id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.13433v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.13433v2
|
AgentGroupChat: An Interactive Group Chat Simulacra For Better Eliciting Emergent Behavior
| 2024-03-20T09:21:32 | 2024-04-04T07:40:31 |
Zhouhong Gu, Xiaoxuan Zhu, Haoran Guo, Lin Zhang, Yin Cai, Hao Shen, Jiangjie Chen, Zheyu Ye, Yifei Dai, Yan Gao, Yao Hu, Hongwei Feng, Yanghua Xiao
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY
|
Language significantly influences the formation and evolution of Human
emergent behavior, which is crucial in understanding collective intelligence
within human societies. Considering that the study of how language affects
human behavior needs to put it into the dynamic scenarios in which it is used,
we introduce AgentGroupChat in this paper, a simulation that delves into the
complex role of language in shaping collective behavior through interactive
debate scenarios. Central to this simulation are characters engaging in dynamic
conversation interactions. To enable simulation, we introduce the Verbal
Strategist Agent, utilizing large language models to enhance interaction
strategies by incorporating elements of persona and action. We set four
narrative scenarios based on AgentGroupChat to demonstrate the simulation's
capacity to mimic complex language use in group dynamics. Evaluations focus on
aligning agent behaviors with human expectations and the emergence of
collective behaviors within the simulation. Results reveal that emergent
behaviors materialize from a confluence of factors: a conducive environment for
extensive information exchange, characters with diverse traits, high linguistic
comprehension, and strategic adaptability. During discussions on ``the impact
of AI on humanity'' in AgentGroupChat simulation, philosophers commonly agreed
that ``AI could enhance societal welfare with judicious limitations'' and even
come to a conclusion that ``the essence of true intelligence encompasses
understanding the necessity to constrain self abilities''. Additionally, in the
competitive domain of casting for primary roles in films in AgentGroupChat,
certain actors were ready to reduce their remuneration or accept lesser roles,
motivated by their deep-seated desire to contribute to the project.
|
[
-0.3801495432853699,
-1.2171862125396729,
0.33353790640830994,
0.1669013351202011,
-0.03850743919610977,
0.760184109210968,
-0.12804986536502838,
-0.39016035199165344,
0.5117132663726807,
0.17775994539260864,
-0.5215455889701843,
0.14399148523807526,
-0.3330173194408417,
-0.1771457940340042,
-0.11883118003606796,
0.9344225525856018,
0.32791921496391296,
-0.07969586551189423,
0.019984841346740723,
0.07027693837881088,
-0.36305058002471924,
-0.7471528649330139,
-1.1550205945968628,
-0.5401644110679626,
0.5930043458938599,
0.2818530797958374,
1.0284510850906372,
0.40944239497184753,
0.17699454724788666,
0.5064792037010193,
0.1821826994419098,
-0.0014809697167947888,
-0.649914562702179,
0.42749789357185364,
-0.1968834400177002,
-0.3150091767311096,
-0.2897137999534607,
0.1889043003320694,
0.7972252368927002,
0.528612494468689,
-0.5041718482971191,
-0.21538405120372772,
-0.010807262733578682,
0.1780407577753067,
0.06644360721111298,
0.47361692786216736,
-0.42020559310913086,
-0.0238665621727705,
0.0021277533378452063,
-0.15179918706417084,
-0.11846457421779633,
-0.0737607553601265,
0.18695068359375,
-0.42721736431121826,
-0.08114027976989746,
0.10691683739423752,
0.7279919981956482,
0.2558240294456482,
-0.49193719029426575,
-0.1627797931432724,
-1.0541051626205444,
0.3574942946434021,
-0.3243114650249481,
-0.17782916128635406,
0.32087406516075134,
0.3466382920742035,
-0.41074687242507935,
-0.7346211671829224,
-0.7630904316902161,
-0.30021628737449646,
0.10344535112380981,
0.23440180718898773,
-0.14614976942539215,
0.3519660532474518,
0.16068434715270996,
0.036197733134031296,
-0.36835408210754395,
0.09413077682256699,
-0.3904992341995239,
0.023351702839136124,
0.6567943692207336,
0.2992589771747589,
0.7723581194877625,
0.07743700593709946,
-0.08675815165042877,
-0.31425949931144714,
-0.07399351894855499,
0.26764366030693054,
0.4664094150066376,
0.2867901623249054,
-0.09084445983171463,
0.3048020303249359,
0.09210579842329025,
0.09672600030899048,
0.10278242081403732,
0.0734347403049469,
0.04338892176747322,
-0.3940887451171875,
0.18093827366828918,
0.2565775513648987,
0.5821545124053955,
0.41175296902656555,
0.39841270446777344,
0.07492518424987793,
0.18144915997982025,
0.20684395730495453,
0.42900514602661133,
-0.763824462890625,
-0.1483721286058426,
0.07059026509523392,
-0.2282942235469818,
-0.33662158250808716,
0.04492252320051193,
-0.8397076725959778,
-0.5572335124015808,
-0.1940939575433731,
0.1888306885957718,
-0.32688620686531067,
-0.6266416311264038,
-0.23338179290294647,
-0.3285543918609619,
0.49770140647888184,
0.498884379863739,
-0.7953314781188965,
0.539878249168396,
0.546806275844574,
0.6477972269058228,
-0.050098709762096405,
-0.6012320518493652,
-0.36585962772369385,
0.1984604448080063,
-0.3565044701099396,
1.005658745765686,
-0.644197940826416,
-0.46896353363990784,
-0.10596214979887009,
-0.3361591100692749,
-0.2520963251590729,
-0.3262748122215271,
0.13247062265872955,
-0.21924008429050446,
-0.03980996459722519,
-0.10175076872110367,
-0.4847506284713745,
0.06451154500246048,
0.21751698851585388,
-0.6844717264175415,
0.4701296389102936,
0.031027261167764664,
-0.36362168192863464,
0.23291437327861786,
-1.1404914855957031,
-0.44406792521476746,
0.6777732968330383,
-0.5809906721115112,
0.12050706893205643,
-0.15285320580005646,
-0.2660621702671051,
0.09688729792833328,
-0.08257163316011429,
0.2604289650917053,
0.009700791910290718,
-0.3061530590057373,
0.6091965436935425,
-0.3851205110549927,
0.43136560916900635,
0.08907818794250488,
-0.3484252095222473,
0.2390192747116089,
0.002133570145815611,
0.18300430476665497,
0.2783961296081543,
-0.28496554493904114,
-0.17689961194992065,
0.196593776345253,
-0.20383726060390472,
0.15476736426353455,
-0.215906023979187,
-0.08338025212287903,
0.35346361994743347,
-0.39839833974838257,
0.39689284563064575,
0.9254568815231323,
0.48170334100723267,
0.46299877762794495,
-0.4204346835613251,
0.868827223777771,
-0.3558562994003296,
0.17275552451610565,
0.05615321919322014,
-0.5845634341239929,
-0.6047163605690002,
-0.22172680497169495,
-0.20141418278217316,
0.6264503598213196,
-1.1176344156265259,
-0.045101866126060486,
-0.15893858671188354,
-0.528121829032898,
-0.4489923119544983,
-0.19185903668403625,
0.35388845205307007,
-0.1826132982969284,
-0.1285530924797058,
-0.18592669069766998,
-0.3997630476951599,
-0.7705110311508179,
-0.3183225691318512,
-0.755378782749176,
0.15738120675086975,
0.19179177284240723,
0.26579785346984863,
-0.09018140286207199,
0.9066603183746338,
-0.2956930994987488,
0.13523107767105103,
-0.9331804513931274,
0.5407597422599792,
-0.16617153584957123,
0.2141600102186203,
0.4904741048812866,
-0.747829794883728,
-0.5531991124153137,
-0.20109926164150238,
-0.551142156124115,
-0.10949991643428802,
-0.14673438668251038,
-0.1745075136423111,
0.10740438848733902,
0.5304476022720337,
-0.6292764544487,
0.5416240692138672,
0.5713460445404053,
-0.6329816579818726,
0.5462354421615601,
-0.24334058165550232,
0.37750115990638733,
-1.1353113651275635,
-0.2798929810523987,
-0.3492836058139801,
0.06624802947044373,
-1.0361599922180176,
-0.006107025779783726,
-0.6638296246528625,
-0.11560112982988358,
-0.48245248198509216,
0.6812673807144165,
-0.38627949357032776,
0.028046276420354843,
-0.3451034128665924,
0.12501941621303558,
-0.19491060078144073,
0.47962746024131775,
-0.20904572308063507,
1.0806158781051636,
0.29423031210899353,
-0.6631113886833191,
0.49570363759994507,
0.10296469926834106,
-0.2656513452529907,
0.4163788855075836,
-0.6145046353340149,
0.27681857347488403,
-0.2843429744243622,
0.44633322954177856,
-0.8225350379943848,
-0.3396192789077759,
0.15881367027759552,
-0.3524995446205139,
0.11508773267269135,
0.07398849725723267,
-0.6424462199211121,
-0.23755525052547455,
-0.0555398166179657,
0.4098668694496155,
0.5436192154884338,
-0.014972630888223648,
0.8793431520462036,
0.7700116038322449,
-0.4227852523326874,
-0.16130630671977997,
-0.4095924198627472,
0.3578576147556305,
-0.22068974375724792,
-0.5771684050559998,
-0.03274006396532059,
-0.417424738407135,
-0.7281032204627991,
-0.27679482102394104,
0.3767721652984619,
-0.13670554757118225,
0.08722133189439774,
0.20399171113967896,
0.11768026649951935,
0.18081822991371155,
0.2759994566440582,
-0.046718258410692215,
0.051345791667699814,
0.05746740475296974,
0.08503469824790955,
1.0039763450622559,
-0.5718130469322205,
-0.2155883014202118,
-0.19312843680381775,
0.5726567506790161,
0.5041607022285461,
-0.11142061650753021,
0.8143317699432373,
0.4270811080932617,
-0.06318147480487823,
-0.17602592706680298,
-0.3517647981643677,
-0.40586555004119873,
-0.5511763095855713,
0.6717045307159424,
-0.19187459349632263,
-0.8383542895317078,
0.8022429943084717,
-0.20033621788024902,
-0.09490812569856644,
0.19441650807857513,
0.5237094163894653,
-0.14797519147396088,
0.8407535552978516,
0.20283731818199158,
0.1666073203086853,
0.667268693447113,
-0.08296821266412735,
0.33688175678253174,
-0.5370494723320007,
-0.15948441624641418,
-0.24655002355575562,
-0.40370652079582214,
-0.49601811170578003,
-0.5806547403335571,
0.32074403762817383,
-0.35727035999298096,
-0.1090417355298996,
-0.04057702422142029,
-0.15365682542324066,
0.6381646990776062,
0.19247356057167053,
-0.2412148118019104,
0.0654948279261589,
-0.011049708351492882,
-0.02057904191315174,
0.0010180515237152576,
-0.6457139253616333,
-0.6259347796440125,
0.3972475826740265,
0.1842622458934784,
0.7957420349121094,
0.3598664104938507,
0.38937878608703613,
0.5984989404678345,
0.3726193904876709,
-0.7664978504180908,
0.9549747109413147,
0.2478463500738144,
-0.6518622040748596,
-0.4575389325618744,
-0.45320507884025574,
-1.3581228256225586,
0.27653980255126953,
-0.1628558188676834,
-0.7964766025543213,
0.011949806474149227,
0.019347526133060455,
-0.200675830245018,
0.16885370016098022,
-0.8944506049156189,
0.7821881771087646,
-0.2127460390329361,
-0.3089695870876312,
-0.38713425397872925,
-0.6581854820251465,
0.09976474195718765,
0.14510291814804077,
0.4355334937572479,
-0.1824842244386673,
0.030003026127815247,
0.4590455889701843,
-0.24381157755851746,
1.0792433023452759,
0.025515802204608917,
0.07041327655315399,
0.6239110231399536,
0.37259072065353394,
0.3718685507774353,
-0.13619394600391388,
-0.11289067566394806,
-0.041705358773469925,
-0.2809964120388031,
-0.26809361577033997,
-0.7138904929161072,
0.32848912477493286,
-0.9343015551567078,
-0.8767253756523132,
-0.40210187435150146,
-0.5771863460540771,
0.052688613533973694,
-0.01452289242297411,
-0.008855680003762245,
0.26724568009376526,
-0.862967848777771,
0.011317623779177666,
0.24088133871555328,
-0.13752709329128265,
0.5445767641067505,
0.5121787786483765,
-0.36136358976364136,
-0.28540828824043274,
0.8908832669258118,
0.11843704432249069,
0.7251263856887817,
-0.06295850872993469,
0.25290635228157043,
-0.06524916738271713,
0.03793220594525337,
-0.2229173630475998,
0.16433145105838776,
-0.5969572067260742,
0.12599855661392212,
-0.7364304661750793,
-0.3809516727924347,
-0.41731685400009155,
-0.12037701159715652,
-0.25878944993019104,
-0.298807293176651,
0.17298100888729095,
-0.4316990375518799,
0.2768487334251404,
0.8165346384048462,
0.05602565407752991,
0.5170240998268127,
-0.544514536857605,
-0.1336621195077896,
0.5568578243255615,
0.06870143115520477,
0.05168513208627701,
-0.16426301002502441,
-0.2750047743320465,
-0.021046847105026245,
-0.2395784705877304,
-0.8125547170639038,
0.3091355562210083,
0.4642958641052246,
0.8953333497047424,
0.5350883603096008,
0.08099057525396347,
0.424566388130188,
-0.47658348083496094,
0.8407691717147827,
-0.1718507558107376,
-0.7515415549278259,
0.4355110824108124,
-0.48800164461135864,
0.2844778001308441,
0.5765008926391602,
-0.18083982169628143,
-0.7822089195251465,
-0.6979376077651978,
-0.7903033494949341,
-0.7385880351066589,
0.7532162070274353,
0.6452500224113464,
0.3690437078475952,
-0.1264551281929016,
0.19382530450820923,
-0.2689923644065857,
0.3150634467601776,
-0.5312262177467346,
-0.2743760347366333,
-0.15467919409275055,
0.12141938507556915,
-0.10702202469110489,
0.041085194796323776,
-0.21258915960788727,
-0.2963522672653198,
0.2618739604949951,
-0.020821018144488335,
0.3339909017086029,
-0.018692485988140106,
0.3526690602302551,
-0.14685110747814178,
0.30507993698120117,
0.6090081334114075,
0.3462788462638855,
0.06868001818656921,
0.196497842669487,
0.11747509986162186,
-0.675814151763916,
0.29039403796195984,
-0.143840029835701,
0.12519453465938568,
-0.27831825613975525,
0.20895777642726898,
0.8388768434524536,
0.038928110152482986,
-0.884915292263031,
0.2532373368740082,
-0.4094070494174957,
-0.14441686868667603,
-0.44034063816070557,
0.4172264337539673,
0.1915343850851059,
0.45756953954696655,
0.46599021553993225,
-0.014091365039348602,
0.07741907984018326,
-1.2220745086669922,
0.23622190952301025,
0.3921016752719879,
-0.11820707470178604,
-0.3053463399410248,
0.3599281907081604,
0.38455620408058167,
-0.9097710251808167,
0.42362964153289795,
-0.6257117390632629,
-0.7690981030464172,
0.9129465818405151,
0.5247933268547058,
0.9146954417228699,
-0.8780937194824219,
0.44447606801986694,
0.010798810981214046,
0.5604857802391052,
-0.0010568503057584167,
0.027722375467419624,
0.3524736166000366,
-1.0189135074615479,
-0.256209135055542,
-0.2636299133300781,
-0.6045441031455994,
-0.19755880534648895,
-0.03606206923723221,
-0.023708214983344078,
-0.37692707777023315,
-0.2849828600883484,
-0.17004552483558655,
0.020791949704289436,
-0.449725866317749,
-0.2727428376674652,
0.12423962354660034,
0.22730498015880585,
-0.6494455337524414,
0.7746765613555908,
0.8651110529899597,
-0.5057581663131714,
-1.1497719287872314,
0.2720063030719757,
-0.008281717076897621,
-0.7443917989730835,
0.4856688380241394,
0.11191828548908234,
-0.2547299861907959,
0.20491284132003784,
-0.7084599137306213,
-0.7272646427154541,
1.0484001636505127,
0.34411776065826416,
0.2652874290943146,
-0.11693956702947617,
0.17385786771774292,
0.8626832365989685,
-0.7154287695884705,
0.3687534034252167,
0.3559076189994812,
0.6045013666152954,
0.5032332539558411,
-0.9689912796020508,
0.05477840453386307,
-0.6482439637184143,
-0.0421191044151783,
0.011095049791038036,
-0.9220970273017883,
0.9341701865196228,
-0.15472003817558289,
-0.4867277443408966,
-0.2421865463256836,
0.5813496708869934,
0.250808984041214,
0.23795144259929657,
0.7276461124420166,
-0.1474534571170807,
0.7105187773704529,
0.1391046792268753,
1.1592235565185547,
-0.06311135739088058,
-0.09953289479017258,
0.9203307628631592,
-0.530767023563385,
0.40674230456352234,
0.33500421047210693,
0.12218990921974182,
0.6319326162338257,
0.2766569256782532,
0.2007981687784195,
0.10620729625225067,
0.48030850291252136,
-0.3573039770126343,
-0.20508472621440887,
-0.4409932494163513,
-0.09772366285324097,
0.7592479586601257,
0.5221684575080872,
0.16042719781398773,
0.011901643127202988,
0.08907118439674377,
0.1362803429365158,
0.12174519151449203,
-0.17930898070335388,
0.9547745585441589,
-0.011332043446600437,
-0.6837416291236877,
-0.02284378558397293,
-0.22695748507976532,
0.28952696919441223,
-0.7082421183586121,
-0.282776802778244,
-0.14817167818546295,
0.04592728242278099,
0.10917675495147705,
-0.636228621006012,
0.061616718769073486,
-0.27620625495910645,
0.17096129059791565,
-0.16351769864559174,
0.7345718741416931,
-0.5393505692481995,
-0.2701243758201599,
0.4456390142440796,
0.7196162939071655,
0.481736958026886,
-0.0097105847671628,
-0.6219757199287415,
0.11595705896615982,
-0.16013900935649872,
-0.37024033069610596,
0.42690369486808777,
0.6852487325668335,
-0.11785878986120224,
0.7887207269668579,
0.5741015672683716,
-0.08691032230854034,
-0.20583753287792206,
0.24598416686058044,
1.0512405633926392,
-0.5028675198554993,
-0.7105531096458435,
-0.854949951171875,
0.46540722250938416,
-0.36712953448295593,
0.042111657559871674,
0.5433579683303833,
0.28059452772140503,
0.16825462877750397,
0.07638375461101532,
0.6396980881690979,
-0.17376044392585754,
0.04252173751592636,
-0.2918042242527008,
1.0539333820343018,
-0.2502204477787018,
0.1397424340248108,
-0.38061046600341797,
-0.8042325973510742,
0.21217826008796692,
0.5879964828491211,
0.00507193012163043,
0.4068257212638855,
0.6701604127883911,
0.5153756737709045,
0.40344953536987305,
0.06096358224749565,
0.42738863825798035,
0.4558025300502777,
0.6828064322471619,
0.142013818025589,
1.147128939628601,
0.15836533904075623,
0.6010939478874207,
0.4128446877002716,
-0.3668254315853119,
-0.18023079633712769,
-0.5423795580863953,
-0.9550964832305908,
-0.5963677763938904,
-0.1777213215827942,
-0.28590190410614014,
0.03225433826446533,
1.3377701044082642,
0.37292763590812683,
-0.10715827345848083,
-0.6690159440040588,
0.08926604688167572,
0.11560212820768356,
-0.31286701560020447,
-0.33266422152519226,
-0.13638617098331451,
-0.2971109449863434,
-0.852515697479248,
0.48169800639152527,
0.20086656510829926,
0.29822367429733276,
-0.30819395184516907,
-0.23986601829528809,
-0.40170344710350037,
0.5638006329536438,
0.6055768132209778,
0.38956496119499207,
-0.406982421875,
-0.29830893874168396,
-0.16970551013946533,
-0.2146996110677719,
-0.10382016748189926,
0.8930913805961609,
-0.4830927848815918,
0.39776450395584106,
0.10462968051433563,
0.29115408658981323,
0.17735479772090912,
0.17513975501060486,
0.8910806179046631,
-0.6646732091903687,
0.24193814396858215,
0.32276251912117004,
0.005581624340265989,
0.0076888506300747395,
-0.573142945766449,
0.49252092838287354,
0.22523897886276245,
-0.8039525747299194,
-0.5366102457046509,
0.394641637802124,
-0.8186381459236145,
-0.18603767454624176,
1.1427860260009766,
0.13873887062072754,
-0.20889273285865784,
-0.4245431125164032,
-0.5762232542037964,
0.2938595414161682,
-0.9615462422370911,
0.8122811913490295,
0.9258889555931091,
-0.3251819610595703,
-0.47644346952438354,
-0.6594552397727966,
0.5629114508628845,
0.11346247792243958,
-0.9718818664550781,
0.03394090384244919,
0.39924389123916626,
-0.24117378890514374,
0.22071443498134613,
1.1260234117507935,
0.3677572011947632,
-0.15476949512958527,
0.14158868789672852,
0.3296949565410614,
0.15090693533420563,
-0.1000150740146637,
0.10483349114656448,
0.0646226555109024,
0.07102856040000916,
0.27907106280326843
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15469v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15469v1
|
Isometric Neural Machine Translation using Phoneme Count Ratio Reward-based Reinforcement Learning
| 2024-03-20T08:52:40 | 2024-03-20T08:52:40 |
Shivam Ratnakant Mhaskar, Nirmesh J. Shah, Mohammadi Zaki, Ashishkumar P. Gudmalwar, Pankaj Wasnik, Rajiv Ratn Shah
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.AS
|
Traditional Automatic Video Dubbing (AVD) pipeline consists of three key
modules, namely, Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR), Neural Machine Translation
(NMT), and Text-to-Speech (TTS). Within AVD pipelines, isometric-NMT algorithms
are employed to regulate the length of the synthesized output text. This is
done to guarantee synchronization with respect to the alignment of video and
audio subsequent to the dubbing process. Previous approaches have focused on
aligning the number of characters and words in the source and target language
texts of Machine Translation models. However, our approach aims to align the
number of phonemes instead, as they are closely associated with speech
duration. In this paper, we present the development of an isometric NMT system
using Reinforcement Learning (RL), with a focus on optimizing the alignment of
phoneme counts in the source and target language sentence pairs. To evaluate
our models, we propose the Phoneme Count Compliance (PCC) score, which is a
measure of length compliance. Our approach demonstrates a substantial
improvement of approximately 36% in the PCC score compared to the
state-of-the-art models when applied to English-Hindi language pairs. Moreover,
we propose a student-teacher architecture within the framework of our RL
approach to maintain a trade-off between the phoneme count and translation
quality.
|
[
-0.3279469311237335,
-0.30987095832824707,
0.17422297596931458,
0.28530582785606384,
-0.8392056226730347,
0.13572658598423004,
-0.32959291338920593,
0.03998556733131409,
0.1289663016796112,
0.30158230662345886,
-0.509380578994751,
-0.5917851328849792,
-0.4569306969642639,
0.27159997820854187,
-0.09653758257627487,
0.8106996417045593,
-0.3691551685333252,
0.3571203351020813,
-0.09820576012134552,
-0.18650345504283905,
-0.6210403442382812,
-0.42518097162246704,
-0.6074358820915222,
-0.5168415307998657,
0.3466029465198517,
0.42378804087638855,
0.5438717007637024,
1.16297447681427,
0.568053126335144,
0.19196996092796326,
0.10880525410175323,
0.24553421139717102,
0.059424400329589844,
0.26191478967666626,
0.15043118596076965,
-0.3776357173919678,
-0.14802546799182892,
-0.027255583554506302,
0.7033819556236267,
0.22517292201519012,
-0.48491042852401733,
0.19112689793109894,
0.17310579121112823,
0.5122207403182983,
-0.4121640920639038,
0.22243960201740265,
-0.2980853319168091,
0.46951913833618164,
0.10339535027742386,
-0.3910641372203827,
-0.4315149188041687,
-0.34914880990982056,
-0.2540377378463745,
-0.6200247406959534,
-0.321087509393692,
-0.18799574673175812,
0.6363388895988464,
0.7719771862030029,
-0.335946261882782,
-0.07715264707803726,
-0.5781330466270447,
0.7642722129821777,
-0.9545178413391113,
0.6828684210777283,
0.4366394281387329,
0.2781980037689209,
0.08538579940795898,
-0.19317631423473358,
-0.4232438802719116,
-0.214243546128273,
0.17364256083965302,
0.3431639075279236,
0.27827686071395874,
-0.019377509132027626,
0.0983160063624382,
0.09511595964431763,
-0.7647422552108765,
0.3670279085636139,
-0.6242009997367859,
-0.1645769476890564,
0.5249640345573425,
0.35291916131973267,
0.24584674835205078,
-0.21123264729976654,
-0.8422608971595764,
-0.29778847098350525,
-0.4826756417751312,
0.30119460821151733,
0.47148704528808594,
0.49685147404670715,
-0.17365887761116028,
0.6586071848869324,
-0.047816064208745956,
0.7982696294784546,
0.05408835411071777,
-0.20834824442863464,
0.11711806803941727,
-0.2901565134525299,
-0.06168648228049278,
0.6213371753692627,
1.126051425933838,
0.16620050370693207,
0.3083999752998352,
0.005227964837104082,
-0.26050013303756714,
-0.01563103497028351,
0.4304426610469818,
-0.9605405926704407,
0.30130162835121155,
0.009465794079005718,
-0.29341813921928406,
-0.4077935516834259,
0.15861263871192932,
-0.33029577136039734,
0.058176763355731964,
-0.6221755743026733,
0.4435034692287445,
-0.8852998614311218,
-0.02383366785943508,
0.09335397183895111,
0.2676432132720947,
0.39024588465690613,
0.10882106423377991,
-0.8088270425796509,
0.4829258322715759,
0.5571712255477905,
1.1306908130645752,
-0.49218448996543884,
-0.4167686402797699,
-0.6364118456840515,
-0.07506858557462692,
-0.6353526711463928,
0.28030315041542053,
-0.2594378888607025,
-0.276216596364975,
-0.18836569786071777,
-0.3355611264705658,
-0.18530763685703278,
-0.4181246757507324,
0.3122681677341461,
-0.5933657884597778,
0.3411013185977936,
0.2564663290977478,
-0.5382270812988281,
-0.18024006485939026,
0.1437007039785385,
-0.3784988820552826,
0.7442602515220642,
-0.09622698277235031,
-0.3694347143173218,
0.14095206558704376,
-0.4884510338306427,
-0.3649047613143921,
-0.019206367433071136,
-0.31867772340774536,
-0.4504142701625824,
-0.05992903560400009,
0.1894255429506302,
0.14358828961849213,
-0.3337765336036682,
0.2902906835079193,
0.0901443287730217,
-0.5868628621101379,
0.4626053273677826,
-0.5427720546722412,
0.7305116653442383,
0.7043827772140503,
-0.33385926485061646,
0.2659282386302948,
-0.45155462622642517,
0.26074662804603577,
-0.37019744515419006,
-0.5410739779472351,
-0.07336028665304184,
-0.03562172129750252,
-0.015751512721180916,
0.5559850335121155,
-0.0961495041847229,
-0.493483304977417,
0.1195826306939125,
-0.3141043484210968,
0.44595038890838623,
0.715187132358551,
0.014681544154882431,
0.3369221091270447,
-0.13792452216148376,
0.8185880780220032,
0.12864281237125397,
-0.031210141256451607,
-0.12101360410451889,
-0.2387293428182602,
-0.26902663707733154,
-0.35053715109825134,
0.5054268836975098,
0.7295060157775879,
-0.7884862422943115,
0.5870450139045715,
-0.3443344235420227,
-0.25811567902565,
-0.8681997060775757,
0.2491704225540161,
0.6399895548820496,
0.34947285056114197,
0.42097389698028564,
-0.8016831278800964,
-0.4429747760295868,
-0.6835233569145203,
-0.08132614195346832,
-0.41884857416152954,
-0.24249367415905,
-0.005332774017006159,
0.0516568124294281,
0.33832406997680664,
0.8251150250434875,
-0.21324318647384644,
-0.4257426857948303,
0.08160336315631866,
0.17064732313156128,
0.15172886848449707,
0.6084450483322144,
0.07817475497722626,
-0.6569077372550964,
-0.5598520636558533,
0.0856831818819046,
-0.6428993940353394,
-0.13552579283714294,
-0.1401643007993698,
0.3069767951965332,
0.1567603051662445,
0.8282043933868408,
-0.31826940178871155,
0.3046925663948059,
0.6322363615036011,
-0.2038821130990982,
0.39807528257369995,
-0.10101156681776047,
0.35151180624961853,
-1.1779043674468994,
-0.14138281345367432,
-0.07731815427541733,
-0.45996174216270447,
-0.2875284254550934,
-0.20682986080646515,
0.047847650945186615,
-0.4242798089981079,
-0.6268147230148315,
0.20165419578552246,
-0.2324855923652649,
-0.2236631065607071,
-0.3608779013156891,
0.11254137754440308,
-0.30053919553756714,
0.7278153300285339,
0.25661763548851013,
1.026857614517212,
-0.008796364068984985,
-0.41746118664741516,
0.36732253432273865,
0.15082404017448425,
-0.4207402467727661,
0.7053069472312927,
-0.5833725333213806,
0.10018450766801834,
0.2911776900291443,
0.22980304062366486,
-0.6998622417449951,
0.11336174607276917,
0.3079802691936493,
-0.9635876417160034,
0.02798118256032467,
-0.2352941632270813,
-0.2260199636220932,
0.17041637003421783,
-0.09977928549051285,
0.5750414133071899,
0.6618990898132324,
-0.3267325162887573,
0.22963029146194458,
0.06727460026741028,
-0.19527661800384521,
-0.7098318338394165,
-0.5479480624198914,
0.10622935742139816,
-0.30316948890686035,
-0.42772746086120605,
0.3713643550872803,
0.20707029104232788,
0.07375482469797134,
0.09534849971532822,
-0.23993846774101257,
-0.14828623831272125,
-0.0999823585152626,
0.2320214807987213,
0.14759834110736847,
-0.5172012448310852,
0.1461321860551834,
-0.12541620433330536,
-0.10014544427394867,
0.0399126373231411,
-0.5950313806533813,
0.6996412873268127,
-0.21205055713653564,
-0.2857387065887451,
-0.8426212072372437,
0.1570994108915329,
0.7072473168373108,
-0.32915470004081726,
0.7363040447235107,
0.9000263810157776,
-0.2512509524822235,
-0.040303874760866165,
-0.15024690330028534,
-0.32746073603630066,
-0.39229321479797363,
0.3652413785457611,
-0.48463746905326843,
-0.6690382957458496,
0.4282664954662323,
0.14857247471809387,
-0.15084703266620636,
0.0790230929851532,
0.41947782039642334,
0.0013725534081459045,
1.1065243482589722,
0.3945345878601074,
-0.12250424176454544,
0.7801299691200256,
-0.1749061793088913,
0.0028761408757418394,
-0.9308289289474487,
-0.1928132325410843,
-0.22510996460914612,
-0.42777585983276367,
-0.4819169044494629,
-0.4818074703216553,
0.36990639567375183,
0.23417453467845917,
-0.5003729462623596,
0.6583304405212402,
-0.28767460584640503,
0.40440577268600464,
0.5441071391105652,
0.1686079353094101,
0.28779053688049316,
0.045085012912750244,
-0.42287343740463257,
-0.24050086736679077,
-0.686025857925415,
-0.3804560601711273,
0.7952120304107666,
0.2704079747200012,
0.6670316457748413,
0.274181067943573,
0.8953576683998108,
0.2331719696521759,
-0.1373605728149414,
-0.8885288238525391,
0.47898179292678833,
-0.07936805486679077,
-0.17727820575237274,
-0.5540256500244141,
-0.6157664060592651,
-0.7049230337142944,
0.29363176226615906,
0.051470693200826645,
-0.6027039289474487,
0.17504097521305084,
-0.010620596818625927,
-0.2158435583114624,
0.19169363379478455,
-0.37720638513565063,
0.8120413422584534,
-0.5419554710388184,
-0.41084370017051697,
-0.3876454532146454,
-0.7857956886291504,
0.23622466623783112,
0.10400380194187164,
-0.16422639787197113,
0.0610581710934639,
-0.3181939125061035,
0.6225507259368896,
-0.5876728296279907,
0.6358569860458374,
-0.05112049728631973,
0.13935188949108124,
0.18409186601638794,
0.003497376572340727,
0.24672791361808777,
-0.06214838847517967,
0.023815354332327843,
-0.04639488086104393,
-0.12945295870304108,
-0.37360870838165283,
-0.6756133437156677,
0.6086589097976685,
-0.9561977386474609,
-0.31285130977630615,
-0.4331217110157013,
-0.697048008441925,
-0.10139373689889908,
0.08466774225234985,
0.2150101363658905,
0.10025527328252792,
-0.0802953690290451,
0.47970810532569885,
0.587341845035553,
-0.2195914387702942,
0.36499935388565063,
0.5153079628944397,
-0.33438536524772644,
-0.8568551540374756,
0.8919246792793274,
0.08034168183803558,
0.4969290494918823,
0.28630274534225464,
0.06623243540525436,
-0.3556385338306427,
-0.39630499482154846,
-0.7428327202796936,
0.0011246580397710204,
-0.21260599792003632,
-0.2974378168582916,
-0.22711609303951263,
-0.4236266613006592,
-0.5085912346839905,
-0.09114325791597366,
-0.5291768312454224,
-0.3711200952529907,
-0.0854935273528099,
-0.02094186097383499,
0.4063876271247864,
0.24747252464294434,
-0.2544511556625366,
0.44963181018829346,
-0.6073405146598816,
0.24695797264575958,
0.2666075527667999,
0.4187324643135071,
-0.3103274703025818,
-1.0443048477172852,
-0.42610809206962585,
-0.04244822636246681,
-0.33903995156288147,
-0.9151349067687988,
0.7159338593482971,
0.012253270484507084,
0.1114148423075676,
0.36519482731819153,
-0.021168647333979607,
0.5772861838340759,
-0.6296164989471436,
0.44506195187568665,
0.5116184949874878,
-0.8383707404136658,
0.20249216258525848,
-0.30849865078926086,
0.3930336534976959,
0.43194425106048584,
0.4106326699256897,
-1.0385311841964722,
-0.15317903459072113,
-0.462994247674942,
-0.9005085229873657,
0.8247970342636108,
0.2791329324245453,
-0.10809137672185898,
0.16083800792694092,
-0.032806724309921265,
-0.15382610261440277,
0.15045416355133057,
-0.5199297666549683,
0.021644791588187218,
-0.4033254086971283,
-0.5241580605506897,
-0.11442938446998596,
0.25018197298049927,
-0.034693047404289246,
-0.03736976161599159,
0.8875634074211121,
-0.04109666123986244,
0.07916199415922165,
0.17282463610172272,
-0.2500130832195282,
-0.02172769233584404,
0.36951446533203125,
0.7807095646858215,
0.30583763122558594,
-0.39376887679100037,
-0.006232257001101971,
0.09506233036518097,
-0.4357517957687378,
0.6300351023674011,
0.11691079288721085,
-0.226162850856781,
0.08802886307239532,
-0.07732845842838287,
1.0163962841033936,
0.03808869048953056,
-0.575707733631134,
0.39798203110694885,
0.07898001372814178,
-0.245046928524971,
-0.4733915328979492,
-0.12978866696357727,
0.18384644389152527,
0.20104649662971497,
0.10727133601903915,
0.06909170746803284,
-0.11946126073598862,
-0.26645123958587646,
0.5670340061187744,
0.027168167755007744,
-1.0091142654418945,
-0.15669481456279755,
0.645167350769043,
0.1803642362356186,
-0.8706463575363159,
0.9116799831390381,
0.0663711354136467,
-0.4192638397216797,
0.7902940511703491,
0.690541684627533,
0.9231380224227905,
-0.5863100290298462,
0.37510260939598083,
0.3901660442352295,
0.39942875504493713,
-0.21485145390033722,
-0.034139201045036316,
-0.14746427536010742,
-0.7049307823181152,
-0.6412411332130432,
-0.5179567933082581,
-0.3491017520427704,
0.10255894064903259,
-0.9546533226966858,
0.542446494102478,
-0.4163716733455658,
-0.052118636667728424,
-0.19566284120082855,
-0.21382875740528107,
-0.2809496819972992,
0.03973405808210373,
0.23561997711658478,
0.7377943396568298,
-1.0100253820419312,
1.0939710140228271,
0.641294002532959,
-0.6683741211891174,
-1.029133677482605,
-0.0971260741353035,
0.20422813296318054,
-0.5266075134277344,
0.8183034658432007,
0.05145446956157684,
-0.28835394978523254,
0.19223591685295105,
-0.08331120014190674,
-0.6604655981063843,
1.033076524734497,
0.2964412569999695,
-0.4332003891468048,
0.2104371041059494,
0.2698691487312317,
0.5824379324913025,
-0.5760458707809448,
0.04882166534662247,
0.1856793314218521,
0.14356417953968048,
-0.06318861991167068,
-0.8680940270423889,
-0.2009669989347458,
-0.2999367415904999,
0.18103815615177155,
0.3305550217628479,
-0.5163096189498901,
0.5861488580703735,
-0.008904218673706055,
-0.05817337706685066,
-0.06235913187265396,
0.6610506176948547,
0.33458054065704346,
0.0008405983098782599,
0.5879542231559753,
0.7101694941520691,
0.11612307280302048,
0.2303655445575714,
0.7269781827926636,
-0.29869189858436584,
0.21402177214622498,
1.1868133544921875,
-0.045702576637268066,
0.9822803735733032,
0.6821550130844116,
-0.1262982189655304,
0.3835798501968384,
0.6884482502937317,
0.1278950273990631,
0.4834344983100891,
0.523354709148407,
-0.2903190851211548,
-0.34976762533187866,
-0.22548140585422516,
-0.19633284211158752,
0.5923968553543091,
0.2228114753961563,
-0.38298553228378296,
-0.00553554343059659,
0.13836413621902466,
-0.09882597625255585,
0.45818251371383667,
-0.011462525464594364,
0.914594292640686,
0.2911272644996643,
-0.8201305270195007,
0.8197134733200073,
0.09646844863891602,
0.5461973547935486,
-0.5544717311859131,
-0.10036826878786087,
-0.3728383481502533,
0.25247618556022644,
0.06212899461388588,
-0.47984614968299866,
0.12648671865463257,
0.1679021269083023,
-0.11821971833705902,
-0.4120948314666748,
0.10981906950473785,
-0.8856955766677856,
-0.30294543504714966,
0.07386152446269989,
0.30603834986686707,
0.37236732244491577,
0.28168976306915283,
-0.800876259803772,
-0.022022055462002754,
0.05149967968463898,
-0.13894116878509521,
0.43771547079086304,
0.35034871101379395,
-0.21052701771259308,
0.6343152523040771,
0.45540767908096313,
0.2816135883331299,
0.0404953807592392,
-0.1406739056110382,
0.37792065739631653,
-0.5656102895736694,
-0.6298246383666992,
-0.808455765247345,
0.2996261417865753,
0.07597208768129349,
-0.32513493299484253,
0.37848928570747375,
0.7082386612892151,
0.9699912667274475,
-0.12033779919147491,
0.4179912209510803,
0.13475550711154938,
0.26834920048713684,
-0.7766358852386475,
0.469438374042511,
-0.3835911452770233,
0.3967975676059723,
-0.008913702331483364,
-0.9024724960327148,
-0.21509221196174622,
0.7480019927024841,
-0.21222306787967682,
-0.22491194307804108,
0.8510844707489014,
0.8363609313964844,
-0.137057825922966,
-0.32888931035995483,
0.36613142490386963,
-0.21668924391269684,
0.11035241931676865,
0.5741593241691589,
0.6939384937286377,
-0.5903953313827515,
0.9601958394050598,
-0.27133312821388245,
0.05625392124056816,
-0.14872850477695465,
-0.6156154274940491,
-0.3817327618598938,
-0.6916934251785278,
-0.2987421751022339,
-0.3848356008529663,
0.38300058245658875,
1.2460418939590454,
0.6011583209037781,
-0.7740027904510498,
-0.8504607081413269,
-0.04542544111609459,
0.13237830996513367,
-0.6699022650718689,
-0.22739177942276,
0.28092899918556213,
-0.5166749954223633,
-0.6718682646751404,
0.4581463634967804,
0.2464173585176468,
-0.017384182661771774,
-0.03989392891526222,
-0.525878369808197,
-0.38817358016967773,
-0.02655590884387493,
0.1729939728975296,
0.43994995951652527,
-0.6847477555274963,
-0.21570836007595062,
0.16351547837257385,
-0.35801759362220764,
0.3583959639072418,
0.9198863506317139,
-0.7133180499076843,
0.42900142073631287,
0.5454608201980591,
0.856259822845459,
0.45023447275161743,
0.3652128279209137,
0.9770821332931519,
-0.8444110751152039,
0.23965832591056824,
0.37889647483825684,
0.0273007582873106,
0.2457040548324585,
-0.09811653196811676,
0.6013720035552979,
0.06588352471590042,
-0.4841609597206116,
-0.7012524604797363,
0.4108840525150299,
-0.8850412964820862,
-0.21648749709129333,
0.9713799357414246,
-0.2357831597328186,
-0.10236925631761551,
0.13941417634487152,
-0.0031148348934948444,
0.49875882267951965,
-0.48017585277557373,
0.8671053647994995,
0.58110111951828,
-0.010345940478146076,
-0.3539442718029022,
-0.5528825521469116,
0.5279437303543091,
0.7491028308868408,
-0.49118056893348694,
-0.15586373209953308,
0.3997959494590759,
0.17259326577186584,
0.13757334649562836,
0.3771507441997528,
-0.40246760845184326,
0.34883061051368713,
-0.17225928604602814,
0.48649218678474426,
-0.3072892129421234,
-0.2189539521932602,
-0.5568184852600098,
-0.28655993938446045,
0.033789992332458496,
-0.777428388595581
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02305v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02305v1
|
Inserting Faces inside Captions: Image Captioning with Attention Guided Merging
| 2024-03-20T08:38:25 | 2024-03-20T08:38:25 |
Yannis Tevissen, Khalil Guetari, Marine Tassel, Erwan Kerleroux, Frédéric Petitpont
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, eess.IV
|
Image captioning models are widely used to describe recent and archived
pictures with the objective of improving their accessibility and retrieval.
Yet, these approaches tend to be inefficient and biased at retrieving people's
names. In this work we introduce AstroCaptions, a dataset for the image
captioning task. This dataset specifically contains thousands of public
fig-ures that are complex to identify for a traditional model. We also propose
a novel post-processing method to insert identified people's names inside the
caption using explainable AI tools and the grounding capabilities of
vi-sion-language models. The results obtained with this method show
signifi-cant improvements of captions quality and a potential of reducing
halluci-nations. Up to 93.2% of the persons detected can be inserted in the
image captions leading to improvements in the BLEU, ROUGE, CIDEr and METEOR
scores of each captioning model.
|
[
-0.6686455607414246,
-0.11874807626008987,
0.4340015947818756,
0.149028018116951,
-0.44990256428718567,
0.1565561592578888,
0.0672471895813942,
-0.7564488649368286,
-0.019194968044757843,
0.9261690974235535,
-0.39943021535873413,
-0.27567920088768005,
-0.5652652382850647,
0.01753964275121689,
-0.4764978885650635,
0.8894577026367188,
-0.09791485220193863,
0.2637338936328888,
-0.7187812924385071,
-0.20221614837646484,
-0.6199100613594055,
-0.32557758688926697,
-0.339934378862381,
0.27354300022125244,
0.29868796467781067,
0.222810760140419,
0.9010785222053528,
0.807274341583252,
0.9545225501060486,
0.22833122313022614,
0.03934948518872261,
0.587391197681427,
-0.2923741042613983,
-0.33116981387138367,
-0.2614627182483673,
-0.4361937344074249,
-0.055465564131736755,
0.23559032380580902,
0.543058454990387,
0.6166207194328308,
0.35889098048210144,
-0.00010186709550907835,
-0.12384379655122757,
0.6516135931015015,
-0.4366501569747925,
0.5678887367248535,
-0.3720216751098633,
0.12193788588047028,
-0.2860042452812195,
-0.22864533960819244,
-0.25616106390953064,
-0.4720812141895294,
0.207992821931839,
-0.39272937178611755,
0.2775605022907257,
0.2487846165895462,
0.9622806310653687,
0.5204561948776245,
0.07904607057571411,
-0.10071324557065964,
-0.6410186886787415,
0.590481698513031,
-0.41932597756385803,
0.22345484793186188,
0.13293008506298065,
0.5752796530723572,
0.006739786360412836,
-0.49575188755989075,
-0.5407534837722778,
-0.13046014308929443,
-0.48350831866264343,
0.06131965294480324,
-0.09930173307657242,
0.036871347576379776,
0.2525155246257782,
0.4696342647075653,
-0.34436294436454773,
-0.013334561139345169,
-0.48006299138069153,
-0.11935501545667648,
0.6949755549430847,
-0.06503261625766754,
0.250055193901062,
-0.023255519568920135,
-0.353907972574234,
-0.20298440754413605,
-0.6317644715309143,
-0.2125633805990219,
0.20130768418312073,
0.4231889545917511,
0.02853044681251049,
0.888235330581665,
-0.2311987727880478,
0.5171246528625488,
0.1987326592206955,
0.16602689027786255,
0.20586664974689484,
-0.18887990713119507,
-0.20775099098682404,
-0.222695454955101,
0.6175175905227661,
0.760974109172821,
0.6180107593536377,
-0.29007741808891296,
-0.040207549929618835,
0.07902439683675766,
0.13907086849212646,
-0.7013282179832458,
-0.40809860825538635,
0.21515855193138123,
-0.4947531223297119,
-0.43896615505218506,
0.5663459300994873,
-0.7876300811767578,
-0.6927676200866699,
-0.45633912086486816,
0.5673600435256958,
-0.20745398104190826,
0.07312080264091492,
-0.278067409992218,
-0.22539980709552765,
0.2366136759519577,
0.4870557188987732,
-0.43745458126068115,
0.4718254506587982,
0.3821306824684143,
0.6549128890037537,
-0.094012051820755,
-0.10316500812768936,
-0.7977707982063293,
-0.014091496355831623,
-0.13467086851596832,
1.183799147605896,
-0.4783809781074524,
0.03961313143372536,
-0.012727653607726097,
0.06495039910078049,
0.07086275517940521,
-0.6970808506011963,
0.0977521762251854,
-0.6743538975715637,
0.4292927384376526,
-0.34028446674346924,
-0.3766869306564331,
-0.25483229756355286,
-0.18012841045856476,
-0.7449910640716553,
0.6298544406890869,
0.1849820464849472,
-0.7465096116065979,
0.2036263793706894,
-0.9276062846183777,
-0.28604716062545776,
0.4645172655582428,
-0.30345866084098816,
-0.5892090797424316,
0.10950106382369995,
0.9631978273391724,
0.6489267945289612,
-0.14800608158111572,
0.20108631253242493,
0.17293882369995117,
-0.23704172670841217,
0.3576599657535553,
0.12106459587812424,
0.6369824409484863,
0.22486339509487152,
-0.19155067205429077,
0.2562262713909149,
0.1333545297384262,
-0.28543993830680847,
0.21380656957626343,
0.12214019894599915,
-0.032700326293706894,
-0.06885452568531036,
0.4682813286781311,
0.010483975522220135,
-0.007896892726421356,
-0.2593790590763092,
0.26435694098472595,
-0.1849924474954605,
0.39003169536590576,
0.3393555283546448,
0.13910339772701263,
0.5893662571907043,
-0.4073406755924225,
0.5087864398956299,
0.22953106462955475,
0.22915059328079224,
-0.6737534999847412,
-0.5781149864196777,
-0.537956714630127,
-0.31765779852867126,
0.4375583529472351,
0.5609338283538818,
-0.7210583090782166,
0.2969023883342743,
-0.31540539860725403,
-0.4739034175872803,
-0.503848135471344,
0.010196401737630367,
0.311661034822464,
0.44490987062454224,
0.30515486001968384,
-0.5074668526649475,
-0.36080795526504517,
-1.071958303451538,
-0.22558215260505676,
-0.10161684453487396,
-0.07777414470911026,
0.7897074222564697,
0.4298124611377716,
-0.2125401645898819,
0.9348574280738831,
-0.5271359086036682,
-0.2980639636516571,
0.07642459869384766,
0.047003135085105896,
0.04247811809182167,
0.42208313941955566,
0.47430795431137085,
-1.194623351097107,
-0.3957199454307556,
-0.033604662865400314,
-0.8193312287330627,
0.05095208063721657,
-0.27053335309028625,
-0.0479426309466362,
-0.010313387028872967,
0.7256519198417664,
-0.7845081090927124,
0.42357057332992554,
0.05698997527360916,
0.03737204521894455,
0.5246867537498474,
0.09062810987234116,
0.3655772805213928,
-0.7510953545570374,
-0.010564906522631645,
0.12077727913856506,
-0.4408552050590515,
-0.3415256142616272,
0.3018035888671875,
0.049510709941387177,
-0.49182963371276855,
-0.6199135780334473,
0.5845292210578918,
-0.8713332414627075,
-0.26030877232551575,
-0.2433125376701355,
0.23063519597053528,
-0.3427944779396057,
0.2755776643753052,
0.2970815896987915,
0.6356230974197388,
0.8899399638175964,
-0.277164489030838,
0.43918806314468384,
0.5901244878768921,
-0.4500225782394409,
0.7829449772834778,
-0.3800688087940216,
0.2217482328414917,
-0.8109825253486633,
0.32407665252685547,
-1.3000421524047852,
-0.8025087714195251,
0.4476076662540436,
-0.38094598054885864,
0.20564472675323486,
-0.1494012176990509,
-0.4755238890647888,
-0.6015644669532776,
-0.03342647850513458,
0.5053974986076355,
0.44238319993019104,
-0.8010079264640808,
0.63265061378479,
0.5116499066352844,
-0.1940782219171524,
-0.4458557665348053,
-0.5358843207359314,
0.4436439573764801,
-0.47833067178726196,
-0.48856449127197266,
0.6819922924041748,
-0.04686148837208748,
-0.2298099845647812,
0.3239978849887848,
0.2724354863166809,
-0.12164764851331711,
-0.385414719581604,
0.3301631510257721,
0.26915836334228516,
-0.01242041401565075,
0.15316857397556305,
-0.12008193880319595,
-0.0520331934094429,
-0.3183811902999878,
-0.12609043717384338,
0.2814156115055084,
-0.06690056622028351,
0.043429724872112274,
-0.9093806743621826,
0.6079077124595642,
0.879298746585846,
-0.598882257938385,
0.5755690336227417,
0.26460278034210205,
-0.7358583807945251,
0.23865902423858643,
-0.7653288841247559,
-0.35952287912368774,
-0.37067320942878723,
0.1789327710866928,
-0.08049774914979935,
-0.6548134088516235,
0.6591191291809082,
-0.17214658856391907,
0.0318865142762661,
0.37014153599739075,
0.158272847533226,
-0.40038326382637024,
0.7612462639808655,
0.5162436962127686,
-0.28393012285232544,
0.5798166990280151,
-0.2518033981323242,
0.1282203495502472,
-0.6115962862968445,
-0.2304503619670868,
-0.30581074953079224,
-0.39529159665107727,
-0.5888774394989014,
-0.7266956567764282,
0.09865759313106537,
-0.20902961492538452,
0.4073290526866913,
0.6621666550636292,
-0.737821102142334,
0.9945389032363892,
0.31505969166755676,
0.3779691755771637,
0.07746938616037369,
0.1093975380063057,
0.670404851436615,
-0.12464645504951477,
-0.46443596482276917,
-0.38782984018325806,
0.80617356300354,
0.2154688984155655,
0.5871265530586243,
-0.31370213627815247,
0.6818394064903259,
0.3415309488773346,
0.6910606622695923,
-0.7057818174362183,
0.4845750629901886,
-0.2867555022239685,
-0.6633208990097046,
-0.13983750343322754,
-0.25224071741104126,
-0.8722555637359619,
0.022489486262202263,
-0.24896927177906036,
-0.7918432950973511,
0.20301993191242218,
0.058447424322366714,
-0.7476766109466553,
-0.06389706581830978,
-0.48862630128860474,
0.8401573896408081,
-0.2997272312641144,
0.042180512100458145,
-0.007797569967806339,
-0.85844486951828,
0.32732275128364563,
0.10645847767591476,
0.39710375666618347,
0.16023196280002594,
0.18904615938663483,
0.7168187499046326,
-0.15287910401821136,
0.635150671005249,
-0.3522733151912689,
0.5156401991844177,
0.27409827709198,
-0.2952892780303955,
0.5323846936225891,
-0.24156799912452698,
0.5654751658439636,
0.22911366820335388,
-0.35550302267074585,
-0.1216474249958992,
-0.5947005152702332,
0.6409812569618225,
-0.5486493110656738,
-0.45654454827308655,
-0.19687001407146454,
-0.7042779326438904,
0.06982307881116867,
0.02573869377374649,
0.2608794569969177,
0.3990662395954132,
0.14450904726982117,
0.18750537931919098,
0.604581892490387,
-0.21517668664455414,
0.20015038549900055,
-0.11741841584444046,
-0.3099122643470764,
-0.7962910532951355,
0.615510106086731,
0.21705801784992218,
-0.11240304261445999,
0.34334084391593933,
0.0622192844748497,
-0.3501427173614502,
-0.5523228049278259,
-0.3647903501987457,
0.6687949895858765,
-0.6482311487197876,
-0.464644193649292,
-0.6448283791542053,
-0.17850831151008606,
-0.25500816106796265,
-0.42289966344833374,
-0.30293023586273193,
-0.22132250666618347,
-0.28106415271759033,
0.13991333544254303,
0.20889170467853546,
0.6228687763214111,
0.25220802426338196,
0.9013859629631042,
-0.6753478050231934,
0.5982485413551331,
0.2432873547077179,
0.2894578278064728,
-0.11935640126466751,
-0.356317937374115,
-0.2867890000343323,
-0.3157724440097809,
-0.1664266586303711,
-1.1264231204986572,
0.47102510929107666,
0.05445678159594536,
0.592460036277771,
0.3837677538394928,
-0.1457260251045227,
0.900421142578125,
-0.2530219256877899,
0.587893545627594,
-0.08592840284109116,
-0.867811918258667,
0.5913200974464417,
-0.38965821266174316,
0.2282114326953888,
0.553745448589325,
0.29291582107543945,
-0.4871065318584442,
-0.36081886291503906,
-0.6888733506202698,
-0.7914162278175354,
0.7765362858772278,
0.3707505762577057,
0.2627277672290802,
0.1502039134502411,
0.5820586085319519,
0.07050956785678864,
0.22109641134738922,
-0.6834539771080017,
-0.13919419050216675,
0.08709465712308884,
-0.33610454201698303,
-0.11556892096996307,
0.18633849918842316,
-0.14986346662044525,
-0.29469215869903564,
0.2624393701553345,
-0.06853600591421127,
0.45381075143814087,
0.1868501603603363,
-0.24290426075458527,
-0.15161971747875214,
-0.4414598047733307,
0.39100366830825806,
0.36759570240974426,
-0.13240444660186768,
0.04345563426613808,
-0.21923328936100006,
-0.04963368922472,
-0.30125924944877625,
0.3616471588611603,
0.04202878475189209,
-0.037293702363967896,
0.1631644368171692,
0.5309321880340576,
0.04442315921187401,
-0.43860816955566406,
0.5337427854537964,
-0.16121743619441986,
-0.04361816123127937,
-0.30236414074897766,
-0.038220565766096115,
-0.02956882305443287,
0.4109081029891968,
0.5831310749053955,
0.46996188163757324,
0.19955341517925262,
-0.5652096271514893,
0.2757920026779175,
0.5557265877723694,
-0.37630799412727356,
0.008799320086836815,
0.790102481842041,
0.3884750008583069,
-0.5008223652839661,
0.7706072330474854,
0.13258211314678192,
-0.5105143785476685,
0.7115439772605896,
0.24360495805740356,
0.8743282556533813,
-0.15807847678661346,
0.20773713290691376,
0.5548930168151855,
0.3144443929195404,
-0.24759680032730103,
-0.025440672412514687,
-0.2959347069263458,
-0.622786283493042,
-0.4339233636856079,
-0.08307894319295883,
-0.504443883895874,
0.1623416543006897,
-0.41186290979385376,
0.36272406578063965,
-0.26297181844711304,
-0.11233177036046982,
0.4081716239452362,
-0.33627477288246155,
-0.9325519800186157,
0.31408974528312683,
0.5808600187301636,
0.5653915405273438,
-1.2453348636627197,
0.1068696528673172,
0.7489184141159058,
-0.4777944087982178,
-0.42157384753227234,
0.10911621898412704,
-0.20671546459197998,
-0.2804180681705475,
0.44222286343574524,
0.7368218898773193,
0.34667256474494934,
0.10665912181138992,
-0.9632625579833984,
-1.0245420932769775,
0.8941075205802917,
0.4128313362598419,
-0.3901823163032532,
0.2674272954463959,
0.11218919605016708,
0.32366541028022766,
-0.7350379824638367,
0.34346580505371094,
0.31601110100746155,
0.8341695070266724,
0.2060050666332245,
-0.7145151495933533,
0.05856011062860489,
-0.13786685466766357,
-0.02968735620379448,
0.026248451322317123,
-0.636093020439148,
0.44394659996032715,
-0.5467725396156311,
-0.4527474045753479,
0.24735088646411896,
0.8316683173179626,
0.05006273463368416,
0.4071939289569855,
0.5065080523490906,
0.32696688175201416,
0.8332341313362122,
-0.30663198232650757,
1.2628179788589478,
0.33542561531066895,
0.10296688973903656,
0.7298542857170105,
0.08355721086263657,
0.45931699872016907,
0.7319266200065613,
-0.17840182781219482,
0.37776029109954834,
0.6971840858459473,
-0.3862743377685547,
0.6969318389892578,
0.06494402885437012,
0.09544402360916138,
-0.19216911494731903,
-0.35655608773231506,
0.1391810029745102,
0.47518303990364075,
0.21929514408111572,
-0.5607371926307678,
-0.10679489374160767,
0.13523243367671967,
-0.05367958918213844,
0.16452379524707794,
-0.2389194369316101,
0.8654677867889404,
-0.1425197720527649,
-0.8360610604286194,
0.12693147361278534,
-0.34401801228523254,
0.3634207546710968,
0.062223490327596664,
-0.1808522492647171,
-0.20525741577148438,
-0.012467958964407444,
-0.4520578980445862,
-0.9005836844444275,
0.39135438203811646,
-0.06509188562631607,
-0.16299840807914734,
-0.02212236262857914,
0.376112163066864,
-0.6067829132080078,
-0.5911601781845093,
-0.1674508899450302,
0.25881674885749817,
0.6078182458877563,
-0.4873960018157959,
-0.4029541015625,
-0.08422687649726868,
-0.024557102471590042,
0.14366993308067322,
-0.09392616152763367,
-0.1553398221731186,
-0.4098150432109833,
0.3965564966201782,
0.553783655166626,
-0.15506218373775482,
-0.37970051169395447,
0.26226964592933655,
0.7798951268196106,
-0.5551806092262268,
-0.4526471793651581,
-0.6718471646308899,
1.0273874998092651,
-0.26133105158805847,
-0.1444339156150818,
0.42782101035118103,
0.4389062821865082,
0.5302819609642029,
-0.5339068174362183,
0.7504968047142029,
-0.0870821475982666,
-0.00462031364440918,
-0.2684529721736908,
0.7197246551513672,
-0.41634270548820496,
-0.21732914447784424,
-0.5590844750404358,
-1.2770819664001465,
-0.8908595442771912,
0.5220035910606384,
-0.2201816588640213,
0.0817738026380539,
0.4213353991508484,
0.7919295430183411,
0.047529056668281555,
-0.34277036786079407,
0.18029120564460754,
-0.13562245666980743,
0.36457550525665283,
0.33955880999565125,
0.9264140129089355,
-0.71324223279953,
0.39023128151893616,
-0.45485764741897583,
-0.41362425684928894,
-0.41925179958343506,
-0.858185350894928,
-1.0029988288879395,
-0.6501182913780212,
-0.828035295009613,
0.2119336873292923,
0.09087162464857101,
0.5458050966262817,
0.9514027237892151,
-0.8596771955490112,
0.10200029611587524,
-0.0591779500246048,
0.00047423242358490825,
-0.3527884781360626,
-0.256914883852005,
0.6165778636932373,
0.019856708124279976,
-0.8955829739570618,
0.12984254956245422,
0.21889787912368774,
0.19891470670700073,
-0.12414009124040604,
0.06243586167693138,
0.3854488134384155,
0.25012046098709106,
0.29703548550605774,
0.21039341390132904,
-0.8816547393798828,
-0.28012147545814514,
-0.1066071167588234,
0.1673971265554428,
0.1834561973810196,
0.47147631645202637,
-0.8149251341819763,
0.5929794311523438,
0.4363279342651367,
0.4344269335269928,
0.47535794973373413,
0.6949765086174011,
0.21262462437152863,
-0.5888190269470215,
-0.033608328551054,
0.2073320746421814,
0.3593093156814575,
0.8250431418418884,
-0.6532739996910095,
0.39126884937286377,
0.2932741045951843,
-0.657672107219696,
-0.8036576509475708,
-0.16585682332515717,
-1.3221609592437744,
0.17332200706005096,
0.7186298966407776,
0.10380328446626663,
-0.11311494559049606,
0.21319545805454254,
-0.6175713539123535,
0.19603349268436432,
-0.3398125171661377,
1.0267584323883057,
0.5753345489501953,
-0.2942875325679779,
-0.6211249232292175,
-0.22343532741069794,
0.2537674605846405,
0.03113630786538124,
-1.125318169593811,
0.19627216458320618,
0.577090322971344,
0.016214098781347275,
0.5455360412597656,
0.1924426257610321,
-0.5259167551994324,
0.5196908116340637,
-0.19477862119674683,
0.2573090195655823,
-0.24383237957954407,
-0.6733381748199463,
-0.22305220365524292,
0.008828063495457172,
-0.18807663023471832,
-0.375752329826355
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.13372v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.13372v4
|
LlamaFactory: Unified Efficient Fine-Tuning of 100+ Language Models
| 2024-03-20T08:08:54 | 2024-06-27T22:44:48 |
Yaowei Zheng, Richong Zhang, Junhao Zhang, Yanhan Ye, Zheyan Luo, Zhangchi Feng, Yongqiang Ma
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Efficient fine-tuning is vital for adapting large language models (LLMs) to
downstream tasks. However, it requires non-trivial efforts to implement these
methods on different models. We present LlamaFactory, a unified framework that
integrates a suite of cutting-edge efficient training methods. It provides a
solution for flexibly customizing the fine-tuning of 100+ LLMs without the need
for coding through the built-in web UI LlamaBoard. We empirically validate the
efficiency and effectiveness of our framework on language modeling and text
generation tasks. It has been released at
https://github.com/hiyouga/LLaMA-Factory and received over 25,000 stars and
3,000 forks.
|
[
-0.29092317819595337,
-0.6596131920814514,
0.5210863351821899,
0.32787612080574036,
-0.12080563604831696,
0.004769609309732914,
-0.3775825798511505,
-0.3778630495071411,
-0.15709710121154785,
0.5133532285690308,
-0.611452043056488,
-0.7129846215248108,
-0.24549439549446106,
0.14933404326438904,
-0.5528318881988525,
0.783899188041687,
-0.0002124447637470439,
-0.15137751400470734,
-0.08494045585393906,
0.05751480534672737,
-0.2581946551799774,
-0.22021740674972534,
-0.5087431073188782,
-0.38424456119537354,
0.45554783940315247,
0.6615126729011536,
0.26895272731781006,
0.9258741736412048,
0.2607654333114624,
0.4187787175178528,
-0.04906635731458664,
0.25722694396972656,
-0.6623912453651428,
0.05552614480257034,
-0.18825900554656982,
-0.4364367723464966,
-0.7320359945297241,
-0.32984960079193115,
0.29461193084716797,
0.7650126218795776,
-0.19861027598381042,
0.5807638168334961,
0.23999428749084473,
0.47571367025375366,
-0.7645951509475708,
-0.15483678877353668,
-0.8612123727798462,
-0.11918532848358154,
-0.23715928196907043,
-0.053118251264095306,
-0.3030308485031128,
-0.288976788520813,
-0.45620113611221313,
-0.7178700566291809,
0.16083382070064545,
-0.10282808542251587,
0.7211012840270996,
0.46254250407218933,
-0.3610391318798065,
0.0528656505048275,
-0.5867002010345459,
0.935139000415802,
-0.8142580986022949,
0.2671477198600769,
0.12845711410045624,
0.20138494670391083,
-0.579771876335144,
-1.0155372619628906,
-0.5592184066772461,
-0.06642857193946838,
0.14750492572784424,
-0.04609072953462601,
-0.2361484169960022,
0.2966400384902954,
0.07718713581562042,
0.4749865233898163,
-0.4765447676181793,
0.5746136903762817,
0.07766003906726837,
-0.05813111737370491,
0.5471298694610596,
0.3309023082256317,
0.29390329122543335,
0.16770340502262115,
-0.192625492811203,
0.17558760941028595,
-0.8215615749359131,
-0.14851099252700806,
0.573321521282196,
0.39240461587905884,
0.039032772183418274,
0.43274903297424316,
-0.8488135933876038,
0.782326877117157,
-0.012966515496373177,
-0.3853100538253784,
0.022984134033322334,
-0.18032775819301605,
-0.35021689534187317,
-0.16191639006137848,
0.8007877469062805,
0.3023596704006195,
0.2225314825773239,
-0.2689141631126404,
-0.4030211269855499,
0.33261838555336,
0.21382376551628113,
-0.8431132435798645,
-0.16592693328857422,
0.17726051807403564,
-0.25538989901542664,
-0.5091943740844727,
-0.32468968629837036,
-0.4943479597568512,
-0.04016934335231781,
-0.3320486843585968,
0.1695026308298111,
0.012918969616293907,
-0.29488787055015564,
0.25224775075912476,
-0.051806047558784485,
0.056307971477508545,
0.4306294620037079,
-1.0771830081939697,
0.17084360122680664,
0.8304375410079956,
0.6402385234832764,
-0.36323797702789307,
-0.5146169662475586,
-0.5653899312019348,
0.2685402035713196,
-0.5000327229499817,
1.035567283630371,
-0.3674899637699127,
-0.4373829960823059,
0.08613665401935577,
0.01961825042963028,
0.14111794531345367,
-0.6169718503952026,
0.4076266288757324,
-0.2822621762752533,
-0.23381532728672028,
-0.06168001890182495,
-0.4844968914985657,
-0.09067364782094955,
0.11706816405057907,
-0.5075626373291016,
1.2211310863494873,
0.00919131375849247,
-0.20739050209522247,
0.34837257862091064,
-0.671768069267273,
-0.5326184034347534,
0.19508470594882965,
0.04615405946969986,
-0.2674049735069275,
0.41000857949256897,
0.12687785923480988,
0.6555265784263611,
-0.3807784616947174,
0.4671729505062103,
-0.39872631430625916,
-0.6390005946159363,
0.13115626573562622,
-0.314956933259964,
0.6768560409545898,
0.38198354840278625,
-0.4931059181690216,
0.2798612713813782,
-1.1575509309768677,
0.04558928683400154,
-0.06286312639713287,
-0.8471028208732605,
-0.06814726442098618,
-0.19311398267745972,
0.423612117767334,
-0.20954596996307373,
0.4236925542354584,
-0.4725148677825928,
0.33918678760528564,
-0.23221251368522644,
0.37499263882637024,
0.8704025745391846,
-0.23934923112392426,
0.38245493173599243,
-0.14296074211597443,
0.4372446835041046,
-0.28738975524902344,
0.12853072583675385,
-0.21772557497024536,
-0.39713147282600403,
-1.2052969932556152,
-0.34761548042297363,
0.1655556559562683,
0.351161926984787,
-0.33843082189559937,
0.5879702568054199,
-0.09340578317642212,
-0.6280361413955688,
-0.5061222314834595,
0.6762081980705261,
0.4502779245376587,
0.2733878493309021,
0.10283759981393814,
-0.3071773946285248,
-0.5705211162567139,
-0.8687052130699158,
-0.3660980463027954,
-0.02066977694630623,
-0.15110507607460022,
-0.1055375412106514,
0.3540678322315216,
-0.6573398113250732,
0.7704026699066162,
-0.27840936183929443,
-0.15969860553741455,
-0.32520902156829834,
-0.024402420967817307,
0.26074323058128357,
0.583293080329895,
0.4987327754497528,
-0.25434139370918274,
-0.31107670068740845,
0.44525039196014404,
-0.7561551332473755,
-0.406643271446228,
-0.0557931512594223,
-0.49795401096343994,
0.3199196755886078,
0.7735339403152466,
-0.5087582468986511,
0.21443960070610046,
0.8929997086524963,
-0.18329457938671112,
0.3958504796028137,
-0.10826785117387772,
-0.09475918114185333,
-1.3124747276306152,
0.14398100972175598,
-0.2044164538383484,
-0.2870871424674988,
-0.688387393951416,
0.23221099376678467,
0.08290688693523407,
-0.012267302721738815,
-0.40370798110961914,
0.46536776423454285,
-0.3470892012119293,
0.04595481976866722,
-0.4258597791194916,
-0.05140897259116173,
0.06606123596429825,
0.6255922913551331,
-0.2532689869403839,
0.8179835677146912,
0.43529120087623596,
-0.7951142191886902,
0.42452266812324524,
-0.0398046113550663,
-0.6299232840538025,
0.35160115361213684,
-0.5969254374504089,
0.11373237520456314,
0.16427414119243622,
0.00532217463478446,
-0.9572185277938843,
-0.4327806532382965,
0.057479411363601685,
0.1292593777179718,
0.023709913715720177,
-0.016624024137854576,
-0.5672502517700195,
-0.1693408191204071,
-0.13754668831825256,
0.08625569939613342,
0.44183433055877686,
-1.0058985948562622,
0.5450372099876404,
0.3140425682067871,
-0.011352057568728924,
-0.40033653378486633,
-0.5589123964309692,
0.2035524547100067,
-0.20994628965854645,
-0.26438993215560913,
0.18126894533634186,
-0.3253212571144104,
-0.05330463871359825,
-0.1963062286376953,
-0.07719473540782928,
0.057722434401512146,
0.6111170053482056,
0.33855655789375305,
-0.043791115283966064,
-0.3289259970188141,
0.24090808629989624,
0.5271444320678711,
-0.29217326641082764,
-0.2902239263057709,
-0.2147487998008728,
0.5479905009269714,
-0.23514370620250702,
-0.313503623008728,
-0.8197762966156006,
0.23047205805778503,
0.6113151907920837,
-0.08209601044654846,
0.4063940644264221,
0.4663178622722626,
-0.3140607178211212,
-0.4806070029735565,
-0.6389678716659546,
0.17108789086341858,
-0.6057215929031372,
0.4980752170085907,
-0.591298520565033,
-1.0346652269363403,
0.3339623212814331,
-0.7588715553283691,
0.3115929067134857,
0.3155735433101654,
0.8501076102256775,
0.08746226876974106,
1.0913368463516235,
0.9854122400283813,
-0.10538847744464874,
0.4786355495452881,
-0.0710822194814682,
-0.012824439443647861,
-0.6232386827468872,
-0.16041260957717896,
-0.6836454272270203,
-0.26800477504730225,
-0.6043757200241089,
-0.10303495824337006,
-0.061124492436647415,
0.40815386176109314,
-0.4885140359401703,
0.4443681836128235,
-0.5116081833839417,
0.7034352421760559,
0.6054693460464478,
-0.11499486118555069,
0.763347864151001,
0.06156671792268753,
0.009490021504461765,
0.30811527371406555,
-0.7688783407211304,
-0.8424660563468933,
1.028938889503479,
0.08904724568128586,
0.9333459138870239,
0.1540641486644745,
0.7696135640144348,
-0.12306466698646545,
0.5395514965057373,
-0.7081326246261597,
0.7025137543678284,
-0.18683768808841705,
-0.520840048789978,
-0.20699091255664825,
-0.36183521151542664,
-0.7871587872505188,
0.18666291236877441,
-0.23837828636169434,
-0.7226228713989258,
0.06913565844297409,
0.2504870891571045,
-0.2932601869106293,
0.31329435110092163,
-0.8576139211654663,
0.9109563827514648,
-0.37506425380706787,
-0.2145887017250061,
-0.27270227670669556,
0.11169392615556717,
0.4117393493652344,
-0.3600693941116333,
0.12366640567779541,
-0.49562618136405945,
-0.31115666031837463,
0.5208467841148376,
-0.34508955478668213,
1.0895752906799316,
0.16340062022209167,
-0.38660570979118347,
0.044201821088790894,
0.07274378836154938,
0.2906028628349304,
0.17295828461647034,
-0.2130318582057953,
0.3194228708744049,
-0.13732491433620453,
-0.31998151540756226,
-0.38188624382019043,
0.9705978035926819,
-0.8693606853485107,
-0.5232526063919067,
0.023394037038087845,
-0.5403971076011658,
-0.13929295539855957,
0.4082963466644287,
0.33164963126182556,
0.15827810764312744,
-0.4952031672000885,
0.11035635322332382,
0.32050180435180664,
-0.2881266176700592,
0.5619442462921143,
0.4068751037120819,
-0.4070952236652374,
-0.18794338405132294,
0.7395110726356506,
-0.2900412976741791,
0.08120658993721008,
0.30692535638809204,
0.01822020299732685,
0.1450076848268509,
-0.5851060748100281,
-0.7948316335678101,
-0.011881092563271523,
-0.5871977806091309,
-0.5510215163230896,
-0.511790931224823,
0.11920236051082611,
-0.1294955313205719,
-0.24752630293369293,
-0.7556829452514648,
-0.42254507541656494,
-0.5707661509513855,
-0.07689649611711502,
0.5576047897338867,
1.0157393217086792,
0.10474072396755219,
0.7431822419166565,
-0.6324253678321838,
0.35231298208236694,
0.5801252126693726,
0.7810583114624023,
0.10516270250082016,
-0.3581118583679199,
-0.3982265293598175,
-0.01353340595960617,
-0.331381618976593,
-0.2713201642036438,
0.062021493911743164,
0.5314911603927612,
0.5604079365730286,
0.5291652679443359,
-0.16372324526309967,
0.9920095801353455,
-0.6193506121635437,
0.6442047953605652,
0.20108141005039215,
-1.178483486175537,
0.5272523164749146,
-0.24304161965847015,
0.5275396704673767,
0.6748776435852051,
0.16362103819847107,
-0.29841145873069763,
-0.4361470341682434,
-0.2392113208770752,
-0.9078840613365173,
0.46273770928382874,
-0.14772765338420868,
0.41065672039985657,
0.10776219516992569,
0.5164637565612793,
0.43756383657455444,
0.14530062675476074,
-0.5302059650421143,
-0.06648436933755875,
0.02347375638782978,
-0.34857839345932007,
-0.15847492218017578,
-0.23966044187545776,
-0.14025937020778656,
-0.37244653701782227,
0.7538749575614929,
-0.38081786036491394,
-0.07910886406898499,
-0.47335100173950195,
-0.2741834223270416,
-0.36936262249946594,
0.1632537990808487,
0.3629060983657837,
0.5828200578689575,
0.09623436629772186,
-0.026213020086288452,
0.5131657123565674,
-0.3709781765937805,
0.19530782103538513,
-0.14897342026233673,
-0.04517519474029541,
-0.05913889780640602,
0.4265962839126587,
0.8197668194770813,
0.39854979515075684,
-0.8475164175033569,
0.10727148503065109,
-0.26549652218818665,
-0.2034665048122406,
-0.04340613633394241,
0.6222640872001648,
0.33724722266197205,
0.38839006423950195,
0.2532614767551422,
-0.13074229657649994,
0.19508406519889832,
-0.3642813265323639,
0.03361897170543671,
0.23730650544166565,
-0.006390116643160582,
-0.1708652675151825,
0.7245556116104126,
0.36146795749664307,
-0.2628432810306549,
0.4584948718547821,
0.009817463345825672,
-0.19825470447540283,
0.363957941532135,
0.5935239195823669,
0.9273771643638611,
-0.16080302000045776,
0.0675656646490097,
0.3398436903953552,
0.13837704062461853,
-0.2641645669937134,
0.13518399000167847,
-0.11827375739812851,
-0.6244580149650574,
-0.711163341999054,
-1.1197031736373901,
-0.5338254570960999,
0.14054900407791138,
-0.4694795310497284,
0.23325645923614502,
-0.4280339777469635,
-0.16476477682590485,
-0.13884882628917694,
-0.20198805630207062,
-0.5895954370498657,
0.03984857350587845,
0.1000683456659317,
0.9373428821563721,
-0.7144344449043274,
0.8882318735122681,
0.790553867816925,
-0.009168734773993492,
-0.7329902052879333,
-0.22777114808559418,
-0.12610742449760437,
-0.7517761588096619,
0.4335283935070038,
0.25759416818618774,
-0.34448036551475525,
0.2974015474319458,
-0.6243681907653809,
-0.7451899647712708,
1.0583528280258179,
0.7232544422149658,
-0.9767009615898132,
0.28398728370666504,
0.3454981744289398,
0.5158373713493347,
-0.3679584860801697,
-0.11885734647512436,
0.7702292203903198,
0.342663049697876,
-0.23311665654182434,
-0.8662241697311401,
-0.0409613698720932,
-0.4270443320274353,
0.4627223014831543,
0.002126600593328476,
-0.638190507888794,
0.5111706256866455,
-0.10862600803375244,
-0.22165879607200623,
0.6238475441932678,
0.521587610244751,
0.2739271819591522,
-0.0557011216878891,
0.3700014054775238,
0.795036792755127,
0.7806597352027893,
-0.18482835590839386,
0.8723552227020264,
-0.36083123087882996,
0.2339729517698288,
0.7959515452384949,
-0.10777553915977478,
0.919456958770752,
0.4802500903606415,
-0.06759587675333023,
0.48736149072647095,
0.5779602527618408,
0.18520522117614746,
0.4104668200016022,
0.290871262550354,
-0.3157907724380493,
-0.5310144424438477,
-0.19230371713638306,
-0.288204550743103,
0.6211991906166077,
0.16048434376716614,
0.10451886802911758,
-0.17448602616786957,
-0.017704278230667114,
0.11190591007471085,
0.10580367594957352,
-0.2779093384742737,
0.9354258179664612,
0.13707804679870605,
-0.4167400896549225,
0.7900084257125854,
0.21511632204055786,
0.897969126701355,
-0.4345485270023346,
0.00486703822389245,
-0.6221266388893127,
0.4697667062282562,
-0.3084954023361206,
-0.30026090145111084,
-0.03420376032590866,
0.370471328496933,
0.05976078659296036,
-0.27413246035575867,
0.5750312209129333,
-0.3203085958957672,
-0.5847194790840149,
0.35099881887435913,
0.5599735379219055,
0.028850652277469635,
0.03867250308394432,
-0.4268854260444641,
0.5395956635475159,
-0.00225406838580966,
-0.5751623511314392,
0.4356520473957062,
0.6598321199417114,
0.15661314129829407,
0.6173169612884521,
0.9908312559127808,
-0.023382335901260376,
0.017102038487792015,
0.17205817997455597,
0.8844533562660217,
-0.5673720836639404,
-0.2980581820011139,
-0.7657949328422546,
0.5992381572723389,
0.0785437673330307,
-0.6226886510848999,
0.7064054608345032,
0.6053853631019592,
1.1305489540100098,
-0.20980846881866455,
0.8904067277908325,
0.22535352408885956,
0.2715734839439392,
-0.4417124390602112,
0.8633180856704712,
-0.8444476127624512,
0.40256160497665405,
-0.28339052200317383,
-1.1242287158966064,
-0.590399980545044,
0.6450561881065369,
0.22373223304748535,
0.015781283378601074,
0.3057156503200531,
1.0317788124084473,
-0.20741640031337738,
-0.03114267997443676,
0.4511653482913971,
0.049666911363601685,
0.2472417652606964,
0.4802403450012207,
0.8008930683135986,
-0.33047839999198914,
0.6704220771789551,
-0.3951905369758606,
-0.30715397000312805,
-0.328463613986969,
-0.981145441532135,
-0.9326612949371338,
-0.4019804298877716,
-0.23066765069961548,
0.11905647814273834,
0.1631096452474594,
0.7400432229042053,
0.7116565108299255,
-0.8447247743606567,
-0.7254613637924194,
-0.3897804021835327,
0.04129420965909958,
-0.17975783348083496,
-0.1105039194226265,
0.019257059320807457,
-0.579800546169281,
-1.0241650342941284,
0.4493781626224518,
0.3301510810852051,
-0.061790671199560165,
-0.1378597766160965,
-0.2310674488544464,
0.08569801598787308,
-0.14664000272750854,
0.6728385090827942,
0.1678653508424759,
-0.4874562919139862,
-0.14768670499324799,
-0.15878425538539886,
-0.2637503445148468,
-0.17637962102890015,
0.6141775846481323,
-0.664891242980957,
0.2090901881456375,
0.2423001527786255,
0.7746074795722961,
0.3918681740760803,
-0.3099096715450287,
0.6786251664161682,
-0.6295179724693298,
0.4128607213497162,
-0.34689584374427795,
0.32252973318099976,
0.3533691167831421,
-0.14686506986618042,
0.47275176644325256,
0.06416686624288559,
-0.49067753553390503,
-0.930168867111206,
0.285905659198761,
-0.7323075532913208,
-0.40544557571411133,
1.0276546478271484,
0.1628037840127945,
-0.30878278613090515,
-0.021897131577134132,
-0.21289876103401184,
0.37233418226242065,
-0.3207169771194458,
0.8137137293815613,
0.3528478741645813,
-0.026638388633728027,
0.020679568871855736,
-0.5353546142578125,
0.32649582624435425,
0.3451903164386749,
-1.0133308172225952,
0.0633072480559349,
0.3374967873096466,
0.3314007818698883,
-0.018467623740434647,
0.48505857586860657,
0.26608896255493164,
0.28084880113601685,
-0.014105158858001232,
0.4962296783924103,
-0.11173644661903381,
-0.34675583243370056,
-0.3143386244773865,
-0.10037276893854141,
0.43175604939460754,
-0.02025029808282852
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.13369v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.13369v1
|
Clinical information extraction for Low-resource languages with Few-shot learning using Pre-trained language models and Prompting
| 2024-03-20T08:01:33 | 2024-03-20T08:01:33 |
Phillip Richter-Pechanski, Philipp Wiesenbach, Dominic M. Schwab, Christina Kiriakou, Nicolas Geis, Christoph Dieterich, Anette Frank
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Automatic extraction of medical information from clinical documents poses
several challenges: high costs of required clinical expertise, limited
interpretability of model predictions, restricted computational resources and
privacy regulations. Recent advances in domain-adaptation and prompting methods
showed promising results with minimal training data using lightweight masked
language models, which are suited for well-established interpretability
methods. We are first to present a systematic evaluation of these methods in a
low-resource setting, by performing multi-class section classification on
German doctor's letters. We conduct extensive class-wise evaluations supported
by Shapley values, to validate the quality of our small training data set and
to ensure the interpretability of model predictions. We demonstrate that a
lightweight, domain-adapted pretrained model, prompted with just 20 shots,
outperforms a traditional classification model by 30.5% accuracy. Our results
serve as a process-oriented guideline for clinical information extraction
projects working with low-resource.
|
[
-0.02870226837694645,
-0.7111109495162964,
0.7079052329063416,
-0.16418075561523438,
-0.34004831314086914,
-0.188174769282341,
-0.3942924737930298,
-0.5437374114990234,
-0.053844746202230453,
0.42023393511772156,
-0.42847099900245667,
-0.4206535220146179,
-0.9828629493713379,
0.17359577119350433,
-0.12997090816497803,
0.9657068252563477,
0.018447428941726685,
0.4785720407962799,
-0.19188816845417023,
-0.1004558801651001,
-0.2934154272079468,
-0.27356722950935364,
-0.4935271441936493,
-0.3028195798397064,
0.4807896018028259,
0.8122749924659729,
0.4678068459033966,
0.7865259051322937,
0.7690661549568176,
0.2033284455537796,
0.33351752161979675,
-0.060549162328243256,
-0.30072709918022156,
-0.14074666798114777,
0.0521821528673172,
-0.4063103199005127,
-0.5420311689376831,
0.13180013000965118,
0.36054426431655884,
0.8695859909057617,
-0.06259430944919586,
0.2584068477153778,
0.15706323087215424,
0.6560719609260559,
-0.838529646396637,
0.2621125876903534,
-0.4437195062637329,
0.11281680315732956,
-0.4025718867778778,
-0.44724786281585693,
-0.6058130860328674,
-0.2926991879940033,
0.4548967480659485,
-0.5399385094642639,
0.41796696186065674,
-0.05867723375558853,
0.7892788648605347,
0.053121037781238556,
-0.05854574218392372,
-0.5737005472183228,
-0.4836677312850952,
0.7437682747840881,
-0.4572458267211914,
0.33669406175613403,
0.7801900506019592,
0.37066319584846497,
0.19281217455863953,
-0.9105328917503357,
-0.29551389813423157,
-0.19744224846363068,
-0.20001935958862305,
0.24227875471115112,
-0.39276909828186035,
0.14541037380695343,
0.3912835717201233,
0.09674271196126938,
-0.5582898855209351,
0.35279175639152527,
-0.722364068031311,
-0.19878362119197845,
0.4794541895389557,
0.09705124795436859,
0.25645583868026733,
-0.2776133120059967,
-0.22801294922828674,
0.01499032974243164,
-0.6669054627418518,
-0.0459938570857048,
0.011782941408455372,
0.44390785694122314,
-0.33578577637672424,
0.3708229660987854,
-0.27107104659080505,
0.6510903239250183,
0.059647802263498306,
-0.3669873774051666,
0.13359703123569489,
-0.12406698614358902,
-0.21540799736976624,
0.11830583214759827,
0.9024651646614075,
0.0058146193623542786,
0.1576637625694275,
-0.058169201016426086,
-0.10290082544088364,
-0.27463075518608093,
0.33515191078186035,
-0.8870536684989929,
-0.6843971014022827,
0.13699090480804443,
-0.9716570973396301,
-0.4542692303657532,
-0.2584964632987976,
-0.9961920380592346,
-0.5515144467353821,
-0.07167156040668488,
0.3647860586643219,
-0.566421389579773,
-0.04193580150604248,
0.05818334221839905,
-0.0005209598457440734,
0.0424853079020977,
0.652621328830719,
-0.9148201942443848,
0.40254783630371094,
0.19124868512153625,
0.8666435480117798,
-0.5149945020675659,
-0.02349565550684929,
-0.7542234063148499,
-0.05369209498167038,
-0.03209665045142174,
1.0262945890426636,
-0.5765069127082825,
-0.44836118817329407,
0.07627052068710327,
0.12705974280834198,
-0.14131268858909607,
-0.6716156601905823,
0.43609505891799927,
-0.29933682084083557,
0.3644014000892639,
-0.09907744824886322,
-0.37128904461860657,
0.11671346426010132,
0.07415580749511719,
-0.783307671546936,
0.6053229570388794,
0.4179694354534149,
-0.5693709254264832,
0.5893234610557556,
-0.6467564105987549,
-0.5075104832649231,
0.5776985287666321,
-0.26647835969924927,
-0.36437368392944336,
0.23198796808719635,
0.2481951117515564,
0.4752449095249176,
-0.5087212324142456,
-0.00967282336205244,
-0.16330327093601227,
-0.08610058575868607,
-0.006850311066955328,
-0.5233584642410278,
0.8263229727745056,
0.43467146158218384,
-0.006389437709003687,
-0.08526358008384705,
-0.8425696492195129,
0.20566463470458984,
0.3453226685523987,
-0.29200243949890137,
-0.27705851197242737,
-0.38589030504226685,
0.08619125932455063,
0.24901920557022095,
0.07948578149080276,
-0.2856236398220062,
0.23362724483013153,
-0.2093791365623474,
0.10997507721185684,
0.4099180996417999,
0.17148424685001373,
0.44559210538864136,
-0.3383863568305969,
1.0186337232589722,
0.10388211905956268,
0.22500528395175934,
-0.10584475100040436,
-0.3589913547039032,
-0.5073314309120178,
-0.6153376698493958,
0.3795563578605652,
0.5556307435035706,
-0.8326173424720764,
0.09695535153150558,
-0.35973459482192993,
-0.48538339138031006,
-0.7764022946357727,
0.25728729367256165,
0.5384482145309448,
0.7315912842750549,
0.4082143008708954,
-0.5683987140655518,
-0.3286709487438202,
-0.621219277381897,
-0.14108115434646606,
-0.1815643608570099,
0.06729558855295181,
0.4063369035720825,
0.44843605160713196,
-0.09736060351133347,
0.6628656387329102,
-0.6263988614082336,
-0.3237139880657196,
-0.47385671734809875,
0.38846567273139954,
0.0747729241847992,
0.4617779552936554,
0.3709152638912201,
-0.4775293171405792,
-0.5997733473777771,
-0.017476139590144157,
-0.8087895512580872,
-0.18800093233585358,
-0.038429852575063705,
0.056625138968229294,
-0.015488269738852978,
0.21952399611473083,
-0.24850307404994965,
0.49156448245048523,
0.3360495865345001,
0.30098071694374084,
0.46887075901031494,
-0.22048991918563843,
0.0067519270814955235,
-0.7720444202423096,
0.2642868161201477,
0.023428253829479218,
-0.3810921907424927,
-0.7634524703025818,
-0.3388848602771759,
0.12524697184562683,
-0.33012038469314575,
-0.7006178498268127,
0.8215636014938354,
-0.5707396268844604,
0.22188283503055573,
-0.4253115653991699,
-0.025654347613453865,
0.12810379266738892,
0.1728857457637787,
0.4218692183494568,
0.5693122744560242,
0.5792004466056824,
-0.5609886646270752,
0.22757986187934875,
0.36687254905700684,
-0.3771379888057709,
0.5242791175842285,
-0.34241199493408203,
0.24004648625850677,
-0.20499254763126373,
-0.14411084353923798,
-0.4238084554672241,
-0.4534826874732971,
0.2965390384197235,
-0.1943654716014862,
0.48225846886634827,
-0.5465835928916931,
-0.3573859632015228,
-0.1589980572462082,
-0.06895428895950317,
0.30975961685180664,
0.5602935552597046,
-0.3001098036766052,
0.10116501897573471,
0.515392005443573,
-0.5796360969543457,
-0.4939385652542114,
-0.38083645701408386,
-0.20168374478816986,
0.0029674500692635775,
-0.10378535091876984,
-0.016382265836000443,
0.19679833948612213,
-0.1443643569946289,
0.0695178210735321,
-0.03521261736750603,
-0.6521415114402771,
0.16247422993183136,
0.21979404985904694,
0.49184828996658325,
-0.3460852801799774,
0.09574726223945618,
0.06921619176864624,
-0.20105616748332977,
-0.09400174021720886,
-0.09179418534040451,
0.39692604541778564,
-0.0740523487329483,
-0.48766207695007324,
-0.651022732257843,
0.35586586594581604,
0.11443277448415756,
0.039717432111501694,
0.5183382034301758,
0.5825818777084351,
-0.6286872029304504,
-0.06551523506641388,
-0.45382484793663025,
-0.45177796483039856,
-0.4089321792125702,
0.36784622073173523,
-0.16321247816085815,
-0.58318030834198,
0.1264365315437317,
-0.3398759961128235,
-0.2974604070186615,
0.5237067937850952,
0.5369089245796204,
-0.3509882092475891,
0.8648281693458557,
0.7839081883430481,
0.10216589272022247,
0.46744394302368164,
-0.026287756860256195,
-0.25566527247428894,
-0.2662164270877838,
-0.11505737900733948,
-0.6091792583465576,
0.07099949568510056,
-0.39609295129776,
-0.038019221276044846,
0.6046192646026611,
0.19456003606319427,
0.45254379510879517,
0.019798854365944862,
-0.46422627568244934,
0.4893784821033478,
0.3628617525100708,
0.29773929715156555,
0.31748753786087036,
0.1368882656097412,
0.22459807991981506,
-0.12624956667423248,
-0.9195734858512878,
-0.5489785075187683,
1.1069092750549316,
0.1629265993833542,
0.8465090990066528,
-0.1559518277645111,
0.8536657094955444,
0.33428099751472473,
0.508120596408844,
-1.0590908527374268,
0.13247761130332947,
-0.35040003061294556,
-0.5676720142364502,
-0.23817934095859528,
-0.28504887223243713,
-1.1086496114730835,
0.027800628915429115,
-0.6027929186820984,
-0.700516939163208,
0.2662208676338196,
0.053731970489025116,
-0.8336074948310852,
-0.09785302728414536,
-0.8525110483169556,
0.9850103259086609,
-0.32331424951553345,
-0.1926126629114151,
0.01868303306400776,
-0.8134313821792603,
0.3123258054256439,
-0.31959226727485657,
0.2367098033428192,
-0.14644543826580048,
0.17117835581302643,
0.767748236656189,
-0.41675230860710144,
0.8848739266395569,
-0.30311480164527893,
0.35371437668800354,
0.14293107390403748,
0.03217220678925514,
0.41890260577201843,
-0.23778189718723297,
0.017553092911839485,
0.19469937682151794,
0.5674675703048706,
-0.5927265286445618,
-0.48047545552253723,
0.13921700417995453,
-0.6100701689720154,
-0.3078070878982544,
-0.5894387364387512,
-0.3383735716342926,
-0.42415618896484375,
0.48253583908081055,
0.6328191161155701,
0.4973980486392975,
-0.3337629735469818,
-0.05378257483243942,
0.5038371086120605,
-0.30923643708229065,
0.2886253595352173,
0.5964615345001221,
0.26615795493125916,
-0.23286932706832886,
0.8333609104156494,
0.05739886686205864,
0.33804333209991455,
0.12261512130498886,
0.407920241355896,
-0.11992108076810837,
-0.9421390891075134,
-0.5424721837043762,
0.1684332638978958,
-0.9221410751342773,
-0.10643356293439865,
-0.5198631286621094,
-0.28609007596969604,
-0.48741376399993896,
-0.09707697480916977,
-0.2404579073190689,
-0.404125839471817,
-0.4560372531414032,
0.23178528249263763,
0.08342074602842331,
0.7000108361244202,
0.10233244299888611,
0.626913845539093,
-1.3581899404525757,
0.2472037672996521,
0.08319894224405289,
0.12762250006198883,
-0.33871710300445557,
-0.5883603692054749,
-0.5604901313781738,
-0.536392331123352,
-0.11805982142686844,
-0.9856018424034119,
0.5025019645690918,
0.3426497280597687,
0.5701085925102234,
0.6533419489860535,
0.17750918865203857,
0.8589100241661072,
-0.5470550060272217,
0.5066754221916199,
0.3555600941181183,
-0.6817222237586975,
0.7524535059928894,
-0.018106648698449135,
0.11395693570375443,
1.1117745637893677,
0.5801674127578735,
-0.3603987395763397,
0.034319303929805756,
-0.7474240660667419,
-0.32564830780029297,
1.0337939262390137,
-0.30536720156669617,
-0.1485545039176941,
0.12731727957725525,
0.4389589726924896,
0.5675274729728699,
0.09736176580190659,
-0.49380427598953247,
-0.0854206457734108,
0.1466134786605835,
-0.5245201587677002,
0.13262422382831573,
-0.2936941981315613,
-0.2963801622390747,
-0.00778775941580534,
0.48099690675735474,
-0.3723086416721344,
0.1703023761510849,
0.1368875801563263,
-0.6847320795059204,
-0.1571439653635025,
0.399836003780365,
0.5140576958656311,
0.7886933088302612,
-0.1518094837665558,
0.28062132000923157,
0.2720702886581421,
-0.8571474552154541,
0.010787014849483967,
0.20424799621105194,
0.011250359006226063,
0.10743987560272217,
0.8094087839126587,
0.6149299740791321,
0.05319712311029434,
-0.7101451754570007,
0.9722340106964111,
-0.17675122618675232,
-0.08645285665988922,
-0.08906316757202148,
0.01896495185792446,
-0.6071817278862,
0.031206386163830757,
0.05277760699391365,
0.05808524042367935,
0.21611982583999634,
-0.26248499751091003,
0.25041788816452026,
0.3915691077709198,
-0.5884121060371399,
-0.4460689425468445,
0.4344347417354584,
0.025419292971491814,
-0.005828241351991892,
0.5437849164009094,
-0.14282453060150146,
0.0024014213122427464,
0.1265973448753357,
0.4315761625766754,
0.7118352055549622,
-0.08456697314977646,
0.3464435636997223,
0.254070907831192,
0.15375562012195587,
-0.2667783796787262,
0.3807401955127716,
-0.2117859572172165,
-0.5616799592971802,
-0.3155263662338257,
-0.3693164885044098,
-0.5464721918106079,
0.19279173016548157,
-0.9844799637794495,
0.48868492245674133,
-0.604762852191925,
-0.11618269979953766,
0.23727336525917053,
0.07575586438179016,
-0.8815646171569824,
0.2625679671764374,
0.1553121954202652,
0.8431280255317688,
-0.9189679026603699,
1.2036298513412476,
0.6206058263778687,
-0.5708322525024414,
-0.50370854139328,
-0.0730745792388916,
0.25726819038391113,
-1.1968262195587158,
0.7790122628211975,
0.03380488604307175,
-0.011988883838057518,
-0.1781489998102188,
-0.675517737865448,
-0.42964184284210205,
0.8211020827293396,
0.4196051061153412,
-0.3924237787723541,
-0.15022395551204681,
0.08623704314231873,
0.4580070674419403,
-0.22440911829471588,
0.24233894050121307,
0.5332458019256592,
0.1782265454530716,
0.0442451573908329,
-0.9296666383743286,
0.07969773560762405,
-0.21756833791732788,
-0.5821459293365479,
-0.19183151423931122,
-0.0650784969329834,
0.5186028480529785,
-0.2909890413284302,
-0.3552306294441223,
-0.1473526507616043,
0.2103901356458664,
0.10654351860284805,
0.40226757526397705,
0.4431656301021576,
0.01806294545531273,
1.1896681785583496,
0.04682525619864464,
1.0850603580474854,
-0.32329776883125305,
0.12517382204532623,
0.9748400449752808,
-0.40047183632850647,
0.6716110706329346,
0.3224826157093048,
-0.21866030991077423,
0.35566896200180054,
0.5640510320663452,
0.05746699497103691,
0.6292251944541931,
-0.2736020088195801,
-0.3176089823246002,
-0.2407933473587036,
-0.3268129229545593,
-0.2435554414987564,
0.5258656144142151,
0.3038536310195923,
-0.4853237271308899,
-0.044547341763973236,
0.12415934354066849,
0.04302211478352547,
-0.47939565777778625,
-0.21089722216129303,
1.162449836730957,
0.27261778712272644,
-0.5172326564788818,
0.6022458076477051,
-0.14009487628936768,
0.20365040004253387,
-0.6363142132759094,
-0.03535904362797737,
0.11349337548017502,
0.012883047573268414,
-0.36386221647262573,
-0.3186842203140259,
-0.012445648200809956,
0.26586678624153137,
-0.17172199487686157,
-0.3043667674064636,
0.997614324092865,
-0.3331106901168823,
-0.40266770124435425,
-0.1355302780866623,
0.9537532329559326,
0.5008534789085388,
0.06630853563547134,
-0.7264176607131958,
-0.22300708293914795,
-0.21296878159046173,
0.03656643256545067,
0.6098770499229431,
0.5110486745834351,
-0.03387143462896347,
0.27496665716171265,
0.7130849957466125,
0.6423662304878235,
-0.07389029860496521,
0.11666512489318848,
0.7294027209281921,
-0.6478469371795654,
-0.33850032091140747,
-0.8851767778396606,
0.20993366837501526,
-0.061027709394693375,
-0.20046302676200867,
0.3603690564632416,
0.5043885111808777,
0.36885854601860046,
-0.16905106604099274,
0.9594993591308594,
0.18496263027191162,
0.4131525158882141,
-0.7602092027664185,
0.9049152731895447,
-0.38947194814682007,
-0.026623325422406197,
-0.19669802486896515,
-0.3333861529827118,
-0.3708808124065399,
0.4926663935184479,
-0.2818322777748108,
-0.1971885859966278,
1.0033726692199707,
0.48308107256889343,
-0.11765100061893463,
0.10731757432222366,
0.41252532601356506,
-0.0620904266834259,
0.06296346336603165,
0.4522841274738312,
0.634964108467102,
-0.19727832078933716,
0.527416467666626,
-0.41940003633499146,
-0.43397799134254456,
-0.29578936100006104,
-0.8282710909843445,
-0.782985508441925,
-0.3420310616493225,
-0.4637908637523651,
-0.4773646295070648,
-0.1581692099571228,
1.192366600036621,
1.1115012168884277,
-0.9721094965934753,
0.13277456164360046,
0.4210672378540039,
-0.024201462045311928,
-0.14639271795749664,
-0.1510724127292633,
0.6972987055778503,
-0.43931716680526733,
-0.5781556367874146,
0.5797082185745239,
0.28389880061149597,
0.20995737612247467,
0.09758441895246506,
0.023976044729351997,
0.20384809374809265,
-0.36924073100090027,
0.41898778080940247,
0.5846335887908936,
-0.3935445249080658,
-0.017125563696026802,
-0.08721659332513809,
-0.455226331949234,
0.419219970703125,
0.7951428294181824,
-0.6228106617927551,
0.7409852147102356,
0.3419850766658783,
0.7391801476478577,
0.5649594664573669,
0.033096253871917725,
0.19039031863212585,
-0.8026641011238098,
0.38673335313796997,
0.4092864394187927,
0.25794559717178345,
0.10121896117925644,
-0.24612994492053986,
0.3034667670726776,
0.37033429741859436,
-0.17826400697231293,
-0.8677429556846619,
0.13374082744121552,
-0.8806130290031433,
-0.07826737314462662,
1.031438946723938,
-0.28826040029525757,
-0.3220374882221222,
-0.40037259459495544,
-0.14122149348258972,
0.2114357203245163,
-0.2601567208766937,
0.7082757949829102,
0.7291750311851501,
-0.5060718655586243,
-0.4377870261669159,
-0.8513971567153931,
0.8270036578178406,
0.15279841423034668,
-1.1999942064285278,
-0.07189233601093292,
0.46427229046821594,
0.28238219022750854,
0.006492967251688242,
1.1529817581176758,
-0.38525912165641785,
0.42698124051094055,
-0.09284047037363052,
0.09319208562374115,
0.051130205392837524,
-0.23694391548633575,
-0.7950335741043091,
0.2646946310997009,
0.30939072370529175,
-0.14443156123161316
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.13368v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.13368v1
|
Computational Models to Study Language Processing in the Human Brain: A Survey
| 2024-03-20T08:01:22 | 2024-03-20T08:01:22 |
Shaonan Wang, Jingyuan Sun, Yunhao Zhang, Nan Lin, Marie-Francine Moens, Chengqing Zong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Despite differing from the human language processing mechanism in
implementation and algorithms, current language models demonstrate remarkable
human-like or surpassing language capabilities. Should computational language
models be employed in studying the brain, and if so, when and how? To delve
into this topic, this paper reviews efforts in using computational models for
brain research, highlighting emerging trends. To ensure a fair comparison, the
paper evaluates various computational models using consistent metrics on the
same dataset. Our analysis reveals that no single model outperforms others on
all datasets, underscoring the need for rich testing datasets and rigid
experimental control to draw robust conclusions in studies involving
computational models.
|
[
-0.23238889873027802,
-0.9248731136322021,
0.5819092988967896,
0.27208054065704346,
0.1799987405538559,
-0.10857610404491425,
-0.47622451186180115,
-0.8461447954177856,
-0.002961378078907728,
0.5168873071670532,
-0.4026833474636078,
-0.1376064419746399,
-0.5802950859069824,
0.11788307130336761,
-0.6333101987838745,
0.5404781103134155,
0.3035343885421753,
0.5452896952629089,
-0.3726053535938263,
0.06746535003185272,
-0.4291255474090576,
-0.7258843779563904,
-0.7452942132949829,
-0.6422183513641357,
0.4476827383041382,
0.0017078111413866282,
0.7355104684829712,
0.5207738876342773,
0.550830602645874,
0.29437804222106934,
-0.324109822511673,
-0.3178190588951111,
-0.10295549035072327,
-0.01981223002076149,
-0.10856683552265167,
-0.6172919273376465,
-0.45711907744407654,
0.12954343855381012,
0.5210692882537842,
1.449276089668274,
-0.17288196086883545,
-0.12607093155384064,
-0.09507734328508377,
0.4456539750099182,
-0.5166575312614441,
0.11536750197410583,
-0.4768705368041992,
-0.12026335299015045,
-0.37595587968826294,
0.22305989265441895,
-0.3265839219093323,
-0.43991267681121826,
0.2740342617034912,
-0.24928432703018188,
0.34485962986946106,
0.05834401398897171,
0.37225043773651123,
-0.10708118230104446,
-0.37618595361709595,
-0.11732930690050125,
-0.6961245536804199,
0.7797597646713257,
-0.7402485609054565,
0.7170960903167725,
0.8310228586196899,
0.17542307078838348,
-0.014399254694581032,
-0.7408437728881836,
-0.5204721689224243,
-0.6874250769615173,
0.014644507318735123,
-0.37012770771980286,
-0.29357200860977173,
0.11237931996583939,
0.23193781077861786,
0.14765506982803345,
-0.6798842549324036,
0.2577085793018341,
-0.627249538898468,
-0.32201817631721497,
0.4648740589618683,
0.4651370048522949,
0.6928030252456665,
-0.029928652569651604,
0.12433309108018875,
-0.12290676683187485,
-0.6282272338867188,
0.11002269387245178,
0.41600990295410156,
0.33741042017936707,
0.12090271711349487,
0.5926945209503174,
-0.2052072435617447,
1.0022268295288086,
-0.41330593824386597,
0.2713243067264557,
-0.04922684654593468,
-0.19209998846054077,
-0.14261145889759064,
-0.21745958924293518,
0.6173709630966187,
0.3430978059768677,
0.41523799300193787,
-0.4377124309539795,
-0.24940644204616547,
0.41546598076820374,
0.49276241660118103,
-0.5822712182998657,
-0.43510252237319946,
0.08560482412576675,
-0.49164167046546936,
-0.19949370622634888,
-0.2551557123661041,
-0.6653559803962708,
-0.47867628931999207,
-0.3588939309120178,
-0.18634796142578125,
-0.39180341362953186,
-0.40740668773651123,
0.17574389278888702,
-0.1427035927772522,
0.0836251899600029,
0.019374197348952293,
-1.0230913162231445,
0.8405000567436218,
0.524691104888916,
0.7577887773513794,
-0.46970516443252563,
-0.5335153341293335,
0.1528303474187851,
-0.34814611077308655,
-0.5108752846717834,
1.1052998304367065,
-0.6301066875457764,
-0.3706478774547577,
-0.02315596491098404,
-0.1388334035873413,
-0.07959689199924469,
-0.5926613211631775,
0.5119252800941467,
-0.666664183139801,
0.0949467346072197,
-0.5169821381568909,
-0.4458305835723877,
-0.292954683303833,
0.055680159479379654,
-0.7178786396980286,
0.541339635848999,
0.15360498428344727,
-0.9500805139541626,
0.0831044465303421,
-0.6289770007133484,
-0.417446494102478,
0.08147412538528442,
-0.2852602005004883,
-0.22552219033241272,
0.4221998453140259,
-0.03952277451753616,
0.16183708608150482,
-0.5590438842773438,
0.360642671585083,
-0.5577813386917114,
-0.5321260690689087,
0.679345428943634,
-0.40615975856781006,
1.191258192062378,
0.33330726623535156,
-0.014622832648456097,
-0.1470262110233307,
-0.39638036489486694,
0.2412968873977661,
0.1777287870645523,
-0.22455371916294098,
-0.31436997652053833,
0.37782028317451477,
0.6399686932563782,
0.06558219343423843,
0.06428197026252747,
-0.7684929370880127,
0.2448851615190506,
-0.5212690830230713,
0.6430533528327942,
0.2349299043416977,
-0.21324636042118073,
0.4843752086162567,
-0.3947214186191559,
0.5635141730308533,
-0.27791205048561096,
-0.1555594950914383,
0.05521513894200325,
-0.4895634353160858,
-0.380866140127182,
-0.03489072993397713,
0.6341464519500732,
0.5172097682952881,
-0.14299379289150238,
0.01403297483921051,
0.02388867922127247,
-0.25018465518951416,
-0.5372493863105774,
-0.4130154848098755,
0.27742284536361694,
0.3987205922603607,
0.28351110219955444,
-0.5246818661689758,
-0.7373558282852173,
-1.0693694353103638,
-0.44262009859085083,
-0.30267709493637085,
-0.13185350596904755,
0.3026612102985382,
0.3743959367275238,
-0.13088159263134003,
1.0326004028320312,
-0.6497769951820374,
0.17695702612400055,
-0.23805592954158783,
0.3649185597896576,
-0.23278376460075378,
0.39072662591934204,
0.6539487838745117,
-0.7802740931510925,
-0.1356843262910843,
0.06374090909957886,
-0.8157217502593994,
-0.20366445183753967,
0.3082581162452698,
0.37105390429496765,
0.15780162811279297,
0.498776376247406,
-0.49326181411743164,
0.5411255955696106,
0.502487301826477,
-0.33528757095336914,
0.5882384777069092,
-0.17960712313652039,
0.40498489141464233,
-0.45753124356269836,
0.2920651435852051,
-0.08293063938617706,
-0.03746236115694046,
-0.9661685824394226,
0.03378923609852791,
0.08521057665348053,
-0.10827895253896713,
-0.2575903534889221,
0.48239433765411377,
-0.43874964118003845,
-0.2008691281080246,
-0.8547379374504089,
-0.28250929713249207,
-0.38542431592941284,
0.3817315101623535,
0.17053745687007904,
0.5058675408363342,
0.7655417919158936,
-0.4529997408390045,
0.05544215813279152,
0.036207254976034164,
-0.5660734176635742,
0.15678554773330688,
-0.9260238409042358,
0.2718517780303955,
-0.39016610383987427,
0.03825792670249939,
-1.1847624778747559,
-0.25127577781677246,
0.12502484023571014,
-0.6000251770019531,
0.11695273220539093,
0.11642909049987793,
-0.3586699366569519,
-0.3309398591518402,
0.025350496172904968,
0.41032472252845764,
0.5797019004821777,
0.07732541114091873,
0.3622890114784241,
0.8089746832847595,
-0.2370515614748001,
-0.2883557081222534,
-0.9512147903442383,
0.13596850633621216,
-0.08268707245588303,
-0.5068328380584717,
0.5302734971046448,
-0.32413601875305176,
-0.47709226608276367,
-0.18207837641239166,
0.16126109659671783,
-0.5442878603935242,
0.20314475893974304,
0.22859704494476318,
0.17012640833854675,
-0.0376976914703846,
-0.12331382930278778,
-0.16754759848117828,
0.13950277864933014,
0.32870396971702576,
0.06152266263961792,
0.5614189505577087,
-0.01561686024069786,
-0.1109275296330452,
-0.47176334261894226,
0.6131775379180908,
0.5847222805023193,
-0.23899345099925995,
0.5619738101959229,
0.05327541381120682,
-0.7856160402297974,
0.20564210414886475,
-0.45868054032325745,
-0.52604740858078,
-0.3627317249774933,
0.6179655194282532,
-0.3726778030395508,
-0.9412831664085388,
0.560373067855835,
-0.06460801512002945,
-0.15808555483818054,
0.12097720801830292,
0.6169283390045166,
-0.2567046880722046,
1.3318804502487183,
0.7775565981864929,
-0.14518433809280396,
0.4119194447994232,
0.05145859718322754,
0.18641690909862518,
-0.6833087801933289,
0.050696294754743576,
-0.9551628232002258,
-0.049194950610399246,
-0.5680004358291626,
0.0312048252671957,
0.1420263946056366,
-0.024356495589017868,
0.06662473827600479,
0.11387963593006134,
-0.39556148648262024,
0.5954505205154419,
-0.008910204283893108,
-0.058925237506628036,
0.09165098518133163,
0.0395490936934948,
-0.25854113698005676,
-0.1196734756231308,
-0.6687944531440735,
-0.49081721901893616,
0.9452153444290161,
0.1634337157011032,
0.5692822933197021,
-0.4168716371059418,
-0.06303421407938004,
0.35322126746177673,
0.4883297383785248,
-0.45718005299568176,
0.5706059336662292,
-0.07124761492013931,
-1.0108921527862549,
-0.26034805178642273,
-0.24488581717014313,
-1.3135745525360107,
0.3520537316799164,
-0.11723653972148895,
-0.9467726349830627,
0.1386784315109253,
0.13882750272750854,
-0.23119622468948364,
0.1619885116815567,
-0.6748115420341492,
0.7673558592796326,
-0.0618259496986866,
-0.11562616378068924,
-0.32100000977516174,
-0.5700923204421997,
0.5023038983345032,
-0.04394187778234482,
0.305402547121048,
0.09493279457092285,
0.12273180484771729,
0.6902688145637512,
0.11848558485507965,
0.7598217725753784,
0.03465554118156433,
0.21545474231243134,
0.35930678248405457,
0.17342069745063782,
-0.07125528156757355,
-0.29622262716293335,
-0.21205481886863708,
0.5279068946838379,
0.12434913218021393,
-0.4322049915790558,
-0.43955349922180176,
0.6705257296562195,
-0.8003785014152527,
-0.37182700634002686,
-0.598114550113678,
-0.7369828224182129,
-0.1346251666545868,
0.10060130804777145,
0.3488680124282837,
0.24452929198741913,
-0.5156146287918091,
0.012244278565049171,
0.3419812321662903,
-0.011834804899990559,
0.47228071093559265,
0.3807101547718048,
-0.3029422461986542,
-0.3045947849750519,
0.6940587759017944,
0.2618863582611084,
0.08505215495824814,
0.044601377099752426,
0.09100820869207382,
-0.17722088098526,
-0.8305475115776062,
-0.2711486518383026,
0.23297259211540222,
-0.36345645785331726,
0.2391362488269806,
-0.6351225972175598,
-0.1083441898226738,
-0.4583469331264496,
0.028086908161640167,
-0.44881972670555115,
-0.31004199385643005,
0.07141254842281342,
0.2856915295124054,
0.0489322654902935,
0.9047037363052368,
0.1426660418510437,
0.3912908136844635,
-0.465983510017395,
0.29437753558158875,
0.22236141562461853,
0.4852456748485565,
0.2892145812511444,
-0.21422703564167023,
-0.303931325674057,
0.39562132954597473,
-0.2542828619480133,
-1.083682894706726,
0.5830400586128235,
-0.07478297501802444,
0.7085838317871094,
-0.07090498507022858,
-0.5751484632492065,
0.38434603810310364,
-0.5296919345855713,
0.8049594163894653,
0.006950720213353634,
-0.7620338201522827,
0.3150784373283386,
-0.44258537888526917,
0.3999052345752716,
0.49877986311912537,
0.587583065032959,
-0.7225972414016724,
-0.07878615707159042,
-0.4530338943004608,
-0.48146194219589233,
0.6198312640190125,
0.3137868642807007,
-0.1817644089460373,
-0.021093418821692467,
0.525628387928009,
0.05659710243344307,
-0.029239444062113762,
-0.43854835629463196,
-0.16943182051181793,
0.2735033631324768,
0.06922715902328491,
-0.0856551006436348,
0.10030078887939453,
0.19956834614276886,
-0.35379987955093384,
0.15286286175251007,
-0.06374415755271912,
0.4080491364002228,
-0.053708236664533615,
-0.03336748480796814,
-0.17950887978076935,
0.11938758194446564,
0.4325256943702698,
0.7599164247512817,
-0.1692138910293579,
0.08349445462226868,
0.3417879045009613,
-0.7225700616836548,
0.005468768998980522,
-0.04974847286939621,
-0.14813444018363953,
-0.4098203778266907,
0.13428692519664764,
0.40563324093818665,
0.01790286786854267,
-0.884910523891449,
0.302172988653183,
-0.5656356811523438,
-0.21289917826652527,
-0.09024591743946075,
0.04783004894852638,
0.44822072982788086,
0.024653317406773567,
0.021746376529335976,
0.46332430839538574,
0.41891005635261536,
-0.46667593717575073,
-0.01346937008202076,
0.5478378534317017,
-0.28377246856689453,
-0.6127287745475769,
0.5833788514137268,
-0.285258024930954,
-0.7046602368354797,
1.2263920307159424,
0.22212332487106323,
-0.36966443061828613,
0.6523304581642151,
0.6674551367759705,
0.8912000060081482,
-0.24473950266838074,
-0.2593677043914795,
0.038135919719934464,
0.26552167534828186,
-0.3651511073112488,
0.511411726474762,
0.05422374606132507,
-0.7498005628585815,
-0.5847331285476685,
-0.5197275876998901,
-0.44240742921829224,
0.1250239908695221,
-0.45850613713264465,
0.11761034280061722,
-0.10950961709022522,
-0.45403552055358887,
0.44281524419784546,
-0.174911767244339,
-0.5194547772407532,
0.37612611055374146,
0.4734414219856262,
0.667971670627594,
-0.8988815546035767,
1.1568951606750488,
0.9545367956161499,
-0.3355250060558319,
-0.1785522699356079,
-0.2454790472984314,
-0.21882669627666473,
-0.1998673677444458,
0.3759993612766266,
-0.07776712626218796,
-0.2297508716583252,
-0.1570930778980255,
-0.9435092210769653,
-0.7963695526123047,
0.5405995845794678,
0.5307174921035767,
-0.24418099224567413,
-0.17150604724884033,
0.17911651730537415,
0.8317142724990845,
-0.4652649462223053,
0.4732315242290497,
0.8131890296936035,
0.28023284673690796,
-0.22478364408016205,
-0.868807315826416,
-0.4072973430156708,
-0.5275158286094666,
0.21342073380947113,
0.11858683079481125,
-0.38990578055381775,
1.0722092390060425,
-0.15818177163600922,
-0.09239264577627182,
0.1246054619550705,
0.7692286968231201,
0.5938639640808105,
0.2245997190475464,
0.43889766931533813,
0.4014989137649536,
0.6765047907829285,
0.12497606128454208,
1.2381876707077026,
-0.2825765609741211,
0.236753910779953,
0.8876285552978516,
-0.3325304687023163,
0.6976956129074097,
0.44836610555648804,
-0.37655824422836304,
0.2722868323326111,
0.5313141345977783,
0.29187509417533875,
0.32526177167892456,
0.5283074378967285,
0.06946311891078949,
-0.2635248005390167,
-0.06625352054834366,
0.081271693110466,
0.586053192615509,
0.4323044419288635,
-0.10634807497262955,
-0.03448585048317909,
0.10549134016036987,
-0.04263104125857353,
0.31577959656715393,
-0.14230631291866302,
0.3048458397388458,
0.08717838674783707,
-0.8648446202278137,
0.5159593820571899,
0.3370611071586609,
0.7118911147117615,
-0.5102552175521851,
-0.10422269254922867,
-0.06453101336956024,
0.056209199130535126,
0.10160258412361145,
-0.6056955456733704,
0.6475105285644531,
0.12972307205200195,
-0.2489759474992752,
-0.2941955626010895,
0.971866250038147,
-0.17285174131393433,
-0.2864975929260254,
0.26903682947158813,
0.536624550819397,
0.435003399848938,
-0.20645999908447266,
-0.5375190377235413,
0.28137755393981934,
-0.15196938812732697,
-0.28674396872520447,
0.5584593415260315,
-0.2009287327528,
-0.42026954889297485,
0.7060352563858032,
0.650208055973053,
0.3278610110282898,
0.2264554351568222,
0.041101276874542236,
0.7198021411895752,
-1.0267369747161865,
-0.4303409159183502,
-0.9065872430801392,
0.28309980034828186,
0.020082803443074226,
-0.3926190435886383,
0.534096896648407,
0.5581737160682678,
0.7986944317817688,
-0.1035582423210144,
0.8030992150306702,
-0.12407432496547699,
0.5661550164222717,
-0.061044611036777496,
0.9009660482406616,
-0.3210453689098358,
-0.13251030445098877,
-0.031376056373119354,
-0.6400981545448303,
-0.5582465529441833,
0.6861200928688049,
-0.22520579397678375,
0.2711816132068634,
0.8232855796813965,
0.7894309163093567,
0.025955641642212868,
0.5716676712036133,
0.3727889060974121,
0.19091351330280304,
0.1549653261899948,
0.49389341473579407,
1.0280483961105347,
-0.3409751355648041,
-0.10935758799314499,
-0.12297859787940979,
-0.08427032083272934,
0.11365088820457458,
-0.737702488899231,
-0.6976533532142639,
-0.7547029852867126,
-0.24614672362804413,
-0.06823615729808807,
0.1515645533800125,
0.7383856773376465,
0.7795720100402832,
-0.7899812459945679,
-0.8148823976516724,
-0.2740668058395386,
-0.10379539430141449,
-0.5743353366851807,
-0.12287922203540802,
0.16946114599704742,
-0.2128535658121109,
-0.8164687156677246,
0.44035130739212036,
0.10217752307653427,
0.056946754455566406,
-0.4973417818546295,
0.16446438431739807,
-0.31914857029914856,
0.25986248254776,
0.3476947546005249,
0.28422293066978455,
-0.6929925084114075,
0.034221500158309937,
0.43163421750068665,
-0.4690457582473755,
-0.016079511493444443,
1.2055679559707642,
-0.9302248358726501,
0.22685034573078156,
0.8943191766738892,
0.6153067350387573,
0.5125023722648621,
-0.3668017089366913,
0.5870850086212158,
-0.22934046387672424,
-0.10016056150197983,
0.472395122051239,
0.3536888659000397,
0.523593008518219,
-0.20113156735897064,
0.30824190378189087,
0.1257578730583191,
-0.8372507691383362,
-0.9083877801895142,
0.09419433027505875,
-0.9335940480232239,
-0.5879972577095032,
0.7179017663002014,
0.22565396130084991,
-0.5297609567642212,
-0.22782982885837555,
-0.2785796523094177,
0.2128104418516159,
-0.03405243903398514,
0.9314533472061157,
1.0477042198181152,
-0.6257728934288025,
-0.06987138837575912,
-0.7798234224319458,
0.3513711392879486,
0.4216064512729645,
-0.6427802443504333,
0.2848707437515259,
0.4182000756263733,
0.3004736006259918,
-0.05134515464305878,
0.7854410409927368,
-0.1878654807806015,
0.30077239871025085,
-0.019444972276687622,
0.3119436502456665,
0.22074252367019653,
-0.4307073950767517,
-0.64850252866745,
0.37978872656822205,
0.10280738770961761,
0.267680287361145
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.13362v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.13362v3
|
Incentivizing News Consumption on Social Media Platforms Using Large Language Models and Realistic Bot Accounts
| 2024-03-20T07:44:06 | 2024-03-30T03:10:48 |
Hadi Askari, Anshuman Chhabra, Bernhard Clemm von Hohenberg, Michael Heseltine, Magdalena Wojcieszak
|
cs.SI
|
cs.SI, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Polarization, declining trust, and wavering support for democratic norms are
pressing threats to U.S. democracy. Exposure to verified and quality news may
lower individual susceptibility to these threats and make citizens more
resilient to misinformation, populism, and hyperpartisan rhetoric. This project
examines how to enhance users' exposure to and engagement with verified and
ideologically balanced news in an ecologically valid setting. We rely on a
large-scale two-week long field experiment (from 1/19/2023 to 2/3/2023) on
28,457 Twitter users. We created 28 bots utilizing GPT-2 that replied to users
tweeting about sports, entertainment, or lifestyle with a contextual reply
containing two hardcoded elements: a URL to the topic-relevant section of
quality news organization and an encouragement to follow its Twitter account.
To further test differential effects by gender of the bots, treated users were
randomly assigned to receive responses by bots presented as female or male. We
examine whether our over-time intervention enhances the following of news media
organization, the sharing and the liking of news content and the tweeting about
politics and the liking of political content. We find that the treated users
followed more news accounts and the users in the female bot treatment were more
likely to like news content than the control. Most of these results, however,
were small in magnitude and confined to the already politically interested
Twitter users, as indicated by their pre-treatment tweeting about politics.
These findings have implications for social media and news organizations, and
also offer direction for future work on how Large Language Models and other
computational interventions can effectively enhance individual on-platform
engagement with quality news and public affairs.
|
[
-0.09397689998149872,
-0.7401491403579712,
0.5638571381568909,
0.4898636043071747,
-0.39939701557159424,
0.40173354744911194,
-0.1932542324066162,
-0.24349045753479004,
0.4093880355358124,
0.4277609586715698,
-0.38700801134109497,
-0.3507680296897888,
-0.6444519758224487,
-0.0771341323852539,
-0.42628729343414307,
1.0782647132873535,
0.16522738337516785,
0.005777436774224043,
0.2316557914018631,
-0.1380176991224289,
-0.33027663826942444,
-0.6856492757797241,
-0.5201188325881958,
-0.04417099803686142,
0.9239856004714966,
0.10915279388427734,
0.7586984634399414,
0.32541021704673767,
0.5639442205429077,
0.25167572498321533,
-0.0938357561826706,
-0.10191819816827774,
-0.9119886159896851,
-0.03812958672642708,
-0.4871743321418762,
-0.4204311668872833,
-0.06796638667583466,
0.4404568374156952,
0.6876418590545654,
0.4185686409473419,
-0.10062757134437561,
0.2880111336708069,
0.1996331661939621,
0.5957702994346619,
-0.4462812840938568,
-0.17033833265304565,
-0.7617921233177185,
-0.20039108395576477,
0.05433280020952225,
-0.4062049984931946,
-0.16295307874679565,
-0.6156489253044128,
0.004858768545091152,
-0.7096807360649109,
0.013865014538168907,
-0.13878725469112396,
0.8915112018585205,
-0.10962415486574173,
-0.7674928903579712,
-0.2530999183654785,
-0.7623730301856995,
0.7430393695831299,
-0.36747363209724426,
0.3845377266407013,
0.34909987449645996,
-0.021211933344602585,
-0.06550928205251694,
-0.07257681339979172,
-0.7853373289108276,
-0.007044903934001923,
0.10416314005851746,
0.3018263280391693,
-0.44911354780197144,
-0.16937360167503357,
0.19000029563903809,
0.0824589729309082,
-0.3273014724254608,
-0.24179403483867645,
-0.542677104473114,
-0.2712518274784088,
0.5740992426872253,
-0.024040311574935913,
0.6140432953834534,
-0.5328590869903564,
-0.4478854238986969,
-0.09667519479990005,
-0.5145915150642395,
0.5028198957443237,
0.9542492032051086,
0.30286070704460144,
-0.20904484391212463,
0.9221333265304565,
-0.14766211807727814,
0.2511644959449768,
0.1613774597644806,
0.09924878180027008,
0.09516879171133041,
-0.5850543975830078,
-0.060615986585617065,
-0.07592867314815521,
0.4871830940246582,
0.6390892863273621,
0.19333530962467194,
0.30034512281417847,
-0.25936469435691833,
0.301334023475647,
0.34492024779319763,
-0.7113032341003418,
0.1318046897649765,
0.2628757655620575,
-0.5981303453445435,
-0.4260866343975067,
0.41923049092292786,
-0.6324744820594788,
-0.7278376817703247,
-0.45424285531044006,
0.723924458026886,
-0.2091183364391327,
-0.515332043170929,
0.03906058892607689,
-0.5621245503425598,
-0.0010275270324200392,
0.4057546555995941,
-0.5833637714385986,
0.09367073327302933,
0.6943343877792358,
1.0120375156402588,
-0.07188107818365097,
0.28613412380218506,
-0.4915430545806885,
0.21736599504947662,
-0.5809869766235352,
0.36192020773887634,
-0.7483944296836853,
-0.0826132670044899,
0.2300044149160385,
0.0033240877091884613,
0.17098994553089142,
-0.24162310361862183,
0.3214069902896881,
-0.6492072343826294,
0.4128986597061157,
-0.7711758017539978,
-0.33086419105529785,
-0.014209853485226631,
0.276790589094162,
-0.5879491567611694,
0.622991144657135,
0.2654796242713928,
-0.8122596740722656,
0.5960008502006531,
-0.8309885263442993,
-0.4196126461029053,
-0.2917366027832031,
0.1705833524465561,
-0.039441969245672226,
0.13439419865608215,
0.21452368795871735,
0.3089666962623596,
0.2914847433567047,
0.2826930284500122,
-0.3782641291618347,
0.03302827104926109,
0.3266453444957733,
-0.3303907811641693,
0.9197689890861511,
-0.03902888670563698,
-0.15577879548072815,
0.44707950949668884,
-0.24441294372081757,
-0.46432217955589294,
0.11179991066455841,
-0.35621577501296997,
-0.5061713457107544,
0.0272610392421484,
0.09870068728923798,
0.4356391727924347,
0.08897978067398071,
-0.7701959609985352,
0.15379561483860016,
-0.33628612756729126,
0.7202767133712769,
1.1185243129730225,
0.36408859491348267,
0.5210250020027161,
-0.46501728892326355,
0.4379623234272003,
0.14828576147556305,
0.1880713552236557,
-0.09138510376214981,
-0.10320349037647247,
-0.457771897315979,
-0.3274211585521698,
0.1591121256351471,
0.39771750569343567,
-0.7807629108428955,
0.27886515855789185,
-0.16795039176940918,
-0.09749303013086319,
-0.43398115038871765,
0.32200345396995544,
-0.14668779075145721,
0.15485285222530365,
0.06799384951591492,
-0.1304454505443573,
-0.4869174063205719,
-0.7800996899604797,
-0.5292724967002869,
-0.2562790811061859,
-0.2700534164905548,
0.38981497287750244,
0.34788042306900024,
0.019598037004470825,
0.6969200968742371,
-0.012547827325761318,
-0.24105766415596008,
-0.3494584858417511,
0.24607793986797333,
0.24360275268554688,
0.1016109511256218,
0.5070236921310425,
-1.0747507810592651,
-0.4355063736438751,
-0.08188968896865845,
-0.34996965527534485,
0.013514069840312004,
-0.2512468695640564,
-0.267733097076416,
0.22981777787208557,
0.23146489262580872,
-0.4969577491283417,
0.4756392538547516,
0.7661429643630981,
-0.5068254470825195,
0.025174755603075027,
0.20440417528152466,
0.5894744396209717,
-1.0468556880950928,
0.08260392397642136,
0.22360752522945404,
-0.5642034411430359,
-0.5464338660240173,
-0.30258163809776306,
-0.3334707021713257,
-0.08222418278455734,
-0.3821616470813751,
0.5326870083808899,
-0.05401383712887764,
0.06870725750923157,
-0.2841942608356476,
0.29689598083496094,
0.005228833761066198,
-0.020285900682210922,
0.046871840953826904,
0.5703202486038208,
0.27664339542388916,
-0.40253007411956787,
-0.1197669729590416,
-0.21419739723205566,
-0.3518117666244507,
0.4320080876350403,
-0.9555359482765198,
-0.03961921110749245,
-0.43260329961776733,
0.7349876165390015,
-1.4572770595550537,
-0.6850260496139526,
0.3129007816314697,
-0.6030325293540955,
-0.24605634808540344,
0.2432384490966797,
-0.6288257241249084,
-0.3204018175601959,
-0.5737419724464417,
0.18163619935512543,
0.46000972390174866,
-0.34205469489097595,
0.5694530606269836,
0.592705488204956,
-0.27852362394332886,
-0.13538908958435059,
-0.26412567496299744,
0.15269123017787933,
-0.2521038353443146,
-0.4642942249774933,
0.007869832217693329,
0.14678604900836945,
-0.38372406363487244,
0.25572630763053894,
-0.09939544647932053,
0.35123443603515625,
0.026580048725008965,
0.02154279686510563,
0.06361875683069229,
0.05774782598018646,
0.45950332283973694,
0.028811011463403702,
0.17685139179229736,
-0.11340706050395966,
-0.22087500989437103,
0.7950426340103149,
0.061996955424547195,
-0.1599070131778717,
-1.0044041872024536,
0.625522792339325,
0.4263888895511627,
-0.40043389797210693,
0.8185362219810486,
0.8427698016166687,
-0.3759474754333496,
0.02864004485309124,
-0.5655697584152222,
-0.6755390763282776,
-0.41024911403656006,
0.3357594609260559,
0.1768893599510193,
-0.9929648041725159,
0.40096375346183777,
0.2695429027080536,
0.3195180594921112,
0.5411986708641052,
0.6920727491378784,
-0.30654385685920715,
1.3843854665756226,
0.6081733703613281,
-0.21250644326210022,
0.628419816493988,
0.02929040789604187,
0.14021815359592438,
-0.4343191981315613,
0.06898722052574158,
-0.3543674647808075,
-0.6802274584770203,
-0.4942139983177185,
-0.30167868733406067,
0.17761830985546112,
-0.14370742440223694,
-0.41423889994621277,
0.03824647143483162,
-0.5769238471984863,
0.26841774582862854,
0.5988520383834839,
0.33525893092155457,
0.1423587054014206,
-0.019264377653598785,
0.6430702209472656,
-0.11932140588760376,
-0.5682728290557861,
-0.5106480717658997,
0.864454448223114,
0.5002197623252869,
0.7151446342468262,
0.265663743019104,
0.5047117471694946,
0.9480244517326355,
0.6320850849151611,
-0.5011013150215149,
0.15535123646259308,
-0.09512020647525787,
-0.9862977862358093,
-0.342394083738327,
-0.5017111301422119,
-0.7757392525672913,
-0.1036854162812233,
-0.18443416059017181,
-0.8631781935691833,
0.23791258037090302,
0.28714245557785034,
-0.29910093545913696,
0.24785418808460236,
-0.6450884342193604,
0.32090476155281067,
-0.211562842130661,
-0.3488457500934601,
-0.6188976168632507,
-0.5653994679450989,
0.28214097023010254,
0.10251470655202866,
0.3094073235988617,
-0.2803988456726074,
-0.23051369190216064,
0.4945785701274872,
0.06297723203897476,
1.1719615459442139,
-0.2980794310569763,
0.0654044896364212,
0.2198452204465866,
-0.054753776639699936,
0.40125250816345215,
0.3456491231918335,
0.0937952995300293,
0.13423390686511993,
-0.176850363612175,
-0.5886899828910828,
-0.35812029242515564,
0.5369524955749512,
-0.9761669039726257,
-0.9043290019035339,
-0.29246991872787476,
-0.6266467571258545,
0.07666035741567612,
0.2135716676712036,
0.11245281994342804,
0.08264786750078201,
-0.1902550458908081,
0.7594614028930664,
0.5183551907539368,
0.058033451437950134,
0.15772011876106262,
0.2173454463481903,
-0.2501380145549774,
-0.5231878161430359,
0.7124584317207336,
0.27866387367248535,
0.5589684247970581,
0.22055687010288239,
0.4526423513889313,
-0.32931575179100037,
0.09010127931833267,
-0.2567361891269684,
0.028720011934638023,
-0.218294158577919,
-0.15169017016887665,
-0.7021830677986145,
0.015342839062213898,
-0.2639312148094177,
-0.2401299923658371,
-0.18250234425067902,
-0.38606685400009155,
-0.3070492744445801,
0.037117164582014084,
0.09615586698055267,
0.5448365211486816,
-0.146628737449646,
0.5855061411857605,
-0.546588659286499,
0.43065911531448364,
0.2057010978460312,
0.1507638841867447,
-0.24762214720249176,
-0.487796813249588,
0.05627074092626572,
0.5250096321105957,
-0.4175940454006195,
-1.0171055793762207,
0.029307851567864418,
-0.04520539194345474,
0.5352563261985779,
0.5696823000907898,
0.25315266847610474,
0.21761232614517212,
-0.17081354558467865,
0.7742133736610413,
0.17293009161949158,
-0.9581335186958313,
0.5985828042030334,
-1.002676010131836,
-0.026451963931322098,
0.4965403079986572,
0.5679657459259033,
-0.5772848129272461,
-0.8163302540779114,
-0.5837231874465942,
-0.6865189671516418,
0.4224627912044525,
0.4513806402683258,
0.9976418614387512,
-0.10934888571500778,
0.21525545418262482,
0.08357149362564087,
0.5614661574363708,
-1.0285875797271729,
0.23355227708816528,
-0.5408431887626648,
-0.08547558635473251,
0.002665736014023423,
-0.33014237880706787,
-0.5633407235145569,
-0.1717638522386551,
0.7177187204360962,
0.05742047727108002,
0.0014383031520992517,
0.49356621503829956,
0.26181551814079285,
-0.3015027940273285,
0.07212083786725998,
0.5355685353279114,
0.6713883280754089,
-0.2461044043302536,
-0.07295969873666763,
-0.5035530924797058,
-0.17729152739048004,
0.025058818981051445,
-0.14244325459003448,
-0.2650892436504364,
0.0710323378443718,
0.14950035512447357,
0.4334852397441864,
-0.15144015848636627,
-0.37971314787864685,
0.636438250541687,
0.0632767453789711,
-0.3359375,
-0.02977031283080578,
0.013002416118979454,
0.37316960096359253,
0.30255740880966187,
0.45752009749412537,
-0.12720175087451935,
0.06062040105462074,
-1.0235201120376587,
0.041237425059080124,
0.7127777934074402,
-0.5303636193275452,
-0.39341500401496887,
0.8697926998138428,
0.4846241772174835,
-0.42915940284729004,
0.30562520027160645,
-0.11966454982757568,
-0.6664362549781799,
0.5391803979873657,
0.6370179057121277,
0.48500871658325195,
-0.17077048122882843,
0.47196510434150696,
0.4038486182689667,
0.4891441762447357,
0.1382708102464676,
0.18050570785999298,
0.22137205302715302,
-0.844184160232544,
-0.1653091013431549,
-0.3674675226211548,
-0.14164116978645325,
0.050012171268463135,
-0.3583447337150574,
0.29155296087265015,
-0.6885920763015747,
-0.661166787147522,
0.18500961363315582,
0.2429637461900711,
-0.5267868041992188,
-0.11284109205007553,
-0.128712460398674,
0.8087084293365479,
-1.2508617639541626,
0.2831730246543884,
0.7155969738960266,
-0.4664666950702667,
-0.5497358441352844,
0.5494030117988586,
0.3274824321269989,
-0.47044554352760315,
0.34152400493621826,
0.2502332031726837,
0.10320756584405899,
-0.1046338826417923,
-0.8054366707801819,
-0.6166526675224304,
0.7863433361053467,
0.42432254552841187,
-0.39255717396736145,
0.3795514702796936,
-0.021381352096796036,
0.4529143273830414,
-0.4330707788467407,
-0.1782914698123932,
0.24013525247573853,
0.653605043888092,
-0.18576134741306305,
-0.5408520102500916,
-0.024228615686297417,
-0.07933249324560165,
-0.21584729850292206,
0.28354373574256897,
-1.0978304147720337,
0.6635316610336304,
-0.0924251526594162,
-0.38375139236450195,
-0.1748562902212143,
0.6281786561012268,
0.04479202255606651,
0.4409579336643219,
0.8813326358795166,
-0.016916071996092796,
0.5990511775016785,
0.03770221769809723,
1.1191164255142212,
-0.2595362961292267,
0.25704964995384216,
0.6506349444389343,
-0.1725357472896576,
0.8024085760116577,
0.6526666879653931,
0.006039025727659464,
0.5298406481742859,
0.6577433347702026,
0.0755481943488121,
0.4710807800292969,
0.1126854196190834,
-0.41280412673950195,
-0.37174639105796814,
-0.9056534171104431,
-0.33402833342552185,
0.36450430750846863,
0.31301337480545044,
-0.5107924938201904,
-0.14077366888523102,
0.09770940989255905,
0.2340426743030548,
0.470081090927124,
-0.19666442275047302,
0.558552622795105,
-0.1319921612739563,
-0.4709863066673279,
-0.2788582444190979,
-0.013972261920571327,
0.35391905903816223,
-0.6318963766098022,
-0.024457784369587898,
-0.11437135934829712,
-0.07974772900342941,
-0.11601756513118744,
-0.8440314531326294,
0.2530207931995392,
-0.09820377826690674,
-0.2986827492713928,
-0.25281551480293274,
0.765918493270874,
-0.45992010831832886,
-0.7541472911834717,
0.1294383555650711,
0.6477163434028625,
-0.33995211124420166,
-0.34667497873306274,
-0.40786632895469666,
0.2724035084247589,
0.11009065061807632,
-0.5285617709159851,
0.2674923241138458,
0.26295503973960876,
-0.18026432394981384,
0.47684410214424133,
1.191481113433838,
0.06343737244606018,
-0.42163535952568054,
0.21977867186069489,
1.15676748752594,
-0.22062991559505463,
-0.397112637758255,
-0.9488541483879089,
0.6232938766479492,
-0.4580335319042206,
-0.2555359899997711,
0.8251652717590332,
0.5693791508674622,
0.6643684506416321,
0.10586492717266083,
0.8242968916893005,
-0.22610591351985931,
0.6185919046401978,
-0.18530133366584778,
0.7467678785324097,
-0.7477025985717773,
0.08482282608747482,
-0.19428230822086334,
-0.6944752931594849,
-0.24649201333522797,
0.30502715706825256,
-0.34863150119781494,
0.08938873559236526,
0.018856050446629524,
0.635790228843689,
0.02506294660270214,
-0.2837086021900177,
0.04461738467216492,
0.1724032312631607,
0.4516817331314087,
0.14179854094982147,
1.0230581760406494,
0.30891239643096924,
0.5207750201225281,
-0.18807530403137207,
-0.4394310414791107,
-0.17755240201950073,
-0.6701216697692871,
-1.1441318988800049,
-0.582728385925293,
0.026036959141492844,
-0.5875540971755981,
0.49300336837768555,
1.1124913692474365,
0.6578779220581055,
-0.40966373682022095,
0.0013049232074990869,
0.10013969987630844,
0.3642786741256714,
-0.05184051766991615,
-0.3093824088573456,
0.4007475972175598,
-0.26088637113571167,
-0.7765339612960815,
-0.4810207784175873,
0.2620473802089691,
-0.30237019062042236,
-0.4595789909362793,
0.2732193171977997,
-0.28941506147384644,
0.48899784684181213,
0.7809180617332458,
0.059225380420684814,
-0.6482829451560974,
-0.7629228830337524,
0.5189282298088074,
-0.2662706971168518,
0.06351865828037262,
0.8320016860961914,
-0.47322332859039307,
0.37614282965660095,
0.707360029220581,
0.5531748533248901,
-0.10057718306779861,
0.8416013717651367,
0.5990155935287476,
-0.5674402713775635,
0.03988923132419586,
0.4129370152950287,
-0.05039175972342491,
0.2325567752122879,
-0.6032171249389648,
0.2034945785999298,
0.28506213426589966,
-0.45076897740364075,
-0.662833034992218,
0.07017157226800919,
-0.8947392106056213,
-0.06107001751661301,
1.4657130241394043,
0.1872667372226715,
-0.039165396243333817,
-0.06355882436037064,
-0.393246591091156,
0.09749092161655426,
-0.9028275609016418,
1.1877155303955078,
0.9728491902351379,
0.06793996691703796,
-0.10164301097393036,
-0.9480240941047668,
0.2422296702861786,
0.07309205085039139,
-0.7644509077072144,
0.10471134632825851,
0.37934964895248413,
0.24582542479038239,
0.05421583727002144,
0.721422553062439,
-0.06814957410097122,
0.31596651673316956,
-0.2505107522010803,
-0.23055300116539001,
0.2690100073814392,
-0.318229615688324,
-0.04127116501331329,
-0.01545218750834465,
-0.3829033672809601,
-0.18155749142169952
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.13344v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.13344v1
|
USE: Dynamic User Modeling with Stateful Sequence Models
| 2024-03-20T07:05:19 | 2024-03-20T07:05:19 |
Zhihan Zhou, Qixiang Fang, Leonardo Neves, Francesco Barbieri, Yozen Liu, Han Liu, Maarten W. Bos, Ron Dotsch
|
cs.SI
|
cs.SI, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
User embeddings play a crucial role in user engagement forecasting and
personalized services. Recent advances in sequence modeling have sparked
interest in learning user embeddings from behavioral data. Yet behavior-based
user embedding learning faces the unique challenge of dynamic user modeling. As
users continuously interact with the apps, user embeddings should be
periodically updated to account for users' recent and long-term behavior
patterns. Existing methods highly rely on stateless sequence models that lack
memory of historical behavior. They have to either discard historical data and
use only the most recent data or reprocess the old and new data jointly. Both
cases incur substantial computational overhead. To address this limitation, we
introduce User Stateful Embedding (USE). USE generates user embeddings and
reflects users' evolving behaviors without the need for exhaustive reprocessing
by storing previous model states and revisiting them in the future.
Furthermore, we introduce a novel training objective named future W-behavior
prediction to transcend the limitations of next-token prediction by forecasting
a broader horizon of upcoming user behaviors. By combining it with the Same
User Prediction, a contrastive learning-based objective that predicts whether
different segments of behavior sequences belong to the same user, we further
improve the embeddings' distinctiveness and representativeness. We conducted
experiments on 8 downstream tasks using Snapchat users' behavioral logs in both
static (i.e., fixed user behavior sequences) and dynamic (i.e., periodically
updated user behavior sequences) settings. We demonstrate USE's superior
performance over established baselines. The results underscore USE's
effectiveness and efficiency in integrating historical and recent user behavior
sequences into user embeddings in dynamic user modeling.
|
[
-0.01219456922262907,
-0.4854329824447632,
0.32021328806877136,
0.08122219890356064,
-0.1027185395359993,
0.3909219801425934,
0.1165856197476387,
-0.343414306640625,
0.5486245155334473,
0.2858835756778717,
-0.5931510329246521,
-0.20642322301864624,
0.01906239427626133,
-0.2936198115348816,
-0.4712429344654083,
0.668432891368866,
-0.016533348709344864,
-0.2578143775463104,
-0.35575029253959656,
-0.15492549538612366,
-0.72775799036026,
-0.5009757876396179,
-0.14143715798854828,
-0.2560245394706726,
0.4691440165042877,
0.4537660777568817,
0.6678425073623657,
0.3412743806838989,
-0.15393367409706116,
0.36089345812797546,
-0.056467026472091675,
0.34174391627311707,
-0.7893356680870056,
0.4980933964252472,
-0.06504648178815842,
-0.12768623232841492,
-0.12469332665205002,
-0.00858299806714058,
0.3241332769393921,
0.5157621502876282,
-0.566580057144165,
0.08118639141321182,
0.0732356533408165,
0.30501821637153625,
-0.6500988006591797,
0.19855456054210663,
-0.4254705011844635,
0.24869263172149658,
0.07890506833791733,
-0.09850719571113586,
-0.36287960410118103,
-0.3997426927089691,
0.25710055232048035,
-0.4251757264137268,
-0.09227711707353592,
0.11789948493242264,
0.5745633244514465,
-0.0011431581806391478,
-0.6764211058616638,
0.05412943661212921,
-0.6914830207824707,
0.6341903805732727,
-0.5062827467918396,
0.6468037366867065,
0.27534550428390503,
0.16481217741966248,
-0.44801023602485657,
-0.7167379856109619,
-0.4349576532840729,
-0.18357357382774353,
0.045108940452337265,
-0.026197869330644608,
-0.03162391483783722,
-0.3087853193283081,
0.26036757230758667,
0.11945365369319916,
-0.21426984667778015,
0.045449282974004745,
-0.2735452950000763,
-0.2133808732032776,
0.6625410318374634,
0.5171694159507751,
0.21209396421909332,
-0.0732979029417038,
-0.6615327596664429,
0.04300423711538315,
-0.3343651592731476,
0.4652884602546692,
0.26001429557800293,
0.2758985459804535,
-0.37232092022895813,
0.613807737827301,
-0.02582940272986889,
0.2775018811225891,
0.3076997995376587,
0.08809279650449753,
0.6379422545433044,
-0.07019868493080139,
0.0648326426744461,
-0.1278662532567978,
0.5583717823028564,
0.2647016644477844,
0.14872197806835175,
-0.28254303336143494,
-0.26274579763412476,
-0.19860343635082245,
0.5867418050765991,
-0.7784969210624695,
-0.18320414423942566,
0.14645972847938538,
-0.3344607651233673,
-0.256269633769989,
0.2396327555179596,
-0.5516104102134705,
-0.596950352191925,
-0.15728652477264404,
0.1910289078950882,
-0.5332702994346619,
-0.2109903246164322,
0.03470190614461899,
0.044519782066345215,
-0.25435495376586914,
0.3657155930995941,
-1.091505527496338,
0.4022855758666992,
0.6409742832183838,
0.9159488677978516,
-0.29342949390411377,
-0.47248488664627075,
-0.44104906916618347,
0.22791410982608795,
-0.3483281433582306,
0.2011229246854782,
-0.8200849294662476,
-0.5993103384971619,
0.3189130127429962,
-0.05681317672133446,
-0.012038826942443848,
-0.37125691771507263,
-0.02979946695268154,
-0.8142128586769104,
-0.11076164990663528,
-0.39335036277770996,
-0.8282071352005005,
-0.2690427005290985,
-0.0056580351665616035,
-0.5764171481132507,
1.010284662246704,
0.23925217986106873,
-0.4090045690536499,
0.5810442566871643,
-0.6035031676292419,
-0.4286341965198517,
0.15189804136753082,
0.06856848299503326,
-0.4750671088695526,
0.4743417799472809,
-0.07923855632543564,
0.7583428025245667,
0.5162675976753235,
0.2942669987678528,
-0.7494956254959106,
-0.6288348436355591,
0.23243306577205658,
0.07496266812086105,
0.28150027990341187,
0.29051825404167175,
0.04428412392735481,
0.16336214542388916,
-0.39266541600227356,
-0.3042536973953247,
0.19806860387325287,
-0.320983350276947,
-0.423083633184433,
0.42550110816955566,
-0.05751773715019226,
0.19602955877780914,
0.41081905364990234,
-0.7171776294708252,
0.207830011844635,
-0.18871556222438812,
0.6907769441604614,
0.837193489074707,
0.02862393483519554,
0.4112497866153717,
-0.2844662070274353,
0.4960961639881134,
0.329021155834198,
0.09229453653097153,
-0.7210595011711121,
-0.35894128680229187,
-0.07716839015483856,
-0.08164245635271072,
-0.020276939496397972,
0.4523027837276459,
-0.39844417572021484,
0.3467881679534912,
-0.36820828914642334,
-0.37365806102752686,
0.24357633292675018,
0.2169787883758545,
0.10169626027345657,
0.36032015085220337,
0.1914815604686737,
-0.5569746494293213,
-0.5866407155990601,
-0.4185386598110199,
-0.34136927127838135,
-0.14732934534549713,
0.2675907611846924,
0.6227672696113586,
0.40268346667289734,
-0.4561167359352112,
1.0146267414093018,
-0.48587334156036377,
0.12219748646020889,
-0.18848218023777008,
-0.02510877326130867,
0.054990582168102264,
0.39597800374031067,
0.27069491147994995,
-1.00559401512146,
-0.3179934322834015,
-0.37373682856559753,
-0.6137522459030151,
0.44652920961380005,
-0.3293013572692871,
-0.037634920328855515,
0.026815420016646385,
0.36069971323013306,
-0.3451392352581024,
0.5644886493682861,
0.5706256628036499,
-0.8362739086151123,
0.149507075548172,
-0.18009276688098907,
0.06016409769654274,
-1.0698161125183105,
-0.271991103887558,
0.21086284518241882,
-0.6396287679672241,
-0.40397924184799194,
-0.3831937313079834,
0.21569645404815674,
-0.5847527980804443,
-0.6577035784721375,
0.6741055250167847,
-0.4138714373111725,
-0.35855013132095337,
-0.005987921264022589,
-0.40857356786727905,
-0.38230058550834656,
0.41006526350975037,
-0.3136485517024994,
0.7362508177757263,
0.2196497619152069,
-0.6008156538009644,
0.15443632006645203,
0.5323985815048218,
-0.4436964988708496,
0.010813015513122082,
-0.39095255732536316,
0.09520043432712555,
0.2045983076095581,
0.26030808687210083,
-1.1333309412002563,
-0.27439576387405396,
0.11345155537128448,
-0.3669510781764984,
0.2657555341720581,
-0.1591780036687851,
-0.37239018082618713,
-0.4976736009120941,
-0.5815368890762329,
0.25189608335494995,
0.7702516317367554,
-0.695097804069519,
0.6773366332054138,
0.5383892059326172,
0.08730503916740417,
-0.3313635289669037,
-0.430644690990448,
-0.03269045799970627,
-0.2567414939403534,
-0.38753369450569153,
0.52828449010849,
0.24344585835933685,
0.4172452390193939,
0.14762774109840393,
-0.2641178369522095,
0.154802605509758,
0.25255286693573,
0.5265113115310669,
0.3006587326526642,
0.13383464515209198,
0.2932906746864319,
0.07663208246231079,
-0.12447059899568558,
-0.2603128254413605,
-0.19869042932987213,
0.6709427237510681,
-0.017326703295111656,
-0.3499480187892914,
-0.7016123533248901,
0.2779986262321472,
0.6067056655883789,
-0.14279070496559143,
0.8441724181175232,
0.6057074069976807,
-0.30719152092933655,
-0.03755805268883705,
-0.41527196764945984,
-0.4418894350528717,
-0.5881958603858948,
0.498469740152359,
-0.1163022518157959,
-1.3916189670562744,
0.6075276136398315,
-0.4066029191017151,
0.26771172881126404,
-0.2038680464029312,
0.5042030215263367,
-0.5259143710136414,
1.0845032930374146,
0.6494259834289551,
-0.13426373898983002,
1.1143418550491333,
-0.07127677649259567,
0.19622699916362762,
-0.7375800013542175,
-0.518842875957489,
0.23631012439727783,
-0.6905478239059448,
-0.7274167537689209,
-0.12926563620567322,
0.09934438765048981,
-0.08058691769838333,
-0.6478910446166992,
0.3863856792449951,
-0.08089258521795273,
0.032790616154670715,
0.3635810911655426,
0.504384458065033,
-0.24374085664749146,
0.26475560665130615,
-0.05250716954469681,
-0.31765422224998474,
-0.40153980255126953,
-0.32125988602638245,
1.1263808012008667,
0.2766910791397095,
1.0913358926773071,
0.1325889676809311,
0.8364965915679932,
0.8367811441421509,
-0.10678234696388245,
-0.7581303119659424,
0.5608320236206055,
-0.1822434663772583,
-0.13367296755313873,
-0.11274880170822144,
-0.25310251116752625,
-1.0868194103240967,
0.16542433202266693,
-0.3305107355117798,
-1.292409062385559,
0.16060124337673187,
0.8141195774078369,
-0.4107878506183624,
0.34654170274734497,
-0.708001971244812,
0.6655988097190857,
-0.14424175024032593,
-0.5549737215042114,
-0.4722086489200592,
-0.35160574316978455,
0.09319376945495605,
0.12949182093143463,
-0.19098031520843506,
-0.17570528388023376,
-0.2558838725090027,
0.6202315092086792,
-0.4879274368286133,
1.2182083129882812,
-0.5681536793708801,
0.266709566116333,
0.24213768541812897,
0.27289366722106934,
0.7736604809761047,
-0.015799950808286667,
0.027151208370923996,
-0.07669904083013535,
-0.06944238394498825,
-0.36343467235565186,
-0.5081441402435303,
0.8271052241325378,
-0.5683919191360474,
-0.5636109113693237,
-0.4679373800754547,
-0.1418246030807495,
-0.41787269711494446,
0.09377125650644302,
-0.23867788910865784,
0.5631729364395142,
-0.2830732464790344,
0.26822707056999207,
0.5182674527168274,
-0.098137766122818,
0.5185079574584961,
0.19493135809898376,
-0.31510722637176514,
-0.16629688441753387,
0.8756996989250183,
-0.12132030725479126,
-0.3201589584350586,
0.20566530525684357,
0.5018963813781738,
-0.5725399255752563,
-0.4308769404888153,
-0.12187694013118744,
0.22322610020637512,
-0.1933157742023468,
0.009007328189909458,
-0.6872029304504395,
0.33167269825935364,
-0.2613981366157532,
-0.2588069438934326,
-0.5487430691719055,
-0.03660336881875992,
-0.3964967131614685,
-0.14871874451637268,
0.5051840543746948,
0.6011003255844116,
0.07581841945648193,
0.27954012155532837,
-0.7965116500854492,
0.19259196519851685,
0.3331303000450134,
0.3395020663738251,
0.32551148533821106,
-0.3692927956581116,
-0.4310568869113922,
0.02091476321220398,
-0.5271023511886597,
-0.8784552216529846,
0.4199056029319763,
0.41229310631752014,
0.6858112215995789,
0.608603835105896,
0.1034877821803093,
0.8271200656890869,
-0.5885071158409119,
0.874257504940033,
0.25776663422584534,
-0.8565046191215515,
0.5905168056488037,
-0.24422450363636017,
0.11977770179510117,
0.4488348066806793,
0.6162276268005371,
-0.8779348731040955,
0.22633817791938782,
-0.4279995858669281,
-0.9089445471763611,
0.6401371955871582,
-0.3704077899456024,
0.9374692440032959,
-0.08113082498311996,
0.68241286277771,
0.20265154540538788,
0.33532530069351196,
-0.16303876042366028,
-0.03705838695168495,
-0.3253258466720581,
-0.22523793578147888,
-0.06215934455394745,
-0.5098697543144226,
0.34683436155319214,
-0.5002790689468384,
0.288766473531723,
-0.13148227334022522,
0.4833373725414276,
-0.35929086804389954,
-0.06581190228462219,
0.12135977298021317,
-0.22207364439964294,
0.34774863719940186,
0.767527163028717,
-0.24142205715179443,
-0.34988775849342346,
0.24798071384429932,
-0.5422981977462769,
0.2462974190711975,
-0.19788672029972076,
-0.08068060874938965,
-0.2634342908859253,
0.012650776654481888,
0.8224736452102661,
0.8675499558448792,
-0.7576314210891724,
0.7507078647613525,
0.009189224801957607,
0.12400942295789719,
-0.7173333168029785,
0.4004109799861908,
0.19180135428905487,
0.4718967080116272,
0.2092031091451645,
0.17779618501663208,
0.10725075751543045,
-0.7350354790687561,
0.2833670675754547,
0.15815113484859467,
-0.659889280796051,
-0.7176337838172913,
0.6050500273704529,
0.37184450030326843,
-0.2989427447319031,
0.9141064882278442,
-0.0979735255241394,
-0.4466627240180969,
0.1554822027683258,
0.6438124179840088,
0.6938145160675049,
-0.5393698811531067,
0.1937641054391861,
0.4986411929130554,
-0.6377001404762268,
-0.2443721741437912,
0.7828584313392639,
-0.28000134229660034,
-0.838080108165741,
-0.032920509576797485,
-0.3287675380706787,
-0.3565954267978668,
-0.04482336342334747,
-0.9463241100311279,
0.35850024223327637,
-0.573233425617218,
-0.4604299068450928,
-0.3050450384616852,
-0.1783073991537094,
-0.6892537474632263,
-0.15346252918243408,
0.056953951716423035,
0.750876247882843,
-0.8646643161773682,
0.5530639290809631,
0.9701539874076843,
-0.01632527820765972,
-0.43890413641929626,
-0.1438797563314438,
0.5185834169387817,
-0.6714203357696533,
0.28822654485702515,
0.3533819913864136,
-0.2058853656053543,
-0.2053566426038742,
-0.5268447399139404,
-0.7503950595855713,
1.2057936191558838,
0.18830598890781403,
-0.6082247495651245,
0.08087781816720963,
-0.5044087767601013,
0.34934329986572266,
-0.3739031255245209,
-0.05472760647535324,
0.19418679177761078,
-0.08170393109321594,
0.3292723596096039,
-0.3555269241333008,
0.13535678386688232,
-0.199175626039505,
0.32447975873947144,
0.15508808195590973,
-0.6223072409629822,
0.727120041847229,
-0.6323937177658081,
-0.3848280608654022,
-0.02953295037150383,
1.0802487134933472,
0.12586505711078644,
0.425682932138443,
0.7116734385490417,
0.4656106233596802,
0.8263798952102661,
0.18187588453292847,
0.8649147748947144,
-0.11405479162931442,
0.3119215667247772,
1.08351731300354,
-0.4023635983467102,
1.1479548215866089,
0.3325120806694031,
-0.1642695963382721,
0.8030120134353638,
0.8377121090888977,
-0.13923802971839905,
0.8535755276679993,
0.11814475059509277,
-0.28728652000427246,
-0.3946351408958435,
0.10834451764822006,
-0.19115518033504486,
0.6082702279090881,
0.47099196910858154,
-0.3084620535373688,
0.09169570356607437,
0.13767042756080627,
0.15129655599594116,
0.11358265578746796,
-0.048508960753679276,
0.823581337928772,
-0.0011512964265421033,
-0.37983953952789307,
0.2051294595003128,
-0.16994045674800873,
0.9904471635818481,
-0.5415375828742981,
0.007681369781494141,
-0.2827225625514984,
0.11862011253833771,
-0.30212751030921936,
-0.6314588189125061,
0.265108197927475,
-0.02851562388241291,
-0.02051890827715397,
-0.3216918110847473,
0.5715934038162231,
-0.1432986706495285,
-0.20290234684944153,
0.3359430432319641,
0.49844589829444885,
-0.028655720874667168,
0.25702202320098877,
-0.5981101393699646,
-0.035974130034446716,
-0.04374892637133598,
-0.5339618921279907,
0.4095125198364258,
-0.07514940947294235,
-0.2318153828382492,
1.050614595413208,
0.6774213910102844,
-0.11782863736152649,
-0.07123375684022903,
0.06290414184331894,
0.9109989404678345,
-0.9140047430992126,
-0.9769377112388611,
-0.8591412901878357,
0.41101595759391785,
0.13364580273628235,
-0.36814531683921814,
0.5249819755554199,
0.6024060249328613,
0.8607223629951477,
0.06131264939904213,
0.558957576751709,
-0.03361816704273224,
0.5111908912658691,
-0.2365611493587494,
0.45414507389068604,
-0.7260282635688782,
0.1010998785495758,
-0.03384916111826897,
-0.5396869778633118,
0.20626269280910492,
0.39363983273506165,
-0.1651579886674881,
0.3565655052661896,
0.07132616639137268,
0.47295117378234863,
-0.41802552342414856,
0.28502169251441956,
0.2805462181568146,
-0.12107660621404648,
0.37500324845314026,
0.3752776086330414,
1.039052128791809,
0.018632331863045692,
0.060006119310855865,
-0.3343055844306946,
-0.1696235090494156,
-0.6167394518852234,
-0.8452290296554565,
-0.71687251329422,
-0.8730868101119995,
-0.22141151130199432,
-0.18197213113307953,
0.2314954549074173,
1.1167694330215454,
0.9827213287353516,
-0.8196659088134766,
-0.25014880299568176,
0.24128292500972748,
-0.06646006554365158,
-0.3357366621494293,
-0.16614888608455658,
0.16301748156547546,
-0.21106000244617462,
-0.5208120346069336,
0.39548438787460327,
0.12493451684713364,
0.21482238173484802,
-0.17590142786502838,
-0.20833207666873932,
0.02902102656662464,
-0.18324752151966095,
0.648896336555481,
0.6413888335227966,
-0.5484485626220703,
-0.5250055193901062,
-0.1029995009303093,
0.1338890641927719,
0.07617216557264328,
0.8846405148506165,
-0.9333354830741882,
0.5801565647125244,
0.5210985541343689,
0.6363067030906677,
0.8147698640823364,
0.45486459136009216,
0.4797767400741577,
-0.6195954084396362,
-0.040411487221717834,
0.24696305394172668,
0.4480927288532257,
0.2642419934272766,
-0.4928516149520874,
0.14329880475997925,
0.2218170315027237,
-0.13849830627441406,
-0.6566157937049866,
0.13112685084342957,
-0.847819447517395,
-0.07918713986873627,
0.682153046131134,
-0.4665904641151428,
-0.019665945321321487,
-0.14704759418964386,
0.2046041637659073,
0.11871034651994705,
-0.9907811284065247,
0.8031913042068481,
0.3036510646343231,
-0.5605283379554749,
-0.2957810163497925,
-0.2610705494880676,
0.22443406283855438,
0.1611684411764145,
-0.4272230267524719,
-0.04249502345919609,
0.4173756241798401,
0.3131355047225952,
-0.22175060212612152,
0.3759765625,
-0.016639547422528267,
0.2722152769565582,
-0.04750358313322067,
-0.2890293300151825,
-0.6794721484184265,
-0.3581148087978363,
-0.2820778787136078,
0.05371742695569992,
-0.1884016990661621,
-0.5284799337387085
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.13334v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.13334v2
|
Hyacinth6B: A large language model for Traditional Chinese
| 2024-03-20T06:37:59 | 2024-03-26T12:24:46 |
Chih-Wei Song, Yin-Te Tsai
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This research's primary motivation of this study is to address the high
hardware and computational demands typically associated with LLMs.Therefore,our
goal is to find a balance between model lightness and performance,striving to
maximize performance while using a comparatively lightweight model. Hyacinth6B
was developed with this objective in mind,aiming to fully leverage the core
capabilities of LLMs without incurring substantial resource costs, effectively
pushing the boundaries of smaller model's performance. The training approach
involves parameter efficient finetuning using the LoRA method.
|
[
-0.14687876403331757,
-0.8101171851158142,
0.44059979915618896,
0.1932956576347351,
-0.4102935791015625,
-0.23234207928180695,
-0.2738189101219177,
-0.647760272026062,
0.4121837913990021,
0.7102048397064209,
-0.4371700584888458,
-0.37030911445617676,
-0.1743583083152771,
-0.06423019617795944,
-0.3887975513935089,
0.5754395127296448,
0.11756883561611176,
0.06204796954989433,
0.4265992045402527,
0.09485404938459396,
-0.25889620184898376,
-0.42324507236480713,
-0.5180182456970215,
-0.7693993449211121,
1.1085401773452759,
0.46847134828567505,
0.8659082651138306,
1.0406962633132935,
0.9157650470733643,
0.2357880175113678,
-0.22290068864822388,
-0.09894052147865295,
-0.5176132321357727,
-0.07827302813529968,
0.11720861494541168,
-0.7361253499984741,
-0.33216920495033264,
-0.4188210666179657,
0.7747846841812134,
0.5858030319213867,
-0.11439007520675659,
0.37001627683639526,
-0.09242075681686401,
0.7558003664016724,
-0.7537182569503784,
0.14559900760650635,
-0.5452570915222168,
0.07694222033023834,
-0.6106776595115662,
-0.09269597381353378,
-0.38941675424575806,
-0.2892025411128998,
0.11920495331287384,
-0.26951199769973755,
-0.12340046465396881,
-0.000028718262910842896,
0.9129739999771118,
0.07561513781547546,
-0.3532094955444336,
0.041619330644607544,
-0.5643597841262817,
0.7036734819412231,
-1.2402738332748413,
-0.046834517270326614,
0.15276631712913513,
0.4700596332550049,
-0.1444617211818695,
-0.5473228096961975,
-0.40259358286857605,
-0.2656514346599579,
0.1382826268672943,
-0.17650540173053741,
0.20486980676651,
0.3899596333503723,
0.5903009176254272,
0.5647072196006775,
-0.5694676637649536,
0.41184383630752563,
-0.803971529006958,
0.07165291160345078,
0.5771104097366333,
0.19832299649715424,
0.5566912293434143,
-0.5157895088195801,
-0.3771857023239136,
0.5088914632797241,
-0.8258925080299377,
0.13243763148784637,
0.2824711203575134,
0.6660115718841553,
-0.2744554877281189,
0.5511969327926636,
-0.13146616518497467,
0.8702363967895508,
-0.20722761750221252,
-0.49988457560539246,
0.15190644562244415,
-0.034383948892354965,
-0.5644126534461975,
0.34956273436546326,
0.5935189127922058,
0.03818698972463608,
0.1287151277065277,
0.10553933680057526,
-0.2884601652622223,
0.004444792866706848,
0.1268066167831421,
-1.19611394405365,
-0.13330887258052826,
-0.06803234666585922,
-0.7891363501548767,
-0.33395346999168396,
0.1111975759267807,
-0.49662065505981445,
-0.30587440729141235,
-0.5080277919769287,
0.5416349172592163,
-0.3648710250854492,
-0.42499840259552,
0.011561745777726173,
-0.016529079526662827,
0.6148224472999573,
0.4607788920402527,
-1.3218975067138672,
0.2872737646102905,
0.6061531901359558,
1.03646981716156,
-0.4626399278640747,
-0.292084276676178,
-0.43728047609329224,
0.17962300777435303,
-0.4600384533405304,
0.19844724237918854,
-0.31318917870521545,
-0.11540192365646362,
-0.031198082491755486,
-0.08961194008588791,
0.012848364189267159,
-0.5301257371902466,
0.5016279816627502,
-0.4162543714046478,
-0.320777028799057,
-0.6115615367889404,
-0.2764662504196167,
-0.38307467103004456,
0.2031836062669754,
-0.9753143191337585,
0.9687525033950806,
0.355082631111145,
-0.8882035613059998,
0.07583968341350555,
-0.5766234397888184,
-0.29634547233581543,
0.28561797738075256,
-0.4120250940322876,
-0.15663115680217743,
0.30949440598487854,
-0.25222423672676086,
0.20005375146865845,
-0.6105489730834961,
0.24135138094425201,
-0.18386872112751007,
-0.9554189443588257,
0.06414167582988739,
-0.6165754795074463,
1.0002806186676025,
0.4019468426704407,
-0.5864769816398621,
0.29154151678085327,
-0.6345126628875732,
-0.13890589773654938,
0.09124528616666794,
-0.6289055347442627,
-0.44059011340141296,
-0.1495547592639923,
0.3190731704235077,
0.21682585775852203,
0.5767947435379028,
-0.4619883894920349,
0.29386672377586365,
-0.7780511379241943,
0.6576752662658691,
0.7519028782844543,
-0.2626248896121979,
0.21319136023521423,
-0.4308291971683502,
0.49551671743392944,
0.022485431283712387,
0.31864798069000244,
-0.31124863028526306,
-0.4659455120563507,
-1.147823691368103,
-0.1863814890384674,
0.3423548936843872,
0.4268351197242737,
-0.7342284917831421,
0.35395681858062744,
0.044527411460876465,
-0.6265143156051636,
-0.6488947868347168,
0.7154010534286499,
0.3033364415168762,
0.2521750032901764,
0.19734147191047668,
-0.125239759683609,
-0.6704251170158386,
-1.2403109073638916,
0.24889019131660461,
-0.15725022554397583,
0.56858891248703,
-0.09881404042243958,
0.5982937216758728,
-0.45991840958595276,
0.6701920032501221,
-0.24777379631996155,
0.06271879374980927,
-0.5569548010826111,
-0.11395244300365448,
0.5570720434188843,
0.5069801211357117,
0.8456511497497559,
-0.9020159840583801,
-0.4741874933242798,
0.18826349079608917,
-0.7732309103012085,
-0.03886748105287552,
0.26312366127967834,
-0.2763833999633789,
0.39980247616767883,
0.29784995317459106,
-0.7834094762802124,
0.7372937798500061,
0.7270940542221069,
0.11649589985609055,
0.59937584400177,
-0.23367911577224731,
0.09581343829631805,
-1.1918139457702637,
0.07047367095947266,
0.11938165128231049,
0.0984545350074768,
-0.6025438904762268,
0.340015709400177,
0.2717573344707489,
-0.06442911922931671,
-0.7295705676078796,
0.39686882495880127,
-0.6510595083236694,
-0.18423035740852356,
-0.5816905498504639,
-0.16386795043945312,
-0.26621219515800476,
0.33652323484420776,
-0.06958867609500885,
0.521887481212616,
0.3444977402687073,
-0.5665407180786133,
0.955467939376831,
-0.36518630385398865,
-0.46173518896102905,
0.04672353342175484,
-0.8474755883216858,
-0.2810358703136444,
0.047900937497615814,
-0.13251367211341858,
-0.8856688141822815,
-0.4384424090385437,
-0.007131442427635193,
-0.25570106506347656,
-0.002809935249388218,
-0.02914801985025406,
-0.5598791837692261,
-0.7472802400588989,
-0.23962926864624023,
0.5175765752792358,
0.7502962350845337,
-0.6383771896362305,
0.6921042799949646,
-0.021551622077822685,
0.004276443272829056,
-0.35706594586372375,
-0.9774993062019348,
0.14950993657112122,
-0.5175556540489197,
-0.884577214717865,
0.38470032811164856,
-0.1273188591003418,
-0.5283874273300171,
-0.4161534607410431,
0.07002302259206772,
-0.05590903013944626,
0.11532580107450485,
0.2171417623758316,
0.5524822473526001,
-0.6982649564743042,
-0.040825605392456055,
-0.1408306360244751,
0.05121007561683655,
0.05749775469303131,
-0.07704498618841171,
0.5951058268547058,
-0.008084893226623535,
-0.5353704690933228,
-0.731806218624115,
0.04285227134823799,
0.7327468395233154,
-0.2210867702960968,
0.595718502998352,
0.6298505663871765,
-0.615983247756958,
-0.3487774729728699,
-0.6429919600486755,
-0.09750006347894669,
-0.5928151607513428,
0.4025419056415558,
-0.36501091718673706,
-0.648684561252594,
0.5811150670051575,
0.37749558687210083,
0.16628390550613403,
0.3574078381061554,
0.8989809155464172,
0.13829629123210907,
0.717747688293457,
0.6352953910827637,
-0.5358682870864868,
0.612979531288147,
0.014632441103458405,
-0.059154167771339417,
-0.5068901777267456,
-0.04464783892035484,
-0.5191605687141418,
-0.3964066803455353,
-0.6297585964202881,
-0.5346593856811523,
0.14785318076610565,
-0.14071416854858398,
-0.4759458005428314,
0.27086061239242554,
-0.3443366587162018,
0.3266606330871582,
0.7603353261947632,
0.20029836893081665,
0.4673711061477661,
0.021448275074362755,
0.03420056402683258,
-0.17560115456581116,
-0.6450679302215576,
-0.4420955181121826,
0.7642503380775452,
0.6430945992469788,
1.3613231182098389,
0.46151381731033325,
0.7838751673698425,
0.16726036369800568,
0.009476576931774616,
-0.9892332553863525,
0.531619668006897,
-0.191710963845253,
-0.7239233255386353,
-0.37474194169044495,
-0.5256183743476868,
-0.9177786111831665,
0.38592788577079773,
-0.05463451147079468,
-0.7097488045692444,
-0.21287205815315247,
0.23220477998256683,
-0.37210074067115784,
0.42494773864746094,
-0.6115227341651917,
0.7250832319259644,
-0.7508993148803711,
-0.49490857124328613,
-0.04149845242500305,
-0.6476243734359741,
0.7863305807113647,
0.13202454149723053,
0.13441430032253265,
-0.018292192369699478,
0.16638797521591187,
0.6836766004562378,
-0.3164982199668884,
0.9305214881896973,
-0.08220374584197998,
-0.3057860732078552,
0.2906862795352936,
-0.01126742921769619,
0.24431294202804565,
-0.23364228010177612,
-0.10214593261480331,
-0.2862621545791626,
-0.006278051529079676,
-0.5117754936218262,
-0.5175610184669495,
0.9780373573303223,
-1.0171412229537964,
-0.6968144178390503,
-0.4305872619152069,
-0.5958825349807739,
0.18941885232925415,
0.35306602716445923,
0.20916743576526642,
0.3886803686618805,
-0.06274112313985825,
0.6702679991722107,
0.8911586403846741,
-0.29974499344825745,
0.5905407667160034,
0.4531767964363098,
-0.8189771771430969,
-0.20111316442489624,
0.7856777310371399,
0.48516613245010376,
0.48994043469429016,
0.4361565411090851,
0.3874746263027191,
0.0854276791214943,
-0.650692343711853,
-0.5350111722946167,
0.4417744576931,
-0.5967342257499695,
0.1476762890815735,
-0.12754708528518677,
-0.7267740964889526,
-0.42043614387512207,
0.03918449953198433,
-0.32568275928497314,
-0.1737171858549118,
-0.4657443165779114,
-0.05648452788591385,
0.19846223294734955,
0.8281892538070679,
0.34256064891815186,
0.625156819820404,
-0.7060099244117737,
0.538444995880127,
0.22852714359760284,
0.13151858747005463,
0.06804076582193375,
-0.7906002998352051,
-0.5808947086334229,
-0.011728115379810333,
-0.3236050009727478,
-0.746604323387146,
0.4730134606361389,
-0.038475021719932556,
0.7186068892478943,
0.6789067983627319,
-0.11032144725322723,
0.5841204524040222,
-0.14798922836780548,
0.7535948753356934,
0.43934857845306396,
-0.886549174785614,
0.7012059092521667,
-0.6983043551445007,
0.4998720586299896,
0.2040584534406662,
0.24473989009857178,
-0.423882395029068,
0.17957253754138947,
-0.370622456073761,
-0.8332850337028503,
0.44688141345977783,
0.07089588791131973,
0.05234551057219505,
0.49236857891082764,
0.6155176162719727,
-0.08092951774597168,
0.1593398004770279,
-0.852230966091156,
-0.19614335894584656,
0.13680103421211243,
-0.40725988149642944,
-0.05542726069688797,
-0.3122098743915558,
0.09830774366855621,
-0.40264788269996643,
0.4855402112007141,
-0.1857294738292694,
-0.05158528313040733,
-0.16741155087947845,
-0.15763165056705475,
-0.27324968576431274,
0.1505064070224762,
0.5385036468505859,
0.8520326614379883,
-0.27447599172592163,
0.003992680460214615,
0.15159745514392853,
-0.41036200523376465,
0.03765008971095085,
-0.20232902467250824,
-0.5784817934036255,
0.05105835199356079,
0.5033842325210571,
1.0189845561981201,
0.17086800932884216,
-0.6920504570007324,
0.2855847477912903,
0.23578234016895294,
-0.22777658700942993,
-0.4445623755455017,
0.6072453260421753,
0.43569114804267883,
0.15874192118644714,
0.5465697050094604,
-0.3824050724506378,
0.05054711550474167,
-0.8646125197410583,
-0.13061504065990448,
0.19449225068092346,
-0.3728332817554474,
-0.22951221466064453,
0.2472664713859558,
0.26974165439605713,
-0.3900258541107178,
0.5539020299911499,
0.33286476135253906,
-0.40330150723457336,
0.8756208419799805,
0.5848459005355835,
0.5147209167480469,
-0.3345796465873718,
-0.1348869502544403,
0.3615168631076813,
0.5998097658157349,
-0.45285114645957947,
0.48132604360580444,
0.3179444372653961,
-0.4905494451522827,
-0.4034319519996643,
-0.6925898790359497,
-0.46691757440567017,
0.13487938046455383,
-0.7779619097709656,
0.6042551398277283,
-0.7823418378829956,
-0.40261518955230713,
-0.07869036495685577,
0.10491572320461273,
-0.20291133224964142,
0.3782670199871063,
0.41695544123649597,
1.209232211112976,
-0.5596125721931458,
1.2875488996505737,
0.39777979254722595,
-0.7073689103126526,
-0.9570664167404175,
-0.330671489238739,
0.06993073225021362,
-0.7438631653785706,
0.989248514175415,
0.29359233379364014,
-0.18403507769107819,
-0.1691131591796875,
-0.7226361632347107,
-0.8847417235374451,
1.3446743488311768,
0.7102611064910889,
-0.8670097589492798,
-0.7036634683609009,
-0.02098337933421135,
0.3990580439567566,
-0.4110163450241089,
-0.07553384453058243,
0.7735335230827332,
0.5373424291610718,
0.25681498646736145,
-1.1491211652755737,
-0.17223571240901947,
-0.4585828483104706,
0.3901093602180481,
0.00005946820601820946,
-1.1270698308944702,
1.4133563041687012,
-0.2267863154411316,
0.2085726261138916,
0.39900732040405273,
0.8862406015396118,
0.5292954444885254,
-0.06533005833625793,
0.18916437029838562,
0.32080355286598206,
0.7421804666519165,
-0.0773644968867302,
0.714612603187561,
-0.2907014489173889,
0.15229003131389618,
0.9077931642532349,
-0.39071574807167053,
0.964201807975769,
0.6805872917175293,
-0.006524192169308662,
0.4399346709251404,
0.7754756212234497,
0.041818127036094666,
0.0938139408826828,
0.6152290105819702,
-0.22757655382156372,
-0.2317030131816864,
0.015995316207408905,
-0.6236666440963745,
0.5205797553062439,
0.4166463315486908,
-0.5074115991592407,
0.2355780303478241,
-0.14260748028755188,
-0.166569784283638,
-0.031045658513903618,
-0.7153611183166504,
0.34843942523002625,
0.43873971700668335,
-0.636346161365509,
0.7714672088623047,
0.2628590762615204,
1.0773102045059204,
-0.9272114038467407,
0.08651498705148697,
-0.024342073127627373,
0.39351263642311096,
-0.3972935378551483,
-0.2929079532623291,
0.007038614712655544,
-0.22536106407642365,
-0.2169315069913864,
0.3763750195503235,
0.861481249332428,
-0.44943565130233765,
-0.645321786403656,
0.5144969820976257,
0.2686935365200043,
-0.021661153063178062,
0.13367505371570587,
-0.7525321841239929,
0.5734380483627319,
-0.03332460671663284,
-0.2810974419116974,
0.38740023970603943,
0.5262916684150696,
0.02795068547129631,
0.9195879697799683,
0.3754676878452301,
0.5060490965843201,
0.06436623632907867,
0.18286001682281494,
0.7519145011901855,
-1.1730862855911255,
-0.6792149543762207,
-1.1138415336608887,
0.19167140126228333,
0.17997559905052185,
-0.11974619328975677,
0.9575554132461548,
0.5686489343643188,
0.2738083302974701,
0.012108761817216873,
1.081246018409729,
0.197851300239563,
0.3235406279563904,
-0.7794064283370972,
0.7290566563606262,
-0.535827100276947,
0.27146947383880615,
-0.42758023738861084,
-0.8709168434143066,
-0.04393341764807701,
0.8450095653533936,
-0.1208472028374672,
0.3276771903038025,
0.6287440061569214,
0.7282313704490662,
0.035743311047554016,
0.07399095594882965,
0.5846961140632629,
0.23494336009025574,
0.356273353099823,
0.9244014024734497,
0.9171313643455505,
-0.3600015640258789,
0.28112444281578064,
-0.1400374174118042,
-0.23415233194828033,
-0.5328986048698425,
-0.7088814973831177,
-1.2266343832015991,
-0.14761045575141907,
0.06907696276903152,
-0.3813577890396118,
0.169654980301857,
1.3970683813095093,
0.6769097447395325,
-0.5589948892593384,
-0.9321631193161011,
0.2965208888053894,
-0.11679692566394806,
0.1541847437620163,
-0.1886763721704483,
0.19046974182128906,
-0.12909020483493805,
-0.6145071387290955,
0.02485639415681362,
0.3426051735877991,
0.32126766443252563,
-1.0269289016723633,
-0.18953073024749756,
-0.2898084819316864,
0.01590110920369625,
0.611526370048523,
0.2061813622713089,
-0.9081839919090271,
0.04337308928370476,
-0.0017671696841716766,
-0.6096739172935486,
0.04270918667316437,
0.8279746174812317,
-0.20171049237251282,
0.0504215732216835,
0.6544756889343262,
0.7907273769378662,
0.6830265522003174,
-0.009687023237347603,
0.6021259427070618,
-0.13287153840065002,
0.29747647047042847,
-0.034615371376276016,
0.5237200260162354,
0.393629252910614,
-0.23668628931045532,
0.29482731223106384,
0.33068302273750305,
-0.3839684724807739,
-0.6906335353851318,
0.12646816670894623,
-1.2706027030944824,
-0.27596214413642883,
1.430548071861267,
-0.09754157066345215,
-0.7564172148704529,
-0.005607312545180321,
-0.5934155583381653,
-0.007054781541228294,
-0.41332629323005676,
0.584202766418457,
0.8043168783187866,
0.12028529495000839,
-0.5131375193595886,
-0.8931014537811279,
0.15587949752807617,
0.08154541999101639,
-0.750106155872345,
-0.001956293359398842,
0.5203007459640503,
0.24245941638946533,
0.03052205592393875,
0.7836465835571289,
0.11288344115018845,
0.5269856452941895,
-0.1731189787387848,
0.09699521213769913,
0.17686688899993896,
-0.40257528424263,
-0.1016736701130867,
0.3764519691467285,
0.6392494440078735,
0.2609199285507202
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15467v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15467v1
|
Don't be a Fool: Pooling Strategies in Offensive Language Detection from User-Intended Adversarial Attacks
| 2024-03-20T06:28:09 | 2024-03-20T06:28:09 |
Seunguk Yu, Juhwan Choi, Youngbin Kim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Offensive language detection is an important task for filtering out abusive
expressions and improving online user experiences. However, malicious users
often attempt to avoid filtering systems through the involvement of textual
noises. In this paper, we propose these evasions as user-intended adversarial
attacks that insert special symbols or leverage the distinctive features of the
Korean language. Furthermore, we introduce simple yet effective pooling
strategies in a layer-wise manner to defend against the proposed attacks,
focusing on the preceding layers not just the last layer to capture both
offensiveness and token embeddings. We demonstrate that these pooling
strategies are more robust to performance degradation even when the attack rate
is increased, without directly training of such patterns. Notably, we found
that models pre-trained on clean texts could achieve a comparable performance
in detecting attacked offensive language, to models pre-trained on noisy texts
by employing these pooling strategies.
|
[
-0.27209779620170593,
-0.9185000658035278,
-0.002312930766493082,
0.04223876819014549,
-0.35141122341156006,
0.14526453614234924,
-0.28452107310295105,
-0.3667803704738617,
0.20866934955120087,
0.8195610642433167,
-0.30508923530578613,
-0.09084440022706985,
-0.6857919096946716,
0.014690348878502846,
-0.6235695481300354,
1.0357933044433594,
0.03709753602743149,
-0.010106606408953667,
0.45505571365356445,
-0.009527746587991714,
-0.25283142924308777,
-0.378486305475235,
-0.9527786374092102,
-0.23175589740276337,
0.4316937327384949,
0.1915469765663147,
0.9662677645683289,
0.565667986869812,
0.2916080355644226,
0.37475091218948364,
0.047840606421232224,
0.2298896610736847,
-0.7028582692146301,
0.3881891667842865,
-0.18194815516471863,
-0.5343514084815979,
-0.01847708225250244,
0.08185655623674393,
0.17649710178375244,
0.05028097331523895,
0.18695151805877686,
-0.2863837480545044,
-0.27973756194114685,
0.7584418654441833,
-1.197171926498413,
-0.005780455656349659,
-0.8473703861236572,
0.2354644536972046,
-0.5611451864242554,
-0.16021762788295746,
-0.514689028263092,
0.09656891226768494,
-0.07453583925962448,
-0.4897010922431946,
-0.11098164319992065,
-0.09276875108480453,
0.6816776394844055,
0.18653659522533417,
-0.1496192365884781,
-0.5403192639350891,
-0.5214884281158447,
0.8035930395126343,
-0.6162130832672119,
0.048502109944820404,
0.6100610494613647,
0.4000462591648102,
-0.14196303486824036,
-0.6079506874084473,
-0.6354203820228577,
-0.2376050055027008,
-0.25268256664276123,
0.2136223018169403,
-0.6504533290863037,
0.09475179761648178,
-0.01095881499350071,
0.09625613689422607,
-0.4730144441127777,
0.14648422598838806,
-0.11654308438301086,
-0.24087737500667572,
0.9110425114631653,
-0.25080230832099915,
0.8127149939537048,
-0.019199268892407417,
-0.6987190246582031,
-0.037267882376909256,
-0.5490158200263977,
-0.09220333397388458,
0.7992172241210938,
0.43155553936958313,
0.09207417070865631,
0.5312939882278442,
-0.13458947837352753,
0.36222660541534424,
0.12233806401491165,
0.15779699385166168,
0.009753433056175709,
-0.1388700306415558,
-0.19415391981601715,
0.1759408563375473,
0.9982531666755676,
0.1302689015865326,
0.7450569272041321,
-0.4633161127567291,
-0.611812949180603,
0.3260100185871124,
0.6025699973106384,
-0.47967711091041565,
-0.728567361831665,
0.16297465562820435,
-0.31671142578125,
-0.9137259125709534,
0.08284280449151993,
-0.8944322466850281,
-0.6828281879425049,
0.19403283298015594,
0.47103843092918396,
-0.6147075295448303,
-0.4470478892326355,
-0.08524098247289658,
-0.4448140561580658,
-0.07543748617172241,
-0.02503240294754505,
-0.7624274492263794,
0.5567851066589355,
0.5929276943206787,
0.4214780926704407,
-0.02034655213356018,
-0.20180954039096832,
-0.8362817764282227,
0.12065315246582031,
-0.3782717287540436,
0.6169653534889221,
-0.6637857556343079,
-0.27025172114372253,
0.1941998302936554,
-0.2929996848106384,
-0.2519586682319641,
-0.6060602068901062,
0.7387468218803406,
-0.7992969751358032,
0.2414461076259613,
-0.128947913646698,
-0.3043684959411621,
-0.25250911712646484,
0.15585017204284668,
-0.6939648389816284,
0.7244824171066284,
0.157727912068367,
-0.8957474827766418,
0.10812797397375107,
-0.7545813918113708,
-0.6365696787834167,
0.3249722421169281,
0.1416686326265335,
-0.3935681879520416,
0.08210092782974243,
0.3991840183734894,
0.18055936694145203,
0.47885453701019287,
-0.20327849686145782,
-0.3312954902648926,
-0.40109914541244507,
0.5944800972938538,
-0.47699999809265137,
0.9903391003608704,
0.5817318558692932,
-0.5573254227638245,
0.03596296161413193,
-0.2452048808336258,
0.14336182177066803,
0.42320579290390015,
-0.10695943981409073,
-0.6264181137084961,
0.10310988128185272,
0.08358225226402283,
0.19195203483104706,
0.18127404153347015,
-0.3362218141555786,
-0.24237610399723053,
-0.6251785755157471,
0.29892536997795105,
0.6374655365943909,
-0.1725553274154663,
0.6101183295249939,
-0.35107290744781494,
0.6794472336769104,
0.17358069121837616,
0.14929994940757751,
-0.4391348361968994,
-0.1580973118543625,
-0.6133847832679749,
-0.4110981822013855,
-0.03882075846195221,
0.9048221111297607,
-1.1736944913864136,
0.26699328422546387,
0.09120091050863266,
-0.428000807762146,
-0.5112104415893555,
0.4352896511554718,
0.9649094343185425,
0.2735746204853058,
0.3783376216888428,
-0.11161764711141586,
-0.7015835642814636,
-0.5660132169723511,
-0.8866497874259949,
-0.4621869921684265,
0.007032036781311035,
0.46060267090797424,
0.3245570659637451,
0.15008309483528137,
0.608059823513031,
-0.4351472556591034,
-0.28933143615722656,
-0.4066336154937744,
-0.2633458077907562,
-0.4939844012260437,
0.19947366416454315,
0.8311752676963806,
-1.1050803661346436,
-0.78225177526474,
0.06775834411382675,
-0.7874360680580139,
-0.35847461223602295,
0.11206741631031036,
-0.16689366102218628,
0.169526606798172,
0.4870999753475189,
-0.40842124819755554,
0.35480496287345886,
0.4495098888874054,
-0.554279625415802,
0.29897305369377136,
0.22301599383354187,
0.09992510825395584,
-0.7241427302360535,
-0.23497894406318665,
0.05204358696937561,
-0.3669757544994354,
-1.1544629335403442,
0.5119576454162598,
0.006800743751227856,
-0.03680333122611046,
-0.6281248927116394,
0.8233524560928345,
-0.21602797508239746,
0.5419203639030457,
-0.5149412155151367,
0.41348153352737427,
-0.02391425147652626,
0.19835060834884644,
-0.25236523151397705,
0.5043086409568787,
0.5245364308357239,
-0.46237510442733765,
0.22431282699108124,
-0.04731099680066109,
0.08332624286413193,
0.6731869578361511,
-0.43699103593826294,
0.22508953511714935,
-0.057344187051057816,
0.07001172006130219,
-1.0669466257095337,
0.05780201032757759,
0.841917097568512,
-0.622949481010437,
0.7198653221130371,
-0.41099539399147034,
-0.12186813354492188,
-0.3519897162914276,
-0.7145710587501526,
0.16251304745674133,
0.3589719533920288,
-0.7506240606307983,
0.3278305232524872,
0.6614589095115662,
0.1689089983701706,
-1.1062095165252686,
-0.8269984126091003,
0.27932634949684143,
-0.552338182926178,
-0.7874163389205933,
0.349712073802948,
0.29788386821746826,
-0.31980690360069275,
0.03014044649899006,
-0.038832757622003555,
-0.27760034799575806,
0.4697685241699219,
-0.0733611062169075,
0.04593699425458908,
-0.18500101566314697,
-0.3832797706127167,
-0.27740979194641113,
-0.008112125098705292,
0.0530996136367321,
-0.4596967399120331,
0.5306071043014526,
0.10366445779800415,
-0.22741298377513885,
-0.5133951306343079,
0.4174634516239166,
0.40322861075401306,
-0.045542147010564804,
0.7611724734306335,
0.7566034197807312,
-0.405981183052063,
-0.3483884036540985,
-0.4004683494567871,
-0.21370908617973328,
-0.5494617223739624,
0.531211793422699,
-0.06008676439523697,
-0.5501238107681274,
0.3729366958141327,
0.15844029188156128,
0.061256807297468185,
0.1260196715593338,
0.22866012156009674,
-0.2877017557621002,
0.9075270295143127,
0.3553270101547241,
-0.3275540769100189,
0.7294087409973145,
-0.035475440323352814,
0.49547916650772095,
-0.5612272620201111,
-0.11822318285703659,
-0.511606752872467,
-0.37402504682540894,
-0.6114223599433899,
-0.28268706798553467,
-0.3065717816352844,
0.36183464527130127,
-0.25004705786705017,
0.3601986765861511,
-0.13975392282009125,
0.6725190877914429,
0.1377267688512802,
0.029974570497870445,
-0.0796440914273262,
0.181246817111969,
0.11171268671751022,
-0.022000374272465706,
-0.6249706745147705,
-0.4848637580871582,
0.9176820516586304,
0.3230125308036804,
0.7060632109642029,
0.2707448899745941,
0.7855224609375,
0.37371453642845154,
0.11509579420089722,
-0.6408587694168091,
0.49844890832901,
-0.6876829266548157,
-0.5009672045707703,
-0.357909232378006,
-0.4528321325778961,
-1.0874706506729126,
0.4531053602695465,
-0.07513643801212311,
-0.818673312664032,
-0.14261141419410706,
0.11689336597919464,
0.09638801217079163,
0.7088009715080261,
-0.8898634314537048,
0.6750770211219788,
-0.13008423149585724,
0.06968019902706146,
0.23505710065364838,
-0.13196803629398346,
0.5747620463371277,
-0.25000685453414917,
0.37097686529159546,
0.22378981113433838,
-0.31274375319480896,
0.634134829044342,
-0.4357760548591614,
0.8128831386566162,
-0.4702136218547821,
0.27403634786605835,
0.3927667737007141,
0.2766939103603363,
0.7591860890388489,
-0.2882983684539795,
0.06916293501853943,
0.13490691781044006,
-0.441290020942688,
-0.5639477372169495,
-0.5303515195846558,
0.6648548245429993,
-0.6276954412460327,
-0.48021960258483887,
-0.10888662189245224,
-0.2008008360862732,
0.25422489643096924,
0.24456265568733215,
0.3607555031776428,
-0.07420910894870758,
-0.26321738958358765,
-0.0949169397354126,
0.5657793283462524,
-0.12643004953861237,
0.7027776837348938,
0.30792367458343506,
-0.19149912893772125,
-0.4191558361053467,
1.1459919214248657,
0.0921160951256752,
0.20795337855815887,
0.17927230894565582,
0.43367281556129456,
-0.5191828012466431,
-0.630228579044342,
-0.5931993126869202,
0.0310551505535841,
-0.46453267335891724,
-0.23953020572662354,
-0.7675479054450989,
-0.3385739326477051,
-0.38366934657096863,
-0.2805601954460144,
-0.44443172216415405,
-0.3082517683506012,
-0.07866012305021286,
0.1547190099954605,
0.24588985741138458,
0.6580068469047546,
0.08766788244247437,
0.6753387451171875,
-0.6117963194847107,
0.2652621865272522,
0.19773367047309875,
0.08009741455316544,
0.010026019997894764,
-0.5838198065757751,
-0.1140194684267044,
0.025440668687224388,
-0.48504671454429626,
-1.0791133642196655,
0.6519320607185364,
0.20575889945030212,
0.792402982711792,
0.7022784352302551,
0.5080377459526062,
0.43314599990844727,
-0.2848878502845764,
0.7132124304771423,
0.2244977355003357,
-0.8891486525535583,
0.622983455657959,
-0.2707269787788391,
-0.00540643697604537,
0.3680438995361328,
0.16927632689476013,
-0.5243324637413025,
-0.5966829657554626,
-0.6740660071372986,
-0.9002758860588074,
0.8852996826171875,
0.4716721475124359,
0.5334553718566895,
-0.11300314962863922,
0.06708985567092896,
-0.33043304085731506,
0.10046039521694183,
-0.827824592590332,
-0.6740373969078064,
-0.34623220562934875,
-0.008217059075832367,
0.11736598610877991,
-0.2174704521894455,
-0.279163122177124,
0.41392022371292114,
0.5948764681816101,
0.145046666264534,
-0.07968155294656754,
-0.20145532488822937,
-0.3315037786960602,
-0.10770999640226364,
0.12108798325061798,
0.3585241734981537,
0.03710484877228737,
0.5183037519454956,
0.16000713407993317,
0.08748083561658859,
-0.7215204238891602,
-0.029192375019192696,
-0.013979626819491386,
-0.39031362533569336,
-0.1040416806936264,
0.3174586296081543,
0.7370971441268921,
0.3539431095123291,
-0.5180494785308838,
0.8252447247505188,
-0.13725587725639343,
0.01100341696292162,
-0.23803992569446564,
0.38134121894836426,
-0.1552245020866394,
0.18870800733566284,
0.17778027057647705,
0.3702796399593353,
0.028370561078190804,
-0.2644139528274536,
0.31954342126846313,
0.5525477528572083,
-0.4976397156715393,
-0.1520717293024063,
0.42480435967445374,
0.14227604866027832,
-0.5422891974449158,
0.4811326265335083,
-0.37463393807411194,
-0.9860122799873352,
0.44664591550827026,
0.7137677669525146,
0.9603729844093323,
-0.6618452668190002,
0.36768531799316406,
0.01454597245901823,
0.37376290559768677,
-0.030018895864486694,
0.19873569905757904,
0.10886013507843018,
-0.8766429424285889,
-0.11911037564277649,
-0.34408676624298096,
-0.052151232957839966,
0.23635095357894897,
-0.4892236292362213,
0.3590218424797058,
-0.6852459907531738,
0.06214126944541931,
-0.0983138456940651,
0.06861678510904312,
-0.32884544134140015,
0.09499421715736389,
0.4666050672531128,
0.7292549014091492,
-0.9213694930076599,
0.5107877254486084,
0.587262749671936,
-0.11737413704395294,
-0.337116539478302,
0.07442346215248108,
0.3640300929546356,
-0.8226835131645203,
0.4419853389263153,
0.0580378994345665,
-0.04751097410917282,
-0.39788496494293213,
-0.4618183970451355,
-0.6052206158638,
0.5105026960372925,
0.418268620967865,
-0.06825204193592072,
0.4113505184650421,
-0.0035154633224010468,
0.32937419414520264,
-0.30989494919776917,
0.173527792096138,
0.5056445002555847,
0.3566015362739563,
0.10217863321304321,
-0.5048844218254089,
0.05340166017413139,
-0.3447689712047577,
-0.24192695319652557,
0.26730799674987793,
-0.5921574234962463,
0.9190821647644043,
-0.015576405450701714,
-0.49853652715682983,
-0.2036801129579544,
0.5124116539955139,
0.24180734157562256,
0.5952631831169128,
0.6519796252250671,
0.5149189233779907,
0.9875956773757935,
-0.04102475568652153,
1.0872502326965332,
-0.08702655881643295,
-0.1150045320391655,
0.8571483492851257,
-0.04623783007264137,
0.8219619989395142,
0.20247310400009155,
-0.1200299859046936,
0.28723371028900146,
0.27719810605049133,
-0.042658865451812744,
0.6134864091873169,
0.44294410943984985,
-0.4827333092689514,
-0.013828874565660954,
-0.03477492183446884,
-0.2584370970726013,
0.6659812927246094,
0.4792269766330719,
-0.3967178463935852,
-0.25542151927948,
-0.07412445545196533,
0.5819299817085266,
0.59129399061203,
-0.4488208293914795,
0.7271714210510254,
0.03437085822224617,
-0.43236473202705383,
0.2847331166267395,
0.23726670444011688,
1.0596840381622314,
-0.5181377530097961,
0.38338813185691833,
-0.20275673270225525,
0.22545310854911804,
-0.37522342801094055,
-0.579378068447113,
0.19484981894493103,
0.32722344994544983,
0.056472450494766235,
-0.005848062224686146,
1.0956283807754517,
-0.2746986746788025,
-0.21827822923660278,
0.47706541419029236,
0.3550812602043152,
0.3361756503582001,
-0.20156405866146088,
-0.9598166346549988,
-0.12711872160434723,
0.06145330145955086,
-0.2992004454135895,
0.7092509269714355,
0.4173375964164734,
-0.11033399403095245,
0.6704764366149902,
0.9254199862480164,
0.27923592925071716,
0.2260148525238037,
0.16924834251403809,
0.9003373980522156,
-0.42066848278045654,
-0.5804752707481384,
-1.2804855108261108,
0.2879965305328369,
-0.417584091424942,
-0.037853438407182693,
0.7517171502113342,
0.3949454426765442,
1.1166203022003174,
0.0729769617319107,
0.8399726152420044,
0.23409198224544525,
0.06578557938337326,
-0.41003862023353577,
1.0800532102584839,
-0.22320233285427094,
0.43140530586242676,
-0.5068128705024719,
-0.5304476022720337,
-0.4021817147731781,
0.6679120659828186,
-0.1492231786251068,
0.3659192621707916,
0.49889475107192993,
0.7043611407279968,
0.12570564448833466,
0.2808104455471039,
0.5138702392578125,
0.1286577582359314,
0.5136653184890747,
0.47176504135131836,
0.8562309145927429,
-0.5784011483192444,
0.842220664024353,
-0.39530178904533386,
-0.23270216584205627,
-0.14878937602043152,
-0.8019846081733704,
-1.1419306993484497,
-0.03608572110533714,
-0.3124220073223114,
-0.5467678308486938,
0.09064996242523193,
0.41099679470062256,
0.6869340538978577,
-0.9350646734237671,
0.05359583720564842,
0.20583990216255188,
0.2024197280406952,
-0.12397395819425583,
-0.23588061332702637,
0.23891040682792664,
-0.6963191032409668,
-0.8275439739227295,
0.5934350490570068,
0.16387969255447388,
0.009357688017189503,
-0.2678409218788147,
-0.22254085540771484,
-0.08715122938156128,
0.2674315869808197,
0.37726181745529175,
0.5165033936500549,
-0.6065036058425903,
-0.08649100363254547,
-0.07561283558607101,
-0.24753345549106598,
-0.32665255665779114,
0.6564390063285828,
-0.7296872735023499,
0.5492513179779053,
0.4276001751422882,
0.720237135887146,
0.01173463836312294,
-0.05621140077710152,
0.40845227241516113,
-0.8975619077682495,
0.22909918427467346,
0.32300865650177,
0.23776085674762726,
0.3039369285106659,
-0.6710801720619202,
0.35352227091789246,
0.25430384278297424,
-0.25453922152519226,
-0.9656409621238708,
0.1585511565208435,
-0.5213068127632141,
-0.5741199254989624,
1.0139591693878174,
-0.6924532055854797,
-0.42624765634536743,
-0.5480645298957825,
-0.21737965941429138,
0.2236853837966919,
-0.4101063907146454,
0.9375700354576111,
0.5876610279083252,
0.12251722812652588,
0.15471568703651428,
-0.4809528887271881,
0.6285828351974487,
0.30010199546813965,
-0.41378575563430786,
0.23719146847724915,
-0.015527917072176933,
0.13748641312122345,
0.09490717202425003,
0.43781623244285583,
-0.27704983949661255,
0.3115003705024719,
0.2606247663497925,
-0.6308853030204773,
-0.34836286306381226,
-0.27861252427101135,
-0.374287873506546,
0.3186764717102051,
-0.3394973874092102,
-0.44057023525238037
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.13313v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.13313v1
|
Polaris: A Safety-focused LLM Constellation Architecture for Healthcare
| 2024-03-20T05:34:03 | 2024-03-20T05:34:03 |
Subhabrata Mukherjee, Paul Gamble, Markel Sanz Ausin, Neel Kant, Kriti Aggarwal, Neha Manjunath, Debajyoti Datta, Zhengliang Liu, Jiayuan Ding, Sophia Busacca, Cezanne Bianco, Swapnil Sharma, Rae Lasko, Michelle Voisard, Sanchay Harneja, Darya Filippova, Gerry Meixiong, Kevin Cha, Amir Youssefi, Meyhaa Buvanesh, Howard Weingram, Sebastian Bierman-Lytle, Harpreet Singh Mangat, Kim Parikh, Saad Godil, Alex Miller
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
We develop Polaris, the first safety-focused LLM constellation for real-time
patient-AI healthcare conversations. Unlike prior LLM works in healthcare
focusing on tasks like question answering, our work specifically focuses on
long multi-turn voice conversations. Our one-trillion parameter constellation
system is composed of several multibillion parameter LLMs as co-operative
agents: a stateful primary agent that focuses on driving an engaging
conversation and several specialist support agents focused on healthcare tasks
performed by nurses to increase safety and reduce hallucinations. We develop a
sophisticated training protocol for iterative co-training of the agents that
optimize for diverse objectives. We train our models on proprietary data,
clinical care plans, healthcare regulatory documents, medical manuals, and
other medical reasoning documents. We align our models to speak like medical
professionals, using organic healthcare conversations and simulated ones
between patient actors and experienced nurses. This allows our system to
express unique capabilities such as rapport building, trust building, empathy
and bedside manner. Finally, we present the first comprehensive clinician
evaluation of an LLM system for healthcare. We recruited over 1100 U.S.
licensed nurses and over 130 U.S. licensed physicians to perform end-to-end
conversational evaluations of our system by posing as patients and rating the
system on several measures. We demonstrate Polaris performs on par with human
nurses on aggregate across dimensions such as medical safety, clinical
readiness, conversational quality, and bedside manner. Additionally, we conduct
a challenging task-based evaluation of the individual specialist support
agents, where we demonstrate our LLM agents significantly outperform a much
larger general-purpose LLM (GPT-4) as well as from its own medium-size class
(LLaMA-2 70B).
|
[
-0.14665448665618896,
-0.23478946089744568,
0.7743965983390808,
0.212211012840271,
-0.37098637223243713,
0.33608290553092957,
0.2479146122932434,
-0.6138563752174377,
0.4264855980873108,
0.7279935479164124,
-0.6991426348686218,
-0.7768043279647827,
-0.47784700989723206,
0.025408368557691574,
-0.00004867218740400858,
1.0600616931915283,
0.4142337143421173,
0.4477350115776062,
-0.3136900067329407,
-0.24436306953430176,
-0.04425756633281708,
-0.7459890842437744,
-0.8411282896995544,
-0.30978697538375854,
0.6699274778366089,
0.3836040198802948,
0.8783072233200073,
0.19259870052337646,
0.630010187625885,
0.28739631175994873,
-0.07153819501399994,
0.12292146682739258,
-0.3654499351978302,
0.35332968831062317,
0.33691006898880005,
-0.4125257432460785,
-0.9606532454490662,
0.04775461181998253,
0.3925651013851166,
0.6516456604003906,
-0.36311057209968567,
0.06687115132808685,
-0.19035598635673523,
0.5846655368804932,
-0.39964380860328674,
0.12638528645038605,
-0.2226155698299408,
0.2149350494146347,
0.24958403408527374,
-0.1253581941127777,
-0.45811304450035095,
-0.3370448350906372,
0.47696080803871155,
-0.7532778382301331,
-0.15285144746303558,
0.19841988384723663,
0.6863236427307129,
0.5357993841171265,
-0.4765142798423767,
-0.25336727499961853,
-0.6581053733825684,
0.6965604424476624,
-0.446310430765152,
0.15558011829853058,
0.07708334177732468,
0.2653357982635498,
0.03982954099774361,
-0.6847853660583496,
-0.2175893485546112,
-0.5515139102935791,
-0.010354035533964634,
0.3888993561267853,
-0.004096588119864464,
0.5471154451370239,
-0.07588599622249603,
0.007127787452191114,
-0.5701775550842285,
0.2244754135608673,
-0.07898210734128952,
-0.14441823959350586,
0.6103137135505676,
0.6572448015213013,
0.12277127802371979,
0.022854449227452278,
-0.5738011598587036,
-0.012250745669007301,
-0.706425130367279,
0.07732988148927689,
-0.10164070874452591,
-0.013076620176434517,
-0.3845849931240082,
0.3296731114387512,
-0.03792504593729973,
0.37938037514686584,
-0.07243863493204117,
-0.29811474680900574,
0.1900278925895691,
-0.14541848003864288,
-0.3787992298603058,
-0.07668352127075195,
0.9359508752822876,
0.5761302709579468,
-0.19441287219524384,
-0.4079265296459198,
-0.08850780129432678,
0.34442275762557983,
0.5507526993751526,
-0.6110772490501404,
0.051917389035224915,
0.42595234513282776,
-0.4639037549495697,
-0.6218997240066528,
-0.0673823356628418,
-0.31160128116607666,
-0.5651248693466187,
-0.3779377341270447,
0.08838578313589096,
-0.08292943239212036,
-0.16600313782691956,
0.16586382687091827,
0.23678192496299744,
0.31993213295936584,
0.2500196397304535,
-0.5116830468177795,
0.46751049160957336,
1.1769131422042847,
0.6553409695625305,
-0.2994276285171509,
-0.020204203203320503,
-0.5852643847465515,
-0.06573756784200668,
-0.46535801887512207,
0.5703451633453369,
-0.07731011509895325,
-0.5340319871902466,
0.0027400017715990543,
0.1263953447341919,
-0.015689251944422722,
-0.7669561505317688,
0.36098551750183105,
-0.4789356589317322,
0.016660835593938828,
-0.25585252046585083,
-0.25093570351600647,
0.12871351838111877,
0.4440878927707672,
-0.3122251033782959,
0.2849278151988983,
0.18050485849380493,
-0.4275462329387665,
0.500815749168396,
-0.7505096197128296,
-0.32922548055648804,
0.42736849188804626,
-0.42300766706466675,
-0.7677339911460876,
-0.1759723573923111,
-0.1471632719039917,
0.5357736945152283,
-0.6445146799087524,
0.29512345790863037,
-0.10116799920797348,
-0.25680169463157654,
0.32964321970939636,
-0.03534828498959541,
0.768497109413147,
0.15349337458610535,
-0.28716298937797546,
0.5812917351722717,
-0.49898862838745117,
0.02974684350192547,
-0.005000243429094553,
-0.20681028068065643,
-0.011581683531403542,
0.024632573127746582,
-0.10409323126077652,
0.019853223115205765,
0.120402030646801,
-0.7912868857383728,
-0.20528492331504822,
-0.39748600125312805,
0.32126137614250183,
0.5793659687042236,
0.0868045911192894,
0.5428419709205627,
-0.7592359185218811,
0.723260223865509,
0.08505311608314514,
1.1196929216384888,
0.17754213511943817,
-0.7387789487838745,
-0.9394738078117371,
-0.5300924777984619,
-0.39568573236465454,
0.8713619112968445,
-0.7201970219612122,
0.410138875246048,
-0.037250369787216187,
-0.3785162568092346,
-0.5572330951690674,
-0.04253138229250908,
0.46025997400283813,
0.7307711243629456,
0.07064399868249893,
-0.2251683473587036,
-0.29436635971069336,
-1.036473035812378,
0.25283804535865784,
-0.4591274857521057,
0.035863012075424194,
0.6149099469184875,
0.07068051397800446,
-0.6778109073638916,
0.7691546678543091,
-0.2036462277173996,
-0.3210340440273285,
-0.329807847738266,
-0.038225091993808746,
0.33163729310035706,
0.27304860949516296,
0.35387948155403137,
-0.5982949137687683,
-0.48389381170272827,
-0.2626674473285675,
-1.110440969467163,
0.17416499555110931,
-0.2022838443517685,
-0.03225787729024887,
0.2424793541431427,
0.23871541023254395,
-0.6641467213630676,
0.2318171113729477,
0.7052813768386841,
-0.6292980909347534,
0.2860014736652374,
-0.18775275349617004,
0.025538861751556396,
-1.2341653108596802,
0.17410658299922943,
-0.0649130716919899,
-0.17148526012897491,
-1.0232772827148438,
-0.09155598282814026,
-0.3444911539554596,
-0.29292401671409607,
-0.5818135738372803,
0.18414096534252167,
-0.3810577094554901,
-0.05130661651492119,
-0.13196173310279846,
-0.029879987239837646,
-0.05214960128068924,
0.24202170968055725,
-0.02963956445455551,
0.7337732315063477,
0.738351047039032,
-0.49613574147224426,
0.47842860221862793,
0.5558747053146362,
-0.07998108863830566,
0.755469799041748,
-0.7674014568328857,
0.4045834243297577,
0.02252322994172573,
0.06848648190498352,
-0.6013444066047668,
0.06428320705890656,
0.40191277861595154,
-0.2303774207830429,
0.016821376979351044,
0.013038073666393757,
-0.032121773809194565,
-0.26330822706222534,
-0.12795764207839966,
0.15944091975688934,
0.5447578430175781,
-0.16032011806964874,
0.6854766011238098,
0.7024142146110535,
-0.544181227684021,
-0.6338467597961426,
-0.3793659806251526,
0.5880599021911621,
-0.07755272835493088,
-0.7923568487167358,
-0.00019752915250137448,
-0.23292766511440277,
-0.5350351929664612,
-0.32125014066696167,
0.1264166682958603,
0.09673276543617249,
0.34940120577812195,
0.7433954477310181,
0.8159703612327576,
-0.256859689950943,
0.003501435974612832,
0.056364528834819794,
-0.5420966744422913,
0.31444939970970154,
-0.11416368186473846,
0.3133388161659241,
-0.672534704208374,
-0.585668683052063,
-0.9128955006599426,
0.541156530380249,
0.9451083540916443,
0.2349708527326584,
0.8668439984321594,
0.2393467277288437,
-0.01297377236187458,
0.14359647035598755,
-0.7468541264533997,
-0.5105863213539124,
-0.4698430299758911,
0.12392726540565491,
-0.037857457995414734,
-0.983822226524353,
0.5304147005081177,
0.02533804625272751,
0.3493419885635376,
0.11390341818332672,
0.36737820506095886,
-0.16168032586574554,
0.9786151051521301,
0.5808847546577454,
-0.12241260707378387,
0.07079946994781494,
-0.25129249691963196,
0.10584057122468948,
-0.6995072364807129,
-0.6313512921333313,
-0.24953904747962952,
-0.1835835576057434,
-0.5182974338531494,
-0.42140522599220276,
1.047898530960083,
-0.635999321937561,
-0.4043276906013489,
0.09555076062679291,
-0.7704173922538757,
-0.08863575756549835,
0.41796553134918213,
0.2602055072784424,
0.24541407823562622,
-0.28243371844291687,
0.0930175855755806,
0.02301710657775402,
-0.6640343070030212,
-0.5962331295013428,
1.0691970586776733,
0.7022303938865662,
0.8820115923881531,
0.04979602247476578,
0.7782085537910461,
0.16210190951824188,
0.7682960033416748,
-0.75454181432724,
0.8176118731498718,
-0.27705293893814087,
-0.3856118321418762,
-0.3013165593147278,
-0.3796173930168152,
-0.7970721125602722,
0.1526295691728592,
-0.5694700479507446,
0.01883555017411709,
0.03035258688032627,
-0.010427871719002724,
-0.832192063331604,
0.002850144635885954,
-0.4491366744041443,
0.5134868025779724,
-0.5603920817375183,
-0.2706669270992279,
-0.18500563502311707,
-0.9467167258262634,
-0.011642906814813614,
0.2686760425567627,
-0.08032537996768951,
-0.18147845566272736,
-0.40995243191719055,
0.4698832631111145,
-0.25599876046180725,
1.068501591682434,
-0.12480132281780243,
0.11896584928035736,
0.22262121737003326,
-0.03744831308722496,
0.21697847545146942,
0.36662089824676514,
0.021550871431827545,
0.6711718440055847,
0.018412098288536072,
-0.2385687381029129,
-0.3236032724380493,
0.5949410796165466,
-1.095934271812439,
-0.6573776602745056,
-0.6590477824211121,
-0.4528951346874237,
-0.2495412826538086,
-0.14842547476291656,
0.007350125350058079,
0.3490312397480011,
-0.3838793635368347,
0.12588027119636536,
0.6955606937408447,
-0.2587226331233978,
0.15042199194431305,
0.9016922116279602,
0.1342836618423462,
-0.8025762438774109,
0.6197144985198975,
-0.3838144540786743,
0.3574531376361847,
0.21187816560268402,
0.04096192121505737,
-0.1344977468252182,
-0.6041412353515625,
-0.42103660106658936,
0.45360252261161804,
-0.5384675860404968,
-0.09474169462919235,
-0.8583888411521912,
-0.5794899463653564,
-0.3608698546886444,
-0.3654702603816986,
-0.37926217913627625,
-0.10815399885177612,
-0.6317846179008484,
-0.009651243686676025,
-0.060425177216529846,
1.068877935409546,
0.2388235628604889,
0.4411148428916931,
-0.7435398697853088,
0.2519281804561615,
0.5596288442611694,
0.23424434661865234,
-0.70088130235672,
-0.11723005771636963,
0.015374042093753815,
-0.34820646047592163,
-0.17532725632190704,
-0.6864418387413025,
0.42972567677497864,
-0.07255345582962036,
0.7492768168449402,
0.6023443341255188,
0.16274496912956238,
0.08258599042892456,
-0.274181991815567,
0.9206863045692444,
0.6785134673118591,
-0.6313308477401733,
0.2592405676841736,
-0.19373373687267303,
-0.1328817456960678,
0.6272590160369873,
0.1528341919183731,
-0.6290805339813232,
-0.41592976450920105,
-0.5777549743652344,
-0.7002524137496948,
0.5094597935676575,
0.07261412590742111,
-0.09214549511671066,
-0.0947452038526535,
0.760249674320221,
-0.08737657219171524,
0.3066386878490448,
-0.52717524766922,
-0.23235687613487244,
0.04885963350534439,
-0.3983137309551239,
-0.2717989683151245,
-0.36057624220848083,
-0.7951676845550537,
0.16812409460544586,
0.5290853977203369,
-0.40407660603523254,
0.41169294714927673,
0.41396430134773254,
0.20674492418766022,
-0.2648315727710724,
0.3284124732017517,
0.9097204208374023,
0.5753882527351379,
-0.03458835557103157,
0.0008182242163456976,
0.31883057951927185,
-0.6537496447563171,
0.1327173113822937,
0.004250845871865749,
0.023125482723116875,
-0.14225289225578308,
0.2503282129764557,
0.7583601474761963,
0.16154442727565765,
-0.6618067622184753,
0.672660768032074,
-0.41260623931884766,
-0.1785997599363327,
-0.693432629108429,
0.11171091347932816,
0.07531886547803879,
0.4304966330528259,
0.15954644978046417,
0.23217542469501495,
0.11875131726264954,
-0.43894731998443604,
0.37558549642562866,
0.7838197350502014,
-0.8073251843452454,
-0.19304651021957397,
0.611763596534729,
0.5687342286109924,
-0.5272749066352844,
0.49822941422462463,
0.2579427659511566,
-0.36282452940940857,
0.8304956555366516,
0.17359860241413116,
1.0459469556808472,
-0.24897518754005432,
0.5643444657325745,
-0.04059264063835144,
0.4339003562927246,
0.08820898830890656,
0.43449628353118896,
0.06848637014627457,
-0.5739731192588806,
-0.2072182595729828,
-0.35337013006210327,
-1.1161843538284302,
-0.09387727826833725,
-0.6322658061981201,
0.06642972677946091,
-0.9322368502616882,
-0.6162242293357849,
-0.3135294020175934,
0.07769870012998581,
-0.34904009103775024,
0.13553129136562347,
0.46444010734558105,
0.7613404989242554,
-0.6968405842781067,
0.40931475162506104,
0.9221133589744568,
-0.01613464578986168,
-0.6871050000190735,
-0.3250753581523895,
-0.009557587094604969,
-1.191416621208191,
0.573907196521759,
0.04652923718094826,
-0.36511898040771484,
-0.34372633695602417,
-0.5002686977386475,
-0.38249972462654114,
1.5558462142944336,
0.4456886947154999,
-0.8349059224128723,
-0.05216154828667641,
0.48259371519088745,
0.7732694149017334,
-0.8065855503082275,
0.24042636156082153,
0.2719991207122803,
0.08803106099367142,
0.2214038372039795,
-0.9123380184173584,
0.06939607858657837,
-0.14499209821224213,
-0.30027979612350464,
-0.242113396525383,
-0.9224883317947388,
0.7993103265762329,
-0.5464111566543579,
-0.0868614912033081,
0.40110889077186584,
0.2765459716320038,
0.3582148253917694,
0.812175452709198,
0.7846587300300598,
0.570062518119812,
0.743660569190979,
-0.17738912999629974,
1.038882851600647,
-0.6700534224510193,
0.015571902506053448,
0.7459955215454102,
-0.6248924732208252,
0.489149272441864,
0.49820947647094727,
0.252095103263855,
0.6727522611618042,
0.3210318982601166,
0.3965564966201782,
0.3961957097053528,
-0.045661553740501404,
-0.8604059219360352,
-0.6105996966362,
-0.23553837835788727,
-0.24606698751449585,
0.12322162836790085,
0.43209847807884216,
-0.3642483651638031,
0.30737462639808655,
0.23651619255542755,
0.020759500563144684,
-0.2626100778579712,
0.025299416854977608,
1.3073906898498535,
0.4664604067802429,
-0.7729783058166504,
0.3851472735404968,
-0.5314978957176208,
0.37327414751052856,
-0.729304850101471,
0.10909512639045715,
-0.08531702309846878,
0.3878777027130127,
-0.09662485867738724,
-0.6373626589775085,
0.0635567307472229,
-0.3306735157966614,
0.05050075799226761,
-0.4464860260486603,
0.4594722390174866,
-0.12940306961536407,
-0.20945319533348083,
0.47265926003456116,
0.33809971809387207,
0.08291766792535782,
0.0678633525967598,
-0.9986034631729126,
0.155745267868042,
-0.3082069456577301,
0.04960922524333,
0.2743324339389801,
-0.15417398512363434,
0.2888353168964386,
1.0309315919876099,
0.7025642991065979,
0.2316424548625946,
-0.16885069012641907,
0.32880499958992004,
1.092143177986145,
-0.556302011013031,
-0.6921680569648743,
-0.3526678681373596,
0.5654157400131226,
-0.15734219551086426,
-0.34092676639556885,
0.24747581779956818,
0.3763013184070587,
-0.21395443379878998,
0.07981505244970322,
0.7117062211036682,
0.43028202652931213,
0.5780861377716064,
-0.131207674741745,
0.9649717807769775,
-0.4818314015865326,
0.384234219789505,
0.21582220494747162,
-0.49364152550697327,
-0.3552611470222473,
0.46843472123146057,
-0.2679854929447174,
-0.3642607033252716,
0.48829561471939087,
0.9190439581871033,
0.5051665306091309,
0.20358943939208984,
0.7029082179069519,
0.26281508803367615,
0.6707720160484314,
0.6853662729263306,
1.1319140195846558,
-0.2602285146713257,
0.42570096254348755,
-0.12595368921756744,
-0.6242334842681885,
-0.26063475012779236,
-0.5326529741287231,
-0.9655181765556335,
-0.16669924557209015,
-0.49004673957824707,
-0.5635741353034973,
0.3320135772228241,
0.9586360454559326,
0.9707047939300537,
-0.8366618156433105,
-0.15657192468643188,
-0.06526418775320053,
-0.02677100896835327,
-0.04639127478003502,
-0.12492980808019638,
-0.0812319964170456,
-0.29128798842430115,
-0.24316191673278809,
0.7065940499305725,
0.8335010409355164,
0.002182618947699666,
-0.6133764982223511,
-0.5196861624717712,
0.3638121783733368,
0.10725221037864685,
0.4658195674419403,
0.24176213145256042,
-0.5653937458992004,
-0.276364266872406,
0.43778541684150696,
-0.6035146117210388,
0.0707542672753334,
0.8419128656387329,
-0.5132239460945129,
0.2940538227558136,
0.11041519790887833,
0.559048056602478,
0.12257742136716843,
-0.08314806967973709,
0.2880359888076782,
-0.12175573408603668,
0.281620055437088,
0.8873022794723511,
0.1797359585762024,
0.26990145444869995,
-0.8153550624847412,
0.2110062837600708,
0.2928753197193146,
-1.0048892498016357,
-0.629315197467804,
0.2180023044347763,
-1.3975493907928467,
0.12032744288444519,
0.9720286726951599,
-0.36812642216682434,
-0.02317832224071026,
-0.522742509841919,
-0.09782423824071884,
0.05791826918721199,
-0.3463759422302246,
0.7809547185897827,
-0.1494426131248474,
-0.4756237864494324,
-0.1580488532781601,
-0.3653855323791504,
0.47073784470558167,
0.7088240385055542,
-0.8638256192207336,
-0.40122899413108826,
0.3366994857788086,
0.5404579639434814,
0.35634106397628784,
0.8348380327224731,
-0.1216065064072609,
0.48107579350471497,
-0.22360123693943024,
0.06652741134166718,
-0.10908510535955429,
-0.4841172397136688,
-0.3709210753440857,
0.376620888710022,
0.009052254259586334,
-0.38448140025138855
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.13312v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.13312v1
|
LeanReasoner: Boosting Complex Logical Reasoning with Lean
| 2024-03-20T05:29:06 | 2024-03-20T05:29:06 |
Dongwei Jiang, Marcio Fonseca, Shay B. Cohen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) often struggle with complex logical reasoning
due to logical inconsistencies and the inherent difficulty of such reasoning.
