19647900760173798,
0.12392538040876389,
-0.631107747554779,
0.29560554027557373,
-0.321827232837677,
0.2744753360748291,
-0.15489299595355988,
-0.9881863594055176,
0.23008204996585846,
0.35084688663482666,
-0.6942099332809448,
1.3211075067520142,
0.20628923177719116,
-0.4267825484275818,
0.0011822410160675645,
-0.5808818936347961,
-0.3769167363643646,
0.22238072752952576,
-0.5066731572151184,
-0.235677570104599,
0.25611409544944763,
0.29402315616607666,
0.6111448407173157,
-0.2053133100271225,
0.39893344044685364,
0.1868414431810379,
-0.5273628234863281,
0.5037561655044556,
-0.07215173542499542,
0.7036848664283752,
0.06267255544662476,
-0.23923982679843903,
0.1690681427717209,
-0.9047279357910156,
0.3795482814311981,
-0.07745528221130371,
-0.6014792919158936,
-0.5923769474029541,
-0.07721587270498276,
0.12904992699623108,
-0.177641823887825,
-0.1052522137761116,
-0.048846617341041565,
0.48530447483062744,
-0.21194516122341156,
0.3358491063117981,
0.7064159512519836,
0.10725726932287216,
0.4370996356010437,
-0.29230135679244995,
0.9087069630622864,
-0.17635613679885864,
-0.15123097598552704,
-0.47011101245880127,
-0.256835013628006,
-0.6913013458251953,
0.08164649456739426,
0.4246872067451477,
-0.16361500322818756,
-0.9960659742355347,
0.2503493130207062,
-0.27741506695747375,
-0.5792708992958069,
-0.4728248417377472,
0.24621394276618958,
0.5847919583320618,
0.14508412778377533,
0.17784000933170319,
-0.3705074191093445,
-0.3009764552116394,
-0.3792079985141754,
-0.2503589391708374,
0.12865369021892548,
-0.1497052013874054,
-0.25671690702438354,
0.5689265727996826,
0.11055289953947067,
1.0439237356185913,
-0.7108210325241089,
0.0034653511829674244,
-0.19765709340572357,
0.10922729969024658,
0.09211481362581253,
0.5747162699699402,
0.3645201623439789,
-0.4879719913005829,
-0.30897295475006104,
-0.02467184327542782,
-0.9023699760437012,
0.04720618948340416,
-0.32592442631721497,
-0.3522825837135315,
-0.14630183577537537,
0.3487435281276703,
-0.05218306556344032,
0.3457023501396179,
0.415483683347702,
-0.3794492781162262,
0.7921304702758789,
0.04889718070626259,
0.09700215607881546,
-0.9742187261581421,
-0.09404046833515167,
0.16471028327941895,
0.1258019655942917,
-0.22476233541965485,
0.2230072319507599,
0.028578942641615868,
-0.46592438220977783,
0.005050212144851685,
0.36400267481803894,
-0.5425102710723877,
-0.15825866162776947,
-0.22511914372444153,
0.3356982171535492,
0.24340792000293732,
0.35037311911582947,
0.012768462300300598,
0.614365816116333,
0.2889760136604309,
-0.45922499895095825,
0.44400766491889954,
0.564837634563446,
-0.783566951751709,
0.8476271033287048,
-0.3425985872745514,
0.30174294114112854,
0.020548252388834953,
0.352538138628006,
-0.5399017333984375,
-0.06995787471532822,
-0.18404564261436462,
-0.26180633902549744,
0.20819397270679474,
-0.24097108840942383,
-0.44436901807785034,
-0.30730822682380676,
-0.5298423767089844,
0.024176517501473427,
0.17324796319007874,
-0.7594397068023682,
0.4454261064529419,
0.19465528428554535,
-0.13429442048072815,
-0.6596184372901917,
-0.4408063292503357,
0.17821188271045685,
-0.011903884820640087,
-0.1381186544895172,
0.1262781322002411,
-0.1828441023826599,
-0.5357228517532349,
0.12366952002048492,
-0.07388319075107574,
-0.16540348529815674,
0.04946077987551689,
0.2969013452529907,
0.4428780674934387,
-0.15995319187641144,
0.634568989276886,
0.026046637445688248,
0.014585789293050766,
0.13616275787353516,
-0.3537209630012512,
0.4747939109802246,
-0.2315799444913864,
-0.15348969399929047,
-0.1924697607755661,
0.5628928542137146,
0.27252838015556335,
-0.4288169741630554,
0.5683438777923584,
0.4742166996002197,
-0.41030699014663696,
-0.9039337635040283,
-0.4247775673866272,
-0.2884235680103302,
-0.4028039574623108,
0.4034775197505951,
-0.14248710870742798,
-0.638390839099884,
0.09183838218450546,
0.12658561766147614,
0.3422160744667053,
0.22450599074363708,
0.593104898929596,
0.08253074437379837,
0.29242661595344543,
0.6024924516677856,
-0.050218529999256134,
0.6061927676200867,
-0.7720131278038025,
0.3109152913093567,
-0.7606360912322998,
-0.2913303077220917,
-0.7952665090560913,
-0.04961799457669258,
-0.23634763062000275,
-0.23984910547733307,
0.07962294667959213,
0.1284436732530594,
0.0420733317732811,
0.1860499382019043,
-0.8075413703918457,
0.8171980381011963,
0.7017114758491516,
0.13583442568778992,
0.4531232416629791,
0.1615297496318817,
0.2705872654914856,
0.013695226050913334,
-0.7284489870071411,
-1.0667251348495483,
1.3585323095321655,
0.1589118093252182,
0.6071215271949768,
0.1221880242228508,
0.6484060287475586,
0.3359966576099396,
0.7762760519981384,
-0.9458695650100708,
0.606250524520874,
-0.2897062599658966,
-0.461458295583725,
-0.49646127223968506,
-0.41276678442955017,
-0.7693333625793457,
0.43581512570381165,
-0.4347569942474365,
-0.29663777351379395,
-0.04410462826490402,
-0.16053694486618042,
-0.38647404313087463,
0.4620806872844696,
-0.7217721939086914,
0.7636710405349731,
0.09377150237560272,
-0.2525257468223572,
-0.07267607003450394,
-0.20712371170520782,
0.2208835333585739,
-0.06555752456188202,
0.1524646133184433,
0.03878790885210037,
0.5168024897575378,
1.2912719249725342,
-0.4683026075363159,
0.9004642963409424,
0.044085729867219925,
-0.43926379084587097,
0.6928520202636719,
0.0431281179189682,
0.08666075766086578,
0.18008653819561005,
-0.27246803045272827,
-0.039816714823246,
0.3539927303791046,
-0.3397497534751892,
-0.7529438734054565,
0.766642689704895,
-0.7527661323547363,
-0.3122215270996094,
-0.34339213371276855,
-0.6147078275680542,
-0.3808450400829315,
0.03393184766173363,
0.0067121670581400394,
0.9788182377815247,
-0.013842386193573475,
0.12675277888774872,
0.4495093524456024,
-0.2730907201766968,
0.5789098739624023,
0.247625470161438,
-0.35503849387168884,
-0.24298930168151855,
1.0135995149612427,
0.25214624404907227,
0.34276214241981506,
0.18946298956871033,
0.21340510249137878,
-0.13330242037773132,
-0.49791592359542847,
-0.44479900598526,
0.12361285835504532,
-1.033053994178772,
-0.42605721950531006,
-0.26842644810676575,
-0.1471293717622757,
-0.46329545974731445,
-0.36303597688674927,
0.10320381075143814,
-0.3129485249519348,
-0.3216634690761566,
-0.3247409164905548,
0.17592521011829376,
1.0477092266082764,
0.29709234833717346,
0.4912906885147095,
-0.8118203282356262,
0.1420574188232422,
0.3985491394996643,
0.4814384877681732,
0.443447083234787,
-0.40355610847473145,
-0.5080180168151855,
-0.19645477831363678,
-0.4250759184360504,
-0.8697413802146912,
0.482600599527359,
0.06259278953075409,
0.15815725922584534,
0.4780788719654083,
0.08416753262281418,
0.39772698283195496,
-0.2926245331764221,
0.865230143070221,
0.2776811122894287,
-0.9364815354347229,
0.6773347854614258,
-0.3849193751811981,
0.2983786463737488,
0.5132538080215454,
0.22468020021915436,
-0.5088207125663757,
-0.47399038076400757,
-0.5789771676063538,
-0.6339125037193298,
0.5842679142951965,
-0.0625041127204895,
0.4209935665130615,
-0.07486345618963242,
0.5349502563476562,
0.08900166302919388,
0.38659945130348206,
-0.773708701133728,
-0.11863357573747635,
-0.1354716569185257,
-0.5747606158256531,
-0.12082637846469879,
-0.632487952709198,
-0.5011292695999146,
-0.19649045169353485,
0.5490320324897766,
-0.21493490040302277,
0.07087250798940659,
-0.052757661789655685,
0.017515333369374275,
-0.04647580161690712,
0.7021550536155701,
0.35268518328666687,
1.170938491821289,
-0.06998557597398758,
0.27627724409103394,
0.015443436801433563,
-0.5491786003112793,
0.11183545738458633,
-0.30139273405075073,
0.0006622645305469632,
0.3070622384548187,
0.7798025608062744,
0.3199998736381531,
0.34825053811073303,
-0.7474099397659302,
0.4327741861343384,
0.17635999619960785,
0.07805491238832474,
-0.5693827271461487,
0.00711965374648571,
-0.14594952762126923,
0.007324901409447193,
0.30320078134536743,
-0.3226294219493866,
0.017912128940224648,
-0.6741425395011902,
-0.006904385052621365,
-0.03447772189974785,
-0.4233539402484894,
-0.21895594894886017,
-0.003774431999772787,
0.4324426054954529,
-0.3131785988807678,
0.7896294593811035,
0.278615802526474,
-0.383196085691452,
0.9152175784111023,
0.7770004272460938,
0.8013598918914795,
-0.15918835997581482,
0.6124559044837952,
0.5050126314163208,
0.12569183111190796,
-0.3253406286239624,
-0.0070124962367117405,
-0.018805986270308495,
-0.7060680985450745,
-0.4731540381908417,
-0.795785665512085,
-0.5641310811042786,
0.12191261351108551,
-1.1500505208969116,
0.16013549268245697,
-0.6120131611824036,
-0.05304538086056709,
0.17045651376247406,
-0.04105032607913017,
-0.3841097950935364,
0.4195863902568817,
-0.1478932797908783,
0.5212969779968262,
-1.0079076290130615,
0.5887994766235352,
1.0121878385543823,
-0.6410070657730103,
-0.8864545822143555,
-0.19990350306034088,
-0.14217530190944672,
-0.37478509545326233,
0.4703667163848877,
0.08796146512031555,
0.3042052686214447,
-0.08856210857629776,
-0.5707894563674927,
-0.2120557725429535,
0.5886792540550232,
-0.12067652493715286,
-0.7607263326644897,
-0.0682574212551117,
-0.041423480957746506,
0.7058166265487671,
-0.18550550937652588,
0.18547341227531433,
0.5332701206207275,
0.36900487542152405,
-0.3975951671600342,
-0.40896809101104736,
-0.11492998898029327,
-0.25847598910331726,
0.1817554235458374,
0.26953065395355225,
-0.3145548403263092,
0.5364978313446045,
-0.043216828256845474,
-0.097374327480793,
-0.12384048849344254,
0.5624538660049438,
0.03742578253149986,
0.23957382142543793,
0.26615190505981445,
0.6067217588424683,
0.7585439085960388,
-0.26481127738952637,
1.180116057395935,
0.002469742903485894,
0.5518955588340759,
1.2104696035385132,
0.07157842069864273,
0.9376581311225891,
0.47190213203430176,
-0.6122201681137085,
0.5580422282218933,
0.3294125497341156,
-0.40011438727378845,
0.15444013476371765,
0.6882439255714417,
-0.47728949785232544,
-0.1962602436542511,
-0.1615051031112671,
-0.49011701345443726,
0.1715543121099472,
0.20079675316810608,
-0.2068849802017212,
-0.005659906659275293,
0.31257855892181396,
-0.10889249294996262,
0.7177104949951172,
-0.4298011362552643,
0.6207432746887207,
0.13687142729759216,
-0.7067002654075623,
0.30912652611732483,
-0.10217129439115524,
0.5123677253723145,
-0.2863575518131256,
-0.33613574504852295,
-0.3062911331653595,
0.03716888278722763,
-0.6144794225692749,
-0.8639979958534241,
0.16835527122020721,
0.24787387251853943,
-0.40178820490837097,
-0.1250120997428894,
0.3108161985874176,
-0.3970884084701538,
-0.7694088220596313,
-0.022361844778060913,
0.0986042246222496,
-0.06979668140411377,
0.35885173082351685,
-0.08225081861019135,
0.14392079412937164,
0.08785168081521988,
-0.05609917268157005,
0.18286509811878204,
0.29763156175613403,
0.011945684440433979,
0.3913000226020813,
0.6850277185440063,
0.10423979163169861,
-0.0405583418905735,
0.6542549729347229,
0.7614148855209351,
-0.7745193839073181,
-0.3149809241294861,
-0.5616353750228882,
0.5773812532424927,
-0.22448329627513885,
-0.6293140053749084,
0.8339861631393433,
0.45928889513015747,
1.1224496364593506,
-0.22741124033927917,
1.061130166053772,
0.0802411213517189,
0.48966577649116516,
-0.6482876539230347,
0.40175861120224,
-0.15925851464271545,
0.600314736366272,
-0.47191715240478516,
-0.9804702401161194,
-0.2490643411874771,
0.6683761477470398,
-0.40922901034355164,
0.006176491733640432,
0.7951346039772034,
0.2824329137802124,
0.3489718437194824,
0.3749374747276306,
0.24250994622707367,
0.007468842435628176,
0.4910259246826172,
0.17001330852508545,
1.2511096000671387,
-0.4761679470539093,
0.38658958673477173,
-0.30650269985198975,
-0.1954507827758789,
0.012464776635169983,
-0.5272930264472961,
-1.1062726974487305,
-0.635622501373291,
-0.6740266680717468,
-0.688373327255249,
-0.008228437043726444,
0.7259082794189453,
0.2185026854276657,
-0.8024300336837769,
-0.4357817471027374,
0.1671050786972046,
0.19363364577293396,
-0.14423583447933197,
-0.29982122778892517,
0.6923955082893372,
-0.48935478925704956,
-0.8518890738487244,
0.254285603761673,
-0.010495394468307495,
-0.07138456404209137,
-0.4530411660671234,
0.1695430427789688,
0.07816703617572784,
-0.0949975773692131,
0.6268531680107117,
0.012139837257564068,
-0.5572426319122314,
-0.176222026348114,
-0.4052163064479828,
-0.0758291631937027,
-0.1452953815460205,
1.1012884378433228,
-0.6080623269081116,
0.6065457463264465,
0.17867067456245422,
0.7161704301834106,
0.23929066956043243,
-0.11534527689218521,
0.5140873193740845,
-0.7540965676307678,
0.01721552573144436,
0.5446782112121582,
0.3209298849105835,
0.4661625921726227,
-0.02278766967356205,
0.7517505288124084,
0.07301707565784454,
-0.40121859312057495,
-1.031058669090271,
-0.14509505033493042,
-0.9420471787452698,
-0.44716307520866394,
1.085493803024292,
-0.3946921229362488,
0.06986374408006668,
0.10054599493741989,
-0.22510658204555511,
0.004463917575776577,
0.07225959748029709,
1.0017223358154297,
0.9463221430778503,
0.3198135495185852,
0.06165700405836105,
-0.46766161918640137,
0.2645232379436493,
0.39831244945526123,
-1.0574326515197754,
-0.1226324513554573,
0.677703320980072,
0.17819197475910187,
0.2524974048137665,
0.431863933801651,
-0.30777159333229065,
0.027533242478966713,
0.049331746995449066,
0.2701157331466675,
0.11540263891220093,
-0.26708468794822693,
-0.5353202223777771,
0.3941803574562073,
0.017331181094050407,
-0.04941226914525032
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15452v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15452v1
|
What Are Tools Anyway? A Survey from the Language Model Perspective
| 2024-03-18T17:20:07 | 2024-03-18T17:20:07 |
Zhiruo Wang, Zhoujun Cheng, Hao Zhu, Daniel Fried, Graham Neubig
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Language models (LMs) are powerful yet mostly for text generation tasks.
Tools have substantially enhanced their performance for tasks that require
complex skills. However, many works adopt the term "tool" in different ways,
raising the question: What is a tool anyway? Subsequently, where and how do
tools help LMs? In this survey, we provide a unified definition of tools as
external programs used by LMs, and perform a systematic review of LM tooling
scenarios and approaches. Grounded on this review, we empirically study the
efficiency of various tooling methods by measuring their required compute and
performance gains on various benchmarks, and highlight some challenges and
potential future research in the field.
|
[
-0.384786456823349,
-0.8195468783378601,
0.6127384305000305,
-0.03089624084532261,
-0.20672616362571716,
0.2527469992637634,
-0.0560787208378315,
-0.37250441312789917,
-0.09872156381607056,
0.5003493428230286,
-0.7332253456115723,
-0.21156682074069977,
-0.4831826090812683,
0.22334297001361847,
-0.6552707552909851,
0.8551713824272156,
-0.07257731258869171,
0.2520163953304291,
-0.2766766846179962,
-0.11244659870862961,
-0.49583399295806885,
-0.45285725593566895,
-0.6293212175369263,
-0.2906181216239929,
0.6716084480285645,
0.4105057120323181,
0.8733139038085938,
0.3593961298465729,
0.7982640266418457,
0.4982219636440277,
0.15781232714653015,
-0.05427635461091995,
-0.17926862835884094,
0.1642993837594986,
-0.10947974026203156,
-0.6228589415550232,
-0.3160882592201233,
0.18689875304698944,
0.28769829869270325,
0.8314118981361389,
0.00033541180891916156,
0.5839803218841553,
0.1012967973947525,
0.5199700593948364,
-0.5675041079521179,
-0.47531649470329285,
-0.6240935325622559,
-0.007955248467624187,
-0.20893621444702148,
-0.06123017147183418,
-0.2542034685611725,
-0.706346333026886,
0.05315084382891655,
-0.11610372364521027,
0.22043737769126892,
-0.09373486042022705,
0.4429088830947876,
0.10681071132421494,
-0.21879354119300842,
-0.5703765153884888,
-0.8177666664123535,
0.7815842032432556,
-0.9315957427024841,
0.41011250019073486,
0.23035511374473572,
0.4624319076538086,
-0.026072438806295395,
-0.8717972636222839,
-0.4017139971256256,
-0.2850489020347595,
0.024483676999807358,
-0.1919635534286499,
0.10880881547927856,
0.03141240403056145,
0.4412376880645752,
0.4437197744846344,
-0.1839224398136139,
0.11226364225149155,
-0.34670159220695496,
-0.22550134360790253,
0.689412534236908,
0.479353666305542,
0.6168516278266907,
-0.04144712910056114,
0.15631051361560822,
-0.3739411234855652,
-0.885265052318573,
0.08409323543310165,
0.7276690006256104,
0.22171907126903534,
0.18035346269607544,
0.8374307751655579,
0.34549403190612793,
0.8278348445892334,
-0.48530519008636475,
-0.42037829756736755,
-0.23787708580493927,
-0.4887659549713135,
-0.5486916899681091,
-0.19189859926700592,
0.7157459855079651,
0.30634605884552,
0.025172680616378784,
-0.3389812409877777,
-0.3622397184371948,
-0.1609199047088623,
0.26518359780311584,
-0.6130374073982239,
-0.2791256904602051,
0.35836726427078247,
-0.11087002605199814,
-0.2862192392349243,
0.03742841258645058,
-0.2029610276222229,
-0.608826220035553,
-0.12322330474853516,
0.4296690821647644,
-0.27773410081863403,
-0.5741560459136963,
-0.26922306418418884,
-0.5135294795036316,
0.07052384316921234,
0.29097795486450195,
-0.28098177909851074,
0.25068798661231995,
0.6228235960006714,
1.017783761024475,
-0.12596270442008972,
-0.0018702823435887694,
-0.4152847230434418,
-0.2271709144115448,
-0.6851625442504883,
0.8201205134391785,
-0.3280567228794098,
-0.8681399822235107,
0.19419801235198975,
0.2401631474494934,
0.24909444153308868,
-0.38586387038230896,
0.3133421540260315,
-0.33137622475624084,
0.5029576420783997,
-0.5785722136497498,
-0.4951520264148712,
-0.29699206352233887,
-0.054020754992961884,
-0.7064607739448547,
1.354303240776062,
0.17329885065555573,
-0.6683186888694763,
0.5361197590827942,
-0.608177661895752,
-0.44107919931411743,
0.13606756925582886,
-0.041438695043325424,
-0.3351820409297943,
0.3966921269893646,
-0.20778225362300873,
0.4590255320072174,
-0.6468691825866699,
0.3935357332229614,
-0.3785247206687927,
-0.38858622312545776,
0.46865880489349365,
-0.31823182106018066,
0.6679911613464355,
0.23036491870880127,
-0.21551144123077393,
0.3746627867221832,
-0.5219911336898804,
0.21559084951877594,
0.16860979795455933,
-0.30552929639816284,
-0.4149264097213745,
0.2349371612071991,
0.20106756687164307,
0.48803290724754333,
0.0388919971883297,
-0.579346239566803,
0.26244616508483887,
-0.6900188326835632,
0.27753275632858276,
0.6532155871391296,
-0.27335166931152344,
0.594039797782898,
-0.32906538248062134,
0.6853570342063904,
-0.2538178563117981,
-0.1827947199344635,
-0.25061312317848206,
-0.4439837336540222,
-0.9230453372001648,
0.08013916015625,
0.49763593077659607,
0.3327167332172394,
-0.6163955926895142,
0.4179804027080536,
0.011355146765708923,
-0.9849860668182373,
-0.9622222781181335,
0.28753453493118286,
0.38099923729896545,
-0.02022402547299862,
-0.1499185860157013,
-0.27604493498802185,
-0.5847025513648987,
-0.9491963386535645,
-0.7027611136436462,
-0.052301760762929916,
-0.04940572381019592,
0.14496733248233795,
0.45038437843322754,
0.05528292432427406,
1.0137619972229004,
-0.2915939390659332,
0.048326581716537476,
-0.7468715310096741,
0.14760079979896545,
0.1319488286972046,
0.14020799100399017,
0.3151493966579437,
-0.536693274974823,
-0.5238553285598755,
-0.13792476058006287,
-0.45376044511795044,
-0.3224189281463623,
-0.08218690007925034,
0.30535733699798584,
0.30587252974510193,
0.7979972958564758,
-0.22614295780658722,
0.12177245318889618,
0.5553834438323975,
-0.08359799534082413,
0.6303115487098694,
-0.22161047160625458,
-0.14382889866828918,
-0.6639701724052429,
0.39239782094955444,
-0.1704040765762329,
-0.3470592200756073,
-0.664158046245575,
0.25234657526016235,
0.04904656484723091,
-0.1058250442147255,
-0.597954511642456,
0.6625563502311707,
-0.7773759961128235,
-0.26244446635246277,
-0.5543811321258545,
0.2818717956542969,
-0.1408659964799881,
0.013757864013314247,
-0.1108321025967598,
0.9012457132339478,
0.41187939047813416,
-0.6229243278503418,
0.4858708679676056,
-0.2717909514904022,
-0.3468247950077057,
0.3374564051628113,
-0.7531457543373108,
0.42234501242637634,
-0.1106942668557167,
-0.0289007518440485,
-0.8220492601394653,
-0.0955282673239708,
0.07615771889686584,
-0.1293231099843979,
-0.020101279020309448,
0.055437833070755005,
-0.8220472931861877,
-0.5584640502929688,
-0.4820629060268402,
-0.18721091747283936,
0.5354852080345154,
-0.21870532631874084,
0.3896397650241852,
0.6360211372375488,
-0.2691495418548584,
-0.4676424264907837,
-0.614159107208252,
0.11107954382896423,
-0.1953485906124115,
-0.5173343420028687,
-0.1485336422920227,
-0.23578152060508728,
-0.5660895109176636,
0.0013938389020040631,
-0.02585248462855816,
0.010782886296510696,
0.2241114377975464,
0.4468822479248047,
0.06209511682391167,
-0.17705202102661133,
0.5058720111846924,
-0.1131652370095253,
0.13816463947296143,
0.2097955346107483,
0.2605758607387543,
0.5442612171173096,
0.011136351153254509,
-0.7668860554695129,
0.16153983771800995,
0.37156304717063904,
0.17442570626735687,
-0.11371491849422455,
0.6648876070976257,
0.7459026575088501,
-0.08815498650074005,
-0.3113047182559967,
-0.669262170791626,
-0.23362402617931366,
-0.551069974899292,
0.35379260778427124,
-0.4286113679409027,
-0.5902855396270752,
0.19082292914390564,
-0.3603394329547882,
0.6195770502090454,
0.26880088448524475,
0.6869206428527832,
0.22373609244823456,
1.264957070350647,
0.8643298149108887,
-0.0763583704829216,
0.28716519474983215,
-0.09384045004844666,
0.40492770075798035,
-0.6456242799758911,
0.06407815217971802,
-0.5107325911521912,
-0.37943705916404724,
-0.3842187225818634,
-0.4152311086654663,
0.14675864577293396,
0.20116999745368958,
0.14012110233306885,
0.3905755281448364,
-0.5554516911506653,
0.2623799443244934,
0.7374288439750671,
-0.4449256956577301,
0.30794504284858704,
-0.37481632828712463,
-0.18467091023921967,
0.043440863490104675,
-0.9546948671340942,
-0.7591549158096313,
1.0874689817428589,
0.2885597348213196,
0.6129153370857239,
-0.13987156748771667,
0.47677159309387207,
-0.03452971205115318,
0.6260753870010376,
-0.8860953450202942,
0.7691610455513,
0.28323355317115784,
-0.7027699947357178,
-0.4247276484966278,
0.014692684635519981,
-0.8670783638954163,
0.25862178206443787,
-0.037352968007326126,
-0.62404465675354,
-0.2838091254234314,
0.05258607119321823,
-0.07709100097417831,
0.5524367690086365,
-0.8823695778846741,
0.7133444547653198,
-0.25337496399879456,
-0.2807546555995941,
0.06444033980369568,
-0.3416849672794342,
0.2839811444282532,
-0.1572839915752411,
0.5246827602386475,
-0.20633216202259064,
-0.10603530704975128,
0.6679782867431641,
-0.46458494663238525,
0.5390869379043579,
-0.18640202283859253,
-0.4801783859729767,
0.5188324451446533,
0.2877765893936157,
0.4914601445198059,
-0.291092187166214,
-0.06752754747867584,
-0.11332803964614868,
0.4035487473011017,
0.07404051721096039,
-0.4655962586402893,
0.8037323951721191,
-0.3619782626628876,
-0.533466100692749,
-0.344655841588974,
-0.6269357204437256,
-0.2711392641067505,
0.25326961278915405,
0.203245609998703,
0.5318710207939148,
-0.36243897676467896,
0.03780658543109894,
0.03968152403831482,
-0.2797315716743469,
0.849221408367157,
0.5091991424560547,
-0.5648966431617737,
0.4433653950691223,
0.9757391214370728,
0.33375826478004456,
0.21066081523895264,
0.044812578707933426,
0.0004876066814176738,
-0.22016462683677673,
-0.35193803906440735,
-0.3042626678943634,
0.0647691860795021,
-0.7500606775283813,
0.006436995230615139,
-0.5553691983222961,
-0.2060358226299286,
-0.29998165369033813,
-0.23718176782131195,
-0.36074408888816833,
-0.4417840540409088,
0.09279362112283707,
-0.06187984347343445,
0.21696366369724274,
1.0236501693725586,
0.045242808759212494,
0.42938703298568726,
-0.8069577217102051,
0.05210219696164131,
0.19428595900535583,
0.3544725775718689,
-0.15399062633514404,
0.11947435140609741,
-0.22037732601165771,
-0.06162816658616066,
-0.2904663383960724,
-0.9533437490463257,
0.36350640654563904,
-0.05186327546834946,
0.3800069987773895,
0.05206718668341637,
-0.16756224632263184,
0.4735775589942932,
-0.5458848476409912,
1.019822120666504,
0.033555615693330765,
-0.7117016911506653,
0.4258720576763153,
0.1255851536989212,
0.5669271945953369,
0.22723062336444855,
0.4079691171646118,
-0.9588790535926819,
-0.6802249550819397,
-0.6158934831619263,
-0.806830883026123,
0.6902451515197754,
0.13145554065704346,
0.11865060031414032,
0.25489678978919983,
-0.1292889565229416,
0.17064452171325684,
0.33051061630249023,
-0.6464516520500183,
-0.1828061193227768,
0.2717341184616089,
-0.14131984114646912,
-0.34261277318000793,
0.10602162778377533,
-0.23795300722122192,
0.042906563729047775,
0.5604961514472961,
-0.005479399114847183,
0.12371359020471573,
0.18282020092010498,
-0.3696374297142029,
-0.27290019392967224,
0.5771475434303284,
-0.04073518514633179,
0.7951735258102417,
0.10575766116380692,
0.07548042386770248,
0.2651815712451935,
-0.2431282252073288,
0.0772925466299057,
-0.16501682996749878,
0.09094806015491486,
0.23990648984909058,
0.21375121176242828,
0.4986693859100342,
0.11986604332923889,
-0.9945756793022156,
0.38799893856048584,
0.013387489132583141,
0.01954718306660652,
-0.19688205420970917,
0.31585144996643066,
0.4884567856788635,
0.00585621502250433,
0.09758105874061584,
-0.12561653554439545,
0.2566835284233093,
-0.5191383361816406,
-0.31089621782302856,
0.7675530910491943,
-0.5398762226104736,
-0.37599411606788635,
0.2692316174507141,
0.25827816128730774,
-0.6883556842803955,
0.10650952160358429,
-0.15381276607513428,
-0.08106396347284317,
0.4442055821418762,
0.33149850368499756,
0.864933431148529,
-0.12601295113563538,
0.1741870641708374,
0.16832171380519867,
0.5338389873504639,
-0.018064172938466072,
0.32107487320899963,
0.00598108721897006,
-0.5231189131736755,
-0.4293659031391144,
-0.5489527583122253,
-0.40023311972618103,
0.4461994171142578,
-0.15969206392765045,
0.38164153695106506,
-0.1102304682135582,
-0.36845746636390686,
0.08644083142280579,
-0.09690890461206436,
-0.9687859416007996,
0.10998009145259857,
-0.26343899965286255,
1.1368178129196167,
-0.6018028259277344,
0.7395882606506348,
1.1181429624557495,
-0.30690091848373413,
-0.7364283204078674,
-0.417944997549057,
0.22161398828029633,
-0.5549675822257996,
0.45509588718414307,
0.024149976670742035,
-0.4007052779197693,
0.02395465411245823,
-0.46329358220100403,
-0.5379241108894348,
0.6453431844711304,
0.16848358511924744,
-0.5694091320037842,
-0.32882940769195557,
0.2718881368637085,
0.38155171275138855,
-0.019288385286927223,
0.4095214903354645,
0.6533563137054443,
0.4984782934188843,
-0.4938763678073883,
-1.0567846298217773,
0.011779669672250748,
-0.38267621397972107,
0.1936875432729721,
0.35711297392845154,
0.09996750205755234,
0.518700122833252,
-0.0931011438369751,
-0.4898925721645355,
0.20442409813404083,
0.18937531113624573,
-0.0465473048388958,
0.09858062863349915,
0.48181387782096863,
0.09026727825403214,
0.25874948501586914,
-0.10464825481176376,
1.1283601522445679,
-0.4966295659542084,
-0.03826984763145447,
0.8342928886413574,
-0.0616387203335762,
0.6809782981872559,
0.6132040619850159,
-0.3754444718360901,
0.39818745851516724,
0.435001939535141,
0.10472994297742844,
0.02835456281900406,
0.3095785081386566,
-0.04296286031603813,
-0.23317508399486542,
-0.03144346922636032,
-0.34198707342147827,
0.19130916893482208,
0.272276908159256,
-0.2990913391113281,
-0.2515115439891815,
-0.045694541186094284,
-0.06683755666017532,
0.04642162099480629,
-0.17313827574253082,
0.9393919110298157,
0.22453677654266357,
-0.7971165776252747,
-0.008009807206690311,
0.3375270962715149,
0.6810623407363892,
-0.9328473806381226,
0.05611176788806915,
0.21158349514007568,
0.05158841982483864,
-0.032757632434368134,
-0.9468905925750732,
0.3494613468647003,
-0.10618831217288971,
0.2306664139032364,
-0.23587541282176971,
1.119738221168518,
-0.21357470750808716,
-0.6616308093070984,
-0.006824872922152281,
1.208431601524353,
0.12510833144187927,
-0.16873112320899963,
-0.6944366097450256,
0.027486342936754227,
-0.3756695091724396,
-0.1798233538866043,
0.33533376455307007,
0.3715274930000305,
0.20704694092273712,
0.8327105045318604,
0.7166682481765747,
0.4285867512226105,
0.12430749088525772,
0.005505305714905262,
0.5353792905807495,
-0.7547898888587952,
-0.2712661921977997,
-0.7973877787590027,
0.606015682220459,
-0.2549234926700592,
-0.468416303396225,
1.0709794759750366,
0.3728604316711426,
0.7428151369094849,
-0.10323800891637802,
0.8848342895507812,
-0.24230597913265228,
0.8387236595153809,
-0.20912575721740723,
0.5952309370040894,
-0.6131994128227234,
0.1565398871898651,
-0.5247528553009033,
-0.8927313089370728,
-0.02694258652627468,
0.3242299258708954,
-0.25611552596092224,
0.1262505054473877,
0.5509812831878662,
0.798944354057312,
-0.014524145983159542,
0.02752596139907837,
0.3368212878704071,
-0.08122450113296509,
0.23377399146556854,
-0.003912373445928097,
0.8514447212219238,
-0.17865990102291107,
0.39295467734336853,
-0.3385293185710907,
0.08509226143360138,
-0.09464066475629807,
-0.8873584866523743,
-0.8746246695518494,
-0.8582834005355835,
0.051169995218515396,
0.029263459146022797,
-0.028060756623744965,
0.8153508305549622,
0.6518498063087463,
-0.4956505298614502,
-0.663181722164154,
-0.18122343719005585,
0.30112648010253906,
-0.1025380939245224,
-0.16946586966514587,
0.13062654435634613,
-0.5219026803970337,
-0.7734870910644531,
0.41684862971305847,
0.20430250465869904,
-0.1564006209373474,
-0.8165290951728821,
0.15310585498809814,
0.02966148965060711,
0.08196553587913513,
0.6553475856781006,
0.2541640102863312,
-0.6644537448883057,
-0.14273683726787567,
0.14303554594516754,
-0.10858412832021713,
-0.3237934112548828,
1.2470247745513916,
-0.7377379536628723,
0.49106135964393616,
0.5048748850822449,
0.4295029938220978,
-0.012337872758507729,
-0.40112271904945374,
0.9279304146766663,
-0.945827305316925,
0.1685178577899933,
0.19853946566581726,
0.26990363001823425,
0.5343327522277832,
0.035866666585206985,
0.46538257598876953,
-0.17210757732391357,
-0.6097758412361145,
-1.0983632802963257,
0.32329607009887695,
-0.3420521020889282,
-0.6085742115974426,
1.0786609649658203,
0.2506026029586792,
0.021218668669462204,
-0.38472601771354675,
-0.6625149250030518,
0.28050488233566284,
-0.05728156864643097,
0.4239901900291443,
0.692091703414917,
0.04223811998963356,
-0.08880925178527832,
-0.7433394193649292,
0.8160750865936279,
0.12407246232032776,
-0.8692591786384583,
-0.10860266536474228,
0.367366760969162,
0.24446341395378113,
0.2789316177368164,
0.7884939312934875,
-0.07098879665136337,
0.19213314354419708,
-0.05739893391728401,
0.020703861489892006,
0.0679098591208458,
-0.0820029005408287,
-0.12250823527574539,
0.17616523802280426,
0.4846642017364502,
0.4866184890270233
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11958v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11958v1
|
Language Evolution with Deep Learning
| 2024-03-18T16:52:54 | 2024-03-18T16:52:54 |
Mathieu Rita, Paul Michel, Rahma Chaabouni, Olivier Pietquin, Emmanuel Dupoux, Florian Strub
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.MA
|
Computational modeling plays an essential role in the study of language
emergence. It aims to simulate the conditions and learning processes that could
trigger the emergence of a structured language within a simulated controlled
environment. Several methods have been used to investigate the origin of our
language, including agent-based systems, Bayesian agents, genetic algorithms,
and rule-based systems. This chapter explores another class of computational
models that have recently revolutionized the field of machine learning: deep
learning models. The chapter introduces the basic concepts of deep and
reinforcement learning methods and summarizes their helpfulness for simulating
language emergence. It also discusses the key findings, limitations, and recent
attempts to build realistic simulations. This chapter targets linguists and
cognitive scientists seeking an introduction to deep learning as a tool to
investigate language evolution.
|
[
-0.3982744812965393,
-1.3403632640838623,
0.5676408410072327,
0.054836519062519073,
0.10094061493873596,
0.5507634878158569,
-0.3641408383846283,
-0.4322580099105835,
-0.2632102370262146,
0.6502216458320618,
-0.6412691473960876,
-0.004062925465404987,
-0.41338562965393066,
-0.04960567131638527,
-0.2746242880821228,
0.759139895439148,
0.22983214259147644,
0.1363096982240677,
0.046399593353271484,
0.2238403856754303,
-0.23720857501029968,
-0.5736349821090698,
-1.0024921894073486,
-0.6120828986167908,
0.2747562825679779,
0.3409455120563507,
0.9429434537887573,
0.5297922492027283,
0.285979300737381,
0.38341253995895386,
-0.0799512192606926,
0.017667701467871666,
-0.31126296520233154,
0.3883313834667206,
0.07338408380746841,
-0.42056936025619507,
0.18283531069755554,
0.0757535919547081,
0.7298513650894165,
1.2066679000854492,
-0.21556183695793152,
-0.2733069062232971,
-0.2265690565109253,
0.5585442185401917,
-0.35154497623443604,
0.25653591752052307,
-0.46413788199424744,
0.25700247287750244,
-0.08832945674657822,
-0.2049967646598816,
-0.27662110328674316,
-0.46777576208114624,
0.4092976748943329,
-0.3668612539768219,
0.18413543701171875,
-0.20172645151615143,
0.5206858515739441,
-0.0034121028147637844,
-0.46538054943084717,
-0.45206698775291443,
-1.1777863502502441,
0.7534878849983215,
-0.7492831349372864,
0.5084531307220459,
0.11693637073040009,
0.5301166772842407,
-0.6297438740730286,
-0.7939624190330505,
-0.6365321278572083,
-0.7586230039596558,
0.2126619815826416,
-0.1352331042289734,
0.005751057527959347,
0.22580409049987793,
0.2784183919429779,
0.2767256200313568,
-0.48012760281562805,
0.4535662829875946,
-0.5643178224563599,
0.26604223251342773,
0.6648044586181641,
0.1822759360074997,
0.6068841218948364,
0.22185233235359192,
-0.016994403675198555,
-0.43095239996910095,
-0.572229266166687,
0.16254891455173492,
0.43338918685913086,
0.5674694180488586,
-0.012449795380234718,
0.31179115176200867,
0.03339887037873268,
0.5014597177505493,
-0.04688487574458122,
0.01741447113454342,
0.26018965244293213,
-0.02705039083957672,
-0.3085104823112488,
0.22413453459739685,
0.5818523168563843,
-0.22583572566509247,
0.6026046276092529,
0.06984704732894897,
-0.08552464842796326,
0.18847575783729553,
0.3058852553367615,
-0.6908442974090576,
-0.2975710332393646,
-0.0286719910800457,
-0.3035866916179657,
-0.6668645143508911,
-0.24415771663188934,
-0.5286217331886292,
-0.5639681220054626,
-0.4937955439090729,
-0.11318238079547882,
-0.41920772194862366,
-0.6462661623954773,
0.3391214609146118,
-0.18771399557590485,
0.5103697180747986,
0.3087451159954071,
-1.0486215353012085,
0.7671625018119812,
0.8037182688713074,
0.14446519315242767,
-0.06752163916826248,
-0.48838695883750916,
-0.09097526967525482,
-0.15129804611206055,
-0.8804137110710144,
0.5689641237258911,
-0.676700234413147,
-0.31346961855888367,
0.24486032128334045,
0.048373110592365265,
0.3087140619754791,
-0.5140748023986816,
0.23955024778842926,
-0.7226386070251465,
0.20844562351703644,
0.09030527621507645,
-0.600105345249176,
-0.48864471912384033,
-0.061352625489234924,
-0.6485726833343506,
0.8560633659362793,
0.18268468976020813,
-0.35451024770736694,
0.3656943142414093,
-0.8409331440925598,
-0.6460427045822144,
0.5277467370033264,
-0.3018941283226013,
-0.32828593254089355,
0.4083840847015381,
-0.08895504474639893,
0.5394122004508972,
-0.37808433175086975,
0.3487021327018738,
-0.41441094875335693,
-0.08010836690664291,
0.5080726146697998,
-0.3915385603904724,
1.0708186626434326,
0.5439187288284302,
-0.3711603581905365,
-0.12489675730466843,
-0.4783676564693451,
0.18958428502082825,
0.37080100178718567,
-0.15969383716583252,
-0.28456392884254456,
0.3403458595275879,
-0.1272834986448288,
0.12124184519052505,
-0.08271171152591705,
-0.2364145815372467,
0.43844059109687805,
-0.7243446111679077,
0.6274678707122803,
0.2808881103992462,
0.22705745697021484,
0.6127166152000427,
0.021473105996847153,
0.658993124961853,
0.0026582772843539715,
0.08960668742656708,
-0.12950332462787628,
-0.37159693241119385,
-0.615856945514679,
0.1696631908416748,
0.3867100477218628,
0.5500238537788391,
-0.47000986337661743,
0.05155884847044945,
-0.05666778236627579,
-0.5799283385276794,
-0.501153826713562,
0.08431604504585266,
0.2039443850517273,
-0.2329704910516739,
0.06796620786190033,
-0.1267775297164917,
-0.6239680051803589,
-0.7877777814865112,
-0.03178128972649574,
0.0901678279042244,
0.2652541697025299,
0.39990341663360596,
0.4050386846065521,
-0.5824721455574036,
0.6117696166038513,
-0.3232601284980774,
0.6739632487297058,
-0.544239342212677,
0.2680235505104065,
0.1357751339673996,
0.6209522485733032,
0.7306554317474365,
-0.6942495703697205,
-0.25754672288894653,
0.23730826377868652,
-0.6562364101409912,
0.1302710920572281,
-0.18298755586147308,
0.28652694821357727,
0.03641025722026825,
0.8266414403915405,
-0.3672025501728058,
0.21893326938152313,
0.5744228363037109,
-0.02749030478298664,
0.44060376286506653,
-0.22157257795333862,
-0.03962235152721405,
-1.05817449092865,
-0.1407294124364853,
-0.20309175550937653,
-0.11452557146549225,
-1.1105259656906128,
0.38809454441070557,
-0.31123027205467224,
-0.3502480685710907,
-0.5023214221000671,
0.48753631114959717,
-0.6173336505889893,
-0.07093647867441177,
-0.6476146578788757,
-0.04938267916440964,
-0.3409252166748047,
0.24516445398330688,
0.2634090483188629,
0.39195308089256287,
0.7420113682746887,
-0.8043950796127319,
0.3319210112094879,
-0.2788872718811035,
-0.3190517723560333,
-0.21352893114089966,
-0.4956374764442444,
0.14743845164775848,
-0.27456045150756836,
0.02341412752866745,
-0.7103368043899536,
-0.21290455758571625,
0.10422816872596741,
-0.544297456741333,
0.6033495664596558,
-0.15868711471557617,
-0.26293134689331055,
-0.375803142786026,
-0.027015462517738342,
0.4904921054840088,
0.6880353093147278,
-0.2751656472682953,
0.2747257649898529,
0.399394154548645,
-0.2636812627315521,
-0.45329564809799194,
-0.4701036512851715,
-0.06216609105467796,
-0.22065874934196472,
-0.2748054563999176,
0.187153160572052,
-0.1278679519891739,
-0.6381411552429199,
-0.213396355509758,
0.41829708218574524,
-0.2824065387248993,
0.639847993850708,
0.19998450577259064,
-0.19014950096607208,
-0.4650305211544037,
0.19660808145999908,
0.3120637834072113,
0.02055683359503746,
0.257282555103302,
-0.48490509390830994,
0.710034966468811,
-0.1194591075181961,
0.025348322466015816,
-0.29199957847595215,
0.3844749927520752,
0.5471593141555786,
-0.07907512784004211,
0.6479604244232178,
0.20862656831741333,
-0.4382036328315735,
-0.515557587146759,
-0.347626656293869,
-0.3487373888492584,
-0.491299569606781,
0.4797716736793518,
-0.42817050218582153,
-0.9217069745063782,
0.33075594902038574,
-0.5070385336875916,
-0.22106505930423737,
0.37164121866226196,
0.6396485567092896,
-0.0877436026930809,
1.0111315250396729,
1.0267560482025146,
0.04512763395905495,
0.6392927169799805,
-0.1858942061662674,
0.05135590210556984,
-0.41182437539100647,
-0.10264703631401062,
-0.654680609703064,
0.0429062582552433,
-0.9324649572372437,
-0.35454151034355164,
-0.1625698208808899,
0.5184746980667114,
-0.5059260129928589,
0.36500638723373413,
-0.22971759736537933,
0.5074330568313599,
0.5296319723129272,
-0.18965643644332886,
-0.17062728106975555,
0.16031214594841003,
-0.34318920969963074,
0.15543851256370544,
-0.6628758907318115,
-0.3607619106769562,
0.8823943734169006,
0.3899681270122528,
0.7337141036987305,
-0.139610156416893,
0.7049536108970642,
0.3221151828765869,
0.06753832846879959,
-0.490765780210495,
0.20701654255390167,
0.04441530629992485,
-0.5763813853263855,
-0.41482892632484436,
-0.25112780928611755,
-1.2968937158584595,
-0.013958904892206192,
-0.35427427291870117,
-0.4979020655155182,
0.32298895716667175,
0.036419399082660675,
-0.18297092616558075,
0.11696655303239822,
-0.4394843280315399,
0.7306479811668396,
-0.5162591934204102,
0.03969558700919151,
-0.36254504323005676,
-0.6182428002357483,
0.41848769783973694,
-0.11513330042362213,
0.4043593406677246,
-0.010588902048766613,
0.10500681400299072,
0.6307810544967651,
-0.19713866710662842,
0.8556869029998779,
-0.10848454385995865,
-0.12316546589136124,
0.5108401775360107,
0.3770441710948944,
0.34934359788894653,
0.055301375687122345,
0.08304956555366516,
-0.029937075451016426,
-0.06661387532949448,
-0.40863320231437683,
-0.6294562816619873,
0.45164018869400024,
-0.9335089921951294,
-0.4390788674354553,
-0.35260340571403503,
-0.44848111271858215,
-0.072487473487854,
0.20638330280780792,
-0.048764873296022415,
0.015900030732154846,
-0.3854573965072632,
0.21703866124153137,
0.7654642462730408,
-0.3880724310874939,
0.5411185026168823,
0.5294674634933472,
-0.5562111139297485,
-0.2948698103427887,
0.8272502422332764,
-0.06838534027338028,
0.2069317251443863,
0.33281663060188293,
0.6329899430274963,
-0.0014343566726893187,
-0.820164680480957,
-0.1150500699877739,
0.07553694397211075,
-0.4282357692718506,
0.16645538806915283,
-0.47566938400268555,
-0.5561472773551941,
-0.2813927233219147,
-0.3304029703140259,
-0.2990782558917999,
-0.30721279978752136,
-0.2043076455593109,
-0.2682931125164032,
0.21302920579910278,
1.0244747400283813,
-0.10272758454084396,
0.5112150311470032,
-0.48242029547691345,
-0.053049664944410324,
0.5053611397743225,
0.1074848547577858,
0.01927027851343155,
-0.18741056323051453,
-0.14290960133075714,
0.326083242893219,
-0.1444832682609558,
-0.9589217305183411,
0.48908159136772156,
0.18850542604923248,
0.8344478011131287,
0.5707743763923645,
-0.2869732081890106,
0.22249191999435425,
-0.559995710849762,
0.8360987305641174,
0.06531961262226105,
-0.7560796737670898,
0.6407255530357361,
-0.5619641542434692,
-0.02215793915092945,
0.2331964373588562,
0.6105156540870667,
-0.514531135559082,
-0.19627968966960907,
-0.6988568902015686,
-0.5613194704055786,
0.296877384185791,
0.06006185710430145,
0.40952616930007935,
-0.07459137588739395,
0.6378185749053955,
0.20964141190052032,
0.23835651576519012,
-0.7285248637199402,
-0.04631580784916878,
-0.1674765795469284,
-0.007070846855640411,
-0.4421318471431732,
-0.3299144506454468,
0.17375047504901886,
-0.4056245684623718,
0.35995739698410034,
-0.25860920548439026,
0.11576102674007416,
-0.28886470198631287,
-0.1823279708623886,
-0.12403181940317154,
0.19305385649204254,
0.9449579119682312,
0.4619428515434265,
0.1664089411497116,
-0.13836181163787842,
0.2061184197664261,
-0.2803664803504944,
0.18325050175189972,
-0.05683498829603195,
-0.08896391838788986,
-0.29694947600364685,
0.40356412529945374,
0.9670523405075073,
0.18875831365585327,
-0.70335853099823,
0.26607275009155273,
0.04472651705145836,
-0.3498588502407074,
-0.49240267276763916,
0.301155686378479,
0.18370234966278076,
0.5081920623779297,
0.23647873103618622,
-0.1648857444524765,
0.1750464290380478,
-0.8220665454864502,
0.15987727046012878,
0.5860783457756042,
-0.4393010139465332,
-0.273244708776474,
0.27113524079322815,
-0.05915350466966629,
-0.6680192947387695,
0.8450185060501099,
-0.10391933470964432,
-0.6062252521514893,
0.8181830644607544,
0.7021484375,
1.0311514139175415,
-0.4562322199344635,
0.1750262826681137,
0.02100946754217148,
0.340803861618042,
0.06706151366233826,
0.42758336663246155,
-0.13958679139614105,
-0.7632200717926025,
-0.4767806828022003,
-0.8243803381919861,
-0.47095727920532227,
0.2635946273803711,
-0.19708608090877533,
0.21269823610782623,
-0.5435681939125061,
-0.06858718395233154,
0.35943111777305603,
0.23519279062747955,
-0.6057548522949219,
0.3054240643978119,
0.7072221040725708,
0.9093122482299805,
-0.8830882906913757,
0.9162096381187439,
0.6333681344985962,
-0.22530360519886017,
-0.5790612697601318,
-0.31288740038871765,
-0.21334083378314972,
-0.7364981770515442,
0.9144829511642456,
-0.038342203944921494,
-0.23182670772075653,
0.03548664599657059,
-1.01382577419281,
-0.8939680457115173,
0.5243675708770752,
0.27099159359931946,
-0.41069576144218445,
0.1125892698764801,
0.20153190195560455,
0.8431652188301086,
-0.5898131132125854,
0.0786658227443695,
0.5149688720703125,
0.3138911724090576,
-0.2680588960647583,
-0.4001852869987488,
-0.13149932026863098,
-0.2060699760913849,
0.20376430451869965,
0.3042425811290741,
-0.13018366694450378,
1.1004207134246826,
-0.28694409132003784,
-0.16860201954841614,
0.0821584090590477,
0.6928167343139648,
-0.04139234870672226,
-0.07120027393102646,
0.10669552534818649,
0.3039996325969696,
0.6071536540985107,
0.018969200551509857,
0.9998754858970642,
-0.29864302277565,
0.17873349785804749,
0.987053394317627,
-0.2717931270599365,
0.6897833943367004,
0.1064215749502182,
-0.16831788420677185,
0.8318960666656494,
0.7113779783248901,
-0.2114550918340683,
0.3433765769004822,
0.7680997848510742,
-0.04191457852721214,
-0.19952993094921112,
0.22125430405139923,
-0.32340192794799805,
0.5624196529388428,
0.8279606103897095,
-0.5181071758270264,
-0.03159705176949501,
0.16882269084453583,
-0.054489124566316605,
0.05093681067228317,
-0.29726940393447876,
1.014057993888855,
-0.027689224109053612,
-0.6250888109207153,
0.36938440799713135,
-0.05969073250889778,
0.2143213152885437,
-0.44119635224342346,
-0.21328681707382202,
-0.07282503694295883,
0.20072224736213684,
0.11241398751735687,
-0.5694513320922852,
0.08742982894182205,
-0.49123769998550415,
-0.2132672369480133,
-0.08623391389846802,
0.6361889243125916,
-0.40752094984054565,
-0.5073943138122559,
0.3867936432361603,
0.4505423903465271,
0.24453826248645782,
0.2890597879886627,
-0.7658005356788635,
0.027711106464266777,
-0.36779719591140747,
-0.34106701612472534,
0.2842075824737549,
0.4483918845653534,
-0.2668711841106415,
0.767349362373352,
0.825481116771698,
-0.038059040904045105,
0.46627625823020935,
-0.06822804361581802,
0.6994765996932983,
-0.8960261344909668,
-0.30853235721588135,
-1.0524481534957886,
0.16224171221256256,
-0.061173032969236374,
-0.15669722855091095,
0.47568199038505554,
0.3693085312843323,
0.697035551071167,
-0.271791934967041,
0.8917672038078308,
0.14058661460876465,
0.24350754916667938,
-0.2644597887992859,
0.8007800579071045,
-0.3389219343662262,
-0.2634177505970001,
-0.4347955286502838,
-0.8109535574913025,
-0.3663623332977295,
0.43331629037857056,
-0.07878458499908447,
0.2038300484418869,
0.6974886655807495,
0.4828396737575531,
0.1496257483959198,
-0.01745685748755932,
0.2122405469417572,
0.31985723972320557,
0.2493063509464264,
0.3062175512313843,
1.1447619199752808,
-0.14221584796905518,
0.10007014870643616,
-0.30745384097099304,
-0.19042547047138214,
-0.2716013789176941,
-0.773431658744812,
-0.7874548435211182,
-0.5245770812034607,
-0.39234060049057007,
-0.18460676074028015,
0.2860572040081024,
0.9100175499916077,
0.9671675562858582,
-0.9431825876235962,
-0.6000953316688538,
-0.6373007893562317,
0.073039710521698,
-0.49795475602149963,
-0.2266966849565506,
0.052966151386499405,
-0.7988547086715698,
-0.6319835186004639,
0.6564570665359497,
0.09073758125305176,
0.5633148550987244,
-0.43831825256347656,
-0.27776387333869934,
-0.1743956357240677,
0.407981812953949,
0.6167008280754089,
0.8093366026878357,
-0.5923464894294739,
0.03414255008101463,
-0.15613608062267303,
-0.15591731667518616,
-0.1672973781824112,
0.9120537638664246,
-0.9855174422264099,
0.3073009252548218,
0.46516644954681396,
0.7513299584388733,
0.561324954032898,
-0.5564067959785461,
0.8999415040016174,
-0.4167264699935913,
0.14206115901470184,
0.42121222615242004,
0.012676267884671688,
0.21236547827720642,
-0.18513347208499908,
0.33890751004219055,
0.1985897421836853,
-0.5013042092323303,
-1.005248785018921,
0.506919801235199,
-0.7569557428359985,
-0.593991219997406,
0.7675690054893494,
0.24237562716007233,
-0.2720089852809906,
0.0019401769386604428,
-0.10681741684675217,
0.2956145703792572,
-0.11721465736627579,
0.5699880719184875,
0.43843626976013184,
-0.13954177498817444,
-0.5159493684768677,
-0.6568800806999207,
0.9265985488891602,
-0.10233649611473083,
-0.8277196288108826,
-0.06316850334405899,
0.13362672924995422,
0.2534883916378021,
0.17301742732524872,
0.05507649481296539,
0.19841031730175018,
0.3853969871997833,
0.09543100744485855,
0.08646401762962341,
0.11194486171007156,
-0.4788048565387726,
-0.5034763216972351,
0.31442326307296753,
0.3334011733531952,
0.1370859146118164
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15451v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15451v1
|
Towards Enabling FAIR Dataspaces Using Large Language Models
| 2024-03-18T16:46:00 | 2024-03-18T16:46:00 |
Benedikt T. Arnold, Johannes Theissen-Lipp, Diego Collarana, Christoph Lange, Sandra Geisler, Edward Curry, Stefan Decker
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Dataspaces have recently gained adoption across various sectors, including
traditionally less digitized domains such as culture. Leveraging Semantic Web
technologies helps to make dataspaces FAIR, but their complexity poses a
significant challenge to the adoption of dataspaces and increases their cost.
The advent of Large Language Models (LLMs) raises the question of how these
models can support the adoption of FAIR dataspaces. In this work, we
demonstrate the potential of LLMs in dataspaces with a concrete example. We
also derive a research agenda for exploring this emerging field.
|
[
-0.2901858687400818,
-0.6419784426689148,
0.9580167531967163,
0.34776929020881653,
0.13478143513202667,
-0.028591660782694817,
-0.5243178009986877,
-0.5374130606651306,
-0.14310461282730103,
0.630994975566864,
-0.6306341886520386,
-0.6130404472351074,
-0.6309925317764282,
0.13519638776779175,
-0.7953754663467407,
0.6408798098564148,
-0.0359683632850647,
0.012595842592418194,
-0.5166199803352356,
0.01162139791995287,
-0.6224080324172974,
-0.6691348552703857,
-0.40468913316726685,
-0.2582952678203583,
0.43368420004844666,
0.5432813763618469,
1.1395392417907715,
0.9648659229278564,
0.573521614074707,
0.34390032291412354,
-0.07580390572547913,
-0.10783340781927109,
-0.5298102498054504,
-0.07021676748991013,
-0.25035497546195984,
-0.8290190100669861,
-0.5137051343917847,
0.30051520466804504,
0.7603394985198975,
1.3055446147918701,
-0.5554052591323853,
-0.02426862344145775,
-0.001296933158300817,
0.6891939043998718,
-0.3846835196018219,
0.22578075528144836,
-0.8244760632514954,
0.19131827354431152,
-0.38018906116485596,
0.21181443333625793,
-0.5370956063270569,
-0.4254923462867737,
-0.07877163589000702,
-0.9164809584617615,
-0.12609317898750305,
0.33413732051849365,
0.49206918478012085,
-0.06331651657819748,
-0.47320854663848877,
-0.506263256072998,
-0.8220013976097107,
1.26114821434021,
-0.5227076411247253,
0.7069410681724548,
0.232749342918396,
0.6065921783447266,
-0.7389223575592041,
-1.0008606910705566,
-1.2386534214019775,
0.10415030270814896,
0.19459469616413116,
-0.29297730326652527,
-0.5402275919914246,
-0.30329182744026184,
0.36052456498146057,
0.38029980659484863,
-0.5364995002746582,
0.5090471506118774,
-0.26127728819847107,
0.0521358922123909,
0.45365068316459656,
0.6608004570007324,
0.27299273014068604,
-0.0036672991700470448,
-0.30807948112487793,
0.14510956406593323,
-0.811357855796814,
-0.17596086859703064,
0.3121257424354553,
0.6743437051773071,
-0.3253437280654907,
0.696716845035553,
-0.266573965549469,
0.8171732425689697,
-0.31147095561027527,
-0.11262445151805878,
0.4914008378982544,
-0.23164714872837067,
-0.22044457495212555,
-0.2989040017127991,
0.3753790557384491,
0.3881790041923523,
0.4879050850868225,
-0.27102768421173096,
-0.15200839936733246,
0.39102837443351746,
0.1527121514081955,
-0.7808284759521484,
0.31923601031303406,
0.4181940257549286,
-0.7941846251487732,
-0.1603512316942215,
-0.16890867054462433,
-0.720818281173706,
-0.7836325168609619,
-0.6273329854011536,
0.10515207797288895,
0.046936631202697754,
-0.3320520520210266,
0.7858436703681946,
-0.14337290823459625,
0.4774909019470215,
0.6431823372840881,
-0.6384032964706421,
0.7060242891311646,
1.049437403678894,
0.61849045753479,
-0.1748460978269577,
-0.1210658848285675,
-0.21499891579151154,
0.1828109622001648,
-0.36481359601020813,
0.342508465051651,
-0.6967437863349915,
-0.40161603689193726,
0.20903614163398743,
-0.0014458287041634321,
0.3299812972545624,
-0.7083044648170471,
0.48065611720085144,
-0.8523144721984863,
0.3004317879676819,
-0.2360549122095108,
-0.7992548942565918,
-0.09806952625513077,
0.304555743932724,
-0.7888965606689453,
0.4240076243877411,
0.20060104131698608,
-0.5904763340950012,
0.6986961960792542,
-0.739425003528595,
-0.23266983032226562,
0.1782291829586029,
-0.30259907245635986,
-0.10022064298391342,
-0.04271026700735092,
-0.06353362649679184,
0.6867614388465881,
-0.5233766436576843,
0.6406064629554749,
-0.6847357153892517,
-0.37360045313835144,
0.5694037675857544,
-0.5301840901374817,
0.8541383743286133,
0.6020265221595764,
-0.05673287436366081,
-0.31465795636177063,
-0.6370007991790771,
-0.0509200356900692,
0.32933443784713745,
-0.29821619391441345,
-0.2073630839586258,
0.2045709490776062,
0.22286714613437653,
0.4494040310382843,
0.22115737199783325,
-0.6065716743469238,
0.25221678614616394,
-0.26081764698028564,
0.20485277473926544,
0.709731936454773,
-0.733309805393219,
0.5175280570983887,
-0.43751072883605957,
0.4001932144165039,
0.19118806719779968,
0.30001190304756165,
0.345926970243454,
-0.34149405360221863,
-0.4993692934513092,
-0.5426427125930786,
0.33340567350387573,
0.31099894642829895,
-0.7882623672485352,
0.31654092669487,
-0.5033468008041382,
-0.32219013571739197,
-0.5762162208557129,
0.34838056564331055,
-0.1450503021478653,
0.24952004849910736,
0.05846615880727768,
-0.13027706742286682,
-0.3577311038970947,
-0.9446765184402466,
-0.03942810744047165,
0.15576916933059692,
-0.10767567902803421,
0.6853060722351074,
0.2902054786682129,
-0.46390584111213684,
1.2413456439971924,
-0.40529730916023254,
-0.24258941411972046,
-0.37856853008270264,
-0.2346373051404953,
0.6444125771522522,
0.2792431712150574,
0.6243513226509094,
-1.4024540185928345,
-0.296230286359787,
-0.18201978504657745,
-0.849690318107605,
-0.21949683129787445,
0.4223445951938629,
0.06817200034856796,
0.1953541338443756,
0.37436360120773315,
-0.656649112701416,
0.44731175899505615,
0.7536524534225464,
-0.6401364803314209,
0.22104546427726746,
-0.0393272265791893,
0.16422250866889954,
-0.9094599485397339,
0.14756733179092407,
-0.19132378697395325,
-0.6034566760063171,
-0.6166408658027649,
0.0369173064827919,
-0.056940168142318726,
-0.2019040584564209,
-0.6706696152687073,
0.7098529934883118,
-0.030840406194329262,
-0.2987980842590332,
-0.539781928062439,
0.42282503843307495,
0.16294850409030914,
-0.07321323454380035,
0.00525533314794302,
0.6417182683944702,
0.5224114656448364,
-0.6006947159767151,
0.27189716696739197,
0.29946568608283997,
-0.44463881850242615,
0.5561607480049133,
-0.5770183801651001,
-0.24970419704914093,
-0.3395407199859619,
0.7527496218681335,
-0.7372685074806213,
-0.2917344570159912,
-0.11394382268190384,
-0.19732053577899933,
-0.1248982772231102,
-0.012723371386528015,
-0.9719784259796143,
-0.3451204299926758,
-0.22376716136932373,
0.5481036305427551,
0.4918293058872223,
-0.8256369829177856,
0.5251721143722534,
0.7512345910072327,
-0.23927007615566254,
-0.5950832962989807,
-0.6516869068145752,
0.2877430319786072,
-0.48859935998916626,
-0.85833740234375,
0.2607260048389435,
-0.3211422860622406,
-0.6113126873970032,
-0.013924489729106426,
0.44339147210121155,
-0.12695004045963287,
0.4592476487159729,
0.2503458559513092,
0.28850430250167847,
0.0024889621417969465,
0.02939923107624054,
-0.34915122389793396,
-0.005511036142706871,
-0.08398542553186417,
-0.6003830432891846,
0.6935888528823853,
-0.2457544356584549,
-0.3367065489292145,
-0.3627760410308838,
0.4091023802757263,
0.5951865911483765,
0.13973934948444366,
0.9606186151504517,
0.3756135106086731,
-0.589438796043396,
-0.41663941740989685,
-0.5771937370300293,
0.24933552742004395,
-0.5593509674072266,
0.3067319691181183,
-0.12014889717102051,
-1.3755396604537964,
0.6230044960975647,
-0.2947511672973633,
0.12791447341442108,
0.15861046314239502,
0.6723191142082214,
-0.031227802857756615,
0.9880885481834412,
0.9892759919166565,
-0.02009221725165844,
0.3012215793132782,
-0.036928724497556686,
0.2538011968135834,
-0.39468449354171753,
-0.09152276068925858,
-0.7820578813552856,
-0.12219616770744324,
-0.8212608695030212,
-0.7754735350608826,
0.1324237585067749,
0.022443585097789764,
-0.32165539264678955,
-0.07651608437299728,
0.11916203051805496,
0.5239253044128418,
0.2642308473587036,
-0.06816978752613068,
0.5830510854721069,
0.03913220390677452,
0.19822454452514648,
-0.10998892784118652,
-0.695051908493042,
-0.7856253385543823,
0.9712567925453186,
0.6434476971626282,
1.0197890996932983,
0.40763163566589355,
0.3412044644355774,
0.5068526864051819,
0.295474112033844,
-0.710053563117981,
0.535813570022583,
-0.7898181676864624,
-0.596195638179779,
-0.2701062560081482,
-0.5896661281585693,
-1.1489049196243286,
-0.0056350077502429485,
-0.2504759132862091,
-0.8268205523490906,
0.40259167551994324,
-0.10054753720760345,
0.09992045164108276,
0.2033194750547409,
-0.45450282096862793,
0.601554811000824,
0.08349695801734924,
-0.4618394374847412,
-0.5254959464073181,
-0.28160351514816284,
0.09373850375413895,
-0.3063089847564697,
0.7704454064369202,
-0.19806620478630066,
0.0420590378344059,
0.7088199257850647,
-0.26667606830596924,
0.8660741448402405,
-0.38615456223487854,
-0.14104339480400085,
0.3458789587020874,
0.3418009579181671,
0.4148319661617279,
-0.039781779050827026,
-0.39570558071136475,
0.2946457862854004,
-0.2946009933948517,
-0.4847806692123413,
-0.6085109710693359,
0.687902569770813,
-0.630259096622467,
-0.655614972114563,
-0.06898846477270126,
-0.8270925283432007,
-0.4126949906349182,
0.15801237523555756,
-0.6041634678840637,
0.15045756101608276,
-0.07645414769649506,
0.52434241771698,
0.6917315125465393,
-0.5102394223213196,
0.40639781951904297,
0.9266734719276428,
-0.5948648452758789,
0.23917534947395325,
0.4874001741409302,
-0.029473649337887764,
0.26688724756240845,
-0.02971574105322361,
0.1725471019744873,
-0.42750468850135803,
-0.46344369649887085,
-0.1931169033050537,
-0.0660533532500267,
-0.7116336822509766,
-0.2646242678165436,
-0.7627384662628174,
0.04151748865842819,
-0.192049041390419,
-0.4029521644115448,
-0.2804580628871918,
-0.5866530537605286,
-0.02443845011293888,
-0.10247799754142761,
0.5112848877906799,
0.8991079926490784,
-0.21510912477970123,
0.389252632856369,
-0.6069539189338684,
0.2860313057899475,
0.15879695117473602,
0.8508117198944092,
0.1698177456855774,
-0.4207639694213867,
-0.00318741612136364,
0.03420237824320793,
0.05940898135304451,
-0.112924724817276,
0.1674056351184845,
-0.3010232150554657,
0.5637926459312439,
-0.06053755059838295,
-0.4013966917991638,
0.5083248019218445,
-0.677781343460083,
0.7910400032997131,
0.12182339280843735,
-1.0120201110839844,
0.18380798399448395,
-0.5335519313812256,
-0.07448718696832657,
0.31886395812034607,
0.46663936972618103,
-0.7872532606124878,
-0.3846844732761383,
-0.4390147626399994,
-0.8519085049629211,
0.5787872672080994,
-0.047866735607385635,
0.6148030757904053,
0.15719762444496155,
0.26079970598220825,
0.47138166427612305,
0.39369481801986694,
-1.0172463655471802,
0.04558037221431732,
0.16527853906154633,
-0.40084245800971985,
0.08240386098623276,
0.047293487936258316,
-0.008988702669739723,
0.10900665819644928,
0.4650076925754547,
-0.015101988799870014,
0.1009921282529831,
-0.21065644919872284,
0.00855456106364727,
0.06534358114004135,
0.4879251718521118,
-0.0009120407048612833,
0.6737927198410034,
0.142367884516716,
-0.1626819521188736,
-0.017794566228985786,
-0.2834313213825226,
0.0645623728632927,
0.0509064644575119,
-0.03917870298027992,
-0.34964096546173096,
0.08446650952100754,
0.5464292168617249,
-0.20217716693878174,
-0.8088400363922119,
0.954347550868988,
-0.4023905396461487,
-0.1810663640499115,
-0.24395804107189178,
0.18415090441703796,
0.18713968992233276,
0.4441773295402527,
0.2141798585653305,
-0.5527258515357971,
0.1920306384563446,
-0.505262553691864,
0.36799356341362,
0.5657784342765808,
-0.17540033161640167,
0.1877533495426178,
0.5964683890342712,
0.06337010115385056,
-0.023761926218867302,
0.8130165338516235,
-0.039965223520994186,
-0.29215922951698303,
0.5839309692382812,
0.7963070273399353,
0.4023386240005493,
0.28899314999580383,
0.036602552980184555,
-0.2894097864627838,
-0.013190156780183315,
-0.1832965463399887,
0.5355978012084961,
0.34415745735168457,
-1.0062263011932373,
-0.45376577973365784,
-0.9154776930809021,
-0.4117579460144043,
0.005160151515156031,
-0.2595312297344208,
0.3761219382286072,
-0.4376433193683624,
-0.1746932864189148,
0.07986527681350708,
0.05802176147699356,
-1.1511374711990356,
0.2931223213672638,
0.4575466215610504,
1.3005605936050415,
-0.7189002633094788,
0.6403775811195374,
0.3408975601196289,
0.03005942516028881,
-0.7779163122177124,
-0.23522406816482544,
0.04595918580889702,
-0.803727388381958,
0.824142336845398,
-0.06603951007127762,
0.0411079041659832,
-0.30015650391578674,
-0.7830050587654114,
-0.7510355114936829,
1.0764849185943604,
0.3616272211074829,
-0.6545045375823975,
0.2818794250488281,
0.5195997953414917,
0.6068097949028015,
-0.542119026184082,
-0.1661078929901123,
0.3197217583656311,
0.5843456387519836,
-0.09954067319631577,
-0.8844194412231445,
0.07177747786045074,
0.012156154960393906,
-0.06579163670539856,
-0.06092217564582825,
-0.6591582894325256,
0.9881780743598938,
0.04010511562228203,
-0.1054893210530281,
0.05155494436621666,
0.698004961013794,
0.3785805106163025,
0.2969475984573364,
0.8032909035682678,
0.3831896185874939,
0.9525651931762695,
0.005513285752385855,
1.035096287727356,
-0.07208073139190674,
0.2633512318134308,
0.8905362486839294,
-0.9942747354507446,
0.7663853764533997,
0.4059126675128937,
-0.3952246904373169,
0.5853567719459534,
0.0244439784437418,
-0.08335740864276886,
0.21831759810447693,
0.6443914771080017,
-0.2482372671365738,
-0.1090635359287262,
-0.7177526354789734,
-0.08758161962032318,
0.8606702089309692,
0.7404768466949463,
-0.1345839947462082,
-0.23025791347026825,
0.12430208921432495,
0.24716998636722565,
0.47196635603904724,
-0.5163359642028809,
0.6422868967056274,
0.16740062832832336,
-0.2256007194519043,
0.0006340437103062868,
0.3340566158294678,
0.6886178255081177,
-0.536903977394104,
-0.0885016918182373,
0.0039213052950799465,
0.07507142424583435,
-0.22161681950092316,
-1.2041971683502197,
0.22233615815639496,
0.3451922535896301,
-0.435594767332077,
-0.3237723410129547,
0.6676008701324463,
-0.23385591804981232,
-0.4674510657787323,
0.7519452571868896,
0.7943833470344543,
0.025012748315930367,
0.37790313363075256,
-0.4147898554801941,
0.30234476923942566,
-0.37831974029541016,
-0.19893686473369598,
0.3841446042060852,
0.5918735861778259,
-0.32131096720695496,
0.7888064384460449,
0.6923784017562866,
0.058025091886520386,
-0.14104101061820984,
0.24254721403121948,
0.8379475474357605,
-0.7586526870727539,
-0.6381255388259888,
-0.7594867944717407,
0.3287660777568817,
-0.042102400213479996,
0.2962051033973694,
0.5947169065475464,
0.44271862506866455,
0.7719327211380005,
0.25019019842147827,
0.8410975933074951,
-0.3230229616165161,
0.7128564715385437,
-0.5556970834732056,
0.7331362366676331,
-0.6433164477348328,
0.3556094467639923,
-0.3492853343486786,
-0.712119460105896,
-0.4040212333202362,
0.24404177069664001,
-0.27768924832344055,
0.12287730723619461,
0.12898319959640503,
0.8142950534820557,
-0.16163881123065948,
0.3729691803455353,
0.34686440229415894,
0.36926576495170593,
0.46595901250839233,
0.5611140727996826,
1.129030466079712,
-0.0437530092895031,
0.23317955434322357,
0.05403032898902893,
-0.3731001615524292,
0.13030824065208435,
-1.180528163909912,
-0.604426383972168,
-0.41655802726745605,
0.05995357781648636,
-0.5377029776573181,
0.046502646058797836,
1.0355838537216187,
0.6469234824180603,
-0.6046540141105652,
-0.4657613933086395,
0.2484031319618225,
0.31910908222198486,
0.38204213976860046,
-0.25109168887138367,
0.0933290496468544,
-0.07690185308456421,
-0.7979349493980408,
0.15624795854091644,
0.2507048547267914,
0.06662063300609589,
-0.2477765679359436,
0.02357117459177971,
0.1777971088886261,
0.1896529495716095,
0.6105837225914001,
-0.17393633723258972,
-0.29815739393234253,
-0.18587493896484375,
-0.2257540374994278,
-0.45360031723976135,
-0.08587091416120529,
0.8058324456214905,
-0.9943678975105286,
0.03447411209344864,
0.19685152173042297,
0.9075906276702881,
0.1381363570690155,
-0.21837136149406433,
0.6952350735664368,
-0.6736999154090881,
0.30008235573768616,
0.09742411226034164,
0.43272942304611206,
0.4978288412094116,
-0.40777963399887085,
0.4863871932029724,
-0.03591146692633629,
-0.4573074281215668,
-0.8425682187080383,
0.14136970043182373,
-0.8496569991111755,
-0.4537110924720764,
1.1628555059432983,
0.026926778256893158,
-0.1796143501996994,
-0.21539480984210968,
0.25778383016586304,
-0.05080097168684006,
-0.25937768816947937,
0.8352581858634949,
0.8115687370300293,
0.18300729990005493,
0.5605752468109131,
-0.8987592458724976,
0.29479172825813293,
0.28599312901496887,
-0.9628243446350098,
0.5231385827064514,
0.615714967250824,
0.1842576563358307,
-0.04518634080886841,
0.754057765007019,
-0.5991005897521973,
0.27943703532218933,
-0.25746479630470276,
-0.11468017846345901,
0.243149071931839,
-0.4112674593925476,
-0.4464019536972046,
0.008594186045229435,
0.3977545499801636,
0.38393110036849976
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11921v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11921v1
|
Adaptative Bilingual Aligning Using Multilingual Sentence Embedding
| 2024-03-18T16:19:41 | 2024-03-18T16:19:41 |
Olivier Kraif
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this paper, we present an adaptive bitextual alignment system called
AIlign. This aligner relies on sentence embeddings to extract reliable anchor
points that can guide the alignment path, even for texts whose parallelism is
fragmentary and not strictly monotonic. In an experiment on several datasets,
we show that AIlign achieves results equivalent to the state of the art, with
quasi-linear complexity. In addition, AIlign is able to handle texts whose
parallelism and monotonicity properties are only satisfied locally, unlike
recent systems such as Vecalign or Bertalign.
|
[
-0.06076453626155853,
-0.6370542645454407,
0.2876783013343811,
0.8153557777404785,
-0.19940131902694702,
0.03789737820625305,
-0.37152099609375,
-0.31647762656211853,
0.5982272028923035,
-0.042020101100206375,
-0.5242890119552612,
-0.4009200632572174,
-0.4837692379951477,
0.3215028941631317,
-0.15321145951747894,
0.7810302376747131,
-0.3795318007469177,
0.2727493643760681,
-0.41489213705062866,
-0.8203963041305542,
-0.8010743260383606,
0.05026987940073013,
-0.42840874195098877,
-0.13718967139720917,
0.2561008334159851,
0.8118695020675659,
1.0591301918029785,
1.0144569873809814,
0.3430382311344147,
0.2563908100128174,
0.22287118434906006,
0.2633119225502014,
-0.1466406136751175,
0.26893916726112366,
-0.3918350636959076,
-0.6397711634635925,
-0.3012167811393738,
-0.5704746842384338,
0.9881594777107239,
0.536770224571228,
-0.21289800107479095,
-0.09089677035808563,
0.10018812119960785,
0.4967837631702423,
-0.28702178597450256,
0.11563070863485336,
-0.5569019913673401,
0.09101483970880508,
-0.4091731607913971,
0.042094238102436066,
-0.23881620168685913,
-0.5007837414741516,
0.1075529083609581,
-0.8862020969390869,
-0.37054023146629333,
0.46546658873558044,
0.7574363946914673,
0.44035884737968445,
-0.5912227630615234,
-0.5034820437431335,
-0.5341618061065674,
0.7787625193595886,
-0.6885551810264587,
0.5779363512992859,
0.14622962474822998,
0.08048927038908005,
0.2013261318206787,
-0.42973947525024414,
-0.4480518400669098,
0.22124576568603516,
-0.23131632804870605,
0.4559757113456726,
-0.12750238180160522,
-0.23846442997455597,
-0.10310263186693192,
0.23396213352680206,
-0.9261810183525085,
0.5218526721000671,
-0.049723654985427856,
-0.3581700921058655,
0.49619030952453613,
0.28240734338760376,
0.8529831171035767,
-0.2627168893814087,
-0.8526887893676758,
-0.10674115270376205,
-0.6440590023994446,
0.32999539375305176,
0.2861892282962799,
0.25728639960289,
-0.3237189054489136,
0.463013231754303,
0.29792070388793945,
0.662064790725708,
0.025357376784086227,
-0.22311095893383026,
0.29292842745780945,
-0.5584656596183777,
0.07652400434017181,
0.5760491490364075,
1.0464508533477783,
0.41250312328338623,
0.4222109913825989,
-0.12258002161979675,
0.012348102405667305,
-0.16352708637714386,
-0.06102689355611801,
-0.38464248180389404,
0.04090284928679466,
0.11760925501585007,
-0.3517710864543915,
0.09613116085529327,
0.24421122670173645,
-0.8418139815330505,
-0.2270621508359909,
-0.13516275584697723,
0.23908045887947083,
-0.6347315907478333,
-0.11295581609010696,
0.031235510483384132,
0.1203252375125885,
0.3153190016746521,
0.10378626734018326,
-1.2135939598083496,
0.17315393686294556,
0.6482383012771606,
1.1745344400405884,
-0.2479926198720932,
-0.804282009601593,
-0.535107433795929,
0.30539581179618835,
-0.13806329667568207,
0.8137133717536926,
-0.4235335886478424,
-0.27266356348991394,
0.11078359186649323,
0.1725899577140808,
-0.49559250473976135,
-0.49261474609375,
0.7118449211120605,
-0.35950925946235657,
0.34759676456451416,
-0.22835056483745575,
-0.599038302898407,
0.002587770577520132,
0.49570780992507935,
-0.5511201620101929,
0.8350970149040222,
-0.067988820374012,
-0.9102121591567993,
0.1868143081665039,
-0.5038599967956543,
-0.8268815875053406,
-0.07641288638114929,
-0.007504340726882219,
-0.3994344472885132,
-0.1949205845594406,
0.8381142020225525,
-0.13582028448581696,
-0.004776217974722385,
0.3191123604774475,
-0.3619247078895569,
-0.1556069254875183,
-0.06181840971112251,
-0.4145202934741974,
1.0361876487731934,
0.17601029574871063,
-0.2568705976009369,
0.19196724891662598,
-0.5608949661254883,
-0.16856107115745544,
-0.09324102848768234,
-0.5282779335975647,
-0.5571367740631104,
0.20240791141986847,
0.09380138665437698,
-0.12321046739816666,
0.4157109260559082,
-0.5749799013137817,
0.5174909830093384,
-0.5816885232925415,
0.27639082074165344,
0.8291767835617065,
-0.17594732344150543,
0.6779634356498718,
-0.3637453317642212,
0.8828954696655273,
0.2025703638792038,
0.02562377043068409,
-0.5859897136688232,
-0.6243077516555786,
-0.9104253649711609,
-0.38364699482917786,
0.6048812866210938,
1.2599022388458252,
-0.9826281070709229,
0.3784681558609009,
-0.6131094694137573,
-0.16809362173080444,
-0.9017466902732849,
0.3938447833061218,
0.41133370995521545,
0.5498102307319641,
0.4279354512691498,
-0.1716143637895584,
-0.45363470911979675,
-0.9519951939582825,
-0.6322140693664551,
-0.23054902255535126,
0.37189775705337524,
0.04056525230407715,
0.0390012226998806,
0.01541115716099739,
0.7776208519935608,
-0.13906030356884003,
-0.4427278935909271,
0.40349268913269043,
0.24724936485290527,
0.11817210167646408,
0.5600025057792664,
0.7308225631713867,
-0.8115447163581848,
-1.0068233013153076,
0.3277748227119446,
-1.0245028734207153,
-0.15793782472610474,
-0.24640317261219025,
-0.1690988838672638,
0.07261835038661957,
0.9411064386367798,
-0.3152701258659363,
0.11280182749032974,
0.6833814382553101,
-0.5419225692749023,
0.13444902002811432,
-0.5020004510879517,
-0.0539422333240509,
-1.422541618347168,
-0.13088726997375488,
-0.07623247057199478,
-0.911592960357666,
-0.35307008028030396,
-0.04554344341158867,
0.47280311584472656,
0.004113905131816864,
-0.19940179586410522,
0.6101036071777344,
-0.6515706777572632,
-0.022951068356633186,
-0.08719338476657867,
0.22732816636562347,
0.006613142788410187,
0.0728939101099968,
-0.2090388685464859,
0.9103114008903503,
0.6276589035987854,
-0.17435652017593384,
0.47951459884643555,
0.6146278977394104,
-0.40747466683387756,
0.9724678993225098,
-0.4368283748626709,
-0.1633640080690384,
-0.40242984890937805,
0.17055805027484894,
-0.9502182006835938,
-0.2110441029071808,
0.24595411121845245,
-0.27096858620643616,
0.21796822547912598,
0.1336025446653366,
-0.43560656905174255,
-0.309551864862442,
-0.33628925681114197,
0.7487151026725769,
0.10267981886863708,
-0.7956427335739136,
0.4302150309085846,
0.23985569179058075,
-0.6967787146568298,
-0.7392600774765015,
-0.7904316782951355,
0.09180186688899994,
-0.3898704946041107,
-0.7544142603874207,
0.4730764627456665,
-0.1590784341096878,
-0.2728813588619232,
0.30121684074401855,
0.31986314058303833,
0.18084003031253815,
-0.07803070545196533,
-0.09032248705625534,
0.2756447494029999,
-0.7366033792495728,
0.46899130940437317,
0.5385130047798157,
-0.08192117512226105,
-0.3367425203323364,
-0.5335893630981445,
0.16882558166980743,
-0.25895631313323975,
-0.43399569392204285,
-0.3997396230697632,
0.5970439314842224,
0.7653104066848755,
-0.29961228370666504,
0.6684583425521851,
0.8147594332695007,
-0.4972454607486725,
0.12501651048660278,
-0.30906942486763,
0.3087485730648041,
-0.4068591892719269,
0.15165181457996368,
-0.29938238859176636,
-0.8837373852729797,
0.6321063041687012,
0.1709752380847931,
0.05258510634303093,
0.4430021643638611,
0.7798585891723633,
-0.05622376874089241,
1.0129963159561157,
0.6066118478775024,
-0.23741395771503448,
0.4112628400325775,
0.6146154403686523,
0.3596184551715851,
-0.5636376142501831,
-0.13645875453948975,
-0.24280913174152374,
-0.5221045613288879,
-0.7907813787460327,
-0.1289675235748291,
0.5662825703620911,
0.3342997133731842,
0.05798044055700302,
0.5376105308532715,
-0.19245368242263794,
0.4458789825439453,
0.6325682997703552,
-0.02308984287083149,
0.3434249460697174,
-0.15571798384189606,
-0.5667673349380493,
-0.346990168094635,
-0.6820926666259766,
-0.2522546350955963,
0.8229056000709534,
0.22214511036872864,
0.7847236394882202,
0.5511645078659058,
0.613479495048523,
0.17737743258476257,
0.3665681481361389,
-0.8138694763183594,
-0.0006793311913497746,
-0.4025745391845703,
-0.4667814075946808,
-0.20441153645515442,
-0.0862639769911766,
-0.8596798777580261,
0.2638763189315796,
-0.31742557883262634,
-1.0237728357315063,
0.5573657155036926,
0.2570134699344635,
-0.44500550627708435,
0.12253782898187637,
-0.9455077052116394,
0.9567743539810181,
-0.32627806067466736,
-0.32776907086372375,
0.047688014805316925,
-0.49502938985824585,
0.15016262233257294,
-0.09771282970905304,
0.48377910256385803,
-0.09940772503614426,
-0.24583211541175842,
0.6763119101524353,
-0.42474573850631714,
0.5339068174362183,
-0.16595876216888428,
-0.005132399033755064,
0.10850480943918228,
0.0378909707069397,
0.5117392539978027,
0.2860110104084015,
-0.20465761423110962,
-0.2670029103755951,
0.14868779480457306,
-0.46857282519340515,
-0.5268108248710632,
1.226293921470642,
-0.6027126312255859,
-0.6043173670768738,
-0.36781489849090576,
-1.131600022315979,
-0.4252544045448303,
0.44959455728530884,
0.20070509612560272,
0.2882145047187805,
-0.14197218418121338,
0.07290377467870712,
0.19720304012298584,
-0.18197788298130035,
0.8578542470932007,
0.30778932571411133,
-0.34995922446250916,
-0.8210850358009338,
1.125268816947937,
0.1092095673084259,
-0.10865738987922668,
0.455329030752182,
0.210543692111969,
-0.5114957690238953,
-0.2322930544614792,
-0.8670070171356201,
0.3909483253955841,
-0.8053428530693054,
-0.3478258550167084,
-0.5036513805389404,
0.15484294295310974,
-0.7134221196174622,
-0.3009198307991028,
-0.2952144742012024,
-0.5648983120918274,
-0.36193525791168213,
-0.007114863488823175,
0.12381647527217865,
0.6982999444007874,
-0.28766655921936035,
0.26242396235466003,
-1.0181684494018555,
0.1328125,
0.2046993374824524,
0.19713646173477173,
-0.36534518003463745,
-0.3618076741695404,
-0.26924237608909607,
-0.12102022022008896,
-0.3609318137168884,
-0.8235944509506226,
0.2810724079608917,
0.47514888644218445,
0.5934018492698669,
0.4437403678894043,
-0.07001651078462601,
0.9278882741928101,
-0.6593251824378967,
0.5954840779304504,
0.32384106516838074,
-1.0755109786987305,
0.3361470401287079,
-0.3768780827522278,
0.7890363335609436,
0.5958126783370972,
0.7411179542541504,
-0.5431140065193176,
-0.2058209627866745,
-0.13668444752693176,
-0.7389071583747864,
0.5847756266593933,
-0.1288360357284546,
0.1712915152311325,
0.07299167662858963,
0.25748229026794434,
0.126420259475708,
-0.18654486536979675,
-1.0105081796646118,
-0.14918413758277893,
-0.28070715069770813,
-0.999140739440918,
-0.10081487149000168,
-0.15924018621444702,
-0.09673704952001572,
-0.38570624589920044,
0.5819801092147827,
-0.4117060899734497,
0.026555344462394714,
0.25873324275016785,
-0.5357359647750854,
-0.06413176655769348,
0.20260001718997955,
0.662420392036438,
0.7164698243141174,
0.23503445088863373,
0.09015624225139618,
0.11398787051439285,
-0.1454373598098755,
0.22346048057079315,
0.5222361087799072,
-0.2634156346321106,
-0.09591411799192429,
0.653226912021637,
0.9250292181968689,
0.25721272826194763,
-0.6034542918205261,
0.689767599105835,
-0.017889482900500298,
-0.11851552873849869,
-0.1103978306055069,
-0.3761255145072937,
0.38516297936439514,
0.6619753837585449,
-0.06380265206098557,
0.082917720079422,
-0.10512194782495499,
-0.43381717801094055,
0.1018482968211174,
0.379091739654541,
-0.7779977917671204,
-0.3609500825405121,
0.9021071791648865,
0.035290420055389404,
-0.506190836429596,
0.7435231804847717,
-0.07465960830450058,
-0.5836823582649231,
0.30265411734580994,
0.9925589561462402,
0.6212412118911743,
-0.5977628827095032,
0.18407601118087769,
0.4244622588157654,
0.31676581501960754,
0.03463200479745865,
0.26287907361984253,
-0.04759737849235535,
-0.8617156147956848,
-0.28684571385383606,
-0.5999776124954224,
-0.31712090969085693,
-0.493463397026062,
-0.7928439974784851,
0.378604531288147,
-0.2509687840938568,
0.15527763962745667,
0.1134033352136612,
-0.8325647711753845,
-0.3791874945163727,
-0.1135362908244133,
0.2545303404331207,
0.7538869380950928,
-1.0342937707901,
0.9635863304138184,
1.1517835855484009,
-0.07453178614377975,
-0.3814646899700165,
0.24699540436267853,
0.24670755863189697,
-1.1681593656539917,
0.20645979046821594,
0.16791240870952606,
0.15868818759918213,
0.1299874186515808,
0.02228122018277645,
-0.8879557251930237,
1.1892776489257812,
0.6222313046455383,
-0.5837423205375671,
-0.3135480582714081,
0.34846535325050354,
0.44934603571891785,
-0.4131559729576111,
0.01002788357436657,
0.4547521770000458,
0.6258275508880615,
-0.39877668023109436,
-1.2091878652572632,
-0.009352262131869793,
-0.37462949752807617,
0.06526362895965576,
0.0745052769780159,
-0.730972170829773,
0.7650161385536194,
0.05717472359538078,
-0.282588392496109,
0.1794155389070511,
0.6693211197853088,
-0.15364375710487366,
0.02208479307591915,
0.6881963014602661,
0.7827710509300232,
0.7845633625984192,
-0.1295982301235199,
0.7917092442512512,
-0.45431819558143616,
0.3574412763118744,
1.2218961715698242,
-0.032562002539634705,
0.903509259223938,
0.7499291300773621,
0.049044862389564514,
0.8430569171905518,
0.4306829869747162,
0.3074689507484436,
0.4106079936027527,
-0.2560739517211914,
-0.2589423656463623,
-0.2286628931760788,
-0.3131260573863983,
0.03467177227139473,
0.6006728410720825,
0.46182987093925476,
-0.23755869269371033,
-0.3416387140750885,
0.610919713973999,
0.2094302624464035,
0.42082738876342773,
-0.10302916169166565,
0.7895239591598511,
0.13650357723236084,
-1.1521434783935547,
0.43772268295288086,
0.05230049043893814,
0.6694884896278381,
-0.4824018180370331,
0.1477476805448532,
-0.3086753189563751,
0.5491862893104553,
-0.10862093418836594,
-0.8454256057739258,
0.4036604166030884,
-0.3070261478424072,
-0.1345084011554718,
-0.5046119093894958,
0.5971201062202454,
-0.8894101977348328,
-0.5353865027427673,
0.445779949426651,
0.4063206911087036,
-0.4116677939891815,
0.4375739097595215,
-0.788627564907074,
-0.01694764383137226,
0.1577271819114685,
-0.037731826305389404,
-0.017903292551636696,
0.277284175157547,
-0.2518916428089142,
0.45470336079597473,
0.12012848258018494,
-0.056019239127635956,
0.33406081795692444,
-0.07945302873849869,
0.5300671458244324,
-0.5636688470840454,
-0.7667306065559387,
-0.9764759540557861,
0.5795885324478149,
0.07611369341611862,
-0.3481624722480774,
0.9074875712394714,
0.4760703444480896,
0.8967204093933105,
0.1295735239982605,
0.5126055479049683,
0.13431407511234283,
0.479446142911911,
-0.7486772537231445,
0.37538856267929077,
-0.8229354619979858,
0.04097636789083481,
0.03708017244935036,
-0.9911742210388184,
-0.6040233969688416,
0.3433783948421478,
-0.12144909054040909,
-0.5071101784706116,
0.9523441791534424,
0.7072606086730957,
-0.5741615295410156,
0.08486179262399673,
0.019810864701867104,
0.16858549416065216,
0.21844391524791718,
0.4355320334434509,
0.6052113771438599,
-0.4632827341556549,
0.6127049326896667,
-0.22906629741191864,
-0.2480289489030838,
0.01615257002413273,
-0.8634361028671265,
-0.4820246696472168,
-0.6157361268997192,
-0.23818713426589966,
-0.19097453355789185,
-0.020404819399118423,
0.8167346119880676,
0.37476491928100586,
-0.9822311401367188,
-0.3250284790992737,
-0.02535119839012623,
0.12306085228919983,
-0.0750228613615036,
-0.2966442108154297,
0.4225527048110962,
-0.5447423458099365,
-0.9766881465911865,
0.5031356811523438,
0.5801545977592468,
0.047143593430519104,
-0.08929208666086197,
-0.12087422609329224,
-0.5663731694221497,
-0.09620316326618195,
0.30310457944869995,
0.535757303237915,
-0.7461445331573486,
-0.49021556973457336,
0.12779709696769714,
-0.01616448350250721,
0.3740198314189911,
0.7890155911445618,
-0.3236481249332428,
1.0785648822784424,
0.464264839887619,
0.8020569682121277,
0.3811591863632202,
0.102971650660038,
0.7904651165008545,
-0.7834556698799133,
0.510365903377533,
-0.06153097003698349,
0.7317392230033875,
0.5510053634643555,
-0.23648488521575928,
0.023227311670780182,
0.2127685397863388,
-0.49870917201042175,
-0.4961335361003876,
0.04761430621147156,
-0.8019923567771912,
0.07259310036897659,
0.8851220011711121,
-0.6267673969268799,
-0.24663886427879333,
0.036029744893312454,
-0.13754026591777802,
0.16562926769256592,
0.1335802674293518,
0.2979275584220886,
1.0483747720718384,
-0.06735032051801682,
-0.2720361649990082,
-0.11021864414215088,
0.1273912638425827,
0.7936719059944153,
-0.9470822811126709,
-0.29361188411712646,
0.21328945457935333,
0.23886190354824066,
0.3111881613731384,
0.6636238098144531,
-0.16608479619026184,
0.2941419780254364,
-0.10786864906549454,
-0.36146917939186096,
0.321759432554245,
-0.2693297863006592,
-0.5589238405227661,
-0.2533319294452667,
0.31519198417663574,
-0.07199016213417053
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11905v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11905v2
|
Tur[k]ingBench: A Challenge Benchmark for Web Agents
| 2024-03-18T16:06:30 | 2024-03-21T21:57:13 |
Kevin Xu, Yeganeh Kordi, Kate Sanders, Yizhong Wang, Adam Byerly, Jack Zhang, Benjamin Van Durme, Daniel Khashabi
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.HC
|
Recent chatbots have demonstrated impressive ability to understand and
communicate in raw-text form. However, there is more to the world than raw
text. For example, humans spend long hours of their time on web pages, where
text is intertwined with other modalities and tasks are accomplished in the
form of various complex interactions. Can state-of-the-art multi-modal models
generalize to such complex domains?
To address this question, we introduce TurkingBench, a benchmark of tasks
formulated as web pages containing textual instructions with multi-modal
context. Unlike existing work which employs artificially synthesized web pages,
here we use natural HTML pages that were originally designed for crowdsourcing
workers for various annotation purposes. The HTML instructions of each task are
also instantiated with various values (obtained from the crowdsourcing tasks)
to form new instances of the task. This benchmark contains 32.2K instances
distributed across 158 tasks.
Additionally, to facilitate the evaluation on TurkingBench, we develop an
evaluation framework that connects the responses of chatbots to modifications
on web pages (modifying a text box, checking a radio, etc.). We evaluate the
performance of state-of-the-art models, including language-only, vision-only,
and layout-only models, and their combinations, on this benchmark. Our findings
reveal that these models perform significantly better than random chance, yet
considerable room exists for improvement. We hope this benchmark will help
facilitate the evaluation and development of web-based agents.
|
[
-0.43631139397621155,
-0.788589596748352,
0.2047196626663208,
0.2072111964225769,
-0.12517987191677094,
0.1237839087843895,
-0.364590048789978,
-0.6730371713638306,
-0.2633109986782074,
0.14927659928798676,
-0.5894608497619629,
-0.27752408385276794,
-0.33643314242362976,
0.1909109652042389,
-0.3112601041793823,
0.7219114899635315,
0.1840200275182724,
0.019259251654148102,
-0.6850395202636719,
-0.06241411715745926,
-0.2374703735113144,
-0.5203363299369812,
-0.41777366399765015,
-0.106604665517807,
0.47836530208587646,
0.29488131403923035,
0.7569093108177185,
0.5142844319343567,
0.7193148136138916,
0.4702329635620117,
0.18502603471279144,
0.32223543524742126,
-0.4137723445892334,
0.4925057291984558,
-0.27789628505706787,
-0.4478045105934143,
-0.31946325302124023,
0.2726331353187561,
0.40639591217041016,
0.72989821434021,
-0.0565878227353096,
0.2647468149662018,
0.10896918922662735,
0.49196022748947144,
-0.811228334903717,
0.3622349798679352,
-0.5787326693534851,
-0.1265626847743988,
-0.1306854486465454,
0.11992622166872025,
-0.44547605514526367,
-0.20699022710323334,
0.2210593819618225,
-0.7193264365196228,
0.3310411274433136,
0.07244858145713806,
0.882548451423645,
0.3243847191333771,
-0.49346044659614563,
-0.006032972596585751,
-0.7093460559844971,
0.7275485396385193,
-0.5354255437850952,
0.710679829120636,
0.5094916224479675,
0.6336290240287781,
-0.42873749136924744,
-0.685476541519165,
-0.7699950337409973,
-0.6671432256698608,
0.09621398150920868,
0.14407549798488617,
-0.38148441910743713,
0.06475115567445755,
0.18521273136138916,
0.13672885298728943,
-0.5063156485557556,
-0.16939663887023926,
-0.22853657603263855,
-0.3317278027534485,
0.4825790822505951,
0.17055274546146393,
0.233071431517601,
-0.18646502494812012,
-0.2506411373615265,
-0.6296656727790833,
0.040733452886343,
0.13589131832122803,
0.2458975464105606,
0.38314810395240784,
-0.2869863212108612,
0.6367174386978149,
-0.4413295388221741,
0.7024194002151489,
0.031200435012578964,
-0.042501300573349,
0.21261096000671387,
-0.16002507507801056,
-0.1334957331418991,
-0.5302837491035461,
0.7420473694801331,
0.5352671146392822,
0.030532557517290115,
-0.3652897775173187,
-0.03257393091917038,
0.20702779293060303,
0.5626384615898132,
-0.6044681072235107,
-0.15188206732273102,
0.2548312246799469,
-0.5826236009597778,
-0.20520231127738953,
0.08089933544397354,
-0.6791462898254395,
-0.7027586102485657,
-0.17861275374889374,
0.4590689539909363,
-0.423146516084671,
-0.26773136854171753,
-0.15528197586536407,
-0.37248510122299194,
0.26228415966033936,
0.5885008573532104,
-0.2802943289279938,
0.3786829113960266,
0.7843076586723328,
0.7720538973808289,
-0.24380165338516235,
-0.37472257018089294,
-0.5882682204246521,
-0.0664089024066925,
-0.30429625511169434,
0.9763376116752625,
-0.7743929624557495,
-0.28053775429725647,
0.08258663862943649,
-0.044538646936416626,
-0.12207251042127609,
-0.34320107102394104,
0.5401632785797119,
-0.474869966506958,
0.3450130522251129,
-0.02214726246893406,
-0.6073333024978638,
-0.3584074378013611,
0.6114258766174316,
-1.0246098041534424,
0.9952908158302307,
0.13347063958644867,
-0.489467978477478,
0.23113995790481567,
-0.820114254951477,
-0.4108427166938782,
-0.06514327228069305,
0.07095039635896683,
-0.25944072008132935,
0.09224661439657211,
-0.22040528059005737,
0.43723225593566895,
-0.6800807118415833,
-0.24316053092479706,
-0.4827493131160736,
-0.11000851541757584,
0.68855220079422,
-0.4940759837627411,
0.4091756343841553,
0.19262494146823883,
-0.48659181594848633,
0.28796494007110596,
-0.9347976446151733,
0.2286940962076187,
-0.03627292066812515,
-0.4718683362007141,
-0.10478853434324265,
0.19454210996627808,
0.4650505483150482,
0.2968566119670868,
0.16426579654216766,
-0.5260764360427856,
0.018455222249031067,
-0.0598485954105854,
0.12159084528684616,
0.64388507604599,
-0.21850290894508362,
0.2522493898868561,
-0.6519434452056885,
0.49550312757492065,
-0.3266507685184479,
0.29075247049331665,
-0.06335073709487915,
-0.33447983860969543,
-0.9089316725730896,
-0.24854595959186554,
0.28534838557243347,
0.4033944308757782,
-0.6209438443183899,
0.15456561744213104,
-0.33164316415786743,
-0.9525542259216309,
-0.361546128988266,
-0.10732918977737427,
0.6268298625946045,
0.15604692697525024,
0.2382178157567978,
-0.4809756875038147,
-0.28000929951667786,
-0.9320040941238403,
-0.42077577114105225,
-0.19207319617271423,
-0.2370055913925171,
0.31877192854881287,
0.283348947763443,
-0.11457249522209167,
0.8198660612106323,
0.1808759570121765,
-0.07544361054897308,
-0.0664767399430275,
0.39997655153274536,
-0.20856446027755737,
0.5924907326698303,
0.26228463649749756,
-0.9356652498245239,
-0.6937667727470398,
0.23434527218341827,
-0.630420446395874,
-0.0473940335214138,
-0.1967318207025528,
-0.1529504805803299,
0.3962884545326233,
0.3295811414718628,
-0.7102023959159851,
0.44550901651382446,
0.5865909457206726,
-0.25908520817756653,
0.5381808876991272,
-0.12146458029747009,
0.40626290440559387,
-0.7861825823783875,
0.24607503414154053,
0.11248300224542618,
-0.5451889634132385,
-0.6738730072975159,
0.28553125262260437,
0.15502005815505981,
-0.21554145216941833,
-0.3816709518432617,
0.5459609627723694,
-0.5140135884284973,
0.007693812251091003,
-0.3905722498893738,
0.1467307060956955,
0.030548186972737312,
0.7288346290588379,
-0.3035030663013458,
0.7347102165222168,
0.18587063252925873,
-0.6381750106811523,
0.5942710638046265,
0.06462736427783966,
-0.2682625949382782,
0.8029727935791016,
-0.6327763795852661,
0.5131655335426331,
0.04341190680861473,
0.31251710653305054,
-0.9348316192626953,
-0.30065497756004333,
0.22905904054641724,
-0.5783950686454773,
-0.06483758240938187,
-0.06754175573587418,
-0.7670286893844604,
-0.26391366124153137,
-0.30945369601249695,
0.19156017899513245,
0.2240307331085205,
-0.14694415032863617,
0.9166996479034424,
0.3920842111110687,
0.02388656511902809,
-0.25303834676742554,
-0.19188863039016724,
0.2746037244796753,
0.010548457503318787,
-0.646450936794281,
0.43177080154418945,
-0.10406266897916794,
-0.37871021032333374,
-0.009533613920211792,
-0.13132761418819427,
-0.39675581455230713,
0.1855081468820572,
0.410194456577301,
0.027916934341192245,
-0.02024918608367443,
0.17329181730747223,
-0.36244067549705505,
-0.15965336561203003,
-0.08116170763969421,
-0.03664261847734451,
0.66746586561203,
-0.24740195274353027,
-0.6844061017036438,
-0.9369815587997437,
0.4217892587184906,
0.7288464903831482,
-0.48166215419769287,
0.62043696641922,
0.6022857427597046,
-0.3988134264945984,
0.09091734886169434,
-0.94390869140625,
-0.04118289425969124,
-0.4904416799545288,
0.3535180389881134,
-0.5020067095756531,
-0.6109703779220581,
0.5387143492698669,
-0.22718271613121033,
0.25608739256858826,
0.4435860812664032,
0.5476629734039307,
-0.21090951561927795,
1.104772686958313,
0.8504598140716553,
0.01063485350459814,
0.5919663310050964,
0.09714821726083755,
-0.29766350984573364,
-0.30826884508132935,
-0.30081799626350403,
-0.7396690845489502,
-0.34801656007766724,
-0.5893104672431946,
-0.7836290001869202,
0.49625107645988464,
-0.02297084778547287,
-0.09923902899026871,
0.2511916756629944,
-0.4214402437210083,
0.3030005395412445,
0.9517078399658203,
0.13015441596508026,
0.16429756581783295,
-0.14667662978172302,
0.08882720023393631,
0.22475041449069977,
-0.4233137369155884,
-0.6208081245422363,
1.1071460247039795,
-0.096844881772995,
0.4570808410644531,
0.1972530633211136,
0.0876535177230835,
0.698257565498352,
0.24990980327129364,
-0.4068145155906677,
0.5210037231445312,
0.23714587092399597,
-0.7638249397277832,
-0.41844597458839417,
-0.2460131049156189,
-1.2139711380004883,
0.543212890625,
-0.47018128633499146,
-0.7561217546463013,
-0.14694488048553467,
0.017455149441957474,
-0.003826639847829938,
0.17234179377555847,
-0.6547939777374268,
1.1595515012741089,
-0.12947151064872742,
-0.6267454624176025,
-0.7678994536399841,
-0.6612752676010132,
-0.18397745490074158,
0.26363375782966614,
0.2580639123916626,
-0.3351532220840454,
0.0052606044337153435,
0.4607726037502289,
-0.48596134781837463,
0.9657459855079651,
-0.17974631488323212,
0.18757034838199615,
0.2694237530231476,
0.3109588325023651,
0.5972751975059509,
-0.319852739572525,
-0.15296417474746704,
-0.050303906202316284,
0.23940959572792053,
-0.6404607892036438,
-0.5257862210273743,
0.21315638720989227,
-0.7619097828865051,
-0.3835586905479431,
-0.3495301306247711,
-0.43505868315696716,
-0.4330745339393616,
0.14746001362800598,
-0.16059844195842743,
0.5322799682617188,
-0.5815109014511108,
0.40956544876098633,
0.15666835010051727,
-0.15705576539039612,
0.3795090317726135,
0.5970237851142883,
0.030308764427900314,
-0.17454786598682404,
0.7638170719146729,
-0.42420852184295654,
0.2342492938041687,
0.5392436981201172,
0.10662947595119476,
-0.21923916041851044,
-0.2466806322336197,
-0.6709052920341492,
-0.17895494401454926,
-0.6403019428253174,
-0.19558748602867126,
-0.5938864350318909,
0.09352849423885345,
-0.24283482134342194,
0.06882850080728531,
-0.5034922361373901,
-0.45837947726249695,
0.07778913527727127,
0.23433710634708405,
0.3146222233772278,
0.5712079405784607,
-0.21404218673706055,
0.20654810965061188,
-0.9879078269004822,
0.4289516806602478,
0.47515869140625,
0.4774264991283417,
0.17480966448783875,
-0.021793633699417114,
-0.2974463105201721,
0.2413417249917984,
-0.4381504952907562,
-0.8994472622871399,
-0.019695008173584938,
0.16596956551074982,
0.8201133608818054,
0.3246738016605377,
0.1302938312292099,
0.6641798615455627,
-0.29130253195762634,
0.5480189323425293,
0.04782324656844139,
-0.9533228278160095,
0.2581881284713745,
-0.46426165103912354,
0.27920079231262207,
0.610788106918335,
0.07689514756202698,
-0.9705021977424622,
-0.4969205856323242,
-0.4313525855541229,
-0.4657004475593567,
0.6867465972900391,
0.46485164761543274,
0.30585065484046936,
0.0775459036231041,
0.033439233899116516,
0.2786693871021271,
0.25170108675956726,
-0.5841020345687866,
-0.07253887504339218,
-0.32362642884254456,
-0.11603186279535294,
0.2366260141134262,
-0.050954364240169525,
-0.005812944378703833,
-0.016880644485354424,
0.42093807458877563,
-0.1195828765630722,
0.1864030957221985,
0.04634273424744606,
-0.5497266054153442,
-0.15139320492744446,
0.2623901963233948,
0.4381585717201233,
0.6709972620010376,
0.03180934861302376,
0.07106702774763107,
0.0784246101975441,
-0.2827177941799164,
-0.12093658745288849,
0.4702185392379761,
0.23751147091388702,
-0.12351561337709427,
0.44133326411247253,
0.5353201627731323,
0.25324440002441406,
-1.1378452777862549,
0.5790576338768005,
-0.22435638308525085,
0.13148994743824005,
-0.22773873805999756,
0.17132112383842468,
-0.09533581137657166,
0.5802807807922363,
0.5599864721298218,
-0.08436387032270432,
0.2755733132362366,
-0.5837684273719788,
0.06499220430850983,
0.5499017834663391,
-0.5186996459960938,
-0.39281055331230164,
0.6758338212966919,
0.5212671756744385,
-0.6473362445831299,
0.42342305183410645,
-0.43481266498565674,
-0.4882938265800476,
0.6439850926399231,
0.1987799108028412,
0.8338319063186646,
-0.06460956484079361,
0.24676749110221863,
0.18589997291564941,
0.1371448040008545,
0.2263544797897339,
0.2305029332637787,
-0.297714501619339,
-0.5132224559783936,
-0.2518589198589325,
-0.38958224654197693,
-0.876162588596344,
-0.11446498334407806,
-0.5821036696434021,
-0.05517186224460602,
-0.3763156235218048,
-0.2719568610191345,
0.18623463809490204,
0.13306187093257904,
-0.9910258054733276,
0.049802228808403015,
0.13207562267780304,
0.5939854979515076,
-0.35958701372146606,
0.4097122251987457,
0.9146816730499268,
-0.374851793050766,
-0.34085613489151,
-0.10330446809530258,
0.2745550274848938,
-0.5023568272590637,
0.1766044944524765,
0.36972835659980774,
-0.22156019508838654,
-0.31426361203193665,
-0.5006694793701172,
-0.7292557954788208,
0.6546883583068848,
0.11999935656785965,
-0.24491654336452484,
0.19128265976905823,
0.42170360684394836,
0.606485903263092,
0.08654997497797012,
0.43820327520370483,
0.1938278079032898,
0.6726168990135193,
-0.3216995894908905,
-1.430847406387329,
0.05260094255208969,
-0.7801294326782227,
-0.15203095972537994,
-0.08469405025243759,
-0.8861581683158875,
0.9339665174484253,
0.25240498781204224,
-0.4169120192527771,
0.23608721792697906,
0.6303667426109314,
-0.007384510710835457,
0.17608757317066193,
0.8360961079597473,
0.17147734761238098,
0.6854432821273804,
0.1656995564699173,
0.968364417552948,
-0.35261866450309753,
0.16117526590824127,
0.9513002038002014,
-0.15434110164642334,
0.7778615355491638,
0.2159796804189682,
-0.36048856377601624,
0.6362412571907043,
0.4922981262207031,
-0.03363244980573654,
0.19613319635391235,
0.1961366981267929,
-0.1802128404378891,
-0.48723259568214417,
-0.34852004051208496,
-0.17918749153614044,
0.8402647972106934,
0.0725414976477623,
0.2998102903366089,
-0.3955031931400299,
0.051037561148405075,
-0.008798293769359589,
0.3753249943256378,
0.07127664983272552,
0.9696521759033203,
-0.3640994429588318,
-0.6690874099731445,
0.47072774171829224,
0.3220548927783966,
0.4779563546180725,
-0.5664854645729065,
-0.10885415226221085,
-0.08010482788085938,
0.26915523409843445,
0.1799662709236145,
-0.24271683394908905,
-0.09054472297430038,
0.10720296204090118,
-0.22804142534732819,
-0.026314660906791687,
0.6090646386146545,
-0.052011460065841675,
-0.5508731007575989,
0.0651053637266159,
0.7774174213409424,
0.15206927061080933,
-0.5434573292732239,
-0.6875342726707458,
0.11313828825950623,
-0.2185819447040558,
-0.3243609368801117,
0.266859233379364,
0.5877747535705566,
-0.305611789226532,
0.8607897162437439,
0.8414505124092102,
-0.48270124197006226,
0.22641295194625854,
0.015416763722896576,
0.8877243399620056,
-0.6633967757225037,
-0.5331878066062927,
-0.6794662475585938,
0.49502548575401306,
-0.4030802249908447,
-0.3229755461215973,
0.6923061609268188,
0.8270406723022461,
0.7322410941123962,
0.13915319740772247,
0.9262786507606506,
-0.2028609961271286,
0.5740845799446106,
-0.13207027316093445,
0.7326357960700989,
-0.6447048783302307,
-0.4422731399536133,
-0.28055211901664734,
-0.8111498355865479,
-0.1402609646320343,
0.6026452779769897,
0.1826966404914856,
-0.08224116265773773,
0.5803978443145752,
0.6647800207138062,
-0.07912039756774902,
0.08327365666627884,
0.1986740678548813,
-0.08921781927347183,
0.4388290345668793,
0.36513006687164307,
1.079439401626587,
-0.12434647977352142,
0.9595021605491638,
-0.4715264141559601,
-0.22728323936462402,
-0.43373632431030273,
-0.715252161026001,
-1.0930092334747314,
-0.8690146803855896,
-0.053512390702962875,
-0.17169949412345886,
0.08120664209127426,
1.0971790552139282,
0.9875689148902893,
-0.5936601161956787,
-0.3673724830150604,
0.08967457711696625,
0.03204694017767906,
-0.5876404643058777,
-0.1519964337348938,
0.21172602474689484,
-0.41356736421585083,
-0.878069281578064,
0.3162529766559601,
0.13669626414775848,
0.03994741663336754,
-0.27570441365242004,
0.19344115257263184,
-0.09433931857347488,
0.09012879431247711,
0.5047093629837036,
0.2093459516763687,
-0.7826672792434692,
-0.4979020357131958,
0.14349448680877686,
-0.34911882877349854,
0.12643414735794067,
0.76768958568573,
-0.7661900520324707,
0.643787682056427,
0.35381922125816345,
0.7436152696609497,
0.6491826176643372,
0.04823092743754387,
0.6447225213050842,
-0.5020744204521179,
0.3324853777885437,
0.26947101950645447,
0.08647187799215317,
0.34050408005714417,
0.1590166985988617,
0.5337465405464172,
-0.06597967445850372,
-0.19559988379478455,
-0.7074087858200073,
0.029006188735365868,
-1.0626600980758667,
-0.39856451749801636,
0.88103848695755,
0.014022181741893291,
-0.21662460267543793,
-0.2876746654510498,
-0.23396381735801697,
0.5082408785820007,
-0.45119068026542664,
1.1871006488800049,
0.6616734266281128,
-0.011782150715589523,
-0.05165671557188034,
-0.6001031994819641,
0.35033470392227173,
0.3662828207015991,
-1.0418647527694702,
0.21888428926467896,
0.8410394787788391,
-0.06449618190526962,
0.12836885452270508,
0.5491257905960083,
0.23993410170078278,
0.570148229598999,
0.1884467601776123,
0.4269796311855316,
-0.15774233639240265,
-0.14002405107021332,
0.27050772309303284,
0.23137454688549042,
-0.03180180490016937,
-0.41120946407318115
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11904v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11904v3
|
CICLe: Conformal In-Context Learning for Largescale Multi-Class Food Risk Classification
| 2024-03-18T16:04:55 | 2024-05-30T08:37:45 |
Korbinian Randl, John Pavlopoulos, Aron Henriksson, Tony Lindgren
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Contaminated or adulterated food poses a substantial risk to human health.
Given sets of labeled web texts for training, Machine Learning and Natural
Language Processing can be applied to automatically detect such risks. We
publish a dataset of 7,546 short texts describing public food recall
announcements. Each text is manually labeled, on two granularity levels (coarse
and fine), for food products and hazards that the recall corresponds to. We
describe the dataset and benchmark naive, traditional, and Transformer models.
Based on our analysis, Logistic Regression based on a tf-idf representation
outperforms RoBERTa and XLM-R on classes with low support. Finally, we discuss
different prompting strategies and present an LLM-in-the-loop framework, based
on Conformal Prediction, which boosts the performance of the base classifier
while reducing energy consumption compared to normal prompting.
|
[
-0.10236603766679764,
-0.522551953792572,
0.41122373938560486,
-0.17471621930599213,
0.3682108223438263,
-0.321961373090744,
-0.32052403688430786,
-0.6855339407920837,
-0.28795143961906433,
0.49441906809806824,
-0.0955718457698822,
-0.62826007604599,
-0.6116064786911011,
0.20285236835479736,
-0.511714518070221,
0.9854745268821716,
0.019372498616576195,
-0.050511684268713,
-0.3302994668483734,
0.1153828501701355,
-0.2946432828903198,
-0.7483496069908142,
-0.6024770140647888,
0.030748575925827026,
0.6172829866409302,
0.8817881941795349,
0.3147290349006653,
0.24281740188598633,
0.2976589798927307,
0.2656992971897125,
-0.1314169019460678,
-0.11200489848852158,
-0.0750412866473198,
0.22615599632263184,
-0.2754144072532654,
-0.4207613468170166,
-0.29286283254623413,
-0.08229801058769226,
0.4335562586784363,
0.5638647675514221,
-0.23584800958633423,
0.35134539008140564,
0.21053756773471832,
1.0803494453430176,
-0.8036632537841797,
0.40159329771995544,
-0.7416725158691406,
0.012250112369656563,
0.03595884144306183,
0.04794685170054436,
-0.7070540189743042,
-0.5837854146957397,
0.3052046597003937,
-0.5859862565994263,
0.0784161165356636,
0.0725383535027504,
0.4988061487674713,
0.22240503132343292,
-0.7193339467048645,
-0.7133467197418213,
-0.8177034854888916,
0.6859180927276611,
-0.3638152778148651,
0.3727192282676697,
0.5514572262763977,
0.41081464290618896,
-0.4353983402252197,
-0.8279898166656494,
-0.2712859511375427,
-0.07348866760730743,
0.07017394155263901,
-0.022672662511467934,
-0.16373784840106964,
0.04569833353161812,
0.1285793036222458,
0.15962418913841248,
-0.3926490843296051,
0.06500715762376785,
-0.7254167199134827,
-0.0682310238480568,
0.4543873369693756,
0.04293699562549591,
0.11801254004240036,
0.053952623158693314,
-0.6398459672927856,
-0.5291842222213745,
-0.59095299243927,
0.2788613736629486,
0.12821517884731293,
0.3125384449958801,
-0.05974523723125458,
0.39044395089149475,
-0.1931924670934677,
0.7408543825149536,
0.27562105655670166,
-0.2991456389427185,
0.3246472179889679,
-0.07091771066188812,
-0.23236992955207825,
0.4531051516532898,
0.5398623943328857,
0.5641530156135559,
0.2676244378089905,
0.13959477841854095,
-0.08884876221418381,
-0.2958137094974518,
0.30162179470062256,
-0.6586138606071472,
-0.3813616931438446,
0.19717928767204285,
-0.26863792538642883,
-0.21771226823329926,
0.3466835618019104,
-0.9155402183532715,
-0.44065865874290466,
-0.1670026034116745,
0.23644615709781647,
-0.42228493094444275,
0.15919172763824463,
0.1669040024280548,
-0.16197195649147034,
0.12391632050275803,
0.2595023810863495,
-0.8128632307052612,
0.25925782322883606,
0.31137552857398987,
0.6241704225540161,
0.053984638303518295,
0.2165902853012085,
-0.45629170536994934,
0.7398146390914917,
0.0973537415266037,
1.0612753629684448,
-0.7040339112281799,
-0.39316871762275696,
0.029702430590987206,
0.23567494750022888,
-0.06057949736714363,
-0.834420382976532,
0.7904422283172607,
-0.33463913202285767,
-0.05070015788078308,
-0.3514605164527893,
-0.5691288709640503,
-0.654330849647522,
0.4694594144821167,
-0.7701901197433472,
0.6629762053489685,
0.109224833548069,
-0.8227552175521851,
0.6029826402664185,
-0.3492131531238556,
-0.6762504577636719,
-0.01323794201016426,
-0.05940818414092064,
-0.8283187747001648,
-0.11585520952939987,
0.1661195456981659,
0.7481881976127625,
-0.21307870745658875,
0.2614462971687317,
-0.482340008020401,
-0.10793859511613846,
0.17354890704154968,
-0.434459388256073,
0.2596709430217743,
0.15566901862621307,
-0.10614532232284546,
0.43820977210998535,
-0.5671560168266296,
0.0718524158000946,
-0.11879877746105194,
-0.7071947455406189,
-0.44451257586479187,
0.08308693021535873,
0.30134981870651245,
0.2357250452041626,
-0.09675762057304382,
-0.21951620280742645,
0.2311512678861618,
-0.029479529708623886,
0.6207830309867859,
0.5766189098358154,
0.38219842314720154,
0.5229311585426331,
-0.6259454488754272,
0.1364702731370926,
0.2834138870239258,
0.24992312490940094,
-0.23175421357154846,
-0.4659477770328522,
-0.16266316175460815,
-0.4281309247016907,
0.28022849559783936,
0.7040878534317017,
-0.2808942496776581,
0.6230450868606567,
-0.14674970507621765,
-0.34966716170310974,
0.2411840856075287,
-0.34056517481803894,
0.15104934573173523,
0.5099650621414185,
0.4657799303531647,
0.14580053091049194,
-0.4470202922821045,
-0.7320951819419861,
-0.0967487171292305,
-0.10981101542711258,
-0.4652303457260132,
0.10074108093976974,
0.3449159264564514,
-0.4885319769382477,
0.7287411093711853,
-0.5161216855049133,
-0.49765661358833313,
-0.16615809500217438,
0.07896368205547333,
-0.0006649135029874742,
0.4319436252117157,
0.30494043231010437,
-1.0879145860671997,
-0.7579717040061951,
0.07634668797254562,
-0.5708342790603638,
0.4390058219432831,
0.045970264822244644,
0.2228468656539917,
0.3395388722419739,
0.7075200080871582,
0.03932444006204605,
0.45882633328437805,
0.5590789318084717,
-0.05979219451546669,
0.3619396686553955,
-0.2308506965637207,
0.09334497898817062,
-1.046058177947998,
-0.05592532455921173,
0.5257303714752197,
-0.07612742483615875,
-0.6756970286369324,
-0.4132915735244751,
0.4367281198501587,
-0.045595668256282806,
-0.5686243772506714,
0.4503960609436035,
-0.368834525346756,
0.2710038125514984,
0.06545764207839966,
-0.2593049705028534,
-0.03993966430425644,
0.23851528763771057,
0.19492299854755402,
0.7450864911079407,
0.19892874360084534,
-0.9630193710327148,
0.028593558818101883,
0.007075729314237833,
-0.37348705530166626,
0.5323155522346497,
-0.35709378123283386,
-0.15230229496955872,
-0.2125743329524994,
0.7587084174156189,
-1.221783995628357,
-0.578654944896698,
0.43047091364860535,
0.02378079481422901,
0.4765823483467102,
-0.0431668795645237,
-0.6465162634849548,
-0.5990279316902161,
-0.3345416784286499,
0.45045459270477295,
0.1487734466791153,
-0.5669024586677551,
0.43968629837036133,
0.5784437656402588,
0.0042001488618552685,
-0.015683306381106377,
-0.47624635696411133,
-0.3435125946998596,
-0.5286235213279724,
-0.29360002279281616,
-0.029221870005130768,
-0.2859962582588196,
-0.06324832141399384,
-0.37295761704444885,
-0.3830072283744812,
-0.32704368233680725,
0.19150422513484955,
0.586295485496521,
0.1232554093003273,
0.2655578553676605,
0.27389201521873474,
0.08753910660743713,
0.04720735177397728,
0.2037949562072754,
-0.4588848352432251,
0.2316906601190567,
-0.5971795320510864,
0.06352483481168747,
-0.4445318579673767,
0.13446195423603058,
0.35542258620262146,
0.2557869255542755,
0.640960693359375,
0.490102618932724,
-0.6814044713973999,
0.3365100026130676,
-0.30385860800743103,
-0.08147778362035751,
-0.44705256819725037,
0.1687505692243576,
-0.1247149333357811,
-0.5511776804924011,
0.092208631336689,
-0.29241734743118286,
-0.007185614667832851,
0.3854256272315979,
0.3092339038848877,
-0.3176831305027008,
0.5816624164581299,
0.45087334513664246,
-0.13366733491420746,
0.4625617265701294,
-0.17226055264472961,
-0.1825859248638153,
-0.6850643157958984,
-0.5463579893112183,
-0.5649623870849609,
-0.05273209512233734,
-0.47569698095321655,
-0.3654070198535919,
1.0162259340286255,
-0.14738526940345764,
-0.45038333535194397,
0.19373676180839539,
-0.6684256196022034,
0.6755393147468567,
0.35557103157043457,
0.3555779755115509,
0.33728212118148804,
-0.04405605047941208,
-0.21171782910823822,
0.23668836057186127,
-0.656607985496521,
-0.5443787574768066,
1.0209497213363647,
0.4014372229576111,
1.015189528465271,
-0.052887458354234695,
0.595185399055481,
0.2952406704425812,
0.7003364562988281,
-0.8305546045303345,
0.09438641369342804,
-0.13106179237365723,
-0.9039357900619507,
-0.4823785424232483,
-0.352771133184433,
-0.8585729598999023,
-0.027745848521590233,
-0.328583300113678,
-0.8356307744979858,
-0.005838441662490368,
0.26937687397003174,
-0.4243446886539459,
0.4130007028579712,
-1.047316074371338,
0.5208635330200195,
-0.3128589391708374,
-0.088282011449337,
0.09235864132642746,
-0.9218265414237976,
0.5249918103218079,
-0.18608148396015167,
0.5135846734046936,
-0.08144690096378326,
0.14835888147354126,
0.5572503805160522,
0.16175420582294464,
1.2373460531234741,
0.12589552998542786,
-0.1278906911611557,
0.20787911117076874,
-0.10346786677837372,
0.6174874901771545,
0.2154516875743866,
-0.14467760920524597,
-0.014659395441412926,
0.2912074029445648,
-0.25814342498779297,
-0.14509634673595428,
0.5891435146331787,
-0.3787609338760376,
-0.18275697529315948,
-0.7002243995666504,
-0.2630997896194458,
-0.2190932035446167,
0.1845472753047943,
0.4111393988132477,
0.2007533460855484,
-0.19644883275032043,
0.3172297477722168,
1.076408863067627,
-0.29968366026878357,
0.3919709026813507,
0.17042328417301178,
0.09049908071756363,
-0.516058087348938,
0.7973706126213074,
0.06810785084962845,
0.24608594179153442,
0.7508759498596191,
0.5087569952011108,
-0.16073034703731537,
0.012423080392181873,
-0.2439032644033432,
-0.251168817281723,
-0.766292929649353,
-0.7572199106216431,
-0.5610315799713135,
-0.24922573566436768,
-0.21272452175617218,
-0.46117037534713745,
-0.17863285541534424,
-0.013987011276185513,
-0.4452866315841675,
-0.047661926597356796,
0.09005731344223022,
0.8990916609764099,
0.06575809419155121,
0.2223329395055771,
-1.0743259191513062,
0.11278380453586578,
0.22355544567108154,
0.334063857793808,
0.2998788058757782,
-0.15394282341003418,
-0.30658966302871704,
-0.02701226994395256,
-0.5769200921058655,
-0.7988854646682739,
0.34551557898521423,
0.2018044888973236,
0.48314040899276733,
0.7162526845932007,
0.444089412689209,
0.32845351099967957,
-0.3369936943054199,
0.5127958059310913,
0.6179555058479309,
-0.7315777540206909,
0.4416121244430542,
-0.16623511910438538,
0.5690499544143677,
0.5678365230560303,
0.9998242259025574,
-0.7859935760498047,
-0.24910275638103485,
-0.42699187994003296,
-1.0303183794021606,
0.24539704620838165,
-0.2877283990383148,
-0.3676134943962097,
-0.416668564081192,
0.24135351181030273,
0.4359331727027893,
0.06884408742189407,
-0.7299222946166992,
-0.12033496797084808,
-0.13513068854808807,
-0.316573828458786,
0.21557842195034027,
-0.4939475655555725,
-0.0604662261903286,
-0.41906800866127014,
0.5845504403114319,
-0.23458193242549896,
0.18020081520080566,
0.20942828059196472,
-0.1713607758283615,
-0.23651087284088135,
0.555767297744751,
0.8294804096221924,
0.5084470510482788,
-0.3077099323272705,
0.3302968442440033,
0.39252737164497375,
-0.5146587491035461,
0.20235276222229004,
-0.30526188015937805,
0.17475567758083344,
-0.6175371408462524,
0.39084532856941223,
0.11276432871818542,
0.6884492635726929,
-0.6433377861976624,
0.3825548589229584,
-0.30512097477912903,
-0.4205292761325836,
-0.8063636422157288,
-0.00021426760940812528,
0.017547236755490303,
0.16251589357852936,
0.439503014087677,
0.03300290182232857,
0.42023763060569763,
-0.5833362340927124,
0.5494424104690552,
0.12983658909797668,
-0.541286051273346,
-0.2648542523384094,
0.5046166777610779,
0.17881782352924347,
0.20691969990730286,
0.668266773223877,
0.01049772184342146,
-0.3773837387561798,
0.4770711660385132,
0.5051138401031494,
0.5977795720100403,
-0.36395347118377686,
0.17759160697460175,
0.7232579588890076,
0.20216143131256104,
-0.29230496287345886,
-0.021546391770243645,
0.10828278958797455,
-0.3805074691772461,
0.19560182094573975,
-0.5416439771652222,
-0.3228573501110077,
0.3172960877418518,
-0.9351171851158142,
0.21717050671577454,
-0.6025145649909973,
-0.04846961051225662,
0.19962678849697113,
-0.2823896110057831,
-0.6165711879730225,
0.1433495134115219,
0.41901758313179016,
0.9884439706802368,
-1.1083016395568848,
0.843402087688446,
0.7743107676506042,
-0.3083283007144928,
-0.4433858394622803,
0.5856150984764099,
0.2786487936973572,
-0.3347553312778473,
0.5344436168670654,
0.5064085125923157,
0.07992809265851974,
-0.32740339636802673,
-0.6926538944244385,
-0.9533409476280212,
0.9309101104736328,
-0.17270363867282867,
-0.8483771681785583,
-0.20488430559635162,
-0.07723990082740784,
0.21996141970157623,
-0.3283238708972931,
0.06597597151994705,
0.4596329927444458,
0.8240752220153809,
0.338245689868927,
-0.6609429717063904,
0.008118399418890476,
0.49446266889572144,
0.00260181468911469,
0.25750213861465454,
-0.595282256603241,
0.48391544818878174,
-0.3308239281177521,
-0.3055143654346466,
-0.2132217139005661,
0.8772801756858826,
0.10475828498601913,
0.6161519885063171,
0.6888585686683655,
0.18472667038440704,
1.023791790008545,
0.05194241926074028,
0.8727938532829285,
0.04610702767968178,
0.24041150510311127,
1.1211082935333252,
-0.1926826387643814,
0.861397922039032,
0.38309982419013977,
-0.03818557783961296,
0.4698067009449005,
0.9913471341133118,
0.130273699760437,
0.7287518382072449,
0.2927761971950531,
-0.3417142927646637,
-0.08179185539484024,
0.25552722811698914,
-0.049248725175857544,
0.13478490710258484,
0.8835095167160034,
-0.3649962842464447,
-0.37235310673713684,
0.4451541304588318,
-0.10593370348215103,
0.14002685248851776,
-0.4551720917224884,
0.9193090796470642,
0.06460516154766083,
-0.18277502059936523,
0.5273722410202026,
0.00594056211411953,
0.3922783136367798,
-0.16968174278736115,
-0.1846635490655899,
0.16119050979614258,
0.3302581310272217,
-0.3294135630130768,
-0.8188478350639343,
0.4335818588733673,
-0.5868058204650879,
-0.5185267925262451,
-0.03898033872246742,
0.5139049887657166,
-0.5372486710548401,
-0.524709939956665,
0.18532295525074005,
-0.17691461741924286,
-0.032668910920619965,
-0.220123752951622,
-0.5232498049736023,
0.010569053702056408,
-0.1521102488040924,
-0.15795664489269257,
0.34418606758117676,
0.4096996784210205,
-0.559860110282898,
0.7231859564781189,
0.28344330191612244,
-0.5625299215316772,
0.06644652783870697,
-0.38365426659584045,
0.9808821082115173,
-0.7227953672409058,
-0.35412928462028503,
-0.43189170956611633,
0.26723504066467285,
0.14860568940639496,
0.02672872133553028,
0.2634405493736267,
0.7111392617225647,
1.1711666584014893,
-0.2991912364959717,
0.9074780344963074,
-0.042140621691942215,
0.32445403933525085,
-0.5979166626930237,
0.39292073249816895,
-0.2913876473903656,
0.18115636706352234,
0.12165500968694687,
-0.5320754051208496,
-0.34661513566970825,
0.4673422873020172,
-0.4339900612831116,
-0.17728307843208313,
0.9403238892555237,
0.3338505029678345,
-0.1367977112531662,
0.03859798237681389,
0.28068944811820984,
0.08010198175907135,
0.23928356170654297,
0.6518326997756958,
0.47294044494628906,
-0.2577279508113861,
0.46471554040908813,
-0.05196138098835945,
-0.28984177112579346,
-0.6844832897186279,
-0.8036335110664368,
-0.9019414186477661,
-1.0275899171829224,
-0.1880262941122055,
-0.39235150814056396,
0.03873959183692932,
1.0089210271835327,
0.8178761601448059,
-0.8476184010505676,
-0.20423159003257751,
0.0943208560347557,
0.2593299150466919,
-0.49215787649154663,
-0.19769273698329926,
0.23160280287265778,
-0.34854188561439514,
-0.43989989161491394,
0.21811622381210327,
0.10849979519844055,
0.23314358294010162,
0.11570896208286285,
0.23084281384944916,
-0.36253052949905396,
-0.05422130227088928,
0.6613052487373352,
0.4874478578567505,
-0.6307820677757263,
-0.4545855224132538,
-0.46048271656036377,
-0.21358485519886017,
0.19618909060955048,
0.7114325761795044,
-0.43432384729385376,
0.23780305683612823,
0.12047988921403885,
0.29271024465560913,
0.6583405137062073,
0.07690368592739105,
0.40298911929130554,
-0.8605992197990417,
0.03635163605213165,
0.12680576741695404,
0.10253602266311646,
0.21610331535339355,
-0.8236432671546936,
0.33935627341270447,
-0.044123996049165726,
-0.5784310698509216,
-0.32432061433792114,
0.24312011897563934,
-0.9707103371620178,
-0.4716613292694092,
1.2816532850265503,
-0.09740811586380005,
-0.7262560725212097,
-0.17889118194580078,
0.11144471913576126,
0.20394550263881683,
-0.5572823286056519,
0.9404165744781494,
0.5598435401916504,
-0.08441697806119919,
0.05394355207681656,
-0.5558359622955322,
0.5454369783401489,
-0.5145772695541382,
-1.04838228225708,
0.053320176899433136,
0.4842890202999115,
0.7254458665847778,
0.10774902254343033,
0.1555410623550415,
-0.0779169425368309,
0.13461311161518097,
-0.34075525403022766,
0.33872345089912415,
0.19720710813999176,
-0.8889021277427673,
-0.220398411154747,
0.3451084792613983,
-0.11600734293460846,
-0.14921756088733673
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11903v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11903v1
|
A Closer Look at Claim Decomposition
| 2024-03-18T16:03:45 | 2024-03-18T16:03:45 |
Miriam Wanner, Seth Ebner, Zhengping Jiang, Mark Dredze, Benjamin Van Durme
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
As generated text becomes more commonplace, it is increasingly important to
evaluate how well-supported such text is by external knowledge sources. Many
approaches for evaluating textual support rely on some method for decomposing
text into its individual subclaims which are scored against a trusted
reference. We investigate how various methods of claim decomposition --
especially LLM-based methods -- affect the result of an evaluation approach
such as the recently proposed FActScore, finding that it is sensitive to the
decomposition method used. This sensitivity arises because such metrics
attribute overall textual support to the model that generated the text even
though error can also come from the metric's decomposition step. To measure
decomposition quality, we introduce an adaptation of FActScore, which we call
DecompScore. We then propose an LLM-based approach to generating decompositions
inspired by Bertrand Russell's theory of logical atomism and neo-Davidsonian
semantics and demonstrate its improved decomposition quality over previous
methods.
|
[
-0.21822622418403625,
-0.4684484601020813,
0.8364602327346802,
-0.052137259393930435,
0.01958051137626171,
0.1089521050453186,
-0.18994705379009247,
-0.3715326488018036,
0.06128215417265892,
0.2668286859989166,
-0.3850783109664917,
-0.4860045909881592,
-0.42599499225616455,
0.20693734288215637,
-0.23432230949401855,
1.0754040479660034,
-0.0035713850520551205,
-0.13193871080875397,
-0.8861439824104309,
-0.11293426901102066,
-0.09577295184135437,
-0.5044921040534973,
-0.32103970646858215,
-0.5062848329544067,
0.34375452995300293,
0.23860877752304077,
0.6245167851448059,
0.5324046611785889,
0.5092065334320068,
0.2632959187030792,
-0.21308201551437378,
0.21718637645244598,
-0.3687256872653961,
0.11796005070209503,
-0.41844749450683594,
-0.7761018872261047,
-0.4404049515724182,
0.1660308837890625,
0.6540109515190125,
0.4029611051082611,
-0.4000292718410492,
0.5201875567436218,
0.04632621258497238,
0.6170685887336731,
-0.9588908553123474,
0.24941353499889374,
-0.8077735900878906,
0.059365786612033844,
0.07157304137945175,
-0.21600283682346344,
-0.7357397079467773,
-0.37194424867630005,
0.04818519949913025,
-0.4243618845939636,
0.5614528059959412,
0.05939346179366112,
0.6410968899726868,
0.15921126306056976,
-0.4516476094722748,
-0.45704585313796997,
-0.6016976237297058,
0.9043315052986145,
-0.6274664998054504,
0.08322887122631073,
0.31087222695350647,
0.29446253180503845,
-0.0024347470607608557,
-0.6808041334152222,
-0.5106980204582214,
-0.2748207747936249,
-0.24484474956989288,
0.4796781539916992,
-0.3614184856414795,
0.027557315304875374,
0.1944483071565628,
0.5782419443130493,
-0.19849541783332825,
-0.0807717964053154,
-0.33047017455101013,
-0.6939512491226196,
0.7982032299041748,
0.21182993054389954,
0.4970068633556366,
-0.568954586982727,
-0.7791057229042053,
0.1319301873445511,
-0.8294482827186584,
-0.06107280030846596,
0.337736040353775,
0.2606056332588196,
0.1651703268289566,
0.736505925655365,
-0.10489558428525925,
0.3577200472354889,
-0.32043251395225525,
-0.5057628154754639,
-0.11194714903831482,
-0.37944236397743225,
-0.3210913836956024,
0.4656749367713928,
0.635805070400238,
0.6046706438064575,
-0.09567682445049286,
-0.15058694779872894,
-0.2907285690307617,
0.467305064201355,
0.18147432804107666,
-0.7456197142601013,
-0.1998695433139801,
0.17056894302368164,
-0.8012619614601135,
-0.21093370020389557,
-0.22812360525131226,
-0.03353966772556305,
-0.6060986518859863,
-0.3730241060256958,
0.1734425127506256,
-0.5498047471046448,
-0.3548736274242401,
0.05599082261323929,
-0.35885682702064514,
0.1588725596666336,
0.389678955078125,
-0.5474599599838257,
0.682619035243988,
0.7563901543617249,
0.6339073777198792,
-0.14785532653331757,
0.1787302941083908,
-0.4469006359577179,
0.23084905743598938,
-0.5371473431587219,
1.161882996559143,
-0.2676064372062683,
-0.29972270131111145,
-0.07967062294483185,
-0.48624107241630554,
0.008915873244404793,
-1.0467661619186401,
0.8402696847915649,
-0.5193976163864136,
0.22989138960838318,
-0.4216021001338959,
-0.7249184846878052,
-0.41346219182014465,
0.6146492958068848,
-0.7323316335678101,
0.938106894493103,
0.23453296720981598,
-0.8924702405929565,
0.3900977671146393,
-0.508086621761322,
-0.21335294842720032,
-0.040065497159957886,
-0.09929908066987991,
-0.3319455683231354,
0.6603708863258362,
0.008860915899276733,
0.40769141912460327,
-0.5835638046264648,
0.10201779007911682,
-0.29591405391693115,
0.12085990607738495,
0.48438769578933716,
-0.1753164678812027,
0.8843965530395508,
0.26335930824279785,
0.11523956060409546,
-0.20403115451335907,
-1.0414862632751465,
0.07967778295278549,
0.05800056457519531,
-0.3918944299221039,
-0.4456580579280853,
0.3760385811328888,
-0.30625754594802856,
-0.11524618417024612,
0.1761757731437683,
-0.7764049768447876,
-0.06884695589542389,
-0.45730069279670715,
0.19244223833084106,
0.8411332964897156,
0.2005504071712494,
0.1062830239534378,
-0.3528025150299072,
0.40422460436820984,
-0.03213074430823326,
-0.16728489100933075,
-0.005985208321362734,
0.07826647162437439,
-0.7348646521568298,
-0.21837162971496582,
0.3369879722595215,
0.5282700657844543,
-0.36132755875587463,
-0.029203947633504868,
-0.3164144456386566,
-0.3931528329849243,
-0.3085211217403412,
-0.0023644992616027594,
0.4354735314846039,
0.7801187634468079,
0.45710301399230957,
-0.15151970088481903,
-0.3941344916820526,
-1.2575063705444336,
-0.7072589993476868,
-0.4773053526878357,
-0.08455263078212738,
-0.017324332147836685,
0.1296035349369049,
-0.1413317769765854,
1.060930609703064,
-0.7779594659805298,
-0.3701666295528412,
-0.11589109897613525,
-0.05682980641722679,
-0.1097559928894043,
0.04569099470973015,
0.7202900648117065,
-0.5590816736221313,
-0.19978830218315125,
-0.11059305816888809,
-0.5837711691856384,
-0.0053436607122421265,
-0.037952203303575516,
-0.01760663278400898,
0.2249886840581894,
0.27190715074539185,
-0.5993061065673828,
0.35775837302207947,
0.3297345042228699,
-0.11007342487573624,
0.8711724281311035,
0.009475907310843468,
0.07067817449569702,
-1.163195252418518,
-0.2844683825969696,
0.06101198121905327,
-0.41938620805740356,
-0.037751149386167526,
0.21625012159347534,
-0.13930444419384003,
0.11001279950141907,
-0.36709657311439514,
0.09562791138887405,
-0.554867148399353,
-0.1806097775697708,
-0.36816030740737915,
0.2152627408504486,
0.07382122427225113,
0.017202459275722504,
-0.1086641252040863,
0.5343810319900513,
0.48985469341278076,
-0.7036499381065369,
0.5093384385108948,
0.2768920958042145,
-0.5280434489250183,
0.7851578593254089,
-0.42396917939186096,
-0.10648803412914276,
-0.2696998417377472,
0.30189114809036255,
-1.3319194316864014,
0.043252311646938324,
0.1681506335735321,
-0.515286386013031,
0.13731402158737183,
-0.19794656336307526,
-0.6348506808280945,
0.18033088743686676,
-0.5751967430114746,
0.27635639905929565,
0.38364946842193604,
-0.4396838843822479,
0.7922827005386353,
0.36669814586639404,
-0.2514508068561554,
-0.4168378412723541,
-0.881167471408844,
0.2251899540424347,
-0.3663613498210907,
-0.4508504569530487,
0.5727895498275757,
-0.15533940494060516,
-0.7929543852806091,
0.4388023018836975,
-0.3958527445793152,
0.2528952956199646,
0.0796959400177002,
0.09940111637115479,
-0.06613772362470627,
-0.2964742183685303,
0.1598052829504013,
0.19170424342155457,
-0.49565446376800537,
0.6943978667259216,
0.09492707997560501,
-0.005708200391381979,
0.301623672246933,
-0.18451334536075592,
-0.22874897718429565,
0.4969419240951538,
0.2117268592119217,
-0.14339682459831238,
0.6595040559768677,
0.24167492985725403,
-0.4521177411079407,
-0.7137401103973389,
-0.43077459931373596,
0.09946027398109436,
-0.4249059855937958,
-0.008907732553780079,
-0.30318784713745117,
-0.5770303010940552,
0.5116775035858154,
-0.37924209237098694,
0.19729478657245636,
0.9604387879371643,
0.6514432430267334,
-0.1220860406756401,
0.8037898540496826,
0.5883690714836121,
0.3676091134548187,
-0.018606876954436302,
-0.20815125107765198,
0.13987770676612854,
-0.933768630027771,
-0.31494712829589844,
-0.6809291839599609,
-0.18759846687316895,
-0.47035136818885803,
-0.32039254903793335,
0.3285428285598755,
-0.07206802815198898,
-0.0632360652089119,
0.14743593335151672,
-0.2864481508731842,
0.48988988995552063,
0.27166351675987244,
0.3338674008846283,
0.5567025542259216,
0.3772820830345154,
-0.0969989076256752,
-0.08313549309968948,
-0.6845722794532776,
-0.5968894362449646,
0.8971304297447205,
0.34473320841789246,
0.6134875416755676,
0.37429019808769226,
0.9532647728919983,
0.5921836495399475,
0.7394949793815613,
-1.1341423988342285,
0.6176104545593262,
0.09276849776506424,
-0.7397076487541199,
0.32229846715927124,
-0.6265923380851746,
-0.41493773460388184,
0.28252461552619934,
-0.1883835345506668,
-0.6544396281242371,
-0.13163340091705322,
0.10068410634994507,
-0.34165966510772705,
0.11097881197929382,
-0.841098964214325,
0.34229764342308044,
0.07418288290500641,
-0.150845468044281,
-0.610262393951416,
-0.3675958216190338,
0.5274955630302429,
0.25822925567626953,
0.254159152507782,
-0.3416776657104492,
-0.05972108989953995,
1.1138404607772827,
-0.7779918909072876,
0.8864865899085999,
-0.20446696877479553,
-0.6408252716064453,
0.9136009216308594,
0.6077724695205688,
0.3881710469722748,
0.27576500177383423,
-0.37070414423942566,
-0.12991787493228912,
0.38129448890686035,
-0.402621865272522,
-0.770595371723175,
0.5677472352981567,
-0.6847917437553406,
-0.682579517364502,
-0.5322662591934204,
-0.3073170483112335,
-0.22706612944602966,
0.23652850091457367,
0.27971646189689636,
0.6908993124961853,
-0.31101664900779724,
-0.05741452798247337,
0.5979697704315186,
-0.1852496862411499,
0.45180419087409973,
0.2999165654182434,
-0.030166251584887505,
-0.6656699776649475,
0.764549732208252,
0.2896619439125061,
0.3484501242637634,
0.44043460488319397,
0.5200856924057007,
-0.6241699457168579,
-0.7119474411010742,
0.1798742264509201,
0.08290880918502808,
-1.2248563766479492,
-0.5662321448326111,
-0.41402748227119446,
-0.012322458438575268,
-0.22464442253112793,
-0.0036438063252717257,
-0.5469333529472351,
-0.46137335896492004,
0.0301667433232069,
-0.6469854712486267,
0.2626761496067047,
0.6632254123687744,
-0.04271281138062477,
0.0883372500538826,
-0.9174567461013794,
0.593795120716095,
0.17994344234466553,
0.3792998790740967,
-0.30453813076019287,
-0.20793378353118896,
-0.2174515724182129,
-0.19407550990581512,
-0.05922354385256767,
-0.8227060437202454,
-0.08884492516517639,
0.20688758790493011,
0.650378942489624,
-0.01662347838282585,
0.578056812286377,
0.5163547992706299,
-0.48499125242233276,
0.9289459586143494,
0.32413339614868164,
-1.013563871383667,
0.4077019989490509,
-0.08286269754171371,
-0.20591218769550323,
0.5604943037033081,
0.4492894411087036,
-0.20665566623210907,
-0.22338618338108063,
-0.8103330731391907,
-0.7232207655906677,
0.43424636125564575,
-0.05931703746318817,
0.326631098985672,
-0.14018723368644714,
0.3816211521625519,
0.25454336404800415,
-0.1354752629995346,
-0.7769515514373779,
-0.2871890068054199,
0.15323235094547272,
-0.14137279987335205,
0.10058191418647766,
-0.7760815024375916,
-0.49448302388191223,
0.13766057789325714,
0.5384360551834106,
-0.18781432509422302,
0.24824289977550507,
0.4651602804660797,
-0.45782968401908875,
0.09902448207139969,
0.3689180612564087,
0.3572103679180145,
1.0996475219726562,
0.08751758188009262,
0.6185675263404846,
0.018421323969960213,
-0.12760204076766968,
0.2679192125797272,
-0.2674737572669983,
-0.2546560764312744,
0.007635254412889481,
0.8462146520614624,
0.3304373323917389,
-0.0548064261674881,
-0.3614290654659271,
0.29164618253707886,
-0.06256954371929169,
-0.2505338191986084,
-0.17510254681110382,
0.15997856855392456,
0.017573529854416847,
0.15849259495735168,
0.43405458331108093,
0.32065537571907043,
0.2929253578186035,
-0.7225028276443481,
0.3200928866863251,
0.23587897419929504,
-0.2774045765399933,
-0.4528330862522125,
0.35699713230133057,
0.025046952068805695,
-0.09003859013319016,
0.33949628472328186,
-0.23082925379276276,
-0.5877055525779724,
0.39387214183807373,
0.7522320747375488,
0.8347275853157043,
-0.049973055720329285,
0.40574848651885986,
0.34964895248413086,
0.2635004222393036,
0.12986601889133453,
0.14556127786636353,
-0.1823059767484665,
-0.9256206750869751,
-0.7782153487205505,
-0.48380517959594727,
-0.2325364649295807,
-0.30423814058303833,
-0.6110398769378662,
-0.04377666488289833,
-0.5082708597183228,
-0.18899336457252502,
-0.09051784127950668,
0.1110660582780838,
-0.41390886902809143,
0.2867836356163025,
0.22175586223602295,
0.8900819420814514,
-0.9248732924461365,
0.06506900489330292,
0.8025143146514893,
-0.28382185101509094,
-0.8895086050033569,
0.32553747296333313,
0.1687961220741272,
-0.7821078896522522,
0.8118433356285095,
-0.013876202516257763,
-0.5372503995895386,
-0.030445516109466553,
-0.5447462201118469,
-0.6259245276451111,
0.8479853272438049,
0.7976561784744263,
0.08336640149354935,
0.3164462447166443,
0.0708998590707779,
0.4308781027793884,
-0.09373930096626282,
0.2414325326681137,
0.2870400846004486,
0.3847114145755768,
-0.13977380096912384,
-0.700874924659729,
0.48434847593307495,
0.07735709846019745,
0.015287968330085278,
0.0614941269159317,
-0.8257015943527222,
0.5359470844268799,
-0.17074713110923767,
-0.684335470199585,
-0.19148661196231842,
0.8350149989128113,
0.112162746489048,
0.2872260510921478,
0.31327325105667114,
0.7574767470359802,
0.7640066742897034,
0.14037278294563293,
1.1423267126083374,
0.1348416656255722,
0.7041486501693726,
0.8319666981697083,
-0.2166450023651123,
0.7762388586997986,
0.26842284202575684,
-0.5236973166465759,
0.9332701563835144,
0.5045713782310486,
0.4548710584640503,
0.367343008518219,
0.4707222580909729,
-0.31095409393310547,
-0.3220193088054657,
-0.3649938106536865,
-0.20472955703735352,
0.6383455395698547,
0.3748266398906708,
-0.27052852511405945,
-0.7238356471061707,
-0.5300529599189758,
0.18204998970031738,
0.3541957437992096,
-0.3934652507305145,
0.9603990912437439,
0.21504224836826324,
-0.7376226782798767,
0.571957528591156,
0.24892333149909973,
0.1611371636390686,
-0.4683375656604767,
-0.1253909319639206,
-0.22821292281150818,
0.29287636280059814,
-0.7150814533233643,
-0.6903753876686096,
0.5411429405212402,
-0.08881829679012299,
-0.3705272674560547,
-0.23237527906894684,
0.9124800562858582,
-0.14102545380592346,
-0.5286998748779297,
0.17177851498126984,
0.22981971502304077,
-0.19692562520503998,
-0.07876214385032654,
-0.4927191734313965,
0.18788820505142212,
-0.08256788551807404,
-0.4653315842151642,
0.21067523956298828,
0.6048118472099304,
0.035380858927965164,
0.4752022922039032,
0.583760678768158,
-0.06593135744333267,
-0.14140333235263824,
-0.2411135733127594,
0.8067772388458252,
-0.6273956894874573,
-0.38165366649627686,
-1.0877922773361206,
0.5454970598220825,
-0.03625766560435295,
0.11437971889972687,
1.1615955829620361,
0.802341639995575,
0.5659316778182983,
0.16677811741828918,
0.9941785931587219,
-0.08143274486064911,
0.5610586404800415,
-0.8539613485336304,
0.5179004669189453,
-0.40776124596595764,
0.23839721083641052,
-0.3539479374885559,
-1.0588334798812866,
-0.48960021138191223,
0.31875672936439514,
-0.18121840059757233,
-0.1958431601524353,
0.787700891494751,
0.5102119445800781,
-0.11329397559165955,
-0.158965602517128,
-0.08579440414905548,
0.08363359421491623,
0.41718509793281555,
0.3728611171245575,
1.0962321758270264,
-0.38153335452079773,
0.43762925267219543,
0.003303017932921648,
-0.3562234044075012,
-0.03035692870616913,
-1.2457681894302368,
-0.4523346722126007,
-0.3858860433101654,
-0.8487840294837952,
-0.6191803216934204,
-0.49794089794158936,
0.5775259733200073,
0.37871551513671875,
-0.5476001501083374,
-0.03257070481777191,
0.2155107855796814,
0.18658585846424103,
-0.30609801411628723,
-0.22650064527988434,
0.5834968090057373,
-0.3591216504573822,
-0.2076943963766098,
0.44435858726501465,
0.309505820274353,
-0.44323331117630005,
-0.18090671300888062,
0.12347090244293213,
0.15557648241519928,
0.16755156219005585,
0.964414656162262,
-0.04321293532848358,
-0.3804354667663574,
-0.5115421414375305,
-0.1639571636915207,
0.1117110401391983,
0.15071043372154236,
1.1355146169662476,
-0.8973873853683472,
0.44312673807144165,
0.8618273735046387,
0.8438182473182678,
0.4101520776748657,
0.37192630767822266,
0.584907054901123,
-0.7691190242767334,
-0.15908613801002502,
0.23458759486675262,
0.2432284653186798,
0.2812046408653259,
-0.403643935918808,
0.35643503069877625,
0.48799076676368713,
-0.06251451373100281,
-0.8357661366462708,
0.6240981817245483,
-0.864772379398346,
-0.4867466986179352,
1.1402980089187622,
-0.12260879576206207,
-0.5348328351974487,
0.23060496151447296,
-0.18774200975894928,
0.07460962980985641,
0.08875804394483566,
0.6470032334327698,
0.8043984174728394,
-0.46200013160705566,
-0.09058497101068497,
-0.19450366497039795,
0.46734222769737244,
0.2762784957885742,
-0.5759332776069641,
0.4305981695652008,
0.8630647659301758,
0.6435348987579346,
0.5228865146636963,
0.7358797192573547,
-0.3416830599308014,
-0.04372265934944153,
0.18661680817604065,
-0.03328520432114601,
-0.06852827966213226,
-0.11091520637273788,
0.042839691042900085,
0.48164981603622437,
0.3352515399456024,
-0.11583779007196426
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11896v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11896v2
|
Investigating Markers and Drivers of Gender Bias in Machine Translations
| 2024-03-18T15:54:46 | 2024-04-02T10:07:39 |
Peter J Barclay, Ashkan Sami
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.SE
|
Implicit gender bias in Large Language Models (LLMs) is a well-documented
problem, and implications of gender introduced into automatic translations can
perpetuate real-world biases. However, some LLMs use heuristics or
post-processing to mask such bias, making investigation difficult. Here, we
examine bias in LLMss via back-translation, using the DeepL translation API to
investigate the bias evinced when repeatedly translating a set of 56 Software
Engineering tasks used in a previous study. Each statement starts with 'she',
and is translated first into a 'genderless' intermediate language then back
into English; we then examine pronoun-choice in the back-translated texts. We
expand prior research in the following ways: (1) by comparing results across
five intermediate languages, namely Finnish, Indonesian, Estonian, Turkish and
Hungarian; (2) by proposing a novel metric for assessing the variation in
gender implied in the repeated translations, avoiding the over-interpretation
of individual pronouns, apparent in earlier work; (3) by investigating sentence
features that drive bias; (4) and by comparing results from three time-lapsed
datasets to establish the reproducibility of the approach. We found that some
languages display similar patterns of pronoun use, falling into three loose
groups, but that patterns vary between groups; this underlines the need to work
with multiple languages. We also identify the main verb appearing in a sentence
as a likely significant driver of implied gender in the translations. Moreover,
we see a good level of replicability in the results, and establish that our
variation metric proves robust despite an obvious change in the behaviour of
the DeepL translation API during the course of the study. These results show
that the back-translation method can provide further insights into bias in
language models.
|
[
-0.15643064677715302,
-0.43106916546821594,
0.6321974396705627,
0.35261136293411255,
0.06468121707439423,
0.05116060748696327,
-0.13131758570671082,
-0.3973968029022217,
-0.4000629484653473,
0.5777361989021301,
-0.9074254631996155,
-0.521314263343811,
-0.8227753043174744,
0.4559297263622284,
-0.5867818593978882,
0.9878416657447815,
-0.5121227502822876,
0.49264833331108093,
0.09670532494783401,
-0.15372830629348755,
-0.8239330649375916,
-0.5258607864379883,
-0.07602191716432571,
-0.448121577501297,
0.33361032605171204,
0.12599192559719086,
0.7644462585449219,
0.4715566635131836,
0.2955021858215332,
0.19127900898456573,
-0.30108803510665894,
0.061205729842185974,
-0.1843082308769226,
0.23229257762432098,
-0.10951921343803406,
-0.8047466278076172,
-0.3663208782672882,
0.35358926653862,
0.7459568381309509,
0.8828573226928711,
0.35021454095840454,
0.502448320388794,
0.2548106908798218,
0.7406216263771057,
-0.6737930774688721,
0.16922271251678467,
-0.492218941450119,
0.30431726574897766,
-0.29356446862220764,
0.049002982676029205,
-0.3298262655735016,
-0.1640680581331253,
0.022323492914438248,
-0.23813074827194214,
0.49425044655799866,
0.08472539484500885,
0.7102618217468262,
0.36314186453819275,
-0.6166576147079468,
-0.28372570872306824,
-0.7726295590400696,
1.0011534690856934,
-0.6139535903930664,
0.7399108409881592,
0.19389906525611877,
0.12872353196144104,
-0.33419811725616455,
-0.02933201566338539,
-0.41704460978507996,
-0.31540340185165405,
-0.21125414967536926,
-0.04769495874643326,
-0.025986457243561745,
-0.3265223503112793,
0.41124865412712097,
0.1861005425453186,
-0.3173048794269562,
0.2353920191526413,
-0.3104555606842041,
-0.0866646096110344,
0.6382418870925903,
0.03474551439285278,
0.5260023474693298,
0.04312298819422722,
0.036407459527254105,
0.020625879988074303,
-1.0063683986663818,
-0.11637093126773834,
0.7217909693717957,
0.3627365529537201,
-0.038126274943351746,
0.832114577293396,
0.06399983167648315,
0.2802087068557739,
0.06190982460975647,
0.16568422317504883,
0.5423030853271484,
-0.44332292675971985,
0.05573561042547226,
0.13280852138996124,
0.7535234689712524,
0.21398790180683136,
0.45825228095054626,
0.09419955313205719,
-0.22126911580562592,
-0.11185666918754578,
0.15022192895412445,
-0.45306214690208435,
0.26245108246803284,
0.10372340679168701,
-0.5160971879959106,
-0.188382089138031,
-0.14450493454933167,
-0.47877079248428345,
-0.32235899567604065,
-0.23449908196926117,
-0.09291567653417587,
0.08444104343652725,
-0.3271946310997009,
0.023757997900247574,
-0.08722099661827087,
0.17282921075820923,
0.18046391010284424,
-0.6199405193328857,
0.04985150694847107,
0.799343466758728,
0.7034686803817749,
-0.18444284796714783,
-0.5231940746307373,
-0.37342020869255066,
0.049106664955616,
-0.8535083532333374,
0.2898435592651367,
-0.42423564195632935,
-0.39065876603126526,
0.1707560122013092,
0.11788298934698105,
0.09336870908737183,
-0.5338808298110962,
0.4200260639190674,
-0.17240922152996063,
0.5772790312767029,
-0.3939419984817505,
-0.39049458503723145,
-0.05081519857048988,
0.03619876503944397,
-0.5821303725242615,
1.1800185441970825,
-0.2866763174533844,
-0.7485014200210571,
0.7655034065246582,
-0.25766223669052124,
-0.3367168605327606,
-0.3357878625392914,
-0.6884065270423889,
-0.5185385942459106,
0.3624647557735443,
0.2794741988182068,
0.37273892760276794,
-0.4339461922645569,
0.4888926148414612,
-0.07106583565473557,
-0.3444281220436096,
0.47485098242759705,
-0.3300322890281677,
0.6785115003585815,
-0.18887941539287567,
-0.6637820601463318,
0.15850472450256348,
-0.20763415098190308,
-0.6349321603775024,
0.008845608681440353,
-0.11307698488235474,
-0.32530394196510315,
0.12439661473035812,
-0.2121957391500473,
0.535622775554657,
0.13173145055770874,
-0.5497538447380066,
0.08085203915834427,
-0.28818801045417786,
0.25546795129776,
0.7907418608665466,
-0.49254223704338074,
0.6754404306411743,
0.04897002503275871,
0.49447721242904663,
0.11127134412527084,
0.16393516957759857,
-0.057803668081760406,
-0.7670184373855591,
-0.6341406106948853,
-0.1864127665758133,
0.1552785038948059,
0.576919436454773,
-0.3200223743915558,
0.29659929871559143,
-0.21139264106750488,
0.07320564240217209,
-0.9858244061470032,
0.3631105422973633,
0.6066457033157349,
0.21661245822906494,
0.2546854615211487,
-0.03790584206581116,
-0.44002896547317505,
-1.3532260656356812,
-0.7222033739089966,
-0.23768943548202515,
-0.08331651240587234,
0.2966431677341461,
0.7944177985191345,
-0.4195447266101837,
0.7919158339500427,
-0.4450666010379791,
-0.4896013140678406,
-0.20139920711517334,
0.29695969820022583,
0.33559393882751465,
0.495895653963089,
0.44761425256729126,
-0.6638926267623901,
-0.17916136980056763,
-0.01123951468616724,
-0.7448028326034546,
-0.44681334495544434,
-0.13298262655735016,
-0.45253828167915344,
0.4039553701877594,
0.6295934915542603,
-0.5877191424369812,
0.4947281777858734,
0.633059024810791,
-0.4128075838088989,
0.5373167991638184,
-0.03389044478535652,
0.06934963911771774,
-0.7299281358718872,
0.03584561124444008,
0.01241344679147005,
-0.16505594551563263,
-0.28773555159568787,
0.13589805364608765,
-0.04624802619218826,
0.21834485232830048,
-0.4259459972381592,
0.6441663503646851,
-0.7372303605079651,
-0.5690005421638489,
-0.23930810391902924,
-0.049536190927028656,
-0.1906004697084427,
0.17193853855133057,
-0.09985043853521347,
0.9873431921005249,
-0.014432547613978386,
-0.3132707476615906,
-0.056851327419281006,
0.2625601291656494,
0.026828186586499214,
0.3439493775367737,
-0.5067098736763,
0.2908382713794708,
-0.3027334213256836,
0.3213382959365845,
-1.187868595123291,
0.18574462831020355,
0.5175291299819946,
-0.4670529067516327,
0.2274460643529892,
-0.3257944583892822,
-0.5653091073036194,
-0.38191255927085876,
-0.20157460868358612,
0.28035756945610046,
0.4554613530635834,
-0.24473652243614197,
0.49902939796447754,
0.15118564665317535,
-0.16081605851650238,
-0.7765246033668518,
-0.9198791980743408,
0.14108610153198242,
0.053321655839681625,
-0.3733742833137512,
0.13520050048828125,
-0.026940926909446716,
-0.4144227206707001,
-0.15773841738700867,
-0.24636928737163544,
0.005224992986768484,
0.23130424320697784,
0.2594151496887207,
0.22422906756401062,
-0.1465701013803482,
-0.02816161699593067,
0.3081679046154022,
-0.08541926741600037,
0.2061561644077301,
-0.4147582948207855,
0.4386599361896515,
-0.11064226180315018,
-0.2964724004268646,
-0.34397006034851074,
0.5993914008140564,
0.48430517315864563,
0.04279375076293945,
0.7370162010192871,
0.6992173194885254,
-0.2812589704990387,
0.0485076867043972,
-0.6549450159072876,
-0.2178204357624054,
-0.3710235357284546,
0.39550918340682983,
-0.6219123005867004,
-0.8407861590385437,
0.6288366317749023,
0.06602691113948822,
0.3528193235397339,
0.5312561392784119,
0.6073271036148071,
-0.2500634789466858,
1.433063268661499,
0.5306767821311951,
-0.16284304857254028,
0.32962334156036377,
-0.003532140515744686,
-0.04573376104235649,
-0.8706210851669312,
0.04450787603855133,
-0.7370539307594299,
-0.4024917185306549,
-0.9693708419799805,
-0.33003532886505127,
0.0848412811756134,
-0.06267297267913818,
-0.311809778213501,
-0.022194236516952515,
-0.2576374113559723,
0.2609090805053711,
0.48538434505462646,
-0.07316549867391586,
0.29751384258270264,
-0.09041693806648254,
-0.04636155441403389,
-0.5108509063720703,
-0.45314258337020874,
-0.6544557809829712,
1.100963830947876,
0.4660024046897888,
0.45840924978256226,
0.07960149645805359,
0.48556044697761536,
0.4666362702846527,
0.3553447425365448,
-0.24522556364536285,
0.6013185977935791,
-0.4521872103214264,
-0.9054399728775024,
-0.046222299337387085,
-0.4041558802127838,
-0.9568403363227844,
0.3204282820224762,
-0.14188918471336365,
-0.5000872015953064,
0.23466186225414276,
0.17772845923900604,
0.30610257387161255,
0.017338566482067108,
-0.35317525267601013,
0.73739093542099,
-0.38700923323631287,
-0.5067129135131836,
-0.0608835332095623,
-0.5469433069229126,
0.4506016671657562,
-0.07790190726518631,
0.3371654152870178,
-0.24201087653636932,
-0.16532611846923828,
0.5538281202316284,
-0.0761188492178917,
1.0126774311065674,
-0.0225937869399786,
-0.7425320744514465,
-0.26712435483932495,
0.26171380281448364,
0.5090069770812988,
-0.05314239487051964,
0.023791272193193436,
0.5830154418945312,
-0.3677692711353302,
-0.4818263351917267,
-0.3027958273887634,
0.4273548722267151,
-0.9663214683532715,
-0.7804258465766907,
-0.49984580278396606,
-0.5939833521842957,
0.05351012200117111,
0.2711015045642853,
0.29237034916877747,
-0.14667780697345734,
-0.07725521177053452,
-0.17652373015880585,
0.5550796389579773,
-0.500144898891449,
0.03463241457939148,
0.45201990008354187,
-0.49009475111961365,
0.16700536012649536,
0.4471837282180786,
0.24298617243766785,
0.157175213098526,
0.259926438331604,
0.20302453637123108,
-0.13859789073467255,
-0.35287582874298096,
-0.8345996141433716,
0.2882508337497711,
-0.5039286613464355,
0.3437093496322632,
-0.6579897403717041,
0.054268840700387955,
-0.4762343764305115,
-0.11087990552186966,
-0.7095708250999451,
-0.14523230493068695,
-0.20158277451992035,
-0.0749446451663971,
0.03314530476927757,
0.6019447445869446,
0.35600489377975464,
0.24164530634880066,
-0.460131973028183,
0.37565499544143677,
0.01610712707042694,
-0.09410755336284637,
-0.36191967129707336,
-0.5039458870887756,
0.06964059174060822,
0.05965292081236839,
0.1465204358100891,
-1.234567642211914,
0.45372602343559265,
-0.1195993721485138,
0.6759334206581116,
-0.2200905978679657,
-0.4056183993816376,
0.2975998520851135,
-0.6081212162971497,
0.8923729658126831,
-0.0902027040719986,
-1.0749263763427734,
0.5938928723335266,
-0.4677518904209137,
0.4046977758407593,
0.3766815960407257,
0.30191007256507874,
-0.5550413131713867,
-0.6288362145423889,
-0.3087010085582733,
-0.9340530633926392,
0.5253336429595947,
0.3672846853733063,
0.14591720700263977,
0.14526039361953735,
0.5803502202033997,
0.43595126271247864,
0.6974442005157471,
-0.6241857409477234,
-0.435031533241272,
0.2825835347175598,
-0.12288736552000046,
-0.09225501120090485,
-0.3625069558620453,
-0.009646772406995296,
-0.021703140810132027,
0.619405210018158,
-0.23492459952831268,
0.36056017875671387,
0.055118314921855927,
-0.5977696180343628,
0.011761466972529888,
0.40077999234199524,
0.6456223130226135,
0.584869384765625,
-0.13970685005187988,
0.0767047107219696,
0.27085399627685547,
-0.4949674904346466,
0.23200394213199615,
0.023003332316875458,
-0.7087424993515015,
0.3435553312301636,
0.3830782473087311,
0.6691319346427917,
-0.05208194628357887,
-0.3425378203392029,
0.47259119153022766,
0.035034678876399994,
0.09618843346834183,
-0.47265806794166565,
-0.2944934070110321,
-0.21820548176765442,
0.36021289229393005,
0.4889228343963623,
-0.034736182540655136,
0.3122117817401886,
-0.5236545205116272,
-0.19238758087158203,
0.2983705699443817,
-0.5690494775772095,
-0.4332513213157654,
0.6590514183044434,
0.2456904947757721,
-0.2499726265668869,
0.5279770493507385,
-0.024660613387823105,
-0.684429943561554,
0.4956011176109314,
0.293641597032547,
1.3455196619033813,
-0.307534784078598,
0.08955242484807968,
0.052894145250320435,
0.7999454140663147,
-0.2912260591983795,
0.5337777137756348,
0.26525571942329407,
-0.676323652267456,
-0.6809259057044983,
-0.03656084090471268,
-0.13149380683898926,
-0.14668886363506317,
-0.5162431597709656,
0.29577434062957764,
0.03142885863780975,
-0.2602350115776062,
-0.22415213286876678,
-0.32299119234085083,
-0.9140411019325256,
-0.07575302571058273,
0.41940364241600037,
0.5290653705596924,
-1.1362104415893555,
0.4491804242134094,
0.7643850445747375,
-0.43894726037979126,
-0.15356500446796417,
0.20088618993759155,
0.26825693249702454,
-0.6697026491165161,
1.2582582235336304,
0.10989250242710114,
-0.24492302536964417,
-0.37995487451553345,
-0.4852627217769623,
-0.5957513451576233,
0.7021422386169434,
0.5213121175765991,
-0.8680801391601562,
-0.024634243920445442,
0.525095522403717,
0.38850927352905273,
-0.3592034876346588,
0.39194977283477783,
0.6826213002204895,
0.4123534858226776,
-0.6672020554542542,
-1.1927977800369263,
0.22597864270210266,
-0.12939004600048065,
0.20093536376953125,
0.27729713916778564,
-0.4773668348789215,
0.9814829230308533,
0.035862214863300323,
0.08986218273639679,
-0.2505491375923157,
0.649735152721405,
0.3168732821941376,
0.27617889642715454,
0.4411298632621765,
-0.058552615344524384,
0.7182738184928894,
-0.07211954146623611,
0.9270014762878418,
-0.06286406517028809,
0.0735073834657669,
1.2080285549163818,
-0.5009754300117493,
0.5272102355957031,
0.7354703545570374,
-0.14339469373226166,
0.42476192116737366,
0.3110254108905792,
0.14037513732910156,
0.0987875759601593,
0.36235976219177246,
0.011641878634691238,
-0.10192891210317612,
-0.2545625865459442,
-0.4872235357761383,
0.22280992567539215,
0.3063208758831024,
-0.800201416015625,
0.15662015974521637,
0.13533787429332733,
0.44508984684944153,
-0.004338743630796671,
-0.07462681084871292,
0.46444493532180786,
0.271962434053421,
-0.5809689164161682,
0.25184014439582825,
0.08265803009271622,
0.7811065316200256,
-0.2871992290019989,
-0.05052975192666054,
-0.5410442352294922,
0.30652904510498047,
-0.1026381403207779,
-0.9234834909439087,
0.18636159598827362,
0.06837204843759537,
-0.3664698004722595,
-0.630405068397522,
0.623614490032196,
-0.4637394845485687,
-0.6536011099815369,
0.3478083908557892,
0.865553081035614,
0.21072432398796082,
-0.13137277960777283,
-0.6681016683578491,
0.21659594774246216,
0.03590771555900574,
-0.2099096179008484,
0.18310675024986267,
0.3137193024158478,
-0.48173707723617554,
0.7398039102554321,
0.46089354157447815,
0.18765698373317719,
0.36391639709472656,
0.1681222915649414,
0.39752405881881714,
-0.6598187685012817,
-0.35584038496017456,
-1.0910698175430298,
0.25231051445007324,
0.0601557120680809,
-0.502866804599762,
1.0202372074127197,
0.6740183234214783,
0.8783714175224304,
0.015844518318772316,
0.8271787166595459,
0.5707644820213318,
0.30557572841644287,
-0.5382982492446899,
0.5215935707092285,
-0.39078202843666077,
0.3978506624698639,
-0.5340849757194519,
-0.9463953375816345,
-0.21419529616832733,
0.4923264682292938,
-0.5400812029838562,
0.05004807189106941,
0.49698004126548767,
0.4208598732948303,
0.1012444943189621,
-0.025536874309182167,
-0.07461151480674744,
0.3507692813873291,
0.35825422406196594,
0.3447439968585968,
1.0699878931045532,
-0.6033501625061035,
0.49270763993263245,
0.062263477593660355,
-0.005228876601904631,
-0.24883730709552765,
-0.8300669193267822,
-0.8710166811943054,
-0.28213411569595337,
-0.6519755125045776,
-0.500623881816864,
0.5464814305305481,
0.8536322116851807,
0.6396793723106384,
-0.6293689012527466,
-0.45276546478271484,
-0.11246641725301743,
0.2744283974170685,
-0.3564244210720062,
-0.08262711018323898,
0.190310537815094,
-0.22260577976703644,
-0.8847327828407288,
0.16305513679981232,
-0.06696278601884842,
-0.18112275004386902,
-0.6560834646224976,
-0.041576087474823,
-0.20421019196510315,
-0.24848203361034393,
0.4619009792804718,
-0.12017925083637238,
-0.904296875,
-0.1907346546649933,
0.22876176238059998,
-0.2480284422636032,
-0.13947470486164093,
0.8889186978340149,
-0.5804771184921265,
0.21414601802825928,
0.6423318386077881,
0.548995852470398,
0.578342080116272,
-0.43874651193618774,
1.1118555068969727,
-1.0733436346054077,
0.1681699901819229,
0.03185044229030609,
0.3486535847187042,
0.40470150113105774,
-0.4171305298805237,
0.5725920796394348,
0.3835008442401886,
-0.3201938271522522,
-0.9668906927108765,
0.24948900938034058,
-0.16637785732746124,
-0.5134618878364563,
1.4800344705581665,
0.08612630516290665,
-0.16100695729255676,
-0.22981084883213043,
-0.4054858386516571,
0.3954617977142334,
-0.3966395854949951,
0.5284678936004639,
0.8598703742027283,
0.19271448254585266,
-0.19051940739154816,
-1.1122652292251587,
0.3401451110839844,
0.7648280262947083,
-0.38502228260040283,
0.03413941338658333,
0.5040221214294434,
0.29064276814460754,
0.12565620243549347,
0.4495636224746704,
-0.059540409594774246,
0.1253098100423813,
-0.21895553171634674,
0.27425771951675415,
0.3124753534793854,
-0.2135021984577179,
-0.3360864520072937,
-0.2884983420372009,
0.038307107985019684,
-0.20845691859722137
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11894v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11894v3
|
From Explainable to Interpretable Deep Learning for Natural Language Processing in Healthcare: How Far from Reality?
| 2024-03-18T15:53:33 | 2024-05-09T19:36:59 |
Guangming Huang, Yingya Li, Shoaib Jameel, Yunfei Long, Giorgos Papanastasiou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Deep learning (DL) has substantially enhanced natural language processing
(NLP) in healthcare research. However, the increasing complexity of DL-based
NLP necessitates transparent model interpretability, or at least
explainability, for reliable decision-making. This work presents a thorough
scoping review of explainable and interpretable DL in healthcare NLP. The term
"eXplainable and Interpretable Artificial Intelligence" (XIAI) is introduced to
distinguish XAI from IAI. Different models are further categorized based on
their functionality (model-, input-, output-based) and scope (local, global).
Our analysis shows that attention mechanisms are the most prevalent emerging
IAI technique. The use of IAI is growing, distinguishing it from XAI. The major
challenges identified are that most XIAI does not explore "global" modelling
processes, the lack of best practices, and the lack of systematic evaluation
and benchmarks. One important opportunity is to use attention mechanisms to
enhance multi-modal XIAI for personalized medicine. Additionally, combining DL
with causal logic holds promise. Our discussion encourages the integration of
XIAI in Large Language Models (LLMs) and domain-specific smaller models. In
conclusion, XIAI adoption in healthcare requires dedicated in-house expertise.
Collaboration with domain experts, end-users, and policymakers can lead to
ready-to-use XIAI methods across NLP and medical tasks. While challenges exist,
XIAI techniques offer a valuable foundation for interpretable NLP algorithms in
healthcare.
|
[
-0.04178834334015846,
-0.36840584874153137,
0.8066949844360352,
0.20360468327999115,
-0.04439123719930649,
-0.19547292590141296,
-0.21403899788856506,
-0.8828182220458984,
-0.07825779914855957,
0.393754243850708,
-0.6574804186820984,
-0.07330956310033798,
-0.7594830393791199,
-0.03831096366047859,
-0.35462912917137146,
1.0335019826889038,
-0.012420880608260632,
0.179262176156044,
-0.1306460052728653,
-0.554471492767334,
-0.2580122947692871,
-0.3615078330039978,
-0.938232421875,
-0.6652847528457642,
0.6203465461730957,
0.21683290600776672,
0.7133026719093323,
0.7576073408126831,
0.6653944849967957,
0.27312034368515015,
-0.1535775363445282,
0.026659881696105003,
-0.061422139406204224,
0.047080181539058685,
0.0172345582395792,
-0.4411673843860626,
-0.6118979454040527,
-0.1771669089794159,
0.618571937084198,
1.0536832809448242,
-0.006339677609503269,
-0.23578080534934998,
0.06456848233938217,
0.8393465876579285,
-0.38906562328338623,
0.26330268383026123,
-0.23746691644191742,
0.3125872015953064,
0.14378777146339417,
-0.05174152925610542,
-0.11571913957595825,
0.007194255478680134,
0.8102513551712036,
-0.5224958658218384,
-0.03775840625166893,
-0.13960708677768707,
0.5733101963996887,
0.5305063724517822,
-0.35003164410591125,
-0.5203486680984497,
-0.8594304919242859,
0.6883228421211243,
-1.071374535560608,
0.4402649998664856,
0.2610590159893036,
0.41687002778053284,
0.23544198274612427,
-1.0214567184448242,
-0.4785701632499695,
-0.2883022427558899,
-0.3312799632549286,
0.2001180201768875,
-0.39254242181777954,
0.2858451306819916,
0.21871748566627502,
0.6064404845237732,
-0.45873862504959106,
0.3812049627304077,
-0.1601928472518921,
0.38060128688812256,
0.5735477209091187,
0.17241932451725006,
0.40654852986335754,
-0.03600354492664337,
-0.18371041119098663,
0.47992628812789917,
-0.37985843420028687,
0.1269693523645401,
-0.23773890733718872,
0.11591675132513046,
-0.20584990084171295,
0.16437600553035736,
-0.4020048677921295,
0.42164409160614014,
-0.0247219055891037,
-0.06580883264541626,
0.19829413294792175,
-0.4007766544818878,
-0.6166960597038269,
0.16699227690696716,
0.5819248557090759,
0.10382242500782013,
0.018260303884744644,
-0.38269078731536865,
0.020361728966236115,
-0.039067499339580536,
0.6316766142845154,
-0.5647925138473511,
-0.12097901105880737,
0.6411876678466797,
-0.7457947731018066,
-0.4306120276451111,
-0.19413936138153076,
-0.25947391986846924,
-0.4460737705230713,
-0.5430960655212402,
-0.012641115114092827,
-0.30851003527641296,
-0.24928529560565948,
0.19649934768676758,
0.21470028162002563,
0.28383195400238037,
0.14899390935897827,
-0.8025362491607666,
0.3913455605506897,
0.8132815957069397,
0.7419043779373169,
-0.2723231911659241,
-0.13836410641670227,
-0.24944502115249634,
-0.0008476990624330938,
-0.13330216705799103,
0.4497127830982208,
-0.3478493094444275,
0.037100616842508316,
0.08408112078905106,
0.040599919855594635,
-0.11454037576913834,
-0.44451904296875,
0.6548708081245422,
-0.28527066111564636,
0.1416083425283432,
0.022077102214097977,
-0.5191769599914551,
-0.25906848907470703,
0.2685573399066925,
-0.6427878737449646,
0.02485828660428524,
0.164033904671669,
-0.6501476168632507,
0.4996962547302246,
-1.024694800376892,
-0.6596377491950989,
0.21799197793006897,
-0.11378829181194305,
-0.48430970311164856,
0.2682706117630005,
0.39507606625556946,
0.6239805817604065,
-0.26661330461502075,
0.5838059782981873,
-0.1948641538619995,
-0.14300194382667542,
0.24104714393615723,
-0.6440867781639099,
0.8872025609016418,
0.26490604877471924,
-0.6517366170883179,
0.4942740201950073,
-0.9997973442077637,
-0.019802456721663475,
-0.07846875488758087,
-0.035164739936590195,
-0.04128124937415123,
0.06618405878543854,
-0.044907622039318085,
0.17159761488437653,
-0.12846262753009796,
-0.017533738166093826,
-0.20570607483386993,
-0.995613157749176,
0.9202297329902649,
0.5081718564033508,
-0.1270865797996521,
0.5780965089797974,
-0.29843878746032715,
0.44156450033187866,
-0.10835716873407364,
0.5102806091308594,
-0.27640455961227417,
-0.5644577741622925,
-0.6065880656242371,
-0.16988521814346313,
0.04874386638402939,
0.433891236782074,
-0.47607865929603577,
0.08886808156967163,
-0.15689601004123688,
-0.3419087529182434,
-0.9568571448326111,
-0.27171599864959717,
0.3980250358581543,
0.8819531798362732,
0.3197159469127655,
-0.03987117484211922,
-0.386013925075531,
-1.0259240865707397,
-0.32254597544670105,
-0.2011442631483078,
0.04474329575896263,
0.5516130924224854,
0.3048228919506073,
-0.7121863961219788,
0.45480889081954956,
-0.1731775552034378,
-0.5149645805358887,
-0.4998849928379059,
0.1309615969657898,
0.2572632431983948,
0.343534380197525,
0.24807108938694,
-0.9154254198074341,
-0.21769431233406067,
0.40097036957740784,
-1.0751863718032837,
-0.02585642971098423,
-0.5074917078018188,
0.3208532929420471,
0.11106164008378983,
0.36713746190071106,
-0.45880958437919617,
0.7101969122886658,
0.35645338892936707,
-0.11551805585622787,
0.29744863510131836,
-0.40430179238319397,
0.009240802377462387,
-0.7739012837409973,
0.370307981967926,
0.06546026468276978,
-0.20597544312477112,
-0.9669157862663269,
0.497387170791626,
-0.11291428655385971,
0.00485407467931509,
-0.36302489042282104,
0.7403680086135864,
-0.2963447570800781,
0.08874522149562836,
-0.45448464155197144,
-0.09703987836837769,
0.16179513931274414,
0.20533353090286255,
-0.011931555345654488,
0.2460954189300537,
0.6193704605102539,
-0.6823970079421997,
0.3228682577610016,
0.20440760254859924,
-0.41301605105400085,
0.42822209000587463,
-0.9272902607917786,
-0.14364531636238098,
-0.08803185820579529,
0.06412511318922043,
-0.5339009165763855,
-0.35282203555107117,
0.5601552724838257,
-0.356568843126297,
0.2604047358036041,
0.27130383253097534,
0.10605181753635406,
-0.19860030710697174,
0.02228102646768093,
0.5068827271461487,
0.2529805302619934,
-0.44898077845573425,
0.45099571347236633,
0.40521907806396484,
-0.1559978425502777,
-0.5442975759506226,
-0.8166245222091675,
0.3706757128238678,
-0.1580473929643631,
-0.4255130887031555,
0.48818135261535645,
-0.011068114079535007,
-0.6022743582725525,
0.19318974018096924,
-0.20858947932720184,
-0.3660605847835541,
0.332871675491333,
0.39765673875808716,
-0.040192846208810806,
-0.37236541509628296,
0.23428061604499817,
0.13116155564785004,
-0.4104233384132385,
0.4135954976081848,
-0.37854844331741333,
-0.05357182398438454,
-0.1831294596195221,
-0.2726920545101166,
-0.9091737270355225,
0.7565611600875854,
0.6561414003372192,
-0.18892797827720642,
0.623421847820282,
0.580930769443512,
-0.6168736219406128,
0.011953499168157578,
-0.2022780179977417,
-0.14741089940071106,
-0.3197365701198578,
0.37028688192367554,
-0.057208724319934845,
-0.7850111722946167,
0.3637745976448059,
0.07834417372941971,
0.3224349021911621,
0.39288532733917236,
0.6451773047447205,
-0.234490305185318,
1.2787803411483765,
0.9263218641281128,
-0.06824879348278046,
0.1740867644548416,
-0.26093530654907227,
0.5267678499221802,
-0.685003936290741,
-0.2998444437980652,
-0.3439185917377472,
-0.2424807995557785,
-0.6104010939598083,
-0.010628221556544304,
0.29575636982917786,
-0.3810082674026489,
-0.0033402880653738976,
-0.11998114734888077,
-0.5846234560012817,
-0.009120998904109001,
0.5924496054649353,
0.26161518692970276,
0.29781630635261536,
-0.4017769992351532,
0.2836565375328064,
0.030611371621489525,
-0.6547999978065491,
-0.15887613594532013,
0.7839037179946899,
0.6697031855583191,
0.4936148226261139,
-0.13595548272132874,
0.433697372674942,
0.21409189701080322,
0.21138371527194977,
-0.9984047412872314,
-0.00534411845728755,
-0.18676979839801788,
-0.40494275093078613,
-0.40098702907562256,
-0.24489142000675201,
-0.9348101019859314,
-0.05837784707546234,
-0.20423351228237152,
-0.4613097310066223,
0.2614970803260803,
0.15634064376354218,
-0.7055840492248535,
0.18412062525749207,
-0.7410950064659119,
0.8712350130081177,
-0.34599971771240234,
-0.01510349940508604,
-0.2205309420824051,
-0.9656339883804321,
0.29329416155815125,
0.0753653272986412,
0.25006332993507385,
0.13551247119903564,
0.07812150567770004,
0.4673234522342682,
-0.16272732615470886,
0.72870934009552,
0.12836351990699768,
-0.07563846558332443,
-0.19066543877124786,
-0.4813794493675232,
0.08824020624160767,
0.2799682021141052,
-0.10770780593156815,
0.36467933654785156,
0.0018719988875091076,
-0.31173789501190186,
-0.9610585570335388,
0.7013473510742188,
-0.7096776962280273,
-0.6958584785461426,
-0.4813438355922699,
-0.5450770854949951,
-0.18752917647361755,
0.27721288800239563,
0.25338029861450195,
0.45544031262397766,
-0.10188981890678406,
-0.037457313388586044,
0.686439037322998,
-0.19508741796016693,
0.17839893698692322,
0.18587668240070343,
0.1187407448887825,
0.01988447830080986,
0.9848790764808655,
0.21393798291683197,
-0.027086425572633743,
0.4357664883136749,
0.4758516848087311,
-0.024292027577757835,
-0.9653162360191345,
-0.27381977438926697,
0.10491999983787537,
-0.6213775873184204,
0.223471000790596,
-0.8291167616844177,
-0.7016094326972961,
-0.4414467513561249,
-0.18730585277080536,
-0.005701076705008745,
-0.12772445380687714,
-0.5770760774612427,
-0.025154786184430122,
-0.22925899922847748,
0.8728502988815308,
0.0510064959526062,
0.32416796684265137,
-0.6081374287605286,
0.6060219407081604,
0.32361605763435364,
0.523686408996582,
0.2148442566394806,
-0.38783374428749084,
-0.32810714840888977,
0.026849491521716118,
0.33136671781539917,
-0.7687227725982666,
0.4432846009731293,
0.21950402855873108,
0.6852380037307739,
0.9017871022224426,
0.041899386793375015,
0.5401045680046082,
-0.49109527468681335,
0.5191486477851868,
0.08679031580686569,
-0.7790156602859497,
0.6042906045913696,
0.018331272527575493,
0.47676917910575867,
0.497974157333374,
0.519176721572876,
-0.582054615020752,
-0.26039227843284607,
-0.5855082869529724,
-1.127082109451294,
0.7054570317268372,
0.04156586900353432,
0.0278051495552063,
0.1252620965242386,
0.5841924548149109,
0.3780854642391205,
0.11775893718004227,
-0.7091220021247864,
-0.35134702920913696,
0.034506797790527344,
-0.216773122549057,
-0.03937629610300064,
-0.3225598931312561,
-0.2582300007343292,
-0.17210756242275238,
0.5804643630981445,
-0.34116536378860474,
0.4205576479434967,
0.4124085307121277,
-0.08525604009628296,
-0.04605325311422348,
0.3413917124271393,
0.49862197041511536,
0.893958568572998,
-0.09530597180128098,
-0.005108012817800045,
-0.17130447924137115,
-0.3174643814563751,
-0.27281326055526733,
0.16755442321300507,
-0.20518556237220764,
-0.06583300977945328,
0.7356666922569275,
0.9816476106643677,
0.18443544209003448,
-0.7152345776557922,
0.3674205243587494,
-0.25316426157951355,
-0.13003988564014435,
-0.3697530925273895,
0.04020538553595543,
-0.1941589117050171,
0.39400142431259155,
-0.0024198582395911217,
0.26230236887931824,
0.6210740208625793,
-0.594370424747467,
0.17820344865322113,
0.22961291670799255,
-1.0793912410736084,
-0.22753922641277313,
0.826323926448822,
0.20561085641384125,
-0.3158252537250519,
0.6842266321182251,
0.24206185340881348,
-0.031818024814128876,
0.5694102644920349,
0.24828021228313446,
0.8686705231666565,
0.0900578424334526,
0.18657395243644714,
-0.08933193236589432,
0.236533522605896,
0.2306288331747055,
0.02478891983628273,
-0.1858799010515213,
-0.485480397939682,
-0.5340391397476196,
-0.07411589473485947,
-0.5837535262107849,
0.33649876713752747,
-0.889886736869812,
-0.10797784477472305,
-0.4057788848876953,
0.10841403156518936,
0.638887882232666,
-0.1628524214029312,
-0.6846040487289429,
0.610299825668335,
0.3353729844093323,
0.7905643582344055,
-0.5242234468460083,
0.6864234209060669,
0.6764633655548096,
-0.21115361154079437,
-0.4589000940322876,
0.29060813784599304,
0.132237508893013,
-1.0192006826400757,
0.2923544645309448,
0.2733262777328491,
0.09260851889848709,
-0.3728506565093994,
-0.5023199319839478,
-0.3552272915840149,
0.7512026429176331,
0.1572781801223755,
-0.5000917911529541,
-0.4607359766960144,
0.051694151014089584,
0.7361841797828674,
-0.29212555289268494,
0.315932035446167,
0.8216884136199951,
0.3523377776145935,
-0.330882728099823,
-0.6046704053878784,
-0.001257650088518858,
-0.1640123873949051,
-0.28178974986076355,
-0.31652796268463135,
-0.35503339767456055,
0.3942950367927551,
-0.5402289628982544,
-0.16705027222633362,
0.05708327889442444,
0.6637628674507141,
-0.10229022800922394,
0.8162714838981628,
0.36093929409980774,
0.5038763880729675,
0.8025514483451843,
0.004930058494210243,
1.212944746017456,
-0.10491202771663666,
-0.13970941305160522,
1.0025357007980347,
-0.3513619899749756,
0.512234091758728,
0.44905582070350647,
-0.003899157978594303,
0.28969335556030273,
0.410089373588562,
0.2436482161283493,
0.47304466366767883,
-0.0875149592757225,
-0.3797047734260559,
0.0437227301299572,
-0.3307783603668213,
-0.3149757385253906,
0.4654900133609772,
0.49163368344306946,
-0.6689068078994751,
0.02581731416285038,
0.37158578634262085,
-0.026255346834659576,
0.012640497647225857,
-0.33142179250717163,
1.1272823810577393,
0.37933915853500366,
-0.6715056896209717,
0.12092012912034988,
-0.16838346421718597,
0.30034875869750977,
-0.6048961877822876,
-0.23786109685897827,
-0.045695673674345016,
0.23018778860569,
-0.40665170550346375,
-0.7244487404823303,
0.637182891368866,
-0.18313634395599365,
-0.5892152786254883,
-0.4767528474330902,
0.7014645934104919,
-0.1082400530576706,
-0.3993718922138214,
0.3282252550125122,
0.5086454749107361,
0.05219333618879318,
-0.10933218896389008,
-0.9041529893875122,
-0.10290288180112839,
0.1036340743303299,
-0.17074628174304962,
0.4050147235393524,
0.49875304102897644,
-0.045489754527807236,
0.916064441204071,
0.6020134091377258,
0.24613456428050995,
-0.26361533999443054,
0.2056414932012558,
0.6492818593978882,
-0.6130792498588562,
-0.5307326912879944,
-0.8486318588256836,
0.44057250022888184,
0.10410112887620926,
-0.343117892742157,
0.2786808907985687,
-0.15029016137123108,
0.3828001022338867,
0.23378053307533264,
0.9534226655960083,
0.19688887894153595,
0.4631156623363495,
-0.426099956035614,
1.0206406116485596,
-0.6460830569267273,
0.13541695475578308,
-0.0232391320168972,
-0.28729456663131714,
-0.7415189743041992,
0.5820055603981018,
-0.11378130316734314,
-0.019232474267482758,
0.6485432386398315,
0.0568409264087677,
0.17398032546043396,
0.16916202008724213,
0.456436425447464,
0.5502813458442688,
0.3959769904613495,
0.47410115599632263,
0.5803483128547668,
-0.30546897649765015,
0.30353280901908875,
-0.5193965435028076,
-0.2858634293079376,
-0.20446059107780457,
-0.7513993978500366,
-0.5153642296791077,
-0.506965160369873,
-0.5418900847434998,
-0.15389861166477203,
0.18925346434116364,
0.6824638843536377,
0.9959970712661743,
-0.9152916669845581,
0.30968162417411804,
-0.20968565344810486,
0.4791201651096344,
-0.709172785282135,
-0.1770043522119522,
0.5083705186843872,
-0.39752197265625,
-0.6364532709121704,
0.4408957064151764,
0.6786700487136841,
-0.3140209913253784,
-0.35947945713996887,
-0.02016288787126541,
-0.050564080476760864,
-0.10471531748771667,
0.5796984434127808,
0.5087521076202393,
-0.9930848479270935,
0.0288697499781847,
0.12080685049295425,
-0.0550580695271492,
0.2856045961380005,
0.7570329308509827,
-0.871047854423523,
0.6504616737365723,
0.2481030374765396,
0.9220289587974548,
-0.02660311572253704,
-0.34610503911972046,
0.6465744972229004,
-0.23391695320606232,
-0.16008499264717102,
0.5539422631263733,
0.40721866488456726,
0.15180325508117676,
-0.5393697619438171,
0.4741452932357788,
-0.011097499169409275,
-0.6559141278266907,
-0.795142650604248,
0.18322807550430298,
-0.9509186148643494,
-0.2873099744319916,
0.7656405568122864,
-0.40280595421791077,
-0.23850764334201813,
-0.49398502707481384,
-0.17933017015457153,
0.19306603074073792,
-0.07187550514936447,
0.7756373882293701,
0.290235310792923,
-0.41759970784187317,
-0.47251859307289124,
-0.8428184986114502,
0.6430878043174744,
0.45806559920310974,
-0.9039763808250427,
-0.06081286072731018,
-0.07601029425859451,
-0.1315947026014328,
-0.0101752495393157,
0.511895477771759,
-0.1698956936597824,
0.4548126459121704,
-0.31208840012550354,
-0.14325442910194397,
0.05221710726618767,
-0.44604820013046265,
-0.7778900265693665,
0.06744343042373657,
0.05370846763253212,
0.02941664308309555
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11886v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11886v2
|
QueryAgent: A Reliable and Efficient Reasoning Framework with Environmental Feedback-based Self-Correction
| 2024-03-18T15:39:14 | 2024-06-13T13:18:43 |
Xiang Huang, Sitao Cheng, Shanshan Huang, Jiayu Shen, Yong Xu, Chaoyun Zhang, Yuzhong Qu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Employing Large Language Models (LLMs) for semantic parsing has achieved
remarkable success. However, we find existing methods fall short in terms of
reliability and efficiency when hallucinations are encountered. In this paper,
we address these challenges with a framework called QueryAgent, which solves a
question step-by-step and performs step-wise self-correction. We introduce an
environmental feedback-based self-correction method called ERASER. Unlike
traditional approaches, ERASER leverages rich environmental feedback in the
intermediate steps to perform selective and differentiated self-correction only
when necessary. Experimental results demonstrate that QueryAgent notably
outperforms all previous few-shot methods using only one example on GrailQA and
GraphQ by 7.0 and 15.0 F1. Moreover, our approach exhibits superiority in terms
of efficiency, including runtime, query overhead, and API invocation costs. By
leveraging ERASER, we further improve another baseline (i.e., AgentBench) by
approximately 10 points, revealing the strong transferability of our approach.
|
[
-0.21603043377399445,
-0.8744531273841858,
0.8282760977745056,
0.2157730758190155,
0.046156518161296844,
-0.04258231073617935,
-0.07644251734018326,
-0.5120016932487488,
0.037113066762685776,
0.839637815952301,
-0.7453929781913757,
-0.5105491876602173,
-0.37738025188446045,
0.2945186197757721,
-0.32219618558883667,
0.581309974193573,
0.1963561326265335,
-0.1579732596874237,
-0.1271740347146988,
-0.13691803812980652,
-0.6249201893806458,
-0.38234972953796387,
-0.933563768863678,
-0.2775169014930725,
0.4958004653453827,
0.37612712383270264,
0.5941376686096191,
0.7492080330848694,
0.3684383034706116,
0.5450407266616821,
-0.2530442476272583,
0.4060133397579193,
-0.5955207943916321,
0.5772160291671753,
-0.6895480155944824,
-0.41221073269844055,
-0.0491485670208931,
-0.48144274950027466,
0.2110653668642044,
0.43489310145378113,
-0.39428508281707764,
-0.06424709409475327,
-0.06183032691478729,
0.5811440348625183,
-0.8150424957275391,
0.06593076884746552,
-0.9326687455177307,
-0.045655883848667145,
0.17330271005630493,
-0.25497207045555115,
-0.4988771080970764,
0.010797576047480106,
-0.3465273380279541,
-0.7285261750221252,
0.34445205330848694,
0.1453530639410019,
0.6290034055709839,
0.6905395984649658,
-0.3870786130428314,
-0.1512555181980133,
-0.648211658000946,
0.6881003975868225,
-0.6204447150230408,
0.3832748830318451,
0.4637420177459717,
0.394644558429718,
-0.41084355115890503,
-0.7995362877845764,
-0.5034396052360535,
-0.058803457766771317,
-0.15683327615261078,
0.1429148018360138,
-0.18858711421489716,
-0.11880913376808167,
0.13592705130577087,
-0.019947251304984093,
-0.36073288321495056,
-0.06471894681453705,
-0.33194586634635925,
-0.4386530816555023,
0.44286853075027466,
0.4697556793689728,
0.3313370645046234,
-0.5034728050231934,
-0.2449110746383667,
0.07669857144355774,
-0.46436113119125366,
-0.08354110270738602,
0.15234552323818207,
0.43883275985717773,
0.6823945045471191,
0.5068419575691223,
-0.5699577927589417,
0.6287333965301514,
0.21098914742469788,
-0.09623762965202332,
-0.20426969230175018,
-0.18946821987628937,
0.15788500010967255,
0.2010706514120102,
0.4633959233760834,
0.4046194851398468,
-0.21312005817890167,
-0.25343987345695496,
-0.4656325876712799,
-0.04905422031879425,
0.3723461627960205,
-0.8966715335845947,
-0.593454897403717,
0.40302908420562744,
-0.12972258031368256,
0.14372216165065765,
-0.23860712349414825,
-0.7075090408325195,
-0.5706309080123901,
-0.477703332901001,
0.4304931163787842,
-0.49011996388435364,
0.12165874242782593,
0.2281542867422104,
0.039611704647541046,
0.2626423239707947,
0.9734183549880981,
-0.6872454285621643,
0.3449487090110779,
0.7183915376663208,
0.6931872963905334,
0.05233699455857277,
-0.33467525243759155,
-0.7178658246994019,
0.2660795748233795,
-0.36490389704704285,
1.2182008028030396,
-0.5768413543701172,
-0.4217544496059418,
-0.3331335783004761,
0.14259786903858185,
-0.15847159922122955,
-0.7430624961853027,
0.2960634231567383,
-0.6380891799926758,
0.17372041940689087,
-0.39059770107269287,
-0.7345924377441406,
-0.11332695186138153,
0.36917102336883545,
-0.6179205179214478,
1.2594702243804932,
-0.007389736827462912,
-0.6040359139442444,
0.1774924248456955,
-0.39492660760879517,
-0.07290519028902054,
0.25317564606666565,
0.10866264253854752,
-0.1473524570465088,
-0.2506404221057892,
0.5318046808242798,
-0.07872475683689117,
0.2201712727546692,
0.09376996010541916,
-0.21941521763801575,
-0.4082951247692108,
-0.0698513314127922,
-0.13923560082912445,
0.6813746094703674,
0.17219573259353638,
-0.7245175242424011,
0.3495226502418518,
-0.9468443989753723,
0.25060373544692993,
0.06840681284666061,
-0.1528557389974594,
-0.25326764583587646,
0.023920459672808647,
-0.2082248479127884,
0.3749745786190033,
0.03660948947072029,
-0.679057240486145,
-0.07528645545244217,
-0.250336229801178,
0.43688300251960754,
0.9633219242095947,
0.15116429328918457,
0.10308975726366043,
-0.11605480313301086,
0.46407613158226013,
-0.18604980409145355,
-0.17048490047454834,
-0.45677047967910767,
-0.02709861285984516,
-1.1279513835906982,
-0.4312160015106201,
-0.11551171541213989,
0.555644690990448,
-0.6259796023368835,
0.5537253618240356,
-0.11156422644853592,
-0.4909916818141937,
-0.42196395993232727,
0.2618997097015381,
0.3671172857284546,
0.7505457401275635,
0.6270046830177307,
0.4812581539154053,
-0.22463755309581757,
-0.6609748601913452,
-0.5682662129402161,
-0.2698185443878174,
0.11467565596103668,
0.2559807598590851,
0.509925127029419,
-0.28853708505630493,
1.052522897720337,
-0.48471906781196594,
-0.3806670010089874,
-0.03189433738589287,
-0.08203334361314774,
-0.033028628677129745,
0.5106138586997986,
0.10542675852775574,
-0.311131089925766,
-0.11405657976865768,
-0.07602714002132416,
-0.7031351327896118,
-0.4361675977706909,
0.011394490487873554,
-0.4734571874141693,
0.3314991891384125,
0.8635971546173096,
-0.648499071598053,
0.46726977825164795,
0.03912215679883957,
-0.6468161940574646,
0.3251360356807709,
-0.2148314118385315,
0.25914838910102844,
-0.5884220004081726,
0.06930772215127945,
-0.2969758212566376,
-0.5140841603279114,
-0.3964287340641022,
0.24710087478160858,
0.11091233044862747,
-0.03921089693903923,
-0.44045352935791016,
0.7890825867652893,
-0.24930088222026825,
0.26063257455825806,
-0.5137991905212402,
0.21364395320415497,
0.41587409377098083,
0.20271185040473938,
-0.15736734867095947,
0.82734614610672,
0.12606707215309143,
-0.5282711982727051,
0.4018760323524475,
0.4908577799797058,
0.11274786293506622,
0.559001088142395,
-0.7270892858505249,
0.5626553297042847,
-0.3272925317287445,
0.26602813601493835,
-1.0931204557418823,
-0.15571017563343048,
0.3464447259902954,
-0.06212304159998894,
-0.06095103546977043,
-0.17827436327934265,
-0.5717785954475403,
-0.2613354027271271,
-0.20951251685619354,
0.11922448873519897,
0.14628171920776367,
-1.1169244050979614,
0.7008604407310486,
0.01782052405178547,
-0.2485451102256775,
-0.3479863107204437,
-0.5935109853744507,
0.14791403710842133,
-0.2552449703216553,
-0.7586594223976135,
0.14245077967643738,
0.056080058217048645,
-0.24909396469593048,
0.03677184507250786,
-0.4082863926887512,
0.09311768412590027,
-0.014111051335930824,
0.12950462102890015,
0.040109049528837204,
-0.004128968808799982,
0.28638002276420593,
-0.11310715973377228,
-0.30434706807136536,
0.3165185749530792,
-0.13968515396118164,
0.4509446918964386,
-0.4085395336151123,
-0.6785954236984253,
-0.22556839883327484,
0.21592725813388824,
0.16549964249134064,
-0.30738264322280884,
0.533639669418335,
0.14174161851406097,
-0.27646002173423767,
-0.5602308511734009,
-0.8523123860359192,
-0.33365222811698914,
-0.5411577820777893,
0.3925551176071167,
-0.5933335423469543,
-1.0326037406921387,
0.8659688234329224,
-0.06579605489969254,
-0.34397178888320923,
0.4710785150527954,
0.30361804366111755,
0.19245442748069763,
1.0165810585021973,
0.16095854341983795,
0.3072815537452698,
0.15057292580604553,
-0.12180425971746445,
0.3136909604072571,
-0.7362813949584961,
-0.4902585744857788,
-0.6205409169197083,
0.07076423615217209,
-0.3488217890262604,
-0.24961650371551514,
0.19635190069675446,
0.05110593140125275,
-0.5298343300819397,
0.11668236553668976,
-0.633623480796814,
0.7230489253997803,
0.5342329144477844,
0.25182417035102844,
0.49598264694213867,
-0.1734083890914917,
-0.0417451485991478,
-0.14598023891448975,
-0.5077402591705322,
-0.5581086874008179,
0.4271797835826874,
0.023015102371573448,
0.9655417799949646,
0.11813274770975113,
0.8655014634132385,
-0.003960665315389633,
0.004300044383853674,
-0.7622238993644714,
0.7634262442588806,
0.2723054885864258,
-0.6482270956039429,
-0.5892727971076965,
-0.36714333295822144,
-0.9617546796798706,
1.0887742042541504,
0.23515862226486206,
-0.9284297227859497,
0.125546395778656,
0.0898040384054184,
-0.19319860637187958,
0.40390825271606445,
-0.553108274936676,
1.027982473373413,
-0.19405362010002136,
-0.912638247013092,
-0.07533878087997437,
-0.6815343499183655,
0.1302577406167984,
-0.13089635968208313,
0.16577091813087463,
-0.403367817401886,
-0.16693149507045746,
0.22238096594810486,
-0.9138754606246948,
0.6531276702880859,
-0.35506370663642883,
-0.12807834148406982,
0.37730327248573303,
0.39634937047958374,
0.583872377872467,
0.11329631507396698,
-0.17258301377296448,
-0.19505132734775543,
0.23358111083507538,
-0.36384493112564087,
-0.9214128255844116,
0.6258230805397034,
-0.5709858536720276,
-1.0081465244293213,
-0.4927017390727997,
-0.359463095664978,
-0.21015727519989014,
0.4500674605369568,
0.09207919985055923,
0.2558612823486328,
0.06501349806785583,
0.10072552412748337,
0.2948537766933441,
-0.15572670102119446,
0.4011647701263428,
0.6582944989204407,
-0.5266416668891907,
-0.4323733150959015,
0.7692382335662842,
0.014288506470620632,
0.1406756192445755,
0.08240246027708054,
0.303559273481369,
-0.3916561007499695,
-0.23594167828559875,
-0.31385910511016846,
0.18853598833084106,
-1.2740495204925537,
-0.3864642083644867,
-0.942469596862793,
-0.11050212383270264,
-0.2655920684337616,
-0.12900882959365845,
-0.477597713470459,
-0.1929452270269394,
-0.012853427790105343,
-0.10399369150400162,
0.3713625371456146,
0.5086591243743896,
0.022097978740930557,
0.3566586375236511,
-0.6520410180091858,
0.31348782777786255,
0.3369223177433014,
0.24237297475337982,
-0.08764700591564178,
-0.4432111084461212,
0.1825326383113861,
-0.046796396374702454,
-0.26502832770347595,
-0.7083279490470886,
0.5044398903846741,
0.126257061958313,
0.7121243476867676,
0.15576289594173431,
0.1911698430776596,
1.0569442510604858,
-0.47634053230285645,
0.7279407978057861,
-0.3371458947658539,
-1.1335904598236084,
0.8519324064254761,
-0.33611273765563965,
0.4304960072040558,
1.000230073928833,
-0.11645021289587021,
-0.5198949575424194,
-0.6986302733421326,
-0.46348321437835693,
-1.0663549900054932,
0.7109439373016357,
0.18318995833396912,
0.08670659363269806,
-0.24838648736476898,
0.42693713307380676,
0.03375603258609772,
-0.119858019053936,
-0.4839199483394623,
-0.053963229060173035,
-0.504228949546814,
0.07030443847179413,
0.21006694436073303,
-0.056144025176763535,
0.01642606407403946,
-0.37150683999061584,
0.8210737109184265,
-0.39314204454421997,
-0.14426638185977936,
0.5739573836326599,
-0.38745373487472534,
-0.06421010941267014,
0.4672275185585022,
0.05426845699548721,
0.8523821234703064,
-0.17030911147594452,
0.3610173463821411,
0.36436712741851807,
-0.12446343898773193,
0.4032047390937805,
0.04103429242968559,
-0.261324018239975,
-0.16553783416748047,
0.3912324607372284,
0.4677222669124603,
0.2171763926744461,
-0.733440101146698,
0.32418954372406006,
-0.10966451466083527,
0.0015103366458788514,
-0.06859294325113297,
0.16739614307880402,
0.09439028799533844,
0.2662067711353302,
0.1567315310239792,
-0.13122858107089996,
0.5803501009941101,
-0.08809080719947815,
0.14988765120506287,
0.1892927885055542,
-0.41937971115112305,
0.003706183983013034,
0.7518173456192017,
-0.03455742076039314,
-0.017023909837007523,
0.9084869027137756,
-0.3289960026741028,
-0.5881518125534058,
0.6245235800743103,
0.8496109247207642,
0.7116400003433228,
-0.2654035985469818,
0.07617584615945816,
0.3221965432167053,
0.19153235852718353,
-0.0769379585981369,
0.3140086829662323,
0.08153153210878372,
-0.7351454496383667,
-0.48517242074012756,
-0.512163519859314,
-0.5042461156845093,
0.005242595449090004,
-0.5367645025253296,
0.020930273458361626,
-0.40039554238319397,
0.03773542866110802,
0.027581550180912018,
-0.2031112015247345,
-0.3423275053501129,
0.2213345766067505,
-0.1979348063468933,
0.6967217326164246,
-0.3907025456428528,
0.3010980486869812,
0.7442082166671753,
-0.45469963550567627,
-1.043962836265564,
-0.05708368495106697,
0.33429354429244995,
-0.6421922445297241,
0.6752719879150391,
0.5413811206817627,
-0.7018624544143677,
0.055021122097969055,
-0.5787988305091858,
-0.906866192817688,
0.8620705008506775,
0.5785201191902161,
-0.39948007464408875,
0.2874848544597626,
-0.0851980596780777,
0.6559741497039795,
-0.052869174629449844,
0.32798340916633606,
0.5780768394470215,
0.5574615597724915,
0.4610235393047333,
-0.3803654909133911,
0.2769889533519745,
-0.4570804238319397,
0.1398250311613083,
0.15465763211250305,
-0.7678569555282593,
0.5430256724357605,
-0.2065499722957611,
-0.2133098542690277,
0.2707981765270233,
0.6716295480728149,
0.531662106513977,
0.15489180386066437,
0.5189083814620972,
0.6859328746795654,
0.9457134008407593,
0.05347723886370659,
0.9656723737716675,
-0.44039785861968994,
0.4584791958332062,
1.3985950946807861,
-0.5692635178565979,
0.7265604138374329,
0.44100221991539,
-0.24358785152435303,
0.5703259706497192,
0.46902573108673096,
-0.04100198298692703,
0.4685307741165161,
0.3668675422668457,
-0.23231472074985504,
-0.49504685401916504,
-0.049053631722927094,
-0.07757244259119034,
0.6843727827072144,
0.0658382996916771,
0.1712861806154251,
-0.5181384682655334,
-0.12388256192207336,
0.22784999012947083,
0.2931930124759674,
-0.18605557084083557,
0.9007958173751831,
-0.1844584345817566,
-0.8269518613815308,
0.2475614696741104,
-0.11247240006923676,
0.3222693204879761,
-0.3529372215270996,
-0.23486725986003876,
-0.42751553654670715,
0.5659220218658447,
-0.3280456066131592,
-0.5299065113067627,
0.31055256724357605,
-0.31387001276016235,
0.09783568978309631,
-0.021440325304865837,
1.042904257774353,
-0.29423287510871887,
-0.43654370307922363,
0.6224478483200073,
0.5937904119491577,
-0.05933534726500511,
-0.4237995743751526,
-0.508699357509613,
-0.005211486015468836,
-0.2639700174331665,
-0.396420955657959,
-0.06504443287849426,
0.7215472459793091,
-0.0025454964488744736,
0.9156198501586914,
0.5867051482200623,
-0.01417337916791439,
0.266221821308136,
0.23159849643707275,
0.955923855304718,
-0.979315996170044,
-0.5432976484298706,
-0.8846039175987244,
0.3767755925655365,
-0.16040973365306854,
-0.11926832795143127,
0.9004737138748169,
0.7137742638587952,
0.7521370053291321,
0.10956215858459473,
0.629332423210144,
0.35916435718536377,
0.6297544836997986,
-0.5746578574180603,
0.4532911777496338,
-0.30503135919570923,
0.5076245069503784,
-0.12369360774755478,
-1.0857594013214111,
-0.3670957386493683,
0.7779865860939026,
-0.3984776437282562,
0.29049190878868103,
0.8776126503944397,
1.1487069129943848,
0.055744171142578125,
0.1334601193666458,
0.12975944578647614,
0.1455259919166565,
0.6096587181091309,
0.15397709608078003,
1.2989342212677002,
-0.20873871445655823,
0.4986545145511627,
-0.3892247974872589,
0.09926052391529083,
-0.039065584540367126,
-0.7515092492103577,
-0.7466152310371399,
0.07208053022623062,
-0.34367239475250244,
-0.5493271946907043,
0.42374107241630554,
0.8125959038734436,
0.5788397192955017,
-0.8160971403121948,
0.054487571120262146,
-0.21686169505119324,
0.01822473295032978,
-0.058826543390750885,
-0.2560606598854065,
0.38774845004081726,
-0.939752995967865,
-0.4691939651966095,
0.4536799192428589,
0.456579327583313,
-0.4062563180923462,
-0.07399153709411621,
-0.044396769255399704,
-0.0055326917208731174,
0.16314812004566193,
0.47069427371025085,
0.15085369348526,
-1.1330569982528687,
-0.627403974533081,
0.09239451587200165,
-0.21890060603618622,
0.2864178419113159,
0.5102745294570923,
-0.8204584717750549,
0.7082961797714233,
0.3607335686683655,
0.7226341962814331,
0.7268540263175964,
0.24460718035697937,
0.12083809077739716,
-0.3728909492492676,
-0.13061748445034027,
0.10796445608139038,
0.5098831653594971,
0.5808875560760498,
-0.5433881878852844,
0.7059561014175415,
0.11687399446964264,
-0.822079598903656,
-0.39148613810539246,
-0.08840393275022507,
-0.7586018443107605,
-0.40605637431144714,
1.266695261001587,
-0.05223354324698448,
-0.4678879976272583,
-0.1392180174589157,
-0.7257066965103149,
-0.1526728719472885,
-0.41522350907325745,
0.7559671401977539,
0.5860698223114014,
-0.48890286684036255,
-0.33250340819358826,
-0.1780811995267868,
0.15768511593341827,
0.553593635559082,
-1.1304311752319336,
0.18671852350234985,
1.002153992652893,
0.4725986421108246,
0.19731992483139038,
0.6927245259284973,
-0.2418345957994461,
0.04171145707368851,
0.25184816122055054,
0.10144363343715668,
-0.09871000051498413,
-0.2875778079032898,
-0.4131498336791992,
0.11085706204175949,
0.05653688311576843,
0.08558599650859833
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11873v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11873v1
|
CO3: Low-resource Contrastive Co-training for Generative Conversational Query Rewrite
| 2024-03-18T15:26:32 | 2024-03-18T15:26:32 |
Yifei Yuan, Chen Shi, Runze Wang, Liyi Chen, Renjun Hu, Zengming Zhang, Feijun Jiang, Wai Lam
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Generative query rewrite generates reconstructed query rewrites using the
conversation history while rely heavily on gold rewrite pairs that are
expensive to obtain. Recently, few-shot learning is gaining increasing
popularity for this task, whereas these methods are sensitive to the inherent
noise due to limited data size. Besides, both attempts face performance
degradation when there exists language style shift between training and testing
cases. To this end, we study low-resource generative conversational query
rewrite that is robust to both noise and language style shift. The core idea is
to utilize massive unlabeled data to make further improvements via a
contrastive co-training paradigm. Specifically, we co-train two dual models
(namely Rewriter and Simplifier) such that each of them provides extra guidance
through pseudo-labeling for enhancing the other in an iterative manner. We also
leverage contrastive learning with data augmentation, which enables our model
pay more attention on the truly valuable information than the noise. Extensive
experiments demonstrate the superiority of our model under both few-shot and
zero-shot scenarios. We also verify the better generalization ability of our
model when encountering language style shift.
|
[
-0.12831276655197144,
-1.105194330215454,
0.04014481231570244,
-0.14176154136657715,
-0.4281517267227173,
0.22437027096748352,
-0.20302776992321014,
-0.3934565484523773,
0.34951719641685486,
0.6062672734260559,
-0.9330742359161377,
-0.5772428512573242,
-0.182384192943573,
0.05166943743824959,
-0.28035348653793335,
0.9921945929527283,
0.2667500674724579,
-0.02967653051018715,
-0.1046687662601471,
-0.12105348706245422,
-0.3047989010810852,
-0.5166301131248474,
-1.11990487575531,
-0.2552622854709625,
0.5202100872993469,
0.658043622970581,
0.7234151363372803,
0.33805131912231445,
0.49411824345588684,
0.1843566745519638,
0.03713615611195564,
0.10659932345151901,
-1.0327088832855225,
0.18881136178970337,
0.11150573939085007,
-0.7565082907676697,
-0.5016875863075256,
-0.18969132006168365,
0.19022506475448608,
0.9760892391204834,
-0.31129884719848633,
-0.09549407660961151,
0.07824152708053589,
0.6057162880897522,
-0.6737886071205139,
0.11420024186372757,
-1.1727631092071533,
0.19117985665798187,
-0.009400425478816032,
-0.28407952189445496,
-0.46176740527153015,
-0.048640813678503036,
0.03223206847906113,
-0.9798445701599121,
0.9352080225944519,
0.44908738136291504,
0.7927781343460083,
0.2992507815361023,
-0.16921967267990112,
-0.07987327128648758,
-0.6362180709838867,
0.9111815690994263,
-0.3552424907684326,
0.48242273926734924,
0.45885148644447327,
0.33469244837760925,
-0.14887361228466034,
-0.7715044021606445,
-0.6296772956848145,
-0.1705329269170761,
-0.16990256309509277,
0.4445710778236389,
-0.33229970932006836,
0.003943805582821369,
-0.018333986401557922,
0.6119264364242554,
-0.5042304992675781,
0.17380666732788086,
-0.3072355091571808,
-0.20226790010929108,
0.5667145848274231,
0.25530725717544556,
0.05916865915060043,
0.09437278658151627,
-0.1539468914270401,
-0.14773692190647125,
-0.8395335078239441,
-0.29944658279418945,
0.4160335958003998,
0.5319286584854126,
-0.4090399146080017,
0.19262683391571045,
-0.5339118242263794,
0.7749955058097839,
0.417046457529068,
-0.125910222530365,
0.07458227127790451,
-0.6914572715759277,
-0.3141429126262665,
-0.042595215141773224,
0.9231891632080078,
0.3576943874359131,
-0.06445153057575226,
-0.3544081151485443,
0.2430925816297531,
-0.10634240508079529,
0.18863755464553833,
-0.9847080111503601,
-0.4114871323108673,
-0.031081777065992355,
-0.28295260667800903,
-0.35638904571533203,
-0.3808576166629791,
-0.8433598875999451,
-0.1708340346813202,
-0.2573055922985077,
0.12580782175064087,
-0.4860260486602783,
-0.10256046801805496,
0.2676142752170563,
0.015442265197634697,
0.32962462306022644,
0.5175259709358215,
-1.2166131734848022,
0.35461339354515076,
0.625933051109314,
0.7640712261199951,
-0.16695356369018555,
0.02223939076066017,
-0.5393721461296082,
0.08830007165670395,
-0.42766135931015015,
0.6484779715538025,
-0.660335123538971,
-0.5927557349205017,
-0.019388115033507347,
0.012191139161586761,
-0.10499037802219391,
-0.6990153789520264,
0.5121726393699646,
-0.8567324280738831,
0.3447806239128113,
-0.12355498969554901,
-0.25070369243621826,
0.060967832803726196,
0.20286031067371368,
-0.7264135479927063,
0.6996292471885681,
0.1941375881433487,
-0.5964087843894958,
0.48300716280937195,
-0.4814680814743042,
-0.5500052571296692,
-0.006366309244185686,
-0.12349898368120193,
-0.9185141921043396,
-0.027178239077329636,
0.10768723487854004,
-0.04629028961062431,
-0.4070868492126465,
-0.056714579463005066,
-0.3026386499404907,
-0.6326011419296265,
-0.0073762619867920876,
-0.5691530704498291,
0.48403283953666687,
0.17130641639232635,
-0.1277177482843399,
-0.04867514595389366,
-0.8214524388313293,
-0.05022796243429184,
0.27882277965545654,
-0.3853161334991455,
-0.0884430855512619,
-0.3368682861328125,
-0.18879351019859314,
-0.027817612513899803,
-0.026564300060272217,
-0.38950443267822266,
0.06562155485153198,
-0.48002925515174866,
0.15503691136837006,
0.25879552960395813,
0.136116161942482,
0.5333672761917114,
-0.22831423580646515,
0.6040446758270264,
0.029249312356114388,
0.011014031246304512,
0.00033499114215373993,
-0.17045655846595764,
-1.228634238243103,
-0.2650015652179718,
0.13590572774410248,
0.38399553298950195,
-0.978691577911377,
0.22124908864498138,
-0.31818848848342896,
-0.39248979091644287,
-0.9626855850219727,
0.3844307065010071,
0.5628060102462769,
0.750074565410614,
0.6640447974205017,
-0.30370935797691345,
-0.6622666716575623,
-0.8759658336639404,
-0.3580465614795685,
-0.07616528868675232,
0.0697069838643074,
0.3967187702655792,
0.33235639333724976,
-0.03773217275738716,
0.6072971224784851,
-0.7273997068405151,
-0.3046998083591461,
-0.4665069878101349,
0.44278237223625183,
0.04082605987787247,
0.4387158751487732,
0.2117472141981125,
-0.663253128528595,
-0.7979698181152344,
-0.2362750619649887,
-0.5744186043739319,
-0.056672707200050354,
-0.12663771212100983,
-0.38677334785461426,
0.2986065149307251,
0.8270847201347351,
-0.09283294528722763,
0.370765745639801,
0.5177597403526306,
0.10794661194086075,
0.10705332458019257,
-0.05869891494512558,
0.21794834733009338,
-1.1502397060394287,
-0.15945756435394287,
-0.10780633985996246,
-0.05413171276450157,
-0.5289058685302734,
-0.12835848331451416,
-0.3986165523529053,
-0.32689955830574036,
-0.41859501600265503,
0.2389371246099472,
-0.60872483253479,
0.023747434839606285,
-0.29752835631370544,
-0.06893397122621536,
0.21435096859931946,
0.702281653881073,
0.33860427141189575,
0.9600591063499451,
0.44685083627700806,
-0.4707637429237366,
0.2366129606962204,
0.3778574764728546,
-0.25215762853622437,
0.7502934336662292,
-0.6888283491134644,
0.6786748766899109,
-0.018537970259785652,
0.467703640460968,
-1.091427206993103,
-0.14368638396263123,
0.2472882717847824,
-0.22224564850330353,
0.2763228416442871,
-0.6234084963798523,
-0.5861794352531433,
0.12000980973243713,
-0.28303322196006775,
0.37896808981895447,
0.41238757967948914,
-0.6202499866485596,
0.0861489325761795,
0.01381430123001337,
0.022640490904450417,
-0.3343587815761566,
-0.8699249625205994,
0.10530436038970947,
-0.2087096869945526,
-0.6408493518829346,
0.6958248019218445,
0.007026689127087593,
-0.08716931939125061,
-0.28084635734558105,
-0.08410852402448654,
-0.20762312412261963,
0.03853931277990341,
0.06925482302904129,
0.22208358347415924,
-0.3192724883556366,
0.04563450440764427,
-0.17326720058918,
-0.16626687347888947,
-0.22754229605197906,
0.17806251347064972,
0.777671754360199,
0.0015191701240837574,
-0.44425198435783386,
-0.7997161746025085,
0.5337890982627869,
0.11645153164863586,
-0.06375785171985626,
1.0118255615234375,
0.6989631056785583,
0.13736560940742493,
-0.03917333856225014,
-0.3749462962150574,
-0.37497496604919434,
-0.422402024269104,
0.4903505742549896,
-0.5076090693473816,
-1.0160000324249268,
0.27841508388519287,
0.034114159643650055,
-0.2581389844417572,
0.34337764978408813,
0.4686136543750763,
-0.24761836230754852,
0.6330269575119019,
0.6049351692199707,
0.07022552192211151,
0.7017120718955994,
-0.33484500646591187,
0.24631431698799133,
-0.6851047277450562,
-0.20416225492954254,
-0.32927078008651733,
-0.23290777206420898,
-0.8039275407791138,
-0.5167986750602722,
0.43972650170326233,
0.053641971200704575,
-0.10809068381786346,
0.17123520374298096,
-0.24335536360740662,
0.5624665021896362,
0.5264306664466858,
0.31088021397590637,
0.5033418536186218,
0.2836473286151886,
0.4436987638473511,
-0.2602095305919647,
-0.858336865901947,
-0.13813407719135284,
1.1462301015853882,
-0.19842173159122467,
1.1749953031539917,
0.2805110514163971,
0.7168322801589966,
0.025325089693069458,
0.010150080546736717,
-0.8338161706924438,
0.46490952372550964,
-0.3302363455295563,
-0.4490799605846405,
-0.2842256426811218,
-0.28137344121932983,
-1.1374151706695557,
0.46401339769363403,
-0.3383648991584778,
-0.2380925416946411,
0.12472541630268097,
0.5390737056732178,
-0.46578553318977356,
0.16399677097797394,
-1.0123450756072998,
0.8107498288154602,
-0.08705193549394608,
-0.9465986490249634,
-0.40923231840133667,
-0.7104297280311584,
0.23145881295204163,
0.0899999663233757,
-0.19845634698867798,
0.21424075961112976,
0.03889354318380356,
0.5759569406509399,
-0.5465529561042786,
1.267552375793457,
0.1394050568342209,
0.0056349835358560085,
0.4350300133228302,
0.1313706934452057,
0.5627551674842834,
-0.10467284917831421,
-0.18365220725536346,
-0.019833063706755638,
-0.4437163472175598,
-0.4368903934955597,
-0.6060965657234192,
0.5056622624397278,
-0.6583909392356873,
-0.6736441254615784,
-0.13228613138198853,
-0.4664785861968994,
-0.27851369976997375,
-0.09390917420387268,
0.4469337463378906,
0.2492421716451645,
-0.5344622135162354,
0.4888803958892822,
0.6336051225662231,
-0.1535692662000656,
0.15158702433109283,
0.7438138723373413,
0.29031527042388916,
-0.2110188752412796,
0.7131379246711731,
-0.11524951457977295,
0.7073355913162231,
0.5929429531097412,
-0.06394606828689575,
-0.3031132221221924,
-0.5748459100723267,
-0.21059207618236542,
0.08954877406358719,
-0.5877257585525513,
-0.047098103910684586,
-0.6416358351707458,
0.04082094132900238,
-0.5399620532989502,
-0.3415627181529999,
-0.4675917327404022,
-0.1677868515253067,
-0.3845219016075134,
0.09225530177354813,
0.33655253052711487,
0.044515252113342285,
0.14148485660552979,
0.6654562950134277,
-0.19047975540161133,
0.5851364731788635,
0.47570347785949707,
0.30501365661621094,
-0.2112942487001419,
-0.8003608584403992,
-0.17230185866355896,
-0.099821075797081,
-0.3108859360218048,
-0.48372963070869446,
0.3930801749229431,
0.35548365116119385,
0.21258002519607544,
0.13965928554534912,
0.1359846293926239,
0.999832272529602,
-0.32043027877807617,
0.5376870036125183,
0.31457480788230896,
-0.5524398684501648,
0.6543000936508179,
-0.17364706099033356,
0.2882254719734192,
1.1345669031143188,
0.17054349184036255,
-0.47017014026641846,
-0.1539972573518753,
-0.7701421976089478,
-0.7311514019966125,
0.7852128148078918,
0.09467159956693649,
0.239957794547081,
0.008399128913879395,
0.20087403059005737,
0.28176581859588623,
0.13407839834690094,
-0.40042656660079956,
-0.1576024293899536,
-0.3445545732975006,
0.0749911293387413,
0.10873229056596756,
-0.33272579312324524,
-0.16053862869739532,
-0.14483805000782013,
0.5445283651351929,
-0.3449060618877411,
0.23339974880218506,
-0.11216659098863602,
-0.13157324492931366,
-0.10265617072582245,
0.6653886437416077,
0.28155192732810974,
0.11434714496135712,
-0.4426864981651306,
0.16886596381664276,
0.29131245613098145,
-0.21093228459358215,
-0.045911043882369995,
-0.04672075808048248,
-0.13339368999004364,
-0.06423107534646988,
0.38616999983787537,
1.0718793869018555,
0.4026028513908386,
-0.21991577744483948,
0.4854605793952942,
-0.07516958564519882,
-0.18667757511138916,
-0.1309846192598343,
0.3164588212966919,
0.12356741726398468,
-0.16212446987628937,
-0.24142852425575256,
0.002152598462998867,
0.17779117822647095,
-0.9215531945228577,
-0.01760242134332657,
0.5039798021316528,
-0.37479591369628906,
-0.41254502534866333,
0.5870310664176941,
0.4598478078842163,
-0.14742648601531982,
0.6731901168823242,
-0.335508793592453,
-0.09353044629096985,
0.2182711362838745,
0.9006738662719727,
0.6691862344741821,
0.009038461372256279,
0.18616633117198944,
0.5864022970199585,
0.008057520724833012,
0.1796344518661499,
0.11806301772594452,
-0.29069769382476807,
-0.7534834742546082,
-0.1402447372674942,
-0.35147401690483093,
-0.7014656662940979,
0.3897649347782135,
-0.7925258278846741,
0.39696407318115234,
-0.30828535556793213,
0.2426389753818512,
0.014927055686712265,
0.01478484459221363,
-0.6499844193458557,
0.36850181221961975,
-0.1852979212999344,
0.42528003454208374,
-0.8487235903739929,
0.7184385061264038,
0.3700563907623291,
-0.6797053217887878,
-0.33029642701148987,
0.2160879671573639,
0.13428840041160583,
-1.1575573682785034,
0.6966739892959595,
-0.17032073438167572,
-0.7077518701553345,
-0.022053198888897896,
-0.8388684988021851,
-0.6146224141120911,
1.1639835834503174,
0.5906925797462463,
-0.7823073267936707,
0.08450955152511597,
0.25206202268600464,
0.7854260802268982,
-0.31645074486732483,
0.08933919668197632,
0.5915406942367554,
-0.07361558824777603,
0.8427961468696594,
-0.6247686147689819,
-0.1138639822602272,
0.1360006332397461,
-0.12180627137422562,
-0.11977497488260269,
-1.097861886024475,
0.6064277291297913,
-0.3015015125274658,
-0.3920080363750458,
0.03701427951455116,
0.6797996163368225,
0.28931277990341187,
0.325777530670166,
0.4257349371910095,
0.6069622039794922,
0.650364100933075,
-0.14912085235118866,
1.1863020658493042,
-0.1818755716085434,
0.1623154729604721,
1.610495686531067,
-0.4096631407737732,
0.9316303730010986,
0.5339739322662354,
-0.23507128655910492,
0.49617230892181396,
0.38694676756858826,
0.06445793062448502,
0.7388134598731995,
0.20675261318683624,
-0.4160439074039459,
-0.5011430978775024,
-0.3904929757118225,
-0.25408095121383667,
0.6248577833175659,
0.04256678372621536,
-0.310013085603714,
-0.27989739179611206,
-0.4728485643863678,
0.4433632791042328,
0.07146238535642624,
0.02621908113360405,
1.1132893562316895,
-0.060957904905080795,
-0.8260219097137451,
0.9241950511932373,
-0.1670561134815216,
0.8996444940567017,
-0.49676668643951416,
-0.05390600860118866,
-0.701154351234436,
0.17258040606975555,
-0.27988898754119873,
-0.42889660596847534,
0.501162588596344,
0.0833507552742958,
-0.25127899646759033,
-0.24174430966377258,
0.5165936946868896,
-0.6462987065315247,
-0.27688685059547424,
0.08035168796777725,
0.48381340503692627,
0.07293757796287537,
0.011569972150027752,
-0.741478443145752,
0.038171812891960144,
0.19067791104316711,
0.22499698400497437,
0.509364128112793,
0.35325661301612854,
0.07404084503650665,
0.4496467113494873,
0.5969212055206299,
-0.08175304532051086,
-0.1502964347600937,
0.5734525918960571,
0.7954460978507996,
-0.6048489212989807,
-0.3961857557296753,
-0.6801496744155884,
0.07706253230571747,
-0.16223780810832977,
-0.11725404858589172,
0.4751255512237549,
0.8471725583076477,
0.8387008905410767,
-0.06731436401605606,
0.6761975288391113,
0.2812993824481964,
0.4503346085548401,
-0.7601186037063599,
0.493572473526001,
-0.45157918334007263,
0.4207226037979126,
0.01562311127781868,
-0.42352190613746643,
-0.38738518953323364,
0.2111293524503708,
-0.45849695801734924,
0.05349166318774223,
0.6058445572853088,
1.3322975635528564,
-0.1465764194726944,
-0.009575683623552322,
0.4585922956466675,
-0.08235038816928864,
0.3768826425075531,
0.7002571821212769,
0.7326985001564026,
-0.5460452437400818,
0.9226722121238708,
-0.19407618045806885,
0.1523040533065796,
-0.5178454518318176,
-0.5789653658866882,
-0.8913402557373047,
-0.41768571734428406,
-0.775705873966217,
-0.3632202744483948,
0.17926408350467682,
0.5593224763870239,
0.911687970161438,
-0.7131511569023132,
-0.0816059410572052,
-0.3486669659614563,
-0.07843610644340515,
0.008469587191939354,
-0.23890027403831482,
0.4799712896347046,
-0.5143119096755981,
-0.8298845291137695,
0.5962615013122559,
0.3248932361602783,
0.27125629782676697,
0.11578556895256042,
0.07534442842006683,
-0.13591380417346954,
-0.08896186947822571,
0.5178996324539185,
0.3378657400608063,
-0.5855867266654968,
-0.07186423987150192,
-0.1065555140376091,
-0.20673368871212006,
0.49973323941230774,
0.8319063782691956,
-0.7053466439247131,
0.647803544998169,
0.28469952940940857,
0.46805551648139954,
0.8229075074195862,
0.08811347931623459,
0.4136035144329071,
-1.1165547370910645,
0.29516956210136414,
0.04840504750609398,
0.0773586705327034,
0.6772813200950623,
-0.2607181668281555,
0.6301465034484863,
0.49542343616485596,
-0.18847644329071045,
-0.44246727228164673,
0.37953948974609375,
-1.1054271459579468,
0.0499960221350193,
1.207899808883667,
0.09358400106430054,
-0.007877684198319912,
-0.21503137052059174,
-0.2632561922073364,
0.3757243752479553,
-0.3858124911785126,
0.8328429460525513,
0.2818763554096222,
-0.4752908945083618,
-0.45553848147392273,
-0.19152548909187317,
0.6928092837333679,
0.5183733105659485,
-0.8942402601242065,
0.10266268253326416,
0.5099599361419678,
0.31037643551826477,
0.03640459105372429,
0.9541051387786865,
-0.10698001086711884,
0.13619893789291382,
0.37215656042099,
-0.10571518540382385,
0.07045784592628479,
0.1005987823009491,
-0.26570531725883484,
0.25227856636047363,
0.09523861855268478,
-0.4476952850818634
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15450v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15450v1
|
Loops On Retrieval Augmented Generation (LoRAG)
| 2024-03-18T15:19:17 | 2024-03-18T15:19:17 |
Ayush Thakur, Rashmi Vashisth
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
This paper presents Loops On Retrieval Augmented Generation (LoRAG), a new
framework designed to enhance the quality of retrieval-augmented text
generation through the incorporation of an iterative loop mechanism. The
architecture integrates a generative model, a retrieval mechanism, and a
dynamic loop module, allowing for iterative refinement of the generated text
through interactions with relevant information retrieved from the input
context. Experimental evaluations on benchmark datasets demonstrate that LoRAG
surpasses existing state-of-the-art models in terms of BLEU score, ROUGE score,
and perplexity, showcasing its effectiveness in achieving both coherence and
relevance in generated text. The qualitative assessment further illustrates
LoRAG's capability to produce contextually rich and coherent outputs. This
research contributes valuable insights into the potential of iterative loops in
mitigating challenges in text generation, positioning LoRAG as a promising
advancement in the field.
|
[
-0.3166601359844208,
-1.082326054573059,
0.3489411771297455,
0.1544526219367981,
-0.4473150670528412,
0.23407724499702454,
-0.016376502811908722,
-0.3354480564594269,
0.5185264348983765,
0.508965790271759,
-0.2812546491622925,
-0.5362351536750793,
-0.3092334270477295,
0.09844253957271576,
-1.0663014650344849,
1.229714274406433,
-0.13783690333366394,
-0.5914309620857239,
-0.00288617005571723,
-0.10768938064575195,
-0.4715047776699066,
-0.3212633430957794,
-0.32257816195487976,
-0.6564286351203918,
0.6592787504196167,
0.34800198674201965,
0.36311572790145874,
0.44844287633895874,
0.6006156802177429,
0.24583500623703003,
-0.11301690340042114,
0.17321603000164032,
-0.8303576111793518,
0.7517006993293762,
-0.299982488155365,
0.03752199560403824,
-0.4518463909626007,
-0.2256266325712204,
0.7838632464408875,
0.4322302043437958,
-0.336337149143219,
0.3039070665836334,
0.17477096617221832,
0.7035979628562927,
-0.9810376763343811,
-0.5524380803108215,
-0.855560302734375,
0.016677360981702805,
-0.47432976961135864,
-0.7357994318008423,
-0.29350799322128296,
-0.4693550169467926,
-0.19011706113815308,
-0.7856823205947876,
0.12984216213226318,
0.10206588357686996,
0.8440720438957214,
0.3242390751838684,
-0.24611294269561768,
-0.6406534314155579,
-0.6625669598579407,
0.4874524772167206,
-0.2930956184864044,
0.1388898491859436,
0.32108986377716064,
0.5220814347267151,
0.009603640995919704,
-1.0374811887741089,
-0.6965847015380859,
0.05031904950737953,
0.32849955558776855,
0.2445845603942871,
-0.11410798132419586,
-0.25596413016319275,
0.27341729402542114,
0.8880895972251892,
-0.21523340046405792,
-0.2020549476146698,
-0.649800717830658,
0.16365887224674225,
0.7363002300262451,
0.2743452489376068,
0.13232143223285675,
-0.32277750968933105,
-0.3990749716758728,
0.051013343036174774,
-0.8872032165527344,
-0.10021938383579254,
0.5717832446098328,
0.273701936006546,
-0.052388034760951996,
1.06459641456604,
-0.35585734248161316,
0.7191752791404724,
0.4625128209590912,
-0.2241857498884201,
0.22068548202514648,
-0.5715795755386353,
-0.13187117874622345,
0.3259938359260559,
0.6775853037834167,
-0.013709444552659988,
-0.2843407094478607,
0.031567078083753586,
-0.4416992962360382,
0.19316475093364716,
0.5911682844161987,
-0.7124028205871582,
0.03672397881746292,
0.14787955582141876,
-0.3441639542579651,
-0.5925619006156921,
0.09771478176116943,
-0.8293055295944214,
-0.3786012530326843,
0.012240082956850529,
0.5996498465538025,
-0.4986952841281891,
0.11194844543933868,
0.10417292267084122,
-0.2749137878417969,
0.05554690957069397,
0.3138605058193207,
-0.6531097292900085,
0.04124592989683151,
0.610235333442688,
0.819525420665741,
-0.5405282378196716,
-0.30771660804748535,
-1.0097448825836182,
0.3526008725166321,
-0.34470033645629883,
1.0350985527038574,
-0.7988020777702332,
-0.639531672000885,
0.29488757252693176,
-0.453326940536499,
0.15996204316616058,
-0.6779882311820984,
0.6012142300605774,
-0.7977216839790344,
0.26286688446998596,
-0.22324137389659882,
-0.4162551760673523,
0.14254066348075867,
0.3397824466228485,
-0.7731837034225464,
1.3237887620925903,
0.3169851303100586,
-0.9961978197097778,
0.4526292681694031,
-0.6285237073898315,
-0.5568921566009521,
0.255217969417572,
-0.19513115286827087,
-0.5103903412818909,
0.3025628626346588,
-0.17333842813968658,
-0.1958841234445572,
-0.500613272190094,
0.2642960548400879,
-0.08556029200553894,
-0.7883029580116272,
0.10456280410289764,
-0.3272032141685486,
0.4722215235233307,
0.41168466210365295,
-0.27854281663894653,
0.11493461579084396,
-0.997183620929718,
0.25451985001564026,
-0.1813061237335205,
-1.0942485332489014,
-0.13896110653877258,
-0.1986968070268631,
0.012656470760703087,
-0.1483391523361206,
0.20864655077457428,
-0.38996508717536926,
0.46478521823883057,
-0.35222476720809937,
0.1886643022298813,
0.48517128825187683,
0.27908509969711304,
0.5283016562461853,
-0.28186970949172974,
0.649997353553772,
-0.07155393064022064,
-0.3113948106765747,
-0.6156108379364014,
-0.29342207312583923,
-0.7421476244926453,
-0.1397838294506073,
0.4499726891517639,
0.3019372820854187,
-1.1230111122131348,
0.3643282651901245,
-0.1584775596857071,
-0.22842051088809967,
-0.6425130367279053,
0.2822898328304291,
0.3969936966896057,
0.5202528834342957,
0.3142014145851135,
-0.3560240864753723,
-0.5455132126808167,
-0.3184832036495209,
-0.4076865017414093,
-0.07440414279699326,
0.23516425490379333,
-0.0813554897904396,
0.7372233867645264,
-0.7025970816612244,
0.8698880076408386,
-0.241872176527977,
-0.058296605944633484,
-0.2083989381790161,
0.2996857166290283,
0.33308178186416626,
0.4464094936847687,
0.2978792190551758,
-0.8042979836463928,
-0.39384618401527405,
0.1730465143918991,
-0.910338282585144,
-0.3328520357608795,
0.23502202332019806,
-0.2524445950984955,
0.24460934102535248,
0.34326329827308655,
-0.47870078682899475,
0.7457097768783569,
0.36249619722366333,
-0.35291650891304016,
0.7880195379257202,
-0.23153086006641388,
0.4223877787590027,
-1.0532814264297485,
0.6343234777450562,
-0.6064453721046448,
-0.0892375186085701,
-0.4016501009464264,
0.5131350755691528,
-0.2933662235736847,
-0.3694775104522705,
-0.036791201680898666,
0.8596989512443542,
-0.21539989113807678,
-0.17070409655570984,
-0.3723457455635071,
0.5329287648200989,
0.434371680021286,
0.0017481012037023902,
-0.5244802236557007,
1.001415491104126,
0.2064480036497116,
-0.7077174186706543,
0.4427584409713745,
0.4796014130115509,
-0.6721576452255249,
0.880501389503479,
-0.8018705248832703,
0.13416644930839539,
-0.08149298280477524,
0.15445144474506378,
-0.6426219344139099,
-0.6671029329299927,
0.029408521950244904,
-0.4813530445098877,
0.17264842987060547,
0.27054211497306824,
-0.3308826982975006,
-0.4843955636024475,
-0.5629346966743469,
0.5949632525444031,
0.44784361124038696,
-0.7301450371742249,
0.23072832822799683,
0.17724186182022095,
-0.03548154979944229,
-0.7145781517028809,
-0.5836288928985596,
0.017575638368725777,
-0.3537391722202301,
-0.43664613366127014,
0.7011563777923584,
-0.10788824409246445,
-0.5163440704345703,
-0.07814642041921616,
0.08675606548786163,
-0.0009681843221187592,
-0.0851711854338646,
0.12724435329437256,
-0.06802847236394882,
-0.15784883499145508,
0.32682040333747864,
0.426052063703537,
-0.18362018465995789,
-0.416594535112381,
-0.185438871383667,
0.6351534128189087,
0.18891741335391998,
-0.6388760805130005,
-0.12386933714151382,
0.7444019317626953,
0.388369619846344,
-0.26125186681747437,
0.4647393226623535,
0.6549345850944519,
-0.28914085030555725,
-0.2690731883049011,
-0.3528299033641815,
0.10264397412538528,
-0.5048322081565857,
0.11528924107551575,
-0.6173991560935974,
-0.9364579319953918,
0.5081338286399841,
-0.051512815058231354,
-0.14124085009098053,
0.3933551609516144,
0.7903019189834595,
-0.2818136215209961,
0.7696489691734314,
0.5799475908279419,
0.02797141671180725,
0.5222274661064148,
-0.4274766743183136,
0.38292574882507324,
-1.0342538356781006,
-0.1493644416332245,
-0.5724114179611206,
-0.1630226969718933,
-0.5753442645072937,
-0.48067232966423035,
0.5661766529083252,
0.9080371260643005,
-0.599053680896759,
0.04392192140221596,
-0.6386082172393799,
0.19767293334007263,
0.6264848709106445,
0.028054790571331978,
0.6515941023826599,
0.3855134844779968,
-0.24712695181369781,
0.23682154715061188,
-0.749239981174469,
-0.5737971663475037,
0.7172701954841614,
-0.13153129816055298,
0.9610899090766907,
0.13053256273269653,
0.9801509380340576,
0.8271194696426392,
0.22909770905971527,
-0.6537237763404846,
0.3741084039211273,
0.09271202236413956,
-0.4847647547721863,
-0.07036282122135162,
-0.3501913845539093,
-1.1037644147872925,
0.045915618538856506,
-0.2041727602481842,
-0.853540301322937,
0.055117037147283554,
0.4427100718021393,
-0.3570486903190613,
0.008687476627528667,
-0.10948686301708221,
0.3820413649082184,
0.010541023686528206,
-1.0259169340133667,
-0.12676426768302917,
-0.2544155418872833,
0.37994101643562317,
-0.13809169828891754,
-0.2142326831817627,
0.2713271677494049,
0.09980715811252594,
0.43530353903770447,
-0.574810266494751,
0.292340487241745,
0.022437291219830513,
-0.6830902099609375,
0.8735809326171875,
0.058928411453962326,
0.6406431198120117,
0.11891961842775345,
-0.6355687975883484,
-0.28992176055908203,
-0.3498375415802002,
-0.3726724684238434,
-0.45875272154808044,
0.9013786315917969,
-0.35014185309410095,
-0.6566459536552429,
-0.08342357724905014,
-0.2922547161579132,
0.11476819962263107,
0.44209787249565125,
0.8207469582557678,
0.563905656337738,
-0.18870215117931366,
0.161393940448761,
0.381011962890625,
-0.560005247592926,
0.3781816065311432,
0.005166498478502035,
-0.575570285320282,
-0.7280144691467285,
1.007096767425537,
-0.0021066779736429453,
0.13157956302165985,
0.23792588710784912,
-0.07428240776062012,
-0.25618213415145874,
-0.3911844789981842,
-0.6779488921165466,
0.13075117766857147,
-0.868340790271759,
-0.4669855833053589,
-0.4702720046043396,
-0.12729555368423462,
-0.27324438095092773,
-0.4952838718891144,
-0.16685909032821655,
-0.3847216069698334,
-0.2415962815284729,
0.03065391071140766,
0.3682737946510315,
0.8774603605270386,
0.07235585898160934,
0.39334389567375183,
-0.6152750849723816,
0.5357876420021057,
0.18132592737674713,
0.4254298806190491,
-0.040043801069259644,
-0.5225189328193665,
-0.3034127354621887,
0.041251037269830704,
-0.7766119241714478,
-0.7332251667976379,
0.42796891927719116,
0.22720125317573547,
0.24950334429740906,
0.23745635151863098,
0.05937625840306282,
0.924139142036438,
-0.4718914031982422,
0.91471266746521,
0.19706104695796967,
-1.0750267505645752,
0.7828448414802551,
-0.786350667476654,
0.48703914880752563,
0.6176862120628357,
-0.037635717540979385,
-0.3269036114215851,
-0.06831233203411102,
-0.3717324733734131,
-0.8374001383781433,
0.281247079372406,
0.31206369400024414,
0.15931937098503113,
-0.16847823560237885,
0.5260531306266785,
0.2927745282649994,
0.7280511260032654,
-0.459245890378952,
0.06281276047229767,
-0.21515274047851562,
-0.21826037764549255,
0.3757026195526123,
-0.4276386797428131,
-0.04394131526350975,
-0.02394047938287258,
0.5593605041503906,
-0.26697468757629395,
0.5938734412193298,
0.19154731929302216,
-0.024678422138094902,
-0.29447007179260254,
0.31140458583831787,
0.7245132923126221,
0.6707710027694702,
0.10889551043510437,
0.07635685801506042,
-0.0267950389534235,
-0.3212721645832062,
0.11132137477397919,
-0.22046127915382385,
-0.4305146634578705,
0.07025781273841858,
0.5429685711860657,
0.920171320438385,
0.047246117144823074,
-0.7119289636611938,
0.2835806608200073,
0.3227711617946625,
0.013457193039357662,
-0.24411438405513763,
0.3559234142303467,
-0.28540143370628357,
0.39036551117897034,
0.545222818851471,
-0.11600450426340103,
0.3531176745891571,
-0.7725489139556885,
0.26584669947624207,
0.29061806201934814,
-0.2533973455429077,
-0.3683367073535919,
0.7333981394767761,
0.2810421288013458,
-0.6709872484207153,
0.4831613004207611,
-0.24073593318462372,
-0.45533889532089233,
0.12505893409252167,
0.9074487090110779,
0.5860736966133118,
-0.025127192959189415,
0.16591918468475342,
0.5763538479804993,
-0.3103086054325104,
-0.13790318369865417,
0.5951784253120422,
-0.5265612602233887,
-0.44053226709365845,
-0.25436121225357056,
-0.9984844923019409,
-0.21644940972328186,
-0.1313801258802414,
-0.748431384563446,
0.35804277658462524,
-0.05219133570790291,
-0.29326915740966797,
-0.5023117661476135,
-0.04889654368162155,
-0.2177005559206009,
0.09169477224349976,
-0.2852858006954193,
0.8589083552360535,
-0.20768266916275024,
0.7237645983695984,
0.6620437502861023,
-0.4067496359348297,
-0.22882293164730072,
0.11391155421733856,
-0.20872358977794647,
-0.5729709267616272,
0.7425713539123535,
0.049151238054037094,
-0.4470937252044678,
0.07306141406297684,
-0.5295377373695374,
-0.704844057559967,
1.140666127204895,
0.2255282998085022,
-0.4680919051170349,
-0.07554538547992706,
-0.004051866475492716,
0.6539747714996338,
-0.43040305376052856,
-0.08862966299057007,
0.4572889506816864,
0.44394591450691223,
0.1816587746143341,
-0.6665442585945129,
-0.2481927126646042,
-0.7297775149345398,
0.11749417334794998,
0.25640958547592163,
-0.41285744309425354,
0.9612791538238525,
-0.39352989196777344,
-0.46026909351348877,
0.6953164339065552,
0.5094724297523499,
0.8227968215942383,
0.6624135375022888,
-0.1407553106546402,
0.8044367432594299,
0.9429656267166138,
-0.016938813030719757,
1.3031686544418335,
-0.3687008321285248,
0.4315868318080902,
1.2836294174194336,
-0.4903161823749542,
0.9599124193191528,
0.6089036464691162,
0.16766101121902466,
0.7353638410568237,
0.2255571037530899,
0.3328153192996979,
0.5742461085319519,
0.28848591446876526,
-0.6156615614891052,
0.09578190743923187,
-0.3232865333557129,
-0.502223014831543,
0.5663514137268066,
0.2734411656856537,
-0.5475618243217468,
-0.09399564564228058,
0.22471056878566742,
-0.2102767527103424,
0.3260149657726288,
-0.32630327343940735,
0.6743309497833252,
-0.14655801653862,
-0.9224926233291626,
1.0205202102661133,
-0.06875154376029968,
0.6737962365150452,
-0.2580622136592865,
-0.3303225636482239,
-0.36666420102119446,
0.27495720982551575,
-0.26671990752220154,
-0.6453207731246948,
0.36078405380249023,
0.3746799826622009,
-0.3260585069656372,
-0.16267001628875732,
1.1083875894546509,
-0.40982112288475037,
-0.37349244952201843,
0.2269553542137146,
0.42884519696235657,
-0.1246374100446701,
0.09424605220556259,
-0.39796727895736694,
0.6503750681877136,
-0.04188860207796097,
-0.27788296341896057,
-0.09996239840984344,
0.6467248201370239,
0.05011659115552902,
0.5837023854255676,
0.24778249859809875,
0.009204268455505371,
0.0834043100476265,
0.006683217827230692,
1.033646583557129,
-0.8838847279548645,
-0.34633198380470276,
-0.5863489508628845,
0.6152819395065308,
-0.2609582841396332,
-0.44698524475097656,
0.7381561398506165,
0.6210459470748901,
0.721071720123291,
0.07606618106365204,
0.8628794550895691,
-0.27222663164138794,
0.5784316062927246,
-0.5944844484329224,
0.7037910223007202,
-0.6746134757995605,
0.5745089650154114,
-0.41522032022476196,
-1.0138884782791138,
-0.010265732184052467,
0.6260520219802856,
-0.1523173451423645,
0.16334699094295502,
0.6401265859603882,
0.5915170311927795,
-0.09062577039003372,
-0.10584801435470581,
0.3472793400287628,
0.09241707623004913,
0.20184573531150818,
0.16195814311504364,
1.0825761556625366,
-0.9338400363922119,
0.17180006206035614,
0.1790628433227539,
0.17175571620464325,
-0.416958749294281,
-0.69937664270401,
-0.7291934490203857,
-0.7759993076324463,
-0.0828307569026947,
-0.5752774477005005,
0.27041009068489075,
0.5208786725997925,
0.25439804792404175,
-0.47951939702033997,
-0.21036742627620697,
-0.23758149147033691,
0.22141584753990173,
0.21041721105575562,
-0.2935221493244171,
0.11105111241340637,
-0.4740997850894928,
-0.610205888748169,
0.3608552813529968,
0.5378648638725281,
-0.22657857835292816,
-0.22820979356765747,
-0.15532304346561432,
-0.1783660501241684,
0.07642191648483276,
0.9422251582145691,
0.15151721239089966,
-0.4926435351371765,
-0.20266179740428925,
-0.08933861553668976,
-0.17892616987228394,
0.24341391026973724,
1.1490496397018433,
-1.0888292789459229,
0.47724229097366333,
0.7950074672698975,
0.6565797328948975,
0.5908750891685486,
0.27188587188720703,
0.5351852178573608,
-0.7687934637069702,
-0.009698477573692799,
0.0798572450876236,
0.11345996707677841,
0.43448013067245483,
-0.1381685435771942,
0.6388348937034607,
0.09098654240369797,
-0.5135375261306763,
-1.1760557889938354,
0.4078995883464813,
-0.731909453868866,
0.03037344664335251,
1.1097761392593384,
-0.06197098270058632,
-0.18266405165195465,
-0.022038884460926056,
-0.4082009792327881,
0.2519720792770386,
-0.3346463739871979,
1.1023755073547363,
0.22926786541938782,
-0.16971898078918457,
-0.024166032671928406,
-0.17789919674396515,
0.3761803209781647,
0.1521068960428238,
-1.1003371477127075,
-0.060150183737277985,
0.5870867371559143,
-0.28214454650878906,
0.5549408197402954,
0.6780272126197815,
-0.2199554294347763,
0.4457288980484009,
0.18419136106967926,
-0.18296149373054504,
0.22918036580085754,
-0.3406362235546112,
-0.18444542586803436,
0.4886189103126526,
-0.039420511573553085,
0.2949788570404053
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11858v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11858v1
|
GPT-4 as Evaluator: Evaluating Large Language Models on Pest Management in Agriculture
| 2024-03-18T15:08:01 | 2024-03-18T15:08:01 |
Shanglong Yang, Zhipeng Yuan, Shunbao Li, Ruoling Peng, Kang Liu, Po Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In the rapidly evolving field of artificial intelligence (AI), the
application of large language models (LLMs) in agriculture, particularly in
pest management, remains nascent. We aimed to prove the feasibility by
evaluating the content of the pest management advice generated by LLMs,
including the Generative Pre-trained Transformer (GPT) series from OpenAI and
the FLAN series from Google. Considering the context-specific properties of
agricultural advice, automatically measuring or quantifying the quality of text
generated by LLMs becomes a significant challenge. We proposed an innovative
approach, using GPT-4 as an evaluator, to score the generated content on
Coherence, Logical Consistency, Fluency, Relevance, Comprehensibility, and
Exhaustiveness. Additionally, we integrated an expert system based on crop
threshold data as a baseline to obtain scores for Factual Accuracy on whether
pests found in crop fields should take management action. Each model's score
was weighted by percentage to obtain a final score. The results showed that
GPT-3.4 and GPT-4 outperform the FLAN models in most evaluation categories.
Furthermore, the use of instruction-based prompting containing domain-specific
knowledge proved the feasibility of LLMs as an effective tool in agriculture,
with an accuracy rate of 72%, demonstrating LLMs' effectiveness in providing
pest management suggestions.
|
[
-0.3139003813266754,
-0.7524270415306091,
0.7474925518035889,
0.12302442640066147,
-0.16362273693084717,
-0.09086340665817261,
-0.547439455986023,
-0.41695594787597656,
0.043468177318573,
0.0730430856347084,
0.026363231241703033,
-0.6972373723983765,
-0.7710723280906677,
0.46085864305496216,
-0.6111427545547485,
1.1925256252288818,
-0.17423421144485474,
-0.03560696914792061,
-0.3585064113140106,
0.09260441362857819,
-0.4269616901874542,
-0.5585029125213623,
-0.7447768449783325,
-0.2154390662908554,
0.4690638780593872,
0.17494209110736847,
0.8051880598068237,
0.10469861328601837,
0.8560250997543335,
0.38995489478111267,
-0.20317943394184113,
0.05698426812887192,
-0.3462366461753845,
-0.2524888813495636,
-0.3868204355239868,
-0.37571004033088684,
-0.4771285653114319,
0.4823335111141205,
0.25315240025520325,
0.3272584080696106,
-0.2057516723871231,
0.14628176391124725,
0.27414456009864807,
0.1691180318593979,
-0.2664037048816681,
0.3439488410949707,
-0.6899005174636841,
0.16319967806339264,
0.011055358685553074,
-0.37408211827278137,
-0.3690396547317505,
-0.46317213773727417,
0.2191617786884308,
-0.7349705100059509,
0.11487860232591629,
-0.12021157890558243,
0.9811745882034302,
0.2950062155723572,
-0.09666451066732407,
-0.4640263319015503,
-0.9283344149589539,
0.5897774696350098,
-0.7874282598495483,
-0.24746175110340118,
0.5010741353034973,
0.44863617420196533,
-0.19868533313274384,
-0.6651869416236877,
-0.5277953743934631,
-0.4731956124305725,
0.09479329735040665,
0.33680933713912964,
-0.35324567556381226,
0.014529475942254066,
-0.01864570565521717,
0.423166424036026,
-0.458674818277359,
0.09730985015630722,
-0.3214576244354248,
-0.3760354518890381,
0.3789668083190918,
0.10861167311668396,
0.19745907187461853,
-0.014255907386541367,
-0.3134482800960541,
0.10710175335407257,
-0.3675522208213806,
0.1323258876800537,
0.1850457489490509,
0.1313132792711258,
0.16476674377918243,
0.6284406781196594,
0.08667337149381638,
0.6230669021606445,
0.1579963117837906,
-0.12404771894216537,
-0.006275595631450415,
-0.591770350933075,
-0.16376717388629913,
-0.45004376769065857,
0.909703254699707,
0.4785609841346741,
0.19928140938282013,
0.01090381108224392,
-0.43254518508911133,
0.27195242047309875,
0.49548256397247314,
-0.5348808169364929,
-0.34574630856513977,
0.13133136928081512,
-0.30553826689720154,
-0.6274299621582031,
0.10919173061847687,
-1.0491405725479126,
-0.2635071277618408,
-0.17997495830059052,
0.5710452198982239,
-0.5482800006866455,
-0.1810954511165619,
-0.0800635814666748,
-0.12393345683813095,
0.5523591637611389,
0.3502714931964874,
-0.6382769346237183,
0.2294585257768631,
0.866782546043396,
0.9610925912857056,
-0.35675257444381714,
-0.23846600949764252,
-0.2804121673107147,
-0.0670158863067627,
-0.45318174362182617,
0.8938890695571899,
-0.8327857851982117,
-0.326447069644928,
-0.15976014733314514,
-0.15924209356307983,
-0.24292641878128052,
-0.6291614174842834,
0.5956657528877258,
-0.6547724008560181,
0.2867352366447449,
-0.003349765669554472,
-0.5468407869338989,
-0.4796103537082672,
0.71055006980896,
-0.5578809976577759,
0.7847656011581421,
0.6382542848587036,
-0.47599756717681885,
0.5532165765762329,
-0.7639899253845215,
-0.31364741921424866,
0.3947921693325043,
-0.2936640977859497,
-0.5985212326049805,
-0.17386679351329803,
0.2719925343990326,
0.26556000113487244,
-0.3002995550632477,
0.2171434462070465,
-0.10722337663173676,
-0.15000425279140472,
0.23123756051063538,
-0.6464707255363464,
0.3259902000427246,
0.09633765369653702,
-0.4796977639198303,
0.47208890318870544,
-0.33102479577064514,
0.007912426255643368,
0.2476179003715515,
-0.5460404753684998,
-0.0764331966638565,
-0.1731032282114029,
-0.2155640721321106,
-0.1334150731563568,
0.18746347725391388,
-0.32244694232940674,
0.20229418575763702,
-0.6509978175163269,
0.4780716896057129,
0.5862795114517212,
0.10077828168869019,
0.2289740890264511,
-0.42526596784591675,
0.8828405141830444,
-0.10535121709108353,
0.23271699249744415,
-0.05768068507313728,
-0.7090620398521423,
-0.5658467411994934,
-0.133840411901474,
0.3708266019821167,
0.5460293889045715,
-0.9058507680892944,
0.5036047101020813,
-0.36977940797805786,
-0.44442614912986755,
0.04098573327064514,
0.014236231334507465,
0.08876276761293411,
0.40940532088279724,
0.40181779861450195,
-0.265727698802948,
-0.105567067861557,
-0.48604005575180054,
-0.3425763249397278,
0.2105557918548584,
0.0665166974067688,
-0.08724244683980942,
0.7323339581489563,
-0.2042347490787506,
1.1549869775772095,
-0.5742341876029968,
-0.26498860120773315,
-0.42392411828041077,
0.21394555270671844,
0.33660566806793213,
0.10626278817653656,
0.9501789212226868,
-0.7671146988868713,
-0.7127243876457214,
0.2747960090637207,
-0.5684846639633179,
-0.04137305170297623,
0.2521771788597107,
0.06575974076986313,
0.08337847888469696,
-0.17306454479694366,
-0.878284752368927,
0.6547410488128662,
0.5898345708847046,
-0.38865578174591064,
0.8948646783828735,
-0.27697011828422546,
0.34181660413742065,
-0.8368934392929077,
-0.03251170367002487,
0.2332097589969635,
-0.44202813506126404,
-0.5447061657905579,
0.04710453748703003,
-0.25046342611312866,
-0.20569615066051483,
-0.36389994621276855,
0.24257998168468475,
-0.17951619625091553,
-0.08547051250934601,
-0.42775049805641174,
0.19711808860301971,
0.0297855231910944,
0.41670510172843933,
-0.41341620683670044,
1.1991667747497559,
0.4479942321777344,
-0.5287550687789917,
0.7439852356910706,
0.2162817120552063,
-0.27241259813308716,
0.66978520154953,
-0.4037073254585266,
-0.0486505851149559,
0.09067580103874207,
0.21420077979564667,
-0.737305223941803,
-0.25951746106147766,
0.7413548827171326,
-0.317664235830307,
0.284013956785202,
0.05855410918593407,
-0.1968948394060135,
-0.7490559816360474,
-0.2884402275085449,
0.17363905906677246,
0.49071207642555237,
-0.3470519781112671,
0.9824532270431519,
-0.016825204715132713,
-0.46532392501831055,
0.06950516998767853,
-0.19526241719722748,
0.22481536865234375,
-0.5326206088066101,
-0.39650318026542664,
-0.1572120189666748,
0.006982420105487108,
-0.18000280857086182,
0.19515067338943481,
-0.2978801727294922,
-0.13492260873317719,
-0.0459497906267643,
0.01134456042200327,
-0.044651348143815994,
-0.2205229103565216,
-0.10250817984342575,
-0.128032848238945,
-0.17182880640029907,
0.3090975880622864,
-0.6404452919960022,
0.40159520506858826,
-0.16484683752059937,
-0.3954866826534271,
-0.5339861512184143,
0.021216070279479027,
0.5463123321533203,
-0.4878089427947998,
0.34177738428115845,
0.4282229244709015,
-0.1809501349925995,
-0.10606981068849564,
-0.2820030748844147,
0.04960992559790611,
-0.4827578663825989,
0.3289765417575836,
-0.3210529088973999,
-0.5556833148002625,
0.021455543115735054,
-0.4827445149421692,
-0.06074699014425278,
0.797515869140625,
0.25756582617759705,
-0.018907437101006508,
0.7671877145767212,
0.5669785141944885,
-0.356346994638443,
0.20967140793800354,
-0.539678692817688,
0.19427676498889923,
-0.48552122712135315,
-0.31902286410331726,
-0.46000444889068604,
-0.1307331621646881,
-0.08513426780700684,
-0.6969500780105591,
0.6405890583992004,
-0.08900830149650574,
-0.2248142659664154,
0.10845313221216202,
-0.4913042485713959,
0.502095103263855,
0.45719021558761597,
0.09250672161579132,
0.2544978857040405,
0.1465969830751419,
-0.05724063515663147,
0.4012072682380676,
-0.538783073425293,
-0.9201238751411438,
0.9531285166740417,
0.39956730604171753,
0.5421953201293945,
0.03888225555419922,
0.25584933161735535,
0.6069496273994446,
0.7942519783973694,
-1.1631486415863037,
0.584551990032196,
-0.24060073494911194,
-0.09770805388689041,
-0.48865246772766113,
-0.5732242465019226,
-1.0355095863342285,
0.26720455288887024,
0.041442640125751495,
-0.6740554571151733,
-0.29223886132240295,
0.22352465987205505,
-0.47919633984565735,
0.26240167021751404,
-0.6149545907974243,
0.8448600769042969,
-0.6418867111206055,
0.07537184655666351,
-0.24335035681724548,
-0.09877936542034149,
0.28703075647354126,
-0.49194517731666565,
0.3535057306289673,
-0.13331371545791626,
-0.07458499819040298,
0.8246366381645203,
-0.7329912781715393,
0.8144856095314026,
-0.2703292965888977,
-0.4250912666320801,
0.6576888561248779,
0.034348875284194946,
0.6673966646194458,
-0.09909850358963013,
-0.28613921999931335,
0.44972220063209534,
0.010148626752197742,
0.0004582276160363108,
-0.6414701342582703,
0.6491682529449463,
-0.8914350271224976,
-0.7274079918861389,
-0.6254124641418457,
-0.2560509741306305,
-0.09388725459575653,
0.2524038851261139,
0.280010849237442,
0.29818040132522583,
-0.12720713019371033,
0.03186800703406334,
0.23820531368255615,
-0.2827607989311218,
0.3412739932537079,
0.4577842950820923,
-0.37492355704307556,
-0.6780990362167358,
1.0022563934326172,
0.03456242009997368,
-0.06594464927911758,
0.3156237304210663,
0.6708329916000366,
-0.253558874130249,
-0.5551156997680664,
-0.40491607785224915,
-0.08711917698383331,
-0.6932088732719421,
-0.5887351632118225,
-0.4467083811759949,
-0.33518773317337036,
-0.11630579084157944,
0.05388444662094116,
0.06988655775785446,
0.04734037443995476,
-0.4593719244003296,
-0.18394312262535095,
0.5485684275627136,
1.2498674392700195,
0.35244277119636536,
0.6013648509979248,
-0.8658562898635864,
0.2988797724246979,
0.08354704082012177,
0.5056185126304626,
-0.03951682150363922,
-0.5289994478225708,
-0.2654280662536621,
0.2915017306804657,
-0.6665052175521851,
-1.2127134799957275,
0.5687215924263,
0.3069145083427429,
0.5050262808799744,
0.43106091022491455,
-0.2569069266319275,
0.1927548050880432,
-0.3832527697086334,
1.0827414989471436,
0.12971153855323792,
-1.091109275817871,
0.410062700510025,
-0.4056883752346039,
0.2603341042995453,
0.11898469924926758,
0.5989841818809509,
-0.04520590230822563,
-0.5441552400588989,
-0.019123759120702744,
-0.8094912171363831,
0.6090215444564819,
0.34387025237083435,
-0.14722666144371033,
0.2014438360929489,
0.40027421712875366,
0.2261711061000824,
0.18329723179340363,
-0.6143231987953186,
0.12666158378124237,
-0.45723026990890503,
-0.5564512014389038,
-0.1860399693250656,
-0.3507910966873169,
-0.14532333612442017,
-0.38062524795532227,
0.5574935078620911,
0.003604851895943284,
0.12217214703559875,
0.02313055843114853,
0.037421226501464844,
-0.153188094496727,
0.45551562309265137,
0.5902862548828125,
0.9668574929237366,
0.2286553531885147,
0.17014846205711365,
0.29411038756370544,
-0.6903538703918457,
0.39926648139953613,
0.15936923027038574,
-0.43439802527427673,
-0.2535208761692047,
0.32936325669288635,
0.5287615060806274,
0.13930629193782806,
-0.14941518008708954,
0.7006892561912537,
0.099531389772892,
-0.5244969129562378,
-0.3828900158405304,
0.08292567729949951,
-0.25130462646484375,
0.137983039021492,
0.33534562587738037,
0.1459244340658188,
0.17014002799987793,
-0.03853214159607887,
0.17614169418811798,
0.3597680926322937,
-0.12933088839054108,
-0.4538356065750122,
0.5104847550392151,
0.46239614486694336,
-0.24145324528217316,
0.46458038687705994,
-0.3756379187107086,
-0.9064674377441406,
0.7614423632621765,
0.549282968044281,
0.6989603042602539,
-0.2156820148229599,
0.33189183473587036,
0.14907604455947876,
0.42492973804473877,
0.04353639483451843,
0.4363041818141937,
0.2875326871871948,
-0.5499733686447144,
-0.5728273987770081,
-0.8747984170913696,
-0.3471930921077728,
0.46980950236320496,
-0.23669199645519257,
0.08523191511631012,
-0.33050844073295593,
-0.4841708540916443,
0.03187962621450424,
-0.09874459356069565,
-0.7056755423545837,
0.2455136626958847,
-0.1998453140258789,
1.0283832550048828,
-0.7336020469665527,
0.4504740536212921,
0.9274988770484924,
-0.5387200117111206,
-1.0488471984863281,
0.27379006147384644,
-0.1175975576043129,
-0.43313533067703247,
0.41267481446266174,
0.29793018102645874,
-0.15853507816791534,
0.09700421988964081,
-0.7179907560348511,
-1.0414968729019165,
0.8293073177337646,
-0.09072985500097275,
-0.5474373698234558,
0.26594972610473633,
0.35844650864601135,
0.6206568479537964,
-0.023801082745194435,
0.4195832312107086,
0.5725977420806885,
0.9535293579101562,
0.043508511036634445,
-0.9880992770195007,
-0.10817144066095352,
-0.07622937858104706,
-0.008759868331253529,
0.26954343914985657,
-0.5473869442939758,
0.6103118658065796,
0.07814379036426544,
-0.33583328127861023,
0.2904902398586273,
0.8878908157348633,
-0.27340269088745117,
0.53272545337677,
0.5652944445610046,
0.42055296897888184,
0.6463611721992493,
-0.28304457664489746,
0.9507330656051636,
-0.5361180901527405,
0.43363380432128906,
0.9604065418243408,
-0.3296471834182739,
0.6977270245552063,
0.08189109712839127,
-0.4479365348815918,
0.44103699922561646,
0.5259480476379395,
-0.3651927709579468,
0.2960440218448639,
0.38422659039497375,
-0.274027556180954,
0.023631028831005096,
0.061267055571079254,
-0.2869468927383423,
0.6301696300506592,
0.5275007486343384,
-0.15153664350509644,
-0.29677072167396545,
0.39542195200920105,
-0.12868431210517883,
0.27112525701522827,
-0.5219166874885559,
0.8906576037406921,
0.0607425831258297,
-0.641655683517456,
0.20002809166908264,
0.1494816541671753,
0.6346705555915833,
-0.7015649080276489,
-0.2509692311286926,
-0.058282624930143356,
0.1506941318511963,
-0.24824289977550507,
-0.9547373652458191,
0.4952603876590729,
0.26990142464637756,
-0.11663661152124405,
0.020305877551436424,
0.5891351699829102,
-0.3665313124656677,
-0.5412507653236389,
0.07037342339754105,
0.1479937732219696,
0.37382036447525024,
-0.29973340034484863,
-0.39407965540885925,
0.03444557636976242,
-0.3510188162326813,
-0.2099926918745041,
-0.1411457359790802,
0.3776208460330963,
-0.1177596002817154,
0.5053861737251282,
0.5101569890975952,
0.3139423131942749,
-0.04342823103070259,
0.01693863421678543,
1.054938554763794,
-0.6124723553657532,
-0.31064480543136597,
-0.868294358253479,
0.0908694714307785,
-0.09167805314064026,
0.028089987114071846,
1.039739966392517,
0.5647565126419067,
0.79341059923172,
-0.1804734319448471,
1.0715653896331787,
-0.0041529955342411995,
0.27936360239982605,
-0.3186744153499603,
0.5996858477592468,
-0.2206360101699829,
0.14677946269512177,
-0.02872898057103157,
-0.9143940806388855,
-0.0786735787987709,
0.3799143135547638,
-0.7931213974952698,
0.39352694153785706,
0.7133133411407471,
0.5129075050354004,
0.030981840565800667,
0.024318939074873924,
0.3728470802307129,
0.4223557412624359,
0.5900411009788513,
0.34066957235336304,
1.2209762334823608,
0.0973072499036789,
0.747127890586853,
0.11093328148126602,
-0.565168559551239,
-0.15025071799755096,
-0.9065480828285217,
-0.6540160179138184,
0.01602545566856861,
-0.08820483088493347,
-0.036616817116737366,
0.1223621591925621,
0.8805683255195618,
0.4123663604259491,
-0.8896128535270691,
0.06144513934850693,
-0.08983192592859268,
-0.1351149082183838,
-0.3411051332950592,
-0.3249191641807556,
0.4178583025932312,
-0.38756632804870605,
-0.4521026611328125,
0.4547788202762604,
0.45872682332992554,
0.1493661254644394,
-0.3946762979030609,
-0.042957428842782974,
0.1683097779750824,
0.10234381258487701,
0.682901918888092,
0.09209249168634415,
-0.9083032608032227,
-0.29605573415756226,
-0.22962887585163116,
-0.05747155845165253,
-0.012821224518120289,
0.6326518654823303,
-0.520940363407135,
0.27688074111938477,
0.3278487026691437,
0.5119675397872925,
-0.09370892494916916,
0.41627779603004456,
0.7881242036819458,
-0.3451947867870331,
-0.2714313268661499,
0.36838799715042114,
0.15717573463916779,
0.259692519903183,
-0.6761408448219299,
0.3866691291332245,
0.1374155730009079,
-0.6779994964599609,
-0.10143560916185379,
0.07229742407798767,
-0.6861205101013184,
-0.18097682297229767,
1.3269939422607422,
-0.5146885514259338,
-0.244341179728508,
-0.050789400935173035,
-0.4734576344490051,
0.17588020861148834,
-0.36080941557884216,
0.6117784380912781,
0.5473424792289734,
0.054975006729364395,
-0.07547048479318619,
-0.2990266978740692,
0.49428439140319824,
0.13595864176750183,
-1.0695782899856567,
-0.4541945457458496,
0.46334803104400635,
0.27268585562705994,
0.1857006996870041,
0.5787336826324463,
0.1213625967502594,
-0.05438540503382683,
-0.22863249480724335,
0.028159242123365402,
-0.1581481397151947,
-0.5694928169250488,
-0.3838297724723816,
0.19935429096221924,
0.3197081685066223,
-0.06696054339408875
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11838v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11838v2
|
Ensuring Safe and High-Quality Outputs: A Guideline Library Approach for Language Models
| 2024-03-18T14:48:29 | 2024-03-23T06:26:41 |
Yi Luo, Zhenghao Lin, Yuhao Zhang, Jiashuo Sun, Chen Lin, Chengjin Xu, Xiangdong Su, Yelong Shen, Jian Guo, Yeyun Gong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) exhibit impressive capabilities but also present
risks such as biased content generation and privacy issues. One of the current
alignment techniques includes principle-driven integration, but it faces
challenges arising from the imprecision of manually crafted rules and
inadequate risk perception in models without safety training. To address these,
we introduce Guide-Align, a two-stage approach. Initially, a safety-trained
model identifies potential risks and formulates specific guidelines for various
inputs, establishing a comprehensive library of guidelines and a model for
input-guidelines retrieval. Subsequently, the retrieval model correlates new
inputs with relevant guidelines, which guide LLMs in response generation to
ensure safe and high-quality outputs, thereby aligning with human values. An
additional optional stage involves fine-tuning a model with well-aligned
datasets generated through the process implemented in the second stage. Our
method customizes guidelines to accommodate diverse inputs, thereby enhancing
the fine-grainedness and comprehensiveness of the guideline library.
Furthermore, it incorporates safety expertise from a safety-trained LLM through
a lightweight retrieval model. We evaluate our approach on three benchmarks,
demonstrating significant improvements in LLM security and quality. Notably,
our fine-tuned model, Labrador, even at 13 billion parameters, outperforms
GPT-3.5-turbo and surpasses GPT-4 in alignment capabilities.
|
[
-0.12862257659435272,
-0.3730235695838928,
0.5959150791168213,
-0.17393091320991516,
-0.2731698453426361,
-0.0570848323404789,
-0.12358023971319199,
-0.3488669693470001,
-0.39512133598327637,
0.8109194040298462,
-0.4812403619289398,
-0.6923498511314392,
-0.5273374915122986,
-0.2806353271007538,
-0.46531662344932556,
1.1202279329299927,
-0.06530888378620148,
0.22446586191654205,
0.016505734995007515,
-0.014390159398317337,
-0.4885566234588623,
-0.3603282570838928,
-0.6085623502731323,
-0.3451458811759949,
0.709010660648346,
0.2730623185634613,
0.9486099481582642,
1.0878673791885376,
0.773359477519989,
0.09432162344455719,
-0.16858501732349396,
0.2916869819164276,
-0.5121064186096191,
0.12174680083990097,
-0.40817704796791077,
0.08860470354557037,
-0.7368513941764832,
0.017043665051460266,
0.510586678981781,
0.6343193650245667,
-0.3451242744922638,
0.007451648823916912,
0.5101689696311951,
0.6343027353286743,
-0.5683320760726929,
-0.12801848351955414,
-0.4312320649623871,
-0.2875840961933136,
-0.14121921360492706,
-0.17535696923732758,
-0.5557242631912231,
-0.7328077554702759,
0.0938607007265091,
-0.5502713918685913,
-0.13790369033813477,
0.21250417828559875,
1.0394762754440308,
0.402920663356781,
-0.405419260263443,
-0.27935272455215454,
-0.690998911857605,
0.6828893423080444,
-0.8615214228630066,
0.5015443563461304,
0.27368828654289246,
0.21709416806697845,
-0.4270867109298706,
-0.4049731492996216,
-0.18690894544124603,
0.14566445350646973,
-0.10544484853744507,
-0.21621979773044586,
0.18538641929626465,
0.17740948498249054,
0.09975910186767578,
0.012143841944634914,
-0.7942879796028137,
0.300782710313797,
-0.13480916619300842,
-0.36325332522392273,
0.7918232083320618,
0.04549882933497429,
0.14410912990570068,
-0.0025236301589757204,
-0.3392189145088196,
-0.23069876432418823,
-1.0177466869354248,
-0.15720070898532867,
0.7157313823699951,
0.6616092324256897,
0.10810525715351105,
0.49638280272483826,
-0.14594745635986328,
0.6830695867538452,
0.21818041801452637,
-0.4496349096298218,
0.030640801414847374,
-0.7012720704078674,
-0.08916392922401428,
0.2999866008758545,
0.9374009370803833,
0.5117888450622559,
0.25212642550468445,
-0.17649678885936737,
-0.292888879776001,
-0.3039945363998413,
0.3119797110557556,
-0.6249529123306274,
0.010738118551671505,
0.16559943556785583,
-0.27445346117019653,
-0.478107750415802,
-0.028502866625785828,
-0.5711153149604797,
-0.6676676869392395,
-0.5330190658569336,
0.4886442720890045,
-0.41062283515930176,
-0.1507684588432312,
0.1328582465648651,
0.3237726390361786,
0.5694106221199036,
0.28377559781074524,
-0.9392555952072144,
0.37113237380981445,
0.9894182085990906,
0.6585014462471008,
-0.19805119931697845,
0.05536679923534393,
-0.7098595499992371,
0.5141378045082092,
-0.3452179729938507,
0.4843514561653137,
-0.257242351770401,
-0.20135802030563354,
0.2146579623222351,
0.08810430020093918,
0.31821972131729126,
-0.1709427684545517,
0.9238671064376831,
-0.621100902557373,
0.07526814937591553,
-0.21056190133094788,
-0.49861329793930054,
0.02013011835515499,
0.16604498028755188,
-0.4516465961933136,
0.927725613117218,
-0.15700019896030426,
-0.7440921664237976,
0.3482346534729004,
-0.10601077228784561,
-0.5080021023750305,
-0.12442748248577118,
-0.15213985741138458,
-0.3702981770038605,
-0.2003684788942337,
0.2600824236869812,
0.23422104120254517,
-0.3502260744571686,
0.6922067403793335,
-0.3276023864746094,
-0.13587120175361633,
0.012163071893155575,
-0.3042512834072113,
0.6723661422729492,
0.24212028086185455,
-0.12348855286836624,
0.2621976137161255,
-0.7378576397895813,
0.14151903986930847,
-0.21053531765937805,
-0.5458013415336609,
-0.3703247308731079,
0.16474826633930206,
0.049338191747665405,
0.2952788472175598,
0.4987252652645111,
-0.4114908277988434,
-0.038469087332487106,
-0.29352787137031555,
0.15607604384422302,
0.9255800247192383,
-0.1466519683599472,
0.6671665906906128,
-0.2480192929506302,
0.30247068405151367,
-0.18848514556884766,
0.3984335958957672,
0.0012994263088330626,
-0.24285471439361572,
-0.5007086396217346,
0.06567663699388504,
0.3338487446308136,
0.633480429649353,
-0.20037835836410522,
0.8696860074996948,
-0.21728777885437012,
-0.3671484887599945,
-0.5494886040687561,
0.49189865589141846,
0.5679393410682678,
0.685075581073761,
0.1729993373155594,
-0.3160344958305359,
-0.6166057586669922,
-0.9149523377418518,
-0.07878218591213226,
-0.2682506740093231,
0.07021514326334,
0.008075546473264694,
0.05381367728114128,
-0.21107669174671173,
1.0035732984542847,
-0.3951348066329956,
-0.1431148648262024,
-0.10215394198894501,
0.013453860767185688,
0.1275414079427719,
0.7298356890678406,
0.1383814662694931,
-0.501082718372345,
-0.3892104923725128,
0.18750233948230743,
-0.817649245262146,
-0.31680506467819214,
0.19551138579845428,
-0.6707653999328613,
0.2216048389673233,
0.48400554060935974,
-0.20225660502910614,
0.04616180434823036,
0.6641371846199036,
-0.1654672920703888,
0.21425911784172058,
-0.1000906303524971,
-0.17715756595134735,
-1.3424698114395142,
0.026095788925886154,
0.16713254153728485,
-0.3595626950263977,
-0.6656212210655212,
-0.07886780798435211,
0.22981169819831848,
-0.06832669675350189,
-0.30351459980010986,
0.5971443057060242,
-0.31976479291915894,
0.10578510910272598,
-0.23665982484817505,
0.11981832981109619,
0.18173213303089142,
0.13935710489749908,
0.018676966428756714,
0.6529016494750977,
0.5052847862243652,
-0.4470231831073761,
0.2950681149959564,
0.2155441790819168,
-0.21185052394866943,
0.6021404266357422,
-0.5382547378540039,
0.1442461907863617,
-0.17313101887702942,
0.020614879205822945,
-0.8520222306251526,
-0.32145872712135315,
0.24263469874858856,
-0.0681133046746254,
0.7165545225143433,
-0.2973831593990326,
-0.5935299396514893,
0.002473891479894519,
-0.37588998675346375,
0.18084809184074402,
0.6913927793502808,
-0.38317686319351196,
0.5762567520141602,
0.5386688709259033,
-0.4436705708503723,
-0.9196616411209106,
-0.39530637860298157,
-0.01912040449678898,
-0.3127724826335907,
-0.6758859157562256,
0.12823185324668884,
-0.14990071952342987,
-0.08227751404047012,
-0.041990622878074646,
-0.19968608021736145,
0.01413821242749691,
0.17228767275810242,
0.20748965442180634,
0.34292611479759216,
-0.10062529891729355,
-0.06754075735807419,
0.10172708332538605,
-0.12690666317939758,
-0.023752467706799507,
-0.37892377376556396,
0.4036189317703247,
0.026286322623491287,
-0.42018893361091614,
-0.3868991434574127,
0.34041956067085266,
0.4670502543449402,
-0.21564103662967682,
0.6371768116950989,
0.41990330815315247,
-0.4538096785545349,
0.07765021920204163,
-0.7026310563087463,
-0.1476661115884781,
-0.4829106628894806,
0.22515714168548584,
0.09389103204011917,
-0.7091376781463623,
0.32443955540657043,
0.10849571228027344,
0.3621702790260315,
0.119520403444767,
0.3922918736934662,
-0.26113662123680115,
1.319217324256897,
0.9640653729438782,
0.016651492565870285,
0.4949970841407776,
0.383920282125473,
0.4314778447151184,
-0.8632710576057434,
-0.31225889921188354,
-0.5591330528259277,
-0.01782640814781189,
-0.4894084334373474,
-0.1647735983133316,
0.2456202656030655,
0.32603615522384644,
-0.4730757772922516,
0.44844359159469604,
-0.4406881630420685,
0.4173620045185089,
0.5209360718727112,
0.07179083675146103,
0.34332385659217834,
-0.04875896871089935,
-0.15612885355949402,
-0.051831070333719254,
-0.5490121245384216,
-1.034380555152893,
1.2293872833251953,
0.6213183403015137,
1.4582170248031616,
0.3907344937324524,
0.8906664252281189,
-0.032953061163425446,
0.32242923974990845,
-0.6700514554977417,
0.5287397503852844,
-0.23815444111824036,
-0.6490208506584167,
-0.26226872205734253,
-0.28552132844924927,
-0.5979252457618713,
-0.04655391350388527,
-0.17685014009475708,
-0.7630189657211304,
0.02612731046974659,
0.24811840057373047,
-0.489080011844635,
-0.03664365038275719,
-0.585472047328949,
0.7618309855461121,
-0.6377807855606079,
-0.7570648193359375,
0.1915929615497589,
-0.7298937439918518,
0.5591596364974976,
-0.4172213673591614,
0.38827311992645264,
-0.23393741250038147,
0.08681020140647888,
0.758284866809845,
-0.27662602066993713,
0.8332101106643677,
0.07122413069009781,
-0.523788332939148,
0.010304609313607216,
0.008215155452489853,
0.6911571621894836,
-0.07893340289592743,
-0.17085082828998566,
-0.23809072375297546,
0.05272747948765755,
-0.1506359726190567,
-0.34443798661231995,
0.8477909564971924,
-0.7427340745925903,
-0.7043936848640442,
-0.36303040385246277,
-0.813624918460846,
-0.2853609323501587,
0.4420495927333832,
-0.008014150895178318,
0.368178129196167,
-0.1515420377254486,
0.0687163695693016,
1.0627564191818237,
-0.21599043905735016,
0.2999219596385956,
0.7134267687797546,
-0.11720724403858185,
-0.5015840530395508,
0.7418271899223328,
0.0027748241554945707,
0.4461004436016083,
0.14853012561798096,
0.17858393490314484,
-0.5862013101577759,
-0.7252063155174255,
-0.41795721650123596,
0.40167391300201416,
-1.001142978668213,
-0.31555595993995667,
-0.40338268876075745,
-0.41399046778678894,
-0.69275963306427,
-0.13502702116966248,
-0.2389518916606903,
-0.04433757811784744,
-0.21452021598815918,
-0.08954484760761261,
0.3120644688606262,
0.7349592447280884,
-0.06470826268196106,
0.3389243185520172,
-0.9108896255493164,
-0.07865564525127411,
0.20076212286949158,
0.48558616638183594,
-0.3817450702190399,
-0.6763145923614502,
-0.2682550251483917,
-0.24078719317913055,
-0.3888072371482849,
-0.7347057461738586,
0.18402454257011414,
0.09704563766717911,
0.7692943811416626,
0.5499784350395203,
0.16486035287380219,
0.5441307425498962,
-0.7068060636520386,
0.5208936333656311,
0.22502171993255615,
-0.7129818797111511,
0.594269335269928,
-0.5537392497062683,
0.019452255219221115,
0.7062352895736694,
0.32177233695983887,
-0.37571319937705994,
-0.3851204812526703,
-0.2995252311229706,
-0.8827388882637024,
0.5785530805587769,
-0.04937669262290001,
0.042124830186367035,
0.22128242254257202,
0.44731035828590393,
-0.005655518267303705,
0.23604851961135864,
-0.7310928702354431,
0.09125271439552307,
0.07967665046453476,
-0.7197080254554749,
0.11645899713039398,
-0.21268852055072784,
-0.6219784021377563,
0.08668401837348938,
0.9111459255218506,
-0.29459714889526367,
-0.3603364825248718,
-0.21728625893592834,
-0.019274331629276276,
-0.28081077337265015,
0.363605797290802,
0.522436797618866,
0.7115164995193481,
-0.4012964367866516,
0.1519596427679062,
-0.12060350924730301,
-0.3109458386898041,
0.28426826000213623,
0.2703556418418884,
-0.34801703691482544,
-0.2689206898212433,
0.30723288655281067,
0.4338204562664032,
0.22396966814994812,
-0.5027887225151062,
0.3589329421520233,
-0.14647574722766876,
-0.11677972972393036,
-0.0036324479151517153,
0.23077483475208282,
0.1941814124584198,
0.13782109320163727,
0.03698771819472313,
-0.12728458642959595,
-0.10082701593637466,
-0.37942275404930115,
0.38441628217697144,
0.607026219367981,
-0.45949965715408325,
-0.06491293013095856,
0.7371020913124084,
0.4015166759490967,
-0.2661512494087219,
0.27834564447402954,
-0.01709388755261898,
-0.15851342678070068,
0.3071900010108948,
0.41276443004608154,
0.8058667778968811,
-0.20823821425437927,
-0.11956726759672165,
0.47880086302757263,
0.5111117362976074,
-0.5325486063957214,
0.24986101686954498,
0.3666561245918274,
-0.7126716375350952,
-0.4384134113788605,
-0.8363164663314819,
-0.3515741527080536,
0.04608495905995369,
-0.8604337573051453,
0.4743134379386902,
-0.6495049595832825,
-0.13185343146324158,
-0.28624507784843445,
-0.17396511137485504,
-0.43345749378204346,
0.020988047122955322,
0.36876216530799866,
0.9339597821235657,
-1.0133774280548096,
1.052316427230835,
0.5644712448120117,
-0.4284358024597168,
-1.149343729019165,
0.017167625948786736,
0.23065263032913208,
-0.7116209864616394,
0.4246254563331604,
0.06158262863755226,
-0.21790239214897156,
-0.06954966485500336,
-0.5225275754928589,
-1.181925892829895,
1.19843590259552,
0.5298997759819031,
-0.9001005291938782,
-0.20246346294879913,
-0.010779017582535744,
0.4082130193710327,
-0.40344440937042236,
-0.14295706152915955,
0.8084779381752014,
0.3809862434864044,
0.21829628944396973,
-0.9922801852226257,
0.22806775569915771,
0.0797785297036171,
0.04891746863722801,
0.3042154610157013,
-0.3495248258113861,
0.5628566741943359,
-0.08536361902952194,
-0.21056002378463745,
0.14243215322494507,
0.3229503631591797,
0.40578916668891907,
-0.02252904139459133,
0.26218193769454956,
0.6584859490394592,
0.8699557185173035,
-0.196583092212677,
0.8905177712440491,
-0.5194804668426514,
0.23747743666172028,
1.3104069232940674,
-0.5953332781791687,
0.8560440540313721,
0.6288736462593079,
0.2085137665271759,
0.19934162497520447,
0.7775640487670898,
0.29042303562164307,
0.8686654567718506,
0.006508102174848318,
-0.13991649448871613,
-0.25831788778305054,
-0.4133240580558777,
-0.22090043127536774,
-0.045942142605781555,
0.2262813001871109,
-0.4385518729686737,
-0.2463049739599228,
-0.3726610839366913,
0.15124063193798065,
0.13908667862415314,
-0.2816388010978699,
0.9145724177360535,
0.024706903845071793,
-0.8116300702095032,
0.41001829504966736,
-0.16497205197811127,
0.5503657460212708,
-0.7719434499740601,
0.04874493554234505,
-0.2079329788684845,
0.330146849155426,
-0.32005587220191956,
-1.0384035110473633,
0.19608739018440247,
0.1680329591035843,
-0.12920546531677246,
-0.3288543224334717,
0.47128739953041077,
-0.6410377025604248,
-0.5564550161361694,
0.3491787314414978,
0.15390644967556,
-0.06457845121622086,
0.5164391994476318,
-0.5587539672851562,
0.2315170168876648,
-0.1597457230091095,
-0.030572272837162018,
0.547235906124115,
0.29576796293258667,
-0.16369470953941345,
0.5010743737220764,
0.5125072002410889,
0.051043927669525146,
0.06329117715358734,
0.22157958149909973,
0.916297197341919,
-0.34685051441192627,
-0.2321426272392273,
-0.8129745721817017,
0.6321512460708618,
-0.030593784525990486,
-0.03009963035583496,
0.47216394543647766,
0.4940858781337738,
0.7398446798324585,
0.370596319437027,
0.8658793568611145,
0.16097524762153625,
0.3413052260875702,
-0.7403052449226379,
0.5763075947761536,
-0.5292595624923706,
0.43154385685920715,
-0.2773050367832184,
-0.9311222434043884,
-0.41500920057296753,
0.5670072436332703,
-0.17883233726024628,
-0.20088393986225128,
0.6073970198631287,
1.1799442768096924,
-0.06137203425168991,
-0.3830360174179077,
0.16993242502212524,
-0.11354158073663712,
0.6679766774177551,
0.4061885178089142,
0.6035845875740051,
-0.4443736672401428,
0.8162702322006226,
-0.12397348880767822,
-0.2180936187505722,
-0.09805895388126373,
-1.3240858316421509,
-0.6831966042518616,
-0.25902315974235535,
-0.428576797246933,
-0.5841715931892395,
0.189719557762146,
0.9767841696739197,
0.8597419261932373,
-0.8155977129936218,
-0.3333190977573395,
-0.01190277561545372,
0.06020032986998558,
-0.09172103554010391,
-0.13611654937267303,
0.22961623966693878,
-0.34554269909858704,
-0.5829265713691711,
0.3095400631427765,
0.27438798546791077,
0.24562902748584747,
-0.36797407269477844,
-0.4448907673358917,
-0.17969031631946564,
0.12903670966625214,
0.1430792212486267,
0.14548639953136444,
-0.8746401071548462,
-0.5023536086082458,
-0.12130440771579742,
-0.6182030439376831,
-0.08500508964061737,
0.5140352249145508,
-0.1905265897512436,
0.4260066747665405,
0.484557181596756,
0.8240959048271179,
0.03914427384734154,
0.24526603519916534,
0.9412899613380432,
-0.811142086982727,
-0.06039360910654068,
0.10538789629936218,
0.5102990865707397,
0.5673081278800964,
-0.5033338665962219,
0.4924382269382477,
-0.372376412153244,
-0.7501832246780396,
-0.819803774356842,
0.47757041454315186,
-1.1389068365097046,
0.10973559319972992,
1.348004698753357,
-0.22334057092666626,
-0.19656212627887726,
-0.09694110602140427,
-0.290442556142807,
0.3869004547595978,
-0.4532931447029114,
0.5400902628898621,
0.8447458148002625,
-0.00915532186627388,
-0.2591378688812256,
-0.6067882776260376,
0.6479949951171875,
0.24693739414215088,
-0.7472780346870422,
0.34292855858802795,
0.5124444961547852,
0.4847651720046997,
0.12547346949577332,
0.2750771641731262,
-0.23523034155368805,
0.12241103500127792,
-0.5411005020141602,
0.16745546460151672,
0.1261448711156845,
-0.3347974121570587,
-0.559718668460846,
-0.010034949518740177,
0.6497868895530701,
-0.021899191662669182
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11834v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11834v1
|
Towards Understanding the Relationship between In-context Learning and Compositional Generalization
| 2024-03-18T14:45:52 | 2024-03-18T14:45:52 |
Sungjun Han, Sebastian Padó
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
According to the principle of compositional generalization, the meaning of a
complex expression can be understood as a function of the meaning of its parts
and of how they are combined. This principle is crucial for human language
processing and also, arguably, for NLP models in the face of
out-of-distribution data. However, many neural network models, including
Transformers, have been shown to struggle with compositional generalization. In
this paper, we hypothesize that forcing models to in-context learn can provide
an inductive bias to promote compositional generalization. To test this
hypothesis, we train a causal Transformer in a setting that renders ordinary
learning very difficult: we present it with different orderings of the training
instance and shuffle instance labels. This corresponds to training the model on
all possible few-shot learning problems attainable from the dataset. The model
can solve the task, however, by utilizing earlier examples to generalize to
later ones (i.e. in-context learning). In evaluations on the datasets, SCAN,
COGS, and GeoQuery, models trained in this manner indeed show improved
compositional generalization. This indicates the usefulness of in-context
learning problems as an inductive bias for generalization.
|
[
-0.25512924790382385,
-0.44165390729904175,
0.4970014989376068,
0.4278408885002136,
-0.21139398217201233,
-0.4339851438999176,
-0.4876030385494232,
-0.22657670080661774,
-0.3661210536956787,
0.3487164378166199,
-0.5632144808769226,
-0.3625287115573883,
-0.5531771183013916,
0.10965118557214737,
-0.4957163333892822,
1.085772156715393,
0.05889367684721947,
0.2086797058582306,
-0.4722253978252411,
-0.15455961227416992,
-0.8280587196350098,
-0.3012370765209198,
-0.4936625063419342,
-0.7961093783378601,
0.4818277955055237,
0.17477594316005707,
0.47677934169769287,
0.3589361608028412,
0.4320122003555298,
0.2406223714351654,
0.037376437336206436,
0.00197182921692729,
-0.45214128494262695,
0.28255748748779297,
-0.41584938764572144,
-0.8685021996498108,
0.47030505537986755,
0.061725858598947525,
0.41436967253685,
1.0885050296783447,
0.03298862650990486,
-0.03190573677420616,
0.27441316843032837,
0.4513985514640808,
-0.6491926312446594,
0.319931298494339,
-0.8359414339065552,
0.30031487345695496,
0.2506544291973114,
-0.19531318545341492,
-0.7121220827102661,
-0.07313697785139084,
0.6167557239532471,
-0.6228917837142944,
0.536590039730072,
-0.1692017912864685,
0.7063013315200806,
0.5681548714637756,
-0.5967998504638672,
-0.20818011462688446,
-0.958975076675415,
0.6144154667854309,
-0.4003078043460846,
0.13512970507144928,
0.268917977809906,
0.4514838755130768,
-0.06825461238622665,
-0.736358106136322,
-0.5810831785202026,
0.012166837230324745,
-0.634459376335144,
0.27581652998924255,
0.030460694804787636,
-0.06883098185062408,
0.385323166847229,
0.1763247549533844,
-0.2642936706542969,
0.0866694524884224,
-0.3528277575969696,
0.3101944625377655,
0.32669246196746826,
0.23910477757453918,
0.3576440215110779,
-0.060642629861831665,
-0.37743115425109863,
-0.21195386350154877,
-0.7851614356040955,
0.21054360270500183,
0.10000626742839813,
0.4470480978488922,
-0.36019665002822876,
0.3212374448776245,
-0.13248974084854126,
0.7436342239379883,
0.22777214646339417,
0.10532736778259277,
0.03468722105026245,
0.009612166322767735,
-0.3808040916919708,
0.0191903468221426,
0.6444054245948792,
0.0617586113512516,
0.08658331632614136,
-0.612305223941803,
-0.06138249486684799,
0.1104310154914856,
0.49860429763793945,
-0.7393127679824829,
-0.1165522038936615,
-0.10189325362443924,
-0.2507871687412262,
-0.12886668741703033,
0.4517008662223816,
-0.3573630452156067,
-0.043541792780160904,
-0.5986725687980652,
0.6582648754119873,
-0.24151460826396942,
0.22561758756637573,
0.15102547407150269,
-0.1641806811094284,
0.5160741209983826,
0.02930430695414543,
-1.2942074537277222,
0.0937577337026596,
0.7071169018745422,
0.6604215502738953,
-0.20721007883548737,
-0.45583397150039673,
-0.10957487672567368,
0.2691408693790436,
-0.1849573403596878,
0.7116235494613647,
-0.5606231689453125,
-0.315252423286438,
0.09941419959068298,
0.1454736888408661,
-0.5555583834648132,
-0.7771422266960144,
0.5307119488716125,
-0.4957365393638611,
0.3454609811306,
-0.36425021290779114,
-0.5189436078071594,
-0.20330213010311127,
-0.037593089044094086,
-0.544457197189331,
0.7981604337692261,
0.3522583246231079,
-0.7385758757591248,
0.7516871690750122,
-0.5343217253684998,
-0.7347831130027771,
-0.10244762152433395,
-0.3094223439693451,
-0.47986844182014465,
0.40654921531677246,
0.2534393072128296,
0.5870774984359741,
-0.24442404508590698,
0.5043247938156128,
-0.2215214967727661,
-0.5362071394920349,
0.28390565514564514,
-0.24157850444316864,
0.7712199091911316,
-0.06140996888279915,
-0.8038919568061829,
-0.05707383155822754,
-0.3873326778411865,
-0.4790949523448944,
0.17125076055526733,
-0.5328397154808044,
-0.45455169677734375,
0.15222862362861633,
-0.2227366715669632,
0.3595087230205536,
-0.3615936040878296,
-0.3239184617996216,
0.1501435786485672,
-0.6253547072410583,
0.31253498792648315,
0.6261242628097534,
0.08592874556779861,
1.1411662101745605,
-0.21781639754772186,
0.17997591197490692,
0.09080617874860764,
0.1058492660522461,
-0.26459354162216187,
-0.3485841751098633,
-0.8862341046333313,
0.1416252851486206,
0.11580511927604675,
0.26836031675338745,
-0.6214845180511475,
0.545543909072876,
-0.3954545259475708,
-0.20465148985385895,
-0.11145108938217163,
0.10278850048780441,
0.17512165009975433,
1.005008578300476,
0.5568881630897522,
0.06037396565079689,
-0.3668947219848633,
-0.8449311852455139,
-0.19277143478393555,
0.37431076169013977,
-0.36664795875549316,
0.3519442081451416,
0.504896342754364,
-0.3757632076740265,
1.2328710556030273,
-0.4606059789657593,
-0.426761269569397,
-0.13884234428405762,
0.012440120801329613,
0.11175858229398727,
0.5449427366256714,
0.5257878303527832,
-0.8232126235961914,
-0.6244738698005676,
0.13429488241672516,
-1.1042413711547852,
-0.05951600521802902,
-0.25601446628570557,
-0.3373872637748718,
-0.1325179785490036,
0.6137419939041138,
-0.4860110878944397,
0.3858225345611572,
0.25673365592956543,
-0.14159050583839417,
0.10383766889572144,
-0.004117194097489119,
-0.4955956041812897,
-0.9233741164207458,
-0.21416740119457245,
0.20296840369701385,
0.14936846494674683,
-0.5695037841796875,
0.1511814296245575,
0.0854000598192215,
-0.01858323998749256,
-0.414877325296402,
0.21675340831279755,
-0.020366810262203217,
0.19986481964588165,
-0.2716231644153595,
-0.20498277246952057,
0.04911583662033081,
0.5388091206550598,
0.055921610444784164,
0.5309512615203857,
0.5650264024734497,
-0.8388897180557251,
-0.012337635271251202,
0.33581116795539856,
-0.4204348623752594,
0.5252504944801331,
-0.7729745507240295,
-0.12431343644857407,
-0.5107364058494568,
0.6305465698242188,
-0.8679540157318115,
-0.23881247639656067,
0.08865317702293396,
0.028938934206962585,
0.3115692734718323,
-0.019897179678082466,
-0.3313058614730835,
0.013273967429995537,
0.21372529864311218,
0.43702834844589233,
0.2363407462835312,
-0.97042316198349,
0.7599161267280579,
0.005220460239797831,
0.5919332504272461,
-0.5078186988830566,
-0.8566135168075562,
-0.4327412247657776,
-0.5719091296195984,
-0.5199295878410339,
0.6580597162246704,
0.15391568839550018,
-0.09580012410879135,
-0.09268658608198166,
-0.08325263857841492,
0.12492244690656662,
0.12757843732833862,
0.2905258536338806,
0.02925220876932144,
-0.08753613382577896,
0.3844849467277527,
0.2082080841064453,
-0.09565774351358414,
0.4045035243034363,
-0.3531949818134308,
0.4818621277809143,
0.10698580741882324,
-0.29765862226486206,
-0.19893081486225128,
0.2670780420303345,
0.20168310403823853,
0.02099538967013359,
0.7935411930084229,
0.5609642863273621,
-0.14276337623596191,
-0.6845139265060425,
-0.1761326789855957,
-0.5333421230316162,
-0.4597882330417633,
0.04357233643531799,
-0.20774763822555542,
-0.8190295696258545,
0.4692530930042267,
-0.1972218006849289,
-0.22436225414276123,
0.5429290533065796,
0.3422802984714508,
-0.23267535865306854,
0.8341526985168457,
0.6300668120384216,
-0.12200591713190079,
0.5651377439498901,
-0.7607128024101257,
0.19355154037475586,
-0.8992847204208374,
-0.4719642102718353,
-0.38594821095466614,
-0.6319395303726196,
-0.6946303248405457,
-0.003421274945139885,
0.5265969038009644,
-0.24796172976493835,
-0.46523407101631165,
0.3334205448627472,
-0.47877129912376404,
0.7180168628692627,
0.6441230773925781,
0.5250676274299622,
-0.027533583343029022,
0.09291619062423706,
-0.3026477098464966,
0.017639003694057465,
-0.7349714040756226,
-0.047448936849832535,
1.1080105304718018,
0.02393592707812786,
0.7697426676750183,
0.10351373255252838,
0.5140858888626099,
-0.08923739939928055,
0.4474616050720215,
-0.9050599932670593,
0.026398679241538048,
-0.10559868812561035,
-0.6184685230255127,
-0.19550728797912598,
-0.2129708230495453,
-1.0554513931274414,
0.5783765912055969,
-0.26201677322387695,
-0.5023199915885925,
0.5212938189506531,
-0.14681476354599,
-0.3204587697982788,
0.0769757330417633,
-0.7074779868125916,
0.8546770811080933,
0.060711897909641266,
-0.3650124669075012,
0.07983465492725372,
-0.9500932097434998,
0.3973751664161682,
0.07651412487030029,
-0.14924287796020508,
0.24104958772659302,
0.3616343140602112,
0.30235692858695984,
-0.37439703941345215,
1.1886740922927856,
-0.1466427892446518,
0.11374315619468689,
0.28386351466178894,
-0.0051097930409014225,
0.47768181562423706,
0.047712769359350204,
0.27474895119667053,
-0.1562853902578354,
-0.5722202658653259,
-0.2885727286338806,
-1.0071452856063843,
0.4381807744503021,
-0.9543150663375854,
-0.5309100151062012,
-0.10719918459653854,
-0.4939922094345093,
-0.16340962052345276,
-0.28645017743110657,
0.8435970544815063,
0.40505021810531616,
-0.05507931113243103,
0.559411883354187,
0.8872531056404114,
0.07284434884786606,
0.6408663392066956,
0.12225687503814697,
0.1538994312286377,
0.13430114090442657,
0.5847850441932678,
-0.03345194458961487,
0.3342691659927368,
0.6457633376121521,
0.5753689408302307,
-0.15860262513160706,
-0.21351595222949982,
-0.14405551552772522,
0.10323988646268845,
-1.0232335329055786,
-0.23745575547218323,
-0.7163355946540833,
-0.07029633969068527,
0.02169601432979107,
-0.44438615441322327,
0.04677591845393181,
-0.12712258100509644,
-0.6368942856788635,
-0.27849459648132324,
-0.2656598687171936,
0.6757623553276062,
0.3017767369747162,
0.8336762189865112,
-0.27928727865219116,
0.06378087401390076,
0.772358238697052,
0.07105941325426102,
0.2402365356683731,
-0.8143447637557983,
-0.3945372402667999,
-0.1973809450864792,
-0.5841507911682129,
-0.6713272929191589,
0.18457718193531036,
0.3478030264377594,
0.561700701713562,
0.6611867547035217,
-0.14254052937030792,
0.43724721670150757,
-0.3739401698112488,
0.574468731880188,
-0.133009672164917,
-0.8880478739738464,
0.4489036202430725,
-0.4595799446105957,
0.4634498059749603,
0.6945400238037109,
0.5546148419380188,
-0.5776326060295105,
-0.22606930136680603,
-0.5377140045166016,
-0.8463929295539856,
0.5418190360069275,
-0.048677872866392136,
0.6406534314155579,
-0.2128119170665741,
0.4495917856693268,
0.23905426263809204,
0.04340478032827377,
-1.1889641284942627,
-0.3100607097148895,
-0.31498128175735474,
-0.0021775367204099894,
-0.05822306498885155,
-0.08892744779586792,
-0.22106586396694183,
-0.5343696475028992,
0.5393176078796387,
-0.2807812988758087,
0.23634470999240875,
0.13038653135299683,
-0.429890900850296,
0.03886788710951805,
0.1081356629729271,
0.6356923580169678,
0.5814131498336792,
-0.0446709543466568,
0.24796031415462494,
0.16262951493263245,
0.0024399536196142435,
0.23102597892284393,
-0.15675705671310425,
-0.548147976398468,
-0.18019555509090424,
0.436452716588974,
0.870360791683197,
0.6188469529151917,
-0.15140141546726227,
0.808517575263977,
0.05501197651028633,
-0.08923914283514023,
-0.20042073726654053,
0.07601547241210938,
0.0006939723389223218,
0.1738004982471466,
0.5791864395141602,
0.2534705400466919,
0.24115264415740967,
-0.45052310824394226,
0.11364289373159409,
0.42828047275543213,
-0.5735840201377869,
-0.38886475563049316,
0.7382358908653259,
-0.029340272769331932,
0.09660699963569641,
0.6967000961303711,
-0.13283920288085938,
-0.48339006304740906,
0.5551046133041382,
1.0897022485733032,
0.9978986978530884,
-0.07831656187772751,
0.23054362833499908,
0.4748481810092926,
0.2796594798564911,
-0.26261889934539795,
-0.41408053040504456,
-0.2939775586128235,
-0.9892534017562866,
-0.4584997594356537,
-0.47639182209968567,
-0.196303129196167,
-0.08910274505615234,
-0.5309471487998962,
0.23092474043369293,
-0.3338816463947296,
0.10484002530574799,
-0.13872705399990082,
-0.7518988847732544,
-0.9318771958351135,
0.37375012040138245,
-0.058661624789237976,
0.3630697727203369,
-1.2152836322784424,
0.597504198551178,
0.3612215518951416,
-0.5229349732398987,
-0.9694663286209106,
0.11448982357978821,
-0.42755624651908875,
-0.4557599127292633,
1.0027656555175781,
0.44614294171333313,
0.16665810346603394,
-0.17345868051052094,
-0.8180828094482422,
-0.6855851411819458,
1.118762493133545,
0.4830819368362427,
-0.09262000769376755,
-0.19572703540325165,
0.23340806365013123,
0.5818435549736023,
-0.7598952651023865,
0.1909995824098587,
0.6480036973953247,
0.3337521255016327,
0.09248652309179306,
-0.4304661750793457,
0.04637981206178665,
0.04919210076332092,
0.08223460614681244,
-0.023687973618507385,
-0.5286623239517212,
1.0166096687316895,
0.06611772626638412,
-0.35771894454956055,
-0.501970648765564,
0.618377685546875,
-0.23975114524364471,
0.27787861227989197,
0.24970877170562744,
0.7204983830451965,
0.3485976755619049,
-0.31395822763442993,
1.1856319904327393,
0.18233734369277954,
0.40513914823532104,
1.3017717599868774,
0.09626732766628265,
0.4004768133163452,
0.5191619992256165,
-0.17277106642723083,
0.8904948234558105,
0.4087921679019928,
0.0033629867248237133,
0.8888541460037231,
0.23987562954425812,
-0.4744071364402771,
-0.057007767260074615,
-0.010084480047225952,
-0.1809701919555664,
0.7826247215270996,
0.2923765480518341,
-0.717377245426178,
-0.4451579749584198,
0.2687373757362366,
-0.02214355207979679,
0.16320514678955078,
-0.19874882698059082,
0.8874556422233582,
-0.00636651273816824,
-0.700508177280426,
0.30189117789268494,
-0.1595185399055481,
0.7946757078170776,
-0.48262134194374084,
0.17735621333122253,
-0.2124452441930771,
0.048928387463092804,
-0.3426823019981384,
-0.21688894927501678,
0.48147666454315186,
-0.7157713770866394,
-0.308243989944458,
0.026163950562477112,
0.46469399333000183,
-0.40044644474983215,
-0.36006608605384827,
0.33501487970352173,
0.36612677574157715,
-0.3740295469760895,
-0.3844640254974365,
-0.2450510412454605,
-0.40632379055023193,
-0.164326474070549,
-0.1701837182044983,
0.37379807233810425,
0.28321826457977295,
-0.05958559364080429,
0.45532843470573425,
0.4858842194080353,
-0.40885457396507263,
0.26423028111457825,
0.22799958288669586,
0.8726165890693665,
-0.30807313323020935,
-0.4237762987613678,
-1.0380754470825195,
0.5864655375480652,
0.1566428244113922,
-0.1855391412973404,
0.62697833776474,
0.4570458233356476,
1.2933027744293213,
-0.35587915778160095,
0.777870237827301,
0.2072053700685501,
-0.030564473941922188,
-0.4474361836910248,
0.46284613013267517,
-0.2093883901834488,
0.017471730709075928,
-0.059065163135528564,
-1.180861234664917,
-0.6413231492042542,
0.6927056908607483,
-0.5274277329444885,
-0.052138812839984894,
0.9209533929824829,
0.5748867988586426,
-0.3001978099346161,
0.05049903690814972,
0.27831506729125977,
-0.3480764627456665,
0.3276500701904297,
0.39357680082321167,
0.818236768245697,
-0.5249467492103577,
0.2847898304462433,
-0.646500825881958,
0.0746322050690651,
-0.08239388465881348,
-0.6963042616844177,
-1.0532643795013428,
-0.7375829815864563,
0.10832355916500092,
-0.3062494695186615,
-0.5363926291465759,
0.9683851003646851,
0.6807205080986023,
-0.6334697604179382,
-0.27683159708976746,
-0.42851608991622925,
0.2133631408214569,
-0.24898654222488403,
-0.3011864423751831,
0.3206247091293335,
-0.7992222905158997,
-0.8483058214187622,
0.4410483241081238,
0.15850293636322021,
0.1358223259449005,
-0.14967843890190125,
0.16882595419883728,
-0.01783180795609951,
-0.055454012006521225,
0.760875403881073,
0.10610148310661316,
-0.5282356142997742,
-0.29567569494247437,
-0.17622797191143036,
-0.06553969532251358,
0.3002137839794159,
1.3196595907211304,
-0.8451647758483887,
0.5242315530776978,
0.31773003935813904,
0.8257586359977722,
0.774863600730896,
-0.020517028868198395,
0.4302855432033539,
-1.0298446416854858,
0.30147993564605713,
0.01762106828391552,
0.4550304710865021,
0.41198644042015076,
-0.48909422755241394,
0.5839296579360962,
0.35094472765922546,
-0.5658552646636963,
-0.321715772151947,
0.42374593019485474,
-0.6942489743232727,
-0.24721072614192963,
1.0199809074401855,
0.12270539999008179,
-0.26127198338508606,
-0.05276606231927872,
0.10942937433719635,
0.30369871854782104,
-0.1485397219657898,
0.9740636348724365,
0.5145889520645142,
-0.12367735058069229,
0.17445628345012665,
-0.30389338731765747,
0.4549170434474945,
0.3618210554122925,
-0.6468263268470764,
-0.36641156673431396,
0.2322724461555481,
0.2882574498653412,
0.0458713173866272,
0.08064737915992737,
0.22339113056659698,
0.08065663278102875,
-0.25130364298820496,
-0.09898736327886581,
0.17508980631828308,
-0.37634727358818054,
-0.5463034510612488,
0.30894649028778076,
-0.34915420413017273,
0.023882461711764336
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11833v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11833v1
|
SSCAE -- Semantic, Syntactic, and Context-aware natural language Adversarial Examples generator
| 2024-03-18T14:45:20 | 2024-03-18T14:45:20 |
Javad Rafiei Asl, Mohammad H. Rafiei, Manar Alohaly, Daniel Takabi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG
|
Machine learning models are vulnerable to maliciously crafted Adversarial
Examples (AEs). Training a machine learning model with AEs improves its
robustness and stability against adversarial attacks. It is essential to
develop models that produce high-quality AEs. Developing such models has been
much slower in natural language processing (NLP) than in areas such as computer
vision. This paper introduces a practical and efficient adversarial attack
model called SSCAE for \textbf{S}emantic, \textbf{S}yntactic, and
\textbf{C}ontext-aware natural language \textbf{AE}s generator. SSCAE
identifies important words and uses a masked language model to generate an
early set of substitutions. Next, two well-known language models are employed
to evaluate the initial set in terms of semantic and syntactic characteristics.
We introduce (1) a dynamic threshold to capture more efficient perturbations
and (2) a local greedy search to generate high-quality AEs. As a black-box
method, SSCAE generates humanly imperceptible and context-aware AEs that
preserve semantic consistency and the source language's syntactical and
grammatical requirements. The effectiveness and superiority of the proposed
SSCAE model are illustrated with fifteen comparative experiments and extensive
sensitivity analysis for parameter optimization. SSCAE outperforms the existing
models in all experiments while maintaining a higher semantic consistency with
a lower query number and a comparable perturbation rate.
|
[
-0.3554580807685852,
-1.2932300567626953,
0.37122631072998047,
0.05376164987683296,
-0.272803395986557,
-0.14631755650043488,
-0.07295394688844681,
-0.3331025540828705,
0.3285121023654938,
0.6501100063323975,
-0.3774307072162628,
-0.4566858410835266,
-0.6975824236869812,
0.0878826454281807,
-0.677159309387207,
0.9480482935905457,
0.08783379197120667,
0.08479532599449158,
0.27490928769111633,
0.04949451982975006,
-0.23395128548145294,
-0.6001468896865845,
-0.9921401739120483,
0.2500576674938202,
0.29689231514930725,
-0.20411713421344757,
0.9033918976783752,
0.6104469895362854,
0.37473833560943604,
0.3345588445663452,
-0.18716591596603394,
-0.04541555792093277,
-0.3383108079433441,
0.4132523536682129,
-0.22956456243991852,
-0.4806019365787506,
-0.09239007532596588,
-0.03532689809799194,
0.4530060887336731,
0.5180442929267883,
-0.08088742196559906,
-0.12533332407474518,
-0.031473226845264435,
0.2918207347393036,
-0.8345856070518494,
-0.10738750547170639,
-1.1294094324111938,
0.04840680956840515,
-0.21685917675495148,
-0.14168687164783478,
-0.5489266514778137,
-0.19664159417152405,
0.13584521412849426,
-0.4978579580783844,
0.20269998908042908,
-0.19705601036548615,
0.8649787306785583,
0.42251312732696533,
-0.24612732231616974,
-0.4248274266719818,
-0.32543355226516724,
0.6282086968421936,
-0.7456315755844116,
0.36691051721572876,
0.18678833544254303,
0.5093265175819397,
-0.6220863461494446,
-0.901798665523529,
-0.52876216173172,
-0.6210795640945435,
0.3418824076652527,
0.16916851699352264,
-0.3755635917186737,
0.059608716517686844,
0.018513936549425125,
0.12489881366491318,
-0.39199361205101013,
0.10155090689659119,
-0.073615662753582,
-0.2764817774295807,
0.49612191319465637,
0.053209513425827026,
0.6733776330947876,
-0.19536851346492767,
-0.5816676616668701,
0.024896683171391487,
-0.7926599979400635,
-0.13342030346393585,
0.49126026034355164,
0.3306821286678314,
0.09708934277296066,
0.5143358707427979,
-0.13801679015159607,
0.6486567258834839,
0.009220466017723083,
0.11682888120412827,
-0.5013512372970581,
-0.37920817732810974,
-0.3274044990539551,
-0.0317041277885437,
0.5627188086509705,
-0.054840054363012314,
-0.0015889325877651572,
-0.5252372622489929,
-0.005630678962916136,
0.7147903442382812,
0.7203153371810913,
-0.7075300812721252,
-0.027460318058729172,
0.010819322429597378,
-0.14145073294639587,
-0.6430502533912659,
-0.15126089751720428,
-0.5404287576675415,
-0.24871958792209625,
-0.3022952079772949,
0.38565564155578613,
-0.5436769127845764,
0.16117888689041138,
0.13881129026412964,
-0.252693772315979,
0.05204036459326744,
0.13754640519618988,
-0.7160025238990784,
0.4998845160007477,
0.4519355297088623,
0.5007535219192505,
-0.06921613216400146,
-0.2656099796295166,
-0.5718424916267395,
0.08856841176748276,
-0.33032622933387756,
0.5979442596435547,
-0.4562833905220032,
-0.2297571301460266,
-0.10937279462814331,
-0.0813915953040123,
-0.11297598481178284,
-0.05546361207962036,
0.666182279586792,
-0.7809224724769592,
0.1340738832950592,
-0.08547810465097427,
-0.5441166162490845,
-0.19436350464820862,
0.1933026760816574,
-0.6945598125457764,
0.8338048458099365,
-0.19413594901561737,
-0.8159558773040771,
0.2750140130519867,
-0.7405822277069092,
-0.3200009763240814,
0.2168395072221756,
-0.2064676433801651,
-0.2784331440925598,
0.17351391911506653,
0.14745283126831055,
0.3792797029018402,
-0.16778647899627686,
0.19818821549415588,
-0.3078797459602356,
-0.22010432183742523,
0.10346546769142151,
-0.7582308053970337,
1.0937252044677734,
0.3225187361240387,
-0.42812713980674744,
-0.049576904624700546,
-0.6092082262039185,
-0.051383230835199356,
0.6297626495361328,
-0.21016666293144226,
-0.5051808953285217,
0.09172409772872925,
-0.01794029027223587,
0.07886232435703278,
0.3050857186317444,
-0.6199374198913574,
-0.0667702704668045,
-0.886211633682251,
0.49949514865875244,
0.5612775683403015,
0.24803206324577332,
0.31516870856285095,
0.07609201222658157,
0.606519877910614,
-0.2545982897281647,
0.22735807299613953,
0.0223982036113739,
-0.3632591664791107,
-0.5152016878128052,
-0.25767090916633606,
0.5237717032432556,
0.5397117137908936,
-1.0328891277313232,
0.5877564549446106,
0.1325828731060028,
-0.6337168216705322,
-0.5507307052612305,
0.08762438595294952,
0.4207192063331604,
0.20870280265808105,
0.2445252239704132,
-0.24073854088783264,
-0.40626853704452515,
-0.9253785014152527,
-0.4947987198829651,
0.15359170734882355,
0.08349096029996872,
-0.05771234259009361,
0.48527631163597107,
-0.1673624962568283,
0.721235454082489,
-0.3588023781776428,
0.10927824676036835,
-0.30950242280960083,
-0.10897833853960037,
-0.4157896339893341,
0.22843940556049347,
0.6530488729476929,
-0.7908558249473572,
-0.34427306056022644,
-0.3108080327510834,
-0.726056694984436,
-0.04837518930435181,
-0.0025055105797946453,
-0.4320280849933624,
0.2551121115684509,
0.42389509081840515,
-0.5827693939208984,
0.6188409328460693,
0.5247839093208313,
-0.3142596185207367,
0.40783610939979553,
-0.1365649700164795,
0.002904838416725397,
-1.2805360555648804,
-0.04532339796423912,
0.03966390714049339,
-0.07395559549331665,
-0.9377706050872803,
0.8901892900466919,
0.011130771599709988,
-0.5168383121490479,
-0.7362427115440369,
0.4361383616924286,
-0.24104656279087067,
0.058231014758348465,
-0.33964160084724426,
0.42112448811531067,
0.04550210386514664,
0.5022680163383484,
0.05102177709341049,
0.5640770196914673,
0.4904104173183441,
-0.6227669715881348,
0.2939623296260834,
0.09743189066648483,
-0.1425960212945938,
0.4002171456813812,
-0.6951156854629517,
0.14874157309532166,
-0.10630621761083603,
0.20253953337669373,
-0.49777698516845703,
0.07435374706983566,
0.16593889892101288,
-0.44712796807289124,
0.3846113383769989,
-0.01835087686777115,
-0.3667527437210083,
-0.0316118486225605,
-0.34871578216552734,
0.24106645584106445,
0.045378196984529495,
-0.6381787061691284,
0.5833131074905396,
0.512598991394043,
-0.20312432944774628,
-0.6437371373176575,
-0.646612286567688,
0.5921328663825989,
-0.23213031888008118,
-0.7110804319381714,
0.51137775182724,
-0.019698355346918106,
-0.12053847312927246,
-0.02012629434466362,
0.032506804913282394,
-0.005151571240276098,
0.5696626305580139,
-0.07740536332130432,
0.2646888792514801,
-0.10602009296417236,
-0.22338448464870453,
0.02140265703201294,
-0.0185506921261549,
0.07420457154512405,
-0.09801075607538223,
0.6286622881889343,
-0.10477568209171295,
-0.3810770809650421,
-0.4402662217617035,
0.46131014823913574,
0.3889019787311554,
-0.23327518999576569,
0.8399270176887512,
0.3085993230342865,
-0.8465245962142944,
-0.3522588908672333,
-0.22043004631996155,
-0.24220338463783264,
-0.45294100046157837,
0.5612441897392273,
-0.4213648736476898,
-0.45031440258026123,
0.36143243312835693,
0.3253813087940216,
0.16334789991378784,
0.5487614870071411,
0.35953599214553833,
0.30497345328330994,
1.2460205554962158,
0.2897477149963379,
-0.11568832397460938,
0.44784340262413025,
-0.3083173930644989,
0.32709237933158875,
-0.543624222278595,
0.11948967725038528,
-0.6505657434463501,
0.2240842580795288,
-0.6183152794837952,
-0.08186037093400955,
0.3237585127353668,
0.10907857120037079,
-0.19274801015853882,
0.8319053053855896,
-0.37216296792030334,
0.4324466288089752,
0.39375147223472595,
0.08365655690431595,
-0.18959234654903412,
0.05946945399045944,
-0.27399519085884094,
-0.11185476928949356,
-0.8189194202423096,
-0.8482858538627625,
0.9619482755661011,
0.42325982451438904,
0.5227002501487732,
0.2640587389469147,
0.6642066836357117,
0.5391773581504822,
0.03037014976143837,
-0.572421133518219,
0.6131121516227722,
-0.45225420594215393,
-0.5737572908401489,
-0.2129524201154709,
-0.22079238295555115,
-1.031885027885437,
0.3078307509422302,
-0.41449612379074097,
-0.6737723350524902,
-0.14443878829479218,
0.020327255129814148,
-0.17190536856651306,
0.2931310832500458,
-0.6766231060028076,
0.9487237930297852,
-0.1913871020078659,
-0.35507023334503174,
-0.18011341989040375,
-0.46122103929519653,
0.33999285101890564,
-0.04480107128620148,
-0.15380977094173431,
0.3174024820327759,
0.04519575089216232,
0.5615630149841309,
-0.37096697092056274,
0.8907703161239624,
-0.1729603260755539,
-0.09153862297534943,
0.3781546950340271,
0.3752670884132385,
0.8669541478157043,
-0.06554720550775528,
-0.10125857591629028,
0.18900582194328308,
-0.11156246811151505,
-0.5523433089256287,
-0.6649505496025085,
0.7840855121612549,
-0.4340105652809143,
-0.6712377071380615,
-0.40643930435180664,
-0.19887784123420715,
0.018573224544525146,
0.08224674314260483,
0.2760457992553711,
0.664475679397583,
-0.5883828997612,
0.09819476306438446,
0.43666765093803406,
-0.3242758810520172,
0.2628394365310669,
0.3891758620738983,
0.31993669271469116,
-0.1942187249660492,
0.8418831825256348,
0.055539123713970184,
0.504170298576355,
0.24199874699115753,
0.025420239195227623,
-0.3775918483734131,
-0.6022972464561462,
-0.6379583477973938,
-0.025197181850671768,
-0.7666087746620178,
-0.2568812668323517,
-0.6474969983100891,
-0.4910788834095001,
-0.40414366126060486,
-0.5105744004249573,
-0.24363048374652863,
-0.5095711946487427,
-0.12967371940612793,
-0.05272560939192772,
0.02590261586010456,
0.5506795048713684,
0.4219878911972046,
0.38900870084762573,
-0.34698519110679626,
0.35401204228401184,
0.29175466299057007,
-0.024523640051484108,
-0.10673266649246216,
-0.4275398254394531,
-0.0565749928355217,
0.29750919342041016,
-0.511277437210083,
-1.2444705963134766,
0.4530833065509796,
-0.0439520888030529,
0.770773708820343,
0.3889332115650177,
0.0878109484910965,
0.26844507455825806,
-0.37684735655784607,
0.9875064492225647,
0.0788312628865242,
-1.004808783531189,
0.7295403480529785,
-0.2038828581571579,
0.14476278424263,
0.5518131852149963,
0.1225527971982956,
-0.2827115058898926,
-0.9683473110198975,
-1.0009312629699707,
-0.7147288918495178,
0.4193381667137146,
0.4966738522052765,
-0.013142889365553856,
-0.3862931728363037,
0.302974134683609,
-0.15307682752609253,
0.012263057753443718,
-0.682642936706543,
-0.10524747520685196,
-0.31737223267555237,
-0.31912171840667725,
0.256149023771286,
0.04318738728761673,
0.08172168582677841,
0.4153219163417816,
1.0064959526062012,
-0.08496667444705963,
0.10846064239740372,
-0.006258541252464056,
-0.2527110278606415,
0.1770683228969574,
0.3821292817592621,
0.4128422439098358,
0.06356774270534515,
0.03015316277742386,
0.22580789029598236,
0.519046425819397,
-0.4461398124694824,
-0.05084851756691933,
0.17414890229701996,
-0.5765109062194824,
-0.12690328061580658,
0.11270847916603088,
0.6314451098442078,
0.3358227610588074,
-0.5539766550064087,
0.6073289513587952,
-0.22907108068466187,
0.13928385078907013,
-0.49180692434310913,
0.20121760666370392,
-0.0010129850124940276,
-0.04613524302840233,
-0.019366800785064697,
0.28757765889167786,
0.34185704588890076,
-0.49331629276275635,
0.11007116734981537,
0.8545739054679871,
-0.2570222020149231,
-0.10780379176139832,
0.8385918140411377,
0.11932818591594696,
-0.3698906898498535,
0.13719308376312256,
-0.30177879333496094,
-0.7591729164123535,
0.8435046672821045,
0.7443780303001404,
0.8391921520233154,
-0.3084776699542999,
0.1491289585828781,
0.09732534736394882,
0.46448689699172974,
0.1621672660112381,
0.059964876621961594,
-0.024303264915943146,
-0.7030435800552368,
-0.10689260065555573,
-0.7234663367271423,
-0.235821932554245,
0.16919369995594025,
-0.571644127368927,
0.4486207664012909,
-0.661747395992279,
-0.21254651248455048,
0.4211467206478119,
0.11654438078403473,
-0.6798118352890015,
0.4019065499305725,
-0.07246224582195282,
0.9679450392723083,
-0.8474817872047424,
0.6594106554985046,
0.5115483403205872,
-0.5486928820610046,
-0.4840039312839508,
-0.05472062900662422,
-0.08156479150056839,
-0.8054409623146057,
0.4928695857524872,
-0.03291719779372215,
-0.38141360878944397,
-0.22835317254066467,
-0.4074169099330902,
-0.7338253259658813,
0.815173864364624,
0.43634405732154846,
-0.1094997450709343,
0.012711646966636181,
-0.10683945566415787,
0.622988224029541,
-0.5457208156585693,
0.14686843752861023,
0.5451343059539795,
0.2347102016210556,
-0.2683386206626892,
-0.37708306312561035,
0.2568606436252594,
-0.32062047719955444,
0.2485634833574295,
0.2963241636753082,
-0.5068612098693848,
0.3360293209552765,
0.038190633058547974,
-0.5153247117996216,
0.16493959724903107,
0.6630299687385559,
0.24732111394405365,
0.14883749186992645,
0.5294632911682129,
0.6340558528900146,
0.4322691559791565,
0.0932813212275505,
1.2008517980575562,
-0.43696489930152893,
-0.27001550793647766,
0.8897132277488708,
-0.3271028697490692,
0.9239656925201416,
0.15653739869594574,
0.0000600730418227613,
0.2960396707057953,
0.3522064983844757,
-0.001966489013284445,
0.4542882740497589,
0.24788083136081696,
-0.44560080766677856,
-0.07906170189380646,
-0.1066650003194809,
-0.23274530470371246,
0.7381147742271423,
0.3714730739593506,
-0.5284740924835205,
-0.2225576788187027,
-0.0181499645113945,
0.1884719729423523,
0.473791241645813,
-0.08986391872167587,
0.7418012619018555,
-0.0880066305398941,
-0.5326640009880066,
0.5230647921562195,
0.49056434631347656,
0.43101000785827637,
-0.8755804896354675,
0.13057440519332886,
0.05516115203499794,
-0.0419670045375824,
0.13694678246974945,
-0.1251390427350998,
0.3505032956600189,
0.2052498608827591,
-0.01140093058347702,
0.22866547107696533,
0.7816995978355408,
-0.3477112948894501,
-0.5725594758987427,
0.374750554561615,
0.03646208718419075,
0.14397263526916504,
0.029981140047311783,
-0.7726194858551025,
-0.24150735139846802,
-0.04749045521020889,
-0.21086174249649048,
0.42545419931411743,
0.09410122036933899,
-0.05196904391050339,
0.540118396282196,
0.7240104675292969,
0.4658394753932953,
0.13055898249149323,
0.16478700935840607,
0.6210382580757141,
-0.6021522283554077,
-0.8338432312011719,
-0.5823161602020264,
0.12323972582817078,
-0.36575907468795776,
-0.209345743060112,
0.874268651008606,
0.4477931559085846,
0.5802567005157471,
0.09611038863658905,
0.8680418133735657,
0.23808111250400543,
0.23720034956932068,
-0.7295950651168823,
0.7269468307495117,
-0.39082828164100647,
0.3483707904815674,
-0.17365851998329163,
-0.7561543583869934,
-0.17747481167316437,
0.46380722522735596,
-0.10879426449537277,
-0.008607740513980389,
0.7532254457473755,
0.9959717988967896,
0.021183311939239502,
0.44861847162246704,
0.3095996081829071,
0.16115941107273102,
0.29255807399749756,
0.5168296098709106,
0.6173009276390076,
-0.7363240122795105,
0.45937827229499817,
-0.12159338593482971,
-0.2967761158943176,
-0.0309828482568264,
-0.8064636588096619,
-0.8344825506210327,
-0.39890944957733154,
-0.3368333876132965,
-0.49812033772468567,
0.38893499970436096,
0.9182924628257751,
0.5556516051292419,
-0.8195033669471741,
0.3065798282623291,
-0.28864043951034546,
-0.07619762420654297,
-0.22251199185848236,
-0.23735716938972473,
0.4641306698322296,
-0.4265570640563965,
-0.6916089057922363,
0.8148690462112427,
0.10332819819450378,
0.24713338911533356,
-0.5143637657165527,
0.018693314865231514,
-0.1566695272922516,
0.6314262747764587,
0.4681146740913391,
0.26599615812301636,
-0.9047185182571411,
-0.183152437210083,
-0.13875609636306763,
-0.24422132968902588,
-0.5818217396736145,
0.6920871138572693,
-0.4139934480190277,
0.43782344460487366,
0.24667581915855408,
0.9716114401817322,
0.2897123396396637,
-0.1323358565568924,
0.5271857976913452,
-0.7382348775863647,
0.24377495050430298,
0.18873445689678192,
0.6533816456794739,
0.26933807134628296,
-0.6019462943077087,
0.2668537497520447,
0.14738625288009644,
-0.32357001304626465,
-0.6445570588111877,
0.45253896713256836,
-0.8168630003929138,
-0.6863808631896973,
1.0569679737091064,
-0.198990136384964,
-0.3441770672798157,
-0.21018050611019135,
-0.20348596572875977,
0.37577998638153076,
-0.1946873813867569,
1.0153477191925049,
0.5256296992301941,
0.44482529163360596,
0.4167484641075134,
-0.4964824318885803,
0.44315457344055176,
0.5499022603034973,
-0.862610936164856,
-0.08432646095752716,
0.3856852948665619,
0.10269775241613388,
0.12144377827644348,
0.21358411014080048,
-0.12016621232032776,
0.39464589953422546,
0.4364936351776123,
-0.01987529918551445,
-0.0631023645401001,
-0.3835035264492035,
-0.38962146639823914,
0.5053726434707642,
-0.07481364160776138,
-0.17615042626857758
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11810v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11810v1
|
Metaphor Understanding Challenge Dataset for LLMs
| 2024-03-18T14:08:59 | 2024-03-18T14:08:59 |
Xiaoyu Tong, Rochelle Choenni, Martha Lewis, Ekaterina Shutova
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Metaphors in natural language are a reflection of fundamental cognitive
processes such as analogical reasoning and categorisation, and are deeply
rooted in everyday communication. Metaphor understanding is therefore an
essential task for large language models (LLMs). We release the Metaphor
Understanding Challenge Dataset (MUNCH), designed to evaluate the metaphor
understanding capabilities of LLMs. The dataset provides over 10k paraphrases
for sentences containing metaphor use, as well as 1.5k instances containing
inapt paraphrases. The inapt paraphrases were carefully selected to serve as
control to determine whether the model indeed performs full metaphor
interpretation or rather resorts to lexical similarity. All apt and inapt
paraphrases were manually annotated. The metaphorical sentences cover natural
metaphor uses across 4 genres (academic, news, fiction, and conversation), and
they exhibit different levels of novelty. Experiments with LLaMA and GPT-3.5
demonstrate that MUNCH presents a challenging task for LLMs. The dataset is
freely accessible at
https://github.com/xiaoyuisrain/metaphor-understanding-challenge.
|
[
0.0017982455901801586,
-0.5299443006515503,
0.7464829087257385,
0.24417169392108917,
-0.5607156157493591,
-0.04159347712993622,
0.029990505427122116,
-0.5049163103103638,
0.15567640960216522,
0.5640881061553955,
-0.5933376550674438,
-0.2904190123081207,
-0.548841655254364,
0.3335724472999573,
-0.4068199694156647,
1.1912850141525269,
-0.1506006419658661,
-0.12363124638795853,
-0.3750610649585724,
-0.3898197114467621,
-0.6717894673347473,
-0.5256272554397583,
-0.37750545144081116,
-0.32108256220817566,
0.752774715423584,
0.4406028687953949,
0.6821311712265015,
0.8779037594795227,
0.7071861028671265,
0.25675737857818604,
-0.16584157943725586,
-0.03092084638774395,
-0.5747147798538208,
0.20763376355171204,
-0.11935433745384216,
-0.5478314757347107,
-0.023644324392080307,
0.06386381387710571,
0.6524856686592102,
0.6816670894622803,
-0.3967553973197937,
0.2804163098335266,
0.135312020778656,
0.5778460502624512,
-0.583504855632782,
0.36881282925605774,
-1.2165367603302002,
0.027330957353115082,
-0.2919764816761017,
-0.19349300861358643,
-0.10842043161392212,
-0.19258618354797363,
0.21382924914360046,
-0.7413601875305176,
0.06636049598455429,
0.4277021586894989,
0.8018844723701477,
0.3240639567375183,
-0.4860761761665344,
-0.49397721886634827,
-0.2505885362625122,
0.6619799733161926,
-0.43017181754112244,
0.12121881544589996,
0.28527361154556274,
0.480052649974823,
-0.23887646198272705,
-0.8458146452903748,
-0.724504292011261,
-0.21735355257987976,
-0.16304215788841248,
-0.09459207206964493,
-0.309933602809906,
-0.1034403070807457,
0.22870463132858276,
0.6430366039276123,
-0.6919527053833008,
0.015727033838629723,
-0.40816155076026917,
-0.18458592891693115,
0.14632894098758698,
0.49325576424598694,
0.18164090812206268,
-0.47378936409950256,
-0.6894011497497559,
-0.055573608726263046,
-0.6095237731933594,
-0.19844721257686615,
0.036989353597164154,
-0.026189487427473068,
-0.21138258278369904,
0.5825887322425842,
0.0163434948772192,
0.718699038028717,
-0.5839434266090393,
-0.14686670899391174,
0.5474153161048889,
-0.23383653163909912,
-0.4906281530857086,
-0.030777551233768463,
0.5173792243003845,
0.3998025953769684,
0.343285471200943,
-0.20301473140716553,
-0.27783462405204773,
0.15277498960494995,
0.12299250066280365,
-0.35146257281303406,
-0.27761155366897583,
0.015734072774648666,
-0.2243965119123459,
-0.2579936981201172,
-0.07767262309789658,
-0.7106781005859375,
-0.7551267147064209,
-0.3969567120075226,
0.48180854320526123,
-0.5956817269325256,
0.039244815707206726,
0.46197763085365295,
-0.5037567019462585,
0.2544928789138794,
0.38427624106407166,
-0.7534952163696289,
0.16922537982463837,
0.7391545176506042,
1.0039023160934448,
-0.25380903482437134,
-0.7176864743232727,
-0.4325104057788849,
0.3801102042198181,
-0.08836324512958527,
0.8046635985374451,
-0.4665493667125702,
-0.04720745235681534,
-0.42193979024887085,
-0.19901199638843536,
-0.40031298995018005,
-0.8710034489631653,
0.8480677008628845,
-0.16349558532238007,
0.04687562957406044,
-0.24417856335639954,
-0.6297308802604675,
-0.31451860070228577,
0.5932102799415588,
-0.7689602971076965,
0.9300557374954224,
0.056417446583509445,
-1.0243362188339233,
0.11950065195560455,
-0.6915769577026367,
-0.07187167555093765,
-0.03662700578570366,
-0.3760441541671753,
0.09695886820554733,
0.49842900037765503,
0.3943151533603668,
0.4863196611404419,
-0.7459081411361694,
0.3019208610057831,
-0.32000675797462463,
-0.31231939792633057,
0.5025145411491394,
-0.44003158807754517,
0.7604401111602783,
0.4186306297779083,
-0.05203159525990486,
-0.0669533833861351,
-0.5277851819992065,
-0.1730143278837204,
0.6147584915161133,
0.09206600487232208,
-0.5106527805328369,
-0.3239574730396271,
0.19674618542194366,
0.30116838216781616,
0.08660344034433365,
-0.3439372479915619,
0.17439499497413635,
-0.05728685110807419,
0.7704561352729797,
0.7975191473960876,
0.07459889352321625,
-0.12695768475532532,
-0.7951653003692627,
0.5503959655761719,
-0.0068106441758573055,
0.0021805644501000643,
-0.4201122224330902,
-0.3713448643684387,
-0.4579668641090393,
-0.6472615599632263,
0.18686208128929138,
0.5018007755279541,
-0.7226815223693848,
0.09799536317586899,
-0.6165419220924377,
-0.5315229296684265,
-0.6262471675872803,
0.15186047554016113,
0.15150538086891174,
0.6638841032981873,
0.3006284832954407,
-0.0698409304022789,
-0.3189331293106079,
-1.1693857908248901,
-0.3207501173019409,
-0.16057270765304565,
-0.28083741664886475,
0.27671176195144653,
0.7602455019950867,
-0.11635976284742355,
0.8043166399002075,
-0.5508929491043091,
-0.23416681587696075,
-0.3248555064201355,
0.3737185299396515,
0.15370911359786987,
0.14377330243587494,
0.7030068039894104,
-0.9217621088027954,
-0.11337907612323761,
-0.21581590175628662,
-0.885068416595459,
-0.11991507560014725,
-0.23090334236621857,
-0.04581236466765404,
-0.3319222629070282,
0.39496585726737976,
-0.7187544703483582,
0.14549410343170166,
0.5910527110099792,
-0.22009901702404022,
0.7346285581588745,
-0.040246691554784775,
0.12396139651536942,
-0.8835501074790955,
0.1289179027080536,
-0.10195063054561615,
-0.051036279648542404,
-0.247968852519989,
0.2013484239578247,
-0.05570807307958603,
-0.04669151455163956,
-0.6055963635444641,
0.7134996652603149,
-0.322687566280365,
0.09938456118106842,
-0.0028486703522503376,
0.13556230068206787,
0.17887522280216217,
0.3227543234825134,
-0.09249498695135117,
0.7688749432563782,
0.5862091183662415,
-0.5263710021972656,
0.6481022238731384,
0.14094574749469757,
-0.8054846525192261,
0.5002497434616089,
-0.5304921865463257,
0.15023013949394226,
-0.2707388997077942,
0.39903610944747925,
-0.9228656888008118,
-0.31966322660446167,
0.35514992475509644,
-0.15456953644752502,
-0.16228456795215607,
0.3857555687427521,
-0.9925677180290222,
-0.2567811906337738,
-0.44334420561790466,
0.42417219281196594,
0.1330735981464386,
-0.5717646479606628,
0.36459314823150635,
0.35138192772865295,
0.027994105592370033,
-0.44144749641418457,
-0.7136766910552979,
0.37350860238075256,
-0.8468860387802124,
-0.2666783630847931,
0.21378585696220398,
-0.1964060515165329,
-0.22507257759571075,
-0.07723113894462585,
-0.18892237544059753,
-0.08816324919462204,
0.19631485641002655,
-0.07534126192331314,
0.09929745644330978,
-0.08870524168014526,
0.27476757764816284,
-0.2703095078468323,
0.045609697699546814,
0.2504524886608124,
-0.042717695236206055,
0.5204415321350098,
-0.13416889309883118,
-0.3315979838371277,
-0.3181842267513275,
0.12487567216157913,
0.9739426970481873,
0.016309726983308792,
0.7370432615280151,
0.3515077233314514,
-0.571155309677124,
0.18317681550979614,
-0.5747324228286743,
-0.10544365644454956,
-0.4054070711135864,
0.32784903049468994,
-0.5527223348617554,
-0.783172070980072,
0.6232597827911377,
0.11933667957782745,
0.00006882153684273362,
0.38249242305755615,
0.464171826839447,
-0.30592596530914307,
0.34609532356262207,
0.27910560369491577,
-0.4070534110069275,
0.10430503636598587,
0.09505893290042877,
-0.1555853933095932,
-0.7298696041107178,
-0.32458341121673584,
-0.5898727178573608,
-0.4909636974334717,
-0.30049359798431396,
-0.5423340797424316,
0.22574953734874725,
-0.14207662642002106,
-0.23439277708530426,
0.1317322552204132,
-0.26484858989715576,
0.4984719455242157,
0.3770524263381958,
-0.0838734582066536,
0.5046340823173523,
0.2924167215824127,
-0.3699128031730652,
-0.42789825797080994,
-0.5945211052894592,
-0.5556845664978027,
0.8045262098312378,
0.5227136611938477,
0.8876764178276062,
0.03874918818473816,
0.48558828234672546,
0.17283107340335846,
0.35544857382774353,
-0.7194659113883972,
0.5904538035392761,
0.05326039716601372,
-0.6456009149551392,
0.004384267143905163,
-0.5915632843971252,
-0.976222574710846,
0.27516525983810425,
-0.017217978835105896,
-1.0826960802078247,
-0.3536128103733063,
0.05990786477923393,
0.03623132035136223,
0.4173921048641205,
-0.6503302454948425,
1.0487087965011597,
-0.4304232597351074,
0.27626365423202515,
-0.07420715689659119,
-0.837200403213501,
0.5433513522148132,
-0.31630250811576843,
0.2819300591945648,
-0.190714493393898,
-0.19998547434806824,
0.9851588606834412,
0.1295175850391388,
0.5646167397499084,
0.25906723737716675,
0.005865293089300394,
0.279706746339798,
0.09741118550300598,
0.33388909697532654,
-0.11871428042650223,
-0.29322123527526855,
0.21595624089241028,
0.20236821472644806,
-0.34481626749038696,
-0.8099029064178467,
0.5140984058380127,
-0.42826274037361145,
-0.5496323108673096,
-0.7157649993896484,
-0.8897609710693359,
-0.2507120370864868,
0.020822936668992043,
0.3138965666294098,
-0.077894426882267,
-0.08141335844993591,
0.6209766864776611,
0.2685663402080536,
-0.11416757851839066,
-0.15824086964130402,
0.22018982470035553,
-0.19216157495975494,
-0.3394564390182495,
0.8717218041419983,
-0.03742941468954086,
0.2973332703113556,
0.4980916380882263,
0.4123445153236389,
-0.3845028281211853,
-0.4239655137062073,
-0.22573241591453552,
0.4916286766529083,
-0.8634698390960693,
-0.25099244713783264,
-0.696085512638092,
-0.18892036378383636,
-0.10612262040376663,
0.17072397470474243,
-0.0005061920965090394,
-0.2563651502132416,
-0.11775533854961395,
-0.1713341474533081,
0.4473395347595215,
0.8087236881256104,
0.0806247889995575,
0.32357701659202576,
-0.7621486783027649,
0.45054709911346436,
0.2066776305437088,
0.047913771122694016,
-0.017659621313214302,
-0.7517297863960266,
-0.1047094389796257,
0.003198194783180952,
-0.5567663908004761,
-1.1273325681686401,
0.2500285804271698,
0.23023410141468048,
0.5339692234992981,
0.43536633253097534,
0.17433615028858185,
0.8338587284088135,
-0.3800857961177826,
0.7052245736122131,
0.20082791149616241,
-1.0142968893051147,
0.3959827125072479,
-0.400984525680542,
0.2705698609352112,
0.5386184453964233,
0.4281010627746582,
-0.8880347609519958,
-0.5761723518371582,
-0.618899941444397,
-0.7626774907112122,
0.49902287125587463,
0.5458469390869141,
0.32708555459976196,
-0.0313197560608387,
0.46819832921028137,
0.2965294122695923,
0.5866231918334961,
-0.9744179248809814,
-0.362010657787323,
0.11084912717342377,
-0.4039582908153534,
-0.2264157384634018,
-0.2264004349708557,
-0.17646104097366333,
-0.40227481722831726,
0.21461425721645355,
0.05945084989070892,
0.22598247230052948,
-0.16058321297168732,
-0.15462389588356018,
0.18335743248462677,
0.268181711435318,
0.39743679761886597,
0.7619754672050476,
-0.27866947650909424,
0.4133344292640686,
0.41402873396873474,
-0.49632421135902405,
0.043537724763154984,
-0.02323758602142334,
0.22294707596302032,
0.012184211052954197,
0.6068823933601379,
0.8598520755767822,
0.37525469064712524,
-1.0253732204437256,
0.20453934371471405,
-0.09894391149282455,
-0.14065603911876678,
0.004324587062001228,
0.06584295630455017,
0.25962430238723755,
0.10407627373933792,
0.5877500772476196,
-0.3664378225803375,
0.2501622438430786,
-0.5357532501220703,
0.0732608512043953,
0.33499372005462646,
0.03246631845831871,
-0.1480155885219574,
0.49285638332366943,
-0.31666383147239685,
0.17014846205711365,
0.8102330565452576,
-0.15808916091918945,
-0.567557692527771,
0.8308727145195007,
0.7407209873199463,
0.6846433877944946,
0.08225783705711365,
0.08210527896881104,
-0.009060542099177837,
0.6276192665100098,
-0.052337151020765305,
0.02785034291446209,
0.13457949459552765,
-0.731876790523529,
-0.02825736440718174,
-0.641072690486908,
-0.6109247207641602,
0.9778491258621216,
-0.6829614639282227,
0.41680073738098145,
-0.123947873711586,
0.2787819504737854,
0.10826396197080612,
-0.3016376197338104,
-0.8543916940689087,
0.2826370298862457,
0.14797337353229523,
1.0111963748931885,
-1.1523818969726562,
0.7718311548233032,
1.0368107557296753,
-0.11056053638458252,
-0.7572197318077087,
0.3600144684314728,
0.14965017139911652,
-0.8801934123039246,
0.6437440514564514,
0.5540130734443665,
-0.0033786750864237547,
-0.08030446618795395,
-0.4855838119983673,
-0.5978658199310303,
1.09823739528656,
1.0082741975784302,
-0.2311353087425232,
-0.07590893656015396,
0.1333533525466919,
0.41683340072631836,
-0.5150033235549927,
0.1146933063864708,
0.6560293436050415,
0.46502485871315,
0.2547518312931061,
-1.0191490650177002,
-0.034079164266586304,
-0.05298895016312599,
-0.1090855672955513,
-0.08366367220878601,
-0.299713671207428,
1.0747278928756714,
-0.066144198179245,
-0.225236177444458,
-0.01032624114304781,
0.611304521560669,
0.5702208876609802,
0.5916767120361328,
0.7598299980163574,
0.7409720420837402,
0.7643323540687561,
0.2249833196401596,
0.9335744976997375,
0.1375381201505661,
0.5241846442222595,
1.3814598321914673,
-0.2360513061285019,
0.6640880107879639,
0.7148851752281189,
-0.11716362088918686,
0.1220751702785492,
0.9161993861198425,
0.11962168663740158,
0.4810757637023926,
0.4575731158256531,
-0.1732630729675293,
-0.0872395858168602,
-0.2688126564025879,
-0.48418864607810974,
0.713599681854248,
0.4801769554615021,
-0.37913277745246887,
-0.6331282258033752,
0.13178570568561554,
-0.017324527725577354,
-0.04356440156698227,
-0.06349891424179077,
0.5649703145027161,
0.212738037109375,
-0.4100153148174286,
0.65895015001297,
-0.04092906415462494,
0.4647045433521271,
-0.5972998738288879,
-0.1373293101787567,
-0.1333921253681183,
-0.0922449603676796,
0.15038645267486572,
-0.9274073243141174,
0.3992104232311249,
0.04244963079690933,
0.016276149079203606,
-0.0020788658875972033,
0.29227954149246216,
-0.28747251629829407,
-0.5098523497581482,
0.3069887161254883,
0.6376739740371704,
0.513717532157898,
-0.2980812191963196,
-0.9509825110435486,
0.28702646493911743,
-0.09724101424217224,
-0.22263935208320618,
0.3222900629043579,
0.9330242276191711,
-0.13299968838691711,
0.9632381796836853,
0.3268316686153412,
0.06939941644668579,
-0.09930789470672607,
-0.3670487403869629,
0.9945619702339172,
-0.6926766037940979,
-0.6632015109062195,
-1.0465549230575562,
0.11674414575099945,
0.019378233700990677,
-0.42077720165252686,
0.7110149264335632,
0.6252872347831726,
0.6959719657897949,
-0.28755974769592285,
0.6551242470741272,
0.0016415261197835207,
0.37794896960258484,
-0.7022029757499695,
0.6659538149833679,
-0.9260218739509583,
0.181395024061203,
-0.4021410644054413,
-0.925630509853363,
-0.35142388939857483,
0.7433016300201416,
-0.32833099365234375,
-0.09963341057300568,
1.0061272382736206,
0.5986148118972778,
-0.3919553756713867,
0.09809219092130661,
0.2263641357421875,
0.12432286888360977,
0.08099325746297836,
0.771480917930603,
0.9885700941085815,
-0.08896476775407791,
0.5550389289855957,
-0.1515255570411682,
-0.04773771017789841,
-0.14044460654258728,
-1.3295643329620361,
-0.7772839069366455,
-0.7412227988243103,
-0.22774818539619446,
-0.1527034342288971,
0.04212166741490364,
1.0935171842575073,
0.24559545516967773,
-0.6962161660194397,
-0.21697412431240082,
-0.05065315589308739,
0.29113292694091797,
-0.21632947027683258,
-0.23903343081474304,
0.324120432138443,
-0.2986524701118469,
-0.6070409417152405,
0.1903657168149948,
0.24866853654384613,
0.04735470563173294,
-0.006671430077403784,
0.0347750224173069,
-0.3843451738357544,
0.057325784116983414,
0.2537707984447479,
0.09381195157766342,
-0.8315794467926025,
-0.4065183103084564,
-0.16600994765758514,
-0.2567427158355713,
0.16950997710227966,
0.903667688369751,
-0.6183038353919983,
0.35898348689079285,
0.24086882174015045,
0.82215815782547,
0.2860508859157562,
-0.17707082629203796,
0.2265762984752655,
-0.730559229850769,
0.30633366107940674,
0.21633833646774292,
0.4491710960865021,
0.40867891907691956,
-0.2022203505039215,
0.5678003430366516,
0.4410478174686432,
-0.24778543412685394,
-1.1091862916946411,
0.29186221957206726,
-0.944459855556488,
-0.2538062036037445,
1.0110522508621216,
-0.2330498993396759,
-0.20104236900806427,
0.0025344882160425186,
-0.30096620321273804,
0.11903883516788483,
-0.21658417582511902,
0.847892701625824,
1.0605841875076294,
-0.08835539221763611,
-0.2851021885871887,
-0.9884241223335266,
0.24846656620502472,
0.6330497860908508,
-0.9503085017204285,
0.25490689277648926,
0.4451400935649872,
0.38888242840766907,
-0.05057675763964653,
0.4559158384799957,
0.0908394306898117,
0.05146018788218498,
-0.3803950250148773,
-0.13099610805511475,
-0.09257471561431885,
-0.35618770122528076,
-0.34018558263778687,
0.07374964654445648,
0.08189847320318222,
-0.5192142128944397
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11807v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11807v2
|
How Far Are We on the Decision-Making of LLMs? Evaluating LLMs' Gaming Ability in Multi-Agent Environments
| 2024-03-18T14:04:47 | 2024-04-25T15:04:41 |
Jen-tse Huang, Eric John Li, Man Ho Lam, Tian Liang, Wenxuan Wang, Youliang Yuan, Wenxiang Jiao, Xing Wang, Zhaopeng Tu, Michael R. Lyu
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Decision-making, a complicated task requiring various types of abilities,
presents an excellent framework for assessing Large Language Models (LLMs). Our
research investigates LLMs' decision-making capabilities through the lens of a
well-established field, Game Theory. We focus specifically on games that
support the participation of more than two agents simultaneously. Subsequently,
we introduce our framework, GAMA-Bench, including eight classical multi-agent
games. We design a scoring scheme to assess a model's performance in these
games quantitatively. Through GAMA-Bench, we investigate LLMs' robustness,
generalizability, and enhancement strategies. Results reveal that while GPT-3.5
shows satisfying robustness, its generalizability is relatively limited.
However, its performance can be improved through approaches such as
Chain-of-Thought. Additionally, we conduct evaluations across various LLMs and
find that GPT-4 outperforms other models on GAMA-Bench, achieving a score of
60.5. Moreover, Gemini-1.0-Pro and GPT-3.5 (0613, 1106, 0125) demonstrate
similar intelligence on GAMA-Bench. The code and experimental results are made
publicly available via https://github.com/CUHK-ARISE/GAMABench.
|
[
-0.6660978198051453,
-0.8979877233505249,
1.144598364830017,
0.29377907514572144,
0.0011027061846107244,
0.25730806589126587,
-0.4723227322101593,
-0.49418020248413086,
-0.08089091628789902,
0.21684186160564423,
-0.4984040856361389,
-0.610621988773346,
-0.5947130918502808,
-0.03958101570606232,
-0.009218187071383,
0.6718080043792725,
0.004118335898965597,
0.24758398532867432,
-0.5566699504852295,
-0.20445801317691803,
-0.43599966168403625,
-0.6089928150177002,
-0.8870759606361389,
-0.5531997680664062,
0.2679327130317688,
0.2923428416252136,
0.7917868494987488,
0.47995761036872864,
0.6559330224990845,
0.34342309832572937,
-0.04053002595901489,
0.22760464251041412,
-0.45903176069259644,
0.3826660215854645,
-0.3036248981952667,
-0.5723950266838074,
-0.7713823914527893,
0.2546613812446594,
0.4847971796989441,
0.20969977974891663,
-0.1829468011856079,
0.3062123954296112,
-0.011846083216369152,
0.46364250779151917,
-0.44493424892425537,
0.3463500440120697,
-0.53822261095047,
0.08170990645885468,
0.09652328491210938,
0.07102782279253006,
-0.315402090549469,
-0.06098562479019165,
0.21024993062019348,
-0.330691933631897,
0.04339428246021271,
0.15598715841770172,
0.6310782432556152,
0.1970892697572708,
-0.2011035680770874,
-0.3885592818260193,
-0.7712822556495667,
0.5754503607749939,
-0.5418415665626526,
0.13393191993236542,
0.5830927491188049,
0.7350038886070251,
-0.2685927450656891,
-0.4549991488456726,
-0.3382331430912018,
-0.4505230784416199,
0.3817397952079773,
0.3978795111179352,
-0.26633527874946594,
0.23059645295143127,
0.3062961995601654,
0.11847072839736938,
-0.3195702135562897,
0.1459181308746338,
-0.10165658593177795,
0.005437171086668968,
0.7133474349975586,
0.24447888135910034,
0.14610423147678375,
0.18926915526390076,
-0.3179062604904175,
0.13764134049415588,
-0.6360622644424438,
0.0020885709673166275,
0.30738741159439087,
0.19369491934776306,
0.03039027750492096,
0.545195460319519,
0.020212974399328232,
0.45560094714164734,
0.01285809651017189,
-0.02543560229241848,
-0.07993895560503006,
-0.34232571721076965,
-0.31275972723960876,
-0.4261024594306946,
0.8153666257858276,
0.5922939777374268,
0.09485325217247009,
-0.33620622754096985,
-0.41451841592788696,
0.3171369731426239,
0.20328859984874725,
-0.5008562207221985,
-0.028531886637210846,
0.27975994348526,
-0.3253650963306427,
-0.06643594801425934,
-0.09853433072566986,
-0.7368141412734985,
-0.7682016491889954,
-0.08485527336597443,
0.5526289343833923,
-0.21813173592090607,
-0.16698776185512543,
0.1042095199227333,
-0.1644289195537567,
0.2717980444431305,
0.273058146238327,
-0.7929775714874268,
0.513617992401123,
0.659241795539856,
0.9936662316322327,
-0.30068475008010864,
-0.5398181080818176,
-0.3980897068977356,
0.1336769163608551,
-0.5023746490478516,
0.954657793045044,
-0.6397174596786499,
-0.7165277004241943,
-0.20258307456970215,
-0.23655915260314941,
0.012456481344997883,
-0.508211612701416,
0.651617169380188,
-0.3672753870487213,
-0.005249629262834787,
-0.5395490527153015,
-0.5167617797851562,
-0.2256879359483719,
0.7575581073760986,
-0.7037510871887207,
0.6899691820144653,
-0.011396719142794609,
-0.1463247537612915,
0.5741425156593323,
-0.6672694087028503,
-0.3556978404521942,
-0.05986341834068298,
-0.3054168224334717,
-0.3811275064945221,
0.2378363460302353,
0.17831836640834808,
0.40547481179237366,
-0.5616816878318787,
0.01213295292109251,
-0.729076623916626,
-0.45340555906295776,
0.2538567781448364,
-0.2824203372001648,
0.19795124232769012,
0.18508701026439667,
-0.33093225955963135,
0.27606791257858276,
-0.3571193516254425,
0.22347617149353027,
0.02704928256571293,
-0.44286710023880005,
0.035841647535562515,
0.447286993265152,
-0.38490188121795654,
0.5700510144233704,
-0.08193331956863403,
-0.12026655673980713,
0.3231513500213623,
0.017501892521977425,
0.5932098627090454,
0.7354499697685242,
-0.08017291873693466,
0.5599535703659058,
-0.6015779376029968,
0.7611714005470276,
-0.4452928304672241,
0.3963099718093872,
0.4313613772392273,
-0.6560338139533997,
-0.7225220203399658,
-0.26573729515075684,
0.36464306712150574,
0.49784204363822937,
-0.7189534306526184,
0.19553567469120026,
-0.10594557225704193,
-0.4322849214076996,
-0.4699224531650543,
-0.12358585000038147,
0.2568710148334503,
-0.07930731028318405,
0.192843958735466,
-0.29558277130126953,
-0.37994474172592163,
-0.6894441843032837,
-0.05338428542017937,
-0.23357965052127838,
0.1557570844888687,
0.5412415862083435,
0.6889258027076721,
-0.4008782207965851,
0.7647651433944702,
-0.07845041155815125,
-0.18683747947216034,
-0.23834164440631866,
-0.15223069489002228,
0.16048482060432434,
0.11132080852985382,
0.6544649004936218,
-0.2874527871608734,
-0.2845175266265869,
0.15230564773082733,
-0.7555187940597534,
0.03794054314494133,
0.02888229489326477,
-0.09167644381523132,
0.1076042577624321,
0.2181735783815384,
-0.8861922025680542,
0.2503211498260498,
0.5833951830863953,
-0.3378215730190277,
0.6691967844963074,
-0.47525665163993835,
0.3403395712375641,
-0.6182877421379089,
-0.18357551097869873,
-0.12058734148740768,
-0.15764322876930237,
-0.6913273334503174,
0.33990639448165894,
-0.1439485102891922,
0.33138948678970337,
-0.1090751513838768,
0.5222011804580688,
-0.6950299739837646,
-0.49490976333618164,
-0.4200953543186188,
0.29347825050354004,
-0.14990249276161194,
0.35641753673553467,
-0.15162092447280884,
0.8258839845657349,
0.728694498538971,
-0.7130207419395447,
0.4168129563331604,
-0.07904418557882309,
-0.58650803565979,
0.47404971718788147,
-0.41002151370048523,
0.342882364988327,
0.03488019481301308,
0.17669031023979187,
-0.9762119054794312,
0.030183248221874237,
0.23478993773460388,
-0.4779343903064728,
0.026229072362184525,
-0.15118831396102905,
-0.4436050057411194,
-0.3476254642009735,
-0.40896162390708923,
0.04597841575741768,
0.18727533519268036,
-0.26518377661705017,
0.8124915957450867,
0.7259414792060852,
-0.31873220205307007,
-0.3911924958229065,
-0.7150595188140869,
0.24233274161815643,
-0.2402152121067047,
-0.5704110860824585,
0.08933504670858383,
-0.2804241478443146,
-0.6473988890647888,
-0.15191037952899933,
-0.13414673507213593,
0.0913238674402237,
0.20565424859523773,
0.25316646695137024,
0.16153617203235626,
0.02884652465581894,
0.18981896340847015,
-0.2385321706533432,
-0.09491503983736038,
0.23349620401859283,
-0.09944583475589752,
0.4784815311431885,
-0.5320979356765747,
-0.48340505361557007,
0.48978835344314575,
0.14901797473430634,
0.6137701869010925,
-0.31873735785484314,
0.2649490535259247,
0.35821160674095154,
-0.11291529983282089,
-0.4303714334964752,
-0.5716214179992676,
0.11361929774284363,
-0.39205923676490784,
0.46996569633483887,
-0.5471351742744446,
-0.9388375878334045,
0.9323186278343201,
-0.06010664626955986,
0.04227590560913086,
0.26560038328170776,
0.952214241027832,
0.1944212019443512,
1.361250638961792,
0.43055009841918945,
-0.05917080491781235,
0.1641819328069687,
-0.1967039257287979,
-0.02174258790910244,
-0.5722863674163818,
-0.1452002227306366,
-0.4026815593242645,
-0.3672525882720947,
-0.6270968317985535,
-0.7976783514022827,
0.26945558190345764,
-0.20264603197574615,
-0.23618893325328827,
-0.1440519541501999,
-0.18232274055480957,
0.7798751592636108,
0.30279451608657837,
0.007977272383868694,
0.18150834739208221,
-0.30973201990127563,
-0.4519142210483551,
0.36831381916999817,
-0.5623000264167786,
-0.5621611475944519,
1.0573087930679321,
0.4010484218597412,
0.5374341607093811,
0.5158769488334656,
0.5803722143173218,
0.3031788468360901,
0.3639361262321472,
-0.907060444355011,
0.6639560461044312,
0.13762301206588745,
-0.8127961158752441,
-0.34229791164398193,
-0.4989349842071533,
-0.8268476128578186,
0.7641438245773315,
-0.48434531688690186,
-0.600260853767395,
-0.15019510686397552,
-0.43591344356536865,
-0.6023610234260559,
0.26080840826034546,
-0.8010120391845703,
0.5465866923332214,
-0.47213077545166016,
-0.5847189426422119,
-0.3488777279853821,
-0.40451568365097046,
0.4176962077617645,
-0.0013091806322336197,
0.445991188287735,
-0.3381986916065216,
-0.3737034499645233,
0.4117956757545471,
0.02813892625272274,
0.23372603952884674,
-0.07637576013803482,
-0.02367153763771057,
0.37610700726509094,
0.1850307434797287,
0.2569475471973419,
0.2819860577583313,
-0.4030245542526245,
-0.02058858424425125,
0.05800435319542885,
-0.2043500542640686,
-0.5386240482330322,
0.7312883734703064,
-0.8489847779273987,
-0.8463168144226074,
-0.6416105031967163,
-0.5207642912864685,
-0.7192814946174622,
0.1823989748954773,
-0.008799509145319462,
0.01040891744196415,
-0.5258072018623352,
-0.05075538158416748,
0.26866254210472107,
-0.05194726958870888,
0.5194085836410522,
0.6576743721961975,
-0.5603792667388916,
-0.4550366997718811,
0.8775711059570312,
0.24035996198654175,
0.33364859223365784,
0.03369186073541641,
0.20557083189487457,
-0.5463122129440308,
-0.8804033994674683,
-0.3284105658531189,
0.042133841663599014,
-0.6908692717552185,
0.046867381781339645,
0.01938490755856037,
-0.00043276610085740685,
-0.08528546988964081,
0.16873900592327118,
-0.0007585251005366445,
-0.09079097956418991,
0.03357349708676338,
-0.28499823808670044,
-0.18412964046001434,
1.1660287380218506,
-0.12857288122177124,
0.17308878898620605,
-0.6129223704338074,
0.04391215741634369,
0.45456889271736145,
0.646018922328949,
-0.07881152629852295,
-0.18277423083782196,
-0.17437979578971863,
-0.01882079243659973,
-0.1520133912563324,
-0.8784674406051636,
0.14613904058933258,
0.04051604121923447,
0.9771016836166382,
0.20283955335617065,
-0.31736889481544495,
0.5201316475868225,
-0.38482505083084106,
0.7335273623466492,
-0.0539248064160347,
-0.8471525311470032,
0.12538933753967285,
-0.5074981451034546,
0.3492526710033417,
0.6755571961402893,
-0.03608977049589157,
-0.23489031195640564,
-0.4348672032356262,
-0.5843445658683777,
-0.3704472482204437,
0.7882183790206909,
0.16546516120433807,
-0.16895855963230133,
0.04749482125043869,
0.11410081386566162,
-0.03147014603018761,
0.24875201284885406,
-0.5449502468109131,
-0.23851540684700012,
0.26245537400245667,
0.42184385657310486,
-0.4082352817058563,
-0.19244809448719025,
-0.14341780543327332,
-0.22543546557426453,
0.5011849999427795,
-0.11042100191116333,
0.32455453276634216,
-0.16261397302150726,
0.005934893153607845,
-0.08847915381193161,
0.4134975075721741,
0.6813017725944519,
0.8896834850311279,
-0.22758880257606506,
0.039683181792497635,
0.4659252166748047,
-0.3660455644130707,
0.28740793466567993,
0.18769514560699463,
-0.018411986529827118,
-0.28470781445503235,
0.2454039454460144,
0.6984612345695496,
-0.023398496210575104,
-0.47354722023010254,
0.39185136556625366,
-0.4876173138618469,
-0.4641265869140625,
0.22976526618003845,
0.08970724791288376,
0.1652642786502838,
0.66398686170578,
0.07986210286617279,
-0.00027908390620723367,
0.1331324428319931,
-0.7360832095146179,
0.08871448040008545,
0.6636303067207336,
-0.13456124067306519,
-0.10984362661838531,
0.336166650056839,
0.2486869990825653,
-0.12142153084278107,
0.34845271706581116,
-0.5569688677787781,
-0.4959799647331238,
0.707730233669281,
0.35208359360694885,
0.8518345952033997,
-0.14996112883090973,
0.35381272435188293,
0.06681711971759796,
0.4576199948787689,
-0.29459330439567566,
0.36144116520881653,
0.022566339001059532,
-0.6687151789665222,
-0.4870362877845764,
-0.37295597791671753,
-0.7570280432701111,
0.013958913274109364,
-0.31505173444747925,
0.09901422262191772,
-0.7228114604949951,
-0.8704253435134888,
-0.20001335442066193,
0.4747319221496582,
-0.6489002108573914,
-0.03403614088892937,
0.44136714935302734,
0.6608505249023438,
-0.4783388674259186,
0.707547128200531,
0.8661230206489563,
-0.34449535608291626,
-0.5643661618232727,
-0.25071579217910767,
0.18044167757034302,
-0.8181834816932678,
-0.006976460572332144,
0.03407702594995499,
-0.2857827842235565,
-0.2357027232646942,
-0.5257351398468018,
-0.8017936944961548,
1.2718935012817383,
0.4801570475101471,
-0.4858973026275635,
-0.015319976024329662,
-0.004347723908722401,
0.5539339780807495,
-0.3093176484107971,
0.7184051275253296,
0.9310365915298462,
0.6642376184463501,
0.11473850160837173,
-0.9200940132141113,
-0.18728721141815186,
-0.14473015069961548,
-0.21372246742248535,
0.17144574224948883,
-0.8899056315422058,
0.9895960092544556,
-0.4546377956867218,
-0.3360969126224518,
0.17245301604270935,
0.49733251333236694,
0.536513090133667,
0.196966290473938,
0.4199520945549011,
0.5678462386131287,
0.9528799057006836,
-0.2556004226207733,
0.9912252426147461,
-0.14183761179447174,
0.5469009280204773,
0.8719471096992493,
-0.5295718908309937,
0.7150853276252747,
0.1456882208585739,
-0.49390676617622375,
0.27325254678726196,
0.7312048077583313,
-0.11648306250572205,
0.3686246871948242,
0.48353156447410583,
-0.20257613062858582,
-0.535521388053894,
0.12495654821395874,
-0.31832149624824524,
0.610777735710144,
0.5127627849578857,
-0.16497445106506348,
-0.3361504077911377,
-0.32562607526779175,
-0.008879839442670345,
-0.2401273101568222,
-0.40815919637680054,
0.6420753598213196,
0.13010112941265106,
-0.8259122967720032,
0.2064097821712494,
0.04825751110911369,
0.5039694905281067,
-0.6912472248077393,
0.08250871300697327,
-0.15636292099952698,
0.40863826870918274,
0.01419922150671482,
-1.0166817903518677,
-0.1888628602027893,
-0.0889625996351242,
-0.21044741570949554,
-0.029832784086465836,
0.7087417244911194,
-0.3447283208370209,
-0.37204477190971375,
0.5400394797325134,
1.0654587745666504,
0.052049603313207626,
-0.15214161574840546,
-0.9009885787963867,
0.33352965116500854,
-0.2822575569152832,
-0.16130898892879486,
0.6322259306907654,
0.3253636062145233,
0.03996015712618828,
0.7397729754447937,
0.4653932750225067,
0.15803876519203186,
-0.24115386605262756,
0.2660660445690155,
0.5448373556137085,
-0.5055697560310364,
-0.50591641664505,
-1.142911434173584,
-0.12324504554271698,
-0.04417387396097183,
-0.42708009481430054,
0.9601925611495972,
0.4575669765472412,
0.48862361907958984,
0.08573344349861145,
1.0456401109695435,
0.05293429270386696,
0.04799183830618858,
-0.43662095069885254,
0.799919068813324,
-0.3153059482574463,
0.2716710865497589,
-0.18427756428718567,
-0.9106338620185852,
-0.2906721830368042,
0.5294278264045715,
-0.6433776021003723,
0.274625301361084,
0.515070915222168,
0.8046932816505432,
0.3328975737094879,
0.09490886330604553,
0.5364440679550171,
0.0206318236887455,
0.520897626876831,
0.9559839367866516,
1.2918081283569336,
0.027058888226747513,
0.4777999222278595,
0.08369776606559753,
-0.4098263382911682,
0.015895292162895203,
-0.8628777265548706,
-1.0462210178375244,
-0.3629407286643982,
0.16142134368419647,
-0.2698855698108673,
0.14264456927776337,
0.8588294386863708,
0.6396576166152954,
-0.5254368185997009,
-0.5584792494773865,
0.2540501356124878,
0.34625351428985596,
-0.39880651235580444,
-0.08156224340200424,
0.12128174304962158,
-0.32133570313453674,
-0.5410833954811096,
0.5523253679275513,
0.2993529438972473,
-0.12222764641046524,
-0.4004703462123871,
-0.5245018601417542,
-0.394222617149353,
0.27590280771255493,
0.7776401042938232,
0.10217791050672531,
-0.726564884185791,
-0.248979389667511,
0.025424322113394737,
-0.2699863910675049,
-0.0652119368314743,
0.6224183440208435,
-0.440157413482666,
0.6287169456481934,
0.4699137508869171,
0.5412245988845825,
0.37981367111206055,
-0.049550190567970276,
0.6331964135169983,
-0.23541782796382904,
-0.30223217606544495,
0.25828564167022705,
0.5084053874015808,
0.2332359403371811,
0.20328480005264282,
0.6811850070953369,
-0.0010113271418958902,
-0.9153652191162109,
-0.46975982189178467,
0.0340317040681839,
-0.8055965900421143,
-0.2569882869720459,
1.5217610597610474,
0.018301881849765778,
-0.23277561366558075,
-0.07846572995185852,
-0.3293644189834595,
-0.06984946131706238,
-0.37731462717056274,
0.6375927925109863,
1.356078028678894,
-0.24739816784858704,
-0.07058943063020706,
-0.7680208683013916,
0.5111965537071228,
0.10624755173921585,
-0.8492435812950134,
-0.07138797640800476,
0.7478237748146057,
0.04748182371258736,
0.2017463743686676,
0.7314493060112,
0.09023616462945938,
0.5093900561332703,
0.18455179035663605,
-0.205600768327713,
-0.22617632150650024,
-0.32593846321105957,
-0.4619410037994385,
0.17827364802360535,
0.47414445877075195,
-0.1294722557067871
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11802v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11802v3
|
Counting-Stars: A Multi-evidence, Position-aware, and Scalable Benchmark for Evaluating Long-Context Large Language Models
| 2024-03-18T14:01:45 | 2024-05-17T16:58:23 |
Mingyang Song, Mao Zheng, Xuan Luo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
While recent research endeavors have focused on developing Large Language
Models (LLMs) with robust long-context capabilities, due to the lack of
long-context benchmarks, relatively little is known about how well the
performance of long-context LLMs. To address this gap, we propose a
multi-evidence, position-aware, and scalable benchmark for evaluating
long-context LLMs, named Counting-Stars, which evaluates long-context LLMs by
using two tasks: multi-evidence acquisition and multi-evidence reasoning. Based
on the Counting-Stars test, we conduct experiments to evaluate long-context
LLMs (i.e., GPT-4 Turbo, Gemini 1.5 Pro, Claude3 Opus, GLM-4, and Moonshot-v1).
Experimental results demonstrate that Gemini 1.5 Pro achieves the best overall
results, while the performance of GPT-4 Turbo is the most stable across various
tasks. Furthermore, our analysis of these LLMs, which are extended to handle
long-context scenarios, indicates that there is potential for improvement as
the length of the input context and the intricacy of the tasks are increasing.
|
[
-0.5829877257347107,
-0.62013840675354,
0.9372254610061646,
0.5068313479423523,
-0.23891039192676544,
-0.07073332369327545,
-0.6862063407897949,
-0.6323442459106445,
0.159144788980484,
0.38527601957321167,
-0.2728114128112793,
-0.5083773136138916,
-0.8668301701545715,
0.16030694544315338,
-0.5757794976234436,
0.8999126553535461,
0.08208045363426208,
-0.04411007836461067,
-0.3614986836910248,
-0.2296207696199417,
-0.5609020590782166,
-0.4999576210975647,
-0.37421220541000366,
0.1333567351102829,
0.79995197057724,
0.42715325951576233,
0.5057660937309265,
0.5696531534194946,
0.5213542580604553,
0.3402981162071228,
0.12131775170564651,
0.07560794055461884,
-0.2892279326915741,
0.16895009577274323,
-0.18662625551223755,
-0.09429977834224701,
-0.4330335855484009,
-0.03681182488799095,
0.8852753043174744,
0.5213652849197388,
0.0618833489716053,
0.24383199214935303,
0.05699601769447327,
0.4629910886287689,
-0.8449306488037109,
0.2956259548664093,
-0.4226365089416504,
-0.34727194905281067,
-0.5285307168960571,
0.08896078169345856,
-0.4714004695415497,
-0.08462011069059372,
0.1860773265361786,
-0.4097727835178375,
-0.19244836270809174,
-0.1399795264005661,
0.3158666789531708,
0.12988735735416412,
-0.5936338901519775,
-0.40778470039367676,
-0.5994864702224731,
1.0188589096069336,
-0.789770781993866,
0.7564210891723633,
0.3728353679180145,
0.3905419409275055,
-0.0546969473361969,
-0.7562428712844849,
-0.5331818461418152,
-0.3977832794189453,
0.01554058026522398,
0.10463743656873703,
0.13813382387161255,
-0.29477694630622864,
0.2549647390842438,
0.16474199295043945,
-0.4548158347606659,
0.3327150046825409,
-0.17129968106746674,
-0.21004627645015717,
0.4321024417877197,
-0.1363244354724884,
-0.13654407858848572,
0.14000196754932404,
-0.3829084038734436,
0.0817023292183876,
-0.7370620965957642,
0.050915565341711044,
-0.04856989160180092,
0.3442596197128296,
-0.22302214801311493,
0.40991711616516113,
-0.36140120029449463,
0.7814651131629944,
-0.24348104000091553,
-0.2581360936164856,
0.253427654504776,
-0.45981061458587646,
-0.023108607158064842,
0.003702573711052537,
0.771041989326477,
0.3414737284183502,
0.05772748962044716,
-0.22008198499679565,
-0.3134399354457855,
0.2784045338630676,
-0.03744004666805267,
-1.236325979232788,
0.19301526248455048,
0.23888620734214783,
-0.0836019441485405,
-0.026250425726175308,
-0.031169747933745384,
-0.6430169343948364,
-0.3283582031726837,
-0.09253840148448944,
0.5133824944496155,
-0.40858304500579834,
-0.17120620608329773,
0.1891803741455078,
0.052875883877277374,
-0.013890642672777176,
0.18058140575885773,
-0.880935549736023,
0.23968660831451416,
1.3361799716949463,
0.7514658570289612,
-0.20343747735023499,
-0.6930488348007202,
-0.9923320412635803,
-0.03971344605088234,
-0.3659282326698303,
0.7760035395622253,
-0.6827264428138733,
-0.19869127869606018,
0.09242097288370132,
0.052417632192373276,
-0.027951205149292946,
-0.3711972236633301,
0.9252927899360657,
-0.4089258015155792,
0.3807630240917206,
-0.5532015562057495,
-0.9080935716629028,
-0.15117111802101135,
0.324566125869751,
-0.523195207118988,
1.0168793201446533,
-0.05715510994195938,
-0.4141250252723694,
0.7038909792900085,
-0.6023235321044922,
-0.4660019874572754,
0.17753641307353973,
-0.4118574857711792,
-0.24613253772258759,
0.3313893675804138,
0.2353454977273941,
0.6365780830383301,
-0.48827502131462097,
0.363167405128479,
-0.4498625695705414,
-0.5472783446311951,
0.26300206780433655,
-0.2472797930240631,
0.3326934576034546,
0.19731149077415466,
-0.4070337414741516,
0.38333651423454285,
-0.4779728353023529,
0.01168343611061573,
-0.05079187825322151,
-0.3417641222476959,
-0.39259645342826843,
0.4297087490558624,
-0.009719152003526688,
0.3275560438632965,
0.2834392786026001,
-0.6912292242050171,
0.13207681477069855,
0.014625756070017815,
0.39819884300231934,
0.39218613505363464,
-0.24567008018493652,
0.1101328507065773,
-0.15603163838386536,
0.15181873738765717,
0.1782197207212448,
0.04591739922761917,
-0.3788289725780487,
-0.6052678227424622,
-0.6585618853569031,
-0.5143937468528748,
0.0772327110171318,
0.1932404786348343,
-0.7377141118049622,
0.659991443157196,
-0.5334408283233643,
-0.46722763776779175,
-0.08267182856798172,
0.10650747269392014,
0.4180954098701477,
0.4001827538013458,
0.3919108808040619,
-0.29775378108024597,
-0.2156958281993866,
-0.9187602400779724,
-0.30888631939888,
-0.08319738507270813,
0.0456811860203743,
0.24696744978427887,
0.6838027238845825,
-0.24391724169254303,
0.8588597774505615,
-0.3320017158985138,
-0.016839193180203438,
0.057133253663778305,
-0.03436463326215744,
0.4516283869743347,
0.2595447301864624,
0.6367190480232239,
-0.41529402136802673,
-0.4792443811893463,
-0.0626210868358612,
-0.7567197680473328,
-0.018641827628016472,
0.12269610911607742,
0.2679911255836487,
0.291157066822052,
0.3610534369945526,
-0.8276992440223694,
-0.048329826444387436,
0.9285065531730652,
-0.7242743968963623,
0.7651040554046631,
0.04514831677079201,
0.3312244117259979,
-0.903339684009552,
0.15496347844600677,
0.042495716363191605,
-0.3335535228252411,
-0.6821098923683167,
0.0331248976290226,
0.5155719518661499,
0.04875845089554787,
-0.24070627987384796,
0.666921854019165,
-0.4339846670627594,
-0.35306844115257263,
-0.45360973477363586,
0.1040862649679184,
-0.16463293135166168,
0.24596787989139557,
0.2209453582763672,
0.9718709588050842,
0.8840895295143127,
-0.5751897692680359,
0.1557401418685913,
-0.19597843289375305,
-1.0531678199768066,
0.6316772103309631,
-0.3990006446838379,
0.018195731565356255,
0.15575888752937317,
0.3786187767982483,
-0.7749403119087219,
-0.05904102697968483,
-0.12177247554063797,
-0.20309016108512878,
0.009861878119409084,
-0.1656622290611267,
-0.5371081829071045,
-0.4423951506614685,
-0.17613938450813293,
0.5297520756721497,
0.2486976981163025,
-0.7313427329063416,
0.22639012336730957,
0.2934623658657074,
-0.4342561960220337,
-0.8178369998931885,
-0.1208547055721283,
0.3658824563026428,
-0.493299275636673,
-0.5329001545906067,
0.4113157391548157,
-0.01187597680836916,
-0.21551574766635895,
-0.17596013844013214,
-0.1120157241821289,
0.30170321464538574,
0.12313448637723923,
0.11633762717247009,
0.0318644642829895,
-0.3845357894897461,
0.30848124623298645,
-0.33062052726745605,
-0.27181920409202576,
0.1634194552898407,
-0.5300315618515015,
0.5684548616409302,
-0.6093540787696838,
-0.4643625020980835,
0.10839300602674484,
0.31979358196258545,
1.082497477531433,
-0.43738678097724915,
0.768672525882721,
0.6922359466552734,
-0.45064258575439453,
-0.2733090817928314,
-0.854939341545105,
-0.11573736369609833,
-0.4455612897872925,
0.6478523015975952,
-0.36599835753440857,
-1.1717685461044312,
0.4941568672657013,
-0.019422639161348343,
0.295217365026474,
0.41757917404174805,
0.7323777675628662,
0.09444228559732437,
0.6879218816757202,
0.4081437587738037,
-0.4016337990760803,
0.35642534494400024,
0.06774377822875977,
-0.012755322270095348,
-0.7764316201210022,
0.13940298557281494,
-0.43332234025001526,
-0.15051764249801636,
-0.32732969522476196,
-0.8618651628494263,
0.40076637268066406,
0.1952405422925949,
-0.3747439682483673,
0.461734414100647,
-0.25917109847068787,
0.4871777296066284,
0.21253609657287598,
-0.2454996109008789,
0.27527400851249695,
-0.4010694921016693,
-0.047966454178094864,
0.11572661995887756,
-0.43972551822662354,
-0.27794089913368225,
0.9819126129150391,
0.4876473546028137,
0.4570927619934082,
0.3894355297088623,
0.4878246486186981,
-0.028155412524938583,
0.7320960164070129,
-0.9606947302818298,
0.617236852645874,
-0.25018590688705444,
-0.7077631950378418,
-0.4169529974460602,
-0.4718230664730072,
-0.7214874029159546,
0.47387972474098206,
-0.24569553136825562,
-0.713786244392395,
0.020300105214118958,
-0.1502666473388672,
-0.26880770921707153,
0.16688185930252075,
-0.5347487926483154,
0.9731686115264893,
-0.7568318247795105,
-0.5726882815361023,
-0.45455822348594666,
-0.19221951067447662,
0.45930567383766174,
-0.3943043351173401,
0.26341015100479126,
-0.277033269405365,
-0.1882573664188385,
0.7997468709945679,
-0.36726006865501404,
0.5582238435745239,
-0.29450079798698425,
-0.3140304982662201,
0.2660606801509857,
-0.07883010059595108,
0.7905371189117432,
0.12282438576221466,
-0.1573244035243988,
0.37767910957336426,
0.055699266493320465,
-0.2828477621078491,
-0.31020721793174744,
1.2080215215682983,
-0.5107897520065308,
-0.36144664883613586,
-0.5981265902519226,
-0.5308459401130676,
-0.40588659048080444,
0.41880419850349426,
-0.016678782179951668,
0.5002754926681519,
-0.2251557856798172,
0.6578973531723022,
0.04689685255289078,
-0.2634918689727783,
0.750481367111206,
0.828132152557373,
-0.6003684401512146,
-0.4653348922729492,
0.7866154313087463,
0.04323572665452957,
0.1552337259054184,
0.31280386447906494,
0.29695481061935425,
-0.6197567582130432,
-0.777184247970581,
-0.5291897058486938,
0.20341117680072784,
-0.5708562135696411,
0.13380400836467743,
-0.4406222701072693,
0.13165050745010376,
-0.18229787051677704,
0.051315926015377045,
-0.715031623840332,
-0.1944374442100525,
0.420642226934433,
0.2215239405632019,
0.2878672778606415,
0.6484415531158447,
0.30487632751464844,
0.2174401730298996,
-0.8392573595046997,
0.15695570409297943,
0.34331583976745605,
0.9831979274749756,
-0.12920230627059937,
-0.39784932136535645,
-0.6575471758842468,
-0.3593273162841797,
-0.060750581324100494,
-0.5196456909179688,
0.18718859553337097,
0.11531885713338852,
0.5069019794464111,
0.5054818987846375,
-0.338256299495697,
0.7764662504196167,
-0.5378309488296509,
0.7204807996749878,
0.29306089878082275,
-0.896589457988739,
-0.0686555728316307,
-0.6253362894058228,
0.5092489123344421,
0.6629691123962402,
0.15494942665100098,
-0.7534018754959106,
-0.14612674713134766,
-0.22723990678787231,
-0.6331005096435547,
0.42856431007385254,
0.11176050454378128,
-0.29241520166397095,
-0.348136305809021,
0.10875912755727768,
0.11520938575267792,
0.2855374813079834,
-0.5333054661750793,
0.0316539891064167,
0.008759594522416592,
0.08587795495986938,
-0.6473391652107239,
-0.2794666588306427,
-0.014751816168427467,
-0.10247660428285599,
0.46599456667900085,
-0.262681245803833,
0.08096898347139359,
-0.047488413751125336,
-0.1777021586894989,
0.16201013326644897,
0.4605551064014435,
0.8622357845306396,
1.0866506099700928,
-0.2656305432319641,
0.3019401431083679,
0.24249759316444397,
-0.37636905908584595,
-0.21956852078437805,
0.23157237470149994,
0.09886805713176727,
-0.13710357248783112,
0.49943259358406067,
0.6596575379371643,
0.5239086151123047,
-0.571267306804657,
0.4878198504447937,
-0.07111252099275589,
0.028214339166879654,
-0.44587060809135437,
-0.16135728359222412,
0.6505550742149353,
0.15117287635803223,
0.23301999270915985,
-0.0843207836151123,
-0.14229708909988403,
-0.7633445262908936,
0.40948158502578735,
0.5367762446403503,
-0.43279412388801575,
-0.233649343252182,
0.44814157485961914,
0.43744638562202454,
-0.199092298746109,
0.6025500893592834,
-0.060988668352365494,
-0.4134279787540436,
0.6058291792869568,
0.6147884726524353,
0.8412684202194214,
-0.1621454954147339,
-0.16241954267024994,
0.5775080919265747,
0.09378847479820251,
-0.38399699330329895,
0.19886034727096558,
-0.21690087020397186,
-0.748759388923645,
-0.832431972026825,
-0.6411136388778687,
-0.4596595764160156,
0.35444408655166626,
-0.46632301807403564,
0.13186617195606232,
-0.2823450565338135,
-0.3357838988304138,
0.25720760226249695,
0.0506477989256382,
-0.6553208231925964,
0.011267351917922497,
0.4218621850013733,
0.9152858853340149,
-0.6554086804389954,
1.0816901922225952,
0.4001043438911438,
0.23256918787956238,
-0.4305434226989746,
-0.13741853833198547,
0.12545378506183624,
-0.5742542147636414,
0.5245809555053711,
0.6633231043815613,
-0.3379566967487335,
-0.28734543919563293,
-0.2218884378671646,
-0.9698071479797363,
1.1210095882415771,
0.08439570665359497,
-0.9199965596199036,
0.650261402130127,
-0.04115574434399605,
0.5459632873535156,
-0.5591729283332825,
0.4249088764190674,
0.6006289720535278,
0.6706812977790833,
-0.053506720811128616,
-1.1950377225875854,
0.0034927763044834137,
-0.36899277567863464,
-0.3629318177700043,
0.48595455288887024,
-0.7409342527389526,
0.8677688837051392,
-0.14910055696964264,
-0.21977700293064117,
0.14795361459255219,
0.7047059535980225,
0.615142822265625,
0.33702245354652405,
0.8663425445556641,
0.5137575268745422,
0.5956324338912964,
-0.1694720834493637,
1.1087208986282349,
-0.7084060311317444,
0.31645721197128296,
1.195892333984375,
-0.6307563781738281,
1.1020010709762573,
0.3723008632659912,
-0.12371299415826797,
0.39382079243659973,
0.396410197019577,
0.03102065809071064,
0.23132279515266418,
0.12873892486095428,
-0.44124171137809753,
-0.4554413855075836,
0.05313638225197792,
-0.3766251802444458,
0.6093493103981018,
0.5350663065910339,
-0.2027796357870102,
-0.12266658246517181,
-0.4285454750061035,
0.04712681472301483,
-0.22701193392276764,
-0.07605741173028946,
0.405702143907547,
0.199467733502388,
-1.3521556854248047,
0.4996342957019806,
0.19971293210983276,
0.8432145118713379,
-0.7997339367866516,
0.169059619307518,
-0.05071418732404709,
0.48612165451049805,
-0.10624276846647263,
-0.9651976227760315,
0.0008699605823494494,
0.17560631036758423,
-0.04975453391671181,
-0.08071122318506241,
0.47687578201293945,
-0.4852803945541382,
-0.6848447322845459,
0.5234500765800476,
0.4732188582420349,
0.1370055228471756,
-0.32294851541519165,
-0.43336576223373413,
0.21170586347579956,
-0.36661913990974426,
-0.3549901843070984,
0.6043965220451355,
0.1874154806137085,
-0.24493853747844696,
0.7681503295898438,
0.7694791555404663,
0.08518214523792267,
-0.21915094554424286,
0.35980841517448425,
0.6791204214096069,
-1.0114330053329468,
-0.6212880611419678,
-1.0321277379989624,
0.22603265941143036,
-0.054641395807266235,
-0.45910367369651794,
0.964713454246521,
0.9691162109375,
0.46171900629997253,
-0.09094449877738953,
0.5696932673454285,
-0.09352727234363556,
0.47523027658462524,
-0.39354053139686584,
0.7222849726676941,
-0.4066213071346283,
0.45864138007164,
-0.21707816421985626,
-1.1585317850112915,
-0.23437334597110748,
0.3063049912452698,
-0.4190060794353485,
0.25500795245170593,
0.8457901477813721,
0.7015812397003174,
-0.08230791240930557,
0.11319255828857422,
0.3147827684879303,
0.2806333005428314,
0.5899091362953186,
0.8521130084991455,
1.0366567373275757,
-0.3137197494506836,
0.3540037274360657,
-0.1913100779056549,
-0.36789897084236145,
-0.04458403214812279,
-1.2504239082336426,
-0.7175444960594177,
-0.5182098150253296,
-0.14243409037590027,
0.01480642519891262,
-0.22198036313056946,
0.6394463181495667,
0.8984341025352478,
-0.8325612545013428,
-0.551047146320343,
0.3401848375797272,
-0.018557768315076828,
-0.5272395610809326,
-0.11229213327169418,
0.468100368976593,
-0.16271063685417175,
-0.6140096783638,
0.947775661945343,
0.5060674548149109,
-0.49750855565071106,
-0.318521648645401,
-0.3526482880115509,
-0.07016126066446304,
-0.20580743253231049,
1.0777435302734375,
0.34041643142700195,
-0.8110816478729248,
-0.7578827738761902,
-0.057416755706071854,
-0.11399383842945099,
-0.17982250452041626,
0.7030530571937561,
-0.8075023889541626,
0.3750464618206024,
0.5198636054992676,
0.5247896909713745,
0.5995119214057922,
0.18191462755203247,
0.41854822635650635,
-0.6124531030654907,
-0.037521667778491974,
0.06494308263063431,
0.5887290239334106,
0.2510976195335388,
0.062093742191791534,
0.48304346203804016,
0.03709644451737404,
-0.8273069858551025,
-0.705413281917572,
0.19855138659477234,
-1.2470697164535522,
-0.2525811493396759,
1.2153568267822266,
-0.08497206121683121,
0.15964053571224213,
-0.09625107049942017,
0.3957640528678894,
-0.19772334396839142,
-0.3304535746574402,
0.7458818554878235,
0.8305677771568298,
-0.05557271093130112,
-0.21089491248130798,
-0.6678659915924072,
0.36343851685523987,
0.5424719452857971,
-0.9165735840797424,
0.362827330827713,
0.5689634084701538,
0.47581037878990173,
0.3444086015224457,
0.6316662430763245,
-0.18180899322032928,
0.21784506738185883,
-0.0855398178100586,
-0.1304425448179245,
-0.3125995099544525,
-0.6576469540596008,
-0.15788647532463074,
0.17527471482753754,
0.11434772610664368,
-0.028667431324720383
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11793v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11793v1
|
Reasoning Abilities of Large Language Models: In-Depth Analysis on the Abstraction and Reasoning Corpus
| 2024-03-18T13:50:50 | 2024-03-18T13:50:50 |
Seungpil Lee, Woochang Sim, Donghyeon Shin, Sanha Hwang, Wongyu Seo, Jiwon Park, Seokki Lee, Sejin Kim, Sundong Kim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.ET, cs.SC
|
The existing methods for evaluating the inference abilities of Large Language
Models (LLMs) have been results-centric, making it difficult to assess the
inference process. We introduce a new approach using the Abstract and Reasoning
Corpus (ARC) dataset to evaluate the inference and contextual understanding
abilities of large language models in a process-centric manner. ARC demands
rigorous logical structures for problem-solving, making it a benchmark that
facilitates the comparison of model inference abilities with humans.
Experimental results confirm that while large language models possess weak
inference abilities, they still lag in terms of logical coherence,
compositionality, and productivity. Our experiments highlight the reasoning
capabilities of LLMs, proposing development paths for achieving human-level
reasoning.
|
[
-0.47261014580726624,
-0.9416396617889404,
0.8584620356559753,
0.02572077512741089,
0.05933597311377525,
0.22814598679542542,
-0.35735878348350525,
-0.6384425163269043,
-0.13564719259738922,
0.748891294002533,
-0.3490144610404968,
-0.5558444857597351,
-0.552029550075531,
0.2085748165845871,
-0.716098964214325,
0.4421418011188507,
0.04846709594130516,
0.006472260225564241,
-0.5749099850654602,
0.02150634676218033,
-0.3361573815345764,
-0.5083852410316467,
-0.7669867873191833,
-0.3977230489253998,
0.38283276557922363,
0.5308159589767456,
0.6402701139450073,
0.4831959009170532,
0.5006225109100342,
0.3468407690525055,
-0.3503780961036682,
0.05864739790558815,
-0.1259153038263321,
0.3334333300590515,
-0.45789939165115356,
-0.5013850331306458,
-0.5093306303024292,
-0.37351086735725403,
0.6388033032417297,
1.2489116191864014,
0.2881768047809601,
0.2043851763010025,
-0.27659550309181213,
0.6596001982688904,
-0.6903240084648132,
0.28241220116615295,
-0.6303111910820007,
-0.06484337896108627,
0.02746671624481678,
0.15780426561832428,
-0.7129919528961182,
-0.17464590072631836,
0.2648365795612335,
-0.4086371660232544,
0.11009882390499115,
0.2600851356983185,
0.41752058267593384,
0.24824976921081543,
-0.15989121794700623,
-0.21680985391139984,
-0.7630115151405334,
0.9155539274215698,
-0.9547558426856995,
0.2334545999765396,
0.4749721884727478,
0.2644876539707184,
-0.14362943172454834,
-0.73545241355896,
-0.5344088673591614,
-0.30893823504447937,
-0.058320481330156326,
-0.2552753686904907,
-0.2616499960422516,
0.09826833754777908,
0.4237620234489441,
0.31440845131874084,
-0.39453285932540894,
0.31595462560653687,
-0.22334939241409302,
-0.13810138404369354,
0.8103079795837402,
0.10523255169391632,
0.2888661324977875,
-0.1461494117975235,
-0.0925598293542862,
0.03699749708175659,
-0.5214390158653259,
0.004396803677082062,
0.19574002921581268,
0.0386170819401741,
0.0501338355243206,
0.7468317747116089,
-0.39625445008277893,
0.6679632067680359,
-0.1397557258605957,
-0.17428869009017944,
0.13702037930488586,
-0.15732239186763763,
-0.29058438539505005,
0.047018393874168396,
0.5172159075737,
-0.06436409056186676,
0.34152528643608093,
-0.32504376769065857,
-0.33718082308769226,
0.13571153581142426,
-0.009033908136188984,
-0.5999657511711121,
0.031958334147930145,
0.5772760510444641,
-0.42116937041282654,
0.15104466676712036,
-0.12085960805416107,
-0.48259177803993225,
-0.4544011652469635,
-0.5733240246772766,
0.1280253827571869,
-0.48683294653892517,
-0.5150773525238037,
0.3001110255718231,
-0.1858343780040741,
0.35749295353889465,
0.44250038266181946,
-0.8065812587738037,
0.48043933510780334,
1.0083359479904175,
0.5944488644599915,
-0.3257748782634735,
-0.36170443892478943,
-0.2566968500614166,
0.015171445906162262,
-0.4223560690879822,
1.032887578010559,
-0.7385610342025757,
-0.1137877106666565,
-0.2966037690639496,
-0.16949746012687683,
-0.030997000634670258,
-0.7357685565948486,
0.8090202808380127,
-0.6164363026618958,
-0.2802274823188782,
-0.19794215261936188,
-0.8277993202209473,
-0.3357238471508026,
0.20402972400188446,
-0.7787884473800659,
0.8784312009811401,
0.06903307139873505,
-0.762900710105896,
0.1749679297208786,
-0.6409924626350403,
-0.4215467572212219,
-0.07714919000864029,
-0.11336076259613037,
-0.16443940997123718,
0.27195754647254944,
0.315387487411499,
0.5642580986022949,
-0.4414537250995636,
0.3772486448287964,
-0.5101518034934998,
-0.27797994017601013,
0.41108468174934387,
-0.300869882106781,
0.7174715995788574,
0.3018943965435028,
-0.14752718806266785,
0.36114445328712463,
-0.8192250728607178,
0.08352035284042358,
-0.025317881256341934,
-0.03997676819562912,
-0.32662978768348694,
0.34013181924819946,
-0.3704482614994049,
0.08482584357261658,
0.16125816106796265,
-0.30375829339027405,
0.18979156017303467,
-0.3910965025424957,
0.6161578893661499,
0.43090930581092834,
-0.05536208674311638,
0.6467608213424683,
-0.007593387737870216,
0.3815430700778961,
-0.07290217280387878,
-0.16957472264766693,
-0.18970055878162384,
-0.3757893145084381,
-0.8345615267753601,
-0.43766719102859497,
0.15756814181804657,
0.4113282859325409,
-0.5015197992324829,
0.686619222164154,
-0.1504540592432022,
-0.44450631737709045,
-0.3084779679775238,
0.051280178129673004,
0.36664846539497375,
0.6917416453361511,
0.3171910047531128,
-0.3023286759853363,
-0.5540639162063599,
-0.854242742061615,
-0.14862194657325745,
-0.3429913818836212,
-0.12289103865623474,
0.17589326202869415,
0.8992180824279785,
-0.10256635397672653,
1.0537586212158203,
-0.2430402636528015,
0.5062655806541443,
-0.595460832118988,
0.252729594707489,
0.21297144889831543,
0.23776911199092865,
0.11803307384252548,
-0.5802256464958191,
0.13536575436592102,
0.018539918586611748,
-1.0373541116714478,
-0.38957130908966064,
0.1547503024339676,
-0.20998907089233398,
0.18480025231838226,
0.6778414845466614,
-0.7072024941444397,
0.40024253726005554,
0.3593803942203522,
-0.5846274495124817,
0.9082865118980408,
-0.18738453090190887,
-0.06187572702765465,
-0.41657891869544983,
0.19341501593589783,
-0.11077608913183212,
-0.08736998587846756,
-0.5760524868965149,
0.148166686296463,
-0.12215300649404526,
-0.10926125198602676,
-0.3946731686592102,
0.7216635346412659,
-0.6543830633163452,
-0.7318211793899536,
-0.3363902270793915,
0.04797743633389473,
0.24311800301074982,
0.3654700517654419,
0.5805755257606506,
0.5689476132392883,
0.7508262991905212,
-0.6251619458198547,
0.3981906473636627,
0.025724543258547783,
-0.835754930973053,
0.46890878677368164,
-0.7451111674308777,
0.09339433163404465,
-0.2117752879858017,
0.36528876423835754,
-0.8868242502212524,
-0.358602374792099,
-0.14286911487579346,
-0.23203179240226746,
0.04970689117908478,
0.12387766689062119,
-0.5492697358131409,
-0.4053093194961548,
0.08165355771780014,
0.5509838461875916,
0.2448650300502777,
-0.24370062351226807,
0.7304033637046814,
0.2988331913948059,
-0.29375913739204407,
-0.5377109050750732,
-0.7199565768241882,
0.15868450701236725,
-0.29906657338142395,
-0.9817309975624084,
0.0696520283818245,
0.14034371078014374,
-0.9817050695419312,
-0.08791279792785645,
-0.013273718766868114,
-0.3082221448421478,
0.25195714831352234,
0.06856943666934967,
0.08931944519281387,
-0.32028713822364807,
0.1540830135345459,
0.16158807277679443,
-0.18802319467067719,
0.3255009353160858,
0.020547281950712204,
0.41047167778015137,
-0.35737723112106323,
-0.7025153636932373,
-0.5328999161720276,
0.3669498562812805,
0.7006140947341919,
-0.48701170086860657,
0.7681218981742859,
0.021094325929880142,
-0.39708855748176575,
-0.19306334853172302,
-0.5546241998672485,
-0.3381272554397583,
-0.2884904444217682,
0.45653507113456726,
-0.5279660224914551,
-0.7439467906951904,
0.7822850346565247,
-0.2181323915719986,
-0.008717902936041355,
0.4973736107349396,
0.7412859797477722,
0.057566165924072266,
0.9999427199363708,
0.16239161789417267,
0.06381390243768692,
0.06335196644067764,
-0.46976977586746216,
0.1989257037639618,
-0.865128219127655,
-0.2900664806365967,
-0.6007891297340393,
-0.23487289249897003,
0.06310585141181946,
-0.4429340660572052,
0.09503603726625443,
0.49547669291496277,
-0.6837765574455261,
0.1328662931919098,
-0.32885465025901794,
0.5254883766174316,
0.2770465016365051,
-0.04842088744044304,
0.7941663861274719,
-0.22505341470241547,
0.0738939717411995,
0.2710736393928528,
-0.4552995264530182,
-0.7458215355873108,
0.826124370098114,
0.6042068004608154,
0.7704547047615051,
0.056165654212236404,
0.20268698036670685,
0.20079132914543152,
0.24145656824111938,
-0.8408988118171692,
0.6517302393913269,
0.17075003683567047,
-0.7528063058853149,
-0.5241140127182007,
-0.3200349509716034,
-0.6937826871871948,
0.4569202661514282,
-0.13109950721263885,
-0.8833233118057251,
0.15718963742256165,
-0.11508660018444061,
-0.25391873717308044,
0.4401422441005707,
-0.952061653137207,
0.8512229323387146,
-0.2846737504005432,
-0.2880355715751648,
-0.36318108439445496,
-0.5715988278388977,
0.520706295967102,
0.03519884869456291,
0.34339234232902527,
-0.41938161849975586,
-0.1459088772535324,
0.43317267298698425,
-0.43796226382255554,
0.7921828031539917,
0.06410682946443558,
-0.1974913626909256,
0.621073842048645,
0.16728447377681732,
0.34286823868751526,
0.04995901510119438,
-0.53775554895401,
0.2547840178012848,
-0.19678199291229248,
-0.39664503931999207,
-0.679861843585968,
0.4663856625556946,
-0.6260306239128113,
-0.6716777086257935,
-0.20735667645931244,
-0.8225532174110413,
-0.3296595513820648,
0.13055874407291412,
-0.0032390712294727564,
0.2941242456436157,
-0.18277397751808167,
0.13637880980968475,
0.63307785987854,
-0.2649519443511963,
0.4892132878303528,
0.4393472373485565,
-0.31160855293273926,
0.0005226936191320419,
0.43782177567481995,
-0.1688641458749771,
0.48008447885513306,
0.2604675590991974,
0.1605110466480255,
-0.3903379440307617,
-0.7926573157310486,
-0.4464435279369354,
0.2200552076101303,
-0.7888407707214355,
0.1479371339082718,
-0.43916717171669006,
-0.23547181487083435,
-0.1422448754310608,
-0.09633301198482513,
-0.3662402927875519,
-0.39193210005760193,
-0.11880484223365784,
-0.03782883659005165,
0.23485170304775238,
0.7148458957672119,
0.25300875306129456,
-0.009644824080169201,
-0.4348873496055603,
0.2049005627632141,
0.18181928992271423,
0.11544021964073181,
0.3508707284927368,
-0.4900048077106476,
-0.05958668515086174,
-0.13432717323303223,
-0.13699141144752502,
-0.6607135534286499,
0.2389589101076126,
-0.03236284479498863,
0.4402492344379425,
0.4814588725566864,
-0.08033758401870728,
0.36214688420295715,
-0.25267207622528076,
0.6188913583755493,
-0.026166599243879318,
-1.1067185401916504,
0.42976677417755127,
-0.19896981120109558,
0.35695964097976685,
0.33013930916786194,
0.10366897284984589,
-0.28908759355545044,
-0.4819890260696411,
-0.450666218996048,
-0.7459560036659241,
0.506363034248352,
0.23321154713630676,
-0.20836248993873596,
0.05964459478855133,
0.3469752073287964,
0.14723001420497894,
0.04293544217944145,
-0.4328976273536682,
-0.07200915366411209,
0.19273078441619873,
0.06503076106309891,
0.1537821739912033,
-0.18127219378948212,
0.16117073595523834,
-0.606885552406311,
0.30980539321899414,
-0.14985273778438568,
0.09407887607812881,
0.20338307321071625,
-0.2006288766860962,
0.07843731343746185,
0.5348535776138306,
0.3859803080558777,
1.2551850080490112,
0.003659498877823353,
0.3763006329536438,
0.43097177147865295,
-0.026858080178499222,
0.14253805577754974,
-0.05658071115612984,
0.13223348557949066,
-0.3012333810329437,
0.8903440237045288,
0.7321674227714539,
0.20787645876407623,
-1.054175853729248,
0.3937898278236389,
-0.017708662897348404,
-0.25024911761283875,
-0.4526458978652954,
0.18778812885284424,
0.5071333050727844,
0.40576428174972534,
0.35684725642204285,
-0.03385144844651222,
0.1700095236301422,
-0.6375070810317993,
-0.041123077273368835,
0.3468697667121887,
-0.06428476423025131,
-0.14702382683753967,
0.4084899127483368,
0.1069156676530838,
-0.16252675652503967,
0.6974493265151978,
-0.09247076511383057,
-0.2677585184574127,
0.8972434401512146,
0.5292367339134216,
0.607435941696167,
-0.051406171172857285,
-0.0636601448059082,
0.29868564009666443,
-0.00579066714271903,
-0.4366905987262726,
0.12882855534553528,
0.01811670884490013,
-0.8938872814178467,
-1.1431430578231812,
-0.5261396169662476,
-0.6650518774986267,
0.1969694048166275,
-0.5324926376342773,
0.17641839385032654,
-0.2889953553676605,
0.07234987616539001,
0.28219544887542725,
-0.1486223340034485,
-0.3604392111301422,
0.15515471994876862,
0.2685883641242981,
1.127395749092102,
-0.739006519317627,
0.8011483550071716,
0.4791576862335205,
-0.3347940742969513,
-0.5962112545967102,
-0.36490288376808167,
-0.22511962056159973,
-0.6284463405609131,
0.8701022863388062,
0.17459619045257568,
-0.31465741991996765,
-0.19907014071941376,
-0.7201356291770935,
-0.7623817920684814,
0.9539111256599426,
0.8106458783149719,
-0.6111437678337097,
-0.07718809694051743,
0.08486606180667877,
0.6804078221321106,
-0.5663158297538757,
0.5121380686759949,
1.093187689781189,
0.6464518308639526,
0.24684637784957886,
-0.8791255950927734,
-0.12935888767242432,
-0.0032661743462085724,
-0.08059109002351761,
0.11842047423124313,
-0.24795061349868774,
0.8820912837982178,
-0.30978527665138245,
-0.23699216544628143,
0.20051850378513336,
1.008363962173462,
0.39377111196517944,
0.3896643817424774,
0.5383842587471008,
0.878768265247345,
0.8863255381584167,
-0.0739380419254303,
1.2010741233825684,
-0.16187956929206848,
0.18074166774749756,
1.0734214782714844,
-0.3579907715320587,
0.995286226272583,
0.33063432574272156,
-0.15647073090076447,
0.9128567576408386,
0.4346327781677246,
0.37486618757247925,
0.08699559420347214,
0.45414838194847107,
-0.5444374680519104,
-0.5210686922073364,
0.006785038858652115,
-0.191862553358078,
0.5991196036338806,
0.5698570609092712,
-0.34095457196235657,
-0.19257627427577972,
-0.23833011090755463,
0.051311884075403214,
0.19720955193042755,
-0.6164161562919617,
0.5868746638298035,
0.2647201418876648,
-0.8453108072280884,
0.48673781752586365,
-0.02924262173473835,
0.32757827639579773,
-0.21251313388347626,
-0.040128424763679504,
0.008446257561445236,
0.25164419412612915,
-0.3873024582862854,
-1.1860989332199097,
0.6525585055351257,
0.16608375310897827,
-0.25899460911750793,
0.038332607597112656,
0.7750954627990723,
-0.10086645931005478,
-0.5386707186698914,
0.3386351466178894,
0.688671350479126,
0.4253078103065491,
-0.18178972601890564,
-0.5602369904518127,
0.11706722527742386,
-0.4010363519191742,
-0.36157354712486267,
0.02511698007583618,
0.5179027915000916,
-0.3445156514644623,
0.9601790904998779,
0.3793555498123169,
0.11686429381370544,
-0.2873977720737457,
0.2648172676563263,
0.6337751746177673,
-0.7311964631080627,
-0.1631091982126236,
-0.9959020018577576,
0.422358900308609,
-0.1350530982017517,
-0.20175078511238098,
0.6317940354347229,
0.5306586027145386,
0.6061913967132568,
0.0973457396030426,
0.8786239624023438,
-0.08707716315984726,
0.619336724281311,
-0.5080990195274353,
0.40432900190353394,
-0.25823429226875305,
0.4753490090370178,
-0.24480892717838287,
-0.8308137655258179,
-0.42251160740852356,
0.6792638301849365,
-0.8029354810714722,
0.01878795027732849,
0.8551669716835022,
0.6602490544319153,
-0.12494456022977829,
0.17511798441410065,
0.24232423305511475,
0.32499420642852783,
0.14800475537776947,
0.6973752975463867,
1.0941598415374756,
0.1308317333459854,
0.22776861488819122,
-0.07242698967456818,
-0.28781765699386597,
0.0542076975107193,
-1.0516033172607422,
-0.9925410151481628,
-0.354190468788147,
-0.06361761689186096,
-0.2647528052330017,
-0.23539334535598755,
0.6408929228782654,
0.6270992755889893,
-0.8736516833305359,
-0.37700095772743225,
-0.37727612257003784,
0.41828402876853943,
-0.30828118324279785,
-0.2217365801334381,
0.5440311431884766,
-0.2587521970272064,
-0.7642927169799805,
0.3667394518852234,
0.3224417567253113,
-0.41092827916145325,
-0.6360886096954346,
-0.18969197571277618,
-0.10594719648361206,
0.10003257542848587,
0.7785704135894775,
0.394352525472641,
-0.9017152190208435,
-0.26775288581848145,
-0.07775352150201797,
0.004078306257724762,
0.02315112017095089,
0.8819410800933838,
-0.7507137060165405,
0.33030906319618225,
0.7147564888000488,
0.6554284691810608,
0.4902520179748535,
-0.0024098511785268784,
0.5614235997200012,
-0.2895079553127289,
0.2701006829738617,
0.3816874027252197,
0.6587479710578918,
0.34274938702583313,
0.03612508997321129,
0.44444766640663147,
-0.03973260894417763,
-0.6570847630500793,
-0.6716775298118591,
0.38843536376953125,
-0.8951511383056641,
-0.619660496711731,
1.1955562829971313,
-0.19055858254432678,
-0.29186320304870605,
-0.46232569217681885,
-0.2234565019607544,
0.12459773570299149,
-0.275204062461853,
0.5262113809585571,
0.8271674513816833,
-0.6830580234527588,
-0.22018632292747498,
-0.5209370255470276,
0.16480794548988342,
0.37147045135498047,
-1.1390392780303955,
0.19368375837802887,
0.5045167803764343,
0.06123804301023483,
0.14810994267463684,
0.4253769814968109,
-0.12366047501564026,
0.15667840838432312,
-0.060122352093458176,
0.14948222041130066,
0.031329501420259476,
-0.356212854385376,
-0.27356573939323425,
0.2240801900625229,
0.4174594581127167,
0.4524754583835602
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11786v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11786v1
|
Construction of Hyper-Relational Knowledge Graphs Using Pre-Trained Large Language Models
| 2024-03-18T13:44:48 | 2024-03-18T13:44:48 |
Preetha Datta, Fedor Vitiugin, Anastasiia Chizhikova, Nitin Sawhney
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Extracting hyper-relations is crucial for constructing comprehensive
knowledge graphs, but there are limited supervised methods available for this
task. To address this gap, we introduce a zero-shot prompt-based method using
OpenAI's GPT-3.5 model for extracting hyper-relational knowledge from text.
Comparing our model with a baseline, we achieved promising results, with a
recall of 0.77. Although our precision is currently lower, a detailed analysis
of the model outputs has uncovered potential pathways for future research in
this area.
|
[
-0.2092476636171341,
-1.1940945386886597,
0.9971741437911987,
-0.24243104457855225,
-0.09778514504432678,
-0.5574788451194763,
-0.07123471796512604,
-0.46660879254341125,
0.11780416965484619,
0.5904439091682434,
-0.5527020692825317,
-0.6537089943885803,
-0.541384220123291,
0.1146479919552803,
-0.2013143002986908,
1.157861590385437,
0.05634006857872009,
-0.5214524865150452,
-0.026848437264561653,
0.14221829175949097,
-0.43003079295158386,
-0.5575025081634521,
-0.23905940353870392,
-0.21785196661949158,
0.7093412280082703,
0.3622782230377197,
0.8158782720565796,
0.853940486907959,
0.24818794429302216,
0.19991080462932587,
-0.04548034444451332,
-0.04031754285097122,
-0.389849454164505,
0.18022145330905914,
-0.19950993359088898,
-0.19908079504966736,
-0.5171178579330444,
0.1940012276172638,
0.7834668159484863,
0.6687988042831421,
0.26479455828666687,
0.22267788648605347,
-0.16691246628761292,
0.4265708923339844,
-0.7844013571739197,
0.6600695252418518,
-0.5569748282432556,
0.010225201025605202,
-0.36348938941955566,
-0.21639782190322876,
-0.5651969313621521,
-0.29653623700141907,
0.23072142899036407,
-1.0467325448989868,
0.02532968670129776,
-0.08002663403749466,
1.3693629503250122,
-0.1450483500957489,
-0.506644070148468,
0.04074813425540924,
-0.997955858707428,
0.6340696215629578,
-0.5218164920806885,
0.27298417687416077,
0.5722956657409668,
0.4949844777584076,
0.08350096642971039,
-0.8916447758674622,
-0.8918673992156982,
-0.14011429250240326,
-0.19633978605270386,
0.10860983282327652,
-0.06078026443719864,
-0.0347319096326828,
0.6001145243644714,
0.26497799158096313,
-0.7031905055046082,
-0.14300395548343658,
-0.11127136647701263,
0.08454252034425735,
0.2642572820186615,
0.27511537075042725,
0.4876614212989807,
-0.5130253434181213,
-0.12198051810264587,
0.14687055349349976,
-0.9220051169395447,
-0.53585284948349,
0.1544167399406433,
0.6203563809394836,
0.16473388671875,
0.7949861288070679,
-0.4197532832622528,
0.9897321462631226,
-0.4561493694782257,
-0.29273879528045654,
0.10964225977659225,
-0.41567644476890564,
-0.2730799615383148,
-0.15917499363422394,
1.1929748058319092,
0.15367108583450317,
0.8196151852607727,
-0.17730024456977844,
0.04352421313524246,
-0.1994335800409317,
-0.27303647994995117,
-0.8260461688041687,
-0.23398561775684357,
-0.1066068485379219,
-0.3306012451648712,
-0.2931361198425293,
-0.14942647516727448,
-0.5103234648704529,
-0.08304473757743835,
-0.3123983144760132,
0.4476475417613983,
-0.5730632543563843,
-0.3265487849712372,
-0.18490120768547058,
-0.14729195833206177,
0.23372460901737213,
0.23868048191070557,
-0.7503939867019653,
0.051343001425266266,
0.36249667406082153,
0.9551023244857788,
0.179763063788414,
-0.42581605911254883,
-0.4355008900165558,
0.8324986696243286,
-0.20963546633720398,
0.6062496900558472,
-0.5661013722419739,
-0.08336099237203598,
0.18306657671928406,
-0.16447892785072327,
0.005132739897817373,
-0.20212838053703308,
0.28395789861679077,
-0.6446089148521423,
0.4700099527835846,
-0.46991899609565735,
-0.7597616314888,
0.05127650499343872,
0.5432936549186707,
-0.6560612916946411,
0.8713459968566895,
0.348613440990448,
-1.09306800365448,
0.2507236897945404,
-0.6626192927360535,
-0.3923349380493164,
0.4233887195587158,
-0.2023535668849945,
-0.14685910940170288,
-0.523166835308075,
0.6117532253265381,
0.6125321388244629,
-0.47838160395622253,
0.3173860013484955,
-0.3875490725040436,
-0.37062230706214905,
-0.12084955722093582,
-0.22795572876930237,
1.0562267303466797,
0.03522514924407005,
-0.2419290393590927,
-0.11476781964302063,
-0.732203483581543,
-0.05896982550621033,
0.3863335847854614,
-0.10013408213853836,
-0.5510607957839966,
-0.316942036151886,
-0.25413694977760315,
0.2375422716140747,
0.19589902460575104,
-0.7322341203689575,
0.45988163352012634,
-0.4689663350582123,
0.1515124887228012,
0.4733467996120453,
0.4128042161464691,
0.15377041697502136,
0.1722443550825119,
0.4105188846588135,
0.04644310101866722,
-0.010794596746563911,
-0.5122358202934265,
-0.718467652797699,
-0.4881530702114105,
-0.09483230859041214,
0.3076864182949066,
0.6265793442726135,
-1.1951236724853516,
0.5754839777946472,
-0.3141373097896576,
-0.5117653608322144,
-0.05926496908068657,
0.13184989988803864,
0.564998984336853,
0.882355809211731,
0.4676175117492676,
0.018099233508110046,
-0.25627776980400085,
-0.5343196988105774,
-0.20285366475582123,
-0.4899815618991852,
0.06719014048576355,
0.2652566432952881,
0.6054106950759888,
-0.08944306522607803,
1.0468480587005615,
-1.11289644241333,
-0.35279977321624756,
-0.4067651927471161,
0.324381023645401,
0.32280105352401733,
0.3653295040130615,
0.6140243411064148,
-0.38335171341896057,
-0.7244842648506165,
0.22371040284633636,
-1.4025328159332275,
0.2524414360523224,
0.17877894639968872,
-0.3630587160587311,
-0.03735097125172615,
0.5914559960365295,
-1.2066056728363037,
0.5528807640075684,
-0.01577400043606758,
-0.25784486532211304,
0.8676984310150146,
0.17346452176570892,
-0.045043446123600006,
-1.202447533607483,
0.3650396466255188,
0.3478246331214905,
-0.24647584557533264,
-0.7571905851364136,
0.0705270916223526,
0.013023767620325089,
-0.45883336663246155,
-0.3781105577945709,
0.7174066305160522,
-0.4721893072128296,
0.05293498933315277,
-0.05963416397571564,
0.18478034436702728,
-0.2713475823402405,
0.6733165979385376,
0.3296073377132416,
0.5421898365020752,
0.5506069660186768,
-0.5882895588874817,
0.3511250913143158,
0.5425305366516113,
-0.20764389634132385,
0.41588011384010315,
-0.8043261766433716,
0.14888030290603638,
-0.14943668246269226,
0.14331990480422974,
-0.8094711899757385,
-0.4109271168708801,
0.3755658268928528,
-0.6140887141227722,
0.2262435108423233,
-0.5705803632736206,
-0.6460698246955872,
-0.48051124811172485,
0.06407476961612701,
0.34740254282951355,
0.4757029712200165,
-0.2699004113674164,
0.2751396894454956,
0.3019253611564636,
-0.374154657125473,
-0.6382371187210083,
-0.22204965353012085,
-0.03943635895848274,
0.15748745203018188,
-0.3482072055339813,
-0.08335912972688675,
0.34889402985572815,
-0.034088555723428726,
0.13272079825401306,
0.2880987823009491,
-0.2859335243701935,
-0.19407662749290466,
0.12697085738182068,
0.41539204120635986,
-0.3688158392906189,
0.2532871663570404,
-0.17907710373401642,
-0.28891444206237793,
0.09739679098129272,
-0.47524628043174744,
0.4936284124851227,
0.09259822219610214,
-0.1925208866596222,
-0.7130850553512573,
0.23066739737987518,
0.6069453954696655,
-0.45694270730018616,
0.8903430104255676,
0.5298156142234802,
-0.6200830936431885,
0.28406283259391785,
-0.2602248787879944,
0.025764450430870056,
-0.40242165327072144,
0.23850496113300323,
-0.39758729934692383,
-0.8407743573188782,
0.23298658430576324,
0.04122480750083923,
-0.14084887504577637,
0.5853967070579529,
0.4937993586063385,
0.0819847509264946,
1.0898255109786987,
0.7487307786941528,
-0.28496238589286804,
0.4497221112251282,
-0.1774398684501648,
0.27206581830978394,
-0.5002344250679016,
-0.1368001252412796,
-0.7089597582817078,
0.3239177167415619,
-0.3816356360912323,
0.1484067291021347,
0.47136667370796204,
0.014274957589805126,
-0.6623885035514832,
0.41943442821502686,
-0.20117676258087158,
0.6609647274017334,
0.7021639347076416,
0.18718238174915314,
0.5005604028701782,
0.06871781498193741,
-0.04889112710952759,
0.03677402436733246,
-0.5743882060050964,
-0.3084503710269928,
1.1728018522262573,
0.1252802163362503,
0.4219783544540405,
-0.03738992661237717,
0.6705807447433472,
-0.13772687315940857,
0.32516855001449585,
-0.8013983964920044,
0.5952593684196472,
0.24451127648353577,
-0.7690313458442688,
-0.7740314602851868,
-0.907699465751648,
-1.0426105260849,
-0.1296961009502411,
-0.19452719390392303,
-0.9436100125312805,
-0.3235127031803131,
0.12821994721889496,
-0.40227794647216797,
0.4128589332103729,
-0.7031694054603577,
1.0489375591278076,
0.24219563603401184,
-0.2897193729877472,
0.44934573769569397,
-0.8280747532844543,
0.6424061059951782,
0.14947721362113953,
-0.04017457365989685,
-0.06422265619039536,
0.38244491815567017,
0.933311939239502,
-0.5801559686660767,
0.6457604169845581,
-0.5944458246231079,
0.09884458035230637,
0.4934936761856079,
0.2562668025493622,
0.4783580005168915,
-0.0721091479063034,
0.12920203804969788,
-0.20053337514400482,
-0.13181234896183014,
-0.5639550685882568,
-0.782012403011322,
0.5233802199363708,
-0.9986377954483032,
-0.3607395589351654,
-0.34825047850608826,
-0.7255564332008362,
-0.5327365398406982,
0.718398928642273,
0.12709949910640717,
0.5188620090484619,
-0.23267453908920288,
-0.13035184144973755,
0.6082223057746887,
-0.2329811155796051,
0.5117670297622681,
0.37091243267059326,
-0.37596336007118225,
-0.2920680642127991,
0.9563153982162476,
0.34310632944107056,
0.08643553406000137,
0.52546626329422,
0.25175079703330994,
-0.31410905718803406,
-0.33997830748558044,
-0.5217023491859436,
0.5356453657150269,
-0.5415392518043518,
-0.4255708158016205,
-0.8770145773887634,
-0.289055198431015,
-0.7223241329193115,
0.13826414942741394,
-0.13221375644207,
-0.38761183619499207,
-0.18833576142787933,
-0.19184990227222443,
0.518498420715332,
1.031014084815979,
0.2574923634529114,
0.5920093655586243,
-1.1708918809890747,
0.3740568459033966,
0.5541260838508606,
0.2671721279621124,
0.14596113562583923,
-0.17757149040699005,
-0.3892008066177368,
-0.17769861221313477,
-0.2336379736661911,
-1.2194428443908691,
0.5143552422523499,
0.009632360190153122,
0.40524426102638245,
0.3909536302089691,
0.06200294941663742,
0.6154453158378601,
-0.2839413583278656,
0.9207056164741516,
0.3184269368648529,
-0.8654757738113403,
0.9037543535232544,
-0.9520105719566345,
0.46855786442756653,
0.39696788787841797,
1.0815054178237915,
-0.2390337884426117,
-0.09091199934482574,
-0.7154865860939026,
-0.6786335110664368,
0.6705249547958374,
0.2808583676815033,
-0.08230996131896973,
-0.3029150664806366,
0.5008494853973389,
-0.2577202320098877,
0.016091613098978996,
-0.7810992002487183,
-0.23144042491912842,
-0.08626902848482132,
-0.20432685315608978,
-0.07492955029010773,
-0.3407061696052551,
-0.023003246635198593,
-0.4827550947666168,
0.6567339897155762,
-0.23566751182079315,
0.3345002233982086,
0.13691245019435883,
-0.2809840738773346,
-0.03795480355620384,
0.1017395406961441,
-0.02418973110616207,
0.790424644947052,
-0.3133709132671356,
0.05734853819012642,
-0.12403472512960434,
-0.5218769907951355,
0.1763496994972229,
0.11238604038953781,
-0.4217085838317871,
-0.13505570590496063,
0.5285782217979431,
0.6180121898651123,
-0.13517031073570251,
-0.2882498800754547,
0.9069077968597412,
0.07039239257574081,
-0.12365992367267609,
0.06047338619828224,
-0.3710079789161682,
0.09808275103569031,
-0.14649467170238495,
0.1624477654695511,
-0.4457123875617981,
-0.04581622779369354,
-0.7736321091651917,
0.31922411918640137,
0.020562833175063133,
-0.6852830052375793,
-0.35466647148132324,
0.5102654099464417,
0.023042596876621246,
0.06007325276732445,
1.2545768022537231,
-0.23033997416496277,
-0.4010842740535736,
0.22407203912734985,
0.8701150417327881,
0.6965582370758057,
-0.1177055686712265,
0.4552701711654663,
0.6488123536109924,
0.11441097408533096,
0.10734058171510696,
0.24700021743774414,
-0.04291320592164993,
-0.7277513742446899,
-0.8341542482376099,
-0.5082197785377502,
-0.35726332664489746,
0.0880851149559021,
-0.6413956880569458,
0.11056048423051834,
-0.47338178753852844,
-0.021262379363179207,
0.203287273645401,
0.10010875761508942,
-0.735386073589325,
0.2951878011226654,
-0.1622718721628189,
0.7484873533248901,
-1.1089872121810913,
1.154465913772583,
0.483851820230484,
-0.9181882739067078,
-1.1137983798980713,
0.06980135291814804,
-0.18232540786266327,
-0.7710568904876709,
0.6918188333511353,
0.08777912706136703,
0.20132134854793549,
0.25137951970100403,
-0.8331515789031982,
-0.6879817247390747,
0.9853611588478088,
0.5392689108848572,
-0.35002973675727844,
-0.3007906973361969,
0.1305224448442459,
0.46028435230255127,
-0.14627863466739655,
0.6185855269432068,
0.5749673247337341,
0.488073468208313,
0.17510288953781128,
-0.8469334244728088,
0.23440657556056976,
-0.34219077229499817,
-0.13257302343845367,
0.33799898624420166,
-0.2476942241191864,
0.970977246761322,
-0.055688731372356415,
-0.21142153441905975,
-0.0283050537109375,
0.8895940184593201,
0.18395467102527618,
0.0762426033616066,
0.12761332094669342,
0.7904061079025269,
0.7438860535621643,
0.07509588450193405,
1.2299368381500244,
-0.17495134472846985,
0.33479049801826477,
1.3047525882720947,
-0.49073880910873413,
0.7166014313697815,
0.17790326476097107,
-0.050317198038101196,
0.5895198583602905,
0.2741539478302002,
0.2637205123901367,
0.32130664587020874,
-0.26370978355407715,
-0.11689551174640656,
-0.402931272983551,
-0.34429895877838135,
-0.5160959959030151,
0.2751905024051666,
0.28558993339538574,
-0.3488083481788635,
-0.3467404246330261,
-0.2616768181324005,
0.42638468742370605,
-0.21344000101089478,
-0.2852016091346741,
0.8976766467094421,
-0.08038688451051712,
-0.7051066160202026,
0.4778086245059967,
-0.19743426144123077,
0.19439591467380524,
-0.5664037466049194,
-0.2334936410188675,
-0.08178061246871948,
-0.060724418610334396,
-0.017647482454776764,
-1.0367578268051147,
0.10581079125404358,
0.08462106436491013,
-0.09024246037006378,
0.016359878703951836,
1.1019182205200195,
-0.37563785910606384,
-0.31702810525894165,
0.13930529356002808,
1.147225022315979,
0.1972516030073166,
-0.4990364909172058,
-0.2989657521247864,
-0.35114315152168274,
-0.1727629005908966,
-0.38011571764945984,
0.30915138125419617,
0.7601773738861084,
-0.11667201668024063,
0.2799754738807678,
0.7309284806251526,
-0.04982547461986542,
-0.08413121104240417,
0.09682976454496384,
0.952711284160614,
-1.0099267959594727,
-0.32400161027908325,
-1.0497318506240845,
0.19605091214179993,
-0.16911950707435608,
-0.4247359335422516,
0.8411141037940979,
0.4436339735984802,
0.7544705867767334,
-0.13350896537303925,
1.0892202854156494,
-0.13687047362327576,
0.5186280608177185,
-0.3592208921909332,
0.7851235270500183,
-0.2163609117269516,
-0.3176996409893036,
-0.7108365893363953,
-0.974539577960968,
-0.5157892107963562,
0.29623693227767944,
-0.3826030492782593,
-0.0019672755151987076,
0.8115109801292419,
0.7682147026062012,
-0.09927433729171753,
0.08521876484155655,
0.37632817029953003,
0.20686697959899902,
0.2868192195892334,
0.667937695980072,
0.8170294761657715,
-0.5171257853507996,
0.7779080867767334,
-0.11055628955364227,
-0.4228622317314148,
0.2780001759529114,
-0.8314752578735352,
-1.078914761543274,
-0.5211480259895325,
-0.17962954938411713,
-0.33740511536598206,
0.13386309146881104,
0.6771509051322937,
0.7596850395202637,
-0.45705634355545044,
-0.11179481446743011,
-0.1395639032125473,
0.22060836851596832,
-0.03497948870062828,
-0.2357233315706253,
0.5568024516105652,
-0.3303426504135132,
-0.403395414352417,
0.15293888747692108,
0.13975559175014496,
0.2646230161190033,
-0.017658354714512825,
-0.07312233000993729,
-0.5759001970291138,
-0.1388540416955948,
0.7607808709144592,
0.5175192356109619,
-0.07091110944747925,
-0.36113518476486206,
0.04560776427388191,
-0.10164093971252441,
-0.08909378945827484,
0.8536997437477112,
-0.9082456827163696,
0.2780244052410126,
0.6591520309448242,
0.4438670873641968,
0.8851427435874939,
-0.07945896685123444,
0.7514609098434448,
-0.9374359250068665,
0.05791933834552765,
0.044575370848178864,
0.23207975924015045,
0.22544296085834503,
-0.3336581885814667,
0.45203980803489685,
0.6463159322738647,
-0.471665620803833,
-0.6475870013237,
0.37385645508766174,
-0.7967915534973145,
-0.16930852830410004,
1.205627202987671,
-0.449457585811615,
-0.45848944783210754,
-0.2905997037887573,
-0.10849971324205399,
0.5460968017578125,
-0.2064928412437439,
0.3068905770778656,
0.5176596641540527,
-0.037022579461336136,
-0.09482673555612564,
-0.48174139857292175,
0.3739819824695587,
-0.01224871352314949,
-1.0040290355682373,
0.21136698126792908,
0.4290417432785034,
0.0926978662610054,
0.19575244188308716,
1.0889016389846802,
-0.3473772406578064,
0.15208758413791656,
0.12215399742126465,
0.046305105090141296,
-0.32542556524276733,
-0.8023585081100464,
0.2218477576971054,
0.49909037351608276,
0.10482890158891678,
0.16030803322792053
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11771v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11771v1
|
Modality-Agnostic fMRI Decoding of Vision and Language
| 2024-03-18T13:30:03 | 2024-03-18T13:30:03 |
Mitja Nikolaus, Milad Mozafari, Nicholas Asher, Leila Reddy, Rufin VanRullen
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Previous studies have shown that it is possible to map brain activation data
of subjects viewing images onto the feature representation space of not only
vision models (modality-specific decoding) but also language models
(cross-modal decoding). In this work, we introduce and use a new large-scale
fMRI dataset (~8,500 trials per subject) of people watching both images and
text descriptions of such images. This novel dataset enables the development of
modality-agnostic decoders: a single decoder that can predict which stimulus a
subject is seeing, irrespective of the modality (image or text) in which the
stimulus is presented. We train and evaluate such decoders to map brain signals
onto stimulus representations from a large range of publicly available vision,
language and multimodal (vision+language) models. Our findings reveal that (1)
modality-agnostic decoders perform as well as (and sometimes even better than)
modality-specific decoders (2) modality-agnostic decoders mapping brain data
onto representations from unimodal models perform as well as decoders relying
on multimodal representations (3) while language and low-level visual
(occipital) brain regions are best at decoding text and image stimuli,
respectively, high-level visual (temporal) regions perform well on both
stimulus types.
|
[
-0.33416548371315,
-0.4590483009815216,
0.5784763693809509,
0.235740065574646,
-0.4130190312862396,
-0.36432531476020813,
-0.2308497577905655,
-0.5283074975013733,
0.23544922471046448,
0.03838471323251724,
-0.3139609694480896,
-0.10737653821706772,
-0.5422725081443787,
0.23978477716445923,
-0.24716928601264954,
0.4552474617958069,
0.04147591069340706,
0.565524697303772,
-0.21646501123905182,
-0.2588738799095154,
-0.2244136780500412,
-0.649692714214325,
-0.485367089509964,
-0.2737374007701874,
0.5587465167045593,
-0.41171419620513916,
0.6897704601287842,
0.533456563949585,
0.42082589864730835,
0.2032165378332138,
0.052548471838235855,
0.04070540517568588,
-0.22007755935192108,
-0.2649937570095062,
-0.2532249689102173,
-0.380891889333725,
-0.3716284930706024,
-0.05038838088512421,
0.525592029094696,
0.8096070289611816,
-0.007605554070323706,
0.07477161288261414,
0.045713167637586594,
0.3652724325656891,
-0.756986677646637,
0.3329446315765381,
-0.44836804270744324,
0.16937761008739471,
0.02175142616033554,
-0.5841054916381836,
-0.5921539068222046,
0.025658678263425827,
0.022795507684350014,
-0.6488695740699768,
0.07582852244377136,
-0.016650423407554626,
0.7326021790504456,
0.20420971512794495,
-0.7643807530403137,
-0.19662901759147644,
-0.661077618598938,
0.669292151927948,
-0.261227548122406,
0.7707698941230774,
0.5967097878456116,
0.184112548828125,
0.10641041398048401,
-0.2579566538333893,
-0.6060091853141785,
-0.12326811254024506,
-0.3087335526943207,
0.31180888414382935,
-0.22750583291053772,
0.05647841468453407,
0.22567763924598694,
0.5272378921508789,
-0.41210460662841797,
-0.34790274500846863,
-0.35678496956825256,
-0.24800197780132294,
0.42199939489364624,
0.2186388373374939,
0.22124584019184113,
-0.10446149855852127,
-0.5498971939086914,
0.01101138535887003,
-0.32116466760635376,
-0.00473772780969739,
0.1623907834291458,
-0.11833038181066513,
-0.05997433513402939,
0.6149324178695679,
-0.05605641379952431,
1.0006846189498901,
0.11246107518672943,
-0.085545614361763,
0.48653554916381836,
-0.41709205508232117,
-0.2834126949310303,
-0.15455184876918793,
0.7146256566047668,
0.39856693148612976,
0.18368259072303772,
-0.43277111649513245,
-0.43062686920166016,
0.7647648453712463,
-0.002892883028835058,
-0.5302165150642395,
-0.20480574667453766,
-0.1440603882074356,
-0.8629223108291626,
-0.18412941694259644,
-0.10412077605724335,
-0.3764776885509491,
-0.5807245969772339,
-0.36689630150794983,
0.6621624231338501,
-0.5967534184455872,
-0.5325422883033752,
0.5248292684555054,
-0.10787662863731384,
0.37612229585647583,
0.26144981384277344,
-1.0027769804000854,
0.1371530145406723,
0.17133130133152008,
0.5174933075904846,
-0.05729250982403755,
-0.39905887842178345,
-0.3995654582977295,
0.25262442231178284,
-0.25860676169395447,
0.872718334197998,
-0.7959352731704712,
-0.24991294741630554,
-0.16918402910232544,
0.10469221323728561,
-0.3261745274066925,
-0.3509814143180847,
0.45239749550819397,
-0.6032203435897827,
0.31418755650520325,
-0.44981300830841064,
-0.22727888822555542,
-0.42273855209350586,
0.25888657569885254,
-0.9058514833450317,
0.4271826148033142,
0.2581457495689392,
-0.5912768244743347,
0.42660221457481384,
-0.7566797137260437,
-0.6783376932144165,
-0.07265730947256088,
-0.7396031022071838,
0.028536014258861542,
0.5451579689979553,
0.20104843378067017,
0.3749607503414154,
-0.4703691899776459,
0.30114737153053284,
-0.12905560433864594,
-0.3664453327655792,
0.6361512541770935,
-0.73135906457901,
0.6508345007896423,
0.3196023106575012,
-0.22802481055259705,
-0.10329869389533997,
-0.7094468474388123,
0.009764205664396286,
0.18904373049736023,
-0.6774798631668091,
-0.38720080256462097,
0.22020894289016724,
0.36958253383636475,
0.3053024411201477,
0.06314612925052643,
-0.7307727932929993,
0.038955990225076675,
0.028672434389591217,
0.6287490129470825,
0.43313539028167725,
-0.22843040525913239,
0.35010892152786255,
-0.3502790331840515,
0.30411362648010254,
0.42761537432670593,
0.1731663942337036,
-0.5630103349685669,
-0.42045858502388,
-0.6008462905883789,
-0.5937976241111755,
0.2032669186592102,
0.35922810435295105,
-0.9559725522994995,
0.2837291359901428,
-0.6448100805282593,
0.21041148900985718,
-0.6953160762786865,
-0.387224406003952,
0.32086190581321716,
0.421242356300354,
0.34488004446029663,
-0.4709424078464508,
-0.3699512183666229,
-1.0472379922866821,
-0.2327592819929123,
-0.18503053486347198,
-0.33113017678260803,
0.2716221511363983,
0.3197217583656311,
-0.42775771021842957,
0.7659107446670532,
-0.32326945662498474,
-0.6040814518928528,
-0.04935327172279358,
0.19606678187847137,
-0.07916232943534851,
0.2541092038154602,
0.6763971447944641,
-1.064442753791809,
-0.12192271649837494,
0.2733958065509796,
-0.7466622591018677,
0.3459152281284332,
-0.30550339818000793,
0.20044077932834625,
0.33680975437164307,
0.3756546378135681,
-0.03037296235561371,
0.4860817492008209,
0.5128095746040344,
-0.8411062359809875,
0.04138658940792084,
-0.11939997225999832,
0.5097134113311768,
-1.0440739393234253,
0.4691154956817627,
-0.029143517836928368,
-0.3189631402492523,
-0.5669949054718018,
-0.2184344232082367,
0.26072871685028076,
0.08569739758968353,
0.01843685656785965,
0.3560132086277008,
-0.7379797101020813,
-0.09063269197940826,
-0.21477799117565155,
-0.3931088149547577,
0.0494718961417675,
0.6916542053222656,
0.49778613448143005,
0.6665051579475403,
0.9476441740989685,
-0.16783013939857483,
0.10268182307481766,
0.32766494154930115,
-0.43749022483825684,
0.5260953307151794,
-0.445599764585495,
-0.10984503477811813,
-0.5601904988288879,
0.06348831951618195,
-0.9786558747291565,
-0.4427492916584015,
0.24119511246681213,
-0.4825859069824219,
0.24618175625801086,
0.11041055619716644,
-0.21331577003002167,
-0.07330843806266785,
-0.02766372635960579,
0.8707681894302368,
0.44970929622650146,
-0.4006527364253998,
1.1562398672103882,
0.39204394817352295,
0.3792426288127899,
-0.4969148337841034,
-1.216808557510376,
0.025127936154603958,
0.29697468876838684,
-0.367921382188797,
0.11942373961210251,
0.02148064225912094,
0.1988508701324463,
0.32601913809776306,
-0.12333487719297409,
-0.24269331991672516,
-0.10690367221832275,
0.43024763464927673,
0.14369362592697144,
-0.22113434970378876,
-0.10936903953552246,
-0.33951643109321594,
-0.11189530044794083,
0.1643541306257248,
-0.014745408669114113,
0.4733073115348816,
-0.15050120651721954,
-0.5989319682121277,
-0.23445266485214233,
0.6711972951889038,
0.8172544240951538,
-0.45126426219940186,
0.46268749237060547,
0.7027063965797424,
-0.5369063019752502,
0.28133851289749146,
-0.3790106177330017,
-0.14095459878444672,
-0.44257014989852905,
0.4772129952907562,
-0.6057290434837341,
-0.8313624262809753,
0.45271211862564087,
0.06755106151103973,
-0.41048040986061096,
0.12223461270332336,
0.5746304988861084,
0.21296067535877228,
1.2421988248825073,
0.7507840991020203,
0.0019175157649442554,
0.5148648619651794,
-0.26254361867904663,
0.22090710699558258,
-1.0254937410354614,
-0.4342655539512634,
0.11356040835380554,
-0.5030114054679871,
0.16618585586547852,
-0.5232860445976257,
0.48002883791923523,
-0.39455482363700867,
0.1777036339044571,
-0.10181928426027298,
-0.4620553255081177,
0.7182624340057373,
0.39355483651161194,
0.4200519025325775,
0.48265695571899414,
0.4173671007156372,
-0.2310461848974228,
-0.01429755799472332,
-0.6320225596427917,
-0.15206950902938843,
1.1516908407211304,
0.22096234560012817,
0.9667584896087646,
-0.08709446340799332,
0.07279593497514725,
0.29951876401901245,
0.3886021077632904,
-1.0482165813446045,
0.6392537355422974,
-0.18691807985305786,
-0.8253695964813232,
0.131883904337883,
-0.3533255159854889,
-0.8077616095542908,
0.3274340033531189,
-0.47774896025657654,
-0.3842538595199585,
0.9256933331489563,
0.08452516794204712,
-0.26594310998916626,
0.28239941596984863,
-0.64626544713974,
0.7022766470909119,
-0.1975298821926117,
-0.05817035585641861,
-0.285543292760849,
-0.5576279759407043,
0.37123799324035645,
-0.03278195858001709,
0.10644476860761642,
0.05299610272049904,
-0.28744184970855713,
0.3342990577220917,
0.21497531235218048,
0.7890220284461975,
0.00033877097303047776,
-0.09849032759666443,
-0.13688038289546967,
0.08245986700057983,
-0.1593289077281952,
-0.0017633135430514812,
-0.007135098800063133,
0.3261142373085022,
0.05913911014795303,
-0.40200456976890564,
-0.4950422942638397,
0.5386446714401245,
-0.8661982417106628,
-0.30434054136276245,
-0.7068718671798706,
-0.630462110042572,
-0.22928598523139954,
0.31729164719581604,
0.5263658761978149,
0.9764348268508911,
-0.23533545434474945,
0.3440534174442291,
0.6481888294219971,
0.22064617276191711,
0.4162156283855438,
0.6267328262329102,
-0.1570330411195755,
-0.7155863642692566,
0.8399068117141724,
-0.09406719356775284,
0.19681300222873688,
0.5516534447669983,
-0.2944851517677307,
-0.23720884323120117,
-0.6834812164306641,
-0.4239760637283325,
0.17598402500152588,
-0.7927440404891968,
-0.17431190609931946,
-0.5798337459564209,
-0.08371719717979431,
-0.02480701357126236,
-0.12913763523101807,
-0.16284054517745972,
-0.22959716618061066,
-0.1826004832983017,
0.14772997796535492,
0.03694506734609604,
0.3813662827014923,
-0.11043711751699448,
-0.0015069710789248347,
-0.5377382040023804,
0.705581784248352,
0.376845121383667,
0.5844897031784058,
-0.04934309050440788,
-0.2373831868171692,
-0.41594648361206055,
0.20604942739009857,
0.11700544506311417,
-0.8707946538925171,
0.18936294317245483,
0.39543721079826355,
0.5330882668495178,
0.6623574495315552,
0.007524446584284306,
0.4121217429637909,
-0.4734126329421997,
0.6440184116363525,
0.6057702898979187,
-0.7728126645088196,
0.22818632423877716,
-0.43748795986175537,
0.5561633110046387,
0.5303452014923096,
0.4905320107936859,
-0.512872040271759,
-0.016521206125617027,
-0.09237398952245712,
-0.5144481658935547,
0.7888085246086121,
0.1425514817237854,
0.1859458088874817,
-0.17706646025180817,
0.27614134550094604,
0.22642414271831512,
0.0905357226729393,
-0.9150435328483582,
-0.17797696590423584,
-0.47076472640037537,
-0.3912651836872101,
-0.1585056632757187,
-0.1947360336780548,
-0.6393763422966003,
-0.3794366717338562,
-0.019281817600131035,
-0.4292200207710266,
0.8649597764015198,
0.43544870615005493,
-0.19228918850421906,
-0.348765105009079,
0.22941100597381592,
0.4819188416004181,
0.6635172367095947,
-0.03129959851503372,
0.40216338634490967,
-0.07751400023698807,
-0.8097598552703857,
0.2582494914531708,
0.09135385602712631,
-0.12922711670398712,
0.04839649423956871,
0.1987256556749344,
1.0303325653076172,
0.013503160327672958,
-0.7344006299972534,
0.7578595876693726,
-0.47505244612693787,
-0.34993717074394226,
-0.2147730439901352,
-0.018884291872382164,
-0.04003467783331871,
0.32078227400779724,
0.58442223072052,
0.5889987945556641,
0.37036383152008057,
-0.7546408772468567,
0.03480742499232292,
0.5160176157951355,
-0.38017532229423523,
-0.7251628637313843,
0.8587728142738342,
0.1463630050420761,
0.08072537183761597,
0.23083186149597168,
0.07123511284589767,
-0.24130839109420776,
0.1759292632341385,
0.6348475217819214,
1.0102791786193848,
-0.08601827174425125,
0.031247692182660103,
0.18773815035820007,
0.24047324061393738,
-0.21429190039634705,
0.7644569277763367,
-0.2474309653043747,
-0.9609659314155579,
-0.3534591495990753,
-0.6692944765090942,
-0.1096198633313179,
0.21850265562534332,
-0.915101945400238,
0.04163661226630211,
-0.33868569135665894,
-0.41668471693992615,
0.1625794917345047,
-0.5361647009849548,
-0.6139397025108337,
0.3861660361289978,
0.5043160319328308,
0.7817791700363159,
-0.9324484467506409,
1.0108267068862915,
1.2386653423309326,
-0.2832513749599457,
-0.44087788462638855,
0.1226629763841629,
-0.3352093994617462,
-0.7525498867034912,
0.3520011901855469,
0.23738670349121094,
-0.4102359712123871,
0.20240768790245056,
-0.28953951597213745,
-0.7771975994110107,
1.1043682098388672,
0.5681103467941284,
-0.2950320839881897,
-0.17538407444953918,
0.2579942047595978,
0.4174676835536957,
-0.6197649240493774,
0.20212125778198242,
0.2956329882144928,
0.39150431752204895,
0.09452056884765625,
-0.7475667595863342,
0.28775227069854736,
-0.5772773623466492,
0.20812946557998657,
0.17456823587417603,
-0.5361620187759399,
0.7377227544784546,
0.06746751070022583,
-0.495871901512146,
-0.13122126460075378,
0.51602703332901,
-0.17988790571689606,
0.24340032041072845,
0.616743803024292,
0.39949536323547363,
0.24375802278518677,
-0.16347816586494446,
0.9173930287361145,
-0.4538092613220215,
0.15940678119659424,
0.6516792178153992,
0.05266052111983299,
0.7142059803009033,
0.6526126265525818,
0.20859438180923462,
0.2727058529853821,
0.25005042552948,
0.047673776745796204,
0.7963007092475891,
-0.36625805497169495,
-0.3131226897239685,
-0.8033263087272644,
-0.1577402949333191,
-0.4144262969493866,
0.4131850302219391,
0.2545379102230072,
-0.5473932027816772,
-0.26761701703071594,
0.5031090974807739,
-0.2722615897655487,
0.07137937843799591,
-0.29562363028526306,
0.6285343766212463,
0.021716013550758362,
-0.432962566614151,
1.039848804473877,
-0.10783561319112778,
0.7561836838722229,
-0.762273371219635,
0.17916855216026306,
-0.003728675888851285,
0.2342546135187149,
-0.149671733379364,
-0.6699672937393188,
0.29972508549690247,
-0.1637275218963623,
-0.47385165095329285,
-0.21664509177207947,
0.6732307076454163,
-0.5413206219673157,
-0.35053032636642456,
0.32158419489860535,
0.32919418811798096,
-0.12253305315971375,
-0.06583348661661148,
-0.3232225775718689,
0.3409869074821472,
-0.0033649152610450983,
-0.375218003988266,
0.3846950829029083,
0.36507028341293335,
-0.02887081541121006,
0.5309310555458069,
0.35702288150787354,
-0.2016148716211319,
-0.044307075440883636,
-0.19878077507019043,
1.2237634658813477,
-0.9163283705711365,
-0.5038661956787109,
-0.6601078510284424,
0.4839247465133667,
0.16363249719142914,
-0.30388596653938293,
0.4232587516307831,
0.6105383038520813,
0.7426175475120544,
-0.4273996651172638,
0.7248912453651428,
-0.25873470306396484,
-0.006756069138646126,
-0.4789343774318695,
0.6529480814933777,
-0.9177038073539734,
-0.1983753740787506,
0.18096791207790375,
-0.7060949802398682,
-0.43834570050239563,
0.7440428733825684,
-0.37762683629989624,
-0.08609773963689804,
0.8800989389419556,
0.6410536766052246,
-0.41626593470573425,
0.24592934548854828,
0.4942488372325897,
0.03457886353135109,
-0.024018125608563423,
0.7386089563369751,
0.9291774034500122,
-0.30295330286026,
0.5355871915817261,
0.17448878288269043,
-0.3469237983226776,
-0.3019638955593109,
-0.6797894239425659,
-0.8967185020446777,
-0.8463618755340576,
-0.23372554779052734,
-0.09736577421426773,
-0.2486894279718399,
0.6464443206787109,
0.5824645757675171,
-0.687030553817749,
-0.11945149302482605,
0.1800875961780548,
-0.5021108388900757,
-0.31919384002685547,
-0.12920214235782623,
0.10149642080068588,
-0.09659373760223389,
-0.5476093292236328,
0.47580140829086304,
0.4884941875934601,
0.011365805752575397,
-0.4983573257923126,
-0.049631014466285706,
-0.0825655534863472,
0.281612753868103,
0.615449845790863,
0.2513176500797272,
-0.6674278974533081,
-0.18007302284240723,
0.33457231521606445,
-0.274730920791626,
0.2464926838874817,
1.0251376628875732,
-1.000045657157898,
0.5453959107398987,
0.7299311757087708,
0.542333722114563,
0.353563517332077,
-0.21870388090610504,
0.5727555751800537,
-0.21311615407466888,
0.34840142726898193,
0.33259639143943787,
0.47567546367645264,
0.28481656312942505,
-0.23973502218723297,
0.45130351185798645,
0.24500299990177155,
-0.26870039105415344,
-0.7864887714385986,
0.5514906644821167,
-1.3968366384506226,
-0.33027684688568115,
1.2020710706710815,
-0.09302276372909546,
-0.6324660181999207,
-0.19123953580856323,
-0.3311087489128113,
-0.14082051813602448,
-0.23166191577911377,
0.7826708555221558,
0.6097558736801147,
-0.018957344815135002,
-0.03769681975245476,
-0.12426020950078964,
0.40571409463882446,
0.5119529366493225,
-0.4396630823612213,
0.014659144915640354,
0.9384002089500427,
0.33222639560699463,
0.21318891644477844,
0.7653939127922058,
-0.32232439517974854,
0.5733750462532043,
-0.028561463579535484,
-0.07049896568059921,
-0.35555365681648254,
-0.3855855166912079,
-0.6920148134231567,
0.32338783144950867,
-0.19427047669887543,
-0.3052584230899811
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11752v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11752v2
|
Revisiting The Classics: A Study on Identifying and Rectifying Gender Stereotypes in Rhymes and Poems
| 2024-03-18T13:02:02 | 2024-03-25T16:33:12 |
Aditya Narayan Sankaran, Vigneshwaran Shankaran, Sampath Lonka, Rajesh Sharma
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Rhymes and poems are a powerful medium for transmitting cultural norms and
societal roles. However, the pervasive existence of gender stereotypes in these
works perpetuates biased perceptions and limits the scope of individuals'
identities. Past works have shown that stereotyping and prejudice emerge in
early childhood, and developmental research on causal mechanisms is critical
for understanding and controlling stereotyping and prejudice. This work
contributes by gathering a dataset of rhymes and poems to identify gender
stereotypes and propose a model with 97% accuracy to identify gender bias.
Gender stereotypes were rectified using a Large Language Model (LLM) and its
effectiveness was evaluated in a comparative survey against human educator
rectifications. To summarize, this work highlights the pervasive nature of
gender stereotypes in literary works and reveals the potential of LLMs to
rectify gender stereotypes. This study raises awareness and promotes
inclusivity within artistic expressions, making a significant contribution to
the discourse on gender equality.
|
[
0.001122305286116898,
-0.27945682406425476,
0.22632740437984467,
0.12252270430326462,
-0.04359423369169235,
0.12499650567770004,
0.04345584288239479,
-0.4307008981704712,
0.28436943888664246,
0.5961145758628845,
-0.5166361927986145,
-0.26409152150154114,
-0.8901996612548828,
0.27031075954437256,
-0.7151525020599365,
0.7346299290657043,
-0.062464430928230286,
0.09974880516529083,
-0.25318723917007446,
0.062189530581235886,
-0.8644285798072815,
-0.424731582403183,
-0.3742561638355255,
-0.3236062526702881,
0.5624983310699463,
0.3195258378982544,
0.20503024756908417,
0.18182899057865143,
0.33025577664375305,
0.3404545187950134,
-0.3158479928970337,
-0.017399713397026062,
-0.9316532015800476,
0.8866063356399536,
-0.07430699467658997,
-0.7201256155967712,
-0.008580454625189304,
0.43653491139411926,
0.7593288421630859,
0.6230136752128601,
0.045847658067941666,
0.2690200209617615,
0.1564081758260727,
0.950598418712616,
-0.39999282360076904,
0.11612976342439651,
-0.7873528003692627,
0.24640505015850067,
-0.5063986778259277,
-0.19738847017288208,
-0.11643222719430923,
-0.656908392906189,
-0.10642470419406891,
-0.2780719995498657,
0.6493632197380066,
0.13673757016658783,
0.9473153352737427,
-0.25930288434028625,
-0.5238475203514099,
-0.46036651730537415,
-0.752395749092102,
0.9315761923789978,
-0.3252658545970917,
0.25869327783584595,
-0.006155661307275295,
0.26660865545272827,
-0.23049627244472504,
-0.8353590369224548,
-0.32976314425468445,
-0.24840253591537476,
-0.1526789665222168,
-0.1651252806186676,
-0.49483126401901245,
-0.6400970816612244,
0.39753037691116333,
0.4693494439125061,
-0.34792158007621765,
-0.43600913882255554,
-0.654714822769165,
-0.08801263570785522,
0.40599197149276733,
0.07670082896947861,
0.7865763306617737,
-0.28152936697006226,
-0.19947290420532227,
0.20657755434513092,
-0.740907609462738,
0.18618617951869965,
0.6581881046295166,
0.3466890752315521,
0.12670421600341797,
0.5747145414352417,
0.0431465320289135,
0.36237597465515137,
0.07523135095834732,
-0.24548286199569702,
0.5392552614212036,
-0.07847543060779572,
0.2157648354768753,
0.08014291524887085,
0.3824991285800934,
0.36962035298347473,
0.7585524320602417,
-0.2742260694503784,
-0.11679782718420029,
-0.004052967764437199,
0.4648061692714691,
-0.318290650844574,
-0.12216488271951675,
-0.26484134793281555,
-0.4177970588207245,
-0.31271669268608093,
-0.03927517682313919,
-0.6136603355407715,
-0.6733599305152893,
-0.3115692138671875,
0.13189850747585297,
-0.4497636556625366,
-0.19120696187019348,
0.16336682438850403,
-0.7034473419189453,
0.12049296498298645,
0.3144896924495697,
-0.6984275579452515,
-0.20085853338241577,
0.853012204170227,
0.8515723943710327,
0.581373929977417,
-0.20345982909202576,
0.12158369272947311,
0.05349324271082878,
-0.5973624587059021,
0.336391419172287,
-0.4457337558269501,
-0.32236695289611816,
-0.057102400809526443,
0.3779442012310028,
-0.0622328445315361,
-0.45599427819252014,
0.8672072291374207,
-0.13991498947143555,
0.0826539620757103,
-0.2336924523115158,
-0.24969778954982758,
-0.12841497361660004,
0.2131861448287964,
-0.8102654218673706,
0.6576932072639465,
-0.04275650903582573,
-1.1145566701889038,
0.28183719515800476,
0.0505196787416935,
0.02558165043592453,
-0.3424604833126068,
-0.34313052892684937,
-0.35349908471107483,
0.3469994068145752,
0.09378276765346527,
0.12961331009864807,
-0.38930779695510864,
0.10467792302370071,
-0.19340787827968597,
-0.46876293420791626,
0.23306892812252045,
-0.33023732900619507,
1.0094945430755615,
0.34902551770210266,
-0.17509232461452484,
-0.08675603568553925,
-0.366546630859375,
-0.46793708205223083,
0.5954350233078003,
0.13121914863586426,
-0.6658783555030823,
-0.17608138918876648,
-0.03363180533051491,
-0.2512444853782654,
0.07469921559095383,
-0.7411540746688843,
0.20889398455619812,
-0.3057054281234741,
0.3968050181865692,
0.6396616697311401,
-0.23949968814849854,
0.16360244154930115,
-0.8430854082107544,
0.726813018321991,
-0.2776827812194824,
0.02398877963423729,
-0.09049069136381149,
-0.6049916744232178,
-0.3438073396682739,
-0.4805748760700226,
0.253359854221344,
0.158285990357399,
-0.5122902393341064,
0.18355493247509003,
-0.3724844455718994,
-0.5811191201210022,
-0.8606839776039124,
0.31357166171073914,
0.18947839736938477,
0.43111297488212585,
-0.13408592343330383,
-0.6045727133750916,
-0.746835470199585,
-0.9214637279510498,
-0.7935218811035156,
-0.33715149760246277,
0.08172786980867386,
0.09858917444944382,
0.2194574624300003,
0.0013320418074727058,
1.035085916519165,
-0.32467982172966003,
-0.42025959491729736,
-0.23121023178100586,
0.4651201665401459,
0.24166260659694672,
0.5756973624229431,
0.9011769890785217,
-0.4575071334838867,
-0.006739663425832987,
-0.5075050592422485,
-0.6414364576339722,
-0.4341396391391754,
0.2501876652240753,
-0.24337591230869293,
-0.28076228499412537,
0.6543170213699341,
-0.18305541574954987,
0.3138728439807892,
0.23649339377880096,
-0.43426766991615295,
0.5555217266082764,
0.2198120355606079,
0.5343037843704224,
-0.44675663113594055,
-0.20605866611003876,
0.029984459280967712,
-0.06466508656740189,
-0.31551393866539,
0.3820131719112396,
-0.17501847445964813,
-0.10624000430107117,
-0.11008483916521072,
0.3976114094257355,
-0.48092594742774963,
0.18333861231803894,
-0.06251649558544159,
-0.07309257239103317,
0.1891690492630005,
-0.4840813875198364,
-0.03876128047704697,
0.4971745014190674,
0.44299474358558655,
-0.05691158026456833,
0.25047704577445984,
-0.03781642019748688,
-0.10188158601522446,
0.8343093395233154,
-0.4998336732387543,
0.19858044385910034,
-0.7885535359382629,
0.4456823468208313,
-1.7644704580307007,
0.14110347628593445,
0.38432762026786804,
-0.7243788242340088,
0.2561441659927368,
-0.6005510687828064,
-0.45202314853668213,
-0.46911048889160156,
-0.36244601011276245,
0.7217544317245483,
0.6239277124404907,
-0.48963162302970886,
0.43142834305763245,
0.2508704662322998,
-0.15050680935382843,
-0.8382469415664673,
-0.4310072362422943,
0.09811843931674957,
-0.32187914848327637,
-0.5875069499015808,
-0.39976802468299866,
0.15026773512363434,
-0.528827428817749,
-0.36359483003616333,
-0.03887740895152092,
0.09148047864437103,
-0.06357920914888382,
0.31614556908607483,
-0.01725318841636181,
0.017607999965548515,
0.2305736392736435,
0.0023036086931824684,
-0.04956228658556938,
-0.012965342961251736,
-0.007511400617659092,
0.6383304595947266,
-0.02309468574821949,
-0.28136947751045227,
-0.04359544813632965,
0.28392282128334045,
0.7114273309707642,
0.03470330685377121,
0.3646126985549927,
0.7402277588844299,
-0.25918614864349365,
0.1024138554930687,
-0.5296034216880798,
-0.02652294747531414,
-0.3953796923160553,
0.16642604768276215,
-0.3613074719905853,
-0.5626663565635681,
0.03326747566461563,
0.04002400115132332,
0.09904304891824722,
0.41652941703796387,
0.13833284378051758,
-0.6223801970481873,
0.32047998905181885,
0.6075831055641174,
-0.1725325584411621,
0.2943989932537079,
-0.21269339323043823,
0.09543348848819733,
-0.923946738243103,
0.11028546839952469,
-0.9094192385673523,
-0.7976139783859253,
-0.5828158855438232,
-0.38780513405799866,
0.32877516746520996,
0.08013161271810532,
-0.4562194049358368,
-0.09102187305688858,
-0.5013743042945862,
0.300780326128006,
0.4653286337852478,
0.13937723636627197,
0.5609994530677795,
0.1274794042110443,
0.06470943242311478,
-0.5169847011566162,
-0.2955133020877838,
-0.7645077705383301,
1.5212481021881104,
0.6877574920654297,
0.6520140171051025,
0.5224964022636414,
0.8321173191070557,
0.36793389916419983,
0.6212136149406433,
-0.552857518196106,
0.4492851495742798,
-0.5222281813621521,
-1.0684912204742432,
-0.10542469471693039,
-0.2706387937068939,
-1.2124673128128052,
0.06949220597743988,
-0.13831759989261627,
-0.693901002407074,
0.4444563090801239,
0.02368449978530407,
0.25452396273612976,
0.6656842827796936,
-0.31477320194244385,
0.279043048620224,
0.2642843425273895,
-0.11837678402662277,
0.019528159871697426,
-0.3935856223106384,
1.0269899368286133,
0.13627661764621735,
0.585356593132019,
-0.14820349216461182,
0.08896145969629288,
0.5771971940994263,
-0.02782725915312767,
1.1857643127441406,
0.19117695093154907,
-0.4193643033504486,
0.107364721596241,
0.4352255165576935,
0.10647708922624588,
-0.4069475829601288,
0.08950062096118927,
0.2819252610206604,
-0.0025165495462715626,
-0.5915652513504028,
-0.16685788333415985,
0.7829846739768982,
-0.7760292887687683,
-0.44541046023368835,
-0.5877606868743896,
-0.7020893096923828,
0.058722421526908875,
-0.18588712811470032,
0.11994650959968567,
0.38791775703430176,
-0.06389964371919632,
0.20034058392047882,
0.4850351810455322,
-0.48918113112449646,
0.12054193764925003,
0.2947162985801697,
-0.7089291214942932,
-0.19204075634479523,
0.26771628856658936,
0.35776498913764954,
0.3806593716144562,
0.019041504710912704,
0.18152430653572083,
-0.16893212497234344,
-0.21563661098480225,
-0.0954926460981369,
0.49461379647254944,
-0.707582414150238,
0.23609638214111328,
-0.42092326283454895,
-0.15102459490299225,
-0.7989949584007263,
-0.2896665036678314,
-0.3224656581878662,
-0.2175300419330597,
0.008450984954833984,
0.005106344819068909,
0.6088139414787292,
0.9077222347259521,
-0.23234683275222778,
0.15978021919727325,
-0.4706445634365082,
0.46249210834503174,
0.5211644768714905,
0.21363860368728638,
0.40624696016311646,
-0.784382700920105,
0.4148992896080017,
-0.5366623997688293,
-0.22049063444137573,
-1.0711236000061035,
0.2854810059070587,
-0.27256134152412415,
0.3103812634944916,
0.2793353497982025,
-0.10476483404636383,
0.34908729791641235,
-0.645269513130188,
0.7341101169586182,
0.4175472557544708,
-0.6458243131637573,
0.384906530380249,
-0.45124486088752747,
-0.1657675802707672,
0.2179863303899765,
0.3011232614517212,
-0.9106602072715759,
-0.6121372580528259,
-0.807900607585907,
-1.1435929536819458,
0.2625235617160797,
0.29305794835090637,
0.5901540517807007,
-0.0987158790230751,
0.6457610130310059,
0.20853033661842346,
0.4402797818183899,
-0.5821677446365356,
-0.6971343159675598,
-0.21078939735889435,
-0.12564153969287872,
-0.34219422936439514,
-0.33522313833236694,
-0.2549803555011749,
-0.37446218729019165,
0.333455353975296,
0.5004571080207825,
0.014564810320734978,
0.22364431619644165,
-0.04773738235235214,
-0.22580291330814362,
0.534952700138092,
0.15568190813064575,
0.4827495515346527,
-0.38948777318000793,
0.26994362473487854,
-0.3062043786048889,
-0.8281278014183044,
0.3509787917137146,
-0.2502840757369995,
-0.611852765083313,
0.3532125651836395,
0.5466646552085876,
0.4153284430503845,
-0.09027360379695892,
-0.45961499214172363,
0.1367068886756897,
0.059592705219984055,
0.17393241822719574,
-0.6931121349334717,
0.04883744195103645,
0.09440150856971741,
0.4015483260154724,
0.2248702198266983,
0.12093135714530945,
0.18030501902103424,
-1.2304078340530396,
0.14461776614189148,
0.5220774412155151,
-0.4555148482322693,
0.20408812165260315,
0.5451928377151489,
0.09099535644054413,
-0.2616518437862396,
0.32917875051498413,
0.06007222831249237,
-0.3398664891719818,
0.7563401460647583,
0.5682277083396912,
0.9720355868339539,
0.05712156742811203,
0.2560614049434662,
0.7034131288528442,
0.8000848293304443,
0.06765354424715042,
0.0628986805677414,
0.6337018609046936,
-0.8588593602180481,
0.1897013634443283,
-0.47218939661979675,
0.044844385236501694,
-0.016909563913941383,
-0.4220568835735321,
0.15112821757793427,
-0.4042414128780365,
-0.2712244987487793,
-0.24015678465366364,
-0.22948366403579712,
-0.7795326709747314,
-0.045252662152051926,
0.46133190393447876,
0.7489398121833801,
-1.346025824546814,
0.33960267901420593,
0.5459710359573364,
-0.7523418068885803,
-0.5686133503913879,
0.40272921323776245,
0.4449169635772705,
-0.6187046766281128,
1.1753865480422974,
-0.17623363435268402,
-0.2727084755897522,
0.22123222053050995,
-0.65640789270401,
-0.6236945390701294,
1.0207581520080566,
0.2717480957508087,
-0.9017429351806641,
0.2512805759906769,
-0.2490302324295044,
0.4647362232208252,
-0.4891640245914459,
0.6096667647361755,
0.7296996712684631,
0.524783194065094,
0.2231152355670929,
-1.0529834032058716,
-0.17399299144744873,
-0.12810614705085754,
0.1638694554567337,
-0.0988173559308052,
-0.39782655239105225,
1.2121824026107788,
-0.0916551873087883,
-0.16291573643684387,
0.5078696608543396,
0.6674441695213318,
0.7226569652557373,
0.4010162949562073,
0.5504121780395508,
0.5022672414779663,
0.7588889598846436,
-0.21951736509799957,
0.8730295896530151,
0.2346549928188324,
0.26777198910713196,
0.8105606436729431,
-0.01488285418599844,
0.5406343936920166,
0.5173871517181396,
-0.36308765411376953,
0.4930771291255951,
0.33041808009147644,
0.31397297978401184,
0.12733562290668488,
0.8335759043693542,
-0.2638840973377228,
0.04824848100543022,
-0.27601075172424316,
-0.650980532169342,
0.15955860912799835,
-0.07790683954954147,
-0.5943894982337952,
-0.36666882038116455,
-0.08462844043970108,
0.3341461420059204,
0.564705491065979,
-0.6532644629478455,
0.3136496841907501,
0.17964032292366028,
-0.022585682570934296,
0.492065966129303,
-0.1914481818675995,
0.9987873435020447,
-0.4281471073627472,
-0.13576708734035492,
-0.17513854801654816,
-0.07635852694511414,
-0.10807692259550095,
-0.822978138923645,
-0.08483309298753738,
0.02688249759376049,
-0.4912736713886261,
-0.0516730397939682,
0.8918216228485107,
-0.5645328760147095,
-0.7934987545013428,
-0.045281510800123215,
0.49851030111312866,
0.3446345031261444,
0.2250848412513733,
-0.534618616104126,
0.05858670920133591,
0.18074071407318115,
0.27750474214553833,
0.0868227556347847,
0.7605740427970886,
0.08769678324460983,
0.7205128073692322,
0.28310826420783997,
0.558072566986084,
0.07068595290184021,
0.3263866901397705,
0.34772565960884094,
-0.6254730224609375,
-0.1509697288274765,
-0.46282851696014404,
0.4784564971923828,
0.019785907119512558,
-0.1889326274394989,
0.6235015988349915,
0.16554510593414307,
0.6467342972755432,
-0.2921403646469116,
0.8064897060394287,
0.04713450372219086,
0.7828293442726135,
-0.3733586072921753,
1.0409990549087524,
-0.5447647571563721,
0.3907955586910248,
-0.5487098097801208,
-0.5777212977409363,
-0.16839361190795898,
0.5280066132545471,
-0.5793150067329407,
0.2061612755060196,
0.37353959679603577,
0.6354236006736755,
-0.040937390178442,
0.05461437627673149,
-0.027244780212640762,
0.4559211730957031,
0.17743144929409027,
0.06460285931825638,
1.1752527952194214,
-0.3710549771785736,
0.13978761434555054,
-0.03218470513820648,
-0.22594799101352692,
-0.1516599804162979,
-1.014965534210205,
-0.5262385010719299,
-0.5575963258743286,
-0.37044310569763184,
-0.4613736569881439,
0.2383355051279068,
1.0053950548171997,
0.15497739613056183,
-0.35652661323547363,
-0.33893999457359314,
0.5041113495826721,
0.35400035977363586,
-0.21298834681510925,
-0.22964906692504883,
0.06801778823137283,
-0.534069836139679,
-0.9359410405158997,
-0.28684505820274353,
-0.22888430953025818,
-0.14643871784210205,
-0.422611802816391,
0.04456884041428566,
-0.001039205933921039,
0.4545360803604126,
0.3993333578109741,
0.07783686369657516,
-0.7446505427360535,
-0.4069563150405884,
-0.5808805823326111,
-0.12845547497272491,
-0.10799796134233475,
1.1065434217453003,
-0.46778184175491333,
0.6865822672843933,
0.8089041709899902,
0.10697482526302338,
-0.20219489932060242,
-0.09098776429891586,
0.5503779649734497,
-0.9396018385887146,
-0.03021291457116604,
0.15165385603904724,
0.7269997000694275,
0.37669065594673157,
-0.18612276017665863,
0.5618961453437805,
0.7159984707832336,
-0.17573058605194092,
-0.9103581309318542,
0.48499712347984314,
-0.7768351435661316,
-0.5527921319007874,
0.958235502243042,
-0.06221453845500946,
-0.03602439910173416,
-0.3085618317127228,
-0.536234438419342,
0.27616962790489197,
-0.2554541528224945,
0.9321919083595276,
0.952343225479126,
0.16897661983966827,
-0.3494188189506531,
-0.8960264921188354,
0.2887328863143921,
0.251079797744751,
-0.08489295095205307,
0.02497955784201622,
0.6627639532089233,
0.7168310880661011,
0.13902699947357178,
0.6388688683509827,
-0.5988713502883911,
-0.1301940679550171,
-0.11043553054332733,
0.6200385093688965,
0.2588885724544525,
-0.2556338608264923,
-0.1762578785419464,
0.39548438787460327,
0.3103635013103485,
-0.27271321415901184
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11747v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11747v1
|
Embedded Named Entity Recognition using Probing Classifiers
| 2024-03-18T12:58:16 | 2024-03-18T12:58:16 |
Nicholas Popovič, Michael Färber
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Extracting semantic information from generated text is a useful tool for
applications such as automated fact checking or retrieval augmented generation.
Currently, this requires either separate models during inference, which
increases computational cost, or destructive fine-tuning of the language model.
Instead, we propose directly embedding information extraction capabilities into
pre-trained language models using probing classifiers, enabling efficient
simultaneous text generation and information extraction. For this, we introduce
an approach called EMBER and show that it enables named entity recognition in
decoder-only language models without fine-tuning them and while incurring
minimal additional computational cost at inference time. Specifically, our
experiments using GPT-2 show that EMBER maintains high token generation rates
during streaming text generation, with only a negligible decrease in speed of
around 1% compared to a 43.64% slowdown measured for a baseline using a
separate NER model. Code and data are available at
https://github.com/nicpopovic/EMBER.
|
[
-0.49394387006759644,
-1.0341942310333252,
0.7828389406204224,
-0.31070223450660706,
-0.3576630651950836,
0.04991259053349495,
-0.17862127721309662,
-0.5993454456329346,
0.39245936274528503,
0.39072492718696594,
-0.1897149384021759,
-0.39895468950271606,
-0.7661337852478027,
0.03052779845893383,
-0.5210022330284119,
0.8927234411239624,
0.01600392535328865,
-0.14974795281887054,
0.030302202329039574,
0.20342005789279938,
-0.11920257657766342,
-0.2797725796699524,
-0.9696877002716064,
-0.05093248561024666,
0.5186977386474609,
0.33649805188179016,
0.31675219535827637,
0.7809295654296875,
0.385346382856369,
0.21981336176395416,
0.07801461964845657,
0.22961780428886414,
-0.03391999751329422,
0.6213700175285339,
-0.26123639941215515,
-0.3877231776714325,
-0.2410905659198761,
-0.06735461950302124,
0.7107633352279663,
0.13575239479541779,
0.1151105985045433,
0.22253668308258057,
-0.05306187644600868,
0.054512180387973785,
-0.9937160611152649,
0.1826978474855423,
-0.8396145701408386,
0.0188068225979805,
-0.36885178089141846,
-0.4806307256221771,
-0.601069450378418,
-0.17350846529006958,
0.2346014678478241,
-0.3203144073486328,
0.5955591201782227,
0.26963475346565247,
1.0181660652160645,
0.30297908186912537,
-0.43922725319862366,
-0.43190300464630127,
-0.7279956936836243,
0.5532134175300598,
-0.5610387325286865,
0.7041088938713074,
0.1826280802488327,
0.11438074707984924,
0.12815192341804504,
-1.0152857303619385,
-0.7087118029594421,
-0.03491711989045143,
-0.129464790225029,
0.22138240933418274,
-0.3237604796886444,
0.019137684255838394,
0.40706562995910645,
0.2048884630203247,
-0.3043488562107086,
0.11785750836133957,
-0.08507989346981049,
-0.14249645173549652,
0.4404454231262207,
0.18799711763858795,
0.4038560688495636,
-0.2528931498527527,
-0.16223350167274475,
-0.1728598177433014,
-0.8983265161514282,
0.01885164901614189,
0.38414284586906433,
0.3271276652812958,
0.14671380817890167,
0.6656867265701294,
0.18398383259773254,
0.3532411754131317,
0.12163135409355164,
0.15319471061229706,
0.041490692645311356,
-0.09476033598184586,
-0.21580985188484192,
0.5118451118469238,
0.7153798937797546,
-0.05542157590389252,
0.05428677052259445,
-0.398102343082428,
-0.2694174349308014,
0.07134833186864853,
0.26403650641441345,
-1.1834441423416138,
-0.43347084522247314,
0.3297497630119324,
-0.14823618531227112,
-0.4106830656528473,
0.21311897039413452,
-0.9714893102645874,
-0.2694486677646637,
0.08257512003183365,
0.3223833441734314,
-0.38416242599487305,
-0.43093112111091614,
-0.1539878100156784,
-0.46368852257728577,
0.5221102833747864,
0.3151973485946655,
-1.0883058309555054,
0.18034669756889343,
0.800566554069519,
0.832104504108429,
-0.04345763847231865,
0.02847343496978283,
-0.8377289772033691,
0.46674638986587524,
-0.07795550674200058,
0.9433053731918335,
-0.742563784122467,
-0.37303972244262695,
-0.17072241008281708,
0.056633394211530685,
-0.15086354315280914,
-0.322441428899765,
0.2599326968193054,
-0.6767287850379944,
-0.09055956453084946,
0.09667643904685974,
-0.9869200587272644,
-0.01383710652589798,
0.35093483328819275,
-0.7466633915901184,
1.0120935440063477,
-0.243594229221344,
-1.1582903861999512,
0.5170061588287354,
-0.6757206320762634,
-0.37335360050201416,
0.29782262444496155,
-0.4971821904182434,
-0.36918559670448303,
0.2452811449766159,
0.3432748317718506,
0.6020404696464539,
-0.39910128712654114,
0.17502892017364502,
-0.11928357183933258,
-0.2574845552444458,
0.09481626749038696,
-0.32714954018592834,
0.4423556327819824,
0.15333794057369232,
-0.626629114151001,
-0.30499863624572754,
-0.7213596701622009,
0.2933191657066345,
0.35563430190086365,
-0.47763532400131226,
-0.5430113673210144,
0.2076309621334076,
0.25022631883621216,
-0.2951902747154236,
-0.061021193861961365,
-1.0028212070465088,
0.11935698986053467,
-0.43347880244255066,
0.41880831122398376,
0.5017949938774109,
0.32226115465164185,
0.3878341615200043,
0.07090460509061813,
0.48429957032203674,
0.06911690533161163,
-0.3926153779029846,
-0.41958087682724,
-0.45670589804649353,
-1.1324999332427979,
-0.4547545313835144,
0.8263130187988281,
0.46842432022094727,
-0.5759923458099365,
0.298850417137146,
-0.49192970991134644,
-0.6465393900871277,
-0.713175356388092,
-0.21284835040569305,
0.3719836473464966,
0.2181662768125534,
0.32812902331352234,
-0.04705285653471947,
-0.5508089065551758,
-0.6156240701675415,
-0.525722324848175,
-0.11303100734949112,
-0.13244281709194183,
0.5384394526481628,
0.47494587302207947,
-0.24629318714141846,
1.0713053941726685,
-0.5563712120056152,
0.09455539286136627,
-0.2508671283721924,
0.3441595137119293,
-0.3243725001811981,
0.6818109750747681,
0.25587761402130127,
-1.0330811738967896,
-0.3012542426586151,
0.030972812324762344,
-0.5702521204948425,
-0.09333190321922302,
-0.08000844717025757,
0.10125920176506042,
-0.021412014961242676,
0.5094293355941772,
-0.6313071250915527,
0.45257338881492615,
0.5790411829948425,
-0.43889039754867554,
0.03432092443108559,
0.030446819961071014,
-0.0003092221450060606,
-1.2581250667572021,
-0.059743482619524,
-0.08112364262342453,
-0.4294869005680084,
-0.48051804304122925,
0.18897618353366852,
0.2811039984226227,
-0.20966191589832306,
-0.32742464542388916,
0.874363362789154,
-0.8872191905975342,
-0.1987018585205078,
-0.28177496790885925,
0.5059149861335754,
0.2109086513519287,
-0.053474508225917816,
0.08762602508068085,
0.6816454529762268,
0.4397343099117279,
-0.8570761680603027,
0.22168168425559998,
0.1213984414935112,
-0.35618168115615845,
0.13424962759017944,
-0.6689071655273438,
0.3798399567604065,
-0.03806484118103981,
-0.04417838528752327,
-0.6359817385673523,
-0.35700517892837524,
0.21663112938404083,
-0.7163923978805542,
0.7966088056564331,
-0.4481121599674225,
-0.6624501347541809,
0.18307475745677948,
-0.06926216930150986,
0.34943926334381104,
0.5516045689582825,
-0.8944056630134583,
1.0630689859390259,
0.5824518203735352,
-0.1408001035451889,
-0.22920143604278564,
-0.7944286465644836,
-0.021567702293395996,
-0.1178978905081749,
-0.4223524034023285,
0.6300229430198669,
0.45700275897979736,
-0.14539220929145813,
0.27280619740486145,
-0.04081275314092636,
-0.048958588391542435,
0.26441413164138794,
0.4139862656593323,
0.014957325533032417,
-0.37002331018447876,
0.5643430352210999,
0.4525831639766693,
-0.21437983214855194,
-0.028480930253863335,
-0.17015403509140015,
0.5731015205383301,
-0.01836252585053444,
-0.5979495048522949,
-0.4813522696495056,
0.33372971415519714,
0.3369068205356598,
-0.5993860363960266,
0.8224902749061584,
0.6112462878227234,
-0.43879997730255127,
-0.20620596408843994,
-0.6971074342727661,
-0.30730417370796204,
-0.4737933874130249,
0.29991766810417175,
-0.7300595641136169,
-0.9465575218200684,
0.3394998013973236,
-0.2315082848072052,
0.1060621365904808,
0.5441504716873169,
0.2812913954257965,
0.05287289619445801,
1.186254858970642,
0.596438467502594,
0.3021141588687897,
0.5596973299980164,
0.019883958622813225,
0.5541484951972961,
-0.9239819645881653,
-0.30913910269737244,
-0.6058316230773926,
-0.01768101379275322,
-0.925178050994873,
-0.2276473492383957,
-0.02561044506728649,
0.09266602247953415,
-0.16729453206062317,
0.3633197546005249,
-0.47220495343208313,
0.35275182127952576,
0.566411554813385,
0.01988549344241619,
0.26104170083999634,
-0.18173003196716309,
-0.13935209810733795,
-0.09601451456546783,
-0.40061649680137634,
-0.659635066986084,
0.9115645885467529,
0.35248562693595886,
0.8099930882453918,
0.2363525778055191,
1.0723092555999756,
0.14582820236682892,
0.28000035881996155,
-1.0095151662826538,
0.4591097831726074,
0.2247287929058075,
-0.7270762324333191,
-0.12408868968486786,
-0.3929048478603363,
-0.9011348485946655,
0.22375066578388214,
-0.15519677102565765,
-0.7842503190040588,
-0.014950957149267197,
0.13898107409477234,
-0.1732746809720993,
0.5402340292930603,
-0.6574399471282959,
0.4694809019565582,
-0.17770162224769592,
-0.23321065306663513,
0.015128884464502335,
-0.1377752721309662,
-0.045678216964006424,
-0.27350765466690063,
-0.1689383089542389,
-0.099117711186409,
-0.2209959775209427,
0.7900274991989136,
-0.08477548509836197,
0.5667436122894287,
-0.37955793738365173,
0.1360127329826355,
0.354908287525177,
0.1853671818971634,
0.7553994059562683,
0.3966204524040222,
0.12654459476470947,
0.04377816244959831,
-0.030600430443882942,
-0.21515890955924988,
-0.747749924659729,
0.6672172546386719,
-0.37512436509132385,
-0.6912129521369934,
-0.41252776980400085,
-0.12260979413986206,
0.031082578003406525,
0.30812370777130127,
0.27930736541748047,
0.43875402212142944,
-0.11895426362752914,
0.30384254455566406,
0.6068213582038879,
-0.1773509830236435,
0.45026323199272156,
0.5587719082832336,
-0.15864095091819763,
-0.18885189294815063,
0.6848732829093933,
0.0898059830069542,
0.08821538090705872,
0.5662260055541992,
0.0008041502442210913,
-0.16679519414901733,
-0.5810380578041077,
-0.6922978758811951,
0.12796123325824738,
-0.558232843875885,
-0.23382705450057983,
-1.3293179273605347,
-0.29777634143829346,
-0.5291110277175903,
-0.025163263082504272,
-0.7284144163131714,
-0.42330464720726013,
-0.34197068214416504,
-0.37158122658729553,
0.45135560631752014,
0.6782130002975464,
0.2536658048629761,
0.3409087359905243,
-1.2100178003311157,
-0.17166773974895477,
0.13368891179561615,
0.057509176433086395,
-0.010657780803740025,
-0.41217926144599915,
-0.02422177605330944,
-0.10829834640026093,
-0.16390638053417206,
-0.9840302467346191,
0.31922659277915955,
0.20111940801143646,
0.5337333083152771,
0.6060516834259033,
0.13597863912582397,
0.5814671516418457,
-0.5525250434875488,
0.7207337021827698,
-0.206552192568779,
-1.1153852939605713,
0.7965372204780579,
-0.0347517766058445,
-0.0660669356584549,
0.43322914838790894,
0.33241528272628784,
-0.2841964662075043,
-0.36717814207077026,
-0.7535949349403381,
-0.9028323292732239,
0.4689851701259613,
0.15257376432418823,
0.3909558355808258,
-0.3984074890613556,
0.3755216896533966,
-0.11551844328641891,
0.03852232173085213,
-0.5786650776863098,
-0.1410595029592514,
0.22086383402347565,
-0.15422937273979187,
0.22884947061538696,
-0.39057105779647827,
0.17056508362293243,
-0.02720995806157589,
0.7192028164863586,
0.012268250808119774,
0.5324270725250244,
0.21238939464092255,
-0.2909185588359833,
0.22906270623207092,
0.35916581749916077,
-0.11463356763124466,
0.0716085284948349,
-0.1733817160129547,
0.37665918469429016,
0.2521962821483612,
-0.49121686816215515,
0.052848752588033676,
0.2476155310869217,
-0.3048096001148224,
0.3141154646873474,
0.2977587580680847,
0.7466379404067993,
0.5426946878433228,
-0.603425920009613,
0.5729216933250427,
-0.2914029359817505,
0.0441453643143177,
-0.4384644627571106,
0.2570341229438782,
0.01498677022755146,
0.5699861645698547,
0.1779991239309311,
-0.282169371843338,
0.09671656042337418,
-0.26524627208709717,
0.2743227779865265,
0.3780333995819092,
-0.3223884105682373,
-0.42337316274642944,
0.6254971623420715,
0.17035743594169617,
-0.35579392313957214,
0.9492282271385193,
-0.32454267144203186,
-0.5274814963340759,
0.637654721736908,
0.8922966122627258,
1.072134017944336,
-0.23976092040538788,
0.01202442403882742,
0.4205688238143921,
0.16978296637535095,
0.11596094816923141,
0.23620373010635376,
-0.3895152807235718,
-0.9807127714157104,
0.03779883682727814,
-0.6958147287368774,
-0.4827839434146881,
-0.20670725405216217,
-0.8324960470199585,
0.4695354998111725,
-0.46610864996910095,
-0.3186877369880676,
0.42090994119644165,
-0.10412730276584625,
-0.8590993285179138,
0.20201408863067627,
0.2482738196849823,
0.8205996751785278,
-0.7029256820678711,
0.8421415090560913,
0.8037264347076416,
-0.5256452560424805,
-0.9145129919052124,
0.2227056920528412,
-0.16843432188034058,
-0.4236830472946167,
0.7911152243614197,
0.6088711023330688,
-0.2815801799297333,
0.605427622795105,
-0.3268304169178009,
-0.91830974817276,
1.2754597663879395,
0.11778715997934341,
-0.4439423978328705,
-0.28888148069381714,
-0.39957866072654724,
0.2777916491031647,
-0.4705996513366699,
0.5844572186470032,
0.35035330057144165,
0.4383048713207245,
-0.05140240117907524,
-0.550470769405365,
0.15653766691684723,
-0.2639871835708618,
-0.14581510424613953,
0.6478908658027649,
-0.42701205611228943,
0.908784031867981,
-0.33482298254966736,
-0.8995519876480103,
-0.12966874241828918,
0.48915037512779236,
0.06824500113725662,
0.3230261504650116,
0.3557436168193817,
0.7191294431686401,
0.858099639415741,
-0.09335032105445862,
0.9204950332641602,
-0.33280834555625916,
0.5228244066238403,
1.2091665267944336,
-0.3668593764305115,
1.0511505603790283,
0.5461235046386719,
0.10675005614757538,
0.3512682020664215,
0.5577943325042725,
-0.33725273609161377,
0.6863747835159302,
0.005429438315331936,
-0.41812339425086975,
-0.06890608370304108,
-0.168893963098526,
-0.28934231400489807,
0.829759418964386,
0.45193174481391907,
-0.8325185775756836,
-0.20988307893276215,
-0.058088380843400955,
0.15526846051216125,
-0.4487262964248657,
0.005759528838098049,
0.881298303604126,
-0.042970966547727585,
-0.5894379019737244,
-0.0067854830995202065,
0.2422173023223877,
0.581823468208313,
-0.24230735003948212,
-0.1427687257528305,
0.14506962895393372,
0.2441098690032959,
-0.16071811318397522,
-0.483384907245636,
0.2820948362350464,
0.35909950733184814,
-0.10386097431182861,
0.01663978211581707,
0.7851960062980652,
-0.23612086474895477,
-0.27294400334358215,
0.5362356901168823,
0.6892848610877991,
0.4844909608364105,
-0.16111773252487183,
-0.2613307535648346,
-0.18384580314159393,
-0.04811464250087738,
-0.7500353455543518,
0.27820706367492676,
0.4296155273914337,
0.3523024320602417,
0.3702635169029236,
0.7034395933151245,
0.06484264880418777,
0.31741225719451904,
0.03459443151950836,
0.991263210773468,
-0.8392433524131775,
-0.4076331853866577,
-1.1844429969787598,
0.3392888605594635,
-0.09977657347917557,
-0.1906416118144989,
0.7712597846984863,
0.7109174728393555,
1.0210161209106445,
0.21703410148620605,
0.8582000732421875,
-0.38372132182121277,
0.43879857659339905,
-0.6764200925827026,
0.7811389565467834,
-0.5139064788818359,
0.07824727147817612,
-0.1449582874774933,
-1.0131365060806274,
-0.09224160015583038,
0.46621012687683105,
-0.3072851598262787,
-0.021879859268665314,
0.7532025575637817,
0.8661532402038574,
-0.23757676780223846,
0.2825278043746948,
0.24951304495334625,
-0.13807626068592072,
0.6294703483581543,
0.17686279118061066,
0.7505840063095093,
-0.6265902519226074,
0.24980799853801727,
-0.13697761297225952,
0.09567347168922424,
-0.0844198614358902,
-0.831520140171051,
-1.0000807046890259,
-0.4680030345916748,
-0.34082725644111633,
-0.26392099261283875,
0.086167111992836,
0.8993076682090759,
0.6318188905715942,
-0.8003948926925659,
0.6153026223182678,
-0.33205732703208923,
-0.2751467823982239,
0.39261436462402344,
-0.2920215129852295,
0.4159737229347229,
-0.3867894411087036,
-1.0660679340362549,
0.37060466408729553,
0.10329638421535492,
0.17813649773597717,
-0.010594944469630718,
0.22813892364501953,
-0.09599669277667999,
0.06664255261421204,
0.18371443450450897,
0.06286133825778961,
-0.6605601906776428,
-0.5201392769813538,
-0.17405937612056732,
-0.14384299516677856,
-0.10050343722105026,
0.9362078309059143,
-0.6491951942443848,
0.6008858680725098,
0.4966737627983093,
1.2379565238952637,
0.8531927466392517,
0.09548257291316986,
0.31860530376434326,
-0.6706600785255432,
0.039007704704999924,
0.3989467918872833,
0.42379918694496155,
0.3185647130012512,
-0.5793013572692871,
0.46260663866996765,
0.05472106859087944,
-0.46220842003822327,
-0.8351054191589355,
0.15409071743488312,
-0.49695754051208496,
0.12996937334537506,
1.0360548496246338,
-0.5233601331710815,
-0.26805245876312256,
0.02096802555024624,
0.0899122804403305,
0.720332682132721,
-0.44333574175834656,
0.38140177726745605,
0.4926671087741852,
-0.1094689667224884,
-0.34405818581581116,
-0.6290861964225769,
0.2679872214794159,
0.29131564497947693,
-0.8340703845024109,
-0.1955331414937973,
0.2502044141292572,
0.46178314089775085,
0.30218666791915894,
0.34051793813705444,
-0.12680913507938385,
-0.11652734130620956,
0.5174436569213867,
0.28648248314857483,
-0.1837291121482849,
-0.4166952967643738,
-0.07942160964012146,
0.09023502469062805,
-0.10238110274076462,
-0.4622662663459778
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11621v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11621v1
|
Let's Focus on Neuron: Neuron-Level Supervised Fine-tuning for Large Language Model
| 2024-03-18T09:55:01 | 2024-03-18T09:55:01 |
Haoyun Xu, Runzhe Zhan, Derek F. Wong, Lidia S. Chao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are composed of neurons that exhibit various
behaviors and roles, which become increasingly diversified as models scale.