We use Lean, a theorem proving framework, to address these challenges. By
formalizing logical reasoning problems into theorems within Lean, we can solve
them by proving or disproving the corresponding theorems. This method reduces
the risk of logical inconsistencies with the help of Lean's symbolic solver. It
also enhances our ability to treat complex reasoning tasks by using Lean's
extensive library of theorem proofs. Our method achieves state-of-the-art
performance on the FOLIO dataset and achieves performance near this level on
ProofWriter. Notably, these results were accomplished by fine-tuning on fewer
than 100 in-domain samples for each dataset.
|
[
-0.0018166744848713279,
-0.5122506022453308,
0.46751832962036133,
0.07468073070049286,
-0.055707793682813644,
0.06635259091854095,
-0.043473437428474426,
-0.4251064360141754,
-0.1614024043083191,
0.4498777389526367,
-0.893714189529419,
-0.4758963882923126,
-0.4895867109298706,
0.040248602628707886,
-0.41444286704063416,
0.8472046256065369,
-0.3566942512989044,
0.3596265912055969,
-0.21653735637664795,
-0.18776017427444458,
-0.15839774906635284,
-0.23515889048576355,
-0.4618188142776489,
-0.44617676734924316,
0.057714372873306274,
0.6356600522994995,
0.7697436213493347,
0.6849995255470276,
0.6432662606239319,
0.3906760811805725,
0.010613545775413513,
0.0610521174967289,
-0.6469531059265137,
0.5744338631629944,
-0.24065591394901276,
-0.8687764406204224,
-0.3736627399921417,
-0.3987385928630829,
0.2600768804550171,
0.6133087873458862,
-0.05085887759923935,
0.08224889636039734,
-0.3791024088859558,
0.6167606115341187,
-0.7292968034744263,
0.15222764015197754,
-0.7684033513069153,
0.2528836727142334,
-0.11590950191020966,
-0.12239319086074829,
-0.2600753605365753,
-0.6784279942512512,
-0.007781842723488808,
-0.7451614737510681,
0.28169873356819153,
0.18415766954421997,
0.9454823136329651,
0.696304976940155,
-0.2945006191730499,
-0.41090884804725647,
-0.763730525970459,
0.8788058161735535,
-0.7712420225143433,
0.41218486428260803,
0.09409085661172867,
0.4632989466190338,
-0.2463523894548416,
-0.7984356880187988,
-0.7052969932556152,
-0.08220592886209488,
0.2894105911254883,
0.017910903319716454,
0.050438590347766876,
0.16331493854522705,
0.7399907112121582,
0.5007532238960266,
-0.507615864276886,
0.009922554716467857,
-0.2058640569448471,
-0.4153580069541931,
0.6758224368095398,
0.41991904377937317,
0.2903580367565155,
0.14003528654575348,
-0.3120257556438446,
-0.15774936974048615,
-0.7528895735740662,
0.04195619374513626,
-0.0249320175498724,
-0.08379920572042465,
0.40318554639816284,
0.9549931287765503,
-0.36280202865600586,
0.6019713878631592,
0.07711348682641983,
-0.8639807105064392,
0.177830770611763,
-0.326015442609787,
-0.47622087597846985,
0.2556341290473938,
0.42934855818748474,
0.33766329288482666,
0.6050860285758972,
0.10916773229837418,
-0.36272746324539185,
0.09954569488763809,
-0.3427703082561493,
-1.2131215333938599,
-0.27887019515037537,
0.46115294098854065,
-0.4294786751270294,
-0.2070273756980896,
0.08559437096118927,
-0.37978166341781616,
-0.6809555292129517,
-0.5299476981163025,
0.28691041469573975,
-0.5917138457298279,
-0.20009461045265198,
0.5396934747695923,
-0.4286036491394043,
0.4826667308807373,
0.6265901327133179,
-0.466509610414505,
0.2358318567276001,
0.7791290879249573,
0.36691465973854065,
0.21101114153862,
-0.3491639792919159,
-0.7404486536979675,
0.4034430980682373,
-0.40411388874053955,
0.8903090953826904,
-0.2177768498659134,
0.21639080345630646,
0.23653483390808105,
-0.18356569111347198,
0.15485019981861115,
-0.8139058351516724,
1.2169831991195679,
-0.1753661185503006,
0.04411616548895836,
-0.47701799869537354,
-0.8668636679649353,
0.03061271458864212,
0.3834972381591797,
-0.49700450897216797,
1.0026262998580933,
0.13218843936920166,
-0.7791576981544495,
0.7356129884719849,
-0.2748849391937256,
-0.7483299374580383,
-0.0010493549052625895,
-0.12929867208003998,
-0.34044089913368225,
0.21027448773384094,
0.16497844457626343,
0.7483197450637817,
-0.6411349177360535,
0.2380019724369049,
-0.4214026629924774,
-0.264457643032074,
0.29081329703330994,
-0.025143882259726524,
0.843325138092041,
0.33548295497894287,
-0.4047200381755829,
0.30852964520454407,
-0.926631510257721,
0.3660149872303009,
0.04756629839539528,
-0.31376132369041443,
-0.2874004542827606,
0.18535172939300537,
-0.09037202596664429,
0.3549080193042755,
-0.014986097812652588,
-0.5207595229148865,
0.3335510194301605,
-0.3887141942977905,
0.4390203654766083,
0.5583459138870239,
-0.24835574626922607,
0.12230666726827621,
-0.46073469519615173,
0.4857803285121918,
0.34661445021629333,
-0.17873454093933105,
-0.13078534603118896,
-0.28209009766578674,
-1.0714043378829956,
-0.7930965423583984,
0.049448683857917786,
0.8891662359237671,
-0.6422821879386902,
0.3731840252876282,
-0.12443134933710098,
-0.41254010796546936,
-0.6153584122657776,
0.45150673389434814,
0.22641432285308838,
0.6311109066009521,
0.5662260055541992,
0.5346612930297852,
-0.5948001146316528,
-0.800563395023346,
-0.6628118753433228,
-0.14867651462554932,
-0.3421197831630707,
-0.15210090577602386,
0.4869665205478668,
-0.5801219940185547,
1.002941608428955,
-0.8461185693740845,
-0.2982630133628845,
-0.5469805598258972,
0.07148831337690353,
0.24804966151714325,
0.38784289360046387,
0.35896769165992737,
-0.5944488048553467,
-0.21581648290157318,
-0.18894730508327484,
-0.9165844321250916,
-0.2897326350212097,
-0.19767975807189941,
-0.04873030260205269,
0.22078937292099,
0.8431549668312073,
-0.8547776937484741,
0.3152998089790344,
0.007407634984701872,
-0.5685698986053467,
0.7766693830490112,
0.20249049365520477,
0.02259497530758381,
-1.129913568496704,
-0.35876086354255676,
0.17404906451702118,
-0.4864569902420044,
-0.3576931655406952,
0.04639881104230881,
-0.21280817687511444,
-0.22889044880867004,
-0.16003809869289398,
0.3055233955383301,
-0.3161437213420868,
0.32170403003692627,
0.06626666337251663,
0.012356128543615341,
0.18574868142604828,
-0.014488907530903816,
-0.036143526434898376,
0.26314350962638855,
0.6339271068572998,
-0.4797123074531555,
0.5884793400764465,
0.0008674787823110819,
-0.4032883048057556,
0.8420557975769043,
-0.9788351058959961,
-0.42176616191864014,
-0.27272602915763855,
0.2710421085357666,
-1.1544768810272217,
-0.3773137629032135,
0.08926111459732056,
-0.13005214929580688,
0.3529919981956482,
-0.08815141767263412,
-0.5279031991958618,
-0.37902331352233887,
-0.36055824160575867,
0.1362353414297104,
0.1816394031047821,
-0.5877962708473206,
0.7958868145942688,
0.2150275707244873,
-0.03618842735886574,
-0.6748374700546265,
-0.7629417181015015,
-0.16778510808944702,
-0.19868794083595276,
-1.0895756483078003,
0.10938706248998642,
-0.2658863365650177,
-0.7733466029167175,
-0.11135454475879669,
-0.4038558900356293,
-0.360714852809906,
-0.0447714701294899,
0.04937521740794182,
0.14968152344226837,
-0.4405485987663269,
0.05061621591448784,
0.24530792236328125,
-0.2498398721218109,
0.2770538926124573,
-0.6116578578948975,
0.07125110179185867,
-0.3919652998447418,
-0.4636390507221222,
-0.5652657747268677,
0.25262361764907837,
0.9004182815551758,
-0.08527485281229019,
0.6745209097862244,
0.5698202848434448,
-0.6689537167549133,
-0.7463372349739075,
-0.6199750304222107,
-0.14271287620067596,
-0.4716847836971283,
0.4845781624317169,
-0.6572502255439758,
-1.0049095153808594,
0.5048540830612183,
-0.4568203389644623,
0.17241474986076355,
0.4692261517047882,
0.7050207853317261,
-0.15271224081516266,
0.8625478148460388,
0.44904157519340515,
0.12093629688024521,
-0.031881820410490036,
-0.209490105509758,
0.3969663679599762,
-0.11691660434007645,
-0.46585893630981445,
-0.7984474301338196,
-0.1765516847372055,
-0.34879428148269653,
-0.6671452522277832,
0.006330388598144054,
0.4485010802745819,
-0.4516894221305847,
0.18127252161502838,
-0.42629629373550415,
0.6244877576828003,
0.15785357356071472,
-0.15899871289730072,
0.5703664422035217,
-0.11981331557035446,
-0.2854250967502594,
-0.41671693325042725,
-0.7781950235366821,
-0.21428954601287842,
0.6853199601173401,
0.40224042534828186,
1.267529845237732,
0.16733093559741974,
0.47983264923095703,
-0.07673145830631256,
0.3208959102630615,
-1.3042428493499756,
0.6901159286499023,
0.06070936843752861,
-0.7016396522521973,
-0.21153634786605835,
-0.7508469820022583,
-0.2316960096359253,
0.2817502021789551,
-0.3736130893230438,
-0.2990145683288574,
0.23392069339752197,
0.1589578539133072,
0.17323234677314758,
0.2577546536922455,
-0.7107471227645874,
0.8980176448822021,
-0.30871254205703735,
-0.37845608592033386,
-0.20190367102622986,
-0.4744204878807068,
0.6698667407035828,
0.25704723596572876,
0.04669802635908127,
-0.18511320650577545,
-0.04525379091501236,
0.5705480575561523,
-0.9917523264884949,
0.6127490997314453,
-0.09315209090709686,
-0.26275378465652466,
0.4156759977340698,
0.31487390398979187,
0.4544656276702881,
0.15212079882621765,
-0.12230341881513596,
-0.32164546847343445,
0.17317770421504974,
-0.33440208435058594,
-0.6240700483322144,
0.6687456965446472,
-0.6736800074577332,
-0.40783974528312683,
-0.6419070959091187,
-0.7597979307174683,
-0.38262224197387695,
0.5404443144798279,
0.3198557198047638,
0.45557475090026855,
0.030340101569890976,
0.24208912253379822,
1.1356502771377563,
0.15794548392295837,
0.11730846017599106,
0.3145328760147095,
-0.11871722340583801,
-0.5506069660186768,
0.7077874541282654,
0.03131454810500145,
0.20977431535720825,
0.5876525640487671,
0.33077460527420044,
-0.3888116776943207,
-0.567512035369873,
-0.22233346104621887,
0.28182870149612427,
-1.1923493146896362,
-0.5371285676956177,
-0.3646319508552551,
-0.09960939735174179,
-0.31222572922706604,
-0.41396141052246094,
-0.5318924188613892,
-0.8931881189346313,
0.14673174917697906,
-0.1282985806465149,
0.2991688549518585,
0.526177704334259,
0.34272125363349915,
-0.18938298523426056,
-0.5790504217147827,
0.6015125513076782,
0.33782991766929626,
0.2599760591983795,
-0.3230169117450714,
-0.38599497079849243,
-0.12104430794715881,
-0.2043999880552292,
-0.1581936776638031,
-0.6551969051361084,
-0.024105675518512726,
0.2656734883785248,
0.5192920565605164,
0.7659035325050354,
0.357418954372406,
1.0148204565048218,
-0.2590947151184082,
0.2669157087802887,
0.26796698570251465,
-1.2661058902740479,
0.5696898698806763,
-0.32757368683815,
0.3613728880882263,
0.8422499299049377,
0.6211471557617188,
-0.0419016107916832,
-0.2559891939163208,
-0.3482494056224823,
-0.909343421459198,
0.2806481122970581,
0.03891492635011673,
-0.4591689109802246,
0.4523705840110779,
0.4870367646217346,
-0.24849043786525726,
0.16643741726875305,
-0.7503576278686523,
-0.05524874106049538,
-0.4890805184841156,
-0.5327932238578796,
0.41463467478752136,
-0.2642248868942261,
-0.38735097646713257,
-0.6355899572372437,
0.7366801500320435,
-0.4120689034461975,
-0.12100550532341003,
0.45981377363204956,
-0.2204645425081253,
-0.2717130780220032,
0.2939051389694214,
0.4791606366634369,
0.9545442461967468,
-0.038327254354953766,
0.14782604575157166,
0.14340421557426453,
-0.40623900294303894,
0.2192917764186859,
0.2692645788192749,
-0.19372472167015076,
-0.090382419526577,
0.7344837784767151,
0.49239107966423035,
-0.015943650156259537,
-1.1915812492370605,
0.45263954997062683,
-0.16406236588954926,
-0.5118927359580994,
-0.26668527722358704,
0.34951990842819214,
0.25960296392440796,
0.2813522219657898,
0.31368905305862427,
0.3959301710128784,
0.17540492117404938,
-0.5089772939682007,
0.10670110583305359,
0.3146451413631439,
-0.3887227475643158,
0.0042931390926241875,
0.7148354649543762,
-0.07684264332056046,
0.031435102224349976,
0.6970502138137817,
0.024887969717383385,
-0.7222278118133545,
0.5277531743049622,
0.8428476452827454,
0.9133442640304565,
-0.002186834579333663,
0.013401356525719166,
0.4269174337387085,
0.4123113751411438,
-0.24904951453208923,
0.42553386092185974,
0.011960767209529877,
-0.8407055735588074,
-0.6665303707122803,
-0.6998012661933899,
-0.572293758392334,
-0.11461454629898071,
-0.4388701617717743,
0.5243747234344482,
-0.6767325401306152,
0.31323549151420593,
-0.09692416340112686,
0.07387720048427582,
-0.44127529859542847,
0.38405677676200867,
-0.08756820857524872,
1.2580639123916626,
-0.707064151763916,
0.6389749646186829,
0.8032230138778687,
-0.19827036559581757,
-1.1884561777114868,
0.23826588690280914,
0.231876939535141,
-0.40738874673843384,
0.6713311672210693,
0.19423823058605194,
-0.6369284391403198,
-0.24143752455711365,
-0.5664164423942566,
-0.5326560735702515,
1.1983987092971802,
0.7746824026107788,
-0.5901362895965576,
0.4055194854736328,
0.20884521305561066,
0.4607982337474823,
-0.46076682209968567,
0.04361031576991081,
0.4420740008354187,
0.5370606184005737,
0.7773135900497437,
-0.3906654119491577,
0.28371721506118774,
-0.22540512681007385,
-0.3074491024017334,
0.08144895732402802,
-0.43198224902153015,
0.7693179845809937,
-0.6946726441383362,
0.11877405643463135,
-0.08406496047973633,
0.9925367832183838,
0.7370591759681702,
0.41371920704841614,
0.5020764470100403,
0.9721848368644714,
1.324830174446106,
-0.2882685661315918,
0.9388800263404846,
0.014172705821692944,
0.15856650471687317,
0.9550737142562866,
-0.7363771200180054,
0.6981783509254456,
0.3315751552581787,
-0.02764657884836197,
0.6693784594535828,
0.3640731871128082,
0.1261049509048462,
-0.004643063992261887,
0.4728895127773285,
-0.23077940940856934,
-0.6409850120544434,
-0.09738177061080933,
-0.3593350052833557,
0.3170149028301239,
0.3480224907398224,
0.026404960080981255,
0.09142748266458511,
-0.29886701703071594,
0.5634678602218628,
0.05297032743692398,
-0.3726262152194977,
0.44300585985183716,
0.11104973405599594,
-0.7534422278404236,
0.8039762377738953,
0.05779583379626274,
0.2774950861930847,
-0.7794839143753052,
0.032774362713098526,
-0.08604316413402557,
0.9845452904701233,
-0.5835979580879211,
-0.7051166892051697,
0.4198969304561615,
-0.07147948443889618,
-0.33450809121131897,
-0.25745707750320435,
1.020444631576538,
-0.3713494539260864,
-0.7653650045394897,
0.10450368374586105,
0.38410553336143494,
-0.30725181102752686,
0.13248740136623383,
-0.7440543174743652,
0.16696633398532867,
-0.004438980482518673,
-0.11449602991342545,
0.019114302471280098,
1.0821326971054077,
0.0719527155160904,
1.1639866828918457,
0.6870418787002563,
-0.09090639650821686,
-0.07886368781328201,
0.14458097517490387,
1.1500715017318726,
-0.6294514536857605,
-0.33146145939826965,
-0.8615727424621582,
0.5919052958488464,
-0.09940813481807709,
-0.3414384424686432,
0.9203256964683533,
0.7456786632537842,
0.6643667221069336,
-0.15678653120994568,
0.7636250257492065,
-0.13868430256843567,
0.4158645272254944,
-0.6297533512115479,
0.4135773479938507,
-0.6332894563674927,
0.3719794750213623,
-0.45576974749565125,
-0.8883287906646729,
-0.6378471851348877,
0.9110360145568848,
0.09596153348684311,
-0.15134388208389282,
0.9613800048828125,
0.764657735824585,
-0.054832328110933304,
0.20491068065166473,
-0.07002361863851547,
0.6297640204429626,
0.42366352677345276,
0.517117977142334,
0.8985668420791626,
-0.4269135594367981,
0.6621843576431274,
0.01701798476278782,
-0.2906808853149414,
0.025753790512681007,
-1.153823971748352,
-1.1492626667022705,
-0.188450425863266,
-0.483723521232605,
-0.8350579738616943,
-0.23499582707881927,
0.9605751633644104,
0.8111183047294617,
-1.044518232345581,
-0.3562653362751007,
-0.18970145285129547,
0.5556588768959045,
-0.2986554205417633,
-0.27105385065078735,
0.02883032336831093,
-0.384721964597702,
-0.43148064613342285,
0.3976791501045227,
0.2980533242225647,
-0.2553655803203583,
-0.3490404188632965,
-0.24911220371723175,
-0.12200342118740082,
0.2150285840034485,
0.690588653087616,
0.20476455986499786,
-0.31873461604118347,
0.07111355662345886,
0.07265174388885498,
0.01624160073697567,
-0.10550951957702637,
1.128819465637207,
-0.6473526358604431,
0.12230944633483887,
0.9996840357780457,
0.6678472757339478,
0.589555025100708,
-0.0657048299908638,
0.6117693781852722,
-0.165606290102005,
0.2639692425727844,
0.493740051984787,
0.5775348544120789,
0.3494715392589569,
-0.20509816706180573,
0.4133915305137634,
0.5154526233673096,
-0.6170012950897217,
-0.917424738407135,
0.4642581343650818,
-1.0184619426727295,
-0.2147994488477707,
0.8042432069778442,
-0.14888788759708405,
-0.09230203926563263,
-0.26652607321739197,
-0.06628534197807312,
-0.14358972012996674,
-0.1330920159816742,
0.33515164256095886,
0.687164306640625,
-0.27255532145500183,
-0.039147622883319855,
-0.4180929660797119,
0.6552391648292542,
0.3676331341266632,
-0.98739093542099,
0.043710194528102875,
0.6000689268112183,
0.5374571084976196,
-0.059928908944129944,
0.49750134348869324,
-0.05839274078607559,
0.13201063871383667,
-0.07551755011081696,
-0.24905389547348022,
-0.07038960605859756,
-0.5598594546318054,
0.08043697476387024,
0.3906920254230499,
0.2594696283340454,
0.44611117243766785
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.13301v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.13301v1
|
Reading Users' Minds from What They Say: An Investigation into LLM-based Empathic Mental Inference
| 2024-03-20T04:57:32 | 2024-03-20T04:57:32 |
Qihao Zhu, Leah Chong, Maria Yang, Jianxi Luo
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.CL
|
In human-centered design, developing a comprehensive and in-depth
understanding of user experiences, i.e., empathic understanding, is paramount
for designing products that truly meet human needs. Nevertheless, accurately
comprehending the real underlying mental states of a large human population
remains a significant challenge today. This difficulty mainly arises from the
trade-off between depth and scale of user experience research: gaining in-depth
insights from a small group of users does not easily scale to a larger
population, and vice versa. This paper investigates the use of Large Language
Models (LLMs) for performing mental inference tasks, specifically inferring
users' underlying goals and fundamental psychological needs (FPNs). Baseline
and benchmark datasets were collected from human users and designers to develop
an empathic accuracy metric for measuring the mental inference performance of
LLMs. The empathic accuracy of inferring goals and FPNs of different LLMs with
varied zero-shot prompt engineering techniques are experimented against that of
human designers. Experimental results suggest that LLMs can infer and
understand the underlying goals and FPNs of users with performance comparable
to that of human designers, suggesting a promising avenue for enhancing the
scalability of empathic design approaches through the integration of advanced
artificial intelligence technologies. This work has the potential to
significantly augment the toolkit available to designers during human-centered
design, enabling the development of both large-scale and in-depth understanding
of users' experiences.
|
[
-0.754769504070282,
-0.9994284510612488,
0.999751627445221,
0.22763189673423767,
-0.09228062629699707,
0.06490728259086609,
-0.3015049695968628,
-0.7169920802116394,
0.14847853779792786,
0.4691978096961975,
-0.8536525964736938,
-0.44847315549850464,
-0.280953049659729,
0.16586415469646454,
-0.04269959777593613,
0.45037949085235596,
0.05412442237138748,
-0.12743380665779114,
-0.19873373210430145,
0.27777594327926636,
-0.2094922661781311,
-0.6011686325073242,
-0.5382933616638184,
-0.46436309814453125,
0.5421136617660522,
0.4975704848766327,
0.5958868861198425,
0.15612256526947021,
0.26694464683532715,
0.17495402693748474,
0.013742431998252869,
0.21974153816699982,
-0.15821713209152222,
-0.11805927753448486,
-0.18018385767936707,
-0.46602630615234375,
-0.43926626443862915,
0.19817271828651428,
-0.04730598255991936,
0.5376766920089722,
-0.2011278122663498,
0.2721399664878845,
0.10599936544895172,
0.26004302501678467,
-0.6383295059204102,
0.04707936570048332,
-0.1866772174835205,
0.5242750644683838,
0.2553441822528839,
-0.18176789581775665,
-0.823157012462616,
-0.010776685550808907,
0.09207174181938171,
-0.5228130221366882,
-0.0538010373711586,
0.3413372337818146,
0.6084576845169067,
0.23801571130752563,
-0.3253055810928345,
-0.18688414990901947,
-0.72362220287323,
0.8860945105552673,
-0.9926035404205322,
0.5067473649978638,
0.7198694944381714,
0.031773511320352554,
-0.032020650804042816,
-0.3951689898967743,
-0.7536266446113586,
-0.18203911185264587,
-0.21315480768680573,
0.10085607320070267,
-0.3209788501262665,
0.2498304843902588,
0.7051632404327393,
0.04183385893702507,
-0.3484469950199127,
0.28899848461151123,
-0.06481634825468063,
0.09273305535316467,
0.802230954170227,
0.3352508544921875,
0.2992836534976959,
-0.12595698237419128,
-0.20463827252388,
0.20251114666461945,
-0.4132980704307556,
0.03713522478938103,
0.022511931136250496,
0.12151841074228287,
-0.2859395444393158,
0.6046172380447388,
-0.12498482316732407,
0.8714509010314941,
0.21811777353286743,
-0.1554298996925354,
0.058689236640930176,
0.08338078111410141,
-0.48933112621307373,
-0.22791220247745514,
0.5749156475067139,
0.5962548851966858,
0.6654837727546692,
-0.3060126006603241,
-0.11118776351213455,
0.03463947772979736,
0.5108386874198914,
-0.7643110156059265,
0.053336627781391144,
0.3594522476196289,
-0.5443177223205566,
0.03832225129008293,
-0.11945497244596481,
-0.7507778406143188,
-0.7096513509750366,
-0.7859879732131958,
0.24321718513965607,
-0.2315765768289566,
-0.36923402547836304,
0.3598955273628235,
-0.08909344673156738,
0.4110662639141083,
0.3503095209598541,
-0.8281164765357971,
0.27816981077194214,
0.7782912254333496,
0.7851413488388062,
0.1821320801973343,
-0.25938063859939575,
-0.20314624905586243,
0.06149350106716156,
-0.07499807327985764,
0.8643925189971924,
-0.5991838574409485,
-0.4793003797531128,
-0.19221080839633942,
-0.42450737953186035,
0.07779824733734131,
-0.25304919481277466,
0.5836051106452942,
-0.27313780784606934,
-0.030743714421987534,
-0.3472563922405243,
-0.5108826160430908,
-0.23103317618370056,
0.3169534504413605,
-0.2681143283843994,
0.3189338445663452,
0.08442115038633347,
-0.6617134809494019,
0.19720856845378876,
-0.5535562038421631,
-0.4030660092830658,
-0.17792749404907227,
-0.32827410101890564,
0.10813429206609726,
0.7521308064460754,
0.40972012281417847,
0.5933529138565063,
-0.6786677837371826,
0.07432075589895248,
-0.6332912445068359,
-0.3730868697166443,
0.5581589937210083,
-0.30729392170906067,
0.6931253671646118,
0.29562610387802124,
-0.19053809344768524,
-0.04519786685705185,
-0.37503084540367126,
0.16644933819770813,
-0.0806586742401123,
0.12019430100917816,
-0.2756802439689636,
-0.058959804475307465,
0.18632198870182037,
0.5776683688163757,
0.017149854451417923,
-0.9306791424751282,
-0.1839945763349533,
-0.3341701328754425,
0.5799620747566223,
0.770018994808197,
-0.07654419541358948,
0.3774358630180359,
-0.2667692303657532,
0.5493564009666443,
-0.2107098251581192,
0.29675424098968506,
-0.022224383428692818,
-0.46469488739967346,
-0.30253735184669495,
-0.5726529955863953,
-0.1913807988166809,
0.4992424249649048,
-0.32434549927711487,
0.6576330065727234,
0.006271562539041042,
-0.47049036622047424,
-0.480577677488327,
0.20790061354637146,
0.23082242906093597,
0.7239255309104919,
0.08182687312364578,
-0.28178754448890686,
-0.3740733563899994,
-0.8412083387374878,
-0.5617145299911499,
-0.17059023678302765,
-0.5484130382537842,
0.8266618251800537,
0.24020598828792572,
-0.2285613715648651,
1.0743547677993774,
-0.667598307132721,
-0.13905511796474457,
-0.33640211820602417,
0.10206030309200287,
0.2513609826564789,
0.06414961814880371,
0.2755005359649658,
-0.6768673062324524,
-0.4060082733631134,
-0.008224246092140675,
-1.1007158756256104,
-0.2093793898820877,
-0.2579662799835205,
-0.21497434377670288,
0.026926396414637566,
0.2544516623020172,
-0.9285154938697815,
0.4737083315849304,
0.32596179842948914,
-0.7677358984947205,
0.35021382570266724,
-0.08903312683105469,
0.12431634962558746,
-0.8652299046516418,
0.15701623260974884,
0.49079054594039917,
0.1839258372783661,
-0.6639084219932556,
-0.008355990052223206,
0.08528672903776169,
-0.004379396326839924,
-0.49379342794418335,
0.8133355379104614,
-0.43214625120162964,
-0.1660453975200653,
-0.11665408313274384,
0.1589011251926422,
0.26967132091522217,
0.5657262802124023,
0.006300732959061861,
0.5413669943809509,
0.3351747989654541,
-0.17339372634887695,
0.33430278301239014,
0.5597364902496338,
-0.3498452305793762,
1.135187029838562,
-0.5851805210113525,
0.35988596081733704,
-0.05146372318267822,
0.210958331823349,
-0.8096490502357483,
-0.3136260509490967,
0.2558198869228363,
-0.6584538817405701,
0.15626949071884155,
0.21391884982585907,
-0.8333777785301208,
-0.6014649271965027,
-0.004340446554124355,
0.19094721972942352,
0.5961574912071228,
-0.6143060922622681,
1.0494887828826904,
0.5151588320732117,
-0.13457387685775757,
-0.16108089685440063,
-0.968390941619873,
0.36033955216407776,
-0.42035940289497375,
-0.8004486560821533,
-0.045043062418699265,
-0.04351160675287247,
-0.8136636018753052,
-0.2405761033296585,
0.005422605667263269,
-0.11119875311851501,
0.09311389923095703,
0.47723278403282166,
0.20331761240959167,
-0.08015228062868118,
0.18838384747505188,
-0.03469472751021385,
0.053749144077301025,
0.5889660120010376,
0.042118895798921585,
0.3392491042613983,
-0.06363097578287125,
-0.5286017060279846,
-0.9006109833717346,
0.48559072613716125,
0.6122973561286926,
-0.24586287140846252,
0.777488648891449,
0.3846871852874756,
-0.48988714814186096,
-0.3076571524143219,
-0.85496586561203,
-0.5129016637802124,
-0.44840744137763977,
0.09210432320833206,
-0.5933030247688293,
-0.859499990940094,
0.5237051248550415,
-0.18456211686134338,
0.05085939168930054,
-0.04578649625182152,
0.40943092107772827,
-0.41939347982406616,
1.2283951044082642,
0.541307806968689,
-0.1499934196472168,
0.3551099896430969,
0.08581782132387161,
0.3845911920070648,
-1.098891019821167,
-0.1427752524614334,
-0.2053736448287964,
-0.5182082653045654,
-0.10408613830804825,
-0.20359370112419128,
0.07319795340299606,
-0.1894121766090393,
-0.5409768223762512,
-0.15312623977661133,
-0.26869919896125793,
0.18978561460971832,
0.35650694370269775,
0.6995869874954224,
0.2954598665237427,
0.34638896584510803,
0.0698428750038147,
-0.16939221322536469,
-0.18309375643730164,
-0.5371721982955933,
0.9608076810836792,
0.453797847032547,
1.036062240600586,
-0.02157551981508732,
0.5012940764427185,
0.5104814171791077,
0.5609049797058105,
-1.0006225109100342,
0.370392769575119,
0.21639014780521393,
-0.473634272813797,
-0.21812118589878082,
-0.18365676701068878,
-0.6205670833587646,
0.19694101810455322,
-0.08395984768867493,
-1.0469342470169067,
0.15648312866687775,
0.22268949449062347,
-0.5956611037254333,
0.4042457938194275,
-0.6540846228599548,
0.560215950012207,
-0.3884683847427368,
-0.4299772381782532,
-0.5061489343643188,
-0.6122204065322876,
0.3159708082675934,
-0.28571686148643494,
0.24450398981571198,
-0.14908213913440704,
0.001035985304042697,
0.5216530561447144,
-0.07722056657075882,
1.1319197416305542,
-0.2575031518936157,
-0.28128477931022644,
0.24534425139427185,
-0.16725701093673706,
0.35208719968795776,
-0.045547254383563995,
-0.47207343578338623,
0.0951467826962471,
-0.4638769328594208,
-0.3479456603527069,
-0.9184419512748718,
0.5281739830970764,
-0.7118701934814453,
-0.8402246236801147,
-0.0032451923470944166,
-0.6359380483627319,
-0.5296968221664429,
-0.033153098076581955,
-0.10756922513246536,
0.3049700856208801,
-0.2630433738231659,
0.05638284981250763,
0.5427881479263306,
-0.3768743574619293,
-0.002798672067001462,
0.6566458940505981,
-0.051308467984199524,
-0.17171452939510345,
0.3950648605823517,
-0.25479403138160706,
0.12409303337335587,
0.35950952768325806,
0.13823150098323822,
-0.37918955087661743,
-0.15547865629196167,
-0.4001571536064148,
0.532715916633606,
-0.5132565498352051,
0.08707646280527115,
-0.6607804894447327,
-0.054058220237493515,
-0.1666596680879593,
-0.4187176525592804,
-0.03024141676723957,
0.03745272383093834,
-0.39623796939849854,
-0.24942444264888763,
0.45003625750541687,
0.7771846652030945,
-0.08077783137559891,
0.441218763589859,
-0.6534746289253235,
0.3481904864311218,
0.07432527840137482,
0.2949477434158325,
0.35420143604278564,
-0.6864559054374695,
-0.19600623846054077,
0.25053870677948,
-0.30736044049263,
-0.781470775604248,
0.6120488047599792,
-0.10178116708993912,
0.621992290019989,
0.5655156970024109,
0.12715326249599457,
0.5106076002120972,
-0.323889821767807,
0.2759976387023926,
0.11428504437208176,
-0.8439961671829224,
0.5271742343902588,
-0.36089155077934265,
0.15575005114078522,
0.30834725499153137,
0.2609265446662903,
-0.6743718385696411,
-0.09704313427209854,
-0.5300848484039307,
-0.5204712152481079,
0.5632569789886475,
-0.18324162065982819,
0.17838934063911438,
-0.024538559839129448,
0.5798117518424988,
-0.07522354274988174,
0.09189511835575104,
-0.11312153935432434,
-0.0015627160901203752,
0.2509382367134094,
-0.40377336740493774,
-0.27456429600715637,
-0.1957610547542572,
-0.2431330680847168,
-0.10204275697469711,
0.04013583064079285,
-0.1858443021774292,
0.4955027997493744,
0.13758140802383423,
-0.07297763228416443,
-0.2951641380786896,
0.11191482841968536,
0.3948590159416199,
0.8030096888542175,
-0.16647373139858246,
0.11062388122081757,
0.3111201524734497,
-0.16173341870307922,
0.05979200080037117,
-0.09379733353853226,
0.1432269662618637,
-0.5108330845832825,
0.18974117934703827,
0.5358671545982361,
0.061099838465452194,
-0.9050672650337219,
0.3088594377040863,
-0.2844313085079193,
-0.02883131243288517,
-0.3732900023460388,
-0.06529869884252548,
0.29256102442741394,
0.6444129943847656,
0.2976457476615906,
-0.013271615840494633,
0.20895949006080627,
-0.46324804425239563,
0.2174597680568695,
0.4719521105289459,
-0.3862183094024658,
-0.49165982007980347,
0.43621498346328735,
0.22811847925186157,
-0.6225169897079468,
1.0416159629821777,
0.3202660381793976,
-0.08417096734046936,
0.6252761483192444,
0.5657655000686646,
1.0162523984909058,
-0.14295701682567596,
0.15651147067546844,
0.17747089266777039,
0.04078703746199608,
-0.009375291876494884,
0.42412349581718445,
-0.31565061211586,
-0.8126717805862427,
-0.3622170090675354,
-0.5978930592536926,
-0.6041866540908813,
-0.15962311625480652,
-0.9178348183631897,
-0.1148165911436081,
-0.5924480557441711,
-0.5012767910957336,
-0.2232341468334198,
-0.07325959950685501,
-0.9219461679458618,
0.39005666971206665,
0.4285374879837036,
1.0562584400177002,
-0.9244549870491028,
0.4484754204750061,
0.5006129145622253,
-0.24469822645187378,
-0.6656874418258667,
0.139989972114563,
0.29718437790870667,
-0.8669033050537109,
0.6085933446884155,
0.19312149286270142,
-0.13962285220623016,
0.10294955223798752,
-0.43707072734832764,
-0.4518267810344696,
1.0696156024932861,
0.356547474861145,
-0.475773423910141,
-0.19420407712459564,
0.12616808712482452,
0.7018815279006958,
-0.4579625129699707,
0.4115956425666809,
0.7162167429924011,
0.5844525098800659,
0.014147381298244,
-0.7110447287559509,
0.27501606941223145,
-0.3671424984931946,
-0.18727613985538483,
0.0013503092341125011,
-0.6686224341392517,
0.4636622667312622,
-0.42689234018325806,
-0.08496170490980148,
0.03364549204707146,
0.633412778377533,
0.6530600190162659,
0.42560482025146484,
0.3046513497829437,
0.620672881603241,
0.7041215300559998,
0.3273998498916626,
1.0289223194122314,
-0.3442550003528595,
0.12500660121440887,
1.017298936843872,
-0.2726278305053711,
1.0071543455123901,
0.6268343329429626,
-0.14428427815437317,
0.29832032322883606,
0.6535503268241882,
-0.05710612237453461,
0.19636371731758118,
0.3006751239299774,
-0.431733638048172,
-0.37866759300231934,
-0.36175286769866943,
0.0013999425573274493,
0.3730018138885498,
0.8155291676521301,
-0.69865882396698,
0.12772226333618164,
-0.01034410111606121,
-0.004979880526661873,
-0.028218450024724007,
-0.26460960507392883,
0.6201915740966797,
0.6493498682975769,
-0.6260396242141724,
0.17471382021903992,
-0.18350744247436523,
0.6685479879379272,
-0.11224798858165741,
0.14768165349960327,
-0.30309823155403137,
0.3963075876235962,
-0.22844508290290833,
-1.0436410903930664,
0.12767218053340912,
0.1499049812555313,
-0.11214160919189453,
-0.3055833876132965,
0.5229587554931641,
0.17198523879051208,
-0.6415422558784485,
0.6040050387382507,
0.7827880382537842,
0.31807011365890503,
-0.4323153793811798,
-0.5483506321907043,
0.07506348937749863,
-0.07338730245828629,
-0.5260425806045532,
0.2541249990463257,
0.5445041060447693,
0.19612210988998413,
0.8907467722892761,
0.3745054304599762,
0.11902198195457458,
-0.30867162346839905,
0.2556140124797821,
0.6917896866798401,
-0.8691625595092773,
-0.1368628740310669,
-1.1019471883773804,
0.4180156886577606,
-0.13679589331150055,
-0.30713793635368347,
0.7133335471153259,
0.18711210787296295,
0.6721229553222656,
-0.12393137812614441,
0.9652137160301208,
0.11484985053539276,
0.3798014521598816,
-0.18651090562343597,
0.6924638152122498,
-0.5654893517494202,
-0.013076466508209705,
-0.36504530906677246,
-0.6521095037460327,
-0.3953256905078888,
0.7607380747795105,
-0.5097036361694336,
0.1653815358877182,
0.2031312733888626,
0.8739831447601318,
-0.1335635781288147,
0.2672346234321594,
0.6125892996788025,
0.29737716913223267,
0.34629711508750916,
0.6731342077255249,
1.0625579357147217,
0.23567965626716614,
-0.052406974136829376,
-0.18205520510673523,
-0.4268258512020111,
-0.13197891414165497,
-0.5002080798149109,
-1.1208208799362183,
-0.11687354743480682,
0.0026032456662505865,
-0.07751447707414627,
-0.1453985571861267,
1.0442516803741455,
0.46812671422958374,
-0.5694136023521423,
-0.31635546684265137,
0.05466106906533241,
-0.20671992003917694,
0.1422938108444214,
-0.18245245516300201,
0.07361859828233719,
-0.0565611906349659,
-0.593383252620697,
0.05536138638854027,
0.33738815784454346,
-0.2553709149360657,
-0.40355637669563293,
-0.23190969228744507,
0.11151265352964401,
0.3876766860485077,
0.8070619106292725,
0.27294036746025085,
-1.117136836051941,
-0.2056221067905426,
0.3023946285247803,
-0.07559088617563248,
-0.011088055558502674,
0.7333517074584961,
-0.731574296951294,
0.34897297620773315,
0.4240562915802002,
0.741995096206665,
0.2360340803861618,
0.30143263936042786,
0.8046784996986389,
-0.25983086228370667,
-0.21443666517734528,
-0.000005344801138562616,
0.3778577744960785,
0.32018908858299255,
-0.5628452301025391,
0.4293787479400635,
-0.10172215104103088,
-0.492201030254364,
-0.6271237134933472,
0.28286758065223694,
-0.8066532611846924,
-0.24345281720161438,
1.1305960416793823,
-0.36701229214668274,
-0.2675146460533142,
-0.16896747052669525,
-0.4481818675994873,
0.21789227426052094,
-0.3921002149581909,
0.9818363189697266,
0.5809199810028076,
-0.5817425847053528,
-0.510718584060669,
-0.5709022283554077,
0.1775258183479309,
0.31572169065475464,
-0.8408763408660889,
0.19228924810886383,
0.42490994930267334,
0.04604073241353035,
-0.07258984446525574,
0.465589702129364,
0.25433385372161865,
0.15112429857254028,
0.03007371537387371,
0.11916244775056839,
0.15627361834049225,
-0.17275692522525787,
-0.11035224050283432,
0.12646877765655518,
0.12411250174045563,
0.2234545648097992
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.13272v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.13272v1
|
Community Needs and Assets: A Computational Analysis of Community Conversations
| 2024-03-20T03:14:54 | 2024-03-20T03:14:54 |
Md Towhidul Absar Chowdhury, Naveen Sharma, Ashiqur R. KhudaBukhsh
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.CL, cs.SI
|
A community needs assessment is a tool used by non-profits and government
agencies to quantify the strengths and issues of a community, allowing them to
allocate their resources better. Such approaches are transitioning towards
leveraging social media conversations to analyze the needs of communities and
the assets already present within them. However, manual analysis of
exponentially increasing social media conversations is challenging. There is a
gap in the present literature in computationally analyzing how community
members discuss the strengths and needs of the community. To address this gap,
we introduce the task of identifying, extracting, and categorizing community
needs and assets from conversational data using sophisticated natural language
processing methods. To facilitate this task, we introduce the first dataset
about community needs and assets consisting of 3,511 conversations from Reddit,
annotated using crowdsourced workers. Using this dataset, we evaluate an
utterance-level classification model compared to sentiment classification and a
popular large language model (in a zero-shot setting), where we find that our
model outperforms both baselines at an F1 score of 94% compared to 49% and 61%
respectively. Furthermore, we observe through our study that conversations
about needs have negative sentiments and emotions, while conversations about
assets focus on location and entities. The dataset is available at
https://github.com/towhidabsar/CommunityNeeds.
|
[
-0.7069158554077148,
-0.7321107387542725,
0.3127574622631073,
-0.0037370386999100447,
-0.10961898416280746,
0.772609293460846,
-0.20773480832576752,
-0.666571319103241,
0.660902202129364,
0.4717212915420532,
-0.6497962474822998,
-0.2747814655303955,
-0.85770583152771,
-0.07164613157510757,
-0.40565499663352966,
1.0330311059951782,
0.2766861021518707,
-0.167613223195076,
-0.42824697494506836,
-0.29650256037712097,
-0.696888267993927,
-0.3597678244113922,
-0.6953552961349487,
0.14087839424610138,
0.5720299482345581,
0.8625847697257996,
0.7173102498054504,
0.3409824073314667,
0.6763384938240051,
0.32995468378067017,
-0.0005491833435371518,
-0.20572522282600403,
-0.8524380922317505,
-0.11940449476242065,
0.056369490921497345,
0.17716138064861298,
-0.24777327477931976,
-0.2069452404975891,
0.0232955664396286,
0.5972126722335815,
-0.11098012328147888,
0.736600935459137,
0.050323352217674255,
0.5976660251617432,
-0.6169543266296387,
0.1958273947238922,
-0.5262710452079773,
-0.11846036463975906,
-0.2336239218711853,
-0.17269819974899292,
0.3910602033138275,
-0.6177440285682678,
0.4297960698604584,
-0.2763622999191284,
0.41696399450302124,
-0.1590576022863388,
0.7122757434844971,
0.08167475461959839,
-0.30499887466430664,
-0.5633646845817566,
-0.5465702414512634,
0.9967498183250427,
-0.3266667425632477,
0.2236955165863037,
0.6748552918434143,
0.14676402509212494,
0.0758526474237442,
-0.48388662934303284,
-0.4291727542877197,
0.32890641689300537,
-0.17320121824741364,
-0.18973207473754883,
-0.4762348234653473,
-0.010310672223567963,
-0.009307151660323143,
0.49954500794410706,
-0.41677460074424744,
-0.21316969394683838,
-0.9887337684631348,
-0.20651178061962128,
0.8309190273284912,
0.19585786759853363,
0.3091599643230438,
-0.5516495108604431,
-0.3666969835758209,
-0.27309465408325195,
-0.22512824833393097,
0.1726713627576828,
0.19424447417259216,
0.2925522029399872,
-0.19580677151679993,
0.42705750465393066,
-0.01576024852693081,
0.15412335097789764,
-0.1503923237323761,
-0.07037559896707535,
0.2526875138282776,
-0.5750434994697571,
-0.20625515282154083,
-0.12196532636880875,
0.6048945784568787,
0.4955103099346161,
0.2613758146762848,
0.17343850433826447,
-0.01726353168487549,
0.03260847181081772,
0.4145238995552063,
-0.49949824810028076,
-0.26365384459495544,
0.5496314764022827,
-0.5700597167015076,
-0.36086541414260864,
0.03984316065907478,
-1.0200257301330566,
-0.7257364988327026,
-0.45854032039642334,
-0.24782207608222961,
-0.15658029913902283,
-0.4845590889453888,
-0.1995527148246765,
-0.2845933735370636,
0.25048938393592834,
0.2130923867225647,
-0.8463835716247559,
0.544958770275116,
0.7844334244728088,
0.9656159281730652,
-0.002891171956434846,
0.1310369074344635,
-0.2629885971546173,
-0.3597133755683899,
0.0741247609257698,
0.963283360004425,
-0.5195509791374207,
-0.5553575754165649,
0.07078949362039566,
-0.22953203320503235,
0.1149916723370552,
-0.3986109495162964,
0.5573394298553467,
-0.6213428378105164,
-0.23737214505672455,
-0.6929571628570557,
-0.20575644075870514,
-0.09941823035478592,
0.44046416878700256,
-0.8336142897605896,
0.8839643597602844,
0.40741756558418274,
-0.6359215974807739,
0.29770055413246155,
-0.8632164001464844,
-0.44533824920654297,
0.3635673522949219,
0.09661281108856201,
-0.1461823284626007,
0.2949995696544647,
0.19047683477401733,
0.24983151257038116,
-0.47205767035484314,
0.25671231746673584,
-0.541776716709137,
0.055393192917108536,
0.5032700300216675,
-0.21395879983901978,
0.6779815554618835,
0.45211145281791687,
-0.022001272067427635,
-0.08298797160387039,
-0.5168744921684265,
0.07211854308843613,
-0.14350563287734985,
-0.04821622371673584,
-0.21192120015621185,
0.4322664439678192,
0.3931550681591034,
0.16913364827632904,
0.5309792757034302,
-0.5452313423156738,
-0.0808953046798706,
-0.4823305904865265,
0.6248055100440979,
0.7452179789543152,
0.21917688846588135,
0.42379704117774963,
-0.17422086000442505,
0.6639986038208008,
-0.26096656918525696,
0.24278169870376587,
0.12635111808776855,
-0.5496408939361572,
-0.7812965512275696,
-0.04430083930492401,
0.04514337703585625,
0.4416275918483734,
-0.39894694089889526,
0.4047328531742096,
-0.1748538315296173,
-0.44053274393081665,
-0.4968430697917938,
0.1901387721300125,
-0.021865887567400932,
0.3037186563014984,
0.29506805539131165,
-0.7137711048126221,
-0.6935319304466248,
-0.7907460927963257,
0.1870536059141159,
-0.4967055022716522,
0.09694639593362808,
0.3036935031414032,
0.29264238476753235,
-0.11037188023328781,
1.1961480379104614,
-0.5946633815765381,
-0.18226729333400726,
-0.4572434723377228,
0.4029557406902313,
-0.10609673708677292,
0.04212166741490364,
0.4784286916255951,
-0.7437833547592163,
-0.33203959465026855,
0.048286788165569305,
-0.4641657769680023,
-0.23654568195343018,
0.19672361016273499,
-0.12679848074913025,
-0.2801118791103363,
0.037132877856492996,
-0.49374645948410034,
0.5809963941574097,
0.4604366719722748,
-0.17797671258449554,
0.07282532006502151,
0.31443527340888977,
0.26475414633750916,
-0.9321863651275635,
0.13793815672397614,
0.035806238651275635,
-0.047594789415597916,
-0.7802806496620178,
-0.06801752001047134,
-0.471144437789917,
-0.4298332631587982,
-0.2163691371679306,
0.4640510678291321,
-0.2161683291196823,
-0.3446509540081024,
-0.5655178427696228,
0.15223455429077148,
-0.11700208485126495,
0.353730171918869,
0.04159407317638397,
0.4242914915084839,
0.43219318985939026,
-0.3573434352874756,
0.6490445733070374,
0.4856971204280853,
-0.2680172920227051,
0.5825059413909912,
-0.48034077882766724,
0.48094937205314636,
-0.22770772874355316,
0.017220236361026764,
-0.9843788146972656,
-0.4353691637516022,
0.19488301873207092,
-0.550710916519165,
-0.3621242940425873,
0.04587668552994728,
-0.4616807997226715,
-0.5423686504364014,
-0.3208044171333313,
0.36999791860580444,
-0.024291593581438065,
0.024542324244976044,
0.4934576153755188,
0.9690374732017517,
-0.6188971400260925,
-0.35382360219955444,
-0.5291900038719177,
0.36732950806617737,
-0.2904137372970581,
-0.5617093443870544,
-0.2538575232028961,
-0.15509316325187683,
-0.49071434140205383,
0.33101803064346313,
0.45451730489730835,
-0.704352080821991,
0.44632482528686523,
0.44889241456985474,
0.17316578328609467,
-0.03482269123196602,
0.289474219083786,
-0.17366822063922882,
-0.23039127886295319,
0.21206295490264893,
0.1698726862668991,
0.5715966820716858,
-0.35743457078933716,
-0.38040634989738464,
-0.2098606824874878,
0.6460863351821899,
0.683715283870697,
-0.453048437833786,
0.6482058763504028,
0.4302668571472168,
-0.48012837767601013,
0.22010207176208496,
-0.5543843507766724,
0.007817431353032589,
-0.46647778153419495,
0.39179790019989014,
0.40616467595100403,
-1.2148300409317017,
0.6216440796852112,
0.34710001945495605,
0.22700171172618866,
0.35298609733581543,
0.6221351623535156,
-0.2973065674304962,
0.43226858973503113,
0.566372811794281,
-0.5488220453262329,
0.2221778780221939,
-0.09549897164106369,
0.5335338115692139,
-0.0907716304063797,
-0.023285502567887306,
-0.4664188027381897,
-0.8523271679878235,
-0.25264182686805725,
-0.40616220235824585,
0.20799969136714935,
-0.27521511912345886,
0.22641898691654205,
0.513314425945282,
-0.4134979844093323,
0.5448964238166809,
0.18568775057792664,
-0.2811611592769623,
0.07930038124322891,
-0.04613493010401726,
0.7881098985671997,
-0.1715879887342453,
-0.39354732632637024,
-0.6045984625816345,
0.8423595428466797,
0.5370602011680603,
0.2963702976703644,
0.3182877004146576,
0.5226835012435913,
0.7601351141929626,
0.7694076895713806,
-1.0877189636230469,
0.4061802327632904,
0.09249700605869293,
-0.8112207055091858,
-0.240873783826828,
-0.3601234555244446,
-0.9856022596359253,
-0.11096055060625076,
-0.45813238620758057,
-0.5103359818458557,
0.5095060467720032,
-0.11150127649307251,
-0.6846032738685608,
0.14394742250442505,
-0.7425487041473389,
0.8271874189376831,
-0.3919723331928253,
0.2402978539466858,
-0.5826094746589661,
-0.3691149353981018,
0.21190816164016724,
-0.5481738448143005,
0.5998575687408447,
-0.4324849545955658,
0.3702095150947571,
0.4890468716621399,
-0.4049334228038788,
0.9270310401916504,
-0.17163874208927155,
0.3657699227333069,
0.8591275811195374,
-0.28514108061790466,
-0.03918775916099548,
-0.08772006630897522,
-0.02504046820104122,
0.1469913125038147,
0.25281086564064026,
-0.47941914200782776,
-0.46553942561149597,
0.5413675308227539,
-0.959621012210846,
-0.14482183754444122,
-0.17908978462219238,
-0.09671639651060104,
-0.19825990498065948,
-0.052677400410175323,
-0.08848445862531662,
0.3752298951148987,
-0.6711602210998535,
0.23765350878238678,
0.38879939913749695,
-0.07820918411016464,
0.3094600737094879,
0.26274365186691284,
0.00048331861034967005,
-0.45679447054862976,
0.9300747513771057,
0.1930932104587555,
0.21507684886455536,
-0.08298079669475555,
0.1359470933675766,
-0.12589433789253235,
-0.36198681592941284,
0.11948557943105698,
0.02484021708369255,
-0.6631395816802979,
-0.5899966359138489,
-0.3665028512477875,
-0.13483737409114838,
-0.47150254249572754,
-0.19998322427272797,
-0.3452490568161011,
-0.17516440153121948,
-0.6447022557258606,
-0.3108029365539551,
0.4549974501132965,
1.046756625175476,
-0.052134089171886444,
0.24072039127349854,
-1.0398489236831665,
0.055258072912693024,
0.43701717257499695,
0.31526675820350647,
0.3603643476963043,
-0.1203075647354126,
-0.5911394357681274,
-0.059090957045555115,
-0.42539191246032715,
-1.138634204864502,
0.5956014394760132,
0.09093798696994781,
0.2495180368423462,
0.46616819500923157,
0.22136107087135315,
1.0175113677978516,
0.1258569210767746,
0.6242756247520447,
0.10879574716091156,
-0.7450206875801086,
0.46203771233558655,
-0.2488848716020584,
-0.0491282194852829,
1.3140314817428589,
0.2671319246292114,
-0.8554799556732178,
-0.27579131722450256,
-0.8242359757423401,
-0.8025639057159424,
0.6226988434791565,
0.3507905900478363,
0.46415290236473083,
-0.4619205892086029,
0.2844688892364502,
-0.3815327286720276,
0.18107426166534424,
-0.4147326946258545,
0.0966511219739914,
-0.2045377492904663,
-0.17600882053375244,
0.34129801392555237,
-0.3917362093925476,
-0.13526512682437897,
-0.15283264219760895,
0.23447294533252716,
-0.011551163159310818,
0.34781384468078613,
0.055106114596128464,
0.03669167309999466,
-0.49351003766059875,
0.3109145164489746,
0.2816970944404602,
0.6871230006217957,
-0.0530872717499733,
0.10270898044109344,
0.5591622591018677,
-0.2576081156730652,
-0.3152158856391907,
-0.1422133594751358,
0.4024939239025116,
-0.27771952748298645,
0.29372894763946533,
0.4701204001903534,
0.4211583435535431,
-0.8049150109291077,
0.8315203189849854,
-0.21199923753738403,
-0.33642610907554626,
-0.5285804867744446,
-0.21607454121112823,
0.27308258414268494,
0.26375651359558105,
0.45917144417762756,
0.10290170460939407,
0.10205215215682983,
-0.53868567943573,
0.14000092446804047,
0.36532825231552124,
-0.8618146777153015,
-0.42424777150154114,
-0.0015918172430247068,
0.4213678240776062,
-0.2918965816497803,
0.8492099642753601,
-0.16330967843532562,
-0.4552561938762665,
0.6039268970489502,
-0.1626594215631485,
1.1834375858306885,
0.03854597359895706,
0.30846908688545227,
0.41140344738960266,
0.3035289943218231,
0.2371152937412262,
0.0001306244812440127,
-0.11944902688264847,
-0.8538396954536438,
-0.42391473054885864,
-0.9587189555168152,
-0.39635416865348816,
0.1567198932170868,
-0.618880033493042,
0.30085089802742004,
-0.9197531342506409,
-0.4598429799079895,
-0.11139629036188126,
0.14023566246032715,
-0.5299748182296753,
0.10353008657693863,
0.27342668175697327,
0.7342881560325623,
-1.1146727800369263,
0.5546041131019592,
0.34323835372924805,
-0.22902023792266846,
-0.7234316468238831,
-0.31410107016563416,
0.19274145364761353,
-0.6291211247444153,
0.4922543466091156,
-0.011430257000029087,
-0.1394144892692566,
-0.3465714454650879,
-0.7433391213417053,
-1.0621224641799927,
0.9937587976455688,
0.17602042853832245,
-0.16215890645980835,
0.39562034606933594,
0.3430952727794647,
0.8673406839370728,
-0.42356184124946594,
-0.032698262482881546,
0.4660213887691498,
0.551969051361084,
0.32291755080223083,
-0.8659602403640747,
-0.39819201827049255,
-0.520990252494812,
-0.2045106440782547,
0.10724231600761414,
-0.5956196784973145,
0.5132040977478027,
0.13069383800029755,
-0.5993534922599792,
0.1426219344139099,
0.7720991373062134,
0.0657917782664299,
0.41028714179992676,
0.6147206425666809,
0.38108181953430176,
0.9072167873382568,
-0.009037173353135586,
0.8423473834991455,
-0.3344104588031769,
0.6425008773803711,
0.5914514064788818,
-0.123672716319561,
0.9560917019844055,
0.08544781804084778,
-0.11444388329982758,
0.5747523307800293,
0.6324431300163269,
-0.03430335968732834,
0.15128828585147858,
0.10335002839565277,
-0.3035188913345337,
-0.22952324151992798,
-0.3229663372039795,
-0.08456308394670486,
0.5953816771507263,
0.4493003487586975,
-0.1900372952222824,
-0.1891542673110962,
-0.09458812326192856,
-0.16858389973640442,
0.021265877410769463,
-0.21616651117801666,
0.8523556590080261,
0.04276832565665245,
-0.37007373571395874,
-0.1225484311580658,
0.059669505804777145,
0.21840840578079224,
-0.4874781370162964,
0.008758053183555603,
-0.0661122053861618,
-0.2464982569217682,
-0.4578549265861511,
-0.9436625242233276,
0.9861874580383301,
0.1797458380460739,
-0.1671568751335144,
-0.44389015436172485,
1.0647504329681396,
-0.1796174794435501,
-0.4822274148464203,
0.29718679189682007,
0.39668360352516174,
0.2344725877046585,
-0.0018470456125214696,
-0.8213987946510315,
0.10375527292490005,
-0.13307102024555206,
0.042576633393764496,
0.3109699487686157,
0.36425966024398804,
-0.1588030308485031,
0.361324280500412,
0.7660622596740723,
-0.18297646939754486,
-0.354886919260025,
0.009522601962089539,
1.0581532716751099,
-0.6355525851249695,
-0.2962271571159363,
-0.6565195322036743,
0.39035722613334656,
-0.19418475031852722,
-0.5808670520782471,
0.5040541887283325,
0.4421137571334839,
0.30241942405700684,
0.30254608392715454,
0.7412059903144836,
-0.46425506472587585,
0.7129487991333008,
0.12501512467861176,
0.6993542313575745,
-0.35492873191833496,
0.3860505521297455,
-0.27920904755592346,
-0.6977988481521606,
-0.23442986607551575,
0.6495636105537415,
-0.5573567152023315,
-0.17175334692001343,
0.15612173080444336,
0.8106066584587097,
0.06514393538236618,
0.5418468713760376,
0.01752871833741665,
-0.19185276329517365,
0.21625074744224548,
0.40952709317207336,
0.9949559569358826,
-0.08412165939807892,
0.5814496278762817,
0.06592855602502823,
-0.09870313107967377,
-0.09258206188678741,
-0.6612185835838318,
-0.5677175521850586,
-0.5525380373001099,
-0.24791781604290009,
-0.2444312572479248,
-0.29222533106803894,
0.9892730116844177,
0.4827435314655304,
-0.9716702103614807,
-0.528639018535614,
0.04426848143339157,
0.23680882155895233,
0.22479894757270813,
-0.2639276683330536,
-0.042504601180553436,
-0.2152237743139267,
-0.21399079263210297,
0.2833414375782013,
0.37652912735939026,
-0.3323560357093811,
-0.5479242205619812,
-0.09275522083044052,
-0.23559343814849854,
0.031471990048885345,
0.4702398180961609,
0.7164125442504883,
-0.3767838180065155,
-0.46193328499794006,
0.17787621915340424,
-0.13519662618637085,
0.17765800654888153,
0.9779556393623352,
-0.5579697489738464,
0.40586915612220764,
0.4428037405014038,
0.8072375059127808,
0.45053768157958984,
0.22519902884960175,
0.3709985911846161,
-0.8701233267784119,
-0.36357632279396057,
0.1904524564743042,
-0.034349475055933,
0.4952922761440277,
-0.3366789221763611,
0.19715559482574463,
0.43810561299324036,
-0.5953962802886963,
-0.3037698268890381,
0.10534278303384781,
-0.9824330806732178,
-0.21817339956760406,
0.835917592048645,
0.1924799531698227,
-0.24740184843540192,
-0.4857374429702759,
-0.21878239512443542,
0.00862596184015274,
-0.5680538415908813,
0.8259857892990112,
0.8769045472145081,
0.04439106211066246,
-0.4795546531677246,
-0.47490304708480835,
0.25727686285972595,
-0.034823108464479446,
-0.8238729238510132,
0.31607481837272644,
0.7361612319946289,
0.0528862401843071,
0.5732207894325256,
1.102384328842163,
0.044285133481025696,
0.21262383460998535,
-0.4712819755077362,
-0.05783173069357872,
0.4043998718261719,
-0.012978453189134598,
-0.21476784348487854,
0.6931998133659363,
0.0015323434490710497,
0.26109233498573303
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.13269v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.13269v3
|
AFLoRA: Adaptive Freezing of Low Rank Adaptation in Parameter Efficient Fine-Tuning of Large Models
| 2024-03-20T03:07:50 | 2024-04-16T17:37:12 |
Zeyu Liu, Souvik Kundu, Anni Li, Junrui Wan, Lianghao Jiang, Peter Anthony Beerel
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
We present a novel Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning (PEFT) method, dubbed as
Adaptive Freezing of Low Rank Adaptation (AFLoRA). Specifically, for each
pre-trained frozen weight tensor, we add a parallel path of trainable low-rank
matrices, namely a down-projection and an up-projection matrix, each of which
is followed by a feature transformation vector. Based on a novel freezing
score, we the incrementally freeze these projection matrices during fine-tuning
to reduce the computation and alleviate over-fitting. Our experimental results
demonstrate that we can achieve state-of-the-art performance with an average
improvement of up to $0.85\%$ as evaluated on GLUE benchmark while yeilding up
to $9.5\times$ fewer average trainable parameters. While compared in terms of
runtime, AFLoRA can yield up to $1.86\times$ improvement as opposed to similar
PEFT alternatives. Besides the practical utility of our approach, we provide
insights on the trainability requirements of LoRA paths at different modules
and the freezing schedule for the different projection matrices. Code will be
released.
|
[
-0.6004164218902588,
-0.7810656428337097,
0.3305775821208954,
0.08359197527170181,
-0.337009996175766,
0.15495909750461578,
-0.18480511009693146,
-0.47685444355010986,
0.2620075047016144,
0.27870839834213257,
-0.45232871174812317,
-0.5105646848678589,
-0.44389235973358154,
-0.0014972316566854715,
-0.2774164378643036,
0.7827991247177124,
-0.17453138530254364,
-0.2311449944972992,
-0.3494266867637634,
-0.2744641602039337,
-0.4207315444946289,
-0.18572856485843658,
-0.5750861167907715,
-0.08751706033945084,
0.4456067979335785,
0.9250248670578003,
0.9558479189872742,
0.9483601450920105,
0.607656717300415,
0.29679688811302185,
-0.09907738864421844,
0.1559087485074997,
-0.7005414962768555,
0.15042617917060852,
-0.19683709740638733,
-0.5116785764694214,
-0.8447636365890503,
-0.16162040829658508,
0.5969550013542175,
0.41028445959091187,
-0.1797618269920349,
0.4635014832019806,
-0.01182093471288681,
0.812920093536377,
-1.1575294733047485,
-0.04576452448964119,
-0.7364066243171692,
0.14241831004619598,
-0.25253239274024963,
-0.20453697443008423,
-0.3494412302970886,
-0.09206108003854752,
-0.11437254399061203,
-1.0533918142318726,
0.1905788630247116,
0.23097418248653412,
0.7484352588653564,
0.765749990940094,
-0.12031275033950806,
0.35633760690689087,
-0.682608962059021,
0.7822393774986267,
-0.6597373485565186,
0.2585218846797943,
0.38685131072998047,
0.45883262157440186,
0.1002330556511879,
-0.7183606028556824,
0.14214171469211578,
-0.04207510128617287,
0.2149590253829956,
0.27297526597976685,
-0.271837443113327,
0.003990338649600744,
0.2607325315475464,
0.3000275790691376,
-0.593550980091095,
0.3721758723258972,
-0.4294760525226593,
-0.19157935678958893,
0.8325631022453308,
0.3035930097103119,
-0.0649079754948616,
0.3402175307273865,
-0.5505890846252441,
-0.18546612560749054,
-0.40624621510505676,
0.06484387814998627,
0.060501828789711,
0.4035417437553406,
-0.1649869978427887,
0.19228138029575348,
-0.4927241802215576,
0.5326955318450928,
0.3670634329319,
-0.2156163454055786,
0.31015339493751526,
0.43453720211982727,
-0.5475116968154907,
0.25159645080566406,
0.3630218803882599,
0.24605444073677063,
-0.12862235307693481,
-0.05321324244141579,
-0.028582485392689705,
0.061047088354825974,
0.21182218194007874,
-0.8868916034698486,
-0.5780819654464722,
0.3044813573360443,
-0.4588514268398285,
-0.4145343601703644,
-0.3168368339538574,
-0.9507486820220947,
-0.2498329132795334,
-0.13393989205360413,
0.7994021773338318,
-0.5801060795783997,
-0.208735391497612,
0.12302451580762863,
0.005519635044038296,
0.24603596329689026,
0.7973626852035522,
-0.9566752910614014,
0.6668834686279297,
0.6377951502799988,
0.8155601024627686,
-0.4419112205505371,
-0.5289090871810913,
-0.9984383583068848,
0.05144943296909332,
-0.6020554304122925,
0.8139919638633728,
-0.6118491888046265,
0.10989782214164734,
-0.21251720190048218,
-0.20926785469055176,
-0.22926531732082367,
-0.6259706020355225,
0.4157944917678833,
-0.3426198363304138,
-0.07274118810892105,
0.03397812321782112,
-0.36988532543182373,
-0.3054056763648987,
0.09864964336156845,
-0.5636311173439026,
1.1506601572036743,
0.2695547044277191,
-0.5906329154968262,
0.5933809876441956,
-0.8632680177688599,
-0.3156256079673767,
0.009296185337007046,
0.42921707034111023,
-0.6049672961235046,
0.15190774202346802,
0.36629775166511536,
0.5749210715293884,
-0.5967533588409424,
-0.15141703188419342,
-0.6673448085784912,
-0.5501222610473633,
-0.06492065638303757,
-0.18708886206150055,
0.3463309407234192,
0.40353548526763916,
-0.427221417427063,
0.2606998383998871,
-0.776832103729248,
0.009366459213197231,
0.08354400843381882,
-0.3882344663143158,
-0.28243228793144226,
-0.167852520942688,
0.1435711532831192,
-0.3144681453704834,
0.253095418214798,
-0.15454182028770447,
0.6235607862472534,
-0.2461307942867279,
0.5005221962928772,
0.8097356557846069,
-0.2230820208787918,
0.6624484658241272,
-0.4538016617298126,
0.5583827495574951,
0.10417786240577698,
0.4757954180240631,
-0.035311635583639145,
-0.5291345119476318,
-0.8815393447875977,
-0.5953535437583923,
0.4666072726249695,
0.25881069898605347,
-0.7437236905097961,
-0.11606895923614502,
0.17883849143981934,
-0.8669827580451965,
-0.38187238574028015,
0.13751691579818726,
0.23301935195922852,
0.38413912057876587,
0.7650603652000427,
-0.12059685587882996,
-0.35194340348243713,
-0.7687882781028748,
-0.0021069857757538557,
-0.17402614653110504,
-0.016375089064240456,
-0.013160613365471363,
0.7194252610206604,
0.044452354311943054,
0.9264086484909058,
-0.8278670907020569,
-0.3316418528556824,
0.22622835636138916,
0.4830046594142914,
0.3129846155643463,
0.7664947509765625,
1.2087682485580444,
-0.959344744682312,
-0.6252927184104919,
-0.10174848884344101,
-0.5052627921104431,
0.20411927998065948,
0.06450957804918289,
-0.23599617183208466,
0.4871709942817688,
0.47568073868751526,
-0.5487448573112488,
0.4252554476261139,
0.6780430674552917,
-0.4245167076587677,
0.5124378800392151,
-0.36733314394950867,
0.22222471237182617,
-0.9266886115074158,
0.21641196310520172,
-0.19921986758708954,
-0.2501091957092285,
-0.5110453963279724,
0.07653310149908066,
-0.004529955331236124,
-0.29679781198501587,
-0.585234522819519,
0.19209016859531403,
-0.47268617153167725,
-0.010984075255692005,
-0.11002278327941895,
-0.4890771210193634,
-0.13075672090053558,
0.6007333993911743,
-0.06358212977647781,
0.6615819334983826,
0.8224058747291565,
-0.4875200390815735,
0.3478756248950958,
0.2726685106754303,
-0.2481340616941452,
0.41566792130470276,
-0.3218020796775818,
0.27288496494293213,
-0.07806355506181717,
-0.11985451728105545,
-0.7514040470123291,
-0.33940035104751587,
0.37155428528785706,
-0.2815442979335785,
0.3589325249195099,
-0.4361700713634491,
-0.006107020657509565,
0.007469296921044588,
-0.5478560328483582,
0.5003241896629333,
0.8046841025352478,
-0.6212772727012634,
0.69415283203125,
0.2342231124639511,
-0.07468865811824799,
-0.5666515231132507,
-0.321984201669693,
-0.11942052841186523,
-0.9003044366836548,
-0.5302116274833679,
0.6802471280097961,
-0.5265263915061951,
-0.1655360907316208,
-0.0585499070584774,
-0.00847571436315775,
-0.19573870301246643,
0.5225238800048828,
0.10099493712186813,
-0.02526792697608471,
-0.6211015582084656,
0.011276657693088055,
0.2738068997859955,
-0.1655806005001068,
-0.21690280735492706,
-0.24365194141864777,
0.338055819272995,
-0.24241392314434052,
-0.07483012974262238,
-0.19819357991218567,
0.33192816376686096,
1.001254916191101,
-0.22065649926662445,
0.9448826313018799,
0.9897142648696899,
-0.6141617894172668,
-0.36613479256629944,
-0.44259941577911377,
-0.18735051155090332,
-0.48956161737442017,
0.21032501757144928,
-0.4122503101825714,
-0.6322223544120789,
0.6257928609848022,
-0.2844513952732086,
0.07199174910783768,
0.4874606132507324,
0.3362143635749817,
-0.0222310833632946,
1.0019667148590088,
1.0362787246704102,
-0.11957024037837982,
0.27705124020576477,
-0.31181642413139343,
-0.2875720262527466,
-0.5989563465118408,
0.016605528071522713,
-0.5615243315696716,
-0.4854969084262848,
-0.4119749963283539,
-0.4829332232475281,
0.4630894958972931,
0.5128189921379089,
-0.5134397745132446,
0.2522049844264984,
-0.5406596064567566,
0.2543930113315582,
0.4347703754901886,
0.16015754640102386,
0.20131920278072357,
-0.19506533443927765,
0.05024109408259392,
-0.0946592167019844,
-1.0918099880218506,
0.037480536848306656,
0.8626710176467896,
0.3365800380706787,
0.788470983505249,
-0.06141471490263939,
0.7245304584503174,
0.5489082932472229,
0.3614415228366852,
-0.9025112986564636,
0.26746752858161926,
-0.30117857456207275,
-0.4548925757408142,
-0.640699028968811,
-0.3081076443195343,
-0.5847415328025818,
0.2620791494846344,
-0.7058705687522888,
-0.9006545543670654,
0.38691195845603943,
0.6660767793655396,
-0.44344624876976013,
0.3968982398509979,
-0.6184149384498596,
0.8946344256401062,
-0.2717147469520569,
-0.6872590184211731,
-0.2257630079984665,
-0.386705219745636,
0.2010045200586319,
-0.43842923641204834,
-0.022775862365961075,
-0.3872847557067871,
-0.04882124811410904,
1.0948445796966553,
-0.4644499123096466,
0.6438295841217041,
-0.444982647895813,
0.09180846065282822,
-0.07047007232904434,
0.04922444000840187,
0.5070379972457886,
0.18908308446407318,
-0.36685124039649963,
0.1047784611582756,
0.25970155000686646,
-0.5680087804794312,
-0.5645270347595215,
0.39313769340515137,
-0.8696759939193726,
-0.6001120209693909,
-0.6655307412147522,
-0.6715555191040039,
-0.4254888892173767,
0.12552519142627716,
0.3120710849761963,
0.339959055185318,
-0.24478422105312347,
0.35592764616012573,
0.5186786651611328,
-0.15066686272621155,
0.33978036046028137,
0.6140171885490417,
-0.07430834323167801,
-0.5267577171325684,
0.8116936087608337,
0.13197141885757446,
-0.015508060343563557,
0.6551426649093628,
0.2549690902233124,
0.24971850216388702,
-0.956802487373352,
-0.3636612296104431,
0.1558489352464676,
-0.43694448471069336,
-0.8714631795883179,
-0.023903606459498405,
0.07051233947277069,
-0.3457358777523041,
-0.5890965461730957,
-0.9052000641822815,
-0.39037951827049255,
-0.5738369822502136,
0.3060128390789032,
0.9339920878410339,
0.5179837942123413,
-0.2942280173301697,
0.27892962098121643,
-0.6805484294891357,
0.18609751760959625,
0.10069799423217773,
0.2393387109041214,
-0.14765974879264832,
-0.6194807291030884,
-0.5145122408866882,
-0.028629042208194733,
-0.08252570033073425,
-0.5001600384712219,
0.5494759678840637,
0.6609508395195007,
0.417995810508728,
0.5723740458488464,
0.7105535268783569,
1.0414007902145386,
-0.2572390139102936,
0.386983722448349,
0.1784314662218094,
-1.0119320154190063,
0.43432167172431946,
-0.36899369955062866,
0.4620102047920227,
0.5160869359970093,
0.5858114957809448,
0.14739489555358887,
-0.2567535638809204,
-0.33329328894615173,
-1.0552228689193726,
0.8716951012611389,
0.1811235547065735,
-0.26814889907836914,
0.7163615822792053,
0.46996480226516724,
0.2528623044490814,
-0.01994307152926922,
-0.02874729037284851,
-0.058672331273555756,
-0.14872924983501434,
0.11064554005861282,
-0.3378750681877136,
-0.34004566073417664,
-0.21693825721740723,
-0.5101257562637329,
0.8263171315193176,
-0.723831057548523,
0.3450002372264862,
0.046537913382053375,
-0.12632399797439575,
-0.473681777715683,
-0.011687284335494041,
0.4849587082862854,
0.69146728515625,
-0.8041630387306213,
-0.04255448281764984,
0.6612181663513184,
-0.5077667236328125,
-0.02145869843661785,
0.21502156555652618,
0.0027802283875644207,
-0.34688398241996765,
0.3276170492172241,
0.732180655002594,
0.47878119349479675,
-0.24305041134357452,
0.019034530967473984,
-0.08448916673660278,
-0.4725351929664612,
-0.3451758027076721,
0.24274411797523499,
-0.09583184868097305,
0.6045966148376465,
0.5922030210494995,
0.4867473840713501,
0.09153279662132263,
-0.48602235317230225,
0.18641632795333862,
0.20264089107513428,
-0.32533562183380127,
-0.2607974112033844,
0.89732825756073,
0.06736838817596436,
0.07845919579267502,
0.7111636400222778,
0.3173712491989136,
-0.24199339747428894,
0.6233639717102051,
0.5974501371383667,
0.7210702300071716,
-0.3965941071510315,
0.4118330478668213,
0.3007410168647766,
0.12049566954374313,
-0.1412779539823532,
0.07303698360919952,
-0.0960669070482254,
-0.7868967652320862,
-0.253015398979187,
-0.9936748743057251,
-0.6193129420280457,
0.05072777718305588,
-1.0620790719985962,
0.37869274616241455,
-0.49943897128105164,
-0.15996281802654266,
0.0321914404630661,
0.007911890745162964,
-0.3819856643676758,
0.26743176579475403,
0.26269105076789856,
1.4052852392196655,
-1.099406361579895,
1.0147480964660645,
0.9500157237052917,
-0.12384715676307678,
-0.7102091312408447,
-0.04912792146205902,
-0.04152263328433037,
-0.6604518294334412,
0.24093928933143616,
-0.11989828944206238,
-0.2180296629667282,
0.04714638367295265,
-0.5650217533111572,
-1.322412371635437,
1.4786531925201416,
1.1617774963378906,
-0.13881681859493256,
-0.04616595804691315,
0.06578656286001205,
0.5393491983413696,
-0.4688730239868164,
0.06107737869024277,
0.7513166666030884,
0.6182706952095032,
0.15484219789505005,
-0.9786405563354492,
0.019931120797991753,
-0.4297787547111511,
-0.11269129812717438,
0.19768010079860687,
-0.9050725102424622,
0.9822321534156799,
-0.09356869012117386,
0.14607994258403778,
0.3761864900588989,
0.8016915917396545,
0.08633878827095032,
0.4470224976539612,
0.5762597918510437,
0.4691234529018402,
0.6933742165565491,
-0.10125961154699326,
0.5006846189498901,
-0.22607025504112244,
0.5724254250526428,
0.6767494082450867,
-0.27152806520462036,
0.9871918559074402,
0.4458540976047516,
0.09606072306632996,
0.1936393827199936,
0.6301026344299316,
-0.08142315596342087,
0.632905900478363,
-0.3278852105140686,
0.26411008834838867,
-0.575446367263794,
0.06442654132843018,
-0.39222127199172974,
0.8257791996002197,
0.3091478943824768,
0.04141242802143097,
0.0290373507887125,
0.3545505404472351,
0.08568523079156876,
-0.18968935310840607,
-0.7153919339179993,
0.568412721157074,
0.07536790519952774,
-0.5785278081893921,
1.218308687210083,
-0.18133515119552612,
0.544333279132843,
-0.552890956401825,
-0.13851989805698395,
-0.2872820198535919,
0.5032474398612976,
-0.4742884635925293,
-0.24804846942424774,
0.2625218629837036,
-0.06945503503084183,
-0.06119304895401001,
-0.14759819209575653,
0.7253516912460327,
-0.1036558747291565,
-0.3587417006492615,
0.44743189215660095,
0.19572623074054718,
0.049421053379774094,
-0.10655348002910614,
-0.7916103005409241,
0.3728969097137451,
-0.33293649554252625,
-0.5492506623268127,
0.6140725016593933,
0.001208420260809362,
0.022658340632915497,
0.7376559376716614,
0.414173424243927,
-0.14568625390529633,
-0.29415977001190186,
-0.5535694360733032,
1.0335770845413208,
-0.3797912001609802,
-0.4134155511856079,
-0.39200499653816223,
0.6085456013679504,
0.25644078850746155,
-0.4642482399940491,
0.3674114942550659,
0.6506715416908264,
0.6502209901809692,
-0.3452743887901306,
0.39781463146209717,
-0.0529203824698925,
0.19446751475334167,
-1.0679655075073242,
0.9054162502288818,
-0.964127779006958,
-0.025824643671512604,
-0.5210960507392883,
-1.0534934997558594,
-0.4613081216812134,
0.5029627680778503,
-0.31079983711242676,
-0.148903027176857,
0.795447587966919,
0.5974595546722412,
-0.45564788579940796,
-0.19256068766117096,
0.6278771758079529,
0.42160409688949585,
-0.12699513137340546,
0.6283422708511353,
0.584878146648407,
-0.5207724571228027,
0.5677624344825745,
-0.47271671891212463,
-0.3634738326072693,
-0.49467602372169495,
-0.8736280798912048,
-0.6852017045021057,
-0.7510000467300415,
-0.6738243699073792,
0.042794566601514816,
0.3318997323513031,
0.7914709448814392,
1.0946382284164429,
-1.0314098596572876,
-0.18223035335540771,
0.24597127735614777,
-0.21695475280284882,
-0.6618232727050781,
-0.165523961186409,
0.5052988529205322,
-0.06813842803239822,
-0.6873427033424377,
0.5198541879653931,
0.33099165558815,
-0.32802557945251465,
0.047152020037174225,
-0.24234209954738617,
-0.10707050561904907,
-0.02466440200805664,
0.4541762173175812,
0.4727524220943451,
-0.1421189308166504,
-0.5185099244117737,
-0.16885140538215637,
0.4659644663333893,
0.41366174817085266,
0.5073243975639343,
-0.8785299062728882,
0.15948940813541412,
0.5076779723167419,
0.27032122015953064,
0.9751741886138916,
0.06643351167440414,
0.6403106451034546,
-0.13512654602527618,
0.4010013937950134,
0.24014325439929962,
0.4871944189071655,
0.10701160877943039,
-0.4223478138446808,
0.6045737862586975,
-0.06633035838603973,
-0.5107578635215759,
-0.9138902425765991,
0.14441263675689697,
-1.1662663221359253,
-0.3721301853656769,
0.5570173263549805,
-0.26384663581848145,
-0.47975224256515503,
0.08916489779949188,
-0.12242807447910309,
0.20464274287223816,
-0.5313976407051086,
0.9950386881828308,
-0.023768743500113487,
-0.44630059599876404,
-0.27871137857437134,
-0.10378163307905197,
0.760849118232727,
0.4734449088573456,
-0.8796880841255188,
-0.04188459366559982,
0.19715355336666107,
0.2619696259498596,
0.2743273079395294,
0.33703821897506714,
0.2251845747232437,
0.5314563512802124,
0.08302916586399078,
-0.2915118932723999,
-0.24000681936740875,
-0.7094753384590149,
-0.3320578336715698,
0.4814041256904602,
0.49505823850631714,
0.10127431899309158
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.13257v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.13257v2
|
Arcee's MergeKit: A Toolkit for Merging Large Language Models
| 2024-03-20T02:38:01 | 2024-03-21T03:13:30 |
Charles Goddard, Shamane Siriwardhana, Malikeh Ehghaghi, Luke Meyers, Vlad Karpukhin, Brian Benedict, Mark McQuade, Jacob Solawetz
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
The rapid expansion of the open-source language model landscape presents an
opportunity to merge the competencies of these model checkpoints by combining
their parameters. Advances in transfer learning, the process of fine-tuning
pretrained models for specific tasks, has resulted in the development of vast
amounts of task-specific models, typically specialized in individual tasks and
unable to utilize each other's strengths. Model merging facilitates the
creation of multitask models without the need for additional training, offering
a promising avenue for enhancing model performance and versatility. By
preserving the intrinsic capabilities of the original models, model merging
addresses complex challenges in AI - including the difficulties of catastrophic
forgetting and multitask learning. To support this expanding area of research,
we introduce MergeKit, a comprehensive, open-source library designed to
facilitate the application of model merging strategies. MergeKit offers an
extensible framework to efficiently merge models on any hardware, providing
utility to researchers and practitioners. To date, thousands of models have
been merged by the open-source community, leading to the creation of some of
the worlds most powerful open-source model checkpoints, as assessed by the Open
LLM Leaderboard. The library is accessible at
https://github.com/arcee-ai/MergeKit.
|
[
-0.6740186810493469,
-0.30539563298225403,
0.3349002003669739,
0.15183088183403015,
0.09915240108966827,
0.28299444913864136,
-0.16224442422389984,
-0.6296090483665466,
0.040918320417404175,
0.7783024311065674,
-0.3320960998535156,
-0.093084417283535,
-0.6213223338127136,
-0.45431986451148987,
-0.9861639738082886,
0.8967352509498596,
-0.3304203748703003,
-0.1657230108976364,
-0.20909391343593597,
-0.22273464500904083,
-0.3735541105270386,
-0.32139715552330017,
-0.693454384803772,
-0.47391170263290405,
0.4325404763221741,
0.5016840100288391,
0.40959063172340393,
0.17674578726291656,
0.7237346172332764,
0.3128790259361267,
0.08714524656534195,
0.09217148274183273,
-0.29515308141708374,
0.3785949647426605,
-0.3556007444858551,
-0.32098478078842163,
-0.7246267199516296,
0.04329727217555046,
0.6329938173294067,
0.8989107012748718,
-0.3630172610282898,
0.17633894085884094,
0.12553849816322327,
0.46392521262168884,
-0.7298294901847839,
0.03809509798884392,
-0.40783339738845825,
-0.2171933650970459,
-0.2902100384235382,
0.22980690002441406,
-0.36819127202033997,
-0.5010688304901123,
0.07624223828315735,
-0.2582751512527466,
-0.07634405791759491,
-0.12194927036762238,
0.7081381678581238,
0.3211784362792969,
-0.3246891498565674,
0.26607802510261536,
-0.9028854370117188,
0.8215121626853943,
-0.8194435834884644,
0.3736027479171753,
0.23588381707668304,
0.5703915953636169,
-0.04744402691721916,
-0.5144107341766357,
-0.7887729406356812,
0.020990028977394104,
0.2627793252468109,
-0.13195867836475372,
-0.4781281352043152,
0.1389898806810379,
0.04755350202322006,
0.5997563004493713,
-0.5597796440124512,
0.3482934832572937,
-0.5105301141738892,
-0.11065492779016495,
0.4374876320362091,
0.05207334831357002,
0.6219615936279297,
0.4179731011390686,
0.007350282743573189,
-0.46870505809783936,
-0.42718449234962463,
-0.24600400030612946,
0.30960613489151,
0.3413245677947998,
-0.0225057490170002,
0.8639720678329468,
-0.18206149339675903,
0.6549057364463806,
-0.11639110743999481,
-0.08186226338148117,
0.26429519057273865,
-0.6337546110153198,
-0.3541110157966614,
-0.13751770555973053,
0.6776087284088135,
0.32558074593544006,
-0.03254234045743942,
-0.13991422951221466,
-0.24286501109600067,
-0.12080080062150955,
0.26874446868896484,
-0.5719727277755737,
-0.3317824900150299,
0.3064369857311249,
-0.2687126100063324,
-0.29128795862197876,
-0.2238113433122635,
-0.7352780103683472,
-0.2828426659107208,
-0.4365514814853668,
0.07840723544359207,
-0.4417530298233032,
-0.6932771801948547,
0.158222958445549,
-0.1659150868654251,
0.2408224493265152,
0.6138542294502258,
-0.5556222796440125,
0.1706867516040802,
0.6930365562438965,
0.9057140946388245,
-0.2755313217639923,
-0.6905989646911621,
-0.5583957433700562,
0.19505539536476135,
-0.25861215591430664,
0.6514093279838562,
-0.4347135126590729,
-0.39237621426582336,
-0.09189905971288681,
-0.03898860514163971,
-0.04126833379268646,
-0.5285226106643677,
0.025475839152932167,
-0.4337398111820221,
0.11911748349666595,
-0.03518310934305191,
-0.36031654477119446,
-0.4709790050983429,
0.2521536946296692,
-0.9491288661956787,
1.4538533687591553,
0.3560275435447693,
-0.3640351891517639,
0.25814926624298096,
-0.6500369906425476,
-0.3327290415763855,
0.17469526827335358,
0.247598335146904,
-0.12295950949192047,
0.04219665005803108,
0.02940972149372101,
0.34284308552742004,
-0.6890532970428467,
0.32242006063461304,
-0.392212837934494,
0.20986731350421906,
-0.1520462930202484,
-0.1588158756494522,
0.8670322299003601,
0.34848201274871826,
-0.18318654596805573,
0.2723023295402527,
-0.49115726351737976,
0.03198608383536339,
-0.22222130000591278,
-0.2730746269226074,
-0.5283263921737671,
-0.41017574071884155,
0.2532316744327545,
0.3174000680446625,
0.3593141734600067,
-0.2661759555339813,
0.5511317849159241,
-0.23157522082328796,
0.3219568729400635,
0.4604652225971222,
-0.31143680214881897,
0.7761318683624268,
-0.513602077960968,
0.5650460124015808,
0.16184677183628082,
-0.05975975841283798,
-0.3951704502105713,
-0.6845272183418274,
-0.9935306310653687,
-0.1353582739830017,
0.3676024079322815,
0.5990549325942993,
-0.4707539677619934,
0.7214916348457336,
-0.23762314021587372,
-0.9485487937927246,
-0.7640063166618347,
0.3311464488506317,
0.16693125665187836,
0.2803621292114258,
0.4289897084236145,
-0.7838801145553589,
-0.5118913054466248,
-0.7982627749443054,
0.0677928552031517,
-0.3954336643218994,
-0.027319731190800667,
0.20291297137737274,
0.5315711498260498,
-0.371489018201828,
1.1001043319702148,
-0.1675102859735489,
-0.20501866936683655,
-0.3878887891769409,
0.4341581165790558,
-0.07775478065013885,
0.790201723575592,
0.5819979310035706,
-0.4346791207790375,
-0.40542072057724,
0.5807579159736633,
-0.6110693216323853,
-0.07832755148410797,
-0.01355456281453371,
-0.09572217613458633,
-0.09733600169420242,
0.6635912656784058,
-0.5969974398612976,
0.27392295002937317,
0.7785608768463135,
0.03605320677161217,
0.7012912631034851,
-0.1404375582933426,
0.4764227271080017,
-1.429678201675415,
0.46817049384117126,
-0.31933438777923584,
-0.22456258535385132,
-0.5906639099121094,
0.36266055703163147,
0.0553838349878788,
-0.3861808776855469,
-0.6049265265464783,
0.9931180477142334,
-0.48511525988578796,
0.026391413062810898,
-0.26916176080703735,
-0.04401855915784836,
-0.25997841358184814,
0.11673147976398468,
-0.327313095331192,
0.8052418231964111,
0.7230606079101562,
-0.4846026599407196,
0.5654066205024719,
0.18880710005760193,
-0.4140610098838806,
0.5620279908180237,
-0.24596619606018066,
0.02327832020819187,
0.09026241302490234,
0.12195397913455963,
-0.8250725269317627,
-0.3861368000507355,
-0.01679583080112934,
-0.06975560635328293,
0.2701348662376404,
-0.1480139046907425,
-0.35113704204559326,
-0.4340784251689911,
-0.014220396056771278,
0.7371122241020203,
0.48545515537261963,
-0.5151185989379883,
1.1478443145751953,
0.45448070764541626,
-0.45065611600875854,
-0.6626838445663452,
-0.7591691017150879,
0.3579840064048767,
0.030519669875502586,
-0.6162585020065308,
0.39044466614723206,
-0.16742926836013794,
-0.11758925765752792,
0.37527579069137573,
0.0761324018239975,
-0.3752375841140747,
-0.03839139640331268,
0.23475958406925201,
0.4136297404766083,
-0.3569602370262146,
-0.1952696293592453,
0.2419828176498413,
0.035198383033275604,
-0.5099543333053589,
-0.20229698717594147,
0.5343178510665894,
0.11887574195861816,
-0.6668303608894348,
-0.44610998034477234,
0.4542849659919739,
1.2058581113815308,
-0.522774338722229,
1.0023490190505981,
0.3070071339607239,
-0.4189207851886749,
-0.22020578384399414,
-0.9112969636917114,
-0.009534785524010658,
-0.341498464345932,
0.43575266003608704,
-0.33051300048828125,
-1.0578479766845703,
0.6743793487548828,
-0.3850400745868683,
0.43161195516586304,
0.17171524465084076,
0.49887630343437195,
0.10009127855300903,
0.7823459506034851,
0.8842141032218933,
-0.5091431140899658,
0.6706512570381165,
-0.14182214438915253,
0.3510202169418335,
-0.9205372929573059,
-0.2059837281703949,
-0.7411774396896362,
-0.4042198657989502,
0.11025762557983398,
-0.651940643787384,
-0.2977742850780487,
0.22332242131233215,
-0.3959210216999054,
0.6225331425666809,
-0.39249590039253235,
0.6538481116294861,
0.48691630363464355,
-0.22640566527843475,
0.2753296196460724,
-0.1382109820842743,
-0.05301838368177414,
0.322757363319397,
-0.5626005530357361,
-0.2776251435279846,
1.123010516166687,
0.18878436088562012,
0.9456037282943726,
0.17302915453910828,
0.6860716938972473,
0.18516896665096283,
0.13645599782466888,
-0.7171953916549683,
0.6926199197769165,
-0.2738990783691406,
-0.45395398139953613,
-0.22151809930801392,
-0.2795064151287079,
-0.7381319403648376,
-0.030834635719656944,
-0.19692470133304596,
-0.8053406476974487,
0.2382706105709076,
0.19972924888134003,
-0.2350475788116455,
0.5991700887680054,
-0.6044046878814697,
0.8904048800468445,
-0.1667991429567337,
0.11812455207109451,
-0.404133677482605,
-0.17954891920089722,
0.7554810643196106,
-0.3993147015571594,
0.02851198799908161,
-0.33293038606643677,
0.1805161088705063,
0.5463041663169861,
-0.23148301243782043,
0.9279826283454895,
0.18604357540607452,
0.054611679166555405,
0.04066234827041626,
0.48898231983184814,
0.38462427258491516,
-0.6399676203727722,
0.20864459872245789,
0.325137197971344,
-0.13288354873657227,
-0.1469401717185974,
-0.41334980726242065,
0.8515877723693848,
-0.8222248554229736,
-0.34868863224983215,
-0.16833704710006714,
-0.6622346043586731,
-0.050609733909368515,
0.460228830575943,
-0.16316455602645874,
0.21154025197029114,
-0.3537555932998657,
0.16219191253185272,
0.45685890316963196,
-0.07431787997484207,
0.30783993005752563,
0.3773781955242157,
-0.552736759185791,
-0.25606581568717957,
0.8077606558799744,
-0.1614464968442917,
0.3709467351436615,
0.15130826830863953,
-0.19956032931804657,
0.1262284368276596,
-0.45829418301582336,
-0.1302095204591751,
0.32191798090934753,
-0.69981449842453,
-0.2797397971153259,
-0.5604165196418762,
-0.48760250210762024,
-0.466334730386734,
-0.33415576815605164,
-0.7477807402610779,
-0.5393146872520447,
-0.16113202273845673,
0.1337880641222,
0.24493081867694855,
0.7982316017150879,
-0.05250169709324837,
0.45681172609329224,
-1.1283246278762817,
0.0683184266090393,
0.3626207411289215,
0.3511180281639099,
0.3923848569393158,
-0.29040664434432983,
-0.23731157183647156,
-0.20207500457763672,
-0.23165345191955566,
-0.7861678600311279,
0.3173043727874756,
0.19074425101280212,
0.787108838558197,
0.18836252391338348,
-0.10569818317890167,
0.801020085811615,
-0.3457396924495697,
0.769374430179596,
0.5888815522193909,
-1.051434874534607,
0.6341966986656189,
0.003747036447748542,
0.3829081654548645,
0.7050320506095886,
0.3056214153766632,
-0.7291495203971863,
-0.7845352292060852,
-0.3562929332256317,
-0.9428235292434692,
0.8672562837600708,
0.040991734713315964,
-0.2600177526473999,
0.3029401898384094,
0.018005920574069023,
0.0888328030705452,
0.18129095435142517,
-0.420164555311203,
-0.17918282747268677,
-0.020641319453716278,
-0.36944714188575745,
-0.07036557793617249,
0.1462506800889969,
-0.3728903830051422,
-0.23089510202407837,
0.7880590558052063,
-0.10491978377103806,
-0.09481996297836304,
-0.468147337436676,
-0.36434462666511536,
-0.022293733432888985,
0.13649722933769226,
0.2633429169654846,
0.5008453726768494,
0.01988242194056511,
0.024618586525321007,
-0.050561875104904175,
-0.4627755582332611,
0.17791642248630524,
0.1902538388967514,
-0.06850305199623108,
-0.2582838237285614,
0.35269173979759216,
0.802374541759491,
0.2975204586982727,
-0.7390065789222717,
0.42316535115242004,
-0.19103707373142242,
-0.22834880650043488,
0.1569821834564209,
0.24873903393745422,
0.03217349946498871,
0.3750387728214264,
0.052461981773376465,
0.5171228051185608,
0.004042527172714472,
-0.5190094709396362,
0.22949965298175812,
0.4814951419830322,
-0.14420007169246674,
-0.34326040744781494,
0.7239933609962463,
0.49486055970191956,
-0.2450903207063675,
0.8275640606880188,
0.11039793491363525,
-0.5032801032066345,
0.5571331977844238,
0.2394578456878662,
1.160011649131775,
-0.5799220204353333,
0.020995737984776497,
0.5939798355102539,
0.4675193727016449,
-0.5690507292747498,
-0.21291516721248627,
-0.19213712215423584,
-0.8671629428863525,
-0.7002441883087158,
-0.6660105586051941,
-0.6167858839035034,
-0.03495434299111366,
-0.5600157380104065,
0.5100043416023254,
-0.0287949126213789,
-0.18690727651119232,
0.041320256888866425,
-0.4506151080131531,
-0.7776916027069092,
-0.1712283492088318,
0.08407250046730042,
1.1563864946365356,
-0.9644023776054382,
1.1665408611297607,
0.6768403053283691,
-0.584102213382721,
-0.8850517868995667,
-0.23786194622516632,
0.08305247873067856,
-0.7309890985488892,
0.5922407507896423,
0.084343321621418,
0.030340339988470078,
0.019749855622649193,
-0.18687379360198975,
-0.916820764541626,
1.0411057472229004,
0.6438900232315063,
-0.5986461639404297,
-0.5844369530677795,
-0.012829658575356007,
0.04588332772254944,
-0.3685031235218048,
0.2930161654949188,
0.8654183745384216,
0.5732600688934326,
0.4243464469909668,
-1.6123619079589844,
-0.12172050029039383,
-0.23088622093200684,
-0.15083681046962738,
0.6185341477394104,
-0.13481421768665314,
0.8767803311347961,
-0.07510523498058319,
-0.18540439009666443,
0.2376786172389984,
0.33403852581977844,
-0.06488659232854843,
-0.04753054678440094,
0.4102160930633545,
0.9651439189910889,
0.8681468367576599,
-0.23198089003562927,
0.721970796585083,
-0.4717273712158203,
0.4616447985172272,
1.2169357538223267,
-0.4076426029205322,
0.9447954893112183,
0.3902522623538971,
-0.09237571060657501,
0.39766010642051697,
0.29919150471687317,
0.040547292679548264,
0.3350132703781128,
-0.5038971900939941,
-0.2979619801044464,
-0.29309865832328796,
0.031884048134088516,
-0.49325695633888245,
0.43117600679397583,
0.11374887079000473,
-0.031425170600414276,
-0.4920196533203125,
0.2960953414440155,
-0.23891766369342804,
-0.3208235800266266,
-0.2561805844306946,
0.9568483829498291,
-0.07974915951490402,
-0.818480372428894,
0.09348788857460022,
-0.3613003194332123,
0.6330088376998901,
-0.8106362819671631,
-0.09109258651733398,
-0.17935040593147278,
0.21622417867183685,
-0.14968416094779968,
-1.0922983884811401,
0.5577395558357239,
-0.26895415782928467,
-0.2694467008113861,
-0.14858074486255646,
0.49211055040359497,
-0.725091278553009,
-0.2189512699842453,
0.5162012577056885,
0.5717685222625732,
0.16394662857055664,
0.0033224059734493494,
-0.8175846338272095,
0.19773711264133453,
0.10477226972579956,
0.3051990270614624,
0.4649445116519928,
0.1549651175737381,
0.045254796743392944,
0.7232410311698914,
0.6838922500610352,
0.33507442474365234,
-0.0010714147938415408,
0.03573613241314888,
0.9128206968307495,
-0.5719706416130066,
-0.5532195568084717,
-0.4224984347820282,
0.7521899342536926,
-0.06887975335121155,
-0.20271357893943787,
0.5808279514312744,
0.6138224005699158,
0.7851778864860535,
0.06874428689479828,
0.943121612071991,
-0.23728272318840027,
0.26051411032676697,
-0.27169692516326904,
0.8961409330368042,
-0.886474609375,
0.17562991380691528,
-0.01783188432455063,
-1.2508052587509155,
-0.24954082071781158,
0.27038905024528503,
0.03967403620481491,
0.057521216571331024,
0.5696445107460022,
0.7150991559028625,
-0.3600497245788574,
-0.28033286333084106,
0.35312193632125854,
0.12120913714170456,
0.5772371292114258,
0.5567622184753418,
0.5195872187614441,
-0.203149676322937,
0.5428129434585571,
-0.12518666684627533,
-0.5521049499511719,
-0.3646133840084076,
-0.8793658018112183,
-0.8409934639930725,
-0.9526710510253906,
-0.41512739658355713,
-0.2148624211549759,
-0.22028060257434845,
0.605006992816925,
0.93755042552948,
-0.9246237277984619,
-0.458790123462677,
-0.11126529425382614,
-0.03724336624145508,
-0.2922683358192444,
-0.1771397888660431,
-0.06284531205892563,
-0.44069743156433105,
-0.9921426177024841,
0.45991384983062744,
0.4153236746788025,
0.12830233573913574,
-0.3665924072265625,
-0.04626546427607536,
-0.23947201669216156,
0.13751868903636932,
0.3072403371334076,
0.7339844107627869,
-0.6983392238616943,
0.024169012904167175,
-0.11256613582372665,
-0.0730271264910698,
-0.13264796137809753,
1.0603731870651245,
-0.6676808595657349,
0.8669545650482178,
0.5259982943534851,
0.9550222158432007,
0.4085236191749573,
-0.3417772650718689,
0.9245761632919312,
-0.6546540856361389,
0.21342496573925018,
0.08571191877126694,
0.5976006984710693,
0.3433725833892822,
0.11731310933828354,
0.44637081027030945,
-0.09256646782159805,
-0.673484742641449,
-1.1444686651229858,
0.20217715203762054,
-1.113996982574463,
-0.21647904813289642,
0.6346689462661743,
0.14779745042324066,
0.1110754981637001,
-0.05945051088929176,
-0.20967578887939453,
0.21164648234844208,
-0.3385835587978363,
0.2496844083070755,
1.0113019943237305,
-0.04466939717531204,
-0.2905351221561432,
-0.2736457884311676,
0.3553229570388794,
0.11738370358943939,
-0.9950829744338989,
0.3225816786289215,
0.26667487621307373,
0.09284354746341705,
0.46286800503730774,
0.3310777544975281,
0.12016584724187851,
0.5939269065856934,
0.10921046137809753,
0.6261923313140869,
-0.04650267958641052,
-0.407940536737442,
-0.40290310978889465,
0.11072877049446106,
0.31735631823539734,
0.019901474937796593
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.13253v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.13253v1
|
Document Author Classification Using Parsed Language Structure
| 2024-03-20T02:32:24 | 2024-03-20T02:32:24 |
Todd K Moon, Jacob H. Gunther
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, eess.AS
|
Over the years there has been ongoing interest in detecting authorship of a
text based on statistical properties of the text, such as by using occurrence
rates of noncontextual words. In previous work, these techniques have been
used, for example, to determine authorship of all of \emph{The Federalist
Papers}. Such methods may be useful in more modern times to detect fake or AI
authorship. Progress in statistical natural language parsers introduces the
possibility of using grammatical structure to detect authorship. In this paper
we explore a new possibility for detecting authorship using grammatical
structural information extracted using a statistical natural language parser.
This paper provides a proof of concept, testing author classification based on
grammatical structure on a set of "proof texts," The Federalist Papers and
Sanditon which have been as test cases in previous authorship detection
studies. Several features extracted from the statistical natural language
parser were explored: all subtrees of some depth from any level; rooted
subtrees of some depth, part of speech, and part of speech by level in the
parse tree. It was found to be helpful to project the features into a lower
dimensional space. Statistical experiments on these documents demonstrate that
information from a statistical parser can, in fact, assist in distinguishing
authors.
|
[
0.09862640500068665,
-0.9488614797592163,
0.9379866719245911,
0.16036033630371094,
0.11349072307348251,
0.11075283586978912,
-0.1592298001050949,
-0.4747317135334015,
0.3478444218635559,
0.4682176113128662,
0.008137439377605915,
-0.564574122428894,
-0.6610773205757141,
0.6303460001945496,
-0.6215899586677551,
0.8360611200332642,
0.23854579031467438,
-0.02700837142765522,
-0.6099376082420349,
0.1015666052699089,
-0.09377194941043854,
-0.5491594076156616,
-0.5950157642364502,
-0.12570638954639435,
0.42729660868644714,
0.052298132330179214,
0.6119576692581177,
0.9766086935997009,
0.48843175172805786,
0.5435346961021423,
-0.19734570384025574,
-0.36957550048828125,
-0.010032008402049541,
0.18447357416152954,
-0.12110119313001633,
-0.817157506942749,
-0.49168556928634644,
0.045234378427267075,
0.7400804162025452,
0.7314527034759521,
-0.009446133859455585,
0.00043302212725393474,
-0.23875100910663605,
0.30293670296669006,
-0.5367713570594788,
0.5317561030387878,
-0.38999006152153015,
-0.06701531261205673,
-0.7351338863372803,
-0.4762464761734009,
-1.0321604013442993,
-0.7016316652297974,
-0.2076074331998825,
-0.3389231860637665,
0.7995815873146057,
0.13347819447517395,
0.5315496325492859,
-0.1415412873029709,
-0.48239439725875854,
-0.37023505568504333,
-0.37081965804100037,
0.7095788717269897,
-0.6322043538093567,
0.39016011357307434,
0.5031614303588867,
0.30349841713905334,
-0.22215251624584198,
-0.525363564491272,
-0.5197457671165466,
-0.42110711336135864,
-0.47564461827278137,
-0.2387535125017166,
-0.2620389759540558,
0.11995477974414825,
0.19793780148029327,
0.7972468733787537,
-0.7206491827964783,
0.07389659434556961,
-0.14258639514446259,
-0.28596732020378113,
0.6404731273651123,
-0.25705239176750183,
0.6383010149002075,
-0.44905105233192444,
-0.17389099299907684,
-0.36537864804267883,
-0.23907850682735443,
0.448471337556839,
0.7011333703994751,
0.3852737843990326,
-0.13912948966026306,
0.6452370882034302,
-0.13624083995819092,
0.4093337953090668,
-0.048743199557065964,
-0.4258420169353485,
0.41199612617492676,
-0.20282383263111115,
-0.2265625149011612,
0.26721715927124023,
0.8519229292869568,
-0.3529737591743469,
0.547231912612915,
-0.1988995373249054,
-0.16692669689655304,
0.2540951669216156,
0.020089328289031982,
-0.48410800099372864,
-0.5201190710067749,
-0.050638969987630844,
-0.7180716395378113,
-0.3789164125919342,
0.6798340082168579,
-0.6123510003089905,
-0.48620128631591797,
-0.17069242894649506,
-0.13443978130817413,
-0.557822585105896,
-0.47629931569099426,
-0.06859876960515976,
-0.38449665904045105,
0.09482705593109131,
0.369966983795166,
-1.0308098793029785,
0.661884605884552,
0.8780905604362488,
0.6341595649719238,
0.2927161157131195,
-0.3266887068748474,
-0.624237060546875,
-0.07493411004543304,
-0.32969120144844055,
0.938029944896698,
-0.5900388360023499,
0.18113131821155548,
0.10257110744714737,
-0.04694697633385658,
-0.18512113392353058,
-0.2421538084745407,
0.5685963034629822,
-0.4673439562320709,
0.7231135368347168,
-0.30915290117263794,
-0.8931835889816284,
0.043540772050619125,
0.00853006262332201,
-0.6076322793960571,
0.722752034664154,
0.12524455785751343,
-0.6530789732933044,
0.5467015504837036,
-0.5773111581802368,
-0.6640076041221619,
0.3359808325767517,
-0.4432388246059418,
-0.4356721341609955,
0.2315463274717331,
0.2172345221042633,
0.6121193170547485,
-0.11236181855201721,
0.4471195638179779,
-0.23224225640296936,
0.22005595266819,
0.4789605736732483,
-0.045433495193719864,
1.168585181236267,
0.16792699694633484,
-0.2295292764902115,
-0.0845123678445816,
-0.9281324744224548,
-0.07832539081573486,
0.3044036626815796,
-0.33220335841178894,
-0.5678539872169495,
0.17705968022346497,
0.19531333446502686,
-0.4167618453502655,
0.24004247784614563,
-0.8221362829208374,
0.11136582493782043,
-0.3673839867115021,
-0.04922666773200035,
0.6783517599105835,
0.18636064231395721,
0.5415874719619751,
-0.36804768443107605,
0.7021583318710327,
-0.6131952404975891,
-0.21997539699077606,
-0.2714315950870514,
-0.6903024315834045,
-0.4464666545391083,
-0.7488580942153931,
0.4747810959815979,
0.6073279976844788,
-0.2204425036907196,
0.9964302778244019,
-0.27214348316192627,
-0.3215717673301697,
-0.10630878806114197,
0.18860958516597748,
0.6163298487663269,
0.3648446202278137,
0.328635036945343,
0.10493211448192596,
-0.49958425760269165,
-0.9154501557350159,
-0.7032360434532166,
-0.6473904848098755,
-0.2590693533420563,
-0.2181272953748703,
0.5919085144996643,
0.2584001421928406,
1.08936607837677,
-0.832097589969635,
-0.39110198616981506,
-0.1985001266002655,
0.3940470814704895,
0.1927245557308197,
0.5077619552612305,
0.6256161332130432,
-0.6512486934661865,
-0.4123583734035492,
0.18819886445999146,
-0.7817394137382507,
-0.5570972561836243,
-0.10238906741142273,
0.06314017623662949,
0.2722947597503662,
0.6844384074211121,
-0.438742995262146,
0.47201892733573914,
0.0036219237372279167,
-0.6113851070404053,
0.21303650736808777,
0.03872956335544586,
0.1522117704153061,
-0.9249646663665771,
0.22846005856990814,
0.05745829641819,
-0.44398969411849976,
-0.5013241767883301,
0.034931425005197525,
0.1218542531132698,
0.17442287504673004,
0.19238175451755524,
0.1467163860797882,
-0.4838731288909912,
-0.11353927105665207,
0.059040557593107224,
-0.22314302623271942,
-0.218368262052536,
0.394513338804245,
-0.06974677741527557,
0.2130512297153473,
0.21879148483276367,
-0.0915275439620018,
0.23419326543807983,
0.22259709239006042,
-0.4928165078163147,
0.7740943431854248,
-0.32922661304473877,
-0.07507004588842392,
-0.374381422996521,
0.2021298110485077,
-1.3812483549118042,
-0.4149170517921448,
-0.022135009989142418,
-0.6709805130958557,
0.20472145080566406,
-0.35205981135368347,
-1.1902661323547363,
0.2728746831417084,
-0.18733958899974823,
0.0012072095414623618,
0.301625519990921,
-0.3806486427783966,
0.4771042764186859,
0.3390165865421295,
-0.47316014766693115,
-0.023900220170617104,
-0.5520445704460144,
0.15852777659893036,
-0.16110165417194366,
-0.7933862805366516,
0.327223002910614,
0.28995195031166077,
-0.5255470871925354,
0.2595824599266052,
0.08551269769668579,
-0.32753515243530273,
0.2516198456287384,
0.1103125587105751,
0.04012192040681839,
-0.4059014320373535,
0.023564161732792854,
0.2595778703689575,
-0.12223371118307114,
0.26881784200668335,
0.13153624534606934,
0.14727900922298431,
-0.13526436686515808,
-0.12369220703840256,
-0.5875666737556458,
0.27291426062583923,
0.39024028182029724,
-0.3220025599002838,
0.7394310235977173,
0.34676283597946167,
-0.4951223134994507,
-0.35937801003456116,
-0.6332404613494873,
-0.04459937661886215,
-0.3552963137626648,
-0.036206457763910294,
-0.20471800863742828,
-0.7178899049758911,
0.5731746554374695,
0.16562823951244354,
-0.203531414270401,
0.6189361214637756,
0.26300936937332153,
0.0761830285191536,
0.683833658695221,
0.6611292362213135,
-0.06983300298452377,
0.47717589139938354,
-0.13282464444637299,
0.09741103649139404,
-0.209663525223732,
-0.2758435904979706,
-0.9988266229629517,
-0.23567815124988556,
-0.5998221635818481,
-0.006138884462416172,
0.017300745472311974,
-0.16729439795017242,
0.01098449807614088,
0.7320550084114075,
-0.34144991636276245,
0.7131021618843079,
0.4659275412559509,
-0.2651023268699646,
0.4694308638572693,
0.09846401959657669,
-0.09619179368019104,
-0.05296630039811134,
-0.11495576053857803,
-0.6971067190170288,
0.5943611264228821,
0.3863234519958496,
0.5778989195823669,
0.5228768587112427,
0.7897049188613892,
0.6239708662033081,
0.11672279238700867,
-0.5317429900169373,
0.7054226994514465,
-0.15315616130828857,
-0.7283031940460205,
-0.22370357811450958,
-0.5329430103302002,
-0.8377712368965149,
0.3956339657306671,
-0.241888627409935,
-0.7461925745010376,
0.4921034276485443,
0.0008860543021000922,
-0.025420306250452995,
0.10738138109445572,
-0.7168534398078918,
0.8417671322822571,
-0.09359386563301086,
-0.028370849788188934,
0.11633414030075073,
-0.6741101741790771,
0.21059413254261017,
0.04650476202368736,
0.3592129349708557,
0.03858364000916481,
0.19933456182479858,
0.8671026825904846,
-0.48944801092147827,
0.9726359844207764,
-0.2895471453666687,
-0.18155615031719208,
-0.04948541149497032,
0.2511371970176697,
0.3548170328140259,
0.1171664223074913,
-0.1256353259086609,
-0.09782905876636505,
-0.015984047204256058,
-0.30121010541915894,
-0.4846232831478119,
0.5423902273178101,
-0.4249572455883026,
-0.13395792245864868,
-0.7659898400306702,
-0.18322765827178955,
0.16694511473178864,
0.5059056878089905,
0.3239991366863251,
0.4439243674278259,
-0.27812114357948303,
0.719188392162323,
0.1585155725479126,
0.1003863513469696,
0.2759971618652344,
0.26010453701019287,
-0.07643163949251175,
-0.6460674405097961,
0.48920783400535583,
0.041309405118227005,
-0.12182841449975967,
0.9397358894348145,
0.4843718409538269,
-0.3210555911064148,
-0.4920406639575958,
-0.09365767985582352,
0.15010672807693481,
-0.5426284074783325,
-0.15495643019676208,
-0.721900463104248,
0.02712646685540676,
-0.8540558815002441,
-0.4428507685661316,
0.00034110393607988954,
-0.48918768763542175,
-0.26292139291763306,
-0.15383820235729218,
0.049032729119062424,
0.7537784576416016,
0.34187421202659607,
0.5180025100708008,
-0.17086641490459442,
0.2819610834121704,
0.17535777390003204,
0.1986815482378006,
-0.15881314873695374,
-0.24061769247055054,
-0.015491794794797897,
-0.4540520906448364,
-0.2801375687122345,
-1.0331238508224487,
0.298259437084198,
0.2403465062379837,
0.7391920685768127,
0.7449854016304016,
0.051129814237356186,
0.4545082747936249,
-0.412356436252594,
0.4879548251628876,
-0.06970924884080887,
-1.095615267753601,
0.6894519329071045,
-0.5213490128517151,
-0.2017216980457306,
0.720255434513092,
0.06405077129602432,
-0.1462227702140808,
-0.7521359920501709,
-0.7799699306488037,
-0.41209009289741516,
0.8014197945594788,
0.624656617641449,
-0.24712328612804413,
-0.035297296941280365,
0.14310267567634583,
0.1300630122423172,
0.16490177810192108,
-1.0996016263961792,
0.11395293474197388,
0.20917023718357086,
-0.417453795671463,
0.022255703806877136,
-0.2882583439350128,
0.029798904433846474,
-0.2095794528722763,
0.3806679844856262,
-0.0762905701994896,
0.07300445437431335,
0.3915066719055176,
-0.3158167600631714,
-0.012002399191260338,
0.4583939015865326,
0.4451526403427124,
0.8303533792495728,
-0.3708820044994354,
0.3958275020122528,
-0.26846763491630554,
-0.08743032068014145,
0.05442379415035248,
0.2798520028591156,
-0.05956778675317764,
-0.010005197487771511,
1.2879760265350342,
0.5097627639770508,
0.26946407556533813,
-0.1469929814338684,
0.8692201375961304,
0.07361029833555222,
-0.37383168935775757,
-0.6182764768600464,
0.16782230138778687,
-0.16976317763328552,
0.16955815255641937,
0.3731938302516937,
0.273760050535202,
0.3079748749732971,
-0.5366867780685425,
0.07981530576944351,
0.2842579782009125,
0.2589706778526306,
-0.6965607404708862,
0.5218263268470764,
0.06840468943119049,
-0.45762574672698975,
0.21271134912967682,
-0.3262613117694855,
-0.46906161308288574,
0.6741704344749451,
0.863786518573761,
1.01931893825531,
-0.41864901781082153,
0.3239118158817291,
0.07028698176145554,
0.43557068705558777,
-0.2111155390739441,
0.17945034801959991,
-0.3599354326725006,
-0.6081870794296265,
-0.3340761065483093,
-0.6174781322479248,
-0.28694429993629456,
-0.06264720112085342,
-0.5700031518936157,
0.23111200332641602,
-0.6150479912757874,
-0.06642331182956696,
0.567363440990448,
-0.1361333280801773,
-0.15460357069969177,
-0.24553319811820984,
0.16407176852226257,
0.48493555188179016,
-1.4044504165649414,
0.5919796228408813,
0.9131736159324646,
-0.2160993367433548,
-0.24816909432411194,
-0.027446968480944633,
0.4332056939601898,
-0.32601097226142883,
0.6299247741699219,
0.27070891857147217,
-0.02477852813899517,
-0.0871046707034111,
-0.440349817276001,
-0.5294695496559143,
0.7312266826629639,
0.592004656791687,
0.11475776880979538,
0.08452142775058746,
0.05689249187707901,
0.7999781966209412,
-0.39291825890541077,
-0.1339070349931717,
-0.060349367558956146,
0.4974302351474762,
-0.08511076122522354,
-0.6751052737236023,
0.12358307838439941,
-0.5158753395080566,
-0.01674771122634411,
0.5608121752738953,
0.02149113081395626,
1.2066380977630615,
0.21411333978176117,
-0.40088579058647156,
0.201558455824852,
0.8120262026786804,
0.16009880602359772,
0.5181581377983093,
0.9126598834991455,
0.6815906167030334,
1.0780344009399414,
0.12356312572956085,
0.9893543124198914,
0.10321230441331863,
0.4006187617778778,
0.7928882241249084,
-0.1760745644569397,
0.7651407718658447,
0.2532866299152374,
-0.5062416195869446,
1.0265371799468994,
-0.04588787257671356,
-0.3588915765285492,
0.2778930962085724,
0.2687746584415436,
-0.1995394229888916,
-0.06493394076824188,
0.1180635318160057,
-0.28574132919311523,
0.519744873046875,
-0.04511741176247597,
-0.7607911229133606,
-0.17767548561096191,
-0.15065507590770721,
0.4113561511039734,
0.7483109831809998,
0.2486467808485031,
0.7402755618095398,
-0.006007996853441,
-0.5856841802597046,
-0.058010149747133255,
0.2119327336549759,
0.28420668840408325,
-0.45592057704925537,
-0.0256500206887722,
-0.0556558221578598,
0.4487350881099701,
-0.4676039516925812,
-0.7128116488456726,
0.18119072914123535,
0.3135012090206146,
-0.36806511878967285,
-0.62550288438797,
0.720733642578125,
-0.28649646043777466,
-0.6630739569664001,
0.1633516550064087,
0.38653141260147095,
0.21952256560325623,
-0.12913797795772552,
0.05288362503051758,
-0.42293035984039307,
-0.2157139629125595,
0.058268915861845016,
-0.01704593561589718,
0.52635657787323,
-0.037894006818532944,
0.17787492275238037,
1.0125588178634644,
0.1130392998456955,
-0.04326356574892998,
-0.11723358929157257,
0.43446630239486694,
-0.7528643608093262,
-0.9706052541732788,
-1.2252253293991089,
0.22295792400836945,
-0.3937529921531677,
-0.48238158226013184,
1.0806692838668823,
0.940335750579834,
0.7868574857711792,
-0.13172927498817444,
0.49098026752471924,
-0.4618625342845917,
0.42203620076179504,
-0.5606995820999146,
0.7837520837783813,
-0.3467976152896881,
-0.03724907711148262,
-0.7408726811408997,
-0.7620322108268738,
-0.6466204524040222,
0.6648499965667725,
-0.3689771890640259,
-0.14110644161701202,
1.0780894756317139,
0.400900661945343,
-0.15287534892559052,
0.18902112543582916,
-0.030763065442442894,
0.03880152478814125,
0.607211709022522,
0.06200959533452988,
0.5618656277656555,
-0.2613135576248169,
0.24678008258342743,
-0.5512006878852844,
-0.46996474266052246,
-0.1866849660873413,
-0.9524833559989929,
-1.0560318231582642,
-0.8676865696907043,
-0.3959018588066101,
-0.12728318572044373,
-0.29624444246292114,
0.7345796227455139,
0.5040571689605713,
-0.9126049280166626,
-0.31682726740837097,
-0.40769657492637634,
0.16698122024536133,
-0.10570873320102692,
-0.3097328245639801,
0.4976547956466675,
-0.34863734245300293,
-0.5995029807090759,
0.5361223816871643,
0.16085757315158844,
-0.13712967932224274,
0.13047164678573608,
0.3765032887458801,
-0.4975241720676422,
-0.2980339527130127,
0.470537394285202,
0.21514616906642914,
-0.755247950553894,
-0.18572670221328735,
0.06509074568748474,
-0.19433020055294037,
-0.08758005499839783,
0.8846447467803955,
-0.5084106922149658,
0.26787298917770386,
1.0201975107192993,
0.5213128328323364,
0.030847735702991486,
0.40306633710861206,
0.3982783257961273,
-1.0415611267089844,
-0.05609789118170738,
0.20740734040737152,
0.6466957330703735,
0.14411020278930664,
-0.6082621812820435,
0.49703070521354675,
0.6313738822937012,
-0.7000024914741516,
-0.8900535106658936,
-0.07731258869171143,
-1.203510046005249,
-0.10462696850299835,
0.8067182302474976,
-0.054164059460163116,
-0.3746986389160156,
-0.13068260252475739,
-0.1949392557144165,
0.0658622458577156,
-0.4771917164325714,
0.48405128717422485,
0.7268610000610352,
-0.15902017056941986,
-0.0728859007358551,
-0.25840023159980774,
0.27295058965682983,
0.26353490352630615,
-0.9893603920936584,
-0.032828912138938904,
0.5584656596183777,
0.11289108544588089,
0.7163214683532715,
0.9041413068771362,
-0.3378453850746155,
0.07739845663309097,
-0.09348394721746445,
0.1686464101076126,
-0.054042696952819824,
-0.3420794606208801,
-0.1992902308702469,
0.5668392181396484,
-0.10132073611021042,
-0.2456686645746231
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.13250v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.13250v1
|
Facilitating Pornographic Text Detection for Open-Domain Dialogue Systems via Knowledge Distillation of Large Language Models
| 2024-03-20T02:29:09 | 2024-03-20T02:29:09 |
Huachuan Qiu, Shuai Zhang, Hongliang He, Anqi Li, Zhenzhong Lan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Pornographic content occurring in human-machine interaction dialogues can
cause severe side effects for users in open-domain dialogue systems. However,
research on detecting pornographic language within human-machine interaction
dialogues is an important subject that is rarely studied. To advance in this
direction, we introduce CensorChat, a dialogue monitoring dataset aimed at
detecting whether the dialogue session contains pornographic content. To this
end, we collect real-life human-machine interaction dialogues in the wild and
break them down into single utterances and single-turn dialogues, with the last
utterance spoken by the chatbot. We propose utilizing knowledge distillation of
large language models to annotate the dataset. Specifically, first, the raw
dataset is annotated by four open-source large language models, with the
majority vote determining the label. Second, we use ChatGPT to update the empty
label from the first step. Third, to ensure the quality of the validation and
test sets, we utilize GPT-4 for label calibration. If the current label does
not match the one generated by GPT-4, we employ a self-criticism strategy to
verify its correctness. Finally, to facilitate the detection of pornographic
text, we develop a series of text classifiers using a pseudo-labeled dataset.
Detailed data analysis demonstrates that leveraging knowledge distillation
techniques with large language models provides a practical and cost-efficient
method for developing pornographic text detectors.
|
[
-0.3435579240322113,
-0.8379164338111877,
0.5377580523490906,
-0.17442813515663147,
-0.571712076663971,
-0.07625386118888855,
-0.04846660792827606,
-0.16956500709056854,
-0.09540846943855286,
0.9587864279747009,
-0.3486252427101135,
-0.8042305111885071,
-0.6231027841567993,
-0.05271086469292641,
-0.6217103600502014,
1.2271884679794312,
0.22505314648151398,
-0.23418082296848297,
-0.18879300355911255,
0.12489096075296402,
-0.3368373513221741,
-0.8022378087043762,
-0.39777839183807373,
0.04792095348238945,
0.2796570062637329,
0.17561271786689758,
0.6473895311355591,
0.2974216938018799,
0.16176100075244904,
0.39576631784439087,
0.07336271554231644,
0.4769532382488251,
-0.7274775505065918,
0.5340341925621033,
-0.18021699786186218,
-0.1830357015132904,
-0.18834957480430603,
-0.20293046534061432,
0.3021526336669922,
0.12360405176877975,
-0.012720702216029167,
-0.08733497560024261,
0.20866559445858002,
0.5309658050537109,
-0.7366580963134766,
0.33292824029922485,
-0.5035011768341064,
0.14321507513523102,
-0.4131343364715576,
-0.1470261663198471,
-0.5734753012657166,
-0.3286750614643097,
0.08097659051418304,
-0.23681704699993134,
0.22487996518611908,
0.028299158439040184,
0.5293200016021729,
0.277190238237381,
-0.4602166712284088,
-0.5116118788719177,
-0.9370701909065247,
0.6494153141975403,
-0.8973154425621033,
0.5396286249160767,
0.9071412682533264,
0.19365032017230988,
-0.14808885753154755,
-0.7923668026924133,
-0.7202785611152649,
-0.4938953220844269,
-0.24305257201194763,
-0.020792875438928604,
-0.35713738203048706,
0.060774244368076324,
-0.021621350198984146,
0.1572568565607071,
-0.3887113034725189,
-0.13597692549228668,
-0.42702516913414,
-0.4263550341129303,
0.37250640988349915,
-0.05459866672754288,
0.5264843702316284,
-0.2652033567428589,
-0.3922165036201477,
0.10885198414325714,
-0.49864205718040466,
-0.35604187846183777,
0.5761952996253967,
0.0647883340716362,
0.30780553817749023,
0.4333679974079132,
0.17064522206783295,
0.4897441565990448,
-0.2009628862142563,
-0.0549011155962944,
0.022324588149785995,
-0.33148592710494995,
-0.18809565901756287,
0.10121355205774307,
1.075487494468689,
0.41810494661331177,
0.33833277225494385,
0.13897021114826202,
-0.14914445579051971,
0.027565274387598038,
0.3917824327945709,
-1.0211424827575684,
-0.7365748286247253,
0.026193758472800255,
-0.13248009979724884,
-0.41435226798057556,
-0.23530809581279755,
-0.8226246237754822,
-0.9898297786712646,
-0.2129795253276825,
0.2174614816904068,
-0.3765988051891327,
-0.41223016381263733,
0.2703818380832672,
-0.08898007124662399,
-0.25995898246765137,
0.3428029716014862,
-0.8353234529495239,
0.32039114832878113,
0.5146311521530151,
0.6249383091926575,
-0.0922665148973465,
0.3057440519332886,
-0.6241302490234375,
-0.12283091247081757,
-0.20807184278964996,
0.4179264307022095,
-0.5176302790641785,
-0.271536648273468,
0.2574150264263153,
-0.010706005617976189,
0.16724319756031036,
-0.45295950770378113,
0.6963494420051575,
-0.6103255152702332,
0.23909108340740204,
0.18461371958255768,
-0.5908020734786987,
-0.058336835354566574,
0.3545578420162201,
-0.7210557460784912,
0.7763059735298157,
-0.0454513244330883,
-1.0408596992492676,
0.14103323221206665,
-0.4507625699043274,
-0.15190979838371277,
0.05237967520952225,
0.02154809609055519,
-0.6016277074813843,
-0.4022837281227112,
0.1954607218503952,
0.34854501485824585,
-0.19267530739307404,
0.4523926377296448,
-0.28976836800575256,
-0.24768571555614471,
0.6236759424209595,
-0.8996381163597107,
0.5812589526176453,
0.22729864716529846,
-0.3370104432106018,
-0.1599486768245697,
-0.47108373045921326,
-0.26307278871536255,
-0.14152629673480988,
0.07889176905155182,
-0.6172357201576233,
0.1992958039045334,
0.057248733937740326,
0.06706331670284271,
0.19696871936321259,
-0.8075194954872131,
-0.07287511229515076,
-0.13380318880081177,
0.43994906544685364,
0.6688240170478821,
0.16612020134925842,
0.07297216355800629,
-0.049199748784303665,
0.4679281711578369,
0.23157116770744324,
0.4226290285587311,
-0.13005734980106354,
-0.7992154955863953,
-0.8423988223075867,
-0.13157875835895538,
0.020645994693040848,
0.4261057674884796,
-0.990575909614563,
0.39221706986427307,
0.12304273992776871,
-0.45512712001800537,
-0.2828485667705536,
0.1040787473320961,
0.7069675922393799,
0.4391085207462311,
0.4152425527572632,
-0.11256318539381027,
-0.33748966455459595,
-0.801000714302063,
-0.15600156784057617,
-0.4269430637359619,
-0.16483250260353088,
0.38820016384124756,
0.36130204796791077,
-0.04116303473711014,
0.8598511219024658,
-0.775278627872467,
-0.6622235178947449,
0.10784396529197693,
0.14595931768417358,
0.11812794208526611,
0.29997724294662476,
0.4782218635082245,
-1.179482102394104,
-0.5177628397941589,
0.04642516374588013,
-0.6495051383972168,
-0.21596269309520721,
0.42587539553642273,
-0.07407088577747345,
-0.04346296563744545,
0.595077395439148,
-0.18371929228305817,
0.5643221139907837,
0.5103287100791931,
-0.23545204102993011,
0.6090497970581055,
-0.26475784182548523,
0.5296658873558044,
-0.7954581379890442,
-0.10494966059923172,
0.2833515703678131,
-0.3293551206588745,
-0.8956730961799622,
-0.3291991353034973,
-0.19048605859279633,
0.0445125550031662,
-0.7196038365364075,
0.31965529918670654,
-0.11280536651611328,
0.4090607762336731,
-0.19664165377616882,
0.4741876423358917,
0.051203273236751556,
0.6193177700042725,
0.1801404356956482,
0.6636449098587036,
0.19922950863838196,
-0.5313990116119385,
0.5105808973312378,
0.4527260363101959,
-0.3648742437362671,
0.3550436198711395,
-0.40780285000801086,
0.5255461931228638,
0.009096176363527775,
0.31733277440071106,
-1.305612564086914,
-0.10510455071926117,
0.44880300760269165,
-0.3971921503543854,
-0.10327454656362534,
-0.7089629769325256,
-0.5108402371406555,
-0.21713095903396606,
-0.2590859532356262,
0.29877758026123047,
0.3635057508945465,
-0.49388551712036133,
0.19870737195014954,
0.8616710305213928,
-0.1677837371826172,
-0.7283618450164795,
-0.3606143891811371,
0.04835982620716095,
-0.06006249412894249,
-0.5534843802452087,
-0.09754527360200882,
0.02101324312388897,
-0.09352026134729385,
-0.25728726387023926,
-0.1864578127861023,
-0.4583229422569275,
-0.12629160284996033,
0.33776819705963135,
0.49420320987701416,
0.06709207594394684,
0.29557856917381287,
0.1529323160648346,
0.14292117953300476,
0.10570896416902542,
-0.539719820022583,
0.642836332321167,
0.0011707128724083304,
-0.44956716895103455,
-0.2949484586715698,
0.011186942458152771,
0.36469608545303345,
-0.19105665385723114,
0.42308029532432556,
0.6412733197212219,
-0.21435227990150452,
-0.21655212342739105,
-0.35579636693000793,
-0.1808663010597229,
-0.5386903285980225,
0.25722765922546387,
-0.08663523942232132,
-1.076733946800232,
0.1507788896560669,
0.034334369003772736,
0.14682051539421082,
0.11844345927238464,
0.42006948590278625,
-0.004913590382784605,
1.1387288570404053,
0.4249032735824585,
0.07615533471107483,
0.3746976852416992,
-0.11386065930128098,
0.39578691124916077,
-0.5831629037857056,
-0.13712915778160095,
-0.7311729788780212,
-0.047975532710552216,
-0.6882205009460449,
-0.583161473274231,
0.5157636404037476,
-0.17523883283138275,
-0.13678385317325592,
0.5135647058486938,
-0.7232717871665955,
0.6243025064468384,
0.3475760817527771,
0.3656255006790161,
0.6213754415512085,
-0.2717806100845337,
-0.10853066295385361,
-0.14490438997745514,
-0.16387279331684113,
-0.731032133102417,
0.8947839736938477,
0.23355861008167267,
0.7982479333877563,
0.3347947299480438,
0.534551739692688,
0.7078278064727783,
0.4707567095756531,
-0.6126664876937866,
0.5913764834403992,
-0.6333861351013184,
-0.8347817063331604,
-0.3034973740577698,
-0.28144875168800354,
-0.8742038011550903,
0.2896486222743988,
0.056453887373209,
-1.0218027830123901,
0.11390065401792526,
0.16706208884716034,
0.008289427496492863,
0.5317445397377014,
-0.49461740255355835,
0.7426404356956482,
0.21103012561798096,
-0.5807875394821167,
0.05593385919928551,
-0.49410611391067505,
0.675695538520813,
-0.25177881121635437,
0.4286673069000244,
-0.1701202541589737,
0.1706276386976242,
0.6977162957191467,
-0.5617377161979675,
1.2705316543579102,
-0.3515233099460602,
-0.5619014501571655,
0.6017470955848694,
0.33630046248435974,
0.3850889503955841,
0.07678434997797012,
0.08700783550739288,
0.1635448932647705,
0.16514348983764648,
0.13942454755306244,
-0.276328980922699,
0.6214065551757812,
-0.5672298669815063,
-0.7339757084846497,
-0.25737372040748596,
-0.08454705029726028,
-0.33873072266578674,
0.17637933790683746,
0.21273311972618103,
0.5482504367828369,
-0.374701589345932,
0.3168914020061493,
0.7668147087097168,
-0.39572906494140625,
-0.00934972520917654,
0.322608083486557,
-0.6594310402870178,
-0.23229287564754486,
0.952297031879425,
-0.25206801295280457,
0.31055501103401184,
0.34702521562576294,
0.35804787278175354,
-0.676572322845459,
-0.5319392085075378,
-0.722988486289978,
0.02247980795800686,
-0.916671633720398,
-0.19793161749839783,
-0.9536919593811035,
-0.41312190890312195,
-0.37178370356559753,
0.2777990996837616,
-0.20527061820030212,
-0.07153399288654327,
-0.1650892049074173,
0.12274216115474701,
0.4298490583896637,
0.7861446738243103,
0.2760615646839142,
0.20728044211864471,
-1.1873364448547363,
0.45971816778182983,
0.4709677994251251,
0.20729433000087738,
-0.20418915152549744,
-0.6175040602684021,
-0.0811285600066185,
0.40074995160102844,
-0.47984468936920166,
-0.7945250272750854,
0.614978551864624,
0.1910180300474167,
0.12406755983829498,
0.4126565456390381,
0.5784833431243896,
0.12092241644859314,
-0.3416636288166046,
0.9064064025878906,
0.1549367755651474,
-0.8970379829406738,
0.5292375683784485,
-0.4998650550842285,
0.01751602254807949,
0.36892169713974,
0.47028157114982605,
-0.7423654794692993,
-0.8258855938911438,
-0.3571431636810303,
-0.5065030455589294,
0.6522895097732544,
0.4828404486179352,
0.464866578578949,
-0.2803112268447876,
-0.18331576883792877,
0.19520631432533264,
0.3005533516407013,
-0.5138818621635437,
-0.13500821590423584,
-0.3006979823112488,
-0.16422341763973236,
0.09413096308708191,
-0.07480064034461975,
-0.023431649431586266,
0.14195823669433594,
0.6378925442695618,
-0.11663129925727844,
-0.031942203640937805,
0.03134291619062424,
-0.34904393553733826,
0.1502886265516281,
0.40731123089790344,
0.37257876992225647,
0.37875688076019287,
-0.23209135234355927,
0.19961027801036835,
-0.2505365312099457,
-1.0658512115478516,
0.3119809925556183,
-0.14408570528030396,
-0.06970237195491791,
0.22370055317878723,
0.05756175145506859,
0.7503944635391235,
0.2061719298362732,
-0.6612351536750793,
0.8791953325271606,
-0.2307448536157608,
-0.1304711550474167,
-0.3047167658805847,
0.26571035385131836,
0.08387603610754013,
0.06382974982261658,
0.1585567146539688,
-0.020662160590291023,
0.5777252316474915,
-0.3658844232559204,
0.48747849464416504,
0.0980655625462532,
-0.7439258098602295,
-0.11731179803609848,
0.6938955783843994,
0.24107575416564941,
-0.3169836401939392,
0.6908534169197083,
-0.12918983399868011,
-0.7031039595603943,
0.6338364481925964,
0.29339709877967834,
0.8392928838729858,
-0.29358479380607605,
0.556930422782898,
0.3542747497558594,
-0.021586822345852852,
0.1252487599849701,
-0.2644846737384796,
-0.17091140151023865,
-0.9969255328178406,
-0.39076122641563416,
-0.8262248039245605,
-0.6041703224182129,
0.35896486043930054,
-0.3362636864185333,
0.446772962808609,
-0.34389638900756836,
-0.19865405559539795,
0.5126034021377563,
-0.42107051610946655,
-0.4250962734222412,
0.08798941969871521,
0.17682290077209473,
0.30114462971687317,
-0.795265257358551,
0.9803072810173035,
0.2321803867816925,
-0.34815940260887146,
-0.3789360225200653,
-0.17085497081279755,
0.2622838318347931,
-0.6317945718765259,
0.7289368510246277,
0.2696213126182556,
-0.3763082027435303,
-0.04363559931516647,
-0.5758082270622253,
-0.1218673512339592,
0.5026660561561584,
0.14997173845767975,
-0.7103366255760193,
0.1760154515504837,
0.2459457665681839,
0.7417274117469788,
-0.07695751637220383,
0.345137357711792,
0.5523048639297485,
0.45861154794692993,
0.35377952456474304,
-1.0107272863388062,
-0.13512329757213593,
-0.34732767939567566,
-0.2522491216659546,
0.6476786732673645,
-0.19219686090946198,
0.7406914234161377,
0.05635720491409302,
-0.34471797943115234,
0.025525039061903954,
0.3650623559951782,
0.24944651126861572,
0.48975706100463867,
0.7673046588897705,
0.06460675597190857,
0.5564956665039062,
-0.035192567855119705,
0.5314160585403442,
0.01625101827085018,
0.4454095661640167,
1.2112789154052734,
-0.39085426926612854,
0.5573280453681946,
0.11365122348070145,
-0.3010362684726715,
0.5012903213500977,
0.3137695789337158,
0.004786698613315821,
0.37916651368141174,
0.5955712199211121,
-0.706702470779419,
-0.2189503163099289,
-0.23901091516017914,
-0.056428611278533936,
0.5465087890625,
0.6280211210250854,
-0.35044771432876587,
-0.3284604847431183,
0.4401886761188507,
0.24106502532958984,
0.2877206802368164,
-0.0399390384554863,
1.0507467985153198,
0.02500363066792488,
-0.7246012091636658,
0.7144071459770203,
-0.2956836521625519,
0.5827763676643372,
-0.44650864601135254,
-0.2926112711429596,
-0.08825521916151047,
0.31131428480148315,
-0.03417932614684105,
-0.9674530625343323,
0.034963224083185196,
0.3468177914619446,
0.18648366630077362,
-0.10144505649805069,
1.1452372074127197,
-0.7901306748390198,
-0.02520616725087166,
0.17805878818035126,
0.2987004816532135,
0.5136673450469971,
-0.3841779828071594,
-0.33177539706230164,
-0.02986469864845276,
0.27272120118141174,
0.04530266672372818,
0.2886647582054138,
0.5547197461128235,
-0.21468280255794525,
0.623562753200531,
0.8373043537139893,
-0.28377512097358704,
-0.09039890766143799,
0.23434297740459442,
1.0964475870132446,
-0.2502741813659668,
-0.44635361433029175,
-0.9058232307434082,
0.40744873881340027,
-0.30441737174987793,
-0.07362724095582962,
0.5743736624717712,
0.5067214965820312,
0.5763953328132629,
-0.12018999457359314,
0.9297948479652405,
-0.044021591544151306,
0.14452405273914337,
-0.40503397583961487,
1.0010040998458862,
-0.09652049094438553,
0.43297356367111206,
-0.32447412610054016,
-0.8867669105529785,
-0.11771523207426071,
0.25737833976745605,
-0.27046263217926025,
-0.20544444024562836,
0.5929078459739685,
0.9524242877960205,
-0.20848508179187775,
0.5230466723442078,
0.6538539528846741,
0.2837775945663452,
0.7244978547096252,
0.25220775604248047,
0.9770295023918152,
-0.3498021364212036,
0.6805713772773743,
-0.15043452382087708,
-0.2737486660480499,
-0.22503474354743958,
-0.8998095393180847,
-1.0178849697113037,
-0.8793577551841736,
-0.3404039740562439,
-0.5493743419647217,
0.09901337325572968,
0.4774269759654999,
0.5129448771476746,
-0.7775812149047852,
-0.03386513888835907,
0.08248571306467056,
-0.04210096225142479,
0.12290230393409729,
-0.18999016284942627,
0.3817172050476074,
-0.24312879145145416,
-1.0322712659835815,
0.22961260378360748,
0.2739889621734619,
-0.13764715194702148,
-0.5951567888259888,
0.2458953559398651,
-0.2940175533294678,
0.24228668212890625,
0.6334748268127441,
-0.03509707376360893,
-0.29314500093460083,
-0.36547067761421204,
-0.05783546715974808,
-0.156904935836792,
-0.09679403156042099,
0.8833959698677063,
-0.49317288398742676,
0.734302282333374,
0.4687127470970154,
0.3713800013065338,
0.855804443359375,
-0.18450696766376495,
0.42557644844055176,
-0.9680267572402954,
0.0318773090839386,
0.42871445417404175,
0.17807434499263763,
0.34995102882385254,
-0.4403476417064667,
0.4604480564594269,
0.12265269458293915,
-0.7185875177383423,
-0.653760552406311,
0.1451706737279892,
-0.72825026512146,
-0.2827848494052887,
1.123145580291748,
-0.5853352546691895,
-0.320472776889801,
-0.8008094429969788,
-0.6591086983680725,
0.2720170319080353,
-0.43294259905815125,
0.751297652721405,
0.8588466644287109,
0.2678777277469635,
-0.10970839858055115,
-0.7883748412132263,
0.7330780625343323,
-0.17758195102214813,
-0.8447509407997131,
0.5898679494857788,
0.7498151063919067,
0.1981983184814453,
0.19178801774978638,
0.7484117150306702,
-0.3018949031829834,
0.07203441858291626,
-0.12345453351736069,
0.019169865176081657,
0.0653877705335617,
-0.14628209173679352,
0.25846120715141296,
0.07194841653108597,
-0.33592644333839417,
-0.3464548587799072
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.13244v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.13244v1
|
Instruction Multi-Constraint Molecular Generation Using a Teacher-Student Large Language Model
| 2024-03-20T02:15:55 | 2024-03-20T02:15:55 |
Peng Zhou, Jianmin Wang, Chunyan Li, Zixu Wang, Yiping Liu, Siqi Sun, Jianxin Lin, Longyue Wang, Xiangxiang Zeng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
While various models and computational tools have been proposed for structure
and property analysis of molecules, generating molecules that conform to all
desired structures and properties remains a challenge. Here, we introduce a
multi-constraint molecular generation large language model, TSMMG, which, akin
to a student, incorporates knowledge from various small models and tools,
namely, the 'teachers'. To train TSMMG, we construct a large set of
text-molecule pairs by extracting molecular knowledge from these 'teachers',
enabling it to generate novel molecules that conform to the descriptions
through various text prompts. We experimentally show that TSMMG remarkably
performs in generating molecules meeting complex, natural language-described
property requirements across two-, three-, and four-constraint tasks, with an
average molecular validity of over 99% and success ratio of 88.08%, 65.27%, and
61.44%, respectively. The model also exhibits adaptability through zero-shot
testing, creating molecules that satisfy combinations of properties that have
not been encountered. It can comprehend text inputs with various language
styles, extending beyond the confines of outlined prompts, as confirmed through
empirical validation. Additionally, the knowledge distillation feature of TSMMG
contributes to the continuous enhancement of small models, while the innovative
approach to dataset construction effectively addresses the issues of data
scarcity and quality, which positions TSMMG as a promising tool in the domains
of drug discovery and materials science. Code is available at
https://github.com/HHW-zhou/TSMMG.
|
[
-0.15134307742118835,
-0.706214189529419,
0.6517254114151001,
-0.34417468309402466,
-0.06314334273338318,
0.3013816475868225,
-0.44606977701187134,
0.019284503534436226,
-0.20449303090572357,
0.41450467705726624,
-0.4464038610458374,
-0.6795071363449097,
-0.6748932003974915,
0.2311362326145172,
-0.0208327267318964,
1.0291192531585693,
-0.13101667165756226,
0.03509386628866196,
-0.18991240859031677,
0.1875111162662506,
-0.11610682308673859,
-0.28883448243141174,
0.02112695388495922,
-0.28696855902671814,
0.3226460814476013,
0.8051776885986328,
0.40699461102485657,
0.857133150100708,
0.3885960280895233,
0.2827368676662445,
-0.01839165762066841,
0.3738952577114105,
-0.2907058000564575,
0.0000813955266494304,
-0.1807609647512436,
-0.13959626853466034,
-0.36283791065216064,
0.22171321511268616,
0.5662080645561218,
0.8386164307594299,
-0.21662241220474243,
0.10165850818157196,
0.12955734133720398,
0.400483638048172,
-0.2809017598628998,
0.05918329209089279,
-0.6419624090194702,
0.22753308713436127,
-0.16582629084587097,
0.06555472314357758,
-0.3696552515029907,
-0.17768113315105438,
0.476572185754776,
-0.5794870853424072,
0.6189999580383301,
-0.13768364489078522,
0.9756919145584106,
0.060819923877716064,
-0.9700581431388855,
-0.5950754284858704,
-0.6129631400108337,
0.7718843221664429,
-0.7221156358718872,
0.30994120240211487,
-0.025344010442495346,
0.5058998465538025,
-0.5215209722518921,
-0.6705039739608765,
-0.4326728880405426,
-0.7529995441436768,
0.1159970760345459,
0.061421819031238556,
0.5951970815658569,
0.35623395442962646,
0.07464559376239777,
0.4963897466659546,
-0.5906708240509033,
-0.35337916016578674,
-0.7568095326423645,
-0.15294088423252106,
0.2271302044391632,
0.031883604824543,
0.15723496675491333,
-0.5154742002487183,
-0.5956480503082275,
-0.10176092386245728,
-0.5673434138298035,
-0.3930709958076477,
0.2208433896303177,
0.5824565291404724,
0.15552455186843872,
0.9088680744171143,
0.14527156949043274,
0.7370073795318604,
-0.1469055712223053,
-0.1883554458618164,
-0.06146613508462906,
-0.5337985754013062,
0.016163941472768784,
0.36396491527557373,
0.7377852201461792,
0.1686353087425232,
0.18451522290706635,
0.08227650821208954,
0.018618352711200714,
-0.12236255407333374,
0.2377946972846985,
-1.2419705390930176,
-0.4058014154434204,
0.22807936370372772,
-0.16853214800357819,
-0.4759950339794159,
0.16573414206504822,
-0.9667909741401672,
-0.39222073554992676,
-0.18182691931724548,
0.6226925849914551,
-0.5170289278030396,
-0.06335002928972244,
0.2492188811302185,
-0.5018581748008728,
-0.28702226281166077,
-0.055802058428525925,
-1.0064687728881836,
0.23809881508350372,
0.29680538177490234,
0.9565539956092834,
-0.1685093641281128,
-0.44973117113113403,
-0.4907948076725006,
0.6801971793174744,
0.0332634299993515,
0.4210794270038605,
-0.5872324109077454,
-0.5871456861495972,
-0.41357144713401794,
-0.26863357424736023,
0.0760251134634018,
-0.6256808638572693,
-0.17799243330955505,
0.11424347013235092,
0.36144351959228516,
-0.12736226618289948,
-0.7415276765823364,
0.06502312421798706,
0.1925666332244873,
-0.5046309232711792,
0.7386434674263,
0.49106156826019287,
-0.18392731249332428,
0.3768059015274048,
-0.698188841342926,
-0.2778337895870209,
-0.01622593216598034,
-0.34021610021591187,
-0.5465864539146423,
0.1546831727027893,
0.03629929944872856,
0.4368549585342407,
-0.4659089744091034,
0.5511182546615601,
-0.3272162675857544,
0.2361653745174408,
0.3710012137889862,
0.0015871007926762104,
0.45039212703704834,
0.08717308193445206,
-0.2552957236766815,
0.014651256613433361,
-1.0346356630325317,
-0.06898624449968338,
-0.037404466420412064,
-0.6583300828933716,
0.30265533924102783,
-0.21833185851573944,
-0.05399433895945549,
0.3579523265361786,
0.18429751694202423,
-0.5603587627410889,
0.657191812992096,
-0.041588082909584045,
0.8940145373344421,
0.7729109525680542,
0.4156133830547333,
0.48669347167015076,
-0.16792169213294983,
0.4982130527496338,
0.21899914741516113,
-0.1931930035352707,
-0.06212339177727699,
-0.33063071966171265,
-0.7064571380615234,
-0.02307409606873989,
0.4078271687030792,
0.1833011656999588,
-0.6098612546920776,
0.2702030837535858,
-0.11675751954317093,
-0.48562705516815186,
-0.10564915835857391,
0.6142078638076782,
0.49865850806236267,
0.5764221549034119,
0.3830009698867798,
-0.13480503857135773,
-0.4708031415939331,
-0.7348394393920898,
-0.18523241579532623,
0.012760276906192303,
-0.018376648426055908,
0.4367785155773163,
0.7675973176956177,
-0.06909964233636856,
0.7332640290260315,
-0.9371826648712158,
-0.3907787799835205,
-0.3333151042461395,
0.20073182880878448,
-0.00714539922773838,
0.5314835906028748,
0.5028199553489685,
-0.4654618203639984,
-0.3051568567752838,
0.13191665709018707,
-0.5696023106575012,
-0.036908071488142014,
-0.1711377501487732,
-0.5081144571304321,
-0.029921473935246468,
0.39060044288635254,
-0.5910647511482239,
-0.10785514116287231,
0.29438188672065735,
-0.29148629307746887,
0.7138528823852539,
-0.26006755232810974,
-0.21587088704109192,
-1.508652687072754,
-0.004372237715870142,
0.20866453647613525,
-0.12356539815664291,
-0.857465922832489,
-0.06092478334903717,
-0.12018834799528122,
-0.5480146408081055,
-0.4813476800918579,
0.512326717376709,
-0.519951581954956,
0.26566174626350403,
-0.27961865067481995,
0.003808090463280678,
0.2728954255580902,
0.6429988741874695,
0.12311966717243195,
0.5599982142448425,
0.34524086117744446,
-0.8545063138008118,
0.26386988162994385,
0.24449224770069122,
-0.11402133852243423,
0.30274003744125366,
-0.5580456256866455,
0.056724101305007935,
0.21672894060611725,
0.019382178783416748,
-0.5924986004829407,
-0.6572511196136475,
0.10342192649841309,
-0.41835537552833557,
0.41657155752182007,
-0.1963745653629303,
-0.4165956377983093,
-0.4801560342311859,
-0.04168764874339104,
0.06465639919042587,
0.31561851501464844,
-0.46170178055763245,
0.8082999587059021,
0.19958271086215973,
0.20747743546962738,
-0.23648566007614136,
-0.696777880191803,
-0.06634209305047989,
-0.21488171815872192,
-0.47104397416114807,
0.27049562335014343,
-0.1491655856370926,
0.09215818345546722,
0.10438887774944305,
-0.39078250527381897,
-0.22553712129592896,
0.017389891669154167,
0.03153456747531891,
0.23457960784435272,
-0.2057134509086609,
0.2606399357318878,
0.04350084811449051,
0.04176025465130806,
0.036801330745220184,
-0.8265069127082825,
0.3187580704689026,
-0.09979051351547241,
0.18729279935359955,
0.04286013916134834,
0.28044119477272034,
0.6784961223602295,
-0.25937265157699585,
0.7824321985244751,
0.40540990233421326,
-0.23918600380420685,
-0.7390708923339844,
0.10654924809932709,
-0.5530907511711121,
-0.5603525638580322,
0.5151051878929138,
-0.48771166801452637,
-0.6899636387825012,
0.173359677195549,
-0.18388298153877258,
-0.0749017670750618,
0.10835392773151398,
0.6388949751853943,
0.13763554394245148,
0.5785613656044006,
0.5205777883529663,
0.5419837236404419,
0.27367520332336426,
-0.25222542881965637,
0.24374648928642273,
-0.4764711260795593,
-0.3460273742675781,
-0.3542467951774597,
-0.2518950402736664,
-0.4382866621017456,
-0.38843774795532227,
0.739181399345398,
0.17357467114925385,
-0.2435527741909027,
0.5442654490470886,
-0.7620982527732849,
0.48813697695732117,
0.875469446182251,
0.33871957659721375,
-0.04861827194690704,
0.03595329821109772,
-0.35256868600845337,
0.12008478492498398,
-0.7243449091911316,
-0.5720496773719788,
1.4094067811965942,
-0.15878762304782867,
0.5023707151412964,
0.26799702644348145,
0.8262093663215637,
-0.1157136857509613,
-0.15566451847553253,
-0.6915790438652039,
0.6412459015846252,
-0.1305655688047409,
-0.8016334176063538,
-0.04904014989733696,
-0.8557248115539551,
-0.6463064551353455,
-0.009187901392579079,
-0.28210675716400146,
-0.4618927240371704,
-0.014405549503862858,
0.4106987714767456,
-0.3030191957950592,
0.3793838322162628,
-1.0659903287887573,
0.9985069632530212,
-0.37323880195617676,
-0.3801027238368988,
0.0050928620621562,
-0.6902631521224976,
0.6152552962303162,
-0.16134542226791382,
-0.12569405138492584,
-0.15683838725090027,
0.1056535542011261,
0.5611955523490906,
-0.8788202404975891,
0.5558619499206543,
-0.13543352484703064,
-0.11203765869140625,
0.520077645778656,
0.3231659531593323,
0.07006880640983582,
-0.10164913535118103,
0.007526396308094263,
-0.2681583762168884,
-0.11188826709985733,
-0.5176835060119629,
-0.6441020965576172,
0.6228682994842529,
-0.6895610690116882,
-0.6763917207717896,
-0.3187406659126282,
-0.7004197835922241,
-0.2145766317844391,
0.4630342423915863,
0.3221982419490814,
0.39798593521118164,
-0.014309216290712357,
0.017077269032597542,
0.508945107460022,
-0.3345485031604767,
0.1755092740058899,
0.4322471022605896,
-0.19125761091709137,
-0.39670631289482117,
1.434083342552185,
0.32123175263404846,
0.7054097652435303,
0.34148457646369934,
0.603291392326355,
-0.08468504995107651,
-0.38775569200515747,
-0.5118001103401184,
0.06374463438987732,
-0.380317747592926,
-0.2043425738811493,
-0.4289189577102661,
-0.3092316687107086,
-0.4733147621154785,
-0.11533887684345245,
-0.46538588404655457,
-0.7454025745391846,
-0.344194620847702,
-0.2536536157131195,
0.42113402485847473,
0.7698545455932617,
-0.13347101211547852,
0.1884918212890625,
-1.0872389078140259,
0.5745993852615356,
0.5433765053749084,
0.2049211710691452,
-0.20807833969593048,
-0.2611781656742096,
-0.3868081569671631,
0.004900467116385698,
-0.7208606004714966,
-1.0657603740692139,
0.05305175855755806,
0.5554379224777222,
0.24105021357536316,
0.44872188568115234,
-0.051076970994472504,
0.2638925015926361,
-0.6145597100257874,
0.7599157094955444,
0.03160183131694794,
-1.0080671310424805,
0.8521080613136292,
-0.591877281665802,
0.312181293964386,
0.31892621517181396,
0.15453074872493744,
-0.27507486939430237,
-0.5413288474082947,
-0.4851010739803314,
-0.7552347779273987,
0.6723378896713257,
0.4591900408267975,
-0.1820567548274994,
0.056150734424591064,
0.43614059686660767,
0.15489645302295685,
0.4428451359272003,
-0.7691699862480164,
-0.20496441423892975,
-0.47419431805610657,
-0.38624557852745056,
0.15335708856582642,
-0.1420433074235916,
-0.1998223513364792,
-0.06608648598194122,
0.7127416133880615,
-0.09416363388299942,
0.07706054300069809,
-0.0802789032459259,
-0.03565715625882149,
0.18436604738235474,
0.3923381268978119,
0.8090660572052002,
0.40731093287467957,
-0.5426858067512512,
0.38188016414642334,
-0.21681199967861176,
-0.688727617263794,
0.49465757608413696,
0.23702287673950195,
-0.046147335320711136,
-0.043010808527469635,
-0.02651122398674488,
0.564041018486023,
-0.24987564980983734,
-0.7107572555541992,
0.1684150993824005,
0.28736013174057007,
-0.47973641753196716,
0.26782339811325073,
0.4018726944923401,
0.07417464256286621,
0.07684732973575592,
0.1193787008523941,
0.08485936373472214,
-0.027941003441810608,
-0.5299179553985596,
0.24770863354206085,
0.07087390869855881,
-0.06432672590017319,
-0.23434360325336456,
0.8278678059577942,
0.2168893665075302,
-0.01572861149907112,
0.42960163950920105,
-0.44458073377609253,
-0.6307485699653625,
0.7938242554664612,
0.5795463919639587,
0.6520335674285889,
-0.34255290031433105,
0.28110799193382263,
0.6122244596481323,
0.26942822337150574,
-0.0728607028722763,
0.31478309631347656,
-0.16158054769039154,
-0.6308565139770508,
0.26324671506881714,
-0.44043204188346863,
-0.4761751890182495,
-0.02499162219464779,
-0.28593266010284424,
0.3396890163421631,
-0.7767987251281738,
0.014834478497505188,
0.2978213131427765,
0.11204274743795395,
-0.26551562547683716,
0.07079019397497177,
0.02331789769232273,
0.38458800315856934,
-0.6235918998718262,
0.9407941699028015,
0.5651929378509521,
-0.4686703085899353,
-0.8311974406242371,
-0.2101449817419052,
0.5111655592918396,
-0.29289188981056213,
0.4809868037700653,
0.3725524842739105,
-0.12105787545442581,
-0.09555458277463913,
-0.5027287602424622,
-0.6652088165283203,
1.038508415222168,
0.46256721019744873,
-0.5316435098648071,
-0.2002534717321396,
0.4256359338760376,
0.4449058473110199,
-0.25188127160072327,
-0.1844908893108368,
0.6150330305099487,
0.49755361676216125,
0.23684062063694,
-0.578269898891449,
0.05796414613723755,
-0.2641388773918152,
-0.0187647994607687,
0.3758395314216614,
-0.6858822703361511,
0.807274580001831,
-0.35953089594841003,
-0.13906826078891754,
0.04474222660064697,
0.5551632046699524,
0.6786025166511536,
0.09405501186847687,
0.028526222333312035,
0.47909197211265564,
0.8521453738212585,
-0.22595219314098358,
0.7506281733512878,
-0.4064830243587494,
0.24890315532684326,
1.247867226600647,
-0.2553195357322693,
0.3974197506904602,
0.5501089692115784,
0.009035219438374043,
0.3277016878128052,
0.32062312960624695,
-0.5236383080482483,
0.35039544105529785,
0.5876635909080505,
-0.32589632272720337,
-0.17471100389957428,
-0.2828042507171631,
-0.16277600824832916,
0.3620830178260803,
0.5785393118858337,
-0.36339032649993896,
-0.20668233931064606,
0.36402207612991333,
-0.1368413269519806,
0.06989510357379913,
-0.11090189963579178,
0.443864107131958,
0.15525630116462708,
-0.5938861966133118,
0.39164310693740845,
0.18833592534065247,
0.26456567645072937,
-0.6170065999031067,
-0.16953282058238983,
0.036601413041353226,
0.2865293025970459,
0.021249596029520035,
-0.6990749835968018,
-0.02845779061317444,
-0.05833704397082329,
-0.19674432277679443,
-0.1790522336959839,
0.469588041305542,
-0.8398652672767639,
-0.60028475522995,
-0.14940984547138214,
0.2678759694099426,
0.16109336912631989,
0.21970675885677338,
-0.365607887506485,
-0.4644733965396881,
0.18500089645385742,
-0.11112242192029953,
-0.01296868547797203,
0.743150532245636,
0.26080256700515747,
0.5218992829322815,
0.40755149722099304,
0.06773506104946136,
0.26196491718292236,
-0.24081368744373322,
0.7946969270706177,
-0.8121917247772217,
-0.07591916620731354,
-0.8350645303726196,
0.42456454038619995,
0.17359204590320587,
-0.5019246935844421,
0.7189392447471619,
0.7630885243415833,
0.769427478313446,
-0.28680726885795593,
0.7384033203125,
-0.01517140120267868,
0.28710952401161194,
-0.6568300724029541,
0.5441107749938965,
-0.5036351680755615,
0.22279073297977448,
-0.12293184548616409,
-0.8804623484611511,
-0.23893554508686066,
0.3771139085292816,
0.14510580897331238,
0.19337816536426544,
0.8690901398658752,
0.9889627695083618,
-0.23424623906612396,
-0.14586269855499268,
-0.07068035751581192,
0.31704792380332947,
0.7958653569221497,
1.106449842453003,
0.6300647854804993,
-0.26164939999580383,
0.7921860218048096,
-0.3287477195262909,
0.17926818132400513,
-0.07238787412643433,
-0.6554546356201172,
-1.3724033832550049,
-0.5154569149017334,
-0.2465393841266632,
-0.7742316722869873,
-0.27891936898231506,
1.1724244356155396,
0.8469122648239136,
-0.7178780436515808,
-0.4650362730026245,
-0.5754988193511963,
-0.016215967014431953,
0.21047164499759674,
-0.21738098561763763,
0.41819366812705994,
-0.06006636098027229,
-0.7560955882072449,
0.47297292947769165,
0.23600395023822784,
0.672577977180481,
-0.3249557614326477,
-0.11391646414995193,
-0.17252641916275024,
-0.030628753826022148,
0.27763631939888,
0.3398033380508423,
-0.4154544472694397,
-0.06275355070829391,
0.052518222481012344,
-0.26443055272102356,
0.16782307624816895,
0.9205062985420227,
-0.37959322333335876,
0.6776509881019592,
0.28582119941711426,
0.5290464758872986,
0.6403265595436096,
-0.1537715047597885,
1.0314934253692627,
-1.158449411392212,
0.05814693123102188,
0.1321175992488861,
0.11861849576234818,
0.20140638947486877,
-0.39884963631629944,
0.3021889925003052,
0.25655239820480347,
-0.5441335439682007,
-0.7900052070617676,
0.4579554498195648,
-1.0712250471115112,
-0.755160391330719,
1.1078455448150635,
0.20430856943130493,
-0.37012428045272827,
0.27901893854141235,
-0.24405014514923096,
0.4266603887081146,
-0.6560958623886108,
0.8499721884727478,
0.9050167798995972,
0.048553626984357834,
-0.1857956498861313,
-0.5459557771682739,
0.6209733486175537,
0.3380785584449768,
-0.9249029755592346,
0.07144160568714142,
0.6257608532905579,
0.19251729547977448,
0.09567955881357193,
0.07159499078989029,
0.07437654584646225,
0.31879112124443054,
0.07841600477695465,
0.08620282262563705,
-0.4641362428665161,
-0.6767972707748413,
-0.023142768070101738,
0.26103848218917847,
-0.0012040626024827361,
-0.24787186086177826
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.13240v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.13240v1
|
SumTra: A Differentiable Pipeline for Few-Shot Cross-Lingual Summarization
| 2024-03-20T02:04:42 | 2024-03-20T02:04:42 |
Jacob Parnell, Inigo Jauregi Unanue, Massimo Piccardi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Cross-lingual summarization (XLS) generates summaries in a language different
from that of the input documents (e.g., English to Spanish), allowing speakers
of the target language to gain a concise view of their content. In the present
day, the predominant approach to this task is to take a performing, pretrained
multilingual language model (LM) and fine-tune it for XLS on the language pairs
of interest. However, the scarcity of fine-tuning samples makes this approach
challenging in some cases. For this reason, in this paper we propose revisiting
the summarize-and-translate pipeline, where the summarization and translation
tasks are performed in a sequence. This approach allows reusing the many,
publicly-available resources for monolingual summarization and translation,
obtaining a very competitive zero-shot performance. In addition, the proposed
pipeline is completely differentiable end-to-end, allowing it to take advantage
of few-shot fine-tuning, where available. Experiments over two contemporary and
widely adopted XLS datasets (CrossSum and WikiLingua) have shown the remarkable
zero-shot performance of the proposed approach, and also its strong few-shot
performance compared to an equivalent multilingual LM baseline, that the
proposed approach has been able to outperform in many languages with only 10%
of the fine-tuning samples.
|
[
-0.3285718858242035,
-0.2838028073310852,
0.22993552684783936,
0.007960961200296879,
-0.6001019477844238,
0.2540445625782013,
-0.2236281931400299,
-0.3439341187477112,
0.6734639406204224,
0.3581663966178894,
-0.6082900166511536,
-0.44531890749931335,
-0.860555112361908,
0.5749790668487549,
-0.5130729079246521,
1.2836902141571045,
-0.20545558631420135,
-0.019029654562473297,
0.25538069009780884,
-0.5011036396026611,
-0.24363495409488678,
-0.10141780972480774,
-0.245040163397789,
-0.29947617650032043,
0.8852627277374268,
0.8074906468391418,
0.5967555642127991,
0.3773104250431061,
0.1926833838224411,
0.20203797519207,
-0.038949064910411835,
0.0819694921374321,
-0.7539564967155457,
-0.008492949418723583,
-0.036711182445287704,
-0.7221177816390991,
-0.3257986903190613,
-0.24197261035442352,
0.7412757873535156,
0.9220839142799377,
0.11592807620763779,
0.24530719220638275,
0.11531181633472443,
0.8806254863739014,
-0.8568084836006165,
-0.22446376085281372,
-0.47803840041160583,
0.12368720769882202,
-0.2637436091899872,
-0.1012817993760109,
-0.2420114427804947,
-0.16234184801578522,
-0.11392994225025177,
-0.4962313175201416,
-0.01891138032078743,
-0.21529698371887207,
0.5909318923950195,
0.15045936405658722,
-0.4694330394268036,
0.12767668068408966,
-0.6104289293289185,
1.004933476448059,
-1.0297167301177979,
0.36906731128692627,
0.11760120093822479,
0.543747067451477,
0.37286922335624695,
-0.6075282692909241,
-0.24875907599925995,
0.3392573297023773,
-0.18586935102939606,
0.35252076387405396,
-0.3314847946166992,
-0.46241074800491333,
-0.043500762432813644,
0.18986491858959198,
-0.6852737665176392,
0.28499647974967957,
-0.5256714820861816,
-0.10370189696550369,
0.5022370219230652,
0.3741001486778259,
0.25506502389907837,
0.08308566361665726,
-0.03448415920138359,
0.13893058896064758,
-0.8480036854743958,
0.08235669881105423,
0.359512597322464,
0.8190394639968872,
-0.5214477181434631,
0.6508249640464783,
-0.5954558253288269,
0.5861950516700745,
-0.1357160061597824,
-0.1326863020658493,
0.21984153985977173,
-0.4668196737766266,
-0.40218278765678406,
0.11066720634698868,
0.6356183290481567,
0.32050901651382446,
0.22710227966308594,
-0.20537109673023224,
-0.1293824017047882,
-0.04241696372628212,
-0.21165545284748077,
-0.8938256502151489,
0.1698647290468216,
0.42268484830856323,
-0.18817290663719177,
-0.03506581485271454,
-0.272616446018219,
-0.45164015889167786,
0.14989235997200012,
-0.4093342423439026,
0.2982582747936249,
-0.5102524161338806,
-0.04492224007844925,
-0.05245745927095413,
0.024608230218291283,
0.2557523548603058,
0.4970795214176178,
-1.0039337873458862,
0.32135623693466187,
0.6702519655227661,
1.1889593601226807,
-0.2513613700866699,
-0.6819056868553162,
-1.1948564052581787,
0.005922255571931601,
-0.666300356388092,
1.0839073657989502,
-0.3932687044143677,
-0.23225314915180206,
-0.09270671010017395,
-0.05657423287630081,
0.06318680942058563,
-0.2906630039215088,
0.05506311357021332,
-0.31994175910949707,
0.2791532576084137,
-0.4400824010372162,
-0.1990542858839035,
-0.05252321437001228,
0.36133256554603577,
-0.4707629978656769,
0.41642388701438904,
0.3280019760131836,
-0.877215564250946,
0.4219982922077179,
-0.3681744933128357,
-0.6684049367904663,
0.024433579295873642,
-0.09626553952693939,
-0.33374786376953125,
-0.09300090372562408,
0.22434471547603607,
0.23422260582447052,
-0.24357697367668152,
-0.19320403039455414,
-0.062490060925483704,
-0.4647454023361206,
-0.33067449927330017,
0.002194462576881051,
0.8755789399147034,
0.3656162917613983,
0.07257729023694992,
0.15970608592033386,
-0.597338080406189,
-0.027260327711701393,
-0.3864460587501526,
-0.2749338150024414,
-0.42604681849479675,
-0.26144278049468994,
0.10404111444950104,
0.24559378623962402,
0.03248831629753113,
-0.5222613215446472,
0.11253862828016281,
-0.7910699248313904,
0.10899771004915237,
0.2034243792295456,
-0.16454416513442993,
0.7068490386009216,
-0.3989122807979584,
0.7310436367988586,
0.18374575674533844,
-0.14549531042575836,
-0.6762049794197083,
-0.314814954996109,
-0.43660736083984375,
-0.41385459899902344,
0.5509783029556274,
0.7161887884140015,
-0.8322842717170715,
-0.31846684217453003,
-0.32019945979118347,
-0.5342932939529419,
-0.44648298621177673,
0.48177772760391235,
0.4850984811782837,
0.47704675793647766,
0.3573565185070038,
-0.49699342250823975,
-0.46362921595573425,
-0.8638505339622498,
-0.4035060703754425,
0.34645742177963257,
-0.295590877532959,
-0.08045338094234467,
0.5171540379524231,
-0.06669753789901733,
0.8256848454475403,
-0.4613678753376007,
-0.4835415482521057,
-0.7446594834327698,
0.49164435267448425,
0.49227872490882874,
0.2678823173046112,
0.9358236789703369,
-0.4706112742424011,
-1.0281893014907837,
0.2827806770801544,
-0.6634686589241028,
-0.19870148599147797,
0.07056809961795807,
-0.016848187893629074,
0.23280945420265198,
0.32744553685188293,
-0.11962272226810455,
0.3086243271827698,
0.5436047911643982,
-0.03240704536437988,
0.48224517703056335,
-0.24884793162345886,
0.16946689784526825,
-1.1276531219482422,
0.2829984724521637,
-0.21284691989421844,
-0.4802529811859131,
-0.6217009425163269,
0.08676206320524216,
0.1210031509399414,
-0.031199974939227104,
-0.973845362663269,
0.43732431530952454,
-0.5207773447036743,
-0.24004730582237244,
-0.35302215814590454,
0.22760513424873352,
-0.19101601839065552,
0.5145655870437622,
0.025236083194613457,
0.4820284843444824,
0.6603070497512817,
-0.6401563286781311,
0.27440568804740906,
0.2916187345981598,
-0.30807074904441833,
0.8247312903404236,
-0.6442636847496033,
-0.07470401376485825,
-0.519413411617279,
0.23485298454761505,
-0.941868245601654,
-0.1544603407382965,
0.01736491732299328,
-0.3295918107032776,
0.4036153554916382,
-0.33344101905822754,
-0.08235391229391098,
0.2875599265098572,
-0.7107589840888977,
0.4776383936405182,
0.2920987606048584,
-0.05102520063519478,
0.5180138945579529,
0.2265482246875763,
-0.5914338231086731,
-0.8649342656135559,
-0.9320166110992432,
0.3042505085468292,
-0.12104135006666183,
-0.4629279375076294,
0.2969789206981659,
0.003027954837307334,
-0.3915099501609802,
-0.10194003582000732,
-0.07188529521226883,
-0.03725051134824753,
-0.21058624982833862,
-0.23885798454284668,
0.16051112115383148,
-0.3091413676738739,
-0.2927471995353699,
0.39634034037590027,
-0.3782939314842224,
-0.6004090309143066,
-0.28677278757095337,
0.25320562720298767,
0.16256506741046906,
-0.20039716362953186,
0.015481184236705303,
0.8019203543663025,
0.48755502700805664,
-0.24863164126873016,
0.566254198551178,
0.562889039516449,
-0.28493544459342957,
-0.08774463087320328,
-0.12544727325439453,
-0.1137988269329071,
-0.31060150265693665,
0.31779950857162476,
-0.3409042954444885,
-0.7058508396148682,
0.749354362487793,
-0.003141578286886215,
0.624694287776947,
0.3553324043750763,
0.8518356680870056,
0.0016094843158498406,
0.6044827103614807,
0.7598485946655273,
-0.16151978075504303,
0.3514242172241211,
-0.5086616277694702,
0.09830693900585175,
-0.7369086742401123,
0.1972590982913971,
-0.4919731914997101,
-0.6664877533912659,
-0.4439833164215088,
-0.0433921180665493,
0.5779545307159424,
-0.16874296963214874,
0.1613239198923111,
0.6523541212081909,
0.2429080307483673,
0.7776275277137756,
0.39600351452827454,
-0.2504587173461914,
0.579295814037323,
-0.1865486204624176,
-0.37967249751091003,
-0.1585494577884674,
-0.8413348197937012,
-0.3704364001750946,
1.165858507156372,
-0.19517983496189117,
0.6672082543373108,
0.3796502947807312,
0.9517493844032288,
0.0030132608953863382,
0.2863995134830475,
-0.6742225885391235,
0.16367670893669128,
-0.48532187938690186,
-0.27903982996940613,
-0.5621453523635864,
-0.30138251185417175,
-1.0315237045288086,
0.4220830500125885,
-0.14703236520290375,
-0.8518897891044617,
0.24976597726345062,
0.07242514193058014,
-0.5759647488594055,
0.302201509475708,
-0.6907459497451782,
0.8383131623268127,
-0.11352664977312088,
-0.7017308473587036,
-0.1930396854877472,
-0.9096407890319824,
0.46061548590660095,
-0.30902019143104553,
0.46451500058174133,
0.018259843811392784,
-0.05069214850664139,
0.5253098011016846,
-0.5550794005393982,
0.7864900827407837,
0.21663109958171844,
-0.26204997301101685,
0.12238809466362,
0.3598564565181732,
0.2928652763366699,
0.07025367766618729,
0.05411620810627937,
0.19048179686069489,
0.3411022126674652,
-0.6144195199012756,
-0.5381007194519043,
0.6770243644714355,
-0.5632182359695435,
-0.2541322112083435,
-0.24945586919784546,
-0.6284457445144653,
-0.16586604714393616,
0.5174721479415894,
0.6876588463783264,
0.508607029914856,
-0.16399627923965454,
0.10962224751710892,
0.043538160622119904,
-0.20339258015155792,
0.7202134728431702,
0.7250462770462036,
-0.3218455910682678,
-0.2803095281124115,
0.7769115567207336,
0.3986245095729828,
0.29341989755630493,
0.8778445720672607,
0.051519688218832016,
-0.1741795390844345,
-0.4099125862121582,
-0.5629396438598633,
0.26792651414871216,
-0.44728997349739075,
-0.22462624311447144,
-0.40581467747688293,
0.06618854403495789,
-0.5662985444068909,
-0.31413164734840393,
-0.6856520175933838,
-0.7182179689407349,
-0.03953816741704941,
0.018198873847723007,
-0.01987544260919094,
0.5268669724464417,
-0.46866974234580994,
0.05048761144280434,
-0.9481304883956909,
0.5328243374824524,
0.39359480142593384,
0.365535169839859,
-0.14895913004875183,
-0.7404969930648804,
-0.714939534664154,
0.1393464356660843,
-0.22537384927272797,
-0.8425126671791077,
0.7664439082145691,
0.25082001090049744,
0.285439133644104,
0.3571977913379669,
0.13053271174430847,
0.6891380548477173,
-0.5666184425354004,
0.603553295135498,
0.2613272964954376,
-0.7670947909355164,
0.445122092962265,
-0.2814338803291321,
0.7472077012062073,
0.5312873721122742,
0.4454917907714844,
-0.8447391986846924,
-0.5007575154304504,
-0.16521915793418884,
-1.0013387203216553,
0.8542347550392151,
0.3577069640159607,
-0.00040805109892971814,
0.43960320949554443,
-0.10799388587474823,
0.5490692257881165,
0.1264641284942627,
-0.3671965003013611,
-0.29675453901290894,
-0.3166760802268982,
0.09728818386793137,
-0.3668404519557953,
-0.052454061806201935,
-0.04995115101337433,
-0.08015287667512894,
0.5559569001197815,
-0.2512240409851074,
-0.3106476664543152,
0.04049035161733627,
-0.326275497674942,
-0.2779370844364166,
0.6213963627815247,
0.7560678124427795,
0.7402547597885132,
-0.3312750458717346,
0.16417457163333893,
0.3774288594722748,
-0.28978368639945984,
-0.027492016553878784,
-0.09898719936609268,
-0.44230759143829346,
0.2809135317802429,
0.46073317527770996,
0.7092686295509338,
0.5553982853889465,
-0.7134571075439453,
0.22510464489459991,
0.07381246238946915,
-0.35194334387779236,
0.02625223994255066,
-0.27858319878578186,
0.016973057761788368,
0.18076486885547638,
0.4128672778606415,
-0.1361236274242401,
0.06617028266191483,
-0.7107216119766235,
0.17049257457256317,
0.3540019392967224,
-0.1114659458398819,
-0.5470508933067322,
0.7323316335678101,
0.22122952342033386,
-0.2857644855976105,
0.11797397583723068,
-0.2852756381034851,
-0.2178838700056076,
0.31982678174972534,
0.3773204982280731,
0.9803842306137085,
0.035988934338092804,
0.20388571918010712,
0.4446026384830475,
0.3209904432296753,
0.002272846642881632,
0.1366937905550003,
-0.2439487725496292,
-0.7486598491668701,
-0.7885293960571289,
-0.26268452405929565,
-0.8287431001663208,
-0.04996534064412117,
-0.4894983470439911,
0.6772822737693787,
0.0057769049890339375,
0.21643714606761932,
0.10178790986537933,
-0.08869975805282593,
-0.4533213973045349,
-0.017254747450351715,
0.23347190022468567,
0.7818154692649841,
-0.9902625679969788,
0.66302090883255,
0.6604790091514587,
-0.4027509093284607,
-0.3860275149345398,
-0.35933685302734375,
0.16097496449947357,
-0.4815487563610077,
0.4761170744895935,
-0.2940576374530792,
-0.2557899057865143,
-0.08963748812675476,
-0.3713221549987793,
-0.7408090829849243,
1.0385984182357788,
0.7140575051307678,
-0.7158345580101013,
-0.06938659399747849,
0.2605591416358948,
0.5413522720336914,
-0.2699225842952728,
0.4444162845611572,
0.5043730139732361,
0.24383628368377686,
0.1717807799577713,
-1.122769832611084,
-0.35144543647766113,
-0.3170929253101349,
-0.3139575123786926,
0.15325531363487244,
-0.7712656855583191,
0.9833990335464478,
-0.47398054599761963,
-0.33790984749794006,
-0.2504478394985199,
0.41997230052948,
0.04068152233958244,
0.48173025250434875,
0.07300276309251785,
0.47896048426628113,
0.2096354216337204,
0.18538498878479004,
0.959019124507904,
-0.44060927629470825,
0.2253265082836151,
1.3263553380966187,
-0.40664124488830566,
0.9160313010215759,
0.5238674283027649,
-0.25298190116882324,
0.28267526626586914,
0.23685595393180847,
0.39871102571487427,
0.5753965377807617,
-0.32598480582237244,
0.0018550982931628823,
-0.22034232318401337,
0.11912345886230469,
-0.317960262298584,
0.5596634149551392,
-0.012029235251247883,
0.041529733687639236,
-0.9508005976676941,
-0.17193447053432465,
0.0141220111399889,
0.12000218778848648,
-0.32939013838768005,
0.6388611197471619,
0.2681024372577667,
-0.7007736563682556,
0.7487125992774963,
0.24137049913406372,
0.8499159216880798,
-0.8210505843162537,
0.1921633780002594,
-0.7783452272415161,
-0.08854808658361435,
-0.40849459171295166,
-0.4799814522266388,
0.6201188564300537,
0.4995049834251404,
0.18994416296482086,
-0.2681540846824646,
0.3618265390396118,
-0.5276678204536438,
-0.6198922395706177,
0.00912567414343357,
0.9014347791671753,
0.269441157579422,
0.1608419120311737,
-0.1642046868801117,
-0.37799495458602905,
-0.07650613784790039,
-0.060849010944366455,
0.6271565556526184,
0.5769881010055542,
0.003547915956005454,
0.5329211354255676,
0.5080649852752686,
0.35446909070014954,
-0.03144697844982147,
0.29352226853370667,
0.6633544564247131,
-0.5398867726325989,
-0.8461856245994568,
-0.9594488739967346,
0.48538100719451904,
0.3531661927700043,
-0.3688652813434601,
0.6913721561431885,
0.9844956994056702,
0.9462702870368958,
-0.1672728806734085,
0.7217362523078918,
0.10005603730678558,
0.5813167691230774,
-0.49876314401626587,
0.6183903813362122,
-0.7264347672462463,
0.2460365742444992,
-0.6597700715065002,
-0.7505437135696411,
-0.5613380670547485,
0.32695913314819336,
-0.10211595892906189,
-0.3185267746448517,
0.7433758974075317,
0.4441552758216858,
-0.2062852829694748,
-0.3356798589229584,
0.6548951864242554,
0.13956625759601593,
0.08180133998394012,
0.7998336553573608,
0.35178351402282715,
-0.4605571925640106,
0.7800440788269043,
-0.22898872196674347,
-0.1207389086484909,
-0.14535480737686157,
-1.127912163734436,
-0.6567793488502502,
-0.4520624577999115,
-0.30390170216560364,
0.23066674172878265,
-0.15930244326591492,
0.8019178509712219,
0.4581163823604584,
-1.0042024850845337,
-0.5019901394844055,
0.19517935812473297,
0.37567296624183655,
-0.43796831369400024,
-0.0859757587313652,
0.039609938859939575,
-0.34359124302864075,
-1.1102057695388794,
0.18562443554401398,
0.7185912132263184,
0.037453215569257736,
-0.2098289132118225,
-0.0958593413233757,
-0.11324344575405121,
-0.028863515704870224,
0.8242928981781006,
0.740998387336731,
-0.2488960176706314,
0.04529806226491928,
0.20675580203533173,
0.07639190554618835,
0.19848914444446564,
0.8421313166618347,
-0.9612705707550049,
0.3834904134273529,
0.6613948345184326,
0.443574994802475,
0.790626049041748,
-0.1278538852930069,
0.657667875289917,
-0.9772012233734131,
0.4528648257255554,
0.13363711535930634,
0.5082876682281494,
0.31278908252716064,
0.057180147618055344,
0.5295031666755676,
0.03613646328449249,
-0.004966709762811661,
-0.8060702085494995,
0.2711712718009949,
-0.9485353231430054,
-0.20521719753742218,
1.014838457107544,
-0.12986618280410767,
-0.07930006086826324,
-0.11605677008628845,
-0.14267723262310028,
0.4140818119049072,
-0.27443403005599976,
0.830796480178833,
0.5251264572143555,
-0.11763076484203339,
-0.21036167442798615,
-0.11550173163414001,
0.04993366450071335,
0.39329278469085693,
-0.779223620891571,
-0.0021801532711833715,
0.3486243188381195,
0.4112878441810608,
0.18486034870147705,
0.819720983505249,
-0.09110759943723679,
0.3273871839046478,
-0.032228462398052216,
-0.4148741364479065,
-0.05046237260103226,
-0.26383209228515625,
-0.2030615657567978,
0.09899236261844635,
-0.14775295555591583,
-0.16582219302654266
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.13233v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.13233v1
|
Technical Report: Competition Solution For BetterMixture
| 2024-03-20T01:46:06 | 2024-03-20T01:46:06 |
Shuaijiang Zhao, Xiaoquan Fang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In the era of flourishing large-scale models, the challenge of selecting and
optimizing datasets from the vast and complex sea of data, to enhance the
performance of large language models within the constraints of limited
computational resources, has become paramount. This paper details our solution
for the BetterMixture challenge, which focuses on the fine-tuning data mixing
for large language models. Our approach, which secured third place,
incorporates data deduplication, low-level and high-level quality filtering,
and diversity selection. The foundation of our solution is Ke-Data-Juicer, an
extension of Data-Juicer, demonstrating its robust capabilities in handling and
optimizing data for large language models.
|
[
-0.4423552453517914,
-0.5270342230796814,
0.34665346145629883,
0.2029537409543991,
-0.25310957431793213,
0.34395521879196167,
-0.12660115957260132,
-0.6023190021514893,
0.04296361282467842,
0.5655038952827454,
-0.308204710483551,
-0.27617397904396057,
-0.6557090282440186,
0.1452869474887848,
-0.4883401691913605,
0.6279230117797852,
0.10867911577224731,
0.08639031648635864,
-0.53858482837677,
-0.19465185701847076,
-0.706592321395874,
-0.4636942148208618,
-0.592628538608551,
-0.714066743850708,
0.28167635202407837,
0.7221664786338806,
1.0211187601089478,
0.949138343334198,
0.6326796412467957,
0.40090975165367126,
-0.41742002964019775,
0.10362189263105392,
-0.7136384844779968,
0.5914044976234436,
-0.3289269208908081,
-0.5077906250953674,
-0.28824275732040405,
-0.04455447196960449,
0.42738816142082214,
0.8567707538604736,
-0.33281370997428894,
0.254402220249176,
0.18459366261959076,
0.8624175190925598,
-0.6888375878334045,
0.042586442083120346,
-0.627251386642456,
0.13873611390590668,
-0.35251525044441223,
0.03163743019104004,
-0.20654459297657013,
-0.4154351055622101,
-0.2224418818950653,
-0.44778260588645935,
0.22610092163085938,
0.1894591897726059,
0.9749361872673035,
0.10588812083005905,
-0.363130122423172,
0.23311039805412292,
-1.105672836303711,
0.9027809500694275,
-0.49463850259780884,
0.6119260787963867,
0.26630735397338867,
0.6036103367805481,
-0.27981647849082947,
-0.4934495985507965,
-0.6910450458526611,
-0.04577537626028061,
0.4479779601097107,
0.10731811821460724,
-0.25924357771873474,
-0.258173406124115,
0.0658695325255394,
0.5648047924041748,
-0.5911287665367126,
0.2901659905910492,
-0.3756294846534729,
-0.18095991015434265,
0.7846918106079102,
0.5315595269203186,
0.12393254041671753,
0.2572668790817261,
0.12243973463773727,
-0.4126116633415222,
-0.469468355178833,
-0.32492709159851074,
0.38966742157936096,
0.29315078258514404,
0.1565583497285843,
0.7182071805000305,
-0.6925499439239502,
0.5899067521095276,
-0.1531086266040802,
-0.05766164883971214,
0.40079110860824585,
-0.32661673426628113,
-0.4629838466644287,
-0.11763688176870346,
0.45727163553237915,
0.475925087928772,
0.054127711802721024,
-0.04764625430107117,
-0.35642209649086,
0.10119021683931351,
-0.2485111653804779,
-0.9293581247329712,
-0.5827084183692932,
0.3938480019569397,
-0.5714242458343506,
-0.15236066281795502,
-0.32452279329299927,
-0.9846339821815491,
-0.5142747163772583,
-0.5742030143737793,
0.4158332943916321,
-0.08054787665605545,
-0.49620646238327026,
0.40460169315338135,
-0.47635045647621155,
0.0062002697959542274,
0.13678871095180511,
-0.6645447015762329,
0.32489627599716187,
0.9169729948043823,
0.8812131881713867,
-0.18236368894577026,
0.17209689319133759,
-0.6590896844863892,
0.09311021119356155,
-0.28839075565338135,
0.48272818326950073,
-0.8157132267951965,
-0.41046348214149475,
-0.3685593903064728,
-0.24572941660881042,
0.06191754341125488,
-1.1122071743011475,
0.627691924571991,
-0.7489964962005615,
0.15110471844673157,
-0.3540491759777069,
-0.8728989362716675,
0.13722385466098785,
0.14480175077915192,
-0.9869343638420105,
1.0035505294799805,
0.17847783863544464,
-0.5879356861114502,
0.4157722592353821,
-0.3654231131076813,
-0.40714046359062195,
0.3598805367946625,
0.07415422052145004,
-0.7196813225746155,
0.10663816332817078,
0.0463344007730484,
0.35862454771995544,
-0.583605945110321,
0.3029617667198181,
-0.6973632574081421,
0.04984842240810394,
-0.1416020691394806,
-0.08468897640705109,
0.8268929719924927,
0.6746901273727417,
-0.034696031361818314,
0.015449617989361286,
-0.8828076720237732,
-0.10176511108875275,
0.5382742881774902,
-0.3500281572341919,
-0.4203006327152252,
0.06327037513256073,
0.2413456290960312,
0.2667369842529297,
0.0024383505806326866,
-0.7190695405006409,
0.04877026379108429,
-0.02709645964205265,
0.3629975914955139,
0.5352715849876404,
-0.2794513404369354,
0.3683321475982666,
-0.41659319400787354,
0.6709644794464111,
0.0775279626250267,
0.3249950110912323,
0.24409039318561554,
-0.5164254903793335,
-0.9650112986564636,
-0.21416723728179932,
0.7186515927314758,
0.6848215460777283,
-0.8765107989311218,
0.5034283399581909,
-0.43413493037223816,
-0.5710043907165527,
-0.5633834600448608,
0.3217853307723999,
0.22100955247879028,
0.24861232936382294,
0.371787965297699,
-0.31316453218460083,
-0.5677183270454407,
-1.1742340326309204,
0.15021687746047974,
0.37695688009262085,
0.07787423580884933,
0.314409464597702,
0.45453914999961853,
-0.22086790204048157,
0.9282687306404114,
-0.5327457785606384,
-0.1705322563648224,
-0.5988208055496216,
-0.009113304316997528,
0.39829346537590027,
0.6615828275680542,
0.4610028564929962,
-0.9993546009063721,
-0.6415112614631653,
0.32203009724617004,
-0.24455676972866058,
-0.3110632002353668,
0.306790292263031,
-0.37445443868637085,
-0.19902868568897247,
0.395137220621109,
-0.4123670160770416,
-0.2376650869846344,
0.7012873291969299,
-0.1564098596572876,
0.5745017528533936,
-0.004855562001466751,
0.23671238124370575,
-1.1480815410614014,
0.1391695737838745,
-0.04051265865564346,
-0.5337138772010803,
-0.49112552404403687,
0.1525202989578247,
0.04594417288899422,
-0.034058261662721634,
-0.25949007272720337,
0.39247244596481323,
-0.06192493438720703,
0.21484313905239105,
-0.18142345547676086,
-0.03522379323840141,
-0.012781597673892975,
-0.04313099756836891,
-0.0866943970322609,
0.5904824733734131,
0.5442492961883545,
-0.7192641496658325,
0.678992509841919,
0.14569146931171417,
-0.6833260655403137,
0.4567265212535858,
-0.6954758167266846,
0.03394131734967232,
-0.3125651478767395,
0.21015571057796478,
-1.0057638883590698,
-0.6401270031929016,
-0.3315182626247406,
-0.3275972902774811,
0.1428213268518448,
-0.04670215770602226,
-0.7512370944023132,
-0.6247460842132568,
-0.20263570547103882,
0.4053628146648407,
0.7005802392959595,
-0.5993314385414124,
0.22178415954113007,
0.5327369570732117,
-0.31234845519065857,
-0.4171130359172821,
-0.5060067176818848,
0.15302661061286926,
-0.33604493737220764,
-0.552102267742157,
0.2881077527999878,
-0.25425031781196594,
-0.29402512311935425,
-0.09923175722360611,
-0.06473852694034576,
-0.39895427227020264,
0.20411905646324158,
-0.378814160823822,
0.22757068276405334,
-0.12538786232471466,
-0.17606917023658752,
0.14277829229831696,
-0.22709429264068604,
-0.0878443717956543,
-0.21169760823249817,
0.5854632258415222,
0.5313945412635803,
-0.06291652470827103,
-0.23868103325366974,
0.42017772793769836,
0.4799290895462036,
-0.14171768724918365,
0.622244119644165,
0.3735264539718628,
-0.25691187381744385,
-0.2682224214076996,
-0.5262669920921326,
0.18304525315761566,
-0.5389116406440735,
0.45077577233314514,
-0.4124874174594879,
-1.2104530334472656,
0.4682964086532593,
0.02651187777519226,
0.043024562299251556,
0.405544251203537,
0.4357002079486847,
0.08769089728593826,
1.4696654081344604,
0.5179548859596252,
-0.6080543994903564,
0.41422975063323975,
-0.0021025037858635187,
0.03516383469104767,
-0.3313521444797516,
-0.32778990268707275,
-1.0139148235321045,
-0.645514190196991,
-0.3970326781272888,
-0.22488021850585938,
0.22556327283382416,
0.03704366832971573,
-0.29662394523620605,
0.37441372871398926,
-0.42280012369155884,
1.0986837148666382,
0.6925851106643677,
-0.0478251613676548,
0.3512992262840271,
-0.035522688180208206,
-0.42422348260879517,
-0.17564064264297485,
-0.7171079516410828,
-0.07374835014343262,
0.6105305552482605,
0.28276076912879944,
0.7321413159370422,
0.3310161828994751,
0.6148422956466675,
0.11505930870771408,
0.03982875123620033,
-0.48763787746429443,
0.48386305570602417,
-0.3580453097820282,
-0.6898703575134277,
0.02009269781410694,
-0.9261873364448547,
-1.2438466548919678,
0.4455713629722595,
-0.20922096073627472,
-0.6437950134277344,
0.17627358436584473,
0.1934380978345871,
-0.31318747997283936,
0.2621789574623108,
-0.6189444065093994,
0.8544417023658752,
0.08130078762769699,
-0.5717244744300842,
-0.20983882248401642,
-0.6007248163223267,
0.4841507077217102,
0.042107801884412766,
0.3963127136230469,
-0.15026171505451202,
0.21175111830234528,
0.5237694382667542,
-0.5777583718299866,
0.32011678814888,
-0.2132628858089447,
-0.24565845727920532,
0.05589502304792404,
0.40573394298553467,
0.480329304933548,
-0.15634702146053314,
-0.13682673871517181,
-0.24592934548854828,
-0.20273080468177795,
-0.32788002490997314,
-0.2644539773464203,
0.5981717705726624,
-0.5382968783378601,
-0.46258559823036194,
0.05918152257800102,
-0.28276777267456055,
-0.2843562364578247,
0.2234065681695938,
0.33048152923583984,
0.32630807161331177,
0.1276213675737381,
0.8346399068832397,
0.8073287606239319,
-0.12129919975996017,
0.41234228014945984,
0.34907302260398865,
-0.18241164088249207,
-0.6160510182380676,
1.1172459125518799,
-0.14384257793426514,
0.43946346640586853,
0.5570735335350037,
0.3636675179004669,
-0.27082788944244385,
-0.7605862021446228,
-0.2977102994918823,
-0.2514464855194092,
-0.5033263564109802,
-0.4892265498638153,
-0.7605693340301514,
-0.1562354862689972,
-0.3250344693660736,
0.18754862248897552,
-0.6805593967437744,
-0.5694152116775513,
0.08211109042167664,
0.1314619779586792,
0.1408551186323166,
0.4296248257160187,
-0.11385121196508408,
0.36710086464881897,
-1.0646182298660278,
0.37026047706604004,
0.31024792790412903,
0.6296958923339844,
-0.02131953462958336,
-0.4419291317462921,
-0.3821335732936859,
-0.04042036086320877,
-0.4016808867454529,
-0.35493203997612,
0.4679436981678009,
0.1289251744747162,
0.5788151621818542,
0.037028513848781586,
-0.22200219333171844,
0.733400821685791,
-0.2766966223716736,
0.82827228307724,
0.15042491257190704,
-0.9908129572868347,
0.6389469504356384,
-0.3950482904911041,
0.5158750414848328,
0.8168506026268005,
0.1249835193157196,
-0.5647610425949097,
-0.554618775844574,
-0.3736589550971985,
-1.1261948347091675,
0.5602793097496033,
0.7428446412086487,
0.03151537477970123,
0.09656554460525513,
0.11927083134651184,
0.35554778575897217,
0.176370769739151,
-0.8612245917320251,
-0.28908371925354004,
0.29922157526016235,
-0.38199397921562195,
-0.08094172179698944,
0.011747063137590885,
0.23678241670131683,
-0.5597002506256104,
0.8889936804771423,
0.22815482318401337,
-0.13007546961307526,
-0.21585120260715485,
-0.12951192259788513,
-0.1295706033706665,
0.26957517862319946,
0.2626812160015106,
0.34332966804504395,
-0.06899247318506241,
-0.17511484026908875,
-0.15415064990520477,
-0.5995665788650513,
0.18980953097343445,
0.14365410804748535,
-0.065310537815094,
-0.02905944176018238,
0.28542110323905945,
0.6515311598777771,
-0.29264745116233826,
-0.7801828384399414,
0.405327171087265,
-0.09633106738328934,
-0.4578859806060791,
0.3960569202899933,
0.5870423913002014,
0.02213110215961933,
0.4476454257965088,
0.2853093147277832,
-0.07548483461141586,
0.5825423002243042,
-0.06713759899139404,
0.31304073333740234,
0.43205806612968445,
0.09105945378541946,
-0.010068224743008614,
0.9929150938987732,
0.4056122303009033,
-0.06683596968650818,
0.6468569040298462,
-0.3430134057998657,
-0.6877793669700623,
0.9818520545959473,
0.543537974357605,
0.5744438171386719,
-0.5720779299736023,
0.036895766854286194,
0.5246608853340149,
0.05765605345368385,
-0.5168902277946472,
0.4110313355922699,
-0.0911935344338417,
-0.7491790056228638,
-0.5919068455696106,
-0.6414671540260315,
-0.4549364745616913,
0.5504277944564819,
-0.47121700644493103,
0.3518522381782532,
-0.1319921612739563,
-0.13258719444274902,
0.30955609679222107,
-0.004764683544635773,
-0.7756949663162231,
0.2722953259944916,
0.4450299143791199,
0.9401875138282776,
-0.7973657250404358,
0.7923451066017151,
0.5245714783668518,
0.07072273641824722,
-0.5261032581329346,
-0.38857388496398926,
-0.010737314820289612,
-0.2721013128757477,
0.5893012285232544,
0.2129802107810974,
0.011745994910597801,
-0.166055828332901,
-0.6232609152793884,
-0.9847410917282104,
0.8075370788574219,
0.618158757686615,
-0.9615931510925293,
0.4926644563674927,
0.43581873178482056,
0.23549996316432953,
-0.1586066633462906,
0.04198521375656128,
0.8660423755645752,
0.4857466518878937,
0.39050817489624023,
-1.1842972040176392,
-0.30360785126686096,
-0.5116485357284546,
0.009399999864399433,
0.4924378991127014,
-0.673542857170105,
0.7371788620948792,
0.1575154960155487,
-0.09332636743783951,
0.19611284136772156,
0.5247266888618469,
0.08834689110517502,
0.22293835878372192,
0.662983775138855,
0.7921128869056702,
0.6524003148078918,
-0.12607045471668243,
0.9360824227333069,
0.13888905942440033,
0.6587956547737122,
1.42196524143219,
-0.6956912279129028,
0.7191287875175476,
0.08829150348901749,
-0.5038977861404419,
0.1474471092224121,
0.7579514980316162,
-0.06673260033130646,
0.703799307346344,
0.37730127573013306,
-0.18564458191394806,
-0.5242928862571716,
-0.06848746538162231,
-0.41886991262435913,
0.5466256141662598,
0.14894874393939972,
-0.20469911396503448,
-0.27514806389808655,
-0.042357634752988815,
-0.16812938451766968,
0.001418998115696013,
-0.3460296392440796,
0.869016706943512,
-0.2971116900444031,
-0.5134482383728027,
0.37741729617118835,
0.15659019351005554,
0.5451660752296448,
-0.3307597041130066,
0.08527330309152603,
-0.4695647060871124,
0.41659241914749146,
0.06289032101631165,
-0.911151111125946,
0.19076019525527954,
-0.22709323465824127,
-0.11548363417387009,
-0.037819523364305496,
0.7118504047393799,
-0.7115780115127563,
-0.5410245656967163,
0.317422091960907,
0.4573858082294464,
-0.18010492622852325,
0.05236819013953209,
-0.6762450933456421,
0.2111848145723343,
-0.11947380751371384,
-0.06554114073514938,
0.094418965280056,
0.395222932100296,
0.16276592016220093,
0.7668271064758301,
0.47895586490631104,
0.028707584366202354,
-0.12425046414136887,
0.44962361454963684,
0.8255255222320557,
-0.6051359176635742,
-0.7520400285720825,
-1.0320286750793457,
0.43189987540245056,
-0.585136890411377,
-0.07635129243135452,
0.5457625985145569,
1.199492335319519,
0.9118874073028564,
0.01901036500930786,
0.8375841975212097,
-0.15557478368282318,
0.5516878962516785,
-0.3528909385204315,
0.4403626620769501,
-0.7017717957496643,
0.004392836708575487,
-0.33273738622665405,
-1.1644338369369507,
-0.495922714471817,
0.3307201862335205,
0.25399503111839294,
0.19556361436843872,
0.37112122774124146,
0.661200225353241,
-0.5450943112373352,
0.22905096411705017,
0.18828971683979034,
0.11682363599538803,
0.35978007316589355,
0.70781010389328,
0.7695832848548889,
-0.1420963704586029,
0.4986666738986969,
-0.28419527411460876,
-0.24289169907569885,
-0.32772600650787354,
-0.8888474106788635,
-0.5989739894866943,
-0.45223143696784973,
-0.411790668964386,
-0.27779966592788696,
-0.09617933630943298,
1.1785951852798462,
0.9431414008140564,
-1.0035438537597656,
-0.3242381811141968,
-0.13956157863140106,
0.08065803349018097,
-0.3692808449268341,
-0.23010185360908508,
-0.14054638147354126,
-0.24610024690628052,
-0.877276599407196,
0.23612329363822937,
0.07562221586704254,
0.053096894174814224,
0.12678997218608856,
0.09600550681352615,
0.12646940350532532,
0.10712329298257828,
0.833051323890686,
-0.048977430909872055,
-0.010413207113742828,
0.005378942005336285,
-0.2967693507671356,
0.050333425402641296,
0.17733009159564972,
0.8967323303222656,
-0.44355857372283936,
0.5854442715644836,
0.47837525606155396,
1.0694113969802856,
0.47330135107040405,
-0.05837744474411011,
0.6448163986206055,
-0.758908212184906,
0.016560539603233337,
0.2186807245016098,
0.5202488899230957,
0.3117436170578003,
-0.44104406237602234,
0.5301077365875244,
0.22332586348056793,
-0.5470182299613953,
-0.6244729161262512,
0.09666672348976135,
-0.8554601073265076,
-0.3559582233428955,
1.2588328123092651,
0.37899523973464966,
-0.11655967682600021,
-0.29732123017311096,
-0.08658213168382645,
0.20394960045814514,
-0.5666218996047974,
0.7356955409049988,
1.1331520080566406,
-0.01229793019592762,
0.04431822896003723,
-0.8424711227416992,
0.34611546993255615,
0.6243062615394592,
-0.9100894331932068,
0.25806596875190735,
0.7776229381561279,
0.2706418037414551,
-0.116553395986557,
0.12946920096874237,
-0.1887878179550171,
0.11159107089042664,
-0.16329894959926605,
-0.3471255600452423,
0.02176314778625965,
-0.25181636214256287,
-0.1588391214609146,
0.32112976908683777,
-0.05216226726770401,
-0.2967015206813812
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.13213v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.13213v3
|
From Representational Harms to Quality-of-Service Harms: A Case Study on Llama 2 Safety Safeguards
| 2024-03-20T00:22:38 | 2024-06-08T01:58:20 |
Khaoula Chehbouni, Megha Roshan, Emmanuel Ma, Futian Andrew Wei, Afaf Taik, Jackie CK Cheung, Golnoosh Farnadi
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CY
|
Recent progress in large language models (LLMs) has led to their widespread
adoption in various domains. However, these advancements have also introduced
additional safety risks and raised concerns regarding their detrimental impact
on already marginalized populations. Despite growing mitigation efforts to
develop safety safeguards, such as supervised safety-oriented fine-tuning and
leveraging safe reinforcement learning from human feedback, multiple concerns
regarding the safety and ingrained biases in these models remain. Furthermore,
previous work has demonstrated that models optimized for safety often display
exaggerated safety behaviors, such as a tendency to refrain from responding to
certain requests as a precautionary measure. As such, a clear trade-off between
the helpfulness and safety of these models has been documented in the
literature. In this paper, we further investigate the effectiveness of safety
measures by evaluating models on already mitigated biases. Using the case of
Llama 2 as an example, we illustrate how LLMs' safety responses can still
encode harmful assumptions. To do so, we create a set of non-toxic prompts,
which we then use to evaluate Llama models. Through our new taxonomy of LLMs
responses to users, we observe that the safety/helpfulness trade-offs are more
pronounced for certain demographic groups which can lead to quality-of-service
harms for marginalized populations.
|
[
-0.11676821857690811,
-0.40501993894577026,
0.5926068425178528,
0.12261293083429337,
-0.22487056255340576,
-0.02984677441418171,
0.22382821142673492,
-0.6777601838111877,
-0.01638590171933174,
0.6576958298683167,
-0.27311334013938904,
-0.26007577776908875,
-0.7094401717185974,
0.02311244048178196,
-0.1364920437335968,
1.086484432220459,
0.0913114994764328,
-0.13876743614673615,
-0.11929640173912048,
0.10138456523418427,
-0.6701509952545166,
-0.9660705924034119,
-0.6421679854393005,
-0.019806506112217903,
0.8576570153236389,
0.31426864862442017,
0.8706052899360657,
0.6572924256324768,
0.5145443677902222,
0.16602705419063568,
-0.4547209143638611,
0.055970173329114914,
-0.5599918365478516,
0.2025490254163742,
-0.1269712746143341,
-0.5904790163040161,
-0.36727187037467957,
0.018331162631511688,
0.4323368966579437,
0.6418657898902893,
-0.3251715898513794,
0.05496969819068909,
0.18045468628406525,
0.327927827835083,
-0.8028889298439026,
0.08259421586990356,
-0.49921536445617676,
0.03027871809899807,
0.0737280622124672,
-0.03598909080028534,
-0.4650228023529053,
-0.6327357292175293,
0.029542740434408188,
-0.47975680232048035,
-0.456870973110199,
0.0510520413517952,
0.7638657689094543,
0.611020565032959,
-0.6452738046646118,
-0.3444453477859497,
-0.4560319483280182,
0.9305298328399658,
-0.6951819062232971,
-0.02004951797425747,
0.7316294312477112,
0.33885982632637024,
-0.32534506916999817,
-0.36834263801574707,
-0.35908395051956177,
-0.2803463041782379,
-0.0938488095998764,
-0.1883598119020462,
-0.38857248425483704,
0.07069582492113113,
0.3454180359840393,
-0.20250970125198364,
-0.21233007311820984,
0.683708131313324,
-0.2761416435241699,
-0.36523672938346863,
0.8983897566795349,
0.3936406672000885,
0.44072672724723816,
-0.3431585133075714,
-0.5706181526184082,
-0.46040862798690796,
-1.177185297012329,
0.2906992435455322,
0.6161596179008484,
0.1595076024532318,
-0.1301354467868805,
0.480130136013031,
0.04041525349020958,
0.20936496555805206,
-0.20932333171367645,
-0.31862160563468933,
0.06363283842802048,
-0.11143092066049576,
-0.08257430791854858,
0.046054720878601074,
0.7028896808624268,
0.7930855751037598,
0.5676962733268738,
-0.1002504751086235,
-0.25231990218162537,
0.20321781933307648,
0.30539676547050476,
-0.6010878682136536,
0.11019619554281235,
0.04273686185479164,
-0.6082399487495422,
-0.5975519418716431,
-0.15240849554538727,
-0.6512419581413269,
-0.6197818517684937,
-0.013258236460387707,
0.20473513007164001,
-0.1319163590669632,
-0.38853755593299866,
0.2396312952041626,
0.23101802170276642,
-0.009881148114800453,
0.12083877623081207,
-0.8631630539894104,
0.07700768858194351,
0.6581100225448608,
0.5686910152435303,
-0.23451364040374756,
0.17737330496311188,
-0.5005329251289368,
0.32385602593421936,
-0.5089666247367859,
0.7606635689735413,
-0.4856089651584625,
-0.8096128702163696,
0.21999691426753998,
-0.018206574022769928,
0.24598486721515656,
-0.7445302605628967,
0.8440226912498474,
-0.4864519238471985,
-0.24111180007457733,
-0.792021632194519,
-0.13672298192977905,
-0.29952409863471985,
0.11833474040031433,
-0.526189386844635,
0.6343622207641602,
-0.13613107800483704,
-0.8019805550575256,
0.3860532343387604,
-0.30034393072128296,
-0.5988539457321167,
-0.3326442241668701,
-0.14047871530056,
-0.5384126305580139,
0.1741335242986679,
0.061219606548547745,
0.45560234785079956,
-0.1620239019393921,
0.314304381608963,
-0.5855185389518738,
-0.3056904077529907,
0.4425317049026489,
-0.48450249433517456,
0.6931312084197998,
0.26144033670425415,
-0.10386716574430466,
0.22211909294128418,
-0.46356356143951416,
-0.14382044970989227,
0.17350277304649353,
-0.5737923979759216,
-0.6185691952705383,
0.13837720453739166,
-0.10843278467655182,
0.5016464591026306,
0.09834527969360352,
-0.17902560532093048,
-0.28063201904296875,
-0.2227277010679245,
0.37280380725860596,
1.0462759733200073,
0.2101353406906128,
0.37230896949768066,
-0.5968383550643921,
0.5571311712265015,
0.001961788162589073,
0.7172778844833374,
0.012388930656015873,
-0.39053699374198914,
-0.5752949714660645,
-0.20630349218845367,
-0.06464830785989761,
0.37973806262016296,
-0.7490414381027222,
0.4124775528907776,
-0.033286675810813904,
-0.26969680190086365,
-0.08784564584493637,
-0.1488049030303955,
0.6209085583686829,
0.345857173204422,
0.11447997391223907,
-0.30981945991516113,
-0.32646870613098145,
-1.0559556484222412,
-0.12905088067054749,
-0.7185187935829163,
0.01217299047857523,
0.24421484768390656,
0.16615433990955353,
-0.2796938419342041,
0.7107003331184387,
-0.19757886230945587,
-0.06929934024810791,
0.15385979413986206,
-0.26920685172080994,
-0.18792875111103058,
0.42565712332725525,
0.7675435543060303,
-0.40858978033065796,
-0.10052059590816498,
-0.4093574583530426,
-0.8891702890396118,
-0.2402006834745407,
0.00839968491345644,
-0.21640872955322266,
0.12710174918174744,
0.3395664691925049,
-0.5647422075271606,
0.28475528955459595,
0.3343793749809265,
-0.19963368773460388,
0.589356005191803,
0.06795337796211243,
-0.0526694729924202,
-0.8617889881134033,
-0.14290869235992432,
-0.05135985091328621,
0.07489694654941559,
-0.675666332244873,
0.027835071086883545,
-0.011192582547664642,
0.17813937366008759,
-0.6593198180198669,
0.3152410686016083,
-0.2546160817146301,
-0.10096187889575958,
-0.3154585361480713,
-0.24978013336658478,
-0.10307886451482773,
0.03866032510995865,
-0.06638539582490921,
0.8866186141967773,
0.3910115957260132,
-0.7374306917190552,
-0.2424812763929367,
0.2711377441883087,
-0.2480563521385193,
0.42404988408088684,
-0.7776229381561279,
0.16789613664150238,
-0.0924554169178009,
0.15495340526103973,
-0.8200867176055908,
-0.3119993507862091,
0.4329778552055359,
-0.07014644891023636,
0.11106158047914505,
-0.11835023015737534,
-0.7237036824226379,
-0.2509477436542511,
-0.5375073552131653,
0.36216363310813904,
0.6494916081428528,
-0.4237113893032074,
0.07252123206853867,
0.9072599411010742,
-0.425965815782547,
-0.7310742735862732,
-0.6799816489219666,
0.27148422598838806,
-0.6678986549377441,
-0.5064858794212341,
-0.10952065140008926,
0.0909711942076683,
-0.4005744457244873,
-0.3573511242866516,
-0.19195988774299622,
0.07537176460027695,
0.6180307865142822,
0.44990524649620056,
0.395723432302475,
0.1957893818616867,
0.2653190493583679,
0.4436853528022766,
-0.3363274335861206,
0.42099639773368835,
0.2807159125804901,
0.332719087600708,
0.11253861337900162,
-0.5487499237060547,
-0.33227550983428955,
0.42490461468696594,
0.43712615966796875,
-0.10628166794776917,
0.6792269945144653,
0.010631225071847439,
-0.43812063336372375,
0.22322435677051544,
-0.5843906998634338,
-0.379799485206604,
-0.5441941022872925,
0.41656795144081116,
0.12341587990522385,
-1.0357015132904053,
0.3364144563674927,
-0.12755456566810608,
0.23512201011180878,
0.09502024203538895,
0.36132803559303284,
-0.28996533155441284,
1.0661735534667969,
0.47077664732933044,
-0.08852944523096085,
0.506701648235321,
0.10940857976675034,
0.4116987884044647,
-0.6673967838287354,
-0.48780515789985657,
-0.5574451684951782,
0.1200333759188652,
-0.6222182512283325,
-0.4025181829929352,
0.7017300724983215,
0.1984919011592865,
-0.5326995849609375,
0.2018289566040039,
-0.3672100901603699,
0.34952017664909363,
0.19870509207248688,
0.08676402270793915,
0.3610631823539734,
0.28243809938430786,
0.05397677421569824,
-0.08010244369506836,
-0.5838496685028076,
-1.165421724319458,
0.9710785746574402,
0.8595603704452515,
1.2939491271972656,
0.387315958738327,
0.6115719079971313,
0.2902076840400696,
0.4431895911693573,
-0.5941616296768188,
0.5249749422073364,
0.04744221642613411,
-0.5598598718643188,
-0.20517705380916595,
-0.37164533138275146,
-0.8737205266952515,
0.19278304278850555,
-0.24639186263084412,
-0.7082438468933105,
0.30454951524734497,
0.27664604783058167,
-0.45719173550605774,
0.12888436019420624,
-0.6412108540534973,
0.2943741977214813,
-0.592073917388916,
-0.43615472316741943,
-0.2340962439775467,
-0.7118664383888245,
0.46372032165527344,
-0.14923132956027985,
0.3785931169986725,
-0.446254700422287,
-0.13268078863620758,
0.7751238346099854,
-0.06501275300979614,
1.210034728050232,
-0.14301830530166626,
-0.4789913594722748,
0.24237680435180664,
0.2431277334690094,
0.5682723522186279,
0.06733356416225433,
-0.24169176816940308,
0.28509771823883057,
0.10098809748888016,
-0.36496490240097046,
-0.306903600692749,
0.6921624541282654,
-0.7439971566200256,
-0.876832902431488,
-0.302044540643692,
-0.5516449213027954,
-0.355942040681839,
0.014121857471764088,
-0.08923681080341339,
-0.0867047905921936,
-0.00675242068246007,
-0.15850931406021118,
0.8844516277313232,
-0.7072024941444397,
0.5612329244613647,
0.5364421010017395,
-0.056553635746240616,
-0.20694294571876526,
0.5659648180007935,
0.037955909967422485,
0.4783024191856384,
-0.09531354159116745,
0.01936439611017704,
-0.6023699641227722,
-0.5676026344299316,
-0.30269694328308105,
0.17130979895591736,
-0.9466692209243774,
-0.3952358663082123,
-0.6196210980415344,
0.03534059599041939,
-0.12967273592948914,
0.038590919226408005,
-0.11623988300561905,
-0.14256231486797333,
-0.45676976442337036,
-0.4488089084625244,
0.11557964235544205,
0.9619327187538147,
-0.22395563125610352,
0.2285570204257965,
-0.6250646114349365,
-0.1005580723285675,
0.43731191754341125,
0.24384358525276184,
0.15522445738315582,
-0.3677864968776703,
0.07086572051048279,
-0.10691196471452713,
-0.38828834891319275,
-0.8320338129997253,
0.08383525907993317,
-0.38965460658073425,
0.8744882941246033,
0.5943105220794678,
0.4709774851799011,
0.1990388035774231,
-0.4438507854938507,
0.6925310492515564,
0.5766723155975342,
-0.5651330351829529,
0.3664405345916748,
-0.2947935461997986,
-0.39003702998161316,
0.3245602548122406,
0.4794277846813202,
-0.4859478771686554,
0.01408989168703556,
-0.13407716155052185,
-0.8331112265586853,
0.4519701600074768,
0.08846651017665863,
0.6128979325294495,
-0.45985931158065796,
0.21384507417678833,
0.17598196864128113,
0.13480480015277863,
-0.8159709572792053,
-0.003375174943357706,
-0.15123684704303741,
0.004544446244835854,
0.20253407955169678,
-0.8645602464675903,
-0.3496241271495819,
0.2706982493400574,
0.5544801950454712,
-0.07181409746408463,
0.11494436860084534,
-0.18951186537742615,
-0.11471068859100342,
-0.13815538585186005,
0.523421585559845,
0.5968306660652161,
0.22655533254146576,
0.1901339739561081,
0.3570702075958252,
0.33567649126052856,
-0.20195728540420532,
0.4769498109817505,
-0.12644356489181519,
-0.07895240932703018,
-0.4816346764564514,
0.3839775025844574,
0.6996530890464783,
0.2741405665874481,
-0.7914143204689026,
0.43845972418785095,
0.10776876658201218,
0.23487704992294312,
0.009243365377187729,
0.2716163396835327,
0.057857636362314224,
0.14377783238887787,
0.2842523455619812,
-0.011232271790504456,
0.1941407024860382,
-0.4184620976448059,
0.0845610499382019,
0.6218315958976746,
-0.3266783654689789,
-0.15791776776313782,
0.6367745399475098,
0.3562043011188507,
-0.3455897867679596,
0.06070641428232193,
0.09833629429340363,
-0.3635776937007904,
0.5871163010597229,
0.3293188810348511,
0.5823471546173096,
-0.2721259295940399,
0.2735394835472107,
0.2804372012615204,
0.6283234357833862,
-0.15247495472431183,
0.03442806750535965,
0.22614219784736633,
-0.5531874895095825,
-0.2834008038043976,
-0.5657309889793396,
-0.3165486454963684,
0.037528593093156815,
-0.7492737174034119,
-0.10893955081701279,
-0.7680068016052246,
-0.5898308753967285,
-0.40226325392723083,
-0.42412588000297546,
-0.32871854305267334,
-0.07308842241764069,
0.2635098695755005,
0.6806804537773132,
-1.0549741983413696,
0.3756803870201111,
0.4973534643650055,
-0.5985811948776245,
-0.8168630003929138,
0.31497514247894287,
-0.02993331477046013,
-0.7888621091842651,
0.6704375743865967,
0.19930480420589447,
-0.1894703358411789,
-0.4533681571483612,
-0.45536553859710693,
-0.990020751953125,
0.8294247388839722,
0.8739644289016724,
-0.854106068611145,
-0.024960797280073166,
0.46242815256118774,
0.5479047894477844,
0.07572707533836365,
0.031616099178791046,
0.6759354472160339,
0.26334741711616516,
-0.20452004671096802,
-0.9850201606750488,
0.4303601086139679,
0.07942645251750946,
0.49270930886268616,
-0.1892751306295395,
-0.6691848635673523,
0.6977699995040894,
-0.4109194576740265,
-0.3965457081794739,
0.12191569060087204,
0.2995840609073639,
0.5405554175376892,
0.18937808275222778,
0.5995764136314392,
0.3758294880390167,
0.6897022724151611,
-0.04331226274371147,
1.3916611671447754,
0.22691255807876587,
0.14216357469558716,
0.7564125061035156,
-0.39470070600509644,
0.6577900052070618,
0.6422362923622131,
-0.3620050549507141,
0.2123183161020279,
0.883215069770813,
0.37308332324028015,
0.9428355693817139,
0.4049720764160156,
-0.33261406421661377,
-0.39706605672836304,
-0.6121672987937927,
-0.4479201138019562,
0.17817065119743347,
0.2260010689496994,
-0.4065069854259491,
-0.1689683049917221,
-0.05453277379274368,
0.37558192014694214,
0.06878800690174103,
-0.04012997820973396,
0.8261423707008362,
0.33476051688194275,
-0.5407025218009949,
0.5451182126998901,
-0.08696604520082474,
0.7892571687698364,
-0.21309950947761536,
-0.13779917359352112,
-0.29215970635414124,
-0.15480937063694,
-0.16445229947566986,
-1.0274945497512817,
0.3188304305076599,
0.04024702310562134,
-0.23689347505569458,
0.011184345930814743,
0.6384503245353699,
-0.0013393748085945845,
-0.35797053575515747,
0.6062146425247192,
0.3146415650844574,
0.08975063264369965,
0.16704590618610382,
-0.48451775312423706,
0.38854482769966125,
-0.218557670712471,
0.007143823895603418,
0.6012652516365051,
-0.025015950202941895,
-0.5863187313079834,
0.8053610324859619,
0.7060402631759644,
-0.13628292083740234,
0.18112653493881226,
0.2123265415430069,
1.0440618991851807,
-0.11092733591794968,
-0.5627869367599487,
-0.6152544021606445,
0.5206902027130127,
-0.08879142254590988,
-0.07658849656581879,
0.37937384843826294,
-0.0019818253349512815,
0.6853034496307373,
-0.022900156676769257,
0.9361655116081238,
0.30497732758522034,
0.24236781895160675,
-0.6057406067848206,
0.9276267290115356,
-0.35294896364212036,
0.6777877807617188,
-0.3191574811935425,
-0.7497713565826416,
-0.18343950808048248,
0.7688591480255127,
-0.5474084615707397,
0.20225094258785248,
0.2571744918823242,
0.9044628739356995,
0.24738524854183197,
-0.054992932826280594,
0.43323367834091187,
-0.03335046395659447,
0.620772123336792,
0.5455487370491028,
1.3837864398956299,
-0.1725088506937027,
0.5891034603118896,
-0.09181036800146103,
-0.18973051011562347,
-0.26182255148887634,
-0.9517375826835632,
-0.9844499826431274,
-0.2712324559688568,
-0.16172266006469727,
-0.38701745867729187,
0.34554335474967957,
0.7237855195999146,
0.7452290654182434,
-0.8347429037094116,
0.09993014484643936,
0.2525203824043274,
0.1898193657398224,
0.2709774971008301,
-0.16353371739387512,
0.22201195359230042,
-0.13655853271484375,
-0.2359977513551712,
0.1561049371957779,
0.2087835669517517,
0.32280272245407104,
-0.26312166452407837,
-0.32947540283203125,
0.28560370206832886,
0.07225026190280914,
0.7499603033065796,
0.2012992799282074,
-0.9189236164093018,
-0.6645920872688293,
-0.19073383510112762,
-0.3081727623939514,
-0.19952794909477234,
0.35895928740501404,
-0.3001099228858948,
0.022463330999016762,
0.07279841601848602,
0.695252001285553,
-0.03162691369652748,
-0.2567760944366455,
0.4204053580760956,
-0.49864059686660767,
0.02392251044511795,
0.2066286951303482,
0.4890095293521881,
0.6523206233978271,
-0.7563040256500244,
0.4994453489780426,
-0.11358103901147842,
-0.3781105577945709,
-1.022383451461792,
0.4232361614704132,
-0.6215212345123291,
-0.07223418354988098,
1.5403459072113037,
-0.3008231222629547,
0.16410037875175476,
-0.14676442742347717,
-0.4754822552204132,
0.2835324704647064,
-0.4840797483921051,
1.2995902299880981,
0.36751458048820496,
0.00041088962461799383,
-0.2002890706062317,
-0.4624404311180115,
0.46467113494873047,
0.5549494624137878,
-1.1435085535049438,
0.07528198510408401,
0.6595665812492371,
0.6628665328025818,
0.018431369215250015,
0.29071635007858276,
-0.26302599906921387,
0.3736445903778076,
-0.2597867250442505,
-0.0879441350698471,
-0.16843564808368683,
-0.295389324426651,
-0.41045641899108887,
0.013872271403670311,
0.42625460028648376,
-0.21367883682250977
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12394v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12394v1
|
A Big Data Analytics System for Predicting Suicidal Ideation in Real-Time Based on Social Media Streaming Data
| 2024-03-19T21:46:52 | 2024-03-19T21:46:52 |
Mohamed A. Allayla, Serkan Ayvaz
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.SI
|
Online social media platforms have recently become integral to our society
and daily routines. Every day, users worldwide spend a couple of hours on such
platforms, expressing their sentiments and emotional state and contacting each
other. Analyzing such huge amounts of data from these platforms can provide a
clear insight into public sentiments and help detect their mental status. The
early identification of these health condition risks may assist in preventing
or reducing the number of suicide ideation and potentially saving people's
lives. The traditional techniques have become ineffective in processing such
streams and large-scale datasets. Therefore, the paper proposed a new
methodology based on a big data architecture to predict suicidal ideation from
social media content. The proposed approach provides a practical analysis of
social media data in two phases: batch processing and real-time streaming
prediction. The batch dataset was collected from the Reddit forum and used for
model building and training, while streaming big data was extracted using
Twitter streaming API and used for real-time prediction. After the raw data was
preprocessed, the extracted features were fed to multiple Apache Spark ML
classifiers: NB, LR, LinearSVC, DT, RF, and MLP. We conducted various
experiments using various feature-extraction techniques with different testing
scenarios. The experimental results of the batch processing phase showed that
the features extracted of (Unigram + Bigram) + CV-IDF with MLP classifier
provided high performance for classifying suicidal ideation, with an accuracy
of 93.47%, and then applied for real-time streaming prediction phase.
|
[
-0.3800552487373352,
-1.3991460800170898,
0.6811875104904175,
0.6781281232833862,
-0.4725850522518158,
0.16561400890350342,
-0.2843453288078308,
-0.4624998867511749,
0.7006763815879822,
0.09131227433681488,
-0.7381552457809448,
-0.6618026494979858,
-0.6714618802070618,
-0.1975504606962204,
-0.26399168372154236,
0.4758831262588501,
-0.17295630276203156,
0.1653352528810501,
0.3202000558376312,
0.25092795491218567,
-0.5392055511474609,
-0.2943134903907776,
-1.2646528482437134,
0.40699371695518494,
0.8479661345481873,
0.15525729954242706,
0.3303174376487732,
0.23485901951789856,
0.6429646015167236,
0.23286984860897064,
-0.09966953843832016,
-0.14556686580181122,
-0.5282614231109619,
0.2674488425254822,
0.15629003942012787,
-0.2141793817281723,
-0.39176151156425476,
-0.1598414033651352,
0.4128262996673584,
-0.060780398547649384,
-0.1840854436159134,
0.6457273364067078,
0.00003939725138479844,
0.6583966016769409,
-0.7285298705101013,
0.0877915769815445,
-0.36740052700042725,
0.5003126263618469,
-0.18815773725509644,
-0.18361815810203552,
-0.06651761382818222,
-0.65175861120224,
-0.1371176689863205,
-0.32610443234443665,
0.012484805658459663,
-0.3348914682865143,
0.41888391971588135,
0.4742225408554077,
0.021227391436696053,
-0.03675258904695511,
-1.0451298952102661,
0.6228703260421753,
-0.6537081003189087,
0.16703738272190094,
0.1509895771741867,
0.8740997314453125,
-0.06888068467378616,
-0.1678304523229599,
-0.7779855132102966,
0.42502638697624207,
0.17755615711212158,
0.11488383263349533,
-0.030980166047811508,
-0.06351065635681152,
0.31749391555786133,
-0.17275965213775635,
-0.654403805732727,
-0.04447479918599129,
-0.3566839098930359,
0.02380479872226715,
0.9873722791671753,
0.20285849273204803,
0.24328838288784027,
-0.40426725149154663,
-0.2206944227218628,
0.2674996852874756,
-0.08879926055669785,
0.020574206486344337,
0.16854707896709442,
0.17638738453388214,
-0.15771476924419403,
0.38773053884506226,
-0.23391073942184448,
0.2742479741573334,
0.061209362000226974,
-0.2709513306617737,
0.3080613315105438,
0.16254381835460663,
-0.2579651474952698,
0.3754773736000061,
1.0303012132644653,
0.520298421382904,
0.3795529007911682,
0.2998327314853668,
0.2866850197315216,
0.1694696992635727,
0.3594360947608948,
-0.9524943232536316,
-0.15370719134807587,
0.8314198851585388,
-0.7904619574546814,
-0.40360596776008606,
-0.22082290053367615,
-0.9429352283477783,
-0.5950900316238403,
-0.26854008436203003,
0.3735004663467407,
-0.567079484462738,
-0.5580155849456787,
-0.09217121452093124,
-0.010013793595135212,
-0.2176411747932434,
0.3325206935405731,
-0.2387801557779312,
-0.31484121084213257,
0.8151276111602783,
1.3256646394729614,
-0.077037513256073,
-0.025188343599438667,
-0.2892993092536926,
0.1216081976890564,
-0.19109055399894714,
0.893268883228302,
-0.3085941970348358,
0.1874960958957672,
0.26551634073257446,
0.05876193568110466,
0.14291855692863464,
-0.06665070354938507,
0.7776525616645813,
-0.3914607763290405,
-0.21503397822380066,
-0.19159133732318878,
-0.47066783905029297,
-0.22954508662223816,
0.23468312621116638,
-0.7553205490112305,
0.544418215751648,
-0.41663220524787903,
-1.0006139278411865,
0.6035743951797485,
-0.8714739680290222,
-0.35074371099472046,
0.5349198579788208,
0.1405024528503418,
-0.6990217566490173,
-0.18434643745422363,
0.2536337077617645,
1.213414192199707,
-0.01606200449168682,
0.5899813771247864,
-0.9035783410072327,
-0.4547642171382904,
0.25329917669296265,
-0.471190869808197,
0.6672128438949585,
0.44734540581703186,
-0.16111133992671967,
-0.019620036706328392,
-0.4898073077201843,
0.15220001339912415,
0.1123039498925209,
-0.05623761937022209,
-0.30211135745048523,
0.24501246213912964,
0.3831356465816498,
0.4707956314086914,
-0.07992945611476898,
-0.9829301238059998,
-0.050999097526073456,
0.05887623503804207,
0.45169031620025635,
0.48562607169151306,
0.768649697303772,
-0.1812867671251297,
-0.08117984235286713,
0.4650997519493103,
-0.0410742424428463,
0.5192837715148926,
0.32832616567611694,
-0.42771393060684204,
0.01937914453446865,
-0.6064025163650513,
-0.01858535222709179,
0.6984450221061707,
-0.40961915254592896,
0.7343896627426147,
-0.1598832905292511,
-0.8504188060760498,
-0.4691363275051117,
-0.06132372096180916,
0.14476294815540314,
0.027608253061771393,
0.36749985814094543,
0.2939929664134979,
-0.8018507361412048,
-0.8050786256790161,
-0.21319925785064697,
0.07181712985038757,
-0.2133917510509491,
-0.23726463317871094,
0.15332181751728058,
-0.36172354221343994,
0.6969119310379028,
-0.9473585486412048,
-0.5029174089431763,
-0.31790465116500854,
0.35099220275878906,
0.23177143931388855,
0.08417048305273056,
0.2710953652858734,
-1.0413874387741089,
-0.749039351940155,
-0.10372992604970932,
-1.1337246894836426,
0.20175765454769135,
-0.19784033298492432,
-0.19950301945209503,
-0.16166932880878448,
0.3848792016506195,
-0.5182085633277893,
0.588301956653595,
0.21360808610916138,
0.047351546585559845,
0.47601446509361267,
0.3303527534008026,
0.16289874911308289,
-1.3182628154754639,
0.030090143904089928,
0.3517472743988037,
0.3050661087036133,
-0.5979872941970825,
-0.6394665837287903,
0.011138739995658398,
-0.2094552367925644,
-0.5179800987243652,
0.4124666452407837,
0.12289480119943619,
0.3258548378944397,
-0.1949893832206726,
-0.21295516192913055,
-0.45630162954330444,
0.46349290013313293,
-0.054516859352588654,
0.2569919228553772,
0.5074924230575562,
-0.219173401594162,
0.46714696288108826,
0.2559637725353241,
-0.48429742455482483,
0.6302919983863831,
-0.4288918077945709,
-0.23445731401443481,
-0.6603401899337769,
0.6513701677322388,
-1.0647547245025635,
-0.5125725269317627,
0.19687727093696594,
-0.5265244245529175,
-0.2001345008611679,
-0.1727813482284546,
-0.25119686126708984,
-0.6056033372879028,
-0.42473500967025757,
0.11405549943447113,
0.19372892379760742,
0.04411930963397026,
0.46022528409957886,
0.6215686798095703,
-0.7321728467941284,
-0.4827744662761688,
-0.40354543924331665,
0.12000928819179535,
-0.5719555616378784,
-0.5365644097328186,
0.052866414189338684,
0.03301696851849556,
-0.1901008039712906,
-0.011925779283046722,
0.3173399567604065,
0.033537134528160095,
-0.12737300992012024,
0.7760401964187622,
0.33469411730766296,
0.19011583924293518,
0.460228830575943,
0.36241546273231506,
-0.13278260827064514,
0.14869746565818787,
0.02439909800887108,
0.6094841957092285,
0.18416617810726166,
-0.17802296578884125,
-0.950497567653656,
0.46826139092445374,
0.521164059638977,
0.0879763588309288,
0.9559858441352844,
0.9132909178733826,
-0.59852135181427,
-0.3313145637512207,
-0.6694620847702026,
0.25577375292778015,
-0.42164358496665955,
0.2615486681461334,
0.07937466353178024,
-0.4467122554779053,
0.5385907292366028,
-0.08166550099849701,
0.20581799745559692,
0.17634692788124084,
0.7296048998832703,
-0.4510589838027954,
0.9804757237434387,
0.3532514274120331,
0.006837824825197458,
0.6650196313858032,
-0.48061344027519226,
0.5995936989784241,
-0.5427015423774719,
-0.10989377647638321,
0.04170399159193039,
-0.718352198600769,
-0.24759452044963837,
-0.1815703809261322,
0.5283963084220886,
0.09922003746032715,
-0.35453659296035767,
0.369676411151886,
-0.4404687285423279,
0.40331199765205383,
-0.17764781415462494,
0.1743963360786438,
0.06176316738128662,
0.03829918056726456,
0.3207802176475525,
-0.19562609493732452,
-0.2108519822359085,
-0.46691086888313293,
1.0896211862564087,
0.48352208733558655,
0.3815697133541107,
-0.08673185110092163,
0.5809094309806824,
0.8680644035339355,
0.6345366835594177,
-0.868072509765625,
0.43752408027648926,
0.0054756999015808105,
-0.5441945791244507,
-0.5720372796058655,
-0.25747349858283997,
-0.6314032673835754,
-0.13600923120975494,
-0.3828031122684479,
-0.47392335534095764,
0.034697502851486206,
-0.10899528115987778,
-0.8233510255813599,
0.30198606848716736,
-0.7520655393600464,
0.5826346278190613,
-0.34131526947021484,
-0.2677918076515198,
-0.3371519446372986,
-0.4173557162284851,
0.4016331136226654,
-0.6337643265724182,
0.45143163204193115,
-0.34537097811698914,
0.29565444588661194,
1.0729840993881226,
-0.18228022754192352,
0.5857563614845276,
-0.4561198055744171,
0.06058329716324806,
0.43245044350624084,
-0.06888923048973083,
0.33326250314712524,
0.19461777806282043,
-0.2006276249885559,
0.19416020810604095,
-0.022082127630710602,
-0.41773664951324463,
-0.5656083226203918,
0.7829715013504028,
-0.5849104523658752,
0.09083374589681625,
0.0020364862866699696,
-0.16798928380012512,
-0.27499231696128845,
0.06116801127791405,
0.40402039885520935,
0.15734605491161346,
-0.3784574866294861,
-0.02272000163793564,
0.4093991816043854,
-0.003619551658630371,
0.7523350715637207,
-0.01026209071278572,
-0.09988445043563843,
-0.49304699897766113,
1.052092432975769,
0.5543301701545715,
-0.030970999971032143,
0.2657414972782135,
0.07092012465000153,
-0.15877887606620789,
-0.6105904579162598,
-0.2900784909725189,
0.31038594245910645,
-0.35083040595054626,
-0.3587058186531067,
-0.993475079536438,
-0.3672385513782501,
-0.3009255826473236,
-0.3591287136077881,
-0.23828527331352234,
-0.05349334701895714,
0.07390932738780975,
-0.35361248254776,
0.4593254625797272,
0.6380398869514465,
-0.07406122982501984,
0.44459080696105957,
-0.9697017669677734,
0.3377669155597687,
0.2618330419063568,
0.3784724473953247,
0.3501507341861725,
0.2205505669116974,
-0.4579166769981384,
0.2459408938884735,
-0.31511834263801575,
-0.7790405750274658,
0.6320837736129761,
-0.10141614824533463,
0.12266089022159576,
0.8972565531730652,
0.10811430215835571,
0.5981751680374146,
-0.15350612998008728,
0.3454568386077881,
0.36618733406066895,
-0.1674068123102188,
0.4998584985733032,
-0.6062302589416504,
-0.09306743741035461,
0.7504844665527344,
0.9400154948234558,
-0.9379489421844482,
-0.20305030047893524,
-0.523328423500061,
-0.5959710478782654,
0.2899357080459595,
0.09227586537599564,
-0.16690675914287567,
-0.006533194333314896,
0.17604592442512512,
0.1928195059299469,
0.22148527204990387,
-0.30429404973983765,
0.031089430674910545,
0.033876340836286545,
-0.35229769349098206,
0.07817273586988449,
-0.04886991158127785,
0.14741601049900055,
-0.3625311255455017,
0.5248640775680542,
0.15105846524238586,
0.5161346197128296,
-0.008060915395617485,
0.3848096430301666,
-0.6563169956207275,
-0.032419800758361816,
-0.08765838295221329,
0.6782693266868591,
-0.626997172832489,
-0.30865034461021423,
0.05532453581690788,
-0.6543496251106262,
0.22911886870861053,
-0.0034785724710673094,
-0.2531977593898773,
-0.026247790083289146,
0.41278666257858276,
0.6290048360824585,
-0.17158113420009613,
-0.7172461748123169,
0.581867516040802,
-0.14411422610282898,
-0.29088401794433594,
-1.0476322174072266,
-0.008744148537516594,
0.3392558693885803,
0.37072062492370605,
0.5156594514846802,
-0.09588304907083511,
0.011971530504524708,
-0.515929639339447,
0.17375729978084564,
0.32566171884536743,
-0.4412224590778351,
-0.3580857813358307,
0.298095166683197,
0.005715600214898586,
-0.5550128221511841,
0.06771925836801529,
-0.2054784595966339,
-0.41627049446105957,
0.3957197070121765,
0.044153280556201935,
1.329619288444519,
-0.3318541944026947,
0.7121675610542297,
0.5124214887619019,
-0.25022050738334656,
-0.09781284630298615,
0.3686582148075104,
0.21760804951190948,
-0.3867643475532532,
-0.7417870163917542,
-1.2135159969329834,
0.030317187309265137,
0.46020984649658203,
-0.42966997623443604,
0.5568062663078308,
-0.8335186243057251,
-0.29591426253318787,
0.502837598323822,
-0.06652843207120895,
-0.3465489149093628,
0.364226758480072,
0.5123013257980347,
0.5956292152404785,
-1.2018587589263916,
0.5607011318206787,
0.39077553153038025,
-0.23787209391593933,
-0.5791441798210144,
0.5092980265617371,
0.19532042741775513,
-0.26442718505859375,
0.3932277262210846,
0.2709824740886688,
0.12967614829540253,
-0.1558716595172882,
-0.6342829465866089,
-0.8376298546791077,
0.8290432691574097,
-0.16749660670757294,
-0.6412421464920044,
-0.20495428144931793,
0.046501949429512024,
0.7684831023216248,
-0.46406519412994385,
0.039177484810352325,
0.32289940118789673,
0.5270651578903198,
0.5919682383537292,
-0.38326841592788696,
-0.030800240114331245,
-0.24257369339466095,
-0.1567058265209198,
0.5941741466522217,
-0.48364508152008057,
0.6291381120681763,
0.06080018728971481,
-0.5177469849586487,
-0.6706883311271667,
0.39105015993118286,
0.05179351195693016,
0.5259225964546204,
0.3807542324066162,
0.7301063537597656,
0.3733493387699127,
0.4866461157798767,
0.5060518383979797,
0.17198562622070312,
0.42108386754989624,
0.5769001841545105,
-0.20347894728183746,
1.2882683277130127,
0.05843252316117287,
-0.26972898840904236,
0.29852208495140076,
0.5169711709022522,
0.08025309443473816,
0.48328158259391785,
-0.0787673071026802,
-0.2341703623533249,
-0.2779581546783447,
0.12157780677080154,
-0.11593730002641678,
0.14079827070236206,
0.709995687007904,
-0.14107675850391388,
-0.25732100009918213,
0.5158459544181824,
0.2322002351284027,
-0.216529980301857,
-0.33302444219589233,
0.8200227618217468,
-0.08329186588525772,
-0.4043980538845062,
0.7659481763839722,
-0.18569612503051758,
0.69533771276474,
-0.2374129295349121,
-0.04999101907014847,
0.18131482601165771,
0.32868465781211853,
-0.3178449273109436,
-0.9835666418075562,
0.6561696529388428,
0.07081829011440277,
-0.09242211282253265,
-0.16574446856975555,
0.8251016736030579,
-0.1539565473794937,
-0.9643747210502625,
0.30528202652931213,
0.39278167486190796,
0.0656447634100914,
-0.6264370083808899,
-0.7567251920700073,
0.02816667966544628,
0.02202793024480343,
-0.20964370667934418,
0.29118067026138306,
0.29019221663475037,
-0.18649746477603912,
0.6782462000846863,
0.8076586723327637,
0.41791412234306335,
-0.2584556043148041,
-0.36349451541900635,
0.789584755897522,
-0.8294381499290466,
-0.5546565055847168,
-0.8573740124702454,
0.3312697112560272,
-0.41616830229759216,
-0.2459430992603302,
0.42681899666786194,
0.44421854615211487,
0.3239121437072754,
0.12101241201162338,
1.0029635429382324,
-0.40116506814956665,
1.0930426120758057,
-0.08151672035455704,
1.028820276260376,
-0.22717714309692383,
-0.23009352385997772,
-0.438194215297699,
-1.1536469459533691,
-0.24761749804019928,
0.24878470599651337,
-0.7398536205291748,
-0.49013829231262207,
0.6245604753494263,
0.3838752508163452,
-0.03018760308623314,
0.35706019401550293,
-0.07833292335271835,
0.3648596405982971,
0.42752528190612793,
0.2509046196937561,
0.5029112696647644,
-0.10524560511112213,
0.27787452936172485,
-0.33297494053840637,
-0.5257589221000671,
-0.5674055218696594,
-0.44270560145378113,
-0.9545201659202576,
-0.7942427396774292,
0.04377945140004158,
-0.0417473129928112,
-0.09312651306390762,
1.0439727306365967,
0.3053407073020935,
-0.6589473485946655,
0.055009666830301285,
0.09894511848688126,
-0.15422423183918,
-0.27661287784576416,
-0.2638632655143738,
0.6156798005104065,
0.074785977602005,
-0.20441177487373352,
0.016849463805556297,
0.3347964882850647,
-0.2851731479167938,
-0.3768862187862396,
0.25278717279434204,
-0.6477695107460022,
0.07952417433261871,
0.7361060380935669,
0.07464610785245895,
-0.3289162814617157,
-0.17825911939144135,
-0.2074352502822876,
-0.03301361948251724,
-0.22028841078281403,
0.5484845638275146,
-0.5851098299026489,
0.07464156299829483,
0.5523310303688049,
0.4427034258842468,
0.5396702885627747,
0.412020742893219,
0.19118568301200867,
-0.2390356957912445,
0.0339106060564518,
0.35121431946754456,
0.020968254655599594,
0.10427912324666977,
-0.8427014946937561,
0.19394250214099884,
0.11091858893632889,
-0.4071473181247711,
-0.6200230717658997,
-0.09581813216209412,
-0.8957592248916626,
-0.4146682620048523,
0.874250054359436,
0.05329429358243942,
-0.5573027729988098,
-0.3638828992843628,
-0.4764159917831421,
0.47935813665390015,
-0.5814829468727112,
1.1153794527053833,
0.5468975901603699,
-0.18839533627033234,
0.18132935464382172,
-0.9809263944625854,
0.5593529939651489,
-0.1307562291622162,
-0.7733581066131592,
0.4199574887752533,
0.36770129203796387,
0.11326059699058533,
0.31537923216819763,
0.48084917664527893,
0.21559594571590424,
0.016949452459812164,
-0.2829028367996216,
0.03063509613275528,
-0.063134104013443,
-0.3898070156574249,
0.022160900756716728,
0.5259995460510254,
-0.7364118695259094,
-0.16710789501667023
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.13169v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.13169v2
|
Wav2Gloss: Generating Interlinear Glossed Text from Speech
| 2024-03-19T21:45:29 | 2024-06-06T03:37:32 |
Taiqi He, Kwanghee Choi, Lindia Tjuatja, Nathaniel R. Robinson, Jiatong Shi, Shinji Watanabe, Graham Neubig, David R. Mortensen, Lori Levin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Thousands of the world's languages are in danger of extinction--a tremendous
threat to cultural identities and human language diversity. Interlinear Glossed
Text (IGT) is a form of linguistic annotation that can support documentation
and resource creation for these languages' communities. IGT typically consists
of (1) transcriptions, (2) morphological segmentation, (3) glosses, and (4)
free translations to a majority language. We propose Wav2Gloss: a task in which
these four annotation components are extracted automatically from speech, and
introduce the first dataset to this end, Fieldwork: a corpus of speech with all
these annotations, derived from the work of field linguists, covering 37
languages, with standard formatting, and train/dev/test splits. We provide
various baselines to lay the groundwork for future research on IGT generation
from speech, such as end-to-end versus cascaded, monolingual versus
multilingual, and single-task versus multi-task approaches.
|
[
-0.6981984376907349,
-0.9211307764053345,
-0.12990465760231018,
0.2752045691013336,
-0.2833762466907501,
0.28200820088386536,
-0.336916983127594,
-0.6503580808639526,
0.22888997197151184,
0.49861428141593933,
-0.6236802935600281,
-0.3132014870643616,
-0.6711366772651672,
-0.16675306856632233,
-0.718687891960144,
1.410631537437439,
0.3060479462146759,
-0.20274527370929718,
-0.05216223746538162,
-0.1292455941438675,
-0.0813266932964325,
-0.5713627338409424,
-0.36290448904037476,
-0.2539355158805847,
0.3368036448955536,
0.6391609907150269,
0.6049370765686035,
0.7004933953285217,
0.3958836793899536,
0.0787416473031044,
0.046743009239435196,
0.11877507716417313,
-0.5090742707252502,
0.15332241356372833,
-0.12831474840641022,
-0.1548430472612381,
-0.14101272821426392,
0.10204412788152695,
0.40510082244873047,
0.5302396416664124,
-0.12859123945236206,
0.46292024850845337,
0.09375270456075668,
0.4272269606590271,
-0.24562737345695496,
0.3324953317642212,
-0.7974748015403748,
-0.13798865675926208,
-0.7902840971946716,
-0.27208212018013,
0.05396966636180878,
-0.36615443229675293,
0.46290239691734314,
-0.6404154300689697,
0.20941512286663055,
-0.0475308932363987,
0.9235910773277283,
0.23519232869148254,
-0.150644451379776,
-0.8223142027854919,
-0.6009500026702881,
0.2857223451137543,
-0.7770302295684814,
0.04789486154913902,
0.49679291248321533,
0.14873109757900238,
-0.06299600005149841,
-1.1637533903121948,
-0.6078323721885681,
-0.19982962310314178,
0.08372759073972702,
0.45022913813591003,
-0.45011189579963684,
0.17525853216648102,
0.25253796577453613,
0.29114651679992676,
-0.5817230343818665,
0.2627081573009491,
-0.832731306552887,
-0.12100888043642044,
0.6513521671295166,
-0.20841872692108154,
0.6626283526420593,
-0.1727343499660492,
-0.5018318295478821,
0.0289726834744215,
-0.6953707933425903,
-0.0954774022102356,
0.6286793351173401,
0.4864121079444885,
0.042037103325128555,
0.4251437485218048,
-0.2021685093641281,
0.37488600611686707,
-0.3089454472064972,
-0.2868413031101227,
0.14409784972667694,
-0.16839046776294708,
0.11258439719676971,
0.21998833119869232,
0.8256320357322693,
0.4835863709449768,
0.37805014848709106,
-0.23117679357528687,
-0.0600518062710762,
0.003102980786934495,
0.13142691552639008,
-0.6869935393333435,
-0.19626392424106598,
0.06384628266096115,
-0.2033463716506958,
-0.108416348695755,
0.03322158008813858,
-0.7325411438941956,
-0.10180693119764328,
-0.2458503693342209,
0.1872919201850891,
-0.7034405469894409,
-0.4451623857021332,
-0.3683028519153595,
-0.1370800882577896,
0.31589508056640625,
-0.0029602041468024254,
-1.2477353811264038,
0.34799808263778687,
0.7459971904754639,
0.9019270539283752,
-0.16194041073322296,
-0.26229745149612427,
-0.684165894985199,
-0.029134225100278854,
-0.20980963110923767,
0.6899300217628479,
-0.2051728516817093,
-0.6215405464172363,
0.2611258625984192,
-0.36025258898735046,
0.4590984880924225,
-0.6071261167526245,
0.5325079560279846,
-0.30622655153274536,
0.3098967671394348,
-0.2236049324274063,
-0.6217672228813171,
-0.36164528131484985,
-0.14223210513591766,
-0.4479401111602783,
1.3144619464874268,
0.3148108720779419,
-0.6207582950592041,
0.45803141593933105,
-0.7069979906082153,
-0.481400728225708,
0.8747084140777588,
-0.42428869009017944,
-0.22299417853355408,
-0.03674904629588127,
0.06849750876426697,
0.19533424079418182,
-0.5450421571731567,
0.3950478732585907,
0.13430383801460266,
-0.13925860822200775,
-0.3046242296695709,
-0.3245536983013153,
0.5175199508666992,
0.42099136114120483,
-0.7621303200721741,
0.14855104684829712,
-0.7843120098114014,
0.2925010919570923,
-0.15189819037914276,
-0.4770899713039398,
-0.24967458844184875,
0.132134810090065,
0.5367313623428345,
0.34732627868652344,
0.12082719057798386,
-0.5641287565231323,
0.2705611288547516,
-0.5039557814598083,
0.4877289831638336,
0.634405791759491,
-0.07690776884555817,
0.14107471704483032,
-0.07575654238462448,
0.7192915081977844,
-0.28994297981262207,
0.09031078964471817,
0.05932214483618736,
-0.7862184643745422,
-0.665116548538208,
-0.05492468550801277,
0.27134639024734497,
0.7676780819892883,
-0.9373466372489929,
0.3638095259666443,
-0.418279767036438,
-0.5837990045547485,
-0.5069800615310669,
-0.05473073199391365,
0.5168908834457397,
0.5461847186088562,
0.3214946389198303,
0.0232814010232687,
-0.6153813004493713,
-1.1340759992599487,
-0.021191531792283058,
-0.3081328570842743,
0.10999272018671036,
-0.14227578043937683,
0.25382113456726074,
-0.24359147250652313,
1.1832406520843506,
-0.2224116325378418,
-0.4399321973323822,
-0.0041040112264454365,
0.439071387052536,
-0.27596715092658997,
0.4855790436267853,
0.5833081007003784,
-0.74527907371521,
-0.5438787937164307,
0.09563564509153366,
-0.8063483834266663,
-0.4609178602695465,
0.1348705142736435,
-0.09939945489168167,
0.12878774106502533,
0.8841243386268616,
0.0633244663476944,
0.3830608129501343,
0.8528310060501099,
-0.0967293530702591,
0.2745167315006256,
-0.15142886340618134,
-0.1891280710697174,
-0.8938866257667542,
0.11150792241096497,
-0.21644006669521332,
-0.15659508109092712,
-0.8146934509277344,
-0.03963936120271683,
-0.2665257751941681,
0.016881758347153664,
-0.2025325894355774,
0.5462164878845215,
-0.3803485631942749,
0.019559914246201515,
-0.45376744866371155,
0.4330371916294098,
-0.6121574640274048,
0.08816654980182648,
-0.2741350531578064,
1.2091139554977417,
0.541763424873352,
-0.4659873843193054,
0.28218042850494385,
0.6429445147514343,
-0.5367843508720398,
0.24223722517490387,
-0.2242330014705658,
0.19147132337093353,
-0.31542298197746277,
-0.011148407123982906,
-0.9414265155792236,
-0.4080226719379425,
0.12230886518955231,
-0.531542181968689,
0.007846368476748466,
-0.07091711461544037,
-0.41718506813049316,
-0.3133901357650757,
-0.06746172904968262,
0.10133544355630875,
0.8223904371261597,
-0.6628357172012329,
0.2123439460992813,
0.8008489012718201,
-0.6547632813453674,
-0.5081890225410461,
-0.8207107782363892,
0.5926939249038696,
-0.30083370208740234,
-0.7666433453559875,
0.20288608968257904,
-0.12368868291378021,
-0.6543303728103638,
-0.07281381636857986,
-0.003747060429304838,
0.08707037568092346,
0.15532252192497253,
0.4718513488769531,
-0.0740460753440857,
-0.21149736642837524,
0.37599316239356995,
0.11336539685726166,
-0.09649480134248734,
0.01611623540520668,
-0.506750226020813,
0.6048038005828857,
-0.2874833047389984,
0.052273284643888474,
0.10765980184078217,
0.8390939831733704,
0.29488837718963623,
-0.23044922947883606,
0.140921950340271,
0.8304300904273987,
-0.38503900170326233,
-0.23503701388835907,
-0.5397962331771851,
0.028864305466413498,
-0.44967415928840637,
0.29108569025993347,
-0.3947254419326782,
-0.8877805471420288,
0.3940420150756836,
-0.3019404709339142,
0.37671026587486267,
0.6982847452163696,
0.6307330131530762,
-0.17679966986179352,
0.6947190761566162,
0.5937458276748657,
0.25693613290786743,
0.6548179984092712,
-0.10076935589313507,
0.0033305007964372635,
-0.5631648302078247,
-0.39582759141921997,
-0.1374489963054657,
0.007159113883972168,
-0.7808528542518616,
-0.33808034658432007,
0.7884874939918518,
0.289065957069397,
0.30594101548194885,
0.018909407779574394,
-0.5381611585617065,
0.22256511449813843,
1.12894868850708,
-0.22818022966384888,
-0.03166545554995537,
0.2791617214679718,
0.20052476227283478,
0.014874791726469994,
-0.392211377620697,
-0.9555045962333679,
0.8022140264511108,
0.06258586049079895,
0.38527101278305054,
0.28249943256378174,
0.8041287660598755,
0.5733160972595215,
0.3601878881454468,
-0.9226235747337341,
0.44115716218948364,
-0.5155488848686218,
-0.5415798425674438,
-0.4366322159767151,
0.09445669502019882,
-1.0550488233566284,
0.2986091375350952,
-0.18362410366535187,
-0.7723753452301025,
-0.29279863834381104,
0.20231427252292633,
-0.1616171896457672,
0.042884208261966705,
-0.4679758846759796,
0.3578653335571289,
-0.20875601470470428,
0.014411387033760548,
0.1025153324007988,
-1.1142908334732056,
0.3887692093849182,
-0.11838772892951965,
0.5281681418418884,
-0.41409844160079956,
0.05678477883338928,
1.0372272729873657,
-0.8190065622329712,
0.4091624319553375,
-0.22448645532131195,
-0.4274713695049286,
0.7565869688987732,
-0.1278710663318634,
0.3939705491065979,
-0.10327048599720001,
-0.07738474011421204,
0.19754907488822937,
-0.017073793336749077,
-0.2684319317340851,
-0.026260968297719955,
0.4709896445274353,
-0.6282128691673279,
-0.6970314383506775,
-0.33884671330451965,
-0.5294003486633301,
-0.3918461501598358,
0.15880289673805237,
0.6443765759468079,
0.5497302412986755,
-0.2511436343193054,
-0.04326282814145088,
0.41913995146751404,
0.03311082720756531,
0.7368642687797546,
-0.0033862933050841093,
-0.45592066645622253,
-0.752659022808075,
1.0278667211532593,
0.4318539798259735,
0.4405006170272827,
-0.10515238344669342,
0.2793219983577728,
-0.27164241671562195,
-0.7217641472816467,
-0.6528815627098083,
0.08417270332574844,
-1.1352696418762207,
0.01812904328107834,
-0.6073280572891235,
-0.20104020833969116,
-0.41045740246772766,
-0.07856607437133789,
0.050365351140499115,
-0.3811560571193695,
-0.4601060152053833,
-0.21040865778923035,
0.6782779097557068,
1.1414375305175781,
-0.5188965797424316,
0.6406129002571106,
-0.6892803311347961,
0.3494413197040558,
0.3317698538303375,
0.003902618307620287,
-0.440189003944397,
-0.30996420979499817,
-0.06773028522729874,
0.0585993155837059,
0.20826034247875214,
-0.4997159242630005,
0.4804033637046814,
0.5634242296218872,
0.4940034747123718,
-0.02090289816260338,
-0.13463042676448822,
0.7987732887268066,
-0.5275546312332153,
1.034250020980835,
0.4057732820510864,
-1.1598423719406128,
0.464957058429718,
-0.5502908825874329,
0.30043116211891174,
0.5559400320053101,
0.1504976600408554,
-0.8196159601211548,
-0.5848177075386047,
-0.5953253507614136,
-1.371652364730835,
0.7345373630523682,
0.186424121260643,
0.21001280844211578,
-0.17063237726688385,
0.3597009778022766,
0.5427144169807434,
0.12985704839229584,
-0.5552423596382141,
-0.387730211019516,
-0.34822604060173035,
-0.2533523738384247,
0.06555505096912384,
-0.322144478559494,
-0.2316911667585373,
0.0032597563695162535,
0.7979757189750671,
-0.4574401080608368,
-0.04030229151248932,
0.22783249616622925,
-0.19518126547336578,
-0.05700826272368431,
0.12909065186977386,
0.7677213549613953,
0.7121965885162354,
-0.005678379908204079,
0.23925743997097015,
-0.03479501232504845,
-0.8292533159255981,
-0.09840250760316849,
0.1249348521232605,
-0.40289974212646484,
0.029356880113482475,
0.335517942905426,
1.012924313545227,
-0.38092172145843506,
-0.7929471731185913,
0.4980500340461731,
0.15692727267742157,
-0.5216553211212158,
-0.5664782524108887,
-0.21590295433998108,
0.1066213920712471,
0.2379106879234314,
0.6615557074546814,
-0.18428745865821838,
0.24170264601707458,
-0.683592677116394,
0.5857563018798828,
0.23949776589870453,
-0.47803303599357605,
-0.18283259868621826,
1.0037786960601807,
0.21677373349666595,
-0.2033970057964325,
0.5582348108291626,
-0.34154045581817627,
-0.48563191294670105,
0.3157958388328552,
0.492735356092453,
0.8157228827476501,
0.009702006354928017,
0.07469838857650757,
0.4536839723587036,
0.3404086232185364,
0.180855393409729,
0.6572429537773132,
0.1502123922109604,
-0.015518205240368843,
-0.20157194137573242,
-0.7420846223831177,
-0.26955243945121765,
0.22440247237682343,
-0.7206134796142578,
0.24206078052520752,
-0.3753978908061981,
-0.13351349532604218,
0.17631477117538452,
-0.5042175054550171,
-0.29988789558410645,
0.34311312437057495,
0.9201654195785522,
0.6927231550216675,
-0.6157044768333435,
0.8261501789093018,
0.20984682440757751,
-0.5831932425498962,
-0.5991822481155396,
0.30078303813934326,
-0.08121711760759354,
-1.0154608488082886,
0.9117559790611267,
-0.007789236027747393,
-0.35801753401756287,
0.4095119535923004,
-0.6199113726615906,
-1.2488034963607788,
0.9052890539169312,
0.24099434912204742,
-0.6614224910736084,
-0.11784164607524872,
0.32250097393989563,
0.4627864956855774,
-0.050253938883543015,
-0.10617587715387344,
0.6363940834999084,
0.5327053070068359,
-0.020956574007868767,
-1.2065672874450684,
0.07693176716566086,
-0.17911642789840698,
0.04795071855187416,
0.24843686819076538,
-0.6297836303710938,
1.0532219409942627,
0.00902562029659748,
-0.5316370129585266,
0.14762306213378906,
0.7893975973129272,
-0.08473928272724152,
-0.1989002227783203,
0.5796971917152405,
0.048096075654029846,
0.9257238507270813,
-0.4037119746208191,
0.8501287698745728,
-0.28302904963493347,
0.14951807260513306,
1.1631345748901367,
-0.039258405566215515,
0.6664682626724243,
0.47842854261398315,
0.011031867936253548,
0.30745750665664673,
0.5343989133834839,
-0.02243037521839142,
0.6421149969100952,
0.7036223411560059,
-0.5509868264198303,
0.1819838136434555,
-0.32768985629081726,
-0.3913993239402771,
0.8714150786399841,
0.788965106010437,
-0.014493911527097225,
-0.29111921787261963,
0.48894092440605164,
0.33688226342201233,
0.038009319454431534,
-0.22969523072242737,
1.0873000621795654,
-0.07466180622577667,
-0.9632696509361267,
0.8637328743934631,
-0.22114884853363037,
0.9339232444763184,
-0.8544720411300659,
-0.15578365325927734,
0.11234486848115921,
-0.1212688758969307,
-0.4095398485660553,
-0.9324920177459717,
0.23334090411663055,
0.016341574490070343,
0.18551921844482422,
-0.2576458156108856,
0.43862971663475037,
-0.8742915391921997,
-0.08757185190916061,
0.33088043332099915,
0.501846969127655,
0.424937903881073,
-0.0028941775672137737,
-0.3941689729690552,
-0.0640149936079979,
0.11550633609294891,
-0.16541942954063416,
0.06949735432863235,
0.05912452191114426,
-0.46004047989845276,
0.415414035320282,
0.5996001958847046,
0.08981062471866608,
0.6544314622879028,
0.17714756727218628,
0.6486964821815491,
-0.5111492872238159,
-0.4817282259464264,
-0.7720720171928406,
0.4857645332813263,
-0.09533196687698364,
-0.5521652102470398,
0.6773183941841125,
0.6975419521331787,
0.6865233778953552,
-0.034524135291576385,
1.6367790699005127,
-0.5195441246032715,
0.3495253324508667,
-0.6154640316963196,
0.6134412884712219,
-0.4212942123413086,
-0.32315611839294434,
0.03132518008351326,
-0.4612443447113037,
-0.24241778254508972,
0.21301406621932983,
0.17254093289375305,
-0.44614964723587036,
0.5317120552062988,
0.3170476257801056,
0.21069158613681793,
0.061835650354623795,
0.31348422169685364,
-0.08187773823738098,
0.6665194034576416,
0.10293427854776382,
0.9044284820556641,
-0.4220862090587616,
0.7389272451400757,
-0.2985054552555084,
-0.23053982853889465,
-0.21206605434417725,
-0.6710336208343506,
-0.4826309382915497,
-1.0321035385131836,
-0.31356343626976013,
-0.4780330955982208,
-0.11955203115940094,
1.0194319486618042,
0.5959903001785278,
-0.6462717652320862,
-0.4579245150089264,
-0.17796964943408966,
-0.6307076215744019,
0.10514224320650101,
-0.20542338490486145,
0.2618408799171448,
-0.4028501510620117,
-0.8232789635658264,
0.5798516273498535,
0.37867289781570435,
0.3464667499065399,
-0.30548885464668274,
0.18808281421661377,
-0.31627610325813293,
-0.012009095400571823,
0.7899819612503052,
0.4887138605117798,
-1.3031713962554932,
-0.5035542249679565,
-0.4277969002723694,
-0.12781201303005219,
0.21021874248981476,
0.5840473771095276,
-0.5542991161346436,
0.6478423476219177,
0.2841718792915344,
0.31048867106437683,
0.7233541011810303,
0.05716674402356148,
0.4925234317779541,
-0.9768914580345154,
0.2811684012413025,
0.36768439412117004,
0.23772703111171722,
0.3755228519439697,
-0.12670361995697021,
0.8434631824493408,
0.1689005345106125,
-0.4325518012046814,
-0.8313454985618591,
0.2540932893753052,
-1.054636836051941,
-0.047910530120134354,
1.4549092054367065,
-0.08271565288305283,
-0.019952047616243362,
-0.21037693321704865,
-0.5127012133598328,
0.5203368663787842,
-0.16394419968128204,
0.44779422879219055,
0.6925400495529175,
-0.2255111038684845,
0.26140251755714417,
-0.8084107637405396,
0.8823350071907043,
-0.003261381294578314,
-1.2584644556045532,
0.38251742720603943,
0.48535728454589844,
0.4082125723361969,
0.22391751408576965,
0.8401623368263245,
0.09810363501310349,
0.10374681651592255,
0.3362220525741577,
0.5309786796569824,
0.19872809946537018,
0.10552334040403366,
-0.11951183527708054,
0.21972347795963287,
0.10884640365839005,
-0.15257564187049866
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.13130v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.13130v1
|
Self-generated Replay Memories for Continual Neural Machine Translation
| 2024-03-19T19:59:54 | 2024-03-19T19:59:54 |
Michele Resta, Davide Bacciu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Modern Neural Machine Translation systems exhibit strong performance in
several different languages and are constantly improving. Their ability to
learn continuously is, however, still severely limited by the catastrophic
forgetting issue. In this work, we leverage a key property of encoder-decoder
Transformers, i.e. their generative ability, to propose a novel approach to
continually learning Neural Machine Translation systems. We show how this can
effectively learn on a stream of experiences comprising different languages, by
leveraging a replay memory populated by using the model itself as a generator
of parallel sentences. We empirically demonstrate that our approach can
counteract catastrophic forgetting without requiring explicit memorization of
training data. Code will be publicly available upon publication. Code:
https://github.com/m-resta/sg-rep
|
[
-0.13982079923152924,
-0.4478124678134918,
0.4301500916481018,
0.4644593596458435,
-0.21676555275917053,
0.3275396525859833,
-0.2977665662765503,
0.061937376856803894,
0.44023650884628296,
0.5484583377838135,
-0.5117509961128235,
-0.03665666654706001,
-0.45714566111564636,
0.39660707116127014,
-0.49354541301727295,
0.9926652908325195,
-0.2651712894439697,
0.05378124490380287,
-0.11513528972864151,
-0.41912925243377686,
-0.8455816507339478,
-0.5426134467124939,
-0.7004899382591248,
-0.39297646284103394,
0.4963567554950714,
0.24005472660064697,
0.20158086717128754,
0.517989993095398,
0.4703252613544464,
0.2838246524333954,
0.25348755717277527,
0.28451910614967346,
-0.6955940127372742,
0.6006115078926086,
-0.09265046566724777,
-0.5070992708206177,
-0.06869801133871078,
-0.5234453678131104,
1.1057721376419067,
0.26517313718795776,
-0.2188713550567627,
0.02366906777024269,
0.1787818968296051,
0.674115002155304,
-0.35426607728004456,
-0.00566434022039175,
-0.8197958469390869,
0.31731948256492615,
0.04524096101522446,
-0.40214619040489197,
-0.7169600129127502,
-0.2515176832675934,
-0.10755293071269989,
-0.24408504366874695,
0.3880733251571655,
-0.08184194564819336,
0.6303364634513855,
0.3047497868537903,
0.04814837872982025,
-0.23458100855350494,
-1.0942002534866333,
0.5763145089149475,
-0.5536095499992371,
0.3568879961967468,
-0.08305351436138153,
0.496062695980072,
-0.08488253504037857,
-0.950128972530365,
-0.5394607186317444,
-0.2914413511753082,
0.10902275145053864,
0.620812177658081,
-0.06831676512956619,
-0.28178492188453674,
0.23608937859535217,
0.5344178676605225,
-0.5344837307929993,
-0.2111084759235382,
-0.39481809735298157,
-0.0757322907447815,
0.33192896842956543,
0.4042196571826935,
0.42620596289634705,
-0.08272919803857803,
-0.56553053855896,
-0.001708504743874073,
-0.8642358183860779,
-0.29171064496040344,
0.029503555968403816,
-0.023126117885112762,
0.11773968487977982,
0.4399403929710388,
0.07283666729927063,
0.2689984440803528,
0.18195238709449768,
0.13934746384620667,
0.31732413172721863,
-0.21836300194263458,
-0.10169532895088196,
0.05671876668930054,
0.9910270571708679,
-0.0055464464239776134,
0.22856299579143524,
-0.7439178228378296,
-0.45136988162994385,
-0.0880749523639679,
0.8121365308761597,
-0.674791157245636,
-0.22543670237064362,
-0.05782470107078552,
-0.5100674629211426,
0.03231201693415642,
-0.1493530124425888,
-0.7108264565467834,
0.13985629379749298,
-0.08127088099718094,
0.44699934124946594,
-0.5735147595405579,
-0.23688994348049164,
-0.02341984584927559,
-0.22665785253047943,
-0.09660530090332031,
-0.24326838552951813,
-0.8545074462890625,
0.15856097638607025,
0.22422999143600464,
0.9780771136283875,
-0.23663462698459625,
-0.8307849168777466,
-0.5112701654434204,
0.23727217316627502,
-0.23193569481372833,
0.48417243361473083,
-0.25565898418426514,
-0.5309157967567444,
-0.006781934294849634,
0.12786442041397095,
-0.3616340458393097,
-0.8077576160430908,
0.11432886868715286,
-0.6491999626159668,
-0.1142454594373703,
-0.17728960514068604,
-0.5472128391265869,
-0.10351836681365967,
0.26135650277137756,
-0.527147650718689,
0.700247585773468,
0.09815994650125504,
-0.2781641483306885,
0.0012161994818598032,
-0.3044048845767975,
-0.492259681224823,
0.07389149814844131,
-0.10151726752519608,
-0.6829347610473633,
0.3298475444316864,
0.08063467592000961,
0.2551279366016388,
-0.04113273322582245,
0.5494066476821899,
-0.060493625700473785,
-0.22553157806396484,
0.2911982238292694,
-0.7097072601318359,
0.14985375106334686,
0.34940093755722046,
-0.30472731590270996,
0.09763075411319733,
-0.47455981373786926,
-0.31834539771080017,
0.39531123638153076,
-0.4274936616420746,
0.06215381622314453,
0.0733531042933464,
-0.21816308796405792,
0.23594379425048828,
0.3258775472640991,
-0.4904487133026123,
0.22255079448223114,
-0.34959232807159424,
0.5516853928565979,
0.6275157332420349,
0.27278175950050354,
0.44335418939590454,
-0.35622984170913696,
0.7094099521636963,
0.2399873584508896,
-0.07167299091815948,
-0.893980860710144,
-0.2878369390964508,
-1.052135944366455,
-0.010153088718652725,
0.10268533229827881,
0.433932900428772,
-0.805328369140625,
0.24026153981685638,
-0.5330436825752258,
-0.2018202394247055,
-0.4861034154891968,
0.3862782418727875,
0.5952282547950745,
0.4812716543674469,
0.685826301574707,
-0.5325716137886047,
-0.7174116373062134,
-0.7683610916137695,
-0.1499788612127304,
0.14957469701766968,
-0.09604949504137039,
0.23657694458961487,
0.5183888077735901,
-0.3639954924583435,
0.6524307727813721,
-0.17536495625972748,
-0.2714812159538269,
-0.2618004083633423,
0.11499743908643723,
-0.029658466577529907,
0.65876704454422,
0.4795306921005249,
-0.3691580891609192,
-0.3521410822868347,
-0.08030770719051361,
-1.238297700881958,
0.22352857887744904,
-0.9063730239868164,
-0.12265388667583466,
0.13921746611595154,
0.7102139592170715,
-0.6426497101783752,
0.11551262438297272,
0.4233391284942627,
-0.030537402257323265,
0.427728533744812,
-0.6058341264724731,
-0.13201358914375305,
-1.2615163326263428,
0.06504923850297928,
-0.4169458746910095,
-0.23953810334205627,
-0.356830894947052,
0.1566515862941742,
0.24571828544139862,
-0.03881622105836868,
-0.2450830340385437,
0.24730174243450165,
-0.5638077855110168,
0.028680574148893356,
-0.43792086839675903,
-0.04506983980536461,
-0.19069023430347443,
0.5787498354911804,
0.012763885781168938,
0.8363758325576782,
0.20835770666599274,
-0.7101909518241882,
0.24932225048542023,
0.24928025901317596,
-0.028969265520572662,
0.20580150187015533,
-0.5204380750656128,
0.20003008842468262,
-0.23255233466625214,
0.3337368965148926,
-0.6481759548187256,
-0.06739884614944458,
0.23602022230625153,
-0.4903421998023987,
0.5631340146064758,
-0.11683061718940735,
-0.31301867961883545,
-0.5998857021331787,
0.4165714681148529,
0.3930127024650574,
0.9111452102661133,
-0.7756115198135376,
0.6560581922531128,
0.16428522765636444,
-0.03564859926700592,
-0.36512354016304016,
-0.7008011937141418,
0.3472479283809662,
-0.10455305874347687,
-0.21197587251663208,
0.33568307757377625,
-0.0081401402130723,
0.39116278290748596,
0.0065235267393291,
-0.1567014455795288,
0.11678975075483322,
-0.06195075064897537,
0.270953893661499,
0.03638642281293869,
-0.3832692801952362,
0.3705607056617737,
0.006638105493038893,
-0.30910417437553406,
0.10850710421800613,
-0.8053321838378906,
0.9129122495651245,
-0.3517952561378479,
-0.3499988317489624,
-0.35355257987976074,
0.3334188163280487,
0.6768494248390198,
-0.36615273356437683,
0.7504130601882935,
0.5104495882987976,
-0.28332579135894775,
-0.30686861276626587,
-0.49511536955833435,
-0.31402498483657837,
-0.49353456497192383,
0.47777149081230164,
-0.46575021743774414,
-0.7478270530700684,
0.7508726716041565,
-0.22252696752548218,
-0.11706952005624771,
0.59281986951828,
0.572908341884613,
-0.20278321206569672,
0.7512094974517822,
0.3581867218017578,
-0.391091912984848,
0.32619211077690125,
-0.35759034752845764,
0.1602606326341629,
-0.8949499130249023,
-0.30304619669914246,
-0.11391224712133408,
-0.38397854566574097,
-0.2770160138607025,
-0.18781226873397827,
0.12309662252664566,
0.40708622336387634,
-0.32534635066986084,
0.5769681334495544,
-0.43006327748298645,
0.43959924578666687,
0.5298301577568054,
0.09290993213653564,
0.12886011600494385,
-0.050137318670749664,
-0.23869451880455017,
-0.16758599877357483,
-0.8945448994636536,
-0.3183678090572357,
0.9388043880462646,
0.3429716229438782,
0.7012884616851807,
-0.203537717461586,
1.0754170417785645,
0.12999776005744934,
0.4606974422931671,
-0.47512564063072205,
0.3308561444282532,
-0.12517862021923065,
-0.12725871801376343,
-0.039812784641981125,
-0.5904906392097473,
-0.9140700697898865,
0.06871617585420609,
0.09871453791856766,
-0.2589378356933594,
-0.1648152768611908,
0.3619489371776581,
-0.24260570108890533,
0.5726553201675415,
-0.41444477438926697,
0.841469943523407,
-0.4521131217479706,
-0.1468835026025772,
-0.28144147992134094,
-0.3946690559387207,
0.24402214586734772,
-0.16133266687393188,
-0.3344009220600128,
0.2503538429737091,
0.20670664310455322,
0.25242769718170166,
-0.1492399126291275,
0.7898427248001099,
-0.0911795124411583,
0.13222594559192657,
0.4308684468269348,
0.2957797050476074,
0.39896464347839355,
0.2285587340593338,
0.34636354446411133,
0.16490353643894196,
-0.5790146589279175,
-0.33620214462280273,
-0.6284467577934265,
0.7966505289077759,
-0.4704228639602661,
-0.4381307065486908,
-0.2746637165546417,
-0.4347759485244751,
0.050506841391325,
0.33770984411239624,
0.3355728089809418,
0.22784169018268585,
-0.42944633960723877,
0.18007685244083405,
0.6840226650238037,
-0.24017539620399475,
0.6679449081420898,
0.3017484247684479,
-0.30961039662361145,
-0.76466965675354,
1.2692245244979858,
0.22060558199882507,
0.3821638822555542,
0.21646545827388763,
0.02456183172762394,
-0.10214980691671371,
-0.521159827709198,
-0.808231770992279,
0.16044297814369202,
-0.5266493558883667,
-0.40818676352500916,
-0.9073893427848816,
-0.561885416507721,
-0.043236151337623596,
-0.12418297678232193,
-0.6827494502067566,
-0.32616689801216125,
-0.1577039659023285,
0.060268841683864594,
0.16758976876735687,
0.7078851461410522,
-0.05771427974104881,
0.20096611976623535,
-1.2358423471450806,
0.7163330912590027,
0.2784390449523926,
0.31561222672462463,
0.18874236941337585,
-0.6961660385131836,
-0.3287854790687561,
0.11393367499113083,
-0.5396139621734619,
-0.6788397431373596,
0.8696094155311584,
0.34356245398521423,
0.6432837843894958,
0.2794695794582367,
-0.21995894610881805,
0.5687295198440552,
-0.9940988421440125,
0.7348102927207947,
0.39670199155807495,
-0.6533417105674744,
0.4162442088127136,
-0.16421298682689667,
0.7074892520904541,
0.38448604941368103,
0.225274458527565,
-0.844518780708313,
-0.5513641238212585,
-0.4742392599582672,
-0.7616320848464966,
0.291553795337677,
0.23312124609947205,
0.5025696158409119,
-0.5603501200675964,
0.5470403432846069,
0.15041592717170715,
0.05280062183737755,
-0.5065617561340332,
-0.21605068445205688,
-0.6493848562240601,
-0.3213810622692108,
-0.2457924485206604,
-0.2295440137386322,
0.15627601742744446,
-0.0751371681690216,
0.4617684781551361,
-0.10585752874612808,
0.5324541330337524,
0.1971971094608307,
-0.2819594144821167,
0.0844622403383255,
0.06109648570418358,
0.6859955787658691,
0.37890705466270447,
0.044147517532110214,
0.04989822581410408,
0.4660830795764923,
-0.5346258878707886,
0.06537925451993942,
-0.24672089517116547,
-0.6346830129623413,
0.18295341730117798,
-0.1580907702445984,
0.7096312046051025,
0.5236672163009644,
-0.4334646165370941,
0.14585500955581665,
-0.07685168087482452,
-0.13094142079353333,
-0.6901207566261292,
-0.08566239476203918,
0.5271229147911072,
0.23802275955677032,
0.37361299991607666,
0.5220792889595032,
-0.18603847920894623,
-0.3000004291534424,
0.5955114960670471,
0.045966945588588715,
-0.5494683980941772,
-0.394351989030838,
0.732269287109375,
0.12562160193920135,
-0.5089842081069946,
0.9958235025405884,
-0.12303096055984497,
-0.7013098001480103,
0.6546689867973328,
1.2533743381500244,
1.3304108381271362,
-0.39629483222961426,
0.10048434138298035,
0.7455580234527588,
0.2631831765174866,
-0.5482518672943115,
0.04975148290395737,
-0.10033434629440308,
-0.6945304870605469,
-0.28599846363067627,
-0.695246160030365,
-0.13764290511608124,
-0.03810150921344757,
-0.7077457308769226,
-0.22727201879024506,
-0.4062857925891876,
-0.05707121267914772,
-0.5056501626968384,
-0.8305231928825378,
-0.551274836063385,
0.08594545722007751,
0.12360864132642746,
0.6146977543830872,
-0.3220040798187256,
1.0242139101028442,
0.19652646780014038,
-0.8712299466133118,
-0.2462334781885147,
0.042921651154756546,
-0.5279845595359802,
-0.6761133670806885,
0.6664136052131653,
0.28398397564888,
-0.27618199586868286,
0.17679835855960846,
-0.30587977170944214,
-0.6925290822982788,
0.945141077041626,
0.3614569306373596,
-0.7137327790260315,
-0.033469345420598984,
0.07133407145738602,
0.681526780128479,
-0.5573189854621887,
-0.0766543373465538,
0.44627735018730164,
-0.00622874079272151,
-0.19485242664813995,
-0.6273426413536072,
-0.1692340224981308,
-0.289421945810318,
0.0687408372759819,
0.22156253457069397,
-0.8474200963973999,
0.534884512424469,
-0.1731029599905014,
-0.3962830901145935,
0.18573306500911713,
0.941598117351532,
0.09496597945690155,
0.19590206444263458,
-0.015901686623692513,
0.7675768136978149,
0.427182674407959,
-0.03289449214935303,
0.9858425259590149,
-0.34831124544143677,
0.38527151942253113,
1.428707242012024,
0.0526433140039444,
1.0024436712265015,
0.5327451825141907,
0.09318453818559647,
0.3991173505783081,
0.070754773914814,
-0.1969829797744751,
0.5098530650138855,
0.07122235000133514,
-0.3846239447593689,
-0.4363333582878113,
0.2572503089904785,
-0.5127021670341492,
0.3811177611351013,
0.3498677909374237,
-0.7868461012840271,
-0.073672816157341,
0.2650250196456909,
-0.18930502235889435,
0.3719252347946167,
-0.11281133443117142,
0.809258759021759,
0.45039623975753784,
-0.8279033899307251,
0.863682210445404,
-0.2452608197927475,
0.6168028116226196,
-0.5496546626091003,
-0.12168999761343002,
-0.42442959547042847,
0.43667086958885193,
0.18067198991775513,
-0.4695727229118347,
0.6583179831504822,
-0.07141201943159103,
-0.3150891959667206,
-0.497300386428833,
0.41610655188560486,
-0.5414339303970337,
-0.41712379455566406,
0.29238367080688477,
0.28070470690727234,
0.011661565862596035,
0.023667113855481148,
-0.4139506220817566,
-0.17811305820941925,
-0.07206811755895615,
-0.14129874110221863,
0.3368678092956543,
0.17693841457366943,
0.29894089698791504,
0.9452456831932068,
0.3867323696613312,
-0.00875080842524767,
0.5213706493377686,
0.15009696781635284,
0.6364960074424744,
-0.9726624488830566,
-0.3664892613887787,
-0.8626807332038879,
0.23389354348182678,
0.022803597152233124,
-0.390727162361145,
0.8077042102813721,
0.7267192602157593,
1.0350956916809082,
-0.5743371844291687,
0.8802918791770935,
0.18973460793495178,
0.22054018080234528,
-0.5089952349662781,
0.9922805428504944,
-0.30090707540512085,
0.09951561689376831,
0.22258900105953217,
-0.7848804593086243,
-0.26479291915893555,
0.4889068305492401,
0.18514518439769745,
-0.16464033722877502,
0.7610037922859192,
0.5352268815040588,
-0.04834207892417908,
0.024012623354792595,
0.3772921860218048,
0.17437279224395752,
0.26371410489082336,
0.8164096474647522,
0.9375194311141968,
-0.7229949235916138,
0.7322941422462463,
-0.08308317512273788,
0.35037973523139954,
0.032992884516716,
-0.5227773189544678,
-0.764374852180481,
-0.5011082291603088,
-0.02483726292848587,
-0.5426139235496521,
0.217262402176857,
0.5714878439903259,
0.3238924443721771,
-0.9129758477210999,
-0.11111491173505783,
-0.5857231020927429,
-0.13276416063308716,
-0.4348938465118408,
-0.10469856858253479,
0.07510442286729813,
-1.0188357830047607,
-0.6369736790657043,
0.7325662970542908,
0.4894413650035858,
0.10052523761987686,
-0.4403502345085144,
-0.5014758706092834,
0.15465940535068512,
-0.12795452773571014,
0.48297885060310364,
0.7404044270515442,
-0.6470010280609131,
-0.2256508469581604,
0.19909541308879852,
-0.1736258864402771,
0.3946595788002014,
0.9688742160797119,
-0.9301921129226685,
0.8467704653739929,
0.45939865708351135,
1.235845923423767,
0.8372547030448914,
-0.2487439066171646,
0.864463210105896,
-0.45123928785324097,
-0.12387200444936752,
0.3246519863605499,
0.43460628390312195,
0.28449684381484985,
-0.17617397010326385,
0.24606409668922424,
0.3379173278808594,
-0.6240217685699463,
-0.4891563653945923,
0.29461532831192017,
-0.7288799285888672,
0.027647877112030983,
0.7817879319190979,
-0.40003257989883423,
-0.12223902344703674,
-0.04571886733174324,
-0.030472971498966217,
0.4246445894241333,
-0.05590585619211197,
1.0668206214904785,
0.2819468379020691,
0.27135559916496277,
-0.21025384962558746,
-0.524569571018219,
0.3156953752040863,
0.5326374173164368,
-0.364495187997818,
-0.013284300453960896,
0.25149503350257874,
0.38886168599128723,
0.1957569122314453,
0.6199295520782471,
-0.30689042806625366,
0.43147149682044983,
0.31234633922576904,
0.22224381566047668,
-0.11142443865537643,
-0.7236183285713196,
-0.5269833207130432,
0.22685396671295166,
-0.25524893403053284,
-0.39016711711883545
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15465v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15465v1
|
Most Likely Sequence Generation for $n$-Grams, Transformers, HMMs, and Markov Chains, by Using Rollout Algorithms
| 2024-03-19T19:58:46 | 2024-03-19T19:58:46 |
Yuchao Li, Dimitri Bertsekas
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.SY, eess.SY
|
In this paper we consider a transformer with an $n$-gram structure, such as
the one underlying ChatGPT. The transformer provides next word probabilities,
which can be used to generate word sequences. We consider methods for computing
word sequences that are highly likely, based on these probabilities. Computing
the optimal (i.e., most likely) word sequence starting with a given initial
state is an intractable problem, so we propose methods to compute highly likely
sequences of $N$ words in time that is a low order polynomial in $N$ and in the
vocabulary size of the $n$-gram. These methods are based on the rollout
approach from approximate dynamic programming, a form of single policy
iteration, which can improve the performance of any given heuristic policy. In
our case we use a greedy heuristic that generates as next word one that has the
highest probability. We show with analysis, examples, and computational
experimentation that our methods are capable of generating highly likely
sequences with a modest increase in computation over the greedy heuristic.
While our analysis and experiments are focused on Markov chains of the type
arising in transformer and ChatGPT-like models, our methods apply to general
finite-state Markov chains, and related inference applications of Hidden Markov
Models (HMM), where Viterbi decoding is used extensively.
|
[
-0.34618374705314636,
-0.6848571300506592,
0.30016523599624634,
-0.21708552539348602,
-0.02956310100853443,
0.21204403042793274,
-0.1358676701784134,
0.005956569220870733,
0.07968717068433762,
0.37029194831848145,
-0.7794910073280334,
-0.25801199674606323,
-0.66020667552948,
-0.12620174884796143,
-0.9734088778495789,
1.039480209350586,
0.27487650513648987,
-0.5144431591033936,
0.5109341144561768,
0.19810473918914795,
-0.18001413345336914,
-0.24986761808395386,
-0.09339961409568787,
-0.4716406464576721,
0.35289567708969116,
0.3692423701286316,
0.9412334561347961,
0.44806185364723206,
0.7286226749420166,
0.2747565805912018,
-0.14307036995887756,
0.31682536005973816,
-0.506416916847229,
-0.16183894872665405,
0.2117951363325119,
-0.44525155425071716,
-0.18730665743350983,
-0.19758661091327667,
0.58177250623703,
0.5279523134231567,
-0.596259593963623,
0.10793472826480865,
-0.2627829611301422,
0.5532150268554688,
-0.5382580161094666,
-0.17655104398727417,
-0.9898345470428467,
0.36100077629089355,
-0.33021900057792664,
-0.39726588129997253,
-0.6301929950714111,
-0.5488704442977905,
0.28585001826286316,
-0.2962222695350647,
0.20203696191310883,
-0.16960962116718292,
0.9526289105415344,
0.045701757073402405,
-0.39643457531929016,
-0.5359777808189392,
-0.9772909879684448,
0.6360648274421692,
-0.7291408777236938,
-0.04252322390675545,
0.19119693338871002,
0.5688146352767944,
-0.7936068177223206,
-0.6346656084060669,
-0.6964121460914612,
-0.30225077271461487,
0.28346800804138184,
0.19570456445217133,
-0.28918126225471497,
0.03267547860741615,
0.3924548029899597,
0.5880886912345886,
-0.5444022417068481,
-0.009655267000198364,
-0.25192251801490784,
0.10837291181087494,
0.49194350838661194,
0.10462285578250885,
0.1848902702331543,
-0.39476996660232544,
-0.30361121892929077,
-0.3270380198955536,
-0.7524779438972473,
-0.27633509039878845,
0.7543942928314209,
0.20215681195259094,
-0.04054680094122887,
1.0351026058197021,
-0.03522029519081116,
0.5757335424423218,
-0.06816110014915466,
-0.13716356456279755,
0.17737554013729095,
-0.243844136595726,
-0.020602812990546227,
0.025218183174729347,
0.6301552653312683,
0.170795738697052,
0.4341830015182495,
-0.18256816267967224,
-0.22285722196102142,
0.16549065709114075,
0.5819774866104126,
-0.43460142612457275,
-0.3328567445278168,
0.18024858832359314,
-0.29643329977989197,
-0.4402972161769867,
0.16510659456253052,
-0.8378620743751526,
-0.13551130890846252,
0.11249174177646637,
0.5557158589363098,
-0.534752368927002,
-0.21275565028190613,
-0.101275734603405,
-0.20084913074970245,
0.43760719895362854,
-0.3669213056564331,
-0.6343115568161011,
0.12169010937213898,
0.6397606134414673,
0.9654216766357422,
-0.23125995695590973,
0.026273293420672417,
-0.4561302959918976,
0.2608890235424042,
-0.26939237117767334,
0.6310011744499207,
-0.22236871719360352,
-0.5482664704322815,
0.5158906579017639,
-0.15285219252109528,
0.127680703997612,
-0.449862539768219,
0.454139769077301,
-0.6844793558120728,
0.08209583163261414,
0.01741672493517399,
-0.6817367076873779,
-0.10427237302064896,
0.11917873471975327,
-0.6116600036621094,
0.7561072707176208,
0.032049648463726044,
-0.7607607245445251,
0.5066881775856018,
-0.5726183652877808,
-0.6643120050430298,
0.10111920535564423,
0.15366892516613007,
-0.5631409287452698,
0.38191527128219604,
-0.19297128915786743,
0.31735581159591675,
-0.2154352068901062,
0.2531566619873047,
0.017812957987189293,
-0.3271051049232483,
0.5077906250953674,
-0.6854076385498047,
0.37418344616889954,
0.4479694962501526,
-0.46733713150024414,
-0.08950537443161011,
-0.8334376215934753,
0.2000233680009842,
0.25854283571243286,
-0.57258141040802,
0.16179879009723663,
0.4269900619983673,
-0.0419110432267189,
0.057575833052396774,
-0.03401979058980942,
-0.31210964918136597,
0.502405047416687,
-0.3086155354976654,
0.4914119839668274,
0.7640380859375,
0.025657331570982933,
0.2534061670303345,
-0.279427170753479,
0.6602559089660645,
0.009576252661645412,
0.08860615640878677,
-0.557449996471405,
-0.792194664478302,
-0.48047763109207153,
-0.030215628445148468,
0.3650476336479187,
0.8086971044540405,
-0.8507453799247742,
0.36102887988090515,
-0.24109196662902832,
-0.516573429107666,
0.030492788180708885,
-0.21637894213199615,
0.49996864795684814,
0.12806954979896545,
0.026670929044485092,
-0.22303561866283417,
-0.45202383399009705,
-0.7788975834846497,
-0.35701584815979004,
-0.11507782340049744,
0.12107609212398529,
0.025077100843191147,
0.12866877019405365,
-0.4025183618068695,
0.7564411163330078,
-0.982797384262085,
0.08808059245347977,
-0.27229899168014526,
0.3493020832538605,
0.7909471392631531,
0.10673601180315018,
0.013216910883784294,
-0.7542083859443665,
-0.06611543893814087,
-0.10022717714309692,
-0.26167741417884827,
0.10762771964073181,
-0.1552123725414276,
-0.06948887556791306,
0.27536529302597046,
0.2148580253124237,
-0.4110108017921448,
0.40228286385536194,
0.6971727609634399,
-0.08346271514892578,
0.423035204410553,
-0.6146544218063354,
-0.24245195090770721,
-1.2081215381622314,
-0.343380331993103,
0.08605805784463882,
-0.17350977659225464,
-0.796924352645874,
0.010947168804705143,
-0.12596279382705688,
0.10911675542593002,
-0.37684521079063416,
-0.04526374861598015,
-0.6089227199554443,
-0.14138980209827423,
-0.1983141154050827,
-0.04905296117067337,
-0.7365719676017761,
0.2841278314590454,
-0.2548710107803345,
0.825168788433075,
0.17892834544181824,
-0.8366543650627136,
0.20664826035499573,
0.20644067227840424,
-0.604751467704773,
0.01458418183028698,
-0.31383857131004333,
-0.08259731531143188,
-0.15012681484222412,
0.07213848829269409,
-1.0985591411590576,
-0.2879631221294403,
-0.22888223826885223,
-0.24685651063919067,
0.314087450504303,
-0.031348470598459244,
-0.37679892778396606,
-0.9601762294769287,
-0.037995535880327225,
0.12501423060894012,
0.9409425258636475,
-0.5318942666053772,
0.026226254180073738,
0.7356920838356018,
0.40418383479118347,
-0.46180060505867004,
-0.8132277727127075,
0.14377886056900024,
-0.31990209221839905,
-0.38481229543685913,
0.31695041060447693,
0.10212437063455582,
0.0925109013915062,
-0.2389606088399887,
0.18608470261096954,
0.04443484544754028,
-0.0988551452755928,
0.20549046993255615,
0.1251101791858673,
0.01615973748266697,
-0.060603413730859756,
-0.08861767500638962,
-0.26950109004974365,
-0.08591106534004211,
-0.5660691857337952,
0.8702582716941833,
-0.21351143717765808,
-0.45781847834587097,
0.04141926020383835,
0.42602354288101196,
0.3674525022506714,
0.18801890313625336,
0.5623686909675598,
0.78437739610672,
-0.281730055809021,
-0.35014471411705017,
-0.3408520519733429,
-0.07527970522642136,
-0.4617517292499542,
0.4899313747882843,
-0.5461541414260864,
-0.4680551290512085,
0.5202305316925049,
-0.34338706731796265,
0.2065679132938385,
0.2775294780731201,
0.8735380172729492,
0.09322235733270645,
1.0449937582015991,
0.48101067543029785,
0.0751740112900734,
0.5510940551757812,
-0.7187003493309021,
0.6898698806762695,
-0.4333473742008209,
-0.0273072961717844,
-0.14797984063625336,
-0.28298231959342957,
-1.4052009582519531,
-0.6205874085426331,
0.6082299947738647,
-0.34097984433174133,
0.026824956759810448,
0.7540430426597595,
-0.5350947380065918,
0.2781328856945038,
0.9016167521476746,
-0.1407824158668518,
0.153527170419693,
0.28027138113975525,
-0.36294567584991455,
0.27738505601882935,
-0.8920201063156128,
-0.3705715239048004,
1.084699034690857,
0.011183435097336769,
0.8252983689308167,
0.3214346468448639,
0.9120951890945435,
0.3085724115371704,
0.014591570012271404,
-0.7900200486183167,
0.5786983370780945,
-0.3651270270347595,
-0.4022302031517029,
-0.2063831090927124,
-0.2938719391822815,
-1.0575999021530151,
-0.13660632073879242,
-0.37566694617271423,
-0.7407522201538086,
-0.17577292025089264,
0.1240038201212883,
-0.24609509110450745,
0.4114624857902527,
-0.6038391590118408,
0.3162820637226105,
0.06901636719703674,
0.0016845271456986666,
0.00883773434907198,
-0.532069206237793,
0.6215081214904785,
-0.009360458701848984,
0.15055200457572937,
-0.02737964317202568,
0.19297489523887634,
0.46464449167251587,
-0.5990220904350281,
0.2897588908672333,
-0.03601549565792084,
-0.35474541783332825,
0.6801997423171997,
0.0033156282734125853,
0.8129187226295471,
-0.21815334260463715,
-0.038298118859529495,
0.0552172027528286,
-0.180756613612175,
-0.23197375237941742,
-0.22861051559448242,
0.42662835121154785,
-0.5061051249504089,
-0.34646379947662354,
-0.3292877674102783,
-0.4600485861301422,
-0.08662782609462738,
-0.02631353959441185,
0.8599241375923157,
0.5216686129570007,
-0.01600443758070469,
-0.2532654404640198,
0.5900615453720093,
-0.2951663136482239,
0.8515397906303406,
-0.17609953880310059,
-0.07740398496389389,
-0.4730905294418335,
0.9546637535095215,
0.38973450660705566,
0.4341830909252167,
0.3462018370628357,
0.43623173236846924,
-0.17923356592655182,
-0.5303094983100891,
-0.4147339165210724,
0.050988391041755676,
-0.23300518095493317,
-0.28794634342193604,
-0.5282617211341858,
-0.43267980217933655,
-0.03586187586188316,
-0.2028341442346573,
-0.2981630861759186,
-0.4187086522579193,
0.2917782664299011,
0.009718523360788822,
0.49215996265411377,
0.8677677512168884,
-0.133687824010849,
0.6251978874206543,
-0.9210352897644043,
0.4388808310031891,
0.211611807346344,
0.10778211802244186,
-0.11268392950296402,
-0.4086780250072479,
-0.0910298302769661,
-0.01036794576793909,
-0.4714147448539734,
-1.2121421098709106,
0.5341032147407532,
0.25328847765922546,
0.4633641839027405,
0.6505010724067688,
-0.11595211923122406,
0.7650132775306702,
-0.9509643912315369,
0.791375458240509,
0.4147357642650604,
-0.6777908802032471,
0.4271044135093689,
-0.6143032908439636,
0.3586568832397461,
0.2378394901752472,
0.2817477881908417,
-0.5566405057907104,
-0.4422231912612915,
-0.8198997974395752,
-1.1648706197738647,
0.3632114827632904,
0.3810141384601593,
0.4307018220424652,
-0.5715990662574768,
0.33788836002349854,
0.1484798640012741,
0.2658809423446655,
-0.15316952764987946,
-0.25720933079719543,
0.32313260436058044,
-0.26385989785194397,
-0.0875406265258789,
-0.39519375562667847,
0.16408950090408325,
0.28072452545166016,
0.7557975649833679,
-0.3282499313354492,
0.7450592517852783,
-0.07788494229316711,
0.08799824118614197,
0.025699414312839508,
0.27788785099983215,
0.669563889503479,
0.5053667426109314,
-0.05675314739346504,
0.037124231457710266,
0.14112074673175812,
-0.731855571269989,
0.23949529230594635,
-0.275721937417984,
-0.534660816192627,
0.15474842488765717,
0.12241141498088837,
0.704930305480957,
0.12072669714689255,
-0.6358678936958313,
0.5067864656448364,
0.05658341199159622,
-0.18480367958545685,
-0.6674805879592896,
0.14282284677028656,
0.0651262104511261,
0.19314661622047424,
0.39591383934020996,
-0.32850828766822815,
0.3250691592693329,
-0.6318336725234985,
0.4863918721675873,
0.669795036315918,
-0.14957940578460693,
-0.16007699072360992,
0.428847074508667,
-0.2787059545516968,
-0.6763338446617126,
0.7133235335350037,
-0.49476712942123413,
-0.5918583869934082,
0.5540502071380615,
0.783804714679718,
0.9850926399230957,
-0.12794239819049835,
0.3842533826828003,
0.42525893449783325,
0.1530056893825531,
-0.3397597074508667,
0.4499676823616028,
-0.007999788969755173,
-0.6653358936309814,
-0.5871121287345886,
-0.6474879384040833,
-0.32245752215385437,
-0.193834587931633,
-0.46539080142974854,
0.34956151247024536,
-0.12961961328983307,
-0.6643646955490112,
-0.29450535774230957,
-0.08425874263048172,
-0.3911587595939636,
-0.13006961345672607,
0.35305142402648926,
0.6925802230834961,
-0.7924380898475647,
0.5177379846572876,
0.5106688141822815,
-0.011742951348423958,
-0.9404556751251221,
0.2257908135652542,
0.1302988976240158,
-0.8691695332527161,
0.36269307136535645,
0.01770026981830597,
0.04249865561723709,
-0.06732641160488129,
-0.17013323307037354,
-0.9620621204376221,
0.9168461561203003,
-0.006660839077085257,
-0.6986242532730103,
-0.30368316173553467,
0.21635115146636963,
0.18872037529945374,
0.05022302642464638,
0.397065669298172,
0.6482473015785217,
0.3826678693294525,
0.5514736175537109,
-0.5529364347457886,
-0.15793779492378235,
0.05171124264597893,
0.33597761392593384,
0.803854763507843,
-0.3993014991283417,
0.6036036014556885,
-0.5560529828071594,
-0.1482255607843399,
0.10756270587444305,
0.8140580058097839,
0.3642934560775757,
0.012642383575439453,
0.5659683346748352,
0.7312633991241455,
0.860682487487793,
-0.1875613033771515,
1.1468746662139893,
-0.3310384750366211,
0.4402449429035187,
0.8996140956878662,
0.1171928346157074,
0.6989080905914307,
0.35193851590156555,
-0.592216968536377,
0.5607380270957947,
0.39867231249809265,
-0.009156697429716587,
0.6692423820495605,
0.7732163667678833,
-0.29576900601387024,
0.05226550251245499,
0.2444877177476883,
0.016950860619544983,
0.5805469155311584,
0.2770475447177887,
-0.3066568076610565,
-0.16409547626972198,
-0.09034958481788635,
0.12084507942199707,
-0.23033957183361053,
-0.10507343709468842,
0.7850560545921326,
0.13630364835262299,
-0.8625907301902771,
0.5668278336524963,
-0.006484095938503742,
0.7604768872261047,
-0.39423567056655884,
0.01660609245300293,
-0.009124044328927994,
0.33521702885627747,
-0.2783867120742798,
-0.6641421914100647,
0.24705515801906586,
0.05211767554283142,
0.006049048621207476,
0.002162512158975005,
0.4635913372039795,
-0.3721126317977905,
-0.6027135252952576,
-0.22878800332546234,
0.29665452241897583,
0.24826274812221527,
0.3344757854938507,
-0.2760483920574188,
-0.42296046018600464,
-0.07478035241365433,
-0.6000558137893677,
0.13836616277694702,
0.31814485788345337,
-0.2187945693731308,
0.5773258209228516,
0.7384501099586487,
0.37473833560943604,
0.9703470468521118,
0.1360253244638443,
0.36450445652008057,
-0.6294690370559692,
-0.5651907920837402,
-0.837273120880127,
0.3765777349472046,
0.04998233541846275,
-0.14767591655254364,
0.47451409697532654,
0.30926647782325745,
0.49667397141456604,
-0.10942728072404861,
0.5515425801277161,
-0.20927074551582336,
0.07085354626178741,
-0.47897496819496155,
0.31570735573768616,
-0.2536742687225342,
-0.021542740985751152,
-0.4335630238056183,
-1.027161717414856,
-0.08457915484905243,
0.38369131088256836,
-0.037353817373514175,
-0.0643983706831932,
0.6310573220252991,
0.6178669333457947,
0.1564921736717224,
0.14782696962356567,
0.34760335087776184,
0.08841285854578018,
0.5548115372657776,
0.7914878726005554,
0.6346205472946167,
-0.5962899923324585,
0.5382369160652161,
-0.13657382130622864,
-0.29084542393684387,
-0.22144025564193726,
-1.0840961933135986,
-0.28222858905792236,
-0.8164066672325134,
-0.25554826855659485,
-0.4786941111087799,
0.15297488868236542,
0.7230345606803894,
0.6362130045890808,
-0.5471928119659424,
-0.14776721596717834,
-0.5697427988052368,
0.12706361711025238,
-0.2402208000421524,
-0.2054682970046997,
0.23330157995224,
-0.3415049612522125,
-0.6574127078056335,
0.16116343438625336,
0.1661580353975296,
0.040383562445640564,
-0.2502954304218292,
0.15605351328849792,
-0.32609879970550537,
0.34897783398628235,
0.6710108518600464,
0.21273893117904663,
-0.446611225605011,
-0.275917112827301,
-0.014022467657923698,
0.16770033538341522,
0.037494633346796036,
0.8118976354598999,
-0.7472630739212036,
0.09501562267541885,
0.687657356262207,
0.5402615070343018,
0.649613082408905,
-0.06001278758049011,
0.6776787042617798,
-0.3547295928001404,
-0.029627932235598564,
-0.08536307513713837,
0.2194628268480301,
-0.01656169630587101,
-0.34877654910087585,
0.5819404125213623,
-0.029539315029978752,
-0.5887885689735413,
-0.7877963185310364,
0.6917180418968201,
-0.9391930103302002,
0.1638953685760498,
1.291625738143921,
0.008715858682990074,
-0.5853039026260376,
0.331076443195343,
0.10269095003604889,
0.5717968344688416,
-0.06374236941337585,
0.6374184489250183,
0.5119531750679016,
-0.13628090918064117,
0.13610830903053284,
-0.6888369917869568,
0.3483497202396393,
0.17576761543750763,
-0.6356775760650635,
-0.1768110692501068,
0.14451082050800323,
0.06774356961250305,
0.38197144865989685,
0.3500915765762329,
-0.2658291459083557,
-0.052649449557065964,
-0.04586481302976608,
-0.00013570970622822642,
0.25953400135040283,
-0.305111289024353,
-0.28424638509750366,
0.5147446990013123,
-0.03618926927447319,
-0.3167823553085327
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.13112v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.13112v2
|
Efficient Encoder-Decoder Transformer Decoding for Decomposable Tasks
| 2024-03-19T19:27:23 | 2024-05-23T17:17:26 |
Bo-Ru Lu, Nikita Haduong, Chien-Yu Lin, Hao Cheng, Noah A. Smith, Mari Ostendorf
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Transformer-based NLP models are powerful but have high computational costs
that limit deployment. Finetuned encoder-decoder models are popular in
specialized domains and can outperform larger more generalized decoder-only
models, such as GPT-4. We introduce a new configuration for encoder-decoder
models that improves efficiency on structured output and decomposable tasks
where multiple outputs are required for a single shared input. Our method,
prompt-in-decoder (PiD), encodes the input once and decodes the output in
parallel, boosting both training and inference efficiency by avoiding duplicate
input encoding and increasing the operational intensity (ratio of numbers of
arithmetic operation to memory access) of decoding process by sharing the input
key-value cache. We achieve computation reduction that roughly scales with the
number of subtasks, gaining up to 4.6x speed-up over state-of-the-art models
for dialogue state tracking, summarization, and question-answering tasks, with
comparable or better performance.
|
[
-0.359483540058136,
-0.47573912143707275,
0.31221166253089905,
0.3699018359184265,
-0.28067144751548767,
-0.24212802946567535,
-0.1695302575826645,
-0.052484191954135895,
-0.07044851034879684,
0.4981120824813843,
-0.540669858455658,
-0.23119039833545685,
-0.7866728901863098,
0.34785595536231995,
-0.19334697723388672,
0.9098167419433594,
0.1454169899225235,
0.009509501978754997,
-0.2977103590965271,
0.034555308520793915,
-0.6348028182983398,
-0.6850959658622742,
-0.8099128007888794,
-0.2363917976617813,
0.21587403118610382,
0.365609735250473,
0.4758053421974182,
0.3270231783390045,
0.7864212393760681,
0.21375378966331482,
-0.0533098429441452,
0.16237713396549225,
-0.4134368300437927,
0.32526400685310364,
-0.006486398633569479,
-0.32294777035713196,
-0.6619553565979004,
-0.26819953322410583,
0.4718863368034363,
0.729563295841217,
-0.2628554403781891,
0.016889628022909164,
0.3049154579639435,
0.5254144668579102,
-0.7582853436470032,
0.6326172947883606,
-0.4450933039188385,
-0.016420859843492508,
-0.0195725467056036,
-0.29828885197639465,
-0.5653270483016968,
-0.2810792922973633,
-0.19182108342647552,
-0.411721795797348,
0.37706458568573,
-0.2928412854671478,
0.5044004321098328,
0.5040599703788757,
-0.023841071873903275,
-0.29706117510795593,
-0.6005846858024597,
0.37315309047698975,
-0.6321587562561035,
0.5198104977607727,
0.43183428049087524,
0.12373733520507812,
0.13510389626026154,
-0.8606784343719482,
-0.5773613452911377,
0.12948712706565857,
-0.33447766304016113,
0.2870331406593323,
-0.46752145886421204,
0.3548121750354767,
0.39841586351394653,
0.4605334997177124,
-0.4873868227005005,
-0.18145789206027985,
-0.21996058523654938,
0.10152292996644974,
0.2191953808069229,
0.2891697287559509,
0.18976770341396332,
-0.13910236954689026,
0.011208154261112213,
0.034432053565979004,
-0.5560263395309448,
0.28924623131752014,
0.048999566584825516,
0.19210082292556763,
0.04459104314446449,
0.4647236764431,
-0.4300850033760071,
0.5740020871162415,
0.31820324063301086,
-0.01757740043103695,
0.17241449654102325,
-0.5968056917190552,
-0.10905467718839645,
-0.05886580049991608,
0.612697958946228,
0.4847392141819,
-0.09284381568431854,
-0.3722890019416809,
-0.2705233097076416,
0.24593161046504974,
0.3861975371837616,
-1.0086058378219604,
-0.34884804487228394,
0.08322920650243759,
-0.4313039183616638,
0.1621897667646408,
-0.14532338082790375,
-0.5473048090934753,
-0.013380083255469799,
0.004111776128411293,
0.3710460364818573,
-0.5562571287155151,
-0.10886242240667343,
0.5813831686973572,
-0.24311888217926025,
0.18071848154067993,
0.36560553312301636,
-1.103098750114441,
0.6546597480773926,
0.7483713626861572,
1.0223197937011719,
-0.48633334040641785,
-0.11164486408233643,
-0.7786334156990051,
-0.07995306700468063,
-0.19656145572662354,
0.7113344073295593,
-0.5953431725502014,
-0.3109219968318939,
-0.21362783014774323,
0.16602210700511932,
-0.4454035758972168,
-0.49342092871665955,
0.7081626653671265,
-0.5899085402488708,
0.030939020216464996,
-0.2954970598220825,
-0.6915034055709839,
-0.2211480438709259,
0.22303281724452972,
-0.8155843615531921,
0.8403922915458679,
0.15684059262275696,
-0.7105345726013184,
0.10458774119615555,
-1.1460413932800293,
-0.3426089286804199,
0.236909881234169,
0.265002965927124,
-0.20548570156097412,
0.21603254973888397,
0.5957791209220886,
0.685286819934845,
-0.3205994963645935,
0.36028751730918884,
0.20782701671123505,
-0.4891833961009979,
-0.18104788661003113,
-0.5458424091339111,
0.6212450265884399,
0.21759000420570374,
-0.06699050962924957,
0.06721264868974686,
-0.48148009181022644,
-0.279930055141449,
-0.02363220974802971,
-0.560309112071991,
-0.06828543543815613,
-0.1441802829504013,
-0.17735852301120758,
-0.05839274078607559,
0.286284863948822,
-0.6829444169998169,
0.23524722456932068,
-0.4066880941390991,
0.5229055285453796,
0.251910537481308,
0.05095776915550232,
0.5991714000701904,
-0.2768506109714508,
0.64012610912323,
-0.12261247634887695,
0.02946496196091175,
-0.6934522986412048,
-0.5916885137557983,
-0.6849700808525085,
-0.4453744888305664,
0.16231441497802734,
0.5673596858978271,
-0.8718810081481934,
0.3695221245288849,
-0.42707559466362,
-0.3708988130092621,
-0.542000412940979,
-0.329759418964386,
0.360917329788208,
0.5764681696891785,
0.417838990688324,
-0.2446819394826889,
-0.2044207900762558,
-0.6188621520996094,
-0.34699344635009766,
0.3321115970611572,
-0.352365106344223,
0.02707354538142681,
0.3842075765132904,
-0.21717573702335358,
0.7861432433128357,
-0.4003199636936188,
-0.06408681720495224,
-0.7201172113418579,
-0.09063486754894257,
0.47647005319595337,
0.6109018325805664,
0.296794593334198,
-0.5189051032066345,
-0.5912205576896667,
-0.08308170735836029,
-0.5049816966056824,
-0.1616535484790802,
-0.18705065548419952,
-0.020614173263311386,
0.0914519727230072,
0.42840245366096497,
-0.9871329665184021,
0.256596177816391,
0.5660017728805542,
-0.3888549208641052,
0.33943042159080505,
-0.3867521286010742,
0.3151110112667084,
-0.8360282182693481,
-0.13502433896064758,
-0.3943062722682953,
-0.2698366045951843,
-0.8819200396537781,
0.06550995260477066,
0.309551477432251,
-0.29172173142433167,
-0.20320048928260803,
0.0821131244301796,
-0.3696047365665436,
-0.030541809275746346,
-0.21384426951408386,
-0.3028118908405304,
0.2650211751461029,
0.8288477063179016,
0.22339148819446564,
1.0178536176681519,
0.4808385670185089,
-0.6125003695487976,
0.2074972689151764,
0.2942832410335541,
-0.0985468178987503,
0.24921977519989014,
-0.931290864944458,
0.32744041085243225,
-0.1948556751012802,
0.3215654492378235,
-0.6455093026161194,
-0.15641950070858002,
0.30416083335876465,
-0.19814926385879517,
0.2478441298007965,
-0.12470188736915588,
-0.41594332456588745,
-0.11368926614522934,
-0.21370185911655426,
0.5772876739501953,
0.5880040526390076,
-0.7272887825965881,
0.6833088994026184,
0.15365222096443176,
-0.4331510365009308,
-0.3410908579826355,
-0.501103401184082,
-0.04449896514415741,
-0.05418648570775986,
-0.5653650760650635,
0.6471124887466431,
0.11866605281829834,
0.28639987111091614,
0.013761226087808609,
-0.13994450867176056,
-0.11404820531606674,
-0.16804899275302887,
0.20980064570903778,
0.015098086558282375,
-0.14314782619476318,
0.10513041913509369,
0.2678188681602478,
-0.3319319188594818,
0.01270281057804823,
-0.23522059619426727,
0.6776940226554871,
-0.22147004306316376,
-0.3780103921890259,
-0.6121604442596436,
0.8607840538024902,
0.5625578165054321,
-0.46959352493286133,
0.7617872953414917,
0.438050776720047,
-0.5311898589134216,
0.03765104338526726,
-0.34574779868125916,
-0.22514237463474274,
-0.47546324133872986,
0.45848220586776733,
-0.6371898055076599,
-0.8669388294219971,
0.39447495341300964,
-0.15129487216472626,
0.11289849877357483,
0.46586963534355164,
0.3707023859024048,
-0.00355581846088171,
0.817710280418396,
0.6471247673034668,
0.2930300235748291,
0.3604441285133362,
-0.3559417426586151,
0.45127302408218384,
-0.7990907430648804,
-0.30956894159317017,
-0.4807884991168976,
0.025014905259013176,
-0.16837692260742188,
-0.6738853454589844,
0.44005247950553894,
0.11378155648708344,
-0.26008281111717224,
0.3808863162994385,
-0.7844341993331909,
0.5654047727584839,
0.7722581624984741,
0.232558473944664,
0.41046279668807983,
-0.14987792074680328,
0.41246211528778076,
-0.14386139810085297,
-1.1328376531600952,
-0.40901753306388855,
0.9882819056510925,
0.23363178968429565,
0.660880446434021,
-0.1252487301826477,
0.5893354415893555,
0.2205968052148819,
-0.14527031779289246,
-0.676454484462738,
0.35690900683403015,
-0.4108366072177887,
-0.004591434262692928,
-0.25720441341400146,
-0.2004275619983673,
-0.7940813302993774,
0.3107360303401947,
-0.02695152349770069,
-0.527360737323761,
0.4226754605770111,
0.2831420600414276,
-0.559630274772644,
0.322954386472702,
-0.8580583930015564,
1.0580605268478394,
0.20772206783294678,
0.0953008234500885,
-0.22127999365329742,
-0.2688180208206177,
0.34802675247192383,
0.1196381151676178,
-0.26487889885902405,
0.06432923674583435,
0.033582478761672974,
0.6825945973396301,
-0.42407023906707764,
0.6024881601333618,
-0.3320566713809967,
0.25574713945388794,
0.06170492619276047,
-0.11174134910106659,
0.7042360901832581,
0.027038881555199623,
-0.15916411578655243,
0.31219223141670227,
0.04366012662649155,
-0.21340398490428925,
-0.8791212439537048,
0.32028961181640625,
-0.4902136027812958,
-0.400848388671875,
-0.21589548885822296,
-0.6735484600067139,
-0.027928892523050308,
-0.14828486740589142,
0.6118171811103821,
0.6933449506759644,
-0.09808224439620972,
0.32881802320480347,
0.7804074287414551,
-0.19370663166046143,
0.5702489018440247,
0.027717942371964455,
0.42016303539276123,
-0.1844715178012848,
0.7353286147117615,
-0.04018356651067734,
0.33370569348335266,
0.5407407879829407,
-0.01982622966170311,
-0.37430596351623535,
-0.5422796607017517,
-0.1598488688468933,
0.017813874408602715,
-0.6519928574562073,
-0.42868760228157043,
-1.1415623426437378,
-0.15250280499458313,
-0.2975325286388397,
-0.3903460204601288,
-0.7177011370658875,
-0.4476281404495239,
-0.2225392907857895,
0.07539825141429901,
0.34007498621940613,
0.4528391361236572,
0.08019062876701355,
0.6336607336997986,
-0.8247202634811401,
0.8084753751754761,
0.29289424419403076,
0.4137371778488159,
-0.19786164164543152,
-0.4101603329181671,
-0.2798784375190735,
-0.15184250473976135,
-0.13253545761108398,
-0.9150409698486328,
0.573879599571228,
0.3673548996448517,
0.4059390425682068,
0.13292039930820465,
0.49514177441596985,
0.4589608609676361,
-0.6344410181045532,
0.6898749470710754,
0.24260416626930237,
-1.0804615020751953,
0.32124894857406616,
-0.12308642268180847,
0.7534938454627991,
0.3206701874732971,
0.2625623643398285,
-0.5801658034324646,
-0.10475845634937286,
-0.2736366093158722,
-0.7332830429077148,
0.9477351307868958,
0.34669339656829834,
0.1629122495651245,
-0.12330935150384903,
0.1750580221414566,
0.40600332617759705,
0.0034895024728029966,
-0.41473597288131714,
0.038594167679548264,
-0.5972822904586792,
-0.2774212956428528,
0.054620902985334396,
-0.627182126045227,
0.07327748090028763,
-0.40701961517333984,
0.48184362053871155,
-0.15005552768707275,
0.8362919092178345,
0.21586111187934875,
-0.23338711261749268,
0.5840250849723816,
0.4718901813030243,
0.3657117486000061,
0.23481088876724243,
-0.17168079316616058,
0.14519450068473816,
0.27715232968330383,
-0.6049799919128418,
0.055294644087553024,
0.09651350975036621,
-0.013348106294870377,
0.3137025237083435,
0.1289919763803482,
1.0998538732528687,
0.15675997734069824,
-0.37624648213386536,
0.5456365942955017,
-0.4318101704120636,
-0.12008260190486908,
-0.10345398634672165,
0.14137618243694305,
0.22667233645915985,
0.2976866066455841,
0.20883652567863464,
0.4175640940666199,
0.49073928594589233,
-0.08497895300388336,
0.016894454136490822,
0.14620503783226013,
0.1250411719083786,
-0.3435131311416626,
0.5396735668182373,
0.5077900886535645,
-0.437034547328949,
0.782338559627533,
-0.5890089869499207,
-0.4340195655822754,
0.4172278344631195,
0.60318922996521,
1.0567272901535034,
-0.16750890016555786,
0.009971186518669128,
0.4745122492313385,
0.2266935557126999,
-0.2140338271856308,
0.25809869170188904,
-0.3358127772808075,
-0.8017526268959045,
-0.6248983144760132,
-0.5923452377319336,
-0.45781978964805603,
-0.07497614622116089,
-0.8299118280410767,
-0.14471498131752014,
-0.05662652105093002,
0.014290407299995422,
-0.15291213989257812,
-0.4042242467403412,
-0.8002018928527832,
-0.15739373862743378,
-0.23553314805030823,
0.6657567620277405,
-0.3828856647014618,
0.8124885559082031,
0.3274954557418823,
0.05348839610815048,
-0.595304548740387,
-0.15425771474838257,
-0.4904799461364746,
-0.30507200956344604,
0.48081427812576294,
0.4027674198150635,
-0.22043702006340027,
0.13467805087566376,
-0.028052352368831635,
-0.6229497790336609,
0.9103495478630066,
0.6781628727912903,
-0.7126277089118958,
-0.33437642455101013,
0.1545872837305069,
0.14484909176826477,
-0.49618029594421387,
0.39397186040878296,
0.8644745349884033,
0.24663423001766205,
-0.3312256634235382,
-1.0074658393859863,
0.06513457000255585,
-0.49217650294303894,
0.152022585272789,
0.027008527889847755,
-0.10153303295373917,
0.881255567073822,
-0.1278475672006607,
-0.36010533571243286,
-0.14365017414093018,
0.40716180205345154,
0.09843344241380692,
0.19855140149593353,
0.3815278708934784,
0.3254511058330536,
0.5730563998222351,
-0.39133593440055847,
1.2119499444961548,
-0.5020213723182678,
0.27926942706108093,
0.9398584961891174,
0.30091601610183716,
0.6536274552345276,
0.30168548226356506,
-0.10961903631687164,
0.14111974835395813,
0.2914014756679535,
0.09494835883378983,
0.7475262880325317,
-0.31140902638435364,
-0.3876904547214508,
-0.3199422359466553,
0.09185361117124557,
-0.249906986951828,
0.47430843114852905,
0.44708046317100525,
-0.08635115623474121,
-0.26094019412994385,
0.35518959164619446,
-0.10517607629299164,
0.00883224606513977,
-0.35565119981765747,
0.7995707988739014,
-0.14337319135665894,
-0.6654177308082581,
0.7384020686149597,
0.08839308470487595,
1.0747430324554443,
-0.5614601373672485,
-0.13000956177711487,
-0.29369792342185974,
0.19357351958751678,
-0.18004478514194489,
-0.6011582016944885,
0.6520679593086243,
0.1208033561706543,
-0.41972261667251587,
-0.5576456189155579,
0.6913434863090515,
-0.5237073302268982,
-0.320671409368515,
-0.0058975303545594215,
0.38199061155319214,
0.22507859766483307,
-0.5902666449546814,
-0.32085299491882324,
0.15398961305618286,
-0.0989750549197197,
-0.2675190567970276,
0.037805717438459396,
0.3006940186023712,
0.2065357267856598,
0.5219444632530212,
0.487411767244339,
-0.1910974383354187,
0.3004625737667084,
0.2121599018573761,
0.8183427453041077,
-0.6477134227752686,
-0.7705142498016357,
-0.64475017786026,
0.5463605523109436,
0.03228333219885826,
-0.16241277754306793,
0.542523205280304,
0.3773784935474396,
0.86346036195755,
-0.429831862449646,
0.6877661347389221,
-0.02131486125290394,
0.318656325340271,
-0.49556776881217957,
0.6007810831069946,
-0.08611978590488434,
0.23430828750133514,
-0.1313929259777069,
-0.7280771732330322,
-0.284145712852478,
0.5864617824554443,
-0.06787916272878647,
-0.1201813593506813,
0.7310386896133423,
0.6987163424491882,
-0.14583928883075714,
0.2872263789176941,
0.32006850838661194,
-0.338547021150589,
0.3580594062805176,
0.6350880861282349,
0.6152011156082153,
-0.37953460216522217,
0.40710023045539856,
-0.45029979944229126,
-0.14574091136455536,
-0.05511357635259628,
-0.5817986726760864,
-0.7144162058830261,
-0.5435693264007568,
-0.3428348898887634,
0.21680577099323273,
0.24368120729923248,
0.6233640313148499,
0.6661157608032227,
-0.6717113256454468,
-0.04867929220199585,
-0.47356510162353516,
-0.12383852154016495,
-0.5385442972183228,
-0.20602239668369293,
0.44040027260780334,
-0.6789398193359375,
-1.0336312055587769,
0.3331800103187561,
0.396926611661911,
-0.28282320499420166,
0.20426017045974731,
-0.25838708877563477,
0.20680317282676697,
0.027542557567358017,
0.7619010210037231,
0.04058973863720894,
-0.6525248885154724,
0.03672424703836441,
0.1438564956188202,
0.08830822259187698,
0.23993952572345734,
0.9579725861549377,
-0.7619549632072449,
0.35819384455680847,
0.6655272841453552,
0.9980848431587219,
0.7100062966346741,
0.09912015497684479,
0.6538622975349426,
-0.5301982760429382,
0.1337229162454605,
0.4070916473865509,
0.42770078778266907,
0.2962568700313568,
-0.5221933722496033,
0.3674428462982178,
0.09588313102722168,
-0.5148897171020508,
-0.5517668128013611,
0.15635180473327637,
-1.0237083435058594,
-0.16974443197250366,
0.8771466612815857,
-0.4937044382095337,
0.037372905761003494,
-0.22431321442127228,
-0.15033060312271118,
0.1831202507019043,
-0.6366721391677856,
0.3286646902561188,
0.36728498339653015,
-0.5669365525245667,
-0.562831461429596,
-0.35883039236068726,
0.5707595944404602,
0.3988966941833496,
-0.7793081998825073,
0.22810450196266174,
0.34113365411758423,
0.03322521969676018,
-0.012856652960181236,
0.8585253953933716,
-0.07281742244958878,
0.5013524293899536,
0.4069916009902954,
0.24057474732398987,
-0.3839453458786011,
-0.3496464490890503,
-0.5191361308097839,
0.5552443861961365,
-0.2678726315498352,
-0.605590283870697
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.13107v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.13107v2
|
Towards Unsupervised Question Answering System with Multi-level Summarization for Legal Text
| 2024-03-19T19:15:13 | 2024-07-02T03:35:53 |
M Manvith Prabhu, Haricharana Srinivasa, Anand Kumar M
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG
|
This paper summarizes Team SCaLAR's work on SemEval-2024 Task 5: Legal
Argument Reasoning in Civil Procedure. To address this Binary Classification
task, which was daunting due to the complexity of the Legal Texts involved, we
propose a simple yet novel similarity and distance-based unsupervised approach
to generate labels. Further, we explore the Multi-level fusion of Legal-Bert
embeddings using ensemble features, including CNN, GRU, and LSTM. To address
the lengthy nature of Legal explanation in the dataset, we introduce T5-based
segment-wise summarization, which successfully retained crucial information,
enhancing the model's performance. Our unsupervised system witnessed a 20-point
increase in macro F1-score on the development set and a 10-point increase on
the test set, which is promising given its uncomplicated architecture.
|
[
-0.32938462495803833,
-0.4364716112613678,
0.638740599155426,
-0.12034543603658676,
-0.6611785888671875,
0.019195379689335823,
0.14219212532043457,
-0.1660841405391693,
-0.02398941107094288,
0.5630843043327332,
-0.1191479042172432,
-0.6486030220985413,
-0.37823617458343506,
0.028134167194366455,
-0.4746885299682617,
1.3123918771743774,
0.3625093996524811,
0.2149699628353119,
-0.5439378023147583,
-0.4625966250896454,
-0.20505674183368683,
-0.4373345375061035,
-0.3132786452770233,
-0.08764135837554932,
0.45840418338775635,
0.4400777518749237,
0.15513619780540466,
0.49052703380584717,
0.4246187210083008,
0.3414006531238556,
-0.29498982429504395,
-0.07886835187673569,
-0.2041538655757904,
0.3603881597518921,
-0.2418924868106842,
-0.4379623532295227,
-0.2553596794605255,
-0.4733123481273651,
0.5466155409812927,
0.47002044320106506,
-0.15465301275253296,
0.15269973874092102,
-0.20359918475151062,
0.4564439356327057,
-0.3616585433483124,
0.019211838021874428,
-0.44593530893325806,
0.0747624933719635,
0.07960719615221024,
-0.18517038226127625,
-0.17758822441101074,
-0.3886175751686096,
0.16754058003425598,
-0.42699873447418213,
0.26234838366508484,
-0.06727936118841171,
0.7350064516067505,
0.6427862644195557,
-0.5635526180267334,
-0.13478323817253113,
-0.40492963790893555,
0.33141613006591797,
-0.8968963623046875,
0.09676771610975266,
-0.20071610808372498,
0.5381382703781128,
0.028491171076893806,
-0.8125212788581848,
-0.3579196631908417,
0.307718962430954,
0.0782288983464241,
0.44385913014411926,
-0.08111068606376648,
0.05755848065018654,
0.06001325696706772,
0.09935151785612106,
-0.5236079692840576,
-0.02043837122619152,
-0.8390776515007019,
-0.2745538353919983,
0.781586229801178,
0.11148999631404877,
0.1846179962158203,
-0.20045088231563568,
-0.15749424695968628,
0.19668252766132355,
-0.43630293011665344,
0.30655714869499207,
0.18048875033855438,
0.01699032634496689,
0.09974244236946106,
0.6085534691810608,
-0.06307081133127213,
0.49007195234298706,
0.10702633112668991,
0.06290005147457123,
0.20055606961250305,
-0.12728111445903778,
-0.3334612548351288,
0.3967040777206421,
0.8074727654457092,
0.33976906538009644,
0.07557816058397293,
0.008160028606653214,
-0.058337870985269547,
-0.45493459701538086,
0.16160565614700317,
-0.7096589207649231,
-0.01196193229407072,
0.71018385887146,
-0.6826668977737427,
-0.5341079235076904,
0.17551517486572266,
-0.9256076812744141,
-0.5227404236793518,
-0.08808253705501556,
0.23433437943458557,
-0.3395388424396515,
0.0353466160595417,
0.18496909737586975,
-0.4380735754966736,
0.5842003226280212,
0.5015567541122437,
-0.5784458518028259,
0.06445785611867905,
0.6395148038864136,
0.2547561526298523,
0.11509329825639725,
0.054972417652606964,
-0.5992684960365295,
0.4433343708515167,
-0.2615382671356201,
0.9672971963882446,
-0.7103379368782043,
-0.20862096548080444,
-0.14367413520812988,
0.062042076140642166,
0.25568366050720215,
-0.45322391390800476,
0.6287313103675842,
-0.5764707326889038,
0.480563759803772,
-0.26661914587020874,
-0.6707530617713928,
-0.3184705376625061,
0.24665921926498413,
-0.3458873927593231,
0.9569743275642395,
-0.32833102345466614,
-0.9044290781021118,
0.5544956922531128,
-0.8714319467544556,
-0.6413154006004333,
0.37796905636787415,
-0.2573547661304474,
-0.5828812122344971,
0.0645500048995018,
0.5665619373321533,
0.501985490322113,
0.044145308434963226,
0.45156529545783997,
-0.27513614296913147,
-0.28256478905677795,
-0.044034700840711594,
0.001320157083682716,
1.0268069505691528,
0.3585203289985657,
-0.3663080036640167,
0.45346540212631226,
-0.5915958881378174,
-0.19160111248493195,
-0.15489009022712708,
-0.574626088142395,
-0.3487027883529663,
0.06239879131317139,
-0.5596031546592712,
0.2631652057170868,
0.32578980922698975,
-0.6918815970420837,
-0.03608245775103569,
-0.29400891065597534,
0.4729064702987671,
0.4957176744937897,
0.44045543670654297,
0.22299830615520477,
-0.018904823809862137,
0.6108382940292358,
0.24959491193294525,
-0.09168387204408646,
-0.3876687288284302,
-0.5655781030654907,
-0.7183846235275269,
-0.12488038837909698,
0.5831188559532166,
0.7556037902832031,
-0.6056630611419678,
0.34339630603790283,
-0.36190322041511536,
-0.25137078762054443,
-0.6262302994728088,
-0.36114275455474854,
0.3322999179363251,
0.4616721570491791,
0.4396986961364746,
0.1981581598520279,
-0.5202831029891968,
-1.0206178426742554,
-0.2960251271724701,
-0.08806406706571579,
-0.12956684827804565,
0.24333809316158295,
0.7807044982910156,
0.06150035187602043,
0.7400640249252319,
-0.36653703451156616,
-0.15485018491744995,
-0.31178587675094604,
0.4825984239578247,
0.1865393966436386,
0.25866809487342834,
0.46839413046836853,
-0.6550496816635132,
-0.26110756397247314,
0.10617125779390335,
-0.7598890662193298,
-0.21573108434677124,
-0.029909078031778336,
0.20587396621704102,
0.177138552069664,
0.7881263494491577,
-0.07000990211963654,
0.3124385178089142,
-0.30377697944641113,
-0.3865456283092499,
0.2843469977378845,
-0.5186968445777893,
0.383788138628006,
-1.4192510843276978,
-0.07176004350185394,
-0.04664844647049904,
-0.3702847361564636,
-0.48198333382606506,
0.12498734891414642,
-0.12081373482942581,
-0.3399648666381836,
-0.6436586976051331,
0.03105083294212818,
-0.31146571040153503,
-0.4317303001880646,
-0.16373315453529358,
0.09802867472171783,
-0.06000738963484764,
0.5433793663978577,
-0.08649968355894089,
0.55026775598526,
0.6233037710189819,
-0.44680848717689514,
0.5323848128318787,
0.2049221396446228,
-0.14117662608623505,
0.7144871354103088,
-0.8719558715820312,
-0.10234946757555008,
-0.6370664834976196,
0.27337491512298584,
-1.0434123277664185,
-0.34348064661026,
-0.07321780920028687,
-0.606301486492157,
0.04589814692735672,
-0.30476880073547363,
-0.47256407141685486,
-0.41045457124710083,
-0.37891852855682373,
0.3380773663520813,
0.5245150923728943,
-0.14223089814186096,
0.6233637928962708,
0.6117364168167114,
-0.4878106117248535,
-0.5702188014984131,
-0.7275959849357605,
0.06731703877449036,
-0.6375433206558228,
-0.573008120059967,
0.13526925444602966,
0.2475712150335312,
-0.27658990025520325,
0.16936372220516205,
0.07850877195596695,
-0.3817940056324005,
-0.19054102897644043,
0.043752238154411316,
-0.17208139598369598,
-0.31506869196891785,
0.36759960651397705,
0.5532287955284119,
0.20193205773830414,
0.4328492283821106,
-0.20886126160621643,
-0.03674876317381859,
-0.4561057388782501,
-0.22772632539272308,
-0.09771770983934402,
0.7372823357582092,
0.6495106816291809,
-0.5245522856712341,
0.25480687618255615,
0.394025057554245,
-0.3395414650440216,
0.03280854970216751,
-0.4439273476600647,
0.07470989227294922,
-0.3495248556137085,
0.22887414693832397,
-0.44588276743888855,
-1.1172528266906738,
0.6500777006149292,
-0.010565136559307575,
0.411742627620697,
0.7823298573493958,
0.6217848658561707,
-0.4808647930622101,
0.8026213049888611,
0.15130504965782166,
0.03364206850528717,
-0.10067229717969894,
0.12490423023700714,
0.11281485110521317,
-0.47424742579460144,
-0.5806623101234436,
-0.6736223697662354,
-0.1253296583890915,
-0.587780237197876,
-0.4404253661632538,
0.6686449646949768,
-0.1665610522031784,
-0.3795033097267151,
0.1125735342502594,
-0.6381493806838989,
0.7474803328514099,
0.652420163154602,
-0.10265493392944336,
0.18002650141716003,
-0.18990033864974976,
-0.49213600158691406,
0.1823369562625885,
-0.6993434429168701,
-0.3754335641860962,
0.8474069833755493,
0.22429440915584564,
0.462461918592453,
0.3336617350578308,
0.9229479432106018,
0.4152284860610962,
-0.3200083076953888,
-0.4883030652999878,
0.7302260994911194,
-0.3520689308643341,
-0.5814617872238159,
-0.7468523383140564,
-0.20460960268974304,
-0.9887561202049255,
0.5659402012825012,
-0.2829197645187378,
-0.5400195121765137,
0.18925277888774872,
-0.15700794756412506,
-0.7809354066848755,
0.1832238733768463,
-0.4364515542984009,
0.8108754754066467,
-0.2831839323043823,
-0.21753820776939392,
-0.12667474150657654,
-1.0761839151382446,
0.3496561348438263,
0.04929876700043678,
0.3132844567298889,
0.10022853314876556,
0.13422666490077972,
0.9147427082061768,
-0.6855738162994385,
0.5528165102005005,
-0.31494706869125366,
-0.2016495317220688,
0.5994688272476196,
-0.34617218375205994,
0.10458099097013474,
0.05324440449476242,
0.20077989995479584,
-0.3533521294593811,
0.34865665435791016,
-0.2929632365703583,
-0.7347056865692139,
0.4424397051334381,
-0.34061816334724426,
-0.6840426325798035,
-0.4474976360797882,
-0.6545146703720093,
0.03557741641998291,
0.28168490529060364,
0.04218762367963791,
0.49003344774246216,
0.01746438816189766,
0.496442973613739,
1.079281210899353,
-0.4573531746864319,
0.5262612700462341,
0.40441715717315674,
0.163216695189476,
-0.5063075423240662,
0.9476134777069092,
-0.1488739252090454,
-0.4421062171459198,
0.5741169452667236,
0.3956403136253357,
-0.9039891958236694,
-0.4763437807559967,
-0.5203050971031189,
0.06404595077037811,
-0.8892360329627991,
-0.12392772734165192,
-0.7064864635467529,
-0.2289435714483261,
-0.665469765663147,
0.026749130338430405,
0.13276685774326324,
-0.6732094883918762,
-0.17135851085186005,
-0.15530981123447418,
0.12979258596897125,
0.8109943866729736,
0.11561083793640137,
-0.2483913153409958,
-0.8562630414962769,
0.21999454498291016,
0.48648086190223694,
0.10974728316068649,
-0.3656120300292969,
-0.751489520072937,
0.13886068761348724,
-0.14962664246559143,
-0.19157995283603668,
-0.8572878241539001,
-0.036858681589365005,
-0.14208567142486572,
0.6853161454200745,
0.5953308939933777,
0.31407907605171204,
0.6724323630332947,
-0.5219368934631348,
0.7912231683731079,
0.004900917410850525,
-0.8994798064231873,
0.815031886100769,
-0.6029256582260132,
0.24417302012443542,
0.5357527136802673,
0.17040148377418518,
-0.15536752343177795,
-0.6557623147964478,
-0.7625506520271301,
-0.8582740426063538,
0.35910695791244507,
0.09680436551570892,
-0.15730787813663483,
0.2598235309123993,
0.232349693775177,
-0.04803144186735153,
0.206244096159935,
-0.7100868821144104,
0.14234596490859985,
-0.4434056878089905,
-0.42085468769073486,
0.4046952426433563,
-0.28296229243278503,
-0.0978696271777153,
-0.5285831093788147,
0.4827321767807007,
-0.03786015510559082,
0.2771226167678833,
0.2047683298587799,
-0.05710401386022568,
0.4305869936943054,
0.8686790466308594,
1.1328651905059814,
0.503032386302948,
-0.09420781582593918,
0.2848816514015198,
0.44507646560668945,
0.02489786222577095,
0.24698401987552643,
0.2955356240272522,
-0.10073855519294739,
0.0444754995405674,
0.4984334111213684,
0.6030478477478027,
0.0470346137881279,
-0.6436801552772522,
0.6620886325836182,
0.11805323511362076,
-0.7511983513832092,
-0.16463516652584076,
-0.22461631894111633,
0.326272189617157,
0.5465889573097229,
0.3566909432411194,
-0.38972923159599304,
0.4255245327949524,
-0.3873743712902069,
0.3590783476829529,
0.1972450613975525,
-0.5657331943511963,
0.13687478005886078,
1.0162110328674316,
0.43812480568885803,
0.06485261768102646,
0.10370053350925446,
-0.10792216658592224,
-0.633510172367096,
0.8394579291343689,
0.2142808586359024,
0.5440376996994019,
-0.1490747034549713,
0.3022587299346924,
0.31656938791275024,
0.2575076222419739,
0.1142648309469223,
0.551908552646637,
-0.1717890202999115,
-0.2992039918899536,
-0.4424876570701599,
-0.3094175159931183,
-0.19798210263252258,
0.2499569058418274,
-0.5685239434242249,
-0.006947748828679323,
-0.20502880215644836,
0.5054088830947876,
0.06905893981456757,
-0.32268577814102173,
0.03194194287061691,
0.4020324945449829,
-0.21094687283039093,
0.5966489911079407,
-0.7438353896141052,
0.5065554976463318,
0.9941122531890869,
-0.5988014936447144,
-0.6531627178192139,
-0.17145656049251556,
-0.10747576504945755,
-0.45645761489868164,
0.5519425272941589,
-0.005765566602349281,
0.0462166890501976,
-0.18880997598171234,
-0.498349130153656,
-0.30541756749153137,
1.175753116607666,
0.1492779552936554,
-0.38193443417549133,
0.014639572240412235,
0.3747021555900574,
0.7756366729736328,
-0.3419652283191681,
0.21211813390254974,
0.4510740041732788,
0.4001257121562958,
0.58897864818573,
-0.4159103035926819,
0.07256083190441132,
-0.3123677968978882,
-0.2283908724784851,
0.2752833664417267,
-0.3896068334579468,
0.4748683571815491,
-0.5063885450363159,
0.031723830848932266,
-0.31388628482818604,
0.7334210276603699,
0.18235346674919128,
0.254727840423584,
0.3945309817790985,
0.8014863133430481,
0.7717235088348389,
-0.08658763021230698,
0.6247971057891846,
-0.16226860880851746,
0.22332389652729034,
1.2298587560653687,
-0.08254387974739075,
0.4969852566719055,
0.30455654859542847,
0.03482445701956749,
0.42535072565078735,
0.8750663995742798,
-0.3005572259426117,
0.45708248019218445,
0.43152812123298645,
-0.23263002932071686,
-0.519734263420105,
-0.17381760478019714,
-0.30952829122543335,
0.5040605068206787,
0.16064932942390442,
-0.4452434778213501,
-0.6065240502357483,
-0.16363024711608887,
-0.30114954710006714,
-0.027593502774834633,
-0.5140683054924011,
1.1088407039642334,
-0.0691789835691452,
-0.6879377961158752,
0.10258254408836365,
0.034437768161296844,
0.19190019369125366,
-0.07202252000570297,
-0.1753796935081482,
-0.2680680453777313,
-0.22705286741256714,
-0.22673504054546356,
-1.1645162105560303,
0.37793028354644775,
0.25413498282432556,
0.03169311583042145,
-0.18317964673042297,
0.788388192653656,
-0.5170217752456665,
-0.5256947875022888,
-0.17099158465862274,
0.4204633831977844,
0.6409772634506226,
0.19857992231845856,
-0.6911144256591797,
-0.6016283631324768,
-0.02028382197022438,
0.15691553056240082,
-0.0489007905125618,
1.0344173908233643,
-0.46417397260665894,
0.6128368973731995,
0.418069064617157,
-0.22783015668392181,
0.22581437230110168,
0.3720893859863281,
0.807228684425354,
-0.6537676453590393,
-0.739311158657074,
-0.7163172364234924,
0.7254776358604431,
-0.21639449894428253,
-0.11869718134403229,
0.3501046597957611,
0.884443998336792,
0.4384002387523651,
-0.04750404134392738,
0.8414706587791443,
-0.018067242577672005,
0.6157507300376892,
-0.4001329839229584,
0.7197220325469971,
-0.7287092804908752,
0.2604728937149048,
-0.4170297384262085,
-0.5793462991714478,
-0.3760947585105896,
0.3620242476463318,
-0.06572756916284561,
-0.13197578489780426,
0.7159174680709839,
0.3802751302719116,
-0.04120681434869766,
-0.06755189597606659,
0.4979590177536011,
-0.09237045794725418,
0.20688915252685547,
0.7198125123977661,
0.6835158467292786,
-0.24259446561336517,
1.1274244785308838,
0.2565253973007202,
-0.05096126347780228,
-0.056540992110967636,
-0.7453520894050598,
-1.0855014324188232,
-0.6357812881469727,
-0.250016987323761,
-0.1052439883351326,
0.06320248544216156,
0.4650425314903259,
0.3432336151599884,
-0.9170169830322266,
0.13271334767341614,
-0.1584937870502472,
0.0887012779712677,
0.16312631964683533,
-0.2279319167137146,
0.44924014806747437,
-0.29580891132354736,
-0.5122145414352417,
0.18304936587810516,
0.45691564679145813,
0.1440405696630478,
0.0357358381152153,
0.1299983412027359,
-0.3603944182395935,
0.12193022668361664,
0.6025355458259583,
0.24936535954475403,
-0.8786083459854126,
-0.4228408634662628,
-0.2693176567554474,
0.1323421150445938,
0.14424237608909607,
0.8344561457633972,
-0.4531286060810089,
0.44327014684677124,
0.7376836538314819,
1.1015863418579102,
0.5208178758621216,
0.5317738056182861,
0.5839166641235352,
-0.6476174592971802,
-0.09411997348070145,
0.3259828984737396,
0.6152049899101257,
-0.041659317910671234,
-0.2965638339519501,
0.5173805356025696,
0.05730929598212242,
-0.5625828504562378,
-0.46554654836654663,
0.0822744071483612,
-0.8510187864303589,
-0.47409388422966003,
0.9464102983474731,
-0.3483867645263672,
-0.22368338704109192,
-0.5768262147903442,
-0.11951382458209991,
0.3852587342262268,
-0.5563043355941772,
0.7227658033370972,
0.7270412445068359,
-0.25825321674346924,
-0.5672155022621155,
-0.20940087735652924,
0.26362401247024536,
0.38214123249053955,
-1.2658640146255493,
-0.25424259901046753,
0.7315442562103271,
0.5389214158058167,
0.1713382452726364,
0.6260582804679871,
-0.32768532633781433,
0.3910447955131531,
-0.2629273235797882,
0.06000041961669922,
-0.28973695635795593,
-0.25459131598472595,
-0.40356123447418213,
0.5060609579086304,
-0.5408596396446228,
-0.440371036529541
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.13106v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.13106v1
|
Knowing Your Nonlinearities: Shapley Interactions Reveal the Underlying Structure of Data
| 2024-03-19T19:13:22 | 2024-03-19T19:13:22 |
Divyansh Singhvi, Andrej Erkelens, Raghav Jain, Diganta Misra, Naomi Saphra
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Measuring nonlinear feature interaction is an established approach to
understanding complex patterns of attribution in many models. In this paper, we
use Shapley Taylor interaction indices (STII) to analyze the impact of
underlying data structure on model representations in a variety of modalities,
tasks, and architectures. Considering linguistic structure in masked and
auto-regressive language models (MLMs and ALMs), we find that STII increases
within idiomatic expressions and that MLMs scale STII with syntactic distance,
relying more on syntax in their nonlinear structure than ALMs do. Our speech
model findings reflect the phonetic principal that the openness of the oral
cavity determines how much a phoneme varies based on its context. Finally, we
study image classifiers and illustrate that feature interactions intuitively
reflect object boundaries. Our wide range of results illustrates the benefits
of interdisciplinary work and domain expertise in interpretability research.
|
[
-0.35082072019577026,
-0.6926420331001282,
0.42708855867385864,
0.2147064357995987,
0.16181820631027222,
-0.18660666048526764,
-0.007244002539664507,
-0.9541450142860413,
0.445059210062027,
0.3138684630393982,
-0.13022856414318085,
-0.0365506112575531,
-0.6059039235115051,
-0.3842089772224426,
-0.2752329111099243,
1.0463804006576538,
0.0387297086417675,
0.3293355107307434,
-0.4959515929222107,
-0.10354498773813248,
-0.05661648139357567,
-0.7775956988334656,
-0.4686903953552246,
-0.35492169857025146,
0.5418519973754883,
-0.10332975536584854,
1.183286428451538,
0.9322444200515747,
0.6622689366340637,
0.4299701154232025,
-0.06858465075492859,
-0.26600906252861023,
-0.38735127449035645,
0.3726283609867096,
-0.13560065627098083,
-0.7077521681785583,
-0.3311591148376465,
0.08278173208236694,
0.5582103729248047,
1.2242515087127686,
0.12893866002559662,
0.09088341891765594,
0.21984653174877167,
0.29079681634902954,
-0.2884247601032257,
0.2947574257850647,
-0.3314763903617859,
0.023297036066651344,
-0.4530048668384552,
-0.2293214648962021,
0.06063618138432503,
0.040178827941417694,
0.3935164213180542,
-0.07095088064670563,
0.05698762461543083,
0.009836788289248943,
1.1111980676651,
0.28108838200569153,
-0.42738062143325806,
-0.5442912578582764,
-0.6411104798316956,
0.8829320669174194,
-0.5590529441833496,
0.6475784778594971,
0.5146647691726685,
-0.003345801029354334,
-0.41124656796455383,
-0.5106827020645142,
-0.43938782811164856,
-0.33940544724464417,
-0.3061569631099701,
-0.30923810601234436,
-0.2877578139305115,
0.31645113229751587,
0.0017459337832406163,
0.6839070916175842,
0.04578769952058792,
-0.017330721020698547,
-0.4849669635295868,
-0.23709481954574585,
0.8017313480377197,
0.21335572004318237,
0.4394283592700958,
-0.6292053461074829,
-0.38023698329925537,
0.2051602005958557,
-0.15997321903705597,
0.6229920387268066,
0.674560546875,
0.46172666549682617,
-0.21984128654003143,
0.5891086459159851,
0.5006796717643738,
0.43704327940940857,
0.2233247309923172,
0.09150806069374084,
0.17732319235801697,
-0.670698881149292,
-0.22461745142936707,
-0.4685075283050537,
0.8749549984931946,
-0.04567841440439224,
-0.05922619625926018,
-0.28863444924354553,
-0.21149477362632751,
-0.7075209021568298,
0.24234633147716522,
-0.5649786591529846,
-0.4629475772380829,
0.27656278014183044,
-0.7840061783790588,
-0.6093864440917969,
0.40049347281455994,
-0.4979734420776367,
-0.3632839322090149,
-0.43071702122688293,
0.5232160091400146,
-0.3534027934074402,
-0.4666067361831665,
-0.3151179552078247,
-0.11516346037387848,
0.18031878769397736,
0.06459300965070724,
-0.9867126941680908,
0.7024813890457153,
0.6798220872879028,
0.9606642723083496,
-0.17908619344234467,
-0.30309778451919556,
-0.4129733443260193,
-0.01723041944205761,
-0.2910187840461731,
0.5988320708274841,
-0.6431187391281128,
-0.2652483582496643,
-0.3069911301136017,
-0.0696495920419693,
-0.08451640605926514,
-0.6611160635948181,
0.37311047315597534,
-0.18826603889465332,
0.2748057544231415,
-0.06156059354543686,
-0.4415854513645172,
-0.3019740581512451,
-0.23374131321907043,
-0.7792345285415649,
1.1320102214813232,
0.170899897813797,
-0.5566465854644775,
0.2832143306732178,
-0.640051007270813,
-0.45801985263824463,
-0.05107687786221504,
-0.36281344294548035,
-0.5252672433853149,
0.44865840673446655,
-0.3794766366481781,
0.2786959111690521,
0.11184459924697876,
0.52801114320755,
-0.5526333451271057,
-0.16712705790996552,
0.5969780683517456,
-0.18175600469112396,
0.7610861659049988,
-0.026346851140260696,
-0.30671995878219604,
0.29833099246025085,
-0.633767306804657,
0.21287381649017334,
-0.3061753511428833,
-0.1986996829509735,
-0.5263176560401917,
-0.0319034643471241,
0.3745594918727875,
0.12270096689462662,
0.3515530824661255,
0.0582210049033165,
-0.036870069801807404,
-0.314877450466156,
0.5930529832839966,
0.5913730263710022,
0.05170581862330437,
0.42877906560897827,
-0.07742482423782349,
0.45281773805618286,
0.37169039249420166,
-0.011909587308764458,
0.012711678631603718,
-0.41562366485595703,
-0.7448580265045166,
-0.4547249674797058,
0.4271043539047241,
0.2612139880657196,
-0.26493820548057556,
0.36968713998794556,
-0.060903437435626984,
-0.24439962208271027,
-0.4075324237346649,
0.1641933172941208,
0.6265581250190735,
0.09722713381052017,
0.1129055991768837,
-0.2954898774623871,
-0.6228916645050049,
-1.3413821458816528,
-0.5154266357421875,
-0.07201547920703888,
-0.35826703906059265,
0.6269429922103882,
0.685263454914093,
-0.014567063190042973,
0.9767888188362122,
-0.2060418426990509,
-0.14235378801822662,
0.07106252014636993,
0.33189940452575684,
0.15483620762825012,
0.4982794225215912,
0.6055698394775391,
-0.9017375707626343,
-0.2527429461479187,
0.029241260141134262,
-0.5352353453636169,
-0.0889430120587349,
0.15025250613689423,
0.09862461686134338,
-0.10855813324451447,
0.4478341341018677,
-0.23766660690307617,
0.6505815982818604,
0.44525042176246643,
-0.35220205783843994,
0.341747522354126,
-0.02037198655307293,
0.2901287376880646,
-0.8658826947212219,
0.11951380223035812,
0.09338535368442535,
-0.22141781449317932,
-1.0905539989471436,
-0.06982273608446121,
-0.3093404769897461,
-0.22306351363658905,
-0.253126323223114,
0.31096234917640686,
-0.3739946484565735,
-0.4088411331176758,
-0.004884631372988224,
0.08994899690151215,
-0.03105616755783558,
0.4523197114467621,
-0.17453262209892273,
1.0312931537628174,
0.48142775893211365,
-0.5882738828659058,
-0.05766979977488518,
0.1982191503047943,
-0.11466742306947708,
0.4926891624927521,
-0.9761978983879089,
0.04054643586277962,
0.03136339411139488,
-0.13813260197639465,
-0.9973402619361877,
-0.3802572190761566,
0.025599418208003044,
-0.489674836397171,
0.09341581165790558,
-0.1907460242509842,
-0.14980290830135345,
0.1264781504869461,
-0.4985160529613495,
0.5263092517852783,
-0.2430058866739273,
-0.22466911375522614,
1.0298550128936768,
0.7362702488899231,
-0.1887904703617096,
-0.4269329905509949,
-0.720636785030365,
0.29130464792251587,
-0.4166431725025177,
-0.9642296433448792,
0.34370920062065125,
0.30380967259407043,
-0.7835330963134766,
0.052006796002388,
-0.06571777164936066,
-0.5265635848045349,
0.1870114505290985,
0.7585186958312988,
0.16720882058143616,
-0.21896269917488098,
0.17764587700366974,
-0.28364044427871704,
0.09275585412979126,
0.1919730007648468,
-0.06246744841337204,
0.505021333694458,
-0.28770652413368225,
0.0002775617176666856,
-0.6676698327064514,
0.2987518608570099,
0.5263451933860779,
0.01442710030823946,
0.6745806336402893,
0.37267178297042847,
-0.464407354593277,
0.07230715453624725,
-0.13317565619945526,
-0.08110891282558441,
-0.461824506521225,
0.449127733707428,
-0.7744251489639282,
-0.4514327347278595,
0.9092206358909607,
0.3038084805011749,
-0.33056169748306274,
0.26382043957710266,
0.2042302042245865,
-0.40766003727912903,
0.9790681600570679,
0.7769585251808167,
-0.07344990223646164,
0.7747751474380493,
-0.19397644698619843,
0.5041948556900024,
-0.9065045118331909,
-0.33461567759513855,
-0.41683271527290344,
-0.45237475633621216,
-0.53395015001297,
-0.4560330808162689,
0.3373757600784302,
0.5751398205757141,
0.21512405574321747,
0.3525979518890381,
-0.05146697908639908,
0.11491149663925171,
0.3663509488105774,
0.2089511901140213,
0.16374529898166656,
-0.2951010465621948,
0.3591386377811432,
-0.43670758605003357,
-0.3135969042778015,
-0.39677396416664124,
0.8317887783050537,
0.7718715071678162,
0.6375678777694702,
0.3154022693634033,
0.44650211930274963,
0.3440972864627838,
-0.10147064179182053,
-1.0480566024780273,
0.2545335292816162,
-0.30766865611076355,
-0.20751380920410156,
-0.2812073528766632,
-0.5143331289291382,
-0.8253516554832458,
0.09919988363981247,
-0.35369375348091125,
-0.7493189573287964,
0.6188786029815674,
0.17237551510334015,
-0.08334574103355408,
0.04355442896485329,
-0.5411925911903381,
0.6186932325363159,
-0.408796101808548,
-0.5108751058578491,
-0.102848581969738,
-0.30462297797203064,
0.31222841143608093,
0.20720678567886353,
0.2087060511112213,
0.2061758190393448,
-0.29702144861221313,
0.7480728030204773,
-0.5962714552879333,
0.8540045022964478,
-0.14568206667900085,
-0.2377854883670807,
-0.11292309314012527,
0.2255236953496933,
0.2626926600933075,
-0.06703202426433563,
-0.04025176167488098,
0.6622969508171082,
0.010324308648705482,
-0.3707955479621887,
-0.8081218004226685,
0.6321211457252502,
-0.6736873388290405,
-0.5067809224128723,
-0.23153282701969147,
-1.0335215330123901,
-0.2228604555130005,
0.13730767369270325,
0.006593352649360895,
0.7340225577354431,
-0.09590297192335129,
0.23167403042316437,
0.5122241973876953,
0.24891223013401031,
0.17623640596866608,
-0.006087766494601965,
-0.3518734574317932,
-0.45282983779907227,
0.7493761777877808,
0.2577718198299408,
0.5179322361946106,
0.06646169722080231,
0.23565760254859924,
-0.19770167768001556,
-0.7985944151878357,
-0.12303921580314636,
0.14785489439964294,
-0.5208001732826233,
0.08147307485342026,
-0.5818361043930054,
-0.2754797041416168,
-0.16215860843658447,
0.03237195685505867,
-0.06203651800751686,
-0.6963068246841431,
-0.21835067868232727,
0.07826991379261017,
0.20268623530864716,
1.0140583515167236,
-0.1057053729891777,
0.1718037873506546,
-0.22108767926692963,
0.001842742902226746,
0.1341158002614975,
0.4711798131465912,
0.14317132532596588,
-0.5702125430107117,
-0.40304723381996155,
0.1165444627404213,
-0.12043413519859314,
-0.595978856086731,
0.13938754796981812,
0.5348689556121826,
0.5338073968887329,
0.6422281265258789,
-0.46228745579719543,
1.216172456741333,
-0.17167481780052185,
0.8739453554153442,
0.0008037801599130034,
-1.456009030342102,
0.35898730158805847,
-0.39636415243148804,
-0.15979117155075073,
0.3816884160041809,
0.342468798160553,
-0.4631802439689636,
-0.5753756761550903,
-0.6115836501121521,
-0.7125145792961121,
0.30861061811447144,
0.23428979516029358,
0.093415267765522,
0.36224567890167236,
0.43760186433792114,
-0.038187600672245026,
0.3326195478439331,
-0.723771870136261,
-0.3572506308555603,
-0.28486156463623047,
-0.4758557975292206,
0.38677018880844116,
-0.19248682260513306,
-0.32755255699157715,
-0.0743756964802742,
0.12020085006952286,
0.013389497995376587,
0.17437215149402618,
0.09422733634710312,
-0.09262215346097946,
-0.03321430832147598,
-0.1512780636548996,
0.7403059601783752,
0.595635175704956,
-0.02140398509800434,
0.424919992685318,
-0.11962300539016724,
-0.5782636404037476,
-0.3810380697250366,
-0.024445585906505585,
0.037219610065221786,
0.03840317949652672,
0.8595467805862427,
0.8177079558372498,
0.6130820512771606,
-0.4755870997905731,
0.40972280502319336,
0.1277725100517273,
-0.11859271675348282,
-0.20991259813308716,
0.2000528872013092,
-0.1708408147096634,
0.37651145458221436,
0.4408094882965088,
0.2894110679626465,
0.4225989282131195,
-0.8727979063987732,
0.5346124768257141,
0.9454830884933472,
-0.6682724952697754,
-0.57096928358078,
0.49034979939460754,
0.1917719691991806,
-0.5398404598236084,
0.1951673924922943,
0.20133356750011444,
-0.7127612829208374,
0.65090411901474,
0.20101653039455414,
0.630585253238678,
-0.28733760118484497,
0.060159917920827866,
0.06125917658209801,
-0.012772481888532639,
0.38473063707351685,
0.2237890660762787,
-0.1973569691181183,
-0.6484098434448242,
-0.052569180727005005,
-0.3790050446987152,
-0.33445796370506287,
0.1926908642053604,
-0.934006929397583,
0.21564555168151855,
-0.4903360903263092,
-0.10569371283054352,
0.6165915131568909,
0.043177105486392975,
-0.37913602590560913,
-0.06530510634183884,
-0.29048019647598267,
0.362085223197937,
-0.7070909738540649,
0.531342625617981,
0.47926443815231323,
-0.6866320371627808,
-0.6666590571403503,
0.19816328585147858,
0.16298548877239227,
-0.9178908467292786,
1.0509631633758545,
0.055983297526836395,
-0.4077182412147522,
-0.3404525816440582,
-0.46792805194854736,
-1.121130347251892,
0.7042717337608337,
0.08438144624233246,
-0.17103126645088196,
0.059859540313482285,
0.3191121220588684,
0.6786694526672363,
-0.5777266621589661,
0.281342089176178,
0.4877752959728241,
0.4544276297092438,
-0.2332739681005478,
-1.225764274597168,
-0.07962805032730103,
-0.33425813913345337,
0.19283805787563324,
0.5607067942619324,
-0.31991901993751526,
0.9982753992080688,
-0.3178437352180481,
-0.6087625622749329,
0.1055620089173317,
0.5759769678115845,
-0.19641202688217163,
0.20332638919353485,
0.7290722131729126,
0.11987654864788055,
0.8843249082565308,
-0.14461523294448853,
0.6736528873443604,
-0.3258873522281647,
0.3428477644920349,
1.0484904050827026,
0.32340535521507263,
0.9283385276794434,
0.7664007544517517,
-0.360914021730423,
0.6152338981628418,
0.44683557748794556,
-0.2244253009557724,
0.19798873364925385,
0.28925150632858276,
-0.006209940183907747,
0.1624370813369751,
-0.3781259059906006,
-0.06479386240243912,
0.6960223317146301,
0.35471615195274353,
-0.4564986526966095,
0.2581423819065094,
0.2778863310813904,
0.1864922046661377,
0.2475038468837738,
-0.2745325267314911,
0.6936911344528198,
0.0032326336950063705,
0.051572829484939575,
0.5049317479133606,
-0.38065144419670105,
0.7052960395812988,
-0.46644893288612366,
-0.08361978083848953,
0.11267704516649246,
-0.0735233947634697,
-0.7368382215499878,
-0.9770597219467163,
0.499116986989975,
-0.375368595123291,
-0.6211398243904114,
0.052216388285160065,
0.41202646493911743,
-0.8368744850158691,
-0.28761640191078186,
0.21897070109844208,
0.26845574378967285,
0.298442006111145,
0.2123611569404602,
-0.5476430654525757,
0.2962118983268738,
0.06497717648744583,
-0.0889504998922348,
0.19048532843589783,
0.3951457440853119,
-0.1799374222755432,
0.7167674899101257,
0.6063272356987,
0.29045286774635315,
-0.05884619802236557,
0.11800923943519592,
0.7199159860610962,
-0.8754388093948364,
-0.28355422616004944,
-0.45633530616760254,
0.5258426666259766,
-0.2506405711174011,
-0.4588090181350708,
0.7678162455558777,
0.549422562122345,
0.4755440950393677,
0.2736833095550537,
0.5547876954078674,
-0.15829205513000488,
0.13932284712791443,
-0.397784024477005,
0.6052923202514648,
-0.308972030878067,
0.21476809680461884,
-0.04257268086075783,
-0.5490881204605103,
-0.08704753965139389,
0.5246366858482361,
-0.43236368894577026,
0.19020675122737885,
0.5197708010673523,
0.5646600723266602,
-0.0586988665163517,
0.055877119302749634,
0.1699160933494568,
0.4012669026851654,
0.4205698072910309,
0.04675600677728653,
0.5617021918296814,
-0.6260808706283569,
0.4929005205631256,
-0.33685922622680664,
-0.3501981198787689,
-0.08325444906949997,
-0.5690010786056519,
-0.869384229183197,
-0.9466012120246887,
-0.10993310809135437,
-0.393850713968277,
-0.2941814363002777,
0.573008120059967,
0.8355293869972229,
-0.8166560530662537,
-0.43363767862319946,
0.04214807227253914,
0.09273489564657211,
-0.3950767517089844,
-0.40489351749420166,
0.44398361444473267,
-0.35925644636154175,
-0.9189397096633911,
0.24807508289813995,
0.3359610438346863,
0.17293812334537506,
-0.7434627413749695,
0.1880781352519989,
0.1499299257993698,
0.24104371666908264,
0.4510762095451355,
0.11951019614934921,
-0.7732776403427124,
-0.4379676878452301,
-0.0972323939204216,
-0.031234264373779297,
0.09648355841636658,
1.0651400089263916,
-0.44011640548706055,
0.3396574854850769,
0.3566492795944214,
0.31851091980934143,
0.15695850551128387,
0.14196239411830902,
0.8358370065689087,
-0.5529879331588745,
0.22385039925575256,
0.21114207804203033,
0.22604568302631378,
0.2563040852546692,
-0.7192497849464417,
0.3318321704864502,
-0.04919475317001343,
-0.459511399269104,
-1.1324948072433472,
0.5396904349327087,
-0.8701227903366089,
-0.03713226690888405,
0.5493077635765076,
-0.042614784091711044,
-0.21980389952659607,
-0.5461864471435547,
0.027534209191799164,
-0.3856631815433502,
-0.2549455165863037,
0.8212700486183167,
0.9182575941085815,
-0.7393920421600342,
-0.3429158627986908,
-0.5721073746681213,
0.8149408102035522,
0.25472405552864075,
-0.7609882354736328,
0.19126254320144653,
0.1755560338497162,
0.28084179759025574,
0.6157639622688293,
0.09490439295768738,
-0.12008275091648102,
0.032940689474344254,
0.09707324951887131,
-0.10806175321340561,
-0.2876007556915283,
-0.2078096717596054,
-0.5762097239494324,
0.0373075045645237,
-0.14424358308315277,
-0.18098331987857819
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.13089v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.13089v1
|
Automatic Summarization of Doctor-Patient Encounter Dialogues Using Large Language Model through Prompt Tuning
| 2024-03-19T18:37:05 | 2024-03-19T18:37:05 |
Mengxian Lyu, Cheng Peng, Xiaohan Li, Patrick Balian, Jiang Bian, Yonghui Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Automatic text summarization (ATS) is an emerging technology to assist
clinicians in providing continuous and coordinated care. This study presents an
approach to summarize doctor-patient dialogues using generative large language
models (LLMs). We developed prompt-tuning algorithms to instruct generative
LLMs to summarize clinical text. We examined the prompt-tuning strategies, the
size of soft prompts, and the few-short learning ability of GatorTronGPT, a
generative clinical LLM developed using 277 billion clinical and general
English words with up to 20 billion parameters. We compared GatorTronGPT with a
previous solution based on fine-tuning of a widely used T5 model, using a
clinical benchmark dataset MTS-DIALOG. The experimental results show that the
GatorTronGPT- 20B model achieved the best performance on all evaluation
metrics. The proposed solution has a low computing cost as the LLM parameters
are not updated during prompt-tuning. This study demonstrates the efficiency of
generative clinical LLMs for clinical ATS through prompt tuning.
|
[
-0.19265590608119965,
-0.6441351771354675,
0.8853099942207336,
0.016620175912976265,
-0.6486586928367615,
0.13229309022426605,
-0.37257465720176697,
-0.15172500908374786,
0.3256781995296478,
0.3172866702079773,
-0.5944103598594666,
-0.6159467697143555,
-0.4620848596096039,
0.6042712330818176,
-0.0950872004032135,
0.9263284802436829,
0.15239067375659943,
0.3514450788497925,
-0.08253621309995651,
-0.19878199696540833,
-0.6002903580665588,
-0.1991632729768753,
-0.9112653136253357,
-0.3634483218193054,
0.2853609323501587,
0.4582931101322174,
0.749142050743103,
0.7375566363334656,
0.31164422631263733,
0.38782545924186707,
-0.239902526140213,
0.41808587312698364,
-0.2002498209476471,
0.2829689681529999,
0.07883969694375992,
-0.37774088978767395,
-0.5281565189361572,
-0.21236452460289001,
0.6552380919456482,
0.7718172669410706,
-0.44769734144210815,
-0.14163190126419067,
-0.046050217002630234,
0.36042577028274536,
-0.09382417798042297,
-0.018612051382660866,
-0.4190197288990021,
0.10997714847326279,
0.12625595927238464,
-0.5672087073326111,
-0.3566017150878906,
-0.453782856464386,
0.1118774563074112,
-0.5456308126449585,
0.5398349761962891,
0.2484670728445053,
0.6453897356987,
0.2888559103012085,
-0.22760513424873352,
-0.6411753296852112,
-0.2784445583820343,
0.6047652959823608,
-0.7836052179336548,
0.06594213098287582,
0.22493433952331543,
0.40814149379730225,
-0.12448838353157043,
-0.5162339806556702,
-0.3817591965198517,
-0.35346218943595886,
-0.19451336562633514,
0.3022756278514862,
-0.1810138076543808,
0.35580894351005554,
0.19315095245838165,
0.5608121752738953,
-0.5064583420753479,
0.3157128095626831,
-0.16762112081050873,
-0.061840638518333435,
0.5177310705184937,
0.9350723624229431,
0.40816769003868103,
-0.4349937438964844,
-0.08552584797143936,
0.22930827736854553,
-0.7800911068916321,
-0.1152937114238739,
-0.07949956506490707,
0.40980657935142517,
-0.3631736934185028,
0.5238534808158875,
-0.13363178074359894,
0.7298997640609741,
0.17669092118740082,
-0.2942999005317688,
-0.03361900895833969,
-0.48778143525123596,
-0.27727094292640686,
0.033428240567445755,
1.004388451576233,
0.8238576054573059,
0.24561923742294312,
-0.15795259177684784,
-0.11832472681999207,
-0.18524183332920074,
0.3480883240699768,
-0.7873295545578003,
-0.24240125715732574,
0.38456952571868896,
-0.5764456987380981,
-0.6214979290962219,
-0.4501323401927948,
-0.6644202470779419,
-0.5575733184814453,
-0.34952512383461,
0.07596458494663239,
-0.556053102016449,
0.14463748037815094,
0.08524025231599808,
0.11203530430793762,
-0.06888004392385483,
0.6929934620857239,
-1.0392770767211914,
0.31147345900535583,
0.48796704411506653,
1.1478831768035889,
-0.12050550431013107,
0.008647558279335499,
-0.8950688242912292,
0.03262266516685486,
-0.3333553075790405,
0.9430341720581055,
-0.3823215067386627,
-0.9783375263214111,
0.15165682137012482,
0.06478093564510345,
-0.3368353843688965,
-0.7299890518188477,
0.49784696102142334,
-0.05665378272533417,
0.43235790729522705,
-0.15175940096378326,
-0.6312655210494995,
0.1343858242034912,
0.12999308109283447,
-0.31961649656295776,
0.421467661857605,
0.1229066252708435,
-0.45415806770324707,
0.25599077343940735,
-0.6573629975318909,
-0.6201648712158203,
0.47143158316612244,
-0.3150903284549713,
-0.5798212289810181,
0.5133197903633118,
0.5834544897079468,
0.5722671151161194,
-0.42803478240966797,
0.3542279303073883,
0.05232121795415878,
-0.3525942862033844,
0.1998441070318222,
-0.11281201988458633,
0.5829241275787354,
0.25783100724220276,
0.23041023313999176,
0.4764714241027832,
-0.49943962693214417,
-0.06333745270967484,
0.05322195962071419,
-0.15436242520809174,
-0.017121974378824234,
0.09523790329694748,
-0.2753642201423645,
-0.00644910242408514,
-0.1771320402622223,
-0.20460569858551025,
0.29155591130256653,
-0.590515673160553,
0.6188557744026184,
0.3687567114830017,
0.3494912087917328,
0.19029898941516876,
-0.5877123475074768,
0.924747109413147,
-0.1314641237258911,
0.024355262517929077,
-0.7411803007125854,
-0.47378820180892944,
-0.4970049560070038,
-0.55426424741745,
0.1579793393611908,
0.6175094246864319,
-0.6612650752067566,
0.4067555069923401,
-0.4175157845020294,
-0.2686372697353363,
-0.6517384052276611,
-0.07013694196939468,
0.37816736102104187,
0.8577699065208435,
0.38016024231910706,
-0.030450398102402687,
-0.2687934339046478,
-0.6566696763038635,
-0.16765621304512024,
-0.16806913912296295,
-0.47636571526527405,
0.6274738907814026,
0.24866659939289093,
0.06204080209136009,
0.6156653165817261,
-0.6965935230255127,
-0.3386767506599426,
-0.570091962814331,
0.21164682507514954,
0.3417230248451233,
0.09846539050340652,
0.5358588099479675,
-0.17707790434360504,
-0.6695666909217834,
-0.1283683478832245,
-0.7325419187545776,
-0.3207872807979584,
-0.11530933529138565,
0.32896852493286133,
0.26136690378189087,
0.6869069337844849,
-0.6718381643295288,
0.1736418753862381,
0.16377148032188416,
-0.316789835691452,
0.6455119252204895,
-0.6274351477622986,
0.3850306272506714,
-1.312993049621582,
0.0003164395457133651,
-0.04816904664039612,
-0.4497772455215454,
-0.6431976556777954,
-0.018813863396644592,
0.10665460675954819,
-0.38844868540763855,
-0.2248276323080063,
0.4157298803329468,
-0.5259988903999329,
0.4000067710876465,
-0.3495873808860779,
0.17855793237686157,
-0.11297039687633514,
0.23127366602420807,
0.14683203399181366,
1.0392576456069946,
0.3940422832965851,
-0.5762373805046082,
0.5596261024475098,
0.6984268426895142,
-0.3372511565685272,
0.741162121295929,
-0.9161926507949829,
-0.14132970571517944,
-0.025790583342313766,
0.4128052294254303,
-0.904349148273468,
-0.5442191362380981,
0.15285730361938477,
-0.5069710612297058,
0.36042311787605286,
-0.13787463307380676,
-0.4177848696708679,
-0.27789509296417236,
-0.38324540853500366,
0.2466525286436081,
0.5878548622131348,
-0.317442387342453,
0.670845091342926,
0.1748628169298172,
-1.0122812986373901,
0.10358282923698425,
-0.2220151573419571,
0.47444096207618713,
-0.4708176553249359,
-0.6554098725318909,
0.40647318959236145,
0.09700193256139755,
-0.10701411217451096,
-0.4840763211250305,
0.26932743191719055,
0.3563563823699951,
-0.12624280154705048,
0.025677060708403587,
0.3862922191619873,
-0.10082543641328812,
0.358824759721756,
0.2525866627693176,
-0.23659029603004456,
0.0867588073015213,
0.04073934629559517,
0.7121369242668152,
0.041816871613264084,
-0.21999286115169525,
-0.5065746903419495,
0.7795042991638184,
0.47931745648384094,
0.04799714684486389,
0.5546992421150208,
0.194420725107193,
-0.18604567646980286,
-0.008176601491868496,
-0.3914355933666229,
-0.28175950050354004,
-0.42985135316848755,
0.3850623071193695,
-0.21498140692710876,
-0.6528138518333435,
0.8375490307807922,
-0.14889214932918549,
-0.009448610246181488,
0.39676979184150696,
0.9394630193710327,
-0.2751942276954651,
1.3148376941680908,
0.43089938163757324,
-0.08071528375148773,
0.32329604029655457,
0.17388875782489777,
-0.11038049310445786,
-0.7847673296928406,
-0.08257091790437698,
-0.6292994618415833,
0.0725131407380104,
-0.33153235912323,
-0.12381428480148315,
1.0185734033584595,
-0.1871946156024933,
0.028833406046032906,
-0.03962381184101105,
-0.36183515191078186,
0.44889289140701294,
0.2886587977409363,
0.27088645100593567,
0.46040648221969604,
-0.033539701253175735,
-0.17210644483566284,
-0.005721316672861576,
-0.7717756628990173,
-0.44032129645347595,
0.9327561855316162,
0.24579596519470215,
0.723297655582428,
0.17970189452171326,
0.4813835918903351,
0.11335594207048416,
0.16551339626312256,
-0.7626686692237854,
0.5587020516395569,
-0.22353610396385193,
-0.0575825497508049,
-0.23831677436828613,
-0.48605188727378845,
-0.8745002150535583,
0.22465340793132782,
-0.1772109866142273,
-0.5914064049720764,
-0.35735487937927246,
0.38421866297721863,
-0.9028109312057495,
-0.06790843605995178,
-0.6904774904251099,
0.4960614740848541,
0.08787182718515396,
-0.016712632030248642,
-0.37990063428878784,
-0.8872601389884949,
0.17747199535369873,
0.1386357992887497,
-0.012230418622493744,
0.2022312432527542,
-0.10606832802295685,
0.445661723613739,
-0.8473660945892334,
0.6990639567375183,
-0.12784165143966675,
-0.3341839611530304,
-0.04885752499103546,
-0.156720831990242,
0.6341424584388733,
0.4209747314453125,
0.21947164833545685,
-0.2197362631559372,
-0.24895183742046356,
-0.22777554392814636,
-0.5809558033943176,
0.5454395413398743,
-0.4315298795700073,
-0.5425438284873962,
-0.31657296419143677,
-0.4421924948692322,
-0.46629875898361206,
-0.04466330260038376,
0.6565134525299072,
0.8292572498321533,
-0.2522021234035492,
-0.1912965625524521,
0.8646991848945618,
-0.5589480996131897,
0.36341917514801025,
0.6527242064476013,
-0.07117724418640137,
-0.6081894040107727,
0.6092925667762756,
-0.17380671203136444,
0.4222657382488251,
0.1594579517841339,
0.3574247658252716,
-0.3965056836605072,
-0.7742162942886353,
-0.8245916962623596,
0.379967600107193,
-0.5576596856117249,
-0.4069954752922058,
-0.7580865621566772,
-0.0757482647895813,
-0.42281296849250793,
-0.39075425267219543,
0.19821001589298248,
-0.1852608621120453,
-0.4150334894657135,
0.12985152006149292,
0.48196521401405334,
0.3600834310054779,
0.4030306935310364,
0.5369536280632019,
-0.9721693992614746,
0.5174642205238342,
0.12332822382450104,
0.25423556566238403,
-0.14006391167640686,
-0.843697190284729,
-0.23923006653785706,
-0.2178424894809723,
-0.250855952501297,
-0.814668595790863,
0.45913058519363403,
0.44096511602401733,
0.27021998167037964,
0.4458185136318207,
0.008382692001760006,
0.674416184425354,
-0.7316898107528687,
0.8640815019607544,
0.3739956021308899,
-0.7868631482124329,
0.6666983366012573,
-0.8287982940673828,
0.7863275408744812,
0.6047673225402832,
0.13469302654266357,
-0.8090136051177979,
-0.4955421984195709,
-0.42190706729888916,
-0.765490710735321,
0.683199405670166,
-0.0451374426484108,
0.14403605461120605,
-0.062227681279182434,
0.28046712279319763,
0.07638818770647049,
0.34606772661209106,
0.045285455882549286,
-0.00034647228312678635,
-0.035825714468955994,
-0.6669613122940063,
-0.36058685183525085,
-0.2606685757637024,
-0.379442036151886,
-0.35848861932754517,
0.5023345351219177,
-0.3941422402858734,
0.4249281585216522,
0.11130789667367935,
-0.20513667166233063,
-0.31077107787132263,
0.343356728553772,
0.9113040566444397,
0.4608181416988373,
-0.047217488288879395,
-0.27692437171936035,
0.4253230392932892,
-0.6057127714157104,
-0.05484766140580177,
0.25248491764068604,
-0.20876194536685944,
0.17209993302822113,
0.5204378366470337,
0.9003188014030457,
0.14571866393089294,
-0.7377219200134277,
0.4865782558917999,
-0.20837882161140442,
-0.3196203112602234,
-0.21136797964572906,
0.18236520886421204,
0.06421052664518356,
0.060804057866334915,
0.19159471988677979,
-0.1832285374403,
0.24735060334205627,
-0.22587965428829193,
-0.04862195998430252,
0.3743366003036499,
-0.2318618893623352,
-0.26153483986854553,
0.6827017068862915,
0.49332672357559204,
-0.31920918822288513,
0.7945228219032288,
0.1680949628353119,
-0.42174670100212097,
0.3827823996543884,
0.3819557726383209,
0.9449505805969238,
-0.3548543155193329,
0.2228066772222519,
0.21093180775642395,
-0.13584230840206146,
0.08931954950094223,
0.2774771749973297,
-0.10845916718244553,
-0.22432848811149597,
-0.6124976277351379,
-0.3118055462837219,
-0.6379680037498474,
0.10077530890703201,
-0.5743834376335144,
0.3537278175354004,
-0.35492414236068726,
-0.0672747939825058,
0.2439216524362564,
0.007905659265816212,
-0.20529823005199432,
0.14295430481433868,
-0.17241160571575165,
0.8805651664733887,
-0.6815302968025208,
0.4323316216468811,
0.6849639415740967,
-0.28740766644477844,
-0.7783747911453247,
-0.11778140813112259,
0.09188549220561981,
-0.881790041923523,
-0.009347942657768726,
0.09585653990507126,
-0.021262245252728462,
0.06963314116001129,
-0.4850979149341583,
-0.18393559753894806,
0.9321355819702148,
0.24647124111652374,
-0.5494216084480286,
-0.20454248785972595,
0.14022186398506165,
0.5411397218704224,
-0.42451152205467224,
0.3916507661342621,
0.4235864579677582,
0.07751432806253433,
0.2973077893257141,
-1.1300865411758423,
0.13899117708206177,
-0.4214131534099579,
-0.17938250303268433,
0.415934294462204,
-0.5831611752510071,
0.5647962689399719,
-0.45155811309814453,
-0.32039207220077515,
0.41299813985824585,
0.3722563683986664,
0.15361694991588593,
0.06679165363311768,
0.4768929183483124,
0.3768874406814575,
0.7175295352935791,
-0.18186239898204803,
1.0831340551376343,
-0.40671196579933167,
0.16191521286964417,
0.946744978427887,
-0.2780259847640991,
0.2463749796152115,
0.22697408497333527,
-0.16663721203804016,
0.21392279863357544,
0.508315920829773,
0.026110192760825157,
0.37951841950416565,
0.2500642240047455,
-0.589521050453186,
-0.3392305076122284,
-0.11304085701704025,
-0.4226926267147064,
0.11539087444543839,
0.45050305128097534,
-0.6135483384132385,
-0.33297082781791687,
0.2310946136713028,
0.17921596765518188,
-0.026017362251877785,
-0.4305216372013092,
1.3105840682983398,
0.16263681650161743,
-1.0165561437606812,
0.8306972980499268,
-0.04128964617848396,
0.31331202387809753,
-0.6782516241073608,
0.1575169861316681,
-0.3461855351924896,
0.10428451746702194,
-0.13710130751132965,
-0.41255468130111694,
0.09259388595819473,
0.14492422342300415,
-0.15989159047603607,
-0.15486811101436615,
0.41324496269226074,
-0.45921847224235535,
-0.4021405577659607,
-0.3820762634277344,
0.30375808477401733,
0.07910943776369095,
-0.0017384120728820562,
-0.4376436471939087,
-0.15311215817928314,
-0.06882548332214355,
-0.20012839138507843,
0.24351882934570312,
0.31056973338127136,
-0.1447710245847702,
0.9089075922966003,
0.252284437417984,
0.34980568289756775,
-0.25203460454940796,
0.41856035590171814,
0.9434500336647034,
-0.7337778210639954,
-0.7945573329925537,
-0.7845777273178101,
0.43144750595092773,
-0.15742115676403046,
-0.4103611409664154,
0.4480178654193878,
0.4091339409351349,
-0.01352881919592619,
-0.11651873588562012,
0.7825714945793152,
0.22775430977344513,
0.911213219165802,
-0.7144222855567932,
0.6581132411956787,
-0.5144945383071899,
0.20236296951770782,
-0.25192588567733765,
-0.3799743950366974,
-0.34913939237594604,
0.40151751041412354,
-0.10237220674753189,
0.02003186009824276,
0.6925673484802246,
0.6190146207809448,
0.05373913422226906,
0.3180106580257416,
0.164514422416687,
0.1973857879638672,
0.44386911392211914,
0.469897985458374,
0.5520840883255005,
-0.08614711463451385,
0.28274866938591003,
0.3055078089237213,
-0.43095487356185913,
-0.4765375852584839,
-0.7937291264533997,
-1.030798316001892,
-0.28733277320861816,
-0.24735264480113983,
-0.2394443303346634,
0.1896207183599472,
1.1301389932632446,
0.41758885979652405,
-0.7726938724517822,
0.10101848840713501,
-0.04879874363541603,
-0.4370969533920288,
-0.22918689250946045,
-0.1149972528219223,
0.5158172249794006,
-0.636099100112915,
-0.5872921347618103,
0.45405343174934387,
0.3211394250392914,
0.2821387052536011,
-0.15225158631801605,
-0.13638709485530853,
0.39225268363952637,
0.062490254640579224,
0.4700411558151245,
0.06006692722439766,
-0.5647051334381104,
-0.005124579183757305,
0.11914617568254471,
-0.06437783688306808,
0.09177018702030182,
0.9697022438049316,
-0.707700252532959,
0.5177853107452393,
0.2661682665348053,
0.2118135541677475,
0.22578872740268707,
0.3100968599319458,
0.9841330647468567,
-0.6821536421775818,
-0.021473780274391174,
0.3415627181529999,
0.27723491191864014,
0.2004043459892273,
-0.2939446270465851,
0.1277802288532257,
0.09310498088598251,
-0.536628007888794,
-0.7684840559959412,
0.367206335067749,
-0.8391150236129761,
-0.08416835963726044,
0.9381332397460938,
-0.12138225138187408,
0.20746079087257385,
-0.23119093477725983,
-0.4229964315891266,
0.18979988992214203,
-0.39038798213005066,
0.989737331867218,
0.6100127696990967,
-0.22324156761169434,
-0.296085387468338,
-0.44534382224082947,
0.7537309527397156,
0.475068062543869,
-0.867068350315094,
0.1125214546918869,
0.6255125999450684,
0.24310389161109924,
-0.18860426545143127,
0.7851557731628418,
-0.14591048657894135,
0.3754822909832001,
-0.3450241982936859,
-0.4633151888847351,
-0.2519473731517792,
-0.09814666956663132,
-0.5689270496368408,
0.1364355832338333,
-0.1927456259727478,
-0.05139544606208801
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15464v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15464v1
|
LLMs-based Few-Shot Disease Predictions using EHR: A Novel Approach Combining Predictive Agent Reasoning and Critical Agent Instruction
| 2024-03-19T18:10:13 | 2024-03-19T18:10:13 |
Hejie Cui, Zhuocheng Shen, Jieyu Zhang, Hui Shao, Lianhui Qin, Joyce C. Ho, Carl Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.MA, J.3; I.2.7
|
Electronic health records (EHRs) contain valuable patient data for
health-related prediction tasks, such as disease prediction. Traditional
approaches rely on supervised learning methods that require large labeled
datasets, which can be expensive and challenging to obtain. In this study, we
investigate the feasibility of applying Large Language Models (LLMs) to convert
structured patient visit data (e.g., diagnoses, labs, prescriptions) into
natural language narratives. We evaluate the zero-shot and few-shot performance
of LLMs using various EHR-prediction-oriented prompting strategies.
Furthermore, we propose a novel approach that utilizes LLM agents with
different roles: a predictor agent that makes predictions and generates
reasoning processes and a critic agent that analyzes incorrect predictions and
provides guidance for improving the reasoning of the predictor agent. Our
results demonstrate that with the proposed approach, LLMs can achieve decent
few-shot performance compared to traditional supervised learning methods in
EHR-based disease predictions, suggesting its potential for health-oriented
applications.
|
[
0.10495499521493912,
-1.0174387693405151,
1.176159381866455,
-0.7289165258407593,
-0.10644200444221497,
-0.051404453814029694,
-0.05768968537449837,
-0.6866123080253601,
0.34675702452659607,
0.7771942615509033,
-0.5581170320510864,
-0.7914981245994568,
-0.256167471408844,
0.26041552424430847,
0.07372967153787613,
1.032210350036621,
-0.08006990700960159,
0.40467777848243713,
-0.22085338830947876,
0.27561143040657043,
-0.3382028341293335,
-0.45494920015335083,
-0.6088030338287354,
-0.896881639957428,
0.6461331844329834,
0.6099979281425476,
0.580459713935852,
0.6344828605651855,
0.6933645606040955,
0.14988291263580322,
0.13245640695095062,
0.3027864694595337,
-0.24689066410064697,
0.22289223968982697,
0.14258421957492828,
-0.5962097644805908,
-0.6426206827163696,
-0.4298054575920105,
0.3645091950893402,
0.6258233189582825,
-0.23957447707653046,
0.026217006146907806,
-0.08683035522699356,
0.5395160913467407,
-0.2602849304676056,
0.13675488531589508,
-0.41922637820243835,
0.3844235837459564,
-0.09124375879764557,
-0.46654269099235535,
-0.6560959219932556,
-0.1676071435213089,
0.25148528814315796,
-0.6086112856864929,
-0.011642937548458576,
0.09161346405744553,
0.5387787222862244,
0.3568870425224304,
-0.3399456739425659,
0.03485792130231857,
-0.9122050404548645,
0.6910286545753479,
-0.7199327945709229,
0.10888484120368958,
0.6384236812591553,
0.7647939920425415,
-0.2919158339500427,
-0.5462259650230408,
-0.39895471930503845,
-0.2712952792644501,
0.007291767280548811,
0.17551808059215546,
-0.3411330282688141,
0.29335927963256836,
0.26554933190345764,
-0.15335634350776672,
-0.6393250823020935,
0.2977689504623413,
-0.200730100274086,
-0.06321805715560913,
0.6238958835601807,
0.6956847310066223,
0.206751748919487,
-0.3730710744857788,
-0.4560528099536896,
0.28882670402526855,
-0.728243350982666,
-0.16516368091106415,
-0.3841240704059601,
0.5805343985557556,
-0.19227729737758636,
0.6096541881561279,
-0.31761935353279114,
0.5078484416007996,
0.10556378960609436,
-0.6521139144897461,
0.2801869809627533,
0.07858529686927795,
-0.4254629909992218,
0.3528396785259247,
0.6500633358955383,
0.48677849769592285,
0.11353025585412979,
-0.2473295032978058,
-0.19813257455825806,
0.1510973572731018,
0.16260726749897003,
-0.8523004055023193,
-0.21462461352348328,
0.6021316647529602,
-0.7279277443885803,
-0.25816458463668823,
-0.38999468088150024,
-0.8502568006515503,
-0.5462881326675415,
-0.2606362998485565,
0.4048875570297241,
-0.694826066493988,
0.075766421854496,
0.1701044887304306,
0.18281352519989014,
0.23516075313091278,
0.643272340297699,
-0.4671507179737091,
0.43494683504104614,
0.5715939402580261,
0.6817489266395569,
-0.23849515616893768,
-0.18856070935726166,
-0.8374434113502502,
0.32762882113456726,
-0.18549364805221558,
0.9883025884628296,
-0.4798199236392975,
-0.4410202205181122,
0.2331586480140686,
-0.22939133644104004,
-0.1132480725646019,
-0.5787917375564575,
0.36066722869873047,
-0.3233090937137604,
-0.010513209737837315,
0.04468643665313721,
-0.6552554368972778,
0.04284098744392395,
0.7452331781387329,
-0.5772223472595215,
0.47602206468582153,
0.13743078708648682,
-0.6267307996749878,
0.27884334325790405,
-0.5590336918830872,
-0.5670763254165649,
0.5204264521598816,
-0.27986928820610046,
-0.6098678112030029,
-0.20607395470142365,
0.2565111517906189,
0.7249369621276855,
-0.3927030563354492,
0.20127061009407043,
-0.23567594587802887,
-0.22876602411270142,
0.38828912377357483,
-0.11339708417654037,
0.30853763222694397,
0.17867068946361542,
-0.07653805613517761,
0.16884160041809082,
-0.5666564106941223,
-0.01312950998544693,
0.3649115562438965,
-0.20185375213623047,
-0.006345368456095457,
0.2279319018125534,
-0.19436600804328918,
0.08167935162782669,
-0.017313547432422638,
-0.35341718792915344,
0.35926443338394165,
-0.5805897116661072,
0.02648041397333145,
0.43578192591667175,
0.30330848693847656,
0.29633358120918274,
-0.956028401851654,
0.850011944770813,
0.11597077548503876,
0.21775493025779724,
-0.5839869379997253,
-0.6428563594818115,
-0.32322174310684204,
-0.2509036958217621,
-0.0756244957447052,
0.6613426804542542,
-0.8920748233795166,
0.030278917402029037,
-0.4606965482234955,
-0.3379819393157959,
-0.3760000765323639,
-0.06459547579288483,
0.28631967306137085,
0.7719457149505615,
0.4904284179210663,
0.07641015201807022,
-0.42466408014297485,
-0.4190615117549896,
-0.03351372852921486,
-0.5056071281433105,
-0.1714170277118683,
0.47009482979774475,
0.47922033071517944,
-0.6621613502502441,
0.615339994430542,
-0.5601935386657715,
-0.6499798893928528,
-0.7543383836746216,
-0.13935139775276184,
0.18118815124034882,
0.026756517589092255,
0.2234169989824295,
-0.22291243076324463,
-0.5267876982688904,
0.2971147894859314,
-0.8290103077888489,
0.13090959191322327,
-0.16024339199066162,
0.2758007049560547,
0.12892001867294312,
0.20151501893997192,
-0.5327681303024292,
0.42016613483428955,
0.31673958897590637,
-0.14160175621509552,
0.4698689877986908,
-0.21616816520690918,
-0.03921164572238922,
-0.9874321222305298,
-0.3308946192264557,
0.2521847188472748,
-0.529952883720398,
-0.8677116632461548,
-0.35488539934158325,
-0.4488208293914795,
-0.09757545590400696,
-0.5308911800384521,
0.6559047698974609,
-0.3081638216972351,
0.32182952761650085,
-0.3406785726547241,
-0.20565852522850037,
0.0069025843404233456,
0.17455580830574036,
0.1284753829240799,
0.16262102127075195,
0.7314848303794861,
-0.4533485174179077,
0.25296252965927124,
0.3502841591835022,
-0.054569780826568604,
0.4561956226825714,
-0.5821574330329895,
0.15805231034755707,
-0.3485794961452484,
0.4297434389591217,
-0.463977187871933,
-0.5929747223854065,
0.41313326358795166,
-0.40675002336502075,
0.4044632613658905,
-0.2005811184644699,
-0.5186617970466614,
-0.3775167763233185,
-0.3067978024482727,
0.14076371490955353,
0.6293665766716003,
-0.2733879089355469,
0.8042940497398376,
0.26910510659217834,
-0.10732175409793854,
-0.07336967438459396,
-1.0079766511917114,
0.10839185863733292,
-0.2414078563451767,
-0.45213180780410767,
0.4326479732990265,
0.07910791039466858,
-0.3051377534866333,
0.15233975648880005,
0.28795018792152405,
-0.06606651842594147,
-0.12649407982826233,
0.4225316047668457,
0.6478177905082703,
-0.36376094818115234,
0.3246546685695648,
-0.13876289129257202,
-0.1589132845401764,
0.04665505886077881,
-0.26948994398117065,
0.30411258339881897,
-0.010180897079408169,
-0.5661951899528503,
-0.7364855408668518,
0.449589341878891,
0.49926936626434326,
0.0759282186627388,
0.6406909227371216,
0.08502870798110962,
-0.7318267226219177,
-0.25359806418418884,
-0.5602855682373047,
-0.4988255202770233,
-0.3113137483596802,
0.1835588812828064,
-0.26142749190330505,
-0.6108770370483398,
0.38103482127189636,
-0.3085266351699829,
-0.1980014592409134,
0.25387299060821533,
0.7890009880065918,
-0.17909739911556244,
1.0833356380462646,
0.39892834424972534,
-0.012662243098020554,
0.1578274965286255,
-0.246891587972641,
-0.014095253311097622,
-0.5733864307403564,
-0.5037437081336975,
-0.35481274127960205,
-0.025986015796661377,
-0.674385130405426,
-0.5126975774765015,
0.8192229866981506,
-0.39745548367500305,
-0.330807626247406,
-0.149943009018898,
-0.34432047605514526,
0.31787317991256714,
0.18659555912017822,
0.5724042057991028,
0.40543392300605774,
0.015733826905488968,
0.001364122610539198,
0.028822708874940872,
-0.825177788734436,
-0.8765717148780823,
1.3301992416381836,
0.5277224779129028,
0.8628746867179871,
-0.01645003817975521,
0.9952011704444885,
0.3518243134021759,
0.31001532077789307,
-1.221606969833374,
0.22625601291656494,
-0.08083958923816681,
-0.47244885563850403,
-0.418776273727417,
-0.27740415930747986,
-1.1673991680145264,
0.01111338660120964,
-0.3619551956653595,
-0.8851112723350525,
-0.024383701384067535,
0.11822333931922913,
-0.7853538393974304,
0.39826297760009766,
-0.5257195830345154,
0.6181015372276306,
-0.42762500047683716,
-0.29020819067955017,
-0.033616796135902405,
-0.875895082950592,
-0.0008253058767877519,
0.0469556488096714,
0.30619940161705017,
-0.1354171633720398,
0.18881244957447052,
0.5066630244255066,
-0.4781656861305237,
1.0617330074310303,
-0.031965743750333786,
0.24045440554618835,
0.3870924711227417,
0.09540051221847534,
0.6737385988235474,
-0.0468018613755703,
-0.3614843189716339,
0.17690396308898926,
0.047379232943058014,
-0.25183403491973877,
-0.3851829767227173,
0.37527135014533997,
-0.6927260160446167,
-0.41945961117744446,
-0.570279061794281,
-0.25955820083618164,
-0.5521039962768555,
0.24685287475585938,
0.16085895895957947,
0.3404799699783325,
-0.4906791150569916,
-0.26837536692619324,
0.5711191892623901,
-0.10979197174310684,
0.05941607430577278,
0.6475353837013245,
-0.1464279592037201,
-0.23319071531295776,
0.6411896347999573,
0.006800235249102116,
0.08461359888315201,
0.5968263149261475,
0.6008202433586121,
0.03309635818004608,
-0.6446571350097656,
-0.3432014584541321,
0.2962595820426941,
-0.4967327415943146,
-0.539179801940918,
-0.554286777973175,
-0.17479586601257324,
-0.3708011209964752,
-0.2787327468395233,
-0.03701347857713699,
0.3039998710155487,
-0.4670833349227905,
-0.15817953646183014,
0.4143412411212921,
0.7749631404876709,
0.20208969712257385,
0.37217068672180176,
-1.0705974102020264,
0.37183669209480286,
0.10283108800649643,
0.09380372613668442,
-0.15685756504535675,
-0.45296353101730347,
-0.309402734041214,
-0.0774066150188446,
-0.3217066824436188,
-1.266395926475525,
0.7020261287689209,
0.06425916403532028,
0.5647980570793152,
0.6667100191116333,
0.1480655074119568,
0.3239341080188751,
-0.864280641078949,
0.582129716873169,
0.4676706790924072,
-0.4469465911388397,
0.9166449308395386,
-0.3466210961341858,
0.12796209752559662,
0.4710424542427063,
0.4196261763572693,
-0.3184599280357361,
-0.006925542838871479,
-0.5267271995544434,
-0.41518598794937134,
0.6413953304290771,
-0.21970169246196747,
-0.07155332714319229,
-0.19292452931404114,
0.2105855643749237,
0.18010079860687256,
-0.22655950486660004,
-0.28193774819374084,
-0.29170989990234375,
0.1104230135679245,
-0.19240710139274597,
-0.0730893686413765,
-0.34981101751327515,
-0.18500885367393494,
-0.017059465870261192,
0.5386204719543457,
-0.39314839243888855,
0.25021642446517944,
0.5156804323196411,
0.012330836616456509,
-0.7179492712020874,
0.6625383496284485,
0.1790342479944229,
0.3844963014125824,
-0.3591175377368927,
0.05233437195420265,
0.4140746593475342,
-0.13720938563346863,
0.026414109393954277,
0.10373495519161224,
-0.2210008203983307,
0.19174563884735107,
0.4612298309803009,
0.8541619181632996,
0.03520893305540085,
-0.8504562973976135,
0.6201715469360352,
0.20924629271030426,
-0.07154431939125061,
-0.3367575705051422,
-0.1383797824382782,
-0.05861244723200798,
0.44944047927856445,
0.2181231677532196,
-0.2570660412311554,
0.3136497735977173,
-0.551288366317749,
0.25586971640586853,
0.2830439805984497,
-0.5297037959098816,
-0.4522877633571625,
0.6703364849090576,
0.16111049056053162,
-0.29914426803588867,
0.4386497735977173,
-0.010660159401595592,
-0.2353174090385437,
0.672427237033844,
0.7893163561820984,
0.7177102565765381,
-0.363288551568985,
0.45702001452445984,
0.2071964293718338,
0.19753128290176392,
-0.1419994980096817,
0.2435186803340912,
0.44907277822494507,
-0.7740110754966736,
-0.5548396110534668,
-0.30836188793182373,
-0.835171639919281,
0.17287155985832214,
-0.5349478125572205,
0.5371394753456116,
-0.3825564682483673,
-0.3764934539794922,
0.2761766016483307,
0.028276748955249786,
-0.8053818941116333,
0.2656998634338379,
0.621928870677948,
0.5669403076171875,
-0.91895592212677,
0.8586152195930481,
0.906352698802948,
-0.500109851360321,
-0.8979981541633606,
0.23746974766254425,
0.41277074813842773,
-0.7255231142044067,
0.5219642519950867,
0.22116614878177643,
-0.08067990094423294,
-0.3105117976665497,
-0.3895796835422516,
-0.361728310585022,
1.099647045135498,
0.48201361298561096,
-0.8616670966148376,
-0.22100047767162323,
0.24591003358364105,
0.6495342254638672,
-0.49722039699554443,
0.18886153399944305,
0.37471047043800354,
0.34761545062065125,
0.3409234881401062,
-0.90058833360672,
0.052789852023124695,
0.07602731138467789,
-0.2574946880340576,
0.011040560901165009,
-0.3709036111831665,
0.6658139228820801,
-0.8412236571311951,
-0.052029602229595184,
-0.08163980394601822,
0.46019047498703003,
0.40563949942588806,
0.9080799221992493,
0.09726166725158691,
0.3797056972980499,
1.0013326406478882,
0.24990731477737427,
1.5075150728225708,
-0.17546124756336212,
0.22281907498836517,
1.0029528141021729,
-0.8344653248786926,
0.9300826787948608,
0.30403196811676025,
-0.24519991874694824,
0.6160030364990234,
0.33578845858573914,
0.09534329921007156,
0.3465656340122223,
0.10536134988069534,
-0.46334782242774963,
-0.5012125968933105,
-0.43178585171699524,
-0.16578325629234314,
0.549114465713501,
0.4239075481891632,
-0.3516158163547516,
-0.17466719448566437,
0.13273771107196808,
0.08589379489421844,
0.0009474109392613173,
-0.3443049490451813,
1.0453307628631592,
0.2790251672267914,
-0.36622244119644165,
0.38291341066360474,
-0.017441658303141594,
0.43690094351768494,
-0.44043728709220886,
-0.3139588534832001,
0.10598961263895035,
0.16318891942501068,
-0.3301836848258972,
-0.5685669183731079,
0.10918702930212021,
0.07713284343481064,
-0.2537265717983246,
-0.12615817785263062,
1.0118626356124878,
-0.24989698827266693,
-0.5925842523574829,
0.21923691034317017,
0.8984692692756653,
0.3459981381893158,
-0.002598460065200925,
-0.5804863572120667,
-0.24962879717350006,
-0.24625790119171143,
-0.09956678748130798,
0.38778722286224365,
0.4888809323310852,
-0.052581943571567535,
0.7604249715805054,
0.5100017189979553,
0.4607069194316864,
-0.45123112201690674,
0.13806821405887604,
0.6930249333381653,
-0.693199634552002,
-0.2996884882450104,
-0.9667837023735046,
0.3576210141181946,
0.3238264322280884,
0.08159000426530838,
0.26931899785995483,
0.3548296093940735,
0.3803761899471283,
-0.04628346487879753,
1.023690104484558,
0.599747896194458,
0.8608896136283875,
-0.6081631779670715,
0.4949371814727783,
-0.4372301995754242,
0.21233908832073212,
0.010073935613036156,
-0.19452929496765137,
-0.49148645997047424,
0.3426433503627777,
-0.41266950964927673,
-0.06717640161514282,
0.7994023561477661,
0.5703479051589966,
0.32399556040763855,
-0.377753347158432,
0.6596993803977966,
0.37221652269363403,
0.3067106306552887,
0.7768235206604004,
0.6861445903778076,
-0.09630987793207169,
0.2727081775665283,
-0.2399364411830902,
-0.11476957052946091,
-0.7008640170097351,
-0.7853153347969055,
-0.9842538833618164,
-0.01615162380039692,
-0.5485182404518127,
-0.46355167031288147,
0.3415403664112091,
1.3026847839355469,
0.5110829472541809,
-0.862221360206604,
0.1289239376783371,
0.18666993081569672,
0.08175316452980042,
0.021389756351709366,
-0.1393401175737381,
0.4435290992259979,
-0.020944811403751373,
-0.4506087601184845,
0.5980737209320068,
0.4225490093231201,
0.09244909137487411,
-0.0662914514541626,
-0.23187367618083954,
0.2538931369781494,
0.0713970959186554,
0.699539065361023,
0.31371134519577026,
-0.9113343358039856,
-0.03430907428264618,
0.22081086039543152,
-0.37740179896354675,
0.22422254085540771,
0.5948036313056946,
-1.0861561298370361,
0.49045097827911377,
0.2979108691215515,
0.6618220806121826,
0.403667151927948,
0.06246098130941391,
0.2029382884502411,
-0.24512933194637299,
-0.2607441246509552,
0.7236533761024475,
0.41701701283454895,
0.35728999972343445,
-0.6065237522125244,
0.10698406398296356,
-0.030064722523093224,
-0.4026104509830475,
-0.671562135219574,
0.18264847993850708,
-1.0886199474334717,
-0.2457321435213089,
1.4806151390075684,
-0.07328323274850845,
-0.3107806146144867,
-0.3148873746395111,
-0.12840355932712555,
0.19876138865947723,
-0.5455252528190613,
0.7522543668746948,
0.06058830767869949,
-0.675396203994751,
-0.07020840048789978,
-0.7078003287315369,
0.24872668087482452,
0.19086164236068726,
-1.1883646249771118,
-0.23577824234962463,
0.702890157699585,
0.16975367069244385,
-0.15545324981212616,
0.9447842836380005,
-0.066677026450634,
0.32450103759765625,
-0.23012007772922516,
0.07573205232620239,
-0.08367986977100372,
-0.4122238755226135,
-0.361570805311203,
-0.01798924058675766,
0.331417441368103,
-0.19953623414039612
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.12968v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.12968v1
|
LLMLingua-2: Data Distillation for Efficient and Faithful Task-Agnostic Prompt Compression
| 2024-03-19T17:59:56 | 2024-03-19T17:59:56 |
Zhuoshi Pan, Qianhui Wu, Huiqiang Jiang, Menglin Xia, Xufang Luo, Jue Zhang, Qingwei Lin, Victor Rühle, Yuqing Yang, Chin-Yew Lin, H. Vicky Zhao, Lili Qiu, Dongmei Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
This paper focuses on task-agnostic prompt compression for better
generalizability and efficiency. Considering the redundancy in natural
language, existing approaches compress prompts by removing tokens or lexical
units according to their information entropy obtained from a causal language
model such as LLaMa-7B. The challenge is that information entropy may be a
suboptimal compression metric: (i) it only leverages unidirectional context and
may fail to capture all essential information needed for prompt compression;
(ii) it is not aligned with the prompt compression objective.
To address these issues, we propose a data distillation procedure to derive
knowledge from an LLM to compress prompts without losing crucial information,
and meantime, introduce an extractive text compression dataset. We formulate
prompt compression as a token classification problem to guarantee the
faithfulness of the compressed prompt to the original one, and use a
Transformer encoder as the base architecture to capture all essential
information for prompt compression from the full bidirectional context. Our
approach leads to lower latency by explicitly learning the compression
objective with smaller models such as XLM-RoBERTa-large and mBERT.
We evaluate our method on both in-domain and out-of-domain datasets,
including MeetingBank, LongBench, ZeroScrolls, GSM8K, and BBH. Despite its
small size, our model shows significant performance gains over strong baselines
and demonstrates robust generalization ability across different LLMs.
Additionally, our model is 3x-6x faster than existing prompt compression
methods, while accelerating the end-to-end latency by 1.6x-2.9x with
compression ratios of 2x-5x.
|
[
-0.17579062283039093,
-0.6846457123756409,
0.5730682611465454,
0.2855444550514221,
-0.5506022572517395,
0.03606865555047989,
-0.2655796706676483,
-0.28090059757232666,
0.04681466147303581,
-0.004561685491353273,
-0.7114784717559814,
-0.30494171380996704,
-0.8987846374511719,
0.4152883291244507,
-0.26601943373680115,
0.8005687594413757,
0.10494239628314972,
-0.17422400414943695,
-0.26570260524749756,
0.20452599227428436,
-0.8506473898887634,
-0.4868922829627991,
-0.8055416941642761,
-0.2893401086330414,
0.478082537651062,
0.3847006857395172,
0.3580061197280884,
0.5515152812004089,
0.25488951802253723,
0.31854763627052307,
-0.27016183733940125,
0.3031185567378998,
-0.5999135375022888,
0.44759559631347656,
0.01682441309094429,
-0.55255126953125,
-0.05446726083755493,
0.018331492319703102,
0.42420724034309387,
0.3780655860900879,
-0.35694772005081177,
0.41624191403388977,
0.37836018204689026,
0.6358743906021118,
-0.4053734838962555,
0.33877336978912354,
-0.6080028414726257,
0.01767224445939064,
-0.2938334345817566,
-0.3578261435031891,
-0.5013824105262756,
-0.40477240085601807,
-0.2757367193698883,
-0.6118100881576538,
0.24807041883468628,
0.3992740511894226,
0.7765606641769409,
0.9486979842185974,
-0.29454928636550903,
-0.38205766677856445,
-0.6301448941230774,
0.689278781414032,
-0.5742451548576355,
0.13159407675266266,
0.5286868214607239,
0.5076298117637634,
-0.1452850103378296,
-0.7804359197616577,
-0.6688292622566223,
0.04773948714137077,
-0.01748819276690483,
0.041056275367736816,
-0.6313925981521606,
0.019306788221001625,
0.4391179084777832,
0.36258503794670105,
-0.6390326619148254,
0.31562894582748413,
-0.45736533403396606,
-0.2920670807361603,
0.23496241867542267,
0.2557717263698578,
0.09846951812505722,
-0.22448399662971497,
-0.4432770609855652,
-0.03860614076256752,
-0.7549622654914856,
0.02288019470870495,
0.45983126759529114,
0.23688989877700806,
-0.08746219426393509,
0.3738960027694702,
-0.2217155545949936,
0.7070972919464111,
0.3073957562446594,
-0.44574981927871704,
0.13932770490646362,
-0.3548007607460022,
-0.20995762944221497,
0.10762128233909607,
0.7062116861343384,
0.33310452103614807,
-0.17226269841194153,
-0.2657129466533661,
-0.21734996140003204,
0.10647588968276978,
0.02723086066544056,
-0.9608827829360962,
-0.11210960149765015,
0.33855417370796204,
-0.42715948820114136,
-0.19980359077453613,
0.05087894946336746,
-0.6458263993263245,
-0.49872297048568726,
-0.6535738706588745,
0.17381341755390167,
-0.14704161882400513,
0.0817505270242691,
0.11140849441289902,
-0.29936230182647705,
-0.03854804486036301,
0.5183984637260437,
-0.9073688387870789,
0.11513403803110123,
0.6451933979988098,
1.036143183708191,
-0.31383436918258667,
-0.03200053051114082,
-0.7449790239334106,
-0.10880275815725327,
0.053915247321128845,
0.7882876396179199,
-0.3643806576728821,
-0.36752042174339294,
-0.14594188332557678,
0.0598832406103611,
0.19169852137565613,
-0.643791675567627,
0.834602415561676,
-0.3764089345932007,
0.2359519749879837,
-0.3279937505722046,
-0.45818954706192017,
-0.11017906665802002,
0.15418444573879242,
-0.8261032104492188,
1.0751383304595947,
0.09244728088378906,
-0.6165872812271118,
0.25463736057281494,
-0.23899467289447784,
-0.28064024448394775,
0.000848886207677424,
-0.12629857659339905,
-0.09142595529556274,
0.252288281917572,
0.26689374446868896,
0.5526508688926697,
-0.9990622401237488,
0.6940092444419861,
0.11247893422842026,
-0.43620380759239197,
0.025016911327838898,
-0.9219398498535156,
0.7943810820579529,
0.4141794443130493,
-0.14990366995334625,
-0.2210794985294342,
-0.7641273736953735,
-0.3682900667190552,
0.008664700202643871,
-0.5636293888092041,
-0.2440738081932068,
-0.4586055874824524,
-0.30666571855545044,
0.1159658133983612,
0.4251735806465149,
-0.6046404242515564,
0.5843093395233154,
-0.10047817975282669,
0.3223062753677368,
0.8023717403411865,
0.041432902216911316,
0.41577765345573425,
-0.2811081111431122,
0.5219308733940125,
0.11223189532756805,
0.2924933433532715,
-0.23402084410190582,
-0.5633843541145325,
-0.5253732204437256,
-0.3188161253929138,
0.33590179681777954,
0.7521745562553406,
-1.1436131000518799,
0.5060834884643555,
-0.47572749853134155,
-0.4509444534778595,
-0.5345855951309204,
0.07458698749542236,
0.19438186287879944,
0.9821405410766602,
0.5088452100753784,
0.19926413893699646,
-0.5028336644172668,
-0.6686089634895325,
0.0601954311132431,
-0.35165899991989136,
-0.3209552466869354,
0.20160305500030518,
0.011750446632504463,
-0.1060226708650589,
0.7519728541374207,
-0.6145719885826111,
-0.14809326827526093,
-0.22220508754253387,
0.5132322311401367,
0.8156307339668274,
0.3896472156047821,
0.5551684498786926,
-0.6256323456764221,
-0.4526176154613495,
-0.29202643036842346,
-0.6840145587921143,
-0.6850163340568542,
-0.20133157074451447,
0.07558739930391312,
0.01244110893458128,
0.2453809231519699,
-0.8501811623573303,
0.4026710093021393,
0.44274505972862244,
-0.40736308693885803,
0.4866369068622589,
-0.2967972457408905,
0.29565364122390747,
-1.1681963205337524,
0.07692401856184006,
-0.16148778796195984,
-0.12041108310222626,
-0.7894837260246277,
-0.2831699550151825,
0.119412362575531,
0.013366603292524815,
-0.4024267792701721,
0.5159164071083069,
-0.5580862164497375,
0.35683295130729675,
-0.4931504726409912,
-0.10893534868955612,
0.22606490552425385,
0.6465340256690979,
-0.14506521821022034,
0.8902021646499634,
0.5807756185531616,
-0.7753545045852661,
0.6216314435005188,
0.3001309633255005,
-0.21965330839157104,
0.5362346172332764,
-0.7966039776802063,
0.24843788146972656,
-0.5651277303695679,
0.20497164130210876,
-0.9531328082084656,
0.031819898635149,
0.41414040327072144,
-0.4438726603984833,
0.4804837703704834,
-0.20208528637886047,
-0.7181395888328552,
-0.2659062445163727,
-0.24655327200889587,
0.376164972782135,
0.8436014652252197,
-0.8040726184844971,
0.4517119526863098,
0.1001053899526596,
-0.25067925453186035,
-0.6921523213386536,
-0.7669819593429565,
0.23257580399513245,
-0.5498071312904358,
-0.39108166098594666,
0.5344867706298828,
-0.1957126408815384,
-0.133770152926445,
-0.2344258427619934,
-0.14790715277194977,
0.015491160564124584,
0.07493046671152115,
0.3185974955558777,
0.4512885808944702,
0.26033714413642883,
0.11772126704454422,
0.3222007751464844,
-0.2841763496398926,
-0.043898794800043106,
-0.3765033483505249,
0.5479292273521423,
0.4345763921737671,
-0.17179308831691742,
-0.5758917927742004,
0.3521764278411865,
0.30617082118988037,
0.4277164340019226,
0.5367568135261536,
0.53939288854599,
-0.3685894310474396,
-0.01722915843129158,
-0.5626187920570374,
-0.10883352905511856,
-0.502886176109314,
-0.12571260333061218,
-0.3064533770084381,
-0.8786336779594421,
0.5125700235366821,
-0.27049732208251953,
0.1411765068769455,
0.29685088992118835,
0.3783745765686035,
0.23110194504261017,
0.44187071919441223,
0.5302819013595581,
-0.2903929054737091,
0.3173595070838928,
-0.057440951466560364,
0.03230847045779228,
-0.6397615671157837,
-0.3396252691745758,
-0.7635148763656616,
-0.37244927883148193,
-0.020236786454916,
-0.6197365522384644,
0.33630046248435974,
0.2566010057926178,
-0.02341318689286709,
0.43595200777053833,
-0.5768588781356812,
0.4122176170349121,
0.49407318234443665,
-0.0011712579289451241,
0.2041114717721939,
0.051405418664216995,
0.2263377606868744,
0.13886871933937073,
-0.720098078250885,
-0.4132840633392334,
0.8173360824584961,
0.20086108148097992,
0.8502262830734253,
0.2655961513519287,
0.7093358039855957,
0.569105327129364,
-0.0006934962584637105,
-0.7740046977996826,
0.34220507740974426,
0.015889178961515427,
-0.047524016350507736,
-0.15937440097332,
-0.4961472451686859,
-1.0777987241744995,
-0.11518559604883194,
0.032608479261398315,
-0.7078011631965637,
0.4756462275981903,
0.1317584067583084,
-0.5888511538505554,
0.09589319676160812,
-0.5827470421791077,
0.30769097805023193,
0.19553419947624207,
-0.22595146298408508,
0.12949496507644653,
-0.7816674113273621,
0.3189941644668579,
-0.21284374594688416,
0.03874608874320984,
-0.2994021475315094,
-0.15617750585079193,
0.7016916275024414,
-0.6708394885063171,
0.9113017916679382,
-0.4448704421520233,
-0.23085980117321014,
0.3772820830345154,
-0.09233494102954865,
0.7733069658279419,
0.12466146796941757,
-0.07994917780160904,
0.38757315278053284,
-0.1423899084329605,
-0.15319278836250305,
-1.0165756940841675,
0.37771788239479065,
-0.4974655508995056,
-0.7092911601066589,
-0.18915550410747528,
-0.26225316524505615,
0.09986355155706406,
-0.09190374612808228,
0.5193331241607666,
0.5931138396263123,
0.11358658969402313,
-0.12107966095209122,
0.665553867816925,
-0.003707540687173605,
0.5955601334571838,
0.3223561644554138,
0.16969171166419983,
-0.4105333685874939,
0.7667590975761414,
-0.007794458884745836,
-0.11617542058229446,
0.5465959906578064,
0.1729901283979416,
-0.49085989594459534,
-0.5599779486656189,
-0.5734037756919861,
0.008384757675230503,
-0.8396019339561462,
-0.84832763671875,
-0.4328560531139374,
0.0618898905813694,
-0.5198974013328552,
0.09623673558235168,
-0.09250809252262115,
-0.6268216967582703,
-0.8090032339096069,
-0.046650998294353485,
0.4917919933795929,
0.6164317727088928,
-0.22790607810020447,
0.49380189180374146,
-0.9080182313919067,
0.47070595622062683,
0.13728861510753632,
-0.2005668729543686,
-0.02781960740685463,
-0.8927360773086548,
-0.08419463783502579,
-0.07535248249769211,
-0.020649731159210205,
-0.994800329208374,
0.48532891273498535,
0.29265353083610535,
0.6252351403236389,
0.5583615303039551,
0.46842706203460693,
0.7823906540870667,
-0.5472308993339539,
1.0351471900939941,
0.33934399485588074,
-0.8273147344589233,
0.5290056467056274,
0.20478765666484833,
0.45183831453323364,
0.6825553178787231,
0.4553017318248749,
-0.4831430912017822,
-0.15157967805862427,
-0.31783026456832886,
-0.806339681148529,
0.5925558805465698,
0.19322171807289124,
-0.041841451078653336,
-0.21986839175224304,
0.6757698655128479,
0.543877363204956,
0.3155480921268463,
-0.4126822352409363,
-0.43836066126823425,
-0.14129452407360077,
-0.4177463948726654,
-0.03356337174773216,
-0.5286781191825867,
-0.07234122604131699,
-0.13213330507278442,
0.49184873700141907,
-0.12976230680942535,
0.43141666054725647,
0.32032254338264465,
-0.16023583710193634,
0.35082533955574036,
0.2773801386356354,
0.43082281947135925,
0.18272942304611206,
0.1779688596725464,
0.45795318484306335,
0.11993003636598587,
-0.6922459006309509,
0.5945412516593933,
0.20942950248718262,
-0.13790996372699738,
0.16898925602436066,
0.2716504633426666,
0.9508777260780334,
-0.09992285072803497,
-0.42527779936790466,
0.5047714710235596,
-0.33610227704048157,
0.04150020331144333,
-0.04182133451104164,
-0.09524554759263992,
-0.3563635051250458,
0.40341755747795105,
0.5533220171928406,
0.018269600346684456,
0.48673754930496216,
-0.2017974853515625,
-0.07961104065179825,
0.07910674810409546,
-0.03312169387936592,
-0.42807960510253906,
0.65556800365448,
0.14033344388008118,
-0.00017053523333743215,
0.6382246613502502,
-0.45117291808128357,
-0.13516125082969666,
0.3898603618144989,
0.5127280950546265,
1.0462232828140259,
-0.23656147718429565,
-0.03070083074271679,
0.5772324204444885,
0.26914283633232117,
-0.2551485300064087,
0.22652243077754974,
-0.5285559296607971,
-0.48221877217292786,
-0.4463179111480713,
-0.6671069264411926,
-0.15459726750850677,
-0.14346937835216522,
-0.689800500869751,
0.3226962387561798,
-0.2633027136325836,
-0.33779773116111755,
-0.3561389744281769,
-0.11899875104427338,
-0.6589890718460083,
-0.07008739560842514,
0.0904579758644104,
1.0476675033569336,
-0.6637871265411377,
0.7508920431137085,
0.175561785697937,
-0.11525118350982666,
-0.7841975688934326,
-0.1231558546423912,
0.15195070207118988,
-0.7306491136550903,
0.6432613730430603,
0.26255741715431213,
0.021794233471155167,
-0.09151195734739304,
-0.5529307126998901,
-0.8396883010864258,
1.5243231058120728,
0.6645243167877197,
-0.7498266100883484,
-0.09280230849981308,
0.10483034700155258,
0.2522880434989929,
-0.043658286333084106,
0.19888637959957123,
0.656216025352478,
0.5275841355323792,
0.43962815403938293,
-0.9082207083702087,
0.3452233672142029,
-0.3683277368545532,
0.033225297927856445,
0.00020122528076171875,
-0.47009041905403137,
0.7206807136535645,
-0.03222767636179924,
-0.6334697604179382,
0.0858568400144577,
0.7705749869346619,
0.20341385900974274,
0.19811514019966125,
0.3492184579372406,
0.533161461353302,
1.2956068515777588,
-0.16310842335224152,
0.7929093241691589,
-0.478483647108078,
0.11048002541065216,
1.0968860387802124,
-0.07600916922092438,
0.4268293082714081,
0.7385416030883789,
-0.1939096301794052,
0.2969949245452881,
0.7287654280662537,
0.0959291085600853,
0.7086495757102966,
0.1582198441028595,
-0.39690500497817993,
0.07057800889015198,
-0.36172476410865784,
-0.24207934737205505,
0.09810052812099457,
0.08848658949136734,
-0.07494846731424332,
-0.272527277469635,
0.0956903025507927,
0.1689370572566986,
-0.28168171644210815,
-0.18940982222557068,
0.8751987814903259,
0.054172709584236145,
-0.7876836061477661,
0.8587782979011536,
0.004420036915689707,
0.8394632339477539,
-0.5436726212501526,
-0.014637839049100876,
-0.343633234500885,
-0.48692086338996887,
-0.08000651001930237,
-0.6123749017715454,
0.3461061418056488,
0.28423088788986206,
-0.23096343874931335,
-0.4133336842060089,
0.8509500622749329,
-0.4270629584789276,
-0.1515132635831833,
-0.10389821231365204,
0.5335367321968079,
0.4298701584339142,
-0.13312363624572754,
-0.35839712619781494,
0.23414555191993713,
0.01452579628676176,
-0.21927905082702637,
0.06535310298204422,
0.6775120496749878,
0.33005768060684204,
0.5705521106719971,
0.647795557975769,
0.07396972924470901,
-0.07722783088684082,
0.08271507173776627,
1.1383564472198486,
-0.5224331021308899,
-0.5335196256637573,
-1.096952199935913,
0.41425085067749023,
-0.17060433328151703,
-0.21121840178966522,
0.5996988415718079,
0.40772563219070435,
0.21624211966991425,
0.008126333355903625,
0.7062970995903015,
-0.10641353577375412,
0.20255962014198303,
-0.805688738822937,
0.369955837726593,
-0.2717185616493225,
0.4147615134716034,
0.1451396942138672,
-0.8742167949676514,
-0.1953975260257721,
0.1887655407190323,
0.13761594891548157,
-0.4300721287727356,
0.5333583354949951,
0.632047712802887,
0.16723185777664185,
-0.08487782627344131,
0.2883957326412201,
-0.08584414422512054,
0.2355826497077942,
0.7818092107772827,
0.8318015336990356,
-0.37528544664382935,
0.4237021207809448,
-0.09062710404396057,
-0.391954630613327,
0.022436609491705894,
-1.009194254875183,
-0.8155239820480347,
-0.7460328936576843,
-0.2845607399940491,
-0.10058938711881638,
-0.1516963094472885,
1.0108654499053955,
0.4566550850868225,
-0.41940170526504517,
0.1608591228723526,
-0.10935372859239578,
0.1462784707546234,
-0.05889425799250603,
-0.17982742190361023,
0.2082873433828354,
-0.3481484651565552,
-0.9170584082603455,
0.5871514081954956,
0.2951884865760803,
0.47056928277015686,
-0.24251337349414825,
-0.11460058391094208,
0.3323269188404083,
0.1324678212404251,
0.4766429364681244,
0.13503199815750122,
-0.5984420776367188,
0.09236885607242584,
-0.11805681139230728,
0.08457335829734802,
0.12821421027183533,
0.7816094756126404,
-0.9498139023780823,
0.09750960767269135,
0.6427303552627563,
0.5496163964271545,
0.23890389502048492,
0.2133471667766571,
0.43080589175224304,
-1.069631576538086,
0.4954681098461151,
0.06811601668596268,
0.5629245638847351,
0.32283034920692444,
-0.7607643604278564,
0.5132381319999695,
0.2779657542705536,
-0.5971918702125549,
-0.8212518692016602,
0.17079313099384308,
-1.0556540489196777,
-0.2893255054950714,
1.3787611722946167,
-0.30348214507102966,
-0.36115339398384094,
-0.18740636110305786,
-0.47566062211990356,
0.3978143334388733,
-0.6751989126205444,
0.8401781320571899,
0.5517512559890747,
-0.15214134752750397,
-0.09163405746221542,
-0.2658750116825104,
0.6000815629959106,
0.04294538497924805,
-0.8362980484962463,
0.2705783545970917,
0.6843512654304504,
-0.12103015929460526,
0.12886664271354675,
0.6703410744667053,
0.09585075825452805,
0.09147322177886963,
0.15763430297374725,
-0.059706464409828186,
-0.407749742269516,
-0.5111457109451294,
-0.6999480724334717,
0.2604843080043793,
-0.07735181599855423,
-0.08875159174203873
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.12964v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.12964v1
|
Negative Yields Positive: Unified Dual-Path Adapter for Vision-Language Models
| 2024-03-19T17:59:39 | 2024-03-19T17:59:39 |
Ce Zhang, Simon Stepputtis, Katia Sycara, Yaqi Xie
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Recently, large-scale pre-trained Vision-Language Models (VLMs) have
demonstrated great potential in learning open-world visual representations, and
exhibit remarkable performance across a wide range of downstream tasks through
efficient fine-tuning. In this work, we innovatively introduce the concept of
dual learning into fine-tuning VLMs, i.e., we not only learn what an image is,
but also what an image isn't. Building on this concept, we introduce a novel
DualAdapter approach to enable dual-path adaptation of VLMs from both positive
and negative perspectives with only limited annotated samples. In the inference
stage, our DualAdapter performs unified predictions by simultaneously
conducting complementary positive selection and negative exclusion across
target classes, thereby enhancing the overall recognition accuracy of VLMs in
downstream tasks. Our extensive experimental results across 15 datasets
validate that the proposed DualAdapter outperforms existing state-of-the-art
methods on both few-shot learning and domain generalization tasks while
achieving competitive computational efficiency. Code is available at
https://github.com/zhangce01/DualAdapter.
|
[
-0.515030026435852,
-0.3447888195514679,
0.2541225254535675,
-0.35369282960891724,
-0.680372953414917,
-0.14307446777820587,
-0.16128186881542206,
-0.7049343585968018,
0.0303821861743927,
0.556231677532196,
-0.6128812432289124,
-0.25657209753990173,
-0.4559629559516907,
-0.2955416142940521,
-0.034401267766952515,
0.90382981300354,
-0.011815252713859081,
0.2768501937389374,
-0.007141985464841127,
-0.42230314016342163,
-0.8044233322143555,
-0.1865077167749405,
-0.5922561883926392,
-0.34184616804122925,
0.8479999303817749,
0.2899321913719177,
0.47753822803497314,
0.33339738845825195,
0.44647571444511414,
0.18794721364974976,
0.4738351106643677,
-0.0068025654181838036,
-0.4477523863315582,
0.04513723403215408,
-0.5172352194786072,
-0.27275988459587097,
0.010675495490431786,
-0.06964820623397827,
0.603232741355896,
0.31772997975349426,
0.16825051605701447,
0.41985395550727844,
0.05602490156888962,
0.7091305255889893,
-0.8318585157394409,
-0.07947760075330734,
-0.9379994869232178,
0.08232053369283676,
-0.21096451580524445,
-0.2609061598777771,
-0.2938234210014343,
-0.0078122299164533615,
0.011468048207461834,
-0.7018260955810547,
0.15888755023479462,
-0.2598835825920105,
0.802075982093811,
0.4695367217063904,
-0.6936091184616089,
0.16630062460899353,
-0.818773090839386,
0.9242773056030273,
-0.3871574103832245,
0.4296565651893616,
-0.161977156996727,
0.7952788472175598,
0.2147645503282547,
-0.3840537369251251,
-0.5080562233924866,
-0.02243671379983425,
0.05915304273366928,
0.28288018703460693,
0.0796491876244545,
0.21145635843276978,
-0.010047060437500477,
0.31818580627441406,
-0.387419730424881,
0.31791335344314575,
-0.3159419596195221,
-0.33578044176101685,
0.6908797025680542,
0.018483014777302742,
0.357533723115921,
0.14261674880981445,
-0.442239373922348,
-0.12380364537239075,
-0.5423092842102051,
0.04981298744678497,
0.22789525985717773,
0.571435272693634,
-0.045074235647916794,
0.5255736708641052,
-0.07041677087545395,
0.9871343374252319,
-0.15970419347286224,
0.06017463654279709,
0.08185181021690369,
-0.41274967789649963,
-0.30937543511390686,
-0.3257928192615509,
0.35251614451408386,
0.5504292249679565,
0.24101491272449493,
-0.20427465438842773,
-0.18457095324993134,
0.7054248452186584,
0.26126283407211304,
-0.8704985976219177,
-0.3590662479400635,
-0.04273486137390137,
-0.1275431513786316,
-0.26745250821113586,
-0.015077086165547371,
-1.0348094701766968,
-0.8822804093360901,
-0.7040268778800964,
0.9882183074951172,
-0.046196646988391876,
-0.4107087254524231,
0.09183461964130402,
-0.5072664022445679,
0.5382048487663269,
0.6786741614341736,
-0.5579925179481506,
0.1740613579750061,
0.4261661767959595,
0.6149927973747253,
0.09199388325214386,
-0.4041871130466461,
-0.9688671827316284,
-0.08696866780519485,
-0.3483136296272278,
0.7828940749168396,
-0.4817543029785156,
0.033074572682380676,
-0.10342027992010117,
-0.19941383600234985,
0.00017428200226277113,
-0.4170374274253845,
0.5140960812568665,
-0.5282852053642273,
0.21774064004421234,
-0.22027987241744995,
-0.1149851530790329,
-0.37183430790901184,
-0.003789147362112999,
-0.3260756731033325,
0.6186563968658447,
-0.06094611436128616,
-0.5609658360481262,
0.8353497385978699,
-0.5252283811569214,
-0.6482529044151306,
0.22695747017860413,
-0.3670094907283783,
-0.4751833975315094,
0.35311320424079895,
-0.03767377510666847,
0.30755507946014404,
-0.24114088714122772,
0.0656285211443901,
-0.5046893954277039,
-0.4431747794151306,
-0.32921308279037476,
-0.427195280790329,
0.8044859766960144,
-0.15572120249271393,
-0.3246498703956604,
0.48131775856018066,
-0.9283565282821655,
-0.07686202228069305,
0.4026397466659546,
-0.0669393539428711,
-0.6096523404121399,
0.027667459100484848,
0.1877812147140503,
0.7466310858726501,
0.027377117425203323,
-0.7270379662513733,
0.3751484453678131,
-0.15205112099647522,
0.1047796905040741,
0.9907712340354919,
-0.30246323347091675,
0.5155938863754272,
-0.009999868459999561,
0.29296571016311646,
0.056247528642416,
0.040812719613313675,
0.014937818050384521,
-0.4348001778125763,
-1.0520888566970825,
-0.17066293954849243,
0.0005894871428608894,
0.5391451120376587,
-1.0785351991653442,
0.271918922662735,
-0.10662324726581573,
-0.44151294231414795,
-0.641966700553894,
0.18106156587600708,
0.5068408250808716,
0.7031669020652771,
0.5592072606086731,
-0.5737900137901306,
-0.7600598335266113,
-0.6023242473602295,
-0.448956698179245,
0.023330368101596832,
-0.07265617698431015,
0.47883808612823486,
0.3446556031703949,
-0.27381232380867004,
0.5636259317398071,
-0.4317089915275574,
-0.5160114169120789,
-0.2190072238445282,
-0.09359966218471527,
0.2753540277481079,
0.1538093537092209,
0.5877039432525635,
-1.0722488164901733,
-0.6773871779441833,
0.02243516966700554,
-0.8181951642036438,
0.0416637659072876,
-0.1945224404335022,
-0.26642045378685,
0.18587443232536316,
0.17428536713123322,
-0.15454554557800293,
0.555492103099823,
0.7797512412071228,
-0.7703837156295776,
0.4014090597629547,
-0.3576276898384094,
-0.22646015882492065,
-0.8063997030258179,
-0.16280436515808105,
0.30624085664749146,
-0.27920520305633545,
-0.6557138562202454,
0.14698685705661774,
0.1796150952577591,
0.046836674213409424,
-0.41749516129493713,
0.6224400997161865,
-0.3944980502128601,
-0.04680277407169342,
-0.3840624690055847,
-0.16832736134529114,
-0.038216859102249146,
0.585195779800415,
0.4002411365509033,
0.6732256412506104,
1.054461121559143,
-0.6066327095031738,
0.16109144687652588,
0.06527865678071976,
-0.15387675166130066,
0.567832887172699,
-0.4282011389732361,
-0.0389530323445797,
-0.3634288012981415,
0.09697248041629791,
-0.9214463233947754,
-0.12051662802696228,
0.20789304375648499,
-0.056050702929496765,
0.4401525557041168,
-0.3622210621833801,
-0.015442484058439732,
-0.6713017225265503,
-0.5012129545211792,
0.25246793031692505,
0.7478585839271545,
-0.8910626173019409,
0.5370864272117615,
0.42104536294937134,
0.29972895979881287,
-0.45590895414352417,
-0.7202379703521729,
0.19593264162540436,
-0.046598464250564575,
-0.35230153799057007,
-0.02543022856116295,
-0.20352871716022491,
0.08722259104251862,
-0.28893738985061646,
-0.2013026475906372,
0.12787342071533203,
0.21129238605499268,
0.49596643447875977,
0.5527772307395935,
-0.3599764108657837,
0.13689805567264557,
-0.023215247318148613,
-0.44491949677467346,
-0.3763382136821747,
-0.7182664275169373,
0.3293488621711731,
-0.1361512541770935,
-0.4241422414779663,
-0.5824240446090698,
-0.03470868244767189,
0.6728741526603699,
-0.434790700674057,
0.7227281928062439,
0.7156974673271179,
-0.22108495235443115,
-0.1789107769727707,
-0.31684282422065735,
-0.18037401139736176,
-0.46083083748817444,
0.45067542791366577,
-0.4274185299873352,
-0.5788791179656982,
0.08438245952129364,
-0.024558402597904205,
0.04184259474277496,
0.4231732189655304,
0.3839130103588104,
0.07809001952409744,
0.8707623481750488,
0.8725427985191345,
0.07177148014307022,
0.7308675646781921,
-0.2676375210285187,
0.4040818512439728,
-0.7795389294624329,
0.09801504015922546,
0.01946500688791275,
-0.40583401918411255,
-0.6089186668395996,
-0.4180571138858795,
0.32933515310287476,
0.1775781363248825,
-0.2756454050540924,
0.37629789113998413,
-0.5319694876670837,
0.5772448182106018,
0.7244676351547241,
0.08473717421293259,
0.29418328404426575,
-0.024931469932198524,
-0.005899847485125065,
-0.06074289232492447,
-0.409847617149353,
-0.22827357053756714,
1.107925295829773,
0.14010347425937653,
0.6100614070892334,
0.030058911070227623,
0.7738800048828125,
0.02551322430372238,
0.3317660391330719,
-0.8955126404762268,
0.4691506326198578,
-0.5610299110412598,
-0.5792116522789001,
-0.3658706545829773,
-0.25006192922592163,
-0.42686188220977783,
0.810577929019928,
-0.40834924578666687,
-0.5811446905136108,
0.3159920871257782,
0.5884237885475159,
-0.20445571839809418,
0.5941532254219055,
-0.8507945537567139,
1.1042622327804565,
-0.4893565773963928,
-0.7422128319740295,
-0.028705798089504242,
-0.8575170040130615,
0.21873006224632263,
-0.21693892776966095,
0.09620913863182068,
-0.19804778695106506,
0.10359365493059158,
0.34265750646591187,
-0.07084667682647705,
0.9823440909385681,
-0.7256833910942078,
-0.01616300456225872,
0.2321491539478302,
-0.017165977507829666,
0.2651873230934143,
0.11739850789308548,
-0.10335451364517212,
0.4192821979522705,
-0.22825375199317932,
-0.5160591006278992,
-0.3210813105106354,
0.36635127663612366,
-0.6575220227241516,
-0.4208217263221741,
-0.37835055589675903,
-0.46227163076400757,
-0.14183644950389862,
0.7116149663925171,
0.2554226219654083,
0.5583959817886353,
-0.14002752304077148,
-0.09470672905445099,
0.11373542994260788,
-0.20826394855976105,
0.296850323677063,
0.6022616028785706,
-0.42891159653663635,
-0.2224586308002472,
1.3268134593963623,
-0.0236845500767231,
0.4255819618701935,
0.5990322232246399,
0.31485143303871155,
-0.11571087688207626,
-0.8201372027397156,
-0.611539363861084,
0.1638101190328598,
-0.5056759119033813,
-0.3008843958377838,
-0.3096865713596344,
-0.3101780116558075,
-0.1461276412010193,
-0.2701108157634735,
-0.39989104866981506,
-0.33180752396583557,
-0.2812393605709076,
-0.03045223280787468,
-0.025464031845331192,
0.7251107692718506,
-0.3371884524822235,
-0.17910829186439514,
-0.2659491300582886,
0.824508011341095,
0.8215864896774292,
0.4480689764022827,
-0.13553673028945923,
-0.5161870121955872,
-0.09303798526525497,
0.2784598469734192,
-0.2615734040737152,
-0.3167893886566162,
0.344210147857666,
0.5165003538131714,
0.35484784841537476,
0.3134693503379822,
0.010024451650679111,
0.8052204251289368,
-0.727134108543396,
0.6213259696960449,
0.5271156430244446,
-0.6465137600898743,
0.628085732460022,
-0.19356100261211395,
0.3506022095680237,
0.6801395416259766,
0.02874165214598179,
-0.46413686871528625,
-0.2503800392150879,
-0.009712154045701027,
-0.644172728061676,
0.6867993474006653,
-0.11171708256006241,
0.20572525262832642,
0.4619547128677368,
0.12517115473747253,
0.41400232911109924,
0.09060300141572952,
-0.8049046993255615,
-0.2518357038497925,
-0.6676936745643616,
-0.10082613676786423,
-0.625044047832489,
-0.12165740132331848,
0.05564282462000847,
-0.6223341226577759,
0.6277608871459961,
-0.30097535252571106,
-0.012820403091609478,
-0.02512221410870552,
-0.2764663100242615,
-0.4213132858276367,
0.29719266295433044,
0.3888982832431793,
0.506960391998291,
-0.3483131229877472,
0.4101203978061676,
0.015292192809283733,
-0.5482078194618225,
0.11651311814785004,
0.2726815938949585,
-0.2854821979999542,
-0.21796110272407532,
0.2992009222507477,
1.0369735956192017,
-0.09546966105699539,
-0.5093368291854858,
0.6090986728668213,
-0.2803254723548889,
-0.0964532271027565,
-0.1338633894920349,
0.2239288091659546,
-0.23575864732265472,
0.23315124213695526,
0.3201880156993866,
0.7987082600593567,
0.13394196331501007,
-0.4172980487346649,
0.15954749286174774,
0.6044350862503052,
-0.6661972999572754,
-0.6624720096588135,
0.7275692224502563,
0.4030689597129822,
-0.21981865167617798,
0.30539771914482117,
-0.3394004702568054,
-0.4304402470588684,
0.4903065264225006,
0.6673057675361633,
0.9701279401779175,
-0.07832245528697968,
0.2778332233428955,
0.32136210799217224,
0.09776173532009125,
0.28142449259757996,
0.24959298968315125,
-0.28092965483665466,
-0.9947760105133057,
-0.2057710438966751,
-0.8785858154296875,
-0.17783643305301666,
-0.08540014922618866,
-0.6232821345329285,
0.44749751687049866,
-0.21451717615127563,
0.23964808881282806,
0.19608862698078156,
-0.11697535216808319,
-0.857969343662262,
0.18309146165847778,
0.6860366463661194,
0.7961004972457886,
-0.8992860913276672,
1.172118067741394,
0.8223780393600464,
-0.42483484745025635,
-0.30733224749565125,
0.03520974889397621,
0.06484269350767136,
-0.9600908160209656,
0.43822360038757324,
0.5154133439064026,
-0.4471893012523651,
-0.0012904079630970955,
-0.17297014594078064,
-0.47772645950317383,
1.0900633335113525,
0.5814433693885803,
-0.7435987591743469,
0.08963456749916077,
-0.09731891751289368,
0.5383925437927246,
-0.006601346656680107,
-0.005646812729537487,
0.1336660236120224,
0.34136244654655457,
0.33692774176597595,
-0.6779690980911255,
-0.12701046466827393,
-0.1634289026260376,
0.04941083490848541,
0.6125397086143494,
-0.5935842394828796,
0.6111874580383301,
-0.5306104421615601,
-0.22930172085762024,
-0.003984948620200157,
0.4184051752090454,
-0.09063132107257843,
0.4786977469921112,
0.5078022480010986,
0.5637282133102417,
0.49135076999664307,
0.2549174726009369,
0.9505472779273987,
0.003457799553871155,
0.46952980756759644,
1.2306376695632935,
-0.4195103645324707,
0.8124904632568359,
0.7449655532836914,
-0.11369054764509201,
0.5349122881889343,
0.17670245468616486,
0.10058935731649399,
0.9815568327903748,
-0.0764366015791893,
-0.22515282034873962,
-0.5955039262771606,
-0.14525073766708374,
-0.2755929231643677,
0.3742128610610962,
0.12003612518310547,
-0.13724379241466522,
-0.36668723821640015,
0.15713104605674744,
-0.510147213935852,
-0.01030842773616314,
-0.43913018703460693,
0.759255051612854,
0.14620332419872284,
-0.6120871305465698,
0.6026350259780884,
-0.3342267870903015,
0.913408637046814,
-0.5039610266685486,
-0.30193424224853516,
0.11691443622112274,
0.6165096163749695,
-0.12936854362487793,
-0.77434241771698,
0.27666914463043213,
-0.25857922434806824,
-0.06809239089488983,
-0.3629709482192993,
1.0746088027954102,
-0.38944900035858154,
-0.6414425373077393,
0.7315719723701477,
0.20722295343875885,
-0.4029463529586792,
-0.20652136206626892,
-0.48375561833381653,
-0.07862234860658646,
0.09266369789838791,
0.09794260561466217,
0.30246394872665405,
0.12617646157741547,
0.1367839276790619,
0.25629913806915283,
0.4680667519569397,
-0.01569170132279396,
0.12288706004619598,
0.23439869284629822,
0.911247730255127,
-0.5855630040168762,
-0.3149608373641968,
-0.7772270441055298,
0.8397383689880371,
-0.15421712398529053,
-0.28706836700439453,
0.6785894632339478,
0.4323744773864746,
1.0774562358856201,
-0.21519821882247925,
0.9083993434906006,
0.08576712012290955,
0.37378546595573425,
-0.45022958517074585,
0.3894828259944916,
-0.8625777959823608,
-0.09541159868240356,
-0.21461260318756104,
-0.7212346792221069,
-0.7418102025985718,
0.5423029661178589,
-0.6754413843154907,
-0.2554164528846741,
0.24865837395191193,
0.5631834268569946,
-0.5832509398460388,
-0.16709810495376587,
0.641074538230896,
0.20243123173713684,
0.3371005058288574,
0.7459766864776611,
0.7450674176216125,
-0.6277336478233337,
0.3739657998085022,
-0.3891151249408722,
-0.3237510621547699,
-0.29430481791496277,
-0.8318493366241455,
-0.9412932991981506,
-0.5349015593528748,
-0.24424618482589722,
-0.08342064917087555,
0.16510646045207977,
0.4300273060798645,
0.8349758982658386,
-0.9640716314315796,
-0.1387527883052826,
-0.6776407957077026,
0.21548575162887573,
-0.12450490891933441,
-0.1697997748851776,
-0.03460335358977318,
-0.1403093785047531,
-0.21425700187683105,
0.17727039754390717,
0.6811437606811523,
0.05767671763896942,
-0.11371422559022903,
-0.2749118506908417,
-0.13851967453956604,
-0.011240163818001747,
0.6595141887664795,
0.544409453868866,
-0.7437626719474792,
-0.4119897484779358,
-0.34879744052886963,
0.088044673204422,
0.2645344138145447,
0.6794689297676086,
-0.9806964993476868,
0.9034554362297058,
0.2899005115032196,
0.551540195941925,
0.5169647336006165,
-0.23342882096767426,
0.4440716505050659,
-0.37788793444633484,
0.4782789647579193,
0.2333470731973648,
0.3926273584365845,
0.36953768134117126,
-0.14253777265548706,
0.3654558062553406,
0.33718469738960266,
-0.29232707619667053,
-0.6832269430160522,
0.6886622905731201,
-0.9527744054794312,
-0.30103397369384766,
0.9599776864051819,
0.2409200221300125,
-0.062592513859272,
0.05408090353012085,
-0.4776838719844818,
0.38953667879104614,
-0.11863076686859131,
0.5328738689422607,
-0.026446092873811722,
-0.04942728579044342,
-0.09835489839315414,
-0.35814717411994934,
0.15254582464694977,
0.21016855537891388,
-0.6497430205345154,
-0.031594425439834595,
0.5993265509605408,
0.30227261781692505,
0.21517875790596008,
0.4666665196418762,
0.190476194024086,
0.3592481315135956,
-0.024198152124881744,
0.15283599495887756,
-0.05697301775217056,
-0.5386456251144409,
-0.7348073124885559,
-0.044754475355148315,
0.19919416308403015,
-0.46767163276672363
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.12958v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.12958v1
|
Dated Data: Tracing Knowledge Cutoffs in Large Language Models
| 2024-03-19T17:57:58 | 2024-03-19T17:57:58 |
Jeffrey Cheng, Marc Marone, Orion Weller, Dawn Lawrie, Daniel Khashabi, Benjamin Van Durme
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Released Large Language Models (LLMs) are often paired with a claimed
knowledge cutoff date, or the dates at which training data was gathered. Such
information is crucial for applications where the LLM must provide up to date
information. However, this statement only scratches the surface: do all
resources in the training data share the same knowledge cutoff date? Does the
model's demonstrated knowledge for these subsets closely align to their cutoff
dates? In this work, we define the notion of an effective cutoff. This is
distinct from the LLM designer reported cutoff and applies separately to
sub-resources and topics. We propose a simple approach to estimate effective
cutoffs on the resource-level temporal alignment of an LLM by probing across
versions of the data. Using this analysis, we find that effective cutoffs often
differ from reported cutoffs. To understand the root cause of this observation,
we conduct a direct large-scale analysis on open pre-training datasets. Our
analysis reveals two reasons for these inconsistencies: (1) temporal biases of
CommonCrawl data due to non-trivial amounts of old data in new dumps and (2)
complications in LLM deduplication schemes involving semantic duplicates and
lexical near-duplicates. Overall, our results show that knowledge cutoffs are
not as simple as they have seemed and that care must be taken both by LLM
dataset curators as well as practitioners who seek to use information from
these models.
|
[
-0.1928417682647705,
-0.710107147693634,
0.625158965587616,
0.00391797861084342,
-0.10388396680355072,
-0.0862412229180336,
-0.13264863193035126,
-0.5195971727371216,
-0.027429459616541862,
0.5207458734512329,
-0.7727077603340149,
-0.33655545115470886,
-0.5093307495117188,
-0.2794617712497711,
-0.45397764444351196,
0.9139519333839417,
-0.19896246492862701,
0.0502653643488884,
-0.3406645357608795,
-0.4606405198574066,
-0.4921640455722809,
-0.5988938212394714,
-0.4703690707683563,
-0.5514585971832275,
0.6740311980247498,
0.20212644338607788,
0.6812665462493896,
0.9641263484954834,
0.70848548412323,
0.10317092388868332,
-0.49683818221092224,
0.10684884339570999,
-0.41857290267944336,
-0.1789071261882782,
-0.2047155201435089,
-0.3497830033302307,
-0.45856332778930664,
0.10133611410856247,
0.667265772819519,
1.15867280960083,
-0.11241329461336136,
0.09716639667749405,
-0.0387103445827961,
0.691146969795227,
-0.9227860569953918,
-0.06296595931053162,
-0.6795334219932556,
0.3862024247646332,
-0.4759570360183716,
-0.3074280619621277,
-0.24114203453063965,
-0.41529783606529236,
0.27125439047813416,
-0.41562557220458984,
0.2594706118106842,
-0.47370585799217224,
0.7882538437843323,
0.5540801882743835,
-0.4644686281681061,
-0.4084889590740204,
-0.7333853840827942,
1.095885992050171,
-0.8685769438743591,
0.5200230479240417,
0.402383029460907,
0.3185507357120514,
-0.18963490426540375,
-0.4647741913795471,
-0.1962154507637024,
-0.09297505021095276,
-0.06520117819309235,
-0.20871920883655548,
-0.1099749356508255,
-0.17838367819786072,
0.5021834373474121,
0.4560322165489197,
-0.31070899963378906,
0.3473474383354187,
-0.4658220112323761,
-0.2638174295425415,
0.3918345272541046,
0.27092570066452026,
0.3283202648162842,
-0.034196216613054276,
-0.5809633135795593,
0.14779897034168243,
-1.2132999897003174,
-0.18185049295425415,
0.4037132263183594,
0.12228255718946457,
-0.15982279181480408,
0.5307530164718628,
0.057034023106098175,
0.8683321475982666,
-0.2610107362270355,
-0.27772942185401917,
0.06512979418039322,
-0.4263443350791931,
-0.13053534924983978,
0.04342564940452576,
0.6320504546165466,
0.3719802498817444,
0.33988362550735474,
-0.07151761651039124,
-0.055520981550216675,
-0.31603094935417175,
-0.15133371949195862,
-0.5475364327430725,
-0.2968507409095764,
-0.04381921514868736,
-0.19445428252220154,
-0.10188133269548416,
-0.1844538301229477,
-0.5538749694824219,
-0.4352293908596039,
-0.5070745348930359,
0.09062853455543518,
-0.0211623664945364,
-0.04378960654139519,
0.07493403553962708,
0.05846317112445831,
0.12496761977672577,
0.2892420291900635,
-0.5161906480789185,
-0.003099562367424369,
0.475433886051178,
0.8698692917823792,
-0.26634451746940613,
-0.20770709216594696,
-0.562872588634491,
0.2833985388278961,
-0.25953277945518494,
0.4086054265499115,
-0.3060476779937744,
-0.13052286207675934,
0.061039842665195465,
-0.140715554356575,
-0.12217295914888382,
-0.6296518445014954,
0.34677520394325256,
-0.5655509829521179,
0.32995688915252686,
-0.3090043365955353,
-0.7526702284812927,
0.2225506454706192,
0.1949453204870224,
-0.7763012647628784,
0.7668400406837463,
-0.062340449541807175,
-1.0178617238998413,
0.565772294998169,
-0.2781161963939667,
-0.2441321462392807,
-0.2895193099975586,
-0.1889970749616623,
-0.33813539147377014,
-0.11621897667646408,
0.2835395932197571,
0.31768113374710083,
-0.4032707214355469,
0.42053136229515076,
-0.3779616355895996,
-0.03723153471946716,
0.3853442072868347,
-0.3917354941368103,
1.0255123376846313,
0.42956534028053284,
-0.02429135888814926,
-0.2209572196006775,
-0.6842389702796936,
-0.013372416608035564,
0.20573648810386658,
-0.45321592688560486,
-0.40955790877342224,
0.1293472796678543,
-0.10097472369670868,
0.07212935388088226,
0.5076746344566345,
-0.4320463538169861,
0.3467871844768524,
0.021796904504299164,
0.5105538964271545,
0.7818126678466797,
0.020852738991379738,
0.41780850291252136,
-0.4344821870326996,
0.5909823179244995,
-0.07906873524188995,
0.5069741606712341,
-0.10789646953344345,
-0.09313343465328217,
-0.5867540836334229,
-0.12493665516376495,
0.1907252073287964,
0.34065863490104675,
-0.26392507553100586,
0.3345579504966736,
-0.2280566543340683,
-0.40263962745666504,
-0.12124602496623993,
0.032001860439777374,
0.3777051866054535,
0.3124990165233612,
0.18197235465049744,
-0.4485747814178467,
-0.629157543182373,
-0.9353928565979004,
-0.39809709787368774,
-0.09762712568044662,
0.09909974783658981,
0.3366265296936035,
0.1788589507341385,
0.1281232237815857,
1.0170406103134155,
-0.7929497361183167,
-0.13584889471530914,
-0.1336420625448227,
0.064133420586586,
0.1755162626504898,
0.46047013998031616,
0.5015270709991455,
-0.5495522022247314,
-0.17129233479499817,
-0.2314816415309906,
-0.7793715596199036,
-0.34004321694374084,
-0.19172993302345276,
-0.12877729535102844,
0.1186537966132164,
0.6674764156341553,
-0.5065171718597412,
0.23079007863998413,
0.6473787426948547,
-0.11572302132844925,
0.4730369448661804,
0.047978658229112625,
-0.0849551111459732,
-0.7464689016342163,
0.16161979734897614,
-0.20807431638240814,
-0.0700567215681076,
-0.4442409574985504,
-0.3073631823062897,
0.08126858621835709,
0.04679347947239876,
-0.43916183710098267,
0.6638919115066528,
-0.6423116326332092,
-0.1403467059135437,
0.01213102601468563,
0.20654408633708954,
-0.06390230357646942,
0.1964622437953949,
-0.13460563123226166,
0.4329819083213806,
0.12783119082450867,
-0.37704402208328247,
0.13974273204803467,
0.2879593074321747,
-0.6785585284233093,
0.40776145458221436,
-0.49424466490745544,
0.5113288760185242,
0.01005738228559494,
0.07167983055114746,
-0.5523943901062012,
-0.08815379440784454,
0.12406272441148758,
-0.21419651806354523,
0.4020407497882843,
-0.48830369114875793,
-0.3030770421028137,
-0.07764200121164322,
-0.06779181212186813,
0.5819118022918701,
0.36811643838882446,
-0.4732747972011566,
0.26129814982414246,
0.48563092947006226,
-0.16225869953632355,
-0.893441915512085,
-0.7289777994155884,
-0.09828195720911026,
-0.2764299809932709,
-0.7197374105453491,
0.07198542356491089,
-0.1312611699104309,
-0.4495965838432312,
0.2262987196445465,
-0.5177704095840454,
-0.394809365272522,
0.11027441173791885,
0.10159488022327423,
0.24763809144496918,
-0.17502056062221527,
-0.10816376656293869,
-0.30278435349464417,
0.1269780844449997,
0.16906821727752686,
-0.009990796446800232,
0.6469641923904419,
0.5831936597824097,
-0.6822373270988464,
-0.013045732863247395,
-0.024218492209911346,
0.5408946871757507,
-0.24342024326324463,
0.8751788139343262,
0.12558484077453613,
-0.3744153082370758,
-0.2069617360830307,
-0.6833692789077759,
0.15387827157974243,
-0.33609727025032043,
0.2104995995759964,
-0.15004925429821014,
-0.5916762351989746,
0.7109096646308899,
0.19287654757499695,
0.17511726915836334,
0.4470673203468323,
0.22922848165035248,
0.12667784094810486,
0.5713005661964417,
0.46301037073135376,
-0.13458757102489471,
0.8169934749603271,
-0.17984962463378906,
0.07507370412349701,
-0.8468425273895264,
-0.45289936661720276,
-0.4177123010158539,
-0.21616312861442566,
-0.15007689595222473,
-0.30177372694015503,
0.09010986983776093,
0.37020641565322876,
-0.27801740169525146,
0.024457288905978203,
-0.08819649368524551,
0.5842621326446533,
0.4410329759120941,
-0.0492766797542572,
0.5511773824691772,
0.02014288492500782,
0.07052882015705109,
-0.16954244673252106,
-0.8125738501548767,
-0.2110549956560135,
1.1245332956314087,
0.3536079525947571,
0.8896784782409668,
-0.18047504127025604,
0.45715007185935974,
0.3438047170639038,
-0.044084977358579636,
-0.5834857225418091,
0.3081549406051636,
-0.05603921785950661,
-0.696486234664917,
-0.29041287302970886,
-0.7913474440574646,
-0.8608063459396362,
-0.14611586928367615,
0.1254366934299469,
-0.36334121227264404,
0.044056329876184464,
0.14643138647079468,
-0.030303044244647026,
0.4266194701194763,
-0.6253066062927246,
0.8727326989173889,
-0.4128147065639496,
-0.2635856866836548,
-0.1200074553489685,
-0.6363545060157776,
0.4231843054294586,
-0.4523616135120392,
0.2753158509731293,
-0.44927436113357544,
0.26095202565193176,
1.137997031211853,
-0.5883662700653076,
0.7335640788078308,
-0.27693983912467957,
0.009242463856935501,
0.24256916344165802,
0.08956696838140488,
0.6271142363548279,
-0.5117455720901489,
0.282572478055954,
0.2599807381629944,
0.12503325939178467,
-0.490215927362442,
-0.5877068042755127,
0.5610469579696655,
-0.72772616147995,
-0.2973804473876953,
-0.33102601766586304,
-0.8141107559204102,
-0.17313772439956665,
0.05927678197622299,
0.3071663975715637,
0.6588591933250427,
-0.2942889928817749,
0.007978799752891064,
0.5114465951919556,
-0.380683034658432,
0.1673700213432312,
0.6607484221458435,
-0.09464724361896515,
-0.33429160714149475,
0.38782086968421936,
0.6120097041130066,
0.5027629733085632,
0.25364845991134644,
0.16086116433143616,
-0.17121484875679016,
-0.7455609440803528,
-0.25099310278892517,
0.41098493337631226,
-0.8236652612686157,
-0.15040552616119385,
-0.46210864186286926,
-0.37647098302841187,
-0.0725746676325798,
-0.1757906824350357,
-0.4085242748260498,
-0.45239272713661194,
-0.11828706413507462,
0.029887422919273376,
0.3598839044570923,
1.0514179468154907,
-0.25455042719841003,
0.239934504032135,
-0.9893128275871277,
-0.08761516213417053,
-0.015059582889080048,
0.2184523046016693,
0.09048491716384888,
-0.5188764333724976,
-0.492103636264801,
0.17587023973464966,
-0.13902506232261658,
-0.8171496987342834,
0.0684584379196167,
0.061230845749378204,
0.8700552582740784,
0.280129611492157,
0.012817258946597576,
0.6048140525817871,
-0.35130175948143005,
0.7066705822944641,
0.3563418388366699,
-0.8575786352157593,
0.638981819152832,
-0.5840207934379578,
0.5492708683013916,
0.30044251680374146,
0.3904414474964142,
-0.763796329498291,
-0.38576218485832214,
-0.6059433221817017,
-1.03018057346344,
0.862974226474762,
0.12891656160354614,
-0.3031415045261383,
0.16251589357852936,
0.08786729723215103,
0.2276175320148468,
0.13760851323604584,
-0.4437236487865448,
-0.2440895140171051,
0.35353884100914,
-0.19366216659545898,
0.02639729343354702,
-0.49760547280311584,
-0.28657159209251404,
-0.07893431931734085,
0.5009927153587341,
0.20081500709056854,
-0.09793481975793839,
-0.1222878247499466,
-0.41634994745254517,
-0.202712744474411,
0.34423696994781494,
0.3756190836429596,
1.3284368515014648,
-0.3166329562664032,
0.2634137272834778,
0.30215394496917725,
-0.5275748372077942,
-0.012653442099690437,
0.0908925011754036,
-0.27179718017578125,
-0.06124452129006386,
0.7912156581878662,
0.5880593061447144,
0.2982606291770935,
-0.661136269569397,
0.38089367747306824,
0.3759130835533142,
0.2049274444580078,
-0.33173996210098267,
-0.1962004005908966,
0.06780635565519333,
0.3214801251888275,
0.26454052329063416,
-0.08287251740694046,
-0.2714115083217621,
-0.4315977692604065,
0.18004122376441956,
0.3155590295791626,
-0.23604421317577362,
-0.3241029381752014,
0.4256565570831299,
0.04207625240087509,
-0.009326417930424213,
0.9137349724769592,
0.30880019068717957,
-0.5619643330574036,
0.6863257884979248,
0.18948355317115784,
0.6384554505348206,
-0.21170811355113983,
-0.0883462056517601,
0.12877140939235687,
0.19676968455314636,
-0.14337588846683502,
-0.04456762596964836,
0.13732200860977173,
-0.7451266646385193,
-0.81650310754776,
-0.6023285388946533,
-0.34969544410705566,
0.4356224834918976,
-0.9539893865585327,
0.22579827904701233,
-0.2711898684501648,
-0.17787432670593262,
-0.14885972440242767,
-0.13275033235549927,
-0.970074474811554,
0.026499472558498383,
0.11573412269353867,
0.9279574751853943,
-1.0193545818328857,
0.49343347549438477,
0.4200076758861542,
-0.46950867772102356,
-0.8521224856376648,
-0.13733656704425812,
0.2576200067996979,
-1.0021781921386719,
0.8404647707939148,
-0.2132357656955719,
0.1164507195353508,
-0.2390255331993103,
-0.5580134391784668,
-1.0424150228500366,
0.8895275592803955,
0.5877730846405029,
-0.8098931312561035,
-0.18703033030033112,
0.3552602529525757,
0.2708069980144501,
0.024496737867593765,
0.05258098617196083,
0.7176639437675476,
0.3397669494152069,
0.29232257604599,
-1.1946675777435303,
-0.04599928483366966,
-0.0274238009005785,
-0.39698851108551025,
0.790382981300354,
-0.5064435601234436,
0.7635927200317383,
-0.1306408792734146,
-0.31293368339538574,
-0.13056042790412903,
0.2298719435930252,
0.08114434033632278,
0.4398871660232544,
0.4669964015483856,
0.8333726525306702,
0.7756282687187195,
-0.15437057614326477,
0.8108994960784912,
-0.02138860709965229,
0.3677098751068115,
1.2263379096984863,
-0.09310239553451538,
0.49771690368652344,
0.4845278859138489,
-0.49742960929870605,
-0.1023978441953659,
0.7172777652740479,
-0.13616617023944855,
0.6210553646087646,
0.1476087123155594,
0.06495390832424164,
-0.1768152117729187,
-0.41829949617385864,
-0.5742263197898865,
0.1500445306301117,
-0.10320352017879486,
-0.4805487394332886,
-0.4338032007217407,
-0.24129551649093628,
0.49871060252189636,
-0.3873961865901947,
-0.16582128405570984,
0.7737004160881042,
0.21016262471675873,
-0.4256126880645752,
0.4943489730358124,
-0.4253825843334198,
0.3807848393917084,
-0.5999346971511841,
0.12738467752933502,
-0.5963802933692932,
0.287716805934906,
-0.2262481451034546,
-0.9918739795684814,
0.3909277021884918,
0.1521240919828415,
-0.3219331204891205,
-0.3570937216281891,
0.508864164352417,
-0.5594497919082642,
-0.19371728599071503,
0.2431165874004364,
0.8069513440132141,
0.39365872740745544,
-0.012240319512784481,
-0.4721667170524597,
0.3947265148162842,
0.1943361759185791,
-0.11928076297044754,
0.3795281946659088,
0.5018614530563354,
-0.024992462247610092,
0.47000619769096375,
0.5257695913314819,
0.40709033608436584,
0.3279081881046295,
0.14843589067459106,
0.819703221321106,
-0.6670117378234863,
-0.04257941618561745,
-0.9568489193916321,
0.3721337616443634,
-0.047285281121730804,
-0.4102325439453125,
0.7571080923080444,
0.680776834487915,
0.8840392231941223,
0.3011048436164856,
0.7011763453483582,
0.03223109617829323,
0.5862215757369995,
-0.8984401226043701,
0.6571357250213623,
-0.603347659111023,
0.476055383682251,
0.007937591522932053,
-1.1732664108276367,
0.025056326761841774,
0.22973036766052246,
-0.5434136986732483,
0.03211167827248573,
0.7163775563240051,
0.47062358260154724,
-0.13327153027057648,
-0.07929464429616928,
0.12541989982128143,
0.07568580657243729,
0.3343973755836487,
0.6354529857635498,
1.2805132865905762,
-0.04123895242810249,
0.4925481379032135,
-0.33940261602401733,
-0.06600482016801834,
-0.08375745266675949,
-0.8895298838615417,
-0.8498673439025879,
-0.502170741558075,
-0.3131053149700165,
-0.10090738534927368,
0.4040677845478058,
0.5998716354370117,
0.4859292507171631,
-0.5023670792579651,
-0.12067736685276031,
0.16874012351036072,
0.08385767787694931,
0.1545557677745819,
-0.1696949005126953,
0.5316146016120911,
-0.024824194610118866,
-0.4688972234725952,
0.3235049843788147,
-0.23113393783569336,
0.15046097338199615,
-0.13649390637874603,
0.12647515535354614,
-0.12039972841739655,
-0.11230863630771637,
0.3128475546836853,
0.3399762213230133,
-0.5557093024253845,
-0.25062522292137146,
0.1810542345046997,
-0.10748254507780075,
0.0008101069834083319,
1.0549458265304565,
-0.4224705398082733,
0.3952982723712921,
0.5492777228355408,
0.5052433013916016,
0.7222858667373657,
-0.18412163853645325,
0.7593837380409241,
-0.7626428008079529,
0.16654783487319946,
0.14596068859100342,
0.40945374965667725,
0.6147857308387756,
-0.18342635035514832,
0.7708250880241394,
0.29514434933662415,
-0.6236088871955872,
-0.9729173183441162,
0.18913835287094116,
-0.8382797241210938,
-0.28529810905456543,
1.2417423725128174,
-0.23542407155036926,
-0.028498755767941475,
0.022856079041957855,
0.22020259499549866,
0.3653202950954437,
-0.04838684946298599,
0.6336058378219604,
1.0455034971237183,
0.04482022672891617,
0.02737690694630146,
-0.7301592826843262,
0.46395114064216614,
0.36769819259643555,
-0.6817759871482849,
0.19701293110847473,
0.8767676949501038,
0.4628927707672119,
0.021607475355267525,
0.4242568612098694,
-0.12388146668672562,
0.0020669219084084034,
-0.02769734524190426,
-0.025676215067505836,
-0.20563717186450958,
-0.3485991656780243,
-0.09304983913898468,
0.018949754536151886,
0.2668985426425934,
-0.11385472863912582
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.12936v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.12936v1
|
Automatic Information Extraction From Employment Tribunal Judgements Using Large Language Models
| 2024-03-19T17:43:08 | 2024-03-19T17:43:08 |
Joana Ribeiro de Faria, Huiyuan Xie, Felix Steffek
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Court transcripts and judgments are rich repositories of legal knowledge,
detailing the intricacies of cases and the rationale behind judicial decisions.
The extraction of key information from these documents provides a concise
overview of a case, crucial for both legal experts and the public. With the
advent of large language models (LLMs), automatic information extraction has
become increasingly feasible and efficient. This paper presents a comprehensive
study on the application of GPT-4, a large language model, for automatic
information extraction from UK Employment Tribunal (UKET) cases. We
meticulously evaluated GPT-4's performance in extracting critical information
with a manual verification process to ensure the accuracy and relevance of the
extracted data. Our research is structured around two primary extraction tasks:
the first involves a general extraction of eight key aspects that hold
significance for both legal specialists and the general public, including the
facts of the case, the claims made, references to legal statutes, references to
precedents, general case outcomes and corresponding labels, detailed order and
remedies and reasons for the decision. The second task is more focused, aimed
at analysing three of those extracted features, namely facts, claims and
outcomes, in order to facilitate the development of a tool capable of
predicting the outcome of employment law disputes. Through our analysis, we
demonstrate that LLMs like GPT-4 can obtain high accuracy in legal information
extraction, highlighting the potential of LLMs in revolutionising the way legal
information is processed and utilised, offering significant implications for
legal research and practice.
|
[
-0.09163379669189453,
-0.37118351459503174,
0.9551317691802979,
-0.16712994873523712,
-0.5124724507331848,
-0.2763797342777252,
-0.19795028865337372,
-0.693886935710907,
-0.18304139375686646,
0.7155340909957886,
-0.0970800593495369,
-0.3118676245212555,
-0.7602080702781677,
0.27161723375320435,
-0.6410478353500366,
0.8179605007171631,
-0.00723968306556344,
-0.029747236520051956,
0.23810556530952454,
0.0006611442076973617,
-0.6569244861602783,
-0.6417160630226135,
-0.435298353433609,
-0.13535161316394806,
0.2954961955547333,
0.13336537778377533,
0.39859241247177124,
0.5747416615486145,
0.5739145874977112,
0.4010201096534729,
0.07462356239557266,
-0.3031323254108429,
-0.3174263536930084,
0.06247729808092117,
-0.4352394938468933,
-0.858647882938385,
-0.2777916491031647,
0.2641458213329315,
0.5606873035430908,
0.0921325609087944,
-0.44195595383644104,
0.18161346018314362,
-0.08644543588161469,
0.4449995458126068,
-0.38601216673851013,
0.49376657605171204,
-0.8738021850585938,
0.21322603523731232,
-0.3488757014274597,
-0.1052001342177391,
-0.35446804761886597,
-0.4222964644432068,
0.11496175825595856,
-0.32392337918281555,
0.26005539298057556,
0.058485910296440125,
0.8541128039360046,
0.23060612380504608,
-0.6146259307861328,
-0.5774827599525452,
-0.673090398311615,
0.792004406452179,
-0.8723792433738708,
0.5281499624252319,
0.26850709319114685,
0.46642395853996277,
0.04041209816932678,
-0.9012053608894348,
-0.5797091722488403,
-0.08736006170511246,
-0.19341960549354553,
0.3669995367527008,
-0.03514491766691208,
0.23201096057891846,
0.5522310733795166,
0.4251266121864319,
-0.40199989080429077,
0.32412049174308777,
-0.6278212666511536,
-0.3455413579940796,
0.5269359350204468,
-0.05663440003991127,
0.22714772820472717,
-0.5315618515014648,
-0.02683134190738201,
0.12249664962291718,
-0.8067887425422668,
-0.19097401201725006,
0.5033319592475891,
0.16082452237606049,
0.1526704579591751,
0.6136166453361511,
0.013709050603210926,
0.43492117524147034,
-0.014729870483279228,
-0.40017402172088623,
0.0693671777844429,
-0.1268760859966278,
-0.20481117069721222,
0.09379100799560547,
1.0197972059249878,
0.13062994182109833,
0.08964824676513672,
-0.3033939599990845,
-0.5246064066886902,
-0.18441694974899292,
0.24594317376613617,
-0.7002428770065308,
0.06582909822463989,
0.3232130706310272,
-0.45235225558280945,
-0.28298482298851013,
0.22875390946865082,
-0.9545809030532837,
-0.44320812821388245,
-0.4872622787952423,
0.0763423815369606,
-0.20990188419818878,
-0.3314749300479889,
0.04755173623561859,
-0.09050126373767853,
0.6200841665267944,
0.6653929352760315,
-0.6222294569015503,
-0.024808745831251144,
0.6791010499000549,
0.43574583530426025,
-0.22996191680431366,
0.2839914560317993,
-0.7321544885635376,
0.2867721915245056,
-0.11928410083055496,
0.5200291275978088,
-0.6358960866928101,
0.006872446741908789,
0.1437157243490219,
0.2369934618473053,
0.11481968313455582,
-0.6088634729385376,
0.8486307859420776,
-0.8908853530883789,
0.42739036679267883,
-0.1416025161743164,
-0.5204972624778748,
-0.20013493299484253,
0.23343399167060852,
-1.0299352407455444,
0.670033872127533,
0.11838120967149734,
-0.5453289747238159,
0.626915693283081,
-0.7884054780006409,
-0.29132750630378723,
0.4457925260066986,
-0.8774823546409607,
-0.3464168310165405,
0.08013840764760971,
0.042116738855838776,
0.48948168754577637,
-0.6612314581871033,
0.3709453046321869,
0.041660454124212265,
-0.1362086534500122,
-0.12101016193628311,
-0.3841840326786041,
0.8127657771110535,
0.32789066433906555,
-0.6182796955108643,
-0.38907209038734436,
-0.3919244110584259,
-0.2006906419992447,
0.09845708310604095,
-0.5623382925987244,
0.06521186232566833,
-0.1605404019355774,
-0.27770814299583435,
0.5226306915283203,
0.23067116737365723,
-0.6244319677352905,
0.16492986679077148,
-0.1778869926929474,
0.4384753406047821,
0.7831127047538757,
0.05092601105570793,
0.012918330729007721,
0.14897708594799042,
0.8930895328521729,
-0.14953529834747314,
0.01955447904765606,
0.27722322940826416,
-0.32199782133102417,
0.02805749885737896,
-0.3822706639766693,
0.7887488603591919,
0.6622488498687744,
-0.7450809478759766,
0.17617321014404297,
-0.4054073095321655,
-0.15367774665355682,
-0.45136189460754395,
0.29648905992507935,
0.18646620213985443,
0.2978155314922333,
-0.0477134995162487,
-0.2139737904071808,
-0.6322664022445679,
-0.8412211537361145,
-0.4546862840652466,
-0.3039211928844452,
-0.09802400320768356,
0.27892258763313293,
0.48548194766044617,
-0.2661668062210083,
1.0698097944259644,
-0.24727007746696472,
-0.1663239449262619,
-0.20491981506347656,
0.36596664786338806,
0.6344241499900818,
0.0699101984500885,
0.4006689190864563,
-1.159839391708374,
-0.2538340985774994,
0.35775402188301086,
-1.0315821170806885,
-0.15220725536346436,
-0.33574482798576355,
-0.09032464772462845,
-0.07579801976680756,
0.29377707839012146,
-0.7136996388435364,
0.49670857191085815,
0.04230697453022003,
-0.23394037783145905,
0.9595993161201477,
0.09622980654239655,
0.2985512912273407,
-0.725217878818512,
0.10492420196533203,
0.09187012910842896,
-0.6560422778129578,
-0.29581981897354126,
0.0720810815691948,
0.2739526033401489,
0.1669386625289917,
-0.5708094239234924,
0.3808818459510803,
-0.7149161696434021,
-0.32959726452827454,
-0.10355616360902786,
0.29879286885261536,
0.06750812381505966,
0.33065152168273926,
-0.10305342823266983,
0.8774181008338928,
0.01193671952933073,
-0.4454314410686493,
0.6467245221138,
0.38007721304893494,
-0.44070136547088623,
0.5370712876319885,
-0.19302645325660706,
0.17869651317596436,
0.13658209145069122,
-0.003061392344534397,
-0.7194032073020935,
-0.3658773601055145,
-0.13025175034999847,
0.010811860673129559,
0.4189945459365845,
-0.5656899213790894,
-0.7793840765953064,
-0.6714227199554443,
-0.09596254676580429,
0.06990430504083633,
0.5533023476600647,
-0.4231739044189453,
0.844468891620636,
0.8139420747756958,
-0.7012381553649902,
-0.517410159111023,
-0.629760205745697,
0.32960858941078186,
-0.4666776955127716,
-0.028150420635938644,
0.16811040043830872,
0.4243411719799042,
-0.322468101978302,
-0.20574449002742767,
-0.12754768133163452,
-0.3492463231086731,
-0.11549431085586548,
0.012631410732865334,
0.3455769419670105,
-0.1356860101222992,
-0.08904831856489182,
-0.15621507167816162,
0.1940218210220337,
0.34563469886779785,
0.008859018795192242,
0.3020794093608856,
-0.05158945918083191,
-0.5476908683776855,
-0.6235905885696411,
0.20773157477378845,
0.7078921794891357,
-0.004390806425362825,
0.2172415554523468,
0.5155197978019714,
-0.4610811173915863,
0.3072832524776459,
-1.0555906295776367,
-0.10296936333179474,
-0.46300962567329407,
0.3724471628665924,
-0.3207854628562927,
-0.6582016944885254,
0.38203537464141846,
-0.417807400226593,
0.253501832485199,
0.8167303800582886,
0.5585376024246216,
0.20627151429653168,
0.7387326955795288,
0.5988448262214661,
-0.45472773909568787,
0.6787170171737671,
0.02111116424202919,
0.12609043717384338,
-0.5738445520401001,
-0.0021811085753142834,
-0.44691863656044006,
0.24787691235542297,
-0.4151820242404938,
0.01530164573341608,
0.3314461410045624,
-0.10551007091999054,
0.2805653214454651,
0.2896592319011688,
-0.18176831305027008,
0.4766193926334381,
0.28720054030418396,
0.154708594083786,
0.31882625818252563,
-0.059663884341716766,
-0.3663330078125,
0.12900672852993011,
-0.32135477662086487,
-0.6473802924156189,
1.0973154306411743,
0.29157429933547974,
0.28692764043807983,
0.39147454500198364,
0.5652731657028198,
0.5128602385520935,
0.4210807979106903,
-0.5378053188323975,
0.43339982628822327,
-0.13229958713054657,
-0.5464091897010803,
-0.3134642541408539,
-0.6410761475563049,
-0.969282329082489,
0.4371187090873718,
-0.1101427674293518,
-0.8026635646820068,
0.22663865983486176,
-0.22726748883724213,
-0.4774833023548126,
0.19023117423057556,
-0.7554575204849243,
0.5259643197059631,
-0.4697414040565491,
-0.5183231234550476,
-0.08910097926855087,
-0.5653910636901855,
0.44046756625175476,
-0.6881723403930664,
0.5622024536132812,
0.038630057126283646,
0.23734742403030396,
1.071028709411621,
-0.5038053393363953,
0.698373019695282,
-0.3463315963745117,
-0.38966310024261475,
0.3846481740474701,
-0.04776163026690483,
0.9089919924736023,
-0.18444745242595673,
-0.5272027850151062,
0.1529933661222458,
0.29843857884407043,
0.06128167733550072,
-0.5015422105789185,
0.21016867458820343,
-0.5199626088142395,
-0.5989336967468262,
-0.3360511362552643,
-0.38355615735054016,
-0.06846382468938828,
0.5499000549316406,
-0.02396874874830246,
0.513429582118988,
0.07754890620708466,
0.20528540015220642,
0.060519617050886154,
-0.20076115429401398,
0.29050520062446594,
0.5912595987319946,
-0.1607123613357544,
-0.3989257216453552,
0.5283007621765137,
0.3684730529785156,
-0.16223329305648804,
0.06945023685693741,
0.1294475942850113,
-0.6894257664680481,
-0.5684467554092407,
-0.29971668124198914,
0.44925183057785034,
-0.8473497629165649,
-0.35905924439430237,
-0.4556474983692169,
-0.04485494643449783,
-0.5565232038497925,
0.284187912940979,
-0.09319320321083069,
-0.4408811926841736,
0.09805861115455627,
-0.29606154561042786,
0.2271963208913803,
1.1793653964996338,
-0.013343826867640018,
0.17653997242450714,
-0.7966467142105103,
0.5424283742904663,
0.5090587735176086,
0.28065407276153564,
-0.6384695172309875,
-0.6980919241905212,
-0.19803187251091003,
-0.17317701876163483,
-0.28800272941589355,
-0.8830181956291199,
0.5640543699264526,
-0.0811077132821083,
0.8049805164337158,
0.46129512786865234,
-0.21911369264125824,
0.49748411774635315,
-0.6553472876548767,
0.7431695461273193,
0.18327009677886963,
-0.5484223365783691,
0.365307480096817,
-0.4838290512561798,
-0.2102613002061844,
0.642006516456604,
0.33708706498146057,
-0.32326173782348633,
-0.3433697521686554,
-0.7392871379852295,
-0.923230767250061,
0.9024016857147217,
0.33027374744415283,
-0.349860817193985,
0.16550065577030182,
0.8185360431671143,
0.3474164605140686,
0.4538997411727905,
-0.7206348776817322,
0.3280611038208008,
0.3250197470188141,
-0.3321036100387573,
0.31780800223350525,
-0.4180344045162201,
-0.030044982209801674,
-0.20467714965343475,
0.6052573919296265,
0.20619980990886688,
0.46569040417671204,
0.006292921956628561,
-0.4613890051841736,
0.057749755680561066,
0.29682058095932007,
0.04150788486003876,
0.8075408339500427,
-0.21524667739868164,
-0.039050955325365067,
0.30981457233428955,
-0.6031427383422852,
0.06907719373703003,
0.23790398240089417,
0.18573009967803955,
-0.03311605751514435,
0.24033428728580475,
0.3490246832370758,
-0.029727434739470482,
-0.5992959141731262,
0.831509530544281,
-0.36861202120780945,
-0.30108141899108887,
-0.580101728439331,
-0.16287600994110107,
-0.3449433445930481,
0.4764997959136963,
0.5301815271377563,
-0.3648986220359802,
0.4105854630470276,
-0.4393627941608429,
0.5048509240150452,
0.25035008788108826,
0.005182635970413685,
-0.13650000095367432,
0.5504536628723145,
0.056130968034267426,
0.024280840530991554,
0.44851675629615784,
-0.12532535195350647,
-0.5359756350517273,
0.5135166645050049,
0.42227768898010254,
0.752207338809967,
-0.23501241207122803,
-0.1419525444507599,
0.06751172989606857,
0.11624108999967575,
-0.45338770747184753,
0.16456006467342377,
0.1026904284954071,
-0.5146806836128235,
-0.7550601959228516,
-0.5115885734558105,
-0.6177975535392761,
0.28021523356437683,
-0.7172163724899292,
0.16520176827907562,
-0.27552396059036255,
-0.11312437057495117,
-0.05951263755559921,
0.03856038302183151,
-1.225436806678772,
0.23460780084133148,
0.14824740588665009,
0.4254303574562073,
-0.7188565731048584,
0.7531497478485107,
0.322616308927536,
-0.4276454746723175,
-0.9214556217193604,
-0.16890913248062134,
0.19209326803684235,
-0.7348529100418091,
0.6528573036193848,
0.2890726625919342,
0.007353956811130047,
-0.1548868864774704,
-0.5017752051353455,
-0.7003419399261475,
1.1158747673034668,
0.7336465120315552,
-0.9482893347740173,
-0.1835547685623169,
0.40476125478744507,
0.2135089486837387,
-0.06647934764623642,
0.742584764957428,
0.8636014461517334,
0.5335296988487244,
0.01616314984858036,
-1.01863694190979,
0.28942394256591797,
-0.2117888629436493,
-0.37453752756118774,
0.09576405584812164,
-0.2454197257757187,
0.7135711312294006,
0.39152073860168457,
-0.32918527722358704,
-0.48430538177490234,
0.29722973704338074,
-0.06741702556610107,
-0.3447222113609314,
0.6723038554191589,
0.25744950771331787,
1.2880582809448242,
-0.01905573345720768,
1.2124786376953125,
-0.43357574939727783,
0.42522376775741577,
0.8080537915229797,
-0.5278117656707764,
0.6621193885803223,
0.367521733045578,
-0.4170713424682617,
0.3861005902290344,
0.373161256313324,
0.01859608106315136,
0.3337869644165039,
-0.08145230263471603,
-0.15011447668075562,
0.000260872213402763,
0.2799281179904938,
-0.16232213377952576,
0.4941495954990387,
0.5093834400177002,
-0.46767619252204895,
-0.23032157123088837,
-0.1273566633462906,
-0.10085143893957138,
-0.509689211845398,
-0.2969459891319275,
1.0177814960479736,
-0.01000132691115141,
-0.7005733847618103,
0.2979765832424164,
0.04897534102201462,
0.3607293367385864,
-0.4192683696746826,
-0.42852073907852173,
0.010733300819993019,
-0.004487819038331509,
-0.30924558639526367,
-0.7416906356811523,
0.14070646464824677,
0.3772486746311188,
0.0997241660952568,
-0.248864084482193,
0.7317672967910767,
-0.14977994561195374,
-0.24155078828334808,
0.12773698568344116,
0.39436301589012146,
0.5772697329521179,
-0.38460487127304077,
-0.808995246887207,
-0.012998274527490139,
0.19302967190742493,
-0.3192347288131714,
0.22438593208789825,
0.9978690147399902,
0.04899553954601288,
0.17982502281665802,
0.4991338551044464,
0.49941760301589966,
0.10698872804641724,
0.08899969607591629,
0.9229152798652649,
-1.0115951299667358,
-0.5298705697059631,
-0.9388980865478516,
0.3763706684112549,
-0.4147997796535492,
0.10056502372026443,
0.3753674626350403,
0.5710592865943909,
0.2612845003604889,
0.20495012402534485,
1.220261812210083,
-0.008655973710119724,
0.6743624806404114,
-0.9290354251861572,
0.3907211124897003,
-0.10632847994565964,
0.37914130091667175,
-0.3607167601585388,
-0.814328134059906,
-0.03332133963704109,
0.5353302359580994,
-0.7811093330383301,
0.06675819307565689,
0.7573282122612,
0.5420448780059814,
-0.25787153840065,
0.21924088895320892,
0.33296042680740356,
0.49211621284484863,
0.6581417918205261,
0.2502457797527313,
0.5323706865310669,
-0.3516988158226013,
0.6763384938240051,
0.2577030062675476,
-0.17432403564453125,
-0.2737252414226532,
-0.9057431221008301,
-0.34584036469459534,
-0.08962272852659225,
-0.13854870200157166,
-0.24394449591636658,
-0.018169088289141655,
0.7347605228424072,
0.5225375294685364,
-0.841924250125885,
-0.1885150521993637,
-0.10500428825616837,
-0.18424297869205475,
0.2104821652173996,
-0.2547049820423126,
0.41013678908348083,
-0.35636967420578003,
-0.3618495464324951,
0.3711943030357361,
0.07845877856016159,
-0.3141818046569824,
0.14734625816345215,
0.1580861359834671,
-0.3073442280292511,
-0.1648048311471939,
0.5894198417663574,
0.2852820158004761,
-0.5800721645355225,
-0.541750431060791,
-0.9099653959274292,
-0.20173992216587067,
0.3029509484767914,
0.6158865690231323,
-0.4532409906387329,
0.3437364995479584,
0.09135521948337555,
0.8038272261619568,
0.7480126619338989,
0.20458857715129852,
0.9500629901885986,
-0.8148051500320435,
0.1189802885055542,
0.12589548528194427,
0.9273437261581421,
0.19538038969039917,
-0.527540385723114,
0.7930392026901245,
0.25770217180252075,
-0.6797604560852051,
-0.6978337168693542,
-0.03193028271198273,
-0.5852105617523193,
-0.05801333114504814,
1.3479758501052856,
-0.13223116099834442,
-0.48573780059814453,
-0.3871767818927765,
-0.34341490268707275,
0.2870790362358093,
-0.4242764711380005,
0.8232935070991516,
0.857373058795929,
0.020387494936585426,
-0.17423857748508453,
-1.2503362894058228,
0.3340095281600952,
0.06951078027486801,
-0.7977611422538757,
-0.029567068442702293,
0.7277075052261353,
0.5031973719596863,
0.05599487945437431,
0.6397762894630432,
-0.5428711771965027,
0.12870359420776367,
-0.32862645387649536,
0.3197993338108063,
0.30181974172592163,
0.06562365591526031,
-0.38279417157173157,
0.41033339500427246,
0.07324282079935074,
0.04468092322349548
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.12924v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.12924v1
|
Supporting Energy Policy Research with Large Language Models
| 2024-03-19T17:28:51 | 2024-03-19T17:28:51 |
Grant Buster, Pavlo Pinchuk, Jacob Barrons, Ryan McKeever, Aaron Levine, Anthony Lopez
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The recent growth in renewable energy development in the United States has
been accompanied by a simultaneous surge in renewable energy siting ordinances.