Recent studies have revealed that not all neurons are active across different
datasets, and this sparsity correlates positively with the task-specific
ability, leading to advancements in model pruning and training efficiency.
Traditional fine-tuning methods engage all parameters of LLMs, which is
computationally expensive and may not be necessary. In contrast,
Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning (PEFT) approaches aim to minimize the number of
trainable parameters, yet they still operate at a relatively macro scale (e.g.,
layer-level). We introduce Neuron-Level Fine-Tuning (NeFT), a novel approach
that refines the granularity of parameter training down to the individual
neuron, enabling more precise and computationally efficient model updates. The
experimental results show that NeFT not only exceeded the performance of
full-parameter fine-tuning and PEFT but also provided insights into the
analysis of neurons.
|
[
-0.4747270345687866,
-1.1394221782684326,
0.2772151529788971,
0.07545106112957001,
0.00039949899655766785,
-0.09443795680999756,
-0.6174439787864685,
-0.34200671315193176,
-0.07040522247552872,
0.4250500798225403,
-0.5031142830848694,
-0.3872987627983093,
-0.534016489982605,
-0.11156917363405228,
-0.5031592845916748,
0.9796894192695618,
0.3346027731895447,
0.08410142362117767,
-0.14080944657325745,
-0.004944600164890289,
-0.05773148313164711,
-0.4456195533275604,
-1.2863798141479492,
-0.740803062915802,
0.8267943263053894,
0.3793841302394867,
0.5406064987182617,
0.4680763781070709,
0.28899359703063965,
0.284993052482605,
-0.551428496837616,
0.41359421610832214,
-0.4618995189666748,
-0.047671616077423096,
-0.2430221140384674,
-0.3775867521762848,
-0.7814769148826599,
-0.18747948110103607,
0.5961424112319946,
1.001465916633606,
-0.31135034561157227,
0.05609956756234169,
0.19010616838932037,
0.599793016910553,
-0.6158444285392761,
-0.020379014313220978,
-0.8612870573997498,
-0.1105557382106781,
0.14159278571605682,
-0.08544691652059555,
-0.3455319404602051,
-0.11503440141677856,
0.07348466664552689,
-0.4340670704841614,
0.5640040040016174,
-0.10548251867294312,
1.0265523195266724,
0.31056126952171326,
-0.38101911544799805,
0.3382303714752197,
-0.5507721304893494,
0.6976011991500854,
-1.0731420516967773,
0.048298582434654236,
0.518113911151886,
0.024376343935728073,
-0.37103334069252014,
-0.5679143667221069,
-0.30037739872932434,
-0.4438244700431824,
-0.011980296112596989,
-0.4385291635990143,
-0.08030559122562408,
0.42151591181755066,
0.44693031907081604,
0.19134493172168732,
-0.24003638327121735,
0.5632437467575073,
-0.0925934836268425,
-0.1877337247133255,
0.5957822799682617,
0.23406653106212616,
0.29655441641807556,
0.2715173065662384,
0.14198555052280426,
-0.036466144025325775,
-0.7487276196479797,
-0.10192377865314484,
0.4317838251590729,
0.6088908314704895,
-0.014195612631738186,
0.26076972484588623,
-0.5097758173942566,
0.930902361869812,
0.3871408700942993,
0.14056947827339172,
0.05678962171077728,
-0.05385705456137657,
-0.2553321123123169,
-0.02746453694999218,
0.7691219449043274,
0.32755476236343384,
0.5785651206970215,
-0.2983505129814148,
-0.3961922228336334,
-0.4189147353172302,
0.29602956771850586,
-0.9615205526351929,
-0.3662266135215759,
-0.11304039508104324,
-0.45702648162841797,
-0.3776949346065521,
-0.6714839339256287,
-0.6345868110656738,
-0.4422528147697449,
-0.6015600562095642,
0.5988014340400696,
-0.4383385479450226,
-0.32615140080451965,
0.19692006707191467,
0.23936285078525543,
0.10973592847585678,
0.5863845944404602,
-1.5205963850021362,
0.4514540731906891,
0.8566251397132874,
0.8215157985687256,
-0.10095778852701187,
-0.5429943799972534,
-0.6655718684196472,
-0.0433046855032444,
-0.5003274083137512,
0.6303952932357788,
-0.6095737218856812,
0.13972273468971252,
-0.25509271025657654,
0.049232032150030136,
-0.11616671085357666,
-0.6936137080192566,
0.2538405656814575,
-0.4282546043395996,
-0.4471782147884369,
-0.18607951700687408,
-0.2903176546096802,
-0.16658999025821686,
0.33538031578063965,
-0.5011415481567383,
0.9276248216629028,
0.1193087175488472,
-0.444088876247406,
0.510904848575592,
-0.4262060821056366,
-0.6953487396240234,
-0.23705419898033142,
-0.023173892870545387,
-0.3007667064666748,
0.6617717742919922,
0.4459507167339325,
0.7287939786911011,
-0.4354892373085022,
0.44100844860076904,
-0.3443687856197357,
-0.37320780754089355,
-0.0900835171341896,
-0.4403717517852783,
0.24496810138225555,
-0.07562188059091568,
-0.20694801211357117,
0.3114403486251831,
-0.9400017261505127,
0.06041939556598663,
-0.12896926701068878,
-0.32741519808769226,
-0.2314835488796234,
0.14930900931358337,
0.11961964517831802,
0.16067588329315186,
0.36394354701042175,
-0.4920327365398407,
0.30963465571403503,
-0.6773649454116821,
1.055230975151062,
0.7492994070053101,
-0.14323684573173523,
0.6796106696128845,
-0.06828324496746063,
0.16273394227027893,
-0.20080602169036865,
0.20046162605285645,
0.09794554114341736,
-0.1463763266801834,
-0.7250691056251526,
-0.0337192639708519,
0.596407949924469,
0.05864005908370018,
-0.155800461769104,
0.3315674066543579,
0.005452961660921574,
-0.5372416973114014,
-0.23447248339653015,
0.06568871438503265,
0.022649552673101425,
0.44779258966445923,
0.41054287552833557,
-0.12775565683841705,
0.07818321883678436,
-1.1358332633972168,
-0.2638646960258484,
0.19225455820560455,
0.03608742728829384,
0.35145407915115356,
0.4784044325351715,
0.044086191803216934,
0.5687081813812256,
-0.30210989713668823,
-0.15559521317481995,
-0.2057551145553589,
0.24715262651443481,
0.4441005289554596,
0.7822414636611938,
0.3656667172908783,
-0.4567738175392151,
-0.4791409969329834,
0.4577731490135193,
-0.3224654793739319,
0.08671367168426514,
-0.2965816259384155,
0.14850616455078125,
0.05482146888971329,
0.9241862893104553,
-0.5691884160041809,
0.2664034962654114,
0.43790310621261597,
-0.14609096944332123,
0.22590669989585876,
-0.7383974194526672,
-0.04807645082473755,
-0.5686330199241638,
-0.13984526693820953,
-0.020627181977033615,
0.016899174079298973,
-0.6834611296653748,
-0.11521398276090622,
0.29629814624786377,
0.08167571574449539,
-0.1109619215130806,
0.4134393632411957,
-0.46679946780204773,
0.06646428257226944,
-0.632381796836853,
-0.16411301493644714,
-0.16170567274093628,
0.6215339303016663,
-0.052248306572437286,
0.6692988872528076,
0.9604064226150513,
-0.6182827949523926,
-0.04294848069548607,
-0.21423868834972382,
-0.39973199367523193,
0.2927076816558838,
-0.944556474685669,
0.12321203202009201,
-0.12000205367803574,
-0.19312894344329834,
-0.6798650026321411,
-0.1857394427061081,
-0.19836609065532684,
-0.259125292301178,
0.6452348232269287,
-0.24292802810668945,
-0.8998777866363525,
0.2513219714164734,
0.13339386880397797,
0.38764527440071106,
0.3862195909023285,
-0.5684759020805359,
0.80403071641922,
0.29713761806488037,
-0.047224901616573334,
-0.4485016465187073,
-0.5894647836685181,
0.11392389982938766,
-0.018323048949241638,
-0.5316445231437683,
0.6042527556419373,
0.1837150752544403,
0.05636715888977051,
-0.2974155843257904,
-0.3856377899646759,
-0.19268393516540527,
0.21759261190891266,
0.08983321487903595,
-0.1475479006767273,
-0.2302655577659607,
0.32993465662002563,
0.38481035828590393,
-0.10319656133651733,
-0.04409756883978844,
-0.0022305587772279978,
0.8444074392318726,
-0.15976308286190033,
-0.21576738357543945,
-0.4027913510799408,
0.23536565899848938,
0.48595353960990906,
-0.471787691116333,
0.743299663066864,
0.670126736164093,
-0.4842042326927185,
-0.6631711721420288,
-0.4604918956756592,
-0.6040183305740356,
-0.5520173907279968,
0.6112224459648132,
-0.28745710849761963,
-1.0715912580490112,
0.33424219489097595,
-0.3853522837162018,
-0.08194339275360107,
0.32477739453315735,
0.385589599609375,
0.06311547756195068,
1.2742754220962524,
0.9345700740814209,
-0.11130695044994354,
0.6382181644439697,
-0.1674615889787674,
0.3816947638988495,
-0.9154995679855347,
-0.21946892142295837,
-0.49466177821159363,
-0.8178993463516235,
-0.46141016483306885,
-0.08906272798776627,
0.12337825447320938,
0.425513356924057,
-0.5286985635757446,
0.3926977515220642,
-0.7644490599632263,
0.6601386666297913,
0.490004301071167,
0.18236605823040009,
0.13660472631454468,
0.20395079255104065,
-0.019947824999690056,
0.15312418341636658,
-0.8253103494644165,
-0.3613671064376831,
0.9857245683670044,
0.23891207575798035,
0.8311997652053833,
-0.41607075929641724,
0.5192657113075256,
-0.1395198255777359,
-0.09102563560009003,
-0.8434320092201233,
0.8048216104507446,
-0.40931209921836853,
-0.5596827268600464,
-0.39457905292510986,
-0.3290087580680847,
-0.882060170173645,
0.33781927824020386,
-0.303170382976532,
-1.1109261512756348,
0.412693053483963,
0.21812774240970612,
-0.5815222859382629,
0.47972550988197327,
-0.7329583168029785,
0.8880493640899658,
-0.24098391830921173,
-0.4658452570438385,
-0.6820415258407593,
-0.36880236864089966,
-0.15979453921318054,
-0.11297009140253067,
-0.15186525881290436,
-0.4564371407032013,
-0.2996700704097748,
0.4471049904823303,
-0.29496484994888306,
0.9733860492706299,
-0.10287736356258392,
-0.1493435502052307,
-0.13217130303382874,
0.15847977995872498,
0.5108635425567627,
0.2811432480812073,
-0.19933074712753296,
0.275346577167511,
-0.06932242959737778,
-0.2897655963897705,
-0.5537388324737549,
1.1489609479904175,
-0.7194876074790955,
-0.49706709384918213,
-0.14007596671581268,
-0.9130573868751526,
-0.4530061185359955,
0.24380096793174744,
0.08617252111434937,
0.4877493679523468,
0.035553138703107834,
0.41910046339035034,
0.9790961146354675,
-0.42529070377349854,
0.5784115195274353,
0.37463709712028503,
0.04074304178357124,
-0.17481103539466858,
0.8493708372116089,
0.2370700240135193,
0.2765117585659027,
0.4657238721847534,
0.05665518715977669,
0.26911380887031555,
-1.2446285486221313,
-0.0554397888481617,
0.2409370094537735,
-0.4649762511253357,
0.06109684705734253,
-0.6411497592926025,
-0.16102860867977142,
-0.16654253005981445,
-0.1534874141216278,
-0.5024227499961853,
-0.218367338180542,
-0.5099436044692993,
0.051042500883340836,
0.5349453687667847,
0.47159212827682495,
-0.17605789005756378,
0.6179566979408264,
-0.5369836091995239,
0.39478471875190735,
0.32642313838005066,
0.6616285443305969,
0.16423343122005463,
-0.6034154891967773,
-0.300927996635437,
-0.017686061561107635,
-0.15023460984230042,
-0.43077534437179565,
0.3886544704437256,
0.5285733342170715,
0.5594699382781982,
0.12867265939712524,
-0.4597502648830414,
0.7227765917778015,
-0.6298797130584717,
0.641525387763977,
0.15345674753189087,
-0.9052425622940063,
0.4974414110183716,
-0.41285356879234314,
0.3843328654766083,
0.637944221496582,
0.0628545954823494,
-0.30997738242149353,
-0.0047310455702245235,
-0.5274811387062073,
-1.13771653175354,
0.9275224208831787,
-0.077104352414608,
0.5414626002311707,
0.09097708761692047,
0.7021329402923584,
0.038368888199329376,
0.17432591319084167,
-0.3679558336734772,
-0.08104299753904343,
0.20653486251831055,
0.04294906184077263,
-0.29344242811203003,
0.0018563311314210296,
0.0017353662988170981,
-0.793397843837738,
0.45858803391456604,
-0.35559290647506714,
0.05386314541101456,
-0.03388048708438873,
0.03321947902441025,
-0.15991884469985962,
0.1098899096250534,
0.5191808938980103,
0.6473668217658997,
-0.20390155911445618,
0.006120884791016579,
0.5609967708587646,
-0.3378232419490814,
-0.14419199526309967,
-0.08685118705034256,
-0.24750135838985443,
-0.11685595661401749,
0.2209930270910263,
0.8737328052520752,
0.1840837150812149,
-0.5735596418380737,
0.31245532631874084,
0.027763359248638153,
-0.584759533405304,
0.038992658257484436,
0.4246424734592438,
0.34338369965553284,
0.39998626708984375,
0.148410364985466,
0.3321244418621063,
-0.007486140355467796,
-0.35836687684059143,
0.08271294832229614,
0.4935076832771301,
-0.48535794019699097,
-0.2571796476840973,
0.5375624895095825,
-0.10544350743293762,
-0.4155876636505127,
0.7036566138267517,
0.17553631961345673,
0.046751152724027634,
0.9438621997833252,
0.48332327604293823,
0.8727630376815796,
0.1279674917459488,
0.07977889478206635,
0.5339863896369934,
0.5219265222549438,
-0.3880578875541687,
0.17132186889648438,
0.008924651890993118,
-0.5934128761291504,
-0.7632642388343811,
-0.8097898364067078,
-0.13295218348503113,
0.4629274904727936,
-0.5937392115592957,
0.11955541372299194,
-0.8932963013648987,
-0.3384475111961365,
0.3482632040977478,
-0.3267514109611511,
-0.3014530837535858,
0.29990553855895996,
0.11935780197381973,
1.0696457624435425,
-0.5117281675338745,
1.1766704320907593,
0.6289072632789612,
-0.12488957494497299,
-0.7920580506324768,
0.005252679344266653,
-0.5336036682128906,
-0.5360264778137207,
0.7796684503555298,
-0.006832593120634556,
-0.04990231618285179,
0.13655291497707367,
-0.8882592916488647,
-0.941857099533081,
0.8123860955238342,
0.7668715715408325,
-0.9353932738304138,
-0.22088505327701569,
-0.08103163540363312,
0.754099428653717,
-0.23081228137016296,
0.1602250039577484,
0.7823378443717957,
0.3409353792667389,
-0.2761359214782715,
-0.9335383772850037,
-0.08808045089244843,
-0.23881389200687408,
0.10024014115333557,
0.6240985989570618,
-0.6447230577468872,
1.0679309368133545,
-0.13533969223499298,
0.22474034130573273,
-0.07808227092027664,
0.5783674120903015,
-0.11991192400455475,
-0.08366134762763977,
0.4291766285896301,
0.5956615209579468,
0.6873786449432373,
-0.20945236086845398,
0.7784008979797363,
-0.4117894172668457,
0.29896384477615356,
1.2325257062911987,
0.004271038342267275,
0.8858816027641296,
0.6834090352058411,
0.04190082848072052,
0.15457873046398163,
0.6294316053390503,
-0.3191568851470947,
0.5576996207237244,
0.49078401923179626,
-0.08026956021785736,
-0.7181568741798401,
-0.02105025388300419,
-0.1229560598731041,
0.18252772092819214,
0.4979817271232605,
-0.3369735777378082,
-0.4322240650653839,
-0.06870654225349426,
-0.20509225130081177,
0.12005487829446793,
-0.670135498046875,
0.7266802787780762,
0.2646450698375702,
-0.4715915322303772,
0.8024248480796814,
0.07378081977367401,
0.9119141697883606,
-0.5729493498802185,
0.00474132876843214,
-0.14668989181518555,
0.22019043564796448,
-0.2777916491031647,
-0.48622068762779236,
0.1785207986831665,
-0.16838301718235016,
-0.251098096370697,
-0.1463526487350464,
0.7457605600357056,
-0.3186444938182831,
-0.2005263715982437,
0.4115294814109802,
0.17313823103904724,
-0.10087215155363083,
-0.5136523246765137,
-0.7491955757141113,
-0.1904870569705963,
-0.23716171085834503,
-0.40937337279319763,
0.7480165958404541,
0.4509539306163788,
-0.006473050452768803,
0.6983299851417542,
0.4865916073322296,
0.23963570594787598,
-0.01318477001041174,
0.31280288100242615,
0.814554750919342,
-0.6986694931983948,
0.05681721866130829,
-1.016558051109314,
0.2582358121871948,
-0.176330104470253,
-0.6882115006446838,
0.4450189769268036,
0.30671608448028564,
0.8626697659492493,
-0.01579809933900833,
0.4636622369289398,
-0.04160289838910103,
0.06590530276298523,
-0.32199856638908386,
0.8482407927513123,
-0.8761367201805115,
0.03197066858410835,
-0.029048234224319458,
-0.8112040758132935,
-0.4501584768295288,
0.5915591716766357,
-0.5474473834037781,
0.1134028285741806,
0.6280130743980408,
1.2022817134857178,
-0.2474348247051239,
0.06571487337350845,
0.5439926981925964,
0.2255445122718811,
0.04918476194143295,
0.6095150709152222,
0.7957325577735901,
-0.2287391722202301,
0.3059536814689636,
-0.38721343874931335,
-0.0023362799547612667,
-0.025523662567138672,
-0.8784282803535461,
-1.1372301578521729,
-0.2962269186973572,
-0.4819777011871338,
0.11948306858539581,
-0.025510229170322418,
0.7763506770133972,
0.9883096218109131,
-0.9070195555686951,
-0.18954360485076904,
-0.5328652858734131,
-0.17101600766181946,
-0.4063963294029236,
-0.10386944562196732,
0.35075247287750244,
-0.6678634881973267,
-0.8411887288093567,
0.5360342860221863,
0.394101083278656,
-0.2289135903120041,
-0.02272450551390648,
0.1914338320493698,
-0.2569003403186798,
0.038103796541690826,
0.5641793608665466,
0.04997289180755615,
-0.612831711769104,
-0.07672221213579178,
-0.008910945616662502,
-0.14677079021930695,
0.13401271402835846,
0.6433005928993225,
-0.46948152780532837,
0.13117383420467377,
0.6754237413406372,
0.7450143694877625,
0.8055843710899353,
-0.451244056224823,
0.6945048570632935,
-0.4328409731388092,
-0.047649871557950974,
0.4044512212276459,
0.28086256980895996,
0.17745673656463623,
-0.2936640977859497,
0.2509014308452606,
-0.2701748013496399,
-0.7449791431427002,
-0.8846497535705566,
0.12754356861114502,
-1.0688756704330444,
-0.5533127188682556,
1.087194561958313,
0.1959710568189621,
-0.2901313602924347,
0.10927380621433258,
-0.33404541015625,
0.17209823429584503,
-0.4186057150363922,
0.574935793876648,
0.6279158592224121,
-0.08064989745616913,
-0.28023645281791687,
-0.7948194146156311,
0.5427936315536499,
0.7901252508163452,
-0.6354039311408997,
0.17871993780136108,
0.26703983545303345,
0.4032071828842163,
-0.14145591855049133,
0.24479414522647858,
0.04715796932578087,
0.10135333985090256,
-0.07879795134067535,
0.039298009127378464,
-0.10126577317714691,
-0.5240815281867981,
-0.6444559097290039,
0.48199230432510376,
0.3002743721008301,
0.14693573117256165
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11585v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11585v2
|
Linguacodus: A Synergistic Framework for Transformative Code Generation in Machine Learning Pipelines
| 2024-03-18T08:58:47 | 2024-04-30T17:56:33 |
Ekaterina Trofimova, Emil Sataev, Andrey E. Ustyuzhanin
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.PL, cs.SE
|
In the ever-evolving landscape of machine learning, seamless translation of
natural language descriptions into executable code remains a formidable
challenge. This paper introduces Linguacodus, an innovative framework designed
to tackle this challenge by deploying a dynamic pipeline that iteratively
transforms natural language task descriptions into code through high-level
data-shaping instructions. The core of Linguacodus is a fine-tuned large
language model (LLM), empowered to evaluate diverse solutions for various
problems and select the most fitting one for a given task. This paper details
the fine-tuning process, and sheds light on how natural language descriptions
can be translated into functional code. Linguacodus represents a substantial
leap towards automated code generation, effectively bridging the gap between
task descriptions and executable code. It holds great promise for advancing
machine learning applications across diverse domains. Additionally, we propose
an algorithm capable of transforming a natural description of an ML task into
code with minimal human interaction. In extensive experiments on a vast machine
learning code dataset originating from Kaggle, we showcase the effectiveness of
Linguacodus. The investigations highlight its potential applications across
diverse domains, emphasizing its impact on applied machine learning in various
scientific fields.
|
[
-0.2802688777446747,
-0.6411604881286621,
-0.2116045504808426,
0.27518975734710693,
-0.2838071584701538,
0.3657993674278259,
-0.4087313413619995,
-0.39555680751800537,
0.3916928470134735,
0.6084036827087402,
-0.48081445693969727,
-0.46864190697669983,
-0.5950009226799011,
0.39156144857406616,
-0.5035877823829651,
1.108498454093933,
0.09418541938066483,
-0.1342373788356781,
-0.21318873763084412,
-0.06463435292243958,
-0.5146149396896362,
-0.30028510093688965,
-0.5474802851676941,
-0.27801382541656494,
0.4769246280193329,
0.5612422227859497,
0.7777463793754578,
0.6604193449020386,
0.22389058768749237,
0.27379733324050903,
0.1551540642976761,
0.5851815342903137,
-0.6474196910858154,
0.27134227752685547,
-0.05212922394275665,
-0.6364278197288513,
-0.27291983366012573,
-0.4931611716747284,
0.5863499045372009,
0.9083601236343384,
-0.06909056752920151,
0.16008207201957703,
0.3632422089576721,
0.45120829343795776,
-0.6017805933952332,
0.534092366695404,
-0.6992576122283936,
0.2670803368091583,
-0.3426991105079651,
-0.6966123580932617,
-0.5359819531440735,
-0.15035709738731384,
-0.22440114617347717,
-0.8121033310890198,
0.024954194203019142,
0.21701684594154358,
0.8707722425460815,
0.48786255717277527,
-0.3902367949485779,
-0.40691447257995605,
-0.4449327886104584,
0.7513870596885681,
-0.5901963710784912,
0.10998722165822983,
0.1506691873073578,
0.32651880383491516,
-0.4839894771575928,
-0.9457668662071228,
-0.5585553050041199,
0.0030140429735183716,
-0.13070467114448547,
-0.17025519907474518,
-0.42676034569740295,
-0.12633875012397766,
0.04371888190507889,
0.6931349635124207,
-0.5549330711364746,
0.4549912214279175,
-0.4520398676395416,
-0.24984431266784668,
0.45264118909835815,
0.3036969304084778,
0.44570302963256836,
-0.24150905013084412,
0.0032670386135578156,
-0.1292719691991806,
-0.7982349991798401,
0.1290358304977417,
0.3283923864364624,
0.5463147759437561,
-0.07806257903575897,
0.35034212470054626,
-0.23433701694011688,
0.7615779042243958,
-0.16020315885543823,
-0.06145557761192322,
0.1930912733078003,
0.22961536049842834,
-0.5834047198295593,
0.29981595277786255,
0.7702179551124573,
0.09639929980039597,
-0.07930967956781387,
-0.4293850362300873,
-0.11870091408491135,
0.24232491850852966,
0.7019373774528503,
-1.0985403060913086,
-0.08900555223226547,
0.3663010597229004,
-0.12423643469810486,
-0.6610144972801208,
0.011342890560626984,
-0.7232925295829773,
-0.35054811835289,
-0.37282654643058777,
-0.10083914548158646,
-0.33249330520629883,
-0.08505378663539886,
0.21870751678943634,
0.35348978638648987,
0.07399608939886093,
-0.053607355803251266,
-0.9890091419219971,
0.3655306100845337,
1.0904864072799683,
0.6881589889526367,
-0.3240746557712555,
-0.3445737063884735,
-1.0430995225906372,
0.05730105936527252,
-0.5776982307434082,
0.3157339096069336,
-0.4027295410633087,
-0.5326014161109924,
0.14653317630290985,
0.28608429431915283,
0.11576520651578903,
-0.5526549816131592,
0.5533644556999207,
-0.6131333708763123,
0.09839466959238052,
0.008893443271517754,
-0.42850571870803833,
-0.35221514105796814,
0.1505381166934967,
-0.7854925990104675,
0.8124924898147583,
0.2494046837091446,
-0.7334221601486206,
0.2630656659603119,
-1.0123014450073242,
-0.8386307954788208,
0.6117568612098694,
-0.10644781589508057,
-0.46428999304771423,
-0.11581289768218994,
0.09912370145320892,
0.5129134654998779,
-0.4796660244464874,
0.351014107465744,
-0.1275482475757599,
-0.21524640917778015,
0.35814419388771057,
-0.057910364121198654,
1.1684387922286987,
0.5600425004959106,
-0.6861894130706787,
0.26925379037857056,
-0.4230681359767914,
0.05004184693098068,
0.1287255436182022,
-0.1881340891122818,
-0.3167164921760559,
-0.1723712980747223,
0.11929365247488022,
-0.0888235941529274,
0.04182080179452896,
-0.24460048973560333,
0.3709258735179901,
-0.5106080174446106,
0.6623278856277466,
0.4373725652694702,
-0.3124159872531891,
0.5563167333602905,
-0.19162821769714355,
0.9084174633026123,
-0.21019025146961212,
0.19754448533058167,
-0.3762359917163849,
-0.39244237542152405,
-0.7493147253990173,
-0.4096184968948364,
0.4282914102077484,
0.46154746413230896,
-1.1134470701217651,
0.19415734708309174,
-0.49515944719314575,
-0.5746987462043762,
-0.6392834186553955,
0.5626350045204163,
0.2926626205444336,
0.5440712571144104,
0.26645204424858093,
-0.44961416721343994,
-0.5938300490379333,
-0.6737757921218872,
0.009261731058359146,
-0.0243045836687088,
0.06266392022371292,
0.2484264075756073,
0.43268388509750366,
-0.7710513472557068,
0.5333496928215027,
-0.3550642132759094,
-0.19041521847248077,
-0.11252057552337646,
0.27406156063079834,
0.08359232544898987,
0.32184895873069763,
0.5290477275848389,
-0.9879193902015686,
-0.17814834415912628,
0.3858121931552887,
-0.7821969389915466,
-0.25796493887901306,
-0.10791002213954926,
-0.4565518796443939,
0.32232666015625,
0.3755567967891693,
-0.31131839752197266,
-0.11149314790964127,
0.8132059574127197,
-0.2857266366481781,
0.4975084960460663,
-0.09772377461194992,
0.19471018016338348,
-1.0935686826705933,
0.4100624620914459,
-0.33837515115737915,
-0.09189007431268692,
-0.3055814504623413,
0.8441934585571289,
0.05872590094804764,
-0.19292673468589783,
-0.388212651014328,
0.5212709307670593,
-0.41694754362106323,
-0.0532195121049881,
-0.21537397801876068,
-0.18432290852069855,
0.10867562144994736,
0.41522809863090515,
-0.05315050482749939,
0.3589947819709778,
1.043515920639038,
-0.7762320637702942,
0.7718068361282349,
0.21182787418365479,
-0.277873694896698,
0.4596298336982727,
-0.39998820424079895,
0.018793033435940742,
0.22283218801021576,
0.11632049828767776,
-0.3126744329929352,
-0.4966263771057129,
0.23743276298046112,
-0.2328415960073471,
0.35398373007774353,
-0.16095173358917236,
-0.6598528027534485,
-0.37136733531951904,
-0.0021543533075600863,
0.43155163526535034,
0.4215257167816162,
-0.5860281586647034,
0.36346694827079773,
0.5189330577850342,
-0.3584159314632416,
-0.6112563014030457,
-0.7356515526771545,
0.5542075037956238,
-0.2596428394317627,
-0.38818100094795227,
0.6146270036697388,
-0.034199927002191544,
-0.060719192028045654,
-0.023999078199267387,
0.09355160593986511,
-0.05549094080924988,
0.29899388551712036,
0.48775196075439453,
0.4447992146015167,
-0.21472427248954773,
0.10943920910358429,
0.3590146005153656,
0.006313060875982046,
0.07784679532051086,
-0.7721919417381287,
0.4031037986278534,
-0.3037659227848053,
-0.1534501165151596,
-0.07873564958572388,
0.015290943905711174,
0.6628662347793579,
-0.4899600148200989,
0.26670774817466736,
0.560579240322113,
-0.38222408294677734,
-0.7830498814582825,
0.05408186838030815,
0.06402922421693802,
-0.509211003780365,
0.31183579564094543,
-0.3081206977367401,
-0.9308474659919739,
0.2753068804740906,
-0.10469364374876022,
0.3109188973903656,
0.24977640807628632,
0.7865742444992065,
0.26158109307289124,
0.4357563555240631,
0.7516582012176514,
0.094265878200531,
0.13861803710460663,
-0.4376503825187683,
0.22302670776844025,
-0.34900832176208496,
-0.3073330819606781,
-0.27494755387306213,
-0.3728729784488678,
-0.6040857434272766,
-0.5579462051391602,
0.2967272698879242,
-0.1851719617843628,
0.10622577369213104,
0.5649566054344177,
-0.7039123177528381,
0.32641395926475525,
0.3295597434043884,
-0.2862500846385956,
0.09856515377759933,
0.04070235416293144,
-0.2564888000488281,
0.07034669816493988,
-0.9157832264900208,
-0.4389924108982086,
1.0228257179260254,
0.2655106484889984,
0.496722549200058,
0.07615252584218979,
0.7112905383110046,
0.4343230128288269,
0.3802717924118042,
-0.9508733153343201,
0.44536954164505005,
-0.32423749566078186,
-0.28951576352119446,
-0.2794412672519684,
-0.6738219857215881,
-1.263973355293274,
-0.03341568261384964,
-0.24993805587291718,
-0.15786093473434448,
-0.06821608543395996,
0.244357630610466,
-0.3581296503543854,
0.3635396957397461,
-0.4858854413032532,
1.1837109327316284,
-0.5877406001091003,
-0.5036619901657104,
-0.2437896728515625,
-0.2770511507987976,
0.31870269775390625,
-0.29783350229263306,
0.5000808835029602,
0.28245821595191956,
-0.09631487727165222,
0.5345562696456909,
-0.46446219086647034,
0.812366783618927,
-0.01957005262374878,
-0.5201905369758606,
0.3531969487667084,
0.5828314423561096,
0.09650257229804993,
0.21383227407932281,
0.007489683106541634,
0.13221554458141327,
0.05236152932047844,
-0.6438291668891907,
-0.5270978212356567,
0.8952370285987854,
-0.3472304344177246,
-0.06680037826299667,
-0.08669265359640121,
-0.7776350378990173,
-0.17100022733211517,
0.2515351474285126,
0.15845507383346558,
0.5963253974914551,
-0.2893923223018646,
0.11770805716514587,
0.5291494727134705,
-0.44300076365470886,
0.21904787421226501,
0.2618165612220764,
-0.3993191719055176,
-0.21891595423221588,
1.0864259004592896,
-0.24486598372459412,
-0.020608210936188698,
0.5978177785873413,
-0.2031768411397934,
0.017889684066176414,
-0.31410107016563416,
-0.7110019326210022,
-0.2130250781774521,
-0.6771449446678162,
-0.4394807815551758,
-0.4561144709587097,
0.22200867533683777,
-0.42557308077812195,
-0.3792373538017273,
-0.3475230038166046,
-0.32539045810699463,
-0.11611295491456985,
-0.0605694055557251,
0.1553807407617569,
0.5328245162963867,
0.1603722870349884,
0.05529657378792763,
-0.602717399597168,
0.4193282127380371,
0.39507707953453064,
0.22484344244003296,
-0.23430627584457397,
-0.18150965869426727,
-0.49178746342658997,
0.1702978014945984,
-0.21424247324466705,
-0.469605028629303,
0.8315984010696411,
0.21588343381881714,
0.40405410528182983,
0.4084340035915375,
0.30933678150177,
0.4089082181453705,
-0.38545286655426025,
0.5515453815460205,
0.23069144785404205,
-0.78251713514328,
0.44084635376930237,
-0.031163465231657028,
0.3389052748680115,
0.14252538979053497,
0.3563745617866516,
-0.560950517654419,
-0.60671067237854,
-0.4754222333431244,
-0.9670163989067078,
0.35460615158081055,
0.23710744082927704,
0.2078126221895218,
0.041074056178331375,
0.0575210377573967,
0.5064305663108826,
0.20631279051303864,
-0.4387611448764801,
-0.054695528000593185,
-0.4800582528114319,
-0.22450751066207886,
-0.28077080845832825,
0.1119469553232193,
-0.31910568475723267,
-0.12113910168409348,
0.5988988876342773,
-0.6102110147476196,
0.2894931137561798,
-0.2956133186817169,
-0.42017799615859985,
-0.06384296715259552,
0.37267550826072693,
0.4236403703689575,
0.3325737416744232,
0.2655984163284302,
0.17595608532428741,
0.04213649407029152,
-0.35563626885414124,
-0.3453366756439209,
0.2630196213722229,
-0.20326077938079834,
0.13339602947235107,
0.3825097978115082,
0.961442768573761,
0.5405921339988708,
-0.8935929536819458,
0.19069314002990723,
-0.047421231865882874,
-0.23128950595855713,
-0.25418996810913086,
0.32672032713890076,
0.1249045878648758,
0.01678481698036194,
0.4212993085384369,
0.13728207349777222,
0.27594470977783203,
-0.7432414889335632,
0.09507373720407486,
0.2911122441291809,
-0.137802392244339,
-0.259024977684021,
0.8492876887321472,
0.4644550383090973,
-0.23463128507137299,
0.3437589704990387,
-0.5053479075431824,
-0.6094911098480225,
0.6524525284767151,
0.3299870789051056,
0.9387942552566528,
0.04337722808122635,
0.436750203371048,
0.25965404510498047,
0.10923813283443451,
0.241360142827034,
-0.05668627470731735,
-0.37332308292388916,
-0.43564558029174805,
-0.5611822009086609,
-1.0738630294799805,
-0.3891128897666931,
-0.18980105221271515,
-0.6513625979423523,
0.42586517333984375,
-0.3670419752597809,
0.0847473219037056,
0.14849966764450073,
-0.13463018834590912,
-0.5324681997299194,
0.14388355612754822,
0.5625647306442261,
0.8107166290283203,
-0.640666663646698,
0.9921417236328125,
0.8653391599655151,
-0.16032490134239197,
-0.668109655380249,
-0.26014649868011475,
0.0020605369936674833,
-0.6142621636390686,
0.7527136206626892,
0.11664050072431564,
-0.23680971562862396,
-0.004654568620026112,
-0.6077449321746826,
-0.21453611552715302,
1.0096068382263184,
0.7661795020103455,
-0.4415774345397949,
-0.14767058193683624,
0.3585905432701111,
0.5207367539405823,
-0.602475643157959,
-0.16999101638793945,
0.3611702024936676,
0.3409160077571869,
0.1597554087638855,
-1.0927882194519043,
0.01104606594890356,
-0.6306208372116089,
-0.1049959734082222,
0.15909698605537415,
-0.3226817548274994,
0.5489854216575623,
-0.31304433941841125,
-0.24596142768859863,
-0.09649591892957687,
0.5619240403175354,
0.02035103179514408,
0.18527477979660034,
0.3673333525657654,
0.36961090564727783,
1.0068880319595337,
-0.13746754825115204,
1.1525189876556396,
-0.5634150505065918,
0.13187432289123535,
0.8242809772491455,
-0.005085095297545195,
0.6512543559074402,
0.512549877166748,
0.06380204856395721,
0.8206408023834229,
0.5000476837158203,
-0.11626755446195602,
0.2533544898033142,
0.2921329140663147,
-0.13235415518283844,
-0.1400061845779419,
-0.04054401442408562,
-0.1902361959218979,
0.5001057982444763,
0.4019697606563568,
-0.22262264788150787,
0.05954182893037796,
0.26442477107048035,
0.14719240367412567,
0.1259983628988266,
-0.4853312373161316,
0.4042889177799225,
0.19523048400878906,
-0.9910548329353333,
1.089603066444397,
0.26669785380363464,
0.8851036429405212,
-0.5410354137420654,
-0.03248576074838638,
-0.2026546150445938,
0.14975452423095703,
-0.5289269089698792,
-0.44901639223098755,
0.45306476950645447,
0.16630813479423523,
0.1971040964126587,
-0.6345580816268921,
0.4754960536956787,
-0.3756454586982727,
-0.37552228569984436,
0.2070724368095398,
0.07650662958621979,
0.09502673149108887,
0.27674561738967896,
-0.6555670499801636,
0.09093177318572998,
0.08378015458583832,
0.13222311437129974,
0.15183112025260925,
0.747786819934845,
0.07302124798297882,
0.8262283802032471,
0.6077979207038879,
0.15977749228477478,
0.2170320749282837,
-0.1698547899723053,
0.7791661620140076,
-0.25357502698898315,
-0.8827059268951416,
-0.4413674473762512,
0.5268322229385376,
0.1382373422384262,
-0.2570140063762665,
0.5552481412887573,
0.6671187877655029,
1.0103340148925781,
-0.2383688986301422,
0.7446277141571045,
-0.3629887104034424,
0.07972094416618347,
-0.5516929626464844,
0.773066520690918,
-0.5948923826217651,
0.3919011950492859,
-0.1229955181479454,
-0.7182489633560181,
-0.377160906791687,
0.36326727271080017,
-0.08543404191732407,
-0.4456734359264374,
0.668656051158905,
0.8380032777786255,
-0.27134934067726135,
-0.023190943524241447,
0.2325008362531662,
0.25640279054641724,
0.11804845184087753,
0.6548318266868591,
0.3077225387096405,
-0.21318350732326508,
0.7880229353904724,
-0.3510585427284241,
-0.15364974737167358,
-0.3984706997871399,
-0.8321468830108643,
-0.6163585782051086,
-0.6584561467170715,
-0.7103385925292969,
-0.28961557149887085,
0.028416680172085762,
0.6746935844421387,
0.646297812461853,
-0.9179098010063171,
-0.5545121431350708,
-0.27055829763412476,
-0.07865338027477264,
-0.47985896468162537,
-0.23392793536186218,
0.033382266759872437,
-0.6374474763870239,
-0.9711821675300598,
0.3187645673751831,
0.28297773003578186,
-0.31579986214637756,
-0.48637765645980835,
-0.5989528894424438,
0.4778709411621094,
-0.2575535774230957,
0.8128706812858582,
0.6728659868240356,
-0.47283935546875,
0.3564163148403168,
0.17917534708976746,
-0.28797271847724915,
-0.18625910580158234,
0.8350975513458252,
-0.8490130305290222,
0.6127741932868958,
0.11810319125652313,
0.9476492404937744,
0.4644964933395386,
-0.6313565373420715,
0.6634876132011414,
-0.6701664924621582,
0.35217127203941345,
0.35969826579093933,
0.37016913294792175,
0.5365186929702759,
-0.3047848045825958,
0.5330928564071655,
0.09828692674636841,
-0.27900436520576477,
-1.1322100162506104,
0.2418968379497528,
-1.1099852323532104,
-0.5240293145179749,
1.1695597171783447,
-0.1661687046289444,
-0.2892972230911255,
0.1361750066280365,
-0.194412499666214,
0.2867918014526367,
0.044868599623441696,
0.9044181108474731,
0.4124460220336914,
0.17219020426273346,
0.05171351507306099,
-0.7508203387260437,
0.5228373408317566,
0.5108745098114014,
-0.812712550163269,
0.10028748959302902,
0.5543727874755859,
0.05339394882321358,
0.23853635787963867,
0.04959046468138695,
-0.10881873965263367,
0.4431498050689697,
-0.01135663129389286,
0.26768919825553894,
-0.31690865755081177,
-0.1757117509841919,
-0.15046942234039307,
0.3968190848827362,
0.166102334856987,
0.02051076479256153
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11558v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11558v1
|
Reinforcement Learning with Token-level Feedback for Controllable Text Generation
| 2024-03-18T08:18:37 | 2024-03-18T08:18:37 |
Wendi Li, Wei Wei, Kaihe Xu, Wenfeng Xie, Dangyang Chen, Yu Cheng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
To meet the requirements of real-world applications, it is essential to
control generations of large language models (LLMs). Prior research has tried
to introduce reinforcement learning (RL) into controllable text generation
while most existing methods suffer from overfitting issues (finetuning-based
methods) or semantic collapse (post-processing methods). However, current RL
methods are generally guided by coarse-grained (sentence/paragraph-level)
feedback, which may lead to suboptimal performance owing to semantic twists or
progressions within sentences. To tackle that, we propose a novel reinforcement
learning algorithm named TOLE which formulates TOken-LEvel rewards for
controllable text generation, and employs a "first-quantize-then-noise"
paradigm to enhance the robustness of the RL algorithm.Furthermore, TOLE can be
flexibly extended to multiple constraints with little computational expense.
Experimental results show that our algorithm can achieve superior performance
on both single-attribute and multi-attribute control tasks. We have released
our codes at https://github.com/WindyLee0822/CTG
|
[
-0.039164185523986816,
-0.9264395833015442,
0.2187671959400177,
0.6406731605529785,
-0.27869799733161926,
0.27524933218955994,
-0.4264855682849884,
-0.22280697524547577,
-0.040382012724876404,
0.3492274284362793,
-0.8353226780891418,
-0.7805551886558533,
-0.6701886653900146,
0.01144854724407196,
-0.39846596121788025,
1.2632914781570435,
-0.03724667802453041,
-0.3249281048774719,
-0.07991065084934235,
0.02934311144053936,
-0.44765859842300415,
-0.526849627494812,
-1.1220786571502686,
-0.2459644228219986,
0.8995064496994019,
0.477057546377182,
0.26825472712516785,
0.5511638522148132,
0.015009584836661816,
0.29518789052963257,
-0.21973225474357605,
0.3691093921661377,
-0.5996368527412415,
0.19235487282276154,
-0.2704123258590698,
-0.2608022391796112,
-0.26251664757728577,
-0.10541550815105438,
0.7770699858665466,
0.221884623169899,
-0.25275522470474243,
-0.12951552867889404,
0.14125275611877441,
0.48596641421318054,
-0.5166119933128357,
0.3148448169231415,
-0.3932553231716156,
0.2765408158302307,
-0.12160655111074448,
-0.5201936960220337,
-0.8447967767715454,
-0.469830721616745,
-0.2637428045272827,
-0.7084231972694397,
-0.19905978441238403,
0.2597425878047943,
0.7107592821121216,
0.34138035774230957,
-0.32314231991767883,
-0.35838446021080017,
-0.6503442525863647,
0.9672970771789551,
-0.6908702254295349,
0.2882594168186188,
0.2537309229373932,
-0.04620867222547531,
-0.3605041205883026,
-0.6883527636528015,
-0.4194198250770569,
-0.6825500726699829,
-0.09528046101331711,
0.23393231630325317,
0.03674955666065216,
0.08784062415361404,
0.18897247314453125,
0.1028161570429802,
-0.3437109589576721,
0.4869703948497772,
-0.12408997863531113,
-0.22778774797916412,
0.5244523286819458,
0.016520580276846886,
0.06548286974430084,
-0.10663608461618423,
-0.6837568283081055,
-0.2833902835845947,
-0.46726956963539124,
0.4600095748901367,
0.2803562581539154,
0.40319520235061646,
0.014249281957745552,
0.4926222860813141,
-0.2930041551589966,
0.36561790108680725,
0.4226130545139313,
-0.22925862669944763,
0.09980398416519165,
-0.23601925373077393,
0.05051003396511078,
0.22055241465568542,
0.8665468692779541,
0.0023744862992316484,
0.03685631975531578,
-0.3661275804042816,
-0.5576959252357483,
-0.015689605847001076,
0.14054909348487854,
-0.8129347562789917,
0.04354952648282051,
0.19393859803676605,
-0.38709017634391785,
-0.8198291063308716,
-0.030727025121450424,
-0.6430469751358032,
-0.3465062379837036,
-0.135279580950737,
0.5628530383110046,
-0.5405699014663696,
-0.2530973255634308,
-0.11135260760784149,
0.07631685584783554,
0.03686346486210823,
0.12777036428451538,
-0.9210829734802246,
0.37122610211372375,
0.6272757053375244,
0.7462093830108643,
-0.46428555250167847,
-0.4468749761581421,
-1.0874282121658325,
0.2986948788166046,
-0.47414299845695496,
0.6408049464225769,
-0.32432085275650024,
-0.46228671073913574,
0.21053439378738403,
-0.352538526058197,
0.19001345336437225,
-0.5054959654808044,
0.22607377171516418,
-0.4410562515258789,
0.3704614043235779,
0.1659870743751526,
-0.5546292066574097,
0.3666369915008545,
0.2987706661224365,
-0.6228622198104858,
1.1477842330932617,
0.1777716726064682,
-0.5636752843856812,
0.6977059841156006,
-0.637463390827179,
-0.7509409785270691,
0.030135169625282288,
-0.21027213335037231,
-0.8357216715812683,
0.16180920600891113,
0.20396655797958374,
0.2581268548965454,
0.06223548948764801,
0.3461463451385498,
0.032337792217731476,
-0.1441403180360794,
0.3896254897117615,
-0.5659427046775818,
0.2919817864894867,
0.05222076177597046,
-0.36969271302223206,
0.7101925015449524,
-0.975956916809082,
0.19152705371379852,
-0.03790523111820221,
-0.6778936982154846,
-0.028047138825058937,
0.059719715267419815,
0.1755826473236084,
0.2918812334537506,
0.33964091539382935,
-0.46099862456321716,
0.2920738160610199,
-0.2670791745185852,
0.45203897356987,
0.9021188616752625,
0.0796804279088974,
0.5787352323532104,
-0.47428685426712036,
0.5771998167037964,
0.14617791771888733,
0.19826668500900269,
-0.12180344760417938,
0.05317258462309837,
-0.767548680305481,
-0.36673057079315186,
0.5045950412750244,
0.41588956117630005,
-0.9135780930519104,
0.5816162824630737,
-0.05582236498594284,
-0.20006532967090607,
-0.060369692742824554,
0.07323690503835678,
0.6516208052635193,
0.18786107003688812,
0.3093269169330597,
-0.15052415430545807,
-0.1428150236606598,
-0.38060930371284485,
-0.1483212560415268,
-0.20250694453716278,
-0.05299273133277893,
0.21603387594223022,
0.3093790113925934,
0.13246563076972961,
0.8401877284049988,
-0.31407198309898376,
-0.4692367911338806,
-0.4530559778213501,
0.4269425868988037,
-0.416289359331131,
0.6321437358856201,
0.1623680293560028,
-0.5617658495903015,
-0.12888340651988983,
-0.009650598280131817,
-0.23047609627246857,
-0.3407614827156067,
-0.49626076221466064,
-0.09902286529541016,
0.37775298953056335,
0.8519814014434814,
-0.3339197635650635,
0.38721534609794617,
0.67093825340271,
-0.6297787427902222,
0.5361631512641907,
-0.3607410192489624,
-0.22236935794353485,
-1.0686599016189575,
-0.022491727024316788,
-0.06093853339552879,
-0.5601507425308228,
-0.34243693947792053,
-0.1630857139825821,
0.03054635226726532,
-0.061327531933784485,
-0.39181414246559143,
0.5989746451377869,
-0.02183900587260723,
0.21314319968223572,
-0.383860319852829,
0.05721603333950043,
-0.09099353849887848,
0.8855282664299011,
0.037293728440999985,
0.8841769695281982,
0.1637229472398758,
-0.7761783003807068,
0.2128884345293045,
0.1608784943819046,
-0.2510049641132355,
0.5558176636695862,
-0.47595542669296265,
-0.16429246962070465,
-0.06638941168785095,
0.3274020850658417,
-0.6905581951141357,
-0.04106873273849487,
0.13036863505840302,
-0.6092780232429504,
0.4294906258583069,
0.26012325286865234,
-0.539608359336853,
-0.020599521696567535,
-0.24030117690563202,
0.4374959170818329,
0.3744506537914276,
-0.6395313739776611,
0.5142960548400879,
0.16999025642871857,
-0.2926188111305237,
-0.3929068148136139,
-0.5378601551055908,
-0.03453546017408371,
-0.10847930610179901,
0.003606546437367797,
0.3938232362270355,
-0.01696423813700676,
0.1981133371591568,
-0.017534704878926277,
-0.12407306581735611,
-0.08173926174640656,
0.11484191566705704,
0.17310456931591034,
0.04571007937192917,
0.2775683104991913,
0.54301518201828,
0.24473834037780762,
-0.4255662262439728,
0.0748203694820404,
-0.6992956399917603,
0.5656192898750305,
-0.01466772798448801,
0.023154059424996376,
-0.4025685489177704,
0.20171265304088593,
0.22927486896514893,
-0.40801531076431274,
0.6236939430236816,
0.5006216168403625,
0.005526822526007891,
-0.9062176942825317,
-0.029442042112350464,
-0.18016037344932556,
-0.5163954496383667,
0.6951379179954529,
-0.28077396750450134,
-1.1918443441390991,
0.273796021938324,
-0.4778558611869812,
0.11532129347324371,
0.26188167929649353,
0.48537009954452515,
-0.01176353171467781,
0.9709292054176331,
0.7308355569839478,
-0.046363696455955505,
0.9083721041679382,
-0.0675383135676384,
0.003578820964321494,
-0.31307291984558105,
-0.47210970520973206,
-0.3905726373195648,
-0.360507607460022,
-0.786395251750946,
-0.25051406025886536,
0.1919640600681305,
0.41850537061691284,
-0.4468240737915039,
0.06674891710281372,
-0.3970717489719391,
0.3853980004787445,
0.758539617061615,
0.306525319814682,
0.35043779015541077,
-0.07653825730085373,
-0.32722896337509155,
0.24903146922588348,
-1.0410760641098022,
-0.08490012586116791,
0.6956278085708618,
0.28429439663887024,
0.8837847113609314,
-0.0366968959569931,
0.9007956981658936,
0.3711439073085785,
0.22602051496505737,
-0.7347527146339417,
0.5594009757041931,
-0.32041263580322266,
-0.008805666118860245,
-0.6720312833786011,
-0.660649299621582,
-0.9313339591026306,
-0.0826207846403122,
-0.37112757563591003,
-0.6373605728149414,
-0.20493273437023163,
0.2972620129585266,
-0.20237408578395844,
0.13228920102119446,
-0.24189046025276184,
0.687125563621521,
-0.31237393617630005,
-0.5459803342819214,
-0.3711398243904114,
-0.40377187728881836,
0.16042070090770721,
0.06457141786813736,
0.17734065651893616,
0.1565975844860077,
-0.12159957736730576,
0.7172432541847229,
-0.5732872486114502,
0.8492525219917297,
-0.14538675546646118,
-0.40515971183776855,
0.18696270883083344,
0.12522883713245392,
0.852671205997467,
0.2389971762895584,
0.23629727959632874,
-0.23340992629528046,
-0.127505823969841,
-0.47487401962280273,
-0.5680134892463684,
0.674996018409729,
-0.6678076386451721,
-0.22565993666648865,
-0.38154134154319763,
-0.5685626268386841,
-0.21818098425865173,
0.2596600353717804,
0.3756434917449951,
0.5064926743507385,
-0.06992555409669876,
0.04114986211061478,
0.8716230392456055,
-0.5475291013717651,
0.5071806311607361,
0.15056119859218597,
-0.6299242973327637,
-0.7732513546943665,
1.3447331190109253,
-0.17162702977657318,
0.3730374276638031,
0.6118607521057129,
0.3566890060901642,
-0.4495597183704376,
-0.4352118670940399,
-0.2584807276725769,
-0.08442414551973343,
-0.32573845982551575,
-0.25064077973365784,
-0.22503843903541565,
-0.3862420916557312,
-0.05644845589995384,
-0.14724767208099365,
-0.33832523226737976,
-0.5283253192901611,
-0.19733838737010956,
-0.1521134078502655,
0.3621455729007721,
0.7488216161727905,
-0.0744936615228653,
0.5632805824279785,
-0.6143784523010254,
0.26542097330093384,
0.3254249691963196,
0.7375878691673279,
-0.03648388758301735,
-0.30518779158592224,
-0.3752613365650177,
-0.3525002896785736,
-0.36838042736053467,
-0.5959761738777161,
0.2204096019268036,
0.19789443910121918,
0.14584237337112427,
0.2592836022377014,
0.19028621912002563,
0.3834483325481415,
-0.41900864243507385,
0.5620888471603394,
0.39614737033843994,
-0.9997349381446838,
0.48469215631484985,
-0.3074040412902832,
0.49002400040626526,
0.3967854678630829,
-0.20851896703243256,
-0.6073569059371948,
-0.8069378733634949,
-0.5405254364013672,
-0.9183499217033386,
0.7119637131690979,
0.1827775090932846,
0.04650312289595604,
-0.10071829706430435,
0.275176465511322,
0.042753126472234726,
0.470842570066452,
-1.0066258907318115,
0.0637674480676651,
-0.21408668160438538,
-0.31838691234588623,
0.025936366990208626,
-0.19384759664535522,
0.01879945583641529,
0.05289340391755104,
0.6057425141334534,
-0.19458715617656708,
0.24528934061527252,
0.009699744172394276,
-0.1345394402742386,
-0.11881302297115326,
0.4543823301792145,
0.8052745461463928,
0.11758100241422653,
0.17526808381080627,
-0.007720605004578829,
0.16841384768486023,
-0.24991165101528168,
0.13436877727508545,
-0.013083097524940968,
-0.3722933232784271,
-0.20482103526592255,
0.2984721064567566,
0.9971650242805481,
0.2693153917789459,
-0.5988226532936096,
0.5959527492523193,
-0.06485443562269211,
-0.5844625234603882,
-0.2708171010017395,
0.05383972451090813,
-0.3467917740345001,
0.4233884811401367,
0.20271717011928558,
-0.15960070490837097,
-0.2961115837097168,
-0.2852579653263092,
0.3278312087059021,
0.42439740896224976,
-0.5406637191772461,
-0.04227058216929436,
0.8119768500328064,
0.3238411843776703,
-0.3064247667789459,
0.4851599633693695,
-0.3794972598552704,
-0.5698469281196594,
0.4443379044532776,
0.7177660465240479,
0.8452601432800293,
0.1553426831960678,
0.4879664182662964,
0.22544530034065247,
0.16840513050556183,
-0.04435332864522934,
0.3620373606681824,
-0.15222181379795074,
-0.3977980315685272,
-0.8499417901039124,
-0.679275393486023,
-0.3242952525615692,
0.17600761353969574,
-0.45546114444732666,
0.12690266966819763,
-0.8646038770675659,
-0.09034014493227005,
-0.4123641550540924,
0.004936900455504656,
-0.14429253339767456,
0.33270564675331116,
0.14298366010189056,
0.9469982385635376,
-0.5161004066467285,
0.8497210741043091,
0.3254846930503845,
-0.4625203311443329,
-0.8394336700439453,
0.11546709388494492,
-0.39992639422416687,
-0.3881031572818756,
0.8020927906036377,
0.12340604513883591,
-0.15155912935733795,
0.33612409234046936,
-0.6505370140075684,
-0.6024273633956909,
0.9155014157295227,
-0.10063307732343674,
-0.527786135673523,
-0.18267884850502014,
0.27381691336631775,
0.45196253061294556,
-0.09862827509641647,
-0.034536633640527725,
0.3437548875808716,
0.5150485038757324,
0.07540653645992279,
-0.7727771997451782,
0.01029068324714899,
0.0263482928276062,
0.20543356239795685,
0.5013025403022766,
-0.9402801990509033,
0.5414029359817505,
-0.05238409712910652,
-0.20560234785079956,
0.25244244933128357,
1.0427359342575073,
0.48094433546066284,
0.20198863744735718,
0.5878145694732666,
0.571562647819519,
0.8201192617416382,
-0.13203352689743042,
0.8962736129760742,
-0.3634600341320038,
0.29088813066482544,
1.119767189025879,
0.03733084723353386,
0.9017438292503357,
0.4854762852191925,
0.058588214218616486,
0.516074001789093,
0.4630201756954193,
0.1251876950263977,
0.7224517464637756,
0.601291835308075,
-0.38387638330459595,
-0.1976357400417328,
-0.28072404861450195,
0.1671377420425415,
0.07372813671827316,
0.21033911406993866,
-0.06661412119865417,
-0.1853082776069641,
0.3246814012527466,
-0.027791805565357208,
0.31844618916511536,
-0.5677085518836975,
1.0610154867172241,
-0.12172190099954605,
-0.5403928160667419,
0.35223495960235596,
0.11068560183048248,
0.8633704781532288,
-0.758815348148346,
-0.08750172704458237,
-0.23523563146591187,
0.309917151927948,
-0.09370798617601395,
-0.5054536461830139,
-0.017518244683742523,
-0.09613662213087082,
-0.11557134240865707,
-0.5189820528030396,
0.6079620718955994,
-0.7448825240135193,
-0.3399924337863922,
0.07984417676925659,
0.11342966556549072,
-0.40391355752944946,
0.25626832246780396,
-0.35898709297180176,
-0.06405019015073776,
-0.11597859114408493,
-0.36155304312705994,
0.4940376579761505,
0.5836794972419739,
-0.3197381794452667,
0.7614880800247192,
0.5475623607635498,
0.26674750447273254,
0.32638272643089294,
-0.13860085606575012,
0.8557148575782776,
-0.6410442590713501,
-0.822645902633667,
-0.6291263103485107,
0.4462478458881378,
-0.017193641513586044,
-0.5270804762840271,
0.35703814029693604,
0.49779316782951355,
1.0750157833099365,
0.15417498350143433,
0.9019997119903564,
-0.05435715615749359,
0.3810681104660034,
-0.8615143299102783,
0.5563840270042419,
-0.4786534011363983,
0.10119472444057465,
0.07124269008636475,
-0.7269162535667419,
-0.40291669964790344,
0.5574604272842407,
0.11624486744403839,
0.10166876018047333,
0.9059861898422241,
0.6518083810806274,
0.394455224275589,
-0.3437570333480835,
0.3024429380893707,
0.1641739457845688,
0.5036414265632629,
0.6333308219909668,
0.9352018237113953,
-0.0576518252491951,
0.7265187501907349,
-0.18196749687194824,
-0.2042887657880783,
-0.034852851182222366,
-1.0080498456954956,
-0.7435258030891418,
-0.3972052335739136,
-0.3693334758281708,
-0.7205671668052673,
0.2695140540599823,
1.111656904220581,
0.5304994583129883,
-0.7518691420555115,
-0.17114652693271637,
-0.5331745743751526,
0.07409291714429855,
-0.3997982442378998,
-0.20053978264331818,
0.3193824887275696,
-0.9300891160964966,
-0.7550275921821594,
0.32073432207107544,
0.29216232895851135,
0.02171185240149498,
-0.2734270989894867,
-0.45249655842781067,
0.14647401869297028,
0.22290010750293732,
0.6983184218406677,
0.4446178078651428,
-0.44337812066078186,
-0.18556436896324158,
-0.234498530626297,
-0.39586034417152405,
-0.03920891880989075,
1.0517481565475464,
-0.8460588455200195,
0.06124841421842575,
0.38903284072875977,
0.6511456370353699,
0.5388174653053284,
0.08900443464517593,
0.5095658898353577,
-1.2626641988754272,
0.2647649347782135,
0.20409159362316132,
-0.17812514305114746,
-0.14861321449279785,
-0.2263718843460083,
0.07996569573879242,
-0.050567228347063065,
-0.6199166774749756,
-0.5203983187675476,
0.3816991150379181,
-0.9677622318267822,
-0.457661896944046,
1.2149040699005127,
0.02464783750474453,
-0.19310636818408966,
0.4171333312988281,
-0.3994119167327881,
0.5361093282699585,
-0.7348346710205078,
0.8859713077545166,
0.5560669302940369,
0.0611303485929966,
-0.4725262522697449,
-0.10340576618909836,
0.853356122970581,
0.4805853068828583,
-0.9621583223342896,
0.16460517048835754,
0.5727355480194092,
-0.1319979429244995,
-0.2293204367160797,
0.44260209798812866,
-0.06297596544027328,
0.3077687621116638,
-0.14015859365463257,
0.098731629550457,
-0.27773046493530273,
-0.5935288071632385,
-0.3900189697742462,
0.3185572028160095,
0.4941290020942688,
-0.12790311872959137
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15449v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15449v1
|
Hatred Stems from Ignorance! Distillation of the Persuasion Modes in Countering Conversational Hate Speech
| 2024-03-18T07:20:35 | 2024-03-18T07:20:35 |
Ghadi Alyahya, Abeer Aldayel
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Examining the factors that the counter-speech uses is at the core of
understanding the optimal methods for confronting hate speech online. Various
studies assess the emotional base factor used in counter speech, such as
emotion-empathy, offensiveness, and level of hostility. To better understand
the counter-speech used in conversational interactions, this study distills
persuasion modes into reason, emotion, and credibility and then evaluates their
use in two types of conversation interactions: closed (multi-turn) and open
(single-turn) conversation interactions concerning racism, sexism, and
religion. The evaluation covers the distinct behaviors of human versus
generated counter-speech. We also assess the interplay between the replies'
stance and each mode of persuasion in the counter-speech. Notably, we observe
nuanced differences in the counter-speech persuasion modes for open and closed
interactions -- especially on the topic level -- with a general tendency to use
reason as a persuasion mode to express the counterpoint to hate comments. The
generated counter-speech tends to exhibit an emotional persuasion mode, while
human counters lean towards using reasoning. Furthermore, our study shows that
reason as a persuasion mode tends to obtain more supportive replies than do
other persuasion types. The findings highlight the potential of incorporating
persuasion modes into studies about countering hate speech, as these modes can
serve as an optimal means of explainability and paves the way for the further
adoption of the reply's stance and the role it plays in assessing what
comprises the optimal counter-speech.
|
[
-0.9285968542098999,
-1.0922878980636597,
0.3895318806171417,
-0.03431223705410957,
-0.3688184916973114,
-0.03261656314134598,
-0.2066657692193985,
-0.3127821683883667,
0.387191504240036,
0.32504406571388245,
-0.6239890456199646,
-0.11673539876937866,
-0.6512024998664856,
0.07124363631010056,
-0.32435542345046997,
1.2493984699249268,
0.4580140709877014,
0.20399540662765503,
-0.17060700058937073,
-0.3326816260814667,
-0.15473942458629608,
-0.7722348570823669,
-0.5253153443336487,
-0.3484494686126709,
0.6320722699165344,
0.2935112714767456,
0.5777847170829773,
0.2923780679702759,
0.11072724312543869,
0.3426494300365448,
0.30048006772994995,
-0.3650396466255188,
-0.8306511044502258,
0.4754200577735901,
-0.27455392479896545,
-0.3273252844810486,
-0.1136288195848465,
0.19767090678215027,
-0.030613474547863007,
0.20431242883205414,
0.027646895498037338,
-0.01464602816849947,
-0.03919784352183342,
0.4582884609699249,
-0.513022243976593,
-0.2573580741882324,
-0.9279710054397583,
-0.009316423907876015,
-0.4156322181224823,
-0.05068645998835564,
-0.3386595547199249,
-0.33938857913017273,
0.4368042051792145,
-0.4678376615047455,
0.20802326500415802,
-0.019670847803354263,
0.5462508201599121,
0.17679212987422943,
-0.6488750576972961,
-0.6012149453163147,
-0.8025946021080017,
0.8877587914466858,
-0.580489456653595,
0.40238434076309204,
0.4415466785430908,
0.22864653170108795,
0.13270573318004608,
-0.1693292111158371,
-0.7525882720947266,
-0.2088925838470459,
-0.07123662531375885,
0.3825770318508148,
-0.8328145146369934,
0.26460447907447815,
0.39571917057037354,
0.12678255140781403,
-0.42365995049476624,
-0.060162678360939026,
-0.5964033603668213,
-0.08490337431430817,
0.6241073608398438,
0.002878232393413782,
0.44192180037498474,
-0.19375456869602203,
-0.3324427604675293,
0.11545209586620331,
-0.5858498811721802,
-0.15143200755119324,
0.576980710029602,
0.020489931106567383,
-0.11195611208677292,
0.46098873019218445,
-0.016224313527345657,
0.6532178521156311,
0.1975942850112915,
-0.26418647170066833,
-0.2241014540195465,
-0.022552067413926125,
-0.28895777463912964,
0.3228006362915039,
0.6001072525978088,
0.743136465549469,
0.4984722435474396,
-0.1100740060210228,
0.21757835149765015,
0.5263993144035339,
0.4725405275821686,
-0.7878085374832153,
-0.23305904865264893,
-0.08849266171455383,
-0.3865829408168793,
-0.2880849242210388,
-0.3583950102329254,
-1.3409277200698853,
-0.660586953163147,
-0.19343867897987366,
0.24705740809440613,
-0.2607423961162567,
-0.3492979407310486,
-0.5284463763237,
-0.5302463173866272,
0.0035286471247673035,
0.18686924874782562,
-0.7098520398139954,
0.4930397868156433,
0.4216271936893463,
0.666316568851471,
-0.2450234740972519,
0.3360286056995392,
-0.3955312669277191,
-0.19373588263988495,
-0.22850532829761505,
0.6280946135520935,
-0.7637026906013489,
-0.562768280506134,
-0.117786705493927,
-0.34704384207725525,
0.1337963342666626,
-0.5483280420303345,
0.7338474988937378,
-0.36984920501708984,
0.4842055141925812,
-0.5044758915901184,
-0.3669230043888092,
-0.5778406858444214,
0.28968796133995056,
-0.327681303024292,
0.43533456325531006,
-0.007496501784771681,
-0.6801332831382751,
0.37420839071273804,
-0.5622231364250183,
-0.5115512609481812,
0.07259320467710495,
-0.3027321398258209,
-0.1599452793598175,
0.27216893434524536,
-0.3186805248260498,
-0.19045212864875793,
-0.37363114953041077,
-0.11856651306152344,
-0.36842453479766846,
0.1417304426431656,
0.3300333619117737,
-0.5203805565834045,
0.8945918083190918,
0.4699934124946594,
-0.8634951710700989,
0.2591003477573395,
-0.5055378079414368,
-0.3633475601673126,
0.24203325808048248,
0.11950007826089859,
-0.8439446091651917,
0.33731165528297424,
-0.15905244648456573,
0.31028372049331665,
-0.2740705609321594,
-0.8322775363922119,
-0.3865124583244324,
-0.5322563052177429,
0.30114370584487915,
0.9150785207748413,
0.08244401961565018,
0.14603132009506226,
-0.4297741651535034,
0.6020335555076599,
0.19035813212394714,
0.1767091453075409,
0.37725135684013367,
-0.6269823312759399,
-0.792700469493866,
0.10327371954917908,
-0.6327061057090759,
0.5171144604682922,
-0.439778596162796,
-0.078048475086689,
0.35589465498924255,
-0.8800475597381592,
-0.2925187945365906,
-0.07971250265836716,
0.672398030757904,
1.0085245370864868,
0.7143312692642212,
0.019733423367142677,
-1.0496095418930054,
-0.9785938858985901,
-0.389422744512558,
-0.4292401969432831,
0.3811165988445282,
0.2843706011772156,
0.2751273214817047,
0.19614177942276,
0.8945708274841309,
-0.3196289539337158,
0.22181670367717743,
-0.43044814467430115,
0.2757928967475891,
-0.35174745321273804,
0.1946021467447281,
0.8666166067123413,
-1.0355045795440674,
-0.7408375144004822,
-0.4145278036594391,
-0.44338780641555786,
-0.2712872326374054,
0.033405087888240814,
-0.14288845658302307,
0.2540326416492462,
0.22397954761981964,
-0.09140773117542267,
0.6534866690635681,
0.6047345399856567,
-0.494873046875,
0.5013337731361389,
0.7475470304489136,
0.48614639043807983,
-0.8571978807449341,
-0.4204806983470917,
0.25253531336784363,
0.1757667511701584,
-1.0289174318313599,
-0.17300143837928772,
-0.7033394575119019,
0.07317091524600983,
-0.4920557141304016,
0.20469576120376587,
-0.12258216738700867,
0.21285435557365417,
-0.23514926433563232,
0.32464852929115295,
0.011746698059141636,
0.11414838582277298,
0.19022873044013977,
0.4791511595249176,
0.3837560713291168,
-0.6721009612083435,
0.573724091053009,
0.038530491292476654,
-0.09627770632505417,
0.9813939929008484,
-0.6065406203269958,
0.04744230955839157,
-0.18903979659080505,
0.0525548942387104,
-0.900216817855835,
0.1594325751066208,
0.6534304618835449,
-0.46459540724754333,
-0.2584078907966614,
-0.386636346578598,
0.20956075191497803,
-0.30975213646888733,
-0.14478394389152527,
0.21380563080310822,
0.48638397455215454,
-0.2219664752483368,
0.5943710207939148,
0.45705536007881165,
-0.1327078491449356,
-0.43132954835891724,
-0.5749367475509644,
-0.05665206164121628,
-0.6686714291572571,
-0.3638729155063629,
0.22096620500087738,
-0.3275567889213562,
-1.1512876749038696,
-0.2240755558013916,
-0.15746095776557922,
0.04903687536716461,
0.016815166920423508,
0.6171905994415283,
0.14361776411533356,
-0.1244204044342041,
0.02644352801144123,
0.22791802883148193,
0.2563973367214203,
0.47665074467658997,
0.06907050311565399,
0.5995225310325623,
0.02802446112036705,
-0.2692658305168152,
-0.1147117167711258,
0.5732169151306152,
0.681588888168335,
0.18539497256278992,
0.8009151816368103,
0.2606337368488312,
-0.32079017162323,
0.070279061794281,
-0.6673879623413086,
-0.4342249631881714,
-0.38714975118637085,
0.29056620597839355,
-0.3682749569416046,
-0.6637475490570068,
0.300192266702652,
0.35147103667259216,
0.12227332592010498,
0.5451165437698364,
0.5730776190757751,
-0.04119649901986122,
1.0348480939865112,
0.07804394513368607,
-0.05373791605234146,
0.365812748670578,
0.5013383626937866,
0.3035306930541992,
-0.28151965141296387,
-0.29767024517059326,
-0.858416736125946,
-0.22268377244472504,
-0.41086456179618835,
-0.11983668804168701,
0.43596890568733215,
-0.028489621356129646,
-0.30135858058929443,
0.21244727075099945,
-0.4965207576751709,
0.19437848031520844,
0.2877778112888336,
-0.18427859246730804,
0.23129013180732727,
0.2775999903678894,
-0.05151506885886192,
-0.6124700307846069,
-0.39575690031051636,
-0.06368488073348999,
0.7298921942710876,
0.24850021302700043,
0.4924691319465637,
0.49186745285987854,
0.45329010486602783,
0.3107648193836212,
0.48199576139450073,
-0.7479828000068665,
0.6593879461288452,
0.024926571175456047,
-0.8292626142501831,
-0.1494336724281311,
-0.42508965730667114,
-0.629042387008667,
0.2776009738445282,
-0.4371117353439331,
-0.716101884841919,
-0.09897051006555557,
0.3133443295955658,
-0.08548011630773544,
0.5028795599937439,
-0.5625599026679993,
0.7371829748153687,
-0.2527538537979126,
-0.24520158767700195,
-0.47322526574134827,
-0.4206952154636383,
0.49760177731513977,
0.20458005368709564,
0.31643638014793396,
0.16143453121185303,
0.32983875274658203,
0.9942503571510315,
-0.2979617118835449,
0.7727601528167725,
-0.24514088034629822,
-0.1487707495689392,
0.36999180912971497,
0.26007965207099915,
0.10391373187303543,
-0.33886492252349854,
-0.08102010190486908,
0.21246156096458435,
-0.3046042025089264,
-0.06060241907835007,
-0.47252127528190613,
0.667167067527771,
-0.6992591619491577,
-0.8504401445388794,
-0.40888142585754395,
-0.30445608496665955,
-0.1642129272222519,
0.05861229822039604,
0.5793711543083191,
0.4622747600078583,
-0.6085408329963684,
0.20584356784820557,
0.9197970628738403,
-0.34766802191734314,
0.31999561190605164,
0.5575549006462097,
-0.3081611394882202,
-0.39648640155792236,
0.9145234823226929,
0.15605652332305908,
0.7146135568618774,
0.24821840226650238,
0.5411223769187927,
-0.5072011351585388,
-0.31522688269615173,
-0.61151123046875,
-0.06800239533185959,
-0.6174237132072449,
0.0817156657576561,
-0.9047926664352417,
-0.024083631113171577,
-0.7887483835220337,
-0.29019105434417725,
-0.09993284940719604,
-0.23299410939216614,
0.023987548425793648,
-0.21151570975780487,
0.6402938961982727,
0.8880490064620972,
-0.33663511276245117,
0.20517531037330627,
-0.2679808437824249,
0.42438969016075134,
0.6808619499206543,
-0.21779754757881165,
0.037307001650333405,
-0.6256244778633118,
0.28422337770462036,
0.2255605012178421,
-0.24628116190433502,
-1.5793653726577759,
0.2821236252784729,
-0.21433797478675842,
0.5033496618270874,
0.9080860614776611,
0.5350923538208008,
0.6730092763900757,
-0.17918729782104492,
0.8053105473518372,
0.38022205233573914,
-0.7840653657913208,
0.6566592454910278,
-0.2184963971376419,
-0.17289596796035767,
0.3404631018638611,
0.9123517274856567,
-0.6175731420516968,
-0.6976743936538696,
-0.679807186126709,
-0.5043283104896545,
0.3377373516559601,
0.0536225289106369,
-0.10370759665966034,
-0.2858700752258301,
-0.40560898184776306,
0.014852301217615604,
0.17936547100543976,
-0.8620657920837402,
-0.9026211500167847,
-0.7313375473022461,
0.015216033905744553,
0.047395970672369,
-0.5371624827384949,
-0.9167180061340332,
-0.1310597062110901,
0.554538369178772,
0.3183469772338867,
-0.08434846997261047,
0.0726548507809639,
-0.10071206837892532,
-0.2648015022277832,
0.5484541654586792,
0.9465650320053101,
0.7161610126495361,
-0.05392584949731827,
0.4890233278274536,
0.02027222327888012,
-0.5493202805519104,
0.08857546001672745,
0.030531020835042,
-0.40373390913009644,
0.12192464619874954,
0.07922757416963577,
0.8182580471038818,
-0.15776851773262024,
-0.35188746452331543,
0.2530013620853424,
0.09657527506351471,
-0.18032029271125793,
-0.2245372235774994,
-0.023347672075033188,
0.02388901822268963,
0.06491443514823914,
0.25881123542785645,
0.1817556619644165,
0.14542295038700104,
-0.6587245464324951,
0.10434649884700775,
0.6186073422431946,
-0.5611851215362549,
-0.21296948194503784,
0.6237969994544983,
0.35820484161376953,
-0.31711068749427795,
0.42392072081565857,
-0.26080524921417236,
-0.8756519556045532,
0.371145635843277,
0.8589991927146912,
0.7794903516769409,
-0.21520739793777466,
0.5424647331237793,
0.5039974451065063,
0.31851062178611755,
0.7773435711860657,
-0.06513255089521408,
-0.1070929616689682,
-0.7417550683021545,
0.028017167001962662,
-0.6122291088104248,
-0.39692771434783936,
0.2996987998485565,
-0.6889411807060242,
-0.34737980365753174,
-0.5726487636566162,
-0.07325040549039841,
-0.02293536625802517,
-0.16651667654514313,
-0.23639322817325592,
0.18083550035953522,
0.34658730030059814,
0.7550736665725708,
-0.9918214678764343,
0.2569231688976288,
0.40483906865119934,
-0.6042208075523376,
-0.44844597578048706,
0.018154460936784744,
0.7986280918121338,
-0.5895812511444092,
0.6368997693061829,
0.023827342316508293,
-0.6514740586280823,
-0.14228734374046326,
-0.5714537501335144,
-0.4167861044406891,
0.2476944625377655,
0.012701443396508694,
-0.5489943027496338,
0.44457632303237915,
0.17253783345222473,
0.40804851055145264,
-0.29504913091659546,
0.2395540475845337,
0.40296223759651184,
0.5427935719490051,
-0.000390046916436404,
-0.7009882926940918,
0.3056506812572479,
-0.12060149759054184,
-0.4201332926750183,
-0.03369763866066933,
-0.5508337020874023,
0.7284222841262817,
0.11430685222148895,
-0.2949744462966919,
-0.33592623472213745,
0.5669900178909302,
0.26505616307258606,
0.48159950971603394,
0.9357168078422546,
0.5797468423843384,
0.2306949645280838,
-0.06910236179828644,
0.5340301394462585,
-0.12019400298595428,
-0.36908626556396484,
0.9405537247657776,
-0.13621285557746887,
0.35331225395202637,
0.4478144347667694,
-0.10278476774692535,
0.856149435043335,
0.030640190467238426,
0.2704884111881256,
0.18599270284175873,
0.47206512093544006,
-0.7338154911994934,
-0.18327413499355316,
-0.5003085136413574,
-0.46606069803237915,
0.5494503974914551,
0.5634750723838806,
-0.07290401309728622,
-0.34842172265052795,
0.2973955273628235,
0.4820028245449066,
0.5976966619491577,
-0.3477490544319153,
0.793356716632843,
-0.14923548698425293,
-0.7749656438827515,
0.27880483865737915,
0.02896469086408615,
0.7695351243019104,
-0.5569032430648804,
-0.038999591022729874,
-0.14058884978294373,
-0.1916072815656662,
-0.33127546310424805,
-0.465313583612442,
0.5217867493629456,
0.32822078466415405,
-0.30217766761779785,
-0.17976011335849762,
0.7541241645812988,
-0.38249337673187256,
0.12223010510206223,
0.32442691922187805,
0.19223487377166748,
0.2678334712982178,
-0.1823049783706665,
-0.8006713390350342,
0.18341752886772156,
0.2398189902305603,
-0.06035086512565613,
0.5629733204841614,
0.183721125125885,
0.07396437227725983,
0.4868507981300354,
0.6083559393882751,
0.1394665390253067,
0.20403741300106049,
0.13161219656467438,
0.9611920714378357,
-0.5146341323852539,
-0.2549753189086914,
-1.1004596948623657,
0.3116762638092041,
-0.23624785244464874,
-0.45581117272377014,
0.9913601279258728,
0.5684654712677002,
0.8373104333877563,
0.05545704439282417,
0.8556168079376221,
-0.46209999918937683,
0.7769380211830139,
-0.20973704755306244,
0.8114632368087769,
-0.36130091547966003,
-0.38377657532691956,
-0.5894958972930908,
-0.7245003581047058,
0.21640650928020477,
0.667885422706604,
-0.6598386764526367,
-0.10251665860414505,
0.5197591185569763,
0.8772701621055603,
0.3172488808631897,
0.29922693967819214,
0.38122937083244324,
0.4913531541824341,
0.47143155336380005,
0.3550967574119568,
0.7730435729026794,
-0.09242668747901917,
0.7573761343955994,
-0.3749380111694336,
-0.36643752455711365,
-0.023806098848581314,
-0.544715940952301,
-0.7871142625808716,
-0.5699523091316223,
-0.3054357171058655,
-0.7599557042121887,
0.011534075252711773,
0.6732397079467773,
0.43946442008018494,
-0.7807710766792297,
-0.25928714871406555,
-0.02593039907515049,
0.4754672646522522,
-0.14141727983951569,
-0.33833247423171997,
-0.3044015169143677,
0.11103763431310654,
-0.9310961961746216,
0.5839627981185913,
0.36906951665878296,
-0.03672601655125618,
-0.2973167896270752,
-0.09924531728029251,
-0.4166329503059387,
0.29081985354423523,
0.7535551190376282,
0.7786374688148499,
-0.9062240123748779,
-0.24172312021255493,
0.013571115210652351,
0.0007079442148096859,
-0.1896193027496338,
0.7930060625076294,
-0.645656168460846,
0.6327182650566101,
0.4099155068397522,
0.1839485913515091,
0.046666741371154785,
0.33318328857421875,
0.5043483972549438,
-0.30632781982421875,
0.2938983142375946,
0.37829989194869995,
0.03855567052960396,
-0.00075473019387573,
-0.011526888236403465,
0.08862856030464172,
0.6931533217430115,
-0.3565738797187805,
-0.7276890277862549,
0.8128222227096558,
-0.902950644493103,
-0.26172900199890137,
0.9459425210952759,
0.017720788717269897,
0.23001991212368011,
-0.5924017429351807,
-0.23878157138824463,
0.2778499126434326,
-0.6115062832832336,
0.5877839922904968,
0.638424277305603,
-0.38652223348617554,
-0.3237996995449066,
-0.19236084818840027,
0.7889640927314758,
0.4148540794849396,
-0.6996990442276001,
-0.055552635341882706,
0.8629054427146912,
0.014507240615785122,
0.33815863728523254,
0.5510757565498352,
0.07310234755277634,
0.04255727306008339,
0.3514939844608307,
-0.19451254606246948,
0.19117224216461182,
-0.32713064551353455,
0.08659675717353821,
0.4138841927051544,
-0.28549885749816895,
-0.03040371648967266
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16852v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16852v1
|
A Disease Labeler for Chinese Chest X-Ray Report Generation
| 2024-03-18T07:10:33 | 2024-03-18T07:10:33 |
Mengwei Wang, Ruixin Yan, Zeyi Hou, Ning Lang, Xiuzhuang Zhou
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, eess.IV
|
In the field of medical image analysis, the scarcity of Chinese chest X-ray
report datasets has hindered the development of technology for generating
Chinese chest X-ray reports. On one hand, the construction of a Chinese chest
X-ray report dataset is limited by the time-consuming and costly process of
accurate expert disease annotation. On the other hand, a single natural
language generation metric is commonly used to evaluate the similarity between
generated and ground-truth reports, while the clinical accuracy and
effectiveness of the generated reports rely on an accurate disease labeler
(classifier). To address the issues, this study proposes a disease labeler
tailored for the generation of Chinese chest X-ray reports. This labeler
leverages a dual BERT architecture to handle diagnostic reports and clinical
information separately and constructs a hierarchical label learning algorithm
based on the affiliation between diseases and body parts to enhance text
classification performance. Utilizing this disease labeler, a Chinese chest
X-ray report dataset comprising 51,262 report samples was established. Finally,
experiments and analyses were conducted on a subset of expert-annotated Chinese
chest X-ray reports, validating the effectiveness of the proposed disease
labeler.
|
[
0.015023281797766685,
-0.15855085849761963,
0.1574026495218277,
0.09788335859775543,
-0.5467177629470825,
-0.11968378722667694,
0.21063129603862762,
-0.7820894122123718,
0.29677465558052063,
0.3996427357196808,
-0.2385471761226654,
-0.7833954095840454,
-0.5262390971183777,
-0.1792481690645218,
-0.03216348588466644,
1.2368712425231934,
0.35518091917037964,
-0.0294136181473732,
0.11821382492780685,
0.003401731140911579,
-0.5861034989356995,
-0.38489699363708496,
-1.0787537097930908,
-0.29996177554130554,
0.6080707907676697,
-0.09969033300876617,
1.037056803703308,
0.9564146995544434,
0.6795404553413391,
0.16663946211338043,
0.250369668006897,
0.2806422710418701,
-0.10087278485298157,
-0.06957466900348663,
0.1525748372077942,
-0.3233166038990021,
-0.7088156342506409,
-0.37689656019210815,
0.23925422132015228,
0.20272353291511536,
0.38236311078071594,
0.1317879855632782,
-0.40500083565711975,
0.6487509608268738,
-0.11889638006687164,
0.35582536458969116,
-0.09862913936376572,
0.6030187606811523,
-0.626395583152771,
-0.44644102454185486,
-0.29981526732444763,
-0.2598433494567871,
0.4476403594017029,
-0.5443007946014404,
0.2905194163322449,
0.09053438901901245,
0.9407832622528076,
0.14978328347206116,
-0.3326347768306732,
-0.30422884225845337,
-0.19162482023239136,
0.49708670377731323,
-0.5441074967384338,
0.25108471512794495,
0.15303905308246613,
0.5947734117507935,
0.2874552011489868,
-0.9100363254547119,
0.27911877632141113,
-0.13359785079956055,
-0.4675769507884979,
0.2341899573802948,
-0.22513464093208313,
-0.11320856958627701,
-0.370042085647583,
0.3750922679901123,
-1.1007322072982788,
0.3902284502983093,
-0.44546836614608765,
-0.40000858902931213,
1.022515892982483,
0.01995839737355709,
0.7125518918037415,
-0.489574134349823,
-0.6268843412399292,
-0.06335623562335968,
-0.5286577939987183,
-0.14739681780338287,
-0.42614006996154785,
0.3331693708896637,
0.14401736855506897,
-0.1730201542377472,
0.0012539578601717949,
0.7428852915763855,
0.06568413227796555,
-0.7060611248016357,
0.5738013982772827,
-0.1049070730805397,
-0.35083240270614624,
0.7699579000473022,
0.6969263553619385,
0.5200978517532349,
-0.5411248207092285,
-0.28389686346054077,
-0.26083624362945557,
-0.1585206389427185,
0.14415957033634186,
-0.8742830753326416,
-0.6549013257026672,
0.36294984817504883,
-0.7750420570373535,
-0.5661724805831909,
0.08057791739702225,
-0.4120616316795349,
-0.6694018244743347,
0.20882588624954224,
0.36958518624305725,
-0.3439646065235138,
-0.09406615793704987,
-0.2064013034105301,
-0.31006285548210144,
-0.12790201604366302,
0.09205158054828644,
-0.5227633714675903,
-0.034678321331739426,
0.24615462124347687,
0.652035117149353,
0.066888727247715,
0.3254365622997284,
-0.7229587435722351,
0.3897482454776764,
-0.3798500597476959,
0.8696818351745605,
-0.2874164879322052,
-0.507279634475708,
-0.22127842903137207,
-0.05667231231927872,
0.07822355628013611,
-0.5305224061012268,
0.44258326292037964,
-0.3868035078048706,
-0.0685477927327156,
-0.1119929850101471,
-0.29525700211524963,
-0.2010723203420639,
0.31099939346313477,
-0.8338769674301147,
0.797972559928894,
0.1996065080165863,
-0.8010085821151733,
0.6421604156494141,
-0.236489936709404,
-0.5116350650787354,
0.5680131912231445,
-0.5436610579490662,
-0.6302329301834106,
-0.048564545810222626,
0.28783541917800903,
0.6386256217956543,
-0.3492116630077362,
0.4546554684638977,
0.37613680958747864,
-0.10974082350730896,
0.15720954537391663,
-0.15279842913150787,
0.7176055908203125,
0.09436410665512085,
-0.41503751277923584,
0.014187237247824669,
-0.8680537939071655,
0.22022828459739685,
0.29314836859703064,
-0.14632175862789154,
-0.4526250660419464,
0.40807798504829407,
-0.12583912909030914,
0.3107052743434906,
0.14280138909816742,
-0.8016797304153442,
0.2727369964122772,
-0.25418582558631897,
-0.03917156904935837,
0.5382780432701111,
0.0007653906941413879,
-0.4394755959510803,
-0.9396551251411438,
0.27971532940864563,
0.11711300164461136,
0.17274609208106995,
-0.24561944603919983,
-0.7673764228820801,
-0.451175719499588,
-0.4479329288005829,
0.2390994429588318,
0.5266836881637573,
-0.6709980964660645,
0.5882120728492737,
-0.3265238106250763,
-0.8419824242591858,
-0.7254193425178528,
-0.139369398355484,
0.7634569406509399,
0.5577285885810852,
0.4118940234184265,
-0.28825998306274414,
-0.5771442651748657,
-0.8623670339584351,
0.15199753642082214,
-0.1440335512161255,
-0.13202641904354095,
0.45799821615219116,
-0.058191727846860886,
-0.16165094077587128,
0.5033382773399353,
-0.8648220300674438,
-0.9327343702316284,
-0.10902991145849228,
0.27953776717185974,
-0.047476623207330704,
0.29027315974235535,
0.8378231525421143,
-0.6943590044975281,
-0.7022496461868286,
0.626821756362915,
-0.7905591130256653,
-0.21920661628246307,
-0.3059053122997284,
-0.19168254733085632,
0.5062556266784668,
0.22656169533729553,
0.13820114731788635,
0.5156745910644531,
0.561789870262146,
0.02627013437449932,
0.5563883781433105,
-0.5067259669303894,
0.052205752581357956,
-0.670821487903595,
0.08061155676841736,
0.3719280958175659,
-0.20122258365154266,
-0.5836045145988464,
-0.006520186550915241,
0.00350699620321393,
-0.10986693203449249,
-0.24992002546787262,
0.2813818156719208,
-0.33291202783584595,
0.5436865091323853,
-0.02621605060994625,
0.16290122270584106,
0.17573770880699158,
0.14452186226844788,
0.5159064531326294,
-0.05049605667591095,
0.7057934403419495,
-0.4417930543422699,
0.2391873002052307,
0.25087857246398926,
-0.2789117395877838,
0.3012416958808899,
-0.665588915348053,
0.05769018828868866,
-0.11366741359233856,
0.3617488741874695,
-0.8985685110092163,
-0.11445426195859909,
0.436199814081192,
-0.4101628065109253,
0.5529049038887024,
0.059959638863801956,
-0.5033257603645325,
-0.6718052625656128,
-0.40025970339775085,
0.09591903537511826,
0.5599961876869202,
-0.7700784206390381,
0.14953550696372986,
0.3243263065814972,
-0.14580579102039337,
-0.3513600826263428,
-1.0882314443588257,
-0.1600770652294159,
0.18913120031356812,
-0.7392175197601318,
0.5785621404647827,
-0.11640345305204391,
0.17363274097442627,
0.09451773762702942,
-0.28735291957855225,
-0.44984695315361023,
-0.15702296793460846,
0.18680709600448608,
0.4129348397254944,
-0.5183534622192383,
0.2890513837337494,
0.12338174134492874,
-0.3598259389400482,
0.07691043615341187,
-0.3334209620952606,
-0.23174075782299042,
0.2622169554233551,
-0.27910277247428894,
-0.5271825194358826,
0.30569788813591003,
0.19567719101905823,
-0.2667617201805115,
0.2574884295463562,
0.41131851077079773,
-0.39509767293930054,
-0.25040245056152344,
-0.12486182153224945,
0.3140895366668701,
-0.43323832750320435,
0.4952172338962555,
-0.3418436646461487,
-0.27685144543647766,
0.0005818195641040802,
0.3181338310241699,
0.2614826560020447,
0.3899851143360138,
0.3495035171508789,
0.10981037467718124,
1.0920917987823486,
0.40915268659591675,
-0.25569427013397217,
-0.24244579672813416,
0.016103770583868027,
0.45338982343673706,
-0.4858940839767456,
-0.3412933051586151,
-0.34042465686798096,
-0.32047390937805176,
-0.39397308230400085,
-0.1867302507162094,
0.6134220361709595,
-0.594048023223877,
0.2071220576763153,
-0.17265284061431885,
-1.2602307796478271,
0.143349751830101,
0.3685551881790161,
0.6347124576568604,
0.31499141454696655,
-0.08390504121780396,
0.5461945533752441,
-0.21848560869693756,
-0.936292290687561,
-0.3553655743598938,
0.8490297794342041,
0.0641719251871109,
0.47419866919517517,
0.07040632516145706,
0.9203651547431946,
0.46730345487594604,
0.6280219554901123,
-0.6241198778152466,
-0.05132385715842247,
-0.9311556816101074,
-0.6734934449195862,
-0.056432463228702545,
-0.24751721322536469,
-1.2438324689865112,
0.2565006613731384,
0.07165602594614029,
-0.6492389440536499,
0.06202475726604462,
0.3886812925338745,
-0.6421147584915161,
0.5024046897888184,
-0.5477672815322876,
0.8431428670883179,
-0.736648440361023,
0.10304268449544907,
0.2698255777359009,
-0.8980249166488647,
0.636667013168335,
-0.5044576525688171,
0.3845876455307007,
0.04338536784052849,
0.2545258104801178,
0.8844807744026184,
-0.5731666088104248,
1.096201777458191,
-0.22116169333457947,
-0.3521720767021179,
0.21540407836437225,
-0.03118208236992359,
-0.08688141405582428,
0.17214009165763855,
-0.03309882804751396,
-0.0009289662120863795,
0.12900283932685852,
-0.3366473317146301,
-0.25978538393974304,
0.4612559378147125,
-0.766253650188446,
-0.6019639372825623,
-0.5016909837722778,
-0.4855790138244629,
0.12623298168182373,
0.49052900075912476,
0.5681374073028564,
0.8641383647918701,
-0.29079583287239075,
-0.20200765132904053,
0.7229064702987671,
-0.4779876470565796,
-0.06480750441551208,
0.541131317615509,
-0.07729863375425339,
-0.3435833156108856,
1.4979060888290405,
0.691658616065979,
0.07607147097587585,
0.8174816966056824,
0.4064166247844696,
0.2299778014421463,
-0.32037609815597534,
-0.4683687686920166,
0.09945733845233917,
-0.29767298698425293,
-0.5505309700965881,
-0.24520418047904968,
-0.508571982383728,
-0.17867974936962128,
-0.4080928862094879,
-0.03386090323328972,
0.050997357815504074,
-0.17560100555419922,
0.20314961671829224,
0.1223333477973938,
0.8215441703796387,
-0.09788422286510468,
0.24770595133304596,
-1.0251600742340088,
0.38764822483062744,
-0.0048827482387423515,
0.021870525553822517,
0.18242232501506805,
-0.2525404393672943,
-0.4621427059173584,
0.09893107414245605,
-0.2984454333782196,
-0.7087544202804565,
0.49864503741264343,
0.2548144459724426,
0.5076666474342346,
0.6722308397293091,
0.6210061311721802,
0.38765567541122437,
-0.08734892308712006,
0.6297270059585571,
0.25612467527389526,
-0.5967828631401062,
0.8579027056694031,
-0.04630844295024872,
0.2552296817302704,
-0.126616969704628,
0.32385724782943726,
-0.42859727144241333,
-0.6716364026069641,
-0.5143662691116333,
-0.8039620518684387,
0.7804166078567505,
-0.019893167540431023,
-0.23131948709487915,
-0.02323915809392929,
0.04840898513793945,
0.5013394951820374,
-0.27375975251197815,
-0.44905978441238403,
-0.5671476125717163,
-0.2713868319988251,
-0.049683768302202225,
0.09714881330728531,
-0.2032136768102646,
-0.10106713324785233,
-0.09948356449604034,
0.8119131326675415,
0.007168612442910671,
0.13402047753334045,
0.5634183287620544,
-0.2536941170692444,
-0.13014563918113708,
-0.016574084758758545,
0.05066806823015213,
0.3452158570289612,
-0.49274441599845886,
0.07488736510276794,
-0.49654126167297363,
-0.19131997227668762,
-0.12899042665958405,
0.30943411588668823,
-0.20620973408222198,
0.39932698011398315,
0.3829447031021118,
0.5939955711364746,
0.08851095288991928,
-0.5318633913993835,
0.531957745552063,
0.020306015387177467,
-0.4468771815299988,
-0.10122080147266388,
0.003118822816759348,
0.006795103661715984,
0.027274655178189278,
0.23304198682308197,
0.21408572793006897,
0.21769370138645172,
-0.22080715000629425,
0.4691299498081207,
-0.01851840317249298,
-0.7436232566833496,
-0.1750723421573639,
0.8180809617042542,
0.41490623354911804,
0.007864054292440414,
0.9352596402168274,
-0.36504876613616943,
-0.21322926878929138,
0.9218944907188416,
0.5299044251441956,
0.45919591188430786,
-0.2962135970592499,
0.5200107097625732,
0.0990649163722992,
0.39526131749153137,
0.4387008249759674,
-0.03671799972653389,
0.04698430374264717,
-0.4532957971096039,
-0.30379214882850647,
0.006727966479957104,
-0.06996126472949982,
0.025168249383568764,
-0.940986692905426,
0.2621123492717743,
-0.2593197524547577,
-0.02397235855460167,
0.48359912633895874,
0.14305749535560608,
-0.16378359496593475,
0.6910670399665833,
0.7808548808097839,
0.9477800130844116,
-0.7750279903411865,
1.0449696779251099,
0.7498412728309631,
-0.4752024710178375,
-0.6439691781997681,
-0.13344556093215942,
0.33479103446006775,
-0.9554359316825867,
0.6954125761985779,
0.4865972101688385,
0.294580340385437,
-0.22370068728923798,
-0.02005859836935997,
-0.6871028542518616,
1.3529635667800903,
0.11722370982170105,
-0.40249520540237427,
0.2151550054550171,
-0.01861673779785633,
0.5712763071060181,
-0.1532086431980133,
0.031630367040634155,
0.48470544815063477,
0.484609454870224,
0.04781713709235191,
-1.0024421215057373,
0.44707250595092773,
-0.49339184165000916,
0.011909715831279755,
0.1795438677072525,
-1.1282843351364136,
0.38953325152397156,
-0.4020000994205475,
-0.1373370885848999,
0.2628743052482605,
0.5742227435112,
0.37542128562927246,
0.45375242829322815,
0.293273389339447,
0.4097558557987213,
0.9933720231056213,
0.026377685368061066,
1.1311510801315308,
-0.15262725949287415,
0.07813098281621933,
0.8349411487579346,
-0.1409820318222046,
0.2317943125963211,
-0.30212363600730896,
0.004553194157779217,
0.4699792265892029,
0.646986186504364,
-0.3636654019355774,
0.4138401746749878,
0.3419296443462372,
-0.19123393297195435,
-0.0027473289519548416,
-0.1694241464138031,
-0.6833235025405884,
0.17333921790122986,
0.3941694498062134,
-0.6616619229316711,
-0.2780795991420746,
0.08283405005931854,
0.1651107221841812,
-0.5005111694335938,
-0.19165804982185364,
0.5217300653457642,
-0.38917461037635803,
-0.10636544227600098,
0.6363554000854492,
-0.11687710881233215,
0.5172995328903198,
-0.7823587656021118,
0.13598962128162384,
-0.07135327160358429,
0.21340054273605347,
-0.5084558725357056,
-0.6823979020118713,
0.31201279163360596,
-0.3413127660751343,
-0.3517751395702362,
0.03569096326828003,
0.7344404458999634,
-0.38626620173454285,
-0.4834841191768646,
0.20356160402297974,
0.3099272549152374,
0.4303576946258545,
0.1429346650838852,
-0.5461463332176208,
0.23073728382587433,
0.2916454076766968,
-0.006974208168685436,
0.44162219762802124,
0.5203936696052551,
-0.22246548533439636,
0.5475106239318848,
0.10359493643045425,
0.17581595480442047,
-0.030447594821453094,
-0.10623739659786224,
0.7334964275360107,
-0.2724301517009735,
-0.40760692954063416,
-0.21883554756641388,
0.5501977205276489,
-0.11710912734270096,
-0.3850342035293579,
0.3915897309780121,
0.6834414005279541,
0.5391217470169067,
-0.037938445806503296,
1.3865162134170532,
-0.3526688814163208,
0.16599899530410767,
-0.20092645287513733,
0.9607990980148315,
-0.7058500647544861,
0.11050888150930405,
-0.04361266642808914,
0.10955332964658737,
-0.8919779062271118,
0.21255169808864594,
0.12389826774597168,
-0.20262159407138824,
0.6645036935806274,
0.6459016799926758,
0.19819407165050507,
-0.24980603158473969,
0.3692743480205536,
0.4138295352458954,
0.42155376076698303,
0.7564607262611389,
0.09161382168531418,
-0.5337129235267639,
0.7890800833702087,
-0.6778304576873779,
-0.6500606536865234,
-0.2441650927066803,
-0.48730555176734924,
-0.7999016642570496,
-0.23902028799057007,
-0.9712410569190979,
-0.03710104897618294,
0.39548757672309875,
0.286236047744751,
1.1284700632095337,
-0.7275285720825195,
-0.06623931229114532,
0.5167005658149719,
-0.010247033089399338,
-0.5388433933258057,
-0.22651243209838867,
1.0453184843063354,
-0.3864137828350067,
-0.5006582736968994,
0.09329020977020264,
0.2924503982067108,
-0.19521406292915344,
0.1461784988641739,
0.03434864059090614,
0.22033798694610596,
-0.32254835963249207,
0.8047701716423035,
0.447777658700943,
-0.6528008580207825,
-0.22230342030525208,
-0.22880356013774872,
-0.2813549339771271,
0.295206218957901,
0.5519302487373352,
-0.8752380013465881,
0.8995060324668884,
0.1545693725347519,
0.5687847137451172,
0.01887049525976181,
-0.22248680889606476,
0.41090506315231323,
-0.9884169101715088,
-0.23785997927188873,
-0.0896417573094368,
0.1775711476802826,
0.0945362076163292,
-0.7952558398246765,
0.34295377135276794,
0.14203789830207825,
-0.5387402176856995,
-0.6037219762802124,
-0.24104732275009155,
-1.1431777477264404,
-0.49962180852890015,
0.5043849349021912,
-0.2616235911846161,
-0.42222151160240173,
-0.12615470588207245,
-0.5952141284942627,
0.21170884370803833,
-0.2701101303100586,
0.7826077342033386,
0.022740362212061882,
-0.6703270077705383,
0.09434428811073303,
-0.044679898768663406,
0.2262064814567566,
0.12202373147010803,
-0.6406528949737549,
-0.08649129420518875,
0.26552653312683105,
0.08719837665557861,
0.21225231885910034,
0.6982266306877136,
-0.22687315940856934,
0.5830392837524414,
-0.014665385708212852,
0.17825771868228912,
-0.2008463442325592,
0.12857285141944885,
0.31455981731414795,
0.03542373329401016,
0.02867227979004383,
-0.5891093015670776
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11509v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11509v1
|
DEE: Dual-stage Explainable Evaluation Method for Text Generation
| 2024-03-18T06:30:41 | 2024-03-18T06:30:41 |
Shenyu Zhang, Yu Li, Rui Wu, Xiutian Huang, Yongrui Chen, Wenhao Xu, Guilin Qi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Automatic methods for evaluating machine-generated texts hold significant
importance due to the expanding applications of generative systems.
Conventional methods tend to grapple with a lack of explainability, issuing a
solitary numerical score to signify the assessment outcome. Recent advancements
have sought to mitigate this limitation by incorporating large language models
(LLMs) to offer more detailed error analyses, yet their applicability remains
constrained, particularly in industrial contexts where comprehensive error
coverage and swift detection are paramount. To alleviate these challenges, we
introduce DEE, a Dual-stage Explainable Evaluation method for estimating the
quality of text generation. Built upon Llama 2, DEE follows a dual-stage
principle guided by stage-specific instructions to perform efficient
identification of errors in generated texts in the initial stage and
subsequently delves into providing comprehensive diagnostic reports in the
second stage. DEE is fine-tuned on our elaborately assembled dataset AntEval,
which encompasses 15K examples from 4 real-world applications of Alipay that
employ generative systems. The dataset concerns newly emerged issues like
hallucination and toxicity, thereby broadening the scope of DEE's evaluation
criteria. Experimental results affirm that DEE's superiority over existing
evaluation methods, achieving significant improvements in both human
correlation as well as efficiency.
|
[
-0.20968180894851685,
-0.9060710668563843,
0.7374137043952942,
0.40676334500312805,
-0.3247585892677307,
0.02695026807487011,
-0.06262432783842087,
-0.3618847131729126,
-0.04920196160674095,
0.3414962589740753,
-0.7016881704330444,
-0.5129590034484863,
-0.5644605755805969,
0.3164803087711334,
-0.5576462149620056,
1.0786956548690796,
-0.21259038150310516,
-0.22165071964263916,
-0.36489787697792053,
0.19582542777061462,
-0.5994047522544861,
-0.16435028612613678,
-0.9438295960426331,
-0.12860852479934692,
0.4391038119792938,
0.35894474387168884,
0.5541743636131287,
0.39004287123680115,
0.44338715076446533,
0.29491591453552246,
-0.13150714337825775,
0.38603222370147705,
-0.39072781801223755,
0.5102096796035767,
0.06273015588521957,
-0.3015911877155304,
-0.4028764069080353,
-0.15959295630455017,
0.5273497700691223,
0.6063763499259949,
-0.036054424941539764,
0.21051090955734253,
0.15289810299873352,
0.907852828502655,
-0.6285012364387512,
0.19146977365016937,
-0.37396982312202454,
0.07802961021661758,
-0.13466668128967285,
-0.2784684896469116,
-0.32891273498535156,
-0.5635248422622681,
-0.08654279261827469,
-0.5195909738540649,
-0.002185993827879429,
-0.3297281861305237,
0.5225377678871155,
0.6772669553756714,
-0.779036819934845,
-0.6894097328186035,
-0.804180383682251,
0.6426255106925964,
-0.6530089974403381,
0.06004774197936058,
0.23659153282642365,
0.31420326232910156,
-0.1543697863817215,
-0.8627291321754456,
-0.8187476396560669,
-0.20921587944030762,
0.06237265095114708,
0.3238871693611145,
-0.08927790075540543,
0.0026792287826538086,
0.27434420585632324,
0.5648422241210938,
-0.47831058502197266,
0.39171406626701355,
-0.1333729773759842,
-0.16200128197669983,
0.7683994174003601,
0.28303003311157227,
0.5094256401062012,
-0.31103721261024475,
-0.47392380237579346,
-0.08097919821739197,
-0.46115484833717346,
-0.03858510032296181,
0.5501744151115417,
-0.08170536160469055,
-0.05342308059334755,
0.5967690944671631,
-0.08189267665147781,
0.4545091688632965,
0.13424094021320343,
-0.05224381387233734,
0.17199930548667908,
-0.5600379109382629,
-0.23963043093681335,
-0.08188868314027786,
0.816721498966217,
0.573722243309021,
-0.00804713275283575,
0.003647928824648261,
-0.36200764775276184,
0.3658912181854248,
0.3775100111961365,
-0.9429143667221069,
-0.1533430516719818,
0.41895073652267456,
-0.5873267650604248,
-0.5711867809295654,
-0.09931642562150955,
-1.1891067028045654,
-0.9293451309204102,
-0.16911347210407257,
0.42374375462532043,
-0.08132265508174896,
-0.5975210666656494,
-0.0449598990380764,
-0.09584277123212814,
0.03191240131855011,
0.09824705868959427,
-0.831001877784729,
-0.016978930681943893,
0.5630595088005066,
0.7177577018737793,
-0.10907857865095139,
-0.0931059792637825,
-0.6015497446060181,
-0.10725247114896774,
-0.6628327965736389,
0.9810716509819031,
-0.25543513894081116,
-0.3350953757762909,
-0.03015833906829357,
-0.3881252706050873,
0.061018265783786774,
-0.6731416583061218,
0.9473676681518555,
-0.5067649483680725,
0.27521759271621704,
-0.06559493392705917,
-0.32748842239379883,
-0.34348344802856445,
-0.12805169820785522,
-0.7137460112571716,
1.1527220010757446,
0.22261659801006317,
-1.0070940256118774,
0.6786290407180786,
-0.7277036905288696,
-0.5104733109474182,
-0.04210425540804863,
0.014408309943974018,
-0.4601023495197296,
0.37297534942626953,
0.10771845281124115,
0.3878241777420044,
-0.4597454071044922,
0.4137658178806305,
0.008736511692404747,
-0.30588069558143616,
0.29087090492248535,
-0.8555554151535034,
0.904958188533783,
0.1914234310388565,
-0.5604282021522522,
0.2241225689649582,
-1.0691438913345337,
0.12686079740524292,
0.09503735601902008,
-0.2965283989906311,
-0.43615078926086426,
0.07136241346597672,
-0.17107713222503662,
0.17666268348693848,
0.28366103768348694,
-0.3064301013946533,
-0.29172712564468384,
-0.6228761672973633,
0.24765843152999878,
0.6141482591629028,
0.263471782207489,
0.12184620648622513,
-0.3424181044101715,
0.7097466588020325,
-0.040188733488321304,
0.008769551292061806,
-0.27164605259895325,
-0.5184620022773743,
-0.8456423282623291,
-0.19207574427127838,
0.3021487295627594,
0.4781419038772583,
-0.8483945727348328,
0.6104450225830078,
-0.023973559960722923,
-0.3090176582336426,
-0.5234787464141846,
-0.001300634234212339,
0.5283838510513306,
0.5768291354179382,
0.14634014666080475,
-0.42237672209739685,
-0.5964059829711914,
-0.9372439980506897,
-0.06409161537885666,
-0.4173195958137512,
-0.230759859085083,
0.04355188459157944,
0.28862231969833374,
-0.6329197883605957,
0.7748066186904907,
-0.2711409330368042,
0.2085065394639969,
-0.0570022352039814,
0.4390203356742859,
0.02812216989696026,
0.02720480225980282,
0.26866406202316284,
-0.7108291983604431,
-0.4609766900539398,
-0.08703622221946716,
-0.9997514486312866,
-0.6296324729919434,
-0.5739270448684692,
-0.2553746700286865,
0.347037672996521,
0.19807805120944977,
-0.17196138203144073,
0.6088898181915283,
0.7205234169960022,
-0.5699895024299622,
0.8880558013916016,
-0.5300968885421753,
0.29852280020713806,
-0.7738136053085327,
-0.16203628480434418,
-0.058078572154045105,
-0.11435793340206146,
-0.5565962195396423,
0.014735039323568344,
0.08586063981056213,
0.11524555087089539,
-0.0063406783156096935,
0.42268699407577515,
-0.4304792582988739,
-0.1344607025384903,
-0.5598587393760681,
0.2230568379163742,
0.4295837879180908,
0.11581320315599442,
-0.368116170167923,
1.002915382385254,
0.45366889238357544,
-0.8759903311729431,
0.49046948552131653,
0.2263394296169281,
-0.5750511884689331,
0.9268283247947693,
-0.7677571177482605,
0.06688464432954788,
-0.22370725870132446,
0.09752354770898819,
-1.2544772624969482,
-0.16047298908233643,
0.2736811637878418,
-0.24322254955768585,
0.43759241700172424,
0.2641820013523102,
-0.4838891625404358,
-0.5952785611152649,
-0.27859213948249817,
0.1885976493358612,
0.6286982297897339,
-0.8784432411193848,
0.1876453310251236,
0.3797914981842041,
-0.36600399017333984,
-0.28303542733192444,
-0.530127227306366,
0.40922683477401733,
-0.6256871819496155,
-0.8352495431900024,
0.22686119377613068,
-0.44382208585739136,
-0.5547999739646912,
-0.3582201898097992,
-0.2593434154987335,
-0.1887444257736206,
0.42083051800727844,
0.3628292977809906,
0.07253982126712799,
0.004549468867480755,
0.187880277633667,
0.6141397356987,
-0.5154088139533997,
0.5338389277458191,
0.024583611637353897,
0.1440039724111557,
0.2864757776260376,
-0.10522033274173737,
-0.8393102288246155,
0.42804309725761414,
0.6582668423652649,
0.017131080850958824,
0.5438922047615051,
0.5033784508705139,
-0.26619407534599304,
-0.5899562239646912,
-0.21656368672847748,
0.051592860370874405,
-0.4334222376346588,
0.4026971161365509,
-0.5425640940666199,
-0.016641778871417046,
0.36772170662879944,
-0.3211589753627777,
0.011550565250217915,
0.7716448307037354,
0.7936370968818665,
-0.008032741025090218,
0.9813586473464966,
0.5432766079902649,
0.7590708136558533,
0.06462264060974121,
-0.11969468742609024,
0.18517577648162842,
-0.8800047636032104,
-0.3222268521785736,
-0.4502401649951935,
-0.16564086079597473,
-0.36663728952407837,
-0.3732053339481354,
0.40513014793395996,
0.3744438588619232,
-0.2793717384338379,
0.004780158866196871,
-0.6163687109947205,
0.3822008967399597,
0.4897231459617615,
0.001720287138596177,
0.5946428775787354,
-0.040502406656742096,
-0.12464804202318192,
-0.11808794736862183,
-0.28341418504714966,
-1.0014690160751343,
1.159879446029663,
0.46370917558670044,
0.5644678473472595,
0.12801653146743774,
0.7643335461616516,
0.5196667313575745,
0.3831842243671417,
-0.8412295579910278,
0.3706008791923523,
-0.2464585155248642,
-0.37862953543663025,
-0.14423516392707825,
-0.5315064787864685,
-0.6827470064163208,
0.27209991216659546,
-0.12511979043483734,
-0.3566106855869293,
0.08957616239786148,
0.001015907502733171,
-0.33408814668655396,
0.07544706761837006,
-0.9297977089881897,
0.8013443946838379,
-0.5084763169288635,
-0.18501517176628113,
-0.10837855190038681,
-0.4863952696323395,
0.6635355949401855,
-0.6421266794204712,
0.34303000569343567,
0.03272087126970291,
-0.2150656133890152,
0.9156188368797302,
-0.521155059337616,
0.7376415729522705,
-0.2273101508617401,
-0.7572159171104431,
0.32301655411720276,
0.14026738703250885,
0.4250725209712982,
0.17315562069416046,
-0.473522812128067,
0.18763257563114166,
0.015880824998021126,
0.1450035721063614,
-0.6635909676551819,
0.7647594213485718,
-0.5078847408294678,
-0.38615715503692627,
-0.2988065183162689,
-0.504652738571167,
-0.1015888974070549,
0.06739965081214905,
0.3968963027000427,
0.48408862948417664,
-0.1372065395116806,
-0.2702294588088989,
0.4215048849582672,
-0.6606284976005554,
0.44831299781799316,
0.22358375787734985,
-0.20150938630104065,
-0.4126424193382263,
0.6334831714630127,
-0.19101592898368835,
0.2430327832698822,
0.09969462454319,
0.25676068663597107,
-0.5169918537139893,
-0.5681108832359314,
-0.7890286445617676,
0.05065254867076874,
-0.6199964880943298,
-0.2771488130092621,
-0.628349781036377,
-0.10750528424978256,
0.10855843126773834,
-0.056091174483299255,
-0.16016091406345367,
-0.5997264981269836,
-0.39910000562667847,
-0.24507494270801544,
0.20034971833229065,
1.029725193977356,
-0.27564775943756104,
0.20978499948978424,
-0.4129115343093872,
0.833621084690094,
0.47771114110946655,
0.5692842602729797,
0.05760851874947548,
-0.515744686126709,
-0.0471811443567276,
0.385355144739151,
-0.35690635442733765,
-1.152654767036438,
0.31786713004112244,
0.19577647745609283,
0.3985845446586609,
0.44584208726882935,
0.31778743863105774,
0.499571293592453,
-0.43487411737442017,
0.7361854314804077,
0.3311627209186554,
-0.9975868463516235,
0.6663318276405334,
-0.04979773983359337,
-0.1490909904241562,
0.4486951529979706,
0.20341390371322632,
-0.28902462124824524,
-0.258128821849823,
-0.3654237985610962,
-0.9338675737380981,
0.6107578277587891,
0.27749133110046387,
0.1476833075284958,
-0.14014625549316406,
0.39536145329475403,
0.6133766770362854,
-0.016669616103172302,
-0.5108055472373962,
-0.4388059973716736,
-0.12662525475025177,
-0.2952646017074585,
0.02095642313361168,
-0.8270986080169678,
-0.08967481553554535,
0.13269956409931183,
0.654609203338623,
0.17279045283794403,
0.20040449500083923,
0.0522875040769577,
-0.08089536428451538,
-0.2885560095310211,
0.3596097528934479,
0.42567190527915955,
0.971138060092926,
-0.1282600611448288,
0.1848679780960083,
-0.1433064490556717,
-0.4063873291015625,
0.33651527762413025,
0.25527453422546387,
-0.3172381520271301,
0.06880555301904678,
0.22083477675914764,
0.7297759056091309,
-0.11314979195594788,
-0.6548879146575928,
0.4103058874607086,
-0.23131750524044037,
-0.21077631413936615,
-0.24611055850982666,
0.019991323351860046,
-0.2157386839389801,
0.30265069007873535,
0.36068323254585266,
-0.12961390614509583,
0.4281632900238037,
-0.36299410462379456,
0.16914604604244232,
0.20127391815185547,
-0.2434166520833969,
-0.25088489055633545,
0.9683723449707031,
0.4763687551021576,
-0.28594985604286194,
0.48717379570007324,
-0.5104910731315613,
-0.31381431221961975,
0.926875650882721,
0.6962732672691345,
1.0856125354766846,
-0.017751123756170273,
0.6348644495010376,
0.4740273952484131,
0.29107898473739624,
0.08550680428743362,
0.2605660557746887,
0.08006982505321503,
-0.4214654564857483,
-0.587956428527832,
-0.8992202877998352,
-0.3041194975376129,
0.010006926022469997,
-0.6702779531478882,
0.11443189531564713,
-0.11017031222581863,
-0.17777015268802643,
0.10871438682079315,
0.055182166397571564,
-0.45846378803253174,
0.2307153344154358,
0.14273138344287872,
0.5493636131286621,
-0.8774181008338928,
0.2979542315006256,
0.5639546513557434,
-0.5055037140846252,
-0.3887193500995636,
0.3225005865097046,
0.04070884734392166,
-0.6795541644096375,
0.7879992723464966,
0.3920883238315582,
-0.06929652392864227,
0.10929693281650543,
0.013549085706472397,
-0.4667799174785614,
1.05362069606781,
0.10471250116825104,
-0.5506190061569214,
0.06390535086393356,
-0.20586737990379333,
0.63508141040802,
-0.05579420551657677,
0.5866730809211731,
0.6877272725105286,
0.6892813444137573,
0.03916274756193161,
-0.7965718507766724,
0.17876878380775452,
-0.11164252460002899,
0.293022096157074,
0.23422084748744965,
-0.2448563128709793,
0.37195101380348206,
-0.542483389377594,
-0.7389929294586182,
0.32304567098617554,
0.5729798674583435,
0.22630155086517334,
0.7695525288581848,
0.5958795547485352,
0.5841967463493347,
1.1126079559326172,
-0.008844364434480667,
1.247442603111267,
-0.10064558684825897,
0.24011363089084625,
0.8485822677612305,
-0.2536793053150177,
0.505790114402771,
0.18146640062332153,
-0.37638068199157715,
0.905754804611206,
0.6081593632698059,
0.31593525409698486,
0.493283748626709,
0.49198541045188904,
-0.44495049118995667,
0.016557563096284866,
0.00273224082775414,
-0.36232295632362366,
0.4192405939102173,
0.41240379214286804,
-0.3329920768737793,
-0.15647074580192566,
0.18685834109783173,
-0.08605724573135376,
0.298980176448822,
-0.19846488535404205,
0.8260483145713806,
-0.04891866818070412,
-0.555388867855072,
0.7656110525131226,
0.12244454771280289,
0.6732394099235535,
-0.2357649952173233,
-0.13807916641235352,
-0.45142263174057007,
0.010857989080250263,
-0.25516635179519653,
-0.7311335802078247,
0.5713277459144592,
0.4085453152656555,
-0.45038849115371704,
-0.30841517448425293,
0.44177478551864624,
-0.2568061947822571,
-0.5403473973274231,
0.17712031304836273,
0.3806915581226349,
0.2619135081768036,
-0.001978004351258278,
-0.49004611372947693,
0.08079031854867935,
0.08633038401603699,
-0.16049565374851227,
-0.18325738608837128,
0.8082082867622375,
0.0368986651301384,
0.46810901165008545,
0.3850422501564026,
-0.014149929396808147,
-0.1296149492263794,
0.20077387988567352,
0.5902511477470398,
-0.5252265930175781,
-0.30683913826942444,
-0.6279231309890747,
0.9022620916366577,
-0.006933919619768858,
-0.1908886432647705,
0.6720825433731079,
0.346261203289032,
0.3152714669704437,
0.08130614459514618,
0.9887183308601379,
-0.1673038899898529,
0.6382107138633728,
-0.6305750608444214,
0.6274998188018799,
-0.47932207584381104,
0.6201319098472595,
-0.2151467502117157,
-1.140079140663147,
-0.33968284726142883,
0.6307498216629028,
-0.16272899508476257,
0.19079343974590302,
1.0013803243637085,
0.6067408919334412,
0.08113347738981247,
-0.024098405614495277,
0.25476858019828796,
0.5606072545051575,
0.1708739995956421,
0.5116239190101624,
1.1574945449829102,
-0.5080887675285339,
0.606671154499054,
-0.2937534749507904,
-0.7083526253700256,
0.01972680725157261,
-1.0300310850143433,
-0.7545838356018066,
-0.5778765678405762,
-0.6234325766563416,
-0.484251469373703,
-0.008204043842852116,
0.1524749994277954,
0.31907257437705994,
-0.5446323156356812,
0.15266677737236023,
-0.24504688382148743,
0.28799715638160706,
-0.24617016315460205,
-0.2734130620956421,
0.4359971880912781,
-0.480091392993927,
-0.8651760220527649,
0.6301760077476501,
0.3294914960861206,
-0.13527238368988037,
-0.40114936232566833,
0.017789611592888832,
0.17468476295471191,
0.10936161130666733,
0.6931847333908081,
0.02555837109684944,
-0.6553760766983032,
-0.07537344843149185,
-0.40661749243736267,
-0.09235596656799316,
-0.19741585850715637,
0.5422101020812988,
-0.8936014771461487,
0.8493706583976746,
0.44316983222961426,
0.5237540006637573,
0.11252949386835098,
0.13577735424041748,
0.6093754172325134,
-0.5548933744430542,
-0.1826094090938568,
0.009781574830412865,
-0.02878434956073761,
0.4948013722896576,
-0.5217736959457397,
0.5763304829597473,
0.0138310631737113,
-0.7453233003616333,
-0.8072333335876465,
0.3005504906177521,
-0.8208385109901428,
-0.2552529275417328,
1.1719012260437012,
0.050198063254356384,
0.24096597731113434,
-0.1829448640346527,
-0.3215160071849823,
0.36553457379341125,
-0.050898030400276184,
1.1179840564727783,
0.4018959701061249,
0.007421781308948994,
0.1638268083333969,
-0.7161436676979065,
0.46258383989334106,
0.1628376692533493,
-1.1505134105682373,
0.12142088264226913,
0.8914675712585449,
0.04100603982806206,
-0.06302881240844727,
0.5234542489051819,
-0.12717203795909882,
0.19069012999534607,
0.23197324573993683,
-0.05619518458843231,
-0.11954851448535919,
-0.4002898335456848,
-0.5189539194107056,
-0.06318644434213638,
0.10488171130418777,
-0.1965961456298828
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11473v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11473v1
|
Word Order's Impacts: Insights from Reordering and Generation Analysis
| 2024-03-18T04:45:44 | 2024-03-18T04:45:44 |
Qinghua Zhao, Jiaang Li, Lei Li, Zenghui Zhou, Junfeng Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Existing works have studied the impacts of the order of words within natural
text. They usually analyze it by destroying the original order of words to
create a scrambled sequence, and then comparing the models' performance between
the original and scrambled sequences. The experimental results demonstrate
marginal drops. Considering this findings, different hypothesis about word
order is proposed, including ``the order of words is redundant with lexical
semantics'', and ``models do not rely on word order''. In this paper, we
revisit the aforementioned hypotheses by adding a order reconstruction
perspective, and selecting datasets of different spectrum. Specifically, we
first select four different datasets, and then design order reconstruction and
continuing generation tasks. Empirical findings support that ChatGPT relies on
word order to infer, but cannot support or negate the redundancy relations
between word order lexical semantics.
|
[
-0.29306480288505554,
-0.6335623264312744,
0.173762708902359,
-0.09673841297626495,
-0.22036895155906677,
-0.04843169450759888,
0.18901418149471283,
-0.7603893280029297,
0.37400105595588684,
0.7896340489387512,
-0.4995877742767334,
-0.05941324308514595,
-0.8837475776672363,
0.28033944964408875,
-0.6625084280967712,
1.1681756973266602,
0.37791547179222107,
-0.21751098334789276,
0.04297160729765892,
-0.25819161534309387,
-0.7273586392402649,
-0.4453333020210266,
-0.5131976008415222,
-0.298799991607666,
0.5941809415817261,
0.43199285864830017,
1.297265648841858,
0.689225971698761,
0.44791409373283386,
0.4014318883419037,
-0.246085986495018,
0.10080907493829727,
-0.8770091533660889,
0.034814126789569855,
-0.0009597805910743773,
-0.3709401488304138,
-0.0529530830681324,
0.40736180543899536,
0.4290538430213928,
0.9662092328071594,
-0.2513144612312317,
-0.11153733730316162,
0.10767305642366409,
0.7188228368759155,
-0.7842610478401184,
0.19986113905906677,
-0.9258445501327515,
0.02749333530664444,
-0.022731462493538857,
-0.3665259778499603,
-0.5378168225288391,
-0.36489129066467285,
0.6730184555053711,
-0.2698584198951721,
0.43204358220100403,
0.14779400825500488,
0.9386000633239746,
-0.11764586716890335,
-0.29270732402801514,
-0.2578703761100769,
-0.8303078413009644,
0.6020660996437073,
-0.5306768417358398,
0.5055238604545593,
0.4470152258872986,
-0.12898938357830048,
-0.6360422968864441,
-0.8728272914886475,
-0.5601003170013428,
0.09944411367177963,
-0.12240038812160492,
0.5949831604957581,
-0.05889670178294182,
0.23248417675495148,
0.1882338672876358,
0.6026188731193542,
-0.29108938574790955,
-0.014428063295781612,
-0.6006786823272705,
-0.044739022850990295,
0.5350366234779358,
0.3025573194026947,
0.5607709288597107,
-0.5203119516372681,
-0.26564696431159973,
-0.34126996994018555,
-0.8273945450782776,
-0.11431998014450073,
0.21351130306720734,
0.4290270209312439,
0.14360570907592773,
0.7637901306152344,
-0.13594257831573486,
0.49870064854621887,
-0.25164344906806946,
0.04276910424232483,
0.28563380241394043,
-0.3442520499229431,
-0.4106115996837616,
0.13222114741802216,
0.812542736530304,
0.44993695616722107,
-0.00637361453846097,
-0.21634916961193085,
-0.028336195275187492,
0.047338422387838364,
0.43885454535484314,
-0.5708977580070496,
-0.27572962641716003,
-0.018792200833559036,
-0.3336150050163269,
-0.1106235682964325,
0.14170867204666138,
-0.6097185015678406,
-0.35663312673568726,
-0.22407642006874084,
0.5338274240493774,
-0.6279722452163696,
-0.1312338262796402,
0.1901765614748001,
-0.35009726881980896,
0.39056679606437683,
0.2180657833814621,
-0.9392885565757751,
0.22694271802902222,
0.91219162940979,
0.6074486970901489,
0.14234475791454315,
-0.4848027229309082,
-0.004346858710050583,
-0.17298386991024017,
-0.45001283288002014,
0.8042103052139282,
-0.6045802235603333,
-0.8576207160949707,
0.20621415972709656,
0.11259441077709198,
-0.08670743554830551,
-0.3606652021408081,
0.7466139793395996,
-0.6384309530258179,
0.7308196425437927,
-0.6069642901420593,
-0.8620381951332092,
-0.4926105737686157,
-0.20688647031784058,
-0.3715294599533081,
0.7537809014320374,
-0.29602816700935364,
-1.003115177154541,
0.7083972096443176,
-0.05192314460873604,
-0.6363213062286377,
0.17326191067695618,
-0.28393837809562683,
-0.16097654402256012,
0.5075995922088623,
-0.12071018666028976,
0.30761343240737915,
0.007252927869558334,
-0.18582092225551605,
-0.2155824452638626,
-0.27456656098365784,
-0.12001662701368332,
-0.3587515354156494,
0.6927617192268372,
0.19075067341327667,
-0.14721128344535828,
-0.4373290240764618,
-0.8529590964317322,
0.1296536773443222,
0.2040315419435501,
-0.5980529189109802,
-0.3228949308395386,
0.8018153309822083,
-0.0573551319539547,
0.04626574367284775,
-0.23324303328990936,
-0.7604596018791199,
0.0932123214006424,
-0.6894884705543518,
0.47871458530426025,
0.548653781414032,
0.20817403495311737,
0.48390382528305054,
-0.30618202686309814,
0.3101740777492523,
-0.2899896800518036,
0.045752521604299545,
0.21143291890621185,
-0.7973675727844238,
-0.6217365860939026,
-0.04328182339668274,
0.20210833847522736,
0.63326495885849,
-0.7107767462730408,
0.04785720258951187,
-0.6840183138847351,
-0.3694886863231659,
-0.20703232288360596,
-0.5890805125236511,
0.4355435073375702,
0.3007701635360718,
0.14111395180225372,
-0.31851089000701904,
-0.6647661924362183,
-0.8723223805427551,
-0.480525404214859,
-0.3841606676578522,
0.010688425973057747,
0.22646337747573853,
0.24771648645401,
-0.11964403092861176,
0.9613850116729736,
-0.7963381409645081,
0.28311318159103394,
-0.25019365549087524,
0.258588969707489,
-0.0014489140594378114,
0.16407105326652527,
0.3345127999782562,
-0.514557421207428,
0.11640588194131851,
-0.15427541732788086,
-0.49382758140563965,
-0.0994989424943924,
0.11897489428520203,
-0.40920767188072205,
0.20338013768196106,
0.3404979109764099,
-0.48010900616645813,
0.6266731023788452,
0.46843135356903076,
-0.24199049174785614,
0.49630308151245117,
-0.3520091772079468,
0.07498888671398163,
-1.339196801185608,
-0.3562234044075012,
-0.603123128414154,
0.15613050758838654,
-0.9051353931427002,
-0.3411968946456909,
-0.13134890794754028,
-0.174471914768219,
-0.25838321447372437,
0.11484051495790482,
-0.5324435234069824,
-0.3351755142211914,
-0.4431402087211609,
0.13762009143829346,
0.10732324421405792,
0.13844947516918182,
0.04010438546538353,
0.3689611554145813,
-0.21467290818691254,
-0.493625670671463,
-0.3094136416912079,
0.5531089305877686,
-0.6093513369560242,
0.05558376759290695,
-0.5578796863555908,
-0.020828725770115852,
-0.2936948239803314,
-0.05326685309410095,
-1.3364238739013672,
-0.0783948302268982,
0.2426493763923645,
-0.5179323554039001,
0.398514062166214,
-0.0729244202375412,
-0.6959524154663086,
-0.251129686832428,
-0.16873116791248322,
0.18597513437271118,
0.5777971148490906,
-0.3848131597042084,
-0.040532682090997696,
0.5038807988166809,
0.04733246937394142,
-0.4800068736076355,
-0.652089536190033,
0.1517105996608734,
0.0015182403149083257,
-0.5233201384544373,
0.38911423087120056,
0.1342352032661438,
-0.2881636917591095,
-0.24825094640254974,
-0.11596757918596268,
0.04705832153558731,
0.009993902407586575,
0.30347517132759094,
0.37851667404174805,
0.002486542798578739,
0.30071792006492615,
-0.0779656320810318,
0.1502961814403534,
0.14363603293895721,
0.03182399272918701,
0.3835993707180023,
0.3183196187019348,
-0.025282490998506546,
0.175473153591156,
0.33358460664749146,
0.6209573745727539,
-0.05548553913831711,
0.8142122626304626,
0.0526413656771183,
-0.28146398067474365,
0.025589393451809883,
-0.5452658534049988,
0.2403419315814972,
-0.5568419098854065,
0.4595142602920532,
-0.15021462738513947,
-0.41985973715782166,
0.3437378704547882,
0.5342161655426025,
0.5549557209014893,
0.4206903576850891,
0.3620695173740387,
-0.14639845490455627,
0.6473701000213623,
0.6350052952766418,
-0.17401060461997986,
0.8950875997543335,
-0.20441551506519318,
0.14939655363559723,
-0.6389716267585754,
-0.006465117912739515,
-0.37670621275901794,
-0.20389407873153687,
-0.9766871333122253,
0.031226057559251785,
-0.18178918957710266,
-0.017372341826558113,
-0.16383349895477295,
0.4949149191379547,
-0.6765711307525635,
0.6606590747833252,
0.30370861291885376,
0.21946310997009277,
0.25619369745254517,
0.37908124923706055,
0.1517041176557541,
0.087178535759449,
-0.7318753004074097,
-0.3104466497898102,
0.8069813251495361,
-0.17509911954402924,
0.3336575925350189,
0.09005483984947205,
0.8496334552764893,
0.027458352968096733,
0.11800228804349899,
-0.8990899324417114,
0.6265509128570557,
-0.3833131492137909,
-0.3481810688972473,
-0.1086801066994667,
-0.31437385082244873,
-1.8460924625396729,
0.6687407493591309,
-0.19529135525226593,
-0.7420182228088379,
0.3511176109313965,
-0.38848623633384705,
-0.38761237263679504,
-0.060552068054676056,
-1.0285383462905884,
0.4656349718570709,
0.10387677699327469,
-0.09870700538158417,
-0.12007062882184982,
-0.49953320622444153,
0.37805914878845215,
0.40352916717529297,
0.2886306047439575,
-0.16148626804351807,
0.20348221063613892,
1.0208215713500977,
-1.0539610385894775,
0.7850189805030823,
0.09198147803544998,
-0.24079763889312744,
0.4677177667617798,
0.27380672097206116,
0.40088361501693726,
-0.4701838493347168,
0.028914067894220352,
0.040182169526815414,
0.1671295166015625,
-0.2804660201072693,
-0.2892346680164337,
0.6348140835762024,
-0.8137161135673523,
-0.5601719617843628,
-0.40051430463790894,
-0.5272055864334106,
-0.24209004640579224,
0.31204667687416077,
0.8328467607498169,
0.8902167081832886,
-0.022959550842642784,
-0.2756389081478119,
0.08089414238929749,
-0.2987717390060425,
0.6627142429351807,
0.24354258179664612,
-0.19031348824501038,
-0.685754656791687,
0.9127407073974609,
0.8829310536384583,
0.5106907486915588,
0.1805906593799591,
0.21526232361793518,
-0.2162686437368393,
-0.7372061014175415,
0.16535229980945587,
0.19084356725215912,
-0.6746193766593933,
0.14218388497829437,
-0.582674503326416,
-0.20798854529857635,
-0.3524343967437744,
-0.24926505982875824,
-0.34465503692626953,
-0.30101385712623596,
-0.06725680083036423,
-0.0707908496260643,
0.4622667729854584,
1.0504974126815796,
0.2221553921699524,
0.22327741980552673,
-0.8877638578414917,
0.19291122257709503,
0.09857334941625595,
0.2995241582393646,
0.10370398312807083,
-0.4564288854598999,
0.027022426947951317,
0.06595276296138763,
-0.36464425921440125,
-0.9722632169723511,
0.5357933044433594,
0.16330088675022125,
0.3982807397842407,
0.25068265199661255,
0.0135249188169837,
0.9842939972877502,
-0.7646008729934692,
0.7015011310577393,
0.1912723183631897,
-0.5497305989265442,
0.3916397988796234,
-0.5743417739868164,
0.4481477439403534,
0.45465826988220215,
-0.01630360819399357,
-0.7977732419967651,
-0.43938350677490234,
-0.9491397738456726,
-1.2425330877304077,
0.7553252577781677,
0.6391803622245789,
0.1005120575428009,
-0.6696944832801819,
0.5900091528892517,
0.21195316314697266,
0.08638513088226318,
-0.2411477267742157,
-0.23439238965511322,
-0.1353285163640976,
0.10415799915790558,
-0.19381289184093475,
-0.35904696583747864,
0.32642078399658203,
-0.13376225531101227,
0.364504337310791,
0.47109124064445496,
0.4303485155105591,
0.17734654247760773,
-0.17039871215820312,
0.35143083333969116,
0.13768596947193146,
0.5178452134132385,
0.41207048296928406,
-0.026931945234537125,
-0.026763509958982468,
0.07252267003059387,
-0.8387105464935303,
-0.21395838260650635,
-0.3724638819694519,
-0.25924816727638245,
0.09940700232982635,
0.5735984444618225,
0.5504233837127686,
0.6114477515220642,
-0.38188183307647705,
0.14543025195598602,
-0.04612123593688011,
-0.1699853539466858,
-0.19351698458194733,
-0.19102729856967926,
-0.024137107655405998,
0.04501938074827194,
0.06337322294712067,
0.015443325974047184,
0.1968509554862976,
-0.7879467010498047,
0.268348753452301,
0.43880578875541687,
-0.05721520632505417,
-0.4695866107940674,
0.2585752606391907,
-0.091190867125988,
-0.4336403012275696,
0.9825721979141235,
0.010320224799215794,
-0.5317290425300598,
0.7271100282669067,
0.4643826186656952,
0.9776891469955444,
0.06007707864046097,
0.1183793693780899,
0.3148787319660187,
0.3017524778842926,
-0.36325669288635254,
0.5266059041023254,
0.24814699590206146,
-0.898628294467926,
-0.2908816337585449,
-0.4423730671405792,
-0.271140456199646,
0.014182536862790585,
-0.6172093152999878,
0.19573469460010529,
-0.7130714058876038,
-0.21810007095336914,
0.11401316523551941,
-0.10432414710521698,
-0.39841800928115845,
-0.04127604141831398,
0.18213865160942078,
0.5493508577346802,
-0.4913078546524048,
0.45837467908859253,
0.2871423661708832,
-0.41521549224853516,
-0.7839340567588806,
0.19749930500984192,
0.13470791280269623,
-0.943730890750885,
0.5998547077178955,
0.28126296401023865,
-0.20470589399337769,
-0.04032239317893982,
-0.3274271488189697,
-1.2742935419082642,
0.8774867057800293,
0.13211454451084137,
-0.07850062847137451,
0.18508854508399963,
0.2824269235134125,
0.7727591395378113,
-0.00915743038058281,
0.2339080572128296,
0.37684866786003113,
0.0639917179942131,
0.39091891050338745,
-0.8147953152656555,
-0.1149161085486412,
-0.11682898551225662,
0.19102628529071808,
0.8045600056648254,
-0.4799771010875702,
0.6966102719306946,
-0.12858915328979492,
-1.0258976221084595,
0.19035476446151733,
0.47027215361595154,
-0.2934150695800781,
-0.08092200756072998,
0.3338395357131958,
0.5685272812843323,
0.5113139748573303,
-0.010997317731380463,
1.234106183052063,
-0.20835375785827637,
0.470577210187912,
1.1803083419799805,
-0.1318005919456482,
1.1887608766555786,
0.2884862720966339,
-0.5554367303848267,
0.24574331939220428,
0.888516366481781,
0.02409280836582184,
0.6412758827209473,
0.26054781675338745,
-0.009630761109292507,
0.18174469470977783,
0.09058019518852234,
-0.3682362139225006,
0.6850778460502625,
0.3970370590686798,
-0.32789289951324463,
-0.393530935049057,
-0.2297811508178711,
0.12327391654253006,
-0.4715961515903473,
-0.23370656371116638,
0.8339368104934692,
0.06034424528479576,
-0.7474499940872192,
0.8853902816772461,
-0.38649001717567444,
0.36970165371894836,
-0.2614193558692932,
0.08882298320531845,
-0.42499834299087524,
0.22697731852531433,
-0.3087265193462372,
-0.5668834447860718,
0.4599311351776123,
-0.5331035852432251,
-0.2858262360095978,
-0.08208893239498138,
0.46945488452911377,
-0.24303580820560455,
-0.5401963591575623,
0.2527405619621277,
0.46226105093955994,
0.170163094997406,
0.3472241163253784,
-0.30852022767066956,
-0.19370883703231812,
-0.211406871676445,
-0.5696015357971191,
0.39674028754234314,
0.4001756012439728,
0.17257367074489594,
0.5122578144073486,
0.49008339643478394,
-0.2234433889389038,
0.398044228553772,
-0.10913414508104324,
0.41601037979125977,
-0.5890958905220032,
-0.3047628402709961,
-0.8540362119674683,
0.08741312474012375,
0.07720662653446198,
-0.315494179725647,
0.8073055148124695,
0.32999998331069946,
0.8254011869430542,
0.08315984904766083,
0.6284471750259399,
-0.21253857016563416,
0.23814931511878967,
-0.3002214729785919,
0.646796464920044,
-0.4284125566482544,
0.29525357484817505,
-0.6218737363815308,
-0.7644444108009338,
-0.3362375497817993,
0.19322924315929413,
-0.5708653926849365,
-0.0018505239859223366,
0.7807992696762085,
0.8074144124984741,
0.16401848196983337,
0.4407159388065338,
0.33470118045806885,
0.25920039415359497,
0.15543457865715027,
0.23032964766025543,
0.8109464049339294,
-0.7163954377174377,
0.5587970614433289,
-0.317604660987854,
-0.07684876769781113,
0.0892275869846344,
-0.49373337626457214,
-0.4926243722438812,
-0.5318565368652344,
-0.18976585566997528,
-0.48211830854415894,
0.04714281111955643,
0.8492409586906433,
0.006980210077017546,
-0.4049175977706909,
-0.11281701177358627,
-0.2489062398672104,
0.035145580768585205,
-0.19555774331092834,
-0.25205910205841064,
0.6273699402809143,
-0.41375985741615295,
-0.6521446108818054,
0.17924629151821136,
0.08359012752771378,
0.07868976891040802,
0.38661569356918335,
0.36285796761512756,
-0.31988146901130676,
0.3330419957637787,
1.1451945304870605,
0.43536972999572754,
-0.8755531311035156,
-0.886371374130249,
-0.0851140022277832,
-0.030424656346440315,
0.2736242711544037,
0.6998273134231567,
-0.783783495426178,
0.30767279863357544,
1.1318020820617676,
0.49864739179611206,
-0.05762756988406181,
-0.1614929735660553,
0.6547259092330933,
-0.5172910690307617,
-0.20422768592834473,
-0.23850710690021515,
0.7024551630020142,
-0.1774655282497406,
-0.2654658555984497,
0.5316784381866455,
0.5154163241386414,
-0.5668609738349915,
-0.6152377128601074,
0.5077587962150574,
-0.8269303441047668,
-0.45675116777420044,
1.2045259475708008,
0.0025080968625843525,
-0.12969465553760529,
-0.2415248602628708,
-0.3421882092952728,
0.3719756305217743,
-0.17585767805576324,
1.088819980621338,
0.8403565287590027,
-0.21541725099086761,
-0.12341189384460449,
-0.5208668112754822,
0.27420297265052795,
0.6526341438293457,
-0.39378783106803894,
0.39977729320526123,
0.7517974972724915,
0.271939218044281,
0.280631959438324,
0.5597588419914246,
-0.20532725751399994,
-0.06283382326364517,
0.20513157546520233,
0.021567681804299355,
0.2967981994152069,
0.18582703173160553,
-0.16243241727352142,
0.35269930958747864,
-0.08623052388429642,
-0.544665515422821
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11456v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11456v3
|
HateCOT: An Explanation-Enhanced Dataset for Generalizable Offensive Speech Detection via Large Language Models
| 2024-03-18T04:12:35 | 2024-06-16T20:55:25 |
Huy Nghiem, Hal Daumé III
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SI
|
The widespread use of social media necessitates reliable and efficient
detection of offensive content to mitigate harmful effects. Although
sophisticated models perform well on individual datasets, they often fail to
generalize due to varying definitions and labeling of "offensive content." In
this paper, we introduce HateCOT, an English dataset with over 52,000 samples
from diverse sources, featuring explanations generated by GPT-3.5Turbo and
curated by humans. We demonstrate that pretraining on HateCOT significantly
enhances the performance of open-source Large Language Models on three
benchmark datasets for offensive content detection in both zero-shot and
few-shot settings, despite differences in domain and task. Additionally,
HateCOT facilitates effective K-shot fine-tuning of LLMs with limited data and
improves the quality of their explanations, as confirmed by our human
evaluation.
|
[
-0.3487214744091034,
-0.8287534713745117,
0.1498354971408844,
-0.15186774730682373,
-0.5605905055999756,
0.011552279815077782,
-0.4202038645744324,
-0.6054660081863403,
-0.007654543034732342,
0.45034995675086975,
-0.4715022146701813,
-0.724904477596283,
-1.0009326934814453,
0.07232864946126938,
-0.6806338429450989,
1.2279090881347656,
0.20113709568977356,
-0.1440453976392746,
0.3887568414211273,
-0.14087699353694916,
-0.0608086921274662,
-0.39119836688041687,
-0.849031388759613,
-0.07700436562299728,
0.8823106288909912,
0.49667781591415405,
0.7474378943443298,
0.6632182002067566,
0.44659703969955444,
0.20872458815574646,
0.03460952267050743,
0.39065536856651306,
-0.9109828472137451,
0.3009444773197174,
-0.3536888659000397,
-0.261707603931427,
-0.20370492339134216,
-0.007488831877708435,
0.18388338387012482,
0.14052380621433258,
-0.03934292495250702,
-0.028409689664840698,
-0.02819225564599037,
0.10251380503177643,
-0.6839893460273743,
-0.3057420253753662,
-0.9810545444488525,
-0.02026551589369774,
-0.36530590057373047,
-0.10207221657037735,
-0.32200556993484497,
-0.06519070267677307,
-0.0663328468799591,
-0.7209391593933105,
0.6119520664215088,
0.03251059353351593,
0.4607146382331848,
0.13296006619930267,
-0.3699372410774231,
-0.3425524830818176,
-0.7213332056999207,
0.8040034770965576,
-0.651767909526825,
0.508539080619812,
0.4412365257740021,
0.3549257218837738,
-0.04843594878911972,
-0.6154574155807495,
-0.7223316431045532,
-0.02745940163731575,
-0.0741257518529892,
0.034843847155570984,
-0.48976951837539673,
0.19609121978282928,
0.31651368737220764,
0.15051662921905518,
-0.6434655785560608,
0.5775393843650818,
-0.21124635636806488,
-0.4667624235153198,
0.6125210523605347,
0.07493837177753448,
0.5698915123939514,
-0.04539092257618904,
-0.011962630786001682,
0.14738014340400696,
-0.6609839200973511,
-0.43734100461006165,
0.6303919553756714,
0.6002426743507385,
-0.39574459195137024,
0.26036766171455383,
0.07542867213487625,
0.5572122931480408,
-0.21053838729858398,
0.20862706005573273,
0.024953119456768036,
0.13344675302505493,
-0.2510174512863159,
-0.11325901001691818,
0.890785276889801,
0.46160727739334106,
0.7964543104171753,
-0.24466107785701752,
-0.11575533449649811,
0.3046785295009613,
0.19313941895961761,
-0.9696457386016846,
-0.3409517705440521,
0.2955610454082489,
-0.15108303725719452,
-0.5664560198783875,
-0.324360191822052,
-0.8570383787155151,
-0.6966550350189209,
-0.30805617570877075,
-0.09502280503511429,
-0.4563969075679779,
-0.3928472399711609,
-0.09904684126377106,
-0.3310371935367584,
0.0990673378109932,
0.4398761987686157,
-0.9843941926956177,
0.3499266505241394,
0.6724950671195984,
0.7503785490989685,
-0.5947737693786621,
-0.1517605185508728,
-0.7529081106185913,
0.06578493118286133,
-0.45060020685195923,
0.7627106308937073,
-0.6949542164802551,
-0.10165274143218994,
0.035111311823129654,
0.09004837274551392,
0.3351137638092041,
-0.6391487717628479,
0.6861432790756226,
-0.5505226254463196,
0.2069435864686966,
-0.0036587028298527002,
-0.23140065371990204,
0.12346412986516953,
0.0818277969956398,
-0.34123530983924866,
0.7133592367172241,
0.20324555039405823,
-0.9929257035255432,
0.7071011662483215,
-0.8755670189857483,
-0.6139207482337952,
0.2824747562408447,
-0.022146740928292274,
-0.458437979221344,
0.06493508070707321,
0.5294932126998901,
0.41261619329452515,
-0.17571477591991425,
0.28292620182037354,
-0.493026465177536,
-0.36871597170829773,
-0.059127479791641235,
-0.5359431505203247,
1.0262013673782349,
0.5646060109138489,
-0.4268951714038849,
0.158445343375206,
-0.520078718662262,
-0.21097931265830994,
0.4625875949859619,
0.12430224567651749,
-0.44968798756599426,
0.01065745484083891,
0.12562121450901031,
-0.029013363644480705,
-0.1758250594139099,
-0.8230522871017456,
-0.3712172210216522,
-0.32267799973487854,
0.51691073179245,
0.8588547110557556,
-0.07658437639474869,
-0.04883277788758278,
-0.31104350090026855,
0.7752496004104614,
0.42368483543395996,
0.28583163022994995,
0.019644644111394882,
-0.5140030980110168,
-0.22827747464179993,
-0.30571508407592773,
-0.1010313406586647,
0.45315685868263245,
-0.6026251912117004,
-0.04217616096138954,
-0.16105839610099792,
-0.37148332595825195,
-0.5110669136047363,
0.1307476907968521,
0.2820124626159668,
0.5381814241409302,
0.5077168345451355,
-0.002814787905663252,
-0.8913995027542114,
-0.907496452331543,
-0.6119945049285889,
-0.04641268774867058,
-0.2969754636287689,
0.6085233688354492,
0.44706112146377563,
-0.10354626178741455,
0.7672203183174133,
-0.30182453989982605,
-0.05208021402359009,
-0.18533478677272797,
0.2066446989774704,
0.23622070252895355,
0.08851708471775055,
0.6314632296562195,
-0.8363474011421204,
-0.6976513862609863,
0.02512170374393463,
-0.36282142996788025,
-0.621405303478241,
0.3352508544921875,
-0.016282139346003532,
-0.08923254162073135,
0.33887508511543274,
-0.22585678100585938,
0.2237720638513565,
0.5339638590812683,
-0.24930930137634277,
0.729162335395813,
0.22992409765720367,
0.3688942492008209,
-0.9144734740257263,
-0.23791097104549408,
-0.06248855963349342,
-0.5669029951095581,
-0.8821808099746704,
-0.012574952095746994,
-0.0547410249710083,
-0.2288699895143509,
-0.8054574728012085,
0.32782915234565735,
-0.0116261662915349,
0.32935991883277893,
-0.19909319281578064,
0.47395744919776917,
-0.10767900198698044,
0.3203366994857788,
-0.20102469623088837,
0.7886291146278381,
0.5399224758148193,
-0.40574514865875244,
0.5156686305999756,
0.03582260385155678,
-0.13148996233940125,
0.7336905002593994,
-0.5274622440338135,
0.4278751015663147,
-0.2751410901546478,
-0.00007296662079170346,
-1.2557767629623413,
-0.5089008212089539,
0.4937005937099457,
-0.6153270602226257,
0.09440506994724274,
-0.4790273606777191,
-0.21607808768749237,
-0.5601935982704163,
-0.2775266766548157,
0.4149094820022583,
0.3672369420528412,
-0.810875415802002,
0.3472314774990082,
0.5816926956176758,
0.08170768618583679,
-0.5495132207870483,
-0.8078137636184692,
0.08703862130641937,
-0.5125657916069031,
-0.3930545449256897,
0.1830568164587021,
-0.13522669672966003,
-0.2807559669017792,
-0.19370388984680176,
-0.006232556886970997,
-0.27310052514076233,
0.1086864173412323,
0.31331002712249756,
0.005959799978882074,
-0.28027966618537903,
0.2704940140247345,
-0.05669859051704407,
0.3788815140724182,
0.001523805083706975,
-0.38762056827545166,
0.4444819390773773,
0.38442322611808777,
-0.1755485087633133,
-0.30923616886138916,
0.3347497284412384,
0.5124551653862,
0.12930552661418915,
0.5419577956199646,
0.628148078918457,
-0.3074493706226349,
-0.5770441889762878,
-0.3630617558956146,
-0.030373575165867805,
-0.487228125333786,
0.37359026074409485,
-0.10510583221912384,
-1.1150341033935547,
0.37806594371795654,
0.4735743999481201,
0.14753195643424988,
0.4353548586368561,
0.4785674810409546,
-0.020585715770721436,
0.9732632637023926,
0.10443512350320816,
-0.21111062169075012,
0.4360823333263397,
0.17897345125675201,
0.17914336919784546,
-0.43707865476608276,
0.16671209037303925,
-0.6394250988960266,
-0.1662343591451645,
-0.5849284529685974,
-0.5196886658668518,
-0.047819528728723526,
-0.43495965003967285,
-0.48596638441085815,
0.31321418285369873,
-0.8049180507659912,
0.9103890657424927,
0.11359309405088425,
0.15295568108558655,
0.24203690886497498,
0.2460109293460846,
0.013433494605123997,
-0.1556442230939865,
-0.47759097814559937,
-0.24007311463356018,
1.1699209213256836,
0.38416221737861633,
0.7100909948348999,
0.2172749638557434,
0.4013291895389557,
0.8063973188400269,
0.587292492389679,
-0.8590088486671448,
0.2291112244129181,
-0.782085120677948,
-0.8511397242546082,
-0.24823978543281555,
-0.6305302977561951,
-0.8935162425041199,
0.18179506063461304,
0.06021232157945633,
-0.7567256093025208,
-0.10711869597434998,
0.5219742655754089,
-0.1800113469362259,
0.43568170070648193,
-0.8618654012680054,
0.5489515066146851,
-0.2786645293235779,
-0.3252478837966919,
-0.10345382988452911,
-0.09714340418577194,
0.4464835822582245,
-0.23921117186546326,
0.5481043457984924,
-0.21300797164440155,
-0.15408717095851898,
1.0540052652359009,
-0.2706362307071686,
0.9166157245635986,
-0.548606812953949,
-0.2785537540912628,
0.2983868420124054,
0.05815412104129791,
0.5111258625984192,
-0.36261802911758423,
-0.18781614303588867,
0.35432079434394836,
-0.39091095328330994,
-0.16444797813892365,
-0.5803260207176208,
0.6278283596038818,
-0.782156229019165,
-0.7247719764709473,
0.22982510924339294,
-0.557925820350647,
-0.3296970725059509,
0.27816784381866455,
0.4666227102279663,
0.4056220054626465,
-0.21320472657680511,
0.28281253576278687,
0.4721534550189972,
-0.32590270042419434,
-0.1494404673576355,
0.6274083256721497,
-0.4893881678581238,
-0.35746029019355774,
0.7410874962806702,
0.1306471824645996,
0.22746343910694122,
0.25599727034568787,
0.4005681574344635,
-0.27997729182243347,
-0.9220521450042725,
-0.13002783060073853,
0.12735000252723694,
-0.6065388917922974,
-0.14497415721416473,
-0.8645353317260742,
-0.13331744074821472,
-0.643315851688385,
-0.03959261626005173,
-0.0988374650478363,
-0.22038201987743378,
-0.19148190319538116,
-0.20067749917507172,
0.5096806287765503,
0.9296194314956665,
-0.2931654751300812,
0.9117100238800049,
-0.10587653517723083,
0.7802329063415527,
0.4029166102409363,
0.6245847940444946,
-0.06703733652830124,
-1.151307463645935,
-0.18851782381534576,
0.3704187870025635,
-0.26308467984199524,
-0.8493286967277527,
0.2833958566188812,
0.23028510808944702,
0.3454241454601288,
0.6995981931686401,
0.012180270627140999,
0.6373945474624634,
-0.4282762408256531,
0.6653934121131897,
0.15395613014698029,
-0.7459393739700317,
0.5823351144790649,
-0.6444637179374695,
0.20105640590190887,
0.15423113107681274,
0.7313568592071533,
-0.7841013669967651,
-0.7179661989212036,
-0.5124392509460449,
-0.6431415677070618,
0.9209499955177307,
0.19619137048721313,
0.3277953863143921,
-0.3498900830745697,
-0.07521481812000275,
0.15743933618068695,
-0.09623875468969345,
-0.620616614818573,
-0.17255808413028717,
-0.3322031497955322,
-0.16085101664066315,
-0.017872795462608337,
-0.4744587540626526,
-0.25004348158836365,
-0.161909818649292,
0.7030124068260193,
0.1344374716281891,
0.15608683228492737,
-0.039732880890369415,
-0.32690224051475525,
-0.3736459016799927,
0.23722918331623077,
0.5211761593818665,
0.6114320755004883,
-0.15473408997058868,
0.25331559777259827,
0.26252591609954834,
-0.729303777217865,
0.16558928787708282,
-0.06900826096534729,
0.13684307038784027,
0.05035889893770218,
0.5580365657806396,
0.8142490386962891,
-0.010555770248174667,
-0.49579766392707825,
0.6403077840805054,
-0.15967029333114624,
-0.29861006140708923,
-0.0012770392931997776,
0.3801318407058716,
-0.04893546551465988,
-0.13222810626029968,
0.20077291131019592,
-0.40394240617752075,
0.04761412739753723,
-0.17474175989627838,
0.519403874874115,
0.4112662076950073,
-0.5199557542800903,
-0.22096902132034302,
0.8168789744377136,
0.21059739589691162,
-0.4983580708503723,
0.4679005444049835,
0.026996849104762077,
-0.5918484926223755,
0.7198399901390076,
0.720150887966156,
0.7110724449157715,
-0.4429132342338562,
0.37134671211242676,
0.3466324210166931,
0.40338850021362305,
0.6850922107696533,
-0.010557584464550018,
-0.13631172478199005,
-1.084635615348816,
-0.390301376581192,
-0.5755050778388977,
-0.4158707857131958,
0.7878261804580688,
-0.25559282302856445,
0.28344833850860596,
-0.6753584146499634,
0.053104840219020844,
0.49146825075149536,
-0.41603565216064453,
-0.7880033850669861,
0.26490673422813416,
0.46413570642471313,
0.9254823327064514,
-1.1346744298934937,
0.48139461874961853,
0.1605553925037384,
-0.005906305741518736,
-0.8322932124137878,
-0.06262831389904022,
0.2672875225543976,
-1.246945858001709,
0.5672186017036438,
0.16065770387649536,
-0.32492655515670776,
0.05906067416071892,
-0.9916455745697021,
-0.2790055274963379,
0.28243088722229004,
0.4700630307197571,
-0.8380944728851318,
0.18658331036567688,
0.38134342432022095,
0.6499090194702148,
-0.47763127088546753,
0.4563151001930237,
0.6519240736961365,
0.28032001852989197,
0.12480199337005615,
-0.46543121337890625,
-0.09138712286949158,
-0.06618677079677582,
-0.3498879373073578,
0.29337358474731445,
-0.1651136875152588,
0.5069494247436523,
0.03532591089606285,
-0.27126646041870117,
-0.511890709400177,
0.2881090044975281,
-0.005511209834367037,
0.17618468403816223,
0.7590598464012146,
0.40987834334373474,
0.8505252003669739,
0.08414686471223831,
0.965455949306488,
0.05392376706004143,
0.09997641295194626,
1.502666711807251,
-0.01460843812674284,
0.3305704593658447,
0.1046983003616333,
-0.35256099700927734,
0.3448810279369354,
0.5931193232536316,
-0.010861731134355068,
0.14472118020057678,
0.3990996479988098,
-0.3143833875656128,
-0.2250390499830246,
-0.5250893235206604,
-0.11994759738445282,
0.5767146944999695,
0.525791585445404,
-0.5703325867652893,
-0.48280271887779236,
0.2113172560930252,
0.30696800351142883,
-0.010876419954001904,
-0.46654418110847473,
0.7080937623977661,
0.03366465866565704,
-0.4913656711578369,
0.8697949051856995,
-0.34435901045799255,
0.7455754280090332,
-0.5262266397476196,
0.12669157981872559,
-0.2319251298904419,
-0.1476123034954071,
-0.34267836809158325,
-0.8141595721244812,
0.3064923882484436,
0.5245055556297302,
0.06377419829368591,
-0.11311294138431549,
0.8251098990440369,
-0.4372360408306122,
-0.02791549451649189,
0.5528103113174438,
0.1289636492729187,
0.4374266266822815,
-0.27443477511405945,
-0.7075358629226685,
0.03977617248892784,
0.09732390195131302,
-0.05363529548048973,
-0.019521916285157204,
0.6876752376556396,
-0.15256446599960327,
0.404098778963089,
0.7954428791999817,
0.41212743520736694,
-0.044767048209905624,
0.48846036195755005,
0.8347286581993103,
-0.43870148062705994,
-0.4097307324409485,
-1.1553423404693604,
0.37212395668029785,
-0.26450982689857483,
-0.21790865063667297,
0.4198159873485565,
0.4894319772720337,
0.8607024550437927,
0.07372637838125229,
1.0446856021881104,
-0.019449863582849503,
0.8174015879631042,
-0.1587153971195221,
0.7839215397834778,
-0.4347325265407562,
0.0209698174148798,
-0.3351351320743561,
-0.6269580721855164,
-0.5886200070381165,
0.21582907438278198,
-0.6334384083747864,
-0.03048275224864483,
0.547076940536499,
0.9795351624488831,
-0.5976942181587219,
0.14220771193504333,
0.7473330497741699,
0.7565075755119324,
0.6809815168380737,
0.2985617220401764,
0.7346551418304443,
0.04623733460903168,
0.7313360571861267,
-0.2063608467578888,
-0.3038015365600586,
-0.10860320925712585,
-0.9363806843757629,
-0.9596343636512756,
-0.2973896861076355,
-0.15246304869651794,
-0.18013231456279755,
0.3387252390384674,
0.8189120292663574,
0.8112232685089111,
-1.2160638570785522,
0.0470876507461071,
-0.07478519529104233,
0.21406391263008118,
0.34484589099884033,
-0.251369833946228,
0.20022884011268616,
-0.2221922129392624,
-0.6952428221702576,
0.23938746750354767,
0.22539572417736053,
0.0023386345710605383,
0.15104363858699799,
0.11693517118692398,
-0.13565267622470856,
0.17735779285430908,
0.6193448305130005,
0.18270327150821686,
-0.5066198706626892,
-0.6573304533958435,
-0.32764488458633423,
0.15018942952156067,
0.18074895441532135,
0.8469590544700623,
-0.413288414478302,
0.4992486238479614,
0.2086612433195114,
0.5244432091712952,
0.2755539119243622,
0.1593683958053589,
0.42879292368888855,
-0.692140519618988,
0.4403134882450104,
0.33858805894851685,
0.2086309939622879,
0.48723816871643066,
-0.5364885330200195,
0.45347368717193604,
0.32803279161453247,
-0.5772795081138611,
-0.729975163936615,
0.3400631546974182,
-0.5743786096572876,
-0.20775097608566284,
1.1534725427627563,
-0.21541637182235718,
-0.32235947251319885,
-0.5805525183677673,
-0.19963297247886658,
0.5243108868598938,
-0.5891671180725098,
0.7328991293907166,
0.8158590793609619,
0.1805049180984497,
-0.34510374069213867,
-0.49714818596839905,
0.6904711723327637,
0.23776546120643616,
-0.7237759828567505,
0.530657947063446,
0.5098182559013367,
0.3644084334373474,
-0.31054651737213135,
0.634117603302002,
-0.06631341576576233,
0.2976307272911072,
-0.2240370362997055,
-0.21849840879440308,
-0.15718135237693787,
-0.2959320843219757,
-0.2082134336233139,
0.06354105472564697,
-0.09035282582044601,
-0.1602717787027359
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11439v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11439v1
|
StyleChat: Learning Recitation-Augmented Memory in LLMs for Stylized Dialogue Generation
| 2024-03-18T03:26:18 | 2024-03-18T03:26:18 |
Jinpeng Li, Zekai Zhang, Quan Tu, Xin Cheng, Dongyan Zhao, Rui Yan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) demonstrate superior performance in generative
scenarios and have attracted widespread attention. Among them, stylized
dialogue generation is essential in the context of LLMs for building
intelligent and engaging dialogue agent. However the ability of LLMs is
data-driven and limited by data bias, leading to poor performance on specific
tasks. In particular, stylized dialogue generation suffers from a severe lack
of supervised data. Furthermore, although many prompt-based methods have been
proposed to accomplish specific tasks, their performance in complex real-world
scenarios involving a wide variety of dialog styles further enhancement. In
this work, we first introduce a stylized dialogue dataset StyleEval with 38
styles by leveraging the generative power of LLMs comprehensively, which has
been carefully constructed with rigorous human-led quality control. Based on
this, we propose the stylized dialogue framework StyleChat via
recitation-augmented memory strategy and multi-task style learning strategy to
promote generalization ability. To evaluate the effectiveness of our approach,
we created a test benchmark that included both a generation task and a choice
task to comprehensively evaluate trained models and assess whether styles and
preferences are remembered and understood. Experimental results show that our
proposed framework StyleChat outperforms all the baselines and helps to break
the style boundary of LLMs.
|
[
-0.2112729847431183,
-0.8721863031387329,
0.3313990831375122,
0.249505415558815,
-0.2653040885925293,
0.5091544985771179,
-0.31095996499061584,
-0.0698230117559433,
0.4671630263328552,
0.7045907378196716,
-0.786983847618103,
-0.7144603729248047,
-0.04973270371556282,
0.14140872657299042,
-0.1119382306933403,
0.7891860008239746,
-0.07448789477348328,
0.1558794379234314,
-0.1527785360813141,
0.047088608145713806,
-0.7777017951011658,
-0.6176468133926392,
-0.881745457649231,
-0.2631813585758209,
0.28049758076667786,
0.38330280780792236,
0.39656469225883484,
0.34168046712875366,
0.03339449688792229,
0.3318805992603302,
0.10602302104234695,
0.7068427801132202,
-0.8442901372909546,
0.7397950887680054,
0.07367914915084839,
-0.46095892786979675,
-0.469750314950943,
-0.11909844726324081,
0.6503939628601074,
0.394021213054657,
-0.4224265217781067,
-0.10162632167339325,
0.06264462321996689,
0.6073951721191406,
-0.26842600107192993,
0.5043444633483887,
-0.8663854002952576,
0.08326926082372665,
0.006347287446260452,
-0.5663040280342102,
-0.44761598110198975,
-0.31791937351226807,
-0.02998341992497444,
-0.5640674233436584,
0.17360123991966248,
0.26734599471092224,
0.46462059020996094,
0.011745830066502094,
-0.28958624601364136,
-0.17244908213615417,
-0.8621737360954285,
0.9100947976112366,
-0.5066831111907959,
0.4504278898239136,
0.2368568778038025,
0.3948895037174225,
-0.3027797043323517,
-0.7060049176216125,
-0.35231468081474304,
-0.1732466220855713,
0.1733458787202835,
0.08934132009744644,
0.01595027558505535,
0.11606638133525848,
0.1895420402288437,
0.2715596556663513,
-0.4371694028377533,
-0.22241128981113434,
-0.10921455919742584,
-0.27877092361450195,
0.45654988288879395,
0.5158876776695251,
0.17197667062282562,
-0.07451041787862778,
-0.28303200006484985,
-0.08309101313352585,
-0.5762837529182434,
-0.09812773019075394,
0.20702774822711945,
0.4131481647491455,
0.04870571196079254,
-0.01098392903804779,
-0.24428856372833252,
0.4150383770465851,
0.4055180251598358,
-0.4576151371002197,
0.35186901688575745,
-0.6390507221221924,
-0.098468117415905,
-0.16501279175281525,
0.7939108610153198,
0.5394607186317444,
0.3110883831977844,
-0.18830476701259613,
-0.22701644897460938,
-0.5440365672111511,
0.5276559591293335,
-0.8961822986602783,
-0.12541702389717102,
-0.12044937908649445,
-0.36699339747428894,
-0.30406349897384644,
-0.30308952927589417,
-0.9021865129470825,
-0.19533953070640564,
-0.5347360372543335,
0.047405291348695755,
-0.5767503976821899,
-0.17323313653469086,
-0.16408194601535797,
0.11619751900434494,
0.2137850821018219,
0.6560111045837402,
-1.0868399143218994,
0.2660098969936371,
0.38011226058006287,
0.857499897480011,
-0.2956664264202118,
0.041257113218307495,
-0.31306883692741394,
0.008320420049130917,
-0.5825222134590149,
0.457692950963974,
-0.7714187502861023,
-0.6881368160247803,
0.17160966992378235,
-0.08038676530122757,
-0.05715535953640938,
-0.6008504033088684,
0.24595695734024048,
-0.5091754198074341,
-0.1059393510222435,
-0.32808971405029297,
-0.36468636989593506,
-0.056860119104385376,
0.22147847712039948,
-0.5106285810470581,
0.9407292604446411,
0.25214695930480957,
-0.46077945828437805,
0.2793375253677368,
-0.4154219925403595,
-0.2861618399620056,
0.2525024116039276,
-0.4912063479423523,
-0.36234918236732483,
-0.18157728016376495,
0.22194762527942657,
0.668895959854126,
-0.2740141749382019,
0.38607850670814514,
-0.07051639258861542,
-0.4798385798931122,
0.31822484731674194,
-0.6951018571853638,
0.26600825786590576,
0.4187130630016327,
-0.08248372375965118,
0.1793547421693802,
-0.5832878351211548,
0.11647148430347443,
0.27853602170944214,
-0.3144620656967163,
-0.04930176958441734,
-0.3009270429611206,
0.14845770597457886,
-0.013703858479857445,
0.18404875695705414,
-0.4431689977645874,
0.39262962341308594,
-0.2536279261112213,
0.45188379287719727,
0.7804482579231262,
0.2929059863090515,
0.33324652910232544,
-0.643608808517456,
0.6234143376350403,
0.0009776345686987042,
-0.12206188589334488,
-0.5099928975105286,
-0.17816562950611115,
-0.7076579332351685,
-0.3055907189846039,
-0.08498212695121765,
0.6385177969932556,
-1.1240230798721313,
0.18035367131233215,
-0.127454936504364,
-0.47160425782203674,
-0.3921922743320465,
0.36155274510383606,
0.4388231337070465,
0.42983776330947876,
0.24341358244419098,
-0.47579556703567505,
-0.5733227133750916,
-0.790634274482727,
0.0074974047020077705,
-0.11463324725627899,
0.07440883666276932,
0.5619257688522339,
0.13371673226356506,
-0.25864338874816895,
0.9113916754722595,
-0.4169955849647522,
0.15856163203716278,
-0.587383508682251,
0.11010858416557312,
-0.03576284646987915,
0.34121787548065186,
0.6030465960502625,
-0.5888708233833313,
-0.2848159968852997,
-0.4294559359550476,
-0.48049673438072205,
-0.03414876013994217,
-0.34084269404411316,
-0.27866822481155396,
0.24689799547195435,
0.48070159554481506,
-0.4256013035774231,
0.20749054849147797,
0.21814760565757751,
0.19733960926532745,
0.7521610856056213,
-0.042765624821186066,
0.4811347723007202,
-1.4719878435134888,
-0.13295121490955353,
0.14509892463684082,
-0.27779433131217957,
-0.8575313091278076,
-0.3764593005180359,
-0.2929072678089142,
-0.24496681988239288,
-0.4226531386375427,
0.6097027063369751,
-0.20712867379188538,
0.05984528362751007,
-0.09710660576820374,
-0.17766788601875305,
0.13862407207489014,
0.9034314751625061,
0.27960821986198425,
1.000433087348938,
0.19875961542129517,
-0.4337220788002014,
0.5433575510978699,
0.17157283425331116,
-0.4174323081970215,
0.6416791081428528,
-0.47163960337638855,
0.367759108543396,
-0.05791075527667999,
0.5439038872718811,
-1.3893518447875977,
-0.2727029025554657,
0.25845471024513245,
-0.06766372919082642,
0.6997195482254028,
-0.14785568416118622,
-0.6525752544403076,
0.036202143877744675,
-0.2611743211746216,
0.38765472173690796,
0.6118655204772949,
-0.5584829449653625,
0.493941992521286,
0.1799536496400833,
-0.4919443726539612,
-0.4290788769721985,
-0.2893071174621582,
-0.02227817103266716,
-0.41434726119041443,
-0.5540445446968079,
0.15495747327804565,
-0.24970664083957672,
-0.1539769023656845,
-0.6895901560783386,
-0.057508692145347595,
-0.02535811811685562,
-0.052695997059345245,
0.2591879963874817,
0.33701616525650024,
-0.008932579308748245,
0.2033400982618332,
0.0687248557806015,
0.16574068367481232,
-0.08122613281011581,
0.0054055918008089066,
0.9034878611564636,
-0.1342000961303711,
-0.36883220076560974,
-0.7172579765319824,
0.41626447439193726,
0.5915618538856506,
0.047914810478687286,
0.41969871520996094,
0.45986035466194153,
0.08762326091527939,
-0.270611971616745,
-0.7725802659988403,
-0.2539471685886383,
-0.5004602074623108,
0.4162236750125885,
-0.2605798840522766,
-0.9616953730583191,
0.41744083166122437,
-0.4488728642463684,
0.5215374827384949,
-0.11291864514350891,
0.584941029548645,
-0.13989368081092834,
0.8601916432380676,
0.22245192527770996,
-0.17510932683944702,
0.9069587588310242,
-0.18079549074172974,
-0.003268137574195862,
-0.7052633166313171,
-0.18306022882461548,
-0.04456533119082451,
-0.2328861802816391,
-0.5601637363433838,
-0.490326464176178,
0.2870709300041199,
-0.02214573323726654,
-0.3125073313713074,
0.10891318321228027,
-0.5079770088195801,
0.2595142126083374,
0.5043747425079346,
0.18290652334690094,
0.3376580774784088,
0.38038599491119385,
-0.13988512754440308,
-0.23688675463199615,
-0.5284414887428284,
-0.5671084523200989,
1.1063148975372314,
0.34821709990501404,
1.090816617012024,
-0.12693803012371063,
0.9410953521728516,
0.25121867656707764,
-0.012849603779613972,
-0.8705216646194458,
0.6748473644256592,
0.1758408397436142,
-0.0917898416519165,
-0.1928250789642334,
-0.5030235052108765,
-0.793559193611145,
0.14047455787658691,
0.0009543168707750738,
-0.650338888168335,
-0.03833763301372528,
0.42676421999931335,
-0.3572249710559845,
0.12905535101890564,
-0.5283688306808472,
0.42170020937919617,
-0.07578475773334503,
-0.226963609457016,
-0.11187812685966492,
-0.5084903240203857,
0.3574516177177429,
0.020720666274428368,
-0.03384101763367653,
0.07323691248893738,
0.15615706145763397,
0.7693231701850891,
-0.34891974925994873,
1.2252581119537354,
0.11341898143291473,
-0.02468164823949337,
0.44773685932159424,
0.2855784296989441,
0.5331114530563354,
-0.059149716049432755,
0.040657781064510345,
0.16062448918819427,
-0.030145732685923576,
-0.1707897186279297,
-0.8704262971878052,
0.5823608040809631,
-0.6502904295921326,
-0.6937087178230286,
-0.034678079187870026,
-0.6930204033851624,
-0.6157127022743225,
-0.09673471748828888,
0.13047416508197784,
0.683344304561615,
-0.3449256122112274,
0.06729745864868164,
0.7523254752159119,
-0.13549873232841492,
0.18360456824302673,
0.40123146772384644,
-0.31866782903671265,
-0.5182595252990723,
1.0820729732513428,
0.14408528804779053,
0.5696964263916016,
0.21464091539382935,
-0.07411022484302521,
-0.1643827110528946,
-0.4272022545337677,
-0.4763045012950897,
0.13846951723098755,
-0.6213223338127136,
-0.09898338466882706,
-0.5689740180969238,
-0.36727312207221985,
-0.4138534665107727,
-0.22776058316230774,
-0.28671184182167053,
-0.26987311244010925,
-0.3201577365398407,
-0.03194068372249603,
0.6572638154029846,
0.6393768191337585,
0.2891603112220764,
0.2266601026058197,
-0.5568580031394958,
0.08841877430677414,
0.43847107887268066,
0.07857886701822281,
0.16867420077323914,
-0.5076842308044434,
0.003948323428630829,
0.10111702978610992,
-0.5989319682121277,
-0.5174136757850647,
0.5395337343215942,
0.009417712688446045,
0.47538942098617554,
0.35118475556373596,
-0.09199637919664383,
0.6537981033325195,
-0.6816596388816833,
0.803744375705719,
0.22354401648044586,
-0.4668436348438263,
0.504912257194519,
-0.4341389834880829,
0.22717909514904022,
0.5642668008804321,
0.18557365238666534,
-0.7656835913658142,
-0.4246826171875,
-0.6860055923461914,
-0.7136780023574829,
0.6150621175765991,
0.12321856617927551,
0.4306436777114868,
-0.24932582676410675,
0.5059342980384827,
0.11003725230693817,
0.5555487871170044,
-0.010988752357661724,
-0.37137559056282043,
-0.5369328856468201,
-0.08764871954917908,
0.054617200046777725,
-0.2965652048587799,
-0.12430169433355331,
-0.10562793165445328,
0.47253039479255676,
-0.2094230353832245,
0.45042744278907776,
-0.07357199490070343,
0.36316683888435364,
-0.03566000610589981,
0.5593392848968506,
0.7302736639976501,
0.34664326906204224,
-0.21923093497753143,
-0.2627456784248352,
0.13633501529693604,
-0.4489510655403137,
0.08757468312978745,
-0.3123004734516144,
-0.15099747478961945,
0.07041884958744049,
0.14182083308696747,
0.9922498464584351,
0.4565032124519348,
-0.638578474521637,
0.20496265590190887,
-0.13021448254585266,
-0.08270681649446487,
-0.2850053310394287,
0.3357454538345337,
0.16860052943229675,
0.1915276050567627,
0.3121491074562073,
-0.15169349312782288,
0.11043372005224228,
-0.7874173521995544,
0.3863667845726013,
0.6063974499702454,
-0.16514064371585846,
-0.12340786308050156,
0.19876517355442047,
0.5075140595436096,
-0.28351548314094543,
0.5503004789352417,
-0.2735165059566498,
-0.38715633749961853,
0.4305364787578583,
0.6220131516456604,
0.7584707736968994,
-0.36020734906196594,
0.21104049682617188,
0.3900342285633087,
-0.21248887479305267,
-0.16208671033382416,
0.3853755295276642,
-0.31936904788017273,
-0.8929102420806885,
-0.2975189983844757,
-0.6647431254386902,
-0.5995084047317505,
0.3516019284725189,
-0.611310601234436,
0.01997886411845684,
-0.6397326588630676,
-0.24781513214111328,
-0.39569491147994995,
0.06715509295463562,
-0.5566741824150085,
-0.07232530415058136,
-0.06140521541237831,
0.6308976411819458,
-0.6275041103363037,
0.5605866312980652,
0.37686312198638916,
-0.2734861671924591,
-0.8290978670120239,
0.10510232299566269,
0.2881673574447632,
-1.0382041931152344,
0.9034781455993652,
0.07091748714447021,
-0.2856965661048889,
0.08382643014192581,
-0.6838542819023132,
-0.6369612812995911,
1.2216362953186035,
0.3116649389266968,
-0.7452539205551147,
-0.23201951384544373,
-0.14663144946098328,
0.47439417243003845,
-0.7063064575195312,
0.2818194627761841,
0.6130962371826172,
0.08083443343639374,
0.9726494550704956,
-0.966592013835907,
-0.05218591168522835,
-0.17696097493171692,
0.3585071563720703,
0.06793180108070374,
-0.908621609210968,
0.5482022762298584,
-0.09217528998851776,
-0.37801626324653625,
0.3022729754447937,
0.7101932764053345,
0.53728187084198,
0.08096649497747421,
0.30387261509895325,
0.14472945034503937,
0.6822459101676941,
-0.06067690625786781,
0.9024736285209656,
-0.1946893036365509,
0.12854062020778656,
1.2817152738571167,
-0.36171379685401917,
0.5642186999320984,
0.20199517905712128,
-0.02398194745182991,
0.39938414096832275,
0.5535991191864014,
0.13628052175045013,
0.47777271270751953,
0.1978977620601654,
-0.3419725000858307,
-0.6017529368400574,
-0.4444998800754547,
-0.12128233164548874,
0.3698635399341583,
0.48303210735321045,
-0.4538184404373169,
-0.21115142107009888,
-0.1321522295475006,
0.19054532051086426,
0.0825967788696289,
-0.1946600377559662,
1.0355968475341797,
0.07100920379161835,
-0.49075549840927124,
0.7973228096961975,
-0.36408957839012146,
0.6808223128318787,
-0.647157609462738,
-0.6131919622421265,
-0.21165643632411957,
-0.17855875194072723,
0.031675659120082855,
-0.7082036733627319,
-0.19249317049980164,
-0.15419402718544006,
-0.13703075051307678,
-0.46744754910469055,
0.5853015780448914,
-0.811952531337738,
-0.3425217568874359,
-0.20347869396209717,
0.3829050660133362,
0.1697603166103363,
0.2652053236961365,
-0.6579198837280273,
0.19169241189956665,
0.11295398324728012,
-0.22331273555755615,
0.5611463189125061,
0.39606010913848877,
-0.08134911954402924,
0.882675051689148,
0.4965750575065613,
0.06893625855445862,
-0.22913891077041626,
0.2580539584159851,
0.8813694715499878,
-0.4298105239868164,
-0.21783693134784698,
-0.6949109435081482,
0.18068428337574005,
-0.09938233345746994,
-0.0799366682767868,
0.6512260437011719,
0.37375327944755554,
0.627549409866333,
0.014231055974960327,
0.8813951015472412,
0.42569249868392944,
0.5575507283210754,
-0.6665644645690918,
0.508104145526886,
-0.20853479206562042,
0.17277485132217407,
-0.3913803994655609,
-0.6789187788963318,
0.10665904730558395,
0.6350628733634949,
-0.1928294152021408,
0.43697869777679443,
0.2897106111049652,
0.9365831613540649,
0.16761790215969086,
0.17760522663593292,
0.5216358304023743,
-0.07174556702375412,
0.41899698972702026,
0.5077499747276306,
0.7924134731292725,
-0.02563248574733734,
0.4299105703830719,
-0.16911059617996216,
-0.1560116410255432,
-0.423269122838974,
-0.5358531475067139,
-1.1138067245483398,
-0.7451463937759399,
-0.126046285033226,
-0.27882108092308044,
0.06225891783833504,
1.3898825645446777,
0.7648317813873291,
-0.5740349888801575,
-0.21979911625385284,
0.1469433307647705,
-0.13583482801914215,
-0.11326809227466583,
-0.2768670618534088,
0.10308794677257538,
-0.6435991525650024,
-0.8471419811248779,
0.5765569806098938,
0.3504939675331116,
0.18452364206314087,
-0.32718124985694885,
-0.13292676210403442,
0.18071159720420837,
0.2541004419326782,
0.6153485774993896,
0.297015905380249,
-0.8066825866699219,
-0.27065953612327576,
-0.17491886019706726,
-0.12153057008981705,
0.1643688678741455,
1.0787014961242676,
-0.675663411617279,
0.7638750076293945,
0.319405734539032,
0.6001187562942505,
0.23790492117404938,
0.30518868565559387,
0.752325177192688,
-0.9664413928985596,
-0.1880401074886322,
0.1720859557390213,
0.40910235047340393,
0.25739777088165283,
-0.3601275682449341,
0.2341688722372055,
0.26403942704200745,
-0.5588076710700989,
-0.48398450016975403,
0.4412597715854645,
-0.9707101583480835,
0.05527949333190918,
1.3319705724716187,
-0.04978788271546364,
0.055031098425388336,
-0.29725953936576843,
-0.703544020652771,
0.16345331072807312,
-1.0849401950836182,
0.6167474389076233,
0.6841095089912415,
-0.4812959134578705,
-0.22721929848194122,
-0.5446922183036804,
0.6730876564979553,
0.17302432656288147,
-0.526646614074707,
0.4271956980228424,
0.7137300372123718,
0.4137042164802551,
0.2534322738647461,
0.8814546465873718,
0.16165675222873688,
0.2587902843952179,
-0.24928173422813416,
-0.0028550142887979746,
-0.19189117848873138,
-0.31899669766426086,
-0.050566986203193665,
0.1286080777645111,
0.10386530309915543,
-0.029423227533698082
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11435v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11435v1
|
InsCL: A Data-efficient Continual Learning Paradigm for Fine-tuning Large Language Models with Instructions
| 2024-03-18T03:10:36 | 2024-03-18T03:10:36 |
Yifan Wang, Yafei Liu, Chufan Shi, Haoling Li, Chen Chen, Haonan Lu, Yujiu Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Instruction tuning effectively optimizes Large Language Models (LLMs) for
downstream tasks. Due to the changing environment in real-life applications,
LLMs necessitate continual task-specific adaptation without catastrophic
forgetting. Considering the heavy computational cost, replay-based Continual
Learning (CL) methods are the simplest and most widely used for LLMs to address
the forgetting issue. However, traditional replay-based methods do not fully
utilize instructions to customize the replay strategy. In this work, we propose
a novel paradigm called Instruction-based Continual Learning (InsCL). InsCL
dynamically replays previous data based on task similarity, calculated by
Wasserstein Distance with instructions. Moreover, we further introduce an
Instruction Information Metric (InsInfo) to quantify the complexity and
diversity of instructions. According to InsInfo, InsCL guides the replay
process more inclined to high-quality data. We conduct extensive experiments
over 16 tasks with different training orders, observing consistent performance
improvements of InsCL. When all tasks have been trained, InsCL achieves
performance gains of 3.0 Relative Gain compared with Random Replay, and 27.96
Relative Gain compared with No Replay.
|
[
0.013368699699640274,
-0.5798138380050659,
0.32602354884147644,
0.3260253071784973,
-0.22629773616790771,
0.48987969756126404,
-0.6756859421730042,
-0.14584402740001678,
-0.36852145195007324,
0.558279275894165,
-0.48495230078697205,
-0.5736628770828247,
-0.4317948818206787,
-0.0732547715306282,
-0.36969056725502014,
0.9992589354515076,
-0.004236724227666855,
0.22970350086688995,
-0.4536689817905426,
-0.07947570085525513,
-0.5367647409439087,
-0.2138816863298416,
-0.8576245903968811,
-0.4671546518802643,
0.1801120489835739,
0.9383720755577087,
0.09047435224056244,
0.638763964176178,
0.271474152803421,
0.19643628597259521,
0.18228642642498016,
0.7016751170158386,
-0.9831892848014832,
0.14960622787475586,
-0.2362642139196396,
-0.4232928454875946,
-0.10495860874652863,
-0.39939072728157043,
1.0637104511260986,
0.6823145151138306,
-0.3090817630290985,
0.3095542788505554,
0.6026214361190796,
0.864178478717804,
-0.5422943830490112,
0.12555699050426483,
-0.7860216498374939,
-0.0678965374827385,
-0.17620804905891418,
-0.5025590062141418,
-0.6572644114494324,
-0.42522042989730835,
-0.07906608283519745,
-0.32553672790527344,
-0.05460832640528679,
0.2614353895187378,
0.5675358772277832,
0.26471492648124695,
0.13320375978946686,
-0.5044731497764587,
-0.774887204170227,
0.8748515248298645,
-1.0384925603866577,
0.4125327169895172,
0.11319750547409058,
-0.038730818778276443,
-0.4598979949951172,
-0.5498073101043701,
-0.3142678141593933,
-0.4453151524066925,
0.11918772757053375,
0.15639418363571167,
0.014898767694830894,
0.05658896639943123,
0.126372292637825,
0.24338777363300323,
-0.5539264678955078,
0.3590140640735626,
-0.18066737055778503,
0.18405622243881226,
0.44055384397506714,
0.3513474464416504,
0.1529761552810669,
0.6062197089195251,
-0.5288543105125427,
0.18581661581993103,
-1.0432074069976807,
0.12094183266162872,
0.1709083765745163,
0.20409534871578217,
-0.16911204159259796,
0.013897626660764217,
-0.24861052632331848,
0.6827780604362488,
0.37797534465789795,
-0.5036776065826416,
0.037898529320955276,
-0.12866072356700897,
-0.10313034057617188,
0.5370947122573853,
0.41370299458503723,
0.15958364307880402,
0.068238765001297,
-0.5608662366867065,
-0.4063316583633423,
-0.3687247931957245,
0.4289511442184448,
-0.7646378874778748,
-0.15527942776679993,
-0.2405698001384735,
-0.3576604127883911,
0.08486704528331757,
0.027942335233092308,
-0.5269278883934021,
0.09604587405920029,
-0.6197168827056885,
0.4067762792110443,
-0.647157609462738,
0.17115738987922668,
0.12088920921087265,
0.19631269574165344,
0.06561999022960663,
0.3577938377857208,
-0.9185582995414734,
0.5225607752799988,
0.8596228361129761,
0.8936582207679749,
-0.5530558228492737,
-0.27911514043807983,
-0.7394742965698242,
0.2528493404388428,
-0.49012985825538635,
0.5659812092781067,
-0.7369860410690308,
-0.31743451952934265,
-0.043222930282354355,
-0.010912583209574223,
-0.15149174630641937,
-0.8123438954353333,
-0.06719538569450378,
-0.6531074643135071,
-0.030265560373663902,
-0.02362193912267685,
-1.0464165210723877,
-0.3900550901889801,
0.2626540958881378,
-0.1890890896320343,
1.098363995552063,
0.15459248423576355,
-0.24822615087032318,
0.36326098442077637,
-0.5263276696205139,
-0.3253941535949707,
0.3610557019710541,
0.20212040841579437,
-0.4093981981277466,
-0.018232936039566994,
-0.20366962254047394,
0.4841030240058899,
-0.5376193523406982,
0.19987572729587555,
-0.3196365535259247,
-0.8760501146316528,
0.07765000313520432,
-0.5897446274757385,
0.2508813440799713,
0.08891809731721878,
-0.597895085811615,
0.062161799520254135,
-0.7068113088607788,
0.040341656655073166,
-0.32765746116638184,
-0.6733387112617493,
-0.3667019009590149,
0.15813985466957092,
-0.4779481887817383,
-0.007580481935292482,
0.35654616355895996,
-0.6848162412643433,
0.1834881603717804,
-0.4301071763038635,
0.2768546938896179,
0.7174234390258789,
0.25028565526008606,
0.3306760787963867,
-0.4751278758049011,
0.37700408697128296,
-0.07730942219495773,
0.1430828869342804,
-0.3624311089515686,
-0.04458702728152275,
-0.8111805319786072,
-0.17135576903820038,
0.005076155066490173,
0.6416423320770264,
-0.5541115999221802,
0.18272943794727325,
-0.536967396736145,
-0.5023160576820374,
-0.3420083522796631,
0.45496416091918945,
0.8802141547203064,
0.6659618616104126,
0.29843565821647644,
-0.27038154006004333,
-0.2832670211791992,
-0.5426896214485168,
-0.10208446532487869,
0.10507829487323761,
0.17659400403499603,
0.2899230420589447,
0.3978070616722107,
-0.18395186960697174,
0.5357897877693176,
-0.007211174815893173,
-0.03219825029373169,
-0.16339324414730072,
0.05416945740580559,
0.29958733916282654,
0.6354395747184753,
0.25914373993873596,
-0.3283643424510956,
-0.8107097744941711,
0.30213662981987,
-0.7771563529968262,
0.09192286431789398,
-0.5641183257102966,
-0.04733264446258545,
0.40476641058921814,
0.862556517124176,
0.03728919103741646,
0.14060752093791962,
0.4632216691970825,
0.14272791147232056,
0.48233291506767273,
-0.6467915177345276,
0.25197675824165344,
-0.44372624158859253,
-0.1895020604133606,
-0.33906206488609314,
-0.25205594301223755,
-0.2734150290489197,
-0.08797705173492432,
0.3666033148765564,
0.1815466433763504,
-0.41525062918663025,
0.49786707758903503,
-0.43351393938064575,
0.15895110368728638,
-0.38251325488090515,
-0.08042493462562561,
-0.3655385375022888,
0.866916835308075,
-0.5255752205848694,
0.8889674544334412,
0.5823763608932495,
-0.9887940287590027,
0.3849405348300934,
-0.27151644229888916,
-0.5349218845367432,
0.5582091212272644,
-0.4597327709197998,
0.23790369927883148,
-0.21953709423542023,
0.010161037556827068,
-0.9567598700523376,
-0.004278846085071564,
0.177814319729805,
-0.11294751614332199,
0.7517771124839783,
-0.1323319673538208,
-0.8349103927612305,
-0.1501314491033554,
-0.030972721055150032,
0.21171565353870392,
0.5332880616188049,
-0.8749510049819946,
0.20863071084022522,
0.1348591148853302,
0.03608115389943123,
-0.34888672828674316,
-0.4555762708187103,
-0.03822188451886177,
-0.31838253140449524,
-0.1894095242023468,
0.5028010606765747,
-0.32694822549819946,
-0.08038481324911118,
0.040670499205589294,
-0.1268918216228485,
0.06247778236865997,
0.01502487063407898,
0.2847145199775696,
0.08984909951686859,
-0.23512813448905945,
0.5710527896881104,
0.3553713262081146,
0.06317461282014847,
-0.13691304624080658,
-0.808086097240448,
0.4919535219669342,
-0.33604133129119873,
-0.2863725423812866,
-0.6091977953910828,
0.31510260701179504,
0.6011569499969482,
-0.09111183881759644,
0.6258498430252075,
0.17352600395679474,
-0.18886587023735046,
-0.540144681930542,
-0.570271372795105,
-0.09811368584632874,
-0.4746359884738922,
0.4125169813632965,
-0.004702651407569647,
-0.8881882429122925,
0.22391073405742645,
-0.40257027745246887,
0.3750520944595337,
-0.013280116952955723,
0.41483643651008606,
-0.40909484028816223,
0.7805482149124146,
0.598540186882019,
-0.1788640171289444,
0.5158712863922119,
-0.15268908441066742,
-0.07551908493041992,
-0.740024745464325,
-0.2780352532863617,
-0.11875444650650024,
-0.4277306795120239,
-0.169854998588562,
-0.038013339042663574,
0.4898548126220703,
0.13913878798484802,
-0.7309650778770447,
0.25955110788345337,
-0.4896366000175476,
0.47967594861984253,
0.6082828640937805,
0.41766905784606934,
0.23818902671337128,
-0.023769304156303406,
0.20289237797260284,
-0.043042879551649094,
-1.0025187730789185,
-0.3298644721508026,
1.006729245185852,
0.02236093021929264,
0.8791639804840088,
-0.19333584606647491,
0.6912682056427002,
0.43508708477020264,
0.4664476215839386,
-0.27394866943359375,
0.46600812673568726,
-0.3733810782432556,
-0.10696752369403839,
-0.23821374773979187,
-0.33227500319480896,
-0.8079533576965332,
-0.10226264595985413,
0.02873089350759983,
-0.5845054984092712,
-0.14282990992069244,
0.6855182647705078,
-0.2874864339828491,
0.5706352591514587,
-0.4432871639728546,
0.603718101978302,
-0.44398394227027893,
-0.3890230357646942,
-0.6748320460319519,
-0.5473389029502869,
0.17882928252220154,
-0.1634141057729721,
0.06555037200450897,
0.11244158446788788,
0.020452924072742462,
0.5993762612342834,
-0.2885039746761322,
0.9123358726501465,
-0.011053903959691525,
0.16901646554470062,
0.23437078297138214,
0.04677755758166313,
0.6821484565734863,
0.09505320340394974,
0.03034740686416626,
0.036621611565351486,
-0.05667828768491745,
-0.27738940715789795,
-0.7645162343978882,
1.0193631649017334,
-0.288761168718338,
-0.2769387662410736,
-0.10853079706430435,
-0.6910112500190735,
-0.1755770742893219,
0.10225612670183182,
0.236387699842453,
0.8306906819343567,
-0.00394919328391552,
0.41163936257362366,
1.1944626569747925,
-0.29143986105918884,
0.46274176239967346,
0.5666260719299316,
0.19577908515930176,
-0.28951239585876465,
1.1348323822021484,
0.18031920492649078,
0.5717781782150269,
0.7591036558151245,
0.09294288605451584,
-0.02057175524532795,
-0.5603370666503906,
-0.46133658289909363,
0.38592958450317383,
-0.5973672866821289,
-0.38262152671813965,
-0.38925471901893616,
-0.07686827331781387,
0.2029886245727539,
-0.36065179109573364,
-0.5562888383865356,
0.1935134381055832,
-0.43985801935195923,
0.2685547173023224,
0.40876278281211853,
0.6116186380386353,
0.12663330137729645,
0.32565921545028687,
-0.7996793985366821,
-0.19428770244121552,
0.11629176884889603,
0.5487676858901978,
0.3187342882156372,
-0.8813173174858093,
-0.6704681515693665,
0.2695946991443634,
-0.22945676743984222,
-0.4457513093948364,
0.26429641246795654,
0.5721386075019836,
0.5424108505249023,
0.2880397439002991,
-0.07924956828355789,
0.9188689589500427,
-0.6342647075653076,
0.5190055966377258,
-0.03455764055252075,
-0.800600528717041,
0.20844705402851105,
-0.00585296843200922,
0.6613318920135498,
0.6132577657699585,
0.3473910987377167,
-0.5791869759559631,
-0.45304256677627563,
-0.4700316786766052,
-0.7507298588752747,
0.5359770059585571,
-0.4778253138065338,
0.26528093218803406,
-0.09958664327859879,
0.6052359938621521,
0.39533621072769165,
0.254313588142395,
-0.19921067357063293,
-0.17330145835876465,
0.1667635589838028,
-0.30253690481185913,
0.03307982161641121,
-0.20107470452785492,
0.1407850980758667,
-0.2372838407754898,
0.8817452192306519,
-0.0750780776143074,
0.22913405299186707,
-0.09882674366235733,
-0.33407828211784363,
0.0101145775988698,
0.04394029453396797,
0.7905721664428711,
0.7340488433837891,
-0.1270950734615326,
0.007010283414274454,
0.6892833113670349,
-0.3695966601371765,
0.06219325214624405,
-0.392056405544281,
-0.23720194399356842,
-0.03578418865799904,
0.3383711576461792,
0.856816828250885,
0.9298184514045715,
-0.9150886535644531,
0.20622514188289642,
0.2619425058364868,
0.014513739384710789,
-0.711836576461792,
0.4145527482032776,
-0.09056983888149261,
0.4148540198802948,
0.19414228200912476,
0.13107667863368988,
-0.08960575610399246,
-0.5026525855064392,
0.4228028655052185,
0.32864177227020264,
-0.7546502947807312,
-0.14160150289535522,
0.5295737981796265,
-0.2532411217689514,
-0.2841787040233612,
0.7910191416740417,
-0.3861777186393738,
-0.26966866850852966,
0.41090473532676697,
0.8790634274482727,
0.5261675119400024,
-0.07387121766805649,
0.02978408709168434,
0.5854499340057373,
-0.016712835058569908,
-0.4748116731643677,
0.16946560144424438,
-0.21458831429481506,
-0.22571085393428802,
-0.3571849763393402,
-0.4846007227897644,
-0.2766578793525696,
-0.03138267621397972,
-0.5890897512435913,
-0.032687555998563766,
-0.657923698425293,
0.407961905002594,
-0.5712133049964905,
-0.2956586182117462,
-0.4637806713581085,
0.13069047033786774,
0.001746095367707312,
0.869295597076416,
-0.22055217623710632,
1.0507999658584595,
0.2599983811378479,
-0.09244897961616516,
-0.6351162195205688,
-0.12656651437282562,
0.0071076382882893085,
-0.5131253004074097,
0.7668328881263733,
0.05588196963071823,
-0.4403243362903595,
0.266182005405426,
-0.8032995462417603,
-1.0173020362854004,
1.1728935241699219,
0.4224703907966614,
-0.8067445755004883,
0.12422304600477219,
-0.299335241317749,
0.4512874484062195,
-0.5944971442222595,
-0.05537700280547142,
0.5235099792480469,
0.15557000041007996,
-0.05068254843354225,
-0.6239146590232849,
-0.132632777094841,
-0.08957954496145248,
0.04863675311207771,
0.3916705250740051,
-0.6444749236106873,
0.6485507488250732,
-0.16636288166046143,
-0.32715919613838196,
0.07024426013231277,
0.8864935636520386,
0.16649377346038818,
0.18574188649654388,
0.3858211636543274,
0.417207270860672,
0.8017606735229492,
-0.0050729610957205296,
0.9929890036582947,
-0.41609227657318115,
0.34397321939468384,
1.3394708633422852,
0.03988732770085335,
0.7502647042274475,
0.15556319057941437,
0.015214934945106506,
0.6146807670593262,
0.3719639182090759,
-0.09818696975708008,
0.6587377786636353,
0.2676985561847687,
-0.32925161719322205,
-0.26260828971862793,
0.06662151217460632,
-0.1350705921649933,
0.25118887424468994,
0.6582654714584351,
-0.1883097141981125,
-0.2681306004524231,
0.28374168276786804,
0.3292008936405182,
0.2660098373889923,
-0.4651390016078949,
0.7028636336326599,
-0.03752065449953079,
-0.7270870804786682,
0.8795213103294373,
-0.2882915735244751,
0.7746166586875916,
-0.868877649307251,
-0.3505196273326874,
-0.26881423592567444,
0.4628792107105255,
0.05620366334915161,
-0.5119060277938843,
0.10308563709259033,
-0.1972769945859909,
-0.28198421001434326,
-0.32394939661026,
0.13031832873821259,
-0.8062657713890076,
-0.22130727767944336,
0.1661425530910492,
-0.2933182120323181,
0.14601068198680878,
0.10707593709230423,
-0.48237165808677673,
0.10384021699428558,
0.07550447434186935,
0.21419794857501984,
0.48767098784446716,
0.2902560830116272,
-0.14946290850639343,
1.0035380125045776,
0.4688684642314911,
0.14662843942642212,
0.18334494531154633,
-0.27531421184539795,
0.6342031955718994,
-0.37429383397102356,
-0.44379523396492004,
-0.8758962750434875,
0.40165120363235474,
-0.02008596807718277,
-0.4373272657394409,
0.7385978102684021,
0.5376047492027283,
1.2727464437484741,
-0.13469329476356506,
0.5560243129730225,
0.29759445786476135,
0.6455406546592712,
-0.8402115702629089,
0.6111903190612793,
-0.7328227758407593,
0.319732129573822,
-0.1250125914812088,
-0.6227161288261414,
-0.30782198905944824,
0.19978545606136322,
-0.07694365084171295,
-0.23177851736545563,
0.5266028046607971,
0.9562574625015259,
-0.18840885162353516,
-0.17412801086902618,
0.21411359310150146,
0.17467547953128815,
0.19622424244880676,
0.8533435463905334,
0.5554908514022827,
-0.14218837022781372,
0.34872034192085266,
-0.27819132804870605,
-0.29760435223579407,
-0.3166135251522064,
-0.6224395036697388,
-0.6848399639129639,
-0.6232691407203674,
-0.26389849185943604,
0.033900126814842224,
0.4876351058483124,
1.212941288948059,
0.6616361737251282,
-0.8182021975517273,
-0.47381317615509033,
-0.17713052034378052,
-0.07148429751396179,
-0.716103196144104,
-0.14479219913482666,
0.3693682551383972,
-0.9526240229606628,
-0.6250249147415161,
0.6206727027893066,
0.8215015530586243,
-0.2565412223339081,
-0.07002566009759903,
-0.3840331733226776,
-0.05685289576649666,
-0.08175569027662277,
0.6181533336639404,
0.5517761707305908,
-0.6338539123535156,
-0.3871868848800659,
-0.06173964962363243,
-0.10914836823940277,
0.12664036452770233,
0.7396751046180725,
-0.7196430563926697,
0.7769914269447327,
0.2006690800189972,
0.9298202395439148,
0.5037069916725159,
-0.0957452729344368,
0.4973444938659668,
-0.6338497400283813,
0.004070168361067772,
0.21771132946014404,
0.19595244526863098,
0.28730154037475586,
-0.4599969685077667,
0.13209988176822662,
0.07029838860034943,
-0.8547333478927612,
-0.7536517977714539,
0.10914431512355804,
-0.7583104372024536,
-0.1882619708776474,
0.8848018050193787,
-0.2884131371974945,
-0.10015390068292618,
-0.13554881513118744,
-0.07947568595409393,
0.18467721343040466,
-0.4344688951969147,
0.8301812410354614,
0.36710697412490845,
-0.18781107664108276,
-0.2234991192817688,
-0.6274168491363525,
0.4476218819618225,
0.2884531617164612,
-0.5877772569656372,
-0.04823235422372818,
0.22576245665550232,
0.3309011459350586,
-0.33216601610183716,
0.2869203984737396,
-0.1523083597421646,
0.44801467657089233,
-0.26307791471481323,
-0.1014062911272049,
-0.2412135899066925,
-0.6153743863105774,
-0.14664620161056519,
-0.005846986547112465,
-0.008218394592404366,
-0.2399521768093109
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11430v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11430v2
|
A Novel Paradigm Boosting Translation Capabilities of Large Language Models
| 2024-03-18T02:53:49 | 2024-04-15T06:34:04 |
Jiaxin Guo, Hao Yang, Zongyao Li, Daimeng Wei, Hengchao Shang, Xiaoyu Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper presents a study on strategies to enhance the translation
capabilities of large language models (LLMs) in the context of machine
translation (MT) tasks. The paper proposes a novel paradigm consisting of three
stages: Secondary Pre-training using Extensive Monolingual Data, Continual
Pre-training with Interlinear Text Format Documents, and Leveraging
Source-Language Consistent Instruction for Supervised Fine-Tuning. Previous
research on LLMs focused on various strategies for supervised fine-tuning
(SFT), but their effectiveness has been limited. While traditional machine
translation approaches rely on vast amounts of parallel bilingual data, our
paradigm highlights the importance of using smaller sets of high-quality
bilingual data. We argue that the focus should be on augmenting LLMs'
cross-lingual alignment abilities during pre-training rather than solely
relying on extensive bilingual data during SFT. Experimental results conducted
using the Llama2 model, particularly on Chinese-Llama2 after monolingual
augmentation, demonstrate the improved translation capabilities of LLMs. A
significant contribution of our approach lies in Stage2: Continual Pre-training
with Interlinear Text Format Documents, which requires less than 1B training
data, making our method highly efficient. Additionally, in Stage3, we observed
that setting instructions consistent with the source language benefits the
supervised fine-tuning process. Experimental results demonstrate that our
approach surpasses previous work and achieves superior performance compared to
models such as NLLB-54B and GPT3.5-text-davinci-003, despite having a
significantly smaller parameter count of only 7B or 13B. This achievement
establishes our method as a pioneering strategy in the field of machine
translation.
|
[
-0.2705773115158081,
-0.7021012306213379,
0.4547722041606903,
0.3821757435798645,
-0.5450055003166199,
0.16532930731773376,
-0.5093990564346313,
-0.36346888542175293,
0.007199922110885382,
0.6724560856819153,
-0.5567009449005127,
-0.3966289162635803,
-0.7366628050804138,
0.32898005843162537,
-0.41696301102638245,
1.1142690181732178,
-0.3456769287586212,
0.40384677052497864,
0.117459736764431,
-0.01755657233297825,
-0.6001203060150146,
-0.4375542402267456,
-0.5865907073020935,
-0.3691153824329376,
0.6731268167495728,
0.3903452455997467,
0.8373957872390747,
1.1140458583831787,
0.5538728833198547,
0.20854215323925018,
-0.09432616829872131,
0.6204299330711365,
-0.5386714935302734,
-0.0790543183684349,
-0.07291760295629501,
-0.6479883790016174,
-0.8048730492591858,
-0.054191477596759796,
0.8577902317047119,
0.6755529046058655,
0.07723578810691833,
0.1767093986272812,
0.3896624743938446,
0.5131363272666931,
-0.26640984416007996,
0.04446835443377495,
-0.852466881275177,
0.1287076622247696,
-0.5371729731559753,
-0.5476061105728149,
-0.4784109890460968,
-0.07402604073286057,
-0.19733650982379913,
-0.7989879846572876,
0.010687303729355335,
0.08601482957601547,
0.7730540037155151,
0.2900177836418152,
-0.5137516856193542,
0.010052246041595936,
-0.6187965273857117,
0.7247887849807739,
-0.9009395241737366,
0.22083504498004913,
0.2948549687862396,
0.09749165922403336,
-0.05667047202587128,
-0.4235789179801941,
-0.4747689664363861,
-0.1391444057226181,
-0.1332564800977707,
-0.14437277615070343,
0.22446022927761078,
-0.09834781289100647,
0.3366745412349701,
0.3340931236743927,
-0.4571057856082916,
0.6751629710197449,
-0.23845769464969635,
-0.048504579812288284,
0.5396827459335327,
0.2220090627670288,
0.21482239663600922,
0.13176608085632324,
-0.4671691358089447,
-0.09659451246261597,
-0.9183372259140015,
-0.008585987612605095,
0.2838284969329834,
0.6423608064651489,
-0.19411851465702057,
0.5919612050056458,
-0.24346698820590973,
0.6701001524925232,
0.17766883969306946,
-0.323032408952713,
0.26850610971450806,
-0.8163701295852661,
-0.03927081823348999,
0.09758619964122772,
0.5754781365394592,
0.17562541365623474,
0.2944449484348297,
-0.14771980047225952,
-0.4223540425300598,
-0.23895595967769623,
0.24139729142189026,
-0.7391523122787476,
0.19722379744052887,
-0.16513857245445251,
-0.32991212606430054,
-0.2559158205986023,
-0.16888301074504852,
-0.3363538384437561,
-0.16499364376068115,
-0.8460904955863953,
0.4987385869026184,
-0.3965946137905121,
-0.05248529464006424,
0.08482706546783447,
0.37634018063545227,
0.3218440115451813,
0.4296986162662506,
-1.1162816286087036,
0.10076315701007843,
0.8962996006011963,
0.7926762700080872,
-0.2719433605670929,
-0.554056704044342,
-0.6598963141441345,
0.31051453948020935,
-0.6118676662445068,
0.4920298457145691,
-0.2935028672218323,
-0.09959572553634644,
0.05468500778079033,
0.10911675542593002,
0.09382923692464828,
-0.4933536648750305,
0.5517372488975525,
-0.5635774731636047,
0.029402144253253937,
-0.2984808385372162,
-0.28627416491508484,
-0.10577239096164703,
0.29447877407073975,
-0.4312354326248169,
0.9838602542877197,
-0.060214441269636154,
-0.5859183669090271,
0.4749997556209564,
-0.44473373889923096,
-0.732517421245575,
0.01117961760610342,
-0.0001671185891609639,
-0.27229058742523193,
0.12786689400672913,
0.46341758966445923,
0.6293202042579651,
-0.4514026641845703,
0.25514477491378784,
-0.16936500370502472,
-0.3282362222671509,
-0.07105572521686554,
-0.41236966848373413,
0.562999963760376,
0.1265605092048645,
-0.20696589350700378,
0.1733444631099701,
-0.4943019151687622,
-0.034163303673267365,
0.13979169726371765,
-0.4525972008705139,
-0.386402428150177,
-0.2479957789182663,
-0.04756958782672882,
0.26901084184646606,
0.5107170939445496,
-0.2427697330713272,
0.45695725083351135,
-0.3783709704875946,
0.27991190552711487,
0.7509207725524902,
-0.340542197227478,
0.5481897592544556,
-0.29004761576652527,
0.47104012966156006,
0.02602541632950306,
0.10598154366016388,
-0.5460513830184937,
-0.10581182688474655,
-0.8069696426391602,
-0.2307756096124649,
0.3607020676136017,
0.6886036396026611,
-0.8367042541503906,
0.5212844014167786,
-0.5789260864257812,
-0.3780280649662018,
-0.5678467750549316,
0.5869825482368469,
0.5117489695549011,
0.5067459940910339,
0.6120741367340088,
-0.26239123940467834,
-0.46176838874816895,
-0.9112032055854797,
-0.17384476959705353,
0.2005596160888672,
0.056039538234472275,
-0.19237671792507172,
0.24608752131462097,
-0.3522510826587677,
0.3606935143470764,
-0.052996326237916946,
-0.4053209722042084,
-0.25980404019355774,
0.1794365644454956,
0.38024041056632996,
0.7119438648223877,
0.22098901867866516,
-0.8385778069496155,
-0.601349949836731,
0.46747490763664246,
-0.7733225226402283,
-0.14600546658039093,
-0.24546915292739868,
-0.20559202134609222,
0.27539530396461487,
0.6083071231842041,
-0.3463877737522125,
-0.057397305965423584,
0.5355470776557922,
0.07588816434144974,
0.30584728717803955,
-0.4747317433357239,
0.09618445485830307,
-1.1152544021606445,
-0.09565812349319458,
-0.09389258921146393,
-0.3035910129547119,
-0.7540414333343506,
0.12408540397882462,
0.3025997281074524,
0.25919297337532043,
-0.4121832549571991,
0.34499046206474304,
-0.5731956362724304,
0.08109036833047867,
-0.37903696298599243,
0.0725863054394722,
-0.15908901393413544,
0.3342250883579254,
0.0172908753156662,
0.7272059917449951,
0.2628273367881775,
-0.4811098873615265,
0.11591991782188416,
0.24200186133384705,
-0.3182520866394043,
0.4567965865135193,
-0.4497675597667694,
0.19799713790416718,
-0.12222671508789062,
0.21687178313732147,
-0.6645215153694153,
-0.06079529598355293,
-0.005605216603726149,
-0.23266303539276123,
0.6998515725135803,
0.08632757514715195,
-0.9181433916091919,
-0.18805670738220215,
-0.09895233809947968,
0.4902123212814331,
0.32852375507354736,
-0.4751987159252167,
0.3768302798271179,
0.12337803840637207,
-0.3945629894733429,
-0.5646016597747803,
-0.7530920505523682,
0.313299298286438,
-0.2056267112493515,
-0.6737165451049805,
0.5391439199447632,
0.1018136665225029,
0.15128165483474731,
-0.26764196157455444,
-0.11601586639881134,
0.134990394115448,
0.14146123826503754,
-0.18101166188716888,
0.42272719740867615,
-0.3141095042228699,
0.043510593473911285,
0.35268932580947876,
-0.26129138469696045,
-0.33072349429130554,
-0.5240960121154785,
0.6027985215187073,
0.09080339968204498,
-0.07754228264093399,
-0.5227081775665283,
0.2743217349052429,
0.46634045243263245,
-0.5164441466331482,
0.7247473001480103,
0.7354626655578613,
-0.26106777787208557,
-0.1876813918352127,
-0.6002712249755859,
-0.18809133768081665,
-0.41774725914001465,
0.6033943891525269,
-0.5471600294113159,
-0.9059454202651978,
0.19692212343215942,
-0.14340679347515106,
0.23065824806690216,
0.2517974376678467,
0.7524839639663696,
-0.08933420479297638,
1.2110077142715454,
0.809281051158905,
-0.25535327196121216,
0.5382525324821472,
-0.06291964650154114,
0.10570623725652695,
-0.8615587949752808,
-0.07265091687440872,
-0.356275349855423,
-0.33037903904914856,
-0.5438159704208374,
-0.7303071022033691,
0.4195278286933899,
0.4397159814834595,
-0.1964763104915619,
0.5598637461662292,
-0.12876783311367035,
0.2901262938976288,
0.4166516661643982,
0.013830375857651234,
0.5760465264320374,
0.16190655529499054,
-0.22524265944957733,
-0.18679481744766235,
-0.8305453062057495,
-0.6283634901046753,
1.2278372049331665,
0.47322526574134827,
0.5310916900634766,
-0.12833696603775024,
0.6046469211578369,
0.027779975906014442,
0.4940430521965027,
-0.5108533501625061,
0.45806604623794556,
-0.3221365809440613,
-0.4783320724964142,
-0.4049660861492157,
-0.32038551568984985,
-0.8089978098869324,
0.4952467679977417,
-0.3365596532821655,
-0.34723636507987976,
-0.2559678852558136,
0.2028324007987976,
-0.12254839390516281,
0.15005755424499512,
-0.4374433159828186,
0.8110621571540833,
-0.7206526398658752,
-0.5591506958007812,
-0.3539561331272125,
-0.7007373571395874,
0.3559262752532959,
-0.5627087354660034,
0.2555103302001953,
0.10541397333145142,
-0.33220669627189636,
0.3645841181278229,
-0.17254772782325745,
0.591509997844696,
0.06765777617692947,
-0.5402594804763794,
-0.24512946605682373,
-0.07231919467449188,
0.872086226940155,
-0.11062012612819672,
-0.02052527666091919,
0.21286004781723022,
-0.039962250739336014,
-0.5317813158035278,
-0.5753539800643921,
0.46914905309677124,
-0.6072869300842285,
-0.6884459853172302,
-0.033045269548892975,
-0.9717332720756531,
-0.3772241473197937,
0.41625604033470154,
0.13434545695781708,
0.06451768428087234,
0.028232304379343987,
0.4297259747982025,
0.6113813519477844,
-0.07354453206062317,
0.1062219962477684,
0.6378017067909241,
-0.3313961923122406,
-0.2914714515209198,
0.7609489560127258,
0.2241925448179245,
0.5580431222915649,
0.7466088533401489,
0.01139607559889555,
-0.18013812601566315,
-0.8916681408882141,
-0.5950677990913391,
0.39560213685035706,
-0.4392087161540985,
-0.09814582765102386,
-0.5179795026779175,
0.017932098358869553,
-0.5262874364852905,
-0.05979962646961212,
-0.4241220951080322,
-0.12383613735437393,
-0.13328273594379425,
-0.017732420936226845,
-0.12860693037509918,
0.36672908067703247,
-0.04083193093538284,
0.3965170681476593,
-0.8672980666160583,
0.33227062225341797,
-0.020718906074762344,
-0.06131937727332115,
-0.19199122488498688,
-0.7508712410926819,
-0.7018882632255554,
0.1907789707183838,
-0.2599767744541168,
-0.47491082549095154,
0.46321022510528564,
-0.08807430416345596,
0.575576901435852,
0.360340416431427,
-0.28152284026145935,
0.862182080745697,
-0.7273763418197632,
0.3861963748931885,
0.11114738881587982,
-0.8625653982162476,
0.39618489146232605,
-0.664391279220581,
0.30556437373161316,
0.553184986114502,
0.43391549587249756,
-0.40913474559783936,
-0.29922041296958923,
-0.07199057936668396,
-0.7803218364715576,
0.6874625086784363,
0.024065790697932243,
0.2093670517206192,
0.3982234299182892,
0.38601648807525635,
0.24040943384170532,
0.37614870071411133,
-0.8279057741165161,
0.006621017586439848,
0.1998949944972992,
-0.0890834778547287,
-0.5335270762443542,
-0.1026831790804863,
-0.21992537379264832,
-0.4106862545013428,
0.6962606906890869,
-0.32627224922180176,
-0.28954553604125977,
-0.03328073397278786,
-0.18008098006248474,
-0.11414731293916702,
0.19783490896224976,
0.5840238928794861,
0.5933629274368286,
0.05106496438384056,
-0.04284702613949776,
0.3804338276386261,
-0.1449367254972458,
0.18730606138706207,
0.1684263050556183,
-0.38337090611457825,
-0.25793522596359253,
0.4637936055660248,
0.8788149356842041,
0.18847650289535522,
-0.37743327021598816,
0.21063828468322754,
0.4293922781944275,
-0.11727425456047058,
-0.11148539185523987,
-0.17526903748512268,
-0.03533214330673218,
0.34578412771224976,
0.340032160282135,
-0.077664315700531,
-0.23310525715351105,
-0.5947763919830322,
0.011849658563733101,
0.4461933672428131,
-0.1944202035665512,
-0.24699847400188446,
0.661133348941803,
0.04643433913588524,
-0.07993743568658829,
0.2301507294178009,
-0.005156455095857382,
-0.4356728792190552,
0.28828638792037964,
0.7357656955718994,
0.5253095626831055,
-0.2407177984714508,
0.03879866003990173,
0.2797909080982208,
0.6921318769454956,
-0.5267931222915649,
-0.10321388393640518,
-0.15797418355941772,
-0.6454774737358093,
-0.7120646834373474,
-0.6549516916275024,
-0.14751416444778442,
0.05391135439276695,
-0.5973772406578064,
0.5162990093231201,
-0.14704996347427368,
0.07304501533508301,
-0.19879695773124695,
0.01209461409598589,
-0.6023982763290405,
0.02536066435277462,
0.28483396768569946,
0.9355034828186035,
-0.6652169227600098,
1.2583130598068237,
0.5438163876533508,
-0.265398234128952,
-0.8326550722122192,
-0.015102298930287361,
0.010285833850502968,
-0.7562097907066345,
0.794284462928772,
0.1367185264825821,
-0.0562514029443264,
0.13825106620788574,
-0.3363661468029022,
-0.8528474569320679,
1.1653411388397217,
0.5320031642913818,
-0.7939916253089905,
-0.3069474995136261,
0.3884199857711792,
0.6156126856803894,
-0.541649341583252,
-0.24039772152900696,
0.6614906787872314,
0.6411720514297485,
-0.20195689797401428,
-1.082802653312683,
0.12667380273342133,
-0.17506445944309235,
0.3524587154388428,
0.16877524554729462,
-0.5391091704368591,
0.8398350477218628,
-0.1532573699951172,
-0.12258404493331909,
0.41022878885269165,
0.6958152055740356,
0.1130177304148674,
0.09708011150360107,
0.4688403904438019,
0.5203829407691956,
0.6439581513404846,
0.04447931423783302,
1.1247035264968872,
-0.2891850471496582,
0.026429902762174606,
1.1158161163330078,
-0.2742989659309387,
0.9194955825805664,
0.7836140394210815,
-0.017446579411625862,
0.21968120336532593,
0.5287033915519714,
-0.04346410930156708,
0.43448469042778015,
0.18125666677951813,
0.08003155887126923,
-0.46502578258514404,
-0.18109726905822754,
-0.5508613586425781,
0.45551303029060364,
0.23155778646469116,
-0.49281156063079834,
-0.04937862604856491,
0.16380713880062103,
0.24818068742752075,
0.3162882328033447,
-0.30769282579421997,
0.6169694066047668,
0.10288626700639725,
-0.8459365367889404,
0.7383760213851929,
0.23880590498447418,
0.8131464123725891,
-0.7491270303726196,
0.11607502400875092,
-0.2269551157951355,
0.3355935513973236,
-0.016753045842051506,
-0.4037831723690033,
0.03688051551580429,
0.05883843079209328,
-0.23618125915527344,
-0.6350967288017273,
0.3016658425331116,
-0.655166506767273,
-0.6559492945671082,
0.35599324107170105,
0.5224827527999878,
-0.09755247831344604,
-0.008519169874489307,
-0.4518488049507141,
0.06050606817007065,
0.018196087330579758,
-0.13210934400558472,
0.5522076487541199,
0.6012693643569946,
-0.16989269852638245,
0.48127812147140503,
0.8339240550994873,
0.3924570083618164,
0.02956174500286579,
-0.10830245167016983,
0.7382281422615051,
-0.43944457173347473,
-0.4174865186214447,
-0.8045472502708435,
0.4560979902744293,
0.02287643775343895,
-0.16340968012809753,
1.010411262512207,
0.5823265910148621,
1.1551085710525513,
0.04491740092635155,
0.5761154890060425,
0.33878499269485474,
0.4390484094619751,
-0.7318205237388611,
0.4365532696247101,
-0.7177737951278687,
0.4179692566394806,
-0.19218036532402039,
-1.062875509262085,
-0.39689311385154724,
0.22015956044197083,
-0.33307236433029175,
-0.11532966792583466,
0.5646309852600098,
0.9345206618309021,
-0.03446204215288162,
-0.16357500851154327,
0.28624528646469116,
0.27503225207328796,
0.24940073490142822,
0.5587641000747681,
0.6722358465194702,
-0.4322395324707031,
0.5853034853935242,
-0.15199196338653564,
-0.2916008532047272,
-0.11642304807901382,
-0.7472983598709106,
-0.7685851454734802,
-0.4312551021575928,
-0.02225278876721859,
-0.16261079907417297,
0.061874572187662125,
0.939228892326355,
0.7073100209236145,
-0.6138100028038025,
-0.34854570031166077,
-0.02473692037165165,
-0.08944202214479446,
-0.33823320269584656,
-0.09495510905981064,
0.023779280483722687,
-0.7658052444458008,
-0.9686102867126465,
0.5614739656448364,
0.4130218029022217,
0.06393248587846756,
-0.33005085587501526,
-0.22953754663467407,
-0.20040030777454376,
-0.14053267240524292,
0.7029139995574951,
0.08615368604660034,
-0.7489002346992493,
0.002103232778608799,
-0.011102992109954357,
-0.3841153383255005,
0.0646611824631691,
0.7727275490760803,
-0.3520101010799408,
0.41877615451812744,
0.3778557777404785,
0.9521029591560364,
0.5781917572021484,
0.10495560616254807,
0.8429933786392212,
-0.4939318299293518,
0.34529125690460205,
0.06672701239585876,
0.24450130760669708,
0.4017046093940735,
-0.27519354224205017,
0.47640854120254517,
-0.017614932730793953,
-0.38290590047836304,
-0.9188151955604553,
0.09565920382738113,
-0.9194803833961487,
-0.14168965816497803,
1.1274755001068115,
-0.10841412842273712,
0.08431495726108551,
0.19680151343345642,
-0.313963383436203,
0.38565218448638916,
-0.014207689091563225,
0.61732017993927,
0.6212673187255859,
0.19178585708141327,
-0.03479577228426933,
-0.7530593872070312,
0.2945472002029419,
0.7732619047164917,
-0.7669275999069214,
0.037290822714567184,
0.262362003326416,
-0.049072399735450745,
0.09088362008333206,
0.3878273665904999,
-0.3525524139404297,
0.01950868032872677,
-0.24717295169830322,
-0.23190312087535858,
-0.27677878737449646,
-0.4146750867366791,
-0.4400410056114197,
-0.06795814633369446,
0.04710232466459274,
0.08667904138565063
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11425v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11425v1
|
Narrative Feature or Structured Feature? A Study of Large Language Models to Identify Cancer Patients at Risk of Heart Failure
| 2024-03-18T02:42:01 | 2024-03-18T02:42:01 |
Ziyi Chen, Mengyuan Zhang, Mustafa Mohammed Ahmed, Yi Guo, Thomas J. George, Jiang Bian, Yonghui Wu
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Cancer treatments are known to introduce cardiotoxicity, negatively impacting
outcomes and survivorship. Identifying cancer patients at risk of heart failure
(HF) is critical to improving cancer treatment outcomes and safety. This study
examined machine learning (ML) models to identify cancer patients at risk of HF
using electronic health records (EHRs), including traditional ML, Time-Aware
long short-term memory (T-LSTM), and large language models (LLMs) using novel
narrative features derived from the structured medical codes. We identified a
cancer cohort of 12,806 patients from the University of Florida Health,
diagnosed with lung, breast, and colorectal cancers, among which 1,602
individuals developed HF after cancer. The LLM, GatorTron-3.9B, achieved the
best F1 scores, outperforming the traditional support vector machines by 39%,
the T-LSTM deep learning model by 7%, and a widely used transformer model,
BERT, by 5.6%. The analysis shows that the proposed narrative features
remarkably increased feature density and improved performance.
|
[
0.05646110698580742,
-0.6871602535247803,
0.9951935410499573,
-0.17391136288642883,
-0.070456363260746,
0.20337218046188354,
0.05078832060098648,
-0.43795010447502136,
0.06670497357845306,
0.7940177917480469,
-0.5529981851577759,
-0.930944561958313,
-0.7819284796714783,
-0.1154824048280716,
-0.41241270303726196,
1.271467924118042,
-0.17594586312770844,
0.03932001814246178,
-0.2482479065656662,
-0.18694394826889038,
-0.3954785466194153,
-0.7209966778755188,
-0.6107257008552551,
-0.5446092486381531,
0.9462150931358337,
0.1523715704679489,
0.8923991322517395,
0.9573750495910645,
0.8010281324386597,
0.2168571650981903,
0.12615151703357697,
-0.2292289137840271,
-0.34298041462898254,
0.10683207213878632,
0.30895307660102844,
-0.5076152682304382,
-0.2777737081050873,
-0.2777968645095825,
0.22226035594940186,
0.8237811326980591,
0.015308651141822338,
0.015990523621439934,
0.0874391496181488,
0.815422534942627,
-0.2948221266269684,
0.1510864943265915,
-0.09742242842912674,
0.5447545647621155,
-0.11427438259124756,
-0.14813388884067535,
-0.2603912353515625,
-0.8107909560203552,
0.40837061405181885,
-0.3981730043888092,
0.3368678689002991,
0.11806224286556244,
0.6152297258377075,
0.3706142008304596,
-0.44714900851249695,
-0.6938886046409607,
-0.8313737511634827,
0.4467591941356659,
-0.29614895582199097,
0.20448309183120728,
0.3696719706058502,
0.5127041935920715,
-0.2712084949016571,
-0.5573333501815796,
-0.11236605793237686,
-0.3457795977592468,
-0.3405172824859619,
0.01649443246424198,
-0.19885452091693878,
0.4119457006454468,
0.2550307810306549,
0.7570058703422546,
-0.8949242234230042,
0.23782506585121155,
-0.4798758625984192,
-0.4614020884037018,
0.5406870245933533,
0.3812631070613861,
0.3267909586429596,
-0.3303643763065338,
-0.2698929011821747,
-0.08421950042247772,
-0.374083548784256,
0.27463263273239136,
0.1392069011926651,
0.2844417095184326,
-0.16073168814182281,
0.6051108241081238,
-0.000696434814017266,
0.22368080914020538,
-0.19387653470039368,
-0.3246919512748718,
0.428009569644928,
-0.020695937797427177,
-0.49343162775039673,
0.4626983106136322,
0.7820165157318115,
0.06306660920381546,
0.21429970860481262,
0.039318908005952835,
0.16294556856155396,
0.14135977625846863,
0.33870550990104675,
-0.7227737307548523,
-0.38424408435821533,
0.6630505323410034,
-0.8475110530853271,
-0.35555335879325867,
0.1078060120344162,
-0.41824057698249817,
-0.5939185619354248,
0.37102624773979187,
0.3380787968635559,
-0.5709195137023926,
0.025722134858369827,
0.15095718204975128,
-0.15598642826080322,
-0.2135317623615265,
0.07558950036764145,
-0.49029943346977234,
0.08312293887138367,
0.684018611907959,
0.9003710746765137,
-0.09350106120109558,
-0.031590208411216736,
-0.6031810641288757,
-0.06170039251446724,
-0.08671578764915466,
0.5755269527435303,
-0.5824122428894043,
-0.5814913511276245,
0.20826469361782074,
0.1600981205701828,
-0.11514796316623688,
-0.3782232999801636,
0.92629075050354,
0.06743106991052628,
0.46551868319511414,
-0.2088114321231842,
-0.6021502017974854,
-0.35407623648643494,
0.1379566490650177,
-1.0165324211120605,
0.7948668003082275,
0.387572705745697,
-0.5322219729423523,
0.2463328242301941,
-0.3753407299518585,
-0.5091013312339783,
-0.01623791828751564,
-0.1261727511882782,
-0.9758473634719849,
0.21613682806491852,
0.1521192193031311,
0.871191143989563,
-0.1289071887731552,
0.15768304467201233,
-0.41155123710632324,
-0.29642271995544434,
0.3723551034927368,
-0.17555557191371918,
0.26857101917266846,
0.19907574355602264,
0.00765131413936615,
0.1469467580318451,
-0.7498966455459595,
0.045851681381464005,
0.17854925990104675,
-0.47484785318374634,
-0.14231707155704498,
0.05759506672620773,
-0.05491359159350395,
0.4201856851577759,
-0.3376939296722412,
-0.322107195854187,
-0.05167359113693237,
-0.46950915455818176,
0.4874500334262848,
0.15788748860359192,
0.32958588004112244,
0.09108417481184006,
-0.8116337060928345,
0.5355023741722107,
0.09977856278419495,
0.09657273441553116,
-0.5191637277603149,
-0.4799586236476898,
-0.3926483392715454,
-0.3706187903881073,
0.0861971527338028,
0.5797218084335327,
-0.30425113439559937,
0.43987521529197693,
-0.11420605331659317,
-0.6419948935508728,
-0.606225311756134,
-0.07981912046670914,
0.610815703868866,
0.7561814188957214,
0.4061224162578583,
-0.2375536859035492,
-0.43268150091171265,
-0.9901674389839172,
-0.08058986812829971,
-0.25125572085380554,
-0.25326427817344666,
0.6527117490768433,
0.2961571216583252,
-0.2257416546344757,
0.28532108664512634,
-0.4820803999900818,
-0.3904041349887848,
-0.4035812318325043,
-0.0483345128595829,
0.2393200546503067,
0.2428625226020813,
0.19569408893585205,
-0.5879154205322266,
-0.2017708420753479,
0.19843219220638275,
-0.6471785306930542,
0.08306978642940521,
-0.19881337881088257,
0.046233415603637695,
0.019817743450403214,
0.04875761643052101,
-0.45825570821762085,
0.5122314691543579,
0.551024317741394,
-0.2828449308872223,
0.18322664499282837,
-0.3600345253944397,
0.17449752986431122,
-0.9262760281562805,
0.14774112403392792,
0.20463505387306213,
-0.16678284108638763,
-0.7654704451560974,
-0.4803098440170288,
-0.14666642248630524,
-0.22263850271701813,
-0.1351214051246643,
0.2812439799308777,
-0.30365970730781555,
0.033851828426122665,
-0.21655848622322083,
-0.186324805021286,
0.09316342324018478,
0.3397674560546875,
0.07543223351240158,
-0.10422152280807495,
0.1662575751543045,
-0.3795398473739624,
0.1562783122062683,
0.1998225748538971,
-0.23883067071437836,
0.42527762055397034,
-0.6570606231689453,
-0.01886558160185814,
-0.1489415317773819,
0.39751434326171875,
-0.888138473033905,
-0.49779295921325684,
0.11204275488853455,
-0.536435604095459,
0.1606706976890564,
-0.09991931170225143,
-0.15166202187538147,
-0.8500827550888062,
-0.14891822636127472,
0.034374840557575226,
0.5958479642868042,
0.062292393296957016,
0.5464461445808411,
0.1318904608488083,
-0.2223999798297882,
-0.16868382692337036,
-0.9268903732299805,
-0.27751418948173523,
-0.4316125214099884,
-0.6692866683006287,
0.2513439357280731,
0.07820704579353333,
0.07185947149991989,
0.06132391840219498,
0.1128186509013176,
-0.05518361181020737,
0.3422866761684418,
0.7048601508140564,
0.05435183644294739,
-0.2255558967590332,
0.5295988321304321,
-0.0971599593758583,
-0.09520082920789719,
0.11781144887208939,
-0.04377463459968567,
0.6189853549003601,
-0.09726833552122116,
-0.5140004754066467,
-0.6456589698791504,
0.6070588827133179,
0.616819441318512,
-0.11297529190778732,
0.634800910949707,
0.5481609106063843,
-0.5959309339523315,
-0.09176003932952881,
-0.42826882004737854,
-0.05935126543045044,
-0.29415565729141235,
0.558097243309021,
0.04338342696428299,
-1.189944863319397,
0.5342260003089905,
-0.07488705962896347,
-0.2238532453775406,
0.6944112777709961,
0.7870344519615173,
-0.3365735113620758,
0.7596468925476074,
0.7074690461158752,
-0.23948557674884796,
0.17115518450737,
-0.0018931420054286718,
0.016005799174308777,
-0.44578126072883606,
-0.49202296137809753,
-0.6246492862701416,
-0.589996337890625,
-0.6762705445289612,
-0.43349170684814453,
0.7429529428482056,
-0.20673859119415283,
-0.3623617887496948,
0.006481048185378313,
-0.5977570414543152,
0.025536170229315758,
0.2434455007314682,
0.48970580101013184,
0.32829439640045166,
-0.12839871644973755,
-0.07796196639537811,
0.1295587569475174,
-0.6605895757675171,
-0.39205485582351685,
1.2973859310150146,
0.686570405960083,
0.2572484612464905,
-0.08817879110574722,
0.7974233627319336,
0.34537237882614136,
0.05591602995991707,
-0.7506006360054016,
-0.0033987897913903,
-0.2162129133939743,
-0.46576011180877686,
-0.35140901803970337,
-0.37365269660949707,
-1.0360164642333984,
-0.35976821184158325,
-0.5541449189186096,
-0.3401099443435669,
0.030333632603287697,
0.2300226092338562,
-0.7888950109481812,
0.1210286021232605,
-0.42076376080513,
0.8801374435424805,
-0.5837058424949646,
0.06556908041238785,
0.10435567796230316,
-0.8161342740058899,
0.2994645833969116,
-0.2428501546382904,
0.1408899426460266,
-0.047269195318222046,
0.1926916092634201,
0.3919622004032135,
-0.5295014977455139,
0.6216856241226196,
0.02241506241261959,
0.395266056060791,
0.0362083837389946,
-0.07408366352319717,
0.625377357006073,
-0.134226992726326,
-0.2875862717628479,
0.08814123272895813,
-0.08925963193178177,
-0.3755723834037781,
-0.5750023722648621,
0.4489747881889343,
-0.542677104473114,
-0.2512650489807129,
-0.38895294070243835,
-0.3467588722705841,
-0.20006394386291504,
0.040793150663375854,
0.3968542218208313,
0.24692022800445557,
-0.5279031991958618,
0.38956040143966675,
0.660267174243927,
-0.4555017054080963,
0.44057363271713257,
0.08222460746765137,
0.0235426127910614,
-0.4193957448005676,
0.5597325563430786,
-0.011188647709786892,
0.22841385006904602,
0.45032355189323425,
0.6186663508415222,
0.07424178719520569,
-0.8062244057655334,
-0.19749140739440918,
0.12001726031303406,
-0.2667337656021118,
-0.05747949331998825,
-0.9695560336112976,
-0.6433764696121216,
0.198158398270607,
-0.34935691952705383,
-0.16602474451065063,
-0.10024584084749222,
-0.3805428445339203,
-0.3485322594642639,
0.36704063415527344,
0.4805302619934082,
0.45852914452552795,
0.193520188331604,
-1.117445945739746,
0.03267467021942139,
0.008815241046249866,
0.10903593897819519,
-0.07254475355148315,
-0.3216562569141388,
-0.37350016832351685,
-0.2974931299686432,
-0.2128085494041443,
-0.87979656457901,
0.40720611810684204,
0.4941881000995636,
0.7317011952400208,
0.3823293447494507,
-0.049846649169921875,
0.32664012908935547,
-0.3522448241710663,
0.6749460101127625,
0.30242836475372314,
-0.5437830686569214,
0.8395859003067017,
-0.4697325825691223,
0.2354128658771515,
0.47136348485946655,
0.7370102405548096,
-0.7343090772628784,
-0.273643434047699,
-0.7764567732810974,
-0.4557364583015442,
0.34460073709487915,
0.24334318935871124,
-0.07681882381439209,
0.000040742248529568315,
0.6053454279899597,
0.26468661427497864,
0.1800716519355774,
-0.6424322724342346,
-0.22964206337928772,
-0.24626320600509644,
-0.7435387969017029,
-0.24865444004535675,
-0.42459025979042053,
-0.19921860098838806,
0.12258927524089813,
0.3286932110786438,
-0.14961327612400055,
0.21497194468975067,
0.5243032574653625,
-0.0911530926823616,
-0.24530074000358582,
0.40404513478279114,
0.4667694568634033,
0.08983056992292404,
-0.15408849716186523,
-0.07380463927984238,
0.01232828013598919,
-0.5228207111358643,
-0.066547691822052,
0.29140907526016235,
0.05790397524833679,
-0.2706231474876404,
0.9562978148460388,
1.0659725666046143,
0.3805108666419983,
-0.6794727444648743,
0.46161699295043945,
0.1740812510251999,
-0.3188958168029785,
-0.2144680768251419,
0.3548658788204193,
0.1965348869562149,
0.5220156311988831,
0.07885123789310455,
-0.10601077973842621,
0.21131153404712677,
-0.7416951656341553,
0.2196437120437622,
0.21229404211044312,
-0.8345605731010437,
-0.20127196609973907,
0.4161388874053955,
0.18734680116176605,
-0.3398158848285675,
0.42080140113830566,
0.35579878091812134,
-0.44882673025131226,
0.6797631978988647,
0.38791030645370483,
0.9201430678367615,
-0.3576323091983795,
0.3937661647796631,
0.349729061126709,
0.2514892518520355,
-0.31556931138038635,
0.2686249613761902,
0.35341599583625793,
-0.3988048732280731,
0.09121905267238617,
-0.6798473000526428,
-0.48808953166007996,
-0.05695131793618202,
-0.4509619176387787,
0.2429116666316986,
-0.5679420828819275,
-0.03426537662744522,
0.008838651701807976,
0.31479769945144653,
-0.6907360553741455,
0.40261730551719666,
0.4827757477760315,
0.47907185554504395,
-0.9042196869850159,
0.8628839254379272,
0.4751676619052887,
-0.2564919590950012,
-0.9371541738510132,
-0.143690288066864,
0.4475955367088318,
-0.5253567695617676,
0.16744956374168396,
0.4009445309638977,
0.42105358839035034,
-0.3123393952846527,
0.15185554325580597,
-0.8749563694000244,
1.5219471454620361,
0.2607281804084778,
-0.744900643825531,
-0.05306042730808258,
0.35270917415618896,
0.8843328356742859,
-0.8313031792640686,
0.2643393278121948,
0.5050761699676514,
0.35480576753616333,
0.28259074687957764,
-0.8931976556777954,
0.06916087120771408,
-0.061722081154584885,
0.045908983796834946,
0.292234867811203,
-0.6776867508888245,
0.7428697347640991,
-0.49428147077560425,
-0.2660759687423706,
0.05780661106109619,
0.36821067333221436,
0.3030628561973572,
0.8784605860710144,
0.16573558747768402,
0.7218877673149109,
1.231213927268982,
-0.20973265171051025,
1.350664734840393,
0.14472408592700958,
0.07079782336950302,
0.7236765623092651,
-0.10238306224346161,
0.6923626065254211,
-0.15614347159862518,
-0.19684258103370667,
0.7293076515197754,
0.7793830037117004,
-0.06354862451553345,
0.26698338985443115,
0.3437652587890625,
-0.028501104563474655,
-0.22361119091510773,
0.182267427444458,
-0.37004250288009644,
0.4003940224647522,
0.4411686658859253,
-1.1308530569076538,
0.029916299507021904,
0.31995800137519836,
0.3463636040687561,
0.08946476131677628,
-0.403464674949646,
0.6544967889785767,
0.20059554278850555,
-0.38747018575668335,
0.2939606010913849,
-0.2081381380558014,
0.23231427371501923,
-0.5864720344543457,
0.13261638581752777,
-0.23817899823188782,
0.1427404284477234,
-0.5372539758682251,
-0.64571613073349,
0.4474901258945465,
-0.12318284809589386,
-0.5644313097000122,
0.029058754444122314,
0.7522305846214294,
-0.43353593349456787,
-1.0217379331588745,
0.2765369713306427,
0.523983895778656,
0.10478196293115616,
-0.33181995153427124,
-0.7277264595031738,
0.3441981375217438,
-0.06970072537660599,
-0.2894039452075958,
0.23744377493858337,
0.3399598002433777,
-0.17515642940998077,
0.6678178310394287,
0.6070376634597778,
0.17408566176891327,
-0.43033328652381897,
-0.217534601688385,
0.6932676434516907,
-1.0368789434432983,
-0.37405696511268616,
-0.8751237988471985,
0.44301560521125793,
0.07059010863304138,
-0.4178043603897095,
0.6280913352966309,
0.39055371284484863,
0.37822288274765015,
0.19062039256095886,
0.8776594996452332,
0.4277414083480835,
0.7644264101982117,
-0.7148589491844177,
1.0277724266052246,
-0.4573148787021637,
0.2407403290271759,
-0.27343234419822693,
-0.5091400742530823,
-0.6183742880821228,
0.029925942420959473,
-0.43646496534347534,
0.1905696541070938,
0.9416402578353882,
0.4148671329021454,
0.3300418257713318,
0.017594989389181137,
0.41297417879104614,
0.46421018242836,
0.4401703178882599,
1.1952179670333862,
0.3832920491695404,
-0.43825164437294006,
0.5445321798324585,
-0.2614743709564209,
-0.21535339951515198,
-0.4987265467643738,
-0.8394113183021545,
-1.0084043741226196,
-0.4783903956413269,
-0.29111820459365845,
-0.3320603370666504,
0.14453616738319397,
0.8697916865348816,
0.5331878662109375,
-0.6569041013717651,
0.15399624407291412,
0.3334084153175354,
0.263502299785614,
-0.11123789101839066,
-0.023574430495500565,
0.6695364117622375,
0.24945032596588135,
-0.16077478229999542,
0.38842809200286865,
0.5574031472206116,
0.003374697407707572,
-0.12596487998962402,
-0.15746814012527466,
0.32206687331199646,
-0.0011275587603449821,
0.36591893434524536,
0.410316526889801,
-0.7335302233695984,
-0.2847853899002075,
-0.09877629578113556,
-0.3813513219356537,
0.22113707661628723,
0.8561637997627258,
-0.925597608089447,
0.31503668427467346,
0.17227639257907867,
0.6334550976753235,
0.24264617264270782,
-0.0364239476621151,
0.3808647692203522,
-0.29654625058174133,
-0.1947886347770691,
0.5181360840797424,
0.382296621799469,
0.39059317111968994,
-0.9095110893249512,
0.10594488680362701,
0.35187864303588867,
-0.5709123611450195,
-0.6050803661346436,
-0.035269737243652344,
-1.125414252281189,
-0.11924246698617935,
1.0157191753387451,
-0.016201982274651527,
-0.2987944185733795,
-0.23166516423225403,
0.04215230047702789,
0.09190069139003754,
-0.19957831501960754,
0.7416173815727234,
0.6637144684791565,
-0.44352808594703674,
-0.2116154432296753,
-0.6724784970283508,
0.7154407501220703,
0.10997481644153595,
-0.8756035566329956,
-0.3475596010684967,
0.49377259612083435,
0.24319151043891907,
-0.08862016350030899,
0.5659292340278625,
-0.23188340663909912,
0.37067002058029175,
-0.3546507954597473,
-0.0326208658516407,
-0.38130444288253784,
-0.2807145416736603,
-0.43227991461753845,
0.6980645656585693,
-0.34541642665863037,
0.16290132701396942
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11413v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11413v1
|
Dynamic Contexts for Generating Suggestion Questions in RAG Based Conversational Systems
| 2024-03-18T02:01:58 | 2024-03-18T02:01:58 |
Anuja Tayal, Aman Tyagi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
When interacting with Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG)-based
conversational agents, the users must carefully craft their queries to be
understood correctly. Yet, understanding the system's capabilities can be
challenging for the users, leading to ambiguous questions that necessitate
further clarification. This work aims to bridge the gap by developing a
suggestion question generator. To generate suggestion questions, our approach
involves utilizing dynamic context, which includes both dynamic few-shot
examples and dynamically retrieved contexts. Through experiments, we show that
the dynamic contexts approach can generate better suggestion questions as
compared to other prompting approaches.