These zoning laws play a critical role in dictating the placement of wind and
solar resources that are critical for achieving low-carbon energy futures. In
this context, efficient access to and management of siting ordinance data
becomes imperative. The National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL) recently
introduced a public wind and solar siting database to fill this need. This
paper presents a method for harnessing Large Language Models (LLMs) to automate
the extraction of these siting ordinances from legal documents, enabling this
database to maintain accurate up-to-date information in the rapidly changing
energy policy landscape. A novel contribution of this research is the
integration of a decision tree framework with LLMs. Our results show that this
approach is 85 to 90% accurate with outputs that can be used directly in
downstream quantitative modeling. We discuss opportunities to use this work to
support similar large-scale policy research in the energy sector. By unlocking
new efficiencies in the extraction and analysis of legal documents using LLMs,
this study enables a path forward for automated large-scale energy policy
research.
|
[
-0.12667378783226013,
-0.6502684354782104,
0.8356842398643494,
0.22307996451854706,
0.11219287663698196,
-0.028382500633597374,
-0.4666573703289032,
-0.32257238030433655,
0.12440211325883865,
0.9541700482368469,
-0.01475773099809885,
-0.48816820979118347,
-0.2522011399269104,
-0.05585581809282303,
-0.4965610206127167,
0.38224050402641296,
-0.2614365220069885,
0.16199356317520142,
-0.13063324987888336,
0.15625663101673126,
-0.3635713756084442,
0.02789301611483097,
-0.226739302277565,
-0.3719649314880371,
0.30967822670936584,
0.32001689076423645,
0.6789401769638062,
0.5289368629455566,
0.5425477027893066,
0.32370924949645996,
-0.013633503578603268,
-0.16252073645591736,
-0.15498492121696472,
-0.07200446724891663,
-0.28911101818084717,
-0.30526867508888245,
-0.3266136050224304,
0.3369552195072174,
1.2707730531692505,
0.37972745299339294,
-0.6539071202278137,
-0.08739209920167923,
-0.22752071917057037,
0.3543089032173157,
-0.5941453576087952,
0.3935689330101013,
-1.0496044158935547,
-0.025601277127861977,
0.02311391569674015,
-0.3032659590244293,
-0.509370744228363,
-0.6066127419471741,
0.06316076964139938,
-0.5076155662536621,
-0.07910153269767761,
0.38560834527015686,
0.9649053812026978,
0.4008985459804535,
-0.5404019951820374,
-0.12783727049827576,
-0.5758079886436462,
0.9600249528884888,
-1.0886707305908203,
0.30520790815353394,
0.38790038228034973,
0.32570403814315796,
-0.3981330990791321,
-0.4874412417411804,
-0.6761904358863831,
-0.5545229315757751,
-0.34155961871147156,
-0.3005389869213104,
-0.046478185802698135,
0.35755133628845215,
0.2579634189605713,
0.16546663641929626,
-0.4861772656440735,
0.37566933035850525,
-0.25843581557273865,
-0.13742636144161224,
0.8680972456932068,
0.15406347811222076,
0.12208612263202667,
-0.6485976576805115,
-0.32009825110435486,
-0.10978519916534424,
-0.5980167984962463,
-0.22857432067394257,
0.41081514954566956,
0.5817234516143799,
-0.03823070600628853,
0.9991225600242615,
0.054367873817682266,
0.6874881982803345,
-0.3111966848373413,
-0.06393790990114212,
-0.08550670742988586,
-0.2558351755142212,
-0.4199695289134979,
0.008080185391008854,
0.672817587852478,
0.20962674915790558,
0.09416234493255615,
0.06393501907587051,
-0.3443690240383148,
-0.6392616033554077,
0.17198032140731812,
-0.7272017002105713,
0.072324737906456,
0.3103000223636627,
-0.4228614866733551,
-0.39570900797843933,
0.10788644850254059,
-0.7282415628433228,
-0.7927452325820923,
-0.8513167500495911,
0.115214042365551,
-0.2197098284959793,
-0.39798593521118164,
0.08543478697538376,
-0.32292407751083374,
0.5125866532325745,
0.1339726597070694,
-0.7200006246566772,
0.26869648694992065,
0.9274600744247437,
0.781426727771759,
0.015281480737030506,
-0.12436529994010925,
-0.39588654041290283,
0.41451770067214966,
-0.26451632380485535,
0.5610751509666443,
-0.9597168564796448,
-0.2908519208431244,
0.13957493007183075,
0.07989787310361862,
-0.1807694137096405,
-0.44890183210372925,
0.19070231914520264,
-0.7190251350402832,
0.13026779890060425,
-0.03514209762215614,
-0.6624821424484253,
-0.0701541155576706,
0.030947290360927582,
-0.7748665809631348,
0.8707290887832642,
0.15355533361434937,
-0.5561893582344055,
0.22488850355148315,
-0.8172670602798462,
-0.29266151785850525,
-0.06799636036157608,
-0.3433857262134552,
-0.4208129644393921,
0.04589482396841049,
-0.17875845730304718,
0.31769442558288574,
-0.6640141606330872,
0.6517842411994934,
-0.32891589403152466,
0.21800416707992554,
0.06260201334953308,
-0.312288761138916,
0.9223911762237549,
0.4165956974029541,
-0.04430965706706047,
0.2387419193983078,
-0.756947934627533,
0.04220118373632431,
0.000871368742082268,
-0.6287153363227844,
-0.2861391603946686,
0.3738371729850769,
0.2370501607656479,
-0.09077382832765579,
0.37443965673446655,
-0.5791952013969421,
0.27842894196510315,
-0.14921826124191284,
0.4515645205974579,
0.6475141048431396,
0.029910515993833542,
0.43319493532180786,
-0.12314025312662125,
0.6193833947181702,
-0.539620578289032,
-0.05625349283218384,
-0.07428492605686188,
0.1639883667230606,
-0.334749311208725,
-0.1274251639842987,
0.27270570397377014,
0.5276645421981812,
-0.37306296825408936,
0.6121494770050049,
-0.3662227690219879,
-0.5501707792282104,
-0.15974576771259308,
-0.15111029148101807,
-0.08331339061260223,
0.34499391913414,
0.19609031081199646,
0.4065864384174347,
-0.6217048764228821,
-0.6019110679626465,
-0.13974936306476593,
-0.12021468579769135,
0.0445549376308918,
0.47523996233940125,
0.5558578968048096,
0.19248582422733307,
1.0422898530960083,
-0.5116614103317261,
-0.1099119633436203,
0.04766972362995148,
0.24988742172718048,
0.2419193834066391,
0.4611395299434662,
0.6963794231414795,
-0.7727816104888916,
-0.6413978934288025,
0.49190977215766907,
-0.621231198310852,
-0.16408953070640564,
-0.2245677411556244,
-0.04902219772338867,
0.04703168943524361,
0.6168413758277893,
-0.7398642897605896,
0.0676368921995163,
0.3386126160621643,
-0.40321317315101624,
0.8140438199043274,
-0.02428782731294632,
0.09698747098445892,
-0.7823297381401062,
0.27494296431541443,
0.04933404177427292,
-0.33184677362442017,
-0.18162527680397034,
0.21438150107860565,
-0.137948140501976,
-0.20818346738815308,
-0.24879144132137299,
0.34294450283050537,
-0.49301138520240784,
-0.34306421875953674,
-0.22613103687763214,
-0.18130145967006683,
0.09055115282535553,
-0.05236108601093292,
0.09734833985567093,
0.9845709204673767,
0.6226228475570679,
-0.37690049409866333,
0.41054388880729675,
0.18916189670562744,
-0.47321388125419617,
0.4920631945133209,
-0.3701018691062927,
-0.1700425148010254,
-0.11044508218765259,
0.45133548974990845,
-0.5622103810310364,
-0.5232886075973511,
-0.1980520635843277,
0.058937933295965195,
0.41011306643486023,
-0.4055682420730591,
-0.2565736770629883,
-0.38201597332954407,
-0.24028773605823517,
-0.16737031936645508,
0.2702338695526123,
-0.3513723909854889,
1.1938450336456299,
0.9053545594215393,
-0.2665621042251587,
-0.6505377888679504,
-0.25743475556373596,
0.22245144844055176,
-0.37172994017601013,
-0.5164971947669983,
0.36872345209121704,
0.32994145154953003,
-0.6350072026252747,
0.00634339265525341,
0.004515418782830238,
-0.15876278281211853,
0.002973868977278471,
0.04319114610552788,
-0.07838115841150284,
-0.33642709255218506,
0.10661128163337708,
-0.30810439586639404,
0.1464652717113495,
0.3326960504055023,
-0.5227845311164856,
0.517261803150177,
0.12534376978874207,
-0.14545732736587524,
-0.6309992671012878,
0.36249253153800964,
1.1195745468139648,
-0.29952898621559143,
0.5861865878105164,
0.05109066516160965,
-0.3162921667098999,
-0.39317628741264343,
-0.46277084946632385,
0.2590038776397705,
-0.5201932787895203,
0.22387443482875824,
-0.16659067571163177,
-0.572269082069397,
0.31850871443748474,
-0.24079518020153046,
0.5869556665420532,
0.4007839560508728,
0.2391745150089264,
-0.26015159487724304,
0.5966456532478333,
0.8222120404243469,
-0.08074384182691574,
0.9427240490913391,
-0.25782185792922974,
0.1237691268324852,
-0.6078280806541443,
-0.09543576091527939,
-0.9536190032958984,
-0.1553630232810974,
-0.3472060561180115,
-0.6010751724243164,
0.15066519379615784,
-0.3699800968170166,
-0.3023081123828888,
0.4570709764957428,
-0.2452411651611328,
0.7328538298606873,
-0.010354760102927685,
-0.25567662715911865,
0.17636863887310028,
0.14294150471687317,
0.1604076325893402,
0.3104499876499176,
-0.42161592841148376,
-0.6752640008926392,
0.9956561923027039,
0.22451794147491455,
0.7524740695953369,
0.000531610450707376,
0.5241986513137817,
0.4895670413970947,
0.36913612484931946,
-0.9036209583282471,
0.5706484913825989,
-0.13016383349895477,
-0.6136804819107056,
-0.6979227066040039,
-0.76131272315979,
-0.9568163752555847,
0.4437296688556671,
-0.00043469431693665683,
-0.6043946146965027,
0.28373289108276367,
0.20741569995880127,
-0.3381820619106293,
0.636259138584137,
-0.5966481566429138,
0.6968448162078857,
-0.39952021837234497,
-0.25596973299980164,
-0.7492075562477112,
-0.32228460907936096,
0.19122400879859924,
-0.12966446578502655,
0.36306366324424744,
-0.4463518559932709,
0.15552867949008942,
0.5911381244659424,
-0.75141441822052,
0.621346116065979,
-0.6621521711349487,
-0.628616452217102,
0.7165927290916443,
-0.09058238565921783,
0.8715547919273376,
-0.41040804982185364,
-0.7016635537147522,
-0.16038718819618225,
0.15814796090126038,
-0.20679260790348053,
-0.22345933318138123,
0.8705345988273621,
-0.5045080184936523,
-0.4516209363937378,
-0.5166329145431519,
-0.32460421323776245,
-0.2140117883682251,
0.18017525970935822,
-0.21484243869781494,
0.09149874746799469,
-0.5344432592391968,
0.12775221467018127,
0.3912784159183502,
-0.08548770099878311,
0.504833459854126,
0.8764814138412476,
-0.38569897413253784,
-0.08082030713558197,
0.8636830449104309,
0.31945061683654785,
-0.034507084637880325,
0.3807695806026459,
0.5241995453834534,
-0.5727961659431458,
-0.6356247067451477,
0.12891885638237,
0.15891221165657043,
-0.4005335569381714,
-0.41826263070106506,
-0.48777344822883606,
-0.10890612751245499,
-0.5403653383255005,
-0.2399565726518631,
-0.32140064239501953,
-0.4086199104785919,
-0.014359411783516407,
-0.4468356668949127,
0.5579485893249512,
0.7679681777954102,
-0.20347289741039276,
0.3525601625442505,
-0.6155931353569031,
0.2627435028553009,
0.2615026831626892,
0.4638264775276184,
0.19309101998806,
-0.18498076498508453,
-0.19303275644779205,
-0.04337858408689499,
-0.046489883214235306,
-0.7274838089942932,
0.23405875265598297,
0.2442421317100525,
0.4654238522052765,
0.29161542654037476,
-0.02326878532767296,
0.4584837853908539,
-0.5386401414871216,
0.5492138266563416,
0.3546101450920105,
-0.7359716892242432,
0.30583247542381287,
-0.6267218589782715,
-0.17883430421352386,
0.5879599452018738,
0.12487713247537613,
-0.4157908856868744,
0.012506384402513504,
-0.2583424150943756,
-0.8280774354934692,
0.8357996940612793,
-0.09872005879878998,
0.16428561508655548,
0.07555165886878967,
0.12652207911014557,
-0.08850785344839096,
0.3001527488231659,
-0.6375910043716431,
0.32102006673812866,
0.05305863916873932,
0.0038742811884731054,
0.27174073457717896,
-0.04818936437368393,
-0.2219867706298828,
-0.38737785816192627,
0.8604834079742432,
-0.15679048001766205,
-0.26876896619796753,
-0.23732638359069824,
0.02219114452600479,
-0.22819294035434723,
0.46690118312835693,
0.17708079516887665,
0.7541283369064331,
-0.3192044794559479,
0.11941780149936676,
0.11626717448234558,
-0.33935031294822693,
0.09723026305437088,
0.24762074649333954,
-0.4639582335948944,
0.02508716471493244,
-0.052783817052841187,
0.4691515862941742,
0.16596728563308716,
-0.6587923765182495,
0.3307172358036041,
0.23349590599536896,
-0.17890216410160065,
-0.5669167637825012,
-0.05905739217996597,
-0.05739571154117584,
0.19542880356311798,
0.3340781629085541,
-0.1485971212387085,
0.03002215176820755,
-0.43890678882598877,
0.21587884426116943,
0.5575240254402161,
-0.14245513081550598,
-0.0515039786696434,
0.4973917305469513,
0.5487686395645142,
-0.07493996620178223,
0.43243786692619324,
0.15962447226047516,
-0.3311806321144104,
0.8059671521186829,
0.3739941120147705,
0.7359724640846252,
0.006597614847123623,
0.27210450172424316,
0.5850550532341003,
0.22818663716316223,
-0.08869153261184692,
0.4497539699077606,
-0.04076128080487251,
-0.34916797280311584,
-0.6943356990814209,
-0.929115355014801,
-0.24986225366592407,
-0.06805278360843658,
-0.3479313254356384,
0.3717837631702423,
-0.6234593987464905,
-0.3481661379337311,
0.14589670300483704,
0.10180400311946869,
-0.5358101725578308,
-0.377828985452652,
0.45813024044036865,
0.9661253690719604,
-0.9121072292327881,
0.7138605713844299,
0.4870617389678955,
-0.15692192316055298,
-0.8229688405990601,
0.0056233517825603485,
0.04949238523840904,
-0.6313304901123047,
0.14531271159648895,
-0.1260625123977661,
-0.33370712399482727,
0.1259254515171051,
-1.0141825675964355,
-1.1229196786880493,
1.359096646308899,
0.3699827492237091,
-0.8178536295890808,
0.05397941172122955,
0.08502069115638733,
0.3280257284641266,
-0.14248251914978027,
0.14361613988876343,
0.7694776058197021,
1.2367961406707764,
0.09419716149568558,
-0.9593485593795776,
-0.08827503025531769,
0.19666294753551483,
-0.2268359363079071,
0.5109668970108032,
-0.6304473876953125,
0.5579898357391357,
-0.09010177105665207,
-0.25976651906967163,
-0.08930657058954239,
0.7678961753845215,
0.07277797162532806,
0.3007133901119232,
0.49805644154548645,
0.4210628271102905,
1.2385280132293701,
0.11811736971139908,
1.048727035522461,
-0.4184829890727997,
0.45303085446357727,
1.074589729309082,
-0.9015719294548035,
0.9858359694480896,
0.5453093647956848,
-0.4570953845977783,
0.6212411522865295,
0.2103121131658554,
-0.26675209403038025,
0.2963425815105438,
0.4887833893299103,
-0.30734866857528687,
-0.34539711475372314,
-0.6286987066268921,
-0.2878415584564209,
0.5811278820037842,
0.3636314868927002,
-0.22611288726329803,
-0.36360254883766174,
-0.22427737712860107,
0.07296118140220642,
0.20989085733890533,
-0.3128550946712494,
0.6086578369140625,
0.19219452142715454,
-0.6911693215370178,
0.06159831956028938,
0.1849939078092575,
0.36326971650123596,
-0.7894169092178345,
-0.19430731236934662,
0.29003211855888367,
-0.14192473888397217,
-0.4336029887199402,
-0.8916751742362976,
0.34795212745666504,
0.3131672143936157,
-0.19563744962215424,
-0.5740615725517273,
0.4061208963394165,
-0.21813848614692688,
-0.5280800461769104,
0.27911466360092163,
0.14182406663894653,
0.2680996060371399,
0.2544315457344055,
-0.5558001399040222,
-0.06351697444915771,
0.001085560186766088,
-0.2508985102176666,
0.15933583676815033,
0.3373844623565674,
-0.10868991166353226,
0.3778891861438751,
0.7133937478065491,
0.17129363119602203,
0.05293106660246849,
0.23310033977031708,
0.8031719326972961,
-0.65287846326828,
-0.5348774194717407,
-0.5757721662521362,
0.21886229515075684,
-0.4247249960899353,
-0.027617018669843674,
0.45534390211105347,
0.6724932193756104,
0.27993932366371155,
0.16056190431118011,
0.9498375654220581,
-0.5319448709487915,
0.32491791248321533,
-0.6900056004524231,
0.8531561493873596,
-0.45945101976394653,
0.416220098733902,
0.2536066472530365,
-0.9343246221542358,
-0.13259252905845642,
0.5079083442687988,
-0.5932818055152893,
-0.2349810004234314,
0.3754202127456665,
0.846890389919281,
-0.12050992995500565,
-0.13935698568820953,
0.04768643155694008,
0.5061831474304199,
0.5826824307441711,
0.13734059035778046,
0.8181639313697815,
0.13132867217063904,
0.3402821123600006,
0.15357129275798798,
0.049633145332336426,
-0.18480059504508972,
-0.9591571092605591,
-0.3920912742614746,
-0.24402910470962524,
-0.32088708877563477,
-0.19982637465000153,
-0.32461780309677124,
1.260846495628357,
0.7388566732406616,
-1.0796571969985962,
-0.6136165261268616,
-0.16160473227500916,
0.42635205388069153,
0.01271273847669363,
-0.302734911441803,
0.5615611672401428,
-0.22842225432395935,
-0.5364732146263123,
0.7169873118400574,
0.17797903716564178,
0.04288974776864052,
-0.4517029821872711,
-0.2418627291917801,
-0.42835935950279236,
0.40425992012023926,
0.4099377393722534,
0.5882581472396851,
-0.5336325764656067,
-0.18394730985164642,
-0.3282284736633301,
-0.19689840078353882,
0.04437224939465523,
1.098567247390747,
-0.5476912260055542,
0.18349622189998627,
0.8257390260696411,
0.4107154309749603,
0.5236040353775024,
0.13393205404281616,
0.7459478378295898,
-0.655359148979187,
-0.12625521421432495,
0.4098568260669708,
0.5983167290687561,
0.2712968587875366,
-0.11909472197294235,
0.4673939347267151,
-0.18095409870147705,
-0.6253653168678284,
-0.7583763599395752,
0.08161335438489914,
-0.9071755409240723,
-0.3597068786621094,
1.1379520893096924,
-0.0412214919924736,
-0.3325307071208954,
-0.01769697107374668,
-0.28420713543891907,
-0.11617483198642731,
-0.4664427638053894,
0.6481921672821045,
0.7383696436882019,
-0.059881940484046936,
0.04423781484365463,
-0.4035731256008148,
0.30640387535095215,
0.1473306268453598,
-0.8634714484214783,
0.6364598274230957,
0.9781112670898438,
0.14956384897232056,
0.09656815230846405,
0.632050096988678,
-0.06655686348676682,
-0.17106708884239197,
0.003359411144629121,
0.2529926896095276,
0.11486992239952087,
-0.42322203516960144,
-0.3987274467945099,
0.24660372734069824,
-0.016939353197813034,
0.19883164763450623
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.12918v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.12918v1
|
Generalizable and Stable Finetuning of Pretrained Language Models on Low-Resource Texts
| 2024-03-19T17:21:29 | 2024-03-19T17:21:29 |
Sai Ashish Somayajula, Youwei Liang, Abhishek Singh, Li Zhang, Pengtao Xie
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Pretrained Language Models (PLMs) have advanced Natural Language Processing
(NLP) tasks significantly, but finetuning PLMs on low-resource datasets poses
significant challenges such as instability and overfitting. Previous methods
tackle these issues by finetuning a strategically chosen subnetwork on a
downstream task, while keeping the remaining weights fixed to the pretrained
weights. However, they rely on a suboptimal criteria for sub-network selection,
leading to suboptimal solutions. To address these limitations, we propose a
regularization method based on attention-guided weight mixup for finetuning
PLMs. Our approach represents each network weight as a mixup of task-specific
weight and pretrained weight, controlled by a learnable attention parameter,
providing finer control over sub-network selection. Furthermore, we employ a
bi-level optimization (BLO) based framework on two separate splits of the
training dataset, improving generalization and combating overfitting. We
validate the efficacy of our proposed method through extensive experiments,
demonstrating its superiority over previous methods, particularly in the
context of finetuning PLMs on low-resource datasets.
|
[
-0.5512956976890564,
-0.511866569519043,
0.05431345850229263,
0.2942402958869934,
-0.5205843448638916,
-0.16721031069755554,
-0.6968487501144409,
0.0068662893027067184,
0.1736009418964386,
0.6622929573059082,
-0.6042340993881226,
-0.2494104653596878,
-0.6922587752342224,
0.20136453211307526,
-0.11269617825746536,
1.3431018590927124,
0.09388849139213562,
-0.10490349680185318,
-0.03433942422270775,
-0.27924802899360657,
-0.5923387408256531,
-0.4013260006904602,
-0.772334635257721,
-0.4459744095802307,
0.7247225642204285,
0.419379860162735,
0.659427285194397,
0.49117597937583923,
0.6525748372077942,
0.2139035314321518,
-0.2636110782623291,
0.48195183277130127,
-0.8770166039466858,
-0.06578491628170013,
-0.3056173324584961,
-0.335407018661499,
-0.40020519495010376,
0.27672243118286133,
0.66526859998703,
1.087591528892517,
-0.2066134363412857,
0.2880057394504547,
0.44201797246932983,
0.6567175984382629,
-0.7975838780403137,
-0.09188952296972275,
-0.8909127116203308,
-0.0550813190639019,
-0.31705987453460693,
-0.24160999059677124,
-0.3746945261955261,
-0.10644832253456116,
0.2971043586730957,
-0.6511404514312744,
0.21877238154411316,
0.21426862478256226,
1.0473315715789795,
0.7656035423278809,
0.06697117537260056,
0.10373443365097046,
-0.6762108206748962,
0.9887781739234924,
-0.8083153963088989,
0.4181552529335022,
0.6471280455589294,
-0.012963238172233105,
0.0458664633333683,
-0.47466856241226196,
-0.2606789171695709,
-0.13019198179244995,
-0.3177003264427185,
0.07622262835502625,
0.05849914625287056,
0.40417036414146423,
0.26037517189979553,
0.5252501368522644,
-0.509479820728302,
0.21978135406970978,
-0.328991174697876,
-0.09234536439180374,
0.24291379749774933,
-0.1652151346206665,
0.310860276222229,
0.13836151361465454,
-0.27657634019851685,
0.07752672582864761,
-0.5727696418762207,
-0.016063205897808075,
0.27976831793785095,
0.7502200603485107,
-0.1481025516986847,
0.6544468402862549,
-0.2969185709953308,
0.7387607097625732,
0.37450435757637024,
0.22805249691009521,
0.21233442425727844,
-0.5563628673553467,
-0.6116802096366882,
0.11420184373855591,
0.8379360437393188,
0.3115675449371338,
0.7101902961730957,
-0.30348190665245056,
-0.22434498369693756,
-0.0852072536945343,
0.24992282688617706,
-0.8041739463806152,
-0.30383822321891785,
0.188842311501503,
-0.4730702340602875,
-0.04404857009649277,
-0.3641514182090759,
-0.424941748380661,
-0.1578216850757599,
-0.5315112471580505,
0.29871177673339844,
-0.3089642822742462,
0.0006241575465537608,
0.30773165822029114,
0.3319457769393921,
-0.23741047084331512,
-0.06337752193212509,
-1.149895191192627,
0.4370737075805664,
0.3575269877910614,
0.9198875427246094,
-0.07357872277498245,
-0.2229669988155365,
-0.9089776873588562,
0.258306622505188,
-0.2524709105491638,
0.32883164286613464,
-0.2662554383277893,
0.1377517133951187,
-0.26583531498908997,
-0.10289237648248672,
-0.1533399075269699,
-0.49759748578071594,
0.5689960718154907,
-0.4922631084918976,
0.20825740694999695,
-0.11666854470968246,
-0.3311062157154083,
0.20193462073802948,
0.3819578289985657,
-0.732809841632843,
0.8807814717292786,
0.026914143934845924,
-1.0724568367004395,
0.39504432678222656,
-0.3691248297691345,
-0.526968777179718,
-0.11697874218225479,
0.054891590029001236,
-0.44928181171417236,
0.13469158113002777,
0.32586899399757385,
0.4241865873336792,
-0.32425999641418457,
0.2830171585083008,
-0.10425198823213577,
-0.3200940787792206,
-0.28558963537216187,
-0.21958161890506744,
0.7178485989570618,
0.20152547955513,
-0.08998528867959976,
0.06639173626899719,
-0.8313453197479248,
0.14936713874340057,
-0.12740157544612885,
-0.7777518033981323,
-0.6199806332588196,
0.03484049811959267,
0.026706203818321228,
0.14591296017169952,
0.32840806245803833,
-0.6640095710754395,
0.08777154982089996,
-0.9673324227333069,
0.4222245514392853,
0.34281983971595764,
-0.14227741956710815,
0.6616808176040649,
-0.3493707776069641,
0.2967005670070648,
0.014003897085785866,
0.018436511978507042,
0.18400824069976807,
-0.16304869949817657,
-1.0445207357406616,
-0.09102556109428406,
0.7554298639297485,
0.6581974625587463,
-0.7344118356704712,
0.49470630288124084,
-0.2092858999967575,
-0.1931382268667221,
-0.829169750213623,
0.537268340587616,
0.626441478729248,
0.3554099202156067,
0.8993163108825684,
-0.26637428998947144,
-0.6492843627929688,
-0.8530891537666321,
-0.26772481203079224,
0.468353807926178,
-0.12686826288700104,
0.09867260605096817,
-0.0462929792702198,
-0.2649786174297333,
1.0237237215042114,
-0.20118756592273712,
-0.7196875810623169,
-0.5267031788825989,
0.3060094714164734,
0.15989449620246887,
0.875377357006073,
0.5674458146095276,
-0.6291956305503845,
-0.5236085057258606,
0.1609247922897339,
-0.07742849737405777,
-0.3955482244491577,
-0.3385908305644989,
-0.17450621724128723,
-0.024310769513249397,
0.5161473155021667,
-0.5230515003204346,
-0.08758292347192764,
0.6502411365509033,
0.03122793883085251,
0.06191055476665497,
-0.17125080525875092,
-0.37916481494903564,
-0.9083215594291687,
0.09817597270011902,
0.2151079922914505,
-0.3327423930168152,
-0.5644580125808716,
-0.24203702807426453,
-0.1390771120786667,
0.030802296474575996,
-0.28050100803375244,
0.5506018400192261,
-0.4913005828857422,
-0.008874909952282906,
-0.14362706243991852,
0.12365284562110901,
0.02379896491765976,
0.6539400815963745,
-0.02863466367125511,
0.402732789516449,
0.4359529912471771,
-0.5378642678260803,
0.10090670734643936,
0.07093356549739838,
-0.10460209101438522,
0.1563819944858551,
-0.7369667887687683,
0.035118501633405685,
-0.3243328928947449,
-0.053289007395505905,
-0.8066936135292053,
0.020757392048835754,
0.293373167514801,
-0.15175914764404297,
0.52861487865448,
-0.3653339743614197,
-0.37475523352622986,
0.08585412800312042,
-0.005758750252425671,
0.4975581765174866,
0.1453927755355835,
-0.11469712108373642,
0.5293776392936707,
0.2447771579027176,
-0.34027335047721863,
-0.5636518597602844,
-0.930181622505188,
-0.12035840004682541,
-0.0025483479257673025,
-0.27390119433403015,
0.44110509753227234,
-0.1487998515367508,
0.04328298196196556,
-0.1475551575422287,
-0.19253450632095337,
-0.23409749567508698,
-0.04656976833939552,
-0.11844272166490555,
-0.012720903381705284,
-0.15893061459064484,
-0.16964314877986908,
0.17987200617790222,
-0.3116370439529419,
-0.3618098795413971,
-0.4027540385723114,
0.6509280204772949,
0.035238321870565414,
-0.011220238171517849,
-0.5325403213500977,
0.2849423289299011,
0.28260987997055054,
-0.6819480061531067,
0.6548715233802795,
0.7128745913505554,
-0.5957000255584717,
-0.38996803760528564,
-0.5271771550178528,
-0.04581165686249733,
-0.4678382873535156,
0.2521989345550537,
-0.0696345642209053,
-0.9088347554206848,
0.38236069679260254,
0.014791009947657585,
0.22963115572929382,
-0.011622533202171326,
0.44138139486312866,
-0.08847654610872269,
0.9427670836448669,
0.7591805458068848,
-0.028520215302705765,
0.6772538423538208,
-0.3615269958972931,
0.02233692817389965,
-0.7443206310272217,
0.15987388789653778,
-0.30986666679382324,
-0.6874067783355713,
-0.3930719792842865,
-0.2877247631549835,
-0.13896797597408295,
0.31268617510795593,
-0.1941772997379303,
0.2974317967891693,
-0.4474455714225769,
0.6969963312149048,
0.6053990125656128,
0.06174128130078316,
0.1979183703660965,
-0.02776399627327919,
-0.2101786881685257,
-0.25663232803344727,
-0.8780150413513184,
-0.27740615606307983,
0.949166476726532,
0.28157687187194824,
0.754590630531311,
-0.12238368391990662,
0.6857567429542542,
0.007149031385779381,
0.3764331042766571,
-0.6818066239356995,
0.2651759088039398,
-0.7714081406593323,
-0.4209049642086029,
-0.5012155771255493,
-0.67345130443573,
-0.874218761920929,
0.25373512506484985,
-0.2942674160003662,
-0.4333963394165039,
0.28790634870529175,
0.4243507385253906,
-0.8269810676574707,
-0.09782741218805313,
-0.9327037334442139,
1.0242581367492676,
-0.22728897631168365,
-0.20889568328857422,
-0.022950975224375725,
-0.7040178179740906,
0.14334745705127716,
-0.05442290008068085,
0.224842831492424,
-0.013097903691232204,
0.046779513359069824,
0.6188876032829285,
-0.5030133128166199,
0.9127478003501892,
-0.09284668415784836,
0.058296144008636475,
0.2178763598203659,
-0.009573611430823803,
0.5107936263084412,
-0.024489320814609528,
0.04561633989214897,
-0.0996355265378952,
-0.08549927920103073,
-0.46227630972862244,
-0.4373834431171417,
0.5621668100357056,
-0.7290232181549072,
-0.192337304353714,
0.023689383640885353,
-0.5631582736968994,
-0.4997323751449585,
0.6362032890319824,
0.4647219479084015,
0.5538785457611084,
0.25452712178230286,
0.4877757728099823,
0.724025309085846,
-0.05093904584646225,
0.4476659297943115,
0.18666717410087585,
0.24611078202724457,
-0.5401806235313416,
0.9824236035346985,
0.4622081518173218,
0.4539613425731659,
0.49415308237075806,
0.3026626706123352,
-0.01679869554936886,
-0.9643872380256653,
-0.1440965235233307,
-0.0010884631192311645,
-0.3176945447921753,
-0.3022250533103943,
-0.48500263690948486,
-0.18974511325359344,
-0.05299924314022064,
-0.10956799238920212,
-0.6367934942245483,
-0.08267960697412491,
-0.38507047295570374,
0.05478381738066673,
-0.16836367547512054,
0.21101079881191254,
0.10586956143379211,
0.663248598575592,
-0.819208025932312,
0.43437299132347107,
0.29342910647392273,
0.7160731554031372,
-0.2554287314414978,
-0.2928942143917084,
-0.5513905882835388,
0.13770604133605957,
0.029049010947346687,
-0.533450186252594,
0.2668495774269104,
0.4615939259529114,
0.5352652668952942,
0.1989232897758484,
0.23988699913024902,
0.5295402407646179,
-0.5218174457550049,
0.27707916498184204,
0.2752254903316498,
-0.8554596900939941,
0.530353844165802,
-0.5398011803627014,
0.3855111598968506,
0.92649245262146,
0.2850933372974396,
-0.27368274331092834,
-0.500969409942627,
-0.30014652013778687,
-0.8565428256988525,
0.8187202215194702,
0.4358365833759308,
0.22665303945541382,
0.10501463711261749,
0.35975584387779236,
-0.05598420277237892,
0.34565985202789307,
-1.0316808223724365,
-0.1367499679327011,
-0.3698671758174896,
-0.5367885828018188,
-0.02838120609521866,
-0.2459181845188141,
-0.10950025916099548,
-0.0985797718167305,
0.4726080894470215,
-0.15534467995166779,
-0.48743563890457153,
0.06143601983785629,
-0.2832742929458618,
-0.20598158240318298,
0.23287007212638855,
0.44917353987693787,
0.46519139409065247,
-0.49688878655433655,
0.2185659259557724,
0.17576636373996735,
-0.7145900726318359,
-0.02440478838980198,
0.31450092792510986,
-0.34999579191207886,
-0.06452777236700058,
0.14363287389278412,
0.7805906534194946,
0.47652968764305115,
-0.5062144994735718,
0.41294023394584656,
-0.08725215494632721,
-0.10375518351793289,
0.404438853263855,
0.08662258833646774,
-0.06982707232236862,
0.1681652069091797,
0.1613444685935974,
0.3618880808353424,
-0.12635676562786102,
-0.08736065775156021,
0.05605026334524155,
0.3474133014678955,
-0.24131351709365845,
-0.0931854397058487,
0.6299147605895996,
0.4509962797164917,
-0.09355565905570984,
0.2348206639289856,
-0.39799830317497253,
-0.27771830558776855,
0.32298246026039124,
0.3680141270160675,
0.7351865768432617,
0.04116395488381386,
-0.08349943161010742,
0.1982225626707077,
0.6943089962005615,
-0.28738078474998474,
0.16116772592067719,
0.11572324484586716,
-0.881973922252655,
-0.8671994805335999,
-0.8762969374656677,
-0.14131055772304535,
0.5167540907859802,
-0.5085792541503906,
0.3736337125301361,
-0.9585533142089844,
-0.4553128778934479,
-0.18458250164985657,
0.181429922580719,
-0.620237410068512,
0.6602904796600342,
0.3052184283733368,
0.504396915435791,
-0.5956525802612305,
0.7163693308830261,
0.879806637763977,
-0.4210798144340515,
-0.6788527965545654,
0.14037588238716125,
-0.5273489952087402,
-0.2526363134384155,
0.5350432991981506,
0.07710783928632736,
0.04915254935622215,
0.4539119303226471,
-0.4214238226413727,
-1.22927987575531,
0.5946947336196899,
0.7745054960250854,
-0.9013084769248962,
-0.2642132341861725,
-0.02893686108291149,
0.444640189409256,
-0.22468620538711548,
-0.14573092758655548,
0.4102626144886017,
0.2471376657485962,
-0.11190710216760635,
-1.1304712295532227,
-0.09408503025770187,
-0.17413829267024994,
0.17769256234169006,
0.16974897682666779,
-0.7334109544754028,
0.8738469481468201,
0.002274797996506095,
-0.3084559440612793,
-0.22842232882976532,
0.587164044380188,
0.15151119232177734,
-0.023464256897568703,
0.5057076215744019,
0.8098332285881042,
0.5772641897201538,
-0.0345751978456974,
0.6514319181442261,
-0.27992451190948486,
0.6034185290336609,
1.469025731086731,
0.09445951133966446,
0.6784657835960388,
0.49389269948005676,
0.05352245643734932,
0.10763297975063324,
0.776033341884613,
0.08450896292924881,
0.7767135500907898,
0.2722303569316864,
0.3371155261993408,
-0.5261355638504028,
-0.15667682886123657,
-0.1522616147994995,
0.3117123544216156,
0.17417556047439575,
-0.23086708784103394,
-0.4287271499633789,
0.12441128492355347,
-0.17123062908649445,
0.06345141679048538,
-0.5945077538490295,
0.49957630038261414,
0.08837316930294037,
-0.5142320990562439,
0.9191964268684387,
-0.027233928442001343,
0.8864582180976868,
-0.5173993110656738,
0.3259076774120331,
-0.2457984983921051,
0.23912763595581055,
-0.3332706093788147,
-0.4272182583808899,
0.326455295085907,
0.015484167262911797,
-0.4864483177661896,
-0.5933155417442322,
0.6734535694122314,
-0.8264275789260864,
-0.39445456862449646,
0.17167465388774872,
0.3633635938167572,
-0.2262604832649231,
-0.02939719706773758,
-0.5937386155128479,
0.07505068928003311,
-0.1433451920747757,
-0.43181750178337097,
0.379499614238739,
0.49797120690345764,
0.018065595999360085,
0.4970150887966156,
0.6289629936218262,
0.4182349145412445,
0.234012171626091,
0.3984290659427643,
0.887330949306488,
-0.1146467998623848,
-0.6824390292167664,
-0.7544692158699036,
0.6180541515350342,
0.05856766179203987,
-0.4919480085372925,
0.47146666049957275,
0.41512343287467957,
1.1510826349258423,
0.12903976440429688,
0.6792457699775696,
0.17251241207122803,
0.4840065538883209,
-0.6933571696281433,
0.8529308438301086,
-0.5728639960289001,
0.1476728618144989,
-0.2448786348104477,
-1.0236101150512695,
-0.3600417971611023,
0.691321074962616,
-0.33493444323539734,
0.09779155999422073,
0.3792375326156616,
0.35260477662086487,
-0.3736606538295746,
-0.3337056040763855,
0.0972752496600151,
0.1409086287021637,
-0.07460985332727432,
0.48278382420539856,
0.3419131636619568,
-0.16719500720500946,
0.7353565692901611,
-0.43007344007492065,
-0.13945510983467102,
-0.1711108684539795,
-0.933327853679657,
-1.1727468967437744,
-0.23383121192455292,
-0.39781641960144043,
0.007841041311621666,
0.12082529067993164,
1.030078649520874,
0.8591307997703552,
-0.9111102819442749,
0.069169782102108,
-0.35864320397377014,
0.026512200012803078,
-0.07446324080228806,
-0.15663515031337738,
0.1940796673297882,
-0.7156364917755127,
-0.7248148918151855,
0.28099220991134644,
0.16790427267551422,
0.2950693964958191,
-0.18463902175426483,
0.04910160228610039,
-0.3838726580142975,
0.04220087453722954,
0.5318160057067871,
0.23818077147006989,
-0.5266914367675781,
-0.11188435554504395,
-0.27926287055015564,
-0.29255151748657227,
-0.18269221484661102,
0.6627410650253296,
-0.6123526096343994,
0.34285497665405273,
0.5970715284347534,
1.0381792783737183,
0.20920221507549286,
0.3009473979473114,
0.6188450455665588,
-1.4524625539779663,
0.4174242913722992,
0.38306018710136414,
0.35593581199645996,
0.530096709728241,
-0.2822757959365845,
0.3444652557373047,
0.19905227422714233,
-0.40394699573516846,
-0.9308754205703735,
0.10481365025043488,
-0.9511700868606567,
-0.07126026600599289,
1.101129412651062,
-0.08880527317523956,
0.06974009424448013,
-0.06664656102657318,
-0.27292370796203613,
0.4129166007041931,
-0.3050753176212311,
0.596065878868103,
0.6927058100700378,
0.09922774881124496,
-0.28668442368507385,
-0.563992440700531,
0.8864976167678833,
0.8297588229179382,
-0.6418276429176331,
0.21253184974193573,
0.3373483121395111,
0.126114159822464,
0.27470868825912476,
0.5500673651695251,
0.39429786801338196,
-0.09570810198783875,
-0.5362391471862793,
-0.21777379512786865,
-0.18268761038780212,
-0.4812104403972626,
0.002243796829134226,
0.01975191943347454,
-0.13561058044433594,
-0.2938977777957916
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.12900v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.12900v1
|
Toward Sustainable GenAI using Generation Directives for Carbon-Friendly Large Language Model Inference
| 2024-03-19T16:53:53 | 2024-03-19T16:53:53 |
Baolin Li, Yankai Jiang, Vijay Gadepally, Devesh Tiwari
|
cs.DC
|
cs.DC, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The rapid advancement of Generative Artificial Intelligence (GenAI) across
diverse sectors raises significant environmental concerns, notably the carbon
emissions from their cloud and high performance computing (HPC) infrastructure.
This paper presents Sprout, an innovative framework designed to address these
concerns by reducing the carbon footprint of generative Large Language Model
(LLM) inference services. Sprout leverages the innovative concept of
"generation directives" to guide the autoregressive generation process, thereby
enhancing carbon efficiency. Our proposed method meticulously balances the need
for ecological sustainability with the demand for high-quality generation
outcomes. Employing a directive optimizer for the strategic assignment of
generation directives to user prompts and an original offline quality
evaluator, Sprout demonstrates a significant reduction in carbon emissions by
over 40% in real-world evaluations using the Llama2 LLM and global electricity
grid data. This research marks a critical step toward aligning AI technology
with sustainable practices, highlighting the potential for mitigating
environmental impacts in the rapidly expanding domain of generative artificial
intelligence.
|
[
-0.381217360496521,
-0.6899695992469788,
0.516576886177063,
0.29027897119522095,
-0.16302326321601868,
-0.02837800420820713,
-0.2742791771888733,
-0.17699645459651947,
0.10712981969118118,
0.48644760251045227,
-0.5401934385299683,
-0.4205741584300995,
-0.30588024854660034,
0.00508852070197463,
-0.38294535875320435,
0.8446357846260071,
0.25304779410362244,
0.004892687778919935,
-0.4015936255455017,
-0.06745889037847519,
-0.30661144852638245,
-0.013022204861044884,
-0.9647116661071777,
-0.19316436350345612,
0.7423393726348877,
0.4924177825450897,
0.8187753558158875,
0.7776607275009155,
0.2898043692111969,
0.29224011301994324,
-0.12348025292158127,
0.2572598457336426,
-0.5043580532073975,
0.12213560193777084,
-0.23401522636413574,
0.04508274048566818,
-0.1755906641483307,
-0.06305558234453201,
0.6098383665084839,
0.4682779312133789,
-0.3985927700996399,
0.11898841708898544,
0.17837367951869965,
0.5608730316162109,
-0.6145001649856567,
0.35617735981941223,
-0.5078327059745789,
0.16109725832939148,
-0.06348824501037598,
-0.2573654353618622,
-0.36997902393341064,
-0.4141973853111267,
-0.5086315870285034,
-0.8138502240180969,
0.10331207513809204,
0.07510407269001007,
0.825264036655426,
0.7422566413879395,
-0.1540127992630005,
-0.15986916422843933,
-0.7032301425933838,
0.7274847030639648,
-0.8174408078193665,
0.41106075048446655,
0.10628214478492737,
0.33958134055137634,
-0.12849365174770355,
-0.5966700315475464,
-0.8673036694526672,
-0.08112873136997223,
0.20421777665615082,
0.5675031542778015,
-0.1603846400976181,
0.19210325181484222,
0.0015203302027657628,
0.35515886545181274,
-0.37558168172836304,
0.32160672545433044,
-0.06339170783758163,
-0.23042607307434082,
0.8531178832054138,
-0.24579021334648132,
0.3317565619945526,
-0.34667497873306274,
-0.3664242625236511,
-0.05378051474690437,
-0.811920166015625,
-0.24614331126213074,
0.7850101590156555,
0.2687322497367859,
-0.06014300137758255,
0.5338372588157654,
-0.07775513827800751,
0.15248511731624603,
-0.1251627653837204,
0.1564895063638687,
0.036839138716459274,
-0.34757664799690247,
-0.2839931547641754,
0.07017078995704651,
0.7299337983131409,
0.5286532044410706,
-0.11817707121372223,
-0.13900721073150635,
-0.03167715668678284,
0.13875894248485565,
0.09779326617717743,
-0.7799397706985474,
-0.43971937894821167,
0.16215623915195465,
-0.41271209716796875,
-0.26639002561569214,
0.016591081395745277,
-1.2300002574920654,
-0.41971978545188904,
-0.2703447937965393,
-0.0360238254070282,
-0.29928067326545715,
-0.2263323962688446,
-0.1139800176024437,
-0.18902677297592163,
0.3272688388824463,
0.46083754301071167,
-0.8871983289718628,
-0.2533997893333435,
0.8098011016845703,
0.7477111220359802,
0.020941346883773804,
-0.052097856998443604,
-0.2855300307273865,
0.1951051503419876,
-0.21300001442432404,
0.8154301643371582,
-0.23759105801582336,
-0.58697909116745,
-0.2189720869064331,
-0.047880470752716064,
0.0215702373534441,
-0.16646194458007812,
0.46976032853126526,
-0.41505295038223267,
0.06119604781270027,
-0.33316683769226074,
-0.5482279658317566,
-0.29803186655044556,
-0.09718269109725952,
-0.5482757687568665,
0.7524410486221313,
-0.11561967432498932,
-0.6323437690734863,
0.6321951150894165,
-0.6365494132041931,
-0.5572652816772461,
0.5178050994873047,
-0.200972318649292,
-0.6850382089614868,
-0.1736452281475067,
-0.06436000019311905,
0.28225675225257874,
-0.34492918848991394,
0.4689082205295563,
-0.23419758677482605,
0.19996236264705658,
-0.4994337856769562,
-0.8268998265266418,
0.8646906018257141,
0.8097449541091919,
-0.34246233105659485,
0.5800443887710571,
-0.6438373327255249,
0.16035224497318268,
0.10808240622282028,
-0.4423086643218994,
0.025884324684739113,
0.3415861427783966,
0.20770245790481567,
-0.2006188929080963,
0.14304567873477936,
-0.5874584317207336,
-0.14863114058971405,
0.007894457317888737,
0.7482039332389832,
1.1046819686889648,
0.17075593769550323,
0.33042508363723755,
-0.39437800645828247,
0.5881638526916504,
-0.6709263324737549,
0.2534426748752594,
-0.15252679586410522,
-0.5491508841514587,
-0.9846775531768799,
-0.5589554905891418,
-0.058869216591119766,
0.44711896777153015,
-0.6023949980735779,
1.1355212926864624,
-0.3537459373474121,
-0.6783768534660339,
-0.14726336300373077,
0.12110939621925354,
-0.07922544330358505,
0.24553269147872925,
0.09512250125408173,
0.028872966766357422,
-0.23689360916614532,
-0.7132161259651184,
-0.07813698798418045,
-0.11533298343420029,
-0.03373562544584274,
0.30188119411468506,
0.3621547818183899,
-0.4828847050666809,
1.0145471096038818,
-0.17452257871627808,
0.4222896099090576,
-0.40402254462242126,
0.0786086842417717,
-0.17161452770233154,
0.6279979944229126,
0.44666343927383423,
-1.1228443384170532,
-0.2999613881111145,
0.11758275330066681,
-0.72950679063797,
-0.0903904139995575,
-0.5726065039634705,
-0.23456960916519165,
-0.16702663898468018,
0.5464727282524109,
-0.659573495388031,
0.10549090057611465,
0.5131307244300842,
-0.5389222502708435,
0.32476988434791565,
-0.46247169375419617,
0.16830402612686157,
-1.0038734674453735,
0.15288226306438446,
-0.06972724199295044,
-0.13246659934520721,
-0.30955952405929565,
0.5094625949859619,
-0.22443081438541412,
-0.32995322346687317,
-0.32493144273757935,
0.3333456814289093,
-0.05463214963674545,
-0.17880453169345856,
0.05892748013138771,
-0.4038965106010437,
0.3050740361213684,
0.10419471561908722,
-0.18596725165843964,
1.0879992246627808,
0.26780790090560913,
-0.6271088719367981,
0.24039746820926666,
0.37431660294532776,
-0.20491711795330048,
0.37421688437461853,
-0.3287627696990967,
0.150183767080307,
-0.2971545159816742,
0.39437904953956604,
-0.6503432989120483,
-0.3610377609729767,
0.19826319813728333,
-0.151434063911438,
0.10630727559328079,
0.4156439006328583,
-0.6646276116371155,
-0.29775097966194153,
-0.09734959155321121,
0.2151934802532196,
0.5796921253204346,
-0.7400904893875122,
0.9035293459892273,
0.26533451676368713,
-0.33103784918785095,
0.2440524846315384,
-0.7732014656066895,
0.38575151562690735,
-0.48659342527389526,
-0.6124508380889893,
0.07060635834932327,
-0.4165722131729126,
-0.045851171016693115,
-0.22696402668952942,
-0.10279752314090729,
0.257547527551651,
0.39867112040519714,
0.1605677753686905,
-0.074852854013443,
-0.03086705505847931,
-0.07302422821521759,
0.021299012005329132,
-0.18949629366397858,
0.15233369171619415,
-0.4653383195400238,
0.6209813356399536,
0.09090565890073776,
-0.437211275100708,
-0.8280466794967651,
0.47443974018096924,
1.0033321380615234,
-0.3129904568195343,
0.5616693496704102,
0.13561241328716278,
-0.11919890344142914,
-0.3238908052444458,
-0.3638022541999817,
0.21397407352924347,
-0.5240865349769592,
0.2153715193271637,
-0.09200330823659897,
-0.6037610769271851,
0.3866700232028961,
-0.4181952476501465,
0.18116866052150726,
0.6742677688598633,
0.18994545936584473,
-0.11587958037853241,
0.8765694499015808,
0.47941383719444275,
0.07585417479276657,
0.6728679537773132,
-0.45581379532814026,
0.6309385299682617,
-0.6535340547561646,
-0.27129313349723816,
-0.548158586025238,
0.1928543746471405,
-0.8136997222900391,
-0.34699729084968567,
0.09242119640111923,
0.06989873945713043,
-0.8423442840576172,
0.11369967460632324,
-0.7603024244308472,
0.23992425203323364,
0.5561627149581909,
0.11766892671585083,
0.07234828174114227,
-0.032862018793821335,
0.10280602425336838,
0.33847102522850037,
-1.0414844751358032,
-0.5449328422546387,
0.43796950578689575,
0.4784802794456482,
0.3744348883628845,
0.06536324322223663,
0.6537048816680908,
0.6540173292160034,
0.3688039183616638,
-0.8019498586654663,
0.6515361666679382,
-0.30355629324913025,
-0.2754802107810974,
-0.31508705019950867,
-0.7636637687683105,
-0.5736194252967834,
-0.097371906042099,
-0.007555918302386999,
-0.4066234529018402,
0.08934718370437622,
0.07007044553756714,
-0.43617719411849976,
0.5347797274589539,
-0.6096253395080566,
0.857122004032135,
-0.604841947555542,
-0.5491229891777039,
-0.4955008029937744,
-0.26574504375457764,
0.025319082662463188,
-0.01711604930460453,
0.37239891290664673,
-0.21300721168518066,
0.2691200375556946,
0.5572062134742737,
-0.5962473154067993,
0.6167943477630615,
-0.4113215506076813,
-0.28969433903694153,
0.4979599416255951,
-0.25417661666870117,
0.6776397228240967,
-0.12401482462882996,
-0.40111881494522095,
0.3646458089351654,
-0.32692694664001465,
-0.585032045841217,
-0.3042941987514496,
0.6871525049209595,
-0.6394583582878113,
-0.5419830083847046,
-0.3871084451675415,
-0.418927401304245,
0.0010366252390667796,
0.46624165773391724,
0.43389052152633667,
-0.3500123620033264,
-0.32715940475463867,
0.2183336317539215,
0.6223464012145996,
-0.6758185625076294,
0.24912647902965546,
0.040536027401685715,
0.08408316224813461,
-0.5969600677490234,
1.1269596815109253,
-0.05196256563067436,
0.5706624388694763,
-0.011623131111264229,
0.5350162982940674,
-0.23061104118824005,
-0.7262194156646729,
-0.4875519871711731,
-0.3119065761566162,
-0.824586808681488,
-0.2785149812698364,
-0.6004525423049927,
-0.31553521752357483,
-0.23751188814640045,
-0.6067080497741699,
-0.2436412274837494,
-0.009480016306042671,
-0.330476313829422,
-0.48861443996429443,
0.4835532009601593,
0.5831690430641174,
-0.017675552517175674,
0.4767177700996399,
-0.39288124442100525,
0.351595014333725,
0.230583056807518,
0.16049762070178986,
-0.011863588355481625,
0.12564685940742493,
0.10016772896051407,
0.23020237684249878,
-0.2003055363893509,
-0.28791722655296326,
0.39794212579727173,
0.571073591709137,
0.537973940372467,
0.6988785862922668,
-0.04670128971338272,
0.5769988894462585,
-0.36530056595802307,
0.8960573673248291,
0.545289158821106,
-0.9487879872322083,
0.4726710319519043,
-0.5623598694801331,
0.22373603284358978,
0.5009244680404663,
-0.09709551185369492,
-0.5303798913955688,
-0.45676565170288086,
-0.6121161580085754,
-1.187667727470398,
0.0029977019876241684,
0.29458126425743103,
0.20997005701065063,
-0.35525965690612793,
0.40354210138320923,
0.26445186138153076,
0.2078416794538498,
-0.3699203431606293,
-0.016487987712025642,
-0.7220383882522583,
-0.31625282764434814,
-0.09836103767156601,
0.11498913168907166,
-0.017727160826325417,
-0.24215742945671082,
0.8443942666053772,
-0.3001716136932373,
0.250081866979599,
-0.06469470262527466,
0.4171450138092041,
-0.06653942167758942,
0.2142401486635208,
0.10304069519042969,
0.24875453114509583,
0.03375493362545967,
-0.008614557795226574,
0.19700667262077332,
-0.21631832420825958,
0.2627933621406555,
0.0196223147213459,
-0.7889866828918457,
-0.46183085441589355,
0.13191431760787964,
0.5419198870658875,
0.030811015516519547,
-0.35857224464416504,
0.0864768773317337,
-0.12151209264993668,
-0.1630178540945053,
-0.3759186565876007,
0.3131696581840515,
0.16927315294742584,
0.038069915026426315,
0.23315541446208954,
0.418073832988739,
0.01601860672235489,
-0.46053093671798706,
0.4295346438884735,
0.53273606300354,
0.11976854503154755,
0.11617789417505264,
1.2082899808883667,
0.7235812544822693,
-0.09836313873529434,
0.6201416254043579,
-0.44443127512931824,
-0.39439812302589417,
1.0613696575164795,
0.4355008602142334,
0.9298058748245239,
0.15037792921066284,
0.24952653050422668,
0.4508485496044159,
-0.0020311186090111732,
-0.10222537070512772,
0.10558604449033737,
-0.352263867855072,
-0.869860827922821,
-0.241605743765831,
-0.8742274641990662,
-0.14847153425216675,
-0.11138337105512619,
-0.5318851470947266,
-0.02744905836880207,
-1.1060699224472046,
0.03845033422112465,
0.07545675337314606,
0.005656978581100702,
-0.6795327067375183,
0.2901657521724701,
0.2810509204864502,
0.7909221649169922,
-0.8386473655700684,
0.5975621342658997,
0.3459511399269104,
-0.4475352168083191,
-0.7686140537261963,
0.05984582006931305,
0.10174065828323364,
-0.7140932679176331,
0.35901135206222534,
0.3201289772987366,
-0.4851880967617035,
0.36653101444244385,
-0.5850143432617188,
-0.7280949354171753,
1.4085705280303955,
0.42558982968330383,
-0.7722976803779602,
0.2078038901090622,
-0.09032995253801346,
0.17724674940109253,
-0.19682201743125916,
0.03967129439115524,
0.40667858719825745,
1.030043125152588,
0.2545301616191864,
-0.11706973612308502,
0.10742039233446121,
-0.2855584919452667,
0.22176991403102875,
0.1269432157278061,
-1.1390260457992554,
0.25503721833229065,
-0.06999382376670837,
-0.7635055780410767,
0.42669087648391724,
0.9102176427841187,
0.19421973824501038,
0.45614996552467346,
0.6288313865661621,
0.7393683791160583,
1.021939992904663,
0.009373458102345467,
1.103227972984314,
-0.6324307918548584,
0.4503951966762543,
0.6703100800514221,
-0.3985724449157715,
0.43879440426826477,
0.3842597007751465,
-0.06625679135322571,
0.23306488990783691,
0.8509700894355774,
-0.2952286899089813,
0.6351548433303833,
0.27721452713012695,
-0.8156450986862183,
-0.22996780276298523,
-0.47004154324531555,
0.017784150317311287,
0.3224540054798126,
0.33689039945602417,
-0.017359064891934395,
-0.2617790997028351,
0.09584341198205948,
0.20860017836093903,
0.2635577321052551,
-0.308428019285202,
0.704262375831604,
-0.10977467894554138,
-0.5790471434593201,
0.03525305166840553,
-0.08552198112010956,
0.819231390953064,
-0.5956909656524658,
-0.14993222057819366,
-0.19403763115406036,
0.09627038985490799,
-0.3372935950756073,
-0.5205269455909729,
0.3136303722858429,
0.12037532031536102,
-0.06808800995349884,
-0.8279851675033569,
0.14196443557739258,
-0.16781871020793915,
-0.7659698128700256,
0.422861248254776,
0.06263785064220428,
0.0008741156198084354,
0.3455844521522522,
-0.6957328915596008,
-0.10638878494501114,
0.3805224597454071,
0.1055794507265091,
0.08724557608366013,
0.41239768266677856,
0.17354071140289307,
0.6141728162765503,
1.0045497417449951,
0.35613536834716797,
-0.2094953954219818,
0.20148925483226776,
0.7902237772941589,
-0.33600276708602905,
-0.7818604111671448,
-0.48806437849998474,
0.29908695816993713,
-0.05569228157401085,
-0.17827215790748596,
0.8099825978279114,
0.5771260857582092,
0.7610840797424316,
0.3824566900730133,
1.3270089626312256,
-0.3198957145214081,
-0.14559093117713928,
-0.6002178192138672,
0.9631001949310303,
-0.26240503787994385,
0.3884525001049042,
0.17903171479701996,
-0.9767944812774658,
-0.13005349040031433,
0.6789281964302063,
-0.2753906548023224,
0.1524847447872162,
0.2561340034008026,
0.7837442755699158,
-0.0684877261519432,
0.07402514666318893,
0.31932881474494934,
0.1826496571302414,
0.8199402093887329,
0.07027536630630493,
0.5170773267745972,
0.1055355817079544,
-0.023187004029750824,
-0.08034779876470566,
-0.3552207946777344,
0.026457540690898895,
-1.0204834938049316,
-0.10896140336990356,
-0.122368723154068,
-0.34393277764320374,
-0.013929405249655247,
0.3468945324420929,
0.868592381477356,
0.6411576271057129,
-0.9459331631660461,
0.2108658254146576,
-1.1821372509002686,
-0.11464130133390427,
-0.2969680726528168,
-0.3417859375476837,
0.509579598903656,
-0.23621515929698944,
-0.42992842197418213,
0.5798636674880981,
0.32069092988967896,
-0.1278068870306015,
-0.49789902567863464,
-0.3974143862724304,
-0.14669816195964813,
0.32529038190841675,
0.4333404004573822,
0.41596248745918274,
-0.4659143388271332,
-0.7797001004219055,
-0.32348012924194336,
0.17852002382278442,
0.02696705237030983,
0.5324939489364624,
-0.5349105596542358,
0.400559663772583,
0.47248128056526184,
0.8240329623222351,
0.15828025341033936,
0.2016015350818634,
0.6887947916984558,
-0.3011801540851593,
0.11912863701581955,
0.41223907470703125,
0.4219679832458496,
0.6663790345191956,
-0.7691855430603027,
0.17526930570602417,
0.04373816028237343,
-0.8013024926185608,
-0.34322449564933777,
0.4070352613925934,
-0.7247255444526672,
-0.25327953696250916,
1.1811400651931763,
-0.30744412541389465,
-0.16234426200389862,
0.1723429560661316,
0.01073021162301302,
0.43534812331199646,
-0.5479989647865295,
0.741502046585083,
0.4262901246547699,
-0.11146040260791779,
-0.2699196934700012,
-0.6476058959960938,
0.23623064160346985,
0.5836568474769592,
-1.0570358037948608,
0.3971325159072876,
0.6879839301109314,
0.1325015276670456,
0.24929603934288025,
0.24821634590625763,
0.2915789783000946,
-0.004559747409075499,
0.31279438734054565,
0.19915467500686646,
0.06332133710384369,
-0.4016638398170471,
-0.23427170515060425,
-0.062346335500478745,
0.03945430368185043,
-0.09639041870832443
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.12881v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.12881v1
|
Agent-FLAN: Designing Data and Methods of Effective Agent Tuning for Large Language Models
| 2024-03-19T16:26:10 | 2024-03-19T16:26:10 |
Zehui Chen, Kuikun Liu, Qiuchen Wang, Wenwei Zhang, Jiangning Liu, Dahua Lin, Kai Chen, Feng Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Open-sourced Large Language Models (LLMs) have achieved great success in
various NLP tasks, however, they are still far inferior to API-based models
when acting as agents. How to integrate agent ability into general LLMs becomes
a crucial and urgent problem. This paper first delivers three key observations:
(1) the current agent training corpus is entangled with both formats following
and agent reasoning, which significantly shifts from the distribution of its
pre-training data; (2) LLMs exhibit different learning speeds on the
capabilities required by agent tasks; and (3) current approaches have
side-effects when improving agent abilities by introducing hallucinations.
Based on the above findings, we propose Agent-FLAN to effectively Fine-tune
LANguage models for Agents. Through careful decomposition and redesign of the
training corpus, Agent-FLAN enables Llama2-7B to outperform prior best works by
3.5\% across various agent evaluation datasets. With comprehensively
constructed negative samples, Agent-FLAN greatly alleviates the hallucination
issues based on our established evaluation benchmark. Besides, it consistently
improves the agent capability of LLMs when scaling model sizes while slightly
enhancing the general capability of LLMs. The code will be available at
https://github.com/InternLM/Agent-FLAN.
|
[
-0.5317530632019043,
-0.6622952818870544,
0.6292403936386108,
0.044465359300374985,
-0.11320172995328903,
0.01801319420337677,
-0.658024787902832,
-0.7988479733467102,
0.43978363275527954,
0.8358665704727173,
-0.28340664505958557,
-0.4726319909095764,
-0.3454940915107727,
0.15415720641613007,
-0.3241560757160187,
0.850300669670105,
0.11564208567142487,
0.08550753444433212,
-0.0233943909406662,
-0.034281693398952484,
-0.3319290280342102,
-0.3529641628265381,
-0.7435804009437561,
-0.41321051120758057,
0.5926727056503296,
0.25792789459228516,
0.9602901935577393,
0.7085292339324951,
0.3981677293777466,
0.36353471875190735,
0.05810510739684105,
0.633206307888031,
-0.5984556078910828,
0.3136996030807495,
-0.34568482637405396,
-0.5062388181686401,
-0.7779301404953003,
-0.09616363048553467,
0.5349866151809692,
0.4141838550567627,
-0.03877352178096771,
-0.07389562577009201,
-0.16536177694797516,
0.5341490507125854,
-0.4966185986995697,
0.22025172412395477,
-0.8244137763977051,
-0.15961953997612,
-0.03760382533073425,
-0.4286794066429138,
-0.4644083082675934,
-0.15524296462535858,
0.005441222805529833,
-0.6111177802085876,
0.35016894340515137,
0.08467470854520798,
0.7060559391975403,
0.49901360273361206,
-0.32099297642707825,
-0.503987193107605,
-0.8427031636238098,
0.6710808873176575,
-0.7249675989151001,
0.26329731941223145,
0.46813395619392395,
0.38848066329956055,
-0.3161635994911194,
-0.48863860964775085,
-0.5171762108802795,
-0.5522868633270264,
0.06963843107223511,
-0.3366911709308624,
0.15089984238147736,
0.27358126640319824,
0.06931374967098236,
0.2878125011920929,
-0.562859058380127,
0.22759133577346802,
-0.1085405945777893,
-0.15770891308784485,
0.8643656373023987,
0.09909573197364807,
0.1656351536512375,
0.4279750883579254,
-0.019726229831576347,
-0.38625919818878174,
-0.5149641633033752,
-0.3756115436553955,
0.578697144985199,
0.7107352018356323,
0.26909592747688293,
0.5562208294868469,
-0.1278914362192154,
0.57855623960495,
-0.11230113357305527,
-0.07753031700849533,
0.2636915147304535,
0.05991769954562187,
-0.13825051486492157,
0.04838663339614868,
0.3981205224990845,
0.06768560409545898,
0.5251885652542114,
-0.4742142856121063,
-0.6443201303482056,
0.16203227639198303,
0.5301718711853027,
-0.6830642223358154,
0.09188789129257202,
0.5089547038078308,
-0.2062247395515442,
-0.3497474789619446,
0.09403427690267563,
-0.6833421587944031,
-0.6633784174919128,
-0.5996599793434143,
0.5127676129341125,
-0.3609660863876343,
-0.6179150938987732,
0.2926522195339203,
-0.0252686720341444,
0.38040438294410706,
0.3366931676864624,
-0.9012152552604675,
0.3139002323150635,
1.0517414808273315,
0.8422656059265137,
-0.11359615623950958,
-0.5578818321228027,
-0.6119884848594666,
-0.06557197868824005,
-0.605558454990387,
0.9129811525344849,
-0.6703898906707764,
0.03341712802648544,
0.2655109763145447,
0.09925641119480133,
-0.11502184718847275,
-0.7761437296867371,
0.2663639783859253,
-0.4758816361427307,
-0.3403239846229553,
-0.2137143909931183,
-0.5993394255638123,
-0.110959991812706,
0.0427011214196682,
-0.7207055687904358,
0.6512571573257446,
0.25499531626701355,
-0.20064765214920044,
0.11308985948562622,
-0.7178440690040588,
-0.4856764078140259,
-0.08727848529815674,
0.08819781988859177,
-0.2959291934967041,
0.2491431087255478,
0.13682213425636292,
0.448698490858078,
-0.27799201011657715,
0.20299270749092102,
-0.3873418867588043,
-0.577165961265564,
0.28885602951049805,
-0.09932813048362732,
0.5773072242736816,
0.3820487856864929,
-0.22364509105682373,
0.37400856614112854,
-0.799806535243988,
0.03932494297623634,
0.2153574526309967,
0.07874961197376251,
-0.1821080893278122,
-0.03354286402463913,
0.11290692538022995,
-0.043239131569862366,
0.09464861452579498,
-0.06230735778808594,
0.2183467000722885,
-0.795208215713501,
0.2891889810562134,
0.7658417224884033,
-0.2613981068134308,
0.5947852730751038,
-0.5605722069740295,
0.6431966423988342,
-0.34461313486099243,
0.10599453002214432,
0.13594631850719452,
-0.21165426075458527,
-0.9064598083496094,
-0.31064140796661377,
0.04121897369623184,
0.2682410478591919,
-0.7488972544670105,
0.6350960731506348,
-0.16735731065273285,
-0.5719622373580933,
-0.5677576065063477,
0.30172669887542725,
0.021646026521921158,
0.027859434485435486,
0.33895817399024963,
-0.09938260912895203,
-0.4678589403629303,
-0.6449796557426453,
-0.17713771760463715,
-0.1355409473180771,
-0.10860782861709595,
0.007094413507729769,
0.6080746054649353,
-0.3286457359790802,
0.6861081719398499,
-0.2242983877658844,
-0.48479998111724854,
-0.40206560492515564,
-0.25253620743751526,
-0.06945692747831345,
0.29721736907958984,
0.6580103635787964,
-0.4234101474285126,
-0.2859404981136322,
0.19098632037639618,
-0.6273085474967957,
-0.1962975561618805,
-0.0810527577996254,
-0.3075862526893616,
0.42189955711364746,
0.382276326417923,
-0.8966324329376221,
0.3061583638191223,
0.25997310876846313,
-0.443395733833313,
0.5251755714416504,
-0.1869727373123169,
-0.14913390576839447,
-0.9163598418235779,
-0.10543079674243927,
-0.19762441515922546,
-0.2047284096479416,
-0.9092389345169067,
0.3067626357078552,
-0.19835567474365234,
0.09732905775308609,
-0.3039393424987793,
0.786747395992279,
-0.5476967692375183,
-0.22179952263832092,
-0.7204903364181519,
0.2974519729614258,
-0.10626909136772156,
0.462828129529953,
0.016237061470746994,
0.6563266515731812,
0.5769354701042175,
-0.5592299699783325,
0.4276909828186035,
0.051741380244493484,
-0.21287041902542114,
0.29790186882019043,
-0.49913397431373596,
0.4113180339336395,
-0.2533162832260132,
0.12877660989761353,
-0.62248295545578,
-0.3259078562259674,
0.36137598752975464,
-0.16384296119213104,
0.40014538168907166,
0.15013593435287476,
-0.5163987278938293,
0.029136743396520615,
-0.3886117935180664,
0.10761947929859161,
0.3153715431690216,
-0.6624157428741455,
0.8387592434883118,
0.26854652166366577,
0.238439679145813,
-0.5991063714027405,
-0.5234243273735046,
0.15645046532154083,
-0.28426554799079895,
-0.6470609307289124,
0.23502779006958008,
0.009924388490617275,
-0.468456506729126,
-0.117792509496212,
-0.03319358453154564,
0.12713155150413513,
0.0018218567129224539,
0.06713838130235672,
-0.14838428795337677,
-0.4229776859283447,
0.4630563259124756,
-0.04861656203866005,
-0.07499085366725922,
-0.10976728796958923,
-0.3514268100261688,
0.690820038318634,
-0.3336622416973114,
-0.30876535177230835,
-0.19441351294517517,
0.13105538487434387,
0.6302137970924377,
-0.33671653270721436,
0.9311005473136902,
0.6167124509811401,
-0.3210599720478058,
-0.8055502772331238,
-0.6530358791351318,
-0.39119967818260193,
-0.44855809211730957,
0.4175976514816284,
-0.3503260314464569,
-0.6639525294303894,
0.6058520674705505,
0.05394373834133148,
0.04757162928581238,
0.26647132635116577,
0.645557165145874,
0.2301144003868103,
0.7412610650062561,
0.7076466083526611,
-0.06074900925159454,
0.6025451421737671,
-0.3626813292503357,
0.15474432706832886,
-0.4818815588951111,
0.0033430042676627636,
-0.4740721583366394,
-0.18883366882801056,
-0.4689602553844452,
-0.5355384945869446,
-0.032005079090595245,
-0.12381622195243835,
-0.26244744658470154,
0.15708720684051514,
-0.42685845494270325,
0.6216753721237183,
0.20263713598251343,
0.10440963506698608,
0.2869516611099243,
0.10182347893714905,
0.3496459722518921,
0.46358442306518555,
-0.3665328919887543,
-0.7818201184272766,
1.2319817543029785,
0.5513531565666199,
0.8191707134246826,
0.22600576281547546,
0.524105429649353,
0.3617323040962219,
0.22193238139152527,
-0.8502374887466431,
0.6044948101043701,
0.07837618887424469,
-0.5680824518203735,
-0.6658271551132202,
-0.15085867047309875,
-1.0116361379623413,
0.5021392703056335,
-0.034819647669792175,
-0.6461197137832642,
0.19110536575317383,
-0.024077605456113815,
-0.053480129688978195,
0.1934576779603958,
-0.6669745445251465,
0.7139782905578613,
-0.27700042724609375,
-0.298666775226593,
-0.3842446208000183,
-0.3478763997554779,
0.2564407289028168,
-0.19155000150203705,
-0.05403755232691765,
-0.3198206126689911,
-0.25501763820648193,
0.2979157567024231,
-0.8554551601409912,
0.8437514901161194,
-0.19334156811237335,
-0.4433373808860779,
0.39326512813568115,
-0.027250614017248154,
0.6774519681930542,
0.07886810600757599,
-0.2802398204803467,
0.11591684818267822,
0.025004902854561806,
-0.44383901357650757,
-0.9011205434799194,
0.5700740814208984,
-0.9715303778648376,
-0.555245578289032,
-0.23352693021297455,
-0.5265014171600342,
-0.2421378344297409,
-0.1046237125992775,
-0.006375621072947979,
0.3642043173313141,
-0.07032402604818344,
0.059682898223400116,
0.5870257616043091,
-0.07335392385721207,
0.2869463562965393,
0.595960795879364,
-0.5436785221099854,
-0.3212449550628662,
1.056795358657837,
0.058640774339437485,
0.22393904626369476,
0.2518867254257202,
0.014754744246602058,
-0.31499388813972473,
-0.5369314551353455,
-0.17677795886993408,
0.5380746126174927,
-0.8269500136375427,
-0.19263479113578796,
-0.42616862058639526,
-0.32758629322052,
-0.47806039452552795,
-0.19202785193920135,
-0.614888072013855,
-0.12592874467372894,
-0.43995413184165955,
-0.03480060026049614,
0.4099155366420746,
0.7558916211128235,
-0.057539843022823334,
0.38613516092300415,
-0.15762829780578613,
0.361476868391037,
0.08044669777154922,
0.5530021786689758,
0.260590136051178,
-0.6040098071098328,
-0.4442122280597687,
-0.022002486512064934,
0.03066639043390751,
-0.8424940705299377,
0.45489612221717834,
0.31542178988456726,
0.5768252015113831,
0.5408704280853271,
0.08121832460165024,
0.450134813785553,
-0.09011033922433853,
0.4386917054653168,
-0.40269678831100464,
-0.8126814961433411,
0.5105264782905579,
-0.34555739164352417,
0.08848360925912857,
0.5136829614639282,
0.024001356214284897,
-0.21151646971702576,
-0.6308162212371826,
-0.23437689244747162,
-0.6479511260986328,
0.7599682807922363,
0.2549488842487335,
0.05852476879954338,
0.09929001331329346,
0.46917641162872314,
0.3091574013233185,
0.22862054407596588,
-0.6593392491340637,
-0.0875689834356308,
-0.2183857560157776,
-0.16224634647369385,
-0.53160160779953,
-0.1360592395067215,
0.03221869468688965,
-0.2964734435081482,
0.8553768992424011,
-0.3439486026763916,
0.15955661237239838,
0.1176917776465416,
-0.42943501472473145,
-0.16601033508777618,
0.11592788994312286,
0.7827258110046387,
0.7736265063285828,
-0.2497277557849884,
0.2182680368423462,
0.14261099696159363,
-0.45329469442367554,
0.21633857488632202,
-0.06870003044605255,
0.099699966609478,
-0.08722880482673645,
0.6234489679336548,
0.8883101940155029,
-0.24306327104568481,
-0.8266671895980835,
0.3449951112270355,
-0.05829505994915962,
-0.27429771423339844,
-0.5639920830726624,
0.4447440803050995,
-0.07623659819364548,
0.5496594905853271,
0.30368921160697937,
-0.09821585565805435,
-0.1067001223564148,
-0.47115951776504517,
-0.07664094865322113,
0.41544264554977417,
-0.1722283661365509,
-0.3797762095928192,
0.39541417360305786,
0.03410843759775162,
-0.64112788438797,
0.41726624965667725,
-0.3346768915653229,
-0.29012176394462585,
0.652441680431366,
0.6355523467063904,
1.1430996656417847,
-0.33437997102737427,
0.22361816465854645,
0.09057210385799408,
0.5828998684883118,
-0.31994056701660156,
0.2308923453092575,
0.0671156495809555,
-0.7902505993843079,
-0.38660699129104614,
-0.7173226475715637,
-0.2858372926712036,
0.4120645821094513,
-0.21039608120918274,
0.433992862701416,
-0.4082808494567871,
-0.160857155919075,
-0.16029812395572662,
0.256536066532135,
-0.6271328926086426,
-0.09080275148153305,
0.12890738248825073,
0.7329527139663696,
-0.7825687527656555,
0.929469883441925,
0.6675112247467041,
-0.5582567453384399,
-0.6706576943397522,
0.1421774923801422,
-0.19577787816524506,
-0.586491048336029,
0.24121282994747162,
0.26080161333084106,
-0.31745681166648865,
-0.03197576105594635,
-0.6580406427383423,
-0.8600955605506897,
0.9211717247962952,
0.7585688233375549,
-0.44596314430236816,
-0.025400225073099136,
0.4666878581047058,
0.9172379970550537,
-0.6637059450149536,
0.39860108494758606,
0.8156091570854187,
0.6502370834350586,
-0.1259593963623047,
-0.8222023844718933,
0.10289716720581055,
-0.2151889204978943,
0.14639343321323395,
-0.009447198361158371,
-0.7750137448310852,
0.618341863155365,
-0.06743175536394119,
-0.01817483641207218,
0.17176000773906708,
0.664126992225647,
0.018972568213939667,
0.3614950180053711,
0.601655900478363,
0.2675282061100006,
0.9161362051963806,
0.1268668919801712,
0.6926727294921875,
-0.2915102243423462,
0.10822091996669769,
0.9691658020019531,
-0.48743754625320435,
0.7889235615730286,
0.346923291683197,
0.00008315999002661556,
0.32810309529304504,
0.506649911403656,
-0.024068865925073624,
0.27479615807533264,
0.41815996170043945,
-0.11761748045682907,
-0.3558826148509979,
-0.05089724063873291,
-0.4188341200351715,
0.7526407241821289,
0.39488404989242554,
-0.23515409231185913,
-0.01108941063284874,
0.1880830079317093,
-0.17352670431137085,
0.13109862804412842,
-0.1694898158311844,
0.7288999557495117,
0.10084249824285507,
-0.6197431087493896,
0.7882622480392456,
-0.1037321388721466,
0.48687002062797546,
-0.5564426779747009,
-0.054385680705308914,
-0.43441861867904663,
0.30943310260772705,
-0.20083913207054138,
-0.22344860434532166,
0.3161383867263794,
-0.1656772643327713,
0.04820060729980469,
0.03779395669698715,
0.8276557326316833,
-0.41614454984664917,
-0.3228532075881958,
0.5466293096542358,
0.48023492097854614,
0.5113301873207092,
-0.429519385099411,
-0.38168397545814514,
0.26139071583747864,
-0.2897319793701172,
-0.3590519428253174,
0.32890376448631287,
0.4739220440387726,
0.012398981489241123,
0.7837443351745605,
0.4108162224292755,
0.2848932147026062,
-0.18838390707969666,
0.41491058468818665,
0.6977638602256775,
-0.6979453563690186,
-0.2697181701660156,
-0.8030427694320679,
0.21159668266773224,
-0.003307520877569914,
-0.16253438591957092,
0.4809771776199341,
0.42666029930114746,
0.6837354898452759,
-0.1567591279745102,
0.5268744826316833,
0.28161874413490295,
0.32908445596694946,
-0.5685901045799255,
0.9050148725509644,
-0.7236083149909973,
0.5204667448997498,
-0.23677149415016174,
-1.2523467540740967,
-0.20692257583141327,
0.63572758436203,
-0.10482756048440933,
0.30696311593055725,
0.692090630531311,
1.286095142364502,
0.13432727754116058,
-0.002171657746657729,
0.5494140386581421,
0.19915002584457397,
0.4931049644947052,
0.38003605604171753,
1.1490293741226196,
-0.3114410936832428,
0.49939432740211487,
-0.11861356347799301,
0.02153235860168934,
-0.5647405982017517,
-0.6240646243095398,
-1.284045696258545,
-0.6915395855903625,
-0.19897642731666565,
-0.24736925959587097,
0.16933917999267578,
1.1702040433883667,
0.6619985103607178,
-0.8049103021621704,
-0.35691002011299133,
-0.12236708402633667,
0.2527671158313751,
-0.3254677653312683,
-0.18434379994869232,
0.2811362147331238,
-0.7357587218284607,
-0.7385298013687134,
0.5604410171508789,
0.11625882983207703,
0.07225782424211502,
-0.6672354340553284,
-0.3565222918987274,
0.1146341934800148,
0.2389102280139923,
0.6156062483787537,
0.15769335627555847,
-1.0626745223999023,
-0.38562238216400146,
-0.03873753920197487,
-0.09133671224117279,
-0.054052166640758514,
0.7360231876373291,
-0.5939230918884277,
0.3590080142021179,
0.21314123272895813,
0.5515594482421875,
0.27705657482147217,
-0.12199154496192932,
0.5606439113616943,
-0.4311380386352539,
0.3124914765357971,
0.24200168251991272,
0.11235637962818146,
0.23595401644706726,
-0.3849826455116272,
0.7182105183601379,
-0.04488202929496765,
-0.6468715667724609,
-1.1241101026535034,
-0.03229614719748497,
-0.8926901817321777,
-0.502780020236969,
1.3103762865066528,
0.34643813967704773,
-0.26867035031318665,
-0.17200621962547302,
-0.33635491132736206,
0.31886011362075806,
-0.2940751314163208,
0.8207482695579529,
0.5801457762718201,
0.004767175763845444,
0.06807716935873032,
-0.5460125803947449,
0.6872101426124573,
0.24366331100463867,
-0.7994866967201233,
0.19997476041316986,
0.44784292578697205,
-0.02324407547712326,
0.0031174474861472845,
0.6728812456130981,
0.2999102473258972,
0.10771308094263077,
0.2862430214881897,
0.2507110834121704,
-0.3154865503311157,
-0.724700927734375,
-0.4757826328277588,
0.17894071340560913,
0.4545689523220062,
0.15934452414512634
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.12862v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.12862v1
|
Epistemology of Language Models: Do Language Models Have Holistic Knowledge?
| 2024-03-19T16:06:10 | 2024-03-19T16:06:10 |
Minsu Kim, James Thorne
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper investigates the inherent knowledge in language models from the
perspective of epistemological holism. The purpose of this paper is to explore
whether LLMs exhibit characteristics consistent with epistemological holism.
These characteristics suggest that core knowledge, such as general scientific
knowledge, each plays a specific role, serving as the foundation of our
knowledge system and being difficult to revise. To assess these traits related
to holism, we created a scientific reasoning dataset and examined the
epistemology of language models through three tasks: Abduction, Revision, and
Argument Generation. In the abduction task, the language models explained
situations while avoiding revising the core knowledge. However, in other tasks,
the language models were revealed not to distinguish between core and
peripheral knowledge, showing an incomplete alignment with holistic knowledge
principles.
|
[
-0.11830680817365646,
-0.98958820104599,
0.83821702003479,
-0.05063183605670929,
0.019650505855679512,
0.15164728462696075,
-0.21831892430782318,
-0.39197471737861633,
-0.14256872236728668,
0.7322257161140442,
-0.28913789987564087,
-0.5082661509513855,
-0.40554481744766235,
0.11646619439125061,
-0.19488351047039032,
0.8264627456665039,
0.01687154918909073,
-0.09604444354772568,
-0.3868257701396942,
-0.19700026512145996,
0.22366896271705627,
-0.6838386058807373,
0.014615429565310478,
-0.5481922626495361,
0.0921175628900528,
0.23975393176078796,
0.6069137454032898,
0.8746787309646606,
0.3961787819862366,
0.17825213074684143,
-0.4959220290184021,
0.0726582258939743,
-0.19343464076519012,
0.2458896040916443,
-0.44296443462371826,
-0.774078369140625,
-0.4464932978153229,
-0.12154584378004074,
0.45439276099205017,
1.1699566841125488,
-0.24553877115249634,
0.2160591185092926,
0.0055064857006073,
0.6266974210739136,
-0.34040066599845886,
0.23423656821250916,
-0.7389191389083862,
-0.020299971103668213,
0.08722899854183197,
-0.09437073022127151,
-0.22108455002307892,
-0.35485589504241943,
0.6033115386962891,
-0.6010187268257141,
0.3707616329193115,
0.2512282729148865,
0.9381933212280273,
0.1886136829853058,
-0.4512737989425659,
-0.4866084158420563,
-0.8671453595161438,
0.7844347953796387,
-0.8206990957260132,
0.09117613732814789,
0.6863498687744141,
0.045073624700307846,
0.3508707582950592,
-0.2793678343296051,
-0.5233892798423767,
-0.3227105736732483,
-0.02939542755484581,
-0.029022200033068657,
-0.1958065927028656,
0.0139854047447443,
0.3753557801246643,
0.3348129391670227,
-0.47512778639793396,
0.01132956799119711,
-0.18662121891975403,
-0.13106584548950195,
0.4779220223426819,
0.12765583395957947,
0.4702768623828888,
-0.14510418474674225,
-0.28144872188568115,
0.37566012144088745,
-1.1782876253128052,
0.07274854183197021,
0.40001219511032104,
0.023926133289933205,
-0.030284777283668518,
0.7169133424758911,
-0.247829869389534,
0.8007475137710571,
0.042239174246788025,
-0.3694721460342407,
0.047813307493925095,
-0.3732262849807739,
-0.15710437297821045,
0.08052751421928406,
0.19134703278541565,
0.019507722929120064,
0.3657480478286743,
-0.33259662985801697,
-0.1217697411775589,
0.23922787606716156,
0.24880282580852509,
-0.22631613910198212,
0.116785429418087,
0.031372036784887314,
-0.23897352814674377,
-0.2644069194793701,
-0.11061269044876099,
-0.20847316086292267,
0.027758417651057243,
-0.40595442056655884,
0.07606759667396545,
-0.3696611225605011,
-0.42404186725616455,
0.21891793608665466,
-0.017894219607114792,
0.33738481998443604,
0.39035579562187195,
-0.9797964096069336,
0.3678944408893585,
0.9584808349609375,
0.5945559740066528,
-0.08388227224349976,
-0.41866612434387207,
0.20528043806552887,
0.5288771986961365,
-0.1990458369255066,
0.8779383897781372,
-0.6047207713127136,
-0.32170432806015015,
0.07385534793138504,
0.05496222898364067,
0.03598622977733612,
-0.610470712184906,
0.1954863965511322,
-0.32047855854034424,
0.06878243386745453,
-0.6205386519432068,
-0.775217592716217,
-0.4759996831417084,
0.3705994486808777,
-0.30725908279418945,
0.7692936658859253,
0.05748501420021057,
-0.8147919774055481,
0.19797416031360626,
-0.4678650200366974,
-0.3292362093925476,
0.11021614819765091,
-0.16641224920749664,
-0.09465950727462769,
0.28578802943229675,
-0.26946917176246643,
0.44533011317253113,
-0.37535756826400757,
0.5609691143035889,
-0.3852081000804901,
-0.13487862050533295,
0.1909542977809906,
0.004507017321884632,
0.7543646693229675,
0.1869048923254013,
-0.3020005524158478,
-0.052775122225284576,
-0.7627149224281311,
-0.21225190162658691,
0.18374133110046387,
-0.4765777289867401,
-0.6957799196243286,
0.06101169437170029,
-0.4028392434120178,
0.1745462715625763,
0.2152286320924759,
-0.5239619016647339,
0.48563751578330994,
-0.6232316493988037,
0.4767591059207916,
0.5490943193435669,
0.04488281160593033,
0.7218120694160461,
-0.5944739580154419,
0.14721737802028656,
0.20441573858261108,
-0.06172650679945946,
-0.0447513572871685,
-0.722856342792511,
-1.0092158317565918,
0.23582160472869873,
-0.28264039754867554,
0.5629093647003174,
-0.35595011711120605,
0.41052937507629395,
-0.23761586844921112,
-0.367410808801651,
-0.5584247708320618,
0.36021074652671814,
0.5214008688926697,
0.4620923399925232,
0.15360549092292786,
0.06300380080938339,
-0.4731736481189728,
-1.1372727155685425,
-0.5264118313789368,
-0.4487435221672058,
0.08659357577562332,
0.13909105956554413,
0.7413769960403442,
-0.13371260464191437,
1.0673964023590088,
-0.3863067924976349,
0.2023697942495346,
-0.26782941818237305,
0.17792266607284546,
0.08767861872911453,
0.09789685159921646,
0.47222185134887695,
-0.5512247085571289,
-0.25849220156669617,
0.23326735198497772,
-1.1339298486709595,
-0.2445060908794403,
0.27369365096092224,
0.15514269471168518,
0.3273122012615204,
0.167970672249794,
-0.6412283182144165,
0.5290164351463318,
0.19765032827854156,
-0.4230569303035736,
0.670059859752655,
-0.28324684500694275,
-0.21736064553260803,
-1.0690670013427734,
-0.0006211864529177547,
0.06649819016456604,
-0.04887380450963974,
-0.9730455875396729,
0.03919399902224541,
-0.12469053268432617,
0.1971319615840912,
-0.4453916847705841,
0.5560534000396729,
-0.6289265751838684,
-0.15992730855941772,
-0.27703332901000977,
0.1663811355829239,
0.08720899373292923,
0.426869660615921,
0.4969870150089264,
0.1820821911096573,
0.5464105606079102,
-0.9152596592903137,
0.22649264335632324,
0.1344965696334839,
-0.3734038472175598,
0.5118602514266968,
-0.6168847680091858,
0.12487168610095978,
-0.25309979915618896,
-0.30205267667770386,
-0.8354208469390869,
-0.10665515065193176,
0.04896842688322067,
-0.1987200230360031,
0.10238825529813766,
0.007098470814526081,
-0.2690050005912781,
-0.08574751764535904,
0.025719264522194862,
-0.08671581745147705,
0.4963562488555908,
-0.1650855988264084,
0.40333446860313416,
0.5212363600730896,
-0.405294805765152,
-0.47430580854415894,
-0.6413256525993347,
-0.4269019663333893,
-0.3007318675518036,
-0.38724902272224426,
0.41497087478637695,
0.10059871524572372,
-1.1091617345809937,
0.25253593921661377,
-0.061648063361644745,
-0.03267517685890198,
0.29806724190711975,
0.4612628221511841,
0.3180246949195862,
-0.19086670875549316,
0.19025367498397827,
0.1906449794769287,
0.10856463015079498,
0.195017471909523,
-0.05538363382220268,
0.3897082805633545,
-0.4246346354484558,
-0.536178708076477,
-0.18965162336826324,
0.10198478400707245,
0.6348837018013,
0.3291991651058197,
0.6923832893371582,
-0.08497229218482971,
-0.5149779319763184,
-0.0038544947747141123,
-0.610032856464386,
-0.032814349979162216,
-0.3124079406261444,
0.23854713141918182,
-0.5151868462562561,
-0.9940289258956909,
0.6098301410675049,
0.0010378800798207521,
0.23481667041778564,
0.5507113337516785,
0.8069645762443542,
-0.19200466573238373,
0.5713674426078796,
0.454946905374527,
0.14650790393352509,
0.038512613624334335,
-0.29535192251205444,
0.15214549005031586,
-1.0235041379928589,
-0.20292559266090393,
-0.5731527805328369,
0.11492079496383667,
-0.19544674456119537,
-0.2164720743894577,
0.14435800909996033,
0.19665805995464325,
-0.6496541500091553,
0.25368571281433105,
-0.09905914217233658,
0.042124513536691666,
0.253555029630661,
-0.061528999358415604,
0.5978947281837463,
0.0800737589597702,
-0.32480406761169434,
0.13946515321731567,
-0.6189309358596802,
-1.1442811489105225,
1.1270499229431152,
0.3867354691028595,
0.8193711638450623,
0.2793195843696594,
0.4137497842311859,
0.03750551864504814,
0.37198251485824585,
-0.6440274119377136,
0.5468345284461975,
0.4471358358860016,
-0.866561233997345,
-0.29427334666252136,
-0.17976053059101105,
-0.5960614681243896,
0.24247896671295166,
-0.08536330610513687,
-0.8112729787826538,
0.0901232361793518,
0.11674501746892929,
-0.3319549560546875,
0.44924697279930115,
-0.37587958574295044,
0.37858569622039795,
-0.237736776471138,
-0.34136804938316345,
-0.1273229867219925,
-0.645185649394989,
0.5429790019989014,
0.024881627410650253,
0.5825614929199219,
-0.27310729026794434,
-0.008711306378245354,
0.8072188496589661,
-0.38428741693496704,
1.103770136833191,
0.09634663909673691,
-0.2249823808670044,
0.48994505405426025,
0.4343429207801819,
0.3141832649707794,
-0.18633943796157837,
0.13317151367664337,
0.14012511074543,
0.12570244073867798,
-0.20320893824100494,
-0.47118714451789856,
0.7228649854660034,
-0.9372372627258301,
-1.0419352054595947,
-0.34605106711387634,
-0.597064197063446,
-0.31239789724349976,
-0.07029448449611664,
0.159495010972023,
0.03455139696598053,
-0.3465971350669861,
0.06847978383302689,
0.7271246910095215,
-0.13000008463859558,
0.5353447794914246,
0.7027373313903809,
-0.5485812425613403,
0.02912452444434166,
0.7287402153015137,
0.2529771625995636,
0.7539138197898865,
0.334320992231369,
0.34566208720207214,
-0.22311638295650482,
-0.28296077251434326,
-0.007576786447316408,
0.48880553245544434,
-0.9183889031410217,
0.17269185185432434,
-0.9012562036514282,
-0.22439715266227722,
-0.43676888942718506,
-0.044892773032188416,
-0.329325407743454,
-0.6326695680618286,
-0.3551139533519745,
-0.23052756488323212,
0.2502294182777405,
1.17848539352417,
0.2117922306060791,
0.13572826981544495,
-0.8773472309112549,
0.14519517123699188,
0.32363468408584595,
-0.23946990072727203,
0.1419684737920761,
-0.7843235731124878,
-0.2198093831539154,
0.23328566551208496,
-0.4986099898815155,
-0.9387224316596985,
0.4821621775627136,
0.2402004897594452,
0.987971305847168,
0.66933673620224,
-0.25498831272125244,
0.4083697497844696,
-0.39020273089408875,
0.8483262062072754,
-0.0024170835968106985,
-1.0752851963043213,
0.5531342625617981,
-0.22809968888759613,
0.2307184785604477,
0.10372818261384964,
0.7539019584655762,
-0.39027318358421326,
-0.4402906000614166,
-0.816501796245575,
-0.33388155698776245,
0.24333219230175018,
-0.15009543299674988,
-0.08443070203065872,
-0.044277943670749664,
0.4260697662830353,
0.4140970706939697,
0.43677133321762085,
-0.6437740325927734,
-0.21278409659862518,
-0.19233013689517975,
0.03733961656689644,
0.02973153255879879,
-0.4008007347583771,
-0.17028377950191498,
-0.47666269540786743,
0.44658851623535156,
-0.18615330755710602,
0.03864205628633499,
0.14074310660362244,
-0.4045960009098053,
-0.25124841928482056,
0.6260749101638794,
0.736399233341217,
1.0417476892471313,
0.09485812485218048,
0.3872256875038147,
0.08548516035079956,
-0.24395708739757538,
0.29576510190963745,
-0.6810293793678284,
-0.4459414780139923,
-0.13903190195560455,
0.8210589289665222,
0.7281826734542847,
0.4967998266220093,
-0.4468817114830017,
0.21874921023845673,
0.36661002039909363,
-0.37889617681503296,
-0.15716882050037384,
-0.08696655929088593,
0.3638594150543213,
0.003040979616343975,
0.4316883087158203,
0.1572311520576477,
-0.05692463740706444,
-1.0374990701675415,
-0.06407157331705093,
0.47461023926734924,
-0.09616603702306747,
-0.991041362285614,
0.30729079246520996,
-0.2141897976398468,
-0.3353050947189331,
0.2818724513053894,
-0.018024474382400513,
-0.8575849533081055,
0.4240836501121521,
0.8089019060134888,
0.5523800849914551,
-0.5169376730918884,
0.28074026107788086,
0.26508787274360657,
0.36400750279426575,
-0.3571581542491913,
0.5682079792022705,
0.05625208467245102,
-1.2309389114379883,
-0.3268234133720398,
-0.826953649520874,
-0.5119127035140991,
-0.1653808355331421,
-0.7462137937545776,
-0.11233321577310562,
-0.4735218584537506,
-0.060460880398750305,
-0.15894640982151031,
-0.29120373725891113,
-0.6591218709945679,
-0.03870779275894165,
0.03223031386733055,
0.4999616742134094,
-0.9990479946136475,
1.022467017173767,
0.7697885036468506,
-0.31682559847831726,
-0.5382501482963562,
-0.1998983770608902,
0.11332494765520096,
-0.8991140723228455,
1.1908633708953857,
-0.1997048556804657,
0.004508295562118292,
0.051194269210100174,
-0.562351405620575,
-0.8458936214447021,
0.8351394534111023,
0.4134212136268616,
-0.5273548364639282,
-0.3622516095638275,
0.15486793220043182,
0.6029041409492493,
-0.7442718148231506,
-0.05723387002944946,
0.4580525755882263,
0.5629626512527466,
0.12277048081159592,
-0.9908847808837891,
-0.0493282712996006,
-0.08335544914007187,
0.046643972396850586,
-0.33448800444602966,
-0.2596416473388672,
1.0125333070755005,
-0.553653359413147,
-0.32138824462890625,
-0.31939956545829773,
0.48433923721313477,
0.26249444484710693,
0.1359558254480362,
0.08300071954727173,
0.8507940173149109,
0.6404199600219727,
-0.0946233868598938,
0.969580888748169,
-0.37344232201576233,
0.6761029958724976,
0.8387696743011475,
-0.778148889541626,
0.8233479857444763,
0.7521305084228516,
-0.4054618775844574,
0.4601098895072937,
0.5028473138809204,
0.44210579991340637,
0.6417783498764038,
0.14655281603336334,
-0.12426430732011795,
-0.5742936134338379,
-0.14973340928554535,
-0.2834607660770416,
0.5419393181800842,
0.5252864360809326,
-0.29948779940605164,
-0.1367010474205017,
0.1485530138015747,
0.013974453322589397,
0.04125269502401352,
-0.3052397668361664,
0.9065844416618347,
0.17598360776901245,
-0.6333646178245544,
0.5155781507492065,
-0.21264123916625977,
0.42333725094795227,
-0.2461061030626297,
-0.0654180496931076,
0.01639081910252571,
-0.07137393206357956,
-0.1830616146326065,
-0.921628475189209,
0.8044956922531128,
-0.16860821843147278,
-0.1781340092420578,
-0.18543635308742523,
0.8137339353561401,
-0.252123087644577,
-0.31933024525642395,
0.1439814269542694,
1.045535683631897,
0.1774337738752365,
0.08753885328769684,
-0.37788519263267517,
0.0056540751829743385,
-0.03238759562373161,
-0.49485164880752563,
0.33264559507369995,
0.36036625504493713,
-0.023767225444316864,
1.011797547340393,
0.6363638043403625,
0.3433960974216461,
0.15391111373901367,
-0.209649920463562,
0.7638912796974182,
-0.9132322072982788,
-0.11859250068664551,
-1.2485744953155518,
0.2820073068141937,
0.07978717982769012,
-0.10488368570804596,
0.9125236868858337,
0.45860815048217773,
0.6985848546028137,
-0.37765324115753174,
1.017685890197754,
0.10781271010637283,
0.6271637082099915,
-0.4714042544364929,
0.6815114617347717,
-0.33645519614219666,
0.40766641497612,
-0.10403382778167725,
-0.8540720343589783,
-0.31010428071022034,
0.8375396728515625,
-0.5907623171806335,
-0.2559964656829834,
0.8327255845069885,
0.5007444620132446,
0.23800987005233765,
0.20128902792930603,
0.6585379838943481,
0.3382524847984314,
0.031351275742053986,
0.47825849056243896,
1.1662007570266724,
-0.025643138214945793,
-0.31420817971229553,
-0.0841185450553894,
-0.1298631876707077,
-0.3090422451496124,
-0.7370111346244812,
-1.033098816871643,
-0.7236922383308411,
-0.32325270771980286,
-0.1778104454278946,
-0.1194012314081192,
0.9044368267059326,
0.326264351606369,
-0.6963182687759399,
-0.3935323655605316,
-0.06871990114450455,
0.3271731436252594,
-0.2554387152194977,
-0.22803592681884766,
0.14608857035636902,
-0.032388340681791306,
-0.3269417881965637,
0.36276063323020935,
0.675898015499115,
0.138521209359169,
-0.5306802988052368,
-0.10596375167369843,
-0.4301959276199341,
0.12309404462575912,
0.6121615767478943,
0.30819758772850037,
-1.3449034690856934,
-0.48486122488975525,
0.34126049280166626,
-0.16467243432998657,
0.06839308142662048,
0.8689402937889099,
-0.43497347831726074,
0.20851822197437286,
0.4080163538455963,
0.2365976721048355,
0.1258717179298401,
-0.1555260866880417,
0.3820026218891144,
-0.21586906909942627,
0.08393961191177368,
0.19778922200202942,
0.7230567336082458,
0.3729749619960785,
-0.236957386136055,
0.3445311486721039,
0.655830979347229,
-0.501063346862793,
-0.8226579427719116,
0.3246837258338928,
-0.8315579891204834,
-0.23585128784179688,
1.292249083518982,
-0.48542043566703796,
-0.5165857672691345,
-0.5295228362083435,
0.06002337858080864,
0.24325788021087646,
0.2312810868024826,
0.5912715196609497,
1.0861462354660034,
-0.2964717149734497,
-0.25437071919441223,
-0.4304802417755127,
0.3904791474342346,
0.10474342107772827,
-0.6987866759300232,
0.10454636812210083,
0.24050351977348328,
0.6126500964164734,
0.3539731204509735,
0.2310333251953125,
-0.011948703788220882,
-0.029700513929128647,
-0.10334204882383347,
0.1567155122756958,
-0.024546241387724876,
-0.2060183882713318,
-0.1576796919107437,
0.2375330626964569,
0.29551905393600464,
0.4725302457809448
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.12809v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.12809v1
|
Comparing Explanation Faithfulness between Multilingual and Monolingual Fine-tuned Language Models
| 2024-03-19T15:07:22 | 2024-03-19T15:07:22 |
Zhixue Zhao, Nikolaos Aletras
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In many real natural language processing application scenarios, practitioners
not only aim to maximize predictive performance but also seek faithful
explanations for the model predictions. Rationales and importance distribution
given by feature attribution methods (FAs) provide insights into how different
parts of the input contribute to a prediction. Previous studies have explored
how different factors affect faithfulness, mainly in the context of monolingual
English models. On the other hand, the differences in FA faithfulness between
multilingual and monolingual models have yet to be explored. Our extensive
experiments, covering five languages and five popular FAs, show that FA
faithfulness varies between multilingual and monolingual models. We find that
the larger the multilingual model, the less faithful the FAs are compared to
its counterpart monolingual models.Our further analysis shows that the
faithfulness disparity is potentially driven by the differences between model
tokenizers. Our code is available:
https://github.com/casszhao/multilingual-faith.
|
[
-0.43703070282936096,
-0.6118791699409485,
0.5934785008430481,
0.40614092350006104,
-0.30305957794189453,
-0.08563851565122604,
-0.25467103719711304,
-0.7373769879341125,
0.02727675437927246,
0.09541343152523041,
-0.6889564990997314,
-0.19793805480003357,
-0.6117448806762695,
0.3563224673271179,
-0.30764615535736084,
0.9025469422340393,
-0.23769783973693848,
0.4393733739852905,
-0.44309550523757935,
-0.4839520752429962,
-0.12364470958709717,
-0.5036142468452454,
-0.6764493584632874,
-0.5783023238182068,
0.5880376696586609,
0.11708460003137589,
1.1386139392852783,
0.8915306329727173,
0.5223017334938049,
0.3201443552970886,
-0.12870365381240845,
0.151706263422966,
-0.1419515162706375,
0.10264687985181808,
-0.30786028504371643,
-0.5878650546073914,
-0.2863120138645172,
0.25739604234695435,
0.5105303525924683,
0.49157747626304626,
0.13395380973815918,
0.29434406757354736,
0.2372138798236847,
0.45217710733413696,
-0.6691664457321167,
0.15664467215538025,
-0.7241839170455933,
-0.1567544788122177,
-0.26435843110084534,
-0.11690225452184677,
-0.2856188118457794,
-0.5216291546821594,
0.14562372863292694,
-0.6647791266441345,
0.7256789207458496,
0.025996513664722443,
1.2038483619689941,
0.18775241076946259,
-0.3337649405002594,
-0.3108740746974945,
-0.5107474327087402,
1.1353479623794556,
-0.8513038158416748,
0.7829261422157288,
0.5883108973503113,
0.09832263737916946,
0.1764044612646103,
-0.30670276284217834,
-0.5145564675331116,
-0.20858709514141083,
-0.17548616230487823,
-0.10400848090648651,
0.07070944458246231,
-0.07218178361654282,
0.0499575175344944,
0.6501621603965759,
-0.4479338824748993,
-0.019500093534588814,
-0.00032480229856446385,
-0.5253652334213257,
0.4918166995048523,
-0.15783825516700745,
-0.009771224111318588,
-0.06385134905576706,
-0.3365897238254547,
-0.12339381873607635,
-0.5088064670562744,
0.24752570688724518,
0.4473972022533417,
0.164116770029068,
-0.22806605696678162,
0.4407784640789032,
0.084797203540802,
0.5461330413818359,
-0.11337801069021225,
-0.3999376595020294,
0.1205630972981453,
-0.725456714630127,
-0.1350540965795517,
-0.17453151941299438,
0.7546764016151428,
0.19769181311130524,
0.6170119643211365,
-0.3052445650100708,
-0.23273105919361115,
0.1531914919614792,
0.03716409206390381,
-0.6260735988616943,
0.03779410198330879,
0.05139986053109169,
-0.6698145270347595,
-0.34841468930244446,
0.12630611658096313,
-0.48245301842689514,
-0.13233941793441772,
-0.4475056529045105,
0.07310391962528229,
-0.5347111821174622,
-0.29999905824661255,
0.05855065956711769,
-0.1267353892326355,
0.06414111703634262,
0.3077031075954437,
-0.9401657581329346,
0.2092643678188324,
0.8278295397758484,
0.8517373204231262,
-0.2990891635417938,
-0.7475597262382507,
-0.41392526030540466,
-0.026824602857232094,
-0.2260238081216812,
0.6111063361167908,
-0.688708484172821,
0.09396664053201675,
0.07913640141487122,
0.033020250499248505,
-0.17078159749507904,
-0.43979400396347046,
0.7037835717201233,
-0.4779912531375885,
0.10429032891988754,
-0.5026637315750122,
-0.5196024775505066,
-0.3181307017803192,
0.1975277066230774,
-0.8235910534858704,
0.7846678495407104,
-0.06279531121253967,
-0.6829532384872437,
0.8453843593597412,
-0.5747315883636475,
-0.2855451703071594,
-0.382858544588089,
-0.14292359352111816,
-0.5296621322631836,
0.5129775404930115,
0.05121902748942375,
0.3363420367240906,
-0.23525558412075043,
0.2000700682401657,
-0.6453933119773865,
-0.274519681930542,
0.7587000727653503,
-1.0229268074035645,
0.7935177087783813,
0.3819389343261719,
-0.1257360428571701,
-0.07601797580718994,
-0.5988161563873291,
0.0460934117436409,
0.3089759349822998,
-0.3648250699043274,
-0.4620506763458252,
0.16455072164535522,
0.21384118497371674,
0.14802204072475433,
0.32286661863327026,
-0.488435834646225,
-0.10802266746759415,
-0.49324744939804077,
0.12305103987455368,
0.5835068821907043,
-0.2737705409526825,
0.35942432284355164,
-0.22132818400859833,
0.5339543223381042,
0.1400013417005539,
0.4007066786289215,
-0.20690645277500153,
-0.409834086894989,
-0.520642876625061,
-0.32213085889816284,
0.44957470893859863,
0.2696838676929474,
-0.5177072882652283,
-0.14534170925617218,
-0.3376225233078003,
-0.14925998449325562,
-0.9057278037071228,
0.1864381581544876,
0.9611301422119141,
0.09168501198291779,
0.3206001818180084,
-0.2672068476676941,
-0.30844858288764954,
-1.1861870288848877,
-0.7420899868011475,
-0.3384868800640106,
0.0752631202340126,
0.04112996906042099,
0.32625290751457214,
0.045089241117239,
0.8870742321014404,
-0.13646438717842102,
-0.026897015050053596,
-0.1448247730731964,
0.22080542147159576,
0.035987723618745804,
0.3143218755722046,
0.9861131906509399,
-1.0110883712768555,
-0.708343505859375,
0.1506703943014145,
-0.526232898235321,
0.03668752312660217,
0.09791862964630127,
0.1461506187915802,
0.574061393737793,
0.10738597810268402,
-0.4099406599998474,
0.5203667879104614,
0.8715105652809143,
-0.45245447754859924,
0.6625873446464539,
-0.08187118172645569,
0.5033481121063232,
-0.9959396123886108,
-0.0753689631819725,
0.13382989168167114,
-0.428180456161499,
-0.6409042477607727,
0.4671168923377991,
0.1361529678106308,
0.23297089338302612,
-0.46381044387817383,
0.48497626185417175,
-0.4561099112033844,
-0.05429118499159813,
-0.1666395366191864,
-0.11223521828651428,
0.3980526924133301,
0.30375733971595764,
-0.01251922082155943,
1.0282893180847168,
0.43408703804016113,
-0.5656561851501465,
0.1579943746328354,
0.1916789561510086,
-0.10989869385957718,
0.14812466502189636,
-0.5668604373931885,
-0.10904651135206223,
0.0847650021314621,
-0.24108625948429108,
-1.1432983875274658,
-0.277303546667099,
-0.045612599700689316,
-0.7170073986053467,
0.31609803438186646,
-0.4334908723831177,
-0.5227681398391724,
-0.0883532464504242,
-0.3980845808982849,
0.536343514919281,
0.16545166075229645,
-0.43099164962768555,
0.5834295749664307,
0.024445533752441406,
-0.03801676630973816,
-0.62702876329422,
-0.9367506504058838,
-0.15895839035511017,
-0.3757718503475189,
-0.6987216472625732,
0.29243478178977966,
-0.15204568207263947,
-0.5349206924438477,
-0.15927669405937195,
-0.2833632528781891,
-0.44289451837539673,
0.47841522097587585,
0.01833196170628071,
0.17450319230556488,
-0.43113091588020325,
-0.034555982798337936,
0.07216709852218628,
-0.21479445695877075,
0.1978478580713272,
-0.0037861233577132225,
0.3782000243663788,
-0.3645552396774292,
-0.6224488615989685,
-0.5123491287231445,
0.46908387541770935,
0.7706886529922485,
-0.45712849497795105,
1.1788502931594849,
0.5439445972442627,
-0.23453985154628754,
0.18226373195648193,
-0.7617693543434143,
-0.22197873890399933,
-0.4595657289028168,
0.1180979534983635,
-0.6019690632820129,
-0.6666678786277771,
0.9157248735427856,
0.423904150724411,
0.3000849783420563,
0.5187404751777649,
0.40229496359825134,
0.13159014284610748,
1.1586891412734985,
0.7981531023979187,
-0.14975202083587646,
0.39176321029663086,
0.32240238785743713,
0.09580967575311661,
-0.20509199798107147,
0.08623453229665756,
-0.8831424117088318,
0.020187683403491974,
-0.6126574873924255,
-0.12822289764881134,
0.006088183261454105,
0.33769816160202026,
0.13885363936424255,
0.25677603483200073,
-0.17725485563278198,
0.5380816459655762,
0.418483704328537,
-0.21693205833435059,
0.5470101237297058,
0.31864428520202637,
-0.19175437092781067,
-0.4396820366382599,
-0.6380664110183716,
-0.6753705143928528,
0.8575962781906128,
0.6576268672943115,
0.5877727270126343,
0.4040849506855011,
0.485120564699173,
0.03339425101876259,
0.36556476354599,
-0.7017094492912292,
0.12316524982452393,
-0.3789295554161072,
-0.7543992400169373,
-0.32591360807418823,
-0.3510427474975586,
-0.675948441028595,
0.24037717282772064,
-0.19567105174064636,
-0.6137552261352539,
0.19311600923538208,
0.4880567789077759,
-0.15506784617900848,
0.007984072901308537,
-0.7520570755004883,
0.9796684384346008,
-0.0883932039141655,
-0.49545958638191223,
-0.19662567973136902,
-0.44092050194740295,
0.2273898869752884,
-0.33748722076416016,
0.3589218556880951,
-0.06670644134283066,
0.16107554733753204,
0.5247418880462646,
-0.33409184217453003,
0.5440695881843567,
-0.07938230782747269,
-0.4149170219898224,
0.024552755057811737,
0.23855896294116974,
0.5780540108680725,
0.281328946352005,
-0.45408275723457336,
0.48727908730506897,
0.13368944823741913,
-0.32776984572410583,
-0.6573273539543152,
0.5728192925453186,
-0.5798097252845764,
-0.5518320798873901,
-0.18264378607273102,
-0.502509593963623,
-0.20290520787239075,
0.16609525680541992,
0.5527868270874023,
0.4671386480331421,
-0.14769724011421204,
0.13800571858882904,
0.8438997268676758,
-0.03621033951640129,
0.4958672821521759,
0.7195221185684204,
-0.3116337060928345,
-0.11356194317340851,
0.7848697304725647,
0.016148308292031288,
0.5584264993667603,
0.1630498617887497,
0.26972246170043945,
-0.2939452826976776,
-0.6699735522270203,
-0.5010881423950195,
0.33700627088546753,
-0.7130756974220276,
-0.05345894768834114,
-0.4878600537776947,
0.08234884589910507,
-0.48994180560112,
-0.23965081572532654,
-0.8287450671195984,
-0.247693732380867,
-0.15442833304405212,
0.08103054761886597,
0.3606394827365875,
0.37546101212501526,
0.29795345664024353,
0.12052471935749054,
-0.8100569844245911,
0.3569413423538208,
0.022966884076595306,
0.5986213088035583,
-0.058104630559682846,
-0.6811149716377258,
-0.4233035147190094,
0.4507634937763214,
-0.22893697023391724,
-0.8697554469108582,
0.07565885782241821,
0.5120697021484375,
0.612403929233551,
0.6459118127822876,
-0.3087488114833832,
1.0607693195343018,
-0.4207911491394043,
0.7520174384117126,
0.10758713632822037,
-1.1128331422805786,
0.2976136803627014,
-0.1738348752260208,
0.20953881740570068,
0.9272304773330688,
0.4364025294780731,
-0.41830265522003174,
-0.7511654496192932,
-0.5315759181976318,
-0.5009353160858154,
0.7162529826164246,
0.4727778136730194,
0.017974670976400375,
-0.00672202929854393,
0.5551856756210327,
0.5670162439346313,
0.15607017278671265,
-0.9631312489509583,
-0.6003541350364685,
-0.3844393193721771,
-0.20067787170410156,
-0.2303091138601303,
-0.29813680052757263,
-0.07192724943161011,
-0.20383253693580627,
0.7299721240997314,
-0.3108239471912384,
0.42459461092948914,
0.1505698263645172,
-0.1550293266773224,
-0.3224349319934845,
0.2925718426704407,
0.857589602470398,
0.8757032155990601,
0.009837429039180279,
0.20880219340324402,
0.1193171814084053,
-0.5097781419754028,
-0.0878848135471344,
0.04559909924864769,
-0.055254820734262466,
0.5247505307197571,
0.6683866381645203,
0.8515913486480713,
0.14252212643623352,
-0.2247156947851181,
0.5765673518180847,
-0.2297891229391098,
-0.27208322286605835,
-0.20227770507335663,
-0.01880170963704586,
0.04143859073519707,
0.14101891219615936,
0.26780030131340027,
0.2775633633136749,
0.20789338648319244,
-0.6003618836402893,
0.01593775302171707,
0.6132513880729675,
-0.3639557957649231,
-0.45797887444496155,
0.6864054799079895,
-0.1652827262878418,
-0.15482278168201447,
0.3629421293735504,
-0.14360575377941132,
-0.6973248720169067,
0.5446722507476807,
0.4553025960922241,
0.8740392327308655,
-0.3737575113773346,
0.08817733079195023,
0.12033477425575256,
0.2996378242969513,
-0.14648345112800598,
0.17016255855560303,
0.10971103608608246,
-0.8967592716217041,
-0.6869441866874695,
-0.7563236355781555,
-0.20287498831748962,
0.07631605118513107,
-0.8744939565658569,
0.048712000250816345,
0.03860506787896156,
-0.18154583871364594,
0.25401148200035095,
-0.07619591057300568,
-0.5696977972984314,
0.13247603178024292,
0.21284599602222443,
0.9303419589996338,
-1.0147701501846313,
0.9394404292106628,
0.8351352214813232,
-0.32576435804367065,
-0.9296540021896362,
0.25537270307540894,
0.01669267565011978,
-0.5706486701965332,
0.47104883193969727,
0.16126500070095062,
-0.27298614382743835,
-0.22388948500156403,
-0.4098413586616516,
-0.9236565828323364,
0.8227795958518982,
0.8062885999679565,
-0.26857319474220276,
0.1400616616010666,
0.4650881588459015,
0.6562674045562744,
-0.22561466693878174,
0.08346600085496902,
0.3629869222640991,
0.625078558921814,
-0.09293998777866364,
-1.2996454238891602,
-0.2212788611650467,
-0.07338124513626099,
-0.05798724293708801,
0.24030350148677826,
-0.43737977743148804,
0.8248746991157532,
0.061760272830724716,
-0.2576369047164917,
0.11981268972158432,
0.7352547645568848,
0.45375147461891174,
0.48474815487861633,
0.49501457810401917,
0.219246968626976,
0.5012892484664917,
-0.27926933765411377,
1.1986658573150635,
-0.30306804180145264,
0.5580616593360901,
0.9265128374099731,
0.002739977091550827,
0.5277532339096069,
0.8437530398368835,
-0.320742130279541,
0.3886551558971405,
0.6267635822296143,
0.05933482572436333,
0.36761659383773804,
-0.3280116319656372,
-0.14698180556297302,
-0.32209253311157227,
-0.2005787044763565,
-0.2162216752767563,
0.41134175658226013,
0.10318993777036667,
-0.6352149844169617,
-0.09429257363080978,
0.10327321290969849,
0.20760582387447357,
0.16364561021327972,
-0.2903980612754822,
0.5966372489929199,
0.006028813775628805,
-0.8537341356277466,
0.8302393555641174,
0.315506249666214,
0.652010977268219,
-0.7584232091903687,
0.07281731069087982,
-0.37192341685295105,
0.23783093690872192,
-0.305063933134079,
-0.6907604336738586,
0.5431675910949707,
-0.021644175052642822,
-0.4952046871185303,
-0.4057213366031647,
0.6786348223686218,
-0.3664230406284332,
-0.3682010769844055,
0.33230942487716675,
0.49138343334198,
0.15862849354743958,
-0.18137282133102417,
-0.9058221578598022,
0.12707102298736572,
0.22592784464359283,
-0.44944530725479126,
0.1627696007490158,
0.5213162302970886,
-0.2909947335720062,
0.8226022720336914,
0.5240657925605774,
0.012666015885770321,
0.18902869522571564,
0.14058975875377655,
0.5731489062309265,
-0.3497669994831085,
-0.29143619537353516,
-1.1473209857940674,
0.497499018907547,
0.12496700882911682,
-0.39058351516723633,
1.1096489429473877,
0.6837878823280334,
0.7917402982711792,
-0.37963590025901794,
0.4678175151348114,
0.11552919447422028,
0.34049949049949646,
-0.6286388635635376,
0.6703893542289734,
-0.8665716052055359,
0.10947718471288681,
-0.37270423769950867,
-1.1361232995986938,
-0.17850029468536377,
0.6505596041679382,
0.11960034817457199,
0.019199354574084282,
0.8626493215560913,
0.6329154372215271,
-0.463508278131485,
0.12361665070056915,
0.3043808937072754,
-0.11656838655471802,
0.1316908746957779,
0.09664203971624374,
0.5817534923553467,
-0.4698067605495453,
0.2600488066673279,
-0.2267744243144989,
-0.06402186304330826,
-0.005553006194531918,
-1.0330650806427002,
-0.7232640981674194,
-0.5871557593345642,
-0.4306199848651886,
-0.19775830209255219,
0.00029481598176062107,
0.8079294562339783,
0.565543532371521,
-0.9329894185066223,
-0.01290629431605339,
-0.18354259431362152,
0.13662008941173553,
-0.5112983584403992,
-0.23864175379276276,
0.055152807384729385,
-0.3261892795562744,
-0.7829291224479675,
0.2829013764858246,
0.022375401109457016,
0.1621113419532776,
-0.4650139808654785,
-0.27067750692367554,
-0.11547288298606873,
0.2544381320476532,
0.3409523069858551,
-0.010366808623075485,
-1.0449739694595337,
-0.35956883430480957,
-0.0029434815514832735,
-0.17221517860889435,
0.08004816621541977,
0.9468410611152649,
-0.3601151704788208,
0.19951961934566498,
0.3867468237876892,
0.37980619072914124,
0.15420232713222504,
0.034644342958927155,
0.6734238266944885,
-0.8359153270721436,
0.15002214908599854,
-0.1451750099658966,
0.4765969216823578,
0.2458646297454834,
-0.45260706543922424,
0.43295326828956604,
0.2490064799785614,
-0.4591372013092041,
-0.6983029842376709,
0.35208043456077576,
-0.7805721163749695,
-0.23298680782318115,
1.1695886850357056,
-0.5110774040222168,
-0.018276356160640717,
-0.3580971360206604,
0.18805746734142303,
0.3800593614578247,
-0.24121211469173431,
0.6510348916053772,
1.2561289072036743,
0.19868172705173492,
-0.05833498761057854,
-0.5380969047546387,
0.7343388199806213,
0.614334762096405,
-0.3498917818069458,
0.43173548579216003,
0.3177672326564789,
0.3079168200492859,
0.42014992237091064,
0.24710358679294586,
-0.22943802177906036,
0.37648287415504456,
-0.2457573562860489,
0.012053415179252625,
-0.22240668535232544,
-0.396487832069397,
-0.5045984983444214,
0.12475337833166122,
0.4757688045501709,
0.14784561097621918
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.12805v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.12805v1
|
Contextual Moral Value Alignment Through Context-Based Aggregation
| 2024-03-19T15:06:53 | 2024-03-19T15:06:53 |
Pierre Dognin, Jesus Rios, Ronny Luss, Inkit Padhi, Matthew D Riemer, Miao Liu, Prasanna Sattigeri, Manish Nagireddy, Kush R. Varshney, Djallel Bouneffouf
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Developing value-aligned AI agents is a complex undertaking and an ongoing
challenge in the field of AI. Specifically within the domain of Large Language
Models (LLMs), the capability to consolidate multiple independently trained
dialogue agents, each aligned with a distinct moral value, into a unified
system that can adapt to and be aligned with multiple moral values is of
paramount importance. In this paper, we propose a system that does contextual
moral value alignment based on contextual aggregation. Here, aggregation is
defined as the process of integrating a subset of LLM responses that are best
suited to respond to a user input, taking into account features extracted from
the user's input. The proposed system shows better results in term of alignment
to human value compared to the state of the art.
|
[
-0.31786876916885376,
-0.650924563407898,
0.6180656552314758,
0.022393153980374336,
-0.35727134346961975,
0.0783149003982544,
0.07326927781105042,
-0.5585624575614929,
0.24501994252204895,
0.5710316300392151,
-0.3096542954444885,
-0.16690535843372345,
-0.7059475183486938,
-0.07604822516441345,
-0.1572793424129486,
0.9793129563331604,
0.4206973910331726,
0.10006065666675568,
-0.5367891192436218,
-0.7803141474723816,
-0.7265421748161316,
-0.5113319158554077,
-0.8235384821891785,
-0.39555230736732483,
0.3457069396972656,
0.2744584381580353,
0.7318502068519592,
0.5820457935333252,
0.5126067399978638,
0.5132163166999817,
-0.09659110009670258,
0.2577465772628784,
-0.5311988592147827,
0.05015551671385765,
-0.6030496954917908,
-0.021662505343556404,
-1.219597339630127,
0.16262191534042358,
0.4712238609790802,
0.32967862486839294,
-0.2029823511838913,
0.24011242389678955,
0.15520480275154114,
0.5486051440238953,
-0.6189943552017212,
0.0760316401720047,
-0.4773959219455719,
-0.1824851930141449,
0.3541601300239563,
-0.23089599609375,
-0.23709706962108612,
-0.6261626482009888,
0.07731584459543228,
-0.5481643676757812,
-0.4684869945049286,
-0.18606121838092804,
0.7319337725639343,
0.45889291167259216,
-0.7588747143745422,
-0.31840911507606506,
-0.2467934787273407,
1.1455459594726562,
-0.6347846984863281,
-0.08014827966690063,
0.19029395282268524,
0.05521615222096443,
0.11228150129318237,
-0.38773226737976074,
-0.7539709806442261,
0.18551157414913177,
-0.25387609004974365,
0.21271272003650665,
0.10038182884454727,
-0.06019408628344536,
-0.44161802530288696,
0.23071950674057007,
0.01058761402964592,
0.1922324150800705,
-0.12209349125623703,
-0.027184361591935158,
0.9763240218162537,
0.4929344356060028,
0.2927870750427246,
0.03906591609120369,
-0.6257081627845764,
-0.07844322919845581,
-0.28133898973464966,
0.4282150864601135,
0.010482924990355968,
0.4678560793399811,
-0.3096068501472473,
0.6807675957679749,
0.12736186385154724,
0.7958112955093384,
0.3818270266056061,
-0.4426010251045227,
0.2628377676010132,
-0.5580853819847107,
-0.30970966815948486,
0.43870091438293457,
0.8723188042640686,
0.8677749037742615,
0.5491262674331665,
0.3997311592102051,
-0.34496450424194336,
-0.05796103551983833,
0.551287829875946,
-0.7403564453125,
0.6625744700431824,
0.3340400159358978,
-0.4622992277145386,
-0.7409152388572693,
-0.24481411278247833,
-0.4759642481803894,
-0.46595796942710876,
-0.5333670377731323,
0.1785792112350464,
-0.402033269405365,
-0.007861216552555561,
-0.12394808232784271,
-0.03578019514679909,
0.4947652518749237,
0.640160858631134,
-0.9470904469490051,
-0.14214693009853363,
0.6934304237365723,
0.7751387357711792,
-0.20785053074359894,
-0.22874659299850464,
-0.8504514098167419,
0.48444902896881104,
-0.17866730690002441,
0.7379062175750732,
-0.878963053226471,
-0.40145134925842285,
-0.018932530656456947,
-0.09216612577438354,
0.09076733142137527,
-0.18288742005825043,
0.5013721585273743,
-0.8069813251495361,
0.11594127118587494,
-0.10801227390766144,
-0.642787754535675,
0.03787560760974884,
0.5758925676345825,
-0.3857556879520416,
0.7115449905395508,
0.30532190203666687,
-0.40839844942092896,
0.36151251196861267,
-0.710274875164032,
-0.26684245467185974,
0.3626905381679535,
-0.31089264154434204,
-0.2392323762178421,
0.03565342724323273,
0.27845779061317444,
0.46153563261032104,
-0.408439040184021,
0.7552833557128906,
-0.2869984209537506,
-0.47116023302078247,
0.5285218358039856,
-0.5595751404762268,
0.8773078918457031,
0.2052662968635559,
-0.023009557276964188,
0.41353079676628113,
-0.2874873876571655,
0.17143641412258148,
-0.11412147432565689,
-0.3810354471206665,
-0.5362684726715088,
0.07635701447725296,
-0.20809592306613922,
0.17667251825332642,
0.6869364380836487,
-0.22488003969192505,
0.4150695204734802,
-0.22560854256153107,
0.14454768598079681,
1.2825958728790283,
-0.1536695808172226,
0.7185429334640503,
-0.40299567580223083,
0.3439525365829468,
0.061475325375795364,
0.07704195380210876,
0.15978439152240753,
-0.3500913679599762,
-0.37028342485427856,
-0.5498132109642029,
-0.15728352963924408,
0.7722066044807434,
-0.32240527868270874,
1.0565106868743896,
-0.335454523563385,
-0.13733968138694763,
-0.38893067836761475,
0.010028437711298466,
0.2890671193599701,
0.8021193742752075,
0.3434852659702301,
-0.24239547550678253,
0.03565115109086037,
-0.8823979496955872,
-0.22357136011123657,
-0.527264416217804,
-0.1777583509683609,
0.6731462478637695,
0.1653827726840973,
-0.376949280500412,
1.174972414970398,
-0.4736124575138092,
-0.46472594141960144,
0.15145298838615417,
0.013189535588026047,
0.2285882830619812,
0.44902247190475464,
0.3886895477771759,
-0.8980401158332825,
-0.32404693961143494,
0.3908407390117645,
-1.1261723041534424,
-0.2854744791984558,
0.032500579953193665,
-0.15952494740486145,
0.05026186257600784,
0.35763078927993774,
-0.21052522957324982,
0.3300773501396179,
0.5561243891716003,
-0.5539013147354126,
0.20259623229503632,
-0.08341854810714722,
0.4875202476978302,
-1.4363627433776855,
0.003676189109683037,
-0.1525869220495224,
-0.3628612756729126,
-0.5676497220993042,
-0.24111589789390564,
-0.14282438158988953,
0.20091451704502106,
-0.7119175791740417,
0.8482290506362915,
-0.08742751181125641,
-0.22320790588855743,
-0.3484679162502289,
0.5225176811218262,
-0.03709699213504791,
0.48963332176208496,
-0.061650559306144714,
1.1514630317687988,
0.36198100447654724,
-0.7549185752868652,
0.7458498477935791,
0.6203742027282715,
0.08922624588012695,
1.521150827407837,
-0.5633599162101746,
-0.042122453451156616,
-0.18019214272499084,
0.27186527848243713,
-0.5780603289604187,
-0.2016136348247528,
0.1294042021036148,
-0.3942766487598419,
-0.19877402484416962,
-0.18133439123630524,
0.1360444575548172,
0.3969150483608246,
-0.21993619203567505,
0.9835318922996521,
0.3417569100856781,
-0.512216329574585,
0.9133384227752686,
0.7285019755363464,
-0.5214614868164062,
-0.8862382173538208,
-0.28679606318473816,
0.0679297223687172,
-0.5650469660758972,
-0.8361116647720337,
0.2565806806087494,
-0.012734861113131046,
-0.3695635497570038,
0.19772841036319733,
0.23020493984222412,
0.05784963071346283,
-0.07040319591760635,
0.022371342405676842,
0.3442772626876831,
-0.30534887313842773,
0.37796226143836975,
0.22574158012866974,
-0.075553297996521,
-0.13921396434307098,
-0.35835587978363037,
0.41982537508010864,
-0.8084441423416138,
-0.37522998452186584,
-0.3177874982357025,
0.5322698950767517,
0.7455167174339294,
-0.3900110423564911,
0.7908823490142822,
0.32315391302108765,
-0.09479160606861115,
0.1931602507829666,
-0.4511330723762512,
0.2040611207485199,
-0.5564254522323608,
0.07449890673160553,
0.03253430500626564,
-1.212237000465393,
0.5484626293182373,
0.002862493274733424,
0.03968954458832741,
0.4516987204551697,
0.6941441297531128,
-0.358750581741333,
1.089802622795105,
0.5853596329689026,
-0.11170724779367447,
0.649256706237793,
0.021682383492588997,
0.15790735185146332,
-1.0248562097549438,
-0.2596166729927063,
-0.27753886580467224,
-0.41286635398864746,
-0.6225674152374268,
-0.44379836320877075,
0.5047463774681091,
0.10472306609153748,
-0.6912423968315125,
-0.13526518642902374,
-0.574521005153656,
0.5922669768333435,
0.38095220923423767,
-0.02059549279510975,
0.3451330363750458,
-0.0017332853749394417,
0.25271961092948914,
0.5274442434310913,
-0.4670770764350891,
-0.9695231318473816,
0.7406252026557922,
-0.09833300858736038,
0.7386364340782166,
0.4875575304031372,
0.561674177646637,
0.6700848937034607,
0.5754597783088684,
-1.1008328199386597,
0.6227788925170898,
-0.10397278517484665,
-0.33924657106399536,
-0.7627369165420532,
-0.3584679365158081,
-1.0391645431518555,
0.4371352195739746,
-0.06305979192256927,
-1.031050205230713,
0.3658878803253174,
0.11975065618753433,
-0.43970152735710144,
-0.07344899326562881,
-0.5276570320129395,
0.7429211139678955,
-0.5918441414833069,
-0.5751813054084778,
-0.3133232891559601,
-0.7501004934310913,
0.22503426671028137,
-0.12915091216564178,
0.07474008947610855,
-0.3370038568973541,
-0.19150076806545258,
0.47898489236831665,
-0.5743943452835083,
0.9967424869537354,
0.0452440045773983,
-0.4289146065711975,
0.447398841381073,
-0.2969396710395813,
0.48348739743232727,
0.2789077162742615,
-0.10280925780534744,
0.28460967540740967,
0.032920535653829575,
-0.594549834728241,
-0.4709971249103546,
0.5866777300834656,
-0.7472764849662781,
-0.7291437387466431,
-0.628960132598877,
-0.7225111126899719,
-0.17601242661476135,
0.3190513849258423,
-0.24762369692325592,
0.34888705611228943,
-0.5000167489051819,
0.027948971837759018,
0.44982442259788513,
-0.25998520851135254,
0.6440601944923401,
0.42615392804145813,
0.0686858519911766,
-0.7116739153862,
0.7207006812095642,
-0.4874328076839447,
0.37587836384773254,
0.2258009910583496,
0.330110639333725,
-0.4165157079696655,
0.034905772656202316,
-0.6217840313911438,
0.11237043887376785,
-0.6622355580329895,
-0.44270333647727966,
-0.3222280740737915,
-0.13852231204509735,
-0.4130256772041321,
-0.9270257949829102,
-0.21429450809955597,
-0.04910140857100487,
-0.3576699197292328,
0.010641288943588734,
0.4624551832675934,
0.5505127310752869,
0.16713310778141022,
0.44094327092170715,
-1.2833212614059448,
0.347010999917984,
0.6121105551719666,
0.5407198071479797,
-0.20104217529296875,
-0.36887386441230774,
-0.24370458722114563,
0.3986705541610718,
-0.21496501564979553,
-0.7126390933990479,
0.3877543807029724,
0.04572790861129761,
0.5061147212982178,
0.7010482549667358,
-0.020880747586488724,
0.8697824478149414,
-0.28243696689605713,
0.7746289968490601,
0.34025904536247253,
-1.217348575592041,
0.43495193123817444,
-0.3965979814529419,
0.20313724875450134,
0.7112310528755188,
-0.11355221271514893,
-0.6258137226104736,
-0.3463190197944641,
-0.4068032503128052,
-0.6580628156661987,
0.9173029065132141,
0.2541079521179199,
0.3890407085418701,
0.11075598746538162,
0.21996256709098816,
-0.20021799206733704,
0.25073230266571045,
-0.4666913151741028,
0.08692435920238495,
-0.19838207960128784,
-0.5530140995979309,
-0.1384074091911316,
-0.040882714092731476,
-0.6177527904510498,
-0.09839466214179993,
0.5515932440757751,
-0.6256709098815918,
0.19821853935718536,
0.04007560387253761,
-0.26851069927215576,
-0.0963706523180008,
0.40546292066574097,
0.687669575214386,
0.6948912739753723,
-0.14371225237846375,
-0.0318140909075737,
0.27660584449768066,
-0.305264413356781,
0.6792795658111572,
-0.2654295563697815,
0.04422709718346596,
-0.7934823036193848,
0.4251125454902649,
0.49731191992759705,
-0.26948171854019165,
-0.803855299949646,
0.8634406924247742,
-0.16155600547790527,
0.13195189833641052,
-0.36128875613212585,
0.21346601843833923,
0.11846937984228134,
0.6546529531478882,
0.1513652205467224,
0.014722381718456745,
-0.015377456322312355,
-0.6683003306388855,
0.24017691612243652,
0.686357319355011,
-0.5007537603378296,
0.08304271847009659,
0.413383811712265,
0.5662574172019958,
-0.5929331183433533,
0.848970890045166,
-0.054155394434928894,
-0.5391287207603455,
0.8169329166412354,
0.414615660905838,
0.909568190574646,
-0.3904539942741394,
0.17111805081367493,
0.08617348223924637,
0.06887950748205185,
0.14425650238990784,
0.09029972553253174,
-0.1274147480726242,
-1.3235446214675903,
-0.5120628476142883,
-0.7451028227806091,
-0.34148040413856506,
-0.379715234041214,
-0.714911937713623,
0.1981583535671234,
-0.04780057817697525,
-0.14859707653522491,
-0.43421003222465515,
-0.3260827660560608,
-0.407039612531662,
0.458984375,
0.002387093147262931,
0.17930611968040466,
-0.8641526699066162,
0.7415627241134644,
0.6951836347579956,
-0.36506977677345276,
-0.6224724054336548,
-0.1320120245218277,
-0.05973424017429352,
-1.0261685848236084,
0.57328200340271,
0.13563919067382812,
-0.6579429507255554,
-0.1630876064300537,
-0.5342819094657898,
-0.981927216053009,
1.3403611183166504,
0.3302167057991028,
-0.052907850593328476,
0.2116747945547104,
0.22906598448753357,
0.6663199663162231,
-0.9719032049179077,
0.18238018453121185,
0.6169614195823669,
0.5470561981201172,
0.32228007912635803,
-0.6989632844924927,
0.11201764643192291,
-0.38699182868003845,
-0.04592810943722725,
0.2759448289871216,
-0.9678720831871033,
0.47039827704429626,
-0.05261039733886719,
-0.051484234631061554,
-0.3132426142692566,
0.6203029155731201,
0.39730533957481384,
0.6040149331092834,
0.5916091203689575,
0.3293296694755554,
0.8676726222038269,
0.17542561888694763,
0.784171462059021,
-0.372954398393631,
0.3715185225009918,
0.9986205101013184,
-0.40513181686401367,
0.41186726093292236,
0.3986338675022125,
0.1979072391986847,
0.27372029423713684,
0.38166072964668274,
0.0943991169333458,
0.2592467665672302,
-0.3354858160018921,
-0.4717784523963928,
-0.4039042592048645,
-0.49958348274230957,
-0.19618737697601318,
0.7874006628990173,
0.4966631829738617,
-0.33239349722862244,
0.2017885148525238,
-0.4899415373802185,
-0.3012140393257141,
-0.04440520331263542,
-0.4759654998779297,
1.2636725902557373,
0.07781565934419632,
-0.875249981880188,
0.5604208111763,
-0.13334648311138153,
0.3987935483455658,
-0.3992626368999481,
-0.13619785010814667,
-0.31418129801750183,
0.10573087632656097,
-0.19538938999176025,
-0.9258848428726196,
0.2986825108528137,
0.20352621376514435,
-0.014865896664559841,
-0.6123239398002625,
0.4273295998573303,
-0.43191394209861755,
-0.5409272909164429,
0.3457520604133606,
0.36224400997161865,
-0.006711501628160477,
0.32735541462898254,
-0.5378969311714172,
-0.252901166677475,
-0.1707666516304016,
-0.048630569130182266,
0.2538354694843292,
0.45942872762680054,
-0.3423570990562439,
0.660039484500885,
0.5243552923202515,
-0.26066264510154724,
-0.3751729428768158,
-0.04696260765194893,
0.8938799500465393,
-0.9249088168144226,
-0.6234047412872314,
-1.0359090566635132,
0.798138439655304,
-0.43466630578041077,
-0.395229309797287,
0.34289535880088806,
0.30053186416625977,
0.48387524485588074,
0.42760133743286133,
0.7000312209129333,
0.016776569187641144,
-0.20138806104660034,
-0.5415013432502747,
0.6830239295959473,
-0.7393921613693237,
0.372342973947525,
-0.38695669174194336,
-0.9126949310302734,
-0.02133588120341301,
0.6405815482139587,
0.018038513138890266,
0.1628410518169403,
0.5234396457672119,
0.5910614132881165,
-0.0628889799118042,
-0.11944670230150223,
0.4706191420555115,
-0.07312458008527756,
0.48723381757736206,
0.5012179017066956,
0.9882757067680359,
-0.017476720735430717,
0.2932441532611847,
0.3709627389907837,
-0.3656395673751831,
-0.3582839369773865,
-1.0944960117340088,
-0.6367788910865784,
-0.38102173805236816,
0.025582652539014816,
-0.11830581724643707,
-0.1296899914741516,
0.8667216897010803,
0.4291292726993561,
-0.7209851145744324,
-0.37785419821739197,
0.15046142041683197,
0.33229634165763855,
-0.42287513613700867,
-0.19943667948246002,
0.43486157059669495,
-0.26378512382507324,
-0.8370875716209412,
0.4068564176559448,
0.6383358240127563,
-0.090225450694561,
0.07350338250398636,
-0.3162097930908203,
-0.23799145221710205,
0.7036342024803162,
0.8768470287322998,
-0.18284209072589874,
-0.6768485903739929,
-0.5745330452919006,
-0.3363009989261627,
-0.38054248690605164,
0.3217675983905792,
0.747573733329773,
-0.5631999373435974,
0.37291252613067627,
0.3344857096672058,
0.7122611403465271,
0.1519380807876587,
0.8001009821891785,
0.73504638671875,
-0.613105297088623,
0.09018869698047638,
0.5017185211181641,
0.302239328622818,
0.16878642141819,
-0.7690959572792053,
0.4827321767807007,
-0.046778250485658646,
-0.7847393751144409,
-0.4535996913909912,
0.5810118913650513,
-1.2106672525405884,
-0.14138512313365936,
0.9373735189437866,
-0.051798947155475616,
-0.06571678072214127,
-0.0022227666340768337,
-0.21411624550819397,
0.3344518840312958,
-0.7199105024337769,
0.6862195730209351,
0.5405001640319824,
-0.39597898721694946,
0.18449147045612335,
0.08606751263141632,
0.017879081889986992,
0.4164218008518219,
-1.0707796812057495,
0.04157126694917679,
0.9486992955207825,
-0.06202448531985283,
0.22071847319602966,
0.7753288745880127,
-0.011094262823462486,
0.11111651360988617,
-0.3523719310760498,
0.10509507358074188,
0.07949793338775635,
0.015302234329283237,
-0.5899686813354492,
0.27715402841567993,
-0.19468265771865845,
-0.007214531768113375
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.12799v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.12799v1
|
Investigating Text Shortening Strategy in BERT: Truncation vs Summarization
| 2024-03-19T15:01:14 | 2024-03-19T15:01:14 |
Mirza Alim Mutasodirin, Radityo Eko Prasojo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The parallelism of Transformer-based models comes at the cost of their input
max-length. Some studies proposed methods to overcome this limitation, but none
of them reported the effectiveness of summarization as an alternative. In this
study, we investigate the performance of document truncation and summarization
in text classification tasks. Each of the two was investigated with several
variations. This study also investigated how close their performances are to
the performance of full-text. We used a dataset of summarization tasks based on
Indonesian news articles (IndoSum) to do classification tests. This study shows
how the summaries outperform the majority of truncation method variations and
lose to only one. The best strategy obtained in this study is taking the head
of the document. The second is extractive summarization. This study explains
what happened to the result, leading to further research in order to exploit
the potential of document summarization as a shortening alternative. The code
and data used in this work are publicly available in
https://github.com/mirzaalimm/TruncationVsSummarization.
|
[
-0.4763885736465454,
-0.6147922873497009,
0.35931169986724854,
0.2553435266017914,
-0.6398707628250122,
0.1696736365556717,
-0.4922979772090912,
-0.7005104422569275,
0.24026250839233398,
0.38245972990989685,
-0.42120516300201416,
-0.29330936074256897,
-0.832414448261261,
0.406328022480011,
-0.5665079355239868,
1.40491783618927,
-0.06129181757569313,
-0.2384653389453888,
-0.35404619574546814,
-0.12275857478380203,
-0.33165985345840454,
-0.5219280123710632,
-0.3369338810443878,
-0.26344525814056396,
0.7021310925483704,
0.530230700969696,
0.6571156978607178,
0.7716375589370728,
0.8857038021087646,
0.2343115508556366,
-0.45068374276161194,
-0.09883049875497818,
-0.43083590269088745,
0.2515873312950134,
0.2281590849161148,
-0.5559108257293701,
0.03158346563577652,
-0.09050870686769485,
0.716282069683075,
0.5731913447380066,
0.27912580966949463,
0.2788470387458801,
0.2389642894268036,
0.8576781749725342,
-0.6091598272323608,
0.0722195953130722,
-0.1147499606013298,
0.012009895406663418,
-0.4464678168296814,
-0.020713375881314278,
-0.3927852511405945,
-0.37697741389274597,
0.37243255972862244,
-0.1388487070798874,
0.5584378242492676,
0.01563846319913864,
1.2987046241760254,
0.1326998472213745,
-0.3146021366119385,
-0.33111894130706787,
-1.050184726715088,
0.9215883612632751,
-0.6445218324661255,
0.05194804072380066,
-0.005387276876717806,
0.2563845217227936,
0.5225480198860168,
-0.7490736246109009,
-0.3511431813240051,
0.11362849175930023,
-0.3998928368091583,
0.17904362082481384,
0.07741181552410126,
0.2695140838623047,
0.41663655638694763,
0.4351610243320465,
-0.7848067879676819,
0.17887651920318604,
-0.8492744565010071,
-0.042643822729587555,
0.5307344198226929,
-0.20993611216545105,
-0.04311390966176987,
-0.4824386239051819,
-0.12340942025184631,
-0.6095953583717346,
-0.40683650970458984,
0.03508930653333664,
0.49626606702804565,
0.1362132877111435,
0.1596430093050003,
0.6347740888595581,
0.02487301267683506,
0.3115023672580719,
-0.30171602964401245,
-0.2242898941040039,
0.14331278204917908,
-0.10984739661216736,
-0.27672654390335083,
0.2936736047267914,
0.5053724646568298,
0.5103715658187866,
0.14961515367031097,
0.014445683918893337,
-0.10519446432590485,
-0.14498871564865112,
0.2810443937778473,
-0.8732160329818726,
0.07279554754495621,
0.11591930687427521,
-0.9762606620788574,
-0.48653581738471985,
0.05218888446688652,
-0.7867772579193115,
0.03158470615744591,
-0.04959318786859512,
0.5439412593841553,
-0.5110390782356262,
0.13810774683952332,
-0.16100823879241943,
-0.6636949777603149,
0.3081355690956116,
0.23333656787872314,
-0.8904758095741272,
0.42056336998939514,
0.6329700946807861,
1.1402430534362793,
-0.3200128376483917,
-0.09254490584135056,
0.029483582824468613,
0.25200921297073364,
-0.10069242864847183,
0.7813872694969177,
-0.1941099911928177,
-0.7970083355903625,
-0.09708645939826965,
-0.29158875346183777,
-0.1954183578491211,
-0.3379348814487457,
1.0576221942901611,
-0.3195379972457886,
0.6114444136619568,
-0.2535693347454071,
-0.6574189066886902,
-0.566796600818634,
0.06617067754268646,
-0.8643126487731934,
0.95878005027771,
-0.16778241097927094,
-1.0772066116333008,
0.2891829013824463,
-0.7849296927452087,
-0.8579530119895935,
-0.11892368644475937,
0.2002037763595581,
-0.857780396938324,
0.22730882465839386,
0.36725422739982605,
0.548919677734375,
-0.11909975856542587,
-0.19611184298992157,
0.18425041437149048,
-0.6850383281707764,
-0.3074842691421509,
-0.2860020697116852,
0.5840920805931091,
0.2118607610464096,
-0.21801644563674927,
0.2895623445510864,
-0.5754027962684631,
-0.1494608372449875,
0.2667257785797119,
-0.21976646780967712,
-0.7546976804733276,
0.1845274567604065,
0.20329834520816803,
-0.045066818594932556,
0.09838217496871948,
-0.5300094485282898,
0.23348480463027954,
-0.6172370314598083,
0.1906243860721588,
0.5292027592658997,
0.20404641330242157,
0.35787779092788696,
-0.7850017547607422,
0.19166336953639984,
-0.35000479221343994,
0.3030320703983307,
-0.22370430827140808,
-0.39641958475112915,
-0.8983257412910461,
-0.33152735233306885,
0.7989439368247986,
0.4533335566520691,
-0.5614361763000488,
0.3576405346393585,
-0.5451435446739197,
-0.744113564491272,
-0.39950117468833923,
-0.209467351436615,
0.3095802962779999,
0.4261772036552429,
0.2581501007080078,
-0.2576046884059906,
-0.6548483967781067,
-0.9693509340286255,
-0.2904004156589508,
-0.2879869043827057,
-0.14551910758018494,
-0.01640026830136776,
0.6122741103172302,
0.07765715569257736,
1.0660436153411865,
-0.6799266934394836,
-0.3978109061717987,
-0.7181889414787292,
0.4991048276424408,
0.39092960953712463,
0.4452410042285919,
0.8544753789901733,
-0.9870104193687439,
-0.48832967877388,
-0.4683316946029663,
-0.5295440554618835,
0.1657535433769226,
-0.21724097430706024,
0.15946754813194275,
0.38990965485572815,
0.08956753462553024,
-0.7303295731544495,
0.8408637642860413,
0.18789513409137726,
0.3184794783592224,
0.7949485778808594,
-0.4706123471260071,
0.10245874524116516,
-0.8539913296699524,
0.09491127729415894,
-0.2466309368610382,
-0.3569933772087097,
-0.7499926090240479,
-0.09751657396554947,
0.24809066951274872,
-0.12370458990335464,
-0.34905368089675903,
0.08453530818223953,
-0.3746710419654846,
-0.15961512923240662,
-0.31802621483802795,
-0.14568333327770233,
0.09016493707895279,
0.505545973777771,
0.11221574991941452,
0.9020729660987854,
0.07496605068445206,
-0.7657200694084167,
0.04267727956175804,
0.4262771010398865,
-0.31607910990715027,
-0.277183473110199,
-0.8501351475715637,
-0.15490005910396576,
-0.48063936829566956,
0.2641497254371643,
-0.9384979605674744,
-0.02400059625506401,
-0.11991642415523529,
-0.46524757146835327,
0.2762773633003235,
0.16771095991134644,
-0.868529736995697,
-0.6747229099273682,
-0.8820220232009888,
0.19500477612018585,
0.8059327006340027,
-0.47710511088371277,
0.4270216226577759,
-0.008292253129184246,
-0.47501683235168457,
-0.5651926398277283,
-0.7789811491966248,
-0.06938448548316956,
-0.4233682453632355,
-0.5441415905952454,
0.6436645984649658,
-0.1506272554397583,
0.008163019083440304,
-0.017965255305171013,
-0.17936870455741882,
-0.011113985441625118,
-0.013002428226172924,
0.1269114762544632,
0.31211116909980774,
0.10863957554101944,
0.302397757768631,
0.5223295092582703,
0.1707787662744522,
0.063517726957798,
0.0027023067232221365,
0.3754226863384247,
0.06515639275312424,
-0.0260374266654253,
-0.3389629125595093,
0.43579956889152527,
0.5370433926582336,
-0.17024950683116913,
0.9847137928009033,
0.5429750084877014,
-0.17476864159107208,
-0.02922346070408821,
-0.548785924911499,
-0.2245742380619049,
-0.3889569640159607,
0.0929853767156601,
-0.1785666048526764,
-0.7175643444061279,
0.5596621632575989,
-0.08911798894405365,
0.3225885033607483,
0.7107592225074768,
0.23821470141410828,
-0.312101811170578,
0.6170095205307007,
0.8735472559928894,
-0.1405906081199646,
0.36985501646995544,
-0.44947969913482666,
0.3653332591056824,
-0.5623574256896973,
0.01614353433251381,
-0.7731014490127563,
-0.44652503728866577,
-0.6330233216285706,
-0.04237046465277672,
0.46394166350364685,
-0.10920236259698868,
0.4966011643409729,
0.5852959752082825,
-0.5929512977600098,
0.606006383895874,
0.7829328179359436,
0.10705583542585373,
0.2923678457736969,
0.0015758174704387784,
-0.03325485438108444,
-0.21076636016368866,
-0.5760131478309631,
-0.3882758915424347,
1.1380342245101929,
0.23534579575061798,
0.4283463954925537,
0.06602287292480469,
0.8362784385681152,
0.503279447555542,
0.10416118055582047,
-0.7363240718841553,
0.43818509578704834,
-0.19465501606464386,
-0.412570983171463,
-0.47409307956695557,
-0.47745460271835327,
-0.8236722350120544,
0.4289007782936096,
-0.1784731149673462,
-0.42436733841896057,
0.08547233790159225,
-0.18415305018424988,
-0.2243669629096985,
0.4320574402809143,
-0.6678128838539124,
0.5278317928314209,
-0.08586716651916504,
0.0542110949754715,
-0.381278932094574,
-0.9943745136260986,
0.1870347112417221,
-0.013142638839781284,
0.12597253918647766,
0.06546760350465775,
0.059418972581624985,
1.2793580293655396,
-0.43652603030204773,
0.5552889704704285,
0.015278035774827003,
0.036068689078092575,
0.09836282581090927,
-0.32866859436035156,
0.4774342179298401,
-0.27156662940979004,
0.15046967566013336,
0.10521253943443298,
-0.03840876743197441,
-0.4216077923774719,
-0.47773653268814087,
0.3323143720626831,
-0.7366715669631958,
-0.5945887565612793,
-0.5908253788948059,
-0.5357772707939148,
-0.05001518130302429,
0.45089855790138245,
0.5021945238113403,
0.3781156837940216,
-0.06369416415691376,
0.32059165835380554,
0.7941674590110779,
-0.10324566811323166,
1.0481367111206055,
0.14946335554122925,
0.07317512482404709,
-0.1835128664970398,
0.7290383577346802,
0.22389771044254303,
0.007046983111649752,
0.787208616733551,
0.21404336392879486,
-0.38512665033340454,
-0.5217635631561279,
-0.11273791640996933,
0.4332577586174011,
-0.4538007080554962,
-0.08783354610204697,
-0.5590016841888428,
-0.5209811925888062,
-0.7012667059898376,
-0.16064804792404175,
-0.1393757462501526,
-1.0302809476852417,
-0.20417790114879608,
-0.16873839497566223,
0.08069147169589996,
0.62924724817276,
0.14034752547740936,
0.4375225901603699,
-1.0395352840423584,
0.02344791404902935,
0.15770629048347473,
0.019063536077737808,
0.11065865308046341,
-0.25962120294570923,
-0.33941155672073364,
-0.4316759407520294,
-0.461645245552063,
-0.9223382472991943,
0.4763581454753876,
0.12764623761177063,
0.22029635310173035,
0.5058268308639526,
0.4332475960254669,
0.62087082862854,
-0.4566255211830139,
0.6879569292068481,
0.12131540477275848,
-0.8728564381599426,
0.5766023993492126,
-0.16124895215034485,
0.39642220735549927,
0.43948954343795776,
0.39157968759536743,
-0.5055751204490662,
-0.59386146068573,
-0.6738044023513794,
-0.9957274794578552,
0.6809565424919128,
0.8203892111778259,
-0.11521030962467194,
0.3747275173664093,
0.23869015276432037,
0.3352776765823364,
0.3606541156768799,
-0.3941613733768463,
-0.3613292872905731,
0.06749556958675385,
-0.30460914969444275,
-0.05121276527643204,
-0.6754091382026672,
0.15200991928577423,
-0.15271517634391785,
0.6843211054801941,
0.36335238814353943,
0.40518248081207275,
0.34482723474502563,
-0.43212711811065674,
0.1846722513437271,
0.404943585395813,
0.9304802417755127,
0.851841390132904,
-0.4924691319465637,
-0.16331768035888672,
0.027299823239445686,
-0.6384670734405518,
-0.16836021840572357,
0.20085802674293518,
-0.4124099612236023,
0.717841386795044,
0.6477832198143005,
0.6959520578384399,
0.05974733456969261,
-0.7152132987976074,
0.6611919403076172,
-0.29495128989219666,
-0.4412887394428253,
-0.24291017651557922,
-0.1668803095817566,
-0.39524516463279724,
-0.15539462864398956,
0.6169275045394897,
0.1055406704545021,
0.43727317452430725,
-0.06204953417181969,
0.021718265488743782,
-0.03703095391392708,
-0.014483590610325336,
-0.04404682293534279,
0.5265750288963318,
0.24420258402824402,
0.07201085239648819,
0.46466296911239624,
0.2387208789587021,
-0.6032034754753113,
0.7479013204574585,
0.198298841714859,
0.7932282090187073,
-0.0741463154554367,
0.2275446206331253,
0.23346856236457825,
0.4650426208972931,
-0.0036665587686002254,
-0.09108208119869232,
-0.3649490177631378,
-0.09638555347919464,
-0.6320962309837341,
-0.3733297288417816,
-0.7000898122787476,
-0.012030999176204205,
-0.8675851225852966,
0.22040720283985138,
-0.24742144346237183,
-0.05080333724617958,
0.01027753483504057,
0.21525612473487854,
-0.16088885068893433,
0.08667974174022675,
-0.13027401268482208,
1.0804414749145508,
-0.7379283905029297,
0.6928478479385376,
0.6120683550834656,
-0.31485292315483093,
-0.2408907115459442,
0.31411296129226685,
-0.22187715768814087,
-0.17959095537662506,
0.42735376954078674,
0.519777238368988,
0.3362927734851837,
-0.34054049849510193,
-0.18507705628871918,
-0.6718047261238098,
1.0106587409973145,
0.029158953577280045,
-0.4531850218772888,
-0.5476452112197876,
0.16642045974731445,
0.5095807313919067,
0.1682601124048233,
0.28436094522476196,
0.441438227891922,
0.4746614992618561,
-0.033059872686862946,
-1.0007946491241455,
-0.1836206465959549,
0.0028116193134337664,
0.4169279634952545,
0.39186936616897583,
-0.7320972084999084,
0.5647193193435669,
-0.24418717622756958,
-0.3146741986274719,
0.18749448657035828,
0.874970555305481,
-0.21262501180171967,
0.3226475119590759,
0.5280495882034302,
0.5118454694747925,
0.5535752177238464,
-0.15641260147094727,
1.053865909576416,
-0.052324648946523666,
0.6300814151763916,
0.812485933303833,
-0.0469583123922348,
0.6889748573303223,
0.5187442302703857,
-0.07025985419750214,
0.4436752200126648,
0.6417438387870789,
-0.036087118089199066,
0.7071887254714966,
-0.0038707649800926447,
-0.0525670051574707,
0.30323082208633423,
0.029076170176267624,
-0.23003001511096954,
0.2736516296863556,
0.2694547474384308,
-0.30472809076309204,
-0.5714144110679626,
0.47246208786964417,
0.25449448823928833,
0.07542942464351654,
-0.23548267781734467,
0.8857829570770264,
-0.20752115547657013,
-0.4433124363422394,
0.33631062507629395,
0.34706103801727295,
0.6489259004592896,
-0.6436042189598083,
0.15404833853244781,
-0.1353864222764969,
0.21398316323757172,
0.13351713120937347,
-0.6452391147613525,
0.6503852009773254,
0.10580937564373016,
-0.4334005117416382,
-0.4944514334201813,
0.9510233402252197,
-0.3109041154384613,
-0.35334858298301697,
0.09887295961380005,
0.25378838181495667,
0.19134509563446045,
0.07823041081428528,
-0.36178886890411377,
0.10819225758314133,
-0.09991899877786636,
-0.0773048996925354,
0.2012125551700592,
0.15559013187885284,
-0.11201943457126617,
0.4854297339916229,
0.3793822228908539,
0.11529779434204102,
-0.06747753173112869,
-0.06716015934944153,
0.8587307333946228,
-0.5424100160598755,
-0.8107227087020874,
-0.8715860247612,
0.1022927537560463,
-0.4216768741607666,
-0.12476801872253418,
0.7949485778808594,
0.8435788154602051,
0.7880643606185913,
-0.3491063416004181,
0.7969698309898376,
-0.17157848179340363,
0.8841980695724487,
-0.31788644194602966,
0.8004457950592041,
-0.43067115545272827,
-0.04041167348623276,
-0.3044241964817047,
-0.9014883637428284,
-0.4167470335960388,
0.12414489686489105,
-0.29545849561691284,
-0.2804452180862427,
0.9719328284263611,
0.1901770532131195,
0.12597447633743286,
0.22152195870876312,
0.16254474222660065,
0.04036218672990799,
0.36924147605895996,
0.40016207098960876,
0.3797910213470459,
-0.47437846660614014,
1.050327181816101,
-0.6652112603187561,
-0.13315162062644958,
-0.4030109941959381,
-0.6128351092338562,
-1.1553564071655273,
-0.5948833227157593,
-0.15885823965072632,
0.10560913383960724,
0.3992726802825928,
0.3920741379261017,
0.6417196393013,
-0.6365861296653748,
-0.255752831697464,
0.13924691081047058,
0.2576245665550232,
-0.502755880355835,
-0.2854631841182709,
0.7304808497428894,
-0.3839120864868164,
-0.8117300271987915,
-0.08836403489112854,
0.1270241141319275,
0.2246941775083542,
0.30333805084228516,
0.21518166363239288,
-0.15926529467105865,
0.023585118353366852,
0.4784485697746277,
0.217231884598732,
-0.47420379519462585,
-0.1068820059299469,
-0.37145161628723145,
0.047910425812006,
0.042727693915367126,
0.8960642218589783,
-0.7049188017845154,
0.19038234651088715,
0.7491686344146729,
0.7116472721099854,
0.764149010181427,
0.2765979766845703,
0.3413821756839752,
-1.2472387552261353,
0.19984489679336548,
0.18286345899105072,
0.05264611169695854,
0.1178094819188118,
-0.5236084461212158,
0.47737637162208557,
0.2720353901386261,
-0.5115587711334229,
-0.7273582816123962,
-0.28017789125442505,
-0.9507235884666443,
-0.4271482229232788,
0.7006040811538696,
0.007174019236117601,
-0.45631930232048035,
0.2844477891921997,
-0.37918487191200256,
0.31048664450645447,
-0.4632273018360138,
0.7870732545852661,
0.8771836757659912,
-0.23449735343456268,
-0.30465880036354065,
-0.2638055384159088,
0.45293524861335754,
0.46040987968444824,
-0.660220742225647,
-0.15228332579135895,
0.16510087251663208,
-0.03312424197793007,
0.4479130804538727,
0.18496128916740417,
0.023428799584507942,
0.33959317207336426,
-0.4423843026161194,
-0.05204503983259201,
-0.01900356449186802,
-0.39327937364578247,
-0.20873700082302094,
0.3833245038986206,
-0.36985960602760315,
-0.5081493258476257
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.12776v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.12776v1
|
Automated Data Curation for Robust Language Model Fine-Tuning
| 2024-03-19T14:44:45 | 2024-03-19T14:44:45 |
Jiuhai Chen, Jonas Mueller
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models have become the de facto approach to
sequence-to-sequence text generation tasks, but for specialized tasks/domains,
a pretrained LLM lacks specific capabilities to produce accurate or
well-formatted responses. Supervised fine-tuning specializes a LLM by training
it on dataset of example prompts with target responses, but real-world data
tends to be noisy. While many fine-tuning algorithms exist, here we consider a
\emph{data-centric AI} perspective on LLM fine-tuning, studying how to
\emph{systematically} curate the training dataset to improve the LLM produced
via \emph{any} fine-tuning algorithm.
We introduce an automated data curation pipeline CLEAR (Confidence-based LLM
Evaluation And Rectification) for instruction tuning datasets, that can be used
with any LLM and fine-tuning procedure. CLEAR estimates which training data is
low-quality and either filters or corrects it. Automatically identifying which
data to filter or correct is done via LLM-derived confidence estimates, to
ensure only confident modifications to the dataset. Unlike existing data
curation techniques, CLEAR is a comprehensive framework that can improve a
dataset (and trained model outputs) without additional fine-tuning
computations. We don't assume access to a stronger LLM than the model being
fine-tuned (e.g.\ relying on GPT-4 when fine-tuning GPT-3.5), to see whether
CLEAR can meaningfully improve the capabilities of any LLM. Experiments reveal
that CLEAR consistently improves the performance of fine-tuned models across
many datasets and models (like GPT-3.5 and Llama2).
|
[
-0.31164243817329407,
-0.9180079102516174,
0.4669165015220642,
-0.35419961810112,
-0.2795596718788147,
0.01636829413473606,
-0.418969988822937,
-0.4057020843029022,
-0.25014448165893555,
0.7519648671150208,
-0.6681339740753174,
-0.7346705198287964,
-0.6018168330192566,
0.0940806046128273,
-0.6205689907073975,
1.1333671808242798,
-0.039986975491046906,
-0.10732635855674744,
-0.018894385546445847,
0.14989407360553741,
-0.6090403199195862,
-0.3054541051387787,
-0.9313989877700806,
-0.4661911129951477,
0.2535271644592285,
0.7524905800819397,
0.7511670589447021,
1.240939974784851,
0.3041226863861084,
0.33013641834259033,
0.1254499852657318,
0.5979829430580139,
-0.8512284159660339,
0.39863455295562744,
-0.1705082803964615,
-0.5617980360984802,
-0.42994341254234314,
0.1592525839805603,
0.45294591784477234,
0.7790930271148682,
-0.07451137155294418,
0.23658983409404755,
0.1725848913192749,
0.8224577903747559,
-0.697360634803772,
0.17796330153942108,
-0.9308605194091797,
0.011564386077225208,
-0.2856079638004303,
-0.27853885293006897,
-0.4224983751773834,
-0.36660677194595337,
-0.3173154294490814,
-0.6480805277824402,
0.5407869815826416,
0.20909972488880157,
0.9931480884552002,
0.668542742729187,
-0.09960880875587463,
-0.04451826214790344,
-1.0271965265274048,
0.8316859602928162,
-0.7957616448402405,
0.2915637493133545,
0.4441624879837036,
0.031049849465489388,
-0.3792155385017395,
-0.7868527173995972,
-0.4244452714920044,
-0.006949671544134617,
0.027070704847574234,
0.100126251578331,
0.0424235537648201,
0.29975759983062744,
0.4531560242176056,
0.7575526237487793,
-0.44027087092399597,
0.32182735204696655,
-0.3855416774749756,
-0.28101566433906555,
0.7783868312835693,
0.23163093626499176,
-0.07440431416034698,
0.2959907352924347,
0.16142131388187408,
0.0050501455552875996,
-0.9283100962638855,
-0.10957366973161697,
0.5023017525672913,
0.540503978729248,
0.08411905914545059,
0.578177273273468,
-0.6384471654891968,
0.827931821346283,
0.4589005708694458,
-0.01579669862985611,
0.05462700501084328,
-0.3708690404891968,
-0.40603771805763245,
-0.038389790803194046,
0.6207798719406128,
0.1436421275138855,
0.7758627533912659,
-0.04773082584142685,
-0.6154508590698242,
0.11393850296735764,
0.21881262958049774,
-0.8865329623222351,
-0.7492143511772156,
0.29308566451072693,
-0.24916261434555054,
-0.24404604732990265,
0.11052010208368301,
-0.2075786292552948,
-0.3355681300163269,
-0.7523648142814636,
0.14865438640117645,
-0.2462412565946579,
0.0578404925763607,
0.2516135573387146,
0.29314154386520386,
0.04142585024237633,
0.3326016366481781,
-0.9633367657661438,
0.33510902523994446,
0.8779909014701843,
0.4871810972690582,
-0.2764607071876526,
0.11799075454473495,
-0.9577206969261169,
0.06942108273506165,
-0.40050074458122253,
0.7416644096374512,
-0.5940734148025513,
-0.17520728707313538,
0.13623404502868652,
0.013159318827092648,
0.1150834783911705,
-0.6341026425361633,
0.7147231698036194,
-0.3905382752418518,
0.21448871493339539,
-0.01562652550637722,
-0.9341059327125549,
-0.03271964564919472,
0.22312594950199127,
-0.657233715057373,
0.9112516045570374,
-0.026035793125629425,
-0.5674406290054321,
0.7144023180007935,
-0.4445520341396332,
-0.47615310549736023,
0.011512472294270992,
-0.1111026480793953,
-0.7014325857162476,
0.04334324225783348,
0.4350806176662445,
0.5990267395973206,
-0.05720937252044678,
0.4085322916507721,
-0.454664021730423,
-0.4719802737236023,
-0.1207011416554451,
-0.5755952596664429,
0.5217013359069824,
0.4333815276622772,
-0.1816501021385193,
0.3594496250152588,
-0.8651993274688721,
0.3008500933647156,
-0.21466276049613953,
-0.22150397300720215,
-0.013610264286398888,
0.08140981197357178,
-0.1362258642911911,
0.030868183821439743,
0.34894004464149475,
-0.49331361055374146,
0.17588815093040466,
-0.6301486492156982,
0.49445992708206177,
0.7650293707847595,
0.0583813302218914,
0.5334710478782654,
-0.5346530675888062,
0.3189377784729004,
0.048438478261232376,
0.20133143663406372,
-0.35219070315361023,
-0.3726363480091095,
-1.0374614000320435,
-0.4298369288444519,
0.4183851182460785,
0.6406581997871399,
-0.34833166003227234,
0.6329019665718079,
-0.13227282464504242,
-0.4080854654312134,
-0.7566365003585815,
0.5320848822593689,
0.4045862555503845,
0.6647674441337585,
0.17965488135814667,
-0.49803251028060913,
-0.4830781817436218,
-0.866197407245636,
-0.09544207900762558,
0.1259700208902359,
-0.12032312154769897,
0.1621478945016861,
0.2950361967086792,
-0.13152983784675598,
0.916070282459259,
-0.5514214634895325,
-0.2959795296192169,
0.03506837412714958,
0.11796827614307404,
0.31260186433792114,
0.6130419969558716,
-0.06855528056621552,
-0.629061758518219,
-0.371521919965744,
-0.02886776439845562,
-0.4429091811180115,
-0.2060818076133728,
-0.08017632365226746,
-0.06632941961288452,
0.20321869850158691,
0.7469865083694458,
-0.32035133242607117,
0.3678382337093353,
0.3747430443763733,
-0.1669067144393921,
0.4163655638694763,
-0.3133634030818939,
0.14182411134243011,
-0.9802007079124451,
0.21996861696243286,
-0.26442375779151917,
-0.49348437786102295,
-0.713058352470398,
-0.05765460804104805,
-0.07787853479385376,
0.030401555821299553,
-0.20162458717823029,
0.5867164731025696,
-0.277726948261261,
0.12298073619604111,
-0.2599189579486847,
0.08619323372840881,
0.11407505720853806,
0.3653930127620697,
-0.018306497484445572,
0.5724464058876038,
0.4785061776638031,
-0.7179951071739197,
0.30806154012680054,
0.20498503744602203,
-0.29318612813949585,
0.4657762944698334,
-0.6429195404052734,
0.22194021940231323,
0.11372270435094833,
-0.09104097634553909,
-0.9186068177223206,
-0.34160202741622925,
0.22994793951511383,
-0.2591288387775421,
0.5150677561759949,
-0.21065972745418549,
-0.6372672915458679,
-0.09625087678432465,
-0.07350308448076248,
0.16288217902183533,
0.3817727565765381,
-0.4217706620693207,
0.10269155353307724,
0.2409743070602417,
-0.2383459210395813,
-0.4552149474620819,
-0.5777778029441833,
-0.1108691543340683,
-0.1728554219007492,
-0.6028316617012024,
0.25504422187805176,
-0.12777704000473022,
-0.19126471877098083,
-0.30580493807792664,
-0.09265577793121338,
-0.298300176858902,
0.26990261673927307,
0.3509833812713623,
0.18889296054840088,
-0.010910220444202423,
0.14184391498565674,
0.20911827683448792,
-0.1563170701265335,
-0.0977911427617073,
-0.28487735986709595,
0.4285973608493805,
-0.11033131927251816,
-0.6321315765380859,
-0.49537864327430725,
0.11614250391721725,
0.3019806742668152,
-0.29370903968811035,
0.4732458293437958,
0.6382606029510498,
-0.40548309683799744,
-0.3649318814277649,
-0.5647194385528564,
-0.592003583908081,
-0.48914647102355957,
0.15413467586040497,
-0.29569190740585327,
-1.0129293203353882,
0.6570935845375061,
0.008992013521492481,
0.4106283187866211,
0.3747161030769348,
0.46074172854423523,
-0.10783882439136505,
1.2319148778915405,
0.7618680596351624,
-0.19032292068004608,
0.4788571894168854,
-0.11403416097164154,
0.2395789623260498,
-0.4433077275753021,
-0.009599748998880386,
-0.5379291772842407,
-0.39344364404678345,
-0.8575097918510437,
0.14885951578617096,
-0.04966646060347557,
0.16651774942874908,
-0.5837146043777466,
-0.08013977110385895,
-0.7072041034698486,
0.4967314600944519,
0.7526727914810181,
0.12438563257455826,
0.6125527024269104,
-0.08348972350358963,
0.12008467316627502,
0.1144234761595726,
-0.7400624752044678,
-0.6328637599945068,
1.2016326189041138,
0.30439168214797974,
0.8457863330841064,
-0.4576113224029541,
0.6723619103431702,
0.19831623136997223,
0.35779905319213867,
-0.7775993347167969,
0.30702197551727295,
-0.4458015263080597,
-0.39813312888145447,
-0.4095601439476013,
-0.3400235176086426,
-0.9193107485771179,
-0.41579675674438477,
-0.3833886682987213,
-0.27964073419570923,
-0.018151117488741875,
0.5956311821937561,
-0.3713071346282959,
0.28762999176979065,
-0.5943720936775208,
0.691264271736145,
0.05726893991231918,
-0.34879177808761597,
-0.054560765624046326,
-0.5529443025588989,
0.4587734341621399,
-0.2686138451099396,
-0.036587197333574295,
-0.10988834500312805,
0.24150754511356354,
0.40691155195236206,
-0.43876054883003235,
0.8668345808982849,
-0.1059398353099823,
-0.26030272245407104,
0.17905983328819275,
0.14740918576717377,
0.6353257894515991,
0.13034380972385406,
-0.27484455704689026,
0.007394333370029926,
-0.10534176975488663,
-0.2633662819862366,
-0.47071409225463867,
0.6546927094459534,
-0.6215522289276123,
-0.5600278973579407,
0.009494361467659473,
-0.7229907512664795,
-0.25490716099739075,
0.38105541467666626,
0.42540282011032104,
0.2536095380783081,
0.034209270030260086,
0.1756482869386673,
0.9152399897575378,
0.011634758673608303,
0.1157892495393753,
0.43169233202934265,
0.1100785881280899,
-0.1380433291196823,
0.6921678781509399,
-0.13136400282382965,
0.33022263646125793,
0.4401989281177521,
-0.08593439310789108,
-0.25712165236473083,
-0.8466497659683228,
-0.27243372797966003,
-0.059691354632377625,
-0.44877931475639343,
-0.47151878476142883,
-0.16670124232769012,
-0.5210385322570801,
-0.35274171829223633,
-0.10064297914505005,
-0.5519619584083557,
-0.4386163651943207,
-0.4945879578590393,
-0.14403246343135834,
0.5504285097122192,
0.6746369004249573,
0.0034784076269716024,
0.36630958318710327,
-0.6548904180526733,
0.35319119691848755,
0.2092418223619461,
0.5632272362709045,
-0.5826659202575684,
-0.7654667496681213,
-0.20488911867141724,
0.3829498589038849,
-0.35921308398246765,
-0.26660212874412537,
0.5002581477165222,
0.5488061904907227,
0.31892672181129456,
0.5351564884185791,
0.13821174204349518,
0.7923805117607117,
-0.4352152943611145,
0.570351779460907,
-0.3608311414718628,
-0.7852858304977417,
0.7267605066299438,
-0.3794952929019928,
0.38924670219421387,
0.8972901701927185,
-0.12862305343151093,
-0.30505815148353577,
-0.8423818349838257,
-0.5535408854484558,
-0.755936861038208,
0.4803048074245453,
0.1018575131893158,
0.04679613560438156,
0.12562648952007294,
0.7637130618095398,
0.2249206006526947,
0.4306635558605194,
-0.36099645495414734,
-0.24619446694850922,
-0.10693758726119995,
-0.49109601974487305,
-0.1578911542892456,
0.046351924538612366,
-0.11898632347583771,
-0.11908984929323196,
0.69187992811203,
-0.2526266872882843,
-0.10343755781650543,
0.03395814448595047,
-0.056110091507434845,
-0.2142336517572403,
0.2588970363140106,
0.4031265377998352,
0.4945712387561798,
-0.2099882960319519,
0.02732895314693451,
0.10983031243085861,
-0.4892648756504059,
-0.1531084030866623,
0.18420855700969696,
-0.5277177095413208,
-0.17871558666229248,
0.2760140895843506,
0.7354750037193298,
-0.017863983288407326,
-0.5443300008773804,
0.18569813668727875,
0.03332918509840965,
-0.2777712941169739,
-0.14541660249233246,
0.5692446231842041,
-0.2537439465522766,
0.006653331220149994,
-0.0190278273075819,
0.15034404397010803,
0.2361302375793457,
-0.2756211757659912,
0.44616439938545227,
0.48770666122436523,
-0.49251919984817505,
-0.011621666140854359,
0.65279620885849,
0.2180534303188324,
-0.07700444757938385,
1.130082368850708,
-0.15709516406059265,
-0.18502192199230194,
0.5439736247062683,
0.28140148520469666,
0.8328297734260559,
-0.13953065872192383,
-0.1383601576089859,
0.45831063389778137,
0.21705308556556702,
-0.21749068796634674,
0.3727428615093231,
0.08280827850103378,
-0.8693015575408936,
-0.7020218372344971,
-0.6118770241737366,
-0.47436922788619995,
0.5121946930885315,
-0.5998780727386475,
0.39838284254074097,
-0.5379644632339478,
-0.01384047046303749,
-0.3514929413795471,
0.39542701840400696,
-0.7675967216491699,
0.5334442257881165,
0.23851428925991058,
0.8995717167854309,
-0.8893250823020935,
0.8968648910522461,
0.3342684507369995,
-0.041547853499650955,
-0.957602858543396,
-0.34360629320144653,
-0.1176982894539833,
-0.7160579562187195,
0.3283199965953827,
0.1947159767150879,
-0.11594671756029129,
0.1328365057706833,
-0.8530619740486145,
-0.6775614619255066,
1.0694712400436401,
0.6214571595191956,
-0.9229417443275452,
0.24025295674800873,
0.21700511872768402,
0.6044303178787231,
-0.4642353653907776,
-0.03743567690253258,
0.7718477249145508,
0.5527719855308533,
0.015923287719488144,
-0.9268209338188171,
-0.05418996140360832,
-0.3374459147453308,
-0.23980677127838135,
0.1759158819913864,
-0.30344948172569275,
0.6650068759918213,
-0.28017401695251465,
-0.3340716063976288,
0.2663804590702057,
0.6760729551315308,
0.4409797489643097,
0.18463437259197235,
0.4545545279979706,
0.632960319519043,
1.1451220512390137,
-0.3504614531993866,
0.7361336946487427,
-0.6831710338592529,
0.13715322315692902,
1.510944128036499,
-0.10326017439365387,
0.7652491331100464,
0.38148948550224304,
0.21709246933460236,
0.1446262151002884,
0.8667594790458679,
-0.2660149931907654,
0.4073789119720459,
0.3373299241065979,
-0.049782294780015945,
-0.36997082829475403,
-0.08164680749177933,
-0.06324845552444458,
0.5134961009025574,
0.3602461516857147,
-0.3672177791595459,
0.026218188926577568,
-0.3382064402103424,
-0.09967763721942902,
0.3678988516330719,
-0.5345619320869446,
0.7853364944458008,
0.03806503117084503,
-0.7827740907669067,
0.5010160207748413,
0.04411650076508522,
0.590900719165802,
-0.4023513197898865,
-0.1097591370344162,
-0.39174240827560425,
0.2729499638080597,
-0.4353776276111603,
-0.9304707050323486,
0.45395100116729736,
-0.010157373733818531,
-0.3538413941860199,
-0.4317862391471863,
0.863362193107605,
-0.7110255360603333,
-0.3709047734737396,
-0.24020011723041534,
0.5425559878349304,
0.10262943804264069,
-0.11309117823839188,
-0.6186887621879578,
-0.08950353413820267,
0.08743155747652054,
-0.3054031431674957,
-0.0703732967376709,
0.5452567934989929,
-0.1381736695766449,
0.9033858776092529,
0.7537563443183899,
0.24997392296791077,
-0.11049410700798035,
0.3317335844039917,
0.725284218788147,
-0.37733203172683716,
-0.18732379376888275,
-0.7814617156982422,
0.4021162986755371,
0.051624760031700134,
-0.279060959815979,
0.3603391945362091,
0.6952717900276184,
0.9935956597328186,
0.02469305507838726,
0.7918805480003357,
0.2444400042295456,
0.5563405156135559,
-0.6501519680023193,
0.8106274008750916,
-0.2597251534461975,
0.30982446670532227,
0.12398100644350052,
-0.8947221040725708,
-0.5251075029373169,
0.564835786819458,
-0.30606672167778015,
0.22275368869304657,
0.2133283168077469,
1.0225133895874023,
-0.18589095771312714,
-0.03153110668063164,
0.22337332367897034,
0.3686261475086212,
0.33861565589904785,
0.47875362634658813,
0.4065675735473633,
-0.3659857213497162,
0.4542900621891022,
-0.3347961902618408,
-0.0685892328619957,
0.010799635201692581,
-0.9686018824577332,
-0.7824394106864929,
-0.503055214881897,
-0.4028263986110687,
-0.01034596934914589,
0.07351768016815186,
0.5918042659759521,
0.9202678203582764,
-1.100358247756958,
0.05394937843084335,
-0.46776485443115234,
0.1346958428621292,
-0.15679942071437836,
-0.20839881896972656,
0.20838125050067902,
-0.6799454092979431,
-0.9262052178382874,
0.1598999947309494,
0.1527181714773178,
-0.04149105027318001,
-0.12189698219299316,
-0.005061740521341562,
0.2720264494419098,
-0.06110512837767601,
0.3774230480194092,
0.25425195693969727,
-0.41909700632095337,
-0.40396443009376526,
-0.07272952795028687,
-0.21911069750785828,
0.14701467752456665,
0.42760491371154785,
-0.761132001876831,
0.5154234170913696,
0.3660244345664978,
0.5369424819946289,
0.44927242398262024,
0.10438641905784607,
0.8489760160446167,
-0.8792670965194702,
-0.04394737258553505,
0.27036577463150024,
0.2611532509326935,
0.5548137426376343,
-0.49546611309051514,
0.4724236726760864,
-0.17586183547973633,
-0.7651539444923401,
-0.608450174331665,
0.34496667981147766,
-0.8182315230369568,
0.059313371777534485,
1.0970362424850464,
-0.08273601531982422,
0.06408465653657913,
-0.28327420353889465,
-0.2615968585014343,
0.5290964841842651,
-0.47534283995628357,
0.9389095902442932,
0.5981183648109436,
-0.09474664181470871,
-0.06515520066022873,
-0.6125398874282837,
0.8242271542549133,
0.39768579602241516,
-0.9483247399330139,
0.22860877215862274,
0.5777105689048767,
0.2983619272708893,
-0.23114030063152313,
0.3259694576263428,
-0.04800546541810036,
0.057553067803382874,
-0.3420095443725586,
-0.15314818918704987,
-0.31554192304611206,
-0.3089345395565033,
-0.2741757333278656,
0.1099967211484909,
0.22793619334697723,
-0.05240623280405998
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.12749v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.12749v1
|
Sebastian, Basti, Wastl?! Recognizing Named Entities in Bavarian Dialectal Data
| 2024-03-19T14:12:54 | 2024-03-19T14:12:54 |
Siyao Peng, Zihang Sun, Huangyan Shan, Marie Kolm, Verena Blaschke, Ekaterina Artemova, Barbara Plank
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Named Entity Recognition (NER) is a fundamental task to extract key
information from texts, but annotated resources are scarce for dialects. This
paper introduces the first dialectal NER dataset for German, BarNER, with 161K
tokens annotated on Bavarian Wikipedia articles (bar-wiki) and tweets
(bar-tweet), using a schema adapted from German CoNLL 2006 and GermEval. The
Bavarian dialect differs from standard German in lexical distribution,
syntactic construction, and entity information. We conduct in-domain,
cross-domain, sequential, and joint experiments on two Bavarian and three
German corpora and present the first comprehensive NER results on Bavarian.
Incorporating knowledge from the larger German NER (sub-)datasets notably
improves on bar-wiki and moderately on bar-tweet. Inversely, training first on
Bavarian contributes slightly to the seminal German CoNLL 2006 corpus.
Moreover, with gold dialect labels on Bavarian tweets, we assess multi-task
learning between five NER and two Bavarian-German dialect identification tasks
and achieve NER SOTA on bar-wiki. We substantiate the necessity of our
low-resource BarNER corpus and the importance of diversity in dialects, genres,
and topics in enhancing model performance.
|
[
-0.7128877639770508,
-0.5823982357978821,
0.40387940406799316,
0.11019989848136902,
-0.39082443714141846,
0.042366873472929,
-0.3813488185405731,
-0.4746277630329132,
0.4732900559902191,
0.5411113500595093,
-0.3880486488342285,
-0.5195139050483704,
-0.6657435297966003,
0.29232779145240784,
-0.42221599817276,
1.1113029718399048,
0.3519962430000305,
0.4337270259857178,
0.25797370076179504,
-0.13750216364860535,
0.003258130978792906,
-0.7780048847198486,
-0.9342630505561829,
-0.17937801778316498,
0.9615720510482788,
0.22843748331069946,
0.16614270210266113,
0.23996607959270477,
0.3010397255420685,
0.33915191888809204,
-0.15553808212280273,
0.018704503774642944,
-0.27921628952026367,
-0.020533530041575432,
-0.31868720054626465,
-0.10266073793172836,
-0.3469931483268738,
-0.4025905132293701,
0.5639025568962097,
0.8176948428153992,
0.14537668228149414,
0.024217190220952034,
0.004058969672769308,
0.6035642623901367,
-0.5309063792228699,
0.3964616358280182,
-0.7806228995323181,
-0.291943222284317,
-0.6851966381072998,
0.12164498120546341,
-0.4243500232696533,
-0.09678082913160324,
0.14221864938735962,
-0.5476388335227966,
0.6654942631721497,
0.17378287017345428,
1.2414788007736206,
0.010574333369731903,
-0.7006875872612,
-0.22728301584720612,
-0.6421642303466797,
0.3696220815181732,
-0.5783618092536926,
0.9095612168312073,
0.3054780662059784,
0.2597562372684479,
-0.18371425569057465,
-0.5568795800209045,
-0.608568012714386,
0.08235196769237518,
-0.25620973110198975,
-0.19855448603630066,
-0.5670670866966248,
-0.22727367281913757,
0.25228744745254517,
-0.026852384209632874,
-0.3672510087490082,
0.05147705599665642,
-0.4459786117076874,
-0.2947435975074768,
0.5070491433143616,
-0.06160958483815193,
-0.1272173970937729,
-0.2596362233161926,
-0.027379561215639114,
0.024964360520243645,
-0.6512123346328735,
-0.10227596014738083,
0.30292028188705444,
0.4675772488117218,
0.05354871228337288,
0.2870350480079651,
-0.2828385531902313,
0.47120893001556396,
0.4699784517288208,
0.12392400205135345,
0.5137311220169067,
-0.056332822889089584,
-0.08640195429325104,
0.17638377845287323,
0.6661173701286316,
0.010973986238241196,
0.45425572991371155,
-0.7203472256660461,
-0.3221794664859772,
-0.49652278423309326,
0.234950453042984,
-0.7820931077003479,
-0.49773308634757996,
-0.18864227831363678,
-0.14235858619213104,
-0.04141027107834816,
0.34856101870536804,
-0.6284279227256775,
-0.41366270184516907,
-0.27980437874794006,
0.09768091887235641,
-0.5058236718177795,
-0.34272250533103943,
-0.37588798999786377,
-0.38719746470451355,
0.3317861557006836,
0.35264378786087036,
-1.1216398477554321,
0.4735126495361328,
0.7741864323616028,
0.3480663001537323,
0.0023590882774442434,
-0.16524751484394073,
-0.4353983402252197,
0.09795289486646652,
-0.5744532942771912,
0.8486003875732422,
-0.2400495857000351,
-0.14991742372512817,
0.025970373302698135,
0.5291921496391296,
0.07351116836071014,
-0.8960846066474915,
0.17954714596271515,
-0.9458773136138916,
-0.17490653693675995,
-0.27969133853912354,
-0.6286566257476807,
-0.35686686635017395,
-0.009442710317671299,
-1.0963364839553833,
0.9640342593193054,
0.38633692264556885,
-0.9378823637962341,
0.5893924236297607,
-0.4195629358291626,
-0.7966500520706177,
0.2051418274641037,
-0.11162110418081284,
-0.10587319731712341,
0.424118310213089,
0.057972125709056854,
0.5677251219749451,
-0.2747938334941864,
0.4330556392669678,
-0.10874617844820023,
-0.10800867527723312,
0.48639169335365295,
-0.24121442437171936,
0.7294819951057434,
-0.12435878813266754,
-0.27788764238357544,
-0.2509952485561371,
-1.0674750804901123,
0.06235345080494881,
0.005513996351510286,
-0.3500607907772064,
-0.5667306184768677,
-0.04220695421099663,
0.58322674036026,
-0.06517217308282852,
-0.07793603092432022,
-0.6277751922607422,
-0.36795592308044434,
-0.41093555092811584,
0.3675651550292969,
0.5110207796096802,
0.1670699268579483,
0.3184813857078552,
-0.052373237907886505,
0.13117697834968567,
0.22640909254550934,
-0.4649543762207031,
0.2737751007080078,
-0.014816711656749249,
-1.215343713760376,
-0.3701261579990387,
0.8491116166114807,
0.6096081137657166,
-0.6131474375724792,
0.6169695258140564,
-0.5685161352157593,
-0.7076584100723267,
-0.30708351731300354,
-0.1607581079006195,
0.2707202136516571,
0.3653101921081543,
0.4220167398452759,
-0.20014642179012299,
-0.6331904530525208,
-1.1167389154434204,
0.12368746846914291,
-0.2076253592967987,
-0.21642868220806122,
0.26614516973495483,
0.6905179023742676,
0.048135269433259964,
0.9070413708686829,
-0.032668255269527435,
-0.14967945218086243,
-0.33476248383522034,
0.2609722316265106,
0.18973654508590698,
0.31103387475013733,
0.6219951510429382,
-0.8543572425842285,
-0.5886533260345459,
0.19015604257583618,
-0.5683094263076782,
-0.2676962614059448,
0.19307705760002136,
-0.1574055254459381,
0.5023472309112549,
0.4104560911655426,
-0.4836674928665161,
0.03887663409113884,
0.2629544734954834,
-0.09008032828569412,
0.41343751549720764,
0.310935914516449,
0.024057505652308464,
-1.1770519018173218,
-0.01227512862533331,
-0.10000429302453995,
-0.22897376120090485,
-0.7171067595481873,
-0.396231085062027,
0.09251253306865692,
0.2693707346916199,
-0.3992083668708801,
0.9743683934211731,
-0.5358067154884338,
0.18469132483005524,
-0.14930640161037445,
0.07650686800479889,
-0.11910261958837509,
0.4533904790878296,
0.27420946955680847,
0.48759666085243225,
0.48212307691574097,
-0.4976264536380768,
0.32154548168182373,
0.1592913419008255,
-0.5823548436164856,
0.7515344023704529,
-0.5223338603973389,
0.23855926096439362,
-0.16714231669902802,
-0.033323388546705246,
-0.4779989421367645,
-0.44126951694488525,
0.32854193449020386,
-0.4675624966621399,
0.6218054890632629,
-0.3350621461868286,
-0.6140098571777344,
0.12432729452848434,
0.43751946091651917,
0.12846964597702026,
0.10775458812713623,
-0.37638500332832336,
0.6688202023506165,
0.561507523059845,
-0.5042036175727844,
-0.41818609833717346,
-0.5372464656829834,
0.2328782081604004,
-0.3212881088256836,
-0.47487378120422363,
0.46154868602752686,
0.3660806119441986,
-0.2912251353263855,
0.34758132696151733,
-0.27022460103034973,
-0.4087781012058258,
-0.06731533259153366,
0.20115326344966888,
0.2612232267856598,
-0.3779073655605316,
0.4854273796081543,
-0.056923605501651764,
-0.23469214141368866,
-0.1469128280878067,
-0.21688169240951538,
0.44256529211997986,
-0.31659114360809326,
-0.14310644567012787,
-0.15016619861125946,
0.5180203914642334,
0.1359894573688507,
-0.24033424258232117,
0.5779871344566345,
0.5605552196502686,
-0.6058887243270874,
-0.1579279899597168,
-0.8113906979560852,
-0.20399457216262817,
-0.3420131504535675,
0.462261438369751,
-0.7012873888015747,
-1.0499926805496216,
0.42745441198349,
-0.16773293912410736,
-0.2259225845336914,
0.4624355435371399,
0.34847068786621094,
-0.2393888384103775,
0.37672555446624756,
0.7855244874954224,
-0.25006118416786194,
0.5001042485237122,
-0.06178947538137436,
0.3621463179588318,
-0.5118003487586975,
-0.13859380781650543,
-0.6435818672180176,
-0.18575036525726318,
-0.7756018042564392,
-0.21144242584705353,
0.2332374006509781,
0.08959660679101944,
-0.3460739552974701,
0.7379915118217468,
-0.030338594689965248,
0.2246372252702713,
0.6320890784263611,
-0.024781381711363792,
0.2100331038236618,
-0.0007708823541179299,
0.10013628751039505,
-0.09499403834342957,
-0.5017445683479309,
-0.6377177238464355,
0.6028856039047241,
-0.04621002823114395,
0.47969087958335876,
0.04721338301897049,
1.0631314516067505,
0.2468864470720291,
0.4047119915485382,
-0.7537671327590942,
0.6589075326919556,
-0.10011149197816849,
-0.9730881452560425,
-0.33533623814582825,
-0.38314032554626465,
-0.9409103393554688,
0.2407269924879074,
-0.20303595066070557,
-0.778262197971344,
0.3947628438472748,
-0.05002053081989288,
-0.0076311733573675156,
0.030671967193484306,
-0.395303338766098,
0.9631780385971069,
-0.23202015459537506,
0.007450704462826252,
-0.009916513226926327,
-0.6147269010543823,
-0.19825783371925354,
-0.4781496226787567,
0.4167117476463318,
-0.17716269195079803,
-0.04305882751941681,
0.7752710580825806,
-0.13191820681095123,
0.6452391743659973,
-0.04895205423235893,
0.2972235381603241,
0.1471678912639618,
-0.07474704831838608,
0.4639706313610077,
-0.1212400272488594,
-0.1868559718132019,
0.6258143186569214,
0.10927937179803848,
-0.32937151193618774,
-0.6315719485282898,
0.2700946629047394,
-0.30983975529670715,
-0.4971328377723694,
-0.41388610005378723,
-0.08358212560415268,
-0.18122072517871857,
0.4651968777179718,
0.4825860857963562,
0.4634818732738495,
-0.6979308724403381,
0.3123916983604431,
0.4572541117668152,
0.3149681091308594,
0.32087114453315735,
0.8345833420753479,
-0.0014842059463262558,
-0.6136163473129272,
0.8536863327026367,
0.2596086859703064,
-0.08513082563877106,
0.5308498740196228,
-0.3294529616832733,
0.05261800065636635,
-0.5329263210296631,
-0.5950088500976562,
0.23739421367645264,
-0.6784961819648743,
-0.2548198103904724,
-0.7794516682624817,
-0.3792140483856201,
-0.20958276093006134,
-0.15917353332042694,
-0.23445963859558105,
-0.5123519897460938,
-0.13188350200653076,
-0.3358694016933441,
0.14892849326133728,
0.6454169750213623,
-0.11195787042379379,
0.39731448888778687,
-0.791730523109436,
-0.10429581999778748,
-0.12204612791538239,
-0.030431443825364113,
-0.10914501547813416,
-0.23429802060127258,
-0.4460286498069763,
-0.24024298787117004,
0.1114514097571373,
-1.2360211610794067,
0.2967238128185272,
0.2642793357372284,
0.6715934872627258,
0.6018706560134888,
0.11547009646892548,
0.29624369740486145,
-0.7377469539642334,
0.35182636976242065,
-0.01649007946252823,
-0.844448447227478,
0.10119589418172836,
-0.14027813076972961,
-0.15774253010749817,
0.6594007015228271,
0.4606449007987976,
-0.6464593410491943,
-0.385515034198761,
-0.7507290840148926,
-0.9190570116043091,
0.7164669632911682,
0.04691467806696892,
0.44322890043258667,
-0.48403096199035645,
-0.10241683572530746,
0.28595858812332153,
0.4686412215232849,
-0.6932088732719421,
-0.11254116892814636,
-0.04857093095779419,
-0.03856050968170166,
-0.05473322793841362,
-0.04194933548569679,
-0.03886479511857033,
-0.24165956676006317,
1.0291539430618286,
-0.03502010181546211,
0.13420316576957703,
-0.03561312332749367,
-0.2149592638015747,
0.09144433587789536,
0.7082195281982422,
-0.1811622530221939,
0.31407201290130615,
0.03977901116013527,
0.4818103611469269,
0.4342276453971863,
-0.00029995449585840106,
0.04895574599504471,
0.424883633852005,
-0.3356131315231323,
0.5135027170181274,
0.40742963552474976,
0.9929677844047546,
0.4829312860965729,
-0.4888744354248047,
0.3275143504142761,
0.3823387920856476,
-0.042720992118120193,
-0.5983569622039795,
-0.023305393755435944,
0.38907167315483093,
0.6490572094917297,
0.4135946035385132,
-0.13060809671878815,
0.14951780438423157,
-0.2950235605239868,
0.2177165448665619,
0.5084567070007324,
-0.45757728815078735,
-0.34137436747550964,
0.3104332983493805,
-0.051442574709653854,
-0.39859360456466675,
0.8048384785652161,
-0.5649065375328064,
-0.7545931339263916,
0.5662570595741272,
0.526328980922699,
0.9321534037590027,
0.14247648417949677,
0.13537290692329407,
0.5803017020225525,
0.18754234910011292,
0.20310956239700317,
0.045119255781173706,
-0.2332339733839035,
-0.8795385956764221,
0.22044457495212555,
-0.8938900828361511,
-0.24499699473381042,
0.0842142403125763,
-0.6067103743553162,
0.5150222778320312,
-0.18039824068546295,
-0.5290830135345459,
0.6549074649810791,
-0.26824334263801575,
-0.81411212682724,
0.10077051818370819,
0.10964247584342957,
0.9022699594497681,
-0.6468104720115662,
0.857404351234436,
0.7448034286499023,
-0.35653987526893616,
-0.7205005884170532,
0.1368366926908493,
-0.004497531335800886,
-0.45380324125289917,
0.8912227749824524,
0.011362268589437008,
-0.11382336914539337,
0.26668933033943176,
-0.32810458540916443,
-0.8439756631851196,
0.6842626929283142,
0.253606915473938,
-0.43976834416389465,
-0.1275688260793686,
0.04698174074292183,
0.606555700302124,
-0.31992435455322266,
0.049210935831069946,
0.3321487307548523,
0.679144561290741,
0.062313225120306015,
-0.8007174730300903,
-0.0851510688662529,
-0.4528285264968872,
-0.1402919739484787,
0.5795024037361145,
-0.4893522262573242,
0.5376513600349426,
-0.2272225320339203,
-0.446003258228302,
0.042015206068754196,
0.7758385539054871,
-0.17373114824295044,
0.3795863091945648,
0.5402377843856812,
0.4329237937927246,
0.8639910817146301,
-0.3613015115261078,
0.5734906792640686,
-0.2844015061855316,
0.13306057453155518,
1.2534847259521484,
-0.36467596888542175,
0.9351646900177002,
0.5056477189064026,
-0.1811542809009552,
0.6100934147834778,
0.7832842469215393,
-0.4448932409286499,
0.6809679269790649,
0.2741304934024811,
-0.4486216902732849,
-0.3454638719558716,
-0.20384764671325684,
-0.13872107863426208,
0.5211021900177002,
0.22583329677581787,
-0.23034489154815674,
-0.3594112694263458,
0.021242858842015266,
0.3893016278743744,
-0.3854176998138428,
0.14108049869537354,
1.081950306892395,
0.07930441945791245,
-0.49133428931236267,
0.38890987634658813,
0.03550909459590912,
0.2901875674724579,
-0.5961265563964844,
0.0768563523888588,
-0.07454366981983185,
0.019302787259221077,
-0.08157818019390106,
-0.3473180830478668,
0.25175973773002625,
0.15283028781414032,
-0.42064839601516724,
0.15760710835456848,
0.6072972416877747,
-0.3945621848106384,
-0.6622564792633057,
0.5044867992401123,
0.8189584016799927,
0.5636226534843445,
-0.27279889583587646,
0.05925304442644119,
-0.5245122909545898,
-0.3970945477485657,
-0.28294792771339417,
0.30823108553886414,
0.9128217101097107,
-0.25514814257621765,
0.19413542747497559,
0.43072330951690674,
-0.026157036423683167,
0.24070236086845398,
0.08385654538869858,
0.8576006293296814,
-0.7263357043266296,
-0.17095470428466797,
-0.7574857473373413,
0.2566184103488922,
-0.11367656290531158,
-0.20009446144104004,
0.5734880566596985,
0.8486137986183167,
1.277131199836731,
-0.16919712722301483,
0.9852323532104492,
-0.5872352719306946,
0.5614071488380432,
-0.31165602803230286,
0.6104196906089783,
-0.712931752204895,
-0.16921129822731018,
-0.11975649744272232,
-0.8581835031509399,
-0.051675088703632355,
0.4552714228630066,
-0.22202236950397491,
0.0063265664502978325,
0.710414707660675,
0.9575861692428589,
-0.19156871736049652,
0.09615913033485413,
0.3054578900337219,
0.09174250066280365,
-0.2173755168914795,
0.2969515323638916,
0.7283549308776855,
-0.25450432300567627,
0.3936011493206024,
-0.2933056950569153,
-0.04406621307134628,
-0.19429126381874084,
-0.7004671692848206,
-0.852683961391449,
-0.8271307945251465,
-0.12839041650295258,
-0.28542008996009827,
0.3168388903141022,
1.0374506711959839,
0.8626705408096313,
-1.2438569068908691,
-0.08012231439352036,
0.141211599111557,
0.0603472962975502,
-0.2994164228439331,
-0.20038805902004242,
0.2823489010334015,
-0.3066437542438507,
-0.8920854330062866,
0.4104337990283966,
0.01726546138525009,
-0.11195402592420578,
0.28559473156929016,
0.01820315420627594,
0.04116503894329071,
0.119651198387146,
0.3756506145000458,
0.2893317639827728,
-0.7523913383483887,
-0.32678720355033875,
0.23404759168624878,
-0.3391888737678528,
0.16249841451644897,
0.7234528660774231,
-0.5426136255264282,
0.16162404417991638,
0.3945188522338867,
0.6363957524299622,
0.663408637046814,
-0.19129106402397156,
0.19027133285999298,
-0.6388021111488342,
-0.010658896528184414,
0.22471347451210022,
0.5010497570037842,
0.4608176350593567,
-0.14274339377880096,
0.6361046433448792,
0.40738147497177124,
-0.34221404790878296,
-0.4867810904979706,
0.05707024037837982,
-1.0370346307754517,
-0.07334284484386444,
0.9795597791671753,
-0.16392862796783447,
0.025582613423466682,
-0.49933236837387085,
-0.10246095806360245,
0.5337871313095093,
-0.5255624651908875,
0.6384655833244324,
1.189199686050415,
-0.16025561094284058,
-0.249860480427742,
-0.6798809766769409,
0.2638840079307556,
0.03259122371673584,
-0.7858961820602417,
0.01905415765941143,
0.6323287487030029,
0.524470865726471,
0.14487986266613007,
0.6776838302612305,
0.06435932219028473,
0.05885722115635872,
0.16264675557613373,
0.034142594784498215,
-0.010461396537721157,
-0.3645073473453522,
0.016276579350233078,
0.12336185574531555,
-0.10899264365434647,
0.0427568219602108
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.13037v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.13037v1
|
BiLoRA: A Bi-level Optimization Framework for Overfitting-Resilient Low-Rank Adaptation of Large Pre-trained Models
| 2024-03-19T14:11:20 | 2024-03-19T14:11:20 |
Rushi Qiang, Ruiyi Zhang, Pengtao Xie
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Low-rank adaptation (LoRA) is a popular method for fine-tuning large-scale
pre-trained models in downstream tasks by learning low-rank incremental
matrices. Though LoRA and its variants effectively reduce the number of
trainable parameters compared to full fine-tuning methods, they often overfit
training data, resulting in sub-optimal generalization on test data. To address
this problem, we introduce BiLoRA, an overfitting-alleviating fine-tuning
approach based on bi-level optimization (BLO). BiLoRA employs pseudo singular
value decomposition to parameterize low-rank incremental matrices and splits
the training of pseudo singular vectors and values across two different subsets
of training data. This division, embedded within separate levels of the BLO
framework, mitigates the risk of overfitting to a single dataset. Tested on ten
datasets covering natural language understanding and generation tasks and
applied to various well-known large pre-trained models, BiLoRA significantly
outperforms LoRA methods and other fine-tuning approaches, with similar amounts
of trainable parameters.
|
[
-0.48779603838920593,
-0.8238845467567444,
0.21216638386249542,
0.26895731687545776,
-0.30655941367149353,
0.10754469782114029,
-0.15086694061756134,
-0.42186999320983887,
-0.28508132696151733,
0.2677820324897766,
-0.4400193691253662,
-0.20932483673095703,
-0.4319530129432678,
-0.19375914335250854,
-0.17516425251960754,
1.4331361055374146,
0.16647683084011078,
0.007959139533340931,
0.05975161865353584,
-0.12956158816814423,
-0.770055890083313,
-0.47322186827659607,
-0.6561586260795593,
-0.19832633435726166,
1.1385257244110107,
0.5723052620887756,
0.47737520933151245,
0.13404668867588043,
0.2995380759239197,
0.15459133684635162,
-0.08668810874223709,
0.38144198060035706,
-1.2861480712890625,
-0.014984827488660812,
-0.6612541675567627,
-0.5881664156913757,
-0.5315548181533813,
-0.09334226697683334,
0.7648001313209534,
0.897185742855072,
-0.026562845334410667,
0.6330926418304443,
0.04452436789870262,
0.9792723059654236,
-1.234465479850769,
0.05646985024213791,
-1.0258785486221313,
-0.22215861082077026,
-0.14728163182735443,
-0.3756124973297119,
-0.29025140404701233,
-0.4519294202327728,
0.08527146279811859,
-0.5846449732780457,
0.01253770012408495,
0.2774035334587097,
0.9720640182495117,
0.5562273263931274,
-0.2550228238105774,
0.058907702565193176,
-1.0586177110671997,
0.6150919795036316,
-0.6997693181037903,
0.2909744679927826,
0.3345470428466797,
0.49900588393211365,
-0.18286018073558807,
-0.2971597909927368,
-0.5301451086997986,
0.23636741936206818,
0.21266967058181763,
0.27875131368637085,
-0.27267783880233765,
-0.0043081860058009624,
0.1075240969657898,
0.3670886158943176,
-0.7732971906661987,
0.3754804730415344,
-0.7376911044120789,
0.24928037822246552,
0.3994138240814209,
-0.25851762294769287,
-0.004676301497966051,
0.2895377278327942,
-0.34227415919303894,
-0.14396949112415314,
-0.8185185194015503,
0.15394634008407593,
0.28473666310310364,
0.7450861930847168,
0.08281005918979645,
0.3666554093360901,
0.010203901678323746,
0.8160611391067505,
0.21706457436084747,
0.12990093231201172,
0.19861653447151184,
-0.3253108263015747,
-0.6904162168502808,
0.4106222987174988,
0.05721580237150192,
0.04773496091365814,
0.3475818932056427,
-0.2325475662946701,
-0.04630790650844574,
0.25398874282836914,
0.4096841812133789,
-0.9133813381195068,
-0.20480228960514069,
0.11446131020784378,
-0.317123144865036,
-0.18889246881008148,
-0.20086559653282166,
-0.9781391024589539,
-0.3102489113807678,
-0.4045812487602234,
0.7262287139892578,
-0.06406629085540771,
-0.028370723128318787,
0.33736279606819153,
0.25856587290763855,
0.2140973061323166,
0.3176844120025635,
-0.7359068989753723,
0.16777750849723816,
0.5407522916793823,
0.7846726179122925,
-0.022190434858202934,
-0.4877769351005554,
-1.1592909097671509,
0.33571380376815796,
-0.6654039025306702,
0.8195508718490601,
-0.23454488813877106,
-0.23816095292568207,
-0.13644517958164215,
-0.05702171102166176,
-0.44755521416664124,
-0.41103246808052063,
0.23698587715625763,
-0.6822080612182617,
0.2078409492969513,
-0.18092240393161774,
-0.14513902366161346,
-0.28149667382240295,
0.3141743838787079,
-0.43985673785209656,
0.9499319791793823,
0.5545998811721802,
-0.6447831988334656,
0.5658637881278992,
-0.9435306787490845,
-0.36719492077827454,
-0.21845775842666626,
0.44278430938720703,
-0.7376794219017029,
0.32240599393844604,
-0.1691257804632187,
0.02737640030682087,
-0.6153020262718201,
-0.2484206259250641,
-0.4624950587749481,
-0.24192695319652557,
-0.15461361408233643,
-0.10324274003505707,
0.49487701058387756,
0.1432342827320099,
-0.2106674313545227,
0.42787835001945496,
-0.9163054823875427,
0.17817412316799164,
0.009026190266013145,
-0.44698718190193176,
-0.45734578371047974,
-0.1540258675813675,
-0.05218978226184845,
0.3120507597923279,
0.264644056558609,
-0.6055085062980652,
0.2213602066040039,
-0.7464973330497742,
0.2995133399963379,
0.7688931226730347,
0.18850122392177582,
0.41822350025177,
-0.3032870590686798,
0.3550315797328949,
0.1266821175813675,
0.4927000105381012,
0.3879687488079071,
-0.3367239236831665,
-0.9271649718284607,
-0.38042017817497253,
0.43163400888442993,
0.6928050518035889,
-0.6132867336273193,
0.5689236521720886,
-0.3328016996383667,
-0.8292496204376221,
-0.5675491690635681,
0.5913571715354919,
0.5800624489784241,
0.632524311542511,
0.7908340096473694,
-0.16850979626178741,
-0.42199429869651794,
-0.8274173140525818,
0.032811783254146576,
-0.07916594296693802,
0.1425672173500061,
-0.3714374601840973,
0.474543958902359,
-0.5205191373825073,
0.9266474843025208,
-0.43268823623657227,
-0.5049150586128235,
-0.30392223596572876,
0.14583955705165863,
0.2258840948343277,
0.5984216332435608,
0.9859308004379272,
-0.6120703220367432,
-0.5141050815582275,
0.3007011413574219,
-0.24286265671253204,
-0.1022229790687561,
-0.13139444589614868,
-0.6348557472229004,
0.19049714505672455,
0.25408700108528137,
-0.2065679430961609,
0.7002677321434021,
0.7091538310050964,
-0.3148367702960968,
0.13553398847579956,
-0.5725610256195068,
-0.28946033120155334,
-0.9854035377502441,
0.3316374123096466,
-0.21411827206611633,
-0.23845481872558594,
-0.6448920369148254,
-0.1747220754623413,
-0.06283336877822876,
-0.25840526819229126,
-0.027927452698349953,
0.3254576325416565,
-0.4261581301689148,
-0.439797043800354,
-0.37899553775787354,
0.013043126091361046,
0.1824917048215866,
0.7808680534362793,
-0.38457363843917847,
0.594999372959137,
0.4555685222148895,
-0.4523257315158844,
0.03471144288778305,
0.3835625648498535,
-0.3320471942424774,
0.6539779305458069,
-0.7151731848716736,
0.3036372661590576,
-0.28794237971305847,
0.03214573860168457,
-0.9501198530197144,
0.2459934651851654,
0.19108150899410248,
-0.0481095165014267,
0.2555825710296631,
-0.4663926362991333,
-0.49364709854125977,
-0.1385098248720169,
-0.3452267646789551,
0.505273699760437,
0.3333614468574524,
-0.5559906363487244,
0.4746056795120239,
0.13718712329864502,
-0.30749621987342834,
-0.2192586064338684,
-0.5050274133682251,
-0.24686864018440247,
-0.22121334075927734,
-0.2516821324825287,
0.07875757664442062,
-0.46049419045448303,
0.13524632155895233,
-0.3750157356262207,
0.04308904707431793,
-0.09726253896951675,
0.30283334851264954,
0.17804183065891266,
0.33905383944511414,
-0.3279739320278168,
-0.20525339245796204,
0.3276546001434326,
-0.24172039330005646,
-0.3762240409851074,
-0.2091445028781891,
0.647987425327301,
-0.1616404503583908,
-0.4230460226535797,
-0.20832695066928864,
0.4070909321308136,
0.7320494651794434,
-0.44354790449142456,
0.9556354880332947,
0.5484646558761597,
-0.38375356793403625,
-0.44039326906204224,
-0.22871552407741547,
0.19487658143043518,
-0.43247801065444946,
0.40005409717559814,
-0.3091629445552826,
-0.19498689472675323,
0.4576784074306488,
-0.10900072008371353,
0.44416704773902893,
0.048971857875585556,
0.629302442073822,
0.016506971791386604,
0.9893611669540405,
0.7390548586845398,
-0.42743074893951416,
0.6507598161697388,
-0.48976829648017883,
0.49966341257095337,
-0.5803706049919128,
-0.011087317951023579,
-0.6340181231498718,
-0.6161566972732544,
-0.34376510977745056,
-0.4475085735321045,
0.43986818194389343,
0.2726035416126251,
-0.5859305262565613,
0.1555803418159485,
-0.5044721961021423,
0.29302212595939636,
0.5803283452987671,
-0.003986509516835213,
0.262478232383728,
-0.05007059499621391,
0.6246231198310852,
0.3567614257335663,
-0.8071231842041016,
-0.008657977916300297,
0.8577044606208801,
0.2849489450454712,
0.6296094059944153,
0.3404516875743866,
0.3859795033931732,
0.3569526970386505,
0.35909679532051086,
-0.6911044716835022,
-0.0025029515381902456,
-0.20698119699954987,
-0.6590532064437866,
-0.6090997457504272,
-0.49045640230178833,
-1.182889699935913,
0.22830237448215485,
-0.38015657663345337,
-0.6668937802314758,
0.8523196578025818,
0.3487224280834198,
-0.611050009727478,
0.22168277204036713,
-0.8461987376213074,
1.0201528072357178,
-0.33420199155807495,
-0.3652828335762024,
-0.2809177339076996,
-0.6802419424057007,
0.03503389656543732,
-0.4397471845149994,
0.2590683400630951,
0.07004795223474503,
0.20793123543262482,
0.4559565782546997,
-0.341418594121933,
0.7843178510665894,
-0.4248557984828949,
-0.2666358947753906,
-0.03595690429210663,
-0.0017585295718163252,
0.5002133250236511,
-0.0656881332397461,
-0.23875883221626282,
-0.01472383737564087,
0.4488754868507385,
-0.9679130911827087,
-0.7890011072158813,
0.49901100993156433,
-1.0218933820724487,
-0.11664421856403351,
-0.33521828055381775,
-0.532553493976593,
-0.62131667137146,
0.25348737835884094,
0.36331483721733093,
0.4969581067562103,
0.049509625881910324,
0.34381046891212463,
0.48432040214538574,
-0.21142706274986267,
0.1235860288143158,
0.3879029154777527,
-0.1509401798248291,
-0.4359111785888672,
1.2753149271011353,
0.21587474644184113,
0.4665534496307373,
0.23290355503559113,
0.23020707070827484,
0.014130632393062115,
-0.9628102779388428,
-0.47066041827201843,
0.13948872685432434,
-0.5093379616737366,
-0.4249722361564636,
0.11752920597791672,
-0.27566832304000854,
-0.29096975922584534,
-0.3592408001422882,
-0.545798122882843,
-0.10206618160009384,
-0.20517955720424652,
-0.05518274009227753,
0.15018664300441742,
0.6129233837127686,
-0.014526799321174622,
0.4361971318721771,
-0.5816831588745117,
0.47367310523986816,
0.33742669224739075,
0.182182177901268,
-0.0807284414768219,
-0.7240477800369263,
-0.5101031064987183,
0.1659647822380066,
-0.014611841179430485,
-0.481527715921402,
0.38704320788383484,
0.5985895395278931,
0.49627211689949036,
0.36367112398147583,
0.20174472033977509,
1.016886591911316,
-0.26174402236938477,
0.23830071091651917,
0.24346061050891876,
-0.7538851499557495,
0.4900077283382416,
-0.3067028224468231,
0.26348328590393066,
1.0570852756500244,
0.22309057414531708,
-0.01664985530078411,
0.14587950706481934,
-0.1566154658794403,
-0.8683919906616211,
0.47290852665901184,
0.2550298571586609,
-0.005781717598438263,
0.5774472951889038,
0.4183014929294586,
0.2636973559856415,
0.2759392261505127,
-0.6525877118110657,
-0.11407093703746796,
-0.6666814684867859,
-0.18919284641742706,
-0.356191486120224,
-0.33750995993614197,
-0.31000640988349915,
-0.3827076554298401,
0.7392451167106628,
-0.399567186832428,
-0.11686672270298004,
0.06410649418830872,
-0.4745844304561615,
-0.2642030119895935,
0.11218447983264923,
0.6490515470504761,
0.8945431113243103,
-0.48655009269714355,
-0.10601244121789932,
0.3425668179988861,
-0.36438027024269104,
-0.10971546173095703,
0.21957355737686157,
-0.20087416470050812,
-0.37558338046073914,
0.36286628246307373,
0.9799321889877319,
0.4851754605770111,
-0.4441635012626648,
0.19065892696380615,
0.19661468267440796,
-0.030198650434613228,
-0.032141972333192825,
0.1373981535434723,
-0.31393948197364807,
0.25105348229408264,
0.4645124077796936,
0.034203410148620605,
-0.05403193086385727,
-0.9538975954055786,
-0.2060370147228241,
0.08339423686265945,
-0.23795750737190247,
-0.5485369563102722,
0.3142146170139313,
0.10839644074440002,
-0.21448971331119537,
0.11947822570800781,
-0.1686163693666458,
-0.3886292576789856,
0.2340984046459198,
0.5061860084533691,
0.485438734292984,
-0.182095468044281,
0.08029475063085556,
0.22095420956611633,
0.18628008663654327,
0.1524456888437271,
0.33830055594444275,
0.11507051438093185,
-0.5664293766021729,
-0.23007303476333618,
-0.8449280858039856,
-0.2456245720386505,
0.06488027423620224,
-0.7427245378494263,
0.13504698872566223,
-0.9489012360572815,
-0.07868906110525131,
0.042753592133522034,
0.20661547780036926,
-0.5061389803886414,
0.140218123793602,
0.1727830171585083,
0.8290960192680359,
-0.7483869791030884,
0.8786411285400391,
0.5865676403045654,
-0.6495264768600464,
-0.5395047664642334,
-0.16676655411720276,
-0.4847325086593628,
-0.5798601508140564,
0.5490772128105164,
-0.25991204380989075,
-0.2661544382572174,
0.3244868814945221,
-0.3346118927001953,
-0.9206184148788452,
0.9694563746452332,
0.8971737027168274,
-0.43684160709381104,
-0.47085505723953247,
0.2014065980911255,
0.7482888102531433,
-0.23907555639743805,
-0.21216577291488647,
0.6435810327529907,
0.7336850166320801,
0.043292660266160965,
-1.0121315717697144,
-0.30618369579315186,
-0.18892432749271393,
0.0522579662501812,
0.006145480088889599,
-0.7094318866729736,
0.7419970631599426,
0.017657771706581116,
0.055947478860616684,
0.0440736785531044,
0.5532892346382141,
0.31808170676231384,
0.5582387447357178,
0.8593692779541016,
0.2879471480846405,
0.8257730007171631,
0.30451926589012146,
0.7206596732139587,
-0.1722937822341919,
0.3955233097076416,
1.3387961387634277,
-0.4912177324295044,
0.8076225519180298,
0.4217418432235718,
-0.0008898437372408807,
0.8166351318359375,
0.7679132223129272,
0.07785151153802872,
0.7385987043380737,
0.30338144302368164,
0.1848359853029251,
-0.32369887828826904,
0.13807880878448486,
-0.46075868606567383,
0.5110909938812256,
0.27697670459747314,
0.05941101536154747,
-0.44102028012275696,
0.17868880927562714,
-0.11318548768758774,
-0.03570147603750229,
-0.6363272070884705,
0.7428383231163025,
-0.08074785768985748,
-0.5682565569877625,
1.08345365524292,
-0.37081336975097656,
0.3211909234523773,
-0.728352963924408,
0.13170666992664337,
-0.27347928285598755,
0.4687120020389557,
-0.2820723056793213,
-0.12527988851070404,
0.14443542063236237,
-0.08201830089092255,
-0.4569471776485443,
0.0466812402009964,
0.5584987998008728,
-0.34686940908432007,
-0.7108979225158691,
0.6253968477249146,
0.4518008530139923,
-0.12199747562408447,
-0.27070677280426025,
-0.6762382388114929,
-0.03737853467464447,
-0.25778964161872864,
-0.3777540326118469,
0.6420803070068359,
0.42345136404037476,
-0.19680963456630707,
0.7722482681274414,
0.9951480627059937,
0.3583778142929077,
0.22594064474105835,
0.2573573887348175,
1.1960593461990356,
-0.25355955958366394,
-0.5753564834594727,
-0.3255522549152374,
0.3446609079837799,
-0.05786774680018425,
-0.3582088053226471,
0.47809910774230957,
0.7634890675544739,
0.6656240820884705,
0.11343421041965485,
0.6252951622009277,
0.23507297039031982,
0.658817708492279,
-0.5305748581886292,
0.7853943705558777,
-0.7144173979759216,
-0.001958512468263507,
-0.38887742161750793,
-1.1592379808425903,
-0.13362152874469757,
0.6057256460189819,
-0.46057718992233276,
0.01723606325685978,
0.28512242436408997,
0.7249196171760559,
-0.3684176504611969,
-0.44662439823150635,
0.6127018928527832,
0.3678228557109833,
0.275555819272995,
0.7105215191841125,
0.5171753764152527,
-0.31289565563201904,
0.6248009204864502,
0.06370548158884048,
-0.30315732955932617,
-0.44701460003852844,
-0.6435468792915344,
-1.053178071975708,
-0.5172619819641113,
-0.058203961700201035,
-0.03554445877671242,
0.288124144077301,
0.6871333718299866,
1.0842297077178955,
-1.0675147771835327,
-0.013013573363423347,
0.08092308044433594,
-0.02905040606856346,
-0.1476079225540161,
-0.1447829008102417,
0.4087446630001068,
-0.3905969262123108,
-0.6921206116676331,
0.6258878111839294,
0.29502564668655396,
-0.0313236229121685,
-0.5028190612792969,
-0.04546646773815155,
-0.5875738859176636,
0.2969425320625305,
0.7202569246292114,
0.6633408665657043,
0.023505045101046562,
-0.5176820158958435,
-0.3444209098815918,
0.0919567346572876,
0.06817116588354111,
0.7086100578308105,
-0.5992762446403503,
0.30505186319351196,
0.6345835328102112,
0.7338241934776306,
0.6357218027114868,
0.31158414483070374,
0.6918470859527588,
-0.5164031386375427,
0.42027395963668823,
0.05341799929738045,
0.3376255929470062,
0.20059174299240112,
-0.33061346411705017,
0.688495934009552,
0.029894061386585236,
-0.5066719055175781,
-1.3727152347564697,
0.15223395824432373,
-1.2970341444015503,
-0.4606201648712158,
0.9300035238265991,
-0.22483788430690765,
-0.292287141084671,
-0.4958043098449707,
-0.3252526521682739,
0.3902497887611389,
-0.21060214936733246,
1.0157301425933838,
0.16038799285888672,
0.013540669344365597,
0.0603339821100235,
-0.534631609916687,
0.47125333547592163,
0.5818476676940918,
-1.209633231163025,
0.28695839643478394,
0.2862134873867035,
0.21255572140216827,
0.3340734839439392,
0.0738050788640976,
0.24884261190891266,
0.30908599495887756,
-0.48784545063972473,
-0.12982437014579773,
-0.18256166577339172,
-0.5180084109306335,
-0.10587967932224274,
0.1371922641992569,
0.3340327739715576,
-0.2125047743320465
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.12744v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.12744v1
|
Instructing Large Language Models to Identify and Ignore Irrelevant Conditions
| 2024-03-19T14:07:28 | 2024-03-19T14:07:28 |
Zhenyu Wu, Chao Shen, Meng Jiang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Math word problem (MWP) solving requires generating a reasoning path based on
a given problem description that often contains irrelevant conditions. Existing
chain-of-thought (CoT) prompting methods elicited multi-step reasoning
abilities of large language models (LLMs) to solve MWPs. However, they were
seriously confused by the irrelevant conditions, resulting in low accuracy. In
this paper, we propose a novel approach named I$^3$C that instructs LLMs to
identify and ignore irrelevant conditions. It identifies a set of irrelevant
condition candidates that have a weak semantic relevance with the question.