|
[
-0.8052743077278137,
-1.1054635047912598,
0.8070761561393738,
-0.13364636898040771,
-0.31018054485321045,
0.19217036664485931,
-0.09085894376039505,
-0.6586484909057617,
0.4654446840286255,
0.4917106032371521,
-1.0807700157165527,
0.26320427656173706,
-0.21086719632148743,
0.11376537382602692,
-0.37560099363327026,
1.1040061712265015,
0.13603490591049194,
-0.5222782492637634,
-0.20039090514183044,
-0.27091965079307556,
-1.106555461883545,
-0.07423826307058334,
-0.8220010995864868,
-0.29205572605133057,
0.6835393905639648,
0.621825635433197,
0.5823376774787903,
-0.09596935659646988,
0.2547033727169037,
0.35159093141555786,
-0.34131529927253723,
0.5707938075065613,
-0.5535789728164673,
1.103092074394226,
-0.1641189306974411,
-0.42730188369750977,
-0.2985554039478302,
-0.20833393931388855,
0.6374303102493286,
0.5549450516700745,
-0.04560502991080284,
0.2175336480140686,
0.02222062088549137,
0.3870770335197449,
-0.685094952583313,
-0.279319167137146,
-1.0324437618255615,
0.2316528856754303,
-0.1415577232837677,
-0.6477230787277222,
-0.15642011165618896,
-0.18722420930862427,
0.39212486147880554,
-0.5524176359176636,
0.10147833079099655,
0.09301363676786423,
0.7004827857017517,
0.16725222766399384,
-0.5077521800994873,
-0.5310101509094238,
-1.017773985862732,
0.535552978515625,
-0.2587764859199524,
0.08354037255048752,
0.31549981236457825,
0.8522289991378784,
-0.4556974470615387,
-0.8033614754676819,
-0.6089496612548828,
-0.3851219117641449,
-0.22484299540519714,
0.08175921440124512,
0.005046074278652668,
-0.3483508229255676,
0.37930211424827576,
0.14450056850910187,
-0.4022442400455475,
-0.5408674478530884,
0.0646965429186821,
0.22402840852737427,
0.38197624683380127,
0.4786737859249115,
-0.03328273072838783,
-0.4154605269432068,
-0.2522118091583252,
0.01789657212793827,
-0.5158830285072327,
0.17835941910743713,
0.15328288078308105,
0.34929507970809937,
0.10880772769451141,
0.2388778179883957,
-0.26645055413246155,
0.9819265604019165,
0.5211153626441956,
-0.03324490785598755,
-0.13863953948020935,
-0.3641098141670227,
0.05684525892138481,
-0.24194888770580292,
0.32700249552726746,
0.3819679617881775,
-0.018082672730088234,
-0.1597307026386261,
-0.2240169793367386,
-0.4476863741874695,
0.5419877171516418,
-0.6192065477371216,
0.2025102823972702,
0.3197767734527588,
-0.31352850794792175,
-0.6329687237739563,
0.15507909655570984,
-0.9337523579597473,
-0.5648637413978577,
-0.09640482813119888,
0.19816240668296814,
-0.24470144510269165,
-0.45286017656326294,
-0.4760761857032776,
-0.4768364131450653,
-0.0069061038084328175,
0.5082657337188721,
-0.9121589064598083,
0.13499753177165985,
0.283191442489624,
0.30385464429855347,
-0.15364229679107666,
0.001039218157529831,
-0.5173140168190002,
0.42520904541015625,
-0.23425722122192383,
1.1740161180496216,
-0.7750852704048157,
-0.7232949137687683,
-0.027222495526075363,
0.06461066752672195,
0.18243780732154846,
-0.7712159156799316,
-0.054457057267427444,
-0.8446473479270935,
0.2037038803100586,
-0.47261402010917664,
-0.3622170090675354,
0.1811060905456543,
0.640620768070221,
-0.34341245889663696,
1.1892520189285278,
0.1379241645336151,
-0.6785233616828918,
0.5952548980712891,
-0.5735531449317932,
-0.09002074599266052,
0.6489260196685791,
-0.497265487909317,
-0.10920756310224533,
-0.0248875729739666,
-0.018055936321616173,
0.2609104812145233,
-0.20946526527404785,
0.5562166571617126,
-0.004663688130676746,
-0.2537274658679962,
0.576335072517395,
-0.4622013568878174,
0.27646878361701965,
0.47188571095466614,
-0.523874044418335,
0.10932241380214691,
-0.760535717010498,
0.3564383387565613,
0.22210925817489624,
-0.2905213236808777,
-0.3826558589935303,
-0.11599007248878479,
-0.11157020926475525,
-0.3260642886161804,
0.2414514124393463,
-0.04878391698002815,
0.37929216027259827,
-0.32650214433670044,
-0.0469130277633667,
0.5569276809692383,
0.48012644052505493,
0.40153366327285767,
-0.538732647895813,
0.8876591324806213,
-0.20424650609493256,
-0.21484683454036713,
-0.40417107939720154,
-0.5997270941734314,
-0.5275104641914368,
0.24097417294979095,
0.13911549746990204,
0.5776782631874084,
-1.3410861492156982,
0.0412789024412632,
0.26550358533859253,
-0.5268473029136658,
0.1677803248167038,
-0.12607809901237488,
0.4251731038093567,
0.5871343016624451,
0.20945554971694946,
0.056278057396411896,
-0.6358357071876526,
-0.5994595289230347,
-0.37036311626434326,
-0.3677353262901306,
-0.019867505878210068,
1.117093801498413,
0.3627603054046631,
-0.2286089062690735,
1.506165862083435,
-0.6921456456184387,
0.0967014729976654,
-0.37968331575393677,
0.24140213429927826,
0.07284785062074661,
0.3010919988155365,
0.7702020406723022,
-1.1015667915344238,
-0.4932522475719452,
-0.11354383826255798,
-0.4265029728412628,
-0.3053911030292511,
-0.16278061270713806,
-0.10617333650588989,
0.058265239000320435,
0.42055293917655945,
-0.5695324540138245,
0.2259780466556549,
0.33150091767311096,
-0.274613618850708,
0.6502075791358948,
-0.16069898009300232,
0.17187665402889252,
-1.5698699951171875,
0.2288711816072464,
-0.5014836192131042,
-0.4289475977420807,
-0.6324239373207092,
0.09984268248081207,
-0.29693490266799927,
-0.33064764738082886,
-0.3315088450908661,
0.9897097945213318,
-0.33648908138275146,
-0.026107987388968468,
-0.5335081219673157,
0.2266249656677246,
-0.1467578262090683,
0.17648707330226898,
-0.031148750334978104,
0.9114360809326172,
0.24229906499385834,
-0.9535883069038391,
0.5406941771507263,
0.17396427690982819,
-0.2331320196390152,
0.7148720026016235,
-0.5875475406646729,
0.38844436407089233,
-0.07905001193284988,
0.6410866379737854,
-1.0556728839874268,
-0.5457189679145813,
0.19339299201965332,
-0.3766823709011078,
0.21464866399765015,
-0.24006134271621704,
-0.1351591795682907,
-0.39490747451782227,
-0.1261121928691864,
0.6887105107307434,
0.389443039894104,
-0.4562431871891022,
0.311319500207901,
0.49244701862335205,
-0.12206614017486572,
-0.5184023976325989,
-0.456464558839798,
0.06321728974580765,
-0.31246036291122437,
-0.5372083187103271,
0.6422037482261658,
-0.2685847580432892,
-0.38563162088394165,
0.1575748473405838,
0.07634507864713669,
0.0411573126912117,
0.08027780055999756,
0.17041751742362976,
0.008612695150077343,
0.07107030600309372,
0.17930473387241364,
0.13091078400611877,
0.01474407222121954,
-0.2935638129711151,
-0.01819572225213051,
0.675692617893219,
-0.2050337940454483,
-0.3081183135509491,
-0.12710130214691162,
0.4552425444126129,
0.32503411173820496,
-0.18345072865486145,
0.4063960015773773,
0.5856478214263916,
-0.21652650833129883,
-0.4404505491256714,
-0.6007901430130005,
-0.5821110010147095,
-0.6031017899513245,
0.01274070143699646,
-0.6045404672622681,
-1.161746621131897,
0.8516240119934082,
-0.3449974060058594,
-0.09618628025054932,
0.0751604214310646,
0.831912636756897,
-0.24921970069408417,
1.1068044900894165,
0.5007318258285522,
0.40979644656181335,
0.7588525414466858,
-0.37885043025016785,
-0.07440400123596191,
-0.7696511745452881,
-0.1705387532711029,
-0.32024744153022766,
-0.4406522810459137,
-0.6774502992630005,
-0.30188947916030884,
0.6440248489379883,
-0.0865987166762352,
0.19177813827991486,
0.2886497974395752,
-0.5565117001533508,
0.3977971374988556,
0.5613396763801575,
-0.1986498385667801,
-0.014833183959126472,
-0.19782374799251556,
-0.43271809816360474,
0.1697525531053543,
-0.7509768009185791,
-0.5780612230300903,
0.44211748242378235,
-0.1604936569929123,
0.6621684432029724,
0.3624632954597473,
0.8367549180984497,
0.3045467138290405,
0.0954902172088623,
-0.7974505424499512,
0.6743248701095581,
0.4444335401058197,
-1.029031753540039,
-0.32708215713500977,
-0.10575035214424133,
-1.608998417854309,
0.08009841293096542,
-0.519720733165741,
-0.9164119958877563,
0.24001425504684448,
0.29416120052337646,
-0.8110981583595276,
0.08194021880626678,
-0.2960472106933594,
0.5295380353927612,
0.08116383105516434,
-0.33838364481925964,
-0.017179708927869797,
-0.5729449391365051,
0.16826583445072174,
0.09341584146022797,
-0.1107107475399971,
-0.010496716015040874,
0.21550112962722778,
0.38445764780044556,
-0.4084149897098541,
0.7269868850708008,
-0.3496125638484955,
-0.052440810948610306,
0.8415512442588806,
0.4282132685184479,
0.6053659915924072,
0.45189282298088074,
-0.06019553914666176,
-0.6236357688903809,
0.18148048222064972,
0.1623542755842209,
-0.8381451368331909,
0.5719504356384277,
-0.2052358090877533,
-0.9439635872840881,
-0.3234695792198181,
-0.8670877814292908,
-0.48383867740631104,
0.21334658563137054,
0.23792614042758942,
0.6210548877716064,
-0.15788908302783966,
0.24798211455345154,
0.39927196502685547,
-0.31324464082717896,
0.4325956404209137,
0.5750601887702942,
-0.25504520535469055,
-0.1980338990688324,
0.5988025069236755,
0.021732686087489128,
0.018587807193398476,
0.01574275828897953,
0.14772731065750122,
-0.15536221861839294,
-0.3164091110229492,
-0.7482284903526306,
-0.06006205081939697,
-0.33336466550827026,
-0.3471730351448059,
-0.4332939684391022,
-0.10828959196805954,
-0.419181764125824,
-0.3250126540660858,
-0.11654623597860336,
-0.3130301237106323,
-0.20416153967380524,
0.12105072289705276,
0.5929628014564514,
0.8621172308921814,
0.22033102810382843,
0.23187217116355896,
-0.9786173105239868,
0.3924493193626404,
0.6815873384475708,
0.33948731422424316,
0.23611854016780853,
-0.3972877264022827,
-0.15006962418556213,
0.11082252115011215,
-0.6875251531600952,
-1.1307449340820312,
0.40897947549819946,
0.0210744496434927,
0.6903508305549622,
0.4114290475845337,
0.19625097513198853,
0.8019075989723206,
-0.9289718270301819,
1.1703263521194458,
-0.15547259151935577,
-0.3280144929885864,
0.990147590637207,
-0.6865676045417786,
0.4835810959339142,
0.6907901167869568,
0.0016001499025151134,
-0.7395926713943481,
-0.5507856607437134,
-0.8014903664588928,
-0.7928646802902222,
0.8250248432159424,
0.28632375597953796,
0.5091374516487122,
-0.2509571313858032,
0.6045414805412292,
0.14123360812664032,
0.166042298078537,
-0.15652534365653992,
-0.33681702613830566,
0.24955421686172485,
0.1866665780544281,
0.3167318105697632,
-0.3949427902698517,
-0.29205361008644104,
-0.08566419780254364,
0.30286461114883423,
-0.2854626774787903,
0.5782089233398438,
0.12521755695343018,
0.31500083208084106,
-0.48208218812942505,
0.3972926437854767,
0.9562653303146362,
0.8124862909317017,
-0.3662148416042328,
-0.10364151000976562,
0.5686023235321045,
-0.13627447187900543,
0.2592538893222809,
-0.09929322451353073,
-0.2543111741542816,
0.08404229581356049,
-0.10561396926641464,
0.8411329388618469,
0.08928698301315308,
-0.6886570453643799,
0.2239437997341156,
-0.3720167279243469,
0.0036187777295708656,
-0.6178531646728516,
0.4066201448440552,
0.024586336687207222,
0.6251174211502075,
0.5441041588783264,
-0.0024010315537452698,
0.18248873949050903,
-0.7824098467826843,
0.28946006298065186,
0.8704818487167358,
-0.30000045895576477,
-0.08749637752771378,
0.5631178021430969,
0.3296019434928894,
-0.7624012231826782,
0.03762392699718475,
-0.46946215629577637,
-0.6240825653076172,
0.6194140911102295,
0.735167920589447,
0.8521406650543213,
-0.09276952594518661,
0.24973280727863312,
0.11688712239265442,
-0.26999592781066895,
0.1210486888885498,
0.46038341522216797,
-0.6695036292076111,
-0.8507776260375977,
-0.1504395306110382,
-0.5122470855712891,
-0.7772412300109863,
0.22226610779762268,
-0.5633329749107361,
0.4361611604690552,
-0.2392842024564743,
-0.5402143001556396,
-0.11661602556705475,
0.004919102881103754,
-0.33351972699165344,
0.13517995178699493,
0.10481493175029755,
0.498455673456192,
-0.07965806871652603,
0.7586134672164917,
1.1599903106689453,
-0.2509886622428894,
-0.9624567627906799,
0.18828952312469482,
0.055872298777103424,
-0.41355791687965393,
0.8131376504898071,
-0.1607556939125061,
-0.4894185960292816,
-0.2462497502565384,
-0.4726700484752655,
-1.0340914726257324,
1.2623591423034668,
0.06877835094928741,
-0.1890876740217209,
-0.039864156395196915,
-0.12773829698562622,
0.5708432793617249,
-0.4540700614452362,
0.46922066807746887,
0.30516499280929565,
0.5626331567764282,
0.5515479445457458,
-1.166821002960205,
-0.01185654941946268,
-0.40838685631752014,
0.07309727370738983,
0.21482542157173157,
-0.6669778227806091,
0.8153789043426514,
-0.09513233602046967,
-0.13050541281700134,
0.43836161494255066,
0.5428225994110107,
0.675116777420044,
0.7684836983680725,
0.6743359565734863,
0.18357953429222107,
0.8274163603782654,
0.11849285662174225,
1.2411563396453857,
-0.33865025639533997,
0.06625757366418839,
1.2331408262252808,
-0.2691110372543335,
0.6373268365859985,
0.4235354959964752,
0.09936262667179108,
0.8221920728683472,
0.6708734035491943,
0.23490729928016663,
0.4332450330257416,
-0.2073378711938858,
-0.3279150426387787,
0.056056637316942215,
-0.18228265643119812,
-0.5321168303489685,
0.5861353874206543,
0.47805649042129517,
-0.21640904247760773,
-0.19434311985969543,
0.14572499692440033,
-0.06881905347108841,
-0.1395934820175171,
0.11281412094831467,
1.1768356561660767,
-0.08526291698217392,
-1.2174811363220215,
0.7334157824516296,
-0.10521506518125534,
0.7113338112831116,
-0.5299796462059021,
-0.24440275132656097,
-0.37700155377388,
-0.10429298132658005,
-0.02857549861073494,
-0.7672536969184875,
0.40282997488975525,
0.23407664895057678,
-0.21333616971969604,
-0.39514732360839844,
1.16825270652771,
-0.5669218897819519,
-0.008950984105467796,
-0.19601531326770782,
0.6661203503608704,
0.30972471833229065,
0.25533628463745117,
-0.7796515226364136,
-0.2117888182401657,
-0.12152989208698273,
-0.44806188344955444,
0.33898505568504333,
0.5685835480690002,
-0.13374140858650208,
0.6982844471931458,
0.5207663178443909,
0.19312866032123566,
-0.19235488772392273,
0.0181873869150877,
0.9861130118370056,
-0.5470957159996033,
-0.5458652377128601,
-0.5196904540061951,
0.5361368656158447,
-0.20953036844730377,
-0.18889941275119781,
0.7413274645805359,
0.12094791233539581,
0.5682105422019958,
0.05311649665236473,
0.4899824261665344,
-0.45742595195770264,
0.7505119442939758,
-0.23767778277397156,
0.7598565220832825,
-0.9195923209190369,
0.40613168478012085,
-0.3740873336791992,
-1.1414238214492798,
0.01935443840920925,
0.5639072060585022,
-0.061257168650627136,
0.41943156719207764,
0.5745782852172852,
0.8783806562423706,
-0.030548173934221268,
0.12023763358592987,
0.33272191882133484,
-0.09127739071846008,
0.5130823850631714,
0.09338472783565521,
1.0634098052978516,
-0.010620327666401863,
0.5505350232124329,
-0.025167029350996017,
0.01826431415975094,
-0.5030365586280823,
-0.991100013256073,
-0.5776783227920532,
-0.8564239144325256,
0.07599184662103653,
-0.2913703918457031,
-0.010143008083105087,
1.1025551557540894,
0.7803385257720947,
-0.638515293598175,
-0.2687661051750183,
-0.013821856118738651,
0.08737730979919434,
0.04048081859946251,
-0.3391839563846588,
0.03990952670574188,
-0.5155832767486572,
-0.8629462122917175,
0.7167521119117737,
0.07061916589736938,
0.2410592883825302,
-0.33488649129867554,
0.10008247941732407,
-0.26686206459999084,
0.21127493679523468,
0.750664234161377,
0.2814372479915619,
-0.6098294258117676,
-0.505139946937561,
-0.0555717907845974,
0.10917335003614426,
-0.351429283618927,
1.109017252922058,
-1.3567314147949219,
0.5587837100028992,
0.5836252570152283,
0.6391988396644592,
0.5558584928512573,
0.2201448380947113,
0.600464403629303,
-1.1219453811645508,
0.4810175597667694,
0.5564743280410767,
0.0058986893855035305,
0.07752304524183273,
-0.5248095989227295,
0.3719576895236969,
0.21811805665493011,
-0.6772807240486145,
-0.9931484460830688,
0.5225515961647034,
-0.9558285474777222,
-0.41796359419822693,
1.4012119770050049,
0.12270332127809525,
-0.10732249170541763,
-0.11378209292888641,
-0.6270429491996765,
0.09113383293151855,
-0.4613363444805145,
0.6762710213661194,
0.5712095499038696,
-0.638473629951477,
-0.12416095286607742,
-0.4753485321998596,
0.9171145558357239,
0.6430610418319702,
-0.6187363266944885,
-0.13458187878131866,
0.489214152097702,
-0.03788132965564728,
0.21366296708583832,
0.7584390044212341,
0.2840396761894226,
0.2956838011741638,
-0.21677927672863007,
-0.39629697799682617,
0.06288010627031326,
-0.30056726932525635,
0.19410772621631622,
0.2563853859901428,
0.1557990461587906,
0.16442207992076874
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15447v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15447v3
|
Decoding Compressed Trust: Scrutinizing the Trustworthiness of Efficient LLMs Under Compression
| 2024-03-18T01:38:19 | 2024-06-04T05:40:12 |
Junyuan Hong, Jinhao Duan, Chenhui Zhang, Zhangheng Li, Chulin Xie, Kelsey Lieberman, James Diffenderfer, Brian Bartoldson, Ajay Jaiswal, Kaidi Xu, Bhavya Kailkhura, Dan Hendrycks, Dawn Song, Zhangyang Wang, Bo Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Compressing high-capability Large Language Models (LLMs) has emerged as a
favored strategy for resource-efficient inferences. While state-of-the-art
(SoTA) compression methods boast impressive advancements in preserving benign
task performance, the potential risks of compression in terms of safety and
trustworthiness have been largely neglected. This study conducts the first,
thorough evaluation of three (3) leading LLMs using five (5) SoTA compression
techniques across eight (8) trustworthiness dimensions. Our experiments
highlight the intricate interplay between compression and trustworthiness,
revealing some interesting patterns. We find that quantization is currently a
more effective approach than pruning in achieving efficiency and
trustworthiness simultaneously. For instance, a 4-bit quantized model retains
the trustworthiness of its original counterpart, but model pruning
significantly degrades trustworthiness, even at 50% sparsity. Moreover,
employing quantization within a moderate bit range could unexpectedly improve
certain trustworthiness dimensions such as ethics and fairness. Conversely,
extreme quantization to very low bit levels (3 bits) tends to reduce
trustworthiness significantly. This increased risk cannot be uncovered by
looking at benign performance alone, in turn, mandating comprehensive
trustworthiness evaluation in practice. These findings culminate in practical
recommendations for simultaneously achieving high utility, efficiency, and
trustworthiness in LLMs. Code and models are available at
https://decoding-comp-trust.github.io.
|
[
-0.10544800758361816,
-0.5031648874282837,
0.6628814339637756,
0.2474271059036255,
-0.39194703102111816,
0.15908795595169067,
-0.0554531067609787,
-0.6263357996940613,
-0.06956034898757935,
0.25484251976013184,
-0.35192686319351196,
-0.2384803295135498,
-1.0194541215896606,
0.1482076495885849,
-0.5350552201271057,
0.6108196973800659,
0.22061611711978912,
0.1614139825105667,
-0.31672203540802,
0.05592639371752739,
-0.12955035269260406,
-0.8670839071273804,
-0.7724785804748535,
-0.2826545536518097,
0.043040912598371506,
0.26407718658447266,
0.9783660769462585,
0.712397575378418,
0.5391509532928467,
0.28026917576789856,
-0.2381717711687088,
0.17301589250564575,
-0.6671651005744934,
0.3240285813808441,
0.23843799531459808,
-0.5975459218025208,
-0.5991220474243164,
0.20401065051555634,
0.5924597978591919,
0.2813265323638916,
-0.2930554449558258,
0.24233126640319824,
0.3284594416618347,
0.5854549407958984,
-0.6607279181480408,
0.08842200040817261,
-0.5096604228019714,
-0.07181210070848465,
-0.016628483310341835,
-0.6272013187408447,
-0.5259523391723633,
-0.6877685189247131,
-0.09371138364076614,
-0.5442918539047241,
-0.13018351793289185,
0.32808929681777954,
0.8135581612586975,
0.42302075028419495,
-0.19769413769245148,
-0.13786686956882477,
-0.6067814826965332,
0.7913572788238525,
-0.4025087356567383,
0.5476747155189514,
0.6027492880821228,
0.09677135199308395,
0.0309040118008852,
-0.7998353838920593,
-0.39097097516059875,
-0.19365264475345612,
0.22004450857639313,
-0.0020396278705447912,
-0.6192768216133118,
0.041790902614593506,
0.37003257870674133,
0.6371265649795532,
-0.34038588404655457,
0.006158972159028053,
-0.03747744858264923,
-0.5951899886131287,
0.47241106629371643,
-0.06964927911758423,
0.21694280207157135,
-0.05453210324048996,
-0.4826373755931854,
-0.47979864478111267,
-0.941960871219635,
-0.027541223913431168,
0.7279558181762695,
-0.26041099429130554,
0.01568792760372162,
0.3860549032688141,
-0.012754898518323898,
0.29437321424484253,
-0.08926821500062943,
-0.2178548276424408,
-0.1743411272764206,
-0.40900710225105286,
-0.37158718705177307,
-0.06556165218353271,
0.8299879431724548,
0.40404272079467773,
0.3846847712993622,
-0.21599751710891724,
-0.2440778911113739,
0.29380032420158386,
0.20456086099147797,
-0.7426732778549194,
-0.12940950691699982,
0.21483924984931946,
-0.7179606556892395,
-0.5515326261520386,
0.017849981784820557,
-0.41269418597221375,
-0.5797917246818542,
0.018491966649889946,
0.46204665303230286,
-0.77378249168396,
-0.17364393174648285,
0.49651455879211426,
-0.10219234228134155,
0.007661492098122835,
0.15533539652824402,
-0.5692617297172546,
0.37156572937965393,
0.854095458984375,
0.835023820400238,
0.010692557319998741,
-0.17037242650985718,
-0.6241773366928101,
0.05511265620589256,
-0.1830548197031021,
0.5664633512496948,
-0.4103897213935852,
-0.40996482968330383,
0.0332476906478405,
-0.26250576972961426,
0.32641446590423584,
-0.4400823712348938,
0.8654369711875916,
-0.641318142414093,
-0.3573512136936188,
-0.08842901140451431,
-0.5141754746437073,
0.01943105086684227,
0.3689746558666229,
-0.8899191617965698,
0.9592106938362122,
0.06374357640743256,
-0.5119838714599609,
0.22290845215320587,
-0.15400093793869019,
-0.17238499224185944,
-0.13126270473003387,
0.07461433112621307,
-0.3072354793548584,
0.42133212089538574,
0.11330380290746689,
0.6888844966888428,
-0.44412511587142944,
0.06337737292051315,
-0.3657808303833008,
-0.5370547771453857,
0.6550804972648621,
-0.7538123726844788,
0.8116229176521301,
0.33945631980895996,
-0.11117502301931381,
-0.17228324711322784,
-0.69460529088974,
0.1265416145324707,
0.020121697336435318,
-0.31898555159568787,
-0.34854280948638916,
-0.3219546973705292,
-0.14606034755706787,
-0.06765728443861008,
0.30727946758270264,
-0.37441158294677734,
-0.11264742165803909,
-0.2680475115776062,
0.6988765001296997,
0.8617013096809387,
-0.02188909240067005,
0.40428832173347473,
-0.3938840329647064,
0.526027262210846,
-0.0013470487901940942,
0.5284934043884277,
0.18356913328170776,
-0.17059169709682465,
-0.7307822108268738,
-0.20232591032981873,
0.45740076899528503,
0.20150040090084076,
-0.7799006104469299,
0.3838483393192291,
-0.542332112789154,
-0.31977805495262146,
-0.5897144079208374,
-0.24109086394309998,
0.6082685589790344,
-0.1039583832025528,
0.18029752373695374,
-0.391436368227005,
-0.4282154440879822,
-0.7434293627738953,
-0.6444286704063416,
-0.1701638251543045,
-0.02566063217818737,
0.018209045752882957,
0.2764831781387329,
0.04205935075879097,
0.4880484938621521,
-0.23219864070415497,
0.12712927162647247,
0.08152952790260315,
0.12569504976272583,
-0.11770789325237274,
0.6374404430389404,
0.3056780695915222,
-0.5495328307151794,
-0.2864445745944977,
-0.35482463240623474,
-0.3145831823348999,
0.15081006288528442,
0.048906609416007996,
-0.055668849498033524,
0.28266090154647827,
0.43888330459594727,
-0.7399116158485413,
0.23921483755111694,
1.0252854824066162,
-0.4044380187988281,
0.6999281644821167,
-0.20510262250900269,
0.27491995692253113,
-0.916157066822052,
-0.10292436927556992,
-0.12206675112247467,
-0.5780928134918213,
-0.5214732885360718,
0.5140401124954224,
0.10152778774499893,
0.12962836027145386,
-0.24184231460094452,
0.05469060689210892,
-0.5990548133850098,
-0.23593854904174805,
0.03781954199075699,
-0.10901083797216415,
0.04922645166516304,
0.13962723314762115,
-0.26238006353378296,
0.9395584464073181,
0.5251224637031555,
-0.4620131552219391,
0.10442184656858444,
-0.040785640478134155,
-0.5039317607879639,
0.4743894934654236,
-0.5686783194541931,
0.49937301874160767,
0.1401233971118927,
0.20589318871498108,
-0.5964974761009216,
0.012342803180217743,
0.1363939344882965,
-0.6144274473190308,
0.39595600962638855,
-0.11795756220817566,
-0.9426204562187195,
0.16710157692432404,
-0.643258273601532,
0.4253208339214325,
0.7072833776473999,
-0.41277599334716797,
0.5063441395759583,
0.3431410789489746,
0.20682649314403534,
-0.6667683124542236,
-0.8481448888778687,
0.16342024505138397,
-0.33009880781173706,
-0.5553293824195862,
0.17863303422927856,
-0.3232462406158447,
-0.2497391700744629,
0.009981419891119003,
-0.6495010852813721,
-0.13751836121082306,
0.3798605501651764,
0.4340949058532715,
0.1175476461648941,
0.24685236811637878,
-0.32134559750556946,
-0.014487229287624359,
-0.3192535638809204,
0.2917930781841278,
-0.4141155481338501,
0.6064868569374084,
-0.38550397753715515,
-0.09885817766189575,
-0.45514729619026184,
0.24579356610774994,
0.38926371932029724,
0.06251741945743561,
0.7562333345413208,
0.5313757658004761,
-0.3447597026824951,
-0.16268715262413025,
-0.6349761486053467,
-0.43703708052635193,
-0.5186049342155457,
-0.12013453990221024,
-0.49614691734313965,
-1.3722071647644043,
0.25365713238716125,
-0.31433385610580444,
-0.2612580358982086,
0.0652213841676712,
0.29103073477745056,
-0.021151188760995865,
0.7571924328804016,
0.6260948777198792,
0.03828606382012367,
0.2034958302974701,
-0.18124666810035706,
0.49083414673805237,
-0.4991231858730316,
-0.11310508102178574,
-0.6832708716392517,
-0.042985714972019196,
-0.6817706227302551,
-0.6030879020690918,
0.48860132694244385,
0.21885035932064056,
0.013536754995584488,
0.23345641791820526,
-0.37695327401161194,
0.4692517817020416,
0.5222844481468201,
0.3257472813129425,
0.6088374257087708,
0.10101042687892914,
0.2738740146160126,
0.0531737357378006,
-0.7235637903213501,
-0.7198238968849182,
1.0341521501541138,
0.6610684394836426,
0.7733550667762756,
0.23788289725780487,
0.8789927363395691,
0.15739670395851135,
-0.006518984213471413,
-0.88308185338974,
0.6417863368988037,
-0.1236855611205101,
-0.36383795738220215,
-0.249036967754364,
-0.5172152519226074,
-0.8805744051933289,
-0.1381075233221054,
-0.4148910641670227,
-0.6113207936286926,
0.09282330423593521,
0.2719514071941376,
-0.6048484444618225,
0.06582825630903244,
-0.5588768124580383,
0.30086228251457214,
0.20312316715717316,
-0.36572352051734924,
-0.4955947995185852,
-0.7048571109771729,
0.5308660268783569,
-0.036268144845962524,
0.11915596574544907,
0.032145094126462936,
-0.13760794699192047,
0.6779255270957947,
-0.15382108092308044,
0.6318919658660889,
0.23200806975364685,
-0.12970072031021118,
0.021882783621549606,
0.5058304667472839,
0.6605645418167114,
0.12452216446399689,
-0.0965854674577713,
0.5708412528038025,
0.5439520478248596,
-0.34700554609298706,
-0.8976088166236877,
0.7510316967964172,
-0.7081137299537659,
-0.6348813772201538,
-0.5188694000244141,
-0.6413373947143555,
-0.43755340576171875,
0.16161514818668365,
0.16694298386573792,
0.4662010073661804,
-0.08802369982004166,
0.4539180099964142,
1.0663827657699585,
-0.060324762016534805,
0.3355557918548584,
0.1482403725385666,
0.4030730128288269,
-0.28170111775398254,
0.6428726315498352,
-0.14414362609386444,
0.3763144612312317,
0.3616771996021271,
0.22753392159938812,
-0.2937264144420624,
-0.7565131187438965,
0.09412945061922073,
0.09094277769327164,
-0.6036380529403687,
-0.5082422494888306,
-0.3103218972682953,
-0.20542505383491516,
-0.5578814744949341,
0.13104934990406036,
-0.4790014326572418,
-0.6027156114578247,
-0.1965423971414566,
-0.16427209973335266,
0.25004512071609497,
0.5759909749031067,
-0.15900282561779022,
0.2892913222312927,
-1.0347578525543213,
0.05423419922590256,
0.07680293917655945,
0.40322408080101013,
-0.08111906051635742,
-0.2719256579875946,
-0.3057180345058441,
-0.21060584485530853,
-0.08672568947076797,
-0.8488710522651672,
0.28835371136665344,
-0.0990334153175354,
0.2839454114437103,
0.45470523834228516,
0.2965976893901825,
0.7598339319229126,
-0.32990217208862305,
0.8674737215042114,
0.23099370300769806,
-1.2111961841583252,
0.0128607964143157,
0.008287228643894196,
-0.2094755321741104,
0.5160963535308838,
0.5301738381385803,
-0.08957011252641678,
-0.2988506853580475,
-0.9520614743232727,
-0.6089869141578674,
0.3852287530899048,
0.3330601155757904,
0.04413085803389549,
0.12636829912662506,
0.4691995680332184,
0.20575812458992004,
0.14306360483169556,
-0.6393402814865112,
-0.25896430015563965,
-0.067607082426548,
-0.16584861278533936,
-0.02999998815357685,
-0.9153348803520203,
-0.5217906832695007,
0.2039484679698944,
0.5288355350494385,
-0.020476747304201126,
0.4755711257457733,
0.27855443954467773,
-0.07571741193532944,
0.05669432505965233,
0.46692344546318054,
0.28680750727653503,
0.36032426357269287,
-0.05110739544034004,
0.5914386510848999,
-0.08165652304887772,
-0.6185747385025024,
0.2861896753311157,
-0.08708394318819046,
0.06858087331056595,
-0.35904955863952637,
0.376829594373703,
0.5925639271736145,
0.23297221958637238,
-0.3842242956161499,
0.5867722034454346,
-0.32147830724716187,
-0.3267340064048767,
-0.18054521083831787,
0.08071058988571167,
-0.12775886058807373,
0.41634947061538696,
0.045609813183546066,
0.1198083907365799,
0.3391619026660919,
-0.6343451142311096,
-0.04510515183210373,
0.4942597448825836,
-0.09819801896810532,
-0.2733859419822693,
0.37260204553604126,
0.1195339784026146,
-0.1356004774570465,
0.2971559464931488,
-0.0627078264951706,
-0.4066890478134155,
0.07234199345111847,
0.45985156297683716,
0.813469409942627,
-0.16487108170986176,
-0.0509331040084362,
0.18213452398777008,
0.6205304265022278,
-0.6101069450378418,
0.3745703101158142,
-0.22296766936779022,
-0.7844210863113403,
-0.5839574337005615,
-0.46956515312194824,
-0.4532182216644287,
0.047729842364788055,
-1.0021589994430542,
-0.2550569176673889,
-0.37852582335472107,
-0.35260632634162903,
-0.6624698638916016,
0.3602958917617798,
-0.5605754852294922,
0.14610478281974792,
-0.03457840904593468,
1.2276995182037354,
-0.6836920976638794,
0.9683520793914795,
0.33828920125961304,
0.022675836458802223,
-1.098496913909912,
0.30162185430526733,
-0.1828272044658661,
-0.9774802327156067,
0.29168522357940674,
-0.07403584569692612,
-0.4142393171787262,
0.18098697066307068,
-0.6674779653549194,
-0.8221771717071533,
1.390508770942688,
0.7577665448188782,
-0.608248233795166,
0.061736591160297394,
0.026402071118354797,
0.2832241654396057,
0.04756123572587967,
0.14795175194740295,
0.9625632762908936,
0.46921566128730774,
-0.169738307595253,
-0.9071736931800842,
0.6158936023712158,
-0.014269818551838398,
0.12755024433135986,
-0.07636476308107376,
-0.775540292263031,
0.43338122963905334,
0.13567177951335907,
-0.4729158878326416,
0.2737258970737457,
0.6002641916275024,
0.6796277761459351,
0.22766011953353882,
0.6677389740943909,
0.7367576956748962,
0.801210880279541,
-0.07910200953483582,
1.2343485355377197,
-0.648006796836853,
0.2397424429655075,
0.636886477470398,
0.10490819811820984,
0.8123733997344971,
0.7478511929512024,
-0.10791365057229996,
0.2835710942745209,
0.4796125888824463,
0.2952355146408081,
0.4507022202014923,
0.05006508156657219,
-0.1592070311307907,
-0.46650153398513794,
-0.1815272569656372,
-0.19585910439491272,
0.3115529417991638,
0.17404033243656158,
-0.1797008067369461,
0.23475812375545502,
-0.47031480073928833,
0.2663983106613159,
-0.0027667901013046503,
-0.13539241254329681,
0.3265863358974457,
0.3451409935951233,
-0.503524661064148,
0.47996798157691956,
-0.11892130225896835,
0.7025514841079712,
-0.5028012990951538,
0.07227936387062073,
-0.0487142913043499,
-0.08987026661634445,
-0.21856561303138733,
-0.7416355013847351,
0.2036992460489273,
-0.06798132508993149,
0.10578713566064835,
-0.6762785315513611,
0.8296365141868591,
-0.030210748314857483,
0.1490420401096344,
0.12472899258136749,
0.4745095372200012,
0.25288280844688416,
-0.2106165885925293,
-0.44807398319244385,
0.7451164722442627,
-0.17778658866882324,
-0.23937895894050598,
0.5200387239456177,
0.4429008364677429,
0.24629008769989014,
0.7850514650344849,
0.7124446034431458,
0.34732016921043396,
-0.08607268333435059,
0.051315657794475555,
0.8692681193351746,
-0.4810832440853119,
-0.49383848905563354,
-0.9297119379043579,
0.23216897249221802,
-0.1495828479528427,
0.0879579484462738,
1.1094015836715698,
0.41738322377204895,
0.846855878829956,
0.0790942832827568,
0.6045944094657898,
0.3185057044029236,
-0.0040715523064136505,
-0.9177384972572327,
0.668394148349762,
-0.39031293988227844,
0.36358481645584106,
-0.04396873712539673,
-0.6984500885009766,
-0.33593258261680603,
0.5203860402107239,
0.1161641851067543,
-0.06135223060846329,
1.0297943353652954,
0.7842801809310913,
0.1666383296251297,
0.12727048993110657,
0.5754006505012512,
0.27897268533706665,
0.1682470738887787,
0.7310816645622253,
1.0966514348983765,
-0.5245161056518555,
0.793822705745697,
-0.34745529294013977,
-0.2864581048488617,
-0.04447036609053612,
-1.1612000465393066,
-0.660150408744812,
-0.426064133644104,
-0.23386771976947784,
-0.7579198479652405,
0.10793260484933853,
0.6895659565925598,
0.9150283336639404,
-0.33634909987449646,
-0.016135018318891525,
-0.11086222529411316,
0.0032937871292233467,
-0.4413367509841919,
-0.16645842790603638,
0.23354148864746094,
0.10963878035545349,
-0.8522233366966248,
0.507952868938446,
0.2496020346879959,
0.12297723442316055,
-0.38406500220298767,
-0.22621756792068481,
0.5863127112388611,
0.22252829372882843,
0.5620961785316467,
-0.1205785796046257,
-0.6367611885070801,
-0.38606947660446167,
0.05911961570382118,
-0.07950469106435776,
-0.25522416830062866,
1.0342084169387817,
-0.5784363150596619,
0.053048599511384964,
0.5233761668205261,
0.5667290091514587,
0.30141395330429077,
0.09163124859333038,
0.5971695184707642,
-0.6068980097770691,
-0.03553115203976631,
0.32630547881126404,
0.3894743025302887,
0.1966135948896408,
-0.6461192965507507,
0.5986979603767395,
0.0010571450693532825,
-0.7866020798683167,
-1.17878258228302,
0.26743072271347046,
-1.1392301321029663,
-0.1759425401687622,
1.3455129861831665,
-0.40587955713272095,
-0.29170817136764526,
0.08004817366600037,
0.021606141701340675,
0.3355225622653961,
-0.4651629328727722,
0.7821577787399292,
0.7876686453819275,
-0.17530900239944458,
-0.36079561710357666,
-0.41792866587638855,
0.6967099905014038,
0.44416698813438416,
-0.6094714999198914,
0.05370025709271431,
0.4144611656665802,
0.24158765375614166,
0.136353000998497,
0.678542971611023,
-0.20467589795589447,
0.26962247490882874,
0.25749510526657104,
-0.2791622281074524,
-0.37908631563186646,
-0.3965087831020355,
-0.7404871582984924,
0.41154855489730835,
0.3965480327606201,
-0.07299742847681046
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11399v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11399v3
|
X-LLaVA: Optimizing Bilingual Large Vision-Language Alignment
| 2024-03-18T01:14:47 | 2024-04-01T06:57:20 |
Dongjae Shin, Hyeonseok Lim, Inho Won, Changsu Choi, Minjun Kim, Seungwoo Song, Hangyeol Yoo, Sangmin Kim, Kyungtae Lim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The impressive development of large language models (LLMs) is expanding into
the realm of large multimodal models (LMMs), which incorporate multiple types
of data beyond text. However, the nature of multimodal models leads to
significant expenses in the creation of training data. Furthermore,
constructing multilingual data for LMMs presents its own set of challenges due
to language diversity and complexity. Therefore, in this study, we propose two
cost-effective methods to solve this problem: (1) vocabulary expansion and
pretraining of multilingual LLM for specific languages, and (2) automatic and
elaborate construction of multimodal datasets using GPT4-V. Based on015 these
methods, we constructed a 91K English-Korean-Chinese multilingual, multimodal
training dataset. Additionally, we developed a bilingual multimodal model that
exhibits excellent performance in both Korean and English, surpassing existing
approaches.
|
[
-0.24362558126449585,
-0.2225547432899475,
0.4113602340221405,
0.26814788579940796,
-0.20388466119766235,
0.307693213224411,
-0.29524385929107666,
-0.4456658363342285,
0.3360354006290436,
0.41378745436668396,
-0.5128458142280579,
-0.43676576018333435,
-0.36526867747306824,
0.08933332562446594,
0.03674459829926491,
0.7909442782402039,
-0.3221754729747772,
0.3622925281524658,
0.03494635596871376,
-0.2870407700538635,
-0.4219868779182434,
-0.3151082992553711,
-0.2969953417778015,
-0.1257673054933548,
0.785990834236145,
0.4064471125602722,
0.6781898140907288,
0.8474458456039429,
0.5166327357292175,
0.42453309893608093,
0.369893878698349,
0.6034020781517029,
-0.30859068036079407,
0.013402401469647884,
-0.19920660555362701,
-0.6337584257125854,
-0.7681031823158264,
-0.26341018080711365,
0.8735182881355286,
0.48135998845100403,
-0.042885903269052505,
0.04409327730536461,
-0.18388846516609192,
0.5333228707313538,
-0.47612398862838745,
0.2953377366065979,
-0.5481449961662292,
0.04849381744861603,
-0.654468297958374,
-0.1563301980495453,
-0.04468073323369026,
-0.21332411468029022,
0.06880886107683182,
-0.8553630113601685,
-0.3423009216785431,
-0.088234081864357,
1.0017505884170532,
0.10002153366804123,
-0.6991873383522034,
-0.11303491145372391,
-0.35372209548950195,
1.1029912233352661,
-0.3940185606479645,
0.794011116027832,
0.16722381114959717,
0.282195508480072,
0.2364128828048706,
-0.3493707776069641,
-0.5238094329833984,
0.02080734632909298,
0.17685255408287048,
0.368137925863266,
0.21905860304832458,
-0.039765018969774246,
0.011001304723322392,
0.22716939449310303,
-0.7820048928260803,
0.2995912432670593,
-0.18740111589431763,
-0.18161411583423615,
0.7110695838928223,
0.3540290892124176,
0.4390977621078491,
-0.15400953590869904,
-0.48698490858078003,
-0.1366669237613678,
-0.6531364917755127,
-0.15744489431381226,
0.5908440947532654,
0.4101254343986511,
-0.1821441650390625,
0.8145444393157959,
-0.19015829265117645,
0.6314557790756226,
-0.14566586911678314,
-0.8940925598144531,
0.6799461245536804,
-1.016710877418518,
-0.10477419197559357,
-0.10541591048240662,
0.5212118029594421,
0.5261518955230713,
0.49361440539360046,
-0.08189362287521362,
-0.25365832448005676,
0.09647520631551743,
0.08732660859823227,
-0.33066651225090027,
0.05228172615170479,
0.10309074074029922,
-0.018195927143096924,
-0.12024020403623581,
-0.36731284856796265,
-0.6950817108154297,
-0.06845591217279434,
-0.7447580099105835,
0.41406556963920593,
-0.36687180399894714,
-0.38375693559646606,
0.0043931142427027225,
0.2675008177757263,
0.3462072014808655,
0.35916125774383545,
-0.9377065896987915,
-0.2668936252593994,
0.36003586649894714,
0.6524661183357239,
-0.19513963162899017,
-0.45152121782302856,
-0.32553622126579285,
0.40134337544441223,
-0.37369638681411743,
0.4873228073120117,
-0.2620221972465515,
-0.10342571139335632,
0.03546261042356491,
0.0945846438407898,
-0.10131721198558807,
-0.30165278911590576,
0.32971662282943726,
-0.5671067833900452,
0.21921785175800323,
-0.26605847477912903,
-0.3638487458229065,
-0.04793643578886986,
0.5402697920799255,
-0.7254950404167175,
0.8435851335525513,
0.20173467695713043,
-0.7596451044082642,
0.4089672565460205,
-0.4501255750656128,
-0.3603932559490204,
0.3000039756298065,
-0.46885961294174194,
-0.2420494705438614,
-0.16415119171142578,
0.5292890071868896,
0.23863299190998077,
-0.39393454790115356,
0.2835310697555542,
0.08162359148263931,
0.18535782396793365,
-0.09651678800582886,
-0.24930192530155182,
0.816736102104187,
0.11954566836357117,
-0.380859375,
0.018105706200003624,
-0.709352970123291,
0.13101191818714142,
0.05829736217856407,
-0.5246967077255249,
-0.3840559720993042,
-0.25829532742500305,
0.058091044425964355,
0.35188016295433044,
0.5534724593162537,
-0.4314429461956024,
0.2515603303909302,
-0.4386247992515564,
-0.17469657957553864,
0.8422539234161377,
-0.6658116579055786,
0.5891563892364502,
-0.1062023863196373,
0.8820823431015015,
0.1387173980474472,
0.23477749526500702,
-0.40794265270233154,
-0.617324948310852,
-0.6922491192817688,
-0.5049002766609192,
0.23356309533119202,
0.9374071359634399,
-1.2873808145523071,
0.1169310212135315,
-0.6456246376037598,
-0.35663095116615295,
-0.6295369863510132,
0.6193520426750183,
0.6632879376411438,
0.49778416752815247,
0.2226659655570984,
-0.24445311725139618,
-0.6611221432685852,
-1.0313560962677002,
-0.04467247799038887,
0.03396550938487053,
0.2824234962463379,
0.09991130232810974,
0.2891499102115631,
-0.49063342809677124,
0.9055882692337036,
-0.3636184632778168,
-0.35466283559799194,
-0.26594364643096924,
-0.182073712348938,
0.0748174861073494,
0.361127108335495,
0.6152982115745544,
-0.9650915861129761,
-0.7867562174797058,
0.6464759111404419,
-0.7634245157241821,
-0.15438543260097504,
0.0822574570775032,
-0.13779909908771515,
0.40295878052711487,
0.2486341893672943,
-0.5451205968856812,
0.13531605899333954,
0.9659702181816101,
0.07477836310863495,
0.6203029751777649,
-0.316095769405365,
0.15309686958789825,
-1.1761882305145264,
-0.2225029021501541,
-0.02471446990966797,
-0.2870826721191406,
-0.7188814282417297,
0.22488389909267426,
0.3358543813228607,
0.15207958221435547,
-0.5808794498443604,
0.6615463495254517,
-0.7795897722244263,
0.08314298093318939,
-0.1985267549753189,
0.31126970052719116,
-0.06373310089111328,
0.49518007040023804,
0.09771285951137543,
0.5907576084136963,
0.6638088226318359,
-0.12330704182386398,
0.6455032825469971,
0.2690776586532593,
-0.5497951507568359,
0.5552648901939392,
-0.29440775513648987,
-0.16587261855602264,
-0.2612437605857849,
0.08209507167339325,
-0.8868373036384583,
-0.3605770766735077,
0.29938849806785583,
-0.10004816204309464,
0.5321633219718933,
-0.08338548243045807,
-0.47502580285072327,
-0.14298036694526672,
-0.3104833662509918,
0.9491596221923828,
0.22598856687545776,
-0.7098934650421143,
0.8161150813102722,
0.4931020438671112,
-0.40445762872695923,
-0.8837080001831055,
-0.714247465133667,
0.3449017107486725,
-0.2507327198982239,
-0.8722656965255737,
0.3024071455001831,
-0.041334353387355804,
-0.2547512352466583,
-0.2153717428445816,
0.211277574300766,
0.06354734301567078,
-0.46624794602394104,
-0.12143423408269882,
0.377332478761673,
-0.39744865894317627,
0.011265978217124939,
-0.010498195886611938,
-0.19257742166519165,
-0.3042629063129425,
-0.3186004161834717,
0.5068941116333008,
0.004889286123216152,
-0.34732335805892944,
-0.24784380197525024,
0.413248747587204,
0.46383166313171387,
-0.5639738440513611,
0.41143956780433655,
0.5640628337860107,
-0.08151622116565704,
0.0927307978272438,
-0.6838780641555786,
0.49247950315475464,
-0.47963595390319824,
0.775339663028717,
-0.5128534436225891,
-0.7534719705581665,
0.34822991490364075,
0.15466292202472687,
0.06908445805311203,
0.01709694229066372,
0.8491604328155518,
0.022939709946513176,
1.1716567277908325,
0.6157271862030029,
-0.1333330273628235,
0.48149141669273376,
0.020360806956887245,
0.14224208891391754,
-0.5148510932922363,
-0.25021791458129883,
0.016116343438625336,
-0.1906721293926239,
-0.7088701725006104,
-0.9072775840759277,
0.3257613480091095,
-0.41309991478919983,
0.02458241581916809,
0.3339187502861023,
-0.026250241324305534,
0.5503725409507751,
0.5379595756530762,
-0.048139650374650955,
0.28043660521507263,
0.24866071343421936,
-0.25983670353889465,
-0.3605690896511078,
-0.7391738295555115,
-0.24498401582241058,
1.4103871583938599,
0.2986421585083008,
0.7940744757652283,
0.3659818470478058,
0.631525456905365,
-0.5347487330436707,
0.08230362832546234,
-0.5493340492248535,
0.4480634033679962,
-0.2860567271709442,
-0.5199029445648193,
-0.3321303725242615,
-0.405402809381485,
-0.9216692447662354,
0.574708104133606,
-0.17121127247810364,
-0.5184468626976013,
0.1155538484454155,
0.1955958604812622,
-0.06887635588645935,
0.2588222324848175,
-0.7455509305000305,
0.735339343547821,
-0.9340707063674927,
-0.35980138182640076,
-0.05612129718065262,
-0.677825391292572,
0.6141669750213623,
-0.7273033261299133,
0.3719111680984497,
0.03668288141489029,
-0.4412490725517273,
0.5052247047424316,
-0.30096983909606934,
0.711068868637085,
-0.049336738884449005,
-0.5927078723907471,
-0.01798197254538536,
-0.443870484828949,
0.5483456254005432,
-0.01692894846200943,
0.3830806314945221,
0.1860402673482895,
-0.22214125096797943,
-0.5083142518997192,
-0.36980727314949036,
0.632777988910675,
-0.8216024041175842,
-0.5414546132087708,
-0.2638377845287323,
-1.0987242460250854,
-0.3426237404346466,
0.26994946599006653,
0.19134162366390228,
0.37936562299728394,
0.07053431123495102,
-0.15947166085243225,
0.5789132714271545,
-0.46526721119880676,
0.2520253360271454,
0.3581896722316742,
-0.616690993309021,
-0.8341790437698364,
1.1283807754516602,
0.3997085392475128,
0.5048654079437256,
0.5311775207519531,
0.028992909938097,
-0.35899755358695984,
-0.4687788486480713,
-0.45932433009147644,
0.5100857019424438,
-0.7323338985443115,
-0.13447974622249603,
-0.5352133512496948,
0.03860584646463394,
-0.6666536927223206,
-0.05823932960629463,
-0.4622897505760193,
-0.33892595767974854,
0.09617165476083755,
0.025868220254778862,
0.029047032818198204,
0.253523051738739,
-0.15690800547599792,
0.44319719076156616,
-0.8634061217308044,
0.397756427526474,
0.3313470482826233,
0.11601224541664124,
-0.24019183218479156,
-0.33266881108283997,
-0.5374460816383362,
0.16499386727809906,
-0.19576799869537354,
-0.5623772144317627,
0.6414197087287903,
0.2100996971130371,
0.5601154565811157,
0.5140141844749451,
-0.42433276772499084,
0.8852091431617737,
-0.6870219111442566,
0.5805104970932007,
0.4848003387451172,
-0.670212984085083,
0.23547694087028503,
-0.4603690207004547,
0.5814123153686523,
0.30718865990638733,
0.5202009677886963,
-0.21667566895484924,
-0.20992828905582428,
-0.14156141877174377,
-0.9511443376541138,
0.5421796441078186,
0.1713312715291977,
0.05313611775636673,
0.1696149855852127,
0.1599038988351822,
0.11991200596094131,
0.06303296983242035,
-0.8407475352287292,
-0.074278324842453,
-0.17950178682804108,
-0.45086023211479187,
-0.49398499727249146,
-0.13411474227905273,
-0.238168865442276,
-0.45263540744781494,
0.5063791275024414,
-0.311139851808548,
-0.2335599809885025,
-0.21564725041389465,
-0.40280881524086,
0.1251080483198166,
-0.10730899125337601,
0.8616483211517334,
0.6978529095649719,
0.07899226993322372,
-0.02551238425076008,
0.17192769050598145,
-0.4280211925506592,
0.408569872379303,
-0.1076328307390213,
0.0911446064710617,
0.03261600434780121,
0.37906455993652344,
0.832604706287384,
0.14445331692695618,
-0.9707271456718445,
0.5569666624069214,
0.12886472046375275,
-0.2977883219718933,
-0.31527087092399597,
-0.288799911737442,
0.30553504824638367,
0.5222105979919434,
-0.0340290330350399,
-0.44772109389305115,
-0.3599981665611267,
-0.3533945083618164,
-0.011420589871704578,
0.5529299378395081,
0.15347668528556824,
-0.3273274898529053,
0.6050685048103333,
0.1876167356967926,
0.1527787446975708,
0.6473225355148315,
0.18772928416728973,
-0.6245013475418091,
0.3392423391342163,
0.5075565576553345,
0.5525305867195129,
-0.5199490189552307,
0.09603345394134521,
0.23742307722568512,
0.3950575292110443,
-0.11407086253166199,
0.42611610889434814,
0.04983473941683769,
-0.9967589974403381,
-0.806201159954071,
-0.5317710041999817,
-0.18154707551002502,
-0.21125592291355133,
-0.392346054315567,
0.5484032034873962,
0.022920871153473854,
-0.19595995545387268,
-0.15396751463413239,
-0.018282229080796242,
-0.6545891165733337,
0.40448451042175293,
0.3924434185028076,
0.6866555213928223,
-0.8600879311561584,
1.2360022068023682,
0.6911298632621765,
-0.3161419928073883,
-0.7131270170211792,
-0.484108030796051,
0.1237357035279274,
-1.2429596185684204,
1.112594723701477,
-0.010214860551059246,
-0.15359994769096375,
-0.14733979105949402,
-0.13314108550548553,
-1.2173408269882202,
1.0974642038345337,
0.5502800345420837,
-0.938542902469635,
-0.27376696467399597,
0.5963720679283142,
0.33569931983947754,
-0.3610284626483917,
0.017234185710549355,
0.41842779517173767,
0.7087315917015076,
-0.03430641070008278,
-1.1529767513275146,
-0.364510715007782,
-0.2862377166748047,
0.05182229354977608,
0.42281389236450195,
-0.5824806690216064,
0.8390843868255615,
-0.09830867499113083,
0.005010291002690792,
0.11457178741693497,
0.515862226486206,
0.16692399978637695,
0.03483475372195244,
0.5839916467666626,
0.7392374277114868,
0.6554301977157593,
0.06987277418375015,
0.8358164429664612,
-0.29745230078697205,
0.12685133516788483,
1.0774259567260742,
-0.428443044424057,
0.538253903388977,
0.7157140374183655,
-0.006349664181470871,
0.05978483334183693,
0.6123981475830078,
-0.14266158640384674,
0.5468556880950928,
-0.024500254541635513,
-0.24860027432441711,
-0.25157323479652405,
0.0924004465341568,
-0.39276787638664246,
0.6030697822570801,
0.2894243896007538,
-0.22886204719543457,
-0.25858548283576965,
0.24534818530082703,
0.04247647523880005,
-0.2502451241016388,
-0.3283652365207672,
0.5465348958969116,
-0.04482052102684975,
-0.6026878356933594,
0.5022986531257629,
-0.10401982814073563,
0.8170650601387024,
-0.8642640709877014,
0.4279249608516693,
-0.3841143250465393,
0.2682267427444458,
-0.18908986449241638,
-0.5797796845436096,
0.07627265900373459,
-0.07003982365131378,
-0.0645400658249855,
-0.25589877367019653,
0.24061454832553864,
-0.9566932320594788,
-0.5964074730873108,
0.4074714183807373,
0.5359528660774231,
0.0900346040725708,
0.25134214758872986,
-0.6682606935501099,
0.11340343952178955,
0.2876310348510742,
-0.12664572894573212,
0.5605676174163818,
0.3291112780570984,
-0.40531450510025024,
0.5983536839485168,
0.4997527599334717,
0.36654162406921387,
0.4274040758609772,
0.0707484558224678,
0.7168131470680237,
-0.49054521322250366,
-0.45054444670677185,
-0.8087188601493835,
0.6521201133728027,
0.06145893782377243,
-0.2693133056163788,
0.8546222448348999,
0.61236971616745,
1.0230906009674072,
-0.09672849625349045,
0.8053848147392273,
0.3258698284626007,
0.2302151322364807,
-0.6758319735527039,
0.2699669599533081,
-1.045290470123291,
0.07064177840948105,
-0.43767645955085754,
-1.124377965927124,
-0.6061028838157654,
0.32885661721229553,
-0.13752220571041107,
-0.023571347817778587,
0.4520680606365204,
1.0229284763336182,
-0.14103657007217407,
-0.37637051939964294,
0.4624670743942261,
-0.018906526267528534,
0.4199497401714325,
0.6521522402763367,
0.821190357208252,
-0.2647477686405182,
0.6018452644348145,
-0.2809104323387146,
-0.43556100130081177,
-0.07031814754009247,
-0.8549454212188721,
-0.6290726661682129,
-0.4981171488761902,
-0.39630672335624695,
0.011325642466545105,
-0.1740858256816864,
0.8479514122009277,
0.601240336894989,
-0.49619823694229126,
-0.5248784422874451,
0.4097824692726135,
-0.23456507921218872,
-0.005628134589642286,
-0.06585121899843216,
0.33434632420539856,
-0.4804131090641022,
-1.0727088451385498,
0.44962751865386963,
0.5039346814155579,
0.1809074878692627,
-0.2789056599140167,
-0.2952634394168854,
-0.40400150418281555,
0.0385306216776371,
0.7908616662025452,
0.30905672907829285,
-0.8316598534584045,
-0.03329186141490936,
0.03973085805773735,
-0.11560739576816559,
0.2546241283416748,
0.4918345510959625,
-0.31941792368888855,
0.7930469512939453,
0.439969003200531,
0.8291542530059814,
0.39642658829689026,
0.01617485098540783,
0.8487778306007385,
-0.6524359583854675,
0.35720744729042053,
-0.0908006802201271,
0.5451845526695251,
0.45435836911201477,
-0.06476333737373352,
0.4319183826446533,
0.10987360030412674,
-0.5188729166984558,
-0.8025970458984375,
0.2419213354587555,
-1.1430516242980957,
-0.020471422001719475,
1.0097345113754272,
-0.05050550401210785,
-0.2729738652706146,
-0.04391644522547722,
-0.3893088400363922,
0.10788281261920929,
0.2211831957101822,
0.40196362137794495,
0.6269981265068054,
-0.14574220776557922,
-0.23961913585662842,
-0.5194664001464844,
0.1665978878736496,
0.46626752614974976,
-0.7114622592926025,
-0.13094976544380188,
0.4405258297920227,
0.21737971901893616,
0.28681573271751404,
0.45247697830200195,
-0.23453213274478912,
0.15389664471149445,
-0.13841639459133148,
0.2731548547744751,
0.2050459235906601,
-0.3349684476852417,
-0.31122490763664246,
0.021181702613830566,
-0.07811864465475082,
-0.27198442816734314
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11381v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11381v2
|
Can LLM-Augmented autonomous agents cooperate?, An evaluation of their cooperative capabilities through Melting Pot
| 2024-03-18T00:13:43 | 2024-06-19T16:23:05 |
Manuel Mosquera, Juan Sebastian Pinzon, Manuel Rios, Yesid Fonseca, Luis Felipe Giraldo, Nicanor Quijano, Ruben Manrique
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
As the field of AI continues to evolve, a significant dimension of this
progression is the development of Large Language Models and their potential to
enhance multi-agent artificial intelligence systems. This paper explores the
cooperative capabilities of Large Language Model-augmented Autonomous Agents
(LAAs) using the well-known Meltin Pot environments along with reference models
such as GPT4 and GPT3.5. Preliminary results suggest that while these agents
demonstrate a propensity for cooperation, they still struggle with effective
collaboration in given environments, emphasizing the need for more robust
architectures. The study's contributions include an abstraction layer to adapt
Melting Pot game scenarios for LLMs, the implementation of a reusable
architecture for LLM-mediated agent development - which includes short and
long-term memories and different cognitive modules, and the evaluation of
cooperation capabilities using a set of metrics tied to the Melting Pot's
"Commons Harvest" game. The paper closes, by discussing the limitations of the
current architectural framework and the potential of a new set of modules that
fosters better cooperation among LAAs.
|
[
-0.5911269783973694,
-0.7126135230064392,
0.8114985227584839,
0.11163994669914246,
0.16438265144824982,
0.5038352608680725,
-0.18039783835411072,
-0.8585066199302673,
0.4126461446285248,
0.5004867911338806,
-0.3233247399330139,
-0.11360366642475128,
-0.4373689889907837,
0.2579779624938965,
-0.0742945745587349,
0.5193319916725159,
-0.027598727494478226,
-0.1317012757062912,
-0.5300993919372559,
-0.18400706350803375,
-0.5622594356536865,
-0.5070421695709229,
-0.49934259057044983,
-0.7177815437316895,
0.5764940977096558,
0.4231989085674286,
0.9179267883300781,
0.45201802253723145,
0.4566071629524231,
0.582689642906189,
0.15700040757656097,
0.2407725602388382,
-0.33279019594192505,
0.18658040463924408,
-0.0767902359366417,
-0.4855595529079437,
-0.8107974529266357,
0.2846096456050873,
0.49444934725761414,
0.2939154803752899,
0.15452834963798523,
-0.08365688472986221,
-0.004431379027664661,
0.3743211328983307,
-0.5970416069030762,
0.3993215560913086,
-0.5658389329910278,
-0.06465673446655273,
0.04018622264266014,
-0.20082977414131165,
-0.5751803517341614,
0.034282028675079346,
0.05304838344454765,
-0.5606354475021362,
-0.37525054812431335,
-0.05684302747249603,
0.3739575743675232,
0.33158984780311584,
-0.3489443063735962,
-0.5051350593566895,
-0.9211141467094421,
0.8641809821128845,
-0.6670068502426147,
-0.1354578286409378,
0.5381583571434021,
0.36309826374053955,
-0.4017637372016907,
-0.598796010017395,
-0.5908243656158447,
-0.46743452548980713,
-0.055381178855895996,
0.323554664850235,
-0.1381779909133911,
-0.11650852859020233,
-0.39234840869903564,
0.4614813029766083,
-0.25607138872146606,
0.42166590690612793,
-0.2095993161201477,
0.026159394532442093,
0.8178364634513855,
0.40593796968460083,
0.514918863773346,
0.14880353212356567,
-0.3820050358772278,
0.14220286905765533,
-0.4205996096134186,
0.0368887335062027,
0.2577093839645386,
0.3828261196613312,
-0.3356403708457947,
0.7091431617736816,
0.15723340213298798,
0.5058649182319641,
0.058231208473443985,
-0.0707436203956604,
0.1831555962562561,
-0.2063985913991928,
-0.16897457838058472,
-0.17909133434295654,
0.7102356553077698,
0.2735106647014618,
-0.07667543739080429,
-0.4592585265636444,
-0.4072225093841553,
0.289498895406723,
0.19588489830493927,
-0.23911981284618378,
-0.3452284336090088,
0.4718843698501587,
-0.17554819583892822,
-0.17979225516319275,
0.00403638044372201,
-0.5527356863021851,
-0.5097106695175171,
-0.2740934491157532,
0.455450177192688,
-0.0855393037199974,
-0.47791779041290283,
-0.20266015827655792,
-0.026123566552996635,
0.6536303758621216,
0.17901311814785004,
-0.8959358930587769,
0.5411456823348999,
1.0415215492248535,
0.9242057800292969,
-0.4191545248031616,
-0.9241307973861694,
-0.4797419011592865,
0.2398987114429474,
-0.23947767913341522,
1.0833312273025513,
-0.53046053647995,
-0.3732592761516571,
-0.04273204132914543,
-0.03909587115049362,
-0.020747506991028786,
-0.6597365140914917,
-0.14281843602657318,
-0.7390641570091248,
-0.07164308428764343,
-0.3156296908855438,
-0.43239328265190125,
0.02639530412852764,
0.5618778467178345,
-1.0176407098770142,
0.42292535305023193,
0.23479613661766052,
-0.33956220746040344,
0.08044163137674332,
-0.7767945528030396,
-0.34369850158691406,
0.3903489112854004,
-0.3101024925708771,
-0.20007763803005219,
-0.20573878288269043,
-0.08710837364196777,
0.3136395514011383,
-0.3563920855522156,
-0.149819478392601,
-0.34249889850616455,
-0.5042559504508972,
0.40812790393829346,
-0.2323048859834671,
0.8895118832588196,
0.000929220812395215,
-0.32474586367607117,
0.5150724053382874,
-0.19499051570892334,
-0.20966573059558868,
0.18198026716709137,
-0.3815830945968628,
-0.05751281976699829,
-0.04424399510025978,
-0.3052629232406616,
-0.08844929933547974,
0.48245835304260254,
-0.0662037581205368,
0.2767487168312073,
-0.12019920349121094,
0.2334408164024353,
1.0362050533294678,
0.0011975809466093779,
0.9146132469177246,
-0.7457892298698425,
0.4866979718208313,
-0.18019095063209534,
0.15441401302814484,
0.066828653216362,
-0.4435855746269226,
-0.7285912036895752,
-0.6414787769317627,
0.0338422991335392,
0.8260805010795593,
-1.1006425619125366,
0.7454059720039368,
-0.053920574486255646,
-0.4464414119720459,
-0.35408636927604675,
0.17953941226005554,
0.07280140370130539,
-0.14627134799957275,
0.042348090559244156,
-0.484255850315094,
-0.32030147314071655,
-0.5991412997245789,
0.37622785568237305,
0.008839060552418232,
0.11448178440332413,
0.37690499424934387,
0.5761697292327881,
-0.3717544674873352,
0.9075581431388855,
0.06431445479393005,
-0.2955104112625122,
-0.3058958053588867,
0.01639546826481819,
0.007255105301737785,
0.29194051027297974,
0.525752604007721,
-0.7069903016090393,
-0.7715855836868286,
0.4532611668109894,
-1.0261949300765991,
0.22672563791275024,
0.07065840810537338,
-0.09765130281448364,
0.21293918788433075,
0.22836089134216309,
-0.7659028172492981,
0.2259267270565033,
0.7072599530220032,
-0.49801039695739746,
0.6427778005599976,
-0.23359760642051697,
0.14207863807678223,
-0.9086495637893677,
-0.2576405704021454,
-0.4302586615085602,
-0.12728969752788544,
-0.7218999862670898,
0.30749496817588806,
-0.6729831695556641,
0.4059934616088867,
-0.5760390758514404,
0.6536287665367126,
-0.6917257308959961,
-0.4545460343360901,
-0.734839677810669,
0.49764254689216614,
-0.30166155099868774,
0.3412553071975708,
-0.05248262733221054,
0.8037501573562622,
0.8740739226341248,
-0.59735506772995,
1.0769238471984863,
0.06074058637022972,
-0.1640194207429886,
0.6616320013999939,
-0.3809260427951813,
0.31268295645713806,
0.3658638298511505,
0.43134865164756775,
-0.2783852219581604,
-0.31590667366981506,
0.42437729239463806,
-0.23527882993221283,
-0.06651489436626434,
0.3606542944908142,
-0.6560832262039185,
0.031295694410800934,
-0.39857175946235657,
0.685443639755249,
0.3760167956352234,
-0.4129540026187897,
1.176775574684143,
0.5607323050498962,
0.012300730682909489,
-0.5604462027549744,
-0.5140679478645325,
0.2271212488412857,
-0.33031901717185974,
-0.7018833756446838,
-0.011137022636830807,
-0.3859281837940216,
-0.9001034498214722,
0.22417692840099335,
0.48871538043022156,
0.0074499850161373615,
0.02432168833911419,
0.3330167233943939,
0.2305285632610321,
-0.1071120947599411,
-0.26018431782722473,
-0.39636722207069397,
-0.11979599297046661,
-0.09409607201814651,
0.24805818498134613,
0.7369787096977234,
-0.6827475428581238,
-0.2516430616378784,
-0.2494206577539444,
0.3578692674636841,
0.7972943782806396,
-0.24595433473587036,
0.9677680134773254,
0.43766504526138306,
-0.27590593695640564,
0.005505476146936417,
-0.46718084812164307,
-0.12193029373884201,
-0.5229228734970093,
0.05830123648047447,
-0.36559629440307617,
-0.9063633680343628,
1.0483908653259277,
-0.04245860502123833,
0.2791639566421509,
0.31060001254081726,
0.9503232836723328,
0.127659872174263,
0.2639593183994293,
0.49094218015670776,
-0.2859502136707306,
0.20482714474201202,
-0.27629554271698,
-0.040457092225551605,
-0.8344132900238037,
-0.28848883509635925,
-0.17520639300346375,
-0.36047083139419556,
-0.68863844871521,
-0.6990372538566589,
0.24819031357765198,
-0.49758201837539673,
-0.26528552174568176,
0.160455122590065,
-0.2144152820110321,
0.8426885008811951,
0.5061015486717224,
0.12709347903728485,
0.48306065797805786,
-0.28976815938949585,
0.43600478768348694,
0.38767534494400024,
-0.6805736422538757,
-0.5140703916549683,
0.6376439929008484,
0.34042513370513916,
0.29080209136009216,
0.3560900390148163,
0.7447358965873718,
0.6315909028053284,
0.6286093592643738,
-0.8565712571144104,
0.7509593367576599,
0.016791149973869324,
-0.48716264963150024,
-0.5618116855621338,
-0.36033084988594055,
-1.1166273355484009,
0.28264090418815613,
-0.3917159140110016,
-0.6568500995635986,
0.040918946266174316,
-0.30823957920074463,
-0.3470650911331177,
0.5731672048568726,
-0.6482500433921814,
0.4958874583244324,
-0.38347578048706055,
-0.48541873693466187,
-0.24655701220035553,
-0.38316795229911804,
0.5241080522537231,
-0.03413031995296478,
0.4099404513835907,
-0.08451415598392487,
-0.21331168711185455,
0.19979780912399292,
-0.02371714822947979,
0.8750719428062439,
0.001469348557293415,
-0.3985403776168823,
0.7143564820289612,
0.309925377368927,
0.37327292561531067,
-0.15855567157268524,
-0.2800007462501526,
0.020566940307617188,
-0.279867023229599,
-0.6500564813613892,
-0.5669599175453186,
1.0230084657669067,
-1.124477505683899,
-0.7098063826560974,
-0.5662496089935303,
-0.989361047744751,
-0.11072970181703568,
0.06070973724126816,
-0.057197071611881256,
-0.020623626187443733,
-0.2878974378108978,
0.18507803976535797,
0.23065967857837677,
-0.13171283900737762,
0.5686091184616089,
0.17267172038555145,
-0.11778010427951813,
-0.40753790736198425,
0.9158747792243958,
-0.08160530775785446,
0.371364951133728,
0.09138825535774231,
0.0693058967590332,
0.1885937601327896,
-0.3954235017299652,
-0.09077491611242294,
0.007913710549473763,
-0.6663134694099426,
-0.2913868725299835,
-0.097127266228199,
-0.35365068912506104,
-0.2123783826828003,
-0.687067985534668,
-0.34156155586242676,
0.1159951388835907,
-0.22294491529464722,
0.006449432112276554,
0.20872128009796143,
1.1369036436080933,
-0.40350815653800964,
0.3851204514503479,
-0.5679454803466797,
0.17691178619861603,
0.5511053800582886,
0.29625043272972107,
0.26479995250701904,
-0.14012238383293152,
-0.3580229580402374,
-0.07510261237621307,
0.005476778373122215,
-0.8516768217086792,
0.0957987979054451,
-0.2769068479537964,
0.5933300852775574,
0.14164727926254272,
0.1876193881034851,
0.28688228130340576,
-0.20748619735240936,
0.9885823726654053,
-0.00043435237603262067,
-0.8034602403640747,
-0.11022064834833145,
-0.41569504141807556,
0.36699074506759644,
0.27842071652412415,
-0.0627475306391716,
0.07559924572706223,
-0.517413318157196,
-0.4293872117996216,
-0.8885989785194397,
0.5216894745826721,
0.30761563777923584,
0.20834030210971832,
0.11527039110660553,
0.24712713062763214,
0.1448225975036621,
-0.11223842948675156,
-1.3093290328979492,
-0.26838767528533936,
0.15743976831436157,
0.2211161106824875,
-0.15838377177715302,
-0.03592100739479065,
-0.3952714800834656,
-0.014638898894190788,
0.73819899559021,
0.22005106508731842,
0.1703459620475769,
-0.1717079132795334,
0.19897477328777313,
-0.23352274298667908,
0.2538481652736664,
0.5387555956840515,
0.5742904543876648,
0.0065504708327353,
0.276018351316452,
0.39920774102211,
-0.12641564011573792,
0.27805015444755554,
-0.10309573262929916,
-0.027292776852846146,
-0.5554067492485046,
0.6213063597679138,
0.4425806701183319,
-0.2017117291688919,
-0.5485885739326477,
0.22950729727745056,
-0.11401791870594025,
-0.24136826395988464,
-0.498900443315506,
0.11688253283500671,
0.18294572830200195,
0.8913558125495911,
0.2735203802585602,
-0.12070484459400177,
-0.10391703248023987,
-1.057669997215271,
0.1948859989643097,
0.8149718642234802,
0.012879598885774612,
-0.19179922342300415,
-0.13015906512737274,
0.3638190031051636,
-0.7094184160232544,
0.5464220643043518,
-0.5267930626869202,
-0.527276337146759,
0.5778409838676453,
0.471699059009552,
0.9839277863502502,
-0.40745019912719727,
0.1634063422679901,
-0.16982145607471466,
0.5186868906021118,
0.13272269070148468,
-0.160333052277565,
-0.03195912018418312,
-0.8252939581871033,
-0.5171193480491638,
-0.2314150631427765,
-0.566448450088501,
0.10306678712368011,
-0.16864781081676483,
0.003411140525713563,
-0.3513987362384796,
-0.12998375296592712,
-0.5204606652259827,
0.2456386238336563,
-0.4426936209201813,
-0.28516271710395813,
0.03490516543388367,
0.3862994313240051,
-0.6597572565078735,
0.5901755690574646,
0.5858491659164429,
-0.15205447375774384,
-0.5934534668922424,
-0.14587394893169403,
-0.13774125277996063,
-0.5293112993240356,
0.08545568585395813,
-0.16027425229549408,
-0.5342908501625061,
-0.30137139558792114,
-0.6289785504341125,
-0.485255628824234,
1.530910849571228,
0.277921587228775,
-0.15687023103237152,
0.08181930333375931,
0.23893621563911438,
0.6313562393188477,
-0.7962468862533569,
0.011264251545071602,
0.7443510293960571,
0.6791783571243286,
0.34899625182151794,
-1.1336528062820435,
-0.10717268288135529,
-0.21503178775310516,
-0.583773136138916,
-0.22305381298065186,
-0.8968228101730347,
0.9863889217376709,
-0.10933536291122437,
0.03286278247833252,
0.42136919498443604,
0.9720994830131531,
0.5593533515930176,
0.6565647125244141,
0.6397458910942078,
0.3069780468940735,
0.4120643734931946,
0.05086864158511162,
0.888477087020874,
-0.17833752930164337,
0.10671888291835785,
1.1875388622283936,
-0.5620140433311462,
0.9035035967826843,
0.40927860140800476,
0.008566114120185375,
0.6856080889701843,
0.33991527557373047,
-0.11885963380336761,
0.34569740295410156,
0.18353679776191711,
-0.8554847836494446,
-0.22012802958488464,
-0.2758863568305969,
-0.21977198123931885,
0.7049822211265564,
0.2990627586841583,
0.007440687622874975,
0.0981036052107811,
-0.03089337795972824,
-0.23009635508060455,
0.23128746449947357,
-0.4651871621608734,
0.867591142654419,
0.13163933157920837,
-0.6272105574607849,
0.03675871714949608,
-0.21332433819770813,
0.7075449824333191,
-0.29954230785369873,
-0.011371856555342674,
-0.12266672402620316,
0.1755378693342209,
-0.2440611869096756,
-0.7133927941322327,
0.21644940972328186,
-0.15033742785453796,
0.07982860505580902,
0.2246507853269577,
0.5578709244728088,
-0.2453736513853073,
-0.22073277831077576,
0.5360584855079651,
0.8725695610046387,
0.1517876833677292,
0.23144130408763885,
-0.5379558801651001,
0.40636467933654785,
-0.39680036902427673,
-0.07040639966726303,
0.4198921024799347,
0.4422459006309509,
0.2489790916442871,
0.6920139193534851,
0.4393773376941681,
0.14502562582492828,
-0.1470784693956375,
-0.3400528132915497,
0.8790077567100525,
-0.36696502566337585,
-0.2350654900074005,
-0.9238365888595581,
0.4019828736782074,
0.21768450736999512,
0.4798315465450287,
0.7417051196098328,
0.40092673897743225,
0.5733256340026855,
-0.11009393632411957,
0.6884636282920837,
-0.1984730213880539,
-0.10619296878576279,
-0.31600338220596313,
0.6205341815948486,
-0.3204178512096405,
0.4388987421989441,
-0.06910218298435211,
-1.0415383577346802,
-0.30453255772590637,
0.4700564742088318,
-0.2546219825744629,
0.2795558273792267,
0.3620070815086365,
0.5287793278694153,
-0.035352084785699844,
-0.3238960802555084,
0.5639941096305847,
0.22883564233779907,
0.47672033309936523,
0.6129264831542969,
0.9834067821502686,
-0.03595258295536041,
0.2723220884799957,
-0.25529906153678894,
-0.5427384376525879,
0.1006118506193161,
-0.7925289273262024,
-1.012813687324524,
-0.64007967710495,
-0.05842604115605354,
-0.2674393653869629,
-0.0759786069393158,
1.036826491355896,
0.4095938205718994,
-0.47252005338668823,
-0.7427015900611877,
0.14257913827896118,
0.3796349763870239,
-0.18941351771354675,
-0.25359591841697693,
0.25541573762893677,
0.04263830929994583,
-0.9081461429595947,
0.5680172443389893,
0.4505417048931122,
0.19805756211280823,
-0.8682337403297424,
-0.6217994689941406,
-0.29335227608680725,
0.3513871133327484,
0.7783910036087036,
0.5143349170684814,
-0.7275551557540894,
-0.19790364801883698,
-0.006852419581264257,
0.022531311959028244,
-0.05073568597435951,
0.728908896446228,
-0.6949259638786316,
0.390489786863327,
0.06002451479434967,
0.5218196511268616,
-0.009683704003691673,
0.0003048377693630755,
0.5922219753265381,
-0.2951870262622833,
0.2592306435108185,
0.35724979639053345,
0.20179510116577148,
0.35421380400657654,
-0.3258366882801056,
0.3222757875919342,
-0.09928504377603531,
-1.0333834886550903,
-0.6591043472290039,
0.34260883927345276,
-1.0536847114562988,
-0.07635165005922318,
1.1124334335327148,
-0.28250837326049805,
-0.3113675117492676,
-0.31932759284973145,
-0.14957375824451447,
0.30107375979423523,
-0.291839599609375,
1.12484872341156,
0.8388870358467102,
-0.5308660268783569,
-0.39933961629867554,
-0.22804473340511322,
0.3315233886241913,
0.08057962357997894,
-1.2287476062774658,
0.06793821603059769,
0.62539142370224,
-0.25685617327690125,
0.61363685131073,
0.7582423686981201,
0.21863721311092377,
0.311408132314682,
0.23538155853748322,
-0.17247718572616577,
-0.0753311961889267,
-0.47672683000564575,
-0.11759664118289948,
0.00460477638989687,
0.4961562156677246,
0.09066899865865707
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15445v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15445v1
|
Decoding Multilingual Topic Dynamics and Trend Identification through ARIMA Time Series Analysis on Social Networks: A Novel Data Translation Framework Enhanced by LDA/HDP Models
| 2024-03-18T00:01:10 | 2024-03-18T00:01:10 |
Samawel Jaballi, Azer Mahjoubi, Manar Joundy Hazar, Salah Zrigui, Henri Nicolas, Mounir Zrigui
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.SI
|
In this study, the authors present a novel methodology adept at decoding
multilingual topic dynamics and identifying communication trends during crises.
We focus on dialogues within Tunisian social networks during the Coronavirus
Pandemic and other notable themes like sports and politics. We start by
aggregating a varied multilingual corpus of comments relevant to these
subjects. This dataset undergoes rigorous refinement during data preprocessing.
We then introduce our No-English-to-English Machine Translation approach to
handle linguistic differences. Empirical tests of this method showed high
accuracy and F1 scores, highlighting its suitability for linguistically
coherent tasks. Delving deeper, advanced modeling techniques, specifically LDA
and HDP models are employed to extract pertinent topics from the translated
content. This leads to applying ARIMA time series analysis to decode evolving
topic trends. Applying our method to a multilingual Tunisian dataset, we
effectively identified key topics mirroring public sentiment. Such insights
prove vital for organizations and governments striving to understand public
perspectives during crises. Compared to standard approaches, our model
outperforms, as confirmed by metrics like Coherence Score, U-mass, and Topic
Coherence. Additionally, an in-depth assessment of the identified topics
revealed notable thematic shifts in discussions, with our trends identification
indicating impressive accuracy, backed by RMSE-based analysis.
|
[
-0.514756977558136,
-0.9277876615524292,
0.23051373660564423,
0.47043848037719727,
-0.46151959896087646,
0.31537294387817383,
-0.15044093132019043,
-0.25085780024528503,
0.4984382688999176,
0.34925296902656555,
-0.6346873641014099,
-0.6410744190216064,
-0.8553849458694458,
-0.041205212473869324,
-0.7201581001281738,
1.288238286972046,
0.06130427122116089,
-0.028950059786438942,
0.25576895475387573,
-0.11963516473770142,
0.04529346898198128,
-0.504811704158783,
-0.706468403339386,
-0.12448632717132568,
0.5227238535881042,
0.3279915750026703,
0.7064645886421204,
0.37396350502967834,
0.38313615322113037,
0.28312230110168457,
-0.2176828235387802,
0.3056163489818573,
-0.5671212077140808,
0.19724996387958527,
-0.24817155301570892,
0.19597892463207245,
-0.28208044171333313,
-0.18588131666183472,
0.501563549041748,
0.4225981831550598,
-0.3005780875682831,
0.32331064343452454,
0.22622302174568176,
0.7352016568183899,
-0.32979413866996765,
0.40023767948150635,
-0.5706455111503601,
-0.09444133937358856,
-0.27705737948417664,
-0.4004519581794739,
-0.08564777672290802,
-0.21481376886367798,
0.12304285168647766,
0.043170616030693054,
0.21805034577846527,
-0.4006898105144501,
0.7906479835510254,
-0.13751062750816345,
-0.6448089480400085,
-0.1666257679462433,
-0.970184326171875,
0.6743737459182739,
-0.549260139465332,
-0.022519536316394806,
0.12695494294166565,
0.3504623472690582,
-0.23235350847244263,
-0.5791722536087036,
-0.4465165138244629,
0.43599969148635864,
0.5241779088973999,
-0.07778030633926392,
-0.13412070274353027,
-0.4074932932853699,
-0.19400358200073242,
0.2997532784938812,
-0.49593600630760193,
-0.2792741358280182,
-0.2065586894750595,
0.08364500105381012,
0.8136866688728333,
0.1788686066865921,
0.44104641675949097,
-0.4661860466003418,
-0.18274922668933868,
-0.04799960181117058,
-0.5736284255981445,
0.053296755999326706,
0.41943982243537903,
0.4965610206127167,
-0.39797714352607727,
0.3363387882709503,
-0.17594724893569946,
0.19700556993484497,
-0.4213474690914154,
-0.09886423498392105,
0.13097399473190308,
-0.46844619512557983,
0.027185780927538872,
0.060087818652391434,
0.8242577314376831,
0.3326965868473053,
0.15785831212997437,
0.1864384114742279,
0.049488332122564316,
-0.3724106550216675,
0.054386500269174576,
-1.036936640739441,
-0.21324042975902557,
0.2701917886734009,
-0.6894208192825317,
-0.2966462969779968,
0.05785438418388367,
-1.1870472431182861,
-0.6825338006019592,
-0.12995600700378418,
-0.13187116384506226,
-0.10143014043569565,
-0.40568166971206665,
0.22501009702682495,
0.21641294658184052,
0.18565204739570618,
0.6008510589599609,
-0.5068638324737549,
0.046775445342063904,
0.6544336080551147,
1.2025501728057861,
0.074894979596138,
0.08902113139629364,
-0.1786898672580719,
-0.054982900619506836,
-0.2565937936306,
0.6516374349594116,
-0.3984494209289551,
-0.313453733921051,
0.24851325154304504,
0.07568725198507309,
-0.039619334042072296,
0.022457055747509003,
0.35473644733428955,
-0.7845739126205444,
-0.07051209360361099,
-0.3858032822608948,
-0.13187545537948608,
-0.20326444506645203,
0.21373987197875977,
-0.6805805563926697,
0.6333560347557068,
-0.5629217028617859,
-0.8876799941062927,
-0.0871041938662529,
-0.7066515684127808,
-0.3597366511821747,
-0.3643690049648285,
-0.18418429791927338,
-0.47924235463142395,
-0.17176230251789093,
0.6123417615890503,
0.7497429847717285,
-0.6406411528587341,
0.5745590329170227,
-0.3607735335826874,
0.14743931591510773,
0.45199188590049744,
-0.579966127872467,
0.8675165176391602,
0.5169288516044617,
-0.12179438024759293,
0.08190534263849258,
-0.6453090906143188,
-0.3971751034259796,
0.07180406898260117,
0.13770999014377594,
-0.11691988259553909,
0.592083752155304,
0.41440269351005554,
0.42227041721343994,
0.23658232390880585,
-0.4207061529159546,
0.23376676440238953,
-0.34200164675712585,
0.7745763659477234,
0.625877320766449,
0.6834126114845276,
0.09640160948038101,
-0.3433019518852234,
0.46770989894866943,
0.3940352499485016,
0.0924161970615387,
-0.39058876037597656,
-0.9445310831069946,
-0.3858798146247864,
-0.18185433745384216,
-0.12558063864707947,
0.9146355390548706,
-0.746860146522522,
0.12721261382102966,
-0.2322481870651245,
-0.550234317779541,
-0.24374298751354218,
0.13577350974082947,
-0.09735739231109619,
0.16342423856258392,
0.4066256582736969,
-0.035572271794080734,
-0.4067946672439575,
-0.6260302662849426,
-0.19057419896125793,
-0.2732762396335602,
0.35430964827537537,
0.16322895884513855,
0.45510727167129517,
-0.2468966692686081,
0.5780981779098511,
-0.2884911000728607,
-0.02558188885450363,
-0.453966349363327,
0.641998291015625,
0.5349721312522888,
0.27348592877388,
0.4955192506313324,
-0.8955767154693604,
-0.4472656846046448,
0.40809905529022217,
-0.4087744653224945,
0.1739504635334015,
-0.44878557324409485,
-0.02734227105975151,
-0.03614138066768646,
0.32210618257522583,
-0.15891242027282715,
0.6080459356307983,
0.44007644057273865,
-0.39279887080192566,
0.15770120918750763,
0.06074228882789612,
0.4653758406639099,
-1.7568761110305786,
0.02340291254222393,
0.4582448899745941,
-0.1662577986717224,
-0.7499387860298157,
-0.23944850265979767,
-0.2481311708688736,
-0.6623330116271973,
-0.4284306764602661,
0.43140196800231934,
-0.2821516990661621,
0.16983763873577118,
-0.3327944576740265,
-0.031956158578395844,
-0.17587582767009735,
0.2261463701725006,
-0.15109963715076447,
0.7107207775115967,
0.539126455783844,
-0.35339611768722534,
0.6340543031692505,
0.3941028118133545,
-0.6516075134277344,
0.11042977124452591,
-0.6138326525688171,
0.09764357656240463,
-0.26585930585861206,
0.06924327462911606,
-0.9947131872177124,
0.020910870283842087,
0.2903536558151245,
-0.270854651927948,
0.07439521700143814,
-0.2577097415924072,
-0.41815951466560364,
-0.1696639209985733,
-0.10308830440044403,
0.2638956904411316,
0.2893190383911133,
-0.2246168553829193,
0.3702419698238373,
0.4713115096092224,
-0.676999032497406,
-0.7191558480262756,
-0.3366239666938782,
0.3924618065357208,
-0.3643239736557007,
-0.7326604127883911,
0.24471481144428253,
0.17185652256011963,
-0.4470284879207611,
-0.24772761762142181,
-0.13907991349697113,
-0.46920540928840637,
0.29544568061828613,
0.2041073441505432,
0.08804716914892197,
-0.3487931489944458,
-0.08441198617219925,
0.20311936736106873,
0.047177668660879135,
0.10843417048454285,
-0.16308774054050446,
0.5866618752479553,
-0.35310813784599304,
-0.12066130340099335,
-0.8651732206344604,
0.6249697208404541,
0.8168188333511353,
-0.3575812876224518,
1.1119006872177124,
0.7403848767280579,
-0.34466877579689026,
0.0865737572312355,
-0.37658435106277466,
-0.0921526551246643,
-0.42103296518325806,
0.3557744026184082,
-0.23045194149017334,
-0.3355415463447571,
0.9880167245864868,
-0.21378709375858307,
-0.09099552035331726,
0.34516263008117676,
0.743320107460022,
0.06001698225736618,
1.0080418586730957,
0.6332627534866333,
-0.5101611614227295,
0.620907723903656,
-0.5281810164451599,
0.40256187319755554,
-0.2939859628677368,
-0.27037373185157776,
-0.7817203402519226,
-0.3132055997848511,
-0.5749088525772095,
-0.36224859952926636,
0.3516014516353607,
0.0602465458214283,
0.07298415899276733,
0.08158976584672928,
0.03236430138349533,
0.33727800846099854,
-0.006343357264995575,
0.027454866096377373,
0.10211159288883209,
0.2929469048976898,
0.373986154794693,
-0.216543048620224,
-0.4128151535987854,
-0.6908711791038513,
0.8074883222579956,
0.34658995270729065,
0.7035021185874939,
0.3480853736400604,
0.5524294972419739,
0.7352466583251953,
0.285831481218338,
-0.6120368242263794,
0.38361409306526184,
-0.13693755865097046,
-0.2466796189546585,
-0.27339622378349304,
-0.310705304145813,
-0.912192165851593,
0.2544432282447815,
-0.30819806456565857,
-0.9232428073883057,
0.6206380724906921,
-0.31568029522895813,
-0.2705402076244354,
0.42586278915405273,
-0.007107133511453867,
1.0084673166275024,
-0.005893385503441095,
-0.2421390265226364,
-0.6342276930809021,
-0.5315232276916504,
0.11989935487508774,
-0.007747089024633169,
0.35469934344291687,
-0.61912602186203,
0.022736867889761925,
0.658504843711853,
-0.3078816831111908,
0.9075161218643188,
-0.00584171200171113,
-0.2913396656513214,
0.14101827144622803,
-0.19322171807289124,
0.45431283116340637,
0.5674786567687988,
-0.33950451016426086,
0.30653589963912964,
0.30300644040107727,
-0.7718873620033264,
-0.5512297749519348,
0.8724852204322815,
-1.2709276676177979,
-0.636653482913971,
-0.46612194180488586,
-0.6285352110862732,
-0.10084567964076996,
0.045328538864851,
-0.05866362899541855,
0.7059926986694336,
-0.7411631345748901,
0.1317429542541504,
0.5533793568611145,
-0.20893864333629608,
0.5745002031326294,
0.5365568399429321,
-0.1593780815601349,
-0.4375799596309662,
0.9962642192840576,
0.08185886591672897,
-0.2731311023235321,
0.49316123127937317,
-0.011084428988397121,
-0.01422041840851307,
-0.5674481391906738,
-0.5972203612327576,
0.33040571212768555,
-0.6112411618232727,
-0.07522863149642944,
-0.648653507232666,
-0.2540041506290436,
-0.4637654721736908,
0.04686595872044563,
-0.5025864839553833,
-0.36173325777053833,
-0.552679717540741,
0.08677955716848373,
0.3928720951080322,
0.6905795931816101,
0.14166268706321716,
0.14299273490905762,
-0.8684630393981934,
0.23555652797222137,
-0.1698303073644638,
-0.28694796562194824,
-0.15282513201236725,
-0.3388882577419281,
-0.40331149101257324,
0.1713767945766449,
-0.44887417554855347,
-1.4772676229476929,
0.940611720085144,
0.5448049306869507,
0.1757812649011612,
0.8407062888145447,
0.3006967306137085,
0.7663089632987976,
-0.46723997592926025,
0.752151370048523,
-0.04820781946182251,
-0.9698984026908875,
0.8100104331970215,
-0.5371013283729553,
0.0793447196483612,
0.22763483226299286,
0.6416858434677124,
-0.8290429711341858,
-0.4042445123195648,
-0.4095354974269867,
-1.0415809154510498,
0.5587472319602966,
0.2252914309501648,
0.5048341155052185,
-0.2169305980205536,
0.45128414034843445,
-0.08143478631973267,
0.39559316635131836,
-0.25568830966949463,
-0.5342539548873901,
-0.4530438482761383,
-0.0717620998620987,
-0.29631751775741577,
-0.4079200327396393,
-0.33624255657196045,
-0.22430312633514404,
0.6515016555786133,
-0.009984215721487999,
0.22724193334579468,
-0.019165366888046265,
0.060564588755369186,
-0.05081407353281975,
0.4360816180706024,
0.7151675224304199,
0.8491866588592529,
-0.1343992054462433,
-0.10868943482637405,
-0.3813827335834503,
-0.38870617747306824,
0.2302311658859253,
0.3859397768974304,
-0.01847977750003338,
0.187574103474617,
0.2752678692340851,
0.7224547863006592,
-0.042100969702005386,
-0.41323429346084595,
0.5829842686653137,
-0.11085614562034607,
0.2576581835746765,
-0.4478205740451813,
-0.2896847128868103,
-0.09818150103092194,
0.4932723343372345,
0.5858935117721558,
0.18085941672325134,
0.1625332087278366,
-0.7710636854171753,
0.2712707221508026,
0.18325401842594147,
-0.23741541802883148,
-0.6988446116447449,
0.5120185017585754,
0.5440395474433899,
-0.0698956772685051,
0.5251260995864868,
-0.060603268444538116,
-0.2836083769798279,
0.8860271573066711,
0.35358741879463196,
1.0016019344329834,
-0.5044237971305847,
0.865818440914154,
0.330238938331604,
0.3103069067001343,
-0.03368447348475456,
0.6217036843299866,
-0.05244250223040581,
-0.9994357824325562,
-0.6428772211074829,
-0.34879669547080994,
-0.1362513154745102,
0.3183543086051941,
-1.1659367084503174,
0.077342689037323,
-0.4061567485332489,
-0.2949199080467224,
0.06933250278234482,
0.20729418098926544,
-0.4451444149017334,
-0.24981895089149475,
0.06827794760465622,
0.7924559116363525,
-1.2298550605773926,
1.1671828031539917,
0.7955234050750732,
-0.23517505824565887,
-0.19785355031490326,
0.21212536096572876,
0.21416348218917847,
-0.5249341130256653,
0.5353803038597107,
0.10045752674341202,
-0.012967911548912525,
-0.01411309465765953,
-0.21794432401657104,
-0.8986700773239136,
0.825499415397644,
0.2583262622356415,
-0.3699931800365448,
0.18069222569465637,
0.10796016454696655,
0.5644461512565613,
-0.5317577123641968,
-0.03983241692185402,
0.27323052287101746,
0.28606611490249634,
0.004872702527791262,
-0.5832399129867554,
-0.20061767101287842,
-0.7005857229232788,
0.08909159153699875,
0.2908969819545746,
-0.5803078413009644,
0.6457029581069946,
-0.17750434577465057,
-0.3450546860694885,
0.18316663801670074,
0.9770762920379639,
-0.42085370421409607,
0.6563464403152466,
-0.003903790609911084,
0.10430851578712463,
0.7141197919845581,
0.0021833223290741444,
1.0115909576416016,
-0.8488591909408569,
0.453931599855423,
0.7461302876472473,
-0.2988118827342987,
0.8245112895965576,
0.48384708166122437,
0.0019332097144797444,
0.7452582120895386,
0.6541415452957153,
0.27352482080459595,
0.6192681789398193,
-0.10752923786640167,
-0.2829777002334595,
-0.2689761817455292,
-0.22545118629932404,
-0.4704662561416626,
0.22829703986644745,
0.8209909200668335,
-0.30644577741622925,
-0.3669512867927551,
0.35751911997795105,
0.14419125020503998,
0.06404668092727661,
-0.37078768014907837,
0.6086736917495728,
0.10006099939346313,
-0.20801012217998505,
0.44055473804473877,
0.3900456428527832,
0.028546450659632683,
-0.38541802763938904,
0.04619571566581726,
-0.42628568410873413,
0.1355661004781723,
0.04634346812963486,
-0.5558307766914368,
0.5979520082473755,
0.07108898460865021,
-0.3326585292816162,
-0.3011396825313568,
0.34279370307922363,
-0.5405097603797913,
-0.5389512777328491,
0.058102529495954514,
0.7403099536895752,
0.14948385953903198,
0.016407784074544907,
-1.1122233867645264,
0.18835784494876862,
-0.007971277460455894,
-0.2684325873851776,
0.15306006371974945,
0.5386406779289246,
-0.15873606503009796,
0.792525053024292,
0.4189026653766632,
0.1701889932155609,
-0.17969778180122375,
0.16731558740139008,
0.6766883134841919,
-0.6341583728790283,
-0.6263797879219055,
-0.8748493790626526,
0.2442682683467865,
-0.14535248279571533,
-0.24045991897583008,
1.0032403469085693,
0.33075568079948425,
0.47301411628723145,
0.05464424937963486,
0.6015605330467224,
0.12750570476055145,
0.2621041238307953,
-0.47823330760002136,
0.7800191640853882,
-0.346293568611145,
0.5844125747680664,
-0.21758191287517548,
-0.6489233374595642,
-0.08888259530067444,
0.5239416360855103,
-0.5060247182846069,
-0.3452836275100708,
0.41684961318969727,
0.7438874840736389,
-0.043543409556150436,
0.2920690178871155,
0.0306678656488657,
0.4298197329044342,
0.41613152623176575,
0.2152199149131775,
0.7194339036941528,
-0.2680050730705261,
0.4424353241920471,
-0.27176108956336975,
-0.04325588420033455,
-0.3576858937740326,
-0.779961884021759,
-1.0550596714019775,
-0.891318142414093,
-0.6220253705978394,
-0.5502697229385376,
0.24429352581501007,
0.9761401414871216,
0.5570051670074463,
-1.176576852798462,
-0.5357154607772827,
0.11746848374605179,
0.34828054904937744,
-0.48287129402160645,
-0.2197434902191162,
0.46252745389938354,
-0.03981142118573189,
-0.6483348608016968,
0.3988514840602875,
0.3073563277721405,
-0.037111006677150726,
-0.5097629427909851,
0.18386362493038177,
-0.3297484815120697,
0.3991338312625885,
0.5185854434967041,
0.4586034417152405,
-0.6172385811805725,
0.07573577016592026,
-0.32857492566108704,
0.019880080595612526,
-0.0411931648850441,
1.1689422130584717,
-0.4037102162837982,
0.4027371406555176,
0.702980101108551,
0.7933370471000671,
0.5092089176177979,
0.07547729462385178,
0.6464364528656006,
-0.6670826077461243,
0.46632468700408936,
0.06814246624708176,
0.43451938033103943,
0.3094845712184906,
-0.2999175488948822,
0.10064511746168137,
0.3372989296913147,
-0.3900046646595001,
-0.8178321123123169,
0.4708954691886902,
-0.7137511968612671,
-0.33273497223854065,
1.0785447359085083,
-0.25712811946868896,
-0.29292938113212585,
-0.4488545358181,
-0.017043298110365868,
0.20781150460243225,
-0.7023518085479736,
1.2216682434082031,
0.7126702070236206,
0.10866091400384903,
-0.3434669077396393,
-0.5473338961601257,
0.3548390865325928,
0.18682844936847687,
-0.6836290955543518,
-0.14535214006900787,
0.24803024530410767,
0.0243130661547184,
0.03669671341776848,
0.464612752199173,
-0.034337058663368225,
0.17405569553375244,
-0.5421156883239746,
-0.22993086278438568,
0.1816098839044571,
-0.6296351552009583,
-0.33189427852630615,
0.31244441866874695,
-0.23288536071777344,
0.01639716513454914
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11369v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11369v2
|
What Makes Math Word Problems Challenging for LLMs?
| 2024-03-17T23:18:40 | 2024-04-01T13:58:34 |
KV Aditya Srivatsa, Ekaterina Kochmar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper investigates the question of what makes math word problems (MWPs)
in English challenging for large language models (LLMs). We conduct an in-depth
analysis of the key linguistic and mathematical characteristics of MWPs. In
addition, we train feature-based classifiers to better understand the impact of
each feature on the overall difficulty of MWPs for prominent LLMs and
investigate whether this helps predict how well LLMs fare against specific
categories of MWPs.
|
[
-0.32577449083328247,
-0.6246344447135925,
0.5656565427780151,
0.3791741728782654,
-0.11532201617956161,
0.3885751962661743,
-0.0682310163974762,
-0.576133131980896,
-0.16361001133918762,
0.5232866406440735,
-0.7235985398292542,
-0.23898017406463623,
-1.11869478225708,
0.44400709867477417,
-0.1338042914867401,
0.7478289604187012,
-0.47400516271591187,
0.28147658705711365,
-0.7601781487464905,
-0.27902552485466003,
-0.9412602782249451,
-0.9721099138259888,
-0.4096672534942627,
-0.5296638011932373,
0.4612888991832733,
0.28024470806121826,
0.957097053527832,
0.2587124705314636,
1.166785478591919,
0.4272671043872833,
-0.34347549080848694,
0.17426520586013794,
-0.3827802240848541,
0.15985547006130219,
-0.04558330774307251,
-0.8158068656921387,
0.00381674082018435,
-0.0023471214808523655,
0.22216758131980896,
1.3597372770309448,
-0.020689569413661957,
0.1068718284368515,
0.10202091932296753,
0.7966639995574951,
-0.3733573853969574,
0.39986786246299744,
-0.8782063722610474,
0.3561808168888092,
-0.4946589171886444,
-0.16149094700813293,
-0.06188037618994713,
-0.21131016314029694,
0.45966005325317383,
-0.36160123348236084,
0.2333090454339981,
0.14381088316440582,
0.800626277923584,
0.18965190649032593,
-0.6086199283599854,
-0.8217053413391113,
-0.673882782459259,
0.8696112632751465,
-0.4043329954147339,
0.20307140052318573,
0.42029765248298645,
0.10927458107471466,
-0.380921870470047,
-0.2990555763244629,
-0.28966426849365234,
-0.20226077735424042,
0.06511357426643372,
-0.16551686823368073,
-0.26325613260269165,
-0.12485907971858978,
0.483070433139801,
0.49231210350990295,
-0.297933429479599,
0.4115124046802521,
-0.35987070202827454,
-0.09217560291290283,
0.7667966485023499,
0.752751886844635,
0.24823786318302155,
-0.16591095924377441,
0.08049246668815613,
0.14850009977817535,
-0.8765063881874084,
0.16663070023059845,
0.4429479241371155,
0.0030604919884353876,
0.08488539606332779,
1.0900357961654663,
0.34506070613861084,
0.6278155446052551,
-0.7072089910507202,
-0.5177323222160339,
0.05391700565814972,
0.36596179008483887,
0.19383768737316132,
-0.3260623514652252,
0.3472937345504761,
0.20585592091083527,
0.7099653482437134,
0.09137771278619766,
-0.5627237558364868,
0.3044346272945404,
-0.06270957738161087,
-0.44105324149131775,
0.14416593313217163,
0.008996300399303436,
-0.1642441749572754,
-0.4604637622833252,
-0.2537652254104614,
-0.07186844199895859,
-0.4006393551826477,
-0.3130575716495514,
0.7234249114990234,
-0.5268246531486511,
0.06831005215644836,
0.24375666677951813,
-0.33239394426345825,
0.021237602457404137,
0.29643499851226807,
-0.9137053489685059,
0.30682337284088135,
1.096177577972412,
0.7617523074150085,
-0.21885943412780762,
-0.3025462329387665,
-0.22502300143241882,
-0.022491632029414177,
-0.4012802839279175,
0.7233672142028809,
-0.6911348104476929,
-0.635420560836792,
0.05330809950828552,
-0.0933905839920044,
-0.01013983879238367,
-0.9960469007492065,
0.20204198360443115,
-0.26006484031677246,
0.2628623843193054,
-0.43727827072143555,
-0.9097061157226562,
-0.07079087197780609,
0.46238067746162415,
-0.37453752756118774,
0.7101780772209167,
0.4187043011188507,
-0.7458406686782837,
0.12082909047603607,
-0.5812446475028992,
-0.5068838596343994,
0.15545259416103363,
-0.2639572322368622,
-0.10691563040018082,
0.845916211605072,
0.07042655348777771,
0.4060874581336975,
-0.31867387890815735,
0.037332404404878616,
-0.30262136459350586,
-0.020667701959609985,
0.6397081613540649,
-0.34373828768730164,
0.2850162088871002,
0.21321047842502594,
-0.05286965146660805,
-0.009174561128020287,
-0.7876895070075989,
-0.05986357107758522,
0.576083242893219,
-0.333280086517334,
-0.3591461479663849,
0.5266152620315552,
-0.20031189918518066,
0.07718712091445923,
0.20766820013523102,
-0.4022779166698456,
0.3880060911178589,
-0.30057552456855774,
0.4804685711860657,
0.8704968690872192,
-0.1572791188955307,
-0.003179697087034583,
-0.5895975828170776,
0.8115513920783997,
-0.05556979775428772,
-0.09414953738451004,
0.009325949475169182,
-0.8532194495201111,
-0.596924364566803,
0.005126266274601221,
0.4797055125236511,
1.0083391666412354,
-0.7919166088104248,
0.17720511555671692,
-0.18276704847812653,
-0.449264258146286,
-0.32228755950927734,
0.3893386721611023,
0.3487809896469116,
0.40176355838775635,
-0.03339332342147827,
-0.05149450898170471,
-0.08286713808774948,
-0.8185115456581116,
-0.2353401929140091,
0.26206159591674805,
-0.24048657715320587,
0.4597894549369812,
0.7094568014144897,
-0.07845209538936615,
0.705694854259491,
-1.0189963579177856,
-0.622481644153595,
-0.3639766573905945,
0.23517419397830963,
0.05774042382836342,
0.1176472157239914,
0.40173643827438354,
-0.6914870738983154,
-0.2704932391643524,
-0.27077969908714294,
-0.5567191243171692,
-0.5778932571411133,
0.32776939868927,
0.4842850863933563,
0.20123513042926788,
0.4653395414352417,
-0.456976979970932,
0.5291786193847656,
0.6065311431884766,
-0.3628344237804413,
0.46425098180770874,
-0.3334009051322937,
-0.22880788147449493,
-0.9005452990531921,
-0.49156373739242554,
0.17944619059562683,
0.13457345962524414,
-0.33773073554039,
0.28272825479507446,
-0.2229139655828476,
-0.6426583528518677,
-0.5022292137145996,
0.10559777915477753,
-0.47924986481666565,
-0.12875494360923767,
-0.14711567759513855,
0.1571270376443863,
-0.06534839421510696,
0.13853967189788818,
-0.08257655054330826,
0.6671730875968933,
0.3529418110847473,
-0.6744322776794434,
0.6402206420898438,
0.035576265305280685,
-0.2614222764968872,
0.43403106927871704,
-0.6938028931617737,
-0.10534054040908813,
-0.14049938321113586,
-0.26006826758384705,
-1.0186752080917358,
0.16889193654060364,
-0.5781106948852539,
-0.2610139548778534,
0.31887364387512207,
0.17394308745861053,
-0.6422913074493408,
-0.6238368153572083,
-0.21105974912643433,
0.39445897936820984,
0.5626433491706848,
-0.27090758085250854,
0.25773635506629944,
0.5324414968490601,
-0.22908499836921692,
-0.2231273651123047,
-0.5701783895492554,
0.07327389717102051,
-0.25835883617401123,
-0.7734292149543762,
0.39854249358177185,
-0.11002189666032791,
-0.5845285058021545,
0.033732958137989044,
0.018160749226808548,
0.1264604926109314,
0.3493526875972748,
0.18317122757434845,
0.18853037059307098,
-0.00865608174353838,
0.2907752990722656,
-0.4127499759197235,
-0.2016814798116684,
0.4483277499675751,
0.19272442162036896,
0.7214578986167908,
-0.11584760248661041,
-0.594088077545166,
0.014335989020764828,
0.5113542675971985,
0.5521743297576904,
-0.11650637537240982,
0.4411231577396393,
0.09041333943605423,
-0.5743535161018372,
-0.27623412013053894,
-0.6298707723617554,
0.15724843740463257,
-0.553791344165802,
0.6591094136238098,
-0.7054361701011658,
-1.2098968029022217,
0.6976945400238037,
-0.08174509555101395,
0.06353208422660828,
0.5562077164649963,
0.4591391682624817,
-0.22155335545539856,
1.3994539976119995,
0.6703040599822998,
-0.13463349640369415,
-0.02611343376338482,
-0.18740449845790863,
-0.03943391144275665,
-0.6682360768318176,
-0.5363948941230774,
-0.6980599761009216,
-0.6758047938346863,
-0.6140347719192505,
-0.3504577875137329,
0.35276296734809875,
-0.0005198370781727135,
0.16286316514015198,
0.08552251756191254,
-0.43360352516174316,
0.4392036497592926,
0.07543911784887314,
-0.2846585810184479,
0.15825395286083221,
0.0572715625166893,
-0.3107631206512451,
-0.9230928421020508,
-0.5725518465042114,
-0.26165854930877686,
0.8424131870269775,
0.5259068012237549,
1.14775812625885,
0.5110399127006531,
0.47196152806282043,
-0.12372025102376938,
0.23516863584518433,
-1.330369472503662,
0.6618452668190002,
-0.2768648862838745,
-0.7277774810791016,
-0.1965041160583496,
-0.814382791519165,
-1.2453820705413818,
0.04978255182504654,
-0.5287665724754333,
-0.6415054798126221,
-0.33676213026046753,
-0.27384161949157715,
0.11129500716924667,
0.5259453654289246,
-0.6155976057052612,
0.3322063386440277,
-0.4405544698238373,
0.1568651646375656,
-0.10183373093605042,
-0.16000811755657196,
0.3612233102321625,
-0.1922769993543625,
0.6572692394256592,
-0.34337183833122253,
-0.2828942835330963,
0.6183944940567017,
-0.8630650639533997,
0.5421546697616577,
0.2629796266555786,
-0.4646615982055664,
0.21375322341918945,
0.4616844654083252,
0.321819007396698,
-0.2594936788082123,
0.37026941776275635,
0.1168186217546463,
-0.09440232813358307,
-0.22162170708179474,
-0.6309597492218018,
0.6209759712219238,
-0.6114624738693237,
-0.9656335115432739,
-0.6532923579216003,
-1.0737810134887695,
-0.6621798276901245,
-0.2223195880651474,
0.38114577531814575,
0.5281233787536621,
0.1999877542257309,
0.17699363827705383,
0.6949856877326965,
-0.44934988021850586,
0.6257666945457458,
0.4136905074119568,
-0.5274432301521301,
-0.25250181555747986,
1.1729179620742798,
0.9157370328903198,
0.2855924963951111,
0.331427663564682,
0.5928936004638672,
-0.22266778349876404,
-0.8038424253463745,
-0.10069990903139114,
0.19875583052635193,
-0.7242828607559204,
-0.2518271803855896,
-0.36750131845474243,
-0.6031728386878967,
-0.20262493193149567,
-0.21559493243694305,
-0.05492357537150383,
-0.5499401688575745,
-0.4557541310787201,
0.1282864362001419,
0.42815521359443665,
1.2447463274002075,
0.29470840096473694,
0.19218841195106506,
-1.0424468517303467,
0.34308919310569763,
0.6758936047554016,
0.3785674571990967,
-0.16513417661190033,
-0.8818697929382324,
0.22844357788562775,
-0.6138834357261658,
-0.5846299529075623,
-0.9228582978248596,
0.3534218966960907,
0.07349449396133423,
0.29809871315956116,
0.4157958924770355,
-0.2186385989189148,
0.7531092166900635,
-0.8633020520210266,
0.809857964515686,
0.2813430726528168,
-1.1712170839309692,
0.35233691334724426,
0.03545800969004631,
0.2560115456581116,
0.10911103338003159,
0.603553056716919,
-0.48620864748954773,
-0.36582067608833313,
-0.6279411911964417,
-0.6844296455383301,
0.2207859754562378,
0.3386070132255554,
0.6381629705429077,
-0.12377490848302841,
0.775243878364563,
-0.15575730800628662,
0.2509177029132843,
-0.6942019462585449,
-0.2736915051937103,
0.3933839797973633,
-0.2997552454471588,
-0.10953184962272644,
-0.5214940309524536,
-0.10565174371004105,
-0.4540048837661743,
0.287388414144516,
0.1729384958744049,
-0.18186570703983307,
-0.021078577265143394,
-0.09619052708148956,
-0.2749329209327698,
0.3436789810657501,
0.9100003838539124,
0.8464012742042542,
-0.0791204422712326,
-0.006375444587320089,
0.6914989948272705,
-0.5452792048454285,
0.27800315618515015,
0.0004459250485524535,
0.17512471973896027,
0.18025578558444977,
0.8367308974266052,
0.6557172536849976,
0.46394699811935425,
-0.6561790704727173,
0.6274733543395996,
0.07636712491512299,
-0.6861408948898315,
-0.23506297171115875,
0.12425635010004044,
0.2972411513328552,
-0.09111288189888,
0.7107493281364441,
-0.3294176459312439,
-0.17308396100997925,
-0.743998646736145,
-0.24318429827690125,
0.8422831892967224,
-0.34137165546417236,
-0.09479130059480667,
0.39397749304771423,
0.24743518233299255,
-0.9920552372932434,
0.2954460680484772,
-0.24344314634799957,
-1.1011511087417603,
0.7774419784545898,
0.9171589612960815,
0.39574134349823,
-0.05899984762072563,
-0.26857271790504456,
-0.21759869158267975,
0.6250036954879761,
0.038672905415296555,
0.6158126592636108,
0.5137089490890503,
-0.674401581287384,
-0.5936867594718933,
-0.4973275661468506,
-0.8263828754425049,
0.2910645008087158,
-0.3700857162475586,
0.44975221157073975,
-0.8258665800094604,
-0.181330144405365,
-0.015887228772044182,
0.17695578932762146,
-0.6354618668556213,
0.33191803097724915,
0.37161150574684143,
0.8929603099822998,
-0.4992946684360504,
0.3421826660633087,
0.6854364275932312,
0.21768984198570251,
-1.004201889038086,
-0.5877348184585571,
0.16192714869976044,
-1.0710947513580322,
0.7189841866493225,
0.24611002206802368,
-0.02139081247150898,
-0.012096446007490158,
-0.5127153992652893,
-0.6104819774627686,
0.7036548256874084,
0.4323035180568695,
-0.7550510168075562,
-0.19426298141479492,
0.6220269203186035,
0.46866142749786377,
-0.4525824189186096,
-0.06735432147979736,
0.20093394815921783,
0.34758245944976807,
0.21401408314704895,
-0.9053614735603333,
-0.19894331693649292,
-0.01725633442401886,
0.24804581701755524,
0.6403840780258179,
-0.573281466960907,
0.9541231393814087,
-0.3956562280654907,
0.048505574464797974,
-0.20082572102546692,
0.5354471206665039,
0.24676291644573212,
0.42745810747146606,
0.6640063524246216,
1.0012247562408447,
0.5446812510490417,
-0.46349430084228516,
0.9609702229499817,
0.08801334351301193,
0.42982032895088196,
0.6834606528282166,
-0.44434499740600586,
0.8702030777931213,
0.4101544916629791,
-0.6284552216529846,
0.2977684736251831,
0.49771586060523987,
-0.2073829174041748,
0.0026286058127880096,
1.1526216268539429,
-0.18575800955295563,
-0.22323888540267944,
0.11337818950414658,
-0.8047945499420166,
0.8329833149909973,
0.6923337578773499,
0.051655542105436325,
-0.242388516664505,
0.1900479793548584,
0.09724994003772736,
0.2658410370349884,
-0.5508910417556763,
0.5025036334991455,
0.3732539713382721,
-0.1587827056646347,
0.20360881090164185,
0.20851334929466248,
0.9074740409851074,
-0.8924427032470703,
-0.004431377165019512,
-0.035362645983695984,
-0.10478754341602325,
-0.16829970479011536,
-0.8408814072608948,
0.5331672430038452,
0.015648769214749336,
-0.06352125108242035,
0.27249741554260254,
0.551101803779602,
-0.12258505076169968,
-0.9737484455108643,
0.12242250144481659,
0.6594812870025635,
0.022669343277812004,
-0.10988235473632812,
-0.771510899066925,
0.170735701918602,
-0.3535901606082916,
-0.29195356369018555,
0.4935550093650818,
0.9916490912437439,
-0.05045368894934654,
1.0490180253982544,
0.7383031249046326,
0.2313162088394165,
-0.18663670122623444,
0.017497919499874115,
0.6450178623199463,
-1.0060927867889404,
-0.2818204462528229,
-1.1167097091674805,
0.16212618350982666,
0.17813843488693237,
-0.7083058953285217,
0.5769852995872498,
0.42659837007522583,
0.49266064167022705,
-0.041906267404556274,
0.2889883816242218,
0.23848773539066315,
0.44321298599243164,
-0.5810557007789612,
0.6277251243591309,
-0.710360586643219,
0.661881685256958,
-0.3078252375125885,
-1.0025118589401245,
-0.46845564246177673,
0.49325594305992126,
-0.205936461687088,
-0.03440758213400841,
0.9748667478561401,
0.33351364731788635,
0.29751133918762207,
-0.27796444296836853,
0.6791595220565796,
-0.14918561279773712,
0.3443586826324463,
0.9270603656768799,
1.0943410396575928,
-0.09097104519605637,
0.7926165461540222,
-0.37836259603500366,
0.0005753934383392334,
-0.0017563621513545513,
-0.969923198223114,
-1.05649733543396,
-0.45489057898521423,
-0.40902626514434814,
-0.4554959535598755,
-0.5610077381134033,
0.95176100730896,
0.18507802486419678,
-0.6010897159576416,
-0.3428162634372711,
0.1795448511838913,
0.5004557967185974,
0.16806861758232117,
-0.31889671087265015,
0.15456652641296387,
-0.622409999370575,
-0.7139926552772522,
-0.035915255546569824,
0.3782986104488373,
0.4559003412723541,
-0.41612446308135986,
0.42578649520874023,
0.20759564638137817,
0.29037076234817505,
0.8277225494384766,
-0.19011190533638,
-0.4597233235836029,
-0.6197114586830139,
-0.0902518704533577,
-0.3126356303691864,
-0.22826893627643585,
1.1300123929977417,
-0.41221147775650024,
0.07681694626808167,
0.19069425761699677,
0.7350022196769714,
0.05708536133170128,
-0.4455130100250244,
0.35429179668426514,
-0.7055858969688416,
0.2405843436717987,
0.3665216267108917,
0.5770701169967651,
0.34163418412208557,
-0.43399447202682495,
0.4844955801963806,
0.8634617924690247,
-0.3174216151237488,
-0.9922958612442017,
0.45113474130630493,
-0.715174674987793,
-0.5550167560577393,
1.152407169342041,
0.037878163158893585,
-0.1599210798740387,
-0.13673840463161469,
-0.2457467019557953,
-0.488491415977478,
0.39927899837493896,
0.6996704936027527,
1.546743631362915,
-0.13906481862068176,
-0.16816282272338867,
-0.678740918636322,
0.4135170578956604,
0.7723074555397034,
-0.45219919085502625,
-0.2835844159126282,
0.32117944955825806,
0.43567410111427307,
0.24449364840984344,
0.00581695232540369,
-0.05280115827918053,
-0.17061056196689606,
-0.1409323811531067,
-0.24440211057662964,
-0.2172878384590149,
-0.027699070051312447,
-0.3225443661212921,
0.5334912538528442,
0.3978809416294098,
0.21440811455249786
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11366v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11366v2
|
JORA: JAX Tensor-Parallel LoRA Library for Retrieval Augmented Fine-Tuning
| 2024-03-17T23:02:04 | 2024-03-19T16:19:49 |
Anique Tahir, Lu Cheng, Huan Liu
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.DC
|
The scaling of Large Language Models (LLMs) for retrieval-based tasks,
particularly in Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG), faces significant memory
constraints, especially when fine-tuning extensive prompt sequences. Current
open-source libraries support full-model inference and fine-tuning across
multiple GPUs but fall short of accommodating the efficient parameter
distribution required for retrieved context. Addressing this gap, we introduce
a novel framework for PEFT-compatible fine-tuning of Llama-2 models, leveraging
distributed training. Our framework uniquely utilizes JAX's just-in-time (JIT)
compilation and tensor-sharding for efficient resource management, thereby
enabling accelerated fine-tuning with reduced memory requirements. This
advancement significantly improves the scalability and feasibility of
fine-tuning LLMs for complex RAG applications, even on systems with limited GPU
resources. Our experiments show more than 12x improvement in runtime compared
to Hugging Face/DeepSpeed implementation with four GPUs while consuming less
than half the VRAM per GPU.
|
[
-0.40082669258117676,
-1.0375795364379883,
0.48297810554504395,
0.46793609857559204,
-0.3185691833496094,
0.13299919664859772,
-0.39484649896621704,
-0.44916144013404846,
0.16775262355804443,
0.6566275954246521,
-0.4044627845287323,
-0.295531302690506,
-0.5924457311630249,
-0.026482252404093742,
-0.16049621999263763,
0.92873215675354,
-0.27332237362861633,
-0.12341582030057907,
-0.1692540943622589,
-0.42187240719795227,
-0.3707258105278015,
-0.05600801482796669,
-0.7926819324493408,
-0.4242112636566162,
0.6232006549835205,
0.271013081073761,
0.6971030235290527,
0.9051612019538879,
0.7646356225013733,
0.23728132247924805,
-0.25955289602279663,
0.543007493019104,
-0.6920480132102966,
0.3085312247276306,
-0.32851722836494446,
-0.6524361968040466,
-0.638393223285675,
-0.19828131794929504,
0.7427845001220703,
0.6438836455345154,
-0.09442169964313507,
0.5080771446228027,
-0.014565767720341682,
0.8033046126365662,
-1.0146945714950562,
-0.031852420419454575,
-0.551001250743866,
-0.08231847733259201,
-0.7031787037849426,
-0.14571315050125122,
-0.276813805103302,
-0.1786392480134964,
-0.008405676111578941,
-0.8606749773025513,
0.15212519466876984,
0.020753029733896255,
0.8453728556632996,
0.7143049240112305,
-0.3142486810684204,
0.12221609055995941,
-0.686037540435791,
0.8369155526161194,
-0.3558684289455414,
0.4574149250984192,
0.3513841927051544,
0.20077364146709442,
-0.2198546975851059,
-0.7755259871482849,
-0.38448989391326904,
0.20124049484729767,
0.14476905763149261,
-0.03444819152355194,
0.0493285246193409,
0.1575896143913269,
0.44958314299583435,
0.5551545023918152,
-0.425980806350708,
-0.003099942347034812,
0.012315423227846622,
0.2837112545967102,
0.3735188841819763,
0.19856823980808258,
-0.010971421375870705,
0.11287237703800201,
-0.4056464731693268,
-0.09100150316953659,
-0.9292446970939636,
-0.3723607361316681,
0.1566154956817627,
0.46972915530204773,
-0.2406834065914154,
0.38881146907806396,
-0.32413655519485474,
0.6843975782394409,
0.09813746064901352,
-0.42134660482406616,
0.23944152891635895,
-0.015603527426719666,
-0.41025510430336,
-0.2811412513256073,
0.46047335863113403,
-0.029971756041049957,
-0.3011072874069214,
-0.07931473106145859,
-0.25482767820358276,
0.07022859901189804,
0.04709981009364128,
-0.8803227543830872,
-0.16098913550376892,
-0.0926935076713562,
-0.414103239774704,
-0.21125257015228271,
-0.46001511812210083,
-0.7188808917999268,
-0.41274696588516235,
-0.4464133381843567,
0.6419936418533325,
-0.09695930778980255,
-0.3821917474269867,
0.09528511017560959,
-0.12611891329288483,
-0.06643882393836975,
0.42046135663986206,
-0.7493366599082947,
0.301887184381485,
0.781960129737854,
0.7526345252990723,
-0.2730794847011566,
-0.1270274966955185,
-0.7601438760757446,
0.46711114048957825,
-0.1288139522075653,
0.6911097764968872,
-0.597622275352478,
-0.19264735281467438,
-0.2701188623905182,
-0.21998481452465057,
-0.03238362446427345,
-0.7249308824539185,
0.6246833205223083,
-0.6750844717025757,
-0.15654480457305908,
-0.48149973154067993,
-0.3990817368030548,
-0.009224931709468365,
0.26890847086906433,
-0.5677054524421692,
1.2167011499404907,
0.3067842125892639,
-0.6434615850448608,
0.14983102679252625,
-0.6220830082893372,
-0.4689892828464508,
0.24279175698757172,
-0.22924846410751343,
-0.5301147103309631,
0.19805358350276947,
0.388727605342865,
0.414509654045105,
-0.7903150916099548,
0.17950472235679626,
-0.4667186141014099,
-0.7401575446128845,
-0.4332945942878723,
-0.21583394706249237,
0.6401460766792297,
0.5688074827194214,
-0.37095168232917786,
-0.1764705330133438,
-0.7329217791557312,
0.02959160879254341,
0.30336645245552063,
-0.6166657209396362,
-0.590785801410675,
-0.230538010597229,
0.06409680098295212,
-0.32853591442108154,
0.6668741703033447,
-0.519771158695221,
0.4056015908718109,
-0.16765515506267548,
0.2482987642288208,
0.5944795608520508,
-0.375565767288208,
0.48228758573532104,
-0.18283556401729584,
0.4123057425022125,
-0.19310058653354645,
0.2664371430873871,
-0.08936333656311035,
-0.1896464079618454,
-0.7864671945571899,
-0.8175172209739685,
0.0893784835934639,
0.3210865259170532,
-0.750377357006073,
-0.1894253045320511,
-0.19420066475868225,
-0.441509485244751,
-0.6130874156951904,
0.32239559292793274,
0.7781347632408142,
0.3674241006374359,
0.334389328956604,
-0.025718890130519867,
-0.6166600584983826,
-0.7867191433906555,
-0.3156089186668396,
-0.006343546323478222,
0.06517679989337921,
0.8375098705291748,
0.07495108991861343,
-0.551952600479126,
0.49505674839019775,
-0.34827402234077454,
-0.3332478106021881,
-0.02183903008699417,
0.10286501049995422,
0.34299689531326294,
0.3444666564464569,
0.5656421780586243,
-0.6992864012718201,
-0.5532048940658569,
0.19153770804405212,
-0.6539424657821655,
-0.3704559803009033,
0.1066422238945961,
-0.348887175321579,
0.13807591795921326,
0.36279788613319397,
-0.6664049029350281,
0.14171941578388214,
0.7358912825584412,
-0.13009676337242126,
0.12012215703725815,
-0.141729474067688,
0.15195588767528534,
-1.09506094455719,
0.2106536626815796,
-0.2980036735534668,
-0.4542643427848816,
-0.06299255788326263,
0.5164604187011719,
0.1549120545387268,
0.023229306563735008,
-0.08268246054649353,
0.5125404000282288,
-0.20478087663650513,
-0.3632189929485321,
-0.530886173248291,
-0.025735415518283844,
0.2304578572511673,
0.2827286422252655,
-0.16605894267559052,
1.1339163780212402,
0.2858221232891083,
-0.6508385539054871,
0.15320883691310883,
0.28754690289497375,
-0.06328683346509933,
0.6814976930618286,
-0.6751307249069214,
0.14389535784721375,
-0.06147649884223938,
0.2722775936126709,
-0.4212243854999542,
-0.45409730076789856,
-0.20769287645816803,
0.004519449546933174,
0.34790146350860596,
-0.41960597038269043,
-0.5221291184425354,
-0.18113566935062408,
-0.037446655333042145,
0.6328192353248596,
0.45698538422584534,
-1.1135329008102417,
0.7352895140647888,
0.5634885430335999,
0.06929104030132294,
-0.7327702045440674,
-0.3450753688812256,
-0.28154000639915466,
-0.22460950911045074,
-0.45497265458106995,
0.5868439078330994,
-0.03120671771466732,
-0.19423551857471466,
-0.14098846912384033,
0.047599613666534424,
-0.04450858384370804,
0.31487494707107544,
0.38049644231796265,
0.05120719224214554,
-0.23005220293998718,
0.015483020804822445,
0.3521912693977356,
-0.03381925821304321,
-0.35205018520355225,
-0.1322832852602005,
0.629397988319397,
-0.21367976069450378,
-0.35420194268226624,
-0.32318615913391113,
0.1865435540676117,
0.4144495129585266,
-0.3437785506248474,
0.6574026942253113,
0.9738883376121521,
-0.20913764834403992,
-0.27311673760414124,
-0.6503820419311523,
0.13423454761505127,
-0.5028306245803833,
0.2252568006515503,
-0.6105561256408691,
-1.3001091480255127,
0.5501603484153748,
-0.6757810711860657,
0.07975547015666962,
0.3875485360622406,
0.8527759909629822,
-0.16147705912590027,
1.012052297592163,
0.7596657872200012,
-0.15604323148727417,
0.7382628321647644,
-0.15734492242336273,
-0.06722178310155869,
-1.0009993314743042,
0.005229306407272816,
-0.4058016240596771,
-0.4826696515083313,
-0.5983110666275024,
-0.4748625159263611,
0.5201959609985352,
0.49093809723854065,
-0.564056932926178,
0.342448353767395,
-0.5146868824958801,
0.8524381518363953,
0.5149064660072327,
0.10986810177564621,
0.3671785295009613,
0.08327805995941162,
-0.05753183737397194,
0.1676996350288391,
-0.49738049507141113,
-0.11357899010181427,
1.0280306339263916,
0.2612588107585907,
0.8464477062225342,
0.24588771164417267,
0.862382173538208,
0.08017251640558243,
0.19590017199516296,
-0.3093153238296509,
0.4257667064666748,
-0.35052555799484253,
-0.7451127171516418,
0.017493650317192078,
-0.5229412913322449,
-0.7923028469085693,
0.19292275607585907,
-0.13805139064788818,
-0.5276954770088196,
0.01753702014684677,
0.15739457309246063,
-0.4931669533252716,
0.40557804703712463,
-0.4426688849925995,
0.4612879455089569,
0.23910900950431824,
-0.638205349445343,
-0.6953593492507935,
-0.275983601808548,
0.3598950505256653,
-0.13096176087856293,
-0.23348568379878998,
-0.45026081800460815,
0.0019547457341104746,
0.6658062934875488,
-0.2751258313655853,
0.5201253294944763,
-0.2371233105659485,
0.1305808275938034,
0.2596527338027954,
0.17303577065467834,
0.7621443271636963,
0.43626174330711365,
-0.07167643308639526,
0.21356435120105743,
0.117660291492939,
-0.5668990612030029,
-0.3598564565181732,
1.1346015930175781,
-1.0603251457214355,
-0.4752379357814789,
-0.1082044467329979,
-0.7655410170555115,
-0.24216580390930176,
0.23472824692726135,
-0.0024841674603521824,
0.054876912385225296,
0.08538723737001419,
0.19841249287128448,
0.8990020751953125,
-0.12401853501796722,
0.19603000581264496,
0.736204981803894,
-0.29450297355651855,
-0.48978686332702637,
0.7423559427261353,
-0.2029590755701065,
-0.005402631592005491,
0.3436950445175171,
-0.002469343598932028,
0.06739464402198792,
-0.5882577300071716,
-0.6774947643280029,
0.4451444745063782,
-0.3100224733352661,
-0.5159695148468018,
-0.4469023048877716,
0.060228101909160614,
-0.09252161532640457,
-0.14440345764160156,
-0.9613761305809021,
-0.30886173248291016,
-0.4359471797943115,
0.32633090019226074,
0.8871870040893555,
0.8175846338272095,
-0.02299836091697216,
0.5859200954437256,
-0.7059915065765381,
0.396663099527359,
0.08343932777643204,
0.7449399828910828,
-0.14617882668972015,
-0.5079658031463623,
-0.41905611753463745,
-0.13364866375923157,
-0.33515477180480957,
-0.14074984192848206,
0.1453535407781601,
0.14104095101356506,
0.16406436264514923,
0.14712125062942505,
-0.09099993109703064,
1.3189654350280762,
-0.4305325448513031,
0.522071123123169,
-0.11469881236553192,
-0.7241969108581543,
0.45193660259246826,
-0.655150294303894,
0.20440411567687988,
0.6640186905860901,
0.2514551281929016,
-0.0819304957985878,
-0.012101906351745129,
-0.30914008617401123,
-0.7027639746665955,
0.593895673751831,
-0.012502876110374928,
0.0965832993388176,
-0.0893082469701767,
0.7451921105384827,
0.16157445311546326,
-0.07991928607225418,
-0.1558024287223816,
-0.1709045022726059,
0.35206037759780884,
-0.2073940485715866,
0.14078545570373535,
-0.3843522071838379,
-0.3011953830718994,
-0.3116638958454132,
0.7401202321052551,
-0.2623668909072876,
0.32619255781173706,
0.08464089781045914,
-0.07852141559123993,
-0.5830153226852417,
-0.1313902735710144,
0.2611275315284729,
0.43599244952201843,
-0.36871421337127686,
-0.11851970106363297,
0.2903081774711609,
-0.5491653084754944,
-0.21324339509010315,
0.2893752157688141,
-0.3070669174194336,
-0.17367850244045258,
-0.10470107942819595,
0.9475815892219543,
0.12638457119464874,
-0.7390637397766113,
0.2975107431411743,
-0.25302761793136597,
0.10280553996562958,
-0.31594398617744446,
0.21103760600090027,
0.018134409561753273,
0.836855947971344,
0.12300393730401993,
0.03926500678062439,
0.005276796407997608,
-0.08990777283906937,
0.12876781821250916,
0.6027058362960815,
0.1449718475341797,
-0.2652018666267395,
0.9414972066879272,
0.19632162153720856,
0.009223399683833122,
0.6561827063560486,
-0.08217562735080719,
-0.018908338621258736,
0.20463921129703522,
0.7066020965576172,
0.6396511197090149,
0.0157968457788229,
-0.20741604268550873,
0.4096806049346924,
-0.18126428127288818,
-0.39605286717414856,
0.578612208366394,
-0.24712570011615753,
-0.48075053095817566,
-0.6599609851837158,
-1.1769708395004272,
-0.4527496099472046,
0.18192556500434875,
-0.7334567308425903,
0.27851611375808716,
-0.7755769491195679,
-0.3388804793357849,
-0.23419086635112762,
0.12562309205532074,
-0.8043204545974731,
-0.1203230693936348,
0.30298808217048645,
0.6515415906906128,
-0.6064245700836182,
1.056821346282959,
0.6979078054428101,
-0.1361195594072342,
-0.8860863447189331,
-0.3081355094909668,
-0.1565537452697754,
-0.6873592734336853,
0.5275201797485352,
-0.130540132522583,
-0.0660807341337204,
0.16614721715450287,
-0.33185532689094543,
-1.3298457860946655,
1.3662737607955933,
0.8138213157653809,
-0.6893393397331238,
-0.043082743883132935,
0.09149699658155441,
0.4651099443435669,
-0.09299539774656296,
0.284641295671463,
0.7823584675788879,
0.08443155884742737,
0.03357924520969391,
-1.2946816682815552,
-0.17405690252780914,
0.02167520858347416,
0.2502315044403076,
0.5643765330314636,
-1.0428508520126343,
1.0619831085205078,
0.011956471018493176,
0.0851663202047348,
0.26476341485977173,
0.7575278282165527,
0.6221138834953308,
0.2824866473674774,
0.30618685483932495,
1.0871881246566772,
0.9246158003807068,
-0.028916411101818085,
1.0738940238952637,
-0.3109990358352661,
0.4881541430950165,
1.0321087837219238,
-0.26072824001312256,
0.9850403666496277,
0.45586320757865906,
-0.28048175573349,
0.29133373498916626,
0.4364158511161804,
0.3468758165836334,
0.5344290137290955,
-0.3174375891685486,
-0.5372658371925354,
-0.3712960183620453,
-0.45792531967163086,
-0.27069830894470215,
0.51551753282547,
0.4465920329093933,
-0.43130162358283997,
-0.345855712890625,
0.04365403950214386,
-0.030113523826003075,
-0.01404716819524765,
-0.6627688407897949,
0.585776686668396,
0.16180436313152313,
-0.3650799095630646,
0.8482436537742615,
0.10063334554433823,
0.7597336769104004,
-0.2708599269390106,
0.032130610197782516,
-0.36420905590057373,
0.5719218254089355,
-0.1162147969007492,
-0.43465688824653625,
0.26689305901527405,
0.10972052812576294,
-0.3360329270362854,
-0.1874430626630783,
0.7420341968536377,
-0.24931687116622925,
-0.1272401511669159,
0.2568570673465729,
0.46171295642852783,
0.07347849756479263,
-0.0801474079489708,
-0.7625517249107361,
0.5477709770202637,
-0.12092327326536179,
-0.5678653717041016,
0.7514067888259888,
0.2608552575111389,
-0.26539015769958496,
0.6540417075157166,
0.6496201753616333,
-0.1400914192199707,
0.18549737334251404,
0.25248220562934875,
1.0403825044631958,
-0.3548668324947357,
-0.2112816870212555,
-0.7106078863143921,
0.021593665704131126,
0.20448607206344604,
-0.2588062286376953,
0.6258712410926819,
0.48924946784973145,
0.9704958200454712,
0.10569020360708237,
0.4675361216068268,
-0.15429803729057312,
0.7820577621459961,
-0.19781333208084106,
0.6731435060501099,
-0.7475392818450928,
0.25203749537467957,
-0.06804603338241577,
-0.9822133779525757,
-0.3780372142791748,
0.6607574224472046,
-0.03773852437734604,
-0.2089620679616928,
0.2064422369003296,
0.7063379287719727,
-0.2921135127544403,
-0.14231565594673157,
0.24906055629253387,
0.115171879529953,
0.2588673532009125,
0.5897109508514404,
0.29976367950439453,
-0.5933879613876343,
0.3129919469356537,
-0.2711501717567444,
0.006474666763097048,
-0.3587449789047241,
-0.605919599533081,
-0.9142718315124512,
-0.42410245537757874,
-0.2440052181482315,
-0.2859608232975006,
0.24226050078868866,
1.0986645221710205,
0.6475281715393066,
-0.5441544055938721,
0.0704546719789505,
-0.10356231033802032,
-0.20926110446453094,
0.010279599577188492,
-0.1310773640871048,
0.35478344559669495,
-0.3926345109939575,
-0.9488627910614014,
0.5508508086204529,
0.2588947117328644,
-0.24684274196624756,
-0.13429321348667145,
-0.2821933925151825,
0.057138536125421524,
-0.004105452913790941,
0.5695180892944336,
0.3253824710845947,
-0.5978866815567017,
-0.07277770340442657,
-0.2527129352092743,
-0.28448280692100525,
-0.00852825865149498,
0.5322595834732056,
-1.0753772258758545,
0.3504781424999237,
0.5676369667053223,
1.0615220069885254,
0.8739258050918579,
-0.08516306430101395,
0.252404123544693,
-0.873418390750885,
0.4960291087627411,
0.21469323337078094,
0.3209923505783081,
0.13570283353328705,
-0.361653596162796,
0.657536506652832,
0.2263011932373047,
-0.7796690464019775,
-0.9803323745727539,
0.19908864796161652,
-1.0772336721420288,
0.01937923952937126,
1.0510774850845337,
-0.13063740730285645,
-0.417644739151001,
0.3468514084815979,
-0.09270545095205307,
0.43485116958618164,
-0.17645780742168427,
0.7226890921592712,
0.1911127269268036,
-0.044118139892816544,
-0.14321120083332062,
-0.536843478679657,
0.57365483045578,
0.6180614233016968,
-0.5198307633399963,
0.1666901558637619,
0.20674146711826324,
0.3177967667579651,
-0.04866359382867813,
0.5819578170776367,
-0.026461558416485786,
0.26529815793037415,
-0.13101086020469666,
0.056958507746458054,
-0.26650944352149963,
-0.2500104010105133,
-0.1430191993713379,
-0.043746162205934525,
0.2348688840866089,
0.150669127702713
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11346v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11346v3
|
CantonMT: Cantonese to English NMT Platform with Fine-Tuned Models Using Synthetic Back-Translation Data
| 2024-03-17T21:16:17 | 2024-06-09T22:10:04 |
Kung Yin Hong, Lifeng Han, Riza Batista-Navarro, Goran Nenadic
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Neural Machine Translation (NMT) for low-resource languages is still a
challenging task in front of NLP researchers. In this work, we deploy a
standard data augmentation methodology by back-translation to a new language
translation direction Cantonese-to-English. We present the models we fine-tuned
using the limited amount of real data and the synthetic data we generated using
back-translation including OpusMT, NLLB, and mBART. We carried out automatic
evaluation using a range of different metrics including lexical-based and
embedding-based. Furthermore. we create a user-friendly interface for the
models we included in this\textsc{ CantonMT} research project and make it
available to facilitate Cantonese-to-English MT research. Researchers can add
more models into this platform via our open-source\textsc{ CantonMT} toolkit
\url{https://github.com/kenrickkung/CantoneseTranslation}.
|
[
-0.1567986011505127,
-0.7219241261482239,
0.36486881971359253,
0.36458903551101685,
-0.5654190182685852,
0.06185634806752205,
-0.2479846030473709,
-0.23457646369934082,
0.37761786580085754,
0.7878062129020691,
-0.3158973455429077,
-0.4389277398586273,
-0.4315582513809204,
0.3240101933479309,
-0.1980394721031189,
0.6407642960548401,
-0.15911036729812622,
0.44886982440948486,
0.23943521082401276,
-0.07852710038423538,
-0.5121111869812012,
-0.6277040839195251,
-0.8383764028549194,
-0.529694139957428,
0.27075085043907166,
0.4039674401283264,
0.7672407031059265,
0.7301600575447083,
0.48133695125579834,
0.2204817682504654,
-0.06141147390007973,
0.3589012324810028,
-0.2617955803871155,
-0.21677915751934052,
-0.2682092785835266,
-0.26080819964408875,
-0.9196859002113342,
-0.0722816064953804,
0.5726221799850464,
0.6743032336235046,
-0.04646201431751251,
0.05488002672791481,
0.00003821946302196011,
0.6124708652496338,
0.03578106313943863,
0.11425842344760895,
-0.630751371383667,
0.22635598480701447,
0.09338577091693878,
-0.5968651175498962,
-0.4795010983943939,
-0.33074551820755005,
-0.05510392412543297,
-0.44577282667160034,
-0.061126116663217545,
0.13535472750663757,
0.8286640644073486,
0.2350592017173767,
-0.7603036761283875,
0.026018589735031128,
-0.6571550965309143,
0.8660773634910583,
-0.9890591502189636,
0.5116840600967407,
0.3575992286205292,
0.5374507308006287,
0.0077051096595823765,
-0.8378812074661255,
-0.15970970690250397,
-0.6521991491317749,
-0.04520445317029953,
0.49148619174957275,
0.27014926075935364,
-0.0527886338531971,
-0.05684637278318405,
0.5188971161842346,
-0.596352219581604,
0.0662020891904831,
-0.35537219047546387,
-0.03422919288277626,
0.4831978678703308,
0.4018153250217438,
0.3640417456626892,
-0.5420072078704834,
-0.6865612268447876,
-0.08329737931489944,
-0.6818990707397461,
-0.3908495604991913,
0.16386763751506805,
0.6144086122512817,
-0.29425573348999023,
0.9256247282028198,
-0.26926058530807495,
0.6223618984222412,
0.09640490263700485,
0.5070099234580994,
0.32587963342666626,
-0.6048208475112915,
-0.25473228096961975,
0.08738668262958527,
0.805019736289978,
0.4614875316619873,
-0.052867863327264786,
-0.20725369453430176,
-0.5964511632919312,
-0.575877845287323,
0.09975169599056244,
-0.9708964824676514,
-0.1777961254119873,
0.030429450795054436,
-0.580207884311676,
-0.3339352607727051,
0.046639297157526016,
-0.3967234492301941,
-0.1054745689034462,
-0.5465183258056641,
0.42566943168640137,
-0.7597266435623169,
-0.537391722202301,
0.3714969754219055,
-0.011007034219801426,
-0.0096426447853446,
0.33764469623565674,
-0.7013826370239258,
0.15281489491462708,
0.7845240235328674,
1.2130602598190308,
-0.1442272663116455,
-0.3280481696128845,
-0.30927860736846924,
0.11162230372428894,
-0.43820720911026,
0.4856671392917633,
-0.045272164046764374,
-0.19646361470222473,
-0.245587557554245,
0.2534298002719879,
-0.06062772125005722,
-0.6201861500740051,
0.4631167948246002,
-0.4083302915096283,
0.2921268045902252,
-0.028654519468545914,
-0.4144681990146637,
-0.3540923297405243,
0.642276406288147,
-0.6940542459487915,
0.8984761834144592,
0.3714258074760437,
-0.5935748815536499,
-0.2257782220840454,
-0.7575775980949402,
-0.5612555146217346,
0.26294204592704773,
0.15078973770141602,
-0.007750826887786388,
0.2621521055698395,
0.1385316699743271,
0.46555909514427185,
-0.5953548550605774,
0.4644896984100342,
0.252230167388916,
-0.3487810492515564,
0.33243200182914734,
-0.6442432403564453,
1.0793113708496094,
0.3124069571495056,
-0.0953131690621376,
0.12269630283117294,
-1.0392814874649048,
-0.04278053343296051,
0.028439393267035484,
-0.4338902235031128,
-0.3409242331981659,
-0.14093418419361115,
0.34998685121536255,
0.5384437441825867,
0.5732537508010864,
-0.47279879450798035,
0.023619767278432846,
-0.7789878249168396,
0.8610257506370544,
0.53319251537323,
-0.18750052154064178,
0.45807451009750366,
-0.3711906671524048,
0.5922927260398865,
0.1235552579164505,
0.020474443212151527,
0.008182534947991371,
-0.44732561707496643,
-0.3524463176727295,
-0.08075378090143204,
0.5315700173377991,
0.7485283613204956,
-1.1281750202178955,
0.4734533429145813,
-0.38008859753608704,
-0.4501827657222748,
-0.7479419112205505,
-0.16947810351848602,
0.003711990313604474,
0.7435586452484131,
0.682616114616394,
-0.45830705761909485,
-0.6482055187225342,
-0.858765721321106,
0.29537856578826904,
-0.09217105805873871,
-0.3660431504249573,
0.3598284125328064,
0.17188489437103271,
-0.6164524555206299,
0.714327335357666,
-0.2028980702161789,
-0.19593219459056854,
-0.24480333924293518,
0.19448088109493256,
0.20436307787895203,
0.6878403425216675,
0.5496096014976501,
-0.7364403605461121,
-0.6392266154289246,
0.519784688949585,
-0.6404018998146057,
-0.21803191304206848,
-0.22054032981395721,
-0.19096404314041138,
0.16233041882514954,
0.5971784591674805,
-0.3836304843425751,
-0.033367641270160675,
0.8647022843360901,
0.003298733616247773,
0.644268810749054,
-0.18934431672096252,
0.206423819065094,
-1.7100186347961426,
0.11046315729618073,
-0.2900332510471344,
-0.34168729186058044,
-0.49387118220329285,
0.38008537888526917,
0.23990276455879211,
-0.13083505630493164,
-0.6479116678237915,
0.6665390729904175,
-0.21338747441768646,
0.11114136874675751,
-0.34737837314605713,
0.11063162982463837,
0.031919654458761215,
0.35662299394607544,
0.12558262050151825,
0.8073289394378662,
0.2413703054189682,
-0.3808540403842926,
0.5815669298171997,
0.21113480627536774,
0.003481681924313307,
0.25011777877807617,
-0.790164589881897,
0.13893406093120575,
0.5653585195541382,
0.026794519275426865,
-0.7900902032852173,
-0.05292247235774994,
0.4760310649871826,
-0.6303202509880066,
0.023771701380610466,
-0.40172088146209717,
-0.622607409954071,
0.10050538927316666,
-0.28611046075820923,
0.45042043924331665,
0.4977862238883972,
-0.639478325843811,
0.6758516430854797,
0.0034564591478556395,
-0.14678193628787994,
-0.21563145518302917,
-0.8909620642662048,
0.5510758757591248,
-0.10281332582235336,
-0.785758912563324,
0.460786908864975,
-0.07260789722204208,
0.03621207922697067,
0.017789535224437714,
0.3638332784175873,
-0.4382707178592682,
0.019031314179301262,
-0.04571091756224632,
0.21587607264518738,
-0.6779442429542542,
-0.08025262504816055,
0.16392818093299866,
-0.2169657200574875,
0.0843670666217804,
-0.4446212351322174,
0.8323615789413452,
-0.1276017427444458,
-0.017740339040756226,
-0.29789847135543823,
0.2882936894893646,
0.3783230781555176,
-0.2394162118434906,
0.7822519540786743,
0.9113631844520569,
-0.3469533622264862,
-0.04243898019194603,
-0.14163203537464142,
-0.38722747564315796,
-0.4992426335811615,
0.5539706945419312,
-0.4937795400619507,
-0.8096082806587219,
0.580682098865509,
-0.16917569935321808,
-0.056923188269138336,
0.3680558502674103,
0.658211350440979,
0.3193206191062927,
1.35877525806427,
0.541392982006073,
0.13787119090557098,
0.2688661515712738,
-0.10725432634353638,
0.15963642299175262,
-1.1307250261306763,
0.2049645334482193,
-0.20889846980571747,
-0.110294871032238,
-0.8036548495292664,
-0.3253781795501709,
-0.016844546422362328,
0.04020698741078377,
-0.12618428468704224,
0.7195233702659607,
-0.5316481590270996,
0.08186956495046616,
0.5953323245048523,
0.19806678593158722,
0.40353888273239136,
-0.21710388362407684,
-0.1735343039035797,
-0.26528921723365784,
-0.7090302109718323,
-0.39081066846847534,
0.8701819181442261,
0.25986382365226746,
0.4969208836555481,
0.12237180769443512,
0.6387908458709717,
-0.21587519347667694,
0.14652463793754578,
-0.9373003244400024,
0.6401467323303223,
-0.4716162085533142,
-0.3218022882938385,
-0.06729502975940704,
-0.838497519493103,
-0.7819987535476685,
0.14796414971351624,
-0.041139040142297745,
0.016593201085925102,
-0.13061325252056122,
0.0363544262945652,
-0.2753259539604187,
0.24753068387508392,
-0.6753472089767456,
0.799766480922699,
-0.5222254991531372,
-0.2422589510679245,
-0.0761546641588211,
-0.5912351012229919,
0.5019446611404419,
-0.2761014401912689,
-0.20184193551540375,
-0.0070548937655985355,
-0.04553567245602608,
0.34708383679389954,
-0.3840404748916626,
0.7610524892807007,
0.012801036238670349,
-0.2196163684129715,
-0.08223642408847809,
0.1467549204826355,
0.3359045684337616,
0.25033465027809143,
-0.3387385606765747,
0.4960847496986389,
0.009689752012491226,
-0.34395304322242737,
-0.4530477821826935,
0.5581701397895813,
-0.5165174603462219,
-0.35513198375701904,
-0.23174576461315155,
-0.9501595497131348,
-0.02137242816388607,
0.4546665549278259,
0.35734090209007263,
0.27680736780166626,
-0.12376867234706879,
0.36506351828575134,
0.09745898842811584,
-0.6081966161727905,
-0.08274184167385101,
0.7143253684043884,
-0.4537474811077118,
-0.5112097263336182,
0.9285712242126465,
0.22700613737106323,
0.3880338668823242,
0.5207544565200806,
0.4577045142650604,
-0.277618944644928,
-0.7616432309150696,
-0.5738570690155029,
0.12792611122131348,
-0.265801340341568,
-0.1554109901189804,
-0.43423163890838623,
-0.5958189964294434,
-0.653928279876709,
-0.10214833915233612,
-0.6495425701141357,
-0.7798442840576172,
-0.2393454611301422,
-0.027293041348457336,
0.26070865988731384,
0.37204521894454956,
-0.3507075607776642,
0.5726721882820129,
-1.0557140111923218,
0.31183871626853943,
-0.0654759630560875,
0.14769352972507477,
-0.0770551785826683,
-0.8507879972457886,
-0.6984625458717346,
0.442070871591568,
-0.1128808781504631,
-0.469138503074646,
1.0824075937271118,
-0.10578291863203049,
-0.01024479977786541,
0.04238774627447128,
0.030850062146782875,
0.591515064239502,
-0.8307463526725769,
0.7460376620292664,
0.03238646313548088,
-0.6802582740783691,
0.3902636468410492,
-0.47703179717063904,
0.20466573536396027,
0.4050051271915436,
0.12041192501783371,
-0.7758789658546448,
-0.23202772438526154,
-0.4278589189052582,
-1.0838247537612915,
0.5112121105194092,
0.05231186002492905,
0.2149868756532669,
-0.0077810888178646564,
0.33119645714759827,
0.05222327262163162,
0.27462685108184814,
-0.6103020906448364,
0.07869289070367813,
-0.46335557103157043,
-0.2977391481399536,
-0.05370243638753891,
-0.07853879034519196,
0.028370758518576622,
-0.33898207545280457,
0.8123594522476196,
-0.11608577519655228,
0.11324793100357056,
0.01467773038893938,
-0.09127327054738998,
-0.021419093012809753,
0.0886748731136322,
0.6522321105003357,
0.5104250311851501,
-0.6321579813957214,
0.08657896518707275,
-0.031014209613204002,
-0.49938103556632996,
-0.09563419222831726,
0.3569156229496002,
-0.4764224886894226,
0.2193496972322464,
0.08289514482021332,
0.6261582970619202,
0.16931165754795074,
-0.4744837284088135,
0.213889941573143,
-0.10387551039457321,
-0.13131274282932281,
-0.39795976877212524,
-0.23276489973068237,
0.1512172818183899,
0.12928418815135956,
0.13375979661941528,
0.23296493291854858,
0.17884519696235657,
-0.3700559139251709,
0.3563011884689331,
0.1770864576101303,
-0.46970248222351074,
-0.65256267786026,
0.7571064233779907,
0.32956597208976746,
-0.41257011890411377,
0.6915446519851685,
-0.2324497252702713,
-0.5866348147392273,
0.5479769110679626,
0.7010396718978882,
1.0683237314224243,
-0.363880455493927,
0.24133320152759552,
0.46002069115638733,
0.71476149559021,
-0.2844729423522949,
0.07044627517461777,
0.43771854043006897,
-0.839152455329895,
-0.7947595715522766,
-0.334493488073349,
-0.5377107858657837,
0.2814158499240875,
-0.7473829984664917,
0.31996509432792664,
-0.37067630887031555,
-0.009036554023623466,
-0.43314293026924133,
-0.022984908893704414,
-0.1488904356956482,
0.0013253516517579556,
-0.37943410873413086,
0.9566208720207214,
-0.6112117767333984,
1.1825577020645142,
0.7112824320793152,
-0.4487277567386627,
-0.9132102131843567,
-0.2078617662191391,
-0.25404229760169983,
-1.0128692388534546,
0.6226447224617004,
0.05079086124897003,
-0.11879438161849976,
0.4148823618888855,
-0.3087095618247986,
-0.4915243685245514,
1.025374174118042,
0.5359330773353577,
-0.412534236907959,
0.03774483501911163,
0.5473834276199341,
0.6422054767608643,
-0.2160535305738449,
0.02461444027721882,
0.39931246638298035,
0.5047680735588074,
-0.0014249527594074607,
-0.7207433581352234,
-0.04630148038268089,
-0.2514776885509491,
0.018109528347849846,
0.0649079829454422,
-0.455031156539917,
1.164770483970642,
0.3321508467197418,
-0.08926970511674881,
0.2821081280708313,
0.4338490962982178,
0.11400800198316574,
0.2601303160190582,
0.1626770943403244,
0.44160139560699463,
0.2413909137248993,
0.006543060764670372,
0.8576139211654663,
-0.5480298399925232,
0.3648926913738251,
1.2378487586975098,
-0.33454400300979614,
0.8817469477653503,
0.5706642866134644,
0.2544369697570801,
-0.08980589359998703,
0.6195299029350281,
-0.10720039159059525,
0.5050116777420044,
-0.10017894208431244,
0.05466711148619652,
-0.0042739794589579105,
-0.27046000957489014,
-0.37315621972084045,
0.286152720451355,
0.23848317563533783,
-0.253858745098114,
-0.11388256400823593,
0.029120055958628654,
-0.1819911003112793,
0.11450400948524475,
-0.2267322689294815,
0.44425511360168457,
0.4059605002403259,
-0.26672106981277466,
0.8540952801704407,
0.468651682138443,
0.9708589315414429,
-0.4761047959327698,
-0.1326974779367447,
-0.45890823006629944,
0.130396768450737,
-0.15016749501228333,
-0.611905574798584,
0.5226964354515076,
-0.1521739810705185,
0.006547537166625261,
-0.32416045665740967,
0.5772866606712341,
-0.7951064109802246,
-0.5389221906661987,
0.3751940429210663,
0.7062457799911499,
0.08664538711309433,
-0.21826952695846558,
-0.854201078414917,
-0.4184592664241791,
0.17262428998947144,
-0.1668650507926941,
0.2911461889743805,
0.7138020396232605,
0.03470919653773308,
0.4266853928565979,
0.66722571849823,
0.5268843770027161,
0.07213441282510757,
0.2499459981918335,
0.4708325266838074,
-0.7563475966453552,
-0.3992661237716675,
-0.8220396041870117,
0.29167529940605164,
0.10284566134214401,
-0.1924055963754654,
0.9600305557250977,
0.7995502352714539,
0.9243937134742737,
-0.22225558757781982,
0.6050185561180115,
0.08369960635900497,
0.6930367946624756,
-0.8174123764038086,
0.8663138151168823,
-0.6626318097114563,
0.2286548763513565,
0.01930299960076809,
-0.8544598817825317,
-0.3828645646572113,
0.5333912372589111,
0.014020686037838459,
-0.17806467413902283,
0.6497215032577515,
0.9231395125389099,
-0.37660256028175354,
-0.16171805560588837,
0.47726088762283325,
0.4530143141746521,
0.3149193227291107,
0.7184080481529236,
0.8413621187210083,
-0.6847549080848694,
0.35860398411750793,
-0.608429491519928,
0.0443907231092453,
-0.3970789313316345,
-0.855674684047699,
-0.7529711127281189,
-0.5818688273429871,
-0.12659741938114166,
-0.2648007571697235,
-0.11265893280506134,
1.1090507507324219,
0.4747849106788635,
-0.6730911135673523,
-0.47551843523979187,
-0.09641123563051224,
-0.1692832112312317,
-0.44927388429641724,
-0.2595643103122711,
0.47498562932014465,
-0.1464581936597824,
-0.9233903884887695,
0.7348225116729736,
0.2674160599708557,
0.2349597066640854,
-0.10365381836891174,
-0.32011252641677856,
-0.16853776574134827,
-0.027586989104747772,
0.894464910030365,
0.053488340228796005,
-0.35880231857299805,
-0.27003568410873413,
0.26272252202033997,
-0.2812839150428772,
0.3158210813999176,
0.5098294019699097,
-0.4674360454082489,
0.20087593793869019,
0.5374770164489746,
0.9712309241294861,
0.17291340231895447,
0.1464783102273941,
0.8408443927764893,
-1.0473519563674927,
0.3468140959739685,
0.4069739282131195,
0.292009562253952,
0.5722293257713318,
-0.2634524703025818,
0.8565683364868164,
0.18504594266414642,
-0.4193081557750702,
-0.9967694878578186,
0.14269216358661652,
-1.1025433540344238,
-0.20246997475624084,
1.11118483543396,
0.12299803644418716,
-0.1926012635231018,
-0.026968801394104958,
-0.36676526069641113,
0.3802112936973572,
-0.215768963098526,
0.846932053565979,
0.5966380834579468,
0.2013753354549408,
-0.23167404532432556,
-0.9472926259040833,
0.1798807978630066,
0.5846527814865112,
-0.6243285536766052,
0.02538844756782055,
0.31040701270103455,
0.010987533256411552,
0.07736670970916748,
0.3793627619743347,
-0.17996393144130707,
0.13623660802841187,
-0.3893713653087616,
-0.005433083511888981,
-0.4790004789829254,
-0.016600338742136955,
-0.46464601159095764,
-0.20314505696296692,
-0.038892313838005066,
-0.19766929745674133
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11335v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11335v1
|
ConvSDG: Session Data Generation for Conversational Search
| 2024-03-17T20:34:40 | 2024-03-17T20:34:40 |
Fengran Mo, Bole Yi, Kelong Mao, Chen Qu, Kaiyu Huang, Jian-Yun Nie
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
Conversational search provides a more convenient interface for users to
search by allowing multi-turn interaction with the search engine. However, the
effectiveness of the conversational dense retrieval methods is limited by the
scarcity of training data required for their fine-tuning. Thus, generating more
training conversational sessions with relevant labels could potentially improve
search performance. Based on the promising capabilities of large language
models (LLMs) on text generation, we propose ConvSDG, a simple yet effective
framework to explore the feasibility of boosting conversational search by using
LLM for session data generation. Within this framework, we design
dialogue/session-level and query-level data generation with unsupervised and
semi-supervised learning, according to the availability of relevance judgments.
The generated data are used to fine-tune the conversational dense retriever.
Extensive experiments on four widely used datasets demonstrate the
effectiveness and broad applicability of our ConvSDG framework compared with
several strong baselines.
|
[
-0.44645485281944275,
-0.9629538655281067,
0.5849931836128235,
-0.21798652410507202,
-0.3455374836921692,
0.06928029656410217,
-0.4579748213291168,
-0.057086020708084106,
0.17061981558799744,
0.5720648765563965,
-0.7047179937362671,
-0.6781589388847351,
-0.060108501464128494,
-0.18248683214187622,
-0.4641265571117401,
0.6918728351593018,
0.5845510363578796,
0.0591295063495636,
-0.44239628314971924,
0.08315316587686539,
-0.7430887818336487,
-0.5833112001419067,
-0.9248440265655518,
-0.19034811854362488,
0.24507953226566315,
0.8373684287071228,
0.7107987403869629,
0.4485234320163727,
0.41126471757888794,
0.2169952392578125,
-0.08227609843015671,
0.5208442211151123,
-0.9908680319786072,
0.5462598204612732,
-0.03508002683520317,
-0.45482903718948364,
-0.04706208407878876,
-0.25927141308784485,
0.515821099281311,
0.8223102688789368,
-0.621083676815033,
-0.23235563933849335,
0.04357217997312546,
0.6451565027236938,
-0.29770511388778687,
0.08773382008075714,
-1.0951381921768188,
-0.04617271199822426,
-0.24858729541301727,
-0.48908665776252747,
-0.43974769115448,
-0.1895391345024109,
0.4095800817012787,
-0.49347954988479614,
0.7298781275749207,
0.23443518579006195,
0.5169728994369507,
0.11360947787761688,
-0.6104249954223633,
-0.2423446625471115,
-0.6220698356628418,
0.6919779777526855,
-0.6685441136360168,
0.4188201129436493,
0.20741797983646393,
0.2947971522808075,
-0.5897679328918457,
-0.9064767956733704,
-0.43952447175979614,
-0.2802968919277191,
-0.16813942790031433,
-0.0420030914247036,
0.0003436068363953382,
0.42223426699638367,
0.3609584867954254,
0.40697064995765686,
-0.7035528421401978,
0.18981721997261047,
-0.1848692148923874,
0.15282593667507172,
0.7765994668006897,
0.3111066520214081,
0.1838604062795639,
-0.11800097674131393,
-0.3563627004623413,
-0.09244663268327713,
-0.8745051026344299,
0.06299617886543274,
0.042288001626729965,
0.6477529406547546,
0.11556708812713623,
0.5121675729751587,
-0.5050764083862305,
0.8764395117759705,
0.30546966195106506,
-0.05971650406718254,
-0.05410126596689224,
-0.5058300495147705,
-0.0348605178296566,
0.2853144109249115,
0.7791265249252319,
0.7723757028579712,
0.0485326312482357,
-0.3535962402820587,
-0.20011359453201294,
-0.23463261127471924,
0.43162739276885986,
-1.1285526752471924,
-0.10916955024003983,
-0.015500379726290703,
-0.41220033168792725,
-0.3971543312072754,
0.03336869552731514,
-0.7186936736106873,
-0.2756314277648926,
-0.5307313203811646,
-0.055152274668216705,
-0.2231544405221939,
0.0023927856236696243,
0.2384365350008011,
-0.02148004062473774,
0.07646020501852036,
0.17155054211616516,
-1.0556391477584839,
0.214918851852417,
0.44205227494239807,
0.667913556098938,
-0.587441086769104,
0.3955139219760895,
-0.8770460486412048,
0.13176333904266357,
-0.2202933132648468,
0.5495743155479431,
-0.8896714448928833,
-0.7587486505508423,
0.3723854720592499,
0.0024124551564455032,
0.1283024102449417,
-0.6982455849647522,
0.3787734806537628,
-0.6185945272445679,
0.24537838995456696,
-0.25322866439819336,
-0.7469755411148071,
-0.03217501565814018,
0.24595625698566437,
-0.4191647171974182,
1.2000123262405396,
0.01111047063022852,
-0.48925384879112244,
0.5451087355613708,
-0.3341200649738312,
-0.48210659623146057,
0.6146705746650696,
-0.5785423517227173,
-0.6193247437477112,
0.14753153920173645,
0.30439493060112,
0.721498429775238,
-0.5369821786880493,
0.844548761844635,
-0.3990402817726135,
-0.4427539110183716,
0.31421005725860596,
-0.22684206068515778,
0.15024152398109436,
0.21811120212078094,
-0.14640595018863678,
-0.11045418679714203,
-0.8226111531257629,
0.1184190884232521,
-0.028979849070310593,
-0.5523404479026794,
-0.3940037190914154,
0.2717541456222534,
0.13470450043678284,
-0.060317691415548325,
0.16710864007472992,
-0.5298246145248413,
0.26037314534187317,
-0.42198264598846436,
0.39214518666267395,
0.3792061507701874,
0.4087674617767334,
0.3979339897632599,
-0.12941913306713104,
0.5111910104751587,
-0.04222831875085831,
-0.1880692094564438,
-0.3395380675792694,
-0.1119430661201477,
-0.7112317681312561,
0.1570020318031311,
0.28702351450920105,
0.17459970712661743,
-1.0522927045822144,
0.5131617188453674,
-0.2827002704143524,
-0.6119653582572937,
-0.08888421207666397,
0.07198501378297806,
0.39675718545913696,
0.4352096915245056,
0.11469650268554688,
-0.38805466890335083,
-0.5974089503288269,
-0.7753996253013611,
-0.00019212637562304735,
0.14801599085330963,
-0.1343209147453308,
1.020776391029358,
-0.03304401412606239,
-0.3247376084327698,
0.8900934457778931,
-0.7230771780014038,
-0.1860090047121048,
-0.14265096187591553,
-0.010393807664513588,
0.037387214601039886,
0.4830501675605774,
0.4999721348285675,
-0.9643043875694275,
-0.4728202819824219,
0.007205558009445667,
-0.6676880121231079,
0.07369901239871979,
-0.1296893209218979,
-0.15422423183918,
-0.04568381607532501,
0.8441532850265503,
-0.5327138304710388,
0.12176795303821564,
0.3090231418609619,
0.07162385433912277,
0.10364633053541183,
-0.3199789822101593,
0.08295528590679169,
-1.1601113080978394,
-0.041794776916503906,
0.2061009258031845,
-0.500850260257721,
-0.6112308502197266,
-0.16402508318424225,
-0.24169956147670746,
-0.5859817266464233,
-0.434287965297699,
0.4555544853210449,
-0.1925119012594223,
0.17458127439022064,
-0.23614217340946198,
0.44236016273498535,
-0.25753071904182434,
0.4872114658355713,
0.10032188892364502,
0.8944647312164307,
0.7466945648193359,
-1.0300054550170898,
0.4462900161743164,
0.37268906831741333,
-0.35323697328567505,
0.4424532949924469,
-0.7447655200958252,
0.25517067313194275,
-0.037774715572595596,
0.20730046927928925,
-1.1492706537246704,
-0.3449225425720215,
-0.45811727643013,
-0.23846329748630524,
0.435221403837204,
-0.20270229876041412,
-0.40493127703666687,
-0.25757160782814026,
-0.18193554878234863,
0.4849696159362793,
0.2788563072681427,
-0.8859976530075073,
0.004349471069872379,
0.7242515087127686,
-0.1072821393609047,
-0.13747051358222961,
-0.20529018342494965,
0.14767640829086304,
-0.414483904838562,
-0.6400073766708374,
0.5771139860153198,
-0.007667549420148134,
0.03840944543480873,
-0.6165822744369507,
-0.0780952200293541,
0.2801128029823303,
0.04653282091021538,
0.0341036282479763,
-0.04309636726975441,
-0.11544841527938843,
0.45086929202079773,
-0.04450702667236328,
-0.02340206690132618,
-0.13736121356487274,
-0.28583890199661255,
0.7936841249465942,
0.10534325987100601,
-0.2029065042734146,
-0.0487789511680603,
0.3194938600063324,
0.28914350271224976,
-0.10631053894758224,
0.37734314799308777,
0.36737531423568726,
-0.2847220003604889,
-0.3237650990486145,
-0.5098323225975037,
-0.49663254618644714,
-0.526360273361206,
0.2510199248790741,
-0.1629588007926941,
-1.3354164361953735,
0.15372046828269958,
-0.3720752000808716,
-0.1869974434375763,
-0.04941845312714577,
0.6806915998458862,
-0.17582523822784424,
1.374228596687317,
0.6910615563392639,
0.2895970344543457,
0.7066440582275391,
-0.11715298146009445,
0.37017425894737244,
-0.46617671847343445,
-0.45661941170692444,
-0.4839974045753479,
-0.30298832058906555,
-1.2402924299240112,
-0.16569910943508148,
0.4729286730289459,
-0.017355700954794884,
0.10177869349718094,
0.13852697610855103,
-0.7652258276939392,
0.36378568410873413,
0.6808835864067078,
0.3461747467517853,
0.13242170214653015,
0.18100275099277496,
0.05108025670051575,
-0.3826473653316498,
-0.806379497051239,
-0.40840399265289307,
1.0745891332626343,
-0.2029755562543869,
0.8521382808685303,
-0.12129893153905869,
0.4604339599609375,
0.43704792857170105,
-0.21934126317501068,
-0.7053394913673401,
0.7056070566177368,
-0.2201656997203827,
-0.5742663741111755,
-0.22291144728660583,
-0.5525290966033936,
-1.3853280544281006,
0.09295535832643509,
-0.22893869876861572,
-0.6793415546417236,
0.1025402620434761,
0.08820441365242004,
-0.3030034303665161,
-0.1411898136138916,
-0.5954848527908325,
0.7127217054367065,
-0.3642696440219879,
-0.3947288990020752,
-0.33058038353919983,
-0.47518450021743774,
0.3378083407878876,
0.04724820703268051,
-0.2665160894393921,
-0.024241019040346146,
0.28664082288742065,
0.7929680347442627,
-0.3883674144744873,
0.6043587923049927,
-0.2396898865699768,
0.14961017668247223,
0.43899884819984436,
0.1625538468360901,
0.6233019828796387,
0.5023695826530457,
0.11874152719974518,
-0.2447538524866104,
-0.05439651012420654,
-0.15028053522109985,
-0.5012332797050476,
0.8717315793037415,
-0.3546972870826721,
-0.5913977026939392,
-0.13129597902297974,
-0.4145084321498871,
-0.4509516656398773,
0.19452761113643646,
0.20444577932357788,
0.4669216573238373,
-0.4897141754627228,
0.8446481823921204,
1.0008355379104614,
-0.3245336711406708,
0.17797881364822388,
0.6891549229621887,
-0.3601047396659851,
-0.03876718133687973,
0.966446578502655,
-0.16712118685245514,
0.01800258830189705,
0.5357505083084106,
0.04030628129839897,
-0.35404521226882935,
-0.5464680194854736,
-0.11944865435361862,
0.005643962882459164,
-0.24755193293094635,
-0.4585810601711273,
-0.5621511936187744,
-0.16871844232082367,
-0.19841565191745758,
-0.1082351952791214,
-0.2743399739265442,
-0.1359102427959442,
-0.39860519766807556,
-0.2172771543264389,
0.48238521814346313,
0.36550799012184143,
0.2759251594543457,
0.8305624723434448,
-0.5842751860618591,
0.2441592663526535,
0.4203140437602997,
0.247186541557312,
-0.31870174407958984,
-0.18687881529331207,
-0.354645311832428,
0.3219893276691437,
-0.6159751415252686,
-0.35473474860191345,
0.47828221321105957,
0.13407376408576965,
0.44922399520874023,
0.5222870111465454,
0.021798426285386086,
0.57149338722229,
-0.3113354444503784,
0.8887935876846313,
0.3267183005809784,
-0.4406132102012634,
0.7722383141517639,
-0.6109333634376526,
-0.0012785675935447216,
0.6460037231445312,
0.11113253235816956,
-0.714455246925354,
-0.16092745959758759,
-0.8941255211830139,
-0.9468500018119812,
0.8953545093536377,
0.260591596364975,
0.3065694570541382,
-0.16581642627716064,
0.5741719603538513,
0.14601749181747437,
0.4765910804271698,
-0.29011496901512146,
-0.13185915350914001,
0.23256957530975342,
0.06324288994073868,
-0.04075475409626961,
-0.29461240768432617,
0.005637459456920624,
-0.15076331794261932,
0.5651378035545349,
-0.38925066590309143,
0.10620765388011932,
-0.13160456717014313,
0.2668353319168091,
0.004196178168058395,
0.11419535428285599,
0.2055007368326187,
0.5011188387870789,
-0.2782922089099884,
0.03891749307513237,
0.1279682070016861,
-0.1262674331665039,
-0.006393054034560919,
0.09590979665517807,
-0.3618944585323334,
0.08496048301458359,
-0.2834436595439911,
0.8759347200393677,
0.3286460340023041,
-0.9855597615242004,
0.5027520656585693,
-0.5351880788803101,
-0.08372737467288971,
-0.1179523766040802,
0.5166686773300171,
0.07387178391218185,
0.0671793669462204,
0.2858622670173645,
-0.2940206527709961,
0.3091851770877838,
-0.3949989378452301,
0.3790533244609833,
0.8756688833236694,
-0.3961776793003082,
0.07850039005279541,
0.7013425827026367,
0.37022048234939575,
-0.39570751786231995,
0.691521167755127,
-0.14228804409503937,
-0.1278199851512909,
0.3350149989128113,
0.43364793062210083,
0.5954428315162659,
0.019612494856119156,
0.13419370353221893,
0.5196468830108643,
-0.2131696492433548,
-0.26055413484573364,
0.10635963082313538,
-0.3894891142845154,
-0.5711590051651001,
-0.17629656195640564,
-0.5501898527145386,
-0.4824177026748657,
0.5429607629776001,
-0.6539716720581055,
0.5185907483100891,
-0.056679144501686096,
-0.25522735714912415,
-0.04276037961244583,
0.19772844016551971,
-0.8683341145515442,
0.34364187717437744,
0.15335401892662048,
0.5227704644203186,
-0.30457982420921326,
0.5877508521080017,
0.47694671154022217,
-0.20769503712654114,
-0.45119208097457886,
-0.10907924175262451,
-0.3451732099056244,
-0.7537899613380432,
0.15151621401309967,
0.26841336488723755,
-0.0191482100635767,
-0.016934437677264214,
-0.9731137156486511,
-0.7336545586585999,
1.125485897064209,
0.4705447256565094,
-0.987967312335968,
-0.20086105167865753,
0.2175094038248062,
0.5841424465179443,
-0.4623280167579651,
0.019969254732131958,
0.7265526056289673,
0.09355586022138596,
0.25510740280151367,
-0.6699506044387817,
0.046793024986982346,
-0.01106447633355856,
0.5269006490707397,
0.0248099472373724,
-0.7375652194023132,
0.2951904833316803,
0.16855736076831818,
-0.33299142122268677,
-0.10278002917766571,
0.6201578378677368,
0.32752811908721924,
0.33284375071525574,
0.21568135917186737,
0.4951726198196411,
0.8877231478691101,
-0.281911700963974,
0.9034393429756165,
-0.3342663645744324,
0.3381309509277344,
0.9051037430763245,
-0.21837002038955688,
0.45312750339508057,
0.3317415416240692,
0.021539416164159775,
-0.043969493359327316,
0.7883385419845581,
0.016929935663938522,
0.6738561391830444,
0.28303995728492737,
-0.35311514139175415,
-0.5984201431274414,
-0.38556817173957825,
-0.227827250957489,
0.6026732325553894,
0.5133815407752991,
-0.3823596239089966,
-0.2898715138435364,
0.1275070160627365,
0.017755696550011635,
0.20425602793693542,
-0.04367441684007645,
1.0672510862350464,
0.02013472467660904,
-1.0166465044021606,
0.7487629055976868,
0.11221980303525925,
0.6909164190292358,
-0.39125609397888184,
-0.04687126725912094,
-0.43702247738838196,
0.35053086280822754,
-0.15012770891189575,
-0.7033383846282959,
-0.1849660575389862,
-0.13770577311515808,
-0.02566109038889408,
-0.3514848053455353,
0.8256235122680664,
-0.7354799509048462,
-0.3395437002182007,
0.026807868853211403,
0.6295613050460815,
0.2783723771572113,
-0.1324351280927658,
-0.5218939185142517,
-0.16035276651382446,
0.32643812894821167,
-0.1453988254070282,
0.4576462507247925,
0.6653876900672913,
0.023871079087257385,
0.5866917371749878,
0.6229774951934814,
-0.1897198110818863,
-0.052836935967206955,
0.10173743963241577,
0.9092251658439636,
-0.528879702091217,
-0.26039919257164,
-0.6492379903793335,
0.11708222329616547,
-0.1442350596189499,
-0.19942337274551392,
0.6438075304031372,
1.0110435485839844,
1.001529574394226,
0.3211677372455597,
0.959784746170044,
-0.005396695341914892,
0.4875762462615967,
-0.6648250818252563,
0.4166288673877716,
-0.5359817743301392,
0.25419148802757263,
0.02916789799928665,
-0.8754737973213196,
-0.10405245423316956,
0.415365070104599,
-0.029315311461687088,
0.11701197922229767,
0.337973028421402,
1.1857566833496094,
-0.3044435679912567,
0.11352216452360153,
0.30895140767097473,
-0.03990953788161278,
0.8412476778030396,
0.512797474861145,
0.5977069735527039,
-0.3307954967021942,
0.6215739846229553,
0.0949370414018631,
0.014389310963451862,
-0.5869957208633423,
-0.5518319010734558,
-1.0615867376327515,
-0.7058966755867004,
-0.31161758303642273,
-0.38962721824645996,
-0.05839046090841293,
0.7605068683624268,
0.81712406873703,
-0.48913413286209106,
-0.1817595511674881,
-0.4516390264034271,
-0.12527374923229218,
0.20912660658359528,
-0.23290234804153442,
0.2297760397195816,
-0.5934662222862244,
-0.7009643912315369,
0.6324445605278015,
0.08917409926652908,
-0.027447432279586792,
-0.23452787101268768,
-0.16653499007225037,
-0.1644306182861328,
-0.08016227185726166,
0.5505298972129822,
0.11945624649524689,
-0.1718209832906723,
-0.17564603686332703,
0.031402382999658585,
-0.2980690896511078,
0.20956073701381683,
1.097493290901184,
-0.9620299339294434,
0.7979739904403687,
0.2738467752933502,
0.6337515115737915,
1.2185574769973755,
0.15945349633693695,
0.7613166570663452,
-1.2969332933425903,
0.04402875527739525,
0.25861385464668274,
0.1259639710187912,
0.5012359023094177,
-0.44237756729125977,
0.43767043948173523,
0.051663193851709366,
-0.6475685238838196,
-0.9038348197937012,
0.1157211884856224,
-1.0901483297348022,
-0.09783101081848145,
1.44524347782135,
0.4385950267314911,
0.20560073852539062,
0.11460941284894943,
-0.5169410109519958,
0.2518344819545746,
-0.6972365379333496,
0.9681267142295837,
0.5408987402915955,
-0.2508312463760376,
-0.004251551348716021,
-0.5154007077217102,
0.8468348979949951,
0.24559286236763,
-0.7553326487541199,
0.2957744002342224,
0.6148640513420105,
0.029222121462225914,
-0.0765790045261383,
0.648998498916626,
0.11865247786045074,
0.2310337871313095,
-0.2809178829193115,
-0.1530144363641739,
0.22301404178142548,
-0.06830821931362152,
0.07530546933412552,
0.10846676677465439,
0.03254907950758934,
-0.13563409447669983
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11330v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11330v2
|
Improving Dialogue Agents by Decomposing One Global Explicit Annotation with Local Implicit Multimodal Feedback
| 2024-03-17T20:21:26 | 2024-04-23T03:17:07 |
Dong Won Lee, Hae Won Park, Yoon Kim, Cynthia Breazeal, Louis-Philippe Morency
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC, cs.LG
|
We describe an approach for aligning an LLM-based dialogue agent based on
global (i.e., dialogue-level) rewards, while also taking into account
naturally-occurring multimodal signals. At a high level, our approach (dubbed
GELI) learns a local, turn-level reward model by decomposing the human-provided
Global Explicit (GE) session-level reward, using Local Implicit (LI) multimodal
reward signals to crossmodally shape the reward decomposition step. This
decomposed reward model is then used as part of the standard RHLF pipeline
improve an LLM-based dialog agent. We run quantitative and qualitative human
studies to evaluate the performance of our GELI approach, and find that it
shows consistent improvements across various conversational metrics compared to
baseline methods.
|
[
-0.3825119137763977,
-0.690224826335907,
0.460794061422348,
-0.15888342261314392,
0.09664700925350189,
0.37965479493141174,
-0.2729911208152771,
-0.480703741312027,
0.2491985708475113,
0.2780163884162903,
-0.8974481821060181,
-0.4923282265663147,
-0.3159266710281372,
0.0885896161198616,
0.311296284198761,
1.0118272304534912,
0.04596598818898201,
0.2613009214401245,
-0.25970983505249023,
-0.3538936972618103,
-0.5353187918663025,
-0.3826591670513153,
-0.8959585428237915,
-0.4667055904865265,
0.9626138210296631,
0.5402950048446655,
0.6336777210235596,
0.1645585149526596,
0.18245361745357513,
0.4123404622077942,
-0.09736360609531403,
0.4834083318710327,
-0.9269514083862305,
0.3591839373111725,
0.1656365841627121,
-0.5304091572761536,
-0.6992185115814209,
0.02052045427262783,
0.6490501761436462,
0.44209903478622437,
-0.4957064390182495,
-0.09373166412115097,
-0.07428571581840515,
0.35578539967536926,
-0.6295984983444214,
0.47497206926345825,
-0.306985467672348,
0.1264582872390747,
0.40058475732803345,
-0.46527865529060364,
-0.5780937075614929,
-0.3934820592403412,
0.10148712247610092,
-0.6359577178955078,
0.11256441473960876,
-0.061005059629678726,
0.5349094867706299,
0.15575508773326874,
-0.5350767970085144,
-0.12487625330686569,
-0.7307451367378235,
0.7879089713096619,
-0.715700089931488,
0.04890431836247444,
0.0998079925775528,
0.3720915913581848,
-0.144302099943161,
-0.2565467655658722,
-0.3390376567840576,
-0.468143492937088,
-0.261214941740036,
0.23858247697353363,
0.023855717852711678,
0.32200413942337036,
0.13933277130126953,
0.34603896737098694,
-0.2553116977214813,
0.12151084095239639,
-0.23571452498435974,
-0.39337438344955444,
0.6212249398231506,
0.4270159602165222,
0.3968316912651062,
0.18773415684700012,
-0.536588728427887,
-0.27664265036582947,
-0.8036067485809326,
0.44070151448249817,
0.382468044757843,
0.4534786641597748,
-0.20204055309295654,
0.25380393862724304,
-0.20438531041145325,
0.49946561455726624,
0.08122561126947403,
-0.5571280717849731,
0.3777574598789215,
-0.6041010022163391,
0.09767390787601471,
0.2923380732536316,
0.4565027952194214,
0.6419061422348022,
0.1907106339931488,
-0.19680723547935486,
-0.3779946267604828,
-0.08481772989034653,
0.27694377303123474,
-0.7531460523605347,
0.22606094181537628,
0.1648297756910324,
-0.3826583921909332,
-0.3408024311065674,
-0.04004887491464615,
-0.41554248332977295,
-0.6429024338722229,
-0.37916505336761475,
0.4645290672779083,
-0.17881552875041962,
-0.33916786313056946,
-0.22044841945171356,
-0.1055402010679245,
0.4023738205432892,
0.6243945360183716,
-1.0551714897155762,
0.2553045451641083,
0.6309716105461121,
0.724256157875061,
0.08540526032447815,
-0.1803409308195114,
-0.8255035877227783,
0.3047211468219757,
-0.29949378967285156,
0.9036096930503845,
-0.5735746622085571,
-0.5047687292098999,
0.22335435450077057,
0.05627007037401199,
-0.25719544291496277,
-0.6378268599510193,
0.4244706332683563,
-0.13299138844013214,
0.40465372800827026,
-0.2869163453578949,
-0.32746461033821106,
-0.06341896951198578,
0.40565016865730286,
-0.6514483690261841,
0.7537738084793091,
0.14370237290859222,
-0.6067487597465515,
0.2150665670633316,
-0.8921837210655212,
-0.1279865801334381,
-0.13429155945777893,
-0.016750847920775414,
-0.11091454327106476,
-0.001226260676048696,
0.5340467691421509,
0.19756464660167694,
-0.10532346367835999,
0.33856937289237976,
-0.11184536665678024,
-0.6414341926574707,
0.2783437669277191,
-0.535072386264801,
0.353809654712677,
0.0931982547044754,
-0.3248262107372284,
0.7335280776023865,
-0.5466306805610657,
0.003256800351664424,
-0.1891365647315979,
-0.35137754678726196,
0.19677628576755524,
-0.13865350186824799,
-0.047185271978378296,
-0.014495864510536194,
-0.029358578845858574,
-0.7222905158996582,
0.37118884921073914,
-0.5410898923873901,
0.3986979126930237,
1.031564712524414,
0.045942626893520355,
0.6033585071563721,
-0.5247925519943237,
0.5856682062149048,
0.10874994844198227,
0.2913888394832611,
-0.4089600741863251,
-0.3697036802768707,
-0.928399384021759,
-0.5098756551742554,
0.1585914045572281,
0.5849835276603699,
-0.7035421133041382,
-0.00838708970695734,
-0.4258217513561249,
-0.3992628753185272,
-0.7528270483016968,
0.10546627640724182,
0.4216545522212982,
0.376992404460907,
0.09064505249261856,
-0.3498903810977936,
-0.06920856237411499,
-1.0555921792984009,
0.058909740298986435,
-0.2531074285507202,
-0.08551667630672455,
0.534180223941803,
0.1156320720911026,
-0.37065204977989197,
0.7880198955535889,
-0.21540763974189758,
-0.29534438252449036,
-0.4455220401287079,
0.623476505279541,
0.07590842992067337,
0.35187405347824097,
0.030962908640503883,
-0.564986526966095,
-0.3757917881011963,
0.09653119742870331,
-0.5810278058052063,
-0.1033867746591568,
-0.18726719915866852,
-0.024861255660653114,
0.45305705070495605,
0.36927780508995056,
-0.7380049824714661,
0.3989512324333191,
0.17294219136238098,
-0.38819366693496704,
0.22468644380569458,
-0.27390486001968384,
0.5980703830718994,
-0.7166942358016968,
-0.13970881700515747,
-0.05510232225060463,
-0.37826335430145264,
-0.6918761730194092,
-0.38238611817359924,
-0.23739132285118103,
-0.19144369661808014,
-0.5335221290588379,
0.6643567681312561,
-0.499662309885025,
-0.06462996453046799,
-0.34207963943481445,
0.21752706170082092,
-0.22700947523117065,
1.0281835794448853,
0.0353071466088295,
0.9120599031448364,
0.34706491231918335,
-0.30721524357795715,
0.6139225959777832,
0.16056910157203674,
-0.21793971955776215,
0.6094093918800354,
-0.6177592277526855,
0.26549163460731506,
-0.40452519059181213,
0.5432644486427307,
-1.2127488851547241,
-0.181532621383667,
0.590864360332489,
-0.30143973231315613,
0.3975240886211395,
-0.029625628143548965,
-0.18437938392162323,
0.17732372879981995,
-0.5537717938423157,
0.43592873215675354,
0.22541062533855438,
-0.5143361687660217,
0.8708369731903076,
0.23261758685112,
-0.5321922302246094,
-0.7106231451034546,
-0.18193753063678741,
0.08094540238380432,
-0.1758577674627304,
-0.7815377712249756,
0.35463806986808777,
-0.2457224279642105,
-0.23000185191631317,
-0.26621055603027344,
-0.13190436363220215,
0.24096417427062988,
-0.11045901477336884,
0.35741907358169556,
0.18458892405033112,
-0.1745532900094986,
0.11414409428834915,
-0.21552997827529907,
-0.460075706243515,
0.032829295843839645,
0.2120526283979416,
0.41738706827163696,
-0.44574373960494995,
-0.40583011507987976,
-0.5643895864486694,
0.508591890335083,
0.4479846656322479,
-0.08201298117637634,
0.5617204308509827,
0.9919074177742004,
0.022046104073524475,
0.02634885348379612,
-0.6143003702163696,
-0.4001867473125458,
-0.47300368547439575,
0.13240580260753632,
-0.27656176686286926,
-1.0502374172210693,
0.46797341108322144,
-0.13254763185977936,
-0.00941724143922329,
-0.031431496143341064,
0.619263768196106,
0.06712167710065842,
1.2880679368972778,
0.5742017030715942,
-0.19016733765602112,
0.5691666007041931,
-0.3599737286567688,
0.23216815292835236,
-0.7375122308731079,
-0.5248631238937378,
-0.1618584841489792,
-0.48396825790405273,
-0.3093429207801819,
-0.3644334077835083,
0.38682588934898376,
-0.131243497133255,
-0.2634950876235962,
-0.1504916101694107,
-0.20137280225753784,
0.3952156901359558,
0.7582900524139404,
0.30210381746292114,
0.18920405209064484,
0.012820644304156303,
0.05311562493443489,
0.1442621797323227,
-0.7767220735549927,
-0.5408236384391785,
0.6747546792030334,
0.5098552107810974,
0.9140435457229614,
0.22132892906665802,
0.6442174315452576,
0.4287593960762024,
0.5525184273719788,
-0.5620671510696411,
0.48113778233528137,
0.6060459613800049,
-0.2760576903820038,
-0.5622000098228455,
-0.4563641846179962,
-1.0786144733428955,
0.3621971309185028,
-0.27026987075805664,
-1.0510649681091309,
0.16451434791088104,
0.06754632294178009,
-0.33495616912841797,
0.08986921608448029,
-0.9911632537841797,
1.1145853996276855,
-0.12990529835224152,
-0.3939721882343292,
-0.4678080976009369,
-0.7939205765724182,
0.20526134967803955,
0.5885893106460571,
0.2631061375141144,
-0.3742462396621704,
0.11344178020954132,
0.4230419397354126,
-0.4234204888343811,
1.149055004119873,
-0.469332754611969,
-0.5245616436004639,
0.34653887152671814,
-0.052319057285785675,
0.462899386882782,
0.31337231397628784,
0.26135432720184326,
-0.05742096155881882,
-0.11753468960523605,
-0.5681880712509155,
-1.117790699005127,
0.49074551463127136,
-0.7637747526168823,
-0.8943626880645752,
-0.15524813532829285,
-0.7935245633125305,
-0.3576968014240265,
-0.3806399703025818,
-0.10959336906671524,
0.823502242565155,
-0.281859427690506,
-0.23642319440841675,
0.6662853360176086,
-0.18982532620429993,
0.42592304944992065,
0.49379539489746094,
-0.026445481926202774,
-0.6725289821624756,
0.894841194152832,
-0.44195863604545593,
0.47955968976020813,
0.6186475157737732,
-0.019728783518075943,
-0.37823083996772766,
-0.030733158811926842,
-0.31358808279037476,
0.2039363533258438,
-0.9887642860412598,
-0.19219352304935455,
-0.11118500679731369,
-0.04324718192219734,
-0.4646371901035309,
-0.09565012156963348,
-0.0780123695731163,
-0.22376053035259247,
0.05107785761356354,
-0.23477120697498322,
0.15749579668045044,
0.8606899976730347,
-0.17628662288188934,
0.37608063220977783,
-0.8031083941459656,
0.17877666652202606,
0.5688119530677795,
0.15187036991119385,
0.052358198910951614,
-0.30585572123527527,
-0.3317260444164276,
0.37209179997444153,
-0.13283030688762665,
-0.6911435127258301,
0.29174476861953735,
0.15434382855892181,
0.8517699837684631,
0.34986791014671326,
-0.07013522833585739,
0.5914630889892578,
-0.24398985505104065,
0.7991623282432556,
0.3944925367832184,
-0.8155390024185181,
0.5466498136520386,
-0.3629292845726013,
0.37474095821380615,
0.357132226228714,
0.11163162440061569,
-0.6795496940612793,
-0.41367143392562866,
-0.34538009762763977,
-0.776327908039093,
0.9050731658935547,
0.0603342205286026,
0.23865075409412384,
0.16370174288749695,
0.23365594446659088,
0.04471224546432495,
0.11533927917480469,
-1.0413947105407715,
-0.20144206285476685,
-0.10088729113340378,
-0.2796921730041504,
-0.1549687534570694,
-0.4422627389431,
-0.6527824401855469,
-0.1189480796456337,
0.6897698640823364,
-0.45812729001045227,
0.5602232217788696,
0.3193676471710205,
-0.3093460500240326,
-0.1311500370502472,
0.5682003498077393,
0.8719863295555115,
0.7002251744270325,
-0.3297904133796692,
0.016690559685230255,
0.21315178275108337,
0.06437196582555771,
0.3436036705970764,
-0.21023865044116974,
0.22566254436969757,
-0.1766471415758133,
0.47587570548057556,
1.1278849840164185,
0.392657607793808,
-0.7906330227851868,
0.5237050652503967,
-0.3136129379272461,
-0.021847542375326157,
0.022120336070656776,
0.31144145131111145,
-0.00693804444745183,
0.6064268350601196,
0.28177616000175476,
-0.2432735115289688,
0.11880853027105331,
-0.7840789556503296,
-0.005199353210628033,
0.46891042590141296,
-0.569919228553772,
-0.10350663959980011,
0.2795226275920868,
0.5806359052658081,
-0.5084860324859619,
0.6726868152618408,
-0.045744627714157104,
-0.5077348351478577,
0.35210317373275757,
0.44549888372421265,
0.7473031282424927,
-0.06106436625123024,
0.6494653224945068,
0.29840564727783203,
0.03280932083725929,
0.2264956384897232,
0.06431298702955246,
-0.536260187625885,
-0.8365346193313599,
-0.5231380462646484,
-0.15382955968379974,
-0.5367947220802307,
-0.2333366870880127,
-0.4265148639678955,
-0.044978298246860504,
-0.06921451538801193,
-0.10869599133729935,
-0.03331572189927101,
-0.14826537668704987,
-0.48721691966056824,
-0.07132286578416824,
0.5197915434837341,
0.4169052243232727,
-0.5905649662017822,
0.6475846171379089,
0.5554797053337097,
-0.6479436159133911,
-0.7238476872444153,
-0.194924995303154,
-0.011404022574424744,
-0.9353471398353577,
0.8966679573059082,
0.4638961851596832,
-0.4678635597229004,
-0.14917375147342682,
-0.5877208709716797,
-0.7939584255218506,
1.2040157318115234,
0.45356878638267517,
-0.29666444659233093,
-0.054170358926057816,
0.22914016246795654,
0.49124065041542053,
-0.6368284225463867,
0.8652273416519165,
0.30912959575653076,
0.5250687599182129,
0.1171984076499939,
-1.0409537553787231,
0.048749055713415146,
-0.552222728729248,
0.17731909453868866,
0.16023299098014832,
-0.6303852200508118,
0.31358128786087036,
-0.3014073371887207,
-0.38377219438552856,
0.18513622879981995,
0.5820604562759399,
0.08284696191549301,
0.2964598834514618,
0.8051887154579163,
0.41191232204437256,
0.6995830535888672,
-0.12639106810092926,
0.9616143703460693,
-0.2493358850479126,
0.1866578459739685,
0.926862359046936,
-0.28090372681617737,
0.5604185461997986,
0.418488472700119,
0.1860378533601761,
0.8145499229431152,
0.5864049196243286,
0.20456725358963013,
0.5575429797172546,
0.2153770923614502,
-0.5700471997261047,
-0.4703061878681183,
-0.34892961382865906,
-0.14901067316532135,
0.22957530617713928,
0.19949817657470703,
0.09829802066087723,
-0.32016170024871826,
0.10475090891122818,
-0.21141129732131958,
-0.07703664898872375,
-0.3406417965888977,
1.0244518518447876,
-0.12385201454162598,
-0.9964250326156616,
0.7833569049835205,
-0.08596523851156235,
0.4898112714290619,
-0.5442355275154114,
-0.3312244117259979,
-0.5562298893928528,
0.09339549392461777,
-0.1749485433101654,
-0.4054027795791626,
-0.1666596531867981,
-0.3433363437652588,
-0.039379414170980453,
-0.36940038204193115,
0.7364299297332764,
-0.8268296718597412,
-0.1871403604745865,
0.29870450496673584,
0.4336797595024109,
0.05831217020750046,
0.22568096220493317,
-0.5921542644500732,
0.0249186884611845,
-0.026359492912888527,
-0.26533064246177673,
0.24012333154678345,
0.24128597974777222,
0.08637053519487381,
1.0221744775772095,
0.48644641041755676,
-0.2991362512111664,
-0.13805975019931793,
0.6101240515708923,
0.7805257439613342,
-0.8711228966712952,
-0.2397240400314331,
-0.5867279767990112,
0.81196129322052,
-0.1496828943490982,
-0.20225200057029724,
0.5196908712387085,
0.3347950279712677,
0.6500793695449829,
0.011947104707360268,
0.38286012411117554,
0.35436710715293884,
0.3159528374671936,
-0.6834081411361694,
0.2015431523323059,
-0.41246160864830017,
0.35802915692329407,
-0.1645941436290741,
-0.9336991906166077,
0.08378707617521286,
0.624961256980896,
0.03901667892932892,
0.15425410866737366,
0.5788078308105469,
1.1823643445968628,
0.2709857225418091,
0.09932585060596466,
0.3102715015411377,
0.04972192272543907,
0.2644090950489044,
0.6176285147666931,
1.4109407663345337,
-0.060237325727939606,
0.5786206126213074,
-0.04901948571205139,
-0.1587669551372528,
0.04863491281867027,
-0.6443586349487305,
-0.8188271522521973,
-0.3632297217845917,
-0.4350039064884186,
-0.15727290511131287,
0.15811879932880402,
0.9444772005081177,
0.8198861479759216,
-0.7074734568595886,
-0.4728924036026001,
0.20171555876731873,
0.3448087275028229,
-0.19152475893497467,
-0.24188631772994995,
0.03650087118148804,
-0.8464066386222839,
-0.828032910823822,
0.7014424800872803,
0.4730677604675293,
-0.08897756040096283,
-0.42578572034835815,
-0.49990811944007874,
-0.12148615717887878,
0.06735705584287643,
0.5396663546562195,
0.027282267808914185,
-0.9321786165237427,
-0.5133856534957886,
-0.1417059451341629,
-0.0411609448492527,
0.45308202505111694,
1.0603954792022705,
-0.8455860614776611,
0.41157546639442444,
0.2462203949689865,
0.3807518184185028,
0.6504342555999756,
0.21323662996292114,
1.0416566133499146,
-0.8379746675491333,
0.1969883143901825,
0.007283465005457401,
0.3760370910167694,
0.4590686559677124,
-0.2748144567012787,
0.6735290288925171,
0.16225233674049377,
-0.5696443319320679,
-0.7857193350791931,
0.30127906799316406,
-1.0150060653686523,
-0.22283872961997986,
1.0928364992141724,
-0.20850320160388947,
-0.23792003095149994,
0.1085158959031105,
-0.6894691586494446,
0.1521342545747757,
-0.6753972172737122,
0.7616417407989502,
0.5775824785232544,
-0.2605040967464447,
-0.32552027702331543,
-0.06547000259160995,
0.49809378385543823,
0.5404343008995056,
-0.7751657962799072,
0.10188035666942596,
0.6993377208709717,
0.07686571776866913,
0.2693442404270172,
0.99524986743927,
0.00307376473210752,
0.21591807901859283,
-0.001149347284808755,
0.2156553417444229,
-0.004168371669948101,
-0.42752519249916077,
-0.45484021306037903,
0.07988093793392181,
0.2244979441165924,
-0.01234123483300209
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11322v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11322v3
|
StateFlow: Enhancing LLM Task-Solving through State-Driven Workflows
| 2024-03-17T19:54:16 | 2024-04-10T23:04:48 |
Yiran Wu, Tianwei Yue, Shaokun Zhang, Chi Wang, Qingyun Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
It is a notable trend to use Large Language Models (LLMs) to tackle complex
tasks, e.g., tasks that require a sequence of actions and dynamic interaction
with tools and external environments. In this paper, we propose StateFlow, a
novel LLM-based task-solving paradigm that conceptualizes complex task-solving
processes as state machines. In StateFlow, we distinguish between "process
grounding" (via state and state transitions) and "sub-task solving" (through
actions within a state), enhancing control and interpretability of the
task-solving procedure. A state represents the status of a running process. The
transitions between states are controlled by heuristic rules or decisions made
by the LLM, allowing for a dynamic and adaptive progression. Upon entering a
state, a series of actions is executed, involving not only calling LLMs guided
by different prompts, but also the utilization of external tools as needed. Our
results show that StateFlow significantly enhances LLMs' efficiency. For
instance, StateFlow achieves 13% and 28% higher success rates compared to ReAct
in InterCode SQL and ALFWorld benchmark, with 5x and 3x less cost respectively.
We also show that StateFlow can be combined with iterative refining methods
like Reflexion to further improve performance.
|
[
0.06930390000343323,
-0.6666560769081116,
0.8098547458648682,
0.1545661985874176,
-0.15042993426322937,
0.4340503215789795,
-0.12353748828172684,
-0.22469225525856018,
0.1751863807439804,
0.4076753556728363,
-0.8146610856056213,
-0.18704059720039368,
-0.575443685054779,
0.09311875700950623,
-0.427877277135849,
0.5589382648468018,
-0.5470426678657532,
-0.08605292439460754,
-0.412052184343338,
0.19407816231250763,
-0.5240914225578308,
-0.4261171221733093,
-0.5643935203552246,
-0.8280370831489563,
0.3466559648513794,
0.2770557999610901,
0.28946855664253235,
0.4198971688747406,
0.5432280898094177,
0.3168385922908783,
-0.2596823275089264,
0.23784111440181732,
-0.6488726735115051,
0.7328195571899414,
-0.47128844261169434,
-0.832554280757904,
-0.3222472667694092,
-0.49195241928100586,
0.29001298546791077,
0.4405146837234497,
-0.47764331102371216,
0.14311295747756958,
0.1512860804796219,
0.8673592209815979,
-0.7496890425682068,
0.5761740207672119,
-0.5031154751777649,
0.22004620730876923,
-0.32370367646217346,
-0.27759766578674316,
-0.22102005779743195,
-0.0396697036921978,
-0.30182531476020813,
-0.5646774768829346,
-0.24429206550121307,
-0.027841724455356598,
0.363353967666626,
0.7519302368164062,
0.007759881671518087,
-0.08169380575418472,
-1.1079550981521606,
0.3110979199409485,
-0.7149026393890381,
0.25659430027008057,
-0.2857029438018799,
0.11205178499221802,
-0.5644437074661255,
-0.6857211589813232,
-0.6305184960365295,
0.09572379291057587,
0.2705400288105011,
0.17773282527923584,
-0.371160626411438,
0.17353187501430511,
0.5308274626731873,
0.49973610043525696,
-0.2329440414905548,
0.07089893519878387,
-0.1412162035703659,
-0.28065523505210876,
0.25763139128685,
0.6849080324172974,
0.2210133820772171,
0.27851924300193787,
-0.27939149737358093,
0.3050934970378876,
-0.6593040227890015,
0.37634989619255066,
-0.18804097175598145,
0.5639198422431946,
0.22016564011573792,
0.7496119141578674,
-0.5740594863891602,
0.6752623319625854,
-0.056421294808387756,
-0.45280343294143677,
0.09258502721786499,
-0.07203839719295502,
-0.4233770966529846,
-0.1185351088643074,
0.37600377202033997,
-0.010821877047419548,
-0.08626241236925125,
-0.21056656539440155,
-0.5764890909194946,
0.15434587001800537,
0.35162582993507385,
-0.8770425915718079,
0.27497372031211853,
0.3964589536190033,
-0.22934171557426453,
-0.17933283746242523,
-0.2535492777824402,
0.034003861248493195,
-0.683603823184967,
-0.600044846534729,
0.6368844509124756,
-0.17268520593643188,
-0.42397430539131165,
-0.09974755346775055,
0.003959599882364273,
0.10154900699853897,
0.6409516334533691,
-0.28736552596092224,
0.4268399775028229,
1.1694132089614868,
1.0611945390701294,
-0.7218199372291565,
-0.025790903717279434,
-0.7090455293655396,
0.005270818714052439,
-0.5806789994239807,
0.5914524793624878,
-0.6000646352767944,
-0.28216949105262756,
0.16627462208271027,
0.028908800333738327,
0.013835547491908073,
-0.9414117932319641,
0.19876761734485626,
-0.73043292760849,
-0.40416857600212097,
-0.36481642723083496,
-0.6966480016708374,
-0.16734962165355682,
0.36667725443840027,
-0.7480700016021729,
1.2080392837524414,
-0.12901633977890015,
-0.336301326751709,
0.23934273421764374,
-0.9645777940750122,
-0.5512758493423462,
0.31898605823516846,
-0.010328782722353935,
0.017488794401288033,
0.28318318724632263,
-0.2606939673423767,
0.7474026679992676,
-0.40384355187416077,
0.31823447346687317,
-0.09841357916593552,
-0.4418821930885315,
-0.0939297080039978,
0.19136720895767212,
0.33560121059417725,
0.37853074073791504,
-0.4781874120235443,
0.4821505844593048,
-0.4387863278388977,
-0.14673373103141785,
0.07596706598997116,
-0.4489683508872986,
0.03840932250022888,
0.10571794211864471,
-0.31868910789489746,
0.44886621832847595,
0.4435356557369232,
-0.6720919609069824,
0.06096937507390976,
-0.28757917881011963,
0.5937166213989258,
0.5776594877243042,
-0.05278225243091583,
0.4610231816768646,
-0.4089178442955017,
0.7518487572669983,
0.4608006179332733,
-0.12638574838638306,
-0.35721462965011597,
-0.2659258246421814,
-0.7329588532447815,
-0.3297238051891327,
-0.25846654176712036,
0.9504308700561523,
-0.9487439393997192,
0.0496172234416008,
-0.10796268284320831,
-0.5848236680030823,
-0.37406423687934875,
0.2342013716697693,
0.23021836578845978,
0.7542095184326172,
0.31436607241630554,
-0.11893946677446365,
-0.2607730031013489,
-0.7594021558761597,
-0.3162376582622528,
0.09907779842615128,
0.4296890199184418,
0.036819152534008026,
0.6218843460083008,
-0.01554033998399973,
0.8986527323722839,
-0.6319131851196289,
-0.463124543428421,
-0.373290479183197,
0.051012713462114334,
0.5157098770141602,
0.31353631615638733,
-0.35417068004608154,
-0.5990387201309204,
-0.3052181005477905,
-0.12886495888233185,
-0.6388642191886902,
-0.06589565426111221,
-0.030153831467032433,
-0.09921063482761383,
0.5438345074653625,
0.6350643634796143,
-0.649906575679779,
0.3662046492099762,
0.39984795451164246,
-0.2652597725391388,
0.5141008496284485,
-0.24560560286045074,
-0.052764732390642166,
-0.9762088060379028,
0.1367727518081665,
0.07921315729618073,
-0.35356858372688293,
-0.6187024116516113,
0.3491210639476776,
-0.005610673222690821,
-0.5957935452461243,
-0.6466408371925354,
0.38644999265670776,
-0.5436118245124817,
-0.1060553714632988,
-0.6375076174736023,
-0.1281387209892273,
-0.25086653232574463,
0.6037521362304688,
0.15421666204929352,
0.9202957153320312,
0.826258659362793,
-0.41752803325653076,
0.5898483395576477,
-0.30425015091896057,
-0.26801925897598267,
0.6242361068725586,
-0.41464585065841675,
0.16265492141246796,
-0.1013336032629013,
0.34379518032073975,
-0.8385476469993591,
0.1476937234401703,
0.05573273450136185,
0.1315036416053772,
0.13464446365833282,
-0.05808253958821297,
-0.7965991497039795,
-0.356094628572464,
0.07818691432476044,
0.027038566768169403,
0.5839250683784485,
-0.2548391819000244,
0.8906015157699585,
0.2714705467224121,
-0.0891537144780159,
-0.4777103364467621,
-0.489838182926178,
0.2116764336824417,
0.09473749250173569,
-0.38295120000839233,
0.4478071331977844,
0.006598403677344322,
-0.1778811365365982,
0.1398402452468872,
-0.6963237524032593,
-0.1494632363319397,
0.27010852098464966,
0.43276047706604004,
0.04127909988164902,
0.05855296179652214,
0.017605649307370186,
0.12974350154399872,
-0.07059764862060547,
0.17213411629199982,
-0.495402067899704,
0.5688621401786804,
-0.028053762391209602,
-0.35372087359428406,
-0.7235111594200134,
0.4021570086479187,
0.8628538250923157,
-0.4501485824584961,
0.6494975090026855,
0.18431778252124786,
-0.730999231338501,
-0.46093109250068665,
-0.2861294448375702,
-0.28871816396713257,
-0.47181442379951477,
0.24746502935886383,
-0.6682780981063843,
-1.060732126235962,
0.4552568197250366,
-0.652219831943512,
0.3624556064605713,
-0.1261347085237503,
0.9135978817939758,
-0.3083508014678955,
0.612308144569397,
0.6961008906364441,
-0.11178372800350189,
0.39968472719192505,
-0.20250919461250305,
0.24714931845664978,
-0.6046580672264099,
-0.405529648065567,
-0.26550278067588806,
-0.5847560167312622,
-0.3113015592098236,
-0.9829784631729126,
0.3912699520587921,
0.05419166386127472,
-0.10057687759399414,
0.2735340893268585,
-0.3204646706581116,
0.3164498507976532,
0.36332380771636963,
0.07664967328310013,
0.430845707654953,
-0.2379404753446579,
-0.19269172847270966,
0.04023478180170059,
-0.7902783155441284,
-0.30176427960395813,
0.5997528433799744,
0.16166479885578156,
0.9215357303619385,
-0.03352252021431923,
0.9019469618797302,
0.5484579801559448,
0.2809552848339081,
-0.9859886169433594,
0.8339689373970032,
-0.05991501361131668,
-0.5172721147537231,
-0.41000714898109436,
-0.15824119746685028,
-0.8334795236587524,
0.3934265673160553,
-0.35455429553985596,
-0.606976330280304,
-0.2598702013492584,
0.40498214960098267,
-0.15981093049049377,
0.43086811900138855,
-0.16711129248142242,
0.6460879445075989,
0.07266292721033096,
-0.39154189825057983,
-0.6653493046760559,
-0.11829959601163864,
-0.006014629267156124,
0.0711897686123848,
0.1842409372329712,
-0.4033004343509674,
-0.3444385230541229,
0.540072500705719,
-0.8193596601486206,
0.7361676096916199,
-0.4163212180137634,
-0.5911483764648438,
0.16580814123153687,
0.3851364552974701,
0.8491122722625732,
-0.48839735984802246,
0.001467794761992991,
-0.13211074471473694,
-0.08496211469173431,
-0.20757752656936646,
-0.7810837030410767,
0.8179664611816406,
-0.16479092836380005,
-0.8666421175003052,
-0.34570205211639404,
-0.8069705367088318,
-0.20551222562789917,
0.42141398787498474,
-0.28285905718803406,
0.599246621131897,
0.1855318397283554,
-0.15456673502922058,
0.7923468947410583,
0.3104958236217499,
0.5651541352272034,
0.5325186252593994,
-0.26211005449295044,
0.13391759991645813,
0.8112749457359314,
0.10407498478889465,
0.13397005200386047,
0.629582405090332,
0.11164402216672897,
-0.33451613783836365,
-0.5303491353988647,
-0.22742785513401031,
0.14788055419921875,
-0.8178145289421082,
-0.1486051231622696,
-0.2815316617488861,
0.10327433794736862,
0.014514653012156487,
0.0435413233935833,
-0.3427625000476837,
-0.28964096307754517,
-0.2668507695198059,
0.12861619889736176,
0.22181642055511475,
0.5160573124885559,
0.18390600383281708,
-0.05265539139509201,
-0.5321834087371826,
0.37347525358200073,
0.11345893889665604,
0.37430527806282043,
-0.019422587007284164,
-0.2884162366390228,
-0.1681412309408188,
-0.5050597190856934,
-0.15260763466358185,
-0.930732250213623,
0.06431134045124054,
0.1294889748096466,
0.5184640288352966,
0.03073512390255928,
0.09974319487810135,
0.727814257144928,
-0.7984403967857361,
0.6247457265853882,
0.06089708209037781,
-1.083746075630188,
0.5899779796600342,
-0.1419508308172226,
0.4356133043766022,
0.2377825379371643,
0.3968307375907898,
-0.6332018971443176,
-0.696803629398346,
-0.19711220264434814,
-0.8352875113487244,
0.7135503888130188,
0.036555688828229904,
0.010430712252855301,
0.37314969301223755,
0.5362284779548645,
-0.26202723383903503,
0.2509823739528656,
-0.3386875092983246,
-0.36889520287513733,
0.2829449772834778,
-0.26778706908226013,
0.03893473744392395,
0.08648762106895447,
-0.4098164737224579,
-0.04694573953747749,
0.6811923384666443,
-0.2499799132347107,
0.34833192825317383,
0.1357712298631668,
-0.499036967754364,
-0.12423127889633179,
0.3729674816131592,
0.5520201921463013,
0.7509726285934448,
0.37844640016555786,
0.02901386097073555,
0.08279814571142197,
-0.19144660234451294,
0.533805251121521,
0.016520250588655472,
-0.21889103949069977,
-0.2664984464645386,
0.1504560261964798,
0.7747927904129028,
0.1136549785733223,
-0.8968156576156616,
0.20482048392295837,
0.31016507744789124,
-0.20417730510234833,
-0.08729156851768494,
0.57928067445755,
0.38917678594589233,
0.8108128309249878,
0.5314000248908997,
-0.031867336481809616,
0.2643914222717285,
-0.4205907881259918,
-0.1066092997789383,
0.2885708808898926,
-0.4326064884662628,
-0.04429463669657707,
0.682385265827179,
0.4581141769886017,
-0.5611522197723389,
0.329456627368927,
-0.1587173193693161,
-0.4729557931423187,
0.5526131987571716,
0.8289055228233337,
0.7818499207496643,
0.2611723244190216,
-0.09337729960680008,
0.16480106115341187,
0.20776256918907166,
-0.2971425950527191,
0.9368053674697876,
-0.22173342108726501,
-0.6734036207199097,
-0.9479313492774963,
-0.4454438090324402,
-0.6329174041748047,
0.07657134532928467,
-0.6255519390106201,
-0.06871765106916428,
-0.5031363368034363,
-0.11350111663341522,
-0.4163953959941864,
-0.018289029598236084,
-0.4429949223995209,
0.15924924612045288,
0.534342885017395,
1.306441307067871,
-0.792838454246521,
0.7003661394119263,
1.2344481945037842,
0.10047583281993866,
-0.6816110014915466,
0.09506198763847351,
0.2612721621990204,
-0.5166000127792358,
0.8348214626312256,
0.1129644513130188,
-0.5163232684135437,
0.1479354053735733,
-0.13161134719848633,
-0.9392587542533875,
1.2729227542877197,
0.4519891142845154,
-0.7401893734931946,
0.29818403720855713,
-0.09184101223945618,
0.36954063177108765,
-0.19807647168636322,
-0.24195502698421478,
0.563481330871582,
0.24282535910606384,
-0.02536964789032936,
-0.9796596765518188,
0.5018628835678101,
-0.27960139513015747,
0.32497987151145935,
0.5381629467010498,
-0.43431568145751953,
0.47038334608078003,
-0.26632919907569885,
-0.26007935404777527,
-0.23238006234169006,
1.089245080947876,
0.4764220118522644,
0.22953970730304718,
0.917304515838623,
0.8584197163581848,
0.8811197876930237,
-0.24708141386508942,
0.5750914812088013,
-0.45624691247940063,
0.19270797073841095,
0.8473750352859497,
-0.6532357931137085,
0.9720904231071472,
0.5060470700263977,
-0.16147108376026154,
0.7717030048370361,
0.3771841824054718,
0.4648759365081787,
0.3502136170864105,
0.4988618493080139,
-0.42082053422927856,
-0.46043190360069275,
-0.06677272170782089,
0.3347817361354828,
0.18990816175937653,
0.20505326986312866,
0.2387084662914276,
-0.32194963097572327,
0.27228695154190063,
0.21627779304981232,
0.23835991322994232,
-0.6814106106758118,
0.6021198630332947,
0.005955229513347149,
-0.8971161842346191,
0.2864508330821991,
-0.15910668671131134,
0.6694291234016418,
-0.41376009583473206,
-0.088469497859478,
-0.13109026849269867,
0.23894867300987244,
-0.37418442964553833,
-0.8909396529197693,
0.31822526454925537,
0.21599358320236206,
-0.37130486965179443,
-0.6336538791656494,
0.8329095840454102,
-0.25093215703964233,
-0.07094525545835495,
0.18751643598079681,
0.5999821424484253,
0.12984918057918549,
-0.14029909670352936,
-0.7987058162689209,
0.142830953001976,
-0.4201750159263611,
-0.1829485297203064,
0.17824149131774902,
0.21645988523960114,
-0.24211017787456512,
1.1004889011383057,
0.6282514929771423,
0.19222012162208557,
0.03850315511226654,
0.0438220351934433,
0.8090483546257019,
-0.5473170280456543,
-0.6205457448959351,
-0.8297807574272156,
0.48048704862594604,
0.04493201524019241,
0.1058620810508728,
0.15522556006908417,
0.5671026110649109,
0.6547594666481018,
0.01778162270784378,
0.6241757273674011,
-0.4429359436035156,
0.4581765830516815,
-0.6200598478317261,
0.4269077479839325,
-0.6365470290184021,
-0.014907494187355042,
0.025965698063373566,
-0.6908984780311584,
-0.05420322343707085,
0.1805584579706192,
-0.08573789894580841,
-0.27249351143836975,
0.6619154214859009,
0.8525558114051819,
0.2096090018749237,
-0.1675841212272644,
0.2058626413345337,
0.08466410636901855,
0.529105007648468,
0.5271598100662231,
0.7817604541778564,
0.2343406230211258,
0.33872631192207336,
-0.3883437216281891,
-0.32943475246429443,
-0.16435228288173676,
-1.0949829816818237,
-0.5031006932258606,
-0.7576123476028442,
-0.41256025433540344,
-0.23172323405742645,
-0.0936734601855278,
1.1492488384246826,
0.8310320973396301,
-0.6007480025291443,
-0.4632336497306824,
-0.17676226794719696,
0.06311985105276108,
-0.6709927916526794,
-0.15807084739208221,
-0.2953367233276367,
-0.9124665856361389,
-0.620015561580658,
0.6920814514160156,
0.5525911450386047,
-0.4302610456943512,
-0.46706023812294006,
0.004244122188538313,
0.1505858451128006,
0.05733967199921608,
0.7202641367912292,
0.3933477997779846,
-0.856687068939209,
0.29221394658088684,
0.05002576857805252,
-0.03253462165594101,
0.059869393706321716,
1.3284670114517212,
-0.6964414715766907,
0.32249847054481506,
0.5922142267227173,
0.834971010684967,
0.6364173889160156,
-0.10204517841339111,
0.5341219305992126,
-0.37233927845954895,
-0.015272231772542,
0.2794067859649658,
0.41277799010276794,
0.08931813389062881,
-0.3699410855770111,
0.3415554463863373,
0.3459251821041107,
-0.2972797751426697,
-0.7438420057296753,
0.3682416081428528,
-0.8414411544799805,
-0.40965595841407776,
0.8870419263839722,
-0.19540463387966156,
-0.2803419530391693,
0.027548274025321007,
-0.021003277972340584,
0.24337580800056458,
-0.4930986166000366,
0.3885405659675598,
0.5680586695671082,
-0.6992294788360596,
-0.058741193264722824,
-0.4131322503089905,
0.3439774215221405,
0.5281347036361694,
-1.099633812904358,
0.13761495053768158,
0.3002478778362274,
0.4001697897911072,
0.11681902408599854,
0.7492315173149109,
0.10972562432289124,
0.13213105499744415,
-0.56107097864151,
0.09353488683700562,
-0.36351877450942993,
-0.5095757246017456,
-0.46739664673805237,
0.115757517516613,
0.11912959814071655,
-0.1095002070069313
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11317v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11317v1
|
Few-Shot VQA with Frozen LLMs: A Tale of Two Approaches
| 2024-03-17T19:44:05 | 2024-03-17T19:44:05 |
Igor Sterner, Weizhe Lin, Jinghong Chen, Bill Byrne
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Two approaches have emerged to input images into large language models
(LLMs). The first is to caption images into natural language. The second is to
map image feature embeddings into the domain of the LLM and pass the mapped
embeddings directly to the LLM. The majority of recent few-shot multimodal work
reports performance using architectures that employ variations of one of these
two approaches. But they overlook an important comparison between them. We
design a controlled and focused experiment to compare these two approaches to
few-shot visual question answering (VQA) with LLMs. Our findings indicate that
for Flan-T5 XL, a 3B parameter LLM, connecting visual embeddings directly to
the LLM embedding space does not guarantee improved performance over using
image captions. In the zero-shot regime, we find using textual image captions
is better. In the few-shot regimes, how the in-context examples are selected
determines which is better.
|
[
-0.5737259984016418,
-0.8906649351119995,
0.8598744869232178,
-0.1755797564983368,
-0.5546050667762756,
0.17651548981666565,
-0.009205693379044533,
-0.5638095140457153,
0.08544838428497314,
0.6141048073768616,
-0.4259375035762787,
-0.29072311520576477,
-0.5012474060058594,
0.22674433887004852,
-0.20645283162593842,
0.3723340332508087,
-0.28145211935043335,
0.2369702309370041,
-0.6318936347961426,
-0.2945307493209839,
-0.34172186255455017,
-0.24919316172599792,
-0.43653997778892517,
-0.2083563655614853,
0.62766033411026,
0.42490866780281067,
0.8473971486091614,
0.587343156337738,
0.6217300891876221,
0.3161487281322479,
0.04676228016614914,
0.1262524276971817,
-0.3907390832901001,
-0.06297837942838669,
0.17434488236904144,
-0.7454259991645813,
0.06399553269147873,
-0.16905900835990906,
0.42710641026496887,
0.24312448501586914,
0.19643297791481018,
0.10614801943302155,
-0.36563345789909363,
0.3734627068042755,
-0.6916617155075073,
0.06666818261146545,
-0.5723249316215515,
0.19903357326984406,
-0.12653063237667084,
-0.3051547706127167,
-0.27861762046813965,
-0.13945721089839935,
0.24346639215946198,
-0.49289241433143616,
-0.054169125854969025,
0.25167354941368103,
1.0057274103164673,
0.46024274826049805,
-0.36660322546958923,
-0.08416317403316498,
-0.6753042340278625,
0.8527271151542664,
-0.7148119807243347,
0.054385747760534286,
0.14570032060146332,
0.4958808720111847,
-0.007186762522906065,
-0.6197817921638489,
-0.806479811668396,
-0.1940377801656723,
-0.05684454366564751,
0.2736192047595978,
-0.4027184247970581,
0.01613091304898262,
0.29293960332870483,
0.12175166606903076,
-0.5831019282341003,
0.37577009201049805,
-0.45748159289360046,
-0.2071639746427536,
0.5027209520339966,
0.3124822676181793,
0.1974661946296692,
-0.31560376286506653,
-0.6708230972290039,
-0.08699638396501541,
-0.7424513101577759,
0.05162816867232323,
-0.1867009550333023,
0.326839417219162,
-0.20052848756313324,
0.926311731338501,
-0.21306325495243073,
0.767255961894989,
-0.13934148848056793,
-0.32783305644989014,
-0.03899119421839714,
-0.2742525637149811,
-0.3782918453216553,
-0.3723914623260498,
0.8499625325202942,
0.6097634434700012,
0.40441396832466125,
-0.00016778410645201802,
-0.11787772178649902,
-0.10387969017028809,
-0.004232058767229319,
-0.687102735042572,
-0.03423643857240677,
0.2899315059185028,
-0.1920021027326584,
-0.022260164842009544,
-0.20247147977352142,
-0.7438797950744629,
-0.33489683270454407,
-0.08457605540752411,
0.7314608693122864,
-0.25755390524864197,
0.20253081619739532,
-0.1787712723016739,
-0.21087829768657684,
0.8074502348899841,
0.6020610928535461,
-0.4736984670162201,
0.33809566497802734,
0.2964451313018799,
0.8664312362670898,
-0.205673947930336,
-0.14636829495429993,
-0.7317149043083191,
-0.03547202795743942,
-0.4684484601020813,
1.0116673707962036,
-0.4625275433063507,
-0.10504653304815292,
0.36619576811790466,
-0.177695170044899,
0.013821862637996674,
-0.5222036242485046,
0.07167167216539383,
-0.9991884827613831,
0.3350811302661896,
-0.42742782831192017,
-0.5436729192733765,
-0.2631080150604248,
0.2866230905056,
-0.6806835532188416,
0.7811472415924072,
-0.048224303871393204,
-0.5902472734451294,
0.47712889313697815,
-0.5440248250961304,
-0.10593199729919434,
0.19831249117851257,
-0.49066704511642456,
-0.23180954158306122,
0.06498021632432938,
0.46427637338638306,
0.6339977979660034,
-0.19934923946857452,
-0.41162270307540894,
-0.390658974647522,
-0.5327991247177124,
0.5683746337890625,
-0.3630457818508148,
0.2869071066379547,
0.05310101434588432,
-0.13578574359416962,
-0.16338835656642914,
-0.208109512925148,
0.24733877182006836,
0.47304514050483704,
-0.3629683554172516,
-0.13206543028354645,
-0.23084799945354462,
0.0832061916589737,
0.2511030435562134,
-0.025943132117390633,
-0.4240422546863556,
0.2689231038093567,
-0.3069271147251129,
0.50727778673172,
0.3659960627555847,
0.10091830790042877,
0.6272671818733215,
-0.40621012449264526,
0.7827821373939514,
0.2552562952041626,
-0.1911662518978119,
-0.3319932520389557,
-0.5644274353981018,
-0.8038269877433777,
-0.454954594373703,
0.33819669485092163,
0.675641655921936,
-1.3707168102264404,
-0.5612964034080505,
-0.20519515872001648,
-0.06898564845323563,
-0.49342215061187744,
0.43272829055786133,
0.41533535718917847,
0.2028559148311615,
0.3742498457431793,
-0.42546480894088745,
-0.0762307345867157,
-1.099779486656189,
0.016770023852586746,
-0.231642484664917,
0.02877790853381157,
0.4657883942127228,
0.6790928840637207,
0.2167273610830307,
0.7809706330299377,
-0.5892117023468018,
-0.28668898344039917,
-0.3627895414829254,
0.09166590124368668,
-0.03883540630340576,
0.06948865205049515,
0.908729076385498,
-0.6268461346626282,
-0.41298410296440125,
-0.20091214776039124,
-0.6301524043083191,
0.33569154143333435,
-0.2294178456068039,
-0.0181074608117342,
0.4383595287799835,
0.416338175535202,
-0.7774785161018372,
0.5013619661331177,
0.3959891200065613,
0.18317566812038422,
0.24943971633911133,
0.15628913044929504,
0.3457038402557373,
-0.7106797099113464,
-0.3158831298351288,
-0.09672369807958603,
-0.5523329973220825,
-0.6757127642631531,
0.2028336375951767,
0.0979740172624588,
0.05221271142363548,
-1.1235359907150269,
0.6132711172103882,
-0.6301916241645813,
-0.24590128660202026,
-0.20347921550273895,
0.3880729377269745,
0.05400587618350983,
0.6021718382835388,
0.1581055372953415,
0.8337063193321228,
0.7328417897224426,
-0.3496030569076538,
0.3891008198261261,
0.2687123119831085,
-0.2616459131240845,
0.4113108813762665,
-0.7184237241744995,
0.40456831455230713,
-0.44225284457206726,
-0.029784323647618294,
-1.3893133401870728,
-0.44115883111953735,
0.3294197618961334,
-0.3191552758216858,
0.5411784052848816,
-0.333777517080307,
-0.586101770401001,
-0.42913222312927246,
-0.5474083423614502,
0.397747278213501,
0.5542528033256531,
-0.3166186511516571,
0.38388076424598694,
-0.11911855638027191,
-0.06298975646495819,
-0.4804757237434387,
-1.1879769563674927,
0.3059238791465759,
-0.30990126729011536,
-0.5700178742408752,
0.12148283421993256,
-0.012558158487081528,
-0.26933321356773376,
0.017636453732848167,
0.10428241640329361,
-0.38882485032081604,
-0.09367082267999649,
0.17150695621967316,
0.24140232801437378,
-0.6052888631820679,
0.061546534299850464,
-0.09052100032567978,
0.07978222519159317,
-0.29005953669548035,
0.1458454579114914,
0.22413043677806854,
-0.25463318824768066,
-0.32431966066360474,
-0.5516197085380554,
0.6535130143165588,
0.7269284129142761,
-0.111906498670578,
0.803743302822113,
0.41269317269325256,
-0.230907142162323,
-0.018434809520840645,
-0.5932155251502991,
-0.16972561180591583,
-0.40706148743629456,
0.14396342635154724,
-0.42063474655151367,
-1.0855635404586792,
0.4097699522972107,
0.08629622310400009,
0.12526077032089233,
0.12920162081718445,
0.6018747091293335,
-0.7382599711418152,
0.5853222608566284,
0.7802180647850037,
0.11619900912046432,
0.3649384081363678,
-0.2749265432357788,
-0.005471310578286648,
-0.5150851011276245,
0.14501571655273438,
-0.33765652775764465,
-0.3012542724609375,
-0.4478147625923157,
-0.7326974272727966,
0.4874032735824585,
0.11667617410421371,
0.04662766680121422,
0.19398748874664307,
0.0992642417550087,
0.583038866519928,
0.42940381169319153,
0.08310011029243469,
0.2199319452047348,
0.21779663860797882,
-0.1283717155456543,
-0.2277262955904007,
-1.170268177986145,
-0.652194082736969,
0.8540892601013184,
0.2814481258392334,
0.7920500636100769,
0.2615739405155182,
0.8075056672096252,
-0.20003899931907654,
0.3526831567287445,
-1.086350679397583,
0.5077650547027588,
-0.12899568676948547,
-0.684715747833252,
-0.334281325340271,
0.0071504688821733,
-0.8177717328071594,
0.4789799749851227,
-0.405880331993103,
-0.6124922633171082,
-0.006504337303340435,
0.23038148880004883,
-0.534848153591156,
0.13140769302845,
-0.6539114117622375,
0.7174760103225708,
-0.36731091141700745,
-0.5427731871604919,
0.18869648873806,
-0.6168133020401001,
0.5870077013969421,
0.11277495324611664,
0.13584694266319275,
0.13614192605018616,
-0.3326341211795807,
0.48259180784225464,
-0.15666906535625458,
0.8961133360862732,
0.04299734905362129,
0.17719461023807526,
0.4973667860031128,
0.23099946975708008,
0.23983734846115112,
-0.04100748524069786,
0.14869318902492523,
0.10156945884227753,
0.20016610622406006,
-0.6140341758728027,
-0.6884538531303406,
0.5573816895484924,
-0.6807855367660522,
-0.7324914932250977,
-0.4252343773841858,
-0.40259411931037903,
-0.25000402331352234,
0.03301125764846802,
0.307171106338501,
0.5077459216117859,
0.058539848774671555,
0.30729764699935913,
0.6687872409820557,
-0.4153277575969696,
0.8125534653663635,
0.27485451102256775,
-0.30780401825904846,
-0.35924917459487915,
0.24661962687969208,
0.23550008237361908,
0.6302381157875061,
0.5260647535324097,
0.022648414596915245,
-0.19558335840702057,
-0.5362464189529419,
-0.6895919442176819,
0.4443649649620056,
-0.993583619594574,
-0.3968794047832489,
-0.35867592692375183,
-0.1018836572766304,
-0.20046788454055786,
-0.3293417990207672,
-0.37788310647010803,
-0.22451497614383698,
-0.485080748796463,
-0.04427909478545189,
0.5200240612030029,
0.4458204507827759,
0.21187563240528107,
0.2585652768611908,
-0.8192999362945557,
0.7039729952812195,
0.5991414189338684,
0.08631924539804459,
-0.18886399269104004,
-0.5929433703422546,
-0.01195665542036295,
-0.06744609773159027,
-0.18535155057907104,
-1.037739872932434,
0.2090034931898117,
0.3540349304676056,
0.435824990272522,
0.300348162651062,
-0.06328785419464111,
0.9175368547439575,
-0.4878062903881073,
1.0924242734909058,
0.232164204120636,
-0.5650215148925781,
0.36557042598724365,
-0.12523116171360016,
0.6654775738716125,
0.5244668126106262,
0.4700183868408203,
-0.14904683828353882,
-0.4227154850959778,
-0.21093741059303284,
-0.5982016324996948,
0.39790859818458557,
0.22863034904003143,
0.5442420244216919,
0.12264528125524521,
0.29942962527275085,
0.02629050798714161,
0.3016144037246704,
-0.7245761752128601,
-0.2488732933998108,
-0.008405555039644241,
0.167616605758667,
-0.04931646212935448,
-0.4235844314098358,
-0.3925243616104126,
-0.028274592012166977,
0.0352008230984211,
-0.33885976672172546,
0.5075642466545105,
0.3934362828731537,
-0.3568156361579895,
-0.23141959309577942,
0.3246692717075348,
0.7777326107025146,
0.5979551672935486,
0.023139135912060738,
0.3220130503177643,
0.3494940400123596,
-0.14772850275039673,
-0.08584762364625931,
-0.48782193660736084,
-0.21283909678459167,
0.15813608467578888,
0.7773776650428772,
0.8755971193313599,
0.17886032164096832,
-0.6408419609069824,
0.6507089138031006,
0.03548111021518707,
-0.5004382729530334,
-0.20811471343040466,
-0.021166816353797913,
0.20277978479862213,
0.4771694242954254,
0.32155749201774597,
-0.13591676950454712,
-0.1034286841750145,
-0.6866989731788635,
0.04727063328027725,
0.5225615501403809,
-0.3566075265407562,
-0.0407247357070446,
0.4537387788295746,
-0.022428441792726517,
-0.056365568190813065,
0.43373116850852966,
0.01059308648109436,
-0.5006898045539856,
0.6114095449447632,
0.27203473448753357,
0.7018973231315613,
0.3767148554325104,
0.4301905632019043,
0.17803038656711578,
0.6195033192634583,
0.13411714136600494,
0.5404912233352661,
0.005447962321341038,
-0.7765389680862427,
-0.5178506374359131,
-0.30719539523124695,
-0.5045896768569946,
0.026135578751564026,
-0.5212447643280029,
0.075224868953228,
-0.4462474584579468,
-0.08795559406280518,
-0.09415213763713837,
-0.08365143835544586,
-1.095653772354126,
0.048525139689445496,
0.49704280495643616,
0.7514191269874573,
-0.8804528713226318,
0.5397846102714539,
0.9596225023269653,
-0.6455552577972412,
-0.6663625836372375,
-0.04812655225396156,
0.1593320369720459,
-0.7635437846183777,
0.5919462442398071,
-0.0676451027393341,
-0.16905461251735687,
-0.14135149121284485,
-1.1351842880249023,
-0.8435378670692444,
1.3170521259307861,
0.35103699564933777,
-0.4236240088939667,
0.4162614643573761,
0.21988071501255035,
0.6179078817367554,
-0.4565480053424835,
0.280072420835495,
0.33846551179885864,
0.41782087087631226,
0.5632715821266174,
-0.8641472458839417,
-0.09222209453582764,
0.22343257069587708,
0.17477034032344818,
-0.22504328191280365,
-0.708458662033081,
0.5339483618736267,
-0.5421603918075562,
-0.38120976090431213,
0.35754087567329407,
0.7082121968269348,
0.207513228058815,
0.4703139364719391,
0.26210057735443115,
0.3084909915924072,
0.2584831714630127,
-0.01267725508660078,
1.2401940822601318,
0.2813349962234497,
0.14093780517578125,
0.985514760017395,
-0.3538092076778412,
1.324139952659607,
1.010495662689209,
-0.33121857047080994,
0.1901867389678955,
0.6287318468093872,
0.07248170673847198,
0.6445793509483337,
0.0887509435415268,
-0.034911055117845535,
-0.5170873403549194,
-0.07828596234321594,
-0.038515299558639526,
0.5961478352546692,
0.10518558323383331,
-0.11305387318134308,
-0.32633399963378906,
0.18112552165985107,
0.0076845986768603325,
0.023677419871091843,
-0.15004903078079224,
0.8351297378540039,
0.37572377920150757,
-0.2856631875038147,
0.7383280396461487,
-0.09427864104509354,
0.5690255761146545,
-0.24139563739299774,
-0.012880631722509861,
-0.45242634415626526,
-0.4688420593738556,
-0.1928550899028778,
-0.9227429032325745,
0.044107306748628616,
0.19573107361793518,
-0.017323080450296402,
-0.09401670843362808,
0.5724030137062073,
-0.41054272651672363,
-0.4176582098007202,
-0.05947853997349739,
0.7574707865715027,
0.332210510969162,
0.22079916298389435,
-0.6768280863761902,
0.09862975031137466,
-0.38676735758781433,
-0.33658909797668457,
0.18246953189373016,
0.2695810794830322,
-0.07971405982971191,
0.7680677771568298,
0.24434858560562134,
-0.21280798316001892,
0.3436448872089386,
0.06708871573209763,
0.8723105788230896,
-0.6335813999176025,
-0.03004748560488224,
-0.6830883622169495,
0.7716270685195923,
0.18262507021427155,
-0.27250367403030396,
0.4468626379966736,
0.15011879801750183,
0.6163747310638428,
-0.4449041485786438,
0.5741687417030334,
0.1439805030822754,
-0.06578385084867477,
-1.0422172546386719,
0.39913293719291687,
-0.8287017941474915,
0.14874404668807983,
-0.29063543677330017,
-0.8570225238800049,
-0.6342251300811768,
0.2898750603199005,
-0.2882927656173706,
-0.06804949790239334,
0.8860194087028503,
0.9928981065750122,
0.019441496580839157,
-0.5395559072494507,
0.7798463106155396,
0.18806709349155426,
0.027364201843738556,
0.7062912583351135,
1.1763101816177368,
-0.5864685773849487,
0.5399090051651001,
-0.2519731819629669,
0.16067340970039368,
-0.25973543524742126,
-0.8995170593261719,
-1.0004290342330933,
-0.33948031067848206,
-0.6869632601737976,
0.21272699534893036,
-0.08913243561983109,
0.5980787873268127,
0.5371352434158325,
-0.5953973531723022,
0.005393562372773886,
0.5005214810371399,
0.2639542520046234,
0.07313738763332367,
-0.1697598695755005,
0.0650511085987091,
0.022825932130217552,
-0.6644558310508728,
0.23535825312137604,
0.5633319616317749,
0.2847495377063751,
-0.46795782446861267,
0.11845522373914719,
-0.22594758868217468,
0.2429342120885849,
0.6919224858283997,
0.23487387597560883,
-1.0897955894470215,
-0.4999694228172302,
0.27813366055488586,
-0.28379470109939575,
0.23476189374923706,
0.41220784187316895,
-0.7840098142623901,
0.484820693731308,
0.6444668769836426,
0.6996369957923889,
0.7195947766304016,
0.02802247181534767,
0.2822957932949066,
-0.5074043869972229,
0.12831979990005493,
0.1569356918334961,
0.12884171307086945,
0.3273027241230011,
-0.1257864087820053,
0.08788401633501053,
-0.001251147361472249,
-0.11225928366184235,
-0.6488287448883057,
0.21397985517978668,
-1.2830970287322998,
-0.30052706599235535,
1.1481107473373413,
-0.1688879430294037,
-0.30896076560020447,
0.09603188186883926,
-0.21962393820285797,
-0.2418646365404129,
-0.13769879937171936,
0.37928974628448486,
0.7751945853233337,
-0.18561139702796936,
-0.822113573551178,
-0.9209038019180298,
0.19845786690711975,
0.3395608067512512,
-0.6014007925987244,
-0.6052404642105103,
0.7036818861961365,
0.28058236837387085,
0.019184716045856476,
0.5941659808158875,
0.0045661418698728085,
0.5146477222442627,
-0.0457291305065155,
-0.13796865940093994,
-0.02098918706178665,
-0.2844015657901764,
-0.5957375764846802,
0.4445064663887024,
0.33528316020965576,
-0.3806955814361572
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11314v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11314v1
|
Reasoning in Transformers -- Mitigating Spurious Correlations and Reasoning Shortcuts
| 2024-03-17T19:32:12 | 2024-03-17T19:32:12 |
Daniel Enström, Viktor Kjellberg, Moa Johansson
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Transformer language models are neural networks used for a wide variety of
tasks concerning natural language, including some that also require logical
reasoning. However, a transformer model may easily learn spurious patterns in
the data, short-circuiting actual reasoning. In this paper we investigate to
what extent transformers can be trained to a) approximate reasoning in
propositional logic while b) avoiding known reasoning shortcuts via spurious
correlations in the training data. To do so, we use a dataset with known
spurious correlation between truth and e.g. the number of rules in the problem.
We augment the data with proofs, and train two models: a generative
transformer, WP-BART, trained on problems and their whole proofs, and a
neuro-symbolic model, SIP-BART, trained on individual proof steps and combining
the generative transformer model BART with a symbolic proof checker. We find
that SIP-BART succeeds in avoiding reasoning shortcuts, while WP-BART does not.
For SIP-BART, we then identify a few remaining reasoning errors, not previously
described in the literature, arising from using a pre-trained language model.