Then it prompts LLMs to verify the irrelevant conditions. Lastly it instructs
the LLMs with the verification on relevant and irrelevant conditions to avoid
confusion and improve reasoning paths. Moreover, we propose to select (problem,
reasoning paths) pairs as demonstrations to enhance I$^3$C with few-shot
reasoning. We develop I$^3$C-Select that selects the most confusing problems
based on the semantic relevance measurement. We conduct extensive experiments
on eight MWP datasets. I$^3$C can be combined with any CoT prompting methods to
improve the performance of solving MWPs. Notably, with GPT-3.5-Turbo and
I$^3$C-Select, we achieve an accuracy of 96.0 and 94.1 on GSM-IC2-1K and
GSM-ICM-1K, respectively, significantly outperforming the state-of-the-art
few-shot prompting method Complex-CoT by +11.7 and +11.1. Our implementation is
made publicly available at https://wzy6642.github.io/I3C.github.io/.
|
[
-0.5468840003013611,
-0.9937899708747864,
0.9533684253692627,
0.38647907972335815,
-0.1999291628599167,
0.04892395809292793,
-0.15269286930561066,
-0.3687821626663208,
-0.22503577172756195,
0.38313671946525574,
-0.7649069428443909,
-0.5670356750488281,
-0.6946603655815125,
0.04480765759944916,
-0.14289113879203796,
0.5147274136543274,
-0.23411397635936737,
0.08984467387199402,
0.04921881854534149,
-0.11615223437547684,
-0.6501666903495789,
-0.29049116373062134,
-0.5438894033432007,
-0.37394365668296814,
0.39271941781044006,
0.7925864458084106,
0.6719813346862793,
0.24443654716014862,
0.4870411455631256,
0.23082709312438965,
-0.23469409346580505,
0.3611082434654236,
-0.3353253901004791,
-0.13588012754917145,
-0.18376855552196503,
-0.2772052586078644,
-0.16846755146980286,
-0.013644522987306118,
0.44628044962882996,
0.6524685621261597,
0.11733882874250412,
0.08752276003360748,
0.1088891550898552,
0.7972762584686279,
-0.8774858713150024,
0.23727171123027802,
-1.1257109642028809,
-0.05597104877233505,
-0.28045976161956787,
-0.4667513370513916,
-0.5582689642906189,
-0.21388350427150726,
-0.15139347314834595,
-0.5298852920532227,
0.056673966348171234,
0.10595552623271942,
0.6325384378433228,
0.061624012887477875,
-0.3112827241420746,
-0.3268752992153168,
-0.715064525604248,
0.5727491974830627,
-0.7081501483917236,
0.08687516301870346,
0.7320691347122192,
0.2955567240715027,
-0.462313175201416,
-0.16710181534290314,
-0.7920480966567993,
-0.05485433712601662,
0.056296445429325104,
0.19867926836013794,
-0.31040388345718384,
0.17422550916671753,
0.5648081302642822,
-0.06545223295688629,
-0.3381398320198059,
0.15932324528694153,
-0.5846429467201233,
-0.14903703331947327,
0.341256320476532,
0.22439558804035187,
0.15572647750377655,
-0.03588635474443436,
-0.10661793500185013,
0.2707819938659668,
-1.163205862045288,
-0.006059611216187477,
0.40846502780914307,
0.285757839679718,
-0.09526173770427704,
0.736393392086029,
-0.25211095809936523,
1.11331045627594,
0.01765623688697815,
-0.23345549404621124,
-0.12420834600925446,
0.06302367895841599,
-0.048532117158174515,
-0.13887622952461243,
0.49848395586013794,
0.0034045539796352386,
0.25323382019996643,
0.09984328597784042,
-0.029501479119062424,
-0.08824196457862854,
0.04420555755496025,
-0.6314647793769836,
0.03637276962399483,
0.3283865451812744,
-0.15440790355205536,
0.05682371184229851,
-0.19554632902145386,
-0.30093756318092346,
-0.10001173615455627,
-0.3199613094329834,
0.688068151473999,
-0.6100803017616272,
-0.0984247699379921,
0.15897542238235474,
0.19213660061359406,
0.2244795709848404,
0.4370839595794678,
-1.0246282815933228,
0.25247347354888916,
0.8283616900444031,
0.7716546654701233,
0.013528834097087383,
-0.33646491169929504,
-0.7411095499992371,
0.173848956823349,
-0.4331100285053253,
0.6661601662635803,
-0.46731868386268616,
-0.31757262349128723,
-0.1000334769487381,
-0.35040897130966187,
-0.04146376624703407,
-0.556281566619873,
0.4388677775859833,
-0.5420110821723938,
0.14765654504299164,
-0.1258368343114853,
-0.5831100940704346,
-0.2422589212656021,
0.4977002739906311,
-0.36042875051498413,
0.8667571544647217,
0.1870887577533722,
-0.7738531231880188,
0.006877202074974775,
-0.5121955871582031,
-0.17436100542545319,
0.019628778100013733,
-0.1987663358449936,
-0.2714206874370575,
-0.11054927855730057,
0.5067070722579956,
0.579613208770752,
-0.3724510371685028,
0.2068786770105362,
-0.5033760070800781,
-0.5785908102989197,
-0.05696183070540428,
-0.5028276443481445,
0.6374679803848267,
0.16767777502536774,
-0.44000187516212463,
-0.038316819816827774,
-0.7506229281425476,
0.36493119597435,
0.0021866438910365105,
-0.22927044332027435,
-0.11902576684951782,
-0.055069755762815475,
-0.46664318442344666,
0.36228787899017334,
-0.1728203147649765,
-0.3607077896595001,
0.20848441123962402,
-0.4939507842063904,
0.2667059004306793,
0.7841384410858154,
0.07083263248205185,
0.31398507952690125,
-0.20076791942119598,
0.6288409233093262,
0.11155039072036743,
0.13057170808315277,
0.0062046595849096775,
-0.7692994475364685,
-0.8429709672927856,
-0.19041801989078522,
-0.007438634522259235,
0.7028409838676453,
-1.1829763650894165,
0.27476319670677185,
-0.10464069992303848,
-0.2779500186443329,
-0.31388261914253235,
0.09945234656333923,
0.45513373613357544,
0.6608151793479919,
0.6325803399085999,
0.5167596936225891,
-0.17865999042987823,
-0.7521600723266602,
-0.5133043527603149,
-0.270502507686615,
0.06540414690971375,
0.12779615819454193,
0.284203439950943,
-0.014586154371500015,
0.8129180073738098,
-0.6213039755821228,
-0.2064458578824997,
-0.17577677965164185,
0.17218537628650665,
0.466339647769928,
0.4835606515407562,
0.2438378483057022,
-0.5194482803344727,
-0.3993600010871887,
-0.27084070444107056,
-0.33402714133262634,
-0.2242256999015808,
-0.044952429831027985,
-0.2026427835226059,
0.1514492928981781,
0.687598466873169,
-0.5574504733085632,
0.5786836743354797,
0.4759041666984558,
-0.34904301166534424,
0.4374210238456726,
-0.02164885401725769,
0.13107573986053467,
-0.7426003217697144,
-0.03975299000740051,
0.07765652984380722,
-0.279445618391037,
-0.3100184500217438,
0.06796380132436752,
0.26066699624061584,
-0.23862643539905548,
-0.6847441792488098,
0.6470128893852234,
-0.4644550085067749,
0.08340490609407425,
-0.22951799631118774,
0.4316677749156952,
-0.06223636865615845,
0.5763113498687744,
-0.17720964550971985,
0.6904132962226868,
0.4470179080963135,
-0.7994317412376404,
-0.06133030727505684,
0.09876943379640579,
-0.2742115259170532,
0.49124494194984436,
-0.16074319183826447,
0.0651741698384285,
-0.09985140711069107,
0.2606644630432129,
-0.8443390130996704,
0.04945991933345795,
0.4293183386325836,
-0.37571197748184204,
0.13492633402347565,
-0.34965604543685913,
-0.6572762727737427,
-0.6821821331977844,
-0.04124590754508972,
0.5041191577911377,
0.3820602595806122,
-0.7636348009109497,
0.5048091411590576,
-0.002907915273681283,
-0.0799088105559349,
-0.6227713823318481,
-0.31943464279174805,
-0.01745433919131756,
-0.09419524669647217,
-0.4283706843852997,
0.22519977390766144,
-0.20117424428462982,
-0.32801035046577454,
-0.15626631677150726,
-0.29390060901641846,
-0.19370713829994202,
0.18198159337043762,
0.0828780084848404,
0.5233790874481201,
0.06546308845281601,
0.1985497921705246,
0.03096511773765087,
-0.4137692451477051,
0.05896677449345589,
-0.2057531177997589,
0.4420429766178131,
-0.16583606600761414,
-0.6243578195571899,
-0.34255287051200867,
0.47596490383148193,
0.32449641823768616,
-0.03732642903923988,
0.3127882182598114,
0.6543431878089905,
-0.511184573173523,
-0.14030487835407257,
-0.703342854976654,
-0.133690744638443,
-0.5038772821426392,
0.1557941436767578,
-0.7051734328269958,
-0.9409022927284241,
0.3772640526294708,
-0.10497548431158066,
0.045682039111852646,
0.3807995021343231,
0.5301305651664734,
0.0737418532371521,
1.3628212213516235,
0.36393022537231445,
0.09152205288410187,
0.3116457760334015,
-0.3344290554523468,
0.5168788433074951,
-1.0184762477874756,
-0.19728395342826843,
-0.4880729019641876,
0.024689121171832085,
-0.3887820243835449,
-0.5097074508666992,
0.7588871121406555,
0.4415232539176941,
-0.12426311522722244,
0.18321043252944946,
-0.4747384190559387,
0.7889522910118103,
0.13496224582195282,
0.28028473258018494,
0.2184406816959381,
-0.2600559592247009,
-0.3143124282360077,
-0.04444785788655281,
-0.7296938896179199,
-0.3456343412399292,
0.8100332021713257,
0.11355355381965637,
0.61644047498703,
0.33946284651756287,
0.6652878522872925,
-0.10787747800350189,
0.4759368598461151,
-1.1579453945159912,
0.595950186252594,
0.09304740279912949,
-0.576222836971283,
-0.020737353712320328,
-0.5722689628601074,
-0.9855728149414062,
0.5249075293540955,
-0.3189811408519745,
-1.028559684753418,
-0.11943820118904114,
0.3946754038333893,
-0.4791666269302368,
0.43977224826812744,
-0.7969771027565002,
0.36991986632347107,
0.019457882270216942,
-0.45030102133750916,
-0.4084184169769287,
-0.49949660897254944,
0.6677360534667969,
0.08159836381673813,
0.38485977053642273,
-0.5227351784706116,
0.011191041208803654,
0.3821215033531189,
-0.6021678447723389,
0.4747650921344757,
-0.116575688123703,
-0.21752682328224182,
0.5371202826499939,
0.4939631223678589,
0.8055068254470825,
0.07183005660772324,
-0.33785974979400635,
-0.013251771219074726,
-0.09912990778684616,
-0.4125199019908905,
-0.6090388894081116,
0.9496672749519348,
-0.37192580103874207,
-1.0068893432617188,
-0.34442138671875,
-0.5371081829071045,
-0.8078952431678772,
0.28193968534469604,
0.22841398417949677,
0.5193082690238953,
0.2803034782409668,
-0.03319436311721802,
0.4200972318649292,
0.030461063608527184,
0.6812286376953125,
0.5824373960494995,
-0.0819593146443367,
-0.2915900945663452,
0.7675846815109253,
0.15687480568885803,
0.6101833581924438,
0.3423692286014557,
0.4105450510978699,
-0.15162938833236694,
-0.5518949627876282,
-0.5044335126876831,
0.059217944741249084,
-1.0622597932815552,
-0.5183566212654114,
-0.7947490811347961,
-0.19707058370113373,
-0.09473593533039093,
-0.32559022307395935,
-0.08457143604755402,
-0.38152042031288147,
-0.5039100050926208,
0.15376868844032288,
0.35793572664260864,
0.533491849899292,
0.030612844973802567,
0.2888367772102356,
-0.8814741373062134,
0.6541552543640137,
0.2851119339466095,
0.40136662125587463,
0.15166328847408295,
-0.4423760771751404,
-0.0032535106875002384,
-0.02909356914460659,
-0.45952552556991577,
-0.6660021543502808,
0.13340137898921967,
-0.09049741178750992,
0.4412902593612671,
0.23291637003421783,
-0.10199058800935745,
1.060463786125183,
-0.4781959354877472,
0.5769789814949036,
0.31885001063346863,
-1.386830449104309,
0.5842002630233765,
-0.41962099075317383,
0.6473990678787231,
0.6131001710891724,
0.3649122416973114,
-0.1963471919298172,
-0.590446412563324,
-0.8356420397758484,
-0.8693863153457642,
0.8318812847137451,
0.4080218970775604,
-0.13531826436519623,
-0.1619800478219986,
0.513710081577301,
-0.11143958568572998,
-0.18108271062374115,
-0.8094706535339355,
-0.12434303760528564,
0.233048677444458,
-0.17150622606277466,
0.3704599440097809,
-0.19555911421775818,
0.029901575297117233,
-0.44199928641319275,
0.8976784348487854,
-0.3976212441921234,
0.10884149372577667,
0.23807324469089508,
-0.01533112395554781,
-0.13430622220039368,
0.2894422113895416,
0.5995197892189026,
1.075821042060852,
-0.07071780413389206,
0.2202313244342804,
0.3630926311016083,
-0.322848916053772,
0.21072204411029816,
-0.17816537618637085,
0.013185602612793446,
-0.08767755329608917,
0.39784446358680725,
0.4539584815502167,
0.14662723243236542,
-0.5072954297065735,
0.7110258936882019,
0.11987097561359406,
-0.1900356411933899,
-0.17982685565948486,
0.22615964710712433,
0.07315996289253235,
0.012916196137666702,
0.3375241160392761,
0.3132103383541107,
0.13954603672027588,
-0.4520963430404663,
-0.09307397902011871,
0.5546941161155701,
-0.5105341672897339,
0.002251280704513192,
0.42981234192848206,
0.13679556548595428,
-0.2534874975681305,
0.5625492334365845,
-0.3522462248802185,
-0.5733793377876282,
0.6317678689956665,
0.8177472352981567,
0.6848753094673157,
0.24516476690769196,
0.058266621083021164,
0.6125789284706116,
0.392557829618454,
-0.15678001940250397,
0.535169243812561,
-0.1403774917125702,
-0.6623753309249878,
-0.506660521030426,
-0.07355394959449768,
-0.5002702474594116,
0.20117609202861786,
-0.5387234687805176,
0.7046706676483154,
-0.6884094476699829,
0.11322060227394104,
0.1408463567495346,
-0.14067956805229187,
-0.7583934664726257,
0.14850161969661713,
0.13788732886314392,
0.9344406127929688,
-0.5190629959106445,
0.7902538776397705,
0.05309445783495903,
0.007878009229898453,
-1.202583909034729,
0.32023829221725464,
0.185503289103508,
-1.032368540763855,
0.40011361241340637,
0.17767518758773804,
-0.6016808152198792,
0.1544533222913742,
-0.8084848523139954,
-0.8538804650306702,
0.8350244164466858,
0.2940656542778015,
-0.6487944722175598,
0.5114206075668335,
-0.3825836181640625,
0.20945623517036438,
-0.20866122841835022,
0.2870520055294037,
0.4789348244667053,
0.5805555582046509,
0.39557039737701416,
-0.6303655505180359,
0.2044459879398346,
-0.10716550797224045,
-0.06237960234284401,
0.47114431858062744,
-0.6163471937179565,
0.5952967405319214,
-0.5975878238677979,
-0.17194104194641113,
0.15121722221374512,
0.23719438910484314,
0.694774866104126,
0.18031559884548187,
0.5989300012588501,
0.3230303227901459,
0.5068828463554382,
-0.13170011341571808,
0.9249141812324524,
-0.02349555306136608,
0.3329615592956543,
1.0891520977020264,
-0.30140921473503113,
0.8612526655197144,
0.6023788452148438,
-0.15900617837905884,
0.2615000009536743,
0.5729392766952515,
0.23283341526985168,
0.40912434458732605,
0.4964803457260132,
-0.47676515579223633,
-0.43693190813064575,
0.30439209938049316,
-0.3582512438297272,
0.5447182655334473,
0.6371609568595886,
0.1798827350139618,
-0.411803662776947,
-0.12049107998609543,
0.418583482503891,
0.00367800728417933,
-0.35049372911453247,
0.6570213437080383,
0.08325354754924774,
-0.9317444562911987,
0.9049749374389648,
0.13218867778778076,
0.5515744686126709,
-0.7740334868431091,
-0.34765714406967163,
0.03732159733772278,
0.04604393243789673,
-0.2841656804084778,
-0.7891242504119873,
0.28185203671455383,
-0.13541433215141296,
-0.1435350477695465,
-0.0773761048913002,
0.5354455709457397,
-0.35193049907684326,
-0.6411202549934387,
0.1707371175289154,
0.37244489789009094,
-0.03612957522273064,
-0.06784048676490784,
-0.64299476146698,
0.0707458108663559,
-0.03373965993523598,
0.11111890524625778,
0.0037433288525789976,
0.5768616199493408,
-0.28112179040908813,
0.891915500164032,
0.79327791929245,
0.17077043652534485,
-0.318627268075943,
0.19306743144989014,
0.9343816637992859,
-0.7918201088905334,
-0.427152544260025,
-1.0671497583389282,
0.32847854495048523,
0.06483520567417145,
-0.46627694368362427,
0.5719519853591919,
0.39453089237213135,
0.541435956954956,
0.09205272048711777,
0.5277150869369507,
0.010414361953735352,
0.4050305485725403,
-0.9206487536430359,
0.25481802225112915,
-0.34095704555511475,
0.6491920948028564,
-0.39712297916412354,
-0.8807960748672485,
-0.6462973356246948,
0.42301154136657715,
-0.3720510005950928,
-0.0930648148059845,
0.9331110119819641,
0.786279559135437,
-0.20093315839767456,
0.006010669283568859,
0.3670046031475067,
0.21225687861442566,
0.46023163199424744,
0.6395360827445984,
1.0012887716293335,
-0.3985748291015625,
0.6703668832778931,
-0.15069861710071564,
-0.21102820336818695,
-0.26902252435684204,
-1.0549418926239014,
-0.8185184001922607,
-0.416507363319397,
-0.29409274458885193,
-0.5862002968788147,
-0.23516757786273956,
1.0873427391052246,
0.6950976848602295,
-0.6054996848106384,
0.07784397900104523,
-0.25739145278930664,
0.6873498558998108,
-0.2506869435310364,
-0.2355492115020752,
0.28040915727615356,
-0.36939454078674316,
-0.4266434609889984,
0.41328319907188416,
0.5384402275085449,
0.1632826179265976,
-0.1595481038093567,
0.10973518341779709,
-0.325401246547699,
0.16881567239761353,
0.728105902671814,
0.18582110106945038,
-0.9610283970832825,
-0.5222364664077759,
-0.28478652238845825,
-0.01655859872698784,
0.011266970075666904,
1.040750503540039,
-0.7688618898391724,
0.4678060710430145,
0.3184768259525299,
0.34496092796325684,
0.5687534809112549,
-0.21994876861572266,
0.3919150233268738,
-0.6750281453132629,
0.4326813519001007,
0.4948492646217346,
0.456827849149704,
0.248260498046875,
-0.5868657231330872,
0.4691479504108429,
0.11365444958209991,
-0.28696176409721375,
-0.46708929538726807,
0.42083513736724854,
-0.8302892446517944,
-0.2987752854824066,
1.3187562227249146,
-0.0917106568813324,
-0.12197494506835938,
-0.19115778803825378,
-0.35666462779045105,
-0.2141544222831726,
-0.07165344059467316,
0.8470909595489502,
0.7606789469718933,
-0.27776363492012024,
0.002325659152120352,
-0.5564205646514893,
0.39839181303977966,
0.5913512706756592,
-0.9729549288749695,
-0.12808531522750854,
0.45518583059310913,
0.24198856949806213,
-0.16444216668605804,
0.8132911920547485,
-0.2747802734375,
0.26034286618232727,
-0.2400490939617157,
-0.2549580931663513,
0.0859135091304779,
-0.25288355350494385,
-0.11777521669864655,
-0.10222607105970383,
0.10692264884710312,
-0.14720334112644196
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.12721v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.12721v2
|
CLASSLA-web: Comparable Web Corpora of South Slavic Languages Enriched with Linguistic and Genre Annotation
| 2024-03-19T13:30:47 | 2024-03-26T14:32:34 |
Nikola Ljubešić, Taja Kuzman
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper presents a collection of highly comparable web corpora of
Slovenian, Croatian, Bosnian, Montenegrin, Serbian, Macedonian, and Bulgarian,
covering thereby the whole spectrum of official languages in the South Slavic
language space. The collection of these corpora comprises a total of 13 billion
tokens of texts from 26 million documents. The comparability of the corpora is
ensured by a comparable crawling setup and the usage of identical crawling and
post-processing technology. All the corpora were linguistically annotated with
the state-of-the-art CLASSLA-Stanza linguistic processing pipeline, and
enriched with document-level genre information via the Transformer-based
multilingual X-GENRE classifier, which further enhances comparability at the
level of linguistic annotation and metadata enrichment. The genre-focused
analysis of the resulting corpora shows a rather consistent distribution of
genres throughout the seven corpora, with variations in the most prominent
genre categories being well-explained by the economic strength of each language
community. A comparison of the distribution of genre categories across the
corpora indicates that web corpora from less developed countries primarily
consist of news articles. Conversely, web corpora from economically more
developed countries exhibit a smaller proportion of news content, with a
greater presence of promotional and opinionated texts.
|
[
-0.46667107939720154,
-0.061234503984451294,
0.10006347298622131,
0.31076374650001526,
-0.2548307180404663,
0.7449920177459717,
-0.6355965733528137,
-0.6351823210716248,
0.6516098976135254,
0.3467250466346741,
-0.2350032478570938,
-0.855684220790863,
-0.328849196434021,
0.6486051678657532,
-0.3571948707103729,
0.794883131980896,
0.2534862458705902,
0.18971019983291626,
-0.20245985686779022,
-0.08298654109239578,
0.18297217786312103,
-0.6047700643539429,
-0.054696984589099884,
0.07604353874921799,
0.452009379863739,
0.0927422046661377,
0.4004897177219391,
0.4025808572769165,
0.8083832859992981,
0.3043389320373535,
-0.03360569849610329,
0.036745864897966385,
-0.3246554136276245,
0.33714860677719116,
-0.38330426812171936,
-0.6911770701408386,
-0.5315452814102173,
0.021660389378666878,
0.5481918454170227,
0.599645733833313,
0.026027917861938477,
0.708293616771698,
-0.1946229785680771,
0.666572630405426,
-0.7460678815841675,
0.13759756088256836,
-0.5802611112594604,
-0.08721253275871277,
-0.4786489009857178,
-0.3134590983390808,
-0.6270083785057068,
-0.5713688731193542,
-0.08861274272203445,
-0.5018348693847656,
0.21178029477596283,
0.4043402373790741,
0.9426723718643188,
0.016688359901309013,
-0.20034460723400116,
-0.5757517218589783,
-0.4474034309387207,
0.6995349526405334,
-0.3994370996952057,
0.6293773651123047,
0.48625296354293823,
0.23316030204296112,
0.23042884469032288,
-0.43529656529426575,
-0.409355491399765,
0.1395709216594696,
0.0964054986834526,
0.35926106572151184,
-0.6062419414520264,
-0.06812947988510132,
-0.25476425886154175,
0.3766888678073883,
-0.9693623781204224,
0.3657045066356659,
-0.7821038365364075,
-0.3584093153476715,
0.6366556882858276,
0.052435100078582764,
0.2037111520767212,
-0.270106703042984,
-0.1854824721813202,
-0.017519427463412285,
-0.9222673177719116,
-0.11422351002693176,
1.0084257125854492,
0.45321235060691833,
-0.1058758869767189,
0.8176313638687134,
-0.2295108437538147,
1.003736972808838,
-0.13707181811332703,
-0.5817739367485046,
0.5242817401885986,
-0.2489297240972519,
-0.14972683787345886,
0.11092104762792587,
0.5357000827789307,
0.7230352163314819,
0.02034592628479004,
-0.4340280294418335,
0.04783269390463829,
0.488707572221756,
0.2612990438938141,
-0.2879179120063782,
0.03140394017100334,
0.2509933114051819,
-0.7351071238517761,
-0.4653818905353546,
-0.02747419849038124,
-1.1775189638137817,
-0.3157445788383484,
-0.2338511347770691,
-0.19213661551475525,
-0.13816778361797333,
-0.22921065986156464,
-0.06364839524030685,
-0.20542719960212708,
0.045687127858400345,
-0.08347894996404648,
-0.8058687448501587,
0.16973154246807098,
0.6935127973556519,
0.9286808371543884,
-0.42599380016326904,
-0.029146453365683556,
-0.08322147279977798,
0.07259759306907654,
-0.47437068819999695,
1.0482566356658936,
-0.8315396904945374,
0.0425843670964241,
0.44050052762031555,
-0.045912280678749084,
0.0697346106171608,
-0.6939140558242798,
0.5704811811447144,
-0.6988662481307983,
0.06988202780485153,
0.07798436284065247,
-0.44563165307044983,
-0.2892826795578003,
0.3009544909000397,
-0.4479289650917053,
0.915826678276062,
0.44475099444389343,
-0.7695672512054443,
0.7978945970535278,
-0.3758808672428131,
-0.35166874527931213,
0.3508668839931488,
0.09532174468040466,
0.1411750763654709,
-0.013627869077026844,
-0.5024309754371643,
0.4801597595214844,
-0.3757217228412628,
0.03991936892271042,
-0.35344576835632324,
-0.20790596306324005,
0.25183817744255066,
0.2091459333896637,
0.6224621534347534,
0.6749156713485718,
-0.2342042624950409,
0.3451302945613861,
-1.2611167430877686,
0.04453955218195915,
-0.30655696988105774,
-0.4449581503868103,
-0.6373571157455444,
-0.27669140696525574,
0.5985356569290161,
0.433371365070343,
0.5032181739807129,
-0.5849859714508057,
0.39003273844718933,
-0.3141920566558838,
0.4408765733242035,
0.4074815809726715,
-0.33408123254776,
0.43495091795921326,
0.059273555874824524,
0.7825692892074585,
-0.2360798865556717,
0.13551561534404755,
0.2956048250198364,
-0.3513142466545105,
-0.8691087961196899,
-0.5113925337791443,
0.6458139419555664,
0.6369048357009888,
-0.635006844997406,
0.6070573925971985,
-0.4244127571582794,
-0.6126603484153748,
-1.0059219598770142,
-0.3448461890220642,
0.49831393361091614,
0.035364583134651184,
0.3221755921840668,
-0.3752419948577881,
-1.1195554733276367,
-1.0146499872207642,
0.11691795289516449,
-0.26817139983177185,
0.004798288457095623,
-0.06939349323511124,
0.22128476202487946,
-0.10808231681585312,
0.8387876749038696,
-0.34909796714782715,
-0.3771625757217407,
-0.44889160990715027,
0.10492224246263504,
-0.11170103400945663,
0.13381214439868927,
0.41254177689552307,
-0.8651276230812073,
-0.5152660012245178,
0.006976063828915358,
-0.7894999980926514,
-0.36716321110725403,
0.17987480759620667,
0.08125979453325272,
0.7465425133705139,
0.22251670062541962,
-0.14347489178180695,
0.2649266719818115,
0.6307492852210999,
-0.4429643154144287,
0.6825379133224487,
-0.11235485225915909,
0.2112799435853958,
-0.9826035499572754,
0.1271757334470749,
-0.13581106066703796,
-0.07389432191848755,
-0.588888943195343,
0.4378809332847595,
-0.12011142820119858,
0.08114443719387054,
-0.4877718389034271,
0.3462468981742859,
-0.5006495118141174,
-0.5595267415046692,
-0.24974556267261505,
0.7489977478981018,
-0.2208600491285324,
0.16650637984275818,
0.23481987416744232,
0.9113364219665527,
0.6409032940864563,
-0.29784882068634033,
0.4708673059940338,
0.2378304898738861,
-0.49362102150917053,
0.4186716675758362,
-0.16038259863853455,
-0.046315889805555344,
-0.028440149500966072,
0.08176661282777786,
-0.6023297309875488,
-0.05790821090340614,
0.13345004618167877,
-0.3850187063217163,
0.0843028798699379,
-0.5406569242477417,
-0.604367733001709,
-0.16270636022090912,
-0.24445392191410065,
-0.035171374678611755,
0.3604190945625305,
-0.0003262189566157758,
0.12692278623580933,
0.5986037850379944,
-0.4570862948894501,
-0.6107797026634216,
-0.6007062196731567,
0.6088747978210449,
-0.44337716698646545,
-0.530691921710968,
0.0449649840593338,
-0.09525077044963837,
-0.6761049628257751,
-0.015299445018172264,
0.22895678877830505,
-0.16999725997447968,
-0.11913496255874634,
0.2541303038597107,
0.5522541403770447,
-0.3821890950202942,
-0.09687811881303787,
0.056930433958768845,
0.2211615890264511,
-0.3042024075984955,
-0.5248218178749084,
1.0439739227294922,
-0.4200034439563751,
0.10135797411203384,
-0.11031010746955872,
0.3619711101055145,
0.39150866866111755,
-0.24393346905708313,
0.8699905276298523,
0.39182937145233154,
0.02343508042395115,
0.37205418944358826,
-0.7880121469497681,
0.47385743260383606,
-0.32760635018348694,
-0.15169933438301086,
-0.5325756072998047,
-0.8841985464096069,
0.577261209487915,
0.08043120801448822,
-0.20225723087787628,
0.5639587640762329,
0.4817051887512207,
0.1040433868765831,
0.521873414516449,
0.5650289058685303,
-0.17055581510066986,
-0.10088139772415161,
-0.4964623749256134,
-0.010177312418818474,
-0.6774340271949768,
-0.5105674862861633,
-0.7927055358886719,
-0.056641675531864166,
-1.0064393281936646,
-0.23048514127731323,
-0.0939812883734703,
0.060519855469465256,
-0.12922294437885284,
0.7930623292922974,
-0.5478901267051697,
0.22642096877098083,
0.552550733089447,
-0.4484533965587616,
0.5313054919242859,
0.16937828063964844,
-0.046998851001262665,
-0.049938466399908066,
-0.6358153820037842,
-1.118202567100525,
1.1707782745361328,
-0.13519738614559174,
0.42760854959487915,
0.4633104205131531,
0.8525164723396301,
0.4637501835823059,
0.07360904663801193,
-0.5397151112556458,
0.4221937358379364,
-0.31171876192092896,
-0.6588771939277649,
-0.07843522727489471,
-0.13730502128601074,
-0.8714144229888916,
0.20037394762039185,
-0.38859695196151733,
-0.9374883770942688,
0.6525495648384094,
-0.30746155977249146,
-0.1169302687048912,
0.19102118909358978,
-0.45486411452293396,
0.646431565284729,
0.305564284324646,
-0.3344864845275879,
-0.21102924644947052,
-0.8054203987121582,
0.034312739968299866,
0.015521382912993431,
0.6350072622299194,
0.0384681299328804,
-0.328828364610672,
0.7933287024497986,
0.12339962273836136,
0.5774978995323181,
0.2782380282878876,
-0.027443282306194305,
0.2448892444372177,
0.07975021004676819,
-0.10527899861335754,
-0.316484272480011,
-0.10396473109722137,
0.14489315450191498,
0.11038240790367126,
-0.6335378885269165,
-0.22878071665763855,
0.41622599959373474,
-0.596405565738678,
-0.32927560806274414,
-0.632837176322937,
-0.2553986608982086,
-0.1540059745311737,
0.4132409989833832,
0.6160402297973633,
0.588750422000885,
-0.11143442243337631,
0.28073278069496155,
0.3074909746646881,
-0.1451060026884079,
0.5028813481330872,
0.46596595644950867,
-0.4650315046310425,
-0.408010333776474,
1.1020241975784302,
0.011694650165736675,
0.2505794167518616,
0.46670207381248474,
-0.3331260085105896,
-0.3185928463935852,
-0.7635375261306763,
-0.6452203392982483,
0.005789381451904774,
-0.719086229801178,
-0.32652807235717773,
-0.8082606792449951,
0.21352174878120422,
-0.749910295009613,
-0.3985837399959564,
-0.08436106145381927,
-0.6948164701461792,
0.01385942567139864,
-0.07620961964130402,
0.10074997693300247,
0.9402092695236206,
-0.05364247038960457,
0.011090477928519249,
-0.6779848337173462,
-0.087143674492836,
-0.3334125280380249,
0.282782644033432,
-0.05282832309603691,
-0.254300057888031,
-0.09801944345235825,
-0.21533577144145966,
0.04995783418416977,
-0.7736794948577881,
0.47509658336639404,
0.15142907202243805,
0.32106366753578186,
0.49577343463897705,
0.20284926891326904,
0.41799017786979675,
-0.3454384207725525,
1.0338935852050781,
0.3435507118701935,
-0.744473934173584,
0.33953943848609924,
-0.4214615523815155,
-0.04191972315311432,
0.7405455112457275,
0.6980626583099365,
-0.5990288853645325,
-0.7453687787055969,
-0.5679205060005188,
-0.9576348066329956,
0.40235716104507446,
0.3210899829864502,
-0.17275913059711456,
-0.18452084064483643,
-0.05586814135313034,
0.4845692813396454,
0.3596084415912628,
-0.7092235684394836,
-0.4331378936767578,
-0.39806267619132996,
-0.20942501723766327,
-0.06349311769008636,
-0.27650222182273865,
-0.059185680001974106,
0.15390174090862274,
0.7708700299263,
0.02377847023308277,
0.11423800885677338,
0.006514161825180054,
-0.42465731501579285,
0.12201524525880814,
0.7202576994895935,
0.9441062211990356,
0.976862370967865,
-0.13197946548461914,
0.47096365690231323,
-0.10220396518707275,
-0.8750869035720825,
0.07383554428815842,
-0.09589862823486328,
-0.5207790732383728,
0.01713336817920208,
0.43862786889076233,
0.75962233543396,
0.2134457677602768,
-1.0508688688278198,
0.1838778704404831,
0.08670573681592941,
0.09592510759830475,
-0.40251871943473816,
-0.2911600172519684,
0.08706837892532349,
0.4097508490085602,
0.7490830421447754,
0.06236041337251663,
0.5907133221626282,
-0.8590518236160278,
0.08330407738685608,
0.0015719825169071555,
-0.3232381045818329,
-0.2925247251987457,
0.2831348776817322,
0.1942807286977768,
-0.32567131519317627,
0.15610511600971222,
-0.5923076272010803,
-0.7766637206077576,
0.293736070394516,
0.6919040083885193,
0.5412603616714478,
0.20448310673236847,
0.5276798605918884,
0.23101870715618134,
0.2526518702507019,
0.18137383460998535,
0.2689390778541565,
0.1150755062699318,
-0.281318724155426,
-0.21424822509288788,
-1.1010136604309082,
-0.23078244924545288,
-0.11949454247951508,
-0.7969368696212769,
0.19537125527858734,
-0.15873901546001434,
-0.06923340260982513,
0.09611024707555771,
0.17037411034107208,
-0.25703123211860657,
0.1904992312192917,
0.05002761259675026,
0.9286407232284546,
-0.7668023109436035,
0.6955190300941467,
0.8327792286872864,
-0.9478129744529724,
-0.3746527433395386,
-0.03020273707807064,
-0.11956580728292465,
-0.43044084310531616,
1.1177854537963867,
-0.22229140996932983,
-0.13234354555606842,
-0.15065622329711914,
-0.03371812775731087,
-0.8632080554962158,
0.7845165729522705,
0.050859078764915466,
-0.5528958439826965,
0.036790624260902405,
0.24093590676784515,
0.9632691144943237,
-0.6044963002204895,
0.1108277291059494,
0.3127995431423187,
0.5420049428939819,
-0.1437302529811859,
-1.0556294918060303,
0.023700598627328873,
-0.3464674949645996,
-0.11820881813764572,
0.10892891138792038,
-0.7445396184921265,
0.5344582796096802,
0.27951759099960327,
-0.10231044888496399,
0.2036702036857605,
0.7648264765739441,
0.10324119031429291,
0.4408204257488251,
0.36152827739715576,
0.32246798276901245,
0.5970280766487122,
-0.022538363933563232,
0.5389763116836548,
-0.44132059812545776,
0.27788078784942627,
0.8313482999801636,
-0.3495088517665863,
0.9962772727012634,
0.20549991726875305,
-0.6743103861808777,
0.7260797023773193,
0.877415120601654,
-0.3333095610141754,
0.45035383105278015,
0.30095919966697693,
-0.37921765446662903,
-0.09030156582593918,
-0.27662426233291626,
-0.4104057848453522,
0.7008841633796692,
0.060302842408418655,
-0.0693402960896492,
-0.04923969507217407,
0.3536455035209656,
0.22665415704250336,
0.41715705394744873,
-0.39388516545295715,
0.7454167604446411,
-0.30604416131973267,
-0.7178959250450134,
0.5340874791145325,
-0.0360451266169548,
0.9695025086402893,
-0.3114682734012604,
0.24082854390144348,
-0.23157374560832977,
-0.2223035842180252,
-0.5071831345558167,
-0.5973026752471924,
0.3245788812637329,
0.47160211205482483,
-0.2908514738082886,
0.0530954971909523,
0.7122610807418823,
-0.5928494930267334,
-0.5186480283737183,
0.4192388355731964,
0.25042498111724854,
0.7439476847648621,
0.24791498482227325,
-0.1471264362335205,
0.29087626934051514,
-0.2531169056892395,
0.22884045541286469,
0.6773385405540466,
0.049194078892469406,
-0.13693587481975555,
0.6817095279693604,
0.4035916030406952,
0.4058510661125183,
0.4428994059562683,
0.08595279604196548,
0.5361406207084656,
-0.38280779123306274,
-0.5639328956604004,
-0.3857717216014862,
-0.0007550623849965632,
-0.32329827547073364,
-0.3454839587211609,
0.9520843625068665,
1.2532814741134644,
0.9458242654800415,
-0.27745652198791504,
0.8657922744750977,
-0.4472752511501312,
0.5238807201385498,
-0.4459085464477539,
1.0468870401382446,
-0.48714056611061096,
-0.13569097220897675,
-0.39178532361984253,
-1.0855591297149658,
-0.3597091734409332,
0.44162455201148987,
-0.06290435791015625,
-0.4606357216835022,
0.6512879729270935,
0.41889747977256775,
0.1187594085931778,
0.10125749558210373,
0.29719868302345276,
0.08780537545681,
-0.2641752064228058,
-0.13960957527160645,
0.44928857684135437,
-0.2056627720594406,
0.73496413230896,
-0.24391691386699677,
-0.32344043254852295,
-0.3427819013595581,
-0.6982003450393677,
-0.7842257022857666,
-1.076309084892273,
-0.15129289031028748,
-0.4612894356250763,
0.48963460326194763,
1.2198193073272705,
0.4656548798084259,
-1.0185558795928955,
-0.39817309379577637,
0.3867911100387573,
-0.0501430481672287,
-0.2333230823278427,
-0.2121075987815857,
0.40952882170677185,
-0.40865686535835266,
-0.7117606401443481,
0.5100533962249756,
0.47864028811454773,
-0.2787402272224426,
-0.5211911797523499,
0.1825876384973526,
-0.5288188457489014,
-0.19025923311710358,
0.856453537940979,
0.08295347541570663,
-0.8832022547721863,
-0.25460508465766907,
0.1852031797170639,
-0.04601367935538292,
0.08866990357637405,
0.7899574041366577,
-0.5394408702850342,
0.20912618935108185,
0.5210150480270386,
-0.05299777165055275,
0.40391579270362854,
-0.22383062541484833,
0.21390292048454285,
-0.5411964058876038,
0.39452654123306274,
0.16105160117149353,
0.2507110834121704,
0.4736521244049072,
-0.11691250652074814,
0.8423671722412109,
0.3568345606327057,
-0.2980121970176697,
-0.9657335877418518,
0.06442602723836899,
-1.2288991212844849,
-0.4209495484828949,
1.280600666999817,
-0.4885615110397339,
-0.04154375195503235,
-0.6341780424118042,
-0.019501661881804466,
0.3847711384296417,
-0.40555858612060547,
0.9526587128639221,
0.8939182162284851,
0.0933929830789566,
0.06813643872737885,
-0.3249015212059021,
0.45960572361946106,
-0.22993013262748718,
-0.6867827773094177,
0.07741952687501907,
0.6368058919906616,
0.14474211633205414,
0.6356777548789978,
0.3095744848251343,
-0.06834347546100616,
0.08511444181203842,
0.05276026576757431,
0.40354886651039124,
0.17079074680805206,
-0.4760116636753082,
-0.16076500713825226,
0.6296156644821167,
-0.1569427102804184,
0.15692658722400665
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.12678v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.12678v1
|
Empowering Air Travelers: A Chatbot for Canadian Air Passenger Rights
| 2024-03-19T12:24:20 | 2024-03-19T12:24:20 |
Maksym Taranukhin, Sahithya Ravi, Gabor Lukacs, Evangelos Milios, Vered Shwartz
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The Canadian air travel sector has seen a significant increase in flight
delays, cancellations, and other issues concerning passenger rights.
Recognizing this demand, we present a chatbot to assist passengers and educate
them about their rights. Our system breaks a complex user input into simple
queries which are used to retrieve information from a collection of documents
detailing air travel regulations. The most relevant passages from these
documents are presented along with links to the original documents and the
generated queries, enabling users to dissect and leverage the information for
their unique circumstances. The system successfully overcomes two predominant
challenges: understanding complex user inputs, and delivering accurate answers,
free of hallucinations, that passengers can rely on for making informed
decisions. A user study comparing the chatbot to a Google search demonstrated
the chatbot's usefulness and ease of use. Beyond the primary goal of providing
accurate and timely information to air passengers regarding their rights, we
hope that this system will also enable further research exploring the tradeoff
between the user-friendly conversational interface of chatbots and the accuracy
of retrieval systems.
|
[
-0.08081599324941635,
-0.4791983962059021,
0.5763527154922485,
0.5802439451217651,
0.005829668138176203,
0.5326023697853088,
0.05673333257436752,
-0.21878214180469513,
0.5293784141540527,
0.7789109349250793,
-0.4515170156955719,
0.073084257543087,
-0.4653073847293854,
-0.2052951455116272,
-0.6682009100914001,
0.5875282287597656,
0.24881161749362946,
-0.12464740127325058,
-0.32640835642814636,
0.13578647375106812,
-0.443448543548584,
-0.9463668465614319,
-0.6011590957641602,
0.16465464234352112,
1.0155086517333984,
0.5086929202079773,
1.015683889389038,
-0.011405413039028645,
0.6797871589660645,
0.19995282590389252,
-0.19174006581306458,
-0.0150931840762496,
-0.1404826045036316,
-0.027500204741954803,
0.1042667105793953,
-0.5044690370559692,
-0.12265761941671371,
-0.4400341212749481,
0.19168448448181152,
0.39266863465309143,
-0.7187671661376953,
-0.19183972477912903,
-0.21441350877285004,
0.3554236888885498,
-0.44866788387298584,
-0.05050182342529297,
-0.6066550016403198,
0.051920510828495026,
-0.13872720301151276,
-0.33750611543655396,
-0.08903146535158157,
-0.5257580876350403,
-0.21495166420936584,
-0.881751298904419,
0.17328307032585144,
0.4708574116230011,
1.0471471548080444,
0.40088391304016113,
-0.6707403659820557,
-0.6009058952331543,
-0.5214163661003113,
0.43385833501815796,
-0.3501862585544586,
0.6515589952468872,
0.5077723264694214,
0.6670457720756531,
-0.065140500664711,
-0.977942943572998,
-0.9079851508140564,
0.017025351524353027,
-0.15287314355373383,
0.19448651373386383,
-0.441875696182251,
0.12084738910198212,
0.3196153938770294,
-0.008203764446079731,
-0.6476002931594849,
0.02081460878252983,
-0.5773857235908508,
-0.640625536441803,
0.4782349169254303,
0.13476841151714325,
0.7512689828872681,
-0.2293778657913208,
-0.07884199917316437,
-0.13512752950191498,
-0.25637295842170715,
0.2195979207754135,
0.5869026780128479,
0.237004354596138,
-0.045364297926425934,
0.6802383065223694,
-0.28185728192329407,
0.5786179900169373,
-0.1709332913160324,
0.3199111521244049,
0.01210468914359808,
0.27615800499916077,
-0.1141924262046814,
0.30892670154571533,
0.4895310699939728,
0.5718281865119934,
-0.011953314766287804,
-0.3116672933101654,
-0.2632576823234558,
-0.4018995463848114,
0.16710582375526428,
-0.6566829681396484,
-0.2763189971446991,
0.19901889562606812,
-0.5281115174293518,
-0.05014768987894058,
0.4016030430793762,
-0.6122332811355591,
-0.4745316505432129,
-0.5541017055511475,
0.40106305480003357,
-0.05766421929001808,
-0.49716609716415405,
0.17126917839050293,
-0.6528461575508118,
0.7024257183074951,
0.5250785946846008,
-1.028470516204834,
0.27224209904670715,
0.6791753172874451,
0.838180661201477,
0.3216961920261383,
0.16469831764698029,
-0.6154478788375854,
-0.322665810585022,
-0.14483356475830078,
0.8122836947441101,
-0.8226346969604492,
-0.8584925532341003,
0.10837847739458084,
0.17505091428756714,
-0.04782683402299881,
-0.36520496010780334,
0.8488985300064087,
-0.8417678475379944,
0.2316776067018509,
-0.548597514629364,
-0.13658586144447327,
-0.21353338658809662,
0.0005016456125304103,
-0.2859032452106476,
0.7242138981819153,
0.0985395759344101,
-0.46139585971832275,
0.10325463116168976,
-0.7284054160118103,
-0.09751956164836884,
0.2732308506965637,
-0.3849053978919983,
-0.11344201117753983,
-0.04613044112920761,
0.184853196144104,
0.027198394760489464,
0.014512935653328896,
-0.047730952501297,
-0.46327298879623413,
-0.059104982763528824,
0.2528429329395294,
-0.18352502584457397,
1.1882026195526123,
0.38851651549339294,
0.37170377373695374,
0.044120803475379944,
-0.10792761296033859,
0.016482703387737274,
-0.03824834153056145,
-0.3890804350376129,
-0.09789850562810898,
-0.053618550300598145,
0.5200176239013672,
0.3295958936214447,
0.22786234319210052,
-0.7045741081237793,
0.2705133855342865,
-0.20393739640712738,
0.4133988618850708,
0.6513605713844299,
0.16743849217891693,
0.11130086332559586,
-0.45473986864089966,
0.632799506187439,
-0.02890791743993759,
0.8480297923088074,
-0.06597074121236801,
-0.5355186462402344,
-0.6445278525352478,
0.29165807366371155,
0.2105836570262909,
0.6674195528030396,
-0.4322744607925415,
0.40786489844322205,
-0.21591493487358093,
-0.36161959171295166,
-0.4204890727996826,
-0.02696649171411991,
-0.26396748423576355,
0.420396089553833,
0.06627683341503143,
-0.3428948223590851,
-0.3896704316139221,
-0.6865620017051697,
-0.3847511112689972,
-0.6381572484970093,
-0.07599692791700363,
0.38791361451148987,
0.38295426964759827,
-0.32644227147102356,
0.8912445902824402,
-0.737322986125946,
-0.1823512315750122,
0.008538373745977879,
0.033327367156744,
-0.18156327307224274,
0.6043052077293396,
0.5325029492378235,
-1.1505681276321411,
-0.36099687218666077,
-0.06583069264888763,
-0.49134260416030884,
-0.2564210891723633,
-0.2453085482120514,
-0.44319406151771545,
0.07700027525424957,
0.5244279503822327,
-0.4235852062702179,
0.6152097582817078,
-0.054418306797742844,
-0.713129460811615,
0.12882496416568756,
-0.23996125161647797,
0.25969573855400085,
-0.620051383972168,
0.13927967846393585,
-0.6093922257423401,
-0.0758141577243805,
-0.49603524804115295,
-0.2106575220823288,
0.007573537528514862,
-0.5531828999519348,
-0.5108492374420166,
0.5667402744293213,
0.16018198430538177,
0.09400536864995956,
-0.5276530981063843,
0.1681220680475235,
0.19387772679328918,
0.35259440541267395,
0.2311655730009079,
0.2841833233833313,
0.5346399545669556,
-0.49758848547935486,
0.37729746103286743,
0.8158282041549683,
0.12584631145000458,
0.5161684155464172,
-0.5244832634925842,
0.26296505331993103,
-0.2978159785270691,
0.1881285458803177,
-0.8139200210571289,
-0.5203156471252441,
0.5872094035148621,
-0.7748790383338928,
-0.2389257699251175,
-0.07783406227827072,
-0.4602768123149872,
-0.37530314922332764,
0.3253801465034485,
-0.08581230044364929,
0.3923368453979492,
-0.3678551912307739,
0.8812845945358276,
0.8336660265922546,
-0.43084093928337097,
-0.5341977477073669,
-0.37523403763771057,
0.5770047307014465,
-0.07271980494260788,
-0.36183592677116394,
0.015075569972395897,
-0.21525679528713226,
-0.3010932207107544,
-0.04970117285847664,
-0.19423440098762512,
-0.3765723407268524,
0.2809540629386902,
0.733611524105072,
0.07409445941448212,
0.23047223687171936,
0.3821077346801758,
0.07684334367513657,
0.17559035122394562,
0.11047505587339401,
-0.1582937091588974,
0.5013884902000427,
-0.023518109694123268,
-0.3898046016693115,
-0.4500249922275543,
0.6954917311668396,
0.7547675967216492,
-0.2056126743555069,
0.41427376866340637,
0.502535343170166,
-0.6198614835739136,
0.4931779205799103,
-0.7017711997032166,
-0.3458585739135742,
-0.48014217615127563,
-0.14665043354034424,
-0.23931263387203217,
-0.735284149646759,
0.6165241599082947,
0.33165717124938965,
0.2088717371225357,
0.3659626543521881,
0.11101022362709045,
-0.23542682826519012,
0.9796610474586487,
0.9733679294586182,
-0.038772642612457275,
0.43156513571739197,
0.3196221590042114,
0.2676517367362976,
-0.3885238468647003,
-0.9575109481811523,
-1.1577414274215698,
-0.20216426253318787,
-0.40687182545661926,
-0.24727025628089905,
0.1503806859254837,
-0.07107961922883987,
-0.4357425272464752,
0.15255962312221527,
-0.5825912952423096,
0.3374289870262146,
0.6702935695648193,
0.22972731292247772,
0.26615849137306213,
-0.2595067024230957,
0.10053636878728867,
0.0172528475522995,
-0.681780219078064,
-0.6042801737785339,
0.6005049347877502,
-0.00847788155078888,
1.057413101196289,
0.22656340897083282,
0.23746298253536224,
0.7103386521339417,
0.1538793444633484,
-0.8241990208625793,
0.44458019733428955,
0.48171165585517883,
-1.0102492570877075,
-0.10157366096973419,
-0.4136783480644226,
-0.9254850745201111,
-0.21702846884727478,
-0.20250895619392395,
-0.6324821710586548,
0.6613754630088806,
-0.013853121548891068,
-0.8209937214851379,
0.2957257330417633,
-0.6228576302528381,
0.5579071640968323,
-0.756615936756134,
-0.19824841618537903,
-0.2665138840675354,
-0.9214823246002197,
-0.05644475296139717,
-0.29766473174095154,
0.052324965596199036,
-0.2828972041606903,
-0.10823781043291092,
0.8930186033248901,
-0.4710075557231903,
0.8222829103469849,
-0.29476240277290344,
0.3269277811050415,
0.31180477142333984,
-0.11415906995534897,
-0.21037791669368744,
0.09651540964841843,
-0.037152111530303955,
0.08929608762264252,
0.28370076417922974,
-0.4512993395328522,
-0.5482040047645569,
0.7598389983177185,
-0.895136296749115,
-0.5902097821235657,
-0.5621939897537231,
-0.03180154040455818,
0.10628485679626465,
0.3794546127319336,
-0.20377717912197113,
0.2786872088909149,
0.11971452087163925,
0.2905348539352417,
-0.01568819023668766,
-0.42420560121536255,
0.4701150059700012,
0.9027355313301086,
-0.606509268283844,
-0.3731634318828583,
0.6855971813201904,
0.3681694269180298,
-0.18587034940719604,
0.7748571038246155,
0.2266378402709961,
-0.7491240501403809,
-0.05631573870778084,
-0.2250494807958603,
-0.07851172983646393,
-0.8140082955360413,
-0.10216636210680008,
-1.1047848463058472,
-0.1879807710647583,
-0.5403647422790527,
-0.31669580936431885,
0.08746393024921417,
-1.0355616807937622,
-0.19906485080718994,
-0.13351434469223022,
0.3886215388774872,
0.6276637315750122,
-0.08909538388252258,
0.8796764016151428,
-0.9009456038475037,
0.4748712182044983,
0.6353206038475037,
0.3065282106399536,
-0.2629826068878174,
-0.4928695559501648,
-0.27074098587036133,
-0.2557169497013092,
-0.8889710307121277,
-0.6536638736724854,
0.35734736919403076,
-0.050334732979536057,
0.7773355841636658,
0.30942970514297485,
0.6936030983924866,
0.8384183645248413,
-0.09535370767116547,
1.067083716392517,
0.25137609243392944,
-1.067370891571045,
0.671004056930542,
-0.05734214559197426,
-0.1256285309791565,
0.5283644795417786,
0.21255862712860107,
-1.0049738883972168,
-0.46979954838752747,
-0.8082252144813538,
-0.9233191609382629,
0.7166128158569336,
0.4556661546230316,
0.4560369849205017,
0.20406708121299744,
0.29576441645622253,
-0.11488358676433563,
0.3880314826965332,
-0.35377174615859985,
0.24185724556446075,
-0.7524338960647583,
0.14345107972621918,
0.1682216078042984,
0.13518261909484863,
-0.046892859041690826,
0.05705735832452774,
0.7679719924926758,
-0.03881847858428955,
0.3017606735229492,
0.5984775424003601,
0.1588435173034668,
-0.3220069110393524,
0.020562278106808662,
0.6118865609169006,
0.8718255162239075,
-0.5105170607566833,
-0.05249496549367905,
0.12263480573892593,
-0.2549513876438141,
-0.20170339941978455,
0.16387441754341125,
0.10255926102399826,
0.1794114112854004,
-0.14587555825710297,
0.6227720379829407,
-0.1677727997303009,
-0.8614426255226135,
0.5188031196594238,
-0.7837007641792297,
-0.21403348445892334,
-0.5973333120346069,
0.1420106142759323,
-0.0862623080611229,
0.0626988485455513,
0.537112295627594,
0.36025336384773254,
0.2033405750989914,
-0.20865629613399506,
0.2225855439901352,
0.315356582403183,
-0.6922365427017212,
-0.09247314184904099,
1.272301435470581,
0.7358150482177734,
-0.8770974278450012,
0.6489874720573425,
0.47698456048965454,
-0.6133156418800354,
0.5712339878082275,
-0.06182537600398064,
0.7770754098892212,
-0.06755614280700684,
0.10491795092821121,
0.3159252405166626,
0.2380974143743515,
-0.13032206892967224,
0.35994952917099,
-0.2997870445251465,
-0.47800412774086,
-0.016847793012857437,
-0.3017515242099762,
-1.2667075395584106,
-0.2941124439239502,
-0.7610387206077576,
0.3815372884273529,
-0.48841944336891174,
-0.42980754375457764,
-0.1326095014810562,
0.14709323644638062,
-0.6470458507537842,
0.0945352166891098,
0.35485661029815674,
1.18191397190094,
-0.5105787515640259,
0.3613043427467346,
0.5810906291007996,
-0.48054784536361694,
-0.8116208910942078,
0.209860160946846,
0.029986729845404625,
-0.43440955877304077,
0.513992190361023,
0.22995370626449585,
-0.21367669105529785,
-0.10534494370222092,
-0.5516600012779236,
-0.18598522245883942,
0.8118218183517456,
0.3759025037288666,
-0.8634467720985413,
-0.12963663041591644,
0.0753566175699234,
0.09977886825799942,
0.12912315130233765,
0.6913324594497681,
0.3624444007873535,
0.4991699159145355,
0.10785360634326935,
-0.9415968656539917,
-0.21697406470775604,
-0.2025928795337677,
-0.33062949776649475,
-0.11379226297140121,
-1.0914803743362427,
0.0956532284617424,
0.0259008277207613,
-0.2601766288280487,
-0.1501389443874359,
0.4603164494037628,
-0.26254260540008545,
0.5806381702423096,
0.7127727270126343,
0.2971700429916382,
1.1494814157485962,
-0.31239214539527893,
1.0885319709777832,
-0.2814095616340637,
0.27718639373779297,
0.5544276237487793,
-0.3403809368610382,
0.7909547090530396,
0.7734418511390686,
0.1487010270357132,
0.3515438735485077,
0.5593552589416504,
0.46102410554885864,
0.3217361867427826,
0.20087039470672607,
-0.560718297958374,
-0.6028282642364502,
-0.25050029158592224,
-0.1937415450811386,
0.42235538363456726,
0.2666622996330261,
0.0856916531920433,
-0.24991212785243988,
0.1990622580051422,
-0.0012851834762841463,
0.11695081740617752,
-0.05061999708414078,
0.8883040547370911,
0.23843717575073242,
-0.758539617061615,
0.0920570120215416,
-0.08628576248884201,
0.05063672736287117,
-0.7802083492279053,
0.1659497618675232,
-0.2874627411365509,
-0.14362716674804688,
-0.31310367584228516,
-0.8366725444793701,
0.49111390113830566,
0.1693500429391861,
0.03119935654103756,
-0.3216853141784668,
0.6862291693687439,
0.004837654065340757,
-0.5310274958610535,
0.09436483681201935,
0.6212697625160217,
0.33418598771095276,
-0.32936450839042664,
-0.7747763991355896,
0.37940865755081177,
0.060324642807245255,
0.11333577334880829,
-0.013074085116386414,
0.2024715542793274,
0.05202938988804817,
0.9445653557777405,
0.8047760725021362,
0.11627127230167389,
0.0990491732954979,
0.043713416904211044,
0.9139681458473206,
-0.8821561336517334,
-0.5575428009033203,
-0.697972297668457,
0.46089425683021545,
-0.25952503085136414,
-0.3827607035636902,
0.2937825620174408,
0.7704806923866272,
0.47698330879211426,
-0.21075159311294556,
1.200809359550476,
-0.567969799041748,
0.6082097887992859,
-0.35184621810913086,
0.6732003092765808,
-0.6482118964195251,
0.4319559335708618,
0.44792458415031433,
-0.2753208577632904,
-0.7586455345153809,
0.6535910964012146,
-0.378604531288147,
-0.510452389717102,
0.005312349181622267,
1.180988073348999,
-0.09163825213909149,
0.07795189321041107,
0.3256053328514099,
-0.46069666743278503,
1.0367616415023804,
0.3915891647338867,
1.4113644361495972,
-0.3560631573200226,
1.0295891761779785,
-0.18589253723621368,
0.14368173480033875,
-0.8771650791168213,
-0.5948602557182312,
-0.6001765727996826,
-0.5430156588554382,
-0.6800134181976318,
-0.31977567076683044,
0.4092063307762146,
1.4308503866195679,
0.9647260904312134,
-0.5230880379676819,
-0.10710156708955765,
0.004602442495524883,
0.4828524887561798,
-0.1422208696603775,
-0.2873646914958954,
0.08817186951637268,
-0.20921315252780914,
-0.735705554485321,
0.025014575570821762,
0.12988950312137604,
0.19811365008354187,
0.24785001575946808,
-0.2769433856010437,
0.2223890721797943,
0.4660617411136627,
0.16825012862682343,
0.7245075106620789,
-0.39414912462234497,
-0.3221406042575836,
0.16593106091022491,
-0.2740386724472046,
0.056904181838035583,
0.891228199005127,
-0.3678496181964874,
0.8186943531036377,
0.4695001542568207,
0.6367393136024475,
0.08155758678913116,
0.2177446186542511,
0.4089527726173401,
-0.5015076398849487,
0.025946002453565598,
0.5050317049026489,
0.2259092479944229,
0.3861178159713745,
-0.4576079845428467,
0.23952242732048035,
0.0001691574725555256,
-0.968651533126831,
-0.8859083652496338,
-0.2114245742559433,
-1.6058779954910278,
0.09479970484972,
0.9327371716499329,
0.06352455914020538,
0.10916885733604431,
-0.3699204623699188,
-0.9866428971290588,
0.32027143239974976,
-0.9526867866516113,
0.8504226207733154,
0.5127150416374207,
-0.2581096291542053,
-0.2548627555370331,
-0.6532523036003113,
0.3422837257385254,
0.007586517371237278,
-0.6052581667900085,
0.06145278364419937,
0.3389734923839569,
0.17536477744579315,
0.10586095601320267,
0.7773628830909729,
-0.008830946870148182,
0.05264922231435776,
-0.2014540433883667,
0.28454580903053284,
0.17862875759601593,
-0.43358302116394043,
-0.20694562792778015,
0.27334511280059814,
0.2513211667537689,
-0.45975616574287415
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.12675v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.12675v1
|
Pragmatic Competence Evaluation of Large Language Models for Korean
| 2024-03-19T12:21:20 | 2024-03-19T12:21:20 |
Dojun Park, Jiwoo Lee, Hyeyun Jeong, Seohyun Park, Sungeun Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The current evaluation of Large Language Models (LLMs) predominantly relies
on benchmarks focusing on their embedded knowledge by testing through
multiple-choice questions (MCQs), a format inherently suited for automated
evaluation. Our study extends this evaluation to explore LLMs' pragmatic
competence--a facet previously underexamined before the advent of sophisticated
LLMs, specifically in the context of Korean. We employ two distinct evaluation
setups: the conventional MCQ format, adapted for automatic evaluation, and
Open-Ended Questions (OEQs), assessed by human experts, to examine LLMs'
narrative response capabilities without predefined options. Our findings reveal
that GPT-4 excels, scoring 81.11 and 85.69 in the MCQ and OEQ setups,
respectively, with HyperCLOVA X, an LLM optimized for Korean, closely
following, especially in the OEQ setup, demonstrating a score of 81.56 with a
marginal difference of 4.13 points compared to GPT-4. Furthermore, while
few-shot learning strategies generally enhance LLM performance,
Chain-of-Thought (CoT) prompting introduces a bias toward literal
interpretations, hindering accurate pragmatic inference. Considering the
growing expectation for LLMs to understand and produce language that aligns
with human communicative norms, our findings emphasize the importance for
advancing LLMs' abilities to grasp and convey sophisticated meanings beyond
mere literal interpretations.
|
[
-0.35849907994270325,
-0.8516872525215149,
0.7214595079421997,
0.20519843697547913,
-0.42533642053604126,
0.2619141638278961,
-0.6690007448196411,
-0.1148100271821022,
-0.14786545932292938,
0.40218445658683777,
-0.2854807376861572,
-0.7124294638633728,
-0.30577632784843445,
0.266166627407074,
0.13847042620182037,
0.9818182587623596,
-0.3155367076396942,
-0.08179543912410736,
-0.30735069513320923,
-0.09013967961072922,
-0.4529944360256195,
-0.45341596007347107,
-0.3153734505176544,
-0.4006126821041107,
0.473931223154068,
0.39248567819595337,
0.7605385780334473,
0.5393254160881042,
0.4162585437297821,
0.2926466763019562,
-0.10774228721857071,
0.1535988301038742,
-0.4994870722293854,
0.047582268714904785,
-0.1766282021999359,
-0.41505077481269836,
-0.49316179752349854,
0.15880189836025238,
0.7391114234924316,
0.7247004508972168,
-0.09325885772705078,
0.4473877549171448,
-0.07330179959535599,
0.730272114276886,
-0.5069294571876526,
0.2582729756832123,
-0.5974604487419128,
-0.020840836688876152,
0.05392003059387207,
0.05237239971756935,
-0.3648639917373657,
-0.4655219614505768,
0.2767304480075836,
-0.6262423992156982,
-0.23274263739585876,
-0.131995290517807,
0.7541549801826477,
0.06868408620357513,
-0.6027862429618835,
-0.5001688599586487,
-0.6022967100143433,
0.7043107151985168,
-0.5682277083396912,
0.293242871761322,
0.28495848178863525,
0.47761571407318115,
0.00927529763430357,
-0.7427602410316467,
-0.5095173716545105,
-0.7326261401176453,
0.10031979531049728,
0.4186669886112213,
0.09337148070335388,
0.24344652891159058,
0.32960426807403564,
0.27161306142807007,
-0.7053953409194946,
0.09421924501657486,
-0.2678471803665161,
-0.2476923167705536,
0.7768368124961853,
0.21764591336250305,
-0.0031558650080114603,
-0.23751293122768402,
-0.3636549115180969,
0.030779914930462837,
-0.5166842341423035,
0.05238566920161247,
0.6447005271911621,
0.163860484957695,
0.08274993300437927,
0.6405940055847168,
-0.27277684211730957,
0.803225576877594,
0.011447283439338207,
-0.4762040972709656,
0.24135206639766693,
-0.515119731426239,
-0.14705704152584076,
-0.10945897549390793,
0.6730183959007263,
0.43990808725357056,
0.8028932809829712,
0.06347810477018356,
-0.05894218385219574,
0.0182192325592041,
0.3405904471874237,
-0.4845770299434662,
-0.1258392482995987,
0.15250343084335327,
-0.3963027596473694,
-0.04019024223089218,
0.11296654492616653,
-0.7039010524749756,
-0.26716867089271545,
-0.43569621443748474,
0.2243669629096985,
-0.17435003817081451,
-0.42262735962867737,
0.14230985939502716,
0.03261096775531769,
0.42068085074424744,
0.25930407643318176,
-0.2805255055427551,
0.15970903635025024,
0.5298941731452942,
0.6910659074783325,
-0.3367842733860016,
-0.38191959261894226,
-0.21079742908477783,
-0.10587883740663528,
-0.5068055987358093,
0.6670945286750793,
-0.4987432062625885,
-0.3786422610282898,
-0.04000828042626381,
-0.09535149484872818,
-0.3949999213218689,
-0.7675411701202393,
0.7206750512123108,
-0.49075016379356384,
-0.039035871624946594,
-0.15585917234420776,
-0.41554275155067444,
-0.1846034973859787,
0.38324952125549316,
-0.38474950194358826,
0.7475968599319458,
0.13823439180850983,
-0.5406274199485779,
0.27571865916252136,
-0.3386956751346588,
-0.38917848467826843,
0.22277237474918365,
-0.3601081073284149,
-0.09744808077812195,
0.11367601901292801,
0.024933431297540665,
0.39634719491004944,
-0.17403888702392578,
0.4795200526714325,
-0.14341551065444946,
-0.4472540318965912,
0.35284918546676636,
-0.48731425404548645,
0.39065369963645935,
0.05891447514295578,
-0.13101300597190857,
0.1293720155954361,
-0.8171971440315247,
0.45548108220100403,
0.24090781807899475,
-0.5064007639884949,
-0.08832307159900665,
-0.44662123918533325,
-0.3718481957912445,
0.5885712504386902,
0.15910042822360992,
-0.1972285658121109,
0.04560631513595581,
-0.3674238622188568,
0.1788630336523056,
0.7107513546943665,
0.10993719100952148,
0.3478033244609833,
-0.27801886200904846,
0.9992689490318298,
-0.13064031302928925,
-0.11501932144165039,
-0.18377971649169922,
-0.5084397792816162,
-0.40912556648254395,
-0.4674112796783447,
0.20382854342460632,
0.6886933445930481,
-0.8260601162910461,
0.2581438422203064,
-0.1410270780324936,
-0.7500365376472473,
-0.5588718056678772,
0.34151312708854675,
0.7105055451393127,
0.6060236096382141,
0.0671214833855629,
-0.2560425400733948,
-0.37696489691734314,
-0.9269237518310547,
-0.596202552318573,
-0.2999109625816345,
-0.1765838861465454,
0.5734817981719971,
0.7201433181762695,
0.14152976870536804,
0.779570996761322,
-0.4023332893848419,
0.08413809537887573,
-0.4523007273674011,
0.04659822955727577,
0.3315252363681793,
0.08467134833335876,
0.12104692310094833,
-0.689535915851593,
-0.671352744102478,
0.14917650818824768,
-0.6173370480537415,
-0.3045017421245575,
-0.08714699000120163,
0.09024396538734436,
0.033902354538440704,
0.3109079897403717,
-0.8566867709159851,
0.2629457414150238,
0.4386327564716339,
-0.2943570911884308,
1.2461024522781372,
-0.06165279075503349,
0.1911318451166153,
-0.5045602917671204,
0.20129626989364624,
-0.030283913016319275,
-0.1505526751279831,
-0.7133820652961731,
0.029311133548617363,
0.0802202969789505,
0.07897748053073883,
-0.5914589762687683,
0.6842414736747742,
-0.3798987865447998,
-0.315891295671463,
-0.1914653331041336,
0.6751833558082581,
-0.004768985789269209,
0.4245409369468689,
0.059054043143987656,
0.8307341933250427,
0.21620628237724304,
-0.7541096806526184,
0.48945218324661255,
0.16609293222427368,
-0.4253334701061249,
0.6039523482322693,
-0.7116966843605042,
0.36440232396125793,
-0.15951943397521973,
0.20015515387058258,
-1.1040014028549194,
-0.38085344433784485,
0.13233377039432526,
-0.4225615859031677,
0.14789046347141266,
-0.2108406126499176,
-0.3711334466934204,
-0.5273190140724182,
-0.23781484365463257,
0.23767220973968506,
0.49302491545677185,
-0.15251624584197998,
0.39090585708618164,
0.0706026703119278,
-0.2756041884422302,
-0.5039473176002502,
-0.48886385560035706,
-0.10097929835319519,
-0.2971716821193695,
-0.595916211605072,
0.06587114185094833,
0.08560197055339813,
-0.628365159034729,
-0.2647987902164459,
-0.27290064096450806,
-0.017070794478058815,
-0.028884442523121834,
-0.028175804764032364,
0.29630085825920105,
-0.373686283826828,
0.08898648619651794,
-0.15548475086688995,
-0.12555979192256927,
0.02718941867351532,
-0.2423153966665268,
0.4859135150909424,
-0.46360161900520325,
-0.44420185685157776,
-0.2705456018447876,
-0.16341929137706757,
0.5662375688552856,
-0.23357172310352325,
0.5252772569656372,
0.5542601943016052,
-0.06450363993644714,
0.025949327275156975,
-0.43031376600265503,
0.014356817118823528,
-0.4250541627407074,
0.5839253664016724,
-0.5573503375053406,
-0.8828766942024231,
0.627104640007019,
-0.25936248898506165,
-0.13615958392620087,
0.25820568203926086,
0.8680680394172668,
-0.023029034957289696,
0.9303321242332458,
0.0920068621635437,
0.44775134325027466,
0.1441718339920044,
-0.007896698080003262,
0.2778604328632355,
-1.0040736198425293,
-0.259927362203598,
-0.3588407337665558,
-0.14664961397647858,
-0.5512176752090454,
-0.5924161672592163,
0.286430299282074,
0.13378854095935822,
-0.42232733964920044,
0.09137903898954391,
-0.032526321709156036,
0.5373522639274597,
0.07307933270931244,
-0.11212769150733948,
0.5374134182929993,
-0.332163006067276,
-0.451310396194458,
-0.2078203558921814,
-0.6437106728553772,
-1.024101972579956,
1.1693063974380493,
0.4944204092025757,
0.6417444944381714,
-0.11421201378107071,
0.4696691930294037,
-0.15350714325904846,
0.19584213197231293,
-0.9398080706596375,
0.7731677889823914,
0.16814404726028442,
-0.5279030203819275,
-0.25382286310195923,
-0.36695751547813416,
-0.6859984397888184,
0.5673242211341858,
0.24309982359409332,
-0.6112361550331116,
-0.16094449162483215,
0.005486347712576389,
-0.351060688495636,
-0.12152405828237534,
-0.8806324005126953,
0.8595868349075317,
-0.32369235157966614,
-0.36607885360717773,
0.11149292439222336,
-0.6483803987503052,
0.5774397850036621,
-0.17602606117725372,
0.09306936711072922,
-0.22364622354507446,
-0.44701793789863586,
0.6212185621261597,
0.16465649008750916,
0.66718590259552,
-0.22838743031024933,
-0.09882314503192902,
0.5201268792152405,
0.013574745506048203,
0.4597522020339966,
0.21601025760173798,
-0.1530805230140686,
-0.057444944977760315,
-0.19841806590557098,
-0.3663181960582733,
-0.7164947390556335,
0.5301018953323364,
-0.5335701704025269,
-0.7175134420394897,
-0.3426908254623413,
-0.6389210820198059,
-0.5180523991584778,
0.2020760178565979,
0.02084953337907791,
-0.0018347466830164194,
-0.2753923833370209,
0.12605221569538116,
0.6621415019035339,
-0.3974280059337616,
0.1641858071088791,
0.5035845041275024,
-0.44216933846473694,
-0.5139668583869934,
0.6214699149131775,
0.2535534203052521,
0.7850190997123718,
-0.23046676814556122,
0.19464659690856934,
-0.4614652395248413,
-0.5789982676506042,
-0.4967575669288635,
0.4615377187728882,
-0.9380937814712524,
-0.015069165267050266,
-0.4921056628227234,
-0.14309614896774292,
-0.14717721939086914,
-0.146613210439682,
-0.35166656970977783,
-0.16158534586429596,
-0.09462141245603561,
-0.3079928755760193,
-0.14615361392498016,
0.6672399640083313,
0.4174450635910034,
0.24860483407974243,
-0.6224045157432556,
0.30158713459968567,
0.21549111604690552,
0.2829711139202118,
-0.023700116202235222,
-0.7640388011932373,
-0.08227961510419846,
-0.053077809512615204,
-0.3264448940753937,
-0.7832176685333252,
0.1868778020143509,
0.15223318338394165,
0.7498375177383423,
0.27729278802871704,
-0.06840701401233673,
0.79911208152771,
-0.4624011516571045,
0.8199679255485535,
-0.08514051139354706,
-0.7865866422653198,
0.28715184330940247,
-0.42822107672691345,
0.5892897844314575,
0.7232301831245422,
0.5735055804252625,
-0.4014478325843811,
-0.37454691529273987,
-0.5669026374816895,
-0.6061789989471436,
0.509918212890625,
0.12916697561740875,
0.20848770439624786,
-0.0909598097205162,
0.40565022826194763,
0.07459644228219986,
0.5053154230117798,
-0.6191892027854919,
-0.0005858276272192597,
-0.019552597776055336,
-0.19201281666755676,
0.0034212993923574686,
-0.15151464939117432,
-0.12786443531513214,
-0.2868266701698303,
0.35803964734077454,
-0.3778633177280426,
0.14294523000717163,
0.31158947944641113,
-0.2469252347946167,
-0.020662367343902588,
0.4117853045463562,
0.6141283512115479,
1.181782841682434,
0.054272327572107315,
0.030773570761084557,
0.31115955114364624,
-0.5822009444236755,
0.2904655337333679,
-0.18834424018859863,
0.09055536985397339,
-0.10686124861240387,
0.53053218126297,
0.7704159021377563,
0.23362813889980316,
-0.9992373585700989,
0.4514490067958832,
0.09469151496887207,
-0.3321762979030609,
-0.07279517501592636,
-0.057451438158750534,
0.1925356686115265,
0.1751234531402588,
0.30574992299079895,
-0.2973043620586395,
-0.2759116590023041,
-0.5961126089096069,
0.206228107213974,
0.22130313515663147,
-0.14358514547348022,
-0.3370583951473236,
0.15633226931095123,
-0.013281053863465786,
-0.17740218341350555,
0.4733129143714905,
-0.5030589699745178,
-0.7300808429718018,
0.6420738697052002,
0.785744845867157,
0.6470059156417847,
-0.27686598896980286,
0.4298470616340637,
0.3502032160758972,
0.39758047461509705,
-0.04710588604211807,
0.468770295381546,
0.1684068739414215,
-0.6641229391098022,
-0.6736706495285034,
-0.6312500238418579,
-0.36656850576400757,
0.07019501179456711,
-0.650781512260437,
0.32946035265922546,
-0.5761590600013733,
-0.10882837325334549,
-0.4248700737953186,
0.2040383368730545,
-0.6126506328582764,
0.1750267744064331,
0.02112744189798832,
1.0114678144454956,
-0.8114016056060791,
0.6047766208648682,
1.029514193534851,
-0.24427799880504608,
-0.8137629628181458,
0.2633608877658844,
-0.10275420546531677,
-0.8550736904144287,
0.5698235034942627,
0.24252314865589142,
0.022767530754208565,
0.2086496204137802,
-0.19117510318756104,
-0.6212508082389832,
1.2852190732955933,
0.4184487462043762,
-0.574883222579956,
0.008405175991356373,
0.037155140191316605,
0.7495800852775574,
-0.5080299973487854,
0.3903104364871979,
0.994428813457489,
0.5645937919616699,
0.19526825845241547,
-1.276537299156189,
-0.010165334679186344,
0.12427449226379395,
0.03550641983747482,
-0.003478417405858636,
-0.5692466497421265,
0.6478855013847351,
-0.2939487397670746,
-0.07260119169950485,
-0.13857927918434143,
0.41092023253440857,
0.702377438545227,
0.46588894724845886,
0.3046562373638153,
0.403875470161438,
0.9388680458068848,
0.12095585465431213,
1.0020445585250854,
-0.038709960877895355,
0.15507517755031586,
1.0312812328338623,
-0.5891545414924622,
0.760192334651947,
0.3735238015651703,
-0.37225717306137085,
0.41611725091934204,
0.4341919422149658,
0.23819690942764282,
0.30059102177619934,
0.4121687412261963,
-0.14871159195899963,
-0.2240482121706009,
-0.018100744113326073,
-0.09185034781694412,
0.5970630049705505,
0.31329938769340515,
-0.32905271649360657,
-0.11975843459367752,
0.09886834025382996,
0.2079150229692459,
0.3067927658557892,
-0.47045689821243286,
0.7449676394462585,
0.2329641729593277,
-0.864476203918457,
0.6080422401428223,
-0.1631459891796112,
0.38745975494384766,
-0.5696029663085938,
0.11644816398620605,
0.006692071445286274,
0.00038441698416136205,
-0.14068706333637238,
-1.0077016353607178,
0.2532668709754944,
0.23353572189807892,
0.14379030466079712,
0.0280349999666214,
1.0021013021469116,
-0.490630567073822,
-0.21116411685943604,
0.1796039491891861,
0.7367187142372131,
0.20774592459201813,
-0.14904892444610596,
-0.8184831142425537,
0.1477775275707245,
-0.15867336094379425,
-0.47942814230918884,
0.40209299325942993,
0.3636036217212677,
-0.172765851020813,
0.718299150466919,
0.5995856523513794,
0.21346083283424377,
0.07876338064670563,
0.09802978485822678,
0.8506361246109009,
-0.639110267162323,
-0.3648865818977356,
-0.913776695728302,
0.5933176279067993,
0.009798136539757252,
-0.412480890750885,
0.9121283292770386,
0.29407116770744324,
0.8698586225509644,
-0.16182497143745422,
0.8188879489898682,
0.09918010234832764,
0.2488173395395279,
-0.5981351733207703,
0.42929843068122864,
-0.03417106345295906,
0.14632056653499603,
-0.29226258397102356,
-0.9317034482955933,
-0.21000611782073975,
0.7059906721115112,
-0.85664963722229,
0.37691086530685425,
0.9335132837295532,
0.5457122325897217,
0.255461722612381,
-0.05542771890759468,
0.6328573226928711,
0.1539870798587799,
0.12744267284870148,
0.6045392751693726,
1.082749843597412,
-0.07199299335479736,
0.5535925626754761,
-0.05407699570059776,
-0.2971613109111786,
-0.08196358382701874,
-0.9694681167602539,
-1.0220640897750854,
-0.27357572317123413,
-0.21392709016799927,
-0.28618812561035156,
0.08245757222175598,
1.0318455696105957,
0.2217881828546524,
-0.5170095562934875,
-0.30027201771736145,
0.11924948543310165,
0.18682369589805603,
-0.13217146694660187,
-0.2183050960302353,
0.2204349786043167,
-0.34565454721450806,
-0.45276862382888794,
0.32840773463249207,
0.36911091208457947,
-0.0817309096455574,
-0.36553487181663513,
-0.34048765897750854,
-0.26972517371177673,
0.06248879060149193,
0.6255365014076233,
0.08678500354290009,
-0.7629697918891907,
-0.06989166140556335,
0.17511029541492462,
-0.05114654079079628,
0.02826584503054619,
0.8161901831626892,
-0.8020763993263245,
0.44259583950042725,
0.3601166009902954,
0.6067938208580017,
0.07589665800333023,
0.3594922423362732,
0.6002747416496277,
-0.603123664855957,
0.1115041971206665,
0.6245915293693542,
-0.021247440949082375,
0.24559269845485687,
-0.12740352749824524,
0.3262362778186798,
0.28699398040771484,
-0.6574167609214783,
-0.9142884612083435,
0.3328985869884491,
-0.597321629524231,
-0.004149486310780048,
1.4525563716888428,
-0.5577145218849182,
-0.1267063468694687,
-0.4592137038707733,
-0.42759570479393005,
0.0923868864774704,
-0.05554460361599922,
0.35174381732940674,
1.1137034893035889,
-0.12336291372776031,
-0.06659214943647385,
-1.0662239789962769,
0.42235681414604187,
0.3102279603481293,
-0.701668918132782,
0.22998325526714325,
0.36076822876930237,
0.20351406931877136,
0.017963089048862457,
0.6822121739387512,
-0.2536189556121826,
0.4878329634666443,
-0.14978541433811188,
-0.30375102162361145,
-0.11643742769956589,
-0.46777570247650146,
-0.5806155204772949,
0.061741024255752563,
0.3302971422672272,
0.06617366522550583
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.12666v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.12666v1
|
Multi-Dimensional Machine Translation Evaluation: Model Evaluation and Resource for Korean
| 2024-03-19T12:02:38 | 2024-03-19T12:02:38 |
Dojun Park, Sebastian Padó
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Almost all frameworks for the manual or automatic evaluation of machine
translation characterize the quality of an MT output with a single number. An
exception is the Multidimensional Quality Metrics (MQM) framework which offers
a fine-grained ontology of quality dimensions for scoring (such as style,
fluency, accuracy, and terminology). Previous studies have demonstrated the
feasibility of MQM annotation but there are, to our knowledge, no computational
models that predict MQM scores for novel texts, due to a lack of resources. In
this paper, we address these shortcomings by (a) providing a 1200-sentence MQM
evaluation benchmark for the language pair English-Korean and (b) reframing MT
evaluation as the multi-task problem of simultaneously predicting several MQM
scores using SOTA language models, both in a reference-based MT evaluation
setup and a reference-free quality estimation (QE) setup. We find that
reference-free setup outperforms its counterpart in the style dimension while
reference-based models retain an edge regarding accuracy. Overall, RemBERT
emerges as the most promising model. Through our evaluation, we offer an
insight into the translation quality in a more fine-grained, interpretable
manner.
|
[
-0.19424712657928467,
-0.3835560083389282,
0.7542757391929626,
0.23284922540187836,
-0.42150434851646423,
0.05485043302178383,
-0.04246561974287033,
-0.1784573793411255,
0.164384663105011,
0.6291000843048096,
-0.5741467475891113,
-0.5769138336181641,
-0.6085935235023499,
0.33459553122520447,
-0.16603435575962067,
0.9343469142913818,
-0.3510124087333679,
0.3369613289833069,
-0.35697928071022034,
-0.3644239008426666,
-0.4469403922557831,
-0.5125792026519775,
-0.23928788304328918,
-0.39547181129455566,
0.3790086805820465,
0.3685421943664551,
0.9451355338096619,
0.7545375227928162,
0.6804132461547852,
0.25319889187812805,
0.2834814190864563,
0.29634156823158264,
-0.13429658114910126,
0.062280815094709396,
-0.03131479769945145,
-0.4100145697593689,
-0.6430407166481018,
0.37670302391052246,
0.8202120065689087,
0.4960445165634155,
0.11458412557840347,
0.4821717143058777,
0.03251736983656883,
0.7881152629852295,
-0.30407822132110596,
0.2079300880432129,
-0.27191224694252014,
0.08679430186748505,
-0.0625360831618309,
-0.1820264309644699,
-0.41588228940963745,
-0.4375472962856293,
0.023385485634207726,
-0.6004428267478943,
-0.18480932712554932,
0.20718730986118317,
0.7651551961898804,
0.42185500264167786,
-0.7173168063163757,
-0.18990539014339447,
-0.5715961456298828,
1.1284537315368652,
-0.6294155120849609,
0.6783237457275391,
0.2853946387767792,
0.6535290479660034,
0.05225954204797745,
-0.5502544045448303,
-0.4945542812347412,
-0.47374212741851807,
-0.007086970377713442,
0.32119444012641907,
-0.030140047892928123,
-0.2117685079574585,
-0.13551467657089233,
0.455374151468277,
-0.6676729917526245,
-0.17439687252044678,
-0.2205023467540741,
-0.16734443604946136,
0.6564093828201294,
0.5411555767059326,
0.1306275725364685,
-0.670814573764801,
-0.6203489899635315,
-0.12996187806129456,
-0.2410196214914322,
-0.03579114004969597,
0.18339717388153076,
0.29772019386291504,
0.026384461671113968,
0.7062568068504333,
-0.23705996572971344,
0.5085787773132324,
-0.15371061861515045,
-0.44459038972854614,
0.5331531167030334,
-0.7714253067970276,
-0.2503140866756439,
-0.43726322054862976,
1.145402193069458,
0.6340788006782532,
-0.046415336430072784,
-0.2952810823917389,
-0.342103511095047,
-0.13641151785850525,
0.45178139209747314,
-0.7833846807479858,
-0.009025191888213158,
0.22620868682861328,
-0.9401883482933044,
-0.25838255882263184,
0.042670924216508865,
-0.7316580414772034,
-0.16681715846061707,
-0.5011619925498962,
0.5053853988647461,
-0.37248504161834717,
-0.17071522772312164,
0.08092334866523743,
0.08683548122644424,
-0.2767178416252136,
0.14245562255382538,
-0.31589505076408386,
0.028724465519189835,
0.2833426594734192,
0.8452799916267395,
-0.30457109212875366,
-0.5289171934127808,
-0.28713494539260864,
-0.21203415095806122,
-0.3694131076335907,
0.8230058550834656,
-0.38450995087623596,
-0.25310513377189636,
-0.25152552127838135,
0.10239661484956741,
-0.20232708752155304,
-0.5271281599998474,
0.9824392795562744,
-0.3653372526168823,
0.13437122106552124,
-0.0835704356431961,
-0.397134006023407,
-0.39191386103630066,
0.35894501209259033,
-0.6620373129844666,
0.9344066977500916,
0.47859987616539,
-0.4187857508659363,
0.22647646069526672,
-0.5895310640335083,
-0.15578855574131012,
-0.07724341005086899,
0.04699530079960823,
-0.3697567284107208,
0.4152326285839081,
-0.015264278277754784,
0.49019187688827515,
-0.7365582585334778,
0.1824941635131836,
-0.1376248449087143,
-0.2630561888217926,
0.3830355405807495,
-0.42000046372413635,
0.37470898032188416,
0.4990488886833191,
0.19613273441791534,
0.27193450927734375,
-0.8563718795776367,
0.5629127621650696,
-0.01709008403122425,
-0.6917733550071716,
-0.22067397832870483,
-0.43493616580963135,
0.2595069408416748,
0.6622766852378845,
0.3114703297615051,
-0.36117199063301086,
0.10183833539485931,
-0.12071748822927475,
0.3171621859073639,
0.2566662132740021,
-0.09055174142122269,
0.4094056189060211,
-0.32296064496040344,
0.8586727380752563,
-0.07172956317663193,
0.11266259104013443,
-0.26948681473731995,
-0.3711659014225006,
-0.4168291389942169,
-0.35363081097602844,
0.7160238027572632,
0.6024885773658752,
-0.9824591875076294,
0.26444756984710693,
-0.44332361221313477,
-0.6495352387428284,
-1.1509437561035156,
0.048451099544763565,
0.7775329351425171,
0.06437311321496964,
0.5403724312782288,
-0.3521234393119812,
-0.361157089471817,
-0.9540656805038452,
-0.45576655864715576,
0.2296096831560135,
-0.24975624680519104,
0.29038286209106445,
0.4458414614200592,
-0.36141958832740784,
0.39184603095054626,
-0.3377878963947296,
-0.26558879017829895,
-0.053928837180137634,
0.3302139639854431,
0.25148454308509827,
0.5240635275840759,
0.35490766167640686,
-0.5610921382904053,
-0.668404221534729,
-0.02184569276869297,
-0.8263948559761047,
-0.2562713623046875,
-0.08785358816385269,
-0.1500225067138672,
-0.0766831710934639,
0.4704662263393402,
-0.49759823083877563,
0.1311025619506836,
0.9299031496047974,
-0.2000211477279663,
1.0535967350006104,
-0.1464904397726059,
0.7672170400619507,
-1.2322955131530762,
0.1731138825416565,
-0.02635154314339161,
-0.16848382353782654,
-0.6439728140830994,
0.2550152540206909,
0.2686712145805359,
-0.06549748033285141,
-0.43315911293029785,
0.4867740869522095,
-0.2627207338809967,
-0.09202718734741211,
-0.39969298243522644,
0.533940851688385,
0.33119669556617737,
0.37675413489341736,
-0.37111207842826843,
0.7030369639396667,
-0.2471277266740799,
-0.36287280917167664,
0.3983786106109619,
0.11440868675708771,
-0.5155240297317505,
0.8979265093803406,
-0.49658042192459106,
0.09153558313846588,
0.09915812313556671,
0.02675473690032959,
-1.018267273902893,
0.12038151174783707,
0.2761569917201996,
-0.4612460732460022,
0.29837000370025635,
-0.1850113570690155,
-0.7376430034637451,
-0.169111430644989,
-0.216881662607193,
0.563115656375885,
0.03982127457857132,
-0.14163261651992798,
0.4298960566520691,
0.21892572939395905,
0.025636732578277588,
-0.42888814210891724,
-0.5178364515304565,
0.1559736132621765,
-0.09492073953151703,
-0.5813565850257874,
0.40021491050720215,
-0.04325868934392929,
0.054688628762960434,
0.1265423446893692,
-0.2070826292037964,
-0.10384326428174973,
0.14307771623134613,
0.187672421336174,
0.12503570318222046,
-0.280159056186676,
0.1258435994386673,
0.16179421544075012,
-0.7016568779945374,
-0.052898019552230835,
-0.45437610149383545,
0.3602125942707062,
-0.07563357055187225,
-0.29587680101394653,
-0.47215887904167175,
0.32074034214019775,
0.8024471998214722,
-0.3369969427585602,
0.697425901889801,
0.8135592341423035,
-0.4116456210613251,
0.2870250940322876,
-0.36517298221588135,
0.08368314057588577,
-0.2964446544647217,
0.6222389340400696,
-0.9107232093811035,
-0.7592088580131531,
0.35394999384880066,
-0.27542686462402344,
-0.062120355665683746,
0.726070761680603,
0.4405149519443512,
-0.0038690376095473766,
1.1926790475845337,
0.39572885632514954,
0.23144415020942688,
0.14119188487529755,
-0.07066187262535095,
0.27519771456718445,
-1.0964038372039795,
-0.10126745700836182,
-0.6737021207809448,
-0.2487412542104721,
-0.7059387564659119,
-0.6013012528419495,
0.39749768376350403,
0.4268280863761902,
-0.012326912023127079,
0.4721573293209076,
-0.2568816840648651,
0.33527445793151855,
0.5121198892593384,
-0.20381978154182434,
0.5148094892501831,
-0.17652402818202972,
-0.6191613078117371,
-0.47816577553749084,
-0.5870246887207031,
-1.1290202140808105,
1.1457140445709229,
0.4278358519077301,
0.40398460626602173,
0.08016413450241089,
0.34139806032180786,
0.15872858464717865,
0.38714492321014404,
-0.7718517184257507,
0.21339429914951324,
-0.471664696931839,
-0.5998489856719971,
-0.3131106495857239,
-0.7116416096687317,
-0.7414122819900513,
0.6972600817680359,
-0.3294064402580261,
-0.376478374004364,
-0.30023494362831116,
-0.11597447842359543,
-0.4511916935443878,
-0.0528428740799427,
-0.5829091668128967,
1.1952624320983887,
-0.2263479232788086,
-0.16205598413944244,
-0.23047785460948944,
-0.4787556529045105,
0.5218618512153625,
-0.4710462689399719,
0.31196486949920654,
-0.5000362992286682,
-0.018806645646691322,
0.6235824227333069,
-0.05706563964486122,
0.30587518215179443,
0.05008558928966522,
0.14344249665737152,
0.1307697296142578,
0.27260443568229675,
0.08469102531671524,
0.003244563704356551,
-0.3642731308937073,
0.2860618233680725,
0.5769288539886475,
-0.3534989655017853,
-0.7108659148216248,
0.6085887551307678,
-0.7414615154266357,
-0.19452503323554993,
-0.13546501100063324,
-0.7294753789901733,
-0.06398502737283707,
0.40191319584846497,
0.13343575596809387,
0.13222017884254456,
-0.21334606409072876,
0.14305901527404785,
-0.0160822831094265,
-0.4606565237045288,
-0.12746749818325043,
0.5479393005371094,
-0.4519583582878113,
-0.7811994552612305,
0.9729220867156982,
0.3196156322956085,
0.4075438678264618,
0.3411155939102173,
0.26656532287597656,
-0.4967624545097351,
-0.3481144607067108,
-0.8886127471923828,
0.09745756536722183,
-0.7256325483322144,
-0.33611661195755005,
-0.622320830821991,
-0.08569798618555069,
-0.16254884004592896,
0.2040266990661621,
-0.6673738360404968,
-0.6094229221343994,
0.13809634745121002,
0.19413328170776367,
-0.13759149610996246,
0.7625464200973511,
0.19859327375888824,
0.4628136456012726,
-1.1967724561691284,
0.24821697175502777,
-0.17169693112373352,
0.3487148582935333,
-0.030450019985437393,
-0.7129106521606445,
-0.7228800058364868,
0.18221502006053925,
-0.6053420305252075,
-0.6541135907173157,
0.3640676736831665,
-0.18575310707092285,
0.6634773015975952,
0.1775193214416504,
-0.028491493314504623,
0.574722945690155,
-0.7105107307434082,
0.6132928729057312,
0.19010698795318604,
-0.9706922173500061,
0.16895656287670135,
-0.016375644132494926,
0.5060138702392578,
0.5983024835586548,
0.4056263864040375,
-0.8436970114707947,
-0.25377196073532104,
-0.42318782210350037,
-0.5391274094581604,
0.510382890701294,
0.005850738845765591,
-0.02007480524480343,
0.13366208970546722,
0.46779733896255493,
0.27309852838516235,
0.5652337074279785,
-0.6087808609008789,
-0.3397867679595947,
-0.36150744557380676,
-0.27522867918014526,
-0.33550387620925903,
-0.5204031467437744,
0.25815919041633606,
0.0656733289361,
0.5844639539718628,
-0.011655242182314396,
0.1730160266160965,
-0.122216135263443,
-0.1433192789554596,
-0.159551739692688,
0.25716519355773926,
0.6611204147338867,
0.5179566144943237,
-0.0964903011918068,
0.21187067031860352,
0.13302834331989288,
-0.24363332986831665,
0.3972449004650116,
-0.03683070093393326,
-0.12262137234210968,
0.17790886759757996,
0.29259273409843445,
0.47152259945869446,
0.3489551544189453,
-0.3756023347377777,
0.31656143069267273,
0.02666495367884636,
-0.1571480631828308,
0.015445424243807793,
-0.42054516077041626,
0.18524080514907837,
0.38177743554115295,
0.07693861424922943,
0.17396950721740723,
0.1592080444097519,
-0.33142778277397156,
0.2556900382041931,
0.1734674870967865,
-0.5601825714111328,
-0.4167514443397522,
0.6415239572525024,
0.1355670988559723,
-0.24172073602676392,
0.5838432908058167,
-0.5892692804336548,
-0.6401793956756592,
0.2218242585659027,
0.36730143427848816,
0.8042725324630737,
-0.5407186150550842,
0.09162500500679016,
0.5052606463432312,
0.4993446469306946,
-0.10048624873161316,
0.2549901008605957,
0.5032192468643188,
-0.6459875702857971,
-0.6255946159362793,
-0.7621439695358276,
-0.23569710552692413,
0.006731885951012373,
-0.5740343332290649,
0.155406653881073,
-0.0776633769273758,
-0.3705827295780182,
0.001470409333705902,
0.37489190697669983,
-0.6541286706924438,
0.20590585470199585,
-0.3341144621372223,
0.6112465858459473,
-0.853155791759491,
0.9873372316360474,
0.728879988193512,
-0.6399490833282471,
-0.4640171229839325,
-0.09259172528982162,
0.08023950457572937,
-0.5897994041442871,
0.5137349367141724,
0.22098608314990997,
-0.24857188761234283,
0.049129437655210495,
0.13708847761154175,
-0.9175799489021301,
1.0625427961349487,
0.32544684410095215,
-0.22335480153560638,
0.39414671063423157,
0.24545666575431824,
0.5324650406837463,
-0.6093472838401794,
0.1854793280363083,
0.6514743566513062,
0.5501874089241028,
-0.3263663649559021,
-1.0241426229476929,
0.1494266539812088,
-0.17158982157707214,
0.14438116550445557,
0.27593904733657837,
-0.7481271624565125,
0.8140026926994324,
-0.0037200050428509712,
-0.2668832838535309,
0.26396387815475464,
0.406931072473526,
0.14795081317424774,
0.3908384144306183,
0.280954509973526,
0.4992727041244507,
0.6384081244468689,
-0.033274080604314804,
0.989562451839447,
-0.46506261825561523,
0.3516370952129364,
1.15200674533844,
-0.0798206627368927,
0.9255576133728027,
0.403899222612381,
-0.33211299777030945,
0.08017289638519287,
0.591319739818573,
-0.09899314492940903,
0.4292726218700409,
0.42677268385887146,
0.11522950977087021,
-0.2126370519399643,
-0.24451853334903717,
-0.23083996772766113,
0.533966064453125,
0.029463455080986023,
-0.46645835041999817,
0.014578879810869694,
0.012700367718935013,
-0.002660817466676235,
0.32277435064315796,
-0.053793203085660934,
0.391411691904068,
0.24804136157035828,
-0.4919746518135071,
0.5161982774734497,
0.5859840512275696,
0.35680118203163147,
-0.046418387442827225,
0.06345813721418381,
-0.16760379076004028,
0.25043120980262756,
-0.13464666903018951,
-0.5692203640937805,
0.4705289304256439,
-0.20538091659545898,
-0.6051282286643982,
-0.2798647880554199,
0.22483427822589874,
-0.5361254215240479,
-0.6964906454086304,
0.25372207164764404,
1.008098840713501,
0.5037583112716675,
-0.27736666798591614,
-0.8714557886123657,
0.0797860324382782,
-0.054441750049591064,
-0.1414748728275299,
0.3922460675239563,
0.795870304107666,
-0.0803670808672905,
0.6957351565361023,
0.5940293669700623,
-0.2761545181274414,
0.00236919685266912,
0.05934177339076996,
0.40918242931365967,
-0.6592295169830322,
-0.1723404824733734,
-0.8861703276634216,
0.4496361315250397,
0.2614534795284271,
-0.42906996607780457,
0.9886319637298584,
0.617729127407074,
0.8321380019187927,
-0.22737158834934235,
0.652934193611145,
0.455424964427948,
0.5649919509887695,
-0.5584390163421631,
0.7389042973518372,
-0.711602509021759,
0.1598644107580185,
-0.4103122055530548,
-1.0452783107757568,
-0.4366048276424408,
0.6626294255256653,
-0.08039162307977676,
0.09430492669343948,
1.0199742317199707,
0.5395757555961609,
0.039415162056684494,
-0.14053262770175934,
0.7365796566009521,
0.028053265064954758,
0.10070886462926865,
0.4838285744190216,
0.967056155204773,
-0.9080530405044556,
0.8060782551765442,
-0.034668415784835815,
-0.20033413171768188,
-0.3516180217266083,
-0.8999359011650085,
-0.6760424375534058,
-0.5796388387680054,
-0.29587388038635254,
-0.4248655438423157,
-0.26570335030555725,
0.9983974695205688,
0.5832955837249756,
-0.7353307604789734,
-0.37122011184692383,
0.6210117340087891,
0.15799938142299652,
-0.5799134373664856,
-0.12147016823291779,
0.3652198016643524,
-0.39399319887161255,
-0.7961359024047852,
0.3316883444786072,
0.32960355281829834,
0.026573574170470238,
-0.37085673213005066,
-0.25557422637939453,
-0.07788565754890442,
-0.12546208500862122,
0.7267751693725586,
-0.43746253848075867,
-0.8285309672355652,
-0.14480064809322357,
0.1535661220550537,
-0.41060909628868103,
0.007422099355608225,
0.6195971369743347,
-0.28775402903556824,
0.542203426361084,
0.2894700765609741,
0.6053515672683716,
0.3229179382324219,
0.055926915258169174,
0.6986190676689148,
-0.5700414776802063,
-0.20113110542297363,
-0.031240880489349365,
0.2386246621608734,
0.23405715823173523,
-0.0010413810377940536,
0.5883251428604126,
0.1414436250925064,
-0.6904343366622925,
-0.669181227684021,
0.18228350579738617,
-0.4742274582386017,
-0.1691768765449524,
0.7759807109832764,
-0.5029081702232361,
-0.05790383368730545,
-0.18620477616786957,
-0.18422535061836243,
0.2928243577480316,
-0.12780089676380157,
0.8224272131919861,
1.0173869132995605,
0.06696983426809311,
-0.15115705132484436,
-1.210198163986206,
0.4029388129711151,
0.35857653617858887,
-0.6328222751617432,
-0.00719941733404994,
0.2989462912082672,
0.027508608996868134,
0.44526830315589905,
0.3891361355781555,
-0.3502754271030426,
0.244196817278862,
0.08913211524486542,
0.23986980319023132,
-0.12070849537849426,
-0.4050752818584442,
-0.3369710445404053,
0.06475581228733063,
0.28127261996269226,
-0.38901740312576294
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15459v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15459v1
|
Assessing effect sizes, variability, and power in the on-line study of language production
| 2024-03-19T11:49:03 | 2024-03-19T11:49:03 |
Bürki Audrey, Vasishth Shravan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
With the pandemic, many experimental psychologists and linguists have started
to collect data over the internet (hereafter on-line data). The feasibility of
such experiments and the sample sizes required to achieve sufficient
statistical power in future experiments have to be assessed. This in turn
requires information on effect sizes and variability. In a series of analyses,
we compare response time data obtained in the same word production experiment
conducted in the lab and on-line. These analyses allow us to determine whether
the two settings differ in effect sizes, in the consistency of responses over
the course of the experiment, in the variability of average response times
across participants, in the magnitude of effect sizes across participants, or
in the amount of unexplained variability. We assess the impact of these
differences on the power of the design in a series of simulations. Our findings
temper the enthusiasm raised by previous studies and suggest that on-line
production studies might be feasible but at a non-negligible cost. The sample
sizes required to achieve sufficient power in on-line language production
studies come with a non-negligible increase in the amount of manual labour.
|
[
-0.6215669512748718,
-0.7721381783485413,
0.27222344279289246,
0.7028932571411133,
0.09170511364936829,
-0.1553400605916977,
-0.5441755056381226,
-0.7128031253814697,
0.8065871596336365,
0.3738991320133209,
-0.18266603350639343,
0.4078386127948761,
-0.7411003708839417,
0.5394898056983948,
-0.5172954201698303,
0.6917809844017029,
0.10351254045963287,
0.22477945685386658,
-0.0315355621278286,
0.018968040123581886,
-0.1894083321094513,
-0.26583608984947205,
-0.6429630517959595,
-0.043215058743953705,
0.6238328218460083,
0.6459206342697144,
0.7995713949203491,
0.6909690499305725,
0.872522234916687,
0.2039480209350586,
0.13799147307872772,
-0.20610223710536957,
-0.6029204726219177,
0.17918504774570465,
0.18091553449630737,
-0.44278183579444885,
-0.5749279260635376,
0.24776461720466614,
0.6711930632591248,
0.8527942895889282,
-0.05950714275240898,
0.3095303177833557,
0.0783899649977684,
0.3107517659664154,
-0.6671737432479858,
-0.2310386747121811,
-0.35072028636932373,
0.20718534290790558,
-0.08780910819768906,
-0.12105449289083481,
-0.41901013255119324,
-0.5066672563552856,
0.1515236347913742,
-0.5977228283882141,
0.32693153619766235,
0.05137375369668007,
0.6830747723579407,
0.06399276107549667,
0.03299122303724289,
-0.3781719505786896,
-1.0325664281845093,
0.6908321976661682,
-0.9630767107009888,
0.2910345494747162,
0.6529696583747864,
0.23833683133125305,
-0.08293129503726959,
-0.9753739237785339,
-0.5827978849411011,
-0.1555449217557907,
0.21421976387500763,
0.229808509349823,
-0.3707740604877472,
-0.04948246106505394,
0.5991100072860718,
0.4837554693222046,
-0.4316723048686981,
0.15222157537937164,
-0.48744526505470276,
0.0888674408197403,
0.6692835688591003,
0.08693789690732956,
0.48179343342781067,
0.14014731347560883,
0.2826288938522339,
-0.09096018970012665,
-0.3426584005355835,
-0.2466345578432083,
0.4440723657608032,
0.3721480071544647,
0.06351567804813385,
0.7244425415992737,
-0.35812464356422424,
0.3754454255104065,
0.15559306740760803,
-0.13681073486804962,
-0.18398544192314148,
-0.6498565673828125,
-0.2508280575275421,
0.13131731748580933,
0.8547940254211426,
0.5380088090896606,
0.07561413198709488,
-0.11554528027772903,
-0.03485216572880745,
-0.0965336486697197,
0.27492770552635193,
-0.9925085306167603,
-0.18326517939567566,
0.009624885395169258,
-0.25253424048423767,
0.00045744626550003886,
0.09862443804740906,
-1.0777281522750854,
-0.41488805413246155,
0.04410721734166145,
0.6073797345161438,
0.00641085347160697,
-0.27483341097831726,
0.13533730804920197,
-0.5805879831314087,
0.2685387432575226,
0.10138780623674393,
-0.8259488940238953,
0.6559492945671082,
0.05747467279434204,
0.970511794090271,
0.12553942203521729,
-0.15966123342514038,
-0.5445267558097839,
-0.4528052806854248,
-0.4072326421737671,
0.6604801416397095,
-0.32942381501197815,
-0.5911997556686401,
0.03135518357157707,
-0.35735753178596497,
0.022362329065799713,
-0.3581383526325226,
0.12354622036218643,
-0.09282513707876205,
0.368072509765625,
-0.4453714191913605,
-0.5919267535209656,
0.4508197605609894,
-0.27200841903686523,
-0.7278552055358887,
0.6449213624000549,
0.05494677275419235,
-1.0061475038528442,
0.5271012783050537,
-0.6759195327758789,
-0.6463505625724792,
-0.023359086364507675,
-0.28310513496398926,
-0.40141308307647705,
0.454170286655426,
-0.2890070974826813,
0.13838322460651398,
-0.26927822828292847,
-0.3541427254676819,
-0.38314124941825867,
-0.24399295449256897,
0.69513338804245,
-0.29891547560691833,
0.7842755913734436,
0.2608034610748291,
-0.7688584327697754,
-0.37637317180633545,
-0.910079836845398,
0.16513387858867645,
0.20760071277618408,
-0.5247445106506348,
-0.19015423953533173,
0.25910574197769165,
0.22672702372074127,
0.11497397720813751,
-0.01650521717965603,
-0.8901458382606506,
0.1622302383184433,
-0.3305855393409729,
0.13048520684242249,
0.1690208464860916,
0.03667673096060753,
0.2149008959531784,
-0.36528047919273376,
0.658844530582428,
-0.8117014169692993,
0.4252844750881195,
0.5011530518531799,
-0.7279912829399109,
-0.8687652349472046,
0.0007287086918950081,
0.5156518816947937,
0.4251159727573395,
-0.42798376083374023,
0.17309248447418213,
-0.21575388312339783,
-0.6821582317352295,
-0.3382182717323303,
-0.08701112121343613,
0.31383389234542847,
-0.15001650154590607,
0.03983430191874504,
-0.874853253364563,
-0.7815291285514832,
-0.8033406138420105,
-0.40847882628440857,
0.08518966287374496,
-0.4407591223716736,
0.13916046917438507,
0.2627168595790863,
-0.00022047734819352627,
1.2491421699523926,
-0.6485917568206787,
-0.10339709371328354,
-0.6180055737495422,
0.6809976696968079,
-0.2518547773361206,
0.10205543786287308,
0.5064870119094849,
-0.30676794052124023,
-0.5780707597732544,
-0.13041900098323822,
-0.4893769323825836,
-0.7038247585296631,
0.06735661625862122,
0.40179136395454407,
0.12541773915290833,
0.39061471819877625,
-0.2095898985862732,
0.5914992094039917,
0.6250125169754028,
-0.14926888048648834,
0.49920740723609924,
-0.6533874869346619,
0.14361067116260529,
-0.9761195778846741,
0.0705464705824852,
-0.0005866179126314819,
0.0988258421421051,
-1.0811561346054077,
-0.18192651867866516,
-0.05908772721886635,
-0.18921047449111938,
-0.35874685645103455,
0.07818492501974106,
-0.4282740652561188,
-0.4345110356807709,
-0.5751603841781616,
0.36425772309303284,
0.033600833266973495,
0.025372399017214775,
-0.3284379839897156,
0.6372793316841125,
0.02185063809156418,
-0.484230101108551,
0.18379858136177063,
-0.11592800170183182,
-0.4400843679904938,
0.12932640314102173,
-0.6765245795249939,
-0.06991495937108994,
0.07460163533687592,
0.26382994651794434,
-0.9944546818733215,
-0.6111664772033691,
-0.073862224817276,
-0.3924946188926697,
0.015611750073730946,
0.5986851453781128,
-0.5237656831741333,
-0.23149564862251282,
-0.4875792860984802,
0.0949939638376236,
0.33284512162208557,
0.09127138555049896,
0.39843642711639404,
0.4825485050678253,
-0.11904148012399673,
-0.10038484632968903,
-1.0021799802780151,
0.1329651027917862,
-0.3850184679031372,
-0.4664563834667206,
-0.09648347645998001,
-0.2824789881706238,
-1.009660243988037,
-0.31878283619880676,
-0.06732770055532455,
-0.31237146258354187,
0.27201375365257263,
0.20364803075790405,
-0.2579403221607208,
-0.11045148968696594,
0.11407258361577988,
-0.2426900416612625,
0.3719418942928314,
0.2719290554523468,
0.40771859884262085,
0.3521539270877838,
0.037081893533468246,
-0.11557208001613617,
-0.3121068775653839,
0.5360042452812195,
0.7156847715377808,
0.13235965371131897,
0.7188025712966919,
0.3729102313518524,
-0.3105647563934326,
-0.12844093143939972,
-0.4791518747806549,
-0.35747602581977844,
-0.4442533850669861,
0.0416250117123127,
-0.07969250530004501,
-0.47890621423721313,
0.40863198041915894,
0.08710212260484695,
0.1305375099182129,
0.6200019121170044,
0.2669402062892914,
0.1329781860113144,
0.9534004330635071,
0.6623234152793884,
0.4433588981628418,
0.6189864277839661,
-0.039933450520038605,
0.3049626648426056,
-0.5224114656448364,
0.2196468859910965,
-0.7791678309440613,
-0.25803348422050476,
-0.6162763237953186,
-0.17724062502384186,
0.35412895679473877,
0.14338041841983795,
-0.01191730983555317,
0.31471699476242065,
-0.11368363350629807,
0.39521440863609314,
0.42807674407958984,
-0.1454547643661499,
0.32718944549560547,
-0.06331861764192581,
0.18572551012039185,
0.07125836610794067,
-0.7968993186950684,
-0.3764747977256775,
1.186503529548645,
0.10475529730319977,
0.5567371845245361,
0.30959847569465637,
0.17221161723136902,
0.43921032547950745,
0.1815214604139328,
-0.7638371586799622,
0.4726819396018982,
-0.021377133205533028,
-0.44519662857055664,
-0.5240916013717651,
-0.27103391289711,
-1.3733296394348145,
0.020323429256677628,
-0.44678765535354614,
-0.8030451536178589,
0.09207621961832047,
0.02100774459540844,
-0.5322425365447998,
0.14079013466835022,
-0.9584718346595764,
0.49491265416145325,
-0.15433873236179352,
-0.22347691655158997,
-0.3682381212711334,
-0.702267050743103,
0.05205263942480087,
-0.5323574542999268,
0.4873242974281311,
0.07487514615058899,
0.21385613083839417,
1.0401469469070435,
-0.5358878970146179,
1.0328278541564941,
0.3302902579307556,
0.01152097899466753,
0.23238186538219452,
-0.07959908992052078,
0.09880873560905457,
-0.26686152815818787,
-0.09650972485542297,
0.09502346068620682,
-0.04623664170503616,
-0.5321152210235596,
-0.4208888113498688,
0.5255078077316284,
-0.9131367206573486,
-0.6568931341171265,
-0.4316621422767639,
-0.587731659412384,
-0.23963190615177155,
-0.010127251967787743,
0.73395836353302,
0.6863178014755249,
-0.4011532664299011,
0.4271080195903778,
0.4365631937980652,
-0.3150123953819275,
0.6977452039718628,
0.5190221667289734,
-0.6615782976150513,
-0.3536696135997772,
0.8071954250335693,
0.9134156703948975,
0.9371749758720398,
0.16834118962287903,
0.6906188130378723,
0.024788429960608482,
-0.1001734733581543,
-0.29781413078308105,
0.15033593773841858,
-0.5470253229141235,
0.4709935486316681,
-0.41845956444740295,
-0.12150420993566513,
-0.5561051368713379,
0.018744967877864838,
-0.45746123790740967,
-0.5570741891860962,
-0.09611966460943222,
0.22238245606422424,
0.5015511512756348,
1.278298020362854,
-0.36809632182121277,
0.39628100395202637,
-0.4234253764152527,
-0.051777392625808716,
0.5590830445289612,
0.3469521999359131,
-0.06645016372203827,
-0.3685290515422821,
-0.4356931447982788,
0.15276266634464264,
-0.496201753616333,
-1.0944701433181763,
0.25993192195892334,
0.2531067728996277,
0.35053494572639465,
0.5278325080871582,
0.21789231896400452,
0.21699030697345734,
-0.23570385575294495,
0.9568055868148804,
0.2071487009525299,
-0.9496283531188965,
0.47197216749191284,
-0.24284730851650238,
0.4244227707386017,
0.05582938343286514,
0.3988591432571411,
-0.6268900632858276,
-0.7806286215782166,
-0.9664477705955505,
-0.7983815670013428,
0.5032147765159607,
0.5957499146461487,
-0.2529298961162567,
0.0025251007173210382,
-0.1012270376086235,
0.16561980545520782,
0.09331530332565308,
-0.13660471141338348,
-0.23604217171669006,
-0.19758370518684387,
0.41307970881462097,
-0.1135115697979927,
0.059641122817993164,
-0.07998868823051453,
-0.18484613299369812,
0.4319849908351898,
0.080693818628788,
0.25625160336494446,
0.3570321798324585,
0.17811544239521027,
-0.39374592900276184,
0.33791619539260864,
0.8230285048484802,
1.1703883409500122,
-0.3223656415939331,
0.30529239773750305,
0.5465895533561707,
-0.7537269592285156,
-0.206767275929451,
-0.3737165331840515,
0.10187743604183197,
0.2538226842880249,
0.4281839430332184,
0.7637800574302673,
-0.0549420565366745,
-0.7724207043647766,
0.45361801981925964,
-0.4088946282863617,
-0.3009379506111145,
-0.13946260511875153,
0.08245140314102173,
-0.13170208036899567,
0.04878992587327957,
0.2691044211387634,
-0.09481538832187653,
0.06658509373664856,
-0.586268424987793,
0.03400221839547157,
0.13493385910987854,
-0.04898384213447571,
-0.27363601326942444,
0.23311109840869904,
0.0689002126455307,
-0.8473946452140808,
0.40997686982154846,
-0.08416851609945297,
-0.09046324342489243,
0.911617636680603,
0.8086381554603577,
0.46627479791641235,
-0.4012647271156311,
0.20147456228733063,
-0.009997538290917873,
0.29362839460372925,
-0.4208613336086273,
0.3547897934913635,
0.4550122320652008,
-0.49300727248191833,
-0.23983748257160187,
-0.440151572227478,
-0.7304807901382446,
0.47867584228515625,
-0.8064654469490051,
-0.08134818822145462,
-0.5359567999839783,
-0.5566837787628174,
0.09410197287797928,
-0.03844495862722397,
-0.4489654302597046,
0.19443358480930328,
-0.13351452350616455,
0.5800917744636536,
-0.9312276840209961,
0.5420510172843933,
0.4095039665699005,
-0.5296422243118286,
-0.8517025709152222,
0.44547006487846375,
0.013974059373140335,
-0.27355802059173584,
0.45776811242103577,
0.13718128204345703,
-0.06728603690862656,
-0.04255305603146553,
-0.22613641619682312,
-1.022843360900879,
0.7716412544250488,
0.1816062480211258,
-0.4229862093925476,
0.5573498606681824,
0.3972664177417755,
0.8769615292549133,
-0.207468643784523,
0.37704432010650635,
0.6637035012245178,
0.4976171851158142,
-0.26158300042152405,
-1.3919099569320679,
-0.23395223915576935,
-0.16793043911457062,
-0.07473127543926239,
0.2892778813838959,
-0.5470175743103027,
0.9311145544052124,
0.050631068646907806,
-0.43656617403030396,
-0.18823426961898804,
0.44119712710380554,
-0.29900383949279785,
0.10711107403039932,
0.46645981073379517,
0.4152275025844574,
0.7332489490509033,
0.11463804543018341,
1.305992841720581,
-0.3136100172996521,
0.4430648982524872,
0.9024662375450134,
-0.22459043562412262,
1.0784894227981567,
0.6544398069381714,
-0.48203980922698975,
0.11632499098777771,
0.5132527351379395,
0.2114240676164627,
0.21752546727657318,
0.83609539270401,
-0.26013416051864624,
0.008153092116117477,
-0.4580896198749542,
-0.47194311022758484,
0.22570717334747314,
0.2785969376564026,
-0.19450721144676208,
-0.07256808876991272,
0.5081309676170349,
0.11317172646522522,
-0.045509759336709976,
-0.22174781560897827,
0.41576704382896423,
0.11009177565574646,
-0.5583986043930054,
0.47124966979026794,
0.0430561788380146,
0.26398733258247375,
-0.609306812286377,
0.4454805850982666,
-0.39218807220458984,
0.46510249376296997,
-0.12737223505973816,
-0.6109216809272766,
0.5707027316093445,
0.09867262840270996,
-0.006271862890571356,
-0.11077548563480377,
0.4556945562362671,
-0.03736582398414612,
-0.44955843687057495,
0.2978995740413666,
0.7086895704269409,
0.5441494584083557,
0.1438341587781906,
0.04769064486026764,
0.3059456944465637,
-0.26484498381614685,
-0.32311755418777466,
0.5536115765571594,
0.27110394835472107,
0.07850582897663116,
0.3613153398036957,
0.23260147869586945,
0.44522392749786377,
0.45030486583709717,
0.2546958327293396,
0.4175047278404236,
-0.3176947832107544,
-0.20332515239715576,
-0.6968510746955872,
-0.053209900856018066,
-0.3169132471084595,
-0.7044661641120911,
1.1147583723068237,
0.5368847846984863,
0.8318358659744263,
-0.17042794823646545,
0.9600801467895508,
-0.4571581482887268,
0.16307969391345978,
-0.027798043563961983,
0.5062087774276733,
-0.6059636473655701,
-0.012878628447651863,
-0.21565626561641693,
-0.6996712684631348,
-0.4008672535419464,
0.4832797646522522,
-0.4051799774169922,
-0.3629656136035919,
1.088608741760254,
0.5387474298477173,
0.07746359705924988,
0.33766674995422363,
0.25437256693840027,
0.3455481231212616,
0.23167236149311066,
0.07658392190933228,
0.5847982168197632,
-0.36231669783592224,
0.4949154555797577,
-0.25861459970474243,
-0.5697236657142639,
-0.32114359736442566,
-0.8581094741821289,
-0.7477381229400635,
-0.41253387928009033,
-0.12930713593959808,
-0.35297876596450806,
-0.22608326375484467,
1.2260793447494507,
0.006271844729781151,
-0.5453686118125916,
-0.814433753490448,
-0.18252453207969666,
-0.37246108055114746,
-0.49310457706451416,
-0.19530533254146576,
0.22322674095630646,
-0.1850314736366272,
-0.6350178718566895,
0.2940603494644165,
0.15776054561138153,
-0.01000075601041317,
-0.39443206787109375,
0.10059065371751785,
-0.4057026505470276,
0.7119059562683105,
0.5277470350265503,
0.4148300886154175,
-0.7648617029190063,
-0.44912585616111755,
0.07562145590782166,
-0.39025071263313293,
0.03328040614724159,
0.8418093323707581,
-0.1396426260471344,
0.6072725057601929,
0.9905346035957336,
0.5728285312652588,
0.20853587985038757,
-0.4350937306880951,
0.9014462232589722,
-0.6289939284324646,
-0.39737677574157715,
-0.27617064118385315,
0.4461122155189514,
0.21049997210502625,
-0.14273610711097717,
0.42329588532447815,
0.40315690636634827,
-0.8093116879463196,
-0.5539551973342896,
0.20196428894996643,
-0.7987846732139587,
-0.3953750729560852,
1.274484634399414,
-0.08780962973833084,
0.18884024024009705,
-0.27620163559913635,
-0.22573359310626984,
0.7605502605438232,
-0.22254125773906708,
1.2168956995010376,
1.0930784940719604,
-0.43082454800605774,
0.33403274416923523,
-0.7980455160140991,
0.3575580418109894,
0.3573876917362213,
-0.9139786958694458,
0.05275316908955574,
0.3115590214729309,
0.04497097432613373,
0.6078983545303345,
0.5226501226425171,
0.49049657583236694,
-0.04195244237780571,
0.4264484643936157,
-0.012040299363434315,
0.5111951231956482,
-0.22735965251922607,
-0.18635481595993042,
0.4383988082408905,
0.12845896184444427,
0.07103977352380753
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15458v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15458v1
|
Fine-Tuning Pre-trained Language Models to Detect In-Game Trash Talks
| 2024-03-19T11:36:53 | 2024-03-19T11:36:53 |
Daniel Fesalbon, Arvin De La Cruz, Marvin Mallari, Nelson Rodelas
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Common problems in playing online mobile and computer games were related to
toxic behavior and abusive communication among players. Based on different
reports and studies, the study also discusses the impact of online hate speech
and toxicity on players' in-game performance and overall well-being. This study
investigates the capability of pre-trained language models to classify or
detect trash talk or toxic in-game messages The study employs and evaluates the
performance of pre-trained BERT and GPT language models in detecting toxicity
within in-game chats. Using publicly available APIs, in-game chat data from
DOTA 2 game matches were collected, processed, reviewed, and labeled as
non-toxic, mild (toxicity), and toxic. The study was able to collect around two
thousand in-game chats to train and test BERT (Base-uncased), BERT
(Large-uncased), and GPT-3 models. Based on the three models' state-of-the-art
performance, this study concludes pre-trained language models' promising
potential for addressing online hate speech and in-game insulting trash talk.
|
[
-0.3010193705558777,
-0.9217721223831177,
0.3810885548591614,
0.02592705935239792,
-0.23308594524860382,
-0.1405976414680481,
-0.12598104774951935,
-0.8214730620384216,
-0.18814173340797424,
0.5692237615585327,
-0.5573365688323975,
-0.2973017394542694,
-0.6701361536979675,
-0.07081504166126251,
-0.3109070956707001,
1.3510191440582275,
0.4778387248516083,
0.26560676097869873,
-0.14899437129497528,
0.020614003762602806,
-0.7715091109275818,
-0.7193464636802673,
-0.9143556356430054,
-0.2935698926448822,
0.3246217370033264,
0.4852175712585449,
0.7786263823509216,
0.15981584787368774,
0.8060950040817261,
0.3539925515651703,
-0.21992725133895874,
-0.05394025892019272,
-1.031389832496643,
0.29496482014656067,
-0.2478737235069275,
-0.3476048707962036,
-0.5458261966705322,
0.12079393118619919,
0.10473193973302841,
-0.15648441016674042,
-0.018808607012033463,
0.31813034415245056,
0.23146313428878784,
0.11497674882411957,
-0.42551591992378235,
0.22465895116329193,
-0.8086802363395691,
-0.06525544077157974,
-0.2747599482536316,
-0.18116098642349243,
-0.414305716753006,
-0.40295758843421936,
0.2532704174518585,
-0.5023354291915894,
-0.25613150000572205,
-0.4617878794670105,
1.044141411781311,
0.2736968696117401,
-0.13167890906333923,
-0.6971134543418884,
-0.9568870067596436,
0.7943356037139893,
-1.243427038192749,
0.10551194846630096,
0.6773622035980225,
0.3587874472141266,
-0.17715448141098022,
-0.3053808808326721,
-0.6192666888237,
-0.2584684491157532,
-0.10974416881799698,
0.13302744925022125,
-0.3445642292499542,
0.2083437740802765,
0.16165494918823242,
0.007251839619129896,
-0.41564416885375977,
0.5895265936851501,
-0.42348548769950867,
-0.09255039691925049,
0.6372146606445312,
0.26552456617355347,
0.4471515119075775,
0.1175585463643074,
-0.09895741939544678,
0.1724424511194229,
-0.6407894492149353,
-0.13417454063892365,
0.5078208446502686,
0.2605415880680084,
0.023581581190228462,
0.20066173374652863,
0.07606620341539383,
0.5236324071884155,
0.0818604975938797,
-0.18914589285850525,
0.1273983120918274,
-0.3089045584201813,
-0.10409962385892868,
-0.27101942896842957,
0.5929712653160095,
0.7356997132301331,
0.6085246205329895,
-0.07729627937078476,
-0.2351335883140564,
0.14987407624721527,
0.28132420778274536,
-1.1296107769012451,
-0.4767877161502838,
0.18432797491550446,
-0.7435944080352783,
-0.6173539757728577,
-0.6001676917076111,
-0.7030571699142456,
-0.823878824710846,
-0.0802006945014,
0.7360326647758484,
-0.30252236127853394,
-0.58607417345047,
-0.12580963969230652,
-0.051080863922834396,
0.10696142166852951,
0.09523490071296692,
-0.7727957963943481,
0.30609002709388733,
0.4330670237541199,
0.5059937238693237,
0.03943274915218353,
-0.04810379445552826,
-0.41711941361427307,
-0.1968187540769577,
-0.13347642123699188,
0.9817018508911133,
-0.7727689146995544,
-0.2917594015598297,
0.1785927265882492,
-0.4782164394855499,
0.2585023045539856,
-0.6974579095840454,
0.8652481436729431,
-0.468138188123703,
0.31874319911003113,
-0.26168423891067505,
-0.7814887762069702,
-0.18240800499916077,
0.2975655496120453,
-0.3161046802997589,
0.6975482106208801,
-0.07886285334825516,
-0.7437655329704285,
0.5548754930496216,
-0.8344749212265015,
-0.3859972357749939,
0.21263542771339417,
0.28260019421577454,
-0.6550556421279907,
0.02761818654835224,
0.12159575521945953,
0.6013917326927185,
-0.1320050060749054,
-0.10374010354280472,
-0.577339768409729,
-0.6145879030227661,
0.35902324318885803,
-0.18441414833068848,
0.6775019764900208,
0.5152134299278259,
-0.3824540972709656,
0.4090017080307007,
-0.4230794608592987,
0.24218972027301788,
-0.07697103917598724,
-0.33167019486427307,
-0.3975854516029358,
0.6906553506851196,
-0.020131252706050873,
0.5981156826019287,
-0.10459918528795242,
-0.6486741304397583,
-0.3784027695655823,
-0.4788050055503845,
0.515143096446991,
0.6515259146690369,
-0.16904646158218384,
0.24430547654628754,
-0.3503873944282532,
0.15598826110363007,
-0.018330993130803108,
0.605338990688324,
0.1331215500831604,
-0.6006093621253967,
-0.5252840518951416,
-0.08373340964317322,
-0.1293606460094452,
0.7269561886787415,
-0.5378088355064392,
0.3559749722480774,
-0.3510415852069855,
-0.5868185758590698,
-0.31746023893356323,
-0.13635559380054474,
0.5891293883323669,
0.49463513493537903,
0.22909612953662872,
-0.2545570135116577,
-0.4569253623485565,
-0.6546832919120789,
-0.38719695806503296,
-0.4149876832962036,
0.04054165631532669,
0.7489073872566223,
0.30975303053855896,
-0.2257334440946579,
0.9733613729476929,
-0.11812207102775574,
-0.35823366045951843,
-0.12785647809505463,
0.31396225094795227,
-0.11518576741218567,
0.3023940920829773,
0.8339961767196655,
-0.571414053440094,
-0.9135181307792664,
-0.25816723704338074,
-0.44316309690475464,
-0.32223793864250183,
0.22450639307498932,
0.0895865261554718,
-0.23217301070690155,
0.5354934334754944,
-0.08192142844200134,
0.39082565903663635,
0.6661932468414307,
-0.41682788729667664,
0.3202093839645386,
-0.049634672701358795,
0.3623283803462982,
-0.6762830018997192,
-0.203970804810524,
-0.22671674191951752,
-0.20802249014377594,
-1.0434774160385132,
-0.01463567279279232,
-0.2112710028886795,
-0.28503963351249695,
-0.6942545771598816,
0.28685709834098816,
-0.30845361948013306,
0.2099839746952057,
-0.6252886652946472,
0.035200074315071106,
-0.6398321390151978,
0.3206495940685272,
0.105867899954319,
0.8391121625900269,
0.530677080154419,
-0.8076183199882507,
0.1115049496293068,
0.1945364773273468,
-0.3785015344619751,
0.7402108311653137,
-0.4306100308895111,
0.3772687613964081,
-0.03791383281350136,
0.18175363540649414,
-0.9125734567642212,
0.11602355539798737,
0.27598968148231506,
-0.5303693413734436,
-0.012393981218338013,
-0.3759184181690216,
-0.684543788433075,
-0.5038503408432007,
-0.0059370072558522224,
0.23801445960998535,
0.4602850079536438,
-0.24366261065006256,
0.2930668890476227,
0.9112932682037354,
-0.18561522662639618,
-0.2877812087535858,
-0.49603405594825745,
-0.18549895286560059,
-0.5032220482826233,
-0.6277201175689697,
-0.15631365776062012,
-0.3487612307071686,
-0.0886201485991478,
-0.28189951181411743,
0.1790030151605606,
-0.7323111295700073,
0.30659136176109314,
0.33540722727775574,
0.12737293541431427,
-0.012132925912737846,
0.2021818608045578,
-0.3191784620285034,
0.11754719913005829,
0.2652237117290497,
0.12336341291666031,
0.496194064617157,
-0.17087268829345703,
0.02069440670311451,
-0.40260007977485657,
0.21121157705783844,
0.5114091634750366,
-0.20174822211265564,
0.6847807168960571,
0.48735442757606506,
-0.17071029543876648,
-0.09612718224525452,
-0.6004415154457092,
-0.31888845562934875,
-0.4993465542793274,
0.6096730828285217,
-0.07360129058361053,
-0.966317892074585,
0.6691830158233643,
0.018470168113708496,
0.15543746948242188,
0.13332834839820862,
0.589618980884552,
-0.36526012420654297,
1.346075177192688,
0.5987540483474731,
-0.1617322862148285,
0.6808062195777893,
0.2266663759946823,
0.13409079611301422,
-0.11827000975608826,
0.13968046009540558,
-0.53163081407547,
-0.3513794243335724,
-0.5076031684875488,
-0.3665846288204193,
0.19205424189567566,
-0.13149785995483398,
-0.648664653301239,
0.07594036310911179,
-0.5266450643539429,
0.9799096584320068,
0.13772530853748322,
0.20514477789402008,
-0.07627786695957184,
-0.12402557581663132,
0.4033619165420532,
-0.2563607394695282,
-0.42845508456230164,
-0.34948307275772095,
1.046870470046997,
0.6716415882110596,
0.6008018255233765,
0.29514211416244507,
0.43457236886024475,
0.10757097601890564,
0.7534685134887695,
-0.6175622940063477,
0.3013361394405365,
-0.2402062863111496,
-1.1149940490722656,
-0.3690328896045685,
-0.3779178261756897,
-0.7696253657341003,
0.01785963401198387,
-0.4582137167453766,
-0.7382189631462097,
-0.10990003496408463,
0.27140679955482483,
-0.6628783345222473,
0.48257386684417725,
-0.90817791223526,
0.7953999042510986,
-0.16028329730033875,
0.014086135663092136,
-0.47034889459609985,
-0.5700523853302002,
0.5035879015922546,
-0.22078090906143188,
0.4095461070537567,
-0.2689448297023773,
0.3592316508293152,
0.6831544041633606,
-0.28785577416419983,
0.9248003363609314,
-0.27186986804008484,
-0.30594348907470703,
0.5157737731933594,
0.25852063298225403,
0.653047502040863,
-0.2649368345737457,
0.12930908799171448,
0.32789427042007446,
-0.08388783037662506,
-0.18204893171787262,
-0.15708106756210327,
0.5584679245948792,
-0.8023621439933777,
-0.1736462414264679,
-0.19423002004623413,
-0.3736695647239685,
-0.4457232356071472,
0.2926214635372162,
0.45153626799583435,
0.023522619158029556,
-0.3503112196922302,
-0.07370414584875107,
0.9062368273735046,
-0.5727723836898804,
0.41707196831703186,
1.015599012374878,
-0.1382715106010437,
0.08769755065441132,
0.9511845111846924,
-0.17533300817012787,
0.27550143003463745,
0.14597611129283905,
0.16552843153476715,
-0.18645156919956207,
-0.7284286022186279,
0.005345222540199757,
0.004552182741463184,
-0.5759906768798828,
-0.4591183364391327,
-0.3900356590747833,
-0.22024154663085938,
-0.18820324540138245,
0.2647528648376465,
-0.5162136554718018,
0.1847546547651291,
-0.3228518068790436,
0.03796130418777466,
0.20159220695495605,
1.2603360414505005,
-0.2664838135242462,
0.6491432189941406,
-0.9297573566436768,
-0.08211971074342728,
0.49102288484573364,
0.8783395886421204,
-0.07638514041900635,
-0.7530612945556641,
-0.25958266854286194,
0.19869041442871094,
-0.22862529754638672,
-1.1716351509094238,
0.333649218082428,
0.22308871150016785,
0.4064236581325531,
0.5804632306098938,
-0.30693918466567993,
0.6641881465911865,
-0.5158621668815613,
0.7284994125366211,
0.032719966024160385,
-0.8093487024307251,
0.5566851496696472,
-0.6865541338920593,
-0.17360009253025055,
0.5519147515296936,
0.20508840680122375,
-0.4942436218261719,
-0.5851576328277588,
-0.3593690097332001,
-0.2841707468032837,
0.8603028655052185,
0.3556521534919739,
0.37175655364990234,
-0.21250438690185547,
-0.015361634083092213,
0.008198488503694534,
0.023204529657959938,
-0.8568944334983826,
-0.48493748903274536,
-0.19244790077209473,
0.1893519014120102,
-0.07225777953863144,
-0.7643140554428101,
0.11373285949230194,
-0.26355311274528503,
0.457367867231369,
0.4441623389720917,
0.27653783559799194,
-0.5993317365646362,
-0.28152650594711304,
-0.2323950082063675,
0.32597920298576355,
0.678881049156189,
0.5194345712661743,
-0.4648537337779999,
-0.215530127286911,
0.2651830315589905,
-0.5973168015480042,
-0.04540955275297165,
-0.14194054901599884,
-0.05520636960864067,
-0.14008961617946625,
0.06520242244005203,
0.6231958866119385,
0.5127568244934082,
-0.6691142320632935,
0.8254314661026001,
-0.13498809933662415,
-0.12820187211036682,
-0.13954012095928192,
-0.10951724648475647,
-0.03176005557179451,
0.08827754110097885,
-0.1300899237394333,
0.09765788167715073,
0.3203020393848419,
-0.6268430352210999,
0.33503758907318115,
0.4955676794052124,
-0.47639185190200806,
-0.3235643208026886,
0.6217901706695557,
0.6676377654075623,
-0.0593017116189003,
0.6626381278038025,
-0.396074116230011,
-0.6995800137519836,
0.12171071022748947,
0.4540373384952545,
0.6694590449333191,
-0.37563082575798035,
0.4364102780818939,
0.49696075916290283,
0.17275306582450867,
0.20966759324073792,
0.23876358568668365,
0.30054807662963867,
-0.8685271739959717,
-0.599966287612915,
-0.48143965005874634,
-0.0061728013679385185,
0.5840180516242981,
-0.33790332078933716,
0.06532316654920578,
-0.38587599992752075,
-0.4991088807582855,
-0.05459553375840187,
0.009537672623991966,
-0.8581146001815796,
-0.015533799305558205,
0.6374136805534363,
0.5131024122238159,
-1.1645289659500122,
0.6745341420173645,
0.5537945032119751,
-0.6406076550483704,
-0.819447934627533,
-0.17458152770996094,
0.03825204819440842,
-0.6351698040962219,
1.0333236455917358,
-0.19474124908447266,
-0.02628857083618641,
0.061665333807468414,
-0.7348164916038513,
-0.9054224491119385,
0.5407101511955261,
0.2593451142311096,
-0.35257449746131897,
0.039991386234760284,
0.10457873344421387,
0.8727723956108093,
0.03585803508758545,
0.8173702955245972,
0.5779664516448975,
0.24677926301956177,
-0.03702022135257721,
-1.5587459802627563,
-0.4132094085216522,
-0.20455080270767212,
-0.14389878511428833,
0.012798825278878212,
-0.49429836869239807,
0.9054921269416809,
0.004858300089836121,
-0.6469308733940125,
-0.09718799591064453,
0.5342893600463867,
-0.09603624045848846,
-0.1199425756931305,
0.6132970452308655,
0.4971311688423157,
0.6262972950935364,
-0.1135629266500473,
0.7332318425178528,
-0.10715460032224655,
0.3605145514011383,
1.0396009683609009,
-0.09814681857824326,
0.7824719548225403,
-0.128738135099411,
0.03072005696594715,
0.5333544611930847,
0.5070459246635437,
0.18764010071754456,
0.6497904658317566,
0.4894215166568756,
-0.15286827087402344,
-0.41396939754486084,
-0.02360965497791767,
-0.3071573078632355,
0.5819658637046814,
0.5558856725692749,
-0.08104193955659866,
-0.5608855485916138,
0.27941176295280457,
0.2675479054450989,
0.16069604456424713,
-0.5055471658706665,
1.0371581315994263,
-0.33453115820884705,
-0.4267619848251343,
0.5072923302650452,
-0.1277613341808319,
1.2609449625015259,
-0.2864052355289459,
-0.09330660849809647,
-0.17937353253364563,
0.4307989478111267,
-0.04037558659911156,
-0.876887857913971,
0.19094744324684143,
0.16423262655735016,
0.03765808045864105,
-0.20712290704250336,
0.9859891533851624,
-0.30115994811058044,
0.014265825040638447,
0.2639318108558655,
0.40876996517181396,
0.5864593982696533,
-0.3685325086116791,
-0.878358006477356,
0.09936017543077469,
-0.1344926357269287,
0.22419196367263794,
0.42650189995765686,
0.4392608106136322,
0.11814969033002853,
0.7441776394844055,
0.3924393653869629,
0.19604046642780304,
0.21453452110290527,
0.07371752709150314,
0.8019165396690369,
-0.20665353536605835,
-0.6034411191940308,
-0.6326448321342468,
0.43345797061920166,
-0.201954647898674,
-0.32176557183265686,
0.7349088788032532,
0.4987742006778717,
0.8683055639266968,
-0.18291668593883514,
0.7314679622650146,
0.021117491647601128,
1.0679188966751099,
-0.038397058844566345,
1.1239134073257446,
-0.11157259345054626,
0.04191458225250244,
-0.4536482095718384,
-0.5543298125267029,
-0.11671759933233261,
0.782787561416626,
-0.37553176283836365,
0.16511736810207367,
0.3967770040035248,
0.7689164280891418,
0.04423653706908226,
-0.16247674822807312,
0.38172441720962524,
0.4556766450405121,
0.6219797730445862,
0.6848728656768799,
0.9649507999420166,
-0.18473400175571442,
0.913145899772644,
-0.01638219878077507,
-0.29833707213401794,
-0.23505516350269318,
-0.691789448261261,
-1.3050495386123657,
-0.529470682144165,
0.023971641436219215,
-0.306842178106308,
0.24017047882080078,
0.3409503400325775,
0.6614111065864563,
-0.9162105321884155,
-0.1529357135295868,
0.13146647810935974,
-0.12501899898052216,
-0.08405015617609024,
-0.2185581773519516,
0.025820977985858917,
-0.5349182486534119,
-0.6751124262809753,
0.33419209718704224,
-0.014423668384552002,
0.013089058920741081,
0.052970536053180695,
-0.19365999102592468,
-0.07243556529283524,
0.2206609547138214,
0.8573550581932068,
0.3842187821865082,
-0.48628875613212585,
-0.45204606652259827,
-0.21321281790733337,
-0.3603043854236603,
-0.09814272820949554,
0.7876148223876953,
-0.6451064348220825,
0.49614065885543823,
0.4906224310398102,
0.17436398565769196,
0.06997767090797424,
0.04169684275984764,
0.5564292669296265,
-0.6762515902519226,
0.14708681404590607,
0.5870930552482605,
-0.18806934356689453,
0.10972455143928528,
-0.26890280842781067,
0.13941259682178497,
-0.1166817918419838,
-0.7709164023399353,
-0.9236037135124207,
0.12043215334415436,
-0.32305973768234253,
-0.40153172612190247,
1.23390793800354,
0.009888100437819958,
0.3248160183429718,
-0.4252139925956726,
-0.3217281401157379,
0.3650604784488678,
-0.30128660798072815,
0.8901857733726501,
0.8228397965431213,
0.001627436256967485,
-0.018500378355383873,
-0.6783368587493896,
1.2818821668624878,
0.22370414435863495,
-0.8669010996818542,
0.21692578494548798,
0.7231073379516602,
0.4512372612953186,
0.07297655940055847,
0.9460487961769104,
-0.11284936219453812,
0.34834134578704834,
-0.08121082931756973,
-0.08946418762207031,
0.08439307659864426,
-0.04346892610192299,
-0.10401321947574615,
-0.19912926852703094,
-0.06503350287675858,
-0.1389034539461136
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.12601v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.12601v1
|
LHMKE: A Large-scale Holistic Multi-subject Knowledge Evaluation Benchmark for Chinese Large Language Models
| 2024-03-19T10:11:14 | 2024-03-19T10:11:14 |
Chuang Liu, Renren Jin, Yuqi Ren, Deyi Xiong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Chinese Large Language Models (LLMs) have recently demonstrated impressive
capabilities across various NLP benchmarks and real-world applications.
However, the existing benchmarks for comprehensively evaluating these LLMs are
still insufficient, particularly in terms of measuring knowledge that LLMs
capture. Current datasets collect questions from Chinese examinations across
different subjects and educational levels to address this issue. Yet, these
benchmarks primarily focus on objective questions such as multiple-choice
questions, leading to a lack of diversity in question types. To tackle this
problem, we propose LHMKE, a Large-scale, Holistic, and Multi-subject Knowledge
Evaluation benchmark in this paper. LHMKE is designed to provide a
comprehensive evaluation of the knowledge acquisition capabilities of Chinese
LLMs. It encompasses 10,465 questions across 75 tasks covering 30 subjects,
ranging from primary school to professional certification exams. Notably, LHMKE
includes both objective and subjective questions, offering a more holistic
evaluation of the knowledge level of LLMs. We have assessed 11 Chinese LLMs
under the zero-shot setting, which aligns with real examinations, and compared
their performance across different subjects. We also conduct an in-depth
analysis to check whether GPT-4 can automatically score subjective predictions.
Our findings suggest that LHMKE is a challenging and advanced testbed for
Chinese LLMs.
|
[
-0.2756192982196808,
-0.8066169023513794,
0.6355492472648621,
0.18564249575138092,
-0.23668533563613892,
-0.06470642238855362,
-0.6431975960731506,
-0.48236629366874695,
-0.30023959279060364,
0.378705769777298,
-0.46695995330810547,
-0.7316784262657166,
-0.3845403790473938,
0.08931120485067368,
-0.10314052551984787,
0.7310866713523865,
-0.03143319487571716,
0.03484855219721794,
-0.13787142932415009,
-0.2454855740070343,
-0.22600659728050232,
-0.30412840843200684,
-0.489696204662323,
-0.4249066114425659,
0.6878589987754822,
0.1371183693408966,
0.3810816705226898,
0.2515856921672821,
0.5891264081001282,
0.1755640059709549,
-0.08420933783054352,
0.21073447167873383,
-0.013585876673460007,
0.15752635896205902,
-0.2278180569410324,
-0.2103363275527954,
-0.559440553188324,
-0.18798735737800598,
0.9027575850486755,
0.739860475063324,
-0.19814766943454742,
0.48169538378715515,
0.22733524441719055,
0.5192830562591553,
-0.7601337432861328,
0.17452511191368103,
-0.5842294692993164,
0.25136715173721313,
-0.39460811018943787,
0.12057904154062271,
-0.2856939136981964,
-0.33930331468582153,
0.25700464844703674,
-0.4212985932826996,
-0.24681518971920013,
-0.027165504172444344,
0.5076054334640503,
0.08099757134914398,
-0.7041996717453003,
0.10584701597690582,
-0.22093413770198822,
0.9395550489425659,
-1.1206377744674683,
0.30732783675193787,
0.2615179419517517,
0.4227801263332367,
-0.0686797946691513,
-0.49951010942459106,
-0.4413217604160309,
-0.44011497497558594,
0.21882419288158417,
0.31649771332740784,
0.2595268189907074,
0.06017550826072693,
0.25565385818481445,
0.45483770966529846,
-0.7849407196044922,
0.24356403946876526,
-0.030663296580314636,
-0.3440413475036621,
0.6101149916648865,
0.24034975469112396,
0.3050451874732971,
-0.25192299485206604,
-0.24068866670131683,
0.00822495762258768,
-0.5719574093818665,
0.21737223863601685,
0.3276996314525604,
0.2251937836408615,
-0.014973911456763744,
0.519666314125061,
-0.41732463240623474,
0.9776044487953186,
-0.11893368512392044,
-0.46789851784706116,
0.17213495075702667,
-0.15060970187187195,
-0.22991134226322174,
0.07220476865768433,
0.920157790184021,
0.18768972158432007,
0.21404053270816803,
-0.018681718036532402,
-0.05892215669155121,
-0.26495951414108276,
-0.062239788472652435,
-0.8354858756065369,
0.04056725278496742,
0.41031718254089355,
-0.2784584164619446,
-0.024053998291492462,
-0.032144974917173386,
-0.591174304485321,
-0.6257463097572327,
-0.2727791666984558,
0.29819461703300476,
-0.23992453515529633,
-0.4777434468269348,
0.2940787672996521,
0.0365649051964283,
0.7617101073265076,
0.42080479860305786,
-0.5718164443969727,
0.020256860181689262,
0.9552150368690491,
0.6646097302436829,
-0.5186837315559387,
-0.6073542237281799,
-0.39376094937324524,
0.11362562328577042,
-0.28503167629241943,
0.684069037437439,
-0.23430581390857697,
-0.28202933073043823,
0.1528603434562683,
0.01779288612306118,
0.346866637468338,
-0.5817961692810059,
0.5807311534881592,
-0.5267528891563416,
0.0685889944434166,
-0.561444103717804,
-0.6216689944267273,
-0.1895192563533783,
0.7554354667663574,
-0.43528446555137634,
1.0028495788574219,
0.16903139650821686,
-0.850199818611145,
0.3010263741016388,
-0.21326391398906708,
-0.6247592568397522,
0.21134713292121887,
-0.3005017936229706,
-0.2764698565006256,
-0.14081844687461853,
0.07058542966842651,
0.7184295058250427,
-0.6913009881973267,
0.6776173710823059,
-0.6706945300102234,
-0.37197571992874146,
0.04871547967195511,
-0.4706088602542877,
0.9150838851928711,
-0.06466364860534668,
-0.38346460461616516,
0.19972534477710724,
-0.7361564636230469,
0.21782110631465912,
0.1434793472290039,
-0.46152082085609436,
-0.44293442368507385,
-0.23341625928878784,
-0.21535369753837585,
0.1688031554222107,
0.4791501760482788,
-0.5386013984680176,
0.213265061378479,
-0.30585604906082153,
0.1023138016462326,
0.8070452213287354,
-0.09090841561555862,
0.19496601819992065,
-0.24097295105457306,
0.33350807428359985,
0.036041975021362305,
0.061043448746204376,
-0.051707323640584946,
-0.5654481053352356,
-0.5470430254936218,
0.04481839761137962,
0.08113572746515274,
0.4206465780735016,
-0.596996545791626,
0.5597957968711853,
-0.30506375432014465,
-0.7375448942184448,
-0.4074477255344391,
0.3918284475803375,
0.2410925328731537,
0.46002715826034546,
0.24952150881290436,
-0.18108762800693512,
-0.05455150827765465,
-0.8813678026199341,
-0.4662877321243286,
-0.04543432965874672,
-0.1866787075996399,
0.224844828248024,
0.518739640712738,
-0.006711533293128014,
0.609269380569458,
-0.5247337818145752,
-0.2556686997413635,
-0.27787357568740845,
0.021250344812870026,
0.3156934380531311,
0.10865780711174011,
0.24853962659835815,
-0.38555005192756653,
-0.6272812485694885,
0.29276058077812195,
-0.8342151045799255,
0.01693074218928814,
0.13325738906860352,
-0.22650182247161865,
0.024385666474699974,
0.11393660306930542,
-0.5649644732475281,
-0.10760582238435745,
0.592616617679596,
-0.016421576961874962,
0.9849068522453308,
-0.06248462572693825,
0.1195635125041008,
-0.8571682572364807,
0.20625771582126617,
0.10373029112815857,
-0.03865356743335724,
-0.3630099296569824,
0.28156036138534546,
0.41911399364471436,
0.0033490739297121763,
-0.5879899859428406,
0.9023841023445129,
-0.4448290467262268,
-0.29690417647361755,
-0.18151985108852386,
0.5979005694389343,
-0.07925111055374146,
0.7980525493621826,
0.1899784505367279,
0.5376576781272888,
0.5102907419204712,
-0.629096508026123,
0.7419974207878113,
-0.10544954985380173,
-0.849071741104126,
0.8327001333236694,
-0.6699191331863403,
0.17034998536109924,
0.1318960189819336,
0.21731242537498474,
-0.6459411382675171,
-0.26783671975135803,
0.10053190588951111,
-0.12965025007724762,
0.1523955762386322,
0.25580888986587524,
-0.5218675136566162,
-0.3888419270515442,
-0.4979812800884247,
0.4772258400917053,
0.33616769313812256,
-0.37137094140052795,
0.5153819918632507,
0.2745096981525421,
-0.08772260695695877,
-0.9138680696487427,
-0.49284622073173523,
-0.0004090224683750421,
-0.19088685512542725,
-0.4775482416152954,
0.09766644984483719,
-0.15978609025478363,
-0.225302591919899,
-0.1179593950510025,
-0.17222467064857483,
-0.09132300317287445,
0.18277621269226074,
-0.23157945275306702,
0.23781868815422058,
-0.43910568952560425,
0.06443193554878235,
0.010127095505595207,
0.13175177574157715,
0.2504318058490753,
-0.27983707189559937,
0.4973333477973938,
-0.21378813683986664,
-0.7746075391769409,
-0.22248616814613342,
-0.07599730789661407,
0.4455069601535797,
-0.4621572196483612,
0.3082699179649353,
0.7777360081672668,
-0.4001260995864868,
-0.4658237397670746,
-0.45812174677848816,
-0.030312009155750275,
-0.4334125518798828,
0.7604787945747375,
-0.4078117609024048,
-0.8347258567810059,
0.3142690360546112,
-0.11679680645465851,
0.5819286704063416,
0.4827290177345276,
0.8006451725959778,
0.05345325544476509,
0.5660832524299622,
0.09730204194784164,
-0.43035972118377686,
0.008816222660243511,
0.023141734302043915,
0.061899054795503616,
-0.9678164124488831,
0.051769010722637177,
-0.2852488160133362,
-0.20232391357421875,
-0.3053681254386902,
-0.4561455249786377,
0.4958694875240326,
-0.331749826669693,
-0.5716305375099182,
0.16432727873325348,
-0.3114950954914093,
0.16556258499622345,
0.47977280616760254,
0.20472732186317444,
0.5540978312492371,
-0.37345534563064575,
-0.04013592377305031,
0.015985913574695587,
-0.38869568705558777,
-0.260793000459671,
1.2803471088409424,
0.3541657030582428,
0.45563340187072754,
0.07410416007041931,
0.5565419793128967,
0.0808778777718544,
0.541904866695404,
-1.0114864110946655,
0.7203993797302246,
-0.18563038110733032,
-0.8596551418304443,
-0.6289187669754028,
-0.3780709207057953,
-0.6868963241577148,
0.5531511902809143,
0.12381051480770111,
-0.43480929732322693,
-0.38892313838005066,
-0.1278015375137329,
-0.47733697295188904,
0.4539601802825928,
-0.009223191998898983,
0.7975590825080872,
-0.658704936504364,
-0.5153858065605164,
-0.24191641807556152,
-0.5343162417411804,
1.022799015045166,
-0.41100895404815674,
0.29235029220581055,
-0.43506869673728943,
-0.0407538041472435,
0.8557596802711487,
0.11719401180744171,
0.8665432929992676,
-0.19131773710250854,
-0.691123902797699,
0.4377290904521942,
0.07613842189311981,
0.263956755399704,
-0.07969491928815842,
-0.3530459702014923,
0.3919616639614105,
0.2584303915500641,
-0.34271639585494995,
-0.5158817172050476,
0.6130158305168152,
-0.8619278073310852,
-0.6817704439163208,
-0.3740912079811096,
-0.44906163215637207,
-0.6250471472740173,
0.3249426782131195,
-0.042391087859869,
0.20041808485984802,
-0.2745612561702728,
0.2867472171783447,
0.44220930337905884,
-0.6732800006866455,
0.13630306720733643,
0.6715302467346191,
-0.3640577495098114,
-0.3331843316555023,
0.7492889165878296,
0.05923837423324585,
0.32458987832069397,
0.3489575684070587,
0.48905616998672485,
-0.18541471660137177,
-0.3045397996902466,
-0.2906145453453064,
0.2289654016494751,
-0.9255492687225342,
-0.14607474207878113,
-0.43586379289627075,
-0.4209699034690857,
-0.3452856242656708,
0.2281647026538849,
-0.3373415768146515,
0.12780402600765228,
0.14236082136631012,
0.021089637652039528,
-0.03499032184481621,
0.4159891605377197,
0.17009292542934418,
0.1967269778251648,
-0.8695778846740723,
0.4736810326576233,
0.4947095513343811,
0.37661686539649963,
0.3023565113544464,
-0.7135440707206726,
-0.31184616684913635,
0.005009258631616831,
-0.5028601288795471,
-0.6589515209197998,
0.007561630103737116,
0.025818221271038055,
0.7996463179588318,
0.5287501215934753,
0.133707195520401,
0.5810641050338745,
-0.3467644453048706,
0.9300557971000671,
0.14299389719963074,
-1.0019885301589966,
0.4054446518421173,
-0.4630655348300934,
0.39226460456848145,
0.47607821226119995,
0.14244544506072998,
-0.7709571719169617,
-0.2647406756877899,
-0.34852516651153564,
-0.6036365628242493,
0.419768363237381,
-0.38905414938926697,
0.06028561294078827,
0.37004992365837097,
0.3608942925930023,
0.3667459785938263,
0.361125648021698,
-0.9401922821998596,
-0.18479152023792267,
0.14750994741916656,
-0.19343750178813934,
-0.10919012874364853,
-0.07893028110265732,
0.02972879819571972,
-0.4170222878456116,
0.48030713200569153,
-0.2211257517337799,
-0.18747875094413757,
-0.07843378186225891,
-0.09683407098054886,
0.07486730068922043,
0.49880868196487427,
0.37826284766197205,
0.5926399827003479,
-0.21105718612670898,
0.19962215423583984,
0.4953947961330414,
-0.35138675570487976,
0.0840950682759285,
-0.2574118971824646,
-0.05130148306488991,
-0.2296111136674881,
0.7195091247558594,
0.4753662347793579,
0.38605791330337524,
-0.7567498683929443,
0.5357848405838013,
0.2684721052646637,
-0.30841317772865295,
-0.27608931064605713,
0.07925257086753845,
0.2704377770423889,
-0.007550056092441082,
0.11514922976493835,
-0.4998244643211365,
0.06846608221530914,
-0.6922643184661865,
0.15940530598163605,
0.5295725464820862,
-0.16797827184200287,
-0.2780154049396515,
0.40680408477783203,
0.21522675454616547,
0.026941290125250816,
0.47848623991012573,
-0.03795463591814041,
-0.566769540309906,
0.5934668183326721,
0.2139875739812851,
0.8540974259376526,
-0.308777779340744,
0.12803661823272705,
0.6667371392250061,
0.3316388726234436,
-0.43488985300064087,
0.24967974424362183,
-0.37250322103500366,
-0.8161849975585938,
-0.41542452573776245,
-0.7140446901321411,
-0.788273274898529,
0.3940351903438568,
-0.6339601874351501,
0.42693042755126953,
-0.5650570392608643,
-0.1424301117658615,
-0.41486266255378723,
0.3581257164478302,
-0.6467388868331909,
0.13926498591899872,
0.30541741847991943,
0.8542333841323853,
-0.45334210991859436,
0.9719659686088562,
0.5291139483451843,
-0.07983247935771942,
-0.6807268857955933,
0.1925942599773407,
-0.04305293783545494,
-1.1091734170913696,
0.5822248458862305,
0.22223025560379028,
0.05118996649980545,
-0.09384841471910477,
-0.38646337389945984,
-0.7610062956809998,
1.0901447534561157,
0.20725037157535553,
-0.7569881081581116,
-0.009309155866503716,
0.22911614179611206,
0.3900419771671295,
0.033165350556373596,
0.24765683710575104,
0.7680398225784302,
0.9589422345161438,
-0.1712130755186081,
-0.9610471129417419,
0.0289380494505167,
0.015890656039118767,
-0.3934871256351471,
-0.15038059651851654,
-0.8510778546333313,
0.8852804899215698,
-0.13479964435100555,
-0.12184099107980728,
-0.1888870894908905,
0.6520110964775085,
0.6389675736427307,
0.26392677426338196,
0.48355430364608765,
0.281669557094574,
0.6963441371917725,
0.061516184359788895,
0.8106747269630432,
-0.4994660019874573,
0.3640328645706177,
1.157362699508667,
-0.6991795897483826,
0.9879220724105835,
0.27104315161705017,
-0.5863372683525085,
0.23799766600131989,
0.7557862997055054,
-0.11487787216901779,
0.26863032579421997,
0.6121890544891357,
-0.08878133445978165,
-0.5124199986457825,
0.03545083850622177,
-0.39175915718078613,
0.41657721996307373,
0.18529453873634338,
0.2619047462940216,
-0.349408894777298,
-0.10478442162275314,
-0.02277766354382038,
-0.17579533159732819,
-0.18777453899383545,
0.6047316193580627,
0.4421132802963257,
-0.7979382872581482,
0.4224959909915924,
0.19063030183315277,
0.9606146812438965,
-0.848434567451477,
0.3428459167480469,
-0.20538194477558136,
0.28558117151260376,
-0.07382194697856903,
-1.0645414590835571,
0.010155249387025833,
-0.18229688704013824,
0.39076554775238037,
0.08553873747587204,
0.7407175302505493,
-0.4428354501724243,
-0.4756384491920471,
0.48811137676239014,
0.6716728210449219,
0.07809858024120331,
-0.32512304186820984,
-0.6860418915748596,
-0.0702408105134964,
-0.15981949865818024,
-0.559516966342926,
0.4295894503593445,
0.5955011248588562,
0.04531010985374451,
0.6259872913360596,
0.5439271330833435,
0.3537411391735077,
-0.15615622699260712,
0.16573579609394073,
0.3661990761756897,
-0.7566737532615662,
-0.2623017430305481,
-1.0239638090133667,
0.39890366792678833,
0.022949809208512306,
-0.43417343497276306,
0.8807279467582703,
0.38881295919418335,
0.7280728220939636,
0.04956769570708275,
1.1080358028411865,
0.30720600485801697,
0.4027060270309448,
-0.25703951716423035,
0.798697829246521,
-0.9046086668968201,
0.21143607795238495,
-0.32178109884262085,
-1.0314817428588867,
-0.22056733071804047,
0.3842109143733978,
-0.3087480366230011,
0.0869792252779007,
0.6149361729621887,
0.26932334899902344,
0.08716025948524475,
-0.11287475377321243,
0.6860689520835876,
0.13620762526988983,
0.36787834763526917,
0.9183447360992432,
0.9942004084587097,
-0.23190312087535858,
0.27736517786979675,
-0.3978252112865448,
-0.24078452587127686,
0.0018137149745598435,
-0.8075674772262573,
-1.0768277645111084,
-0.47055116295814514,
-0.21246781945228577,
0.10119646042585373,
-0.34586137533187866,
0.7410879731178284,
0.32531625032424927,
-0.751443088054657,
-0.5465434193611145,
0.4554588198661804,
0.12224681675434113,
-0.27834147214889526,
-0.1760082244873047,
0.6494718790054321,
-0.30280157923698425,
-0.5709065794944763,
0.08565729856491089,
0.3795832395553589,
-0.1956544816493988,
-0.7670289874076843,
0.01609983667731285,
0.10267012566328049,
-0.08524289727210999,
0.7894403338432312,
0.06966669112443924,
-0.8527605533599854,
-0.1326984465122223,
0.2499208003282547,
-0.2178097665309906,
-0.13290713727474213,
0.7631880640983582,
-0.36920392513275146,
0.07381007820367813,
0.374773234128952,
0.8206414580345154,
0.1624077707529068,
-0.2510013282299042,
0.44067880511283875,
-0.36970552802085876,
0.05415879935026169,
0.17479382455348969,
0.43713727593421936,
0.2556475102901459,
-0.21579857170581818,
0.30503642559051514,
0.09589475393295288,
-0.4513905942440033,
-0.7809063196182251,
-0.023767612874507904,
-0.9388468265533447,
-0.47530636191368103,
1.43132746219635,
-0.3143479824066162,
-0.17315909266471863,
-0.07331298291683197,
-0.12320980429649353,
0.2264154851436615,
-0.00436639878898859,
0.7233057022094727,
1.0705032348632812,
0.21195563673973083,
-0.14863154292106628,
-0.8728623986244202,
0.22832107543945312,
0.5514688491821289,
-1.0388157367706299,
0.4332362115383148,
0.27298176288604736,
0.4003632068634033,
-0.10928834974765778,
0.6113709211349487,
-0.08015286922454834,
0.2219671607017517,
-0.31609612703323364,
0.19536232948303223,
0.13321609795093536,
-0.07291910797357559,
-0.13364553451538086,
0.2884550094604492,
0.1631620228290558,
0.1055048257112503
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.12596v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.12596v1
|
Chart-based Reasoning: Transferring Capabilities from LLMs to VLMs
| 2024-03-19T10:03:07 | 2024-03-19T10:03:07 |
Victor Carbune, Hassan Mansoor, Fangyu Liu, Rahul Aralikatte, Gilles Baechler, Jindong Chen, Abhanshu Sharma
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Vision-language models (VLMs) are achieving increasingly strong performance
on multimodal tasks. However, reasoning capabilities remain limited
particularly for smaller VLMs, while those of large-language models (LLMs) have
seen numerous improvements. We propose a technique to transfer capabilities
from LLMs to VLMs. On the recently introduced ChartQA, our method obtains
state-of-the-art performance when applied on the PaLI3-5B VLM by
\citet{chen2023pali3}, while also enabling much better performance on PlotQA
and FigureQA.
We first improve the chart representation by continuing the pre-training
stage using an improved version of the chart-to-table translation task by
\citet{liu2023deplot}. We then propose constructing a 20x larger dataset than
the original training set. To improve general reasoning capabilities and
improve numerical operations, we synthesize reasoning traces using the table
representation of charts. Lastly, our model is fine-tuned using the multitask
loss introduced by \citet{hsieh2023distilling}.
Our variant ChartPaLI-5B outperforms even 10x larger models such as PaLIX-55B
without using an upstream OCR system, while keeping inference time constant
compared to the PaLI3-5B baseline. When rationales are further refined with a
simple program-of-thought prompt \cite{chen2023program}, our model outperforms
the recently introduced Gemini Ultra and GPT-4V.
|
[
-0.16743704676628113,
-0.4534843862056732,
0.9608447551727295,
-0.051177702844142914,
-0.6060062646865845,
0.10569081455469131,
-0.01667446829378605,
-0.610865592956543,
-0.08212394267320633,
1.1551141738891602,
-0.31296807527542114,
-0.4697189927101135,
-0.4965457022190094,
-0.20304059982299805,
-0.43863534927368164,
0.6676858067512512,
-0.22219479084014893,
0.2150164097547531,
-0.11534828692674637,
-0.0998743399977684,
-0.7582813501358032,
-0.7541404962539673,
-0.45565760135650635,
-0.11085473746061325,
0.49616366624832153,
0.6074272990226746,
0.4644785523414612,
0.5914591550827026,
0.6234524846076965,
0.29245179891586304,
0.20304402709007263,
0.7139222621917725,
-0.6344361901283264,
0.2240583598613739,
-0.09853925555944443,
-0.6185916662216187,
-0.723253607749939,
-0.21295182406902313,
0.41196608543395996,
0.5115640163421631,
0.20696501433849335,
0.12990616261959076,
-0.1930619478225708,
0.7812885642051697,
-0.6492018103599548,
0.6360290050506592,
-0.5051651000976562,
0.010090929456055164,
-0.06926567852497101,
-0.17677606642246246,
-0.9104273319244385,
-0.28933751583099365,
-0.0565972775220871,
-0.9327861666679382,
-0.2173716425895691,
0.23941823840141296,
0.8913007974624634,
0.3900551497936249,
-0.6335213780403137,
-0.07411089539527893,
-0.9175740480422974,
0.7107977867126465,
-0.6517255902290344,
0.5132861137390137,
0.3469848334789276,
0.6680765748023987,
0.22636103630065918,
-1.2255703210830688,
-0.49979811906814575,
-0.4131534695625305,
0.016312126070261,
0.30642902851104736,
-0.17889374494552612,
-0.09954136610031128,
0.5262850522994995,
0.011380135081708431,
-0.30229538679122925,
-0.03222500905394554,
-0.6467989087104797,
-0.16560110449790955,
0.722579836845398,
0.334960401058197,
0.0033644111827015877,
-0.21202875673770905,
-0.4367949664592743,
-0.22363588213920593,
-0.8295174241065979,
-0.044617488980293274,
-0.2291901558637619,
0.27063512802124023,
0.13204002380371094,
0.7563813924789429,
-0.2313782274723053,
0.797416090965271,
-0.09281909465789795,
-0.2359621822834015,
0.24286416172981262,
-0.6762462258338928,
-0.3069053292274475,
-0.18078763782978058,
0.3196077346801758,
0.49952125549316406,
0.4166345000267029,
0.16143730282783508,
-0.10171492397785187,
-0.004496230743825436,
0.38448813557624817,
-0.4618695378303528,
-0.3917941153049469,
-0.21778255701065063,
-0.43285930156707764,
0.013344005681574345,
-0.1812005490064621,
-0.4373278021812439,
-0.6777225136756897,
-0.8458807468414307,
0.4396982192993164,
-0.6657280325889587,
0.17523065209388733,
-0.017035052180290222,
-0.09529784321784973,
0.14498253166675568,
0.8535155057907104,
-0.6326638460159302,
0.09595280140638351,
0.5920701026916504,
0.7025964856147766,
-0.24599511921405792,
-0.08694865554571152,
-0.7421423196792603,
0.5968343615531921,
-0.549249529838562,
0.8396563529968262,
-0.2613181471824646,
-0.32537588477134705,
-0.31541377305984497,
-0.20069922506809235,
-0.22406239807605743,
-0.4706030488014221,
0.46656396985054016,
-0.4528023600578308,
0.044508494436740875,
-0.5550332069396973,
-0.6669940948486328,
-0.4346978962421417,
0.2201399952173233,
-0.675258219242096,
0.8946828246116638,
0.17254923284053802,
-0.4346373379230499,
0.4219043254852295,
-0.582103967666626,
-0.33754411339759827,
0.13781408965587616,
-0.33215564489364624,
-0.29678407311439514,
-0.18135425448417664,
0.6183960437774658,
0.43893149495124817,
-0.2242523729801178,
-0.2066926658153534,
-0.4611509442329407,
-0.36574628949165344,
0.14398977160453796,
-0.25576677918434143,
0.705586850643158,
0.37272343039512634,
-0.36683422327041626,
0.5727648138999939,
-0.6788066029548645,
0.24968622624874115,
-0.022985724732279778,
-0.1480393409729004,
-0.07411357760429382,
-0.17954057455062866,
-0.016365941613912582,
0.17012199759483337,
0.14751239120960236,
-0.19204729795455933,
0.30822592973709106,
-0.18329112231731415,
0.48474282026290894,
0.6778489947319031,
-0.15406125783920288,
0.40216055512428284,
-0.27216336131095886,
0.4593431055545807,
-0.03374302759766579,
0.310638964176178,
0.10441506654024124,
-0.7482715845108032,
-1.0245060920715332,
-0.46723195910453796,
0.06684757769107819,
0.7650052309036255,
-1.295971393585205,
0.07076145708560944,
-0.42371952533721924,
-0.6386994123458862,
-0.2877231538295746,
0.09147924929857254,
0.17193958163261414,
0.8310710191726685,
0.6101176142692566,
-0.45050251483917236,
-0.5044983625411987,
-0.7769558429718018,
0.14439497888088226,
-0.29229915142059326,
0.0637633427977562,
0.33328893780708313,
0.13378386199474335,
0.06778905540704727,
0.5440093874931335,
-0.4957451820373535,
-0.19206804037094116,
-0.6228724122047424,
0.005306378472596407,
0.137313574552536,
0.2705145478248596,
0.5928319692611694,
-0.6264428496360779,
-0.6346924304962158,
0.17882558703422546,
-0.8312870264053345,
-0.0802462100982666,
-0.3293764591217041,
-0.40033674240112305,
0.37280574440956116,
0.8089113235473633,
-0.6768941283226013,
0.8932278156280518,
0.20590555667877197,
-0.6008959412574768,
0.8590264916419983,
-0.26591163873672485,
0.08955961465835571,
-0.8169748187065125,
0.0011561224237084389,
-0.311425119638443,
-0.40408003330230713,
-0.5528817772865295,
-0.014030461199581623,
0.12001437693834305,
-0.0007588440785184503,
-0.3882719874382019,
0.610837996006012,
-0.5459089875221252,
-0.3269808292388916,
-0.3209500312805176,
0.21012593805789948,
0.16560781002044678,
0.4769042730331421,
-0.014598829671740532,
0.7439084649085999,
0.7821372747421265,
-0.5647857189178467,
0.7427021265029907,
0.37211453914642334,
-0.36661070585250854,
0.6805327534675598,
-0.2576903998851776,
0.12216173857450485,
-0.011615704745054245,
0.363828182220459,
-0.9474945664405823,
0.22275909781455994,
0.6008520722389221,
-0.18730482459068298,
0.2430056780576706,
-0.06445426493883133,
-0.4325788915157318,
-0.5066837668418884,
-0.030461380258202553,
0.05235854536294937,
0.5472697019577026,
-0.4563191831111908,
0.8706320524215698,
0.0736842155456543,
-0.17901258170604706,
-0.5354353189468384,
-0.837979793548584,
0.2974686622619629,
-0.17721107602119446,
-0.6041314601898193,
0.20276258885860443,
-0.008024632930755615,
-0.13990354537963867,
0.047113362699747086,
-0.1836203783750534,
-0.01536658313125372,
-0.22506901621818542,
0.09744638204574585,
0.6744471788406372,
-0.4299072027206421,
0.24593260884284973,
-0.1531568467617035,
-0.4081869125366211,
-0.09234298765659332,
-0.4228144884109497,
0.3026145398616791,
-0.25728118419647217,
-0.8487564325332642,
-0.38104164600372314,
0.1532144844532013,
0.8248496055603027,
-0.5133166909217834,
0.554719865322113,
0.66880202293396,
-0.02409243956208229,
-0.10870964080095291,
-0.5911294221878052,
-0.1631471961736679,
-0.4506249725818634,
0.4523945152759552,
-0.4092574417591095,
-0.6550666093826294,
0.2630420923233032,
-0.06330865621566772,
0.024135995656251907,
0.26775455474853516,
0.6339303255081177,
-0.3200099468231201,
1.0205888748168945,
0.3964439928531647,
0.15438374876976013,
0.5494324564933777,
-0.4564201533794403,
0.3770539462566376,
-0.7303972244262695,
-0.21468932926654816,
-0.13871079683303833,
-0.2919224798679352,
-0.2589748799800873,
-0.8337886333465576,
0.38115158677101135,
-0.09681110829114914,
-0.43048930168151855,
0.17116597294807434,
-0.3176933825016022,
0.1606789231300354,
0.8571673631668091,
0.2789589762687683,
0.4659314453601837,
0.048922184854745865,
-0.1119653508067131,
-0.0056296526454389095,
-0.7813975214958191,
-0.5659324526786804,
1.3809510469436646,
-0.0017371822614222765,
0.6155674457550049,
0.12888215482234955,
0.4372192621231079,
0.13875830173492432,
0.6018690466880798,
-0.6216285228729248,
0.8965184688568115,
-0.3681585490703583,
-0.4141905605792999,
-0.5846459269523621,
-0.48367539048194885,
-0.7838246822357178,
0.4539951682090759,
-0.2949104309082031,
-0.8324690461158752,
0.07186944037675858,
0.2610825300216675,
-0.1446378529071808,
0.4842783212661743,
-0.9719505906105042,
0.8991550803184509,
-0.6095042824745178,
-0.3359881639480591,
-0.3770911991596222,
-0.5642260313034058,
0.3480941355228424,
0.12236437946557999,
0.2162933349609375,
-0.14632777869701385,
-0.011787124909460545,
0.3601638376712799,
-0.4898713231086731,
0.8134915232658386,
-0.1715756505727768,
0.006688261404633522,
0.41460394859313965,
-0.007779215928167105,
0.501274824142456,
-0.3175193667411804,
-0.018217332661151886,
-0.19129560887813568,
0.01102436799556017,
-0.555727481842041,
-0.8241998553276062,
0.3257334530353546,
-0.6515045762062073,
-0.6712614893913269,
-0.09414748102426529,
-0.8024470806121826,
-0.5487135648727417,
0.347290575504303,
0.03439981862902641,
0.34983134269714355,
0.38953566551208496,
0.18955087661743164,
0.3192650377750397,
0.1507282704114914,
0.043320536613464355,
0.19186024367809296,
-0.6154570579528809,
-0.23931092023849487,
0.9636113047599792,
0.2514292597770691,
0.4136197566986084,
0.3540510833263397,
0.033878862857818604,
-0.5962241291999817,
-0.7958394885063171,
-0.5701943635940552,
0.2952074706554413,
-1.225040316581726,
-0.10927850008010864,
-0.1377173364162445,
-0.253176748752594,
-0.311062753200531,
-0.1031663715839386,
-0.21626414358615875,
-0.5791537761688232,
-0.23919929563999176,
-0.16737765073776245,
0.47358769178390503,
0.6870167255401611,
-0.14039655029773712,
0.1791663020849228,
-0.8287960290908813,
0.46503305435180664,
0.562670111656189,
0.12129895389080048,
0.10971645265817642,
-0.6293526291847229,
-0.20031268894672394,
-0.17936988174915314,
-0.27885323762893677,
-0.9995718598365784,
0.37880897521972656,
-0.16079331934452057,
0.7276837825775146,
0.3010269105434418,
-0.006551102269440889,
0.8521025776863098,
-0.23568372428417206,
0.5561070442199707,
0.30936893820762634,
-1.0899676084518433,
0.26476967334747314,
-0.15844132006168365,
0.18886105716228485,
0.26659220457077026,
-0.017850598320364952,
-0.3689080774784088,
-0.363202840089798,
-0.4506149888038635,
-0.8525487780570984,
0.5847954154014587,
0.3161393702030182,
-0.34665635228157043,
0.5266954302787781,
0.3018318712711334,
-0.0760570839047432,
0.15025578439235687,
-0.6983120441436768,
-0.12320571392774582,
-0.5943108797073364,
-0.2863321006298065,
-0.10314085334539413,
0.057494595646858215,
-0.06358593702316284,
-0.736366868019104,
0.5617707967758179,
-0.3688678443431854,
0.07767482101917267,
0.23836857080459595,
-0.20764513313770294,
0.20965410768985748,
0.016993394121527672,
0.554700493812561,
0.9993360638618469,
0.1408451348543167,
0.3514159023761749,
0.36219725012779236,
-0.44384050369262695,
-0.07077105343341827,
0.23877674341201782,
-0.14369739592075348,
-0.2939949035644531,
0.647561252117157,
1.1967693567276,
0.2218855917453766,
-0.8273220062255859,
0.25600019097328186,
0.09049134701490402,
-0.13101159036159515,
0.035989679396152496,
0.08253549784421921,
0.4883262813091278,
0.5869951844215393,
0.11869882792234421,
0.06019383668899536,
-0.00226561794988811,
-0.47564396262168884,
0.21366721391677856,
0.09214754402637482,
-0.25445789098739624,
0.10271992534399033,
0.716536819934845,
0.12041918188333511,
-0.040429048240184784,
0.6950767636299133,
0.016733186319470406,
-0.4559648334980011,
0.673429012298584,
0.3265945017337799,
0.3704822361469269,
0.027630070224404335,
0.28933265805244446,
0.3533678650856018,
0.36037030816078186,
0.1022169440984726,
0.5427122116088867,
0.008033039048314095,
-0.6379655599594116,
-0.7874962091445923,
0.011335999704897404,
-0.6670973896980286,
0.13303729891777039,
-0.4603661000728607,
0.22273556888103485,
-0.4016819894313812,
-0.21220636367797852,
-0.11594821512699127,
-0.1849343180656433,
-0.7548093199729919,
0.11686650663614273,
0.6861307621002197,
0.6640159487724304,
-0.4300524592399597,
0.8779422640800476,
0.5899779796600342,
-0.5243959426879883,
-1.0816411972045898,
-0.4033384621143341,
-0.075101338326931,
-1.179250955581665,
0.7253038287162781,
-0.023622730746865273,
-0.09756042063236237,
-0.08910471200942993,
-0.515338659286499,
-1.0907827615737915,
1.2964611053466797,
0.5791493654251099,
-0.6600298881530762,
0.020233653485774994,
0.16160419583320618,
0.6144958734512329,
-0.3688361346721649,
0.12935392558574677,
0.45757773518562317,
0.7975786328315735,
0.41868525743484497,
-1.1007601022720337,
0.20697715878486633,
-0.014908420853316784,
-0.13313259184360504,
-0.1894090473651886,
-0.37468773126602173,
0.9800540804862976,
-0.48949122428894043,
-0.12113963812589645,
0.08677999675273895,
0.7289924621582031,
0.5800134539604187,
0.4055158793926239,
0.4745098054409027,
0.5045422911643982,
1.090976595878601,
0.07243140041828156,
1.0561604499816895,
-0.15774543583393097,
0.1989719271659851,
1.1798814535140991,
-0.35840824246406555,
0.9580076336860657,
0.5932519435882568,
-0.06540944427251816,
0.5422956943511963,
0.3712373673915863,
-0.10279518365859985,
0.40431633591651917,
0.1371239721775055,
0.10531070828437805,
-0.6596348881721497,
0.17874307930469513,
-0.3560752272605896,
0.4557393491268158,
0.44278591871261597,
-0.25088968873023987,
-0.30140402913093567,
0.0019067458342760801,
-0.12581175565719604,
0.13768558204174042,
-0.46377846598625183,
0.5045227408409119,
0.12558843195438385,
-0.6501361131668091,
0.7157934904098511,
-0.35212016105651855,
0.1021769791841507,
-0.5934205651283264,
-0.20755819976329803,
0.0005202651373110712,
0.16442060470581055,
0.07002126425504684,
-0.9334487915039062,
0.24095717072486877,
-0.22667013108730316,
0.17781712114810944,
-0.4704611897468567,
0.8562434315681458,
-0.2923853397369385,
-0.6205109357833862,
0.1681191623210907,
0.9494158029556274,
0.11031497269868851,
-0.057184625416994095,
-0.6682106852531433,
0.029459601268172264,
0.14457868039608002,
-0.00830201804637909,
0.10608931630849838,
0.5106393098831177,
-0.24320045113563538,
0.921140730381012,
0.6744849681854248,
0.1833072155714035,
0.23585748672485352,
0.31796854734420776,
0.8769287467002869,
-0.6573566198348999,
-0.7047744393348694,
-0.4545768201351166,
0.46099957823753357,
-0.24535153806209564,
-0.10820119827985764,
0.7295576930046082,
0.3722854256629944,
0.5908778309822083,
-0.25517258048057556,
0.860277533531189,
0.2320401519536972,
0.5204582214355469,
-0.8704759478569031,
0.7697871327400208,
-0.5637902617454529,
0.2694323658943176,
-0.16797995567321777,
-0.5783408880233765,
-0.3369448482990265,
0.571900486946106,
-0.6812154650688171,
-0.16555003821849823,
0.924251139163971,
0.4624648988246918,
0.022844558581709862,
0.015677589923143387,
0.4709501564502716,
0.24453331530094147,
0.5829774141311646,
0.7713344693183899,
0.9217408299446106,
-0.031035130843520164,
0.9610984325408936,
-0.17436543107032776,
-0.11069009453058243,
-0.31901267170906067,
-0.8181799650192261,
-0.7770591974258423,
-0.6488677263259888,
-0.24762950837612152,
-0.1812887340784073,
-0.07796177268028259,
0.26757940649986267,
0.8147722482681274,
-0.5701282620429993,
-0.3202434778213501,
0.026116706430912018,
0.18782393634319305,
-0.42224016785621643,
-0.18287816643714905,
0.5411961078643799,
-0.20270176231861115,
-0.3525444567203522,
0.3406106233596802,
0.23260480165481567,
0.10823258757591248,
-0.19392015039920807,
-0.2063671499490738,
0.026059795171022415,
0.11509633809328079,
0.8954615592956543,
0.230759859085083,
-0.8948594331741333,
-0.6240116953849792,
-0.0029983175918459892,
-0.07401581853628159,
0.2553819715976715,
0.7482227683067322,
-0.8567028045654297,
0.4957290589809418,
0.3823208212852478,
0.5577000379562378,
1.091020107269287,
-0.17756210267543793,
0.4340612292289734,
-0.28790467977523804,
-0.012743140570819378,
0.40123265981674194,
0.5419787168502808,
0.4310591518878937,
-0.13188491761684418,
0.6169731616973877,
0.4738926291465759,
-0.18663093447685242,
-0.7219011783599854,
0.4465517997741699,
-1.368988275527954,
-0.4253053367137909,
1.005887508392334,
-0.051480572670698166,
-0.10796782374382019,
-0.2783670425415039,
-0.6796087622642517,
0.3280578851699829,
-0.13353575766086578,
0.7097355723381042,
0.642996609210968,
-0.5646766424179077,
-0.4288231432437897,
-0.5234395861625671,
0.29180991649627686,
0.403877317905426,
-1.137213110923767,
0.08164791017770767,
0.6257840394973755,
0.0188796017318964,
0.24841049313545227,
0.7308968305587769,
-0.003569344524294138,
0.5177264213562012,
0.18828219175338745,
-0.03955109044909477,
-0.365521639585495,
-0.22573542594909668,
0.28459689021110535,
0.24899141490459442,
0.11731525510549545,
-0.18407922983169556
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.12582v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.12582v1
|
AlphaFin: Benchmarking Financial Analysis with Retrieval-Augmented Stock-Chain Framework
| 2024-03-19T09:45:33 | 2024-03-19T09:45:33 |
Xiang Li, Zhenyu Li, Chen Shi, Yong Xu, Qing Du, Mingkui Tan, Jun Huang, Wei Lin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The task of financial analysis primarily encompasses two key areas: stock
trend prediction and the corresponding financial question answering. Currently,
machine learning and deep learning algorithms (ML&DL) have been widely applied
for stock trend predictions, leading to significant progress. However, these
methods fail to provide reasons for predictions, lacking interpretability and
reasoning processes. Also, they can not integrate textual information such as
financial news or reports. Meanwhile, large language models (LLMs) have
remarkable textual understanding and generation ability. But due to the
scarcity of financial training datasets and limited integration with real-time
knowledge, LLMs still suffer from hallucinations and are unable to keep up with
the latest information. To tackle these challenges, we first release AlphaFin
datasets, combining traditional research datasets, real-time financial data,
and handwritten chain-of-thought (CoT) data. It has a positive impact on
training LLMs for completing financial analysis. We then use AlphaFin datasets
to benchmark a state-of-the-art method, called Stock-Chain, for effectively
tackling the financial analysis task, which integrates retrieval-augmented
generation (RAG) techniques. Extensive experiments are conducted to demonstrate
the effectiveness of our framework on financial analysis.
|
[
-0.31583720445632935,
-0.5766081809997559,
0.04840297996997833,
0.0609869547188282,
-0.36201512813568115,
0.46396514773368835,
-0.20629221200942993,
-0.7168340086936951,
0.24835623800754547,
0.3727899491786957,
-0.5623090267181396,
-0.4059690237045288,
-0.4605393409729004,
-0.02441604621708393,
-0.6853517889976501,
0.8805900812149048,
-0.05586674064397812,
0.14462532103061676,
0.10236018896102905,
-0.11800052225589752,
-0.02197982370853424,
-0.5334870219230652,
-1.103305459022522,
-0.07916808873414993,
0.34557053446769714,
0.35968509316444397,
0.7830184102058411,
0.82901531457901,
0.8432999849319458,
0.17303891479969025,
0.27826330065727234,
0.1347372829914093,
-0.5000466704368591,
0.321365624666214,
0.09748207777738571,
-0.09564384073019028,
-0.7083768844604492,
0.22633039951324463,
0.5629748106002808,
0.6476790904998779,
-0.33241400122642517,
0.3414957523345947,
0.03012441284954548,
0.850469708442688,
-0.7921125292778015,
0.3821897804737091,
-0.41681113839149475,
0.3541002869606018,
-0.2510979473590851,
-0.20457103848457336,
-0.04047980159521103,
-0.5161933898925781,
0.5080337524414062,
-0.7330135107040405,
0.19747252762317657,
0.7441017031669617,
0.943092405796051,
0.014316667802631855,
-0.24224020540714264,
-0.6084185242652893,
-0.5433371663093567,
0.697851300239563,
-0.6189430356025696,
0.514010488986969,
0.5937916040420532,
0.5493555665016174,
0.19640439748764038,
-0.9018769264221191,
-0.228624165058136,
-0.012292621657252312,
-0.01904929429292679,
-0.018609976395964622,
-0.31509506702423096,
-0.2773023247718811,
-0.14991717040538788,
0.8378174304962158,
-0.487687885761261,
0.008827965706586838,
-0.6236521601676941,
0.11440932005643845,
0.7769634127616882,
-0.03333485499024391,
-0.27908971905708313,
0.153553768992424,
-0.564715564250946,
-0.8398370146751404,
-0.4454900324344635,
-0.29704806208610535,
0.527126669883728,
0.5354647040367126,
0.15945643186569214,
0.2655933201313019,
0.06146673485636711,
0.31709906458854675,
0.08385924249887466,
0.27541816234588623,
0.43316400051116943,
-0.11167381703853607,
-0.44054141640663147,
0.34080594778060913,
0.6152836084365845,
0.403164803981781,
0.4763030409812927,
-0.1900876760482788,
-0.31051701307296753,
-0.3509733974933624,
0.5256308317184448,
-0.5420559048652649,
-0.16601362824440002,
0.2998036742210388,
-0.45596471428871155,
-0.20333094894886017,
0.283247172832489,
-1.0576220750808716,
-0.3707638382911682,
-0.2370299994945526,
0.26414069533348083,
-0.18191637098789215,
-0.15484756231307983,
0.2081414759159088,
-0.3407506048679352,
0.537610650062561,
-0.16433294117450714,
-0.733124852180481,
0.7033129930496216,
0.9537554979324341,
0.6079739332199097,
-0.16933615505695343,
-0.08559679239988327,
-0.9121484756469727,
0.15117686986923218,
-0.42953410744667053,
0.7836639285087585,
-0.3130306005477905,
-0.2621164619922638,
-0.061148542910814285,
-0.2837803363800049,
0.05640062689781189,
-0.6536782383918762,
0.11215007305145264,
-0.5695189833641052,
0.0434531532227993,
-0.32707324624061584,
-0.54867023229599,
-0.3498327136039734,
0.5362105965614319,
-0.7127513289451599,
1.04310142993927,
-0.11955366283655167,
-0.7405978441238403,
0.4853641390800476,
-0.5694673657417297,
-0.3343808054924011,
0.04811886325478554,
-0.24429799616336823,
-0.519777774810791,
-0.30120909214019775,
0.28368496894836426,
0.4833485186100006,
-0.6582673192024231,
0.13744813203811646,
-0.5126493573188782,
-0.5027741193771362,
0.3743165135383606,
-0.4660184383392334,
-0.056221913546323776,
0.2795386016368866,
-0.5428786277770996,
-0.08565323054790497,
-0.7958042621612549,
0.10275237262248993,
0.159999281167984,
0.2087736427783966,
-0.5789414644241333,
0.17520366609096527,
0.11320389062166214,
-0.023632997646927834,
0.20554448664188385,
-0.19379281997680664,
0.1832360029220581,
-0.4322187900543213,
0.1484193354845047,
0.8560547232627869,
0.041440438479185104,
0.10611006617546082,
-0.41334813833236694,
0.7426838278770447,
-0.13302835822105408,
0.3073502779006958,
-0.007383399643003941,
0.005327465943992138,
-0.6020489931106567,
-0.11342097073793411,
0.38524389266967773,
0.7221436500549316,
-0.33281171321868896,
0.011132990941405296,
0.028973659500479698,
-0.2729358375072479,
-0.4798060953617096,
0.24406062066555023,
0.3749740421772003,
0.2253386527299881,
0.3860947787761688,
-0.6455765962600708,
-0.7749637365341187,
-1.012865662574768,
-0.3250623345375061,
-0.07590946555137634,
-0.026371080428361893,
0.19541846215724945,
0.14545351266860962,
-0.10874797403812408,
0.5780059695243835,
-0.7891935110092163,
-0.11936869472265244,
0.04725446552038193,
0.32470908761024475,
0.4711048901081085,
0.35336512327194214,
0.3697385787963867,
-0.9450558423995972,
-0.12622183561325073,
0.15660527348518372,
-0.7742583155632019,
0.4602375626564026,
-0.05445548892021179,
-0.2704369127750397,
-0.19108809530735016,
0.5425462126731873,
0.17889761924743652,
0.49066224694252014,
0.3530508875846863,
-0.5664061307907104,
0.24297067523002625,
-0.11414378136396408,
0.015065883286297321,
-0.7414938807487488,
0.5225045084953308,
0.33300986886024475,
-0.17034472525119781,
-0.3468603193759918,
0.02701093629002571,
-0.25261518359184265,
-0.2268761694431305,
-0.10018415749073029,
0.9562391638755798,
-0.1937180459499359,
-0.6863893270492554,
-0.21419629454612732,
0.1950308084487915,
0.018404191359877586,
0.5960630178451538,
-0.393326997756958,
1.0490458011627197,
0.49522751569747925,
-0.5345562696456909,
0.3330347239971161,
0.1848856657743454,
-0.2179882824420929,
0.39013969898223877,
-0.5445210337638855,
0.06719514727592468,
-0.06874298304319382,
-0.14677047729492188,
-0.9583126306533813,
0.1846528798341751,
0.4574315845966339,
-0.003330560866743326,
0.0731741338968277,
0.3169567286968231,
-0.5559162497520447,
-0.3106774389743805,
-0.49201831221580505,
0.3969701826572418,
0.31146642565727234,
-0.4529525637626648,
0.6606585383415222,
0.12114715576171875,
-0.38568976521492004,
-0.8697900176048279,
-0.6168602108955383,
-0.024337654933333397,
-0.2671400308609009,
-0.15365897119045258,
0.1440180093050003,
-0.10961515456438065,
-0.6714043617248535,
-0.002495056949555874,
-0.5625213384628296,
-0.10874401032924652,
0.1614946871995926,
0.14281214773654938,
0.620655357837677,
-0.23680102825164795,
0.09140826761722565,
-0.1669333130121231,
-0.3091470003128052,
0.016855020076036453,
-0.48182716965675354,
0.30489325523376465,
-0.4791322350502014,
-0.040854934602975845,
-0.07031973451375961,
0.18889634311199188,
0.5629521012306213,
-0.2990390658378601,
0.48043566942214966,
0.20729418098926544,
-0.1552441418170929,
-0.1912919133901596,
-0.6108932495117188,
-0.09151094406843185,
-0.5436769127845764,
-0.13750705122947693,
-0.08048278838396072,
-0.6498379707336426,
0.6370139718055725,
-0.06730906665325165,
0.5443418622016907,
0.6168286800384521,
0.09790171682834625,
-0.06371115893125534,
0.6939253807067871,
0.6860787272453308,
-0.10358689725399017,
0.5399308800697327,
-0.6175011992454529,
0.08526692539453506,
-0.5523138642311096,
-0.18569351732730865,
-0.2652375102043152,
-0.6449780464172363,
-0.3297150135040283,
-0.055667731910943985,
0.1580819934606552,
0.17833563685417175,
-0.4572007358074188,
0.20260395109653473,
-0.3165523111820221,
0.3284371793270111,
0.4335537552833557,
-0.16359826922416687,
0.37585246562957764,
0.16992801427841187,
-0.4398035407066345,
0.16815783083438873,
-0.5930319428443909,
-0.22821077704429626,
1.492539644241333,
0.39046964049339294,
0.645656168460846,
-0.4591112434864044,
0.39575883746147156,
0.7002065181732178,
0.42300158739089966,
-0.6149799227714539,
0.3603476583957672,
-0.5536545515060425,
-0.47931909561157227,
0.021245108917355537,
-0.5032694339752197,
-0.6667079925537109,
0.22518453001976013,
-0.23039522767066956,
-0.2666007876396179,
0.6657414436340332,
0.21903333067893982,
-0.4879072606563568,
0.1584077626466751,
-0.4521797001361847,
0.6883738040924072,
-0.42445966601371765,
-0.3518535792827606,
-0.05356527119874954,
-0.2548619508743286,
0.24860145151615143,
-0.28327232599258423,
0.47901105880737305,
-0.0819459855556488,
-0.18318989872932434,
0.8663318157196045,
-0.3501821756362915,
0.6464917063713074,
0.20976880192756653,
-0.3615984320640564,
0.053073517978191376,
-0.11767437309026718,
0.4803270101547241,
0.1961841583251953,
-0.38271448016166687,
-0.018431561067700386,
-0.16900433599948883,
-0.5315283536911011,
-0.6479955315589905,
0.5334017872810364,
-0.4847171902656555,
-0.21201789379119873,
-0.7321725487709045,
-0.3920615315437317,
-0.3768543601036072,
-0.049779850989580154,
-0.08499382436275482,
0.29085972905158997,
-0.12666639685630798,
0.028873905539512634,
0.3694280982017517,
0.28667351603507996,
0.45369142293930054,
0.39387375116348267,
-0.43954816460609436,
-0.8849809765815735,
0.7946683168411255,
0.07365936040878296,
-0.12923495471477509,
-0.025857221335172653,
-0.08566490560770035,
-0.29806625843048096,
-0.30880820751190186,
-0.08210618048906326,
0.2970605790615082,
-0.7335407137870789,
-0.21516360342502594,
-0.2670891582965851,
-0.17257025837898254,
-0.15670353174209595,
-0.3246026039123535,
-0.5256049036979675,
-0.2663276195526123,
-0.08433613926172256,
-0.32115015387535095,
0.6332778930664062,
0.679595410823822,
-0.12743622064590454,
0.09678570926189423,
-0.5958399772644043,
0.5174209475517273,
0.5568811297416687,
0.7879877686500549,
0.45444419980049133,
0.05736096575856209,
-0.4813568890094757,
-0.00651925802230835,
-0.26021283864974976,
-0.3336440920829773,
0.3421442210674286,
0.052216190844774246,
0.31001362204551697,
0.717637836933136,
0.011508493684232235,
0.9070993065834045,
0.0007026806706562638,
0.19586223363876343,
-0.05775177851319313,
-0.7623944878578186,
0.456936776638031,
-0.06102694571018219,
0.19255107641220093,
0.8412712216377258,
0.44065773487091064,
-0.5404901504516602,
-0.5110238790512085,
-0.7851672768592834,
-1.3047420978546143,
0.3436669707298279,
0.2458888739347458,
-0.41701415181159973,
-0.11375532299280167,
0.7288261651992798,
0.2743920385837555,
0.6970573663711548,
-0.2446533888578415,
-0.34591495990753174,
-0.21341298520565033,
-0.06657899171113968,
-0.24581490457057953,
0.049330130219459534,
0.012237612158060074,
-0.2817554771900177,
0.7947895526885986,
-0.31523141264915466,
-0.03811057657003403,
0.11090954393148422,
0.31067726016044617,
-0.292276531457901,
-0.11858876794576645,
0.29427987337112427,
1.063256025314331,
-0.5960164666175842,
-0.07232674956321716,
0.16284126043319702,
-0.47976920008659363,
-0.07146081328392029,
0.4447512924671173,
0.1750781387090683,
-0.05065684765577316,
0.35790565609931946,
0.6476859450340271,
0.7725037336349487,
-1.1189053058624268,
0.0805182233452797,
-0.31009337306022644,
-0.28269413113594055,
-0.6666082739830017,
0.068435899913311,
-0.32858332991600037,
0.5924462080001831,
1.214350700378418,
-0.02252393588423729,
0.2107175886631012,
-0.781349241733551,
0.5849223732948303,
0.20862288773059845,
-0.46090495586395264,
0.03444059193134308,
0.6341935396194458,
-0.07449860125780106,
0.11947446316480637,
0.9456932544708252,
0.12544909119606018,
-0.3423519730567932,
0.8006705641746521,
0.04287203401327133,
1.1005405187606812,
0.06133166700601578,
-0.05870731920003891,
0.17907193303108215,
0.10434356331825256,
-0.453183114528656,
0.6844019889831543,
0.04682013392448425,
-0.41938015818595886,
-0.4301886260509491,
-0.7277786731719971,
-0.7195244431495667,
0.13154169917106628,
-1.16921865940094,
0.09747586399316788,
-0.9040522575378418,
-0.22852426767349243,
0.01405618991702795,
0.4260372519493103,
-0.5774285793304443,
0.35190680623054504,
0.08522943407297134,
1.1244195699691772,
-0.5112532377243042,
0.3891722857952118,
0.5646724104881287,
-0.12953941524028778,
-0.3596036434173584,
0.07370946556329727,
-0.02476947009563446,
-0.7396340370178223,
0.45092853903770447,
0.09649661928415298,
-0.0029163360595703125,
-0.08467601239681244,
-0.47677376866340637,
-0.8082122206687927,
1.1372815370559692,
0.16380372643470764,
-0.9368263483047485,
-0.12273949384689331,
-0.3455604612827301,
0.3031317889690399,
-0.6557772755622864,
-0.13078050315380096,
0.6058852672576904,
0.7470513582229614,
0.5785770416259766,
-0.6186320781707764,
-0.18244023621082306,
-0.5575501918792725,
-0.11570414900779724,
0.4060714542865753,
-0.5682789087295532,
0.8860641121864319,
0.08288639783859253,
-0.15897613763809204,
-0.20238015055656433,
0.8051916360855103,
0.5142208337783813,
0.6342200040817261,
0.38696882128715515,
0.45611223578453064,
0.8781564235687256,
0.10722951591014862,
1.2014546394348145,
-0.5523700714111328,
0.3482987880706787,
1.1027253866195679,
-0.5087140798568726,
1.2683305740356445,
0.30080917477607727,
0.10292740166187286,
0.4144628942012787,
0.5705039501190186,
-0.5536696314811707,
0.4609993100166321,
0.273949533700943,
-0.049141496419906616,
-0.29531052708625793,
0.19482503831386566,
-0.4917779266834259,
0.35372981429100037,
0.325450599193573,
-0.45114845037460327,
-0.05414790287613869,
0.14437660574913025,
-0.023119909688830376,
-0.00357713270932436,
-0.5259454250335693,
0.7111425995826721,
0.23106278479099274,
-0.3137889802455902,
0.5448442101478577,
0.009155706502497196,
0.6657382845878601,
-0.8415697813034058,
0.025096602737903595,
-0.41861605644226074,
0.3336949646472931,
0.2737850248813629,
-0.37055060267448425,
0.32881030440330505,
0.0941210612654686,
-0.01558668352663517,
-0.4243316352367401,
0.39561405777931213,
-0.20145589113235474,
-0.771297037601471,
0.35564860701560974,
0.4219752848148346,
-0.1334291249513626,
0.12693782150745392,
-0.6754149794578552,
-0.0004486987309064716,
-0.38941463828086853,
-0.22060732543468475,
0.3079168200492859,
0.16666710376739502,
0.08677291870117188,
0.8756137490272522,
0.9500249624252319,
-0.01645827293395996,
-0.13928210735321045,
-0.39333269000053406,
1.007620930671692,
-1.12572181224823,
-0.7532209753990173,
-0.6862077713012695,
0.020664341747760773,
-0.12391549348831177,
-0.4521743953227997,
0.6259524822235107,
0.9844777584075928,
0.6159934401512146,
0.28744953870773315,
0.562162458896637,
0.4220832586288452,
0.4132254421710968,
-0.5239417552947998,
0.7926359176635742,
-0.6179022192955017,
0.4153229892253876,
-0.20804782211780548,
-0.9759077429771423,
-0.28429681062698364,
0.5218374133110046,
-0.21110042929649353,
-0.030799075961112976,
0.7156752347946167,
0.3692604899406433,
-0.3514731228351593,
0.4475840628147125,
-0.12491435557603836,
0.2073877453804016,
-0.13302473723888397,
0.20223067700862885,
0.3143354058265686,
-0.7717247605323792,
0.5669174194335938,
-0.18662160634994507,
0.10191650688648224,
-0.2868351340293884,
-0.895521879196167,
-0.6624203324317932,
-0.37696322798728943,
-0.495844304561615,
-0.15146997570991516,
0.6014527082443237,
0.8397517800331116,
0.5126421451568604,
-0.7873080372810364,
-0.8054217100143433,
0.19867871701717377,
-0.09762547165155411,
-0.8168387413024902,
-0.21720226109027863,
0.5320104360580444,
-0.3658508360385895,
-0.363935649394989,
0.5400885343551636,
0.375663697719574,
0.2856265604496002,
-0.4553714990615845,
-0.03567015752196312,
-0.39258676767349243,
0.30915364623069763,
0.35993897914886475,
0.5033578872680664,
-0.1694229692220688,
0.03694463148713112,
0.06474718451499939,
0.12763668596744537,
0.01924283802509308,
0.9537680149078369,
-0.8576866388320923,
0.06885823607444763,
0.21122314035892487,
0.5783653855323792,
0.6548326015472412,
0.1668066531419754,
0.9542117714881897,
-0.718000590801239,
0.1342950463294983,
0.18143408000469208,
0.22245414555072784,
-0.03355550020933151,
-0.31714069843292236,
0.7198395133018494,
-0.07485111802816391,
-0.14749805629253387,
-0.7299729585647583,
-0.3897590637207031,
-0.7238053679466248,
-0.520452082157135,
0.6521202325820923,
0.03189057484269142,
-0.5705938339233398,
0.12059643119573593,
0.2827651798725128,
0.043128203600645065,
-0.5046876072883606,
0.7449628114700317,
0.7236326336860657,
0.13198621571063995,
-0.33247047662734985,
-0.8681931495666504,
0.46422597765922546,
0.27517974376678467,
-0.6708076000213623,
0.31822818517684937,
0.14797340333461761,
-0.051834359765052795,
-0.020025087520480156,
0.5040790438652039,
0.05108099430799484,
0.4918668866157532,
-0.036899592727422714,
-0.0934339165687561,
-0.3348580598831177,
-0.5300822257995605,
-0.23592720925807953,
0.5384405851364136,
-0.1786407083272934,
-0.22812288999557495
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.12563v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.12563v1
|
Simple Hack for Transformers against Heavy Long-Text Classification on a Time- and Memory-Limited GPU Service
| 2024-03-19T09:17:25 | 2024-03-19T09:17:25 |
Mirza Alim Mutasodirin, Radityo Eko Prasojo, Achmad F. Abka, Hanif Rasyidi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Many NLP researchers rely on free computational services, such as Google
Colab, to fine-tune their Transformer models, causing a limitation for
hyperparameter optimization (HPO) in long-text classification due to the method
having quadratic complexity and needing a bigger resource. In Indonesian, only
a few works were found on long-text classification using Transformers. Most
only use a small amount of data and do not report any HPO. In this study, using
18k news articles, we investigate which pretrained models are recommended to
use based on the output length of the tokenizer. We then compare some hacks to
shorten and enrich the sequences, which are the removals of stopwords,
punctuation, low-frequency words, and recurring words. To get a fair
comparison, we propose and run an efficient and dynamic HPO procedure that can
be done gradually on a limited resource and does not require a long-running
optimization library. Using the best hack found, we then compare 512, 256, and
128 tokens length. We find that removing stopwords while keeping punctuation
and low-frequency words is the best hack. Some of our setups manage to
outperform taking 512 first tokens using a smaller 128 or 256 first tokens
which manage to represent the same information while requiring less
computational resources. The findings could help developers to efficiently
pursue optimal performance of the models using limited resources.
|
[
-0.6329478025436401,
-0.7698848843574524,
0.46413153409957886,
0.3292714059352875,
-0.5493553876876831,
0.051768939942121506,
-0.4067172408103943,
-0.7406795620918274,
0.12262560427188873,
0.6542825698852539,
-0.24832698702812195,
0.06059257686138153,
-0.6174023151397705,
0.39697107672691345,
-0.4796307384967804,
1.386059045791626,
0.02362629398703575,
-0.33815333247184753,
-0.13103467226028442,
-0.08446241170167923,
-0.32104772329330444,
-0.4979359209537506,
-0.7318653464317322,
-0.3023740351200104,
0.5647291541099548,
0.17745499312877655,
1.002089262008667,
0.8501988649368286,
0.6195566654205322,
0.31397321820259094,
-0.426523894071579,
0.15136030316352844,
-0.4135597050189972,
-0.058709390461444855,
-0.06807603687047958,
-0.4076843857765198,
-0.10330474376678467,
-0.08165979385375977,
0.4518120586872101,
0.3424477279186249,
-0.014107942581176758,
0.37401771545410156,
0.15752914547920227,
0.5117875337600708,
-0.8499028086662292,
0.14498993754386902,
-0.5698829293251038,
0.3086409866809845,
-0.5001400709152222,
-0.21512217819690704,
-0.664066731929779,
-0.22577564418315887,
-0.08996061235666275,
-0.6493731737136841,
0.3500421941280365,
0.29018595814704895,
1.0197762250900269,
0.5925118923187256,
-0.18400537967681885,
-0.01863228902220726,
-1.1754775047302246,
1.1069834232330322,
-0.42038625478744507,
0.3380601704120636,
0.2928895652294159,
0.39346086978912354,
-0.029074417427182198,
-0.7283837795257568,
-0.7394118905067444,
0.004981924779713154,
-0.15912467241287231,
0.09211442619562149,
-0.30088290572166443,
0.2968660593032837,
0.8042848706245422,
0.3769053518772125,
-0.6106263399124146,
0.47218480706214905,
-0.2559686005115509,
-0.19296814501285553,
0.3821195662021637,
0.06890825182199478,
0.016018541529774666,
-0.5568397641181946,
-0.4510062634944916,
-0.08110250532627106,
-0.5773285031318665,
-0.01272311620414257,
0.33503785729408264,
0.036747079342603683,
0.22922591865062714,
0.6190552115440369,
-0.01601298712193966,
0.4995901584625244,
-0.06465958058834076,
-0.3634389042854309,
0.052749328315258026,
-0.1481037586927414,
-0.326118141412735,
0.04870574548840523,
0.8220068216323853,
0.0011954460060223937,
0.30330464243888855,
-0.3854530155658722,
-0.24240726232528687,
0.09130269289016724,
0.23105357587337494,
-0.9739628434181213,
0.0898493155837059,
0.14357490837574005,
-0.5528615117073059,
-0.30049049854278564,
-0.1807679980993271,
-1.0525259971618652,
-0.1869145929813385,
-0.15696173906326294,
0.24824479222297668,
-0.18603219091892242,
0.21358254551887512,
0.026268992573022842,
-0.3213564157485962,
0.16158948838710785,
0.040071744471788406,
-0.917677640914917,
0.33296942710876465,
0.8150660395622253,
0.9675257802009583,
-0.3248918354511261,
-0.2325945645570755,
-0.7599877119064331,
0.1274542659521103,
-0.08967660367488861,
0.5325100421905518,
-0.46922171115875244,
-0.5172222256660461,
-0.05144780874252319,
-0.08941267430782318,
-0.0041585685685276985,
-0.5144243240356445,
0.8288787603378296,
-0.5896468162536621,
0.4888148307800293,
-0.0324195958673954,
-0.5334081053733826,
0.1641438603401184,
-0.03594675287604332,
-0.8285035490989685,
1.1476199626922607,
0.09386840462684631,
-1.0478264093399048,
0.4906729757785797,
-0.5016102194786072,
-0.4983925521373749,
0.3138622045516968,
-0.00275623332709074,
-0.705891489982605,
0.2358623445034027,
0.3342275619506836,
0.31107208132743835,
-0.4577503800392151,
0.26597946882247925,
-0.07893311977386475,
-0.739763081073761,
0.04332226142287254,
-0.5715640187263489,
0.8541819453239441,
0.45706117153167725,
-0.5046803951263428,
0.17908860743045807,
-0.7021839618682861,
-0.17433863878250122,
0.16780272126197815,
-0.478045254945755,
-0.39570632576942444,
0.1899772733449936,
0.29612189531326294,
0.14024455845355988,
0.025323795154690742,
-0.6909897923469543,
0.30455365777015686,
-0.52559894323349,
0.4923080503940582,
0.7899664640426636,
-0.32331109046936035,
0.27004724740982056,
-0.2347782552242279,
0.577094554901123,
-0.2528098523616791,
0.6126063466072083,
-0.07143998146057129,
-0.5839236974716187,
-0.8741351366043091,
-0.5188804268836975,
0.2768784761428833,
0.6229220628738403,
-1.0024245977401733,
0.5915725231170654,
-0.6100989580154419,
-0.5117436647415161,
-0.40416219830513,
0.17605751752853394,
0.24434645473957062,
0.52067631483078,
0.6219499111175537,
-0.09611984342336655,
-0.43402910232543945,
-0.7897666692733765,
-0.3519545793533325,
-0.011580274440348148,
-0.2369489222764969,
0.38710328936576843,
0.4067821502685547,
-0.2856205105781555,
0.9485223293304443,
-0.6408975720405579,
-0.17039792239665985,
-0.25130972266197205,
0.17348629236221313,
0.3771831691265106,
0.22391118109226227,
0.725715160369873,
-0.6940450072288513,
-0.3096124529838562,
-0.15247611701488495,
-0.4358629584312439,
0.06047734245657921,
-0.25210800766944885,
0.1772737205028534,
0.27614498138427734,
0.4980580806732178,
-0.9009600877761841,
0.5757697224617004,
0.46992620825767517,
-0.12724441289901733,
0.6589361429214478,
-0.2591717541217804,
-0.2605021297931671,
-0.9808288216590881,
0.24848444759845734,
-0.12724041938781738,
-0.2462657243013382,
-0.3531157076358795,
0.10697843134403229,
0.09503189474344254,
-0.5542235970497131,
-0.42418622970581055,
0.6645379662513733,
-0.21415142714977264,
0.31237244606018066,
-0.4145958125591278,
-0.28045976161956787,
-0.1610097736120224,
0.4269694685935974,
-0.05372875928878784,
0.9779713153839111,
0.20100617408752441,
-0.6885663270950317,
0.39615368843078613,
0.2134392112493515,
-0.46391618251800537,
-0.017038336023688316,
-0.7014363408088684,
0.2890782058238983,
-0.27031823992729187,
0.3233197033405304,
-0.6120296120643616,
-0.025750599801540375,
0.035885199904441833,
-0.07420723885297775,
0.19511070847511292,
-0.1584397405385971,
-0.796750009059906,
-0.8353487849235535,
-0.32347431778907776,
0.4994334280490875,
0.8748658299446106,
-0.9015185832977295,
0.4114440381526947,
0.21081389486789703,
-0.10367931425571442,
-0.8480162024497986,
-0.5167823433876038,
0.1519719511270523,
-0.3666535019874573,
-0.3433743417263031,
0.6563793420791626,
0.05328652262687683,
0.21776257455348969,
-0.1386261284351349,
0.09597931802272797,
0.009762615896761417,
0.05201799422502518,
0.19656920433044434,
0.30731168389320374,
0.129050612449646,
0.2392524778842926,
0.046584583818912506,
-0.2126515507698059,
-0.008378496393561363,
-0.25172698497772217,
0.7821136116981506,
0.10880767554044724,
-0.14049212634563446,
-0.3764130175113678,
0.20041121542453766,
0.6444762349128723,
-0.38764747977256775,
0.7266086935997009,
0.9839080572128296,
-0.2517494261264801,
-0.24403537809848785,
-0.6432188749313354,
-0.03517467901110649,
-0.525720477104187,
0.2535330355167389,
-0.14761982858181,
-0.9187391996383667,
0.31781843304634094,
-0.11639360338449478,
0.002404011320322752,
0.6020697951316833,
0.19445133209228516,
0.23012714087963104,
1.0566082000732422,
0.7929438948631287,
-0.5334816575050354,
0.5355860590934753,
-0.13663731515407562,
0.4078386723995209,
-0.4950014650821686,
-0.011812233366072178,
-0.8021816611289978,
-0.27567633986473083,
-0.8735505938529968,
-0.3050447702407837,
0.20104488730430603,
-0.025695452466607094,
-0.2043427973985672,
0.42662474513053894,
-0.692240834236145,
0.5705398321151733,
0.5181135535240173,
0.00022089022968430072,
0.05944123491644859,
0.18614806234836578,
0.23610225319862366,
-0.06676360964775085,
-0.6591858267784119,
-0.18169067800045013,
0.9381416440010071,
0.3753499388694763,
0.7736344933509827,
-0.2688780426979065,
0.7061772346496582,
0.18579474091529846,
0.1798844039440155,
-1.0879558324813843,
0.5620179772377014,
-0.41481050848960876,
-0.35188108682632446,
-0.3013404309749603,
-0.7143106460571289,
-1.0155200958251953,
-0.18178032338619232,
-0.2371353954076767,
-0.3912404775619507,
0.01494799554347992,
0.01115048211067915,
-0.31348511576652527,
0.5113820433616638,
-0.42415353655815125,
0.6985673308372498,
-0.2210792601108551,
-0.21427014470100403,
-0.35065990686416626,
-0.3394908607006073,
0.09563986212015152,
-0.2671802341938019,
0.03595418855547905,
0.1133359894156456,
-0.03186514601111412,
0.9479731321334839,
-0.5508087277412415,
0.3630164563655853,
-0.2188648134469986,
0.29709306359291077,
0.3518419861793518,
-0.24481259286403656,
0.59012371301651,
-0.1570901721715927,
0.19529078900814056,
0.30225083231925964,
-0.1069054827094078,
-0.5219422578811646,
-0.4988524615764618,
0.5926282405853271,
-0.773111879825592,
-0.5241639018058777,
-0.5239022970199585,
-0.2337927669286728,
-0.11545213311910629,
0.3641403019428253,
0.5391608476638794,
0.0436876118183136,
0.03204985707998276,
0.4011893570423126,
0.5650507807731628,
-0.31968748569488525,
0.8011587858200073,
-0.1000886783003807,
-0.22864368557929993,
-0.29477348923683167,
0.7565195560455322,
0.10476794838905334,
-0.158133402466774,
0.29430845379829407,
0.48708847165107727,
-0.1885344535112381,
-0.5697208046913147,
-0.3798986077308655,
0.30312296748161316,
-0.28491830825805664,
-0.3111552596092224,
-0.5419692397117615,
-0.4004004895687103,
-0.21584884822368622,
0.0396592915058136,
-0.3093668818473816,
-0.4836810231208801,
-0.2829006314277649,
0.13179072737693787,
0.2589505910873413,
0.3511985242366791,
0.3391196131706238,
0.510934054851532,
-0.8462215065956116,
0.44448769092559814,
0.35779350996017456,
0.5198586583137512,
-0.020407667383551598,
-0.4757572114467621,
-0.4020690619945526,
-0.3181598484516144,
-0.2806761562824249,
-0.6214951276779175,
0.3919522166252136,
0.1848645806312561,
0.33628296852111816,
0.650446891784668,
-0.010427840985357761,
0.8336207866668701,
-0.6451792120933533,
0.6876585483551025,
0.3083392381668091,
-1.0397143363952637,
0.4193718731403351,
-0.06325236707925797,
0.32456347346305847,
0.3810431957244873,
0.6468468904495239,
-0.616314709186554,
-0.07391471415758133,
-0.4067429304122925,
-0.9144593477249146,
0.4585942029953003,
0.1746029555797577,
0.2736245095729828,
-0.21046409010887146,
0.4871765673160553,
0.11032194644212723,
0.06523571163415909,
-0.5351516008377075,
-0.08462359011173248,
-0.21370726823806763,
-0.04261403903365135,
-0.06715738773345947,
-0.4352089762687683,
-0.04874047636985779,
-0.383768230676651,
0.6064772009849548,
-0.1436835378408432,
0.3188879191875458,
0.05867490917444229,
-0.1953764259815216,
0.03203653544187546,
0.28683900833129883,
0.31878185272216797,
0.5274008512496948,
-0.10348381102085114,
0.0006119654863141477,
0.24403174221515656,
-0.7784923315048218,
-0.09745553880929947,
0.210186168551445,
-0.3949010372161865,
0.3094540536403656,
0.19917459785938263,
0.8119696378707886,
-0.0038301546592265368,
-0.6538497805595398,
0.5559293031692505,
-0.19585347175598145,
0.08422761410474777,
-0.20606911182403564,
0.0498904213309288,
-0.34222525358200073,
-0.1381247639656067,
0.26573920249938965,
0.15993326902389526,
0.09956279397010803,
-0.22117874026298523,
-0.0041895536705851555,
0.3143734931945801,
-0.19939717650413513,
-0.16720721125602722,
0.7300111055374146,
0.10997709631919861,
-0.298597127199173,
0.9662750363349915,
-0.21913017332553864,
-0.4364829361438751,
0.45775359869003296,
0.4941036105155945,
1.0025827884674072,
-0.17491644620895386,
0.037270985543727875,
0.28734785318374634,
0.17571859061717987,
-0.32552221417427063,
-0.0019922363571822643,
-0.16220137476921082,
-0.3765602707862854,
-0.8959274291992188,
-0.930427074432373,
-0.35220634937286377,
0.42594924569129944,
-0.6201037764549255,
0.5358885526657104,
-0.6338828802108765,
-0.46087098121643066,
0.2557348608970642,
-0.010218856856226921,
-0.805193305015564,
0.044577475637197495,
0.1376160830259323,
0.9596213102340698,
-0.762730598449707,
0.862434983253479,
0.2749469578266144,
-0.2002469152212143,
-0.3820160925388336,
-0.1964017152786255,
-0.5033401250839233,
-0.49926039576530457,
0.6054977774620056,
0.3679819703102112,
0.044349554926157,
-0.35613951086997986,
-0.48997148871421814,
-0.6707698106765747,
0.6726483702659607,
0.31966474652290344,
-0.7513893842697144,
-0.5147141218185425,
0.44930532574653625,
0.6725113987922668,
0.270406037569046,
0.139358252286911,
0.3522670865058899,
0.44555479288101196,
-0.27829644083976746,
-1.2419438362121582,
-0.03648700565099716,
-0.09628081321716309,
0.06641732901334763,
0.49011534452438354,
-0.6324638724327087,
0.7710849642753601,
0.10382138937711716,
-0.25969985127449036,
0.09322940558195114,
0.6469263434410095,
-0.1650245487689972,
0.282991886138916,
0.6154745221138,
0.7965204119682312,
0.6873025894165039,
-0.16268274188041687,
1.124295949935913,
-0.4134766161441803,
0.5958720445632935,
0.7859269380569458,
0.008489272557199001,
0.817764401435852,
0.6377050876617432,
-0.3093525767326355,
0.25005996227264404,
0.38967153429985046,
-0.3264986276626587,
0.29097673296928406,
0.2548493444919586,
-0.2601861357688904,
-0.08741976320743561,
-0.1283230036497116,
-0.1921403408050537,
0.6908618211746216,
0.06857597082853317,
-0.310880184173584,
-0.07178222388029099,
0.23336417973041534,
0.3265596628189087,
-0.18081088364124298,
-0.26381340622901917,
0.7103410959243774,
-0.0007859712932258844,
-0.7183302640914917,
0.6789535880088806,
0.10698741674423218,
0.9344035387039185,
-0.4786425828933716,
0.2987688481807709,
-0.12781748175621033,
0.3407624363899231,
-0.2663755714893341,
-0.49470826983451843,
0.4201154112815857,
0.23414123058319092,
-0.1359393298625946,
-0.2576897442340851,
0.6807307004928589,
-0.08408605307340622,
-0.4286174178123474,
0.2322453260421753,
0.21057461202144623,
0.02550310268998146,
-0.36118751764297485,
-0.5754905343055725,
-0.16368426382541656,
-0.3079085648059845,
-0.25092947483062744,
0.3556429445743561,
0.16421444714069366,
-0.09084628522396088,
0.5854759812355042,
0.8417367935180664,
0.3453809320926666,
0.012073209509253502,
0.01365904975682497,
0.8271673321723938,
-0.7835323810577393,
-0.6590969562530518,
-0.9283029437065125,
-0.2254725992679596,
-0.24915577471256256,
-0.4017814099788666,
0.7888795137405396,
0.961959183216095,
0.9146212339401245,
-0.12274777889251709,
0.5667226910591125,
0.20142509043216705,
0.30348390340805054,
-0.34187814593315125,
0.7106276154518127,
-0.33621880412101746,
-0.060758333653211594,
-0.16790121793746948,
-1.2594858407974243,
-0.26471182703971863,
0.23380328714847565,
-0.2283899039030075,
-0.14717410504817963,
0.6532397866249084,
0.3833029568195343,
-0.16851402819156647,
0.08351804316043854,
0.0658106803894043,
-0.19534774124622345,
0.5653294324874878,
0.48204588890075684,
0.6498753428459167,
-0.35112062096595764,
0.9161192774772644,
-0.4841720461845398,
-0.17690695822238922,
-0.27396997809410095,
-0.842473030090332,
-0.8647761344909668,
-0.2441967874765396,
-0.030315514653921127,
-0.34093981981277466,
0.04256962984800339,
0.7490862607955933,
0.5593612194061279,
-0.6014627814292908,
-0.05957761034369469,
0.007821385748684406,
-0.00915607251226902,
-0.23912882804870605,
-0.2388526201248169,
0.5673936009407043,
-0.38303065299987793,
-0.7631646394729614,
0.17501412332057953,
0.27698060870170593,
-0.04458398371934891,
-0.06345471739768982,
0.08719859272241592,
0.23863014578819275,
0.15049172937870026,
0.7250293493270874,
0.42005088925361633,
-0.4906317889690399,
-0.49468114972114563,
0.22760750353336334,
0.0070938607677817345,
0.11392490565776825,
0.9383475184440613,
-0.9199012517929077,
0.4638417959213257,
0.7225039601325989,
0.9186481833457947,
0.7463953495025635,
-0.12078439444303513,
-0.038745567202568054,
-0.6081090569496155,
0.44669684767723083,
0.4678526222705841,
0.31161171197891235,
0.049835026264190674,
-0.3501715660095215,
0.266488254070282,
0.32869425415992737,
-0.7944993376731873,
-0.8134254813194275,
0.17164409160614014,
-0.9277575612068176,
-0.33797508478164673,
1.03508460521698,
0.08943118900060654,
-0.40127280354499817,
0.02380312979221344,
-0.20636658370494843,
0.3336995542049408,
-0.0931839793920517,
1.1603031158447266,
0.6492567658424377,
-0.11621896922588348,
0.1610896736383438,
-0.34152621030807495,
0.7960253953933716,
0.5497416257858276,
-0.8245716691017151,
-0.01672687567770481,
0.1380273997783661,
-0.0021093571558594704,
0.47140175104141235,
0.2255432903766632,
-0.09180398285388947,
0.17105050384998322,
-0.11938498914241791,
-0.148152157664299,
-0.11856827139854431,
-0.5800319910049438,
-0.23753081262111664,
0.17771026492118835,
-0.14604933559894562,
-0.06395849585533142
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.12556v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.12556v1
|
Factorized Learning Assisted with Large Language Model for Gloss-free Sign Language Translation
| 2024-03-19T09:00:23 | 2024-03-19T09:00:23 |
Zhigang Chen, Benjia Zhou, Jun Li, Jun Wan, Zhen Lei, Ning Jiang, Quan Lu, Guoqing Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Previous Sign Language Translation (SLT) methods achieve superior performance
by relying on gloss annotations. However, labeling high-quality glosses is a
labor-intensive task, which limits the further development of SLT. Although
some approaches work towards gloss-free SLT through jointly training the visual
encoder and translation network, these efforts still suffer from poor
performance and inefficient use of the powerful Large Language Model (LLM).
Most seriously, we find that directly introducing LLM into SLT will lead to
insufficient learning of visual representations as LLM dominates the learning
curve. To address these problems, we propose Factorized Learning assisted with
Large Language Model (FLa-LLM) for gloss-free SLT. Concretely, we factorize the
training process into two stages. In the visual initialing stage, we employ a
lightweight translation model after the visual encoder to pre-train the visual
encoder. In the LLM fine-tuning stage, we freeze the acquired knowledge in the
visual encoder and integrate it with a pre-trained LLM to inspire the LLM's
translation potential. This factorized training strategy proves to be highly
effective as evidenced by significant improvements achieved across three SLT
datasets which are all conducted under the gloss-free setting.
|
[
-0.22551558911800385,
-0.488262802362442,
0.5446045398712158,
0.06569138914346695,
-0.698327362537384,
0.1898702085018158,
-0.1927844136953354,
-0.6285189390182495,
0.30312874913215637,
0.5020018219947815,
-0.4313657283782959,
-0.40012961626052856,
-0.9146866798400879,
0.018761103972792625,
-0.1153673380613327,
1.0394798517227173,
-0.2990058958530426,
0.5068982839584351,
0.027794942259788513,
-0.13552379608154297,
-0.2086167186498642,
-0.36840328574180603,
-0.8924334049224854,
-0.47410282492637634,
0.2991252541542053,
0.4048612415790558,
0.8483346104621887,
0.34575748443603516,
0.49361124634742737,
0.22867827117443085,
-0.0709124282002449,
0.4241843819618225,
-0.43709468841552734,
-0.014656612649559975,
0.19117313623428345,
-0.29046913981437683,
-0.81927889585495,
-0.050849273800849915,
0.5992459654808044,
0.7229935526847839,
0.2038775384426117,
-0.005255853291600943,
-0.15869645774364471,
0.6038750410079956,
-0.1855132281780243,
0.5885696411132812,
-0.4014210104942322,
0.11716651171445847,
-0.08566654473543167,
-0.09212761372327805,
-0.3380189836025238,
-0.14312420785427094,
-0.024401698261499405,
-0.7967755794525146,
0.2998182475566864,
0.28909778594970703,
0.5636919736862183,
0.3013737201690674,
-0.7148758769035339,
-0.41916027665138245,
-0.7930834889411926,
0.4656067490577698,
-0.6733083724975586,
0.6744896173477173,
0.425752729177475,
0.049842771142721176,
-0.1871882826089859,
-0.2938123643398285,
-0.5038426518440247,
-0.42964231967926025,
0.003929795231670141,
0.10088752955198288,
0.3325682580471039,
0.30241408944129944,
0.30620628595352173,
0.4361237585544586,
-0.432963490486145,
0.08303001523017883,
-0.3070402443408966,
-0.3197586238384247,
0.7629965543746948,
-0.1267184615135193,
0.3763584494590759,
0.1681079864501953,
-0.5325857996940613,
-0.14182353019714355,
-0.6578389406204224,
-0.12589441239833832,
-0.2286933958530426,
0.7032673954963684,
-0.20707179605960846,
0.5901167988777161,
-0.044459182769060135,
0.4519405961036682,
0.08160001784563065,
-0.36464837193489075,
0.40304115414619446,
-0.11955851316452026,
-0.06180091202259064,
-0.07840411365032196,
0.8404894471168518,
0.06293287128210068,
0.4573054313659668,
-0.1242169663310051,
-0.8372333645820618,
-0.32070547342300415,
-0.23175838589668274,
-0.7877931594848633,
0.14736762642860413,
0.10927953571081161,
0.004897909704595804,
0.11525754630565643,
0.05330958589911461,
-0.3839448392391205,
-0.5554699301719666,
-0.5595422387123108,
0.6608957648277283,
-0.5050551891326904,
-0.40773817896842957,
0.05723397806286812,
0.40851056575775146,
0.15670570731163025,
0.5870510935783386,
-0.9716485142707825,
0.28863126039505005,
0.7619135975837708,
0.9934419393539429,
-0.26396849751472473,
-0.040944479405879974,
-1.0198513269424438,
0.00783309992402792,
-0.471483051776886,
0.17293113470077515,
-0.2291058450937271,
-0.372879296541214,
0.18956583738327026,
-0.21128369867801666,
-0.11587642878293991,
-0.38134074211120605,
0.23104901611804962,
-0.7958885431289673,
-0.08884109556674957,
-0.1768009066581726,
-0.6553574204444885,
-0.18947942554950714,
-0.19487214088439941,
-0.6118494868278503,
0.7911686897277832,
0.1954515427350998,
-0.240327388048172,
0.59394371509552,
-0.5972951650619507,
-0.7105207443237305,
0.45506954193115234,
-0.169601708650589,
-0.40338170528411865,
0.41173994541168213,
0.34813106060028076,
0.5936160087585449,
-0.25948700308799744,
0.4638110101222992,
-0.016671501100063324,
-0.2762860059738159,
0.10828572511672974,
-0.0741068422794342,
0.5874611139297485,
0.08115953207015991,
-0.586936354637146,
0.4454730451107025,
-0.6694797277450562,
-0.40888747572898865,
0.15649017691612244,
-0.2569705545902252,
-0.3044527471065521,
-0.44516521692276,
0.1879444420337677,
0.49062296748161316,
0.3137722909450531,
-0.5855965614318848,
0.11820372939109802,
-0.3362347483634949,
-0.06980625540018082,
0.6299289464950562,
-0.08412756025791168,
0.5379877090454102,
0.2714277505874634,
0.6657360196113586,
0.1301906555891037,
0.36146730184555054,
0.2480575293302536,
-0.5580857396125793,
-1.3774386644363403,
-0.06405629217624664,
0.15479734539985657,
0.4602503180503845,
-1.382423996925354,
0.303426057100296,
-0.28686580061912537,
-0.15095753967761993,
-0.36053264141082764,
0.49972599744796753,
0.6084608435630798,
0.15964090824127197,
0.5582520961761475,
-0.5581489205360413,
0.04395147040486336,
-0.5453543663024902,
0.40925413370132446,
0.05924716964364052,
-0.048877134919166565,
-0.08591568470001221,
0.7424055337905884,
0.10454824566841125,
0.4687484800815582,
-0.46265941858291626,
-0.804226815700531,
-0.29767143726348877,
0.12333110719919205,
0.03186320886015892,
0.40185150504112244,
0.24064892530441284,
-0.8779056668281555,
-0.6062096953392029,
0.17728160321712494,
-0.6056081652641296,
0.028159910812973976,
-0.3168452978134155,
-0.03916846588253975,
0.1888285130262375,
0.7564943432807922,
-0.3501712679862976,
0.23784025013446808,
0.5861515998840332,
-0.6367886066436768,
0.3596813976764679,
-0.35329362750053406,
-0.057700544595718384,
-0.9180222153663635,
-0.05952051281929016,
0.13306201994419098,
-0.40406334400177,
-0.9267171621322632,
0.24300721287727356,
0.22737127542495728,
-0.40244171023368835,
-0.3978607654571533,
0.49146848917007446,
-0.7903429269790649,
-0.146845743060112,
-0.42714518308639526,
0.3369334042072296,
-0.286837100982666,
0.5625097751617432,
0.3418862819671631,
0.9181548953056335,
0.6587644815444946,
-0.4511171579360962,
0.041307415813207626,
0.3668419122695923,
-0.31075596809387207,
0.41257625818252563,
-0.4050213098526001,
0.09664243459701538,
-0.1435953676700592,
0.08678587526082993,
-0.6659550666809082,
-0.10821817815303802,
0.33453503251075745,
-0.07354320585727692,
0.7413197755813599,
0.0022102296352386475,
-0.5120192170143127,
-0.18596479296684265,
0.01746414415538311,
0.2142951339483261,
0.31253886222839355,
-0.6178665161132812,
0.7585368752479553,
0.144733726978302,
-0.11563718318939209,
-0.26173490285873413,
-0.5874465703964233,
0.060754984617233276,
0.16621148586273193,
-0.5555756092071533,
-0.03371459245681763,
-0.10541825741529465,
0.1513810008764267,
-0.5205165147781372,
-0.17287461459636688,
0.12557581067085266,
-0.0672370195388794,
0.14889399707317352,
0.1933736652135849,
-0.2959403991699219,
0.29822081327438354,
-0.23293377459049225,
-0.4761926233768463,
-0.10552682727575302,
-0.3003431558609009,
0.4409778118133545,
-0.2540868818759918,
-0.4514206349849701,
-0.2857494056224823,
0.20413950085639954,
0.7555056214332581,
-0.576073944568634,
0.9721839427947998,
0.8515481352806091,
-0.07174201309680939,
-0.26549601554870605,
-0.40458446741104126,
-0.21273252367973328,
-0.47873324155807495,
0.22369833290576935,
-0.3568681478500366,
-1.1563206911087036,
0.39007413387298584,
-0.1500329077243805,
0.05647512152791023,
0.12283598631620407,
0.15901687741279602,
0.19983530044555664,
0.9935052394866943,
0.8375862836837769,
0.2556094229221344,
0.7218411564826965,
-0.24153929948806763,
0.14896592497825623,
-0.8421630263328552,
-0.28555935621261597,
0.14693467319011688,
-0.019593067467212677,
-0.2635825276374817,
-0.8688881993293762,
0.5468799471855164,
0.28206098079681396,
-0.14195546507835388,
0.28955796360969543,
-0.1089184507727623,
0.17206180095672607,
0.3835808336734772,
0.18949207663536072,
0.4811592102050781,
0.08061495423316956,
-0.2515830397605896,
0.08225912600755692,
-0.5382415056228638,
-0.07927722483873367,
0.990073025226593,
0.45266395807266235,
0.4866982102394104,
0.2762506604194641,
0.7359199523925781,
-0.06150742247700691,
0.521708071231842,
-0.9814141392707825,
0.7774533629417419,
-0.3186824917793274,
-0.33773985505104065,
-0.39920344948768616,
-0.43765485286712646,
-0.5580443143844604,
0.47008076310157776,
-0.520207941532135,
-0.35171109437942505,
0.21831026673316956,
0.21526303887367249,
0.029944341629743576,
0.25422969460487366,
-0.628605842590332,
0.55507493019104,
-0.6608301401138306,
-0.3682270348072052,
-0.11598318815231323,
-0.483890175819397,
0.4296529293060303,
-0.5359713435173035,
0.3609493374824524,
-0.1372850090265274,
-0.2593947649002075,
0.7299251556396484,
-0.7076910734176636,
0.9510233998298645,
-0.39104902744293213,
-0.5993783473968506,
-0.03828215226531029,
0.20092441141605377,
0.7021686434745789,
-0.1227908581495285,
0.10611706227064133,
0.08793319016695023,
-0.6490018963813782,
-0.40723028779029846,
-0.4794260859489441,
0.407505065202713,
-0.570209801197052,
-0.6336506009101868,
-0.5633059144020081,
-0.516179621219635,
-0.5813336372375488,
0.2684408724308014,
0.03873026743531227,
0.44949737191200256,
-0.0004941161605529487,
-0.05424007400870323,
0.7373793721199036,
0.0077607352286577225,
0.3122308850288391,
0.6441731452941895,
-0.6340165734291077,
-0.5440431833267212,
1.120126485824585,
0.046784982085227966,
0.7058652639389038,
0.44675007462501526,
0.2860110402107239,
-0.3294934332370758,
-0.9556838274002075,
-0.37268301844596863,
0.6038835644721985,
-0.6856464147567749,
-0.16007593274116516,
-0.14116908609867096,
0.0015144398203119636,
-0.2792617678642273,
-0.18033379316329956,
-0.4787822365760803,
-0.24114809930324554,
-0.23866374790668488,
-0.1191178411245346,
0.48254674673080444,
0.8433658480644226,
0.05457943305373192,
0.4592509865760803,
-0.41709986329078674,
0.40831154584884644,
0.2800377607345581,
0.5451765656471252,
0.1527661830186844,
-0.495792955160141,
-0.4635496735572815,
-0.12209615111351013,
0.09574181586503983,
-0.518777072429657,
0.25737833976745605,
0.39499586820602417,
0.1937836855649948,
0.5119830369949341,
-0.013738039880990982,
0.4988629221916199,
-0.4209584593772888,
0.5701004862785339,
0.6382323503494263,
-0.9135335683822632,
0.440107136964798,
-0.3406044542789459,
0.5645026564598083,
0.47218674421310425,
0.5617144107818604,
-0.4771174192428589,
-0.4766920506954193,
-0.20896565914154053,
-1.0565440654754639,
0.5966989398002625,
0.21713480353355408,
-0.1482127159833908,
0.036559537053108215,
0.17491093277931213,
0.11121156811714172,
0.1651380956172943,
-0.8779400587081909,
-0.2560488283634186,
-0.08049959689378738,
0.026408541947603226,
-0.5090954303741455,
-0.1621834933757782,
-0.014621087349951267,
-0.43451735377311707,
1.0057424306869507,
-0.4509233236312866,
-0.11618918180465698,
0.07956236600875854,
-0.5553666353225708,
-0.3017049729824066,
0.10092318058013916,
0.6754279732704163,
0.5138661861419678,
-0.10992719233036041,
-0.03720467537641525,
0.16006453335285187,
-0.6330438256263733,
0.1396574079990387,
-0.028759939596056938,
-0.6047348976135254,
-0.24007828533649445,
0.58737713098526,
1.3129236698150635,
0.4481360912322998,
-0.4211771488189697,
0.6271241307258606,
0.10193666070699692,
-0.30405014753341675,
-0.20488154888153076,
-0.009291461668908596,
0.1935405284166336,
0.10498090833425522,
0.5102997422218323,
-0.045213732868433,
-0.3207263648509979,
-0.23426303267478943,
0.12652532756328583,
0.4730433225631714,
-0.643958568572998,
-0.2032051384449005,
0.7491491436958313,
0.5584242343902588,
-0.19398005306720734,
0.4175543487071991,
-0.1819743514060974,
-0.6268335580825806,
0.16103138029575348,
0.5771955847740173,
0.850230872631073,
-0.33674174547195435,
0.47110259532928467,
0.39500388503074646,
0.36176997423171997,
-0.08747590333223343,
0.26751112937927246,
-0.02911536768078804,
-0.5785906910896301,
-0.576640248298645,
-0.9307849407196045,
-0.2744930386543274,
0.29889583587646484,
-0.38853251934051514,
0.10799995064735413,
-0.6481735110282898,
-0.041117340326309204,
-0.3079170286655426,
0.0738409012556076,
-0.7085860967636108,
0.3058289587497711,
0.5278281569480896,
0.8052644729614258,
-1.1083707809448242,
0.8988958597183228,
0.4831351637840271,
-0.7706349492073059,
-0.6555284261703491,
0.0686039924621582,
0.09175760298967361,
-0.7583596706390381,
0.702444851398468,
0.07935360074043274,
-0.41824716329574585,
0.09674029052257538,
-0.3434101641178131,
-1.0642459392547607,
1.0461426973342896,
0.28994083404541016,
-0.6477669477462769,
0.297343373298645,
0.4285884499549866,
0.6868913173675537,
-0.5931047201156616,
-0.05214487388730049,
0.3749939501285553,
0.4670596122741699,
0.33200353384017944,
-0.9778197407722473,
0.34575217962265015,
0.06945262849330902,
0.09443678706884384,
0.30912715196609497,
-0.6990517377853394,
0.5299723744392395,
-0.3063373267650604,
-0.4529486894607544,
-0.12505345046520233,
0.9816417098045349,
-0.18857355415821075,
0.05378121882677078,
0.6842367649078369,
0.10683481395244598,
0.7676111459732056,
-0.058845385909080505,
0.8565009832382202,
-0.1983112096786499,
0.15309010446071625,
0.9554219245910645,
-0.20589257776737213,
0.9963054060935974,
0.5070802569389343,
-0.058623142540454865,
-0.03133004903793335,
0.2628757357597351,
0.16658441722393036,
0.15829558670520782,
0.015395964495837688,
-0.4910005033016205,
-0.5834683775901794,
-0.06542177498340607,
-0.20917026698589325,
0.3856569528579712,
0.5286949872970581,
-0.3200775384902954,
-0.16161294281482697,
0.4249619245529175,
-0.033903468400239944,
0.08689635246992111,
-0.5120863914489746,
0.7307896018028259,
0.40028050541877747,
-0.4455302059650421,
0.7919320464134216,
-0.2286112755537033,
0.9968384504318237,
-0.8587021231651306,
0.12125465273857117,
-0.3725466728210449,
0.04293947294354439,
-0.1752016842365265,
-0.5410460829734802,
-0.22927387058734894,
-0.31771120429039,
0.17853707075119019,
-0.44663769006729126,
0.5979776978492737,
-0.8687309622764587,
-0.6883530616760254,
0.5297262668609619,
0.6335265636444092,
0.15811800956726074,
0.14887800812721252,
-0.650974690914154,
0.01161845400929451,
0.1338007003068924,
-0.2841942012310028,
0.5662549734115601,
0.2200416475534439,
-0.366242915391922,
0.7682459950447083,
0.7606174349784851,
0.20474892854690552,
-0.04792100191116333,
0.4762583076953888,
0.7551001310348511,
-0.4417186379432678,
-0.36931583285331726,
-0.27127015590667725,
0.3097827136516571,
0.052417173981666565,
-0.33251526951789856,
0.5437813997268677,
0.5219843983650208,
0.5736256837844849,
-0.3602758049964905,
0.4413353204727173,
0.09299718588590622,
-0.07046204060316086,
-0.8420714139938354,
0.7468669414520264,
-0.7218541502952576,
0.11284660547971725,
-0.241586372256279,
-1.0637009143829346,
-0.5570953488349915,
0.4162439703941345,
-0.3568670451641083,
0.03863834589719772,
0.7688727974891663,
0.8453865051269531,
-0.13744013011455536,
-0.08448074012994766,
0.6384360194206238,
0.1572839617729187,
0.44887447357177734,
0.5325953364372253,
0.15462954342365265,
-0.4769073724746704,
0.5284697413444519,
-0.31447678804397583,
-0.4735954999923706,
-0.3803756535053253,
-0.8707295060157776,
-0.9244092702865601,
-0.9134126901626587,
-0.5176639556884766,
-0.09654930979013443,
-0.08753006160259247,
1.0401047468185425,
0.6118070483207703,
-1.0464166402816772,
-0.3033433258533478,
-0.03475380688905716,
-0.12362870573997498,
-0.38757872581481934,
-0.1359070986509323,
0.48770755529403687,
-0.3581411838531494,
-0.6303989291191101,
0.7078614234924316,
0.06439178436994553,
0.3338974714279175,
-0.34250062704086304,
-0.4356817305088043,
-0.329314649105072,
-0.20125290751457214,
0.9482528567314148,
0.36167412996292114,
-0.620899498462677,
-0.5113846659660339,
-0.39882516860961914,
-0.02625146321952343,
0.0566275492310524,
0.9370753169059753,
-0.40328121185302734,
0.5515364408493042,
0.3292314112186432,
0.33345791697502136,
0.8596383929252625,
-0.03681149333715439,
0.7167429327964783,
-0.9186007976531982,
0.22170138359069824,
-0.007361866999417543,
0.3499746322631836,
0.7406643033027649,
-0.35179492831230164,
0.5604264140129089,
0.11729401350021362,
-0.27903613448143005,
-0.3350849747657776,
0.385768324136734,
-1.1908369064331055,
-0.06770158559083939,
1.3312897682189941,
0.0068752216175198555,
-0.1319642812013626,
-0.2650323510169983,
-0.1563255935907364,
0.36110392212867737,
-0.5270006060600281,
0.31443139910697937,
0.4823421239852905,
-0.27459609508514404,
-0.2853638827800751,
-0.6022645235061646,
0.7757698893547058,
0.21352960169315338,
-0.4510270655155182,
0.28756603598594666,
0.5925768613815308,
0.24820052087306976,
0.3420712947845459,
0.7140658497810364,
0.07242279499769211,
0.18165245652198792,
0.0960790365934372,
0.17139117419719696,
-0.4488752782344818,
-0.3115590214729309,
-0.4388577938079834,
0.10725091397762299,
0.45984554290771484,
0.0933382660150528
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.12526v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.12526v1
|
Prompt-based Graph Model for Joint Liberal Event Extraction and Event Schema Induction
| 2024-03-19T07:56:42 | 2024-03-19T07:56:42 |
Haochen Li, Di Geng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Events are essential components of speech and texts, describing the changes
in the state of entities. The event extraction task aims to identify and
classify events and find their participants according to event schemas.