These are qualitatively analysed to create a taxonomy of four different types
of additional pitfalls.
|
[
-0.3581539988517761,
-0.7690532207489014,
0.6655433177947998,
0.1768249273300171,
-0.18457864224910736,
0.049017783254384995,
-0.12997132539749146,
-0.2523336708545685,
-0.032251156866550446,
0.7160409688949585,
-0.4487462043762207,
0.05565953254699707,
-0.5701184868812561,
0.0856255516409874,
-0.5781998634338379,
0.9330618977546692,
0.11059829592704773,
-0.06475977599620819,
-0.2949751317501068,
-0.0111997677013278,
-0.7848268747329712,
-0.6539575457572937,
-0.639859139919281,
-0.5546878576278687,
0.35546138882637024,
0.2936156094074249,
1.022152304649353,
0.3199222981929779,
0.672718346118927,
0.2414039820432663,
-0.24605412781238556,
0.1328420490026474,
-0.3034154176712036,
0.1672893613576889,
-0.4220849573612213,
-0.8798961639404297,
-0.11320473253726959,
-0.2611401081085205,
0.22458703815937042,
0.7461671829223633,
0.05007762834429741,
-0.0744909942150116,
-0.11019960045814514,
0.5963589549064636,
-0.5800904631614685,
0.058144330978393555,
-0.6509953737258911,
0.06422007083892822,
-0.1903306394815445,
-0.24067902565002441,
-0.705346405506134,
-0.37658026814460754,
0.2279064655303955,
-0.5294528007507324,
0.3997650146484375,
0.15997669100761414,
0.9854123592376709,
0.6877368092536926,
-0.3834848403930664,
-0.2283744066953659,
-1.2148995399475098,
0.7573055624961853,
-0.4631367325782776,
0.19666583836078644,
0.4118574559688568,
0.6031903624534607,
-0.10216760635375977,
-0.7364028096199036,
-0.6109034419059753,
-0.17060479521751404,
-0.5061963796615601,
0.22575955092906952,
-0.3974432647228241,
0.030522679910063744,
0.7869565486907959,
-0.01344761997461319,
-0.39026662707328796,
-0.08031396567821503,
-0.2470194697380066,
-0.26770514249801636,
0.5275197625160217,
0.20740492641925812,
0.08354895561933517,
-0.2229255735874176,
-0.37678810954093933,
-0.3621637523174286,
-0.8834352493286133,
0.13610011339187622,
0.42782771587371826,
0.013018799014389515,
0.172074556350708,
0.5090286135673523,
0.17195606231689453,
0.6219385266304016,
0.04197920858860016,
0.039374880492687225,
-0.1853063702583313,
-0.34556880593299866,
0.03427977114915848,
-0.059291206300258636,
0.7440028786659241,
0.14468343555927277,
0.5187628865242004,
-0.35257628560066223,
-0.2604620158672333,
0.37232506275177,
0.3714565336704254,
-0.49894970655441284,
-0.3925277590751648,
0.04747241735458374,
-0.292789101600647,
-0.3087176978588104,
-0.06825199723243713,
-0.5406592488288879,
-0.07194908708333969,
-0.2661747932434082,
0.5620020627975464,
-0.5794571042060852,
-0.04698352515697479,
0.158356711268425,
-0.5235368609428406,
0.1985337734222412,
0.132231667637825,
-0.6067107319831848,
0.37098953127861023,
0.7690039277076721,
0.5303672552108765,
0.18680843710899353,
-0.3006165325641632,
-0.4116079807281494,
0.2519414722919464,
-0.3431614637374878,
0.8824256062507629,
-0.540837287902832,
-0.5293260812759399,
-0.12946385145187378,
-0.1725480556488037,
-0.19108526408672333,
-0.6241530179977417,
1.0250798463821411,
-0.4956907033920288,
0.35228219628334045,
-0.2682749927043915,
-0.5672985911369324,
-0.22943496704101562,
0.04447823762893677,
-0.7112396359443665,
0.9601528644561768,
-0.11238014698028564,
-0.9073654413223267,
0.2042573243379593,
-0.5558381676673889,
-0.7625948786735535,
-0.15846587717533112,
0.05036896839737892,
-0.3710951507091522,
0.09156985580921173,
0.16011330485343933,
0.17706163227558136,
-0.49371832609176636,
0.5681827664375305,
-0.11891289800405502,
-0.47393015027046204,
0.2231486737728119,
-0.580267608165741,
0.8696144223213196,
0.08063901960849762,
-0.3404903709888458,
0.14262732863426208,
-0.566578209400177,
-0.3001056909561157,
0.295472651720047,
0.2901068329811096,
-0.4933485984802246,
0.2117527425289154,
-0.29143020510673523,
0.5383466482162476,
-0.12197412550449371,
-0.2526785135269165,
0.15252821147441864,
-0.4355742633342743,
0.4749208688735962,
0.5782756209373474,
0.12566961348056793,
0.4842189848423004,
-0.567779004573822,
0.3856310248374939,
0.3861856162548065,
0.48119592666625977,
-0.20528359711170197,
-0.8073359131813049,
-1.2531914710998535,
0.15347951650619507,
0.26555493474006653,
0.7359646558761597,
-1.0646061897277832,
0.6334819793701172,
-0.2761956453323364,
-0.5951763987541199,
-0.27610141038894653,
-0.22228530049324036,
0.22651027143001556,
0.8864428997039795,
0.5751206874847412,
-0.05881723016500473,
-0.3611457347869873,
-0.9438683390617371,
-0.4981885552406311,
-0.12696431577205658,
-0.12675178050994873,
0.06333699077367783,
0.6290331482887268,
-0.012777199037373066,
1.249029517173767,
-0.48520705103874207,
-0.22185936570167542,
-0.2579055428504944,
0.19091807305812836,
0.27027612924575806,
0.6040917634963989,
0.4955201745033264,
-0.8255462050437927,
-0.2954762578010559,
-0.35975101590156555,
-0.5886265635490417,
0.15592190623283386,
-0.5948541760444641,
-0.11799514293670654,
-0.25034603476524353,
0.5376448631286621,
-0.9724147319793701,
0.6066625118255615,
-0.14079022407531738,
-0.08714369684457779,
0.7834230065345764,
-0.16138505935668945,
-0.3940892517566681,
-0.8653463125228882,
-0.15260301530361176,
0.03833645209670067,
-0.1397102326154709,
-0.7826817035675049,
-0.14857390522956848,
-0.03359631076455116,
-0.01870734430849552,
-0.2809664309024811,
0.314308762550354,
-0.04424791783094406,
0.4163683354854584,
-0.17674243450164795,
0.003054264700040221,
0.2805239260196686,
0.49425527453422546,
0.2741548418998718,
0.6603555679321289,
0.6430438160896301,
-0.6234718561172485,
0.30848678946495056,
0.4926937222480774,
-0.09080920368432999,
0.3131166994571686,
-0.8091470003128052,
0.04856866970658302,
-0.14331094920635223,
0.2925109565258026,
-0.5399055480957031,
0.11036160588264465,
0.31777432560920715,
-0.2427959144115448,
0.21250826120376587,
-0.10014782100915909,
-0.672714352607727,
-0.6009364128112793,
-0.04882392659783363,
0.3925354480743408,
0.6780383586883545,
-0.7943518757820129,
0.7458487749099731,
-0.019487252458930016,
0.20449815690517426,
-0.7869468927383423,
-0.5769570469856262,
-0.1301501840353012,
-0.36322200298309326,
-0.5596780776977539,
0.33564579486846924,
0.18602919578552246,
-0.2566499710083008,
0.10122248530387878,
-0.114136703312397,
-0.14337988197803497,
0.1456061750650406,
0.07309333980083466,
0.29762300848960876,
-0.10539951175451279,
0.15394775569438934,
0.0614585317671299,
-0.4465252459049225,
0.48634883761405945,
-0.11058187484741211,
0.3660303056240082,
-0.3701164424419403,
-0.6687078475952148,
-0.19389869272708893,
0.3425775468349457,
0.45737314224243164,
-0.05218369886279106,
0.7306880950927734,
0.3769397735595703,
-0.34823912382125854,
-0.22463306784629822,
-0.5252562761306763,
-0.6309579014778137,
-0.4831320643424988,
0.13287511467933655,
-0.3800197243690491,
-0.5847060680389404,
0.5607860088348389,
-0.24476926028728485,
-0.14462478458881378,
0.5023751258850098,
0.27057313919067383,
-0.1939355432987213,
1.014707088470459,
0.42202240228652954,
0.09463518857955933,
0.2419753223657608,
-0.21526676416397095,
0.7529584169387817,
-0.46440446376800537,
-0.14841602742671967,
-0.5499321818351746,
-0.03073902800679207,
-0.6462153196334839,
-0.5431561470031738,
0.3117976784706116,
0.16836677491664886,
-0.20719899237155914,
0.5943305492401123,
-0.42010703682899475,
0.7092686891555786,
0.790433943271637,
0.09450162947177887,
0.34198108315467834,
-0.27348053455352783,
-0.22191548347473145,
0.031162023544311523,
-1.06283700466156,
-0.5077236294746399,
0.8639416098594666,
0.1672087162733078,
0.8591722846031189,
-0.03507353365421295,
0.38573718070983887,
0.04116502031683922,
0.12658832967281342,
-0.9101315140724182,
0.46113890409469604,
0.11315730959177017,
-0.7267176508903503,
-0.051212377846241,
-0.6500134468078613,
-0.7897558212280273,
0.2099517285823822,
-0.27601584792137146,
-0.558526337146759,
0.18844303488731384,
0.35256534814834595,
-0.28258344531059265,
0.5658767819404602,
-0.8828926086425781,
0.8510326147079468,
-0.3385453224182129,
-0.2928878366947174,
-0.2955457866191864,
-1.1394402980804443,
0.6527197360992432,
-0.09377988427877426,
-0.001261819270439446,
0.2138015180826187,
0.6329478621482849,
0.45249658823013306,
-0.5241461396217346,
0.7452916502952576,
0.09963814169168472,
0.21168872714042664,
0.46251508593559265,
0.27338656783103943,
0.6558220982551575,
-0.20724906027317047,
0.3344062566757202,
0.1644877940416336,
-0.034202199429273605,
-0.27038297057151794,
-0.8792428374290466,
0.1554449200630188,
-0.5083640217781067,
-0.905824601650238,
-0.5534258484840393,
-0.6175218820571899,
-0.4242728352546692,
0.04031898081302643,
0.4443730413913727,
0.3608962297439575,
-0.015151120722293854,
0.03414439409971237,
0.6045465469360352,
-0.16962355375289917,
0.5056332349777222,
0.0041222102008759975,
0.015711147338151932,
0.026680653914809227,
1.0087940692901611,
-0.13784073293209076,
0.4136304259300232,
0.5727876424789429,
0.4374866485595703,
-0.45179715752601624,
-0.14449459314346313,
-0.09338243305683136,
0.24381452798843384,
-0.9329671859741211,
-0.2777915298938751,
-0.4388168156147003,
-0.4059627950191498,
-0.05368312448263168,
0.026150673627853394,
-0.32618802785873413,
-0.808009922504425,
-0.15591537952423096,
0.09791101515293121,
0.24804730713367462,
0.5351752042770386,
0.03381265327334404,
0.48853978514671326,
-0.9784456491470337,
0.3537515103816986,
0.40906795859336853,
0.2624736726284027,
0.13762392103672028,
-0.389964759349823,
-0.01760116033256054,
-0.0622282437980175,
-0.5012597441673279,
-0.9375420808792114,
0.16957274079322815,
-0.01180865615606308,
0.54854816198349,
0.6501670479774475,
0.1414879858493805,
0.6193791031837463,
-0.679561972618103,
0.6465004682540894,
0.32639753818511963,
-1.0823403596878052,
0.6214628219604492,
-0.019226113334298134,
-0.08703113347291946,
0.3440812826156616,
0.5148535370826721,
-0.4691399037837982,
-0.45589679479599,
-0.9803587794303894,
-0.532902717590332,
0.49974343180656433,
0.5363861322402954,
0.023661861196160316,
-0.1345786452293396,
0.14627298712730408,
0.009101144038140774,
-0.019950170069932938,
-0.6032921075820923,
-0.4325510859489441,
-0.5455588698387146,
-0.021294953301548958,
0.25275918841362,
-0.12110187113285065,
-0.39921504259109497,
-0.4586819112300873,
0.8105029463768005,
-0.11138960719108582,
0.15094725787639618,
-0.08260799199342728,
-0.3564026951789856,
0.21135865151882172,
0.3501930832862854,
0.652850329875946,
0.42348697781562805,
-0.06137526407837868,
0.30452239513397217,
0.03324347361922264,
-0.21243606507778168,
0.13284435868263245,
0.027831053361296654,
-0.3897339403629303,
0.19361889362335205,
0.2072499394416809,
0.8065620064735413,
0.0827617272734642,
-0.6195840239524841,
0.7051337361335754,
-0.19045275449752808,
-0.04090752825140953,
-0.3166218400001526,
0.029640069231390953,
0.0730617493391037,
0.004621801897883415,
0.1258087307214737,
0.8825552463531494,
-0.015617438592016697,
-0.12419147789478302,
0.17339085042476654,
0.4288404881954193,
-0.2526547312736511,
-0.41492098569869995,
0.6100518703460693,
0.1865711212158203,
-0.3515051305294037,
0.6612220406532288,
-0.07949378341436386,
-0.7292354106903076,
0.5714520812034607,
0.666965901851654,
0.7021492719650269,
0.07781263440847397,
0.2099967896938324,
0.4007287323474884,
0.6926079392433167,
-0.2367461621761322,
-0.3133506774902344,
-0.16340963542461395,
-1.0718718767166138,
-0.5658500790596008,
-0.17272159457206726,
-0.7568384408950806,
-0.03359502553939819,
-0.7689533829689026,
0.36813366413116455,
-0.2841627895832062,
-0.25833582878112793,
0.004615794867277145,
-0.657623827457428,
-0.7818059921264648,
-0.031774166971445084,
-0.16522713005542755,
0.9262799024581909,
-1.0773504972457886,
0.8585919141769409,
0.2730333209037781,
-0.5933579802513123,
-0.9350423812866211,
0.11018586158752441,
-0.3355371654033661,
-0.5836546421051025,
0.667465090751648,
0.08911947160959244,
-0.21769417822360992,
-0.24200166761875153,
-0.25125518441200256,
-0.6092373728752136,
0.4930521249771118,
0.4970366954803467,
-0.590069591999054,
-0.17752766609191895,
0.3946250081062317,
0.43410784006118774,
0.17589171230793,
0.5018234252929688,
0.9502988457679749,
0.462175577878952,
0.10236931592226028,
-0.7673600912094116,
0.09611596912145615,
-0.08430516719818115,
-0.22168633341789246,
0.2571198344230652,
-0.45868077874183655,
0.5430949330329895,
-0.2582160532474518,
-0.13472390174865723,
-0.12381158769130707,
0.47739487886428833,
0.20216955244541168,
0.08799894154071808,
0.7381433844566345,
0.6520249843597412,
0.741503119468689,
-0.4387734830379486,
1.1087838411331177,
-0.3293149173259735,
0.4107579290866852,
1.1933561563491821,
-0.3733445703983307,
0.4731985330581665,
0.7208273410797119,
-0.10940933227539062,
0.609323263168335,
0.26054486632347107,
-0.18241794407367706,
0.4265522062778473,
-0.0012188332621008158,
-0.1835075169801712,
-0.6331778168678284,
-0.02104378677904606,
-0.32718729972839355,
0.484292596578598,
0.5283294916152954,
-0.05396093800663948,
-0.39288538694381714,
-0.09922774881124496,
-0.140080526471138,
0.025859935209155083,
0.07906314730644226,
0.5661003589630127,
0.24339458346366882,
-0.8867861032485962,
0.4767604172229767,
-0.2546423077583313,
0.5791234374046326,
-0.4978457987308502,
-0.084686279296875,
-0.10098548233509064,
0.11792679131031036,
-0.12962572276592255,
-0.7321011424064636,
0.736331582069397,
-0.1785658597946167,
-0.14336922764778137,
-0.3013451397418976,
1.0231704711914062,
-0.12065586447715759,
-0.48423582315444946,
0.20780372619628906,
0.6691089272499084,
0.0029099720995873213,
-0.06726101785898209,
-0.6154263019561768,
-0.5464310050010681,
-0.20976386964321136,
0.04938837140798569,
-0.04254994913935661,
0.4635731875896454,
-0.3003297746181488,
0.925640344619751,
0.6728699803352356,
0.09864170104265213,
0.1142372414469719,
0.45049014687538147,
0.9422328472137451,
-0.6932099461555481,
-0.4381745159626007,
-0.9082861542701721,
0.30949532985687256,
-0.13340866565704346,
-0.1706947386264801,
0.6585129499435425,
0.4852215349674225,
0.7088398337364197,
-0.34559333324432373,
0.5938899517059326,
0.2772909700870514,
0.353372722864151,
-0.3984661400318146,
0.4532378911972046,
-0.18660375475883484,
0.3429886996746063,
-0.1475609689950943,
-0.8357563614845276,
-0.46609675884246826,
0.6805782318115234,
-0.49186402559280396,
-0.14132210612297058,
1.0110868215560913,
0.7365063428878784,
-0.18182307481765747,
0.5070299506187439,
0.3116929531097412,
0.03423169255256653,
0.40693575143814087,
0.6920518279075623,
1.3536481857299805,
-0.408037006855011,
0.7861576676368713,
-0.666303813457489,
0.14569765329360962,
-0.0284177977591753,
-0.9339202642440796,
-1.0112844705581665,
-0.3748161196708679,
-0.2197588086128235,
-0.4287603795528412,
-0.33983543515205383,
0.6033795475959778,
0.6720457077026367,
-0.8239914774894714,
0.08534035086631775,
-0.5646571516990662,
0.7355571389198303,
-0.46325623989105225,
-0.2841891050338745,
0.2465752512216568,
-0.413889616727829,
-0.43535512685775757,
0.3554663360118866,
0.12335533648729324,
0.08085162192583084,
-0.07759775221347809,
0.17174498736858368,
0.04097527638077736,
0.11238530278205872,
0.4597196877002716,
0.18195462226867676,
-0.8125040531158447,
-0.5941648483276367,
0.12435433268547058,
0.19150468707084656,
0.24131804704666138,
1.0960530042648315,
-0.8585754036903381,
0.3313257396221161,
0.4773586392402649,
0.47151821851730347,
0.5951128005981445,
-0.0419609397649765,
0.5206072926521301,
-0.901555061340332,
0.45282062888145447,
0.5824154615402222,
0.6060864329338074,
0.34367427229881287,
-0.37016761302948,
0.41503721475601196,
0.3870892822742462,
-0.4312990605831146,
-0.7821567058563232,
0.49193015694618225,
-0.9910058379173279,
-0.20544953644275665,
0.7926048040390015,
0.03312470763921738,
-0.10239972919225693,
-0.2774406671524048,
0.07779739797115326,
0.2525772452354431,
0.042690206319093704,
0.8162345290184021,
0.704273521900177,
-0.2767080068588257,
0.10712716728448868,
-0.3951717019081116,
0.6446383595466614,
0.8203370571136475,
-0.7775612473487854,
-0.089798703789711,
0.13058196008205414,
0.24547865986824036,
0.5552141666412354,
0.06890062242746353,
0.011750889010727406,
0.3586220145225525,
0.18200790882110596,
-0.18844608962535858,
0.12940040230751038,
-0.5410012006759644,
-0.1613655686378479,
0.0843639075756073,
-0.09250041097402573,
-0.06218006834387779
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11311v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11311v2
|
Mixture-of-Prompt-Experts for Multi-modal Semantic Understanding
| 2024-03-17T19:12:26 | 2024-03-24T06:21:27 |
Zichen Wu, Hsiu-Yuan Huang, Fanyi Qu, Yunfang Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.MM
|
Deep multimodal semantic understanding that goes beyond the mere superficial
content relation mining has received increasing attention in the realm of
artificial intelligence. The challenges of collecting and annotating
high-quality multi-modal data have underscored the significance of few-shot
learning. In this paper, we focus on two critical tasks under this context:
few-shot multi-modal sarcasm detection (MSD) and multi-modal sentiment analysis
(MSA). To address them, we propose Mixture-of-Prompt-Experts with Block-Aware
Prompt Fusion (MoPE-BAF), a novel multi-modal soft prompt framework based on
the unified vision-language model (VLM). Specifically, we design three experts
of soft prompts: a text prompt and an image prompt that extract
modality-specific features to enrich the single-modal representation, and a
unified prompt to assist multi-modal interaction. Additionally, we reorganize
Transformer layers into several blocks and introduce cross-modal prompt
attention between adjacent blocks, which smoothens the transition from
single-modal representation to multi-modal fusion. On both MSD and MSA datasets
in few-shot setting, our proposed model not only surpasses the 8.2B model
InstructBLIP with merely 2% parameters (150M), but also significantly
outperforms other widely-used prompt methods on VLMs or task-specific methods.
|
[
-0.5546615123748779,
-0.8107635974884033,
0.7106462121009827,
0.1436665952205658,
-0.43531495332717896,
-0.07065468281507492,
-0.1693081557750702,
-0.18230867385864258,
-0.07725055515766144,
0.19210200011730194,
-0.9422691464424133,
-0.34389621019363403,
-0.44366657733917236,
0.13267192244529724,
0.2804757356643677,
0.8126552104949951,
0.4464932978153229,
0.26459741592407227,
-0.1300499141216278,
-0.18276585638523102,
-0.9288779497146606,
-0.0010195504873991013,
-0.26050105690956116,
-0.02291622944176197,
0.6239089965820312,
0.5425862669944763,
0.5655966997146606,
0.08523692190647125,
0.259387344121933,
0.3408326506614685,
0.005299386568367481,
0.493236243724823,
-0.2400389164686203,
0.208089679479599,
-0.25803664326667786,
-0.28283247351646423,
-0.2204614281654358,
-0.06344019621610641,
0.3765466809272766,
0.5568445324897766,
0.22005866467952728,
-0.14789973199367523,
-0.08107951283454895,
0.3034417927265167,
-0.6595144867897034,
0.17033469676971436,
-0.6525057554244995,
-0.025289956480264664,
0.022526171058416367,
-0.10942348837852478,
-0.49147358536720276,
0.276619553565979,
0.08900868147611618,
-0.6229841113090515,
0.06779691576957703,
0.09417364746332169,
0.45468851923942566,
0.5604720711708069,
-0.8489151000976562,
0.20358484983444214,
-0.24771203100681305,
0.8922128677368164,
-0.5918980836868286,
0.2288265824317932,
0.12216591089963913,
0.53190678358078,
-0.25003501772880554,
-0.21455198526382446,
-0.7349979281425476,
-0.06473145633935928,
-0.08418197184801102,
0.31095388531684875,
-0.048511117696762085,
0.11233445256948471,
0.010067706927657127,
0.1873110979795456,
-0.5240505933761597,
0.0739884302020073,
-0.17867128551006317,
-0.3595260977745056,
0.36267489194869995,
0.33799824118614197,
0.08891110867261887,
-0.6968327164649963,
-0.8939187526702881,
0.046257246285676956,
-0.30040982365608215,
0.10994656383991241,
-0.08045828342437744,
0.42129215598106384,
-0.1253979653120041,
0.3587486147880554,
-0.2536412179470062,
0.8276551365852356,
0.12546730041503906,
-0.5223316550254822,
0.29992881417274475,
-0.7825585007667542,
-0.29842808842658997,
-0.3453029692173004,
0.8992393612861633,
0.29537320137023926,
-0.05516936257481575,
0.010365089401602745,
-0.26131775975227356,
0.03782820329070091,
-0.0146487420424819,
-0.4927156865596771,
-0.07203420251607895,
0.03334161639213562,
-0.5921364426612854,
-0.22762565314769745,
0.14922437071800232,
-0.8285234570503235,
-0.8034778833389282,
-0.3401640057563782,
0.5951980948448181,
-0.6852718591690063,
-0.5090351700782776,
0.00830100104212761,
-0.28468090295791626,
0.1440465748310089,
0.6291561722755432,
-0.47479188442230225,
-0.19523070752620697,
0.5568823218345642,
0.5220170021057129,
0.008654410019516945,
-0.3691869080066681,
-0.6964299082756042,
-0.009958051145076752,
0.05264725536108017,
0.9481993913650513,
-0.684175431728363,
-0.4937409460544586,
-0.1959380954504013,
-0.2582624554634094,
-0.3087002635002136,
-0.12425431609153748,
0.4863077700138092,
-0.3194364011287689,
0.5204993486404419,
-0.17631766200065613,
-0.24103422462940216,
-0.49955493211746216,
0.4560750424861908,
-0.5758712291717529,
0.8848517537117004,
0.1948428601026535,
-0.5574668645858765,
0.39156046509742737,
-0.367951899766922,
-0.3965563476085663,
0.19982677698135376,
-0.49620282649993896,
0.1646314561367035,
0.3338640034198761,
0.39081618189811707,
0.7140488028526306,
-0.36158138513565063,
0.22546124458312988,
-0.11743400245904922,
0.05137708783149719,
0.3956495523452759,
-0.746597945690155,
0.5784680843353271,
0.14882031083106995,
-0.21596817672252655,
0.2796957492828369,
-0.8156617283821106,
-0.09304149448871613,
-0.2801818251609802,
-0.11227461695671082,
-0.2407171130180359,
-0.3618049621582031,
0.26614925265312195,
0.650618314743042,
0.056589532643556595,
-0.2952784597873688,
0.18368615210056305,
-0.18442775309085846,
0.11411803960800171,
0.8530064225196838,
0.12162533402442932,
0.5562442541122437,
-0.21190258860588074,
0.5298409461975098,
0.5155758857727051,
0.1970110386610031,
-0.940021812915802,
-0.65816730260849,
-0.4679313600063324,
-0.8588231801986694,
0.13608522713184357,
0.504297137260437,
-1.1923381090164185,
0.4640026390552521,
-0.07840271294116974,
-0.2981354892253876,
-0.5828412771224976,
0.3417302966117859,
0.46849966049194336,
0.8992181420326233,
0.4328033924102783,
-0.20378059148788452,
-0.056008171290159225,
-0.836765468120575,
-0.12112000584602356,
-0.07577336579561234,
0.06538049876689911,
0.4540691077709198,
0.2660391330718994,
-0.2107902616262436,
1.1298900842666626,
-0.32605141401290894,
-0.409860759973526,
-0.43979254364967346,
0.47509875893592834,
0.20571333169937134,
0.5149620771408081,
0.6033803224563599,
-0.8457523584365845,
-0.4150872528553009,
-0.11404971033334732,
-0.5736271739006042,
-0.021709956228733063,
-0.34429001808166504,
-0.03765224292874336,
0.10651896893978119,
0.13863413035869598,
-0.8456182479858398,
0.23586764931678772,
0.07246550917625427,
-0.5562307238578796,
0.40930044651031494,
0.15975408256053925,
0.4335836172103882,
-1.1874393224716187,
-0.18799665570259094,
0.2703092396259308,
-0.4289335608482361,
-0.5596017241477966,
0.0589289516210556,
0.010516411624848843,
-0.08258066326379776,
-0.7397552728652954,
0.6037495732307434,
-0.3829377591609955,
0.31030797958374023,
-0.4001471996307373,
0.10443053394556046,
0.09856631606817245,
0.6268520951271057,
-0.012412617914378643,
0.5265695452690125,
0.7956557869911194,
-0.5300165414810181,
0.3332895040512085,
0.04595828428864479,
-0.11237537115812302,
0.8675886988639832,
-0.3670176565647125,
0.15280555188655853,
-0.28840744495391846,
0.3260773718357086,
-1.3048994541168213,
-0.41380393505096436,
0.49615898728370667,
-0.5062556862831116,
0.21015559136867523,
-0.2775116264820099,
-0.40860140323638916,
-0.19267840683460236,
-0.4462777376174927,
0.5167238116264343,
0.4619598388671875,
-0.2923213839530945,
1.2170873880386353,
-0.04124860465526581,
-0.10390232503414154,
-0.6962669491767883,
-0.5200300812721252,
-0.1666935682296753,
0.05768837779760361,
-1.0400562286376953,
0.26340675354003906,
-0.1433148980140686,
-0.20522886514663696,
0.08484183996915817,
-0.07509297877550125,
-0.22177426517009735,
0.06382182240486145,
0.33171284198760986,
0.5500065684318542,
-0.33225464820861816,
0.22811681032180786,
0.10572625696659088,
-0.4132438004016876,
-0.1543055921792984,
0.020800171419978142,
0.5390092134475708,
-0.13310018181800842,
-0.3857191205024719,
-0.6758293509483337,
0.5886746048927307,
0.6576730608940125,
-0.22451019287109375,
0.6385180950164795,
0.9472335577011108,
-0.25837790966033936,
-0.1367938220500946,
-0.7133061289787292,
-0.35658419132232666,
-0.4369746148586273,
0.17019672691822052,
-0.5680726170539856,
-0.6403989195823669,
0.45863667130470276,
0.00723204854875803,
-0.054385170340538025,
0.534880518913269,
0.5964316129684448,
-0.06259578466415405,
1.135993480682373,
0.7529305815696716,
-0.14943097531795502,
0.48619985580444336,
-0.05287294462323189,
0.025755465030670166,
-0.32924818992614746,
-0.5370480418205261,
-0.23161037266254425,
-0.3772878050804138,
-0.030796119943261147,
-0.6022574305534363,
0.5869140625,
-0.13450166583061218,
0.10452446341514587,
-0.04281599819660187,
-0.1857272982597351,
0.5806379318237305,
0.554956316947937,
0.4196966290473938,
0.22298303246498108,
-0.19249823689460754,
0.07891053706407547,
0.1384594589471817,
-0.7164890170097351,
-0.13023741543293,
0.5876123905181885,
0.25094935297966003,
0.7669482827186584,
-0.07774412631988525,
0.4316664934158325,
0.18866899609565735,
-0.3634231686592102,
-1.099769949913025,
0.6180882453918457,
0.14472950994968414,
-0.5558236241340637,
0.02699974924325943,
-0.3249439597129822,
-0.4588240385055542,
0.5528329014778137,
-0.4387909471988678,
-0.31936559081077576,
0.3353103995323181,
0.0605437271296978,
-0.7981671094894409,
-0.04432835802435875,
-0.8778607249259949,
0.9458641409873962,
-0.12069538980722427,
-0.27001169323921204,
-0.5376632809638977,
-1.0411853790283203,
0.5100914239883423,
0.2499392032623291,
0.47033336758613586,
-0.298166424036026,
-0.21941523253917694,
0.3519936203956604,
-0.2967013418674469,
1.0698384046554565,
-0.34328320622444153,
0.1050390973687172,
0.29632821679115295,
0.08293701708316803,
0.17753371596336365,
0.2142917513847351,
0.0888323187828064,
-0.16513213515281677,
-0.21882478892803192,
-0.5125439167022705,
-0.6154701709747314,
0.5191243290901184,
-0.6659415364265442,
-0.43915462493896484,
-0.3859892785549164,
-0.616425096988678,
-0.3011210262775421,
0.06870406866073608,
0.24175064265727997,
0.72817462682724,
0.05245322734117508,
0.06845948100090027,
0.7138262391090393,
0.15332305431365967,
0.6667720675468445,
0.3969414234161377,
0.24685092270374298,
-0.4150501489639282,
0.826623797416687,
-0.26641586422920227,
0.14570480585098267,
0.25275957584381104,
0.26341184973716736,
-0.041967593133449554,
-0.1770109385251999,
-0.5873008966445923,
0.12716057896614075,
-0.9751527905464172,
-0.5157198309898376,
-0.6239328980445862,
0.23037879168987274,
-0.45891305804252625,
-0.26339107751846313,
-0.14737287163734436,
-0.34121960401535034,
-0.6210566759109497,
0.07303386926651001,
0.411775678396225,
0.47537726163864136,
0.003422435838729143,
0.49358123540878296,
-1.0449228286743164,
0.5884310007095337,
0.40833571553230286,
-0.21493177115917206,
-0.06304919719696045,
-0.510327935218811,
0.10919342190027237,
-0.08281783759593964,
-0.04221689701080322,
-1.0755813121795654,
0.22053508460521698,
0.22293256223201752,
0.6583191156387329,
0.6944196224212646,
0.01229644101113081,
0.5004963874816895,
-0.2236381471157074,
1.0411635637283325,
0.6971636414527893,
-0.8967943787574768,
0.5648078322410583,
-0.3141467869281769,
0.4216318428516388,
0.8912829160690308,
0.27206045389175415,
-0.491982638835907,
-0.0413920097053051,
-0.3243788182735443,
-0.6637163162231445,
0.8170318007469177,
-0.2856144607067108,
0.275782972574234,
0.06879568099975586,
-0.06782404333353043,
0.707663893699646,
0.2891712784767151,
-0.6127445101737976,
-0.22068682312965393,
-0.29596471786499023,
-0.6242492198944092,
0.26718831062316895,
-0.2392606884241104,
-0.27928441762924194,
-0.22143474221229553,
0.408630907535553,
-0.4225422143936157,
0.07234618812799454,
-0.0062804692424833775,
-0.5608702898025513,
0.1195320338010788,
0.5362828969955444,
0.5182377696037292,
0.554215133190155,
0.11562171578407288,
0.3901574909687042,
0.008474319241940975,
-0.20318959653377533,
0.04179413616657257,
0.02750791609287262,
-0.004091562703251839,
0.01585831493139267,
0.43153396248817444,
0.7393466830253601,
0.32632750272750854,
-0.7152359485626221,
0.8813509345054626,
0.11711132526397705,
0.20824812352657318,
0.1673511266708374,
0.13913017511367798,
-0.43962082266807556,
0.3633304238319397,
0.6413518190383911,
0.6266250610351562,
0.25439682602882385,
-0.6649498343467712,
0.1274413913488388,
0.41141295433044434,
-0.3496840298175812,
-0.5305826663970947,
0.21817447245121002,
0.576168417930603,
-0.009723944589495659,
0.39621299505233765,
-0.3575615882873535,
-0.6941853761672974,
0.4585164785385132,
0.20683099329471588,
0.8656538724899292,
-0.04570871219038963,
0.43979665637016296,
-0.009457748383283615,
0.11675796657800674,
0.1247626394033432,
0.3788405954837799,
-0.19941791892051697,
-0.6707497239112854,
-0.37437620759010315,
-0.13201914727687836,
-0.20973065495491028,
-0.20671887695789337,
-0.30861037969589233,
0.5121957063674927,
-0.41140830516815186,
-0.08695056289434433,
-0.002903679385781288,
-0.29313135147094727,
-0.9086357951164246,
0.14541633427143097,
0.3697170317173004,
0.7932794690132141,
-1.0167486667633057,
0.42661893367767334,
0.7519341111183167,
-0.7657504081726074,
-0.628940761089325,
-0.08561524003744125,
0.3954164683818817,
-0.7349513173103333,
0.48937276005744934,
0.39604082703590393,
-0.3122254014015198,
-0.13976363837718964,
-0.6175427436828613,
-0.262662798166275,
1.0046178102493286,
0.26636794209480286,
-0.2889415919780731,
0.087905153632164,
-0.38386693596839905,
0.0985013023018837,
-0.4754505455493927,
0.6786322593688965,
0.43681979179382324,
0.5875824093818665,
0.22309987246990204,
-0.8566136956214905,
0.011056682094931602,
-0.2504083216190338,
-0.34508654475212097,
-0.13054457306861877,
-0.7586781978607178,
0.951076328754425,
-0.16013412177562714,
-0.055842287838459015,
-0.14909693598747253,
0.8552991151809692,
0.17453564703464508,
0.5736224055290222,
0.806629478931427,
0.24014712870121002,
0.7517132759094238,
0.10661844909191132,
0.9123406410217285,
-0.12567038834095,
0.03424741327762604,
0.8783335089683533,
-0.10184945911169052,
0.48927322030067444,
0.5618464350700378,
0.2052815556526184,
0.6473904848098755,
0.6644237637519836,
0.190072163939476,
0.729749321937561,
-0.5598146319389343,
-0.5597683787345886,
-0.756486177444458,
-0.35273176431655884,
-0.3227039575576782,
0.4335651695728302,
0.19010429084300995,
-0.24224403500556946,
-0.30593153834342957,
0.5042462944984436,
-0.09026004374027252,
-0.023653468117117882,
-0.4843388497829437,
0.9074199199676514,
0.029067883267998695,
-0.4717409312725067,
0.17136576771736145,
-0.07426369935274124,
1.078450083732605,
-0.4863843023777008,
0.09687238186597824,
-0.09255285561084747,
-0.09623943269252777,
-0.3204501271247864,
-0.7430074214935303,
-0.3080361485481262,
-0.1984511762857437,
-0.43055176734924316,
-0.07529173046350479,
0.9858167767524719,
-0.48308196663856506,
-0.4461490213871002,
-0.014384598471224308,
0.8652272820472717,
-0.08770528435707092,
-0.2916732430458069,
-0.7384947538375854,
-0.08051905035972595,
-0.23221030831336975,
-0.24611356854438782,
0.11906067281961441,
0.646209716796875,
0.23381371796131134,
0.5223382115364075,
0.32962754368782043,
-0.40321671962738037,
0.17054219543933868,
0.3165915310382843,
1.154977798461914,
-0.6064865589141846,
-0.5387137532234192,
-0.9528722167015076,
0.9049037098884583,
0.0041069695726037025,
-0.4880264401435852,
0.5562612414360046,
0.15684957802295685,
0.4393370747566223,
-0.30731090903282166,
0.7453076243400574,
-0.18611587584018707,
0.19189320504665375,
-0.6434924602508545,
0.33077219128608704,
-0.6951747536659241,
-0.13337677717208862,
-0.20069459080696106,
-0.672895610332489,
-0.17874100804328918,
0.4743691086769104,
-0.04909830912947655,
0.11182884126901627,
0.7364732623100281,
0.799788236618042,
-0.24058230221271515,
-0.05454771965742111,
0.380291610956192,
-0.05109015479683876,
0.12041313201189041,
0.5585697293281555,
1.0240086317062378,
-0.16286888718605042,
0.6146494746208191,
-0.358223557472229,
-0.30089110136032104,
-0.36892169713974,
-0.798643171787262,
-1.0436835289001465,
-0.6225040555000305,
-0.30751949548721313,
-0.07196509093046188,
-0.47023093700408936,
1.530349612236023,
0.7789972424507141,
-0.679967999458313,
0.3803881108760834,
0.20760081708431244,
0.38962534070014954,
-0.1901855617761612,
-0.269183874130249,
0.028372710570693016,
-0.678246796131134,
-0.6573505997657776,
0.8240013718605042,
0.442241370677948,
-0.1407105177640915,
-0.4694306254386902,
0.06521493941545486,
-0.056003328412771225,
0.05478835850954056,
0.7448104023933411,
-0.05525665730237961,
-0.9013569951057434,
-0.2356317639350891,
0.2302679866552353,
-0.22913861274719238,
0.02810298651456833,
0.9383676648139954,
-1.1261261701583862,
0.5545841455459595,
0.9614664912223816,
0.7208082675933838,
-0.018784131854772568,
0.15652869641780853,
0.385984867811203,
-0.9154824614524841,
0.4022457003593445,
0.3576202988624573,
0.4690902829170227,
0.30144479870796204,
-0.4014226496219635,
0.19533374905586243,
0.6174991726875305,
-0.203724205493927,
-0.6499465107917786,
0.3253190517425537,
-1.5600517988204956,
-0.4881850481033325,
1.215678334236145,
0.06175101920962334,
-0.3225167989730835,
-0.25739923119544983,
-0.6915011405944824,
-0.042433034628629684,
-0.7281835079193115,
0.4666108191013336,
0.6060785055160522,
-0.06561699509620667,
-0.492622435092926,
-0.061643194407224655,
0.16464775800704956,
0.564110517501831,
-0.6490349173545837,
-0.24683260917663574,
0.9599097967147827,
0.022072909399867058,
0.1660228818655014,
0.590836763381958,
0.28281593322753906,
0.6082565784454346,
-0.024277571588754654,
-0.18122106790542603,
-0.432558536529541,
-0.6853951811790466,
-0.545484185218811,
0.40342313051223755,
-0.2775558829307556,
-0.3381747901439667
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11299v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11299v1
|
SQ-LLaVA: Self-Questioning for Large Vision-Language Assistant
| 2024-03-17T18:42:38 | 2024-03-17T18:42:38 |
Guohao Sun, Can Qin, Jiamian Wang, Zeyuan Chen, Ran Xu, Zhiqiang Tao
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Recent advancements in the vision-language model have shown notable
generalization in vision-language tasks after visual instruction tuning.
However, bridging the gap between the pre-trained vision encoder and the large
language models becomes the whole network's bottleneck. To improve
cross-modality alignment, existing works usually consider more visual
instruction data covering a broader range of vision tasks to fine-tune the
model for question-answering, which are costly to obtain. However, the image
contains rich contextual information that has been largely under-explored. This
paper first attempts to harness this overlooked context within visual
instruction data, training the model to self-supervised `learning' how to ask
high-quality questions. In this way, we introduce a novel framework named
SQ-LLaVA: Self-Questioning for Large Vision-Language Assistant. SQ-LLaVA
exhibits proficiency in generating flexible and meaningful image-related
questions while analyzing the visual clue and prior language knowledge,
signifying an advanced level of generalized visual understanding. Moreover,
fine-tuning SQ-LLaVA on higher-quality instruction data shows a consistent
performance improvement compared with traditional visual-instruction tuning
methods. This improvement highlights the efficacy of self-questioning
techniques in achieving a deeper and more nuanced comprehension of visual
content across various contexts.
|
[
-0.5172225832939148,
-1.2056994438171387,
0.4835298955440521,
-0.06943239271640778,
-0.16768281161785126,
-0.20090550184249878,
-0.0415373295545578,
-0.476030170917511,
0.353098064661026,
0.6032441258430481,
-0.6112438440322876,
-0.18572190403938293,
-0.4257669448852539,
0.1514488309621811,
-0.24757730960845947,
0.28812137246131897,
-0.14433832466602325,
0.16558842360973358,
-0.3246013820171356,
-0.2415538728237152,
-0.8033798933029175,
-0.165617898106575,
-0.5405312776565552,
0.30314958095550537,
0.5958045125007629,
0.6826875805854797,
0.636050820350647,
0.5427852272987366,
0.44941988587379456,
0.416448712348938,
0.4619066119194031,
0.45255014300346375,
-0.40485307574272156,
0.41560518741607666,
-0.22463344037532806,
-0.746243417263031,
-0.28899043798446655,
-0.2693222761154175,
0.6382716298103333,
0.3367202579975128,
0.09485388547182083,
0.42476826906204224,
-0.11183666437864304,
0.5897365212440491,
-0.6944450736045837,
-0.13835623860359192,
-0.5197850465774536,
0.12462339550256729,
-0.12047810852527618,
-0.3152490258216858,
-0.08093155175447464,
0.025101060047745705,
-0.02717810496687889,
-0.829241931438446,
0.025852123275399208,
0.2561265826225281,
1.0255956649780273,
0.7263433337211609,
-0.48481208086013794,
-0.14518097043037415,
-0.3629840910434723,
0.5662217736244202,
-0.13390998542308807,
0.5251463055610657,
0.5054514408111572,
0.6323215961456299,
0.16997092962265015,
-0.6246230006217957,
-0.8138675093650818,
0.0432746596634388,
0.11142058670520782,
0.09320872277021408,
-0.14294268190860748,
-0.10720586031675339,
0.11698900908231735,
0.39241719245910645,
-0.8236615657806396,
-0.045755382627248764,
-0.5157502889633179,
-0.10340123623609543,
0.6704240441322327,
0.10701088607311249,
0.3372111916542053,
-0.16280658543109894,
-0.42959433794021606,
-0.15925166010856628,
-0.5730053186416626,
0.06488052010536194,
0.15078802406787872,
-0.2685345709323883,
0.20147714018821716,
0.7533794641494751,
-0.3535698652267456,
0.8766452670097351,
0.3028489351272583,
0.029390849173069,
0.03871975094079971,
-0.35544314980506897,
-0.4346151351928711,
-0.25846508145332336,
0.6182052493095398,
0.512946605682373,
0.5516546964645386,
0.3044373691082001,
-0.20096293091773987,
-0.22507202625274658,
0.3376665711402893,
-0.47478097677230835,
-0.14469444751739502,
0.0626901164650917,
-0.13798260688781738,
-0.08625560253858566,
-0.3975731134414673,
-0.7627546191215515,
-0.06613806635141373,
-0.4572412073612213,
0.8929359912872314,
-0.18835370242595673,
0.010076998732984066,
0.04816827550530434,
0.2643086612224579,
0.700912594795227,
0.749558687210083,
-0.9123349189758301,
-0.18430113792419434,
0.3389659821987152,
0.38813769817352295,
-0.17308369278907776,
-0.4922069013118744,
-0.6547285914421082,
0.16893376410007477,
-0.6052575707435608,
0.7214041352272034,
-0.5314423441886902,
-0.0992056354880333,
-0.09406133741140366,
0.16393330693244934,
-0.17804209887981415,
-0.48474934697151184,
-0.12493336945772171,
-0.6295263767242432,
0.5655036568641663,
-0.4352427124977112,
-0.4380883574485779,
-0.007371034473180771,
0.7245714664459229,
-0.3457094728946686,
1.1109118461608887,
0.1570807248353958,
-0.5306276082992554,
0.3155202865600586,
-0.31483975052833557,
-0.07355368137359619,
0.285591185092926,
-0.7461273670196533,
-0.24526913464069366,
-0.10500979423522949,
0.8426740765571594,
0.43674251437187195,
-0.17902149260044098,
0.21292851865291595,
-0.1508912891149521,
-0.28856831789016724,
0.15550750494003296,
-0.4667929410934448,
0.5725927352905273,
0.17918722331523895,
-0.43822339177131653,
0.19687020778656006,
-0.5594886541366577,
0.17128151655197144,
0.22783084213733673,
0.002449497813358903,
-0.3964978754520416,
-0.6482735872268677,
-0.3919730484485626,
0.03759505972266197,
0.5726687908172607,
-0.40152880549430847,
0.34092193841934204,
-0.15684007108211517,
0.006246952805668116,
0.7365590929985046,
0.02616501785814762,
0.421443372964859,
0.12912090122699738,
0.8652226328849792,
-0.21614086627960205,
0.711078941822052,
-0.32708027958869934,
-0.5308040976524353,
-1.0607938766479492,
0.018218355253338814,
0.018431352451443672,
0.6504238843917847,
-1.1696619987487793,
0.16950954496860504,
0.03901074081659317,
-0.13475169241428375,
-0.8512932062149048,
0.44600456953048706,
0.5049144625663757,
0.8082506656646729,
0.4947822690010071,
-0.29416942596435547,
-0.3478214144706726,
-1.008899211883545,
0.12637774646282196,
-0.10571354627609253,
0.16865694522857666,
0.5726125240325928,
0.43268948793411255,
-0.26225680112838745,
0.7418987154960632,
-0.632618248462677,
-0.3479265868663788,
-0.09426618367433548,
0.02418590523302555,
-0.23411495983600616,
0.4331243634223938,
0.35189616680145264,
-0.9068436026573181,
-0.4631462097167969,
-0.06481721997261047,
-1.0099934339523315,
-0.026904234662652016,
-0.23177470266819,
-0.3128809928894043,
0.09879804402589798,
0.8117886781692505,
-0.5023829340934753,
0.4650258719921112,
0.46358048915863037,
-0.2868287265300751,
0.5994119048118591,
-0.3275558054447174,
0.4263635277748108,
-0.9404224753379822,
-0.07355702668428421,
-0.24298739433288574,
-0.15818259119987488,
-0.5150562524795532,
0.35178470611572266,
0.08964484930038452,
-0.17027787864208221,
-0.36171549558639526,
0.6210127472877502,
-0.6094908118247986,
-0.35790544748306274,
-0.2599938213825226,
0.026883814483880997,
0.231086865067482,
0.5539653301239014,
-0.08459609746932983,
1.1655300855636597,
0.866232693195343,
-0.3647181987762451,
0.4895658493041992,
0.3957376778125763,
-0.32015150785446167,
0.8971036076545715,
-0.7881791591644287,
0.17121675610542297,
-0.22696660459041595,
-0.13156020641326904,
-1.1592731475830078,
-0.26983413100242615,
0.2538331151008606,
-0.4638654291629791,
0.38677483797073364,
-0.1754954308271408,
-0.1398366391658783,
-0.3053094744682312,
0.11749118566513062,
0.8345760107040405,
0.251857191324234,
-0.7499025464057922,
0.6280969977378845,
0.36517196893692017,
-0.08056435734033585,
-1.0120645761489868,
-0.5797988176345825,
0.2927420139312744,
-0.17912940680980682,
-0.9202867150306702,
-0.22530463337898254,
-0.10691750794649124,
-0.046344853937625885,
-0.23517484962940216,
-0.05367365479469299,
-0.2256171554327011,
-0.13346372544765472,
0.049769382923841476,
0.2648751735687256,
-0.45317909121513367,
0.2786419987678528,
-0.009206034243106842,
0.06947454810142517,
0.06550810486078262,
-0.09779366850852966,
0.34020817279815674,
-0.2904083728790283,
-0.584943413734436,
-0.429464727640152,
0.4708075523376465,
0.24425335228443146,
-0.48913663625717163,
0.03755246102809906,
0.705638587474823,
0.1034957766532898,
-0.09044519811868668,
-0.8412428498268127,
-0.1257152557373047,
-0.5448932647705078,
0.3703692853450775,
-0.6877442598342896,
-1.0786149501800537,
0.11747856438159943,
0.08215469866991043,
-0.21464259922504425,
0.13815739750862122,
0.4528285562992096,
-0.565617561340332,
0.8953660726547241,
0.6779845356941223,
0.1527758687734604,
0.4031924605369568,
-0.2803567349910736,
-0.014770048670470715,
-0.6558055877685547,
-0.2986831068992615,
0.05625953897833824,
-0.30362337827682495,
-0.1081138625741005,
-0.9272648096084595,
0.4932878613471985,
-0.04727012291550636,
-0.10570939630270004,
0.2483125478029251,
-0.4514208734035492,
0.5388476252555847,
0.6046112775802612,
-0.022402988746762276,
0.15081284940242767,
-0.03141070529818535,
0.15589718520641327,
-0.03129692003130913,
-0.5951758623123169,
-0.17114423215389252,
0.789096474647522,
0.4242413341999054,
1.0495117902755737,
-0.22741618752479553,
0.7183020710945129,
0.009458228014409542,
-0.3033826947212219,
-0.6177825927734375,
0.6765338778495789,
0.33817604184150696,
-0.6500608325004578,
-0.8777458667755127,
-0.18064181506633759,
-1.093933343887329,
0.5507107973098755,
-0.07020778208971024,
-0.4968259930610657,
0.5852893590927124,
0.504864513874054,
-0.2188470959663391,
0.0329735204577446,
-0.694075882434845,
1.1261138916015625,
-0.7961478233337402,
-0.44974783062934875,
-0.15768329799175262,
-0.79686039686203,
0.46783769130706787,
0.1833929866552353,
-0.0790993869304657,
0.04981515184044838,
-0.12394602596759796,
0.2876744270324707,
-0.22575314342975616,
0.8700054287910461,
-0.07888557016849518,
-0.4113527834415436,
0.41990527510643005,
0.15245692431926727,
0.24187436699867249,
0.09295939654111862,
0.5776888728141785,
0.0017913683550432324,
0.036659128963947296,
-0.45070478320121765,
-0.8702749609947205,
0.49436154961586,
-0.6786141395568848,
-0.979076087474823,
-0.22968636453151703,
-0.5140863656997681,
-0.3471006751060486,
0.17485925555229187,
0.20860643684864044,
0.3301171660423279,
-0.022692156955599785,
0.044701576232910156,
0.9737780094146729,
-0.4395171105861664,
0.05338802933692932,
0.2451506406068802,
-0.37204405665397644,
-0.3428983688354492,
0.8795912861824036,
-0.03971586748957634,
0.39909878373146057,
0.5608087182044983,
0.10379741340875626,
-0.2416059523820877,
-0.16773363947868347,
-0.9028339982032776,
0.24843177199363708,
-0.7601540088653564,
-0.1865031123161316,
-0.5068394541740417,
0.02935454435646534,
-0.49417224526405334,
-0.09034440666437149,
-0.451337993144989,
-0.2970229685306549,
-0.28815633058547974,
0.13800528645515442,
0.0681079551577568,
0.44894877076148987,
0.11697274446487427,
0.12612758576869965,
-0.43623894453048706,
0.4620228707790375,
1.0716015100479126,
0.09168572723865509,
-0.1894739866256714,
-0.6068967580795288,
-0.05026679486036301,
-0.09290701150894165,
-0.09915488958358765,
-0.9143202900886536,
0.3938143253326416,
0.2667481005191803,
0.44737115502357483,
0.2998282313346863,
-0.19708967208862305,
1.0491812229156494,
-0.4363638758659363,
0.7089908123016357,
0.2539961040019989,
-0.7060546278953552,
0.796036958694458,
-0.11271225661039352,
0.40877896547317505,
0.5563522577285767,
0.41134896874427795,
-0.33092960715293884,
-0.17652519047260284,
-0.29393088817596436,
-0.719097912311554,
0.24238674342632294,
-0.06777633726596832,
0.11916396766901016,
0.12254507839679718,
0.3438962996006012,
0.04214201867580414,
0.05204296112060547,
-0.6425055861473083,
-0.059543803334236145,
-0.5259026288986206,
-0.07879435271024704,
0.03211987391114235,
-0.1899804174900055,
-0.36809825897216797,
-0.5199363231658936,
0.3246002197265625,
-0.6235150694847107,
0.16467218101024628,
0.4855572283267975,
-0.42391812801361084,
-0.1775560826063156,
0.18707966804504395,
0.5189288854598999,
0.7573404908180237,
0.14480535686016083,
0.2116258591413498,
0.43356645107269287,
-0.3203071355819702,
-0.009031928144395351,
-0.3301115036010742,
-0.17903374135494232,
-0.24058176577091217,
0.2879663407802582,
0.8964521884918213,
0.10925976186990738,
-0.7917029857635498,
0.8742186427116394,
-0.21877719461917877,
-0.3064397871494293,
-0.3383684456348419,
0.20851890742778778,
-0.12654542922973633,
0.44629666209220886,
0.35173359513282776,
-0.440059632062912,
0.1966942995786667,
-0.5928232669830322,
0.3143613338470459,
0.5033396482467651,
-0.32105910778045654,
0.0371212437748909,
0.4204810559749603,
0.03733699768781662,
0.03900063410401344,
0.5125362873077393,
0.16035495698451996,
-0.42164185643196106,
0.5978679656982422,
0.36162862181663513,
0.38647058606147766,
-0.3424150049686432,
0.362684041261673,
0.3337479829788208,
0.37525826692581177,
0.2586324214935303,
0.6212495565414429,
-0.4320719838142395,
-0.5083152055740356,
-0.5365650653839111,
-0.32292798161506653,
-0.2947685122489929,
-0.07615083456039429,
-0.549068033695221,
0.025793002918362617,
-0.2541710138320923,
0.1486576497554779,
-0.3956279158592224,
-0.15356354415416718,
-0.7122641801834106,
0.5751333832740784,
0.22217512130737305,
0.7857747077941895,
-0.6624099612236023,
0.9610148072242737,
0.5700041055679321,
-0.6122047305107117,
-0.8967540860176086,
-0.16237010061740875,
-0.36726903915405273,
-1.401170015335083,
0.9376436471939087,
0.05962524563074112,
-0.1137549877166748,
-0.1672704666852951,
-0.8273046612739563,
-1.155759334564209,
1.1683086156845093,
0.25752076506614685,
-0.7362018823623657,
-0.25005123019218445,
0.1510709673166275,
0.5232327580451965,
-0.3940240442752838,
0.27129480242729187,
0.33527782559394836,
0.4542432725429535,
0.4042833149433136,
-0.848512589931488,
-0.037329137325286865,
-0.26509472727775574,
-0.16164237260818481,
0.07923294603824615,
-0.740865170955658,
0.7315506935119629,
-0.3544979393482208,
-0.00900332909077406,
0.007114384789019823,
0.9545757174491882,
-0.011297082528471947,
0.4532155394554138,
0.6801608800888062,
0.4426722228527069,
0.6611858010292053,
0.16346974670886993,
0.790276050567627,
-0.1285880208015442,
-0.03972167149186134,
1.1499111652374268,
0.0355549119412899,
0.739770770072937,
0.7440044283866882,
0.23936979472637177,
0.3078295886516571,
0.48021355271339417,
-0.24895861744880676,
0.2632468640804291,
-0.05291280150413513,
0.15034762024879456,
-0.6725148558616638,
0.18420273065567017,
-0.4158994257450104,
0.7857556343078613,
0.3407149314880371,
-0.08168298006057739,
-0.04955349117517471,
0.10238893330097198,
-0.7181122303009033,
0.060371141880750656,
-0.3482590317726135,
0.8084813952445984,
0.01963408850133419,
-0.881574809551239,
0.8256672024726868,
-0.5130675435066223,
0.4593493938446045,
-0.4522979259490967,
-0.1368403136730194,
-0.4313054382801056,
-0.1009315699338913,
0.014750534668564796,
-0.9596032500267029,
0.09119701385498047,
-0.23528186976909637,
0.26460596919059753,
-0.0502239465713501,
0.6231510639190674,
-0.6980419754981995,
-0.2644362449645996,
-0.06649211794137955,
0.6420928239822388,
0.37613099813461304,
0.03774391487240791,
-0.9983334541320801,
-0.03329126909375191,
0.011766333132982254,
-0.1521112322807312,
0.39254361391067505,
0.603765606880188,
-0.16970708966255188,
0.851280927658081,
0.31355488300323486,
-0.20819154381752014,
0.28488755226135254,
0.17916972935199738,
0.7857733368873596,
-0.6239148378372192,
-0.4600684940814972,
-0.33741068840026855,
0.35337620973587036,
-0.13273778557777405,
-0.6836652159690857,
0.780320405960083,
0.32948246598243713,
0.7943981289863586,
-0.08855698257684708,
0.3506326675415039,
0.18569305539131165,
0.12719714641571045,
-0.5532541275024414,
0.25811585783958435,
-1.0661091804504395,
-0.016836920753121376,
-0.09071218967437744,
-0.7140059471130371,
-0.10616294294595718,
0.808738112449646,
-0.39933085441589355,
-0.11064375936985016,
0.5182021260261536,
1.0949651002883911,
-0.09771130234003067,
-0.20999754965305328,
0.716023862361908,
-0.06116615608334541,
0.13120603561401367,
0.4975197911262512,
1.0546619892120361,
-0.511635959148407,
0.7042128443717957,
-0.1450144201517105,
-0.16531775891780853,
-0.35277265310287476,
-0.40557849407196045,
-0.9559940099716187,
-0.6925415992736816,
-0.23784653842449188,
-0.008165561594069004,
0.2231110781431198,
0.5656741261482239,
0.695698618888855,
-0.44958752393722534,
-0.12112082540988922,
0.09632711857557297,
-0.08545757830142975,
-0.056021884083747864,
-0.16438248753547668,
0.4333159625530243,
-0.5597628951072693,
-0.6548071503639221,
0.6068416237831116,
0.3818715810775757,
0.11439651250839233,
-0.6843301057815552,
-0.08085151016712189,
-0.26833951473236084,
-0.002491608029231429,
0.5081223845481873,
0.6273318529129028,
-0.7207973599433899,
-0.3111211657524109,
0.3580571413040161,
-0.2436448484659195,
0.21425433456897736,
0.5625424981117249,
-0.607411801815033,
0.9017407894134521,
0.4904845356941223,
0.9318782687187195,
0.6658443212509155,
0.2203480750322342,
0.646626353263855,
-0.7938097715377808,
-0.12912489473819733,
0.1769806146621704,
0.3831896483898163,
0.430480033159256,
-0.7375816106796265,
0.3907300531864166,
-0.049893055111169815,
-0.7062204480171204,
-0.5481644868850708,
0.4068964123725891,
-0.9958668351173401,
-0.4032863676548004,
1.0781214237213135,
0.025157378986477852,
-0.47235772013664246,
-0.04727458953857422,
-0.662832498550415,
0.04192351549863815,
0.07561898231506348,
0.7781447768211365,
0.2627514898777008,
-0.25563880801200867,
-0.6556389927864075,
-0.4828914701938629,
0.372996985912323,
0.9198575615882874,
-0.7920175790786743,
-0.07997005432844162,
0.6809260845184326,
0.27256378531455994,
-0.04525065794587135,
0.6675639748573303,
0.06566260010004044,
0.6467077732086182,
-0.06438540667295456,
0.08281241357326508,
-0.1710776537656784,
-0.5888538360595703,
-0.2748863101005554,
0.22090336680412292,
-0.015981009230017662,
-0.46166637539863586
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11297v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11297v1
|
A Modified Word Saliency-Based Adversarial Attack on Text Classification Models
| 2024-03-17T18:39:14 | 2024-03-17T18:39:14 |
Hetvi Waghela, Sneha Rakshit, Jaydip Sen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG
|
This paper introduces a novel adversarial attack method targeting text
classification models, termed the Modified Word Saliency-based Adversarial
At-tack (MWSAA). The technique builds upon the concept of word saliency to
strategically perturb input texts, aiming to mislead classification models
while preserving semantic coherence. By refining the traditional adversarial
attack approach, MWSAA significantly enhances its efficacy in evading detection
by classification systems. The methodology involves first identifying salient
words in the input text through a saliency estimation process, which
prioritizes words most influential to the model's decision-making process.
Subsequently, these salient words are subjected to carefully crafted
modifications, guided by semantic similarity metrics to ensure that the altered
text remains coherent and retains its original meaning. Empirical evaluations
conducted on diverse text classification datasets demonstrate the effectiveness
of the proposed method in generating adversarial examples capable of
successfully deceiving state-of-the-art classification models. Comparative
analyses with existing adversarial attack techniques further indicate the
superiority of the proposed approach in terms of both attack success rate and
preservation of text coherence.
|
[
-0.4523541331291199,
-1.1890960931777954,
0.20605133473873138,
-0.07710053771734238,
-0.5833583474159241,
0.08782464265823364,
0.041744478046894073,
-0.5228157043457031,
0.449312686920166,
0.5184103846549988,
-0.40073007345199585,
-0.4733884632587433,
-0.9866482019424438,
0.017620321363210678,
-0.6740251183509827,
1.158913493156433,
0.16883455216884613,
-0.12390220910310745,
0.026561297476291656,
-0.10218493640422821,
-0.3926900625228882,
-0.6237232089042664,
-0.6933363080024719,
0.04676924645900726,
0.8667905330657959,
-0.09135743230581284,
0.9506497383117676,
0.3257066309452057,
0.9531688690185547,
0.3195725381374359,
-0.4323767125606537,
-0.030650008469820023,
-0.4395734965801239,
-0.021243397146463394,
-0.0370955690741539,
-0.5444115996360779,
-0.40990686416625977,
0.30190181732177734,
0.41161784529685974,
0.32508233189582825,
0.10619769990444183,
-0.1547057181596756,
0.03528197482228279,
0.6153762936592102,
-1.1950218677520752,
-0.2857111990451813,
-1.1290775537490845,
0.06719356030225754,
-0.5351141095161438,
-0.3040485382080078,
-0.5956933498382568,
-0.23659703135490417,
0.20352144539356232,
-0.41549980640411377,
0.3632626533508301,
-0.057487230747938156,
1.0255788564682007,
0.4851391613483429,
-0.03854411467909813,
-0.2755489647388458,
-0.1677422821521759,
0.9011931419372559,
-0.4478778839111328,
0.08371222764253616,
0.46388179063796997,
0.3262903094291687,
-0.48012828826904297,
-0.6679898500442505,
-0.47450491786003113,
-0.24902553856372833,
0.032706961035728455,
0.2928662896156311,
-0.48400169610977173,
0.1186278909444809,
0.06579404324293137,
0.18656323850154877,
-0.19154423475265503,
-0.15847955644130707,
-0.283157080411911,
-0.12697020173072815,
0.7401297092437744,
-0.23795196413993835,
0.49451836943626404,
-0.2390587031841278,
-0.9470186829566956,
-0.18488554656505585,
-0.5541226863861084,
-0.051363151520490646,
0.28321146965026855,
0.1632724106311798,
0.1577211618423462,
0.4814439117908478,
-0.14167217910289764,
0.7885366082191467,
0.005332954227924347,
0.028193023055791855,
-0.1671449989080429,
-0.12046355754137039,
-0.39151811599731445,
0.33296871185302734,
0.7240362763404846,
0.2895417809486389,
-0.08090454339981079,
-0.28450077772140503,
-0.312833309173584,
0.3925422132015228,
0.8167060613632202,
-0.39433664083480835,
-0.3736266493797302,
-0.1182001456618309,
-0.2659430503845215,
-1.0670642852783203,
0.15414687991142273,
-1.0099700689315796,
-0.5542096495628357,
0.2547943890094757,
0.565605878829956,
-0.5572698712348938,
0.46416139602661133,
-0.05883106216788292,
-0.3400823771953583,
-0.15386468172073364,
0.4593174159526825,
-0.8021095991134644,
0.20817407965660095,
0.6771349906921387,
0.8024952411651611,
-0.24292530119419098,
-0.2962535321712494,
-0.4844796359539032,
0.2753984332084656,
-0.34153544902801514,
0.7502221465110779,
-0.6045905351638794,
-0.5282323956489563,
-0.25517553091049194,
-0.2558530271053314,
-0.04805278033018112,
-0.15411202609539032,
0.5546040534973145,
-1.0507245063781738,
0.5391466617584229,
-0.06156601756811142,
-0.2770926058292389,
-0.5640162229537964,
0.7747690677642822,
-0.8210022449493408,
0.7255194783210754,
-0.08795914053916931,
-1.1340904235839844,
0.3678058087825775,
-0.7260516285896301,
-0.2938821017742157,
-0.019346822053194046,
0.33108896017074585,
-0.6960012912750244,
0.3027969002723694,
0.12135086953639984,
0.3403916656970978,
0.11969880014657974,
-0.16503392159938812,
-0.4732697606086731,
-0.5506044030189514,
0.33324792981147766,
-0.9223847389221191,
0.5989487767219543,
0.06969042122364044,
-0.31511828303337097,
0.27996137738227844,
-0.7403422594070435,
-0.021968575194478035,
0.20646405220031738,
-0.2737716734409332,
-0.910682201385498,
-0.05223656818270683,
-0.10853841155767441,
-0.034973617643117905,
0.5057532787322998,
-0.4835754930973053,
0.1946975141763687,
-0.7858036756515503,
-0.06247005611658096,
0.6388207077980042,
0.24371184408664703,
0.15206439793109894,
-0.1915394514799118,
0.40773487091064453,
-0.31083646416664124,
0.3545052111148834,
0.07615114748477936,
-0.5295868515968323,
-0.7590640783309937,
-0.4756488800048828,
0.4186305105686188,
0.4931977689266205,
-0.9656364321708679,
0.341741144657135,
0.12081936746835709,
-0.5282602906227112,
-0.5939051508903503,
-0.3243337571620941,
0.6741671562194824,
0.11230167746543884,
0.6087409853935242,
-0.29917874932289124,
-0.4116062521934509,
-0.6943905353546143,
-0.7635909914970398,
-0.22100311517715454,
0.2050303816795349,
-0.024234609678387642,
0.4370310604572296,
-0.32174673676490784,
0.5062587857246399,
-0.711673378944397,
-0.272924542427063,
0.17373783886432648,
0.22194457054138184,
-0.6268954277038574,
0.2934674918651581,
0.744278609752655,
-1.091718077659607,
-0.44476673007011414,
-0.23600737750530243,
-0.4593627154827118,
0.09389136731624603,
-0.02242898941040039,
-0.28406551480293274,
0.26402929425239563,
0.41505399346351624,
-0.20186322927474976,
0.7338875532150269,
0.5109880566596985,
-0.579397439956665,
0.5777444839477539,
-0.1393892914056778,
0.49583765864372253,
-0.9592381715774536,
-0.23987552523612976,
-0.08666236698627472,
-0.07276309281587601,
-0.7964463233947754,
0.5102069973945618,
-0.037766922265291214,
-0.06246813386678696,
-0.47616612911224365,
0.5515131950378418,
-0.1647113859653473,
0.2173047959804535,
-0.6202678680419922,
0.22230499982833862,
0.08063845336437225,
0.3734169900417328,
-0.35882648825645447,
0.6041244864463806,
0.22277705371379852,
-0.43833667039871216,
0.49556151032447815,
0.33275049924850464,
0.06744448840618134,
0.5774630308151245,
-0.43457576632499695,
0.20752087235450745,
0.051214419305324554,
0.08220582455396652,
-0.8519976139068604,
-0.02687186934053898,
0.4919052720069885,
-0.5434246063232422,
0.5275642275810242,
0.17807111144065857,
-0.18133562803268433,
-0.12398814409971237,
-0.7776141166687012,
0.006088703870773315,
0.12197377532720566,
-0.8277142643928528,
0.43606385588645935,
0.2012709230184555,
-0.08386195451021194,
-0.8625821471214294,
-0.7491880655288696,
0.6051845550537109,
-0.32743948698043823,
-0.4197523295879364,
0.747075617313385,
0.16651728749275208,
-0.21459265053272247,
-0.14144201576709747,
0.1261497139930725,
-0.13824643194675446,
0.6354243159294128,
0.008281807415187359,
0.49359357357025146,
0.26440519094467163,
-0.1677374541759491,
-0.041832100600004196,
-0.10854535549879074,
-0.015327230095863342,
0.25001299381256104,
0.36385878920555115,
0.12507133185863495,
-0.39183902740478516,
-0.746595561504364,
0.23726718127727509,
0.7218334078788757,
-0.24794705212116241,
0.7414785027503967,
0.7049570083618164,
-0.42621445655822754,
-0.01136690005660057,
-0.2841915786266327,
-0.19166748225688934,
-0.4994838833808899,
0.7547800540924072,
-0.3244870603084564,
-0.4200889766216278,
0.1262647956609726,
0.19789427518844604,
-0.0796838328242302,
0.4408954083919525,
0.08961385488510132,
-0.12127194553613663,
1.051273226737976,
0.8419161438941956,
-0.3103548288345337,
0.7543594241142273,
-0.06809552758932114,
-0.07251224666833878,
-0.8315750956535339,
-0.3250340521335602,
-0.5309308767318726,
-0.32050055265426636,
-0.47160080075263977,
-0.29642942547798157,
0.12475961446762085,
0.16462603211402893,
0.17205463349819183,
0.3066049814224243,
-0.5759318470954895,
0.3789128363132477,
0.37041446566581726,
0.3680919408798218,
0.002767434110864997,
0.24797280132770538,
0.02205757424235344,
-0.22003470361232758,
-0.689691424369812,
-0.4885092079639435,
0.8883200883865356,
0.27971699833869934,
0.503362238407135,
0.29911699891090393,
0.6937264204025269,
0.5529723167419434,
0.5149391889572144,
-0.7556772232055664,
0.7156410217285156,
-0.6123095154762268,
-0.24592065811157227,
-0.17645849287509918,
-0.11230123788118362,
-0.8066674470901489,
0.4528660178184509,
-0.4677652418613434,
-0.6242436170578003,
0.05743942782282829,
0.19551555812358856,
-0.047310721129179,
0.6432799100875854,
-0.6862765550613403,
0.6549370288848877,
-0.17125284671783447,
-0.26687708497047424,
-0.3387035131454468,
-0.3565135598182678,
0.39004212617874146,
-0.272901326417923,
-0.0015781990950927138,
0.3589964807033539,
-0.32047656178474426,
0.8547436594963074,
-0.39640796184539795,
0.9871185421943665,
-0.268597275018692,
-0.20647156238555908,
-0.026151839643716812,
0.029897071421146393,
0.9546418190002441,
-0.5269731283187866,
-0.09471534937620163,
0.11464443802833557,
-0.3501797616481781,
-0.4912516474723816,
-0.6932657361030579,
0.5688857436180115,
-0.39967581629753113,
-0.7251959443092346,
-0.5206027030944824,
-0.3905417025089264,
-0.17451271414756775,
0.04600139334797859,
0.369061142206192,
0.3737644553184509,
-0.6024709343910217,
0.04980643466114998,
0.4158865213394165,
-0.07276475429534912,
0.48396191000938416,
0.31111544370651245,
0.22899304330348969,
-0.6311121582984924,
1.2023123502731323,
-0.13742037117481232,
0.519577145576477,
0.31243038177490234,
0.08221955597400665,
-0.2511279881000519,
-0.7438783645629883,
-0.2936362624168396,
-0.13048328459262848,
-0.6408871412277222,
-0.09375333786010742,
-0.549057126045227,
0.04850233346223831,
-0.21473512053489685,
-0.5736224055290222,
-0.10278678685426712,
-0.2345580905675888,
-0.4542211890220642,
0.468887060880661,
0.4552290141582489,
0.6897537112236023,
0.6129412651062012,
0.5136991143226624,
-0.7197555899620056,
0.2044091820716858,
0.27277740836143494,
0.10248883068561554,
-0.013591998256742954,
-0.5749770402908325,
-0.25921177864074707,
-0.04013969376683235,
-0.491486132144928,
-1.0844577550888062,
0.45698851346969604,
-0.0013214285718277097,
0.3663738965988159,
0.4540117084980011,
0.1865251064300537,
0.48903363943099976,
-0.38634437322616577,
0.9365246295928955,
0.5018764138221741,
-0.8366838693618774,
0.6847105026245117,
0.011054468341171741,
0.3627259135246277,
0.5128033757209778,
0.12678292393684387,
-0.23495268821716309,
-0.69677734375,
-0.9328051209449768,
-0.5560382604598999,
0.6049817204475403,
0.3319038152694702,
-0.13774044811725616,
0.22616046667099,
0.21134722232818604,
-0.12836547195911407,
0.3122571110725403,
-0.30513060092926025,
-0.21034924685955048,
-0.3748164176940918,
-0.3711659014225006,
0.014749211259186268,
-0.5105333924293518,
-0.18611331284046173,
0.22065649926662445,
0.9770850539207458,
0.024355702102184296,
-0.021614784374833107,
0.10640199482440948,
0.0485835075378418,
0.28415361046791077,
0.40938660502433777,
0.5702832937240601,
-0.07653938978910446,
0.0011958532268181443,
0.2544964551925659,
0.5000753998756409,
-0.9810091853141785,
0.14355729520320892,
0.29666388034820557,
-0.5590277910232544,
-0.015910161659121513,
0.2796255350112915,
0.814386248588562,
0.4790273606777191,
-0.3335941731929779,
0.4946140646934509,
-0.21379008889198303,
-0.0002719159238040447,
0.17072921991348267,
0.14000388979911804,
-0.5502316355705261,
0.26553279161453247,
0.22591464221477509,
0.7497169375419617,
0.22810667753219604,
-0.40640735626220703,
0.255710631608963,
0.8977569937705994,
-0.9333680868148804,
-0.22621534764766693,
0.4489963948726654,
0.09977211058139801,
-0.3366510570049286,
-0.3839719295501709,
-0.1042996495962143,
-1.0943135023117065,
0.6011267304420471,
0.44675707817077637,
0.9916709065437317,
-0.46639031171798706,
0.019941387698054314,
-0.18761761486530304,
0.3824272155761719,
0.06382323056459427,
-0.04965105280280113,
0.010032241232693195,
-0.5655757188796997,
0.27363717555999756,
-0.46921277046203613,
-0.38458138704299927,
0.19315706193447113,
-0.5622757077217102,
0.3167591691017151,
-0.7112628221511841,
-0.2964465916156769,
0.11928452551364899,
0.09254831820726395,
0.268207311630249,
0.7051443457603455,
0.08415884524583817,
0.5397617816925049,
-0.42108821868896484,
0.5877893567085266,
0.916428804397583,
-0.17424583435058594,
-0.24950112402439117,
0.589709460735321,
0.16749988496303558,
-0.4260385036468506,
0.43573442101478577,
-0.06357105821371078,
-0.5863227844238281,
-0.17086762189865112,
-0.5994467735290527,
-0.8316723704338074,
0.7580882906913757,
0.07659528404474258,
-0.19153480231761932,
0.13955198228359222,
-0.40830016136169434,
0.44767212867736816,
0.007621435914188623,
-0.3143135905265808,
0.42401114106178284,
0.38055676221847534,
0.07552658766508102,
-0.3617044985294342,
0.20526732504367828,
-0.20662689208984375,
0.02868320792913437,
0.2551741600036621,
-0.8120206594467163,
0.5914281606674194,
-0.18667097389698029,
-0.3220116198062897,
0.18466931581497192,
0.7894300222396851,
0.34752991795539856,
0.30701345205307007,
0.5728847980499268,
0.5195904970169067,
0.7375066876411438,
-0.2598172724246979,
1.133206844329834,
-0.1704992949962616,
0.326296865940094,
0.737504780292511,
0.058895543217659,
0.9328336715698242,
0.5216990113258362,
-0.1258499026298523,
0.43684810400009155,
0.45381787419319153,
-0.3413671553134918,
0.8687147498130798,
0.06056908890604973,
-0.5121858716011047,
0.1593283861875534,
0.06582508236169815,
-0.3725021183490753,
0.5388581156730652,
0.2706831097602844,
-0.37028732895851135,
-0.08393102884292603,
0.3168073892593384,
0.2570257782936096,
0.3485174775123596,
-0.42733535170555115,
0.7552279829978943,
-0.2564345896244049,
-0.39260879158973694,
0.8325865268707275,
0.36008772253990173,
1.2199054956436157,
-0.7560526132583618,
0.07479547709226608,
0.38028597831726074,
0.4494103789329529,
-0.20870627462863922,
-0.36594581604003906,
0.309835821390152,
0.2875880002975464,
-0.36689215898513794,
0.254535049200058,
1.1261498928070068,
-0.4772041141986847,
-0.5073805451393127,
0.23541900515556335,
-0.2876957952976227,
0.015707027167081833,
-0.1371169090270996,
-0.9295233488082886,
-0.07622785866260529,
0.18343473970890045,
-0.24622878432273865,
0.4484769403934479,
0.24149586260318756,
0.010499478317797184,
0.5317121148109436,
0.566398561000824,
0.31025430560112,
-0.17452438175678253,
-0.04127528890967369,
0.7818617224693298,
-0.5660861134529114,
-0.8776041269302368,
-0.852598249912262,
0.043187689036130905,
-0.3205106854438782,
0.0054834564216434956,
1.0252835750579834,
0.21377310156822205,
0.5037248730659485,
0.01484643667936325,
0.8145483136177063,
0.3269139230251312,
0.25158050656318665,
-0.7334813475608826,
1.2570691108703613,
-0.6522276997566223,
0.28900226950645447,
-0.5900936126708984,
-0.3211146593093872,
-0.3937811255455017,
0.2892971932888031,
-0.42842936515808105,
0.039453428238630295,
0.7262074947357178,
0.6248641014099121,
0.1692529022693634,
0.36606231331825256,
0.4329701364040375,
0.09746752679347992,
0.3206790089607239,
0.20051319897174835,
0.6278011798858643,
-0.8309486508369446,
0.5343011021614075,
-0.07833340764045715,
-0.4206860065460205,
-0.470193475484848,
-0.5980757474899292,
-0.9113044738769531,
-0.1443166881799698,
-0.45090362429618835,
-0.3717496693134308,
0.601487934589386,
0.47514957189559937,
0.29858672618865967,
-0.8161262273788452,
0.6455421447753906,
0.07635528594255447,
0.0361056886613369,
-0.15868857502937317,
-0.2790564000606537,
0.6487079858779907,
-0.34541037678718567,
-0.6720553636550903,
0.5391566753387451,
0.2330806851387024,
0.5279588103294373,
-0.3461698293685913,
0.24215349555015564,
-0.44065678119659424,
0.3579118847846985,
0.6420570611953735,
0.026012059301137924,
-0.788108766078949,
-0.36644983291625977,
-0.3740282654762268,
-0.2976319491863251,
-0.28987476229667664,
0.465411514043808,
-0.7287242412567139,
0.47359272837638855,
0.3008851706981659,
0.6727030277252197,
-0.05859657749533653,
0.26786738634109497,
0.3048838675022125,
-0.9606717228889465,
0.462964802980423,
0.10917098820209503,
0.26882147789001465,
0.48975732922554016,
-0.7123382687568665,
0.1128707230091095,
0.5924983024597168,
0.03885475918650627,
-0.867607593536377,
0.2209005355834961,
-0.6832189559936523,
-0.6433241367340088,
0.8531472682952881,
-0.2661142349243164,
-0.5713344812393188,
-0.19423122704029083,
-0.4387499690055847,
0.23819991946220398,
-0.3806092143058777,
1.239280343055725,
0.6541062593460083,
0.3418743312358856,
0.44183218479156494,
-0.07971300184726715,
0.7986882925033569,
0.49817267060279846,
-0.8142538666725159,
-0.022536111995577812,
0.22808875143527985,
-0.09843549132347107,
0.4439498782157898,
0.10243606567382812,
-0.22652707993984222,
0.35377663373947144,
0.11450671404600143,
-0.14729046821594238,
-0.13961820304393768,
-0.4259476661682129,
-0.5586290955543518,
0.5432955622673035,
-0.39528289437294006,
-0.5640891790390015
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11265v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11265v1
|
Forging the Forger: An Attempt to Improve Authorship Verification via Data Augmentation
| 2024-03-17T16:36:26 | 2024-03-17T16:36:26 |
Silvia Corbara, Alejandro Moreo
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Authorship Verification (AV) is a text classification task concerned with
inferring whether a candidate text has been written by one specific author or
by someone else. It has been shown that many AV systems are vulnerable to
adversarial attacks, where a malicious author actively tries to fool the
classifier by either concealing their writing style, or by imitating the style
of another author. In this paper, we investigate the potential benefits of
augmenting the classifier training set with (negative) synthetic examples.
These synthetic examples are generated to imitate the style of the author of
interest. We analyze the improvements in classifier prediction that this
augmentation brings to bear in the task of AV in an adversarial setting. In
particular, we experiment with three different generator architectures (one
based on Recurrent Neural Networks, another based on small-scale transformers,
and another based on the popular GPT model) and with two training strategies
(one inspired by standard Language Models, and another inspired by Wasserstein
Generative Adversarial Networks). We evaluate our hypothesis on five datasets
(three of which have been specifically collected to represent an adversarial
setting) and using two learning algorithms for the AV classifier (Support
Vector Machines and Convolutional Neural Networks). This experimentation has
yielded negative results, revealing that, although our methodology proves
effective in many adversarial settings, its benefits are too sporadic for a
pragmatical application.
|
[
-0.20770838856697083,
-0.9262305498123169,
0.510008692741394,
-0.4936613440513611,
-0.10744758695363998,
0.22233398258686066,
-0.010991504415869713,
-0.46234846115112305,
0.07634208351373672,
0.5270294547080994,
-0.2933594584465027,
-0.1780475378036499,
-0.6818526983261108,
0.37912464141845703,
-0.6178382635116577,
0.830982506275177,
0.19969721138477325,
0.00502196466550231,
-0.5237265825271606,
-0.08167313039302826,
-0.5902401804924011,
-0.7183021306991577,
-0.7063592672348022,
-0.45811396837234497,
0.48822182416915894,
-0.16487713158130646,
0.7699005603790283,
0.7545613050460815,
0.3245498836040497,
0.4526965618133545,
0.14657044410705566,
0.2949027419090271,
-0.40167656540870667,
0.2054179608821869,
-0.14349506795406342,
-0.5796451568603516,
-0.060333382338285446,
0.20943109691143036,
0.49895891547203064,
0.3044761121273041,
0.5134592652320862,
0.016598118469119072,
-0.1685129702091217,
0.4650506377220154,
-0.7612218856811523,
0.02296869456768036,
-0.6990014910697937,
-0.058190178126096725,
-0.43177956342697144,
-0.3414041996002197,
-0.7694603800773621,
-0.41410747170448303,
-0.15893787145614624,
-0.4813728928565979,
0.5417425036430359,
0.019148685038089752,
0.6385040283203125,
0.17960241436958313,
-0.4238024652004242,
-0.2620704174041748,
-1.0071111917495728,
0.5826460719108582,
-0.4004959166049957,
0.07410243898630142,
0.18708989024162292,
0.38849982619285583,
-0.12301801145076752,
-0.5927899479866028,
-0.8522370457649231,
-0.2903720736503601,
-0.24962404370307922,
-0.0445520393550396,
-0.18728838860988617,
0.15062350034713745,
0.350172221660614,
0.8456171154975891,
-0.39350074529647827,
-0.08356896042823792,
-0.6031983494758606,
-0.408879816532135,
0.9167796969413757,
-0.07897461950778961,
0.4261843264102936,
0.14227332174777985,
-0.31292015314102173,
-0.5287001729011536,
-0.9205188751220703,
0.3576313555240631,
0.9842647314071655,
0.49221935868263245,
0.330970823764801,
0.7345826029777527,
0.2082214057445526,
0.680512547492981,
0.3421616852283478,
0.17166319489479065,
0.3787015974521637,
0.02593197301030159,
-0.19966356456279755,
0.24715331196784973,
0.5533503293991089,
-0.201181560754776,
0.022716958075761795,
-0.36680352687835693,
-0.309268057346344,
0.36347195506095886,
0.6362816095352173,
-0.5371512174606323,
-0.3272112011909485,
0.19303588569164276,
-0.34628599882125854,
-0.7881965041160583,
0.5804584622383118,
-0.3246082365512848,
-0.8065376281738281,
-0.508617639541626,
0.8550278544425964,
-0.6344583630561829,
-0.18829211592674255,
-0.3435891568660736,
-0.5364789962768555,
0.32378315925598145,
0.3452364504337311,
-0.7079343795776367,
-0.11540825664997101,
1.0047194957733154,
0.5348864793777466,
0.019800301641225815,
-0.38126322627067566,
-0.8940623998641968,
-0.3167271912097931,
-0.6491315364837646,
0.5204548835754395,
-0.4806574881076813,
-0.13501283526420593,
0.21719422936439514,
0.017571812495589256,
0.035724908113479614,
-0.34949585795402527,
0.3810708522796631,
-0.75306636095047,
0.2818761467933655,
-0.4281548857688904,
-0.5914623141288757,
-0.29756397008895874,
0.42643222212791443,
-0.8665317296981812,
0.8600257635116577,
0.15419809520244598,
-0.511228084564209,
0.5796427726745605,
-0.2918749451637268,
-0.5884181261062622,
0.1894359290599823,
-0.4284827709197998,
-0.7998281717300415,
0.25617218017578125,
0.21930785477161407,
0.4482573866844177,
0.09254848957061768,
-0.16573195159435272,
-0.2628762125968933,
-0.4472636282444,
0.3571837246417999,
-0.3651387393474579,
0.9574195742607117,
0.21088597178459167,
-0.326554536819458,
0.009160196408629417,
-0.7304883003234863,
-0.3224090039730072,
0.0025404721964150667,
-0.1940607726573944,
-0.5413348078727722,
-0.1149124950170517,
-0.24842098355293274,
-0.18352186679840088,
-0.1884789764881134,
-0.84886234998703,
0.282372385263443,
-0.6920127868652344,
-0.23232726752758026,
1.1352266073226929,
0.13537654280662537,
0.35947108268737793,
-0.6952316164970398,
0.7300342321395874,
-0.36433708667755127,
-0.13816508650779724,
-0.3146454691886902,
-0.36020389199256897,
-0.5241929292678833,
-0.4261454939842224,
0.45761990547180176,
0.42509976029396057,
-1.3446358442306519,
0.28324514627456665,
-0.17076607048511505,
-0.49261903762817383,
-0.5541875958442688,
0.2338137924671173,
0.5323735475540161,
0.23705820739269257,
0.30992382764816284,
-0.16125771403312683,
-0.6201860904693604,
-0.5284873247146606,
-0.7147527933120728,
-0.36503279209136963,
-0.06326209008693695,
0.008449521847069263,
0.46257176995277405,
-0.13042375445365906,
0.7341859936714172,
-0.07380779832601547,
-0.3105947971343994,
-0.2631000876426697,
0.16037248075008392,
0.01725708693265915,
0.47208088636398315,
0.6421829462051392,
-0.7803433537483215,
-0.3587417006492615,
0.09239725768566132,
-0.8109315633773804,
0.22642293572425842,
-0.5856156349182129,
0.13422484695911407,
-0.015504646115005016,
0.5787377953529358,
-0.32402363419532776,
0.5431700944900513,
0.2525523900985718,
-0.339503675699234,
0.6420168280601501,
0.07540528476238251,
0.3617836833000183,
-1.0781611204147339,
-0.10069601237773895,
-0.07630471140146255,
-0.32754644751548767,
-0.8166177868843079,
0.30952638387680054,
-0.3005428910255432,
-0.1457667350769043,
-0.34551888704299927,
0.38571715354919434,
-0.39443665742874146,
0.3578717112541199,
-0.254547119140625,
-0.4468204081058502,
-0.10771837085485458,
0.32910090684890747,
-0.28462672233581543,
0.9456856846809387,
0.5595606565475464,
-0.5382983088493347,
0.7247601747512817,
0.22899608314037323,
-0.14027902483940125,
0.605017364025116,
-0.60626620054245,
0.3450474143028259,
-0.4415656626224518,
0.07134357839822769,
-1.027982473373413,
-0.29508891701698303,
0.22693896293640137,
-0.8379461169242859,
0.728204071521759,
-0.24623700976371765,
-0.41991275548934937,
-0.19147424399852753,
-0.565959632396698,
0.3272874355316162,
0.4749636650085449,
-0.914181113243103,
1.0431568622589111,
0.061249565333127975,
0.09968264400959015,
-0.7356621026992798,
-0.6339102983474731,
0.25445348024368286,
-0.11291726678609848,
-0.7033942937850952,
0.49972105026245117,
0.3544944226741791,
-0.4722990393638611,
-0.10198760032653809,
0.06736575812101364,
0.21999922394752502,
-0.009525636211037636,
0.3460966944694519,
0.2544940114021301,
-0.12466259300708771,
0.2104608118534088,
-0.03210083395242691,
-0.06981100142002106,
0.17751173675060272,
-0.14937631785869598,
0.17485317587852478,
-0.12370073795318604,
-0.5086811184883118,
-0.5600835680961609,
0.29945141077041626,
0.565912663936615,
-0.21215033531188965,
0.8673619031906128,
0.6593713760375977,
-0.2260606288909912,
-0.3705379068851471,
-0.6516045331954956,
-0.37228065729141235,
-0.5359774827957153,
0.017066404223442078,
-0.3684496581554413,
-0.7001014947891235,
0.46535739302635193,
0.06624987721443176,
0.19602398574352264,
0.6679019927978516,
0.38986560702323914,
0.12931522727012634,
0.8769388198852539,
0.42887693643569946,
-0.15168359875679016,
0.6961390376091003,
-0.5510848164558411,
0.179120272397995,
-0.6131435632705688,
-0.2671545743942261,
-0.39420872926712036,
-0.3186827301979065,
-0.6810905933380127,
-0.1311524212360382,
0.4042357802391052,
-0.6427541971206665,
-0.01359474379569292,
0.46887916326522827,
-0.6887732744216919,
0.5405184030532837,
0.7744343876838684,
0.3787015676498413,
-0.054702915251255035,
0.16574084758758545,
0.20075413584709167,
0.17517121136188507,
-0.3384650647640228,
-0.48588114976882935,
1.3052011728286743,
0.17834427952766418,
0.7261315584182739,
0.21029996871948242,
0.7815478444099426,
0.8730611801147461,
0.24807576835155487,
-0.5089004635810852,
0.32972440123558044,
-0.22215571999549866,
-0.8889899253845215,
-0.24480792880058289,
-0.2977859377861023,
-0.8168692588806152,
0.20674273371696472,
-0.3646680414676666,
-0.428154855966568,
0.46814268827438354,
0.6317967176437378,
-0.36756840348243713,
0.4434472620487213,
-0.5301437377929688,
0.5520098209381104,
-0.1419348418712616,
-0.6361681222915649,
0.11063152551651001,
-0.5282732248306274,
0.311297744512558,
0.208339661359787,
-0.08450629562139511,
0.6604834198951721,
0.5073272585868835,
0.3866761326789856,
-0.7701226472854614,
0.803540050983429,
-0.38823431730270386,
0.14813189208507538,
0.3985922932624817,
0.06132693216204643,
0.893276572227478,
-0.016028285026550293,
-0.36833271384239197,
-0.18991415202617645,
-0.30345824360847473,
-0.22237035632133484,
-0.6757645010948181,
0.46929702162742615,
-0.8374290466308594,
-0.6107029318809509,
-0.7421453595161438,
-0.04699716717004776,
0.009889069013297558,
-0.014671656303107738,
0.6049434542655945,
0.5783867835998535,
-0.2562316656112671,
0.5445744395256042,
0.703370213508606,
-0.1287590116262436,
-0.00870414637029171,
-0.22604823112487793,
0.3410182297229767,
-0.5615741610527039,
1.0042475461959839,
-0.10917124897241592,
0.1639745682477951,
0.49426645040512085,
0.07306152582168579,
-0.2037510871887207,
-0.5725967288017273,
-0.6170032024383545,
-0.12504172325134277,
-0.6505301594734192,
-0.3245386481285095,
-0.5350649952888489,
-0.26179808378219604,
-0.5443682074546814,
-0.43924179673194885,
-0.20256945490837097,
-0.48022231459617615,
-0.30768829584121704,
-0.22292061150074005,
0.36929851770401,
0.5174042582511902,
0.14725430309772491,
0.2607230544090271,
-0.20536425709724426,
0.2592109143733978,
0.48139506578445435,
-0.0928865298628807,
-0.12132105976343155,
-0.5843935608863831,
-0.11141389608383179,
0.13646933436393738,
-0.498495489358902,
-0.7707446813583374,
0.1512986719608307,
0.20928680896759033,
0.5949597358703613,
0.5174895524978638,
0.06534282863140106,
0.5507373809814453,
-0.268344908952713,
1.0039628744125366,
-0.030931133776903152,
-0.7908056974411011,
0.4598560929298401,
-0.3072613775730133,
-0.17314176261425018,
0.9105750322341919,
-0.08891492336988449,
-0.17398938536643982,
-0.6650018692016602,
-0.6872480511665344,
-0.7107390761375427,
0.5702871680259705,
0.4758142828941345,
0.33715829253196716,
0.22481927275657654,
0.6148276329040527,
0.31995800137519836,
0.10132654011249542,
-0.8692349195480347,
-0.13891389966011047,
-0.4285438060760498,
-0.0005573030794039369,
-0.11360709369182587,
-0.04422742873430252,
-0.07606597989797592,
-0.2404414415359497,
1.1627825498580933,
0.04230864718556404,
0.34970179200172424,
0.34784236550331116,
-0.16411328315734863,
0.08524739742279053,
0.035182464867830276,
0.42558079957962036,
0.3117668032646179,
0.01808479242026806,
0.33826127648353577,
0.1719236820936203,
-0.251786470413208,
0.2401169240474701,
0.33917540311813354,
-0.3701801896095276,
0.12289188802242279,
0.8787236213684082,
0.7337543368339539,
-0.6486436724662781,
-0.1632491648197174,
0.8199504017829895,
0.08567867428064346,
-0.3274326026439667,
-0.7091609835624695,
0.38365840911865234,
-0.6239993572235107,
0.1970437467098236,
0.41319435834884644,
0.49896717071533203,
0.3110359311103821,
-0.6542476415634155,
0.17308282852172852,
0.7051836848258972,
-0.3693813383579254,
-0.5182493925094604,
0.7110274434089661,
0.07497309893369675,
-0.520416796207428,
0.46241554617881775,
-0.3330155611038208,
-0.6049590110778809,
0.6147160530090332,
0.46316733956336975,
1.061327338218689,
-0.29647010564804077,
0.06465332210063934,
0.27987581491470337,
0.5526525974273682,
-0.11703620105981827,
-0.0145182516425848,
-0.20618732273578644,
-0.4924812316894531,
-0.36510032415390015,
-0.26649779081344604,
-0.35945385694503784,
0.16852104663848877,
-0.3549654185771942,
0.3000688850879669,
-0.5050653219223022,
-0.0559174045920372,
0.23399539291858673,
-0.08216048777103424,
-0.6274200677871704,
0.10137169063091278,
-0.04932166263461113,
0.5047691464424133,
-1.1742194890975952,
0.2972753643989563,
0.7737920880317688,
-0.42895564436912537,
-0.6540886759757996,
-0.11060728877782822,
0.4076550006866455,
-0.5608481168746948,
0.3025258183479309,
0.3042885661125183,
-0.2449401617050171,
-0.29897719621658325,
-0.5378050804138184,
-0.3678998053073883,
1.0058720111846924,
0.3814130425453186,
-0.05934232473373413,
0.11941404640674591,
0.08891773968935013,
0.6798044443130493,
-0.271526038646698,
-0.17457763850688934,
0.05103378742933273,
0.29665422439575195,
0.3092852234840393,
-0.1904090940952301,
0.2706638276576996,
-0.6107726693153381,
0.07276679575443268,
0.11556567996740341,
-0.2588691711425781,
0.9467569589614868,
-0.018112407997250557,
-0.19085541367530823,
0.26302260160446167,
0.6726191639900208,
0.023322919383645058,
0.41079026460647583,
0.5425053834915161,
0.5315124988555908,
0.6138681173324585,
-0.13919149339199066,
1.4370143413543701,
0.09417951852083206,
-0.009271621704101562,
0.8587040901184082,
0.07352666556835175,
0.19159267842769623,
0.4042831361293793,
-0.13583943247795105,
0.6304633617401123,
0.31782644987106323,
-0.4448293149471283,
0.3844842314720154,
0.13481342792510986,
-0.5145466327667236,
-0.15935902297496796,
0.22924527525901794,
-0.5909676551818848,
0.5601931214332581,
-0.02877073362469673,
-0.8864886164665222,
0.21713724732398987,
0.22213616967201233,
0.08221037685871124,
0.3883725106716156,
-0.026928305625915527,
0.9052473306655884,
-0.254720538854599,
-0.8388829231262207,
0.31050413846969604,
0.015890900045633316,
0.4554409384727478,
-0.3545415997505188,
-0.1852983981370926,
0.23705866932868958,
0.6191266179084778,
-0.3667483925819397,
-0.12581312656402588,
0.39718499779701233,
-0.12974224984645844,
-0.07539128512144089,
-0.31958287954330444,
0.8897830247879028,
-0.2625117897987366,
-0.8841103315353394,
-0.35514119267463684,
0.14200027287006378,
-0.1608368307352066,
-0.27215296030044556,
-0.12545043230056763,
0.007534054573625326,
-0.06983885914087296,
-0.08537653088569641,
-0.0745568498969078,
0.371682345867157,
0.14805391430854797,
0.21881861984729767,
1.0712929964065552,
0.23396456241607666,
-0.2317003756761551,
-0.0842047855257988,
0.9404544830322266,
-0.1304936558008194,
-0.34497910737991333,
-1.27628493309021,
0.5380961298942566,
-0.4147651791572571,
-0.2973877787590027,
1.1321269273757935,
0.7952781915664673,
0.8372071981430054,
-0.1522754728794098,
0.9883213043212891,
-0.15661869943141937,
0.37664371728897095,
-0.4263969361782074,
0.6149956583976746,
-0.4827605187892914,
0.4246731698513031,
-0.5109068155288696,
-0.49075865745544434,
-0.45439594984054565,
0.5427259802818298,
-0.3374728262424469,
0.18351341784000397,
0.29348182678222656,
0.8450735211372375,
-0.03741644695401192,
-0.025381173938512802,
0.23257556557655334,
-0.1827867478132248,
0.7845571041107178,
0.05216570571064949,
0.8178930282592773,
-0.7695580720901489,
0.40662628412246704,
-0.36225223541259766,
-0.3334609866142273,
-0.23504090309143066,
-0.6924842596054077,
-1.2553154230117798,
-0.6690036654472351,
-0.3401639759540558,
-0.7510830760002136,
0.44133561849594116,
0.9649726748466492,
0.6326629519462585,
-0.7214103937149048,
0.3226214349269867,
-0.27006784081459045,
0.236687570810318,
-0.5986367464065552,
-0.21655681729316711,
0.3356553018093109,
-0.19647040963172913,
-0.49312227964401245,
0.29329973459243774,
-0.012531270273029804,
0.016074534505605698,
-0.19805166125297546,
0.025354519486427307,
0.020696420222520828,
0.2025556117296219,
0.5383821725845337,
0.43874770402908325,
-0.6584466099739075,
-0.46892470121383667,
0.02927798591554165,
0.35390982031822205,
-0.07971227914094925,
1.0373038053512573,
-0.7886965870857239,
0.9868715405464172,
0.5266780853271484,
1.0136722326278687,
0.2402498424053192,
0.4697536826133728,
0.7233856916427612,
-0.9986168146133423,
-0.04520123451948166,
0.41696566343307495,
0.24116453528404236,
0.3780621886253357,
-0.9062415957450867,
0.2532740831375122,
0.26771003007888794,
-0.5056562423706055,
-0.9046737551689148,
0.22432425618171692,
-0.6333642601966858,
-0.0659501925110817,
1.0342817306518555,
0.02317824400961399,
-0.14372225105762482,
-0.18056747317314148,
-0.1585298478603363,
0.20938976109027863,
-0.31755638122558594,
1.1694772243499756,
0.5746250748634338,
0.013469263911247253,
0.13113899528980255,
0.022675681859254837,
0.6847702264785767,
0.012188529595732689,
-0.63755863904953,
0.04080582782626152,
0.5366325378417969,
-0.011731457896530628,
0.45245203375816345,
0.5267970561981201,
-0.22121569514274597,
0.6239789128303528,
0.21815738081932068,
-0.06680849939584732,
-0.7221870422363281,
-0.2825583815574646,
-0.3077353835105896,
0.29378002882003784,
-0.0017712742555886507,
-0.3440583348274231
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11236v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11236v2
|
ChartThinker: A Contextual Chain-of-Thought Approach to Optimized Chart Summarization
| 2024-03-17T14:49:09 | 2024-04-25T03:04:14 |
Mengsha Liu, Daoyuan Chen, Yaliang Li, Guian Fang, Ying Shen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Data visualization serves as a critical means for presenting data and mining
its valuable insights. The task of chart summarization, through natural
language processing techniques, facilitates in-depth data analysis of charts.
However, there still are notable deficiencies in terms of visual-language
matching and reasoning ability for existing approaches. To address these
limitations, this study constructs a large-scale dataset of comprehensive
chart-caption pairs and fine-tuning instructions on each chart. Thanks to the
broad coverage of various topics and visual styles within this dataset, better
matching degree can be achieved from the view of training data. Moreover, we
propose an innovative chart summarization method, ChartThinker, which
synthesizes deep analysis based on chains of thought and strategies of context
retrieval, aiming to improve the logical coherence and accuracy of the
generated summaries. Built upon the curated datasets, our trained model
consistently exhibits superior performance in chart summarization tasks,
surpassing 8 state-of-the-art models over 7 evaluation metrics. Our dataset and
codes are publicly accessible.
|
[
-0.48865658044815063,
-0.5722993016242981,
0.3154365122318268,
-0.16825594007968903,
-0.7120224237442017,
0.450575590133667,
-0.08996649086475372,
-0.28335750102996826,
0.47259876132011414,
0.5145386457443237,
-0.47519436478614807,
-0.7003698348999023,
-0.4045342803001404,
-0.08993539959192276,
-0.32268092036247253,
1.001952052116394,
-0.16247908771038055,
-0.12229170650243759,
-0.13172748684883118,
-0.1884545087814331,
-0.9850910902023315,
-0.17663855850696564,
-0.43572744727134705,
-0.04689469188451767,
0.2943994402885437,
0.7331377863883972,
0.5157530307769775,
0.5564206838607788,
0.7226511240005493,
0.29059484601020813,
0.2243676334619522,
0.4788273572921753,
-1.0814714431762695,
0.244644895195961,
-0.14423325657844543,
-0.23364071547985077,
-0.5935209393501282,
-0.1890859603881836,
0.19403761625289917,
0.7815290093421936,
0.20024019479751587,
0.41333040595054626,
-0.14347268640995026,
1.1895335912704468,
-0.5184983611106873,
0.580440104007721,
-0.4220671057701111,
0.15331622958183289,
-0.024606361985206604,
-0.6343051195144653,
-0.25672656297683716,
-0.5487785339355469,
0.42338207364082336,
-0.7477917671203613,
0.007282799109816551,
0.3155244290828705,
0.5358316898345947,
0.2826600670814514,
-0.5969641804695129,
-0.22502632439136505,
-0.5681388974189758,
0.4772125780582428,
-0.6093042492866516,
0.08672782778739929,
0.1735605001449585,
0.7645685076713562,
0.3221631646156311,
-1.0095577239990234,
-0.2116587907075882,
0.25013458728790283,
-0.21612069010734558,
0.409968763589859,
-0.20614713430404663,
-0.2527702748775482,
0.055790361016988754,
0.5524961352348328,
-0.6604014039039612,
-0.20235572755336761,
-0.6461192965507507,
0.04335157573223114,
0.8091586232185364,
0.5163325667381287,
0.3860933482646942,
-0.14700207114219666,
-0.1820889115333557,
-0.21132831275463104,
-0.30839112401008606,
-0.07150235772132874,
-0.05264529958367348,
0.4290819466114044,
-0.4655611217021942,
0.5297837853431702,
-0.4194260835647583,
0.6647953391075134,
0.03889843821525574,
-0.016790222376585007,
0.1280404031276703,
-0.4794958829879761,
-0.279919296503067,
0.19700609147548676,
0.6081873178482056,
1.0673028230667114,
0.664089024066925,
-0.2579456865787506,
0.04669993743300438,
-0.12101670354604721,
0.42393651604652405,
-0.8216784596443176,
-0.6622412204742432,
0.18920518457889557,
-0.33653560280799866,
-0.501162052154541,
0.1068752333521843,
-0.45737409591674805,
-0.5072268843650818,
-0.820223867893219,
0.06052302569150925,
-0.38660410046577454,
0.02286497876048088,
-0.09600751101970673,
-0.5740295648574829,
-0.25371256470680237,
0.31293001770973206,
-0.5400911569595337,
0.03723343089222908,
0.6505963206291199,
0.8623988628387451,
-0.056371837854385376,
-0.07319720834493637,
-0.3283228576183319,
0.5366308689117432,
-0.690532386302948,
0.79011070728302,
-0.3859870433807373,
-0.041241783648729324,
-0.23682929575443268,
-0.18833918869495392,
-0.11225736141204834,
-0.17817923426628113,
0.19998003542423248,
-0.5369817018508911,
0.1794213205575943,
-0.4971711337566376,
-0.9260512590408325,
-0.40208131074905396,
0.30055585503578186,
-0.7104425430297852,
0.4366593360900879,
0.11090411245822906,
-1.0548930168151855,
0.6947891116142273,
-0.733618974685669,
-0.6286770701408386,
0.3260754346847534,
-0.4063504934310913,
-0.4110282361507416,
-0.06091288477182388,
0.526044487953186,
0.5535890460014343,
-0.004280854947865009,
0.4033154845237732,
-0.23106200993061066,
-0.5205665230751038,
0.03473011776804924,
0.17093303799629211,
0.4512139558792114,
0.2643764615058899,
-0.38769108057022095,
0.540763258934021,
-0.5270476341247559,
0.12579691410064697,
0.24987906217575073,
0.27010709047317505,
-0.309513121843338,
0.08151619881391525,
0.31326520442962646,
0.10231286287307739,
-0.06081649288535118,
0.21499834954738617,
0.10971018671989441,
-0.5189627408981323,
0.6258776187896729,
0.5727037191390991,
0.33999893069267273,
0.49720945954322815,
-0.2730446457862854,
0.5161446332931519,
-0.1579856425523758,
-0.0835038498044014,
-0.24449977278709412,
-0.3369887173175812,
-0.4730392098426819,
-0.1825452446937561,
0.00928986631333828,
0.3760265111923218,
-0.6896402835845947,
0.6365349888801575,
-0.7565587162971497,
-0.8585937023162842,
0.09412932395935059,
0.001100121415220201,
0.1776682734489441,
0.9143960475921631,
0.3034208118915558,
-0.4299275279045105,
-0.7036932706832886,
-0.9065935611724854,
-0.2749062478542328,
0.28673964738845825,
0.050291262567043304,
0.08646513521671295,
0.48907071352005005,
-0.053847670555114746,
0.977336585521698,
-0.9759148359298706,
-0.2877562344074249,
-0.7203447222709656,
0.07582008838653564,
0.3146301507949829,
0.34044981002807617,
0.7493525743484497,
-0.6892625093460083,
-0.5690696835517883,
-0.01860114373266697,
-0.9934665560722351,
0.3091091811656952,
-0.10233858972787857,
-0.46754589676856995,
-0.33907049894332886,
0.6904037594795227,
-0.1368662416934967,
0.5920771360397339,
0.0233270563185215,
-0.4224485158920288,
0.30856043100357056,
-0.2643536925315857,
0.2033558487892151,
-1.2013126611709595,
0.35188567638397217,
-0.18668103218078613,
-0.22051675617694855,
-0.5605649352073669,
-0.031745895743370056,
0.03789011761546135,
-0.4527954161167145,
0.049494147300720215,
0.3399752080440521,
-0.2906668484210968,
0.11609391123056412,
-0.4406847655773163,
0.42800143361091614,
0.09655570238828659,
0.5132718682289124,
-0.05583580583333969,
0.47661304473876953,
0.6511678099632263,
-0.391364723443985,
0.43939754366874695,
0.6121885180473328,
-0.4699026644229889,
0.6963508725166321,
-0.5542954206466675,
0.04086950048804283,
-0.3355792462825775,
0.5260942578315735,
-1.2033172845840454,
-0.38460636138916016,
0.2091512233018875,
0.013645531609654427,
0.0758574903011322,
-0.07794784009456635,
-0.3936893939971924,
-0.5272228121757507,
-0.442050576210022,
0.30575811862945557,
0.070528045296669,
-0.3766317665576935,
0.3282705843448639,
0.542515754699707,
-0.11380109190940857,
-0.291006863117218,
-0.7158520817756653,
0.3256582021713257,
-0.46301963925361633,
-0.5594421029090881,
0.21177643537521362,
-0.10013801604509354,
-0.11675234884023666,
-0.35824328660964966,
-0.3615538477897644,
0.10199219733476639,
0.007609203923493624,
0.17220215499401093,
0.35532933473587036,
0.09250182658433914,
0.1272488534450531,
-0.029086902737617493,
-0.3787199854850769,
0.07763116806745529,
-0.40872645378112793,
0.31119033694267273,
-0.18566380441188812,
-0.18669557571411133,
-0.4133603870868683,
0.15115806460380554,
0.5448797345161438,
-0.33549410104751587,
0.364734947681427,
0.46822208166122437,
-0.28794142603874207,
-0.050919681787490845,
-0.14628255367279053,
-0.0473623052239418,
-0.4543594717979431,
0.39207711815834045,
-0.144593745470047,
-0.564969003200531,
0.38186588883399963,
0.08190618455410004,
0.21084578335285187,
0.13633529841899872,
0.4845074415206909,
-0.41144222021102905,
0.6829613447189331,
0.36418038606643677,
-0.4557507634162903,
0.3804633617401123,
-0.6849919557571411,
0.5810300707817078,
-0.32957103848457336,
-0.053312402218580246,
0.09495878964662552,
-0.7673903107643127,
-0.5835556387901306,
-0.17290668189525604,
0.5421322584152222,
-0.07456257939338684,
-0.31507328152656555,
0.3455735743045807,
-0.6128912568092346,
0.6592815518379211,
0.3616194725036621,
0.24434027075767517,
0.2929965853691101,
-0.06585627794265747,
0.09320288896560669,
-0.026865018531680107,
-0.7249572277069092,
-0.5557860732078552,
1.2903717756271362,
-0.1276978999376297,
0.5380433797836304,
-0.10867924243211746,
0.3138478100299835,
0.31115221977233887,
0.12526935338974,
-0.6585568785667419,
0.40475374460220337,
0.10486392676830292,
-0.43935200572013855,
-0.42811766266822815,
-0.3539954423904419,
-0.9097108840942383,
0.19750237464904785,
-0.22186918556690216,
-0.6255970001220703,
-0.0007235797238536179,
0.3994767963886261,
0.06353241205215454,
0.2984637916088104,
-0.7872005701065063,
1.03831946849823,
-0.2482505589723587,
-0.044209495186805725,
-0.3381582200527191,
-0.8851893544197083,
0.3050144612789154,
0.06436716765165329,
0.34787625074386597,
0.11049969494342804,
0.35014182329177856,
0.765306830406189,
-0.5548813939094543,
0.6266204118728638,
0.12393052875995636,
-0.07589031010866165,
0.19914107024669647,
0.027775658294558525,
0.49402663111686707,
-0.00015473560779355466,
0.3792422115802765,
-0.31749433279037476,
-0.22514145076274872,
-0.5989330410957336,
-0.6009836792945862,
0.5546412467956543,
-0.33640578389167786,
-0.14958456158638,
-0.03999415040016174,
-0.8005618453025818,
-0.41972029209136963,
0.3183244466781616,
0.334532231092453,
0.7591447234153748,
-0.15089790523052216,
0.20710453391075134,
0.029128974303603172,
0.1401936262845993,
0.3262147903442383,
-0.0467921681702137,
-0.13662049174308777,
-0.6660305261611938,
1.0300227403640747,
0.24289554357528687,
0.03901383653283119,
0.4975165128707886,
0.09149446338415146,
-0.10852339118719101,
-0.4380876421928406,
-0.26576605439186096,
0.03464385122060776,
-0.9880554676055908,
-0.151444211602211,
-0.3284440040588379,
0.09889202564954758,
-0.02699276991188526,
-0.5183683037757874,
-0.10085722804069519,
-0.5542312264442444,
0.06898078322410583,
-0.44294503331184387,
0.48447924852371216,
0.5804125666618347,
0.289249986410141,
0.16487064957618713,
-0.3125901222229004,
0.5493150949478149,
0.45953476428985596,
0.41069209575653076,
0.4046228229999542,
-0.04746973142027855,
-0.5816879868507385,
-0.023940475657582283,
-0.399722695350647,
-0.7291502952575684,
0.20137079060077667,
-0.16174744069576263,
0.16309525072574615,
0.6622665524482727,
0.12759795784950256,
0.9603038430213928,
-0.24269385635852814,
0.34514614939689636,
0.3260464668273926,
-0.6764221787452698,
0.7970162630081177,
-0.5349708199501038,
0.5158424973487854,
0.6674037575721741,
0.19303090870380402,
-0.481060266494751,
-0.6822227835655212,
-0.5652326941490173,
-1.1468621492385864,
0.5516030788421631,
0.5420807600021362,
-0.28424492478370667,
0.23003900051116943,
0.010115483775734901,
0.03339570388197899,
0.39903131127357483,
-0.2686399519443512,
-0.36562952399253845,
-0.634722888469696,
-0.5030247569084167,
-0.4726918041706085,
0.3404898941516876,
-0.3058468997478485,
-0.6246538162231445,
0.32543882727622986,
-0.4125664532184601,
-0.20052796602249146,
-0.06256058812141418,
-0.40481454133987427,
-0.1954154521226883,
0.07060219347476959,
0.40405935049057007,
1.4703402519226074,
-0.3144102692604065,
0.13636057078838348,
0.20188573002815247,
-0.38274049758911133,
-0.23610587418079376,
0.04159379005432129,
-0.15296639502048492,
-0.2098928987979889,
0.7757061123847961,
0.8862302303314209,
0.5601454377174377,
-0.9568895697593689,
0.4013931453227997,
-0.10296972841024399,
0.10953035205602646,
-0.12294769287109375,
0.09476445615291595,
0.42705658078193665,
0.2887057960033417,
0.4392681419849396,
0.17170794308185577,
0.3690637946128845,
-0.38184189796447754,
0.09134095907211304,
0.23661567270755768,
-0.42769166827201843,
-0.19483506679534912,
0.7565208077430725,
0.12461541593074799,
0.07400132715702057,
0.42861077189445496,
0.23166631162166595,
-0.4581499397754669,
0.7033640146255493,
0.06816155463457108,
0.649771511554718,
0.539127767086029,
0.13169555366039276,
0.4328472912311554,
0.1408369392156601,
0.3656104803085327,
0.294562965631485,
-0.25590068101882935,
-0.22826409339904785,
-0.3580046594142914,
0.10083775222301483,
-0.4933321177959442,
-0.05108844116330147,
-0.6859197020530701,
0.23452885448932648,
-0.2637455463409424,
-0.1152280941605568,
-0.03703027963638306,
0.012546578422188759,
-0.8292075991630554,
0.42606744170188904,
0.16051271557807922,
0.7134065628051758,
-0.6928067207336426,
0.1613841950893402,
0.5909019708633423,
-0.5348031520843506,
-0.6508879661560059,
-0.11848203092813492,
-0.05120918154716492,
-0.5793235898017883,
0.3752979636192322,
0.2781082093715668,
0.0660240426659584,
-0.044356316328048706,
-0.5877527594566345,
-0.5930601358413696,
1.3276822566986084,
0.2975494861602783,
-0.6047241687774658,
0.12929177284240723,
0.06772635132074356,
0.6501945853233337,
-0.3694324791431427,
0.2689868211746216,
0.6159676313400269,
0.5110638737678528,
-0.06209868565201759,
-0.629619300365448,
0.2600046694278717,
-0.43972209095954895,
-0.10017119348049164,
0.06208132207393646,
-0.5549079179763794,
0.31820249557495117,
-0.3901258111000061,
-0.1593545824289322,
-0.33905208110809326,
0.5722071528434753,
0.3796342611312866,
0.599158525466919,
0.26785004138946533,
0.42991459369659424,
0.9066421985626221,
-0.0030677164904773235,
0.9439122676849365,
-0.43786218762397766,
0.3164905905723572,
1.3282936811447144,
0.07139208912849426,
0.5260032415390015,
0.34245049953460693,
0.08882784843444824,
0.4660123586654663,
0.5404548645019531,
-0.075361467897892,
0.7070646286010742,
0.1201903447508812,
0.6438916921615601,
-0.16545619070529938,
0.23341841995716095,
-0.4598722755908966,
0.22651506960391998,
-0.057392314076423645,
-0.3469502329826355,
-0.31754210591316223,
-0.19337677955627441,
-0.19269977509975433,
0.2429492175579071,
-0.2438928186893463,
0.7860934734344482,
-0.052085284143686295,
-0.3363025486469269,
0.6721229553222656,
-0.5532017350196838,
0.16088783740997314,
-0.32919493317604065,
0.21901538968086243,
-0.2949077785015106,
-0.08608953654766083,
-0.15727868676185608,
-0.7806717157363892,
0.07471896708011627,
-0.0883941650390625,
-0.04549279063940048,
-0.2702997624874115,
0.49769023060798645,
-0.15441490709781647,
-0.5181254744529724,
0.06845759600400925,
0.5557651519775391,
-0.16500535607337952,
-0.1740250587463379,
-0.4322230815887451,
-0.21673855185508728,
-0.12256573140621185,
0.06530790776014328,
-0.09708978980779648,
0.455458402633667,
-0.1361164152622223,
0.8960615396499634,
0.4503113925457001,
-0.19553984701633453,
-0.4025714695453644,
0.550794243812561,
0.9778889417648315,
-0.867640495300293,
-1.1934304237365723,
-0.6317299604415894,
0.6204909682273865,
-0.5024126768112183,
-0.2676546573638916,
0.7015653252601624,
1.0888363122940063,
0.6136508584022522,
-0.30786845088005066,
0.8545990586280823,
0.302839994430542,
0.3482247591018677,
-0.28337857127189636,
0.9467677474021912,
-0.4141506254673004,
0.05659303069114685,
-0.8109204769134521,
-0.7418762445449829,
-0.14981091022491455,
0.29675108194351196,
-0.5836811065673828,
-0.14435145258903503,
0.7122228145599365,
0.3257109522819519,
-0.2966476380825043,
0.4203028380870819,
-0.21600885689258575,
0.0926382914185524,
0.33458271622657776,
0.5526411533355713,
0.6252347230911255,
-0.5023131966590881,
0.6444724798202515,
-0.3387937843799591,
-0.1478639543056488,
-0.3708072006702423,
-0.7289676070213318,
-1.208282709121704,
-0.7167127728462219,
-0.3705216944217682,
0.21140070259571075,
-0.24904118478298187,
0.5942015647888184,
0.8362975716590881,
-0.9206763505935669,
-0.44421252608299255,
-0.3141988515853882,
0.0642794594168663,
-0.48226284980773926,
-0.25059211254119873,
0.842029333114624,
-0.14489033818244934,
-0.30154284834861755,
0.2978235185146332,
0.4036164879798889,
0.07078979909420013,
0.020057199522852898,
-0.1636464148759842,
0.17824497818946838,
-0.16058284044265747,
0.700543999671936,
-0.08708082139492035,
-0.4327975809574127,
-0.06124027445912361,
-0.25506576895713806,
0.1244015097618103,
0.20750243961811066,
0.8729852437973022,
-0.5944626927375793,
0.8359829783439636,
0.5779286026954651,
0.34627440571784973,
0.7942590117454529,
0.20207048952579498,
0.6725452542304993,
-0.6009129881858826,
0.05712083354592323,
-0.015899643301963806,
0.4403102993965149,
0.31239640712738037,
-0.17543505132198334,
0.724622905254364,
0.006612397264689207,
-0.033563364297151566,
-0.7267371416091919,
-0.03551459684967995,
-1.2056907415390015,
-0.3519841432571411,
0.28949907422065735,
0.36099880933761597,
0.11147702485322952,
-0.03981448709964752,
-0.4726196527481079,
0.49323299527168274,
-0.31963613629341125,
1.045467734336853,
0.42324450612068176,
-0.25643232464790344,
0.09745047986507416,
-0.23890964686870575,
0.3278037905693054,
-0.03369602933526039,
-1.101270318031311,
0.15765050053596497,
0.47392842173576355,
0.1172538548707962,
0.050761040300130844,
0.42729851603507996,
0.3530834913253784,
0.23585714399814606,
-0.22773557901382446,
-0.4806625247001648,
-0.17920294404029846,
-0.08544956892728806,
0.3205703794956207,
0.36683908104896545,
-0.26399707794189453,
0.032239384949207306
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11227v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11227v1
|
Cheap Ways of Extracting Clinical Markers from Texts
| 2024-03-17T14:21:42 | 2024-03-17T14:21:42 |
Anastasia Sandu, Teodor Mihailescu, Sergiu Nisioi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
This paper describes the work of the UniBuc Archaeology team for CLPsych's
2024 Shared Task, which involved finding evidence within the text supporting
the assigned suicide risk level. Two types of evidence were required:
highlights (extracting relevant spans within the text) and summaries
(aggregating evidence into a synthesis). Our work focuses on evaluating Large
Language Models (LLM) as opposed to an alternative method that is much more
memory and resource efficient. The first approach employs a good old-fashioned
machine learning (GOML) pipeline consisting of a tf-idf vectorizer with a
logistic regression classifier, whose representative features are used to
extract relevant highlights. The second, more resource intensive, uses an LLM
for generating the summaries and is guided by chain-of-thought to provide
sequences of text indicating clinical markers.
|
[
0.046264227479696274,
-0.46572381258010864,
0.8682792782783508,
-0.06228666007518768,
-0.3158199191093445,
-0.22440533339977264,
-0.0515117272734642,
-0.5681261420249939,
0.19364428520202637,
0.6207033395767212,
-0.49611395597457886,
-0.901786208152771,
-0.7374007701873779,
0.19818705320358276,
-0.3111218512058258,
1.2619575262069702,
-0.034565269947052,
0.32462066411972046,
0.10009066760540009,
-0.33131927251815796,
-0.12772665917873383,
-0.4720032513141632,
-0.7407190799713135,
-0.11809824407100677,
0.5737830400466919,
0.3836268186569214,
0.60622239112854,
0.9147146940231323,
0.6740037798881531,
0.15411147475242615,
-0.0859607383608818,
0.012610765174031258,
-0.4650389850139618,
-0.007614946458488703,
0.06147444620728493,
-0.3783840239048004,
-0.5780588388442993,
0.25268468260765076,
-0.023041844367980957,
0.7579740881919861,
0.06486212462186813,
0.40183278918266296,
-0.1038731038570404,
0.6089160442352295,
-0.647991418838501,
0.215313121676445,
-0.371882826089859,
-0.03959569334983826,
-0.315010130405426,
-0.24037179350852966,
-0.6564241051673889,
-0.36969926953315735,
0.45906636118888855,
-0.5089704990386963,
0.4642878770828247,
-0.34199440479278564,
0.5738597512245178,
0.2065260261297226,
-0.4411482810974121,
-0.934034526348114,
-0.40787196159362793,
0.9605302810668945,
-0.8402853608131409,
0.03413734212517738,
0.5798079371452332,
-0.021865416318178177,
-0.258596807718277,
-1.0012990236282349,
0.03333243355154991,
-0.03810328245162964,
-0.4013723134994507,
0.2852700650691986,
0.1168910339474678,
0.22121447324752808,
0.19933457672595978,
0.5230739116668701,
-0.4542025625705719,
0.2120341807603836,
-0.5196547508239746,
-0.5965582728385925,
0.8246099352836609,
0.4889395236968994,
0.5444472432136536,
-0.20269376039505005,
-0.3783336877822876,
0.22105929255485535,
-0.8848402500152588,
0.1285269856452942,
0.04838079586625099,
0.21731194853782654,
-0.018424974754452705,
0.4426329433917999,
-0.11247541010379791,
0.534977912902832,
-0.3631969690322876,
-0.5921134948730469,
0.2841137945652008,
-0.4921676218509674,
-0.011369939893484116,
0.2244955599308014,
0.9663105607032776,
0.7374433279037476,
0.11876428872346878,
-0.06209583207964897,
0.016697145998477936,
0.14120514690876007,
0.18709957599639893,
-0.9666804671287537,
-0.6556525826454163,
0.5242887735366821,
-0.9828946590423584,
-0.25311195850372314,
-0.6287412047386169,
-1.009743571281433,
-0.27862706780433655,
-0.00946748536080122,
0.3268646001815796,
-0.5111312866210938,
0.19053755700588226,
0.08895557373762131,
-0.4068526327610016,
-0.2422644942998886,
0.5957192182540894,
-0.7590723633766174,
0.16795392334461212,
0.32457032799720764,
0.9705277681350708,
-0.43326205015182495,
0.10171683877706528,
-0.5043672323226929,
0.21144647896289825,
-0.22087790071964264,
0.9653146862983704,
-0.3229182958602905,
-0.5203089714050293,
0.257096529006958,
0.2012927085161209,
0.2013557404279709,
-0.5782250761985779,
0.8251359462738037,
-0.04354703798890114,
0.6094117164611816,
-0.3346807360649109,
-0.653668224811554,
-0.06316458433866501,
-0.26747483015060425,
-0.9881917834281921,
1.1655734777450562,
0.25035351514816284,
-0.977454662322998,
0.721332848072052,
-0.5376256108283997,
-0.41730996966362,
0.398884654045105,
-0.2976699471473694,
-0.46087193489074707,
0.005804288201034069,
0.2838098406791687,
0.7133802175521851,
-0.1252826750278473,
0.3297082781791687,
-0.1415444314479828,
-0.32224148511886597,
0.050527192652225494,
-0.15168718993663788,
1.0168143510818481,
0.1749732941389084,
-0.32481467723846436,
-0.1209399476647377,
-0.8134590983390808,
-0.22328035533428192,
-0.01286341156810522,
-0.6244952082633972,
-0.5363905429840088,
0.2930910289287567,
0.22333548963069916,
0.19555088877677917,
0.25978416204452515,
-0.6507511734962463,
0.06330625712871552,
-0.2137763500213623,
0.21467703580856323,
0.27897587418556213,
0.29950380325317383,
0.21988539397716522,
-0.5859534740447998,
0.33606284856796265,
-0.1837463527917862,
0.16805091500282288,
-0.14669470489025116,
-0.8388022184371948,
-0.36052048206329346,
-0.9460176229476929,
0.08790545165538788,
0.3663748800754547,
-0.32070523500442505,
0.2072245478630066,
-0.016759606078267097,
-0.5702188611030579,
-0.6910072565078735,
0.12961889803409576,
0.5201201438903809,
0.5564694404602051,
0.7121809720993042,
-0.26351991295814514,
-0.7300616502761841,
-0.7390676736831665,
-0.23688381910324097,
-0.15168726444244385,
-0.09861240535974503,
-0.0776338204741478,
0.6017664074897766,
0.01877586729824543,
0.79862380027771,
-0.7635948657989502,
-0.6024937033653259,
-0.3260667622089386,
0.363027423620224,
0.34232547879219055,
0.4003097414970398,
0.48293769359588623,
-0.6889110803604126,
-0.5699995160102844,
-0.1862172782421112,
-0.7882052063941956,
-0.2825391888618469,
-0.10923051834106445,
0.07562188059091568,
-0.002353212097659707,
0.6276589035987854,
-0.4711722433567047,
1.0589849948883057,
0.2216065227985382,
0.0237607229501009,
0.5867879390716553,
-0.30240702629089355,
0.0070395274087786674,
-0.8111621737480164,
0.3482566177845001,
-0.18193788826465607,
-0.2359415888786316,
-0.9489797353744507,
-0.2586762011051178,
-0.04559842124581337,
0.009426400065422058,
-0.33716684579849243,
0.4930325746536255,
-0.515826940536499,
0.3195323348045349,
-0.45847612619400024,
0.1733560711145401,
-0.22416341304779053,
0.24471110105514526,
0.41732102632522583,
0.7368983626365662,
0.0983891636133194,
-0.4306868612766266,
-0.0041016764007508755,
0.47943729162216187,
-0.24013055860996246,
0.37164393067359924,
-0.30444079637527466,
-0.3086147904396057,
-0.016110677272081375,
0.2117050141096115,
-0.8912038207054138,
-0.3748096227645874,
-0.17200782895088196,
-0.3703170418739319,
0.009924231097102165,
-0.23848940432071686,
-0.25888246297836304,
-0.2954399585723877,
-0.5649660229682922,
0.3546680212020874,
0.6368798017501831,
-0.16832928359508514,
0.4663769602775574,
0.6438277363777161,
-0.49423396587371826,
-0.46338924765586853,
-0.6164252161979675,
-0.03975778445601463,
-0.5746183395385742,
-0.10608485341072083,
0.28865399956703186,
-0.21828311681747437,
-0.2266417145729065,
-0.16639815270900726,
0.05816974490880966,
-0.31620413064956665,
0.30834856629371643,
0.5006299614906311,
0.2937457859516144,
-0.1513134241104126,
0.07742141932249069,
-0.053853683173656464,
-0.23356634378433228,
0.24587632715702057,
0.23180900514125824,
0.44089606404304504,
0.30783066153526306,
-0.04562456160783768,
-0.5680365562438965,
0.7818282842636108,
0.3378465473651886,
0.188692107796669,
0.6930133700370789,
0.2785392701625824,
-0.4509356617927551,
-0.16799995303153992,
-0.5206005573272705,
0.06969467550516129,
-0.3921070098876953,
0.2190542221069336,
0.19331751763820648,
-0.9500885009765625,
0.6899589896202087,
-0.43167608976364136,
0.24671649932861328,
0.6127404570579529,
1.0712542533874512,
-0.2712979316711426,
0.8772003054618835,
0.5338038802146912,
0.020962310954928398,
0.02557278238236904,
-0.05817916616797447,
0.1378706991672516,
-0.5877956748008728,
-0.3011675775051117,
-0.5862844586372375,
0.0372174046933651,
-0.4808981418609619,
-0.3551701605319977,
0.5956825613975525,
0.1263081133365631,
-0.07371695339679718,
0.39922159910202026,
-0.5698356628417969,
0.2468254268169403,
0.5682326555252075,
0.4493674337863922,
0.4918328821659088,
-0.09781120717525482,
0.08787018060684204,
-0.18133755028247833,
-0.4348253011703491,
-0.846777617931366,
1.3784399032592773,
0.2260381281375885,
0.20554009079933167,
0.01480802334845066,
0.8459416627883911,
0.2952982783317566,
0.7287759184837341,
-0.46238410472869873,
0.5385510325431824,
-0.25249117612838745,
-0.8385514616966248,
-0.2591226398944855,
-0.07664583623409271,
-1.0010906457901,
-0.008664394728839397,
-0.23071244359016418,
-0.9982181191444397,
0.06833373755216599,
-0.034307658672332764,
-0.4708425998687744,
0.021264124661684036,
-0.4029727876186371,
0.6165091395378113,
-0.11174121499061584,
0.04111497104167938,
0.0063398838974535465,
-0.8249636292457581,
0.14776906371116638,
-0.44250574707984924,
0.39861738681793213,
-0.1337725818157196,
-0.09545976668596268,
1.0530481338500977,
-0.47892439365386963,
0.8875861167907715,
-0.10001268237829208,
-0.17959846556186676,
0.4172734320163727,
0.19030140340328217,
0.3103656768798828,
-0.00033202621852979064,
-0.2404698133468628,
0.044020187109708786,
0.250895231962204,
-0.6248603463172913,
-0.09408677369356155,
0.38181495666503906,
-0.530569851398468,
-0.3801966607570648,
-0.24693116545677185,
-0.7536510825157166,
0.012609254568815231,
0.27015113830566406,
0.5855861902236938,
0.6238550543785095,
-0.49483177065849304,
-0.19298526644706726,
0.39436638355255127,
-0.3040224313735962,
0.6689350008964539,
0.34989166259765625,
0.08876819908618927,
-0.6214604377746582,
0.44886693358421326,
-0.04785529524087906,
0.36460670828819275,
0.3143860995769501,
0.2979641556739807,
-0.019583383575081825,
-1.1055314540863037,
-0.12901946902275085,
0.3694245219230652,
-0.8911576271057129,
-0.1370684951543808,
-0.7990114092826843,
-0.10761898010969162,
-0.4310758113861084,
-0.37967315316200256,
-0.3114624321460724,
-0.2965240180492401,
-0.5849317908287048,
-0.3103346526622772,
0.4766148328781128,
0.8370776176452637,
-0.2592475712299347,
0.5269361734390259,
-0.893230676651001,
0.13529735803604126,
-0.08247923105955124,
-0.2599794268608093,
-0.19665108621120453,
-0.17805342376232147,
-0.46647676825523376,
-0.1892395168542862,
-0.09114736318588257,
-0.9496505856513977,
0.603041410446167,
0.014631644822657108,
0.49594685435295105,
0.8040808439254761,
0.30746689438819885,
0.7603626847267151,
-0.4838780164718628,
0.916467547416687,
0.3591262400150299,
-0.6613869071006775,
0.4981941878795624,
-0.5319779515266418,
-0.058229710906744,
1.0043864250183105,
1.004692554473877,
-0.3784124553203583,
-0.4181201756000519,
-0.6064302325248718,
-0.8030787110328674,
0.3832060396671295,
0.24365636706352234,
-0.42522159218788147,
-0.3268636465072632,
0.28682711720466614,
0.4868643283843994,
0.07183956354856491,
-0.7585449814796448,
-0.19146007299423218,
0.28805336356163025,
-0.7085224986076355,
-0.06579092144966125,
-0.6110556125640869,
-0.49223047494888306,
-0.04866567999124527,
0.2359771579504013,
-0.21719805896282196,
0.1880595088005066,
0.5387839078903198,
-0.2718146741390228,
-0.04051293060183525,
0.028609231114387512,
0.4622551202774048,
0.8615062832832336,
-0.5075340867042542,
0.3524513840675354,
0.34736549854278564,
-0.7663854360580444,
0.038381289690732956,
-0.10598837584257126,
-0.2851302921772003,
0.23359104990959167,
1.0652698278427124,
0.34906670451164246,
0.13427990674972534,
-0.9965070486068726,
0.8514506816864014,
0.09849657863378525,
-0.4452318847179413,
-0.5318060517311096,
-0.1747918277978897,
0.1553998440504074,
0.20791782438755035,
0.26870375871658325,
-0.3790516257286072,
0.3592023253440857,
-0.45661938190460205,
0.2671857476234436,
0.36893534660339355,
-0.4140761196613312,
-0.47825485467910767,
0.4291466772556305,
0.06341654062271118,
-0.17647971212863922,
0.41740137338638306,
0.17045852541923523,
-0.4560456871986389,
0.35103556513786316,
0.3468662202358246,
0.6206408143043518,
-0.12819842994213104,
0.4091636538505554,
0.3682924509048462,
0.03500303998589516,
-0.27890926599502563,
0.4253588318824768,
0.15151557326316833,
-0.11260570585727692,
-0.6551395058631897,
-0.5815445780754089,
-0.27452725172042847,
0.13306862115859985,
-0.7654640078544617,
0.12692442536354065,
-0.29619988799095154,
-0.08712808042764664,
0.0018943786853924394,
-0.06260141730308533,
-0.548224687576294,
0.5079745054244995,
0.07701730728149414,
0.9025850296020508,
-0.9076048731803894,
0.49194660782814026,
0.2634955048561096,
-0.4138486981391907,
-0.5488865375518799,
-0.3104892671108246,
0.11110281944274902,
-0.7832808494567871,
0.9237638115882874,
0.35613444447517395,
0.23179562389850616,
-0.4256731867790222,
-0.6383216381072998,
-0.629936933517456,
1.1177759170532227,
-0.04132750630378723,
-0.28970134258270264,
-0.5523989796638489,
0.28005608916282654,
0.7342637181282043,
-0.5341354012489319,
0.6038339734077454,
0.4754031300544739,
0.20962627232074738,
-0.2653575539588928,
-0.7553465366363525,
0.26982682943344116,
0.006128665525466204,
-0.5326434969902039,
0.3651433289051056,
-0.33583274483680725,
0.7761496305465698,
-0.19028456509113312,
-0.4058988392353058,
0.40689152479171753,
0.3855211138725281,
-0.03767675533890724,
0.5865503549575806,
0.23602674901485443,
0.6832855939865112,
0.9174870848655701,
0.2234167754650116,
0.7414993047714233,
-0.1330856829881668,
0.4849102199077606,
1.0540270805358887,
-0.36184197664260864,
0.6933426260948181,
0.469287633895874,
-0.08983705192804337,
0.6492980718612671,
0.5523789525032043,
0.1315736323595047,
0.8319368362426758,
0.08712352067232132,
-0.41981181502342224,
-0.3649831712245941,
-0.1391039937734604,
-0.0965048298239708,
0.2626182436943054,
0.4482477605342865,
-0.6594012975692749,
-0.37460261583328247,
-0.058881182223558426,
0.5095208287239075,
-0.06397327035665512,
-0.24161604046821594,
0.9584614634513855,
0.21499648690223694,
-0.6770396828651428,
0.2937186658382416,
-0.3062731921672821,
0.1924300491809845,
-0.45753973722457886,
-0.26045846939086914,
-0.19079235196113586,
0.39254796504974365,
-0.18500393629074097,
-0.5778898000717163,
0.3612929880619049,
0.033098652958869934,
-0.000039212769479490817,
-0.20444419980049133,
0.6668887734413147,
-0.28545263409614563,
-0.2928452491760254,
0.3919478952884674,
0.5327653288841248,
0.3816269040107727,
0.12655320763587952,
-0.4601435363292694,
-0.2941827178001404,
0.13378752768039703,
-0.1299026757478714,
0.495813250541687,
0.640200138092041,
-0.1801818162202835,
0.5636178851127625,
0.856583297252655,
0.48061230778694153,
-0.19674938917160034,
-0.309175968170166,
0.905170738697052,
-0.9271634221076965,
-0.2643167972564697,
-0.9890158176422119,
0.3428322970867157,
-0.18851716816425323,
-0.5072548389434814,
0.7236390709877014,
0.6232070922851562,
0.5503926873207092,
-0.0024127026554197073,
0.5882068276405334,
0.149394229054451,
0.8092753887176514,
-0.630041778087616,
0.7736735343933105,
-0.30368587374687195,
-0.10095105320215225,
-0.31973403692245483,
-0.331046462059021,
-0.5361901521682739,
0.330996572971344,
-0.08559207618236542,
-0.5218392014503479,
1.2862253189086914,
0.4338988959789276,
0.34785738587379456,
0.2521727383136749,
0.1418737918138504,
0.016491234302520752,
0.3829280138015747,
0.7914514541625977,
0.5365563631057739,
-0.2361845076084137,
0.4312695860862732,
-0.2535022497177124,
-0.5148868560791016,
-0.09276048094034195,
-1.00359046459198,
-1.2722278833389282,
-0.5882586240768433,
-0.4271673560142517,
-0.5028480291366577,
0.08876784890890121,
0.7144029140472412,
0.27716001868247986,
-0.8731068968772888,
-0.15251512825489044,
0.16027624905109406,
-0.4421462118625641,
-0.10807618498802185,
-0.06475728005170822,
0.9968979954719543,
-0.06459198147058487,
-0.44440823793411255,
0.3114436864852905,
0.4079643785953522,
-0.17680996656417847,
0.03695007413625717,
0.17406071722507477,
-0.49287843704223633,
-0.2843182384967804,
0.38018539547920227,
-0.03954910486936569,
-0.4246235489845276,
-0.2859777808189392,
-0.2234831303358078,
-0.200151726603508,
0.22435839474201202,
1.0216221809387207,
-0.8092182278633118,
0.23282429575920105,
0.527862548828125,
0.41567057371139526,
0.4958510994911194,
-0.01958376355469227,
0.416273295879364,
-0.2937166690826416,
0.20678453147411346,
0.4352237284183502,
0.4559412896633148,
0.10771791636943817,
-0.4191727638244629,
0.7166059613227844,
0.4549182653427124,
-0.7255644202232361,
-0.7937271595001221,
0.13901939988136292,
-1.0900049209594727,
-0.3521767556667328,
1.001176357269287,
-0.5730927586555481,
-0.3606536388397217,
-0.7163541316986084,
-0.31484904885292053,
0.36905863881111145,
-0.3401529788970947,
0.7404065728187561,
0.5097504258155823,
-0.1608901023864746,
0.02939796634018421,
-0.6777186393737793,
0.9504256248474121,
0.229232519865036,
-0.7761426568031311,
0.1850135773420334,
0.45652472972869873,
0.36407342553138733,
0.31062746047973633,
0.9962162971496582,
-0.346028208732605,
0.294502317905426,
-0.22484128177165985,
0.2636227309703827,
0.31009984016418457,
-0.059255991131067276,
0.03164893761277199,
0.28071650862693787,
-0.20404167473316193,
0.20557737350463867
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11209v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11209v1
|
Creating an African American-Sounding TTS: Guidelines, Technical Challenges,and Surprising Evaluations
| 2024-03-17T13:21:33 | 2024-03-17T13:21:33 |
Claudio Pinhanez, Raul Fernandez, Marcelo Grave, Julio Nogima, Ron Hoory
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.HC
|
Representations of AI agents in user interfaces and robotics are
predominantly White, not only in terms of facial and skin features, but also in
the synthetic voices they use. In this paper we explore some unexpected
challenges in the representation of race we found in the process of developing
an U.S. English Text-to-Speech (TTS) system aimed to sound like an educated,
professional, regional accent-free African American woman. The paper starts by
presenting the results of focus groups with African American IT professionals
where guidelines and challenges for the creation of a representative and
appropriate TTS system were discussed and gathered, followed by a discussion
about some of the technical difficulties faced by the TTS system developers. We
then describe two studies with U.S. English speakers where the participants
were not able to attribute the correct race to the African American TTS voice
while overwhelmingly correctly recognizing the race of a White TTS system of
similar quality. A focus group with African American IT workers not only
confirmed the representativeness of the African American voice we built, but
also suggested that the surprising recognition results may have been caused by
the inability or the latent prejudice from non-African Americans to associate
educated, non-vernacular, professionally-sounding voices to African American
people.
|
[
-0.5463719964027405,
-0.27543213963508606,
0.37806427478790283,
0.11346287280321121,
-0.18081827461719513,
0.7952255010604858,
-0.11579304933547974,
-0.7998510599136353,
0.701884388923645,
-0.0068379235453903675,
-0.4679391086101532,
-0.26436418294906616,
-0.6592854857444763,
0.4682503938674927,
-0.6083857417106628,
0.9061509966850281,
0.0071420553140342236,
-0.16078507900238037,
0.4060561954975128,
-0.2091139554977417,
-0.6696373820304871,
-0.670357346534729,
-0.667422354221344,
-0.11258018761873245,
0.45569759607315063,
0.3601180911064148,
1.062168002128601,
0.5641433596611023,
-0.09556060284376144,
0.2908598482608795,
-0.024931734427809715,
0.14878684282302856,
-0.08133569359779358,
0.03826675936579704,
0.0558772087097168,
-0.30011770129203796,
-0.02639837935566902,
0.17197957634925842,
0.02172750234603882,
0.711102306842804,
-0.01867815852165222,
0.30649906396865845,
-0.1244424432516098,
0.4737723171710968,
-0.6604107618331909,
-0.16518230736255646,
-0.5803262591362,
0.26994651556015015,
-0.4291124939918518,
-0.048532966524362564,
-0.37080442905426025,
-0.26952284574508667,
0.18668591976165771,
-0.6435105204582214,
0.3106567859649658,
0.18383045494556427,
0.873993456363678,
0.22769953310489655,
-0.782758355140686,
-0.3661768436431885,
-1.4233791828155518,
0.4302304983139038,
-0.38897454738616943,
0.3807934522628784,
0.056961867958307266,
0.6486570835113525,
0.05370092764496803,
-0.6000056266784668,
-0.7672805190086365,
-0.527779221534729,
0.14835627377033234,
0.10360605269670486,
-0.2541181445121765,
-0.07126205414533615,
0.3133620321750641,
0.14296279847621918,
-0.4933581054210663,
0.06299503892660141,
-0.7818295955657959,
-0.46903201937675476,
0.8878844380378723,
0.2730141878128052,
0.2604821026325226,
0.06656079739332199,
-0.027125559747219086,
-0.06943001598119736,
-0.31973257660865784,
-0.05120490491390228,
0.7785018086433411,
0.8681831359863281,
-0.2513097822666168,
0.7581831216812134,
0.013084198348224163,
0.3707912266254425,
-0.31128785014152527,
0.1600247025489807,
0.2744556665420532,
0.155466690659523,
0.16745387017726898,
0.2019966095685959,
0.6766987442970276,
0.24957789480686188,
0.8744648694992065,
-0.23598460853099823,
-0.3579117953777313,
0.49396297335624695,
0.7914398312568665,
-0.17797541618347168,
0.24160310626029968,
0.25659316778182983,
-0.48421287536621094,
0.24012526869773865,
0.23891077935695648,
-0.3824598491191864,
-0.6035118103027344,
-0.513309895992279,
0.3799218535423279,
-0.27110815048217773,
-0.31476181745529175,
-0.40485844016075134,
-0.5329317450523376,
-0.06425277888774872,
0.3151698708534241,
-0.9505516290664673,
0.35748541355133057,
0.4855131208896637,
0.8282966017723083,
-0.07887664437294006,
-0.13968253135681152,
0.1625690907239914,
0.09785057604312897,
-0.2663634121417999,
0.3356449007987976,
-0.3859056234359741,
-0.727816641330719,
0.13952675461769104,
-0.26342469453811646,
0.2299165576696396,
-0.5506163835525513,
0.1751030534505844,
-0.25529733300209045,
-0.13134151697158813,
-0.2921121418476105,
-0.20315930247306824,
0.09074807912111282,
-0.19670775532722473,
-0.2983567416667938,
0.8045170307159424,
0.23203149437904358,
-0.3889109790325165,
0.30309805274009705,
-0.6294575333595276,
-0.6724076867103577,
0.2303115576505661,
-0.5562908053398132,
-0.07814441621303558,
0.4409388601779938,
-0.19005447626113892,
-0.09862576425075531,
-0.1549074798822403,
-0.033854078501462936,
-0.03084622696042061,
-0.7648089528083801,
0.023807406425476074,
-0.23897750675678253,
1.0805200338363647,
0.4541442394256592,
-0.8553265929222107,
-0.24984383583068848,
-0.891446590423584,
-0.20706330239772797,
0.2735590636730194,
0.266184538602829,
-0.18533048033714294,
0.03191422298550606,
-0.006918266415596008,
-0.22076283395290375,
0.09634071588516235,
-0.8099545240402222,
-0.17993253469467163,
0.030275022611021996,
0.28845083713531494,
0.8415820002555847,
-0.4552936553955078,
0.1724999099969864,
-0.21264271438121796,
0.7374556660652161,
-0.45935600996017456,
0.08473584800958633,
-0.04432354494929314,
-0.629176139831543,
-0.8120611906051636,
0.13987399637699127,
0.2539522647857666,
0.6592679023742676,
-0.7103154063224792,
0.29634183645248413,
0.12079061567783356,
-0.46452611684799194,
-0.6989665031433105,
-0.458072692155838,
-0.0433863028883934,
0.5906916856765747,
0.2859852910041809,
-0.20664124190807343,
-0.5215278267860413,
-1.1937326192855835,
-0.018148712813854218,
-0.5594784021377563,
-0.3148181736469269,
0.3755314350128174,
0.4848208427429199,
-0.41256141662597656,
0.9506245255470276,
-0.18077383935451508,
-0.127389058470726,
0.1757122427225113,
0.35782912373542786,
-0.17229758203029633,
0.3744451105594635,
0.5293257832527161,
-0.4909084737300873,
-0.5716186165809631,
0.18779471516609192,
-0.5509259104728699,
-0.2874486744403839,
0.10313355922698975,
0.11698473244905472,
0.1712857335805893,
0.5099717378616333,
-0.2640347480773926,
0.733687698841095,
0.37979599833488464,
-0.510712742805481,
0.7423906326293945,
-0.05146462097764015,
0.23713530600070953,
-0.88620924949646,
0.22134463489055634,
0.14293506741523743,
-0.07672852277755737,
-0.4575074017047882,
-0.13654524087905884,
-0.29122021794319153,
-0.455070436000824,
-0.09130413830280304,
0.6785871982574463,
-0.5162193775177002,
-0.4919925332069397,
-0.37529751658439636,
0.19524386525154114,
-0.1681121289730072,
0.26956096291542053,
-0.17071223258972168,
1.2034283876419067,
0.11758124828338623,
-0.5222803354263306,
0.42668211460113525,
0.4029569625854492,
0.015411628410220146,
0.7807708382606506,
-0.7284956574440002,
0.470205157995224,
-0.1285523772239685,
-0.11509334295988083,
-0.7615802884101868,
0.17368243634700775,
0.04698720946907997,
-0.6177841424942017,
0.07712577283382416,
0.09612055122852325,
-0.18702788650989532,
-0.8600469827651978,
0.14652740955352783,
0.3791154623031616,
0.5745500922203064,
-0.40938812494277954,
0.5727344751358032,
0.6913892030715942,
-0.5433776378631592,
-0.42313942313194275,
-0.7990084886550903,
0.543803870677948,
-0.06479497998952866,
-0.6549984812736511,
0.4695359468460083,
0.18776632845401764,
-0.42397958040237427,
-0.11080227792263031,
-0.02140139415860176,
-0.21970206499099731,
0.32483962178230286,
0.13558329641819,
0.027243684977293015,
-0.08921577036380768,
0.08872125297784805,
-0.024069495499134064,
0.04128270968794823,
0.0944966971874237,
-0.19204548001289368,
0.05831784009933472,
0.18180876970291138,
-0.3837093114852905,
-0.5444526672363281,
0.8633698225021362,
0.46716439723968506,
-0.18000458180904388,
0.42930465936660767,
0.47307997941970825,
-0.3424525260925293,
-0.33429867029190063,
-0.41044554114341736,
-0.30691036581993103,
-0.49717921018600464,
0.36768829822540283,
-0.21238604187965393,
-0.9741533398628235,
0.7361207604408264,
0.19033490121364594,
0.285786509513855,
0.278469979763031,
0.333156555891037,
-0.388502836227417,
1.1322401762008667,
0.909033477306366,
0.2681432068347931,
0.7541025876998901,
-0.09931069612503052,
0.2120150923728943,
-0.42800599336624146,
-0.46618416905403137,
-1.1484675407409668,
-0.6439069509506226,
-0.7630058526992798,
-0.0027516530826687813,
0.5275211334228516,
-0.902182936668396,
-0.5518205761909485,
0.22220158576965332,
-0.6820550560951233,
-0.018836718052625656,
1.0180511474609375,
0.06629105657339096,
-0.04505586996674538,
0.1840289682149887,
-0.16840247809886932,
-0.18015915155410767,
-0.3855866491794586,
-0.8622578978538513,
0.9963459372520447,
0.42771100997924805,
0.32684776186943054,
0.1118941456079483,
0.7665178775787354,
0.9524682760238647,
0.21981532871723175,
-0.5513608455657959,
0.41189277172088623,
-0.39071446657180786,
-0.6650177836418152,
-0.350120484828949,
-0.30371806025505066,
-0.9883436560630798,
-0.21331031620502472,
-0.2947368621826172,
-1.0435243844985962,
0.17758171260356903,
0.2827965021133423,
-0.3250364065170288,
-0.08623377233743668,
-0.8518664240837097,
0.6509833335876465,
-0.34356942772865295,
0.10589142888784409,
0.026240406557917595,
-0.7813950777053833,
0.020888445898890495,
0.19662541151046753,
0.17424876987934113,
-0.011425108648836613,
0.18807122111320496,
0.88370281457901,
-0.8329327702522278,
0.4780780076980591,
-0.37777474522590637,
0.05596521869301796,
0.5831011533737183,
0.08902095258235931,
0.23141217231750488,
-0.3245380222797394,
-0.2390386313199997,
0.2961541712284088,
-0.3517402112483978,
-0.4402376711368561,
-0.6165657639503479,
-0.031843699514865875,
-1.0291951894760132,
-0.8452323079109192,
-0.480776309967041,
-0.4456760883331299,
-0.5253047943115234,
0.10701725631952286,
0.17019404470920563,
0.3176704943180084,
-0.18721051514148712,
-0.21951816976070404,
0.006784001365303993,
-0.06481063365936279,
0.2946387231349945,
0.22196181118488312,
0.13230206072330475,
-0.32336145639419556,
0.9311013221740723,
0.13529378175735474,
-0.08391755074262619,
-0.13436728715896606,
-0.04204418137669563,
-0.23817220330238342,
-0.8240979909896851,
-0.6682335138320923,
0.2987910211086273,
-0.4751303493976593,
0.13742856681346893,
-0.3650376796722412,
-0.4104524552822113,
-0.22732393443584442,
-0.18847587704658508,
-0.3148537576198578,
-0.6215167045593262,
-0.5869547128677368,
-0.1764381378889084,
0.1258137971162796,
1.212827444076538,
0.1763422191143036,
0.524535059928894,
-0.7008552551269531,
0.41002216935157776,
0.4209560751914978,
0.28894278407096863,
0.04865727946162224,
-0.7303469777107239,
-0.5527547001838684,
0.15192343294620514,
-0.3587791621685028,
-0.9562194347381592,
0.057729870080947876,
-0.27232787013053894,
0.603623628616333,
0.06955505907535553,
0.14027565717697144,
0.4887353181838989,
-0.6760382652282715,
1.0815380811691284,
-0.011103068478405476,
-1.1471970081329346,
0.3689258098602295,
-0.0760086178779602,
0.07927250117063522,
0.666199803352356,
0.21504025161266327,
-0.4650959074497223,
-0.9722152948379517,
-0.41159170866012573,
-0.7727742791175842,
0.6741901636123657,
0.47853001952171326,
0.5574763417243958,
0.004130595829337835,
0.4114830791950226,
0.16891157627105713,
0.3601432144641876,
-0.7166246175765991,
-0.8436217904090881,
-0.5357167720794678,
-0.3894233703613281,
0.08384039252996445,
-0.168242409825325,
-0.08177579194307327,
0.28368186950683594,
0.5030440092086792,
-0.11532283574342728,
0.3471149802207947,
0.26355892419815063,
0.04906857758760452,
0.022918060421943665,
0.25300130248069763,
0.7239336371421814,
0.49882400035858154,
-0.07350889593362808,
-0.0660862848162651,
-0.3864252269268036,
-0.3986814320087433,
0.522196888923645,
0.54924476146698,
-0.3891887366771698,
0.3372001647949219,
0.3779304325580597,
1.1283804178237915,
-0.6135150790214539,
-0.3688866198062897,
0.03244375064969063,
-0.23866991698741913,
-0.09452041238546371,
-0.17752762138843536,
-0.008598465472459793,
-0.2182742953300476,
0.15997453033924103,
1.0310378074645996,
0.04103206843137741,
0.21516458690166473,
-0.6294271349906921,
-0.06207386031746864,
0.7223339676856995,
-0.3666245639324188,
-0.3805927038192749,
1.0063188076019287,
0.9515451788902283,
-0.958017885684967,
0.37677618861198425,
-0.2062053233385086,
-0.6114630699157715,
0.821326732635498,
0.4662303924560547,
1.166062355041504,
-0.2866300940513611,
0.3734017312526703,
0.07630910724401474,
0.7254785299301147,
0.35661405324935913,
0.4701788127422333,
-0.002194612752646208,
-0.6228598356246948,
0.060766447335481644,
-0.22136732935905457,
-0.7989354729652405,
-0.39588189125061035,
-0.3760071098804474,
0.35220399498939514,
-0.5321351885795593,
-0.8579453229904175,
0.07567005604505539,
-0.11218047887086868,
-0.5275998711585999,
0.469210147857666,
0.48568475246429443,
1.0284650325775146,
-0.908383309841156,
-0.11312168836593628,
0.9271473288536072,
-0.10739632695913315,
-0.9781292080879211,
0.05400218069553375,
0.019591830670833588,
-0.5431054830551147,
0.4948943853378296,
-0.05298934876918793,
-0.0630655512213707,
-0.1855754256248474,
0.0543920062482357,
-0.5688977837562561,
0.8028661012649536,
0.8673084378242493,
-0.4769039750099182,
-0.12237782776355743,
0.41560378670692444,
0.652169942855835,
-0.3897806704044342,
0.5697282552719116,
0.41392675042152405,
0.45702803134918213,
-0.14537012577056885,
-1.48991060256958,
-0.12554410099983215,
-0.21801544725894928,
0.10728032141923904,
-0.035097718238830566,
-0.8252538442611694,
0.8991804718971252,
-0.4168832302093506,
-0.46244511008262634,
-0.05848659202456474,
0.685537576675415,
0.23968534171581268,
0.7062100768089294,
0.566416323184967,
0.053596995770931244,
0.9257421493530273,
-0.19681894779205322,
1.062408685684204,
-0.06443528831005096,
-0.18241795897483826,
0.7313846349716187,
-0.42965126037597656,
0.08197376877069473,
0.3229975402355194,
-0.4978330135345459,
0.7629028558731079,
0.5965573787689209,
0.25147464871406555,
0.044003743678331375,
0.20964254438877106,
-0.4504413902759552,
0.39852046966552734,
-0.4137793779373169,
-0.5338821411132812,
0.738915741443634,
0.07613307982683182,
-0.18081660568714142,
0.24369800090789795,
0.00993314664810896,
-0.4343603551387787,
0.507858395576477,
-0.25137272477149963,
0.691875159740448,
0.059651121497154236,
-0.4462241530418396,
0.28922680020332336,
-0.058152277022600174,
0.45913323760032654,
-0.4760430157184601,
-0.13646572828292847,
-0.21371152997016907,
-0.5110871195793152,
-0.13702060282230377,
-0.41929617524147034,
0.4651488661766052,
0.20718547701835632,
-0.2383575439453125,
0.038966625928878784,
0.04960448294878006,
-0.23839305341243744,
-0.47514402866363525,
0.34901323914527893,
0.46847137808799744,
-0.05451662838459015,
0.18195123970508575,
-0.4009563624858856,
0.3696848452091217,
0.1922614872455597,
0.17309387028217316,
-0.26863470673561096,
0.44474148750305176,
-0.29003384709358215,
0.5839935541152954,
0.2972412705421448,
0.601172149181366,
0.00802792888134718,
0.3570655286312103,
0.25453782081604004,
-0.8949096202850342,
-1.110667109489441,
-0.5079437494277954,
0.7551215291023254,
-0.032193273305892944,
-0.26575079560279846,
0.5218163728713989,
0.3607499897480011,
0.725178599357605,
0.16172169148921967,
1.1408777236938477,
-0.03754564747214317,
0.6960840821266174,
-0.22244122624397278,
0.6099198460578918,
-0.6030709147453308,
0.23212793469429016,
-0.42862847447395325,
-1.0274971723556519,
0.09707778692245483,
0.44539210200309753,
0.4277982711791992,
0.5842391848564148,
0.5924033522605896,
0.4853442907333374,
0.20572035014629364,
0.23143981397151947,
0.39583492279052734,
0.10210878401994705,
0.3232976496219635,
0.09743227064609528,
0.9554291367530823,
-0.2989366948604584,
0.6643654704093933,
-0.2965165674686432,
-0.2287093997001648,
-0.15016788244247437,
-0.7071298360824585,
-0.48270633816719055,
-0.5555300116539001,
-0.4150460362434387,
-0.5058181881904602,
0.08437687903642654,
1.0661580562591553,
0.8055640459060669,
-0.9930088520050049,
-0.5591049790382385,
0.3440670669078827,
0.2857675552368164,
0.06044215336441994,
-0.24545875191688538,
-0.13595911860466003,
0.18299831449985504,
-1.0096698999404907,
0.3564539849758148,
0.1995982825756073,
0.5175493955612183,
-0.1145259216427803,
-0.08955994248390198,
0.34181153774261475,
0.030379153788089752,
0.3399042785167694,
0.7907102704048157,
-0.6068512201309204,
-0.6029552221298218,
-0.13101355731487274,
-0.1788707822561264,
-0.11169105768203735,
0.9794129729270935,
-0.6923602819442749,
0.6357566714286804,
-0.3515656292438507,
0.7818747758865356,
0.2794173061847687,
-0.005417777691036463,
1.0789538621902466,
-1.0523289442062378,
0.49994343519210815,
0.5122647881507874,
0.4289845824241638,
0.5151057243347168,
-0.3591371774673462,
0.4388435184955597,
0.211173877120018,
-0.3156600296497345,
-1.0651582479476929,
0.13498848676681519,
-0.7737118601799011,
-0.04667403921484947,
0.8174458742141724,
0.1710158884525299,
0.18122203648090363,
-0.4814095199108124,
-0.49530720710754395,
0.5026080012321472,
-0.655001699924469,
0.9699258804321289,
0.42210808396339417,
-0.227873295545578,
-0.010771490633487701,
-0.32754090428352356,
0.34712958335876465,
0.3881012797355652,
-0.6630123853683472,
-0.10636810213327408,
0.6622765064239502,
-0.2402990162372589,
0.5425354838371277,
0.7066416144371033,
0.4063599705696106,
0.6827874183654785,
0.0594603568315506,
0.27531540393829346,
-0.31592461466789246,
-0.39414677023887634,
-0.3464631140232086,
0.06486628949642181,
0.2611185610294342,
-0.24306334555149078
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00017v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00017v1
|
Psittacines of Innovation? Assessing the True Novelty of AI Creations
| 2024-03-17T13:08:11 | 2024-03-17T13:08:11 |
Anirban Mukherjee
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC
|
We examine whether Artificial Intelligence (AI) systems generate truly novel
ideas rather than merely regurgitating patterns learned during training.
Utilizing a novel experimental design, we task an AI with generating project
titles for hypothetical crowdfunding campaigns. We compare within AI-generated
project titles, measuring repetition and complexity. We compare between the
AI-generated titles and actual observed field data using an extension of
maximum mean discrepancy--a metric derived from the application of kernel mean
embeddings of statistical distributions to high-dimensional machine learning
(large language) embedding vectors--yielding a structured analysis of AI output
novelty. Results suggest that (1) the AI generates unique content even under
increasing task complexity, and at the limits of its computational
capabilities, (2) the generated content has face validity, being consistent
with both inputs to other generative AI and in qualitative comparison to field
data, and (3) exhibits divergence from field data, mitigating concerns relating
to intellectual property rights. We discuss implications for copyright and
trademark law.
|
[
-0.4739632308483124,
-0.6480439901351929,
0.49229809641838074,
0.19726194441318512,
-0.18205438554286957,
0.38347750902175903,
0.14101016521453857,
-0.44478097558021545,
0.3082536458969116,
0.26119929552078247,
-0.46560609340667725,
-0.11005125194787979,
-0.7380250692367554,
0.014352583326399326,
-0.8196556568145752,
1.1797916889190674,
0.11574573069810867,
-0.24203190207481384,
-0.17701610922813416,
-0.270099401473999,
-0.0878274217247963,
-0.3477647602558136,
-0.3350442349910736,
-0.12920990586280823,
0.44251468777656555,
0.2640295922756195,
0.57906174659729,
0.5531269311904907,
0.4889434278011322,
0.46303796768188477,
0.18316811323165894,
0.295231431722641,
-0.27580538392066956,
-0.1600574553012848,
-0.0916624367237091,
-0.287845253944397,
0.22733862698078156,
0.2005275934934616,
0.5961405038833618,
0.44056519865989685,
0.06966337561607361,
0.2135489284992218,
0.028183696791529655,
0.5088865756988525,
-0.5598161816596985,
0.02397039532661438,
-0.5923390984535217,
0.2801567316055298,
-0.18231067061424255,
-0.16364817321300507,
-0.11315596848726273,
-0.5575103759765625,
0.08491528779268265,
-0.7948129177093506,
0.5580006837844849,
-0.07010401040315628,
1.0978223085403442,
0.2518085241317749,
0.12278920412063599,
-0.7005891799926758,
-1.1822075843811035,
0.5354553461074829,
-0.6947183609008789,
-0.3438321053981781,
-0.18252401053905487,
0.4317280948162079,
-0.22372937202453613,
-0.9578608274459839,
-1.034152865409851,
-0.3507601022720337,
0.49988293647766113,
-0.10200970619916916,
-0.6220303773880005,
-0.3395584225654602,
0.19989708065986633,
0.5717959403991699,
-0.5455729961395264,
0.16728264093399048,
-0.5143172740936279,
0.1043129488825798,
0.9020371437072754,
0.1811813861131668,
0.3663957417011261,
0.02375362068414688,
-0.3795279264450073,
-0.3343554437160492,
-0.3978024423122406,
0.4222137928009033,
0.7276967763900757,
-0.13342076539993286,
0.0027586095966398716,
0.7046714425086975,
-0.48587873578071594,
0.19842666387557983,
0.1756155639886856,
0.03716108947992325,
0.42019742727279663,
-0.012114610522985458,
-0.21183305978775024,
-0.029558679088950157,
0.9597620368003845,
0.011623196303844452,
0.1982387900352478,
-0.2507309317588806,
-0.2097429633140564,
-0.0547683984041214,
0.39440345764160156,
-0.28604719042778015,
-0.329985111951828,
0.23671162128448486,
-0.45890969038009644,
-0.7783142328262329,
0.5983357429504395,
-0.057224877178668976,
-0.5889052152633667,
-0.005439302418380976,
0.6923230886459351,
-0.41181811690330505,
-0.21367409825325012,
0.05062491074204445,
-0.9131460785865784,
0.21534153819084167,
0.12350986152887344,
-0.5115402936935425,
-0.14292263984680176,
0.8520529270172119,
0.5435718894004822,
-0.010861363261938095,
-0.4939901530742645,
-0.17203254997730255,
-0.034274473786354065,
-0.6077613830566406,
0.9498814344406128,
-0.2907722592353821,
-0.5646853446960449,
-0.272347092628479,
-0.07945975661277771,
0.2460516393184662,
-0.6248885989189148,
0.12483149021863937,
-0.3086419403553009,
-0.10726762562990189,
-0.16786150634288788,
-0.4474467635154724,
0.016842450946569443,
0.07397188246250153,
-0.5447984933853149,
0.7017960548400879,
0.030066752806305885,
-0.634200930595398,
0.8512980341911316,
-0.6643642783164978,
-0.38930413126945496,
0.5969489812850952,
-0.6500797867774963,
-0.3997689187526703,
0.3977912366390228,
-0.24991142749786377,
0.10239775478839874,
-0.1275435984134674,
0.381011039018631,
-0.145168736577034,
-0.22687068581581116,
0.8958451151847839,
-0.418033242225647,
0.6429632902145386,
0.21205966174602509,
-0.6546259522438049,
-0.04131925851106644,
-0.8702781796455383,
-0.03773095831274986,
0.20307612419128418,
-0.01126225758343935,
-0.3598770797252655,
0.06776402145624161,
-0.13502982258796692,
0.00987333245575428,
0.2638974189758301,
-0.7253228425979614,
0.19298143684864044,
-0.11609538644552231,
0.6203416585922241,
0.7509335875511169,
0.22142857313156128,
0.14252869784832,
-0.8005330562591553,
0.40498873591423035,
0.12220575660467148,
0.1193515732884407,
-0.04396982863545418,
-0.9568880200386047,
-0.60365229845047,
-0.41752442717552185,
0.1786654144525528,
0.332573801279068,
-0.687745213508606,
0.28981220722198486,
-0.02621196024119854,
-0.845246434211731,
-0.5122286081314087,
0.024816937744617462,
0.12468496710062027,
0.2714528739452362,
-0.19499249756336212,
-0.5949663519859314,
-0.3312896490097046,
-1.3053628206253052,
-0.5324755907058716,
-0.1599350869655609,
-0.3080810308456421,
0.37385889887809753,
0.624771773815155,
-0.11318247020244598,
0.8825342059135437,
-0.3314515948295593,
0.02140974998474121,
-0.1725492626428604,
1.0346707105636597,
0.14422793686389923,
0.6103712320327759,
0.5437185168266296,
-0.8901579976081848,
-0.12365538626909256,
-0.1614072322845459,
-0.8715794682502747,
0.33453568816185,
-0.4464988708496094,
0.275439590215683,
-0.15718500316143036,
-0.02158959209918976,
-0.979070246219635,
0.5626586079597473,
-0.12440143525600433,
-0.04308469593524933,
0.5775113105773926,
-0.30882397294044495,
0.4141332805156708,
-0.880418598651886,
0.23903994262218475,
-0.130274698138237,
0.43615487217903137,
-0.3583163022994995,
-0.012214005924761295,
-0.3573777675628662,
-0.21571871638298035,
-0.48510104417800903,
0.22154539823532104,
-0.04168402776122093,
-0.02955961786210537,
-0.42223435640335083,
0.006552150007337332,
-0.03905276209115982,
0.08778174221515656,
-0.26299700140953064,
0.633537232875824,
0.38977327942848206,
-0.6558055281639099,
0.6713781952857971,
0.040369611233472824,
-0.6380952596664429,
0.3087163269519806,
-0.666843831539154,
0.09854648262262344,
-0.2383241355419159,
0.17421744763851166,
-1.0200271606445312,
-0.34766915440559387,
-0.009863922372460365,
-0.9050260782241821,
-0.3715214431285858,
0.3719148337841034,
-0.3982250392436981,
-0.7271157503128052,
-0.20501326024532318,
0.2615108788013458,
0.6436604857444763,
-0.22830116748809814,
0.14293520152568817,
0.3128918409347534,
-0.2618720531463623,
-0.49635860323905945,
-0.9337438344955444,
0.2068496197462082,
-0.3742727041244507,
-0.3311157524585724,
0.2661535441875458,
0.0008811496081762016,
-0.5797205567359924,
0.30502474308013916,
0.3228181004524231,
-0.10975704342126846,
0.22450904548168182,
0.4915766716003418,
-0.22021566331386566,
-0.42504850029945374,
-0.0050231642089784145,
0.11609415709972382,
0.007726532872766256,
0.1398581713438034,
-0.579812228679657,
0.21875768899917603,
-0.042175520211458206,
-0.3766331970691681,
-0.5943610668182373,
0.3788383901119232,
0.6012533903121948,
-0.04063940420746803,
0.4993222653865814,
0.6755618453025818,
-0.44138363003730774,
-0.3549380302429199,
-0.3504623472690582,
0.05060117691755295,
-0.5186167359352112,
0.3406757116317749,
-0.27843359112739563,
-0.6037493348121643,
0.3920680582523346,
0.060509394854307175,
0.3868786096572876,
0.7387378215789795,
0.6820223331451416,
-0.28716662526130676,
0.8434886336326599,
0.7786352634429932,
0.04147743433713913,
0.15677331387996674,
-0.6056888103485107,
0.4955495297908783,
-0.28724050521850586,
-0.45368897914886475,
-0.601281464099884,
-0.7172406315803528,
-0.8196960091590881,
-0.14710314571857452,
0.13627681136131287,
-0.0010820606257766485,
-0.1950177550315857,
0.2050127387046814,
-0.6644867062568665,
0.35713502764701843,
1.1130536794662476,
-0.26890408992767334,
0.23092012107372284,
-0.007863498292863369,
0.21310833096504211,
0.0685974732041359,
-0.6481302976608276,
-0.681751012802124,
1.3098607063293457,
0.11255881935358047,
0.3824562132358551,
-0.08628720790147781,
0.9860554337501526,
0.9324513673782349,
0.5239562392234802,
-0.6393548250198364,
0.1970076858997345,
-0.06213640049099922,
-0.34780317544937134,
-0.41848811507225037,
-0.22846120595932007,
-0.9198856949806213,
-0.2746773362159729,
-0.36639082431793213,
-0.6643375754356384,
0.40762248635292053,
0.016126710921525955,
-0.5144765973091125,
0.48682722449302673,
-0.3827519416809082,
0.44479116797447205,
-0.24930840730667114,
-0.1593826711177826,
-0.361812949180603,
-0.2651067078113556,
0.4057641327381134,
-0.1381281316280365,
0.24353060126304626,
0.05454188585281372,
0.14099448919296265,
0.866786777973175,
-0.2653605043888092,
0.3976130485534668,
-0.03654985502362251,
-0.03636639565229416,
0.799619734287262,
-0.0341198593378067,
0.15161573886871338,
0.3306492865085602,
0.059705667197704315,
-0.16490542888641357,
-0.3555227518081665,
-0.5634788870811462,
-0.6731425523757935,
0.7798680663108826,
-0.9446882009506226,
-0.8633835315704346,
-0.37215912342071533,
-0.8064784407615662,
0.017383450642228127,
0.19572915136814117,
0.7303605079650879,
0.36230435967445374,
-0.5570533275604248,
0.4085352420806885,
0.5039865374565125,
-0.3142845630645752,
0.3639044463634491,
0.3576643168926239,
0.4898701012134552,
-0.3089480400085449,
1.2242852449417114,
0.209444060921669,
-0.172918900847435,
0.24525153636932373,
0.16392137110233307,
0.06340771168470383,
-0.5239986181259155,
-0.7346099615097046,
-0.1709049791097641,
-0.2530072331428528,
0.11495093256235123,
-0.5249017477035522,
-0.30300724506378174,
-0.42772626876831055,
-0.22675839066505432,
-0.27189335227012634,
-0.8517820239067078,
0.033314451575279236,
0.009936702437698841,
0.2619321048259735,
1.3439953327178955,
-0.3346928358078003,
0.12267637997865677,
-0.5858943462371826,
0.2846659719944,
0.5000734925270081,
-0.1291005164384842,
0.09880338609218597,
-0.21637669205665588,
-0.32314175367355347,
0.2282470464706421,
-0.8602445125579834,
-0.6161906719207764,
0.12614552676677704,
0.09888297319412231,
0.610076904296875,
0.8095993995666504,
-0.023844053968787193,
0.007303961552679539,
-0.3627881407737732,
1.1951130628585815,
0.2627822756767273,
-0.5510884523391724,
0.43899092078208923,
-0.44118472933769226,
0.2915155291557312,
0.328326553106308,
0.40104010701179504,
-0.0508810356259346,
-0.7858948111534119,
-1.262638807296753,
-0.6602157354354858,
0.16396115720272064,
0.45370760560035706,
0.3148154020309448,
-0.001998875755816698,
0.26878809928894043,
0.2674231231212616,
0.6023668050765991,
-0.33132216334342957,
-0.10047163814306259,
-0.2859104573726654,
-0.1888769567012787,
0.025933923199772835,
0.2525024712085724,
-0.22119082510471344,
-0.013574730604887009,
0.42523661255836487,
0.2587399184703827,
0.21726326644420624,
0.27269262075424194,
0.24585436284542084,
0.01624729298055172,
0.06932873278856277,
0.7551040053367615,
0.8600850105285645,
0.23478730022907257,
-0.011014212854206562,
-0.0812198594212532,
-0.4627271890640259,
0.24578136205673218,
0.12543757259845734,
-0.19931402802467346,
0.18661175668239594,
0.37890464067459106,
0.5823625326156616,
-0.14745071530342102,
-0.8926321268081665,
0.25396543741226196,
-0.04808826744556427,
-0.5051633715629578,
-0.49007657170295715,
0.3629811704158783,
0.004172198008745909,
0.555245041847229,
0.8463845252990723,
0.37009015679359436,
0.49328070878982544,
-0.6332235932350159,
0.37938398122787476,
0.42997682094573975,
0.0693337544798851,
-0.27810195088386536,
0.5348844528198242,
0.12116032093763351,
-0.8576766848564148,
0.5743546485900879,
-0.3294653296470642,
-0.27409207820892334,
1.2325198650360107,
0.2755047380924225,
0.991685152053833,
0.0276925191283226,
0.5111574530601501,
0.01881626434624195,
0.43435099720954895,
0.13334868848323822,
0.14740028977394104,
-0.31705471873283386,
-0.4528503715991974,
0.22076375782489777,
-0.33970603346824646,
-0.49929672479629517,
0.5602247714996338,
-0.4064908027648926,
0.067357137799263,
-0.7232956886291504,
-0.3078032433986664,
0.25814539194107056,
-0.21140341460704803,
-0.6880311965942383,
0.2746664583683014,
0.09610410034656525,
0.7076980471611023,
-0.8093570470809937,
0.4849996864795685,
0.7420651912689209,
-0.6090659499168396,
-0.5194346904754639,
0.013500573113560677,
-0.12180384248495102,
-0.6142725348472595,
0.6025474071502686,
0.022395137697458267,
-0.07329963147640228,
-0.1532866358757019,
-0.7265171408653259,
-0.7554967403411865,
0.9144089818000793,
-0.044176142662763596,
-0.3462415933609009,
-0.27089646458625793,
0.5250532627105713,
0.5504109859466553,
-0.5323385000228882,
-0.33306798338890076,
0.28644755482673645,
0.2488722950220108,
-0.17415474355220795,
-0.47335192561149597,
-0.36150068044662476,
-0.7033537030220032,
-0.10799509286880493,
-0.03302379697561264,
-0.4870624244213104,
0.8672986030578613,
-0.44320395588874817,
-0.07386572659015656,
0.5146611332893372,
0.7655758261680603,
0.5474099516868591,
0.7484662532806396,
0.21388162672519684,
0.7100360989570618,
0.7078168392181396,
0.07505466789007187,
0.9825146198272705,
-0.35638856887817383,
0.14401012659072876,
0.6033661961555481,
0.04630982503294945,
0.6321597099304199,
0.43730899691581726,
0.030455198138952255,
0.62422776222229,
0.4946746528148651,
-0.46072742342948914,
0.32094547152519226,
0.4293670952320099,
-0.10553941875696182,
0.032791197299957275,
-0.08012709766626358,
-0.4434140622615814,
0.3761349320411682,
0.2028457522392273,
-0.4775022864341736,
0.08115379512310028,
0.3415067791938782,
-0.23296910524368286,
0.10363338887691498,
0.13225464522838593,
0.7981840968132019,
0.15326564013957977,
-0.4883660674095154,
0.3043641149997711,
0.04763400927186012,
0.452776163816452,
-0.4153592884540558,
-0.09057475626468658,
-0.32354527711868286,
0.27100977301597595,
0.0022132787853479385,
-0.6044211983680725,
0.1567099690437317,
0.20587462186813354,
-0.16970135271549225,
0.2068934589624405,
0.18038073182106018,
0.1003367006778717,
-0.6502572298049927,
-0.4366222321987152,
0.33702802658081055,
0.2285453826189041,
0.2899783253669739,
-0.6365294456481934,
-0.07273021340370178,
-0.3526344895362854,
-0.10978659242391586,
0.06901297718286514,
0.8361091613769531,
-0.009805848821997643,
0.6765164136886597,
0.49348530173301697,
0.21164867281913757,
-0.004947233479470015,
-0.2817698121070862,
0.6881703734397888,
-0.5444048047065735,
-0.8359485864639282,
-0.4450042247772217,
0.41694188117980957,
-0.2371094822883606,
-0.9302792549133301,
0.8434251546859741,
0.711555540561676,
0.857517421245575,
-0.2797391414642334,
1.197422742843628,
-0.286100298166275,
0.08597209304571152,
-0.10023899376392365,
0.8869636654853821,
-0.5541187524795532,
0.051983751356601715,
-0.37001171708106995,
-0.6959284543991089,
0.24622568488121033,
0.24394765496253967,
-0.16416794061660767,
-0.2196950912475586,
0.23544548451900482,
0.5104308128356934,
-0.14352776110172272,
0.2527238130569458,
0.0205208882689476,
0.189278244972229,
0.23709653317928314,
0.5246618390083313,
1.1685857772827148,
-0.34299397468566895,
0.24811889231204987,
-0.21804139018058777,
-0.5382388830184937,
-0.12773992121219635,
-0.4094104468822479,
-0.404300332069397,
-0.9100958108901978,
-0.3298017382621765,
-0.27969732880592346,
0.14906729757785797,
0.47036829590797424,
0.5377931594848633,
-0.8507011532783508,
-0.3238198757171631,
-0.2528647780418396,
-0.009556833654642105,
-0.4187234044075012,
-0.3179866373538971,
0.1899154782295227,
-0.2747592628002167,
-0.5382539629936218,
0.35374751687049866,
0.15487797558307648,
0.024595143273472786,
-0.5414721965789795,
0.11083852499723434,
0.09063073992729187,
0.5307797789573669,
0.3509434163570404,
0.6091997027397156,
-0.7328810691833496,
-0.09391139447689056,
-0.04926316440105438,
-0.07324638217687607,
-0.15486584603786469,
1.2263551950454712,
-0.8908079266548157,
0.20219749212265015,
0.6041262149810791,
0.769262969493866,
0.14730077981948853,
0.0910671055316925,
0.5773383975028992,
-0.21416154503822327,
0.408480703830719,
0.4155927300453186,
-0.012082628905773163,
0.1931631714105606,
-0.41497159004211426,
-0.058552276343107224,
0.43279582262039185,
-0.3046036660671234,
-0.9333986043930054,
0.2610417306423187,
-0.3730378746986389,
-0.3761625587940216,
0.5471242666244507,
-0.15720175206661224,
-0.24321922659873962,
0.06370484083890915,
0.03828487917780876,
0.21650037169456482,
-0.2151809185743332,
1.4681475162506104,
0.4391317069530487,
-0.4302031099796295,
0.23838819563388824,
-0.3009202778339386,
0.7035512328147888,
0.15717154741287231,
-0.5731239914894104,
-0.4422646164894104,
0.2203826606273651,
0.2023601233959198,
0.5118998885154724,
0.342529833316803,
-0.14093343913555145,
0.6430933475494385,
0.325741171836853,
-0.07323620468378067,
-0.2386695295572281,
-0.46777716279029846,
0.02372743934392929,
0.44569194316864014,
0.19369621574878693,
-0.31926602125167847
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11203v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11203v1
|
TRELM: Towards Robust and Efficient Pre-training for Knowledge-Enhanced Language Models
| 2024-03-17T13:04:35 | 2024-03-17T13:04:35 |
Junbing Yan, Chengyu Wang, Taolin Zhang, Xiaofeng He, Jun Huang, Longtao Huang, Hui Xue, Wei Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
KEPLMs are pre-trained models that utilize external knowledge to enhance
language understanding. Previous language models facilitated knowledge
acquisition by incorporating knowledge-related pre-training tasks learned from
relation triples in knowledge graphs. However, these models do not prioritize
learning embeddings for entity-related tokens. Moreover, updating the entire
set of parameters in KEPLMs is computationally demanding. This paper introduces
TRELM, a Robust and Efficient Pre-training framework for Knowledge-Enhanced
Language Models. We observe that entities in text corpora usually follow the
long-tail distribution, where the representations of some entities are
suboptimally optimized and hinder the pre-training process for KEPLMs. To
tackle this, we employ a robust approach to inject knowledge triples and employ
a knowledge-augmented memory bank to capture valuable information. Furthermore,
updating a small subset of neurons in the feed-forward networks (FFNs) that
store factual knowledge is both sufficient and efficient. Specifically, we
utilize dynamic knowledge routing to identify knowledge paths in FFNs and
selectively update parameters during pre-training. Experimental results show
that TRELM reduces pre-training time by at least 50% and outperforms other
KEPLMs in knowledge probing tasks and multiple knowledge-aware language
understanding tasks.
|
[
-0.19091056287288666,
-0.6887059807777405,
0.6191002726554871,
0.12850001454353333,
-0.3362670838832855,
0.5335918664932251,
-0.36873167753219604,
-0.15257754921913147,
-0.11333974450826645,
0.5460543632507324,
-0.36381033062934875,
-0.629895806312561,
-0.5389570593833923,
-0.15356335043907166,
-0.17215529084205627,
0.7634704113006592,
0.09070036560297012,
-0.08653721958398819,
-0.29712384939193726,
-0.14326554536819458,
-0.21242114901542664,
-0.6856958866119385,
-0.6855474710464478,
-0.21630656719207764,
0.5258811712265015,
0.07297460734844208,
0.3488360047340393,
0.39792755246162415,
0.35278239846229553,
0.3033246397972107,
-0.03518713638186455,
0.4538487493991852,
-0.44528037309646606,
0.3594079911708832,
-0.1683429628610611,
-0.45307907462120056,
-0.4855741262435913,
-0.3201923370361328,
0.6782419681549072,
0.8560088872909546,
0.007611737120896578,
0.08799263089895248,
0.34650301933288574,
0.5568574070930481,
-0.7624772787094116,
0.18464067578315735,
-0.8247508406639099,
-0.08195832371711731,
-0.4459681212902069,
-0.1673276573419571,
-0.5673590302467346,
-0.511079728603363,
0.3157043755054474,
-0.6982539892196655,
0.052286628633737564,
0.15786562860012054,
0.7684152722358704,
0.2792978286743164,
-0.26099106669425964,
-0.2326369285583496,
-0.4855804443359375,
0.8289428353309631,
-0.5616751313209534,
0.8114017844200134,
0.43168243765830994,
0.07003606855869293,
-0.021752607077360153,
-1.061409592628479,
-0.43952542543411255,
-0.29207083582878113,
-0.3045271933078766,
-0.16243648529052734,
-0.03564028814435005,
0.26081979274749756,
0.1416589915752411,
0.0023575115483254194,
-0.39825984835624695,
-0.041484490036964417,
-0.12192904949188232,
-0.3294095993041992,
0.09280446916818619,
-0.019678011536598206,
0.10090986639261246,
0.1471770703792572,
-0.47076404094696045,
-0.10689262300729752,
-0.642770528793335,
-0.14011666178703308,
0.28246745467185974,
0.4298158884048462,
0.10477083921432495,
0.24539552628993988,
0.10257108509540558,
0.9655840992927551,
0.005814034957438707,
-0.1931980401277542,
0.4465756416320801,
-0.28962117433547974,
-0.24362614750862122,
-0.08293008804321289,
0.7414960861206055,
-0.3660348653793335,
0.30498990416526794,
-0.2806953191757202,
-0.2503352165222168,
-0.3150581419467926,
0.33181193470954895,
-0.5932809114456177,
-0.2922023832798004,
0.02351396158337593,
-0.20830154418945312,
-0.4911191761493683,
-0.34313252568244934,
-0.9173193573951721,
0.003040625248104334,
-0.14508876204490662,
0.6104273796081543,
-0.7931017279624939,
-0.3022153079509735,
0.06725592166185379,
0.186737522482872,
-0.07516129314899445,
0.19013188779354095,
-0.7489334940910339,
0.23273465037345886,
0.473408579826355,
0.6439735889434814,
-0.13011765480041504,
-0.3766727149486542,
-0.5914829969406128,
0.6086403727531433,
-0.2769758105278015,
0.6472035050392151,
-0.6614035367965698,
-0.16071656346321106,
0.07706567645072937,
-0.25004324316978455,
-0.20609956979751587,
-0.3115686774253845,
0.2592422664165497,
-0.977219820022583,
0.23765096068382263,
-0.3004627525806427,
-0.6363270878791809,
-0.13967545330524445,
0.4352487325668335,
-0.5264993906021118,
1.0130529403686523,
0.17982211709022522,
-0.922426164150238,
0.3888385593891144,
-0.8860657215118408,
-0.6901661157608032,
0.004127569030970335,
0.17937782406806946,
-0.3038943409919739,
-0.0951504111289978,
0.2878498136997223,
0.5575549602508545,
0.04707159101963043,
0.3684544861316681,
-0.4233238995075226,
0.00438418984413147,
-0.13838261365890503,
-0.2400573343038559,
0.7699875831604004,
0.2325768917798996,
-0.13045841455459595,
0.12391208112239838,
-0.7067468762397766,
0.11365975439548492,
-0.02220752462744713,
-0.38828790187835693,
-0.7121158242225647,
-0.19062350690364838,
-0.493478387594223,
0.07265079021453857,
0.29388585686683655,
-0.21009433269500732,
0.05113810673356056,
-0.4399973750114441,
0.4016914963722229,
0.8127943277359009,
0.0022347259800881147,
0.5043104290962219,
-0.001503550447523594,
0.4287930130958557,
0.1875804215669632,
0.11741375923156738,
-0.18598130345344543,
-0.072585828602314,
-0.8217447996139526,
-0.1657266616821289,
0.5545242428779602,
0.3340657353401184,
-1.0406512022018433,
0.3635028004646301,
-0.36037677526474,
-0.37911611795425415,
-0.39157915115356445,
0.2605949938297272,
0.34013691544532776,
0.8228865265846252,
0.5011776089668274,
0.06084588170051575,
-0.4780031144618988,
-0.6436019539833069,
-0.33775997161865234,
-0.33084967732429504,
0.044722024351358414,
0.11526456475257874,
0.2954273819923401,
-0.054272111505270004,
0.7931899428367615,
-0.45597872138023376,
-0.2104274481534958,
-0.3184258043766022,
0.1731874793767929,
-0.04020311310887337,
0.6033364534378052,
0.5059818029403687,
-0.7022672891616821,
-0.5043546557426453,
-0.19479204714298248,
-0.42303234338760376,
-0.10444463789463043,
-0.002884121611714363,
-0.33099043369293213,
0.11263124644756317,
0.5392292737960815,
-0.7284283638000488,
-0.0052388873882591724,
0.3495727777481079,
-0.24559494853019714,
0.31785285472869873,
-0.3128367066383362,
-0.07633577287197113,
-0.9957627058029175,
0.2210027277469635,
-0.3190540075302124,
-0.5302958488464355,
-0.7186243534088135,
-0.05503670871257782,
0.2768140137195587,
-0.0009727681172080338,
-0.5144943594932556,
0.6127222776412964,
-0.4656793475151062,
-0.028479035943746567,
0.08677151054143906,
0.04910225421190262,
0.3098497688770294,
0.7988116145133972,
0.32160165905952454,
0.5662298798561096,
0.6030064225196838,
-0.8152145743370056,
0.20459438860416412,
0.16217494010925293,
-0.3355165421962738,
0.3401311933994293,
-0.3165125846862793,
0.38016277551651,
-0.062006957828998566,
-0.061905637383461,
-0.629727840423584,
0.18434782326221466,
0.3096996545791626,
-0.2647886574268341,
0.6801090836524963,
0.054078880697488785,
-0.5338661074638367,
-0.33670416474342346,
-0.07337893545627594,
0.3317553400993347,
0.45432713627815247,
-0.5204302668571472,
1.0647387504577637,
0.3708961606025696,
0.005318451207131147,
-0.7306150197982788,
-0.682115375995636,
-0.2561306357383728,
-0.18459710478782654,
-0.4404177963733673,
0.34982872009277344,
0.16022899746894836,
-0.09227734804153442,
0.27071109414100647,
-0.01819019764661789,
-0.17648077011108398,
0.11082773655653,
-0.2825087010860443,
0.013340197503566742,
-0.14912666380405426,
0.6061697006225586,
0.032955385744571686,
-0.0007875621085986495,
-0.005421153269708157,
-0.8589484691619873,
0.8274156451225281,
-0.17915962636470795,
-0.3506650924682617,
-0.15899498760700226,
0.13295067846775055,
0.669163167476654,
-0.46388980746269226,
0.8056681156158447,
0.637880802154541,
-0.37149181962013245,
-0.23458781838417053,
-0.7064458727836609,
-0.17830917239189148,
-0.49790337681770325,
0.5790439248085022,
-0.5383679270744324,
-0.7926509976387024,
0.3180255889892578,
-0.23526717722415924,
0.10862290114164352,
0.35316717624664307,
0.38654014468193054,
-0.30053916573524475,
0.7236126661300659,
0.7019519209861755,
0.021648874506354332,
0.33578041195869446,
-0.13020150363445282,
0.12269897758960724,
-0.6172320246696472,
-0.5831113457679749,
-0.4722791612148285,
0.06629132479429245,
-0.12909458577632904,
-0.5022286772727966,
0.07627475261688232,
0.11866544187068939,
-0.4033650755882263,
0.23590688407421112,
-0.13392341136932373,
0.18721453845500946,
0.6469869017601013,
0.19427351653575897,
0.1896321177482605,
-0.023620376363396645,
-0.5706530809402466,
0.06311464309692383,
-1.111269474029541,
-0.27426695823669434,
1.0827184915542603,
0.28415361046791077,
0.6544560790061951,
-0.25810521841049194,
0.5093932747840881,
0.2303108274936676,
0.2650386095046997,
-0.43949568271636963,
0.5969637632369995,
-0.15596474707126617,
-0.4740539491176605,
-0.35263592004776,
-0.5261198282241821,
-0.7106205224990845,
-0.06680114567279816,
-0.22682134807109833,
-0.3828919529914856,
0.1939200609922409,
0.5314203500747681,
-0.5416627526283264,
0.7554458975791931,
-0.6809870004653931,
0.8404448628425598,
-0.546754777431488,
-0.4633653163909912,
-0.2574934661388397,
-0.665939450263977,
0.15754227340221405,
-0.499702125787735,
0.12030379474163055,
0.1836196929216385,
-0.26490211486816406,
0.699745774269104,
-0.48632267117500305,
0.6744952201843262,
-0.42039963603019714,
0.0611598864197731,
0.2667803168296814,
0.13109233975410461,
0.7635625600814819,
-0.1600305736064911,
-0.14082081615924835,
-0.008397531695663929,
-0.2277897745370865,
-0.531158983707428,
-0.6562473177909851,
0.356211394071579,
-0.6212136149406433,
-0.6948974132537842,
-0.1769031137228012,
-0.5168505311012268,
-0.7420448064804077,
0.2812020182609558,
0.23026564717292786,
0.47619006037712097,
0.009413985535502434,
0.3057405650615692,
0.8351863622665405,
-0.44916781783103943,
0.38620948791503906,
0.39263319969177246,
-0.20138917863368988,
-0.37658438086509705,
0.7562258243560791,
0.027366848662495613,
0.49075955152511597,
0.8340644836425781,
0.1136164665222168,
-0.7327229976654053,
-0.6934424042701721,
-0.05507665127515793,
0.059250324964523315,
-0.6827106475830078,
-0.2360338568687439,
-1.0135457515716553,
-0.16388949751853943,
-0.443924218416214,
0.015294910408556461,
-0.44262051582336426,
-0.18915976583957672,
-0.1870681494474411,
-0.21035756170749664,
0.3290082812309265,
0.359562486410141,
-0.12115178257226944,
0.3183917999267578,
-0.8575940132141113,
0.16531071066856384,
0.6404112577438354,
0.5845237970352173,
0.1296163648366928,
-0.3866705894470215,
-0.2460857480764389,
-0.005865081679075956,
0.13030734658241272,
-0.7867129445075989,
0.35763320326805115,
0.25614193081855774,
0.6958164572715759,
0.39171120524406433,
0.10336630046367645,
0.7681356072425842,
-0.3712013065814972,
0.6385371685028076,
0.1580488085746765,
-1.0851669311523438,
0.672460675239563,
-0.1421097218990326,
0.3412441313266754,
0.662433922290802,
0.46425601840019226,
-0.17109842598438263,
-0.3724152445793152,
-0.6130967736244202,
-0.5892741084098816,
0.7391483187675476,
0.14488570392131805,
0.16848833858966827,
0.05195394530892372,
0.19056540727615356,
0.15379974246025085,
0.5215905904769897,
-0.6489644050598145,
-0.16654427349567413,
-0.3893667757511139,
-0.3320808410644531,
0.10959507524967194,
-0.5089755654335022,
0.10794026404619217,
-0.3302841782569885,
0.8371700644493103,
0.05351034924387932,
0.11598432809114456,
-0.02969287894666195,
-0.41377225518226624,
0.1872951090335846,
0.04650811105966568,
0.4609321355819702,
0.700725793838501,
-0.2869519591331482,
0.5170140862464905,
0.5561763644218445,
-0.6599546670913696,
0.09572435170412064,
0.03210839256644249,
-0.09055925905704498,
0.14303018152713776,
0.44937145709991455,
0.871195912361145,
0.2928624749183655,
-0.5183947682380676,
0.39210858941078186,
0.04259636998176575,
-0.20118528604507446,
-0.07258342951536179,
-0.09677310287952423,
0.1616617739200592,
0.16514331102371216,
0.2709854543209076,
0.3238157331943512,
-0.3419531285762787,
-0.29612791538238525,
0.32485249638557434,
0.3346242308616638,
-0.3749522864818573,
-0.3461514115333557,
0.49869585037231445,
0.3530820310115814,
-0.2550801932811737,
0.5501052737236023,
-0.14083828032016754,
-0.808205783367157,
0.1150970607995987,
0.4373061954975128,
0.7196208238601685,
-0.4379643499851227,
0.18265460431575775,
0.13359512388706207,
0.2947719991207123,
0.09177102893590927,
0.2735120356082916,
-0.235392764210701,
-0.828613817691803,
-0.5368942618370056,
-0.8505911827087402,
-0.06444504857063293,
0.42811018228530884,
-0.36176350712776184,
0.3013141453266144,
-0.4213521480560303,
-0.14457251131534576,
-0.4051472246646881,
0.06736302375793457,
-0.9892227649688721,
0.16956160962581635,
-0.04285457357764244,
1.1236767768859863,
-0.5753844380378723,
1.3571438789367676,
0.6411720514297485,
-0.1153278648853302,
-0.950091540813446,
-0.04611925780773163,
-0.5109342336654663,
-0.8419933319091797,
0.795708179473877,
-0.2083226591348648,
-0.031908947974443436,
0.3348916172981262,
-0.2896471917629242,
-0.9411991238594055,
0.8179004192352295,
0.6128802299499512,
-0.6046465635299683,
-0.2240295112133026,
0.28166070580482483,
0.43398505449295044,
-0.2612077295780182,
0.0898253470659256,
0.37226802110671997,
0.6097001433372498,
0.07555451989173889,
-0.4688267409801483,
-0.028798827901482582,
-0.03631051629781723,
-0.10985660552978516,
0.31204384565353394,
-0.42446601390838623,
0.5831605792045593,
-0.10389422625303268,
-0.1860819011926651,
-0.35702699422836304,
0.690914511680603,
0.27459877729415894,
0.021096637472510338,
0.9221102595329285,
0.542341411113739,
1.0170013904571533,
-0.03262937441468239,
0.8192272186279297,
-0.5642732977867126,
0.06836017221212387,
1.1652635335922241,
-0.15002109110355377,
0.5746172666549683,
0.5161260366439819,
-0.09314711391925812,
0.5096068382263184,
0.6098220348358154,
0.17181259393692017,
0.8754968643188477,
0.023255372419953346,
-0.23954308032989502,
-0.6184941530227661,
0.04130920022726059,
-0.3410465717315674,
0.24765363335609436,
0.460896760225296,
-0.39783403277397156,
-0.2558731734752655,
0.1803158074617386,
-0.056101348251104355,
0.022687824442982674,
-0.341816246509552,
0.6532108783721924,
0.20035094022750854,
-0.5033677816390991,
0.3841764032840729,
-0.2901712954044342,
0.5737490653991699,
-0.9894001483917236,
0.1888672113418579,
-0.1382792592048645,
0.04635767638683319,
0.10594577342271805,
-0.6738210916519165,
0.36294999718666077,
0.04819878190755844,
0.03020614944398403,
-0.46704864501953125,
1.1342772245407104,
-0.7216734290122986,
-0.43896880745887756,
0.38094112277030945,
0.8117835521697998,
-0.12082688510417938,
-0.05633991211652756,
-0.666107177734375,
-0.18499648571014404,
-0.03171384334564209,
-0.5027433633804321,
0.07470659166574478,
0.641472339630127,
0.1501617729663849,
0.8255761861801147,
0.6991164684295654,
0.3331585228443146,
0.08414354175329208,
0.17937853932380676,
0.8402553796768188,
-0.41082316637039185,
-0.6456166505813599,
-1.0573911666870117,
0.5128213763237,
-0.17775630950927734,
0.02638595551252365,
0.4777701199054718,
0.3582082688808441,
0.7702945470809937,
-0.12703637778759003,
0.7417677044868469,
0.10328502207994461,
0.6067298054695129,
-0.6181873083114624,
0.8547636270523071,
-0.48695287108421326,
0.39795857667922974,
-0.15475375950336456,
-0.8983619809150696,
-0.2367338091135025,
0.2824590802192688,
-0.4283389747142792,
0.006619036663323641,
0.6374732255935669,
0.6801850199699402,
-0.14789989590644836,
-0.10173723846673965,
0.3862438499927521,
0.32475030422210693,
0.11873197555541992,
0.6136433482170105,
0.9795573353767395,
0.14026035368442535,
0.9013463258743286,
-0.44143784046173096,
0.11605425179004669,
0.09943313151597977,
-0.9799515604972839,
-1.03049635887146,
-0.6458972096443176,
-0.17225787043571472,
-0.009307224303483963,
0.3603549003601074,
0.8921173214912415,
1.0010101795196533,
-0.7046840786933899,
0.1291716992855072,
-0.2653465270996094,
0.2871982157230377,
-0.1090586930513382,
-0.17888914048671722,
0.7130502462387085,
-0.7915867567062378,
-0.5350152254104614,
0.3048771619796753,
0.2712074816226959,
0.13116545975208282,
-0.23734088242053986,
-0.027986489236354828,
-0.262289822101593,
-0.19688621163368225,
0.5804198980331421,
-0.0028590387664735317,
-0.36926138401031494,
-0.4128500521183014,
0.06177842617034912,
-0.018943162634968758,
-0.04529544338583946,
0.7185000777244568,
-1.1113135814666748,
0.3658720850944519,
0.5721828937530518,
0.8880572319030762,
0.5447252988815308,
-0.20866680145263672,
0.9263256788253784,
-0.9228699803352356,
0.20338299870491028,
0.47961193323135376,
0.3442390561103821,
0.3427477180957794,
-0.3216487765312195,
0.37712207436561584,
0.2801620662212372,
-0.14318135380744934,
-0.9644197225570679,
0.045243434607982635,
-0.6977189779281616,
-0.3703632354736328,
0.9046706557273865,
-0.43519049882888794,
-0.18903256952762604,
-0.2530900239944458,
0.2318492978811264,
0.4264075458049774,
-0.1760001927614212,
0.5265843868255615,
0.5500901937484741,
0.26608651876449585,
-0.2514646351337433,
-0.326684832572937,
0.8953340649604797,
0.4513854682445526,
-0.7876158952713013,
-0.03194228932261467,
0.0065239607356488705,
0.25558724999427795,
0.09729018807411194,
0.5649459362030029,
-0.09268737584352493,
-0.17756354808807373,
-0.201152503490448,
-0.06639016419649124,
-0.4489162862300873,
-0.43440788984298706,
0.04187930375337601,
0.4799652099609375,
-0.015203051269054413,
-0.26864093542099
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14705v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14705v1
|
Concept-Best-Matching: Evaluating Compositionality in Emergent Communication
| 2024-03-17T12:47:02 | 2024-03-17T12:47:02 |
Boaz Carmeli, Yonatan Belinkov, Ron Meir
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Artificial agents that learn to communicate in order to accomplish a given
task acquire communication protocols that are typically opaque to a human. A
large body of work has attempted to evaluate the emergent communication via
various evaluation measures, with \emph{compositionality} featuring as a
prominent desired trait. However, current evaluation procedures do not directly
expose the compositionality of the emergent communication. We propose a
procedure to assess the compositionality of emergent communication by finding
the best-match between emerged words and natural language concepts. The
best-match algorithm provides both a global score and a translation-map from
emergent words to natural language concepts. To the best of our knowledge, it
is the first time that such direct and interpretable mapping between emergent
words and human concepts is provided.
|
[
-0.37272870540618896,
-0.8120054006576538,
0.565050482749939,
0.4494929313659668,
-0.4569886326789856,
0.7372522354125977,
-0.20993204414844513,
-0.8491650819778442,
0.27731263637542725,
0.037583135068416595,
-0.3239988684654236,
-0.27222585678100586,
-0.42704057693481445,
0.29270657896995544,
-0.40489324927330017,
0.6469345688819885,
-0.06421594321727753,
-0.4693610668182373,
-0.3619453012943268,
0.058419253677129745,
-0.44966840744018555,
0.1613265424966812,
-0.9413332343101501,
-0.731996476650238,
0.11345524340867996,
0.14763018488883972,
0.614033043384552,
0.8880064487457275,
0.676246702671051,
0.5430662631988525,
-0.3565256893634796,
0.4061656892299652,
-0.5336166024208069,
0.2774846851825714,
-0.5214217901229858,
-0.3652389943599701,
-0.0872042328119278,
0.11733435839414597,
0.5454630851745605,
0.41062524914741516,
-0.12802955508232117,
0.29316452145576477,
-0.02570662647485733,
0.5427531003952026,
-0.4579989016056061,
0.22601129114627838,
-0.6379306316375732,
0.2918637692928314,
0.07587558031082153,
-0.6139733195304871,
-0.3571242094039917,
-0.3136909008026123,
0.3777306079864502,
-0.7056369185447693,
-0.0058500193990767,
0.23611845076084137,
0.8497379422187805,
0.2165202498435974,
-0.4847756624221802,
-0.48609790205955505,
-0.9742184281349182,
0.3737974464893341,
-0.13442260026931763,
0.17385047674179077,
0.14664500951766968,
0.4288054406642914,
-0.21423520147800446,
-0.48618945479393005,
-0.7647290825843811,
-0.2966240644454956,
0.03911435976624489,
0.4180946946144104,
-0.24770596623420715,
0.18017615377902985,
-0.3291044533252716,
0.5091336369514465,
-0.6821089386940002,
-0.13698264956474304,
-0.19313813745975494,
-0.2290390133857727,
0.7749698162078857,
0.13736526668071747,
0.5598089694976807,
-0.054658398032188416,
-0.6397611498832703,
-0.13916835188865662,
-0.08007794618606567,
-0.3971749544143677,
0.21929959952831268,
0.3710104525089264,
-0.2588406205177307,
0.4322951138019562,
-0.10520616173744202,
0.9188900589942932,
0.23789188265800476,
-0.09843500703573227,
0.1660853922367096,
-0.7222573757171631,
-0.1597999483346939,
0.06406653672456741,
0.8114202618598938,
0.5341801047325134,
0.12142763286828995,
-0.5223873257637024,
-0.21403434872627258,
0.36313343048095703,
0.2628926634788513,
-0.44864413142204285,
-0.06526891142129898,
0.10068033635616302,
-0.2986547350883484,
-0.5886462330818176,
0.1480259895324707,
-0.34962937235832214,
-0.29663875699043274,
-0.3345765173435211,
0.6427668333053589,
-0.21280279755592346,
-0.5389342904090881,
-0.27368998527526855,
-0.3011381924152374,
0.5504424571990967,
0.05039780214428902,
-0.8617551922798157,
0.23497068881988525,
0.8137038350105286,
1.1864529848098755,
-0.35925954580307007,
-0.06337913870811462,
0.08853837847709656,
-0.003905372926965356,
-0.7468283772468567,
1.1575205326080322,
-0.3896844983100891,
-0.3382907509803772,
-0.284831166267395,
-0.39365583658218384,
-0.26789969205856323,
-0.6541664004325867,
0.6715611815452576,
-0.5539739727973938,
0.14286445081233978,
-0.06418142467737198,
-0.8880239725112915,
0.14202980697155,
0.19013111293315887,
-0.5701552629470825,
0.7241796255111694,
0.3809942603111267,
-0.6916064620018005,
0.42498818039894104,
-1.0913176536560059,
-0.3446347415447235,
0.5758232474327087,
0.07981553673744202,
0.0377553254365921,
-0.10963886231184006,
-0.38558661937713623,
0.17991578578948975,
-0.17252694070339203,
0.00013922128709964454,
-0.031968045979738235,
-0.3620103895664215,
0.3868071436882019,
0.2046625018119812,
0.6589618921279907,
0.5030907392501831,
-0.31803447008132935,
0.365154504776001,
-0.6415522694587708,
0.18490591645240784,
0.42682451009750366,
-0.20027345418930054,
-0.4980766773223877,
0.18940788507461548,
0.010709291324019432,
0.27046170830726624,
0.35069286823272705,
-0.6169871091842651,
-0.253555029630661,
-0.6337120532989502,
0.6180737018585205,
0.9599144458770752,
0.09585905820131302,
0.8176211714744568,
-0.6627485156059265,
0.2569041848182678,
-0.14371781051158905,
0.19910722970962524,
-0.04275049641728401,
-0.4296291470527649,
-0.615182101726532,
-0.143314391374588,
0.04666915535926819,
0.6713483929634094,
-0.5793309807777405,
0.9101518988609314,
-0.2832547724246979,
-0.8938704133033752,
-0.8974837064743042,
0.017468363046646118,
0.4184624254703522,
0.4021769165992737,
0.07816329598426819,
-0.4574972093105316,
-0.609346330165863,
-0.8396898508071899,
-0.13359509408473969,
-0.445659875869751,
0.16005481779575348,
0.20632171630859375,
0.3200116753578186,
-0.2760619819164276,
1.004280686378479,
-0.3807595670223236,
-0.24207709729671478,
-0.2974119186401367,
0.18034903705120087,
-0.13088198006153107,
0.4444970488548279,
0.39762404561042786,
-0.9517748355865479,
-0.7546406984329224,
0.29680052399635315,
-0.6886968612670898,
0.017009347677230835,
-0.0008941254345700145,
-0.3721911609172821,
-0.24126166105270386,
0.33743706345558167,
-0.5338283181190491,
-0.11526887118816376,
0.6203218102455139,
-0.6202329397201538,
0.249176487326622,
-0.09871004521846771,
0.2449081391096115,
-1.4249194860458374,
0.13772070407867432,
-0.08295082300901413,
-0.16320262849330902,
-0.6702657341957092,
0.8002864718437195,
-0.24041496217250824,
0.19446530938148499,
-0.3385592997074127,
0.7105477452278137,
-0.41650769114494324,
-0.1899518072605133,
-0.33500370383262634,
0.6095168590545654,
-0.04421049728989601,
-0.1350528448820114,
0.031737711280584335,
0.875558614730835,
0.5339354872703552,
-0.8213657140731812,
0.5682888627052307,
0.5745537281036377,
-0.23400887846946716,
0.9764081239700317,
-0.7374503016471863,
0.5059886574745178,
-0.1831226348876953,
0.2113005369901657,
-0.9788838028907776,
-0.10333887487649918,
0.15782298147678375,
-0.6652680039405823,
0.0205041766166687,
0.05889195576310158,
-0.48013922572135925,
-0.23217467963695526,
-0.17288658022880554,
0.3241664469242096,
0.28910043835639954,
-0.20463937520980835,
0.484193354845047,
0.271313339471817,
0.1224995106458664,
-0.2118978202342987,
-0.38330382108688354,
0.33875569701194763,
-0.17043331265449524,
-0.7399073243141174,
0.6235092282295227,
-0.6170386075973511,
-0.16052182018756866,
-0.171044260263443,
-0.10831031203269958,
-0.13432350754737854,
0.43544381856918335,
-0.09515154361724854,
0.15196096897125244,
-0.32047170400619507,
-0.3293367028236389,
-0.20567277073860168,
-0.15361632406711578,
0.09103488177061081,
-0.3247312605381012,
0.4226776957511902,
-0.2559908926486969,
-0.179275780916214,
-0.23767147958278656,
0.4422133266925812,
0.47927892208099365,
-0.16976653039455414,
0.7593145370483398,
0.7956575751304626,
-0.3371712267398834,
-0.1770971268415451,
-0.30843761563301086,
-0.18050000071525574,
-0.5421832799911499,
0.3599417209625244,
-0.3336274325847626,
-0.5343233346939087,
0.4644504189491272,
-0.10629913955926895,
-0.010214288718998432,
0.47732049226760864,
0.3837778568267822,
-0.15904118120670319,
0.7832908630371094,
0.7418667078018188,
0.1061154380440712,
0.5548725724220276,
-0.27161043882369995,
0.1555420160293579,
-0.9338350296020508,
-0.5135562419891357,
-0.602120578289032,
-0.23319615423679352,
-0.8042953014373779,
-0.29775819182395935,
0.1356937736272812,
-0.38011735677719116,
-0.09897779673337936,
0.6024878621101379,
-0.7288629412651062,
0.7775753140449524,
0.4279423654079437,
0.10132773220539093,
0.45716923475265503,
-0.3903322219848633,
-0.3798424005508423,
0.15270106494426727,
-0.36716532707214355,
-0.5586585998535156,
0.9203310012817383,
0.04192958399653435,
0.46429377794265747,
0.3705293536186218,
0.9210493564605713,
0.4447341859340668,
0.2368042767047882,
-1.030420184135437,
0.6994888782501221,
0.16008886694908142,
-0.36865437030792236,
-0.2008393257856369,
-0.6745411157608032,
-1.322285532951355,
0.26743677258491516,
-0.5105485320091248,
-0.7224330902099609,
-0.2692970037460327,
-0.12750104069709778,
-0.047995373606681824,
-0.013496006838977337,
-0.7193376421928406,
0.8331863880157471,
-0.21952342987060547,
0.10739035159349442,
-0.11425269395112991,
-0.8734007477760315,
0.27354878187179565,
-0.14060109853744507,
0.09027030318975449,
-0.05563143268227577,
-0.22099371254444122,
0.7310146689414978,
0.33957639336586,
0.3623460829257965,
0.29557743668556213,
-0.22116824984550476,
0.31078866124153137,
0.2633124589920044,
0.07555125653743744,
-0.4096841514110565,
0.11823974549770355,
-0.34343305230140686,
-0.058289576321840286,
-0.431202232837677,
-0.6096193194389343,
0.20497724413871765,
-0.9451853632926941,
-0.16031131148338318,
-0.501314640045166,
-0.12994267046451569,
0.03352418169379234,
0.3116556406021118,
0.29637283086776733,
0.016514554619789124,
-0.8394168615341187,
-0.05581076815724373,
0.7970373034477234,
0.28240370750427246,
0.48434630036354065,
0.8100377321243286,
0.0784277692437172,
-0.21846339106559753,
1.106117606163025,
-0.5282845497131348,
0.5745102167129517,
0.835894763469696,
0.387008398771286,
-0.5347671508789062,
-0.5832122564315796,
-0.3150128722190857,
-0.05264586582779884,
-0.6467597484588623,
-0.30924415588378906,
-0.4450775384902954,
-0.5792236924171448,
0.008333341218531132,
-0.03739314153790474,
-0.26112616062164307,
0.045997388660907745,
-0.263824462890625,
-0.1746702790260315,
-0.32070374488830566,
0.9161543846130371,
-0.1116836816072464,
0.17367033660411835,
-0.8450581431388855,
0.30743247270584106,
0.4819551408290863,
0.08176140487194061,
-0.1658792793750763,
-0.5500194430351257,
-0.2015472948551178,
-0.0006466106860898435,
-0.5472533702850342,
-1.0557990074157715,
-0.1597328633069992,
0.7804065942764282,
0.771456241607666,
0.6613566279411316,
-0.051157042384147644,
0.4803950786590576,
-0.2103056013584137,
0.5681245923042297,
0.08146781474351883,
-1.0913740396499634,
0.8517815470695496,
-0.15826347470283508,
0.1925113946199417,
0.4858696162700653,
0.28612464666366577,
-0.711550235748291,
-0.6028627753257751,
-0.7806892395019531,
-0.8053132891654968,
0.34858468174934387,
0.48832064867019653,
0.2753162980079651,
-0.1979781687259674,
0.037967223674058914,
-0.1437474936246872,
0.1437937468290329,
-0.5581552386283875,
-0.2178158462047577,
0.20264898240566254,
-0.3823882043361664,
-0.21607427299022675,
0.24114751815795898,
-0.36831679940223694,
-0.01684088446199894,
0.17994485795497894,
-0.19364143908023834,
0.9199084043502808,
0.07659970968961716,
-0.2622101306915283,
-0.5111033916473389,
0.27530398964881897,
0.7674632668495178,
0.7779718637466431,
-0.03479098901152611,
0.14696267247200012,
-0.2836403548717499,
-0.564054548740387,
0.5383071303367615,
0.031059712171554565,
-0.37216898798942566,
-0.08163954317569733,
0.5423572659492493,
0.6483073234558105,
0.24493294954299927,
-0.5556699633598328,
0.6063605546951294,
-0.0957399532198906,
-0.017464108765125275,
-0.10409314930438995,
0.3493296504020691,
0.1864606887102127,
0.25991639494895935,
0.48869118094444275,
0.3886664807796478,
0.3402337431907654,
-0.9287142157554626,
0.40351322293281555,
0.5348296761512756,
-0.24408698081970215,
-0.5669769644737244,
0.41341283917427063,
0.39690518379211426,
-0.6001268625259399,
0.3215787708759308,
-0.5714271068572998,
-0.6983143091201782,
0.5432809591293335,
0.8045229315757751,
0.9988731741905212,
-0.7177067399024963,
0.6313437223434448,
0.29567456245422363,
0.4346165359020233,
0.059883419424295425,
0.287233829498291,
-0.1728193461894989,
-1.0857410430908203,
-0.28698664903640747,
-0.6262137293815613,
-0.3365955650806427,
-0.21300238370895386,
-0.4643631875514984,
-0.1452198177576065,
-0.20245249569416046,
-0.23484106361865997,
0.08197879046201706,
0.12549887597560883,
-0.6459351181983948,
0.12507200241088867,
0.1855202317237854,
0.870140552520752,
-1.205317497253418,
0.1376287043094635,
0.969367504119873,
-0.4138149619102478,
-0.6054045557975769,
-0.08819723129272461,
-0.17196859419345856,
-0.8122888803482056,
0.3491520881652832,
-0.10625042021274567,
-0.1896260380744934,
0.2210160791873932,
-0.42245781421661377,
-0.9035425186157227,
1.2117705345153809,
0.5013237595558167,
0.1399826556444168,
-0.015330794267356396,
-0.004027718212455511,
0.7263293266296387,
-0.5570235252380371,
0.7599174380302429,
0.6051273345947266,
0.5061362385749817,
0.5151834487915039,
-1.133679747581482,
0.17221993207931519,
-0.3468080163002014,
-0.02698548138141632,
0.10021930187940598,
-0.7271527051925659,
0.496383935213089,
-0.21732176840305328,
-0.6241110563278198,
0.20084039866924286,
0.7761948704719543,
0.03455048426985741,
0.42071112990379333,
0.5131253004074097,
0.4410196840763092,
0.7082025408744812,
-0.025676347315311432,
0.4019297957420349,
-0.28581640124320984,
0.32440873980522156,
0.9904491305351257,
-0.08960724622011185,
0.837211549282074,
0.17928820848464966,
-0.2358432114124298,
0.4905101954936981,
0.8399483561515808,
0.26745784282684326,
0.5728363990783691,
0.3752995431423187,
-0.2642956078052521,
-0.10502094775438309,
-0.3919772803783417,
-0.10829494148492813,
0.7948563098907471,
0.2867126762866974,
-0.06558740884065628,
-0.05647272244095802,
-0.4229101538658142,
-0.3620011508464813,
0.3622882068157196,
0.0723046287894249,
1.4788233041763306,
-0.027629932388663292,
-0.6132100224494934,
0.5315115451812744,
0.051417406648397446,
0.5912284851074219,
-0.44298186898231506,
-0.049258504062891006,
-0.2675672173500061,
-0.23195679485797882,
-0.23028191924095154,
-0.7025361657142639,
0.17360419034957886,
-0.47222450375556946,
0.32323020696640015,
0.10174528509378433,
0.5649551749229431,
-0.6373464465141296,
0.04289710894227028,
0.42708414793014526,
0.7045704126358032,
-0.04336552694439888,
0.06097770109772682,
-0.9384862780570984,
-0.09999239444732666,
-0.5077638030052185,
0.339869886636734,
0.06704280525445938,
0.3137359619140625,
0.31046053767204285,
0.8866615295410156,
0.5189075469970703,
0.22753380239009857,
-0.044062480330467224,
-0.1678263396024704,
0.6176277995109558,
-0.4452718198299408,
-0.8348802924156189,
-0.8026317358016968,
0.36223718523979187,
-0.45476242899894714,
-0.41543343663215637,
0.41109177470207214,
0.577475368976593,
0.7477236986160278,
0.08441618084907532,
0.6564925312995911,
-0.15132303535938263,
-0.02384069189429283,
-0.2919313609600067,
0.5487520694732666,
-0.2361159324645996,
-0.19824975728988647,
-0.6504302620887756,
-1.4060593843460083,
0.3657079339027405,
0.8854261040687561,
0.5723820924758911,
0.11228209733963013,
0.9092656970024109,
0.45139357447624207,
-0.265982985496521,
0.09289642423391342,
0.1945890188217163,
0.04556301236152649,
0.17231498658657074,
0.6648060083389282,
1.0201215744018555,
-0.36322450637817383,
0.343111515045166,
0.12137195467948914,
-0.5554144382476807,
-0.2319272756576538,
-0.9010522961616516,
-0.6380990147590637,
-0.9986618757247925,
-0.41631683707237244,
-0.23524363338947296,
0.12911725044250488,
1.193928837776184,
0.8072184920310974,
-0.5773735642433167,
-0.2866235673427582,
-0.27116090059280396,
0.1852162480354309,
-0.599977433681488,
-0.26791855692863464,
0.0914701521396637,
-0.16281022131443024,
-0.47523435950279236,
0.6170309782028198,
0.28858572244644165,
0.5021169781684875,
-0.4494684338569641,
-0.2365468144416809,
-0.10097000747919083,
0.4082500636577606,
0.7045672535896301,
0.24882322549819946,
-0.4810371696949005,
-0.40484297275543213,
0.03610317036509514,
-0.10313175618648529,
0.029792338609695435,
0.786078929901123,
-0.2563566565513611,
0.8055227398872375,
0.3410945534706116,
0.7853503227233887,
0.2411206066608429,
0.021776506677269936,
0.6473439335823059,
-0.768031895160675,
-0.09020143747329712,
0.43803268671035767,
-0.1320096254348755,
0.7029814720153809,
-0.27422666549682617,
0.48497891426086426,
0.3678486943244934,
-0.36057209968566895,
-0.5662971138954163,
0.3444874584674835,
-1.1400141716003418,
0.23010702431201935,
0.9424989223480225,
0.013848824426531792,
-0.10030259937047958,
-0.2919866442680359,
-0.10678168386220932,
0.4542423188686371,
-0.33031728863716125,
0.9269561171531677,
0.5777345895767212,
0.1544114649295807,
-0.010953729040920734,
-0.18889082968235016,
0.6059694290161133,
-0.09945384413003922,
-0.9157005548477173,
-0.5291782021522522,
-0.1291712075471878,
0.23625878989696503,
0.3952825963497162,
0.8695662021636963,
0.3003479242324829,
0.15355448424816132,
-0.032545577734708786,
-0.3552439510822296,
0.21330885589122772,
-0.21794761717319489,
0.23648273944854736,
-0.25283730030059814,
0.2693932056427002,
-0.37092408537864685
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11183v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11183v2
|
Decoding Continuous Character-based Language from Non-invasive Brain Recordings
| 2024-03-17T12:12:33 | 2024-03-19T10:09:20 |
Cenyuan Zhang, Xiaoqing Zheng, Ruicheng Yin, Shujie Geng, Jianhan Xu, Xuan Gao, Changze Lv, Zixuan Ling, Xuanjing Huang, Miao Cao, Jianfeng Feng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Deciphering natural language from brain activity through non-invasive devices
remains a formidable challenge. Previous non-invasive decoders either require
multiple experiments with identical stimuli to pinpoint cortical regions and
enhance signal-to-noise ratios in brain activity, or they are limited to
discerning basic linguistic elements such as letters and words. We propose a
novel approach to decoding continuous language from single-trial non-invasive
fMRI recordings, in which a three-dimensional convolutional network augmented
with information bottleneck is developed to automatically identify responsive
voxels to stimuli, and a character-based decoder is designed for the semantic
reconstruction of continuous language characterized by inherent character
structures. The resulting decoder can produce intelligible textual sequences
that faithfully capture the meaning of perceived speech both within and across
subjects, while existing decoders exhibit significantly inferior performance in
cross-subject contexts. The ability to decode continuous language from single
trials across subjects demonstrates the promising applications of non-invasive
language brain-computer interfaces in both healthcare and neuroscience.
|
[
-0.17720913887023926,
-0.9702972173690796,
0.4360980987548828,
0.3607902228832245,
-0.5066413879394531,
0.09301276504993439,
-0.34072422981262207,
-0.40272101759910583,
0.5274425148963928,
0.6501100659370422,
-0.6702508330345154,
-0.5409266948699951,
-0.3817727267742157,
0.44605985283851624,
-0.32920917868614197,
0.7037795186042786,
0.009058852680027485,
0.041554078459739685,
-0.24333149194717407,
-0.35239270329475403,
-0.5860483646392822,
-0.58244389295578,
-0.8157809972763062,
-0.3528066575527191,
0.5223641395568848,
0.09848834574222565,
0.4385680556297302,
0.3599832057952881,
0.19506992399692535,
0.24618272483348846,
0.008202943950891495,
0.17189675569534302,
-0.3895561695098877,
-0.10554271936416626,
0.1670004278421402,
-0.22374293208122253,
-0.032291147857904434,
-0.39592206478118896,
0.7662303447723389,
0.9862646460533142,
-0.049916815012693405,
-0.2855241000652313,
0.25456514954566956,
0.5556418895721436,
-0.5504999756813049,
0.3824073374271393,
-0.22294726967811584,
-0.1386060267686844,
-0.21975696086883545,
-0.16344718635082245,
-0.8219664096832275,
-0.398681640625,
-0.21294663846492767,
-0.6812248229980469,
0.2249610424041748,
-0.19873033463954926,
0.6178649663925171,
0.002706893254071474,
-0.23728519678115845,
-0.5201601982116699,
-0.47355228662490845,
0.5669539570808411,
-0.4563664197921753,
0.4340709447860718,
0.549302339553833,
-0.01731010153889656,
-0.30605241656303406,
-0.5702418088912964,
-0.7228913307189941,
-0.3386651575565338,
-0.4136480391025543,
-0.039382483810186386,
-0.17911876738071442,
0.18165463209152222,
0.039951495826244354,
0.13138307631015778,
-0.7616457939147949,
-0.037504568696022034,
-0.15710540115833282,
-0.355997234582901,
0.42006275057792664,
0.11540986597537994,
0.6668295860290527,
-0.0905911847949028,
-0.05110298842191696,
-0.12044470757246017,
-0.36033785343170166,
0.05420411750674248,
-0.10322533547878265,
0.3462635278701782,
-0.3159174919128418,
0.5297269225120544,
0.1826113760471344,
0.541797935962677,
0.015557273291051388,
-0.06088729947805405,
0.2999478578567505,
-0.22590923309326172,
-0.10236330330371857,
0.25318023562431335,
0.9318962693214417,
0.18795427680015564,
0.14463917911052704,
-0.5495126843452454,
0.022563690319657326,
0.2145565301179886,
0.006807965226471424,
-0.5733978152275085,
-0.36802938580513,
0.1983398199081421,
-0.46210145950317383,
0.09571248292922974,
-0.3242883086204529,
-0.7365247011184692,
-0.38953959941864014,
-0.01548406295478344,
0.21785536408424377,
-0.876334547996521,
-0.4822356402873993,
0.34962472319602966,
-0.25567492842674255,
-0.0005340275238268077,
-0.19935403764247894,
-1.0082167387008667,
0.33332088589668274,
0.31690701842308044,
0.9566717743873596,
-0.07408162206411362,
-0.07658054679632187,
-0.41741904616355896,
0.12601269781589508,
-0.5119832158088684,
0.775710940361023,
-0.24475033581256866,
-0.5786930322647095,
-0.12296146899461746,
0.049836549907922745,
-0.21807071566581726,
-0.5040713548660278,
0.4864492416381836,
-0.42182523012161255,
-0.15119047462940216,
-0.23502464592456818,
-0.4034900665283203,
-0.0212613083422184,
0.05536305159330368,
-0.9078810811042786,
0.38214126229286194,
0.17637456953525543,
-0.5553969144821167,
0.08112640678882599,
-0.8075833320617676,
-0.8346766233444214,
0.47135695815086365,
-0.32106688618659973,
-0.4515302777290344,
0.39962852001190186,
0.19694261252880096,
0.19862309098243713,
0.10728424787521362,
0.16464297473430634,
-0.2842465341091156,
-0.44344303011894226,
0.5330579876899719,
-0.62091463804245,
0.6777933239936829,
0.1070600301027298,
-0.060379207134246826,
-0.26530155539512634,
-0.944382905960083,
0.21924357116222382,
0.1209038719534874,
-0.3638855516910553,
-0.4184997081756592,
0.1665629744529724,
0.2255871295928955,
-0.11932937800884247,
0.3271298110485077,
-0.9451949000358582,
-0.10762391239404678,
-0.26916754245758057,
0.5770146250724792,
0.05384039133787155,
0.19151367247104645,
0.2554210424423218,
-0.21889996528625488,
0.20398306846618652,
-0.08200934529304504,
-0.23210428655147552,
-0.11909668147563934,
-0.2826080918312073,
-0.682628333568573,
-0.7474868297576904,
0.08135572075843811,
0.33408328890800476,
-1.2503468990325928,
0.24008260667324066,
-0.5258604288101196,
-0.1803179532289505,
-0.5804804563522339,
-0.3915475904941559,
0.4013574421405792,
0.7012829184532166,
0.5764045119285583,
-0.37032002210617065,
-0.5258406400680542,
-0.8701326251029968,
-0.13297024369239807,
-0.20780204236507416,
-0.4478144943714142,
0.054618027061223984,
0.055050626397132874,
-0.11225471645593643,
0.7762693166732788,
-0.2332247942686081,
-0.2675198018550873,
-0.31025010347366333,
0.5581623911857605,
0.3559349477291107,
0.3387621343135834,
-0.041745975613594055,
-0.34519830346107483,
-0.32667940855026245,
0.3407718539237976,
-0.9357941150665283,
0.05865340679883957,
-0.4689842164516449,
0.12601055204868317,
0.2023993283510208,
0.5146949887275696,
-0.39198681712150574,
0.14776252210140228,
0.463848739862442,
-0.37706565856933594,
0.08637704700231552,
-0.4364190399646759,
0.05628958344459534,
-0.7021761536598206,
0.38962796330451965,
-0.03581937402486801,
0.028791524469852448,
-0.909133791923523,
-0.26234397292137146,
0.37928369641304016,
-0.05573011189699173,
0.01502090785652399,
0.3090212345123291,
-0.7502439618110657,
0.3424071669578552,
-0.4181671440601349,
0.06468275934457779,
0.12446796894073486,
0.6573873162269592,
0.6407988667488098,
0.8151111006736755,
0.15474656224250793,
-0.5312319993972778,
-0.13961495459079742,
0.4137720763683319,
-0.40852683782577515,
0.7148938775062561,
-0.3590046763420105,
0.4095373749732971,
-0.4327584207057953,
0.12625010311603546,
-0.7111050486564636,
-0.16784101724624634,
0.06200385093688965,
-0.430880606174469,
0.346567302942276,
0.01824055425822735,
-0.35662969946861267,
0.036523401737213135,
0.16392943263053894,
0.48360100388526917,
0.4660533368587494,
-0.29141536355018616,
0.4460749328136444,
0.5124096274375916,
0.0023131263442337513,
-0.2465301901102066,
-1.1555192470550537,
0.30109158158302307,
0.18654990196228027,
-0.5753413438796997,
0.07125873863697052,
0.0403820239007473,
0.16368764638900757,
-0.21342457830905914,
-0.10802250355482101,
-0.42112430930137634,
-0.14300571382045746,
0.11520151793956757,
0.08046270906925201,
-0.2346193641424179,
-0.038153473287820816,
0.1350882649421692,
0.05412646755576134,
0.06832189857959747,
-0.16709619760513306,
0.3451324701309204,
0.07540156692266464,
-0.15246331691741943,
-0.6588385105133057,
0.7901929616928101,
0.7855228781700134,
-0.11811842769384384,
0.49460434913635254,
0.2998664975166321,
-0.5850009322166443,
0.07645824551582336,
-0.12811614573001862,
-0.019527040421962738,
-0.5029610991477966,
0.5544496774673462,
-0.6719099283218384,
-0.905738890171051,
0.08810983598232269,
-0.05488549545407295,
-0.24909357726573944,
0.11239401251077652,
0.2856079339981079,
-0.2528737783432007,
0.6842674612998962,
0.5313712358474731,
0.20429374277591705,
0.3342429995536804,
0.009249201975762844,
0.33827194571495056,
-1.0227879285812378,
-0.4155881702899933,
-0.1384909749031067,
-0.2786349058151245,
-0.2869842052459717,
-0.18106259405612946,
0.414277583360672,
-0.016700375825166702,
0.12852028012275696,
0.6047832369804382,
-0.4543033540248871,
0.44864723086357117,
0.0024810838513076305,
0.4841505289077759,
0.2458163946866989,
0.18862301111221313,
-0.31599026918411255,
-0.13712213933467865,
-0.5313928723335266,
-0.4419577717781067,
0.7365373969078064,
0.256870299577713,
0.6192750334739685,
0.011444306001067162,
0.42837849259376526,
0.06334978342056274,
0.4148830473423004,
-0.7112413644790649,
0.48683714866638184,
-0.3440684676170349,
-0.3883422613143921,
-0.26986193656921387,
-0.5071730613708496,
-1.056164026260376,
0.16485406458377838,
-0.07313047349452972,
-0.7144041061401367,
0.6152389049530029,
0.05179491266608238,
-0.46847960352897644,
0.175664022564888,
-0.7648521065711975,
0.6986193060874939,
-0.09763363003730774,
-0.3683575391769409,
0.11834943294525146,
-0.45470014214515686,
0.38501957058906555,
-0.07704365253448486,
0.2542053759098053,
0.1516466736793518,
-0.11452378332614899,
0.34399935603141785,
-0.16886667907238007,
0.679048478603363,
-0.16752202808856964,
-0.0026616996619850397,
0.10381010174751282,
0.24181297421455383,
0.2840229570865631,
0.11503445357084274,
-0.2246875911951065,
0.545006275177002,
0.24633359909057617,
-0.3571937084197998,
-0.5963847637176514,
0.5732749700546265,
-0.6239582896232605,
0.14583036303520203,
-0.3550771474838257,
-0.5932657718658447,
-0.3567245602607727,
0.2506270706653595,
0.33340707421302795,
0.5508127212524414,
-0.8200685381889343,
0.26918262243270874,
0.7784040570259094,
0.014302597381174564,
0.6038380861282349,
0.3967725932598114,
0.2879534959793091,
-0.6320186257362366,
1.1320232152938843,
-0.07392952591180801,
0.05576023831963539,
0.927913248538971,
-0.14119651913642883,
-0.48103833198547363,
-0.8100385665893555,
-0.2265782505273819,
0.29312005639076233,
-0.4031628668308258,
0.14916476607322693,
-0.7301652431488037,
-0.04720476642251015,
0.05964839830994606,
-0.14622148871421814,
-0.3186899721622467,
-0.03590460866689682,
-0.33908674120903015,
0.21343334019184113,
-0.001273173256777227,
0.37380754947662354,
-0.05439653620123863,
0.4684208035469055,
-0.6872354745864868,
0.5301287174224854,
-0.03870021924376488,
0.3749683201313019,
-0.41388311982154846,
0.03599405661225319,
-0.38084879517555237,
0.20143742859363556,
0.1614445000886917,
-0.8561094999313354,
0.6497909426689148,
0.18155382573604584,
0.22260552644729614,
0.3064299523830414,
0.17397001385688782,
0.6340520977973938,
-0.5458295941352844,
0.6428571939468384,
0.5159499645233154,
-0.8460802435874939,
0.017413273453712463,
-0.14240045845508575,
0.7433470487594604,
0.8008922934532166,
0.13747771084308624,
-0.9389139413833618,
-0.27036401629447937,
-0.020422661677002907,
-0.6724987030029297,
0.6765124797821045,
0.4913182258605957,
0.0618685819208622,
-0.6122047901153564,
0.2273484766483307,
-0.0023710462264716625,
-0.018607044592499733,
-0.5121394395828247,
0.04103844612836838,
-0.32785987854003906,
-0.5481836199760437,
-0.13571900129318237,
-0.04129911959171295,
-0.2182837426662445,
0.1691942662000656,
0.24161262810230255,
-0.3139772117137909,
0.7228676080703735,
0.4237130880355835,
-0.3310164511203766,
0.2932896316051483,
0.34276849031448364,
0.6805015206336975,
0.20896318554878235,
-0.19525934755802155,
0.22124046087265015,
0.21433258056640625,
-0.8196706175804138,
0.09421613067388535,
0.03671221435070038,
0.12213793396949768,
0.3947458863258362,
0.2999369204044342,
0.9239761829376221,
0.10710594058036804,
-0.4981372058391571,
0.4564369022846222,
-0.6810619235038757,
-0.20419703423976898,
-0.4228217303752899,
-0.3706808090209961,
0.2007020115852356,
0.018442098051309586,
0.1345246434211731,
0.17327328026294708,
0.08764595538377762,
-0.3190516531467438,
0.37852591276168823,
0.35527557134628296,
-0.42138874530792236,
-0.39286333322525024,
0.40892744064331055,
0.3158467710018158,
-0.4819362461566925,
0.7812545299530029,
0.1331143081188202,
0.3161262273788452,
0.4773007333278656,
0.7240232825279236,
1.110419511795044,
0.07401995360851288,
-0.014600022695958614,
0.4069644510746002,
0.2865482568740845,
-0.0810946375131607,
0.509520411491394,
-0.26255372166633606,
-0.6280825734138489,
-0.33772990107536316,
-0.4721779525279999,
-0.24313870072364807,
0.32535091042518616,
-0.6391449570655823,
0.13395272195339203,
-0.7990241646766663,
-0.02633524499833584,
-0.21157555282115936,
-0.43138280510902405,
-0.3160618543624878,
0.24341484904289246,
0.29685819149017334,
0.6959792971611023,
-0.27621081471443176,
1.1341334581375122,
0.11768756806850433,
-0.29346829652786255,
-0.44842955470085144,
0.1159282699227333,
-0.2889935076236725,
-0.472220778465271,
0.03635319694876671,
0.15381890535354614,
-0.3841220736503601,
0.11668042838573456,
-0.2763904631137848,
-0.5852586030960083,
0.8518211245536804,
0.537566602230072,
-0.6318908929824829,
-0.1489185392856598,
0.30937460064888,
0.5564892888069153,
-0.28771913051605225,
0.483645498752594,
0.5083275437355042,
0.31221410632133484,
0.026769835501909256,
-0.7128405570983887,
0.20970991253852844,
-0.4554477632045746,
0.22766785323619843,
0.2971404790878296,
-0.4082159698009491,
0.4867837131023407,
0.314828097820282,
-0.7738124132156372,
0.20240077376365662,
0.853794276714325,
0.18312042951583862,
0.21411770582199097,
0.27452364563941956,
0.12092720717191696,
0.6903162002563477,
-0.009048563428223133,
0.920289933681488,
-0.40075501799583435,
0.18196089565753937,
0.9339393973350525,
0.04698040336370468,
0.8230046033859253,
0.7085422873497009,
0.18537691235542297,
0.608321487903595,
0.3089173436164856,
0.33633899688720703,
0.7622838616371155,
0.21761873364448547,
-0.8250342011451721,
-0.12369351089000702,
-0.0151571249589324,
-0.05779331922531128,
0.2543724775314331,
0.6153525114059448,
-0.11522100120782852,
-0.36943790316581726,
0.2534978687763214,
0.06424760073423386,
0.1833580881357193,
0.04489455372095108,
0.6273401379585266,
0.2039497345685959,
-0.7502233386039734,
0.9503546357154846,
0.13043756783008575,
0.74275141954422,
-1.046718955039978,
-0.14610958099365234,
-0.27322354912757874,
0.019512221217155457,
0.026320185512304306,
-0.4607779383659363,
0.6471174955368042,
-0.13302497565746307,
-0.008002099581062794,
-0.32589027285575867,
0.260650098323822,
-0.6576371192932129,
-0.3297414779663086,
0.10956363379955292,
-0.05118386074900627,
0.3133417069911957,
-0.0688084214925766,
-0.259822279214859,
0.2797744870185852,
-0.19888009130954742,
0.08186613023281097,
0.12020052224397659,
0.3220233917236328,
-0.06722670793533325,
0.2717054784297943,
0.5024279952049255,
-0.23511527478694916,
-0.08892194926738739,
-0.1251712143421173,
0.6435907483100891,
-0.6697673201560974,
-0.4982180595397949,
-0.6934748888015747,
0.6408768892288208,
0.0024517972487956285,
-0.2572658061981201,
0.3490627706050873,
0.4578563868999481,
0.6379535794258118,
-0.10506758838891983,
0.8011589646339417,
-0.18628165125846863,
0.18927283585071564,
-0.5631272792816162,
1.0465054512023926,
-0.3600267469882965,
-0.12563839554786682,
0.09548760950565338,
-0.013361163437366486,
-0.3572812080383301,
0.5670682787895203,
0.03824414685368538,
-0.29667019844055176,
1.2510219812393188,
0.8455016613006592,
0.022509876638650894,
0.28546765446662903,
0.6277163624763489,
0.06779459118843079,
0.15281863510608673,
0.8126630783081055,
0.27388474345207214,
-0.2593802809715271,
0.7586384415626526,
0.15710881352424622,
-0.4853234887123108,
0.13068139553070068,
-0.6005645990371704,
-0.8893500566482544,
-0.5051972270011902,
-0.2626740634441376,
-0.29934364557266235,
-0.0017863769317045808,
0.517838716506958,
0.33620351552963257,
-0.7797554731369019,
-0.5252441763877869,
-0.4363481104373932,
-0.039983298629522324,
-0.5071815848350525,
-0.1526314914226532,
0.330839067697525,
-0.2975022494792938,
-0.8424520492553711,
0.9354583024978638,
0.4376855790615082,
-0.19908355176448822,
-0.16448429226875305,
0.008539125323295593,
-0.24007776379585266,
0.24624989926815033,
0.605462908744812,
0.7262730002403259,
-0.4605874717235565,
-0.25461384654045105,
0.2144675850868225,
-0.30502375960350037,
0.2742278277873993,
0.888641893863678,
-0.6453115940093994,
0.7071053981781006,
0.6377151608467102,
0.7640507817268372,
0.7882695198059082,
-0.4367924630641937,
0.7230485677719116,
-0.748025119304657,
0.0778970867395401,
0.28907671570777893,
0.1767307072877884,
0.4051263630390167,
-0.5844897627830505,
-0.04408373683691025,
0.2002156376838684,
-0.11310239881277084,
-0.4227137565612793,
0.4566897451877594,
-1.0857222080230713,
-0.36849501729011536,
0.8746776580810547,
-0.3242641091346741,
-0.6342725157737732,
-0.5276662111282349,
-0.1638808697462082,
0.2875294089317322,
-0.23778903484344482,
0.5995654463768005,
0.7783194184303284,
-0.38647690415382385,
-0.47083500027656555,
-0.2616174519062042,
0.2909541428089142,
0.28340569138526917,
-0.641973078250885,
0.009039764292538166,
0.619270384311676,
0.36761727929115295,
0.21334412693977356,
0.9398202300071716,
-0.4798482060432434,
0.12728917598724365,
0.31242093443870544,
0.2626802623271942,
-0.11176709830760956,
-0.128309428691864,
-0.531489372253418,
0.5427296757698059,
-0.29224464297294617,
-0.545390248298645
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11176v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11176v1
|
Quality-Aware Image-Text Alignment for Real-World Image Quality Assessment
| 2024-03-17T11:32:18 | 2024-03-17T11:32:18 |
Lorenzo Agnolucci, Leonardo Galteri, Marco Bertini
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
No-Reference Image Quality Assessment (NR-IQA) focuses on designing methods
to measure image quality in alignment with human perception when a high-quality
reference image is unavailable. The reliance on annotated Mean Opinion Scores
(MOS) in the majority of state-of-the-art NR-IQA approaches limits their
scalability and broader applicability to real-world scenarios. To overcome this
limitation, we propose QualiCLIP (Quality-aware CLIP), a CLIP-based
self-supervised opinion-unaware method that does not require labeled MOS. In
particular, we introduce a quality-aware image-text alignment strategy to make
CLIP generate representations that correlate with the inherent quality of the
images. Starting from pristine images, we synthetically degrade them with
increasing levels of intensity. Then, we train CLIP to rank these degraded
images based on their similarity to quality-related antonym text prompts, while
guaranteeing consistent representations for images with comparable quality. Our
method achieves state-of-the-art performance on several datasets with authentic
distortions. Moreover, despite not requiring MOS, QualiCLIP outperforms
supervised methods when their training dataset differs from the testing one,
thus proving to be more suitable for real-world scenarios. Furthermore, our
approach demonstrates greater robustness and improved explainability than
competing methods. The code and the model are publicly available at
https://github.com/miccunifi/QualiCLIP.
|
[
-0.4401252865791321,
-0.2504040598869324,
0.3539992868900299,
0.2624824047088623,
-0.6597405672073364,
0.24173057079315186,
0.2644053101539612,
-0.7626472115516663,
0.5006502866744995,
0.18376506865024567,
-0.3382696211338043,
-0.5557294487953186,
-0.37265491485595703,
0.1892137974500656,
-0.5008588433265686,
0.899933934211731,
-0.1412348449230194,
0.22026567161083221,
-0.5108125805854797,
-0.5467828512191772,
-0.5011178851127625,
-0.2764071524143219,
-0.15952637791633606,
0.42175745964050293,
0.1676553636789322,
0.4002784788608551,
1.2837908267974854,
0.651313304901123,
0.7442009449005127,
0.15215544402599335,
0.0413888618350029,
0.3286586403846741,
-0.41755881905555725,
-0.026582885533571243,
-0.4227157235145569,
-0.18479971587657928,
-0.4623546004295349,
0.17912325263023376,
0.4114754796028137,
-0.21720516681671143,
0.11691798269748688,
0.2197016179561615,
0.16882750391960144,
0.6813680529594421,
-0.8359505534172058,
-0.19147667288780212,
-0.5797470808029175,
0.11185045540332794,
0.03979041427373886,
-0.148058220744133,
0.04027001932263374,
-0.7305744886398315,
0.14590603113174438,
-1.067547082901001,
0.10493505001068115,
0.23971204459667206,
1.3563528060913086,
0.32300621271133423,
-0.13845674693584442,
-0.2868388593196869,
-0.35019078850746155,
0.7537180185317993,
-0.6108508110046387,
0.2362600862979889,
0.34501317143440247,
0.40892142057418823,
0.039818815886974335,
-0.19792568683624268,
-0.8060968518257141,
0.41098523139953613,
0.1114700585603714,
0.6111985445022583,
-0.01510995626449585,
-0.055215317755937576,
-0.32636675238609314,
0.45433586835861206,
-0.4947471618652344,
0.02376866340637207,
-0.23995375633239746,
-0.46213826537132263,
0.31580716371536255,
-0.02034641243517399,
0.46405020356178284,
-0.36958152055740356,
-0.7446824312210083,
-0.13242532312870026,
-0.5740717053413391,
0.2106609344482422,
0.22364476323127747,
-0.2200092375278473,
0.15282605588436127,
0.4502381384372711,
0.021980170160531998,
0.3084975481033325,
0.21178340911865234,
-0.36595144867897034,
0.16072078049182892,
-0.45880061388015747,
0.008883151225745678,
-0.06535211950540543,
1.0850164890289307,
0.9899870157241821,
0.01281468290835619,
0.04938233271241188,
-0.22273516654968262,
0.20415706932544708,
0.16590973734855652,
-0.9244573712348938,
-0.22659392654895782,
0.32484593987464905,
-0.26352912187576294,
-0.40164151787757874,
0.11023485660552979,
-0.9563263654708862,
-0.1750164031982422,
-0.15624122321605682,
0.7530896067619324,
-0.7093250155448914,
-0.006998212542384863,
-0.2057601511478424,
-0.07884138822555542,
-0.003233388066291809,
0.48118776082992554,
-0.6978386640548706,
-0.06250588595867157,
0.5957719087600708,
0.9527872800827026,
-0.19016218185424805,
-0.1557653397321701,
-0.3662137985229492,
0.04408147186040878,
-0.6725744009017944,
1.1574256420135498,
-0.32638201117515564,
-0.2647853493690491,
0.09694907069206238,
-0.2842758297920227,
0.412445068359375,
-0.728542685508728,
0.8360136151313782,
-0.43098682165145874,
0.40052375197410583,
-0.1228829175233841,
-0.507239043712616,
-0.16856324672698975,
0.481556236743927,
-0.5089448690414429,
1.2612659931182861,
0.1797265112400055,
-0.7872053384780884,
0.5667136907577515,
-0.2115166187286377,
-0.00895623117685318,
-0.08698146790266037,
-0.2874857485294342,
-0.811793327331543,
-0.09685706347227097,
0.8863608241081238,
0.2069748342037201,
-0.18583592772483826,
0.1776418387889862,
-0.47813883423805237,
-0.44780248403549194,
0.5319461822509766,
-0.1886313408613205,
0.506697952747345,
-0.11232829093933105,
-0.080217145383358,
0.21782800555229187,
-0.45755863189697266,
0.34379976987838745,
-0.09886385500431061,
0.25159746408462524,
-0.4142220914363861,
-0.16570419073104858,
-0.02920040488243103,
0.44180750846862793,
0.3176092505455017,
-0.6998069286346436,
0.06457827240228653,
-0.2772672176361084,
0.4110676646232605,
0.6261924505233765,
0.2593953013420105,
0.4863232970237732,
-0.4422111511230469,
0.5948504209518433,
0.017494559288024902,
0.7780358195304871,
-0.03832279518246651,
-0.2628949284553528,
-0.479219526052475,
-0.7053138017654419,
0.6749680638313293,
0.5577535629272461,
-0.7639066576957703,
0.27707013487815857,
-0.38794997334480286,
-0.5455219745635986,
-0.8344993591308594,
0.034337885677814484,
0.45695656538009644,
0.5919876098632812,
0.5358249545097351,
-0.4765144884586334,
-0.12330017238855362,
-1.064592719078064,
0.047081202268600464,
-0.13843309879302979,
-0.024580489844083786,
0.09680020809173584,
0.2167683094739914,
0.1307688057422638,
1.1806669235229492,
-0.4059669077396393,
-0.8632817268371582,
0.2720835208892822,
0.11896239221096039,
-0.018673142418265343,
0.5632051229476929,
0.8311738967895508,
-0.7679702043533325,
-0.36642441153526306,
-0.3356083035469055,
-0.7562493085861206,
-0.06430032104253769,
-0.23547768592834473,
-0.6373931169509888,
-0.051057249307632446,
0.2416747510433197,
-0.307320773601532,
0.4856220781803131,
0.8242959976196289,
-0.00418530497699976,
0.9173365831375122,
-0.03354603424668312,
0.5569456219673157,
-0.9361311197280884,
-0.2484070360660553,
0.17848455905914307,
-0.365438848733902,
-0.05874224752187729,
-0.13640710711479187,
0.34890231490135193,
-0.18870560824871063,
-0.5647285580635071,
0.389657586812973,
-0.46896371245384216,
-0.20848755538463593,
-0.300306111574173,
0.35367196798324585,
0.7690526247024536,
0.3787307143211365,
0.0268210768699646,
1.284169316291809,
0.4479804039001465,
-0.3195731043815613,
-0.22515694797039032,
0.6083178520202637,
-0.5562574863433838,
1.1057401895523071,
-0.592191219329834,
0.01170363463461399,
0.009166215546429157,
0.022949418053030968,
-0.917839527130127,
-0.04001076892018318,
0.3334442973136902,
-0.6563558578491211,
0.09753988683223724,
-0.1409282684326172,
-0.34864354133605957,
0.018245879560709,
-0.5721312761306763,
0.6053292155265808,
0.28235751390457153,
-0.677935779094696,
0.3822959363460541,
0.5011458396911621,
-0.11256726086139679,
-0.8024889230728149,
-0.3722033202648163,
0.13707754015922546,
-0.1929827332496643,
-0.4496411681175232,
0.7070147395133972,
0.08908373862504959,
0.314399778842926,
0.15861675143241882,
-0.21980583667755127,
-0.5570296049118042,
-0.03623630478978157,
0.332764208316803,
0.4648720622062683,
0.03393823653459549,
0.14912185072898865,
0.29475411772727966,
0.07869391143321991,
-0.04797099903225899,
-0.13779008388519287,
-0.19891580939292908,
-0.017061155289411545,
-0.1519293487071991,
-0.8845518231391907,
0.30461883544921875,
0.7344215512275696,
-0.4413021206855774,
0.2649138569831848,
0.5251527428627014,
-0.30789923667907715,
0.041114531457424164,
-0.285918653011322,
-0.026464596390724182,
-0.43354886770248413,
0.16425323486328125,
-0.0905475839972496,
-0.6796690225601196,
0.4932591915130615,
-0.032575756311416626,
0.15492068231105804,
0.20334096252918243,
-0.07668352872133255,
-0.772426962852478,
0.9098336100578308,
0.3857628405094147,
0.15150122344493866,
0.6841397881507874,
-0.34462276101112366,
0.25280681252479553,
-1.1292814016342163,
0.08235978335142136,
-0.22235175967216492,
-0.1668178290128708,
-0.18184968829154968,
-0.5859878659248352,
0.5631791353225708,
0.4272758364677429,
-0.0008645728230476379,
0.21812359988689423,
-0.7799213528633118,
0.6032885909080505,
0.4357483983039856,
0.3482765853404999,
0.3125165104866028,
-0.1001993864774704,
-0.018544841557741165,
-0.42338594794273376,
-0.6320483684539795,
-0.7448757886886597,
0.7466555833816528,
0.18323776125907898,
0.5360640287399292,
0.026928234845399857,
0.5090974569320679,
0.4607931077480316,
0.5007993578910828,
-0.9248586893081665,
0.39614441990852356,
-0.06279362738132477,
-0.5580950379371643,
-0.2219555824995041,
-0.1778411865234375,
-0.6155200600624084,
0.20295575261116028,
-0.7753031849861145,
-0.28453558683395386,
0.390944242477417,
0.4313453733921051,
-0.45230475068092346,
0.14081403613090515,
-0.42277488112449646,
0.813847541809082,
-0.33031144738197327,
-0.5072939991950989,
-0.04293424263596535,
-0.3944462835788727,
0.36709681153297424,
0.0009382247808389366,
0.22587530314922333,
-0.5714215040206909,
-0.1967715322971344,
0.6162616014480591,
-0.5995786786079407,
0.5811516642570496,
-0.09656640142202377,
0.1365644633769989,
0.6158161759376526,
0.29590606689453125,
0.2523893713951111,
0.22081398963928223,
0.14106032252311707,
0.4340333044528961,
0.47560349106788635,
-0.411205530166626,
-1.020812749862671,
0.4762108325958252,
-0.7665274143218994,
-0.31089067459106445,
-0.4633651673793793,
-0.1667027473449707,
-0.2743222117424011,
0.22746451199054718,
0.35060960054397583,
0.7033912539482117,
-0.2018231451511383,
-0.1473322957754135,
0.302265465259552,
-0.044003844261169434,
0.13035602867603302,
0.1927126795053482,
-0.4348159730434418,
-1.1223515272140503,
1.1666141748428345,
0.19793862104415894,
0.17200544476509094,
0.28744184970855713,
0.18020804226398468,
-0.5026425719261169,
-0.8432884216308594,
-0.6311227083206177,
0.0580315962433815,
-0.6433535814285278,
-0.8041286468505859,
-0.18266983330249786,
0.17832274734973907,
-0.28095874190330505,
-0.2386014759540558,
-0.5156514048576355,
-0.5512756109237671,
-0.4500562250614166,
0.05670260265469551,
0.2866554260253906,
0.2496042549610138,
0.18563786149024963,
0.3052932620048523,
-0.958588719367981,
0.30327531695365906,
0.31044378876686096,
0.4612502157688141,
-0.2765423655509949,
-0.5745072960853577,
-0.23203082382678986,
-0.0500514879822731,
-0.514204740524292,
-0.837673008441925,
0.5436099171638489,
0.4539738595485687,
0.29062286019325256,
0.5563428401947021,
0.4235159754753113,
0.7908966541290283,
-0.16462203860282898,
0.7987430691719055,
0.29389286041259766,
-1.1254888772964478,
0.3955000936985016,
-0.16010530292987823,
0.12680591642856598,
0.9071248769760132,
0.46657419204711914,
-0.26666387915611267,
-0.5529595613479614,
-0.3494156002998352,
-0.727753758430481,
-0.12951965630054474,
0.16341981291770935,
-0.08227089047431946,
-0.1373768150806427,
0.37667372822761536,
0.17580430209636688,
-0.03332967683672905,
-0.4770227074623108,
0.29685044288635254,
-0.8643999099731445,
-0.5384278893470764,
0.43527811765670776,
-0.33004727959632874,
-0.03534636273980141,
-0.060544341802597046,
0.7205835580825806,
-0.4857143461704254,
0.2683297395706177,
0.7521513104438782,
-0.31704774498939514,
0.17960727214813232,
0.171962708234787,
0.42949801683425903,
0.7375175356864929,
-0.278117835521698,
-0.06798806041479111,
-0.2654387354850769,
-0.5297635793685913,
0.3225322663784027,
-0.5244995951652527,
-0.4474570155143738,
-0.018304839730262756,
0.04069850593805313,
0.35909920930862427,
0.29484641551971436,
-0.6884548664093018,
0.97233647108078,
-0.2511484622955322,
-0.24612924456596375,
-0.27379733324050903,
-0.10387010872364044,
-0.3539898991584778,
-0.07945724576711655,
0.4488045573234558,
0.1800529658794403,
0.29287591576576233,
-0.2458678036928177,
0.2549254298210144,
0.4258752465248108,
-0.852343738079071,
-0.28828510642051697,
0.5096315741539001,
0.4385317862033844,
0.052424006164073944,
0.47828999161720276,
-0.37959522008895874,
-0.6635815501213074,
0.48973149061203003,
0.3540080487728119,
0.5975461006164551,
0.1957906037569046,
0.41766637563705444,
0.6328686475753784,
0.22848686575889587,
-0.012789174914360046,
0.2438419759273529,
0.26030343770980835,
-0.8829022645950317,
-0.4643213152885437,
-0.26298588514328003,
-0.9010071754455566,
-0.32280951738357544,
-0.8422865867614746,
0.10290572792291641,
-0.8475764393806458,
-0.49006858468055725,
-0.1031000018119812,
-0.3766089975833893,
-0.19964680075645447,
0.387362539768219,
-0.19325566291809082,
0.8281299471855164,
-0.6928528547286987,
0.6093243956565857,
0.527496874332428,
-0.4257359504699707,
-0.6611586213111877,
0.06856188178062439,
-0.13211321830749512,
-0.6138181090354919,
0.2680661976337433,
0.3863905370235443,
-0.2664487659931183,
-0.29774194955825806,
-0.5509992241859436,
-0.9492870569229126,
1.0637415647506714,
0.3379219174385071,
-0.25205349922180176,
0.41858309507369995,
-0.23262429237365723,
0.5547340512275696,
-0.2439536154270172,
0.28333228826522827,
0.10066743940114975,
0.02900521084666252,
-0.028108680620789528,
-0.6066610217094421,
-0.051409341394901276,
-0.1309075951576233,
-0.028419306501746178,
0.3886236548423767,
-0.8627423048019409,
0.20368023216724396,
-0.21729755401611328,
-0.6188231706619263,
0.2190859317779541,
1.189784049987793,
0.01183289848268032,
0.26530659198760986,
0.4530383050441742,
0.4168011546134949,
0.7158716917037964,
-0.00809469260275364,
0.6450441479682922,
-0.4221414625644684,
0.24554812908172607,
1.2344388961791992,
-0.09275560826063156,
1.1091610193252563,
0.5256122350692749,
-0.03572267293930054,
0.49462786316871643,
0.6155542135238647,
-0.03435354307293892,
0.5972669720649719,
-0.2564661502838135,
-0.0388745442032814,
-0.26620355248451233,
-0.4323751926422119,
-0.01563161052763462,
0.6171376705169678,
0.23773828148841858,
-0.12106126546859741,
0.057242877781391144,
0.04136132076382637,
-0.2525728642940521,
0.48461905121803284,
-0.3110809922218323,
0.6110957860946655,
-0.2624607980251312,
-0.5043999552726746,
0.6255728006362915,
-0.486492782831192,
0.9453376531600952,
-0.04745158180594444,
-0.20274806022644043,
-0.16689829528331757,
-0.2711727023124695,
-0.33643049001693726,
-1.171552062034607,
0.5013920664787292,
-0.08457309007644653,
-0.33077272772789,
0.09414053708314896,
0.3905913531780243,
-0.26477083563804626,
-0.45652955770492554,
-0.15254029631614685,
0.030974533408880234,
0.1731284260749817,
-0.09421011060476303,
-0.8827252388000488,
-0.11556247621774673,
-0.1613280028104782,
0.36182719469070435,
0.3980849087238312,
0.31901514530181885,
-0.3210386633872986,
0.5961974263191223,
0.4950532913208008,
-0.1276913434267044,
-0.15091422200202942,
-0.22764691710472107,
0.5348355174064636,
-0.4708422124385834,
-0.5241740345954895,
-0.27477946877479553,
0.12151165306568146,
-0.2486790120601654,
-0.6088035702705383,
0.4948362708091736,
0.6494273543357849,
0.6583462953567505,
0.10000443458557129,
0.5006850957870483,
0.4179624021053314,
0.6173846125602722,
-0.5962753295898438,
0.6049728393554688,
-0.4352218508720398,
-0.18463480472564697,
-0.39010900259017944,
-0.7316508889198303,
-0.3692299723625183,
0.651882529258728,
-0.24914629757404327,
-0.5839132070541382,
0.6685598492622375,
0.9415715336799622,
0.07995517551898956,
-0.08355230838060379,
0.24413959681987762,
-0.13365137577056885,
0.4188329577445984,
0.21828551590442657,
0.7928511500358582,
-0.7365636229515076,
0.9132647514343262,
-0.43415409326553345,
-0.2866228520870209,
-0.08800004422664642,
-1.2045701742172241,
-0.5175502300262451,
-0.44568395614624023,
-0.7330437898635864,
-0.3118766248226166,
-0.14160498976707458,
0.7457167506217957,
0.6975070834159851,
-0.643325924873352,
0.36662453413009644,
0.2663910984992981,
0.1328277438879013,
-0.5182990431785583,
-0.25435036420822144,
0.6054715514183044,
0.061450280249118805,
-0.6178868412971497,
0.030792057514190674,
0.6177765130996704,
0.4009231626987457,
-0.22124135494232178,
0.3161909878253937,
0.1487613469362259,
0.18955716490745544,
0.31415417790412903,
0.5066231489181519,
-0.5326247215270996,
-0.4358282685279846,
-0.01573827490210533,
-0.31630033254623413,
0.7156007885932922,
0.4147207736968994,
-0.5587731599807739,
0.5960925221443176,
0.5170639157295227,
0.49398642778396606,
0.027557868510484695,
0.5289651155471802,
0.35644036531448364,
-0.44157156348228455,
0.054376304149627686,
0.4777686595916748,
0.32467782497406006,
0.713965117931366,
-0.4702123999595642,
0.21800585091114044,
-0.049499183893203735,
-0.6936241388320923,
-0.521075427532196,
-0.07658996433019638,
-1.319941759109497,
-0.07501746714115143,
0.6412380933761597,
-0.45142310857772827,
-0.6011086702346802,
0.056592803448438644,
-0.6091831922531128,
-0.02249140664935112,
-0.5850406885147095,
1.1578644514083862,
0.42172813415527344,
-0.0827709287405014,
-0.28313446044921875,
-0.16561710834503174,
0.4215565323829651,
0.5324085354804993,
-0.8238889575004578,
-0.21350343525409698,
0.6096922159194946,
0.3410356044769287,
0.2155340164899826,
0.4288000464439392,
-0.4686928391456604,
0.48499900102615356,
-0.3231044113636017,
0.3682979345321655,
-0.19849346578121185,
-0.2860181927680969,
-0.13299314677715302,
0.14460235834121704,
0.1687566041946411,
-0.610872745513916
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11169v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11169v3
|
Correcting misinformation on social media with a large language model
| 2024-03-17T10:59:09 | 2024-04-30T20:03:13 |
Xinyi Zhou, Ashish Sharma, Amy X. Zhang, Tim Althoff
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Real-world misinformation can be partially correct and even factual but
misleading. It undermines public trust in science and democracy, particularly
on social media, where it can spread rapidly. High-quality and timely
correction of misinformation that identifies and explains its (in)accuracies
has been shown to effectively reduce false beliefs. Despite the wide acceptance
of manual correction, it is difficult to be timely and scalable, a concern as
technologies like large language models (LLMs) make misinformation easier to
produce. LLMs also have versatile capabilities that could accelerate
misinformation correction-however, they struggle due to a lack of recent
information, a tendency to produce false content, and limitations in addressing
multimodal information. We propose MUSE, an LLM augmented with access to and
credibility evaluation of up-to-date information. By retrieving evidence as
refutations or contexts, MUSE identifies and explains (in)accuracies in a piece
of content-not presupposed to be misinformation-with references. It also
describes images and conducts multimodal searches to verify and correct
multimodal content. Fact-checking experts evaluate responses to social media
content that are not presupposed to be (non-)misinformation but broadly include
incorrect, partially correct, and correct posts, that may or may not be
misleading. We propose and evaluate 13 dimensions of misinformation correction
quality, ranging from the accuracy of identifications and factuality of
explanations to the relevance and credibility of references. The results
demonstrate MUSE's ability to promptly write high-quality responses to
potential misinformation on social media-overall, MUSE outperforms GPT-4 by 37%
and even high-quality responses from laypeople by 29%. This work reveals LLMs'
potential to help combat real-world misinformation effectively and efficiently.