Manually predefined event schemas have limited coverage and are hard to migrate
across domains. Therefore, the researchers propose Liberal Event Extraction
(LEE), which aims to extract events and discover event schemas simultaneously.
However, existing LEE models rely heavily on external language knowledge bases
and require the manual development of numerous rules for noise removal and
knowledge alignment, which is complex and laborious. To this end, we propose a
Prompt-based Graph Model for Liberal Event Extraction (PGLEE). Specifically, we
use a prompt-based model to obtain candidate triggers and arguments, and then
build heterogeneous event graphs to encode the structures within and between
events. Experimental results prove that our approach achieves excellent
performance with or without predefined event schemas, while the automatically
detected event schemas are proven high quality.
|
[
-0.15877194702625275,
-0.9602501392364502,
0.7759040594100952,
0.03261737525463104,
-0.0811300054192543,
-0.029718317091464996,
-0.2613022029399872,
-0.28171306848526,
0.16745661199092865,
0.4184015691280365,
-0.6835291981697083,
-0.6042068004608154,
-0.2812020182609558,
0.152846097946167,
-0.19959361851215363,
0.9443613290786743,
0.11295142769813538,
-0.3114147186279297,
0.14104700088500977,
-0.06638859957456589,
-0.4654332101345062,
-0.27186256647109985,
-0.8444728255271912,
-0.22904102504253387,
0.5060528516769409,
0.3606830835342407,
0.576653003692627,
0.5894524455070496,
-0.02237752638757229,
0.1833920180797577,
-0.10627847164869308,
0.34446215629577637,
-0.384714812040329,
0.08003585785627365,
-0.3119142949581146,
-0.09720269590616226,
-0.36119508743286133,
0.38643062114715576,
0.8886155486106873,
0.8562783002853394,
-0.12703512609004974,
0.033369943499565125,
0.10934942215681076,
0.09878704696893692,
-0.5241236686706543,
0.3698040843009949,
-0.6181639432907104,
0.06337516754865646,
-0.2037522792816162,
-0.4402294456958771,
-0.7149490118026733,
-0.5699610114097595,
-0.18374313414096832,
-0.9084136486053467,
0.19610537588596344,
0.20806139707565308,
0.8950433731079102,
-0.2273484319448471,
-0.3871104419231415,
-0.39327287673950195,
-0.4321659803390503,
0.5849257111549377,
-0.4380146563053131,
0.5666083097457886,
0.19584298133850098,
0.09078894555568695,
-0.3896850347518921,
-1.0588799715042114,
-0.7586517930030823,
-0.1985148936510086,
-0.3351263999938965,
0.03129199892282486,
-0.2914077043533325,
0.10159801691770554,
0.8344205021858215,
-0.13517121970653534,
-0.7175410389900208,
0.3342163860797882,
-0.1528887003660202,
-0.40793266892433167,
0.7089252471923828,
0.4340664744377136,
0.6914677619934082,
-0.6893631219863892,
-0.26121118664741516,
0.34224551916122437,
-0.4839355945587158,
0.2977813184261322,
0.5813530087471008,
0.6902014017105103,
-0.16047056019306183,
0.494556188583374,
-0.4653303027153015,
0.7308869957923889,
0.23340469598770142,
-0.38963714241981506,
0.26714327931404114,
-0.5942039489746094,
-0.04659881815314293,
0.13866081833839417,
1.1605790853500366,
0.3739716708660126,
0.14202997088432312,
-0.4815673232078552,
-0.13844610750675201,
0.05084699019789696,
-0.5603039264678955,
-0.7762969136238098,
-0.31917524337768555,
0.30747362971305847,
-0.7822716236114502,
-0.2552620768547058,
-0.16756266355514526,
-1.0405250787734985,
-0.8257409930229187,
-0.3790005147457123,
0.12214861810207367,
-0.36330482363700867,
-0.4814992845058441,
-0.19044971466064453,
-0.2820419371128082,
0.21262460947036743,
0.43320968747138977,
-0.5622411370277405,
0.08683565258979797,
0.596478283405304,
0.9116905331611633,
-0.34750449657440186,
-0.10305701941251755,
-1.5831701755523682,
-0.010406388901174068,
-0.10017824918031693,
0.6660673022270203,
-0.7925718426704407,
-0.5688377022743225,
0.18483838438987732,
0.4152226150035858,
-0.1403505653142929,
-0.2184126079082489,
0.44466352462768555,
-0.6094674468040466,
0.5203421115875244,
-0.5354107022285461,
-0.8370280861854553,
0.13245604932308197,
-0.06169816851615906,
-0.7374579906463623,
0.8502479195594788,
0.05130598694086075,
-0.9101464152336121,
0.3609910011291504,
-0.8755446076393127,
-0.37202417850494385,
0.46429359912872314,
-0.5322907567024231,
-0.11753528565168381,
-0.4008162021636963,
0.4355108439922333,
0.42239877581596375,
-0.3262726962566376,
0.6499407291412354,
-0.4221644401550293,
-0.1699894815683365,
0.1424969881772995,
-0.14171572029590607,
1.502684235572815,
0.147670716047287,
-0.1597575694322586,
0.4530753493309021,
-1.0520386695861816,
-0.2695898115634918,
0.10047782212495804,
-0.08828944712877274,
-0.06780276447534561,
-0.02415412664413452,
-0.04470039904117584,
0.3257814347743988,
0.1589435338973999,
-0.5874564051628113,
0.4108215570449829,
-0.42012548446655273,
0.1988709568977356,
0.6598793864250183,
0.5071736574172974,
0.9440374374389648,
0.04878728464245796,
0.6407931447029114,
-0.05607808753848076,
0.08614896237850189,
-0.37791579961776733,
-0.6910625100135803,
0.016143804416060448,
-0.325543612241745,
0.13424788415431976,
0.8531818389892578,
-0.81703782081604,
0.4416479766368866,
0.08214707672595978,
-0.17250850796699524,
-0.06150469928979874,
-0.11244398355484009,
-0.21341878175735474,
1.0638991594314575,
0.1869017481803894,
0.014434047043323517,
-0.5795342922210693,
-0.3987780809402466,
-0.18959806859493256,
-0.27849864959716797,
0.12350049614906311,
0.014801222831010818,
0.07538516819477081,
-0.04590941220521927,
1.1053352355957031,
-0.4936814308166504,
0.09861315786838531,
-0.37442469596862793,
0.28750139474868774,
0.35030752420425415,
0.2441532164812088,
0.38605454564094543,
-0.7219443321228027,
-0.3077077269554138,
0.27224287390708923,
-0.8209574222564697,
-0.5110620856285095,
-0.3656826913356781,
-0.14049600064754486,
0.12688082456588745,
0.8072061538696289,
-0.5363233685493469,
0.6641173958778381,
0.11780869960784912,
-0.5866373181343079,
0.8089589476585388,
0.4060080349445343,
0.07967493683099747,
-1.0037896633148193,
0.10169143229722977,
-0.1866789311170578,
-0.39526742696762085,
-0.6678330898284912,
-0.4396761357784271,
0.1004355251789093,
-0.3925623297691345,
-0.348137229681015,
0.7374787330627441,
-0.4173504114151001,
-0.19001194834709167,
-0.18697847425937653,
0.5582773089408875,
0.1475083976984024,
0.3490539789199829,
0.11302700638771057,
0.44514593482017517,
0.5914223790168762,
-0.6744641661643982,
0.4962555170059204,
0.3926054537296295,
-0.23850630223751068,
0.5816708207130432,
-0.42199310660362244,
-0.027327552437782288,
-0.12770028412342072,
0.16521598398685455,
-0.895980179309845,
-0.16064471006393433,
0.668350875377655,
-0.24863849580287933,
0.24415597319602966,
-0.3904372751712799,
-0.38259240984916687,
-0.17038163542747498,
0.06338150799274445,
-0.11417645215988159,
0.6142930388450623,
-0.5034468173980713,
0.9324782490730286,
0.5036880970001221,
-0.4177587330341339,
-0.5945257544517517,
-0.11711849272251129,
-0.05319763347506523,
-0.2200324386358261,
-0.4561667740345001,
0.1346665620803833,
0.11303116381168365,
-0.2614390254020691,
0.32926473021507263,
0.359708309173584,
0.21904811263084412,
0.01013941504061222,
0.4608525335788727,
0.47852909564971924,
-0.25026735663414,
0.39151889085769653,
-0.045960184186697006,
-0.2312251180410385,
0.013054968789219856,
-0.4171178936958313,
0.4873250126838684,
0.1610584408044815,
-0.44082263112068176,
-1.0321383476257324,
0.6705299615859985,
0.4194909632205963,
-0.49684855341911316,
0.7307818531990051,
0.9532695412635803,
-0.6102242469787598,
-0.11203731596469879,
-0.3149830400943756,
-0.3845977187156677,
-0.4054168164730072,
0.29775241017341614,
-0.24500297009944916,
-0.603967547416687,
0.8848004341125488,
-0.41046345233917236,
0.026050100103020668,
0.5076729655265808,
0.42250117659568787,
-0.02448434568941593,
1.085983395576477,
0.3607984483242035,
0.19254866242408752,
0.8478904366493225,
-0.0073889694176614285,
0.10165680199861526,
-0.6786831617355347,
-0.05654764547944069,
-0.5910295248031616,
0.091265469789505,
-0.3424603044986725,
-0.14740484952926636,
0.04780792072415352,
0.14056101441383362,
-0.17066818475723267,
0.0443686917424202,
-0.4030269980430603,
0.45836448669433594,
0.3990241289138794,
-0.13655906915664673,
0.23787106573581696,
-0.0996469110250473,
0.0071500614285469055,
-0.15994372963905334,
-0.921168327331543,
-0.5858315825462341,
0.8411861658096313,
0.08004925400018692,
0.3209593892097473,
-0.3118864595890045,
0.9075881838798523,
0.22327838838100433,
0.3504927456378937,
-0.43261173367500305,
0.6040000915527344,
0.1437915414571762,
-0.3461603820323944,
-0.5766749382019043,
-0.5281254649162292,
-0.9118554592132568,
-0.14415770769119263,
-0.339124470949173,
-1.241897702217102,
0.6103871464729309,
-0.06980543583631516,
-0.5075618624687195,
0.45801758766174316,
-0.4354766607284546,
1.1720398664474487,
0.17913387715816498,
-0.22389516234397888,
0.19126564264297485,
-0.5111082792282104,
0.23442786931991577,
0.2713651657104492,
0.6261995434761047,
-0.4765089452266693,
0.24369372427463531,
1.0828993320465088,
-0.09308300912380219,
0.7619748711585999,
-0.520258367061615,
0.08612499386072159,
0.6174370050430298,
0.18781469762325287,
1.0781497955322266,
0.29225391149520874,
-0.30173879861831665,
-0.27713942527770996,
-0.03351830318570137,
-0.1553972065448761,
-0.6363150477409363,
0.4714244604110718,
-0.5215344429016113,
-0.34696024656295776,
-0.033122483640909195,
-0.62193363904953,
-0.06589954346418381,
0.17543277144432068,
0.4111446142196655,
0.9062789082527161,
-0.28778740763664246,
-0.2732228934764862,
0.40668219327926636,
-0.23431487381458282,
0.6191529035568237,
0.3349779546260834,
-0.6910645961761475,
-0.1781335175037384,
0.9936060309410095,
0.33663955330848694,
0.16357414424419403,
-0.03864752873778343,
0.20255446434020996,
-0.4159637689590454,
-0.48117464780807495,
-0.42003878951072693,
0.19875401258468628,
-1.1327142715454102,
-0.21874593198299408,
-1.2477048635482788,
0.03819410130381584,
-0.5468848347663879,
-0.3061700165271759,
0.06503593921661377,
-0.5379381775856018,
-0.7786960601806641,
-0.23638379573822021,
0.296592652797699,
0.5085305571556091,
-0.4586602747440338,
0.2768903076648712,
-0.695299506187439,
0.6014661192893982,
0.2877807021141052,
-0.10623161494731903,
-0.2607991695404053,
-0.3628234267234802,
0.16857215762138367,
-0.27352985739707947,
-0.17345841228961945,
-1.544931173324585,
0.283332884311676,
0.2415192723274231,
0.8008012175559998,
0.3711704909801483,
0.4038246273994446,
0.415593683719635,
-0.4899570047855377,
0.8769977688789368,
0.3635358512401581,
-0.9355399012565613,
0.8481376767158508,
-0.3251844346523285,
-0.16600382328033447,
0.24525995552539825,
0.4041016697883606,
-0.6464073657989502,
-0.320230096578598,
-0.9233171343803406,
-0.6338121891021729,
0.8441754579544067,
-0.2647151052951813,
-0.2699406147003174,
-0.1436368077993393,
0.3126569986343384,
0.28052473068237305,
-0.027584021911025047,
-0.7020139098167419,
-0.08449950069189072,
-0.05553906410932541,
-0.21159745752811432,
0.14718694984912872,
-0.11824247986078262,
-0.3363189399242401,
0.00785604678094387,
0.48364558815956116,
-0.3011535406112671,
-0.028705554082989693,
0.17469803988933563,
-0.09143394231796265,
-0.15335415303707123,
0.2935660481452942,
-0.005650407634675503,
0.6976455450057983,
0.061231084167957306,
-0.04563801735639572,
0.4417877495288849,
-0.07568105310201645,
-0.058915119618177414,
0.4733649492263794,
-0.36919158697128296,
0.13200324773788452,
0.6778337359428406,
0.9080362915992737,
0.11681906878948212,
-0.3821676969528198,
0.666021466255188,
-0.11535626649856567,
0.11519835889339447,
0.11920137703418732,
0.038095053285360336,
0.08624601364135742,
0.4201113283634186,
0.3509227931499481,
-0.29254627227783203,
0.38711461424827576,
-0.706577479839325,
0.46743521094322205,
0.3480437099933624,
-0.40329933166503906,
-0.3235321342945099,
0.5655137896537781,
0.25552451610565186,
-0.4436637759208679,
0.6339114904403687,
-0.8962313532829285,
-0.4540485739707947,
0.6352518200874329,
0.5784169435501099,
0.5947288870811462,
-0.04589236155152321,
0.5249468088150024,
0.7159430384635925,
0.2938043475151062,
0.3312326967716217,
0.6021614670753479,
0.15605658292770386,
-0.7133457660675049,
-0.580665647983551,
-0.5975396037101746,
-0.3654484450817108,
0.0737791657447815,
-0.6545461416244507,
0.5013942718505859,
-0.2220417857170105,
-0.22273021936416626,
0.24532108008861542,
0.06060714274644852,
-0.9050104022026062,
-0.058122195303440094,
0.258823424577713,
0.7769055962562561,
-1.1860716342926025,
0.5930495858192444,
0.3076712191104889,
-0.42562335729599,
-1.1456698179244995,
-0.23472243547439575,
0.059877265244722366,
-0.29417628049850464,
0.5136433243751526,
0.07045929878950119,
0.3921729326248169,
0.19739511609077454,
-0.4181203544139862,
-0.5290905237197876,
0.9454800486564636,
0.40926504135131836,
-0.8352106809616089,
-0.2479633092880249,
-0.36392679810523987,
-0.014592140913009644,
-0.5962424278259277,
0.021542008966207504,
0.50728440284729,
0.4995131194591522,
-0.126305490732193,
-0.7858012914657593,
0.2656562924385071,
0.20733200013637543,
-0.3789011538028717,
0.0676356628537178,
0.01784990169107914,
1.0740509033203125,
-0.265473335981369,
-0.80927973985672,
-0.2326657623052597,
0.8692633509635925,
0.2269609272480011,
0.7416492104530334,
0.604058563709259,
-0.11969904601573944,
1.6454468965530396,
-0.09346315264701843,
1.0372992753982544,
-0.22880497574806213,
0.30951687693595886,
1.2002286911010742,
-0.7091605067253113,
0.32426831126213074,
0.1529235690832138,
-0.05840825289487839,
0.6243600249290466,
0.5872604250907898,
0.47042641043663025,
0.46846041083335876,
-0.1699906587600708,
-0.266305536031723,
-0.4850352704524994,
-0.45995455980300903,
-0.4868125021457672,
0.20395779609680176,
0.5798057913780212,
-0.21873173117637634,
-0.2224445641040802,
0.3554735779762268,
-0.02951143868267536,
0.08733630180358887,
-0.3942590355873108,
0.7879911065101624,
-0.11787160485982895,
-0.5534063577651978,
0.04627523943781853,
-0.2765684127807617,
0.11940617859363556,
-0.509150505065918,
-0.03631306067109108,
0.05257769674062729,
-0.3601952791213989,
-0.16829079389572144,
-0.8881971836090088,
0.24434100091457367,
-0.17951637506484985,
-0.14017724990844727,
0.07704656571149826,
1.1226270198822021,
-0.47672009468078613,
-0.3044111728668213,
0.3946188688278198,
0.6998293995857239,
0.025682350620627403,
0.040305718779563904,
-0.5311338305473328,
0.38400450348854065,
-0.008538779802620411,
-0.4469074606895447,
-0.037688110023736954,
0.8354381918907166,
-0.32129982113838196,
0.20581063628196716,
0.9295614361763,
0.191153421998024,
-0.0075561245903372765,
0.2748658061027527,
0.830588161945343,
-0.5581105947494507,
-0.8836392164230347,
-0.85475093126297,
0.6255349516868591,
-0.7143418788909912,
-0.17230843007564545,
0.4147768020629883,
0.2901957035064697,
0.26693493127822876,
0.28194427490234375,
0.9784091114997864,
-0.02794422022998333,
0.4446522295475006,
-0.4932272136211395,
0.4614868760108948,
-0.21956562995910645,
-0.1197730302810669,
-0.3387867510318756,
-0.6523811221122742,
-0.23169921338558197,
0.4650418758392334,
-0.482144296169281,
-0.37629643082618713,
0.536202073097229,
0.811805248260498,
0.02587335929274559,
0.4686489701271057,
0.22797954082489014,
0.08163533359766006,
0.5447509288787842,
0.3369441330432892,
1.0582544803619385,
-0.07475098967552185,
0.37714916467666626,
-0.0023224842734634876,
-0.4110476076602936,
-0.4024151563644409,
-1.1121344566345215,
-0.8036641478538513,
-1.0409767627716064,
-0.7236037254333496,
-0.5674663186073303,
0.005239777732640505,
1.0645060539245605,
0.44926705956459045,
-0.8340238928794861,
0.26137030124664307,
0.12147780507802963,
0.3991067111492157,
-0.03557288646697998,
-0.28774839639663696,
0.657660961151123,
-0.5680304169654846,
-0.4737100899219513,
0.5671728253364563,
0.3240838348865509,
-0.07938668876886368,
0.24577532708644867,
-0.026735486462712288,
-0.29144173860549927,
0.08032544702291489,
0.43363696336746216,
0.5377458930015564,
-0.6084391474723816,
-0.5906437039375305,
-0.05087565258145332,
-0.1945149451494217,
-0.2576299011707306,
0.6471095681190491,
-0.8007153868675232,
0.40659385919570923,
0.5331392884254456,
0.3314966857433319,
0.25677821040153503,
-0.17606134712696075,
0.44564032554626465,
-0.7467895150184631,
0.4270000457763672,
0.19225530326366425,
0.5872482657432556,
0.3581334948539734,
-0.5375703573226929,
0.5089231133460999,
0.5176306962966919,
-0.5355243682861328,
-1.3322720527648926,
0.5292906165122986,
-0.9756764769554138,
-0.03668580949306488,
1.3742725849151611,
-0.07728645205497742,
-0.24685528874397278,
-0.44904598593711853,
-0.5688937306404114,
0.6627551317214966,
-0.21528637409210205,
0.13386449217796326,
0.5678588151931763,
-0.2945830225944519,
-0.06424931436777115,
-0.3719061315059662,
0.7612532377243042,
-0.35640183091163635,
-0.6731439828872681,
0.33458375930786133,
0.5714088082313538,
0.1671006828546524,
0.28635668754577637,
1.1502220630645752,
0.11729694902896881,
0.5818546414375305,
0.1762205958366394,
0.0684393048286438,
-0.20263825356960297,
-0.38787826895713806,
-0.23175863921642303,
0.6639102101325989,
-0.3268754482269287,
-0.22503253817558289
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.12523v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.12523v1
|
GraphERE: Jointly Multiple Event-Event Relation Extraction via Graph-Enhanced Event Embeddings
| 2024-03-19T07:50:32 | 2024-03-19T07:50:32 |
Haochen Li, Di Geng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Events describe the state changes of entities. In a document, multiple events
are connected by various relations (e.g., Coreference, Temporal, Causal, and
Subevent). Therefore, obtaining the connections between events through
Event-Event Relation Extraction (ERE) is critical to understand natural
language. There are two main problems in the current ERE works: a. Only
embeddings of the event triggers are used for event feature representation,
ignoring event arguments (e.g., time, place, person, etc.) and their structure
within the event. b. The interconnection between relations (e.g., temporal and
causal relations usually interact with each other ) is ignored. To solve the
above problems, this paper proposes a jointly multiple ERE framework called
GraphERE based on Graph-enhanced Event Embeddings. First, we enrich the event
embeddings with event argument and structure features by using static AMR
graphs and IE graphs; Then, to jointly extract multiple event relations, we use
Node Transformer and construct Task-specific Dynamic Event Graphs for each type
of relation. Finally, we used a multi-task learning strategy to train the whole
framework. Experimental results on the latest MAVEN-ERE dataset validate that
GraphERE significantly outperforms existing methods. Further analyses indicate
the effectiveness of the graph-enhanced event embeddings and the joint
extraction strategy.
|
[
-0.5857033133506775,
-0.9391695857048035,
0.6117020845413208,
-0.08093014359474182,
-0.1715160310268402,
-0.05135153979063034,
-0.20860737562179565,
-0.7517446875572205,
0.20661857724189758,
0.31080785393714905,
-0.6212693452835083,
-0.5561712980270386,
-0.7240582704544067,
0.11397430300712585,
-0.035195205360651016,
0.8814576268196106,
-0.4431474506855011,
-0.2231108844280243,
-0.018939143046736717,
-0.4820590913295746,
-0.44863054156303406,
-0.5538972020149231,
-0.7960448265075684,
-0.3824642300605774,
0.6568191647529602,
0.13099418580532074,
0.14322564005851746,
0.30994269251823425,
0.3919938802719116,
0.2861468195915222,
0.08767960965633392,
0.44567686319351196,
-0.49566414952278137,
0.4054195284843445,
0.12944920361042023,
-0.20168688893318176,
-0.6396299004554749,
-0.05087393894791603,
0.6304826736450195,
0.4219195544719696,
0.14882202446460724,
0.1722962111234665,
0.1879018098115921,
0.23726551234722137,
-0.777293860912323,
0.7117377519607544,
-0.43709123134613037,
0.024788403883576393,
-0.3337920308113098,
-0.018156660720705986,
-0.5702734589576721,
-0.06622640043497086,
-0.12141866981983185,
-0.7762085199356079,
0.14876343309879303,
0.07977274060249329,
1.1864545345306396,
-0.14042899012565613,
-0.5686553716659546,
-0.20874786376953125,
-0.6020132303237915,
0.6101944446563721,
-0.3356008231639862,
0.5535500645637512,
0.1055728867650032,
0.15038569271564484,
-0.12358754873275757,
-0.7939777970314026,
-0.3811245858669281,
-0.0914459303021431,
-0.3683868944644928,
0.25646618008613586,
-0.07059825956821442,
-0.038747891783714294,
0.33365657925605774,
0.10117347538471222,
-0.36939385533332825,
0.022843336686491966,
0.18373405933380127,
-0.07640198618173599,
0.39094278216362,
0.16661374270915985,
0.6056183576583862,
-0.31606367230415344,
-0.40157487988471985,
-0.06545937061309814,
-0.6156981587409973,
-0.31909462809562683,
0.2584949731826782,
0.28903284668922424,
-0.07572590559720993,
0.413594126701355,
0.2416771650314331,
0.46362510323524475,
-0.008664657361805439,
-0.058861758559942245,
0.31213754415512085,
-0.42449066042900085,
-0.15918180346488953,
-0.18684707581996918,
0.8930816650390625,
0.008459114469587803,
0.15583625435829163,
-0.4649302661418915,
0.17032156884670258,
0.22703814506530762,
-0.18743252754211426,
-0.6664522886276245,
-0.0139298802241683,
0.1434597671031952,
-0.3511200547218323,
-0.23835952579975128,
0.04642052575945854,
-1.1961116790771484,
-0.22439156472682953,
-0.16111861169338226,
0.23326389491558075,
-0.4651014804840088,
-0.29604506492614746,
-0.30070802569389343,
-0.37862616777420044,
-0.06639731675386429,
0.42722952365875244,
-0.6454893946647644,
0.4514200687408447,
0.5433472990989685,
0.7223373055458069,
-0.06730403006076813,
-0.5307565927505493,
-0.6560739278793335,
0.7312704920768738,
0.11526403576135635,
0.6837770342826843,
-0.7632749080657959,
-0.3554694652557373,
0.04623434320092201,
0.054627981036901474,
-0.41779664158821106,
-0.14219467341899872,
0.3645886182785034,
-0.5896059274673462,
0.21931403875350952,
-0.12494732439517975,
-0.6841517090797424,
-0.25130295753479004,
0.26685598492622375,
-0.9266981482505798,
1.0456074476242065,
-0.19752830266952515,
-0.8164680004119873,
0.5125139951705933,
-0.8770385384559631,
-0.6113797426223755,
-0.1551213413476944,
-0.5234196782112122,
-0.5729678273200989,
-0.2183058112859726,
0.5679247379302979,
0.3500779867172241,
-0.1969502717256546,
0.271335244178772,
-0.48777976632118225,
0.1781338006258011,
-0.14879830181598663,
-0.12610091269016266,
0.6096316576004028,
-0.12438908964395523,
-0.3247988522052765,
0.004625613801181316,
-0.7637094259262085,
-0.3603198528289795,
0.22695939242839813,
-0.1143108606338501,
-0.40171363949775696,
0.146470308303833,
-0.06523989140987396,
0.2559136748313904,
0.18009820580482483,
-0.5967850089073181,
0.1721954196691513,
-0.34569230675697327,
0.14692746102809906,
0.7363632321357727,
0.5049594044685364,
0.6074999570846558,
0.0192547757178545,
0.23360252380371094,
0.09246604889631271,
0.1318938136100769,
-0.33467328548431396,
-0.4633539617061615,
-0.5106713175773621,
-0.17940008640289307,
0.039497166872024536,
0.69996178150177,
-0.48048704862594604,
0.41588327288627625,
-0.16291029751300812,
-0.12301282584667206,
0.10290195792913437,
0.09082146733999252,
0.24928951263427734,
0.2929442524909973,
0.3753436505794525,
-0.026454266160726547,
-0.6449989676475525,
-0.514859139919281,
-0.22989238798618317,
-0.1419302076101303,
0.23668824136257172,
0.45025497674942017,
0.44546380639076233,
-0.08098036050796509,
0.8277184963226318,
-0.7280131578445435,
-0.31479451060295105,
-0.13652649521827698,
0.46889814734458923,
0.012380086816847324,
0.3256436288356781,
0.6077167987823486,
-0.7528773546218872,
-0.33686190843582153,
0.27932003140449524,
-1.0813225507736206,
0.16522595286369324,
-0.10514413565397263,
-0.3295707702636719,
0.1350952535867691,
0.29428526759147644,
-0.3771812617778778,
0.5581343173980713,
0.3680351674556732,
-0.1874120682477951,
0.350323349237442,
0.07747378945350647,
0.31373023986816406,
-1.3221993446350098,
-0.10394438356161118,
0.054188698530197144,
-0.3603810667991638,
-0.43692925572395325,
0.09549380838871002,
-0.09495183825492859,
-0.3983415365219116,
-0.17142613232135773,
0.665934145450592,
-0.8338485360145569,
-0.13090898096561432,
0.015846196562051773,
0.6018766760826111,
0.29678282141685486,
0.47379058599472046,
-0.08751080185174942,
0.23610232770442963,
0.6260907053947449,
-0.6509405970573425,
0.3228886127471924,
0.393247127532959,
0.14353148639202118,
0.6171894669532776,
-0.2693634033203125,
0.37208446860313416,
-0.07126179337501526,
0.16441339254379272,
-0.6482571363449097,
0.0018793413182720542,
0.36401456594467163,
-0.3079949617385864,
0.6399011611938477,
-0.5700588822364807,
-0.5472826361656189,
-0.21196918189525604,
-0.10196948796510696,
0.12941262125968933,
0.06854834407567978,
-0.49998894333839417,
1.1976051330566406,
0.6624957919120789,
-0.1894659548997879,
-0.6593438982963562,
-0.48374006152153015,
0.10040324181318283,
-0.14408911764621735,
-0.7798314094543457,
0.2091781347990036,
0.3188057839870453,
-0.1328052282333374,
0.5610655546188354,
-0.06492526829242706,
-0.21325035393238068,
-0.15411686897277832,
0.3138757348060608,
0.3749884068965912,
-0.1284656524658203,
0.46432337164878845,
0.031311821192502975,
-0.5405808687210083,
-0.2790178656578064,
-0.2597711384296417,
0.5125599503517151,
0.07601188868284225,
-0.6285573244094849,
-0.49393409490585327,
0.696618378162384,
0.37823396921157837,
-0.35168108344078064,
0.8249726891517639,
0.8174543380737305,
-0.7619815468788147,
0.15245291590690613,
-0.6205519437789917,
-0.40899091958999634,
-0.3377212584018707,
0.6470755338668823,
-0.6982375979423523,
-0.8595725893974304,
0.8282177448272705,
-0.5415261387825012,
0.3202907145023346,
0.5409234166145325,
0.2760884761810303,
0.0924413874745369,
0.9629843235015869,
0.41078507900238037,
-0.22466155886650085,
0.6185643672943115,
-0.28120243549346924,
0.13910764455795288,
-0.9595249891281128,
-0.2922637164592743,
-0.5545467138290405,
-0.10154300183057785,
-0.3261505663394928,
-0.27445295453071594,
0.40657544136047363,
0.3531879782676697,
-0.2649017870426178,
0.5570679306983948,
-0.043711382895708084,
0.12389987707138062,
0.06737680733203888,
-0.03724092245101929,
0.3188011646270752,
0.021426279097795486,
-0.16866637766361237,
-0.09273963421583176,
-0.7662774324417114,
-0.42577987909317017,
0.6559262275695801,
-0.042608775198459625,
0.6239637136459351,
0.16509075462818146,
1.0241448879241943,
0.024674391373991966,
0.31615468859672546,
-0.4752845764160156,
0.4533596634864807,
-0.10985605418682098,
-0.6541546583175659,
-0.4516427516937256,
-0.46300604939460754,
-1.1559805870056152,
0.3202618658542633,
-0.5014053583145142,
-1.2845573425292969,
0.39596638083457947,
0.013282852247357368,
0.37082380056381226,
0.5832058191299438,
-0.5362918376922607,
0.9632106423377991,
-0.1214788407087326,
-0.4266810417175293,
-0.36928024888038635,
-0.3926326036453247,
-0.016112275421619415,
0.07626321911811829,
0.5842152833938599,
-0.3620401620864868,
0.12665946781635284,
0.7812487483024597,
-0.17913588881492615,
0.9671713709831238,
-0.023267101496458054,
0.27017346024513245,
0.2952519357204437,
0.18333575129508972,
1.1965030431747437,
0.4452757239341736,
-0.15667738020420074,
0.13291899859905243,
-0.19805054366588593,
-0.2890689969062805,
-0.6296803951263428,
0.7373228073120117,
-0.7011850476264954,
-0.24217960238456726,
-0.16188496351242065,
-0.3305695950984955,
-0.1838739812374115,
0.3861747086048126,
0.1888435333967209,
1.0714695453643799,
-0.4978293478488922,
-0.46468621492385864,
0.17027106881141663,
-0.004772494081407785,
0.6500377655029297,
0.2811899483203888,
-0.17544132471084595,
-0.5206278562545776,
0.7729262709617615,
0.14960375428199768,
0.07611902803182602,
0.46422532200813293,
0.07346296310424805,
-0.20014728605747223,
-0.08996070921421051,
-0.5702476501464844,
0.32869741320610046,
-0.7972040176391602,
-0.026118291541934013,
-1.0302881002426147,
0.18890540301799774,
-0.4603201150894165,
-0.24092280864715576,
-0.3538823127746582,
-0.25829294323921204,
-0.44474783539772034,
-0.22044067084789276,
0.31307902932167053,
0.7940241694450378,
-0.11803533136844635,
-0.19262336194515228,
-1.18538236618042,
0.2834266126155853,
0.17190125584602356,
0.02629636414349079,
0.17133215069770813,
0.2112153172492981,
-0.06728815287351608,
-0.3321838974952698,
-0.2190312147140503,
-1.3927608728408813,
0.1393664926290512,
0.20022745430469513,
0.8605324029922485,
0.2836998403072357,
-0.06845691055059433,
0.8062326312065125,
-0.6241549849510193,
0.47271811962127686,
0.38589227199554443,
-0.9540937542915344,
0.8295283317565918,
-0.14207611978054047,
-0.15146750211715698,
0.3260945677757263,
0.2987367808818817,
-0.49786612391471863,
-0.4875461459159851,
-0.8593817353248596,
-0.9837788343429565,
0.6446877717971802,
0.33307716250419617,
-0.11283695697784424,
-0.20664066076278687,
0.35802966356277466,
0.02882232330739498,
0.0009759431704878807,
-0.7016774415969849,
-0.5704777836799622,
0.23693202435970306,
-0.011063547804951668,
0.14400897920131683,
-0.23791034519672394,
-0.28685903549194336,
0.13458777964115143,
0.6353644132614136,
0.08688964694738388,
0.480376660823822,
0.10125844925642014,
-0.3070429563522339,
-0.0903613418340683,
0.36426565051078796,
0.008666622452437878,
0.7167837023735046,
-0.04473329335451126,
0.2023419737815857,
0.5779101848602295,
-0.298654705286026,
-0.029834680259227753,
0.49783089756965637,
-0.027355896309018135,
0.090985007584095,
0.6557505130767822,
0.9926533102989197,
0.39098086953163147,
0.0640595406293869,
0.338245153427124,
0.021308505907654762,
0.08069922029972076,
-0.18439993262290955,
-0.29884177446365356,
0.07311982661485672,
0.3032133877277374,
0.2105616331100464,
0.026389913633465767,
0.13044697046279907,
-0.5421014428138733,
0.544042706489563,
0.1491241753101349,
-0.6292188763618469,
-0.39553436636924744,
0.6084432005882263,
0.4636134207248688,
-0.07831104099750519,
0.4151339828968048,
-0.4596811830997467,
-0.4187338054180145,
0.618716299533844,
0.6749119758605957,
0.7122324109077454,
0.05638457089662552,
0.06999528408050537,
0.5870780944824219,
0.3448965549468994,
0.40828630328178406,
0.2404697686433792,
0.24896666407585144,
-1.0192629098892212,
-0.7599924802780151,
-0.42819809913635254,
-0.18612483143806458,
-0.054233063012361526,
-0.6263977289199829,
0.3943113386631012,
0.2229573130607605,
-0.345702201128006,
-0.05449840798974037,
-0.0426437072455883,
-0.7629255056381226,
-0.21051211655139923,
-0.0005934773362241685,
0.4283426105976105,
-1.0350068807601929,
0.6118825078010559,
0.9452576041221619,
-0.6045904159545898,
-0.8451739549636841,
-0.12699198722839355,
0.1863265186548233,
-0.4390225112438202,
0.5307076573371887,
-0.05639928579330444,
-0.09758159518241882,
0.20224173367023468,
0.19909407198429108,
-0.7299648523330688,
0.9695845246315002,
0.2746322453022003,
-0.6537492871284485,
0.04180716723203659,
-0.4122253954410553,
0.059064023196697235,
-0.4346636235713959,
0.20980946719646454,
-0.0018908297643065453,
0.7460002303123474,
-0.04100899025797844,
-0.5572906732559204,
0.19751964509487152,
-0.06418674439191818,
-0.2872244119644165,
0.8679842948913574,
-0.40272223949432373,
0.5080968141555786,
-0.15390929579734802,
-0.6779778003692627,
-0.4073941111564636,
0.6156649589538574,
0.05252917483448982,
0.4601309299468994,
0.5304601192474365,
0.7325583100318909,
0.8938606381416321,
-0.16786600649356842,
1.0647780895233154,
-0.2609519064426422,
0.7689955234527588,
1.2645413875579834,
-0.5986107587814331,
0.5828703045845032,
0.1466890573501587,
-0.24856197834014893,
0.6712949872016907,
0.306612491607666,
0.26640212535858154,
0.2505001127719879,
-0.33871957659721375,
-0.40010058879852295,
-0.4521138072013855,
0.04822216182947159,
-0.40613093972206116,
0.14838054776191711,
0.45804479718208313,
-0.20537544786930084,
-0.5726214051246643,
0.115351602435112,
0.3526407480239868,
-0.14246612787246704,
0.05956534668803215,
0.842321515083313,
0.16811110079288483,
-0.22267889976501465,
-0.21161410212516785,
-0.2565131187438965,
0.11791542172431946,
-0.5366092324256897,
-0.16531921923160553,
0.3070545792579651,
0.004567595664411783,
-0.035109490156173706,
-0.53924560546875,
0.24725781381130219,
-0.22670094668865204,
-0.23766691982746124,
0.2532978057861328,
1.12974214553833,
-0.2649325430393219,
-0.4103037416934967,
0.8654599189758301,
0.8228663802146912,
-0.09173864126205444,
0.3156605660915375,
-0.6551425457000732,
0.03650745376944542,
-0.2807798981666565,
-0.40013906359672546,
0.3234612047672272,
0.5606575012207031,
-0.017063086852431297,
0.23605987429618835,
0.6357911229133606,
0.0061548915691673756,
0.0044856928288936615,
0.46292588114738464,
0.9093960523605347,
-0.46660515666007996,
-0.39608538150787354,
-1.0742908716201782,
0.3730927109718323,
-0.6377723813056946,
-0.11256412416696548,
0.5714402794837952,
0.5366021394729614,
0.3347857892513275,
0.19588133692741394,
0.7640972137451172,
-0.24855369329452515,
0.17696595191955566,
-0.44057372212409973,
0.19798916578292847,
-0.3423767685890198,
-0.04449393227696419,
-0.37954655289649963,
-0.9190525412559509,
-0.3925114572048187,
0.36821433901786804,
-0.298804372549057,
0.005103612784296274,
1.0490163564682007,
0.5466500520706177,
-0.03884006664156914,
0.07930456101894379,
0.1548982709646225,
0.09877031296491623,
0.46010610461235046,
0.6648239493370056,
0.7185958027839661,
-0.37720125913619995,
0.5627935528755188,
0.012577561661601067,
-0.3452141582965851,
-0.1134001761674881,
-1.0940356254577637,
-0.916883111000061,
-0.6135066151618958,
-0.5283074975013733,
-0.15207791328430176,
0.3728276789188385,
0.5913245677947998,
0.6934878826141357,
-0.7480230331420898,
0.057901278138160706,
-0.0684930756688118,
0.27189844846725464,
-0.37612801790237427,
-0.22779621183872223,
0.6813349723815918,
-0.46063467860221863,
-0.8264169692993164,
0.457653284072876,
0.6999008655548096,
-0.0771622508764267,
0.29802605509757996,
0.04846108704805374,
-0.5569358468055725,
-0.28235775232315063,
0.6555823683738708,
0.16664764285087585,
-0.33504605293273926,
-0.6948272585868835,
-0.33811211585998535,
0.01744607463479042,
0.07068891078233719,
0.8392838835716248,
-0.3704560101032257,
0.4953368604183197,
0.6942154169082642,
0.3607262372970581,
1.083493709564209,
-0.32052046060562134,
0.6172800660133362,
-0.9607483148574829,
0.3100593686103821,
-0.08596669137477875,
0.7674832344055176,
-0.10088656842708588,
-0.39902591705322266,
0.6131375432014465,
0.4884580969810486,
-0.5040662884712219,
-0.5384024381637573,
0.587855339050293,
-1.007506012916565,
-0.20450562238693237,
0.9616357684135437,
-0.3310336172580719,
-0.03299136832356453,
-0.492409348487854,
-0.012259635142982006,
0.7678537368774414,
-0.2886601984500885,
0.20230767130851746,
0.6382051706314087,
-0.5103051662445068,
-0.13418766856193542,
-0.509150505065918,
0.012064909562468529,
-0.11734586209058762,
-0.9379377961158752,
-0.11678775399923325,
0.5243951082229614,
-0.013102684170007706,
0.4684584140777588,
0.6191331148147583,
-0.29335418343544006,
0.07012845575809479,
0.2423868626356125,
0.24858413636684418,
-0.2372511774301529,
-0.34753137826919556,
0.24418045580387115,
0.3692891001701355,
-0.09635484218597412,
-0.40639930963516235
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.13031v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.13031v1
|
RigorLLM: Resilient Guardrails for Large Language Models against Undesired Content
| 2024-03-19T07:25:02 | 2024-03-19T07:25:02 |
Zhuowen Yuan, Zidi Xiong, Yi Zeng, Ning Yu, Ruoxi Jia, Dawn Song, Bo Li
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Recent advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs) have showcased remarkable
capabilities across various tasks in different domains. However, the emergence
of biases and the potential for generating harmful content in LLMs,
particularly under malicious inputs, pose significant challenges. Current
mitigation strategies, while effective, are not resilient under adversarial
attacks. This paper introduces Resilient Guardrails for Large Language Models
(RigorLLM), a novel framework designed to efficiently and effectively moderate
harmful and unsafe inputs and outputs for LLMs. By employing a multi-faceted
approach that includes energy-based training data augmentation through Langevin
dynamics, optimizing a safe suffix for inputs via minimax optimization, and
integrating a fusion-based model combining robust KNN with LLMs based on our
data augmentation, RigorLLM offers a robust solution to harmful content
moderation. Our experimental evaluations demonstrate that RigorLLM not only
outperforms existing baselines like OpenAI API and Perspective API in detecting
harmful content but also exhibits unparalleled resilience to jailbreaking
attacks. The innovative use of constrained optimization and a fusion-based
guardrail approach represents a significant step forward in developing more
secure and reliable LLMs, setting a new standard for content moderation
frameworks in the face of evolving digital threats.
|
[
-0.4080357551574707,
-1.0432569980621338,
0.22805902361869812,
0.06325611472129822,
-0.24720162153244019,
0.2472497969865799,
-0.37473368644714355,
-0.06114397197961807,
0.06166870519518852,
0.9443424344062805,
-0.16644707322120667,
-0.6174210906028748,
-0.7335914969444275,
-0.2596278786659241,
-0.5858272910118103,
1.1242140531539917,
-0.16622187197208405,
0.003690528916195035,
-0.28073716163635254,
-0.275605708360672,
-0.4762462079524994,
-0.593687117099762,
-0.6481939554214478,
-0.22250790894031525,
0.48975205421447754,
0.06314893811941147,
0.7170493006706238,
0.58851557970047,
0.7409502267837524,
0.26347312331199646,
-0.011640972457826138,
0.018254991620779037,
-0.6610035300254822,
0.5067756772041321,
-0.36741241812705994,
-0.224928081035614,
-0.4220587909221649,
-0.3140650987625122,
0.5607744455337524,
0.4579198658466339,
-0.17414332926273346,
0.022209985181689262,
0.12770719826221466,
0.6484779715538025,
-0.8500551581382751,
-0.0915958434343338,
-0.9032620787620544,
-0.14829979836940765,
-0.30441468954086304,
-0.21207638084888458,
-0.43193185329437256,
-0.3514290452003479,
-0.24452424049377441,
-0.11417289078235626,
-0.2595374584197998,
0.26722824573516846,
0.6603303551673889,
0.3271373510360718,
-0.2258574217557907,
-0.07427956163883209,
-0.694237232208252,
0.8222348093986511,
-0.631013810634613,
0.19142946600914001,
0.4018614888191223,
0.22001422941684723,
-0.505205512046814,
-0.4819411039352417,
-0.389131098985672,
-0.2439059168100357,
0.2395288050174713,
0.059794411063194275,
-0.24329432845115662,
0.12710347771644592,
-0.007979735732078552,
0.14503726363182068,
-0.6680031418800354,
0.37653642892837524,
-0.10997733473777771,
-0.24494898319244385,
0.5077024698257446,
0.2741162180900574,
0.5699121952056885,
-0.2640700340270996,
-0.6150129437446594,
-0.24847640097141266,
-0.8869827389717102,
-0.23583488166332245,
0.7101906538009644,
0.4292943775653839,
-0.006425566505640745,
0.46885159611701965,
0.17610576748847961,
0.4199816584587097,
-0.09967676550149918,
-0.23342452943325043,
-0.3050994873046875,
0.04677823930978775,
-0.014775832183659077,
0.20903606712818146,
0.8805318474769592,
0.4086206257343292,
-0.0005891088512726128,
-0.36798423528671265,
-0.2856886386871338,
0.21717852354049683,
0.4850955307483673,
-0.8295246958732605,
-0.22830024361610413,
0.5031201243400574,
-0.1961151659488678,
-0.4950821101665497,
0.11234904080629349,
-0.9681957960128784,
-0.8073306679725647,
0.07812052220106125,
0.4452773332595825,
-0.6519151329994202,
-0.4539550840854645,
0.33699923753738403,
0.273771733045578,
0.2205117642879486,
-0.02658318728208542,
-0.823946475982666,
0.18941883742809296,
0.9904003143310547,
0.8763606548309326,
-0.5144068598747253,
-0.0158530380576849,
-0.6195312738418579,
0.379641592502594,
-0.13421384990215302,
0.46064257621765137,
-0.4508059322834015,
-0.5410956144332886,
0.2125229686498642,
0.054953545331954956,
0.13169829547405243,
-0.3254925608634949,
0.9561440944671631,
-0.9861111044883728,
0.010806851089000702,
0.12076780945062637,
-0.4476664364337921,
-0.16385997831821442,
0.5789007544517517,
-0.7613145112991333,
0.6220415234565735,
-0.09047618508338928,
-1.0292192697525024,
0.1206241250038147,
-0.30970460176467896,
-0.5956773161888123,
-0.11231019347906113,
0.20033462345600128,
-0.7073668241500854,
-0.03766336664557457,
-0.003924172837287188,
0.27572721242904663,
-0.10239133983850479,
0.6926658749580383,
-0.5904643535614014,
-0.06567605584859848,
0.286027729511261,
-0.7454906105995178,
0.5101954340934753,
0.24578575789928436,
-0.11342466622591019,
0.41239264607429504,
-0.45822587609291077,
-0.044864263385534286,
0.09205085784196854,
-0.47532519698143005,
-0.36261260509490967,
0.07594551146030426,
0.09460463374853134,
0.21045982837677002,
0.12487565726041794,
-0.3718246817588806,
-0.12453094869852066,
-0.5047826766967773,
0.21094362437725067,
1.102742075920105,
0.0633172020316124,
0.323294073343277,
-0.4394757151603699,
0.7530689239501953,
-0.20572927594184875,
0.0321306549012661,
0.04468229413032532,
0.07445075362920761,
-0.7457486391067505,
-0.18685947358608246,
0.3780718147754669,
0.5219950079917908,
-0.9434412121772766,
0.6130070090293884,
-0.6516827344894409,
-0.6293286085128784,
-0.09635267406702042,
0.23922693729400635,
0.5798470377922058,
0.3951932489871979,
0.16186478734016418,
-0.39524582028388977,
-0.659002959728241,
-0.5887033343315125,
-0.30352702736854553,
-0.18940316140651703,
0.13598717749118805,
-0.1681431084871292,
0.5548166036605835,
-0.16993311047554016,
0.6184703707695007,
-0.18004801869392395,
-0.205769345164299,
-0.4510438144207001,
-0.19256432354450226,
0.18773803114891052,
0.6615424156188965,
0.5061823129653931,
-0.6746460199356079,
-0.2652120888233185,
-0.27401986718177795,
-0.7470325827598572,
-0.15278922021389008,
-0.17483720183372498,
-0.3385029733181,
-0.14408114552497864,
0.3930284380912781,
-0.3967214524745941,
0.06949897110462189,
0.7075012922286987,
-0.1422339379787445,
0.5885077714920044,
0.03318237513303757,
-0.14149877429008484,
-1.2919360399246216,
0.07549674808979034,
-0.030929002910852432,
-0.4369331896305084,
-0.6297723054885864,
0.25992321968078613,
-0.17315936088562012,
-0.0449351966381073,
-0.5725655555725098,
0.6237382292747498,
-0.09260599315166473,
0.22731372714042664,
-0.6233332753181458,
0.2545813024044037,
-0.02597099356353283,
0.26187074184417725,
-0.034243542701005936,
0.5771456360816956,
0.7340799570083618,
-0.5690025091171265,
0.5449086427688599,
0.20636068284511566,
-0.2280644327402115,
0.5879723429679871,
-0.6171987056732178,
-0.005141059402376413,
-0.2066277712583542,
0.2806563675403595,
-0.588528573513031,
-0.501351535320282,
0.2172536551952362,
-0.18556156754493713,
0.5793686509132385,
-0.22970743477344513,
-0.4812961518764496,
-0.24247540533542633,
-0.743911862373352,
0.0826672911643982,
0.41849657893180847,
-0.6739828586578369,
0.6548886299133301,
0.8329905867576599,
-0.05489034578204155,
-0.5364292860031128,
-0.49562978744506836,
0.30546531081199646,
-0.7052350640296936,
-0.8107447028160095,
0.2694174349308014,
0.045448027551174164,
-0.3166588842868805,
-0.3562878668308258,
-0.17372602224349976,
0.15424273908138275,
0.35337337851524353,
0.47691744565963745,
0.3437628746032715,
0.1467774659395218,
0.009802174754440784,
-0.02375553734600544,
-0.31545740365982056,
0.3016902804374695,
-0.21663779020309448,
0.8756747841835022,
-0.07188151776790619,
-0.4781031608581543,
-0.12042549252510071,
0.25935083627700806,
0.5655320882797241,
-0.1484626829624176,
0.9606359601020813,
0.807624101638794,
-0.3038468062877655,
-0.1951899230480194,
-0.3916774392127991,
-0.2614039480686188,
-0.5479996204376221,
0.4418679475784302,
-0.09976335614919662,
-1.0634708404541016,
0.39125993847846985,
-0.2700466513633728,
0.11238579452037811,
0.1273917853832245,
0.5239241123199463,
0.26289403438568115,
0.9085296392440796,
0.3782309591770172,
-0.3647753596305847,
0.5532259941101074,
-0.04948453605175018,
0.20042496919631958,
-1.037359356880188,
-0.10671728104352951,
-0.24993568658828735,
-0.2104732245206833,
-0.5218578577041626,
-0.1127709224820137,
0.5966688394546509,
0.015058093704283237,
-0.2926514744758606,
0.32506129145622253,
-0.32219254970550537,
0.41637706756591797,
0.392951101064682,
0.23185734450817108,
0.15301154553890228,
-0.08608411252498627,
-0.022792158648371696,
0.043850596994161606,
-0.5960739850997925,
-0.8524619936943054,
1.1473342180252075,
0.4172282814979553,
1.3928560018539429,
0.5292761921882629,
0.36642026901245117,
0.4194205701351166,
0.32170870900154114,
-0.5601459741592407,
0.6830744743347168,
-0.17470546066761017,
-0.719005286693573,
0.07603945583105087,
-0.44908326864242554,
-0.777682363986969,
0.25775250792503357,
-0.27973875403404236,
-0.7904665470123291,
-0.3191883862018585,
0.03835213556885719,
-0.3573337197303772,
0.8094852566719055,
-0.42152097821235657,
0.5926104784011841,
-0.6274688839912415,
-1.1145702600479126,
-0.018938474357128143,
-0.6493869423866272,
0.7040004134178162,
-0.217817485332489,
0.2781877815723419,
-0.17111338675022125,
-0.03729065880179405,
0.7036741375923157,
-0.3076450526714325,
0.8722851872444153,
-0.10348992794752121,
-0.2574874460697174,
0.17845825850963593,
0.48435482382774353,
0.6830738186836243,
0.38382506370544434,
-0.1474858969449997,
-0.02789168991148472,
-0.23135815560817719,
-0.2126484215259552,
-0.28759467601776123,
1.0795912742614746,
-0.5766401290893555,
-0.9206711649894714,
-0.50102299451828,
-0.5015294551849365,
-0.33386197686195374,
0.24707065522670746,
-0.04624210298061371,
0.27798259258270264,
-0.12779386341571808,
0.5462941527366638,
0.8998387455940247,
-0.32812270522117615,
0.5557264685630798,
0.456625372171402,
-0.4045288860797882,
-0.5281330943107605,
0.9817372560501099,
-0.34595394134521484,
0.4735461175441742,
0.09904016554355621,
-0.03235793113708496,
-0.2950824797153473,
-0.8709826469421387,
-0.2437351495027542,
-0.11482833325862885,
-0.6924076676368713,
-0.48892635107040405,
-0.637657642364502,
-0.3393702507019043,
-0.21951241791248322,
-0.311343789100647,
-0.41725555062294006,
-0.21744892001152039,
-0.007321975193917751,
-0.24874958395957947,
0.4178240895271301,
0.13352207839488983,
-0.19606146216392517,
0.44039177894592285,
-0.6959819793701172,
0.23821987211704254,
0.23820903897285461,
0.4512326121330261,
-0.21649929881095886,
-0.6718830466270447,
-0.0832066759467125,
-0.0533023364841938,
-0.3166724443435669,
-0.4255361258983612,
0.47303491830825806,
0.02098153345286846,
0.3943321108818054,
0.5039315819740295,
0.2873761057853699,
0.21299025416374207,
-0.27190423011779785,
0.6996622085571289,
0.22584006190299988,
-0.7151275873184204,
0.4894297420978546,
-0.5848211050033569,
0.10863814502954483,
0.57811439037323,
0.16112153232097626,
-0.4357497990131378,
-0.3793966770172119,
-0.343723863363266,
-1.0040379762649536,
0.4329283535480499,
0.1287274807691574,
0.5223686099052429,
0.02989119105041027,
0.18638478219509125,
0.1570761352777481,
0.23068371415138245,
-0.8026072382926941,
0.08792450278997421,
-0.2656089961528778,
-0.15065090358257294,
0.37824690341949463,
-0.2150079309940338,
-0.35286423563957214,
0.12066105008125305,
1.0086331367492676,
-0.13197574019432068,
-0.2060217261314392,
-0.29393520951271057,
-0.23363839089870453,
-0.005075080320239067,
0.5147971510887146,
0.34741324186325073,
0.3117631673812866,
-0.20357288420200348,
0.5131639838218689,
0.2665376663208008,
-0.624499499797821,
0.11939346790313721,
-0.06275934725999832,
-0.3274853825569153,
-0.376754492521286,
0.40368279814720154,
0.8018925786018372,
0.11956143379211426,
-0.8015690445899963,
0.3667333424091339,
-0.06193450093269348,
0.17091135680675507,
-0.34917277097702026,
0.42303964495658875,
-0.2120692878961563,
-0.07318476587533951,
-0.040710173547267914,
-0.052483852952718735,
-0.31101682782173157,
-0.3722373843193054,
0.30734720826148987,
0.7760822176933289,
-0.4913268983364105,
-0.25394630432128906,
0.9661538600921631,
0.28498217463493347,
0.05202968418598175,
-0.005326217506080866,
-0.0021628299728035927,
-0.6629979610443115,
0.22861026227474213,
0.5307068824768066,
0.9430397152900696,
-0.17652243375778198,
0.09372367709875107,
0.23903430998325348,
0.405703604221344,
-0.17752662301063538,
0.0966857299208641,
0.31474000215530396,
-0.8656433820724487,
-0.08714944869279861,
-0.9607629776000977,
-0.3373006582260132,
0.2179717719554901,
-0.5058566927909851,
0.2571631073951721,
-0.8711570501327515,
-0.3425830006599426,
-0.4576435089111328,
-0.2684933543205261,
-0.03964592143893242,
0.07066906243562698,
0.14419539272785187,
0.6298818588256836,
-0.7089310884475708,
0.6902812123298645,
0.3245587646961212,
-0.3105868995189667,
-0.4958127737045288,
-0.019867364317178726,
0.16463057696819305,
-0.6522602438926697,
0.09914661943912506,
0.1456800103187561,
-0.2817317843437195,
-0.11740713566541672,
-0.43758127093315125,
-0.6864668726921082,
0.9168654680252075,
0.4764007031917572,
-0.37108704447746277,
0.12289831042289734,
0.2750530242919922,
0.40662774443626404,
-0.11541013419628143,
-0.10359703004360199,
0.49373185634613037,
0.5297011733055115,
0.09912063181400299,
-0.4702107012271881,
0.26536500453948975,
-0.07760690897703171,
0.19846202433109283,
0.32485732436180115,
-0.8475762605667114,
0.4515206515789032,
0.22631385922431946,
-0.19902779161930084,
0.20864911377429962,
0.4466884434223175,
0.32654449343681335,
-0.06690743565559387,
0.4384062588214874,
0.6699241995811462,
0.4695212244987488,
-0.41860365867614746,
1.031967282295227,
-0.6107386350631714,
0.23920153081417084,
1.0333306789398193,
-0.40838712453842163,
0.6784497499465942,
0.620688796043396,
-0.0830351859331131,
0.3405243158340454,
0.3911856412887573,
-0.10201647877693176,
0.622911274433136,
0.41046857833862305,
-0.635554850101471,
-0.42899635434150696,
-0.46419113874435425,
-0.23175477981567383,
0.5075801610946655,
0.4456820785999298,
-0.37902089953422546,
-0.15872304141521454,
0.3477633595466614,
0.5932270884513855,
0.28321942687034607,
-0.3470250368118286,
0.6767639517784119,
0.08101367950439453,
-0.4609871506690979,
0.49432259798049927,
0.2109060138463974,
0.8768582344055176,
-0.7836900949478149,
0.4610085189342499,
-0.06417206674814224,
0.3812968134880066,
-0.14679117500782013,
-0.810272753238678,
0.4436580240726471,
0.2883639931678772,
0.13851438462734222,
-0.3473832607269287,
1.070516586303711,
-0.27071627974510193,
-0.4993460476398468,
0.31985241174697876,
0.3051398992538452,
-0.22789761424064636,
0.16746115684509277,
-0.4582238793373108,
0.5408099293708801,
-0.25926995277404785,
-0.20185436308383942,
0.5031982660293579,
0.010743063874542713,
-0.01883619837462902,
0.8402745723724365,
0.7439382076263428,
0.20854738354682922,
-0.03873184323310852,
0.016992241144180298,
1.1425527334213257,
-0.3114369213581085,
-0.2790625989437103,
-0.972867488861084,
0.5080302357673645,
-0.20382218062877655,
0.00016842696641106158,
0.9483588933944702,
0.498522013425827,
0.5587567090988159,
0.1312241554260254,
0.9472206234931946,
-0.05502612888813019,
0.27629154920578003,
-0.7706116437911987,
1.0453200340270996,
-0.19536855816841125,
0.6839991807937622,
-0.30787667632102966,
-0.7631623148918152,
-0.5277079939842224,
0.1345624476671219,
-0.3924953043460846,
0.005699581000953913,
0.27299267053604126,
0.9608305096626282,
-0.07475234568119049,
-0.130183145403862,
0.1581721007823944,
0.12784920632839203,
0.6510798335075378,
0.5527759194374084,
0.7318422198295593,
-0.1661616861820221,
0.7717331647872925,
-0.10586068034172058,
-0.015930956229567528,
-0.2096414864063263,
-0.7555226683616638,
-1.20333731174469,
-0.19966168701648712,
-0.28930792212486267,
-0.6691141724586487,
0.30611321330070496,
0.6439995169639587,
0.595192551612854,
-0.954317569732666,
0.036333438009023666,
-0.217754527926445,
0.2712680399417877,
0.3229939341545105,
-0.2817531228065491,
0.4584670662879944,
-0.10734821856021881,
-0.5523351430892944,
0.40407538414001465,
0.4884936213493347,
-0.03867069259285927,
-0.7200237512588501,
-0.12990713119506836,
-0.04619108885526657,
0.13019181787967682,
0.35107946395874023,
0.29798924922943115,
-0.6244616508483887,
-0.5937570929527283,
-0.1099119707942009,
-0.05261010676622391,
-0.14884348213672638,
0.43251001834869385,
-0.5470430254936218,
0.49935153126716614,
0.445266991853714,
0.8916240930557251,
0.0476132407784462,
0.1191524863243103,
0.6061442494392395,
-0.8747021555900574,
0.3133816123008728,
0.27797144651412964,
0.6313713192939758,
0.5429000854492188,
-0.13255617022514343,
0.434255987405777,
0.01030928734689951,
-0.4642755687236786,
-0.9683049321174622,
0.45088160037994385,
-0.8559150099754333,
-0.07517246901988983,
1.3484697341918945,
-0.22420674562454224,
-0.3869309723377228,
-0.03689775988459587,
-0.1984768956899643,
0.1143118366599083,
-0.27157503366470337,
1.1178442239761353,
0.759624183177948,
0.2626129686832428,
-0.14379490911960602,
-0.48606857657432556,
0.4478793442249298,
0.4171823263168335,
-0.985401451587677,
0.15262001752853394,
0.42602571845054626,
0.0826139822602272,
0.18618769943714142,
-0.17679943144321442,
-0.3493903875350952,
0.019446751102805138,
-0.1416434794664383,
-0.2918300926685333,
-0.1723787933588028,
-0.2716229259967804,
-0.3243516683578491,
0.4250655472278595,
0.0026025124825537205,
-0.022667890414595604
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.12500v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.12500v1
|
A Large Collection of Model-generated Contradictory Responses for Consistency-aware Dialogue Systems
| 2024-03-19T07:07:13 | 2024-03-19T07:07:13 |
Shiki Sato, Reina Akama, Jun Suzuki, Kentaro Inui
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Mitigating the generation of contradictory responses poses a substantial
challenge in dialogue response generation. The quality and quantity of
available contradictory response data play a vital role in suppressing these
contradictions, offering two significant benefits. First, having access to
large contradiction data enables a comprehensive examination of their
characteristics. Second, data-driven methods to mitigate contradictions may be
enhanced with large-scale contradiction data for training. Nevertheless, no
attempt has been made to build an extensive collection of model-generated
contradictory responses. In this paper, we build a large dataset of response
generation models' contradictions for the first time. Then, we acquire valuable
insights into the characteristics of model-generated contradictions through an
extensive analysis of the collected responses. Lastly, we also demonstrate how
this dataset substantially enhances the performance of data-driven
contradiction suppression methods.
|
[
-0.6534255743026733,
-0.5297187566757202,
0.35901716351509094,
0.029141638427972794,
0.03827911242842674,
-0.10020910948514938,
0.27690497040748596,
-0.26952844858169556,
-0.15718813240528107,
0.6387950778007507,
-1.0657474994659424,
0.051004644483327866,
-0.4476233124732971,
0.1953529268503189,
-0.5398991107940674,
0.9939495325088501,
0.1763734519481659,
0.0006801866693422198,
-0.17175200581550598,
-0.07864110171794891,
-0.790375828742981,
-0.2121465504169464,
-0.3055630028247833,
-0.2515074908733368,
0.39125150442123413,
0.2842804789543152,
0.764945924282074,
0.3844161927700043,
0.1875731199979782,
0.33687418699264526,
0.14707915484905243,
0.39074957370758057,
-0.8435344696044922,
0.4132750630378723,
-0.3295052945613861,
-0.39789244532585144,
-0.07593275606632233,
-0.1436164230108261,
0.7944207787513733,
0.6235100030899048,
-0.17963770031929016,
0.06730072945356369,
0.30466899275779724,
0.6070241332054138,
-0.6096723675727844,
0.02981940098106861,
-0.916731059551239,
0.18910668790340424,
0.02217702753841877,
0.0074045294895768166,
-0.6289511322975159,
-0.47479626536369324,
0.24026398360729218,
-0.8749666810035706,
0.4778895676136017,
0.02541453018784523,
0.9315041303634644,
0.4042263329029083,
-0.4786030352115631,
-0.3123992681503296,
-0.9699591398239136,
0.7053220272064209,
-0.8270980715751648,
0.11352621763944626,
0.04922127351164818,
0.33760902285575867,
-0.42789316177368164,
-0.35837894678115845,
-1.0914603471755981,
0.19142040610313416,
-0.05009257048368454,
0.3832120895385742,
-0.3812161386013031,
-0.059796251356601715,
0.7009135484695435,
0.24414275586605072,
-0.6084468960762024,
-0.11031409353017807,
0.15117992460727692,
-0.11635657399892807,
0.5587858557701111,
0.6850920915603638,
-0.2237679809331894,
-0.3466561734676361,
-0.140333890914917,
-0.3483821451663971,
-0.8470763564109802,
-0.058299511671066284,
0.6195564866065979,
0.26330286264419556,
0.06910895556211472,
0.5921373963356018,
-0.3082623779773712,
0.6881446838378906,
0.17518047988414764,
-0.04493652284145355,
-0.05877819284796715,
-0.4821837246417999,
-0.4106007516384125,
-0.32613325119018555,
0.8420848846435547,
0.1949327141046524,
-0.21572135388851166,
0.11539530009031296,
-0.38323378562927246,
0.21118661761283875,
0.08359085768461227,
-0.81322181224823,
0.03276428207755089,
0.3280138075351715,
-0.27386191487312317,
-0.1262310892343521,
-0.02011953294277191,
-0.8416904807090759,
-0.5659810304641724,
-0.4229055345058441,
0.3499850332736969,
-0.027649294584989548,
-0.3323478400707245,
0.23114465177059174,
-0.0822376161813736,
0.14825500547885895,
0.446843683719635,
-0.5770084857940674,
0.2658754289150238,
0.4849076569080353,
0.43763625621795654,
0.32550203800201416,
0.29794901609420776,
-0.7735477685928345,
0.14684143662452698,
-0.371232271194458,
0.45381981134414673,
-0.48637762665748596,
-0.5575926899909973,
0.02144433930516243,
-0.10891497135162354,
0.12081217765808105,
-1.0478214025497437,
0.5005267262458801,
-0.18928833305835724,
0.29635247588157654,
-0.6179347038269043,
-0.7034742832183838,
0.10052020847797394,
0.04204104468226433,
-0.5468476414680481,
0.585792064666748,
0.15457329154014587,
-0.8962313532829285,
0.1253790706396103,
-0.21561048924922943,
-0.1861758679151535,
-0.07733363658189774,
-0.34336337447166443,
-0.5471534132957458,
0.13866347074508667,
-0.12751629948616028,
0.12957863509655,
-0.7054424285888672,
0.5463298559188843,
-0.4484226703643799,
-0.021235205233097076,
0.3269183337688446,
-0.7472928166389465,
0.7332661747932434,
0.4323641359806061,
-0.33676716685295105,
-0.22025910019874573,
-0.7830449342727661,
0.07619505375623703,
0.2806367874145508,
-0.09572015702724457,
-0.06876783818006516,
0.1306813508272171,
-0.2543675899505615,
0.46637603640556335,
-0.07878748327493668,
-0.7733128070831299,
-0.11959125846624374,
-0.2985509932041168,
0.1389581859111786,
0.9935240149497986,
0.07342195510864258,
-0.15797556936740875,
-0.7346594929695129,
0.3359261751174927,
0.5198073983192444,
0.056820258498191833,
-0.36491525173187256,
-0.24740877747535706,
-0.7790647745132446,
-0.04266100376844406,
0.09856577962636948,
0.333278626203537,
-0.917443573474884,
0.6117706894874573,
-0.3587814271450043,
-0.38459843397140503,
-0.532234251499176,
0.1949879378080368,
0.5293343663215637,
1.0659106969833374,
0.06081312522292137,
-0.11595650017261505,
-0.7226340174674988,
-1.034938097000122,
-0.1992575079202652,
-0.09541786462068558,
-0.30766618251800537,
0.5122458934783936,
0.4400292634963989,
0.08100289106369019,
1.1139004230499268,
-0.4678058326244354,
0.21356265246868134,
0.16334819793701172,
0.17260730266571045,
0.06744962185621262,
0.5966989398002625,
0.25180545449256897,
-0.9477918744087219,
-0.494536817073822,
-0.16381344199180603,
-0.8297140598297119,
-0.23156175017356873,
-0.4445350766181946,
-0.10047921538352966,
0.004673351999372244,
0.101315438747406,
-0.5673026442527771,
0.6606966257095337,
0.4489195644855499,
-0.012601504102349281,
0.7373142242431641,
0.29801851511001587,
0.02996002696454525,
-1.1675132513046265,
0.31132036447525024,
-0.035036712884902954,
-0.24840863049030304,
-0.6758421063423157,
-0.22488296031951904,
-0.1429894119501114,
-0.02110137790441513,
-0.12608005106449127,
0.24430657923221588,
-0.012042051181197166,
0.13585662841796875,
-0.18854838609695435,
0.14827625453472137,
0.20083510875701904,
0.2902645766735077,
-0.011915339156985283,
0.5973318219184875,
0.2100905179977417,
-0.5478238463401794,
0.5575015544891357,
0.9222820401191711,
-0.2576083242893219,
0.8116302490234375,
-0.8752630352973938,
0.1923668533563614,
-0.37119677662849426,
0.4891078472137451,
-1.3405565023422241,
-0.6343846321105957,
0.31316155195236206,
-0.2073059231042862,
0.07714581489562988,
-0.05548406392335892,
-0.48150119185447693,
-0.4869649410247803,
-0.08341832458972931,
0.231560617685318,
0.3842604458332062,
-0.6949131488800049,
0.6237460970878601,
-0.03844517096877098,
-0.42898330092430115,
-0.6034408807754517,
-0.4865739345550537,
-0.28516221046447754,
-0.07263480871915817,
-0.4716018736362457,
-0.12527461349964142,
-0.5940986275672913,
-0.20599333941936493,
-0.4497843384742737,
-0.371474027633667,
0.266637921333313,
-0.0937904417514801,
0.41362032294273376,
0.36239707469940186,
-0.06499765813350677,
0.26298895478248596,
-0.01984664984047413,
0.16240723431110382,
0.20258642733097076,
-0.04661610722541809,
0.5958878993988037,
0.24806071817874908,
-0.7797977328300476,
-0.741518497467041,
0.6893005967140198,
0.6065806150436401,
0.1468593031167984,
0.5614939332008362,
-0.012411430478096008,
-0.05708250775933266,
0.14657670259475708,
-0.466793030500412,
-0.021789195016026497,
-0.5155271291732788,
0.23229603469371796,
-0.35737770795822144,
-0.6550037264823914,
0.614025890827179,
-0.13808847963809967,
0.48696357011795044,
0.2985058128833771,
0.4069700837135315,
0.1767088770866394,
1.4164937734603882,
0.06588473170995712,
-0.08606322109699249,
0.29681605100631714,
0.15396663546562195,
0.3713448941707611,
-0.7391171455383301,
-0.4275807738304138,
-0.8753926157951355,
-0.1288703829050064,
-0.4252237379550934,
0.175191730260849,
0.22186408936977386,
-0.06796767562627792,
-0.657611072063446,
0.01012841984629631,
-0.38413339853286743,
0.27244317531585693,
0.23262281715869904,
0.17565952241420746,
0.2328367978334427,
-0.005241051781922579,
0.06796851754188538,
-0.1364549845457077,
-0.7651580572128296,
-0.3514837324619293,
1.0671111345291138,
0.22592876851558685,
0.8930036425590515,
0.3440706729888916,
0.26582640409469604,
0.0019419577438384295,
0.11636874824762344,
-0.5537459254264832,
0.5676854252815247,
0.2098018079996109,
-0.4246613681316376,
-0.14494265615940094,
-0.9758241772651672,
-0.7797412872314453,
0.2146654576063156,
-0.3870852589607239,
-0.3926360309123993,
0.23281802237033844,
0.2100887894630432,
-0.44498899579048157,
0.10908107459545135,
-0.8772682547569275,
0.4088933765888214,
0.1155194416642189,
-0.5982850790023804,
0.1248798668384552,
-0.6922051310539246,
0.4375408887863159,
-0.39235883951187134,
-0.1423584669828415,
0.1540333777666092,
0.5244640707969666,
0.4130720794200897,
-0.6788784265518188,
0.7949168682098389,
-0.2309904545545578,
-0.4742752015590668,
0.2027573138475418,
0.3358713388442993,
0.8053467273712158,
0.213841512799263,
0.0644548311829567,
-0.43172216415405273,
-0.27636459469795227,
-0.6744412183761597,
-0.8118785619735718,
0.6212458610534668,
-0.6367703080177307,
-0.9744554758071899,
0.1134994700551033,
-0.8472017645835876,
-0.5102108120918274,
0.2742252051830292,
0.4057890772819519,
0.5545980930328369,
-0.1629505455493927,
0.2204587608575821,
0.9861774444580078,
-0.32760530710220337,
0.16423219442367554,
0.4747081398963928,
0.0452299490571022,
-0.18716658651828766,
0.6590362787246704,
-0.06836891174316406,
0.7900606989860535,
0.030777495354413986,
-0.0798516720533371,
-0.4706295430660248,
-0.22372204065322876,
-0.3052411675453186,
-0.10154178738594055,
-0.3902975618839264,
-0.49909743666648865,
-0.3501393795013428,
-0.20956763625144958,
-0.5694733262062073,
0.3008999526500702,
-0.23443114757537842,
-0.23066949844360352,
-0.047718025743961334,
0.17690396308898926,
-0.04660135135054588,
0.9267584085464478,
-0.011361639015376568,
0.22791416943073273,
-0.6563927531242371,
0.47624555230140686,
0.4595887362957001,
0.19396549463272095,
0.2369479238986969,
-0.47134751081466675,
0.057353660464286804,
0.6728680729866028,
-0.7505462169647217,
-0.7105869650840759,
0.171423077583313,
0.17273154854774475,
0.3872081935405731,
0.688975989818573,
0.3712095022201538,
0.8134483695030212,
-0.36859825253486633,
0.7205445766448975,
0.46831774711608887,
-1.156883955001831,
0.6530321836471558,
-0.5348249673843384,
0.3084568679332733,
0.030384235084056854,
0.25346481800079346,
-0.3686237931251526,
-0.47815456986427307,
-0.7120041251182556,
-0.7082675695419312,
0.7075890898704529,
0.5020294785499573,
0.21102021634578705,
0.06215497851371765,
0.3529846966266632,
0.2700884938240051,
0.5046045184135437,
-0.41667744517326355,
-0.12274011224508286,
-0.5382328033447266,
-0.23414121568202972,
0.14272966980934143,
0.10534275323152542,
-0.7753307223320007,
-0.03666141256690025,
0.6109223961830139,
-0.2828255891799927,
0.16203060746192932,
0.18058134615421295,
0.2112346738576889,
-0.35690033435821533,
0.17955805361270905,
0.7585998773574829,
0.34959477186203003,
0.21872034668922424,
-0.17829781770706177,
-0.010478486306965351,
-0.0777401328086853,
0.21926459670066833,
-0.010804612189531326,
-0.35046419501304626,
0.01015410479158163,
0.025464758276939392,
0.793344259262085,
-0.3719054162502289,
-0.92875736951828,
0.4850116968154907,
0.03198054060339928,
-0.330284059047699,
-0.10800351202487946,
0.229971244931221,
-0.17319566011428833,
0.24790169298648834,
0.30664053559303284,
0.2108471542596817,
0.0672742947936058,
-0.40726572275161743,
0.23955492675304413,
0.7683314681053162,
-0.07959746569395065,
-0.09477230906486511,
0.42018455266952515,
-0.06055073440074921,
0.06270286440849304,
0.779335081577301,
0.19752635061740875,
-0.30267640948295593,
0.5666925311088562,
0.5793924331665039,
0.4544643759727478,
-0.23609434068202972,
0.31119194626808167,
0.45916107296943665,
-0.13114799559116364,
-0.10389432311058044,
0.08534764498472214,
-0.11807046085596085,
-0.7267562747001648,
-0.11317694932222366,
-0.1450367420911789,
-0.40483006834983826,
0.4777844250202179,
-1.193601369857788,
-0.08618280291557312,
-0.7508053779602051,
-0.05912293121218681,
0.11579523980617523,
-0.18641085922718048,
-0.6878110766410828,
0.16619540750980377,
-0.11575154215097427,
0.8518358469009399,
-0.8202232718467712,
0.31725838780403137,
-0.03303186595439911,
-0.40916717052459717,
-1.0418418645858765,
0.22575923800468445,
0.18045969307422638,
-0.5247476100921631,
0.4185071885585785,
-0.10149386525154114,
-0.23667553067207336,
-0.21873576939105988,
-1.1078031063079834,
-0.2733910083770752,
0.7668879628181458,
0.6749457716941833,
-0.7653917074203491,
0.14742667973041534,
0.38985246419906616,
0.38744255900382996,
-0.4525710940361023,
0.24915765225887299,
0.5651790499687195,
0.37923750281333923,
0.37021875381469727,
-0.8074438571929932,
0.2530125379562378,
-0.34054356813430786,
0.16316728293895721,
0.06884755194187164,
-0.7448852062225342,
0.8246397376060486,
0.10652231425046921,
-0.32286959886550903,
0.6431573629379272,
0.33644554018974304,
0.34743183851242065,
0.03869466483592987,
0.4014909863471985,
0.6975270509719849,
0.8927529454231262,
-0.32127007842063904,
0.6883161067962646,
0.07956989109516144,
0.30826184153556824,
1.388893485069275,
-0.7115940451622009,
0.6726803183555603,
0.4188442826271057,
0.10219355672597885,
0.6027718782424927,
0.3077845871448517,
-0.21713978052139282,
0.2918606996536255,
0.34467580914497375,
-0.7099883556365967,
-0.6242814064025879,
-0.3910486102104187,
-0.43225738406181335,
0.22599127888679504,
0.3496728837490082,
-0.13537324965000153,
-0.2938089966773987,
-0.13467000424861908,
-0.2583332359790802,
0.20454664528369904,
0.01705196127295494,
0.8672877550125122,
-0.2548045516014099,
-0.8283857107162476,
1.0456243753433228,
-0.4786835014820099,
0.12129054218530655,
-0.5867820978164673,
-0.23179300129413605,
-0.4032089114189148,
0.09284046292304993,
-0.24869340658187866,
-0.8186209201812744,
0.04964316636323929,
0.01860359124839306,
-0.4111100435256958,
-0.011244137771427631,
0.27276137471199036,
-0.3372361660003662,
0.15627819299697876,
-0.09443642199039459,
0.3086133897304535,
-0.26732704043388367,
0.17549483478069305,
-0.6594761610031128,
0.025937378406524658,
0.35406985878944397,
-0.08023735880851746,
0.27325448393821716,
0.6180053353309631,
0.28216037154197693,
0.8103688359260559,
0.6923867464065552,
-0.22575733065605164,
-0.14638133347034454,
-0.01587359420955181,
1.2513394355773926,
-0.2671244740486145,
-0.34184741973876953,
-0.41266557574272156,
0.5675805807113647,
-0.3551980257034302,
-0.1574108898639679,
0.6662834286689758,
0.585481584072113,
0.693753719329834,
-0.004016874823719263,
1.2034716606140137,
-0.003086171578615904,
0.9185429215431213,
-0.40073713660240173,
0.27042701840400696,
-0.5625227093696594,
0.524150013923645,
-0.3335084319114685,
-0.6734165549278259,
0.04769575595855713,
0.36587560176849365,
-0.015008724294602871,
0.14864614605903625,
0.27920523285865784,
1.015562653541565,
-0.15855281054973602,
0.4529429078102112,
0.306925505399704,
0.5966219305992126,
0.5651078224182129,
0.8897461295127869,
1.0321743488311768,
-0.6148284673690796,
0.599395215511322,
0.3792285621166229,
-0.04450615867972374,
0.04880011826753616,
-0.6089322566986084,
-0.6229677200317383,
-0.48959124088287354,
-0.03341338410973549,
-0.8050752878189087,
-0.017365897074341774,
0.7859093546867371,
0.593979001045227,
-1.102577567100525,
0.015923356637358665,
-0.5844458341598511,
-0.08922265470027924,
0.14281439781188965,
-0.19779525697231293,
-0.10866736620664597,
-0.0687374621629715,
-0.689781665802002,
0.1464715301990509,
0.026361919939517975,
0.4206663966178894,
-0.2772829532623291,
-0.2823513150215149,
0.2073867917060852,
0.3870316445827484,
0.1685512512922287,
0.6082801222801208,
-0.7209495902061462,
-0.43594807386398315,
-0.12334337830543518,
-0.13672369718551636,
0.07421685010194778,
0.8246023654937744,
-0.7610569596290588,
0.6106140613555908,
0.43769094347953796,
0.6373977661132812,
0.15229178965091705,
0.15155187249183655,
0.8473198413848877,
-0.9290314316749573,
0.16005456447601318,
0.10113999247550964,
0.18227310478687286,
0.31818148493766785,
-0.362369179725647,
0.22481200098991394,
0.37724316120147705,
-0.40772098302841187,
-0.9243304133415222,
0.8372684717178345,
-0.9209203124046326,
-0.005309035070240498,
0.8431468605995178,
-0.48667654395103455,
0.3632011413574219,
-0.3372824788093567,
-0.2450524866580963,
0.241402268409729,
-0.3529190421104431,
0.8817363977432251,
0.8855187892913818,
-0.17115604877471924,
0.0809599831700325,
-0.358518123626709,
0.3845084011554718,
0.8007344007492065,
-0.8087359070777893,
0.5715064406394958,
0.8563920855522156,
0.22840462625026703,
0.24818693101406097,
0.1905139535665512,
-0.05659131705760956,
0.24062030017375946,
0.2721461057662964,
-0.44395437836647034,
0.17340192198753357,
-0.2595081031322479,
-0.2388436645269394,
0.1060216873884201,
-0.21346764266490936,
0.12579141557216644
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.12482v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.12482v2
|
Embodied LLM Agents Learn to Cooperate in Organized Teams
| 2024-03-19T06:39:47 | 2024-05-23T06:29:00 |
Xudong Guo, Kaixuan Huang, Jiale Liu, Wenhui Fan, Natalia Vélez, Qingyun Wu, Huazheng Wang, Thomas L. Griffiths, Mengdi Wang
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.MA
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have emerged as integral tools for reasoning,
planning, and decision-making, drawing upon their extensive world knowledge and
proficiency in language-related tasks. LLMs thus hold tremendous potential for
natural language interaction within multi-agent systems to foster cooperation.
However, LLM agents tend to over-report and comply with any instruction, which
may result in information redundancy and confusion in multi-agent cooperation.
Inspired by human organizations, this paper introduces a framework that imposes
prompt-based organization structures on LLM agents to mitigate these problems.
Through a series of experiments with embodied LLM agents and human-agent
collaboration, our results highlight the impact of designated leadership on
team efficiency, shedding light on the leadership qualities displayed by LLM
agents and their spontaneous cooperative behaviors. Further, we harness the
potential of LLMs to propose enhanced organizational prompts, via a
Criticize-Reflect process, resulting in novel organization structures that
reduce communication costs and enhance team efficiency.
|
[
-0.30019184947013855,
-0.6248899698257446,
0.8041048645973206,
0.41316089034080505,
-0.03966762125492096,
0.4801345467567444,
-0.21122877299785614,
-0.5211861729621887,
0.433648943901062,
0.375081330537796,
-0.5766737461090088,
-0.3917546570301056,
-0.4150732159614563,
0.5039609670639038,
0.06718667596578598,
0.5888751149177551,
0.17537333071231842,
-0.02337552048265934,
-0.22300295531749725,
-0.25784122943878174,
-0.5384178757667542,
-0.3611224889755249,
-0.8308007717132568,
-0.6176489591598511,
0.7043728828430176,
0.43776845932006836,
1.010377287864685,
0.2818681001663208,
0.12973259389400482,
0.493330180644989,
0.13683129847049713,
0.5581879615783691,
-0.4650702178478241,
0.43279391527175903,
-0.14677028357982635,
-0.5536319613456726,
-0.6207110285758972,
0.13803760707378387,
0.7495421171188354,
0.6622929573059082,
-0.5285074710845947,
-0.3456147015094757,
0.3249152898788452,
0.37185412645339966,
-0.2377886027097702,
0.4986996650695801,
-0.4022201895713806,
-0.09883461147546768,
0.5080153346061707,
-0.35771334171295166,
-0.49179771542549133,
-0.42395615577697754,
-0.1022353246808052,
-0.8440414071083069,
-0.17209942638874054,
0.21400561928749084,
0.3861211836338043,
0.18721993267536163,
-0.20509660243988037,
-0.3437519371509552,
-0.3648707866668701,
0.665810227394104,
-0.3226477801799774,
-0.003999346401542425,
0.45338746905326843,
0.2574554979801178,
-0.4509623050689697,
-0.26465290784835815,
-0.507777750492096,
-0.18896321952342987,
-0.17836464941501617,
0.23577679693698883,
-0.27401208877563477,
0.16963021457195282,
-0.07573293894529343,
-0.11423372477293015,
-0.33528247475624084,
0.3801545798778534,
0.06106417253613472,
0.10171842575073242,
0.6443758010864258,
0.4541979730129242,
0.6860342025756836,
0.0840170681476593,
-0.5213126540184021,
-0.18927086889743805,
-0.49170684814453125,
-0.0012452586088329554,
-0.11884888261556625,
0.4505332112312317,
-0.13630345463752747,
0.34679096937179565,
-0.1579851657152176,
0.30438944697380066,
0.10289718210697174,
0.05468021333217621,
-0.03892066702246666,
-0.1753205955028534,
-0.2811773717403412,
0.10739404708147049,
0.5077652335166931,
0.48283225297927856,
0.12004101276397705,
-0.625347912311554,
-0.5432085990905762,
0.21689637005329132,
0.3412250578403473,
-0.6996521949768066,
0.20451828837394714,
-0.04967064782977104,
-0.2923468053340912,
-0.38000550866127014,
0.1809825599193573,
-0.44407224655151367,
-0.658065915107727,
-0.4138161540031433,
0.5296984314918518,
-0.22940020263195038,
-0.1611727476119995,
-0.09640753269195557,
-0.33570173382759094,
0.5208469033241272,
0.8645288944244385,
-0.6114580631256104,
0.5020031332969666,
0.5992567539215088,
0.8281358480453491,
-0.17830252647399902,
-0.6373104453086853,
-0.7555195093154907,
0.2830163240432739,
-0.623455822467804,
0.5982802510261536,
-0.45810753107070923,
-0.6558566689491272,
0.06896291673183441,
-0.09232305735349655,
-0.008054598234593868,
-0.5822382569313049,
0.26799100637435913,
-0.5135620832443237,
-0.005920523311942816,
-0.6055334806442261,
-0.4422513246536255,
0.09676261991262436,
0.3162172734737396,
-0.5861726999282837,
0.657896101474762,
0.07795064151287079,
-0.20308811962604523,
0.32549145817756653,
-0.7197842001914978,
-0.4584859311580658,
0.4463728368282318,
-0.43481478095054626,
-0.011919545941054821,
0.06164589151740074,
-0.05368659272789955,
0.6318621635437012,
-0.37050679326057434,
0.26346921920776367,
0.054932817816734314,
-0.4828207194805145,
0.33141887187957764,
-0.022149456664919853,
0.6789596080780029,
0.1305677890777588,
-0.2388024777173996,
0.567579984664917,
-0.48786845803260803,
0.07150290906429291,
-0.05777239799499512,
-0.5658532977104187,
-0.3758907914161682,
-0.07705939561128616,
-0.36316293478012085,
0.12343165278434753,
-0.035160306841135025,
-0.04444306716322899,
0.6086211204528809,
-0.08323440700769424,
0.06303064525127411,
1.0816147327423096,
-0.14067485928535461,
1.0238192081451416,
-0.779119074344635,
0.6347611546516418,
-0.41453397274017334,
0.2816280424594879,
-0.040856391191482544,
-0.5188649296760559,
-0.5006545782089233,
-0.62429279088974,
-0.8320530652999878,
0.29289522767066956,
-1.1211674213409424,
0.45136916637420654,
0.001914895954541862,
-0.47529667615890503,
-0.3225957751274109,
0.054102249443531036,
0.31321313977241516,
0.4008779227733612,
0.3228548765182495,
-0.11784622073173523,
-0.4167060852050781,
-0.568170964717865,
-0.04118605703115463,
-0.2347254455089569,
0.05549129098653793,
0.22396865487098694,
0.473719984292984,
-0.20927023887634277,
1.017472267150879,
-0.12845855951309204,
-0.16309617459774017,
-0.545233428478241,
0.15512807667255402,
0.3576042950153351,
0.26974403858184814,
0.31541720032691956,
-0.7264211177825928,
-0.617768406867981,
-0.18627269566059113,
-0.8198240995407104,
-0.3100419342517853,
-0.04456901177763939,
-0.37461838126182556,
0.2962496876716614,
0.42707759141921997,
-0.956571638584137,
0.24537980556488037,
0.31585410237312317,
-0.6398020386695862,
0.7122345566749573,
-0.27514737844467163,
0.31168264150619507,
-0.9039645791053772,
-0.11662312597036362,
-0.501666784286499,
-0.21380415558815002,
-0.7263935208320618,
-0.06230209395289421,
-0.24677728116512299,
0.10354401171207428,
-0.19017168879508972,
0.7726226449012756,
-0.8228333592414856,
-0.2288540154695511,
-0.416876882314682,
0.26094505190849304,
0.1036759689450264,
0.5375516414642334,
0.20471446216106415,
0.8119817972183228,
0.45554468035697937,
-1.0227246284484863,
0.39485964179039,
0.47708237171173096,
-0.2531469762325287,
0.8570937514305115,
-0.8550069332122803,
0.09306228160858154,
-0.33185720443725586,
0.45852071046829224,
-0.6739352941513062,
-0.41266730427742004,
0.3981824815273285,
-0.31199556589126587,
0.3078711926937103,
0.22989971935749054,
-0.7555601000785828,
0.031249338760972023,
-0.5723533630371094,
0.08412113785743713,
0.5313630104064941,
-0.5522294044494629,
0.7755812406539917,
0.20049382746219635,
0.12852506339550018,
-0.4320470988750458,
-0.6003657579421997,
0.27742457389831543,
-0.1647559106349945,
-0.640034556388855,
0.33099886775016785,
-0.4252724051475525,
-0.5392350554466248,
-0.019693074747920036,
0.12675762176513672,
-0.08186358213424683,
0.36521029472351074,
0.4326375424861908,
0.34809455275535583,
0.04083915799856186,
0.40415069460868835,
-0.3203267753124237,
0.21225224435329437,
-0.09458878636360168,
-0.053134795278310776,
0.5858176350593567,
-0.3238774836063385,
-0.21314960718154907,
-0.4716668725013733,
0.5852982997894287,
0.6385406851768494,
-0.053246404975652695,
1.2389940023422241,
0.11341004073619843,
-0.2590184509754181,
-0.42036229372024536,
-0.5130937695503235,
-0.6122291088104248,
-0.4930417537689209,
0.23559580743312836,
-0.04699871316552162,
-0.7240344285964966,
0.7102758288383484,
0.1076287031173706,
0.1992543786764145,
-0.011703957803547382,
0.4762926697731018,
-0.037956155836582184,
0.8054927587509155,
0.5112903714179993,
-0.04951988533139229,
0.46461838483810425,
-0.09462403506040573,
-0.270956426858902,
-0.6753379702568054,
-0.49309760332107544,
-0.5183740854263306,
-0.28408801555633545,
-0.29786211252212524,
-0.667357325553894,
0.41453036665916443,
0.1378599852323532,
-0.26817017793655396,
0.23259606957435608,
-0.37462708353996277,
0.40119466185569763,
0.2838582694530487,
-0.035929471254348755,
0.38390660285949707,
-0.4026728868484497,
0.020528532564640045,
0.3263387978076935,
-0.876590371131897,
-0.7520942687988281,
0.12281540781259537,
0.0952305793762207,
0.9743666648864746,
0.4276161193847656,
0.8339183926582336,
0.41993269324302673,
0.38771796226501465,
-0.7759915590286255,
0.7246584892272949,
0.4937516748905182,
-0.4066924750804901,
-0.6300762295722961,
-0.3802052140235901,
-1.1772119998931885,
0.5022223591804504,
-0.2746986746788025,
-0.5838879942893982,
0.201476588845253,
-0.20651493966579437,
-0.23324862122535706,
0.019996406510472298,
-0.5657921433448792,
0.39309340715408325,
-0.06691914796829224,
-0.4333396553993225,
-0.2810980975627899,
-0.49533092975616455,
0.13888446986675262,
0.11013323068618774,
0.3591946065425873,
0.015058018267154694,
-0.3912135660648346,
0.38703566789627075,
-0.2836710512638092,
1.3070025444030762,
-0.010159444995224476,
-0.24638400971889496,
0.29819202423095703,
0.011156152002513409,
0.9071487784385681,
-0.12960466742515564,
-0.27926382422447205,
-0.3023349344730377,
-0.7507595419883728,
-0.34770408272743225,
-0.7570436596870422,
0.4403734803199768,
-0.6245079040527344,
-0.6392657160758972,
-0.16262105107307434,
-0.4850451350212097,
0.012335757724940777,
0.09896554052829742,
0.19595789909362793,
0.34910649061203003,
-0.396350234746933,
0.18324464559555054,
0.5734177231788635,
-0.4044245183467865,
0.731963038444519,
0.8316017985343933,
-0.07596718519926071,
-0.33912891149520874,
0.4354407787322998,
0.1110016331076622,
0.5055667757987976,
0.27950409054756165,
0.10444477945566177,
-0.21012064814567566,
-0.13570986688137054,
0.011957166716456413,
0.17743563652038574,
-0.6927386522293091,
-0.342108815908432,
-0.45340365171432495,
0.19721420109272003,
-0.3639727830886841,
-0.5893406271934509,
-0.1846800595521927,
-0.12882690131664276,
-0.44005292654037476,
-0.2080136388540268,
0.10339962691068649,
0.9103591442108154,
-0.031805623322725296,
0.34998106956481934,
-0.8486273884773254,
0.12529268860816956,
0.5004007816314697,
0.17151868343353271,
0.38929954171180725,
-0.18272154033184052,
-0.3065197467803955,
-0.15562297403812408,
-0.17852626740932465,
-0.9771074056625366,
0.3713800609111786,
0.11064725369215012,
1.1618843078613281,
0.24516715109348297,
0.38234972953796387,
0.36977285146713257,
-0.38353052735328674,
0.6049020886421204,
0.4124692976474762,
-0.8837401270866394,
0.4099774956703186,
-0.38415664434432983,
0.1798153966665268,
0.14771489799022675,
0.11426249891519547,
-0.550534725189209,
-0.6531981825828552,
-0.49403220415115356,
-0.7495816349983215,
0.979365885257721,
0.5121273398399353,
0.12590810656547546,
-0.24243678152561188,
0.13136976957321167,
-0.06314801424741745,
0.3688189685344696,
-0.5928949117660522,
-0.1357981413602829,
0.12728366255760193,
0.21701820194721222,
-0.03587155416607857,
-0.19293765723705292,
-0.19681121408939362,
0.0937356948852539,
0.4810484051704407,
-0.11063988506793976,
0.1622270792722702,
0.5319908857345581,
-0.12133307754993439,
-0.2399238795042038,
0.5964478254318237,
0.7018653154373169,
0.5396085381507874,
0.25450682640075684,
0.38630279898643494,
0.18068625032901764,
0.14971709251403809,
0.26849332451820374,
-0.3821047246456146,
0.19581882655620575,
-0.2454097867012024,
0.6307928562164307,
0.6081584692001343,
0.20530475676059723,
-0.40174221992492676,
0.29579487442970276,
-0.06837555766105652,
0.11855597794055939,
-0.061826352030038834,
0.3373588025569916,
0.2985581159591675,
0.6885977983474731,
0.6804690361022949,
-0.06763244420289993,
0.0013535472098737955,
-1.1418426036834717,
0.2208648920059204,
0.6416431665420532,
-0.1371416300535202,
-0.36741968989372253,
0.3027651906013489,
0.525778591632843,
-0.6361331343650818,
0.31819814443588257,
-0.3432758152484894,
-0.8194687962532043,
0.7737382650375366,
0.3490291237831116,
0.8812742233276367,
-0.48943713307380676,
0.413298636674881,
0.040612418204545975,
0.4055790305137634,
-0.381054162979126,
0.014957948587834835,
-0.25580447912216187,
-0.9067382216453552,
-0.24098628759384155,
-0.30861997604370117,
-0.49049970507621765,
-0.4384623169898987,
-0.28662338852882385,
0.22636966407299042,
-0.4044540226459503,
-0.2364117056131363,
-0.34105855226516724,
0.12760892510414124,
-0.3991340398788452,
-0.24960549175739288,
0.028718408197164536,
0.5509395599365234,
-0.45233750343322754,
0.687760055065155,
0.7017067074775696,
-0.5539707541465759,
-0.9668979048728943,
-0.3051293194293976,
-0.20076067745685577,
-0.883040726184845,
0.7609977126121521,
0.34174665808677673,
-0.5630273222923279,
-0.010386474430561066,
-0.8208519816398621,
-0.22972972691059113,
1.3081861734390259,
0.42291080951690674,
-0.36390170454978943,
-0.13621865212917328,
-0.24237897992134094,
0.46686869859695435,
-0.6192211508750916,
0.21637412905693054,
0.04795590043067932,
0.6933487057685852,
0.1609867811203003,
-0.9715302586555481,
0.3025963306427002,
-0.11800972372293472,
-0.25259122252464294,
0.018953951075673103,
-0.7432835698127747,
0.7828927636146545,
-0.48734018206596375,
-0.33198419213294983,
0.1643219292163849,
0.5032079219818115,
0.5331780910491943,
0.5192268490791321,
0.5995926260948181,
-0.060095615684986115,
1.0583176612854004,
0.2494686096906662,
0.9988545775413513,
0.1789911538362503,
0.022981775924563408,
1.0427484512329102,
-0.44690221548080444,
0.2769569456577301,
0.49912163615226746,
0.13909666240215302,
0.4757581353187561,
-0.07058358937501907,
0.008991815149784088,
0.24828927218914032,
0.21730710566043854,
-0.458939790725708,
-0.43836161494255066,
-0.5650038123130798,
-0.15016649663448334,
0.2886822819709778,
0.14378798007965088,
-0.15864039957523346,
-0.10314548015594482,
-0.21086379885673523,
-0.05370854586362839,
0.4258692264556885,
-0.31080764532089233,
0.7217702269554138,
0.31708037853240967,
-0.7816675305366516,
0.4185324013233185,
-0.289353609085083,
0.7491215467453003,
-0.4542511999607086,
-0.3529687523841858,
-0.2069357931613922,
-0.174265518784523,
-0.2868272066116333,
-0.6399935483932495,
0.18110594153404236,
-0.16983440518379211,
-0.21449273824691772,
-0.551914632320404,
0.49371352791786194,
-0.6436624526977539,
0.18572747707366943,
0.6257298588752747,
0.6058884263038635,
-0.01951434835791588,
-0.17971475422382355,
-0.19182004034519196,
0.035384755581617355,
-0.4043862223625183,
-0.30327552556991577,
0.21327431499958038,
0.5051740407943726,
-0.1149907261133194,
0.8211791515350342,
0.4538167119026184,
-0.11541201174259186,
-0.18290404975414276,
0.23413658142089844,
0.9118033647537231,
-0.6202050447463989,
-0.6374923586845398,
-0.982555091381073,
0.5051490664482117,
-0.35917720198631287,
0.37103134393692017,
0.6650810837745667,
0.17370307445526123,
0.17617779970169067,
-0.024616390466690063,
0.40461552143096924,
0.040882378816604614,
0.06389608979225159,
-0.43286779522895813,
0.8583177328109741,
-0.5345969200134277,
0.5023894309997559,
-0.4115404188632965,
-0.8006640076637268,
-0.10372478514909744,
0.7025278806686401,
0.339183509349823,
0.1527486890554428,
0.3297557234764099,
0.6967705488204956,
0.45346957445144653,
-0.17356014251708984,
0.7283962368965149,
0.27145373821258545,
0.6081013083457947,
0.4452008903026581,
1.283305048942566,
0.14857260882854462,
0.42157503962516785,
0.23226463794708252,
-0.36566099524497986,
-0.2739202082157135,
-0.7924876809120178,
-1.033068299293518,
-0.4469943940639496,
-0.2056397795677185,
0.03572661057114601,
0.16976383328437805,
1.3145536184310913,
0.6530597805976868,
-0.17739975452423096,
-0.3917962312698364,
-0.3234803080558777,
0.5640740394592285,
-0.018999535590410233,
-0.24237191677093506,
0.12001822143793106,
-0.5238608717918396,
-0.5813087821006775,
0.7278769612312317,
0.37240374088287354,
0.2576276361942291,
-0.02442300133407116,
-0.7620774507522583,
-0.14696647226810455,
0.27356040477752686,
0.8469104170799255,
-0.018129631876945496,
-0.6498725414276123,
-0.15644018352031708,
0.21584105491638184,
-0.5766397714614868,
-0.011804110370576382,
0.7175341248512268,
-0.7316581606864929,
0.1930912435054779,
0.47624894976615906,
0.3788243532180786,
-0.22715626657009125,
0.06708936393260956,
0.7373552322387695,
-0.747808575630188,
-0.0027950096409767866,
0.46217483282089233,
0.20351220667362213,
0.26082873344421387,
-0.5719471573829651,
0.6002503633499146,
0.07289217412471771,
-0.6289035677909851,
-0.7143814563751221,
0.09278148412704468,
-0.8772002458572388,
-0.4248224198818207,
1.1192938089370728,
-0.1272403597831726,
-0.13967300951480865,
-0.16560013592243195,
-0.4308903217315674,
0.5563825368881226,
-0.9976552128791809,
0.7841023206710815,
0.6988062858581543,
-0.28665050864219666,
-0.1134343296289444,
-0.26727432012557983,
0.5237507224082947,
0.33513325452804565,
-1.101778268814087,
0.16184833645820618,
0.6462198495864868,
-0.183838352560997,
0.16120734810829163,
0.959616482257843,
0.2795184850692749,
0.23365455865859985,
-0.16735489666461945,
0.12029524892568588,
-0.09516239911317825,
-0.4469725489616394,
-0.2664392292499542,
-0.05318763852119446,
0.19628940522670746,
-0.09379078447818756
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15456v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15456v3
|
WoLF: Wide-scope Large Language Model Framework for CXR Understanding
| 2024-03-19T06:39:23 | 2024-03-29T04:38:51 |
Seil Kang, Donghyun Kim, Junhyeok Kim, Hyo Kyung Lee, Seong Jae Hwang
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Significant methodological strides have been made toward Chest X-ray (CXR)
understanding via modern vision-language models (VLMs), demonstrating
impressive Visual Question Answering (VQA) and CXR report generation abilities.
However, existing CXR understanding frameworks still possess several procedural
caveats. (1) Previous methods solely use CXR reports, which are insufficient
for comprehensive Visual Question Answering (VQA), especially when additional
health-related data like medication history and prior diagnoses are needed. (2)
Previous methods use raw CXR reports, which are often arbitrarily structured.
While modern language models can understand various text formats, restructuring
reports for clearer, organized anatomy-based information could enhance their
usefulness. (3) Current evaluation methods for CXR-VQA primarily emphasize
linguistic correctness, lacking the capability to offer nuanced assessments of
the generated answers. In this work, to address the aforementioned caveats, we
introduce WoLF, a Wide-scope Large Language Model Framework for CXR
understanding. To resolve (1), we capture multi-faceted records of patients,
which are utilized for accurate diagnoses in real-world clinical scenarios.
Specifically, we adopt the Electronic Health Records (EHR) to generate
instruction-following data suited for CXR understanding. Regarding (2), we
enhance report generation performance by decoupling knowledge in CXR reports
based on anatomical structure even within the attention step via masked
attention. To address (3), we introduce an AI-evaluation protocol optimized for
assessing the capabilities of LLM. Through extensive experimental validations,
WoLF demonstrates superior performance over other models on MIMIC-CXR in the
AI-evaluation arena about VQA (up to +9.47%p mean score) and by metrics about
report generation (+7.3%p BLEU-1).
|
[
-0.29112952947616577,
-0.5767630338668823,
0.846736490726471,
0.1285768300294876,
-0.2709066569805145,
-0.1475237011909485,
-0.09223823249340057,
-0.8790481686592102,
-0.13525989651679993,
0.7627606391906738,
-0.5693601965904236,
-0.5705187320709229,
-0.6131078600883484,
-0.11147952824831009,
-0.44232094287872314,
0.9702135920524597,
0.1240377128124237,
0.2837846577167511,
-0.22884155809879303,
-0.3345418870449066,
-0.40818095207214355,
-0.693726658821106,
-0.7454209327697754,
-0.4505072236061096,
0.5815390944480896,
-0.12445596605539322,
0.7661061882972717,
0.9634181261062622,
0.6597563028335571,
0.25661933422088623,
-0.24239160120487213,
-0.20542971789836884,
-0.3385084569454193,
-0.1515863537788391,
-0.10868377238512039,
-0.38885051012039185,
-0.5867919325828552,
-0.7178528308868408,
0.6725780367851257,
0.7999390959739685,
-0.24285925924777985,
-0.007049683481454849,
-0.08862722665071487,
0.5184629559516907,
-0.5481242537498474,
0.20659208297729492,
-0.27494585514068604,
0.28951939940452576,
0.11020009219646454,
-0.09429244697093964,
-0.5427409410476685,
-0.09359346330165863,
0.7873752117156982,
-0.6384754180908203,
0.2684931457042694,
-0.002589902374893427,
0.7657641172409058,
0.20716556906700134,
-0.5937977433204651,
-0.44281435012817383,
-0.7170677781105042,
0.797122061252594,
-0.6331787705421448,
0.6827481389045715,
0.1791701316833496,
0.6783270835876465,
0.26424580812454224,
-0.9656149744987488,
-0.24332600831985474,
-0.13871772587299347,
-0.26021847128868103,
0.2537963092327118,
-0.591997504234314,
0.2997937500476837,
0.23079730570316315,
0.6407508254051208,
-0.8958265781402588,
0.08701841533184052,
-0.23582515120506287,
-0.3620123565196991,
0.6995822787284851,
0.5106390118598938,
0.2832227051258087,
-0.17937755584716797,
-0.366692453622818,
-0.36458486318588257,
-0.47146546840667725,
0.10521867126226425,
-0.3496900796890259,
0.08999944478273392,
-0.28849706053733826,
0.45095038414001465,
-0.3590944707393646,
0.9167959094047546,
0.04022634029388428,
-0.2914673984050751,
0.24882544577121735,
-0.2514972686767578,
-0.5072011947631836,
0.11540888994932175,
0.6046682000160217,
0.29253533482551575,
-0.24555525183677673,
-0.3301336467266083,
-0.04973038658499718,
0.08658723533153534,
0.23991219699382782,
-0.8264468312263489,
-0.027878042310476303,
0.5157684087753296,
-0.8598027229309082,
-0.18098662793636322,
-0.12156996876001358,
-0.6457614302635193,
-0.445989191532135,
-0.33228635787963867,
0.3834415674209595,
-0.3857448995113373,
-0.19272857904434204,
0.5102729797363281,
0.005461939610540867,
0.7249404191970825,
0.42844635248184204,
-0.41726240515708923,
0.45360997319221497,
0.6151175498962402,
0.4443759024143219,
0.006978115066885948,
-0.004664899315685034,
-0.8592703938484192,
-0.08488881587982178,
-0.17758892476558685,
0.8249781727790833,
-0.34604448080062866,
-0.4368899464607239,
0.040238041430711746,
0.16096404194831848,
0.08842216432094574,
-0.6334390044212341,
0.3699314594268799,
-0.33894798159599304,
0.055854566395282745,
-0.16677232086658478,
-0.3731500804424286,
-0.41431716084480286,
0.5200355648994446,
-0.6244881749153137,
0.5329558849334717,
0.08515693247318268,
-0.5356622934341431,
0.2539985179901123,
-0.2739775776863098,
-0.3800942301750183,
0.09384378790855408,
-0.31037113070487976,
-0.41249993443489075,
0.1605183482170105,
0.5003416538238525,
0.575961172580719,
-0.5323255062103271,
0.3801848590373993,
0.0013469945406541228,
-0.018822479993104935,
0.22488676011562347,
-0.2002507448196411,
0.6450895071029663,
0.010132390074431896,
-0.31906023621559143,
0.256067156791687,
-0.9703395962715149,
0.3405199348926544,
-0.02745971269905567,
-0.20742926001548767,
-0.22777298092842102,
0.0598117932677269,
0.0870376005768776,
0.21179191768169403,
-0.029279373586177826,
-0.4700661301612854,
-0.00834129098802805,
-0.3785143196582794,
0.10301124304533005,
0.38198333978652954,
-0.028696652501821518,
0.05569291114807129,
-0.5821337699890137,
0.6679967641830444,
-0.2415442317724228,
0.2694817781448364,
-0.4373261034488678,
-0.21367529034614563,
-0.7037185430526733,
-0.4189487397670746,
-0.09584742784500122,
0.5147374868392944,
-0.6406057476997375,
0.07808986306190491,
-0.24780714511871338,
-0.6123329401016235,
-0.5257720947265625,
-0.19935406744480133,
0.9539681673049927,
0.5865887403488159,
0.38664373755455017,
-0.3278965950012207,
-0.47207120060920715,
-0.9840757846832275,
0.03819599747657776,
-0.14821316301822662,
-0.152359738945961,
0.675686240196228,
0.24952128529548645,
-0.3531892001628876,
0.4767579436302185,
-0.6491330862045288,
-0.32670584321022034,
-0.35615256428718567,
0.2854110598564148,
0.08873817324638367,
0.23107819259166718,
0.38747215270996094,
-0.7617670297622681,
-0.17248591780662537,
0.3724996745586395,
-0.9443631768226624,
0.15644364058971405,
-0.23742525279521942,
-0.028707673773169518,
-0.045115381479263306,
0.5330814123153687,
-0.1998792439699173,
0.43963101506233215,
0.736913800239563,
-0.2828081548213959,
0.4880673289299011,
-0.21713294088840485,
0.10472352057695389,
-0.903965175151825,
0.14823122322559357,
0.19313789904117584,
-0.3970473110675812,
-0.5435479283332825,
0.33700451254844666,
0.04144265875220299,
-0.044852543622255325,
-0.7093350887298584,
0.7774794101715088,
-0.5755909085273743,
-0.08241411298513412,
-0.015538041479885578,
0.04597928002476692,
0.10597556829452515,
0.34732669591903687,
0.5526298880577087,
0.15775534510612488,
0.7260315418243408,
-0.5706731677055359,
0.23759569227695465,
0.42901965975761414,
-0.2813482880592346,
0.749862015247345,
-0.9726290106773376,
0.17329098284244537,
-0.14539580047130585,
0.13901303708553314,
-0.682806134223938,
-0.14546814560890198,
-0.02971675433218479,
-0.41920921206474304,
0.4613865315914154,
-0.10769559442996979,
-0.27015402913093567,
-0.41812294721603394,
-0.2053973525762558,
0.5677606463432312,
0.43967974185943604,
-0.4761267602443695,
0.8850492835044861,
0.23564466834068298,
-0.0859256237745285,
-0.6474418640136719,
-0.7163524627685547,
0.059666600078344345,
0.1194644346833229,
-0.7884312272071838,
0.2800746560096741,
-0.3052070736885071,
-0.4936583638191223,
0.07148324698209763,
-0.1259220987558365,
-0.3133033514022827,
-0.25195395946502686,
0.06016962230205536,
0.32202738523483276,
-0.6748965978622437,
0.05493275448679924,
-0.13374535739421844,
-0.20123106241226196,
0.13980679214000702,
-0.1526230126619339,
0.42117708921432495,
-0.25945836305618286,
-0.5409649610519409,
-0.4268617331981659,
0.5055702328681946,
0.7690191268920898,
-0.38869571685791016,
0.44339531660079956,
0.3516544699668884,
-0.5325417518615723,
0.03379189595580101,
-0.5840381383895874,
-0.13221612572669983,
-0.318684846162796,
0.6649671792984009,
-0.2939789295196533,
-1.017988920211792,
0.6488224864006042,
0.20452538132667542,
0.017873674631118774,
0.27315109968185425,
0.750745415687561,
0.13521693646907806,
1.445267677307129,
0.9850731492042542,
0.1257910579442978,
-0.05213025584816933,
-0.23120112717151642,
0.21348749101161957,
-1.0937259197235107,
-0.37827619910240173,
-0.661978006362915,
0.23895405232906342,
-0.5039830803871155,
-0.2593194842338562,
0.5119352340698242,
-0.39478328824043274,
0.014333885163068771,
-0.114714615046978,
-0.6804291605949402,
0.18497221171855927,
-0.007699036039412022,
0.3922523260116577,
0.41052135825157166,
-0.21196992695331573,
0.22423085570335388,
-0.034712519496679306,
-0.6500609517097473,
-0.2621053457260132,
0.9938040375709534,
0.4915529489517212,
0.8909814953804016,
0.05697878077626228,
0.4804616868495941,
-0.0557064451277256,
0.41002312302589417,
-1.1402876377105713,
0.3336394429206848,
-0.24928347766399384,
-0.5593350529670715,
-0.23734785616397858,
-0.19052018225193024,
-0.9861087799072266,
0.5038429498672485,
-0.2054734230041504,
-0.8884173631668091,
0.19276434183120728,
0.17925924062728882,
-0.5929277539253235,
0.07198277115821838,
-0.37886762619018555,
0.8829848766326904,
-0.4845781624317169,
-0.28208956122398376,
-0.12323006242513657,
-0.7755555510520935,
0.5378447771072388,
-0.13470715284347534,
0.2764870226383209,
0.32160046696662903,
0.024748962372541428,
0.5118024349212646,
-0.39383664727211,
0.7918300032615662,
0.11476214230060577,
-0.20061998069286346,
-0.04831494018435478,
-0.02043745666742325,
0.27837520837783813,
0.07429765909910202,
-0.16953891515731812,
0.18784557282924652,
0.2784735858440399,
-0.23566509783267975,
-0.6269639730453491,
0.43846753239631653,
-0.6415001749992371,
-0.4958755075931549,
-0.5528424382209778,
-0.8468696475028992,
-0.17681626975536346,
0.12308145314455032,
0.3601944148540497,
0.8784801959991455,
-0.30090081691741943,
0.40814638137817383,
0.9178549647331238,
-0.6364881992340088,
-0.09555220603942871,
0.7272188067436218,
-0.3425953686237335,
-0.3740637004375458,
0.6409100890159607,
-0.03174491599202156,
0.34589776396751404,
0.5436473488807678,
0.19819384813308716,
-0.33264949917793274,
-0.6405260562896729,
-0.4691217839717865,
0.49438992142677307,
-0.7894837856292725,
-0.1166091114282608,
-0.8325668573379517,
-0.4148257374763489,
-0.06856119632720947,
-0.5109218955039978,
-0.16843733191490173,
0.16345827281475067,
0.020742876455187798,
0.14515629410743713,
0.16651546955108643,
0.7243494391441345,
0.08275187015533447,
0.34968873858451843,
-1.0461269617080688,
0.45503392815589905,
0.24082817137241364,
0.2408803105354309,
0.14673300087451935,
-0.4240538477897644,
-0.1941957026720047,
-0.11981334537267685,
-0.07863246649503708,
-0.6340059638023376,
0.4053088128566742,
0.020762711763381958,
0.7016441226005554,
0.22106079757213593,
0.04441702365875244,
0.8988750576972961,
-0.28324946761131287,
0.6798444390296936,
0.2601158618927002,
-1.08943772315979,
0.6586898565292358,
-0.30333611369132996,
0.575459897518158,
0.22936485707759857,
0.11433359980583191,
-0.5007771849632263,
-0.5670896172523499,
-0.6325040459632874,
-1.0215178728103638,
0.7070934176445007,
-0.09249313175678253,
0.08921584486961365,
0.13179805874824524,
0.2842267155647278,
0.09637599438428879,
-0.005631665233522654,
-0.8497858643531799,
-0.1299697458744049,
0.08426976948976517,
-0.2764032185077667,
-0.11259795725345612,
-0.18820255994796753,
-0.19258636236190796,
-0.21532808244228363,
0.45644667744636536,
-0.363472580909729,
0.2569729685783386,
0.591995358467102,
-0.18090087175369263,
-0.06751938909292221,
0.34347307682037354,
0.40909719467163086,
0.9449754357337952,
-0.11571159958839417,
0.04832872003316879,
0.24917617440223694,
-0.5120026469230652,
-0.097737617790699,
0.22710439562797546,
0.17758512496948242,
-0.1584351509809494,
0.7931748628616333,
0.6982167959213257,
0.2920733392238617,
-0.9688618183135986,
0.5735368132591248,
-0.48154667019844055,
-0.35958829522132874,
-0.13560925424098969,
-0.10602862387895584,
0.10857701301574707,
0.44205501675605774,
0.26045936346054077,
-0.16784891486167908,
0.2995295524597168,
-0.547197163105011,
0.3705848455429077,
0.43748360872268677,
-0.7885498404502869,
-0.002155009191483259,
0.5427854061126709,
-0.1122109517455101,
0.0631326213479042,
0.6541249752044678,
0.1446097493171692,
-0.368577778339386,
0.865667462348938,
0.5958432555198669,
0.7535024285316467,
-0.15333519876003265,
0.17081190645694733,
0.4212511479854584,
0.2735386788845062,
-0.06351324170827866,
0.34642279148101807,
-0.11048417538404465,
-0.4496867060661316,
-0.6358725428581238,
-0.481410950422287,
-0.4856082499027252,
0.3707186281681061,
-1.1799767017364502,
0.317450612783432,
-0.4264850318431854,
0.23365896940231323,
0.1870037466287613,
-0.24556198716163635,
-0.6903576850891113,
0.6223530769348145,
0.22067183256149292,
0.8500086665153503,
-0.5679591298103333,
0.7295172810554504,
0.6433421969413757,
-0.37013721466064453,
-1.0816859006881714,
0.12608978152275085,
0.2605627179145813,
-0.9378718733787537,
0.47792044281959534,
0.20507755875587463,
-0.15159207582473755,
-0.08948231488466263,
-0.40084153413772583,
-0.7026995420455933,
1.1638282537460327,
0.3835226595401764,
-0.8619474768638611,
0.10893481224775314,
-0.10463564097881317,
0.7776094079017639,
-0.38248899579048157,
0.17581091821193695,
0.49650701880455017,
0.3201867938041687,
0.2656060457229614,
-1.137114405632019,
0.2825620770454407,
-0.22267520427703857,
-0.05804155766963959,
0.1645846664905548,
-0.40431055426597595,
0.7039110064506531,
-0.47496506571769714,
-0.10517184436321259,
0.29871752858161926,
0.3209015130996704,
0.3086228668689728,
0.5422253608703613,
0.36694252490997314,
0.5630452036857605,
0.7264723181724548,
-0.023614566773176193,
1.5504140853881836,
-0.15337343513965607,
0.22685037553310394,
1.0088075399398804,
-0.31060951948165894,
0.7920286655426025,
0.22836795449256897,
0.11684658378362656,
0.3220800757408142,
0.45673057436943054,
0.009506103582680225,
0.3385156989097595,
0.2683584988117218,
-0.19866180419921875,
-0.34456560015678406,
-0.17217566072940826,
-0.5212442278862,
0.528215765953064,
0.20773018896579742,
-0.4963567554950714,
-0.3166368901729584,
0.2625458836555481,
0.13580672442913055,
-0.05566771328449249,
-0.3951363265514374,
1.0046916007995605,
0.06256336718797684,
-0.577439546585083,
0.7823658585548401,
-0.3527339696884155,
0.32805997133255005,
-0.8185678720474243,
-0.18018896877765656,
0.03923354297876358,
0.44534528255462646,
-0.2685571610927582,
-0.9083995223045349,
0.5181547999382019,
0.09946753829717636,
-0.32612231373786926,
0.05321633443236351,
0.5191900730133057,
-0.21233658492565155,
-0.6278607845306396,
0.5814975500106812,
0.5897067785263062,
0.11289186775684357,
-0.09928137809038162,
-0.5985511541366577,
0.410410612821579,
0.0985477864742279,
-0.08005137741565704,
0.3757384717464447,
0.3182589113712311,
-0.218890979886055,
0.7451679110527039,
0.48055097460746765,
0.04525645449757576,
-0.29062971472740173,
0.07273527979850769,
0.8420732021331787,
-0.4962124526500702,
-0.41935092210769653,
-0.6244734525680542,
0.7502341270446777,
0.12335477769374847,
-0.21606004238128662,
0.3618590235710144,
0.4705263376235962,
0.7676486372947693,
0.2116125077009201,
0.9816901087760925,
0.017328297719359398,
0.346797913312912,
-0.6853460073471069,
0.6913449168205261,
-0.898953914642334,
0.17244577407836914,
-0.3020998239517212,
-0.5849692821502686,
-0.7271448969841003,
0.5274695158004761,
-0.3115396797657013,
-0.22416095435619354,
0.8298482894897461,
0.7346230745315552,
-0.021227743476629257,
-0.12950557470321655,
0.5530476570129395,
0.4744940400123596,
0.38829776644706726,
0.7741279602050781,
0.6802535653114319,
-0.38058915734291077,
0.8104379773139954,
-0.1728907823562622,
-0.5108303427696228,
-0.18312744796276093,
-0.8159659504890442,
-0.7135331630706787,
-0.5218183994293213,
-0.4896271824836731,
-0.34871336817741394,
0.15710297226905823,
0.5437552332878113,
1.0611931085586548,
-0.5043665170669556,
-0.178849995136261,
0.24496760964393616,
-0.11644042283296585,
-0.33917108178138733,
-0.17602595686912537,
0.6378554701805115,
-0.056724272668361664,
-0.33203238248825073,
0.10897146910429001,
0.44550853967666626,
-0.12598420679569244,
-0.23899675905704498,
-0.2308298498392105,
0.30101650953292847,
-0.013935143128037453,
0.898936927318573,
0.39617255330085754,
-0.9541001915931702,
-0.28860601782798767,
0.3935224115848541,
-0.1268519014120102,
0.25428134202957153,
0.7564919590950012,
-0.8577798008918762,
0.7809261679649353,
0.20867885649204254,
0.7589542865753174,
0.6900625228881836,
-0.28311479091644287,
0.5866497159004211,
-0.21820226311683655,
-0.006716339848935604,
0.3073386251926422,
0.39785075187683105,
0.3918551504611969,
-0.632104754447937,
0.21877750754356384,
-0.22258807718753815,
-0.4684760868549347,
-0.8546299934387207,
0.21614961326122284,
-1.3527534008026123,
-0.3335620164871216,
0.9333939552307129,
-0.17337322235107422,
-0.28590309619903564,
-0.2725130021572113,
-0.5180582404136658,
-0.0030709956772625446,
0.014210080727934837,
0.6056375503540039,
0.4325230121612549,
-0.5627031326293945,
-0.45438575744628906,
-0.7023909091949463,
0.15297269821166992,
0.28980642557144165,
-1.0470974445343018,
0.056023165583610535,
0.6259155869483948,
0.2842606008052826,
0.13124266266822815,
0.7888670563697815,
-0.4853726029396057,
0.6946753263473511,
-0.1803119033575058,
0.11803419142961502,
0.23662802577018738,
-0.10484469681978226,
-0.562995195388794,
0.11115958541631699,
0.19461670517921448,
-0.052030667662620544
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.12469v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.12469v1
|
When Do "More Contexts" Help with Sarcasm Recognition?
| 2024-03-19T06:01:02 | 2024-03-19T06:01:02 |
Ojas Nimase, Sanghyun Hong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Sarcasm recognition is challenging because it needs an understanding of the
true intention, which is opposite to or different from the literal meaning of
the words. Prior work has addressed this challenge by developing a series of
methods that provide richer $contexts$, e.g., sentiment or cultural nuances, to
models. While shown to be effective individually, no study has systematically
evaluated their collective effectiveness. As a result, it remains unclear to
what extent additional contexts can improve sarcasm recognition. In this work,
we explore the improvements that existing methods bring by incorporating more
contexts into a model. To this end, we develop a framework where we can
integrate multiple contextual cues and test different approaches. In evaluation
with four approaches on three sarcasm recognition benchmarks, we achieve
existing state-of-the-art performances and also demonstrate the benefits of
sequentially adding more contexts. We also identify inherent drawbacks of using
more contexts, highlighting that in the pursuit of even better results, the
model may need to adopt societal biases.
|
[
-0.4880276918411255,
-0.3223314881324768,
0.5170600414276123,
0.3106861412525177,
-0.431059867143631,
-0.15990319848060608,
-0.3326912522315979,
-0.5387499332427979,
0.11095492541790009,
-0.006766959093511105,
-0.5736712217330933,
-0.05648372694849968,
-0.6019585132598877,
0.48413360118865967,
-0.17662744224071503,
1.022539734840393,
0.1704680323600769,
0.2679574489593506,
0.023051612079143524,
-0.3387959599494934,
-0.7617949843406677,
-0.5551120638847351,
-0.6800034642219543,
-0.23561392724514008,
0.5083801746368408,
0.3531005084514618,
0.2705746591091156,
0.027499951422214508,
0.6060762405395508,
0.24327926337718964,
-0.14403904974460602,
-0.06859558820724487,
-0.37239906191825867,
0.12031567841768265,
0.12942789494991302,
-0.2868717312812805,
-0.08016534894704819,
0.19051872193813324,
0.5088174343109131,
0.32121121883392334,
0.3510969579219818,
0.2120356410741806,
-0.27898502349853516,
0.1423255354166031,
-0.7834165096282959,
0.030648576095700264,
-0.3143579661846161,
0.23426896333694458,
0.011469821445643902,
-0.31651419401168823,
-0.4224647283554077,
-0.25574105978012085,
0.37489163875579834,
-0.2733129560947418,
-0.19629575312137604,
-0.30729636549949646,
0.4869047999382019,
0.15401576459407806,
-1.0779598951339722,
-0.025043560191988945,
-0.5029001832008362,
0.6360127329826355,
-0.5995315909385681,
0.239167258143425,
-0.08173742890357971,
0.6091288924217224,
0.25051042437553406,
-0.7439301013946533,
-0.412818968296051,
-0.10856889933347702,
-0.24534404277801514,
0.2581733465194702,
0.07220469415187836,
-0.18834984302520752,
0.634563148021698,
0.010158187709748745,
-0.17934125661849976,
-0.5623034834861755,
-0.17654326558113098,
-0.3516291081905365,
0.304450124502182,
0.13777223229408264,
0.21659162640571594,
-0.3029271960258484,
-0.6741555333137512,
0.02828550525009632,
-0.4540162980556488,
0.3830771744251251,
-0.028281373903155327,
0.1687866747379303,
0.0012586504453793168,
0.06377940624952316,
-0.16655464470386505,
0.2918190658092499,
-0.20957036316394806,
-0.14495182037353516,
0.19312651455402374,
-0.3708817660808563,
-0.209904283285141,
-0.2040625661611557,
-0.00910421833395958,
0.4526616334915161,
0.3004191219806671,
0.07565587759017944,
-0.08726172894239426,
0.16452467441558838,
0.1680043637752533,
-0.7751865386962891,
-0.12683536112308502,
-0.263651967048645,
-0.27812978625297546,
-0.15275180339813232,
0.17192865908145905,
-0.26281967759132385,
-0.6007782220840454,
-0.5181861519813538,
0.13113842904567719,
-0.48208823800086975,
-0.265857994556427,
-0.02407611533999443,
-1.2414238452911377,
0.523922324180603,
0.770253598690033,
-0.27919790148735046,
0.15190105140209198,
0.6435786485671997,
0.7626060247421265,
0.2621745467185974,
-0.30420130491256714,
-0.4335031509399414,
0.046806707978248596,
-0.19507932662963867,
0.6861390471458435,
-0.8004685640335083,
-0.1884600669145584,
-0.3013070523738861,
-0.10975753515958786,
-0.09614066779613495,
-0.24469971656799316,
0.7785177826881409,
-0.41807711124420166,
0.1137232705950737,
-1.0503543615341187,
-0.22904296219348907,
-0.40948814153671265,
0.45946216583251953,
-0.8031920194625854,
1.11874520778656,
0.29100993275642395,
-0.8577315807342529,
0.49992865324020386,
-0.5553085207939148,
-0.8340199589729309,
0.23995272815227509,
-0.2573898136615753,
0.2850404679775238,
0.7797305583953857,
0.18736660480499268,
0.25264623761177063,
-0.2505572736263275,
0.5858497023582458,
-0.24558855593204498,
-0.6663957238197327,
0.7595774531364441,
-0.9557494521141052,
1.139482021331787,
-0.03137676417827606,
-0.7021141052246094,
-0.2772979140281677,
-0.2420407086610794,
-0.10715297609567642,
-0.16105374693870544,
-0.25024840235710144,
-0.5055451989173889,
-0.37559011578559875,
0.30981335043907166,
0.48319149017333984,
0.05796961858868599,
-0.18858426809310913,
-0.16729086637496948,
-0.2008546143770218,
0.5969027280807495,
0.7774971127510071,
-0.31945404410362244,
0.42948952317237854,
-0.22209195792675018,
0.43704888224601746,
0.18667520582675934,
0.3343193233013153,
-0.29508262872695923,
-0.4777012765407562,
-0.5577353835105896,
-0.37446457147598267,
0.06409938633441925,
0.43188101053237915,
-0.6064387559890747,
0.16435571014881134,
-0.25242936611175537,
-0.03880711644887924,
-0.00299812201410532,
-0.23569877445697784,
0.5179414749145508,
0.7057878375053406,
0.38504403829574585,
-0.681074321269989,
-0.8443688750267029,
-0.6145663857460022,
-0.6041245460510254,
0.003101478097960353,
0.41108086705207825,
0.8180736899375916,
0.6877203583717346,
-0.042743269354104996,
1.0296066999435425,
-0.4919778108596802,
-0.08403719216585159,
-0.08368700742721558,
0.10609915852546692,
-0.22985689342021942,
0.21470694243907928,
0.8527705073356628,
-1.0137195587158203,
-0.6242373585700989,
0.04547630250453949,
-0.6777973175048828,
0.2310308814048767,
-0.009076493792235851,
-0.17905224859714508,
0.042032018303871155,
0.4755617678165436,
-0.48465874791145325,
0.4764672815799713,
0.057660285383462906,
-0.08939480781555176,
0.6824426651000977,
0.5469845533370972,
0.38479378819465637,
-0.7654448747634888,
0.14309024810791016,
0.07466986775398254,
-0.27176424860954285,
-0.838434636592865,
0.22982777655124664,
0.09930837899446487,
0.05906958878040314,
-0.5356054306030273,
1.0551261901855469,
-0.5202591419219971,
-0.13133925199508667,
-0.13555102050304413,
0.18539828062057495,
0.18987968564033508,
0.214900940656662,
0.03544369339942932,
0.5938018560409546,
0.5296962261199951,
-0.45267269015312195,
0.46531081199645996,
-0.2902901768684387,
-0.2983018159866333,
1.0743684768676758,
-0.3459753096103668,
-0.02578793466091156,
-0.2483985722064972,
1.219635248184204,
-1.277638554573059,
-0.7596577405929565,
0.3281688392162323,
-0.5808484554290771,
0.12933143973350525,
-0.009159346111118793,
-0.08536181598901749,
-0.6107168793678284,
-0.6775099635124207,
0.8793428540229797,
0.4081076979637146,
-0.7957044839859009,
0.6509042978286743,
0.10400024056434631,
0.13931293785572052,
-1.062070369720459,
-1.1572260856628418,
0.4554387331008911,
-0.7251102924346924,
-0.5542964935302734,
0.2547107934951782,
-0.0009189036791212857,
-0.20736287534236908,
-0.35236114263534546,
-0.30897316336631775,
-0.20638003945350647,
0.33884766697883606,
-0.07774288952350616,
-0.10945381969213486,
-0.25609076023101807,
0.29375338554382324,
0.10008101910352707,
-0.04505029693245888,
0.04007713496685028,
-0.30733340978622437,
0.22553445398807526,
-0.06279589980840683,
-0.013491985388100147,
-0.9020661115646362,
0.40111541748046875,
0.3293289244174957,
0.06526026129722595,
0.505851149559021,
1.0285354852676392,
-0.707417905330658,
-0.0018891035579144955,
-0.8338704705238342,
-0.37318116426467896,
-0.43578121066093445,
0.08815515786409378,
-0.4040144681930542,
-0.8666028380393982,
0.6559332609176636,
-0.2767912447452545,
-0.33660927414894104,
0.08045060187578201,
0.10245237499475479,
0.10876954346895218,
0.9436753392219543,
0.5080034732818604,
-0.1089935302734375,
0.7806035876274109,
0.08593900501728058,
0.43850260972976685,
-1.2205981016159058,
-0.07992768287658691,
-0.40847745537757874,
-0.5136219263076782,
-0.09028346091508865,
-0.550743579864502,
0.45624953508377075,
-0.12611080706119537,
-0.018007325008511543,
0.41056546568870544,
-0.21297712624073029,
0.7265046834945679,
0.26150423288345337,
0.27238327264785767,
0.2889968156814575,
0.023054122924804688,
0.017459029331803322,
-0.038394421339035034,
-0.5298385620117188,
-0.4116809666156769,
0.5643531084060669,
0.058200936764478683,
0.346316397190094,
0.5224076509475708,
0.6423454880714417,
0.09767470508813858,
0.854925811290741,
-0.8352882266044617,
0.5281676054000854,
-0.10329240560531616,
-1.0575382709503174,
-0.10611363500356674,
-0.5197885036468506,
-0.3988373577594757,
0.30204638838768005,
0.2865599989891052,
-0.8256294131278992,
0.22349250316619873,
0.30635493993759155,
-0.49285417795181274,
-0.37049296498298645,
-1.074268102645874,
0.7225155234336853,
-0.1475687026977539,
-0.17584440112113953,
0.17607161402702332,
-1.078465461730957,
0.5871443748474121,
0.40010976791381836,
0.29793694615364075,
-0.024666499346494675,
-0.04926704987883568,
0.1319507211446762,
0.09714469313621521,
1.19064199924469,
-0.3410344421863556,
0.009962176904082298,
0.4153740108013153,
-0.3582010269165039,
0.3269355893135071,
0.4772082567214966,
-0.11735698580741882,
-0.1821443736553192,
-0.130462646484375,
-0.20687894523143768,
-0.6056997776031494,
0.6658658981323242,
-0.3450232148170471,
-0.4391152262687683,
-0.19136644899845123,
-0.4960157573223114,
0.04497627168893814,
0.029072405770421028,
0.39790627360343933,
0.7806248068809509,
-0.49517688155174255,
0.00691114692017436,
0.32137012481689453,
-0.02612355537712574,
0.41922980546951294,
-0.0028594844043254852,
0.37932831048965454,
-0.4305942952632904,
0.6115675568580627,
0.04837021976709366,
-0.022634021937847137,
0.2468319684267044,
0.29326000809669495,
-0.43991783261299133,
0.10513775050640106,
-0.30616921186447144,
0.012031951919198036,
-1.450927495956421,
-0.40996214747428894,
-0.6171844005584717,
0.07196101546287537,
-1.058748722076416,
-0.426796019077301,
0.3299992084503174,
-0.6546136736869812,
-0.39806148409843445,
0.13976900279521942,
0.47163575887680054,
0.47543415427207947,
-0.02413986623287201,
0.5533309578895569,
-0.30660149455070496,
-0.06891875714063644,
0.2937600016593933,
0.27813488245010376,
0.30990710854530334,
-0.6476700901985168,
-0.005784378852695227,
-0.11962830275297165,
-0.022368162870407104,
-1.1121433973312378,
0.11349975317716599,
0.22856909036636353,
0.457425594329834,
0.3513886630535126,
-0.05710214003920555,
1.0640610456466675,
-0.2873898446559906,
0.6775446534156799,
0.034843310713768005,
-1.201040267944336,
0.29265260696411133,
-0.11093096435070038,
0.3962950110435486,
0.8393915891647339,
0.4406893849372864,
-0.6367053985595703,
-0.04459334909915924,
-0.504308819770813,
-0.7872021198272705,
0.829975426197052,
-0.0471474714577198,
0.8241498470306396,
-0.18414416909217834,
0.6391842365264893,
-0.049032166600227356,
0.3070635199546814,
-1.061596393585205,
0.045290783047676086,
-0.07597625255584717,
-0.20464466512203217,
-0.08062640577554703,
-0.12003067135810852,
-0.6495271325111389,
-0.46991074085235596,
0.3070463538169861,
-0.42657068371772766,
0.13346603512763977,
0.10428735613822937,
-0.5506837368011475,
0.2931562662124634,
0.3111596405506134,
0.6743074655532837,
0.2508417069911957,
0.33759209513664246,
0.43411314487457275,
0.4093446135520935,
-0.17838154733181,
-0.09208305925130844,
-0.16965161263942719,
0.006082773208618164,
-0.02105797454714775,
0.3554348051548004,
0.8703149557113647,
0.2435280680656433,
-0.5460479855537415,
0.8617439270019531,
-0.28510037064552307,
0.13751961290836334,
-0.41815951466560364,
0.07046327739953995,
0.016756724566221237,
0.4369152784347534,
0.27958449721336365,
0.30430275201797485,
0.7500267624855042,
-0.7699335813522339,
0.0048819901421666145,
0.6800301671028137,
-0.4414481818675995,
-0.29337239265441895,
-0.1000557690858841,
0.34833839535713196,
-0.1010463684797287,
0.22378236055374146,
-0.4110666811466217,
-1.1060253381729126,
1.0926865339279175,
0.6270264387130737,
0.7252400517463684,
-0.18539680540561676,
0.32585564255714417,
0.3596026301383972,
0.23652775585651398,
-0.4628802239894867,
0.27622294425964355,
-0.49537137150764465,
-0.5064481496810913,
-0.12447381764650345,
-0.1479967087507248,
-0.07694797962903976,
-0.34917786717414856,
-0.4630313515663147,
0.5661066174507141,
-0.4655962288379669,
-0.5767343640327454,
-0.19070498645305634,
-0.3972747325897217,
-0.7823445796966553,
0.3544886112213135,
-0.021093333140015602,
0.780168354511261,
-1.0491875410079956,
0.14558154344558716,
0.9494959712028503,
-0.21098709106445312,
-0.6942902207374573,
0.44575610756874084,
0.4335688650608063,
-0.5141711831092834,
0.5729082226753235,
0.9444218873977661,
-0.392691433429718,
0.07127559185028076,
-0.5441190600395203,
-0.8144731521606445,
0.9971693754196167,
0.3368063271045685,
-0.11151805520057678,
0.1169843077659607,
-0.5206693410873413,
0.7709086537361145,
-0.6229636073112488,
0.835823655128479,
0.8429871797561646,
0.7722651958465576,
0.2586440443992615,
-0.5863240957260132,
0.4153677523136139,
-0.19745174050331116,
0.024582326412200928,
-0.06785692274570465,
-0.6229576468467712,
0.8154531121253967,
-0.27882909774780273,
-0.46102175116539,
0.06734127551317215,
0.27904340624809265,
0.023468516767024994,
0.7640923857688904,
0.4023168087005615,
0.2707849144935608,
0.660098671913147,
-0.2846401333808899,
1.0267293453216553,
-0.018408749252557755,
0.34616732597351074,
1.2959957122802734,
-0.43190059065818787,
0.5115641951560974,
0.39414089918136597,
0.19589000940322876,
0.5583956241607666,
0.5672868490219116,
0.32373809814453125,
0.2799002230167389,
0.0988074317574501,
-0.43561869859695435,
-0.05957462266087532,
-0.494526207447052,
-0.5277742147445679,
0.3028098940849304,
0.3323290944099426,
-0.4413524568080902,
-0.016636516898870468,
0.1938031166791916,
0.1377527415752411,
-0.24503478407859802,
0.015483048744499683,
0.6767716407775879,
0.172526016831398,
-0.8344685435295105,
0.32744109630584717,
-0.028186701238155365,
0.8030019402503967,
0.06448525190353394,
0.23326025903224945,
-0.31901347637176514,
-0.026090800762176514,
-0.4565456211566925,
-0.31710660457611084,
0.2152653932571411,
0.08503197878599167,
-0.02250712551176548,
0.09315099567174911,
0.8878123164176941,
-0.08389129489660263,
-0.27767419815063477,
0.4083000123500824,
0.3415694832801819,
0.07147949188947678,
-0.07776004821062088,
-0.5711676478385925,
0.13395437598228455,
-0.48262831568717957,
-0.16594815254211426,
-0.02042699046432972,
0.9480370283126831,
-0.21418176591396332,
0.1529359370470047,
0.29391583800315857,
-0.4096094071865082,
0.1325528770685196,
0.6453917026519775,
0.8625528216362,
-0.7201231718063354,
-0.4945371150970459,
-0.8324689269065857,
0.6390537023544312,
-0.49141618609428406,
-0.6600900292396545,
0.6171438694000244,
0.03499618172645569,
0.8025349974632263,
0.1222895085811615,
0.8869003057479858,
-0.21737274527549744,
-0.19245901703834534,
-0.19042909145355225,
-0.13861514627933502,
-0.9003759622573853,
0.2312326580286026,
-0.6394342184066772,
-0.6976916790008545,
-0.6821619868278503,
0.8619160056114197,
-0.30912700295448303,
0.7797902822494507,
0.9534727334976196,
0.3633195459842682,
-0.14164191484451294,
0.44836461544036865,
-0.015023401938378811,
-0.15136198699474335,
0.08025775849819183,
0.5941660404205322,
1.1679776906967163,
-0.35164380073547363,
0.3345772624015808,
-0.057382091879844666,
-0.45842987298965454,
-0.500068724155426,
-0.9095571041107178,
-0.9169260859489441,
-0.2587890625,
-0.055480290204286575,
-0.21988573670387268,
0.08131778985261917,
0.8849216103553772,
0.7206236124038696,
-0.2971576750278473,
0.08191356062889099,
-0.11990030854940414,
0.07103265821933746,
-0.34969428181648254,
-0.29534852504730225,
-0.31407904624938965,
-0.3195517659187317,
-0.475267618894577,
0.018027614802122116,
0.4951935410499573,
-0.06765782833099365,
-0.035826247185468674,
0.030887367203831673,
-0.03645169362425804,
0.2655177116394043,
0.9646839499473572,
0.0916549414396286,
-0.6818501353263855,
-0.545488715171814,
0.2599984407424927,
-0.24696244299411774,
0.0659477636218071,
1.2677075862884521,
-0.6743744611740112,
0.2206798642873764,
0.7599964737892151,
0.664406418800354,
0.12434306740760803,
0.22584904730319977,
0.3002159297466278,
-1.021551251411438,
0.06494095176458359,
0.3126188814640045,
0.38165900111198425,
0.5666055083274841,
-0.708361804485321,
0.47552236914634705,
0.47737178206443787,
-0.12452496588230133,
-1.049641489982605,
0.739904522895813,
-0.7381064295768738,
-0.3998459577560425,
1.2029650211334229,
-0.06948739290237427,
-0.042723171412944794,
-0.11800653487443924,
-0.3929808735847473,
0.31351161003112793,
-0.5811206698417664,
0.6695881485939026,
1.0184139013290405,
-0.4227863848209381,
-0.060109466314315796,
-0.3795524835586548,
0.4051949381828308,
0.771592915058136,
-0.8529413938522339,
0.023476483300328255,
0.8004142045974731,
0.20052476227283478,
0.09045033156871796,
1.0663059949874878,
-0.11078689247369766,
0.6908503174781799,
-0.20680178701877594,
-0.6253970861434937,
0.5933300256729126,
-0.9255635738372803,
-0.7350618839263916,
-0.15168555080890656,
-0.12213131040334702,
0.73714280128479
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.12468v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.12468v1
|
CrossTune: Black-Box Few-Shot Classification with Label Enhancement
| 2024-03-19T05:52:56 | 2024-03-19T05:52:56 |
Danqing Luo, Chen Zhang, Yan Zhang, Haizhou Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Training or finetuning large-scale language models (LLMs) requires
substantial computation resources, motivating recent efforts to explore
parameter-efficient adaptation to downstream tasks. One approach is to treat
these models as black boxes and use forward passes (Inference APIs) to interact
with them. Current research focuses on adapting these black-box models to
downstream tasks using gradient-free prompt optimization, but this often
involves an expensive process of searching task-specific prompts. Therefore, we
are motivated to study black-box language model adaptation without prompt
search. Specifically, we introduce a label-enhanced cross-attention network
called CrossTune, which models the semantic relatedness between the input text
sequence and task-specific label descriptions. Its effectiveness is examined in
the context of few-shot text classification. To improve the generalization of
CrossTune, we utilize ChatGPT to generate additional training data through
in-context learning. A switch mechanism is implemented to exclude low-quality
ChatGPT-generated data. Through extensive experiments on seven benchmark text
classification datasets, we demonstrate that our proposed approach outperforms
the previous state-of-the-art gradient-free black-box tuning method by 5.7% on
average. Even without using ChatGPT-augmented data, CrossTune performs better
or comparably than previous black-box tuning methods, suggesting the
effectiveness of our approach.
|
[
-0.41207417845726013,
-0.7397305369377136,
0.2608345150947571,
-0.0013340205186977983,
-0.30716055631637573,
-0.09583549201488495,
-0.32158806920051575,
-0.49531087279319763,
-0.19107414782047272,
0.44336166977882385,
-0.7436807155609131,
-0.46137598156929016,
-0.5675727725028992,
0.051370199769735336,
-0.30761969089508057,
1.3026093244552612,
0.08363417536020279,
-0.18624483048915863,
0.10365419089794159,
-0.10015948861837387,
-0.4917237460613251,
-0.21838261187076569,
-0.9200447797775269,
-0.38344183564186096,
0.7014913558959961,
0.3329795002937317,
0.5265636444091797,
0.5106586217880249,
0.10764002799987793,
0.20541393756866455,
-0.024239229038357735,
-0.08742222189903259,
-0.8184918165206909,
-0.06667841970920563,
-0.2966000735759735,
-0.5931996703147888,
-0.1539720743894577,
-0.09422159194946289,
0.4839760363101959,
0.3675234615802765,
0.3263256549835205,
0.1430685669183731,
0.47032344341278076,
0.31673508882522583,
-0.7394562363624573,
-0.02165018767118454,
-0.6833202838897705,
0.26187020540237427,
-0.15710897743701935,
-0.32070744037628174,
-0.44021058082580566,
-0.08457694947719574,
0.3343331813812256,
-0.6314213871955872,
0.43383708596229553,
0.10161824524402618,
0.7390446066856384,
0.5552041530609131,
-0.1054789274930954,
0.009044098667800426,
-0.56389319896698,
0.8203920722007751,
-0.4298768639564514,
0.6168004870414734,
0.302219957113266,
0.3211613595485687,
-0.045139044523239136,
-0.6802617907524109,
-0.3010082542896271,
0.07384965568780899,
0.0007326476043090224,
0.23852013051509857,
-0.601713240146637,
0.10565327852964401,
0.2630406320095062,
0.10576328635215759,
-0.6718741655349731,
0.29087457060813904,
-0.22552955150604248,
-0.260623574256897,
0.3609073758125305,
-0.0916532650589943,
0.22363388538360596,
-0.06401064246892929,
-0.5434898734092712,
-0.13485834002494812,
-0.46901845932006836,
0.1932404339313507,
-0.03466152027249336,
0.37707626819610596,
-0.34536075592041016,
0.39324885606765747,
-0.26506951451301575,
0.7507823705673218,
0.22325778007507324,
0.20581969618797302,
0.00592243205755949,
-0.5104943513870239,
-0.42198294401168823,
0.27328774333000183,
0.8306410908699036,
0.21581166982650757,
0.22044768929481506,
-0.3784331679344177,
-0.0171426460146904,
0.12880364060401917,
0.2280636578798294,
-0.9845089912414551,
-0.1720687747001648,
0.05557772144675255,
-0.2320076823234558,
-0.18075577914714813,
-0.38428443670272827,
-0.7956293821334839,
-0.21180643141269684,
-0.26512476801872253,
0.5032371878623962,
-0.16222499310970306,
0.11822232604026794,
-0.0924508199095726,
-0.11110467463731766,
0.09371261298656464,
0.34656769037246704,
-0.6060619354248047,
0.18339939415454865,
0.6079530119895935,
0.9619057178497314,
-0.34656810760498047,
-0.2506602108478546,
-0.9583418965339661,
0.10846323519945145,
-0.18269406259059906,
0.9670228362083435,
-0.6868628263473511,
-0.29688599705696106,
-0.22614438831806183,
0.17676591873168945,
0.014908983372151852,
-0.316161185503006,
0.5465289354324341,
-0.3574484586715698,
0.09410884976387024,
0.11618495732545853,
-0.40730008482933044,
-0.20403562486171722,
0.24630457162857056,
-0.5054306387901306,
1.103630542755127,
0.00897976104170084,
-0.6927409172058105,
0.40883541107177734,
-0.555531919002533,
-0.20203463733196259,
0.13517126441001892,
-0.07019973546266556,
-0.6360490918159485,
0.017419811338186264,
0.44041916728019714,
0.6142585277557373,
-0.4484095275402069,
-0.027717845514416695,
-0.5617460012435913,
-0.4114249646663666,
0.3498712182044983,
-0.5211424827575684,
0.6825053095817566,
-0.11905942112207413,
-0.4286539852619171,
0.14600591361522675,
-0.8314052224159241,
0.17036320269107819,
-0.3516390025615692,
-0.24347950518131256,
-0.48148131370544434,
-0.48346078395843506,
0.14505544304847717,
0.39276814460754395,
-0.3575718104839325,
-0.5631840229034424,
0.06180162355303764,
-0.4493291676044464,
0.15412546694278717,
0.5035672187805176,
0.028755268082022667,
0.7150220274925232,
-0.3274588882923126,
0.7122361063957214,
-0.00743924779817462,
-0.03890727087855339,
0.019551096484065056,
-0.6410772800445557,
-0.7766693830490112,
-0.18699568510055542,
0.5330249667167664,
0.841688334941864,
-0.9130958914756775,
0.1825236827135086,
-0.2123463749885559,
-0.399323433637619,
-0.715403139591217,
0.47698211669921875,
0.5202756524085999,
0.47092223167419434,
0.4981083273887634,
-0.23738230764865875,
-0.44945913553237915,
-0.7536548972129822,
-0.3707483410835266,
0.3221677243709564,
-0.14446352422237396,
0.43758952617645264,
0.29938504099845886,
-0.38975319266319275,
0.7670598030090332,
-0.24364244937896729,
-0.31463226675987244,
-0.232539564371109,
0.18813404440879822,
0.011490244418382645,
0.3627731204032898,
0.4126755893230438,
-0.3805033564567566,
-0.5072181224822998,
0.11799115687608719,
-0.45019403100013733,
-0.2822006046772003,
-0.24436789751052856,
-0.4753772020339966,
0.10526732355356216,
0.5274848341941833,
-0.2902112305164337,
0.6512109637260437,
0.6664453744888306,
-0.235040083527565,
0.16950663924217224,
0.19948656857013702,
-0.23436841368675232,
-0.8430571556091309,
-0.2096307873725891,
0.4195687770843506,
-0.4045356214046478,
-0.6428593993186951,
-0.3894234597682953,
0.021468063816428185,
-0.33238866925239563,
-0.5634240508079529,
0.9198015332221985,
-0.3253810703754425,
-0.13118526339530945,
-0.5155355930328369,
0.18204182386398315,
-0.05076878145337105,
0.7519963979721069,
0.28470343351364136,
0.5917130708694458,
0.7315773963928223,
-0.7299481630325317,
0.27992889285087585,
0.19383814930915833,
-0.1206316351890564,
0.7719899415969849,
-0.5026014447212219,
0.23528900742530823,
-0.1720384657382965,
0.3046213388442993,
-0.9624751806259155,
0.22464464604854584,
0.631292462348938,
-0.36608561873435974,
0.3846682608127594,
-0.390616238117218,
-0.027016999199986458,
-0.02036702260375023,
-0.17280258238315582,
0.5048261284828186,
0.308594673871994,
-0.6808586716651917,
0.4372914135456085,
-0.10890233516693115,
-0.16013316810131073,
-0.49314016103744507,
-0.9664298295974731,
-0.05536625534296036,
-0.1306818425655365,
-0.23304229974746704,
0.24026064574718475,
0.04202616587281227,
0.2604001462459564,
0.1401197761297226,
-0.20259831845760345,
-0.007215512450784445,
-0.011614450253546238,
0.07755767554044724,
0.07219094038009644,
-0.3512066900730133,
0.3653218746185303,
0.1926916539669037,
-0.2514137029647827,
-0.20817700028419495,
-0.6118581295013428,
0.08542689681053162,
0.14830616116523743,
0.22588248550891876,
-0.47784173488616943,
0.19647403061389923,
-0.11651411652565002,
-0.16151276230812073,
0.3473816514015198,
0.9368054270744324,
-0.20976485311985016,
-0.8580853343009949,
-0.15798769891262054,
-0.33898627758026123,
-0.44790369272232056,
0.34426188468933105,
-0.5128176212310791,
-0.9487707614898682,
0.07021815329790115,
-0.0334198884665966,
-0.10499899834394455,
0.05339206010103226,
0.4124326705932617,
-0.07980432361364365,
0.41108232736587524,
0.6601670384407043,
0.034506309777498245,
0.7141919732093811,
-0.20015105605125427,
0.04754820466041565,
-0.7966338992118835,
0.1384076178073883,
-0.5548290610313416,
-0.5038398504257202,
-0.6883903741836548,
-0.5052530169487,
0.2006485015153885,
0.06764409691095352,
-0.07678242772817612,
0.3975399434566498,
-0.557073175907135,
0.44681212306022644,
0.5563752055168152,
0.5079125165939331,
0.2338479608297348,
0.19590963423252106,
0.10355037450790405,
-0.08123447000980377,
-1.1405948400497437,
-0.03709423542022705,
1.1084115505218506,
0.371185302734375,
0.9968332648277283,
-0.18720854818820953,
0.7193296551704407,
0.10557730495929718,
0.48888590931892395,
-0.9205173850059509,
0.3505299985408783,
-0.24837227165699005,
-0.5550515651702881,
-0.5301358699798584,
-0.5632160305976868,
-1.1496745347976685,
0.3098980784416199,
-0.3387467861175537,
-0.7870223522186279,
0.3899732232093811,
0.14256995916366577,
-0.4202316403388977,
0.07005404680967331,
-0.7345505952835083,
1.056095838546753,
-0.41282781958580017,
-0.7454630732536316,
0.09602908790111542,
-0.37227901816368103,
0.3804799020290375,
-0.217984139919281,
0.044143710285425186,
-0.022640494629740715,
-0.2016596496105194,
0.6977624297142029,
-0.23327875137329102,
1.2575037479400635,
0.020684819668531418,
-0.15074971318244934,
0.25122034549713135,
0.002912964904680848,
0.5189867615699768,
0.15492962300777435,
0.188457190990448,
0.10258642584085464,
-0.16763243079185486,
-0.4772542417049408,
-0.7642679810523987,
0.6810938715934753,
-0.6767295598983765,
-0.39888426661491394,
-0.24893368780612946,
-0.7238889932632446,
-0.338733971118927,
0.21208259463310242,
0.4360319972038269,
0.4689565598964691,
0.06750422716140747,
0.16999489068984985,
0.6257856488227844,
-0.3281836211681366,
0.5840598344802856,
0.14030176401138306,
-0.03606903925538063,
-0.5237522721290588,
0.8719567060470581,
0.021496325731277466,
0.3838823735713959,
0.6245406270027161,
0.33323436975479126,
-0.5356571078300476,
-0.3465126156806946,
-0.484801322221756,
0.11271494626998901,
-0.7375728487968445,
-0.31475040316581726,
-0.6222290992736816,
-0.0645671933889389,
-0.2759348154067993,
-0.09784502536058426,
-0.23158004879951477,
-0.3503893315792084,
-0.42938587069511414,
0.1022767573595047,
0.5592041015625,
0.2641226053237915,
0.2580305337905884,
0.580927312374115,
-0.7923836708068848,
0.5806588530540466,
0.4941890835762024,
0.6768924593925476,
-0.03798520192503929,
-0.6582752466201782,
-0.27516448497772217,
-0.12626174092292786,
-0.33477774262428284,
-0.7541927099227905,
0.07839547842741013,
0.35407280921936035,
0.6175687313079834,
-0.057520199567079544,
0.14155305922031403,
0.6271869540214539,
-0.35003045201301575,
0.15672741830348969,
0.17881783843040466,
-0.9392837285995483,
0.44238656759262085,
-0.08419249951839447,
0.6613652110099792,
0.43504491448402405,
0.5003613829612732,
-0.45794183015823364,
-0.27497848868370056,
-0.4722141921520233,
-0.3606027662754059,
0.9184125661849976,
0.30080899596214294,
-0.07440359890460968,
0.52005535364151,
0.11293118447065353,
0.26780375838279724,
0.02503254823386669,
-1.011188268661499,
-0.11738571524620056,
-0.4666037857532501,
-0.29318973422050476,
-0.38495108485221863,
0.1364780068397522,
0.10944872349500656,
-0.10844980925321579,
0.7019361853599548,
-0.3894166946411133,
0.18449340760707855,
0.2500016391277313,
-0.3064185678958893,
-0.0017578157130628824,
0.6183215379714966,
0.3345460593700409,
0.18301653861999512,
0.05723737180233002,
-0.01114128902554512,
0.30740389227867126,
-0.2652966380119324,
0.32713544368743896,
0.4468913674354553,
-0.47580504417419434,
0.2562348544597626,
0.10344266146421432,
1.3330562114715576,
0.6151667237281799,
-0.20848152041435242,
0.2681390643119812,
0.006689961533993483,
-0.13982819020748138,
0.4243878126144409,
0.1693444550037384,
-0.10892242193222046,
0.5560432076454163,
0.04321080818772316,
-0.023683112114667892,
0.2175590842962265,
-0.4393664598464966,
0.37746623158454895,
0.40539753437042236,
-0.6799097061157227,
-0.08254796266555786,
0.6502554416656494,
0.25843435525894165,
-0.35706061124801636,
0.15412607789039612,
-0.07829096168279648,
-0.2740214765071869,
0.3434641659259796,
0.5430291891098022,
1.2184264659881592,
-0.11745502799749374,
0.34082064032554626,
0.2601538598537445,
0.3639053702354431,
0.05592099577188492,
0.07505035400390625,
-0.3640349209308624,
-0.6596349477767944,
-0.5771416425704956,
-0.5697802305221558,
-0.43944403529167175,
0.2627768814563751,
-0.2894805371761322,
0.5894368290901184,
-0.47322773933410645,
-0.23162291944026947,
0.2588014304637909,
-0.1951897144317627,
-0.8382998704910278,
0.3355008065700531,
0.25225797295570374,
0.7846826910972595,
-0.7060467600822449,
0.928134560585022,
0.680027961730957,
-0.2289213091135025,
-0.4685794711112976,
0.02089555189013481,
-0.15635086596012115,
-0.3970087170600891,
0.5117850303649902,
0.17352020740509033,
-0.055762819945812225,
0.2531340420246124,
-0.36934560537338257,
-0.7040742039680481,
0.6552685499191284,
0.20884867012500763,
-0.9645602703094482,
-0.028163770213723183,
0.2225319892168045,
0.4497028589248657,
-0.26378241181373596,
0.35060739517211914,
0.5025348663330078,
0.36719176173210144,
-0.008814983069896698,
-0.8956738114356995,
0.16194520890712738,
-0.005030317232012749,
0.20349855720996857,
0.19551226496696472,
-0.5216313004493713,
0.23577171564102173,
0.02735937386751175,
-0.1386389136314392,
-0.1920894831418991,
0.5086619853973389,
0.2480728179216385,
0.577430784702301,
0.44299569725990295,
0.5039722919464111,
0.5355773568153381,
-0.11566723883152008,
1.0110297203063965,
0.1505925953388214,
0.2745875418186188,
1.2079418897628784,
-0.10878001153469086,
0.6152698397636414,
0.37112724781036377,
-0.08185213059186935,
0.23209963738918304,
0.5682604908943176,
-0.16643159091472626,
0.4502983093261719,
0.2058335691690445,
-0.04050205275416374,
-0.3259128928184509,
-0.05435904115438461,
-0.16640974581241608,
0.3746393918991089,
0.3229677975177765,
-0.2886016368865967,
-0.44123971462249756,
0.4032187759876251,
-0.2768658399581909,
-0.1666135936975479,
-0.5500087738037109,
0.9176567792892456,
0.35394638776779175,
-0.6202909350395203,
1.001251220703125,
-0.3706994354724884,
0.8618448972702026,
-0.24031811952590942,
0.14176909625530243,
-0.08154597878456116,
0.2959703207015991,
-0.2983729839324951,
-0.7268775105476379,
0.015511791221797466,
0.012562519870698452,
-0.15217801928520203,
-0.062151044607162476,
0.8524190783500671,
-0.769559383392334,
-0.6541677117347717,
0.3702298402786255,
0.38070857524871826,
0.10857542604207993,
0.013766329735517502,
-0.8942676782608032,
0.0033711346331983805,
-0.06577138602733612,
-0.08332354575395584,
0.22209513187408447,
0.6398797035217285,
-0.2624590992927551,
0.5871860384941101,
0.5245685577392578,
0.051549121737480164,
0.39872801303863525,
0.044565487653017044,
0.6252169609069824,
-0.7951228618621826,
-0.6872357130050659,
-0.60029137134552,
0.39205077290534973,
0.13578654825687408,
-0.4602104127407074,
0.5568234920501709,
0.5646107196807861,
1.1117953062057495,
-0.15558360517024994,
1.0149903297424316,
0.49370431900024414,
0.49819520115852356,
-0.7014796733856201,
0.4040146470069885,
-0.6140123009681702,
0.040863893926143646,
-0.4734433591365814,
-0.9689257740974426,
-0.35256651043891907,
0.1748068928718567,
-0.4679422974586487,
0.04385657608509064,
0.7108228802680969,
0.8766762018203735,
-0.5308533906936646,
-0.03184632211923599,
0.3186168968677521,
-0.031915660947561264,
-0.07605151832103729,
0.8490514755249023,
0.8108649849891663,
-0.681251585483551,
1.1273943185806274,
-0.4011136293411255,
-0.20194751024246216,
-0.22876344621181488,
-0.7700336575508118,
-1.2323051691055298,
-0.15866033732891083,
-0.6360126733779907,
-0.33848464488983154,
0.25816598534584045,
0.6118021607398987,
0.9023453593254089,
-0.8890438675880432,
-0.18403908610343933,
-0.08495654165744781,
0.19338493049144745,
-0.2458169013261795,
-0.1816079020500183,
0.14860005676746368,
-0.5117536783218384,
-0.7871180772781372,
0.23292124271392822,
0.25604379177093506,
0.29200395941734314,
0.14399510622024536,
-0.11668398231267929,
-0.07173462212085724,
-0.1807537078857422,
0.5848323702812195,
0.4318939745426178,
-0.6338221430778503,
-0.019574202597141266,
-0.09595166891813278,
-0.025354821234941483,
0.2524828314781189,
0.7900757789611816,
-0.8125702738761902,
0.43568477034568787,
0.5221767425537109,
1.2452847957611084,
0.8507912755012512,
0.05220708250999451,
0.529418408870697,
-0.8658349514007568,
0.3680287301540375,
0.0908345952630043,
0.040218986570835114,
0.30540433526039124,
-0.3926795423030853,
0.30089861154556274,
0.21626724302768707,
-0.4183068871498108,
-0.6011564135551453,
0.1404561549425125,
-1.0133460760116577,
-0.3775143027305603,
1.2384626865386963,
0.11652712523937225,
-0.4335267245769501,
-0.22094395756721497,
-0.3583446443080902,
0.4126160740852356,
-0.6285113096237183,
0.4381153881549835,
0.4633083641529083,
-0.0893016830086708,
-0.9453245997428894,
-0.5689861178398132,
0.6637557744979858,
0.4819875955581665,
-1.0068820714950562,
-0.030696328729391098,
0.2807850241661072,
0.18061859905719757,
-0.08812494575977325,
0.23478510975837708,
0.24624758958816528,
0.5128422379493713,
-0.21274274587631226,
-0.0570782870054245,
0.07190845906734467,
-0.24258781969547272,
-0.6181828379631042,
0.08858316391706467,
-0.19840234518051147,
-0.417267769575119
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.12416v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.12416v3
|
Eye-gaze Guided Multi-modal Alignment for Medical Representation Learning
| 2024-03-19T03:59:14 | 2024-06-14T03:18:18 |
Chong Ma, Hanqi Jiang, Wenting Chen, Yiwei Li, Zihao Wu, Xiaowei Yu, Zhengliang Liu, Lei Guo, Dajiang Zhu, Tuo Zhang, Dinggang Shen, Tianming Liu, Xiang Li
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, 68T07, I.2.0; I.4.0; I.5.4; I.7.0
|
In the medical multi-modal frameworks, the alignment of cross-modality
features presents a significant challenge. However, existing works have learned
features that are implicitly aligned from the data, without considering the
explicit relationships in the medical context. This data-reliance may lead to
low generalization of the learned alignment relationships. In this work, we
propose the Eye-gaze Guided Multi-modal Alignment (EGMA) framework to harness
eye-gaze data for better alignment of medical visual and textual features. We
explore the natural auxiliary role of radiologists' eye-gaze data in aligning
medical images and text, and introduce a novel approach by using eye-gaze data,
collected synchronously by radiologists during diagnostic evaluations. We
conduct downstream tasks of image classification and image-text retrieval on
four medical datasets, where EGMA achieved state-of-the-art performance and
stronger generalization across different datasets. Additionally, we explore the
impact of varying amounts of eye-gaze data on model performance, highlighting
the feasibility and utility of integrating this auxiliary data into multi-modal
alignment framework.
|
[
-0.23546549677848816,
-0.5483512878417969,
0.9647734761238098,
-0.3462843596935272,
-0.3978622257709503,
-0.23533958196640015,
0.011671822518110275,
-0.8588812947273254,
0.5028634071350098,
0.25490492582321167,
-0.4127033054828644,
-0.3974369168281555,
-0.6678901314735413,
0.0514768622815609,
0.0857125073671341,
0.660525918006897,
-0.2359979748725891,
0.5949781537055969,
-0.5605488419532776,
-0.4261586368083954,
-0.4953392446041107,
-0.03543940559029579,
-0.09733851999044418,
-0.2951395809650421,
0.5255774259567261,
0.1945457011461258,
0.7433543801307678,
0.8043546080589294,
0.6909957528114319,
0.17019903659820557,
0.5241466760635376,
0.42397063970565796,
-0.24425125122070312,
0.12929126620292664,
0.1112513393163681,
-0.40424129366874695,
-0.30028536915779114,
0.02229384146630764,
0.44602206349372864,
0.7036369442939758,
-0.1398976743221283,
0.2005283385515213,
-0.1715768575668335,
0.8029503226280212,
-0.5746858716011047,
0.3657682240009308,
-0.13268953561782837,
0.1170484647154808,
-0.19375957548618317,
-0.4542393982410431,
-0.36520370841026306,
-0.29533058404922485,
0.5850528478622437,
-0.9599565267562866,
0.00225046812556684,
0.2995487451553345,
1.051433801651001,
0.6107137203216553,
-0.5512128472328186,
-0.18390144407749176,
-0.2862887382507324,
0.5548987984657288,
-0.19575956463813782,
0.5313541293144226,
0.1734664887189865,
0.4719090759754181,
0.3689523935317993,
-0.37030601501464844,
-0.1386597752571106,
-0.15372058749198914,
-0.3315187096595764,
0.4344910681247711,
0.16644807159900665,
-0.019866030663251877,
0.26372310519218445,
0.21900108456611633,
-0.7458723187446594,
-0.19719837605953217,
-0.21766364574432373,
0.02547464519739151,
0.22466331720352173,
0.22030001878738403,
0.381490558385849,
-0.12873521447181702,
-0.7705973982810974,
-0.013294046744704247,
-0.5264960527420044,
-0.13395316898822784,
-0.37382417917251587,
-0.07245174050331116,
-0.14780877530574799,
0.7990161776542664,
-0.21856465935707092,
0.9390828609466553,
0.3686266541481018,
-0.2675015926361084,
0.6517448425292969,
-0.3574922978878021,
-0.34821978211402893,
-0.010173729620873928,
0.5693895220756531,
0.44472017884254456,
-0.0665288046002388,
0.011315418407320976,
0.10214060544967651,
0.23433926701545715,
0.47110217809677124,
-0.4628290832042694,
-0.054717034101486206,
-0.005656907334923744,
-0.7976974248886108,
-0.3250548243522644,
0.013959704898297787,
-0.8665382266044617,
-0.3133501410484314,
-0.8363844156265259,
0.644503653049469,
-0.49406513571739197,
-0.007361173164099455,
0.15347786247730255,
0.20387430489063263,
0.2599690854549408,
0.43371284008026123,
-0.767740786075592,
-0.09129153192043304,
0.29700300097465515,
0.8161404728889465,
-0.07246086746454239,
-0.22466711699962616,
-0.41341060400009155,
0.4085458219051361,
-0.20102091133594513,
0.5092995762825012,
-0.7745616436004639,
0.18880018591880798,
-0.01903081312775612,
0.22146810591220856,
-0.4307941496372223,
-0.40086162090301514,
0.14602264761924744,
-0.40880441665649414,
0.4423629939556122,
-0.19585222005844116,
-0.28511813282966614,
-0.48290252685546875,
0.3425387442111969,
-0.7842139005661011,
0.8098893165588379,
0.24191662669181824,
-0.6233240365982056,
0.6203316450119019,
-0.4107864797115326,
-0.3854990303516388,
-0.03360648453235626,
-0.620248019695282,
-0.7558332681655884,
0.1599843055009842,
0.5582272410392761,
0.6597800850868225,
-0.41395968198776245,
0.360495001077652,
-0.3365967571735382,
-0.1268177479505539,
0.2567928433418274,
-0.10072661936283112,
0.5218541026115417,
-0.05466262623667717,
-0.3912060558795929,
-0.11084387451410294,
-0.6552520990371704,
0.003954423125833273,
0.10059121251106262,
-0.012930369935929775,
-0.5682276487350464,
0.13027067482471466,
0.0870085135102272,
0.36787766218185425,
0.20077809691429138,
-0.377936452627182,
0.18357209861278534,
0.0693749487400055,
-0.19269758462905884,
0.3627813458442688,
-0.10357556492090225,
0.2662757933139801,
-0.5536763668060303,
0.42768779397010803,
0.16227594017982483,
0.4925462007522583,
-0.20906303822994232,
-0.5884786248207092,
-0.5863642692565918,
-0.4840102791786194,
0.12474396824836731,
0.46148884296417236,
-1.0603379011154175,
-0.036216989159584045,
-0.38996484875679016,
-0.2688642740249634,
-0.6683184504508972,
-0.03419738635420799,
0.6300560832023621,
0.7177771925926208,
0.5185471773147583,
-0.5761810541152954,
-0.3367285430431366,
-1.0224242210388184,
-0.03483886644244194,
0.07024222612380981,
0.05354473367333412,
0.6665788888931274,
-0.013202724047005177,
-0.41436079144477844,
0.4680063724517822,
-0.6005036234855652,
-0.6510993838310242,
0.3094700872898102,
0.2867807447910309,
-0.13754957914352417,
0.4186495244503021,
0.6607572436332703,
-0.9619348049163818,
-0.5624520778656006,
0.3082442581653595,
-1.047741413116455,
-0.2663792669773102,
-0.2969781458377838,
-0.2219407856464386,
0.10031375288963318,
0.2865298092365265,
-0.19716162979602814,
0.22283293306827545,
0.6609703302383423,
-0.2244328260421753,
0.1993270367383957,
-0.06564074754714966,
0.6170883774757385,
-1.224510669708252,
0.26527494192123413,
0.3521713316440582,
-0.5486851334571838,
-0.5587376356124878,
0.06669383496046066,
0.3561302125453949,
-0.10210495442152023,
-0.10511838644742966,
-0.07530821859836578,
-0.9625871181488037,
-0.024030273780226707,
-0.00009265566768590361,
0.1748771220445633,
0.09089222550392151,
0.3205893635749817,
0.27185913920402527,
0.46535375714302063,
0.8424242734909058,
-0.3266026973724365,
0.23898130655288696,
0.3979385793209076,
-0.1825726330280304,
1.0478156805038452,
-0.16857792437076569,
0.10137873888015747,
-0.13132502138614655,
-0.1813669353723526,
-0.42688316106796265,
-0.4433581829071045,
0.22841081023216248,
-0.45845457911491394,
0.8094121217727661,
-0.09739481657743454,
-0.011840421706438065,
0.07225386053323746,
-0.20922940969467163,
0.6774284243583679,
0.1338401436805725,
-0.44477197527885437,
0.9609588384628296,
0.5654378533363342,
-0.08352702111005783,
-0.8403788208961487,
-0.5896141529083252,
0.11446965485811234,
0.08549942076206207,
-0.6367402076721191,
0.5506131649017334,
0.18147967755794525,
0.1401779055595398,
0.10154762119054794,
0.02150091715157032,
0.014922035858035088,
-0.398093044757843,
0.3604881763458252,
0.8620316982269287,
-0.35276055335998535,
0.12120294570922852,
-0.21544557809829712,
-0.14137569069862366,
-0.20799973607063293,
-0.023568391799926758,
0.2340916097164154,
0.11871834844350815,
-0.6052826046943665,
-0.3938327133655548,
0.4526706635951996,
0.8064086437225342,
-0.05865127965807915,
0.46783018112182617,
0.6014974117279053,
-0.5479214191436768,
0.24899037182331085,
-0.7707181572914124,
0.03778689354658127,
-0.35093390941619873,
0.39949771761894226,
-0.09917964786291122,
-0.7602458596229553,
0.14022721350193024,
-0.09461736679077148,
-0.19780239462852478,
0.13763035833835602,
0.5426270961761475,
-0.2052038311958313,
1.1963348388671875,
0.8249322175979614,
0.23714645206928253,
0.6096251606941223,
0.16532526910305023,
-0.05571800470352173,
-1.2023967504501343,
-0.784795343875885,
-0.06117585301399231,
-0.20633672177791595,
-0.12671098113059998,
-0.6465680599212646,
0.5337993502616882,
-0.3761851489543915,
0.3908846974372864,
0.19976384937763214,
-0.5772485136985779,
0.24234384298324585,
0.1791616678237915,
0.7454798221588135,
0.2053273618221283,
0.03265354409813881,
-0.19358667731285095,
-0.2636890113353729,
-0.4527600109577179,
-0.2687769830226898,
1.1611149311065674,
0.12078750133514404,
0.8602932691574097,
-0.09148605167865753,
0.5523095726966858,
-0.07024989277124405,
0.36070525646209717,
-0.8817286491394043,
0.22288930416107178,
-0.08712280541658401,
-0.44159433245658875,
-0.009751160629093647,
-0.2901991307735443,
-0.5695822834968567,
0.42496657371520996,
-0.4453209638595581,
-0.24348968267440796,
0.6079598665237427,
0.09288663417100906,
-0.4060874581336975,
-0.09624714404344559,
-0.6827970147132874,
0.8440716862678528,
-0.4884413778781891,
-0.4600258767604828,
-0.10727207362651825,
-0.7306432723999023,
0.15599356591701508,
-0.24696291983127594,
0.04132256656885147,
0.011664184741675854,
-0.4045122265815735,
0.22320598363876343,
-0.17935851216316223,
0.9018748998641968,
-0.07308685779571533,
0.2508094906806946,
-0.330522745847702,
-0.25049570202827454,
0.2998964488506317,
-0.06099824979901314,
0.5250707268714905,
0.0770810917019844,
0.0969730094075203,
-0.19749481976032257,
-0.31633734703063965,
0.4914645850658417,
-0.5167056918144226,
-0.41327688097953796,
-0.5628658533096313,
-0.523425817489624,
-0.5130335092544556,
0.13801859319210052,
0.04439466446638107,
0.5744666457176208,
-0.2540125846862793,
0.26401159167289734,
0.6749697923660278,
0.09553834795951843,
0.08468440920114517,
0.5780761241912842,
-0.13753949105739594,
-0.4964207708835602,
0.8701041340827942,
0.15419591963291168,
0.33021336793899536,
0.46206334233283997,
-0.15882423520088196,
-0.04294214025139809,
-0.42135900259017944,
-0.8061450719833374,
0.3284521698951721,
-0.6634463667869568,
-0.23068271577358246,
-0.5452356338500977,
0.12549376487731934,
-0.17000852525234222,
-0.3263016939163208,
-0.11549482494592667,
-0.03254587575793266,
-0.38710230588912964,
0.3331681787967682,
0.09527651220560074,
0.5828976631164551,
0.08109863102436066,
-0.06547233462333679,
-0.8023325204849243,
0.602051317691803,
0.32883965969085693,
0.4147495925426483,
-0.34114953875541687,
-0.0661279559135437,
-0.5160483717918396,
-0.2327401489019394,
-0.18940651416778564,
-0.9606989622116089,
0.3604913353919983,
0.2875842750072479,
0.6407520174980164,
0.6763385534286499,
-0.27337291836738586,
0.9173150062561035,
-0.5984117388725281,
0.44468045234680176,
0.7140640616416931,
-0.6594511270523071,
0.3963780105113983,
-0.13205783069133759,
0.28290504217147827,
0.6301908493041992,
0.3775584101676941,
-0.3849948048591614,
-0.14054745435714722,
-0.142569437623024,
-0.5241264700889587,
0.7112613320350647,
-0.009608699008822441,
-0.4721086621284485,
0.26881784200668335,
0.3062452971935272,
0.23753678798675537,
0.11587293446063995,
-0.6347020864486694,
-0.3319799602031708,
-0.16078037023544312,
-0.6667554378509521,
0.1209995448589325,
0.006619641091674566,
-0.5222018957138062,
-0.20752759277820587,
0.5180069804191589,
-0.6574569940567017,
0.22439220547676086,
0.3533320426940918,
-0.5518532991409302,
-0.3347533941268921,
-0.04967895895242691,
0.47943636775016785,
0.6679301857948303,
0.09674771875143051,
0.045111946761608124,
-0.1720193475484848,
-0.8685874938964844,
0.09385441988706589,
0.2486402839422226,
-0.23310160636901855,
0.010374560952186584,
-0.08546750247478485,
0.6977410316467285,
0.4657285213470459,
-0.5202255845069885,
0.699720561504364,
-0.07960410416126251,
-0.05955163761973381,
0.013606984168291092,
-0.2594231069087982,
-0.009313410148024559,
0.43486130237579346,
0.4537557065486908,
0.5210268497467041,
0.3197965919971466,
-0.3096294403076172,
0.4067775011062622,
0.4978230893611908,
-0.5975469946861267,
-0.2221101075410843,
0.6352795958518982,
0.01636250503361225,
0.4132004678249359,
0.1860993206501007,
0.5055200457572937,
-0.33630290627479553,
0.5577205419540405,
0.3293960392475128,
0.8232712149620056,
-0.18704324960708618,
0.29876139760017395,
0.297615110874176,
0.3095066249370575,
-0.26236024498939514,
0.30397695302963257,
-0.00635209446772933,
-0.3880762755870819,
-0.4886844754219055,
-0.23106202483177185,
-0.45032986998558044,
-0.3292238414287567,
-0.9729411005973816,
0.4581964313983917,
-0.11735276877880096,
-0.3030954897403717,
0.08035049587488174,
-0.4563930928707123,
-0.639865517616272,
0.4233510494232178,
0.43904101848602295,
0.20532368123531342,
-0.7446169257164001,
0.6677846312522888,
0.8076122999191284,
-0.6534627079963684,
-0.6210182905197144,
0.13425029814243317,
0.282120019197464,
-0.9740718603134155,
0.25678369402885437,
0.48808950185775757,
-0.3014940619468689,
-0.22687329351902008,
-0.43295907974243164,
-0.9891714453697205,
1.3315930366516113,
0.40210670232772827,
-0.7224360704421997,
-0.1856473684310913,
-0.00001254409107787069,
0.40334662795066833,
-0.7266001105308533,
0.004437598399817944,
0.11991694569587708,
0.2623969614505768,
0.07761488854885101,
-0.9491822719573975,
0.3577362895011902,
-0.26395055651664734,
-0.13048239052295685,
0.2679062783718109,
-0.7554237246513367,
0.4857228696346283,
-0.3384672999382019,
-0.31478413939476013,
-0.3361162841320038,
0.14834052324295044,
-0.046570684760808945,
0.4460934102535248,
0.3495389521121979,
0.7623301148414612,
0.46498557925224304,
-0.23275037109851837,
0.7963333129882812,
-0.32526907324790955,
0.2973267436027527,
0.7757241725921631,
-0.36668482422828674,
0.5023820400238037,
0.6985582113265991,
0.02765405736863613,
0.4278987944126129,
0.5305834412574768,
-0.059870991855859756,
0.5643231272697449,
-0.6199154257774353,
-0.08654775470495224,
-0.4655032157897949,
0.025713985785841942,
-0.5796238780021667,
0.46268534660339355,
0.370958149433136,
-0.7294784784317017,
0.002912803553044796,
0.2580544054508209,
-0.31151047348976135,
-0.37719547748565674,
-0.23563699424266815,
1.0570886135101318,
0.17238612473011017,
-0.4859776794910431,
0.6183648109436035,
-0.6787896156311035,
0.5815110206604004,
-0.4817260801792145,
-0.16794472932815552,
0.4725111126899719,
0.013930213637650013,
-0.30614137649536133,
-0.37402814626693726,
0.10844249278306961,
-0.47131600975990295,
-0.4216836988925934,
-0.02262364700436592,
0.4266156852245331,
-0.5961699485778809,
-0.2670619487762451,
0.23829185962677002,
0.4498450756072998,
-0.12400925159454346,
0.26283401250839233,
-0.6823452711105347,
-0.03541073203086853,
0.07589267194271088,
-0.23067834973335266,
0.623407244682312,
0.25897833704948425,
0.1573476344347,
0.40852728486061096,
0.42803654074668884,
0.12166925519704819,
0.05406809225678444,
0.072214275598526,
0.9693958163261414,
-0.43496912717819214,
-0.20737360417842865,
-0.45477157831192017,
0.30815625190734863,
-0.12860877811908722,
-0.24316184222698212,
0.44905170798301697,
0.48880594968795776,
0.712831974029541,
-0.13918688893318176,
0.4637746214866638,
-0.187895268201828,
0.37337547540664673,
-0.8764508962631226,
0.6956347823143005,
-0.8895748257637024,
-0.2662283778190613,
-0.25222888588905334,
-0.694462776184082,
-0.44201231002807617,
0.6816133856773376,
-0.04272668808698654,
-0.03699950873851776,
1.0980862379074097,
0.6834511756896973,
-0.12120240926742554,
-0.09680961817502975,
0.568392276763916,
-0.19673772156238556,
-0.14802545309066772,
0.6221980452537537,
0.40952935814857483,
-0.36442846059799194,
0.3395025432109833,
-0.28126487135887146,
-0.4986107647418976,
-0.5302048921585083,
-0.6125160455703735,
-0.7378358244895935,
-0.6709672212600708,
-0.48839694261550903,
-0.12236551940441132,
-0.17159219086170197,
0.8172367811203003,
0.7819941639900208,
-0.5881562232971191,
0.34294405579566956,
0.5085822939872742,
-0.4581848382949829,
-0.5274733304977417,
-0.143060564994812,
0.4385736286640167,
-0.3337036371231079,
-0.8022341132164001,
0.3148193359375,
0.6904177069664001,
-0.0022552632726728916,
-0.22809597849845886,
0.04213537648320198,
-0.25776535272598267,
-0.16546276211738586,
0.43389272689819336,
0.2551141381263733,
-0.6758165955543518,
-0.24944362044334412,
0.26149362325668335,
-0.40507978200912476,
0.39194387197494507,
0.998375415802002,
-0.7538474202156067,
1.1768598556518555,
0.2807653248310089,
0.5699824094772339,
0.42543500661849976,
0.07408032566308975,
0.531287670135498,
-0.3764785826206207,
-0.0369575135409832,
0.2644723057746887,
0.6765785217285156,
0.3554801642894745,
-0.6366270184516907,
0.38253939151763916,
0.24083803594112396,
-0.5638768076896667,
-0.5845108032226562,
0.1505320966243744,
-1.2857438325881958,
-0.04454173147678375,
0.7579757571220398,
-0.068120077252388,
-0.2916855812072754,
-0.5419225692749023,
-0.3558689057826996,
0.34801846742630005,
-0.13262079656124115,
0.832984447479248,
0.411704421043396,
-0.38806426525115967,
-0.43789732456207275,
-0.6661900281906128,
0.44850194454193115,
0.5166590213775635,
-0.8170391321182251,
-0.17206978797912598,
1.0907502174377441,
0.39135077595710754,
0.31846165657043457,
0.4072742760181427,
-0.630483090877533,
0.6715458035469055,
-0.22941520810127258,
0.11748474836349487,
-0.20451828837394714,
-0.35287827253341675,
-0.37436729669570923,
0.23123762011528015,
-0.3452741801738739,
-0.3810354471206665
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.12413v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.12413v1
|
Third-Party Language Model Performance Prediction from Instruction
| 2024-03-19T03:53:47 | 2024-03-19T03:53:47 |
Rahul Nadkarni, Yizhong Wang, Noah A. Smith
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Language model-based instruction-following systems have lately shown
increasing performance on many benchmark tasks, demonstrating the capability of
adapting to a broad variety of instructions. However, such systems are often
not designed to be transparent about their limitations; a user may easily
prompt a model with an instruction without any idea of whether the responses
should be expected to be accurate, or if the system is even capable of
performing the task. We propose a third party performance prediction framework,
where a separate model is trained to predict the metric resulting from
evaluating an instruction-following system on a task while assuming access only
to its inputs and outputs at inference time. We perform this analysis with a
variety of both open and closed instruction-following models as well as
multiple performance predictors, and examine the effect of various factors such
as model size, number of training tasks, and prompt format. Our findings
indicate that third-party performance prediction is very challenging, and much
work remains in developing predictors that can automatically reveal the
limitations of modern instruction-following natural language processing
systems.
|
[
-0.09458135068416595,
-0.44428297877311707,
0.6488469839096069,
0.20809899270534515,
0.2325262874364853,
-0.23275133967399597,
-0.1676514893770218,
-0.7569373846054077,
-0.2900269329547882,
0.7719990015029907,
-0.6868773698806763,
-0.3383277952671051,
-0.6331530213356018,
-0.03619438037276268,
-0.15809963643550873,
0.6487881541252136,
-0.020947033539414406,
0.23584868013858795,
-0.33302557468414307,
0.08063904196023941,
-0.8343505263328552,
-0.4609167277812958,
-0.2650085985660553,
-0.3546035587787628,
0.1890125423669815,
0.6290156245231628,
0.5562047362327576,
0.7485942840576172,
0.35858434438705444,
0.2600576877593994,
0.18321484327316284,
-0.19974860548973083,
-0.16570696234703064,
0.09028641134500504,
0.025642599910497665,
-0.759856641292572,
-0.4343511462211609,
-0.049871258437633514,
0.8558386564254761,
0.7990087270736694,
0.009035896509885788,
0.1442086100578308,
0.36131101846694946,
0.683553159236908,
-0.8030887246131897,
0.4622272551059723,
-0.3747917711734772,
0.07998349517583847,
-0.14889924228191376,
0.10889965295791626,
-0.7652826309204102,
-0.5153185129165649,
0.19763922691345215,
-0.3686481714248657,
0.18063828349113464,
0.056557778269052505,
0.3297079801559448,
0.17859631776809692,
0.11541197448968887,
-0.1797075718641281,
-0.8525781631469727,
0.5947694182395935,
-0.7514682412147522,
0.5811704993247986,
0.7482154369354248,
0.6663752198219299,
-0.13044725358486176,
-0.3532786965370178,
-0.3824366629123688,
-0.42194321751594543,
-0.1439686119556427,
0.06798598170280457,
0.020085066556930542,
0.004313252400606871,
0.3882831335067749,
0.00982685200870037,
-0.5471780300140381,
0.22519484162330627,
-0.5255438685417175,
-0.01763075590133667,
0.33284860849380493,
0.2976829409599304,
0.13340575993061066,
0.2051175832748413,
-0.31707820296287537,
0.11595035344362259,
-0.5925865769386292,
0.1613156944513321,
0.40432432293891907,
0.5965249538421631,
-0.08880728483200073,
0.8286243677139282,
-0.3192804157733917,
0.7883939146995544,
-0.07465723156929016,
0.0015743159456178546,
0.055173780769109726,
-0.014422358013689518,
-0.008719509467482567,
0.017838485538959503,
0.7756942510604858,
0.16044364869594574,
0.14313596487045288,
-0.10844112187623978,
-0.4391125440597534,
0.04005887731909752,
-0.020159604027867317,
-0.9838722348213196,
-0.3855574429035187,
-0.11429480463266373,
-0.45741668343544006,
0.060360949486494064,
0.10793687403202057,
-0.7143533229827881,
-0.4339449405670166,
-0.1427919864654541,
0.30211782455444336,
-0.6229189038276672,
0.04022105410695076,
-0.20965513586997986,
0.18258598446846008,
-0.15315914154052734,
0.16327659785747528,
-0.9999831914901733,
0.7594694495201111,
0.7697506546974182,
1.1119338274002075,
-0.2245282381772995,
-0.44966644048690796,
-0.9889504909515381,
0.20729851722717285,
-0.18883754312992096,
0.7459031343460083,
-1.008433222770691,
-0.37008044123649597,
0.03825412318110466,
0.11877105385065079,
-0.33240166306495667,
-0.20095884799957275,
0.1286175549030304,
-0.6145315766334534,
0.3463287055492401,
-0.08002088963985443,
-0.9364619255065918,
-0.1430785208940506,
-0.21263492107391357,
-1.0568562746047974,
0.7242589592933655,
-0.019901404157280922,
-0.6408357620239258,
0.15493427217006683,
-0.7282085418701172,
-0.33525311946868896,
0.06671740859746933,
-0.06861518323421478,
-0.15728752315044403,
0.2518591284751892,
0.22047708928585052,
0.44355398416519165,
-0.2241431176662445,
0.08558092266321182,
-0.41376763582229614,
-0.7687368392944336,
0.0636289119720459,
-0.4873490035533905,
0.5128940939903259,
-0.006995135918259621,
-0.23761212825775146,
0.05907220020890236,
-0.995769202709198,
-0.011438760906457901,
-0.27910634875297546,
-0.37894630432128906,
-0.0896187275648117,
0.35747411847114563,
-0.42013439536094666,
0.19497795403003693,
0.4598791301250458,
-0.6285948753356934,
-0.12005185335874557,
-0.4519020617008209,
-0.02823464386165142,
0.9878246188163757,
-0.21512503921985626,
0.5613471865653992,
-0.1303253173828125,
1.0551689863204956,
-0.2761978209018707,
0.04777852073311806,
-0.4289872646331787,
-0.7547272443771362,
-0.5730578899383545,
0.12399479746818542,
0.27731913328170776,
0.6490768194198608,
-0.5156489610671997,
-0.14839516580104828,
-0.18976566195487976,
-0.4999227523803711,
-0.4346865713596344,
0.003591664368286729,
0.5946670770645142,
0.5523656606674194,
0.41903749108314514,
-0.1158042773604393,
-0.40206852555274963,
-0.899054765701294,
-0.4856531023979187,
-0.5342822074890137,
-0.23574082553386688,
0.3275570869445801,
0.38396742939949036,
0.31823933124542236,
0.5263969898223877,
-0.7662851214408875,
-0.10318584740161896,
-0.20996849238872528,
0.15277346968650818,
0.22692923247814178,
0.4331471920013428,
-0.060201678425073624,
-0.31363019347190857,
-0.5729842782020569,
0.10725291073322296,
-0.289872944355011,
-0.20696179568767548,
0.265254408121109,
0.2580890357494354,
0.4450221061706543,
0.5671603083610535,
-0.01682417094707489,
0.39424848556518555,
1.1878453493118286,
-0.14660091698169708,
0.5990967154502869,
-0.19496041536331177,
-0.18130864202976227,
-0.6737090349197388,
0.0642491802573204,
0.09768712520599365,
0.12024310231208801,
-0.5417338609695435,
-0.2671503722667694,
0.24009299278259277,
-0.31551864743232727,
-0.2792584002017975,
0.670193076133728,
-0.4532588720321655,
-0.4250189960002899,
-0.2534523904323578,
-0.21010874211788177,
-0.0014701804611831903,
0.5034356117248535,
0.40845897793769836,
1.0645079612731934,
0.48692116141319275,
-0.5722222924232483,
-0.037526484578847885,
-0.06750165671110153,
-0.4555160701274872,
0.2371622771024704,
-0.7014561295509338,
0.08730871975421906,
0.11637861281633377,
0.14346282184123993,
-0.6669073700904846,
-0.3371184170246124,
0.3164047300815582,
-0.49902939796447754,
0.14000898599624634,
-0.33740583062171936,
-0.3694039285182953,
-0.364937424659729,
0.10556214302778244,
0.1587570160627365,
0.30371028184890747,
-0.37679311633110046,
0.706373929977417,
-0.041801199316978455,
-0.1426762044429779,
-0.723637044429779,
-0.6915447115898132,
-0.30373501777648926,
0.2723797559738159,
-0.4973512291908264,
0.2478315383195877,
-0.14115804433822632,
0.11008599400520325,
0.06319230049848557,
-0.025396307930350304,
-0.40460726618766785,
0.21311920881271362,
0.5765175819396973,
0.503958523273468,
-0.4045465886592865,
0.2948586940765381,
-0.3132278621196747,
-0.03729137405753136,
0.28440648317337036,
-0.32533860206604004,
0.14677797257900238,
-0.2928799092769623,
-0.6392173171043396,
-0.6601970195770264,
0.24665330350399017,
0.1745918244123459,
-0.46384677290916443,
0.838219165802002,
0.46501877903938293,
-0.4812772572040558,
-0.14282287657260895,
-0.4081200659275055,
-0.2548666000366211,
-0.45742276310920715,
0.5433326363563538,
-0.37632688879966736,
-0.46954333782196045,
0.35336795449256897,
0.27087435126304626,
-0.13867394626140594,
0.1719849854707718,
0.22175540030002594,
0.06726452708244324,
1.380503535270691,
1.0380479097366333,
0.24925026297569275,
0.7047990560531616,
0.12246940284967422,
-0.03890669718384743,
-0.5992696285247803,
-0.4728626310825348,
-0.6715916395187378,
-0.06296089291572571,
-0.8855365514755249,
-0.3466047942638397,
-0.03732624650001526,
0.09959650039672852,
-0.07863204181194305,
0.5259217619895935,
-0.19051310420036316,
0.5658473372459412,
0.7457587718963623,
-0.08960286527872086,
0.28038927912712097,
-0.23221909999847412,
-0.12293102592229843,
0.10154096782207489,
-0.6546638011932373,
-0.6359766721725464,
0.9968217015266418,
0.4993900954723358,
0.7405830025672913,
0.11589236557483673,
0.5577998161315918,
0.027367589995265007,
0.6141654253005981,
-0.6537757515907288,
0.5910775661468506,
-0.2257612943649292,
-0.5893768072128296,
-0.18018147349357605,
-0.554615318775177,
-0.4622168242931366,
0.018849551677703857,
0.033434201031923294,
-0.9932676553726196,
0.011720076203346252,
0.10455870628356934,
-0.37063220143318176,
0.233648419380188,
-0.9738526344299316,
0.7898595333099365,
-0.13607831299304962,
-0.3689514696598053,
0.11593426018953323,
-0.4916156530380249,
0.27005815505981445,
0.015556812286376953,
0.18507620692253113,
-0.18805760145187378,
-0.27498146891593933,
0.7725974321365356,
-0.2818298637866974,
0.9702196717262268,
-0.3808252215385437,
0.0449196919798851,
0.20055004954338074,
0.2468835562467575,
0.4018442630767822,
-0.16507315635681152,
-0.3763721287250519,
0.02882675640285015,
0.048004623502492905,
-0.32426542043685913,
-0.6661559343338013,
0.7252257466316223,
-0.6439225077629089,
-0.7651292681694031,
-0.30474022030830383,
-0.45328399538993835,
-0.5985077023506165,
0.4122689664363861,
0.1082729622721672,
0.5228413939476013,
-0.17961159348487854,
-0.034316692501306534,
0.3961578905582428,
0.03574955090880394,
0.5635663866996765,
0.5161806344985962,
-0.21455766260623932,
-0.1426582783460617,
1.0923638343811035,
0.13714557886123657,
0.2693884074687958,
0.5125046372413635,
0.38847970962524414,
-0.4177961051464081,
-0.7046422958374023,
-0.4721377193927765,
0.00526889692991972,
-0.6175273060798645,
-0.059504155069589615,
-0.4113849997520447,
0.022922901436686516,
-0.24198606610298157,
0.10259824991226196,
-0.3772071301937103,
-0.4239124059677124,
-0.6139030456542969,
0.11834509670734406,
-0.06308035552501678,
1.1046698093414307,
0.07481469959020615,
0.5576779842376709,
-0.9251721501350403,
-0.10217799246311188,
0.20935288071632385,
1.0538203716278076,
-0.13102523982524872,
-0.5429818034172058,
-0.47083139419555664,
-0.051561977714300156,
-0.35027626156806946,
-0.8935349583625793,
0.08055626600980759,
0.241996169090271,
0.45797109603881836,
0.3404771685600281,
-0.016040101647377014,
0.3684093952178955,
-0.7965649962425232,
0.7270491123199463,
0.24626119434833527,
-0.9087581634521484,
0.6137645840644836,
-0.046969618648290634,
0.33356255292892456,
0.2870899438858032,
0.3646790385246277,
-0.20283262431621552,
-0.4705890715122223,
-0.4491158723831177,
-0.34153103828430176,
1.2525956630706787,
0.025783218443393707,
0.012187476269900799,
-0.07085832208395004,
-0.08106077462434769,
0.3547111451625824,
0.0766770988702774,
-0.5486791729927063,
-0.049445416778326035,
-0.23443788290023804,
-0.044602103531360626,
-0.1250644326210022,
-0.11553651094436646,
0.30299434065818787,
0.2920381426811218,
0.7102795839309692,
-0.25606560707092285,
0.34248051047325134,
-0.35335010290145874,
0.08541255444288254,
-0.20948688685894012,
0.17285394668579102,
0.6208248138427734,
0.9360834956169128,
-0.4123891294002533,
-0.30793139338493347,
0.06136663258075714,
-0.3518829047679901,
-0.07636220753192902,
0.42857858538627625,
0.06565496325492859,
0.03436984494328499,
0.5736595392227173,
0.8914629220962524,
0.09059984236955643,
-0.6992816925048828,
0.5478618741035461,
-0.10808590799570084,
-0.01563793048262596,
-0.4192288815975189,
0.36354464292526245,
0.07967328280210495,
0.3716757893562317,
0.1098073199391365,
0.37141627073287964,
0.19603534042835236,
-0.3438217043876648,
0.05568118393421173,
0.020184852182865143,
-0.8986322283744812,
-0.5797792077064514,
0.7096574306488037,
0.07751184701919556,
-0.5692620277404785,
0.23397204279899597,
0.08939380943775177,
-0.4241436719894409,
0.5766558647155762,
0.6826308965682983,
0.8418802618980408,
-0.5704545974731445,
0.16796228289604187,
0.37865138053894043,
0.16813534498214722,
-0.3454896807670593,
0.12995018064975739,
0.15127034485340118,
-0.39970433712005615,
-0.6099078059196472,
-0.29453718662261963,
-0.5841353535652161,
0.16341175138950348,
-0.8775179982185364,
0.3426741063594818,
-0.5801297426223755,
-0.16891849040985107,
0.005574673414230347,
0.03371337428689003,
-0.8026143312454224,
0.20928624272346497,
0.32254210114479065,
1.1256669759750366,
-0.763407289981842,
0.7815243005752563,
0.6450780034065247,
-0.3503953814506531,
-0.47272247076034546,
0.29591506719589233,
-0.1102336049079895,
-0.7157898545265198,
0.5916041731834412,
0.5666806697845459,
-0.3886703848838806,
-0.5000425577163696,
-0.1862412542104721,
-0.8057540059089661,
0.8518598079681396,
0.43180471658706665,
-0.7081717848777771,
-0.36465880274772644,
-0.08710579574108124,
0.4422060549259186,
-0.561888575553894,
0.3379475772380829,
0.5082810521125793,
0.21910662949085236,
-0.016507279127836227,
-0.7296197414398193,
0.1073794960975647,
-0.007983341813087463,
0.25089991092681885,
0.044521018862724304,
-0.356923907995224,
0.8959912657737732,
-0.44954437017440796,
-0.31015563011169434,
0.2502380311489105,
0.9078110456466675,
0.044866129755973816,
0.3500068485736847,
0.33933183550834656,
0.06758652627468109,
0.7257565259933472,
0.2469554990530014,
1.1782970428466797,
-0.3571636378765106,
0.004243664443492889,
1.694495677947998,
-0.24622318148612976,
1.2159836292266846,
0.19863943755626678,
-0.14363768696784973,
0.7326961159706116,
0.2733956575393677,
0.14627325534820557,
0.5941871404647827,
0.04064454138278961,
-0.19887425005435944,
0.0016718378756195307,
-0.11897985637187958,
-0.4095763564109802,
0.6322000026702881,
0.3828531503677368,
-0.6542531847953796,
0.11664165556430817,
-0.3010750710964203,
-0.38149505853652954,
0.2898462116718292,
-0.19245702028274536,
0.6945346593856812,
-0.2682054042816162,
-0.9387273788452148,
0.41791990399360657,
0.09123919904232025,
0.24069873988628387,
-0.2619704604148865,
-0.41535085439682007,
-0.010504820384085178,
0.14325593411922455,
0.06933677196502686,
-0.8316839933395386,
0.09991814941167831,
-0.10932576656341553,
-0.24749785661697388,
0.05588529631495476,
0.6598852872848511,
-0.21435439586639404,
-0.7523928880691528,
0.5093287825584412,
0.6165102124214172,
-0.06634753942489624,
0.1395605504512787,
-0.44970670342445374,
0.05738603323698044,
-0.13958027958869934,
-0.2844396233558655,
0.2653501033782959,
0.3385072946548462,
0.07096455991268158,
0.8798323273658752,
0.29257532954216003,
0.2004559487104416,
0.06014632806181908,
-0.04799452796578407,
0.6969533562660217,
-0.380730539560318,
-0.5354986190795898,
-0.7380435466766357,
0.1021575778722763,
0.11290725320577621,
-0.09640725702047348,
0.37709346413612366,
0.42244085669517517,
0.9987677931785583,
0.09279947727918625,
0.9301810264587402,
0.3060363233089447,
0.5883821249008179,
-0.5911597609519958,
0.33506113290786743,
-0.30037635564804077,
0.4480082094669342,
-0.18582554161548615,
-0.8952789306640625,
-0.01067806314677,
0.19676163792610168,
-0.6057944893836975,
0.16865476965904236,
0.7266517281532288,
0.8008571863174438,
-0.01759665086865425,
0.7512047290802002,
0.25611066818237305,
0.16815875470638275,
0.15196266770362854,
0.5287985801696777,
0.7909736037254333,
-0.05550582334399223,
0.7464475631713867,
-0.6050999760627747,
-0.27983996272087097,
-0.3360917866230011,
-0.9247400164604187,
-0.90931236743927,
-0.5406111478805542,
0.08091162145137787,
-0.23408673703670502,
0.18687394261360168,
0.6112661957740784,
0.6320729851722717,
-1.0196669101715088,
-0.29988914728164673,
-0.23811958730220795,
0.08840804547071457,
-0.4191396236419678,
-0.17561843991279602,
0.3114910423755646,
-0.26658201217651367,
-0.7520767450332642,
0.5116159915924072,
-0.05892278999090195,
0.03238379582762718,
-0.2931312024593353,
-0.18041351437568665,
0.0827457532286644,
-0.017749566584825516,
0.3945758044719696,
0.3137195110321045,
-0.7877028584480286,
-0.48650485277175903,
0.14723624289035797,
0.09007658809423447,
-0.11275152862071991,
0.6761894822120667,
-0.7135099172592163,
0.6073440313339233,
0.3403874933719635,
0.7170044779777527,
0.2712778151035309,
0.036431726068258286,
0.9240846633911133,
-0.7960212230682373,
-0.34276947379112244,
0.43987974524497986,
0.2288544774055481,
0.3704553246498108,
-0.2924831211566925,
0.21400533616542816,
-0.11028942465782166,
-0.4240550994873047,
-0.6599617004394531,
0.2119048833847046,
-0.16756226122379303,
-0.22579406201839447,
1.0004445314407349,
-0.5353382229804993,
-0.2752612829208374,
-0.014125825837254524,
0.20670168101787567,
0.1877443641424179,
-0.7181794047355652,
0.27510005235671997,
0.7403546571731567,
-0.4058959186077118,
-0.20694372057914734,
-1.0852628946304321,
0.2943158447742462,
0.27811047434806824,
-0.44257545471191406,
0.4388520121574402,
0.6902674436569214,
0.20625869929790497,
0.13064360618591309,
0.5821518301963806,
0.1271996647119522,
0.3551175892353058,
0.01918085291981697,
-0.2271857112646103,
-0.2694447934627533,
-0.7324557304382324,
-0.29362574219703674,
0.2880147695541382,
0.19373469054698944,
-0.422597736120224
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.12408v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.12408v1
|
MSLM-S2ST: A Multitask Speech Language Model for Textless Speech-to-Speech Translation with Speaker Style Preservation
| 2024-03-19T03:35:20 | 2024-03-19T03:35:20 |
Yifan Peng, Ilia Kulikov, Yilin Yang, Sravya Popuri, Hui Lu, Changhan Wang, Hongyu Gong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
There have been emerging research interest and advances in speech-to-speech
translation (S2ST), translating utterances from one language to another. This
work proposes Multitask Speech Language Model (MSLM), which is a decoder-only
speech language model trained in a multitask setting. Without reliance on text
training data, our model is able to support multilingual S2ST with speaker
style preserved.
|
[
0.202858105301857,
-0.6653419137001038,
0.4494432806968689,
0.004135082475841045,
-0.5550246238708496,
0.13635262846946716,
-0.007358773611485958,
-0.1730269342660904,
0.1502583920955658,
0.7760270833969116,
-0.8159056901931763,
-0.15828628838062286,
-0.6564244031906128,
0.0953444316983223,
-0.45470887422561646,
1.345301866531372,
0.15226757526397705,
0.31562018394470215,
-0.0647183358669281,
-0.08643807470798492,
-0.46478894352912903,
-0.8277645707130432,
-0.6799280643463135,
-0.14256002008914948,
0.3154485821723938,
0.3227093815803528,
0.3331444263458252,
0.5191254019737244,
0.20465926826000214,
0.1162988469004631,
-0.188411146402359,
0.2189934104681015,
-0.5393946170806885,
0.3611379861831665,
-0.11590804159641266,
-0.10407150536775589,
-0.6187359094619751,
-0.20742714405059814,
0.8409671783447266,
0.4058447778224945,
-0.32633864879608154,
0.22142566740512848,
0.1719297170639038,
0.6149634122848511,
-0.3657395839691162,
0.1367148756980896,
-0.5598157644271851,
-0.03490802273154259,
-0.39719218015670776,
-0.2803146541118622,
-0.7536152601242065,
-0.1786072999238968,
-0.15995390713214874,
0.13934393227100372,
-0.0968441441655159,
-0.0670328438282013,
0.4865764081478119,
0.41973793506622314,
-0.7310490012168884,
-0.0032719168812036514,
-0.6738179326057434,
0.8733959794044495,
-0.7203137874603271,
0.8882450461387634,
0.6772382259368896,
0.3170560896396637,
0.30201876163482666,
-0.34758496284484863,
-0.42295166850090027,
-0.1856803297996521,
-0.09338068217039108,
0.15399301052093506,
0.09271671622991562,
0.123555026948452,
-0.05499473959207535,
-0.07490924000740051,
-0.9350680708885193,
-0.31522509455680847,
-0.4846700429916382,
-0.17954021692276,
0.6455597281455994,
0.2984997630119324,
0.18064692616462708,
-0.40273991227149963,
-0.7131003141403198,
0.4770030081272125,
-0.6453401446342468,
0.0242268368601799,
0.07721299678087234,
0.5700919032096863,
-0.19201582670211792,
0.7740188837051392,
-0.07568523287773132,
0.5951983332633972,
-0.6354130506515503,
-0.5101268887519836,
0.36917373538017273,
-0.7405086755752563,
-0.1545044332742691,
0.22176897525787354,
0.40700989961624146,
0.27220457792282104,
0.011201959103345871,
-0.3139376938343048,
-0.31330299377441406,
0.10594068467617035,
0.12227708101272583,
-0.551424503326416,
0.09355396032333374,
0.16558454930782318,
-0.7183147072792053,
-0.08847444504499435,
-0.2911372780799866,
-0.32604196667671204,
-0.12425469607114792,
-0.458092600107193,
0.08028518408536911,
-0.4095946252346039,
-0.7854536771774292,
-0.10406970232725143,
-0.12654006481170654,
-0.03988906368613243,
0.3453122079372406,
-0.7220281958580017,
0.20219582319259644,
0.554110586643219,
1.1086832284927368,
-0.5474897027015686,
-0.6374367475509644,
-0.5550481081008911,
0.24580621719360352,
-0.40169480443000793,
0.7592092156410217,
-0.2213527411222458,
-0.6470275521278381,
-0.054193105548620224,
0.22708480060100555,
-0.44992920756340027,
-0.04368152469396591,
0.42611345648765564,
-0.2787822186946869,
-0.05193191394209862,
-0.12840308248996735,
-0.5260471105575562,
-0.013910412788391113,
0.22709769010543823,
-0.22792372107505798,
1.2622272968292236,
0.13819821178913116,
-0.6343497037887573,
-0.13070553541183472,
-0.8477814197540283,
-0.5478643774986267,
0.12066979706287384,
0.22031356394290924,
-0.2667795717716217,
0.030361896380782127,
-0.4463491141796112,
0.4934045076370239,
0.10493650287389755,
0.3483280837535858,
-0.010071351192891598,
-0.10931873321533203,
0.17350617051124573,
-0.5233612656593323,
0.7653249502182007,
0.6032987236976624,
0.06503371149301529,
0.558549165725708,
-0.6851357221603394,
-0.0417281799018383,
0.3419659435749054,
-0.5912061929702759,
-0.05811488255858421,
0.21142275631427765,
0.59771329164505,
0.7724021673202515,
0.4155769348144531,
-0.8154916167259216,
0.09585626423358917,
-0.23174713551998138,
0.7285827994346619,
0.6179746389389038,
-0.36659476161003113,
0.25931400060653687,
-0.38683468103408813,
0.41288331151008606,
-0.33136600255966187,
-0.037325091660022736,
-0.4999048113822937,
-0.7080888152122498,
-0.7193206548690796,
-0.1557890623807907,
-0.14754673838615417,
0.9415518641471863,
-0.8216121792793274,
0.09366720169782639,
-0.41364333033561707,
-0.32792606949806213,
-0.6800819635391235,
-0.04252351075410843,
0.6873134970664978,
0.43122613430023193,
0.4471123218536377,
0.19003179669380188,
-0.6295631527900696,
-1.0605162382125854,
-0.20875003933906555,
0.22853761911392212,
0.09765176475048065,
-0.12248388677835464,
0.35495510697364807,
-0.21841961145401,
0.59991854429245,
-0.08348928391933441,
-0.36647167801856995,
-0.6758064031600952,
-0.11770716309547424,
-0.2602992653846741,
0.48680785298347473,
0.27654382586479187,
-0.5435172319412231,
-0.7010605335235596,
0.04938638582825661,
-0.7348032593727112,
0.1124149039387703,
0.14114098250865936,
0.06408026069402695,
0.503119707107544,
0.7554844617843628,
-0.5363523960113525,
0.652180552482605,
1.0082075595855713,
-0.51191645860672,
0.6972741484642029,
-0.288899302482605,
0.0965413972735405,
-1.4248961210250854,
0.3884754776954651,
-0.5745169520378113,
-0.7976904511451721,
-1.3008311986923218,
0.07042510062456131,
0.318773478269577,
-0.5608192682266235,
-0.7993396520614624,
0.6196228265762329,
-0.48395442962646484,
-0.29495373368263245,
-0.6485877633094788,
0.16511748731136322,
-0.08092617988586426,
0.4549415707588196,
0.38221314549446106,
1.111631989479065,
0.45899975299835205,
-0.5616497993469238,
0.4382021427154541,
0.5402980446815491,
-0.17990750074386597,
0.7581113576889038,
-0.33922502398490906,
0.728258490562439,
0.01574857160449028,
0.08480802923440933,
-1.011938452720642,
0.16266246140003204,
0.0046645174734294415,
-0.387333482503891,
0.26995810866355896,
-0.3083195388317108,
-0.7264101505279541,
-0.283771276473999,
-0.04870741069316864,
0.18771980702877045,
-0.013697104528546333,
-0.1811911165714264,
0.5517534017562866,
0.3242892920970917,
-0.8864765763282776,
-0.17227034270763397,
-0.8791947960853577,
0.45960524678230286,
0.11126818507909775,
-0.7311161160469055,
0.10457857698202133,
-0.3768894076347351,
0.19086915254592896,
-0.1532963514328003,
0.09171897917985916,
-0.11229830980300903,
-0.12672410905361176,
0.11609872430562973,
0.5063114762306213,
-0.24809163808822632,
0.23694494366645813,
0.031407807022333145,
-0.37747809290885925,
-0.4110393524169922,
-0.08203007280826569,
0.8855509161949158,
-0.019583653658628464,
-0.3030790686607361,
-0.7637537717819214,
1.1914622783660889,
0.655010461807251,
-0.5534971952438354,
0.8033051490783691,
0.386605829000473,
-0.13819944858551025,
0.2320769876241684,
-0.4748310446739197,
-0.12708860635757446,
-0.39415091276168823,
0.6859639883041382,
-0.7256333827972412,
-0.8746891617774963,
0.22214412689208984,
0.05219075083732605,
0.024278994649648666,
0.158132866024971,
0.5463029146194458,
-0.11452776938676834,
1.2076386213302612,
0.631698727607727,
0.11234388500452042,
0.5656173229217529,
0.2046734094619751,
0.07013481110334396,
-0.964521586894989,
-0.34105950593948364,
-0.5152925848960876,
0.10395146161317825,
-0.009171704761683941,
-0.3763675391674042,
0.2527952790260315,
-0.2748125493526459,
-0.27978619933128357,
0.4025181829929352,
-0.4243546724319458,
0.18979883193969727,
0.5922641754150391,
-0.0005202344618737698,
0.18643803894519806,
0.10479473322629929,
0.048882000148296356,
-0.052056971937417984,
-0.5126420259475708,
-0.5842105746269226,
0.8721551299095154,
0.3499259650707245,
0.2644880414009094,
0.34368643164634705,
0.45059967041015625,
0.21641376614570618,
-0.2901705503463745,
-0.8280292749404907,
0.43256041407585144,
-0.5683702826499939,
-0.8098751306533813,
-0.534568727016449,
-0.31073901057243347,
-0.7949267625808716,
0.40625664591789246,
0.0632200837135315,
-0.9727330207824707,
-0.21854153275489807,
0.17454758286476135,
-0.13756713271141052,
0.340629905462265,
-0.5560699105262756,
0.9548893570899963,
-0.3872913420200348,
-0.0005266532534733415,
-0.27780628204345703,
-0.8299272656440735,
0.21881064772605896,
0.08276424556970596,
0.4311602711677551,
-0.2701193690299988,
0.09208188205957413,
0.7942079305648804,
-0.29226720333099365,
0.508840024471283,
-0.19735245406627655,
-0.11141684651374817,
-0.007196563761681318,
0.5984599590301514,
0.9257581830024719,
-0.4536614716053009,
-0.24302420020103455,
0.2267802357673645,
0.2679192125797272,
-0.6086558103561401,
-0.2364223450422287,
0.5193313360214233,
-0.4372614622116089,
-0.43024006485939026,
-0.30396002531051636,
-0.6835823059082031,
-0.3708440065383911,
0.3578876554965973,
0.23013398051261902,
0.2512834072113037,
-0.17803189158439636,
0.11878970265388489,
0.4423545002937317,
0.2002657949924469,
0.6564406752586365,
0.683861255645752,
-0.3055272400379181,
-0.3598096966743469,
1.1015344858169556,
0.1408822238445282,
0.6235402822494507,
0.11684294044971466,
0.2518426179885864,
-0.6640436053276062,
-0.44638147950172424,
-0.7895662784576416,
0.13833650946617126,
-0.6715547442436218,
0.04695015028119087,
-0.9173446297645569,
-0.43022438883781433,
-0.7415420413017273,
-0.03849848359823227,
-0.7474049925804138,
-0.38200628757476807,
-0.2789270579814911,
-0.14297108352184296,
0.262800008058548,
1.0545096397399902,
0.07392627745866776,
0.41154932975769043,
-0.8067736625671387,
0.44861000776290894,
0.21585693955421448,
0.18962565064430237,
-0.3001953065395355,
-0.8989861011505127,
-0.3188127279281616,
0.09403372555971146,
-0.03952712193131447,
-1.063923954963684,
0.5196017026901245,
0.3710591197013855,
0.46392637491226196,
0.38336777687072754,
-0.13036584854125977,
0.5677099823951721,
-0.8456088304519653,
1.004952311515808,
0.6005101799964905,
-1.0700087547302246,
0.7852573394775391,
-0.38707640767097473,
0.40646135807037354,
0.25585997104644775,
-0.22832903265953064,
-1.2750871181488037,
-0.10008794814348221,
-0.28038468956947327,
-0.5666103363037109,
1.1578361988067627,
0.3092634975910187,
0.357083261013031,
0.2910996675491333,
-0.2731150686740875,
0.2753426730632782,
0.5058205127716064,
-0.5647428035736084,
-0.350408136844635,
-0.9017385840415955,
-0.09787081927061081,
-0.4346907436847687,
-0.671818196773529,
-0.141387477517128,
-0.19736944139003754,
0.5911548733711243,
0.001017231959849596,
0.5771481990814209,
-0.19943663477897644,
-0.2332228720188141,
0.15330858528614044,
0.56437087059021,
1.4465219974517822,
0.3160775899887085,
-0.14130799472332,
0.4641706347465515,
0.18333472311496735,
-0.29942548274993896,
0.2547193765640259,
0.09049350023269653,
-0.20767925679683685,
0.13285483419895172,
0.15893998742103577,
1.1819734573364258,
0.2331216186285019,
-0.34636467695236206,
0.6443436741828918,
0.249546617269516,
-0.16936685144901276,
-0.1334010362625122,
-0.4500817656517029,
0.4011949300765991,
-0.06958650052547455,
0.267547070980072,
0.48694783449172974,
0.05285409465432167,
-0.3946221172809601,
0.25652703642845154,
0.229566752910614,
-0.549567699432373,
-0.3682169020175934,
0.7622175812721252,
0.283926784992218,
-0.6566723585128784,
0.220910906791687,
-0.3291133642196655,
-0.5321852564811707,
0.1594078093767166,
0.8460231423377991,
0.8465616106987,
-0.8361483812332153,
0.14723947644233704,
0.1278696358203888,
0.18413956463336945,
-0.1567763090133667,
0.6048929691314697,
-0.06583459675312042,
-0.3600092828273773,
-0.12159489095211029,
-0.47489383816719055,
-0.06206747516989708,
0.0749131590127945,
-0.5501903891563416,
0.13393695652484894,
-0.19168709218502045,
-0.14126957952976227,
-0.10138414800167084,
-0.4338759481906891,
-0.4734596610069275,
0.04257974028587341,
0.19629082083702087,
0.6811468601226807,
-0.5968379974365234,
1.60957670211792,
0.4842129945755005,
-0.22043341398239136,
-0.5876709222793579,
-0.4590480625629425,
0.5066247582435608,
-0.8089118003845215,
0.6681290864944458,
-0.12915639579296112,
-0.49213331937789917,
0.17138659954071045,
-0.3146238625049591,
-1.1455256938934326,
0.7075796723365784,
0.4326191246509552,
-0.4917905926704407,
-0.16566058993339539,
0.15075752139091492,
0.0808098167181015,
-0.30256932973861694,
-0.18062712252140045,
0.33919787406921387,
0.2985517978668213,
-0.017990099266171455,
-1.540228009223938,
-0.17653529345989227,
-0.4196430444717407,
0.2214350402355194,
0.038833703845739365,
-0.5721564888954163,
1.1192744970321655,
-0.1280343383550644,
-0.33881881833076477,
0.3133900463581085,
0.39090994000434875,
0.09554877132177353,
0.2533116638660431,
0.32967573404312134,
0.085621178150177,
0.5837454795837402,
0.04401271045207977,
0.948143482208252,
-0.26772141456604004,
0.5134508013725281,
1.4685086011886597,
-0.3536970317363739,
1.2544910907745361,
0.5907943844795227,
-0.32933467626571655,
0.05585591495037079,
0.4928642511367798,
0.21957209706306458,
0.8019224405288696,
-0.20677201449871063,
-0.28211507201194763,
-0.2966037690639496,
-0.30290406942367554,
-0.5765702724456787,
0.7488922476768494,
0.22612063586711884,
-0.27245032787323,
-0.15877564251422882,
0.5246833562850952,
0.2389223873615265,
-0.03597041964530945,
-0.1594477891921997,
0.9256497025489807,
0.198038250207901,
-0.388458251953125,
0.7249971628189087,
0.08487018197774887,
0.8245830535888672,
-0.8131198287010193,
0.11039239913225174,
-0.03456035628914833,
-0.1676534116268158,
-0.1909499615430832,
-0.636872410774231,
0.6961564421653748,
-0.023402485996484756,
-0.3959736227989197,
-0.5039387345314026,
0.7488574385643005,
-0.8142697811126709,
-0.5443262457847595,
0.35332053899765015,
0.5154345035552979,
0.6105179190635681,
-0.2446419596672058,
-0.780204176902771,
0.08410798758268356,
0.1187673956155777,
-0.02086869440972805,
0.2452038824558258,
0.0025489411782473326,
0.1861569732427597,
0.8306155800819397,
0.8512677550315857,
0.20309880375862122,
0.4638524353504181,
0.07597304880619049,
0.44312185049057007,
-0.5960950255393982,
-0.904757559299469,
-0.6650434136390686,
0.631782591342926,
0.12317270785570145,
-0.2127964049577713,
0.8331723809242249,
0.7866920828819275,
0.42055460810661316,
-0.5036671161651611,
0.989855170249939,
0.19847342371940613,
0.9843059182167053,
-0.5462765097618103,
1.0616482496261597,
-0.6355392336845398,
-0.36448171734809875,
-0.15545617043972015,
-0.550030529499054,
-0.023094190284609795,
0.5736960172653198,
0.09179089963436127,
-0.11001172661781311,
0.8267492651939392,
0.7181350588798523,
0.12540291249752045,
0.13967174291610718,
1.0317658185958862,
-0.17590129375457764,
0.12412051856517792,
0.28302162885665894,
0.6208226680755615,
-0.2652812600135803,
0.5847094058990479,
-0.097144715487957,
-0.03553728014230728,
-0.5322813987731934,
-0.5853793621063232,
-0.8259978294372559,
-0.9659069180488586,
-0.1267414689064026,
-0.35757976770401,
0.22368934750556946,
0.9308170676231384,
1.1476757526397705,
-0.8997268080711365,
-0.46228015422821045,
0.22180132567882538,
-0.1934230625629425,
-0.38814836740493774,
-0.14171206951141357,
0.43208593130111694,
-0.31557661294937134,
-0.5288681387901306,
1.0327584743499756,
0.3482896685600281,
0.20511870086193085,
-0.17677196860313416,
-0.3631085753440857,
-0.33348318934440613,
0.11506449431180954,
1.0887978076934814,
0.02070869877934456,
-1.098980188369751,
-0.2092686891555786,
0.03874397650361061,
-0.2246469259262085,
0.20938259363174438,
0.9101625084877014,
-0.10148647427558899,
0.6668615937232971,
0.18060649931430817,
0.2862492501735687,
0.641682505607605,
-0.27752137184143066,
0.28111371397972107,
-0.9779778122901917,
0.33375877141952515,
0.12204043567180634,
0.3765700161457062,
0.4222220182418823,
-0.262708842754364,
0.24418236315250397,
0.41875436902046204,
-0.48480790853500366,
-0.9547803401947021,
0.4569944739341736,
-1.0705169439315796,
-0.2946726381778717,
1.3399578332901,
-0.21632882952690125,
0.16400624811649323,
-0.6254981756210327,
-0.6119089722633362,
0.45991936326026917,
-0.6312310695648193,
0.24509014189243317,
0.5472211241722107,
-0.1062113344669342,
-0.6985930800437927,
-0.9847640991210938,
0.7178734540939331,
0.21850727498531342,
-0.6895745396614075,
0.4329073429107666,
-0.007382988929748535,
0.4023110866546631,
0.12151233106851578,
0.8815335035324097,
0.1371636986732483,
0.15103495121002197,
0.14189466834068298,
0.30253568291664124,
-0.3583883047103882,
-0.4106734097003937,
-0.0952056348323822,
0.21674278378486633,
-0.01888422481715679,
-0.5359997153282166
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.12407v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.12407v1
|
Cross-Lingual Transfer for Natural Language Inference via Multilingual Prompt Translator
| 2024-03-19T03:35:18 | 2024-03-19T03:35:18 |
Xiaoyu Qiu, Yuechen Wang, Jiaxin Shi, Wengang Zhou, Houqiang Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Based on multilingual pre-trained models, cross-lingual transfer with prompt
learning has shown promising effectiveness, where soft prompt learned in a
source language is transferred to target languages for downstream tasks,
particularly in the low-resource scenario. To efficiently transfer soft prompt,
we propose a novel framework, Multilingual Prompt Translator (MPT), where a
multilingual prompt translator is introduced to properly process crucial
knowledge embedded in prompt by changing language knowledge while retaining
task knowledge. Concretely, we first train prompt in source language and employ
translator to translate it into target prompt. Besides, we extend an external
corpus as auxiliary data, on which an alignment task for predicted answer
probability is designed to convert language knowledge, thereby equipping target
prompt with multilingual knowledge. In few-shot settings on XNLI, MPT
demonstrates superiority over baselines by remarkable improvements. MPT is more
prominent compared with vanilla prompting when transferring to languages quite
distinct from source language.
|
[
-0.25420263409614563,
-0.5535350441932678,
0.6709180474281311,
0.4920162260532379,
-0.14126816391944885,
-0.11420060694217682,
-0.48945194482803345,
-0.320097416639328,
-0.042370494455099106,
0.2532481551170349,
-0.8684020638465881,
-0.20290593802928925,
-0.3380856513977051,
0.38677799701690674,
0.08575654029846191,
1.119545340538025,
-0.05901792645454407,
0.17239563167095184,
0.13788653910160065,
-0.05524642392992973,
-0.5779639482498169,
-0.4042927324771881,
-0.9587688446044922,
-0.10972072929143906,
0.8015907406806946,
0.5970559120178223,
0.4299638867378235,
0.1191391795873642,
-0.024780653417110443,
0.2607539892196655,
0.24062368273735046,
0.03652770072221756,
-0.14795145392417908,
-0.19367055594921112,
-0.5921832323074341,
-0.5463265180587769,
-0.03305288776755333,
-0.08210476487874985,
0.6703938245773315,
0.8366268873214722,
0.21342134475708008,
-0.048730090260505676,
0.15264292061328888,
0.22593586146831512,
-0.5489840507507324,
0.3460765480995178,
-0.36001744866371155,
0.2089947611093521,
-0.17098990082740784,
-0.16824695467948914,
-0.723168671131134,
-0.46515053510665894,
0.08171076327562332,
-0.6955923438072205,
0.027982914820313454,
0.011076690629124641,
0.4508281350135803,
0.27075475454330444,
-0.7877703905105591,
-0.077493816614151,
-0.45366910099983215,
0.7761877775192261,
-0.48520785570144653,
0.478288859128952,
0.23827992379665375,
0.632982075214386,
0.10338454693555832,
-0.5682634711265564,
-0.6553162932395935,
-0.413097620010376,
-0.25369518995285034,
0.15600916743278503,
0.006418510340154171,
-0.09519171714782715,
0.0678892433643341,
-0.04552881419658661,
-0.6734538078308105,
0.09374465048313141,
0.05258230119943619,
-0.4606104791164398,
0.45136427879333496,
-0.1849711537361145,
0.5378402471542358,
-0.3097134828567505,
-0.6731589436531067,
-0.2006130814552307,
-0.5315904021263123,
0.2761097848415375,
0.2367195039987564,
0.7945739030838013,
-0.30267632007598877,
0.2883988916873932,
-0.17104311287403107,
0.772472083568573,
-0.04205990582704544,
-0.22365951538085938,
0.2353745698928833,
-0.8671314716339111,
0.20297619700431824,
0.37577706575393677,
0.7716434001922607,
0.24806290864944458,
0.3340318202972412,
-0.10828305780887604,
0.04266694188117981,
-0.3372117280960083,
-0.26914182305336,
-0.6197496652603149,
0.01791568286716938,
-0.16903334856033325,
-0.3971269726753235,
0.17960518598556519,
-0.1969601958990097,
-0.9109808206558228,
-0.35270339250564575,
-0.25890055298805237,
0.1732843667268753,
-0.5032723546028137,
-0.2842067778110504,
-0.10703667253255844,
0.0798790454864502,
0.2755310833454132,
0.47971147298812866,
-0.8469598889350891,
-0.09845443814992905,
0.4092772603034973,
0.7966208457946777,
-0.3358679711818695,
-0.6088994145393372,
-1.079711675643921,
0.18597668409347534,
-0.16845405101776123,
0.89537513256073,
-0.3386237323284149,
-0.1761264204978943,
0.08120457082986832,
0.22056341171264648,
-0.4755324721336365,
0.05205632746219635,
0.6820115447044373,
-0.33519548177719116,
0.6777107119560242,
-0.36169102787971497,
-0.1438477635383606,
-0.22851751744747162,
0.2748543918132782,
-0.6373251676559448,
0.70644611120224,
0.18151260912418365,
-0.5097121596336365,
0.2793176770210266,
-0.470131516456604,
-0.8008165955543518,
-0.018538212403655052,
0.11936583369970322,
0.35971617698669434,
-0.14450553059577942,
0.3831462860107422,
0.2665374279022217,
-0.24047257006168365,
0.4030839204788208,
-0.16725336015224457,
0.06545744836330414,
0.20723949372768402,
-0.778261125087738,
1.0375522375106812,
0.29743692278862,
-0.21833737194538116,
0.20074571669101715,
-0.646004319190979,
-0.11886276304721832,
-0.1528310477733612,
-0.2653283476829529,
-0.2740738093852997,
-0.49003416299819946,
0.2296631634235382,
0.5956929922103882,
0.2124512940645218,
-0.46368494629859924,
0.2646370530128479,
-0.21919701993465424,
0.12158408015966415,
0.5442578792572021,
-0.09357156604528427,
0.8276874423027039,
-0.10861226916313171,
0.734322190284729,
-0.03048226609826088,
-0.026470938697457314,
-0.41618502140045166,
-0.6329729557037354,
-0.2596893012523651,
-0.29677441716194153,
0.4011145532131195,
1.2146937847137451,
-1.4159936904907227,
0.04369065538048744,
-0.2788807451725006,
-0.11094456166028976,
-0.6864444017410278,
0.07439056038856506,
0.43601101636886597,
0.8636949062347412,
0.4843730330467224,
0.18991932272911072,
-0.22136440873146057,
-0.8874534368515015,
-0.4413160979747772,
-0.3156668543815613,
0.038901325315237045,
0.13792447745800018,
0.03063294291496277,
0.03958803787827492,
0.7825431227684021,
-0.11900810152292252,
-0.30979499220848083,
-0.7848297953605652,
0.3478914797306061,
0.5493500232696533,
0.6083368062973022,
0.7671727538108826,
-0.8085348606109619,
-0.8380953669548035,
0.4506251811981201,
-0.514445424079895,
-0.4968673884868622,
-0.6053426861763,
-0.2748766541481018,
0.3017054498195648,
0.4345913529396057,
-0.7775623202323914,
-0.019867729395627975,
0.5703973174095154,
-0.45116445422172546,
0.6576442122459412,
-0.10115084052085876,
0.5940114855766296,
-1.4933221340179443,
0.13288411498069763,
-0.07291696220636368,
-0.40455886721611023,
-0.6579271554946899,
-0.13761195540428162,
0.1196351945400238,
-0.04082639142870903,
-0.8113107681274414,
1.1602330207824707,
-0.47117266058921814,
0.09011118859052658,
-0.09098415821790695,
0.07906697690486908,
0.04536982253193855,
0.5792601108551025,
0.29267996549606323,
0.9709126353263855,
0.5033565759658813,
-0.5102142095565796,
0.4260575771331787,
0.40940338373184204,
-0.2377752959728241,
0.9713611602783203,
-0.1793551743030548,
-0.011907532811164856,
-0.07307734340429306,
0.25875794887542725,
-1.058074712753296,
-0.03034697100520134,
0.4943971335887909,
-0.40858668088912964,
0.5385855436325073,
-0.6724455952644348,
-0.4465853273868561,
-0.05473686754703522,
0.012524099089205265,
0.4149075150489807,
0.4336397647857666,
-0.670688271522522,
0.6207395792007446,
-0.2627347707748413,
-0.7724324464797974,
-0.6145452260971069,
-0.8141329884529114,
0.14544034004211426,
-0.1922452747821808,
-0.5862377882003784,
0.2746753692626953,
-0.1751416027545929,
-0.019569065421819687,
-0.03716927394270897,
0.20757374167442322,
-0.3146189749240875,
-0.08114226162433624,
-0.49935418367385864,
0.368108332157135,
-0.4806632697582245,
0.0868556797504425,
0.2985328733921051,
-0.2796052098274231,
0.07819731533527374,
-0.4894680976867676,
0.21759575605392456,
0.11890113353729248,
-0.40040427446365356,
-0.40865907073020935,
0.7631022930145264,
0.35569387674331665,
-0.23356477916240692,
0.7863287925720215,
0.9388719201087952,
-0.1265089064836502,
-0.02126275561749935,
-0.2878873944282532,
-0.17903243005275726,
-0.3490724563598633,
0.23817668855190277,
-0.8851315975189209,
-0.5043652057647705,
0.5619166493415833,
-0.11295522004365921,
0.05455072596669197,
0.25653505325317383,
0.3204799294471741,
0.3421952426433563,
1.2366204261779785,
0.5909152030944824,
-0.018974684178829193,
0.6256912350654602,
0.21036340296268463,
0.10767561197280884,
-0.3130427598953247,
0.10132545232772827,
-0.5470364093780518,
-0.18585161864757538,
-0.38662824034690857,
-0.4443795680999756,
0.20368251204490662,
0.15974345803260803,
0.04033960774540901,
0.3963340222835541,
0.10846589505672455,
0.4065394401550293,
0.8237771987915039,
-0.17444203794002533,
0.35936084389686584,
0.004153212532401085,
-0.24379928410053253,
-0.22605933248996735,
-0.8410478830337524,
-0.32437363266944885,
0.4415239989757538,
-0.007136722560971975,
0.4955194294452667,
0.34933459758758545,
0.4577851891517639,
0.0839846134185791,
0.24600671231746674,
-0.7071245908737183,
0.46283653378486633,
-0.0721120685338974,
-0.48075300455093384,
-0.12181055545806885,
-0.7395014762878418,
-0.7615928649902344,
0.39367514848709106,
-0.23119501769542694,
-0.6844804286956787,
0.2885496914386749,
0.07073450088500977,
-0.3479546308517456,
0.31490615010261536,
-1.0344315767288208,
1.2604331970214844,
-0.3570796251296997,
-0.6036602854728699,
0.06300879269838333,
-0.9282576441764832,
0.341344952583313,
-0.17592765390872955,
0.37186065316200256,
-0.09807560592889786,
-0.0521029531955719,
0.39293766021728516,
-0.10384570062160492,
0.8736740350723267,
-0.34000128507614136,
-0.2728724479675293,
0.16875112056732178,
0.16182565689086914,
0.604619562625885,
0.2802346348762512,
-0.2265251725912094,
0.028177352622151375,
-0.05172538757324219,
-0.45626264810562134,
-0.8021564483642578,
0.4960261285305023,
-0.5028870105743408,
-0.47854170203208923,
-0.4326480031013489,
-0.7602897882461548,
-0.3449578881263733,
0.4081602096557617,
0.4868888556957245,
0.2744525372982025,
-0.12695136666297913,
-0.4167141914367676,
0.4718608260154724,
-0.35611650347709656,
0.5050516128540039,
0.7220282554626465,
0.004801307339221239,
-0.2879284620285034,
1.0534673929214478,
-0.105995312333107,
0.32235491275787354,
0.78548663854599,
0.33058053255081177,
-0.687890350818634,
-0.4086702764034271,
-1.0743482112884521,
0.13625451922416687,
-0.9166622161865234,
-0.17798461019992828,
-0.6531427502632141,
0.07474546879529953,
-0.6985218524932861,
-0.30444028973579407,
-0.2928709089756012,
-0.40963229537010193,
-0.29222387075424194,
-0.025791620835661888,
0.3196004629135132,
0.2120043933391571,
-0.22351360321044922,
0.39255040884017944,
-1.1989439725875854,
0.3075278103351593,
0.29340118169784546,
0.04457555711269379,
-0.5157627463340759,
-0.6522272229194641,
-0.004926105961203575,
0.048110295087099075,
0.35918644070625305,
-1.2345126867294312,
0.5311347246170044,
0.3843294680118561,
0.7558339238166809,
0.24652241170406342,
0.42992669343948364,
0.6147421002388,
-0.6624225974082947,
0.7319743633270264,
0.391319215297699,
-0.9349169731140137,
0.35703763365745544,
-0.16356031596660614,
0.5700408816337585,
0.8051924109458923,
0.495118647813797,
-0.8550481796264648,
-0.0657549574971199,
-0.2681499123573303,
-0.6010522842407227,
0.9493993520736694,
-0.25245538353919983,
0.1333642452955246,
-0.07926138490438461,
-0.12663862109184265,
0.5056552290916443,
0.09900423139333725,
-0.781308114528656,
-0.07148949801921844,
-0.1286279410123825,
-0.4293992519378662,
-0.2697545289993286,
0.1060648187994957,
0.08260887861251831,
-0.18832352757453918,
0.5701378583908081,
-0.7552617788314819,
0.14399635791778564,
0.18640901148319244,
-0.6103348135948181,
0.127107173204422,
0.693085789680481,
0.518230140209198,
0.45145076513290405,
0.12697380781173706,
0.31114059686660767,
0.4577048718929291,
-0.11648131906986237,
0.35769692063331604,
0.5161758065223694,
-0.1324198991060257,
0.010616719722747803,
0.5587226748466492,
0.9571007490158081,
0.5189148783683777,
-0.5497631430625916,
0.6320963501930237,
-0.09345891326665878,
0.17523285746574402,
0.05007730796933174,
-0.2979709506034851,
-0.10100629180669785,
0.29337078332901,
0.33078160881996155,
0.17051078379154205,
0.33965688943862915,
-0.5385429859161377,
0.23036085069179535,
0.1988499015569687,
-0.47059184312820435,
-0.5228705406188965,
0.5984014868736267,
0.3139379024505615,
-0.12967215478420258,
0.5629416704177856,
-0.5554256439208984,
-0.6474967002868652,
0.17215454578399658,
0.6765345931053162,
0.7953214645385742,
-0.4074045717716217,
0.44956645369529724,
0.5202546119689941,
0.3020365238189697,
0.03915870562195778,
0.2706916630268097,
-0.25853264331817627,
-0.5586007237434387,
-0.9623149037361145,
-0.4124000370502472,
-0.32532477378845215,
-0.38662394881248474,
-0.48285579681396484,
0.261013925075531,
0.0704294741153717,
0.14589378237724304,
-0.2941538095474243,
-0.20084258913993835,
-0.643690824508667,
-0.2822437286376953,
0.47283682227134705,
1.0970410108566284,
-1.1062017679214478,
0.9510288238525391,
0.9284375905990601,
-0.4374857544898987,
-0.6860888004302979,
-0.21018725633621216,
-0.020431214943528175,
-0.7727344632148743,
0.6592879295349121,
0.20275795459747314,
-0.015333623625338078,
0.2640557885169983,
-0.1757839471101761,
-0.7852910757064819,
0.563761293888092,
0.9175669550895691,
-0.3314650058746338,
-0.06862760335206985,
0.006063998211175203,
0.1511092633008957,
-0.20350107550621033,
0.4332118034362793,
0.5551929473876953,
0.7710685729980469,
0.26418912410736084,
-1.190086007118225,
0.1480879783630371,
-0.20173130929470062,
-0.24760383367538452,
0.06441284716129303,
-0.20440326631069183,
0.8848599791526794,
-0.45338401198387146,
-0.4054632782936096,
0.0065635195933282375,
0.8306193351745605,
0.255024790763855,
0.31233376264572144,
0.5897737741470337,
0.13249413669109344,
0.7657544016838074,
0.12550479173660278,
1.1693859100341797,
-0.26202985644340515,
-0.08507294207811356,
1.1903274059295654,
-0.48963144421577454,
0.6928504705429077,
0.7155715823173523,
0.09070633351802826,
0.487109899520874,
0.6987422704696655,
0.3783940076828003,
0.7134192585945129,
-0.31235188245773315,
-0.5034763216972351,
-0.3597809672355652,
-0.4729660153388977,
-0.31809523701667786,
0.09959446638822556,
0.10734202712774277,
-0.09692801535129547,
-0.3776656687259674,
0.4600001275539398,
0.06222303584218025,
-0.024947170168161392,
-0.31798413395881653,
0.8189645409584045,
0.06797896325588226,
-1.1760127544403076,
0.4466286897659302,
-0.21152263879776,
0.730854868888855,
-0.8765751123428345,
-0.30759891867637634,
-0.3407577872276306,
0.21820016205310822,
0.03868227079510689,
-0.9392454624176025,
0.15038175880908966,
-0.14550742506980896,
-0.13782040774822235,
-0.7053343057632446,
0.6334805488586426,
-0.7762710452079773,
-0.47017452120780945,
0.39004209637641907,
0.8720213770866394,
0.3053476810455322,
-0.19802740216255188,
-0.877213716506958,
-0.5036686062812805,
0.1869739145040512,
-0.28686726093292236,
0.35842153429985046,
0.6916562914848328,
-0.3283553123474121,
0.4462068974971771,
0.8219581842422485,
0.18722879886627197,
0.3480244278907776,
0.2673199474811554,
0.5448053479194641,
-0.526080846786499,
-0.8703607320785522,
-0.6544021368026733,
0.5209800601005554,
0.0005956378881819546,
-0.4432642459869385,
0.8871455192565918,
0.19781148433685303,
0.7333886027336121,
-0.24294587969779968,
0.8049173355102539,
-0.17219612002372742,
0.27671095728874207,
-0.8230692744255066,
0.5590343475341797,
-0.3740193843841553,
-0.1263754665851593,
-0.017448987811803818,
-0.9312275052070618,
-0.13116216659545898,
0.5008881688117981,
-0.2817758023738861,
-0.10230281203985214,
0.8216201663017273,
0.5742006301879883,
-0.2730380892753601,
-0.14754435420036316,
0.3779759705066681,
-0.15499737858772278,
0.19118843972682953,
0.8639412522315979,
0.8237220644950867,
-0.08894742280244827,
0.8065353035926819,
-0.37310531735420227,
-0.33838003873825073,
-0.09636441618204117,
-1.0958696603775024,
-0.7942510843276978,
-0.5778396725654602,
-0.3472163677215576,
-0.1092129573225975,
-0.06042317673563957,
1.0978232622146606,
0.8178976774215698,
-1.0022436380386353,
-0.11656411737203598,
0.11592979729175568,
0.4207020401954651,
-0.5257933139801025,
-0.2174447476863861,
0.20757441222667694,
-0.7745355367660522,
-0.9662252068519592,
0.8520088791847229,
-0.10956971347332001,
0.14383359253406525,
-0.14825627207756042,
-0.14190731942653656,
-0.4907941520214081,
-0.24688731133937836,
0.6904398798942566,
0.4373991787433624,
-0.5666809678077698,
-0.21603865921497345,
0.15663973987102509,
-0.20298871397972107,
-0.10831670463085175,
0.8129880428314209,
-0.8192816376686096,
0.3050849139690399,
0.8728144764900208,
0.9445940256118774,
0.11285808682441711,
-0.10162252187728882,
0.9714003801345825,
-1.0881516933441162,
0.42228400707244873,
0.10398106276988983,
0.47883495688438416,
0.5244170427322388,
-0.4495207965373993,
0.400866836309433,
0.3465162515640259,
-0.07608892768621445,
-0.6441431641578674,
0.38653311133384705,
-0.9801032543182373,
-0.40849217772483826,
1.264750361442566,
-0.3371923863887787,
-0.3831513822078705,
-0.31317397952079773,
-0.49515247344970703,
0.4317503273487091,
-0.3779771327972412,
0.09039910137653351,
0.6395959854125977,
0.1803903877735138,
-0.6712032556533813,
-0.6801836490631104,
0.44800272583961487,
0.4991385340690613,
-0.9560984373092651,
0.04785619303584099,
0.4243965744972229,
0.044439367949962616,
0.3077850937843323,
0.6148384213447571,
0.23397694528102875,
0.41352370381355286,
-0.1605752557516098,
0.16024081408977509,
0.05644145607948303,
-0.3443528711795807,
-0.583712100982666,
0.05022883415222168,
-0.07187379151582718,
-0.14823861420154572
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.12403v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.12403v2
|
Towards Interpretable Hate Speech Detection using Large Language Model-extracted Rationales
| 2024-03-19T03:22:35 | 2024-05-08T02:47:36 |
Ayushi Nirmal, Amrita Bhattacharjee, Paras Sheth, Huan Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Although social media platforms are a prominent arena for users to engage in
interpersonal discussions and express opinions, the facade and anonymity
offered by social media may allow users to spew hate speech and offensive
content. Given the massive scale of such platforms, there arises a need to
automatically identify and flag instances of hate speech. Although several hate
speech detection methods exist, most of these black-box methods are not
interpretable or explainable by design. To address the lack of
interpretability, in this paper, we propose to use state-of-the-art Large
Language Models (LLMs) to extract features in the form of rationales from the
input text, to train a base hate speech classifier, thereby enabling faithful
interpretability by design. Our framework effectively combines the textual
understanding capabilities of LLMs and the discriminative power of
state-of-the-art hate speech classifiers to make these classifiers faithfully
interpretable. Our comprehensive evaluation on a variety of English language
social media hate speech datasets demonstrate: (1) the goodness of the
LLM-extracted rationales, and (2) the surprising retention of detector
performance even after training to ensure interpretability. All code and data
will be made available at https://github.com/AmritaBh/shield.
|
[
-0.29040291905403137,
-0.799742579460144,
0.4461275041103363,
0.11890119314193726,
-0.3924773931503296,
0.26687923073768616,
-0.32838985323905945,
-0.5898247361183167,
0.26559391617774963,
0.6260374188423157,
-0.5604034066200256,
-0.3473462760448456,
-0.8912625908851624,
-0.07614488899707794,
-0.7219821810722351,
1.0176535844802856,
-0.009975766763091087,
-0.02399068884551525,
0.25838297605514526,
-0.23636478185653687,
-0.12735091149806976,
-0.4930794835090637,
-0.6481649279594421,
-0.29176464676856995,
0.6566475033760071,
0.21644452214241028,
0.5977970361709595,
0.6620839834213257,
0.14971333742141724,
0.254160612821579,
-0.1655963659286499,
0.06200917437672615,
-0.6771407723426819,
0.2729758620262146,
-0.3451930582523346,
-0.2857408821582794,
-0.0973513126373291,
0.06731781363487244,
0.4274914860725403,
0.04592042788863182,
0.06211681291460991,
0.1547008603811264,
0.22654090821743011,
0.06270851939916611,
-0.3723706305027008,
0.005656108725816011,
-1.076815128326416,
-0.07488322257995605,
-0.3735677897930145,
-0.13175082206726074,
-0.5309838652610779,
-0.2372993528842926,
-0.2521226406097412,
-0.32486534118652344,
0.04237980395555496,
0.024360446259379387,
0.609873354434967,
0.047814659774303436,
-0.15094658732414246,
-0.5051333904266357,
-0.6995609402656555,
0.91941899061203,
-0.6756259799003601,
0.5205790400505066,
0.28949639201164246,
0.5478280782699585,
-0.14564138650894165,
-0.3773851990699768,
-0.7734952569007874,
-0.18289557099342346,
0.07303586602210999,
-0.04660089686512947,
-0.5262923836708069,
-0.16767440736293793,
0.31544625759124756,
0.2448272407054901,
-0.42810964584350586,
0.5854537487030029,
-0.2879689037799835,
-0.3517865836620331,
0.8367817997932434,
0.036715034395456314,
0.41520941257476807,
-0.3328544795513153,
-0.5420340895652771,
0.4541536569595337,
-0.35914281010627747,
-0.2295198142528534,
0.5313431620597839,
0.38254693150520325,
-0.2652532458305359,
0.4896833300590515,
-0.09109252691268921,
0.34389859437942505,
0.07574060559272766,
-0.21476933360099792,
0.16149014234542847,
0.2938048243522644,
-0.0817127376794815,
-0.02081325463950634,
0.708816409111023,
0.33071622252464294,
0.6130532622337341,
-0.3383990526199341,
-0.1960458755493164,
0.6817448139190674,
0.48267966508865356,
-0.896796464920044,
-0.008011534810066223,
0.2809152603149414,
-0.4571860432624817,
-0.6507847309112549,
-0.42077431082725525,
-1.0238232612609863,
-0.9627882242202759,
-0.2669222950935364,
0.17202436923980713,
-0.32343563437461853,
-0.5459867715835571,
0.05698172748088837,
-0.23325185477733612,
0.25150787830352783,
0.3382223844528198,
-0.578904926776886,
0.07938598841428757,
0.755289614200592,
0.7944943904876709,
-0.49320167303085327,
-0.03299684822559357,
-0.714629054069519,
0.04526923596858978,
0.04099396616220474,
0.6510328650474548,
-0.7197825908660889,
0.02817269042134285,
0.24881473183631897,
0.04444931074976921,
0.215211421251297,
-0.5086004734039307,
0.833034098148346,
-0.7847980856895447,
-0.183202862739563,
0.07641253620386124,
-0.5548577904701233,
-0.18942539393901825,
0.26201802492141724,
-0.46805956959724426,
0.5142253041267395,
-0.04582519829273224,
-0.7221850752830505,
0.2220471054315567,
-0.5140894055366516,
-0.4233366549015045,
0.38841918110847473,
-0.04257866367697716,
-0.5302697420120239,
0.08346755057573318,
0.07764549553394318,
0.5947375297546387,
-0.266377329826355,
0.32099658250808716,
-0.9681841135025024,
-0.04203745350241661,
0.5447674989700317,
-0.5338040590286255,
0.9755218625068665,
0.6106818318367004,
-0.5592861175537109,
0.2441704422235489,
-0.7429078817367554,
-0.20526164770126343,
0.2823253273963928,
-0.001437657279893756,
-0.26200559735298157,
0.22253766655921936,
0.4223288893699646,
0.30065906047821045,
0.017695769667625427,
-0.8380665183067322,
-0.47163259983062744,
-0.27159807085990906,
0.4954974055290222,
1.1383962631225586,
-0.2297106832265854,
0.15545561909675598,
-0.24388836324214935,
0.8644157648086548,
-0.10852604359388351,
0.05590406805276871,
0.3832119107246399,
-0.26392391324043274,
-0.3616757094860077,
-0.6473169922828674,
-0.28544560074806213,
0.43833690881729126,
-0.5968592166900635,
0.2634652554988861,
-0.1390160173177719,
-0.4400263726711273,
-0.3107290267944336,
0.300010621547699,
0.25202590227127075,
0.430381178855896,
0.3680717647075653,
0.09784328192472458,
-0.9571746587753296,
-0.8866714835166931,
-0.514133632183075,
-0.21501635015010834,
-0.04382862150669098,
0.1470104604959488,
0.4791565537452698,
-0.31842923164367676,
0.8885813355445862,
-0.2737327516078949,
0.028852691873908043,
-0.5869190692901611,
0.028983257710933685,
-0.07122684270143509,
-0.042555827647447586,
0.31983110308647156,
-0.9558092355728149,
-0.49331480264663696,
-0.09276298433542252,
-0.7034502029418945,
-0.6982771158218384,
-0.03456701338291168,
-0.33160150051116943,
-0.04493087902665138,
0.5005990862846375,
-0.29644301533699036,
0.40806740522384644,
0.5551106333732605,
-0.3753378093242645,
0.6893672943115234,
0.798937201499939,
-0.03204790875315666,
-1.0681157112121582,
-0.1086985394358635,
0.29875555634498596,
-0.42542126774787903,
-0.7400096654891968,
0.019691476598381996,
-0.1819625198841095,
0.010166807100176811,
-0.5667469501495361,
0.6275573372840881,
-0.057323064655065536,
0.201867938041687,
-0.5314655303955078,
0.29191404581069946,
-0.11164490878582001,
0.2088514268398285,
-0.028673063963651657,
0.3405798375606537,
0.19010551273822784,
-0.3344007134437561,
0.34500375390052795,
0.1321125626564026,
-0.3830040395259857,
0.8552652597427368,
-0.4151720702648163,
-0.13886594772338867,
-0.13601858913898468,
0.21446257829666138,
-0.8493257761001587,
-0.2577245533466339,
0.5855239629745483,
-0.4726325571537018,
-0.08015090972185135,
-0.5014817714691162,
-0.3143406808376312,
-0.2706716060638428,
-0.255787193775177,
0.25426921248435974,
0.3692898452281952,
-0.69261234998703,
0.6387458443641663,
0.8501220941543579,
-0.05382495000958443,
-0.516935408115387,
-0.5378982424736023,
-0.01504298485815525,
-0.662214457988739,
-0.4448981285095215,
0.1999085396528244,
-0.0928259864449501,
-0.5186958909034729,
-0.027338797226548195,
0.04759185016155243,
-0.12103812396526337,
0.2547553777694702,
0.5258854031562805,
0.13717028498649597,
-0.04718531295657158,
0.11993693560361862,
-0.038557905703783035,
0.1531101018190384,
0.38556912541389465,
-0.12258048355579376,
0.6284972429275513,
0.009506472386419773,
-0.008410181850194931,
-0.3785536587238312,
0.2625117301940918,
0.8873645663261414,
-0.05742465332150459,
0.696438729763031,
0.7725646495819092,
-0.5268441438674927,
-0.6135175824165344,
-0.5958423018455505,
-0.012023868039250374,
-0.4428435266017914,
0.3849559724330902,
-0.1743580847978592,
-1.1904938220977783,
0.5845909714698792,
0.20112645626068115,
0.11383046954870224,
0.3695191442966461,
0.7266680002212524,
-0.01055002212524414,
0.9526829123497009,
0.2948075830936432,
-0.14311657845973969,
0.5469865202903748,
0.37864750623703003,
0.21510829031467438,
-0.5180106163024902,
0.013378690928220749,
-0.49013254046440125,
-0.01565460115671158,
-0.34381622076034546,
-0.29587769508361816,
0.09128972142934799,
-0.08043095469474792,
-0.21448108553886414,
0.22403834760189056,
-0.4305647611618042,
0.4832938015460968,
-0.20892959833145142,
0.11967536062002182,
0.05955582484602928,
0.4466533660888672,
0.22564180195331573,
-0.20064707100391388,
-0.2523514926433563,
-0.5537102818489075,
0.8671078681945801,
0.8363533020019531,
0.6517090201377869,
0.18503959476947784,
0.3835758566856384,
0.497627317905426,
0.7520440220832825,
-1.083742618560791,
0.45735499262809753,
-0.29457032680511475,
-0.8066998720169067,
-0.130879208445549,
-0.5165214538574219,
-0.7696511149406433,
0.35026103258132935,
-0.405261754989624,
-0.8556545972824097,
-0.1639319211244583,
0.13220945000648499,
-0.04396847262978554,
0.5782405734062195,
-0.44042107462882996,
0.9092341065406799,
-0.2591760456562042,
-0.4565463364124298,
-0.42000991106033325,
-0.05584951117634773,
0.4902915060520172,
-0.2546140253543854,
0.6811823844909668,
-0.21184810996055603,
0.21526360511779785,
0.9841955900192261,
-0.18723516166210175,
1.082503080368042,
-0.23834864795207977,
-0.26057377457618713,
0.16329185664653778,
0.005488671362400055,
0.3508744537830353,
-0.23321868479251862,
-0.26200997829437256,
0.39413467049598694,
-0.2542630732059479,
-0.23855511844158173,
-0.47815027832984924,
0.5359836220741272,
-0.45713675022125244,
-0.4008950889110565,
-0.12881188094615936,
-0.6433244943618774,
-0.03763571009039879,
0.20225879549980164,
-0.012717047706246376,
0.3781544268131256,
-0.24308255314826965,
0.1789335459470749,
0.6408814787864685,
-0.35397055745124817,
0.020330281928181648,
0.4748583734035492,
-0.5474626421928406,
-0.3828343451023102,
0.9111098647117615,
0.20499290525913239,
0.19097508490085602,
0.10678772628307343,
0.3863193988800049,
-0.38633421063423157,
-0.7884266376495361,
-0.5584251880645752,
0.2610160708427429,
-0.678174614906311,
-0.098813995718956,
-0.8041371703147888,
-0.2144060581922531,
-0.2896699905395508,
-0.29613980650901794,
-0.14626544713974,
-0.15913131833076477,
-0.046252183616161346,
0.02260352298617363,
0.3709946572780609,
0.7900182008743286,
-0.18960006535053253,
0.5377258658409119,
-0.4370970129966736,
0.5393574833869934,
0.0530855692923069,
0.2699466645717621,
-0.001330305472947657,
-1.0794121026992798,
-0.2179861217737198,
0.11150627583265305,
-0.09641909599304199,
-1.1572911739349365,
0.38000866770744324,
-0.4019116461277008,
0.47164690494537354,
0.4116020202636719,
0.1316220909357071,
0.44574326276779175,
-0.43654245138168335,
0.26253998279571533,
0.23239666223526,
-0.8662620782852173,
0.4359988272190094,
-0.3832893967628479,
-0.11193858832120895,
0.3596791625022888,
0.6511651873588562,
-0.5019452571868896,
-0.6817978620529175,
-0.5036084055900574,
-0.5936009287834167,
0.5931953191757202,
0.10339684039354324,
0.02709735371172428,
-0.011868088506162167,
0.20470348000526428,
0.1000324934720993,
0.07449138909578323,
-1.1356902122497559,
-0.10616623610258102,
-0.21939724683761597,
-0.4581620693206787,
0.02888564206659794,
-0.6026299595832825,
-0.14795419573783875,
0.033617082983255386,
0.850581705570221,
0.10253217816352844,
-0.024322979152202606,
-0.4357585906982422,
-0.45987826585769653,
0.006106877233833075,
0.5081461668014526,
0.34939974546432495,
0.6594633460044861,
-0.10134828835725784,
0.222326397895813,
0.08546921610832214,
-0.4617968499660492,
0.05506764352321625,
0.152067169547081,
-0.24710488319396973,
-0.014118267223238945,
0.2639358639717102,
0.6406587958335876,
0.014654120430350304,
-0.6522235870361328,
0.6078131794929504,
0.03429189696907997,
-0.11113161593675613,
-0.6462876200675964,
-0.09390144795179367,
0.02791217342019081,
0.3568379282951355,
0.11859739571809769,
-0.2432052344083786,
0.10783054679632187,
-0.36917877197265625,
0.4410471022129059,
0.6479892730712891,
-0.49893811345100403,
-0.3068958818912506,
0.6089596748352051,
0.09538423269987106,
-0.34841129183769226,
0.07971499860286713,
-0.2785898447036743,
-0.9042381048202515,
0.33270499110221863,
0.6534397602081299,
0.922134280204773,
-0.3013738989830017,
0.5033487677574158,
0.29318633675575256,
0.4163637161254883,
0.37973538041114807,
-0.015988951548933983,
0.12648679316043854,
-0.9881453514099121,
-0.5016362071037292,
-1.056447982788086,
-0.30765849351882935,
0.715561032295227,
-0.567535400390625,
0.2627589702606201,
-0.7098666429519653,
0.27406197786331177,
0.5461839437484741,
-0.30072006583213806,
-0.3510591387748718,
0.045189470052719116,
0.626319408416748,
0.6819861531257629,
-1.0870616436004639,
0.6060487031936646,
0.43681520223617554,
-0.13328976929187775,
-0.5754592418670654,
-0.1079147607088089,
0.3033600151538849,
-0.9877838492393494,
0.5270734429359436,
0.4199712872505188,
-0.45071032643318176,
-0.26786646246910095,
-0.9064773917198181,
-0.28384941816329956,
0.30155128240585327,
0.3488777279853821,
-0.44769009947776794,
0.4132850766181946,
0.2549201250076294,
0.558413565158844,
-0.5536642074584961,
0.16982530057430267,
0.42646723985671997,
0.2942342162132263,
0.021083936095237732,
-0.4746873378753662,
0.3470589518547058,
-0.17999213933944702,
-0.2410399466753006,
0.05369811877608299,
-0.24972417950630188,
0.40560266375541687,
0.39157211780548096,
-0.38383498787879944,
-0.3447730839252472,
0.551034688949585,
0.18597625195980072,
0.5073513388633728,
0.8833599090576172,
0.4117658734321594,
0.5835403203964233,
0.26648256182670593,
0.7152669429779053,
-0.0036790776066482067,
0.09453608840703964,
0.9188300371170044,
-0.19054651260375977,
0.8559966683387756,
0.14630012214183807,
-0.03061847761273384,
0.5004708766937256,
0.20722080767154694,
-0.04696013033390045,
0.10706968605518341,
0.5383591055870056,
-0.606441080570221,
-0.5388777256011963,
-0.4217252731323242,
0.07755936682224274,
0.6372113823890686,
0.6145411729812622,
-0.497062623500824,
-0.29178085923194885,
0.21491125226020813,
0.38186267018318176,
0.4460170567035675,
-0.5253028869628906,
0.41367796063423157,
0.11711215227842331,
-0.28966355323791504,
0.640984296798706,
0.14507271349430084,
0.939001202583313,
-0.5077361464500427,
0.024834219366312027,
0.2657218277454376,
0.21653325855731964,
-0.47027960419654846,
-0.7236724495887756,
0.48160985112190247,
0.4491497576236725,
-0.1393730640411377,
-0.3569703698158264,
0.894498348236084,
-0.33921319246292114,
-0.3134131133556366,
0.5370430946350098,
0.24212944507598877,
0.24914659559726715,
-0.2562183141708374,
-0.927520751953125,
0.5578392744064331,
0.2224331945180893,
-0.021453632041811943,
0.3144524395465851,
0.24021311104297638,
-0.05808349326252937,
0.6834580898284912,
0.6638690829277039,
0.08326578140258789,
-0.056361857801675797,
0.09853031486272812,
0.8739319443702698,
-0.42254725098609924,
-0.39493682980537415,
-1.206510066986084,
0.4340612590312958,
-0.3420007526874542,
-0.08062124997377396,
0.7352845072746277,
0.5226839184761047,
0.7878581881523132,
0.2656250596046448,
1.0524297952651978,
-0.12098128348588943,
0.9859364032745361,
-0.41454389691352844,
0.7160663604736328,
-0.42759060859680176,
0.2199568748474121,
-0.41124096512794495,
-0.6733318567276001,
-0.2925260663032532,
0.7888780236244202,
-0.645470142364502,
-0.3146142065525055,
0.33999037742614746,
0.9441200494766235,
-0.24412141740322113,
0.2443763017654419,
0.3444531559944153,
0.6912384629249573,
0.6337794065475464,
0.1937309354543686,
1.0724279880523682,
-0.00022572236775886267,
0.7712530493736267,
-0.08229874074459076,
-0.4598204791545868,
-0.21698592603206635,
-0.7272886633872986,
-1.0798380374908447,
-0.3908144235610962,
-0.3748530447483063,
-0.9011961817741394,
0.005332943517714739,
0.8738729357719421,
0.40282168984413147,
-0.8321765661239624,
-0.24082313477993011,
0.16331660747528076,
0.37203940749168396,
0.1368200182914734,
-0.29829132556915283,
0.04398699104785919,
-0.17315693199634552,
-0.6579700112342834,
0.3460516929626465,
0.13589993119239807,
-0.28697121143341064,
-0.18550732731819153,
-0.14979316294193268,
-0.16991139948368073,
0.10844075679779053,
0.9083585143089294,
0.44523102045059204,
-0.8135737180709839,
-0.5290841460227966,
-0.3247455358505249,
0.0677795559167862,
-0.15603545308113098,
0.5484396815299988,
-0.45010650157928467,
0.302975058555603,
0.16350889205932617,
0.903240978717804,
0.43822577595710754,
-0.009740415029227734,
0.22342605888843536,
-0.25469034910202026,
-0.003541090991348028,
0.2984767258167267,
0.31599318981170654,
0.247928649187088,
-0.16589684784412384,
0.31463298201560974,
0.2820366322994232,
-0.3708762228488922,
-1.1018091440200806,
0.6054407358169556,
-1.1237316131591797,
-0.3053382635116577,
1.5041954517364502,
-0.13396954536437988,
-0.2289612740278244,
-0.510042130947113,
-0.09989456087350845,
0.309096097946167,
-0.3144993484020233,
0.666504979133606,
0.6899632811546326,
0.2558477818965912,
-0.17698319256305695,
-0.611628532409668,
0.397799551486969,
0.29985660314559937,
-0.6793763637542725,
0.38637176156044006,
0.7698715925216675,
0.39099448919296265,
0.02208065241575241,
0.5568621754646301,
-0.13470862805843353,
0.12631960213184357,
-0.13614527881145477,
0.12208297103643417,
0.06789994239807129,
-0.1554577499628067,
-0.4425009787082672,
0.33457472920417786,
-0.06634452939033508,
0.02296283468604088
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.12402v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.12402v1
|
An Empirical Study of Speech Language Models for Prompt-Conditioned Speech Synthesis
| 2024-03-19T03:22:28 | 2024-03-19T03:22:28 |
Yifan Peng, Ilia Kulikov, Yilin Yang, Sravya Popuri, Hui Lu, Changhan Wang, Hongyu Gong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Speech language models (LMs) are promising for high-quality speech synthesis
through in-context learning. A typical speech LM takes discrete semantic units
as content and a short utterance as prompt, and synthesizes speech which
preserves the content's semantics but mimics the prompt's style. However, there
is no systematic understanding on how the synthesized audio is controlled by
the prompt and content. In this work, we conduct an empirical study of the
widely used autoregressive (AR) and non-autoregressive (NAR) speech LMs and
provide insights into the prompt design and content semantic units. Our
analysis reveals that heterogeneous and nonstationary prompts hurt the audio
quality in contrast to the previous finding that longer prompts always lead to
better synthesis. Moreover, we find that the speaker style of the synthesized
audio is also affected by the content in addition to the prompt. We further
show that semantic units carry rich acoustic information such as pitch, tempo,
volume and speech emphasis, which might be leaked from the content to the
synthesized audio.
|
[
-0.5857473611831665,
-1.063726544380188,
0.6129414439201355,
0.2674916982650757,
0.06482075154781342,
-0.043564651161432266,
-0.2383565604686737,
-0.19312584400177002,
0.10014478862285614,
0.5007720589637756,
-0.6933098435401917,
-0.4460715055465698,
-0.07443726807832718,
0.26078447699546814,
-0.4569183886051178,
0.8767102956771851,
0.2750101685523987,
0.1515982747077942,
-0.12053029239177704,
-0.07904529571533203,
-0.9303812384605408,
-0.6493397355079651,
-0.46375519037246704,
-0.15562652051448822,
0.49309873580932617,
0.3389737010002136,
0.6743360757827759,
0.5431734323501587,
-0.0009261243394576013,
0.28486543893814087,
-0.18675273656845093,
-0.3085881471633911,
-0.19909335672855377,
0.5907778143882751,
-0.238040030002594,
-0.1140848770737648,
-0.3492775559425354,
0.23794758319854736,
0.9217534065246582,
0.9504757523536682,
-0.201796293258667,
-0.012306569144129753,
0.27109214663505554,
0.3936569094657898,
-0.42609867453575134,
0.08469785749912262,
-0.6111441254615784,
0.060956165194511414,
0.23072952032089233,
-0.4202340841293335,
-0.7431591749191284,
-0.38795122504234314,
0.19385705888271332,
-0.49941423535346985,
0.326526403427124,
0.17176519334316254,
0.46780961751937866,
0.503096878528595,
-0.2552821636199951,
-0.5417808294296265,
-0.9323203563690186,
0.7761824727058411,
-0.8969945907592773,
0.5978946089744568,
0.3701678216457367,
0.3533431887626648,
-0.4323745369911194,
-0.6001250743865967,
-0.481974720954895,
-0.4978993833065033,
-0.1448582410812378,
-0.04779094457626343,
-0.09906607121229172,
0.19432730972766876,
0.15473367273807526,
0.19498573243618011,
-0.6515306234359741,
0.2990656793117523,
-0.17649738490581512,
-0.498691588640213,
0.5053326487541199,
0.41450923681259155,
0.6097436547279358,
-0.3972034156322479,
-0.5403497219085693,
-0.3310047686100006,
-0.6753663420677185,
0.3079662322998047,
0.4345730245113373,
0.685773491859436,
-0.1129608005285263,
0.5060263276100159,
-0.02719835191965103,
0.9709545969963074,
0.017361445352435112,
-0.46866342425346375,
0.15936745703220367,
-0.6008673906326294,
-0.1506502479314804,
0.5358985066413879,
0.8659585118293762,
0.09901929646730423,
-0.1749398410320282,
-0.1403721123933792,
-0.47244444489479065,
-0.08871175348758698,
0.05713614448904991,
-0.7425452470779419,
-0.04110874980688095,
0.08080153912305832,
-0.45473217964172363,
0.10596956312656403,
-0.25097113847732544,
-0.43419939279556274,
-0.04040076956152916,
-0.8104330897331238,
0.6003310084342957,
-0.5564340949058533,
-0.05693725869059563,
-0.21952372789382935,
-0.16549982130527496,
0.19686053693294525,
0.20382848381996155,
-0.8082609176635742,
0.22940729558467865,
0.40845057368278503,
0.6551752090454102,
-0.43507692217826843,
-0.3502713143825531,
-0.6966041326522827,
-0.18401652574539185,
-0.5716582536697388,
0.6716468334197998,
-0.4837716519832611,
-0.7940837144851685,
-0.12301843613386154,
0.07808732986450195,
-0.06943931430578232,
-0.44907084107398987,
0.403543084859848,
-0.38804563879966736,
0.4296434819698334,
-0.2702436149120331,
-0.663492739200592,
0.06242210045456886,
-0.3507704436779022,
-0.7798104286193848,
0.5964422225952148,
0.058278828859329224,
-0.1609848141670227,
0.2636162340641022,
-0.2715081572532654,
-0.44333842396736145,
-0.24678196012973785,
-0.1938522458076477,
0.020524920895695686,
0.18503527343273163,
-0.032977186143398285,
0.29779618978500366,
-0.23584549129009247,
0.42812371253967285,
-0.00602641049772501,
-0.09789372980594635,
0.86872398853302,
-0.6273739337921143,
0.39163336157798767,
0.6617499589920044,
-0.015844065696001053,
0.23369194567203522,
-0.9247286319732666,
-0.015099044889211655,
-0.22942303121089935,
-0.22809424996376038,
-0.23912784457206726,
-0.13022629916667938,
0.071352019906044,
0.34818559885025024,
-0.11857860535383224,
-0.4624835252761841,
-0.22995777428150177,
-0.35694313049316406,
0.6054495573043823,
0.480783611536026,
0.48901650309562683,
0.7730886936187744,
-0.32180848717689514,
0.4141724705696106,
-0.2215002477169037,
-0.04076136648654938,
-0.5297021269798279,
-0.44395968317985535,
-0.3663526177406311,
-0.1801435500383377,
0.2682594060897827,
0.3978542685508728,
-0.5573031306266785,
0.19136522710323334,
0.2792893350124359,
-0.4300335645675659,
-0.2944659888744354,
-0.2321198582649231,
0.3540109097957611,
0.9142166972160339,
0.3776352107524872,
-0.14283554255962372,
-0.36349037289619446,
-0.8841935396194458,
-0.20594535768032074,
-0.2969660758972168,
-0.20859338343143463,
0.3678693175315857,
-0.06893129646778107,
0.06516963243484497,
1.3190561532974243,
-0.08175618946552277,
-0.04010734707117081,
-0.06685269623994827,
0.199176624417305,
0.3836022615432739,
0.695602297782898,
0.5557085275650024,
-0.44096776843070984,
-0.24044470489025116,
-0.5710598826408386,
-0.46346330642700195,
-0.5135301947593689,
-0.23665428161621094,
0.05784739926457405,
0.3102893531322479,
0.7026817798614502,
-0.593829870223999,
0.2761342227458954,
0.4444046914577484,
-0.3834846019744873,
0.5316418409347534,
-0.23323829472064972,
0.21749433875083923,
-0.7346151471138,
-0.0029496322385966778,
-0.16945795714855194,
0.06322512030601501,
-0.7902924418449402,
-0.39591002464294434,
-0.14801125228405,
-0.5367501974105835,
-0.7599728107452393,
0.5962511301040649,
-0.41265448927879333,
-0.36202824115753174,
-0.40751340985298157,
0.14866165816783905,
0.2387637346982956,
0.4467780590057373,
0.2681195139884949,
1.0309182405471802,
0.2911914885044098,
-0.9804143905639648,
0.19304440915584564,
0.10954194515943527,
-0.46795493364334106,
0.4183119237422943,
-1.0661121606826782,
0.11822155863046646,
-0.16582487523555756,
0.22102931141853333,
-1.2165820598602295,
-0.23773668706417084,
-0.03249548003077507,
-0.6263132095336914,
0.3982139229774475,
-0.012836226262152195,
-0.3043413758277893,
0.3691297769546509,
0.26488620042800903,
0.5554572939872742,
0.8293917775154114,
-0.3153551518917084,
0.5321717858314514,
0.3035614490509033,
-0.478118360042572,
-0.10587486624717712,
-0.7867493033409119,
-0.006731264293193817,
-0.22634442150592804,
-0.4096028506755829,
0.45200857520103455,
-0.2648373246192932,
-0.4547279477119446,
0.10963661968708038,
0.08779343217611313,
0.06063678488135338,
0.08172563463449478,
0.3627096712589264,
0.27663010358810425,
-0.3165832459926605,
0.23285400867462158,
0.09482492506504059,
-0.08453452587127686,
0.31896430253982544,
-0.08965674042701721,
0.525168776512146,
0.09155548363924026,
-0.43320685625076294,
-0.7026907801628113,
0.6014538407325745,
0.4768236577510834,
-0.1236158162355423,
0.6289910674095154,
0.30317190289497375,
-0.080024853348732,
-0.3876529932022095,
-0.2914316952228546,
-0.5356736779212952,
-0.4385869801044464,
0.04954148083925247,
-0.39612528681755066,
-0.7792372107505798,
0.5978044271469116,
0.34338873624801636,
-0.015023062005639076,
0.4493391215801239,
0.8035755753517151,
0.0783899575471878,
1.02744722366333,
0.14112085103988647,
0.17215946316719055,
0.6229619979858398,
0.030792728066444397,
-0.04966704174876213,
-0.6928702592849731,
-0.3377704322338104,
-0.7409402132034302,
-0.03010079823434353,
-0.5917173624038696,
-0.14519062638282776,
0.5548251271247864,
-0.17625045776367188,
-0.24155010282993317,
0.1534147709608078,
-0.40229228138923645,
0.20638053119182587,
0.582001268863678,
-0.17481441795825958,
-0.04990941286087036,
-0.04610229656100273,
-0.1319229006767273,
-0.08229131251573563,
-0.8155253529548645,
-0.4379332959651947,
0.5902901291847229,
0.40004488825798035,
0.9080473184585571,
0.11415355652570724,
0.5195157527923584,
0.39052775502204895,
-0.4401625394821167,
-0.8917207717895508,
0.3410884141921997,
0.21107853949069977,
-0.4491102695465088,
-0.3656124472618103,
-0.40276357531547546,
-0.935826301574707,
0.18870960175991058,
-0.10243961215019226,
-0.37817853689193726,
0.4318026006221771,
0.09869527071714401,
-0.5110291242599487,
-0.1157289445400238,
-0.6786670088768005,
0.54449462890625,
-0.0025873719714581966,
-0.3221275806427002,
0.09644667059183121,
-0.846366286277771,
0.04680795222520828,
0.18132373690605164,
0.4593050479888916,
-0.22330215573310852,
0.12121199071407318,
0.5688558220863342,
-0.48302480578422546,
0.74995356798172,
-0.21260081231594086,
-0.2239556610584259,
0.5601189136505127,
0.36950966715812683,
0.27347368001937866,
0.18113212287425995,
-0.09555300325155258,
-0.12439218908548355,
-0.059295136481523514,
-0.18968968093395233,
-0.7052022218704224,
0.7888808250427246,
-0.8292701244354248,
-0.6680477857589722,
-0.2625855505466461,
-0.6090075969696045,
-0.42264506220817566,
-0.11774497479200363,
0.39004775881767273,
1.0498861074447632,
-0.4117950201034546,
0.12492997944355011,
0.8845835328102112,
-0.5254256725311279,
0.7461321949958801,
0.5601876378059387,
-0.03756183013319969,
-0.46626099944114685,
0.7557461261749268,
0.1373445689678192,
0.7922428846359253,
0.15668444335460663,
0.2792621850967407,
-0.4193805754184723,
-0.5260098576545715,
-0.643129289150238,
0.017638858407735825,
-0.9904287457466125,
0.07041668146848679,
-0.5560702085494995,
-0.24552951753139496,
-0.6856932044029236,
0.09483395516872406,
-0.44580090045928955,
-0.5817703604698181,
-0.5412178039550781,
0.033001985400915146,
0.3725205957889557,
0.658566415309906,
-0.1501011699438095,
0.1341014951467514,
-0.8419815301895142,
0.17015348374843597,
0.34086304903030396,
-0.03992104530334473,
-0.013040534220635891,
-0.7426566481590271,
0.08557368814945221,
0.15844477713108063,
0.2575364112854004,
-1.0063210725784302,
0.5826600193977356,
0.2772957980632782,
0.8381310701370239,
0.02691211737692356,
0.18683530390262604,
0.11266803741455078,
-0.706325113773346,
1.2870310544967651,
0.0738694816827774,
-0.8734899759292603,
0.5736181139945984,
-0.23655493557453156,
0.5935711860656738,
0.36993592977523804,
0.09520090371370316,
-0.578384280204773,
-0.3658173680305481,
-0.362101674079895,
-0.9163668155670166,
0.6670215129852295,
0.22473493218421936,
0.2574004828929901,
-0.20092779397964478,
0.2255803942680359,
0.31478142738342285,
0.14201608300209045,
-0.19485892355442047,
-0.4156481921672821,
-0.6747056245803833,
0.059047069400548935,
-0.1985008716583252,
-0.3602481484413147,
0.06206021085381508,
0.027619002386927605,
0.6857507228851318,
0.22697339951992035,
0.24801434576511383,
0.47036847472190857,
-0.06257038563489914,
0.13385599851608276,
0.6126660108566284,
0.8784747123718262,
0.4137943387031555,
-0.23707155883312225,
0.2558823823928833,
-0.07997369021177292,
-0.1272112876176834,
0.43942636251449585,
-0.24719054996967316,
-0.2188330739736557,
0.41703924536705017,
0.45471784472465515,
1.2964458465576172,
0.12956498563289642,
-0.43437570333480835,
0.21212826669216156,
-0.18569378554821014,
0.04389354586601257,
-0.29500845074653625,
0.2462872713804245,
-0.20698659121990204,
-0.07949291169643402,
0.3705386519432068,
-0.1305733472108841,
0.4344896674156189,
-0.8046674132347107,
0.12364307790994644,
0.2513205111026764,
-0.4636829197406769,
-0.38760805130004883,
0.7062596082687378,
0.1222376674413681,
-0.5125336647033691,
0.4868077337741852,
-0.07460128515958786,
-0.1575193554162979,
0.5585324168205261,
0.7302356362342834,
0.754223644733429,
-0.5152119398117065,
0.024702640250325203,
0.3632822334766388,
-0.06609424203634262,
0.19466575980186462,
0.10177189856767654,
-0.26830995082855225,
-0.4873385727405548,
-0.3469432592391968,
-0.6837234497070312,
-0.5052892565727234,
0.08101607859134674,
-0.784125566482544,
0.047863755375146866,
-0.39838358759880066,
-0.260977178812027,
0.003828264307230711,
-0.5359676480293274,
-0.5191205143928528,
0.3441607356071472,
0.10164175182580948,
0.6174049377441406,
-0.7959706783294678,
0.7114880681037903,
0.48886269330978394,
-0.38155606389045715,
-1.2037572860717773,
-0.3208485245704651,
-0.016042599454522133,
-0.4556460976600647,
0.6516854166984558,
-0.18252545595169067,
-0.2121124267578125,
0.05434858053922653,
-0.400887668132782,
-1.0017529726028442,
0.6472529768943787,
0.2890850305557251,
-0.37162813544273376,
-0.016398577019572258,
0.3414310812950134,
0.5309975743293762,
-0.49329298734664917,
0.13434569537639618,
0.4567511975765228,
0.2733936607837677,
0.3864578604698181,
-1.0820655822753906,
-0.044158075004816055,
-0.14239902794361115,
0.34674501419067383,
-0.03393130004405975,
-0.22595931589603424,
1.2233097553253174,
0.0694475844502449,
-0.34664061665534973,
0.13088901340961456,
0.7384653687477112,
0.30824777483940125,
0.3443411588668823,
0.45308706164360046,
0.08426707983016968,
0.501297116279602,
0.07589387148618698,
1.0370733737945557,
-0.4896791875362396,
-0.009547006338834763,
1.1193732023239136,
-0.2633472979068756,
0.50691157579422,
0.5944852232933044,
0.08220653235912323,
0.5987124443054199,
0.7424523830413818,
0.3991227149963379,
0.8581627607345581,
0.13190647959709167,
-0.26857805252075195,
-0.1301112323999405,
-0.4475853145122528,
-0.626086413860321,
0.32918035984039307,
0.5151078104972839,
-0.5148932933807373,
-0.025640463456511497,
0.5043472647666931,
-0.05389334633946419,
0.057980045676231384,
-0.2963985800743103,
1.0816259384155273,
0.19867771863937378,
-0.949587881565094,
0.8797390460968018,
-0.10161984711885452,
0.21101818978786469,
-0.51088947057724,
0.1137453094124794,
-0.16317766904830933,
-0.3188014030456543,
-0.18049484491348267,
-0.6560054421424866,
0.23426376283168793,
-0.19680005311965942,
-0.30732962489128113,
-0.3148967921733856,
0.6297461986541748,
-0.5785820484161377,
-0.077558234333992,
-0.049193765968084335,
0.5221331715583801,
0.1242687776684761,
0.13133081793785095,
-0.31204408407211304,
0.1986244171857834,
-0.28841161727905273,
-0.4177955985069275,
0.3728163540363312,
0.5386368036270142,
0.013196492567658424,
0.3931358754634857,
0.8155784010887146,
0.11724159866571426,
0.12657058238983154,
0.2238740473985672,
0.59666907787323,
-0.6565290689468384,
-0.7113643288612366,
-0.8626388311386108,
0.27716144919395447,
0.3823448121547699,
-0.11497144401073456,
0.8635968565940857,
0.2665669918060303,
0.5487180352210999,
-0.08623367547988892,
0.7037568688392639,
0.2034078985452652,
0.41386154294013977,
-1.0593936443328857,
0.6108571887016296,
-0.23868520557880402,
0.3153102695941925,
-0.2681618928909302,
-1.0352213382720947,
0.1518150418996811,
0.2625819146633148,
-0.020523540675640106,
-0.10805254429578781,
0.5541784167289734,
0.7695829272270203,
0.2642538845539093,
0.16849541664123535,
0.38874778151512146,
0.04362335801124573,
0.3410337269306183,
0.22089239954948425,
1.1325328350067139,
-0.03427228704094887,
0.07939402014017105,
-0.3115948736667633,
0.005474964622408152,
-0.007769455201923847,
-0.8491750955581665,
-0.6541867256164551,
-0.888433039188385,
-0.2539371848106384,
-0.4165596663951874,
-0.14065074920654297,
1.2421612739562988,
0.596399188041687,
-0.7884200811386108,
-0.35677772760391235,
-0.046110399067401886,
0.10116328299045563,
0.16165880858898163,
-0.24655702710151672,
0.3577284514904022,
-0.5732821226119995,
-0.6277107000350952,
0.9344186782836914,
0.1076434999704361,
0.38888734579086304,
-0.3679165542125702,
-0.14432445168495178,
0.2180306613445282,
0.4127453565597534,
0.6257584691047668,
0.2706088423728943,
-0.9188127517700195,
-0.22494596242904663,
0.2351575493812561,
-0.2617815434932709,
0.07447849959135056,
0.9373711347579956,
-0.9960842728614807,
0.4544079005718231,
0.8535187840461731,
0.3187936246395111,
0.017890678718686104,
-0.06375447660684586,
0.7296240925788879,
-0.7880088090896606,
0.34284234046936035,
0.3568468987941742,
0.4667049050331116,
0.308297336101532,
-0.18513399362564087,
0.022769849747419357,
0.1242457702755928,
-0.6930261254310608,
-0.8658459186553955,
0.3601525127887726,
-0.997941255569458,
-0.4939444065093994,
1.4492616653442383,
0.05266265943646431,
-0.31540146470069885,
-0.0008735712035559118,
-0.33333298563957214,
0.4240300953388214,
-0.7576379179954529,
0.2468307763338089,
0.6061342358589172,
-0.34010055661201477,
-0.02805711142718792,
-0.5721433758735657,
0.7579948902130127,
0.3984236419200897,
-0.35313040018081665,
-0.09530758112668991,
0.8658318519592285,
0.2796202003955841,
0.05622382089495659,
0.38909104466438293,
-0.11203539371490479,
0.3075862526893616,
-0.0072328136302530766,
0.0076720076613128185,
-0.17325924336910248,
-0.39439091086387634,
-0.6756899356842041,
0.17917345464229584,
0.22538498044013977,
0.001020680065266788
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.12393v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.12393v1
|
Dr3: Ask Large Language Models Not to Give Off-Topic Answers in Open Domain Multi-Hop Question Answering
| 2024-03-19T03:00:03 | 2024-03-19T03:00:03 |
Yuan Gao, Yiheng Zhu, Yuanbin Cao, Yinzhi Zhou, Zhen Wu, Yujie Chen, Shenglan Wu, Haoyuan Hu, Xinyu Dai
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Open Domain Multi-Hop Question Answering (ODMHQA) plays a crucial role in
Natural Language Processing (NLP) by aiming to answer complex questions through
multi-step reasoning over retrieved information from external knowledge
sources. Recently, Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable
performance in solving ODMHQA owing to their capabilities including planning,
reasoning, and utilizing tools. However, LLMs may generate off-topic answers
when attempting to solve ODMHQA, namely the generated answers are irrelevant to
the original questions. This issue of off-topic answers accounts for
approximately one-third of incorrect answers, yet remains underexplored despite
its significance. To alleviate this issue, we propose the
Discriminate->Re-Compose->Re- Solve->Re-Decompose (Dr3) mechanism.
Specifically, the Discriminator leverages the intrinsic capabilities of LLMs to
judge whether the generated answers are off-topic. In cases where an off-topic
answer is detected, the Corrector performs step-wise revisions along the
reversed reasoning chain (Re-Compose->Re-Solve->Re-Decompose) until the final
answer becomes on-topic. Experimental results on the HotpotQA and
2WikiMultiHopQA datasets demonstrate that our Dr3 mechanism considerably
reduces the occurrence of off-topic answers in ODMHQA by nearly 13%, improving
the performance in Exact Match (EM) by nearly 3% compared to the baseline
method without the Dr3 mechanism.
|
[
-0.6832166314125061,
-1.1269091367721558,
0.7548547387123108,
-0.2737090587615967,
-0.1590815633535385,
0.013465152122080326,
0.05022522434592247,
-0.3095206618309021,
-0.14679941534996033,
0.7391995787620544,
-0.684613049030304,
-0.16432960331439972,
-0.4103134870529175,
0.17382609844207764,
-0.04168037697672844,
0.8221865892410278,
-0.3788638114929199,
-0.3206741511821747,
-0.31394386291503906,
-0.307005912065506,
-0.3745720684528351,
-0.4203607141971588,
-0.7696358561515808,
-0.003451647236943245,
0.5184215903282166,
0.5682200193405151,
0.6744412183761597,
0.6944859027862549,
0.4547055661678314,
0.18352580070495605,
-0.20615743100643158,
0.3377344310283661,
-0.5445690155029297,
0.30741798877716064,
-0.1509362906217575,
-0.5774206519126892,
-0.7189620137214661,
-0.03497571870684624,
0.3939339518547058,
0.7921020984649658,
-0.3312292695045471,
0.292108416557312,
-0.18481555581092834,
0.8663049340248108,
-0.7190306186676025,
-0.04250061884522438,
-0.6714014410972595,
-0.0655122920870781,
-0.421686589717865,
-0.4804963767528534,
-0.45851436257362366,
-0.283963680267334,
0.0019460923504084349,
-0.6045345067977905,
0.43116262555122375,
0.015611100010573864,
0.5481245517730713,
0.4173116087913513,
-0.30910828709602356,
-0.07491836696863174,
-0.806331217288971,
0.6987587213516235,
-0.7134054899215698,
0.3032967150211334,
0.5930249094963074,
0.235732302069664,
-0.1614341288805008,
-0.3991342782974243,
-0.7469027042388916,
0.21552123129367828,
0.09910877794027328,
0.06445932388305664,
-0.28486472368240356,
-0.03449076786637306,
0.3261469900608063,
0.24035954475402832,
-0.8462600111961365,
0.1220371425151825,
-0.2949764132499695,
-0.132480651140213,
0.38692548871040344,
0.20462746918201447,
0.0706719309091568,
0.27549296617507935,
-0.200364351272583,
0.10134141892194748,
-1.0144442319869995,
-0.05892051011323929,
0.2336416244506836,
0.32657358050346375,
0.18597999215126038,
0.7265481352806091,
-0.07714813947677612,
0.902562141418457,
0.268783301115036,
-0.10478830337524414,
0.20541372895240784,
-0.3579811155796051,
-0.1129395142197609,
-0.12982811033725739,
0.5398173332214355,
0.15081921219825745,
0.20719720423221588,
-0.01502066757529974,
-0.15342946350574493,
-0.33036428689956665,
0.2842255234718323,
-0.7410110831260681,
0.07371204346418381,
0.6032531261444092,
-0.5223633646965027,
0.02544974349439144,
-0.13057765364646912,
-0.9626531600952148,
-0.2228238433599472,
0.124564528465271,
0.5238951444625854,
-0.0984051376581192,
-0.3318965435028076,
0.328583300113678,
-0.05463341996073723,
-0.023090334609150887,
0.47761937975883484,
-0.6105024814605713,
0.40583664178848267,
0.656850278377533,
0.7284353971481323,
-0.020705323666334152,
-0.27331826090812683,
-0.9079596996307373,
0.17372730374336243,
-0.44773778319358826,
0.5937941074371338,
-0.3979097008705139,
-0.18282340466976166,
0.010064358823001385,
-0.08137521892786026,
-0.05818257853388786,
-0.6945428848266602,
0.4709039032459259,
-1.1816190481185913,
0.5402519106864929,
-0.2620956003665924,
-0.43486693501472473,
-0.23247061669826508,
0.2899474501609802,
-0.8665467500686646,
0.8781120777130127,
0.09624279290437698,
-0.993013858795166,
0.1517099291086197,
-1.0406287908554077,
-0.26848113536834717,
-0.3048764169216156,
0.013588720001280308,
-0.42933356761932373,
-0.07480596005916595,
0.3976825177669525,
0.2515583634376526,
-0.5118604898452759,
0.16229301691055298,
-0.41461196541786194,
-0.23974065482616425,
0.06689729541540146,
-0.309950590133667,
0.6960901618003845,
0.2306472659111023,
-0.4063175320625305,
0.06091097369790077,
-0.6203177571296692,
-0.0942738726735115,
0.41841813921928406,
-0.31573110818862915,
-0.5004843473434448,
-0.037438105791807175,
-0.646353542804718,
0.5045273303985596,
-0.043767333030700684,
-0.8574150204658508,
0.05616626515984535,
-0.3710503578186035,
0.4144931733608246,
0.686281144618988,
0.11850015819072723,
0.4093727171421051,
-0.5585697889328003,
0.6577991843223572,
0.2344372719526291,
-0.06583260744810104,
-0.06400175392627716,
-0.9594675302505493,
-0.5299822688102722,
-0.19702811539173126,
0.0694570317864418,
0.401752233505249,
-0.9506277441978455,
0.10307058691978455,
-0.22266365587711334,
-0.3796439468860626,
-0.7020464539527893,
-0.1481899619102478,
0.38982975482940674,
0.5834057927131653,
0.8215997219085693,
-0.02065255120396614,
-0.39416196942329407,
-0.6323562264442444,
-0.12707947194576263,
-0.34771719574928284,
0.10206346213817596,
0.2600891888141632,
0.6150087714195251,
0.04323859140276909,
1.2035011053085327,
-0.9650744795799255,
-0.27333182096481323,
-0.2481590062379837,
0.14783062040805817,
0.22616466879844666,
0.19502867758274078,
0.4351266622543335,
-0.9525507688522339,
-0.25166040658950806,
-0.38541755080223083,
-0.439040869474411,
-0.08484872430562973,
0.16954730451107025,
-0.07470820099115372,
0.39639246463775635,
0.4964207708835602,
-1.059598684310913,
0.4663521647453308,
0.3449808657169342,
-0.27502524852752686,
0.44769057631492615,
-0.21982097625732422,
0.23857712745666504,
-0.6715047955513,
0.3251621425151825,
-0.2659350335597992,
-0.027933334931731224,
-0.7745782732963562,
0.2970936596393585,
0.02461906336247921,
-0.06645774841308594,
-0.37811601161956787,
0.5865713953971863,
-0.34779563546180725,
0.09374412149190903,
-0.1946427971124649,
0.3857698142528534,
0.3817901313304901,
0.3746984899044037,
0.314643532037735,
0.6138972640037537,
0.29144322872161865,
-0.7394323348999023,
0.23667767643928528,
0.5937719941139221,
-0.173508420586586,
0.3925231695175171,
-0.618882954120636,
0.3081294298171997,
-0.3070402145385742,
0.5141134858131409,
-1.0248908996582031,
0.10202398896217346,
0.3344433605670929,
-0.5336664319038391,
0.25189730525016785,
-0.240575909614563,
-0.4710627496242523,
-0.5664862394332886,
-0.3841768801212311,
0.7172420024871826,
0.2163650542497635,
-0.6569911241531372,
0.335423082113266,
0.4072625935077667,
-0.16383349895477295,
-0.6950589418411255,
-0.6476128101348877,
-0.27259939908981323,
-0.29536187648773193,
-0.6732974052429199,
0.43164145946502686,
-0.23667731881141663,
-0.30667397379875183,
0.07054665684700012,
-0.2543821334838867,
-0.30958324670791626,
0.09092418104410172,
-0.251206636428833,
0.20036739110946655,
-0.43687334656715393,
0.06266672909259796,
-0.14033201336860657,
-0.09015380591154099,
0.2171827256679535,
-0.16072818636894226,
0.5782273411750793,
0.43484923243522644,
-0.4127999544143677,
-0.09212182462215424,
0.692609429359436,
0.7813591957092285,
-0.5694653391838074,
0.9970096349716187,
0.4980115294456482,
-0.29278188943862915,
-0.14420883357524872,
-0.35322636365890503,
-0.3597506582736969,
-0.4055386781692505,
0.41375502943992615,
-0.6433060765266418,
-1.0924115180969238,
0.3791396915912628,
0.25804734230041504,
0.36927154660224915,
0.3976011872291565,
0.6408880949020386,
0.070799320936203,
1.102622389793396,
0.272037535905838,
0.2543497681617737,
-0.16624076664447784,
0.06384812295436859,
0.48637545108795166,
-0.9125540852546692,
-0.20742715895175934,
-0.854231595993042,
0.12168706953525543,
-0.3935598134994507,
-0.7469611763954163,
0.26497817039489746,
0.04973975941538811,
-0.3093763291835785,
0.17287467420101166,
-0.17369332909584045,
0.1115499809384346,
0.489053875207901,
0.004049318376928568,
0.3833411633968353,
-0.32335126399993896,
0.06267991662025452,
0.20822204649448395,
-0.7776893973350525,
-0.244802325963974,
1.0200443267822266,
0.5091403722763062,
0.7943545579910278,
0.5774034261703491,
0.4877949357032776,
0.13027188181877136,
-0.08236168324947357,
-0.6094151735305786,
0.5866021513938904,
0.08466359972953796,
-0.9213452339172363,
-0.4820685386657715,
-0.9022607803344727,
-0.9315648078918457,
0.385489284992218,
0.14276623725891113,
-0.49974900484085083,
0.11712457984685898,
0.19231894612312317,
-0.41774940490722656,
0.6591776609420776,
-0.31432265043258667,
0.7468100786209106,
0.137045755982399,
-0.2936384379863739,
-0.10332915186882019,
-0.6597705483436584,
0.467245489358902,
-0.4605371654033661,
0.45766502618789673,
-0.031039120629429817,
-0.14507053792476654,
0.8775254487991333,
-0.49082884192466736,
0.6957718133926392,
-0.40706369280815125,
-0.6554005742073059,
0.39881959557533264,
0.25423261523246765,
0.4937087297439575,
0.03507550060749054,
-0.13437312841415405,
0.1220320537686348,
0.060702502727508545,
-0.3140292167663574,
-0.6904522180557251,
0.6724504232406616,
-0.679248034954071,
-0.933054506778717,
-0.31725236773490906,
-0.3427419066429138,
-0.3407246470451355,
0.1282186508178711,
0.14405228197574615,
0.5363087058067322,
0.08176607638597488,
-0.18568763136863708,
0.82893967628479,
-0.29072895646095276,
0.2275265008211136,
0.800041675567627,
-0.36719977855682373,
-0.3157999813556671,
0.579646646976471,
-0.019801631569862366,
0.6658032536506653,
0.593201756477356,
0.3470258414745331,
-0.4743328094482422,
-0.5781251788139343,
-0.7892388701438904,
0.3389204144477844,
-0.8319472670555115,
-0.260229229927063,
-0.868638277053833,
-0.03391019254922867,
-0.4160710871219635,
0.15733222663402557,
-0.3052310049533844,
-0.5362336039543152,
-0.15687072277069092,
0.09420928359031677,
0.32666441798210144,
0.5012670159339905,
-0.21704530715942383,
-0.18567253649234772,
-1.013936161994934,
0.9169419407844543,
0.39205408096313477,
0.3973102569580078,
0.10045204311609268,
-0.8552045822143555,
-0.08967337012290955,
0.29771631956100464,
-0.21829888224601746,
-0.7792243957519531,
0.015878209844231606,
0.2998735308647156,
0.592477023601532,
0.19724269211292267,
0.46366265416145325,
0.7416185736656189,
-0.6914494037628174,
0.695345938205719,
-0.19694051146507263,
-0.7942437529563904,
0.586820662021637,
-0.24328871071338654,
0.38139382004737854,
0.3030232787132263,
0.7768736481666565,
-0.35557907819747925,
-0.5135610699653625,
-0.32844167947769165,
-0.8522655963897705,
1.0451223850250244,
0.2997468411922455,
-0.22166499495506287,
-0.09869406372308731,
0.3600907325744629,
0.25225743651390076,
0.13612540066242218,
-0.5750017762184143,
-0.572019636631012,
-0.1119811087846756,
0.2765389680862427,
0.11897845566272736,
-0.28784966468811035,
-0.2752675414085388,
0.07029788196086884,
0.7663439512252808,
-0.08153349906206131,
0.37344980239868164,
0.21863524615764618,
0.0673242062330246,
-0.5465202927589417,
0.3846451938152313,
0.5461045503616333,
0.6903745532035828,
-0.5672768950462341,
0.32157382369041443,
-0.2260557860136032,
-0.4695607125759125,
0.28885605931282043,
-0.012800399214029312,
-0.21664680540561676,
-0.14218078553676605,
0.41340696811676025,
0.40961113572120667,
-0.4444233775138855,
-0.6430245637893677,
0.4815000295639038,
-0.1944291740655899,
-0.3984759747982025,
0.09892105311155319,
-0.06970550864934921,
-0.13547103106975555,
-0.09994292259216309,
0.339270681142807,
0.24449390172958374,
0.07429082691669464,
-0.6013619303703308,
0.20473292469978333,
0.24069364368915558,
-0.4142521321773529,
-0.24191994965076447,
0.640376091003418,
0.11037755757570267,
-0.07664547860622406,
0.609035074710846,
-0.09173097461462021,
-0.5334851145744324,
0.4689401090145111,
0.711832582950592,
0.5907185077667236,
-0.3083820343017578,
0.25701361894607544,
0.4291231036186218,
0.26477375626564026,
-0.06723387539386749,
0.4451097548007965,
0.1967034637928009,
-0.925379753112793,
-0.6732472777366638,
-0.3649127185344696,
-0.3265557885169983,
0.32393598556518555,
-0.8935583233833313,
0.10303107649087906,
-0.06116597354412079,
0.0005776582402177155,
0.033065054565668106,
-0.41136613488197327,
-0.24408768117427826,
0.2766340672969818,
-0.022582294419407845,
0.8840959072113037,
-0.6213316321372986,
0.7389287948608398,
0.6437205076217651,
-0.31179988384246826,
-0.3702678084373474,
0.38157543540000916,
0.0684780552983284,
-0.5070592164993286,
0.6181142926216125,
0.07475659996271133,
-0.3169710338115692,
0.14536240696907043,
-0.28643471002578735,
-0.905997633934021,
0.6041861176490784,
0.23370404541492462,
-0.21989333629608154,
0.1569516807794571,
0.2701890766620636,
0.20885702967643738,
0.019679812714457512,
0.3362586200237274,
0.5375353693962097,
0.6088228225708008,
0.17709484696388245,
-1.072380542755127,
0.35016655921936035,
-0.0482710525393486,
-0.4368957579135895,
0.5013673901557922,
-0.3742365539073944,
0.9210232496261597,
-0.6847160458564758,
-0.19022586941719055,
0.10758943855762482,
0.2065969854593277,
0.39954015612602234,
0.09049119800329208,
0.6623565554618835,
0.5974483489990234,
0.5480360388755798,
-0.07228883355855942,
0.785224974155426,
0.15319988131523132,
0.2915881872177124,
1.1511377096176147,
-0.5474300384521484,
0.9341191053390503,
0.5436425805091858,
-0.20764589309692383,
0.2591884434223175,
0.5367329120635986,
0.39185830950737,
0.8340570330619812,
0.3828532099723816,
-0.14038845896720886,
-0.3508627116680145,
0.13156981766223907,
-0.5193081498146057,
0.6764709949493408,
0.1592811644077301,
0.0662631168961525,
-0.4100267291069031,
-0.04935327544808388,
0.2558349668979645,
0.10316435247659683,
-0.23816733062267303,
0.752564013004303,
-0.03625807911157608,
-0.9127969145774841,
0.8871922492980957,
0.2688564658164978,
0.300099641084671,
-0.5982537865638733,
-0.2515605092048645,
-0.26511093974113464,
0.2461797446012497,
-0.1559697389602661,
-1.0471056699752808,
0.5800600051879883,
0.04779966548085213,
-0.47937867045402527,
-0.1682380735874176,
0.20722150802612305,
-0.36531952023506165,
0.05147659778594971,
0.4237765371799469,
0.7877992987632751,
-0.13273857533931732,
-0.2113082855939865,
-0.6936785578727722,
-0.17162472009658813,
-0.018513843417167664,
-0.2440239042043686,
0.34615960717201233,
0.7254543900489807,
-0.11143379658460617,
0.7598084211349487,
0.6486044526100159,
-0.08039914816617966,
-0.22420841455459595,
0.0692143663764,
1.044478178024292,
-0.39866653084754944,
-0.4773619771003723,
-0.9499120712280273,
0.30574870109558105,
0.1740029901266098,
-0.21702060103416443,
0.7625700235366821,
0.5441005825996399,
0.7601409554481506,
-0.07116169482469559,
0.688572108745575,
-0.2947518527507782,
0.872890055179596,
-0.6089196801185608,
0.5359964370727539,
-0.812136173248291,
0.4474024176597595,
-0.452333003282547,
-0.7735561728477478,
-0.48139557242393494,
0.37099844217300415,
-0.2128303200006485,
0.15413661301136017,
0.8202022910118103,
0.846076488494873,
0.00959246139973402,
0.07488489896059036,
0.3244291841983795,
0.34613150358200073,
0.5355890989303589,
0.40524229407310486,
0.9881543517112732,
-0.25042545795440674,
0.7513747811317444,
-0.22732174396514893,
-0.27734947204589844,
-0.15228015184402466,
-0.717258632183075,
-0.8633328080177307,
-0.5381227135658264,
-0.49559158086776733,
-0.4908953011035919,
-0.07010962069034576,
0.5551925897598267,
0.47273290157318115,
-0.8259381651878357,
-0.05833303555846214,
0.055548034608364105,
0.16427360475063324,
-0.395886093378067,
-0.2365381419658661,
0.5614516139030457,
-0.08268275111913681,
-0.27552565932273865,
0.49728068709373474,
0.347087025642395,
-0.30284690856933594,
-0.23383694887161255,
0.101744145154953,
-0.42177557945251465,
0.08415663242340088,
0.560884416103363,
0.20097313821315765,
-0.7127609848976135,
-0.3361184000968933,
0.2206355333328247,
0.18290020525455475,
0.2812448740005493,
0.8050974011421204,
-0.5820206999778748,
0.3863282799720764,
0.5583093166351318,
0.5536990165710449,
0.26423004269599915,
0.14451013505458832,
0.615096926689148,
-0.5688221454620361,
-0.24816426634788513,
0.33896610140800476,
0.2844875156879425,
0.15510332584381104,
-0.17459219694137573,
0.34742751717567444,
0.17617389559745789,
-0.6164103150367737,
-0.6889193654060364,
0.43069013953208923,
-0.6230833530426025,
-0.4742099642753601,
1.1264158487319946,
-0.3912128806114197,
-0.047469135373830795,
-0.7718319296836853,
-0.18732507526874542,
0.020945588126778603,
-0.2734833061695099,
0.6936047673225403,
0.29435276985168457,
-0.16389168798923492,
-0.22268594801425934,
-0.5939921140670776,
0.48994189500808716,
0.31294146180152893,
-0.9150978922843933,
0.409950315952301,
0.3690603971481323,
0.1445431113243103,
0.2696376144886017,
0.840279757976532,
-0.258910596370697,
0.33001360297203064,
-0.17187903821468353,
-0.15037685632705688,
-0.06134907901287079,
-0.3291603624820709,
-0.11928390711545944,
0.4482749104499817,
0.21673575043678284,
-0.4025784432888031
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.12392v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.12392v1
|
AraPoemBERT: A Pretrained Language Model for Arabic Poetry Analysis
| 2024-03-19T02:59:58 | 2024-03-19T02:59:58 |
Faisal Qarah
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Arabic poetry, with its rich linguistic features and profound cultural
significance, presents a unique challenge to the Natural Language Processing
(NLP) field. The complexity of its structure and context necessitates advanced
computational models for accurate analysis. In this paper, we introduce
AraPoemBERT, an Arabic language model pretrained exclusively on Arabic poetry
text. To demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed model, we compared
AraPoemBERT with 5 different Arabic language models on various NLP tasks
related to Arabic poetry. The new model outperformed all other models and
achieved state-of-the-art results in most of the downstream tasks. AraPoemBERT
achieved unprecedented accuracy in two out of three novel tasks: poet's gender
classification (99.34\% accuracy), and poetry sub-meter classification (97.79\%
accuracy). In addition, the model achieved an accuracy score in poems' rhyme
classification (97.73\% accuracy) which is almost equivalent to the best score
reported in this study. Moreover, the proposed model significantly outperformed
previous work and other comparative models in the tasks of poems' sentiment
analysis, achieving an accuracy of 78.95\%, and poetry meter classification
(99.03\% accuracy), while significantly expanding the scope of these two
problems. The dataset used in this study, contains more than 2.09 million
verses collected from online sources, each associated with various attributes
such as meter, sub-meter, poet, rhyme, and topic. The results demonstrate the
effectiveness of the proposed model in understanding and analyzing Arabic
poetry, achieving state-of-the-art results in several tasks and outperforming
previous works and other language models included in the study. AraPoemBERT
model is publicly available on \url{https://huggingface.co/faisalq}.
|
[
-0.23109160363674164,
-0.46977493166923523,
0.13562671840190887,
0.517437756061554,
-0.3302662670612335,
-0.023480180650949478,
-0.14543747901916504,
-0.5888519883155823,
0.12326116859912872,
0.623375415802002,
-0.1031695157289505,
-0.82216876745224,
-1.1695152521133423,
0.09956426173448563,
-0.6679017543792725,
1.114681363105774,
-0.3254566192626953,
-0.11280299723148346,
0.1537821739912033,
-0.3685106933116913,
-0.27855101227760315,
-0.5854504108428955,
-0.6373904347419739,
-0.3337083160877228,
0.28912997245788574,
0.026940489187836647,
0.7834010720252991,
0.14766795933246613,
0.3845503032207489,
0.2944425344467163,
-0.16462711989879608,
0.1376192420721054,
0.06850653141736984,
0.11020375043153763,
0.22197391092777252,
-0.48318567872047424,
-0.6030580401420593,
0.5040014982223511,
0.6245940327644348,
0.6338018178939819,
-0.383706271648407,
0.3221793472766876,
0.13623496890068054,
0.9643881320953369,
-0.8571321368217468,
-0.1037391945719719,
-0.5324351191520691,
0.16648967564105988,
-0.30591967701911926,
-0.053938381373882294,
-0.2877519726753235,
-0.3499908149242401,
0.22496819496154785,
-0.25604721903800964,
0.007072645239531994,
-0.08162522315979004,
0.7666321396827698,
0.3948805332183838,
-0.3778315484523773,
-0.5843448638916016,
-0.7040678858757019,
0.6985991597175598,
-0.5404419898986816,
0.23389391601085663,
0.48599666357040405,
0.28242725133895874,
0.00340819894336164,
-0.9341589212417603,
-0.5238005518913269,
-0.5675486922264099,
0.11902095377445221,
0.24661171436309814,
-0.6380726099014282,
-0.27008840441703796,
-0.18702968955039978,
0.18336370587348938,
-0.511049211025238,
-0.2402113825082779,
-0.04331311210989952,
-0.003531438997015357,
0.43865352869033813,
-0.09983593970537186,
0.5348455905914307,
-0.22965452075004578,
-0.28435930609703064,
0.15712538361549377,
-0.2622094750404358,
0.3981497585773468,
0.63295978307724,
-0.0382760651409626,
-0.2007473111152649,
0.4510544538497925,
-0.12179068475961685,
0.8094115853309631,
-0.4810836911201477,
0.0019014518475160003,
0.2761361300945282,
0.3447304964065552,
0.07786360383033752,
0.10229882597923279,
0.9390851259231567,
0.09820292890071869,
0.5560182929039001,
-0.05956871435046196,
-0.24943576753139496,
0.3710883557796478,
0.39605727791786194,
-0.669720470905304,
-0.6869011521339417,
0.31711095571517944,
-0.5279079675674438,
-0.36619797348976135,
-0.2024374157190323,
-0.25256335735321045,
-0.20793797075748444,
-0.09191763401031494,
0.30570000410079956,
-0.5751467943191528,
-0.22837568819522858,
0.3238714039325714,
0.05475747957825661,
-0.19735604524612427,
0.30859026312828064,
-0.4064697325229645,
0.3381746709346771,
0.7015124559402466,
1.239707589149475,
-0.1744629591703415,
-0.4729021489620209,
-0.5542834997177124,
-0.2295447587966919,
-0.4556340277194977,
0.7856834530830383,
-0.8699653744697571,
0.1399562656879425,
-0.0027097684796899557,
-0.4830279052257538,
-0.03439876437187195,
-0.3590770363807678,
1.0837044715881348,
-0.5291091799736023,
-0.03293374180793762,
0.3973684012889862,
-0.5596466660499573,
-0.2552972435951233,
0.2524457573890686,
-0.9318755269050598,
0.8575462698936462,
-0.14815206825733185,
-1.0666884183883667,
-0.11932821571826935,
-0.7284623384475708,
0.07581248134374619,
-0.028053177520632744,
-0.13500063121318817,
-0.4187605082988739,
0.04842543229460716,
0.24353864789009094,
0.4071686267852783,
-0.3368128836154938,
0.004572748672217131,
0.09356550872325897,
-0.36206167936325073,
0.4724453091621399,
-0.18366797268390656,
0.9185405969619751,
0.3414838910102844,
-0.23241406679153442,
-0.08118886500597,
-0.8060883283615112,
-0.018676113337278366,
0.17944374680519104,
-0.1082804799079895,
-0.23447160422801971,
-0.06763086467981339,
0.3754977583885193,
0.2548695206642151,
0.14920519292354584,
-0.5733227729797363,
0.022314289584755898,
-0.6549831628799438,
0.43133142590522766,
0.3824213743209839,
-0.33792802691459656,
0.3017744719982147,
-0.3992898166179657,
1.1613200902938843,
-0.23161965608596802,
-0.1131434515118599,
0.13446848094463348,
-0.5758618712425232,
-0.4657130837440491,
-0.5796550512313843,
0.7880873084068298,
0.5982198715209961,
-0.36073651909828186,
0.6004402041435242,
-0.09067349880933762,
-1.0007320642471313,
-0.8235316872596741,
0.0492682084441185,
0.17687223851680756,
0.36987268924713135,
0.2818702757358551,
-0.5540173053741455,
-0.40574243664741516,
-0.6091679930686951,
-0.5817693471908569,
-0.12535996735095978,
0.3270106911659241,
-0.00010992249008268118,
0.3975525200366974,
-0.4274788200855255,
0.8332650661468506,
-0.3969084322452545,
-0.3303524851799011,
-0.598398745059967,
0.7726589441299438,
0.37158429622650146,
0.4573488235473633,
0.7938095927238464,
-0.59430992603302,
-0.5645480155944824,
-0.11698872596025467,
-0.46240898966789246,
-0.4954841434955597,
0.40664082765579224,
-0.33108824491500854,
0.1159101128578186,
0.05169645696878433,
-0.667053759098053,
0.53472900390625,
0.8300585746765137,
-0.16374194622039795,
0.6790628433227539,
0.033171314746141434,
-0.0025504333898425102,
-0.8336268663406372,
0.26472318172454834,
-0.1474480926990509,
-0.18312394618988037,
-0.6978808641433716,
0.22804710268974304,
-0.11856485158205032,
-0.3522305488586426,
-0.42516398429870605,
0.5964269042015076,
-0.11755693703889847,
0.1800006777048111,
-0.806700587272644,
-0.08515918254852295,
-0.027622591704130173,
0.21707956492900848,
0.08482986688613892,
0.5653538703918457,
0.7638469338417053,
-0.3069898784160614,
0.3773548901081085,
0.26249513030052185,
-0.551753044128418,
0.0468723364174366,
-0.7304854989051819,
0.26252281665802,
-0.4119025468826294,
0.42283424735069275,
-1.1219463348388672,
0.2639331519603729,
0.2911682426929474,
-0.7235302925109863,
-0.1646180897951126,
-0.32827967405319214,
-0.5413422584533691,
0.20224666595458984,
-0.07306931167840958,
0.7042257785797119,
0.5836827158927917,
-0.2286042720079422,
0.9855464696884155,
0.1718490570783615,
-0.35038331151008606,
-0.8927391171455383,
-0.20435090363025665,
0.035476408898830414,
-0.2092626988887787,
-0.47526848316192627,
0.08575023710727692,
0.17577491700649261,
-0.05897053703665733,
-0.06277048587799072,
-0.007577066775411367,
-0.23442405462265015,
0.31373247504234314,
0.40112242102622986,
0.12221292406320572,
0.22036366164684296,
0.41722995042800903,
-0.28844743967056274,
-0.4316256642341614,
0.07662953436374664,
-0.27946433424949646,
1.0649255514144897,
-0.2477705031633377,
-0.09472139179706573,
-0.7434602379798889,
0.4891512095928192,
0.3540174961090088,
-0.866157591342926,
0.9970987439155579,
0.983490526676178,
-0.24135535955429077,
-0.1269931048154831,
-0.26480525732040405,
0.40250325202941895,
-0.3723975419998169,
0.24454274773597717,
-0.19911272823810577,
-0.621275782585144,
0.2834707498550415,
-0.27018341422080994,
-0.05035693570971489,
0.4311368465423584,
0.38329580426216125,
-0.19483155012130737,
1.006047010421753,
0.728238582611084,
-0.3663969933986664,
0.2882997989654541,
-0.391472727060318,
0.18262456357479095,
-0.7643470168113708,
0.14495472609996796,
-0.8582062721252441,
-0.45059117674827576,
-0.6713975667953491,
-0.07411698251962662,
0.3679036796092987,
0.3259296715259552,
-0.2363712638616562,
0.10196740925312042,
-0.42625904083251953,
0.17789454758167267,
0.41329774260520935,
-0.12198285758495331,
0.1835392713546753,
0.1512538641691208,
-0.1767423152923584,
-0.03754991292953491,
-0.4597874581813812,
-0.9655963778495789,
1.4087095260620117,
0.19457218050956726,
0.44848477840423584,
0.34747540950775146,
0.7302799224853516,
0.5971121191978455,
0.3421514332294464,
-0.6064143776893616,
0.323322594165802,
-0.34874922037124634,
-0.38248172402381897,
-0.03211243078112602,
-0.20982994139194489,
-1.1645475625991821,
0.17086894810199738,
-0.34697842597961426,
-0.6020081043243408,
-0.35727161169052124,
0.22072376310825348,
-0.24783633649349213,
0.06396994739770889,
-0.40767621994018555,
0.8049129247665405,
-0.19917340576648712,
0.11854927241802216,
-0.09399016201496124,
-0.4137846827507019,
0.0709175243973732,
-0.18301931023597717,
0.3568319082260132,
-0.3791828155517578,
-0.2417333871126175,
0.960113525390625,
-0.47136783599853516,
0.4769068956375122,
-0.02526966854929924,
-0.06256785988807678,
0.34355923533439636,
0.16301199793815613,
0.6504765748977661,
-0.20637838542461395,
-0.3843272030353546,
0.3583240211009979,
-0.013372940942645073,
-0.7872893810272217,
-0.6815674901008606,
0.43003755807876587,
-1.2131969928741455,
-0.26085397601127625,
-0.7057635188102722,
-0.34831902384757996,
-0.023267529904842377,
-0.05986964330077171,
0.4214071035385132,
0.47410547733306885,
0.02752186357975006,
-0.011851596646010876,
0.02154611423611641,
-0.16464804112911224,
0.27995142340660095,
0.5312730669975281,
-0.4667743146419525,
-0.3331843316555023,
0.41284382343292236,
0.09559357911348343,
-0.16737531125545502,
0.3202379643917084,
0.23614723980426788,
-0.22247713804244995,
-0.6622496247291565,
-0.27098965644836426,
0.08548467606306076,
-0.678525447845459,
0.06072770059108734,
-0.9654233455657959,
-0.39513933658599854,
-0.3077632486820221,
0.11139032244682312,
-0.4855096936225891,
-0.40697669982910156,
0.018089786171913147,
0.21482433378696442,
0.41329964995384216,
0.38112694025039673,
0.12494499981403351,
0.5855770707130432,
-0.9436589479446411,
0.18084242939949036,
0.19968156516551971,
0.14914903044700623,
0.21819990873336792,
-0.7380673885345459,
-0.08005516231060028,
-0.29650530219078064,
-0.2922731041908264,
-1.0364253520965576,
0.6011570692062378,
0.33679619431495667,
0.1341274082660675,
0.12638665735721588,
0.12252289056777954,
0.29446080327033997,
-0.7435618042945862,
0.4922908544540405,
0.14696115255355835,
-1.0514219999313354,
0.7888939380645752,
-0.06097106263041496,
0.3563511073589325,
0.4377061724662781,
0.710258424282074,
-0.6110967397689819,
-0.49028801918029785,
-0.6012860536575317,
-0.9013090133666992,
0.5081945657730103,
0.9009613990783691,
0.15242868661880493,
0.08245152980089188,
0.5939180850982666,
0.23573313653469086,
0.3416495621204376,
-0.7908884882926941,
-0.3943445086479187,
-0.21601220965385437,
-0.48941633105278015,
-0.3285888135433197,
-0.1115279421210289,
0.033583272248506546,
-0.39318254590034485,
0.7054458856582642,
0.27582651376724243,
0.27009493112564087,
0.12700948119163513,
-0.43065956234931946,
0.10430463403463364,
0.2500922381877899,
0.26366472244262695,
0.7533268332481384,
-0.17127129435539246,
0.32669875025749207,
-0.055539071559906006,
-0.7087604403495789,
0.22246883809566498,
0.2814651131629944,
-0.04757988452911377,
0.1046881377696991,
0.8933417797088623,
0.6275139451026917,
-0.5232400298118591,
-0.9709052443504333,
0.6703804731369019,
-0.14146408438682556,
0.2593902051448822,
-0.8307620882987976,
0.17364731431007385,
0.01176040805876255,
0.27650195360183716,
0.24715296924114227,
0.36483144760131836,
0.38590723276138306,
-0.36850517988204956,
0.03616192191839218,
0.3595421016216278,
-0.4276658892631531,
-0.21834523975849152,
0.5126311182975769,
0.01241083350032568,
-0.5353336334228516,
0.3488733768463135,
-0.25229954719543457,
-0.7777983546257019,
0.42027178406715393,
0.33299776911735535,
0.8514004349708557,
-0.25562435388565063,
0.3981892466545105,
0.11706309765577316,
0.24834077060222626,
0.2612691819667816,
0.4077709913253784,
-0.14181222021579742,
-0.9338279366493225,
-0.4782656729221344,
-1.0409057140350342,
-0.2813732624053955,
0.0807257667183876,
-0.4902894198894501,
-0.044294483959674835,
-0.5121840238571167,
-0.26607704162597656,
0.20234015583992004,
0.16241924464702606,
-0.648831844329834,
0.2829350233078003,
0.012775625102221966,
0.700036346912384,
-1.033095121383667,
0.8167766332626343,
1.1837174892425537,
-0.19556260108947754,
-0.7476124167442322,
0.08366400003433228,
-0.24383243918418884,
-0.7328439354896545,
0.8664989471435547,
0.36262446641921997,
-0.4719904959201813,
0.19759050011634827,
-0.6365325450897217,
-0.6354626417160034,
0.6364247798919678,
0.41930097341537476,
-0.38192060589790344,
0.6726089715957642,
0.15321511030197144,
0.6531238555908203,
-0.465731680393219,
0.560124397277832,
0.5806536078453064,
-0.018270205706357956,
0.04340379685163498,
-0.6980786323547363,
-0.3332351744174957,
-0.8199657201766968,
0.005767628084868193,
0.4043899476528168,
-0.5484256744384766,
1.062800645828247,
0.46515023708343506,
0.14503240585327148,
0.3167661428451538,
0.758240282535553,
0.40753600001335144,
0.1320813000202179,
0.5854358673095703,
0.859571099281311,
0.7315431833267212,
0.21302460134029388,
0.9861478209495544,
-0.43595069646835327,
0.20517517626285553,
0.9645856022834778,
-0.37981459498405457,
1.0565705299377441,
-0.0946081355214119,
-0.2563856542110443,
0.8309164643287659,
0.31286418437957764,
0.3867732584476471,
0.45174694061279297,
0.19362537562847137,
-0.5981215238571167,
-0.4656996428966522,
-0.34852084517478943,
-0.31590035557746887,
0.9104140400886536,
-0.13063696026802063,
-0.3725811839103699,
-0.002696917625144124,
0.10098892450332642,
0.09884606301784515,
0.34761500358581543,
-0.2027914673089981,
0.38589537143707275,
0.0028653957415372133,
-0.5344240069389343,
0.5913898348808289,
0.4389907419681549,
0.4110787808895111,
-0.4755409061908722,
-0.09429236501455307,
0.07899753004312515,
0.09014857560396194,
-0.10836879163980484,
-0.45466771721839905,
0.1897192746400833,
0.4161645174026489,
0.05326669663190842,
0.1336887925863266,
0.8413937091827393,
-0.14522212743759155,
-0.774415910243988,
0.31228309869766235,
0.47792360186576843,
0.3508404791355133,
-0.416436105966568,
-0.7056827545166016,
0.10312189906835556,
-0.23376508057117462,
0.10032816976308823,
-0.0037353967782109976,
0.4356234073638916,
0.116594098508358,
0.7093620896339417,
0.49688467383384705,
0.47786781191825867,
0.06127173453569412,
0.06430353969335556,
0.4500214159488678,
-0.6474814414978027,
-0.7428363561630249,
-0.8722731471061707,
0.3675859272480011,
0.07355819642543793,
-0.3682202100753784,
0.4335848093032837,
0.3182085454463959,
0.5306645035743713,
0.1145554631948471,
0.7697603106498718,
0.2215147316455841,
0.641822099685669,
-0.5539079308509827,
0.8906181454658508,
-0.4880409240722656,
0.12268684804439545,
-0.3667403757572174,
-1.0741294622421265,
-0.18221278488636017,
0.9391920566558838,
-0.46980950236320496,
0.062496185302734375,
0.5663167834281921,
0.3198795020580292,
0.09557436406612396,
0.16105733811855316,
-0.10096561908721924,
0.0416511669754982,
0.11669810116291046,
0.4782223403453827,
1.233961582183838,
-0.4845072329044342,
0.428658664226532,
-0.3343575894832611,
-0.3498161733150482,
-0.07588014006614685,
-0.8398802280426025,
-0.9480617046356201,
-0.5464321374893188,
-0.3248007595539093,
-0.039900995790958405,
0.012043656781315804,
1.2600256204605103,
0.43136265873908997,
-0.6276535987854004,
-0.27282819151878357,
-0.13766832649707794,
-0.2691831588745117,
-0.2131572812795639,
-0.047066375613212585,
0.7004600167274475,
-0.30506348609924316,
-0.6496869921684265,
-0.2001209855079651,
0.21116486191749573,
-0.07117976248264313,
0.16344133019447327,
-0.2779938280582428,
-0.37660127878189087,
0.05548441410064697,
0.5639081597328186,
-0.12442940473556519,
-0.690828263759613,
-0.02755015343427658,
-0.5106362700462341,
0.021718915551900864,
0.054204218089580536,
0.4722978174686432,
-0.6935583353042603,
0.430683970451355,
0.19481272995471954,
0.6701154112815857,
0.2927543520927429,
0.09597840160131454,
0.17613179981708527,
-0.6968787312507629,
0.40674227476119995,
0.5236573219299316,
0.44983842968940735,
0.229061096906662,
0.07394156605005264,
0.4845503866672516,
-0.009129732847213745,
-0.4546239972114563,
-0.4846993088722229,
0.44902369379997253,
-0.7921825647354126,
-0.1377687305212021,
0.7612314820289612,
-0.352992981672287,
0.03154926747083664,
0.0019268819596618414,
-0.46351996064186096,
0.5925067663192749,
-0.2653704881668091,
0.9110963344573975,
0.9788990020751953,
-0.2606576681137085,
-0.3661659061908722,
-0.8216196298599243,
0.2919735014438629,
1.0114961862564087,
-0.5574839115142822,
-0.5166288614273071,
0.14850430190563202,
-0.027525324374437332,
0.21428148448467255,
0.614189624786377,
0.1400984525680542,
0.4647030532360077,
-0.4060024321079254,
0.3736441731452942,
0.18969322741031647,
-0.4630807638168335,
-0.3273024260997772,
0.5423478484153748,
0.5622652769088745,
-0.27845314145088196
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.12386v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.12386v1
|
Pipelined Biomedical Event Extraction Rivaling Joint Learning
| 2024-03-19T02:52:58 | 2024-03-19T02:52:58 |
Pengchao Wu, Xuefeng Li, Jinghang Gu, Longhua Qian, Guodong Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Biomedical event extraction is an information extraction task to obtain
events from biomedical text, whose targets include the type, the trigger, and
the respective arguments involved in an event. Traditional biomedical event
extraction usually adopts a pipelined approach, which contains trigger
identification, argument role recognition, and finally event construction
either using specific rules or by machine learning. In this paper, we propose
an n-ary relation extraction method based on the BERT pre-training model to
construct Binding events, in order to capture the semantic information about an
event's context and its participants. The experimental results show that our
method achieves promising results on the GE11 and GE13 corpora of the BioNLP
shared task with F1 scores of 63.14% and 59.40%, respectively. It demonstrates
that by significantly improving theperformance of Binding events, the overall
performance of the pipelined event extraction approach or even exceeds those of
current joint learning methods.
|
[
-0.3443599343299866,
-0.6604946851730347,
0.49483203887939453,
-0.3564232289791107,
-0.49732503294944763,
-0.16799886524677277,
-0.04203210771083832,
-0.8071575164794922,
0.604103684425354,
0.20214027166366577,
-0.8659343123435974,
-0.5942440032958984,
-0.7139827609062195,
0.023788204416632652,
-0.09949183464050293,
1.4224711656570435,
0.15457026660442352,
0.22231130301952362,
-0.33595436811447144,
-0.066285140812397,
-0.016555363312363625,
-0.6962418556213379,
-0.494383841753006,
-0.36175405979156494,
1.0019257068634033,
-0.08917801827192307,
0.33290496468544006,
0.6419153809547424,
0.8695091009140015,
0.15892843902111053,
-0.14060398936271667,
0.028336508199572563,
-0.34742605686187744,
0.11724767088890076,
-0.18597277998924255,
-0.23122617602348328,
-0.5629222393035889,
0.2745126485824585,
0.672636866569519,
0.8924863934516907,
0.31347301602363586,
0.0992518737912178,
0.17452694475650787,
0.40190017223358154,
-0.6785552501678467,
0.44988930225372314,
-0.5716480612754822,
0.24736329913139343,
-0.4998570680618286,
-0.37682613730430603,
-0.4286445379257202,
-0.10701030492782593,
0.4690115451812744,
-0.6179240942001343,
0.3582306206226349,
-0.3026038110256195,
1.2721812725067139,
-0.018060218542814255,
-0.2629581391811371,
-0.3475490212440491,
-0.1266004890203476,
0.7568904161453247,
-0.7040529847145081,
0.6271527409553528,
0.11479482799768448,
-0.2971184253692627,
-0.4070240259170532,
-0.9105432033538818,
-0.2971669137477875,
0.006916315760463476,
-0.14316092431545258,
0.1973472386598587,
-0.03050418198108673,
0.3125413656234741,
0.2960274815559387,
-0.052419207990169525,
-0.46202412247657776,
0.027327531948685646,
-0.47000208497047424,
-0.2022552341222763,
0.6290977597236633,
-0.24266619980335236,
0.40982410311698914,
-0.49400851130485535,
-0.4432998299598694,
-0.1070549413561821,
-0.7132004499435425,
-0.08150805532932281,
0.07434031367301941,
0.32912230491638184,
0.08745448291301727,
0.32127392292022705,
0.1825525164604187,
0.6604350209236145,
0.13436442613601685,
-0.06019021198153496,
0.34137943387031555,
-0.32733094692230225,
-0.24802203476428986,
0.2525484263896942,
1.0846670866012573,
0.03547818586230278,
0.031825825572013855,
-0.6413487195968628,
0.44151100516319275,
-0.03893489018082619,
-0.06871196627616882,
-0.7883450388908386,
-0.18201731145381927,
0.38902202248573303,
-0.8904607892036438,
-0.15310513973236084,
0.038180720061063766,
-1.0955864191055298,
0.02223774418234825,
-0.28921183943748474,
0.563010036945343,
-0.7417021989822388,
-0.1558929979801178,
-0.186809241771698,
-0.3190315365791321,
0.5990666747093201,
0.16518853604793549,
-0.7432134747505188,
-0.00020797491015400738,
0.7991827130317688,
0.9026750326156616,
-0.5042255520820618,
-0.19764013588428497,
-1.1770254373550415,
0.33431363105773926,
0.15097862482070923,
0.6835602521896362,
-0.606814444065094,
-0.29055172204971313,
-0.09176723659038544,
0.013969779945909977,
-0.13581176102161407,
-0.3584425449371338,
0.31857237219810486,
-0.8081839680671692,
0.24746429920196533,
-0.2873396575450897,
-0.9441866874694824,
0.0343560129404068,
-0.14195644855499268,
-0.46311020851135254,
0.5592630505561829,
-0.24614202976226807,
-0.8789700269699097,
0.8018690347671509,
-0.7372153997421265,
-0.5144887566566467,
0.28704917430877686,
-0.48086032271385193,
-0.3974553942680359,
-0.2489064335823059,
0.2896958589553833,
0.695274293422699,
0.1553998440504074,
0.5417925119400024,
-0.7128186821937561,
0.19052857160568237,
0.010990320704877377,
0.22807905077934265,
0.9864615797996521,
0.025401640683412552,
-0.2161584496498108,
0.16101668775081635,
-0.8041883707046509,
-0.15946532785892487,
-0.23792456090450287,
-0.2844782769680023,
-0.2373741716146469,
0.19967377185821533,
-0.05606362968683243,
0.28553929924964905,
0.21291546523571014,
-0.8400277495384216,
0.4172816872596741,
-0.7311720848083496,
0.14132466912269592,
0.5785543918609619,
0.24275869131088257,
0.4723829925060272,
-0.06978438049554825,
0.29229965806007385,
-0.018544888123869896,
-0.08660797029733658,
-0.019021177664399147,
-0.7408272624015808,
-0.2542240619659424,
-0.42321106791496277,
0.7215432524681091,
0.38125061988830566,
-0.746934711933136,
0.7588144540786743,
-0.03804056718945503,
-0.23416197299957275,
-0.45507267117500305,
0.13269753754138947,
0.4382762908935547,
0.6200191378593445,
0.40226006507873535,
-0.47402840852737427,
-0.8024314045906067,
-0.560657799243927,
-0.3015788793563843,
-0.300383061170578,
-0.23006078600883484,
0.025106022134423256,
0.302374929189682,
-0.25976088643074036,
1.1837115287780762,
-0.4161299169063568,
-0.4221051335334778,
-0.2781980633735657,
0.6105623841285706,
0.32613319158554077,
0.5598610639572144,
0.5979816913604736,
-0.550033450126648,
-0.19767047464847565,
0.22835126519203186,
-1.0644636154174805,
-0.2961968183517456,
0.07711558789014816,
-0.37724635004997253,
0.15975479781627655,
0.5665149092674255,
-0.429240882396698,
0.745394766330719,
0.4194450378417969,
-0.2064988762140274,
0.5098636150360107,
-0.14946705102920532,
-0.13846832513809204,
-0.9918761253356934,
0.1506020426750183,
-0.07825984805822372,
-0.2669011056423187,
-0.6285752654075623,
-0.0455084927380085,
-0.07930061221122742,
0.0016760394209995866,
-0.5103433132171631,
0.428666353225708,
-0.5494107007980347,
-0.3904568552970886,
-0.23450614511966705,
0.0995841771364212,
-0.008987137116491795,
0.4293627142906189,
0.5114322900772095,
0.13078421354293823,
0.3258989453315735,
-0.6099386811256409,
0.191597118973732,
0.7219359874725342,
-0.22710508108139038,
-0.036721352487802505,
-0.5070147514343262,
0.07130373269319534,
-0.21551665663719177,
0.3372536599636078,
-0.6258799433708191,
-0.21660171449184418,
0.21686500310897827,
-0.5154233574867249,
0.3258974552154541,
-0.3609354496002197,
-0.3305712640285492,
0.054252203553915024,
-0.09373489022254944,
0.22835423052310944,
0.5974931716918945,
-0.5727249383926392,
0.7442635297775269,
0.6219769716262817,
-0.415874183177948,
-0.6569497585296631,
-0.4449133276939392,
-0.15869048237800598,
-0.09231908619403839,
-0.6128496527671814,
0.5704033374786377,
0.28888875246047974,
0.1948162466287613,
0.15743345022201538,
-0.06966979801654816,
-0.3501107096672058,
-0.2796972990036011,
0.24817661941051483,
0.6305200457572937,
-0.22563043236732483,
0.21642029285430908,
-0.05086259916424751,
-0.2799321711063385,
0.2642362117767334,
0.02234356477856636,
0.37726128101348877,
0.2883570194244385,
-0.32870104908943176,
-0.7396603226661682,
0.7538840770721436,
0.2719661593437195,
-0.27156350016593933,
0.8281816840171814,
0.9409677386283875,
-0.5554857850074768,
0.322005033493042,
-0.43923142552375793,
-0.6110915541648865,
-0.38306429982185364,
0.3273569345474243,
-0.12027867138385773,
-0.6678191423416138,
0.49162399768829346,
-0.2846517264842987,
0.0706339180469513,
0.5769219994544983,
0.5324962735176086,
-0.4089374244213104,
0.8076799511909485,
0.3062426447868347,
-0.21483080089092255,
0.7636796832084656,
-0.11798272281885147,
0.010488198138773441,
-0.8020336031913757,
-0.316333532333374,
-0.39880797266960144,
-0.3437094986438751,
-0.3927772641181946,
-0.3052596151828766,
0.5617470741271973,
0.33013734221458435,
0.17183008790016174,
0.4550008475780487,
-0.18985357880592346,
0.012831359170377254,
0.7452747225761414,
0.31355762481689453,
0.21891900897026062,
-0.14154548943042755,
-0.16535018384456635,
-0.38297852873802185,
-0.9688880443572998,
-0.3506348729133606,
1.0849686861038208,
0.06502684950828552,
0.25670382380485535,
-0.012726597487926483,
1.2362370491027832,
-0.12109871953725815,
0.35130637884140015,
-0.556906521320343,
0.3539468050003052,
-0.13349060714244843,
-0.6540753245353699,
-0.2584325671195984,
-0.3757131099700928,
-1.4156885147094727,
-0.043414440006017685,
-0.6830652356147766,
-1.2906084060668945,
0.5623815059661865,
-0.09998635947704315,
-0.2491360306739807,
0.3194299042224884,
-0.6785627007484436,
0.9698562622070312,
-0.015212435275316238,
-0.47135674953460693,
0.10166805237531662,
-1.1876678466796875,
0.16173101961612701,
-0.023208897560834885,
0.3261926770210266,
-0.10692396014928818,
0.3400564193725586,
1.0815314054489136,
-0.35680878162384033,
0.7626855969429016,
-0.1952444463968277,
0.2836451530456543,
0.15134252607822418,
-0.18926484882831573,
0.49290862679481506,
0.17381414771080017,
-0.11781518906354904,
0.19583529233932495,
0.4625435769557953,
-0.31593140959739685,
-0.38900062441825867,
0.4067551791667938,
-0.6107925176620483,
-0.2366228550672531,
-0.3155299425125122,
-0.4800303280353546,
-0.16683296859264374,
0.04592185094952583,
0.3371238708496094,
0.6370410919189453,
-0.26911723613739014,
0.1692945808172226,
0.5978587865829468,
-0.3764820098876953,
0.649179995059967,
0.2918359935283661,
-0.18205556273460388,
-0.1872580200433731,
0.7297720313072205,
-0.024385502561926842,
0.2676143944263458,
0.5357296466827393,
0.12106886506080627,
-0.4135560095310211,
-0.3355696499347687,
-0.19996288418769836,
0.23933228850364685,
-0.38557684421539307,
-0.36733686923980713,
-1.138432502746582,
-0.3934451639652252,
-0.6828798055648804,
-0.14531831443309784,
-0.2160876840353012,
-0.17852672934532166,
-0.5258758068084717,
0.03476902097463608,
0.2790414094924927,
0.3302479088306427,
-0.6343734860420227,
0.02255518175661564,
-1.379976511001587,
0.5492625832557678,
0.23096773028373718,
-0.0029528148006647825,
-0.3544684946537018,
-0.05977126955986023,
0.11969703435897827,
-0.3577694296836853,
-0.3811245858669281,
-1.346686840057373,
0.5347752571105957,
0.4712899923324585,
0.7963360548019409,
0.6602937579154968,
0.038213759660720825,
0.6313362717628479,
-0.49749720096588135,
0.522925078868866,
0.4566059112548828,
-0.9064109325408936,
0.9518890976905823,
-0.3327936828136444,
0.044618453830480576,
0.3721461892127991,
0.6432702541351318,
-0.16884540021419525,
-0.2529348134994507,
-1.1566200256347656,
-0.8547101020812988,
0.6792317032814026,
0.2306816428899765,
-0.5825750827789307,
-0.1655055433511734,
0.4953853189945221,
0.21205854415893555,
0.0052132634446024895,
-0.6799556016921997,
-0.22147363424301147,
0.5006459951400757,
-0.22781938314437866,
0.20045314729213715,
-0.3413921296596527,
-0.11005089432001114,
-0.2762693166732788,
0.576801598072052,
0.04636046290397644,
0.437137633562088,
0.5636541843414307,
-0.08758096396923065,
0.1656508892774582,
0.11356755346059799,
-0.042835962027311325,
0.5016652941703796,
-0.7117530107498169,
-0.16122253239154816,
0.14840836822986603,
-0.39416950941085815,
-0.16655780375003815,
0.5062544941902161,
0.19511929154396057,
0.25225716829299927,
0.9988237023353577,
0.44601136445999146,
0.24957193434238434,
-0.6833342909812927,
0.7389664649963379,
0.15064574778079987,
-0.4349701702594757,
0.23164814710617065,
-0.035800155252218246,
0.06657647341489792,
0.39894774556159973,
0.1776559054851532,
-0.2590336799621582,
0.42062386870384216,
-0.6337050795555115,
0.9152896404266357,
0.461176335811615,
-0.6249892115592957,
-0.3072800934314728,
0.7958245277404785,
0.260620653629303,
-0.126918762922287,
0.4616498649120331,
-0.2305021733045578,
-0.34710949659347534,
0.6198526620864868,
0.4482816457748413,
0.49619215726852417,
-0.02118704281747341,
0.201940655708313,
0.4721265137195587,
-0.18144439160823822,
0.5088127255439758,
0.31548964977264404,
-0.07744447886943817,
-0.9053078293800354,
-1.054582953453064,
-0.821154773235321,
-0.355692982673645,
0.19051386415958405,
-1.1205273866653442,
0.4449215829372406,
-0.056109264492988586,
-0.13622118532657623,
0.6544003486633301,
0.18140219151973724,
-0.7205889225006104,
0.014020491391420364,
-0.014071816578507423,
0.6034363508224487,
-0.7594234347343445,
1.0843287706375122,
0.6154640316963196,
-0.39222609996795654,
-0.5409762263298035,
-0.23694747686386108,
0.04777611419558525,
-0.5229946374893188,
1.0353481769561768,
-0.05225450173020363,
0.45660555362701416,
-0.0406559482216835,
-0.2555208206176758,
-0.7369590997695923,
0.7623145580291748,
0.47006744146347046,
-0.7460311055183411,
-0.21376542747020721,
-0.24812841415405273,
0.35509711503982544,
-0.27486446499824524,
0.08831343799829483,
0.5127355456352234,
0.31924211978912354,
0.30846232175827026,
-0.8791381120681763,
-0.17614305019378662,
-0.030898036435246468,
-0.5907615423202515,
0.4574308395385742,
-0.007380079012364149,
0.44561898708343506,
-0.12439842522144318,
-0.37811073660850525,
-0.04303552582859993,
0.7084593176841736,
0.4524388015270233,
0.546013593673706,
0.4045146107673645,
0.277347207069397,
0.7560839056968689,
-0.053868617862463,
0.946491003036499,
-0.17249691486358643,
0.4492458999156952,
1.051235318183899,
-0.3394943177700043,
0.8991860747337341,
0.7071980834007263,
-0.32417258620262146,
0.5008111000061035,
0.5234262347221375,
0.44747626781463623,
0.7285870313644409,
0.10652542114257812,
-0.4431411325931549,
-0.3777957856655121,
-0.05786386877298355,
-0.6189866065979004,
0.4962817430496216,
0.5291199684143066,
-0.4273219704627991,
-0.4283064007759094,
0.07084384560585022,
-0.10737143456935883,
-0.2627723813056946,
-0.002928917296230793,
1.171515703201294,
0.07694119960069656,
-0.3614909052848816,
-0.012176701799035072,
-0.4492419958114624,
0.4695117473602295,
-0.7070446014404297,
-0.09885315597057343,
0.4151390790939331,
0.049005404114723206,
-0.002189199673011899,
-0.43363136053085327,
0.580247163772583,
-0.10157762467861176,
-0.37947705388069153,
0.03497950732707977,
0.9370100498199463,
-0.5658526420593262,
-0.36481356620788574,
0.6059888601303101,
0.6707796454429626,
0.3595070540904999,
0.15380047261714935,
-0.5732901096343994,
0.16158241033554077,
-0.0025474419817328453,
0.011634580790996552,
0.5927427411079407,
0.3873371481895447,
0.27898848056793213,
0.17692291736602783,
0.8520705699920654,
0.4006974399089813,
-0.057132281363010406,
-0.20485150814056396,
0.7120827436447144,
-0.6696181297302246,
-0.24950776994228363,
-0.8020355105400085,
0.3039642572402954,
-0.46192798018455505,
-0.3338642120361328,
0.1006363108754158,
0.4324890971183777,
0.5781493186950684,
0.02515583299100399,
0.6990453600883484,
-0.14378385245800018,
0.5987536907196045,
-0.5848453640937805,
0.5293160676956177,
-0.26228463649749756,
-0.06694325059652328,
-0.48707160353660583,
-0.6005809903144836,
-0.5577529668807983,
0.7790012955665588,
-0.27367347478866577,
-0.3095009922981262,
0.7927766442298889,
0.36750343441963196,
-0.08506150543689728,
0.26650264859199524,
0.20392774045467377,
-0.0511530302464962,
0.42577946186065674,
0.7915376424789429,
0.6433742642402649,
-0.5181705951690674,
0.32156628370285034,
0.09048686176538467,
-0.6146519184112549,
-0.23584751784801483,
-1.3354241847991943,
-0.9629995822906494,
-0.7053971886634827,
-0.591378390789032,
-0.3593667149543762,
0.3821192681789398,
1.1189920902252197,
0.9856637716293335,
-0.9440767168998718,
0.17465782165527344,
-0.05041544511914253,
0.0033824562560766935,
-0.1873820275068283,
-0.23955976963043213,
0.7124849557876587,
-0.8456085920333862,
-0.7591090202331543,
0.37026047706604004,
0.29452767968177795,
-0.20450621843338013,
0.4281240403652191,
0.17400842905044556,
-0.6739761829376221,
-0.39722704887390137,
0.5929639935493469,
0.44113510847091675,
-0.4855738878250122,
-0.4599204361438751,
-0.39059025049209595,
0.19883185625076294,
0.030684780329465866,
0.5275079607963562,
-0.9898085594177246,
0.38817843794822693,
0.5602200031280518,
1.0086289644241333,
0.9444195628166199,
-0.27432379126548767,
0.9521239399909973,
-0.8840316534042358,
0.3686619997024536,
0.06642793864011765,
0.32950878143310547,
-0.23545441031455994,
-0.3564256429672241,
0.5492221713066101,
0.4001864492893219,
-0.7080032825469971,
-0.6311305165290833,
0.18038776516914368,
-1.4572643041610718,
-0.16826574504375458,
1.0751246213912964,
-0.28090643882751465,
-0.23670196533203125,
-0.21852494776248932,
-0.08907198160886765,
0.7273415923118591,
-0.12107580155134201,
0.7096750140190125,
0.6093685030937195,
-0.535631000995636,
0.09336444735527039,
-0.481608510017395,
0.6927079558372498,
0.2700146734714508,
-0.8583592176437378,
-0.36625444889068604,
0.3096473217010498,
0.08411356806755066,
0.19884859025478363,
0.6066200137138367,
-0.2262611985206604,
0.24872982501983643,
-0.2959955930709839,
0.3080732822418213,
0.35496631264686584,
-0.3063478171825409,
0.13977183401584625,
0.41077205538749695,
-0.4811232089996338,
-0.4936477541923523
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.12374v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.12374v1
|
Improving Generalizability of Extracting Social Determinants of Health Using Large Language Models through Prompt-tuning
| 2024-03-19T02:34:33 | 2024-03-19T02:34:33 |
Cheng Peng, Zehao Yu, Kaleb E Smith, Wei-Hsuan Lo-Ciganic, Jiang Bian, Yonghui Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The progress in natural language processing (NLP) using large language models
(LLMs) has greatly improved patient information extraction from clinical
narratives. However, most methods based on the fine-tuning strategy have
limited transfer learning ability for cross-domain applications. This study
proposed a novel approach that employs a soft prompt-based learning
architecture, which introduces trainable prompts to guide LLMs toward desired
outputs. We examined two types of LLM architectures, including encoder-only
GatorTron and decoder-only GatorTronGPT, and evaluated their performance for
the extraction of social determinants of health (SDoH) using a
cross-institution dataset from the 2022 n2c2 challenge and a cross-disease
dataset from the University of Florida (UF) Health. The results show that
decoder-only LLMs with prompt tuning achieved better performance in
cross-domain applications. GatorTronGPT achieved the best F1 scores for both
datasets, outperforming traditional fine-tuned GatorTron by 8.9% and 21.8% in a
cross-institution setting, and 5.5% and 14.5% in a cross-disease setting.
|
[
0.02940056473016739,
-0.8657771348953247,
0.5817270278930664,
0.0553918331861496,
-0.2577874958515167,
0.16394463181495667,
-0.4955078661441803,
-0.4600291848182678,
0.2619573473930359,
0.1857519894838333,
-0.5522955656051636,
-0.6071901321411133,
-0.6910287737846375,
0.4405260384082794,
0.13555483520030975,
1.1218098402023315,
0.2330910861492157,
0.2825635075569153,
-0.09076990932226181,
-0.12249448895454407,
-0.4859195053577423,
-0.42367973923683167,
-0.9440010786056519,
-0.24554505944252014,
0.5683191418647766,
0.4951890707015991,
0.641693115234375,
0.7854135632514954,
0.25473836064338684,
0.1874719113111496,
0.022350724786520004,
0.27379292249679565,
-0.24326109886169434,
0.35934892296791077,
-0.561030924320221,
-0.18245762586593628,
-0.2093702256679535,
-0.24423880875110626,
0.3490847051143646,
0.7155355215072632,
-0.010687783360481262,
0.2911779284477234,
0.3872675597667694,
0.6887717843055725,
-0.44371774792671204,
0.39433568716049194,
-0.32032114267349243,
0.008833365514874458,
-0.13535664975643158,
-0.392115980386734,
-0.34418320655822754,
-0.461465060710907,
0.2531055212020874,
-0.5022251605987549,
0.36042529344558716,
0.11354885250329971,
0.7680172920227051,
0.2595834732055664,
-0.45501458644866943,
-0.5846531391143799,
-0.4748464822769165,
0.7232848405838013,
-0.39385557174682617,
0.3257358968257904,
0.282822847366333,
0.42518559098243713,
-0.14832326769828796,
-0.6048597693443298,
-0.035635244101285934,
-0.02047966979444027,
-0.08154613524675369,
-0.08238320052623749,
-0.23736673593521118,
-0.038059528917074203,
0.13190212845802307,
0.11159151047468185,
-0.7169827222824097,
0.23836420476436615,
-0.29757553339004517,
-0.3831992745399475,
0.743394672870636,
0.42337387800216675,
0.5056544542312622,
-0.354378342628479,
-0.2557687759399414,
0.06630495190620422,
-0.6312278509140015,
0.2577550709247589,
0.03294416517019272,
0.7451698184013367,
-0.3630315959453583,
0.2774280309677124,
-0.19931982457637787,
0.21831727027893066,
0.35157832503318787,
-0.005585470236837864,
0.5209193229675293,
-0.23451273143291473,
-0.10942485183477402,
0.22347068786621094,
0.6963486671447754,
0.21056751906871796,
0.10602253675460815,
-0.46657097339630127,
-0.12915544211864471,
-0.187173530459404,
0.10268740355968475,
-0.8787151575088501,
-0.12217879295349121,
0.3719748854637146,
-0.6578261852264404,
-0.11060307919979095,
-0.22751344740390778,
-1.2015469074249268,
-0.5890981554985046,
-0.5135179162025452,
0.19278566539287567,
-0.47758322954177856,
-0.10009877383708954,
0.12672270834445953,
0.09519105404615402,
0.37177976965904236,
0.2925397753715515,
-1.2332044839859009,
0.33190828561782837,
0.8405847549438477,
1.1400961875915527,
-0.43325042724609375,
0.14473366737365723,
-1.0699379444122314,
-0.08555616438388824,
-0.12072006613016129,
0.6649109721183777,
-0.6590888500213623,
-0.25025224685668945,
0.3635317385196686,
0.30410581827163696,
-0.41844791173934937,
-0.6385875940322876,
0.7368355989456177,
-0.20867407321929932,
0.06947223097085953,
-0.400533527135849,
-0.421404093503952,
0.17877328395843506,
0.061628635972738266,
-0.6216924786567688,
0.712110161781311,
0.3002933859825134,
-0.4260728359222412,
0.29111945629119873,
-0.25708630681037903,
-0.8122245073318481,
0.3287944197654724,
-0.40815556049346924,
-0.41471800208091736,
0.2506687641143799,
0.5518479943275452,
0.7370556592941284,
-0.5384718179702759,
0.5780205130577087,
-0.21068890392780304,
-0.33872610330581665,
-0.13603723049163818,
-0.20692108571529388,
0.7799304127693176,
0.182496577501297,
-0.4364391565322876,
0.2666788399219513,
-0.8862794041633606,
-0.1127830445766449,
0.1847948580980301,
-0.35771453380584717,
-0.23891852796077728,
-0.0017418648349121213,
-0.11372669786214828,
0.2888130843639374,
0.009114396758377552,
-0.391412615776062,
0.09368091821670532,
-0.44108715653419495,
0.4329809844493866,
0.8254261612892151,
0.03724002465605736,
0.5492809414863586,
-0.392976850271225,
0.6240906715393066,
-0.2114086002111435,
0.15593485534191132,
0.011332283727824688,
-0.5596803426742554,
-0.24602869153022766,
-0.5191776156425476,
0.1961170881986618,
0.646557629108429,
-1.0205705165863037,
0.3434596359729767,
-0.3210875988006592,
-0.21234552562236786,
-0.6298457980155945,
0.11885592341423035,
0.30433255434036255,
0.730322003364563,
0.6176031231880188,
0.054986800998449326,
-0.3509145677089691,
-0.5215253233909607,
-0.40777117013931274,
0.1659681648015976,
-0.2844262421131134,
0.5506191849708557,
0.3914934992790222,
-0.09807633608579636,
0.5676080584526062,
-0.2954027056694031,
-0.36656442284584045,
-0.6935230493545532,
-0.06352987885475159,
0.3534349799156189,
0.41334637999534607,
0.4320327043533325,
-0.5590353012084961,
-0.5061137080192566,
0.08194384723901749,
-0.6813606023788452,
-0.4009230434894562,
-0.02049149014055729,
-0.030280860140919685,
0.06555748730897903,
0.3050287961959839,
-0.5154117345809937,
0.27205973863601685,
0.36192429065704346,
-0.3416460454463959,
0.6366681456565857,
-0.13506023585796356,
-0.00924178771674633,
-0.9973879456520081,
0.11218883097171783,
0.26791930198669434,
0.013471645303070545,
-0.7200431227684021,
-0.1890111118555069,
0.20172056555747986,
-0.19704219698905945,
-0.4196484088897705,
0.8018676042556763,
-0.49775782227516174,
0.2341679185628891,
-0.01941516436636448,
-0.0807000920176506,
-0.007142723072320223,
0.4856148362159729,
-0.04182497784495354,
0.6371335983276367,
0.6572120785713196,
-0.6878163814544678,
0.284696489572525,
0.34571972489356995,
-0.2613306939601898,
0.6711505055427551,
-0.9423364996910095,
0.1604672223329544,
-0.3177347779273987,
0.12390682846307755,
-0.7617388367652893,
-0.3707810044288635,
0.5393573045730591,
-0.4745962917804718,
0.3187498152256012,
-0.1655907928943634,
-0.15446656942367554,
-0.08387098461389542,
-0.35488492250442505,
0.12152332812547684,
0.4463430345058441,
-0.6086232662200928,
0.5703082084655762,
0.19804111123085022,
-0.49500420689582825,
-0.3060658276081085,
-0.45099687576293945,
-0.05644138902425766,
-0.24190881848335266,
-0.5361964702606201,
0.4158606231212616,
0.1180468425154686,
-0.03018857166171074,
-0.24120862782001495,
-0.007010006345808506,
0.17807522416114807,
0.018568966537714005,
0.27102598547935486,
0.45752623677253723,
-0.2694035470485687,
0.430539608001709,
0.22088311612606049,
-0.2291317582130432,
0.1316821426153183,
0.03472553938627243,
0.6014847159385681,
0.11668118089437485,
-0.010262534953653812,
-0.4513382911682129,
0.577411949634552,
0.18685099482536316,
-0.26748165488243103,
0.6555795669555664,
0.5223519802093506,
-0.3221624791622162,
-0.4569297730922699,
-0.1257675737142563,
-0.20409461855888367,
-0.4738040566444397,
0.32161763310432434,
-0.16746409237384796,
-1.0648956298828125,
0.5062015652656555,
-0.2563896179199219,
0.018269425258040428,
0.2711966931819916,
0.5984642505645752,
0.3595891296863556,
1.1905999183654785,
0.5563628077507019,
-0.25532346963882446,
0.413566529750824,
0.15387612581253052,
-0.05577130988240242,
-0.8708223700523376,
-0.34667572379112244,
-0.8819589614868164,
-0.17390479147434235,
-0.44552701711654663,
-0.13136550784111023,
0.43055689334869385,
-0.2563118636608124,
-0.26492634415626526,
-0.06243767961859703,
-0.512409508228302,
0.10978690534830093,
0.2191840261220932,
0.4031093716621399,
0.07072027772665024,
0.16131292283535004,
-0.13954395055770874,
-0.04547586292028427,
-0.5050472617149353,
-0.35360071063041687,
1.0453052520751953,
0.289361834526062,
0.7458887100219727,
0.21337485313415527,
0.6121640801429749,
0.38160440325737,
0.05414985865354538,
-0.7783990502357483,
0.3790627121925354,
-0.31561043858528137,
-0.23684567213058472,
-0.2654555141925812,
-0.619063675403595,
-1.2152535915374756,
0.2377854734659195,
-0.1753481775522232,
-0.8484536409378052,
0.3998035192489624,
-0.0003924249322153628,
-0.6508255004882812,
-0.0035152025520801544,
-0.4635694622993469,
0.6271794438362122,
-0.23394200205802917,
-0.4988970160484314,
0.14198428392410278,
-0.7568654417991638,
-0.012044206261634827,
0.22041581571102142,
0.23063892126083374,
-0.34941336512565613,
0.031773146241903305,
0.49370336532592773,
-0.12623456120491028,
0.7753448486328125,
-0.24588444828987122,
-0.0960436686873436,
-0.12907977402210236,
-0.19048132002353668,
0.600886881351471,
0.3000311553478241,
-0.36824721097946167,
0.21360526978969574,
-0.24082686007022858,
-0.30015450716018677,
-0.7171998620033264,
0.5958460569381714,
-0.7090715169906616,
-0.6000227928161621,
-0.32554250955581665,
-0.18412458896636963,
-0.49427086114883423,
-0.0282618198543787,
0.21014800667762756,
0.8617519736289978,
-0.1503569334745407,
0.06665226072072983,
0.7612454295158386,
-0.5249658226966858,
0.3374400734901428,
0.44799095392227173,
0.1687459945678711,
-0.5399655699729919,
0.8681017756462097,
0.01169820036739111,
0.24364039301872253,
0.33512356877326965,
0.5848273634910583,
-0.3740924000740051,
-0.43483421206474304,
-0.7203277945518494,
0.1985720694065094,
-0.4444162845611572,
-0.321709543466568,
-0.7050845623016357,
-0.20001956820487976,
-0.7930477261543274,
-0.21596896648406982,
0.03962251543998718,
-0.0208139605820179,
-0.690585732460022,
-0.03622836619615555,
0.26073360443115234,
0.33080917596817017,
-0.14075644314289093,
-0.01838950626552105,
-0.8822365403175354,
0.49353262782096863,
0.12384901940822601,
0.20152784883975983,
0.09734448790550232,
-0.5263271331787109,
-0.22848819196224213,
-0.1480288952589035,
0.08025943487882614,
-0.9353556632995605,
0.5211226344108582,
0.4663639962673187,
0.7193738222122192,
0.30817607045173645,
0.26880863308906555,
0.44913166761398315,
-0.5453817248344421,
0.6563200354576111,
0.2033270001411438,
-0.7336866855621338,
0.7031094431877136,
-0.21302416920661926,
0.466402143239975,
0.8629661202430725,
0.5722479820251465,
-0.5396540760993958,
0.02299209125339985,
-0.1946079283952713,
-0.9282477498054504,
0.6095402240753174,
-0.3201926350593567,
0.14687226712703705,
-0.3040609359741211,
0.4128621816635132,
0.3914390504360199,
-0.04935193806886673,
-0.05336201563477516,
-0.26223742961883545,
-0.06602442264556885,
-0.5354803800582886,
-0.08012892305850983,
-0.19809187948703766,
0.03480873256921768,
-0.34493497014045715,
0.561654269695282,
-0.519261360168457,
0.18223127722740173,
0.4255978465080261,
-0.17811498045921326,
-0.1252264827489853,
0.5442273616790771,
0.27254849672317505,
0.36119967699050903,
0.02294073812663555,
0.25520241260528564,
-0.02804824896156788,
-0.6424720883369446,
0.15653665363788605,
0.26264432072639465,
-0.38872215151786804,
0.03607923910021782,
0.3585289418697357,
0.7934209704399109,
0.28899067640304565,
-0.5962185263633728,
0.5308707356452942,
-0.08779715746641159,
-0.127896249294281,
0.2565208673477173,
0.27804267406463623,
-0.2356581687927246,
0.40685418248176575,
0.4707374572753906,
-0.3200269937515259,
0.342593252658844,
-0.4877295196056366,
0.22990791499614716,
0.32031694054603577,
-0.5564063787460327,
-0.5158596038818359,
0.6948671340942383,
0.3191450536251068,
-0.3823438286781311,
0.5738725066184998,
-0.07379554957151413,
-0.19295825064182281,
0.5983699560165405,
0.7788172960281372,
0.9634631276130676,
-0.31657782196998596,
0.6162328720092773,
0.48748305439949036,
0.0713856965303421,
-0.0262044295668602,
0.3797197937965393,
-0.045186713337898254,
-0.4926941692829132,
-0.4751379191875458,
-0.6314906477928162,
-0.3932179808616638,
0.11260872334241867,
-0.9194731712341309,
0.20830361545085907,
-0.49997714161872864,
-0.11789914965629578,
0.12232815474271774,
0.28844234347343445,
-0.8320159912109375,
0.09580285102128983,
0.13079048693180084,
0.7665041089057922,
-0.7825143337249756,
0.6440608501434326,
0.6555798053741455,
-0.24299544095993042,
-0.8938586115837097,
-0.08518972992897034,
0.157014399766922,
-0.8128764629364014,
0.24498969316482544,
0.42636096477508545,
0.07542070746421814,
-0.07617563754320145,
-0.5906292796134949,
-0.6784735321998596,
0.989967942237854,
0.5792145729064941,
-0.6851422786712646,
-0.17048867046833038,
0.41789767146110535,
0.331694632768631,
-0.30331915616989136,
0.15458551049232483,
0.7012662887573242,
0.2970920205116272,
0.12387566268444061,
-0.7751092314720154,
0.5004072189331055,
-0.2827620804309845,
-0.11028743535280228,
0.05346111208200455,
-0.6037642955780029,
0.753393828868866,
-0.40729713439941406,
-0.5908262133598328,
0.019105101004242897,
0.5418885946273804,
0.25607559084892273,
0.4388171136379242,
0.2025490552186966,
0.17501595616340637,
1.037963628768921,
0.0513688325881958,
0.859109103679657,
-0.16651864349842072,
0.2850925028324127,
1.053421139717102,
-0.5948898792266846,
0.3235168159008026,
0.34967947006225586,
-0.033541154116392136,
0.43705055117607117,
0.45726263523101807,
0.08683089166879654,
0.658779501914978,
0.17455416917800903,
-0.2607609033584595,
-0.2000984251499176,
-0.2806396186351776,
-0.35497891902923584,
0.2438735067844391,
0.3602144718170166,
-0.6049998998641968,
-0.372426301240921,
0.06568964570760727,
0.18969188630580902,
-0.04964084178209305,
-0.4785839021205902,
0.8376041054725647,
0.21913957595825195,
-0.4082992672920227,
0.38483673334121704,
-0.07827561348676682,
0.7145395874977112,
-0.7332009077072144,
-0.24836696684360504,
-0.26967570185661316,
-0.06395794451236725,
-0.22157402336597443,
-0.47484883666038513,
0.17007459700107574,
-0.18969838321208954,
-0.13707150518894196,
-0.1188436895608902,
1.0158482789993286,
-0.2951113283634186,
-0.36874425411224365,
0.3004617989063263,
0.6684039831161499,
-0.00749377254396677,
0.06798702478408813,
-0.6112522482872009,
0.03652727231383324,
-0.09961267560720444,
-0.3398410975933075,
0.5406053066253662,
0.5144510865211487,
-0.10778883099555969,
0.5166993737220764,
0.8139573335647583,
0.31616535782814026,
-0.2247835397720337,
0.25494521856307983,
0.7359981536865234,
-0.7907076478004456,
-0.47190922498703003,
-0.9703109860420227,
0.21055938303470612,
-0.06789226830005646,
-0.551891565322876,
0.6481755375862122,
0.3022976517677307,
0.2341170608997345,
0.09955081343650818,
0.7595856785774231,
-0.05491090938448906,
0.613331139087677,
-0.4917188286781311,
0.5799273252487183,
-0.37243911623954773,
-0.10068366676568985,
-0.08045902848243713,
-0.30848056077957153,
-0.34214913845062256,
0.3059477210044861,
-0.33797261118888855,
-0.21681451797485352,
0.4851558804512024,
0.6465405821800232,
0.2987268567085266,
0.1962653547525406,
0.2365579903125763,
-0.08884761482477188,
0.48899710178375244,
0.7282288670539856,
0.4386593699455261,
-0.05686017870903015,
0.18737396597862244,
-0.00023024660185910761,
-0.3617081940174103,
-0.22679942846298218,
-0.700595498085022,
-0.8866462707519531,
-0.298733651638031,
-0.19250793755054474,
-0.4230285584926605,
0.44561827182769775,
1.093154788017273,
0.4378339350223541,
-0.8426103591918945,
0.2795262038707733,
0.31711435317993164,
0.17696085572242737,
-0.4573320150375366,
-0.24532246589660645,
0.699263334274292,
-0.5356206893920898,
-0.46427273750305176,
0.41530561447143555,
0.2941283881664276,
-0.3595231771469116,
-0.017857473343610764,
-0.028260134160518646,
0.0968490019440651,
0.14523902535438538,
0.6281307935714722,
0.3739789128303528,
-0.1990974247455597,
-0.4904773235321045,
0.07639037817716599,
-0.2779843807220459,
0.17474958300590515,
0.6868058443069458,
-0.7808383107185364,
0.024501679465174675,
0.356981486082077,
0.8847647309303284,
-0.09058588743209839,
0.09880705177783966,
0.4499865174293518,
-0.525252640247345,
-0.21253855526447296,
0.24516865611076355,
0.2598154842853546,
0.3573961853981018,
-0.7336759567260742,
0.40952691435813904,
0.19649948179721832,
-0.5865011811256409,
-0.4547725021839142,
-0.010180335491895676,
-0.8535045981407166,
-0.23414857685565948,
1.5317277908325195,
0.025897657498717308,
-0.5185773372650146,
-0.5232275128364563,
-0.16734711825847626,
0.38323646783828735,
-0.6796351075172424,
0.7591351866722107,
0.18756906688213348,
-0.25526416301727295,
-0.07915090024471283,
-0.637599766254425,
0.5229707956314087,
0.3014030456542969,
-1.0185496807098389,
0.0696864202618599,
0.48714563250541687,
0.46829214692115784,
-0.24785293638706207,
0.7367950081825256,
-0.20993547141551971,
0.321964293718338,
-0.3754916787147522,
-0.13783161342144012,
-0.05951830372214317,
-0.37090378999710083,
-0.6754776835441589,
0.3005915880203247,
-0.6437466740608215,
-0.12454220652580261
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.12373v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.12373v3
|
RankPrompt: Step-by-Step Comparisons Make Language Models Better Reasoners
| 2024-03-19T02:34:18 | 2024-03-22T06:18:54 |
Chi Hu, Yuan Ge, Xiangnan Ma, Hang Cao, Qiang Li, Yonghua Yang, Tong Xiao, Jingbo Zhu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have achieved impressive performance across
various reasoning tasks. However, even state-of-the-art LLMs such as ChatGPT
are prone to logical errors during their reasoning processes. Existing
solutions, such as deploying task-specific verifiers or voting over multiple
reasoning paths, either require extensive human annotations or fail in
scenarios with inconsistent responses. To address these challenges, we
introduce RankPrompt, a new prompting method that enables LLMs to self-rank
their responses without additional resources. RankPrompt breaks down the
ranking problem into a series of comparisons among diverse responses,
leveraging the inherent capabilities of LLMs to generate chains of comparison
as contextual exemplars. Our experiments across 11 arithmetic and commonsense
reasoning tasks show that RankPrompt significantly enhances the reasoning
performance of ChatGPT and GPT-4, with improvements of up to 13%. Moreover,
RankPrompt excels in LLM-based automatic evaluations for open-ended tasks,
aligning with human judgments 74% of the time in the AlpacaEval dataset. It
also exhibits robustness to variations in response order and consistency.
Collectively, our results validate RankPrompt as an effective method for
eliciting high-quality feedback from language models.
|
[
-0.27581587433815,
-0.5660362839698792,
0.8545125126838684,
0.3339326083660126,
-0.19922906160354614,
0.05601413547992706,
-0.2025865912437439,
-0.04035463184118271,
-0.015932781621813774,
0.5005340576171875,
-0.3217800557613373,
-0.5351336598396301,
-0.8126742839813232,
0.13335320353507996,
-0.4044244587421417,
0.8954368829727173,
0.22406068444252014,
-0.002069576410576701,
-0.46956953406333923,
-0.10493701696395874,
-0.5092982053756714,
-0.5564737319946289,
-1.04042649269104,
-0.41253823041915894,
0.6249414086341858,
0.4856245517730713,
0.8460320234298706,
0.22635842859745026,
0.582826554775238,
0.3856903910636902,
0.17554354667663574,
0.33109545707702637,
-0.3745512068271637,
0.4917324483394623,
-0.11994805932044983,
-0.33732345700263977,
-0.563504695892334,
0.22440887987613678,
0.35187044739723206,
0.6564180850982666,
-0.1646825671195984,
0.1702805459499359,
0.19082260131835938,
0.5178995728492737,
-0.4038182497024536,
0.2618394196033478,
-0.5028913021087646,
-0.34239697456359863,
-0.035793084651231766,
-0.40530112385749817,
-0.5509909987449646,
-0.5966964364051819,
-0.25778552889823914,
-0.3637259900569916,
0.109370157122612,
0.14228568971157074,
0.5532692074775696,
0.5369240641593933,
-0.3064276874065399,
-0.1158389076590538,
-0.3258988559246063,
0.5145770311355591,
-0.8759545683860779,
0.5505455136299133,
0.40395691990852356,
0.36298590898513794,
-0.39367616176605225,
-0.6213143467903137,
-0.6141794919967651,
-0.6750087738037109,
-0.12933261692523956,
0.0992540568113327,
-0.1072009727358818,
-0.1366872787475586,
0.38718169927597046,
0.17557717859745026,
-0.6895222663879395,
0.07691234350204468,
-0.02069360390305519,
-0.16908963024616241,
0.3830544352531433,
-0.07186481356620789,
0.3016457259654999,
-0.21113193035125732,
-0.04123265668749809,
-0.29245734214782715,
-1.00814688205719,
0.19163696467876434,
0.34441766142845154,
0.25423336029052734,
0.22326982021331787,
0.3526920974254608,
-0.37358465790748596,
0.8723510503768921,
0.06939265877008438,
-0.1355908215045929,
0.05927250161767006,
-0.001838677329942584,
-0.17292127013206482,
-0.04736093431711197,
0.7738038301467896,
0.4264083802700043,
0.21351630985736847,
-0.07507143169641495,
-0.33245596289634705,
-0.013631293550133705,
0.09266931563615799,
-0.7679402232170105,
-0.5997429490089417,
0.39396363496780396,
-0.13302360475063324,
-0.2616763114929199,
-0.25540393590927124,
-0.44724777340888977,
-0.5622438788414001,
-0.39800089597702026,
0.7240225076675415,
-0.26088449358940125,
-0.16788876056671143,
0.005419720895588398,
0.09391764551401138,
-0.02404577098786831,
0.740311861038208,
-0.8668299913406372,
0.23532624542713165,
0.847313642501831,
0.7234154343605042,
-0.35342422127723694,
-0.35926005244255066,
-0.940669596195221,
-0.21086792647838593,
-0.5394694209098816,
1.1205785274505615,
-0.5138346552848816,
-0.15457852184772491,
-0.2957714796066284,
-0.24513334035873413,
-0.07656805217266083,
-0.9444928765296936,
0.6960604786872864,
-0.3626633584499359,
0.33822616934776306,
-0.4601539969444275,
-0.5062345862388611,
0.2855982184410095,
0.45246702432632446,
-0.5181623101234436,
1.2878698110580444,
-0.10207261145114899,
-0.6493029594421387,
0.37571969628334045,
-0.600785493850708,
-0.3725023865699768,
0.1725221425294876,
-0.19448290765285492,
-0.17507655918598175,
0.09156770259141922,
0.5578135251998901,
0.5221740007400513,
-0.20214730501174927,
0.13825498521327972,
-0.19583140313625336,
-0.18014352023601532,
0.13489055633544922,
-0.33254948258399963,
0.6920391917228699,
0.14016588032245636,
-0.44819921255111694,
0.30771270394325256,
-0.38921675086021423,
0.1559181958436966,
0.2795875668525696,
-0.3233473598957062,
-0.3326078951358795,
0.07726185023784637,
-0.639182984828949,
0.2917976975440979,
0.06656599044799805,
-0.3773837685585022,
0.3802415132522583,
-0.23785005509853363,
0.35719889402389526,
0.8518325686454773,
-0.04196380078792572,
0.06351030617952347,
-0.2937953472137451,
0.44377845525741577,
-0.1727435439825058,
0.18604181706905365,
-0.12684859335422516,
-0.6681931018829346,
-0.985710084438324,
-0.16529323160648346,
0.36044272780418396,
0.455586314201355,
-0.6723344326019287,
0.44343897700309753,
-0.30231747031211853,
-0.4490273892879486,
-0.5153442025184631,
0.17743566632270813,
0.28884631395339966,
0.552452564239502,
0.42307835817337036,
-0.15550096333026886,
-0.15076111257076263,
-0.5744269490242004,
-0.45211273431777954,
-0.5587040781974792,
-0.2265527993440628,
-0.00019751035142689943,
0.24855804443359375,
0.2092278003692627,
0.6988308429718018,
-0.39624154567718506,
0.07140529155731201,
-0.3075833022594452,
0.35149064660072327,
0.2681153118610382,
0.29348623752593994,
0.11841028928756714,
-0.46405360102653503,
-0.18602335453033447,
-0.28579115867614746,
-0.482077419757843,
-0.5741168856620789,
-0.033242277801036835,
-0.23249773681163788,
0.004399369936436415,
0.58439040184021,
-0.5738805532455444,
0.03333728015422821,
0.5033217668533325,
-0.5677892565727234,
0.5397320985794067,
-0.21820485591888428,
0.4974420964717865,
-0.6786259412765503,
-0.1244688406586647,
-0.20425818860530853,
-0.6097634434700012,
-0.3406204283237457,
0.09055384248495102,
-0.015491019003093243,
-0.12177729606628418,
-0.19585520029067993,
0.6234070062637329,
-0.220350444316864,
-0.137430801987648,
-0.2573186755180359,
0.309009850025177,
0.038467250764369965,
0.3738948702812195,
0.007456830237060785,
0.9072461128234863,
0.4290063679218292,
-0.5821700692176819,
0.34687989950180054,
0.16935692727565765,
-0.31239038705825806,
0.5903562903404236,
-0.6828222274780273,
0.08701850473880768,
0.06121218204498291,
0.32830610871315,
-1.260213017463684,
-0.1289350837469101,
0.13954336941242218,
-0.5784459710121155,
0.05551217868924141,
-0.19116993248462677,
-0.7106687426567078,
-0.2929458022117615,
-0.18299047648906708,
0.1575804054737091,
0.6110399961471558,
-0.8005635738372803,
0.3288884162902832,
0.10077491402626038,
-0.5905040502548218,
-0.36928635835647583,
-0.20795953273773193,
0.25646522641181946,
-0.1395251601934433,
-0.3779408037662506,
0.003509456291794777,
-0.32141658663749695,
-0.35185718536376953,
-0.3669358491897583,
-0.2652883529663086,
0.17138130962848663,
0.18529334664344788,
0.22560863196849823,
0.1475500762462616,
0.019040575250983238,
0.20360979437828064,
-0.06799162179231644,
-0.35228919982910156,
0.2445334643125534,
-0.30613282322883606,
0.48099085688591003,
-0.2132388800382614,
-0.8207045793533325,
-0.24091050028800964,
0.06998372822999954,
0.6712287664413452,
-0.28940245509147644,
0.24061240255832672,
0.24859619140625,
-0.0053313253447413445,
-0.2834964096546173,
-0.7142098546028137,
-0.4820297956466675,
-0.46464672684669495,
-0.08964139223098755,
-0.3076581060886383,
-0.8907336592674255,
0.19495795667171478,
-0.26668357849121094,
0.3049388825893402,
0.2613448202610016,
0.7122765183448792,
-0.0912213921546936,
1.329783320426941,
0.13964709639549255,
0.14709937572479248,
0.17395786941051483,
0.14952419698238373,
0.5393570065498352,
-0.5151442885398865,
-0.22864671051502228,
-0.5168728232383728,
-0.1596507877111435,
-0.37673404812812805,
-0.5604826211929321,
0.5711647272109985,
0.1326533854007721,
-0.19168761372566223,
0.19771601259708405,
-0.45421427488327026,
0.7231773138046265,
0.4695776402950287,
-0.04888492450118065,
0.5123368501663208,
-0.1705288141965866,
-0.404811829328537,
-0.059770043939352036,
-0.614483654499054,
-0.4451150596141815,
0.74640953540802,
0.20375755429267883,
0.5889879465103149,
0.3050878643989563,
0.9809555411338806,
0.4331844449043274,
0.5172054171562195,
-0.7904454469680786,
0.7283620238304138,
-0.03879109397530556,
-0.18906284868717194,
-0.45160821080207825,
-0.4772968292236328,
-0.8246188759803772,
0.4690808653831482,
-0.03057209402322769,
-0.6252654194831848,
-0.14374105632305145,
0.36803025007247925,
-0.5367076396942139,
-0.0842171162366867,
-0.5814714431762695,
0.9073507189750671,
-0.30766645073890686,
-0.3289773762226105,
-0.008577666245400906,
-0.3123207688331604,
0.28158295154571533,
0.15138015151023865,
0.26192551851272583,
-0.4636700749397278,
0.17197304964065552,
0.6777270436286926,
-0.6501444578170776,
0.5922427177429199,
-0.1405530869960785,
-0.34821632504463196,
0.01262338925153017,
0.4471977949142456,
0.6276413798332214,
0.045406274497509,
-0.09501545876264572,
-0.11320091038942337,
-0.12052526324987411,
-0.30773183703422546,
-0.9899817705154419,
0.9239112138748169,
-0.4004474878311157,
-0.8990299105644226,
-0.2991417944431305,
-0.38174447417259216,
-0.4655303359031677,
0.059614505618810654,
0.2070837914943695,
0.5396573543548584,
0.305915504693985,
-0.02648358978331089,
0.7222601771354675,
-0.038411498069763184,
0.31247031688690186,
0.46062853932380676,
-0.4353794753551483,
-0.22497637569904327,
0.7874324321746826,
-0.0765407606959343,
0.3861847519874573,
0.18482068181037903,
0.34450823068618774,
-0.6075210571289062,
-0.43820029497146606,
-0.5036618709564209,
0.10200522094964981,
-1.0019255876541138,
-0.3215096592903137,
-0.6151824593544006,
0.0021466887556016445,
-0.5056024789810181,
-0.05381050705909729,
-0.3953598737716675,
-0.6553206443786621,
0.48847565054893494,
-0.1423829197883606,
0.3461199700832367,
0.7695529460906982,
-0.02929558977484703,
0.008920474909245968,
-0.4296005666255951,
0.4163200855255127,
0.6753795742988586,
0.2441236823797226,
-0.034327756613492966,
-0.6364021301269531,
0.1806158721446991,
-0.4479348659515381,
-0.2255002111196518,
-0.8405154347419739,
0.3000098466873169,
0.041205570101737976,
0.814673662185669,
0.21812134981155396,
0.15013554692268372,
0.5660268664360046,
-0.4736109972000122,
0.8711769580841064,
0.007073169574141502,
-0.9177661538124084,
0.757265567779541,
-0.3059556484222412,
0.44265714287757874,
0.5537362098693848,
0.3876796066761017,
-0.48092785477638245,
-0.8653184771537781,
-0.6500605940818787,
-0.933817446231842,
0.34574857354164124,
0.4094780385494232,
-0.10400636494159698,
-0.22075290977954865,
0.22019541263580322,
0.09920839965343475,
-0.01028660498559475,
-0.7644942402839661,
-0.17185725271701813,
-0.28751906752586365,
-0.11099377274513245,
-0.00011749470286304131,
-0.09774331003427505,
-0.039019178599119186,
-0.3739381432533264,
0.694982647895813,
-0.2816118896007538,
0.23194338381290436,
0.14564023911952972,
-0.2757173478603363,
0.12943050265312195,
0.4431522488594055,
0.48085254430770874,
0.8916558623313904,
0.010754047892987728,
0.5893756747245789,
0.3195112347602844,
0.018601978197693825,
0.27133893966674805,
0.03496967628598213,
0.05045256018638611,
0.05322981998324394,
0.5972462892532349,
0.5580840706825256,
0.40850043296813965,
-0.4962908625602722,
0.635083794593811,
-0.237151637673378,
-0.02198421210050583,
0.0184630136936903,
0.33439284563064575,
0.20884966850280762,
0.12753009796142578,
0.3200940191745758,
-0.21580085158348083,
0.24464762210845947,
-0.37385091185569763,
0.21388988196849823,
0.29997625946998596,
-0.07538364082574844,
0.1045297160744667,
0.5502514243125916,
0.3039293885231018,
-0.3090091049671173,
0.5594303607940674,
-0.3132093846797943,
-0.5445638298988342,
0.4213990271091461,
0.4381943643093109,
0.5194247364997864,
-0.40808555483818054,
0.3372630178928375,
0.4514046609401703,
0.11851578205823898,
-0.4544329345226288,
0.19296211004257202,
-0.19676817953586578,
-0.5357507467269897,
-0.6685406565666199,
-0.5910841226577759,
-0.6235207319259644,
0.18143917620182037,
-0.4639093279838562,
0.1471051573753357,
-0.5345614552497864,
-0.037258174270391464,
0.05793853476643562,
-0.16406680643558502,
-0.39045655727386475,
0.1613987386226654,
0.25623369216918945,
0.844025731086731,
-0.9234890937805176,
0.7427549362182617,
0.5359356999397278,
-0.3639090359210968,
-0.940892219543457,
0.20181100070476532,
0.08235924690961838,
-0.8075254559516907,
0.7876667976379395,
0.36745527386665344,
-0.2272886484861374,
0.24390067160129547,
-0.512018620967865,
-0.725935161113739,
0.7721073627471924,
0.6502385139465332,
-0.44342219829559326,
0.3430916666984558,
0.020711766555905342,
0.40697935223579407,
-0.2550758421421051,
0.656086802482605,
0.6749473810195923,
0.6621624827384949,
0.25082603096961975,
-0.9478265047073364,
0.21880611777305603,
-0.3028276562690735,
-0.3462725579738617,
0.23334121704101562,
-0.3722614645957947,
0.7332494258880615,
-0.30056655406951904,
0.08225215971469879,
-0.08945196121931076,
0.5281975269317627,
0.7060043215751648,
0.006310576107352972,
0.7460636496543884,
0.6744457483291626,
0.8981950879096985,
-0.271018385887146,
1.0497488975524902,
-0.22018083930015564,
0.20810091495513916,
1.1596044301986694,
-0.27811869978904724,
1.0340449810028076,
0.22193743288516998,
-0.16627395153045654,
0.7069339156150818,
0.6704249978065491,
0.20414218306541443,
0.34721195697784424,
0.24527902901172638,
-0.2841726541519165,
-0.8661593794822693,
0.021996937692165375,
-0.19952541589736938,
0.35123196244239807,
0.12261981517076492,
0.025751324370503426,
-0.5422378182411194,
-0.1341877281665802,
0.22042223811149597,
0.08522424846887589,
-0.21068352460861206,
0.6866952776908875,
0.09619956463575363,
-1.0965397357940674,
0.7976066470146179,
-0.24294522404670715,
0.45231008529663086,
-0.48894041776657104,
-0.35738611221313477,
-0.5657446980476379,
-0.035720035433769226,
-0.17138703167438507,
-0.8336693644523621,
0.01388255599886179,
0.03360912948846817,
0.06295643746852875,
-0.6058383584022522,
0.5905228853225708,
-0.3437357544898987,
-0.4290006458759308,
0.20754827558994293,
0.6722185015678406,
0.4355579614639282,
-0.3096776604652405,
-0.8104943633079529,
0.03052348643541336,
-0.2498452514410019,
-0.2901656925678253,
0.35449299216270447,
0.26772424578666687,
-0.33585333824157715,
0.8639578223228455,
0.7665220499038696,
0.096953384578228,
-0.13633330166339874,
0.5109013319015503,
0.7012673616409302,
-0.44555744528770447,
-0.42600852251052856,
-0.90666663646698,
0.2856558561325073,
-0.2537970542907715,
-0.14252667129039764,
0.8106477856636047,
0.3099648356437683,
0.6325439810752869,
0.16655822098255157,
0.6111111044883728,
0.07567772269248962,
0.6318179368972778,
-0.6695548295974731,
0.6720649003982544,
-0.5173220634460449,
0.41698482632637024,
0.029402753338217735,
-0.7652837038040161,
-0.37963980436325073,
0.6529814004898071,
-0.5948547124862671,
0.11740522086620331,
0.9139161705970764,
0.8676014542579651,
0.058712221682071686,
-0.30195191502571106,
0.42862793803215027,
0.20683187246322632,
0.4588814079761505,
0.39165744185447693,
0.9710491895675659,
0.01481780968606472,
0.5071274042129517,
0.08966393768787384,
-0.24103586375713348,
-0.24943940341472626,
-1.097529411315918,
-0.8756464719772339,
-0.38014814257621765,
-0.48843708634376526,
-0.3401601314544678,
0.22263599932193756,
1.0608245134353638,
0.7817768454551697,
-0.9616442918777466,
-0.11336683481931686,
-0.05270645022392273,
0.24835121631622314,
-0.3028114438056946,
-0.19011154770851135,
0.32295891642570496,
-0.6986886262893677,
-0.6225823760032654,
0.7092500329017639,
0.31506890058517456,
-0.23199614882469177,
-0.2885023057460785,
-0.18895313143730164,
0.15620754659175873,
0.123807393014431,
0.5371761322021484,
0.14415523409843445,
-0.9604494571685791,
-0.2843894064426422,
-0.27759653329849243,
-0.08104675263166428,
0.10521913319826126,
0.950928807258606,
-1.0058506727218628,
0.22784732282161713,
0.7212877869606018,
0.4294740855693817,
-0.0015319448430091143,
0.20520639419555664,
0.5422554612159729,
-0.697478175163269,
-0.19871510565280914,
0.12206903100013733,
0.46825283765792847,
0.5750077962875366,
-0.40635356307029724,
0.47471779584884644,
0.08102796971797943,
-0.7031643390655518,
-0.6991761922836304,
0.25780245661735535,
-0.8278012275695801,
-0.24809370934963226,
1.1673716306686401,
-0.33742475509643555,
0.05150313675403595,
-0.02970985323190689,
-0.20073682069778442,
-0.05940653756260872,
-0.497801810503006,
0.8950737118721008,
0.6566176414489746,
-0.4684901237487793,
-0.38165283203125,
-0.7353405952453613,
0.6808105111122131,
0.7640748023986816,
-1.1328624486923218,
0.3390035033226013,
0.4116378724575043,
0.40710127353668213,
0.017930565401911736,
0.8252742290496826,
-0.05145411938428879,
0.2625584304332733,
-0.27223652601242065,
-0.1517018973827362,
-0.19524165987968445,
-0.47625532746315,
-0.2021244764328003,
0.23305898904800415,
0.5493524670600891,
0.18445074558258057
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.12368v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.12368v1
|
Characteristic AI Agents via Large Language Models
| 2024-03-19T02:25:29 | 2024-03-19T02:25:29 |
Xi Wang, Hongliang Dai, Shen Gao, Piji Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The advancement of Large Language Models (LLMs) has led to significant
enhancements in the performance of chatbot systems. Many researchers have
dedicated their efforts to the development of bringing characteristics to
chatbots. While there have been commercial products for developing role-driven
chatbots using LLMs, it is worth noting that academic research in this area
remains relatively scarce. Our research focuses on investigating the
performance of LLMs in constructing Characteristic AI Agents by simulating
real-life individuals across different settings. Current investigations have
primarily focused on act on roles with simple profiles. In response to this
research gap, we create a benchmark for the characteristic AI agents task,
including dataset, techniques, and evaluation metrics. A dataset called
``Character100'' is built for this benchmark, comprising the most-visited
people on Wikipedia for language models to role-play. With the constructed
dataset, we conduct comprehensive assessment of LLMs across various settings.
In addition, we devise a set of automatic metrics for quantitative performance
evaluation. The experimental results underscore the potential directions for
further improvement in the capabilities of LLMs in constructing characteristic
AI agents. The benchmark is available at
https://github.com/nuaa-nlp/Character100.
|
[
-0.21939019858837128,
-0.7142576575279236,
0.2946734130382538,
0.2658809721469879,
0.26617977023124695,
0.18349692225456238,
-0.3578752279281616,
-0.5527521371841431,
0.36125636100769043,
0.7237712740898132,
-0.2253253310918808,
-0.44005241990089417,
-0.3199149966239929,
0.2465110719203949,
-0.6016419529914856,
0.654190719127655,
0.2633991837501526,
0.1949811428785324,
-0.47146111726760864,
-0.13363459706306458,
-0.5357983708381653,
-0.6604086756706238,
-0.8187400698661804,
-0.4067811369895935,
0.5096781253814697,
0.2676549553871155,
0.5907217264175415,
0.671208381652832,
0.4425587058067322,
0.45963993668556213,
0.06402523815631866,
0.2794238030910492,
-0.6026312112808228,
0.438147634267807,
0.0195506252348423,
-0.7202432155609131,
-0.6893723011016846,
0.22705921530723572,
0.9306108951568604,
0.31414794921875,
0.09246351569890976,
0.13773085176944733,
0.16638313233852386,
0.358917236328125,
-0.06519622355699539,
0.6505207419395447,
-0.5534176826477051,
-0.20317381620407104,
-0.15818051993846893,
-0.1792261153459549,
-0.4805700182914734,
-0.18533910810947418,
-0.019244588911533356,
-0.45443543791770935,
0.24876074492931366,
0.18880778551101685,
0.7193663120269775,
-0.021245663985610008,
-0.3307066559791565,
-0.2608310580253601,
-0.9116312265396118,
0.8888410329818726,
-0.7159028649330139,
0.19829359650611877,
0.3157394826412201,
0.5228660702705383,
-0.3329756259918213,
-0.6085785627365112,
-0.4237060546875,
-0.8687444925308228,
-0.0557313971221447,
-0.22164224088191986,
-0.06879808008670807,
-0.11339307576417923,
0.3720673620700836,
0.23200015723705292,
-0.4899308681488037,
0.38789451122283936,
-0.07808578014373779,
-0.11959787458181381,
0.9382867217063904,
0.504549503326416,
0.2632930874824524,
0.07458408921957016,
0.01050281897187233,
-0.43591728806495667,
-0.633395791053772,
0.311282217502594,
0.46928101778030396,
0.4599294066429138,
-0.31756117939949036,
0.6419511437416077,
-0.418674498796463,
0.17542293667793274,
-0.22740331292152405,
-0.31029391288757324,
0.2856174111366272,
0.0030232828576117754,
0.1625732183456421,
-0.08113904297351837,
0.8094468116760254,
0.1079605296254158,
0.6232480406761169,
-0.24677704274654388,
-0.4666827321052551,
-0.1371614933013916,
0.4055521786212921,
-0.9054598212242126,
-0.0873003676533699,
0.14959093928337097,
-0.45034921169281006,
-0.4168669879436493,
-0.20507249236106873,
-0.5214381217956543,
-0.6618033051490784,
-0.3550066351890564,
0.4827646315097809,
-0.5210675001144409,
-0.1007997915148735,
-0.40847423672676086,
0.008740844205021858,
0.42112940549850464,
0.28565022349357605,
-0.6635130643844604,
0.41208645701408386,
0.9426147937774658,
0.6581476926803589,
-0.29585108160972595,
-0.4656308889389038,
-0.5942782163619995,
-0.2037583291530609,
-0.4586881697177887,
0.6906479597091675,
-0.8338609933853149,
-0.28463515639305115,
0.1277112066745758,
-0.03272544965147972,
0.16445331275463104,
-0.7719004154205322,
0.34221720695495605,
-0.42510321736335754,
-0.11793656647205353,
-0.27002081274986267,
-0.6305683851242065,
0.029635954648256302,
0.5612621903419495,
-0.67476886510849,
0.8602861762046814,
0.18844613432884216,
-0.26918840408325195,
0.1820027083158493,
-0.6936708092689514,
-0.42379599809646606,
0.37178727984428406,
-0.3971215486526489,
-0.2251395583152771,
-0.020286941900849342,
-0.10960566252470016,
0.5910500288009644,
-0.4221644401550293,
0.03261406347155571,
-0.22669774293899536,
-0.7085965871810913,
0.8080781698226929,
-0.6137672662734985,
0.5453199744224548,
-0.04829687252640724,
-0.18537785112857819,
0.24681785702705383,
-0.6618881821632385,
0.002889742609113455,
0.10503034293651581,
-0.27757638692855835,
-0.10637465864419937,
0.08582977205514908,
-0.04611041024327278,
-0.15658487379550934,
0.4286670982837677,
-0.3133622705936432,
0.21243329346179962,
-0.1659860759973526,
0.2019083946943283,
0.6177329421043396,
-0.225473552942276,
0.25420740246772766,
-0.4639946222305298,
0.7022066116333008,
-0.33601999282836914,
0.10328925400972366,
-0.07313177734613419,
-0.26629123091697693,
-0.7469181418418884,
-0.6385844349861145,
0.24745336174964905,
0.43071380257606506,
-0.5656886100769043,
0.6895902156829834,
-0.21620295941829681,
-0.6601108908653259,
-0.3616408705711365,
0.3089517056941986,
0.5258068442344666,
0.10844679176807404,
0.11193790286779404,
-0.5162327289581299,
-0.07480642944574356,
-0.8872119188308716,
-0.15835954248905182,
-0.5172874331474304,
-0.21885833144187927,
0.7032386660575867,
0.30340906977653503,
-0.19248227775096893,
0.7359475493431091,
-0.21614888310432434,
-0.29576218128204346,
-0.41263991594314575,
0.15059509873390198,
0.05514822527766228,
0.31215623021125793,
0.5922962427139282,
-0.5383769869804382,
-0.4526970088481903,
-0.1931179314851761,
-0.8185965418815613,
-0.20884084701538086,
0.05484911426901817,
-0.00040358977275900543,
0.08897368609905243,
0.5987541079521179,
-0.6790765523910522,
0.20467577874660492,
0.5467369556427002,
-0.2623630166053772,
0.641224205493927,
-0.2795078754425049,
0.35195326805114746,
-0.9109845161437988,
0.3588014841079712,
0.09469349682331085,
-0.34615492820739746,
-0.6611738801002502,
0.036956075578927994,
-0.1801358014345169,
-0.05269593745470047,
-0.37240365147590637,
0.7324231266975403,
-0.2926363945007324,
-0.36749112606048584,
-0.3394176661968231,
0.06412863731384277,
-0.2802865505218506,
0.4978177547454834,
-0.21552881598472595,
0.9486785531044006,
0.47162574529647827,
-0.6970363259315491,
0.6206418871879578,
0.13148577511310577,
-0.3894786238670349,
0.6398812532424927,
-0.9550819396972656,
-0.038502246141433716,
0.0737936869263649,
0.16404548287391663,
-0.9852882623672485,
-0.3622393012046814,
0.073677197098732,
-0.39305251836776733,
0.3180563747882843,
0.025836467742919922,
-0.7885183095932007,
-0.2012532651424408,
-0.17949996888637543,
0.3179672360420227,
0.7397695779800415,
-0.10146874189376831,
0.6173558235168457,
0.4873811602592468,
-0.19347341358661652,
-0.34889936447143555,
-0.21026702225208282,
0.1522563397884369,
-0.4918884038925171,
-0.3208205997943878,
0.2703325152397156,
0.05363935977220535,
-0.429364413022995,
-0.1567172408103943,
0.27520179748535156,
0.08005380630493164,
0.3232342004776001,
0.4846205711364746,
0.05984056368470192,
-0.2598423659801483,
0.163161963224411,
-0.30064448714256287,
-0.02743370831012726,
0.12364258617162704,
0.5338567495346069,
0.9066065549850464,
-0.18425355851650238,
-0.22347238659858704,
-0.7636174559593201,
-0.027999397367239,
0.752116858959198,
-0.2658196985721588,
0.7894406914710999,
0.3744068741798401,
-0.043283749371767044,
-0.44811710715293884,
-0.6160357594490051,
-0.37149837613105774,
-0.4982856810092926,
0.6312846541404724,
-0.34888529777526855,
-0.8175166845321655,
0.7507926821708679,
0.05587805435061455,
0.20398913323879242,
0.3662793040275574,
0.4002956748008728,
-0.2042028307914734,
0.9393782019615173,
0.6770305037498474,
-0.39809685945510864,
0.587946355342865,
-0.10411334037780762,
-0.07202167809009552,
-0.671327531337738,
-0.19845224916934967,
-0.7862504124641418,
-0.4961104393005371,
-0.8093485236167908,
-0.533734142780304,
0.4238053262233734,
-0.05503196269273758,
-0.5072247385978699,
0.4916961193084717,
-0.08118249475955963,
0.31716060638427734,
0.4084027111530304,
0.02754913829267025,
0.18424326181411743,
0.03118991106748581,
0.30908796191215515,
0.12222535163164139,
-0.36738407611846924,
-0.9486569166183472,
1.0669329166412354,
0.5115220546722412,
0.861772894859314,
0.10881859809160233,
0.5309692025184631,
0.6868555545806885,
0.3052218556404114,
-0.653980016708374,
0.9919958114624023,
-0.3081704378128052,
-0.4813033938407898,
-0.7361114025115967,
-0.5488480925559998,
-0.9444448351860046,
0.01738704927265644,
-0.22149401903152466,
-0.8246869444847107,
-0.3912504315376282,
0.1577199548482895,
0.006743410602211952,
-0.1593499630689621,
-0.38424885272979736,
0.7615117430686951,
-0.41089892387390137,
-0.1921558529138565,
-0.46661704778671265,
-0.3972373306751251,
0.17031733691692352,
0.00663694366812706,
-0.23975510895252228,
-0.42835959792137146,
0.01599290408194065,
0.5540451407432556,
-0.18365254998207092,
1.0024598836898804,
-0.22883053123950958,
-0.08516440540552139,
0.24209342896938324,
0.21460431814193726,
0.6236395835876465,
0.06574659049510956,
-0.3209817707538605,
0.18075904250144958,
-0.008116650395095348,
-0.28774383664131165,
-0.5232658982276917,
0.8140980005264282,
-0.9872287511825562,
-0.5794394612312317,
-0.029207369312644005,
-0.6361203193664551,
-0.3682209253311157,
-0.03827379643917084,
-0.3357037603855133,
0.5173760652542114,
-0.7425179481506348,
0.4686051607131958,
0.5571145415306091,
-0.49696511030197144,
0.5495429635047913,
0.6498481035232544,
-0.2289096713066101,
0.14042338728904724,
0.7978070974349976,
0.02803497388958931,
0.18393661081790924,
0.5433832406997681,
0.08522049337625504,
-0.2358090579509735,
-0.2108013927936554,
-0.4369269907474518,
0.32087594270706177,
-0.328111469745636,
-0.057139407843351364,
-0.5054100751876831,
-0.5215411186218262,
-0.43138912320137024,
0.22177660465240479,
-0.5538799166679382,
-0.1057087779045105,
-0.10478216409683228,
0.40574911236763,
0.40066784620285034,
0.7005302309989929,
0.4286094605922699,
0.31607910990715027,
-0.7093943953514099,
0.3649858236312866,
0.41669443249702454,
0.2619687020778656,
0.134377121925354,
-0.7005132436752319,
-0.18273645639419556,
0.04487203434109688,
-0.25703176856040955,
-0.32305753231048584,
0.4830339550971985,
0.1410171240568161,
1.0014008283615112,
0.4862949550151825,
0.06227153539657593,
0.44826969504356384,
-0.33240798115730286,
0.8040968775749207,
-0.256684273481369,
-0.8091569542884827,
0.21267643570899963,
-0.21708931028842926,
0.049991507083177567,
0.44768011569976807,
0.1721777617931366,
-0.600325882434845,
-0.6501216292381287,
-0.35034605860710144,
-0.44852474331855774,
0.721278190612793,
0.45555752515792847,
0.5743143558502197,
0.1321091204881668,
0.3466041684150696,
0.09935254603624344,
0.24810294806957245,
-0.33780190348625183,
-0.25203949213027954,
0.21402892470359802,
-0.2294672280550003,
-0.3420782685279846,
-0.26743319630622864,
-0.13714216649532318,
0.15350553393363953,
0.4954310357570648,
-0.1936548948287964,
0.3574613630771637,
-0.1885860562324524,
0.037179071456193924,
0.255311518907547,
0.09622468799352646,
0.5404900908470154,
0.6211485862731934,
-0.07434442639350891,
0.055685289204120636,
0.1745055764913559,
-0.3100837171077728,
0.0365331694483757,
-0.03447827324271202,
-0.0754588395357132,
-0.17254456877708435,
0.7135854959487915,
0.4981439411640167,
0.006505245342850685,
-0.9353690147399902,
0.5623974800109863,
-0.15281595289707184,
0.20296376943588257,
-0.5183602571487427,
0.6392374634742737,
0.10155968368053436,
0.5759245753288269,
0.2871052026748657,
-0.39026588201522827,
-0.01890999637544155,
-0.8565091490745544,
0.19555723667144775,
0.6114261150360107,
-0.40582433342933655,
-0.404678612947464,
0.26637256145477295,
0.5526984333992004,
-0.7882404923439026,
0.846082329750061,
-0.22194257378578186,
-0.35777586698532104,
1.0753549337387085,
0.30739670991897583,
0.9110822677612305,
-0.18291808664798737,
0.2162005603313446,
0.12518669664859772,
0.10445043444633484,
-0.14551377296447754,
0.07616058737039566,
0.037739403545856476,
-0.8198728561401367,
-0.15623626112937927,
-0.6114495992660522,
-0.48193296790122986,
0.2383873164653778,
-0.25594353675842285,
0.30663540959358215,
-0.36209043860435486,
-0.1224818006157875,
-0.12787838280200958,
0.30551013350486755,
-0.8507317304611206,
0.05037108436226845,
0.07605788856744766,
0.5566633343696594,
-0.7115845680236816,
0.9175665378570557,
0.4591901898384094,
-0.2547082006931305,
-0.674081027507782,
0.19179919362068176,
-0.10080181062221527,
-0.9891378283500671,
0.5674690008163452,
0.3196054995059967,
-0.07026271522045135,
-0.19312193989753723,
-0.6083051562309265,
-0.5132285952568054,
1.2825413942337036,
0.2874530851840973,
-0.5340589880943298,
-0.03686530143022537,
0.5362765789031982,
0.9650865197181702,
-0.7524071335792542,
0.48708149790763855,
0.43296119570732117,
0.22501860558986664,
-0.1594887226819992,
-1.0342777967453003,
-0.06367936730384827,
-0.1452198028564453,
0.08084958791732788,
-0.25482994318008423,
-1.0312284231185913,
0.5681029558181763,
0.16090042889118195,
-0.00443273363634944,
0.44678086042404175,
0.6424440145492554,
0.4298744797706604,
0.26772111654281616,
0.5592843890190125,
0.1099126785993576,
0.6324265599250793,
0.22772470116615295,
0.9123563170433044,
-0.578507125377655,
0.03775372356176376,
0.9717811942100525,
-0.575240969657898,
0.7726656198501587,
0.06152462959289551,
-0.13633602857589722,
0.3819817304611206,
0.07666540145874023,
-0.22556710243225098,
0.18248678743839264,
0.4738638699054718,
-0.21644993126392365,
-0.2926505506038666,
-0.3214113414287567,
-0.10153583437204361,
0.9520667791366577,
0.09738529473543167,
-0.5698210000991821,
0.26962390542030334,
-0.33409589529037476,
-0.06041109561920166,
0.20456570386886597,
-0.16198284924030304,
0.7559471130371094,
0.027647586539387703,
-0.5311362743377686,
0.0883822962641716,
0.11925472319126129,
0.4855200946331024,
-0.6284357309341431,
-0.30955633521080017,
-0.5321931838989258,
0.21159526705741882,
0.24140030145645142,
-0.6621639132499695,
-0.057753052562475204,
0.2307644486427307,
-0.013005251064896584,
-0.15634103119373322,
0.44624847173690796,
-0.2378241866827011,
-0.3879026472568512,
0.14995989203453064,
0.5544446706771851,
0.6276816725730896,
0.0013387014623731375,
-0.48820960521698,
0.1928144097328186,
-0.31445884704589844,
-0.23694591224193573,
0.40296682715415955,
0.5077861547470093,
-0.39561596512794495,
0.9572955965995789,
0.295158326625824,
0.15755249559879303,
-0.3194763660430908,
0.17330601811408997,
0.6426642537117004,
-0.8632479310035706,
-0.2889646887779236,
-0.8075172305107117,
0.2924797236919403,
-0.2268281877040863,
-0.4627951979637146,
0.7904987335205078,
0.7297496199607849,
0.6038554310798645,
-0.041477933526039124,
0.5314489006996155,
-0.08783277869224548,
0.46504250168800354,
-0.2672874629497528,
1.047190546989441,
-0.3598927855491638,
0.3988233804702759,
-0.19483187794685364,
-1.0741751194000244,
0.030888589099049568,
0.24957570433616638,
0.15550723671913147,
0.3447086215019226,
0.27136605978012085,
1.1276631355285645,
0.16956914961338043,
-0.3684861958026886,
0.7605741620063782,
0.19249160587787628,
0.662396252155304,
0.2418534755706787,
0.9446427822113037,
-0.2444990575313568,
0.30984827876091003,
-0.1114690825343132,
-0.16252471506595612,
-0.4025218188762665,
-0.642010509967804,
-1.211626410484314,
-0.47454512119293213,
-0.30111992359161377,
-0.15448583662509918,
0.005218891426920891,
0.9281827211380005,
0.8306522965431213,
-0.688359797000885,
-0.6159089207649231,
0.21064355969429016,
-0.03681906312704086,
-0.29590392112731934,
-0.2501472532749176,
0.09039410948753357,
-0.3289855718612671,
-0.9316794872283936,
0.41447603702545166,
0.03624660149216652,
-0.1172536313533783,
-0.6299809217453003,
-0.3379073739051819,
0.27083495259284973,
0.3384980261325836,
0.5419291853904724,
0.3199954926967621,
-0.743646502494812,
-0.33464720845222473,
-0.08913934230804443,
-0.6093307733535767,
-0.13639305531978607,
0.834358811378479,
-0.6130026578903198,
0.21425597369670868,
0.5549420714378357,
0.48468154668807983,
0.3003140687942505,
0.20572495460510254,
0.6542347073554993,
-0.6409156918525696,
-0.1066460981965065,
0.2412227839231491,
0.0974450409412384,
0.30235061049461365,
-0.29668140411376953,
0.5181313753128052,
-0.0819312259554863,
-0.75224369764328,
-0.7539903521537781,
-0.0731726661324501,
-1.0168105363845825,
0.0622577965259552,
1.3286410570144653,
-0.3634885549545288,
-0.11276184022426605,
0.15569262206554413,
-0.1725565791130066,
0.3189728856086731,
-0.6116678714752197,
0.9665756821632385,
0.4844752252101898,
-0.4433608055114746,
-0.13067761063575745,
-0.44643932580947876,
0.4123685657978058,
0.2012929767370224,
-0.9895455241203308,
0.22854502499103546,
0.5184648633003235,
0.20627717673778534,
0.07333975285291672,
0.38935986161231995,
-0.09366238862276077,
-0.05162526294589043,
0.04445948451757431,
0.30897870659828186,
-0.09861158579587936,
-0.6032646298408508,
-0.25519099831581116,
0.2393379807472229,
0.40643206238746643,
-0.11131764203310013
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.12328v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.12328v1
|
Methods for Generating Drift in Text Streams
| 2024-03-18T23:48:33 | 2024-03-18T23:48:33 |
Cristiano Mesquita Garcia, Alessandro Lameiras Koerich, Alceu de Souza Britto Jr, Jean Paul Barddal
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Systems and individuals produce data continuously. On the Internet, people
share their knowledge, sentiments, and opinions, provide reviews about services
and products, and so on. Automatically learning from these textual data can
provide insights to organizations and institutions, thus preventing financial
impacts, for example. To learn from textual data over time, the machine
learning system must account for concept drift. Concept drift is a frequent
phenomenon in real-world datasets and corresponds to changes in data
distribution over time. For instance, a concept drift occurs when sentiments
change or a word's meaning is adjusted over time. Although concept drift is
frequent in real-world applications, benchmark datasets with labeled drifts are
rare in the literature. To bridge this gap, this paper provides four textual
drift generation methods to ease the production of datasets with labeled
drifts. These methods were applied to Yelp and Airbnb datasets and tested using
incremental classifiers respecting the stream mining paradigm to evaluate their
ability to recover from the drifts. Results show that all methods have their
performance degraded right after the drifts, and the incremental SVM is the
fastest to run and recover the previous performance levels regarding accuracy
and Macro F1-Score.
|
[
-0.14825795590877533,
-0.7343006134033203,
0.3701370656490326,
-0.05804366245865822,
-0.4404277205467224,
0.23393039405345917,
-0.14343766868114471,
-0.14443868398666382,
0.1954660415649414,
0.43087098002433777,
-0.8653047680854797,
-0.5696012377738953,
-0.1981620043516159,
-0.06203495338559151,
-0.6357210874557495,
1.364075779914856,
-0.005264960695058107,
-0.22276195883750916,
-0.1708146333694458,
-0.10062718391418457,
-0.4676530659198761,
-0.37075120210647583,
-0.5061173439025879,
-0.23330196738243103,
0.13966475427150726,
0.15109188854694366,
0.38835644721984863,
0.7488740682601929,
0.52264004945755,
0.2148125320672989,
0.08973026275634766,
0.25733643770217896,
-0.5364614129066467,
0.4730808138847351,
-0.12987153232097626,
-0.5625157356262207,
0.0431852713227272,
-0.09098875522613525,
0.44430893659591675,
0.16010606288909912,
-0.37558358907699585,
0.5093637704849243,
-0.15086887776851654,
0.5963690876960754,
-0.6962689757347107,
0.030596217140555382,
-0.7587560415267944,
-0.007720319088548422,
-0.4672035276889801,
-0.6019721627235413,
-0.38806474208831787,
-0.6926677823066711,
0.2861335575580597,
-0.5222432017326355,
0.5976736545562744,
-0.16195133328437805,
0.9672064185142517,
0.474072128534317,
-0.12698587775230408,
-0.9483973383903503,
-0.69890296459198,
0.6711698174476624,
-0.822526752948761,
0.03614888712763786,
0.18504364788532257,
-0.006124487146735191,
0.11389335244894028,
-0.7692309021949768,
-0.5850087404251099,
0.03342844545841217,
0.08654404431581497,
0.20986326038837433,
0.3460245132446289,
-0.6654267907142639,
0.00900934636592865,
0.10430096089839935,
-0.253347784280777,
-0.006626328453421593,
-0.1270648092031479,
0.017595680430531502,
0.7538574934005737,
0.5436486601829529,
0.12342453002929688,
-0.30850476026535034,
-0.5537048578262329,
-0.307718425989151,
-0.707839846611023,
0.01291089877486229,
0.4172111451625824,
0.44373953342437744,
0.05827733874320984,
0.3329835534095764,
-0.036909863352775574,
0.4585109353065491,
-0.0003537751908879727,
-0.4508429169654846,
0.6033890247344971,
-0.37842872738838196,
0.14498788118362427,
0.449178546667099,
0.4508912265300751,
0.5875369906425476,
-0.05587828531861305,
0.05476130545139313,
-0.22446255385875702,
0.2242441177368164,
0.43795016407966614,
-0.4721079468727112,
-0.30662670731544495,
0.19643549621105194,
-0.5705196261405945,
-0.5383185744285583,
0.05780728906393051,
-0.9994220733642578,
-0.3902791738510132,
-0.3026418387889862,
0.41102656722068787,
-0.4826691150665283,
-0.5328118205070496,
-0.3916526734828949,
-0.6910215020179749,
0.26115089654922485,
0.28854691982269287,
-0.6936362385749817,
0.08371834456920624,
0.643764078617096,
0.9863834381103516,
-0.2283145934343338,
-0.06770510971546173,
-0.4267283082008362,
0.050318364053964615,
-0.4254678189754486,
0.9950776100158691,
-0.3447374999523163,
-0.3381403088569641,
0.2782192528247833,
-0.3998797833919525,
-0.00151271210052073,
-0.5118185877799988,
0.5482252240180969,
-0.4992389678955078,
0.2792719602584839,
-0.03650086745619774,
-1.0230093002319336,
-0.03374946489930153,
-0.06452369689941406,
-0.2865557372570038,
1.1243404150009155,
-0.02567906677722931,
-0.9174299240112305,
0.5593635439872742,
-0.755872368812561,
-0.5140344500541687,
0.3727438747882843,
0.19902920722961426,
-0.5443522930145264,
0.27673977613449097,
-0.03531850501894951,
0.4389547109603882,
0.21054498851299286,
-0.013617288321256638,
-0.1963724046945572,
0.000297947961371392,
0.14018841087818146,
-0.13946203887462616,
0.5038838386535645,
0.41921600699424744,
-0.39601930975914,
-0.2625313699245453,
-0.5720728039741516,
0.18749752640724182,
0.10391721874475479,
-0.3628595173358917,
-0.8113288879394531,
0.6707115769386292,
0.23723742365837097,
0.10018226504325867,
-0.10773228853940964,
-0.38912639021873474,
0.06501498073339462,
-0.22806259989738464,
0.6097483038902283,
1.0202046632766724,
0.5373079180717468,
0.08122458308935165,
-0.42256155610084534,
0.44146934151649475,
0.24697168171405792,
-0.4341319501399994,
-0.752824068069458,
-0.296568363904953,
-0.7674320340156555,
-0.0384993813931942,
0.28916993737220764,
0.4289535880088806,
-0.8311147093772888,
0.4095068573951721,
-0.5350321531295776,
-0.5628897547721863,
-0.5381394624710083,
0.22215911746025085,
-0.02994176186621189,
0.6190937757492065,
0.32066962122917175,
0.1941828727722168,
-0.18056073784828186,
-0.16542142629623413,
-0.3589325249195099,
0.052908528596162796,
-0.10772670060396194,
0.10776720196008682,
0.16794036328792572,
-0.3324761390686035,
1.1739509105682373,
-0.8713449835777283,
-0.23505260050296783,
0.025255151093006134,
0.46537256240844727,
-0.21516326069831848,
0.2739368975162506,
0.3750031888484955,
-0.8061535954475403,
-0.39972665905952454,
-0.17284345626831055,
-0.7210252285003662,
-0.01984303444623947,
-0.5470150113105774,
-0.04503130912780762,
0.5772247314453125,
0.550014078617096,
-0.09856341779232025,
0.24915055930614471,
0.25458163022994995,
-0.4403747320175171,
0.2169322967529297,
0.045896582305431366,
-0.31644538044929504,
-1.1060137748718262,
-0.42735087871551514,
0.5632514357566833,
-0.3536238968372345,
-0.4262893497943878,
-0.05010618641972542,
-0.11322974413633347,
0.08985430747270584,
-0.2755703926086426,
0.3677295446395874,
-0.13575921952724457,
0.4158341586589813,
-0.1961878538131714,
0.3943733870983124,
-0.244787335395813,
0.06248210743069649,
0.24464410543441772,
0.2994881868362427,
0.2679567337036133,
-1.0562485456466675,
0.37514063715934753,
0.1453080028295517,
-0.40589261054992676,
0.7229727506637573,
-0.13946689665317535,
0.1269904375076294,
-0.3813614845275879,
0.2593904435634613,
-0.999571681022644,
-0.11460315436124802,
-0.045189399272203445,
-0.3934842348098755,
0.23424413800239563,
0.18907946348190308,
-0.22191086411476135,
-0.19356006383895874,
-0.493376761674881,
-0.41430070996284485,
0.4323020279407501,
-0.5490658283233643,
0.17615936696529388,
0.5677350759506226,
-0.21412406861782074,
-0.24261151254177094,
-0.6448677182197571,
0.04089963436126709,
-0.5962298512458801,
-0.29982519149780273,
0.2362792193889618,
0.000839209882542491,
-0.3357607126235962,
0.25243493914604187,
-0.19571553170681,
0.10773403197526932,
0.07059208303689957,
0.11252230405807495,
0.20866432785987854,
-0.04872040078043938,
0.7129221558570862,
0.056077759712934494,
-0.11029330641031265,
0.15442700684070587,
-0.414861261844635,
0.4684315621852875,
0.13927936553955078,
0.18712061643600464,
-0.4006682336330414,
0.0772792249917984,
0.16655944287776947,
0.12036515772342682,
0.4941084682941437,
0.7410897612571716,
-0.21505846083164215,
-0.6936454772949219,
-0.46457168459892273,
-0.05819370970129967,
-0.46748024225234985,
0.028171099722385406,
-0.30320629477500916,
-0.6020668745040894,
0.2693440020084381,
-0.4324369728565216,
0.40113502740859985,
0.6749680638313293,
0.7924807071685791,
-0.6279311776161194,
0.43777966499328613,
0.6185052990913391,
0.13443303108215332,
0.5240212678909302,
-0.37259963154792786,
0.22478175163269043,
-0.5853903889656067,
-0.23352614045143127,
-0.6245063543319702,
-0.3982136845588684,
-0.965383768081665,
-0.1565505564212799,
0.20228298008441925,
-0.24635851383209229,
0.20241114497184753,
0.24707336723804474,
-0.5373663306236267,
0.14311394095420837,
0.5996147394180298,
-0.02963176928460598,
0.3378220498561859,
0.03679819405078888,
-0.18725618720054626,
-0.12386011332273483,
-0.4757499098777771,
-0.514000415802002,
1.1329131126403809,
0.210964173078537,
0.784316897392273,
-0.09831223636865616,
0.8896352648735046,
0.8168556690216064,
0.6039010286331177,
-0.5779692530632019,
0.15110698342323303,
0.08612887561321259,
-0.6360841989517212,
-0.3697568476200104,
-0.6536014676094055,
-0.5610118508338928,
0.06294862926006317,
-0.1442061811685562,
-0.42387309670448303,
0.07799054682254791,
0.15801531076431274,
-0.024673884734511375,
0.10988660156726837,
-0.7764636278152466,
0.35883450508117676,
-0.08163706213235855,
-0.19123859703540802,
-0.21102726459503174,
-0.46339553594589233,
0.34199830889701843,
-0.39389920234680176,
0.3665884733200073,
-0.33364400267601013,
-0.1941002905368805,
0.6494662165641785,
-0.7174215316772461,
0.5143627524375916,
-0.42755499482154846,
-0.37934577465057373,
0.5685760378837585,
-0.15632201731204987,
0.4972299635410309,
0.10694443434476852,
0.01559434738010168,
0.05445774272084236,
-0.15073584020137787,
-0.1510571986436844,
-0.2612834870815277,
0.7494430541992188,
-0.7183948159217834,
0.0068262903951108456,
-0.2703603506088257,
0.04713580757379532,
-0.14109228551387787,
-0.07478302717208862,
0.7631909251213074,
0.3695610463619232,
-0.0775824561715126,
-0.0006443618913181126,
0.7200789451599121,
0.09276344627141953,
1.026516079902649,
0.3485671579837799,
-0.08786655962467194,
-0.3700859844684601,
1.07860267162323,
0.36033663153648376,
0.10278139263391495,
0.4073917269706726,
0.12898702919483185,
-0.43659916520118713,
-0.4290652871131897,
-0.425790935754776,
-0.12617240846157074,
-0.5455913543701172,
-0.5581973791122437,
-0.5837523937225342,
-0.06819170713424683,
-0.22816187143325806,
-0.2789643108844757,
-0.23200708627700806,
-0.5184125900268555,
-0.18661172688007355,
-0.3171806335449219,
0.6061322093009949,
0.6467655897140503,
0.034996241331100464,
0.27060067653656006,
-0.7682257890701294,
0.35307180881500244,
0.1682640016078949,
0.26628708839416504,
0.076348677277565,
-0.12482316046953201,
-0.5381856560707092,
0.17924271523952484,
-0.45242756605148315,
-0.5429793000221252,
0.33886244893074036,
0.3309403955936432,
0.4035291373729706,
0.5209561586380005,
0.27904021739959717,
0.45311859250068665,
-0.4961467683315277,
0.8738250136375427,
0.17892061173915863,
-1.1043083667755127,
0.8471508026123047,
-0.5123714208602905,
0.4220949113368988,
0.4440917670726776,
0.48491334915161133,
-0.7324445247650146,
-0.49899962544441223,
-0.6429305672645569,
-1.0536786317825317,
0.7073748707771301,
0.061212729662656784,
0.3912147283554077,
-0.05286687985062599,
0.47761693596839905,
0.31838008761405945,
0.4398218095302582,
-0.6875289082527161,
-0.3279380202293396,
-0.5602837204933167,
-0.3086954355239868,
-0.1094464585185051,
0.014469366520643234,
0.3174923062324524,
-0.048803843557834625,
0.8710466027259827,
-0.16121576726436615,
0.09904324263334274,
0.13488033413887024,
-0.26559674739837646,
-0.22390644252300262,
-0.08791116625070572,
0.44649598002433777,
0.7390561103820801,
-0.1692582219839096,
-0.08310355991125107,
-0.10623971372842789,
-0.7356468439102173,
0.40466898679733276,
-0.3040443956851959,
-0.7222580313682556,
0.48933547735214233,
0.2684229612350464,
0.5837934613227844,
-0.13329626619815826,
-0.6575243473052979,
0.2055307924747467,
-0.03785962238907814,
-0.17369064688682556,
-0.45881420373916626,
0.3324880003929138,
0.3321613669395447,
-0.3281645178794861,
0.641738772392273,
0.2921375334262848,
-0.004396830685436726,
-0.5131991505622864,
0.23022155463695526,
0.07263956218957901,
-0.30554601550102234,
-0.1006794273853302,
0.5130005478858948,
0.3745722770690918,
-0.3634395897388458,
0.7534958720207214,
-0.18028290569782257,
-0.19630514085292816,
0.26441502571105957,
0.4696754813194275,
1.0201079845428467,
-0.16748929023742676,
0.5196980834007263,
0.3316572308540344,
0.1490122526884079,
-0.1288534700870514,
0.018585065379738808,
-0.16230805218219757,
-0.8191661238670349,
-0.42517971992492676,
-0.7275918126106262,
-0.30676066875457764,
0.06766735762357712,
-0.7419105768203735,
0.36931389570236206,
-0.42518797516822815,
-0.4243236482143402,
0.29992666840553284,
-0.04173075035214424,
-0.45914947986602783,
0.19399189949035645,
0.4322640001773834,
0.831786572933197,
-0.7442078590393066,
0.5518805980682373,
0.7926657795906067,
-0.16485123336315155,
-0.34320756793022156,
0.51144939661026,
0.20259998738765717,
-0.3026221990585327,
0.36349090933799744,
0.03424711152911186,
-0.2042265683412552,
0.13389931619167328,
-0.6987815499305725,
-0.7336317896842957,
0.7872284054756165,
-0.39678332209587097,
-0.35957151651382446,
0.11622525006532669,
-0.08203119039535522,
0.6595486998558044,
-0.42735785245895386,
-0.07271605730056763,
0.3859167993068695,
0.2244158685207367,
0.05810360610485077,
-0.3501409590244293,
-0.10996419191360474,
-0.2203252613544464,
0.274515300989151,
0.4827808737754822,
-0.7450697422027588,
0.538341760635376,
-0.05391409248113632,
-0.3040678799152374,
-0.3712807893753052,
0.42459747195243835,
-0.09615777432918549,
0.6264488697052002,
0.3649442493915558,
0.9755839109420776,
1.0486429929733276,
-0.255612850189209,
0.6095809936523438,
0.10096260905265808,
0.512356162071228,
1.0425910949707031,
-0.5345475673675537,
1.084380030632019,
0.0020970769692212343,
-0.05135662481188774,
0.9436038136482239,
0.646362841129303,
-0.1669335812330246,
0.8882070183753967,
0.2921425402164459,
-0.15005092322826385,
0.024469248950481415,
0.11057987809181213,
-0.3710607886314392,
0.41436511278152466,
0.8021515011787415,
-0.11361056566238403,
-0.3960062861442566,
0.2694239020347595,
0.2835068702697754,
0.08576367795467377,
-0.4140543043613434,
1.2708439826965332,
-0.0185233186930418,
-0.6692454814910889,
0.4540974199771881,
0.08543827384710312,
0.8248764872550964,
-0.544865608215332,
0.3291999399662018,
-0.3086446523666382,
0.42800793051719666,
-0.2810632884502411,
-0.34584155678749084,
0.4221612811088562,
0.18851153552532196,
-0.2217559665441513,
-0.43231168389320374,
0.6403416991233826,
-0.09735233336687088,
-0.5816399455070496,
-0.16584512591362,
0.34729135036468506,
-0.16196857392787933,
0.27951449155807495,
-0.4281553328037262,
0.03147902712225914,
0.13765253126621246,
-0.21455980837345123,
0.1908724457025528,
0.5068090558052063,
0.050897061824798584,
0.7743140459060669,
0.6083341836929321,
-0.04477517679333687,
0.41674065589904785,
-0.3552738428115845,
0.7136000394821167,
-0.7480992078781128,
-0.6657048463821411,
-0.8606113791465759,
0.4275202751159668,
-0.16906817257404327,
-0.5512915849685669,
0.9823386669158936,
0.6105248928070068,
0.9749011397361755,
-0.007750319316983223,
1.1077489852905273,
-0.0815025046467781,
0.9618581533432007,
-0.6948986649513245,
0.5404988527297974,
-0.2468726933002472,
0.19568471610546112,
-0.3968558609485626,
-0.8621662855148315,
0.12776346504688263,
0.5798587799072266,
-0.0423058457672596,
-0.27076324820518494,
0.7813159227371216,
0.06817790865898132,
0.41962960362434387,
0.25559186935424805,
-0.330646812915802,
0.054839856922626495,
0.263301819562912,
0.007651329040527344,
0.9072483777999878,
-0.37830600142478943,
0.2948644757270813,
-0.18704092502593994,
-0.030418219044804573,
-0.32891765236854553,
-0.8530912399291992,
-0.5333985686302185,
-0.55350261926651,
-0.7665660977363586,
-0.3688676953315735,
-0.05186661332845688,
0.7325631380081177,
0.6450781226158142,
-0.8005746603012085,
-0.22504913806915283,
-0.15284903347492218,
0.2884293794631958,
-0.5071154832839966,
-0.4158925712108612,
0.3257081210613251,
-0.9719136953353882,
-0.5122901797294617,
0.019025903195142746,
0.21561214327812195,
-0.10984212160110474,
-0.25411614775657654,
0.22749844193458557,
-0.25973451137542725,
0.13850876688957214,
0.4224395155906677,
-0.09675105661153793,
-0.20544148981571198,
0.10607782751321793,
-0.13570760190486908,
0.13181553781032562,
0.13031573593616486,
0.859679102897644,
-1.0047521591186523,
0.34111785888671875,
0.49963366985321045,
0.35824185609817505,
0.7780210375785828,
0.3092120587825775,
0.27517661452293396,
-0.7994439005851746,
-0.05860443785786629,
0.24058157205581665,
-0.16344967484474182,
0.30626431107521057,
-0.47970375418663025,
0.38946232199668884,
0.36512237787246704,
-0.36642688512802124,
-0.7080681920051575,
-0.1449194848537445,
-0.3579275608062744,
-0.4100727140903473,
0.7555773258209229,
-0.06450812518596649,
0.035262737423181534,
-0.19462285935878754,
0.33652183413505554,
-0.15260913968086243,
-0.4918488562107086,
0.9696834087371826,
0.8817351460456848,
-0.0767374038696289,
0.17198427021503448,
-0.5569372773170471,
0.7811341881752014,
-0.2423611581325531,
-0.952587902545929,
0.15853753685951233,
0.6765351891517639,
0.40850308537483215,
0.456903338432312,
0.6283318400382996,
0.11084297299385071,
-0.19318512082099915,
0.11853843182325363,
-0.1589765101671219,
0.4518716335296631,
-0.10591395199298859,
-0.10509413480758667,
0.2721833884716034,
-0.3689062297344208,
-0.23481126129627228
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15455v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15455v1
|
Improving Sampling Methods for Fine-tuning SentenceBERT in Text Streams
| 2024-03-18T23:41:52 | 2024-03-18T23:41:52 |
Cristiano Mesquita Garcia, Alessandro Lameiras Koerich, Alceu de Souza Britto Jr, Jean Paul Barddal
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The proliferation of textual data on the Internet presents a unique
opportunity for institutions and companies to monitor public opinion about
their services and products. Given the rapid generation of such data, the text
stream mining setting, which handles sequentially arriving, potentially
infinite text streams, is often more suitable than traditional batch learning.
While pre-trained language models are commonly employed for their high-quality
text vectorization capabilities in streaming contexts, they face challenges
adapting to concept drift - the phenomenon where the data distribution changes
over time, adversely affecting model performance. Addressing the issue of
concept drift, this study explores the efficacy of seven text sampling methods
designed to selectively fine-tune language models, thereby mitigating
performance degradation. We precisely assess the impact of these methods on
fine-tuning the SBERT model using four different loss functions. Our
evaluation, focused on Macro F1-score and elapsed time, employs two text stream
datasets and an incremental SVM classifier to benchmark performance. Our
findings indicate that Softmax loss and Batch All Triplets loss are
particularly effective for text stream classification, demonstrating that
larger sample sizes generally correlate with improved macro F1-scores. Notably,
our proposed WordPieceToken ratio sampling method significantly enhances
performance with the identified loss functions, surpassing baseline results.
|
[
-0.43239057064056396,
-0.6657688021659851,
0.3069038391113281,
-0.02755766175687313,
-0.6766710877418518,
0.09518139064311981,
-0.4568411111831665,
-0.08138378709554672,
-0.09734588116407394,
0.5167746543884277,
-0.6957370042800903,
-0.49889665842056274,
-0.5360057353973389,
0.16208435595035553,
-0.6783483624458313,
1.4342526197433472,
0.020429985597729683,
-0.057839639484882355,
-0.13208740949630737,
-0.09134641289710999,
-0.514146089553833,
-0.10309486836194992,
-0.6395758390426636,
-0.3463883399963379,
0.29419219493865967,
0.310691773891449,
0.37075522541999817,
0.5411399602890015,
0.6018528342247009,
0.20090283453464508,
-0.3524904251098633,
0.3544859290122986,
-0.8724563121795654,
0.19419369101524353,
-0.2704499661922455,
-0.7200605869293213,
-0.016269974410533905,
0.03480251133441925,
0.5280082821846008,
0.2524488568305969,
-0.43806809186935425,
0.4596785008907318,
0.15737535059452057,
0.5196263790130615,
-0.6639450788497925,
-0.10117457807064056,
-0.8161609172821045,
-0.09371321648359299,
-0.47409799695014954,
-0.5230713486671448,
-0.5690451264381409,
-0.37724778056144714,
0.3089410066604614,
-0.5172678232192993,
0.5627321004867554,
0.03908782824873924,
0.9991540312767029,
0.5365914106369019,
-0.12666469812393188,
-0.4837965965270996,
-0.6862472891807556,
0.910538911819458,
-0.8071708679199219,
0.15330950915813446,
0.30914777517318726,
0.003591635962948203,
0.18196919560432434,
-0.5894814729690552,
-0.4910789430141449,
0.033236194401979446,
0.13530167937278748,
0.09110052138566971,
0.0428655743598938,
-0.12775708734989166,
0.0011093789944425225,
0.22464506328105927,
-0.36274659633636475,
0.1307118684053421,
-0.4572945237159729,
-0.14323200285434723,
0.6989011764526367,
0.14347030222415924,
0.049448974430561066,
-0.22835354506969452,
-0.40430381894111633,
-0.33741694688796997,
-0.5461814999580383,
0.1456632912158966,
0.47000744938850403,
0.5932771563529968,
0.1598186492919922,
0.34855887293815613,
-0.12320253998041153,
0.7127236127853394,
0.02106143720448017,
-0.02492975816130638,
0.3496035635471344,
-0.3706902861595154,
-0.2592661380767822,
0.030121969059109688,
0.49480140209198,
0.5915525555610657,
0.40545883774757385,
0.15929386019706726,
-0.22896242141723633,
-0.029731009155511856,
0.5398416519165039,
-1.0104032754898071,
-0.3148759603500366,
0.17486341297626495,
-0.547603964805603,
-0.4454057216644287,
0.1966100037097931,
-0.858464777469635,
-0.24075156450271606,
-0.3440540134906769,
0.28936824202537537,
-0.6194515824317932,
-0.17017395794391632,
-0.02168881893157959,
-0.5599353313446045,
-0.006089931819587946,
0.22755831480026245,
-0.7201598882675171,
0.24463023245334625,
0.7611414790153503,
1.0299931764602661,
-0.213411346077919,
0.021841544657945633,
-0.6288263201713562,
-0.1415831744670868,
-0.4926813244819641,
1.153897762298584,
-0.5521339178085327,
-0.3265776038169861,
0.10449124872684479,
-0.3459946811199188,
-0.2223341315984726,
-0.590549886226654,
0.8386391997337341,
-0.4670408070087433,
0.23964852094650269,
-0.06792319566011429,
-0.9468067288398743,
-0.022005118429660797,
0.04801085591316223,
-0.510145902633667,
1.0770368576049805,
-0.07666824012994766,
-0.8424440622329712,
0.5328860878944397,
-0.3901037275791168,
-0.5151293277740479,
0.10656175017356873,
0.14591822028160095,
-0.3931669592857361,
0.4525066614151001,
0.2755264341831207,
0.7482360005378723,
0.09722865372896194,
-0.15464656054973602,
-0.31788212060928345,
-0.5366123914718628,
0.10213491320610046,
-0.3256227374076843,
0.4488353729248047,
0.45465847849845886,
-0.10782304406166077,
-0.057851046323776245,
-0.6067498326301575,
0.30515506863594055,
-0.2557758688926697,
-0.2934931814670563,
-0.7622628211975098,
0.45357152819633484,
0.4925636351108551,
-0.002485147910192609,
-0.32544201612472534,
-0.3670777976512909,
0.056897033005952835,
-0.6124616861343384,
0.7341993451118469,
0.9044511914253235,
0.1942780315876007,
0.2956139147281647,
-0.38472238183021545,
0.5132882595062256,
0.012247808277606964,
-0.23709475994110107,
-0.5657168030738831,
-0.23963329195976257,
-0.5782572627067566,
-0.2965802550315857,
0.5700979828834534,
0.4485761523246765,
-0.783973217010498,
0.3399006426334381,
-0.6840423941612244,
-0.49789971113204956,
-0.7359893918037415,
0.273421972990036,
0.11008951812982559,
0.3548290431499481,
0.34224674105644226,
-0.03947329521179199,
-0.1450541764497757,
-0.4295145273208618,
-0.4468992054462433,
0.033992234617471695,
-0.13791322708129883,
0.10133419930934906,
0.19252872467041016,
-0.30736351013183594,
1.188761591911316,
-0.7793287038803101,
-0.40562382340431213,
-0.31903699040412903,
0.592307448387146,
-0.06526941061019897,
0.14864341914653778,
0.48528099060058594,
-0.8709129095077515,
-0.2575743496417999,
-0.23934797942638397,
0.011313998140394688,
-0.15112173557281494,
-0.24223491549491882,
0.12090294808149338,
0.3653620183467865,
0.49529045820236206,
-0.25222980976104736,
0.26723775267601013,
0.6005702018737793,
-0.3645370900630951,
0.23157097399234772,
0.009309142827987671,
0.02294274792075157,
-1.1082786321640015,
-0.2077232301235199,
0.35581451654434204,
-0.3755400776863098,
-0.538700520992279,
-0.024664506316184998,
-0.012824580073356628,
0.07174814492464066,
-0.36826691031455994,
0.44744884967803955,
-0.10854659229516983,
0.4899287521839142,
-0.5733811259269714,
0.338988721370697,
-0.11585045605897903,
0.09755121916532516,
-0.16229313611984253,
0.8446175456047058,
0.02278219535946846,
-0.9148545265197754,
0.06497083604335785,
0.2645581066608429,
-0.43213391304016113,
0.7217383980751038,
-0.4810297191143036,
-0.06488338112831116,
-0.47949740290641785,
0.27869775891304016,
-1.1374197006225586,
0.07416239380836487,
-0.221981018781662,
-0.5320960283279419,
0.46433791518211365,
0.0724424421787262,
-0.22293540835380554,
-0.22201970219612122,
-0.593305766582489,
-0.13287542760372162,
0.45523810386657715,
-0.2482173889875412,
0.1102980300784111,
0.41175568103790283,
-0.31813743710517883,
-0.34396642446517944,
-0.8626995086669922,
-0.10611684620380402,
-0.29093512892723083,
-0.3803047239780426,
0.5726447105407715,
-0.03836642578244209,
0.0065958863124251366,
0.12228371202945709,
-0.4313584864139557,
-0.17915527522563934,
-0.007790797855705023,
-0.21688887476921082,
-0.0168914757668972,
-0.017977995797991753,
0.5428060293197632,
0.15415221452713013,
-0.07907651364803314,
-0.13380061089992523,
-0.35326114296913147,
0.5666725039482117,
0.23067249357700348,
0.20285753905773163,
-0.40985631942749023,
0.1003003865480423,
0.24123607575893402,
-0.16690118610858917,
0.6819851994514465,
0.9099574685096741,
-0.18013827502727509,
-0.882098376750946,
-0.5268383026123047,
-0.23167690634727478,
-0.43724602460861206,
0.3166694641113281,
-0.13708984851837158,
-1.0709428787231445,
0.26633644104003906,
-0.12029417604207993,
0.18821771442890167,
0.35977450013160706,
0.4762079417705536,
-0.4649873971939087,
0.6332618594169617,
0.7758023738861084,
-0.3224702775478363,
0.7184142470359802,
-0.3296346068382263,
0.22216369211673737,
-0.6740183234214783,
0.3217616379261017,
-0.7281080484390259,
-0.21499404311180115,
-0.8244643211364746,
-0.41119077801704407,
0.1444009244441986,
0.011696824803948402,
0.24147316813468933,
0.29430097341537476,
-0.3444046676158905,
0.3909066617488861,
0.48503339290618896,
0.12884311378002167,
0.14677315950393677,
0.07084045559167862,
-0.11238208413124084,
-0.09361392259597778,
-0.6411945819854736,
-0.5816664695739746,
1.0905861854553223,
0.21076956391334534,
0.6003208756446838,
-0.2693321406841278,
0.7188501954078674,
0.48814424872398376,
0.3067066967487335,
-0.6426124572753906,
0.37359800934791565,
-0.496170312166214,
-0.7343004941940308,
-0.5206723213195801,
-0.6048650741577148,
-0.615794837474823,
0.11470459401607513,
-0.1426621526479721,
-0.5264915823936462,
-0.18974797427654266,
0.45825791358947754,
-0.42321503162384033,
0.07431471347808838,
-0.7099369764328003,
0.8234598636627197,
0.26308882236480713,
-0.11831557005643845,
-0.5580322742462158,
-0.3679901957511902,
0.28226038813591003,
-0.150276780128479,
0.24538984894752502,
-0.4390625059604645,
-0.08150098472833633,
0.5150953531265259,
-0.4823269248008728,
0.5364869832992554,
-0.09818975627422333,
-0.10537067800760269,
0.3587431013584137,
-0.309740275144577,
0.49230125546455383,
0.000714355381205678,
-0.01641787588596344,
0.01338520459830761,
0.06042134389281273,
-0.2753654420375824,
-0.5311478972434998,
0.5516248941421509,
-0.5380801558494568,
-0.05259236320853233,
-0.1906459629535675,
0.02532404474914074,
-0.15714852511882782,
0.03939765691757202,
0.6363529562950134,
0.5473513603210449,
-0.23786133527755737,
0.4621066153049469,
0.9184577465057373,
-0.12261835485696793,
0.7688888311386108,
0.17306911945343018,
0.07754729688167572,
-0.43404263257980347,
0.9028549790382385,
0.2462552934885025,
0.25527292490005493,
0.6674700975418091,
0.17736560106277466,
-0.34957897663116455,
-0.6496497392654419,
-0.39007872343063354,
-0.06471671909093857,
-0.40890923142433167,
-0.45558351278305054,
-0.505030632019043,
-0.09371151775121689,
-0.22545506060123444,
-0.04464690387248993,
-0.2598956525325775,
-0.2579110562801361,
-0.40473392605781555,
-0.22811825573444366,
0.4652881622314453,
0.13608521223068237,
0.4338132441043854,
0.6217319369316101,
-0.7344828844070435,
0.35498228669166565,
-0.001404838520102203,
0.5663261413574219,
-0.2002016007900238,
-0.5556100010871887,
-0.31774666905403137,
-0.01406529638916254,
-0.3186197578907013,
-0.7236316204071045,
0.3147726058959961,
0.5530889630317688,
0.40401318669319153,
0.4017944931983948,
0.1092202216386795,
0.8596945405006409,
-0.6504525542259216,
0.7905477285385132,
-0.18507149815559387,
-1.0636459589004517,
0.6852441430091858,
-0.43106046319007874,
0.5003167390823364,
0.7746066451072693,
0.35911884903907776,
-0.7509479522705078,
-0.5373403429985046,
-0.40473228693008423,
-0.9163436889648438,
0.7355902791023254,
0.3008938729763031,
0.48096945881843567,
0.04435189068317413,
0.3307555019855499,
-0.0030246006790548563,
0.4237207770347595,
-0.5195644497871399,
-0.14956243336200714,
-0.23060958087444305,
-0.6549514532089233,
-0.43114280700683594,
-0.21612119674682617,
0.3730568587779999,
-0.09315931051969528,
0.8402448296546936,
-0.15154792368412018,
0.008678252808749676,
0.13531208038330078,
-0.33230459690093994,
-0.10597620159387589,
0.3166932463645935,
0.7213485836982727,
0.5810969471931458,
-0.11676622927188873,
-0.13580964505672455,
0.16918334364891052,
-0.8056120276451111,
0.078494593501091,
0.17431767284870148,
-0.7040659785270691,
0.3112441599369049,
0.3654709756374359,
0.8245782256126404,
0.40424832701683044,
-0.8238993287086487,
0.41981902718544006,
-0.09065187722444534,
-0.04419392719864845,
-0.029885131865739822,
0.38793420791625977,
0.02098950557410717,
-0.14523768424987793,
0.47395363450050354,
0.22931399941444397,
0.21956925094127655,
-0.40042558312416077,
0.3018084168434143,
0.27989640831947327,
-0.43442070484161377,
0.003058267990127206,
0.5381155610084534,
0.2665337324142456,
-0.2038886398077011,
0.5953479409217834,
-0.1659643054008484,
-0.2354924976825714,
0.2628866732120514,
0.18817049264907837,
0.9320302605628967,
-0.31032243371009827,
0.4649389088153839,
0.2111879587173462,
0.43290975689888,
-0.39511653780937195,
-0.00198729382827878,
-0.03291366621851921,
-0.7649219632148743,
-0.7224316000938416,
-0.8566147089004517,
-0.17643795907497406,
0.10423395037651062,
-0.6577755212783813,
0.43369898200035095,
-0.23651117086410522,
-0.516651451587677,
0.16697384417057037,
0.1679798662662506,
-0.5272758603096008,
0.20207206904888153,
0.2915726602077484,
1.0781900882720947,
-0.7719108462333679,
0.6113390326499939,
0.7075792551040649,
-0.1757892221212387,
-0.5176504850387573,
0.3994094729423523,
0.04614096134901047,
-0.18026979267597198,
0.27751412987709045,
0.2627336382865906,
-0.1145235076546669,
0.21944524347782135,
-0.5036454796791077,
-0.7921339869499207,
0.7937188148498535,
-0.08875764906406403,
-0.598751425743103,
0.08562111854553223,
-0.0968405231833458,
0.706404447555542,
-0.14982068538665771,
0.21251574158668518,
0.629111647605896,
0.1849016696214676,
-0.016425877809524536,
-0.7234662771224976,
-0.2684440314769745,
-0.07848367840051651,
0.5256919264793396,
0.5464122891426086,
-0.6149601340293884,
0.5161650776863098,
0.09084782749414444,
-0.3163112699985504,
-0.13333436846733093,
0.7105216383934021,
0.03164620324969292,
0.36246880888938904,
0.5490995645523071,
0.7031973600387573,
0.8445295095443726,
-0.16185887157917023,
0.6863614320755005,
-0.07573862373828888,
0.4648273289203644,
0.9533615708351135,
-0.265671968460083,
1.2663322687149048,
0.2560427486896515,
-0.05108911544084549,
0.4486009478569031,
0.4888019263744354,
-0.08639682084321976,
0.7671387791633606,
0.36129775643348694,
0.035835329443216324,
0.034118834882974625,
0.16432805359363556,
0.03052518330514431,
0.4916846752166748,
0.4701479375362396,
-0.16281898319721222,
-0.23335881531238556,
0.435973197221756,
0.12946489453315735,
0.3615871071815491,
-0.5623660087585449,
0.8244295120239258,
-0.010402296669781208,
-0.7961732149124146,
0.39060723781585693,
0.22415193915367126,
0.9936866164207458,
-0.37744152545928955,
0.36717966198921204,
-0.2079296112060547,
0.5086636543273926,
-0.10426787286996841,
-0.446541965007782,
0.4944838583469391,
0.25697481632232666,
-0.27164560556411743,
-0.4432680010795593,
0.5922091007232666,
-0.3775240182876587,
-0.6223196387290955,
-0.1736755669116974,
0.18232719600200653,
-0.1686360388994217,
-0.11364082992076874,
-0.5181606411933899,
0.1724335104227066,
-0.06400354206562042,
-0.3183324337005615,
-0.036407601088285446,
0.4854254722595215,
0.06143359839916229,
0.7240167856216431,
0.4660765528678894,
0.21877354383468628,
0.16687758266925812,
0.04165398329496384,
0.5831085443496704,
-0.6684243083000183,
-0.6180496215820312,
-0.9160473346710205,
0.3899042308330536,
-0.2420908361673355,
-0.7186521291732788,
0.8539485931396484,
0.5452731847763062,
1.2719799280166626,
-0.06459341198205948,
0.7189372181892395,
0.20812417566776276,
0.9961519241333008,
-0.6666335463523865,
0.6285190582275391,
-0.30434948205947876,
0.027068134397268295,
-0.5736487507820129,
-0.7588745951652527,
-0.07122506946325302,
0.6000480055809021,
-0.1322804093360901,
-0.08155916631221771,
0.7336663603782654,
0.4296957850456238,
0.08197715133428574,
0.26784399151802063,
-0.11464376002550125,
0.039558324962854385,
0.34440067410469055,
0.11883500218391418,
0.6003798246383667,
-0.5408996343612671,
0.6681768298149109,
-0.026944143697619438,
-0.07410299777984619,
-0.47068968415260315,
-0.9952289462089539,
-0.9122940897941589,
-0.6298168301582336,
-0.44808268547058105,
0.13038496673107147,
0.1109202578663826,
0.9133522510528564,
0.9747721552848816,
-0.8256761431694031,
-0.10197999328374863,
-0.12486278265714645,
-0.06903862953186035,
-0.4606144428253174,
-0.2887188196182251,
0.0554422028362751,
-0.9415755867958069,
-0.6537238359451294,
0.006186091806739569,
0.1509150266647339,
-0.07977248728275299,
-0.06669361144304276,
0.3526863753795624,
-0.11205776035785675,
0.25232186913490295,
0.6738190650939941,
-0.20572178065776825,
-0.5221303105354309,
-0.1428041160106659,
0.007613928522914648,
0.007978185079991817,
-0.17170841991901398,
0.8527981042861938,
-0.7676618099212646,
0.2398289144039154,
0.5832732915878296,
0.6743600964546204,
0.7011351585388184,
0.35704904794692993,
0.4178934097290039,
-0.9591927528381348,
0.012784971855580807,
0.3819732367992401,
-0.04066073149442673,
0.314492404460907,
-0.26275840401649475,
0.2966548502445221,
0.12165176123380661,
-0.44106367230415344,
-0.9337651133537292,
-0.09046180546283722,
-0.737125039100647,
-0.5527840852737427,
0.9096316695213318,
0.17860065400600433,
-0.0680837333202362,
0.09385856986045837,
-0.0112775769084692,
0.06611505150794983,
-0.33690503239631653,
0.8316389918327332,
1.0818480253219604,
0.19947928190231323,
-0.16123604774475098,
-0.8245264291763306,
0.8800735473632812,
0.1924954205751419,
-0.7241870760917664,
0.17071808874607086,
0.5018323063850403,
0.4097250699996948,
0.11418566852807999,
0.6479493379592896,
0.29976093769073486,
-0.07418794184923172,
-0.394988477230072,
-0.24259375035762787,
0.2252153903245926,
-0.3438537120819092,
-0.4365563988685608,
0.1806337535381317,
-0.32190021872520447,
-0.1895127296447754
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15454v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15454v2
|
Emotion Detection with Transformers: A Comparative Study
| 2024-03-18T23:22:50 | 2024-03-28T21:26:39 |
Mahdi Rezapour
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, stat.AP
|
In this study, we explore the application of transformer-based models for
emotion classification on text data. We train and evaluate several pre-trained
transformer models, on the Emotion dataset using different variants of
transformers. The paper also analyzes some factors that in-fluence the
performance of the model, such as the fine-tuning of the transformer layer, the
trainability of the layer, and the preprocessing of the text data. Our analysis
reveals that commonly applied techniques like removing punctuation and stop
words can hinder model performance. This might be because transformers strength
lies in understanding contextual relationships within text. Elements like
punctuation and stop words can still convey sentiment or emphasis and removing
them might disrupt this context.
|
[
-0.5963025093078613,
-0.5732237100601196,
0.4391513466835022,
0.24169130623340607,
-0.3430076837539673,
0.03013712167739868,
-0.1502823680639267,
-0.6097993850708008,
-0.056052807718515396,
0.29866161942481995,
-0.5470187067985535,
-0.323659747838974,
-0.7326491475105286,
0.4803881049156189,
-0.5855255722999573,
0.8630521893501282,
-0.2281818687915802,
-0.02054944820702076,
-0.13184472918510437,
-0.2014504224061966,
-0.23241393268108368,
-0.642817497253418,
-0.676673412322998,
-0.6850149631500244,
0.49720677733421326,
0.45030900835990906,
0.7301133871078491,
0.18188171088695526,
0.7921587228775024,
0.40007221698760986,
-0.3347122073173523,
-0.4429030418395996,
-0.3211914002895355,
0.2642943859100342,
0.10458474606275558,
-0.6572232842445374,
-0.1400531679391861,
0.2468957155942917,
0.0985432043671608,
-0.028966808691620827,
-0.016513766720891,
-0.0824207067489624,
-0.16777010262012482,
0.6643567085266113,
-0.6784117221832275,
0.28023335337638855,
-0.263825923204422,
0.5629976391792297,
-0.13324642181396484,
-0.1262480467557907,
-0.5681810975074768,
-0.2788909375667572,
0.41053539514541626,
-0.16754727065563202,
0.2722175717353821,
0.21787342429161072,
1.0135926008224487,
0.5971587896347046,
-0.5411054491996765,
-0.4437031149864197,
-0.9009985327720642,
0.8515242338180542,
-0.5256922245025635,
0.4685153365135193,
0.20113851130008698,
0.20334798097610474,
0.6145159006118774,
-0.7177016139030457,
-0.9175532460212708,
-0.09416725486516953,
-0.5169333815574646,
0.5758797526359558,
-0.5154730081558228,
0.08068912476301193,
0.5711374282836914,
0.6539029479026794,
-0.43910980224609375,
0.17040304839611053,
-0.11758448928594589,
0.06988747417926788,
0.36446240544319153,
0.266293466091156,
0.4327618181705475,
-0.5354529619216919,
-0.3074803352355957,
-0.4382602274417877,
-0.31899234652519226,
0.34175196290016174,
0.5715051889419556,
-0.11929674446582794,
-0.1644420474767685,
0.4640364944934845,
0.003674477571621537,
0.1409679651260376,
0.032336581498384476,
0.20900411903858185,
0.40329012274742126,
0.13404378294944763,
-0.41610193252563477,
-0.1346626579761505,
0.846321702003479,
0.44305089116096497,
0.8132656216621399,
-0.1373319923877716,
-0.307263046503067,
0.4691893756389618,
0.4837278723716736,
-0.924367368221283,
-0.2836180031299591,
0.22504116594791412,
-0.7792338728904724,
-0.5473527908325195,
-0.1769484579563141,
-1.0979936122894287,
-0.25394004583358765,
-0.3012703061103821,
0.32891684770584106,
-0.5303869247436523,
-0.22192953526973724,
0.07984448224306107,
-0.23742656409740448,
0.2514697313308716,
-0.08018993586301804,
-0.7421556115150452,
0.36656877398490906,
0.37130671739578247,
0.6749087572097778,
-0.13706693053245544,
-0.029869697988033295,
-0.0564226359128952,
-0.6601293087005615,
-0.02369239553809166,
0.8429867625236511,
-0.7849022746086121,
-0.5600416660308838,
0.14720189571380615,
0.2137596607208252,
-0.348877489566803,
-0.5869188904762268,
0.9705510139465332,
-0.42426130175590515,
0.5151259899139404,
-0.2168535441160202,
-0.5171566009521484,
-0.31197795271873474,
0.10107409209012985,
-1.0404725074768066,
1.1534059047698975,
0.20323537290096283,
-0.9811065196990967,
0.26497775316238403,
-0.7907662987709045,
-0.6098840236663818,
-0.27197691798210144,
0.27624765038490295,
-0.7596620321273804,
0.3091476559638977,
0.17559927701950073,
0.4674733281135559,
-0.11395026743412018,
0.06822837889194489,
0.12654273211956024,
-0.5429041385650635,
0.41578835248947144,
-0.176085963845253,
0.3373114764690399,
0.3673056364059448,
-0.4914816617965698,
0.11291803419589996,
-0.6330204606056213,
-0.45514294505119324,
0.0820891484618187,
-0.04551037400960922,
-0.3429662883281708,
0.3218473792076111,
0.439852237701416,
0.38376760482788086,
-0.203382670879364,
-0.6197764277458191,
-0.1585775762796402,
-0.3559918701648712,
0.258914053440094,
0.4856407642364502,
-0.23067957162857056,
0.29353952407836914,
-0.08784925937652588,
0.8986600041389465,
0.34443265199661255,
0.17627838253974915,
-0.34133389592170715,
-0.2795121669769287,
-1.169738531112671,
-0.10159721970558167,
0.20226389169692993,
0.7813421487808228,
-0.842085063457489,
0.5330967307090759,
0.12606950104236603,
-0.5102951526641846,
-0.5658429265022278,
-0.43756330013275146,
0.3518170714378357,
0.7328035831451416,
0.5766842365264893,
-0.18034660816192627,
-0.63719642162323,
-0.8229387998580933,
-0.5395155549049377,
-0.036889996379613876,
0.031855423003435135,
0.2156807780265808,
0.4575459659099579,
-0.0851692259311676,
0.9677348732948303,
-0.6920198798179626,
-0.003337496193125844,
-0.22257661819458008,
0.5870864391326904,
-0.030460763722658157,
0.25800004601478577,
0.7036977410316467,
-1.1115314960479736,
-0.5084645748138428,
-0.15779320895671844,
-0.824282169342041,
-0.3280600607395172,
0.13485951721668243,
0.2207280546426773,
-0.0036817777436226606,
0.5212880373001099,
-0.5884019136428833,
0.808840811252594,
0.3948880732059479,
-0.41611096262931824,
0.5795717835426331,
0.17479629814624786,
0.4431345760822296,
-0.8706515431404114,
0.020720703527331352,
0.44259417057037354,
-0.16023167967796326,
-1.0294444561004639,
-0.30531221628189087,
0.21149909496307373,
-0.15107055008411407,
-0.6270981431007385,
0.3333022892475128,
-0.017411718145012856,
0.36702755093574524,
-0.35682588815689087,
-0.1905180811882019,
0.19738984107971191,
0.3882341980934143,
0.3496931791305542,
0.5902467966079712,
0.21226385235786438,
-0.3506511151790619,
0.3661265969276428,
0.46186113357543945,
-0.3715363144874573,
0.8851446509361267,
-0.7255691885948181,
0.006466049700975418,
-0.33396708965301514,
0.0003725453279912472,
-0.9957336783409119,
-0.12981735169887543,
0.2173052430152893,
-0.24594449996948242,
0.22847020626068115,
0.2217668741941452,
-0.37432631850242615,
-0.5778627395629883,
-0.242437943816185,
0.11859039962291718,
0.7852288484573364,
-0.6785025000572205,
0.7609471678733826,
-0.12511196732521057,
-0.05932061746716499,
-0.36974257230758667,
-0.6248553395271301,
-0.10734817385673523,
-0.7180730700492859,
-0.39225032925605774,
0.2526989281177521,
-0.11919356882572174,
-0.2502278685569763,
-0.11152742803096771,
-0.012720765545964241,
-0.13239485025405884,
0.10115336626768112,
0.5918012261390686,
0.1308477222919464,
0.056619081646203995,
0.4041804075241089,
-0.013964849524199963,
-0.2793859839439392,
0.2763533592224121,
0.6036583781242371,
0.4447503089904785,
-0.03334003686904907,
-0.15598560869693756,
-0.6186712384223938,
0.14694875478744507,
0.5981670618057251,
-0.29885706305503845,
0.7665926814079285,
1.1086090803146362,
-0.24418604373931885,
-0.052163075655698776,
-0.4983551800251007,
-0.3598267138004303,
-0.5242401361465454,
0.24530908465385437,
-0.37859755754470825,
-0.8795468211174011,
0.5879523754119873,
-0.3059009909629822,
-0.5286160707473755,
0.5414025783538818,
0.4076925218105316,
-0.3337099552154541,
1.0593245029449463,
0.9074928760528564,
-0.25805047154426575,
0.779521107673645,
0.12813660502433777,
0.5722505450248718,
-0.7762588858604431,
-0.203959122300148,
-0.8891187310218811,
-0.4894334375858307,
-0.6038551330566406,
0.2839359641075134,
0.020146893337368965,
0.005687765311449766,
-0.14833369851112366,
0.467736154794693,
-0.636367917060852,
0.3369377851486206,
0.083149753510952,
0.18439021706581116,
0.16056908667087555,
-0.1785404235124588,
0.22036397457122803,
-0.3891902565956116,
-0.15841712057590485,
-0.5149371027946472,
0.5305061936378479,
0.36843031644821167,
0.7339401841163635,
-0.24760261178016663,
0.25766822695732117,
0.28871965408325195,
0.55116868019104,
-1.054869532585144,
0.22192662954330444,
-0.1928444355726242,
-0.4071812033653259,
0.025540197268128395,
-0.4115504026412964,
-0.7089337706565857,
0.14550653100013733,
-0.2615576982498169,
-0.9012361168861389,
0.2590970993041992,
-0.0026360538322478533,
-0.137284517288208,
0.28859806060791016,
-1.035542368888855,
0.996035099029541,
0.10646318644285202,
0.19931495189666748,
0.050928253680467606,
-0.5931568145751953,
0.25743576884269714,
-0.23628376424312592,
0.09730943292379379,
-0.04451177641749382,
0.37935733795166016,
0.8412885665893555,
-0.12969262897968292,
0.6657150387763977,
-0.06767314672470093,
0.07124260812997818,
0.26347923278808594,
-0.011845624074339867,
0.47650107741355896,
-0.3882838785648346,
-0.25442788004875183,
-0.004531512036919594,
-0.33507540822029114,
0.18159209191799164,
-0.6811124682426453,
0.22580385208129883,
-0.633867084980011,
-0.20934484899044037,
-0.1629945933818817,
-0.4760819375514984,
-0.04008986055850983,
-0.01969338394701481,
0.6070822477340698,
0.3219195306301117,
-0.18638615310192108,
0.2015516459941864,
0.5825849771499634,
-0.2948468327522278,
0.8641635179519653,
0.32166212797164917,
-0.08411191403865814,
-0.1529422551393509,
0.6015557050704956,
-0.1138138398528099,
-0.02624392695724964,
0.4071289896965027,
0.22399942576885223,
-0.23721157014369965,
-0.10674717277288437,
0.06254194676876068,
-0.053182121366262436,
-0.6395403742790222,
-0.18977396190166473,
-0.8844633102416992,
-0.05035888031125069,
-0.2268320620059967,
-0.19448095560073853,
-0.21624533832073212,
-0.17059731483459473,
-0.44230055809020996,
-0.21046195924282074,
0.6296376585960388,
0.7595574855804443,
0.2666899561882019,
0.9184613823890686,
-0.6864763498306274,
0.37851375341415405,
0.24206988513469696,
0.6217911243438721,
-0.004905416164547205,
-0.4280490279197693,
-0.2908391058444977,
-0.5064380764961243,
-0.5640535354614258,
-1.047039270401001,
0.6770263314247131,
0.02979338727891445,
0.002730261767283082,
0.6317089200019836,
0.1464429795742035,
0.2853691279888153,
-0.3560482859611511,
0.7617170214653015,
0.20790152251720428,
-1.4894250631332397,
0.5003246068954468,
-0.01589842699468136,
0.29525768756866455,
0.34286147356033325,
0.7243995666503906,
-0.7057337760925293,
-0.19399552047252655,
-0.6571112275123596,
-0.5927183032035828,
0.8400539755821228,
0.551166296005249,
0.07227934151887894,
0.1220584288239479,
0.36136460304260254,
-0.0926101878285408,
0.2730865776538849,
-0.7932732105255127,
-0.26828739047050476,
-0.35176166892051697,
-0.7142108678817749,
-0.13107264041900635,
-0.38990873098373413,
0.31563839316368103,
-0.20084309577941895,
0.2872503399848938,
0.09267950057983398,
0.262565553188324,
0.15190936625003815,
-0.25551483035087585,
-0.24749048054218292,
0.36460068821907043,
0.34915241599082947,
-0.06914481520652771,
-0.3176751732826233,
0.1245460957288742,
0.25431138277053833,
-0.6027486324310303,
0.09759362787008286,
-0.06018780916929245,
0.08855928480625153,
0.21528051793575287,
0.359466016292572,
0.8807111382484436,
0.22690711915493011,
-0.47136440873146057,
0.4643201529979706,
-0.3599895238876343,
-0.043627362698316574,
0.03319835662841797,
-0.10116767883300781,
0.04182877019047737,
0.3434089720249176,
0.08207423239946365,
0.2645779848098755,
0.3618377447128296,
-0.43726077675819397,
0.14990746974945068,
0.05582652986049652,
-0.8583412766456604,
-0.6218813061714172,
0.5934455990791321,
0.18004770576953888,
-0.5793598890304565,
0.5381803512573242,
0.03092096373438835,
-1.170222282409668,
0.8132365942001343,
0.4104883074760437,
0.9858899116516113,
-0.6670696139335632,
0.07812585681676865,
0.15957440435886383,
0.29612788558006287,
-0.09640625864267349,
0.32276996970176697,
-0.0008340885397046804,
-0.8691301345825195,
-0.33309119939804077,
-0.45827290415763855,
-0.7387157678604126,
0.10679072141647339,
-1.0148675441741943,
0.3996904194355011,
-0.06753680109977722,
-0.3645190894603729,
0.16300052404403687,
-0.2756045162677765,
-0.9980762600898743,
0.8273935914039612,
0.12944883108139038,
0.8157855868339539,
-1.1911687850952148,
0.599412202835083,
0.5728477239608765,
-0.28418973088264465,
-0.697995662689209,
-0.07738672196865082,
-0.04478216916322708,
-0.1943645179271698,
0.69309002161026,
0.6333122253417969,
-0.10361127555370331,
-0.08183590322732925,
-0.6035767793655396,
-0.2498159259557724,
0.6450634598731995,
0.004649484995752573,
-0.41972148418426514,
0.11366698145866394,
0.1991848647594452,
0.9316229820251465,
-0.22077986598014832,
0.923987627029419,
0.79738849401474,
0.6089425086975098,
-0.08324020355939865,
-0.6986425518989563,
-0.20199821889400482,
-0.431841641664505,
-0.20033709704875946,
0.27190595865249634,
-0.7027865052223206,
0.978859007358551,
0.44548749923706055,
-0.2904525101184845,
-0.1330607533454895,
0.4827546775341034,
-0.2992018461227417,
0.418911337852478,
0.7801732420921326,
0.673422634601593,
0.3833419680595398,
-0.5525321960449219,
1.051930546760559,
-0.18870823085308075,
0.7257512807846069,
0.6647986769676208,
-0.4281010925769806,
0.6816996932029724,
0.2306935042142868,
-0.24559128284454346,
0.751623809337616,
0.5801065564155579,
-0.04310926795005798,
0.3666115999221802,
0.06584147363901138,
-0.15822136402130127,
-0.04508057236671448,
-0.20026163756847382,
-0.14006860554218292,
0.7458635568618774,
0.35699087381362915,
-0.5007898211479187,
-0.011678817681968212,
0.33426347374916077,
0.13000884652137756,
-0.004366444423794746,
0.04656146466732025,
0.5723934769630432,
0.15012910962104797,
-0.43199244141578674,
-0.00880663562566042,
-0.17104706168174744,
0.863091766834259,
-0.18072044849395752,
0.1625324934720993,
-0.30734366178512573,
0.15107585489749908,
-0.3761773109436035,
-0.7423141002655029,
0.5202380418777466,
0.38874557614326477,
-0.26969245076179504,
-0.31172990798950195,
0.9931171536445618,
-0.2799372673034668,
-0.2765134572982788,
0.46527379751205444,
0.24782870709896088,
0.06324532628059387,
-0.29896098375320435,
-0.4105857312679291,
0.14726150035858154,
-0.18765747547149658,
-0.8104925751686096,
-0.10644353181123734,
0.692976176738739,
0.39574354887008667,
0.595993161201477,
0.3169187903404236,
-0.3573291301727295,
-0.3085474967956543,
0.2767869830131531,
0.7454190254211426,
-1.0232082605361938,
-0.39024266600608826,
-0.9532617330551147,
0.6379998326301575,
-0.13467931747436523,
-0.19383765757083893,
0.6141244769096375,
0.24905909597873688,
0.45222294330596924,
-0.3172251880168915,
0.5659055709838867,
0.041398316621780396,
0.480267733335495,
-0.30599358677864075,
0.6593919396400452,
-0.344331294298172,
-0.2596643269062042,
-0.7539887428283691,
-0.9021415710449219,
-0.36370187997817993,
0.6952775120735168,
-0.3547053635120392,
0.10308922082185745,
0.9161879420280457,
0.4002349078655243,
0.03821048140525818,
0.5774312019348145,
0.42753368616104126,
0.09612543135881424,
0.3004120886325836,
0.4058336615562439,
1.1013946533203125,
-0.6243026256561279,
0.39875176548957825,
-0.4008205235004425,
-0.012087700888514519,
-0.1786363124847412,
-0.9174665212631226,
-1.0300132036209106,
-0.4445767104625702,
-0.3833444118499756,
-0.16290241479873657,
-0.34503409266471863,
0.39074423909187317,
0.5763918161392212,
-0.789867639541626,
0.13952909409999847,
0.12051353603601456,
0.15959136188030243,
0.03425304591655731,
-0.31981536746025085,
0.23967838287353516,
-0.1786380261182785,
-0.8841344118118286,
0.15206293761730194,
0.18241547048091888,
0.1473761945962906,
0.09659375995397568,
0.19933219254016876,
0.05150102078914642,
0.2579993009567261,
0.6759445667266846,
-0.053262095898389816,
-0.27300241589546204,
-0.5049009919166565,
0.1041315570473671,
-0.04770830646157265,
0.29676076769828796,
0.9184149503707886,
-0.7884424328804016,
0.4150882065296173,
0.5616902709007263,
0.26338884234428406,
0.5513820052146912,
0.2245638072490692,
0.25980743765830994,
-0.7839108109474182,
0.41293230652809143,
-0.0029100135434418917,
0.5319377779960632,
0.3521793484687805,
-0.5410328507423401,
0.46717873215675354,
0.15830788016319275,
-0.7406814098358154,
-0.5925546288490295,
0.1591922640800476,
-0.9106582999229431,
0.10620398819446564,
0.7343746423721313,
-0.13456054031848907,
-0.1941860020160675,
-0.010354960337281227,
-0.32075366377830505,
0.5442845821380615,
-0.24728453159332275,
0.8217938542366028,
0.868491530418396,
-0.19628538191318512,
-0.5010241866111755,
-0.2198401540517807,
0.5761203169822693,
0.609786331653595,
-0.9428675770759583,
-0.2793199419975281,
0.09493973106145859,
-0.004511924926191568,
0.36736929416656494,
0.14721572399139404,
0.04460296034812927,
-0.11174876987934113,
-0.08331748098134995,
0.4370398223400116,
0.27033960819244385,
-0.19832636415958405,
-0.604478657245636,
0.34772181510925293,
-0.43928205966949463,
0.001110762357711792
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.12316v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.12316v1
|
OpenEval: Benchmarking Chinese LLMs across Capability, Alignment and Safety
| 2024-03-18T23:21:37 | 2024-03-18T23:21:37 |
Chuang Liu, Linhao Yu, Jiaxuan Li, Renren Jin, Yufei Huang, Ling Shi, Junhui Zhang, Xinmeng Ji, Tingting Cui, Tao Liu, Jinwang Song, Hongying Zan, Sun Li, Deyi Xiong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The rapid development of Chinese large language models (LLMs) poses big
challenges for efficient LLM evaluation. While current initiatives have
introduced new benchmarks or evaluation platforms for assessing Chinese LLMs,
many of these focus primarily on capabilities, usually overlooking potential
alignment and safety issues. To address this gap, we introduce OpenEval, an
evaluation testbed that benchmarks Chinese LLMs across capability, alignment
and safety. For capability assessment, we include 12 benchmark datasets to
evaluate Chinese LLMs from 4 sub-dimensions: NLP tasks, disciplinary knowledge,
commonsense reasoning and mathematical reasoning. For alignment assessment,
OpenEval contains 7 datasets that examines the bias, offensiveness and
illegalness in the outputs yielded by Chinese LLMs. To evaluate safety,
especially anticipated risks (e.g., power-seeking, self-awareness) of advanced
LLMs, we include 6 datasets. In addition to these benchmarks, we have
implemented a phased public evaluation and benchmark update strategy to ensure
that OpenEval is in line with the development of Chinese LLMs or even able to
provide cutting-edge benchmark datasets to guide the development of Chinese
LLMs. In our first public evaluation, we have tested a range of Chinese LLMs,
spanning from 7B to 72B parameters, including both open-source and proprietary
models. Evaluation results indicate that while Chinese LLMs have shown
impressive performance in certain tasks, more attention should be directed
towards broader aspects such as commonsense reasoning, alignment, and safety.