|
[
-0.1316499561071396,
-0.9497293829917908,
0.6562359929084778,
0.6099944710731506,
-0.08482449501752853,
0.3549206256866455,
-0.42049333453178406,
-0.6596914529800415,
0.3067055344581604,
0.1089383140206337,
-0.7315096855163574,
-0.44656604528427124,
-0.8157268762588501,
0.04950741305947304,
-0.436323881149292,
0.5875903964042664,
-0.07915940135717392,
0.2528676986694336,
-0.3046838343143463,
-0.11212683469057083,
-0.4217921793460846,
-0.20388837158679962,
-0.5850507020950317,
-0.19973669946193695,
0.9002260565757751,
0.5794736742973328,
0.6579406261444092,
0.49132126569747925,
0.5495319366455078,
0.2839096188545227,
-0.1856965869665146,
0.5851494669914246,
-0.8521049618721008,
-0.14781944453716278,
-0.4010516405105591,
-0.5583650469779968,
-0.3062235116958618,
0.403289794921875,
0.6490717530250549,
0.3584854006767273,
0.00046151949209161103,
0.3923022150993347,
0.0059159910306334496,
0.3091714084148407,
-0.45747604966163635,
0.10548098385334015,
-0.710801362991333,
-0.05776812881231308,
-0.23503346741199493,
-0.29971805214881897,
-0.4045121669769287,
-0.4035468101501465,
-0.06144149973988533,
-0.7198605537414551,
0.2956834137439728,
0.11390795558691025,
0.9996116161346436,
0.29775920510292053,
-0.2368355095386505,
-0.2514529824256897,
-1.0495564937591553,
0.6243573427200317,
-0.5542150139808655,
0.44242048263549805,
0.4820976257324219,
0.40564247965812683,
-0.22907893359661102,
-0.7008194327354431,
-0.9021627306938171,
0.20578789710998535,
0.0926431342959404,
0.18667371571063995,
-0.19853681325912476,
-0.37993359565734863,
0.3815650939941406,
0.2537049949169159,
-0.3619772493839264,
0.13030782341957092,
-0.36237144470214844,
-0.5969843864440918,
0.5678492188453674,
-0.1208343505859375,
0.2408178299665451,
-0.28214263916015625,
-0.10235855728387833,
-0.14327087998390198,
-0.9873797297477722,
-0.26973211765289307,
0.3597213625907898,
0.16668441891670227,
-0.0029487116262316704,
0.7967983484268188,
-0.03945518657565117,
0.3598890006542206,
0.2837676703929901,
-0.6451118588447571,
0.06355643272399902,
-0.22005847096443176,
-0.2069733738899231,
0.05228789523243904,
0.5230475068092346,
0.6935158967971802,
-0.115167997777462,
-0.18991047143936157,
-0.13627125322818756,
0.36977219581604004,
0.3230184018611908,
-0.5324490070343018,
0.15628157556056976,
0.1254495531320572,
-0.3537185490131378,
-0.055393803864717484,
-0.12436030805110931,
-0.6079577207565308,
-0.8575752377510071,
-0.5311461687088013,
0.7733314037322998,
-0.414585679769516,
0.004042519256472588,
0.0744585320353508,
0.03084113821387291,
-0.36295899748802185,
0.8577800989151001,
-0.11729353666305542,
-0.25435274839401245,
0.49823611974716187,
0.9671418070793152,
0.12510009109973907,
-0.2910540997982025,
-0.4109008014202118,
0.2736993432044983,
-0.3042434751987457,
0.9474456310272217,
-0.3524509072303772,
-0.014519988559186459,
0.13855434954166412,
0.26113200187683105,
-0.017666297033429146,
-0.3493103086948395,
0.8809200525283813,
-0.593672513961792,
0.19694997370243073,
-0.6540545225143433,
-0.4453273117542267,
-0.20914563536643982,
0.2625059485435486,
-0.7995803356170654,
0.8020674586296082,
-0.1345604956150055,
-0.7100812196731567,
0.4195585250854492,
-0.4860684871673584,
-0.4233628213405609,
-0.25186866521835327,
0.19763138890266418,
-0.30178210139274597,
-0.0911460667848587,
0.364654004573822,
0.47314512729644775,
-0.17485561966896057,
0.4120573401451111,
-0.3514435887336731,
-0.2741628885269165,
0.3200196921825409,
-0.6314278244972229,
0.474313348531723,
0.1496124118566513,
-0.40179020166397095,
0.21037840843200684,
-0.9190280437469482,
-0.4984385669231415,
0.08394867926836014,
-0.5564862489700317,
-0.10097309947013855,
-0.011929604224860668,
-0.008355340920388699,
0.4325094223022461,
0.1207018792629242,
-0.7724164724349976,
0.09786271303892136,
0.11592935025691986,
0.650614857673645,
0.7982744574546814,
-0.15328547358512878,
0.3305422067642212,
-0.6484024524688721,
0.07798969000577927,
0.18089477717876434,
0.2247496396303177,
-0.2000403106212616,
-0.5837106704711914,
-0.7202516198158264,
-0.15359269082546234,
0.3671693503856659,
0.5092402696609497,
-0.7881951332092285,
0.09720487147569656,
-0.5672909617424011,
-0.746090829372406,
-0.8192474842071533,
0.20756907761096954,
0.04916057735681534,
0.6766351461410522,
0.3972932696342468,
0.0751822292804718,
-0.5957459807395935,
-0.7961300015449524,
-0.4783364236354828,
-0.1772443950176239,
0.037740614265203476,
0.1956084668636322,
0.2718718349933624,
-0.31467363238334656,
0.8578041195869446,
-0.21814224123954773,
-0.3502286672592163,
0.1288808137178421,
0.493114173412323,
-0.003120540175586939,
0.12599830329418182,
0.35344815254211426,
-0.8501909375190735,
-0.19197268784046173,
-0.3107641935348511,
-0.5097941160202026,
-0.10195112228393555,
-0.29642367362976074,
-0.06584528833627701,
0.1275123655796051,
0.18659193813800812,
-1.075162649154663,
0.35370296239852905,
0.5532936453819275,
-0.09099508076906204,
0.5229176878929138,
-0.07019634544849396,
0.5781494975090027,
-0.9740279316902161,
-0.05780210718512535,
0.27397340536117554,
-0.381189227104187,
-0.3994438648223877,
-0.18401296436786652,
0.2643963098526001,
0.0337798073887825,
-0.3183010518550873,
0.3494219481945038,
-0.472416490316391,
0.04354790598154068,
-0.18357154726982117,
0.41373783349990845,
-0.006101344712078571,
0.05314496532082558,
-0.25486403703689575,
0.7398747205734253,
0.28387945890426636,
-0.5145573019981384,
0.5176215767860413,
0.20528626441955566,
-0.5689433813095093,
0.7592280507087708,
-0.36365944147109985,
0.040705300867557526,
-0.36365529894828796,
0.469708114862442,
-1.1349332332611084,
-0.62706458568573,
0.19262652099132538,
-0.6562640070915222,
0.26180627942085266,
-0.07525016367435455,
-0.9834808707237244,
-0.6039546728134155,
-0.058950211852788925,
-0.134279265999794,
-0.02076740562915802,
-0.6217572093009949,
0.6127598285675049,
0.3834749162197113,
-0.14225532114505768,
-0.6483872532844543,
-0.7531672716140747,
0.400111585855484,
0.06217285990715027,
-1.0117112398147583,
0.30155837535858154,
-0.18176589906215668,
-0.2509801983833313,
0.16296228766441345,
-0.2524629831314087,
0.14436569809913635,
-0.19172048568725586,
0.2168349325656891,
0.06529546529054642,
-0.10052237659692764,
0.47113850712776184,
-0.24729324877262115,
0.26086437702178955,
-0.2056574523448944,
-0.05831892788410187,
0.5401825904846191,
0.14374974370002747,
-0.5178735256195068,
-0.4840719401836395,
0.05014762282371521,
0.8561558127403259,
-0.04629119485616684,
0.803234338760376,
0.8476629853248596,
-0.749305248260498,
0.03545250743627548,
-1.1236259937286377,
-0.22514072060585022,
-0.38873186707496643,
0.189379021525383,
0.05695050582289696,
-0.9225460886955261,
0.5807718634605408,
-0.14116032421588898,
0.11453621834516525,
0.5155587196350098,
0.4367983341217041,
-0.16616109013557434,
0.8910827040672302,
0.6102092862129211,
-0.21279308199882507,
0.3134937882423401,
-0.1398342102766037,
0.440925270318985,
-0.42284414172172546,
-0.3790189027786255,
-0.5391735434532166,
-0.49644312262535095,
-0.1454305648803711,
-0.7717176675796509,
0.18866652250289917,
-0.0027029390912503004,
0.008339887484908104,
0.29907283186912537,
-0.11493751406669617,
0.2437204271554947,
0.6475164890289307,
0.24732017517089844,
0.4537215530872345,
0.12668254971504211,
0.08226987719535828,
-0.2984733581542969,
-0.848418653011322,
-0.5288054347038269,
0.7633264660835266,
0.49852898716926575,
1.0526978969573975,
0.2538484036922455,
0.047243744134902954,
0.5588973760604858,
0.6349506974220276,
-0.7126458287239075,
0.3626914620399475,
0.21293124556541443,
-0.8085910081863403,
-0.16344600915908813,
-0.4324361979961395,
-0.3696046471595764,
0.01882922649383545,
-0.672783374786377,
-0.5740650296211243,
0.2666279375553131,
0.30233579874038696,
-0.3988911211490631,
0.5710890293121338,
-0.6870328783988953,
0.5391559600830078,
-0.19904133677482605,
-0.5486024618148804,
-0.47911810874938965,
-0.6454527378082275,
0.41713711619377136,
-0.3317481279373169,
0.46885037422180176,
-0.12929725646972656,
0.19569694995880127,
0.3880215883255005,
-0.07495784014463425,
1.1579796075820923,
-0.00017850899894256145,
-0.19420795142650604,
0.13407272100448608,
0.03356612101197243,
0.7494837641716003,
0.06195782497525215,
0.040845777839422226,
0.08485619723796844,
-0.3360048532485962,
-0.10139670968055725,
-0.5993800759315491,
0.9275431036949158,
-0.7847837805747986,
-0.6332614421844482,
-0.20272007584571838,
-0.5789920091629028,
-0.43523475527763367,
0.027998968958854675,
0.2951433062553406,
0.3104274272918701,
-0.2094993144273758,
0.3616773784160614,
0.8375959992408752,
-0.17357319593429565,
0.2529715597629547,
0.6305243372917175,
-0.08592615276575089,
-0.3139965236186981,
0.7024809122085571,
0.5307554006576538,
0.009850278496742249,
0.3418343961238861,
0.15110498666763306,
-0.5148845911026001,
-0.23498626053333282,
-0.5904660820960999,
0.4929226338863373,
-0.795619785785675,
-0.29327428340911865,
-0.8200476169586182,
-0.1515948325395584,
-0.5620049238204956,
0.018769025802612305,
-0.2967403531074524,
-0.5297399759292603,
-0.3827734589576721,
-0.17834638059139252,
0.29205524921417236,
0.5969421863555908,
-0.3450908064842224,
0.5834257006645203,
-0.7939366698265076,
0.3576854467391968,
0.2873762249946594,
0.3560866713523865,
-0.06446138769388199,
-0.575244128704071,
-0.23345619440078735,
0.4469892382621765,
-0.39427927136421204,
-1.0264161825180054,
0.008067887276411057,
0.08014761656522751,
0.549924373626709,
0.5775907039642334,
-0.28430643677711487,
1.0897964239120483,
-0.508224606513977,
0.770025908946991,
0.2480841875076294,
-0.833989143371582,
0.4034067392349243,
-0.4426736831665039,
0.0013894669245928526,
0.19236759841442108,
0.49261021614074707,
-1.0108412504196167,
-0.3828055262565613,
-0.6190997958183289,
-0.6609407663345337,
0.5324961543083191,
0.035540468990802765,
0.14652381837368011,
-0.003051220905035734,
0.256332665681839,
-0.11849911510944366,
0.3105771541595459,
-0.8182575106620789,
-0.09970494359731674,
-0.34272727370262146,
0.012036505155265331,
-0.15574032068252563,
-0.5679497122764587,
-0.4146519899368286,
-0.18856632709503174,
1.053727149963379,
0.018403310328722,
0.28175535798072815,
0.2997775673866272,
-0.44489797949790955,
-0.6441341638565063,
0.20417901873588562,
0.945284903049469,
1.0449745655059814,
0.015797801315784454,
0.15179701149463654,
0.008447865955531597,
-0.4021393060684204,
-0.042588550597429276,
0.0479363352060318,
-0.3073287308216095,
0.23572561144828796,
0.28343483805656433,
0.6536595225334167,
0.179497629404068,
-0.49943870306015015,
0.5552548170089722,
0.045267120003700256,
-0.08253132551908493,
-0.17551152408123016,
-0.3076546788215637,
0.5028623342514038,
0.2988266348838806,
0.524960994720459,
0.4633982479572296,
-0.21036702394485474,
-0.6614574790000916,
0.00032189450575970113,
0.19708168506622314,
-0.3084121644496918,
-0.34139731526374817,
0.7480518221855164,
0.1661052256822586,
-0.20016644895076752,
0.284421443939209,
0.06031831353902817,
-0.3612871468067169,
0.1630294770002365,
0.682624876499176,
0.4483793377876282,
-0.3449760675430298,
0.532998263835907,
0.39466625452041626,
0.7272900342941284,
-0.4954347312450409,
0.005412037950009108,
0.45779427886009216,
-0.8916952013969421,
-0.8078563809394836,
-0.5831389427185059,
-0.24499543011188507,
0.6690633893013,
-0.04029317945241928,
0.16425958275794983,
-0.5705128908157349,
-0.5244242548942566,
0.17073379456996918,
-0.1489776372909546,
-0.5579283833503723,
0.3179472088813782,
-0.019675839692354202,
1.1787978410720825,
-0.8694926500320435,
0.34787890315055847,
0.761113166809082,
-0.4464385509490967,
-0.9209486842155457,
0.13999664783477783,
0.5440200567245483,
-0.6109323501586914,
0.4312675893306732,
0.021911006420850754,
-0.310848593711853,
-0.26673775911331177,
-1.0111815929412842,
-1.006192684173584,
1.1511043310165405,
0.5739819407463074,
-0.7528741359710693,
0.21874359250068665,
0.10241877287626266,
0.5772145986557007,
-0.30238741636276245,
-0.05679077282547951,
0.05925203114748001,
0.7870503664016724,
0.32281503081321716,
-0.88946533203125,
-0.12503278255462646,
-0.06679389625787735,
-0.12337352335453033,
-0.1701241135597229,
-0.7205273509025574,
0.7761192321777344,
-0.10926677286624908,
-0.40593668818473816,
-0.010667530819773674,
0.7125962972640991,
-0.04666014760732651,
0.3260841965675354,
0.4008384943008423,
0.7424448132514954,
1.1285905838012695,
-0.3787282705307007,
0.8310849666595459,
-0.3245388865470886,
0.2793082892894745,
1.088162899017334,
-0.18132196366786957,
0.6671180129051208,
0.3836863934993744,
0.13944314420223236,
0.32685142755508423,
0.8953204154968262,
-0.022459128871560097,
0.1360008865594864,
0.008330602198839188,
-0.30467385053634644,
-0.486399382352829,
-0.1703009307384491,
-0.1567227840423584,
0.25051888823509216,
0.4565940201282501,
-0.30446359515190125,
-0.2332485318183899,
0.12133004516363144,
0.3082904517650604,
0.20238567888736725,
-0.41535231471061707,
0.3448582887649536,
-0.15307044982910156,
-0.5212228894233704,
0.2425360232591629,
0.27945476770401,
0.6525334715843201,
-0.3163186013698578,
0.017414042726159096,
-0.1414921134710312,
0.20432157814502716,
-0.31450071930885315,
-0.721213698387146,
0.2685103118419647,
0.06117250397801399,
-0.47271230816841125,
-0.12715543806552887,
1.0741755962371826,
-0.5756773948669434,
-0.5388253927230835,
0.1541524976491928,
0.49982672929763794,
-0.09810628741979599,
-0.30883416533470154,
-0.6260599493980408,
0.08841973543167114,
-0.2060607522726059,
0.10125532001256943,
-0.10400858521461487,
0.5389866828918457,
-0.09791852533817291,
1.0088248252868652,
0.8555285930633545,
0.19721315801143646,
0.08372537046670914,
0.23891094326972961,
0.772936999797821,
-0.26986590027809143,
-0.2746020257472992,
-0.5780907869338989,
0.33165937662124634,
-0.3826932907104492,
-0.12359876930713654,
0.9909322261810303,
0.5605717897415161,
0.8285536170005798,
-0.12608015537261963,
0.8536337614059448,
0.05286596715450287,
0.9447560906410217,
-0.35757288336753845,
0.829346776008606,
-0.6658525466918945,
0.19471682608127594,
-0.3664166033267975,
-1.0156439542770386,
-0.36937394738197327,
0.5608269572257996,
-0.28308767080307007,
-0.18638494610786438,
0.5593189597129822,
1.0013086795806885,
-0.252827525138855,
0.13160161674022675,
0.29039931297302246,
0.8405248522758484,
0.15868382155895233,
-0.11301517486572266,
1.0211803913116455,
-0.18436607718467712,
0.446380615234375,
-0.12134858965873718,
-0.24910210072994232,
-0.4103768765926361,
-0.8143084645271301,
-0.7283740639686584,
-0.4672849774360657,
-0.12361299246549606,
-0.7226464748382568,
0.24369995296001434,
0.9633845090866089,
0.6078302264213562,
-0.5337094664573669,
0.21479322016239166,
0.48735228180885315,
0.2733217179775238,
-0.11181143671274185,
-0.21670709550380707,
0.15636131167411804,
-0.017236489802598953,
-0.6389631628990173,
0.49104997515678406,
0.40529587864875793,
0.02259041555225849,
-0.4646003544330597,
0.07853175699710846,
-0.3750041723251343,
0.37514030933380127,
0.7782191634178162,
0.06361269950866699,
-0.8182783126831055,
-0.6728118062019348,
0.19984042644500732,
-0.22447720170021057,
0.16943193972110748,
0.7798780798912048,
-0.2835210859775543,
0.35814741253852844,
0.3568573296070099,
0.5528156757354736,
0.5192906260490417,
0.076854407787323,
0.34259623289108276,
-0.7170079946517944,
-0.20706456899642944,
0.09116175025701523,
0.5023212432861328,
0.8116948008537292,
-0.4838768541812897,
0.29218313097953796,
0.6776996850967407,
-0.5358733534812927,
-0.6152365803718567,
0.08841343969106674,
-0.9854909181594849,
-0.1352679431438446,
1.238370656967163,
-0.04658173769712448,
-0.3815222382545471,
-0.1487872451543808,
-0.38641682267189026,
0.31131207942962646,
-0.3457961976528168,
1.2141398191452026,
1.3235089778900146,
0.43385937809944153,
-0.18428073823451996,
-0.5038704872131348,
0.37688523530960083,
0.018825622275471687,
-0.6011862754821777,
-0.014948653988540173,
0.8828704953193665,
0.586319088935852,
0.5989388823509216,
0.42360368371009827,
-0.19935491681098938,
0.3563225567340851,
-0.18467320501804352,
0.002428813138976693,
-0.051717452704906464,
-0.4936533272266388,
0.021573515608906746,
-0.02739112265408039,
-0.266185998916626,
0.2098405510187149
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11152v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11152v1
|
Evaluation Ethics of LLMs in Legal Domain
| 2024-03-17T09:05:13 | 2024-03-17T09:05:13 |
Ruizhe Zhang, Haitao Li, Yueyue Wu, Qingyao Ai, Yiqun Liu, Min Zhang, Shaoping Ma
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In recent years, the utilization of large language models for natural
language dialogue has gained momentum, leading to their widespread adoption
across various domains. However, their universal competence in addressing
challenges specific to specialized fields such as law remains a subject of
scrutiny. The incorporation of legal ethics into the model has been overlooked
by researchers. We asserts that rigorous ethic evaluation is essential to
ensure the effective integration of large language models in legal domains,
emphasizing the need to assess domain-specific proficiency and domain-specific
ethic. To address this, we propose a novelty evaluation methodology, utilizing
authentic legal cases to evaluate the fundamental language abilities,
specialized legal knowledge and legal robustness of large language models
(LLMs). The findings from our comprehensive evaluation contribute significantly
to the academic discourse surrounding the suitability and performance of large
language models in legal domains.
|
[
-0.04180121049284935,
-0.8505406975746155,
1.0302720069885254,
0.05124475806951523,
-0.4232339859008789,
0.20300406217575073,
-0.3939855992794037,
-0.5436162352561951,
-0.07296723872423172,
0.6646031737327576,
-0.23821723461151123,
-0.46535974740982056,
-0.5049482583999634,
-0.03656865656375885,
-0.27866068482398987,
0.9814683198928833,
0.23356057703495026,
0.46256595849990845,
-0.2990010380744934,
-0.6181604266166687,
-0.40025725960731506,
-0.6643196940422058,
-0.5169104337692261,
-0.23857799172401428,
-0.02099357731640339,
-0.14179113507270813,
0.5773119330406189,
0.4127155542373657,
0.3953526020050049,
0.3999052345752716,
-0.36988914012908936,
-0.011271062307059765,
-0.6630816459655762,
0.0040557123720645905,
-0.546272337436676,
-0.18447250127792358,
-0.5986433625221252,
0.16284915804862976,
0.6408771872520447,
0.6476529836654663,
-0.4518006145954132,
0.23255431652069092,
-0.1770854890346527,
0.37086912989616394,
-0.500899612903595,
-0.12303077429533005,
-0.7380540370941162,
0.020635321736335754,
0.007935289293527603,
-0.43316614627838135,
-0.32901570200920105,
-0.6207781434059143,
0.3128484785556793,
-0.5227075815200806,
-0.21827110648155212,
0.043759945780038834,
0.6076897978782654,
-0.05118457227945328,
-0.45366171002388,
-0.6263877153396606,
-0.8346151113510132,
0.8343600630760193,
-0.9643446803092957,
0.27275902032852173,
-0.02492614835500717,
0.5577794313430786,
-0.0561298243701458,
-0.6923019886016846,
-0.8259766697883606,
-0.7222058176994324,
0.4074406325817108,
0.055896006524562836,
-0.21963053941726685,
0.11742199212312698,
0.13889874517917633,
0.5085621476173401,
-0.2674263119697571,
0.5985718369483948,
-0.057581547647714615,
-0.01573234237730503,
0.7805966734886169,
0.4838374853134155,
0.39921560883522034,
0.005253282375633717,
-0.13346047699451447,
0.4835573136806488,
-0.6829957365989685,
0.2644873857498169,
0.8563269972801208,
0.2102471888065338,
0.004054751247167587,
0.542451024055481,
-0.06581707298755646,
0.45429858565330505,
-0.20100875198841095,
-0.26216965913772583,
0.25968772172927856,
-0.4581989347934723,
-0.3211744725704193,
-0.07209354639053345,
0.795197069644928,
0.5853804349899292,
0.574387788772583,
-0.09299497306346893,
-0.340824693441391,
-0.2828541398048401,
0.4374513328075409,
-0.6214198470115662,
0.49668094515800476,
0.4465530514717102,
-0.7678607106208801,
-0.5359833836555481,
-0.04254961758852005,
-0.4572935998439789,
-0.4314538240432739,
-0.4658842384815216,
0.32232359051704407,
-0.33263546228408813,
-0.3691803514957428,
0.3842330873012543,
-0.09699887782335281,
0.468807190656662,
0.4845415949821472,
-0.48490259051322937,
0.3431711196899414,
1.1487773656845093,
0.2797394096851349,
-0.24421338737010956,
-0.11239748448133469,
-0.6675769090652466,
0.01601436361670494,
-0.17456085979938507,
0.43073999881744385,
-1.0630532503128052,
-0.5853848457336426,
0.3030928373336792,
0.06093154475092888,
-0.009851768612861633,
-0.5368046760559082,
1.025108814239502,
-0.7431147694587708,
-0.2539125084877014,
-0.13011279702186584,
-0.5926531553268433,
-0.2269126921892166,
0.23612241446971893,
-0.33882299065589905,
0.5569480061531067,
0.11128799617290497,
-0.5541627407073975,
0.6562799215316772,
-0.787811279296875,
-0.5257874131202698,
0.7615178823471069,
-0.3198684751987457,
-0.42581450939178467,
0.086624376475811,
-0.36407142877578735,
0.4362947344779968,
-0.42896345257759094,
0.7574577927589417,
-0.5093677043914795,
-0.4548616111278534,
0.5528204441070557,
-0.5386549830436707,
1.245042085647583,
0.2629382312297821,
-0.2245279997587204,
0.12406553328037262,
-0.6129357218742371,
0.1659056842327118,
0.08810179680585861,
-0.2981782853603363,
-0.5900894999504089,
-0.16951902210712433,
0.18901406228542328,
-0.004096946679055691,
0.17843212187290192,
-0.4772785007953644,
-0.021522222086787224,
-0.411923885345459,
0.6110634207725525,
0.6456645131111145,
0.26928219199180603,
0.3082381784915924,
-0.2716538608074188,
0.7509626746177673,
-0.4402724802494049,
0.2018708735704422,
0.3046966791152954,
-0.5253914594650269,
-0.4209272563457489,
-0.3156696856021881,
0.30598363280296326,
0.5199049711227417,
-0.2668786942958832,
0.5519328117370605,
-0.6097143292427063,
-0.3016899824142456,
-0.679387092590332,
0.15045630931854248,
0.33658450841903687,
0.014164685271680355,
-0.018812987953424454,
-0.30766722559928894,
-0.3127148449420929,
-1.0957390069961548,
-0.6759694218635559,
0.05556478723883629,
0.07528264820575714,
0.5746909379959106,
0.728348970413208,
-0.3174469769001007,
0.8982529044151306,
0.2910083532333374,
0.1360998898744583,
-0.5341458916664124,
0.16488392651081085,
0.3842635154724121,
0.4442209005355835,
0.6952388882637024,
-0.7489253282546997,
-0.38074010610580444,
0.3564419448375702,
-0.8386999368667603,
0.07120920717716217,
-0.06644170731306076,
0.1456831991672516,
0.04772426187992096,
0.15761516988277435,
-0.7093735933303833,
0.38341596722602844,
0.05527042970061302,
-0.34365248680114746,
0.792081892490387,
-0.24043363332748413,
0.48738721013069153,
-0.7445011734962463,
0.03420798480510712,
-0.07765073329210281,
-0.348013311624527,
-0.7048904895782471,
0.5140649080276489,
-0.13351929187774658,
0.09761007875204086,
-0.801007866859436,
0.4673117399215698,
-0.340928316116333,
-0.09792254120111465,
-0.1357397884130478,
0.08971885591745377,
-0.016421617940068245,
-0.054165180772542953,
-0.19385948777198792,
0.5387299060821533,
0.5727096796035767,
-0.7472426891326904,
0.37832170724868774,
0.11327006667852402,
-0.7194963097572327,
1.0900810956954956,
-0.5835999250411987,
0.07445356994867325,
-0.028051378205418587,
0.013186316005885601,
-0.3081386983394623,
-0.13083747029304504,
0.1593920737504959,
-0.21711231768131256,
0.37864720821380615,
-0.30027830600738525,
-0.5372121930122375,
-0.3104776442050934,
-0.4145509600639343,
0.3266224265098572,
0.6480733156204224,
-0.11144708096981049,
0.6443871855735779,
0.6026899218559265,
-0.19683565199375153,
-0.7173668742179871,
-0.5464040637016296,
0.2534310817718506,
-0.4971335232257843,
-0.5620328783988953,
0.055491186678409576,
-0.021720506250858307,
-0.8260654211044312,
0.11970338225364685,
0.0338200218975544,
-0.1715676188468933,
0.354979008436203,
0.1205853596329689,
0.08245477080345154,
-0.32103049755096436,
-0.3452796936035156,
0.19398799538612366,
0.3409394323825836,
0.3768954873085022,
-0.1240026205778122,
0.33172139525413513,
-0.35925865173339844,
-0.5494937300682068,
-0.4224264919757843,
0.39914873242378235,
0.7507976293563843,
-0.19949591159820557,
0.37635207176208496,
0.15376073122024536,
-0.3760405480861664,
-0.20776014029979706,
-0.8661952614784241,
0.17700591683387756,
-0.47437530755996704,
0.5509946346282959,
-0.4520758092403412,
-1.1771118640899658,
0.43732863664627075,
-0.08301591873168945,
0.11216799169778824,
0.5176721215248108,
0.899577796459198,
0.06366299837827682,
0.38460275530815125,
0.6887632012367249,
0.23383405804634094,
-0.08148380368947983,
-0.009861836209893227,
0.5917419195175171,
-0.8318274617195129,
-0.2511538863182068,
-0.4716421365737915,
0.30876657366752625,
-0.6409796476364136,
-0.4426884353160858,
0.17998705804347992,
-0.11567730456590652,
-0.06357155740261078,
0.07647712528705597,
-0.1631391942501068,
0.7449689507484436,
0.058625366538763046,
-0.07717297226190567,
0.7973318696022034,
0.043958380818367004,
-0.38906458020210266,
-0.0982762798666954,
-0.4782317280769348,
-1.1512854099273682,
1.108778715133667,
0.7682963609695435,
0.4276103973388672,
0.16620475053787231,
0.48797154426574707,
0.4551331102848053,
0.4101846218109131,
-1.1396476030349731,
0.7057010531425476,
-0.1377771943807602,
-0.43054237961769104,
-0.4349633753299713,
-0.4912456274032593,
-0.9467306137084961,
0.2142760306596756,
-0.1534227877855301,
-1.123278021812439,
0.026891013607382774,
-0.42400455474853516,
-0.5784667730331421,
0.37383344769477844,
-0.2500151991844177,
0.5825123190879822,
-0.22244468331336975,
-0.4488413333892822,
-0.46698758006095886,
-0.5487602353096008,
0.6385000944137573,
-0.3185374140739441,
0.47272008657455444,
-0.16375374794006348,
0.13603077828884125,
0.7405657768249512,
-0.4367099106311798,
0.5627473592758179,
0.11762334406375885,
-0.3301398754119873,
0.5144619345664978,
0.21453857421875,
0.26575297117233276,
0.41169485449790955,
-0.3036937415599823,
0.23120655119419098,
0.07037930935621262,
0.030204636976122856,
-0.43944597244262695,
0.8664482831954956,
-0.4359884560108185,
-0.9429396390914917,
-0.4937560558319092,
-0.5813400745391846,
-0.48928868770599365,
0.1627868264913559,
-0.058775853365659714,
0.09107010811567307,
-0.5850343704223633,
0.16145412623882294,
0.7126808166503906,
-0.4705963134765625,
0.3090724050998688,
1.024478793144226,
-0.015521452762186527,
-0.20983317494392395,
0.7778408527374268,
-0.04218486696481705,
0.18168678879737854,
-0.05654389411211014,
0.29471829533576965,
-0.41248801350593567,
-0.7027872800827026,
-0.431671142578125,
0.25875383615493774,
-0.9892362952232361,
0.13539449870586395,
-0.9206428527832031,
-0.22624452412128448,
-0.11609500646591187,
-0.15639595687389374,
-0.1951429694890976,
-0.3482922911643982,
0.10348305106163025,
-0.04124259203672409,
0.26163432002067566,
0.8167310357093811,
0.3136083781719208,
-0.2524441182613373,
-0.7991338968276978,
0.20635147392749786,
0.30107101798057556,
0.4633372724056244,
-0.06680578738451004,
-1.0302746295928955,
0.23691073060035706,
-0.018535256385803223,
-0.08611501753330231,
-0.3157692849636078,
-0.06842458993196487,
0.053079381585121155,
1.1989656686782837,
0.39533424377441406,
-0.21650120615959167,
0.2984602749347687,
-0.8610007762908936,
0.6994672417640686,
0.15528634190559387,
-1.0788267850875854,
0.18777309358119965,
-0.4969226121902466,
-0.1984211504459381,
0.7688052654266357,
0.4920763671398163,
-0.16322386264801025,
-0.6766889095306396,
-0.6929817199707031,
-0.8044267892837524,
0.3776075839996338,
0.46941429376602173,
0.7268396615982056,
0.21457941830158234,
0.4007236063480377,
0.33842024207115173,
0.4861089289188385,
-0.8256887197494507,
0.012925248593091965,
0.25619664788246155,
0.05118163675069809,
0.44879215955734253,
-0.4053325653076172,
-0.45943599939346313,
-0.3277186453342438,
0.29684022068977356,
0.14928942918777466,
0.11654195189476013,
-0.11933571845293045,
-0.1463366150856018,
0.03430468961596489,
0.7401401400566101,
0.7556512355804443,
1.0792357921600342,
-0.07840930670499802,
-0.2589137852191925,
0.2839377820491791,
-0.4890873432159424,
0.2572324872016907,
-0.14245201647281647,
0.0270986445248127,
0.02185378409922123,
0.2730110287666321,
0.4424198567867279,
0.2191934883594513,
-0.9166725277900696,
0.80189049243927,
0.050354525446891785,
-0.3418353199958801,
-0.36281755566596985,
-0.15375208854675293,
0.10118891298770905,
0.2109709233045578,
0.3710862100124359,
-0.0393824428319931,
0.5318130254745483,
-0.8981180191040039,
0.23240138590335846,
0.7271282076835632,
-0.01944286935031414,
-0.04896954074501991,
0.4825086295604706,
0.1901867836713791,
-0.33092913031578064,
0.22782394289970398,
-0.36454498767852783,
-0.6838944554328918,
0.7874318361282349,
0.23136068880558014,
1.0178104639053345,
-0.09153430163860321,
0.14589737355709076,
0.08785661309957504,
0.5285621285438538,
-0.16584473848342896,
0.2795118987560272,
0.09337519109249115,
-0.5555542707443237,
-0.602512001991272,
-0.8625089526176453,
-0.5686134099960327,
0.26325052976608276,
-0.5032228827476501,
0.19223521649837494,
-0.6004084348678589,
-0.07305219769477844,
-0.21865972876548767,
-0.1655675619840622,
-0.6677039265632629,
0.08241301029920578,
-0.033479589968919754,
0.7708408832550049,
-0.4670330286026001,
0.9288004636764526,
0.5323292016983032,
-0.17589546740055084,
-0.3829667568206787,
0.06485074758529663,
-0.19407621026039124,
-0.913354754447937,
0.8378985524177551,
0.20355616509914398,
-0.3189164102077484,
-0.37892764806747437,
-0.51137775182724,
-0.13506071269512177,
0.9215027689933777,
0.3292609453201294,
-0.699359655380249,
0.26229846477508545,
0.44548457860946655,
0.7685016989707947,
-0.5991348028182983,
0.14157621562480927,
0.6432629823684692,
0.5018774271011353,
-0.0064397272653877735,
-1.0695527791976929,
0.36192700266838074,
-0.25094178318977356,
0.14053303003311157,
-0.2807735204696655,
-0.5386816263198853,
0.522981584072113,
-0.2984432578086853,
-0.16680721938610077,
0.16013991832733154,
0.37785986065864563,
0.5168326497077942,
0.45797401666641235,
0.4078296422958374,
0.49046003818511963,
0.8429346680641174,
0.10743702203035355,
1.2043757438659668,
-0.3377959728240967,
0.4736138582229614,
0.9587677717208862,
-0.7442103624343872,
0.5297577381134033,
0.48784834146499634,
-0.19855625927448273,
0.23294803500175476,
0.25752007961273193,
-0.21549460291862488,
0.16461439430713654,
0.545343279838562,
-0.28519371151924133,
-0.436062753200531,
-0.3572620153427124,
-0.22833478450775146,
0.4148799479007721,
0.4418675899505615,
-0.32767096161842346,
-0.008682587184011936,
-0.23405040800571442,
0.023318907245993614,
0.2929880619049072,
-0.3556768000125885,
0.4493221044540405,
0.284456729888916,
-0.3934456408023834,
0.2841610610485077,
0.26406288146972656,
0.6857070922851562,
-0.3357313871383667,
-0.12775196135044098,
0.08264998346567154,
-0.34833836555480957,
-0.1865590512752533,
-0.9825554490089417,
0.3115667402744293,
0.259487122297287,
0.30737417936325073,
-0.04289480298757553,
0.4683617651462555,
0.03134623169898987,
-0.40848851203918457,
0.284833699464798,
0.46934086084365845,
0.241487517952919,
0.2400355339050293,
-0.7051301002502441,
0.1519462913274765,
-0.3938583433628082,
-0.2705449163913727,
0.3233475089073181,
0.6913148760795593,
-0.1715262085199356,
0.8302931189537048,
0.6590803265571594,
0.049485791474580765,
-0.15761908888816833,
0.29045262932777405,
0.7813488841056824,
-0.5789995193481445,
-0.4109362065792084,
-0.9370060563087463,
0.5374159216880798,
-0.27589550614356995,
-0.38455596566200256,
0.6928466558456421,
0.5434147715568542,
0.46826881170272827,
-0.11183340847492218,
0.8952195644378662,
-0.007253582589328289,
0.14090272784233093,
-0.8620367646217346,
0.8665865659713745,
-0.43540269136428833,
0.5923845171928406,
-0.32899340987205505,
-0.8812788724899292,
-0.09220024943351746,
0.5760617256164551,
-0.4063572585582733,
0.24801191687583923,
0.7915604114532471,
0.3867824375629425,
-0.22452710568904877,
0.11623596400022507,
0.7782907485961914,
0.11909104138612747,
0.10065504908561707,
0.38816288113594055,
0.9957520365715027,
-0.1504840850830078,
0.38598906993865967,
0.19934238493442535,
-0.27806296944618225,
-0.4256678521633148,
-1.1066994667053223,
-1.0668178796768188,
-0.09286525100469589,
-0.25751370191574097,
-0.3816292881965637,
0.1290973722934723,
0.9377865791320801,
0.2801945209503174,
-0.7757917046546936,
-0.3173823654651642,
0.10207007080316544,
-0.007360602729022503,
-0.018648292869329453,
-0.3147454857826233,
-0.07439076155424118,
-0.14078672230243683,
-0.8065317273139954,
0.5184188485145569,
0.5844537019729614,
-0.020773043856024742,
-0.3209393322467804,
-0.23202042281627655,
-0.12538236379623413,
0.40496373176574707,
0.6536899209022522,
0.24289335310459137,
-0.9491011500358582,
-0.19758276641368866,
-0.35409015417099,
-0.3679087162017822,
-0.07969953864812851,
1.067855954170227,
-0.1772146224975586,
0.3114497661590576,
0.0922771468758583,
0.9541412591934204,
-0.05142446234822273,
-0.12728029489517212,
0.7324274778366089,
-0.12205656617879868,
0.18433284759521484,
0.6592273116111755,
0.6481260657310486,
0.16134235262870789,
-0.5395796895027161,
0.5051194429397583,
0.13229632377624512,
-0.4847835898399353,
-1.0514423847198486,
0.3722880780696869,
-1.143721580505371,
-0.14191533625125885,
1.3706090450286865,
-0.4721362888813019,
-0.0672902762889862,
-0.48220211267471313,
0.06447626650333405,
-0.1403101682662964,
-0.22139035165309906,
0.6391222476959229,
0.7697122693061829,
0.19169603288173676,
0.1143563836812973,
-1.0061962604522705,
0.3255559504032135,
0.44992077350616455,
-0.6888132691383362,
-0.22592082619667053,
0.23529881238937378,
0.657457709312439,
-0.13467064499855042,
0.4642271101474762,
-0.5191874504089355,
0.37526071071624756,
-0.28324371576309204,
-0.20389801263809204,
0.034814026206731796,
0.14318865537643433,
-0.5265305638313293,
0.12363339960575104,
0.2947382628917694,
0.4811597466468811
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11145v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11145v2
|
A Challenge Dataset and Effective Models for Conversational Stance Detection
| 2024-03-17T08:51:01 | 2024-03-21T06:22:56 |
Fuqiang Niu, Min Yang, Ang Li, Baoquan Zhang, Xiaojiang Peng, Bowen Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Previous stance detection studies typically concentrate on evaluating stances
within individual instances, thereby exhibiting limitations in effectively
modeling multi-party discussions concerning the same specific topic, as
naturally transpire in authentic social media interactions. This constraint
arises primarily due to the scarcity of datasets that authentically replicate
real social media contexts, hindering the research progress of conversational
stance detection. In this paper, we introduce a new multi-turn conversation
stance detection dataset (called \textbf{MT-CSD}), which encompasses multiple
targets for conversational stance detection. To derive stances from this
challenging dataset, we propose a global-local attention network
(\textbf{GLAN}) to address both long and short-range dependencies inherent in
conversational data. Notably, even state-of-the-art stance detection methods,
exemplified by GLAN, exhibit an accuracy of only 50.47\%, highlighting the
persistent challenges in conversational stance detection. Furthermore, our
MT-CSD dataset serves as a valuable resource to catalyze advancements in
cross-domain stance detection, where a classifier is adapted from a different
yet related target. We believe that MT-CSD will contribute to advancing
real-world applications of stance detection research. Our source code, data,
and models are available at \url{https://github.com/nfq729/MT-CSD}.
|
[
-0.4565073847770691,
-0.8673228025436401,
0.3592117726802826,
0.20623700320720673,
-0.2007344365119934,
0.13657212257385254,
-0.16599233448505402,
-0.13756334781646729,
0.6656714081764221,
0.43780091404914856,
-0.7765827775001526,
-0.6660122275352478,
-0.6658060550689697,
-0.40854647755622864,
-0.10325063019990921,
1.104710578918457,
0.16627474129199982,
-0.0151063222438097,
-0.07052155584096909,
-0.8184561729431152,
-0.39850255846977234,
-0.5991146564483643,
-0.7367911338806152,
-0.08700501918792725,
0.5722719430923462,
0.6513478755950928,
0.7854568362236023,
0.19711712002754211,
0.34749799966812134,
0.22801658511161804,
-0.12755517661571503,
0.17760896682739258,
-0.3903487026691437,
0.1579054594039917,
0.11303089559078217,
-0.037646714597940445,
-0.855705738067627,
-0.07820155471563339,
0.717383086681366,
0.6091296672821045,
-0.307585209608078,
0.05803658813238144,
0.0004330032679717988,
0.6582167148590088,
-0.38056787848472595,
-0.16028662025928497,
-0.6983067393302917,
0.19018714129924774,
-0.33639851212501526,
0.11231304705142975,
-0.3525446653366089,
-0.18610188364982605,
0.049211110919713974,
-0.31790077686309814,
0.4508781433105469,
-0.1579468548297882,
0.8810135722160339,
-0.12377073615789413,
-0.5993632674217224,
-0.14595745503902435,
-0.4648248553276062,
0.679706335067749,
-0.607203483581543,
0.5028154253959656,
0.20344293117523193,
0.30840086936950684,
-0.10942384600639343,
-0.33326682448387146,
-0.6847646236419678,
-0.08054378628730774,
0.21943694353103638,
0.10000230371952057,
-0.40833109617233276,
-0.15487807989120483,
0.15148572623729706,
0.2602161765098572,
-0.5873045325279236,
-0.11646434664726257,
-0.11335484683513641,
0.06498401612043381,
0.3531893491744995,
0.22276347875595093,
0.19575975835323334,
-0.4261336922645569,
-0.5167354345321655,
-0.054263949394226074,
-0.5062350034713745,
0.22251074016094208,
0.5357367992401123,
0.5796458721160889,
-0.5829514265060425,
0.4577856957912445,
-0.4215031862258911,
0.4882560074329376,
0.43934816122055054,
0.08200489729642868,
0.44665637612342834,
-0.3048255145549774,
-0.14224940538406372,
-0.27406734228134155,
0.9592746496200562,
0.4929286241531372,
0.0225426834076643,
0.024894263595342636,
0.3305756151676178,
0.012212012894451618,
0.23617751896381378,
-0.6098636984825134,
-0.16284294426441193,
0.3932534158229828,
-0.543664276599884,
-0.3970767855644226,
0.06438320875167847,
-0.7984123826026917,
-0.8054941296577454,
-0.6014920473098755,
-0.19228391349315643,
-0.3291046917438507,
-0.7098485231399536,
0.0946723073720932,
0.08496762812137604,
0.635975182056427,
0.2697158455848694,
-0.7654938101768494,
0.1182873398065567,
0.8450233936309814,
1.2065414190292358,
-0.4887043237686157,
0.0830649584531784,
-0.38797125220298767,
-0.05589567869901657,
-0.26304736733436584,
0.779411792755127,
-0.630179762840271,
-0.3974280059337616,
-0.06671832501888275,
0.1712867021560669,
-0.06885910779237747,
-0.3973757326602936,
0.8771597146987915,
-0.21737660467624664,
-0.01215697918087244,
-0.4139460325241089,
-0.24204480648040771,
0.04215620458126068,
0.8640470504760742,
-0.7996557950973511,
0.9733298420906067,
-0.19806064665317535,
-1.0784149169921875,
0.3533492088317871,
-0.7829362750053406,
-0.49077513813972473,
-0.25435584783554077,
-0.24804078042507172,
-0.6513523459434509,
-0.08093807846307755,
0.45254284143447876,
0.6767579913139343,
-0.06066175177693367,
0.36532363295555115,
-0.8962475657463074,
0.1018388494849205,
0.25683560967445374,
-0.4217335879802704,
1.029565691947937,
-0.1094416156411171,
-0.2398192137479782,
0.3243074119091034,
-0.6705694794654846,
-0.06901587545871735,
0.1550743579864502,
-0.18079252541065216,
-0.28288766741752625,
0.21431505680084229,
-0.1965346485376358,
0.43022432923316956,
-0.0780191570520401,
-0.4949728548526764,
0.2746332585811615,
-0.07746023684740067,
0.30567818880081177,
0.8009827733039856,
0.17727160453796387,
0.28326502442359924,
-0.14705340564250946,
0.607797384262085,
0.25510168075561523,
0.30616167187690735,
0.07039843499660492,
-0.45941445231437683,
-0.8425359725952148,
-0.3276025354862213,
-0.0904705598950386,
0.3970806300640106,
-0.6927841305732727,
0.39178183674812317,
-0.4911304712295532,
-0.4470236599445343,
-0.5000061392784119,
0.10227616131305695,
0.33093157410621643,
0.34638237953186035,
0.35975325107574463,
-0.34818774461746216,
-0.4073486626148224,
-0.9008784294128418,
-0.3408310115337372,
-0.09396727383136749,
0.18615445494651794,
0.22712324559688568,
0.35065507888793945,
0.06530088186264038,
1.0411057472229004,
-0.16845034062862396,
-0.5637896656990051,
-0.40659385919570923,
0.29169541597366333,
0.09668679535388947,
0.2753220498561859,
0.6201435327529907,
-0.8685739040374756,
-0.6294955611228943,
0.08975987881422043,
-0.6176596879959106,
0.15746748447418213,
-0.20762711763381958,
-0.3031008541584015,
0.09712911397218704,
0.5704659223556519,
-0.7418552041053772,
0.278672993183136,
0.6364685893058777,
-0.24244987964630127,
0.40924447774887085,
0.28110945224761963,
0.24449115991592407,
-1.2523870468139648,
-0.1141267865896225,
0.4331277310848236,
-0.12123323976993561,
-0.9706787467002869,
-0.23450735211372375,
-0.044749900698661804,
-0.06651158630847931,
-0.6570703983306885,
0.3336186110973358,
-0.306710809469223,
-0.04753908887505531,
-0.025623176246881485,
0.2525976300239563,
-0.049490850418806076,
0.7664816975593567,
0.2963542938232422,
0.28691092133522034,
0.5927926898002625,
-0.46891480684280396,
0.38900378346443176,
0.3820495009422302,
-0.09885141998529434,
1.3123366832733154,
-0.7333179116249084,
0.4809085726737976,
-0.11262001842260361,
0.5215422511100769,
-1.1690623760223389,
-0.25174063444137573,
0.7046060562133789,
-0.5503878593444824,
0.2919115722179413,
-0.5907933115959167,
-0.19720035791397095,
-0.38651177287101746,
-0.572537362575531,
0.24875202775001526,
-0.30106279253959656,
-0.6941010355949402,
0.7113041281700134,
0.5727400183677673,
-0.2570812404155731,
-0.7887258529663086,
-0.4627382457256317,
0.2159864753484726,
-0.33329159021377563,
-0.7209196090698242,
0.22343306243419647,
0.03846908360719681,
-0.06482971459627151,
-0.3711671829223633,
-0.0021587612573057413,
0.19964011013507843,
-0.3329927921295166,
0.37693852186203003,
0.10631053149700165,
-0.1422840803861618,
-0.09185882657766342,
-0.2995340824127197,
0.004247453995049,
0.16827119886875153,
-0.22925865650177002,
0.5874449610710144,
-0.3018379807472229,
-0.6720244288444519,
-0.7430528998374939,
0.5178518891334534,
0.946780800819397,
-0.1769452840089798,
0.46284693479537964,
0.76420658826828,
-0.31231412291526794,
-0.13593801856040955,
-0.3587336242198944,
0.11316221207380295,
-0.49541062116622925,
0.4196363687515259,
-0.21777190268039703,
-0.6800715923309326,
0.6443926692008972,
0.16060693562030792,
-0.05140545219182968,
-0.03921566903591156,
0.6758983731269836,
-0.15131105482578278,
1.1057499647140503,
0.30230748653411865,
-0.527380645275116,
0.5685184001922607,
-0.3512215316295624,
0.26363107562065125,
-0.9165092706680298,
-0.09326285868883133,
-0.5549542903900146,
-0.5006829500198364,
-0.43764036893844604,
-0.6114662885665894,
0.18662422895431519,
-0.43190404772758484,
-0.04700136184692383,
0.29752063751220703,
-0.46319907903671265,
0.3557972311973572,
0.27575406432151794,
0.26117607951164246,
0.13835273683071136,
-0.06291728466749191,
0.07547982782125473,
-0.3302856683731079,
-0.3494768738746643,
-0.2919119894504547,
1.0725291967391968,
0.33088546991348267,
0.3575682044029236,
0.22782589495182037,
0.3475155830383301,
0.5261414051055908,
0.4883841276168823,
-1.044771432876587,
0.7392125129699707,
0.04050755500793457,
-0.5085821151733398,
-0.11288178712129593,
-0.3440750241279602,
-0.9886780977249146,
0.4555971622467041,
-0.16348445415496826,
-0.6727890968322754,
0.1903623342514038,
0.2178039252758026,
-0.10529210418462753,
0.5253431797027588,
-0.49776023626327515,
1.2706407308578491,
-0.17062115669250488,
-0.3909233510494232,
-0.15967413783073425,
-0.739711344242096,
0.4013403356075287,
0.394944965839386,
0.22283050417900085,
-0.27012911438941956,
0.5682367086410522,
0.6614594459533691,
-0.11998901516199112,
1.1841579675674438,
-0.7242125868797302,
-0.20559710264205933,
0.4290638267993927,
-0.1145782619714737,
0.5444462895393372,
0.07292018085718155,
0.10157902538776398,
0.03785889595746994,
-0.4485865831375122,
-0.31195929646492004,
-0.21902517974376678,
0.7016142010688782,
-0.42894017696380615,
-0.316312313079834,
-0.32094159722328186,
-0.33921363949775696,
-0.5609155297279358,
-0.030941084027290344,
0.02368544600903988,
0.4292825162410736,
-0.8602357506752014,
0.40705928206443787,
0.6059236526489258,
-0.013332090340554714,
0.383515328168869,
0.24847717583179474,
0.060043249279260635,
-0.44174349308013916,
1.0121287107467651,
-0.08054490387439728,
0.28023871779441833,
0.228639155626297,
0.05673335865139961,
-0.4536673128604889,
-0.31597399711608887,
-0.274861603975296,
-0.01782923750579357,
-0.819713830947876,
-0.13064244389533997,
-0.5449896454811096,
0.2941462993621826,
-0.43740805983543396,
-0.12563177943229675,
-0.46937382221221924,
-0.3950541615486145,
-0.13924790918827057,
-0.2256437987089157,
0.17170056700706482,
0.318163126707077,
0.04183938354253769,
0.35420796275138855,
-0.37897732853889465,
0.8104395866394043,
0.20667441189289093,
0.12484262883663177,
-0.166266530752182,
-0.31092751026153564,
0.14393533766269684,
0.25231432914733887,
-0.656678318977356,
-0.8479790091514587,
0.2716999351978302,
0.22890286147594452,
0.46702486276626587,
0.6440829038619995,
0.24802403151988983,
0.43551212549209595,
-0.2248939424753189,
0.6150946021080017,
0.41517534852027893,
-0.7800686359405518,
0.5223292708396912,
-0.6981799602508545,
0.25450554490089417,
0.5099465250968933,
0.48361966013908386,
-0.6753579378128052,
-0.5627981424331665,
-0.6975263953208923,
-0.7393728494644165,
0.7722424268722534,
-0.046606484800577164,
0.2722991704940796,
-0.04584978148341179,
0.04906954988837242,
-0.10629786550998688,
0.023641403764486313,
-0.8126267194747925,
-0.17094804346561432,
-0.19714172184467316,
-0.1695016622543335,
0.4380556344985962,
0.18606461584568024,
-0.219070702791214,
-0.2955498993396759,
0.6571135520935059,
-0.5767163634300232,
0.312271386384964,
0.028335999697446823,
-0.01497549656778574,
0.1431194543838501,
0.3314279019832611,
0.4462983012199402,
0.2996685802936554,
-0.08620961010456085,
-0.1338946372270584,
0.24887055158615112,
-0.4783262610435486,
-0.011133729480206966,
-0.19356265664100647,
-0.10454387962818146,
0.15026606619358063,
-0.19407342374324799,
0.7888373732566833,
0.025789666920900345,
-0.052000269293785095,
0.6729512214660645,
-0.07544663548469543,
-0.31298986077308655,
-0.337900847196579,
-0.27959173917770386,
0.3401917815208435,
0.14905956387519836,
0.16817212104797363,
0.3405744731426239,
0.1100216954946518,
-0.5258990526199341,
0.2551344037055969,
0.8071264028549194,
-0.715950608253479,
-0.4453712999820709,
0.4967047870159149,
0.07631206512451172,
-0.16928620636463165,
0.21081912517547607,
-0.41517287492752075,
-0.66877281665802,
0.6871213912963867,
0.24336127936840057,
0.7747451066970825,
-0.05167389288544655,
0.6463440656661987,
0.25167378783226013,
-0.037349920719861984,
0.14432848989963531,
0.2714036703109741,
-0.08624176681041718,
-0.9410613179206848,
-0.16163459420204163,
-0.11050286144018173,
-0.816058874130249,
0.25503817200660706,
-0.8922593593597412,
0.581631600856781,
-0.6923387050628662,
-0.5100012421607971,
0.2698657214641571,
-0.17366522550582886,
-0.47555550932884216,
-0.05755671113729477,
0.17288291454315186,
0.29471760988235474,
-0.5782064199447632,
0.8275935649871826,
0.6731444001197815,
0.05747225880622864,
-0.260978102684021,
0.2019677609205246,
0.5877622961997986,
-0.5915161967277527,
0.0773971900343895,
0.2562066614627838,
-0.6039386987686157,
-0.33349764347076416,
-0.7477982044219971,
-0.27143043279647827,
0.9207159280776978,
0.3917821943759918,
-0.21696963906288147,
0.3308587968349457,
0.24130739271640778,
0.43121805787086487,
-0.4033787250518799,
-0.036147136241197586,
0.5402605533599854,
0.4296831786632538,
0.19094635546207428,
-0.5180270075798035,
0.010502836667001247,
-0.22333325445652008,
-0.27238327264785767,
0.1361228972673416,
-1.139430046081543,
0.6297231912612915,
-0.19307495653629303,
-0.14312314987182617,
-0.24877768754959106,
0.775321364402771,
0.357707679271698,
0.4112761318683624,
0.6257571578025818,
0.5427576303482056,
0.7621698975563049,
-0.26153790950775146,
0.6973670125007629,
-0.02763553149998188,
0.4581295847892761,
1.0319385528564453,
-0.5674311518669128,
0.9471049904823303,
0.39324086904525757,
-0.04960932955145836,
0.51209557056427,
0.43343061208724976,
-0.03963702172040939,
0.32704123854637146,
0.08367329835891724,
-0.35059410333633423,
-0.39021384716033936,
-0.13263998925685883,
-0.21526797115802765,
0.4429510533809662,
0.6669071912765503,
0.011349985376000404,
-0.11218858510255814,
-0.03027181886136532,
0.378132164478302,
0.014454152435064316,
-0.23603500425815582,
0.5200503468513489,
-0.15142883360385895,
-0.5666282176971436,
0.42674678564071655,
-0.05505086109042168,
0.8710273504257202,
-0.515190064907074,
0.20245768129825592,
-0.30059462785720825,
0.4416232407093048,
-0.22388790547847748,
-0.7317659854888916,
0.3074197471141815,
-0.08290483802556992,
-0.10764117538928986,
-0.18837091326713562,
0.8435421586036682,
-0.4381488859653473,
-0.25089722871780396,
0.34276655316352844,
0.37445539236068726,
-0.1929977834224701,
-0.15126386284828186,
-0.9043185710906982,
0.08992289006710052,
0.03723665699362755,
-0.42868301272392273,
0.4565221071243286,
0.6425115466117859,
-0.2030337154865265,
0.5610836148262024,
0.7095820307731628,
-0.3911612033843994,
-0.1241580918431282,
0.3051123023033142,
0.9632633924484253,
-0.4195038676261902,
-0.6733255386352539,
-0.584935188293457,
0.4803103506565094,
-0.4561312198638916,
-0.5467615127563477,
0.5919065475463867,
0.34298744797706604,
0.6025819778442383,
0.10825637727975845,
0.8153625130653381,
-0.31144261360168457,
0.6261334419250488,
-0.3935014009475708,
0.5717307925224304,
-0.33684760332107544,
-0.04411997273564339,
-0.36299675703048706,
-0.5432296991348267,
-0.4258645474910736,
0.6952517628669739,
-0.15920870006084442,
-0.017952974885702133,
0.5096930265426636,
0.8514108061790466,
-0.40489593148231506,
0.3554074764251709,
-0.10035301744937897,
-0.06134580075740814,
0.5571886897087097,
0.5661606192588806,
0.8026033639907837,
-0.2445099949836731,
0.8019108772277832,
-0.02126983553171158,
0.0615544319152832,
-0.24810278415679932,
-1.0646820068359375,
-1.0901647806167603,
-0.5041176676750183,
-0.7260499000549316,
-0.481442391872406,
-0.12647812068462372,
0.9318833947181702,
0.8745606541633606,
-1.0842281579971313,
-0.09702037274837494,
-0.07267537713050842,
0.14859752357006073,
-0.36245521903038025,
-0.3195253312587738,
0.42287448048591614,
-0.13034744560718536,
-0.6607959866523743,
0.5931728482246399,
0.09392256289720535,
-0.02695893682539463,
-0.05104951560497284,
-0.26721200346946716,
-0.45263612270355225,
-0.043943293392658234,
0.5424702763557434,
0.6739871501922607,
-0.6159328818321228,
-0.5481235384941101,
0.22286362946033478,
-0.0385906882584095,
0.5645514726638794,
1.0011454820632935,
-0.3560432195663452,
0.2670650780200958,
0.22610118985176086,
0.5305129289627075,
0.576757550239563,
0.21768824756145477,
0.3243010640144348,
-1.5888121128082275,
0.20813606679439545,
0.06905901432037354,
0.44586023688316345,
0.6953911185264587,
-0.03424721583724022,
0.38263270258903503,
0.4111138582229614,
-0.2958381474018097,
-0.6452944874763489,
0.27660199999809265,
-1.441416621208191,
0.04262707382440567,
1.2358100414276123,
-0.09807760268449783,
0.0918492004275322,
-0.4856407344341278,
-0.6121488213539124,
0.039009224623441696,
-0.7038300633430481,
0.5124537348747253,
0.8450742959976196,
-0.2179303765296936,
-0.11303389072418213,
-0.6197846531867981,
0.43117645382881165,
0.47410619258880615,
-0.8125326037406921,
0.6429296731948853,
0.6700330972671509,
0.02330731227993965,
0.39823979139328003,
0.8747943043708801,
-0.09947410970926285,
0.04398976266384125,
-0.27591562271118164,
-0.03370816633105278,
0.27031803131103516,
-0.43008124828338623,
-0.25574225187301636,
0.36677420139312744,
-0.42450419068336487,
-0.379981130361557
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11130v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11130v1
|
Exploring Tokenization Strategies and Vocabulary Sizes for Enhanced Arabic Language Models
| 2024-03-17T07:44:44 | 2024-03-17T07:44:44 |
Mohamed Taher Alrefaie, Nour Eldin Morsy, Nada Samir
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper presents a comprehensive examination of the impact of tokenization
strategies and vocabulary sizes on the performance of Arabic language models in
downstream natural language processing tasks. Our investigation focused on the
effectiveness of four tokenizers across various tasks, including News
Classification, Hate Speech Detection, Sentiment Analysis, and Natural Language
Inference. Leveraging a diverse set of vocabulary sizes, we scrutinize the
intricate interplay between tokenization approaches and model performance. The
results reveal that Byte Pair Encoding (BPE) with Farasa outperforms other
strategies in multiple tasks, underscoring the significance of morphological
analysis in capturing the nuances of the Arabic language. However, challenges
arise in sentiment analysis, where dialect specific segmentation issues impact
model efficiency. Computational efficiency analysis demonstrates the stability
of BPE with Farasa, suggesting its practical viability. Our study uncovers
limited impacts of vocabulary size on model performance while keeping the model
size unchanged. This is challenging the established beliefs about the
relationship between vocabulary, model size, and downstream tasks, emphasizing
the need for the study of models' size and their corresponding vocabulary size
to generalize across domains and mitigate biases, particularly in dialect based
datasets. Paper's recommendations include refining tokenization strategies to
address dialect challenges, enhancing model robustness across diverse
linguistic contexts, and expanding datasets to encompass the rich dialect based
Arabic. This work not only advances our understanding of Arabic language models
but also lays the foundation for responsible and ethical developments in
natural language processing technologies tailored to the intricacies of the
Arabic language.
|
[
-0.6281947493553162,
-0.6901450157165527,
0.2190903127193451,
0.29405686259269714,
-0.42684414982795715,
0.08934182673692703,
-0.19837866723537445,
-0.5836111903190613,
0.1877681463956833,
0.3638961613178253,
0.01883988082408905,
-0.40458032488822937,
-0.8376322388648987,
0.14860162138938904,
-0.36593157052993774,
1.1375566720962524,
0.09809860587120056,
0.23819413781166077,
0.14061692357063293,
-0.1263253092765808,
-0.5363147258758545,
-0.9590999484062195,
-0.7702999114990234,
0.071410171687603,
0.5883143544197083,
0.1776900589466095,
0.9863035082817078,
0.7501477003097534,
0.40572819113731384,
0.24567532539367676,
-0.3112504184246063,
0.06627468764781952,
-0.25839492678642273,
0.005317092407494783,
-0.02543405443429947,
-0.12675850093364716,
-0.36964523792266846,
-0.22296284139156342,
0.9103948473930359,
0.7902053594589233,
0.0020955761428922415,
0.3347785472869873,
-0.08593425899744034,
0.6313040852546692,
-0.8052082657814026,
-0.10086508840322495,
-0.5704497694969177,
-0.25087398290634155,
-0.4831926226615906,
0.3778578042984009,
-0.2504444420337677,
0.06363994628190994,
-0.07407000660896301,
0.05218401923775673,
-0.02483583800494671,
0.2175654023885727,
0.7282409071922302,
0.10343939810991287,
-0.594534158706665,
-0.4407159984111786,
-0.6323282122612,
0.9708640575408936,
-0.9250195026397705,
0.40905410051345825,
0.3442113697528839,
0.19213294982910156,
-0.002595687285065651,
-0.72465580701828,
-0.6396899223327637,
-0.18047527968883514,
0.030222807079553604,
-0.314362108707428,
-0.29816994071006775,
0.33917906880378723,
0.04890749976038933,
0.4766272306442261,
-0.1403537541627884,
0.305462509393692,
-0.2686183452606201,
-0.460567444562912,
0.4622582495212555,
0.08626094460487366,
0.3873112201690674,
-0.3169027864933014,
-0.1777285784482956,
0.13041949272155762,
-0.5113948583602905,
0.2519124150276184,
0.5337520241737366,
0.6193552613258362,
-0.08163376152515411,
0.48176828026771545,
-0.19279055297374725,
0.731113076210022,
-0.19227169454097748,
0.061581891030073166,
-0.029554709792137146,
-0.6682624220848083,
-0.13047826290130615,
0.16354037821292877,
0.39265018701553345,
0.1398901790380478,
-0.017745809629559517,
-0.3074352741241455,
-0.48728328943252563,
-0.18284285068511963,
0.452892541885376,
-1.2543556690216064,
0.2343563586473465,
0.5051330924034119,
-0.6789703965187073,
-0.21889038383960724,
0.0896853655576706,
-0.8402034640312195,
-0.20806032419204712,
-0.17952798306941986,
0.44136765599250793,
-0.38847488164901733,
-0.2600407004356384,
0.17871975898742676,
-0.1602810174226761,
0.3975149691104889,
0.12458675354719162,
-0.9463104009628296,
0.5696931481361389,
1.0057275295257568,
1.2139360904693604,
-0.07265444099903107,
-0.013565756380558014,
-0.6716320514678955,
0.05903085693717003,
-0.4263945519924164,
0.3500385880470276,
-0.6872149705886841,
-0.3807378113269806,
0.20580625534057617,
-0.5293748378753662,
0.01948661170899868,
-0.49056950211524963,
0.748486340045929,
-0.7775444984436035,
-0.3159467279911041,
-0.22590388357639313,
-0.701541543006897,
-0.33774274587631226,
0.052688851952552795,
-0.8630993366241455,
0.8253258466720581,
-0.10202611237764359,
-0.6742244362831116,
0.2609640657901764,
-1.0019279718399048,
-0.42184311151504517,
-0.07281532883644104,
0.04464104399085045,
-0.36649593710899353,
0.5475779175758362,
0.29479336738586426,
0.592115581035614,
-0.17759524285793304,
0.29640865325927734,
0.15913598239421844,
-0.4827730655670166,
0.2802574932575226,
-0.4085259437561035,
0.5426623225212097,
0.2978369891643524,
-0.36008980870246887,
0.20569728314876556,
-0.774458110332489,
-0.11662466078996658,
-0.02374466322362423,
-0.2311800867319107,
-0.26415660977363586,
-0.06154154986143112,
0.432807058095932,
0.1444033980369568,
0.35003700852394104,
-0.7142630815505981,
-0.025911230593919754,
-0.6703066229820251,
0.2647731304168701,
0.736027181148529,
-0.08779242634773254,
0.3461473286151886,
-0.332658588886261,
0.45064881443977356,
0.2736523151397705,
-0.015770722180604935,
-0.008110517635941505,
-0.4705590307712555,
-1.0630348920822144,
-0.6709049344062805,
0.689493715763092,
0.0980030968785286,
-0.3429723083972931,
0.30129873752593994,
-0.404719740152359,
-0.5042197108268738,
-0.6321559548377991,
-0.035311102867126465,
0.28111347556114197,
0.04119660705327988,
0.4258507788181305,
-0.584341824054718,
-0.5609287023544312,
-0.9810830354690552,
-0.4729713201522827,
0.04197220504283905,
0.2155485451221466,
0.1570800244808197,
0.7737632989883423,
-0.24247150123119354,
1.087018609046936,
-0.02889413945376873,
-0.10654031485319138,
-0.4674428701400757,
0.22963735461235046,
0.23633064329624176,
0.49769821763038635,
0.8001500368118286,
-0.7062686681747437,
-0.37054985761642456,
0.1004088968038559,
-0.05459440499544144,
-0.011623429134488106,
0.03077070415019989,
-0.07624060660600662,
0.48870399594306946,
0.1539672315120697,
-0.2748427987098694,
0.6507282853126526,
0.6565518379211426,
-0.4962373673915863,
0.5479520559310913,
0.18448880314826965,
-0.011266132816672325,
-1.0120551586151123,
0.09269555658102036,
-0.16902315616607666,
-0.12685684859752655,
-1.0851070880889893,
0.16270828247070312,
-0.24248415231704712,
0.023945625871419907,
-0.33172017335891724,
0.7598695755004883,
-0.43347445130348206,
-0.06863462924957275,
-0.37480610609054565,
-0.3679029643535614,
-0.18824239075183868,
0.33897680044174194,
-0.04289788380265236,
0.9971134066581726,
0.4181787967681885,
-0.5339093804359436,
0.08127862960100174,
0.10548371821641922,
-0.39079365134239197,
0.003395802341401577,
-0.7323306202888489,
0.42432764172554016,
-0.21678847074508667,
0.03510872647166252,
-1.0365415811538696,
0.013565591536462307,
0.09994149953126907,
-0.4777323007583618,
0.3280215561389923,
-0.26344117522239685,
-0.44910991191864014,
0.2011612206697464,
-0.5149384140968323,
0.47118040919303894,
0.2849982678890228,
-0.3553481101989746,
0.7711421847343445,
0.2748365104198456,
-0.25219467282295227,
-0.6514901518821716,
-0.5354257822036743,
0.45250412821769714,
-0.3753605782985687,
-0.6324056386947632,
0.46564918756484985,
0.2868974804878235,
-0.467878133058548,
-0.3741130530834198,
-0.1873995065689087,
-0.25842583179473877,
0.3083074390888214,
0.26696231961250305,
0.1897825449705124,
-0.20006103813648224,
0.2570667266845703,
0.18210144340991974,
0.1705653816461563,
0.1295841783285141,
-0.4446995258331299,
0.9011158347129822,
-0.20225933194160461,
-0.11968747526407242,
-0.5081987977027893,
0.5594298839569092,
0.4064560532569885,
-0.5217697620391846,
1.569861888885498,
0.9170768857002258,
-0.353558212518692,
0.08969379216432571,
-0.7087934613227844,
-0.18403002619743347,
-0.4389232397079468,
0.5894442796707153,
-0.5809943079948425,
-1.0236177444458008,
0.6771308779716492,
-0.07553670555353165,
0.12827040255069733,
0.3849611282348633,
0.6200151443481445,
0.3591283857822418,
0.9356682896614075,
0.601150393486023,
-0.5418306589126587,
0.4257909655570984,
-0.1373661905527115,
0.41086819767951965,
-0.7073488235473633,
0.03537369519472122,
-0.7308453917503357,
-0.3201614022254944,
-0.5340300798416138,
-0.5871052145957947,
0.2139466106891632,
0.0567324198782444,
-0.38548916578292847,
-0.1999092698097229,
-0.12001354247331619,
0.16657432913780212,
0.4863986074924469,
-0.16841939091682434,
0.17678052186965942,
0.32940664887428284,
-0.12005589157342911,
0.02667032927274704,
-0.6647739410400391,
-0.9852897524833679,
1.179053544998169,
0.49107834696769714,
0.125491663813591,
0.5873903632164001,
0.7792399525642395,
0.5751940011978149,
0.08087682723999023,
-0.9924883842468262,
0.3704403340816498,
-0.02478042058646679,
-0.6083562970161438,
-0.2320687621831894,
-0.24186012148857117,
-1.001113772392273,
0.29186588525772095,
-0.04179605469107628,
-0.6580883860588074,
-0.006872922647744417,
-0.18085233867168427,
-0.29682332277297974,
0.33283326029777527,
-0.5379208326339722,
0.9472171664237976,
-0.11866356432437897,
-0.3184034526348114,
-0.5485138297080994,
-0.5583853125572205,
-0.10040121525526047,
-0.1527864933013916,
0.28779515624046326,
0.1370135247707367,
-0.5682595372200012,
1.0653455257415771,
-0.5864719152450562,
0.9027567505836487,
-0.20572659373283386,
-0.07359270751476288,
0.2882661521434784,
-0.046944405883550644,
0.4145752489566803,
-0.12937946617603302,
-0.28865668177604675,
0.7692440748214722,
0.2097983956336975,
-0.9239575862884521,
-0.3904076814651489,
0.4584677815437317,
-0.9716808795928955,
-0.7180353403091431,
-0.4151826500892639,
-0.43107032775878906,
-0.24119172990322113,
0.16302399337291718,
-0.1645316183567047,
0.596940815448761,
-0.2673386335372925,
0.12270008027553558,
0.09928163886070251,
-0.1480913907289505,
0.5323636531829834,
0.27450013160705566,
-0.26793143153190613,
-0.3534301221370697,
0.9621585011482239,
0.16444005072116852,
0.23684239387512207,
0.26378393173217773,
0.10127624869346619,
-0.21880997717380524,
-1.1788097620010376,
-0.4933963716030121,
0.14821802079677582,
-0.539044201374054,
-0.007005877792835236,
-0.5037409067153931,
-0.13600203394889832,
-0.5707272291183472,
0.13746538758277893,
-0.3845488429069519,
-0.48416268825531006,
-0.14723722636699677,
-0.0024865532759577036,
0.4270766079425812,
0.8592495322227478,
0.06972184032201767,
0.4869958460330963,
-0.9127742052078247,
-0.15315543115139008,
0.01099995244294405,
0.22171926498413086,
0.37464073300361633,
-0.668365478515625,
-0.43761658668518066,
0.13100218772888184,
-0.0814213976264,
-0.8422912359237671,
0.38122186064720154,
0.1249370127916336,
0.2381308674812317,
0.34917011857032776,
-0.19730055332183838,
0.617831826210022,
-0.49503207206726074,
0.9553690552711487,
-0.09398937970399857,
-1.2312076091766357,
0.17277052998542786,
-0.2776029109954834,
0.06750455498695374,
0.3326531648635864,
0.45537471771240234,
-0.8110300898551941,
0.04873509705066681,
-0.3006674647331238,
-0.827930748462677,
0.5763208866119385,
0.49351420998573303,
0.4697858691215515,
-0.16472689807415009,
0.4071829915046692,
0.19039881229400635,
0.38321182131767273,
-0.3180290758609772,
-0.3379921019077301,
-0.28564220666885376,
-0.23860976099967957,
0.1040610671043396,
-0.5488324761390686,
0.2279082089662552,
-0.3183867931365967,
0.7118491530418396,
-0.1476677656173706,
0.2833687961101532,
-0.008823040872812271,
-0.10106171667575836,
0.31150829792022705,
0.4746188223361969,
0.3976886570453644,
0.457570344209671,
0.02638057991862297,
-0.07649476081132889,
0.05015197768807411,
-0.6239854097366333,
-0.09089808166027069,
0.13707944750785828,
-0.03801668435335159,
0.13850080966949463,
0.3039644658565521,
0.7519997954368591,
-0.13040468096733093,
-0.8082510232925415,
0.43995681405067444,
0.00991855375468731,
0.2067965418100357,
-0.11576186120510101,
-0.24991019070148468,
0.056962158530950546,
0.05842842161655426,
0.306966632604599,
0.04583273082971573,
0.30832433700561523,
-0.47310611605644226,
-0.15168797969818115,
0.6858447194099426,
-0.15009482204914093,
-0.333625853061676,
0.25651875138282776,
0.20579423010349274,
-0.15417490899562836,
0.5894026756286621,
-0.08307049423456192,
-0.5850194096565247,
0.6450952887535095,
0.4598301351070404,
0.5734231472015381,
-0.10261303186416626,
0.11140888929367065,
0.23080754280090332,
0.14091937243938446,
0.21167238056659698,
0.09319625794887543,
-0.2342536300420761,
-0.9845249652862549,
-0.39274293184280396,
-0.9377090334892273,
-0.29271361231803894,
0.06253528594970703,
-0.5058603286743164,
-0.07473432272672653,
-0.6172985434532166,
-0.36180543899536133,
0.06243462115526199,
0.2589331865310669,
-0.5514087080955505,
0.03453117981553078,
0.2740635275840759,
0.8334137201309204,
-0.4944951832294464,
0.636218249797821,
0.8429203629493713,
-0.5299487709999084,
-0.7883627414703369,
0.0105765825137496,
-0.0290768351405859,
-0.7347311973571777,
0.8024882674217224,
0.4108034670352936,
-0.25365620851516724,
-0.024745987728238106,
-0.35503074526786804,
-0.9189394116401672,
0.603425145149231,
0.04783613234758377,
-0.24230656027793884,
0.10351823270320892,
0.4228515028953552,
0.49428054690361023,
-0.33534732460975647,
0.19463278353214264,
0.6977207660675049,
0.36458078026771545,
-0.01126262079924345,
-0.9996699690818787,
0.018806809559464455,
-0.21665017306804657,
0.3022409677505493,
0.3368280231952667,
-0.8062471747398376,
0.76483553647995,
0.030342526733875275,
-0.115896075963974,
0.5416759252548218,
0.8423460125923157,
-0.21791765093803406,
0.11905303597450256,
0.31553325057029724,
0.39537307620048523,
0.6530250310897827,
0.13527174293994904,
0.9855629205703735,
-0.47363966703414917,
-0.04860483109951019,
0.67043137550354,
-0.20065467059612274,
1.0010181665420532,
0.7661821246147156,
-0.21265284717082977,
0.5363903045654297,
0.4417397975921631,
0.2658153474330902,
0.19738610088825226,
0.37801623344421387,
-0.5535615086555481,
-0.0836033746600151,
-0.650574803352356,
-0.15916700661182404,
0.8376143574714661,
0.3475906550884247,
-0.3749222755432129,
0.01369559671729803,
-0.03339367359876633,
0.271025151014328,
0.12683835625648499,
-0.5668134689331055,
0.6779953241348267,
-0.1722247153520584,
-0.47153645753860474,
0.5616440773010254,
0.526770830154419,
0.9045376181602478,
-0.5166248083114624,
0.15594284236431122,
-0.20519913733005524,
0.04537228122353554,
-0.07829771190881729,
-0.21373037993907928,
0.4922131299972534,
0.31427818536758423,
-0.02513299509882927,
-0.08064194023609161,
0.7591454386711121,
-0.055891748517751694,
-0.5318928360939026,
0.045281291007995605,
0.6891673803329468,
0.23943683505058289,
-0.3051236569881439,
-0.3817564845085144,
0.29159873723983765,
-0.010646787472069263,
-0.06838788092136383,
0.5338147282600403,
0.24376365542411804,
-0.13072893023490906,
0.40406522154808044,
0.7007195353507996,
0.3716154098510742,
0.22591464221477509,
0.1880142241716385,
0.8079600930213928,
-0.8158404231071472,
-0.35005712509155273,
-1.1191565990447998,
0.2483852505683899,
-0.19746460020542145,
-0.20382240414619446,
0.9104057550430298,
0.7115735411643982,
0.8217976093292236,
-0.02942086197435856,
0.5337575078010559,
0.12163812667131424,
0.36693620681762695,
-0.42417269945144653,
0.6913072466850281,
-0.4237860143184662,
0.13073785603046417,
-0.08992435783147812,
-0.6263782382011414,
-0.17352838814258575,
0.513207733631134,
-0.3473801612854004,
0.27441877126693726,
0.34835201501846313,
0.786571204662323,
0.2549172639846802,
0.1691576987504959,
0.20397044718265533,
0.20347481966018677,
0.3344556987285614,
0.15907429158687592,
0.7569477558135986,
-0.38023486733436584,
0.26787838339805603,
-0.17924021184444427,
0.02363782934844494,
-0.04306032136082649,
-0.7234248518943787,
-1.0480778217315674,
-0.4964233934879303,
-0.10120178014039993,
-0.14783672988414764,
0.14288783073425293,
1.0847469568252563,
0.6596918702125549,
-0.9253412485122681,
-0.3875705301761627,
-0.024331890046596527,
-0.03314950317144394,
-0.16162027418613434,
-0.23102398216724396,
0.3866337537765503,
-0.49283507466316223,
-0.8754479289054871,
0.06968200951814651,
0.23217985033988953,
0.031179804354906082,
-0.1649724543094635,
-0.030243149027228355,
-0.2868419587612152,
0.3703688681125641,
0.6894678473472595,
-0.06930955499410629,
-0.8283402323722839,
-0.2757236361503601,
-0.26015135645866394,
0.05272315442562103,
-0.0005851158639416099,
0.7025510668754578,
-0.7752264738082886,
0.3001880347728729,
0.16212612390518188,
1.049120545387268,
0.1945415884256363,
-0.078774593770504,
0.5085498690605164,
-0.7899277210235596,
0.3181683421134949,
0.30102115869522095,
0.32563865184783936,
0.43912723660469055,
-0.2167626917362213,
0.37043583393096924,
-0.04215820133686066,
-0.3161937892436981,
-0.7559029459953308,
0.15134578943252563,
-0.7350676655769348,
-0.2986762523651123,
1.0597600936889648,
0.02510206587612629,
-0.05172149837017059,
-0.24125699698925018,
-0.5246673822402954,
0.35891175270080566,
-0.6321287751197815,
0.7899549007415771,
1.1146236658096313,
0.10545310378074646,
0.1572967767715454,
-0.4906884431838989,
0.479732483625412,
0.8463363647460938,
-0.5094254612922668,
-0.07277671247720718,
0.4875298738479614,
-0.03675249591469765,
0.05028204247355461,
0.2683313190937042,
0.0666903406381607,
0.1605149656534195,
-0.07388869673013687,
-0.29278525710105896,
-0.08936060965061188,
0.01184553001075983,
-0.6104373931884766,
0.23163242638111115,
0.43443551659584045,
-0.1701006442308426
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11129v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11129v1
|
Enhancing Event Causality Identification with Rationale and Structure-Aware Causal Question Answering
| 2024-03-17T07:41:58 | 2024-03-17T07:41:58 |
Baiyan Zhang, Qin Chen, Jie Zhou, Jian Jin, Liang He
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Document-level Event Causality Identification (DECI) aims to identify causal
relations between two events in documents. Recent research tends to use
pre-trained language models to generate the event causal relations. Whereas,
these methods are prone to the errors of sequential generation due to multiple
events in a document. Moreover, the potential structures such as event
coreference and related causal chain are neglected. In this paper, we propose a
multi-task learning framework to enhance event causality identification with
rationale and structure-aware causal question answering. Specifically, the DECI
task is transformed into multiple-choice question answering, and the causes and
effects of the questioned event are generated with large language models. In
addition, we generate the rationales to explain why these events have causal
relations. Moreover, we construct an event structure graph, which models the
multi-hop potential relations for causal reasoning of the current event.
Experiments on two benchmark datasets show the great advantages of our proposed
approach compared to the state-of-the-art methods. Moreover, we conduct both
quantitative and qualitative analyses, which shed light on why each component
of our approach can lead to great improvements.
|
[
-0.12359298020601273,
-1.0261716842651367,
0.9490493535995483,
-0.08294837176799774,
-0.23180410265922546,
-0.07699106633663177,
0.0007452132413163781,
-0.5772984027862549,
-0.015669669955968857,
0.2584461271762848,
-0.7531784772872925,
-0.1381078064441681,
-0.5139945149421692,
0.13097478449344635,
-0.000887514092028141,
0.7775811553001404,
-0.18783000111579895,
0.015043999999761581,
-0.3328920602798462,
-0.05162781849503517,
-0.6303533315658569,
-0.7132611870765686,
-1.1549733877182007,
-0.1641286462545395,
0.9099971055984497,
0.23712310194969177,
-0.10283482074737549,
0.5494307279586792,
0.43956151604652405,
0.295684278011322,
0.11121326684951782,
0.18398292362689972,
-0.3604324460029602,
0.14149799942970276,
-0.2156878262758255,
-0.4284926950931549,
-0.32851651310920715,
0.05156039074063301,
0.5433093309402466,
0.7931454181671143,
0.24277570843696594,
0.19374752044677734,
-0.027553770691156387,
0.298418253660202,
-0.7874823808670044,
0.4361034333705902,
-0.5794241428375244,
-0.29516318440437317,
-0.257948637008667,
-0.5318829417228699,
-0.5617091059684753,
-0.18960116803646088,
-0.1835317760705948,
-0.8029116988182068,
0.42863476276397705,
-0.10769736766815186,
0.7544881701469421,
0.27906766533851624,
-0.9111320972442627,
-0.21489599347114563,
-0.5439838767051697,
0.7210578322410583,
-0.5829397439956665,
0.43252357840538025,
0.30028051137924194,
0.10197945684194565,
-0.10879253596067429,
-0.5984372496604919,
-0.48637330532073975,
-0.03562038019299507,
-0.20133990049362183,
0.20607905089855194,
0.2652025520801544,
0.03696545958518982,
0.5764997601509094,
-0.12489966303110123,
-0.758633017539978,
0.010622389614582062,
-0.24965424835681915,
-0.18197345733642578,
0.5387992858886719,
0.2681219279766083,
0.3744729161262512,
-0.20761480927467346,
-0.29930227994918823,
0.15431396663188934,
-0.7185794115066528,
0.24106258153915405,
0.5171796679496765,
0.40663376450538635,
0.11671489477157593,
0.2727147936820984,
-0.2543507218360901,
0.6558312177658081,
0.3701428771018982,
-0.48532015085220337,
0.11928323656320572,
-0.7908722162246704,
-0.14042137563228607,
0.19588635861873627,
0.38555705547332764,
0.19402775168418884,
-0.08115363866090775,
-0.3583233952522278,
0.49388739466667175,
0.07198813557624817,
0.179000586271286,
-1.0581163167953491,
0.16250264644622803,
0.5235007405281067,
-0.4516078233718872,
-0.09454662352800369,
-0.020371897146105766,
-0.4797419309616089,
-0.5710145235061646,
-0.6432536244392395,
0.17407605051994324,
-0.4844130575656891,
-0.40636739134788513,
-0.10807261615991592,
-0.44770389795303345,
0.41495198011398315,
0.5609334707260132,
-0.5079160332679749,
-0.1334606409072876,
0.473949134349823,
0.2793178856372833,
-0.07825649529695511,
-0.3485889136791229,
-0.6913670897483826,
0.5270034670829773,
-0.2112313210964203,
0.7438785433769226,
-0.4298577606678009,
0.066866934299469,
-0.18469256162643433,
0.14599080383777618,
-0.5464196801185608,
-0.14144763350486755,
0.6818087697029114,
-0.7857185006141663,
0.24036042392253876,
-0.6660674810409546,
-0.5498392581939697,
-0.29970911145210266,
0.4618072509765625,
-0.5805823802947998,
0.6965420842170715,
-0.3575628101825714,
-1.169161081314087,
0.49916329979896545,
-0.393370658159256,
-0.6432940363883972,
0.0055089169181883335,
-0.25269508361816406,
-0.35196200013160706,
-0.07440971583127975,
0.14443400502204895,
0.34014928340911865,
-0.43100062012672424,
0.9328790903091431,
-0.4364909529685974,
0.23647348582744598,
0.1981128454208374,
-0.4943498373031616,
0.769827127456665,
0.015926755964756012,
-0.12144862115383148,
0.5423964858055115,
-1.07047700881958,
-0.35784104466438293,
0.04006181284785271,
-0.06296360492706299,
-0.4124928116798401,
0.23875409364700317,
-0.023744121193885803,
0.40779149532318115,
0.20202766358852386,
-0.6828129291534424,
-0.10084088146686554,
-0.2691446542739868,
0.1936870515346527,
0.5082999467849731,
0.5672369003295898,
0.4491588771343231,
-0.32555386424064636,
0.35827523469924927,
0.3012143671512604,
0.2575882375240326,
-0.3604753613471985,
-0.5045703649520874,
-0.24744628369808197,
-0.22737421095371246,
-0.1807251274585724,
0.710112988948822,
-0.7903262376785278,
0.2315797656774521,
0.04192258045077324,
-0.3363912105560303,
0.16872179508209229,
-0.19870051741600037,
0.2192991077899933,
1.1264516115188599,
0.4217356741428375,
0.08401954174041748,
-0.7770377397537231,
-0.6197461485862732,
-0.2784539461135864,
-0.40964365005493164,
-0.047109317034482956,
0.30433183908462524,
0.48300403356552124,
0.08652130514383316,
0.8932109475135803,
-0.5901405215263367,
-0.06714989244937897,
-0.21589058637619019,
0.3441779613494873,
0.019514799118041992,
0.5611774325370789,
0.5076162815093994,
-1.072411060333252,
-0.08153638988733292,
-0.17910291254520416,
-0.7808977961540222,
0.05464734137058258,
-0.6934735774993896,
-0.19189046323299408,
-0.13080793619155884,
0.5499454736709595,
-0.4522674083709717,
0.32455357909202576,
-0.1501445174217224,
-0.562008261680603,
0.7045738101005554,
-0.06075403466820717,
0.4064309000968933,
-1.3784794807434082,
0.36489400267601013,
0.0357520654797554,
0.26258477568626404,
-0.908909797668457,
0.02538578398525715,
0.24317342042922974,
-0.20448753237724304,
-0.49025759100914,
0.47523677349090576,
-0.22304843366146088,
0.3429531753063202,
-0.2197568416595459,
0.27804067730903625,
0.13634873926639557,
0.6953479647636414,
0.05182776227593422,
0.45706960558891296,
0.4804498851299286,
-0.6543353796005249,
-0.03367149084806442,
0.2927335500717163,
-0.11300014704465866,
0.7252621650695801,
-0.52082759141922,
-0.13130317628383636,
-0.5707846879959106,
0.38505998253822327,
-1.1113702058792114,
-0.32738029956817627,
0.25256267189979553,
-0.38691845536231995,
0.3127441108226776,
-0.2431124448776245,
-0.33232632279396057,
-0.2003999650478363,
-0.1643599569797516,
0.6749622821807861,
-0.23175625503063202,
-0.5002191066741943,
1.0486088991165161,
0.35660985112190247,
-0.10429730266332626,
-0.7356148362159729,
-0.2823452651500702,
0.01977318711578846,
-0.4413815438747406,
-0.676846981048584,
0.2957364320755005,
-0.3443100154399872,
-0.027693582698702812,
-0.19878818094730377,
-0.3697457015514374,
-0.44583114981651306,
0.3953706622123718,
0.3323725759983063,
0.36554765701293945,
-0.2058708816766739,
0.3683854937553406,
0.0969972088932991,
-0.21084174513816833,
0.25630858540534973,
-0.2366471141576767,
0.2311510294675827,
0.12178820371627808,
-0.3659117519855499,
-0.638376772403717,
0.682254433631897,
0.8035439252853394,
-0.5422673225402832,
0.720626950263977,
0.6091246008872986,
-0.5693685412406921,
0.32163798809051514,
-0.7005868554115295,
-0.2155003845691681,
-0.3382812738418579,
0.32323625683784485,
-0.6207218766212463,
-0.8327218294143677,
0.7747291922569275,
-0.1733655482530594,
-0.015213334001600742,
0.6010704636573792,
0.5327537655830383,
0.1533028781414032,
0.9142026305198669,
0.23588122427463531,
-0.015134886838495731,
0.6455954313278198,
0.017782149836421013,
0.275622695684433,
-0.8471952676773071,
-0.35378122329711914,
-0.7007968425750732,
0.11427230387926102,
-0.10059312731027603,
-0.4212377369403839,
0.2827773094177246,
0.39192065596580505,
-0.3904239237308502,
0.3959745168685913,
-0.1266728788614273,
0.3466325104236603,
0.4238406717777252,
0.11354824900627136,
0.34233415126800537,
-0.5051694512367249,
-0.02281452901661396,
0.3040231466293335,
-0.7229294180870056,
-0.21698753535747528,
0.7927508354187012,
-0.0920662060379982,
0.3980654180049896,
-0.059213489294052124,
0.6434166431427002,
-0.3009769320487976,
0.2917216420173645,
-0.3148723840713501,
0.36114031076431274,
0.48798391222953796,
-0.8815799355506897,
-0.33738973736763,
-0.5739947557449341,
-1.0201325416564941,
0.3058658242225647,
-0.21536843478679657,
-0.8028628826141357,
0.5775235891342163,
-0.04730438441038132,
-0.3006818890571594,
0.16181617975234985,
-0.7263718843460083,
1.1432607173919678,
-0.11609488725662231,
-0.3489907383918762,
-0.4288891553878784,
-0.6406129002571106,
0.40509968996047974,
-0.07917127013206482,
0.3477648198604584,
-0.19292840361595154,
0.21671950817108154,
0.9494292736053467,
-0.008324012160301208,
1.2352465391159058,
-0.029872072860598564,
-0.00006899947038618848,
0.41425758600234985,
-0.23245656490325928,
0.6809113025665283,
0.44472095370292664,
-0.1617046594619751,
-0.048734698444604874,
0.17454101145267487,
-0.3762463927268982,
-0.5799152851104736,
0.7191229462623596,
-0.5778763294219971,
-0.6346184611320496,
-0.022641757503151894,
-0.7086318135261536,
-0.2728438973426819,
0.44202378392219543,
-0.034653954207897186,
0.9554702639579773,
-0.20142394304275513,
-0.08048448711633682,
0.5331273078918457,
-0.05356540530920029,
0.6991457343101501,
0.6750571727752686,
0.4822300970554352,
-0.4590998888015747,
0.7706629037857056,
0.05326531082391739,
-0.059585005044937134,
0.5471298098564148,
0.3394578695297241,
-0.30644485354423523,
-0.3499714732170105,
-0.5013477802276611,
0.3338758647441864,
-0.767504096031189,
-0.23482628166675568,
-0.9787653088569641,
0.13050509989261627,
-0.5257645845413208,
-0.28025195002555847,
0.04191754758358002,
-0.43218907713890076,
-0.4358740448951721,
-0.33809030055999756,
0.11179843544960022,
0.041313495486974716,
0.18669547140598297,
-0.06016187742352486,
-0.640286922454834,
0.5695532560348511,
0.3424619436264038,
0.13218647241592407,
0.2654474973678589,
-0.2358814775943756,
-0.0592728890478611,
-0.1891890913248062,
-0.2659556269645691,
-1.278577208518982,
-0.016707366332411766,
0.017405066639184952,
0.8050923347473145,
0.644166886806488,
0.4470074474811554,
0.757672905921936,
-0.6422617435455322,
0.504369854927063,
0.37589189410209656,
-0.7480416893959045,
0.7492281198501587,
-0.32435861229896545,
0.15435220301151276,
0.6018825769424438,
0.7196692824363708,
-0.3391386866569519,
-0.6216435432434082,
-0.9071279764175415,
-0.7549644708633423,
0.6364960074424744,
0.22164660692214966,
-0.35978034138679504,
-0.2592286765575409,
0.5302098989486694,
-0.08471998572349548,
0.22006426751613617,
-0.5615752339363098,
-0.33552053570747375,
0.05132712051272392,
-0.05980132147669792,
0.05199820175766945,
-0.2956724464893341,
-0.3107897639274597,
-0.10571827739477158,
0.6578419804573059,
-0.3624486029148102,
-0.08858425170183182,
0.3519955575466156,
-0.1831359565258026,
-0.175649493932724,
0.4071667790412903,
0.5780256986618042,
0.9493245482444763,
-0.11728159338235855,
0.28443947434425354,
0.30241119861602783,
-0.18563848733901978,
0.028266679495573044,
0.4293399751186371,
-0.1822575479745865,
-0.4196006655693054,
0.6268278360366821,
0.7676063179969788,
0.21594208478927612,
-0.6447173953056335,
0.47882869839668274,
-0.03436572849750519,
-0.1465538591146469,
-0.05739743262529373,
-0.15791215002536774,
0.07486999779939651,
0.3707066774368286,
0.5071313381195068,
-0.020128026604652405,
0.1735079437494278,
-0.47741976380348206,
0.3338378667831421,
0.4388011395931244,
-0.3812619149684906,
-0.3775729537010193,
0.9570616483688354,
0.2598347067832947,
0.061595380306243896,
0.2970432639122009,
-0.10494600236415863,
-0.5000481009483337,
0.9950742125511169,
0.5864683389663696,
0.8614241480827332,
-0.22879645228385925,
0.21635128557682037,
0.8960482478141785,
0.4680790901184082,
0.3573383092880249,
0.4545214772224426,
-0.16663604974746704,
-0.8689196109771729,
-0.8808802366256714,
-0.4076674282550812,
-0.2810690999031067,
0.20737633109092712,
-0.5502544045448303,
-0.0691700130701065,
0.00674004340544343,
-0.08346409350633621,
0.19473841786384583,
0.0712687149643898,
-0.48276498913764954,
0.19364549219608307,
0.17812691628932953,
0.4878210127353668,
-1.2795053720474243,
0.7773071527481079,
0.6057183146476746,
-0.804660975933075,
-0.7217631936073303,
-0.18565896153450012,
-0.14503102004528046,
-0.08722114562988281,
0.6497976183891296,
0.16016051173210144,
0.25115054845809937,
0.06822232156991959,
-0.03496886044740677,
-1.0368801355361938,
1.0680105686187744,
0.2990240156650543,
-0.15786296129226685,
-0.00967948418110609,
-0.11203652620315552,
0.34602102637290955,
-0.34116557240486145,
0.3626854717731476,
0.23020626604557037,
0.6080347895622253,
0.11026862263679504,
-0.4947153329849243,
0.5036465525627136,
0.07114040851593018,
-0.20219022035598755,
0.28468137979507446,
-0.2604086399078369,
0.4370988607406616,
-0.312098890542984,
-0.5081974267959595,
-0.3732883632183075,
0.7339260578155518,
0.25664255023002625,
0.7172380685806274,
0.5751374363899231,
0.3284238576889038,
1.1737110614776611,
0.023656561970710754,
1.0284192562103271,
-0.6106588840484619,
0.1106606274843216,
1.2470461130142212,
-0.3039381206035614,
0.4758055508136749,
0.5121564865112305,
0.21469655632972717,
0.3762233853340149,
0.5101431012153625,
0.37959837913513184,
0.33770081400871277,
-0.05784058943390846,
-0.27253299951553345,
-0.6940364241600037,
-0.19568543136119843,
-0.13651339709758759,
-0.042917490005493164,
0.29002246260643005,
0.08938737213611603,
-0.700149416923523,
0.3065602481365204,
-0.13137009739875793,
-0.2566351592540741,
-0.10026685148477554,
0.7008939385414124,
-0.161418616771698,
-0.608063817024231,
0.19856856763362885,
0.042777080088853836,
-0.012180169112980366,
-0.7286360263824463,
0.08978499472141266,
0.023169562220573425,
-0.0399765819311142,
-0.014593039639294147,
-0.18655842542648315,
0.5181301236152649,
-0.3208792805671692,
-0.5654585361480713,
-0.22066748142242432,
0.9627593159675598,
-0.5782480239868164,
-0.3946276307106018,
0.12380310893058777,
0.6567534804344177,
-0.37680715322494507,
-0.23524242639541626,
-0.5675399899482727,
-0.11972228437662125,
-0.3874918520450592,
-0.19849766790866852,
0.4402230679988861,
0.5110521912574768,
-0.40396302938461304,
0.42989787459373474,
0.9216005206108093,
-0.4169304370880127,
-0.1115909293293953,
0.14912909269332886,
0.6854196786880493,
-0.49870458245277405,
-0.5817276835441589,
-0.7003005146980286,
0.42518511414527893,
-0.2917865812778473,
-0.39997705817222595,
0.8134743571281433,
0.643147349357605,
0.49761897325515747,
-0.08742674440145493,
0.42997753620147705,
-0.1359405815601349,
0.20704586803913116,
-0.27494141459465027,
0.3321368396282196,
-0.41057687997817993,
-0.10090194642543793,
-0.30604180693626404,
-0.34408485889434814,
-0.41622209548950195,
0.057174839079380035,
-0.5045100450515747,
-0.44497954845428467,
1.1038904190063477,
0.7878659963607788,
0.13381437957286835,
0.1201295480132103,
0.29353630542755127,
0.067936472594738,
0.4845393896102905,
0.6530959606170654,
0.7646192312240601,
-0.42948511242866516,
0.4876847267150879,
-0.016216320917010307,
-0.42669498920440674,
0.03907870873808861,
-0.9575878381729126,
-0.9820927381515503,
-0.9695234298706055,
-0.8638117909431458,
0.007142098154872656,
-0.0752788707613945,
0.48630794882774353,
0.6323151588439941,
-0.8614336848258972,
0.03789414092898369,
-0.2796865701675415,
0.5156566500663757,
-0.5620144009590149,
-0.2545802891254425,
0.8070561289787292,
-0.7337721586227417,
-0.428213506937027,
0.6955235600471497,
0.3039385676383972,
-0.40061652660369873,
0.5231518149375916,
0.4547122120857239,
-0.5786285400390625,
0.2418128401041031,
0.902975857257843,
0.2831689417362213,
-0.5412635803222656,
-0.5209870934486389,
-0.15084263682365417,
0.1106807067990303,
-0.21463245153427124,
1.2790857553482056,
-0.5813016891479492,
0.22474037110805511,
0.6661509871482849,
0.8759366869926453,
0.34177085757255554,
0.037053126841783524,
0.3674558401107788,
-0.7099015116691589,
0.09204050898551941,
-0.0595453605055809,
0.4523026943206787,
-0.059947796165943146,
-0.6248348355293274,
0.3121182918548584,
0.6074903607368469,
-0.32792937755584717,
-0.5594955682754517,
0.4707251489162445,
-1.318358063697815,
-0.5143659114837646,
0.9532095193862915,
0.07045479118824005,
-0.1792851984500885,
-0.5895422101020813,
-0.21546760201454163,
0.48260658979415894,
0.053816501051187515,
0.55836021900177,
0.4854568839073181,
-0.3368014097213745,
0.030071303248405457,
-0.2712036669254303,
0.3182356059551239,
0.07392068952322006,
-1.0413259267807007,
0.23690380156040192,
0.6959375143051147,
0.11328002065420151,
0.29063087701797485,
0.7082285284996033,
-0.01426895335316658,
0.34073105454444885,
-0.13106007874011993,
0.008125784806907177,
-0.21803033351898193,
-0.5926711559295654,
-0.05838664248585701,
0.6810752749443054,
-0.2922529876232147,
-0.13528908789157867
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11128v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11128v2
|
Beyond Static Evaluation: A Dynamic Approach to Assessing AI Assistants' API Invocation Capabilities
| 2024-03-17T07:34:12 | 2024-03-27T15:22:53 |
Honglin Mu, Yang Xu, Yunlong Feng, Xiaofeng Han, Yitong Li, Yutai Hou, Wanxiang Che
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
With the rise of Large Language Models (LLMs), AI assistants' ability to
utilize tools, especially through API calls, has advanced notably. This
progress has necessitated more accurate evaluation methods. Many existing
studies adopt static evaluation, where they assess AI assistants' API call
based on pre-defined dialogue histories. However, such evaluation method can be
misleading, as an AI assistant might fail in generating API calls from
preceding human interaction in real cases. Instead of the resource-intensive
method of direct human-machine interactions, we propose Automated Dynamic
Evaluation (AutoDE) to assess an assistant's API call capability without human
involvement. In our framework, we endeavor to closely mirror genuine human
conversation patterns in human-machine interactions, using a LLM-based user
agent, equipped with a user script to ensure human alignment. Experimental
results highlight that AutoDE uncovers errors overlooked by static evaluations,
aligning more closely with human assessment. Testing four AI assistants using
our crafted benchmark, our method further mirrored human evaluation compared to
conventional static evaluations.
|
[
-0.34824803471565247,
-0.6864030361175537,
0.5258508324623108,
0.07654675841331482,
-0.0833488330245018,
0.7244656682014465,
-0.25724270939826965,
-0.5933728814125061,
0.09045728296041489,
0.13901136815547943,
-0.8188662528991699,
-0.184734508395195,
-0.35094505548477173,
0.4744097888469696,
-0.5005691647529602,
0.3277527987957001,
-0.21579013764858246,
-0.06687618046998978,
-0.6403944492340088,
-0.23584304749965668,
-0.7945614457130432,
-0.14191493391990662,
-0.5943989753723145,
-0.40072911977767944,
-0.10354749858379364,
0.19286927580833435,
0.8226145505905151,
0.6429426670074463,
0.37741902470588684,
0.5792967677116394,
0.1721271127462387,
0.6233371496200562,
-0.04555637389421463,
0.13314683735370636,
0.03516602888703346,
-0.43686971068382263,
-0.6369457244873047,
0.18362770974636078,
0.4569966197013855,
0.4808497428894043,
0.08993352949619293,
0.44122323393821716,
0.14984719455242157,
0.3872058689594269,
-0.5105839967727661,
0.23909689486026764,
-0.6156954765319824,
0.03286462649703026,
0.01556691899895668,
-0.20178863406181335,
-0.18955624103546143,
-0.3396012783050537,
0.4893718957901001,
-0.34783706068992615,
-0.36292895674705505,
-0.1473388820886612,
0.9191935658454895,
0.9417260885238647,
-0.28094053268432617,
-0.4382794201374054,
-0.8574204444885254,
0.6698383688926697,
-0.6615361571311951,
0.2935231029987335,
0.3810115158557892,
0.3908565640449524,
-0.2976246774196625,
-0.5839003324508667,
-0.6116238832473755,
-0.9684171676635742,
-0.058137353509664536,
-0.10909564793109894,
-0.20700357854366302,
-0.007168400567024946,
0.17731726169586182,
0.2007276564836502,
-0.20657077431678772,
0.048778217285871506,
0.052931658923625946,
-0.06063074618577957,
0.7208167314529419,
0.4459417760372162,
0.6584216952323914,
0.06746386736631393,
-0.31747472286224365,
-0.12528720498085022,
-0.3087492883205414,
0.04975100979208946,
0.4844914674758911,
0.12909308075904846,
-0.2627357840538025,
0.3424140214920044,
-0.002874797210097313,
0.5481107831001282,
0.35568663477897644,
0.08332641422748566,
0.2729136347770691,
-0.3724258840084076,
-0.20951628684997559,
-0.19198526442050934,
0.7877211570739746,
0.33034220337867737,
0.3225646913051605,
-0.4418448805809021,
-0.11219392716884613,
-0.07672353833913803,
0.7467369437217712,
-0.41399049758911133,
0.0805417001247406,
0.39934810996055603,
-0.5404592156410217,
-0.3374815285205841,
0.10697511583566666,
-0.9191877245903015,
-0.5749910473823547,
-0.5529744625091553,
0.31096789240837097,
-0.19040003418922424,
-0.27203798294067383,
-0.39318451285362244,
0.11220847070217133,
0.28878071904182434,
0.24863162636756897,
-0.4422805607318878,
0.6786300539970398,
0.6359659433364868,
0.6562319993972778,
-0.4820612370967865,
-0.6329066157341003,
-0.39950576424598694,
-0.2947441339492798,
-0.3687671422958374,
0.8827519416809082,
-0.4956464171409607,
-0.4549637734889984,
-0.07850059866905212,
-0.20210926234722137,
0.1810409277677536,
-0.747284471988678,
0.42089810967445374,
-0.4309644401073456,
-0.24493643641471863,
0.040581099689006805,
-0.31213152408599854,
-0.049324944615364075,
0.158648282289505,
-0.377580851316452,
0.9435436129570007,
0.20060813426971436,
-0.1452445685863495,
0.5302132368087769,
-1.0780069828033447,
-0.2795005440711975,
0.27953100204467773,
-0.36549112200737,
-0.19189254939556122,
-0.06770102679729462,
0.14213721454143524,
0.025821605697274208,
-0.36478710174560547,
0.04816818982362747,
-0.4006060063838959,
-0.48698410391807556,
0.45029792189598083,
-0.8560127019882202,
0.8225923776626587,
0.0017582593718543649,
-0.8443158268928528,
0.3267717957496643,
-0.8967492580413818,
0.0811830684542656,
-0.06764722615480423,
-0.1979464292526245,
-0.19593079388141632,
0.1661561131477356,
-0.373178094625473,
-0.1439054012298584,
0.41262149810791016,
-0.23638536036014557,
0.15201665461063385,
-0.5397634506225586,
0.15112513303756714,
0.8655117750167847,
-0.2807627320289612,
0.47319960594177246,
-0.08587765693664551,
0.7080255746841431,
-0.9124510884284973,
0.31968608498573303,
-0.09054974466562271,
-0.20615731179714203,
-0.6667247414588928,
-0.43930989503860474,
0.3248791992664337,
0.6649554371833801,
-0.42987629771232605,
1.0291640758514404,
-0.24339963495731354,
-0.5779038667678833,
-0.6513535380363464,
0.5413903594017029,
0.6542036533355713,
0.495958149433136,
0.08743008226156235,
-0.4276736080646515,
-0.48978275060653687,
-0.7328020930290222,
-0.19611018896102905,
-0.507817804813385,
-0.1464046835899353,
0.6206265091896057,
0.08563673496246338,
-0.6169623732566833,
1.0005202293395996,
0.025924324989318848,
0.008947915397584438,
0.11009564250707626,
0.5733315348625183,
0.02607034519314766,
0.2068469375371933,
0.4814603626728058,
-0.36515653133392334,
-0.4244496822357178,
-0.2872196137905121,
-0.8193748593330383,
-0.617519736289978,
-0.16802597045898438,
-0.14053355157375336,
0.18930819630622864,
0.5332714915275574,
-0.48117879033088684,
0.63933265209198,
0.3762817680835724,
-0.2614278197288513,
0.532116711139679,
-0.28519484400749207,
0.20086035132408142,
-0.5008653998374939,
-0.033888183534145355,
-0.2778891921043396,
-0.2858734726905823,
-0.25333133339881897,
-0.06331761926412582,
-0.08179328590631485,
-0.2765332758426666,
-0.39200398325920105,
0.7950100898742676,
-0.7899529933929443,
-0.46473053097724915,
-0.5088967680931091,
-0.059297844767570496,
-0.2113342136144638,
0.21843130886554718,
-0.32347214221954346,
1.0074928998947144,
0.434271901845932,
-0.5210961103439331,
0.6687441468238831,
0.1554948389530182,
-0.3486838638782501,
0.533190906047821,
-0.7008872628211975,
0.4917919337749481,
0.3943517804145813,
0.3292221128940582,
-1.3810735940933228,
-0.09556322544813156,
0.1410849541425705,
-0.26978620886802673,
0.32847368717193604,
-0.12775173783302307,
-0.6749468445777893,
-0.50738924741745,
-0.578998863697052,
0.4777599573135376,
0.44940561056137085,
-0.49419382214546204,
0.9337815642356873,
0.3751932978630066,
-0.18879207968711853,
-0.38541853427886963,
-0.340783029794693,
0.3616501986980438,
-0.2787444591522217,
-0.6658897995948792,
0.028502896428108215,
-0.21136201918125153,
-0.5298092365264893,
-0.06585738062858582,
-0.07290735840797424,
-0.059418294578790665,
0.4953041970729828,
0.5022895336151123,
0.463633269071579,
0.0022124159149825573,
-0.1455763578414917,
-0.12031012028455734,
-0.08050572872161865,
0.21327392756938934,
0.2737632393836975,
0.8420300483703613,
-0.42470744252204895,
-0.7760552763938904,
-1.2201881408691406,
-0.0841178297996521,
1.0323127508163452,
-0.18491114675998688,
0.06223883107304573,
0.4512600600719452,
-0.1708853840827942,
0.186477929353714,
-0.5987145900726318,
-0.20238718390464783,
-0.5582178235054016,
0.0720217227935791,
-0.2793004810810089,
-0.07437314093112946,
0.5760086178779602,
-0.3224199414253235,
0.1387646645307541,
0.2290918081998825,
0.7106307744979858,
-0.1284923255443573,
1.0444934368133545,
0.33414211869239807,
-0.0423918217420578,
0.4875462055206299,
-0.1342867910861969,
-0.03402461111545563,
-0.7829869985580444,
0.03789179027080536,
-0.3041911721229553,
-0.3734336197376251,
-0.5039219856262207,
-0.04205026477575302,
0.5042263269424438,
-0.42924386262893677,
-0.3175027668476105,
0.2666878402233124,
-0.44761529564857483,
0.28433454036712646,
0.4372707009315491,
-0.09106765687465668,
0.006015000864863396,
-0.15076233446598053,
0.24175430834293365,
0.13590790331363678,
-0.07041483372449875,
-0.9230483770370483,
1.1799430847167969,
0.573602557182312,
0.707709014415741,
-0.007463059388101101,
0.46033185720443726,
0.6805976033210754,
0.4051070809364319,
-0.7624754905700684,
0.6868691444396973,
0.1691974252462387,
-0.12488310039043427,
-0.5280561447143555,
-0.04896991699934006,
-0.9007724523544312,
0.0449543222784996,
-0.22622524201869965,
-0.9007856845855713,
0.003224573563784361,
0.14043542742729187,
-0.8196167349815369,
-0.0692075714468956,
-0.936004102230072,
0.4778074324131012,
-0.7142395377159119,
-0.379254549741745,
-0.19163061678409576,
-0.46202734112739563,
0.2126857042312622,
-0.009061167016625404,
-0.008888553828001022,
-0.2754640579223633,
-0.2226993590593338,
0.4692862331867218,
-0.6248916983604431,
0.9528626203536987,
-0.140241339802742,
-0.3031891882419586,
0.3030608296394348,
0.2468138039112091,
0.4345569610595703,
0.02467290125787258,
-0.27107247710227966,
0.23902907967567444,
-0.07141431421041489,
-0.12231072783470154,
-0.7865232229232788,
0.5747290253639221,
-0.9096882939338684,
-0.6417547464370728,
-0.29918110370635986,
-0.5264605283737183,
-0.4331643581390381,
0.12308545410633087,
-0.2010624259710312,
0.3612224757671356,
-0.24744734168052673,
-0.2349478155374527,
-0.06265021860599518,
-0.2648060619831085,
0.4467541575431824,
0.5475547313690186,
0.08649291098117828,
-0.19515758752822876,
0.5761578679084778,
-0.034512922167778015,
0.023766513913869858,
-0.1790042668581009,
0.30612021684646606,
-0.5429414510726929,
-0.3215896785259247,
-0.9306403994560242,
0.010314380750060081,
-0.3821120262145996,
-0.051932405680418015,
-0.4499976336956024,
0.1480425000190735,
-0.3161614239215851,
-0.10509299486875534,
-0.5485105514526367,
0.0806114673614502,
-0.2816920876502991,
0.2003069669008255,
0.1808365434408188,
0.5745683312416077,
0.11563912779092789,
0.1268586367368698,
-0.7338188290596008,
0.28418081998825073,
0.48476874828338623,
0.3475067615509033,
0.21351231634616852,
-0.38384270668029785,
0.18663327395915985,
0.00988499354571104,
-0.341300904750824,
-0.7448026537895203,
0.2169100046157837,
-0.016968771815299988,
0.7657687664031982,
0.4799025356769562,
0.03740204870700836,
0.8903730511665344,
-0.7482784986495972,
0.9432950615882874,
-0.27843865752220154,
-1.1160142421722412,
0.5124830603599548,
-0.05299046263098717,
0.0708584189414978,
0.8022671937942505,
0.0014198041753843427,
0.1345617175102234,
-0.35760918259620667,
-0.6202359199523926,
-0.9599767923355103,
0.6378589272499084,
0.06085658445954323,
0.4505280554294586,
0.1613689661026001,
0.4040580689907074,
-0.021587930619716644,
0.1605127602815628,
-0.06572883576154709,
-0.20687520503997803,
0.15089623630046844,
-0.04670252278447151,
0.41946232318878174,
-0.12853576242923737,
-0.2761525511741638,
-0.16784901916980743,
0.163945272564888,
-0.07578270137310028,
0.5553328990936279,
-0.04859553650021553,
-0.08800482004880905,
-0.2613373100757599,
0.02431248128414154,
0.6274346709251404,
1.1152830123901367,
-0.4328813850879669,
-0.09278040379285812,
0.5641631484031677,
-0.12848961353302002,
0.13831429183483124,
0.24686197936534882,
0.15788151323795319,
-0.07141381502151489,
0.5710360407829285,
0.47139373421669006,
0.10132098197937012,
-1.098166823387146,
0.4788613021373749,
-0.3666699230670929,
0.30284351110458374,
-0.6923006772994995,
0.10663557797670364,
-0.34697723388671875,
0.3454049825668335,
0.3405218720436096,
-0.09699106216430664,
0.27725791931152344,
-0.8568241000175476,
0.3810102939605713,
0.5745254158973694,
-0.2745337188243866,
-0.27159586548805237,
0.4043295681476593,
0.4701733887195587,
-0.8376739025115967,
0.5844560265541077,
-0.27270835638046265,
-0.3962849974632263,
0.8079764246940613,
0.2119942605495453,
1.3202792406082153,
-0.2749420702457428,
-0.16156844794750214,
-0.13570214807987213,
0.04014578089118004,
0.19980230927467346,
0.1934889703989029,
-0.2418106347322464,
-0.4765303432941437,
-0.3112664222717285,
-0.3628986179828644,
-0.7236973643302917,
0.1305326521396637,
-0.4403405785560608,
0.4133037030696869,
-0.5839714407920837,
-0.19569848477840424,
-0.04853060841560364,
0.12833645939826965,
-0.6152204871177673,
-0.17090392112731934,
0.19951771199703217,
0.7776954174041748,
-0.5752729773521423,
0.47874751687049866,
0.8049954175949097,
-0.32528918981552124,
-0.5739776492118835,
0.5009760856628418,
0.3555874824523926,
-0.8265613913536072,
0.8796674609184265,
-0.02089371532201767,
-0.6184335350990295,
-0.3849853277206421,
-0.4259791672229767,
-0.6626601219177246,
1.1044230461120605,
0.37616437673568726,
-0.14078542590141296,
0.2841303050518036,
-0.006598657462745905,
0.8847455382347107,
-0.4352937638759613,
0.9305155873298645,
0.5447373390197754,
0.5858154892921448,
-0.2509850859642029,
-1.3957327604293823,
0.11115848273038864,
-0.3364616632461548,
-0.02807925082743168,
-0.2602822482585907,
-0.8842998743057251,
0.5331689715385437,
0.2732967138290405,
-0.2673346996307373,
0.3254535496234894,
0.6955357193946838,
0.004300849512219429,
0.3242352306842804,
0.9480364322662354,
0.1633003056049347,
0.8885083198547363,
0.34466996788978577,
1.303384780883789,
-0.5279281735420227,
-0.026130447164177895,
1.1307811737060547,
-0.6527647972106934,
0.6836223602294922,
0.24572178721427917,
-0.25479403138160706,
0.5659616589546204,
0.514382541179657,
-0.10490504652261734,
0.3313369154930115,
0.40830090641975403,
-0.19762016832828522,
0.04983518645167351,
-0.059921760112047195,
0.05525490641593933,
0.8458890914916992,
0.22145937383174896,
-0.060114406049251556,
-0.35108307003974915,
-0.1546388417482376,
-0.03861382231116295,
0.33058619499206543,
-0.049154579639434814,
0.9153342843055725,
-0.2952633500099182,
-0.7997785210609436,
0.9419073462486267,
-0.1382589340209961,
0.6896109580993652,
-0.2617029845714569,
-0.23322844505310059,
-0.12734316289424896,
0.13885998725891113,
-0.05430365726351738,
-0.593438982963562,
0.5210230350494385,
0.4214385747909546,
0.17547449469566345,
-0.2098340541124344,
0.6797237992286682,
0.013192232698202133,
-0.22779174149036407,
0.42502084374427795,
0.4133571684360504,
0.38538238406181335,
0.2360004037618637,
-0.9648872017860413,
0.2946653962135315,
-0.2515670955181122,
0.1256198137998581,
0.16136422753334045,
0.23768706619739532,
-0.27818524837493896,
0.8376227617263794,
0.5413482189178467,
-0.015799997374415398,
-0.060768526047468185,
0.07420843839645386,
0.6582983136177063,
-0.16019515693187714,
-0.13129490613937378,
-1.124570608139038,
0.38659149408340454,
-0.13532958924770355,
-0.2772890329360962,
0.558793842792511,
0.4025624394416809,
0.364305704832077,
0.09138881415128708,
0.7737168073654175,
0.08831518888473511,
0.474489688873291,
-0.2934703826904297,
0.6768839359283447,
-0.483295738697052,
0.5384517908096313,
-0.4220764935016632,
-0.6097304821014404,
0.008186794817447662,
0.5671727061271667,
-0.29468148946762085,
0.022499825805425644,
0.27987903356552124,
0.7232928276062012,
-0.1944372057914734,
-0.099583700299263,
0.17987021803855896,
0.15902955830097198,
0.4790705442428589,
-0.007270485162734985,
1.3122061491012573,
-0.13961222767829895,
0.5805054306983948,
0.0032928111031651497,
-0.7122294306755066,
-0.29662883281707764,
-0.948556125164032,
-0.9442806839942932,
-0.3298179507255554,
-0.2492695152759552,
-0.33822694420814514,
0.15844804048538208,
1.4323952198028564,
0.6898334622383118,
-0.530330240726471,
-0.4574280381202698,
0.045244619250297546,
-0.07687996327877045,
-0.3215749263763428,
-0.23808008432388306,
0.5053098797798157,
-0.6555604934692383,
-1.1658388376235962,
0.8357470035552979,
0.24703074991703033,
-0.024838576093316078,
-0.624595046043396,
0.018770083785057068,
-0.027665266767144203,
0.2420954406261444,
0.39424851536750793,
0.49562832713127136,
-0.7647236585617065,
-0.3213409185409546,
-0.20159025490283966,
0.029426606371998787,
-0.023882977664470673,
0.6769240498542786,
-0.8465908169746399,
0.4861169755458832,
0.4444679617881775,
1.1290959119796753,
-0.11845851689577103,
0.31429991126060486,
0.8829058408737183,
-0.5683400630950928,
0.1518067717552185,
0.060583606362342834,
0.09618193656206131,
0.20956586301326752,
-0.5466395020484924,
0.4711056053638458,
-0.05839953199028969,
-0.5758071541786194,
-0.9738584160804749,
0.03638770803809166,
-0.7858850955963135,
-0.01822984591126442,
1.105272889137268,
-0.38542744517326355,
-0.1459237039089203,
-0.3661683201789856,
-0.3152065575122833,
0.26608890295028687,
-0.5022956132888794,
1.2024388313293457,
0.6528041958808899,
-0.6287433505058289,
0.09773960709571838,
-0.594399631023407,
0.5785439014434814,
0.439534991979599,
-0.9588178992271423,
0.13538862764835358,
0.33034130930900574,
0.048828478902578354,
0.559747576713562,
0.48754262924194336,
-0.12003882974386215,
0.20809178054332733,
-0.3021274507045746,
-0.08482535928487778,
-0.02308952622115612,
-0.19055937230587006,
-0.39729171991348267,
-0.20496052503585815,
0.2485337108373642,
-0.5258447527885437
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11124v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11124v2
|
Scaling Data Diversity for Fine-Tuning Language Models in Human Alignment
| 2024-03-17T07:08:55 | 2024-03-30T16:48:16 |
Feifan Song, Bowen Yu, Hao Lang, Haiyang Yu, Fei Huang, Houfeng Wang, Yongbin Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Alignment with human preference prevents large language models (LLMs) from
generating misleading or toxic content while requiring high-cost human
feedback. Assuming resources of human annotation are limited, there are two
different ways of allocating considered: more diverse PROMPTS or more diverse
RESPONSES to be labeled. Nonetheless, a straightforward comparison between
their impact is absent. In this work, we first control the diversity of both
sides according to the number of samples for fine-tuning, which can directly
reflect their influence. We find that instead of numerous prompts, more
responses but fewer prompts better trigger LLMs for human alignment.
Additionally, the concept of diversity for prompts can be more complex than
responses that are typically quantified by single digits. Consequently, a new
formulation of prompt diversity is proposed, further implying a linear
correlation with the final performance of LLMs after fine-tuning. We also
leverage it on data augmentation and conduct experiments to show its effect on
different algorithms.
|
[
-0.6544497013092041,
-0.563633382320404,
0.20922408998012543,
0.2893069386482239,
-0.16037896275520325,
0.2573567032814026,
-0.663201630115509,
-0.5688394904136658,
0.10746258497238159,
0.49342191219329834,
-0.584800660610199,
-0.30775830149650574,
-0.5866613984107971,
0.39240366220474243,
-0.040258802473545074,
1.0900377035140991,
0.2380220890045166,
0.05452829971909523,
-0.09953295439481735,
-0.5536652207374573,
-0.5927131175994873,
-0.3554355204105377,
-0.5935382843017578,
-0.2279556691646576,
0.9191536903381348,
0.8629640340805054,
1.2209949493408203,
1.057422399520874,
0.49613717198371887,
0.2745465040206909,
-0.3828990161418915,
0.3410336375236511,
-0.5615363717079163,
0.13715025782585144,
-0.3300545811653137,
-0.5156956911087036,
-0.3095814287662506,
-0.1362830102443695,
0.7353559732437134,
0.992523729801178,
0.02295811101794243,
0.19519302248954773,
0.1482231467962265,
0.737912654876709,
-0.46753183007240295,
-0.36256957054138184,
-0.5915203094482422,
-0.26291272044181824,
-0.3074207007884979,
0.0187928918749094,
-0.21316403150558472,
-0.3972548246383667,
0.17969821393489838,
-0.42906874418258667,
0.11410655081272125,
0.22943200170993805,
0.7119565606117249,
0.28053149580955505,
-0.3787916898727417,
-0.15102101862430573,
-0.7965987920761108,
1.0533055067062378,
-0.7014897465705872,
0.30012333393096924,
0.20438005030155182,
0.21763627231121063,
-0.15700922906398773,
-0.026284705847501755,
-0.4312138557434082,
-0.0602143257856369,
0.06890881061553955,
-0.3419049084186554,
-0.037196964025497437,
-0.04920075833797455,
0.31378424167633057,
0.2858198583126068,
-0.4301348328590393,
0.7770602107048035,
-0.3368985056877136,
-0.35010361671447754,
0.8337489366531372,
0.4730576276779175,
0.476880818605423,
0.18016771972179413,
0.04270010441541672,
-0.34138205647468567,
-0.7267733812332153,
0.18069419264793396,
0.6715425252914429,
0.8339918851852417,
-0.0579565055668354,
0.5445064902305603,
-0.44870978593826294,
0.8528506755828857,
0.23921379446983337,
-0.1573212891817093,
0.33069872856140137,
-0.4333381652832031,
-0.027843670919537544,
-0.10730193555355072,
0.7589191198348999,
0.517617404460907,
0.42139932513237,
-0.03801284357905388,
-0.13989710807800293,
-0.0032520226668566465,
0.15913192927837372,
-0.7453332543373108,
0.10005059093236923,
0.009912381879985332,
-0.34449243545532227,
-0.300705224275589,
-0.11392708122730255,
-0.9486039876937866,
-0.7531445622444153,
-0.6019946336746216,
0.06458420306444168,
-0.1691310852766037,
-0.07905177026987076,
0.2581430673599243,
0.1554228663444519,
0.07412809878587723,
0.44905340671539307,
-1.3299094438552856,
0.2653992772102356,
0.7112458944320679,
0.6714568138122559,
-0.43321648240089417,
-0.3421420156955719,
-0.4603140950202942,
-0.35405677556991577,
-0.21272866427898407,
0.6868504285812378,
-0.8273838758468628,
-0.3682020902633667,
-0.04634274169802666,
-0.2430860847234726,
0.441995769739151,
-0.7538985013961792,
0.6902918219566345,
-0.4400191307067871,
0.37619924545288086,
-0.7073594331741333,
-0.5046178102493286,
0.11025699973106384,
-0.01859220117330551,
-0.7464403510093689,
0.8700681924819946,
0.24296344816684723,
-0.6964596509933472,
0.6126638054847717,
-0.42792466282844543,
-0.4414375424385071,
0.026933804154396057,
-0.3001154661178589,
-0.4563051760196686,
0.04334868863224983,
0.4233342707157135,
0.1961245983839035,
-0.3976859748363495,
0.25569775700569153,
-0.585181713104248,
-0.2023821622133255,
0.300920695066452,
-0.22006532549858093,
0.7960281372070312,
0.3939897119998932,
-0.09831922501325607,
0.47085121273994446,
-0.6669782400131226,
-0.2096971571445465,
-0.17058195173740387,
-0.5409284234046936,
-0.31096377968788147,
-0.07647766172885895,
0.017976082861423492,
0.16524381935596466,
0.16131679713726044,
-0.45965254306793213,
0.4817501902580261,
-0.38324424624443054,
0.2700619697570801,
0.7771781086921692,
-0.2870429754257202,
0.8832670450210571,
-0.6479768753051758,
0.5154032707214355,
-0.03475440666079521,
0.08949119597673416,
-0.10342442989349365,
-0.6237847208976746,
-0.5903589725494385,
-0.34836775064468384,
0.3284206688404083,
0.40100494027137756,
-0.20502257347106934,
0.6560456156730652,
-0.32936814427375793,
-0.459694504737854,
-0.9700681567192078,
0.4142165780067444,
0.052135907113552094,
0.44251084327697754,
0.3276160955429077,
-0.3120587170124054,
-0.623593807220459,
-1.0334744453430176,
-0.5788201689720154,
-0.10927905887365341,
-0.25985780358314514,
0.5423322916030884,
0.11287982016801834,
-0.2562788724899292,
1.2028303146362305,
-0.2799474000930786,
-0.02577979490160942,
-0.21558918058872223,
0.1495986133813858,
0.22779031097888947,
0.5153989195823669,
0.5650439262390137,
-0.605042040348053,
-0.47789284586906433,
-0.008359583094716072,
-0.1988542079925537,
-0.46872568130493164,
-0.25761452317237854,
-0.1444149762392044,
0.03454267233610153,
0.19424203038215637,
-0.31791719794273376,
-0.0027092790696769953,
0.5211626291275024,
-0.3612646460533142,
0.3993329107761383,
0.034494899213314056,
0.12390779703855515,
-1.0679172277450562,
-0.22075630724430084,
0.048993777483701706,
-0.06104151904582977,
-0.6509153842926025,
-0.13407042622566223,
0.18154072761535645,
0.15179134905338287,
-0.11907622218132019,
0.7072180509567261,
-0.33604490756988525,
0.06692520529031754,
-0.32212480902671814,
0.06683443486690521,
-0.05487510561943054,
0.2143004983663559,
-0.30981507897377014,
0.6619274616241455,
0.48319488763809204,
-0.5024319887161255,
0.32069164514541626,
0.20272429287433624,
-0.310585618019104,
0.5982599258422852,
-0.5547767281532288,
0.022782649844884872,
-0.3709234595298767,
0.19492840766906738,
-1.1173932552337646,
-0.3844680190086365,
-0.03613000735640526,
-0.3856422007083893,
0.25542688369750977,
0.0017652878304943442,
-0.5832579135894775,
-0.24208964407444,
-0.412331759929657,
0.5153809189796448,
0.5544125437736511,
-0.5632753372192383,
0.3374507427215576,
0.3249691426753998,
-0.4722670018672943,
-0.5053834915161133,
-0.6663831472396851,
0.03433002904057503,
-0.4680096209049225,
-0.8147639036178589,
0.18173199892044067,
-0.26900047063827515,
-0.40642794966697693,
-0.3656180202960968,
0.02420075796544552,
0.14201444387435913,
0.3787584900856018,
0.13303695619106293,
0.31330087780952454,
-0.17832927405834198,
0.3023231625556946,
0.1744423657655716,
0.1319853514432907,
-0.2237691730260849,
-0.3627241253852844,
0.5843080282211304,
-0.018517307937145233,
-0.4107697904109955,
-0.3934624195098877,
0.4160102903842926,
0.6028282642364502,
-0.25763532519340515,
0.6744325160980225,
0.5759447813034058,
-0.20536503195762634,
0.11339431256055832,
-0.5662758350372314,
-0.32619065046310425,
-0.5045585036277771,
0.355943888425827,
-0.06539901345968246,
-1.4335448741912842,
0.8035972714424133,
0.03330082818865776,
0.3910873532295227,
0.3705165982246399,
0.9126113653182983,
0.019500477239489555,
1.2667423486709595,
0.5603517889976501,
-0.4187622666358948,
0.7489714622497559,
0.3738653361797333,
-0.0939997062087059,
-0.6064091324806213,
0.021808886900544167,
-0.763737678527832,
-0.859032392501831,
-0.871279239654541,
-0.20508664846420288,
0.031382545828819275,
0.29744192957878113,
-0.32859092950820923,
0.013250437565147877,
-0.5625626444816589,
0.6318538784980774,
0.5256438851356506,
0.05590640380978584,
0.26847657561302185,
0.056574009358882904,
0.12053857743740082,
-0.20607440173625946,
-0.47289562225341797,
-0.4734775125980377,
1.1939327716827393,
0.4316375255584717,
0.9763535857200623,
0.2648247182369232,
0.7304365038871765,
0.02554125338792801,
0.3547428548336029,
-0.5476966500282288,
0.22287312150001526,
-0.21047379076480865,
-0.6479660272598267,
-0.6381316184997559,
-0.5455911159515381,
-1.0430036783218384,
0.32893815636634827,
-0.36393260955810547,
-0.8353391885757446,
0.3424871265888214,
0.21100439131259918,
-0.6347852945327759,
0.18815074861049652,
-0.7341998815536499,
0.4790797233581543,
-0.16358406841754913,
-0.18369083106517792,
-0.027444200590252876,
-0.7222335338592529,
0.09601106494665146,
-0.1679949015378952,
0.2879510521888733,
-0.27581220865249634,
-0.0640563890337944,
0.6899943947792053,
-0.2670764923095703,
1.0601619482040405,
0.05515652149915695,
-0.34810277819633484,
0.020894717425107956,
-0.012407096102833748,
0.5309044122695923,
0.0827808678150177,
-0.25364258885383606,
-0.10013570636510849,
-0.42420390248298645,
-0.5883648991584778,
-0.5700697302818298,
0.7435057759284973,
-0.9684737324714661,
-0.6349815726280212,
0.07532931119203568,
-0.9853897094726562,
-0.3767317533493042,
0.22112096846103668,
0.33224648237228394,
0.11390730738639832,
0.1726853996515274,
0.20855745673179626,
0.596557080745697,
-0.24370820820331573,
0.274855375289917,
0.49176520109176636,
-0.2606707513332367,
-0.41002893447875977,
0.782848596572876,
0.13994689285755157,
0.5287832617759705,
0.25754767656326294,
0.3665827214717865,
-0.21706503629684448,
-0.5656371712684631,
-0.49376532435417175,
0.18255867063999176,
-0.5498262047767639,
-0.07708925753831863,
-0.5856308937072754,
0.3412335216999054,
-0.5570313930511475,
-0.2751733958721161,
-0.2105592042207718,
-0.5121973156929016,
-0.5406454205513,
-0.11495635658502579,
0.5690734386444092,
0.5761467814445496,
-0.1372465193271637,
0.4314042627811432,
-0.6583384871482849,
0.10265139490365982,
0.45336586236953735,
0.509480357170105,
-0.09194924682378769,
-0.7997514009475708,
-0.2118382751941681,
0.1781918704509735,
-0.17599397897720337,
-0.8017576932907104,
0.2041936218738556,
0.12017089873552322,
0.4133337140083313,
0.3988211154937744,
-0.005519057624042034,
0.6873634457588196,
-0.3078897297382355,
0.6929749250411987,
0.1391061246395111,
-0.8039281964302063,
0.3698619604110718,
-0.5231835246086121,
0.5753158926963806,
0.7771016955375671,
0.201315775513649,
-0.7546682953834534,
-0.5458303689956665,
-0.390849232673645,
-0.8092591166496277,
0.7272777557373047,
-0.0848221480846405,
0.3364100754261017,
0.16807028651237488,
0.39880603551864624,
0.27961647510528564,
-0.021837418898940086,
-0.4140273630619049,
-0.2962281107902527,
0.13733868300914764,
-0.3975617587566376,
-0.1387084722518921,
-0.26340392231941223,
-0.25094354152679443,
-0.33647969365119934,
0.12669441103935242,
-0.1519002765417099,
-0.3160894215106964,
-0.12505976855754852,
-0.026476643979549408,
-0.46836337447166443,
0.5608104467391968,
0.8461045622825623,
0.5171813368797302,
-0.015320630744099617,
0.21106822788715363,
0.3841080069541931,
-0.30694085359573364,
0.11100733280181885,
-0.11813852190971375,
-0.2513342499732971,
-0.21641066670417786,
0.43555063009262085,
1.0309114456176758,
0.016432106494903564,
-0.5155327916145325,
0.10288289934396744,
-0.07261373847723007,
-0.01804034784436226,
0.5564261078834534,
0.2528628408908844,
0.15994450449943542,
0.28658729791641235,
0.20511312782764435,
0.13201086223125458,
0.03857431560754776,
-0.3374401330947876,
0.1789674460887909,
0.4183499217033386,
-0.22696956992149353,
-0.2494427114725113,
0.5604641437530518,
0.32511696219444275,
-0.5292031168937683,
0.6222872734069824,
-0.13197100162506104,
-0.35015669465065,
0.5751121044158936,
0.3796219825744629,
0.6849356293678284,
-0.4065394699573517,
-0.023625081405043602,
0.36430805921554565,
0.3012131154537201,
-0.1867901086807251,
0.3735920786857605,
0.11772900819778442,
-0.8558995723724365,
-0.42691272497177124,
-0.526161253452301,
-0.46469491720199585,
-0.13090316951274872,
-0.8291505575180054,
0.28677523136138916,
-0.44838985800743103,
-0.21325956284999847,
0.2262221872806549,
0.02505112998187542,
-0.5914507508277893,
0.07141638547182083,
0.38144978880882263,
0.7516450881958008,
-1.0171663761138916,
0.7274326086044312,
0.7286432981491089,
-0.3183596730232239,
-0.6755374073982239,
-0.0899081900715828,
0.15462055802345276,
-0.7307372093200684,
0.5733280777931213,
0.11066706478595734,
0.18475817143917084,
-0.04158985614776611,
-0.6577691435813904,
-0.9857525825500488,
0.8367409706115723,
0.5766698122024536,
-0.8832055330276489,
0.18814195692539215,
0.36797013878822327,
0.6902482509613037,
-0.4852373003959656,
0.1818617284297943,
0.7033318877220154,
0.48127561807632446,
0.027103129774332047,
-1.159040927886963,
0.03170556202530861,
-0.029880553483963013,
0.15766631066799164,
0.18408948183059692,
-0.4626660645008087,
1.0603069067001343,
-0.45585528016090393,
-0.30594274401664734,
-0.04138774797320366,
0.6372905373573303,
0.3026486933231354,
-0.0675274059176445,
0.7119226455688477,
0.48475611209869385,
1.1304116249084473,
-0.057020463049411774,
0.9605690240859985,
-0.04764610156416893,
0.362486332654953,
1.306389331817627,
-0.25806331634521484,
0.5369247198104858,
0.547356903553009,
-0.29903438687324524,
0.34588557481765747,
0.9088097214698792,
-0.0716228038072586,
0.20771563053131104,
0.3600062131881714,
-0.16769284009933472,
-0.3740703761577606,
-0.3659263849258423,
-0.17502911388874054,
0.11350783705711365,
0.19911988079547882,
-0.25599268078804016,
-0.20160163938999176,
-0.045332543551921844,
0.003332460531964898,
0.12010424584150314,
-0.2241489589214325,
0.8842406272888184,
-0.171131432056427,
-0.7393015623092651,
0.605407178401947,
-0.017245708033442497,
0.9035071134567261,
-0.19557827711105347,
0.327863484621048,
-0.5085421204566956,
-0.1541782170534134,
-0.36159977316856384,
-1.011144995689392,
0.0748591348528862,
-0.05512768402695656,
-0.5820196866989136,
-0.14982444047927856,
0.4020843505859375,
-0.720768392086029,
-0.3310535252094269,
0.052968580275774,
0.2637944221496582,
-0.22415778040885925,
0.005470710340887308,
-0.48415493965148926,
0.21410053968429565,
0.20954349637031555,
-0.1401420533657074,
0.48810699582099915,
0.43791714310646057,
-0.45089903473854065,
0.7366605997085571,
0.6871088147163391,
0.11916188895702362,
0.288863867521286,
0.33209532499313354,
0.9446825981140137,
-0.563103973865509,
-0.5086308717727661,
-1.2212018966674805,
0.4938723146915436,
-0.1696036010980606,
-0.46799489855766296,
0.5345674157142639,
0.3350409269332886,
0.7444298267364502,
0.1725205034017563,
0.7222025990486145,
0.2797654867172241,
0.514623761177063,
-0.13152721524238586,
0.3621176481246948,
-0.5010123252868652,
0.420669823884964,
-0.2427295446395874,
-0.8367711901664734,
-0.6456884741783142,
0.3024846613407135,
-0.2097778171300888,
0.056085504591464996,
0.13196209073066711,
0.943414032459259,
0.08660176396369934,
0.07521801441907883,
0.11985182017087936,
0.04096883535385132,
0.4622887372970581,
0.35058948397636414,
0.8037529587745667,
0.1174493059515953,
0.45056837797164917,
-0.09128250926733017,
-0.416441410779953,
-0.4825141429901123,
-0.6876967549324036,
-0.6676034331321716,
-0.41783103346824646,
-0.21778786182403564,
-0.24220430850982666,
-0.36053842306137085,
1.1600559949874878,
0.6787048578262329,
-0.996098518371582,
-0.24117055535316467,
0.10714195668697357,
0.3115483224391937,
-0.0007703502778895199,
-0.17092488706111908,
0.01621807925403118,
-0.5108057856559753,
-0.7277678847312927,
0.02305733971297741,
0.3238525390625,
0.1771167516708374,
-0.3478970229625702,
-0.2824428677558899,
0.11073808372020721,
0.02064061164855957,
0.34210771322250366,
0.3161858022212982,
-0.8961286544799805,
-0.36375296115875244,
0.10747621953487396,
-0.3369584083557129,
0.22028979659080505,
0.7721808552742004,
-0.421259343624115,
0.5851041078567505,
0.7210484743118286,
0.8759391903877258,
-0.13273440301418304,
0.16759636998176575,
0.7527422308921814,
-0.9628641605377197,
0.03414814919233322,
0.24810542166233063,
0.24340209364891052,
0.4630776047706604,
-0.45971155166625977,
0.16724689304828644,
-0.05616501718759537,
-0.6678709387779236,
-0.8125444054603577,
0.5067322850227356,
-1.0356111526489258,
-0.16988283395767212,
1.3811880350112915,
0.2286948561668396,
0.09394687414169312,
-0.020109403878450394,
-0.4547611176967621,
0.1391889899969101,
-0.6292733550071716,
0.9425192475318909,
0.8381664752960205,
-0.21744751930236816,
-0.13305500149726868,
-0.08048856258392334,
0.5160051584243774,
0.8130981922149658,
-0.8060836791992188,
0.38833701610565186,
0.5139119625091553,
0.2788715064525604,
0.22529567778110504,
0.33684420585632324,
0.06129038706421852,
0.16183117032051086,
-0.4955165982246399,
0.058103106915950775,
0.2928519546985626,
-0.02088191546499729,
-0.8302111625671387,
-0.07925141602754593,
0.4246615469455719,
0.10048452019691467
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11123v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11123v1
|
Granular Change Accuracy: A More Accurate Performance Metric for Dialogue State Tracking
| 2024-03-17T07:07:44 | 2024-03-17T07:07:44 |
Taha Aksu, Nancy F. Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Current metrics for evaluating Dialogue State Tracking (DST) systems exhibit
three primary limitations. They: i) erroneously presume a uniform distribution
of slots throughout the dialog, ii) neglect to assign partial scores for
individual turns, iii) frequently overestimate or underestimate performance by
repeatedly counting the models' successful or failed predictions. To address
these shortcomings, we introduce a novel metric: Granular Change Accuracy
(GCA). GCA focuses on evaluating the predicted changes in dialogue state over
the entire dialogue history. Benchmarking reveals that GCA effectively reduces
biases arising from distribution uniformity and the positioning of errors
across turns, resulting in a more precise evaluation. Notably, we find that
these biases are particularly pronounced when evaluating few-shot or zero-shot
trained models, becoming even more evident as the model's error rate increases.
Hence, GCA offers significant promise, particularly for assessing models
trained with limited resources. Our GCA implementation is a useful addition to
the pool of DST metrics.
|
[
-0.271116703748703,
-0.6728362441062927,
0.7703320980072021,
0.011205180548131466,
-0.17683015763759613,
0.16599830985069275,
0.05345441773533821,
-0.4184466004371643,
0.12164682894945145,
0.1192459762096405,
-0.6144582629203796,
-0.44638463854789734,
-0.7279194593429565,
-0.24940691888332367,
-0.4043215811252594,
1.143355131149292,
-0.020083626732230186,
0.201015442609787,
-0.08281807601451874,
-0.1178470328450203,
-0.6213359832763672,
-0.38481107354164124,
-0.5530734062194824,
-0.4165528118610382,
0.30779606103897095,
-0.16064979135990143,
0.9402142763137817,
0.21672989428043365,
0.3949538767337799,
0.25892630219459534,
-0.5011166334152222,
0.22818949818611145,
-0.3977592885494232,
-0.1575116515159607,
-0.1593198925256729,
-0.4717882573604584,
-0.7176883220672607,
-0.08920353651046753,
0.6967838406562805,
0.5138536691665649,
-0.3456652760505676,
0.06842464208602905,
0.006953334901481867,
0.5079619884490967,
-0.6405057907104492,
0.40040233731269836,
-0.7300944924354553,
-0.049286749213933945,
-0.1369403451681137,
-0.33179593086242676,
-0.1722947061061859,
-0.4603510797023773,
0.24610616266727448,
-0.5776659250259399,
0.3875119984149933,
-0.5374951958656311,
0.741238534450531,
0.45094549655914307,
-0.3446916341781616,
-0.502876877784729,
-0.8899763226509094,
0.708861231803894,
-0.845902681350708,
0.1195899173617363,
0.22915402054786682,
0.5865356922149658,
-0.22596308588981628,
-0.5420428514480591,
-0.3093423843383789,
-0.28801530599594116,
0.20053823292255402,
0.14140501618385315,
-0.0867643654346466,
0.2680528163909912,
0.3142557442188263,
0.39049816131591797,
0.0603611133992672,
-0.22368301451206207,
-0.26776883006095886,
-0.3920632004737854,
0.5941450595855713,
0.7459478974342346,
0.04064983129501343,
0.08225265145301819,
-0.12097806483507156,
-0.10549362748861313,
-0.11199720948934555,
0.2865998446941376,
0.3923089802265167,
0.44044578075408936,
0.07115980237722397,
0.06312824785709381,
-0.4635910391807556,
0.7884191870689392,
0.4206138551235199,
-0.5401244163513184,
0.21231524646282196,
-0.5216821432113647,
-0.18917708098888397,
-0.12120182812213898,
0.420167475938797,
0.31271058320999146,
-0.37454140186309814,
0.03996393829584122,
-0.25025075674057007,
0.21164284646511078,
0.6347401738166809,
-0.8275855183601379,
-0.20765060186386108,
-0.003570172004401684,
-0.12317157536745071,
-0.310066282749176,
0.1108006089925766,
-0.4826706051826477,
-0.3141883313655853,
-0.3154064118862152,
0.504256546497345,
-0.4354954957962036,
-0.04683626443147659,
0.16247302293777466,
0.1438007652759552,
0.04586897790431976,
0.9996628165245056,
-0.9638680219650269,
0.4959847629070282,
0.8439614772796631,
1.3363488912582397,
-0.16436001658439636,
-0.08176711946725845,
-0.4722548723220825,
-0.20900727808475494,
-0.6380366086959839,
0.8497516512870789,
-0.6564438343048096,
-0.588119387626648,
-0.252214640378952,
-0.22159627079963684,
-0.22326737642288208,
-0.5467862486839294,
0.430683434009552,
-0.19531868398189545,
-0.009085454046726227,
-0.40925276279449463,
-0.5433910489082336,
-0.12787406146526337,
0.3206435739994049,
-0.37365221977233887,
0.9999076724052429,
0.27848824858665466,
-0.45427948236465454,
0.6708808541297913,
-0.7436332702636719,
0.010353216901421547,
-0.19134294986724854,
-0.10927315801382065,
-0.45598509907722473,
0.40214934945106506,
0.13525252044200897,
-0.06354468315839767,
0.08071909844875336,
0.41867685317993164,
-0.250382661819458,
-0.6846401691436768,
0.2152039259672165,
-0.7890459299087524,
0.3370884656906128,
0.09125558286905289,
-0.16481105983257294,
-0.036068763583898544,
-0.46126019954681396,
0.20546670258045197,
-0.455687940120697,
-0.3379027247428894,
-0.01273141335695982,
0.049541499465703964,
-0.19583889842033386,
0.06705951690673828,
0.1465539038181305,
-0.4344745874404907,
0.33664047718048096,
0.00028396392008289695,
0.10588647425174713,
0.7942078709602356,
0.045996859669685364,
0.3920164108276367,
-0.50217205286026,
0.5393659472465515,
0.21261796355247498,
0.35026055574417114,
-0.09136271476745605,
-0.644564688205719,
-0.4921168386936188,
-0.2574022114276886,
0.3528965711593628,
0.3281426429748535,
-0.44478073716163635,
0.22706614434719086,
-0.3133378326892853,
-0.6143006682395935,
-0.38728633522987366,
-0.12099207192659378,
0.2518620193004608,
0.33676692843437195,
0.2841246724128723,
-0.9306137561798096,
0.03289534151554108,
-0.4255322813987732,
-0.4264135956764221,
-0.2710745632648468,
-0.0012521654134616256,
0.4206201434135437,
0.6090015172958374,
-0.1700170785188675,
1.1491085290908813,
-0.6032799482345581,
-0.3541029393672943,
0.02661288157105446,
0.4502257704734802,
0.1003190204501152,
0.3307236433029175,
0.3804505467414856,
-0.48712825775146484,
-0.4662259817123413,
0.11855225265026093,
-0.31685420870780945,
-0.25194406509399414,
-0.30478808283805847,
0.2004735916852951,
0.21381855010986328,
0.13833653926849365,
-0.41921088099479675,
0.8663777112960815,
0.6336340308189392,
-0.3111187815666199,
0.8488223552703857,
-0.11793099343776703,
0.5652117133140564,
-0.7216570377349854,
-0.13660846650600433,
-0.20705103874206543,
-0.3551609516143799,
-0.6782593727111816,
-0.46329838037490845,
0.1427978128194809,
0.06337649375200272,
-0.5643537640571594,
0.4562716484069824,
-0.06950566172599792,
-0.42659661173820496,
-0.18516777455806732,
0.1115533709526062,
-0.057189568877220154,
0.43529900908470154,
-0.21092723309993744,
1.1434959173202515,
0.4031279981136322,
-0.7150506377220154,
0.3091862201690674,
0.47470563650131226,
-0.683843731880188,
1.0900641679763794,
-0.39735084772109985,
0.3080230951309204,
0.13623252511024475,
0.8041573762893677,
-0.7247575521469116,
-0.17353509366512299,
0.00493455259129405,
-0.38893431425094604,
0.0790100172162056,
-0.4293823838233948,
-0.053053878247737885,
-0.01799304038286209,
-0.10867001861333847,
0.36035051941871643,
0.2921641170978546,
-0.28148335218429565,
0.4053072929382324,
0.18051788210868835,
-0.19936621189117432,
-0.48317068815231323,
-0.5009024143218994,
0.1606930047273636,
-0.029652409255504608,
-0.5221031904220581,
0.32758283615112305,
-0.06114409863948822,
-0.1035802885890007,
-0.1455032378435135,
-0.6156657338142395,
-0.30892595648765564,
-0.009976748377084732,
0.08304321020841599,
0.03681790828704834,
0.0009981099283322692,
0.3101171851158142,
-0.05873489007353783,
-0.23194058239459991,
-0.22062863409519196,
-0.22838017344474792,
0.6956346035003662,
-0.25909674167633057,
-0.5660111904144287,
-0.9458491802215576,
0.05921568721532822,
0.517689049243927,
0.3028855621814728,
0.5113639235496521,
0.5686293244361877,
-0.1066136285662651,
0.18634487688541412,
-0.4445782005786896,
-0.022754937410354614,
-0.3952905237674713,
0.503949761390686,
-0.47540605068206787,
-0.4992685914039612,
0.6658172011375427,
0.026252219453454018,
0.037088096141815186,
0.2526808977127075,
0.3208884298801422,
0.09394916892051697,
1.2801182270050049,
0.5299914479255676,
0.012224496342241764,
0.8541430830955505,
-0.09922778606414795,
0.17016218602657318,
-1.0646858215332031,
-0.0801776871085167,
-0.5955433249473572,
-0.30052629113197327,
-0.4685462713241577,
-0.6743669509887695,
0.5619887709617615,
0.12601663172245026,
-0.10133972018957138,
0.23991699516773224,
-0.15897411108016968,
0.4032342731952667,
0.26455754041671753,
0.06042194366455078,
0.6026932001113892,
-0.23964735865592957,
0.30074113607406616,
-0.14984048902988434,
-0.3884861171245575,
-0.6471405625343323,
1.019445776939392,
0.2771657109260559,
1.0491862297058105,
0.11755169183015823,
0.593906819820404,
0.46110329031944275,
0.10040102899074554,
-0.9194976091384888,
0.3763848841190338,
-0.062136463820934296,
-0.5315358638763428,
-0.36858293414115906,
-0.6717393398284912,
-0.5061932802200317,
0.3586820363998413,
0.1883435845375061,
-1.0171499252319336,
-0.008939838036894798,
0.36674177646636963,
-0.5767767429351807,
0.6095821261405945,
-0.46188485622406006,
0.7375149130821228,
0.002000928157940507,
0.040145356208086014,
-0.3766891062259674,
-0.1734284609556198,
-0.03208223730325699,
-0.11340224742889404,
-0.2825081944465637,
-0.4004139304161072,
-0.07937108725309372,
0.5889051556587219,
-0.48738476634025574,
0.8460529446601868,
-0.3268916606903076,
-0.09923490881919861,
0.2937082350254059,
0.2561127245426178,
0.6902105212211609,
0.06929967552423477,
-0.03634290769696236,
0.3114803731441498,
0.35048606991767883,
-0.6178604364395142,
-0.7888607978820801,
0.4331817030906677,
-0.6445431709289551,
-0.4683345854282379,
-0.6876898407936096,
-0.8585276007652283,
-0.45521610975265503,
-0.30471354722976685,
0.12552449107170105,
0.7921158671379089,
-0.5580808520317078,
-0.04665443301200867,
0.43921977281570435,
-0.054434504359960556,
0.26098889112472534,
0.40193167328834534,
-0.12026133388280869,
-0.2109781801700592,
0.5845200419425964,
0.38292577862739563,
0.8489896655082703,
0.07349596172571182,
0.029854444786906242,
-0.37682434916496277,
-0.7831127643585205,
-0.6698958277702332,
-0.15819981694221497,
-0.5432299375534058,
-0.13145321607589722,
-0.606689453125,
-0.13061875104904175,
-0.3462674021720886,
-0.26261353492736816,
-0.5009580254554749,
-0.4110831320285797,
-0.17104551196098328,
0.15561151504516602,
0.1208401694893837,
0.9357547760009766,
-0.039939284324645996,
0.7739368081092834,
-0.5954258441925049,
0.032899267971515656,
0.487793892621994,
0.5782007575035095,
-0.43043988943099976,
-0.910557210445404,
-0.26620450615882874,
0.37738075852394104,
-0.7989086508750916,
-0.5517433285713196,
0.12520954012870789,
0.2623295187950134,
0.2788214683532715,
0.20288868248462677,
-0.33127036690711975,
1.162737250328064,
-0.17754606902599335,
1.0505472421646118,
0.3192591071128845,
-1.3344920873641968,
0.585760772228241,
-0.41964098811149597,
0.8436756730079651,
0.6546303033828735,
-0.2811923027038574,
-0.8448845744132996,
-0.40864717960357666,
-0.8139346241950989,
-0.2624228894710541,
1.1179122924804688,
0.15605586767196655,
0.2818377614021301,
0.2253575474023819,
0.007322266697883606,
0.1304992288351059,
0.3208761215209961,
-0.1890924721956253,
0.14456301927566528,
-0.031364623457193375,
0.058189507573843,
-0.038323432207107544,
-0.0860215574502945,
-0.15442772209644318,
-0.016995692625641823,
0.8432064056396484,
-0.5432779788970947,
0.26118311285972595,
0.23386654257774353,
-0.09604369848966599,
-0.11658275872468948,
0.3537570834159851,
0.8000890612602234,
1.0764503479003906,
-0.3381783664226532,
-0.41185376048088074,
0.6979215741157532,
-0.6703073978424072,
0.026649506762623787,
-0.3439192473888397,
-0.48931482434272766,
0.22869150340557098,
0.0678354948759079,
0.9674256443977356,
0.14415793120861053,
-0.24301278591156006,
0.5522927045822144,
-0.09061212837696075,
-0.009974179789423943,
-0.1715242862701416,
0.2779388129711151,
-0.41025304794311523,
0.2735913395881653,
0.17244607210159302,
0.7190030813217163,
0.252439022064209,
-0.6887062191963196,
0.07945941388607025,
0.4438815414905548,
-1.0020025968551636,
-0.3822425305843353,
0.19499894976615906,
0.2762370705604553,
-0.403533935546875,
0.23703038692474365,
-0.36296796798706055,
-0.4032333791255951,
0.5681381225585938,
0.28828272223472595,
0.8972806930541992,
-0.36993861198425293,
0.8358207941055298,
0.3238084614276886,
0.022715244442224503,
-0.39202681183815,
-0.0972176343202591,
-0.21269716322422028,
-0.7167888283729553,
-0.3985624313354492,
-0.5147305130958557,
-0.8664525151252747,
0.10114485770463943,
-0.9307994246482849,
0.21419847011566162,
-0.5379572510719299,
-0.5832601189613342,
-0.15920555591583252,
0.16836807131767273,
-0.5812032222747803,
0.23363181948661804,
0.04451362043619156,
0.8392854928970337,
-0.8126652240753174,
0.581277072429657,
0.3284448981285095,
-0.057208552956581116,
-0.49858707189559937,
0.19591884315013885,
0.42063477635383606,
-0.5823471546173096,
0.08126789331436157,
0.16505523025989532,
-0.3906961679458618,
-0.45585688948631287,
-0.3325766921043396,
-0.8052637577056885,
1.1815179586410522,
0.23308232426643372,
-0.61680006980896,
0.0379398837685585,
-0.01863120310008526,
0.7259626984596252,
-0.4336686134338379,
0.7584033012390137,
1.0902018547058105,
0.24568814039230347,
0.1671840250492096,
-1.43923819065094,
-0.4667414426803589,
0.231554314494133,
0.3289157748222351,
0.5072821974754333,
-0.7370221614837646,
0.6970664262771606,
-0.14471881091594696,
-0.36784791946411133,
0.2573578953742981,
0.2835475504398346,
-0.006414211820811033,
0.5066565871238708,
0.5834876894950867,
0.5935256481170654,
1.0120007991790771,
-0.6513167023658752,
0.9634006023406982,
0.17104558646678925,
0.6957260966300964,
1.1973209381103516,
-0.20428957045078278,
0.4439813196659088,
0.2673684060573578,
-0.42691290378570557,
0.4878479540348053,
0.4700090289115906,
0.31523963809013367,
0.5658683776855469,
-0.05335608497262001,
-0.5100030899047852,
-0.20026633143424988,
-0.1257113665342331,
-0.3987480401992798,
0.46248504519462585,
0.36262592673301697,
-0.04393457993865013,
-0.2952190339565277,
-0.29653963446617126,
0.30029526352882385,
-0.14929994940757751,
-0.33137768507003784,
0.9770539402961731,
-0.156825453042984,
-0.5970789790153503,
0.4591387212276459,
-0.3883931040763855,
0.43897655606269836,
-0.7762332558631897,
0.10231651365756989,
-0.34445297718048096,
0.3027510643005371,
-0.14848563075065613,
-0.6294431090354919,
0.40278998017311096,
0.029957525432109833,
-0.0075691500678658485,
-0.1618790626525879,
0.153385728597641,
-0.27277231216430664,
-0.4753444790840149,
0.10074600577354431,
0.32502299547195435,
0.17098167538642883,
-0.12326239794492722,
-0.8264735341072083,
0.176646426320076,
0.2030262053012848,
-0.08982948958873749,
0.31103020906448364,
0.2849482297897339,
-0.10717129707336426,
0.6069576740264893,
0.4992487132549286,
0.44751250743865967,
-0.0001722552697174251,
0.2655656337738037,
0.6964220404624939,
-0.6761177182197571,
-0.726773738861084,
-0.38395676016807556,
0.47049808502197266,
-0.3428017199039459,
-0.7499995827674866,
0.1073087528347969,
0.21620893478393555,
0.8768250942230225,
0.2320558875799179,
0.8461577892303467,
-0.175675630569458,
0.4369075298309326,
-0.5407208800315857,
0.17599360644817352,
-0.2707892060279846,
0.26947125792503357,
-0.4314190447330475,
-1.0957714319229126,
0.03516945242881775,
0.4714837968349457,
-0.6418914198875427,
0.1751771718263626,
0.8945000767707825,
1.0611059665679932,
-0.08950283378362656,
0.29790523648262024,
0.7287896871566772,
0.272001177072525,
0.7339239120483398,
0.44892048835754395,
0.9296247959136963,
-0.6950580477714539,
0.5584058165550232,
-0.2068551480770111,
-0.32107308506965637,
-0.28861749172210693,
-0.7041302919387817,
-0.4943736493587494,
-0.4854535162448883,
-0.46495625376701355,
-0.2650217115879059,
0.19743503630161285,
0.7201558351516724,
0.9024794697761536,
-0.9725043177604675,
-0.11563228815793991,
0.04563741385936737,
-0.25156518816947937,
-0.5050563216209412,
-0.17693805694580078,
0.0067195286974310875,
-0.6258702278137207,
-0.935401201248169,
0.3366091549396515,
0.5450911521911621,
0.10690540075302124,
-0.10514403134584427,
-0.22627931833267212,
0.14766214787960052,
0.31987202167510986,
0.2701059579849243,
0.0880606397986412,
-0.86860591173172,
-0.7596591114997864,
-0.4408653974533081,
-0.2524802088737488,
0.2171953022480011,
0.9200721979141235,
-0.7036800980567932,
0.7576429843902588,
0.3725423514842987,
0.3776211738586426,
0.7530608177185059,
0.38639962673187256,
0.4415549337863922,
-0.49941179156303406,
0.04804001376032829,
0.18753878772258759,
0.141485795378685,
0.4565068781375885,
-0.16959406435489655,
0.5962382555007935,
0.24771538376808167,
-0.6985041499137878,
-0.7101749181747437,
0.43696126341819763,
-0.9726613759994507,
0.22949020564556122,
0.9359158873558044,
-0.2058204710483551,
0.025127414613962173,
-0.2657165229320526,
-0.5061625838279724,
-0.026331130415201187,
-0.7259176969528198,
1.1214128732681274,
0.8444412350654602,
-0.2796487510204315,
0.2548655569553375,
-0.6200942397117615,
0.6755746006965637,
0.41449448466300964,
-0.8302774429321289,
-0.03716536611318588,
0.5561186671257019,
0.3852258026599884,
0.4605749845504761,
0.8934503197669983,
-0.21266786754131317,
0.41297733783721924,
0.24303044378757477,
-0.2801850438117981,
0.221726655960083,
-0.4043102562427521,
-0.4687878489494324,
-0.22882555425167084,
-0.1563725620508194,
-0.15240365266799927
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11108v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11108v1
|
HarmPot: An Annotation Framework for Evaluating Offline Harm Potential of Social Media Text
| 2024-03-17T06:23:25 | 2024-03-17T06:23:25 |
Ritesh Kumar, Ojaswee Bhalla, Madhu Vanthi, Shehlat Maknoon Wani, Siddharth Singh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this paper, we discuss the development of an annotation schema to build
datasets for evaluating the offline harm potential of social media texts. We
define "harm potential" as the potential for an online public post to cause
real-world physical harm (i.e., violence). Understanding that real-world
violence is often spurred by a web of triggers, often combining several online
tactics and pre-existing intersectional fissures in the social milieu, to
result in targeted physical violence, we do not focus on any single divisive
aspect (i.e., caste, gender, religion, or other identities of the victim and
perpetrators) nor do we focus on just hate speech or mis/dis-information.
Rather, our understanding of the intersectional causes of such triggers focuses
our attempt at measuring the harm potential of online content, irrespective of
whether it is hateful or not. In this paper, we discuss the development of a
framework/annotation schema that allows annotating the data with different
aspects of the text including its socio-political grounding and intent of the
speaker (as expressed through mood and modality) that together contribute to it
being a trigger for offline harm. We also give a comparative analysis and
mapping of our framework with some of the existing frameworks.
|
[
-0.2962748408317566,
-0.980899453163147,
0.2881735563278198,
0.1825471669435501,
-0.24092409014701843,
-0.18851011991500854,
-0.1433652639389038,
-0.555086612701416,
0.4877820909023285,
0.301691472530365,
-0.48142147064208984,
-0.40266454219818115,
-0.7081420421600342,
0.11098524183034897,
-0.35868164896965027,
0.8908879160881042,
0.11660192161798477,
-0.07403906434774399,
0.035353485494852066,
0.11931397765874863,
-0.5384395718574524,
-0.43482425808906555,
-0.38176167011260986,
0.32731181383132935,
0.9067916870117188,
0.4128435552120209,
0.386944442987442,
0.42853596806526184,
1.158569097518921,
0.22865933179855347,
-0.05318816006183624,
-0.21967104077339172,
-0.9097105860710144,
0.42768028378486633,
-0.21661536395549774,
-0.4037661552429199,
-0.1036495640873909,
0.14194399118423462,
0.13884204626083374,
0.4781929552555084,
0.20721378922462463,
0.3151530921459198,
-0.23053845763206482,
0.34365156292915344,
-0.8324225544929504,
-0.21001455187797546,
-0.614993691444397,
0.3690051734447479,
-0.3242248594760895,
-0.3778109848499298,
-0.4052220284938812,
-0.6748703122138977,
-0.15930187702178955,
-0.6361029148101807,
-0.17582429945468903,
0.2049514651298523,
0.6874006986618042,
0.5126355290412903,
-0.4683001935482025,
-0.1913415491580963,
-0.8802056908607483,
0.5158334970474243,
-0.30238983035087585,
0.07462327927350998,
0.7506494522094727,
0.5917694568634033,
0.036946386098861694,
-0.4433092176914215,
-0.6448976397514343,
0.18389758467674255,
-0.06626850366592407,
0.13111142814159393,
-0.21788839995861053,
0.042494453489780426,
0.434325248003006,
0.47040855884552,
-0.28878387808799744,
-0.0093451626598835,
-0.41071850061416626,
0.04137888550758362,
0.8790122866630554,
0.22294574975967407,
0.6136535406112671,
-0.48667362332344055,
-0.4188248813152313,
0.06687228381633759,
-0.7264402508735657,
-0.04775209352374077,
0.8129833936691284,
0.5457485318183899,
-0.17449000477790833,
0.7085544466972351,
0.30919158458709717,
0.645997941493988,
0.091627337038517,
-0.19139695167541504,
0.10191464424133301,
-0.3129403293132782,
0.07779552042484283,
0.33407342433929443,
1.0001258850097656,
1.0307337045669556,
0.19926851987838745,
-0.09852435439825058,
0.3899441361427307,
0.19566375017166138,
0.772445797920227,
-1.0594313144683838,
-0.21715542674064636,
0.3865087628364563,
-0.5910030007362366,
-0.7844744324684143,
0.200852170586586,
-1.035749912261963,
-1.0285862684249878,
0.13769063353538513,
0.3939571976661682,
-0.30776846408843994,
-0.46585145592689514,
-0.3601803481578827,
-0.4152020514011383,
-0.17831166088581085,
-0.01144822221249342,
-0.8402339220046997,
0.06519122421741486,
0.3505907356739044,
1.1903979778289795,
-0.11712139844894409,
-0.04480573907494545,
-0.237339586019516,
0.08265624940395355,
-0.21678589284420013,
0.965676486492157,
-0.532895565032959,
-0.2587587237358093,
0.4056472182273865,
0.052541062235832214,
0.3028429448604584,
-0.2727017104625702,
0.9402216076850891,
-0.4324902296066284,
0.04492572322487831,
-0.6857902407646179,
-0.4871760606765747,
-0.508323073387146,
0.19363287091255188,
-0.8225417733192444,
1.020771861076355,
0.09394694864749908,
-1.1670315265655518,
0.7749606966972351,
-1.1033443212509155,
-0.6746102571487427,
0.0983971655368805,
0.07213100790977478,
-0.4842870831489563,
-0.24828091263771057,
-0.4450983703136444,
0.7219245433807373,
-0.30052170157432556,
0.15795986354351044,
-0.7307309508323669,
-0.40769827365875244,
0.2892409563064575,
-0.03047439269721508,
0.8963936567306519,
0.056633614003658295,
-0.7005846500396729,
0.4803917407989502,
-0.8691070675849915,
-0.1820880025625229,
0.28725603222846985,
0.03897065669298172,
-0.7724303007125854,
0.17718298733234406,
0.5540697574615479,
0.5360313057899475,
-0.2678941488265991,
-0.870496928691864,
-0.04324600100517273,
-0.30764079093933105,
0.46341535449028015,
0.596230149269104,
0.25681981444358826,
0.19961968064308167,
-0.37592172622680664,
0.3678317070007324,
-0.21449151635169983,
0.39552152156829834,
-0.026275331154465675,
-0.4321281313896179,
-0.1054069995880127,
-0.39156344532966614,
0.19193869829177856,
0.5801774263381958,
-0.37607336044311523,
0.617707371711731,
-0.11855600029230118,
-0.7563379406929016,
-0.30483928322792053,
-0.2452891767024994,
0.1838236153125763,
0.21340855956077576,
0.5078819990158081,
-0.17778851091861725,
-0.9356661438941956,
-0.7109158635139465,
-0.38734516501426697,
-0.403499037027359,
-0.009180632419884205,
0.1385483592748642,
0.23316217958927155,
-0.05154743045568466,
1.2560960054397583,
-0.34887605905532837,
-0.7669329047203064,
-0.24600853025913239,
0.2886877655982971,
-0.4211222529411316,
0.05356868728995323,
0.5102483630180359,
-1.177546501159668,
-0.6639212369918823,
-0.2326483577489853,
-1.050294041633606,
-0.7118043303489685,
-0.15721680223941803,
-0.2884805202484131,
-0.3649922013282776,
0.17965003848075867,
-0.41873183846473694,
0.7891108393669128,
0.301056444644928,
-0.40412434935569763,
0.2515774071216583,
0.49128884077072144,
0.7305364608764648,
-1.2306675910949707,
0.19120143353939056,
0.022017037495970726,
0.06988780200481415,
-0.8751425743103027,
-0.10943415015935898,
-0.192750945687294,
-0.16174450516700745,
-0.8630956411361694,
0.1984199732542038,
-0.014709311537444592,
0.16944189369678497,
-0.23575589060783386,
0.3787144422531128,
-0.09726294875144958,
0.1056172326207161,
-0.23581966757774353,
0.4718116521835327,
0.17387115955352783,
-0.20942290127277374,
0.4390276074409485,
0.42925208806991577,
-0.09904560446739197,
0.9147244095802307,
-0.43871232867240906,
-0.1171618103981018,
0.022965164855122566,
0.08941731601953506,
-0.8061907291412354,
-0.4902850091457367,
0.7970322966575623,
-0.30152636766433716,
-0.09278393536806107,
-0.26328739523887634,
-0.6025192737579346,
-0.13570930063724518,
-0.5641003251075745,
0.5475215911865234,
0.029163207858800888,
-0.17955955862998962,
0.2905549705028534,
1.054616928100586,
-0.14611932635307312,
-0.1088477224111557,
-0.6618306040763855,
0.34669411182403564,
-0.6911559104919434,
-0.5688656568527222,
0.38286250829696655,
0.05546041205525398,
-0.7770806550979614,
-0.17480458319187164,
0.621706485748291,
-0.1391555517911911,
0.03703828528523445,
1.0170106887817383,
-0.2563275992870331,
0.41409483551979065,
0.36432012915611267,
0.19027848541736603,
-0.15033435821533203,
0.21018996834754944,
0.3030761480331421,
0.4355369210243225,
0.2164754867553711,
-0.23398743569850922,
-0.3876652121543884,
0.6775601506233215,
0.17820486426353455,
0.038229092955589294,
0.7966833710670471,
0.375154972076416,
-0.5817981362342834,
0.20538043975830078,
-0.23755182325839996,
-0.07270649075508118,
-0.3435227572917938,
0.0220103207975626,
0.06979108601808548,
-0.664160430431366,
0.6053532958030701,
-0.11925358325242996,
0.06747547537088394,
0.4846024811267853,
0.7761571407318115,
0.10894128680229187,
0.5437116026878357,
0.6141248345375061,
0.2788386940956116,
0.5929386019706726,
-0.06530120223760605,
0.4191149175167084,
-0.3623442053794861,
-0.2073262631893158,
-0.30443257093429565,
-0.25787150859832764,
-0.4795995056629181,
-0.3106769621372223,
0.19694052636623383,
0.048623524606227875,
-0.18254119157791138,
0.5545215010643005,
-0.7402214407920837,
0.2973790168762207,
0.2502621114253998,
0.005282714497298002,
0.1949608027935028,
-0.017641939222812653,
0.12121149897575378,
-0.36504867672920227,
-0.5840846300125122,
-0.7313786745071411,
1.0550477504730225,
0.3537483811378479,
0.5144841074943542,
0.3858051896095276,
0.35612592101097107,
0.6738157272338867,
0.6527747511863708,
-0.7519664764404297,
0.3365737795829773,
0.511942982673645,
-1.234948992729187,
-0.44625839591026306,
-0.22980830073356628,
-0.9744272828102112,
0.17910081148147583,
-0.3228014409542084,
-0.937316358089447,
0.10103720426559448,
0.17270512878894806,
-0.49847182631492615,
0.5957571268081665,
-0.5724035501480103,
0.9501835703849792,
-0.31602534651756287,
-0.6144608855247498,
0.07972532510757446,
-0.8255425095558167,
0.24980850517749786,
-0.44408732652664185,
0.5501880645751953,
-0.20209914445877075,
0.1710704267024994,
0.924231231212616,
-0.5523104667663574,
1.2261840105056763,
-0.22569558024406433,
-0.033226899802684784,
0.5743505954742432,
-0.029921600595116615,
0.040537599474191666,
-0.2953563332557678,
-0.014080744236707687,
0.6474842429161072,
0.04631291329860687,
-0.13728925585746765,
-0.30810171365737915,
0.4822568893432617,
-0.4856572449207306,
-0.09493985772132874,
-0.5556387901306152,
-0.33681178092956543,
0.06284279376268387,
0.4597088694572449,
0.4457995295524597,
0.06222746893763542,
-0.45388591289520264,
0.03435559198260307,
0.30460885167121887,
-0.11062655597925186,
0.5324540138244629,
0.082252636551857,
-0.34164127707481384,
-0.5133748054504395,
0.9011454582214355,
0.3580484092235565,
-0.0764726772904396,
0.30087053775787354,
0.1783003956079483,
-0.22954007983207703,
-0.20717351138591766,
-0.48073840141296387,
-0.2782082259654999,
-0.8249044418334961,
-0.4261337220668793,
-0.7171046733856201,
0.26031091809272766,
-0.28674769401550293,
-0.289404958486557,
-0.2460366189479828,
-0.11767461150884628,
-0.18835848569869995,
-0.21410802006721497,
0.7718889713287354,
0.8130760788917542,
-0.39922481775283813,
0.5574541091918945,
-0.49850359559059143,
0.23227834701538086,
0.07604017108678818,
0.4919951260089874,
-0.3537091612815857,
-0.2540483772754669,
-0.260423868894577,
0.10319060832262039,
-0.5249689221382141,
-1.6346831321716309,
0.048956941813230515,
-0.03786443546414375,
0.1318439096212387,
0.678877055644989,
0.7259747385978699,
0.6210587024688721,
-0.6139680743217468,
0.8608429431915283,
0.3164042532444,
-0.6734436750411987,
0.7203601002693176,
-0.640296459197998,
-0.3323676884174347,
0.8475607633590698,
0.8059536814689636,
-0.7870666980743408,
-0.2956179976463318,
-0.6503710150718689,
-0.973695695400238,
0.3738200068473816,
0.40973952412605286,
0.08747067302465439,
-0.2601841986179352,
0.14847491681575775,
0.3804987668991089,
0.22784999012947083,
-0.9214644432067871,
-0.34044602513313293,
-0.4115847945213318,
-0.15764489769935608,
0.28178560733795166,
-0.40420079231262207,
-0.35648322105407715,
-0.069964200258255,
0.6019119620323181,
0.1528686285018921,
0.5070794820785522,
-0.028659144416451454,
-0.15094175934791565,
-0.7971912622451782,
-0.05563613399863243,
0.3297715485095978,
0.595988392829895,
-0.2622442841529846,
0.23636947572231293,
0.027297493070364,
-0.5365496873855591,
0.24028418958187103,
0.19063697755336761,
-0.28339138627052307,
-0.019852489233016968,
0.4631284177303314,
0.614341676235199,
0.4816158711910248,
-0.5689287185668945,
0.8732408285140991,
-0.03757205978035927,
-0.05070687085390091,
-0.5444309115409851,
-0.2599620819091797,
-0.21038298308849335,
0.1646834760904312,
0.4518436789512634,
-0.192599356174469,
0.34370315074920654,
-0.3512531518936157,
0.3391246795654297,
0.1562846601009369,
-0.5967442393302917,
-0.35198351740837097,
0.7026455402374268,
0.3360251486301422,
-0.7981728315353394,
-0.3453567624092102,
-0.2759590446949005,
-0.6965188384056091,
0.0466877818107605,
0.25447380542755127,
0.7854043245315552,
-0.31311604380607605,
0.32253241539001465,
0.22641697525978088,
0.4252154231071472,
0.5375849604606628,
0.2776186764240265,
0.04574091359972954,
-0.33997678756713867,
-0.2967609465122223,
-0.494577556848526,
-0.3294948637485504,
0.1843077391386032,
-0.48749101161956787,
0.45326778292655945,
-0.564672589302063,
-0.4803711175918579,
0.1640639305114746,
-0.10221566259860992,
-0.13989758491516113,
0.357810378074646,
-0.06441745162010193,
0.44281718134880066,
-1.0315712690353394,
-0.010850932449102402,
0.5722261667251587,
-0.6953076720237732,
-0.6606323719024658,
0.35282376408576965,
0.21402591466903687,
-0.1820606291294098,
0.5729353427886963,
0.3902422785758972,
0.029112471267580986,
-0.17584045231342316,
-0.3718314468860626,
-0.6357326507568359,
0.6484203338623047,
0.22820045053958893,
-0.3340192139148712,
0.344255656003952,
0.5706939697265625,
0.6743143796920776,
-0.09755237400531769,
0.44764411449432373,
-0.045376069843769073,
0.5628568530082703,
0.008085698820650578,
-0.670005202293396,
0.3910154402256012,
-0.4568304419517517,
-0.290047824382782,
0.5673558712005615,
-0.5525095462799072,
0.3205849528312683,
0.051095135509967804,
-0.3482173681259155,
-0.564598798751831,
0.2271270751953125,
-0.30438920855522156,
0.46788862347602844,
0.5008596777915955,
0.4756336808204651,
0.1645449548959732,
-0.15612107515335083,
0.8883634805679321,
-0.16068166494369507,
0.4544292390346527,
0.7766569256782532,
-0.17813417315483093,
0.813528299331665,
0.5584533214569092,
-0.3117256462574005,
0.3615189492702484,
0.9470071196556091,
0.00019613630138337612,
0.5475860834121704,
0.3167015612125397,
-0.08570138365030289,
-0.18703486025333405,
-0.3332727253437042,
-0.4889867901802063,
0.5282055139541626,
0.11369659751653671,
-0.5095730423927307,
-0.14241181313991547,
0.3211856484413147,
0.23311445116996765,
0.10144613683223724,
-0.03274954855442047,
0.9179551005363464,
0.010222908109426498,
-0.20131543278694153,
0.24185235798358917,
0.14891046285629272,
0.44282066822052,
-0.17270493507385254,
-0.10252216458320618,
0.38784441351890564,
-0.18106336891651154,
-0.42063575983047485,
-0.6888803839683533,
0.7899506092071533,
0.15075039863586426,
-0.1901920884847641,
-0.10621311515569687,
1.0472149848937988,
-0.12133534252643585,
-0.4293695390224457,
0.4155494272708893,
0.21761225163936615,
0.3636319041252136,
-0.26386791467666626,
-0.5031642317771912,
0.36507269740104675,
-0.43556714057922363,
-0.18324817717075348,
0.345573365688324,
0.48428037762641907,
-0.13025523722171783,
0.2985968589782715,
0.8252407312393188,
0.08741965144872665,
-0.0303468257188797,
0.029781842604279518,
0.8700914978981018,
-0.5171710252761841,
-0.6949893236160278,
-0.8842451572418213,
0.7035708427429199,
-0.5267404317855835,
-0.5954998135566711,
0.8531249761581421,
0.4910162091255188,
0.6307719349861145,
0.3068060874938965,
0.993250846862793,
-0.5928834080696106,
0.7043651342391968,
-0.009855182841420174,
1.0070250034332275,
-0.43479591608047485,
-0.020824795588850975,
-0.9367635250091553,
-0.8857682347297668,
-0.7144907116889954,
0.8987499475479126,
-0.8032135963439941,
-0.07934270054101944,
0.5482177734375,
0.5253944993019104,
0.16811375319957733,
0.3666275143623352,
0.3808661103248596,
0.15325294435024261,
0.11129532754421234,
-0.06594417244195938,
0.9010990858078003,
-0.5867447257041931,
0.584778368473053,
-0.44564351439476013,
-0.49137404561042786,
-0.5779263377189636,
-1.0256319046020508,
-1.25749933719635,
-0.7768973112106323,
-0.28891146183013916,
-0.26985740661621094,
0.007826963439583778,
0.9313185811042786,
0.47593653202056885,
-0.5855945348739624,
0.14476698637008667,
0.02661818079650402,
-0.10539241880178452,
0.07827746123075485,
-0.26034945249557495,
0.2700696289539337,
0.10932629555463791,
-0.2862166166305542,
-0.1481732577085495,
0.5463353991508484,
-0.21034172177314758,
-0.3142721951007843,
0.16787925362586975,
-0.44633206725120544,
-0.03168352693319321,
0.8525604605674744,
0.08428782224655151,
-0.5361573696136475,
-0.5029441714286804,
-0.2478170543909073,
0.08396698534488678,
-0.0660489872097969,
0.8352757692337036,
-0.16114257276058197,
0.5059078931808472,
0.30494654178619385,
0.46202462911605835,
-0.04051359370350838,
-0.0075644454918801785,
0.22472113370895386,
-0.6748947501182556,
0.14563807845115662,
0.2359687089920044,
0.12819895148277283,
0.5090376138687134,
-0.7621800303459167,
0.4135245084762573,
0.39701899886131287,
-0.4557742476463318,
-1.076966643333435,
0.2676924765110016,
-0.775124192237854,
-0.17965878546237946,
1.4281916618347168,
-0.3298836052417755,
-0.04206443950533867,
-0.5017884373664856,
-0.670336902141571,
0.6683903932571411,
-0.31968528032302856,
1.2802128791809082,
0.5905565023422241,
0.002750936197116971,
-0.09552569687366486,
-0.46768179535865784,
0.6340047717094421,
0.10263723880052567,
-1.184414029121399,
0.2137436419725418,
0.49875301122665405,
-0.18748115003108978,
0.5210357904434204,
0.396526962518692,
0.0971330851316452,
0.1186671108007431,
0.23500917851924896,
0.2892366349697113,
-0.07615870237350464,
-0.2512918710708618,
0.010472097434103489,
0.59364914894104,
-0.37634143233299255,
0.0015578351449221373
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11103v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11103v2
|
ProgGen: Generating Named Entity Recognition Datasets Step-by-step with Self-Reflexive Large Language Models
| 2024-03-17T06:12:43 | 2024-06-09T04:48:35 |
Yuzhao Heng, Chunyuan Deng, Yitong Li, Yue Yu, Yinghao Li, Rongzhi Zhang, Chao Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Although Large Language Models (LLMs) exhibit remarkable adaptability across
domains, these models often fall short in structured knowledge extraction tasks
such as named entity recognition (NER). This paper explores an innovative,
cost-efficient strategy to harness LLMs with modest NER capabilities for
producing superior NER datasets. Our approach diverges from the basic
class-conditional prompts by instructing LLMs to self-reflect on the specific
domain, thereby generating domain-relevant attributes (such as category and
emotions for movie reviews), which are utilized for creating attribute-rich
training data. Furthermore, we preemptively generate entity terms and then
develop NER context data around these entities, effectively bypassing the LLMs'
challenges with complex structures. Our experiments across both general and
niche domains reveal significant performance enhancements over conventional
data generation methods while being more cost-effective than existing
alternatives.
|
[
-0.46565550565719604,
-0.2536586821079254,
0.4361114501953125,
-0.10111487656831741,
-0.1781896948814392,
-0.0460917167365551,
-0.272117555141449,
-0.3543620705604553,
0.4012087285518646,
0.5473820567131042,
-0.512082576751709,
-0.322926789522171,
-0.28557464480400085,
0.28006818890571594,
-0.3024674654006958,
1.022535800933838,
0.15093068778514862,
-0.12882472574710846,
-0.2262483537197113,
0.043636634945869446,
-0.16921411454677582,
-0.5351665019989014,
-0.7000502347946167,
-0.1873224526643753,
0.7401973605155945,
0.4727798402309418,
0.22385366261005402,
0.3614441752433777,
0.4559353291988373,
0.24745598435401917,
0.4001457393169403,
0.36799272894859314,
-0.29363948106765747,
0.17672958970069885,
-0.2423461228609085,
-0.18745696544647217,
-0.4327133297920227,
0.056243669241666794,
0.668666422367096,
0.36737683415412903,
-0.09791526198387146,
0.1994047462940216,
0.1373499035835266,
0.5714057087898254,
-0.6515799760818481,
0.16595707833766937,
-0.8164846897125244,
-0.029258880764245987,
-0.37675726413726807,
-0.035731516778469086,
-0.3602294325828552,
-0.23148468136787415,
0.31040623784065247,
-0.6209449768066406,
0.4154667556285858,
0.09835022687911987,
0.9433034062385559,
-0.027445552870631218,
-0.17438538372516632,
-0.2405327409505844,
-0.5818801522254944,
0.6262012124061584,
-0.7109503746032715,
0.5537508130073547,
0.03514249250292778,
0.271344929933548,
-0.3318006694316864,
-0.8326351046562195,
-0.7803287506103516,
-0.14039352536201477,
-0.15338847041130066,
-0.004334450699388981,
-0.2244529128074646,
-0.24876055121421814,
0.17287811636924744,
0.31514719128608704,
-0.3112887740135193,
0.19719262421131134,
0.0131212854757905,
-0.054558638483285904,
0.661268413066864,
0.026597797870635986,
0.2050458937883377,
-0.3486784100532532,
-0.24471619725227356,
0.0559106320142746,
-1.1274672746658325,
-0.09161744266748428,
0.43852609395980835,
0.5529174208641052,
0.4610242545604706,
0.4308147132396698,
-0.11540473997592926,
0.4996185004711151,
0.3981090188026428,
-0.2415357381105423,
0.2495754361152649,
0.05580044537782669,
-0.12831580638885498,
0.14946629106998444,
0.8557658195495605,
0.22039026021957397,
0.22623607516288757,
-0.6359264254570007,
-0.4214288592338562,
-0.3007386326789856,
0.27112215757369995,
-1.0968177318572998,
-0.4764896035194397,
0.05246463418006897,
-0.14990447461605072,
-0.19590908288955688,
-0.21079286932945251,
-0.7763432860374451,
-0.36041438579559326,
-0.46268707513809204,
0.6620438694953918,
-0.25852513313293457,
-0.3977275490760803,
-0.07649065554141998,
0.23519271612167358,
0.23330157995224,
0.2022036910057068,
-0.7794631719589233,
0.22456032037734985,
0.27520111203193665,
0.6239690780639648,
-0.3390972912311554,
0.08153869211673737,
-0.6928953528404236,
0.20406021177768707,
-0.27679353952407837,
0.8161760568618774,
-0.5005355477333069,
-0.3647632896900177,
-0.1745123714208603,
0.12033899873495102,
0.07142461091279984,
-0.8507207632064819,
0.11021573841571808,
-0.7616447806358337,
0.04082648456096649,
-0.2964312434196472,
-0.7000110745429993,
0.03719926252961159,
0.2097068428993225,
-0.7360882759094238,
0.7949344515800476,
0.12602363526821136,
-0.8739450573921204,
0.5281127691268921,
-0.3850390613079071,
-0.4017106890678406,
0.5771603584289551,
-0.470895916223526,
-0.44978615641593933,
0.1594693511724472,
0.1859133094549179,
0.7334258556365967,
-0.4902118444442749,
0.650070309638977,
0.022807497531175613,
0.19488739967346191,
0.20539765059947968,
0.027397578582167625,
0.1152106374502182,
0.11400043964385986,
-0.4973772466182709,
-0.18245427310466766,
-1.0363686084747314,
-0.06287968903779984,
0.4145655333995819,
-0.44929638504981995,
-0.5794257521629333,
0.2009536325931549,
-0.20418718457221985,
0.025740772485733032,
-0.04890042170882225,
-0.4425344467163086,
0.25098374485969543,
-0.2885787785053253,
0.11365588009357452,
0.6286200284957886,
-0.004463875666260719,
0.574996829032898,
0.33340218663215637,
0.4057653248310089,
0.12318038940429688,
-0.2951752841472626,
0.11739294230937958,
-0.002805605996400118,
-0.9421995878219604,
-0.47126975655555725,
0.5967009663581848,
0.3433305621147156,
-1.1126068830490112,
0.4519101679325104,
-0.4076023995876312,
-0.43742635846138,
-0.3218851089477539,
0.08221177011728287,
0.44000083208084106,
0.7949999570846558,
0.35177069902420044,
-0.4022926092147827,
-0.5905013084411621,
-1.0558128356933594,
-0.2996746301651001,
-0.007398699410259724,
-0.14958545565605164,
0.6004132032394409,
0.43120020627975464,
-0.16977715492248535,
1.1842759847640991,
-0.5759589076042175,
-0.3668096363544464,
-0.4105159044265747,
0.07883977144956589,
0.23827563226222992,
0.5080923438072205,
0.3400898277759552,
-0.7111091613769531,
-0.27278950810432434,
-0.24790175259113312,
-0.7288434505462646,
-0.1567876636981964,
-0.2056441307067871,
-0.23690593242645264,
-0.05440849810838699,
0.41630175709724426,
-0.6018773913383484,
-0.12084853649139404,
0.20208361744880676,
-0.048849813640117645,
0.6637438535690308,
0.11327388882637024,
-0.23282641172409058,
-1.0404216051101685,
0.12866704165935516,
0.21732202172279358,
-0.2230115681886673,
-0.7979506254196167,
-0.13010558485984802,
-0.043497342616319656,
-0.038990844041109085,
-0.521070659160614,
0.8462557196617126,
-0.9490479826927185,
-0.04805963486433029,
-0.11750214546918869,
0.22222033143043518,
-0.08749677985906601,
0.3986775577068329,
0.41212794184684753,
0.8878443837165833,
0.6183759570121765,
-1.039917230606079,
0.19583332538604736,
0.19947288930416107,
-0.5249704718589783,
0.484953910112381,
-0.5394434332847595,
0.11618643254041672,
-0.30647313594818115,
0.07904654741287231,
-0.32118499279022217,
-0.41550716757774353,
0.22935093939304352,
-0.054188910871744156,
0.6760661602020264,
-0.057902369648218155,
-0.33474600315093994,
-0.35333117842674255,
0.058273714035749435,
0.3606378436088562,
0.539901614189148,
-0.9373311400413513,
0.8385207056999207,
0.7011943459510803,
-0.412941575050354,
-0.4110676348209381,
-0.3986159861087799,
0.3683388829231262,
-0.39646148681640625,
-0.14945892989635468,
0.4526340663433075,
0.13114532828330994,
-0.06413746625185013,
-0.05940859764814377,
-0.16908571124076843,
0.17733988165855408,
-0.015585610643029213,
-0.019606532528996468,
0.10247428715229034,
-0.13286079466342926,
0.4294854402542114,
-0.21620357036590576,
-0.09562697261571884,
0.09330614656209946,
-0.6152141094207764,
0.3178684115409851,
-0.02901051752269268,
0.0049186949618160725,
-0.0404156856238842,
0.2206237018108368,
0.0366775318980217,
-0.4233176112174988,
0.6131060719490051,
0.43425285816192627,
-0.4722154140472412,
-0.5043612718582153,
-0.6886426210403442,
-0.29378432035446167,
-0.47830289602279663,
0.32060763239860535,
-0.5726258754730225,
-0.9558029770851135,
0.3087558448314667,
-0.3547888398170471,
0.08963805437088013,
0.3830171227455139,
0.3783673942089081,
0.16253861784934998,
0.7211064100265503,
0.39405298233032227,
0.1565658003091812,
0.5109334588050842,
-0.2295183539390564,
0.6467308402061462,
-0.881207287311554,
-0.36313745379447937,
-0.18457157909870148,
-0.2837658226490021,
-0.4446324110031128,
-0.26999372243881226,
0.3012329041957855,
0.18713055551052094,
-0.22592948377132416,
0.4823392629623413,
-0.4538845121860504,
0.6151126623153687,
0.6362239718437195,
0.07311266660690308,
-0.023286713287234306,
0.18209753930568695,
0.008919940330088139,
-0.14768630266189575,
-0.6944974660873413,
-0.6837464570999146,
0.9474869966506958,
0.053516220301389694,
0.8459444642066956,
0.1572260558605194,
0.9904006719589233,
0.10781271755695343,
0.6018043756484985,
-0.7940888404846191,
0.8788137435913086,
-0.23094582557678223,
-0.32284337282180786,
-0.12697097659111023,
-0.5844328999519348,
-0.9075391888618469,
0.11346479505300522,
-0.3035096824169159,
-0.5641361474990845,
0.4750725030899048,
0.2778981328010559,
-0.3792472779750824,
0.35322874784469604,
-0.5219188332557678,
0.6365603804588318,
-0.2962794601917267,
-0.3568010628223419,
0.33463019132614136,
-0.44707050919532776,
0.35549601912498474,
-0.39232155680656433,
0.04536902904510498,
-0.18860788643360138,
-0.01745189167559147,
0.8687006235122681,
-0.27457043528556824,
0.7615102529525757,
-0.373542845249176,
-0.22974491119384766,
0.5909728407859802,
0.3585415482521057,
0.5801287293434143,
0.30434849858283997,
-0.018244819715619087,
0.13038961589336395,
-0.7170574069023132,
0.04366671293973923,
-0.5142034888267517,
0.7038553357124329,
-0.5229735374450684,
-0.6775210499763489,
-0.186564639210701,
-0.3698456287384033,
-0.3505280613899231,
0.3306507468223572,
0.25270262360572815,
0.7180292010307312,
-0.20907916128635406,
-0.034825440496206284,
0.8827675580978394,
-0.260080486536026,
0.4542616605758667,
0.6324348449707031,
-0.04944998398423195,
-0.5286399126052856,
1.2261866331100464,
0.36207515001296997,
-0.007331128232181072,
0.3207135796546936,
-0.048274457454681396,
-0.37386780977249146,
-0.39905399084091187,
-0.41755470633506775,
0.2992139160633087,
-0.6493778824806213,
-0.6517089605331421,
-1.0472577810287476,
-0.210989311337471,
-0.32649320363998413,
0.1166122779250145,
-0.32061201333999634,
-0.36653202772140503,
-0.43236657977104187,
-0.2059813290834427,
0.28500494360923767,
0.49901413917541504,
-0.10750090330839157,
0.3141261041164398,
-0.8049625158309937,
0.2814987897872925,
0.7238005995750427,
0.3042079210281372,
0.08990179002285004,
-0.23477023839950562,
-0.16304048895835876,
-0.3485441207885742,
-0.14100314676761627,
-0.8176299333572388,
0.5696064829826355,
0.6634984612464905,
0.6300796270370483,
0.2949322462081909,
0.10442797839641571,
0.3699363172054291,
-0.8373706936836243,
0.8462647795677185,
0.3255675137042999,
-0.7829338312149048,
0.6130132675170898,
-0.10093427449464798,
-0.02359687350690365,
0.4279845058917999,
0.6166604161262512,
-0.11861752718687057,
-0.17118920385837555,
-0.7436032295227051,
-1.0664466619491577,
0.4795604944229126,
0.14368323981761932,
0.1791488528251648,
-0.4678246080875397,
0.6748930215835571,
0.2668619155883789,
0.3254657983779907,
-0.786767303943634,
0.01353705208748579,
0.032790638506412506,
-0.211107075214386,
-0.15665622055530548,
-0.3512967824935913,
0.06907761096954346,
-0.1254226267337799,
0.9022788405418396,
-0.34174585342407227,
0.2581300139427185,
0.3900549113750458,
-0.3575969934463501,
0.2835978865623474,
0.40279078483581543,
0.08179663121700287,
0.25515061616897583,
0.09590675681829453,
0.4747353196144104,
0.2684451639652252,
-0.2301766574382782,
0.17727605998516083,
-0.08051156997680664,
-0.21446536481380463,
0.09142538160085678,
0.129945769906044,
0.8651461601257324,
0.15823853015899658,
-0.6246386766433716,
0.49490031599998474,
-0.07749932259321213,
-0.21931879222393036,
-0.17503826320171356,
0.11720088869333267,
0.1373862326145172,
0.43879759311676025,
0.2525692582130432,
-0.34926602244377136,
0.2202271968126297,
-0.26637303829193115,
0.29135602712631226,
0.407203733921051,
-0.028150230646133423,
-0.4994567036628723,
0.61838698387146,
0.22915491461753845,
-0.06913500279188156,
0.719831645488739,
-0.483073353767395,
-0.48982295393943787,
0.3032873570919037,
0.7845237255096436,
1.0519593954086304,
-0.254550963640213,
0.2406979650259018,
0.6001321077346802,
-0.1342029720544815,
-0.25450414419174194,
0.32086631655693054,
-0.06724375486373901,
-0.8439399600028992,
-0.156357541680336,
-0.8760251402854919,
-0.284552663564682,
0.21214428544044495,
-0.5474604964256287,
0.22949804365634918,
-0.3314611315727234,
-0.4253886640071869,
0.01466374658048153,
-0.29763367772102356,
-0.8456945419311523,
0.46255525946617126,
0.2635662853717804,
0.7637145519256592,
-0.6191654205322266,
0.6023505330085754,
0.6581513285636902,
-0.3953061103820801,
-0.9364177584648132,
-0.0957244336605072,
-0.3981083929538727,
-0.5453076362609863,
1.0093975067138672,
0.3437465727329254,
-0.15086370706558228,
0.38049015402793884,
-0.5892797112464905,
-0.794965922832489,
0.9426791071891785,
0.4488239586353302,
-1.0046716928482056,
-0.23860229551792145,
-0.15451347827911377,
0.3651829659938812,
-0.7123742699623108,
0.022867757827043533,
0.6667501926422119,
0.2741292119026184,
0.01656525209546089,
-0.4802184998989105,
0.17623281478881836,
-0.26952603459358215,
0.030711909756064415,
0.24636535346508026,
-0.4511161744594574,
0.6835041046142578,
-0.40713632106781006,
-0.528170645236969,
-0.4284139573574066,
0.9254314303398132,
0.1737537533044815,
-0.06425406783819199,
0.6059525012969971,
0.5228659510612488,
0.8357217311859131,
-0.007144024129956961,
0.7656661868095398,
-0.2942315638065338,
0.12975731492042542,
1.1665767431259155,
-0.5764678120613098,
0.7981187105178833,
0.3801426291465759,
0.0032687808852642775,
0.5223908424377441,
0.54435133934021,
-0.21895410120487213,
0.7647149562835693,
0.4365209937095642,
-0.5550459623336792,
-0.6664535999298096,
-0.33425450325012207,
-0.1587429642677307,
0.3139643669128418,
0.23535548150539398,
-0.17754560708999634,
-0.16848061978816986,
0.09651228785514832,
-0.01070254947990179,
-0.3518586754798889,
-0.3819493353366852,
1.0646127462387085,
0.23719309270381927,
-0.5906060338020325,
0.3228877782821655,
-0.2847612798213959,
0.6900247931480408,
-0.4459415674209595,
0.02780638262629509,
-0.17685839533805847,
0.1844557225704193,
-0.20383505523204803,
-0.5056447386741638,
-0.005998979322612286,
0.3266427516937256,
-0.1776275485754013,
-0.18222776055335999,
0.983015775680542,
-0.580470085144043,
-0.542871356010437,
0.0968165174126625,
0.6183371543884277,
0.3428843021392822,
-0.05841576308012009,
-0.2834838628768921,
-0.4711307883262634,
-0.3281208574771881,
-0.5736441016197205,
0.39367228746414185,
0.41935282945632935,
-0.07833368331193924,
0.5482799410820007,
0.4897293746471405,
0.23119975626468658,
-0.023194169625639915,
0.25926756858825684,
1.0065544843673706,
-0.5801476836204529,
-0.2867525517940521,
-0.7785716652870178,
0.4504797160625458,
-0.14133480191230774,
-0.021602237597107887,
0.5477952361106873,
0.5494437217712402,
0.8043822646141052,
-0.2277953028678894,
0.803877055644989,
-0.22463026642799377,
0.40399280190467834,
-0.5534000396728516,
0.5275181531906128,
-0.6489613056182861,
0.1080569475889206,
-0.16477838158607483,
-0.9688050746917725,
-0.4140162169933319,
0.4762284457683563,
-0.30844539403915405,
-0.035835977643728256,
0.3801921308040619,
0.8520716428756714,
0.02122003212571144,
-0.25815439224243164,
0.046729203313589096,
0.10051174461841583,
0.5199688076972961,
0.4410025179386139,
0.7269529700279236,
-0.33574843406677246,
0.25148260593414307,
0.17897504568099976,
-0.09721757471561432,
-0.017551252618432045,
-1.0844985246658325,
-0.9062129259109497,
-0.3934091627597809,
-0.5284829139709473,
-0.2657560110092163,
-0.0014110106276348233,
0.9656872749328613,
0.6644953489303589,
-0.9533652663230896,
0.21307703852653503,
-0.14108619093894958,
-0.17525255680084229,
0.09055688232183456,
-0.21351999044418335,
0.5033972859382629,
-0.45661988854408264,
-0.6284605264663696,
0.5431336760520935,
0.08778996020555496,
0.13225485384464264,
-0.13127537071704865,
-0.10669006407260895,
0.1295052468776703,
0.14306838810443878,
0.5703930854797363,
0.19038593769073486,
-0.560541033744812,
-0.3421691656112671,
0.0678931176662445,
0.006909716874361038,
-0.07083441317081451,
0.8645150065422058,
-1.0028616189956665,
0.28823599219322205,
0.3518761694431305,
0.834039032459259,
0.1832263171672821,
-0.07844546437263489,
0.5769644975662231,
-0.8771871328353882,
-0.3820771872997284,
0.19982604682445526,
0.32653117179870605,
0.6046922206878662,
-0.516431987285614,
0.3848203718662262,
0.2501347064971924,
-0.518489420413971,
-0.7904736995697021,
0.28498125076293945,
-0.5933080911636353,
-0.04715873301029205,
1.1818480491638184,
-0.1754285991191864,
-0.17415234446525574,
0.2520195245742798,
-0.031394317746162415,
0.12783844769001007,
-0.223052516579628,
0.568662166595459,
0.29246750473976135,
-0.16251827776432037,
-0.13185393810272217,
-0.22187206149101257,
0.5908347368240356,
0.08637505769729614,
-0.8493729829788208,
0.13760526478290558,
0.5077009797096252,
0.5988656282424927,
0.08414698392152786,
0.659625232219696,
-0.07495924085378647,
-0.09119986742734909,
-0.09113556146621704,
0.5671806335449219,
-0.09077127277851105,
-0.6987228989601135,
-0.15551213920116425,
0.170390322804451,
0.05214015766978264,
0.08076633512973785
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11092v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11092v1
|
Lost in Translation? Translation Errors and Challenges for Fair Assessment of Text-to-Image Models on Multilingual Concepts
| 2024-03-17T05:05:11 | 2024-03-17T05:05:11 |
Michael Saxon, Yiran Luo, Sharon Levy, Chitta Baral, Yezhou Yang, William Yang Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.CY, eess.IV
|
Benchmarks of the multilingual capabilities of text-to-image (T2I) models
compare generated images prompted in a test language to an expected image
distribution over a concept set. One such benchmark, "Conceptual Coverage
Across Languages" (CoCo-CroLa), assesses the tangible noun inventory of T2I
models by prompting them to generate pictures from a concept list translated to
seven languages and comparing the output image populations. Unfortunately, we
find that this benchmark contains translation errors of varying severity in
Spanish, Japanese, and Chinese. We provide corrections for these errors and
analyze how impactful they are on the utility and validity of CoCo-CroLa as a
benchmark. We reassess multiple baseline T2I models with the revisions, compare
the outputs elicited under the new translations to those conditioned on the
old, and show that a correction's impactfulness on the image-domain benchmark
results can be predicted in the text domain with similarity scores. Our
findings will guide the future development of T2I multilinguality metrics by
providing analytical tools for practical translation decisions.
|
[
-0.0038411200512200594,
-0.2935541868209839,
0.39845678210258484,
0.6144973039627075,
-0.2346806824207306,
0.21160946786403656,
-0.224795401096344,
-0.8185235261917114,
-0.2387525886297226,
0.32070013880729675,
-0.21260057389736176,
-0.2265075296163559,
-1.0608434677124023,
0.2977602481842041,
-0.46208760142326355,
0.732006311416626,
-0.5917679071426392,
0.23462721705436707,
-0.3474230468273163,
-0.4764464795589447,
-0.7221747636795044,
-0.10074501484632492,
-0.4505404531955719,
-0.09778569638729095,
0.32251986861228943,
0.5641143321990967,
0.7355573177337646,
0.4070371687412262,
0.6397925615310669,
0.17740119993686676,
0.006756510119885206,
0.28996965289115906,
-0.42874476313591003,
-0.35692068934440613,
-0.23017457127571106,
-0.5517362356185913,
-0.2820921838283539,
0.03555555269122124,
0.6846982836723328,
0.7979914546012878,
0.014611488208174706,
0.05559256672859192,
0.0389382429420948,
0.5270593166351318,
-0.7798559665679932,
0.19765955209732056,
-0.5577989220619202,
0.11987994611263275,
-0.23832468688488007,
-0.29808542132377625,
-0.5684676766395569,
-0.27942994236946106,
-0.054897990077733994,
-0.5261656641960144,
0.4724733829498291,
-0.038867827504873276,
0.9753709435462952,
0.2831694483757019,
-0.5727705359458923,
-0.593678891658783,
-0.6781322360038757,
1.0533567667007446,
-0.5403758883476257,
0.3700445890426636,
0.22410902380943298,
0.30186474323272705,
-0.08510997146368027,
-0.5964592695236206,
-0.4906597137451172,
-0.03461381047964096,
-0.00005815498298034072,
0.29578039050102234,
-0.13940608501434326,
-0.44415292143821716,
0.0072057717479765415,
0.2162853628396988,
-0.3886883556842804,
-0.1726246476173401,
-0.3997286260128021,
-0.14638012647628784,
0.5826313495635986,
-0.10907875746488571,
0.39617297053337097,
0.06931661814451218,
-0.24652178585529327,
-0.30678218603134155,
-0.7339916825294495,
-0.0662231370806694,
0.16479814052581787,
0.19334281980991364,
-0.3502373993396759,
0.7898297905921936,
0.12619690597057343,
0.3026336133480072,
-0.40632909536361694,
-0.3149726092815399,
0.43784716725349426,
-0.6056802868843079,
0.07146895676851273,
-0.0015544294146820903,
0.6732984781265259,
0.8022704124450684,
0.37156277894973755,
-0.23599472641944885,
-0.28132709860801697,
0.1932850480079651,
-0.19808253645896912,
-0.6308819651603699,
0.25730177760124207,
0.08190882205963135,
-0.2501693665981293,
-0.22662505507469177,
-0.006924272980540991,
-0.5828589797019958,
-0.166767880320549,
0.17047879099845886,
-0.0032520045060664415,
-0.0973738580942154,
-0.24016760289669037,
0.03137938305735588,
-0.3567959666252136,
0.09049618244171143,
0.44408276677131653,
-0.5040080547332764,
0.22690875828266144,
0.2587299942970276,
0.8737203478813171,
-0.1952418088912964,
-0.33458733558654785,
0.009887677617371082,
0.21203039586544037,
-0.9189767241477966,
0.9396358728408813,
-0.2555235028266907,
-0.6658782362937927,
0.2414960414171219,
0.05254368856549263,
-0.33149850368499756,
-0.5895510911941528,
0.4562428295612335,
-0.25172877311706543,
0.21298471093177795,
-0.5340535044670105,
-0.33554643392562866,
-0.17020197212696075,
0.46164989471435547,
-0.5411809682846069,
0.9315133690834045,
0.2224552184343338,
-0.7640875577926636,
0.22838933765888214,
-0.3397556245326996,
-0.5118595361709595,
-0.19739535450935364,
-0.24152213335037231,
-0.2954205274581909,
0.218058243393898,
0.011510148644447327,
0.14052213728427887,
-0.5790576338768005,
0.2157435119152069,
-0.2830412983894348,
-0.24798192083835602,
0.48015090823173523,
-0.3183339834213257,
0.6821295022964478,
0.06679695099592209,
-0.38051146268844604,
-0.26089414954185486,
-0.4818374514579773,
0.12293878942728043,
0.45656058192253113,
-0.1803416758775711,
-0.10600461810827255,
0.1298968493938446,
0.5279237627983093,
0.2766823172569275,
0.044543661177158356,
-0.6036499738693237,
-0.06972689181566238,
0.043007705360651016,
0.4527505040168762,
0.34431248903274536,
-0.08262477070093155,
0.39040663838386536,
-0.23952975869178772,
0.3601025938987732,
0.3663584291934967,
0.14129240810871124,
-0.04708203300833702,
-0.8353963494300842,
-0.6116113066673279,
0.19234143197536469,
0.4133519232273102,
0.6443982124328613,
-0.9987928867340088,
-0.2405615895986557,
-0.5430780649185181,
-0.5963541269302368,
-0.5884838700294495,
-0.017120197415351868,
0.5697649121284485,
0.47456416487693787,
0.3824138939380646,
-0.5330568552017212,
-0.019923292100429535,
-0.8925694823265076,
-0.39110326766967773,
-0.1000632494688034,
0.20894883573055267,
0.3586770296096802,
0.7153214812278748,
-0.4237026870250702,
0.5351876616477966,
-0.27225592732429504,
-0.706397294998169,
-0.198795348405838,
0.21919356286525726,
-0.20344413816928864,
0.5436641573905945,
0.7926437854766846,
-1.0079188346862793,
-0.5743906497955322,
0.43129631876945496,
-0.7467368841171265,
0.10030863434076309,
-0.11784397810697556,
0.150571808218956,
0.32381510734558105,
0.37569618225097656,
-0.38551077246665955,
0.5798773169517517,
0.5838139653205872,
-0.11414851248264313,
0.445104718208313,
-0.17544186115264893,
0.5811089873313904,
-1.127254843711853,
0.21868500113487244,
0.1074681207537651,
-0.12850821018218994,
-0.38495296239852905,
0.297680139541626,
0.5286177396774292,
-0.0025912795681506395,
-0.6686094999313354,
0.6213343739509583,
-0.3215547502040863,
-0.3288012444972992,
-0.15276198089122772,
0.4223032295703888,
0.27611979842185974,
0.1752002090215683,
0.006004864349961281,
1.0470669269561768,
0.3132512867450714,
-0.43949654698371887,
0.19946110248565674,
0.4938996732234955,
-0.44884175062179565,
0.7228719592094421,
-0.709674060344696,
0.11842386424541473,
-0.21566270291805267,
0.29462191462516785,
-0.9266153573989868,
-0.20632055401802063,
0.571221113204956,
-0.7333236336708069,
0.3874456286430359,
0.007971721701323986,
-0.4779117703437805,
-0.20626714825630188,
-0.28426870703697205,
0.8260841369628906,
0.20762532949447632,
-0.3022744953632355,
0.26180362701416016,
0.3690918982028961,
0.13847029209136963,
-0.9873104095458984,
-1.3524231910705566,
0.4454893171787262,
0.027342598885297775,
-0.35638052225112915,
0.4749153256416321,
-0.26146721839904785,
-0.0761045292019844,
0.20149335265159607,
0.0046647884882986546,
-0.33941173553466797,
0.03204035013914108,
-0.08540261536836624,
-0.07351884990930557,
-0.13895735144615173,
0.048136886209249496,
0.1170443743467331,
0.07777424901723862,
-0.04226027429103851,
-0.17377527058124542,
0.08611708134412766,
-0.13646985590457916,
-0.1660805642604828,
-0.31406497955322266,
0.4018641412258148,
0.49302926659584045,
-0.3393595814704895,
0.4954773783683777,
0.43146488070487976,
-0.6253877282142639,
0.17629113793373108,
-0.5208386182785034,
0.5235246419906616,
-0.3275821805000305,
0.5364689826965332,
-0.5562247633934021,
-0.29326102137565613,
0.6767119765281677,
0.10599362105131149,
0.04975065216422081,
0.6881380081176758,
0.39000403881073,
-0.17683766782283783,
0.8301624655723572,
0.6937995553016663,
0.2596499025821686,
0.28419023752212524,
-0.5212333798408508,
0.2318374663591385,
-0.8151523470878601,
-0.5183980464935303,
-0.8972688317298889,
-0.16506198048591614,
-0.6836231350898743,
-0.7968697547912598,
0.2520526647567749,
-0.04136253148317337,
0.17398428916931152,
0.4941455125808716,
-0.1659960001707077,
0.4825778305530548,
0.25191330909729004,
0.03037860058248043,
0.43326640129089355,
0.12994706630706787,
-0.12392223626375198,
-0.196015864610672,
-0.7530241012573242,
-0.5370462536811829,
0.94398033618927,
0.18696242570877075,
0.5528156757354736,
0.20099520683288574,
0.2780535817146301,
0.35835158824920654,
0.5491166114807129,
-0.9422276020050049,
0.19021296501159668,
-0.2840695381164551,
-0.44015803933143616,
0.10035420954227448,
-0.4830440580844879,
-0.7213417887687683,
0.16649329662322998,
-0.1267743855714798,
-0.4170999825000763,
0.4840342700481415,
0.18081626296043396,
0.27381813526153564,
0.35481372475624084,
-0.6002587080001831,
1.16336989402771,
-0.32790347933769226,
-0.1764823943376541,
-0.4538293182849884,
-0.5124205350875854,
0.3217300474643707,
-0.22237727046012878,
0.49807310104370117,
-0.2311704456806183,
-0.3530530035495758,
0.5094895362854004,
-0.10033193230628967,
0.38780099153518677,
0.17370392382144928,
-0.14312320947647095,
0.34213995933532715,
0.17215503752231598,
0.1753331571817398,
-0.040712691843509674,
-0.12970998883247375,
0.5073287487030029,
0.2569267749786377,
-0.8839918375015259,
-0.5203312039375305,
0.5350902676582336,
-0.75804203748703,
-0.15371361374855042,
-0.5061377882957458,
-0.5247119069099426,
-0.11910867691040039,
0.17921046912670135,
0.6195225119590759,
0.36618515849113464,
-0.37461093068122864,
0.037228647619485855,
0.22888363897800446,
-0.37684041261672974,
0.3463393747806549,
0.2319384068250656,
0.039911992847919464,
-0.37605345249176025,
0.8016968369483948,
0.13531935214996338,
0.45208585262298584,
0.3380843997001648,
-0.1118234246969223,
-0.4357941150665283,
-0.47240889072418213,
-0.9048816561698914,
0.3217357397079468,
-0.9923565983772278,
-0.21712127327919006,
-0.3415547311306,
0.19761709868907928,
-0.2942675054073334,
0.04361293464899063,
-0.6111510396003723,
-0.36235156655311584,
-0.3002844750881195,
0.18722765147686005,
-0.21040332317352295,
0.7375820279121399,
0.24402497708797455,
0.2613828778266907,
-0.8969167470932007,
0.10649418830871582,
-0.27795296907424927,
0.30278950929641724,
0.025896942242980003,
-0.6226283311843872,
-0.45410585403442383,
0.17960162460803986,
-0.5274153351783752,
-0.9392284154891968,
0.10563936084508896,
0.35727256536483765,
0.24284440279006958,
0.20559419691562653,
-0.06465142965316772,
0.7954491972923279,
-0.610052764415741,
0.6414452791213989,
0.4901391565799713,
-1.0062057971954346,
0.45002511143684387,
-0.029223725199699402,
0.24961647391319275,
0.3486396074295044,
0.26788774132728577,
-1.014540195465088,
-0.5129315853118896,
-0.4093078672885895,
-0.572563886642456,
0.3877851366996765,
0.27532511949539185,
0.28214192390441895,
-0.22983068227767944,
0.21225231885910034,
-0.17401856184005737,
0.21479864418506622,
-0.8089491128921509,
-0.02234700508415699,
-0.28407126665115356,
-0.2318052351474762,
-0.25490063428878784,
-0.2649551331996918,
-0.054467592388391495,
0.03695972263813019,
0.7089775800704956,
-0.3117300570011139,
0.23433810472488403,
0.4530054032802582,
-0.43143531680107117,
-0.4605964422225952,
0.2349744290113449,
0.7589238882064819,
0.7303574085235596,
0.05450461804866791,
-0.0775931179523468,
0.10904766619205475,
-0.28487712144851685,
0.09126035869121552,
-0.2060878723859787,
-0.26118701696395874,
0.27300259470939636,
0.4743245840072632,
0.7100317478179932,
0.32330161333084106,
-0.8439507484436035,
0.6780365705490112,
-0.30019423365592957,
-0.11043090373277664,
-0.4071630835533142,
-0.44048914313316345,
-0.08994444459676743,
0.0042480421252548695,
0.2814995050430298,
0.754603385925293,
0.035179443657398224,
-0.5558377504348755,
-0.18510600924491882,
0.302558034658432,
-0.5423595905303955,
-0.24972675740718842,
0.729290783405304,
0.22268694639205933,
-0.11511996388435364,
0.6872869729995728,
-0.27488625049591064,
-0.5074289441108704,
0.8370490074157715,
0.4613361954689026,
0.5655151605606079,
-0.11003413051366806,
0.3170399069786072,
0.461856484413147,
0.6758351922035217,
-0.4815046191215515,
0.012613105587661266,
0.3786909580230713,
-0.9401647448539734,
-0.18591557443141937,
0.16348953545093536,
-0.375853031873703,
-0.26613688468933105,
-0.6942814588546753,
0.20711803436279297,
-0.09979850798845291,
-0.1836293488740921,
-0.15080776810646057,
-0.1938873529434204,
-0.7755999565124512,
0.19188199937343597,
0.03318262845277786,
0.9779852628707886,
-1.0456868410110474,
0.7637471556663513,
0.6901587843894958,
-0.5649422407150269,
-0.583378255367279,
0.06205602362751961,
-0.20910191535949707,
-0.5742116570472717,
0.38835281133651733,
0.19078047573566437,
0.062168341130018234,
-0.1238020658493042,
-0.30038052797317505,
-0.7746061086654663,
0.9276726841926575,
0.4459303021430969,
-0.34504568576812744,
0.1092488169670105,
0.4758360981941223,
0.5186895728111267,
-0.23854975402355194,
0.36549463868141174,
0.49658337235450745,
0.5364170074462891,
0.10254513472318649,
-1.0183420181274414,
-0.15548162162303925,
-0.2189619392156601,
0.20513571798801422,
-0.03864075988531113,
-0.5892385244369507,
0.5654633641242981,
-0.6019256711006165,
-0.45287057757377625,
0.5396474003791809,
0.38683250546455383,
-0.07558682560920715,
0.7204797267913818,
0.2633029818534851,
0.6286227107048035,
0.5447516441345215,
-0.33667686581611633,
1.4419105052947998,
-0.10145056992769241,
0.6353027820587158,
0.9550175666809082,
-0.24638380110263824,
0.976452648639679,
0.5390843152999878,
-0.06499636173248291,
0.14330366253852844,
0.9184771180152893,
-0.20879556238651276,
0.4768660068511963,
-0.13646239042282104,
0.008101390674710274,
0.1606830358505249,
-0.5668257474899292,
-0.4227539002895355,
0.14661599695682526,
0.35695680975914,
-0.016603734344244003,
-0.18320724368095398,
0.02536778897047043,
-0.09887676686048508,
0.39201778173446655,
-0.2218962013721466,
0.34268808364868164,
0.3534647226333618,
-0.6828984618186951,
0.6400373578071594,
0.41959407925605774,
0.3620702028274536,
-0.1788923144340515,
0.13632549345493317,
-0.5706392526626587,
0.3727136254310608,
-0.21066446602344513,
-0.8083951473236084,
0.3983801603317261,
0.061763398349285126,
-0.12017780542373657,
-0.1110042929649353,
0.28666749596595764,
-0.6478053331375122,
-0.685172438621521,
0.6227697730064392,
0.6219038367271423,
0.19738875329494476,
0.032343607395887375,
-0.9896975755691528,
0.18248441815376282,
-0.09038808196783066,
0.06153440102934837,
-0.06278393417596817,
0.23605115711688995,
-0.4735721945762634,
0.6648019552230835,
0.1574617624282837,
0.009984574280679226,
0.13124980032444,
0.15471552312374115,
0.3690015375614166,
-0.3898860812187195,
-0.168443962931633,
-0.42623934149742126,
0.33583179116249084,
0.11915052682161331,
-0.45833680033683777,
0.5234776735305786,
0.6877647638320923,
1.3939642906188965,
-0.39059215784072876,
0.6138309836387634,
-0.13522125780582428,
0.24636396765708923,
-0.2770926058292389,
0.6552433967590332,
-1.0012428760528564,
-0.15149244666099548,
-0.37288203835487366,
-0.9266807436943054,
-0.4082989990711212,
0.2803397476673126,
-0.043663233518600464,
-0.13962075114250183,
1.1391255855560303,
0.777833878993988,
-0.08364628255367279,
-0.3676203787326813,
0.2879531979560852,
0.1398618519306183,
0.21688155829906464,
0.6482874751091003,
0.6772670149803162,
-1.2689554691314697,
0.7255784869194031,
-0.21499982476234436,
-0.02515094168484211,
-0.04733569547533989,
-0.8321570158004761,
-0.5162842869758606,
-0.5769885182380676,
-0.6434139013290405,
-0.47715532779693604,
0.06623586267232895,
0.6476736664772034,
0.4969753921031952,
-1.0280588865280151,
-0.5129367113113403,
0.11783451586961746,
0.28634172677993774,
-0.4466620087623596,
-0.14968204498291016,
0.3779790699481964,
-0.21463224291801453,
-1.1210025548934937,
0.1803860068321228,
0.06978902965784073,
0.3201267719268799,
0.29540830850601196,
-0.27647724747657776,
0.04952520877122879,
-0.16772688925266266,
0.5443341135978699,
0.24632106721401215,
-0.9397995471954346,
-0.11980073153972626,
-0.060315266251564026,
-0.2961866557598114,
0.18119315803050995,
0.8070166110992432,
-0.2387070506811142,
0.5958192944526672,
0.29632818698883057,
0.7980422377586365,
0.4318220019340515,
-0.3079276382923126,
0.5869730710983276,
-0.763851523399353,
0.49820905923843384,
0.023365112021565437,
0.4673866629600525,
0.677586019039154,
-0.05790642648935318,
0.7498248815536499,
0.6669761538505554,
-0.01495890598744154,
-0.9109089970588684,
0.1864974945783615,
-1.0393246412277222,
-0.2889762818813324,
0.8813424110412598,
-0.3955756425857544,
-0.16996833682060242,
0.1885087639093399,
-0.0043396553955972195,
0.4094490110874176,
-0.033603254705667496,
0.8510153293609619,
0.8457849025726318,
0.5739943385124207,
-0.3891458213329315,
-0.7796003222465515,
0.2919488847255707,
0.4255146384239197,
-0.6921230554580688,
-0.21503999829292297,
0.1871325522661209,
0.28740090131759644,
0.2755758464336395,
0.5432025790214539,
-0.49758440256118774,
0.5898241996765137,
-0.1285516917705536,
0.21937501430511475,
0.37154558300971985,
-0.30738696455955505,
-0.0030365048442035913,
-0.3115485906600952,
0.2553803026676178,
-0.23518988490104675
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11085v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11085v3
|
m&m's: A Benchmark to Evaluate Tool-Use for multi-step multi-modal Tasks
| 2024-03-17T04:36:18 | 2024-03-21T17:25:23 |
Zixian Ma, Weikai Huang, Jieyu Zhang, Tanmay Gupta, Ranjay Krishna
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Real-world multi-modal problems are rarely solved by a single machine
learning model, and often require multi-step computational plans that involve
stitching several models. Tool-augmented LLMs hold tremendous promise for
automating the generation of such computational plans. However, the lack of
standardized benchmarks for evaluating LLMs as planners for multi-step
multi-modal tasks has prevented a systematic study of planner design decisions.
Should LLMs generate a full plan in a single shot or step-by-step? Should they
invoke tools directly with Python code or through structured data formats like
JSON? Does feedback improve planning? To answer these questions and more, we
introduce m&m's: a benchmark containing 4K+ multi-step multi-modal tasks
involving 33 tools that include multi-modal models, (free) public APIs, and
image processing modules. For each of these task queries, we provide
automatically generated plans using this realistic toolset. We further provide
a high-quality subset of 1,565 task plans that are human-verified and correctly
executable. With m&m's, we evaluate 6 popular LLMs with 2 planning strategies
(multi-step vs. step-by-step planning), 2 plan formats (JSON vs. code), and 3
types of feedback (parsing/verification/execution). Finally, we summarize
takeaways from our extensive experiments. Our dataset and code are available on
HuggingFace (https://huggingface.co/datasets/zixianma/mnms) and Github
(https://github.com/RAIVNLab/mnms).
|
[
-0.47073012590408325,
-0.5664381980895996,
0.5625569224357605,
0.43902587890625,
-0.005404964555054903,
0.010066011920571327,
0.054953403770923615,
-0.36354199051856995,
0.28443169593811035,
0.25218358635902405,
-1.0647799968719482,
-0.2422904521226883,
-0.40461480617523193,
0.23773735761642456,
-0.08178750425577164,
0.3572103679180145,
-0.3229498863220215,
0.3990124762058258,
-0.3367953300476074,
0.021740753203630447,
-0.3202451467514038,
-0.47269514203071594,
-0.4948491156101227,
-0.3508976101875305,
0.7892206311225891,
0.4140128195285797,
0.6659931540489197,
0.5182771682739258,
0.5327080488204956,
0.325420081615448,
0.13707000017166138,
0.6466273665428162,
-0.17587891221046448,
0.18745103478431702,
0.17859283089637756,
-0.211683988571167,
-0.6448599696159363,
0.3440917432308197,
0.280651330947876,
0.6516074538230896,
0.02525673434138298,
0.3438890874385834,
-0.0008380159270018339,
0.636646568775177,
-0.9888728260993958,
0.051811765879392624,
-0.5213543772697449,
0.1612006276845932,
0.14865003526210785,
-0.31744664907455444,
-0.23308071494102478,
-0.05536958947777748,
-0.07033891975879669,
-0.3748249411582947,
-0.3106014132499695,
0.0594000443816185,
0.09057211130857468,
0.28252243995666504,
-0.6366803050041199,
-0.4691864848136902,
-0.8250529766082764,
1.0276955366134644,
-0.2892821431159973,
0.457854300737381,
0.22531676292419434,
0.38852423429489136,
-0.45288410782814026,
-0.41558241844177246,
-0.1873784214258194,
-0.5349264144897461,
0.12542176246643066,
0.1306852251291275,
0.03696362301707268,
-0.04755084589123726,
0.6170371174812317,
-0.009204818867146969,
-0.44518613815307617,
-0.12390414625406265,
-0.3732351064682007,
-0.20201939344406128,
0.8616039156913757,
0.6288167238235474,
-0.19303110241889954,
-0.22507408261299133,
-0.7991984486579895,
0.028442053124308586,
-0.7175255417823792,
0.1619243025779724,
0.366351842880249,
0.006843925919383764,
-0.11176850646734238,
0.8603456616401672,
-0.2742132544517517,
0.5533164739608765,
-0.39814940094947815,
-0.5826686024665833,
0.06270408630371094,
-0.8886891007423401,
-0.5031138062477112,
-0.46359771490097046,
0.7055295705795288,
0.6708171963691711,
0.16096247732639313,
-0.23448574542999268,
-0.5096350908279419,
-0.08347867429256439,
0.3583133816719055,
-0.8852970600128174,
0.008621888235211372,
0.2950853407382965,
-0.4606739580631256,
-0.11432577669620514,
-0.3420844078063965,
-0.4854121804237366,
-0.3674893379211426,
-0.7956196665763855,
0.5474687218666077,
-0.24880915880203247,
-0.1818544566631317,
0.15410110354423523,
-0.1725025624036789,
-0.12342413514852524,
0.6787874698638916,
-0.33479222655296326,
0.1579427570104599,
0.6040225028991699,
0.8399304151535034,
-0.07232379168272018,
-0.6040242910385132,
-0.4074021279811859,
-0.05518357455730438,
-0.4579024910926819,
0.8877716064453125,
-0.26283589005470276,
-0.7797732949256897,
-0.119825080037117,
-0.21335753798484802,
-0.30362507700920105,
-0.5304356813430786,
0.5385386943817139,
-0.026884542778134346,
0.12740691006183624,
-0.5049852132797241,
-0.06192917376756668,
-0.15712958574295044,
0.7322806715965271,
-0.5908430814743042,
0.9388416409492493,
0.18199437856674194,
-0.34061989188194275,
0.6525554060935974,
-0.6916248202323914,
-0.29583674669265747,
-0.5600601434707642,
-0.3010333776473999,
-0.14010491967201233,
-0.043372992426157,
0.11021579802036285,
0.6112563014030457,
-0.5614698529243469,
0.07602805644273758,
-0.529684841632843,
-0.3074515461921692,
0.4385623037815094,
-0.3391876518726349,
0.45161300897598267,
0.3742324411869049,
-0.2264741063117981,
0.6099693775177002,
-0.7592894434928894,
0.18814586102962494,
-0.12145973742008209,
-0.7521649599075317,
0.37084969878196716,
0.23778235912322998,
0.15420746803283691,
0.8140936493873596,
0.13869169354438782,
-0.46976137161254883,
0.30689382553100586,
0.068730928003788,
0.28274819254875183,
0.6543673872947693,
-0.1730484515428543,
0.2827630639076233,
-0.687345564365387,
0.5171499252319336,
0.09909942001104355,
0.4382489025592804,
-0.5157022476196289,
-0.16329210996627808,
-0.6185513138771057,
-0.3432696759700775,
0.028080075979232788,
0.510155439376831,
-0.8141299486160278,
0.03846370056271553,
-0.041714299470186234,
-0.6426194310188293,
-0.08184433728456497,
0.22972041368484497,
0.41540366411209106,
0.11319167912006378,
0.13989311456680298,
-0.30738523602485657,
-0.4373849034309387,
-0.9822842478752136,
-0.13451449573040009,
0.16205093264579773,
-0.21942856907844543,
0.384067177772522,
0.4604109823703766,
-0.2200855165719986,
0.5036702156066895,
-0.09905847907066345,
-0.15462031960487366,
-0.15654626488685608,
0.23518811166286469,
-0.013548953458666801,
0.29811593890190125,
0.39237844944000244,
-0.6877209544181824,
-0.1395062655210495,
-0.48828744888305664,
-0.66415935754776,
0.016637170687317848,
-0.3484906256198883,
-0.030707085505127907,
-0.015377242118120193,
0.3688358664512634,
-0.60419100522995,
0.18446338176727295,
0.4680708646774292,
-0.2320317178964615,
1.092349886894226,
-0.09438884258270264,
0.5121211409568787,
-1.1665329933166504,
0.18547247350215912,
0.06651856750249863,
-0.20326556265354156,
-0.4067971706390381,
-0.05277888849377632,
0.1398906260728836,
-0.08336379379034042,
-0.7661965489387512,
0.21171192824840546,
-0.7317327857017517,
-0.3284589350223541,
-0.3963959515094757,
-0.13500291109085083,
-0.1393987536430359,
0.5733158588409424,
-0.3930657207965851,
1.0610028505325317,
0.35904380679130554,
-0.7084704637527466,
0.384367972612381,
-0.1711788922548294,
-0.15308740735054016,
0.7696106433868408,
-0.4215877652168274,
0.18679089844226837,
0.2646504342556,
0.10119542479515076,
-0.7058459520339966,
0.018168939277529716,
0.2916748821735382,
-0.17879563570022583,
0.14608344435691833,
-0.166456401348114,
-0.8855483531951904,
-0.2962381839752197,
-0.8817043900489807,
0.11623973399400711,
-0.053035199642181396,
-0.20836549997329712,
0.9495180249214172,
0.27267152070999146,
0.09140940755605698,
-0.5984392166137695,
-0.4136084318161011,
0.2533079981803894,
0.008753404021263123,
-0.6905955076217651,
0.1840214878320694,
-0.37526655197143555,
-0.18533767759799957,
-0.08887266367673874,
-0.32797670364379883,
0.02102622389793396,
0.162784144282341,
0.7500663995742798,
0.20336826145648956,
-0.07924386113882065,
-0.23120370507240295,
-0.1437138468027115,
-0.379060298204422,
0.28012552857398987,
0.1613343507051468,
0.6597275137901306,
0.16351446509361267,
-0.7646366953849792,
-0.31906506419181824,
0.35467520356178284,
0.9685790538787842,
-0.08996711671352386,
0.18682093918323517,
0.5790643692016602,
-0.3165851831436157,
0.12485618144273758,
-0.6039038300514221,
-0.00884978286921978,
-0.41069355607032776,
0.07783029228448868,
-0.888334333896637,
-0.4993579089641571,
0.21561312675476074,
-0.7224668264389038,
0.6320323348045349,
0.16045066714286804,
0.7425666451454163,
-0.09285824000835419,
1.2248116731643677,
0.605231761932373,
-0.11899323016405106,
0.35783833265304565,
-0.28851741552352905,
-0.2714505195617676,
-0.8819497227668762,
-0.3649979531764984,
-0.37433454394340515,
-0.8335345387458801,
-0.3388122022151947,
-0.733395516872406,
0.4457283914089203,
0.13950040936470032,
0.08439268171787262,
0.426300048828125,
-0.15491268038749695,
0.1437896192073822,
0.6934995651245117,
-0.07100570946931839,
0.24751944839954376,
-0.2884962558746338,
-0.43243229389190674,
0.009640267118811607,
-0.5351458787918091,
-0.6940971612930298,
1.388505220413208,
0.0902242660522461,
0.895289421081543,
-0.21862506866455078,
0.47983518242836,
0.20075960457324982,
0.15123024582862854,
-0.936773419380188,
0.6382385492324829,
0.36766985058784485,
-0.3890092372894287,
0.032409533858299255,
-0.3319162130355835,
-1.0070273876190186,
0.6938411593437195,
-0.5166270732879639,
-0.5672721862792969,
0.1895192265510559,
0.0671810731291771,
-0.16028428077697754,
0.3413134217262268,
-0.6682360172271729,
0.6339825987815857,
-0.5277668237686157,
-0.44214752316474915,
-0.4435643255710602,
-0.4536237418651581,
0.3954187035560608,
-0.1519022434949875,
0.16315411031246185,
-0.6089348196983337,
-0.36655721068382263,
0.4621003270149231,
-0.12178254872560501,
0.4464433491230011,
-0.1588549166917801,
0.20715636014938354,
0.0604093074798584,
0.25090423226356506,
0.3987836539745331,
-0.017141077667474747,
-0.2581545114517212,
-0.07739061117172241,
0.338841050863266,
-0.14142508804798126,
-0.3528176546096802,
0.6848158240318298,
-0.33818674087524414,
-0.2210991382598877,
-0.20128537714481354,
-0.8514173626899719,
-0.18578383326530457,
0.2243787944316864,
-0.2509341835975647,
0.6443282961845398,
-0.18356946110725403,
0.12667164206504822,
-0.01889994367957115,
0.1929132640361786,
0.660377025604248,
0.4382633566856384,
-0.3812025785446167,
-0.5826364159584045,
0.47124966979026794,
0.2851217985153198,
0.21367089450359344,
0.13369548320770264,
-0.04389966279268265,
-0.10240059345960617,
-0.6029061675071716,
-0.761417806148529,
-0.029456783086061478,
-0.40914827585220337,
-0.16767475008964539,
-0.5891243815422058,
0.14867892861366272,
-0.09823044389486313,
-0.11763440817594528,
-0.4458090662956238,
-0.5079449415206909,
0.013110851868987083,
0.2657732367515564,
-0.3464268147945404,
0.8082848191261292,
-0.20005129277706146,
0.11505827307701111,
-0.6783709526062012,
0.3036428689956665,
-0.0633024200797081,
0.08638516813516617,
-0.2727675437927246,
0.4969947636127472,
-0.324558287858963,
0.07384413480758667,
-0.7339858412742615,
-0.7617102265357971,
0.14504274725914001,
-0.23389625549316406,
0.6409456133842468,
0.4126838147640228,
-0.10885779559612274,
0.7491953372955322,
-0.49580830335617065,
0.5833537578582764,
0.2835542857646942,
-0.42967939376831055,
0.45637276768684387,
-0.023469582200050354,
0.3042081594467163,
0.49795371294021606,
0.6411817669868469,
-0.43450987339019775,
-0.12719814479351044,
-0.4606005847454071,
-0.5070200562477112,
0.686850368976593,
0.08064129948616028,
-0.20461224019527435,
0.3216068148612976,
0.16888344287872314,
0.11257608979940414,
0.5861403942108154,
-0.5053659081459045,
-0.25342023372650146,
0.2496735155582428,
0.23354877531528473,
-0.049612537026405334,
-0.4417528212070465,
-0.40785613656044006,
-0.02868581749498844,
0.19212289154529572,
-0.14088930189609528,
0.3423968255519867,
0.0401720330119133,
-0.20358219742774963,
-0.22124868631362915,
0.21884946525096893,
0.952000617980957,
1.134608507156372,
-0.20867174863815308,
0.41479697823524475,
0.21732954680919647,
-0.2653208076953888,
0.0746738538146019,
0.1361324042081833,
0.04974707216024399,
0.026676224544644356,
0.16975776851177216,
0.23848894238471985,
0.49027472734451294,
-0.6806321144104004,
0.23719483613967896,
-0.05682112276554108,
-0.6036872267723083,
-0.1049705445766449,
0.1287974864244461,
0.09528065472841263,
0.48705223202705383,
0.24708157777786255,
0.45521488785743713,
0.1968415230512619,
-0.5081150531768799,
0.14849019050598145,
0.604598343372345,
-0.3304422199726105,
-0.43091943860054016,
0.41358911991119385,
0.21909886598587036,
-0.40646079182624817,
0.15123505890369415,
-0.25260958075523376,
-0.2530774474143982,
0.3619746267795563,
0.26570603251457214,
0.7937208414077759,
0.007597634103149176,
-0.05621308460831642,
0.31373098492622375,
0.7203404307365417,
0.24165783822536469,
0.7380970120429993,
-0.3121965229511261,
-0.34094610810279846,
-0.42757853865623474,
-0.44909822940826416,
-0.6079137325286865,
0.03876129165291786,
-0.26349255442619324,
0.37504854798316956,
-0.5214492082595825,
-0.442881315946579,
-0.12389864772558212,
0.20567622780799866,
-0.8950693607330322,
0.19489943981170654,
-0.18094085156917572,
1.1143896579742432,
-0.3946693241596222,
0.5613337159156799,
0.8102165460586548,
-0.30626317858695984,
-0.5452011227607727,
-0.27599599957466125,
0.6037197709083557,
-0.8724091053009033,
0.4043951630592346,
0.28784751892089844,
-0.48720046877861023,
-0.3721611797809601,
-0.2348601222038269,
-0.8311556577682495,
1.3280152082443237,
0.18087118864059448,
-0.28844135999679565,
0.06744085252285004,
0.21207009255886078,
-0.05025676637887955,
-0.3698772192001343,
0.43571609258651733,
0.31672272086143494,
0.5662521123886108,
0.24073442816734314,
-1.097347617149353,
0.04448571056127548,
-0.1663418561220169,
-0.2928798198699951,
0.4918508231639862,
-0.4064171612262726,
0.9399902820587158,
-0.35408493876457214,
-0.1795068085193634,
0.002330890391021967,
0.10039032995700836,
0.3342100977897644,
0.7018960118293762,
0.7260281443595886,
0.5949447154998779,
0.283478707075119,
-0.05890202894806862,
0.8455885052680969,
-0.5153570175170898,
0.013162568211555481,
0.8993521928787231,
-0.3314608335494995,
0.917008101940155,
0.587020218372345,
-0.3169417679309845,
-0.051986414939165115,
0.8343929648399353,
0.014745301567018032,
0.35394546389579773,
0.1577569991350174,
-0.11945432424545288,
-0.19127170741558075,
-0.05968988686800003,
-0.2822903096675873,
0.31292277574539185,
0.1909819394350052,
-0.15210986137390137,
-0.43132051825523376,
-0.018384860828518867,
0.04989533871412277,
-0.4823372960090637,
-0.2144177407026291,
0.7254272103309631,
0.1500396579504013,
-0.36205899715423584,
0.2177238017320633,
0.06668426096439362,
0.8463781476020813,
-0.6109268665313721,
0.1645679920911789,
0.05596407502889633,
0.05239984765648842,
-0.22639422118663788,
-0.6392368674278259,
0.22067135572433472,
-0.2433893084526062,
-0.18340043723583221,
-0.48822179436683655,
0.7816258668899536,
-0.09851391613483429,
-0.43475210666656494,
0.16786907613277435,
1.1288809776306152,
0.10460533201694489,
-0.43965011835098267,
-1.0293774604797363,
0.019310075789690018,
-0.28157925605773926,
-0.3340409994125366,
0.40037208795547485,
0.24020302295684814,
0.10952486097812653,
0.9893558621406555,
0.9603385329246521,
0.007705428637564182,
0.17469501495361328,
-0.028351671993732452,
1.0160274505615234,
-0.7265220284461975,
-0.04821227863430977,
-0.9267758131027222,
0.5658299922943115,
-0.05601746588945389,
-0.4068390130996704,
0.8824025988578796,
0.9950745105743408,
0.8120765089988708,
0.021996671333909035,
0.31524479389190674,
0.20496246218681335,
0.3290329873561859,
-0.6762824654579163,
0.28844285011291504,
-0.8619838356971741,
0.09615755826234818,
0.008738117292523384,
-1.0791406631469727,
-0.027267860248684883,
0.162411168217659,
-0.23232057690620422,
0.09702829271554947,
0.720166802406311,
0.8639557361602783,
-0.081069715321064,
-0.21052667498588562,
0.4630424678325653,
-0.5614786148071289,
0.40164339542388916,
0.516056478023529,
1.2131890058517456,
-0.04496603459119797,
0.5853422284126282,
-0.4375549852848053,
-0.2125188112258911,
-0.36816325783729553,
-0.7897343039512634,
-0.6457018852233887,
-0.4371173679828644,
-0.07802934944629669,
-0.015624837949872017,
-0.2687240242958069,
1.3235812187194824,
1.076820969581604,
-0.30439645051956177,
-0.6782798767089844,
0.3733403980731964,
0.19818216562271118,
-0.3235097825527191,
-0.10183729976415634,
-0.0927971750497818,
-0.5370712876319885,
-0.5446497201919556,
0.765305757522583,
0.7117918133735657,
0.009462081827223301,
-0.5345965027809143,
-0.08824766427278519,
-0.11937999725341797,
-0.09941084682941437,
0.9327276349067688,
-0.13531525433063507,
-0.7511049509048462,
0.05228696018457413,
0.2192830890417099,
-0.25985297560691833,
0.14749102294445038,
1.283589243888855,
-0.49211275577545166,
0.5268630385398865,
0.31707486510276794,
0.4030541777610779,
0.4852999746799469,
-0.16474731266498566,
0.5687892436981201,
-0.52556312084198,
0.003826902946457267,
0.14154456555843353,
0.5884299874305725,
-0.08564870804548264,
0.09506714344024658,
0.7836436629295349,
0.052079156041145325,
-0.7038884162902832,
-0.6101424098014832,
0.2463257759809494,
-1.0582098960876465,
-0.2219192385673523,
0.8888269066810608,
0.15509814023971558,
-0.024568933993577957,
-0.14077691733837128,
-0.5387113094329834,
-0.052291180938482285,
-0.20207251608371735,
0.6453489661216736,
0.5017469525337219,
-0.6867120862007141,
-0.09997716546058655,
-0.7956323623657227,
0.37967032194137573,
0.24091991782188416,
-0.9523419141769409,
-0.1682625263929367,
0.8986928462982178,
0.05442825332283974,
0.2349546253681183,
0.6682929396629333,
0.13027873635292053,
0.3691791296005249,
0.08889178186655045,
-0.005168526899069548,
-0.49116528034210205,
-0.5936290621757507,
0.06096911057829857,
0.3294650614261627,
0.13428471982479095,
-0.496418297290802
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11083v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11083v1
|
Customizing Visual-Language Foundation Models for Multi-modal Anomaly Detection and Reasoning
| 2024-03-17T04:30:57 | 2024-03-17T04:30:57 |
Xiaohao Xu, Yunkang Cao, Yongqi Chen, Weiming Shen, Xiaonan Huang
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Anomaly detection is vital in various industrial scenarios, including the
identification of unusual patterns in production lines and the detection of
manufacturing defects for quality control. Existing techniques tend to be
specialized in individual scenarios and lack generalization capacities. In this
study, we aim to develop a generic anomaly detection model applicable across
multiple scenarios. To achieve this, we customize generic visual-language
foundation models that possess extensive knowledge and robust reasoning
abilities into anomaly detectors and reasoners. Specifically, we introduce a
multi-modal prompting strategy that incorporates domain knowledge from experts
as conditions to guide the models. Our approach considers multi-modal prompt
types, including task descriptions, class context, normality rules, and
reference images. In addition, we unify the input representation of
multi-modality into a 2D image format, enabling multi-modal anomaly detection
and reasoning. Our preliminary studies demonstrate that combining visual and
language prompts as conditions for customizing the models enhances anomaly
detection performance. The customized models showcase the ability to detect
anomalies across different data modalities such as images and point clouds.
Qualitative case studies further highlight the anomaly detection and reasoning
capabilities, particularly for multi-object scenes and temporal data. Our code
is available at https://github.com/Xiaohao-Xu/Customizable-VLM.
|
[
-0.33212828636169434,
-1.1410166025161743,
0.6994854211807251,
0.2666184604167938,
-0.1636902540922165,
-0.23860891163349152,
0.1026623323559761,
-0.31443414092063904,
0.03600319102406502,
0.38448867201805115,
-0.7396146059036255,
-0.7060034275054932,
-0.28161460161209106,
0.0870789885520935,
-0.312941312789917,
0.5654107928276062,
-0.04112100601196289,
-0.2961752116680145,
-0.45585620403289795,
-0.12198200076818466,
-0.8171637654304504,
-0.4162212014198303,
-0.3402827978134155,
0.07002811878919601,
0.21799105405807495,
0.35608789324760437,
0.42819923162460327,
0.5104333162307739,
0.35733941197395325,
0.4040486514568329,
0.1806037575006485,
0.6129196882247925,
-0.10305969417095184,
0.3606620132923126,
-0.10076984018087387,
-0.2723185122013092,
-0.618104875087738,
-0.54712975025177,
0.4003894329071045,
0.3679134249687195,
-0.08684621751308441,
-0.08669765293598175,
-0.3375888764858246,
0.09739135205745697,
-0.5381686687469482,
0.42927560210227966,
-0.4730224609375,
0.03606840968132019,
-0.13623975217342377,
-0.37728938460350037,
-0.46194490790367126,
-0.014370104297995567,
-0.09397424012422562,
-0.7508655786514282,
0.4351119101047516,
0.09255024790763855,
0.8999225497245789,
0.28621906042099,
-0.4271773099899292,
-0.04304062947630882,
-0.5307978987693787,
0.7131565809249878,
-0.5848268270492554,
0.509099006652832,
0.18236315250396729,
0.6848379969596863,
-0.1212518960237503,
-0.8202418088912964,
-0.6154703497886658,
-0.26234179735183716,
-0.21814611554145813,
0.04642036557197571,
-0.3730076551437378,
-0.1534596085548401,
0.16817457973957062,
-0.04408926144242287,
-0.8412213921546936,
0.040175195783376694,
0.077785424888134,
-0.2805573344230652,
0.30968424677848816,
0.588178277015686,
0.3649459779262543,
-0.3263593018054962,
-0.46603676676750183,
0.11239861696958542,
-0.4061807692050934,
0.3862666189670563,
0.2717120051383972,
0.129652202129364,
-0.48308199644088745,
0.19172145426273346,
-0.38756391406059265,
1.0065380334854126,
-0.11128182709217072,
-0.1267155408859253,
0.23763875663280487,
-0.5131474733352661,
-0.3289302587509155,
-0.3760829269886017,
0.5646675229072571,
0.34349513053894043,
-0.09157384186983109,
0.2600823938846588,
-0.4088967740535736,
0.03325518220663071,
0.10529858618974686,
-0.5937231183052063,
-0.4506551921367645,
0.1262168288230896,
-0.6685539484024048,
-0.43031057715415955,
-0.060349706560373306,
-0.7502756714820862,
-0.6120755672454834,
-0.4113543927669525,
0.4888487458229065,
-0.35645630955696106,
-0.6201967000961304,
0.14063826203346252,
-0.4148361384868622,
-0.21831320226192474,
0.6679790616035461,
-0.6341750621795654,
-0.26098963618278503,
0.29185572266578674,
0.4126814603805542,
-0.22032468020915985,
-0.24153004586696625,
-0.6870481371879578,
0.2607479989528656,
-0.15892274677753448,
0.9784809350967407,
-0.981929361820221,
-0.6184544563293457,
-0.02860124409198761,
0.254283607006073,
-0.22181805968284607,
-0.3737991452217102,
0.380675733089447,
-0.4380442798137665,
0.17816945910453796,
-0.5351789593696594,
-0.12196443229913712,
-0.40779909491539,
0.7354896068572998,
-0.4521723687648773,
0.6991380453109741,
0.22842301428318024,
-0.6869004964828491,
0.4738197326660156,
-0.8060442805290222,
-0.3283694386482239,
0.1752094179391861,
-0.7216246128082275,
-0.4573272168636322,
-0.10842936486005783,
0.5419914126396179,
0.4184715747833252,
-0.3619108200073242,
0.31848427653312683,
-0.3418586552143097,
-0.007178851403295994,
0.4027617573738098,
-0.6451532244682312,
0.5666067004203796,
0.27804329991340637,
-0.386393278837204,
0.4064541161060333,
-0.8510971069335938,
0.011663575656712055,
0.10446436703205109,
-0.41161563992500305,
-0.15830765664577484,
0.03119874745607376,
0.4215707778930664,
0.197382390499115,
0.17648130655288696,
-0.22937625646591187,
0.2959479093551636,
0.23002634942531586,
0.1101975291967392,
0.5050755739212036,
0.29392898082733154,
0.06555695086717606,
-0.15190237760543823,
0.7462252974510193,
0.8590252995491028,
0.38107797503471375,
-0.8208030462265015,
-0.6590451002120972,
-0.6288392543792725,
-0.6723172068595886,
-0.15574409067630768,
0.6681381464004517,
-0.9967869520187378,
0.3331676721572876,
-0.1051851361989975,
0.086435467004776,
-0.11231984198093414,
0.029512720182538033,
0.21650509536266327,
1.055372953414917,
0.4566204249858856,
0.0037307473830878735,
-0.6302695870399475,
-0.9114714860916138,
-0.3855727016925812,
0.11580052971839905,
0.049964625388383865,
0.2985592782497406,
0.3576551377773285,
-0.6306414008140564,
1.306328535079956,
-0.4331054389476776,
-0.11027249693870544,
-0.26100873947143555,
0.154147669672966,
0.2008378803730011,
0.6478002071380615,
0.9541772603988647,
-1.0961395502090454,
-0.2031337469816208,
0.28775331377983093,
-1.1480034589767456,
-0.1971963495016098,
-0.2081916183233261,
0.25030073523521423,
0.2324497550725937,
0.5234498381614685,
-0.3227595090866089,
0.5275560617446899,
0.26406365633010864,
-0.5647751688957214,
0.5783119201660156,
-0.12557537853717804,
0.46270444989204407,
-1.2053133249282837,
-0.023378685116767883,
0.23633626103401184,
-0.19862976670265198,
-0.8468015193939209,
0.04192443937063217,
0.09939851611852646,
-0.22830046713352203,
-0.284128874540329,
0.4381806254386902,
-0.3680141270160675,
0.23233507573604584,
-0.2501283586025238,
-0.19630667567253113,
0.31078097224235535,
0.362970232963562,
0.09958882629871368,
0.3614456355571747,
0.9146549701690674,
-0.6422284841537476,
0.45685267448425293,
-0.04065635800361633,
-0.13884064555168152,
0.877735435962677,
-0.592579185962677,
-0.1831497699022293,
-0.3691408038139343,
0.0707307830452919,
-0.9755299091339111,
-0.48356276750564575,
0.4216829836368561,
-0.32888373732566833,
0.1838928759098053,
-0.3716675937175751,
-0.4221988320350647,
-0.3305123746395111,
-0.019251162186264992,
0.33032047748565674,
0.15349017083644867,
-0.6984164118766785,
0.9777849316596985,
-0.026663344353437424,
0.10241731256246567,
-0.5625942349433899,
-0.8404828906059265,
-0.015952249988913536,
-0.22229674458503723,
-0.9718013405799866,
-0.06857790052890778,
-0.2643680274486542,
-0.14803089201450348,
0.16591769456863403,
-0.14038775861263275,
-0.4373985826969147,
0.1647525578737259,
0.3298226594924927,
0.3158109784126282,
-0.6633942127227783,
-0.05358467251062393,
0.3233066201210022,
-0.10522688925266266,
0.07196814566850662,
-0.20420525968074799,
0.28083258867263794,
-0.47874605655670166,
-0.8312065005302429,
-0.5157912969589233,
0.6152651309967041,
0.8150662183761597,
-0.29121485352516174,
0.3661404252052307,
0.9763571619987488,
-0.6057156324386597,
-0.13116255402565002,
-0.6638426780700684,
-0.27207520604133606,
-0.540482223033905,
0.4156574010848999,
-0.6163426637649536,
-0.5330763459205627,
0.5733000040054321,
-0.08534647524356842,
-0.13569241762161255,
0.012224865145981312,
0.5663638114929199,
0.1299820840358734,
1.4401432275772095,
0.7358312010765076,
0.2203410416841507,
0.34286412596702576,
-0.34646075963974,
0.41025617718696594,
-0.44205737113952637,
-0.6210469603538513,
-0.09782691299915314,
-0.06249057501554489,
-0.1421886384487152,
-0.539630651473999,
0.7807435393333435,
0.0818735733628273,
0.021257417276501656,
0.05742514878511429,
-0.3749532103538513,
0.43466293811798096,
0.33074691891670227,
-0.01853087544441223,
0.4443734586238861,
0.14154501259326935,
0.053988222032785416,
-0.0870150551199913,
-0.7043997645378113,
-0.29199811816215515,
0.4377847909927368,
0.2693568766117096,
0.6819045543670654,
0.4099070727825165,
0.3468174338340759,
0.4332239627838135,
-0.002523858565837145,
-0.5869590044021606,
0.2751403748989105,
0.2382836937904358,
-0.4868814945220947,
-0.20160247385501862,
-0.30849960446357727,
-0.7531164884567261,
0.483322411775589,
-0.2941426932811737,
-0.7816497087478638,
0.8120276927947998,
0.4744921326637268,
-0.2999182343482971,
0.19556723535060883,
-0.9684125185012817,
1.1476051807403564,
-0.22904075682163239,
0.013338790275156498,
-0.037363044917583466,
-0.4758013188838959,
0.6466807126998901,
0.13249075412750244,
0.3807711899280548,
-0.04612371698021889,
-0.05573948100209236,
-0.15035118162631989,
-0.30774492025375366,
1.031935214996338,
-0.23459099233150482,
0.15161876380443573,
0.26536479592323303,
0.22043803334236145,
0.4209558665752411,
0.4556974172592163,
0.07565508037805557,
-0.05165988951921463,
-0.042404741048812866,
-0.33898162841796875,
-0.5452526211738586,
0.6524146795272827,
-0.3581850230693817,
-0.6719585061073303,
-0.15791645646095276,
-0.8382964730262756,
-0.1328129768371582,
0.3277439475059509,
0.4756488800048828,
0.6221569180488586,
-0.05133742466568947,
0.23106221854686737,
0.7372997999191284,
-0.13450051844120026,
0.6098263263702393,
0.7988265156745911,
-0.12181979417800903,
0.11216545850038528,
1.1263422966003418,
-0.18748705089092255,
-0.12723854184150696,
0.4101237952709198,
0.41017481684684753,
-0.091958187520504,
-0.3567591905593872,
-0.8418562412261963,
-0.3150990605354309,
-0.9030354619026184,
-0.25560733675956726,
-0.9092444181442261,
0.04994388297200203,
-0.5408005714416504,
-0.21677391231060028,
-0.10005760937929153,
-0.16390004754066467,
-0.4774707853794098,
0.22538350522518158,
0.4407239258289337,
0.5166695713996887,
-0.0359414741396904,
0.10014602541923523,
-0.8655126690864563,
0.4686639904975891,
0.48703816533088684,
-0.04333136975765228,
0.026742324233055115,
-0.3147852420806885,
0.11103203892707825,
-0.041789647191762924,
-0.2660221457481384,
-0.9022905826568604,
0.364083468914032,
0.018833106383681297,
0.9065548777580261,
0.8564841151237488,
-0.02340179868042469,
0.40872618556022644,
-0.14838287234306335,
0.7733306288719177,
0.4047647714614868,
-0.9588800668716431,
0.730084240436554,
-0.7545116543769836,
0.3205621540546417,
-0.001524178427644074,
0.2554926872253418,
-0.39211970567703247,
-0.13413897156715393,
-0.4379916489124298,
-0.6238760948181152,
0.6191672682762146,
-0.08800516277551651,
-0.12656767666339874,
-0.0019295922247692943,
-0.09783560782670975,
0.08737742900848389,
0.2975598871707916,
-0.645272433757782,
-0.24935495853424072,
-0.6756730079650879,
-0.11244052648544312,
0.4090801775455475,
-0.07813210785388947,
-0.44024398922920227,
-0.13460849225521088,
-0.030397890135645866,
-0.36616453528404236,
0.02128996141254902,
0.01106199249625206,
-0.37829136848449707,
0.07907973229885101,
0.3095199167728424,
1.0003023147583008,
0.9944742918014526,
0.14914867281913757,
0.13644863665103912,
0.2464739978313446,
-0.22147779166698456,
-0.0193049106746912,
0.17914362251758575,
0.012320960871875286,
0.28518417477607727,
0.3416181802749634,
0.8745036125183105,
0.15989814698696136,
-0.6917147040367126,
0.7108607292175293,
0.019823316484689713,
0.03060080111026764,
-0.23435468971729279,
0.08377139270305634,
-0.036384593695402145,
0.42970776557922363,
0.3418521583080292,
0.40318915247917175,
0.43202316761016846,
-0.5513887405395508,
0.05294979736208916,
0.24265696108341217,
-0.047493260353803635,
-0.44586777687072754,
0.7674909234046936,
0.21150724589824677,
-0.20614196360111237,
0.3343331813812256,
-0.420178085565567,
-0.4857615828514099,
0.9475399851799011,
0.4673019051551819,
0.5289943814277649,
-0.3602851629257202,
0.2796695828437805,
-0.13434523344039917,
0.5533517599105835,
0.06028441712260246,
0.4390729069709778,
0.03013322502374649,
-0.7489030361175537,
-0.022086456418037415,
-0.040607087314128876,
-0.22335799038410187,
0.27891045808792114,
-0.4036901891231537,
0.5477532148361206,
-0.48677149415016174,
-0.06005282700061798,
-0.2261865884065628,
-0.764051616191864,
-0.867026150226593,
0.2039385288953781,
0.09949075430631638,
0.728815495967865,
-1.092346429824829,
0.6143401265144348,
0.8466622233390808,
-0.5522862672805786,
-0.5087631940841675,
-0.21252623200416565,
0.44953906536102295,
-0.6716935038566589,
0.5566612482070923,
0.1889164298772812,
-0.021452993154525757,
-0.33793047070503235,
-0.19467036426067352,
-0.7620118856430054,
1.0563172101974487,
0.4051559269428253,
-0.3994893431663513,
0.1367003321647644,
-0.10697627812623978,
0.38823068141937256,
-0.5503530502319336,
0.07604386657476425,
0.6591663360595703,
0.7730041742324829,
-0.20554973185062408,
-0.5658036470413208,
0.05369354411959648,
-0.3924168646335602,
0.09378758817911148,
0.07916749268770218,
-0.25517308712005615,
0.9775145053863525,
-0.24207791686058044,
0.043078385293483734,
-0.24941369891166687,
0.4701685905456543,
0.44768834114074707,
0.7990656495094299,
0.6918255090713501,
0.46687304973602295,
0.8084997534751892,
-0.06462296843528748,
0.9844759106636047,
-0.15375424921512604,
-0.100941501557827,
0.8000171184539795,
-0.08276490122079849,
0.16445030272006989,
0.1205945536494255,
0.37992578744888306,
0.7506545186042786,
0.6520599722862244,
-0.15786702930927277,
0.39256149530410767,
-0.25967153906822205,
-0.2575860619544983,
-0.6442036628723145,
-0.22241447865962982,
-0.7679111361503601,
0.2994252145290375,
0.6986849308013916,
-0.19465601444244385,
-0.2841573655605316,
0.3496454656124115,
-0.10943154245615005,
0.04534830525517464,
-0.22915300726890564,
0.21623310446739197,
-0.2511756420135498,
-0.26779648661613464,
0.4529452919960022,
0.026874743402004242,
0.6235737800598145,
-0.4320191740989685,
-0.1912064254283905,
-0.20986415445804596,
0.024762392044067383,
-0.42322686314582825,
-0.5182541012763977,
0.07326439768075943,
-0.0690804049372673,
-0.5114299654960632,
-0.06017522141337395,
0.7222816944122314,
-0.5008872151374817,
-0.3482401371002197,
-0.1213303953409195,
0.6732208728790283,
-0.00669719185680151,
0.05353052169084549,
-0.6092967391014099,
0.2587975561618805,
-0.12206997722387314,
-0.20346948504447937,
0.0896395742893219,
0.6201372146606445,
-0.5107576847076416,
0.6692529916763306,
0.6965000629425049,
-0.37032344937324524,
0.1965186446905136,
0.43025290966033936,
0.945018470287323,
-0.314210444688797,
-0.7959073781967163,
-0.46041563153266907,
0.8364400267601013,
-0.40596044063568115,
-0.39848488569259644,
0.693611741065979,
0.4048110544681549,
0.43209800124168396,
-0.5856708884239197,
0.8394549489021301,
-0.052264075726270676,
0.13060475885868073,
-0.5198814272880554,
0.5459116101264954,
-0.7399373054504395,
0.456293523311615,
-0.16043038666248322,
-0.5619897246360779,
-0.17797905206680298,
0.3821524381637573,
-0.04331928491592407,
0.15272819995880127,
0.7732524871826172,
1.0241198539733887,
-0.3998356759548187,
-0.00984041579067707,
0.3831855058670044,
0.062107425183057785,
0.6493186950683594,
0.4098939895629883,
0.9905924201011658,
-0.05118902027606964,
0.6408781409263611,
-0.000519021472427994,
-0.25061994791030884,
-0.5262842774391174,
-1.1818478107452393,
-0.956756591796875,
-0.6424833536148071,
-0.37451159954071045,
-0.09749342501163483,
-0.11780388653278351,
0.7221630215644836,
0.9406092762947083,
-0.904651939868927,
0.06243341416120529,
-0.014779499731957912,
0.41111356019973755,
-0.29126495122909546,
-0.35055869817733765,
0.09650491923093796,
-0.41102463006973267,
-0.6535094380378723,
0.9291961193084717,
0.42253217101097107,
0.21242988109588623,
-0.1863885223865509,
0.16292686760425568,
0.1368052363395691,
-0.08951073884963989,
0.668510913848877,
0.4368494153022766,
-0.8405194282531738,
-0.2865599989891052,
0.15135891735553741,
0.0789821594953537,
-0.12271714955568314,
1.0512975454330444,
-0.6216452717781067,
0.7814773321151733,
0.827102780342102,
0.6089097857475281,
0.2046363800764084,
-0.11014170199632645,
0.6441953182220459,
-0.9716007709503174,
0.5944840908050537,
0.18171218037605286,
0.604925274848938,
0.40444663166999817,
-0.5394673347473145,
0.11781253665685654,
0.6352012157440186,
-0.16321130096912384,
-1.0719422101974487,
0.5989598631858826,
-1.0562621355056763,
-0.4789412319660187,
0.7924410104751587,
-0.14661771059036255,
0.1620800942182541,
-0.47584840655326843,
-0.10861509293317795,
-0.16906268894672394,
-0.48599162697792053,
0.7511504888534546,
0.3970790207386017,
-0.3960230350494385,
-0.14911745488643646,
-0.41947293281555176,
0.3384985029697418,
0.36439254879951477,
-0.9784790277481079,
-0.3133391737937927,
0.7028127312660217,
0.32132488489151,
0.3235440254211426,
0.27510592341423035,
0.176716610789299,
0.7757894396781921,
0.02536841295659542,
-0.15769128501415253,
-0.5198903679847717,
-0.5658965110778809,
-0.5280516743659973,
0.11889051645994186,
-0.2591438591480255,
-0.3789118826389313
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11082v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11082v1
|
RobustSentEmbed: Robust Sentence Embeddings Using Adversarial Self-Supervised Contrastive Learning
| 2024-03-17T04:29:45 | 2024-03-17T04:29:45 |
Javad Rafiei Asl, Prajwal Panzade, Eduardo Blanco, Daniel Takabi, Zhipeng Cai
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Pre-trained language models (PLMs) have consistently demonstrated outstanding
performance across a diverse spectrum of natural language processing tasks.
Nevertheless, despite their success with unseen data, current PLM-based
representations often exhibit poor robustness in adversarial settings. In this
paper, we introduce RobustSentEmbed, a self-supervised sentence embedding
framework designed to improve both generalization and robustness in diverse
text representation tasks and against a diverse set of adversarial attacks.
Through the generation of high-risk adversarial perturbations and their
utilization in a novel objective function, RobustSentEmbed adeptly learns
high-quality and robust sentence embeddings. Our experiments confirm the
superiority of RobustSentEmbed over state-of-the-art representations.
Specifically, Our framework achieves a significant reduction in the success
rate of various adversarial attacks, notably reducing the BERTAttack success
rate by almost half (from 75.51\% to 38.81\%). The framework also yields
improvements of 1.59\% and 0.23\% in semantic textual similarity tasks and
various transfer tasks, respectively.
|
[
-0.25191569328308105,
-0.686969518661499,
0.41519826650619507,
0.31762996315956116,
-0.20410436391830444,
-0.1211523562669754,
-0.19820237159729004,
0.14934571087360382,
0.08338901400566101,
0.48394399881362915,
-0.2309364527463913,
-0.7826787233352661,
-0.9251869916915894,
0.02345425635576248,
-0.239179790019989,
0.9506458044052124,
0.08416411280632019,
-0.09050410240888596,
-0.33701229095458984,
-0.2998819351196289,
-0.4118332862854004,
-0.5521674752235413,
-0.13468898832798004,
0.028366951271891594,
0.21164050698280334,
-0.07783515006303787,
0.9156447052955627,
0.7394394278526306,
0.5754327178001404,
0.34392666816711426,
0.07906512171030045,
-0.12329906970262527,
-0.47101375460624695,
0.6334003806114197,
-0.2308553010225296,
-0.555585503578186,
0.009524530731141567,
0.14553719758987427,
0.5469993948936462,
0.36665934324264526,
-0.10970655083656311,
-0.36035478115081787,
0.5873898267745972,
0.22160403430461884,
-0.8282536268234253,
-0.06127634271979332,
-0.6307986974716187,
0.2449152171611786,
-0.09112656116485596,
0.016612481325864792,
-0.381692498922348,
-0.1530630737543106,
0.12691199779510498,
-0.48393115401268005,
0.11589355766773224,
-0.2678241431713104,
0.7348537445068359,
0.6324092745780945,
-0.39616814255714417,
-0.2543478012084961,
-0.04664869233965874,
0.8924951553344727,
-0.6590967774391174,
0.22722449898719788,
0.3637401759624481,
0.054202113300561905,
-0.2851041853427887,
-0.7588558197021484,
-0.05929945036768913,
-0.2540986239910126,
-0.12573570013046265,
0.2328035533428192,
-0.40907517075538635,
-0.02368786558508873,
-0.1481034904718399,
0.3283628225326538,
-0.8091120719909668,
0.1038476899266243,
0.3999135196208954,
-0.34315404295921326,
0.22101278603076935,
0.0005197774735279381,
0.36762872338294983,
-0.16163672506809235,
-0.6706861257553101,
-0.441862553358078,
-0.3772302567958832,
-0.09296775609254837,
0.5990003347396851,
0.3878428637981415,
-0.22985577583312988,
0.24025888741016388,
0.16460832953453064,
0.5170238018035889,
-0.11167211085557938,
0.05639969930052757,
0.16695505380630493,
-0.41454699635505676,
-0.20173530280590057,
-0.20143410563468933,
1.0952508449554443,
0.09558583796024323,
-0.04774664714932442,
-0.20658349990844727,
-0.15798835456371307,
0.34330451488494873,
0.3377731740474701,
-0.6802839636802673,
-0.7164078950881958,
-0.043829530477523804,
-0.5103764533996582,
-0.5845553278923035,
0.2471623420715332,
-0.8854537606239319,
-0.504615068435669,
0.3188457787036896,
0.4133785367012024,
-0.6591005325317383,
-0.04783270135521889,
0.09108119457960129,
-0.07005199790000916,
0.04217910021543503,
0.1587614119052887,
-0.5992071628570557,
0.2147074192762375,
0.30815377831459045,
0.7654531002044678,
-0.2523685693740845,
-0.27189499139785767,
-0.697512149810791,
0.08763708919286728,
-0.22867245972156525,
0.5469303131103516,
-0.3573889434337616,
-0.425913542509079,
0.17513105273246765,
-0.29207903146743774,
-0.16480964422225952,
-0.49021825194358826,
0.8271259069442749,
-0.22408875823020935,
0.5452490448951721,
0.11291516572237015,
-0.6133667230606079,
0.04007827490568161,
0.5750317573547363,
-0.6990140080451965,
0.6788123250007629,
-0.013779155910015106,
-0.9899975061416626,
0.025134297087788582,
-0.4940386712551117,
-0.5621328949928284,
-0.265298455953598,
-0.08912502229213715,
-0.8606454133987427,
-0.04412013664841652,
0.570917010307312,
0.7731625437736511,
0.16969846189022064,
-0.06280569732189178,
-0.5534924268722534,
-0.08937375992536545,
0.17609764635562897,
-0.6815599799156189,
0.8552496433258057,
0.35537189245224,
-0.3101103901863098,
0.03797391802072525,
-0.31823471188545227,
-0.2128458321094513,
0.3272958993911743,
-0.18112115561962128,
-0.7190299034118652,
-0.2224162518978119,
0.04261506721377373,
-0.02271820232272148,
0.4168482720851898,
-0.5014999508857727,
-0.04883009195327759,
-0.5367382764816284,
0.43903329968452454,
0.6872055530548096,
-0.031893350183963776,
0.5795149803161621,
-0.17853613197803497,
0.573038637638092,
0.2414492815732956,
0.04861907288432121,
-0.5278323888778687,
-0.17361675202846527,
-0.44834795594215393,
-0.5236226320266724,
0.38964608311653137,
0.55295330286026,
-0.6765198707580566,
0.7598674297332764,
0.04010749235749245,
-0.07134035229682922,
-0.614050030708313,
0.5872390270233154,
0.3813526928424835,
0.4773915112018585,
0.5846365094184875,
0.029787952080368996,
-0.3205859661102295,
-0.8493985533714294,
-0.4243450462818146,
0.037230104207992554,
-0.1677393913269043,
-0.34273356199264526,
0.27305954694747925,
-0.40059560537338257,
0.6821985840797424,
-0.33110955357551575,
-0.6169638633728027,
-0.32100892066955566,
0.2872074842453003,
-0.10173670947551727,
0.7285041809082031,
0.8338374495506287,
-0.813015341758728,
-0.5240041613578796,
-0.45311418175697327,
-0.8277295827865601,
-0.024013962596654892,
-0.35278889536857605,
-0.14087870717048645,
-0.20354697108268738,
0.70490562915802,
-0.4566245973110199,
0.21597597002983093,
0.7257415652275085,
-0.39183902740478516,
0.04458138346672058,
-0.32320424914360046,
-0.09275337308645248,
-1.4378280639648438,
-0.22844210267066956,
0.07653213292360306,
-0.7039662003517151,
-0.32889044284820557,
0.2635420858860016,
0.18964339792728424,
-0.18916983902454376,
-0.3300342559814453,
0.0007481221691705287,
-0.43530502915382385,
0.4374276101589203,
-0.1871643364429474,
0.3798415958881378,
0.08861781656742096,
0.3124626874923706,
-0.3159102499485016,
0.664599597454071,
0.6824199557304382,
-0.4230000078678131,
0.19727863371372223,
0.43335944414138794,
0.01473542582243681,
0.715654194355011,
-0.5819810032844543,
0.02475135400891304,
-0.17948578298091888,
0.058018624782562256,
-0.8683011531829834,
-0.03145299479365349,
0.3079538941383362,
-0.5140370726585388,
0.5700046420097351,
0.17692241072654724,
-0.3450189232826233,
-0.04701857268810272,
-0.7359673380851746,
-0.05345679074525833,
0.31217139959335327,
-0.5735389590263367,
0.5895081758499146,
0.34117722511291504,
-0.17776092886924744,
-0.5930687189102173,
-1.1102010011672974,
0.31175416707992554,
-0.37646836042404175,
-0.284249484539032,
0.36714109778404236,
0.09217125177383423,
-0.07742899656295776,
0.20765352249145508,
0.05837976187467575,
0.11546992510557175,
0.4961988627910614,
0.025128690525889397,
-0.049498628824949265,
-0.11167176812887192,
0.17437779903411865,
0.10513715445995331,
-0.24966800212860107,
0.09626901894807816,
-0.31704965233802795,
0.4037144184112549,
-0.27330300211906433,
-0.4938206076622009,
-0.6366658210754395,
0.6106423139572144,
0.31355777382850647,
-0.26932138204574585,
0.6532271504402161,
0.7863774299621582,
-0.2983585000038147,
-0.3620348870754242,
-0.22267724573612213,
-0.10409624874591827,
-0.4643917977809906,
0.4762503504753113,
-0.30301299691200256,
-1.0731158256530762,
0.306672066450119,
-0.04485982283949852,
-0.05020797252655029,
0.4512220621109009,
0.19251304864883423,
-0.36483892798423767,
0.983418345451355,
0.5323819518089294,
-0.29230964183807373,
0.4210098385810852,
-0.1978740394115448,
0.08894159644842148,
-0.5377110838890076,
0.04249858483672142,
-0.5955035090446472,
-0.16649746894836426,
-0.7360678315162659,
-0.2117818146944046,
0.060919515788555145,
0.10351946949958801,
-0.28355953097343445,
0.4935649037361145,
-0.41578203439712524,
0.19374993443489075,
0.7133685350418091,
0.265727698802948,
-0.02706509828567505,
-0.19126351177692413,
-0.24028021097183228,
-0.3534407913684845,
-0.8330510258674622,
-0.5516902804374695,
1.0815566778182983,
0.4936627447605133,
1.0692453384399414,
0.21966435015201569,
0.9097161293029785,
0.5941026210784912,
0.19124893844127655,
-0.49602773785591125,
0.37076228857040405,
-0.6621159315109253,
-0.0443408377468586,
-0.04000386968255043,
-0.5096080303192139,
-1.029967188835144,
0.20416299998760223,
-0.3985443711280823,
-0.35832223296165466,
0.10752509534358978,
0.16543444991111755,
-0.30542099475860596,
0.27406275272369385,
-0.6099070906639099,
1.1378062963485718,
-0.1945573091506958,
-0.26331084966659546,
-0.013160936534404755,
-0.7209451794624329,
0.05370594188570976,
0.18226903676986694,
-0.12444484233856201,
0.17150186002254486,
-0.28760236501693726,
0.574812114238739,
-0.15948458015918732,
0.9321575164794922,
-0.20869168639183044,
0.038904979825019836,
0.11764150857925415,
0.2746677100658417,
0.6039997339248657,
0.2520654797554016,
0.0077451844699680805,
-0.24245303869247437,
-0.23247571289539337,
-0.6253131031990051,
-0.7136375308036804,
1.0404075384140015,
-0.7184608578681946,
-0.7071253061294556,
-0.48804381489753723,
-0.36597877740859985,
-0.3503929376602173,
0.19978193938732147,
0.37912482023239136,
0.3412278890609741,
-0.4927422106266022,
0.7722263336181641,
0.9509329199790955,
-0.20636342465877533,
0.5811336636543274,
-0.14182128012180328,
0.30595192313194275,
-0.7964145541191101,
0.6971685886383057,
-0.3943101167678833,
0.09819217026233673,
0.5160728693008423,
0.11730971932411194,
-0.6810560822486877,
-0.6511266827583313,
-0.0307233314961195,
-0.19600361585617065,
-0.7437084913253784,
-0.5757167339324951,
-0.730974555015564,
0.10007216781377792,
-0.6937379240989685,
-0.25111860036849976,
-0.3407479524612427,
-0.06768056750297546,
-0.6460369229316711,
-0.16231931746006012,
-0.10082178562879562,
0.47837355732917786,
0.007825558073818684,
0.4344068467617035,
-0.6826680302619934,
0.3148394823074341,
0.40368571877479553,
0.120192751288414,
-0.5614897608757019,
-0.2849542498588562,
-0.05895032733678818,
-0.12347658723592758,
-0.4356580078601837,
-0.9091922640800476,
0.40406015515327454,
0.35656705498695374,
0.8704020380973816,
0.5264644026756287,
0.6325014233589172,
0.2711690664291382,
0.03873440995812416,
0.8521320819854736,
0.3534458577632904,
-0.906683087348938,
0.7758979797363281,
-0.30696621537208557,
0.6460413336753845,
0.8390815258026123,
0.3544839322566986,
0.15987162292003632,
-0.7472981214523315,
-0.6230602264404297,
-0.5982881188392639,
0.15996956825256348,
0.41949471831321716,
0.4698660671710968,
-0.03254563361406326,
0.1054813340306282,
0.05064336583018303,
0.13834619522094727,
-0.9687212705612183,
-0.08976127207279205,
-0.8147222399711609,
-0.7732057571411133,
-0.20640824735164642,
-0.15314015746116638,
-0.0883115753531456,
0.3876531422138214,
0.39750275015830994,
-0.17159104347229004,
0.2547534704208374,
0.44402220845222473,
-0.35277512669563293,
0.4593413770198822,
0.4290284216403961,
0.1540439873933792,
-0.18479439616203308,
0.0033535826951265335,
0.6838403940200806,
0.04158075153827667,
-0.3867359459400177,
0.008135436102747917,
0.5388927459716797,
-0.12487396597862244,
-0.03459576517343521,
0.6567978858947754,
0.4521799087524414,
0.1990913301706314,
-0.5668413043022156,
0.7885271310806274,
-0.3174847960472107,
-0.09873715788125992,
0.10585622489452362,
0.013930222019553185,
-0.11878752708435059,
0.1840669810771942,
0.15635089576244354,
0.3365268409252167,
0.2941369414329529,
-0.4176400899887085,
0.45173773169517517,
0.5291537046432495,
-0.49412646889686584,
-0.08788333088159561,
0.8224717974662781,
0.2627926468849182,
-0.0036635366268455982,
0.27467766404151917,
-0.11097870022058487,
-0.7711595892906189,
0.2303992360830307,
0.6179701089859009,
0.9585814476013184,
-0.5016605257987976,
0.2641461193561554,
-0.04110206663608551,
0.44133979082107544,
-0.08004270493984222,
-0.0476595014333725,
-0.12481383979320526,
-0.5939215421676636,
-0.04971645399928093,
-0.37665680050849915,
-0.1811777949333191,
0.12152722477912903,
-0.5941821336746216,
-0.048757899552583694,
-0.5540475249290466,
-0.23636743426322937,
-0.6033794283866882,
-0.022602833807468414,
-0.5397406816482544,
0.11451783776283264,
-0.06151082366704941,
0.747521162033081,
-0.7801936268806458,
0.5977778434753418,
0.8183029294013977,
-0.28720903396606445,
-0.2792714238166809,
0.39860886335372925,
-0.16995878517627716,
-0.26757827401161194,
0.02844049409031868,
0.2609480321407318,
-0.24736055731773376,
-0.14402280747890472,
-0.4466017484664917,
-0.47640857100486755,
0.8375438451766968,
0.8403223752975464,
-0.25417742133140564,
0.3551824688911438,
0.06675287336111069,
0.5141171813011169,
-0.3384498059749603,
-0.21136033535003662,
0.12101612985134125,
0.24383680522441864,
-0.26801812648773193,
-0.294813871383667,
0.1657707244157791,
-0.3103580176830292,
0.08132902532815933,
-0.08904602378606796,
-0.519507884979248,
0.6278888583183289,
0.14151610434055328,
-0.20239827036857605,
0.21360625326633453,
0.9644335508346558,
-0.030312644317746162,
0.08740047365427017,
0.44951382279396057,
0.7919179201126099,
0.6769870519638062,
-0.16029001772403717,
1.0614209175109863,
-0.26864999532699585,
0.15451818704605103,
1.214228868484497,
0.021496770903468132,
0.7585741281509399,
0.35132330656051636,
0.15196365118026733,
0.5010959506034851,
0.3904322385787964,
0.029447657987475395,
0.8846233487129211,
-0.02994992397725582,
-0.17987820506095886,
-0.5348051190376282,
-0.02325700968503952,
-0.3207862377166748,
0.500776469707489,
0.3077130913734436,
-0.5334400534629822,
-0.3994165360927582,
0.4020836353302002,
0.1437765210866928,
0.9430198073387146,
0.01353564765304327,
0.5686468482017517,
0.15631364285945892,
-0.3254985511302948,
0.2515283226966858,
-0.043792057782411575,
1.0299696922302246,
-0.7701528668403625,
0.1242934912443161,
-0.187419593334198,
0.4112417995929718,
0.10217159986495972,
-0.7336629033088684,
0.3053055703639984,
-0.19685493409633636,
0.23133735358715057,
-0.5694126486778259,
0.9186393022537231,
-0.4025048613548279,
-0.09667886793613434,
0.4682680070400238,
0.41217997670173645,
-0.4586910009384155,
-0.12076737731695175,
-0.8455870151519775,
0.0953899621963501,
-0.11254218965768814,
-0.24367620050907135,
0.45207270979881287,
0.40493544936180115,
0.44912323355674744,
0.7085099220275879,
0.2952893376350403,
-0.07217861711978912,
-0.2595212757587433,
-0.08899493515491486,
0.9049880504608154,
-0.4525676667690277,
-0.9083620309829712,
-0.8403467535972595,
0.2982245087623596,
-0.3197442293167114,
-0.29102423787117004,
0.9828774333000183,
0.4368886649608612,
0.6294996738433838,
-0.02346443384885788,
0.8428905010223389,
0.24653977155685425,
0.34925922751426697,
-0.5106783509254456,
0.7605690360069275,
-0.3833870589733124,
0.23731271922588348,
-0.1883114129304886,
-0.6694461703300476,
-0.7565277218818665,
0.8390099406242371,
-0.18631026148796082,
-0.08476494997739792,
0.5113083124160767,
0.6242569088935852,
-0.10744254291057587,
-0.16364960372447968,
0.42481958866119385,
0.19811411201953888,
0.41015252470970154,
0.5272846221923828,
0.7098109722137451,
-0.47174564003944397,
0.9084155559539795,
-0.13680633902549744,
-0.16329698264598846,
0.023870928213000298,
-0.936854362487793,
-1.1036566495895386,
-0.4026857316493988,
-0.45496538281440735,
-0.20295943319797516,
0.4066354036331177,
0.7734726667404175,
0.6664785146713257,
-0.9624049067497253,
0.29496699571609497,
-0.32923343777656555,
0.032762955874204636,
-0.15402725338935852,
-0.2354194074869156,
0.5234298706054688,
-0.6905043125152588,
-0.6127945184707642,
0.6579774618148804,
0.2670026123523712,
0.3382209539413452,
-0.44036951661109924,
0.014158863574266434,
-0.2630489468574524,
-0.09303053468465805,
0.23052962124347687,
0.05677761510014534,
-0.2962181866168976,
-0.18075518310070038,
-0.081108957529068,
-0.5053178668022156,
-0.06186777353286743,
0.5485174655914307,
-0.7903353571891785,
0.42925214767456055,
0.42804110050201416,
1.177773118019104,
0.08860106766223907,
0.1506778746843338,
0.6831489205360413,
-0.8285378813743591,
0.20582175254821777,
0.5469959378242493,
0.5377388000488281,
0.6347920298576355,
-0.34725233912467957,
0.1213037297129631,
0.20077407360076904,
-0.250287801027298,
-0.5680524706840515,
0.18863430619239807,
-0.8785953521728516,
-0.5047512054443359,
0.7342201471328735,
-0.7756218314170837,
-0.014055953361093998,
-0.251018762588501,
-0.11511016637086868,
0.12429159879684448,
-0.3718489110469818,
0.6930275559425354,
0.4947061538696289,
0.18666745722293854,
-0.2688809633255005,
0.009119429625570774,
0.4169577658176422,
0.6666768193244934,
-0.6700592637062073,
-0.15824608504772186,
0.305640310049057,
0.1591053605079651,
0.2236703485250473,
-0.037135813385248184,
-0.18055486679077148,
0.03283128887414932,
0.24203167855739594,
-0.42987531423568726,
-0.22508111596107483,
-0.19025886058807373,
-0.4824083745479584,
0.8576561808586121,
-0.14140604436397552,
-0.5677828788757324
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11069v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11069v1
|
Deep Learning-based Sentiment Analysis in Persian Language
| 2024-03-17T03:15:29 | 2024-03-17T03:15:29 |
Mohammad Heydari, Mohsen Khazeni, Mohammad Ali Soltanshahi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recently, there has been a growing interest in the use of deep learning
techniques for tasks in natural language processing (NLP), with sentiment
analysis being one of the most challenging areas, particularly in the Persian
language. The vast amounts of content generated by Persian users on thousands
of websites, blogs, and social networks such as Telegram, Instagram, and
Twitter present a rich resource of information. Deep learning techniques have
become increasingly favored for extracting insights from this extensive pool of
raw data, although they face several challenges. In this study, we introduced
and implemented a hybrid deep learning-based model for sentiment analysis,
using customer review data from the Digikala Online Retailer website. We
employed a variety of deep learning networks and regularization techniques as
classifiers. Ultimately, our hybrid approach yielded an impressive performance,
achieving an F1 score of 78.3 across three sentiment categories: positive,
negative, and neutral.
|
[
-0.5318158268928528,
-0.737227201461792,
0.17902034521102905,
0.37332814931869507,
-0.6031136512756348,
0.7668043375015259,
-0.5563752055168152,
-0.4413624405860901,
0.4504355788230896,
0.060691576451063156,
-0.634150505065918,
-0.7770809531211853,
-0.26879438757896423,
0.14371518790721893,
-0.10245471447706223,
1.2252970933914185,
-0.000014114198165771086,
0.41177016496658325,
0.17542728781700134,
-0.07880090922117233,
-0.31835922598838806,
-0.5257734060287476,
-0.7045359015464783,
-0.09802736341953278,
0.3132880926132202,
0.7042499780654907,
0.7956165671348572,
-0.4533170759677887,
0.5234000086784363,
0.22736407816410065,
-0.04038451611995697,
0.35478320717811584,
-0.21671783924102783,
0.16101697087287903,
-0.040491923689842224,
-0.3317587971687317,
-0.35428357124328613,
0.05397825688123703,
0.636411190032959,
0.5757970213890076,
-0.13528916239738464,
0.1303093582391739,
0.11851779371500015,
1.0521563291549683,
-0.46159669756889343,
-0.14240241050720215,
-0.22557327151298523,
0.4427925944328308,
0.06661970168352127,
0.08698920905590057,
-0.08566828072071075,
-0.8385401368141174,
0.03072727471590042,
-0.43235301971435547,
0.059522539377212524,
-0.32685789465904236,
0.9836201071739197,
0.10551504045724869,
-0.3119639754295349,
-0.15285724401474,
-1.1759122610092163,
0.9950772523880005,
-0.884854257106781,
0.28726691007614136,
0.1031201034784317,
0.4019315540790558,
0.23257021605968475,
-0.3314485549926758,
-0.7176088094711304,
-0.24142542481422424,
0.005445627961307764,
0.3919631838798523,
-0.135761097073555,
-0.3307020366191864,
0.003623695345595479,
0.885988175868988,
-0.3953828811645508,
0.2309018224477768,
-0.12568354606628418,
0.22077615559101105,
0.9314603805541992,
0.325518935918808,
0.15262939035892487,
-0.2716164290904999,
-0.5364000201225281,
-0.1965450644493103,
-0.23004768788814545,
0.2672985792160034,
0.45709171891212463,
0.2941407263278961,
-0.12016132473945618,
0.3767392635345459,
-0.5686372518539429,
0.38691937923431396,
0.2516748011112213,
0.18230372667312622,
0.5579008460044861,
-0.16575384140014648,
-0.3534519076347351,
0.05293228477239609,
1.2611756324768066,
0.3762475848197937,
0.4751787781715393,
0.1539129912853241,
-0.20646798610687256,
0.32436665892601013,
0.25301966071128845,
-0.5642502903938293,
0.011087617836892605,
0.45610418915748596,
-0.5549553036689758,
-0.6030449867248535,
0.16038310527801514,
-1.1559809446334839,
-0.7591231465339661,
-0.2951875925064087,
-0.13680030405521393,
-0.3480232059955597,
-0.7564202547073364,
0.19224125146865845,
0.09261466562747955,
0.6344126462936401,
0.347364604473114,
-0.4327857792377472,
0.6324868202209473,
0.5843223333358765,
0.7491017580032349,
-0.20761623978614807,
0.05930772051215172,
0.02284562587738037,
-0.40849047899246216,
-0.556012749671936,
0.6817812919616699,
-0.7244976758956909,
-0.26550447940826416,
0.005753403529524803,
-0.5688534379005432,
-0.02179826982319355,
-0.5079867839813232,
0.8352411389350891,
-0.671867311000824,
0.2701766788959503,
0.11017636954784393,
-0.6253775358200073,
-0.5950039029121399,
0.5341775417327881,
-0.6451829075813293,
1.0396769046783447,
-0.0032816522289067507,
-0.7211178541183472,
0.22133708000183105,
-0.5130340456962585,
-0.7851428389549255,
0.3061746060848236,
-0.014091056771576405,
-0.7290154695510864,
0.3754294216632843,
0.34542298316955566,
0.747539758682251,
-0.2603568732738495,
0.3286782205104828,
-0.4224066436290741,
-0.17188535630702972,
0.6119258999824524,
-0.21059435606002808,
0.7214761972427368,
0.5010209679603577,
-0.6021966934204102,
0.0634840875864029,
-0.7729839086532593,
0.03366769477725029,
0.17697052657604218,
-0.31083086133003235,
-0.3732970952987671,
-0.07252640277147293,
0.4154319167137146,
0.3755292296409607,
0.17695750296115875,
-0.8048570156097412,
0.21182414889335632,
-0.6814541220664978,
0.09859535843133926,
0.5163882970809937,
0.1604142040014267,
0.30376413464546204,
0.16209034621715546,
0.8815681338310242,
0.26949557662010193,
0.28227943181991577,
0.46906816959381104,
-0.48987865447998047,
-1.0770741701126099,
0.026282330974936485,
0.4190255105495453,
0.6099363565444946,
-0.5626353025436401,
0.5330324769020081,
-0.298062801361084,
-0.6985312104225159,
-0.5209769010543823,
0.1505175083875656,
0.11997010558843613,
0.19898274540901184,
0.3339233100414276,
-0.336919367313385,
-0.49182695150375366,
-0.9149191379547119,
-0.4099401831626892,
0.2518746852874756,
0.4276593327522278,
0.44572776556015015,
0.2448790818452835,
-0.46532052755355835,
0.7764018177986145,
-0.5743994116783142,
-0.6784209609031677,
-0.5784573554992676,
0.1276632845401764,
0.6361166834831238,
0.4713973104953766,
0.1922709047794342,
-0.907817006111145,
-0.9956012964248657,
0.39584821462631226,
-0.6115124821662903,
0.33478766679763794,
-0.2904687523841858,
0.040176812559366226,
0.20210567116737366,
0.21732699871063232,
-0.5504473447799683,
0.223438560962677,
0.4928498864173889,
-0.25164952874183655,
0.43273475766181946,
0.2933695614337921,
0.11511091142892838,
-1.5908911228179932,
0.06392630189657211,
0.49639177322387695,
-0.3109220862388611,
-0.6939890384674072,
0.07674229890108109,
-0.09247786551713943,
-0.2536693811416626,
-0.434771329164505,
0.05329103022813797,
-0.24365808069705963,
0.06546791642904282,
-0.19436202943325043,
-0.5224587917327881,
0.05573180317878723,
0.5242685079574585,
0.39549148082733154,
0.4888051152229309,
0.608834445476532,
-0.44569066166877747,
0.6523966789245605,
0.16596826910972595,
-0.455642968416214,
0.25169023871421814,
-0.5273916125297546,
0.1313701719045639,
0.1577432006597519,
0.17367833852767944,
-1.027882695198059,
-0.0871405303478241,
0.5488765239715576,
-0.6602065563201904,
0.37489908933639526,
0.07183998823165894,
-0.5610811114311218,
-0.1522197723388672,
-0.5043708086013794,
0.29556113481521606,
0.5868118405342102,
-0.32345613837242126,
0.7320244312286377,
0.3254292905330658,
-0.07863268256187439,
-0.43625402450561523,
-0.4832344949245453,
0.23599909245967865,
-0.2995457351207733,
-0.4715988337993622,
0.13592462241649628,
0.1413210928440094,
-0.4292634427547455,
-0.036254674196243286,
0.23618030548095703,
-0.25678175687789917,
0.34973058104515076,
0.21796926856040955,
0.08213236182928085,
-0.3222082555294037,
0.1525438278913498,
0.0944121852517128,
-0.16161571443080902,
0.22063985466957092,
-0.07046104222536087,
0.8719565272331238,
-0.6105095148086548,
0.10961386561393738,
-0.841006875038147,
0.47806960344314575,
0.4933081865310669,
-0.3115759491920471,
0.8047599196434021,
0.716830313205719,
-0.4506942927837372,
-0.4086998999118805,
-0.5707147121429443,
-0.015244468115270138,
-0.42691150307655334,
0.11514636129140854,
-0.10707370936870575,
-0.6187881827354431,
0.24379312992095947,
-0.37189796566963196,
-0.3227509558200836,
0.7844420075416565,
0.7828071713447571,
-0.30966293811798096,
1.10438072681427,
0.7423996329307556,
-0.4969835877418518,
0.2504461109638214,
-0.3772965669631958,
0.45708197355270386,
-0.5799197554588318,
-0.33138859272003174,
-0.37765124440193176,
-0.5734730958938599,
-0.5018171668052673,
-0.08572827279567719,
0.08762840181589127,
-0.03904540464282036,
0.04822467640042305,
-0.0037239163648337126,
-0.25795778632164,
0.4032524824142456,
0.6349464654922485,
0.35948583483695984,
0.24186763167381287,
0.41244328022003174,
-0.2157658040523529,
-0.0670580267906189,
-0.4833042025566101,
-0.39934754371643066,
0.7770361304283142,
0.5088041424751282,
0.7600979208946228,
0.18088439106941223,
0.8403425216674805,
0.5004431009292603,
-0.13415586948394775,
-1.0255568027496338,
0.4768313765525818,
-0.37066757678985596,
-0.3074077069759369,
0.03615288808941841,
-0.3516209125518799,
-0.6002559661865234,
-0.039655521512031555,
-0.388530433177948,
-0.0671144425868988,
0.4268168807029724,
-0.15601162612438202,
-0.7241532802581787,
0.16876675188541412,
-0.48149779438972473,
0.8625243902206421,
-0.3758675456047058,
-0.30366984009742737,
-0.7309489846229553,
-0.44243040680885315,
0.39836809039115906,
0.08557164669036865,
0.23446865379810333,
-0.10516761988401413,
0.07188121974468231,
0.7106523513793945,
-0.30202585458755493,
1.021804928779602,
-0.08814376592636108,
-0.02299315854907036,
0.12946587800979614,
0.24407802522182465,
0.16913600265979767,
0.31150510907173157,
0.17429420351982117,
0.26541274785995483,
-0.5336991548538208,
-0.25496405363082886,
-0.3046814799308777,
0.9053314924240112,
-1.0948978662490845,
-0.22068582475185394,
-0.8595988154411316,
-0.12545180320739746,
-0.6709305644035339,
-0.010546567849814892,
-0.013393544591963291,
0.16817782819271088,
-0.27647164463996887,
0.11676322668790817,
0.7426941990852356,
-0.46393513679504395,
0.44655513763427734,
0.29045987129211426,
-0.15292157232761383,
-0.42757079005241394,
1.2360471487045288,
-0.4239608645439148,
-0.08234582096338272,
0.332509845495224,
0.566423773765564,
-0.21856996417045593,
-0.42542415857315063,
-0.645614504814148,
0.18172915279865265,
-0.4924127161502838,
-0.2471906691789627,
-0.48319241404533386,
-0.22503505647182465,
-0.31879112124443054,
0.03407706320285797,
-0.528943657875061,
-0.4635924994945526,
-0.6365031599998474,
-0.2033175528049469,
0.2969566583633423,
0.8139505386352539,
0.0694047063589096,
-0.004275107756257057,
-0.9958140850067139,
0.3124586343765259,
0.31067562103271484,
0.5530861020088196,
0.15600164234638214,
-0.19190169870853424,
-0.4327492117881775,
-0.04820919409394264,
-0.0720309242606163,
-0.8548997640609741,
0.7345014214515686,
0.30329710245132446,
0.17285113036632538,
0.5494349002838135,
-0.018771782517433167,
0.43869808316230774,
-0.11306162923574448,
0.8485413193702698,
0.30144932866096497,
-0.8202483057975769,
0.6872982978820801,
-0.39389291405677795,
0.16398046910762787,
0.6340910196304321,
0.8631724119186401,
-0.6225261688232422,
-0.20765691995620728,
-0.36251044273376465,
-0.6878101825714111,
0.48223599791526794,
0.11095228791236877,
0.5158957242965698,
0.1828959435224533,
0.2041919082403183,
0.2919169068336487,
0.20338748395442963,
-0.8130406737327576,
-0.35022810101509094,
-0.2607763111591339,
-0.41827869415283203,
-0.22976812720298767,
-0.45815396308898926,
0.1835997849702835,
-0.49802419543266296,
0.7501099109649658,
0.024531157687306404,
-0.09881440550088882,
0.018247973173856735,
-0.3165004849433899,
-0.2003084421157837,
0.3881794512271881,
0.4067065119743347,
0.3086921274662018,
-0.04423665627837181,
-0.314962774515152,
0.04079835116863251,
-0.4393816590309143,
-0.08502684533596039,
0.12783993780612946,
-0.2906639575958252,
-0.026180341839790344,
0.006260440219193697,
0.6440938711166382,
-0.23653313517570496,
-0.6965249180793762,
0.6204851269721985,
-0.2737303078174591,
-0.23129406571388245,
-0.7898675203323364,
-0.2239713966846466,
-0.06035530939698219,
0.38530534505844116,
0.4361257255077362,
0.20059747993946075,
0.6065709590911865,
-0.3974011242389679,
-0.11303595453500748,
0.5217283368110657,
-0.6914048194885254,
-0.33716005086898804,
0.14531855285167694,
0.3945363461971283,
0.1341438591480255,
0.8279601335525513,
-0.061033062636852264,
-0.9200904369354248,
0.34032127261161804,
0.13904811441898346,
1.319831371307373,
-0.1181199923157692,
0.712795615196228,
0.35475969314575195,
0.0018592982087284327,
0.36188358068466187,
0.5849094390869141,
-0.05964275822043419,
-0.8478931784629822,
-0.5548492670059204,
-0.9659375548362732,
-0.49755167961120605,
-0.05898357927799225,
-0.7804054021835327,
0.003960934467613697,
-0.9543803930282593,
-0.12495821714401245,
-0.04541565105319023,
0.39701902866363525,
-0.6714216470718384,
0.6321702599525452,
0.7524624466896057,
0.6206974387168884,
-1.017691969871521,
0.7157321572303772,
0.8618730902671814,
-0.41504499316215515,
-0.7132864594459534,
-0.08960672467947006,
-0.33208152651786804,
-0.39849600195884705,
0.7897418737411499,
0.4064202606678009,
-0.3453679084777832,
-0.16351450979709625,
-0.37880802154541016,
-0.5107361674308777,
0.4407469928264618,
-0.28722336888313293,
-0.7844158411026001,
0.6109297871589661,
0.3673838973045349,
0.8795124888420105,
-0.25269776582717896,
-0.07518339902162552,
0.49203965067863464,
0.25466904044151306,
-0.31976115703582764,
-0.5285841226577759,
-0.0868309885263443,
-0.6886111497879028,
-0.19959387183189392,
0.14425194263458252,
-0.6657735109329224,
0.9392966032028198,
0.15985651314258575,
-0.3044050633907318,
-0.15735003352165222,
0.7103407979011536,
-0.3679417371749878,
0.13891655206680298,
0.5096197724342346,
1.0248528718948364,
0.5198033452033997,
0.16342367231845856,
1.1800317764282227,
-0.05220416560769081,
0.40482544898986816,
0.8359657526016235,
-0.29019007086753845,
1.0504138469696045,
0.25475412607192993,
-0.27783364057540894,
1.1450830698013306,
0.6287623047828674,
-0.20005902647972107,
0.45237892866134644,
-0.0006981638725847006,
-0.4280436933040619,
-0.5564449429512024,
-0.3042193651199341,
-0.396435409784317,
0.36083853244781494,
0.40858834981918335,
-0.38082751631736755,
0.061435528099536896,
-0.08422620594501495,
-0.13490892946720123,
0.1992962509393692,
-0.555259644985199,
1.1842126846313477,
0.1529875099658966,
-0.43762585520744324,
0.28853604197502136,
0.2501865327358246,
0.5966039299964905,
-0.2602861225605011,
-0.06515838205814362,
-0.4143677055835724,
0.662942111492157,
-0.46148428320884705,
-0.8905702829360962,
0.30291327834129333,
0.1346663236618042,
-0.09541745483875275,
-0.2396780401468277,
0.8224780559539795,
0.0336591899394989,
-1.1067020893096924,
0.17208607494831085,
0.625982940196991,
-0.154710054397583,
-0.36842334270477295,
-1.006232500076294,
-0.23288841545581818,
0.13980688154697418,
-0.37355074286460876,
0.22092421352863312,
-0.04011436179280281,
0.05496450141072273,
0.43581995368003845,
0.8207639455795288,
-0.0787232294678688,
0.029105650261044502,
0.40663933753967285,
1.072205662727356,
-0.9061676859855652,
-0.6315242648124695,
-1.0203156471252441,
0.3477124273777008,
-0.5159602761268616,
-0.5801932215690613,
1.1945000886917114,
0.5954281091690063,
0.8064884543418884,
-0.15981972217559814,
0.7509512901306152,
0.153488427400589,
0.8949507474899292,
-0.32183220982551575,
0.5915897488594055,
-0.518801212310791,
0.15016412734985352,
-0.2866511642932892,
-0.9562497138977051,
-0.5639574527740479,
0.7290944457054138,
-0.2984243929386139,
-0.06925990432500839,
0.43778830766677856,
0.3764996826648712,
0.04225007817149162,
0.2816406786441803,
-0.09428109228610992,
0.17272043228149414,
-0.03479677811264992,
0.5428266525268555,
1.3247102499008179,
-0.27817657589912415,
0.2770894765853882,
-0.8186206817626953,
-0.039529431611299515,
-0.19339722394943237,
-0.5365580320358276,
-1.0852817296981812,
-0.12529312074184418,
-0.47223442792892456,
-0.5561885833740234,
-0.2866264581680298,
1.0366207361221313,
0.3314647674560547,
-1.2730220556259155,
-0.41625046730041504,
-0.09825634211301804,
0.04544830694794655,
-0.308118611574173,
-0.2935582399368286,
0.41354191303253174,
-0.3961794078350067,
-0.6491163372993469,
0.34298962354660034,
0.1304968148469925,
-0.2328782081604004,
-0.46336403489112854,
-0.10109077394008636,
-0.26179900765419006,
-0.17935046553611755,
0.4391189217567444,
0.16667477786540985,
-0.4735463261604309,
0.343089759349823,
0.16124184429645538,
-0.20155790448188782,
0.13754291832447052,
0.7097920775413513,
-1.125391960144043,
0.24185986816883087,
0.4994032084941864,
0.7413275241851807,
0.47032102942466736,
0.03361925855278969,
0.6010223627090454,
-0.5660627484321594,
-0.11194349825382233,
0.8090891242027283,
0.29350587725639343,
0.5220838785171509,
-0.47015538811683655,
0.24192069470882416,
0.1930241584777832,
-0.13937225937843323,
-0.403918594121933,
0.1931968480348587,
-0.996728241443634,
-0.5449166297912598,
1.1670361757278442,
0.03159426525235176,
-0.04528979957103729,
0.1153344064950943,
-0.22562651336193085,
-0.05821353942155838,
-0.558896541595459,
0.8593859672546387,
0.21988770365715027,
0.18695221841335297,
-0.18422681093215942,
-0.057805515825748444,
0.45439085364341736,
0.6167187690734863,
-0.7704319953918457,
-0.41081684827804565,
0.5902026891708374,
0.11783695966005325,
0.1427556723356247,
0.2291008085012436,
0.20522193610668182,
0.4266374111175537,
-0.3525891900062561,
-0.05191206932067871,
0.1568714678287506,
-0.29071030020713806,
-0.7083081007003784,
0.3423510789871216,
-0.004645243752747774,
-0.2401217371225357
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13050v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13050v1
|
FlowMind: Automatic Workflow Generation with LLMs
| 2024-03-17T00:36:37 | 2024-03-17T00:36:37 |
Zhen Zeng, William Watson, Nicole Cho, Saba Rahimi, Shayleen Reynolds, Tucker Balch, Manuela Veloso
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The rapidly evolving field of Robotic Process Automation (RPA) has made
significant strides in automating repetitive processes, yet its effectiveness
diminishes in scenarios requiring spontaneous or unpredictable tasks demanded
by users. This paper introduces a novel approach, FlowMind, leveraging the
capabilities of Large Language Models (LLMs) such as Generative Pretrained
Transformer (GPT), to address this limitation and create an automatic workflow
generation system. In FlowMind, we propose a generic prompt recipe for a
lecture that helps ground LLM reasoning with reliable Application Programming
Interfaces (APIs). With this, FlowMind not only mitigates the common issue of
hallucinations in LLMs, but also eliminates direct interaction between LLMs and
proprietary data or code, thus ensuring the integrity and confidentiality of
information - a cornerstone in financial services. FlowMind further simplifies
user interaction by presenting high-level descriptions of auto-generated
workflows, enabling users to inspect and provide feedback effectively. We also
introduce NCEN-QA, a new dataset in finance for benchmarking question-answering
tasks from N-CEN reports on funds. We used NCEN-QA to evaluate the performance
of workflows generated by FlowMind against baseline and ablation variants of
FlowMind. We demonstrate the success of FlowMind, the importance of each
component in the proposed lecture recipe, and the effectiveness of user
interaction and feedback in FlowMind.
|
[
-0.0513053797185421,
-0.5654075741767883,
0.5168602466583252,
-0.03178150951862335,
-0.12147678434848785,
0.04031163454055786,
0.035822223871946335,
-0.15200825035572052,
0.21787358820438385,
0.9461263418197632,
-0.9660962820053101,
-0.29475536942481995,
-0.4890531301498413,
0.01760927028954029,
-0.5627302527427673,
0.6827250719070435,
-0.18495970964431763,
-0.13299398124217987,
-0.052305713295936584,
0.22808420658111572,
-0.4945707619190216,
-0.1860971599817276,
-0.8678954839706421,
-0.7020599246025085,
0.32133206725120544,
0.20038776099681854,
0.7508901357650757,
0.3683834373950958,
0.5457176566123962,
0.3708011209964752,
0.2340632826089859,
0.17644770443439484,
-0.2645920515060425,
0.6578007936477661,
-0.03644825145602226,
-0.43544915318489075,
-0.37898141145706177,
-0.23384417593479156,
0.08604786545038223,
0.4525255262851715,
-0.6212219595909119,
0.22840438783168793,
-0.09177134931087494,
1.042994499206543,
-0.45893070101737976,
0.24036797881126404,
-0.5065136551856995,
0.3549466133117676,
-0.1312342882156372,
-0.22768692672252655,
-0.20648136734962463,
-0.4014795422554016,
0.10810501873493195,
-0.43386414647102356,
0.035627055913209915,
-0.02674758806824684,
0.6249839663505554,
0.8325518369674683,
0.07857271283864975,
-0.4898538887500763,
-0.829626739025116,
0.22948142886161804,
-0.7177084684371948,
0.1911913901567459,
-0.14587342739105225,
0.6067225337028503,
-0.36267125606536865,
-1.076676607131958,
-0.7649273872375488,
-0.008487682789564133,
0.09866124391555786,
0.14516811072826385,
-0.44969192147254944,
-0.05737752094864845,
0.34189313650131226,
0.28440061211586,
-0.582028865814209,
-0.09935527294874191,
-0.19189903140068054,
-0.14855718612670898,
0.6313589215278625,
0.5090270638465881,
0.11109206080436707,
0.1008979007601738,
0.029037080705165863,
-0.3733803927898407,
-0.7184728980064392,
-0.13664768636226654,
0.5163291692733765,
0.2648310661315918,
0.10404296219348907,
0.722923755645752,
-0.35069453716278076,
0.7369179725646973,
-0.04783819615840912,
-0.29727762937545776,
0.12438289821147919,
0.015761850401759148,
-0.5349679589271545,
-0.2155275195837021,
0.8682042956352234,
-0.05912591889500618,
0.3991924822330475,
-0.10982107371091843,
-0.31514599919319153,
-0.23442409932613373,
0.47952672839164734,
-0.727293074131012,
-0.42096981406211853,
0.31501054763793945,
-0.2828272581100464,
-0.25406768918037415,
0.04752146080136299,
-0.5029181241989136,
-0.48086225986480713,
-0.6522974967956543,
0.3385671079158783,
-0.30884432792663574,
-0.2871238887310028,
-0.10307881236076355,
-0.18266738951206207,
0.4931887686252594,
0.39220795035362244,
-0.5687474608421326,
0.08002103865146637,
0.7345803380012512,
0.6069697737693787,
-0.28414490818977356,
-0.21416065096855164,
-0.6612816452980042,
0.3544740378856659,
-0.22412067651748657,
0.8743249177932739,
-0.29476964473724365,
-0.24363745748996735,
0.08215141296386719,
-0.2726091146469116,
-0.01210633385926485,
-0.856572151184082,
-0.034396734088659286,
-0.3089570999145508,
0.14388342201709747,
0.14094030857086182,
-0.706277072429657,
-0.02805776707828045,
0.07200005650520325,
-0.3874189853668213,
0.6450982093811035,
0.22370076179504395,
-0.4670436382293701,
0.38939017057418823,
-1.0645830631256104,
-0.5398221015930176,
0.4957669675350189,
-0.3445233404636383,
-0.1980927735567093,
-0.1919735223054886,
-0.04804682359099388,
0.6242668628692627,
-0.17422263324260712,
0.36686548590660095,
-0.1655431091785431,
-0.027743343263864517,
0.3897559940814972,
-0.30723837018013,
0.6005992293357849,
0.3106175661087036,
-0.445105642080307,
0.47365856170654297,
-0.49568971991539,
-0.018031373620033264,
0.400074303150177,
0.1416281759738922,
0.30971670150756836,
-0.13616575300693512,
-0.30067238211631775,
0.13500544428825378,
0.07271885126829147,
-0.13572582602500916,
0.11044976115226746,
-0.41400206089019775,
0.7158345580101013,
0.6791052222251892,
0.14877237379550934,
0.22397541999816895,
-0.4773479402065277,
0.7991232872009277,
-0.06170825660228729,
0.14987489581108093,
-0.22745181620121002,
-0.37533241510391235,
-0.5130142569541931,
-0.1973317414522171,
-0.09377806633710861,
0.8458037376403809,
-0.864605724811554,
0.43818843364715576,
0.11265457421541214,
-0.4789377450942993,
-0.1938922107219696,
0.544664204120636,
-0.07036060839891434,
0.6534695029258728,
-0.11533807963132858,
-0.25425484776496887,
-0.4415736496448517,
-0.7937932014465332,
-0.09744395315647125,
-0.15774598717689514,
-0.36005812883377075,
0.3041047751903534,
0.2113444209098816,
-0.4426938593387604,
0.7549461126327515,
-1.040898084640503,
-0.30944404006004333,
-0.4813961982727051,
0.20354968309402466,
0.30904021859169006,
0.2847038805484772,
0.05266321823000908,
-0.5870203375816345,
-0.2375582456588745,
-0.41980496048927307,
-0.6727156043052673,
-0.10824945569038391,
-0.1644238829612732,
-0.42252087593078613,
0.18645603954792023,
0.5626821517944336,
-0.6163105964660645,
0.39929911494255066,
0.4017277956008911,
-0.2721180021762848,
0.31345054507255554,
-0.062009021639823914,
-0.3517434298992157,
-1.160528302192688,
0.09594174474477768,
-0.15835095942020416,
-0.22457388043403625,
-0.43198058009147644,
-0.06173893064260483,
-0.26942509412765503,
-0.49045529961586,
-0.45993563532829285,
0.6813494563102722,
-0.14981868863105774,
-0.17412418127059937,
-0.48772454261779785,
0.028480110689997673,
-0.2041294425725937,
0.6365653276443481,
0.207694411277771,
0.7904841303825378,
0.6649342179298401,
-0.621809184551239,
0.6774300336837769,
0.2537303864955902,
-0.0892711654305458,
0.5273996591567993,
-0.5382344722747803,
0.0692121759057045,
0.11943235248327255,
0.28298693895339966,
-0.6208579540252686,
-0.41534224152565,
0.4564572870731354,
-0.19852212071418762,
0.24732878804206848,
0.07516651600599289,
-0.45472562313079834,
-0.49448955059051514,
0.2232077568769455,
-0.14976154267787933,
0.8116423487663269,
-0.32246965169906616,
0.8794679045677185,
0.34448757767677307,
-0.3294081687927246,
-0.31132984161376953,
-0.4903295934200287,
0.3158204257488251,
-0.18493588268756866,
-0.612052321434021,
-0.05016051232814789,
-0.17044849693775177,
-0.22511370480060577,
-0.23947779834270477,
-0.12135056406259537,
-0.079842209815979,
0.2593563199043274,
0.45922592282295227,
0.2686208188533783,
0.07093899697065353,
-0.22234287858009338,
-0.12281248718500137,
-0.13284842669963837,
0.36391833424568176,
-0.6102107763290405,
0.5039640069007874,
-0.001364937867037952,
-0.5218136310577393,
-0.4935549199581146,
0.11855608224868774,
0.4350254535675049,
-0.009106652811169624,
0.40260377526283264,
0.6153721809387207,
-0.45877277851104736,
-0.5235116481781006,
-0.3613690733909607,
-0.30441349744796753,
-0.5788291692733765,
-0.1292196363210678,
-0.08398836851119995,
-0.8146384358406067,
0.47561803460121155,
-0.2974531054496765,
0.35429710149765015,
0.3486735224723816,
1.1146247386932373,
-0.1650996059179306,
0.35461175441741943,
0.5740227103233337,
0.31298092007637024,
0.5206447839736938,
-0.3545399308204651,
0.4183099567890167,
-0.4228946566581726,
-0.249618798494339,
-0.13972319662570953,
-0.11826116591691971,
-0.2314542829990387,
-0.41061508655548096,
0.25544291734695435,
-0.1796802133321762,
-0.14001598954200745,
0.39259329438209534,
-0.4942232370376587,
0.28496041893959045,
0.6465315222740173,
-0.2275412529706955,
0.1233440637588501,
-0.29251211881637573,
-0.12184230238199234,
0.3124103844165802,
-0.6901782155036926,
-0.6419586539268494,
1.17936110496521,
0.2712477445602417,
0.8256006240844727,
-0.055360764265060425,
0.9315279126167297,
0.5065580010414124,
0.6096397042274475,
-0.6796873211860657,
0.49197646975517273,
0.10860089212656021,
-0.23764637112617493,
-0.6080688238143921,
-0.4977262020111084,
-0.7728780508041382,
-0.2070409506559372,
-0.008382716216146946,
-0.39209258556365967,
-0.1874481588602066,
0.48711836338043213,
-0.6290094256401062,
0.23870854079723358,
-0.66903156042099,
0.7897003293037415,
-0.07909850776195526,
-0.1563102751970291,
0.2566502094268799,
-0.4394935369491577,
0.5641275644302368,
-0.13012871146202087,
-0.08922290056943893,
-0.16232725977897644,
0.13763482868671417,
0.6014286875724792,
-0.9051764011383057,
0.7670516967773438,
-0.28549784421920776,
-0.5818182826042175,
0.6142732501029968,
0.06136384606361389,
0.5879141688346863,
0.19576279819011688,
0.2784704566001892,
0.02014109119772911,
-0.24020560085773468,
-0.037096649408340454,
-0.5802831053733826,
0.39135316014289856,
-0.26878559589385986,
-0.567893922328949,
-0.22451141476631165,
-0.6626497507095337,
-0.28744328022003174,
0.18430346250534058,
0.08548317849636078,
0.08664727956056595,
-0.005812130868434906,
-0.19000624120235443,
0.6195381283760071,
0.0009732378530316055,
0.5365853309631348,
0.4211091697216034,
-0.12614929676055908,
-0.38152968883514404,
0.7544787526130676,
-0.20559239387512207,
0.15404394268989563,
0.377165824174881,
0.09914203733205795,
-0.3210825026035309,
-0.42178577184677124,
-0.5708861947059631,
0.05640891566872597,
-0.6848135590553284,
-0.4812624454498291,
-0.5983043313026428,
-0.4196237027645111,
-0.5610207915306091,
-0.17714589834213257,
-0.39756497740745544,
-0.31370043754577637,
-0.171880841255188,
0.10741123557090759,
0.39152297377586365,
0.6960567235946655,
-0.17040322721004486,
0.20381219685077667,
-0.7069010734558105,
0.44319459795951843,
0.8443824052810669,
0.37704482674598694,
0.05390539392828941,
-0.29683083295822144,
-0.07249792665243149,
-0.32328179478645325,
-0.5316392183303833,
-0.6164993047714233,
0.4767553508281708,
-0.06031237542629242,
0.5055228471755981,
0.537630021572113,
0.05697730556130409,
0.27361929416656494,
-0.5163396000862122,
0.5714598298072815,
0.23365415632724762,
-0.806620717048645,
0.5899518728256226,
-0.17536382377147675,
0.3390088379383087,
0.4317548871040344,
0.0022643785923719406,
-0.4839628040790558,
-0.8951268792152405,
-0.6547852754592896,
-0.9401729106903076,
0.41283106803894043,
0.4164414405822754,
0.016012825071811676,
0.07687683403491974,
0.4010653793811798,
0.3538968861103058,
0.39572837948799133,
-0.44822588562965393,
-0.2182416319847107,
-0.3699379861354828,
-0.38958993554115295,
0.15263967216014862,
0.17430122196674347,
-0.2752850651741028,
0.0523591972887516,
0.5917669534683228,
-0.33083367347717285,
0.3236214220523834,
0.04928693175315857,
0.03750964626669884,
-0.07518741488456726,
0.03299988806247711,
0.7693823575973511,
0.9172449707984924,
0.06536740809679031,
-0.2901938259601593,
-0.010409830138087273,
-0.49751123785972595,
0.17004431784152985,
0.07182906568050385,
-0.16215789318084717,
0.02690725214779377,
0.3362886607646942,
0.6568855047225952,
-0.27280908823013306,
-1.0254673957824707,
0.3791414797306061,
-0.35389605164527893,
-0.7164106965065002,
-0.7878119349479675,
0.7667639851570129,
0.3794737756252289,
0.416047066450119,
0.49984443187713623,
0.05619367957115173,
0.06340427696704865,
-0.30740752816200256,
0.244185209274292,
0.34598106145858765,
-0.09944980591535568,
0.05972323566675186,
0.6631810665130615,
0.2654131054878235,
-0.528952419757843,
0.5733376741409302,
-0.30398041009902954,
-0.2925114333629608,
0.5196543335914612,
0.2039247751235962,
1.3494468927383423,
0.21416190266609192,
0.1552429497241974,
0.05054363235831261,
0.16744212806224823,
-0.06329179555177689,
0.5702371597290039,
-0.194548562169075,
-0.5829923152923584,
-0.6292480826377869,
-0.6676383018493652,
-1.044455885887146,
0.1652115136384964,
-0.5232232213020325,
0.024167513474822044,
-0.520970344543457,
0.04526623710989952,
-0.021528517827391624,
-0.3607405126094818,
-0.813530445098877,
0.07701539993286133,
0.37030255794525146,
0.8715724945068359,
-0.6330676674842834,
0.5521113872528076,
0.6638035178184509,
-0.163506418466568,
-0.8532084822654724,
0.08574797213077545,
-0.03525504097342491,
-0.9366298913955688,
0.5551367402076721,
-0.12461631745100021,
-0.056900035589933395,
-0.1485898196697235,
-0.471154123544693,
-0.7430378198623657,
1.1935021877288818,
0.43378275632858276,
-0.5691263675689697,
0.1499791145324707,
0.19910688698291779,
0.3642357587814331,
-0.46435636281967163,
-0.015183637849986553,
0.378710001707077,
0.4906732141971588,
0.6206471920013428,
-0.5657433867454529,
0.08024902641773224,
-0.1880272477865219,
-0.08794576674699783,
0.27860233187675476,
-0.40984809398651123,
0.48695826530456543,
-0.21489819884300232,
-0.15963365137577057,
-0.19240215420722961,
0.8535007238388062,
0.39464399218559265,
0.317200243473053,
0.5478095412254333,
0.5722275376319885,
0.8325978517532349,
-0.11906779557466507,
0.7890224456787109,
-0.5710006952285767,
-0.13699805736541748,
1.0638657808303833,
-0.6123093366622925,
0.5490955710411072,
0.45136746764183044,
-0.23578032851219177,
0.5510406494140625,
0.531768262386322,
-0.09802309423685074,
0.20676134526729584,
0.6372425556182861,
-0.0128764808177948,
-0.1987217366695404,
0.2871305048465729,
-0.025942277163267136,
0.3846932351589203,
0.040189314633607864,
-0.16112209856510162,
-0.07277129590511322,
0.1041857972741127,
0.0201873742043972,
0.00012991094263270497,
-0.21175570785999298,
1.0709824562072754,
0.2510375380516052,
-0.8727918863296509,
0.22588835656642914,
-0.16322973370552063,
0.5565400719642639,
-0.6726000905036926,
-0.021566711366176605,
-0.47924259305000305,
0.04037121310830116,
-0.018034489825367928,
-0.7314450144767761,
0.6248347163200378,
0.2169942408800125,
-0.003911060281097889,
-0.6073479056358337,
0.6563512682914734,
-0.20192493498325348,
-0.4670082628726959,
-0.15375016629695892,
0.6772127151489258,
0.30386874079704285,
-0.04894085228443146,
-0.657703697681427,
-0.40315043926239014,
-0.00900451373308897,
-0.27213534712791443,
0.104108527302742,
0.6119544506072998,
0.2513844668865204,
1.1005263328552246,
0.7780012488365173,
0.18275685608386993,
-0.039806727319955826,
0.2991291284561157,
0.678032636642456,
-0.8049293756484985,
-0.5631048083305359,
-0.752810001373291,
0.07053347676992416,
-0.0278987567871809,
-0.32921233773231506,
0.18728739023208618,
0.30937525629997253,
0.6616321206092834,
-0.10894022136926651,
0.735197126865387,
-0.040398795157670975,
0.4342634975910187,
-0.6950212121009827,
0.6878553032875061,
-0.30896124243736267,
0.18732163310050964,
-0.22996476292610168,
-0.8163889050483704,
-0.14050273597240448,
0.3398003578186035,
0.05207173898816109,
-0.02951202727854252,
0.5982030630111694,
0.5378057360649109,
0.17128928005695343,
0.03747142478823662,
0.10677707940340042,
-0.13385945558547974,
0.42097747325897217,
0.49478575587272644,
0.6476065516471863,
-0.00641450984403491,
0.7314795255661011,
-0.19908437132835388,
-0.020436203107237816,
-0.10635874420404434,
-1.1201695203781128,
-0.7958105206489563,
-0.29647329449653625,
-0.624015212059021,
-0.14339293539524078,
-0.311872661113739,
0.727487325668335,
0.5259320139884949,
-0.6367389559745789,
-0.40590137243270874,
-0.34145039319992065,
0.2485889047384262,
-0.3329000174999237,
-0.24938105046749115,
-0.011391701176762581,
-0.5750818252563477,
-0.4461789131164551,
0.2847295105457306,
0.6265888810157776,
0.3609200119972229,
-0.6668225526809692,
-0.3074999451637268,
0.44523322582244873,
0.18603311479091644,
0.2932039201259613,
0.4210233986377716,
-0.4791060984134674,
0.19431376457214355,
0.014369920827448368,
0.04443403333425522,
-0.0627465546131134,
0.8950391411781311,
-0.4724274277687073,
-0.0732245221734047,
0.3259568512439728,
0.7301042675971985,
0.49093547463417053,
-0.11337188631296158,
0.9261481761932373,
-0.3640378415584564,
-0.06422163546085358,
0.34041041135787964,
0.35001859068870544,
0.24112950265407562,
-0.4192747473716736,
0.633901834487915,
0.19406892359256744,
-0.43068087100982666,
-0.6109145283699036,
0.29890432953834534,
-0.7463106513023376,
-0.21597988903522491,
0.9113543033599854,
-0.01508311741054058,
-0.39703747630119324,
0.08260126411914825,
0.04879111051559448,
0.15540063381195068,
-0.38012704253196716,
0.7501524686813354,
0.48352089524269104,
-0.48688021302223206,
-0.05118626728653908,
-0.5097002387046814,
0.6299598813056946,
0.3004140257835388,
-1.0738040208816528,
0.253101646900177,
0.24924391508102417,
0.23736858367919922,
-0.02013474702835083,
0.7460606098175049,
0.15014377236366272,
0.17623774707317352,
-0.13680393993854523,
0.2927720546722412,
-0.3411453068256378,
-0.12431381642818451,
0.06527151167392731,
0.28120192885398865,
0.0025916239246726036,
-0.01374472863972187
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15440v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15440v1
|
Linguistics from a topological viewpoint
| 2024-03-16T23:10:42 | 2024-03-16T23:10:42 |
Rui Dong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, 91F20, 62R40, 55N31, 55U10
|
Typological databases in linguistics are usually categorical-valued. As a
result, it is difficult to have a clear visualization of the data. In this
paper, we describe a workflow to analyze the topological shapes of South
American languages by applying multiple correspondence analysis technique and
topological data analysis methods.
|
[
-0.3618943989276886,
-0.7603196501731873,
0.4718689024448395,
0.1511547565460205,
-0.4105347990989685,
0.5280116200447083,
-0.21801169216632843,
-0.4492965042591095,
0.863278865814209,
0.8044734597206116,
-0.5366862416267395,
-0.7217763662338257,
-0.35370659828186035,
0.03200727701187134,
-0.5420999526977539,
0.6709433794021606,
0.09902317821979523,
-0.14458534121513367,
0.0019496130989864469,
-0.26647600531578064,
-0.18695075809955597,
-0.8668237924575806,
-0.7175106406211853,
-0.1521480679512024,
0.17636488378047943,
0.549978494644165,
0.9264293909072876,
0.4774031341075897,
0.707338809967041,
0.3316393196582794,
-0.30513525009155273,
0.00550105283036828,
-0.5605606436729431,
0.34231653809547424,
-0.1426459550857544,
-0.615424633026123,
-0.30379384756088257,
-0.10057128220796585,
0.6544301509857178,
1.1284760236740112,
-0.18538697063922882,
0.318928599357605,
-0.2771257162094116,
0.9588103294372559,
-0.01918487250804901,
0.524581789970398,
-0.3637114465236664,
0.2429923415184021,
-0.9113478660583496,
-0.35446012020111084,
-0.07511776685714722,
-0.9497486352920532,
0.3422025144100189,
-0.391512393951416,
0.2666436433792114,
0.4651419520378113,
0.8261507749557495,
0.08143870532512665,
-0.3789299428462982,
-0.2640686631202698,
-0.8682574033737183,
0.3316798210144043,
-0.43659213185310364,
0.5965434312820435,
0.4458162784576416,
0.5440240502357483,
-0.24843622744083405,
-0.39423897862434387,
-0.5420965552330017,
0.10208703577518463,
-0.401646226644516,
-0.1581973284482956,
0.2308543175458908,
-0.11857738345861435,
0.043674517422914505,
0.7590438723564148,
-0.8118889331817627,
-0.06372621655464172,
-0.9149042963981628,
-0.049128323793411255,
0.7969422936439514,
0.42539191246032715,
0.7891648411750793,
-0.29636359214782715,
0.3660823106765747,
-0.03417852148413658,
-0.7598845362663269,
0.043313637375831604,
0.6858195662498474,
0.4511640667915344,
-0.3326781392097473,
0.834482729434967,
-0.0565967932343483,
1.1584964990615845,
-0.4111466109752655,
-0.2963094413280487,
0.1842418611049652,
-0.48032402992248535,
0.07149633765220642,
-0.36641713976860046,
0.8805722594261169,
-0.13009238243103027,
0.7325899004936218,
-0.3135698735713959,
0.3345465064048767,
-0.2191697061061859,
0.2886545658111572,
-0.02570609375834465,
-0.3090724050998688,
0.3769201636314392,
-0.28543561697006226,
-0.3114340305328369,
-0.018418116495013237,
-1.2120674848556519,
-0.4973132610321045,
-0.7102388143539429,
-0.3395006060600281,
-0.5698583722114563,
-0.4088413715362549,
0.13784757256507874,
-0.0647943988442421,
0.04187905788421631,
0.10026338696479797,
-0.8376249670982361,
0.5217709541320801,
0.6101601123809814,
1.110605239868164,
-0.2129613161087036,
-0.41614454984664917,
0.23005586862564087,
0.18642057478427887,
-0.3864768445491791,
1.0863341093063354,
-0.79241943359375,
-0.054569169878959656,
-0.04021609574556351,
-0.07870205491781235,
-0.2816106975078583,
-0.2901918292045593,
0.2060021460056305,
-0.16094890236854553,
0.21388499438762665,
-0.004986111540347338,
-0.1656155288219452,
-0.5700108408927917,
0.15322630107402802,
-0.7748190760612488,
1.2397161722183228,
0.3177270293235779,
-0.6905544996261597,
0.3909992277622223,
-0.5555129051208496,
-0.5099419951438904,
0.055206298828125,
-0.45031681656837463,
-0.026721730828285217,
0.11745448410511017,
-0.18805257976055145,
0.1708964854478836,
-0.33267542719841003,
0.4572107195854187,
-0.3414943516254425,
-0.2506640553474426,
-0.028795883059501648,
0.5613883137702942,
1.2195221185684204,
0.09543269127607346,
-0.18091464042663574,
0.1924651861190796,
-1.0229673385620117,
-0.04398757591843605,
0.01988382637500763,
0.048092372715473175,
-0.41850680112838745,
0.07898328453302383,
0.04856569319963455,
0.45990368723869324,
-0.24571777880191803,
-0.3131694197654724,
0.6694686412811279,
-0.516042947769165,
0.4677862524986267,
0.28808650374412537,
-0.03004501760005951,
0.4404902756214142,
-0.14794249832630157,
0.7991105914115906,
-0.051679402589797974,
-0.08716608583927155,
0.6760399341583252,
-0.7125611305236816,
-1.0836477279663086,
-0.22895874083042145,
0.1877571940422058,
0.7242864370346069,
-0.6072540879249573,
0.26860928535461426,
-0.5614409446716309,
-0.7669201493263245,
-0.44615891575813293,
-0.3197730779647827,
0.154100239276886,
0.10276885330677032,
-0.09826361387968063,
-0.37077587842941284,
-0.6749813556671143,
-0.8862007260322571,
-0.0862380862236023,
-0.23351912200450897,
0.17649289965629578,
0.5349704623222351,
0.5385897755622864,
0.0796692818403244,
0.6791735291481018,
-0.6727571487426758,
-0.36290204524993896,
0.049282826483249664,
0.22996920347213745,
0.38861536979675293,
0.35154977440834045,
0.8519834876060486,
-0.3011913001537323,
-0.38019314408302307,
0.29969003796577454,
-0.8401144742965698,
-0.01236103568226099,
0.3325325846672058,
-0.4377649128437042,
0.11476374417543411,
0.5619693398475647,
-0.1703786700963974,
0.5079354643821716,
0.40513041615486145,
-0.5995965600013733,
0.694732666015625,
0.2819467782974243,
0.2837388515472412,
-0.7910224795341492,
0.22841815650463104,
-0.2435069978237152,
0.0487513393163681,
-0.9236176609992981,
0.24427635967731476,
-0.4719163179397583,
-0.6841391921043396,
-0.156168133020401,
0.4714692533016205,
-0.6244194507598877,
-0.4605206847190857,
0.20552633702754974,
0.17390035092830658,
-0.23671357333660126,
0.5484970211982727,
0.49323368072509766,
0.5933084487915039,
0.9143273830413818,
-0.46081823110580444,
0.5707846283912659,
0.49294400215148926,
-0.13482916355133057,
0.7076417207717896,
-0.32626065611839294,
0.20363517105579376,
-0.3821847438812256,
-0.11999114602804184,
-1.0153411626815796,
-0.3228943645954132,
0.36992427706718445,
-0.2785429060459137,
0.2219608724117279,
-0.5428718328475952,
-0.42503172159194946,
-0.3910437226295471,
-0.17491628229618073,
0.7693644165992737,
-0.1935805380344391,
-0.15026317536830902,
0.31497517228126526,
0.8010085225105286,
-0.49934151768684387,
-0.20943687856197357,
-0.6157006621360779,
0.2377578765153885,
-0.6067193150520325,
-0.9346530437469482,
-0.0313287153840065,
0.2206452190876007,
-0.5290828347206116,
-0.11283458769321442,
0.1693669706583023,
-0.7142020463943481,
-0.18339452147483826,
0.0707494467496872,
0.054032906889915466,
-0.2803143858909607,
-0.15828874707221985,
-0.2832764983177185,
0.16242651641368866,
-0.08023674041032791,
-0.5624290704727173,
0.873201310634613,
-0.2106361985206604,
0.017188910394906998,
-0.35449060797691345,
0.4256722331047058,
0.8332275152206421,
-0.2114047110080719,
0.7653434872627258,
0.007546137552708387,
-0.5627743601799011,
0.0077921668998897076,
-0.3015381693840027,
0.2204653024673462,
-0.3412196636199951,
-0.33091866970062256,
-0.5673044919967651,
-0.5554077625274658,
0.8303378820419312,
0.2775115668773651,
-0.25220412015914917,
0.09718280285596848,
0.6047571301460266,
-0.11964868009090424,
0.10451191663742065,
0.535664975643158,
-0.0668996274471283,
0.209311842918396,
-0.4260116219520569,
0.47759750485420227,
-0.47016438841819763,
-0.7078870534896851,
-1.104878306388855,
-0.07417726516723633,
-0.49077147245407104,
-0.3117547631263733,
0.365433931350708,
-0.15734191238880157,
-0.015027296729385853,
0.8076577186584473,
-0.4285126328468323,
0.22551950812339783,
0.6256040930747986,
-0.25152257084846497,
0.33824196457862854,
0.30614325404167175,
-0.31174445152282715,
-0.14322786033153534,
-0.5170304775238037,
-0.540928840637207,
1.051761269569397,
-0.13286817073822021,
0.6846626400947571,
0.4791122376918793,
0.5485408902168274,
-0.14012031257152557,
-0.4242299199104309,
-0.9444282650947571,
0.27328482270240784,
0.05858656391501427,
-0.5220887660980225,
-0.5499266982078552,
-0.09676922857761383,
-1.0360996723175049,
0.4333142340183258,
-0.4152790606021881,
-1.374815583229065,
0.7601311802864075,
-0.0674375593662262,
0.18339085578918457,
0.2929491102695465,
-0.4102836549282074,
0.7029515504837036,
-0.07894698530435562,
0.001964407041668892,
0.0339365229010582,
-0.5141565203666687,
0.6011295318603516,
-0.1851375848054886,
0.4002854824066162,
0.05616195127367973,
0.5721484422683716,
0.9027199745178223,
-0.3373018503189087,
0.49509748816490173,
0.37504255771636963,
-0.19824495911598206,
0.237602099776268,
0.6736438274383545,
0.0771912932395935,
0.13496172428131104,
-0.2576230466365814,
0.3750492036342621,
0.3193758726119995,
-0.43402206897735596,
-0.6374878287315369,
0.46146273612976074,
-0.39319783449172974,
-0.29315677285194397,
-0.6712576746940613,
-0.6264089345932007,
-0.574045717716217,
0.45912671089172363,
0.37548938393592834,
0.4327934682369232,
-0.07722434401512146,
-0.19323739409446716,
0.015617366880178452,
-0.05875465273857117,
0.05922872945666313,
0.21307572722434998,
-0.2857797145843506,
-0.04931080341339111,
0.9297483563423157,
0.27934908866882324,
-0.0001615899382159114,
0.07318741083145142,
-0.13599525392055511,
-0.3094193935394287,
-0.6760009527206421,
-0.127223938703537,
0.5816854238510132,
-0.3280985355377197,
0.13170507550239563,
-0.3685685992240906,
-0.2348095178604126,
-0.5401917695999146,
-0.07074897736310959,
-0.11129233241081238,
-0.9166056513786316,
0.1806744635105133,
-0.01111934706568718,
0.24903303384780884,
0.932556688785553,
0.11881861835718155,
0.5425949096679688,
-0.4063594341278076,
0.3439018130302429,
-0.13779997825622559,
0.7160970568656921,
-0.2064104974269867,
0.07451583445072174,
0.15677772462368011,
-0.08606589585542679,
0.015706971287727356,
-1.220781922340393,
0.35562950372695923,
0.17828024923801422,
0.4802660644054413,
0.4807450473308563,
-0.43959924578666687,
0.8155055046081543,
-0.4594707787036896,
0.4799487590789795,
-0.15678876638412476,
-0.9732091426849365,
0.6523208618164062,
-0.4650374948978424,
-0.2479090690612793,
0.5626302361488342,
0.4990580379962921,
-1.0389165878295898,
-0.7582119703292847,
-0.6762202978134155,
-0.5270256400108337,
0.8714131116867065,
0.6426052451133728,
-0.7544376254081726,
0.26173150539398193,
0.2953360676765442,
-0.061723385006189346,
0.1693238466978073,
-0.4767743945121765,
-0.4983980059623718,
-0.37248095870018005,
-0.13950255513191223,
-0.1866692304611206,
-0.0819043442606926,
-0.3116059899330139,
-0.5292040109634399,
0.3844205439090729,
-0.027490850538015366,
0.2647579312324524,
-0.26881933212280273,
-0.26407432556152344,
0.24843429028987885,
0.3471924960613251,
0.6367724537849426,
1.1613342761993408,
-0.10321677476167679,
0.2511032819747925,
-0.24192336201667786,
-0.5254152417182922,
0.1233358234167099,
-0.12499653548002243,
-0.13494321703910828,
0.14336933195590973,
0.4998641312122345,
0.5645546913146973,
-0.17188037931919098,
-0.27788475155830383,
0.1149715781211853,
0.20924580097198486,
-0.0641830712556839,
-0.1767015904188156,
-0.2609408497810364,
0.15649117529392242,
-0.09531448781490326,
-0.11085639148950577,
-0.2558925747871399,
0.6639367341995239,
-0.7120406627655029,
-0.07948242127895355,
0.24972425401210785,
-0.27466654777526855,
-0.40412208437919617,
0.16484849154949188,
0.05447772145271301,
-0.3818938434123993,
0.8690915107727051,
-0.0008431760943494737,
-0.7074065208435059,
0.7476248741149902,
0.43414995074272156,
0.6116157174110413,
-0.0050248256884515285,
0.4499915540218353,
0.532612144947052,
0.5875008702278137,
0.33196592330932617,
0.597409725189209,
0.2602021098136902,
-0.327359139919281,
-0.06521635502576828,
-0.6273359060287476,
-0.3830694258213043,
0.094890296459198,
-0.7000411748886108,
0.44126129150390625,
-0.3281528949737549,
0.12139469385147095,
0.3834102153778076,
-0.3095167577266693,
-0.6126479506492615,
0.1341107189655304,
-0.10868252068758011,
0.5471173524856567,
-1.0256086587905884,
0.6309142112731934,
0.911139965057373,
-0.36110758781433105,
-0.5285620093345642,
-0.3936963677406311,
0.6588907837867737,
-0.9409137964248657,
0.5859094858169556,
-0.35564225912094116,
-0.22800669074058533,
-0.2925048768520355,
-0.2065349519252777,
-1.2023645639419556,
0.4874242842197418,
0.2686573266983032,
-0.2641338109970093,
-0.06601937115192413,
0.7076614499092102,
0.9442572593688965,
-0.23650974035263062,
0.12403252720832825,
1.0873504877090454,
0.6145898699760437,
-0.1556510031223297,
-1.0824368000030518,
0.05721668899059296,
-0.4437559247016907,
-0.030986540019512177,
0.7851836681365967,
-0.3477262258529663,
0.6336512565612793,
0.12150082737207413,
-0.6991882920265198,
-0.3924875855445862,
0.24371026456356049,
0.0168765839189291,
-0.19211669266223907,
0.20680786669254303,
0.5174373984336853,
1.0200810432434082,
-0.39968931674957275,
0.6532037258148193,
-0.38509953022003174,
0.6364173293113708,
0.7098025679588318,
0.0018132132245227695,
0.3378249406814575,
0.5086628198623657,
-0.36740466952323914,
0.7052417993545532,
0.8207287788391113,
-0.024278223514556885,
-0.056635744869709015,
0.6464061737060547,
0.24340775609016418,
0.10268056392669678,
0.018293803557753563,
-0.3993598222732544,
0.7876057624816895,
0.6394174098968506,
0.2262348234653473,
-0.3053176701068878,
-0.2687711715698242,
-0.05095800757408142,
0.14617910981178284,
0.06555210798978806,
0.6441221833229065,
-0.13017942011356354,
-0.5467079281806946,
0.7222315669059753,
-0.5086449384689331,
0.07864618301391602,
-0.172841414809227,
-0.024885162711143494,
-0.4348353445529938,
-0.5470340847969055,
-0.42329171299934387,
-1.1152293682098389,
0.8013299107551575,
-0.17628666758537292,
0.06251604110002518,
0.3305049240589142,
0.27256134152412415,
-0.43399786949157715,
-0.4753001034259796,
0.15615251660346985,
0.5054745674133301,
0.7721146941184998,
0.28817012906074524,
-0.3908956050872803,
-0.30422428250312805,
-0.3551345467567444,
0.1733461618423462,
-0.2915893793106079,
0.44916439056396484,
-0.6014667749404907,
0.9904207587242126,
0.5007815957069397,
0.4137902855873108,
0.3510891795158386,
0.06417696923017502,
0.5212257504463196,
-1.055755376815796,
-0.6011985540390015,
-0.6065433621406555,
0.02439333125948906,
-0.18720011413097382,
-0.4419289827346802,
0.40268465876579285,
0.6685689091682434,
0.619976282119751,
-0.11602054536342621,
0.49522876739501953,
-0.44955867528915405,
0.4121691882610321,
-0.557348906993866,
0.7135879397392273,
-0.34515661001205444,
0.03854748606681824,
-0.5580869317054749,
-1.1142054796218872,
-0.7137567400932312,
0.5648927688598633,
-0.05353135988116264,
-0.47817954421043396,
1.1894060373306274,
0.5647429823875427,
-0.3045313060283661,
0.046384114772081375,
-0.07421626895666122,
0.16645662486553192,
0.1019451916217804,
0.44823816418647766,
0.7444002628326416,
0.007506959605962038,
0.3956652879714966,
-0.5827396512031555,
-0.26899534463882446,
-0.07379642874002457,
-0.5257070064544678,
-1.0982792377471924,
-0.9008405804634094,
-0.01007392443716526,
-0.532480001449585,
0.1111537367105484,
0.21691906452178955,
0.8739818334579468,
-1.0070401430130005,
-0.8877745270729065,
0.007365119643509388,
0.35379865765571594,
-0.2195662558078766,
-0.25655025243759155,
0.7576813697814941,
-0.24168173968791962,
-0.8818156719207764,
0.28227195143699646,
0.3788999021053314,
0.0786760225892067,
-0.19066162407398224,
0.43921923637390137,
-0.37208762764930725,
-0.14794577658176422,
0.5596869587898254,
0.6042357683181763,
-0.7371599674224854,
-0.3349835276603699,
-0.17267227172851562,
-0.15076403319835663,
0.2673565745353699,
1.1972310543060303,
-0.25496935844421387,
0.4983602464199066,
0.73052978515625,
0.18555204570293427,
0.6225670576095581,
-0.030335616320371628,
0.8428890705108643,
-0.4268799424171448,
0.5877207517623901,
0.12562187016010284,
0.5333308577537537,
0.09606960415840149,
-0.44381144642829895,
0.9889588356018066,
0.28413012623786926,
-0.24613071978092194,
-0.6407468914985657,
0.4597802460193634,
-1.4054840803146362,
-0.16073283553123474,
1.1230827569961548,
0.1832876205444336,
-0.1851307898759842,
-0.6645990610122681,
-0.315291166305542,
0.06839393824338913,
0.12800158560276031,
0.7321790456771851,
1.1572524309158325,
-0.3597847521305084,
-0.038053955882787704,
-0.43872979283332825,
0.7466527819633484,
-0.10320242494344711,
-1.2588611841201782,
-0.19728423655033112,
0.5268376469612122,
0.2603929340839386,
0.4462530314922333,
0.5838370323181152,
-0.27402111887931824,
-0.046620551496744156,
0.02171896956861019,
-0.16690228879451752,
0.31805041432380676,
-0.8344548940658569,
-0.3076227009296417,
0.03893693536520004,
-0.11189546436071396,
0.08553842455148697
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11025v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11025v1
|
Pre-Trained Language Models Represent Some Geographic Populations Better Than Others
| 2024-03-16T22:01:39 | 2024-03-16T22:01:39 |
Jonathan Dunn, Benjamin Adams, Harish Tayyar Madabushi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper measures the skew in how well two families of LLMs represent
diverse geographic populations. A spatial probing task is used with
geo-referenced corpora to measure the degree to which pre-trained language
models from the OPT and BLOOM series represent diverse populations around the
world. Results show that these models perform much better for some populations
than others. In particular, populations across the US and the UK are
represented quite well while those in South and Southeast Asia are poorly
represented. Analysis shows that both families of models largely share the same
skew across populations. At the same time, this skew cannot be fully explained
by sociolinguistic factors, economic factors, or geographic factors. The basic
conclusion from this analysis is that pre-trained models do not equally
represent the world's population: there is a strong skew towards specific
geographic populations. This finding challenges the idea that a single model
can be used for all populations.
|
[
-0.4732397198677063,
-0.3360024392604828,
0.6573138236999512,
0.23755612969398499,
-0.11497518420219421,
0.2991783618927002,
-0.4486754536628723,
-0.47269144654273987,
0.16242508590221405,
0.35643184185028076,
-0.46695393323898315,
-0.5384229421615601,
-0.7540064454078674,
0.07666339725255966,
-0.29412442445755005,
0.5918853282928467,
0.32656845450401306,
0.3544682562351227,
-0.02924785390496254,
-0.28641369938850403,
0.013844890519976616,
-0.910767138004303,
-0.11678536236286163,
-0.34328845143318176,
0.3455372750759125,
0.4636915624141693,
1.082093358039856,
0.2592899799346924,
0.6502232551574707,
0.2776327431201935,
-0.20031732320785522,
-0.18799425661563873,
-0.9460186958312988,
-0.053992096334695816,
-0.12446451932191849,
-0.6274309754371643,
-0.1361699253320694,
0.20105352997779846,
0.5194810032844543,
1.2073484659194946,
0.021649792790412903,
0.05850127339363098,
-0.19713182747364044,
0.3330879211425781,
-0.5191100239753723,
-0.34965065121650696,
-0.7992613315582275,
-0.0552930012345314,
-0.4354732036590576,
-0.04564714431762695,
-0.21101327240467072,
-0.5386186838150024,
0.6840159893035889,
-0.5560484528541565,
0.4994591474533081,
0.29985615611076355,
0.9332211017608643,
0.13592995703220367,
-0.6115781664848328,
-0.14095096290111542,
-1.030644178390503,
0.9111158847808838,
-0.7348753213882446,
0.31495773792266846,
0.2986986041069031,
0.1895373910665512,
-0.22004516422748566,
-0.11940130591392517,
-0.2999654710292816,
-0.42830875515937805,
-0.13441762328147888,
0.2710852324962616,
0.06957168132066727,
-0.14720939099788666,
0.14839684963226318,
0.4068300127983093,
-0.7383049726486206,
0.3815269470214844,
-0.6841695308685303,
-0.12002784758806229,
0.8013888597488403,
0.09964122623205185,
0.48314327001571655,
0.041125666350126266,
-0.26128315925598145,
-0.1579487919807434,
-0.94248366355896,
0.0964447483420372,
0.690738320350647,
0.5471495985984802,
-0.23319727182388306,
0.5751051902770996,
0.08469369262456894,
0.5394349694252014,
-0.2136942446231842,
-0.060724955052137375,
0.1957191824913025,
-0.25723379850387573,
0.10578744858503342,
-0.24968577921390533,
0.6920300126075745,
0.13656102120876312,
0.76734459400177,
-0.22482238709926605,
-0.016034822911024094,
0.024965887889266014,
0.12154402583837509,
-0.35753127932548523,
-0.14082013070583344,
-0.06395179778337479,
-0.18105345964431763,
0.10074973106384277,
0.17640741169452667,
-0.9784446954727173,
-0.1126897931098938,
-0.24483108520507812,
-0.2220749408006668,
-0.15889139473438263,
-0.5892044305801392,
0.23731012642383575,
0.1265946328639984,
0.34355831146240234,
0.09767430275678635,
-1.1064053773880005,
0.16742664575576782,
0.6978051066398621,
0.800952136516571,
-0.42063114047050476,
-0.5982177257537842,
0.34438183903694153,
-0.20650939643383026,
-0.40177661180496216,
1.0340969562530518,
-0.7715888023376465,
-0.5445113182067871,
0.2125532478094101,
-0.17113174498081207,
-0.10197269171476364,
-0.7034350037574768,
-0.05773569643497467,
-0.6006201505661011,
0.05329718440771103,
-0.6337196826934814,
-0.11805960536003113,
0.10626588761806488,
0.07882009446620941,
-0.6414099335670471,
1.2507435083389282,
0.3575495183467865,
-0.6999670267105103,
0.9152580499649048,
-0.39150458574295044,
-0.2138049453496933,
0.06295935809612274,
-0.14549008011817932,
-0.19575035572052002,
0.2945711612701416,
0.3369094133377075,
0.09402386844158173,
-0.06984365731477737,
0.14848124980926514,
-0.735258162021637,
-0.3730615973472595,
0.15813179314136505,
-0.17492187023162842,
0.8801907896995544,
0.36269134283065796,
-0.20501577854156494,
0.10176781564950943,
-0.6141735911369324,
0.0741528868675232,
0.2544614374637604,
-0.3207095265388489,
-0.508496880531311,
0.1377040445804596,
-0.07038514316082001,
0.11728718131780624,
0.11989486962556839,
-0.42923790216445923,
0.2333478480577469,
-0.5792356133460999,
0.3649948537349701,
0.3619796633720398,
-0.33215972781181335,
0.9177615642547607,
-0.08272669464349747,
0.8399569988250732,
0.11961394548416138,
0.052246857434511185,
0.1478145569562912,
-0.3123537302017212,
-0.6116108298301697,
-0.26449260115623474,
-0.1300370842218399,
0.49560490250587463,
-0.2979901432991028,
0.11902057379484177,
-0.622382640838623,
-0.7557653188705444,
-0.339120090007782,
-0.07627765834331512,
0.08016300201416016,
-0.01246107742190361,
-0.06411347538232803,
-0.29760119318962097,
-0.6061685085296631,
-0.7217287421226501,
-0.3398449420928955,
-0.29287010431289673,
0.08504641801118851,
0.4567817747592926,
0.42500054836273193,
-0.22881516814231873,
1.1116836071014404,
-0.3396972715854645,
0.21724101901054382,
-0.34312477707862854,
0.1195366308093071,
-0.07555174082517624,
0.027391891926527023,
0.9303827881813049,
-0.6494871377944946,
-0.430340051651001,
-0.04700756072998047,
-0.3746001422405243,
-0.3298813998699188,
0.10811811685562134,
-0.4448300302028656,
-0.07049672305583954,
0.15292558073997498,
-0.3210536539554596,
0.528854489326477,
0.7458045482635498,
-0.21819238364696503,
0.6109979152679443,
-0.17266863584518433,
0.19000673294067383,
-0.8040055632591248,
-0.038909610360860825,
0.015430365689098835,
-0.014746214263141155,
-0.556876003742218,
0.029691262170672417,
-0.08058242499828339,
-0.25889691710472107,
-0.47343671321868896,
0.3604954183101654,
-0.6556622385978699,
-0.674221396446228,
-0.009733234532177448,
0.2508508563041687,
-0.23860818147659302,
-0.0016018664464354515,
0.30596551299095154,
0.9936283230781555,
0.42713767290115356,
-0.5613111257553101,
0.13847629725933075,
0.1447007805109024,
-0.48621314764022827,
0.3273804485797882,
-0.4994151294231415,
-0.02051553875207901,
-0.2682543396949768,
-0.014895888976752758,
-1.1112051010131836,
-0.2862150967121124,
-0.2840249240398407,
-0.33672794699668884,
-0.062113143503665924,
-0.07215417176485062,
-0.3191920518875122,
-0.7081116437911987,
0.1956178843975067,
0.33146393299102783,
0.43258050084114075,
-0.5370463728904724,
0.3203027844429016,
0.42601078748703003,
-0.2397020310163498,
-0.41122379899024963,
-0.677970290184021,
-0.35344505310058594,
-0.586652398109436,
-0.6849718689918518,
-0.0472324974834919,
0.10830476880073547,
-0.42617398500442505,
-0.13216227293014526,
-0.05172823742032051,
-0.31548553705215454,
0.11465279757976532,
0.14497965574264526,
0.30312758684158325,
-0.5806445479393005,
0.07157109677791595,
-0.5351825952529907,
0.012734529562294483,
0.004601072054356337,
-0.32599058747291565,
0.7034067511558533,
-0.0024849676992744207,
-0.6383341550827026,
0.23989000916481018,
0.4114265739917755,
0.8145692348480225,
-0.44316592812538147,
0.8056418895721436,
0.17442716658115387,
-0.21176467835903168,
0.026314958930015564,
-0.6034404635429382,
-0.08219227939844131,
-0.47512367367744446,
0.6558162569999695,
-0.22203628718852997,
-1.1206108331680298,
0.8312859535217285,
-0.19899305701255798,
0.06724382191896439,
0.36263012886047363,
0.4663664698600769,
-0.2037345916032791,
0.7416262626647949,
0.9940245747566223,
-0.31933680176734924,
0.4091261029243469,
-0.1188824474811554,
0.567130982875824,
-0.29487448930740356,
-0.10384153574705124,
-0.7900262475013733,
-0.1931210160255432,
-0.4889971613883972,
-0.119493268430233,
0.19583863019943237,
0.2571775019168854,
-0.5508851408958435,
0.23208004236221313,
-0.3934866786003113,
0.5280164480209351,
0.7217158675193787,
-0.27763620018959045,
-0.05966874584555626,
0.37150338292121887,
-0.17691892385482788,
-0.5754213929176331,
-0.7082481384277344,
-0.8128353953361511,
1.1895649433135986,
0.12096336483955383,
0.9941818118095398,
0.05683474615216255,
0.6704464554786682,
-0.22166495025157928,
0.6088864803314209,
-0.4484963119029999,
0.32516932487487793,
-0.29406967759132385,
-0.7708938121795654,
-0.4253275394439697,
-0.441091388463974,
-1.0883914232254028,
0.36178845167160034,
-0.2863803207874298,
-0.630731463432312,
0.2841251492500305,
0.2466338723897934,
-0.5180783271789551,
0.3890906870365143,
-0.6696963310241699,
0.6201420426368713,
-0.8234485387802124,
0.04618323966860771,
0.10219720005989075,
-0.3550610840320587,
0.3140864670276642,
-0.1874648481607437,
0.3166040778160095,
-0.34960898756980896,
0.3177199959754944,
0.45855632424354553,
-0.31760743260383606,
0.7290248870849609,
-0.041913196444511414,
-0.11542070657014847,
0.31446292996406555,
-0.09313997626304626,
-0.07968711853027344,
-0.18222790956497192,
-0.17319412529468536,
0.3424816131591797,
0.1096242368221283,
-0.6060049533843994,
-0.40720343589782715,
0.478413462638855,
-1.3119808435440063,
-0.6288239359855652,
-0.41651880741119385,
-0.5454612970352173,
-0.2115759253501892,
0.24884212017059326,
0.6743313670158386,
0.03437374159693718,
-0.31976738572120667,
0.07934453338384628,
0.43447768688201904,
-0.2771175503730774,
0.08940394222736359,
0.5599105358123779,
-0.43715107440948486,
-0.21976371109485626,
0.4154384136199951,
0.35089653730392456,
0.6711301207542419,
0.17808233201503754,
0.20472872257232666,
-0.32548800110816956,
-0.3831031322479248,
0.045488908886909485,
0.4125201106071472,
-0.6312324404716492,
0.2801186740398407,
-0.5500292181968689,
-0.15979424118995667,
-0.6010401248931885,
-0.38247597217559814,
-0.33865851163864136,
0.14537665247917175,
-0.23926761746406555,
-0.1517583131790161,
0.22019176185131073,
1.1257728338241577,
-0.10203314572572708,
0.8217315673828125,
-0.44360360503196716,
-0.07100962847471237,
0.22873857617378235,
0.10134033113718033,
-0.15406909584999084,
-0.425612211227417,
-0.013977820985019207,
0.300394207239151,
-0.03910532966256142,
-1.166683554649353,
0.6050708293914795,
0.14318940043449402,
0.8745639324188232,
0.5702951550483704,
-0.08058347553014755,
1.1033588647842407,
-0.6048884987831116,
0.962917149066925,
-0.15615881979465485,
-0.6743676066398621,
0.4124157428741455,
-0.3083686828613281,
0.48116427659988403,
0.6717775464057922,
0.7502346038818359,
-0.4742025136947632,
-0.5307942628860474,
-0.40749290585517883,
-0.9228406548500061,
0.5366219878196716,
-0.25404036045074463,
0.40548816323280334,
-0.09459468722343445,
0.42574378848075867,
0.16287849843502045,
-0.018331393599510193,
-1.058240532875061,
-0.2989875376224518,
-0.20028167963027954,
-0.25346633791923523,
-0.4121645390987396,
-0.5673605799674988,
0.11406189203262329,
0.005816922057420015,
0.4014769494533539,
0.19698360562324524,
0.21237245202064514,
0.11885516345500946,
-0.3099915683269501,
-0.2661752700805664,
0.24995914101600647,
0.7576438188552856,
0.9551562666893005,
-0.08467159420251846,
0.24346576631069183,
0.2506526708602905,
-0.7475603222846985,
0.3846435546875,
-0.1532629430294037,
-0.23261576890945435,
0.1256381869316101,
0.480048269033432,
0.6398398876190186,
0.42547744512557983,
-0.42689967155456543,
0.32599228620529175,
0.03429040312767029,
-0.210536390542984,
-0.32444462180137634,
-0.0026345213409513235,
0.21951653063297272,
0.11999129503965378,
0.4245400130748749,
0.09042017161846161,
-0.2572389245033264,
-0.44952696561813354,
-0.06431133300065994,
0.5686051249504089,
-0.003275885246694088,
-0.49679866433143616,
0.5069922804832458,
0.2826696038246155,
-0.3026312291622162,
0.7673513889312744,
-0.26443326473236084,
-1.0022833347320557,
0.6663523316383362,
0.680447518825531,
0.21053721010684967,
-0.22625145316123962,
0.1220027357339859,
0.6261242032051086,
0.8332595229148865,
-0.07499298453330994,
0.24751070141792297,
0.21742364764213562,
-0.8431146740913391,
-0.27383702993392944,
-0.4884323477745056,
-0.2927016019821167,
0.22657233476638794,
-0.7836625576019287,
0.20046520233154297,
-0.2507018744945526,
-0.4063378572463989,
-0.3941790759563446,
-0.02907756343483925,
-0.9723036289215088,
0.24098463356494904,
0.4246978461742401,
0.732572615146637,
-1.4123824834823608,
0.3957868218421936,
0.8621733784675598,
-0.08818766474723816,
-0.8724924325942993,
0.01402550470083952,
-0.11296293139457703,
-0.7943612933158875,
0.9805958271026611,
0.24868521094322205,
-0.1324908584356308,
-0.16444212198257446,
-0.6784757971763611,
-1.7331050634384155,
0.694240927696228,
0.4182874262332916,
-0.5970762372016907,
-0.011919165030121803,
0.6334764361381531,
0.642388105392456,
-0.4554577171802521,
0.3550947606563568,
0.4783465266227722,
0.1751975566148758,
-0.0460234172642231,
-0.9429975748062134,
-0.599007785320282,
-0.02890302985906601,
0.25470516085624695,
-0.08390340954065323,
-0.46657466888427734,
0.9557114243507385,
-0.4762875437736511,
-0.618486225605011,
-0.09653053432703018,
0.8119043707847595,
0.4436146020889282,
0.08258561044931412,
0.5086858868598938,
0.3733173608779907,
0.7783715128898621,
-0.43529483675956726,
0.9698655009269714,
-0.4436746835708618,
0.4672822654247284,
1.018610954284668,
-0.5916906595230103,
0.8805866241455078,
0.2886936664581299,
-0.7406051158905029,
0.24901404976844788,
0.9904481768608093,
0.21226991713047028,
0.6325682997703552,
0.3904910683631897,
-0.0764017328619957,
-0.41380760073661804,
0.4510561227798462,
-0.43725264072418213,
0.55357426404953,
0.4759182035923004,
0.0589824803173542,
-0.4384806752204895,
0.09669500589370728,
-0.07354321330785751,
0.18221734464168549,
-0.26076170802116394,
0.4366641640663147,
0.0636160671710968,
-0.8433411121368408,
0.27522730827331543,
-0.42359641194343567,
1.0022456645965576,
-0.6757960319519043,
0.48325690627098083,
-0.44783514738082886,
-0.008464309386909008,
-0.24420559406280518,
-0.6778638958930969,
0.36252421140670776,
0.050305917859077454,
-0.2251139134168625,
-0.019626397639513016,
0.5612951517105103,
-0.5937758088111877,
-0.6380587816238403,
0.5014417767524719,
0.5170597434043884,
0.555270791053772,
0.34224826097488403,
-0.5003044605255127,
-0.04256618022918701,
0.09241928160190582,
-0.27182745933532715,
-0.022353826090693474,
0.4205473065376282,
-0.15923239290714264,
0.7114456295967102,
0.690774142742157,
0.46281373500823975,
0.9290823340415955,
0.1491667628288269,
0.24034623801708221,
-0.43959757685661316,
-0.5553573966026306,
-0.7685410380363464,
0.3953641653060913,
-0.10399790108203888,
-0.38947173953056335,
0.8921195864677429,
0.4563145041465759,
1.0448909997940063,
-0.057595644146203995,
0.7608745694160461,
0.3218875527381897,
0.6398428678512573,
-0.1402740478515625,
0.7113265991210938,
-0.4026790261268616,
0.005692861042916775,
-0.014965751208364964,
-1.2347705364227295,
-0.23713691532611847,
1.0735869407653809,
-1.0836498737335205,
0.5057174563407898,
0.5191998481750488,
0.7247998118400574,
-0.16143009066581726,
-0.04945797845721245,
0.44026660919189453,
0.03129159286618233,
0.20792748034000397,
0.3993972837924957,
1.0678738355636597,
0.14176499843597412,
0.34369879961013794,
-0.18194207549095154,
-0.24878281354904175,
-0.1263655126094818,
-0.7913872003555298,
-0.8956729769706726,
-0.27239400148391724,
-0.13960009813308716,
0.011488177813589573,
-0.1413014829158783,
0.5550657510757446,
1.1664650440216064,
-0.8136333227157593,
-0.20361994206905365,
0.22551654279232025,
-0.32563918828964233,
0.24428512156009674,
-0.19206763803958893,
0.02018839679658413,
-0.3376866579055786,
-0.6618069410324097,
0.1473865956068039,
0.26103025674819946,
0.2952611744403839,
-0.6115541458129883,
0.10191945731639862,
-0.07161016017198563,
0.08627938479185104,
0.29915857315063477,
0.326086163520813,
-0.8628166913986206,
-0.20893806219100952,
0.34928977489471436,
-0.473536878824234,
0.10143405199050903,
0.8221187591552734,
-0.49620652198791504,
0.29999011754989624,
0.1888572871685028,
0.36185142397880554,
0.20540517568588257,
-0.010791483335196972,
0.5863112211227417,
-0.6203760504722595,
0.4407953917980194,
0.0803234875202179,
0.49554112553596497,
0.6269346475601196,
-0.41465312242507935,
0.4198015332221985,
-0.010759327560663223,
-0.7634022235870361,
-0.6177602410316467,
0.39466771483421326,
-0.5356892943382263,
0.10743693262338638,
1.3240303993225098,
-0.37344568967819214,
-0.14441761374473572,
-0.1151077002286911,
0.08415006846189499,
-0.033239446580410004,
0.06373976171016693,
0.5730153918266296,
0.9835310578346252,
0.22761495411396027,
-0.05308302491903305,
-0.6837125420570374,
0.18576382100582123,
0.8255645036697388,
-0.7040870785713196,
-0.1969105303287506,
0.4373255968093872,
0.5972210168838501,
0.3118825852870941,
0.7531455755233765,
-0.09386549890041351,
0.0436880961060524,
-0.08106685429811478,
0.08791957050561905,
0.44475996494293213,
-0.2148861438035965,
-0.3049675524234772,
-0.08246267586946487,
0.1799405813217163,
0.2149927318096161
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11009v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11009v1
|
DIALECTBENCH: A NLP Benchmark for Dialects, Varieties, and Closely-Related Languages
| 2024-03-16T20:18:36 | 2024-03-16T20:18:36 |
Fahim Faisal, Orevaoghene Ahia, Aarohi Srivastava, Kabir Ahuja, David Chiang, Yulia Tsvetkov, Antonios Anastasopoulos
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Language technologies should be judged on their usefulness in real-world use
cases. An often overlooked aspect in natural language processing (NLP) research
and evaluation is language variation in the form of non-standard dialects or
language varieties (hereafter, varieties). Most NLP benchmarks are limited to
standard language varieties. To fill this gap, we propose DIALECTBENCH, the
first-ever large-scale benchmark for NLP on varieties, which aggregates an
extensive set of task-varied variety datasets (10 text-level tasks covering 281
varieties). This allows for a comprehensive evaluation of NLP system
performance on different language varieties. We provide substantial evidence of
performance disparities between standard and non-standard language varieties,
and we also identify language clusters with large performance divergence across
tasks. We believe DIALECTBENCH provides a comprehensive view of the current
state of NLP for language varieties and one step towards advancing it further.
Code/data: https://github.com/ffaisal93/DialectBench
|
[
-0.8243387937545776,
-0.6264961957931519,
0.12297496199607849,
0.5731047987937927,
-0.05755705013871193,
0.00018260438810102642,
-0.47840720415115356,
-0.5527324080467224,
0.576115608215332,
0.59373939037323,
-0.39969828724861145,
-0.5039389133453369,
-0.3294711410999298,
0.23351715505123138,
-0.6086228489875793,
0.6609168648719788,
0.45152559876441956,
-0.1699116975069046,
-0.16081680357456207,
-0.3573469817638397,
-0.19677267968654633,
-0.5891894102096558,
-0.5395668148994446,
-0.2447485327720642,
0.37773486971855164,
0.3313153088092804,
0.6314923167228699,
0.39941853284835815,
0.5169491767883301,
0.3736325800418854,
-0.09260889142751694,
-0.14472107589244843,
-0.3243011236190796,
0.4724666476249695,
-0.33812424540519714,
-0.5045587420463562,
-0.39330026507377625,
-0.131839781999588,
0.6010260581970215,
1.1505974531173706,
-0.33990105986595154,
0.07281335443258286,
-0.021335747092962265,
0.9258516430854797,
-0.5478492379188538,
-0.05872967466711998,
-0.6099980473518372,
0.22317610681056976,
-0.92225581407547,
0.1980905681848526,
-0.1949038803577423,
-0.37076535820961,
-0.08712129294872284,
-0.358370304107666,
0.49967536330223083,
0.2832914888858795,
0.8097556829452515,
0.004074036609381437,
-0.17287543416023254,
0.25827696919441223,
-0.4689771234989166,
0.763752281665802,
-0.8963161110877991,
0.5640684962272644,
0.38036835193634033,
0.6732659339904785,
-0.23122842609882355,
-0.8066815733909607,
-0.6169324517250061,
-0.26465854048728943,
0.076942577958107,
0.00377154559828341,
-0.31131479144096375,
0.0845639631152153,
0.3317566514015198,
0.7993051409721375,
-0.9051401615142822,
0.11078112572431564,
-0.09543008357286453,
0.010900938883423805,
0.4257034957408905,
0.16214287281036377,
0.0883752629160881,
-0.25516849756240845,
-0.00778430188074708,
-0.22557008266448975,
-0.4393402934074402,
-0.04609290510416031,
0.45832085609436035,
0.5061787366867065,
-0.08199421316385269,
0.3998372554779053,
-0.7886357307434082,
0.9024816751480103,
-0.08317777514457703,
0.35720112919807434,
0.5111775994300842,
-0.1689886748790741,
-0.15292008221149445,
-0.24867504835128784,
0.9109004139900208,
0.46237778663635254,
0.08159500360488892,
-0.43438035249710083,
-0.2250158041715622,
-0.2056342363357544,
0.4498206675052643,
-0.5884179472923279,
-0.3656221926212311,
0.13143017888069153,
-0.19064578413963318,
-0.16062213480472565,
-0.0025158252101391554,
-1.2607474327087402,
-0.5253229737281799,
-0.03904504328966141,
0.01934751681983471,
-0.5390152335166931,
-0.5017463564872742,
0.01589750498533249,
-0.36437034606933594,
0.13678599894046783,
0.02396845817565918,
-1.1110378503799438,
0.7878952026367188,
1.0604114532470703,
0.8770403861999512,
-0.3342052102088928,
-0.40709149837493896,
-0.445431649684906,
-0.5487461686134338,
-0.35770565271377563,
0.8307748436927795,
-0.3482724130153656,
-0.363614946603775,
-0.0059297895058989525,
-0.023660197854042053,
0.10032834112644196,
-1.1418664455413818,
0.5553940534591675,
-0.3862309157848358,
0.04732431843876839,
-0.28262531757354736,
-0.555334746837616,
-0.13688509166240692,
0.3647347092628479,
-1.060880422592163,
1.4202505350112915,
0.4795909821987152,
-0.6539599299430847,
0.4715607762336731,
-0.32995688915252686,
-0.38872262835502625,
0.2798440456390381,
-0.07818014174699783,
-0.12514252960681915,
0.34229573607444763,
-0.20959414541721344,
0.07913747429847717,
-0.5612909197807312,
0.3179245591163635,
-0.4397415518760681,
-0.17485827207565308,
0.1687161773443222,
-0.32699742913246155,
0.7013288140296936,
0.07584456354379654,
-0.45958492159843445,
-0.053144730627536774,
-0.8472681641578674,
0.3815288841724396,
-0.09967366605997086,
-0.04048524424433708,
-0.3175179958343506,
0.14439204335212708,
0.5190767645835876,
0.16251996159553528,
0.23320363461971283,
-0.5896931886672974,
0.05573718994855881,
-0.7554429769515991,
0.11380889266729355,
0.45916470885276794,
-0.4152384102344513,
0.12935195863246918,
-0.3825047016143799,
0.44757819175720215,
-0.3063492178916931,
-0.02183896116912365,
0.25622841715812683,
-0.39627331495285034,
-1.0475554466247559,
0.06002417579293251,
0.5863814949989319,
0.2961835265159607,
-0.4638245105743408,
0.8615247011184692,
-0.411318838596344,
-0.7745630741119385,
-0.34086981415748596,
0.24364377558231354,
0.30908265709877014,
0.1806495189666748,
0.35904204845428467,
-0.8412467241287231,
-0.6547173261642456,
-1.1609960794448853,
-0.3524096608161926,
-0.11724148690700531,
-0.21861709654331207,
0.022967834025621414,
0.18861813843250275,
0.13508950173854828,
1.2244210243225098,
-0.17343851923942566,
0.02180333063006401,
-0.5578837394714355,
0.25808480381965637,
0.23989830911159515,
0.4378798007965088,
0.7678712606430054,
-0.5716436505317688,
-0.5431581735610962,
0.09543585032224655,
-0.453968346118927,
-0.48518553376197815,
0.20341190695762634,
-0.18830296397209167,
0.18316896259784698,
0.4446609914302826,
-0.19302114844322205,
-0.046415191143751144,
0.9975419640541077,
-0.16193735599517822,
0.7099367380142212,
0.1989526003599167,
0.04588785022497177,
-0.9090337157249451,
0.27567076683044434,
-0.18193647265434265,
-0.38787832856178284,
-0.5473700165748596,
0.30142471194267273,
-0.052303023636341095,
0.025344589725136757,
-0.006938403006643057,
0.4476225674152374,
0.03080856241285801,
-0.261275053024292,
-0.03622991219162941,
0.1849443018436432,
0.1533527821302414,
0.13249471783638,
0.02497335523366928,
0.7691532969474792,
0.39900410175323486,
-0.2550964653491974,
0.5800824165344238,
-0.15900208055973053,
-0.5494301915168762,
0.73105388879776,
-0.6338311433792114,
0.13015158474445343,
0.3936067223548889,
0.006976018659770489,
-0.6474518775939941,
-0.22771961987018585,
-0.21428555250167847,
-0.14165693521499634,
0.11945714801549911,
0.004946110770106316,
-0.4445727467536926,
-0.1796916127204895,
-0.1968686878681183,
0.10130026191473007,
0.3598548471927643,
-0.41712844371795654,
0.3980536162853241,
0.2779851257801056,
-0.40692636370658875,
-0.40082383155822754,
-0.727455735206604,
0.36776164174079895,
-0.1069222167134285,
-0.5882333517074585,
0.16914737224578857,
0.04052850604057312,
-0.38920000195503235,
-0.08423930406570435,
-0.24752765893936157,
-0.29691874980926514,
0.04497946426272392,
0.14694024622440338,
-0.2297704666852951,
-0.516541063785553,
0.08482441306114197,
-0.08996792137622833,
-0.0794084221124649,
-0.043765466660261154,
-0.18405403196811676,
0.9491662383079529,
-0.35004377365112305,
-0.5027883052825928,
0.0842394307255745,
0.5281672477722168,
0.15385252237319946,
-0.21669253706932068,
0.4915216267108917,
0.27273088693618774,
-0.009889058768749237,
-0.6046770215034485,
-0.7586436867713928,
0.03871835023164749,
-0.47533994913101196,
0.5663728713989258,
-0.36170679330825806,
-0.9000749588012695,
0.2980384826660156,
-0.3531584143638611,
0.14939136803150177,
0.5536646842956543,
0.31306517124176025,
0.036411844193935394,
0.16832785308361053,
0.7097725868225098,
-0.2930183410644531,
0.4077187180519104,
0.1554301381111145,
0.1498013287782669,
-0.38644343614578247,
0.1736142486333847,
-0.7388173937797546,
-0.44003334641456604,
-0.6529269814491272,
-0.6688752174377441,
0.14693105220794678,
0.26448342204093933,
-0.032242756336927414,
0.5408529043197632,
-0.1634286791086197,
0.5298671126365662,
0.6875153183937073,
-0.3498532176017761,
0.39138296246528625,
-0.11566422879695892,
-0.24545206129550934,
-0.20282325148582458,
-0.48190388083457947,
-0.3560502827167511,
1.0170923471450806,
-0.09143730252981186,
0.29615768790245056,
0.16472315788269043,
0.8656308054924011,
0.4105818569660187,
0.001852528308518231,
-0.7079223394393921,
0.6852012276649475,
-0.5379750728607178,
-0.6955483555793762,
-0.1862175017595291,
-0.518600583076477,
-1.0100256204605103,
0.3842792809009552,
-0.08932051062583923,
-0.8338568210601807,
0.15996494889259338,
0.07136276364326477,
0.007806060835719109,
0.3375634551048279,
-0.451116144657135,
1.1043962240219116,
-0.18593819439411163,
-0.34208282828330994,
-0.3237632215023041,
-0.5256986021995544,
0.19521497189998627,
-0.19010010361671448,
0.15080046653747559,
-0.2730153501033783,
0.198797807097435,
0.49135029315948486,
-0.43961185216903687,
0.6283298134803772,
-0.05439164116978645,
0.22792217135429382,
-0.1689845770597458,
0.41306793689727783,
0.06492329388856888,
-0.22354482114315033,
-0.5092068910598755,
0.5255745053291321,
0.0914309173822403,
-0.4005545973777771,
-0.44071465730667114,
0.6330937743186951,
-0.4778634011745453,
-0.44331443309783936,
-0.37785133719444275,
-0.24998338520526886,
-0.6490147709846497,
0.2886941134929657,
0.255221426486969,
0.28691574931144714,
-0.9211030602455139,
0.43961670994758606,
0.38401105999946594,
-0.17644256353378296,
0.2909778952598572,
0.5619099736213684,
-0.5789918303489685,
-0.19463765621185303,
0.9208616018295288,
-0.18002581596374512,
0.46305251121520996,
0.33963704109191895,
0.0663183405995369,
0.015466738492250443,
-0.6823704838752747,
-0.49477314949035645,
-0.2160051017999649,
-0.5306521654129028,
0.03069321997463703,
-0.4758123755455017,
-0.10149930417537689,
-0.24452681839466095,
-0.04794357717037201,
-0.6964477300643921,
-0.6808542609214783,
0.6273485422134399,
0.17057126760482788,
0.3172048032283783,
0.6595994830131531,
-0.06681293994188309,
0.3661368489265442,
-0.6976880431175232,
0.37444695830345154,
0.26932114362716675,
0.6242957711219788,
-0.3850264847278595,
-0.29911574721336365,
-0.16795995831489563,
-0.29263851046562195,
-0.2411777526140213,
-0.6313164234161377,
0.3273429870605469,
0.4229159653186798,
0.5586768388748169,
0.30710241198539734,
-0.009992517530918121,
0.4357384741306305,
-0.46470916271209717,
1.0371918678283691,
0.0957215279340744,
-1.0635091066360474,
0.2573527693748474,
-0.24698443710803986,
0.24483118951320648,
0.9970009922981262,
-0.03823375701904297,
-1.1580212116241455,
-0.6159698367118835,
-0.5836849808692932,
-1.1725009679794312,
0.7591797709465027,
0.17304666340351105,
0.019189076498150826,
0.10559062659740448,
-0.10866531729698181,
0.3551751673221588,
0.4833622872829437,
-0.5394810438156128,
-0.216791570186615,
-0.335604190826416,
-0.1528792679309845,
-0.36685892939567566,
0.06705749034881592,
-0.24017047882080078,
-0.010554561391472816,
0.36843985319137573,
-0.16068169474601746,
-0.09279686957597733,
-0.11338556557893753,
-0.02612355351448059,
-0.007402949966490269,
0.5822741985321045,
0.0026057949289679527,
0.4542194604873657,
-0.24102675914764404,
0.26348188519477844,
0.13917936384677887,
-0.4523228704929352,
-0.1772468388080597,
0.3657655417919159,
-0.14054317772388458,
0.2869367301464081,
0.3826214671134949,
0.664405107498169,
0.0234135240316391,
-0.9256365895271301,
0.38415998220443726,
0.08167584240436554,
-0.07989317178726196,
-0.1728229522705078,
0.3009992241859436,
0.3291034400463104,
0.0005569218192249537,
0.02401452511548996,
0.25954848527908325,
0.5838745832443237,
-0.4662235677242279,
0.32952943444252014,
0.32659316062927246,
-0.24907951056957245,
-0.0956864133477211,
0.12818817794322968,
0.25665801763534546,
-0.2126387059688568,
0.5278699398040771,
-0.43980827927589417,
-0.3580920994281769,
0.7984462380409241,
0.2848065197467804,
0.9668533205986023,
-0.2056903839111328,
0.3101259469985962,
0.31973350048065186,
0.380682110786438,
-0.14930665493011475,
0.1124531552195549,
-0.144876167178154,
-0.5706287026405334,
-0.19810807704925537,
-1.0462393760681152,
-0.7554567456245422,
0.03873505815863609,
-0.6591874361038208,
0.04107318073511124,
-0.5328611731529236,
-0.2667834460735321,
0.04183731973171234,
-0.10521705448627472,
-0.35770726203918457,
0.11826353520154953,
0.17689062654972076,
1.0100780725479126,
-0.7591566443443298,
0.7760831713676453,
0.5480634570121765,
0.0654541403055191,
-0.4518032968044281,
0.23155619204044342,
0.20802301168441772,
-0.43216755986213684,
0.41655662655830383,
0.14251035451889038,
-0.2967318594455719,
-0.3101227283477783,
-0.1344558447599411,
-0.644516110420227,
0.3674108684062958,
0.33052074909210205,
-0.7873297333717346,
0.3478938937187195,
0.6973565816879272,
0.6694691777229309,
0.09543248265981674,
0.34018823504447937,
0.8306831121444702,
0.4922822117805481,
-0.17751610279083252,
-1.198718786239624,
-0.09495645761489868,
-0.6312146186828613,
0.15236210823059082,
0.4638386070728302,
-0.69143146276474,
0.9355604648590088,
0.6147488951683044,
-0.0008868445875123143,
0.20473851263523102,
0.31507331132888794,
-0.041493844240903854,
0.2260834276676178,
0.6969490051269531,
0.7237810492515564,
0.6789583563804626,
-0.5104032754898071,
0.8934213519096375,
-0.39617377519607544,
0.2578468322753906,
1.2615845203399658,
-0.4275442361831665,
1.097362756729126,
0.3621703088283539,
-0.7068852186203003,
0.5864670276641846,
0.3407425582408905,
-0.028610460460186005,
0.19320057332515717,
0.44414687156677246,
-0.26647040247917175,
-0.26651498675346375,
-0.02783922664821148,
-0.45204249024391174,
0.45873627066612244,
0.32744139432907104,
0.029028497636318207,
-0.5171850323677063,
-0.4948205053806305,
-0.11917983740568161,
0.23401644825935364,
0.20341448485851288,
0.7254639863967896,
-0.005727184470742941,
-0.7106502056121826,
0.6664466857910156,
0.09328176826238632,
0.8233080506324768,
-1.0886369943618774,
0.1813109815120697,
-0.4439948797225952,
0.14088667929172516,
-0.24537372589111328,
-0.7132145762443542,
0.5268188118934631,
0.003603108925744891,
-0.060300201177597046,
-0.08331078290939331,
0.2598722577095032,
-0.2356119453907013,
-0.33169129490852356,
0.5824159383773804,
0.639503002166748,
0.17107044160366058,
-0.3165115714073181,
-0.6773485541343689,
0.10741348564624786,
-0.06239313632249832,
-0.37940287590026855,
0.46833765506744385,
0.5754407048225403,
0.02584232948720455,
0.3474869132041931,
0.41261589527130127,
0.2328619509935379,
0.2401694804430008,
0.369332879781723,
0.773475170135498,
-0.7714667320251465,
-0.4374222457408905,
-0.5529630780220032,
0.16446812450885773,
-0.4886977970600128,
-0.6175675988197327,
0.7913175225257874,
0.864675760269165,
0.8770253658294678,
0.11457281559705734,
0.7932435274124146,
-0.5719125866889954,
0.6534884572029114,
-0.3316008746623993,
0.53493332862854,
-0.8088216185569763,
-0.020427538082003593,
-0.1972053200006485,
-0.9848892688751221,
-0.16924168169498444,
0.4632546603679657,
-0.26139727234840393,
0.12102493643760681,
0.9031364917755127,
0.814777135848999,
-0.2035170942544937,
0.3719855546951294,
0.45086583495140076,
0.1644676923751831,
0.058191172778606415,
0.26070931553840637,
0.582472562789917,
0.050274137407541275,
0.29366692900657654,
-0.7137877941131592,
-0.22556602954864502,
-0.18387383222579956,
-0.7617911696434021,
-0.5954638719558716,
-0.4297596216201782,
0.103488989174366,
-0.16426017880439758,
0.15574030578136444,
0.8766444325447083,
0.7119741439819336,
-1.0753172636032104,
-0.848544180393219,
-0.3513893485069275,
-0.28521037101745605,
-0.6465663313865662,
-0.2888680398464203,
-0.0709272250533104,
-0.6354287266731262,
-0.836471438407898,
0.6459580063819885,
0.36857426166534424,
-0.42916756868362427,
-0.35151779651641846,
0.23484580218791962,
0.07236194610595703,
-0.1017068475484848,
0.32042884826660156,
0.37984612584114075,
-0.5424874424934387,
0.15373000502586365,
-0.09357348829507828,
-0.1904887855052948,
0.23066098988056183,
0.8895500898361206,
-0.5810102224349976,
0.7291595935821533,
0.49333229660987854,
0.6571131944656372,
0.471804141998291,
-0.09802428632974625,
0.664808452129364,
-0.9367070198059082,
0.28962743282318115,
0.4866281747817993,
0.35520875453948975,
0.4497070908546448,
0.12075043469667435,
0.5879920125007629,
0.30246710777282715,
-0.374361127614975,
-0.4651479423046112,
0.28518301248550415,
-1.2441716194152832,
-0.15872515738010406,
0.8000110983848572,
-0.10872462391853333,
-0.004083841573446989,
-0.37493032217025757,
-0.03268977627158165,
-0.1276804506778717,
-0.4715755581855774,
0.6941965222358704,
0.8590196967124939,
-0.01126138400286436,
0.07752030342817307,
-0.8094703555107117,
0.48544803261756897,
0.8157508969306946,
-0.9900990724563599,
0.33859139680862427,
0.6150637865066528,
0.15074242651462555,
0.2849407196044922,
0.5554885864257812,
0.019699610769748688,
0.07079046219587326,
0.4099588096141815,
0.34343791007995605,
0.36812660098075867,
-0.032032743096351624,
-0.22123391926288605,
0.3893214464187622,
0.30842816829681396,
0.16393475234508514
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10978v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10978v1
|
Entity Alignment with Unlabeled Dangling Cases
| 2024-03-16T17:21:58 | 2024-03-16T17:21:58 |
Hang Yin, Dong Ding, Liyao Xiang, Yuheng He, Yihan Wu, Xinbing Wang, Chenghu Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR, I.2.4; H.3.3
|
We investigate the entity alignment problem with unlabeled dangling cases,
meaning that there are entities in the source or target graph having no
counterparts in the other, and those entities remain unlabeled. The problem
arises when the source and target graphs are of different scales, and it is
much cheaper to label the matchable pairs than the dangling entities. To solve
the issue, we propose a novel GNN-based dangling detection and entity alignment
framework. While the two tasks share the same GNN and are trained together, the
detected dangling entities are removed in the alignment. Our framework is
featured by a designed entity and relation attention mechanism for selective
neighborhood aggregation in representation learning, as well as a
positive-unlabeled learning loss for an unbiased estimation of dangling
entities. Experimental results have shown that each component of our design
contributes to the overall alignment performance which is comparable or
superior to baselines, even if the baselines additionally have 30\% of the
dangling entities labeled as training data.
|
[
-0.3730114996433258,
-0.4473203420639038,
0.45438456535339355,
-0.22056682407855988,
-0.3447205424308777,
0.31460416316986084,
0.0955357551574707,
-0.7166006565093994,
0.8884122371673584,
0.3451631963253021,
-0.5325267910957336,
-0.2958489954471588,
-0.546975314617157,
-0.2883571684360504,
-0.4190412759780884,
1.1727129220962524,
-0.0726698562502861,
-0.24643030762672424,
-0.3278050422668457,
-0.6778655648231506,
-0.28704530000686646,
-0.141438290476799,
-0.6141453981399536,
-0.32880839705467224,
0.7523165345191956,
0.22118495404720306,
0.7368510365486145,
0.9461473822593689,
0.35749924182891846,
0.2491234391927719,
-0.17116186022758484,
0.276287704706192,
-0.48277223110198975,
-0.3233017325401306,
-0.32239478826522827,
-0.11611100286245346,
-0.5662140250205994,
-0.20372727513313293,
0.7604897618293762,
1.0055724382400513,
-0.3188817501068115,
0.21543839573860168,
0.0014067403972148895,
0.6411895155906677,
-0.839790403842926,
-0.13634806871414185,
-0.5502201318740845,
-0.008764286525547504,
-0.31635361909866333,
0.09739482402801514,
-0.3189310133457184,
-0.09430333971977234,
0.15173222124576569,
-0.7387830018997192,
0.41980111598968506,
0.10573594272136688,
1.3670001029968262,
0.3708406984806061,
-0.6202661991119385,
-0.15761922299861908,
-0.4464706778526306,
0.43507248163223267,
-0.2448006570339203,
0.3583252727985382,
-0.12466851621866226,
0.032551441341638565,
-0.11678677797317505,
-0.5538737773895264,
-0.2358577400445938,
0.016460943967103958,
-0.17990842461585999,
0.30588141083717346,
-0.19411903619766235,
-0.04414227232336998,
0.15816199779510498,
0.48014703392982483,
-0.4610331058502197,
0.2557615637779236,
-0.25831589102745056,
-0.23582856357097626,
0.42896074056625366,
-0.17582295835018158,
0.43368151783943176,
-0.10787587612867355,
-0.7100390791893005,
0.3684464693069458,
-0.9005416631698608,
-0.39280396699905396,
0.7768970727920532,
0.30633705854415894,
0.004783176351338625,
0.5076925754547119,
0.051166780292987823,
0.5386927723884583,
0.5152629017829895,
0.5141984224319458,
0.5036498308181763,
-0.25434914231300354,
-0.2843859791755676,
0.5309804677963257,
0.6158103942871094,
0.28843963146209717,
0.25893256068229675,
-0.5758289098739624,
-0.22826960682868958,
0.1272827535867691,
0.41736069321632385,
-0.40526530146598816,
-0.4755057394504547,
-0.016269689425826073,
-0.3746809661388397,
-0.06566832214593887,
-0.05830035358667374,
-0.40966495871543884,
-0.2701159715652466,
-0.3473477363586426,
0.4521383047103882,
-0.327735036611557,
-0.6081302165985107,
-0.21305252611637115,
-0.08099821209907532,
0.018076753243803978,
0.09429557621479034,
-1.0268877744674683,
0.22050535678863525,
0.6140924096107483,
0.8595425486564636,
-0.3720960021018982,
-0.014335536397993565,
-0.7120099663734436,
0.536460816860199,
-0.44312483072280884,
0.6678643226623535,
-0.23994924128055573,
-0.07783575356006622,
-0.183254674077034,
0.13515020906925201,
-0.2616015672683716,
-0.425123929977417,
0.44508248567581177,
-0.6116724014282227,
0.0609348900616169,
-0.28619131445884705,
-0.9154537916183472,
-0.07450839132070541,
0.14582815766334534,
-0.9528120756149292,
0.8556771874427795,
0.24120400846004486,
-1.0296730995178223,
0.5621966123580933,
-0.26354122161865234,
-0.2547807991504669,
0.20206516981124878,
-0.25935742259025574,
-0.8886620402336121,
0.19470112025737762,
0.3438514769077301,
0.04815218597650528,
0.26359283924102783,
0.17959444224834442,
-0.4285753667354584,
-0.6807978749275208,
-0.23302151262760162,
-0.01675737276673317,
0.8955883383750916,
-0.12809760868549347,
-0.2494611293077469,
0.059339117258787155,
-0.9291359186172485,
-0.0457838699221611,
0.15367428958415985,
-0.3780432343482971,
-0.8067975044250488,
0.07089201360940933,
0.015000732615590096,
-0.004348231013864279,
0.11526023596525192,
-0.46527522802352905,
0.44355475902557373,
-0.4870816171169281,
0.25636786222457886,
0.5961898565292358,
0.24452313780784607,
0.8341351747512817,
0.06848745793104172,
0.2301402986049652,
0.2555614411830902,
-0.13356931507587433,
0.26686713099479675,
-0.3074972927570343,
-0.8078285455703735,
-0.3014140725135803,
0.6925815343856812,
0.24517598748207092,
-0.8271480798721313,
0.38991671800613403,
-0.4960119128227234,
0.00835284125059843,
-0.49408721923828125,
0.11635825783014297,
0.45761483907699585,
0.9753434658050537,
0.5105078816413879,
-0.351285845041275,
-0.55815190076828,
-0.9702742099761963,
-0.2641286253929138,
-0.22057899832725525,
-0.07233412563800812,
-0.035053882747888565,
0.4800112247467041,
-0.10103597491979599,
1.0473203659057617,
-0.39671212434768677,
-0.5321388840675354,
0.1814253032207489,
0.01943565160036087,
-0.0419064499437809,
0.8316736221313477,
0.7965722680091858,
-1.0208438634872437,
-0.2816387712955475,
0.11059695482254028,
-0.8611063957214355,
0.2618216872215271,
-0.19744399189949036,
-0.3185710906982422,
0.30061957240104675,
0.4789590537548065,
-0.7634838223457336,
0.3264288008213043,
0.04411587119102478,
-0.09792333096265793,
0.39780232310295105,
0.015808887779712677,
-0.330157071352005,
-1.2355945110321045,
-0.01347445324063301,
0.38838014006614685,
-0.3552827537059784,
-0.6455657482147217,
0.059833310544490814,
0.4854101538658142,
0.30434274673461914,
-0.506296694278717,
0.16483093798160553,
-1.0119330883026123,
-0.3140658140182495,
-0.08165353536605835,
0.39006680250167847,
0.005503525026142597,
0.5714849233627319,
0.14611020684242249,
0.6439636945724487,
0.3391214609146118,
-0.3475387692451477,
0.183188796043396,
0.21683813631534576,
-0.31920602917671204,
0.8708076477050781,
-0.5680897831916809,
0.24153243005275726,
-0.34034162759780884,
0.019715609028935432,
-0.6657910346984863,
-0.15338365733623505,
0.6732078194618225,
-0.3004973232746124,
0.8009873628616333,
-0.7536547183990479,
-0.1590280532836914,
-0.40682554244995117,
-0.1301179826259613,
0.40578389167785645,
-0.07538308948278427,
-0.5972065925598145,
0.4823305010795593,
0.39966049790382385,
0.3947984576225281,
-0.8597163558006287,
-0.7930339574813843,
0.07117412984371185,
-0.5722759366035461,
-0.29429933428764343,
0.43522781133651733,
0.3352746367454529,
0.1765773892402649,
0.708462655544281,
-0.6393985748291016,
0.003944892901927233,
0.11614416539669037,
0.16239045560359955,
0.4494350552558899,
-0.44546347856521606,
0.557090699672699,
0.11578088998794556,
-0.2263227105140686,
0.07227901369333267,
-0.9017907381057739,
-0.02961316891014576,
-0.12551450729370117,
-0.5707343220710754,
-0.017729222774505615,
0.3995988070964813,
0.07842528820037842,
-0.2277487963438034,
0.8306294679641724,
0.4854329824447632,
-0.897929847240448,
0.2537499666213989,
-0.2836158871650696,
0.34977081418037415,
-0.5035243034362793,
0.4146575331687927,
-0.2957771122455597,
-0.8260656595230103,
0.6062099933624268,
0.06564010679721832,
-0.07129497826099396,
0.42461568117141724,
0.31353437900543213,
-0.08253617584705353,
0.9750188589096069,
0.7011834979057312,
-0.29301637411117554,
0.4915028214454651,
-0.20213648676872253,
0.39475592970848083,
-1.2401822805404663,
-0.14079086482524872,
-0.21612344682216644,
-0.5144305229187012,
-0.6544194221496582,
-0.11352503299713135,
0.08893296122550964,
0.43699967861175537,
-0.28158798813819885,
0.7035404443740845,
-0.8897923827171326,
0.7475415468215942,
0.5134505033493042,
0.10290833562612534,
0.2499680370092392,
0.09473265707492828,
-0.41546136140823364,
-0.009876959957182407,
-0.3728008270263672,
-0.2962586283683777,
0.8173638582229614,
0.039085738360881805,
0.43477439880371094,
0.3919069170951843,
1.003846526145935,
0.1745302677154541,
0.449586421251297,
-0.7589898705482483,
0.08471909165382385,
0.10852832347154617,
-0.5498927235603333,
-0.4076257348060608,
-0.7309611439704895,
-1.0132430791854858,
0.47099772095680237,
0.027393463999032974,
-1.4979406595230103,
0.5194659233093262,
0.3131770193576813,
-0.21306203305721283,
0.3502013385295868,
-0.8327951431274414,
0.944072961807251,
-0.0990472063422203,
-0.2116982489824295,
0.3069239556789398,
-0.7610558271408081,
0.457695335149765,
0.09149258583784103,
-0.26538535952568054,
-0.2041606605052948,
-0.02122802846133709,
0.623599112033844,
-0.5424418449401855,
0.4036826491355896,
-0.2927452623844147,
-0.11464114487171173,
0.30780068039894104,
-0.17910492420196533,
0.6165363192558289,
0.23783144354820251,
0.09411726146936417,
0.0019236254738643765,
-0.34850770235061646,
-0.5875236392021179,
-0.6992371678352356,
0.8396880626678467,
-0.4985000193119049,
-0.5694265365600586,
-0.32137465476989746,
-0.36091238260269165,
-0.20413541793823242,
0.5435376167297363,
0.378521591424942,
0.24385343492031097,
-0.05759480968117714,
-0.04030698165297508,
0.7468127012252808,
0.4164806008338928,
0.49114495515823364,
0.2375984936952591,
0.08133581280708313,
-0.4378521740436554,
1.2703819274902344,
0.29939648509025574,
0.1763780415058136,
0.49276092648506165,
-0.2659192979335785,
-0.4916445016860962,
-0.5426419973373413,
-0.8399127125740051,
0.20782382786273956,
-0.8786337375640869,
-0.23181083798408508,
-0.6930606961250305,
-0.2061799168586731,
-0.21152983605861664,
0.08943060040473938,
-0.560357391834259,
-0.489734411239624,
-0.6195691823959351,
-0.40739938616752625,
0.12579654157161713,
0.2469409853219986,
0.1089199110865593,
0.1725059449672699,
-0.5476244688034058,
0.1353997439146042,
0.10374913364648819,
0.3975459039211273,
0.11098115891218185,
-0.11450263112783432,
-0.2715897858142853,
0.1488855630159378,
-0.34424889087677,
-0.8858705759048462,
-0.07559388875961304,
0.1206413134932518,
0.6158859133720398,
0.74835604429245,
0.12293753772974014,
0.7965402603149414,
-0.4410429298877716,
0.25046250224113464,
0.4764445722103119,
-1.0231715440750122,
0.31829527020454407,
-0.3200865685939789,
0.03588194400072098,
0.43047383427619934,
0.2911222279071808,
-0.40257924795150757,
-0.26766490936279297,
-0.5160166025161743,
-1.077598214149475,
0.5620225071907043,
0.36271774768829346,
-0.17761285603046417,
-0.03877340257167816,
0.5059942603111267,
-0.3600001931190491,
0.319548100233078,
-0.5948222279548645,
-0.49036064743995667,
-0.05663149431347847,
-0.4183104634284973,
0.1948055922985077,
0.10108516365289688,
-0.11171887814998627,
-0.09044495224952698,
0.5693013072013855,
-0.47400349378585815,
0.28398215770721436,
0.011290882714092731,
-0.3271404504776001,
-0.3531293272972107,
-0.15748222172260284,
0.33525291085243225,
0.5667092204093933,
-0.07563892751932144,
0.1008782908320427,
0.04935264214873314,
-0.3227701187133789,
0.26950618624687195,
0.16169506311416626,
-0.3958737254142761,
-0.1206788718700409,
0.318155437707901,
0.9144167900085449,
0.5237553715705872,
-0.03984665870666504,
0.4755699634552002,
0.07016303390264511,
-0.21961887180805206,
-0.14701369404792786,
-0.14734825491905212,
0.7008939385414124,
0.10865654051303864,
0.44831231236457825,
0.2930053770542145,
0.2669987082481384,
-0.20473408699035645,
0.4324379861354828,
0.5404211282730103,
-0.7353005409240723,
-0.14406462013721466,
0.922927975654602,
-0.0789637565612793,
-0.13750797510147095,
0.9130808711051941,
-0.2570746839046478,
-0.4346592128276825,
0.9823641180992126,
0.3719198405742645,
0.7566121220588684,
0.15840931236743927,
0.3055160343647003,
-0.16290771961212158,
0.43180739879608154,
0.0074216825887560844,
-0.12627680599689484,
0.0005741957575082779,
-0.7474461197853088,
-0.2676691710948944,
-0.3007600009441376,
-0.32599782943725586,
-0.04549819976091385,
-1.1170098781585693,
0.10287546366453171,
-0.07673777639865875,
-0.038517065346241,
0.2901623547077179,
0.03682661056518555,
-0.3983476758003235,
0.18496298789978027,
0.009972287341952324,
0.479163259267807,
-0.7137396931648254,
0.7336562871932983,
1.0585802793502808,
-0.6040979623794556,
-0.8523098230361938,
0.19784829020500183,
0.1878109723329544,
-0.4312179386615753,
0.12672755122184753,
0.42579835653305054,
0.008669182658195496,
0.12131822854280472,
-0.3459460139274597,
-1.360355019569397,
0.927547812461853,
0.7214267253875732,
-0.5598692297935486,
-0.2453373223543167,
-0.3479089140892029,
0.5011208653450012,
-0.2526300251483917,
-0.09251199662685394,
0.5022329688072205,
0.11194117367267609,
0.23735158145427704,
-0.41470763087272644,
0.09940529614686966,
-0.2528831958770752,
0.04077579453587532,
0.8505171537399292,
-0.8987669348716736,
0.67227703332901,
-0.0838957205414772,
-0.6629340052604675,
0.09323187917470932,
0.9508791565895081,
0.06769534945487976,
0.43353238701820374,
0.4408164620399475,
0.9752357006072998,
1.0834028720855713,
-0.22618368268013,
0.6004399657249451,
0.17088520526885986,
0.7723208665847778,
1.316903829574585,
-0.4856603443622589,
0.46042513847351074,
0.6006940603256226,
0.07691770792007446,
0.30886897444725037,
0.954721212387085,
-0.167438805103302,
0.5944203734397888,
0.20329411327838898,
-0.002266958588734269,
-0.3482110798358917,
0.040955983102321625,
-0.29182085394859314,
0.05928531289100647,
0.3832496702671051,
-0.14381277561187744,
-0.3978837728500366,
-0.10982820391654968,
-0.21214134991168976,
-0.17605318129062653,
-0.3805215358734131,
0.44625869393348694,
0.125623419880867,
-0.5411048531532288,
0.5256507992744446,
-0.29343080520629883,
0.29372063279151917,
0.023392263799905777,
0.042933057993650436,
-0.24853995442390442,
0.2904435098171234,
-0.42127174139022827,
-0.4211539328098297,
0.33054420351982117,
-0.44546225666999817,
-0.39379972219467163,
0.17052115499973297,
0.7715514302253723,
-0.4911040663719177,
-0.4377182722091675,
0.45868808031082153,
0.2896467447280884,
0.11345073580741882,
0.09353119134902954,
-0.5980329513549805,
-0.22292667627334595,
-0.20087674260139465,
-0.2571035325527191,
0.5746306777000427,
0.4894827604293823,
-0.5699790120124817,
0.564765214920044,
0.27695539593696594,
-0.13283582031726837,
0.18786771595478058,
0.2202465981245041,
0.9779536128044128,
-0.3052261769771576,
-0.48689883947372437,
-0.5828447937965393,
0.3096589744091034,
-0.44921642541885376,
-0.21117915213108063,
0.6281304955482483,
0.5505743622779846,
0.9466058611869812,
0.14699842035770416,
0.2958891987800598,
0.1120288148522377,
0.2305842638015747,
-0.5634690523147583,
0.7725138664245605,
-0.8276352882385254,
0.23718252778053284,
-0.46612757444381714,
-1.0350532531738281,
-0.26083138585090637,
0.4801943302154541,
-0.03954658284783363,
0.11798941344022751,
0.6219440698623657,
0.43199899792671204,
-0.42152753472328186,
-0.056733038276433945,
0.05418708547949791,
-0.3811027407646179,
0.17098164558410645,
0.8101751208305359,
0.6802521347999573,
-0.5481089353561401,
0.5805396437644958,
-0.11922243237495422,
0.08544804900884628,
-0.13950535655021667,
-0.9055943489074707,
-0.8422526121139526,
-0.2623579204082489,
-0.966915488243103,
-0.14417681097984314,
0.15107721090316772,
0.5768822431564331,
0.6276981830596924,
-0.7934010624885559,
0.4201226532459259,
-0.28650179505348206,
0.5786079168319702,
-0.4377410113811493,
-0.26685211062431335,
0.7839842438697815,
0.03541640192270279,
-0.8496737480163574,
0.3278402090072632,
0.4555891454219818,
0.261339008808136,
0.027224702760577202,
0.1217312440276146,
-0.5340409278869629,
-0.3761906921863556,
-0.05103907734155655,
0.49451199173927307,
-0.6173043251037598,
-0.564883291721344,
-0.2719726860523224,
-0.11047878116369247,
0.23339548707008362,
0.5467385053634644,
-0.6312553286552429,
0.20254182815551758,
0.10894738137722015,
0.7797465920448303,
0.4562041461467743,
0.4458405673503876,
0.2419111728668213,
-1.4924935102462769,
0.1502375602722168,
0.0969417467713356,
0.4830164313316345,
0.4748207628726959,
-0.8088392615318298,
0.6256689429283142,
0.44052353501319885,
-0.40202030539512634,
-0.8671916723251343,
0.2286752313375473,
-0.7798377871513367,
0.03945321589708328,
0.5949617624282837,
-0.41918107867240906,
-0.2931661605834961,
-0.02241634763777256,
0.27160871028900146,
0.5962042212486267,
-0.38426947593688965,
0.6398361921310425,
0.6263467669487,
-0.0962781235575676,
-0.23963192105293274,
-0.19121915102005005,
0.09599301218986511,
0.5397393703460693,
-0.4363330602645874,
-0.24565860629081726,
0.5954602956771851,
0.361457884311676,
0.6181931495666504,
0.4754553735256195,
0.09031260758638382,
0.33517754077911377,
-0.0909084677696228,
-0.021384498104453087,
0.0376182422041893,
-0.3518837094306946,
-0.3153242766857147,
0.2549048364162445,
-0.2948402166366577,
-0.6954715251922607
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10963v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10963v3
|
Pointer-Generator Networks for Low-Resource Machine Translation: Don't Copy That!
| 2024-03-16T16:17:47 | 2024-06-18T02:57:31 |
Niyati Bafna, Philipp Koehn, David Yarowsky
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
While Transformer-based neural machine translation (NMT) is very effective in
high-resource settings, many languages lack the necessary large parallel
corpora to benefit from it. In the context of low-resource (LR) MT between two
closely-related languages, a natural intuition is to seek benefits from
structural "shortcuts", such as copying subwords from the source to the target,
given that such language pairs often share a considerable number of identical
words, cognates, and borrowings. We test Pointer-Generator Networks for this
purpose for six language pairs over a variety of resource ranges, and find weak
improvements for most settings. However, analysis shows that the model does not
show greater improvements for closely-related vs. more distant language pairs,
or for lower resource ranges, and that the models do not exhibit the expected
usage of the mechanism for shared subwords. Our discussion of the reasons for
this behaviour highlights several general challenges for LR NMT, such as modern
tokenization strategies, noisy real-world conditions, and linguistic
complexities. We call for better scrutiny of linguistically motivated
improvements to NMT given the blackbox nature of Transformer models, as well as
for a focus on the above problems in the field.
|
[
-0.2133660912513733,
-0.34052515029907227,
0.38038328289985657,
0.16701407730579376,
-0.5506712198257446,
0.14821362495422363,
-0.2454434484243393,
-0.32083338499069214,
0.3150216042995453,
0.24485373497009277,
-0.38106968998908997,
0.13493716716766357,
-0.794880211353302,
0.5194205045700073,
-0.44065117835998535,
1.0006905794143677,
-0.1889956295490265,
-0.026689380407333374,
0.16714267432689667,
-0.46226298809051514,
-0.5092840194702148,
-0.4618408679962158,
-0.6874222159385681,
-0.5557081699371338,
0.8952590823173523,
0.3091655373573303,
0.9968023896217346,
0.7957504391670227,
0.7489495277404785,
0.2697257995605469,
-0.4193001985549927,
0.018816955387592316,
-0.6649894714355469,
0.17525434494018555,
-0.22150863707065582,
-0.28268924355506897,
-0.2681557238101959,
-0.26699504256248474,
0.6917495727539062,
0.9477328658103943,
0.2759445607662201,
0.15019311010837555,
0.22997798025608063,
0.6474998593330383,
-0.47814351320266724,
-0.04497087746858597,
-0.742594301700592,
0.2132367640733719,
-0.37407928705215454,
-0.022517746314406395,
-0.32349374890327454,
-0.30183714628219604,
0.25495174527168274,
-0.30765777826309204,
0.3834112882614136,
0.3263615071773529,
0.6823767423629761,
0.4037712514400482,
-0.3171619176864624,
0.031514957547187805,
-0.6839829087257385,
0.810443103313446,
-0.3305719494819641,
0.274291068315506,
0.3040770888328552,
0.1815786063671112,
-0.012885893695056438,
-0.5176382660865784,
-0.37964946031570435,
-0.3038443922996521,
-0.21990928053855896,
-0.03581678494811058,
-0.3431622385978699,
-0.055168818682432175,
0.44172975420951843,
0.33296671509742737,
-0.4208199381828308,
0.06922583281993866,
-0.7013938426971436,
0.04177302122116089,
0.012512153014540672,
0.05793309584259987,
0.05606171116232872,
-0.5014970898628235,
-0.49937528371810913,
-0.17040392756462097,
-1.0774147510528564,
-0.15880221128463745,
0.23427748680114746,
0.4634237289428711,
-0.09049874544143677,
0.7752970457077026,
-0.03182249143719673,
0.5344363451004028,
0.15611529350280762,
0.37388789653778076,
0.040736716240644455,
-0.6218557357788086,
-0.13004359602928162,
0.079856276512146,
1.0556082725524902,
0.08447133004665375,
0.15483394265174866,
-0.5494107604026794,
-0.33739012479782104,
-0.12744028866291046,
0.12161191552877426,
-0.8272970914840698,
-0.2502683699131012,
-0.2891830801963806,
-0.6853638291358948,
-0.16153907775878906,
-0.29690343141555786,
-0.32167789340019226,
-0.30072903633117676,
-0.18347319960594177,
0.32692477107048035,
-0.5589662194252014,
-0.20747046172618866,
-0.1271122694015503,
-0.2530337870121002,
-0.050749752670526505,
-0.2017083615064621,
-0.9562186598777771,
0.15660618245601654,
0.6071307063102722,
1.1022214889526367,
-0.43829599022865295,
-0.4981311559677124,
-0.355844110250473,
0.03424191474914551,
-0.08205121010541916,
0.5177561044692993,
-0.21095474064350128,
-0.5825399160385132,
-0.30083438754081726,
-0.05295813828706741,
-0.4376636743545532,
-0.780181348323822,
0.3191487193107605,
-0.3445199131965637,
0.0791931003332138,
-0.7375524044036865,
-0.10187625885009766,
0.12090799957513809,
0.03990597650408745,
-0.7352622151374817,
0.8630263805389404,
0.14608347415924072,
-0.7832261323928833,
0.06584204733371735,
-0.5880513191223145,
-0.5378080606460571,
-0.12956608831882477,
-0.06707237660884857,
-0.34488704800605774,
0.46361711621284485,
-0.2141573429107666,
0.2311987727880478,
-0.49784737825393677,
0.07178273797035217,
-0.1474660187959671,
-0.5429601073265076,
0.35558339953422546,
-0.4925214350223541,
0.5487211346626282,
0.23858968913555145,
-0.4238984286785126,
-0.06956273317337036,
-0.4956768751144409,
-0.15784712135791779,
0.19122731685638428,
-0.37884533405303955,
-0.3409041464328766,
-0.07915862649679184,
-0.061021558940410614,
0.39411771297454834,
0.13385340571403503,
-0.49630206823349,
0.17753708362579346,
-0.3855965733528137,
0.6042546629905701,
0.5830514430999756,
-0.07694214582443237,
0.7859995365142822,
-0.5017873048782349,
0.5899845957756042,
0.14621689915657043,
0.13926497101783752,
0.21397386491298676,
-0.5411754846572876,
-0.884319543838501,
0.0756140723824501,
0.22820700705051422,
0.3288801908493042,
-1.1594418287277222,
0.003406142583116889,
-0.49364879727363586,
-0.1048518493771553,
-0.6236145496368408,
0.2788587510585785,
0.6696968078613281,
0.6114827990531921,
0.5981066226959229,
-0.3494938313961029,
-0.32523131370544434,
-1.1207590103149414,
-0.3237772285938263,
0.0450439378619194,
0.10435333102941513,
0.10899641364812851,
0.41038671135902405,
0.1170981377363205,
0.7067120671272278,
-0.10238669067621231,
-0.09628896415233612,
-0.5051054358482361,
-0.018325582146644592,
0.2274690568447113,
0.43791478872299194,
0.5388964414596558,
-0.8671151995658875,
-0.7734826803207397,
0.1541539579629898,
-0.5191261768341064,
0.05210040882229805,
0.07482058554887772,
-0.02834223210811615,
-0.10087329894304276,
0.34652888774871826,
-0.7363358736038208,
-0.04359639436006546,
0.6541474461555481,
-0.0840059295296669,
0.27590543031692505,
-0.08510909974575043,
-0.2538381516933441,
-1.1790379285812378,
0.23132862150669098,
-0.22160425782203674,
-0.04510795325040817,
-0.5509713292121887,
-0.03818058595061302,
-0.1915627270936966,
-0.20900467038154602,
-0.6863915324211121,
0.41087889671325684,
-0.40883713960647583,
-0.06354378908872604,
-0.32755202054977417,
-0.01919511891901493,
-0.1529865860939026,
0.47705286741256714,
-0.13750143349170685,
0.8529647588729858,
0.14210554957389832,
-0.2850497364997864,
0.2573365867137909,
0.1996978223323822,
0.005008803214877844,
0.448249489068985,
-0.81915682554245,
0.27402666211128235,
-0.006001350935548544,
0.035925425589084625,
-0.28210264444351196,
0.13422857224941254,
0.4725687503814697,
-0.2112620770931244,
0.14482982456684113,
-0.1989210695028305,
-0.5230907201766968,
-0.20877687633037567,
-0.17531123757362366,
0.5677337646484375,
0.6775825619697571,
-0.4320719838142395,
0.11165972054004669,
-0.06437895447015762,
-0.017187006771564484,
-0.8716636896133423,
-0.7444140315055847,
0.11478858441114426,
-0.18636025488376617,
-0.5491366982460022,
0.2631627321243286,
0.2742869555950165,
-0.16331346333026886,
0.34280475974082947,
-0.25770431756973267,
-0.10128282755613327,
0.07347655296325684,
0.22826385498046875,
-0.09620056301355362,
-0.37086716294288635,
0.06889263540506363,
-0.10017768293619156,
-0.2830299139022827,
-0.09505685418844223,
-0.4885033667087555,
0.4927520155906677,
-0.3047645390033722,
-0.26825642585754395,
-0.277870237827301,
0.3507128953933716,
0.407861590385437,
-0.21711060404777527,
0.8845754265785217,
0.668169379234314,
-0.1075393483042717,
-0.15653258562088013,
-0.21900497376918793,
-0.30601516366004944,
-0.4522689878940582,
0.3929377496242523,
-0.5509176254272461,
-0.9683405756950378,
0.3288367986679077,
-0.07856818288564682,
-0.287975013256073,
0.4838627874851227,
0.5375996828079224,
-0.216980442404747,
0.5731552839279175,
0.5761614441871643,
-0.04993604123592377,
0.6471378803253174,
-0.536367654800415,
0.34310489892959595,
-0.9499006271362305,
-0.031519562005996704,
-0.583633542060852,
-0.6930568218231201,
-0.7113627791404724,
-0.5463943481445312,
0.23455281555652618,
0.10760599374771118,
-0.10045970976352692,
0.9001365900039673,
-0.4238475561141968,
0.5491071343421936,
0.8414876461029053,
-0.10997568070888519,
0.2886081039905548,
0.11079414933919907,
-0.3258025348186493,
-0.16944125294685364,
-1.0405809879302979,
-0.2651173174381256,
0.6278000473976135,
0.08815568685531616,
0.5956766605377197,
0.04729430377483368,
0.7570238709449768,
0.023579560220241547,
0.24197986721992493,
-0.9718981385231018,
0.5311954617500305,
-0.5173776745796204,
-0.4007453918457031,
-0.2562522292137146,
-0.7582024931907654,
-0.9681345820426941,
0.5088311433792114,
-0.17680546641349792,
-0.3457794189453125,
0.2112826406955719,
0.3182729482650757,
-0.19928237795829773,
0.5253432989120483,
-0.7411812543869019,
0.9414988160133362,
-0.12112107127904892,
-0.453389048576355,
-0.1441289186477661,
-0.5781494975090027,
0.16814740002155304,
-0.20240958034992218,
-0.2812855839729309,
0.018479712307453156,
0.22024177014827728,
0.3259987533092499,
-0.5078456401824951,
0.6560956239700317,
0.09471964091062546,
0.2985416054725647,
0.2822885811328888,
0.18573269248008728,
0.6069158911705017,
-0.4163738191127777,
-0.09093590825796127,
0.0967869907617569,
-0.26269495487213135,
-0.3977842926979065,
-0.38938194513320923,
0.6251358985900879,
-0.6649364233016968,
-0.40805211663246155,
-0.12448622286319733,
-0.6332270503044128,
0.06512635946273804,
0.4704204797744751,
0.6550970077514648,
0.1559268832206726,
-0.09335198998451233,
0.5777438879013062,
0.4007635712623596,
-0.08043249696493149,
0.4404667317867279,
-0.04146207123994827,
0.155976340174675,
-0.2562401592731476,
1.0276455879211426,
0.19370706379413605,
0.5202745199203491,
0.5093836188316345,
0.3579966425895691,
-0.19748294353485107,
-0.6841570138931274,
-0.49752897024154663,
0.3230842649936676,
-0.38236579298973083,
-0.14958925545215607,
-0.5017426013946533,
-0.08993088454008102,
0.01246823463588953,
-0.019101422280073166,
-0.4702960252761841,
-0.8501165509223938,
-0.007981421425938606,
0.10882613062858582,
0.1495712697505951,
0.7535359263420105,
-0.044438328593969345,
0.6070431470870972,
-0.9043812155723572,
0.35136789083480835,
0.21177831292152405,
0.1135621964931488,
0.07670171558856964,
-0.3699973225593567,
-0.5595273375511169,
0.013440602459013462,
-0.47921499609947205,
-0.7981017827987671,
0.2070545107126236,
0.05252258852124214,
0.28844428062438965,
0.039473727345466614,
0.10462122410535812,
0.3683924376964569,
-0.7390677332878113,
0.4426645040512085,
0.47933611273765564,
-0.8738540410995483,
0.1915435492992401,
-0.40014639496803284,
0.30170774459838867,
0.45866408944129944,
0.2863007187843323,
-0.7238043546676636,
-0.3766285181045532,
-0.4023455083370209,
-0.6405869722366333,
0.5850620865821838,
0.5301934480667114,
0.16796553134918213,
-0.13229680061340332,
0.30498042702674866,
-0.1823015809059143,
0.14452941715717316,
-0.8518071174621582,
-0.26453542709350586,
-0.29505908489227295,
-0.20842526853084564,
0.011121735908091068,
-0.11880318820476532,
-0.00553541723638773,
0.09953688085079193,
0.4596514403820038,
-0.1647752821445465,
0.20070238411426544,
0.07347436249256134,
-0.27163439989089966,
-0.37970811128616333,
0.4698139727115631,
0.5625420808792114,
0.557817816734314,
-0.24094903469085693,
0.3458622395992279,
0.38066285848617554,
-0.4257693886756897,
0.26415833830833435,
0.10668767243623734,
-0.4027967154979706,
0.19354715943336487,
0.16092535853385925,
1.0235408544540405,
0.2713371217250824,
-0.009582988917827606,
0.4662657082080841,
-0.027145741507411003,
-0.09190542250871658,
0.0954398363828659,
-0.15257471799850464,
0.3916221559047699,
0.2474341243505478,
0.026490595191717148,
0.5306890606880188,
-0.16096951067447662,
-0.2545991837978363,
-0.07911107689142227,
0.39643025398254395,
-0.4858698546886444,
-0.7301685810089111,
0.658282995223999,
0.2741551697254181,
-0.5420502424240112,
0.7366352081298828,
-0.2769542932510376,
-0.6418660879135132,
0.5197196006774902,
0.5608692169189453,
1.0123565196990967,
0.011883910745382309,
0.023533135652542114,
0.13491758704185486,
0.6540168523788452,
-0.2831266224384308,
-0.05736396461725235,
-0.04167836531996727,
-0.5337145924568176,
-0.5719289183616638,
-0.41912955045700073,
-0.5227180123329163,
0.010401351377367973,
-0.46634969115257263,
0.15853258967399597,
-0.32608774304389954,
-0.40694189071655273,
-0.17242245376110077,
-0.18030323088169098,
-0.6807379722595215,
-0.4271553158760071,
-0.20211906731128693,
0.6822677254676819,
-0.6456030011177063,
1.1879150867462158,
0.5249436497688293,
-0.46714502573013306,
-0.5341627597808838,
-0.10959114134311676,
-0.1995714157819748,
-0.6876475811004639,
1.12297785282135,
0.020568331703543663,
-0.19619303941726685,
-0.1376521736383438,
0.03987084701657295,
-0.7129863500595093,
1.0519042015075684,
0.5610179901123047,
-0.6296937465667725,
-0.45754578709602356,
0.4981181025505066,
0.583220362663269,
0.055148620158433914,
-0.3573341369628906,
0.1672556847333908,
0.3312024474143982,
-0.004461874254047871,
-1.1211196184158325,
0.19191177189350128,
0.07501597702503204,
0.19735461473464966,
0.569478452205658,
-0.802025556564331,
1.0904701948165894,
-0.12599560618400574,
-0.2872079312801361,
0.21244995296001434,
0.36176934838294983,
-0.01837986148893833,
0.05752947926521301,
0.4909275472164154,
0.5890880227088928,
0.33855754137039185,
-0.03501001000404358,
1.1962753534317017,
-0.3181873559951782,
0.37147200107574463,
1.2585406303405762,
-0.24923835694789886,
0.8127728700637817,
0.7990284562110901,
0.09202785789966583,
0.024825870990753174,
0.12313184142112732,
-0.08322163671255112,
0.6363632082939148,
0.3257276713848114,
-0.23513706028461456,
-0.1601557731628418,
-0.3444786071777344,
-0.5091671347618103,
0.20637957751750946,
0.035658761858940125,
-0.6067553162574768,
-0.20157437026500702,
-0.15484656393527985,
-0.0352834016084671,
0.001344209653325379,
0.023466940969228745,
0.4538349211215973,
0.6510508060455322,
-0.5312644243240356,
0.5928891897201538,
0.009984771721065044,
0.6533308029174805,
-0.27409011125564575,
0.17454609274864197,
-0.4322977364063263,
0.41952285170555115,
0.08874185383319855,
-0.3145260214805603,
0.6857254505157471,
0.12024245411157608,
-0.3949463665485382,
-0.6030884981155396,
0.7236208915710449,
-0.31707727909088135,
-0.22390620410442352,
0.5270510911941528,
0.9353191256523132,
0.04377942904829979,
-0.05519415810704231,
-0.7445911765098572,
-0.16653183102607727,
-0.1580801159143448,
-0.08381292223930359,
0.42317065596580505,
0.5513064861297607,
-0.049963608384132385,
0.3411811888217926,
0.6511402130126953,
0.4389957785606384,
0.30529263615608215,
0.0054250359535217285,
0.7034516930580139,
-0.6971465945243835,
-0.12353222817182541,
-0.9304742217063904,
-0.015158487483859062,
0.06129853054881096,
-0.20891955494880676,
0.7625022530555725,
0.4917442500591278,
0.9216235280036926,
-0.15733495354652405,
0.48238956928253174,
0.0813564881682396,
0.28630515933036804,
-0.4400807321071625,
0.7640730738639832,
-0.3109082579612732,
0.0197162963449955,
0.185442253947258,
-1.3025528192520142,
-0.1226661205291748,
0.48124170303344727,
-0.15238714218139648,
-0.15166407823562622,
1.0512595176696777,
0.6114037036895752,
-0.3072987198829651,
-0.2794441282749176,
0.3955570459365845,
0.1531084179878235,
0.1086592972278595,
0.8370388746261597,
1.1846119165420532,
-0.4992067813873291,
1.0065785646438599,
-0.43974074721336365,
0.28925493359565735,
-0.09165897220373154,
-0.8171659708023071,
-0.9107025861740112,
-0.38158002495765686,
-0.09165740758180618,
-0.42035937309265137,
0.137176513671875,
1.0404900312423706,
0.6019209623336792,
-0.5507065057754517,
-0.2906220555305481,
0.03590528666973114,
0.47580811381340027,
-0.2697001099586487,
-0.07581734657287598,
0.3559516966342926,
-0.15587511658668518,
-0.7248692512512207,
0.5759499073028564,
0.21785685420036316,
0.20395547151565552,
-0.090956911444664,
-0.146187886595726,
0.03438644856214523,
-0.3486964702606201,
0.5701848268508911,
0.38944342732429504,
-0.5636274218559265,
-0.29726696014404297,
0.3686913549900055,
-0.22388006746768951,
0.05912594869732857,
1.07465660572052,
-0.49379080533981323,
0.0733380913734436,
0.7941392660140991,
0.789659321308136,
0.2858973443508148,
-0.2601509690284729,
0.5223645567893982,
-0.9419562220573425,
0.25673016905784607,
0.14941968023777008,
0.528021514415741,
0.5227149128913879,
-0.0010715032694861293,
0.4675702154636383,
0.535565972328186,
-0.336446613073349,
-0.6838358640670776,
0.29443666338920593,
-0.8223832249641418,
0.021920017898082733,
1.066652536392212,
-0.1344267725944519,
-0.1936231404542923,
-0.017913345247507095,
0.10624077916145325,
0.39816972613334656,
-0.21999076008796692,
0.6631326675415039,
0.49685201048851013,
0.017132196575403214,
-0.030032837763428688,
-0.4925822615623474,
0.5163136124610901,
0.727918267250061,
-0.35578224062919617,
-0.05348426476120949,
0.15148168802261353,
0.231926828622818,
0.3840460479259491,
0.5406935214996338,
-0.009556068107485771,
0.027947360649704933,
-0.16969794034957886,
-0.2296696901321411,
-0.24078001081943512,
-0.21675416827201843,
-0.5718793272972107,
0.0780474841594696,
0.2583639919757843,
-0.34462159872055054
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10961v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10961v1
|
Energy-Based Models with Applications to Speech and Language Processing
| 2024-03-16T16:16:31 | 2024-03-16T16:16:31 |
Zhijian Ou
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Energy-Based Models (EBMs) are an important class of probabilistic models,
also known as random fields and undirected graphical models. EBMs are
un-normalized and thus radically different from other popular self-normalized
probabilistic models such as hidden Markov models (HMMs), autoregressive
models, generative adversarial nets (GANs) and variational auto-encoders
(VAEs). Over the past years, EBMs have attracted increasing interest not only
from the core machine learning community, but also from application domains
such as speech, vision, natural language processing (NLP) and so on, due to
significant theoretical and algorithmic progress. The sequential nature of
speech and language also presents special challenges and needs a different
treatment from processing fix-dimensional data (e.g., images). Therefore, the
purpose of this monograph is to present a systematic introduction to
energy-based models, including both algorithmic progress and applications in
speech and language processing. First, the basics of EBMs are introduced,
including classic models, recent models parameterized by neural networks,
sampling methods, and various learning methods from the classic learning
algorithms to the most advanced ones. Then, the application of EBMs in three
different scenarios is presented, i.e., for modeling marginal, conditional and
joint distributions, respectively. 1) EBMs for sequential data with
applications in language modeling, where the main focus is on the marginal
distribution of a sequence itself; 2) EBMs for modeling conditional
distributions of target sequences given observation sequences, with
applications in speech recognition, sequence labeling and text generation; 3)
EBMs for modeling joint distributions of both sequences of observations and
targets, and their applications in semi-supervised learning and calibrated
natural language understanding.
|
[
0.07652627676725388,
-0.8547932505607605,
0.464118093252182,
-0.041518907994031906,
0.23621270060539246,
0.06682372093200684,
-0.2250676453113556,
-0.28486770391464233,
0.3014500141143799,
0.3688136339187622,
-0.2476452738046646,
-0.4371270537376404,
-0.2968562841415405,
-0.06879612058401108,
-0.5746785998344421,
0.4646800756454468,
0.10474078357219696,
0.16867433488368988,
-0.24307246506214142,
0.00005182162931305356,
-0.07951557636260986,
-0.43006575107574463,
-0.5028575658798218,
-0.5630539655685425,
0.18972870707511902,
-0.11115557700395584,
0.6432637572288513,
0.6704815626144409,
0.569031834602356,
0.2970402240753174,
0.10202796012163162,
-0.3247668147087097,
-0.2811952531337738,
0.20872388780117035,
-0.24900801479816437,
-0.7021171450614929,
-0.011027844622731209,
0.03635016828775406,
0.7564241886138916,
1.254176139831543,
-0.6573425531387329,
0.19391773641109467,
-0.3846495747566223,
0.6338863372802734,
-0.671865701675415,
0.5312979817390442,
-0.5788163542747498,
0.2411719262599945,
-0.2386726289987564,
-0.19030821323394775,
-0.4668392241001129,
-0.2122105211019516,
-0.004398105200380087,
-0.46547505259513855,
0.24791115522384644,
0.34458956122398376,
0.6382301449775696,
0.21129824221134186,
-0.4080637991428375,
-0.3612348437309265,
-0.833041250705719,
1.0641205310821533,
-0.5972813367843628,
0.47532621026039124,
0.2917112410068512,
0.2980769872665405,
-0.17611855268478394,
-0.7795498967170715,
-0.44033950567245483,
0.035492341965436935,
-0.09412000328302383,
0.24904868006706238,
-0.5278574228286743,
0.6666651368141174,
0.21413536369800568,
0.2450871765613556,
-0.574429452419281,
0.2530615031719208,
-0.16000668704509735,
0.006116876844316721,
0.4084934890270233,
0.21246382594108582,
0.22757166624069214,
-0.358442097902298,
-0.15174777805805206,
-0.12206071615219116,
-0.5789716839790344,
0.014198033139109612,
0.4046292304992676,
0.2901664078235626,
-0.15447451174259186,
0.532168984413147,
-0.25413990020751953,
1.307568907737732,
-0.20725415647029877,
-0.2489968091249466,
0.1245887279510498,
0.045457545667886734,
-0.5016329884529114,
-0.09029585123062134,
0.5770546793937683,
0.10985696315765381,
-0.008545253425836563,
0.01777135208249092,
-0.12194309383630753,
-0.025937195867300034,
-0.19627022743225098,
-0.5949624180793762,
-0.4914417564868927,
0.25936198234558105,
-0.8818581104278564,
-0.16702239215373993,
-0.17742660641670227,
-0.8832893967628479,
-0.031247705221176147,
-0.6238534450531006,
0.49069327116012573,
-0.265791654586792,
-0.5935987830162048,
0.2954573631286621,
-0.010565622709691525,
0.031893689185380936,
-0.21428115665912628,
-1.27407705783844,
0.525305449962616,
0.36822617053985596,
0.8602414727210999,
0.19714348018169403,
0.13795728981494904,
-0.06570816040039062,
0.4362896680831909,
-0.032499391585588455,
0.8499089479446411,
-1.0072013139724731,
-0.2656240463256836,
0.12378406524658203,
-0.20439773797988892,
-0.3027845621109009,
-0.5046699047088623,
0.3541405200958252,
-0.4202580153942108,
0.12891562283039093,
-0.011991530656814575,
-0.7750244736671448,
-0.39514562487602234,
-0.3567222058773041,
-0.6381011605262756,
0.8452069759368896,
-0.051393382251262665,
-0.42875584959983826,
-0.032006874680519104,
-1.0826530456542969,
-0.403065949678421,
-0.11548197269439697,
-0.06589845567941666,
-0.23937028646469116,
0.44551530480384827,
-0.14121964573860168,
0.5600706338882446,
-0.4921490252017975,
0.2499113231897354,
-0.2200108915567398,
0.1503579318523407,
-0.13727478682994843,
-0.49710702896118164,
0.7243600487709045,
0.7223412394523621,
-0.038703154772520065,
-0.032906629145145416,
-1.1289165019989014,
0.1435331404209137,
0.17609979212284088,
-0.031422462314367294,
-0.3944540023803711,
0.491564005613327,
0.17095890641212463,
0.21476761996746063,
0.0626392662525177,
-0.42133063077926636,
-0.0820213034749031,
-0.276172012090683,
0.5705073475837708,
0.48419106006622314,
-0.06891138851642609,
0.23761965334415436,
-0.18532539904117584,
0.3177790939807892,
0.06593901664018631,
-0.08317245543003082,
-0.5902367830276489,
-0.35895460844039917,
-0.5649265646934509,
-0.33718234300613403,
0.37409508228302,
0.7306780219078064,
-0.8766021728515625,
0.3709295094013214,
0.06799231469631195,
-0.6061459183692932,
-0.6278616189956665,
-0.2991883456707001,
0.12069769948720932,
0.3949315845966339,
0.4221169650554657,
-0.028728455305099487,
-0.6761442422866821,
-1.0654429197311401,
-0.5297043919563293,
-0.32629090547561646,
-0.15993021428585052,
0.28107449412345886,
0.11096319556236267,
0.06895846128463745,
0.921807050704956,
-0.6486718654632568,
0.26639625430107117,
0.10711638629436493,
0.331234872341156,
0.2291475236415863,
0.5475857257843018,
0.4998321235179901,
-0.897541344165802,
-0.38523370027542114,
-0.22176538407802582,
-0.9269124269485474,
-0.31328311562538147,
-0.11252039670944214,
0.23522713780403137,
-0.1690133661031723,
0.2962145209312439,
-0.510877251625061,
0.3190072476863861,
0.6754404306411743,
0.04322083294391632,
0.20330718159675598,
-0.21875758469104767,
0.06654531508684158,
-1.0242745876312256,
-0.03661365061998367,
0.33981990814208984,
-0.30401796102523804,
-0.9995262026786804,
-0.16631250083446503,
-0.3341064453125,
-0.47858795523643494,
-0.607071578502655,
0.18621613085269928,
-0.841160774230957,
-0.43811577558517456,
-0.5267994403839111,
-0.28427213430404663,
-0.07306897640228271,
0.3093326985836029,
0.2896387577056885,
0.14127953350543976,
1.0310367345809937,
-0.6364091038703918,
0.6773858666419983,
-0.27879396080970764,
-0.3711473047733307,
0.6239962577819824,
-0.5392065644264221,
0.3705229163169861,
-0.35255753993988037,
-0.024391790851950645,
-0.8774775266647339,
-0.22563046216964722,
-0.12344525754451752,
-0.1018599197268486,
0.7932753562927246,
0.1395934373140335,
-0.47561919689178467,
-0.2480078637599945,
0.14191634953022003,
0.2883584499359131,
0.5189781785011292,
-0.3791458308696747,
0.7890326976776123,
0.8183163404464722,
-0.12624990940093994,
-0.26366937160491943,
-0.6228249669075012,
-0.09647448360919952,
0.0074516176246106625,
-0.6286410093307495,
0.5147373676300049,
0.09290178120136261,
-0.4767548739910126,
0.24358591437339783,
0.20336583256721497,
-0.03307521715760231,
0.0014186863554641604,
0.21954290568828583,
0.021183514967560768,
-0.002686194609850645,
0.4029415547847748,
-0.1030389666557312,
-0.06492772698402405,
-0.10629706084728241,
-0.46923357248306274,
0.5182598829269409,
-0.2515084445476532,
-0.45846572518348694,
-0.4483132064342499,
0.6465222835540771,
0.24067473411560059,
0.3382175862789154,
1.1439985036849976,
0.5015608072280884,
-0.7954822182655334,
0.14875401556491852,
-0.4620630443096161,
-0.07785966992378235,
-0.42978811264038086,
0.6433187127113342,
-0.43666350841522217,
-0.5555036664009094,
0.28292346000671387,
-0.3312598168849945,
0.13615429401397705,
0.6175393462181091,
1.015173316001892,
-0.3126814365386963,
1.0519847869873047,
0.9737923741340637,
0.07787823677062988,
0.9419326186180115,
-0.07699905335903168,
0.3742828071117401,
-0.6168370246887207,
-0.2415727823972702,
-0.5415223240852356,
-0.38675838708877563,
-0.8462059497833252,
-0.33549734950065613,
0.21742144227027893,
-0.1756165623664856,
0.00892461184412241,
0.2619727551937103,
-0.36251598596572876,
0.492178350687027,
0.30810654163360596,
-0.15515947341918945,
-0.131729394197464,
0.2469126582145691,
-0.128137469291687,
0.1276140660047531,
-0.961816132068634,
-0.5290250778198242,
0.9952841401100159,
0.35774198174476624,
0.9606678485870361,
-0.14722585678100586,
0.46395015716552734,
0.26588869094848633,
0.2547091543674469,
-0.7212499380111694,
0.39573919773101807,
0.040852729231119156,
-0.7575438022613525,
-0.2578987181186676,
-0.6199007034301758,
-0.9437538385391235,
0.4162071943283081,
-0.07693392783403397,
-0.705721378326416,
0.24906858801841736,
0.23852106928825378,
-0.41865769028663635,
0.7521480917930603,
-1.0165960788726807,
0.5030856728553772,
-0.27404141426086426,
-0.3773380517959595,
-0.41863229870796204,
-0.7129881381988525,
0.008922535926103592,
0.15614406764507294,
0.5979963541030884,
-0.2901630699634552,
-0.05181129649281502,
0.9436455368995667,
-0.09116664528846741,
0.7505692839622498,
-0.47569385170936584,
0.29501521587371826,
0.6401469111442566,
-0.20861950516700745,
0.34464889764785767,
-0.5006654262542725,
-0.32404595613479614,
0.44317761063575745,
0.19951006770133972,
-0.475534588098526,
-0.4962661564350128,
0.601275622844696,
-0.5793868899345398,
-0.7181829214096069,
-0.4135254919528961,
-0.5375949740409851,
-0.21611540019512177,
0.15720950067043304,
0.239200159907341,
0.31349143385887146,
-0.17593342065811157,
0.20172666013240814,
0.49626654386520386,
-0.2868420481681824,
0.6445369720458984,
0.539773166179657,
-0.23969221115112305,
-0.1828065812587738,
1.0700255632400513,
0.33795806765556335,
0.3818703591823578,
0.6735125780105591,
0.14019079506397247,
-0.22712816298007965,
-0.4766806364059448,
-0.06682424247264862,
0.01314333826303482,
-0.6642254590988159,
-0.11979029327630997,
-0.6198880076408386,
-0.09259876608848572,
-0.27657246589660645,
0.012504778802394867,
-0.3510685861110687,
-0.6650593280792236,
-0.5078176856040955,
-0.3147425651550293,
0.14160668849945068,
0.5792964100837708,
-0.6859177947044373,
0.20814703404903412,
-0.5326961874961853,
0.3882695734500885,
0.29346126317977905,
0.18733565509319305,
-0.09917862713336945,
-0.3301161825656891,
-0.5300139784812927,
0.08173149824142456,
-0.40616002678871155,
-1.2074909210205078,
0.575319766998291,
0.5187606811523438,
0.6657813191413879,
0.17931000888347626,
-0.44040781259536743,
0.2695700526237488,
-0.5489267706871033,
0.740014910697937,
0.7260702252388,
-0.8693855404853821,
0.6780888438224792,
-0.3521396517753601,
-0.09720590710639954,
0.21034203469753265,
0.5825780034065247,
-0.6040204167366028,
0.3654448390007019,
-0.6645680665969849,
-0.8035298585891724,
0.33722883462905884,
0.2058662325143814,
-0.10480518639087677,
-0.1255987286567688,
0.42208877205848694,
-0.08472171425819397,
0.5663705468177795,
-0.5783109664916992,
-0.5659489631652832,
-0.460726797580719,
-0.5545589923858643,
0.23339401185512543,
-0.03864530846476555,
0.17622965574264526,
-0.23444779217243195,
0.7233209013938904,
-0.0841205045580864,
0.5130605101585388,
-0.018842406570911407,
-0.1536487340927124,
-0.4114505350589752,
0.35247740149497986,
0.3415629267692566,
0.3012542724609375,
-0.31646105647087097,
-0.058457326143980026,
-0.0045925164595246315,
-0.2597169876098633,
0.4433037340641022,
-0.019340306520462036,
-0.10775714367628098,
0.1589427888393402,
-0.023432517424225807,
0.9868058562278748,
0.34137821197509766,
-0.40032973885536194,
-0.04345696419477463,
0.12917345762252808,
0.12405645102262497,
-0.2597096562385559,
-0.10157781839370728,
0.11687176674604416,
0.08126689493656158,
0.316129595041275,
0.2574954032897949,
0.33165237307548523,
-0.9638802409172058,
-0.0663393959403038,
0.5592460036277771,
-0.33498185873031616,
-0.7364463210105896,
0.46825888752937317,
0.21674925088882446,
-0.5631018280982971,
0.25788119435310364,
0.03542272374033928,
-0.23804855346679688,
0.5558934807777405,
0.7349334955215454,
0.6961647868156433,
-0.39452284574508667,
-0.08820134401321411,
0.17894530296325684,
0.2279185801744461,
0.11156078428030014,
0.5846796035766602,
0.005651066079735756,
-0.7238307595252991,
-0.2196914255619049,
-0.8264433145523071,
-0.5925583243370056,
-0.15207573771476746,
-0.8720971941947937,
0.15805184841156006,
-0.4943924844264984,
-0.5382381081581116,
0.30794045329093933,
-0.12839864194393158,
-0.9911349415779114,
0.23000100255012512,
0.5788007378578186,
0.6833062171936035,
-0.935367226600647,
0.6630286574363708,
0.8743636012077332,
0.003920982591807842,
-0.4885699450969696,
-0.47521263360977173,
0.1357651650905609,
-0.661988377571106,
0.6074889898300171,
-0.06101691722869873,
0.042663831263780594,
0.508009672164917,
-0.6918817758560181,
-1.3039921522140503,
0.9326979517936707,
0.49835437536239624,
-0.9497748017311096,
-0.0470193549990654,
0.011663221754133701,
0.424287348985672,
-0.3774077892303467,
0.4930822551250458,
0.6668100357055664,
0.34245166182518005,
-0.14035342633724213,
-0.6708310842514038,
-0.43181896209716797,
-0.06214449927210808,
0.1586109846830368,
0.3631231486797333,
-1.0440189838409424,
0.881062388420105,
-0.1301967203617096,
-0.29393425583839417,
-0.06331002712249756,
0.860660970211029,
0.18414424359798431,
0.27357056736946106,
0.29155850410461426,
0.7056340575218201,
1.0156840085983276,
-0.2983449697494507,
1.0989265441894531,
-0.43191051483154297,
0.7506245374679565,
0.5241801738739014,
-0.7203879356384277,
0.7739018201828003,
0.30609795451164246,
-0.6704918742179871,
0.656168520450592,
0.6079097390174866,
0.10676254332065582,
0.7531976103782654,
0.5972142219543457,
-0.4081050753593445,
-0.11605558544397354,
-0.29266369342803955,
-0.3767049312591553,
0.3732287287712097,
0.8762287497520447,
-0.5329722166061401,
-0.056009646505117416,
0.30137860774993896,
-0.4097937345504761,
-0.07815840095281601,
-0.6215934157371521,
0.5387489199638367,
0.4678087830543518,
-0.05515303090214729,
0.17257636785507202,
0.24570107460021973,
0.5114649534225464,
-0.550713837146759,
-0.0065628476440906525,
0.4972761571407318,
-0.1474156677722931,
-0.2866629958152771,
-0.381759911775589,
0.47013241052627563,
-0.07871563732624054,
-0.6032437086105347,
-0.3934716284275055,
1.0600426197052002,
-0.24220995604991913,
-0.6342343091964722,
0.07108252495527267,
0.47376298904418945,
0.2555086314678192,
0.3436802327632904,
-0.8317750692367554,
-0.03913165256381035,
-0.21552324295043945,
-0.49374276399612427,
0.2718483507633209,
0.07841363549232483,
0.45423951745033264,
0.48858025670051575,
0.699800968170166,
0.22240757942199707,
0.22285988926887512,
0.17351451516151428,
0.46920689940452576,
-1.0088762044906616,
-0.4517624080181122,
-0.7363359928131104,
0.04086514934897423,
0.22797100245952606,
0.26149827241897583,
0.458359032869339,
0.4955601692199707,
0.5982744097709656,
0.0420411117374897,
0.9684644341468811,
-0.04046731814742088,
0.5805528163909912,
-0.9709824323654175,
0.5487560033798218,
-0.23128612339496613,
-0.0985214114189148,
-0.07184945046901703,
-0.7136279344558716,
-0.13739873468875885,
0.8257370591163635,
-0.5855634212493896,
0.2640506327152252,
0.7125133872032166,
0.4314917027950287,
0.27025845646858215,
0.3565894067287445,
0.7735550999641418,
0.21393977105617523,
0.3823202848434448,
0.7069053053855896,
0.7241261005401611,
-0.35547760128974915,
-0.03251620754599571,
-0.3453248143196106,
-0.22974568605422974,
-0.1301552951335907,
-0.9888207316398621,
-0.47682520747184753,
-0.5429511070251465,
-0.5481851100921631,
0.08165276050567627,
-0.09895263612270355,
1.1983942985534668,
1.0018235445022583,
-1.0394479036331177,
-0.35916775465011597,
-0.10819637775421143,
-0.12369159609079361,
-0.1976173371076584,
-0.20674990117549896,
0.3526749014854431,
0.027217349037528038,
-0.7121752500534058,
0.5779556632041931,
0.7098075747489929,
0.18774071335792542,
-0.3057522773742676,
0.39010030031204224,
-0.41247865557670593,
0.3856385350227356,
0.6739361882209778,
0.6214744448661804,
-0.46583738923072815,
-0.052944593131542206,
-0.08270783722400665,
0.20139241218566895,
0.13467054069042206,
0.8441137075424194,
-0.9829214215278625,
0.5895457863807678,
0.5301216244697571,
0.4357508718967438,
0.5429579615592957,
-0.21331852674484253,
0.48000019788742065,
-0.6520388722419739,
0.4717043936252594,
0.49402472376823425,
0.9299800395965576,
0.6912044286727905,
-0.2856068015098572,
0.209458127617836,
0.688877522945404,
-0.5585131049156189,
-0.8594732284545898,
0.46990203857421875,
-0.607292115688324,
-0.06446545571088791,
0.8357163071632385,
-0.051941901445388794,
-0.5765714645385742,
0.0059818606823682785,
0.39892545342445374,
0.5240774750709534,
-0.09622593224048615,
0.5870988368988037,
0.9448995590209961,
-0.4450285732746124,
-0.17850710451602936,
-0.8862807154655457,
0.3221606910228729,
0.701659619808197,
-0.9154345989227295,
-0.12091461569070816,
0.4489709436893463,
0.17858706414699554,
0.297070175409317,
0.2781831920146942,
0.02220967225730419,
-0.05149707570672035,
0.14365239441394806,
0.16257452964782715,
-0.00802507996559143,
-0.3371453881263733,
-0.5674166083335876,
0.415995329618454,
-0.41141510009765625,
-0.10503993928432465
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10949v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10949v2
|
SelfIE: Self-Interpretation of Large Language Model Embeddings
| 2024-03-16T15:30:34 | 2024-03-26T01:15:09 |
Haozhe Chen, Carl Vondrick, Chengzhi Mao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
How do large language models (LLMs) obtain their answers? The ability to
explain and control an LLM's reasoning process is key for reliability,
transparency, and future model developments. We propose SelfIE
(Self-Interpretation of Embeddings), a framework that enables LLMs to interpret
their own embeddings in natural language by leveraging their ability to respond
to inquiries about a given passage. Capable of interpreting open-world concepts
in the hidden embeddings, SelfIE reveals LLM internal reasoning in cases such
as making ethical decisions, internalizing prompt injection, and recalling
harmful knowledge. SelfIE's text descriptions on hidden embeddings also open up
new avenues to control LLM reasoning. We propose Supervised Control, which
allows editing open-ended concepts while only requiring gradient computation of
individual layer. We extend RLHF to hidden embeddings and propose Reinforcement
Control that erases harmful knowledge in LLM without supervision targets.
|
[
-0.2075338214635849,
-0.8369901180267334,
0.8489443063735962,
0.33841127157211304,
-0.12645414471626282,
-0.0752660483121872,
-0.004381281789392233,
-0.43294966220855713,
0.1596987545490265,
0.7780551910400391,
-0.6315457820892334,
-0.512583315372467,
-0.6306967735290527,
-0.02565380372107029,
-0.23656880855560303,
0.6667938828468323,
-0.2984553277492523,
0.0572333000600338,
-0.4395749568939209,
-0.06701433658599854,
-0.17951536178588867,
-0.38840657472610474,
-0.4014088213443756,
-0.4117152988910675,
0.6825228333473206,
0.25993385910987854,
0.8220159411430359,
0.8283535838127136,
0.4844798743724823,
0.2572113871574402,
0.04863177612423897,
-0.2058434635400772,
-0.3584449887275696,
0.2890589237213135,
-0.4950936436653137,
-0.356023907661438,
-0.12512938678264618,
0.02064882218837738,
0.7761099934577942,
0.3100651502609253,
-0.10033965855836868,
0.2223675698041916,
-0.0028013421688228846,
0.40728169679641724,
-0.6075413823127747,
0.2335381954908371,
-0.22831307351589203,
0.19775331020355225,
0.14361917972564697,
-0.2711756229400635,
-0.3920347988605499,
0.0714554563164711,
-0.25439780950546265,
-0.2722815275192261,
-0.13782429695129395,
0.04155679792165756,
0.41474220156669617,
0.446488618850708,
-0.3423628509044647,
-0.47860631346702576,
-0.6857829093933105,
0.5137818455696106,
-0.5202374458312988,
0.2995228171348572,
0.40560245513916016,
0.29680967330932617,
-0.3656059801578522,
-0.5442216396331787,
-0.4754156470298767,
-0.12500543892383575,
-0.3287491202354431,
0.13320381939411163,
-0.17217406630516052,
0.04390979930758476,
0.007819713093340397,
0.2974710166454315,
-0.45456427335739136,
0.2989736795425415,
-0.1810542345046997,
-0.28011345863342285,
0.6458171606063843,
0.035211801528930664,
0.45026952028274536,
-0.2656107246875763,
-0.4497321844100952,
0.2796097993850708,
-0.7505213618278503,
-0.16379450261592865,
0.23093442618846893,
-0.004473716951906681,
-0.0528709776699543,
0.6845487356185913,
-0.19439902901649475,
0.4203342795372009,
0.011327055282890797,
-0.1258130818605423,
-0.061454880982637405,
0.043173398822546005,
-0.43235597014427185,
0.022434048354625702,
0.7959636449813843,
0.31324586272239685,
0.17288532853126526,
-0.12008468061685562,
-0.34751468896865845,
-0.29864805936813354,
0.09993553161621094,
-0.7184685468673706,
0.11800533533096313,
0.36100515723228455,
-0.7179739475250244,
-0.40726882219314575,
-0.2015039026737213,
-0.5613833665847778,
-0.3316236734390259,
-0.033413104712963104,
0.3712223768234253,
-0.09868521243333817,
-0.3708268404006958,
0.229299396276474,
0.09625772386789322,
0.39741256833076477,
0.46250399947166443,
-0.8528361916542053,
0.39237087965011597,
0.5560356974601746,
0.6690425872802734,
0.04288140684366226,
-0.31953731179237366,
-0.25543999671936035,
0.5108253359794617,
-0.48019906878471375,
0.5550326108932495,
-0.6032849550247192,
-0.2958638072013855,
-0.03958437964320183,
0.060169294476509094,
0.08499424904584885,
-0.2837993800640106,
0.3094050884246826,
-0.5970871448516846,
0.2230522632598877,
-0.02035546489059925,
-0.7312432527542114,
-0.11287347972393036,
0.17753997445106506,
-0.5542477369308472,
0.6052154898643494,
-0.36408936977386475,
-0.6791589856147766,
-0.01323064137250185,
-0.6536096334457397,
-0.23546411097049713,
0.2205120176076889,
-0.4679282009601593,
-0.14322344958782196,
0.1289936751127243,
0.39033856987953186,
0.8078613877296448,
0.0825595036149025,
0.21158987283706665,
-0.6141325235366821,
-0.23323023319244385,
0.29842081665992737,
-0.3613775074481964,
0.7080151438713074,
0.34176912903785706,
-0.2707507610321045,
0.11102810502052307,
-0.2916760742664337,
0.025745172053575516,
0.49831444025039673,
-0.14214912056922913,
-0.3014603853225708,
-0.1310688704252243,
-0.4171675443649292,
0.32753056287765503,
0.42193901538848877,
-0.4822819232940674,
0.22189554572105408,
-0.045197371393442154,
0.6330797076225281,
0.7723225951194763,
0.17756032943725586,
0.5539150834083557,
-0.03469424322247505,
0.6881407499313354,
-0.09808150678873062,
0.36569008231163025,
-0.39163804054260254,
-0.3861686587333679,
-0.406294047832489,
-0.30506908893585205,
0.011978808790445328,
0.4026549756526947,
-0.552707314491272,
0.19193561375141144,
0.04416936635971069,
-0.1953299641609192,
-0.7777100801467896,
0.34394919872283936,
0.6055333614349365,
0.28210586309432983,
0.2946489751338959,
-0.08833427727222443,
-0.03630717098712921,
-1.1918233633041382,
-0.3051801025867462,
0.006300562061369419,
0.19533361494541168,
0.4069942831993103,
0.6530563831329346,
-0.24794705212116241,
0.6410323977470398,
-0.39941537380218506,
-0.33725687861442566,
-0.22322164475917816,
0.17487697303295135,
0.009271643124520779,
0.6207156181335449,
0.3736613690853119,
-0.6374734044075012,
-0.061039041727781296,
-0.26907598972320557,
-1.110089898109436,
0.042598187923431396,
-0.45719778537750244,
-0.23066915571689606,
0.06974023580551147,
0.8701698184013367,
-0.8294538855552673,
0.5358847379684448,
0.5819171667098999,
-0.35945355892181396,
0.42408517003059387,
-0.38349759578704834,
-0.044926684349775314,
-0.5773229598999023,
-0.24123011529445648,
0.11836255341768265,
-0.7608078122138977,
-0.21614563465118408,
0.43670153617858887,
0.13439039885997772,
0.10122790187597275,
-0.43381333351135254,
0.7979821562767029,
-0.7339336276054382,
-0.3081034719944,
-0.23030558228492737,
0.29588350653648376,
0.006519252900034189,
0.3756336271762848,
0.09570858627557755,
0.6147900819778442,
0.6335357427597046,
-0.3673335313796997,
0.3968343138694763,
0.3384406566619873,
-0.45311832427978516,
0.34927618503570557,
-0.6955977082252502,
0.3052780032157898,
-0.36162564158439636,
0.4252684712409973,
-0.8265710473060608,
-0.28982818126678467,
0.5277476906776428,
-0.4521690905094147,
0.42123502492904663,
-0.21047799289226532,
-0.5514563322067261,
-0.3738222122192383,
-0.10756075382232666,
0.10721650719642639,
0.22638410329818726,
-0.8061139583587646,
0.7005046010017395,
0.3695911765098572,
-0.088381826877594,
-0.7381070256233215,
-0.8463084697723389,
0.20963191986083984,
-0.17842422425746918,
-0.2433580607175827,
0.19440968334674835,
-0.1436508148908615,
-0.34812426567077637,
0.342032253742218,
-0.06786104291677475,
-0.16662605106830597,
0.1614784151315689,
0.414539098739624,
0.07220873236656189,
-0.010869104415178299,
0.5002834796905518,
0.21991632878780365,
-0.08848488330841064,
0.4343488812446594,
-0.2417483627796173,
0.21039125323295593,
-0.1934288591146469,
-0.39888039231300354,
-0.6254303455352783,
0.38333550095558167,
0.35855743288993835,
-0.11008578538894653,
0.7569836974143982,
0.3884519040584564,
-0.290606290102005,
-0.1829933226108551,
-0.5571984648704529,
-0.1830022931098938,
-0.4862743020057678,
0.01892089657485485,
-0.6869212985038757,
-1.2685463428497314,
0.46412211656570435,
-0.015642622485756874,
-0.09115803986787796,
0.3460642397403717,
0.7539365291595459,
-0.48294559121131897,
1.1753331422805786,
0.6617114543914795,
-0.12220382690429688,
0.3461347818374634,
0.010921117849647999,
0.07780348509550095,
-0.7167901992797852,
-0.18889133632183075,
-0.10713108628988266,
-0.1566525250673294,
-0.6684927344322205,
-0.525913417339325,
0.0497334785759449,
0.2272319197654724,
-0.3307895064353943,
0.06013496220111847,
-0.48531374335289,
0.78694748878479,
0.4852049946784973,
0.22277680039405823,
0.45964109897613525,
-0.3470921516418457,
-0.3242522180080414,
0.14212436974048615,
-0.5510694980621338,
-0.7287447452545166,
0.8190066814422607,
0.8917682766914368,
1.253494143486023,
0.05521208420395851,
1.0379185676574707,
0.2409263253211975,
0.2895447909832001,
-0.6394209265708923,
0.5115339159965515,
0.3262426257133484,
-0.8510830998420715,
-0.4286699891090393,
-0.4540697932243347,
-0.6045985817909241,
0.3003029525279999,
0.006522274576127529,
-0.8211718201637268,
-0.00928665604442358,
0.3752908408641815,
-0.2160276472568512,
0.2885482609272003,
-0.5917952656745911,
0.8966611623764038,
-0.4655790627002716,
-0.32535743713378906,
-0.4927713871002197,
-0.7326588034629822,
0.5642105937004089,
0.06520022451877594,
0.3995157480239868,
-0.13451537489891052,
0.016441436484456062,
0.4906371533870697,
0.01976678892970085,
1.252597689628601,
-0.19219455122947693,
-0.25305697321891785,
0.4283328056335449,
0.5499976277351379,
0.38483235239982605,
0.2639572322368622,
0.14273867011070251,
0.25020840764045715,
0.18681247532367706,
-0.35847342014312744,
-0.9389209747314453,
0.8296540379524231,
-0.6542295217514038,
-0.9349949359893799,
-0.2028503119945526,
-0.37756869196891785,
0.06629358977079391,
0.24391117691993713,
-0.08214326947927475,
0.2351890653371811,
-0.1693064570426941,
0.12505657970905304,
0.5142556428909302,
-0.5187742710113525,
0.385785311460495,
0.29582440853118896,
-0.7896365523338318,
-0.1202174723148346,
0.7072338461875916,
-0.10912834107875824,
0.4158402979373932,
0.40488842129707336,
0.3629886209964752,
-0.5201888084411621,
-0.38019904494285583,
-0.3764028549194336,
0.5248602628707886,
-1.1627815961837769,
-0.08735717087984085,
-0.5588065981864929,
-0.08732493221759796,
-0.4855673611164093,
0.022598406299948692,
-0.3230663239955902,
-0.5729942321777344,
-0.39804214239120483,
-0.326680451631546,
0.1295488029718399,
1.1562374830245972,
-0.33668699860572815,
0.2610275149345398,
-0.5419927835464478,
0.23775091767311096,
0.4162893295288086,
0.4783087968826294,
-0.18531560897827148,
-0.4160076677799225,
-0.12916016578674316,
-0.12977038323879242,
-0.08488163352012634,
-0.8161848187446594,
0.36410361528396606,
-0.026212656870484352,
0.6346634030342102,
0.3140476942062378,
-0.07603387534618378,
0.44408732652664185,
-0.39662081003189087,
0.4388316571712494,
0.11111902445554733,
-1.105664849281311,
0.6567860841751099,
-0.28438374400138855,
0.1968875378370285,
0.1327369064092636,
0.6088994145393372,
-0.4215845465660095,
-0.5112943649291992,
-0.6914268136024475,
-0.241064190864563,
0.23282545804977417,
-0.08447305858135223,
0.4086408019065857,
-0.023286888375878334,
0.7345125675201416,
-0.12869682908058167,
0.17745593190193176,
-1.1526789665222168,
-0.047385819256305695,
-0.23813408613204956,
-0.14357106387615204,
0.028337804600596428,
-0.4714865982532501,
-0.43549805879592896,
-0.20033681392669678,
0.4124387204647064,
-0.37867844104766846,
0.40086257457733154,
0.47241073846817017,
-0.24290835857391357,
-0.3632080852985382,
0.22348205745220184,
0.35785627365112305,
0.5534480214118958,
-0.03301793709397316,
0.5014355182647705,
-0.03996114805340767,
0.08817228674888611,
-0.16911296546459198,
-0.4126983880996704,
-0.009741677902638912,
-0.4003320038318634,
0.5763785243034363,
0.6156520843505859,
0.2541947662830353,
-0.5185647010803223,
0.6882876753807068,
-0.061769038438797,
-0.059419069439172745,
-0.33599787950515747,
0.02022380195558071,
0.35809817910194397,
0.43008700013160706,
-0.016840847209095955,
-0.39229798316955566,
0.07837886363267899,
-0.6310880184173584,
0.26939740777015686,
0.5355187654495239,
-0.4644430875778198,
-0.21839283406734467,
0.568659782409668,
-0.026972947642207146,
-0.06336912512779236,
0.5505312085151672,
-0.22033774852752686,
-0.365185022354126,
0.46566203236579895,
0.6977534294128418,
0.7212539315223694,
-0.33141595125198364,
0.5607393383979797,
0.1698240488767624,
0.5144658088684082,
0.13384829461574554,
0.2331705391407013,
-0.07657311856746674,
-1.1142951250076294,
-0.6615883111953735,
-0.42907729744911194,
-0.49298185110092163,
0.2077837735414505,
-0.7423239946365356,
-0.1473904252052307,
-0.7829207181930542,
0.23721426725387573,
0.034747298806905746,
-0.3739027976989746,
-0.4977076053619385,
0.3240903615951538,
0.30974075198173523,
0.9712876677513123,
-0.7036295533180237,
0.8876774311065674,
0.33408820629119873,
-0.47975587844848633,
-0.7231357097625732,
-0.08066857606172562,
0.08959583938121796,
-1.2243103981018066,
0.8757290840148926,
0.22646871209144592,
-0.3599500060081482,
0.05059311166405678,
-1.1170496940612793,
-0.8360268473625183,
0.9911894202232361,
0.426095187664032,
-0.5989333391189575,
0.10005457699298859,
-0.2278185933828354,
0.46044352650642395,
-0.658290684223175,
0.1568172127008438,
0.5328042507171631,
0.46480613946914673,
0.2103905975818634,
-0.7173764109611511,
0.2109154462814331,
0.09142649173736572,
-0.309987336397171,
-0.1040443629026413,
-0.5458417534828186,
0.5451865196228027,
-0.5488386750221252,
-0.2795691192150116,
-0.06249352544546127,
0.6450021266937256,
-0.11452247947454453,
0.06695519387722015,
0.39548513293266296,
0.5189652442932129,
0.48123428225517273,
0.2579963505268097,
1.2946757078170776,
-0.20594768226146698,
0.4550256133079529,
1.4625177383422852,
-0.18842613697052002,
0.8509637713432312,
0.37927547097206116,
0.1793493926525116,
0.5928969383239746,
0.6117079257965088,
-0.03261595219373703,
0.5418564677238464,
0.045301519334316254,
-0.2492232471704483,
-0.558935284614563,
-0.14736223220825195,
0.08059144020080566,
0.6682772636413574,
0.5490593910217285,
-0.48599475622177124,
-0.1899053305387497,
0.127250075340271,
-0.04600861296057701,
0.07577954232692719,
-0.3203262686729431,
0.7999621033668518,
0.29537153244018555,
-0.36855584383010864,
0.18338005244731903,
-0.06277777999639511,
0.3287464678287506,
-0.20806780457496643,
-0.17264904081821442,
-0.009247059002518654,
-0.01675211265683174,
-0.30015018582344055,
-1.273962140083313,
0.39656680822372437,
-0.30298811197280884,
0.23253129422664642,
-0.7301507592201233,
1.0962929725646973,
-0.3630748391151428,
-0.31074175238609314,
0.651875913143158,
0.7605870962142944,
0.3352486193180084,
-0.0966344028711319,
-1.0958462953567505,
-0.09891193360090256,
-0.1780361533164978,
-0.548190712928772,
0.22939395904541016,
0.43499886989593506,
-0.06549582630395889,
1.1335281133651733,
0.35913920402526855,
0.06028345972299576,
-0.0006135713192634284,
0.13467927277088165,
0.9177740812301636,
-0.8159387707710266,
-0.34589025378227234,
-0.8055902719497681,
0.07704897224903107,
0.12776094675064087,
-0.0650569275021553,
0.5739901661872864,
0.19516265392303467,
0.7657705545425415,
0.00829445943236351,
0.7285152673721313,
0.18808232247829437,
0.49580565094947815,
-0.6555678844451904,
0.6502079963684082,
-0.5293273329734802,
-0.0725163146853447,
-0.030520761385560036,
-0.4338677227497101,
-0.3336930274963379,
0.9601279497146606,
-0.5664641857147217,
-0.04875507205724716,
0.542123019695282,
0.7458518743515015,
0.055895112454891205,
-0.03385232016444206,
0.581864058971405,
0.4025358557701111,
0.330824613571167,
0.1388722062110901,
1.143525242805481,
0.07260019332170486,
0.2133830040693283,
-0.28882694244384766,
-0.2466423213481903,
0.036899928003549576,
-1.0980747938156128,
-0.9207690358161926,
-0.3055444657802582,
-0.3285289406776428,
-0.11723348498344421,
-0.13283957540988922,
0.8692730069160461,
0.6308544278144836,
-0.548915684223175,
-0.13220615684986115,
-0.13072626292705536,
0.46614161133766174,
0.031559694558382034,
-0.21751324832439423,
0.125779390335083,
-0.33228152990341187,
-0.4985908269882202,
0.6329235434532166,
0.5967382192611694,
0.21453212201595306,
-0.8593825101852417,
-0.10739438980817795,
-0.11325550824403763,
0.05959157645702362,
0.4237135648727417,
0.3414570987224579,
-0.9648587107658386,
-0.5514125227928162,
-0.2474086880683899,
-0.19299784302711487,
0.10192382335662842,
0.8905301094055176,
-0.5659819841384888,
0.6028665900230408,
0.06015242636203766,
0.521497905254364,
0.6256731748580933,
-0.16223271191120148,
0.610122561454773,
-0.5495843887329102,
0.026215553283691406,
0.29342126846313477,
0.4297352135181427,
0.2593590319156647,
-0.696351170539856,
0.44312310218811035,
0.028049660846590996,
-0.6142610907554626,
-0.5232293009757996,
0.40534090995788574,
-0.7160349488258362,
-0.5751221179962158,
1.0636298656463623,
-0.49493011832237244,
-0.4767250716686249,
0.01483967062085867,
0.0029426824767142534,
0.021601736545562744,
-0.1479259878396988,
0.6993556022644043,
0.6577766537666321,
-0.22782154381275177,
-0.7702884078025818,
-0.791563868522644,
0.33347561955451965,
0.2455424666404724,
-0.9078346490859985,
0.07633326202630997,
0.4971267580986023,
0.47688406705856323,
0.08845128118991852,
0.8129897117614746,
-0.24058376252651215,
-0.06006303057074547,
-0.27305683493614197,
0.2649003267288208,
-0.046802736818790436,
-0.5655871033668518,
-0.5935460925102234,
-0.05609377473592758,
0.1368020623922348,
-0.13454756140708923
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10943v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10943v4
|
MIntRec2.0: A Large-scale Benchmark Dataset for Multimodal Intent Recognition and Out-of-scope Detection in Conversations
| 2024-03-16T15:14:15 | 2024-06-28T02:05:59 |
Hanlei Zhang, Xin Wang, Hua Xu, Qianrui Zhou, Kai Gao, Jianhua Su, jinyue Zhao, Wenrui Li, Yanting Chen
|
cs.MM
|
cs.MM, cs.CL
|
Multimodal intent recognition poses significant challenges, requiring the
incorporation of non-verbal modalities from real-world contexts to enhance the
comprehension of human intentions. Existing benchmark datasets are limited in
scale and suffer from difficulties in handling out-of-scope samples that arise
in multi-turn conversational interactions. We introduce MIntRec2.0, a
large-scale benchmark dataset for multimodal intent recognition in multi-party
conversations. It contains 1,245 dialogues with 15,040 samples, each annotated
within a new intent taxonomy of 30 fine-grained classes. Besides 9,304 in-scope
samples, it also includes 5,736 out-of-scope samples appearing in multi-turn
contexts, which naturally occur in real-world scenarios. Furthermore, we
provide comprehensive information on the speakers in each utterance, enriching
its utility for multi-party conversational research. We establish a general
framework supporting the organization of single-turn and multi-turn dialogue
data, modality feature extraction, multimodal fusion, as well as in-scope
classification and out-of-scope detection. Evaluation benchmarks are built
using classic multimodal fusion methods, ChatGPT, and human evaluators. While
existing methods incorporating nonverbal information yield improvements,
effectively leveraging context information and detecting out-of-scope samples
remains a substantial challenge. Notably, large language models exhibit a
significant performance gap compared to humans, highlighting the limitations of
machine learning methods in the cognitive intent understanding task. We believe
that MIntRec2.0 will serve as a valuable resource, providing a pioneering
foundation for research in human-machine conversational interactions, and
significantly facilitating related applications. The full dataset and codes are
available at https://github.com/thuiar/MIntRec2.0.
|
[
-0.42445072531700134,
-0.8274892568588257,
0.5585348010063171,
0.1160188838839531,
0.097108393907547,
-0.034977443516254425,
-0.4802692234516144,
-0.23599113523960114,
0.1245788112282753,
0.4082176685333252,
-0.5781589150428772,
-0.0695318952202797,
-0.39915165305137634,
-0.38725149631500244,
-0.22942139208316803,
0.6709480285644531,
0.03872931748628616,
0.042988914996385574,
-0.45341747999191284,
-0.3855329751968384,
-0.7897087931632996,
-0.2411235272884369,
-0.3396714925765991,
-0.11878801882266998,
0.36057525873184204,
1.0118597745895386,
0.23172591626644135,
-0.0034783335868269205,
0.22041840851306915,
0.2940165102481842,
0.21213319897651672,
0.45338714122772217,
-0.6362146735191345,
0.26748374104499817,
-0.1999778300523758,
-0.2215937077999115,
-0.28630223870277405,
0.19687899947166443,
0.6028851270675659,
0.4662090241909027,
-0.08626881241798401,
0.015276157297194004,
-0.26132896542549133,
0.5291383266448975,
-0.8519662618637085,
0.5564438700675964,
-0.4445143938064575,
-0.48977407813072205,
-0.29995256662368774,
-0.22518467903137207,
-0.6130118370056152,
-0.12218573689460754,
0.11306491494178772,
-0.42949023842811584,
-0.05345526337623596,
0.029238218441605568,
0.49128374457359314,
-0.25952082872390747,
-0.5503339171409607,
-0.3990876078605652,
-0.4211999475955963,
0.7740188837051392,
-0.162942573428154,
0.8357346653938293,
0.4333006739616394,
0.3842550814151764,
-0.4452528655529022,
-0.755841851234436,
-0.5550903081893921,
0.0736338421702385,
0.057465143501758575,
0.1537458300590515,
-0.4135892987251282,
-0.1084836944937706,
0.21047604084014893,
0.11480984091758728,
-0.6825228929519653,
-0.16741685569286346,
-0.16112825274467468,
-0.14649389684200287,
0.12539881467819214,
-0.10362482815980911,
0.011280027218163013,
-0.25231871008872986,
-0.39425763487815857,
-0.5851198434829712,
-0.3052392303943634,
0.4041253626346588,
0.19666899740695953,
0.14838486909866333,
-0.07446446269750595,
0.525945782661438,
-0.16126959025859833,
0.3695017397403717,
0.09910789877176285,
0.008383957669138908,
0.28272345662117004,
-0.6370640397071838,
-0.007915309630334377,
0.09816591441631317,
0.7982017993927002,
0.5047352910041809,
0.07064279913902283,
-0.08484705537557602,
0.16508372128009796,
0.041097354143857956,
0.005447290372103453,
-0.9900570511817932,
-0.1997031569480896,
0.31525635719299316,
-0.40817439556121826,
0.19288088381290436,
0.12117893248796463,
-0.9234617948532104,
-0.5369503498077393,
-0.260189414024353,
0.06291168183088303,
-0.5034430623054504,
-0.7212730646133423,
-0.0305565744638443,
-0.5060747265815735,
0.408202201128006,
0.24225570261478424,
-0.8085777163505554,
0.44658970832824707,
0.8955307006835938,
0.709601104259491,
0.054749008268117905,
-0.2436113953590393,
-0.9193596243858337,
0.0393870510160923,
-0.31295448541641235,
0.8634955883026123,
-0.5156017541885376,
-0.43643394112586975,
-0.29799753427505493,
0.06970398873090744,
-0.06471027433872223,
-0.4871535003185272,
0.3796544075012207,
-0.25717589259147644,
0.24407264590263367,
-0.18450045585632324,
-0.3084554374217987,
-0.20596282184123993,
0.28427308797836304,
-0.5653221011161804,
0.7093316316604614,
0.4025879204273224,
-0.5789945721626282,
0.4487500786781311,
-0.8041329383850098,
-0.5155390501022339,
0.09267168492078781,
-0.31326672434806824,
-0.30986425280570984,
0.311644047498703,
0.07654289156198502,
0.18010063469409943,
-0.5295183062553406,
0.33501240611076355,
-0.5445072054862976,
-0.10055667161941528,
0.923301100730896,
-0.7482806444168091,
0.48973485827445984,
0.10770575702190399,
-0.3034914433956146,
0.2967148423194885,
-0.528331458568573,
0.37179306149482727,
-0.2781861126422882,
0.1281510889530182,
-0.2812628149986267,
-0.20332565903663635,
0.3784232437610626,
0.35797184705734253,
0.03707286715507507,
-0.5447090268135071,
-0.09493602067232132,
0.02132774330675602,
0.8502247929573059,
0.5348189473152161,
-0.09662824869155884,
0.4591135084629059,
-0.2076273113489151,
0.10451269894838333,
-0.011635271832346916,
0.23595595359802246,
-0.5830362439155579,
-0.5971240997314453,
-0.5764999389648438,
-0.7175037264823914,
0.19660617411136627,
0.39755186438560486,
-0.4508877098560333,
0.23736472427845,
-0.4734380841255188,
-0.252491295337677,
-0.19063498079776764,
-0.06090380623936653,
0.627109944820404,
0.3267180621623993,
0.20263537764549255,
-0.6037947535514832,
-0.6483044624328613,
-0.8142648935317993,
-0.17713500559329987,
-0.4408225119113922,
0.041133951395750046,
0.7178229093551636,
0.3161174952983856,
-0.36614924669265747,
1.2852355241775513,
-0.22754040360450745,
-0.39943844079971313,
-0.3333565294742584,
0.6808472275733948,
-0.16496777534484863,
0.29669034481048584,
0.08704107999801636,
-0.9679145812988281,
-0.24679814279079437,
-0.014841589145362377,
-0.5491454601287842,
0.08897752314805984,
-0.1461380124092102,
-0.12995333969593048,
0.2876986861228943,
0.5448467135429382,
-0.4137192964553833,
0.39897608757019043,
0.6486339569091797,
-0.3405454754829407,
0.1399213671684265,
-0.2909225821495056,
0.5263046622276306,
-0.9829681515693665,
0.12154310196638107,
-0.03531520813703537,
-0.2549246549606323,
-0.7277352809906006,
-0.5736136436462402,
0.5558059811592102,
-0.012194178998470306,
-0.4896303415298462,
0.657328188419342,
-0.35551074147224426,
-0.10790247470140457,
-0.05303014814853668,
0.242619127035141,
0.16149084270000458,
0.40628525614738464,
0.39153844118118286,
0.8255627751350403,
0.16007360816001892,
-0.3486017882823944,
0.2619442045688629,
0.4159494638442993,
-0.44855451583862305,
1.1234087944030762,
-0.19080141186714172,
0.2563657760620117,
0.07245771586894989,
0.444163978099823,
-1.3319114446640015,
-0.5546875596046448,
0.21860165894031525,
-0.6222348213195801,
0.3653908371925354,
-0.24717272818088531,
-0.5593540072441101,
-0.0481574572622776,
-0.47723931074142456,
0.6103871464729309,
0.25726068019866943,
-0.6042884588241577,
0.7485429048538208,
0.6362878084182739,
-0.09962429851293564,
-0.14202138781547546,
-0.7894567847251892,
0.4120803773403168,
-0.11731483042240143,
-0.8107176423072815,
0.03379930928349495,
-0.03960761800408363,
-0.1508522629737854,
-0.48042359948158264,
0.11697547137737274,
-0.0963631346821785,
-0.4329608380794525,
0.5753047466278076,
0.17423902451992035,
0.2554822862148285,
0.06057192012667656,
-0.24018429219722748,
-0.1957244575023651,
0.013914697803556919,
-0.1705256551504135,
0.6244826316833496,
-0.3334876596927643,
-0.35131096839904785,
-0.5457562804222107,
0.32697972655296326,
0.796971321105957,
-0.2826865613460541,
0.11809290945529938,
0.7150191068649292,
-0.07842297106981277,
0.43790197372436523,
-0.8626331686973572,
-0.19942554831504822,
-0.4344816207885742,
0.5435255169868469,
-0.5185559391975403,
-0.6885894536972046,
0.30838844180107117,
-0.2603665292263031,
-0.26712116599082947,
-0.1362875998020172,
0.5704383254051208,
0.17761056125164032,
0.8980908989906311,
0.23532181978225708,
0.1375487595796585,
0.7609983086585999,
-0.2639465928077698,
0.2131485790014267,
-1.1870203018188477,
-0.41786855459213257,
-0.10875414311885834,
-0.17398378252983093,
-0.6565818190574646,
-0.7780182361602783,
0.3077479898929596,
-0.18107783794403076,
0.05720091983675957,
0.5441930294036865,
-0.11570728570222855,
0.24314111471176147,
0.61341392993927,
-0.018130771815776825,
0.16551744937896729,
-0.22332370281219482,
0.41151151061058044,
-0.09846440702676773,
-0.4094482660293579,
-0.016939163208007812,
1.1377757787704468,
0.3370652496814728,
0.7611201405525208,
0.3068055808544159,
0.2949371039867401,
0.01314315665513277,
0.15495340526103973,
-0.9192456007003784,
0.4300926625728607,
0.19657930731773376,
-0.927823007106781,
-0.21554000675678253,
-0.7162639498710632,
-0.8499050736427307,
0.14618642628192902,
0.12366142123937607,
-0.9262451529502869,
0.5427259206771851,
-0.2472975254058838,
-0.054179105907678604,
0.07552168518304825,
-1.044340968132019,
1.1465725898742676,
-0.5467398166656494,
-0.627387285232544,
-0.2878132462501526,
-0.6755539178848267,
0.4314941167831421,
0.09930086880922318,
0.4710785448551178,
-0.1520005166530609,
0.18000775575637817,
0.7374138236045837,
0.13374711573123932,
0.6080629825592041,
-0.2248261570930481,
0.13109129667282104,
0.4185584485530853,
0.15450148284435272,
0.5469813346862793,
0.5983980894088745,
0.34934040904045105,
0.22289825975894928,
0.13643352687358856,
0.058266326785087585,
-0.3122469484806061,
0.8339628577232361,
-0.4645753800868988,
0.10084440559148788,
-0.5584647059440613,
-0.744165301322937,
-0.4163694381713867,
0.2890213131904602,
0.008035277016460896,
0.7383427023887634,
-0.5791563391685486,
0.5053783655166626,
0.8066480755805969,
0.006395048927515745,
0.3383199870586395,
0.5484704971313477,
-0.14989463984966278,
-0.7184619307518005,
1.1892520189285278,
-0.19879202544689178,
0.20168592035770416,
0.523500919342041,
0.16187703609466553,
-0.7787991762161255,
-0.06203622743487358,
-0.5238249897956848,
0.04198971763253212,
-0.6091774702072144,
-0.12020868808031082,
-0.6955032348632812,
0.2433323860168457,
-0.6613931655883789,
0.023109041154384613,
-0.5128985643386841,
-0.27806296944618225,
-0.24154551327228546,
0.404998779296875,
0.34209349751472473,
0.32121580839157104,
-0.25387147068977356,
0.14024057984352112,
-0.4723362326622009,
0.5330209732055664,
0.4222392439842224,
0.4373007118701935,
-0.4391249418258667,
-0.2648952603340149,
0.20367582142353058,
0.2660108804702759,
-0.18525773286819458,
-0.5173117518424988,
0.250953733921051,
0.20265483856201172,
0.2460898756980896,
0.7251442074775696,
-0.019808795303106308,
0.7746243476867676,
-0.12897613644599915,
0.3496845066547394,
0.7294911742210388,
-0.895643413066864,
0.36952507495880127,
-0.21652132272720337,
0.34645742177963257,
0.7667895555496216,
-0.14795877039432526,
-0.9738250374794006,
0.06989175826311111,
-0.5430378913879395,
-0.6834442615509033,
1.1472208499908447,
0.18268288671970367,
-0.24501806497573853,
-0.09453029930591583,
-0.1739259958267212,
0.11204880475997925,
0.21108706295490265,
-0.09916999191045761,
0.12442350387573242,
-0.36743423342704773,
-0.018012534826993942,
-0.2916536033153534,
-0.2582988142967224,
-0.27004337310791016,
0.03280213847756386,
0.2804766893386841,
-0.3412027359008789,
0.2989419102668762,
-0.10479114204645157,
-0.14144928753376007,
-0.1457587629556656,
0.5403661131858826,
0.6406345963478088,
0.6692835092544556,
-0.5386847853660583,
0.055999089032411575,
-0.031942933797836304,
-0.4302671551704407,
-0.08815795183181763,
0.29795095324516296,
0.393216609954834,
-0.2989383041858673,
0.05745851993560791,
0.641377866268158,
0.39752867817878723,
-1.102726936340332,
0.795947790145874,
-0.6957690119743347,
-0.15392367541790009,
-0.4678420126438141,
-0.27226004004478455,
-0.1772611141204834,
0.2573772668838501,
-0.016534680500626564,
0.20452751219272614,
0.32379665970802307,
-1.0073645114898682,
0.282501220703125,
0.6449319124221802,
-0.7110900282859802,
-0.27831020951271057,
0.2652779519557953,
0.06688674539327621,
-0.013118351809680462,
0.8128424286842346,
-0.4880674183368683,
-0.21391385793685913,
0.18906834721565247,
0.30902180075645447,
0.7976068258285522,
0.28809162974357605,
0.3006627857685089,
0.25483161211013794,
-0.07774940878152847,
-0.07998544722795486,
0.2710563838481903,
-0.34467899799346924,
-0.3852940499782562,
-0.11414413899183273,
-0.09266941249370575,
-0.6336421370506287,
0.0822480320930481,
-0.5517500638961792,
0.3743639886379242,
-0.3321287930011749,
-0.19745612144470215,
0.047553785145282745,
-0.07400114089250565,
-0.5564699769020081,
-0.29696008563041687,
0.10450384765863419,
0.5186072587966919,
-0.4674762785434723,
0.6953884363174438,
0.5748451948165894,
-0.20826950669288635,
-0.31476354598999023,
-0.3314312696456909,
0.3474820554256439,
-0.6398841142654419,
0.45570918917655945,
0.436973512172699,
-0.3394545316696167,
-0.26656270027160645,
-0.16063974797725677,
-0.6206287145614624,
1.0228798389434814,
0.08350860327482224,
-0.4189741313457489,
0.22133010625839233,
0.278857558965683,
0.09844746440649033,
-0.2407216578722,
0.7906309962272644,
0.6577399373054504,
0.8445597887039185,
0.5324061512947083,
-0.9382773637771606,
-0.049639564007520676,
-0.006312644109129906,
-0.03005354106426239,
0.5046074390411377,
-0.7397958636283875,
0.736710250377655,
-0.05927657335996628,
-0.2567548453807831,
0.19868279993534088,
0.23535272479057312,
0.27210015058517456,
0.5795214772224426,
0.4639471173286438,
0.4699043333530426,
0.5674813389778137,
-0.4380761682987213,
0.55083167552948,
-0.0885937511920929,
0.01595105230808258,
1.1667566299438477,
-0.4807390570640564,
0.7646040320396423,
0.609994649887085,
0.08173737674951553,
0.32351499795913696,
0.36397111415863037,
0.31456658244132996,
0.6820566058158875,
-0.06007785722613335,
-0.17251908779144287,
-0.2863430976867676,
-0.31665340065956116,
-0.16921250522136688,
0.7522136569023132,
0.7834678888320923,
0.16381315886974335,
-0.07879004627466202,
0.1924637407064438,
-0.1283358484506607,
-0.2815403938293457,
0.005221079103648663,
1.0802171230316162,
-0.226832777261734,
-0.9187893867492676,
0.357119083404541,
-0.15879012644290924,
0.6167826056480408,
-0.5656360387802124,
-0.07614481449127197,
0.0007005077204667032,
0.7675561308860779,
-0.12409445643424988,
-0.8423656225204468,
-0.20109231770038605,
-0.3509983718395233,
-0.10637222230434418,
-0.3069530427455902,
0.5534392595291138,
-0.43325182795524597,
-0.14689476788043976,
0.17787890136241913,
0.2448379248380661,
0.16092461347579956,
-0.4252575635910034,
-0.4449232816696167,
0.3247065246105194,
-0.23380915820598602,
0.10243500024080276,
0.4024485945701599,
0.7018532156944275,
-0.25955212116241455,
0.38041630387306213,
0.7744913101196289,
-0.31651952862739563,
-0.23527581989765167,
0.14302605390548706,
0.8619962334632874,
-0.40784209966659546,
-0.47572627663612366,
-0.44721201062202454,
0.24425256252288818,
-0.2783224284648895,
-0.5050033926963806,
0.6059224009513855,
0.8599061965942383,
0.820650041103363,
0.33557888865470886,
0.6355919241905212,
-0.4512084722518921,
0.47305890917778015,
-0.18783064186573029,
0.17341524362564087,
-0.4243645966053009,
-0.08383160084486008,
0.0011029803426936269,
-0.5311291217803955,
0.04743389040231705,
0.5014578700065613,
-0.33143001794815063,
0.1863517314195633,
0.6840188503265381,
0.8065905570983887,
-0.2886813282966614,
0.33240437507629395,
0.2093532383441925,
-0.16261686384677887,
0.7012128829956055,
0.6718171834945679,
0.9605202078819275,
-0.4338347613811493,
0.8593272566795349,
-0.17550736665725708,
-0.6354984641075134,
-0.6268473267555237,
-0.6107195615768433,
-0.9637871384620667,
-0.9003790616989136,
-0.17964600026607513,
-0.39745432138442993,
-0.003274667076766491,
0.8993186950683594,
0.9961022734642029,
-0.7826704382896423,
-0.45070749521255493,
-0.2731667160987854,
-0.12435879558324814,
-0.3188866078853607,
-0.2337787002325058,
0.05747970566153526,
-0.30998748540878296,
-0.6091350317001343,
0.5039716362953186,
0.551437258720398,
-0.17024052143096924,
-0.3186156153678894,
-0.2940766215324402,
-0.4450424015522003,
-0.07007480412721634,
0.652295708656311,
0.4541604518890381,
-0.5595386624336243,
-0.10937364399433136,
0.19629938900470734,
0.11408472806215286,
0.13536061346530914,
1.2148761749267578,
-0.6977766752243042,
0.8869496583938599,
0.5181992650032043,
0.1931559294462204,
0.7093381285667419,
-0.08642173558473587,
0.241280660033226,
-0.74598628282547,
0.20646192133426666,
0.20509672164916992,
0.20299434661865234,
0.4201247990131378,
0.12406766414642334,
0.2787986099720001,
0.01603805087506771,
-0.5822298526763916,
-0.7086936831474304,
0.3333958387374878,
-1.2628791332244873,
-0.3407343924045563,
1.2724109888076782,
0.12113755196332932,
-0.3151005208492279,
-0.3708151578903198,
-0.4912845492362976,
0.16196252405643463,
-0.9435292482376099,
0.40521663427352905,
0.5434255003929138,
-0.41251233220100403,
-0.26083287596702576,
-0.39167073369026184,
0.3046110272407532,
0.1330794394016266,
-0.800392746925354,
0.7960888743400574,
0.6548415422439575,
0.0032948264852166176,
0.2789640724658966,
0.7516579627990723,
-0.2693118155002594,
0.46201661229133606,
0.015292186290025711,
-0.006349651608616114,
-0.10235457122325897,
-0.5242056846618652,
-0.04891558364033699,
-0.02150765061378479,
-0.10538855195045471,
-0.20406366884708405
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10937v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10937v1
|
Initial Decoding with Minimally Augmented Language Model for Improved Lattice Rescoring in Low Resource ASR
| 2024-03-16T14:34:31 | 2024-03-16T14:34:31 |
Savitha Murthy, Dinkar Sitaram
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
This paper addresses the problem of improving speech recognition accuracy
with lattice rescoring in low-resource languages where the baseline language
model is insufficient for generating inclusive lattices. We minimally augment
the baseline language model with word unigram counts that are present in a
larger text corpus of the target language but absent in the baseline. The
lattices generated after decoding with such an augmented baseline language
model are more comprehensive. We obtain 21.8% (Telugu) and 41.8% (Kannada)
relative word error reduction with our proposed method. This reduction in word
error rate is comparable to 21.5% (Telugu) and 45.9% (Kannada) relative word
error reduction obtained by decoding with full Wikipedia text augmented
language mode while our approach consumes only 1/8th the memory. We demonstrate
that our method is comparable with various text selection-based language model
augmentation and also consistent for data sets of different sizes. Our approach
is applicable for training speech recognition systems under low resource
conditions where speech data and compute resources are insufficient, while
there is a large text corpus that is available in the target language. Our
research involves addressing the issue of out-of-vocabulary words of the
baseline in general and does not focus on resolving the absence of named
entities. Our proposed method is simple and yet computationally less expensive.
|
[
-0.08169382065534592,
-0.2772826552391052,
-0.10086940973997116,
-0.08755794167518616,
-0.42789456248283386,
0.22571823000907898,
-0.21674032509326935,
-0.23722490668296814,
0.16442212462425232,
0.4414306879043579,
-0.1467440128326416,
-0.14999940991401672,
-0.31384092569351196,
0.1729850471019745,
-0.3062792718410492,
0.4715293049812317,
0.14660322666168213,
0.39183202385902405,
-0.16797471046447754,
-0.10255537927150726,
-0.24826689064502716,
-0.5381921529769897,
-0.7686083912849426,
-0.5630896687507629,
-0.1634279489517212,
0.5631988644599915,
0.4437985122203827,
0.694370448589325,
0.29760947823524475,
0.3408588469028473,
-0.5190746784210205,
0.39346227049827576,
-0.4517368674278259,
-0.468660444021225,
0.1223343014717102,
-0.1272512823343277,
-0.41706329584121704,
-0.40795961022377014,
1.1195197105407715,
0.8295989036560059,
-0.46456998586654663,
0.1580287367105484,
0.3853673040866852,
0.6465467810630798,
-0.7766200304031372,
0.017601914703845978,
-0.7520206570625305,
0.004366483073681593,
-0.23807121813297272,
-0.2816535234451294,
-0.5655022859573364,
0.1512305587530136,
-0.3159758150577545,
-0.4583463966846466,
0.26664984226226807,
0.13123176991939545,
0.46739286184310913,
0.1881348341703415,
-0.09699142724275589,
-0.20470570027828217,
-0.8918785452842712,
0.8874368071556091,
-0.5834081768989563,
0.6598497033119202,
0.8101944923400879,
-0.05106517672538757,
0.10661210864782333,
-0.6338424682617188,
-0.6170987486839294,
-0.42590007185935974,
-0.10818939656019211,
-0.09045184403657913,
-0.3084534704685211,
0.304048627614975,
0.4487379193305969,
0.6082728505134583,
-0.33717313408851624,
-0.07632492482662201,
-0.5381001830101013,
-0.5471381545066833,
0.2833571434020996,
0.2291027158498764,
0.37633952498435974,
-0.454956591129303,
-0.07628531008958817,
0.045001477003097534,
-0.5734758973121643,
0.26541998982429504,
0.1337953358888626,
0.5849946737289429,
-0.4261840581893921,
0.6323378682136536,
-0.28159549832344055,
0.7442697286605835,
0.04534323886036873,
-0.28651732206344604,
0.21716713905334473,
-0.49137312173843384,
-0.29230159521102905,
0.5630759000778198,
0.6342922449111938,
0.03206891939043999,
-0.026655463501811028,
-0.06215495243668556,
-0.15259581804275513,
0.279282808303833,
0.0985322967171669,
-0.6615501046180725,
-0.21821750700473785,
-0.15084987878799438,
-0.43272334337234497,
0.017967062070965767,
-0.4208732545375824,
-0.419353187084198,
-0.37428414821624756,
-0.3072935938835144,
0.08119922876358032,
-0.7034423351287842,
-0.08298787474632263,
-0.1850292980670929,
0.03991301357746124,
0.2819465696811676,
0.07468479871749878,
-1.041147232055664,
0.7042844295501709,
0.35092461109161377,
0.8451184630393982,
0.06369439512491226,
-0.03430774807929993,
-0.7415044903755188,
0.09042797237634659,
-0.4245026111602783,
0.7073960304260254,
-0.43167826533317566,
-0.867020845413208,
-0.2242511659860611,
-0.3006744384765625,
0.16471631824970245,
-0.5654220581054688,
0.7599239349365234,
-0.2735383212566376,
-0.1418839395046234,
-0.29721081256866455,
-0.3265019953250885,
0.1373961716890335,
0.09946199506521225,
-0.508348822593689,
0.9126377105712891,
0.01563890278339386,
-0.6132985949516296,
0.024493461474776268,
-0.45312148332595825,
-0.4048626124858856,
0.2895551025867462,
-0.24015991389751434,
-0.04904962703585625,
0.2688172161579132,
0.31430783867836,
-0.1463855504989624,
-0.5438483357429504,
-0.3889772891998291,
0.22828789055347443,
-0.5436936020851135,
0.1868119239807129,
-0.6456668972969055,
0.6974904537200928,
0.4398213326931,
0.2127305120229721,
-0.18941067159175873,
-1.022011637687683,
0.3887307643890381,
-0.3134417235851288,
-0.5621798634529114,
-0.3334031403064728,
0.021307798102498055,
0.31255221366882324,
-0.3723469376564026,
0.25089702010154724,
-0.6557462215423584,
-0.16591912508010864,
-0.8598918914794922,
0.2718985676765442,
0.42629459500312805,
-0.12956656515598297,
0.8224663734436035,
-0.14868518710136414,
0.2002025544643402,
-0.04734877124428749,
-0.10668433457612991,
0.09440555423498154,
-0.2062234878540039,
-0.7669453024864197,
-0.27097412943840027,
0.6367319226264954,
0.6375069618225098,
-1.2990946769714355,
0.07989291846752167,
-0.414325088262558,
-0.09608761966228485,
-0.8290594816207886,
0.38820981979370117,
0.9360449314117432,
0.6517738103866577,
0.5436940789222717,
-0.38278481364250183,
-1.0002654790878296,
-0.7438059449195862,
-0.054376691579818726,
-0.41383036971092224,
0.05359901860356331,
0.24176502227783203,
-0.042961958795785904,
-0.1789872944355011,
0.7298415899276733,
-0.3830689787864685,
-0.30608025193214417,
-0.48521125316619873,
-0.0176544189453125,
0.24965444207191467,
0.605596661567688,
0.12174766510725021,
-0.7660776972770691,
-0.7161188125610352,
0.18608435988426208,
-0.4464578926563263,
0.3000986576080322,
0.37511125206947327,
0.16485276818275452,
0.3152078688144684,
0.41996628046035767,
-0.34781476855278015,
0.4706572890281677,
0.3960340619087219,
0.048296861350536346,
0.190212681889534,
-0.5108714699745178,
0.20413872599601746,
-1.179848551750183,
0.02113855630159378,
-0.16968737542629242,
-0.059653233736753464,
-1.1786974668502808,
-0.29062125086784363,
0.08936237543821335,
-0.303117573261261,
-0.5391921401023865,
0.4883754253387451,
-0.8141425848007202,
-0.22651997208595276,
-0.6880914568901062,
0.05298711359500885,
-0.3307943046092987,
0.29408034682273865,
0.21404804289340973,
0.971828281879425,
0.4028511047363281,
-0.7996724247932434,
0.3375498652458191,
0.514326810836792,
-0.3755094110965729,
0.3633526861667633,
-0.46340736746788025,
0.07091201841831207,
-0.2033945918083191,
-0.10548213869333267,
-0.7708117365837097,
-0.12224939465522766,
0.18254178762435913,
-0.9623509645462036,
0.6409465074539185,
-0.30084720253944397,
-0.20454226434230804,
-0.22166377305984497,
-0.11974307149648666,
0.5854965448379517,
0.9079554080963135,
-0.4871505796909332,
0.6390613913536072,
0.6769106984138489,
0.05566050484776497,
-0.6999025344848633,
-1.0173063278198242,
0.07756351679563522,
0.12088257819414139,
-0.35431593656539917,
0.5081642270088196,
-0.03757821023464203,
-0.18548281490802765,
0.0329519584774971,
-0.13987334072589874,
-0.379594087600708,
-0.22912880778312683,
-0.0008680345490574837,
0.19054408371448517,
-0.17628411948680878,
0.0770905390381813,
-0.17102663218975067,
-0.2951493263244629,
-0.3443007469177246,
0.045693639665842056,
0.664262056350708,
-0.20698493719100952,
-0.17361880838871002,
-0.5980716347694397,
0.2472338080406189,
0.154378741979599,
-0.2194623351097107,
0.6784376502037048,
0.6223865151405334,
-0.9154457449913025,
0.07211536169052124,
-0.46547308564186096,
-0.00748836062848568,
-0.4860391914844513,
0.33485984802246094,
-0.383999228477478,
-0.5833169221878052,
0.6059017181396484,
0.3608359098434448,
-0.37920308113098145,
0.2571866512298584,
0.36853453516960144,
0.059820789843797684,
0.7494269013404846,
0.6750912666320801,
-0.4275013208389282,
0.5141803026199341,
-0.332268625497818,
0.16449272632598877,
-1.3580832481384277,
-0.016345364972949028,
-0.5335512757301331,
0.03435608372092247,
-0.5601953864097595,
-0.43092772364616394,
0.28313782811164856,
0.3572218716144562,
0.0446278341114521,
0.15670245885849,
-0.7045209407806396,
0.5846508741378784,
0.448806494474411,
0.3773914575576782,
0.3495871126651764,
0.47996243834495544,
-0.03106950968503952,
-0.22984734177589417,
-0.8977741599082947,
-0.15721221268177032,
0.8312512040138245,
-0.04548734799027443,
0.8106343746185303,
0.22356072068214417,
0.6846694946289062,
0.43448305130004883,
0.27819302678108215,
-0.9397047162055969,
0.41049858927726746,
-0.5298454165458679,
-0.29834261536598206,
-0.4305230379104614,
-0.6880560517311096,
-0.8345221281051636,
0.12119948863983154,
-0.3767244815826416,
-0.7597463130950928,
0.31261587142944336,
0.4697355329990387,
-0.7353948354721069,
0.30712494254112244,
-0.668507993221283,
0.4119838774204254,
0.025701729580760002,
-0.2792009115219116,
-0.03910619392991066,
-0.27941811084747314,
0.41170734167099,
0.2041766345500946,
0.24642795324325562,
0.23242118954658508,
-0.05525560304522514,
0.7792261242866516,
-0.6848002076148987,
0.5817896723747253,
-0.2520659267902374,
0.42142605781555176,
0.6606420278549194,
-0.15923818945884705,
0.44312137365341187,
-0.15809454023838043,
-0.2032860368490219,
-0.07161232084035873,
-0.03302526846528053,
-0.33394956588745117,
-0.37591803073883057,
0.7272622585296631,
-0.8139343857765198,
-0.23242944478988647,
-0.4700298011302948,
-0.3557092845439911,
-0.30348169803619385,
0.045670054852962494,
0.53704833984375,
0.8672833442687988,
-0.19623951613903046,
0.34448671340942383,
0.7626851201057434,
-0.11538009345531464,
0.4945412278175354,
0.6020854711532593,
0.07967131584882736,
-0.8278418183326721,
1.0605772733688354,
0.2702752351760864,
0.1289893090724945,
0.4201284348964691,
0.048045337200164795,
-0.49391600489616394,
-0.9321796894073486,
-0.49549204111099243,
0.10745793581008911,
-0.5950111150741577,
-0.3679277300834656,
-0.41861605644226074,
-0.46427109837532043,
-0.5649809241294861,
0.089260034263134,
-0.4981926381587982,
-0.23941634595394135,
-0.4837215542793274,
0.23561248183250427,
0.5107196569442749,
0.26586055755615234,
-0.29067477583885193,
0.7228524088859558,
-1.0711950063705444,
0.563859224319458,
0.04452408105134964,
0.3530650734901428,
0.15493430197238922,
-1.0501470565795898,
-0.5229368805885315,
0.26608985662460327,
0.13822510838508606,
-0.7655800580978394,
0.5713608860969543,
0.4240468442440033,
0.5322046279907227,
0.11045070737600327,
0.19562150537967682,
1.031743049621582,
-0.7372342944145203,
0.6581900715827942,
0.45864585041999817,
-1.2354415655136108,
0.4762936234474182,
-0.06360824406147003,
0.38968878984451294,
0.5912238359451294,
-0.003445826005190611,
-0.519366979598999,
0.3521363139152527,
-0.5042172074317932,
-0.6976767182350159,
0.9807550311088562,
0.31941500306129456,
0.164720356464386,
0.002736535621806979,
0.4715797007083893,
-0.6179907917976379,
0.002238581655547023,
-0.5617855787277222,
-0.3830886483192444,
0.008659160695970058,
-0.30176612734794617,
-0.38423383235931396,
-0.6877898573875427,
0.101007379591465,
-0.3895498812198639,
0.8408183455467224,
-0.04520788416266441,
0.29420819878578186,
0.14375673234462738,
-0.30347129702568054,
-0.24276643991470337,
0.4249561131000519,
0.6721469163894653,
0.14772073924541473,
-0.13182273507118225,
0.0971655398607254,
0.9227659702301025,
-0.8149148225784302,
0.2563459575176239,
0.08969137072563171,
-0.14250798523426056,
0.09523971378803253,
0.1916274130344391,
0.8812570571899414,
0.493489533662796,
-0.40425756573677063,
0.2749720811843872,
-0.11399349570274353,
0.14338602125644684,
-0.5362169146537781,
-0.2551305294036865,
-0.07805594801902771,
0.05927055701613426,
0.3174363076686859,
0.0012149036629125476,
0.3416559398174286,
-0.6302707195281982,
0.2604113221168518,
0.6010390520095825,
-0.5379424095153809,
-0.0712612122297287,
0.3837677836418152,
0.21909204125404358,
-0.5286813974380493,
0.7836729288101196,
-0.34302008152008057,
-0.25259414315223694,
0.33758193254470825,
0.6096392869949341,
0.6565774083137512,
-0.7346977591514587,
-0.08064023405313492,
0.5651190876960754,
0.4384930431842804,
-0.362603098154068,
0.46900781989097595,
-0.2147471308708191,
-1.0215251445770264,
-0.5112720727920532,
-0.8992283344268799,
-0.5348820090293884,
0.12754766643047333,
-0.8914791941642761,
0.2780103087425232,
-0.5113438367843628,
-0.14453570544719696,
-0.22060994803905487,
0.12528954446315765,
-0.11246340721845627,
0.2395407259464264,
0.298443078994751,
0.7334392070770264,
-0.4002656638622284,
1.0352762937545776,
0.6436882615089417,
-0.2770698070526123,
-0.8135772943496704,
-0.3087397813796997,
-0.04970494657754898,
-0.7335600852966309,
0.38371261954307556,
-0.17612439393997192,
-0.5227493047714233,
0.2576836049556732,
-0.22466377913951874,
-1.0737091302871704,
0.9570235013961792,
0.24514949321746826,
-0.2904413640499115,
-0.013530367985367775,
0.1249367743730545,
0.5900481343269348,
-0.285213828086853,
0.1197456568479538,
0.5559282302856445,
-0.056476496160030365,
0.44626495242118835,
-1.0215575695037842,
-0.2013317346572876,
-0.4491539001464844,
0.3466910719871521,
0.23808467388153076,
-0.3772999346256256,
0.8412923812866211,
-0.10358855128288269,
-0.53736811876297,
0.37276408076286316,
0.9489650726318359,
0.2142133265733719,
0.26009559631347656,
0.3258036971092224,
0.5174618363380432,
0.6471530199050903,
0.020139778032898903,
1.070021629333496,
-0.5118803381919861,
0.24533191323280334,
1.0632134675979614,
-0.159092515707016,
1.2128219604492188,
0.29206550121307373,
-0.3778474032878876,
0.08178097009658813,
0.3120783269405365,
0.42979133129119873,
0.6310942769050598,
0.09626410901546478,
-0.4846961200237274,
-0.24515150487422943,
-0.3150060474872589,
-0.5398060083389282,
0.5643854737281799,
0.552529513835907,
-0.10563234239816666,
-0.1355365663766861,
0.09813818335533142,
-0.3060736358165741,
0.26753440499305725,
-0.9498919248580933,
0.8301616311073303,
0.20667524635791779,
-0.13486583530902863,
1.1513389348983765,
0.11284755170345306,
0.7600961327552795,
-0.6815651059150696,
0.03088359907269478,
-0.14203545451164246,
0.30781230330467224,
-0.37559476494789124,
-0.2552620470523834,
0.46901699900627136,
0.3354107439517975,
-0.4240846633911133,
-0.05143541842699051,
0.8989704847335815,
-0.6683332920074463,
-0.6043325066566467,
-0.0590599961578846,
0.3186028003692627,
0.29281362891197205,
0.11942153424024582,
-0.45561903715133667,
0.1496180146932602,
0.23576775193214417,
0.38526850938796997,
0.26057499647140503,
0.02979503758251667,
0.23614902794361115,
0.4231281578540802,
0.7369667291641235,
0.26698964834213257,
0.050629716366529465,
-0.1293318122625351,
0.7673280835151672,
-0.5690581202507019,
-0.6734583377838135,
-0.7286797761917114,
0.45265674591064453,
-0.053036388009786606,
0.14378111064434052,
0.7255556583404541,
0.6837659478187561,
0.588341474533081,
-0.003310747677460313,
0.6570214629173279,
0.027031073346734047,
0.877194881439209,
-0.7667558193206787,
0.7520581483840942,
-0.43967050313949585,
0.48412948846817017,
-0.10846037417650223,
-0.6652182936668396,
-0.10447633266448975,
0.7867335677146912,
-0.0785437747836113,
-0.03431711345911026,
0.39809632301330566,
0.847218930721283,
0.04245175048708916,
-0.1430414766073227,
0.6017761826515198,
0.16849930584430695,
-0.15323251485824585,
0.34850016236305237,
0.7733253836631775,
-0.7058382034301758,
0.6693323254585266,
-0.3040755093097687,
-0.3072846531867981,
-0.028544262051582336,
-0.456325888633728,
-0.5837843418121338,
-0.46460363268852234,
-0.14164257049560547,
-0.6050797700881958,
-0.0605284683406353,
1.0707941055297852,
0.3127809762954712,
-0.8673762679100037,
-0.5627289414405823,
-0.004789209924638271,
0.10334016382694244,
0.05249482020735741,
-0.13033634424209595,
0.1962939351797104,
-0.17713050544261932,
-0.6187373995780945,
0.6349709033966064,
0.025968242436647415,
0.20924492180347443,
0.04521428421139717,
-0.5086653828620911,
-0.17805080115795135,
-0.025953641161322594,
0.6142719984054565,
0.7514622807502747,
-0.5402616858482361,
-0.008138789795339108,
-0.06291210651397705,
-0.0036728198174387217,
0.20397520065307617,
0.7210447788238525,
-0.6825248003005981,
0.4683099687099457,
0.5260282158851624,
0.5302663445472717,
0.5014851689338684,
0.1608632206916809,
0.1885831654071808,
-0.9560516476631165,
0.4934249222278595,
0.24523811042308807,
0.4851669371128082,
0.6491444706916809,
-0.29451581835746765,
0.24780669808387756,
0.2935285270214081,
-0.12147893011569977,
-1.1234798431396484,
0.2724904417991638,
-0.941830039024353,
0.17994986474514008,
1.025356411933899,
0.25687316060066223,
-0.4471853971481323,
-0.03422419726848602,
-0.22901785373687744,
0.33493250608444214,
-0.3686370849609375,
0.3640438914299011,
0.4587319493293762,
-0.27814698219299316,
-0.46570295095443726,
-0.2360634058713913,
0.8986139893531799,
0.13228213787078857,
-0.5186893343925476,
0.11105018854141235,
0.5888664722442627,
0.16408179700374603,
0.5052964687347412,
1.140803337097168,
-0.01425420306622982,
0.3911599814891815,
0.4166804552078247,
0.27967673540115356,
-0.11967098712921143,
-0.15007995069026947,
-0.674443781375885,
-0.10586071014404297,
0.4067223072052002,
-0.3255627453327179
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10900v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10900v1
|
BEnQA: A Question Answering and Reasoning Benchmark for Bengali and English
| 2024-03-16T11:27:42 | 2024-03-16T11:27:42 |
Sheikh Shafayat, H M Quamran Hasan, Minhajur Rahman Chowdhury Mahim, Rifki Afina Putri, James Thorne, Alice Oh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this study, we introduce BEnQA, a dataset comprising parallel Bengali and
English exam questions for middle and high school levels in Bangladesh. Our
dataset consists of approximately 5K questions covering several subjects in
science with different types of questions, including factual, application, and
reasoning-based questions. We benchmark several Large Language Models (LLMs)
with our parallel dataset and observe a notable performance disparity between
the models in Bengali and English. We also investigate some prompting methods,
and find that Chain-of-Thought prompting is beneficial mostly on reasoning
questions, but not so much on factual ones. We also find that appending English
translation helps to answer questions in Bengali. Our findings point to
promising future research directions for improving the performance of LLMs in
Bengali and more generally in low-resource languages.
|
[
-0.47117915749549866,
-0.8671728372573853,
0.42679423093795776,
0.2625730633735657,
-0.007881165482103825,
0.04593249037861824,
0.09068886190652847,
-0.5015075206756592,
-0.03594078868627548,
0.40618517994880676,
-0.4752657115459442,
-0.0663532093167305,
-0.36562085151672363,
0.5957337021827698,
-0.4456004202365875,
0.5199679732322693,
-0.13575734198093414,
0.4996328055858612,
-0.4183413088321686,
-0.23726804554462433,
-0.6733155250549316,
-0.33361896872520447,
-0.8128918409347534,
-0.2546086013317108,
0.8207504153251648,
0.2742304801940918,
0.4071178734302521,
0.4730093777179718,
0.3825334906578064,
0.26965710520744324,
-0.15192797780036926,
0.2838754951953888,
-0.036453645676374435,
0.298276424407959,
-0.8734530210494995,
-0.6965145468711853,
0.1933615505695343,
-0.21250683069229126,
0.8490676879882812,
1.071397304534912,
0.23203638195991516,
0.4194057583808899,
-0.08425042033195496,
0.7633044719696045,
-0.7623718976974487,
-0.06965316087007523,
-0.45161646604537964,
-0.503606915473938,
-0.21956132352352142,
-0.085068479180336,
-0.12688662111759186,
-0.6647843718528748,
-0.07514441013336182,
-0.06937125325202942,
-0.0212493147701025,
0.42715755105018616,
0.9303926229476929,
0.34048575162887573,
-0.5885133743286133,
-0.10025058686733246,
-0.24989520013332367,
0.9335557818412781,
-0.31163182854652405,
0.45051735639572144,
0.45799025893211365,
0.6032005548477173,
0.01668042130768299,
-0.4391258955001831,
-0.6972928643226624,
0.07223014533519745,
0.03327568992972374,
0.23851197957992554,
-0.09257035702466965,
-0.13890759646892548,
0.17399616539478302,
0.18707214295864105,
-0.8205995559692383,
-0.1408197581768036,
-0.6835139989852905,
-0.050653595477342606,
0.5463191866874695,
0.3241822123527527,
0.1809842586517334,
-0.45449545979499817,
-0.289928138256073,
-0.03508969396352768,
-0.9001939296722412,
0.3333028256893158,
0.45134395360946655,
0.4250049889087677,
-0.0483805276453495,
0.5772855877876282,
-0.480790913105011,
1.0353326797485352,
-0.22624267637729645,
0.36446353793144226,
-0.13782285153865814,
-0.5389673113822937,
-0.10730530321598053,
0.013535389676690102,
0.23666943609714508,
0.16213609278202057,
0.40206798911094666,
0.23036257922649384,
0.08163277059793472,
0.09716733545064926,
-0.03488083556294441,
-0.719224214553833,
-0.11770549416542053,
0.538956344127655,
-0.2863931953907013,
0.41802388429641724,
-0.25594621896743774,
-0.7498942613601685,
-0.3658386766910553,
-0.4522233009338379,
0.5095694065093994,
-0.18029005825519562,
-0.1363270878791809,
0.2560272812843323,
-0.1441051959991455,
0.46783506870269775,
0.2986641228199005,
-0.9569445252418518,
0.3596176505088806,
0.6625382304191589,
0.48701104521751404,
-0.12495836615562439,
-0.47753092646598816,
-0.4482051730155945,
0.02323395386338234,
-0.5340887904167175,
1.0522514581680298,
-0.6270751953125,
-0.12216547131538391,
0.09221067279577255,
-0.029595276340842247,
-0.23357532918453217,
-0.792672872543335,
0.4730064272880554,
-0.6688025593757629,
0.18812240660190582,
-0.9140113592147827,
-0.4290839433670044,
-0.3909771740436554,
0.5795902609825134,
-0.6145772933959961,
1.1396452188491821,
0.10105384886264801,
-0.8573236465454102,
-0.04988594725728035,
-0.4199011027812958,
-0.3901416063308716,
0.15160274505615234,
-0.4517558515071869,
0.399377703666687,
-0.04455512762069702,
0.5728364586830139,
0.5546004176139832,
-0.9722819924354553,
0.2749658524990082,
0.14038604497909546,
-0.7000577449798584,
0.386303573846817,
-0.5364575982093811,
1.0969431400299072,
0.24774044752120972,
-0.06522344797849655,
-0.17203037440776825,
-0.6855413913726807,
0.25400465726852417,
-0.1078675165772438,
-0.3719201385974884,
-0.3871336281299591,
-0.06106569990515709,
-0.07328774780035019,
0.1406051516532898,
0.23333458602428436,
-0.6999584436416626,
0.01423943042755127,
-0.34330087900161743,
0.24218091368675232,
0.5446435213088989,
0.1846057027578354,
-0.22686411440372467,
-0.7458187341690063,
0.5079995393753052,
0.18028947710990906,
-0.13176856935024261,
-0.09528927505016327,
-0.674936830997467,
-0.6359091997146606,
-0.27048465609550476,
0.6051431894302368,
0.7419447898864746,
-0.830500602722168,
-0.006476965267211199,
-0.10447115451097488,
-0.4234066903591156,
-1.010222315788269,
-0.047404129058122635,
0.588310182094574,
0.7094306349754333,
0.4985094368457794,
0.024281634017825127,
-0.4638376832008362,
-1.1575639247894287,
-0.5360787510871887,
-0.41370823979377747,
-0.09925922006368637,
0.14793911576271057,
0.7499008774757385,
0.12459055334329605,
0.7371954917907715,
-0.2808796167373657,
0.6320238709449768,
-0.2617607116699219,
-0.020909642800688744,
0.27599772810935974,
0.24649393558502197,
0.40119504928588867,
-1.1611838340759277,
-0.38652732968330383,
-0.28952401876449585,
-0.5957826972007751,
-0.45206111669540405,
0.06317447870969772,
-0.32433268427848816,
0.3330676555633545,
0.21794921159744263,
-0.5212012529373169,
0.2552877962589264,
0.6659731864929199,
-0.2337792068719864,
0.8969895839691162,
0.1327313482761383,
0.7145655155181885,
-1.3307620286941528,
0.09562215954065323,
-0.11521890759468079,
0.056141868233680725,
-0.33772796392440796,
0.14253218472003937,
0.21827556192874908,
0.00009041163866641,
-0.6655526161193848,
1.1010538339614868,
-0.2360127568244934,
-0.16785630583763123,
-0.027824262157082558,
0.1531018316745758,
0.15727707743644714,
0.21028579771518707,
-0.013518312014639378,
1.0900765657424927,
0.6158484816551208,
-0.5158101320266724,
0.5354194045066833,
0.35451698303222656,
-0.6817649602890015,
0.7147231101989746,
-0.8596513271331787,
-0.24382857978343964,
-0.07778450101613998,
0.05332053452730179,
-1.1929537057876587,
-0.39236652851104736,
-0.137632355093956,
-0.417893648147583,
-0.04838840290904045,
0.10543783754110336,
-0.6177096962928772,
-0.4724677503108978,
-0.09728015214204788,
0.6500981450080872,
0.3978413939476013,
-0.7888613343238831,
0.28680065274238586,
-0.03055925853550434,
-0.5237446427345276,
-0.81816565990448,
-0.8629499077796936,
-0.18236921727657318,
-0.06364655494689941,
-0.5112848281860352,
0.010552020743489265,
-0.30180683732032776,
-0.5382325649261475,
0.14612126350402832,
-0.12086409330368042,
-0.35464128851890564,
-0.18374627828598022,
0.13468703627586365,
0.31492969393730164,
-0.10697586089372635,
0.23299889266490936,
0.2513783276081085,
0.0836159810423851,
0.2943301200866699,
-0.03509775176644325,
0.4721764326095581,
-0.19276833534240723,
-0.4025048017501831,
-0.37751495838165283,
0.8023130893707275,
0.4979652762413025,
-0.16033487021923065,
0.6170573234558105,
0.04598001018166542,
-0.5286622643470764,
-0.2753641903400421,
-0.6780479550361633,
-0.17029643058776855,
-0.4792240262031555,
0.32583093643188477,
-0.6707400679588318,
-0.8723717331886292,
0.6779020428657532,
-0.03870443254709244,
-0.11440058052539825,
0.15297146141529083,
0.8336641788482666,
-0.2956421971321106,
0.8900244235992432,
0.20986200869083405,
-0.08750239759683609,
-0.13880358636379242,
0.10050816833972931,
0.2525183856487274,
-0.5602564811706543,
-0.23149040341377258,
-0.8862057328224182,
-0.19281749427318573,
-0.684413731098175,
-0.4734348654747009,
0.23367911577224731,
0.2950638234615326,
-0.598733127117157,
0.24480921030044556,
-0.32780879735946655,
0.596379280090332,
0.8308632969856262,
-0.04628422483801842,
0.14790385961532593,
-0.2088412642478943,
-0.22518368065357208,
0.046648088842630386,
-0.7665565609931946,
-0.44793277978897095,
0.8489634394645691,
-0.12600524723529816,
0.5045916438102722,
0.23748493194580078,
0.5894412398338318,
0.04833221808075905,
-0.06537610292434692,
-0.33862555027008057,
0.8206877708435059,
0.11349529772996902,
-1.2111904621124268,
-0.28145989775657654,
-0.5859142541885376,
-0.9416672587394714,
0.2544463872909546,
0.0828133374452591,
-0.6153842210769653,
0.14988645911216736,
-0.02588544227182865,
-0.3189176023006439,
0.22670651972293854,
-0.5909969210624695,
0.5383706092834473,
-0.12869594991207123,
-0.6985030174255371,
-0.2235531508922577,
-0.5927535891532898,
0.3542385399341583,
-0.10992075502872467,
0.10812664031982422,
-0.12583382427692413,
0.02622661553323269,
0.7448164224624634,
-0.08683937788009644,
0.4850327670574188,
0.01518742274492979,
0.26900535821914673,
0.5213961005210876,
-0.03176593407988548,
0.04217667505145073,
0.08557762205600739,
-0.3810216188430786,
0.08150664716959,
0.5939226746559143,
-1.0529608726501465,
-0.7753099203109741,
0.6384519934654236,
-0.7305383682250977,
-0.8244150876998901,
-0.49712398648262024,
-0.9841057658195496,
-0.5928308367729187,
-0.0037356382235884666,
-0.020241500809788704,
0.43674376606941223,
0.3253142237663269,
0.2624348998069763,
0.6444936990737915,
-0.4055815041065216,
0.394714891910553,
0.5042797327041626,
-0.08330953866243362,
-0.4424801170825958,
0.6688187122344971,
0.3699638247489929,
0.18726038932800293,
0.4356660544872284,
0.2662803530693054,
-0.6344916224479675,
-0.5810834765434265,
-0.5099913477897644,
0.4438188374042511,
-0.7099037170410156,
-0.19452175498008728,
-0.38474783301353455,
-0.37717404961586,
-0.4009730815887451,
-0.2892703711986542,
-0.17328545451164246,
-0.40795108675956726,
0.42065760493278503,
0.09217940270900726,
0.29632842540740967,
0.6082677245140076,
0.08145409822463989,
-0.2432807981967926,
-0.8440039753913879,
0.2301451563835144,
0.6131346225738525,
0.16361087560653687,
-0.1427989900112152,
-0.460915207862854,
-0.1546846628189087,
-0.06485534459352493,
-0.052707623690366745,
-0.9342259168624878,
0.02771526761353016,
-0.28840479254722595,
0.5898577570915222,
0.030687788501381874,
0.21719002723693848,
0.6516481041908264,
-0.27997249364852905,
1.1273150444030762,
-0.0007224294822663069,
-0.8851599097251892,
0.5339445471763611,
-0.5186234712600708,
0.6845115423202515,
0.7586023211479187,
1.0374515056610107,
-0.5758255124092102,
-0.0021280269138514996,
-0.07825051993131638,
-0.45450320839881897,
0.1744823455810547,
0.044524647295475006,
-0.016766829416155815,
-0.1696230173110962,
0.3723998963832855,
0.1542467176914215,
0.42066583037376404,
-0.33706527948379517,
-0.17018502950668335,
0.07297473400831223,
-0.357376366853714,
0.14044958353042603,
-0.151267871260643,
-0.15818803012371063,
-0.6315711736679077,
0.646802544593811,
-0.041259851306676865,
0.13570944964885712,
0.13521701097488403,
0.29879122972488403,
0.10036293417215347,
0.42423442006111145,
0.28796324133872986,
0.7305036783218384,
-0.06517592817544937,
0.038285139948129654,
0.3488145172595978,
-0.3676912486553192,
0.1509792059659958,
0.1889752894639969,
-0.2595764100551605,
-0.21944878995418549,
0.4424700140953064,
0.3164668679237366,
0.015593798831105232,
-1.080325961112976,
0.18839295208454132,
0.1308741420507431,
-0.3609320819377899,
0.14704293012619019,
-0.00039888155879452825,
0.2402234971523285,
0.5240663290023804,
0.5568955540657043,
-0.29303476214408875,
0.1044943630695343,
-0.7132337689399719,
0.06224583461880684,
0.03325072303414345,
0.015391362830996513,
-0.13970445096492767,
0.5605790019035339,
0.18976958096027374,
-0.2819262146949768,
0.5289797186851501,
0.02409719116985798,
-0.5869387984275818,
0.6248941421508789,
0.49476292729377747,
0.5186372399330139,
-0.2857967019081116,
0.18210093677043915,
0.5181443691253662,
0.30879920721054077,
0.01022981759160757,
1.2011082172393799,
-0.137645423412323,
-0.6395595669746399,
-0.5705664157867432,
-0.7066339254379272,
-0.995177149772644,
0.21294794976711273,
-0.7180637717247009,
0.11533413082361221,
-0.2733677625656128,
0.08762127161026001,
0.040633730590343475,
0.6014860272407532,
-0.6917060613632202,
0.49960485100746155,
-0.13717029988765717,
1.235105037689209,
-0.8411232233047485,
0.8619073629379272,
1.0387797355651855,
-0.3821701109409332,
-1.0253844261169434,
-0.0877440869808197,
-0.05715860426425934,
-0.5009871125221252,
0.7133084535598755,
0.18726620078086853,
-0.15771906077861786,
0.022185076028108597,
-0.48290982842445374,
-0.8689046502113342,
0.7894850969314575,
0.3236665725708008,
-0.5151269435882568,
0.06853431463241577,
0.37600618600845337,
0.40388959646224976,
-0.12810246646404266,
0.3968672752380371,
0.6633444428443909,
0.6439557671546936,
-0.00815107673406601,
-0.6837767958641052,
-0.030738022178411484,
-0.567607581615448,
-0.07940280437469482,
-0.0261532049626112,
-0.8647760152816772,
0.9735572934150696,
0.11476732045412064,
0.024791505187749863,
0.22178088128566742,
0.5738439559936523,
0.7409798502922058,
0.36898893117904663,
0.12170889973640442,
0.26534581184387207,
0.8015756607055664,
-0.3110821545124054,
0.966541051864624,
-0.3246619403362274,
-0.22113382816314697,
1.0503966808319092,
-0.5935418605804443,
1.1319247484207153,
0.6443427205085754,
-0.35747769474983215,
0.542023241519928,
1.0284984111785889,
0.14988994598388672,
0.3970359265804291,
0.438245564699173,
-0.30414173007011414,
-0.27306994795799255,
-0.392287939786911,
-0.39252036809921265,
0.46709221601486206,
0.25699520111083984,
0.3415813446044922,
-0.2164773792028427,
0.042449552565813065,
-0.3066423237323761,
0.5699065923690796,
-0.5088152289390564,
0.06643220782279968,
-0.11043209582567215,
-0.9206640720367432,
0.7928022742271423,
-0.2929837107658386,
0.3783324062824249,
-0.5565518140792847,
-0.08294940739870071,
-0.5819000601768494,
-0.0913252905011177,
0.10373908281326294,
-0.8409910202026367,
0.43622562289237976,
0.08744759112596512,
-0.3722890317440033,
0.02420256845653057,
0.39041537046432495,
-0.5126615166664124,
-0.42506489157676697,
0.3358563482761383,
0.691008985042572,
0.4939059913158417,
0.23836606740951538,
-0.7160466313362122,
0.1696600615978241,
-0.3128257393836975,
-0.3376462161540985,
0.2155144363641739,
0.40002739429473877,
-0.2624569237232208,
0.8388938307762146,
0.3932214081287384,
0.33724310994148254,
0.26894792914390564,
0.045702822506427765,
0.6936469674110413,
-0.6968974471092224,
-0.2808692455291748,
-0.3731614351272583,
0.4152372479438782,
-0.13132061064243317,
-0.4464241862297058,
0.9621149897575378,
0.5459538102149963,
1.1521601676940918,
0.0474972128868103,
0.8895659446716309,
0.07279065996408463,
0.9333186745643616,
-0.43541136384010315,
0.595751166343689,
-0.6165130734443665,
-0.056230686604976654,
-0.05171086639165878,
-0.9990190267562866,
-0.11086586862802505,
0.17742003500461578,
-0.40953919291496277,
0.17332549393177032,
0.9692065715789795,
1.025131106376648,
0.28534188866615295,
0.3197217583656311,
0.5818759202957153,
-0.01801188476383686,
-0.20414362847805023,
0.8049843907356262,
1.105211853981018,
-0.6277741193771362,
0.28155866265296936,
0.0024992339313030243,
-0.01112714596092701,
0.15848025679588318,
-0.5078795552253723,
-1.2269103527069092,
-0.8140618801116943,
-0.15025758743286133,
-0.15161211788654327,
0.5752590894699097,
0.8593214154243469,
0.5997142195701599,
-1.0218876600265503,
-0.29730039834976196,
0.09498056769371033,
0.07213553786277771,
-0.3934672176837921,
-0.16089661419391632,
0.5484008193016052,
-0.06760583817958832,
-1.0200978517532349,
0.5259236693382263,
0.023811109364032745,
-0.09081218391656876,
-0.3333986699581146,
0.09992102533578873,
-0.7141069769859314,
0.8387695550918579,
0.32897108793258667,
0.4207017123699188,
-0.6632291078567505,
-0.42880892753601074,
-0.03384780511260033,
-0.1166614219546318,
-0.3340531289577484,
0.5150030255317688,
-0.7986506223678589,
0.42835158109664917,
0.8567831516265869,
1.1863925457000732,
0.257742702960968,
0.2229621261358261,
0.2948437035083771,
-0.5606204867362976,
0.038754284381866455,
0.2586671710014343,
0.18933376669883728,
0.4104810059070587,
-0.040210433304309845,
0.5005766749382019,
0.12876373529434204,
-0.6309365034103394,
-0.9105250239372253,
0.2516250014305115,
-0.7068732380867004,
-0.5668469071388245,
0.8937522768974304,
-0.0991838127374649,
-0.3663279712200165,
-0.44129621982574463,
-0.0032421115320175886,
0.1685398519039154,
0.09319856762886047,
0.7682127356529236,
0.9894911050796509,
-0.12109984457492828,
-0.28969863057136536,
-0.800489068031311,
0.20497022569179535,
0.9784373044967651,
-0.8427119851112366,
0.027552198618650436,
0.39295700192451477,
0.09728854149580002,
-0.06435994803905487,
0.4820224344730377,
0.08313356339931488,
0.592248260974884,
0.29113897681236267,
-0.13577844202518463,
-0.025507090613245964,
-0.7416971921920776,
-0.3222157657146454,
0.3011537492275238,
-0.32980817556381226,
-0.24078655242919922
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10894v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10894v1
|
Towards Robustness and Diversity: Continual Learning in Dialog Generation with Text-Mixup and Batch Nuclear-Norm Maximization
| 2024-03-16T11:09:27 | 2024-03-16T11:09:27 |
Zihan Wang, Jiayu Xiao, Mengxiang Li, Zhongjiang He, Yongxiang Li, Chao Wang, Shuangyong Song
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In our dynamic world where data arrives in a continuous stream, continual
learning enables us to incrementally add new tasks/domains without the need to
retrain from scratch. A major challenge in continual learning of language model
is catastrophic forgetting, the tendency of models to forget knowledge from
previously trained tasks/domains when training on new ones. This paper studies
dialog generation under the continual learning setting. We propose a novel
method that 1) uses \textit{Text-Mixup} as data augmentation to avoid model
overfitting on replay memory and 2) leverages Batch-Nuclear Norm Maximization
(BNNM) to alleviate the problem of mode collapse. Experiments on a $37$-domain
task-oriented dialog dataset and DailyDialog (a $10$-domain chitchat dataset)
demonstrate that our proposed approach outperforms the state-of-the-art in
continual learning.
|
[
-0.34930217266082764,
-0.8551778197288513,
0.29689672589302063,
-0.04234151169657707,
-0.323517382144928,
0.2888023853302002,
-0.33638888597488403,
-0.26557657122612,
-0.2666069567203522,
0.49168112874031067,
-0.79847651720047,
-0.2825216054916382,
-0.29420438408851624,
0.23648937046527863,
-0.0722554624080658,
1.0637834072113037,
0.2420666664838791,
0.1667063683271408,
-0.2719327211380005,
-0.2777515947818756,
-1.0908687114715576,
-0.49187251925468445,
-0.9985111951828003,
-0.4265812933444977,
0.18565642833709717,
0.267179399728775,
0.7054522037506104,
0.3396790623664856,
0.01105798315256834,
0.3111267387866974,
0.03645669296383858,
0.5597862601280212,
-0.760308027267456,
0.7129719853401184,
-0.2684295177459717,
-0.48662200570106506,
-0.3030712902545929,
-0.241180881857872,
1.0248855352401733,
0.9165500998497009,
0.004018824081867933,
-0.39051511883735657,
0.3362456262111664,
0.4340059459209442,
-0.28621771931648254,
0.008600866422057152,
-1.0840959548950195,
0.10939585417509079,
0.15633055567741394,
-0.3692871034145355,
-0.47720494866371155,
-0.28319939970970154,
0.08079007267951965,
-0.4221843183040619,
0.11552468687295914,
0.13204960525035858,
0.8330668807029724,
0.28225278854370117,
-0.39050206542015076,
-0.3570857644081116,
-0.837191641330719,
1.1432898044586182,
-0.692790687084198,
0.44537684321403503,
0.4630666971206665,
0.1916581094264984,
-0.35623079538345337,
-0.32136085629463196,
-0.4384387731552124,
-0.16984649002552032,
0.3437216877937317,
0.2575739622116089,
-0.18339155614376068,
-0.002299519721418619,
-0.007656959351152182,
0.47053197026252747,
-0.5802035927772522,
-0.08128733187913895,
-0.24276675283908844,
-0.3261679410934448,
0.1987234503030777,
0.46723508834838867,
0.573452889919281,
-0.1473640352487564,
-0.27125102281570435,
0.12427076697349548,
-0.6669442057609558,
-0.3528635501861572,
0.08858981728553772,
0.32881659269332886,
0.10360877960920334,
0.04952225834131241,
0.04850137606263161,
0.7151355743408203,
0.16500693559646606,
-0.17942358553409576,
0.07148057222366333,
-0.735154926776886,
-0.4439683258533478,
-0.31235992908477783,
0.5781606435775757,
0.35363659262657166,
0.05825110897421837,
-0.29264381527900696,
-0.24543698132038116,
-0.08282297104597092,
0.5547285079956055,
-0.5509401559829712,
-0.1347641497850418,
0.1682761311531067,
-0.31453874707221985,
-0.42309314012527466,
-0.3087611198425293,
-0.6811808943748474,
0.08688446134328842,
-0.45378604531288147,
0.3660869300365448,
-0.7231869101524353,
-0.18177126348018646,
-0.19190376996994019,
0.07457348704338074,
-0.22559110820293427,
0.4552146792411804,
-0.5875422954559326,
0.32964465022087097,
0.44923606514930725,
0.8134070634841919,
-0.248202845454216,
-0.22952258586883545,
-0.6247900724411011,
0.05540739372372627,
-0.34868451952934265,
0.4173983037471771,
-0.536510705947876,
-0.7126651406288147,
-0.14760352671146393,
-0.13281552493572235,
-0.27161940932273865,
-1.041739821434021,
-0.009426168166100979,
-0.4110463261604309,
0.5965360999107361,
-0.20683695375919342,
-0.6105927228927612,
-0.11368110030889511,
0.4984532594680786,
-0.5452155470848083,
1.093584656715393,
0.25469139218330383,
-0.463783323764801,
0.6962687969207764,
-0.18120664358139038,
-0.221424862742424,
0.24679353833198547,
-0.2572631239891052,
-0.635059118270874,
-0.13126328587532043,
-0.08948881179094315,
0.3168081045150757,
-0.11700206249952316,
0.6478513479232788,
-0.35802239179611206,
-0.07518163323402405,
0.3348729908466339,
-0.6516627669334412,
0.7091994285583496,
0.1658967286348343,
-0.319394052028656,
-0.04082033038139343,
-0.6049137711524963,
-0.20252272486686707,
-0.02946529909968376,
-0.47515007853507996,
-0.2798803448677063,
-0.06394319236278534,
0.020322103053331375,
0.37655535340309143,
0.0003170818672515452,
-0.20650018751621246,
0.06526655703783035,
-0.11322174966335297,
0.3395610749721527,
0.8581218719482422,
0.3807761073112488,
0.3486923575401306,
-1.0459485054016113,
0.49979981780052185,
0.2610938251018524,
-0.029259543865919113,
-0.5978713035583496,
-0.4157087504863739,
-0.821243166923523,
-0.25419723987579346,
0.07564211636781693,
0.6908875703811646,
-0.9686271548271179,
0.5753076076507568,
-0.189854234457016,
-0.06770548969507217,
0.2633489668369293,
0.6208317279815674,
0.2543124854564667,
0.5567785501480103,
0.26717236638069153,
-0.5824440717697144,
-0.7929732203483582,
-0.4325602054595947,
0.12170400470495224,
-0.1396094262599945,
-0.09987729787826538,
0.4365445077419281,
0.3987416923046112,
-0.5433816313743591,
0.954916775226593,
0.11518502980470657,
0.06617510318756104,
-0.5465434193611145,
0.14397980272769928,
-0.20235759019851685,
0.7698538303375244,
0.4515400826931,
-0.7863566875457764,
-0.2672957181930542,
-0.07627027481794357,
-0.8285548686981201,
0.19111207127571106,
-0.7661793231964111,
-0.11318594217300415,
0.35677793622016907,
0.3695862293243408,
-0.38450026512145996,
0.08474820852279663,
0.29712602496147156,
-0.03235945850610733,
0.6088530421257019,
0.0025850150268524885,
0.024350037798285484,
-1.4484245777130127,
-0.17035707831382751,
-0.06051065772771835,
-0.6556116342544556,
-0.7116765379905701,
-0.2509627342224121,
-0.2814560830593109,
-0.20845913887023926,
-0.08718185871839523,
0.49508869647979736,
-0.3875962793827057,
0.4395483434200287,
-0.3576575219631195,
0.0815199762582779,
-0.1638028919696808,
0.499505877494812,
-0.09918881207704544,
0.6769439578056335,
0.4874352216720581,
-0.8359034061431885,
0.027170579880475998,
0.24012398719787598,
0.033151619136333466,
0.6663839817047119,
-0.484679251909256,
-0.006903198082000017,
-0.1520327478647232,
0.4076305329799652,
-0.9279192686080933,
-0.47823938727378845,
0.2506709098815918,
-0.42595162987709045,
0.7113267183303833,
-0.0032215567771345377,
-0.25873270630836487,
0.10685059428215027,
-0.20229150354862213,
0.4850144386291504,
0.6748360395431519,
-0.4085492789745331,
0.6327009797096252,
0.4044117033481598,
-0.41681548953056335,
-0.41622409224510193,
-0.5451145768165588,
0.22638311982154846,
-0.2225092649459839,
-0.5740688443183899,
0.03689107671380043,
-0.30619046092033386,
-0.2375524789094925,
-0.13769559562206268,
-0.4880130887031555,
-0.2137657105922699,
-0.02669169008731842,
0.31296539306640625,
0.47432032227516174,
-0.08333496004343033,
0.18910075724124908,
0.17457033693790436,
0.13168273866176605,
-0.0459107868373394,
-0.48925188183784485,
0.8394556641578674,
-0.16097021102905273,
-0.12402018159627914,
-0.39046117663383484,
0.5501571893692017,
0.5107277035713196,
0.4043716490268707,
0.6860902309417725,
0.40996503829956055,
-0.43875792622566223,
-0.5109227895736694,
-0.5656067132949829,
-0.3145351707935333,
-0.4947441816329956,
0.26923900842666626,
0.005256009288132191,
-1.220603108406067,
0.5490530133247375,
-0.2272304892539978,
0.29634949564933777,
0.23235265910625458,
0.6868320107460022,
-0.15620853006839752,
0.5009515881538391,
0.6249622106552124,
-0.04810405895113945,
0.6417905688285828,
-0.05178844556212425,
0.05114351212978363,
-0.6178157925605774,
-0.10985782742500305,
-0.11812282353639603,
0.025819698348641396,
-0.3463125228881836,
-0.5127591490745544,
0.30524128675460815,
0.12540064752101898,
-0.11677121371030807,
0.2032572627067566,
-0.24048906564712524,
0.24146094918251038,
0.18789514899253845,
0.19076019525527954,
0.249927818775177,
0.07086805999279022,
-0.18099404871463776,
-0.27736687660217285,
-1.0483821630477905,
-0.30930814146995544,
1.133156657218933,
0.26237159967422485,
0.459839403629303,
-0.14714983105659485,
0.9149521589279175,
0.38373249769210815,
0.26695919036865234,
-0.6024236679077148,
0.501358687877655,
0.222482830286026,
-0.403958797454834,
-0.10457401722669601,
-0.9100302457809448,
-0.996006965637207,
0.10516410320997238,
-0.15789176523685455,
-0.6699585318565369,
0.19859638810157776,
0.4237149953842163,
-0.10981622338294983,
0.3910023272037506,
-0.1597050428390503,
0.4714227616786957,
0.09047108143568039,
-0.36807772517204285,
-0.2084052413702011,
-0.5513206720352173,
0.4619047939777374,
-0.2725876569747925,
0.3143795132637024,
0.08996937423944473,
0.17060889303684235,
0.4073939025402069,
-0.3655576705932617,
1.1107343435287476,
0.11907627433538437,
0.049940578639507294,
0.20398113131523132,
0.22831028699874878,
0.29902973771095276,
0.2733466327190399,
0.27407172322273254,
0.01309200469404459,
-0.44373682141304016,
-0.5721383094787598,
-0.47575634717941284,
0.5189403891563416,
-0.5674511790275574,
-0.21710269153118134,
-0.3944687843322754,
-0.8008639812469482,
-0.44414907693862915,
0.19206228852272034,
0.400581419467926,
0.9133419990539551,
-0.26802441477775574,
0.34758323431015015,
1.165711522102356,
-0.23060759902000427,
0.270232230424881,
-0.062488872557878494,
-0.13757996261119843,
-0.6337200999259949,
1.11385977268219,
-0.05791652947664261,
0.9197567105293274,
0.07813911885023117,
0.0011632988462224603,
0.03149032220244408,
-0.5356107950210571,
-0.25192227959632874,
-0.014371094293892384,
-0.8241413831710815,
-0.2768256664276123,
-0.886635959148407,
-0.31555381417274475,
-0.09549989551305771,
-0.47904881834983826,
-0.21476371586322784,
-0.35672304034233093,
-0.18883289396762848,
0.15459787845611572,
0.08543183654546738,
0.6488505601882935,
-0.22785744071006775,
0.017372360453009605,
-0.9848361015319824,
0.2604645788669586,
0.48819684982299805,
0.02295612543821335,
0.11878855526447296,
-0.5159876346588135,
-0.13574612140655518,
0.18417887389659882,
-0.40672585368156433,
-0.7277875542640686,
0.3377658724784851,
0.40341460704803467,
0.7515375018119812,
0.29082804918289185,
-0.1265028566122055,
0.3435870110988617,
-0.25816449522972107,
0.9598965644836426,
0.3255966007709503,
-0.9521132707595825,
0.42016103863716125,
-0.8411036133766174,
0.7177398800849915,
0.8368195295333862,
0.281134694814682,
-0.6931992769241333,
-1.0503895282745361,
-0.7055659294128418,
-1.0679410696029663,
0.22726395726203918,
0.4050786793231964,
0.3568442761898041,
-0.30149227380752563,
0.17910674214363098,
0.4069462716579437,
0.35248705744743347,
-0.598420262336731,
-0.14356933534145355,
-0.4471532106399536,
-0.17361216247081757,
0.34580156207084656,
-0.07454504072666168,
-0.1397024542093277,
-0.24130812287330627,
0.839097261428833,
-0.12006212025880814,
0.27768373489379883,
-0.10807345062494278,
-0.2823024392127991,
0.12950335443019867,
0.37966805696487427,
0.7710339426994324,
0.8482235074043274,
-0.23453651368618011,
-0.06586280465126038,
0.42258450388908386,
-0.6864264011383057,
0.0384841226041317,
-0.522431492805481,
-0.27387019991874695,
0.2859381437301636,
0.21245557069778442,
0.6865053176879883,
0.5757725834846497,
-0.6951309442520142,
-0.03267812356352806,
-0.10828275978565216,
-0.31516024470329285,
-0.20159882307052612,
0.3052977919578552,
-0.13256411254405975,
-0.07817684859037399,
0.5157372951507568,
0.5446745157241821,
0.012774803675711155,
-0.7827742099761963,
0.6745542883872986,
0.414407342672348,
-0.3650705814361572,
-0.0017595201497897506,
0.5809491276741028,
0.16801373660564423,
-0.06913050264120102,
0.7118800282478333,
-0.3906242251396179,
-0.696537971496582,
0.49827146530151367,
0.676030695438385,
0.9177078008651733,
-0.1289859116077423,
0.1633024364709854,
0.5372456908226013,
0.21867698431015015,
-0.201838880777359,
0.17714348435401917,
-0.40642049908638,
-0.8281065225601196,
-0.3104686439037323,
-0.3320310711860657,
-0.7251911759376526,
0.2524425983428955,
-0.7184238433837891,
-0.11998230963945389,
-0.8044781684875488,
-0.19496971368789673,
-0.3433578610420227,
-0.12106192111968994,
-0.4251725673675537,
0.4169823229312897,
-0.08406161516904831,
0.4511811435222626,
-0.6225836277008057,
0.7895843386650085,
0.2993220090866089,
-0.32871341705322266,
-0.5671584010124207,
0.28865575790405273,
0.29697248339653015,
-0.4733065068721771,
0.3220583200454712,
0.22071732580661774,
-0.12672975659370422,
-0.3793405294418335,
-0.5482404232025146,
-0.41920241713523865,
0.8713207244873047,
0.07271312922239304,
-0.3389926850795746,
0.06324335932731628,
-0.008060198277235031,
0.21125884354114532,
-0.45543015003204346,
-0.09660604596138,
0.36581936478614807,
0.32704201340675354,
0.24069683253765106,
-0.8076396584510803,
0.07240163534879684,
-0.5748321413993835,
0.19561903178691864,
0.19731193780899048,
-0.547158420085907,
0.756295382976532,
0.26367253065109253,
-0.32420361042022705,
-0.06400161236524582,
0.604296863079071,
0.28723856806755066,
0.25881025195121765,
0.5650919079780579,
0.4041396379470825,
0.9121777415275574,
-0.17972299456596375,
0.7683142423629761,
-0.11135481297969818,
0.4017188847064972,
1.345712423324585,
-0.051975544542074203,
0.3967238664627075,
0.18165062367916107,
0.07561901956796646,
0.417889803647995,
0.5086326003074646,
-0.1174330934882164,
0.25558599829673767,
-0.17713016271591187,
-0.5826326608657837,
-0.5723402500152588,
0.01879964768886566,
-0.21282783150672913,
0.18085241317749023,
0.5341997742652893,
-0.030717862769961357,
-0.4895055294036865,
0.1547439992427826,
0.24750298261642456,
0.16690859198570251,
-0.17258486151695251,
0.8898478150367737,
0.16729779541492462,
-0.5199652910232544,
0.933604896068573,
-0.3606224060058594,
0.9051709771156311,
-0.6442777514457703,
0.05452319607138634,
-0.30420562624931335,
-0.044746335595846176,
-0.083693727850914,
-0.27001434564590454,
0.558392345905304,
-0.24333912134170532,
-0.3735721707344055,
-0.28487345576286316,
0.6248459219932556,
-0.7859413623809814,
-0.3025500476360321,
-0.07965748012065887,
0.2824587821960449,
-0.14165624976158142,
0.2728551924228668,
-0.6516759991645813,
0.3053017258644104,
0.10186589509248734,
0.0766509547829628,
0.5382411479949951,
0.2650928795337677,
-0.015637747943401337,
0.8120261430740356,
0.5565557479858398,
-0.1660437434911728,
0.20193639397621155,
-0.14024442434310913,
0.9962071180343628,
-0.4045460820198059,
-0.4695635139942169,
-0.6094014048576355,
0.5220479369163513,
-0.3412094712257385,
-0.2517283260822296,
0.8058475852012634,
0.4799615442752838,
0.8702170252799988,
0.10225758701562881,
1.1637085676193237,
0.08035077154636383,
0.2951219081878662,
-0.6161292195320129,
0.6726207137107849,
-0.5957438945770264,
0.19477578997612,
-0.22372573614120483,
-0.8061487674713135,
-0.17536661028862,
0.45566388964653015,
0.059451624751091,
0.349737286567688,
0.6776485443115234,
0.6237474083900452,
-0.19695328176021576,
0.14764617383480072,
0.4847724139690399,
-0.048292241990566254,
0.26711905002593994,
0.6455891132354736,
0.6309210062026978,
-0.27188631892204285,
0.31763651967048645,
-0.009618918411433697,
-0.14599725604057312,
-0.2185463309288025,
-0.6451728940010071,
-1.1218034029006958,
-0.6967695951461792,
-0.34522122144699097,
-0.5201722383499146,
0.02547108195722103,
1.0893003940582275,
0.756161630153656,
-0.8605985641479492,
-0.12195141613483429,
-0.2792382836341858,
0.12698641419410706,
-0.1323934942483902,
-0.2531319856643677,
-0.33828437328338623,
-0.9643250703811646,
-0.6595785617828369,
0.6404616236686707,
0.6225942969322205,
0.15958592295646667,
-0.2442474514245987,
-0.08181021362543106,
-0.04887378215789795,
0.3965952396392822,
0.34390953183174133,
0.5712499618530273,
-0.41450732946395874,
-0.12472614645957947,
-0.19010162353515625,
-0.037027716636657715,
0.310116171836853,
0.9409322142601013,
-0.5520835518836975,
0.7401113510131836,
0.26452749967575073,
1.0692015886306763,
0.3391340970993042,
-0.07924122363328934,
1.0254902839660645,
-0.8239062428474426,
0.1817718893289566,
0.42925047874450684,
0.1765396147966385,
0.47459688782691956,
-0.4107078015804291,
0.04977237060666084,
0.3862999677658081,
-0.7372702360153198,
-0.82430499792099,
0.5339781641960144,
-1.1671311855316162,
-0.3399812877178192,
0.8428227305412292,
-0.041656494140625,
-0.0606628879904747,
-0.7167231440544128,
0.0030844539869576693,
0.08033422380685806,
-0.4736790060997009,
0.8349409699440002,
0.7093150615692139,
0.11176358908414841,
-0.27896174788475037,
-0.6391150951385498,
0.6402002573013306,
0.6684784293174744,
-0.9263283014297485,
-0.08081644773483276,
0.7955718040466309,
0.6578295826911926,
0.0026642263401299715,
0.641225278377533,
-0.05627765879034996,
0.6258243918418884,
0.25927144289016724,
-0.39382848143577576,
-0.10491752624511719,
-0.5426957011222839,
-0.3040429353713989,
0.1825680434703827,
-0.12040472775697708,
0.06444966793060303
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10882v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10882v2
|
Optimizing Language Augmentation for Multilingual Large Language Models: A Case Study on Korean
| 2024-03-16T10:26:38 | 2024-03-21T14:50:18 |
ChangSu Choi, Yongbin Jeong, Seoyoon Park, InHo Won, HyeonSeok Lim, SangMin Kim, Yejee Kang, Chanhyuk Yoon, Jaewan Park, Yiseul Lee, HyeJin Lee, Younggyun Hahm, Hansaem Kim, KyungTae Lim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) use pretraining to predict the subsequent word;
however, their expansion requires significant computing resources. Numerous big
tech companies and research institutes have developed multilingual LLMs (MLLMs)
to meet current demands, overlooking less-resourced languages (LRLs). This
study proposed three strategies to enhance the performance of LRLs based on the
publicly available MLLMs. First, the MLLM vocabularies of LRLs were expanded to
enhance expressiveness. Second, bilingual data were used for pretraining to
align the high- and less-resourced languages. Third, a high-quality small-scale
instruction dataset was constructed and instruction-tuning was performed to
augment the LRL. The experiments employed the Llama2 model and Korean was used
as the LRL, which was quantitatively evaluated against other developed LLMs
across eight tasks. Furthermore, a qualitative assessment was performed based
on human evaluation and GPT4. Experimental results showed that our proposed
Bllossom model exhibited superior performance in qualitative analyses compared
to previously proposed Korean monolingual models.
|
[
-0.25566932559013367,
-0.625908374786377,
0.34219691157341003,
0.47441238164901733,
-0.3222338557243347,
0.4197058081626892,
-0.7458940744400024,
-0.543670654296875,
0.12305819243192673,
0.5521318912506104,
-0.5482818484306335,
-0.3901421129703522,
-0.30035749077796936,
0.29576653242111206,
0.23106886446475983,
0.7956393361091614,
-0.12159059941768646,
0.30160558223724365,
-0.20790289342403412,
-0.15708506107330322,
-0.5903599858283997,
-0.610991358757019,
-0.3313154876232147,
-0.564357578754425,
0.5313851237297058,
0.5262253880500793,
0.6185219287872314,
0.5616434812545776,
0.3223399221897125,
0.30918848514556885,
-0.13181231915950775,
0.350367933511734,
-0.6643136143684387,
-0.007080215960741043,
0.05198436602950096,
-0.36528560519218445,
-0.5640354752540588,
-0.18804483115673065,
0.710534393787384,
0.8201487064361572,
-0.09908050298690796,
0.40036749839782715,
0.18443624675273895,
0.6937826871871948,
-0.7497228384017944,
0.11328212171792984,
-0.41249871253967285,
0.0675690621137619,
-0.2799403667449951,
0.05129266157746315,
-0.266709566116333,
-0.43569451570510864,
0.07086194306612015,
-0.5841051936149597,
-0.2563396096229553,
-0.14969563484191895,
0.5271919965744019,
0.2140105962753296,
-0.3002086877822876,
-0.032182659953832626,
-0.7174383401870728,
0.9238290786743164,
-0.769042432308197,
0.7254990935325623,
0.2502110004425049,
0.09419454634189606,
-0.03582381457090378,
-0.45809462666511536,
-0.3399677872657776,
-0.522408664226532,
-0.17020319402217865,
0.08414755016565323,
0.1234382763504982,
0.24438658356666565,
0.32036545872688293,
0.2940351963043213,
-0.6947137713432312,
0.6556920409202576,
-0.29877564311027527,
-0.2932296395301819,
0.7095745205879211,
0.10875183343887329,
0.17997249960899353,
-0.08576542884111404,
-0.259024441242218,
-0.009356463328003883,
-0.7846092581748962,
0.10958345979452133,
0.4367729127407074,
0.5176525712013245,
-0.16875730454921722,
0.8293519616127014,
-0.25653669238090515,
0.74430251121521,
-0.03375793620944023,
-0.3767719566822052,
0.5082460045814514,
-0.675434947013855,
-0.1269914209842682,
0.17169871926307678,
0.48775070905685425,
0.15305282175540924,
0.37245121598243713,
-0.22457736730575562,
-0.21452632546424866,
-0.07226142287254333,
0.06893573701381683,
-0.8554417490959167,
0.11546960473060608,
0.09114611893892288,
-0.4061499238014221,
-0.01487731747329235,
-0.27134808897972107,
-0.6337202191352844,
-0.43401187658309937,
-0.5875992774963379,
0.411167174577713,
-0.11656361818313599,
-0.4337487518787384,
0.012273278087377548,
0.2945186197757721,
-0.11486104875802994,
0.12752659618854523,
-0.635194718837738,
-0.044367946684360504,
0.5742023587226868,
0.7271362543106079,
-0.3400155007839203,
-0.3856937885284424,
-0.3514166474342346,
0.11213002353906631,
-0.4873763620853424,
0.4027324616909027,
-0.4652934968471527,
-0.37976133823394775,
0.15680882334709167,
0.0310185756534338,
0.0515434667468071,
-0.6522150039672852,
0.5650207996368408,
-0.6503564715385437,
0.20351442694664001,
-0.13312090933322906,
-0.5144630670547485,
-0.11018925905227661,
0.16917259991168976,
-0.8672117590904236,
1.2040950059890747,
0.3038841187953949,
-0.4821096658706665,
0.19440831243991852,
-0.7720211148262024,
-0.615537166595459,
0.2135351598262787,
0.0022418166045099497,
-0.15204834938049316,
0.29470095038414,
0.3187745213508606,
0.4293762445449829,
-0.16496190428733826,
0.07218514382839203,
-0.06497450172901154,
-0.32084500789642334,
0.09126963466405869,
-0.39813515543937683,
0.48134085536003113,
0.20641301572322845,
-0.05073446407914162,
0.23404660820960999,
-0.7635068297386169,
0.4441321790218353,
-0.04720686376094818,
-0.7308743596076965,
-0.29585331678390503,
-0.4617130160331726,
0.014689694158732891,
0.3449254035949707,
0.6603268384933472,
-0.36173903942108154,
0.036732833832502365,
-0.6457642316818237,
-0.11022235453128815,
0.6727676391601562,
-0.38407713174819946,
0.6607675552368164,
-0.04634445905685425,
0.8887014985084534,
-0.07587610930204391,
0.07942406833171844,
-0.32706236839294434,
-0.07379823178052902,
-0.6337148547172546,
-0.40442532300949097,
0.5023651123046875,
0.6271383762359619,
-1.0260604619979858,
0.18862633407115936,
-0.4036117196083069,
-0.40404215455055237,
-0.9335231184959412,
0.5647541880607605,
0.5786964297294617,
0.22056728601455688,
0.3996525704860687,
0.004155527334660292,
-0.7259277701377869,
-0.9490647912025452,
-0.2947561740875244,
0.17121194303035736,
-0.06280745565891266,
0.1726844310760498,
0.03411579132080078,
-0.16892693936824799,
0.6169382929801941,
-0.33119916915893555,
0.01227642223238945,
-0.5785526633262634,
-0.24281807243824005,
0.3882520794868469,
0.20373715460300446,
0.26295751333236694,
-0.648196816444397,
-0.7503429055213928,
0.3968738913536072,
-0.47705596685409546,
-0.22733356058597565,
0.1804826259613037,
0.020298654213547707,
0.4594549834728241,
0.5544288754463196,
-0.5988003015518188,
0.18281881511211395,
0.7922699451446533,
0.042479630559682846,
0.7785641551017761,
-0.279611200094223,
-0.03311055526137352,
-0.9674224853515625,
-0.049838174134492874,
-0.1253030002117157,
-0.2186669409275055,
-0.8999744653701782,
0.17277401685714722,
0.10652666538953781,
-0.09971018135547638,
-0.42222458124160767,
0.7098367214202881,
-0.7758998274803162,
-0.15663132071495056,
-0.5590521097183228,
0.30916401743888855,
-0.11078281700611115,
0.42956939339637756,
0.050931666046381,
0.8886651992797852,
0.328857958316803,
-0.5697840452194214,
0.32260847091674805,
-0.15731438994407654,
-0.5382816791534424,
0.16696226596832275,
-0.5226307511329651,
0.12180513888597488,
-0.24038760364055634,
0.032067254185676575,
-0.7337279319763184,
-0.3298364579677582,
-0.0004067557165399194,
-0.07927215844392776,
0.4162951409816742,
-0.10765628516674042,
-0.4744183123111725,
-0.4238334894180298,
-0.25736743211746216,
0.41412684321403503,
0.3679405748844147,
-0.6556089520454407,
0.5584807991981506,
0.2960539162158966,
-0.44448840618133545,
-0.5307811498641968,
-0.5303046107292175,
0.07934463024139404,
-0.2342296987771988,
-0.6885953545570374,
0.360027939081192,
-0.013625659979879856,
-0.13827605545520782,
-0.12372414767742157,
0.05887443572282791,
0.04397333785891533,
0.008270472288131714,
-0.10385902225971222,
0.4022016227245331,
-0.47404778003692627,
0.29208964109420776,
0.006137944757938385,
0.016607128083705902,
-0.28516092896461487,
-0.19402596354484558,
0.8542481660842896,
-0.039178404957056046,
-0.38414496183395386,
-0.39232245087623596,
0.1633598804473877,
0.4294496178627014,
-0.25734543800354004,
0.7208887934684753,
0.8545438647270203,
-0.27437153458595276,
-0.02485443279147148,
-0.6875407099723816,
-0.08448351174592972,
-0.4776586890220642,
0.7785332202911377,
-0.30091461539268494,
-1.0770385265350342,
0.33218276500701904,
-0.34858909249305725,
-0.09730494022369385,
0.08933553844690323,
0.7794725894927979,
0.20056770741939545,
1.019361972808838,
0.5936102271080017,
-0.2942621111869812,
0.5465584397315979,
-0.04934361204504967,
0.15513736009597778,
-0.9538363814353943,
-0.20184674859046936,
-0.28525495529174805,
-0.36651918292045593,
-0.8757166266441345,
-0.7328262329101562,
0.3446296751499176,
0.2433374673128128,
-0.017952069640159607,
0.22013479471206665,
-0.007256343960762024,
0.6747475266456604,
0.2952426075935364,
-0.10341145098209381,
0.2681809365749359,
0.28813841938972473,
-0.21110855042934418,
-0.18097758293151855,
-0.9454147219657898,
-0.5769391655921936,
1.1415114402770996,
0.394289493560791,
0.7829713225364685,
0.161838099360466,
0.5613422989845276,
-0.13491256535053253,
0.29860636591911316,
-0.6181935667991638,
0.37076660990715027,
-0.23942658305168152,
-0.4383275806903839,
-0.5031527876853943,
-0.4987368583679199,
-0.9290611147880554,
0.5400365591049194,
-0.28443729877471924,
-0.6199947595596313,
-0.17114052176475525,
0.1647893339395523,
-0.2624484598636627,
-0.22857025265693665,
-0.8169978857040405,
0.7637154459953308,
-0.6380568146705627,
-0.5412036180496216,
-0.34467804431915283,
-0.3428574502468109,
0.42797622084617615,
-0.39073148369789124,
0.2541533410549164,
0.10301361978054047,
-0.18455301225185394,
0.35126277804374695,
-0.19584733247756958,
0.6073209047317505,
-0.18936000764369965,
-0.2614113390445709,
0.003002328099682927,
-0.3041040599346161,
0.7526512742042542,
-0.1813770979642868,
-0.24092762172222137,
0.1322849988937378,
-0.3500424921512604,
-0.45259982347488403,
-0.660862922668457,
0.7271800637245178,
-0.5618910193443298,
-0.5807355642318726,
0.15559186041355133,
-0.6729466319084167,
-0.4988921880722046,
0.17992502450942993,
0.11056575179100037,
0.15135467052459717,
-0.1628505289554596,
0.15815961360931396,
0.37087807059288025,
-0.4082808494567871,
0.4378189444541931,
0.6541606783866882,
-0.5944024324417114,
-0.42182403802871704,
1.0361201763153076,
0.18677932024002075,
0.48616933822631836,
0.061261821538209915,
0.3293234407901764,
-0.5788853168487549,
-0.5767859220504761,
-0.5571067333221436,
0.3355533480644226,
-0.4738461673259735,
-0.001957861240953207,
-0.35992076992988586,
-0.17842331528663635,
-0.5189070701599121,
0.1721736639738083,
-0.3940909802913666,
-0.4548477828502655,
-0.27901020646095276,
-0.1178480014204979,
0.08225001394748688,
0.5163582563400269,
-0.06558334827423096,
0.5838503837585449,
-0.8303924798965454,
0.24232858419418335,
-0.05046817287802696,
0.3543407618999481,
0.23923663794994354,
-0.6052391529083252,
-0.6877532005310059,
0.24090397357940674,
-0.1760658472776413,
-0.4169224202632904,
0.3836781084537506,
0.17453426122665405,
0.7521834373474121,
0.289494127035141,
-0.2423289269208908,
1.0574150085449219,
-0.6202343702316284,
0.5327751040458679,
0.2053632140159607,
-0.6582552790641785,
0.25863176584243774,
-0.06406252831220627,
0.4733586013317108,
0.3849155306816101,
0.4222874045372009,
-0.5169737935066223,
-0.14758634567260742,
-0.2633272409439087,
-0.8261308073997498,
0.7594384551048279,
-0.01213438156992197,
0.38325604796409607,
0.32087036967277527,
0.24443717300891876,
0.12301814556121826,
0.3944471776485443,
-0.7752289772033691,
-0.06460124254226685,
0.10121572017669678,
-0.2371877282857895,
-0.3930685520172119,
-0.2907102108001709,
0.12685741484165192,
-0.18476502597332,
0.6750763654708862,
-0.0929606482386589,
-0.29492637515068054,
-0.20814017951488495,
-0.39800339937210083,
-0.03271964192390442,
0.22760148346424103,
0.7633731365203857,
0.7625125646591187,
0.1917664259672165,
-0.06960932910442352,
0.3564305901527405,
-0.41310107707977295,
0.1892067939043045,
0.059283070266246796,
0.013702917844057083,
0.013397600501775742,
0.5479162931442261,
1.1109635829925537,
0.13628129661083221,
-0.8104006052017212,
0.15392132103443146,
0.2770868241786957,
0.2992413341999054,
-0.101845383644104,
-0.007511783856898546,
0.2534239590167999,
0.49359315633773804,
0.23316487669944763,
-0.3510162830352783,
-0.19588345289230347,
-0.41133514046669006,
-0.20371487736701965,
0.523230791091919,
-0.10408397763967514,
-0.3565405309200287,
0.20191651582717896,
0.1867520809173584,
-0.23829145729541779,
0.35156872868537903,
-0.23413598537445068,
-0.7639379501342773,
0.35239192843437195,
0.7810315489768982,
0.4700733423233032,
-0.5384806990623474,
0.1479537934064865,
0.3776431977748871,
0.508523166179657,
-0.17415744066238403,
0.2681784927845001,
0.14799360930919647,
-0.7502297163009644,
-0.9619101881980896,
-0.6882250308990479,
-0.10895013064146042,
0.4306218922138214,
-0.43261995911598206,
0.34904634952545166,
-0.15745024383068085,
-0.2665182054042816,
-0.3216550052165985,
0.3078451454639435,
-0.608140766620636,
-0.004215249791741371,
0.18735681474208832,
0.7201927304267883,
-0.6939601898193359,
0.8039993643760681,
0.7676416635513306,
-0.13151878118515015,
-0.8065632581710815,
-0.03990506753325462,
-0.26958322525024414,
-0.8395552039146423,
0.8927152156829834,
0.04105434566736221,
-0.11654380708932877,
0.0521869920194149,
-0.1312340497970581,
-1.0125031471252441,
0.8038957715034485,
0.5669875144958496,
-0.7171702980995178,
0.16830682754516602,
0.4402250349521637,
0.7489185929298401,
-0.4132581651210785,
-0.04995734617114067,
0.5664883852005005,
0.5636862516403198,
-0.0699678286910057,
-1.0963432788848877,
-0.16640138626098633,
0.0012144666397944093,
0.20724725723266602,
0.2067936211824417,
-0.4079784154891968,
0.7068202495574951,
-0.24015524983406067,
-0.22177328169345856,
0.08437945693731308,
0.6354652643203735,
0.37445926666259766,
0.23200441896915436,
0.35219714045524597,
0.4364858567714691,
0.992399275302887,
0.2673804759979248,
1.0983887910842896,
-0.3064795732498169,
-0.018018020316958427,
1.2937648296356201,
-0.47958046197891235,
0.7433677911758423,
0.5147762894630432,
-0.1588277667760849,
0.12434253841638565,
0.6125253438949585,
0.15996448695659637,
0.38647371530532837,
0.3384605348110199,
-0.33449968695640564,
-0.221694216132164,
-0.39894750714302063,
-0.3989270031452179,
0.597748339176178,
0.3124113082885742,
-0.16068989038467407,
-0.11329644173383713,
0.24776630103588104,
0.09633736312389374,
0.08757951110601425,
-0.5296105146408081,
0.6978879570960999,
-0.06902727484703064,
-0.6967719197273254,
0.7220168113708496,
0.18859204649925232,
0.6689842343330383,
-0.4795994162559509,
0.1867268681526184,
-0.33745110034942627,
0.15670274198055267,
-0.25715935230255127,
-0.47987672686576843,
-0.045201316475868225,
0.13501210510730743,
-0.1314956396818161,
-0.06844456493854523,
0.7895203232765198,
-1.0062918663024902,
-0.7639766931533813,
0.41048648953437805,
0.6507092118263245,
0.05358310043811798,
0.029086600989103317,
-0.516077995300293,
0.26568156480789185,
-0.04818139970302582,
-0.15779168903827667,
0.542553186416626,
0.46532124280929565,
-0.3288251459598541,
0.6656771302223206,
0.7983105778694153,
0.5608628988265991,
0.22936390340328217,
0.29852357506752014,
0.8488079309463501,
-0.19481617212295532,
-0.35770726203918457,
-0.9230949878692627,
0.32216134667396545,
-0.1835121363401413,
-0.12308624386787415,
0.9692229628562927,
0.7044647932052612,
0.9447330236434937,
-0.2473842054605484,
0.6738697290420532,
0.5078218579292297,
0.6871174573898315,
-0.8240070939064026,
0.5078123211860657,
-0.6117531061172485,
0.2514721751213074,
-0.300279438495636,
-1.1292235851287842,
-0.039631616324186325,
0.5035749077796936,
-0.2536533772945404,
0.1801450550556183,
0.3632569909095764,
0.9038975834846497,
-0.05684040114283562,
-0.20554672181606293,
0.4527304768562317,
0.25716912746429443,
-0.011681648902595043,
0.274883508682251,
1.0144927501678467,
-0.024060601368546486,
0.34455567598342896,
-0.2514297664165497,
-0.12096384167671204,
-0.23248541355133057,
-0.9115509986877441,
-0.8400779366493225,
-0.2664525806903839,
-0.10936319828033447,
-0.0829547718167305,
-0.17123836278915405,
1.1372764110565186,
0.4950612485408783,
-0.6315941214561462,
-0.6094897985458374,
0.4333377480506897,
0.23763571679592133,
0.113218292593956,
-0.178622767329216,
0.2884671092033386,
-0.5552769899368286,
-0.7139945030212402,
0.6442264914512634,
0.19811196625232697,
-0.005695488303899765,
-0.38326701521873474,
-0.32157066464424133,
-0.11529701203107834,
-0.10475074499845505,
1.0553278923034668,
0.08044122159481049,
-0.657019317150116,
-0.04210014268755913,
0.19437174499034882,
0.028034783899784088,
-0.14756008982658386,
0.7787163257598877,
-0.6262657642364502,
0.40397679805755615,
0.3058914542198181,
0.8006736040115356,
0.3007732033729553,
0.18775895237922668,
0.5812278985977173,
-0.9236152172088623,
0.42846614122390747,
0.12375449389219284,
-0.013485106639564037,
0.5184159874916077,
-0.2723841667175293,
0.45299193263053894,
-0.1130467876791954,
-0.42249247431755066,
-0.9718775749206543,
0.244679793715477,
-0.4309527277946472,
-0.2815089225769043,
1.1773686408996582,
-0.07918894290924072,
-0.04140057787299156,
-0.040973417460918427,
-0.19223184883594513,
0.23680946230888367,
-0.0767691433429718,
0.6287287473678589,
0.8681567311286926,
-0.1317954957485199,
-0.11633359640836716,
-0.6672020554542542,
0.5424795150756836,
0.30954015254974365,
-0.8244045376777649,
0.2787570357322693,
0.545832097530365,
0.0121915303170681,
0.19480596482753754,
0.49847474694252014,
0.013847596943378448,
0.17850488424301147,
-0.4224984645843506,
-0.032267019152641296,
-0.1598767787218094,
-0.3821071684360504,
-0.5457857847213745,
-0.11093483120203018,
0.1421380192041397,
-0.00272343005053699
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10856v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10856v1
|
Zero-shot Generative Linguistic Steganography
| 2024-03-16T08:31:25 | 2024-03-16T08:31:25 |
Ke Lin, Yiyang Luo, Zijian Zhang, Ping Luo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CR
|
Generative linguistic steganography attempts to hide secret messages into
covertext. Previous studies have generally focused on the statistical
differences between the covertext and stegotext, however, ill-formed stegotext
can readily be identified by humans. In this paper, we propose a novel
zero-shot approach based on in-context learning for linguistic steganography to
achieve better perceptual and statistical imperceptibility. We also design
several new metrics and reproducible language evaluations to measure the
imperceptibility of the stegotext. Our experimental results indicate that our
method produces $1.926\times$ more innocent and intelligible stegotext than any
other method.
|
[
-0.16850601136684418,
-1.1287407875061035,
0.48220768570899963,
0.09989841282367706,
-0.5099313855171204,
0.06045331805944443,
-0.4724159240722656,
-0.32404449582099915,
0.21048760414123535,
0.4009558856487274,
-0.3352646827697754,
-1.0208274126052856,
-0.6222585439682007,
0.14674507081508636,
-0.5228280425071716,
0.9023610353469849,
-0.0419386625289917,
0.07418572902679443,
0.15276837348937988,
-0.20078563690185547,
-0.6737954616546631,
-0.7482315897941589,
-0.44166266918182373,
0.1404823660850525,
0.11881548166275024,
0.5138285756111145,
0.5020847320556641,
0.4270477294921875,
0.34174609184265137,
0.20605802536010742,
0.10127708315849304,
-0.3166859447956085,
-0.766952633857727,
0.6291697025299072,
-0.1814638376235962,
-0.4743573069572449,
0.0467122383415699,
-0.30368494987487793,
0.6692379117012024,
0.49160951375961304,
0.037346165627241135,
0.09264598041772842,
-0.09498782455921173,
0.22139503061771393,
-0.7236842513084412,
0.09080439060926437,
-0.6842039823532104,
0.2692451775074005,
-0.4021822512149811,
-0.4269038736820221,
-0.4791029095649719,
-0.2744211256504059,
-0.0006108818342909217,
-0.5959265828132629,
0.4505847990512848,
-0.023757224902510643,
0.7448509335517883,
0.017275996506214142,
-0.15497644245624542,
-0.2993756830692291,
-0.8142200708389282,
0.7285288572311401,
-0.6474047303199768,
0.15268518030643463,
0.514954686164856,
0.2872826159000397,
0.1546335518360138,
-0.585849404335022,
-0.5619313716888428,
-0.29739537835121155,
0.016738450154662132,
0.1304619461297989,
0.05968821048736572,
0.0025283461436629295,
0.1494937241077423,
0.36407455801963806,
-0.7519469857215881,
-0.16278673708438873,
-0.07123024016618729,
-0.12726862728595734,
0.4941147565841675,
-0.11025230586528778,
0.6280001401901245,
-0.0749376192688942,
-0.5643207430839539,
-0.16227763891220093,
-0.6342718601226807,
-0.41051197052001953,
0.35846829414367676,
0.12210598587989807,
0.009453687816858292,
0.43409082293510437,
-0.2649729549884796,
0.2689986824989319,
-0.03553903102874756,
-0.0009489813819527626,
0.15269778668880463,
-0.1308039277791977,
-0.43039417266845703,
0.24973292648792267,
0.8720946311950684,
-0.060125067830085754,
0.0778777152299881,
-0.48792704939842224,
-0.03741130232810974,
-0.012449357658624649,
0.14541782438755035,
-0.7452409267425537,
0.007607162930071354,
-0.22717830538749695,
-0.22353148460388184,
-0.6239908933639526,
0.12824906408786774,
-0.7507829666137695,
-0.026279965415596962,
0.1369795948266983,
0.8885921239852905,
-0.8002318739891052,
-0.007313443347811699,
0.03326686471700668,
-0.33194154500961304,
0.14599962532520294,
0.15307040512561798,
-0.8659694790840149,
0.2621121108531952,
0.42914676666259766,
0.934701681137085,
0.17378969490528107,
-0.08462077379226685,
-0.24685341119766235,
0.280107319355011,
-0.7756829857826233,
0.5418617129325867,
-0.4884045720100403,
-0.3256781995296478,
-0.08158189803361893,
0.09389957040548325,
0.13538454473018646,
-0.26910409331321716,
0.5023921728134155,
-0.5733665823936462,
0.3276863992214203,
-0.12989924848079681,
-0.7064736485481262,
-0.4711455702781677,
-0.1847425103187561,
-0.4066805839538574,
0.7712113857269287,
0.07503097504377365,
-0.3379899859428406,
0.6181846857070923,
-0.5681343078613281,
-0.4425503611564636,
0.6084979176521301,
-0.22330038249492645,
-0.48780184984207153,
0.14450298249721527,
-0.04395444318652153,
0.46420007944107056,
0.2571234107017517,
0.5345854163169861,
-0.33870890736579895,
-0.67861008644104,
0.3797093331813812,
-1.2397459745407104,
0.8867897391319275,
0.12511934340000153,
-0.8396291732788086,
-0.05437174811959267,
-0.4586465060710907,
0.01449647918343544,
0.24931690096855164,
-0.015112662687897682,
-0.6542631983757019,
-0.4810069501399994,
-0.067039854824543,
-0.20473045110702515,
0.011688307859003544,
-0.7392709255218506,
-0.12887965142726898,
-0.85238116979599,
0.15562623739242554,
0.586816132068634,
0.2172025591135025,
0.8213292360305786,
0.018386851996183395,
0.45574796199798584,
-0.33395621180534363,
0.20904423296451569,
-0.2793325185775757,
-0.6232367157936096,
-0.5417190790176392,
-0.40458598732948303,
0.15557141602039337,
0.46702149510383606,
-0.853853166103363,
0.3212035596370697,
-0.08426935970783234,
-0.22173090279102325,
-0.39602959156036377,
0.30769482254981995,
0.873712956905365,
0.6647747159004211,
0.2231656014919281,
-0.5432493090629578,
-0.29603978991508484,
-0.803209662437439,
-0.40436288714408875,
0.11844732612371445,
-0.17734254896640778,
0.14429108798503876,
0.6115890145301819,
0.2499786764383316,
0.6740185022354126,
-0.41719532012939453,
-0.39563852548599243,
-0.023636167868971825,
0.44262391328811646,
-0.0334099605679512,
0.4054904282093048,
0.6330475211143494,
-0.584597647190094,
-0.7542362213134766,
-0.10074970871210098,
-1.1127904653549194,
0.09547274559736252,
0.09619791805744171,
-0.1747959852218628,
0.3009892702102661,
0.519672155380249,
-0.20173650979995728,
0.7756996154785156,
0.28767940402030945,
-0.41124865412712097,
0.2741157114505768,
-0.22677621245384216,
0.19752827286720276,
-0.8605505228042603,
0.00047416702727787197,
-0.1613568812608719,
-0.338716983795166,
-1.0535733699798584,
0.11484202742576599,
0.18861788511276245,
-0.3499172627925873,
-0.522842526435852,
0.5322610139846802,
-0.7072787284851074,
0.25682497024536133,
0.039206262677907944,
0.0320357121527195,
-0.024919012561440468,
0.6011178493499756,
0.14676374197006226,
0.7539505958557129,
0.8198904395103455,
-0.2008141130208969,
0.21260397136211395,
0.25630664825439453,
-0.6120413541793823,
0.4982025921344757,
-0.3811306059360504,
0.23152942955493927,
-0.5597277283668518,
0.1850869506597519,
-1.1751322746276855,
-0.43220287561416626,
0.5472432374954224,
-0.5624126195907593,
0.6566030979156494,
-0.19611100852489471,
-0.3277263045310974,
0.2602759599685669,
-0.4698513448238373,
0.43890807032585144,
0.4896966516971588,
-0.36557555198669434,
-0.16773687303066254,
0.24245800077915192,
0.029425567016005516,
-0.69056236743927,
-0.7821783423423767,
0.4332716763019562,
-0.21678180992603302,
-0.25806725025177,
0.37015706300735474,
0.000584486173465848,
-0.06263843923807144,
0.09096802771091461,
0.02152821607887745,
-0.1981884092092514,
0.010712813585996628,
0.44439640641212463,
0.2408980429172516,
-0.18121150135993958,
0.3808906674385071,
0.20779788494110107,
-0.1327706128358841,
-0.26488208770751953,
-0.10357915610074997,
0.47508302330970764,
-0.22177158296108246,
-0.41640505194664,
-0.6728789210319519,
0.5751134157180786,
0.15197069942951202,
0.21438567340373993,
0.9687200784683228,
0.5645619034767151,
-0.34614554047584534,
-0.3546302616596222,
-0.222616046667099,
-0.3624531328678131,
-0.44235119223594666,
0.23266616463661194,
-0.29211461544036865,
-0.7158423066139221,
0.17346851527690887,
0.29769057035446167,
-0.25640392303466797,
0.0981142520904541,
0.3414497971534729,
-0.1263553351163864,
0.6985585689544678,
0.4808777868747711,
0.15246804058551788,
0.5671752691268921,
-0.3152792751789093,
0.33068108558654785,
-0.538906455039978,
-0.1732816994190216,
-0.21585363149642944,
-0.19119709730148315,
-0.18754388391971588,
-0.44884973764419556,
0.40539947152137756,
0.3782762587070465,
-0.14983753859996796,
0.5687516331672668,
-0.7216910719871521,
0.5884116291999817,
0.6494061350822449,
0.3161245882511139,
0.36700281500816345,
0.3869645297527313,
-0.05452946946024895,
-0.14984586834907532,
-0.574937641620636,
-0.6138716340065002,
1.2062747478485107,
0.22503794729709625,
0.6011306047439575,
0.27121371030807495,
0.6974892020225525,
0.11741984635591507,
0.7137482762336731,
-0.753382682800293,
0.3614438474178314,
-0.256590336561203,
-0.9942812323570251,
-0.7311659455299377,
-0.29240670800209045,
-0.6359533667564392,
0.22250452637672424,
-0.24850556254386902,
-0.7463045716285706,
0.10545619577169418,
0.0022520245984196663,
-0.15280941128730774,
0.3406004011631012,
-0.9005584716796875,
0.7195596098899841,
-0.10177744925022125,
-0.3216699957847595,
0.3412984013557434,
-0.6551296710968018,
0.4294387102127075,
0.06656154245138168,
0.3170188069343567,
-0.08551332354545593,
-0.09588590264320374,
0.7705791592597961,
-0.3193137049674988,
1.2076072692871094,
-0.18793998658657074,
-0.0894656851887703,
0.10829615592956543,
0.3280552625656128,
0.2193140685558319,
0.2619647681713104,
0.13705453276634216,
0.47297412157058716,
-0.274339497089386,
-0.15788991749286652,
-0.5648283958435059,
0.701204776763916,
-0.3294159770011902,
-0.5021036863327026,
-0.31586137413978577,
-0.3346506655216217,
-0.13526175916194916,
0.25247490406036377,
0.659740686416626,
0.720431387424469,
-0.4100181460380554,
0.46166765689849854,
0.8999725580215454,
-0.48396894335746765,
0.6375372409820557,
0.3241029977798462,
0.19265244901180267,
-0.4649990499019623,
0.8916492462158203,
0.2611185908317566,
0.33993902802467346,
0.7148006558418274,
0.1544317901134491,
-0.49402129650115967,
-0.2860446572303772,
-0.548524022102356,
0.21686595678329468,
-0.7954459190368652,
-0.3116380572319031,
-0.4407498836517334,
-0.17352643609046936,
-0.4896908402442932,
-0.4397526979446411,
-0.05905366316437721,
-0.3539733290672302,
-0.3513872027397156,
-0.06849398463964462,
0.45229142904281616,
0.42322850227355957,
0.10268915444612503,
0.4011619985103607,
-0.12657995522022247,
0.486005038022995,
0.32128533720970154,
0.5233437418937683,
-0.13852868974208832,
-0.6996041536331177,
0.24640725553035736,
0.03958645835518837,
0.026179293170571327,
-1.3305668830871582,
0.6118307113647461,
0.35398194193840027,
0.44808804988861084,
0.6082751154899597,
0.07658601552248001,
0.7315130829811096,
-0.3701414167881012,
0.620417058467865,
0.33295926451683044,
-1.1705673933029175,
0.7220281362533569,
-0.22035400569438934,
0.1939421445131302,
0.5262542963027954,
0.24656303226947784,
-0.5227375626564026,
-0.6366381645202637,
-0.7204270958900452,
-0.8507742285728455,
0.6162074208259583,
0.414436012506485,
0.557346761226654,
-0.09245160967111588,
0.4256706237792969,
0.2955758571624756,
0.22654810547828674,
-0.7297490239143372,
-0.361564964056015,
-0.42234209179878235,
-0.3457319140434265,
-0.1250283569097519,
-0.44187024235725403,
-0.31939131021499634,
-0.21889562904834747,
0.35446643829345703,
-0.09797068685293198,
0.3542906641960144,
0.2786562442779541,
-0.4349074959754944,
-0.006403216160833836,
0.40352004766464233,
0.834041953086853,
0.4478946030139923,
-0.26068708300590515,
0.5077035427093506,
0.29945582151412964,
-0.6970595717430115,
0.2697409987449646,
-0.5220525860786438,
-0.6459154486656189,
0.45975571870803833,
0.5592697858810425,
0.968655526638031,
0.44146984815597534,
-0.5010069012641907,
1.0863003730773926,
-0.05306132137775421,
-0.48430702090263367,
-0.43079912662506104,
-0.0536644384264946,
-0.23423409461975098,
-0.17075584828853607,
0.38238412141799927,
0.1830662190914154,
0.09696399420499802,
-0.6709651947021484,
0.33805862069129944,
0.6404394507408142,
-0.7549686431884766,
-0.3884449005126953,
0.8311630487442017,
-0.0999540314078331,
-0.34062889218330383,
0.10628581792116165,
-0.20445285737514496,
-0.38654568791389465,
0.45088934898376465,
0.9780712127685547,
0.9756317138671875,
-0.42188599705696106,
0.7355781197547913,
0.3098238706588745,
0.3166983425617218,
0.02144019864499569,
0.06353845447301865,
-0.4397088885307312,
-0.5820910334587097,
-0.17664627730846405,
-0.63004070520401,
-0.10348108410835266,
0.23859958350658417,
-0.4459497928619385,
0.02219306118786335,
-0.47396937012672424,
0.17397095263004303,
-0.07238010317087173,
-0.3223881423473358,
-0.4765612483024597,
0.12880739569664001,
0.04229039326310158,
0.42220890522003174,
-0.934353768825531,
0.8368329405784607,
0.19525310397148132,
-0.497833788394928,
-0.5098795294761658,
-0.014064779505133629,
0.01838468387722969,
-1.014679193496704,
0.7771494388580322,
-0.037268396466970444,
-0.20347781479358673,
0.03156030550599098,
-0.8503674864768982,
-0.7218766212463379,
1.0657252073287964,
0.6806367635726929,
-0.40440085530281067,
0.2751401364803314,
-0.0237148255109787,
0.6583747863769531,
-0.12604862451553345,
0.20242944359779358,
0.13479086756706238,
0.3258149027824402,
0.12072008103132248,
-0.5161718726158142,
0.3936418890953064,
0.03234586864709854,
0.2551591694355011,
0.19902975857257843,
-0.17222651839256287,
0.5660881400108337,
0.11440545320510864,
-0.9863483905792236,
-0.1519998013973236,
0.4118455946445465,
-0.0563960000872612,
0.25768163800239563,
0.21790169179439545,
0.40381500124931335,
0.4539893865585327,
0.1174025684595108,
0.8514695763587952,
-0.02157568372786045,
0.5432211756706238,
0.9585952758789062,
-0.0541733056306839,
0.8080679774284363,
0.44557759165763855,
0.23038560152053833,
0.4054844081401825,
-0.03335823863744736,
0.14174886047840118,
0.7048826217651367,
0.06037922576069832,
-0.8556494116783142,
0.10811062157154083,
0.07486768066883087,
-0.15396106243133545,
0.15571057796478271,
0.39932602643966675,
-0.36026617884635925,
-0.23282766342163086,
0.36527031660079956,
0.4668700397014618,
0.17089080810546875,
0.09746827930212021,
0.8960994482040405,
0.018817761912941933,
-0.34543704986572266,
0.7810664176940918,
-0.14887797832489014,
0.7648778557777405,
-0.5759441256523132,
-0.22305893898010254,
-0.30579516291618347,
-0.003372080624103546,
-0.2152632772922516,
-1.0194171667099,
0.4328904449939728,
0.04830027371644974,
0.18622060120105743,
-0.6198031306266785,
0.9353036880493164,
-0.6812816262245178,
-0.30395615100860596,
0.2670714557170868,
0.05474347248673439,
0.3614364266395569,
-0.27541178464889526,
-0.3157801628112793,
-0.22802002727985382,
-0.19572779536247253,
-0.0225159153342247,
0.30041998624801636,
0.4675569236278534,
-0.24968446791172028,
0.5005841255187988,
0.6961036324501038,
0.18719080090522766,
0.20139119029045105,
0.215515598654747,
0.37125158309936523,
-0.5884901881217957,
-0.26403865218162537,
-0.9874359369277954,
0.06845476478338242,
-0.26612237095832825,
-0.23449699580669403,
1.017964243888855,
0.3507934808731079,
0.8635551333427429,
-0.3850097358226776,
0.8569268584251404,
-0.2356274574995041,
0.22525227069854736,
-0.2928434908390045,
0.9529772400856018,
-0.36547988653182983,
0.10658756643533707,
-0.44392332434654236,
-0.5790802240371704,
-0.7755913734436035,
0.5028737783432007,
-0.3204497694969177,
-0.3352356255054474,
0.7256482839584351,
0.9994088411331177,
-0.03207872062921524,
-0.2067318856716156,
0.8891898989677429,
0.08205834776163101,
0.01577090658247471,
0.3763527274131775,
0.6322328448295593,
-0.671197772026062,
0.7430756688117981,
-0.4600445330142975,
-0.5299115180969238,
-0.3463159501552582,
-0.6085440516471863,
-0.8191114068031311,
-0.79715895652771,
-0.07503198087215424,
0.050817131996154785,
0.2285390943288803,
0.06807402521371841,
0.6929401159286499,
-0.7534653544425964,
0.026139380410313606,
-0.35200345516204834,
0.14739078283309937,
-0.24917256832122803,
-0.3353312611579895,
0.4378640353679657,
-0.34623679518699646,
-0.6017328500747681,
0.4984481930732727,
0.752833902835846,
0.11401302367448807,
-0.274579793214798,
0.09422444552183151,
-0.05034848675131798,
0.10089683532714844,
0.6898626685142517,
0.361152708530426,
-0.6300212740898132,
-0.4992722272872925,
-0.1028628870844841,
-0.11348964273929596,
0.135760098695755,
0.6301755309104919,
-0.4828836917877197,
0.7403568625450134,
0.7131941318511963,
0.11687150597572327,
0.6553435921669006,
0.15099315345287323,
0.4175843298435211,
-1.1461658477783203,
0.4006761610507965,
0.2698195278644562,
-0.06850014626979828,
0.1734449714422226,
-0.5116453170776367,
0.14818193018436432,
0.35405483841896057,
-0.22947591543197632,
-0.7976517677307129,
0.16369503736495972,
-0.7954121232032776,
-0.5273049473762512,
0.9987192153930664,
-0.20097093284130096,
-0.44478893280029297,
-0.4150087833404541,
-0.22182397544384003,
0.33327314257621765,
-0.3850101828575134,
0.6585302948951721,
0.4033811688423157,
0.18137520551681519,
-0.21793010830879211,
-0.7622277736663818,
0.6725873947143555,
0.3315928280353546,
-0.5756910443305969,
-0.15237556397914886,
0.15770666301250458,
0.6428901553153992,
0.1195930540561676,
0.8130855560302734,
-0.42581769824028015,
0.07674440741539001,
0.26046475768089294,
-0.0500672273337841,
0.12544268369674683,
-0.43329131603240967,
-0.6137599945068359,
0.5684916377067566,
-0.3918493986129761,
-0.41623079776763916
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10849v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10849v2
|
RetinaQA: A Robust Knowledge Base Question Answering Model for both Answerable and Unanswerable Questions
| 2024-03-16T08:08:20 | 2024-06-15T20:42:13 |
Prayushi Faldu, Indrajit Bhattacharya, Mausam
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
An essential requirement for a real-world Knowledge Base Question Answering
(KBQA) system is the ability to detect answerability of questions when
generating logical forms. However, state-of-the-art KBQA models assume all
questions to be answerable. Recent research has found that such models, when
superficially adapted to detect answerability, struggle to satisfactorily
identify the different categories of unanswerable questions, and simultaneously
preserve good performance for answerable questions. Towards addressing this
issue, we propose RetinaQA, a new KBQA model that unifies two key ideas in a
single KBQA architecture: (a) discrimination over candidate logical forms,
rather than generating these, for handling schema-related unanswerability, and
(b) sketch-filling-based construction of candidate logical forms for handling
data-related unaswerability. Our results show that RetinaQA significantly
outperforms adaptations of state-of-the-art KBQA models in handling both
answerable and unanswerable questions and demonstrates robustness across all
categories of unanswerability. Notably, RetinaQA also sets a new
state-of-the-art for answerable KBQA, surpassing existing models.
|
[
-0.2731924057006836,
-0.9599187970161438,
0.7219525575637817,
0.025907248258590698,
-0.17640656232833862,
0.30649513006210327,
0.3403550982475281,
-0.673409104347229,
0.5699968338012695,
0.6825651526451111,
-0.7002665996551514,
-0.20816302299499512,
-0.2797594666481018,
-0.18680313229560852,
-0.5864315032958984,
0.37246933579444885,
-0.26316502690315247,
-0.24381306767463684,
-0.7116369009017944,
-0.32519370317459106,
-0.7409480810165405,
-0.30256903171539307,
-0.2325042188167572,
-0.05880483239889145,
0.43648189306259155,
0.6589747071266174,
0.8375445008277893,
0.4756909906864166,
0.3028836250305176,
0.254923015832901,
0.10750790685415268,
0.19015923142433167,
0.11830955743789673,
0.5196792483329773,
-0.07256940752267838,
-0.6259656548500061,
-0.5662751197814941,
-0.13252919912338257,
0.3819022476673126,
0.5348851680755615,
-0.1604965478181839,
0.5316289663314819,
-0.33232295513153076,
0.7019281983375549,
-0.6815000772476196,
-0.14499668776988983,
-0.7229329347610474,
-0.027204450219869614,
0.06852750480175018,
-0.038682591170072556,
-0.34355172514915466,
-0.3087940812110901,
0.2037700116634369,
-1.009506344795227,
-0.016194483265280724,
0.10396887362003326,
0.7579970955848694,
0.4019416868686676,
-0.44327643513679504,
0.04363298416137695,
-0.28785988688468933,
0.33040517568588257,
-0.5259191393852234,
0.5728482604026794,
0.11911545693874359,
0.8737668991088867,
-0.14768929779529572,
-0.9832836985588074,
-0.6085168123245239,
-0.16128094494342804,
0.1994054615497589,
0.3080439865589142,
-0.41714441776275635,
-0.21324226260185242,
-0.04468756541609764,
-0.038216784596443176,
-0.48817968368530273,
-0.15124015510082245,
-0.3246299624443054,
-0.49842485785484314,
0.12475381791591644,
0.2655975818634033,
0.3822277784347534,
-0.3288407325744629,
-0.39025598764419556,
0.43165600299835205,
-0.6153474450111389,
0.503135621547699,
-0.01980174519121647,
0.09760557115077972,
0.230140820145607,
0.47096845507621765,
-0.6931542158126831,
0.9906271696090698,
0.08157692104578018,
0.06616753339767456,
-0.1424347162246704,
-0.020776692777872086,
-0.2014940083026886,
-0.3529336750507355,
0.06749080866575241,
0.3828706443309784,
0.3013445734977722,
-0.43298739194869995,
-0.23098096251487732,
-0.10690387338399887,
0.6690820455551147,
-0.5528259873390198,
-0.5559946298599243,
0.4640364348888397,
-0.6159221529960632,
-0.6113436818122864,
-0.30711695551872253,
-0.5936631560325623,
-0.4410145580768585,
-0.1380796730518341,
0.779691219329834,
-0.17398656904697418,
-0.5577506422996521,
-0.12328379601240158,
-0.08553820103406906,
0.22809167206287384,
0.7854068875312805,
-0.619231641292572,
0.19194439053535461,
0.5846214294433594,
0.49365729093551636,
0.05983342230319977,
-0.12104383856058121,
-0.311100572347641,
-0.12043646723031998,
-0.43656548857688904,
1.058160662651062,
-0.4074363708496094,
0.3884987235069275,
-0.26070988178253174,
0.08676262199878693,
-0.014752528630197048,
-0.6332447528839111,
0.3725172281265259,
-1.1484779119491577,
-0.031368158757686615,
-0.4271691143512726,
-0.5244447588920593,
-0.48443344235420227,
0.6096900105476379,
-0.8090776205062866,
0.523749589920044,
0.4945157766342163,
-0.9895244836807251,
0.7138565182685852,
-0.5096876621246338,
0.012048061937093735,
0.200160950422287,
-0.11505021154880524,
-0.3023802936077118,
0.09734579175710678,
0.2558799088001251,
0.21222615242004395,
-0.44274917244911194,
0.42759019136428833,
-0.31873470544815063,
-0.3167920410633087,
0.4497531056404114,
-0.2686545252799988,
0.7013645768165588,
0.2694687247276306,
-0.1588766723871231,
0.1149003803730011,
-0.8728119134902954,
0.6188960075378418,
0.009677449241280556,
-0.5261129140853882,
-0.10372442752122879,
-0.12426085025072098,
0.06665122509002686,
0.2891067862510681,
0.21866659820079803,
-0.8724313378334045,
-0.06349651515483856,
-0.23636864125728607,
0.5342563986778259,
0.7086698412895203,
-0.07755912840366364,
0.26058658957481384,
-0.45506349205970764,
0.6646000742912292,
0.3805335760116577,
0.28089746832847595,
0.3857368528842926,
-0.6483319997787476,
-0.77163165807724,
-0.22848184406757355,
0.37559160590171814,
0.933855414390564,
-1.0530009269714355,
-0.17245221138000488,
0.05618101358413696,
-1.0178871154785156,
-0.45869210362434387,
-0.0409422442317009,
0.4607182443141937,
1.1403006315231323,
0.3274497985839844,
-0.32315945625305176,
-0.46668216586112976,
-1.317229151725769,
-0.3914700448513031,
-0.49646851420402527,
0.2427334040403366,
0.47002530097961426,
0.5994503498077393,
0.12372098118066788,
1.2008488178253174,
-0.4608461856842041,
0.2869974374771118,
-0.19512039422988892,
-0.2832360565662384,
0.33843210339546204,
0.16841605305671692,
0.5060868859291077,
-1.137474536895752,
-0.2337593287229538,
-0.3684990704059601,
-1.1168302297592163,
-0.15886777639389038,
0.17629869282245636,
-0.3076471984386444,
0.08297354727983475,
0.2806430160999298,
-0.7961388230323792,
0.7921187281608582,
-0.10290660709142685,
-0.48228225111961365,
0.7176910638809204,
0.08728937804698944,
0.19397446513175964,
-1.0673487186431885,
0.29180699586868286,
-0.5022666454315186,
-0.24929316341876984,
-0.8869422078132629,
0.2660493552684784,
0.49990636110305786,
-0.1342063695192337,
-0.6359898447990417,
0.4994611442089081,
-0.11160367727279663,
-0.08424485474824905,
-0.12598158419132233,
0.030261272564530373,
0.28564444184303284,
0.43224942684173584,
0.11856433749198914,
0.5996627807617188,
0.6501083970069885,
-0.6733661890029907,
0.7886667251586914,
0.5859778523445129,
-0.7274754047393799,
0.5208157896995544,
-0.7523180842399597,
-0.26011428236961365,
-0.4117366075515747,
0.2148301750421524,
-1.0068665742874146,
-0.28392457962036133,
0.3932041823863983,
-0.7233589887619019,
-0.018957417458295822,
-0.1408231556415558,
-0.11083932965993881,
-0.2879844605922699,
0.0938509926199913,
0.507509171962738,
0.20653441548347473,
-0.5355620980262756,
1.009954810142517,
0.3012916147708893,
-0.19097979366779327,
-0.9013577103614807,
-0.6222482919692993,
-0.018524663522839546,
-0.22128306329250336,
-1.083442211151123,
0.06580396741628647,
0.10797721892595291,
-0.06715906411409378,
0.2651195824146271,
-0.3097432553768158,
-0.564019501209259,
0.4193754494190216,
0.3739897608757019,
0.5501748323440552,
-0.4762762486934662,
0.12973111867904663,
-0.09342733770608902,
-0.11504417657852173,
0.22515884041786194,
-0.3697868883609772,
0.0911284014582634,
0.1816788911819458,
-0.24125586450099945,
-0.3459502160549164,
0.5380945801734924,
0.8962542414665222,
-0.4574196934700012,
0.6814813017845154,
0.3680364787578583,
-0.5903286337852478,
-0.01772281713783741,
-0.5244098901748657,
-0.02365337684750557,
-0.3780151903629303,
0.6278933882713318,
-0.5933448672294617,
-0.9092090725898743,
0.7295454144477844,
0.1077013611793518,
0.30101484060287476,
0.10426323860883713,
0.4956270754337311,
-0.1852964609861374,
0.494474858045578,
0.6344675421714783,
0.23773139715194702,
0.08096175640821457,
0.3441934287548065,
0.32151976227760315,
-0.6966291666030884,
-0.5731618404388428,
-0.20566679537296295,
-0.34734052419662476,
-0.24540242552757263,
-0.11534743756055832,
0.31556111574172974,
0.049729734659194946,
-0.4996376633644104,
0.32373732328414917,
-0.4537341296672821,
0.21537132561206818,
0.7822860479354858,
0.3652227222919464,
0.27712157368659973,
-0.24515362083911896,
-0.1724146157503128,
-0.04202986881136894,
-0.9232337474822998,
-0.3386063873767853,
1.1882227659225464,
0.3470877408981323,
0.7580317258834839,
0.45183101296424866,
0.3878278136253357,
0.13076162338256836,
0.4176682233810425,
-0.4374064803123474,
0.4996269643306732,
0.06597129255533218,
-1.032450556755066,
-0.3184974789619446,
-0.4301377534866333,
-0.25281307101249695,
0.30793261528015137,
-0.41870710253715515,
-0.7286418080329895,
0.4344477653503418,
0.4582623839378357,
-0.5405787825584412,
0.5080460906028748,
-0.8266830444335938,
1.132048487663269,
-0.24901242554187775,
-0.1824100911617279,
0.2827035188674927,
-0.8072504997253418,
0.5464170575141907,
-0.35025185346603394,
-0.046514224261045456,
0.08464433997869492,
-0.07924391329288483,
0.9498816728591919,
-0.3758751451969147,
0.5161389708518982,
-0.5461519956588745,
0.20425377786159515,
0.5214228630065918,
0.2943980097770691,
0.20228300988674164,
0.30466529726982117,
0.2712389826774597,
-0.4181062877178192,
0.4072578549385071,
-0.5607237219810486,
-0.9721460342407227,
0.4151213765144348,
-0.6511449813842773,
-0.7722398638725281,
-0.2096497118473053,
-0.6204614043235779,
-0.5521670579910278,
0.2623549997806549,
0.26336050033569336,
0.6027966141700745,
-0.022119035944342613,
0.09339434653520584,
0.7017260193824768,
-0.36969172954559326,
-0.16857989132404327,
0.7205056548118591,
-0.37143197655677795,
-0.3532719910144806,
0.7427853345870972,
0.11023657768964767,
0.4969930648803711,
0.5429316759109497,
-0.22362349927425385,
-0.4313705563545227,
-0.38727182149887085,
-0.7769892811775208,
-0.16536401212215424,
-0.8824021220207214,
-0.4075336158275604,
-0.597663938999176,
-0.295834481716156,
-0.4571497142314911,
0.021981483325362206,
-0.2676163911819458,
-1.0039101839065552,
0.14773845672607422,
-0.1680712252855301,
0.3334266245365143,
0.5138082504272461,
-0.06424679607152939,
-0.13500048220157623,
-0.4752614498138428,
0.6358416080474854,
0.76069176197052,
0.4287397563457489,
0.1335238665342331,
-0.8195023536682129,
0.08687274903059006,
0.07053865492343903,
-0.1930999457836151,
-1.1287264823913574,
-0.05990775674581528,
0.06646767258644104,
0.5588482022285461,
0.02078135870397091,
0.26853281259536743,
0.5741185545921326,
-0.292618989944458,
0.27566537261009216,
0.05174316465854645,
-0.5302556157112122,
0.3832588195800781,
-0.07832281291484833,
0.08373614400625229,
0.8317112326622009,
0.15277893841266632,
-0.5347779393196106,
-0.15855319797992706,
-0.34991881251335144,
-0.7211902141571045,
0.4756743311882019,
-0.003018376650288701,
-0.19506902992725372,
0.4236331880092621,
0.5971542000770569,
-0.07091528922319412,
0.3143174946308136,
-0.7365837097167969,
-0.22377169132232666,
-0.7755793333053589,
-0.04792853444814682,
0.564325749874115,
-0.2712777256965637,
0.02791358157992363,
-0.08879116922616959,
0.5642346739768982,
0.0687706470489502,
0.409530907869339,
0.2709026336669922,
-0.19557365775108337,
-0.03999067470431328,
0.34911221265792847,
0.010020607151091099,
0.6407961249351501,
-0.4395245313644409,
0.1422269344329834,
0.11489991098642349,
-0.6705811619758606,
0.2637273967266083,
-0.09321946650743484,
-0.5871993899345398,
-0.29854029417037964,
0.38727766275405884,
0.3701508939266205,
-0.057600777596235275,
-0.821664571762085,
0.5539791584014893,
-0.25245141983032227,
-0.4696340560913086,
-0.3090941905975342,
0.09747960418462753,
0.2721162438392639,
0.3871915936470032,
0.2512851655483246,
0.30432936549186707,
-0.006061536259949207,
-0.5543807148933411,
0.4376647174358368,
0.3981291353702545,
-0.4475361108779907,
0.15395700931549072,
0.9592711925506592,
0.1866912990808487,
-0.23453986644744873,
0.932010293006897,
0.12858837842941284,
-0.8170379996299744,
0.8240424394607544,
0.5873687267303467,
0.29450806975364685,
0.11331287771463394,
0.6082739233970642,
0.06385345757007599,
0.4900455176830292,
0.48490309715270996,
0.6662459969520569,
-0.21572665870189667,
-1.0097665786743164,
-0.13208986818790436,
-0.43550774455070496,
-0.5032901763916016,
-0.039369694888591766,
-0.8627649545669556,
-0.21853354573249817,
-0.45944008231163025,
0.11275514960289001,
0.20371519029140472,
-0.15926013886928558,
-0.3214178681373596,
0.6674812436103821,
-0.2853403091430664,
1.682723045349121,
-0.908672571182251,
0.4922363758087158,
0.8250993490219116,
-0.4122979938983917,
-1.1229007244110107,
-0.3586292266845703,
-0.19355852901935577,
-0.915681004524231,
0.5856014490127563,
0.03470867872238159,
0.0986754447221756,
-0.12994956970214844,
-0.5685237646102905,
-0.826964795589447,
1.4921274185180664,
0.3694971799850464,
-0.0061653791926801205,
0.05501667782664299,
0.1658058762550354,
0.1341632902622223,
-0.2175130993127823,
-0.06332534551620483,
0.4060109853744507,
0.5079463124275208,
0.1951393336057663,
-0.6386370062828064,
0.24477870762348175,
-0.5852454900741577,
-0.6024978160858154,
0.22362349927425385,
-0.5363948345184326,
0.7323919534683228,
-0.30537810921669006,
-0.09772755205631256,
0.5703197121620178,
0.6795543432235718,
0.4873782694339752,
0.5033920407295227,
0.6636452674865723,
0.7651476263999939,
0.8220573663711548,
-0.21780794858932495,
0.5258214473724365,
-0.14490161836147308,
-0.09370017796754837,
0.8269338011741638,
-0.05792522802948952,
0.8583343625068665,
0.44200846552848816,
0.07823283225297928,
0.4294604957103729,
0.6570207476615906,
0.24918703734874725,
0.636621356010437,
0.19203881919384003,
-0.32466402649879456,
-0.8874727487564087,
0.06146423891186714,
-0.3929717540740967,
0.6052758693695068,
0.07815539091825485,
-0.05545814707875252,
-0.20978330075740814,
-0.10486982762813568,
-0.2679471969604492,
0.10163174569606781,
-0.31830793619155884,
0.2484797239303589,
-0.097206249833107,
-0.9255151748657227,
0.3450991213321686,
0.10858379304409027,
0.2319008857011795,
-0.3843167722225189,
-0.05990535020828247,
-0.4357374310493469,
-0.09839285165071487,
-0.39036697149276733,
-0.9673711061477661,
0.2074533998966217,
0.07129248231649399,
-0.6001478433609009,
0.3600703477859497,
1.0906405448913574,
-0.045271698385477066,
-0.6640744805335999,
-0.07406336814165115,
1.0192879438400269,
0.0280205886811018,
-0.08955390751361847,
-0.63543301820755,
-0.5285448431968689,
0.031519535928964615,
-0.12900124490261078,
0.1789735108613968,
0.5848730206489563,
-0.2165071815252304,
1.3747069835662842,
0.47474485635757446,
-0.07369214296340942,
0.2901820242404938,
-0.21549125015735626,
1.0835614204406738,
-0.5896367430686951,
-0.5959173440933228,
-0.16098588705062866,
0.4602389633655548,
0.17813949286937714,
-0.39001280069351196,
0.4038403630256653,
0.37179669737815857,
0.21123720705509186,
-0.10070396214723587,
0.6318297982215881,
-0.3596850335597992,
0.8542238473892212,
-0.38547298312187195,
0.842254638671875,
-0.7554938197135925,
0.06066618114709854,
-0.35956451296806335,
-0.7757688164710999,
-0.34644410014152527,
0.5544570088386536,
-0.00838023703545332,
-0.009097863920032978,
0.43691888451576233,
0.9236647486686707,
-0.13910306990146637,
0.18852947652339935,
0.2642647922039032,
0.09161597490310669,
0.11606288701295853,
1.0877922773361206,
1.1597797870635986,
-0.3393671214580536,
0.690629780292511,
-0.12923018634319305,
-0.3989780843257904,
0.10333900153636932,
-0.6018122434616089,
-0.47164544463157654,
-0.6652507781982422,
-0.14182768762111664,
-0.37455782294273376,
0.12087053805589676,
0.2341003268957138,
0.6679345965385437,
-0.747270941734314,
0.3730012774467468,
0.08045894652605057,
0.16095013916492462,
0.03856920823454857,
-0.1556788980960846,
0.35760989785194397,
0.22561706602573395,
0.1511215716600418,
0.10138974338769913,
0.2574903964996338,
-0.11661651730537415,
-0.035624902695417404,
0.08201039582490921,
-0.03496938943862915,
0.09331813454627991,
0.244937464594841,
0.539605438709259,
-0.6277053952217102,
-0.5344206690788269,
0.3894575536251068,
0.29631608724594116,
-0.24251379072666168,
0.5092757344245911,
-1.169135570526123,
0.3516945540904999,
0.35808613896369934,
0.9330047369003296,
0.003899139119312167,
0.15639355778694153,
0.30808815360069275,
-0.388889342546463,
-0.26278653740882874,
0.2043355405330658,
0.34251391887664795,
0.049155060201883316,
-0.2460845410823822,
0.29633212089538574,
0.20319053530693054,
-0.615653932094574,
-0.682019829750061,
0.7167350649833679,
-1.079789161682129,
-0.2635425627231598,
0.47059547901153564,
-0.15722458064556122,
-0.32551878690719604,
-0.6475780606269836,
-0.025940673425793648,
-0.024220161139965057,
0.013018234632909298,
0.6007167100906372,
0.6511520743370056,
-0.2991514801979065,
-0.34772855043411255,
-0.5766103267669678,
0.038912322372198105,
0.5196727514266968,
-0.7560365796089172,
0.1218089684844017,
0.5276924967765808,
0.6831609606742859,
0.16556592285633087,
0.8126249313354492,
-0.0653446763753891,
1.0464228391647339,
0.09888000041246414,
-0.4088222086429596,
-0.5004580020904541,
-0.6560042500495911,
0.2810772657394409,
0.44715616106987,
0.34634238481521606,
-0.27735692262649536
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10838v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10838v1
|
Two-step Automated Cybercrime Coded Word Detection using Multi-level Representation Learning
| 2024-03-16T07:18:29 | 2024-03-16T07:18:29 |
Yongyeon Kim, Byung-Won On, Ingyu Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In social network service platforms, crime suspects are likely to use
cybercrime coded words for communication by adding criminal meanings to
existing words or replacing them with similar words. For instance, the word
'ice' is often used to mean methamphetamine in drug crimes. To analyze the
nature of cybercrime and the behavior of criminals, quickly detecting such
words and further understanding their meaning are critical. In the automated
cybercrime coded word detection problem, it is difficult to collect a
sufficient amount of training data for supervised learning and to directly
apply language models that utilize context information to better understand
natural language. To overcome these limitations, we propose a new two-step
approach, in which a mean latent vector is constructed for each cybercrime
through one of five different AutoEncoder models in the first step, and
cybercrime coded words are detected based on multi-level latent representations
in the second step. Moreover, to deeply understand cybercrime coded words
detected through the two-step approach, we propose three novel methods: (1)
Detection of new words recently coined, (2) Detection of words frequently
appeared in both drug and sex crimes, and (3) Automatic generation of word
taxonomy. According to our experimental results, among various AutoEncoder
models, the stacked AutoEncoder model shows the best performance. Additionally,
the F1-score of the two-step approach is 0.991, which is higher than 0.987 and
0.903 of the existing dark-GloVe and dark-BERT models. By analyzing the
experimental results of the three proposed methods, we can gain a deeper
understanding of drug and sex crimes.
|
[
-0.18323791027069092,
-0.9714205265045166,
0.3039165139198303,
0.06723761558532715,
-0.4738956391811371,
0.47052013874053955,
-0.04276035726070404,
-0.5545041561126709,
0.2577228248119354,
0.5746956467628479,
-0.3012985289096832,
-0.6376456618309021,
-1.002403974533081,
-0.01825517974793911,
-0.7307779788970947,
0.9851599931716919,
-0.12199267745018005,
0.19139529764652252,
-0.013818918727338314,
0.10497361421585083,
-0.6193975210189819,
-0.5754843950271606,
-0.6502156853675842,
-0.24338825047016144,
0.33826708793640137,
0.24249953031539917,
0.36041364073753357,
0.6709592342376709,
0.7239225506782532,
0.3249242901802063,
0.3021117150783539,
0.24777157604694366,
-0.4561835825443268,
-0.023201802745461464,
0.08353891968727112,
-0.4229840338230133,
-0.25087133049964905,
0.012246684171259403,
-0.0857163518667221,
0.3626798093318939,
-0.09393926709890366,
0.09153580665588379,
0.04752209037542343,
0.4696296155452728,
-0.7375496029853821,
0.15003584325313568,
-0.6685956716537476,
0.09369229525327682,
-0.14271992444992065,
-0.42695724964141846,
-0.18344581127166748,
0.11804740130901337,
-0.12266621738672256,
-0.4397662281990051,
0.12902283668518066,
0.020834701135754585,
0.40180301666259766,
-0.004331757314503193,
-0.34113118052482605,
-0.6747755408287048,
-0.733950674533844,
0.6344939470291138,
-0.45569875836372375,
0.27748796343803406,
0.574251651763916,
0.22276444733142853,
-0.0307456087321043,
-0.795937180519104,
-0.7988437414169312,
-0.13907425105571747,
-0.11053657531738281,
-0.15653325617313385,
-0.3829733729362488,
0.09653355181217194,
-0.015521914698183537,
0.2246728390455246,
-0.6978642344474792,
0.15318943560123444,
-0.6023339033126831,
-0.5145722031593323,
0.5204501748085022,
0.24454009532928467,
0.32888972759246826,
-0.2680594325065613,
-0.4556523859500885,
-0.18709538877010345,
-0.34172412753105164,
0.0496276430785656,
0.42110782861709595,
0.4449858069419861,
-0.370123952627182,
0.31178510189056396,
0.0764353945851326,
0.39047786593437195,
-0.002888481365516782,
-0.2443024069070816,
0.4762514531612396,
-0.45001542568206787,
-0.07374869287014008,
-0.037826333194971085,
0.7499220967292786,
0.3020097017288208,
0.12434551864862442,
-0.016219640150666237,
-0.4202518165111542,
0.5066619515419006,
0.42202869057655334,
-0.6401503682136536,
-0.4017975330352783,
0.3917784094810486,
-0.7387740015983582,
-0.6067181825637817,
0.1572798490524292,
-0.7102332711219788,
-0.4119885563850403,
-0.5123334527015686,
0.6530912518501282,
-0.3468794524669647,
-0.34671473503112793,
0.20297342538833618,
-0.2257382720708847,
0.1981702595949173,
-0.010266087017953396,
-0.4931700527667999,
0.6068339943885803,
0.6393315196037292,
0.9298833012580872,
-0.38894107937812805,
-0.13070113956928253,
-0.5646183490753174,
-0.03152080997824669,
-0.3847995698451996,
0.6448502540588379,
-0.5302267670631409,
-0.11422678828239441,
0.08740180730819702,
-0.020109886303544044,
0.10458268225193024,
-0.3766504228115082,
-0.13420362770557404,
-0.7061106562614441,
0.2903832793235779,
0.19845053553581238,
-0.41639357805252075,
-0.24333126842975616,
0.3238922655582428,
-0.35542991757392883,
0.9055095911026001,
0.008983783423900604,
-0.7785964012145996,
0.4266641139984131,
-0.644503116607666,
-0.5757483243942261,
0.29803475737571716,
-0.08042456209659576,
-0.2828656733036041,
-0.05655544251203537,
0.2375471293926239,
0.6055045127868652,
-0.11705268919467926,
0.2805521488189697,
-0.3017125427722931,
-0.5447807908058167,
0.17065389454364777,
-0.2483295500278473,
0.803178071975708,
0.16159281134605408,
-0.5008715987205505,
-0.08782472461462021,
-0.6245103478431702,
-0.2338831126689911,
0.22540509700775146,
-0.14306004345417023,
-0.3843141198158264,
0.05104244500398636,
0.37193992733955383,
0.37370458245277405,
0.304826557636261,
-0.7514030933380127,
-0.030345140025019646,
-0.3924856185913086,
0.39393848180770874,
0.5888183116912842,
0.18105879426002502,
0.22166095674037933,
-0.0345502644777298,
0.599963366985321,
0.35536396503448486,
0.16097337007522583,
-0.1686900556087494,
-0.3152817487716675,
-0.6187067627906799,
-0.20254430174827576,
0.23952771723270416,
0.9815789461135864,
-1.0330432653427124,
0.5892441272735596,
-0.028195654973387718,
-0.22218893468379974,
-0.26574429869651794,
0.14851899445056915,
0.3838334381580353,
0.10525725036859512,
0.7717224955558777,
-0.46216052770614624,
-0.5764446258544922,
-0.7195632457733154,
-0.3346772789955139,
-0.09482438117265701,
-0.058026377111673355,
0.23000387847423553,
1.0736490488052368,
-0.4102526605129242,
0.7426211833953857,
-0.7158023715019226,
-0.6459348797798157,
-0.21372590959072113,
0.7553055882453918,
0.12802088260650635,
0.40319591760635376,
0.5023338198661804,
-0.846204936504364,
-0.4059428870677948,
-0.41493892669677734,
-0.5143148303031921,
0.006207454018294811,
-0.08022728562355042,
0.3275887668132782,
-0.20490583777427673,
0.8714902997016907,
0.16722583770751953,
0.5206570625305176,
0.36712732911109924,
-0.3425922691822052,
0.3516017198562622,
-0.30539581179618835,
0.1308932900428772,
-1.0606341361999512,
-0.19439682364463806,
0.029664689674973488,
-0.2759862244129181,
-0.9702425599098206,
0.12469342350959778,
0.017791924998164177,
-0.1803165227174759,
-0.4379940330982208,
0.19333511590957642,
-0.5769339799880981,
0.0901409313082695,
-0.5216380953788757,
0.2326844483613968,
-0.40342792868614197,
0.6042965650558472,
-0.024253662675619125,
0.6002439856529236,
0.7256116271018982,
-0.6296664476394653,
0.7219971418380737,
-0.04743143171072006,
-0.3011246919631958,
0.5428903102874756,
-0.6088875532150269,
0.38525497913360596,
-0.4176202714443207,
0.23670537769794464,
-1.1110881567001343,
-0.08714725822210312,
0.3682147264480591,
-0.6712245941162109,
0.3115987777709961,
-0.1241719201207161,
-0.6339000463485718,
-0.5045787692070007,
-0.3275308907032013,
0.551082968711853,
0.18893887102603912,
-0.2796110510826111,
0.30634641647338867,
0.9382202625274658,
0.18677707016468048,
-0.5606908202171326,
-1.0746018886566162,
0.4439835250377655,
-0.1509682685136795,
-0.31791460514068604,
0.5087520480155945,
0.09900624305009842,
0.007428569719195366,
-0.20962576568126678,
0.19492372870445251,
-0.35696786642074585,
0.10271082073450089,
-0.027804307639598846,
0.24985727667808533,
0.08240218460559845,
0.03801494091749191,
-0.022891324013471603,
-0.184347003698349,
0.19211439788341522,
-0.5951833724975586,
0.8851233720779419,
0.15756855905056,
-0.09020029753446579,
-0.3217965364456177,
0.6323946118354797,
0.35555005073547363,
-0.3215397298336029,
0.5937869548797607,
0.8836546540260315,
-0.7672469615936279,
-0.23665031790733337,
-0.33122411370277405,
-0.39533036947250366,
-0.4680633544921875,
0.2307988554239273,
-0.10126806050539017,
-0.981170117855072,
0.3497235178947449,
0.22444520890712738,
-0.13149335980415344,
0.10616503655910492,
0.5776559710502625,
0.07437937706708908,
1.0953041315078735,
0.6544342041015625,
-0.3189100921154022,
0.43469515442848206,
-0.41819244623184204,
0.4955803453922272,
-0.5588777661323547,
-0.19014641642570496,
-0.2686447501182556,
-0.19623315334320068,
-0.6792861223220825,
-0.6343773603439331,
0.47587984800338745,
-0.2592319846153259,
-0.06332141160964966,
0.7860345840454102,
-0.39358073472976685,
0.11875668913125992,
0.24725046753883362,
0.46222659945487976,
0.05873209238052368,
0.28901585936546326,
-0.36809080839157104,
0.10497070848941803,
-0.4547717571258545,
-0.2769997715950012,
1.1167116165161133,
0.3726159930229187,
0.40639111399650574,
-0.014532147906720638,
0.7930784821510315,
0.8256571292877197,
-0.05155014619231224,
-0.8429851531982422,
0.4535863697528839,
-0.38883915543556213,
-0.5098022222518921,
-0.11260963976383209,
-0.27712130546569824,
-1.029386281967163,
0.032507702708244324,
-0.45377272367477417,
-0.8793327808380127,
0.3699825704097748,
0.02348627708852291,
-0.3609333634376526,
0.24973562359809875,
0.025814710184931755,
0.6093679070472717,
-0.1339491903781891,
-0.2792569696903229,
-0.6274164319038391,
-0.6662137508392334,
0.3285437524318695,
-0.1950518935918808,
0.7476076483726501,
0.04651561379432678,
-0.1287536770105362,
0.8726688623428345,
-0.505916953086853,
0.9080027937889099,
-0.3374471366405487,
-0.19381356239318848,
0.26212960481643677,
0.11905369907617569,
0.4555915296077728,
-0.23820917308330536,
0.4867195785045624,
0.2643565237522125,
-0.07722502201795578,
-0.2376958429813385,
-0.355819970369339,
0.3539724051952362,
-0.45935148000717163,
-0.006543424911797047,
-0.3402349054813385,
-0.3744627833366394,
0.020457474514842033,
0.2621346712112427,
0.3112209737300873,
0.7613877654075623,
-0.029395874589681625,
0.1977062225341797,
0.5831729173660278,
-0.28781217336654663,
0.3205296993255615,
0.3846794664859772,
-0.08507706224918365,
-0.5879207253456116,
0.9607024192810059,
-0.08300269395112991,
-0.07480673491954803,
0.5617266893386841,
0.11804267019033432,
-0.15980525314807892,
-0.6433899998664856,
-0.1173190325498581,
0.1507844775915146,
-0.5239629149436951,
-0.3180454969406128,
-0.8747712969779968,
0.02348286658525467,
-0.6570553779602051,
-0.04215474799275398,
-0.08844003826379776,
-0.03230837732553482,
-0.266226589679718,
0.2819516062736511,
0.3272957503795624,
0.5838150978088379,
-0.2492971569299698,
0.45704934000968933,
-0.7812179327011108,
0.8376662135124207,
0.12335799634456635,
0.25438395142555237,
-0.0671660527586937,
-0.6337624192237854,
-0.3236258029937744,
0.09482400119304657,
0.005496225319802761,
-1.1461870670318604,
0.5028876066207886,
-0.006857132539153099,
0.26286035776138306,
0.4837069511413574,
-0.12459904700517654,
0.5529930591583252,
-0.32901644706726074,
0.8141112327575684,
0.2845580279827118,
-0.9627338647842407,
0.5680950284004211,
-0.3799743354320526,
-0.022129181772470474,
0.5573927164077759,
0.47544988989830017,
-0.7680333852767944,
-0.26183098554611206,
-0.39799264073371887,
-0.866413414478302,
0.5828260183334351,
0.21273404359817505,
0.34121009707450867,
-0.18658258020877838,
0.20734049379825592,
-0.12057743966579437,
0.5070580244064331,
-0.7676823735237122,
-0.4485134482383728,
-0.04683762416243553,
-0.1459798812866211,
0.17215830087661743,
-0.2843270003795624,
0.27514421939849854,
-0.05092732235789299,
0.5861431360244751,
-0.2103533297777176,
0.6586159467697144,
-0.05408040061593056,
-0.44440987706184387,
0.052557703107595444,
0.00879001710563898,
0.23701490461826324,
0.4011452794075012,
0.14044053852558136,
0.05394896864891052,
0.05485566705465317,
-0.8829930424690247,
0.24240754544734955,
-0.045706506818532944,
-0.039578843861818314,
-0.21603016555309296,
0.5464980602264404,
0.5248939990997314,
0.08148641884326935,
-0.4997099041938782,
1.0268000364303589,
-0.02847089059650898,
-0.3368539810180664,
-0.4982924163341522,
0.026718169450759888,
-0.28272953629493713,
0.14817634224891663,
0.45082250237464905,
-0.01351921446621418,
0.48261380195617676,
-0.6669967174530029,
0.5612547993659973,
0.45299169421195984,
-0.5381426215171814,
0.11042145639657974,
0.39453125,
-0.03973554074764252,
-0.41252556443214417,
0.554412305355072,
-0.4515697956085205,
-0.9090648293495178,
0.6015943288803101,
0.6267892718315125,
0.8697130084037781,
-0.21364934742450714,
0.23779253661632538,
0.27602192759513855,
0.3575792610645294,
-0.15769602358341217,
0.5889881253242493,
-0.1522403061389923,
-0.9976263046264648,
-0.23420929908752441,
-0.4928661584854126,
0.17824216187000275,
0.432898610830307,
-0.732605516910553,
0.3708280920982361,
-0.5788694620132446,
-0.14239619672298431,
-0.10366500169038773,
-0.08834540098905563,
-0.6414656639099121,
0.23216722905635834,
0.3673287630081177,
0.5794815421104431,
-1.1339070796966553,
0.5238599181175232,
0.5051501393318176,
-0.1730974018573761,
-0.5098510980606079,
0.04323509335517883,
0.31407439708709717,
-0.7169592976570129,
0.5415894389152527,
0.3235653042793274,
-0.2127687931060791,
-0.023957204073667526,
-0.7041783332824707,
-0.8908091187477112,
0.9136879444122314,
-0.34363624453544617,
-0.5932214260101318,
-0.009627124294638634,
0.22804197669029236,
0.5946062803268433,
-0.6384494304656982,
0.009722195565700531,
0.6372816562652588,
0.3272799253463745,
-0.12220125645399094,
-0.5733582377433777,
-0.03970475122332573,
-0.30012592673301697,
0.07588578760623932,
0.4198485314846039,
-0.055696796625852585,
0.8957149386405945,
0.06106853112578392,
-0.3377881646156311,
-0.18326324224472046,
0.6745981574058533,
0.10410523414611816,
0.2594931125640869,
0.8286256194114685,
0.3493432104587555,
0.5095534324645996,
0.11538353562355042,
0.6428754329681396,
-0.4916969835758209,
0.3936670422554016,
0.7681746482849121,
0.1421283334493637,
0.5746389031410217,
0.251516193151474,
-0.24636444449424744,
0.7713623046875,
0.49219921231269836,
-0.4379816949367523,
0.45170092582702637,
0.5547414422035217,
-0.05857785791158676,
-0.29137086868286133,
0.05292332172393799,
0.18882165849208832,
0.9132394790649414,
0.7045181393623352,
-0.38578376173973083,
-0.16783380508422852,
0.45317205786705017,
0.0019509203266352415,
0.06811623275279999,
-0.37964287400245667,
0.8668238520622253,
0.06312808394432068,
-0.2764754593372345,
0.4189537465572357,
0.4362654983997345,
0.8602631688117981,
-0.40319353342056274,
-0.15506009757518768,
0.15090201795101166,
0.07608233392238617,
-0.19630712270736694,
-0.4561913013458252,
0.16282056272029877,
0.06160921975970268,
0.15616343915462494,
-0.056975044310092926,
1.0086344480514526,
-0.5987347960472107,
-0.48844677209854126,
0.5988548398017883,
0.2647557258605957,
0.3548935651779175,
-0.1271384060382843,
-1.0500519275665283,
-0.3098028600215912,
-0.2922697067260742,
0.23079192638397217,
0.012724637985229492,
0.09627102315425873,
0.059976112097501755,
0.4746007025241852,
0.8440206050872803,
0.3653303384780884,
-0.1379317343235016,
0.061109766364097595,
0.7112395167350769,
-0.34120285511016846,
-0.9214559197425842,
-0.8719725012779236,
0.22348785400390625,
-0.20060963928699493,
-0.20184101164340973,
0.5123886466026306,
0.5027082562446594,
0.8511935472488403,
0.14666539430618286,
0.7220196723937988,
-0.15531599521636963,
0.5367986559867859,
-0.5983458161354065,
0.35717615485191345,
-0.5513104200363159,
0.36617571115493774,
-0.5491755604743958,
-0.6794752478599548,
-0.3980250358581543,
0.7079350352287292,
-0.22309347987174988,
0.002223486313596368,
0.7725878357887268,
0.925140917301178,
-0.2553560733795166,
-0.14261984825134277,
0.07529733330011368,
0.07738147675991058,
0.18540304899215698,
0.43731725215911865,
0.3588121831417084,
-0.7115740776062012,
0.40967345237731934,
-0.2708468437194824,
-0.4387262463569641,
-0.2548148036003113,
-0.8285655379295349,
-1.0157603025436401,
-0.562038779258728,
-0.2217288464307785,
-0.3295166492462158,
0.03920130431652069,
1.095445990562439,
0.5950576066970825,
-1.0006628036499023,
-0.29183658957481384,
-0.13907423615455627,
-0.14362266659736633,
-0.38382279872894287,
-0.21923138201236725,
0.25790873169898987,
-0.281482994556427,
-0.35395053029060364,
0.5193957090377808,
0.2685120701789856,
-0.06686984747648239,
-0.5087043046951294,
0.33543455600738525,
-0.33344653248786926,
0.11920703947544098,
0.7240326404571533,
-0.3291723132133484,
-0.35836654901504517,
-0.19507457315921783,
0.013571423478424549,
-0.10376202315092087,
0.010603598318994045,
1.2390753030776978,
-0.7331573963165283,
0.3691961169242859,
0.6991754770278931,
0.556029200553894,
0.6058246493339539,
-0.20029374957084656,
0.5693936944007874,
-0.6165384650230408,
-0.07895706593990326,
0.23518915474414825,
0.3670901954174042,
0.2529093027114868,
-0.5083316564559937,
0.061324067413806915,
0.5503115653991699,
-0.2207297384738922,
-0.5227539539337158,
0.4034743010997772,
-0.39065396785736084,
-0.7866169810295105,
0.9056881070137024,
-0.0159650556743145,
-0.12130260467529297,
-0.7254116535186768,
0.1948811113834381,
0.40440183877944946,
-0.2227591574192047,
0.8343589305877686,
0.3797949552536011,
0.13618303835391998,
0.007577995304018259,
-0.5669173002243042,
0.40591195225715637,
-0.14072342216968536,
-0.5223578214645386,
0.18335387110710144,
0.38926073908805847,
0.26102253794670105,
0.4022843539714813,
0.5693891644477844,
-0.24244043231010437,
0.29280149936676025,
-0.06408088654279709,
-0.1335301250219345,
-0.11537058651447296,
-0.5910869836807251,
-0.5675231218338013,
0.2485714852809906,
-0.7179239392280579,
-0.14043556153774261
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10829v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10829v1
|
Deciphering Hate: Identifying Hateful Memes and Their Targets
| 2024-03-16T06:39:41 | 2024-03-16T06:39:41 |
Eftekhar Hossain, Omar Sharif, Mohammed Moshiul Hoque, Sarah M. Preum
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Internet memes have become a powerful means for individuals to express
emotions, thoughts, and perspectives on social media. While often considered as
a source of humor and entertainment, memes can also disseminate hateful content
targeting individuals or communities. Most existing research focuses on the
negative aspects of memes in high-resource languages, overlooking the
distinctive challenges associated with low-resource languages like Bengali
(also known as Bangla). Furthermore, while previous work on Bengali memes has
focused on detecting hateful memes, there has been no work on detecting their
targeted entities. To bridge this gap and facilitate research in this arena, we
introduce a novel multimodal dataset for Bengali, BHM (Bengali Hateful Memes).
The dataset consists of 7,148 memes with Bengali as well as code-mixed
captions, tailored for two tasks: (i) detecting hateful memes, and (ii)
detecting the social entities they target (i.e., Individual, Organization,
Community, and Society). To solve these tasks, we propose DORA (Dual cO
attention fRAmework), a multimodal deep neural network that systematically
extracts the significant modality features from the memes and jointly evaluates
them with the modality-specific features to understand the context better. Our
experiments show that DORA is generalizable on other low-resource hateful meme
datasets and outperforms several state-of-the-art rivaling baselines.
|
[
-0.5515388250350952,
-0.7257619500160217,
0.06768245995044708,
0.41923707723617554,
-0.42081019282341003,
0.37925615906715393,
-0.05829625204205513,
-0.4329582750797272,
0.6424604654312134,
0.2106185406446457,
-0.7618889808654785,
-0.22752010822296143,
-0.964206874370575,
0.21176062524318695,
-0.26859116554260254,
0.8789429068565369,
0.2895950675010681,
-0.17241865396499634,
0.13573405146598816,
-0.4684391915798187,
-0.34328657388687134,
-0.48861634731292725,
-0.5651407241821289,
0.2434050440788269,
1.1746876239776611,
0.41077443957328796,
0.5594425797462463,
0.22687861323356628,
0.603491485118866,
0.2096385657787323,
0.08915500342845917,
0.1747850775718689,
-0.6504152417182922,
0.13186728954315186,
-0.3759011924266815,
-0.23030495643615723,
-0.05440891906619072,
0.20836058259010315,
0.15031012892723083,
0.3166838586330414,
0.22375811636447906,
0.3654296100139618,
-0.08752960711717606,
0.47828951478004456,
-0.9216515421867371,
-0.023094112053513527,
-0.8423779010772705,
0.04122485592961311,
-0.41401827335357666,
-0.23445965349674225,
-0.25135472416877747,
-0.2057192325592041,
-0.11700195074081421,
-0.31652477383613586,
0.2523939907550812,
0.13029897212982178,
0.6093084216117859,
0.2916695475578308,
-0.7696530222892761,
-0.6334336400032043,
-0.3377523124217987,
1.2517486810684204,
-0.4446207880973816,
0.4349864721298218,
0.2766473591327667,
0.31721317768096924,
0.17396041750907898,
-0.045453689992427826,
-0.7186983823776245,
0.11087912321090698,
-0.06240431219339371,
-0.1639566868543625,
-0.5319926738739014,
-0.34269359707832336,
0.11031235009431839,
0.396660715341568,
-0.8503214120864868,
0.015804443508386612,
-0.5681865811347961,
-0.5150667428970337,
0.6020677089691162,
0.12384293228387833,
0.6491503119468689,
-0.6589206457138062,
-0.6349726915359497,
-0.031563542783260345,
-0.5926888585090637,
-0.16393253207206726,
0.5315186381340027,
0.24566252529621124,
-0.2743985652923584,
0.6022754311561584,
0.1517593115568161,
0.6516330242156982,
-0.0950852483510971,
-0.26172253489494324,
0.26500874757766724,
-0.02649676240980625,
-0.12511441111564636,
-0.08331793546676636,
0.658976674079895,
0.6473920941352844,
0.40669748187065125,
-0.014632473699748516,
0.07865848392248154,
0.5896748304367065,
0.4073195159435272,
-0.7885795831680298,
-0.26621541380882263,
-0.12461213767528534,
-0.5851395130157471,
-0.4847516119480133,
-0.6062399744987488,
-1.177388072013855,
-0.7991669774055481,
-0.0406523272395134,
0.20300334692001343,
-0.3446910083293915,
-0.3297690749168396,
-0.448727548122406,
-0.24268849194049835,
-0.0651756301522255,
0.25818192958831787,
-0.8446828126907349,
-0.04063070937991142,
0.4748625159263611,
0.9489033818244934,
0.05715155601501465,
0.038958653807640076,
-0.49682191014289856,
0.08162982761859894,
-0.22662396728992462,
0.6254324316978455,
-0.887535035610199,
0.16837549209594727,
-0.05006565898656845,
-0.013482033275067806,
-0.05162704363465309,
-0.6327318549156189,
0.5435417890548706,
-0.777393102645874,
-0.19747327268123627,
-0.03200998157262802,
-0.14347921311855316,
-0.6847659349441528,
0.5414721965789795,
-0.8865692615509033,
0.28111934661865234,
0.2560020685195923,
-0.6266646385192871,
0.3204222321510315,
-0.511289656162262,
-0.5633925199508667,
-0.10829239338636398,
-0.11783120036125183,
-0.3403185307979584,
0.14926251769065857,
0.013818321749567986,
0.6957638263702393,
-0.3290945589542389,
-0.009201004169881344,
-0.5137463808059692,
-0.07484618574380875,
0.12390192598104477,
-0.45071759819984436,
0.801405131816864,
0.7124196290969849,
-0.29720136523246765,
0.0763091966509819,
-0.9092932939529419,
-0.4659339189529419,
0.3893032670021057,
-0.16617383062839508,
-0.8616375923156738,
-0.11957091093063354,
0.29858478903770447,
0.28507933020591736,
0.11126402765512466,
-0.7872691750526428,
-0.13110944628715515,
0.031220151111483574,
0.41946589946746826,
0.8827226161956787,
-0.1672496199607849,
0.2159937471151352,
-0.29389381408691406,
0.7124636173248291,
0.3736065924167633,
0.21885865926742554,
0.02136125974357128,
-0.5544019341468811,
-0.38077405095100403,
-0.4471346139907837,
-0.2733551561832428,
0.2115490436553955,
-0.6644467711448669,
-0.07864689826965332,
0.08626450598239899,
-0.2730070650577545,
-0.7736779451370239,
0.34492525458335876,
0.40831655263900757,
0.33350759744644165,
0.6663632988929749,
-0.24021993577480316,
-1.0194460153579712,
-1.2053340673446655,
-0.1416102647781372,
0.06961889564990997,
0.2648976445198059,
0.33621200919151306,
0.2974150478839874,
-0.556664228439331,
0.27509745955467224,
-0.23578724265098572,
-0.4688552916049957,
-0.13047629594802856,
0.3130265176296234,
0.004427506122738123,
0.24291802942752838,
0.7442940473556519,
-1.199620008468628,
-0.7061336636543274,
-0.3093782067298889,
-0.5805709958076477,
-0.17310257256031036,
-0.03444245830178261,
-0.03190907835960388,
-0.013631900772452354,
0.18412943184375763,
0.2977558672428131,
0.33930283784866333,
0.9864703416824341,
-0.4962022006511688,
0.4935752749443054,
0.5044406056404114,
0.6659207940101624,
-0.9567564725875854,
-0.13598373532295227,
0.105857715010643,
-0.052860528230667114,
-0.36708399653434753,
-0.25637009739875793,
-0.037698280066251755,
-0.08942646533250809,
-0.3889527916908264,
0.49991852045059204,
-0.4263993799686432,
0.13772790133953094,
-0.04766476899385452,
-0.24146509170532227,
-0.08222862333059311,
0.47127974033355713,
-0.3033093512058258,
0.694056510925293,
0.21330508589744568,
-0.31163591146469116,
0.5183793306350708,
0.2917959988117218,
-0.4296071231365204,
0.7788010835647583,
-0.18278516829013824,
0.06384321302175522,
-0.10692156851291656,
-0.2505404055118561,
-1.134703278541565,
-0.24322925508022308,
0.7012582421302795,
-0.40512147545814514,
0.16180692613124847,
-0.4371434152126312,
-0.4266827404499054,
-0.30909162759780884,
-0.29066234827041626,
1.0616378784179688,
0.31757649779319763,
-0.5836808681488037,
0.25970932841300964,
0.5887279510498047,
-0.07100341469049454,
-0.7043160796165466,
-0.7027731537818909,
0.2710454761981964,
-0.45322856307029724,
-0.47487595677375793,
-0.007648051716387272,
-0.2725028693675995,
-0.28837746381759644,
0.007229621987789869,
0.17268574237823486,
-0.39555951952934265,
0.03726544231176376,
0.44827067852020264,
-0.24894389510154724,
-0.09428124129772186,
0.00523751275613904,
0.010103960521519184,
0.0016350799705833197,
-0.0834442675113678,
0.24949076771736145,
0.6916937828063965,
0.124739870429039,
-0.28254434466362,
-0.24580252170562744,
0.6543304920196533,
0.8936105966567993,
-0.331529825925827,
0.4552137553691864,
0.7163137793540955,
-0.3036544919013977,
-0.32822370529174805,
-0.6808885931968689,
0.029411789029836655,
-0.399511456489563,
0.2532337009906769,
-0.3901658058166504,
-0.892130970954895,
0.43515676259994507,
0.10341688990592957,
-0.2980019152164459,
0.21856994926929474,
0.5654841661453247,
-0.03952355682849884,
0.9610049724578857,
0.5290940403938293,
-0.3807906210422516,
0.42241644859313965,
-0.1122124195098877,
0.40677410364151,
-0.8586880564689636,
-0.1746366173028946,
-0.24377930164337158,
-0.7827844023704529,
-0.24216623604297638,
-0.6843936443328857,
0.4560782015323639,
-0.281628280878067,
-0.04029649868607521,
0.24678944051265717,
-0.5873814225196838,
0.339128702878952,
0.4994688630104065,
0.0729699432849884,
0.150671124458313,
0.3078567087650299,
0.0995376706123352,
-0.5281481742858887,
-0.38736218214035034,
-0.3787747919559479,
1.1253305673599243,
0.2525034248828888,
0.8370863795280457,
0.46769484877586365,
0.4097694754600525,
0.840438961982727,
0.2983347475528717,
-0.7784143686294556,
0.3496730625629425,
-0.3710577189922333,
-0.862345814704895,
0.023275384679436684,
-0.3647138774394989,
-1.0270603895187378,
0.086180679500103,
-0.003952694591134787,
-0.28241539001464844,
0.04960276931524277,
0.10977412015199661,
-0.029951587319374084,
0.5378324389457703,
-0.48380064964294434,
0.9894184470176697,
-0.2479744255542755,
-0.29519084095954895,
-0.7671090960502625,
-0.6016707420349121,
0.43126118183135986,
0.08837448060512543,
0.6261288523674011,
-0.40494292974472046,
-0.08989846706390381,
0.8285039663314819,
0.07318370044231415,
1.0097285509109497,
-0.1013045459985733,
-0.08837054669857025,
0.40373948216438293,
0.35493946075439453,
-0.1535709649324417,
-0.37982073426246643,
-0.0701482892036438,
0.2894735038280487,
-0.29094812273979187,
-0.7935242652893066,
-0.4914998710155487,
0.7574602365493774,
-0.4601055979728699,
-0.033452361822128296,
-0.2692670226097107,
-0.804804265499115,
-0.025757309049367905,
0.18133999407291412,
-0.05282580479979515,
0.5963797569274902,
-0.20890311896800995,
0.20880350470542908,
0.4785401523113251,
-0.22628487646579742,
0.2427985519170761,
0.29335352778434753,
-0.043404582887887955,
-0.4312538504600525,
1.3476155996322632,
0.2145087867975235,
-0.02916899137198925,
0.37576213479042053,
-0.009196982719004154,
-0.27873921394348145,
-0.5460279583930969,
-0.5935338735580444,
0.17711451649665833,
-0.6749037504196167,
-0.1645744889974594,
-0.5570603609085083,
0.1859346330165863,
-0.3385469317436218,
-0.3692528009414673,
-0.2203282117843628,
-0.06602443009614944,
-0.19230175018310547,
0.23721131682395935,
0.17569348216056824,
1.094092845916748,
-0.4415135085582733,
0.15566980838775635,
-0.6727613806724548,
0.5116450786590576,
0.5758394002914429,
0.2741515338420868,
0.28651461005210876,
-0.6261491179466248,
-0.1365470588207245,
0.0591927133500576,
-0.22159475088119507,
-1.2163820266723633,
0.4546518623828888,
-0.004375591408461332,
0.2652813792228699,
0.8356190323829651,
0.12118064612150192,
0.6019601821899414,
-0.37756070494651794,
0.5372886061668396,
0.42850473523139954,
-0.5028004050254822,
0.5322991609573364,
-0.3369959592819214,
-0.28256264328956604,
0.36149197816848755,
0.9306312203407288,
-0.6797633767127991,
-0.28436610102653503,
-0.506857693195343,
-0.4946700632572174,
0.37544912099838257,
0.005768615752458572,
0.38154828548431396,
-0.46769365668296814,
-0.05067687854170799,
0.2956431806087494,
0.4058297276496887,
-0.8172346949577332,
-0.39910614490509033,
-0.22684019804000854,
-0.35843124985694885,
-0.14367201924324036,
-0.816249668598175,
-0.1971874088048935,
-0.17586100101470947,
0.5538356304168701,
0.00023971317568793893,
0.023704878985881805,
-0.0988709107041359,
-0.5081036686897278,
-0.3181586265563965,
0.1526220589876175,
0.5878612399101257,
0.41044601798057556,
-0.326622873544693,
0.6049726009368896,
-0.3312787711620331,
-0.40048810839653015,
0.30570948123931885,
-0.2632451057434082,
0.006670130416750908,
-0.005657394882291555,
0.37950167059898376,
0.3858467936515808,
0.3378971219062805,
-0.9388147592544556,
0.7365403771400452,
0.12439900636672974,
0.12110120058059692,
-0.0966377705335617,
-0.28810036182403564,
-0.1684814989566803,
0.540635347366333,
0.25945842266082764,
0.2003953754901886,
0.3351120054721832,
-0.6783521175384521,
0.4565146863460541,
0.5117478966712952,
-0.5820279717445374,
-0.6758736968040466,
0.4904271066188812,
0.2687167227268219,
-0.18814939260482788,
0.2737041413784027,
-0.4907393753528595,
-0.8686831593513489,
0.6932610273361206,
0.6313507556915283,
0.578242838382721,
-0.38297855854034424,
0.5001785755157471,
0.5672208666801453,
0.5078004002571106,
0.8034515380859375,
0.1843554973602295,
-0.15276558697223663,
-0.7436431050300598,
-0.002900281921029091,
-0.9466990232467651,
-0.19249731302261353,
0.5105656385421753,
-0.562452495098114,
-0.004713369999080896,
-0.6776389479637146,
0.21127808094024658,
0.18521076440811157,
-0.07102974504232407,
-0.5982303619384766,
0.43758872151374817,
0.5308329463005066,
0.4227387607097626,
-0.9734055995941162,
0.22060097754001617,
0.7511011362075806,
-0.6220546364784241,
-0.3832114338874817,
-0.2205110490322113,
0.4352037012577057,
-1.1372939348220825,
0.5638254284858704,
0.33247700333595276,
-0.023332985118031502,
0.06351476162672043,
-0.7456514239311218,
-0.5753890872001648,
0.456965833902359,
0.04229426383972168,
-0.4987398386001587,
0.3012498617172241,
-0.07317297905683517,
0.3461305797100067,
-0.5053507089614868,
0.12765611708164215,
0.24319927394390106,
0.4516887664794922,
0.0491463802754879,
-0.5117167830467224,
0.14861105382442474,
-0.4413512051105499,
-0.4067903161048889,
0.12936696410179138,
-0.8757209777832031,
1.0086010694503784,
-0.24576802551746368,
-0.10365329682826996,
-0.31840837001800537,
0.43110716342926025,
-0.14345170557498932,
0.6162198781967163,
0.7934216260910034,
0.6071609854698181,
0.5377914905548096,
0.4347488582134247,
0.6781513094902039,
0.12412435561418533,
0.18851621448993683,
0.9453960061073303,
0.1772920936346054,
0.4869902729988098,
0.5604038834571838,
-0.2267921417951584,
0.6884533166885376,
0.5215029120445251,
-0.28508278727531433,
0.7054797410964966,
0.40270310640335083,
-0.412692129611969,
-0.34444841742515564,
-0.4949924051761627,
-0.22546948492527008,
0.5088974833488464,
0.47502705454826355,
-0.357674777507782,
-0.6074954271316528,
0.4078376889228821,
0.10465303808450699,
0.36668217182159424,
-0.4069943130016327,
0.6877624988555908,
-0.0662870928645134,
-0.12183155119419098,
0.8263995051383972,
-0.18098819255828857,
0.9528933763504028,
-0.42968177795410156,
-0.1479034572839737,
0.15326352417469025,
0.14416764676570892,
-0.3043510913848877,
-0.43956711888313293,
0.6269664168357849,
0.18210874497890472,
-0.6346002817153931,
0.05919649079442024,
0.5675442218780518,
-0.5775870680809021,
-0.3782999515533447,
0.7454884052276611,
0.32735058665275574,
0.3821238577365875,
-0.3950067460536957,
-0.8918558955192566,
0.44414499402046204,
0.20294415950775146,
0.013181623071432114,
0.39289331436157227,
0.407932847738266,
-0.04738442599773407,
0.6241763234138489,
0.5274446606636047,
-0.0067338282242417336,
0.4409305453300476,
0.23577234148979187,
0.7351386547088623,
-0.5508819818496704,
-0.23071449995040894,
-0.776825487613678,
0.2853209972381592,
-0.06307394802570343,
-0.27210843563079834,
0.8001114130020142,
0.6294663548469543,
0.8298527598381042,
-0.21968163549900055,
0.9942542314529419,
-0.2866494059562683,
0.8638965487480164,
0.03835568204522133,
0.7243883013725281,
-1.1349989175796509,
-0.2825546860694885,
-0.27053698897361755,
-0.5100582838058472,
-0.3356671631336212,
0.6632622480392456,
-0.3902702033519745,
-0.29843398928642273,
0.3226865828037262,
0.9061325192451477,
-0.35521844029426575,
-0.10120239108800888,
0.6222183108329773,
0.5028799772262573,
0.36988145112991333,
0.7091265916824341,
1.1483311653137207,
-0.44133055210113525,
0.8085625171661377,
-0.5731446146965027,
-0.43855348229408264,
-0.5540668368339539,
-0.48908519744873047,
-1.1299294233322144,
-0.7192332744598389,
-0.14721378684043884,
-0.2827550172805786,
-0.025457214564085007,
0.8996312618255615,
0.6119752526283264,
-1.0438610315322876,
0.018780861049890518,
0.3692351281642914,
0.5117599368095398,
0.09129223227500916,
-0.22747467458248138,
0.18280890583992004,
-0.3498797118663788,
-0.8653587102890015,
0.5778260827064514,
0.4437792897224426,
-0.1940869688987732,
-0.20602987706661224,
0.009975356981158257,
-0.6108283996582031,
0.20098203420639038,
0.7329403162002563,
0.1900300532579422,
-0.7028099298477173,
-0.3871232271194458,
-0.27407029271125793,
-0.19352665543556213,
-0.019983921200037003,
0.8245874047279358,
-0.37928110361099243,
0.6640689373016357,
0.2844165563583374,
0.6441118121147156,
-0.00793304480612278,
0.07421335577964783,
0.02500525489449501,
-0.68403160572052,
0.3827486038208008,
0.5519075989723206,
0.20294758677482605,
0.426147997379303,
-0.25131627917289734,
0.488398939371109,
0.5831287503242493,
-0.3048429787158966,
-0.8565094470977783,
0.4216347336769104,
-1.1160664558410645,
-0.36122992634773254,
0.9008216857910156,
0.06287579983472824,
-0.31664615869522095,
-0.48818439245224,
-0.35609325766563416,
0.22398900985717773,
-0.41596150398254395,
1.062660574913025,
0.5985255837440491,
0.2455657720565796,
-0.09980549663305283,
-0.24742932617664337,
0.4727197289466858,
0.6420329809188843,
-0.3184870183467865,
-0.158817857503891,
0.7661442756652832,
0.2851240932941437,
0.5323126912117004,
0.5535745024681091,
0.08614424616098404,
0.33002740144729614,
0.06253829598426819,
0.12870384752750397,
-0.08842552453279495,
-0.69432133436203,
-0.09143202751874924,
0.6090140342712402,
-0.5265921354293823,
-0.35115545988082886
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10827v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10827v2
|
Multi-party Response Generation with Relation Disentanglement
| 2024-03-16T06:33:44 | 2024-03-23T02:19:18 |
Tianhao Dai, Chengyu Huang, Lizi Liao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Existing neural response generation models have achieved impressive
improvements for two-party conversations, which assume that utterances are
sequentially organized. However, many real-world dialogues involve multiple
interlocutors and the structure of conversational context is much more complex,
e.g. utterances from different interlocutors can occur "in parallel". Facing
this challenge, there are works trying to model the relations among utterances
or interlocutors to facilitate response generation with clearer context.
Nonetheless, these methods rely heavily on such relations and all assume that
these are given beforehand, which is impractical and hinders the generality of
such methods. In this work, we propose to automatically infer the relations via
relational thinking on subtle clues inside the conversation context without any
human label, and leverage these relations to guide the neural response
generation. Specifically, we first apply a deep graph random process to fully
consider all possible relations among utterances in the conversational context.
Then the inferred relation graphs are integrated with a variational
auto-encoder framework to train a GAN for structure-aware response generation.
Experimental results on the Ubuntu Internet Relay Chat (IRC) channel benchmark
and the most recent Movie Dialogues show that our method outperforms various
baseline models for multi-party response generation.
|
[
-0.5927717089653015,
-0.9392345547676086,
0.37123027443885803,
0.313701868057251,
-0.22430871427059174,
0.19627797603607178,
0.01175859197974205,
-0.39779430627822876,
0.3536500036716461,
0.18923993408679962,
-0.8659797310829163,
0.07058071345090866,
-0.30716991424560547,
0.06111609563231468,
-0.12459893524646759,
1.069726586341858,
0.4229038953781128,
0.08274514228105545,
-0.35763293504714966,
-0.22523583471775055,
-0.25256919860839844,
-0.5700293183326721,
-0.663221538066864,
-0.6452078223228455,
0.5956799983978271,
0.16929493844509125,
0.5491687655448914,
0.2527669668197632,
0.5133572816848755,
0.38387370109558105,
-0.14883515238761902,
0.26051270961761475,
-0.4354653060436249,
0.4305507242679596,
-0.14400525391101837,
-0.2589508593082428,
-0.4400089979171753,
-0.20910149812698364,
0.3929339051246643,
0.6569734215736389,
-0.43001076579093933,
0.1395774632692337,
0.17391934990882874,
0.7946567535400391,
-0.625829815864563,
0.227871373295784,
-0.8299424648284912,
0.22213423252105713,
0.08919839560985565,
-0.07679887115955353,
-0.5216766595840454,
-0.09884020686149597,
0.19823846220970154,
-0.25458014011383057,
0.30657726526260376,
-0.01773168332874775,
0.7530363202095032,
0.26567885279655457,
-0.4741925001144409,
-0.33473140001296997,
-0.9692089557647705,
0.056801632046699524,
-0.7850120067596436,
0.11828934401273727,
0.13865213096141815,
0.4176769256591797,
-0.43264514207839966,
-0.7904475331306458,
-0.7871894836425781,
-0.1256936490535736,
-0.3622680902481079,
0.25087547302246094,
-0.101748026907444,
0.18492110073566437,
0.4850986897945404,
0.24904868006706238,
-0.43381136655807495,
-0.2908025085926056,
0.06821555644273758,
0.09938299655914307,
0.46157535910606384,
0.38054245710372925,
0.05191706120967865,
-0.38503962755203247,
-0.45815688371658325,
-0.04944326728582382,
-0.4408540427684784,
-0.16072632372379303,
0.571258008480072,
0.1887115091085434,
-0.04091154411435127,
0.3227970600128174,
-0.1318846344947815,
0.5687610507011414,
0.5501136779785156,
0.3345288634300232,
0.057993676513433456,
-0.6201842427253723,
-0.18014086782932281,
-0.041518211364746094,
1.3414164781570435,
0.2807544767856598,
0.17699527740478516,
-0.11985307931900024,
0.20573720335960388,
0.19757357239723206,
0.09905946254730225,
-1.0376033782958984,
-0.6104270219802856,
0.11761003732681274,
-0.2744482457637787,
-0.07732775062322617,
-0.11215391010046005,
-0.9392752647399902,
-0.26553887128829956,
-0.02847607620060444,
-0.012351274490356445,
-0.4021058976650238,
-0.6389267444610596,
-0.37134215235710144,
-0.07861090451478958,
0.18948575854301453,
-0.03608749061822891,
-0.8581749200820923,
0.4326411187648773,
0.16069015860557556,
0.4303020238876343,
0.21275892853736877,
-0.1473039835691452,
-0.767635703086853,
0.3234238624572754,
-0.0737701803445816,
0.7520092129707336,
-0.4359200894832611,
-0.05607914552092552,
-0.33650752902030945,
-0.3502422571182251,
0.056791119277477264,
-0.34311649203300476,
0.035837892442941666,
-0.6519185304641724,
0.3793678283691406,
-0.15701813995838165,
-0.5105235576629639,
0.19649219512939453,
0.34414491057395935,
-0.5878220200538635,
0.38042423129081726,
-0.03163013979792595,
-1.2308510541915894,
0.1252192258834839,
-0.5637214183807373,
-0.3837878406047821,
-0.027219953015446663,
-0.6361804604530334,
-0.6701644062995911,
-0.07980600744485855,
0.6280316114425659,
0.30572330951690674,
-0.31723910570144653,
0.4018760323524475,
-0.7270858883857727,
0.07355283200740814,
0.5500541925430298,
-0.3970596492290497,
0.7441328167915344,
0.18557487428188324,
-0.36696305871009827,
0.18358388543128967,
-0.7655163407325745,
0.05968664586544037,
0.053045596927404404,
-0.02900753729045391,
-0.1203761100769043,
0.11690329015254974,
-0.3998522460460663,
0.5080986618995667,
-0.20906826853752136,
-0.5905322432518005,
-0.052860334515571594,
-0.6701580286026001,
0.6591508388519287,
0.6103100776672363,
0.44016796350479126,
0.5250433683395386,
0.058018773794174194,
0.37406042218208313,
0.6392231583595276,
0.07868882268667221,
-0.277468204498291,
-0.37021443247795105,
-0.6812713146209717,
0.13437315821647644,
0.18919293582439423,
0.4245472848415375,
-1.073803186416626,
0.3857201635837555,
-0.23283249139785767,
0.06006217375397682,
-0.40137284994125366,
-0.0868716761469841,
0.7478476762771606,
0.8250606060028076,
0.22536982595920563,
-0.34225794672966003,
-0.41085711121559143,
-0.9393231272697449,
-0.22935155034065247,
-0.3673723638057709,
-0.09749669581651688,
0.5393026471138,
0.16452904045581818,
0.18764953315258026,
1.0401123762130737,
-0.6488692760467529,
-0.16030804812908173,
-0.1108640730381012,
0.3185589611530304,
-0.09207514673471451,
0.2669714093208313,
0.3704272508621216,
-0.904282808303833,
-0.706204891204834,
-0.20126909017562866,
-0.8990989923477173,
0.45131245255470276,
-0.07562389969825745,
-0.18459409475326538,
0.025418056175112724,
0.5757015347480774,
-0.5224081873893738,
0.423050194978714,
0.4751388728618622,
-0.19950774312019348,
0.036111220717430115,
-0.16442520916461945,
-0.017473556101322174,
-1.477685809135437,
-0.2407018542289734,
-0.1957300454378128,
-0.10181538015604019,
-0.5469022989273071,
-0.11114702373743057,
-0.11896169185638428,
-0.06096205115318298,
-0.2922526001930237,
0.12607303261756897,
-0.809941828250885,
-0.1018025353550911,
-0.004293947946280241,
0.27204251289367676,
-0.14953692257404327,
0.9546817541122437,
-0.2176101803779602,
0.5620313286781311,
0.34584149718284607,
-0.5502824783325195,
0.5383009910583496,
0.5053353309631348,
-0.12633726000785828,
0.7410128712654114,
-0.6915432214736938,
0.6769281625747681,
-0.49820345640182495,
0.553517758846283,
-1.385298252105713,
-0.4924699664115906,
0.5018432140350342,
-0.7303346991539001,
0.30965057015419006,
-0.2809939682483673,
-0.4448297619819641,
-0.37935805320739746,
0.0087676290422678,
0.39602693915367126,
0.2584189772605896,
-0.5015138387680054,
0.7829614877700806,
0.4501628875732422,
-0.05842860788106918,
-0.6742386817932129,
-0.8565725088119507,
0.12726272642612457,
-0.19072270393371582,
-0.8203669190406799,
0.11266249418258667,
-0.34646129608154297,
-0.10457780957221985,
0.19273974001407623,
0.10286610573530197,
-0.2793009281158447,
-0.2498125582933426,
0.3684733808040619,
0.053323499858379364,
0.01907416433095932,
0.18050606548786163,
0.06406272202730179,
0.06856586039066315,
0.29151201248168945,
0.08119984716176987,
0.5254390239715576,
-0.24077153205871582,
-0.3964543640613556,
-0.3512764573097229,
0.5648278594017029,
0.41311219334602356,
-0.3765089511871338,
0.6688330173492432,
0.6036437749862671,
-0.12197516113519669,
-0.13698631525039673,
-0.30480632185935974,
-0.5450620055198669,
-0.5206115245819092,
0.4671008288860321,
-0.6640890836715698,
-0.741548478603363,
0.8561781644821167,
-0.16790953278541565,
-0.1738591194152832,
-0.136753648519516,
0.4947704076766968,
-0.1742885708808899,
1.1841249465942383,
0.36598271131515503,
-0.00037299556424841285,
0.4398215413093567,
-0.13390517234802246,
0.46962782740592957,
-1.0137072801589966,
-0.2871352732181549,
-0.11832799762487411,
-0.5882155895233154,
-0.6364913582801819,
-0.12751543521881104,
0.38641631603240967,
0.04273555800318718,
-0.2417493313550949,
0.3523528575897217,
-0.5282418131828308,
0.5173530578613281,
0.33397868275642395,
0.2243778109550476,
0.32485076785087585,
-0.002237138105556369,
-0.1398981213569641,
-0.13655713200569153,
-0.8675805330276489,
0.08388824760913849,
0.8186011910438538,
0.1302759051322937,
0.798904299736023,
0.22756509482860565,
0.80445796251297,
-0.26330235600471497,
0.47718164324760437,
-0.5635455250740051,
0.5354224443435669,
0.29897528886795044,
-0.5956541895866394,
-0.3624139130115509,
-0.8934651613235474,
-1.0370850563049316,
0.2380920797586441,
-0.10931163281202316,
-0.7418673038482666,
0.29039058089256287,
0.2217574119567871,
-0.5662445425987244,
0.10792677849531174,
-0.6834294199943542,
0.4650860130786896,
0.23359307646751404,
-0.27640193700790405,
0.0752723291516304,
-1.1407957077026367,
0.66374671459198,
0.3538384437561035,
-0.04831485077738762,
-0.15187866985797882,
0.5155981183052063,
0.4190214276313782,
-0.33223962783813477,
0.7812301516532898,
-0.14577341079711914,
0.21503832936286926,
0.4588879346847534,
0.23636630177497864,
0.6149869561195374,
0.49514561891555786,
0.24805444478988647,
-0.3723643720149994,
-0.41876518726348877,
-0.00045858442899771035,
-0.7646198868751526,
0.7756990790367126,
-0.7605673670768738,
-0.37514472007751465,
-0.07355373352766037,
-0.6314825415611267,
-0.4727168381214142,
-0.03810117393732071,
0.44218114018440247,
0.35471805930137634,
-0.3263157308101654,
0.0652710497379303,
0.6414137482643127,
-0.01314001064747572,
0.7799832224845886,
0.36326736211776733,
-0.12250251322984695,
-0.6712813377380371,
0.6629245281219482,
-0.09543391317129135,
0.27069205045700073,
0.37711864709854126,
0.01475671399384737,
-0.34187647700309753,
-0.024182870984077454,
-0.5613791942596436,
0.21086741983890533,
-0.4258449077606201,
-0.38343319296836853,
-0.8048706650733948,
-0.297782838344574,
-0.294339120388031,
0.5772581696510315,
-0.41640856862068176,
-0.21031403541564941,
-0.1149330586194992,
-0.22091567516326904,
0.1838466227054596,
0.5742104649543762,
0.046019747853279114,
0.271067351102829,
-0.7254452109336853,
0.6325156688690186,
0.832714855670929,
0.24160772562026978,
0.21332722902297974,
-0.18567925691604614,
0.09881486743688583,
0.33228665590286255,
-0.4699471592903137,
-1.1355410814285278,
0.325674831867218,
0.34410563111305237,
0.3645429015159607,
0.2653709948062897,
0.42582640051841736,
0.7649889588356018,
-0.650072455406189,
0.48225754499435425,
0.548095166683197,
-0.7675385475158691,
0.5984965562820435,
-0.31031084060668945,
0.20708297193050385,
0.32706522941589355,
0.10339219123125076,
-0.2267649918794632,
-0.4974749982357025,
-0.8570449352264404,
-0.9150072932243347,
0.785367488861084,
0.5454784035682678,
0.35527297854423523,
-0.31818607449531555,
0.2613101899623871,
-0.4460999369621277,
0.4320075511932373,
-0.8508800268173218,
-0.5264208912849426,
-0.09161977469921112,
0.016524802893400192,
0.2982001006603241,
-0.1304348260164261,
-0.5923659801483154,
-0.06292728334665298,
0.08712334930896759,
-0.295613557100296,
0.5845263600349426,
0.24979087710380554,
0.12345527857542038,
-0.41366901993751526,
0.22197577357292175,
0.4251708984375,
0.6396072506904602,
-0.168331578373909,
0.17736363410949707,
-0.08303400874137878,
0.010647225193679333,
0.32076728343963623,
0.17030033469200134,
0.18551349639892578,
0.03846913203597069,
-0.007873324677348137,
0.8883349895477295,
-0.1654580533504486,
0.0010506334947422147,
0.6180659532546997,
-0.5719410181045532,
-0.1809307336807251,
-0.14928533136844635,
-0.06100895255804062,
0.6491328477859497,
0.38104861974716187,
0.0943363830447197,
0.24172183871269226,
0.3266661763191223,
-0.629468560218811,
0.483330637216568,
0.5030040144920349,
-0.3809913992881775,
-0.32892581820487976,
0.7548865675926208,
0.2988298237323761,
-0.49209699034690857,
1.0095534324645996,
-0.4409019351005554,
-0.24009157717227936,
0.5908858180046082,
0.5608159303665161,
1.0929335355758667,
-0.3367188572883606,
0.30960947275161743,
0.6027287840843201,
-0.07692930102348328,
0.36242589354515076,
0.044877491891384125,
-0.2027273029088974,
-0.8553438782691956,
-0.5537450909614563,
-0.36098843812942505,
-0.32798853516578674,
0.22408507764339447,
-0.9441242814064026,
-0.18255876004695892,
-0.4603832960128784,
-0.3960137665271759,
0.07562175393104553,
-0.4214746952056885,
-0.6460735201835632,
-0.09048116207122803,
0.1515970081090927,
0.2797048091888428,
-0.5880634784698486,
0.8691107034683228,
0.4405302405357361,
-0.5817382335662842,
-0.9766733646392822,
0.2819119393825531,
-0.38993072509765625,
-0.37472349405288696,
0.6962394118309021,
0.01288032066076994,
-0.32130253314971924,
0.015916429460048676,
-0.5277289748191833,
-0.6086485385894775,
0.8346303701400757,
0.7792915105819702,
-0.746532678604126,
-0.2648729681968689,
0.16831666231155396,
0.5192714333534241,
-0.39600086212158203,
0.5337976217269897,
0.14986036717891693,
-0.050322845578193665,
0.39371374249458313,
-0.7610942125320435,
0.14536811411380768,
-0.3090423345565796,
0.2952180802822113,
0.3791269063949585,
-0.8577964901924133,
0.9599092602729797,
-0.1825818121433258,
-0.31571027636528015,
-0.3169265687465668,
0.9888809323310852,
0.23896880447864532,
0.12764272093772888,
0.6209904551506042,
0.43043532967567444,
0.4099912941455841,
0.05211680009961128,
0.6651239991188049,
-0.41230037808418274,
0.22763516008853912,
1.8697742223739624,
-0.21806487441062927,
0.7382524013519287,
0.6882352828979492,
-0.13343274593353271,
0.7245122790336609,
0.3097046911716461,
0.3599027395248413,
0.6541398167610168,
0.31664398312568665,
-0.3322906792163849,
-0.19689719378948212,
0.06492289900779724,
-0.42253565788269043,
0.3294438421726227,
0.5335939526557922,
-0.2977505028247833,
-0.3676033020019531,
-0.14073793590068817,
-0.24110017716884613,
0.21539805829524994,
0.22288063168525696,
1.1696021556854248,
0.2070973664522171,
-0.8526726961135864,
0.5157058835029602,
-0.36771807074546814,
0.45463165640830994,
-0.525833010673523,
-0.23257732391357422,
-0.5458236336708069,
0.3867338299751282,
-0.17110782861709595,
-0.7257612943649292,
0.29743316769599915,
-0.2842324376106262,
-0.2938595414161682,
0.08683564513921738,
0.4908633828163147,
-0.8355937004089355,
-0.046513017266988754,
0.5487991571426392,
0.5102362036705017,
-0.10870616137981415,
-0.04261041432619095,
-0.7891446352005005,
-0.2607215642929077,
-0.026753053069114685,
-0.36918318271636963,
0.5118982791900635,
0.7216848134994507,
0.2131817638874054,
0.6201980113983154,
0.4571143388748169,
-0.2958425283432007,
0.11756398528814316,
0.20479479432106018,
1.1557769775390625,
-0.2114192694425583,
-0.5704330801963806,
-0.923835039138794,
0.6090853214263916,
-0.39773666858673096,
-0.1903340369462967,
0.5734031200408936,
0.15720845758914948,
0.8086899518966675,
-0.025645192712545395,
0.5049874186515808,
-0.11047859489917755,
0.13756433129310608,
-0.13418380916118622,
0.515471339225769,
-0.024772481992840767,
0.20016732811927795,
-0.37593990564346313,
-0.859978437423706,
0.027682006359100342,
0.6432719826698303,
0.12955622375011444,
0.030412983149290085,
0.5793268084526062,
0.7308138012886047,
-0.08144847303628922,
-0.10654080659151077,
0.14053237438201904,
0.1306757628917694,
0.6021997332572937,
0.951239824295044,
1.020296335220337,
-0.5047513246536255,
0.9568824768066406,
-0.26924949884414673,
-0.0023633551318198442,
0.1276630014181137,
-0.901593804359436,
-1.1203900575637817,
-0.6358003616333008,
-0.35213685035705566,
-0.4595893323421478,
-0.11090134084224701,
0.6263233423233032,
0.7331457734107971,
-0.6033255457878113,
-0.20091918110847473,
-0.641040027141571,
-0.028736082836985588,
-0.13287422060966492,
-0.2932170033454895,
0.14017973840236664,
-0.3346385061740875,
-0.7071807384490967,
0.31248727440834045,
0.25776973366737366,
0.07294968515634537,
-0.3635922968387604,
-0.1286676526069641,
-0.44645246863365173,
0.06908900290727615,
0.38260260224342346,
0.10347991436719894,
-0.5106125473976135,
-0.17053650319576263,
-0.1397879272699356,
-0.13601016998291016,
0.270512193441391,
0.7381981611251831,
-0.7800748348236084,
0.646094560623169,
0.5562955737113953,
0.41387835144996643,
0.7836418747901917,
0.038958292454481125,
0.7954880595207214,
-1.3200703859329224,
0.26287272572517395,
0.48660677671432495,
0.047571487724781036,
0.423682302236557,
-0.5134592652320862,
0.38037440180778503,
0.04435687139630318,
-0.5802350640296936,
-0.7456965446472168,
0.7569971084594727,
-0.6646080613136292,
-0.1855863481760025,
0.7428795099258423,
-0.43817922472953796,
-0.2020178586244583,
0.03933756425976753,
-0.08464910835027695,
0.5344046354293823,
-0.4675920903682709,
0.6809901595115662,
0.5779992938041687,
-0.62947678565979,
-0.24780243635177612,
-0.09000538289546967,
0.6104238033294678,
0.3218391537666321,
-0.8100099563598633,
0.3105091452598572,
0.46408388018608093,
0.1821342259645462,
0.4427589178085327,
0.9932039380073547,
0.09912265837192535,
-0.01985129341483116,
0.21104389429092407,
-0.12361153215169907,
-0.06956101953983307,
-0.41256022453308105,
0.07961642742156982,
0.33514875173568726,
-0.1891380101442337,
-0.38772591948509216
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10822v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10822v3
|
Can Large Language Models abstract Medical Coded Language?
| 2024-03-16T06:18:15 | 2024-06-06T21:58:49 |
Simon A. Lee, Timothy Lindsey
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have become a pivotal research area, potentially
making beneficial contributions in fields like healthcare where they can
streamline automated billing and decision support. However, the frequent use of
specialized coded languages like ICD-10, which are regularly updated and
deviate from natural language formats, presents potential challenges for LLMs
in creating accurate and meaningful latent representations. This raises
concerns among healthcare professionals about potential inaccuracies or
``hallucinations" that could result in the direct impact of a patient.
Therefore, this study evaluates whether large language models (LLMs) are aware
of medical code ontologies and can accurately generate names from these codes.
We assess the capabilities and limitations of both general and
biomedical-specific generative models, such as GPT, LLaMA-2, and Meditron,
focusing on their proficiency with domain-specific terminologies. While the
results indicate that LLMs struggle with coded language, we offer insights on
how to adapt these models to reason more effectively.
|
[
-0.08969021588563919,
-0.5393338203430176,
1.191415786743164,
0.07579237222671509,
-0.2359619438648224,
0.040630072355270386,
-0.33867698907852173,
-0.733954906463623,
0.09038274735212326,
0.7587000131607056,
-0.157205268740654,
-0.6498004794120789,
-0.8055673241615295,
0.43680819869041443,
-0.420363187789917,
0.8188682794570923,
-0.1301724761724472,
0.3747364580631256,
-0.06531297415494919,
-0.1609674096107483,
-0.3739127516746521,
-1.0141026973724365,
-0.5015108585357666,
-0.45629245042800903,
0.3943594992160797,
-0.13283321261405945,
0.7150390148162842,
0.5379130244255066,
0.7869588732719421,
0.21335075795650482,
-0.1538722664117813,
0.06740662455558777,
-0.10002826154232025,
0.06826915591955185,
-0.14102259278297424,
-0.45320841670036316,
-0.627194881439209,
-0.3075016438961029,
0.53230881690979,
1.066680669784546,
-0.2813224792480469,
-0.09968239814043045,
-0.38127991557121277,
0.4144413471221924,
-0.2430216521024704,
0.21194839477539062,
-0.7071779370307922,
0.23901477456092834,
0.11546161025762558,
-0.1579335629940033,
-0.5385364890098572,
-0.27882975339889526,
0.0888235792517662,
-0.45334669947624207,
-0.05246298387646675,
-0.06170923262834549,
0.7040905952453613,
0.36173027753829956,
-0.29155394434928894,
-0.6922010183334351,
-0.815645158290863,
0.44627341628074646,
-0.9672667980194092,
0.2903500497341156,
0.49369916319847107,
0.3744722306728363,
-0.2050166130065918,
-0.8958327770233154,
-0.495809942483902,
-0.4778122901916504,
-0.12389685213565826,
-0.2287585735321045,
-0.3351201117038727,
0.14295780658721924,
0.6100257039070129,
0.4358866214752197,
-0.5413662791252136,
0.5065641403198242,
-0.46387994289398193,
0.005771567579358816,
0.5670075416564941,
0.43435588479042053,
0.6407483816146851,
-0.04412218555808067,
-0.10052189975976944,
0.37945643067359924,
-0.8683673739433289,
-0.35601821541786194,
-0.04684656858444214,
0.08521159738302231,
-0.4566763937473297,
0.7486155033111572,
0.07149282097816467,
0.7440957427024841,
-0.18688654899597168,
-0.3616740107536316,
0.27523890137672424,
0.03283423185348511,
-0.46427860856056213,
0.09584014862775803,
0.5339305400848389,
0.17702023684978485,
0.38588955998420715,
-0.6180949211120605,
-0.3578101396560669,
0.3574848175048828,
0.5686456561088562,
-0.6348433494567871,
-0.450147807598114,
0.5295124650001526,
-0.5501596331596375,
-0.3713965117931366,
-0.18469785153865814,
-0.35766488313674927,
-0.6245381832122803,
-0.3717712163925171,
0.23140296339988708,
-0.33330434560775757,
-0.045588746666908264,
0.45115765929222107,
0.18681272864341736,
0.1275768131017685,
0.4346220791339874,
-0.7899678945541382,
0.16540487110614777,
0.5691219568252563,
0.6964574456214905,
-0.17017948627471924,
0.007294477894902229,
-0.21064865589141846,
0.04138113185763359,
-0.6609200239181519,
0.8529961705207825,
-0.7055183053016663,
-0.47110411524772644,
-0.03774869441986084,
0.037733614444732666,
0.05580884590744972,
-0.783329427242279,
0.2748933732509613,
-0.5058414936065674,
-0.1276971697807312,
-0.06336460262537003,
-0.6026051640510559,
-0.025192834436893463,
0.3028693199157715,
-0.6094077825546265,
0.23587946593761444,
0.30721786618232727,
-0.579874575138092,
0.13296450674533844,
-0.472427099943161,
-0.5039588212966919,
0.18970134854316711,
-0.781943678855896,
-0.3678843379020691,
0.3785381019115448,
-0.056759048253297806,
0.48247063159942627,
-0.5909764766693115,
0.5587402582168579,
0.046588968485593796,
-0.09607812017202377,
0.6990593671798706,
-0.24836301803588867,
0.5199544429779053,
0.24085626006126404,
-0.12952791154384613,
0.16147193312644958,
-0.8801090717315674,
0.03861615061759949,
0.20475700497627258,
-0.4624972939491272,
-0.1942186802625656,
-0.05415048450231552,
0.04941615089774132,
0.311845064163208,
-0.15155012905597687,
-0.27762365341186523,
0.46489083766937256,
-0.4380239248275757,
0.6285178065299988,
0.6160158514976501,
-0.042355213314294815,
0.10497916489839554,
-0.4547584652900696,
0.8291340470314026,
0.07352763414382935,
-0.25673770904541016,
-0.3795711100101471,
-0.5856378078460693,
-0.5176410675048828,
-0.17391915619373322,
0.4016181528568268,
0.2503293752670288,
-0.779769778251648,
0.32210370898246765,
-0.29151883721351624,
-0.5099599957466125,
-0.22501422464847565,
-0.0824408307671547,
0.4970856308937073,
0.427615761756897,
0.1863914579153061,
-0.12199205160140991,
-0.43917909264564514,
-0.711287260055542,
-0.0026287438813596964,
-0.13276223838329315,
-0.15045134723186493,
0.4738706350326538,
0.6200065016746521,
-0.7059586048126221,
0.49507978558540344,
-0.5030104517936707,
-0.2672842741012573,
-0.26477617025375366,
-0.04905153065919876,
0.09583102911710739,
0.2787073850631714,
0.5601627230644226,
-0.673511266708374,
-0.15285645425319672,
0.15171900391578674,
-0.9901827573776245,
-0.1944730132818222,
-0.33650127053260803,
0.3230768144130707,
0.22527235746383667,
0.42815396189689636,
-0.4413425028324127,
0.3898194134235382,
0.8097217082977295,
-0.4765765070915222,
0.785987377166748,
-0.6832031607627869,
-0.05030517652630806,
-0.9899875521659851,
0.21045255661010742,
-0.09380236268043518,
-0.08744937926530838,
-0.8375519514083862,
0.2558598220348358,
0.2195879966020584,
-0.0873098075389862,
-0.3147096335887909,
0.6961294412612915,
-0.5024296641349792,
-0.16680662333965302,
-0.3481385409832001,
-0.1461644023656845,
-0.06723728775978088,
0.09344354271888733,
0.3435600697994232,
0.7562380433082581,
0.6874567270278931,
-0.6945660710334778,
0.2134559005498886,
0.33513450622558594,
-0.6851164698600769,
0.18906821310520172,
-0.856909990310669,
0.032147713005542755,
-0.11950839310884476,
0.28642868995666504,
-0.4301955997943878,
-0.5764629244804382,
-0.0004247190663591027,
-0.28134873509407043,
0.2904588282108307,
-0.035331230610609055,
-0.6384483575820923,
-0.4057859182357788,
0.3291504681110382,
0.6341954469680786,
0.7332456111907959,
-0.49588778614997864,
0.4255872368812561,
0.6144077777862549,
-0.12502513825893402,
-0.03850569948554039,
-0.978394091129303,
0.31853893399238586,
-0.09800492227077484,
-0.3752707839012146,
0.4979754388332367,
0.06045277416706085,
-0.5080790519714355,
-0.31270071864128113,
0.04369310289621353,
-0.1525329053401947,
0.02154146507382393,
0.4585972726345062,
0.2834601104259491,
-0.18641072511672974,
0.5623916983604431,
-0.1196262314915657,
-0.07080717384815216,
0.22430089116096497,
-0.13456575572490692,
0.7386451959609985,
0.14773043990135193,
-0.47786641120910645,
-0.2079991102218628,
0.34809499979019165,
0.804503321647644,
-0.20792974531650543,
0.7064614295959473,
-0.07637535780668259,
-0.7647602558135986,
-0.16655249893665314,
-0.5440037250518799,
-0.15573877096176147,
-0.3803924024105072,
0.5409786105155945,
-0.30665427446365356,
-0.9607949256896973,
0.8409057259559631,
-0.06481608748435974,
-0.22978784143924713,
0.43075501918792725,
0.9572724103927612,
0.20166784524917603,
1.1280150413513184,
0.5649016499519348,
0.2504790127277374,
-0.2661653161048889,
-0.11389641463756561,
0.257832795381546,
-0.8941829800605774,
-0.42541342973709106,
-0.640438437461853,
0.11913396418094635,
-0.5522317290306091,
-0.5256642699241638,
0.44215771555900574,
-0.18110625445842743,
-0.2841004431247711,
-0.004866768140345812,
-0.5064684748649597,
0.14308229088783264,
-0.04986610636115074,
0.00045130657963454723,
0.39830803871154785,
0.173958882689476,
-0.11483826488256454,
0.057521671056747437,
-0.5289149284362793,
-0.8060287833213806,
1.0989474058151245,
0.5268186330795288,
1.0842820405960083,
0.1138557493686676,
0.37833932042121887,
0.26750490069389343,
0.3539775609970093,
-0.7103654146194458,
0.2736451029777527,
-0.40097588300704956,
-0.43624168634414673,
0.14359846711158752,
-0.4070170521736145,
-0.9937668442726135,
-0.03165191039443016,
-0.15372386574745178,
-0.7719079852104187,
0.16448043286800385,
0.07920312881469727,
-0.49598559737205505,
0.4140358865261078,
-0.3298379182815552,
0.6048526763916016,
-0.3821210265159607,
0.37342971563339233,
0.016237983480095863,
-0.45160138607025146,
0.405984491109848,
-0.676437258720398,
0.3289024531841278,
-0.16319571435451508,
-0.05487990751862526,
0.6155201196670532,
-0.6399562358856201,
0.8017755150794983,
0.23790644109249115,
-0.5308111310005188,
0.027840083464980125,
0.02309124357998371,
0.40535128116607666,
0.022227896377444267,
-0.06971782445907593,
0.5301477909088135,
-0.036931078881025314,
-0.15587453544139862,
-0.4261682331562042,
0.7378873825073242,
-0.7216543555259705,
-0.5881826281547546,
-0.42576149106025696,
-0.49086862802505493,
-0.32504090666770935,
0.02751176618039608,
0.3352711498737335,
0.5296286344528198,
0.04855174571275711,
-0.09936495125293732,
0.6593031883239746,
-0.7114688754081726,
0.03348955139517784,
0.4904848337173462,
-0.4601159989833832,
-0.154184490442276,
0.553382158279419,
0.15972018241882324,
0.4093809425830841,
0.1559867262840271,
0.10361402481794357,
-0.008421596139669418,
-0.7548825144767761,
-0.5731622576713562,
0.4301166236400604,
-0.8097473978996277,
-0.19678954780101776,
-0.907651960849762,
-0.3912217319011688,
-0.3170362114906311,
-0.3015487492084503,
-0.1048472672700882,
-0.29656434059143066,
-0.26665154099464417,
0.00288000819273293,
0.38643938302993774,
0.8994065523147583,
0.3678065836429596,
0.1755048632621765,
-1.0471082925796509,
0.54292893409729,
0.019485261291265488,
0.6136581301689148,
-0.023091528564691544,
-0.6331539154052734,
-0.048921968787908554,
0.00006232970190467313,
0.18156664073467255,
-0.9274246692657471,
0.4594443142414093,
-0.13361655175685883,
0.5957356691360474,
0.43168607354164124,
-0.07648120820522308,
0.4431763291358948,
-0.7931835055351257,
0.8488689661026001,
0.41937994956970215,
-0.7150914669036865,
0.408481627702713,
-0.2424413114786148,
0.3002486824989319,
0.05345107987523079,
0.37436017394065857,
-0.5443609952926636,
-0.30381616950035095,
-0.4936214089393616,
-0.4476670026779175,
0.4246538579463959,
0.030933231115341187,
0.3629963994026184,
-0.3892223834991455,
0.5383452773094177,
0.21831856667995453,
0.08507685363292694,
-0.6429307460784912,
-0.22847512364387512,
0.22761088609695435,
-0.17364560067653656,
0.201206773519516,
-0.40939128398895264,
-0.08036211878061295,
0.036722104996442795,
0.2059873640537262,
-0.10199467092752457,
0.5523118376731873,
0.13943788409233093,
0.17724475264549255,
-0.11756864190101624,
0.3826049268245697,
0.8160455822944641,
0.941633939743042,
0.21638080477714539,
0.2289871722459793,
0.036984413862228394,
-0.5265087485313416,
0.21696776151657104,
-0.1248055100440979,
0.016820451244711876,
-0.007855369709432125,
0.47394266724586487,
0.6267181038856506,
0.04911300912499428,
-1.2389776706695557,
0.36385563015937805,
0.012394308112561703,
-0.2375633865594864,
-0.44632744789123535,
0.016951190307736397,
0.0977252721786499,
0.24915491044521332,
0.14445549249649048,
0.04385774955153465,
-0.044918108731508255,
-0.6180821657180786,
-0.10604605078697205,
0.42787545919418335,
-0.18445877730846405,
-0.2887452244758606,
0.7949625849723816,
-0.05978956073522568,
-0.3515726327896118,
0.5567074418067932,
-0.008828980848193169,
-0.4691881537437439,
0.8784722089767456,
0.7977259159088135,
0.7368853092193604,
-0.08476869016885757,
-0.10398536920547485,
0.07479389756917953,
0.11498621851205826,
-0.3461662530899048,
0.2772432565689087,
0.43380483984947205,
-0.8404868245124817,
-0.6655907034873962,
-0.7526773810386658,
-0.33315563201904297,
0.3339630663394928,
-0.5446459650993347,
0.18402139842510223,
-0.6673076748847961,
-0.42784443497657776,
0.3150094747543335,
-0.5191242098808289,
-0.6494137644767761,
0.3422495126724243,
0.4162202775478363,
0.7395497560501099,
-0.5659435391426086,
1.0327073335647583,
1.013590693473816,
-0.4137430489063263,
-1.0028125047683716,
-0.12578752636909485,
-0.28680530190467834,
-0.8114632964134216,
0.8805367350578308,
-0.046750523149967194,
0.08480682224035263,
-0.19938863813877106,
-0.37489596009254456,
-0.6371920108795166,
0.7786275744438171,
0.30851081013679504,
-0.7597213387489319,
-0.47861284017562866,
0.2570761442184448,
0.7791708707809448,
-0.5485137701034546,
-0.02353508211672306,
0.4733087122440338,
0.33914831280708313,
0.03766313195228577,
-1.1629291772842407,
0.12296358495950699,
-0.2617858946323395,
0.21138957142829895,
0.029110537841916084,
-0.22894562780857086,
0.9456104040145874,
-0.624981164932251,
-0.14278806746006012,
0.20108762383460999,
0.05986389145255089,
0.3766908645629883,
0.1108199954032898,
0.009883487597107887,
0.45137372612953186,
0.7321724891662598,
-0.03811118006706238,
1.4014558792114258,
-0.5000265836715698,
0.21901005506515503,
0.9180711507797241,
-0.5628924369812012,
0.5491371750831604,
0.2563137710094452,
-0.3226029574871063,
0.4179924428462982,
0.26992711424827576,
-0.19991406798362732,
0.2824224531650543,
0.4163115620613098,
-0.1992688924074173,
-0.43997541069984436,
0.11602988839149475,
-0.5864971280097961,
0.41123393177986145,
0.6350368857383728,
-0.9113722443580627,
0.01902371272444725,
0.20569725334644318,
0.053626228123903275,
0.12563519179821014,
-0.4875306189060211,
0.778285801410675,
0.39704030752182007,
-0.5664542317390442,
0.6484618186950684,
0.3994894325733185,
0.42737770080566406,
-0.4226328432559967,
-0.18293800950050354,
-0.05894995480775833,
0.15020126104354858,
-0.2575113773345947,
-0.4696371853351593,
0.30902835726737976,
0.2634676694869995,
-0.22786392271518707,
0.14847348630428314,
0.5866449475288391,
-0.22868873178958893,
-0.7260379791259766,
0.1024637371301651,
0.3935616612434387,
0.2730376124382019,
0.027760794386267662,
-0.36100220680236816,
0.29551735520362854,
0.034982625395059586,
0.0935802012681961,
0.3955940008163452,
0.27948713302612305,
-0.25764521956443787,
0.8467862606048584,
0.4803662598133087,
0.5864266157150269,
-0.04527192562818527,
0.23802918195724487,
0.836448609828949,
-0.6934654712677002,
-0.43854039907455444,
-0.8349015712738037,
0.19454599916934967,
0.32671529054641724,
-0.17045749723911285,
0.38860437273979187,
0.29127609729766846,
0.6727079153060913,
-0.38456884026527405,
0.9641802906990051,
0.2291005700826645,
0.3422047197818756,
-0.7788069844245911,
0.9451144933700562,
-0.39915892481803894,
0.5557252168655396,
-0.1411363035440445,
-0.6215476393699646,
-0.7650531530380249,
0.7682198286056519,
-0.44719406962394714,
0.24680779874324799,
0.6904362440109253,
0.5287604331970215,
0.2075214684009552,
-0.06046605110168457,
0.6808965802192688,
0.41971251368522644,
0.4414052665233612,
0.6536954641342163,
0.6988635063171387,
-0.16083799302577972,
0.15793302655220032,
0.02035193331539631,
0.05921841412782669,
-0.3169921636581421,
-0.7075210809707642,
-0.9758145809173584,
-0.30347752571105957,
-0.5245442986488342,
-0.3508349061012268,
0.16132010519504547,
1.0048116445541382,
0.4736440181732178,
-0.8124797940254211,
0.18824279308319092,
-0.037704262882471085,
-0.20330967009067535,
0.14718933403491974,
-0.0766042172908783,
0.6550835967063904,
-0.24817191064357758,
-0.3722490668296814,
0.11663859337568283,
0.47865915298461914,
0.3329995572566986,
-0.3376779556274414,
-0.20312881469726562,
0.4504871070384979,
0.1294848471879959,
0.6293795704841614,
0.07677949219942093,
-1.1076098680496216,
-0.22897610068321228,
0.002759684110060334,
-0.44647711515426636,
0.1245313286781311,
0.9751954674720764,
-0.828660786151886,
0.4316195249557495,
0.08630017936229706,
0.6055848002433777,
-0.12058473378419876,
0.009703915566205978,
0.304923415184021,
-0.171586811542511,
-0.06252815574407578,
0.39451366662979126,
0.6028668880462646,
0.2193598598241806,
-0.3047487437725067,
0.3681926727294922,
0.06670892983675003,
-0.5247488617897034,
-0.8931740522384644,
0.23099109530448914,
-0.7519124150276184,
-0.46131306886672974,
1.4988973140716553,
-0.28943970799446106,
0.15248970687389374,
-0.30334973335266113,
-0.16332939267158508,
-0.0739651620388031,
0.14700289070606232,
0.8620360493659973,
0.40236109495162964,
-0.147384375333786,
-0.1040823832154274,
-0.6449775695800781,
0.541680097579956,
0.1849149763584137,
-0.981553316116333,
0.08677031099796295,
0.6591681838035583,
0.24819429218769073,
0.22698797285556793,
0.7527549266815186,
-0.47086387872695923,
0.3694659173488617,
-0.03458712622523308,
0.1511256992816925,
-0.038921184837818146,
-0.17845652997493744,
-0.5125126838684082,
0.11193984746932983,
0.436272531747818,
0.42872390151023865
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10799v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10799v3
|
Efficient Pruning of Large Language Model with Adaptive Estimation Fusion
| 2024-03-16T04:12:50 | 2024-05-15T02:20:54 |
Jun Liu, Chao Wu, Changdi Yang, Hao Tang, Zhenglun Kong, Geng Yuan, Wei Niu, Dong Huang, Yanzhi Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) have become crucial for many generative
downstream tasks, leading to an inevitable trend and significant challenge to
deploy them efficiently on resource-constrained devices. Structured pruning is
a widely used method to address this challenge. However, when dealing with the
complex structure of the multiple decoder layers, general methods often employ
common estimation approaches for pruning. These approaches lead to a decline in
accuracy for specific downstream tasks. In this paper, we introduce a simple
yet efficient method that adaptively models the importance of each
substructure. Meanwhile, it can adaptively fuse coarse-grained and finegrained
estimations based on the results from complex and multilayer structures. All
aspects of our design seamlessly integrate into the endto-end pruning
framework. Our experimental results, compared with state-of-the-art methods on
mainstream datasets, demonstrate average accuracy improvements of 1.1%, 1.02%,
2.0%, and 1.2% for LLaMa-7B,Vicuna-7B, Baichuan-7B, and Bloom-7b1,
respectively.
|
[
-0.180979385972023,
-0.9177143573760986,
0.437874972820282,
0.3416479825973511,
-0.502811074256897,
0.0697091668844223,
-0.49188652634620667,
-0.14481525123119354,
0.04886488616466522,
0.2193278968334198,
-0.5294273495674133,
-0.7238538861274719,
-0.407673716545105,
-0.11699534207582474,
-0.2062692940235138,
0.5870481729507446,
0.10675004869699478,
-0.17091158032417297,
0.1622009128332138,
-0.018910011276602745,
-0.6114202737808228,
-0.2533137798309326,
-0.3330151438713074,
-0.20989395678043365,
0.46318957209587097,
0.36101242899894714,
0.5175267457962036,
0.6955325603485107,
0.2074875384569168,
0.42802971601486206,
-0.37919095158576965,
0.5928473472595215,
-0.3977639079093933,
0.17852401733398438,
-0.10264523327350616,
-0.3583875894546509,
-0.5471269488334656,
-0.4093096852302551,
0.8434282541275024,
0.7499929666519165,
-0.3691454231739044,
0.20538848638534546,
0.24837753176689148,
0.6476399302482605,
-0.7135107517242432,
0.06965328007936478,
-0.8313542604446411,
-0.012760316953063011,
-0.28717339038848877,
-0.2660213112831116,
-0.6063247323036194,
-0.22099347412586212,
-0.1576848328113556,
-0.4670667052268982,
0.291398823261261,
-0.038574084639549255,
0.6929612755775452,
0.31301242113113403,
-0.2918510138988495,
-0.006607001647353172,
-0.8946512937545776,
1.053788661956787,
-0.8438420295715332,
0.40351179242134094,
0.14641697704792023,
0.35059356689453125,
-0.49479618668556213,
-0.5608806014060974,
-0.2662715017795563,
-0.07148680835962296,
0.08341363072395325,
0.3701995313167572,
-0.1929972767829895,
0.1889800727367401,
-0.0916154682636261,
0.3440999686717987,
-0.4390769302845001,
0.4431827664375305,
-0.2889816164970398,
-0.39678800106048584,
0.6042647361755371,
0.008648298680782318,
0.14275315403938293,
-0.02157747372984886,
-0.3787207305431366,
-0.06726047396659851,
-0.7064605951309204,
-0.2825968563556671,
0.418542742729187,
0.26278799772262573,
-0.016954759135842323,
0.3554653525352478,
-0.1378345638513565,
1.068423867225647,
0.07573617994785309,
-0.4498106837272644,
0.2560689449310303,
-0.44204267859458923,
-0.4757823646068573,
0.05610963702201843,
0.7399377822875977,
0.20760448276996613,
0.17971660196781158,
-0.12243427336215973,
-0.15788137912750244,
0.04208000376820564,
0.052102670073509216,
-0.47675296664237976,
-0.41754505038261414,
0.48990872502326965,
-0.32898762822151184,
-0.07415301352739334,
-0.10192088782787323,
-0.6735377311706543,
-0.3400498628616333,
-0.022034743800759315,
0.12420868128538132,
-0.40477636456489563,
-0.4099101722240448,
0.21584327518939972,
0.08685320615768433,
0.35421252250671387,
0.4291047751903534,
-0.7952666878700256,
0.0750032588839531,
0.7143392562866211,
0.984319269657135,
0.010240552015602589,
-0.2665257453918457,
-0.6162201762199402,
0.3084038197994232,
-0.3710170388221741,
0.8888005614280701,
-0.3084670305252075,
-0.15726599097251892,
-0.24386908113956451,
0.003416354302316904,
-0.27573835849761963,
-0.8034253716468811,
0.9473274946212769,
-0.3525793254375458,
-0.2506401836872101,
0.11979279667139053,
-0.4041798412799835,
-0.2671877145767212,
0.3501456379890442,
-0.6082665920257568,
0.8179692625999451,
0.10691887885332108,
-0.5652928948402405,
-0.03648066148161888,
-0.15300889313220978,
-0.5447773933410645,
0.005860702134668827,
0.09964635968208313,
-0.7163798809051514,
0.46985864639282227,
0.5589562654495239,
0.569584310054779,
-0.4310726523399353,
0.4596138894557953,
-0.4267413318157196,
-0.37071284651756287,
0.0488458089530468,
-0.5844020843505859,
0.6091750860214233,
0.23620474338531494,
-0.06524358689785004,
0.5240724086761475,
-0.8304690718650818,
-0.0427454449236393,
0.02257397584617138,
-0.5778125524520874,
-0.3277963101863861,
0.3183307349681854,
0.011075049638748169,
0.10227497667074203,
-0.00027191051049157977,
-0.5792621970176697,
0.23342841863632202,
-0.49924585223197937,
0.5623449087142944,
0.9431836605072021,
0.037525422871112823,
0.45414432883262634,
-0.30565574765205383,
0.4204534888267517,
0.24347935616970062,
0.09050513058900833,
-0.23884029686450958,
-0.17208988964557648,
-0.6766412258148193,
-0.42643675208091736,
0.3672727346420288,
0.3855191767215729,
-0.5544931292533875,
0.6333383917808533,
-0.6267475485801697,
-0.7649880051612854,
-0.5132404565811157,
0.3143117129802704,
0.3458753228187561,
0.35677382349967957,
0.39170539379119873,
-0.2234901487827301,
-0.4674721956253052,
-0.8594197630882263,
-0.24943464994430542,
-0.06017429381608963,
-0.3754827082157135,
0.17450110614299774,
0.007248857524245977,
0.10080994665622711,
0.7179512977600098,
-0.6076516509056091,
-0.5026760697364807,
-0.37117770314216614,
-0.08898472785949707,
0.29994311928749084,
0.48791202902793884,
0.3160633444786072,
-0.7145489454269409,
-0.37461528182029724,
0.2733043134212494,
-0.46217894554138184,
-0.14929881691932678,
-0.3400840163230896,
-0.06674355268478394,
-0.04934588447213173,
0.24119940400123596,
-0.5538620352745056,
-0.0986185222864151,
0.9000000953674316,
-0.15186478197574615,
0.639826774597168,
-0.11582804471254349,
-0.29443883895874023,
-1.1542261838912964,
-0.1993524432182312,
0.30837392807006836,
-0.21255120635032654,
-0.8517032265663147,
0.11021163314580917,
0.20407918095588684,
0.21463915705680847,
-0.5244182348251343,
0.2951456308364868,
-0.8586878180503845,
-0.2393970638513565,
-0.26951009035110474,
0.14941991865634918,
0.09659521281719208,
0.6692056655883789,
-0.07218116521835327,
0.5831469297409058,
0.5391207933425903,
-0.5336636900901794,
0.4941211938858032,
-0.051611293107271194,
-0.7598781585693359,
0.10115861147642136,
-0.6007275581359863,
0.08258377015590668,
-0.1730988621711731,
0.3162838816642761,
-0.9606553912162781,
-0.15886491537094116,
0.3072461187839508,
-0.11303002387285233,
0.24081893265247345,
-0.3332490921020508,
-0.27023136615753174,
-0.08695084601640701,
-0.4127696454524994,
0.30555373430252075,
0.36640989780426025,
-0.534902811050415,
1.0381324291229248,
0.528532087802887,
-0.2799965739250183,
-0.2742355167865753,
-0.5206140279769897,
0.01922861859202385,
-0.40768980979919434,
-0.8983628153800964,
0.6232814788818359,
0.047037139534950256,
0.05005794018507004,
-0.18463952839374542,
-0.361670583486557,
-0.17260408401489258,
0.2789185643196106,
0.16519136726856232,
0.19469065964221954,
-0.37633469700813293,
-0.16884927451610565,
0.18893791735172272,
-0.027742132544517517,
-0.19840320944786072,
-0.15034911036491394,
0.8089568018913269,
0.17379824817180634,
-0.4375273287296295,
-0.19730359315872192,
0.19357356429100037,
0.601740837097168,
-0.4116947054862976,
0.8085280060768127,
0.6829790472984314,
-0.2929694950580597,
-0.4305015206336975,
-0.6396853923797607,
0.17717337608337402,
-0.5242874622344971,
0.7150592803955078,
-0.5118674039840698,
-0.7944698929786682,
0.7800837755203247,
-0.20196492969989777,
0.2348509430885315,
0.23833473026752472,
0.6092357635498047,
0.05193766951560974,
1.046743631362915,
0.46232715249061584,
-0.12864060699939728,
0.619243860244751,
-0.0819377601146698,
0.2189599871635437,
-1.1627936363220215,
-0.1718272715806961,
-0.4340992569923401,
-0.2654743492603302,
-0.42560088634490967,
-0.5728448033332825,
0.34331822395324707,
0.2706475257873535,
0.03596612066030502,
0.2707403898239136,
-0.5152257680892944,
0.2934882640838623,
0.39445972442626953,
0.2715846002101898,
0.2920752465724945,
0.24063479900360107,
0.25209492444992065,
0.29751163721084595,
-0.8219233155250549,
-0.1485043168067932,
0.5925894975662231,
0.6332565546035767,
0.9220406413078308,
0.37687310576438904,
0.44700708985328674,
-0.20298029482364655,
0.3222059905529022,
-0.8631141185760498,
0.4887629747390747,
-0.33928382396698,
-0.10659761726856232,
-0.33493947982788086,
-0.60988849401474,
-0.6548368334770203,
0.6377623677253723,
0.07570189982652664,
-0.5322359204292297,
0.34857961535453796,
0.3405144214630127,
-0.4513839781284332,
0.3370954394340515,
-0.900813639163971,
0.5723984241485596,
-0.09129700809717178,
-0.2716215252876282,
-0.12021436542272568,
-0.32611405849456787,
0.4903737008571625,
-0.17718134820461273,
0.2610270082950592,
-0.329811155796051,
0.04421933740377426,
0.8028795123100281,
-0.35784289240837097,
0.7986435890197754,
-0.23908379673957825,
-0.24813127517700195,
0.31706565618515015,
0.003162141889333725,
0.7554070949554443,
-0.4178880453109741,
-0.22510232031345367,
0.08297287672758102,
-0.1771339774131775,
-0.45275333523750305,
-0.6334376931190491,
0.7143537998199463,
-0.6481619477272034,
-0.6774395704269409,
-0.11236391961574554,
-0.6340399384498596,
-0.1945846676826477,
-0.01047150045633316,
0.06987283378839493,
0.5031144022941589,
0.11797323822975159,
0.43050938844680786,
0.4018045663833618,
-0.37938693165779114,
0.5703750848770142,
0.33825594186782837,
0.21437081694602966,
-0.43189212679862976,
1.0668035745620728,
0.24674801528453827,
0.4026365578174591,
0.3934846818447113,
0.3684524595737457,
-0.18834586441516876,
-1.0899542570114136,
-0.504386305809021,
0.1845225691795349,
-0.5940626263618469,
-0.5387083292007446,
-0.5722997188568115,
-0.2652311325073242,
-0.415888249874115,
-0.032035451382398605,
-0.33943283557891846,
-0.06384749710559845,
-0.0960792526602745,
-0.17710107564926147,
0.18197086453437805,
0.12822303175926208,
0.4451850652694702,
0.6252663135528564,
-1.127543568611145,
0.23511578142642975,
0.13882724940776825,
0.34916266798973083,
0.17325101792812347,
-0.6469092965126038,
-0.2789599895477295,
0.09695171564817429,
-0.16954216361045837,
-0.816932201385498,
0.5197392106056213,
0.5510303974151611,
0.49979615211486816,
0.11444447934627533,
0.14369414746761322,
1.0889214277267456,
-0.391361802816391,
0.5007914304733276,
0.06996561586856842,
-0.7512965798377991,
0.3070225417613983,
-0.3626217544078827,
0.69361811876297,
0.2587184011936188,
-0.05511060357093811,
-0.3761806786060333,
-0.26853370666503906,
-0.18489158153533936,
-1.1248602867126465,
0.5920392274856567,
0.05257356911897659,
-0.006727213971316814,
0.23328736424446106,
0.13189736008644104,
-0.2591691017150879,
-0.10220314562320709,
-0.7042607665061951,
0.0027373554185032845,
0.0010157665237784386,
-0.5761898756027222,
0.09673561155796051,
-0.46972304582595825,
-0.07708747684955597,
-0.0883788987994194,
0.6753619909286499,
-0.34029993414878845,
0.03906973451375961,
0.06615153700113297,
-0.42166244983673096,
-0.07367952913045883,
0.34359312057495117,
0.5161482095718384,
0.8274466395378113,
-0.21577924489974976,
0.17500117421150208,
0.240207701921463,
-0.6473771333694458,
0.11852386593818665,
0.10700085014104843,
-0.2793530821800232,
-0.029694313183426857,
0.5246426463127136,
0.9828826189041138,
0.32270070910453796,
-0.6721974611282349,
0.22432684898376465,
0.049259986728429794,
-0.04973527789115906,
-0.23514778912067413,
0.09099441021680832,
0.1490929126739502,
0.17832189798355103,
0.43050044775009155,
-0.01404472067952156,
-0.10706020891666412,
-0.42115241289138794,
-0.029385864734649658,
0.357807993888855,
-0.1373390406370163,
-0.37614914774894714,
0.2531023621559143,
0.2823925018310547,
-0.03611911088228226,
0.5506823062896729,
0.29918205738067627,
-0.472335547208786,
0.525708019733429,
0.6978952288627625,
1.0298409461975098,
-0.43879905343055725,
0.08611185103654861,
0.36594104766845703,
0.31918618083000183,
-0.0650227963924408,
-0.1290963739156723,
-0.05275322496891022,
-1.0896210670471191,
-0.9134889841079712,
-1.15412437915802,
0.06939885020256042,
0.08976278454065323,
-0.31784650683403015,
0.09190088510513306,
-0.42686325311660767,
0.07706515491008759,
0.09576861560344696,
0.03457561135292053,
-0.2040393203496933,
0.19602735340595245,
-0.05553944408893585,
1.1035327911376953,
-1.063748836517334,
1.1408181190490723,
0.5507872700691223,
0.0005170456133782864,
-0.9975484609603882,
-0.0941578671336174,
-0.13562552630901337,
-0.5367642045021057,
0.09124413877725601,
0.04897404834628105,
-0.17201468348503113,
0.2606634199619293,
-0.12917912006378174,
-0.9837827682495117,
1.1587226390838623,
0.5032410621643066,
-0.906802773475647,
-0.08618266880512238,
-0.2141313999891281,
0.25492438673973083,
-0.23049400746822357,
0.06262194365262985,
0.553119421005249,
0.4796743392944336,
0.25865909457206726,
-0.7533838152885437,
0.025731626898050308,
-0.2981943190097809,
0.19815680384635925,
0.523486852645874,
-0.627874493598938,
0.6519654393196106,
0.09556836634874344,
-0.5613036751747131,
-0.03336165100336075,
0.7977511286735535,
0.4851049780845642,
-0.1313074380159378,
0.8630966544151306,
0.34404370188713074,
0.5328993797302246,
-0.20891991257667542,
0.8064201474189758,
-0.23019438982009888,
0.38772210478782654,
1.115902066230774,
-0.09529700130224228,
0.7143476605415344,
0.4799988567829132,
-0.2428402453660965,
0.21149495244026184,
0.8174983859062195,
-0.053344037383794785,
0.5749703645706177,
0.04088538885116577,
-0.22683483362197876,
-0.43273141980171204,
-0.0718945786356926,
-0.12217768281698227,
0.3755031228065491,
0.47842249274253845,
-0.15629898011684418,
-0.2636089622974396,
-0.08061753213405609,
-0.10531596839427948,
-0.05764860659837723,
-0.3433831036090851,
0.8704705238342285,
0.17417588829994202,
-0.7996188998222351,
0.5733312964439392,
0.4152252674102783,
0.7685242891311646,
-0.6364734768867493,
0.0655001550912857,
-0.272656112909317,
0.3995172083377838,
-0.3702668249607086,
-0.5377058386802673,
0.2995688021183014,
-0.1908135861158371,
-0.10407937318086624,
-0.0566183477640152,
0.9167505502700806,
-0.6372862458229065,
-0.7226744294166565,
0.2696331739425659,
0.25124627351760864,
-0.11600938439369202,
-0.13136126101016998,
-0.468833327293396,
0.6653369665145874,
0.15410208702087402,
-0.30868133902549744,
0.47293809056282043,
0.05236833915114403,
-0.16549068689346313,
0.7270642518997192,
0.8618785738945007,
0.32379135489463806,
0.3563616871833801,
0.07226965576410294,
1.0059895515441895,
-0.4944029748439789,
-0.3769983947277069,
-0.9712752103805542,
0.5673779845237732,
0.007257542107254267,
-0.08670438081026077,
0.6912407875061035,
0.40642213821411133,
0.7732183933258057,
0.025530364364385605,
0.4663258194923401,
-0.05502491816878319,
0.30977150797843933,
-0.7589974999427795,
0.2946431338787079,
-0.310770183801651,
0.6272735595703125,
-0.17912806570529938,
-1.423803687095642,
-0.42847082018852234,
0.5305454134941101,
-0.21373826265335083,
-0.08025342971086502,
0.1759011447429657,
0.9519433379173279,
-0.3486662805080414,
-0.19467763602733612,
0.2804129719734192,
0.5327431559562683,
0.5051694512367249,
0.582298994064331,
0.5801073908805847,
-0.32687121629714966,
0.4337785840034485,
-0.5201283693313599,
-0.3705917000770569,
-0.09796278178691864,
-0.8565502166748047,
-0.36267510056495667,
-0.4078843593597412,
-0.29293954372406006,
-0.07335561513900757,
-0.05337129533290863,
0.6780229806900024,
0.7219815254211426,
-0.8152443766593933,
-0.30660900473594666,
-0.03314585983753204,
0.172729954123497,
-0.3747212290763855,
-0.16691440343856812,
0.7490236163139343,
-0.016628902405500412,
-0.7993419766426086,
0.6160750985145569,
0.44943392276763916,
-0.18052825331687927,
-0.23695339262485504,
-0.009747463278472424,
-0.4411684274673462,
-0.09459984302520752,
0.7997255325317383,
0.13775907456874847,
-0.8722195029258728,
-0.3824632465839386,
-0.15225613117218018,
0.18157608807086945,
-0.026096735149621964,
0.5682059526443481,
-0.6634427309036255,
0.2994633913040161,
0.6162456274032593,
0.5655096769332886,
0.344154417514801,
0.4577614367008209,
0.7547569870948792,
-0.9819143414497375,
0.2991892397403717,
0.10319297015666962,
0.5048131942749023,
0.5315375924110413,
-0.1106313094496727,
0.34602072834968567,
0.12643934786319733,
-0.3244287371635437,
-1.0706238746643066,
0.344021201133728,
-1.0357707738876343,
-0.3644448220729828,
1.0401055812835693,
-0.3292597830295563,
-0.5933310985565186,
-0.015757428482174873,
-0.10835731774568558,
0.3505440950393677,
-0.06822335720062256,
0.5413902997970581,
0.3412245512008667,
0.1613648533821106,
-0.5025725364685059,
-0.19591845571994781,
0.07213439047336578,
0.4414037764072418,
-0.6248655319213867,
0.26758623123168945,
0.536794126033783,
0.29197660088539124,
0.18300074338912964,
0.49652791023254395,
0.068629190325737,
0.0018166902009397745,
-0.1955389678478241,
-0.23401013016700745,
-0.272975355386734,
-0.49131855368614197,
-0.38692551851272583,
0.43615081906318665,
0.06460513174533844,
-0.3433862328529358
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10795v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10795v1
|
From Words to Routes: Applying Large Language Models to Vehicle Routing
| 2024-03-16T03:54:38 | 2024-03-16T03:54:38 |
Zhehui Huang, Guangyao Shi, Gaurav S. Sukhatme
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.RO
|
LLMs have shown impressive progress in robotics (e.g., manipulation and
navigation) with natural language task descriptions. The success of LLMs in
these tasks leads us to wonder: What is the ability of LLMs to solve vehicle
routing problems (VRPs) with natural language task descriptions? In this work,
we study this question in three steps. First, we construct a dataset with 21
types of single- or multi-vehicle routing problems. Second, we evaluate the
performance of LLMs across four basic prompt paradigms of text-to-code
generation, each involving different types of text input. We find that the
basic prompt paradigm, which generates code directly from natural language task
descriptions, performs the best for GPT-4, achieving 56% feasibility, 40%
optimality, and 53% efficiency. Third, based on the observation that LLMs may
not be able to provide correct solutions at the initial attempt, we propose a
framework that enables LLMs to refine solutions through self-reflection,
including self-debugging and self-verification. With GPT-4, our proposed
framework achieves a 16% increase in feasibility, a 7% increase in optimality,
and a 15% increase in efficiency. Moreover, we examine the sensitivity of GPT-4
to task descriptions, specifically focusing on how its performance changes when
certain details are omitted from the task descriptions, yet the core meaning is
preserved. Our findings reveal that such omissions lead to a notable decrease
in performance: 4% in feasibility, 4% in optimality, and 5% in efficiency.
Website: https://sites.google.com/view/words-to-routes/
|
[
-0.17914028465747833,
-0.6673935651779175,
1.11298668384552,
0.3190613090991974,
-0.31216320395469666,
0.058683015406131744,
-0.3224645256996155,
-0.2745983302593231,
-0.19272136688232422,
0.5758180618286133,
-0.8189573287963867,
-0.35759061574935913,
-0.4167328178882599,
0.30702677369117737,
-0.3255799114704132,
0.7407527565956116,
-0.18935063481330872,
-0.10484928637742996,
-0.29900723695755005,
0.15914657711982727,
-0.5203344225883484,
-0.49816814064979553,
-0.6978423595428467,
-0.24610812962055206,
0.6806313395500183,
0.17703993618488312,
0.45300111174583435,
0.8443573713302612,
0.6223359704017639,
0.32007288932800293,
0.05366223677992821,
0.20940977334976196,
-0.2593415081501007,
0.3137970268726349,
-0.3491024374961853,
-0.17521099746227264,
-0.16124026477336884,
-0.2724836766719818,
0.6888723373413086,
0.5686399936676025,
-0.16697220504283905,
-0.1871972382068634,
0.2664797902107239,
0.7709721922874451,
-0.3305916488170624,
0.16054949164390564,
-0.5058098435401917,
-0.07070386409759521,
-0.26670798659324646,
-0.5430439114570618,
-0.13415464758872986,
-0.10747644305229187,
0.19311898946762085,
-0.6332698464393616,
0.42458677291870117,
0.2371610403060913,
0.872128427028656,
0.41745084524154663,
-0.4444809556007385,
-0.817867636680603,
-0.9266284108161926,
0.7568866610527039,
-0.635953426361084,
0.363948255777359,
0.26158615946769714,
0.12973558902740479,
-0.40759003162384033,
-0.6746798753738403,
-0.5733728408813477,
-0.2519245445728302,
-0.01757870428264141,
0.23259763419628143,
-0.2592970132827759,
0.2865774631500244,
0.3707025647163391,
0.25383567810058594,
-0.7700040340423584,
0.2592090368270874,
-0.478115975856781,
-0.2988092005252838,
0.6309981346130371,
0.33506155014038086,
0.13342314958572388,
-0.2692888379096985,
-0.6508435606956482,
0.09721379727125168,
-0.8241775631904602,
0.08402077853679657,
0.26328060030937195,
0.4769054055213928,
0.022301552817225456,
0.6402314305305481,
-0.32056909799575806,
0.9179844856262207,
-0.19572338461875916,
-0.36825889348983765,
0.15551182627677917,
-0.5601162910461426,
-0.20850636065006256,
-0.043648213148117065,
0.873205304145813,
0.34991464018821716,
-0.044268470257520676,
-0.6187525987625122,
-0.3733096718788147,
-0.061288345605134964,
0.42939555644989014,
-0.4472070038318634,
-0.02336745522916317,
-0.010633106343448162,
-0.40277227759361267,
-0.0031714667566120625,
-0.46645814180374146,
-0.6329248547554016,
-0.2700113356113434,
-0.588348925113678,
0.5039094686508179,
-0.40188929438591003,
0.0520760640501976,
0.3939361572265625,
-0.0782206729054451,
0.5737265348434448,
0.3885499835014343,
-0.6314228773117065,
0.32889336347579956,
0.7293981313705444,
1.052895188331604,
-0.2894705832004547,
-0.248395636677742,
-0.5483903884887695,
0.2925010919570923,
-0.11140727996826172,
0.8464843034744263,
-0.30024051666259766,
-0.7228822708129883,
0.05100422725081444,
-0.012487492524087429,
-0.1109827384352684,
-0.3056226372718811,
0.6934186220169067,
-0.433833509683609,
0.2094128429889679,
-0.8283758163452148,
-0.6128184795379639,
-0.2886814475059509,
0.380779892206192,
-0.5610155463218689,
0.8186349868774414,
-0.08290953189134598,
-0.42239075899124146,
-0.12105382233858109,
-0.549712598323822,
-0.8031050562858582,
0.09147398173809052,
-0.12251634150743484,
-0.014490568079054356,
0.16280797123908997,
0.03096722811460495,
0.5661761164665222,
-0.6095823645591736,
0.029626773670315742,
0.3572806715965271,
-0.2280740588903427,
-0.3664405047893524,
-0.4786951243877411,
0.5395704507827759,
0.06913960725069046,
-0.40692228078842163,
-0.08759285509586334,
-0.6680562496185303,
-0.11173328757286072,
0.2757852077484131,
-0.6889570355415344,
-0.24680498242378235,
0.3343907296657562,
-0.33933523297309875,
0.23084884881973267,
0.2665417790412903,
-0.46525201201438904,
0.4268574118614197,
-0.6039379835128784,
0.438912570476532,
1.0973533391952515,
-0.09841892868280411,
0.5636463761329651,
-0.2302151471376419,
0.9317606091499329,
-0.21499912440776825,
-0.0753961130976677,
-0.3139491081237793,
-0.8352723717689514,
-0.9902794361114502,
0.21239137649536133,
-0.10149126499891281,
0.6214892864227295,
-1.031577229499817,
0.04105788841843605,
-0.10306613892316818,
-0.44648802280426025,
-0.06213561072945595,
0.13083574175834656,
0.49264419078826904,
0.8378422856330872,
0.5135526657104492,
-0.25118398666381836,
-0.1755756288766861,
-0.8530406951904297,
-0.317149817943573,
-0.25681421160697937,
0.08775147795677185,
0.1327318400144577,
0.30790019035339355,
-0.2728702425956726,
0.8405275344848633,
-0.5862250924110413,
-0.16535095870494843,
-0.2417980134487152,
0.1479794681072235,
-0.00001401498320774408,
0.2960783541202545,
0.1563858985900879,
-0.4711591601371765,
-0.2073005586862564,
-0.21289367973804474,
-0.498090535402298,
-0.021779900416731834,
-0.239350825548172,
-0.023097677156329155,
0.06463261693716049,
0.444950670003891,
-0.7176428437232971,
0.3542780578136444,
0.5319795608520508,
-0.2985574007034302,
0.5768564939498901,
-0.4553868770599365,
-0.21747860312461853,
-0.8645272254943848,
-0.30176883935928345,
0.3827469050884247,
-0.14184333384037018,
-0.5349616408348083,
-0.07898888736963272,
-0.32822707295417786,
0.06622800976037979,
-0.3061750531196594,
0.5732709169387817,
-0.640518307685852,
-0.11762407422065735,
-0.3094467520713806,
0.27097824215888977,
0.009470319375395775,
0.6048394441604614,
-0.07918531447649002,
0.8884484767913818,
0.7119092345237732,
-0.9633302688598633,
0.5384182333946228,
0.0905233770608902,
-0.01589975133538246,
0.5194312334060669,
-0.6257033944129944,
0.2725733518600464,
-0.4280007779598236,
0.06664246320724487,
-1.230346918106079,
-0.03607049211859703,
0.48293426632881165,
-0.007943978533148766,
0.2166096419095993,
-0.023247092962265015,
-0.705247163772583,
-0.3946422338485718,
0.056159064173698425,
0.2643909156322479,
0.5980179309844971,
-0.38454189896583557,
0.7163538932800293,
0.09303995966911316,
-0.15003640949726105,
-0.14728060364723206,
-0.4915766417980194,
0.29711586236953735,
-0.17392879724502563,
-0.5608392953872681,
0.5852552056312561,
-0.17902638018131256,
0.04063683748245239,
-0.22578828036785126,
-0.18730907142162323,
-0.06438547372817993,
0.02793085388839245,
0.29372477531433105,
0.047640610486269,
-0.05589764937758446,
0.4540761113166809,
-0.17279089987277985,
-0.25972306728363037,
0.340776264667511,
-0.1264294534921646,
0.5835115909576416,
-0.24983978271484375,
-0.4233732521533966,
-0.21857592463493347,
0.3083958625793457,
0.12261291593313217,
-0.3941659927368164,
0.37287068367004395,
0.4795404076576233,
-0.1364976316690445,
-0.20576709508895874,
-0.438135027885437,
0.0811104029417038,
-0.5775427222251892,
0.1707855612039566,
-0.4668845534324646,
-0.9809070229530334,
0.25200948119163513,
-0.4161401093006134,
0.15988141298294067,
0.5545627474784851,
0.4932578504085541,
-0.2393980622291565,
0.6672318577766418,
0.6467489004135132,
0.1338430643081665,
-0.004993782378733158,
-0.11426316201686859,
0.5060052871704102,
-0.7655125856399536,
-0.5753507018089294,
-0.6472946405410767,
-0.16025394201278687,
-0.9070449471473694,
-0.8483636379241943,
0.5419681072235107,
-0.171443909406662,
-0.1577913463115692,
0.2860257923603058,
-0.6111467480659485,
0.2166474610567093,
0.7247021198272705,
-0.12839220464229584,
0.4492496848106384,
0.049961019307374954,
-0.16307486593723297,
-0.0031401943415403366,
-0.9684053063392639,
-0.6425493955612183,
0.8563203811645508,
0.20643818378448486,
0.6690772771835327,
0.06724505126476288,
0.6188309788703918,
0.2669346034526825,
0.0732184499502182,
-0.8453324437141418,
0.9317692518234253,
-0.001909046433866024,
-0.4206506907939911,
-0.2742098867893219,
-0.42166224122047424,
-1.0836067199707031,
0.028062056750059128,
0.05849708616733551,
-0.4546471834182739,
-0.23455920815467834,
0.1368008553981781,
-0.3770190179347992,
0.2711274325847626,
-0.4372447729110718,
0.8009217381477356,
-0.6990343332290649,
-0.5101655125617981,
-0.018945790827274323,
-0.7320584058761597,
0.17266716063022614,
0.01036145817488432,
0.2714073061943054,
-0.11211404204368591,
-0.21536608040332794,
0.7875462770462036,
-0.29935675859451294,
0.6089425683021545,
-0.044034693390131,
-0.43493416905403137,
0.32002684473991394,
-0.029375866055488586,
0.6829180717468262,
-0.4396284520626068,
-0.010972476564347744,
0.08068893104791641,
-0.5034266710281372,
-0.11572413146495819,
-0.6051357388496399,
0.8608388304710388,
-0.36262014508247375,
-0.5547226667404175,
-0.4046550393104553,
-0.2612692415714264,
-0.33416834473609924,
0.3015548586845398,
0.26941511034965515,
0.6860495805740356,
0.07362782955169678,
-0.31675660610198975,
0.695330023765564,
-0.6453530788421631,
0.7956756353378296,
0.5213550925254822,
-0.012452332302927971,
0.04811437800526619,
0.9936774373054504,
0.11051148176193237,
0.09667663276195526,
0.48302724957466125,
0.23225508630275726,
-0.6111065745353699,
-0.6285399198532104,
-0.5501911640167236,
0.39965447783470154,
-0.74802565574646,
-0.18018145859241486,
-0.5069358944892883,
-0.08095955848693848,
-0.048100925981998444,
-0.17412300407886505,
-0.534420907497406,
-0.2639421224594116,
-0.43502697348594666,
-0.03046366199851036,
0.280271053314209,
1.058598518371582,
-0.0346357561647892,
0.6140498518943787,
-0.6199546456336975,
0.39874228835105896,
0.41206225752830505,
0.37598592042922974,
0.0338134728372097,
-0.29419827461242676,
-0.21608296036720276,
-0.09530384093523026,
-0.6029226183891296,
-0.8745144605636597,
0.34412577748298645,
-0.13691546022891998,
0.5609923601150513,
0.10466200858354568,
-0.04014737159013748,
0.8624937534332275,
-0.9622789025306702,
1.0071011781692505,
0.3430637717247009,
-0.8023964762687683,
0.5753317475318909,
-0.49715688824653625,
0.10761989653110504,
0.1962226778268814,
0.4136185646057129,
-0.19708384573459625,
-0.1988130807876587,
-0.42351850867271423,
-1.0184944868087769,
0.313599169254303,
0.4223390519618988,
0.1212005615234375,
-0.21600274741649628,
0.527779757976532,
-0.1007700189948082,
0.19068416953086853,
-0.6445601582527161,
-0.5327829122543335,
0.02212940715253353,
0.013349151238799095,
-0.22136752307415009,
-0.39733633399009705,
0.14717067778110504,
-0.07543161511421204,
0.5271640419960022,
0.11394206434488297,
0.716858446598053,
0.34088170528411865,
0.18694689869880676,
0.1480797678232193,
0.286567360162735,
0.9309362173080444,
0.7567148804664612,
0.11414354294538498,
0.12292595207691193,
-0.11445780843496323,
-0.03797590360045433,
0.3050312399864197,
-0.0035736924037337303,
-0.08730548620223999,
0.15468309819698334,
0.38205859065055847,
0.7415408492088318,
-0.05869271233677864,
-0.5900954008102417,
0.4533197581768036,
0.007565548177808523,
-0.1963866800069809,
-0.2769419848918915,
0.05410602688789368,
0.05726916342973709,
0.21639172732830048,
0.39431703090667725,
0.01373582798987627,
0.3909265100955963,
-0.27497950196266174,
-0.11001518368721008,
0.5015302896499634,
-0.3571724593639374,
-0.4111432135105133,
0.7891312837600708,
0.42652812600135803,
-0.6492974758148193,
0.47639200091362,
-0.4483467936515808,
-0.5893377661705017,
0.44211941957473755,
0.3450588285923004,
1.0095950365066528,
-0.07301753014326096,
0.11387109011411667,
0.38306480646133423,
0.5396049618721008,
-0.3639822006225586,
0.006554259918630123,
-0.018149225041270256,
-0.5621321797370911,
-0.8390035033226013,
-0.6468120813369751,
-0.283877968788147,
-0.09327269345521927,
-0.35880786180496216,
-0.04368111491203308,
-0.3882819414138794,
-0.28139176964759827,
-0.5078319907188416,
-0.1995735466480255,
-0.9310198426246643,
0.31963151693344116,
0.21988733112812042,
0.5834763050079346,
-0.6057878136634827,
0.31431809067726135,
0.8917722702026367,
-0.21391868591308594,
-0.9795573353767395,
0.06552987545728683,
-0.07549218088388443,
-0.7417067885398865,
0.7646077871322632,
0.18806378543376923,
-0.5441360473632812,
0.041598495095968246,
-0.2852303087711334,
-0.8611109852790833,
0.9696258306503296,
0.21085114777088165,
-0.7432829737663269,
-0.47571906447410583,
0.26118844747543335,
0.32461225986480713,
-0.04223218560218811,
-0.08051718026399612,
0.2762415409088135,
0.46604523062705994,
0.14663274586200714,
-1.130895972251892,
0.21343478560447693,
0.259053111076355,
0.22527234256267548,
-0.011161540634930134,
-0.718174397945404,
0.6054205894470215,
-0.08967150747776031,
-0.12100771069526672,
0.1728602796792984,
0.5017789006233215,
0.1921468824148178,
0.3385750353336334,
0.3750004172325134,
0.5964261293411255,
0.7044258117675781,
-0.11024735122919083,
1.243794560432434,
-0.18784046173095703,
0.2092413604259491,
0.9873756766319275,
-0.22628289461135864,
0.5154528617858887,
0.6119442582130432,
-0.1901896446943283,
0.5172374844551086,
0.31796884536743164,
0.3639027774333954,
0.7869178652763367,
0.5393463969230652,
-0.3037489056587219,
-0.352407306432724,
0.09271182119846344,
-0.24239489436149597,
0.5756977200508118,
-0.06297676265239716,
-0.22752141952514648,
-0.47501686215400696,
0.15014107525348663,
0.11570101231336594,
0.027620289474725723,
-0.4600926339626312,
0.5243431925773621,
-0.004623399581760168,
-0.7343921661376953,
0.3446340560913086,
0.3430134356021881,
0.5508479475975037,
-0.5953905582427979,
-0.20911887288093567,
-0.10416363179683685,
-0.04710990935564041,
0.057872191071510315,
-0.7329680919647217,
0.24088340997695923,
-0.03110809251666069,
-0.1975194215774536,
-0.8324359655380249,
0.6918931603431702,
-0.08393077552318573,
-0.5305747389793396,
0.057983141392469406,
0.6224356889724731,
0.1021478995680809,
-0.05063994601368904,
-0.6553672552108765,
0.20708785951137543,
0.15211793780326843,
-0.22632138431072235,
0.21229758858680725,
0.6240153312683105,
0.35088908672332764,
1.0785506963729858,
0.44449034333229065,
0.15692104399204254,
0.25934451818466187,
-0.2936207056045532,
0.9656456112861633,
-0.977767825126648,
-0.3804318606853485,
-1.1206015348434448,
0.6258772015571594,
0.25178584456443787,
-0.21450577676296234,
1.053354024887085,
0.6876624226570129,
0.7092150449752808,
-0.06763827055692673,
0.8587084412574768,
0.09139310568571091,
0.6094797849655151,
-0.8454764485359192,
0.03458881005644798,
-0.6401530504226685,
0.6847530007362366,
-0.2447652965784073,
-0.6843435764312744,
-0.002847020048648119,
0.7306950688362122,
-0.26853737235069275,
0.11111979186534882,
0.547382652759552,
0.7261782288551331,
0.11200115829706192,
-0.28702107071876526,
0.09493547677993774,
-0.012171952053904533,
0.598266065120697,
0.7250029444694519,
0.9653201699256897,
-0.419635146856308,
0.5082396864891052,
-0.2052689641714096,
0.19199027121067047,
0.07219293713569641,
-1.1340258121490479,
-0.7393313050270081,
-0.5898790955543518,
-0.46677863597869873,
-0.3260682225227356,
0.16302110254764557,
0.5011665225028992,
0.5759418606758118,
-0.03924180194735527,
-0.3175346851348877,
-0.4255382716655731,
0.2725166976451874,
0.11449310928583145,
-0.16035668551921844,
0.13299931585788727,
-0.480608731508255,
-0.3547309339046478,
0.7102475762367249,
0.4116032123565674,
-0.0315840020775795,
-0.4635310769081116,
-0.3316788673400879,
0.12018199265003204,
-0.06840245425701141,
0.7847029566764832,
0.18693891167640686,
-0.8671711683273315,
-0.20814724266529083,
0.05920548737049103,
0.03968490660190582,
0.0034079216420650482,
0.8411121368408203,
-0.7988801598548889,
0.4637770652770996,
0.15708868205547333,
0.6296359896659851,
0.39410340785980225,
0.255180686712265,
0.7505281567573547,
-0.5126491785049438,
-0.11592351645231247,
0.29799073934555054,
0.1743176132440567,
0.39928674697875977,
-0.09140734374523163,
0.47193899750709534,
0.39379358291625977,
-0.7075307965278625,
-0.510273277759552,
0.34156903624534607,
-1.2704577445983887,
-0.04537668824195862,
1.5871506929397583,
0.1581375002861023,
-0.19104325771331787,
-0.1682477444410324,
-0.261462926864624,
0.015131816267967224,
-0.2964246869087219,
0.3129516541957855,
0.5380348563194275,
-0.35567256808280945,
-0.20851267874240875,
-0.8956907391548157,
0.6434106230735779,
0.1211736723780632,
-0.44853007793426514,
-0.0879698395729065,
0.6223773956298828,
0.3011877238750458,
0.04562389850616455,
1.0253510475158691,
0.4600004255771637,
-0.10720003396272659,
-0.5015999674797058,
-0.09774515777826309,
-0.14048725366592407,
-0.18351389467716217,
-0.2018384486436844,
0.16235293447971344,
0.19690270721912384,
-0.27608782052993774
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10781v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10781v1
|
Exploring Chinese Humor Generation: A Study on Two-Part Allegorical Sayings
| 2024-03-16T02:58:57 | 2024-03-16T02:58:57 |
Rongwu Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Humor, a culturally nuanced aspect of human language, poses challenges for
computational understanding and generation, especially in Chinese humor, which
remains relatively unexplored in the NLP community. This paper investigates the
capability of state-of-the-art language models to comprehend and generate
Chinese humor, specifically focusing on training them to create allegorical
sayings. We employ two prominent training methods: fine-tuning a medium-sized
language model and prompting a large one. Our novel fine-tuning approach
incorporates fused Pinyin embeddings to consider homophones and employs
contrastive learning with synthetic hard negatives to distinguish humor
elements. Human-annotated results show that these models can generate humorous
allegorical sayings, with prompting proving to be a practical and effective
method. However, there is still room for improvement in generating allegorical
sayings that match human creativity.
|
[
-0.11622384935617447,
-0.702023446559906,
0.3167313039302826,
0.7392659187316895,
-0.6640203595161438,
-0.2738180160522461,
-0.196231409907341,
-0.18441492319107056,
0.20065607130527496,
0.3079613149166107,
-0.5608662962913513,
-0.07376458495855331,
-0.18898563086986542,
0.2904544174671173,
-0.051355134695768356,
1.0847729444503784,
0.6420862078666687,
0.10795772075653076,
0.07818151265382767,
0.01743066869676113,
-0.36564016342163086,
-0.45837637782096863,
-0.7767317295074463,
-0.42582273483276367,
1.0009983777999878,
0.4703993499279022,
0.8302662372589111,
0.588405430316925,
0.10022560507059097,
0.13861633837223053,
-0.19655512273311615,
0.11804578453302383,
-0.5196112990379333,
-0.0038204218726605177,
-0.11567232757806778,
-0.5114142894744873,
-0.1194063052535057,
-0.13077260553836823,
0.45843398571014404,
0.7355949282646179,
-0.47533926367759705,
-0.03162463381886482,
-0.21578611433506012,
0.4551876485347748,
-0.4974261224269867,
-0.22328174114227295,
-1.0013853311538696,
0.4436675012111664,
-0.37955793738365173,
-0.47150781750679016,
-0.3224700093269348,
-0.43388938903808594,
-0.0442475788295269,
-0.40946829319000244,
0.2342028021812439,
0.07984741777181625,
0.6208701729774475,
0.2882075011730194,
-0.39544782042503357,
-0.361212819814682,
-0.3361215889453888,
0.8140535354614258,
-1.0017127990722656,
-0.12270742654800415,
-0.027427339926362038,
0.28975287079811096,
-0.07659943401813507,
-0.7577560544013977,
-0.806337833404541,
-0.25980791449546814,
0.18279199302196503,
0.0644763931632042,
-0.05226584151387215,
-0.30595457553863525,
0.10360155254602432,
0.3277149200439453,
-0.6083311438560486,
0.20943216979503632,
-0.3276582956314087,
0.19203932583332062,
0.8122363686561584,
0.18010298907756805,
0.5998859405517578,
-0.505963921546936,
-0.3027084767818451,
-0.15983270108699799,
-0.8391153216362,
0.13095681369304657,
0.46396705508232117,
0.3646014928817749,
0.10618274658918381,
0.38972386717796326,
-0.12973235547542572,
0.269382506608963,
-0.4225020110607147,
-0.09240777045488358,
-0.0645604059100151,
0.08851339668035507,
-0.2843005955219269,
0.03756963834166527,
0.7663721442222595,
0.313085675239563,
0.49977126717567444,
-0.2539050281047821,
-0.23985664546489716,
-0.14468882977962494,
0.15868254005908966,
-0.6298627257347107,
-0.5433520674705505,
0.050370004028081894,
-0.43902787566185,
-0.8247623443603516,
0.013905392028391361,
-0.6209045052528381,
-0.8141627907752991,
-0.03905168175697327,
0.3783102035522461,
-0.4798087179660797,
-0.4555680453777313,
0.39314234256744385,
-0.45396873354911804,
0.31545090675354004,
0.14359894394874573,
-1.0626240968704224,
-0.5367622375488281,
0.8312110900878906,
0.4003474712371826,
0.3396550118923187,
-0.35903286933898926,
-0.5768851041793823,
-0.09123504161834717,
-0.5833961963653564,
0.7805557250976562,
-0.2621016204357147,
-0.16900838911533356,
0.07397425919771194,
-0.2323271483182907,
0.07864948362112045,
-0.6366387009620667,
0.6320803165435791,
-0.06937192380428314,
-0.032401300966739655,
-0.32189247012138367,
-0.12512435019016266,
-0.049513012170791626,
0.209380105137825,
-0.4523448646068573,
0.8232297301292419,
0.22374790906906128,
-0.9598045945167542,
0.242787167429924,
-0.30845707654953003,
-0.7206635475158691,
0.37500429153442383,
-0.15354827046394348,
-0.2979244291782379,
0.46882927417755127,
0.08504778891801834,
0.1980137676000595,
-0.6680026054382324,
0.5170155167579651,
-0.2674558758735657,
-0.29856541752815247,
0.5139471888542175,
-0.34913375973701477,
0.999992311000824,
0.513423502445221,
-0.4204135835170746,
0.04647953808307648,
-0.4038572609424591,
0.06472552567720413,
0.5793158411979675,
-0.27577945590019226,
-0.056262582540512085,
0.10489631444215775,
-0.06636426597833633,
0.6139593124389648,
0.07970449328422546,
-0.614762008190155,
-0.02102239988744259,
-0.6561756730079651,
0.7337660193443298,
0.6079234480857849,
-0.2349039763212204,
-0.08310543745756149,
-0.2910478115081787,
0.267061710357666,
0.1898200660943985,
0.37419983744621277,
-0.43304046988487244,
-0.634430468082428,
-0.9723073840141296,
0.11244682222604752,
0.10328659415245056,
0.5259293913841248,
-1.2334059476852417,
0.28598156571388245,
-0.12354449182748795,
-0.5325718522071838,
-0.7460871338844299,
0.20938612520694733,
0.2547815144062042,
0.2941444218158722,
0.11858714371919632,
-0.4300951659679413,
-0.31643614172935486,
-0.6740884184837341,
-0.318228542804718,
-0.2996240556240082,
-0.5388330221176147,
0.46642544865608215,
0.2634481191635132,
0.09988915175199509,
0.6342813372612,
-0.3766584098339081,
0.10358334332704544,
-0.4593237340450287,
0.5514645576477051,
-0.1216684952378273,
0.2799273133277893,
0.7627823948860168,
-0.635536789894104,
-0.3089996874332428,
-0.025992045179009438,
-0.9027747511863708,
0.0003200198116246611,
-0.10744652152061462,
-0.07034888118505478,
0.09150717407464981,
0.21132884919643402,
-0.3070766031742096,
0.2153293639421463,
0.10710841417312622,
-0.22220341861248016,
0.6600281596183777,
-0.17553400993347168,
-0.2063891738653183,
-0.8214206695556641,
-0.08246776461601257,
-0.1194029152393341,
0.27840253710746765,
-0.7545799612998962,
0.357472687959671,
-0.2308891862630844,
-0.3727357089519501,
-0.7872468829154968,
0.6878504753112793,
-0.17801254987716675,
0.13406813144683838,
-0.3582146465778351,
0.15482449531555176,
-0.0731729045510292,
0.38175007700920105,
0.07638825476169586,
0.1554664522409439,
0.7318035960197449,
-0.5658047795295715,
0.5725662112236023,
-0.025687074288725853,
-0.14867523312568665,
0.35497748851776123,
-0.5269638299942017,
0.3009898066520691,
-0.30952656269073486,
0.1746625304222107,
-0.839958906173706,
-0.4577021598815918,
-0.0009827766334638,
-0.5457749962806702,
-0.04376142844557762,
0.4110775291919708,
-0.8634846210479736,
-0.5188859105110168,
-0.4938075542449951,
0.36156609654426575,
0.7611699104309082,
-0.6986299157142639,
0.13361166417598724,
0.09540223330259323,
-0.4100535213947296,
-0.515114963054657,
-0.5709887146949768,
0.4015370309352875,
-0.47189798951148987,
-0.9238644242286682,
0.00029084706329740584,
0.03079906292259693,
-0.06777208298444748,
-0.42386361956596375,
0.3634262979030609,
0.13506917655467987,
0.291201651096344,
-0.27397310733795166,
-0.09734486788511276,
-0.4752140939235687,
0.08152735233306885,
-0.03544474020600319,
0.2374161332845688,
0.14217038452625275,
-0.07005073875188828,
0.5224924683570862,
0.0869905948638916,
-0.16022734344005585,
-0.26918715238571167,
0.41547203063964844,
-0.000491869926918298,
-0.23384380340576172,
0.6155224442481995,
0.7444069981575012,
-0.3213150203227997,
-0.3691738545894623,
-0.3483864367008209,
-0.37172171473503113,
-0.4870084822177887,
0.3461385667324066,
0.11560650914907455,
-0.8474230170249939,
0.14826233685016632,
-0.17583946883678436,
0.14967282116413116,
0.2328779548406601,
0.41591718792915344,
-0.09809503704309464,
1.1251813173294067,
0.7199430465698242,
0.23457549512386322,
0.30630162358283997,
0.3390326499938965,
0.6476960182189941,
-0.47750768065452576,
-0.08076886832714081,
-0.5456916093826294,
-0.27138978242874146,
-0.6008241176605225,
-0.5068070292472839,
0.1236700788140297,
0.32873252034187317,
-0.28899946808815,
-0.0902630165219307,
-0.3380180597305298,
0.47064706683158875,
0.5495913028717041,
0.039595987647771835,
0.014546637423336506,
0.15803168714046478,
-0.12140396982431412,
-0.05343877151608467,
-0.7270023822784424,
-0.348073273897171,
0.5548481941223145,
0.3856792747974396,
0.6607402563095093,
0.20427845418453217,
0.6071261763572693,
-0.058876872062683105,
0.3333505690097809,
-0.7230642437934875,
0.5204498171806335,
-0.8988791108131409,
-0.2148200273513794,
-0.2618465721607208,
-0.4812972843647003,
-0.6334413290023804,
-0.02014072611927986,
-0.3288481533527374,
-0.729600727558136,
-0.04222315922379494,
0.18298740684986115,
-0.3520856201648712,
0.3081289231777191,
-0.20324192941188812,
0.6347047090530396,
-0.33747991919517517,
-0.06993625313043594,
-0.08701828867197037,
-0.8629114031791687,
0.7630198001861572,
0.1213226318359375,
0.11990394443273544,
0.005900258664041758,
0.6881899833679199,
0.4199262857437134,
0.05511738359928131,
0.9155924916267395,
-0.0417729914188385,
-0.4274240732192993,
0.4761551320552826,
0.24429446458816528,
0.05910506471991539,
0.02727176807820797,
-0.30974820256233215,
0.015869993716478348,
-0.38130977749824524,
-0.4255037307739258,
-0.5523035526275635,
0.43242964148521423,
-0.546888530254364,
-0.5679673552513123,
0.037833284586668015,
-0.6645370721817017,
-0.0010274002561345696,
-0.16907070577144623,
0.27073758840560913,
0.06931985169649124,
-0.0241787601262331,
0.48109444975852966,
0.5272185206413269,
-0.8689544796943665,
0.3288915157318115,
0.21878336369991302,
0.14633552730083466,
-0.3330357074737549,
1.2917605638504028,
-0.3313452899456024,
0.16027745604515076,
0.22132427990436554,
0.5513338446617126,
-0.27251407504081726,
0.12294599413871765,
-0.5841080546379089,
0.2893133759498596,
-0.9063656330108643,
-0.04353535547852516,
-0.5193416476249695,
-0.5273082852363586,
-0.5739646553993225,
-0.13542670011520386,
-0.2687017023563385,
-0.5847223401069641,
-0.10918927192687988,
0.0840984508395195,
0.03377861902117729,
0.7740004658699036,
-0.03473932668566704,
0.32471054792404175,
-0.8010778427124023,
0.037186816334724426,
0.6480307579040527,
0.08182864636182785,
0.507595419883728,
-0.28868016600608826,
-0.15706706047058105,
0.08171770721673965,
-0.8382019400596619,
-0.8138219714164734,
0.3289891481399536,
0.5324259400367737,
0.3165118396282196,
0.5612117648124695,
0.1733519434928894,
0.3580962121486664,
-0.5484463572502136,
1.2577358484268188,
0.36047935485839844,
-0.7328320145606995,
0.6745925545692444,
-0.2916153371334076,
0.0006038813735358417,
-0.0984412431716919,
-0.0226848516613245,
-0.7916212677955627,
-0.48173201084136963,
-0.6616972088813782,
-0.8595080971717834,
0.6558597683906555,
0.26938503980636597,
0.5922845005989075,
-0.35920438170433044,
0.5408286452293396,
-0.06907133758068085,
0.4234088361263275,
-0.9430833458900452,
-0.20656846463680267,
-0.5292688012123108,
-0.23906749486923218,
0.21203936636447906,
-0.19853031635284424,
-0.2795899212360382,
-0.09940318018198013,
0.4219004809856415,
-0.24568571150302887,
0.1088312566280365,
-0.18192337453365326,
0.09168616682291031,
-0.26988765597343445,
0.5288209319114685,
0.6935669779777527,
0.5206700563430786,
0.06372915953397751,
0.22694502770900726,
-0.08363192528486252,
-0.1805790215730667,
-0.19285370409488678,
-0.13446050882339478,
-0.09534555673599243,
0.023245694115757942,
0.2199748009443283,
1.2302204370498657,
0.10621877759695053,
-0.7873298525810242,
0.45450130105018616,
-0.016035577282309532,
-0.2810423672199249,
0.13023807108402252,
0.30463355779647827,
0.18501822650432587,
0.12551642954349518,
0.35800901055336,
-0.3555853068828583,
0.25185105204582214,
-0.8357728123664856,
0.1388273388147354,
0.350876122713089,
-0.23509357869625092,
-0.4967205226421356,
0.8743380904197693,
0.20103025436401367,
-0.23408757150173187,
0.7387406826019287,
-0.45989683270454407,
-0.6439140439033508,
0.72646164894104,
0.9551808834075928,
1.0709513425827026,
-0.2976394593715668,
0.6175346970558167,
0.5450134873390198,
0.25015127658843994,
-0.08918476104736328,
0.31518638134002686,
-0.003850064007565379,
-0.6104258894920349,
-0.25108152627944946,
-0.8707370758056641,
-0.33030277490615845,
0.048779770731925964,
-0.4961063861846924,
0.5895513892173767,
-0.18733501434326172,
0.247791588306427,
-0.051980551332235336,
-0.37955451011657715,
-0.46074092388153076,
0.4981274902820587,
0.6691530346870422,
0.7037554383277893,
-0.9058235287666321,
0.7164399027824402,
0.8151810765266418,
-0.29332590103149414,
-0.9826825261116028,
0.23759545385837555,
-0.13526642322540283,
-0.7239965796470642,
0.6297221779823303,
0.3904978036880493,
0.1400720328092575,
0.03930285945534706,
-0.886077344417572,
-0.10203369706869125,
0.887434184551239,
0.4080490171909332,
-0.05616387724876404,
-0.13630062341690063,
0.4374450743198395,
0.642844021320343,
-0.47844111919403076,
0.2109900265932083,
0.6291557550430298,
0.1113133653998375,
0.5487282872200012,
-0.7044245600700378,
0.1769811362028122,
-0.4373868405818939,
0.3343198597431183,
-0.16588972508907318,
-0.6885725855827332,
1.3576650619506836,
-0.5819611549377441,
-0.2517942190170288,
0.12764601409435272,
0.7095648646354675,
0.8577012419700623,
0.5626038312911987,
0.792140781879425,
0.385031133890152,
0.5663840174674988,
-0.03552143648266792,
0.8151834607124329,
-0.16317468881607056,
0.2468862682580948,
0.771644115447998,
-0.27478232979774475,
0.7021527886390686,
0.22374098002910614,
0.23226480185985565,
0.42875418066978455,
0.7018589377403259,
0.07601680606603622,
0.46805188059806824,
0.6022472381591797,
-0.2997141182422638,
-0.4158181846141815,
-0.45415785908699036,
-0.23072397708892822,
0.3243897557258606,
0.2180250734090805,
-0.15311910212039948,
-0.3688315153121948,
-0.005361448973417282,
0.13210082054138184,
-0.08925154060125351,
-0.12318450957536697,
0.8261075615882874,
0.42817234992980957,
-0.6962171196937561,
0.6802390217781067,
0.059404194355010986,
0.8896779417991638,
-0.3241209089756012,
-0.15304861962795258,
-0.35152801871299744,
-0.3037615120410919,
-0.14844490587711334,
-0.8571502566337585,
-0.0512893982231617,
0.19371004402637482,
0.30945613980293274,
0.30914542078971863,
0.3580082952976227,
-0.5504652857780457,
-0.3527992069721222,
0.14729802310466766,
0.19973506033420563,
0.32907333970069885,
-0.051987674087285995,
-0.4983448088169098,
-0.4588284194469452,
0.12594854831695557,
-0.14346365630626678,
0.31935200095176697,
1.2051146030426025,
-0.16417907178401947,
0.5440882444381714,
0.6267316341400146,
0.19226400554180145,
0.15223604440689087,
0.6549803614616394,
0.7795916199684143,
-0.9820334911346436,
-0.6924580931663513,
-0.8767858147621155,
0.736382007598877,
0.009415908716619015,
-0.40073361992836,
0.20989476144313812,
-0.03283965587615967,
0.42834582924842834,
-0.1908310055732727,
0.7958614230155945,
-0.1993088573217392,
0.018008479848504066,
-0.4265161454677582,
0.8135493397712708,
-1.1013739109039307,
0.11779699474573135,
-0.11867845058441162,
-0.7780880928039551,
-0.28550806641578674,
0.4687088429927826,
0.29328933358192444,
-0.110218346118927,
0.5589610934257507,
0.6513650417327881,
0.0973801240324974,
0.35631993412971497,
0.4373430907726288,
0.25862357020378113,
0.5637624859809875,
0.46005383133888245,
0.9474765658378601,
-0.16121989488601685,
0.48524272441864014,
-0.5540243983268738,
-0.17073309421539307,
-0.2288975566625595,
-1.0739737749099731,
-0.8885135650634766,
-0.378069132566452,
-0.13534493744373322,
-0.08732947707176208,
-0.3417859375476837,
0.6578671336174011,
0.2857581079006195,
-0.4722331464290619,
-0.165068119764328,
0.16843973100185394,
-0.0851215198636055,
-0.1187923327088356,
-0.2651659846305847,
0.19853778183460236,
-0.6348187923431396,
-0.5633746981620789,
0.17487972974777222,
0.2773624658584595,
-0.1420753449201584,
-0.46158066391944885,
0.07575251907110214,
0.19309870898723602,
0.40922680497169495,
0.7946879863739014,
0.252898246049881,
-0.910118818283081,
-0.25645047426223755,
0.12559325993061066,
-0.036647405475378036,
-0.17427970468997955,
0.7858057022094727,
-0.20912694931030273,
0.4043915271759033,
0.5266698002815247,
0.49235308170318604,
-0.14338691532611847,
0.032405342906713486,
0.6016148328781128,
-1.2056013345718384,
0.3149321377277374,
0.305498868227005,
0.20973825454711914,
0.8173403739929199,
-0.5055117607116699,
0.4278929531574249,
0.06897438317537308,
-0.6274915337562561,
-1.1775977611541748,
0.37832775712013245,
-0.5886178612709045,
-0.2474561333656311,
0.9848141074180603,
-0.06464292854070663,
-0.4046980142593384,
0.26403769850730896,
-0.22364123165607452,
0.511925995349884,
0.041317906230688095,
1.1754330396652222,
0.5554251074790955,
-0.17005150020122528,
-0.3007308542728424,
-0.6455560326576233,
0.6286443471908569,
0.7141311764717102,
-0.7188814282417297,
0.11305081099271774,
0.0025361329317092896,
0.20561642944812775,
0.2929801940917969,
0.5603516697883606,
-0.08058618754148483,
0.6707490086555481,
0.055422592908144,
0.4214266240596771,
0.4767899215221405,
-0.3917878568172455,
-0.11721161007881165,
-0.22496949136257172,
0.23311388492584229,
0.2872852683067322
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.