|
[
0.11260028183460236,
-0.3260492980480194,
0.20722682774066925,
0.5323450565338135,
-0.1295401006937027,
-0.14430822432041168,
-0.6223822236061096,
-0.4527440369129181,
-0.4222818613052368,
0.36553633213043213,
-0.14205217361450195,
-0.7723077535629272,
-0.19590020179748535,
-0.19804708659648895,
-0.12849561870098114,
0.8668569922447205,
-0.2801933288574219,
0.3780789077281952,
-0.12223554402589798,
-0.44189587235450745,
-0.34098881483078003,
-0.47952163219451904,
-0.5582534670829773,
-0.1196095198392868,
0.3092968165874481,
0.15182830393314362,
0.8349096775054932,
0.8258057832717896,
1.0380899906158447,
0.18840892612934113,
-0.0514548160135746,
0.19357328116893768,
-0.5060023069381714,
-0.10870484262704849,
-0.11369509994983673,
-0.1279192864894867,
-0.7635916471481323,
0.005916737951338291,
0.9352070689201355,
0.5427731275558472,
-0.2948841452598572,
0.2788833677768707,
0.3644505441188812,
0.4873647093772888,
-0.7520392537117004,
-0.014646346680819988,
-0.6482411026954651,
0.052964549511671066,
-0.4481552541255951,
0.0965212881565094,
-0.23583635687828064,
-0.7704744935035706,
0.16691158711910248,
-0.46309763193130493,
-0.2276884913444519,
0.05849491059780121,
0.7971599698066711,
0.14339269697666168,
-0.20033355057239532,
-0.002827766351401806,
-0.3827769458293915,
0.9340183734893799,
-0.8049646019935608,
0.5140956044197083,
0.06569266319274902,
0.5220617651939392,
-0.032208334654569626,
-0.8883004784584045,
-0.23396115005016327,
-0.4027720093727112,
0.12413835525512695,
0.17358684539794922,
0.37681281566619873,
-0.10139422118663788,
0.1515771597623825,
0.5089187622070312,
-0.7011106610298157,
0.4680646061897278,
-0.21928556263446808,
-0.2967411279678345,
0.9179514646530151,
0.2876686751842499,
0.4654407501220703,
0.01256274152547121,
-0.844139814376831,
-0.10597445070743561,
-1.0878592729568481,
0.17537975311279297,
0.10164956003427505,
0.597283124923706,
-0.19046799838542938,
0.5336272716522217,
-0.12853220105171204,
0.4047994315624237,
-0.47445255517959595,
-0.05603929981589317,
0.49640074372291565,
-0.6376216411590576,
-0.3845363259315491,
0.2512306272983551,
0.9870268702507019,
0.6252622008323669,
0.12242476642131805,
-0.013353909365832806,
-0.4131137430667877,
-0.33017683029174805,
0.2183886021375656,
-0.697582483291626,
-0.047541361302137375,
0.31003108620643616,
-0.7270119190216064,
-0.1935276985168457,
0.27694880962371826,
-0.6313667297363281,
-0.7596837282180786,
-0.025995295494794846,
0.3192935287952423,
-0.42870786786079407,
-0.31939104199409485,
0.09899647533893585,
0.2395811378955841,
0.6754967570304871,
0.24735690653324127,
-0.8312061429023743,
0.17881301045417786,
1.02031409740448,
0.9434373378753662,
-0.5536335706710815,
-0.5084734559059143,
-0.6064667105674744,
0.08660808205604553,
-0.4927138388156891,
0.42370447516441345,
-0.16788707673549652,
-0.13740955293178558,
0.45123180747032166,
0.07992639392614365,
0.07299511879682541,
-0.5844589471817017,
0.9414504170417786,
-0.3300043046474457,
-0.05699621140956879,
-0.5074846744537354,
-0.17655719816684723,
-0.05816267058253288,
0.4362844228744507,
-0.6063916087150574,
1.0720174312591553,
-0.1749410331249237,
-0.5873709321022034,
0.4496172368526459,
-0.7976112365722656,
-0.37308093905448914,
0.2665936350822449,
-0.34557655453681946,
-0.3168778419494629,
-0.18805363774299622,
0.20029979944229126,
0.19305327534675598,
-0.5626582503318787,
0.02808210626244545,
-0.3829366862773895,
-0.3938197195529938,
-0.011395188048481941,
-0.581376314163208,
0.9219342470169067,
0.18284972012043,
-0.22324585914611816,
0.49045097827911377,
-0.5428088307380676,
0.21372799575328827,
0.08702301979064941,
-0.46219831705093384,
-0.3911091983318329,
0.29044249653816223,
0.016530167311429977,
0.11336515843868256,
0.772191047668457,
-0.685299813747406,
-0.05483202636241913,
-0.5056391358375549,
0.24425967037677765,
0.7614096403121948,
-0.28523561358451843,
0.029545661062002182,
-0.3630031943321228,
0.177238330245018,
-0.030911503359675407,
0.4377114474773407,
-0.07776820659637451,
-0.3142312169075012,
-0.5290089249610901,
0.0812283605337143,
0.2104695439338684,
0.6904706954956055,
-0.3545527160167694,
0.5486794710159302,
-0.29930102825164795,
-0.6895588636398315,
-0.7897547483444214,
0.2556685507297516,
0.6611284613609314,
0.2827044129371643,
0.4044162333011627,
-0.3112861216068268,
-0.18061450123786926,
-0.735800564289093,
-0.29082366824150085,
-0.44586238265037537,
-0.38489970564842224,
-0.0028025784995406866,
0.2635861933231354,
0.22017544507980347,
0.46876001358032227,
-0.17235493659973145,
-0.5102581977844238,
-0.1077055111527443,
-0.18031057715415955,
0.09104475378990173,
0.48099154233932495,
0.4342590570449829,
-0.6990782022476196,
-0.42223069071769714,
0.4609079957008362,
-0.9224112629890442,
-0.12385598570108414,
-0.031170543283224106,
-0.1902536153793335,
0.3026163578033447,
0.4217143654823303,
-0.24036037921905518,
0.2012564241886139,
0.46332550048828125,
-0.029515951871871948,
0.5304611921310425,
-0.08661910146474838,
0.11914467066526413,
-0.8430132865905762,
0.09420814365148544,
-0.03482186421751976,
0.2204253077507019,
-0.4746004343032837,
0.35933926701545715,
0.5095303058624268,
0.07487616688013077,
-0.9129465818405151,
0.3508186340332031,
-0.5761484503746033,
-0.3630017042160034,
0.028131484985351562,
0.6464044451713562,
-0.24340713024139404,
0.12703825533390045,
0.018090011551976204,
0.7529916763305664,
0.5124551653862,
-0.3549979627132416,
0.5725662708282471,
0.20938101410865784,
-0.671500027179718,
0.37121981382369995,
-0.7782494425773621,
0.056967467069625854,
0.3527976870536804,
-0.24696499109268188,
-0.9958670139312744,
-0.0015178150497376919,
0.06084516644477844,
-0.1461530327796936,
0.09624890238046646,
0.23714670538902283,
-0.4256782531738281,
-0.2218586951494217,
-0.7759247422218323,
0.2968018352985382,
0.46735116839408875,
-0.7511879801750183,
0.31369683146476746,
0.245934396982193,
0.11511087417602539,
-0.9126888513565063,
-0.6874097585678101,
-0.11529431492090225,
-0.25226157903671265,
-0.8548853993415833,
0.37214553356170654,
0.03134755790233612,
-0.3410675823688507,
0.024206632748246193,
-0.07402142882347107,
0.07200474292039871,
0.24709457159042358,
0.049563825130462646,
0.4594026803970337,
-0.5492516160011292,
0.08903206884860992,
-0.2989254295825958,
0.12421111017465591,
0.17823956906795502,
-0.12419982254505157,
0.3049200475215912,
-0.48262399435043335,
-0.8202739953994751,
-0.25033247470855713,
-0.27780622243881226,
0.33357566595077515,
-0.5163595080375671,
0.6011216044425964,
0.4424624443054199,
-0.554392397403717,
-0.09118503332138062,
-0.40759268403053284,
0.2154056429862976,
-0.5287071466445923,
0.5534931421279907,
-0.18944476544857025,
-0.6080074310302734,
0.4983082413673401,
0.06851007789373398,
0.7770721316337585,
0.39401164650917053,
0.8207921385765076,
0.265851229429245,
0.8123610019683838,
0.38577407598495483,
-0.3165404796600342,
0.1444147825241089,
0.323684960603714,
0.038548972457647324,
-0.9738355278968811,
-0.36023199558258057,
-0.43405118584632874,
-0.20055244863033295,
-0.6161620020866394,
-0.584705650806427,
0.40228378772735596,
0.007946822792291641,
-0.53241366147995,
0.24204686284065247,
-0.4285535514354706,
0.5212175846099854,
0.28725889325141907,
-0.02971598505973816,
0.4110502004623413,
-0.29562267661094666,
-0.22769781947135925,
-0.12938529253005981,
-0.34003427624702454,
-0.8455294966697693,
1.229345440864563,
0.6479955911636353,
0.8878236413002014,
0.2818625569343567,
0.456557959318161,
0.003080537775531411,
0.5805483460426331,
-0.575391411781311,
0.6912446618080139,
-0.40827444195747375,
-0.3710925877094269,
-0.46624240279197693,
-0.13555839657783508,
-0.8569145202636719,
0.39208704233169556,
-0.13372722268104553,
-0.6482852697372437,
-0.365495502948761,
-0.24193796515464783,
-0.3654033839702606,
0.5156984329223633,
-0.3652215003967285,
0.9622869491577148,
-0.8725179433822632,
-0.46697598695755005,
-0.010023694485425949,
-0.5459856390953064,
0.666839599609375,
-0.15826918184757233,
-0.08331957459449768,
-0.15489551424980164,
-0.38449379801750183,
0.7184315919876099,
-0.24465374648571014,
0.6388829946517944,
-0.058059170842170715,
-0.28285884857177734,
0.1465592086315155,
-0.29682862758636475,
0.08209145069122314,
-0.07636824250221252,
-0.5567715764045715,
0.4519416391849518,
-0.03376943990588188,
-0.30341920256614685,
-0.28224027156829834,
1.0539180040359497,
-1.0202592611312866,
-0.707220196723938,
-0.4200149178504944,
-0.3655945062637329,
-0.19726267457008362,
0.3755223751068115,
-0.010142378509044647,
0.056263864040374756,
-0.6109180450439453,
0.3933488428592682,
0.5150320529937744,
-0.5189900994300842,
0.580337405204773,
0.642960250377655,
-0.3534037172794342,
-0.35264870524406433,
0.7963231801986694,
0.23222193121910095,
0.4538010358810425,
0.28719374537467957,
0.1382720023393631,
-0.35845792293548584,
-0.9850045442581177,
-0.48424461483955383,
-0.010833490639925003,
-0.7904378175735474,
-0.11225507408380508,
-0.02133180759847164,
-0.6923351883888245,
-0.4951513707637787,
0.06271146982908249,
-0.46676409244537354,
-0.023534659296274185,
-0.01855599880218506,
-0.12703531980514526,
-0.10634145140647888,
0.6086004972457886,
-0.02866227738559246,
-0.048111315816640854,
-0.7767894864082336,
0.16775530576705933,
0.012931017205119133,
0.708093523979187,
0.10436825454235077,
-0.47195208072662354,
-0.3295971155166626,
-0.1498536616563797,
-0.6453576683998108,
-0.5492775440216064,
0.13757792115211487,
-0.060419630259275436,
0.9615077376365662,
0.697478175163269,
0.34218713641166687,
0.5265012383460999,
-0.4791432023048401,
1.1754820346832275,
0.06041024252772331,
-0.9135712385177612,
0.5094109773635864,
-0.21112608909606934,
0.09346809983253479,
0.5725497603416443,
0.485542893409729,
-0.5367488265037537,
-0.11241040378808975,
-0.08705085515975952,
-0.7436808347702026,
0.5402634143829346,
0.06028144061565399,
-0.10942598432302475,
0.07089938223361969,
0.107541024684906,
-0.05233532562851906,
-0.017511911690235138,
-0.8920092582702637,
-0.054619405418634415,
-0.14325867593288422,
-0.04419431462883949,
0.12152764946222305,
-0.06237148493528366,
-0.2592256963253021,
0.16203002631664276,
0.6351048350334167,
-0.10327271372079849,
-0.10094387084245682,
0.14728902280330658,
0.10136637091636658,
-0.17635084688663483,
0.18154549598693848,
0.5229874849319458,
0.6596528887748718,
-0.25195127725601196,
-0.1263270080089569,
0.5472426414489746,
-0.4943734109401703,
-0.1756434440612793,
0.06152842193841934,
-0.04852684959769249,
-0.3776724338531494,
0.5099796056747437,
0.4944915771484375,
-0.0162902120500803,
-0.8417849540710449,
0.6714581847190857,
0.010858329012989998,
-0.13046325743198395,
-0.36710041761398315,
-0.010900908149778843,
0.1605965793132782,
0.08583536744117737,
0.25772568583488464,
-0.500041663646698,
-0.20580008625984192,
-0.384273499250412,
0.15107868611812592,
0.5523157715797424,
-0.5620737075805664,
-0.1624494045972824,
0.7822985053062439,
0.3473758399486542,
-0.3253324031829834,
0.6913888454437256,
0.13205644488334656,
-0.3496930003166199,
0.5378554463386536,
0.31511494517326355,
1.094967246055603,
-0.4675459861755371,
-0.21936365962028503,
0.32386574149131775,
0.9617722630500793,
-0.04861211031675339,
0.4445659816265106,
0.32610541582107544,
-0.6754575371742249,
-0.27092891931533813,
-0.5430615544319153,
-0.7961302995681763,
0.3132495880126953,
-0.6533033847808838,
0.6729978322982788,
-0.5927660465240479,
0.2531552016735077,
-0.4994581341743469,
0.19724617898464203,
-0.2968660593032837,
0.010900779627263546,
0.33679133653640747,
1.317419409751892,
-0.5475386381149292,
0.8775961995124817,
0.6833975911140442,
-0.3520049452781677,
-0.7872564792633057,
0.23138514161109924,
0.14165562391281128,
-1.1461772918701172,
0.5858123302459717,
0.5162228941917419,
-0.0488274022936821,
-0.6158016324043274,
-0.3379846513271332,
-0.7408272624015808,
1.4828161001205444,
0.226045161485672,
-0.6193110942840576,
0.17024779319763184,
0.4959234893321991,
0.6670773029327393,
-0.39727112650871277,
0.31614798307418823,
0.5375975966453552,
0.6113989353179932,
-0.14975912868976593,
-1.2084110975265503,
0.2844076454639435,
-0.11701876670122147,
0.055199798196554184,
0.10330164432525635,
-1.120072603225708,
0.8646485805511475,
-0.2650943696498871,
-0.4236239492893219,
0.3396977186203003,
0.7750790119171143,
0.3929072916507721,
0.5034711956977844,
0.4697820544242859,
0.41335371136665344,
0.8563389778137207,
-0.1727471649646759,
0.8452304601669312,
-0.4469270408153534,
0.04589461535215378,
1.0887669324874878,
-0.9132794737815857,
1.2229151725769043,
0.22541365027427673,
-0.051632218062877655,
0.32774949073791504,
0.685701847076416,
-0.13558818399906158,
0.3559929132461548,
0.3062019348144531,
-0.19715793430805206,
-0.02860541082918644,
-0.2712497413158417,
-0.5440940856933594,
0.29062849283218384,
0.23976635932922363,
-0.2752259373664856,
-0.32541990280151367,
-0.23317112028598785,
-0.16496235132217407,
0.22895550727844238,
-0.40479475259780884,
0.5768827795982361,
-0.04364463686943054,
-0.6585708260536194,
0.5703842639923096,
0.1527077704668045,
0.638698399066925,
-0.7937434911727905,
0.15051865577697754,
-0.09516351670026779,
0.33644261956214905,
-0.3647700846195221,
-1.0587596893310547,
0.284028559923172,
-0.07817740738391876,
0.4825432002544403,
-0.10090216249227524,
0.7487308979034424,
-0.4007490277290344,
-0.09504420310258865,
0.5675138831138611,
0.33656227588653564,
0.1890125572681427,
0.15375125408172607,
-0.5920685529708862,
0.12097179889678955,
-0.07883818447589874,
-0.24366416037082672,
0.6152400374412537,
0.42251846194267273,
-0.37323033809661865,
0.6358767747879028,
0.6545386910438538,
0.30779021978378296,
-0.025920825079083443,
0.09648541361093521,
0.8001040816307068,
-0.6887040734291077,
-0.15838725864887238,
-1.0151070356369019,
0.37816426157951355,
-0.11940514296293259,
-0.5232877731323242,
0.9495878219604492,
0.6869467496871948,
0.875416100025177,
0.22410039603710175,
0.8160211443901062,
0.1568584442138672,
0.2427850067615509,
-0.5309474468231201,
0.9204461574554443,
-0.49404293298721313,
0.5607544779777527,
-0.0653291866183281,
-0.8077815771102905,
-0.30686289072036743,
0.3411749303340912,
-0.41554391384124756,
-0.1389266848564148,
0.6157833337783813,
0.7327847480773926,
0.17832647264003754,
0.2205410748720169,
0.4442119002342224,
0.12952476739883423,
0.5421738624572754,
0.8850988745689392,
0.9845121502876282,
-0.4068887233734131,
0.7615084052085876,
-0.23350417613983154,
-0.4252576529979706,
0.0640730932354927,
-1.2839128971099854,
-0.9874289631843567,
-0.22452929615974426,
-0.214081272482872,
-0.19515183568000793,
0.0163931455463171,
0.9387351274490356,
0.41307201981544495,
-0.8500996232032776,
-0.5979099273681641,
0.27654165029525757,
0.18782567977905273,
-0.4583330750465393,
-0.2362411618232727,
0.5739346146583557,
-0.4904920160770416,
-0.6172239780426025,
0.4313942492008209,
0.4545997977256775,
-0.17078490555286407,
-0.6371665596961975,
-0.14599238336086273,
-0.03273285925388336,
-0.03222530707716942,
0.47799840569496155,
0.20400601625442505,
-0.8038216829299927,
-0.4734388589859009,
0.06915111839771271,
-0.31971776485443115,
0.015499106608331203,
0.5884817838668823,
-0.32186925411224365,
0.27234676480293274,
0.5800593495368958,
0.989186704158783,
-0.14240776002407074,
0.04241195693612099,
0.6156604290008545,
-0.5431116819381714,
-0.20597052574157715,
0.047255635261535645,
0.40225476026535034,
0.4019853174686432,
-0.08811607211828232,
0.7084490656852722,
-0.13954997062683105,
-0.8090652823448181,
-0.9580456018447876,
-0.09561124444007874,
-0.9688035845756531,
-0.02835761569440365,
1.037160873413086,
-0.5427455902099609,
0.0013558606151491404,
0.041846320033073425,
-0.04837244749069214,
0.10182231664657593,
-0.08657665550708771,
0.6498872637748718,
0.812934398651123,
-0.009648045524954796,
0.18079151213169098,
-0.555060088634491,
0.40299251675605774,
0.529333233833313,
-0.9419167041778564,
0.5067328214645386,
0.23587600886821747,
0.024653097614645958,
0.26367130875587463,
0.4025002419948578,
-0.49447083473205566,
0.469497948884964,
-0.2685377597808838,
-0.07375072687864304,
0.05031677708029747,
-0.16972464323043823,
-0.3767407536506653,
0.31500598788261414,
0.24058204889297485,
-0.3742012083530426
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.12297v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.12297v1
|
Leveraging Large Language Models to Extract Information on Substance Use Disorder Severity from Clinical Notes: A Zero-shot Learning Approach
| 2024-03-18T22:39:03 | 2024-03-18T22:39:03 |
Maria Mahbub, Gregory M. Dams, Sudarshan Srinivasan, Caitlin Rizy, Ioana Danciu, Jodie Trafton, Kathryn Knight
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Substance use disorder (SUD) poses a major concern due to its detrimental
effects on health and society. SUD identification and treatment depend on a
variety of factors such as severity, co-determinants (e.g., withdrawal
symptoms), and social determinants of health. Existing diagnostic coding
systems used by American insurance providers, like the International
Classification of Diseases (ICD-10), lack granularity for certain diagnoses,
but clinicians will add this granularity (as that found within the Diagnostic
and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders classification or DSM-5) as
supplemental unstructured text in clinical notes. Traditional natural language
processing (NLP) methods face limitations in accurately parsing such diverse
clinical language. Large Language Models (LLMs) offer promise in overcoming
these challenges by adapting to diverse language patterns. This study
investigates the application of LLMs for extracting severity-related
information for various SUD diagnoses from clinical notes. We propose a
workflow employing zero-shot learning of LLMs with carefully crafted prompts
and post-processing techniques. Through experimentation with Flan-T5, an
open-source LLM, we demonstrate its superior recall compared to the rule-based
approach. Focusing on 11 categories of SUD diagnoses, we show the effectiveness
of LLMs in extracting severity information, contributing to improved risk
assessment and treatment planning for SUD patients.
|
[
0.009205535985529423,
-0.7241308689117432,
1.0613890886306763,
0.016450462862849236,
-0.12976934015750885,
-0.05419742316007614,
-0.2853313386440277,
-0.5390967130661011,
0.2669489085674286,
0.7704573273658752,
-0.01535878051072359,
-1.04759681224823,
-0.9038394093513489,
0.03229295834898949,
-0.23693439364433289,
1.413016676902771,
-0.15691618621349335,
0.2289307564496994,
0.0350191630423069,
0.08198992908000946,
-0.6080678701400757,
-0.5825110077857971,
-0.9016638398170471,
-0.22100116312503815,
1.0703113079071045,
0.6151441335678101,
0.09326699376106262,
0.2479230761528015,
0.9198887944221497,
0.14859099686145782,
0.03492734581232071,
-0.2856747806072235,
-0.3900768458843231,
0.19533632695674896,
-0.38484063744544983,
-0.3400850296020508,
-0.7513967752456665,
-0.2557024657726288,
0.3318169116973877,
0.80400151014328,
-0.20642685890197754,
0.15497682988643646,
-0.267997682094574,
0.23147070407867432,
-0.6581589579582214,
0.04790283739566803,
-0.4232082664966583,
0.047042232006788254,
-0.2010938823223114,
-0.20406903326511383,
-0.42244818806648254,
0.10152824968099594,
0.014616445638239384,
-0.3506346046924591,
0.3389968276023865,
-0.1921953409910202,
0.6922319531440735,
-0.03954341262578964,
-0.4816690981388092,
-0.4966350793838501,
-0.981652021408081,
0.6318480372428894,
-0.9226603507995605,
0.06933058798313141,
0.469182550907135,
0.3541053533554077,
-0.09054761379957199,
-0.41664406657218933,
-0.36838123202323914,
-0.221542090177536,
-0.0010750293731689453,
-0.010387074202299118,
0.24635973572731018,
0.15964308381080627,
0.593806266784668,
0.5045234560966492,
-0.6158400177955627,
0.384367972612381,
-0.6719155311584473,
-0.1351737678050995,
0.7086368203163147,
0.5436263680458069,
0.6062225699424744,
-0.24798168241977692,
-0.4468189477920532,
0.38564589619636536,
-0.6928164958953857,
0.0030545182526111603,
-0.410286009311676,
0.5262986421585083,
-0.2779918909072876,
0.6957047581672668,
0.0698617622256279,
0.49487605690956116,
-0.3351081907749176,
-0.6169354915618896,
0.16611695289611816,
0.05574570596218109,
-0.39470988512039185,
0.21113011240959167,
0.84493088722229,
0.2011631429195404,
-0.16277632117271423,
-0.2784605026245117,
-0.4054807722568512,
-0.11845895648002625,
0.35263699293136597,
-0.7481346726417542,
-0.25309816002845764,
0.3923845887184143,
-0.4352930784225464,
-0.40201085805892944,
-0.33945658802986145,
-0.916292667388916,
-0.810512125492096,
-0.43303367495536804,
0.5310159921646118,
-0.6146044135093689,
-0.37854573130607605,
-0.01775531657040119,
-0.09724733233451843,
0.009725917130708694,
0.4827081263065338,
-0.8777649998664856,
0.521442174911499,
0.6403346061706543,
1.1282206773757935,
-0.43521246314048767,
0.06705508381128311,
-0.7551197409629822,
0.4134023189544678,
-0.3377818465232849,
0.8210467100143433,
-0.3940039873123169,
-0.3699398636817932,
-0.17161080241203308,
-0.027151117101311684,
-0.12627539038658142,
-0.7336944341659546,
0.7526357769966125,
-0.10077963769435883,
-0.14778272807598114,
-0.1752350628376007,
-0.6059349179267883,
-0.0677509531378746,
0.12530314922332764,
-0.6083541512489319,
0.4954949915409088,
0.4685983657836914,
-0.6327146887779236,
0.4674258530139923,
-0.7836107611656189,
-0.5198755860328674,
0.338032066822052,
0.07306919246912003,
-0.30641093850135803,
0.41894322633743286,
-0.03242731839418411,
0.5795641541481018,
-0.2724301815032959,
0.4435672163963318,
-0.46285951137542725,
-0.300254225730896,
0.027214013040065765,
-0.28027933835983276,
0.7217494249343872,
0.27507349848747253,
0.18558050692081451,
0.1770009547472,
-0.8096464276313782,
-0.4556502401828766,
0.06071095168590546,
-0.3116039037704468,
-0.7149906158447266,
-0.2636651396751404,
0.27274295687675476,
0.38759443163871765,
0.01877121441066265,
-0.7255924940109253,
-0.004681425169110298,
-0.21424554288387299,
0.041415512561798096,
0.3781241774559021,
0.5796064138412476,
0.15237392485141754,
-0.4957859516143799,
0.5636073350906372,
0.4616614580154419,
0.0397210419178009,
-0.34470462799072266,
-0.22333920001983643,
-0.5068668723106384,
-0.4928951561450958,
0.27738094329833984,
0.6614589691162109,
-0.44779565930366516,
0.39052945375442505,
-0.33505526185035706,
-0.40382617712020874,
-0.27901774644851685,
0.2129371166229248,
0.23553261160850525,
0.7892200946807861,
0.563652753829956,
-0.1956770271062851,
-0.3557451069355011,
-0.43418294191360474,
-0.10340315103530884,
0.3254673480987549,
-0.13461026549339294,
0.2884758710861206,
0.6377543210983276,
-0.06763287633657455,
0.5318013429641724,
-0.6373286843299866,
-0.8318604230880737,
-0.6288447976112366,
0.29949039220809937,
0.12537366151809692,
0.19839930534362793,
0.3896111845970154,
-0.18595783412456512,
-0.6443945169448853,
0.26293694972991943,
-0.7435207366943359,
-0.16143105924129486,
-0.23420973122119904,
0.17843197286128998,
0.19841235876083374,
0.5429615378379822,
-0.35080352425575256,
0.5183656811714172,
0.14536409080028534,
-0.35191231966018677,
0.4470748007297516,
-0.31939488649368286,
-0.29560625553131104,
-1.1241915225982666,
0.2021389752626419,
0.301064133644104,
-0.2058691680431366,
-0.7428737282752991,
-0.20828348398208618,
-0.024845918640494347,
-0.23510020971298218,
-0.34068673849105835,
0.4368188679218292,
-0.43610867857933044,
0.15920870006084442,
-0.15978656709194183,
0.14472967386245728,
0.039280906319618225,
0.16623017191886902,
0.15829609334468842,
0.22649511694908142,
0.6821988821029663,
-0.6097030639648438,
0.19072100520133972,
-0.3431863784790039,
-0.3935001790523529,
0.7876676917076111,
-0.4405612647533417,
-0.30934834480285645,
-0.32971712946891785,
-0.05218615382909775,
-0.6399332880973816,
-0.3402878940105438,
0.16394995152950287,
-0.18305394053459167,
0.6305100321769714,
-0.24453121423721313,
-0.19672317802906036,
-0.20560942590236664,
-0.07696402817964554,
0.18571524322032928,
0.3030058443546295,
0.044283121824264526,
0.21618172526359558,
0.6077597737312317,
-0.48718366026878357,
-0.4198566675186157,
-0.3859046995639801,
0.325724720954895,
-0.47146403789520264,
0.11664775758981705,
0.25319626927375793,
0.11946182698011398,
-0.2609710693359375,
-0.08229666948318481,
-0.0638304278254509,
-0.16459690034389496,
0.19080501794815063,
0.17981234192848206,
0.5345353484153748,
-0.23688717186450958,
0.48773515224456787,
0.024588169530034065,
-0.1173182800412178,
0.10314388573169708,
0.137471541762352,
0.6096603274345398,
0.10206423699855804,
-0.1088285967707634,
-0.4644216001033783,
0.5924698710441589,
0.6604433655738831,
-0.05064861476421356,
0.8005843162536621,
0.4323928654193878,
-0.6017321944236755,
-0.39969152212142944,
-0.2555473744869232,
-0.11963009834289551,
-0.3160102665424347,
0.18327058851718903,
-0.18556801974773407,
-0.6727801561355591,
0.5877478718757629,
-0.18060608208179474,
-0.05350378528237343,
0.2503555715084076,
0.4559670388698578,
-0.34116479754447937,
0.8487007021903992,
0.5107829570770264,
-0.02851169742643833,
0.27142468094825745,
-0.2372930943965912,
0.5620846152305603,
-0.9466404914855957,
-0.21489012241363525,
-0.3295157849788666,
-0.08796227723360062,
-0.06043560430407524,
-0.4865591824054718,
0.6968153119087219,
0.19111430644989014,
-0.3267399072647095,
-0.060139451175928116,
-0.0791642814874649,
0.3369584083557129,
0.039760444313287735,
0.12453959882259369,
0.4555710554122925,
0.08484289795160294,
-0.0015734387561678886,
-0.29355889558792114,
-0.41520124673843384,
-0.4784526228904724,
1.2780636548995972,
0.424136221408844,
0.5846911072731018,
0.13999037444591522,
0.8082013726234436,
0.47490552067756653,
0.8607448935508728,
-1.1952553987503052,
0.26592740416526794,
-0.42934852838516235,
-0.3245333433151245,
-0.2304151952266693,
-0.5822348594665527,
-0.9266336560249329,
0.14907535910606384,
-0.19506870210170746,
-0.8723322749137878,
0.02401242032647133,
-0.256941020488739,
-0.6267009377479553,
0.41972416639328003,
-0.6816757917404175,
0.8768418431282043,
-0.31248679757118225,
0.09856969118118286,
-0.06612581759691238,
-0.3345692753791809,
0.7541137933731079,
-0.2706493139266968,
0.5623684525489807,
-0.3609241843223572,
0.007800201885402203,
0.644599199295044,
-0.5825245380401611,
0.909165620803833,
-0.2843245267868042,
-0.44535183906555176,
0.06148650497198105,
0.17808440327644348,
-0.034902896732091904,
0.15193524956703186,
0.06756509095430374,
0.18216288089752197,
0.22612833976745605,
-0.15610277652740479,
-0.7831534743309021,
0.8248280882835388,
-0.6277303099632263,
-0.37684711813926697,
-0.4046453833580017,
-0.4548153579235077,
-0.18838103115558624,
0.47864362597465515,
0.06626497954130173,
0.7134678959846497,
-0.24199242889881134,
-0.09266462922096252,
0.6595087051391602,
-0.43720147013664246,
0.43009641766548157,
0.8130103945732117,
-0.35588929057121277,
-0.28946736454963684,
1.087726354598999,
0.392127126455307,
0.3265056312084198,
0.42542216181755066,
0.3797018826007843,
-0.02578350156545639,
-0.7090907096862793,
-0.2549588978290558,
0.4813527762889862,
-0.5424054265022278,
-0.4652910530567169,
-0.7777699828147888,
-0.4013745188713074,
-0.7402387261390686,
0.04570631682872772,
-0.12389379739761353,
-0.3052257299423218,
-0.3084562122821808,
-0.16263128817081451,
0.47423747181892395,
0.8219521045684814,
0.022751031443476677,
0.21277663111686707,
-0.9540716409683228,
0.6236838698387146,
-0.07170230895280838,
0.6686966419219971,
0.27869436144828796,
-0.48481160402297974,
-0.34152549505233765,
-0.11608916521072388,
-0.19516250491142273,
-0.9794618487358093,
0.6072744131088257,
0.12359574437141418,
0.39866137504577637,
0.6821680665016174,
0.38986098766326904,
0.5848225951194763,
-0.2750445008277893,
0.7334716320037842,
0.3251155614852905,
-0.8056443929672241,
0.7363184094429016,
-0.4447382092475891,
-0.0170374047011137,
0.5454904437065125,
0.7511162757873535,
-1.0066165924072266,
-0.3059135675430298,
-0.44532766938209534,
-0.8495174050331116,
0.8289626836776733,
-0.4115281403064728,
-0.06861598044633865,
-0.19972093403339386,
0.29349568486213684,
0.11019445210695267,
-0.15370163321495056,
-0.6475846171379089,
-0.055736467242240906,
0.0925021544098854,
-0.44680044054985046,
-0.20551450550556183,
-0.29300111532211304,
-0.26046717166900635,
-0.3986290693283081,
0.41366100311279297,
0.012958120554685593,
0.0004361434548627585,
0.37543365359306335,
-0.31415751576423645,
-0.0671839639544487,
0.4129413366317749,
0.5779733657836914,
0.48642754554748535,
-0.3046201765537262,
0.20295800268650055,
0.027989307418465614,
-0.6612429618835449,
0.020885296165943146,
-0.4833170771598816,
-0.2868235409259796,
-0.0211464986205101,
0.40323278307914734,
0.9775866270065308,
-0.012582794763147831,
-0.9147430062294006,
0.8180273771286011,
0.08095543831586838,
-0.13486307859420776,
-0.44426241517066956,
0.15767160058021545,
-0.12070751190185547,
-0.18179893493652344,
-0.1140439435839653,
-0.08183179795742035,
0.19440461695194244,
-0.6756842732429504,
0.14941437542438507,
0.28904423117637634,
-0.6978871822357178,
-0.33572643995285034,
0.26414987444877625,
-0.07376710325479507,
-0.5178177356719971,
0.5143114328384399,
-0.036348242312669754,
0.014133227057754993,
0.5647492408752441,
0.8699498176574707,
0.7165626883506775,
-0.11264767497777939,
0.6076151728630066,
0.44954076409339905,
-0.02619543857872486,
0.06625708937644958,
0.2759612798690796,
0.05578601360321045,
-0.505790650844574,
-0.3595482110977173,
-0.7588285207748413,
-0.25428321957588196,
0.5820692777633667,
-0.8009029030799866,
0.5913240909576416,
-0.9704974293708801,
-0.15542759001255035,
-0.003671051701530814,
-0.19379553198814392,
-0.33510884642601013,
0.1869996041059494,
0.4142949879169464,
0.6805064082145691,
-0.9256187677383423,
0.5884782075881958,
0.6380919218063354,
-0.6516847014427185,
-0.7442969679832458,
-0.049562063068151474,
0.04059150442481041,
-0.2724687457084656,
0.25764545798301697,
0.0956016480922699,
0.1998046338558197,
-0.25100040435791016,
-0.4692138433456421,
-0.8095077872276306,
0.851650595664978,
0.0072724539786577225,
-0.4072996973991394,
0.03185642510652542,
0.1887086033821106,
0.9277515411376953,
-0.5582239031791687,
0.2640293836593628,
0.7474202513694763,
0.21934251487255096,
0.3272961676120758,
-0.9341909289360046,
0.12358717620372772,
-0.16635015606880188,
-0.2333473116159439,
0.3138713240623474,
-0.18241894245147705,
0.7476100921630859,
-0.6833255290985107,
-0.2170848548412323,
-0.2602161765098572,
-0.058101046830415726,
0.1322241872549057,
0.49627459049224854,
0.20885953307151794,
0.706864058971405,
0.9947168827056885,
0.32967790961265564,
0.9132788777351379,
-0.028203481808304787,
0.2712664008140564,
1.249988317489624,
-0.6329103708267212,
1.1196856498718262,
0.22400346398353577,
0.035709574818611145,
0.6711894869804382,
0.2913946509361267,
-0.052268221974372864,
0.30429917573928833,
0.2518389821052551,
-0.4996250569820404,
-0.16371826827526093,
-0.23453620076179504,
-0.10989877581596375,
0.4094076156616211,
0.9764875769615173,
-0.5487028956413269,
-0.5527759790420532,
0.1918734312057495,
0.2155655026435852,
-0.1199377253651619,
-0.4991859793663025,
1.1420040130615234,
0.3088119626045227,
-0.47894763946533203,
0.6716926097869873,
0.10748834908008575,
0.4073999524116516,
-0.3431902825832367,
-0.10206250101327896,
-0.13755236566066742,
0.16736093163490295,
-0.3274635076522827,
-0.5943597555160522,
0.5048148036003113,
0.18392612040042877,
-0.3726365268230438,
-0.1448071151971817,
0.6056086421012878,
-0.5137954354286194,
-0.7963719367980957,
0.21008509397506714,
0.30005598068237305,
0.38122376799583435,
-0.08550359308719635,
-0.32575762271881104,
-0.3487762212753296,
-0.2546968460083008,
0.12233857065439224,
0.595235288143158,
0.5336254835128784,
-0.37732380628585815,
0.6010829210281372,
0.6634007096290588,
0.7489717602729797,
-0.1483985036611557,
0.38770097494125366,
0.5086984038352966,
-0.8782960176467896,
-0.16586561501026154,
-0.6926573514938354,
0.3280378580093384,
-0.20594260096549988,
-0.3277720510959625,
0.32294097542762756,
0.4460105001926422,
0.48880085349082947,
-0.060013312846422195,
0.8229882121086121,
0.049708448350429535,
0.9653075337409973,
-0.26130735874176025,
0.9042060971260071,
-0.6088874340057373,
0.478079617023468,
-0.27893194556236267,
-0.5214289426803589,
-0.7088398337364197,
0.3096851408481598,
-0.45586857199668884,
-0.14965318143367767,
0.7705185413360596,
0.4972165524959564,
0.06004791706800461,
-0.2138470709323883,
0.34104666113853455,
0.4699968695640564,
0.5889573693275452,
0.7473132610321045,
0.4845137596130371,
-0.26188138127326965,
0.309173583984375,
-0.22217091917991638,
-0.18961718678474426,
-0.11004655808210373,
-0.6267324686050415,
-0.8847066760063171,
-0.3008098006248474,
-0.25002530217170715,
-0.14297011494636536,
-0.3408808410167694,
0.7927241921424866,
0.2711837589740753,
-0.9631279110908508,
-0.10639012604951859,
0.09830249845981598,
0.4387408196926117,
-0.15163446962833405,
-0.3341931402683258,
0.2846637964248657,
-0.5643699765205383,
-0.339756041765213,
0.15483123064041138,
0.5813755989074707,
0.12432021647691727,
-0.22384610772132874,
0.23132136464118958,
-0.018901647999882698,
-0.25301626324653625,
0.781723141670227,
0.12914294004440308,
-0.5172370672225952,
0.07578831911087036,
-0.06421130895614624,
-0.32689395546913147,
0.09255027770996094,
1.1508809328079224,
-0.6114890575408936,
0.26056841015815735,
0.4036080539226532,
0.24083922803401947,
0.2753807604312897,
-0.057312414050102234,
0.46921637654304504,
-0.22301772236824036,
-0.2701798379421234,
0.5168315768241882,
0.11381398141384125,
0.3359338045120239,
-0.4563053548336029,
0.024025365710258484,
0.3690659701824188,
-0.2360106110572815,
-0.9522930979728699,
0.0394657664000988,
-0.8783270120620728,
-0.4464268982410431,
1.089690089225769,
-0.3377753794193268,
-0.13902191817760468,
-0.7705609798431396,
-0.26967254281044006,
-0.042043667286634445,
-0.3889087736606598,
1.006103515625,
0.5692879557609558,
-0.2742415964603424,
-0.3755471706390381,
-0.8431439995765686,
0.5789358615875244,
0.03284040838479996,
-0.7356894612312317,
0.21783338487148285,
0.4006447494029999,
0.7457032203674316,
-0.02259025350213051,
0.923346996307373,
-0.4235646724700928,
0.11728135496377945,
-0.12012047320604324,
0.15580423176288605,
0.14463628828525543,
-0.46169736981391907,
-0.46548059582710266,
0.32753923535346985,
-0.11393292248249054,
0.3466760814189911
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.12294v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.12294v1
|
A Comparative Investigation of Compositional Syntax and Semantics in DALL-E 2
| 2024-03-18T22:33:51 | 2024-03-18T22:33:51 |
Elliot Murphy, Jill de Villiers, Sofia Lucero Morales
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this study we compared how well DALL-E 2 visually represented the meaning
of linguistic prompts also given to young children in comprehension tests.
Sentences representing fundamental components of grammatical knowledge were
selected from assessment tests used with several hundred English-speaking
children aged 2-7 years for whom we had collected original item-level data.
DALL-E 2 was given these prompts five times to generate 20 cartoons per item,
for 9 adult judges to score. Results revealed no conditions in which DALL-E
2-generated images that matched the semantic accuracy of children, even at the
youngest age (2 years). DALL-E 2 failed to assign the appropriate roles in
reversible forms; it failed on negation despite an easier contrastive prompt
than the children received; it often assigned the adjective to the wrong noun;
it ignored implicit agents in passives. This work points to a clear absence of
compositional sentence representations for DALL-E 2.
|
[
-0.2131325602531433,
-0.7792694568634033,
0.6681533455848694,
0.5008841753005981,
-0.07943345606327057,
0.04649613797664642,
-0.017556535080075264,
-0.43438205122947693,
-0.276763916015625,
0.02679784782230854,
-0.7182392477989197,
-0.14128077030181885,
-0.5660213232040405,
0.31991180777549744,
-0.3971245586872101,
0.7664057016372681,
-0.1597578227519989,
-0.1611054390668869,
-0.6008532047271729,
0.20657935738563538,
-0.49104806780815125,
0.05418681353330612,
-0.9295169711112976,
-0.1416560262441635,
0.7384989857673645,
0.6009596586227417,
0.30879518389701843,
0.37697985768318176,
0.23607321083545685,
0.2393597662448883,
-0.07783050835132599,
-0.04142691567540169,
-0.35996368527412415,
0.45966315269470215,
-0.5562726855278015,
-0.5402413010597229,
-0.007875526323914528,
0.046120092272758484,
0.47886714339256287,
1.0126546621322632,
0.25725260376930237,
-0.2758720815181732,
0.003424321301281452,
1.1890361309051514,
-0.6964202523231506,
0.37410280108451843,
-0.46399354934692383,
-0.002110561588779092,
0.1220383420586586,
0.06720862537622452,
-0.779674232006073,
-0.02535208873450756,
0.1476850062608719,
-0.7413060069084167,
-0.16368766129016876,
-0.03294816613197327,
1.0204066038131714,
0.193600133061409,
-0.8144187927246094,
-0.6926581263542175,
-0.26237452030181885,
1.0156834125518799,
-0.2908906638622284,
0.11590882390737534,
0.5395559072494507,
0.09868898242712021,
-0.012235806323587894,
-0.8625107407569885,
-0.798237144947052,
-0.2934606075286865,
-0.558477520942688,
0.5859684944152832,
-0.33623015880584717,
-0.27851828932762146,
0.2953672707080841,
-0.21831654012203217,
-0.9346978068351746,
0.0833674818277359,
-0.4179342985153198,
-0.008602410554885864,
0.5694782137870789,
0.34277722239494324,
0.4713077247142792,
-0.24977831542491913,
-0.6079439520835876,
-0.3084542155265808,
-0.7135495543479919,
0.19855523109436035,
0.405299574136734,
-0.0963471308350563,
-0.4015079140663147,
0.9074968695640564,
-0.16943174600601196,
0.44476744532585144,
0.33157879114151,
-0.18510200083255768,
0.0485277958214283,
-0.4882875382900238,
0.05548124015331268,
-0.25760146975517273,
0.5071477890014648,
0.9010002613067627,
0.5252184271812439,
0.06134969741106033,
-0.4287303686141968,
0.6476513743400574,
-0.07973015308380127,
-0.5232682228088379,
-0.23410451412200928,
0.06010856106877327,
-0.30539393424987793,
0.04835296422243118,
0.21730060875415802,
-0.6469667553901672,
-0.12924595177173615,
-0.4362848699092865,
0.09577886015176773,
-0.2284623682498932,
0.05564134195446968,
-0.11590017378330231,
-0.3399387001991272,
0.5572807192802429,
0.3323199152946472,
-0.8595073819160461,
0.24528656899929047,
0.5217896699905396,
0.29745471477508545,
-0.38890090584754944,
-0.3685799539089203,
-0.17358969151973724,
0.11068738996982574,
-0.6431036591529846,
1.0222432613372803,
-0.7700744867324829,
-0.4043657183647156,
-0.04577142372727394,
0.2546936869621277,
-0.3465098440647125,
-0.7589921355247498,
0.5069057941436768,
-0.48781469464302063,
0.6520683765411377,
-0.04004658758640289,
-0.5056791305541992,
-0.2241286039352417,
-0.016158917918801308,
-0.47640785574913025,
0.6949554681777954,
0.24977433681488037,
-0.6137274503707886,
0.762317955493927,
-0.2137678563594818,
-0.594389796257019,
-0.27456799149513245,
-0.28349438309669495,
0.053602807223796844,
0.026034947484731674,
0.1671866476535797,
0.1829572319984436,
-0.07164439558982849,
-0.0169757641851902,
0.14090071618556976,
-0.34567922353744507,
0.2493046075105667,
-0.3390829563140869,
0.8172354102134705,
0.15648508071899414,
-0.4921117126941681,
-0.41041699051856995,
-0.4960576295852661,
0.25262540578842163,
0.2639601528644562,
-0.11303918808698654,
-0.16740906238555908,
0.024889903143048286,
0.033776383846998215,
0.22660699486732483,
0.31148838996887207,
-0.45753324031829834,
0.008464639075100422,
-0.5071052312850952,
0.2753241956233978,
0.36341869831085205,
0.0838400200009346,
0.5613333582878113,
-0.5287296175956726,
0.4336754381656647,
0.13069705665111542,
0.042049214243888855,
-0.33193439245224,
-0.6825068593025208,
-0.8711841702461243,
0.08978823572397232,
0.06592419743537903,
0.6384764313697815,
-0.6926944255828857,
0.4615533947944641,
-0.1422678381204605,
-0.24150539934635162,
-0.0038350000977516174,
-0.07321929186582565,
0.5979705452919006,
0.009385609067976475,
0.031965773552656174,
-0.284212201833725,
-0.6258752346038818,
-1.2288644313812256,
0.02552935667335987,
-0.5954174995422363,
0.19398359954357147,
0.5106431245803833,
0.5744152069091797,
-0.17614880204200745,
0.5672445297241211,
-0.34325218200683594,
-0.053426023572683334,
-0.11239639669656754,
0.047702450305223465,
-0.06278331577777863,
0.32589030265808105,
0.6561283469200134,
-0.6056299209594727,
-0.9055919051170349,
0.04870617762207985,
-0.6751569509506226,
-0.5620607733726501,
-0.026477361097931862,
0.057354073971509933,
0.5334777235984802,
0.5175880789756775,
-0.7194623351097107,
0.2509405016899109,
0.37611308693885803,
-0.9062743782997131,
0.4021502435207367,
0.06407387554645538,
0.13666893541812897,
-0.5106024146080017,
-0.013400446623563766,
-0.44555750489234924,
-0.12561705708503723,
-0.18133170902729034,
0.1463247835636139,
0.0015143528580665588,
0.09087622910737991,
-0.5268124938011169,
0.6744089722633362,
-0.4307760000228882,
-0.0038946771528571844,
-0.27859264612197876,
0.5939416885375977,
0.5993931293487549,
0.1038837730884552,
-0.05671600624918938,
1.0446277856826782,
0.5129586458206177,
-0.34711554646492004,
0.47738009691238403,
-0.10802871733903885,
-0.03535061329603195,
0.9859726428985596,
-0.7625526189804077,
0.28499457240104675,
-0.3499070405960083,
0.07076680660247803,
-1.2890173196792603,
-0.2491094172000885,
0.24853761494159698,
-0.4441016912460327,
0.46496304869651794,
0.23051317036151886,
-0.4113825261592865,
-0.14673539996147156,
-0.4385632276535034,
0.5391839146614075,
0.7913651466369629,
-0.27450987696647644,
0.13346245884895325,
0.09663794189691544,
-0.44066670536994934,
-0.3627510964870453,
-0.7258187532424927,
0.018277768045663834,
-0.2090025693178177,
-0.709033191204071,
0.23827403783798218,
-0.014554401859641075,
-0.7403502464294434,
0.27669501304626465,
-0.2903949022293091,
-0.23224882781505585,
-0.13047979772090912,
0.22697940468788147,
0.08581755310297012,
-0.3703855574131012,
0.018610186874866486,
0.47053641080856323,
-0.22522424161434174,
0.34803706407546997,
0.1489015370607376,
0.34097957611083984,
0.16011087596416473,
-0.14542880654335022,
-0.24699664115905762,
0.48991087079048157,
0.578833818435669,
0.29467275738716125,
0.5173614025115967,
0.0960230603814125,
-0.24683846533298492,
-0.4674723446369171,
-0.2196815460920334,
-0.010653195902705193,
-0.3766384720802307,
0.11285647004842758,
-0.3200639486312866,
-0.34926658868789673,
0.2730710208415985,
0.22681856155395508,
-0.14908702671527863,
0.6600621938705444,
0.4209233820438385,
-0.4905920624732971,
0.8684243559837341,
-0.008592554368078709,
0.5520614385604858,
0.15609264373779297,
-0.2772776484489441,
-0.15412573516368866,
-0.9542507529258728,
-0.5946673154830933,
-0.41172412037849426,
-0.3704965114593506,
-0.22448661923408508,
-0.10466507822275162,
0.031591061502695084,
0.2530853748321533,
-0.2645264267921448,
0.29964694380760193,
-0.13186778128147125,
0.8104793429374695,
0.22389930486679077,
-0.07615499198436737,
0.0845596194267273,
-0.09546186774969101,
-0.14210546016693115,
-0.30259206891059875,
-0.4106767177581787,
-0.9053579568862915,
0.9123551845550537,
-0.005345700308680534,
0.8306803703308105,
0.6571416854858398,
0.4638994634151459,
0.38087499141693115,
-0.07187683880329132,
-0.7862645983695984,
0.7719171047210693,
-0.4850330948829651,
-0.33944225311279297,
0.08325200527906418,
0.08672451972961426,
-1.3417471647262573,
0.12129456549882889,
0.06886251270771027,
-0.5246940851211548,
0.4084016680717468,
-0.40202125906944275,
-0.11422713845968246,
-0.4589097201824188,
-1.1709861755371094,
0.6522241830825806,
0.10450668632984161,
-0.5239810943603516,
-0.16639426350593567,
-0.7472840547561646,
0.21662256121635437,
0.019564254209399223,
0.01825522445142269,
0.08008212596178055,
-0.47836801409721375,
0.8299627900123596,
-0.32283738255500793,
0.9476666450500488,
-0.1679801195859909,
-0.26377391815185547,
0.596295952796936,
0.2470933496952057,
0.4426393508911133,
0.1337149739265442,
0.3865693211555481,
-0.7623910307884216,
0.14425241947174072,
-0.5936962366104126,
-0.935302734375,
0.9848902821540833,
-0.674982488155365,
-0.47525554895401,
-0.5921760201454163,
-0.3682846128940582,
0.021210819482803345,
-0.09915805608034134,
0.01889680325984955,
0.6227633953094482,
0.2207992672920227,
0.26403021812438965,
0.2208547592163086,
-0.21066275238990784,
0.5982234477996826,
0.46559658646583557,
-0.2536584138870239,
-0.1984487920999527,
0.6529971957206726,
-0.03791644424200058,
0.5835282206535339,
0.2770887613296509,
-0.17232435941696167,
-0.6509007215499878,
0.04748300090432167,
-0.3834913671016693,
0.292826771736145,
-1.1258035898208618,
0.009933089837431908,
-0.4307147264480591,
0.05078643932938576,
-0.07970931380987167,
-0.4545325040817261,
0.08597759902477264,
-0.5969548225402832,
-0.24069085717201233,
-0.021637242287397385,
-0.043173275887966156,
1.100460171699524,
0.06954021751880646,
-0.019840048626065254,
-0.3576706349849701,
0.2201859951019287,
0.6056812405586243,
-0.11413739621639252,
0.049958787858486176,
-0.4950310289859772,
0.03969801217317581,
-0.13987089693546295,
-0.44414788484573364,
-0.9632218480110168,
-0.2422417551279068,
0.5572232604026794,
0.5176469683647156,
0.37784543633461,
-0.07040352374315262,
0.3916747570037842,
-0.2651709318161011,
1.3604846000671387,
0.07105140388011932,
-0.7431680560112,
0.8060067892074585,
-0.1621512770652771,
0.20543228089809418,
0.3333461582660675,
-0.06369587779045105,
-0.23668044805526733,
-0.313951313495636,
-0.7051852941513062,
-0.6251895427703857,
0.6287679672241211,
0.305267333984375,
0.37665483355522156,
-0.4847983717918396,
0.01285854633897543,
0.2720269560813904,
-0.13628217577934265,
-0.5186476707458496,
-0.5586625933647156,
-0.04101674258708954,
-0.2566170394420624,
0.2076888233423233,
-0.4614289700984955,
-0.036644019186496735,
-0.29938241839408875,
0.36384785175323486,
0.1280539333820343,
0.24350236356258392,
0.3989059031009674,
-0.36654114723205566,
-0.12571501731872559,
0.3899776339530945,
0.791157066822052,
0.780835747718811,
0.37745755910873413,
0.639746367931366,
-0.06652382016181946,
-0.3904041349887848,
0.41706061363220215,
-0.2006232589483261,
-0.4439224898815155,
0.06460508704185486,
1.0112874507904053,
0.6288679838180542,
0.2741677761077881,
-0.9796369671821594,
0.6102770566940308,
0.30237138271331787,
-0.1783357709646225,
-0.32424497604370117,
0.051914215087890625,
0.008611219935119152,
0.44478872418403625,
0.015869731083512306,
-0.34526076912879944,
0.05364691838622093,
-0.9034790992736816,
0.296080082654953,
0.22595372796058655,
-0.10062252730131149,
-0.43843570351600647,
0.46031779050827026,
-0.02551986090838909,
0.12400291115045547,
0.3673234283924103,
-0.5675963759422302,
-0.38086211681365967,
0.7786082625389099,
0.8466538786888123,
0.5984100103378296,
0.15486493706703186,
0.5340431928634644,
0.4002525508403778,
0.4066537916660309,
0.38790345191955566,
0.5627708435058594,
0.13377588987350464,
-0.5910653471946716,
-0.4210696816444397,
-0.1509803980588913,
0.013083875179290771,
-0.16420669853687286,
-0.4975621700286865,
0.01496516540646553,
-0.29933327436447144,
-0.0671285092830658,
-0.05340654402971268,
0.05826008692383766,
-0.7443400025367737,
0.34084686636924744,
0.07483232766389847,
0.5040914416313171,
-0.9701588153839111,
0.27734261751174927,
1.1361911296844482,
-0.639702320098877,
-0.7650732398033142,
-0.0063733248971402645,
-0.1922234147787094,
-0.6828235983848572,
1.422199010848999,
0.10524987429380417,
0.003986753057688475,
0.0811971053481102,
-0.5222688317298889,
-0.37962377071380615,
0.9686629176139832,
-0.04779205098748207,
-0.37735414505004883,
-0.013392782770097256,
0.05343452841043472,
0.58663409948349,
-0.3641084134578705,
0.460818350315094,
0.5501091480255127,
0.7721803784370422,
0.05457103252410889,
-0.8373705744743347,
-0.0019222921691834927,
-0.3713388442993164,
-0.16607707738876343,
-0.06081531569361687,
-0.32087746262550354,
1.0046472549438477,
-0.37786760926246643,
-0.8725168704986572,
0.24478550255298615,
0.3358832597732544,
0.20340485870838165,
0.8038995265960693,
0.35751980543136597,
0.6490492820739746,
0.2351011484861374,
-0.3527759611606598,
1.064479112625122,
0.034878119826316833,
0.3744739294052124,
0.7071272134780884,
-0.31711646914482117,
0.6131272912025452,
0.6822364330291748,
-0.6358123421669006,
0.7099732160568237,
0.5083611607551575,
0.2360888123512268,
0.974541962146759,
-0.0014977765968069434,
-0.3433874845504761,
0.024312863126397133,
-0.35354405641555786,
-0.21167872846126556,
-0.05297088250517845,
0.3911474943161011,
-0.3812175691127777,
-0.21565036475658417,
-0.0005078355316072702,
0.000815030827652663,
0.46410369873046875,
-0.022743074223399162,
1.1277791261672974,
0.3836824893951416,
-0.6055993437767029,
0.7264651656150818,
-0.22681008279323578,
0.3086334466934204,
-0.19299325346946716,
-0.18682165443897247,
-0.5817205905914307,
-0.2870560884475708,
-0.2921670377254486,
-1.314401388168335,
0.25841453671455383,
-0.01517596747726202,
-0.17475625872612,
0.12773124873638153,
0.6149545907974243,
-0.44136518239974976,
-0.23484350740909576,
0.2717156410217285,
0.7720168232917786,
0.2783459424972534,
0.37230223417282104,
-0.5127789974212646,
-0.03573104366660118,
-0.251848965883255,
-0.23771433532238007,
-0.2668781280517578,
0.8108800649642944,
0.017990153282880783,
0.37222445011138916,
0.22315260767936707,
0.061347488313913345,
0.25297948718070984,
0.14744162559509277,
0.6593106389045715,
-0.39377880096435547,
-0.09246931225061417,
-0.6615188121795654,
0.7306380271911621,
0.04619354382157326,
-0.24473810195922852,
0.5960291028022766,
0.6005890369415283,
1.0119785070419312,
-0.4036959707736969,
0.5696829557418823,
-0.34073343873023987,
0.23122844099998474,
-0.8128146529197693,
0.2973967492580414,
-0.7206867933273315,
0.015286574140191078,
-0.062142182141542435,
-1.300220251083374,
-0.1535111516714096,
0.7165443897247314,
-0.30032142996788025,
0.12018830329179764,
1.425105333328247,
0.8237949013710022,
0.06873413920402527,
-0.1349160224199295,
0.30010148882865906,
0.15673652291297913,
-0.03449936583638191,
0.6704334616661072,
1.2809879779815674,
-0.4542757272720337,
-0.0387062132358551,
-0.1905401349067688,
0.02960197813808918,
-0.0685165673494339,
-0.3424689471721649,
-0.9931000471115112,
-0.7027045488357544,
-0.2097797840833664,
-0.19046209752559662,
0.3708692491054535,
0.8170205950737,
0.218571275472641,
-0.6968261003494263,
0.25208404660224915,
-0.08463720977306366,
0.03836013376712799,
-0.1426863670349121,
-0.2842644155025482,
0.48112747073173523,
-0.47402462363243103,
-0.9137036204338074,
0.5990472435951233,
0.06123170256614685,
0.09895821660757065,
-0.23310570418834686,
-0.20751698315143585,
0.09337765723466873,
0.16652436554431915,
0.9696634411811829,
-0.10234604775905609,
-1.085803508758545,
-0.4990884065628052,
0.18878161907196045,
-0.4851253926753998,
-0.21026872098445892,
0.46368643641471863,
-0.6868677139282227,
0.3917664587497711,
0.7311927676200867,
0.22063091397285461,
-0.05039069056510925,
0.0520307756960392,
0.1259070634841919,
-0.7290396094322205,
0.25097429752349854,
0.1712101399898529,
0.2403230220079422,
0.2616211473941803,
0.12668560445308685,
0.5020424127578735,
0.6000440716743469,
-0.2746068239212036,
-0.5373329520225525,
0.5299879312515259,
-1.1814444065093994,
-0.22021444141864777,
1.2919734716415405,
-0.1033809706568718,
-0.014858545735478401,
-0.28844988346099854,
-0.6202110648155212,
-0.13520090281963348,
-0.4069279730319977,
0.30527007579803467,
0.8033490180969238,
0.08129870891571045,
-0.2933802604675293,
-0.39164429903030396,
0.11117131263017654,
0.5104900002479553,
-0.7200003266334534,
-0.24269169569015503,
0.5516785383224487,
0.007329969201236963,
0.010786502622067928,
0.31876757740974426,
-0.22627149522304535,
0.38100430369377136,
0.4725024104118347,
-0.33586645126342773,
0.2738782465457916,
-0.4533425271511078,
0.04173211380839348,
-0.06422732770442963,
0.33956268429756165,
0.02564900927245617
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.12285v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.12285v1
|
FinLlama: Financial Sentiment Classification for Algorithmic Trading Applications
| 2024-03-18T22:11:00 | 2024-03-18T22:11:00 |
Thanos Konstantinidis, Giorgos Iacovides, Mingxue Xu, Tony G. Constantinides, Danilo Mandic
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, q-fin.ST, q-fin.TR
|
There are multiple sources of financial news online which influence market
movements and trader's decisions. This highlights the need for accurate
sentiment analysis, in addition to having appropriate algorithmic trading
techniques, to arrive at better informed trading decisions. Standard lexicon
based sentiment approaches have demonstrated their power in aiding financial
decisions. However, they are known to suffer from issues related to context
sensitivity and word ordering. Large Language Models (LLMs) can also be used in
this context, but they are not finance-specific and tend to require significant
computational resources. To facilitate a finance specific LLM framework, we
introduce a novel approach based on the Llama 2 7B foundational model, in order
to benefit from its generative nature and comprehensive language manipulation.
This is achieved by fine-tuning the Llama2 7B model on a small portion of
supervised financial sentiment analysis data, so as to jointly handle the
complexities of financial lexicon and context, and further equipping it with a
neural network based decision mechanism. Such a generator-classifier scheme,
referred to as FinLlama, is trained not only to classify the sentiment valence
but also quantify its strength, thus offering traders a nuanced insight into
financial news articles. Complementing this, the implementation of
parameter-efficient fine-tuning through LoRA optimises trainable parameters,
thus minimising computational and memory requirements, without sacrificing
accuracy. Simulation results demonstrate the ability of the proposed FinLlama
to provide a framework for enhanced portfolio management decisions and
increased market returns. These results underpin the ability of FinLlama to
construct high-return portfolios which exhibit enhanced resilience, even during
volatile periods and unpredictable market events.
|
[
-0.25557175278663635,
-0.7141977548599243,
0.16341134905815125,
0.46501433849334717,
-0.37972626090049744,
0.3258764147758484,
-0.3314104974269867,
-0.5444338321685791,
0.41969212889671326,
0.7367684841156006,
-0.32718947529792786,
-0.8611599206924438,
-0.7007133960723877,
-0.23154495656490326,
-0.4763384461402893,
1.1002848148345947,
0.03383663669228554,
0.22012795507907867,
0.18032962083816528,
-0.09231659024953842,
-0.2961593568325043,
-0.4205320477485657,
-1.0330331325531006,
-0.3798074424266815,
0.44159626960754395,
0.25718820095062256,
0.6155552864074707,
0.40143367648124695,
0.813849687576294,
0.3684343695640564,
-0.13281786441802979,
0.14198236167430878,
-0.3455941379070282,
-0.0628955215215683,
-0.11201667040586472,
-0.5957459211349487,
-0.6584569215774536,
-0.004288115538656712,
0.1725102812051773,
0.5328865051269531,
-0.45935821533203125,
0.3163512349128723,
-0.06671755015850067,
0.701789915561676,
-0.5940527319908142,
0.7251726984977722,
-0.6023377776145935,
0.022060921415686607,
-0.360331267118454,
-0.2926766872406006,
-0.33091607689857483,
-0.4246131479740143,
0.08351381868124008,
-0.3869855999946594,
-0.13777397572994232,
0.10307832807302475,
0.6081199049949646,
0.3215917944908142,
-0.16958877444267273,
-0.457986444234848,
-0.42263615131378174,
0.6740813255310059,
-0.7646793127059937,
0.09622490406036377,
0.26221731305122375,
0.5328991413116455,
-0.1550099104642868,
-0.4974789023399353,
-0.4576650559902191,
0.17730942368507385,
0.29157754778862,
0.15478259325027466,
-0.22483374178409576,
0.10353579372167587,
-0.08615919947624207,
0.4799457788467407,
-0.1752539873123169,
0.2593461275100708,
-0.5572167038917542,
0.05832539498806,
0.6406894326210022,
0.20081833004951477,
-0.12102203071117401,
-0.18330018222332,
-0.6085606813430786,
-0.2520085275173187,
-0.7098235487937927,
0.2602909803390503,
0.506892204284668,
0.7053093314170837,
-0.13653232157230377,
0.137006938457489,
-0.1779315173625946,
0.6154479384422302,
0.18917667865753174,
-0.5694855451583862,
0.2923499047756195,
0.23567084968090057,
-0.4490946829319,
0.36062443256378174,
0.5481343865394592,
0.5068584680557251,
0.10309045761823654,
0.17389246821403503,
-0.16023145616054535,
0.31766003370285034,
0.2885163724422455,
-0.4696827530860901,
0.021696485579013824,
0.0594782792031765,
-0.507658064365387,
-0.8821356296539307,
0.1226925328373909,
-1.0982158184051514,
-0.4297131597995758,
-0.17153747379779816,
0.2265191525220871,
-0.030773155391216278,
-0.076370470225811,
0.4596363306045532,
0.0288152564316988,
0.5000301599502563,
0.31649985909461975,
-1.071744441986084,
0.5094624757766724,
0.984309196472168,
0.7836401462554932,
0.15965136885643005,
0.00013382874021772295,
-0.5979185700416565,
0.031116263940930367,
-0.5404483079910278,
0.9076011180877686,
-0.4701152443885803,
-0.2270725667476654,
-0.049496326595544815,
-0.3845299184322357,
-0.08044470846652985,
-0.5043482184410095,
0.1375826895236969,
-0.7440714836120605,
0.09184946864843369,
-0.01587652415037155,
-0.401859849691391,
-0.8168210387229919,
0.17113298177719116,
-0.5793538093566895,
0.646343469619751,
0.30499884486198425,
-0.6798866391181946,
0.2609708607196808,
-0.8702741861343384,
-0.36475518345832825,
-0.07953732460737228,
-0.09593059122562408,
-0.3935311734676361,
-0.0006010359502397478,
-0.07938846945762634,
0.619321882724762,
-0.6840158104896545,
0.2220120131969452,
-0.4976491332054138,
-0.3411252796649933,
0.5988675355911255,
-0.2275790423154831,
0.24698717892169952,
0.2671000063419342,
-0.6373746395111084,
0.0827423557639122,
-0.6588873863220215,
-0.21646414697170258,
-0.07872102409601212,
-0.07496781647205353,
-0.550233006477356,
0.0443134680390358,
0.26900336146354675,
0.16068606078624725,
0.3859318196773529,
-0.3029940128326416,
0.12103717029094696,
-0.9426296949386597,
0.528339147567749,
1.090462327003479,
-0.12466911971569061,
0.32564395666122437,
-0.29157277941703796,
0.5347365140914917,
-0.03139108419418335,
0.20609603822231293,
0.2053467482328415,
-0.3457728624343872,
-0.9798421263694763,
-0.18586210906505585,
0.2579994201660156,
0.7066450119018555,
-0.24285224080085754,
0.3826156556606293,
-0.15745705366134644,
-0.4733387231826782,
-0.2828989028930664,
0.7100630402565002,
0.16347233951091766,
0.4122869372367859,
0.2128300815820694,
-0.29654571413993835,
-0.47292762994766235,
-0.9947947859764099,
0.09226514399051666,
-0.320794016122818,
0.4456055760383606,
-0.12372841686010361,
0.022202545776963234,
-0.36447012424468994,
0.6529508829116821,
-0.6506129503250122,
-0.5009726285934448,
-0.35025379061698914,
0.016255144029855728,
0.6952592134475708,
0.18816454708576202,
0.8310021162033081,
-0.7035142183303833,
-0.011754417791962624,
0.35922521352767944,
-0.5508173704147339,
-0.08948860317468643,
-0.3201090693473816,
-0.3283548355102539,
0.26976507902145386,
0.4416007399559021,
-0.3366396725177765,
0.48685190081596375,
0.4450289011001587,
-0.35143718123435974,
-0.14773955941200256,
0.14250266551971436,
-0.2637072503566742,
-1.295965313911438,
0.05340617150068283,
0.2406502664089203,
-0.2381022572517395,
-0.36068299412727356,
0.07767156511545181,
-0.27069947123527527,
0.35899490118026733,
-0.23862934112548828,
0.5446398258209229,
0.18401920795440674,
-0.18223825097084045,
-0.7199702858924866,
-0.03102482669055462,
-0.22764940559864044,
0.5092225074768066,
-0.01855439879000187,
0.6659310460090637,
0.3356189727783203,
-0.37162384390830994,
0.5758503079414368,
0.1878996342420578,
-0.36704692244529724,
0.6157315373420715,
-0.25698426365852356,
-0.11398588120937347,
0.08930344134569168,
0.09896553307771683,
-1.0178322792053223,
-0.10499552637338638,
0.5705739259719849,
-0.2327822893857956,
0.23644378781318665,
0.29191023111343384,
-0.30731549859046936,
-0.26166823506355286,
-0.4755770266056061,
0.060027725994586945,
0.4344865083694458,
-0.6887697577476501,
0.7089360356330872,
0.28303617238998413,
-0.4156173765659332,
-0.7055591344833374,
-0.5687447190284729,
0.07015785574913025,
-0.5526452660560608,
-0.4058927297592163,
0.09651335328817368,
-0.11327095329761505,
-0.6123346090316772,
-0.49121785163879395,
-0.10156034678220749,
0.2690180838108063,
0.36476221680641174,
0.6735000610351562,
0.5856831669807434,
-0.08777584135532379,
0.11404218524694443,
0.2634470760822296,
-0.4749632775783539,
0.10261441022157669,
-0.22160111367702484,
0.6338467001914978,
-0.539741039276123,
0.027169914916157722,
-0.32980862259864807,
0.0406547412276268,
0.5812930464744568,
-0.05012732744216919,
0.6785120368003845,
0.4963223338127136,
-0.2983505427837372,
-0.3846651613712311,
-0.6981538534164429,
0.20751085877418518,
-0.6016576290130615,
0.12454915046691895,
-0.1264125555753708,
-0.9268878698348999,
0.6371936798095703,
-0.23727744817733765,
0.0708978995680809,
0.6890286803245544,
0.8823404312133789,
0.004608106333762407,
0.6377810835838318,
0.6739522218704224,
-0.5427706837654114,
0.40291744470596313,
-0.4274478554725647,
0.1838761270046234,
-0.4754534363746643,
-0.32742074131965637,
-0.22123585641384125,
-0.5410652160644531,
-0.33612632751464844,
-0.2755809426307678,
0.10923529416322708,
0.06457832455635071,
-0.3626788258552551,
0.1218099445104599,
-0.12502989172935486,
0.339306503534317,
0.2572469711303711,
0.03488801792263985,
0.16297966241836548,
0.25344473123550415,
-0.10303837060928345,
0.2402210384607315,
-0.4332086443901062,
-0.5965030193328857,
1.1374574899673462,
0.6237729787826538,
0.8734285831451416,
0.05850992724299431,
0.5360643863677979,
0.6292330622673035,
0.6392889022827148,
-0.8935774564743042,
0.5366921424865723,
-0.38024240732192993,
-0.05737936496734619,
0.16954925656318665,
-0.4768059551715851,
-0.5321349501609802,
-0.08218861371278763,
-0.1743229180574417,
-0.5630994439125061,
0.38324135541915894,
-0.188836932182312,
-0.9001531600952148,
0.35073912143707275,
-0.27028727531433105,
0.6012704372406006,
-0.3085033595561981,
-0.2249661684036255,
-0.3960864245891571,
-0.3714648187160492,
0.3974030017852783,
-0.48845145106315613,
0.5439789295196533,
-0.3819764256477356,
-0.1513257920742035,
0.693509578704834,
-0.5622279644012451,
1.0883471965789795,
0.00936118420213461,
-0.5349686741828918,
0.16783592104911804,
-0.056764427572488785,
0.260043740272522,
0.24044032394886017,
-0.14525100588798523,
0.2910025119781494,
-0.18524658679962158,
-0.21618162095546722,
-0.5215187072753906,
0.928544819355011,
-0.8493933081626892,
-0.4697607159614563,
-0.4936577081680298,
-0.48664191365242004,
-0.33192867040634155,
-0.2036484181880951,
-0.008910081349313259,
0.07199039310216904,
0.11310815811157227,
0.06005535274744034,
0.2952977120876312,
0.07405960559844971,
0.31809282302856445,
0.38459640741348267,
-0.4496114253997803,
-0.7256208062171936,
0.9673371315002441,
-0.15953652560710907,
-0.046934906393289566,
0.3881714940071106,
0.11730607599020004,
-0.28575631976127625,
-0.5530755519866943,
-0.06843145936727524,
0.01953710988163948,
-0.9077578186988831,
-0.6871689558029175,
-0.07344158738851547,
-0.15705899894237518,
-0.3006432056427002,
-0.497224360704422,
-0.39202091097831726,
-0.406217098236084,
-0.45390763878822327,
-0.5569983124732971,
0.8855858445167542,
0.6960233449935913,
-0.18813644349575043,
0.6829826831817627,
-0.5941606760025024,
0.15417593717575073,
0.4444052278995514,
0.5074263215065002,
0.09600331634283066,
-0.3390873372554779,
-0.3133358359336853,
-0.1278401017189026,
-0.1555468738079071,
-0.7085574269294739,
0.6224461793899536,
0.18659304082393646,
0.30404284596443176,
0.97044438123703,
-0.11994669586420059,
0.5940622687339783,
0.34432336688041687,
0.22748123109340668,
0.328831285238266,
-0.9282246232032776,
0.6448755860328674,
-0.317856103181839,
-0.18298229575157166,
0.6125882863998413,
0.003012249479070306,
-0.48515981435775757,
-0.3184581398963928,
-0.30832046270370483,
-0.973543643951416,
0.5311564207077026,
-0.053295668214559555,
0.07959310710430145,
-0.2103201001882553,
0.8224881887435913,
0.2739483714103699,
0.4218975007534027,
-0.5032353401184082,
-0.04471899941563606,
-0.25264304876327515,
-0.5570295453071594,
-0.28241920471191406,
-0.17912247776985168,
-0.11634717881679535,
-0.15228381752967834,
0.6187970638275146,
-0.3549427390098572,
-0.13121140003204346,
-0.24891187250614166,
-0.01875130459666252,
-0.20601624250411987,
0.10190225392580032,
0.3638361096382141,
0.6044012308120728,
-0.30389872193336487,
0.06827953457832336,
0.3744899034500122,
-0.32283666729927063,
0.124702088534832,
0.21146810054779053,
-0.06112269312143326,
-0.34197214245796204,
0.18175387382507324,
0.7417547702789307,
0.7107560634613037,
-0.9475963115692139,
0.3554264307022095,
0.06753688305616379,
-0.17182323336601257,
-0.4868936240673065,
0.33687758445739746,
-0.044140852987766266,
0.9050383567810059,
0.5589696764945984,
0.2684583067893982,
0.21043947339057922,
-0.4719330668449402,
-0.02249964140355587,
0.24202094972133636,
-0.19312287867069244,
-0.15336273610591888,
0.5821475386619568,
0.07604525238275528,
0.18846531212329865,
0.39832961559295654,
0.16519294679164886,
-0.5154033899307251,
0.6641761064529419,
0.31860509514808655,
0.8723785281181335,
-0.21119259297847748,
0.3358074724674225,
0.030716117471456528,
0.0004466925165615976,
-0.3505801260471344,
0.5851935744285583,
0.10518443584442139,
-0.7936593294143677,
-0.24649940431118011,
-1.0929005146026611,
-0.3770807385444641,
-0.1038355827331543,
-0.8196597099304199,
0.10892568528652191,
-1.1542099714279175,
-0.6199997067451477,
0.19904643297195435,
0.16919676959514618,
-0.484775573015213,
0.11844907701015472,
0.5369300246238708,
0.8743105530738831,
-0.6125456690788269,
0.59280925989151,
0.6799471974372864,
-0.2530287206172943,
-0.46446168422698975,
-0.5010806322097778,
0.07122879475355148,
-0.8578112721443176,
0.6935142874717712,
0.30664291977882385,
-0.35860806703567505,
-0.17633597552776337,
-0.4753275215625763,
-0.6257337927818298,
1.1803580522537231,
0.37491244077682495,
-0.6679896116256714,
0.16480538249015808,
0.15266752243041992,
0.5648763179779053,
-0.5898783802986145,
-0.21231797337532043,
0.6162156462669373,
0.5589549541473389,
0.3367235064506531,
-0.7338873147964478,
-0.2814737558364868,
-0.5490857362747192,
0.2300136536359787,
0.29522716999053955,
-1.0149730443954468,
0.7477567791938782,
-0.0004325552436057478,
0.09672420471906662,
0.22554579377174377,
0.7520456910133362,
0.3206205666065216,
0.45094573497772217,
0.5285259485244751,
0.5644070506095886,
0.7727434635162354,
-0.19260655343532562,
0.9106701016426086,
-0.643936276435852,
0.45945796370506287,
0.633717954158783,
-0.3451533913612366,
1.2938342094421387,
0.3249351978302002,
-0.2520517110824585,
0.7416976690292358,
0.8907310366630554,
-0.029315590858459473,
0.3820103406906128,
0.26956260204315186,
-0.3497264087200165,
-0.5126472115516663,
0.04770209267735481,
-0.31915485858917236,
0.9126554727554321,
0.6425614356994629,
-0.5358416438102722,
-0.0429142527282238,
0.19303235411643982,
0.05859162285923958,
0.23887065052986145,
-0.7112104296684265,
0.6404374241828918,
0.4006485342979431,
0.04028637334704399,
0.19694939255714417,
0.5347721576690674,
0.9487146735191345,
-0.7342156767845154,
0.2950904667377472,
-0.32557982206344604,
0.4741584360599518,
-0.11219597607851028,
-0.43909645080566406,
0.31325629353523254,
0.03948444873094559,
-0.16013702750205994,
-0.21351879835128784,
0.7174846529960632,
-0.13998839259147644,
-0.9136224389076233,
0.5852362513542175,
0.24379657208919525,
-0.22049729526042938,
0.007200589869171381,
-0.49462535977363586,
-0.05194614827632904,
-0.33121201395988464,
-0.25071126222610474,
0.3293081521987915,
-0.07481875270605087,
0.02816552110016346,
0.6930950880050659,
0.9546703100204468,
0.015062980353832245,
-0.3449472188949585,
-0.0004756064445246011,
0.834024965763092,
-0.9493546485900879,
-0.893218457698822,
-0.935674250125885,
-0.2672606408596039,
0.1530119776725769,
-0.13862773776054382,
0.5390633940696716,
0.5692622661590576,
0.512738049030304,
0.090730220079422,
0.5474317073822021,
0.6876111030578613,
0.21872086822986603,
-0.7256919741630554,
0.8184751272201538,
-0.29322049021720886,
0.5346367359161377,
-0.38185247778892517,
-0.8123021721839905,
-0.4602218568325043,
0.9754515290260315,
-0.4827572703361511,
-0.24054931104183197,
0.09092678129673004,
0.6532143354415894,
0.1787368357181549,
0.3875328004360199,
-0.04746595397591591,
0.1306234449148178,
-0.08528554439544678,
0.6659208536148071,
0.5904709100723267,
-0.25533178448677063,
0.1943492591381073,
-0.13189361989498138,
-0.06702452898025513,
-0.4002823531627655,
-0.5986788868904114,
-0.7703209519386292,
-0.25414738059043884,
-0.2758695185184479,
-0.23416019976139069,
0.10314581543207169,
1.351008415222168,
0.3358834981918335,
-0.6410364508628845,
-0.6762819290161133,
0.194041445851326,
0.14970989525318146,
-0.27207472920417786,
-0.2281060814857483,
0.3207882046699524,
-0.30652445554733276,
-0.3675491213798523,
0.35209476947784424,
0.7414111495018005,
0.16619031131267548,
-0.5486710071563721,
-0.12188693135976791,
0.18434597551822662,
0.29712679982185364,
0.7382729053497314,
0.1653086543083191,
-0.47625741362571716,
-0.036639101803302765,
-0.24737508594989777,
0.111782006919384,
0.04098893702030182,
0.4493306279182434,
-0.6038806438446045,
0.09916877001523972,
0.29936251044273376,
0.5687271356582642,
0.2749563753604889,
-0.12058573216199875,
0.5808067917823792,
-0.28426626324653625,
0.3280196487903595,
-0.14061355590820312,
0.4089933931827545,
0.016814738512039185,
-0.3785611689090729,
0.34647467732429504,
0.11118009686470032,
0.08371084928512573,
-0.5268235802650452,
-0.30427348613739014,
-1.3800289630889893,
-0.2501741647720337,
1.0402336120605469,
0.06312977522611618,
-0.5928133130073547,
0.18115916848182678,
-0.15738357603549957,
-0.1399117112159729,
-0.5251500010490417,
1.0736008882522583,
0.5582170486450195,
0.29615628719329834,
-0.14199696481227875,
-0.47534477710723877,
0.2744523584842682,
0.04547790437936783,
-0.7971915006637573,
-0.1024458035826683,
0.3289686441421509,
0.1833198219537735,
0.17189572751522064,
0.6666585206985474,
0.04213925451040268,
0.5015542507171631,
-0.29827606678009033,
-0.0470193549990654,
-0.1536235511302948,
-0.2513329088687897,
-0.3241085410118103,
0.5747295022010803,
0.045258644968271255,
0.07443546503782272
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.12244v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.12244v1
|
Zero-Shot Multi-task Hallucination Detection
| 2024-03-18T20:50:26 | 2024-03-18T20:50:26 |
Patanjali Bhamidipati, Advaith Malladi, Manish Shrivastava, Radhika Mamidi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In recent studies, the extensive utilization of large language models has
underscored the importance of robust evaluation methodologies for assessing
text generation quality and relevance to specific tasks. This has revealed a
prevalent issue known as hallucination, an emergent condition in the model
where generated text lacks faithfulness to the source and deviates from the
evaluation criteria. In this study, we formally define hallucination and
propose a framework for its quantitative detection in a zero-shot setting,
leveraging our definition and the assumption that model outputs entail task and
sample specific inputs. In detecting hallucinations, our solution achieves an
accuracy of 0.78 in a model-aware setting and 0.61 in a model-agnostic setting.
Notably, our solution maintains computational efficiency, requiring far less
computational resources than other SOTA approaches, aligning with the trend
towards lightweight and compressed models.
|
[
-0.09292163699865341,
-1.0723422765731812,
1.0765968561172485,
0.3481179177761078,
-0.18773338198661804,
-0.36439821124076843,
-0.09993797540664673,
-0.5567586421966553,
0.36672618985176086,
0.4536322057247162,
-0.6207171678543091,
-0.4842468202114105,
-0.5931788682937622,
0.19647392630577087,
-0.6097133755683899,
0.9050071239471436,
-0.01597944274544716,
-0.038597673177719116,
-0.22417274117469788,
-0.1810561716556549,
-0.7494169473648071,
-0.5266836285591125,
-0.29319825768470764,
-0.2611097991466522,
0.2605975866317749,
0.23669613897800446,
0.49071836471557617,
0.34223034977912903,
0.32487934827804565,
0.21711225807666779,
0.39820632338523865,
0.00965449120849371,
-0.44577643275260925,
0.6614289879798889,
0.10283524543046951,
-0.14712116122245789,
-0.4240172505378723,
-0.2737675607204437,
0.4205038547515869,
0.42405441403388977,
-0.06773106008768082,
0.28803104162216187,
-0.1090141087770462,
0.3138017952442169,
-1.0094308853149414,
-0.07662063091993332,
-0.8213744759559631,
0.23456090688705444,
0.006892435718327761,
-0.5347075462341309,
-0.5571314096450806,
0.01309162750840187,
-0.20112918317317963,
-0.40734758973121643,
0.5873385071754456,
-0.26597103476524353,
0.8310321569442749,
0.5000925660133362,
-0.05238784849643707,
-0.4167938232421875,
-0.8847346305847168,
0.9140583872795105,
-0.7305999398231506,
0.5335782766342163,
0.40204718708992004,
0.30470240116119385,
-0.033633213490247726,
-0.3198198676109314,
-0.949237048625946,
-0.35411596298217773,
0.15947125852108002,
0.10437845438718796,
-0.16510318219661713,
-0.10142701119184494,
0.2726081907749176,
0.2288900762796402,
-0.869900107383728,
-0.10711096972227097,
-0.1134779155254364,
-0.2647514045238495,
0.40702009201049805,
0.23228785395622253,
0.3210674226284027,
-0.3900148868560791,
-0.05580029636621475,
0.14000116288661957,
-0.22661714255809784,
-0.5105032324790955,
0.38646331429481506,
0.4624960720539093,
0.12550127506256104,
0.7976117730140686,
-0.32877495884895325,
0.7346763014793396,
-0.06674744188785553,
-0.015664448961615562,
0.29479146003723145,
-0.4330451488494873,
-0.4911786913871765,
0.1284082978963852,
0.8206481337547302,
0.12513674795627594,
0.14567585289478302,
-0.3831566572189331,
-0.41065719723701477,
0.5367041826248169,
0.643747091293335,
-0.9921644330024719,
-0.14780384302139282,
0.6030286550521851,
-0.4704391658306122,
-0.5586987733840942,
-0.17524610459804535,
-0.7298238277435303,
-0.5468040108680725,
-0.24680714309215546,
0.8333024978637695,
-0.560360848903656,
-0.40449264645576477,
0.3835984766483307,
-0.09701661020517349,
0.043799497187137604,
0.05405091866850853,
-0.8135286569595337,
0.03641994670033455,
0.3346184492111206,
1.0922552347183228,
-0.26901721954345703,
-0.35361868143081665,
-0.5460352897644043,
0.04003950208425522,
-0.3410046398639679,
1.2000664472579956,
-0.27756375074386597,
-0.19732984900474548,
-0.1717086136341095,
-0.11835736781358719,
-0.04433738440275192,
-0.4415402412414551,
0.5493066906929016,
0.04949823021888733,
0.11301456391811371,
0.049187544733285904,
-0.3595443665981293,
-0.20643025636672974,
0.3690740168094635,
-0.6402942538261414,
1.0021487474441528,
0.13442812860012054,
-0.6016258001327515,
0.5632855296134949,
-0.43670961260795593,
-0.37086063623428345,
0.1438939869403839,
-0.4970155358314514,
-0.7437881231307983,
0.5301640629768372,
0.009231985546648502,
0.6738775372505188,
-0.042420655488967896,
0.5781465172767639,
-0.30353957414627075,
-0.8067982196807861,
0.11635313928127289,
-0.47414708137512207,
0.6319769024848938,
0.07239577919244766,
-0.8200273513793945,
0.48422273993492126,
-0.9020752310752869,
-0.00492732971906662,
0.19838355481624603,
0.3086717426776886,
-0.30933573842048645,
-0.1223057210445404,
0.2265627682209015,
0.1284104734659195,
-0.09213434159755707,
-0.4765872359275818,
0.036810025572776794,
-0.2429717779159546,
0.04102211445569992,
0.44141513109207153,
0.12159646302461624,
0.06818847358226776,
-0.2767104208469391,
0.45804375410079956,
0.03414632007479668,
0.018067486584186554,
-0.2772974669933319,
-0.39465752243995667,
-0.7461646199226379,
-0.3763217031955719,
-0.06939961016178131,
0.4090532064437866,
-0.776523232460022,
0.6726613640785217,
-0.05362625792622566,
-0.4337560534477234,
-0.39187246561050415,
-0.20938871800899506,
0.43490633368492126,
0.333097904920578,
0.3815850615501404,
-0.19306997954845428,
-0.5439130663871765,
-0.6559609770774841,
-0.05897050350904465,
0.05634615570306778,
-0.20181629061698914,
0.09256476908922195,
0.7648618221282959,
-0.2706992030143738,
0.6215899586677551,
-0.48962724208831787,
-0.6236514449119568,
-0.19529274106025696,
0.5844805240631104,
0.08453017473220825,
0.34854626655578613,
0.6949136853218079,
-0.4507654905319214,
-0.3602154552936554,
-0.07472359389066696,
-1.2654592990875244,
-0.1023683100938797,
-0.5597958564758301,
0.08113937079906464,
0.5350999236106873,
0.34440842270851135,
-0.6457286477088928,
0.798129141330719,
0.40072259306907654,
-0.44935235381126404,
0.9675930142402649,
-0.021564390510320663,
0.3747488260269165,
-0.9224240183830261,
0.2129175364971161,
-0.026693051680922508,
-0.047205954790115356,
-0.9931071400642395,
0.1413256675004959,
-0.07425912469625473,
-0.11561786383390427,
-0.1896083801984787,
0.2714807987213135,
-0.38004258275032043,
-0.08223708719015121,
-0.5138131976127625,
0.2445286363363266,
0.00556534668430686,
0.43954750895500183,
0.3644911050796509,
0.6361582279205322,
0.637749969959259,
-0.5746207237243652,
0.0519203245639801,
0.08974399417638779,
-0.26092833280563354,
0.6079896688461304,
-0.643150806427002,
0.15530985593795776,
-0.373424232006073,
-0.07716334611177444,
-0.8308805227279663,
-0.374016135931015,
0.38496240973472595,
-0.7451376914978027,
0.034702517092227936,
0.5295862555503845,
-0.4710560142993927,
-0.0013087133411318064,
-0.5094956755638123,
0.42726999521255493,
0.08988038450479507,
-0.13356611132621765,
0.3416690230369568,
0.10500941425561905,
0.2874446511268616,
-0.6418898105621338,
-0.6672945618629456,
-0.053654201328754425,
0.00294767739251256,
-0.38295838236808777,
0.2511492073535919,
-0.1097865030169487,
-0.050479501485824585,
-0.02766496129333973,
-0.28573423624038696,
-0.2797892391681671,
0.08564069122076035,
0.34817561507225037,
0.22323253750801086,
-0.1830553561449051,
0.09929671883583069,
0.10341324657201767,
0.023820478469133377,
-0.0922638326883316,
-0.10958199203014374,
0.8175042271614075,
0.14060641825199127,
-0.5151259899139404,
-0.6417360901832581,
0.38058599829673767,
0.7734878659248352,
0.12199173122644424,
0.7823290228843689,
0.7842659950256348,
-0.8793072700500488,
-0.3127770721912384,
-0.5495200753211975,
-0.5172973275184631,
-0.35203009843826294,
0.29094696044921875,
-0.6305221319198608,
-0.6044662594795227,
0.678007960319519,
0.4764733612537384,
-0.3168644309043884,
0.49000313878059387,
0.6795405745506287,
0.31722477078437805,
1.059912919998169,
0.6364201903343201,
0.40966442227363586,
0.20489712059497833,
-0.08308542519807816,
0.6204168200492859,
-0.515228807926178,
-0.37133103609085083,
-0.6344992518424988,
-0.027731694281101227,
-0.23334214091300964,
-0.25642579793930054,
0.12742622196674347,
0.04523593559861183,
-0.11498858034610748,
0.5695322751998901,
-0.9722936153411865,
0.41103148460388184,
0.23075911402702332,
0.13086827099323273,
0.34707406163215637,
-0.029161447659134865,
0.058762140572071075,
-0.1430080085992813,
-0.40343284606933594,
-0.5272351503372192,
1.0003560781478882,
-0.03259008377790451,
0.35117480158805847,
0.04503636807203293,
0.728127121925354,
0.38972407579421997,
-0.004855633247643709,
-1.0233168601989746,
0.4792177677154541,
0.08847387880086899,
-0.6339412331581116,
-0.6782841682434082,
-0.4868496358394623,
-0.7760670185089111,
0.22572720050811768,
-0.4012390077114105,
-1.1440699100494385,
0.2305264174938202,
-0.1505555808544159,
-0.8442478179931641,
0.12001220136880875,
-0.41799497604370117,
1.1441694498062134,
-0.10916140675544739,
-0.46033987402915955,
-0.09659732133150101,
-0.18781274557113647,
0.7587423920631409,
-0.39978402853012085,
-0.14363624155521393,
-0.3513866662979126,
0.3500683605670929,
0.4421403706073761,
-0.08000192046165466,
0.6091997027397156,
-0.10892830044031143,
-0.07554040104150772,
0.2601994574069977,
0.42546752095222473,
0.24069760739803314,
-0.09839904308319092,
-0.1607542634010315,
0.3453482687473297,
0.2762254476547241,
-0.34079068899154663,
-0.6244488954544067,
0.58833247423172,
-0.4252214729785919,
-0.18576937913894653,
-0.6424287557601929,
-0.7834853529930115,
-0.01582806557416916,
0.30612993240356445,
0.5637603998184204,
0.2593945860862732,
-0.1786964237689972,
0.11585711687803268,
0.5042714476585388,
-0.34754475951194763,
0.41573113203048706,
0.32529690861701965,
-0.5402187705039978,
-0.06891611963510513,
1.1589996814727783,
0.22180473804473877,
0.01753443293273449,
-0.08059309422969818,
-0.1098080724477768,
-0.29928261041641235,
-0.6044795513153076,
-0.572080135345459,
0.09666312485933304,
-0.4310067892074585,
-0.3273371756076813,
-0.8126131296157837,
-0.25651654601097107,
-0.6996582746505737,
-0.15381228923797607,
-0.4154071807861328,
-0.3138000965118408,
-0.5004314184188843,
0.07708103954792023,
0.006396820768713951,
0.5415509343147278,
0.11005686223506927,
0.20624281466007233,
-0.6906324625015259,
0.826278030872345,
-0.008412187919020653,
0.3273492455482483,
0.1455099731683731,
-0.5135075449943542,
-0.07263590395450592,
-0.12820567190647125,
-0.41698139905929565,
-1.1714738607406616,
0.6296929717063904,
-0.0050775823183357716,
0.5474256873130798,
0.6524712443351746,
0.23530904948711395,
0.7854875922203064,
-0.1708172857761383,
0.8305657505989075,
0.35367250442504883,
-1.3357422351837158,
0.5441024899482727,
-0.19484959542751312,
0.35282841324806213,
0.6878282427787781,
0.39853352308273315,
-0.3521994948387146,
-0.6137940883636475,
-0.3921172022819519,
-0.5099794268608093,
0.5901251435279846,
0.5092473030090332,
0.12961581349372864,
-0.03953871130943298,
0.23609013855457306,
0.42322757840156555,
0.2902836799621582,
-1.056059718132019,
0.14748190343379974,
-0.3445849120616913,
-0.08004407584667206,
0.23128201067447662,
-0.3866523504257202,
0.16692107915878296,
-0.13777050375938416,
0.5175826549530029,
-0.2369564175605774,
0.5000863075256348,
0.251840204000473,
-0.2695136070251465,
-0.2916167378425598,
0.17633791267871857,
0.9088717699050903,
0.7794396281242371,
-0.43120256066322327,
0.2572418749332428,
-0.04821160063147545,
-0.4962100088596344,
0.25166043639183044,
-0.24373109638690948,
-0.5313670039176941,
0.46819832921028137,
0.4133678674697876,
0.7621084451675415,
0.1426209956407547,
-0.7330242991447449,
0.7210959792137146,
0.13077732920646667,
-0.2612806558609009,
-0.3359961211681366,
-0.11097799986600876,
-0.45715054869651794,
0.10429219901561737,
0.33082908391952515,
0.11872698366641998,
0.5544908046722412,
-0.670077919960022,
0.5681192278862,
0.547158420085907,
-0.6352689266204834,
-0.4499816596508026,
0.7922531366348267,
-0.23145653307437897,
-0.2692117393016815,
0.5576372742652893,
-0.7499806880950928,
-0.42663314938545227,
0.49630260467529297,
0.6739053726196289,
1.374303936958313,
-0.3500184416770935,
0.5296847820281982,
0.4867195785045624,
0.38840848207473755,
-0.18120324611663818,
0.7177561521530151,
-0.08216892182826996,
-0.9268513321876526,
-0.516514241695404,
-0.8918905854225159,
-0.19826406240463257,
0.5029421448707581,
-0.7568798661231995,
0.5192269086837769,
-0.1707444190979004,
-0.2833108603954315,
0.21422319114208221,
-0.32366421818733215,
-0.2459285408258438,
0.1023174300789833,
0.14634700119495392,
0.246271550655365,
-1.0998425483703613,
0.8706482648849487,
0.19596479833126068,
-0.6645197868347168,
-0.32581907510757446,
0.4378407299518585,
0.02925015054643154,
-0.4424305260181427,
0.2742033898830414,
0.6732229590415955,
-0.4187253415584564,
-0.1960195153951645,
-0.2592032551765442,
-0.30924302339553833,
0.9252399206161499,
0.4103570878505707,
-0.3264811336994171,
0.0034349923953413963,
0.012669669464230537,
0.5976192355155945,
-0.2301931232213974,
0.2289358228445053,
0.6112040281295776,
0.42570996284484863,
0.18065881729125977,
-0.8630778193473816,
0.2769666910171509,
-0.008226917125284672,
-0.1199798509478569,
0.18265657126903534,
-0.23379597067832947,
0.8352535963058472,
-0.20639649033546448,
-0.5386149287223816,
0.12711511552333832,
0.5175432562828064,
0.529590368270874,
0.7645330429077148,
0.32779526710510254,
0.6008604168891907,
0.6290883421897888,
0.027249159291386604,
0.6781017780303955,
-0.39223435521125793,
0.39908453822135925,
1.0656425952911377,
-0.6021012663841248,
0.8039107322692871,
0.49134016036987305,
0.17977683246135712,
0.2511102855205536,
0.3447679877281189,
-0.1394079327583313,
0.4623667299747467,
0.20171482861042023,
-0.3569619357585907,
-0.32120534777641296,
-0.3333352208137512,
-0.23177136480808258,
0.6747881770133972,
0.11783198267221451,
-0.19034457206726074,
-0.19001558423042297,
0.2464703917503357,
-0.07581508904695511,
0.14979195594787598,
-0.030568458139896393,
0.5249989032745361,
-0.15567895770072937,
-0.6815201044082642,
0.7307670712471008,
-0.12986499071121216,
0.678267776966095,
-0.28188642859458923,
-0.31667402386665344,
-0.04470531642436981,
0.05878717452287674,
-0.35096806287765503,
-0.3820253908634186,
0.8672052621841431,
0.0716162696480751,
-0.23340189456939697,
-0.11916185915470123,
0.8606657981872559,
-0.22669026255607605,
-0.6554616093635559,
0.42700618505477905,
0.7105234861373901,
0.5361664891242981,
-0.7530301213264465,
-0.2792356312274933,
0.4638836681842804,
-0.09761248528957367,
-0.11439645290374756,
0.1725142002105713,
0.593891978263855,
-0.056872349232435226,
0.2783368229866028,
0.47530925273895264,
0.08601658046245575,
-0.023874416947364807,
0.12098459899425507,
0.4575324058532715,
-0.622760534286499,
-0.18980498611927032,
-1.092428207397461,
0.34680312871932983,
-0.11519312113523483,
-0.3118755519390106,
0.8635743260383606,
0.6262786984443665,
0.7066877484321594,
-0.32258841395378113,
0.6977661848068237,
-0.08754434436559677,
0.1595209836959839,
-0.3411903977394104,
1.053576111793518,
-0.7129578590393066,
0.011915338225662708,
-0.382287859916687,
-1.1067888736724854,
-0.7254139184951782,
0.8213603496551514,
-0.04455488175153732,
-0.1496839076280594,
1.0240269899368286,
0.9194955229759216,
-0.0375957190990448,
-0.0047399383038282394,
0.9069017171859741,
-0.03143150731921196,
-0.16292819380760193,
0.42880958318710327,
0.712228536605835,
-0.5291088223457336,
0.4667145311832428,
-0.2326945811510086,
-0.2382252812385559,
-0.21860972046852112,
-0.8499652743339539,
-0.8842241168022156,
-0.7588157653808594,
-0.4927833676338196,
-0.37908777594566345,
-0.07639952749013901,
0.5045701861381531,
0.6954145431518555,
-1.196631669998169,
-0.26120641827583313,
-0.30810999870300293,
0.028129931539297104,
-0.46612104773521423,
-0.3253627419471741,
0.2960071861743927,
-0.5201927423477173,
-0.6736247539520264,
0.3912588059902191,
0.6314070820808411,
0.02442345581948757,
-0.6016213893890381,
0.0011221782770007849,
-0.17338398098945618,
0.33851733803749084,
0.7701593637466431,
0.050775740295648575,
-0.8294992446899414,
-0.40541505813598633,
0.351126492023468,
-0.06448110193014145,
-0.052558161318302155,
0.8140347599983215,
-0.6765263080596924,
0.6310073733329773,
0.5249515771865845,
0.36479872465133667,
0.5913498997688293,
-0.24916298687458038,
0.1892794519662857,
-0.6330996155738831,
0.2907871603965759,
0.37821242213249207,
0.06390265375375748,
0.19041134417057037,
-0.48924243450164795,
0.4555186629295349,
0.458786278963089,
-0.49879714846611023,
-1.3524391651153564,
0.2154029905796051,
-0.9621577262878418,
-0.506603479385376,
0.871592104434967,
0.0628160685300827,
-0.07591557502746582,
-0.24107715487480164,
-0.03563021123409271,
0.41502895951271057,
-0.13496600091457367,
1.417275071144104,
0.6823530197143555,
-0.3782358765602112,
-0.1544354110956192,
-0.8373895883560181,
0.3381302058696747,
0.4154350161552429,
-0.8731445074081421,
0.007023770362138748,
0.6973023414611816,
-0.30713507533073425,
0.527069628238678,
0.7913492918014526,
0.055469680577516556,
0.3185366988182068,
0.37435710430145264,
0.521578848361969,
0.12178520858287811,
-0.7926766276359558,
-0.37666207551956177,
0.528252363204956,
-0.2519755959510803,
-0.3640328347682953
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.12242v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.12242v2
|
Reference-based Metrics Disprove Themselves in Question Generation
| 2024-03-18T20:47:10 | 2024-06-17T15:33:37 |
Bang Nguyen, Mengxia Yu, Yun Huang, Meng Jiang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Reference-based metrics such as BLEU and BERTScore are widely used to
evaluate question generation (QG). In this study, on QG benchmarks such as
SQuAD and HotpotQA, we find that using human-written references cannot
guarantee the effectiveness of the reference-based metrics. Most QG benchmarks
have only one reference; we replicated the annotation process and collect
another reference. A good metric was expected to grade a human-validated
question no worse than generated questions. However, the results of
reference-based metrics on our newly collected reference disproved the metrics
themselves. We propose a reference-free metric consisted of multi-dimensional
criteria such as naturalness, answerability, and complexity, utilizing large
language models. These criteria are not constrained to the syntactic or
semantic of a single reference question, and the metric does not require a
diverse set of references. Experiments reveal that our metric accurately
distinguishes between high-quality questions and flawed ones, and achieves
state-of-the-art alignment with human judgment.
|
[
-0.7640641331672668,
-0.7038774490356445,
0.6114400625228882,
0.051762957125902176,
-0.18418103456497192,
0.008145230822265148,
0.007760521024465561,
-0.4468744695186615,
-0.0970098227262497,
0.3512665927410126,
-0.6130917072296143,
-0.1775510013103485,
-0.08459997177124023,
0.3017822504043579,
-0.26549032330513,
1.2555569410324097,
0.1091562807559967,
-0.05381988734006882,
-0.7819520235061646,
-0.5611968040466309,
-0.232160285115242,
-0.6109676957130432,
-0.44362780451774597,
-0.3377936780452728,
0.6946173310279846,
0.6432719826698303,
0.8419539928436279,
0.2764280140399933,
0.7663368582725525,
0.19662688672542572,
0.014797576703131199,
0.6250757575035095,
-0.24331727623939514,
0.07785067707300186,
-0.17550179362297058,
-0.5229226350784302,
-0.28843408823013306,
0.27700555324554443,
0.6280997395515442,
0.6517209410667419,
-0.04015347734093666,
0.6590052843093872,
-0.13710486888885498,
0.626207172870636,
-0.714592456817627,
-0.24454890191555023,
-0.8095550537109375,
-0.17438647150993347,
-0.033599212765693665,
-0.002795666689053178,
-0.15864233672618866,
-0.903687596321106,
-0.015566954389214516,
-0.6059070229530334,
0.9549004435539246,
0.06866717338562012,
1.1741280555725098,
0.390411913394928,
-0.3671118915081024,
-0.3627045154571533,
-0.8362399935722351,
0.5867053270339966,
-0.5574634671211243,
0.30597612261772156,
0.45600977540016174,
0.6125960350036621,
-0.1255478411912918,
-0.5391713976860046,
-0.7906578183174133,
-0.13167287409305573,
-0.09100397676229477,
0.287488728761673,
-0.09907685965299606,
-0.4523422420024872,
0.4686528146266937,
0.0722106397151947,
-0.6321730613708496,
-0.2810513377189636,
-0.5409188866615295,
-0.12531721591949463,
0.6855344176292419,
0.16077394783496857,
-0.08567942678928375,
-0.39469778537750244,
-0.5383675694465637,
-0.07650024443864822,
-0.8499012589454651,
-0.08244676887989044,
0.28248652815818787,
0.041482362896203995,
0.3813437819480896,
0.1794975996017456,
-0.34996935725212097,
0.34688788652420044,
0.34245163202285767,
0.15511249005794525,
0.20157259702682495,
-0.6757112145423889,
0.12832465767860413,
-0.3071844279766083,
0.945094108581543,
0.4495174288749695,
0.4098530113697052,
-0.432090699672699,
0.3099968433380127,
-0.08012265712022781,
0.37606191635131836,
-0.7476211786270142,
-0.17540833353996277,
0.3304826021194458,
0.09359648078680038,
-0.08475594222545624,
0.2918877601623535,
-0.5335659980773926,
-0.251174658536911,
0.23108775913715363,
0.20865179598331451,
-0.19130827486515045,
-0.27443569898605347,
-0.35505563020706177,
-0.31234070658683777,
0.2857777774333954,
0.35328787565231323,
-0.42135483026504517,
-0.2188565731048584,
0.3077968657016754,
0.43239134550094604,
-0.02058161422610283,
-0.3190557062625885,
-0.32138317823410034,
0.25930655002593994,
-0.364084392786026,
1.2319220304489136,
-0.17145884037017822,
-0.4498753249645233,
-0.06130311265587807,
-0.1512862592935562,
0.1418989896774292,
-0.9699720144271851,
0.698671281337738,
-0.4120669662952423,
0.44571518898010254,
-0.7637055516242981,
-0.518090546131134,
-0.10164599120616913,
0.5197527408599854,
-0.4190242290496826,
1.0886547565460205,
0.012049035169184208,
-0.6336395740509033,
0.7734299898147583,
-0.2508724629878998,
0.05430630221962929,
0.40465047955513,
-0.2483891397714615,
-0.4938039183616638,
0.024815820157527924,
0.15982414782047272,
0.2896910607814789,
-0.8337754011154175,
0.16676677763462067,
-0.25129595398902893,
-0.21061819791793823,
0.4159085750579834,
-0.11270596832036972,
0.42211106419563293,
0.2645086646080017,
-0.037935130298137665,
-0.20549094676971436,
-0.7589896321296692,
0.6570885181427002,
0.06696697324514389,
-0.19924677908420563,
-0.3215789794921875,
0.0906728059053421,
-0.4034605026245117,
0.3068092167377472,
0.1062345877289772,
-0.6305621862411499,
-0.2887449264526367,
0.19612061977386475,
0.14352500438690186,
0.19860059022903442,
0.3266700506210327,
0.0005862846155650914,
-0.6768823862075806,
0.4091598391532898,
0.22702187299728394,
-0.12428406625986099,
0.13312585651874542,
-0.5762509703636169,
-0.6974013447761536,
0.20765182375907898,
0.24111886322498322,
0.4788976311683655,
-0.7095485329627991,
0.2402544468641281,
-0.0978323295712471,
-0.9951164722442627,
-0.6715850234031677,
0.2804756462574005,
0.5042965412139893,
0.7613791823387146,
0.5311486721038818,
-0.16344040632247925,
-0.29262974858283997,
-0.988332211971283,
-0.12837162613868713,
-0.8378234505653381,
-0.12393155694007874,
0.4979771077632904,
0.2752041220664978,
0.4012176990509033,
1.0627188682556152,
-0.6272607445716858,
0.20805439352989197,
0.03701198473572731,
0.45754146575927734,
-0.01151464693248272,
0.49629849195480347,
0.6674333214759827,
-0.746442973613739,
-0.3131920397281647,
-0.4442446231842041,
-0.8220570087432861,
-0.43563568592071533,
-0.13050326704978943,
-0.32693058252334595,
-0.2639800012111664,
0.4638358950614929,
-0.5195815563201904,
-0.00825183279812336,
0.16833524405956268,
-0.2968560755252838,
0.8285408020019531,
-0.09871121495962143,
0.35733237862586975,
-1.0334314107894897,
0.27712172269821167,
0.12535735964775085,
-0.03482261300086975,
-0.4582493305206299,
0.3226490318775177,
0.32130441069602966,
-0.006133677437901497,
-0.39668792486190796,
0.6527349352836609,
-0.16053317487239838,
0.3253273665904999,
-0.1240227073431015,
0.47436079382896423,
0.2714676558971405,
0.30992621183395386,
-0.17197224497795105,
0.7681021094322205,
-0.1451907902956009,
-0.6420953869819641,
0.4533308744430542,
0.5671992897987366,
-0.23882372677326202,
0.9606795907020569,
-0.9089804887771606,
0.5579330921173096,
-0.3367340862751007,
0.19740138947963715,
-1.219117283821106,
0.007216504774987698,
0.09070795774459839,
-0.732193112373352,
-0.3562057614326477,
-0.10265962779521942,
-0.6203579306602478,
-0.5095537304878235,
-0.09561920166015625,
0.5996955633163452,
0.5098087787628174,
-0.34370070695877075,
-0.3397972881793976,
-0.03295772895216942,
-0.09321499615907669,
-0.4590739905834198,
-0.5499441623687744,
-0.3663020730018616,
-0.10608185827732086,
-0.48054373264312744,
0.023901714012026787,
-0.48976075649261475,
-0.19975490868091583,
0.0037794511299580336,
-0.052470605820417404,
-0.481609046459198,
-0.08594212681055069,
0.22262603044509888,
0.2595265209674835,
-0.4186438024044037,
0.33932849764823914,
-0.29565632343292236,
0.15980744361877441,
0.2299850434064865,
0.11683535575866699,
0.06377959996461868,
0.10624050348997116,
-0.3245014548301697,
-0.0831315740942955,
0.3839546740055084,
0.8275847434997559,
-0.454936146736145,
0.37135833501815796,
0.5345067977905273,
-0.14830927550792694,
-0.12618838250637054,
-0.9217319488525391,
-0.02654053270816803,
-0.4074726402759552,
0.24832366406917572,
-0.16846515238285065,
-0.6352823376655579,
0.5544745326042175,
0.08983547985553741,
0.2938840687274933,
0.4196622371673584,
0.46599167585372925,
-0.2814899682998657,
0.8738623261451721,
-0.13231615722179413,
0.22777752578258514,
0.1808713674545288,
-0.0031096721068024635,
-0.14334388077259064,
-0.8065420389175415,
-0.16594187915325165,
-0.9296532273292542,
-0.35345885157585144,
-0.5274717807769775,
-0.42501646280288696,
0.48416927456855774,
0.4034614861011505,
-0.39328664541244507,
0.2520526051521301,
-0.4349208474159241,
0.38555410504341125,
0.6247621178627014,
-0.04305456578731537,
0.20496900379657745,
-0.2789676785469055,
-0.24011249840259552,
-0.07702556997537613,
-0.7154488563537598,
-0.5251902937889099,
1.0602703094482422,
0.016740132123231888,
0.3494824469089508,
0.04547172784805298,
0.6513254642486572,
0.0002924242289736867,
0.47599950432777405,
-0.4510215222835541,
0.6374942064285278,
0.18643710017204285,
-1.2261757850646973,
-0.34831538796424866,
-0.7252722978591919,
-0.7891491651535034,
0.4951871633529663,
-0.3659847676753998,
-0.39972054958343506,
0.2079026997089386,
0.19088301062583923,
-0.6346902847290039,
0.2744239866733551,
-0.8009949922561646,
0.5723873972892761,
-0.1052192971110344,
-0.6433984041213989,
0.03539641946554184,
-0.2599849998950958,
0.3721475601196289,
-0.10138679295778275,
0.05802128463983536,
-0.473861962556839,
0.28771519660949707,
0.7600358724594116,
-0.42330870032310486,
0.3736273944377899,
-0.26281315088272095,
0.07480130344629288,
0.8860621452331543,
0.008120628073811531,
0.07906713336706161,
0.30398890376091003,
-0.2198776751756668,
-0.04277390241622925,
0.306018590927124,
-0.6279264688491821,
-0.752691924571991,
0.42833268642425537,
-0.7221498489379883,
-0.6433050036430359,
-0.28953784704208374,
-0.6393662095069885,
-0.5570056438446045,
0.07502051442861557,
0.292984277009964,
0.216398224234581,
-0.3410404324531555,
0.13158786296844482,
0.18927797675132751,
-0.13314226269721985,
0.16581138968467712,
0.7032696604728699,
0.14334821701049805,
-0.5726941823959351,
0.5739030241966248,
0.07677194476127625,
0.35893505811691284,
0.020072396844625473,
0.17640900611877441,
-0.30008161067962646,
-0.38424837589263916,
-0.7373752593994141,
0.42280879616737366,
-0.3221762776374817,
-0.40487176179885864,
-0.11312954127788544,
-0.270470529794693,
-0.35200124979019165,
0.18169376254081726,
-0.2511274218559265,
-0.4878944456577301,
0.22740618884563446,
-0.04344946891069412,
0.12260325998067856,
0.4800776243209839,
0.030182577669620514,
0.011182410642504692,
-0.9832125902175903,
0.28905653953552246,
0.6534950137138367,
-0.0014551305212080479,
0.009204152040183544,
-0.2769384980201721,
-0.29922717809677124,
0.27625852823257446,
-0.6405249834060669,
-0.8326663970947266,
-0.21060937643051147,
0.04544759541749954,
0.4614419937133789,
0.36464136838912964,
0.2813572287559509,
0.6237214803695679,
-0.4605275094509125,
0.9644841551780701,
0.2196565568447113,
-0.5365946888923645,
0.5321370959281921,
-0.41050153970718384,
0.6033362150192261,
0.8610852956771851,
0.2829589247703552,
-0.5025566220283508,
-0.743405818939209,
-0.7076827883720398,
-0.5313540697097778,
0.29882609844207764,
0.29354536533355713,
-0.015154777094721794,
-0.2966318130493164,
0.7911928296089172,
0.09011603146791458,
0.29516690969467163,
-0.3522396385669708,
-0.2512125074863434,
-0.1693667769432068,
0.16069094836711884,
-0.0018205243395641446,
-0.15092650055885315,
-0.0649004727602005,
-0.2759917676448822,
0.38123443722724915,
-0.12115011364221573,
0.1662474274635315,
0.462741494178772,
0.15017089247703552,
-0.4610636234283447,
0.4537566304206848,
0.5261027812957764,
0.7574693560600281,
-0.4539543688297272,
0.021428313106298447,
0.26016682386398315,
-0.3989979028701782,
0.39998528361320496,
-0.12201715260744095,
-0.5831676721572876,
0.17570990324020386,
0.23635245859622955,
0.32007765769958496,
-0.11371151357889175,
-0.40944212675094604,
0.11677968502044678,
0.08377756178379059,
-0.5937056541442871,
-0.3018331229686737,
0.23621432483196259,
-0.03629125654697418,
0.02662699669599533,
0.4153405427932739,
-0.2033519297838211,
-0.3592689037322998,
-0.48918861150741577,
0.30519866943359375,
0.4871358275413513,
-0.5768430829048157,
-0.3792269825935364,
0.865728497505188,
0.2882879674434662,
-0.17853659391403198,
0.622434675693512,
-0.35042718052864075,
-0.28593170642852783,
0.6902139782905579,
0.3412576913833618,
0.7455891370773315,
-0.1486843377351761,
0.5815175771713257,
0.7840932011604309,
0.2440728098154068,
0.09179557114839554,
0.418521910905838,
-0.010859382338821888,
-1.1518266201019287,
-0.0461244210600853,
-0.2952367663383484,
-0.6764792799949646,
0.3124328553676605,
-0.7995895147323608,
-0.14317096769809723,
-0.6423406004905701,
-0.4039269685745239,
0.189025416970253,
0.17446887493133545,
-0.8095669746398926,
0.5448378324508667,
-0.14693152904510498,
0.6861308813095093,
-0.5815945863723755,
0.5390009880065918,
1.2125627994537354,
-0.8473034501075745,
-0.6900613307952881,
0.25076186656951904,
-0.16563104093074799,
-0.5940287709236145,
0.5848572850227356,
-0.21553988754749298,
0.025547487661242485,
-0.09949985146522522,
-0.5707086324691772,
-0.6602353453636169,
0.9726268649101257,
0.15446177124977112,
-0.02153679169714451,
-0.25349652767181396,
0.2885148525238037,
0.562923789024353,
0.02213357388973236,
0.41114118695259094,
0.42070022225379944,
0.4345584213733673,
0.30261367559432983,
-1.0004923343658447,
0.13741636276245117,
-0.35962629318237305,
-0.437569260597229,
0.37742647528648376,
-1.0929418802261353,
0.6356364488601685,
-0.37461957335472107,
-0.1726011037826538,
0.19854167103767395,
0.5630790591239929,
0.44481998682022095,
0.47266319394111633,
0.5453882217407227,
0.5036467909812927,
0.8019797801971436,
-0.18351241946220398,
0.6549920439720154,
-0.17212146520614624,
0.27866673469543457,
0.9588272571563721,
-0.4168459475040436,
0.8186773657798767,
0.4741678237915039,
-0.1993497908115387,
0.6159836053848267,
0.21561367809772491,
-0.2568073868751526,
0.3414463400840759,
0.3386928141117096,
-0.12555593252182007,
-0.4114615023136139,
-0.17352241277694702,
-0.40162238478660583,
0.4905503988265991,
0.08259853720664978,
-0.04097561910748482,
-0.4732460677623749,
-0.6067861318588257,
-0.05070047453045845,
0.28728383779525757,
0.025990398600697517,
0.7621000409126282,
-0.10334817320108414,
-1.0272711515426636,
0.8205876350402832,
-0.2301635891199112,
0.2231544554233551,
-0.607444703578949,
0.01841217651963234,
-0.5706647634506226,
0.14313526451587677,
-0.11434954404830933,
-0.5237717032432556,
0.10894820094108582,
0.2031497061252594,
-0.34163135290145874,
0.0488421730697155,
0.30366620421409607,
-0.3747314214706421,
-0.5362954139709473,
-0.2753766179084778,
1.2521764039993286,
0.26183679699897766,
0.01777939684689045,
-0.5428715944290161,
-0.8150387406349182,
-0.008228247053921223,
0.08258038014173508,
0.13269226253032684,
0.6231346130371094,
0.04178129881620407,
0.6350425481796265,
0.45180654525756836,
0.23611710965633392,
-0.08576276898384094,
-0.1501229852437973,
0.42988261580467224,
-0.7525317072868347,
-0.3364672362804413,
-0.42355701327323914,
0.4625011682510376,
-0.2075750231742859,
-0.7516454458236694,
0.7898866534233093,
0.5015490055084229,
0.8520733714103699,
0.23346713185310364,
0.9814286828041077,
0.07974272966384888,
0.8584908246994019,
-0.13830941915512085,
0.7504995465278625,
-0.5502496361732483,
-0.1099172830581665,
-0.5961521863937378,
-0.9887169003486633,
-0.04977847635746002,
0.3456052541732788,
-0.13041149079799652,
0.20531350374221802,
0.8782092332839966,
0.7421217560768127,
0.0633234903216362,
-0.033004436641931534,
0.3019166588783264,
-0.2624024450778961,
0.31533709168434143,
0.7065128684043884,
1.0743682384490967,
-0.546472430229187,
1.021857738494873,
-0.12270068377256393,
-0.025766538456082344,
0.0677938312292099,
-0.6182016134262085,
-0.9445736408233643,
-0.6218693256378174,
-0.5779098272323608,
-0.4205876588821411,
-0.09801743924617767,
0.634537935256958,
0.6068004369735718,
-0.9350968599319458,
-0.17137283086776733,
0.1492580622434616,
0.11459589004516602,
-0.21686005592346191,
-0.18714262545108795,
0.265931099653244,
-0.309421181678772,
-0.5981151461601257,
0.08975622802972794,
-0.2579537630081177,
0.10169225186109543,
-0.2827032208442688,
0.12633326649665833,
-0.18239134550094604,
0.2990628480911255,
0.24115930497646332,
0.47976425290107727,
-0.5816681385040283,
-0.8150469660758972,
0.19023750722408295,
-0.3496644198894501,
-0.03915823996067047,
0.8627848029136658,
-0.8337525725364685,
0.2539001703262329,
0.5284761190414429,
0.43840324878692627,
0.18917959928512573,
0.5703168511390686,
0.672603189945221,
-0.9508529305458069,
0.008240658789873123,
0.19806678593158722,
0.06589838862419128,
0.30412983894348145,
-0.0707731619477272,
0.5282545685768127,
0.4315999448299408,
-0.6667332649230957,
-0.6711471676826477,
0.38447463512420654,
-0.4876062572002411,
-0.04073917120695114,
1.0353597402572632,
-0.11272181570529938,
0.18790623545646667,
-0.011807470582425594,
-0.08201712369918823,
0.14530810713768005,
-0.23630395531654358,
1.078365445137024,
1.0238957405090332,
-0.3284435272216797,
0.022890545427799225,
-0.5045698881149292,
0.49446699023246765,
0.710973858833313,
-0.7907835245132446,
0.1092626303434372,
0.7454882264137268,
0.24291890859603882,
0.5775110721588135,
0.3975571393966675,
-0.14548440277576447,
0.6702736020088196,
0.0372282937169075,
0.0966378003358841,
-0.18683651089668274,
0.008124993182718754,
0.40393975377082825,
0.5828156471252441,
0.2790229320526123,
-0.36644071340560913
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15453v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15453v1
|
Span-Oriented Information Extraction -- A Unifying Perspective on Information Extraction
| 2024-03-18T20:10:44 | 2024-03-18T20:10:44 |
Yifan Ding, Michael Yankoski, Tim Weninger
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
Information Extraction refers to a collection of tasks within Natural
Language Processing (NLP) that identifies sub-sequences within text and their
labels. These tasks have been used for many years to link extract relevant
information and to link free text to structured data. However, the
heterogeneity among information extraction tasks impedes progress in this area.
We therefore offer a unifying perspective centered on what we define to be
spans in text. We then re-orient these seemingly incongruous tasks into this
unified perspective and then re-present the wide assortment of information
extraction tasks as variants of the same basic Span-Oriented Information
Extraction task.
|
[
-0.3674663305282593,
-0.8031458258628845,
0.06535843759775162,
0.678496778011322,
-0.2938384413719177,
0.21401184797286987,
0.020629223436117172,
-0.937603235244751,
0.45397499203681946,
0.5081166625022888,
-0.6469671726226807,
-0.15916074812412262,
-0.7010588049888611,
0.26021212339401245,
-0.6581713557243347,
1.4351617097854614,
0.02301626093685627,
-0.43613189458847046,
0.005057880189269781,
0.13815023005008698,
-0.5011717081069946,
-0.25309160351753235,
-0.45566532015800476,
-0.4133722186088562,
0.4472365379333496,
0.29760992527008057,
0.49552690982818604,
0.9552380442619324,
0.6098746657371521,
0.21416786313056946,
0.03539465740323067,
-0.040459804236888885,
-0.10074157267808914,
0.3244445323944092,
-0.37237459421157837,
-0.44099172949790955,
-0.10515599697828293,
0.2652856707572937,
0.8196765184402466,
1.0576109886169434,
0.12605959177017212,
0.28431105613708496,
0.17430488765239716,
1.0244890451431274,
-0.7123609185218811,
0.10556713491678238,
-0.5874993205070496,
0.3868483304977417,
-0.4276393949985504,
-0.4388843774795532,
-0.3245970606803894,
-0.3974006772041321,
0.5247431993484497,
-0.6549916863441467,
0.2387610822916031,
-0.08744439482688904,
0.9372237324714661,
0.2002786248922348,
-0.27691933512687683,
-0.2553671598434448,
-0.8766923546791077,
0.8216307759284973,
-0.421265572309494,
0.15602581202983856,
0.15686383843421936,
0.059174153953790665,
0.05909323692321777,
-0.7511597871780396,
-0.21291612088680267,
0.5182890295982361,
-0.1336764544248581,
0.20742230117321014,
-0.4970201253890991,
-0.05038122832775116,
0.1815222054719925,
0.5309064388275146,
-0.21333742141723633,
0.17732535302639008,
-0.5249298214912415,
0.03900270164012909,
0.7122650146484375,
-0.11195029318332672,
0.5661529302597046,
-0.38535746932029724,
-0.6821863651275635,
0.30682677030563354,
-0.6690973043441772,
0.21720346808433533,
0.29270702600479126,
0.5311972498893738,
0.07328290492296219,
0.862105131149292,
-0.21731990575790405,
0.7991319298744202,
0.2897070348262787,
-0.0388205386698246,
0.1298796683549881,
-0.21121197938919067,
-0.4896116852760315,
0.171486034989357,
0.5711745619773865,
0.13845404982566833,
0.3271293342113495,
-0.547982931137085,
-0.001634883345104754,
-0.15805011987686157,
0.471057265996933,
-0.28719449043273926,
-0.1096915528178215,
0.14966803789138794,
-0.685563862323761,
-0.28969037532806396,
0.6857093572616577,
-1.1113057136535645,
-0.20863504707813263,
-0.42474010586738586,
0.1263166069984436,
-0.40956437587738037,
-0.2979086637496948,
-0.11890774220228195,
-0.5138881206512451,
0.3041682243347168,
0.14237265288829803,
-0.9718821048736572,
0.2836766839027405,
0.6568282842636108,
0.719726026058197,
-0.8002462387084961,
-0.31999000906944275,
-0.4707081615924835,
0.25637635588645935,
0.0879596620798111,
0.8573635220527649,
-0.7394658327102661,
-0.20811495184898376,
-0.05660960450768471,
0.13883988559246063,
-0.4188126027584076,
-0.5876102447509766,
0.42886367440223694,
-0.5688908696174622,
0.4321443736553192,
-0.11591264605522156,
-0.8044383525848389,
-0.24426484107971191,
0.13739094138145447,
-1.0721853971481323,
1.4151606559753418,
0.15759924054145813,
-1.1027872562408447,
0.40838101506233215,
-0.8509666919708252,
-0.44966092705726624,
0.12888510525226593,
-0.16785863041877747,
0.04359978064894676,
0.2751913368701935,
0.03940427303314209,
0.3153199553489685,
-0.22316214442253113,
0.13264617323875427,
0.2548710107803345,
-0.062199003994464874,
0.010350169613957405,
-0.1722596138715744,
0.9105362296104431,
0.11649734526872635,
-0.26187679171562195,
0.05110577121376991,
-0.8130402565002441,
0.1286839097738266,
0.001257949392311275,
-0.8580225110054016,
-0.7829087376594543,
0.14490686357021332,
0.09967824071645737,
0.3017256557941437,
0.4106045961380005,
-0.5729721188545227,
0.5555866956710815,
-0.5879371166229248,
-0.08485923707485199,
0.5284357666969299,
0.13748091459274292,
0.6223082542419434,
-0.15083418786525726,
0.5520958304405212,
-0.13108602166175842,
-0.07777638733386993,
-0.0513203889131546,
-0.5264588594436646,
-0.4693506062030792,
-0.4642365276813507,
0.25324633717536926,
0.829763650894165,
-0.5439894199371338,
0.5403916239738464,
-0.10462542623281479,
-0.24085503816604614,
-0.4617024064064026,
0.11539329588413239,
0.3046874403953552,
0.5840159058570862,
0.4861781895160675,
-0.5228153467178345,
-1.0291720628738403,
-0.7715762257575989,
-0.7236011028289795,
0.11669814586639404,
0.04665873572230339,
-0.5091555714607239,
0.2866721749305725,
-0.06873761862516403,
1.3568116426467896,
-0.3332269489765167,
-0.1609615683555603,
-0.5775198340415955,
0.7045609354972839,
0.37201058864593506,
0.381032794713974,
0.23821020126342773,
-1.2609792947769165,
-0.49425533413887024,
0.048797301948070526,
-0.9137085676193237,
-0.3854929208755493,
-0.08136391639709473,
0.08327624201774597,
-0.034055195748806,
0.6184124946594238,
-0.3247426152229309,
0.6095137000083923,
0.16894911229610443,
-0.29450148344039917,
0.5524414777755737,
0.051096536219120026,
-0.17730757594108582,
-0.9646046757698059,
0.11971022188663483,
0.1972016543149948,
0.08860966563224792,
-0.8135129809379578,
-0.015745989978313446,
-0.16908137500286102,
0.4660910367965698,
-0.10161375999450684,
0.2601209282875061,
-0.6642869114875793,
-0.43333789706230164,
-0.3706448972225189,
0.0920894667506218,
0.19669753313064575,
0.2584713101387024,
0.14351077377796173,
0.28652265667915344,
0.24802428483963013,
-0.5548970103263855,
0.38255026936531067,
0.08063050359487534,
-0.17763751745224,
0.6235866546630859,
-0.3317340314388275,
-0.1039065420627594,
-0.4729110300540924,
-0.121644988656044,
-0.8131565451622009,
-0.24581500887870789,
0.017764417454600334,
-0.1485850065946579,
0.2931011915206909,
0.18135878443717957,
-0.3461899757385254,
-0.16883474588394165,
-0.44102826714515686,
0.2993094027042389,
-0.04920528829097748,
-0.4602043330669403,
0.34213489294052124,
0.6797195076942444,
-0.4442140758037567,
-0.8920364379882812,
-0.5824094414710999,
-0.18433795869350433,
-0.44382578134536743,
-0.26388269662857056,
0.5180675983428955,
0.4620218276977539,
-0.6289581656455994,
0.26673218607902527,
-0.5720791220664978,
-0.46763044595718384,
0.23645538091659546,
0.33529746532440186,
0.4549623131752014,
-0.2351791262626648,
0.3433547019958496,
0.09670330584049225,
-0.09096623957157135,
-0.047385938465595245,
-0.3023131191730499,
0.485265851020813,
0.08978483080863953,
-0.2284882813692093,
-0.4617795944213867,
1.1007320880889893,
0.09747021645307541,
-0.24881471693515778,
0.4343576729297638,
0.3854414224624634,
-0.6270844340324402,
0.05216454714536667,
-0.33020031452178955,
0.22068563103675842,
-0.3341276943683624,
0.46032920479774475,
-0.2700658142566681,
-0.839597225189209,
0.2337607592344284,
-0.24421736598014832,
0.3832998275756836,
1.060555100440979,
0.1416729837656021,
-0.40358683466911316,
0.60404372215271,
1.3268650770187378,
-0.494594931602478,
0.5955372452735901,
0.1602625995874405,
0.06800446659326553,
-0.7781021595001221,
-0.5335173010826111,
-0.7891664505004883,
-0.39059463143348694,
-0.24046339094638824,
0.09467791020870209,
0.03239653259515762,
0.5830928087234497,
-0.01626347191631794,
0.5863977670669556,
-0.614108145236969,
0.4948948621749878,
0.5667480826377869,
-0.27112749218940735,
0.6256977915763855,
0.09462185949087143,
0.2426423281431198,
-0.20768338441848755,
-0.3298269510269165,
-0.5384191274642944,
1.0225492715835571,
0.09311752021312714,
0.6739888191223145,
0.018585797399282455,
0.7618800401687622,
0.4908892810344696,
0.3266613781452179,
-0.7815520167350769,
0.2217307686805725,
-0.1643553078174591,
-0.5034663677215576,
-0.37209710478782654,
-0.1628432422876358,
-1.2785241603851318,
0.2405586540699005,
-0.3537830412387848,
-1.440881609916687,
0.16801011562347412,
-0.26483556628227234,
-0.050135985016822815,
0.34203147888183594,
-0.6364849209785461,
0.7756965160369873,
-0.02977912873029709,
0.22454367578029633,
0.18933075666427612,
-1.0966171026229858,
0.2438332736492157,
-0.2033427655696869,
0.28268373012542725,
-0.03931344300508499,
0.1173875629901886,
0.9655570983886719,
-0.026169799268245697,
0.7804361581802368,
0.01122117880731821,
-0.052110400050878525,
0.22486424446105957,
-0.18612144887447357,
0.2977573573589325,
-0.506320595741272,
-0.0025673401542007923,
-0.1614893078804016,
0.19440412521362305,
-0.18349908292293549,
-0.36841046810150146,
0.025763338431715965,
-0.479672908782959,
-0.21235254406929016,
-0.4086591601371765,
-0.8127672672271729,
-0.25504910945892334,
0.3513106107711792,
0.4536731541156769,
0.0353025458753109,
-0.3982023000717163,
-0.011769505217671394,
0.548923134803772,
0.02364567667245865,
0.7795117497444153,
-0.04611101746559143,
-0.2571859657764435,
0.16367152333259583,
0.5309208631515503,
-0.030666589736938477,
0.2738224267959595,
1.0321768522262573,
-0.026157451793551445,
-0.36585208773612976,
-0.22294528782367706,
-0.04392845556139946,
-0.10026497393846512,
-0.7415525913238525,
-0.05778367072343826,
-0.5914334058761597,
-0.42162349820137024,
-0.1849682778120041,
0.030121445655822754,
-0.27239224314689636,
-0.7048273682594299,
-0.24108467996120453,
-0.1612320989370346,
0.07942603528499603,
0.9072069525718689,
-0.1460803896188736,
0.46491923928260803,
-0.8381139636039734,
0.47434765100479126,
0.37846076488494873,
-0.1275688260793686,
-0.41444340348243713,
-0.050732482224702835,
-0.2759194076061249,
-0.3154066205024719,
-0.2695236802101135,
-1.2754154205322266,
0.4085734188556671,
0.1671018749475479,
0.7290455102920532,
0.43506374955177307,
-0.24699871242046356,
0.594502329826355,
-0.22830449044704437,
0.6200295686721802,
0.4011034667491913,
-0.8870459198951721,
0.6254199743270874,
-0.1030752956867218,
0.08729731291532516,
0.6669629812240601,
0.5258685350418091,
-0.6003801226615906,
-0.2668927013874054,
-0.73354172706604,
-1.1416666507720947,
0.6598883867263794,
-0.10767044126987457,
-0.34302276372909546,
0.07297442108392715,
0.25370949506759644,
0.374688982963562,
0.4195851683616638,
-0.8764592409133911,
-0.23929479718208313,
-0.17806902527809143,
-0.2240801602602005,
0.30039867758750916,
-0.24588070809841156,
-0.16957491636276245,
-0.13387973606586456,
0.3387185335159302,
0.01626310497522354,
0.3043719530105591,
0.3629330098628998,
-0.33333295583724976,
-0.08732612431049347,
0.6161497831344604,
0.000746116042137146,
0.5994225740432739,
-0.14092300832271576,
0.4159582555294037,
-0.2767012417316437,
-0.674541175365448,
-0.17178918421268463,
0.40920111536979675,
-0.10490214824676514,
0.1756390929222107,
0.59303879737854,
0.4645681381225586,
0.0039148349314928055,
-0.47104018926620483,
0.4813976287841797,
0.3945311903953552,
0.1713462769985199,
-0.058257102966308594,
-0.1853899508714676,
-0.27027350664138794,
0.37311455607414246,
0.8606064915657043,
-0.038983121514320374,
0.37420418858528137,
-0.7103237509727478,
0.448727548122406,
0.41604354977607727,
-0.5091174244880676,
-0.38019290566444397,
0.3654046952724457,
-0.12772226333618164,
-0.18214963376522064,
0.5300952792167664,
0.21440750360488892,
-0.21503125131130219,
0.6820667386054993,
0.7170025706291199,
0.970470130443573,
-0.24333561956882477,
0.33377406001091003,
0.11682362109422684,
0.3476375639438629,
-0.1943221390247345,
0.1411280632019043,
-0.1332532912492752,
-0.7542182207107544,
-0.6270284652709961,
-0.5434749722480774,
-0.1880776733160019,
-0.015074465423822403,
-1.086984634399414,
-0.1273462474346161,
-0.14613178372383118,
0.22803717851638794,
0.47655975818634033,
-0.07718965411186218,
-0.3664805591106415,
0.41050708293914795,
-0.0161795224994421,
0.930976152420044,
-0.9732238054275513,
0.8175427913665771,
0.6846964955329895,
-0.4015082120895386,
-0.8474202752113342,
0.11097243428230286,
0.19128698110580444,
-0.5797127485275269,
0.8154647946357727,
0.30563539266586304,
0.00864778645336628,
-0.2587902843952179,
-0.6393563747406006,
-0.7411326169967651,
0.946618378162384,
0.06706266105175018,
-0.10004939138889313,
-0.6018959283828735,
0.18289609253406525,
0.3560539782047272,
-0.541750431060791,
-0.2131560742855072,
0.7163774371147156,
0.6012488007545471,
-0.2283008098602295,
-0.909485936164856,
0.02942502126097679,
-0.5289803147315979,
-0.19964782893657684,
0.45107126235961914,
0.07813246548175812,
1.1070783138275146,
0.15873001515865326,
-0.4268075227737427,
-0.09634443372488022,
0.5458532571792603,
-0.16854166984558105,
0.15003782510757446,
0.5309109687805176,
0.39220497012138367,
0.9035800099372864,
-0.24776498973369598,
0.9395880103111267,
0.3253282904624939,
0.3566455841064453,
1.2484211921691895,
0.013150293380022049,
0.5480600595474243,
1.0433977842330933,
-0.13544532656669617,
0.6246864795684814,
0.49070093035697937,
0.030275749042630196,
0.6258864402770996,
-0.004960251972079277,
-0.253397673368454,
0.11149495095014572,
-0.1301543116569519,
-0.30672138929367065,
0.5875986218452454,
0.34821638464927673,
-0.48954465985298157,
-0.6649260520935059,
-0.3135117292404175,
-0.014196351170539856,
-0.007239659782499075,
-0.45531517267227173,
0.9126134514808655,
-0.12598110735416412,
-0.7692219614982605,
-0.10687122493982315,
0.09035419672727585,
0.5693385601043701,
-0.5867055058479309,
-0.21476483345031738,
0.15209536254405975,
-0.22369170188903809,
-0.6643676161766052,
-0.831517219543457,
0.9108626246452332,
0.11437531560659409,
-0.563630223274231,
-0.339546799659729,
1.0124940872192383,
-0.2798415422439575,
0.03323974087834358,
0.23329083621501923,
0.8629123568534851,
0.26280996203422546,
-0.3953796625137329,
-0.48226988315582275,
-0.29892393946647644,
0.24757766723632812,
-0.3901529312133789,
0.2513934373855591,
0.6641438603401184,
-0.230573832988739,
0.16894301772117615,
0.4314182698726654,
0.1376846432685852,
0.5113531947135925,
-0.24160821735858917,
0.7179023027420044,
-1.0606615543365479,
-0.32088783383369446,
-0.982122540473938,
0.6328550577163696,
-0.4439227879047394,
-0.4323166310787201,
0.7698042988777161,
0.7077279686927795,
0.5722759962081909,
-0.013477299362421036,
1.105867862701416,
-0.5588114261627197,
0.5620701313018799,
-0.3555096387863159,
0.12482278794050217,
-0.3583526015281677,
0.10690422356128693,
-0.7704164981842041,
-0.9018692374229431,
-0.432419091463089,
0.5375677347183228,
-0.176058828830719,
-0.5560605525970459,
0.7548170685768127,
-0.04438379034399986,
-0.08823775500059128,
0.4612622857093811,
-0.27413809299468994,
-0.22238677740097046,
-0.12315383553504944,
0.5176699161529541,
0.8772009611129761,
-0.09605702757835388,
0.4011469781398773,
-0.07404739409685135,
-0.372569739818573,
0.02095828764140606,
-0.8053090572357178,
-0.4330640435218811,
-0.7163485288619995,
-0.20985470712184906,
-0.10430208593606949,
-0.307259202003479,
0.7707027792930603,
0.46845197677612305,
-0.587091863155365,
-0.16850773990154266,
-0.4307328164577484,
0.40632832050323486,
-0.5910493731498718,
-0.41180288791656494,
0.41629883646965027,
-0.4322889447212219,
-0.8048508167266846,
0.4448237419128418,
0.7273493409156799,
-0.11952818930149078,
0.04947829619050026,
0.564581036567688,
-0.7267853617668152,
-0.16935692727565765,
0.46397337317466736,
0.9075307846069336,
-0.34036222100257874,
-0.43265393376350403,
-0.08713611960411072,
-0.1487864851951599,
0.5175259709358215,
0.7729570865631104,
-0.475314199924469,
0.3963077962398529,
0.4586750566959381,
0.9479097723960876,
0.5626266598701477,
0.25256192684173584,
0.4707592725753784,
-1.227997064590454,
0.22124043107032776,
0.16975468397140503,
0.1969720423221588,
0.144697904586792,
-0.1979905217885971,
0.761408269405365,
0.3197888135910034,
-0.16609367728233337,
-0.5387098789215088,
0.6467865705490112,
-1.3752374649047852,
-0.25364378094673157,
0.9576314091682434,
-0.23564547300338745,
-0.06618156284093857,
-0.46945810317993164,
-0.20193512737751007,
0.5314514636993408,
-0.01111648604273796,
0.6698895692825317,
0.7321589589118958,
-0.5121604204177856,
-0.01757844351232052,
-0.3993957042694092,
0.3647497892379761,
0.120859794318676,
-1.3588652610778809,
-0.34893113374710083,
0.3264290690422058,
0.2609905004501343,
0.6296587586402893,
0.7737581133842468,
-0.48769277334213257,
-0.17814531922340393,
-0.28466692566871643,
0.3018859028816223,
0.5877342820167542,
-0.4469909071922302,
-0.1503717601299286,
0.7529816031455994,
-0.4083784222602844,
-0.4266059398651123
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.12212v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.12212v1
|
Evaluating Named Entity Recognition: Comparative Analysis of Mono- and Multilingual Transformer Models on Brazilian Corporate Earnings Call Transcriptions
| 2024-03-18T19:53:56 | 2024-03-18T19:53:56 |
Ramon Abilio, Guilherme Palermo Coelho, Ana Estela Antunes da Silva
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, 68T50
|
Named Entity Recognition (NER) is a Natural Language Processing technique for
extracting information from textual documents. However, much of the existing
research on NER has been centered around English-language documents, leaving a
gap in the availability of datasets tailored to the financial domain in
Portuguese. This study addresses the need for NER within the financial domain,
focusing on Portuguese-language texts extracted from earnings call
transcriptions of Brazilian banks. By curating a comprehensive dataset
comprising 384 transcriptions and leveraging weak supervision techniques for
annotation, we evaluate the performance of monolingual models trained on
Portuguese (BERTimbau and PTT5) and multilingual models (mBERT and mT5).
Notably, we introduce a novel approach that reframes the token classification
task as a text generation problem, enabling fine-tuning and evaluation of T5
models. Following the fine-tuning of the models, we conduct an evaluation on
the test dataset, employing performance and error metrics. Our findings reveal
that BERT-based models consistently outperform T5-based models. Furthermore,
while the multilingual models exhibit comparable macro F1-scores, BERTimbau
demonstrates superior performance over PTT5. A manual analysis of sentences
generated by PTT5 and mT5 unveils a degree of similarity ranging from 0.89 to
1.0, between the original and generated sentences. However, critical errors
emerge as both models exhibit discrepancies, such as alterations to monetary
and percentage values, underscoring the importance of accuracy and consistency
in the financial domain. Despite these challenges, PTT5 and mT5 achieve
impressive macro F1-scores of 98.52% and 98.85%, respectively, with our
proposed approach. Furthermore, our study sheds light on notable disparities in
memory and time consumption for inference across the models.
|
[
-0.13785621523857117,
-0.6130592226982117,
0.0696597546339035,
0.4414137899875641,
-0.25399014353752136,
0.37883567810058594,
-0.29787546396255493,
-1.0252368450164795,
0.22587363421916962,
0.4581826627254486,
-0.12491949647665024,
-0.40953096747398376,
-0.7849553227424622,
0.518053412437439,
-0.532953143119812,
1.332782506942749,
0.11277954280376434,
0.2504143714904785,
0.0856252983212471,
-0.20543234050273895,
-0.2851017415523529,
-0.5577048063278198,
-1.12835693359375,
-0.15799973905086517,
0.4511699080467224,
-0.11543883383274078,
0.4362521767616272,
0.35283195972442627,
0.7200126647949219,
0.33755525946617126,
-0.3058626055717468,
0.05382499843835831,
-0.28869983553886414,
-0.25793036818504333,
0.014626017771661282,
-0.31835463643074036,
-0.675308883190155,
-0.24101640284061432,
0.6655727624893188,
0.6450636982917786,
-0.03156239166855812,
0.319265216588974,
0.13304868340492249,
0.3905624449253082,
-0.26485493779182434,
0.7095003724098206,
-0.5768197774887085,
-0.02603074721992016,
-0.18004775047302246,
-0.07947973906993866,
-0.6179344058036804,
-0.5339128375053406,
0.6048742532730103,
-0.41690313816070557,
0.3410775661468506,
0.10588044673204422,
1.2203923463821411,
0.05891459807753563,
-0.5514132380485535,
-0.48733147978782654,
-0.7834621667861938,
0.7594923377037048,
-0.5522001385688782,
0.670889675617218,
0.05872097983956337,
0.19596897065639496,
0.150002583861351,
-0.6159597039222717,
-0.2240018993616104,
-0.1913144886493683,
-0.1578935980796814,
0.02056092396378517,
-0.6372172832489014,
-0.020556729286909103,
0.23083704710006714,
0.17629565298557281,
-0.09580675512552261,
0.1432245373725891,
-0.7992192506790161,
-0.331508994102478,
0.4682418406009674,
-0.22624047100543976,
-0.08793888241052628,
-0.2825545370578766,
-0.60120689868927,
-0.24900704622268677,
-0.7383260726928711,
0.10389463603496552,
0.7125239372253418,
0.6674935817718506,
0.12324262410402298,
0.33781909942626953,
0.29023176431655884,
0.5908521413803101,
0.06452256441116333,
-0.4452264606952667,
0.28118523955345154,
-0.2105402946472168,
-0.4129861295223236,
0.5076774954795837,
0.5528273582458496,
0.06969919800758362,
0.34945499897003174,
-0.4271228015422821,
-0.4831930994987488,
-0.17704470455646515,
0.3112911581993103,
-0.7285218238830566,
-0.05485635623335838,
0.03273501619696617,
-0.4603102505207062,
-0.20761431753635406,
0.2840478718280792,
-0.6503047347068787,
-0.10196452587842941,
-0.40736058354377747,
0.4906441271305084,
-0.6316155791282654,
-0.08302603662014008,
-0.16528110206127167,
-0.4488338232040405,
0.4327400028705597,
0.24373093247413635,
-0.7183248996734619,
0.3385683596134186,
0.7601975798606873,
0.43253418803215027,
0.002491792431101203,
-0.1618359237909317,
-0.43657228350639343,
0.19089674949645996,
-0.23573744297027588,
0.8844916224479675,
-0.3694205582141876,
-0.41805559396743774,
-0.12662269175052643,
-0.10057029873132706,
-0.3009355366230011,
-0.6539897322654724,
0.6662163138389587,
-0.5062125325202942,
0.2810696065425873,
-0.10780846327543259,
-0.5853961110115051,
-0.38157230615615845,
0.24931186437606812,
-0.8656610250473022,
1.0173289775848389,
0.06108405813574791,
-0.8305292725563049,
0.920371413230896,
-0.879736065864563,
-0.43522071838378906,
0.04513108730316162,
-0.09984108060598373,
-0.5290835499763489,
-0.014881826005876064,
0.22709201276302338,
0.3689883351325989,
-0.4361996650695801,
0.3239140808582306,
-0.14007362723350525,
-0.1715160459280014,
0.49566492438316345,
-0.5935842394828796,
0.43345528841018677,
-0.18674610555171967,
-0.41059958934783936,
-0.00016875125584192574,
-0.9665014147758484,
-0.09792579710483551,
0.09953653812408447,
-0.2767276465892792,
-0.5828040838241577,
0.10504469275474548,
0.3381168246269226,
-0.035978592932224274,
0.29351314902305603,
-0.4355301260948181,
0.01065423060208559,
-0.4203954041004181,
0.5621212124824524,
0.7243272066116333,
-0.10682384669780731,
0.09414207190275192,
-0.09549381583929062,
0.3892068862915039,
0.1958611011505127,
0.07101896405220032,
-0.10334581881761551,
-0.24263609945774078,
-0.777897834777832,
-0.37975791096687317,
1.0165764093399048,
0.5597010254859924,
-0.4407844543457031,
0.0016036874148994684,
-0.6096155643463135,
-0.494619220495224,
-0.6978644132614136,
-0.13628961145877838,
0.4737878143787384,
0.46417099237442017,
0.5176354050636292,
-0.26958167552948,
-0.6464330554008484,
-1.2788652181625366,
-0.28420016169548035,
-0.10809777677059174,
0.07832498103380203,
0.3064699172973633,
0.48979583382606506,
-0.1549501121044159,
0.7618421912193298,
-0.16137197613716125,
-0.20495359599590302,
-0.4197785258293152,
0.4967595338821411,
0.3456852436065674,
0.2944127917289734,
0.7788234353065491,
-0.9214683771133423,
-0.18282119929790497,
0.04123617708683014,
-0.4562417268753052,
0.1676238775253296,
-0.1408260017633438,
0.25380444526672363,
0.4449247717857361,
0.26652881503105164,
-0.06796523928642273,
0.4526917040348053,
0.35820525884628296,
-0.2778969705104828,
0.36696216464042664,
-0.2668479084968567,
0.07981286942958832,
-0.967906653881073,
0.20995301008224487,
0.13606488704681396,
-0.3404778838157654,
-0.46167442202568054,
-0.3905413746833801,
0.0979333221912384,
0.09663762152194977,
-0.3554065525531769,
0.5721611976623535,
-0.7188367247581482,
-0.20612609386444092,
-0.04916711151599884,
-0.023047246038913727,
-0.14271889626979828,
0.4074306786060333,
0.07344149053096771,
0.7004735469818115,
0.4141831398010254,
-0.644133448600769,
0.04069174453616142,
0.19027763605117798,
-0.4237699806690216,
0.6234539747238159,
-0.8075867295265198,
0.06809615343809128,
-0.13233019411563873,
-0.02988111600279808,
-0.9021852016448975,
0.12138237804174423,
0.045700427144765854,
-0.2881554663181305,
0.5033013224601746,
-0.29559195041656494,
-0.5591619610786438,
-0.24423789978027344,
0.010450360365211964,
0.1382623314857483,
0.17765289545059204,
-0.4475308954715729,
0.8034212589263916,
0.45974549651145935,
-0.4247312843799591,
-0.7252362370491028,
-0.7240525484085083,
0.23523804545402527,
-0.4716586470603943,
-0.37121474742889404,
0.5752484202384949,
0.3817666471004486,
-0.17856614291667938,
-0.014733764342963696,
-0.23815202713012695,
-0.17642125487327576,
0.09050613641738892,
0.1226922869682312,
0.6498626470565796,
-0.27102506160736084,
0.09507988393306732,
0.13144926726818085,
-0.25292855501174927,
-0.02373667061328888,
-0.2521035373210907,
0.2714824378490448,
-0.1844870150089264,
0.0580793097615242,
-0.11967971175909042,
0.10037584602832794,
0.44329413771629333,
-0.4379771053791046,
0.9085668921470642,
0.6045562028884888,
-0.4071691632270813,
-0.004669785965234041,
-0.7004268169403076,
0.14546695351600647,
-0.403999388217926,
0.01693756878376007,
-0.4874650835990906,
-0.7597622275352478,
0.6642831563949585,
-0.023367127403616905,
0.1653745323419571,
0.759455680847168,
0.40751877427101135,
0.16320626437664032,
0.5974398255348206,
0.97646164894104,
-0.021529465913772583,
0.6693528890609741,
-0.30486199259757996,
0.45861032605171204,
-0.4487118721008301,
-0.2941795587539673,
-0.5841941833496094,
-0.41359323263168335,
-0.8320485949516296,
-0.1722586303949356,
0.4431602954864502,
-0.18620336055755615,
0.04680666700005531,
0.8721175193786621,
-0.3225335478782654,
0.4102519154548645,
0.561409056186676,
-0.24091453850269318,
0.24236375093460083,
-0.12280737608671188,
-0.23802544176578522,
-0.08324260264635086,
-0.48907727003097534,
-0.7239761352539062,
1.1604024171829224,
0.3869098126888275,
0.5283775925636292,
0.06437928974628448,
0.8508484959602356,
0.3143351674079895,
0.5838726758956909,
-0.5632717609405518,
0.2880595624446869,
-0.17302751541137695,
-0.5171993970870972,
-0.08841419219970703,
-0.6238877177238464,
-1.0530216693878174,
0.1550348401069641,
-0.21426638960838318,
-0.6946520209312439,
0.36851078271865845,
-0.07019659876823425,
-0.5378835797309875,
0.08913369476795197,
-0.9657780528068542,
1.071319341659546,
-0.40080851316452026,
-0.09369099140167236,
0.1250361055135727,
-0.5518081784248352,
0.14511476457118988,
-0.18749825656414032,
0.34543269872665405,
-0.014596023596823215,
-0.0198727585375309,
0.9286302924156189,
-0.11824464797973633,
0.6614965796470642,
0.019765488803386688,
-0.34038522839546204,
0.3171139359474182,
-0.17633947730064392,
0.3783619701862335,
0.05179046094417572,
-0.24714598059654236,
0.5376924276351929,
0.2910681664943695,
-0.254179984331131,
-0.33662286400794983,
0.3688930869102478,
-0.4433349072933197,
-0.038393259048461914,
-0.5496522188186646,
-0.23526506125926971,
-0.029483728110790253,
0.36077240109443665,
0.11087929457426071,
0.4293769598007202,
-0.6069601774215698,
0.1431283801794052,
0.263174444437027,
-0.19673284888267517,
0.6249575018882751,
0.5769684910774231,
-0.13469740748405457,
-0.6785552501678467,
0.8769369125366211,
0.3517935276031494,
0.022186648100614548,
0.5977659821510315,
-0.2046283334493637,
-0.5563887357711792,
-0.4212294816970825,
-0.40209120512008667,
0.23768973350524902,
-0.4594193398952484,
-0.39272060990333557,
-0.6278212666511536,
-0.06767168641090393,
-0.6210461258888245,
0.13823197782039642,
-0.3974681794643402,
-0.4029102325439453,
-0.1423380821943283,
-0.392325758934021,
0.18087823688983917,
0.5651724934577942,
0.06704197078943253,
0.08334363251924515,
-0.9625453352928162,
0.12382294982671738,
-0.0777522400021553,
0.27303940057754517,
-0.10474377870559692,
-0.29515576362609863,
-0.2862568199634552,
-0.0720147043466568,
-0.21032503247261047,
-1.1306195259094238,
0.5500752329826355,
0.1119171604514122,
0.4642508924007416,
0.554714024066925,
-0.27054864168167114,
0.8735533356666565,
-0.3998165428638458,
0.37487679719924927,
-0.028548384085297585,
-1.1937779188156128,
0.35781624913215637,
-0.09754325449466705,
-0.18615680932998657,
0.5829066038131714,
0.34589943289756775,
-0.5011270046234131,
-0.3639248013496399,
-1.0400688648223877,
-1.0654988288879395,
0.7257623672485352,
0.3399416208267212,
-0.0006407555774785578,
-0.23342686891555786,
0.13016091287136078,
0.282122939825058,
0.5324797630310059,
-0.8622883558273315,
-0.1643231362104416,
0.07629070430994034,
0.06125780567526817,
-0.019655464217066765,
-0.2406635284423828,
0.18860189616680145,
-0.09585783630609512,
0.6183741092681885,
0.008796796202659607,
0.45725998282432556,
0.1897728145122528,
-0.09855800122022629,
0.13445143401622772,
0.4128873944282532,
0.4641261398792267,
0.6434695720672607,
-0.21385237574577332,
-0.08973082154989243,
0.38415396213531494,
-0.19335706532001495,
-0.21257555484771729,
0.5916499495506287,
-0.08015841245651245,
0.39971989393234253,
0.3339180648326874,
0.8882613778114319,
0.7202938199043274,
-0.8351181149482727,
0.32539334893226624,
-0.12387028336524963,
0.008810199797153473,
-0.5773971080780029,
-0.26223036646842957,
-0.07354789972305298,
0.33011001348495483,
0.46763256192207336,
0.0525083988904953,
0.2615456283092499,
-0.576979398727417,
0.09811817854642868,
0.22559697926044464,
-0.41986939311027527,
-0.3364998400211334,
0.6829651594161987,
0.045339442789554596,
-0.14227621257305145,
0.7583209276199341,
-0.3392806053161621,
-0.6372316479682922,
0.7884807586669922,
0.4687970280647278,
1.0019961595535278,
-0.1553964614868164,
0.11967696249485016,
0.34751278162002563,
0.4696085751056671,
-0.08670589327812195,
0.2358599454164505,
-0.016162918880581856,
-0.6385208964347839,
-0.3215065598487854,
-0.8124547004699707,
-0.6092756390571594,
-0.12530672550201416,
-0.7859236001968384,
0.5809072256088257,
-0.2592070996761322,
-0.44140639901161194,
0.5908791422843933,
-0.22531090676784515,
-0.8462568521499634,
0.12677055597305298,
0.3089238703250885,
0.7354308366775513,
-0.5027312636375427,
0.6271884441375732,
0.7534000873565674,
-0.6226910948753357,
-0.7730919718742371,
-0.25531309843063354,
-0.3220398724079132,
-0.5851070880889893,
0.8137436509132385,
0.26279208064079285,
0.14967942237854004,
-0.12400871515274048,
-0.1446971595287323,
-0.7555376291275024,
0.9977291822433472,
0.5947907567024231,
-0.4742752015590668,
-0.327473908662796,
0.2265181839466095,
0.7358030676841736,
-0.27737823128700256,
0.4774913489818573,
0.5826486945152283,
0.6239237189292908,
0.12226583063602448,
-1.2904702425003052,
-0.4149756133556366,
-0.18516139686107635,
-0.19121526181697845,
0.7365353107452393,
-0.7245455980300903,
0.6845560669898987,
-0.24492892622947693,
-0.2635146975517273,
-0.31616872549057007,
0.7706307768821716,
-0.004626569803804159,
0.41385960578918457,
0.40130528807640076,
0.4608360230922699,
0.8472143411636353,
-0.32229918241500854,
1.0318777561187744,
-0.4894827604293823,
0.5050119757652283,
0.9936693906784058,
-0.24238847196102142,
0.8917737603187561,
0.439905047416687,
-0.25056371092796326,
0.4894459545612335,
0.5261043906211853,
-0.39012593030929565,
0.1354796141386032,
0.18274204432964325,
-0.07188104838132858,
0.028920549899339676,
-0.09145859628915787,
-0.17985258996486664,
0.6980084776878357,
0.2449350357055664,
-0.7700807452201843,
-0.2211463898420334,
-0.1077410951256752,
0.1667029708623886,
-0.4102973937988281,
-0.186355859041214,
0.8754697442054749,
0.17680396139621735,
-0.520267128944397,
0.10443054884672165,
0.385406494140625,
0.6073695421218872,
-0.5813129544258118,
0.0018313765758648515,
-0.07665456831455231,
0.34612104296684265,
0.052412018179893494,
-0.24722498655319214,
0.556229293346405,
0.5171555280685425,
-0.0580129511654377,
-0.6041643619537354,
0.572379469871521,
-0.4124002456665039,
-0.8768943548202515,
0.3603484630584717,
0.43619051575660706,
0.2719215154647827,
0.002088717184960842,
-0.6038863658905029,
-0.29732847213745117,
-0.1243424043059349,
-0.05630902200937271,
0.16154150664806366,
0.663962721824646,
-0.0341266468167305,
0.3980865478515625,
0.6353209018707275,
0.043562982231378555,
0.028972942382097244,
0.0822514221072197,
0.48518019914627075,
-0.9076429009437561,
-0.5325301289558411,
-0.9481870532035828,
0.2031928449869156,
0.0010122602107003331,
-0.4940144717693329,
0.7297509908676147,
1.0856338739395142,
1.0104410648345947,
-0.12763838469982147,
0.47426727414131165,
0.04742029309272766,
0.5207814574241638,
-0.3613174855709076,
0.595312774181366,
-0.2754304111003876,
0.2478412389755249,
-0.5983732342720032,
-0.9321762919425964,
-0.17206870019435883,
0.4601838290691376,
-0.6289132833480835,
0.013481209985911846,
0.5081595778465271,
0.36802396178245544,
-0.16499215364456177,
0.13431645929813385,
0.0880763977766037,
0.20224720239639282,
0.20865076780319214,
0.37450480461120605,
0.5087000727653503,
-0.760794460773468,
0.8008798956871033,
-0.12048014998435974,
0.24703742563724518,
-0.14167509973049164,
-1.0821551084518433,
-0.6577532887458801,
-0.3325580358505249,
-0.5665183067321777,
-0.31559574604034424,
0.01802368462085724,
0.9079458117485046,
0.3123553693294525,
-0.8167377710342407,
-0.3271922469139099,
0.23443958163261414,
0.12857487797737122,
-0.42695003747940063,
-0.25593188405036926,
0.40183404088020325,
-0.13209763169288635,
-1.0523966550827026,
0.22302289307117462,
0.4168787896633148,
0.3180217742919922,
0.024768033996224403,
0.30953800678253174,
0.10658831894397736,
0.205526664853096,
0.608322262763977,
0.0865420401096344,
-0.5392773151397705,
-0.10537482798099518,
0.09779004007577896,
-0.04603372514247894,
0.16592030227184296,
0.7243461608886719,
-0.5976755023002625,
0.1947018802165985,
0.2403090000152588,
0.6396631002426147,
0.4787514805793762,
0.03257155045866966,
0.39288270473480225,
-0.5820098519325256,
0.04581516608595848,
0.31778794527053833,
0.6214756965637207,
0.31538596749305725,
-0.21100777387619019,
0.5853805541992188,
0.18087823688983917,
-0.25435754656791687,
-0.7710908055305481,
-0.34294378757476807,
-1.19981849193573,
0.040451835840940475,
0.9134153723716736,
-0.06587442010641098,
-0.37740153074264526,
0.12879544496536255,
-0.29898059368133545,
0.2985836863517761,
-0.6287881731987,
0.8267379999160767,
0.8198403716087341,
-0.05581666901707649,
-0.013060618191957474,
-0.5418704748153687,
0.24402526021003723,
0.22231829166412354,
-0.6403911709785461,
-0.15641139447689056,
0.40500786900520325,
0.2754584848880768,
0.2938203513622284,
0.4075574576854706,
-0.20500755310058594,
0.1687961369752884,
-0.0372045561671257,
0.17041444778442383,
-0.010245501063764095,
-0.2893025577068329,
-0.1804761290550232,
0.3542606234550476,
-0.13741308450698853,
-0.06812570244073868
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.12173v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.12173v1
|
TnT-LLM: Text Mining at Scale with Large Language Models
| 2024-03-18T18:45:28 | 2024-03-18T18:45:28 |
Mengting Wan, Tara Safavi, Sujay Kumar Jauhar, Yujin Kim, Scott Counts, Jennifer Neville, Siddharth Suri, Chirag Shah, Ryen W White, Longqi Yang, Reid Andersen, Georg Buscher, Dhruv Joshi, Nagu Rangan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
Transforming unstructured text into structured and meaningful forms,
organized by useful category labels, is a fundamental step in text mining for
downstream analysis and application. However, most existing methods for
producing label taxonomies and building text-based label classifiers still rely
heavily on domain expertise and manual curation, making the process expensive
and time-consuming. This is particularly challenging when the label space is
under-specified and large-scale data annotations are unavailable. In this
paper, we address these challenges with Large Language Models (LLMs), whose
prompt-based interface facilitates the induction and use of large-scale pseudo
labels. We propose TnT-LLM, a two-phase framework that employs LLMs to automate
the process of end-to-end label generation and assignment with minimal human
effort for any given use-case. In the first phase, we introduce a zero-shot,
multi-stage reasoning approach which enables LLMs to produce and refine a label
taxonomy iteratively. In the second phase, LLMs are used as data labelers that
yield training samples so that lightweight supervised classifiers can be
reliably built, deployed, and served at scale. We apply TnT-LLM to the analysis
of user intent and conversational domain for Bing Copilot (formerly Bing Chat),
an open-domain chat-based search engine. Extensive experiments using both human
and automatic evaluation metrics demonstrate that TnT-LLM generates more
accurate and relevant label taxonomies when compared against state-of-the-art
baselines, and achieves a favorable balance between accuracy and efficiency for
classification at scale. We also share our practical experiences and insights
on the challenges and opportunities of using LLMs for large-scale text mining
in real-world applications.
|
[
0.08963802456855774,
-0.722594141960144,
0.7377908229827881,
0.2251998484134674,
-0.1868477761745453,
0.2020241618156433,
-0.24538108706474304,
-0.18864458799362183,
-0.06687162071466446,
0.6595300436019897,
-0.4024730324745178,
-0.7666217088699341,
-0.649269163608551,
0.05194763094186783,
-0.46717187762260437,
1.0063024759292603,
-0.021121185272932053,
-0.31446415185928345,
-0.15698611736297607,
0.2636274993419647,
-0.3734152019023895,
-0.6015856266021729,
-0.8972899317741394,
-0.42063412070274353,
0.65156090259552,
0.45185959339141846,
0.599361777305603,
0.5808176398277283,
0.025722995400428772,
0.24928733706474304,
-0.11790002882480621,
0.39004164934158325,
-0.569835364818573,
0.2903584837913513,
-0.1451999396085739,
-0.39426282048225403,
-0.4613204896450043,
0.08657852560281754,
0.5108665227890015,
0.677524209022522,
-0.09045358002185822,
0.17649248242378235,
0.023247670382261276,
0.2388785481452942,
-0.13508233428001404,
0.27705639600753784,
-0.7089320421218872,
0.00013333863171283156,
-0.1508437693119049,
-0.5205439925193787,
-0.7998777627944946,
-0.26769164204597473,
0.22602826356887817,
-0.4410059154033661,
-0.12115470319986343,
0.37399667501449585,
0.42418426275253296,
0.25785669684410095,
-0.9329339265823364,
-0.47978031635284424,
-0.661945104598999,
1.0132825374603271,
-0.48616498708724976,
0.22217582166194916,
0.30266425013542175,
0.18197718262672424,
-0.5891530513763428,
-0.9613355398178101,
-0.3175441026687622,
-0.12062320113182068,
-0.19300898909568787,
-0.1209145337343216,
-0.054870374500751495,
0.003240961115807295,
0.09044043719768524,
0.1779349446296692,
-0.6010786890983582,
0.4943544864654541,
-0.12927061319351196,
-0.22693432867527008,
0.3501947224140167,
0.20349709689617157,
0.32372862100601196,
-0.4036099314689636,
-0.3324413001537323,
0.09427467733621597,
-0.6402644515037537,
-0.08055347949266434,
0.14137165248394012,
0.5337420701980591,
0.17224714159965515,
0.7663479447364807,
-0.014595745131373405,
0.6820066571235657,
-0.0017051083268597722,
-0.3640807569026947,
0.09682870656251907,
-0.1098971962928772,
-0.22530612349510193,
0.20480072498321533,
1.130348563194275,
0.2351086437702179,
0.1632479578256607,
-0.27074870467185974,
-0.11521883308887482,
-0.4052051901817322,
0.15942612290382385,
-1.0317097902297974,
-0.11703667789697647,
0.46321409940719604,
-0.40252283215522766,
-0.43541982769966125,
-0.3741838037967682,
-0.5786099433898926,
-0.6266455054283142,
-0.3365514278411865,
0.4313669204711914,
-0.18765105307102203,
-0.11195152997970581,
-0.03352363780140877,
0.09727448225021362,
0.06322013586759567,
0.39629578590393066,
-0.7175658941268921,
0.01927144080400467,
0.7225266695022583,
1.0221614837646484,
-0.14917123317718506,
-0.05990048497915268,
-0.6849021911621094,
0.18383833765983582,
-0.3757414221763611,
0.8825127482414246,
-0.5210854411125183,
-0.3172067701816559,
-0.04069317504763603,
0.007495560683310032,
0.1523507982492447,
-0.5665415525436401,
0.46697571873664856,
-0.45378026366233826,
0.3092602789402008,
0.12058353424072266,
-0.6396319270133972,
0.08979249000549316,
0.43880096077919006,
-0.25847476720809937,
1.4523371458053589,
0.09890957921743393,
-0.7231473326683044,
0.29828080534935,
-0.3020407259464264,
-0.4361431896686554,
0.23505276441574097,
-0.031519144773483276,
-0.336753785610199,
0.036477673798799515,
0.08614697307348251,
0.8395282626152039,
-0.7675967812538147,
0.7997392416000366,
-0.04953198879957199,
-0.25057849287986755,
0.23323459923267365,
-0.21395906805992126,
0.5886449813842773,
0.13724519312381744,
-0.1617315709590912,
0.33141037821769714,
-0.6469834446907043,
0.023915696889162064,
-0.1131419688463211,
-0.5012997388839722,
-0.39430248737335205,
0.3011126220226288,
0.09542813152074814,
0.4299769997596741,
0.2506077289581299,
-0.47739580273628235,
0.4736720323562622,
-0.3938688635826111,
0.5934459567070007,
0.6690276861190796,
-0.05388730391860008,
0.5007871389389038,
-0.08550503849983215,
0.3345901370048523,
-0.08336984366178513,
0.026783697307109833,
-0.2873069941997528,
-0.5268048048019409,
-0.5797418355941772,
-0.3906785547733307,
0.36200520396232605,
0.6153731942176819,
-0.9879279136657715,
0.626656174659729,
-0.46910589933395386,
-0.6236323714256287,
-0.0860273540019989,
0.15310554206371307,
0.1724351942539215,
0.3767484128475189,
0.2513476014137268,
-0.08497314155101776,
-0.5963296890258789,
-0.7414515614509583,
-0.0029967923182994127,
-0.08682320266962051,
-0.4436151683330536,
0.3224823474884033,
0.2751469612121582,
-0.44083863496780396,
1.1555062532424927,
-0.5514535903930664,
-0.4715847671031952,
-0.4508216083049774,
0.5275608897209167,
0.32593604922294617,
0.21227288246154785,
0.13498975336551666,
-0.7282521724700928,
-0.5862053632736206,
0.07307285815477371,
-0.7049351334571838,
-0.3780059516429901,
-0.34534865617752075,
-0.09275280684232712,
0.1358802318572998,
0.7875271439552307,
-0.4252620339393616,
0.08561761677265167,
0.553879976272583,
-0.19233863055706024,
0.3233411908149719,
-0.12573739886283875,
-0.049616001546382904,
-1.2273080348968506,
-0.06586194783449173,
0.1865609735250473,
-0.42248424887657166,
-0.7603535056114197,
-0.34034934639930725,
-0.11708971858024597,
-0.1661078929901123,
-0.49330732226371765,
0.7980601191520691,
-0.343892365694046,
0.05176424980163574,
-0.5076231956481934,
0.3162809908390045,
-0.22139917314052582,
0.4569949209690094,
0.20366637408733368,
0.6099816560745239,
0.5265970230102539,
-0.5588185787200928,
0.5003153681755066,
-0.011727439239621162,
-0.2114449292421341,
0.4489808976650238,
-0.4913000762462616,
0.0420617051422596,
-0.08984506130218506,
0.6979836225509644,
-1.0838590860366821,
-0.1841423511505127,
0.1748640239238739,
-0.3687353730201721,
0.3291509747505188,
-0.39285358786582947,
-0.9741598963737488,
-0.34411218762397766,
-0.3823900818824768,
0.2604503333568573,
0.4998837411403656,
-0.5630627274513245,
0.8125009536743164,
0.46390703320503235,
-0.1752738505601883,
-0.2739257514476776,
-0.43503475189208984,
0.3740793466567993,
-0.22250378131866455,
-0.44861936569213867,
0.30101799964904785,
-0.0066919708624482155,
-0.005986175965517759,
-0.123056560754776,
-0.08223739266395569,
-0.20644041895866394,
-0.03627119958400726,
0.3546260893344879,
0.07421950995922089,
0.18087893724441528,
0.3213064670562744,
0.07704071700572968,
-0.2535895109176636,
0.04240299016237259,
-0.6789147257804871,
0.6947137117385864,
0.21975982189178467,
0.18014566600322723,
-0.2795899510383606,
0.08362853527069092,
0.4720703959465027,
0.13670411705970764,
0.832745373249054,
0.6303098797798157,
-0.2977553606033325,
-0.46241313219070435,
-0.3763808310031891,
-0.011685637757182121,
-0.44842296838760376,
0.29923394322395325,
-0.22523173689842224,
-1.0478596687316895,
0.07056942582130432,
-0.5645533204078674,
0.17238593101501465,
0.30856019258499146,
0.7691326141357422,
-0.060836561024188995,
0.9252828359603882,
0.7260803580284119,
0.04166285693645477,
0.09521512687206268,
-0.023424450308084488,
0.4613802134990692,
-0.7708473801612854,
-0.4227568209171295,
-0.6202278137207031,
-0.3294205963611603,
-0.686809778213501,
-0.6665247678756714,
0.3754425048828125,
-0.20587489008903503,
-0.04504252225160599,
0.29488345980644226,
-0.5137352347373962,
0.3811592757701874,
0.5369487404823303,
0.0435875803232193,
0.31868401169776917,
-0.1304410845041275,
0.1373639553785324,
0.03363557532429695,
-0.6443215608596802,
-0.6023187637329102,
1.1988420486450195,
0.31294500827789307,
0.678098201751709,
-0.040373481810092926,
0.6207165718078613,
0.20279376208782196,
0.6018931269645691,
-1.1408611536026,
0.7037248611450195,
-0.3479115664958954,
-0.6345362067222595,
-0.3033897280693054,
-0.7277693152427673,
-0.9416371583938599,
0.18538884818553925,
-0.28874510526657104,
-0.7722587585449219,
-0.28617778420448303,
0.07569453120231628,
-0.11211814731359482,
0.3780776858329773,
-0.6427462697029114,
0.6822066307067871,
-0.33317163586616516,
-0.23417173326015472,
0.13968314230442047,
-0.49455490708351135,
0.46476560831069946,
-0.5718300342559814,
0.49587175250053406,
-0.12936769425868988,
-0.11670682579278946,
0.8368909955024719,
-0.4631568491458893,
1.0251938104629517,
-0.08697450160980225,
-0.4137578010559082,
0.4092075526714325,
0.18373647332191467,
0.5321975350379944,
0.011523924767971039,
-0.001936736167408526,
0.05552768334746361,
-0.08914396166801453,
-0.117334745824337,
-0.46794894337654114,
0.7293532490730286,
-0.6500444412231445,
-0.35250920057296753,
-0.5603769421577454,
-0.6348624229431152,
-0.3107684850692749,
0.26774582266807556,
0.10404147952795029,
0.5591508150100708,
0.1898595094680786,
0.4337025284767151,
0.8260361552238464,
-0.7333981990814209,
0.23209291696548462,
0.3560824692249298,
-0.48566484451293945,
-0.223425954580307,
0.9698131084442139,
0.00131649908144027,
0.02755090221762657,
0.8547477722167969,
0.4249918758869171,
-0.4146031439304352,
-0.5763511657714844,
-0.17201067507266998,
0.19491998851299286,
-0.5196660757064819,
-0.34921780228614807,
-0.8223242163658142,
-0.11466310918331146,
-0.3104623258113861,
-0.1647484302520752,
-0.21849407255649567,
-0.31789109110832214,
-0.21054965257644653,
0.062376026064157486,
0.3207813501358032,
0.588185727596283,
0.26047074794769287,
0.486918181180954,
-0.7422789931297302,
0.4502866268157959,
0.35086336731910706,
0.335421085357666,
-0.012102853506803513,
-0.5218071937561035,
-0.1683891862630844,
-0.14432163536548615,
-0.14588940143585205,
-0.5166245698928833,
0.43525034189224243,
0.013297941535711288,
0.25962334871292114,
-0.08082632720470428,
0.13985960185527802,
0.3679558038711548,
-0.5571906566619873,
0.6974278092384338,
0.1680176705121994,
-0.8414519429206848,
0.4969017207622528,
-0.455720454454422,
0.2712271511554718,
0.2598867416381836,
0.6055927872657776,
-0.7279031276702881,
-0.443043977022171,
-0.31507307291030884,
-1.1407252550125122,
0.9591119289398193,
0.22353006899356842,
-0.02663293294608593,
-0.086264468729496,
0.42813748121261597,
0.15487037599086761,
0.24915960431098938,
-0.9616310596466064,
-0.3569173514842987,
-0.03783741965889931,
-0.4933443069458008,
-0.11486442387104034,
-0.4846417307853699,
0.22481976449489594,
0.02169041521847248,
0.7817786931991577,
-0.18597117066383362,
-0.07513588666915894,
-0.05597107484936714,
-0.27348199486732483,
0.15403148531913757,
0.5091432332992554,
0.1588948369026184,
0.5164276361465454,
-0.267526775598526,
0.4074757695198059,
0.09920292347669601,
-0.37976041436195374,
0.24315688014030457,
-0.037777844816446304,
-0.17741963267326355,
-0.20360597968101501,
0.25808167457580566,
0.36354804039001465,
0.42266321182250977,
-0.8999974131584167,
0.4377996027469635,
-0.16820818185806274,
-0.28520143032073975,
-0.08824844658374786,
-0.2039075493812561,
0.15469644963741302,
0.0778699591755867,
0.4958835542201996,
-0.4371494948863983,
0.1037573516368866,
-0.747378945350647,
0.10282796621322632,
0.3468521535396576,
-0.18187183141708374,
-0.05922189727425575,
0.5367392897605896,
0.25827693939208984,
-0.23975549638271332,
0.6173226833343506,
-0.38026607036590576,
-0.42818883061408997,
0.38499724864959717,
0.3945954442024231,
0.7436572313308716,
-0.09384734183549881,
0.3984072804450989,
0.22347532212734222,
0.28308728337287903,
-0.25323936343193054,
-0.15783679485321045,
-0.02927817404270172,
-0.5522088408470154,
-0.724127471446991,
-0.7983393669128418,
-0.5297881960868835,
0.16504830121994019,
-0.21256448328495026,
0.3897852301597595,
-0.48286426067352295,
-0.048235032707452774,
0.04626769199967384,
-0.016058240085840225,
-0.32190757989883423,
0.31791451573371887,
0.24163706600666046,
0.6481798887252808,
-0.6741352081298828,
0.9452826976776123,
0.6387502551078796,
0.10307399928569794,
-0.7338034510612488,
-0.25969821214675903,
0.23431167006492615,
-0.6420267820358276,
0.794583797454834,
0.3846602141857147,
-0.002669377950951457,
0.07197008281946182,
-0.4635431170463562,
-0.710256040096283,
1.0741885900497437,
-0.03773649409413338,
-0.621654212474823,
-0.015526785515248775,
0.29218921065330505,
0.6471837162971497,
-0.17395402491092682,
0.4872366487979889,
0.48268041014671326,
0.397154301404953,
0.5192243456840515,
-0.9833865165710449,
0.15032844245433807,
0.11078198999166489,
0.07933162152767181,
0.44204074144363403,
-0.380877286195755,
0.6052761673927307,
0.14925600588321686,
-0.06986170262098312,
-0.08506608009338379,
0.45602571964263916,
0.26759809255599976,
0.2486286759376526,
0.5474368929862976,
0.4007242023944855,
0.6253985166549683,
-0.20153506100177765,
0.7474620342254639,
-0.11026708781719208,
0.35402026772499084,
1.0631533861160278,
-0.35929423570632935,
0.6388292908668518,
0.2077442854642868,
-0.13249199092388153,
0.3151787221431732,
0.6428806781768799,
0.059844695031642914,
0.1356939822435379,
0.34749990701675415,
-0.1251901239156723,
-0.32626965641975403,
-0.2846171259880066,
0.12259023636579514,
0.353558748960495,
0.39073675870895386,
-0.13279742002487183,
-0.37634000182151794,
0.018480772152543068,
0.30916115641593933,
-0.04794272780418396,
-0.4029068946838379,
0.7753273844718933,
0.12719477713108063,
-0.5404548645019531,
0.34100231528282166,
0.254462331533432,
0.9260309338569641,
-0.605408787727356,
0.2329840362071991,
-0.06329707056283951,
0.07766695320606232,
-0.3060334622859955,
-0.8803972601890564,
0.1925175040960312,
0.2298123836517334,
-0.0988730862736702,
-0.7138026356697083,
0.7134508490562439,
-0.4030493497848511,
-0.5721901655197144,
0.2549613416194916,
0.30694273114204407,
0.2834034860134125,
-0.19337046146392822,
-0.4737795889377594,
0.039293691515922546,
0.045859627425670624,
-0.39105695486068726,
0.45721060037612915,
0.7456066012382507,
-0.20476442575454712,
0.8927109837532043,
0.626917839050293,
-0.016784125939011574,
-0.037588465958833694,
0.17499041557312012,
0.7629427313804626,
-0.7738204002380371,
-0.2627938389778137,
-0.8046936988830566,
0.3222728371620178,
-0.0030897820834070444,
0.020545918494462967,
0.7346044778823853,
0.728140115737915,
0.46798598766326904,
0.24583345651626587,
0.721827507019043,
-0.18128512799739838,
0.595508337020874,
-0.5820016264915466,
0.3383480906486511,
-0.5214099287986755,
0.38467538356781006,
-0.13095439970493317,
-0.9956169128417969,
-0.5552840828895569,
0.21933522820472717,
-0.36038094758987427,
-0.10259107500314713,
0.7461572289466858,
0.6016212701797485,
0.06774710863828659,
-0.27265438437461853,
0.20071624219417572,
0.49817949533462524,
0.7871174216270447,
0.6381391882896423,
0.7062039375305176,
-0.18108007311820984,
0.9663320183753967,
-0.0012797772651538253,
-0.39988091588020325,
-0.10115525126457214,
-1.043575644493103,
-1.1855136156082153,
-0.4919171929359436,
-0.4083672761917114,
-0.08492331951856613,
-0.36745238304138184,
0.9243883490562439,
0.6934460997581482,
-0.41661378741264343,
-0.2711229622364044,
0.011073191650211811,
0.10064291954040527,
0.262227326631546,
-0.26661717891693115,
0.3104751706123352,
-0.37945249676704407,
-0.8066473603248596,
0.3934779465198517,
0.5216705203056335,
-0.0631377324461937,
-0.1931454837322235,
0.2707400918006897,
-0.16649077832698822,
0.01231103390455246,
1.0271484851837158,
0.04822830855846405,
-0.5797799229621887,
-0.15885202586650848,
-0.18171340227127075,
-0.09972129762172699,
-0.05532576143741608,
0.8244932293891907,
-0.9479700922966003,
0.3345361649990082,
0.28077611327171326,
0.5074777603149414,
0.6806106567382812,
-0.006004660855978727,
0.3577018976211548,
-1.0339735746383667,
0.0695536732673645,
0.08586406707763672,
0.13758356869220734,
0.3613286018371582,
-0.34027299284935,
0.3529447019100189,
-0.01009228453040123,
-0.6085288524627686,
-0.8334039449691772,
0.1695842146873474,
-1.166925072669983,
-0.5788206458091736,
1.402705430984497,
0.20502932369709015,
-0.09619343280792236,
-0.27592042088508606,
-0.4147452712059021,
0.1062607541680336,
-0.4231269657611847,
0.5886309146881104,
0.5859447717666626,
-0.06034068018198013,
-0.1862758994102478,
-0.4583275616168976,
0.3256937861442566,
-0.16945916414260864,
-0.9115273356437683,
0.2502679228782654,
0.4422987997531891,
0.3550393283367157,
0.05320734530687332,
0.6714498400688171,
0.05792732909321785,
-0.306906133890152,
-0.3495323956012726,
0.00017615361139178276,
-0.10039939731359482,
-0.3464287221431732,
0.027330880984663963,
0.3409402668476105,
0.08940498530864716,
0.321614146232605
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.12171v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.12171v1
|
EasyJailbreak: A Unified Framework for Jailbreaking Large Language Models
| 2024-03-18T18:39:53 | 2024-03-18T18:39:53 |
Weikang Zhou, Xiao Wang, Limao Xiong, Han Xia, Yingshuang Gu, Mingxu Chai, Fukang Zhu, Caishuang Huang, Shihan Dou, Zhiheng Xi, Rui Zheng, Songyang Gao, Yicheng Zou, Hang Yan, Yifan Le, Ruohui Wang, Lijun Li, Jing Shao, Tao Gui, Qi Zhang, Xuanjing Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Jailbreak attacks are crucial for identifying and mitigating the security
vulnerabilities of Large Language Models (LLMs). They are designed to bypass
safeguards and elicit prohibited outputs. However, due to significant
differences among various jailbreak methods, there is no standard
implementation framework available for the community, which limits
comprehensive security evaluations. This paper introduces EasyJailbreak, a
unified framework simplifying the construction and evaluation of jailbreak
attacks against LLMs. It builds jailbreak attacks using four components:
Selector, Mutator, Constraint, and Evaluator. This modular framework enables
researchers to easily construct attacks from combinations of novel and existing
components. So far, EasyJailbreak supports 11 distinct jailbreak methods and
facilitates the security validation of a broad spectrum of LLMs. Our validation
across 10 distinct LLMs reveals a significant vulnerability, with an average
breach probability of 60% under various jailbreaking attacks. Notably, even
advanced models like GPT-3.5-Turbo and GPT-4 exhibit average Attack Success
Rates (ASR) of 57% and 33%, respectively. We have released a wealth of
resources for researchers, including a web platform, PyPI published package,
screencast video, and experimental outputs.
|
[
-0.34493115544319153,
-0.8831568956375122,
0.6012645363807678,
0.3969971537590027,
-0.14289571344852448,
0.20782579481601715,
-0.34013181924819946,
-0.3647351861000061,
0.16374808549880981,
0.8043249249458313,
-0.392841637134552,
-0.5036888122558594,
-0.6789747476577759,
-0.08078337460756302,
-0.48310717940330505,
1.0784964561462402,
0.0013212427729740739,
-0.13756577670574188,
0.03233661875128746,
-0.022840449586510658,
-0.656764566898346,
-0.5358349084854126,
-0.3177633285522461,
-0.04653850197792053,
0.2717532515525818,
0.2641005218029022,
0.5208281874656677,
0.3700023889541626,
0.5907008051872253,
0.3231954574584961,
-0.3687095046043396,
-0.22954846918582916,
-0.23229894042015076,
0.2813691198825836,
-0.10948828607797623,
-0.2924814820289612,
-0.32621869444847107,
-0.36464276909828186,
0.29089629650115967,
0.45924580097198486,
-0.3186754882335663,
0.17469486594200134,
-0.029391175135970116,
0.8024828433990479,
-0.9035204648971558,
0.07418249547481537,
-0.8165958523750305,
-0.17938263714313507,
-0.526622474193573,
0.42708301544189453,
-0.5696534514427185,
-0.14812466502189636,
-0.420738160610199,
-0.15942533314228058,
-0.1459449976682663,
-0.242479607462883,
0.27493807673454285,
0.129075825214386,
-0.5229833126068115,
-0.32013097405433655,
-0.3265528976917267,
0.6142653226852417,
-0.6480733156204224,
0.2243223339319229,
0.16450358927249908,
0.42316728830337524,
-0.5672773718833923,
-0.5597103238105774,
-0.21451567113399506,
-0.3166350722312927,
0.13109713792800903,
-0.5270835161209106,
-0.16061551868915558,
0.14439745247364044,
0.3028254210948944,
0.2200411856174469,
-0.5113007426261902,
0.10685936361551285,
-0.37270691990852356,
-0.09393585473299026,
0.48962244391441345,
0.10891348123550415,
0.680047333240509,
-0.41849035024642944,
-0.3048943281173706,
0.10984784364700317,
-0.9596740007400513,
0.06761730462312698,
0.4465949535369873,
0.2560719847679138,
-0.2625933289527893,
0.39194759726524353,
-0.08497795462608337,
0.8266505599021912,
-0.21946197748184204,
-0.34331175684928894,
0.12342023849487305,
-0.23734784126281738,
-0.21944288909435272,
-0.052106499671936035,
0.8602375984191895,
0.042337872087955475,
0.06673390418291092,
-0.29940375685691833,
-0.07780230045318604,
-0.30037054419517517,
0.11388759315013885,
-0.9400117993354797,
-0.3997649848461151,
0.3338893949985504,
-0.28397679328918457,
-0.5126832127571106,
0.21583297848701477,
-0.815109372138977,
-0.7993839979171753,
0.2347763627767563,
0.006603062152862549,
-0.3680158257484436,
-0.29480984807014465,
0.2473265379667282,
-0.042894396930933,
0.2895232141017914,
0.33369919657707214,
-0.8709182739257812,
0.40386930108070374,
0.8709350824356079,
0.7355641722679138,
-0.050618965178728104,
-0.34397655725479126,
-0.5265647172927856,
0.3315722346305847,
0.15835066139698029,
0.5587021112442017,
-0.2273576855659485,
-0.2899455428123474,
-0.20526254177093506,
-0.09674355387687683,
-0.07665791362524033,
-0.37488889694213867,
0.5693566799163818,
-0.5587697625160217,
-0.46301302313804626,
0.200849711894989,
-0.5036568641662598,
-0.09557738900184631,
0.2408660650253296,
-1.0985056161880493,
0.48992541432380676,
-0.21470889449119568,
-0.8194020390510559,
0.03914058580994606,
-0.6184535622596741,
-0.5721209049224854,
-0.06557773053646088,
-0.09865514934062958,
-0.5690943598747253,
0.17059196531772614,
0.43580833077430725,
0.40964433550834656,
-0.4513280987739563,
0.6488365530967712,
-0.6346849799156189,
-0.250801682472229,
0.3744894862174988,
-0.4576527178287506,
1.174430012702942,
0.4403882920742035,
-0.5182263851165771,
-0.035976942628622055,
-0.7860527634620667,
0.08387936651706696,
0.425723135471344,
-0.31231698393821716,
-0.4940342605113983,
0.06261378526687622,
0.1822902113199234,
-0.0547947883605957,
0.26178088784217834,
-0.7574283480644226,
0.6110290288925171,
-0.35036423802375793,
0.6268762946128845,
0.7331297397613525,
0.0540291890501976,
0.2591872811317444,
0.30178526043891907,
0.4547020196914673,
-0.27852749824523926,
0.3560306429862976,
-0.34800776839256287,
-0.24505272507667542,
-0.2332002967596054,
-0.6339757442474365,
0.49507755041122437,
0.4475387632846832,
-0.33988630771636963,
0.3340534567832947,
-0.06440196186304092,
-0.6374511122703552,
-0.5020641088485718,
0.7327518463134766,
0.5591723918914795,
-0.12298309803009033,
0.16032136976718903,
-0.23696327209472656,
-0.6282411813735962,
-0.8166248202323914,
-0.5949301719665527,
-0.015682173892855644,
-0.04849003255367279,
-0.172844797372818,
0.6017993688583374,
-0.31428107619285583,
0.666654646396637,
-0.5226099491119385,
-0.05716003105044365,
-0.6828566789627075,
-0.14553357660770416,
0.3452100455760956,
0.538031280040741,
0.7157405614852905,
-0.5350625514984131,
-0.284648597240448,
-0.33128148317337036,
-0.8480492234230042,
0.01524127647280693,
0.06574899703264236,
0.21351294219493866,
-0.11444330960512161,
0.4886718988418579,
-0.8234800100326538,
0.3652043342590332,
0.6984829902648926,
-0.5307708978652954,
0.6214831471443176,
0.11788135021924973,
0.002418043790385127,
-0.9348169565200806,
0.02835419401526451,
-0.0676025003194809,
-0.2975372076034546,
-0.7008826732635498,
0.8469318151473999,
0.2177794873714447,
-0.2400435209274292,
-0.6691520810127258,
0.4306771457195282,
-0.428241103887558,
0.06393352150917053,
-0.17846697568893433,
-0.22362077236175537,
-0.038946378976106644,
0.16057133674621582,
-0.5379002690315247,
0.47806742787361145,
0.4597043991088867,
-0.042763903737068176,
0.5074387788772583,
0.07616839557886124,
-0.6533053517341614,
0.046011097729206085,
-0.773375928401947,
0.35076722502708435,
0.19614848494529724,
0.4708169102668762,
-0.9242551922798157,
-0.48644891381263733,
0.18050643801689148,
-0.25112631916999817,
0.25400036573410034,
-0.517605721950531,
-0.6696497797966003,
-0.1809876263141632,
-0.5738739967346191,
0.36474746465682983,
0.10600574314594269,
-0.7991743087768555,
0.458450049161911,
0.5741041898727417,
-0.24236874282360077,
-0.5058338046073914,
-0.6052525043487549,
0.39599868655204773,
-0.2617795169353485,
-0.9259532690048218,
-0.05965456739068031,
-0.16046278178691864,
-0.49892833828926086,
-0.30242398381233215,
-0.03763144090771675,
-0.213607519865036,
0.6404472589492798,
0.44209960103034973,
0.3783264756202698,
0.11664696782827377,
-0.41977018117904663,
0.054194945842027664,
-0.0969783365726471,
0.13083381950855255,
0.015374542213976383,
0.6062825322151184,
-0.3037806451320648,
-0.5138915777206421,
-0.3550453186035156,
0.30583441257476807,
0.8931363224983215,
-0.3223346471786499,
0.7162694334983826,
0.09922410547733307,
-0.2132883369922638,
-0.10055761784315109,
-0.6016613841056824,
0.128354012966156,
-0.49925827980041504,
0.35853469371795654,
-0.6893694400787354,
-1.0871303081512451,
0.389413446187973,
-0.21357335150241852,
0.10196571797132492,
0.14689889550209045,
0.5539100170135498,
0.16803894937038422,
1.1086877584457397,
0.6031419634819031,
-0.4563881754875183,
0.13473093509674072,
0.06383541971445084,
0.24322295188903809,
-0.7285072207450867,
-0.13418041169643402,
-0.6238744258880615,
0.04738779366016388,
-0.4700395166873932,
-0.0795009508728981,
-0.05615442991256714,
0.3752609193325043,
-0.24316217005252838,
0.4318428337574005,
-0.3538202941417694,
0.9060679078102112,
0.07976904511451721,
-0.15009109675884247,
0.45170965790748596,
-0.1814216524362564,
-0.1309794932603836,
0.07196372747421265,
-0.22533299028873444,
-0.29838061332702637,
1.3513619899749756,
0.49418702721595764,
1.0494062900543213,
0.5502885580062866,
0.9332530498504639,
0.2998600900173187,
0.3930599093437195,
-0.5905196070671082,
0.5534878969192505,
-0.029826216399669647,
-0.8851104974746704,
-0.07830074429512024,
-0.4860062301158905,
-0.8058081865310669,
0.3913732171058655,
0.05627721920609474,
-1.105339765548706,
-0.19007360935211182,
-0.039442334324121475,
-0.24316057562828064,
0.5188792943954468,
-0.7212878465652466,
1.0457220077514648,
-0.4523981213569641,
-0.12214405834674835,
-0.030699895694851875,
-0.582480788230896,
1.1076871156692505,
-0.3380790054798126,
0.6515038013458252,
-0.16233879327774048,
0.4057641327381134,
0.5848064422607422,
-0.8023034334182739,
0.8455820679664612,
-0.3210963308811188,
0.0018373618368059397,
0.2584124803543091,
0.42402344942092896,
0.6596196293830872,
0.337105393409729,
0.08005040884017944,
0.09601084887981415,
0.13066399097442627,
-0.33986911177635193,
-0.5564305186271667,
0.8670491576194763,
-0.6911157965660095,
-0.6585328578948975,
-0.37241244316101074,
-0.25596264004707336,
-0.10251584649085999,
0.0183970145881176,
-0.07524584978818893,
0.15980932116508484,
-0.29505103826522827,
0.22252465784549713,
0.5570687055587769,
-0.21802394092082977,
0.3262447118759155,
0.5604369640350342,
-0.7374939918518066,
-0.49002864956855774,
0.606339156627655,
-0.3268764913082123,
0.14420025050640106,
-0.028884874656796455,
0.024596940726041794,
0.13363243639469147,
-0.6996636986732483,
-0.5382886528968811,
0.07170376181602478,
-0.6399891972541809,
-0.40091243386268616,
-0.43188947439193726,
-0.2877712845802307,
-0.4641186594963074,
-0.10163648426532745,
-0.592833936214447,
-0.47832682728767395,
0.37555134296417236,
-0.2831316590309143,
0.3919893503189087,
0.6422893404960632,
0.03159553185105324,
0.3815988600254059,
-0.891404926776886,
0.45081964135169983,
0.323235422372818,
0.2178172767162323,
0.012086650356650352,
-0.3471640348434448,
-0.11023222655057907,
-0.29009920358657837,
-0.3581177890300751,
-0.9825719594955444,
0.1879422664642334,
0.10464148968458176,
0.3471284508705139,
0.2865065932273865,
-0.06503011286258698,
0.6059623956680298,
-0.5806764960289001,
0.587263822555542,
0.6119850873947144,
-1.1444144248962402,
0.8662149310112,
-0.3011259138584137,
0.1877758949995041,
0.9822753667831421,
-0.09139522165060043,
-0.3681100904941559,
-0.6687917113304138,
-0.49760207533836365,
-1.2245550155639648,
0.4816551208496094,
0.16265277564525604,
0.10053607821464539,
0.027440285310149193,
0.3386204242706299,
0.13160744309425354,
0.1730789840221405,
-1.0690776109695435,
-0.43674591183662415,
0.02254592813551426,
-0.023778995499014854,
0.1528300940990448,
-0.20500293374061584,
-0.2110920250415802,
-0.4116019904613495,
0.37664759159088135,
0.29060670733451843,
-0.1441754251718521,
-0.3359427750110626,
-0.5907832384109497,
0.1560858190059662,
0.6448348760604858,
0.28481194376945496,
0.5361696481704712,
-0.40775540471076965,
0.10734907537698746,
-0.04690249636769295,
-0.6017928123474121,
0.5059493780136108,
0.1250903308391571,
-0.3735187351703644,
-0.09314672648906708,
0.3256886303424835,
0.6741527915000916,
0.27161794900894165,
-0.8547344207763672,
0.7467342615127563,
-0.3751996159553528,
0.0960477739572525,
-0.4330706000328064,
0.23998308181762695,
0.11087848246097565,
0.14343290030956268,
0.21173502504825592,
0.04246554151177406,
0.15689165890216827,
-0.6605277061462402,
0.3144690990447998,
0.3004688024520874,
-0.306606650352478,
-0.2505015432834625,
0.6076565980911255,
0.32150915265083313,
-0.10972126573324203,
0.56442791223526,
-0.1741066873073578,
-0.36996257305145264,
0.655377209186554,
0.7213608622550964,
0.994850754737854,
-0.3323521614074707,
0.004026372451335192,
0.023246468976140022,
0.6362553238868713,
-0.13960060477256775,
-0.0680999830365181,
0.027603209018707275,
-0.518974781036377,
-0.7068344354629517,
-0.8430096507072449,
-0.3981165289878845,
0.3253912925720215,
-0.606502115726471,
0.23444315791130066,
-0.7481302618980408,
0.09642882645130157,
-0.014658819884061813,
-0.3056069612503052,
-0.47720539569854736,
-0.09307260811328888,
0.29264068603515625,
1.0409098863601685,
-0.7158823013305664,
1.0907806158065796,
0.6149098873138428,
-0.22151243686676025,
-0.7861341238021851,
-0.1584649235010147,
0.6136497855186462,
-0.4775678813457489,
0.6763077974319458,
0.36534038186073303,
0.07339922338724136,
-0.35241106152534485,
-0.6282017827033997,
-0.8147066831588745,
0.7845593690872192,
0.5172240138053894,
-0.8529852628707886,
0.09581387042999268,
0.04948241263628006,
0.012083903886377811,
-0.2860167920589447,
0.12139400094747543,
1.0476701259613037,
0.6251963376998901,
-0.1658632606267929,
-0.7610375881195068,
0.20096486806869507,
-0.3037429749965668,
-0.2220703512430191,
0.6018587946891785,
-0.41004103422164917,
0.6813955903053284,
-0.30501458048820496,
0.20316927134990692,
0.4345051348209381,
0.34089982509613037,
0.683407723903656,
0.2125272899866104,
0.5622838735580444,
0.8173555731773376,
0.5175122618675232,
-0.06787223368883133,
1.146055817604065,
-0.35513824224472046,
0.3201671242713928,
1.3397371768951416,
-0.25907668471336365,
0.8025212287902832,
0.5543662905693054,
-0.13997025787830353,
0.29910486936569214,
0.1361403465270996,
-0.0836794450879097,
0.6784051656723022,
0.569557785987854,
-0.3922722339630127,
-0.08158788830041885,
0.46061354875564575,
-0.31497541069984436,
0.6398890614509583,
0.3138032853603363,
-0.1279577612876892,
-0.3343503475189209,
0.3198997378349304,
0.7158663868904114,
-0.21591854095458984,
-0.4185321033000946,
0.6445475816726685,
0.27714237570762634,
-0.36248818039894104,
0.43134790658950806,
0.572192370891571,
0.6920762658119202,
-0.7360529899597168,
0.2842443287372589,
-0.12030568718910217,
0.20427349209785461,
-0.35087186098098755,
-0.6268792152404785,
0.19409818947315216,
0.588935375213623,
0.07450572401285172,
0.07800596952438354,
0.9167278409004211,
0.026880888268351555,
-0.3017117977142334,
0.6113412976264954,
0.2953706979751587,
-0.013502659276127815,
-0.3070996105670929,
-0.7467086911201477,
0.5900294184684753,
0.26566755771636963,
-0.551779568195343,
0.7776167392730713,
0.06532032787799835,
0.2643299400806427,
0.5670251846313477,
0.7755310535430908,
0.1102210059762001,
0.04383547231554985,
0.025922616943717003,
0.9895411133766174,
-0.8795400857925415,
-0.13580526411533356,
-1.2369688749313354,
0.616083025932312,
-0.19000595808029175,
-0.12764853239059448,
0.8453903198242188,
0.4812847971916199,
0.47522738575935364,
0.07542678713798523,
1.0324840545654297,
-0.2153763622045517,
0.24841931462287903,
-0.570361316204071,
0.8730428814888,
-0.18560223281383514,
0.8108128905296326,
-0.5672875642776489,
-0.9721080660820007,
-0.467995822429657,
0.42127349972724915,
-0.341571569442749,
-0.35086390376091003,
0.5353200435638428,
0.4797418415546417,
-0.1370876431465149,
-0.0317852608859539,
0.16119016706943512,
0.4105319380760193,
0.6424652338027954,
0.5745658874511719,
0.8129544854164124,
-0.27832871675491333,
0.6520420908927917,
-0.12460194528102875,
-0.3107215166091919,
-0.08214550465345383,
-0.8223097324371338,
-0.943446695804596,
0.08901204913854599,
-0.18636105954647064,
-0.38843342661857605,
0.27842992544174194,
0.8661466240882874,
0.35083693265914917,
-0.7818911671638489,
-0.35334232449531555,
-0.04483432695269585,
0.2313254028558731,
0.12376626580953598,
-0.25394460558891296,
0.2515064477920532,
-0.2656557857990265,
-0.1894359141588211,
0.7453129291534424,
0.5288586020469666,
-0.4726319909095764,
-0.25451532006263733,
-0.030907584354281425,
0.023667126893997192,
0.028845062479376793,
0.5253507494926453,
0.5982727408409119,
-0.5207492709159851,
-0.18787719309329987,
-0.546385645866394,
-0.22255152463912964,
-0.10319701582193375,
0.8117408156394958,
-0.5283467769622803,
0.3873237669467926,
0.21979351341724396,
0.8349435329437256,
0.5602743029594421,
-0.3626241683959961,
0.36718714237213135,
-0.7300563454627991,
0.4737579822540283,
-0.10385289788246155,
0.672809898853302,
0.2470371425151825,
-0.00797860324382782,
0.39632007479667664,
0.14975479245185852,
-0.5078505277633667,
-0.9849949479103088,
0.5197635889053345,
-0.8170629739761353,
-0.648693323135376,
0.9393678307533264,
-0.3443564772605896,
-0.520964503288269,
-0.18152455985546112,
-0.09084548056125641,
-0.33502158522605896,
-0.3863959312438965,
0.753976583480835,
0.7231887578964233,
0.17930148541927338,
-0.13474254310131073,
-0.6796618103981018,
0.2727591395378113,
0.10568944364786148,
-0.8482295274734497,
0.15202488005161285,
0.3915606737136841,
0.6477153897285461,
0.0282884631305933,
0.4691082239151001,
-0.46669629216194153,
0.3279285430908203,
-0.27193883061408997,
0.35573700070381165,
-0.1872195601463318,
-0.37601104378700256,
-0.47537603974342346,
0.4728768467903137,
0.36071738600730896,
0.28563281893730164
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.12151v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.12151v2
|
Fusing Domain-Specific Content from Large Language Models into Knowledge Graphs for Enhanced Zero Shot Object State Classification
| 2024-03-18T18:08:44 | 2024-03-25T18:50:06 |
Filippos Gouidis, Katerina Papantoniou, Konstantinos Papoutsakis Theodore Patkos, Antonis Argyros, Dimitris Plexousakis
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG
|
Domain-specific knowledge can significantly contribute to addressing a wide
variety of vision tasks. However, the generation of such knowledge entails
considerable human labor and time costs. This study investigates the potential
of Large Language Models (LLMs) in generating and providing domain-specific
information through semantic embeddings. To achieve this, an LLM is integrated
into a pipeline that utilizes Knowledge Graphs and pre-trained semantic vectors
in the context of the Vision-based Zero-shot Object State Classification task.
We thoroughly examine the behavior of the LLM through an extensive ablation
study. Our findings reveal that the integration of LLM-based embeddings, in
combination with general-purpose pre-trained embeddings, leads to substantial
performance improvements. Drawing insights from this ablation study, we conduct
a comparative analysis against competing models, thereby highlighting the
state-of-the-art performance achieved by the proposed approach.
|
[
-0.2823924124240875,
-0.7659213542938232,
0.652915894985199,
-0.706072211265564,
-0.39307501912117004,
0.09703554958105087,
-0.23507218062877655,
-0.6626421213150024,
-0.12111001461744308,
0.9353653192520142,
-0.0999625101685524,
-0.8188298940658569,
-0.666498064994812,
-0.18490445613861084,
-0.673393189907074,
0.7196324467658997,
-0.15353606641292572,
-0.3089255094528198,
-0.4161306321620941,
0.06600026786327362,
-0.430325984954834,
-0.6198294758796692,
-0.21070508658885956,
-0.509329080581665,
0.4072440564632416,
0.1772349625825882,
0.5996580719947815,
0.8617109656333923,
0.34090346097946167,
0.2796967327594757,
0.1954813450574875,
0.25053852796554565,
-0.46777603030204773,
0.017780374735593796,
-0.4052547812461853,
-0.31681621074676514,
-0.3414933681488037,
-0.24428993463516235,
0.5677220821380615,
0.8496310710906982,
-0.09442926198244095,
0.019499167799949646,
-0.12926435470581055,
0.16344857215881348,
-0.8687224984169006,
0.2270047813653946,
-0.7990362644195557,
0.09675199538469315,
-0.23446732759475708,
-0.16533257067203522,
-0.5121839046478271,
-0.009507324546575546,
0.2883170247077942,
-0.5154070258140564,
0.2802487015724182,
0.11701498925685883,
0.9987888932228088,
0.31747114658355713,
-0.47705012559890747,
-0.10338468104600906,
-0.8696399927139282,
0.8802350163459778,
-0.6586823463439941,
0.5927534699440002,
0.04015791788697243,
0.028500566259026527,
-0.03882347419857979,
-0.5177693963050842,
-0.6978343725204468,
0.14099609851837158,
-0.06005757674574852,
-0.15118660032749176,
-0.30276232957839966,
0.24420781433582306,
0.21039937436580658,
0.17094603180885315,
-0.5275092720985413,
0.345572292804718,
-0.2641178071498871,
-0.18458177149295807,
0.586054801940918,
0.3345078229904175,
0.38188159465789795,
0.055884186178445816,
-0.2692306339740753,
-0.05598301813006401,
-0.8423155546188354,
-0.3078966438770294,
0.17008070647716522,
0.32667312026023865,
0.1228695660829544,
0.9821304082870483,
-0.3808741271495819,
1.3606667518615723,
-0.23016411066055298,
-0.1905488818883896,
0.19535067677497864,
-0.13384602963924408,
-0.5004910230636597,
0.04866010323166847,
0.5164585709571838,
0.26437222957611084,
0.4633117616176605,
-0.3868624269962311,
-0.10388337820768356,
0.42294642329216003,
0.3624964654445648,
-0.9607629179954529,
-0.10335195809602737,
0.2244967371225357,
0.08051180839538574,
-0.20612578094005585,
-0.2030150145292282,
-0.24292005598545074,
-0.3407604992389679,
-0.5077418684959412,
0.5819822549819946,
-0.4613431990146637,
-0.3262733817100525,
0.40355968475341797,
-0.2095421701669693,
0.3445613980293274,
0.5295346975326538,
-0.7047690153121948,
-0.07831734418869019,
0.7329720854759216,
0.7280864715576172,
-0.21903859078884125,
-0.24417495727539062,
-0.34995871782302856,
0.6123748421669006,
-0.5436269640922546,
0.9444634914398193,
-0.7237299084663391,
-0.2741430699825287,
0.3817076086997986,
-0.08331750333309174,
0.03328229486942291,
-0.5858679413795471,
-0.1647510975599289,
-0.880440890789032,
-0.1580837517976761,
0.1691323071718216,
-1.0076851844787598,
-0.3856104612350464,
0.4294032156467438,
-0.19865621626377106,
0.527539074420929,
0.28726160526275635,
-0.5605238080024719,
0.5885208249092102,
-0.37389323115348816,
-0.4508223235607147,
0.34581705927848816,
-0.4058060348033905,
-0.30550873279571533,
0.0628819465637207,
-0.10390057414770126,
0.9625989198684692,
-0.24636273086071014,
0.13949054479599,
-0.35989493131637573,
-0.23286715149879456,
0.152279794216156,
0.05559489503502846,
0.41958773136138916,
0.11737522482872009,
-0.06171731278300285,
-0.015148337930440903,
-0.42489951848983765,
-0.08049202710390091,
0.19437803328037262,
-0.17788180708885193,
-0.4585728049278259,
-0.10414188355207443,
-0.4340967833995819,
0.18655186891555786,
0.25678083300590515,
-0.7875449061393738,
0.28555139899253845,
-0.4140268564224243,
-0.08934161067008972,
0.461344838142395,
0.03690754994750023,
0.5445982813835144,
-0.04116014763712883,
0.32436805963516235,
0.2387888878583908,
-0.027387022972106934,
-0.3688393235206604,
-0.3557142913341522,
-0.7972914576530457,
-0.2528510093688965,
0.01831934042274952,
0.366598904132843,
-0.8856296539306641,
0.4275909662246704,
-0.2577623426914215,
-0.5114784240722656,
-0.17957934737205505,
0.3090551495552063,
0.33419379591941833,
0.7930423617362976,
0.27219250798225403,
-0.41864070296287537,
-0.22938871383666992,
-0.7720156908035278,
0.07627556473016739,
0.09037168323993683,
0.05375772342085838,
0.4384404122829437,
0.38887378573417664,
-0.2014111876487732,
1.0506892204284668,
-1.1080048084259033,
-0.5419122576713562,
-0.23642520606517792,
-0.10854145884513855,
0.039687350392341614,
0.17267023026943207,
0.5104765295982361,
-0.4165912866592407,
-0.44905006885528564,
0.28802552819252014,
-1.1373021602630615,
0.17164619266986847,
0.18049654364585876,
-0.2285182625055313,
0.41837045550346375,
0.3204375207424164,
-0.4433634579181671,
0.5896440744400024,
0.47140195965766907,
-0.43908625841140747,
0.38306283950805664,
-0.13855119049549103,
0.11203030496835709,
-0.720142662525177,
-0.07960408926010132,
0.10413096100091934,
-0.21803168952465057,
-1.0213794708251953,
0.07570181041955948,
-0.10213583707809448,
-0.34614086151123047,
-0.8608455061912537,
0.674752950668335,
-0.390872597694397,
-0.30170655250549316,
-0.5909236669540405,
0.2576235830783844,
0.05736761912703514,
0.4724653363227844,
0.5828798413276672,
0.29058006405830383,
0.8323076963424683,
-0.7099080681800842,
0.42371565103530884,
0.4015682339668274,
-0.5534684062004089,
0.43868082761764526,
-0.36866042017936707,
0.07012689858675003,
-0.20678725838661194,
0.08926805108785629,
-0.7618882656097412,
-0.18767932057380676,
0.052588265389204025,
-0.30228349566459656,
0.5971012115478516,
-0.33532848954200745,
-0.4613424241542816,
-0.21331457793712616,
0.0860079899430275,
0.3759397566318512,
0.6883931159973145,
-0.4286283850669861,
0.6904740929603577,
0.5547788143157959,
0.036618925631046295,
-0.6036519408226013,
-0.5534046292304993,
-0.12796719372272491,
0.007590055465698242,
-0.7092443704605103,
0.34828048944473267,
0.29763931035995483,
0.011834274046123028,
0.4486975073814392,
0.10559694468975067,
-0.11102821677923203,
-0.02056962251663208,
0.24282360076904297,
0.5053244829177856,
-0.16484791040420532,
0.25269851088523865,
-0.18238723278045654,
-0.09113685041666031,
-0.2969073951244354,
-0.5734342932701111,
0.8241389393806458,
0.24048705399036407,
-0.6460902094841003,
-0.35703030228614807,
0.26626700162887573,
0.36279550194740295,
-0.4305846691131592,
0.97613924741745,
0.5172903537750244,
-0.39357560873031616,
-0.5097895264625549,
-0.5926967859268188,
-0.135635107755661,
-0.43849658966064453,
0.4983483552932739,
-0.24730385839939117,
-1.1435573101043701,
0.26047971844673157,
-0.28108805418014526,
0.18054665625095367,
0.3103351294994354,
0.6412366628646851,
0.01870102621614933,
0.9311439990997314,
0.8534498810768127,
0.16038642823696136,
0.5880184173583984,
-0.6472634077072144,
0.3239409625530243,
-0.7996216416358948,
-0.3930078446865082,
-0.26840099692344666,
-0.11440050601959229,
-0.02832644432783127,
-0.7840534448623657,
0.12086851894855499,
0.06747329980134964,
-0.45196768641471863,
0.25176870822906494,
-0.39261940121650696,
0.4475964605808258,
0.15029317140579224,
0.05117039382457733,
0.28803589940071106,
0.2587434947490692,
-0.010435499250888824,
0.3248465657234192,
-0.8285244703292847,
-0.3307856023311615,
1.3141454458236694,
0.14136923849582672,
0.8967604041099548,
-0.07547295838594437,
0.6617209911346436,
0.1376389116048813,
0.2827617824077606,
-0.9869050979614258,
0.6109121441841125,
-0.5641283392906189,
-0.45445966720581055,
-0.5013878345489502,
-0.35333001613616943,
-0.9563988447189331,
0.29227617383003235,
-0.34992244839668274,
-0.6860837340354919,
-0.03383278101682663,
0.11247452348470688,
-0.23907846212387085,
0.6785207390785217,
-0.5272292494773865,
0.8544663190841675,
-0.21196064352989197,
-0.3090556561946869,
-0.30350029468536377,
-0.04288076236844063,
0.33317965269088745,
-0.4338207244873047,
0.07191744446754456,
-0.43528929352760315,
-0.040446650236845016,
0.5993097424507141,
-0.37584659457206726,
0.849348783493042,
-0.3829212784767151,
-0.2955004870891571,
0.47791916131973267,
0.13446354866027832,
0.3878217041492462,
-0.5500377416610718,
-0.011078473180532455,
0.5844736695289612,
-0.2814563810825348,
-0.21391014754772186,
-0.5929532051086426,
0.6701916456222534,
-0.8305583000183105,
-0.7137165665626526,
-0.22396530210971832,
-0.5291664600372314,
-0.31777122616767883,
0.18953152000904083,
-0.07721227407455444,
0.6943212747573853,
0.13523957133293152,
0.21863572299480438,
0.6792649030685425,
-0.4566018581390381,
0.12815025448799133,
0.8017589449882507,
-0.47498583793640137,
0.10477566719055176,
1.0596528053283691,
0.3262629806995392,
0.3971033990383148,
0.43097755312919617,
-0.12418712675571442,
-0.3286224603652954,
-0.7409628033638,
-0.4630995988845825,
0.42538967728614807,
-0.7925333976745605,
-0.4777020812034607,
-0.7361617684364319,
-0.39259007573127747,
-0.5209211707115173,
-0.43172362446784973,
-0.39513862133026123,
-0.0203903466463089,
-0.3517805337905884,
-0.08641137182712555,
0.43330681324005127,
0.8158115744590759,
0.23316024243831635,
0.3023304343223572,
-0.8313353061676025,
0.2822783887386322,
0.3150567412376404,
0.6429639458656311,
0.1930835247039795,
-0.546023428440094,
-0.5905308723449707,
-0.15291419625282288,
-0.07137060165405273,
-0.6288045048713684,
0.46287110447883606,
0.2939126491546631,
0.6437302231788635,
0.5003699660301208,
0.159465029835701,
0.6762344241142273,
-0.6298874616622925,
0.7709285616874695,
0.46093764901161194,
-0.8405513763427734,
0.559228241443634,
-0.2231854945421219,
0.21074357628822327,
-0.09918028861284256,
0.4864221513271332,
-0.42782577872276306,
-0.5116389393806458,
-0.2710161507129669,
-0.8742345571517944,
0.8794974088668823,
-0.3082481622695923,
0.2989569306373596,
-0.11310883611440659,
0.40699365735054016,
-0.09615486115217209,
0.15915094316005707,
-0.20827840268611908,
-0.18925637006759644,
-0.06353869289159775,
-0.21256554126739502,
-0.07678013294935226,
-0.094763845205307,
-0.14182521402835846,
-0.047604382038116455,
0.4953916668891907,
-0.2800336480140686,
0.23699218034744263,
-0.004713588394224644,
-0.4395260512828827,
-0.09030672162771225,
-0.01766519993543625,
0.32521218061447144,
0.4989739656448364,
-0.10455761849880219,
0.07535646855831146,
0.25678932666778564,
-0.14607755839824677,
0.16890469193458557,
-0.2751353979110718,
-0.16934305429458618,
-0.2937241792678833,
0.370100736618042,
0.8931726217269897,
0.1275368332862854,
-0.7153313755989075,
0.7135052680969238,
0.2804121971130371,
-0.3678167164325714,
-0.19915500283241272,
0.39421895146369934,
-0.07114458084106445,
0.28366097807884216,
0.23261478543281555,
-0.22063565254211426,
-0.04932878166437149,
-0.5576731562614441,
0.34335094690322876,
0.7045630812644958,
-0.28924939036369324,
-0.2138735055923462,
0.31937360763549805,
0.1929055154323578,
0.13392961025238037,
0.6875265836715698,
0.05564809590578079,
-0.517386794090271,
0.37767452001571655,
0.6113424301147461,
0.611428439617157,
-0.1691504269838333,
0.28625279664993286,
0.224799245595932,
-0.05389454960823059,
0.2684324085712433,
0.048203468322753906,
-0.053158972412347794,
-1.2818057537078857,
-0.8365683555603027,
-0.9530842900276184,
-0.43257999420166016,
-0.11209196597337723,
-0.35730740427970886,
0.3820335566997528,
-0.4896545708179474,
-0.1156671866774559,
-0.08352624624967575,
-0.09718404710292816,
-1.083365797996521,
0.38232266902923584,
0.45030975341796875,
0.7420784831047058,
-0.9122650623321533,
0.9859341382980347,
0.7804046273231506,
-0.3685366213321686,
-0.8346710801124573,
-0.41986629366874695,
-0.14556719362735748,
-1.0168676376342773,
0.8725659847259521,
-0.12058763951063156,
-0.20476992428302765,
0.1697283685207367,
-0.2969394624233246,
-0.9315608739852905,
1.1585444211959839,
0.40169867873191833,
-0.5146906971931458,
0.03132731467485428,
0.4443492293357849,
0.40174853801727295,
-0.5928228497505188,
-0.0373174250125885,
0.3889007270336151,
0.15365533530712128,
0.4872126877307892,
-0.7245873808860779,
0.015511003322899342,
0.18638797104358673,
-0.06896189600229263,
0.3515649437904358,
-0.4849376976490021,
0.6880362629890442,
-0.18800589442253113,
-0.4763171076774597,
-0.4576568305492401,
0.5574227571487427,
-0.017842303961515427,
0.11084997653961182,
0.45591527223587036,
0.835821270942688,
0.6306357383728027,
-0.03362464904785156,
1.0721209049224854,
-0.5553834438323975,
0.23800921440124512,
0.7981461882591248,
-0.6823223233222961,
1.0614979267120361,
0.18211199343204498,
0.010125282220542431,
0.6133485436439514,
0.19904088973999023,
-0.2302338033914566,
0.4579954147338867,
0.17958657443523407,
-0.41190460324287415,
-0.5207628607749939,
-0.5580875277519226,
-0.2713187634944916,
0.6640622019767761,
0.4890040457248688,
-0.27679216861724854,
-0.27037274837493896,
0.17788293957710266,
-0.09312404692173004,
-0.2843119204044342,
-0.4474106431007385,
1.0290167331695557,
0.0075677186250686646,
-0.40295228362083435,
0.4790195822715759,
-0.09968166053295135,
0.8031153082847595,
-0.7191962599754333,
0.01376006007194519,
0.03120516613125801,
0.24802708625793457,
-0.440852552652359,
-1.0490524768829346,
0.5072572827339172,
0.26105740666389465,
0.009983005933463573,
-0.15588684380054474,
0.9955672025680542,
-0.6071393489837646,
-0.23788784444332123,
0.4769022762775421,
0.48937752842903137,
0.2472349852323532,
-0.05339847877621651,
-0.21789425611495972,
0.19255678355693817,
-0.012299032881855965,
-0.1111561506986618,
0.5505913496017456,
0.19871164858341217,
0.20284110307693481,
0.5869317650794983,
0.7970870137214661,
0.2517619729042053,
0.06231370195746422,
0.1687536984682083,
1.0020930767059326,
-0.6160129308700562,
-0.07982324808835983,
-0.6895964741706848,
0.5662907958030701,
0.02658676914870739,
0.1690986603498459,
0.6333995461463928,
0.46928852796554565,
1.064571738243103,
-0.18983182311058044,
0.8972404599189758,
0.09122544527053833,
0.32989808917045593,
-0.5161921977996826,
0.701579749584198,
-0.8315965533256531,
0.07702857255935669,
-0.1466466337442398,
-1.0202158689498901,
-0.6028435230255127,
0.3788270950317383,
-0.4326944649219513,
-0.22955916821956635,
0.3385823965072632,
0.7042444944381714,
0.0868716686964035,
-0.4319465458393097,
0.9898996949195862,
0.038715071976184845,
0.4187610149383545,
0.5569334030151367,
0.8035223484039307,
-0.047256238758563995,
0.587875485420227,
-0.18708749115467072,
-0.07378998398780823,
-0.2843327522277832,
-0.8564872741699219,
-0.8278367519378662,
-0.4216705858707428,
-0.6266636252403259,
0.028075246140360832,
-0.18227441608905792,
0.6486813426017761,
0.8783184289932251,
-0.6029043197631836,
-0.1280381679534912,
0.2783381938934326,
-0.010154839605093002,
0.3798733651638031,
-0.17542974650859833,
0.31089749932289124,
-0.3252771496772766,
-0.6709194183349609,
0.24118293821811676,
0.549261212348938,
0.11735734343528748,
-0.37493616342544556,
-0.04269913211464882,
0.09025410562753677,
0.17609503865242004,
0.8633567094802856,
0.21377195417881012,
-0.6464501619338989,
-0.5780274868011475,
0.02348196879029274,
0.08646737784147263,
-0.16032984852790833,
0.6509801149368286,
-0.885095477104187,
0.5462778806686401,
0.39676743745803833,
0.7678878903388977,
0.6741597652435303,
-0.0682169497013092,
0.5462814569473267,
-0.8513041138648987,
0.20470069348812103,
0.09733469039201736,
0.5511826276779175,
0.46672648191452026,
-0.1500069797039032,
0.35944864153862,
0.13381600379943848,
-0.4462589919567108,
-0.7189766764640808,
0.39946550130844116,
-0.8187869191169739,
-0.4638573229312897,
1.1420515775680542,
-0.4076305627822876,
-0.3428220748901367,
-0.19972237944602966,
0.08616582304239273,
0.4830634295940399,
-0.10806309431791306,
0.3770788013935089,
0.5022679567337036,
-0.36936715245246887,
-0.17679589986801147,
-0.19807381927967072,
0.16538196802139282,
0.040461812168359756,
-0.717010498046875,
0.0033004104625433683,
0.6723483800888062,
0.497938334941864,
0.31445732712745667,
0.4734574854373932,
-0.10496754944324493,
-0.03665577247738838,
0.14367102086544037,
0.30470919609069824,
-0.39729762077331543,
-0.4493711590766907,
-0.26347899436950684,
0.43500253558158875,
0.19714201986789703,
0.008862311951816082
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.12145v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.12145v1
|
Syn-QA2: Evaluating False Assumptions in Long-tail Questions with Synthetic QA Datasets
| 2024-03-18T18:01:26 | 2024-03-18T18:01:26 |
Ashwin Daswani, Rohan Sawant, Najoung Kim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Sensitivity to false assumptions (or false premises) in information-seeking
questions is critical for robust question-answering (QA) systems. Recent work
has shown that false assumptions in naturally occurring questions pose
challenges to current models, with low performance on both generative QA and
simple detection tasks (Kim et al. 2023). However, the focus of existing work
on naturally occurring questions leads to a gap in the analysis of model
behavior on the long tail of the distribution of possible questions. To this
end, we introduce Syn-(QA)$^2$, a set of two synthetically generated QA
datasets: one generated using perturbed relations from Wikidata, and the other
by perturbing HotpotQA (Yang et al. 2018). Our findings from evaluating a range
of large language models are threefold: (1) false assumptions in QA are
challenging, echoing the findings of prior work, (2) the binary detection task
is challenging even compared to the difficulty of generative QA itself,
possibly due to the linguistic structure of the problem, and (3) the detection
task is more challenging with long-tail questions compared to naturally
occurring questions, highlighting the utility of our synthetic datasets and
generation method.
|
[
-0.27271953225135803,
-1.1033128499984741,
0.765102207660675,
0.10348798334598541,
-0.05665453523397446,
-0.06731051951646805,
0.02927391603589058,
-0.6591325402259827,
0.1744656264781952,
0.3355462849140167,
-0.7648202776908875,
-0.020130231976509094,
-0.2570274770259857,
0.31312981247901917,
-0.3373432159423828,
0.8433902263641357,
0.046862661838531494,
-0.17432183027267456,
-0.2581251561641693,
-0.2841346561908722,
-0.49011361598968506,
-0.4576849341392517,
-0.5362982749938965,
0.17020732164382935,
0.5132275819778442,
0.13545739650726318,
1.0545343160629272,
0.07297837734222412,
0.28585734963417053,
0.19848108291625977,
-0.0507013201713562,
0.05315754562616348,
-0.48692381381988525,
0.4407484233379364,
-0.3425397574901581,
-0.9006181359291077,
-0.0014147231122478843,
-0.01423362921923399,
0.7560842037200928,
0.5890200734138489,
0.06861986219882965,
0.6072395443916321,
-0.27911436557769775,
0.5718879699707031,
-0.7370595932006836,
-0.041956111788749695,
-0.8169938921928406,
-0.26205626130104065,
-0.3205406069755554,
0.0747620090842247,
-0.2967119812965393,
-0.2722242772579193,
0.11021222174167633,
-0.6539960503578186,
0.3771519660949707,
-0.01339787058532238,
0.9432533383369446,
0.2321571409702301,
-0.6721976399421692,
-0.24453367292881012,
-0.9790948033332825,
0.6449897289276123,
-0.620433509349823,
0.3431984782218933,
0.39786970615386963,
0.45925188064575195,
-0.34825170040130615,
-0.7245763540267944,
-1.0913307666778564,
0.2201836109161377,
0.06738483905792236,
-0.034379344433546066,
-0.5431655645370483,
-0.19229210913181305,
0.671090304851532,
0.1699281632900238,
-0.8304770588874817,
0.01773827336728573,
-0.4321152865886688,
-0.3142627477645874,
0.6449944376945496,
0.1451813280582428,
0.3130422830581665,
-0.3256393074989319,
-0.18516282737255096,
-0.24500879645347595,
-0.6101945638656616,
0.1607794165611267,
0.7212634086608887,
0.12528888881206512,
-0.01229971181601286,
0.6478066444396973,
-0.1140165701508522,
0.4760800004005432,
0.1465648114681244,
0.17819294333457947,
0.22292454540729523,
-0.6848848462104797,
0.11763934046030045,
-0.33540332317352295,
0.6817628741264343,
0.24584589898586273,
0.15511785447597504,
-0.021251214668154716,
-0.31870296597480774,
0.38678139448165894,
0.20095989108085632,
-0.4469076097011566,
-0.29747286438941956,
0.49186694622039795,
-0.2460174262523651,
-0.20324404537677765,
0.03496198728680611,
-0.8478413224220276,
-0.26077014207839966,
-0.11292638629674911,
0.666608452796936,
0.060136426240205765,
-0.649899423122406,
-0.08148693293333054,
-0.3150501549243927,
0.5528737306594849,
0.08543921262025833,
-0.5039886236190796,
0.5174670815467834,
0.6258143782615662,
0.3699570596218109,
-0.05715779587626457,
-0.02233065664768219,
-0.41987910866737366,
-0.2727617025375366,
-0.5873863101005554,
0.9038141965866089,
-0.4338682293891907,
-0.10563113540410995,
-0.17971712350845337,
0.13953863084316254,
-0.06948517262935638,
-0.6426420211791992,
0.4729272425174713,
-0.7774892449378967,
0.6283849477767944,
-0.6003904938697815,
-0.3546353876590729,
-0.12412756681442261,
0.3089849054813385,
-0.7765467166900635,
1.2520182132720947,
0.5245508551597595,
-0.9639410972595215,
0.1870419979095459,
-0.3689318597316742,
-0.24128559231758118,
-0.13846738636493683,
-0.09045813977718353,
-0.40101897716522217,
-0.023732177913188934,
-0.03985556960105896,
-0.2184121310710907,
-0.4305833876132965,
0.21627317368984222,
-0.39143529534339905,
-0.25739288330078125,
0.4005643427371979,
-0.511808454990387,
0.9031503796577454,
0.059784576296806335,
-0.4810270071029663,
-0.13023820519447327,
-0.6581841707229614,
0.3832469880580902,
0.3745659291744232,
0.1494576781988144,
-0.5204001069068909,
-0.030431734398007393,
-0.006946756038814783,
0.5194896459579468,
0.17519232630729675,
-0.521151602268219,
-0.043776798993349075,
-0.6008032560348511,
0.1577608585357666,
0.4968911409378052,
0.2678520679473877,
0.03427336737513542,
-0.16373617947101593,
0.7610399723052979,
0.12102966010570526,
0.11580348759889603,
0.138209730386734,
-0.6751806139945984,
-0.4210871756076813,
0.3954167664051056,
0.26937565207481384,
0.60944002866745,
-0.9589487314224243,
0.24961531162261963,
0.0222258772701025,
-0.371056467294693,
-0.5310599207878113,
0.14380860328674316,
0.45416155457496643,
0.46158862113952637,
0.35570815205574036,
-0.06803157180547714,
-0.5967935919761658,
-1.0872859954833984,
-0.42934566736221313,
-0.5243995189666748,
-0.024924717843532562,
0.18041802942752838,
0.6010681390762329,
-0.07651691138744354,
0.9611275792121887,
-0.4143635332584381,
0.35164812207221985,
-0.14288733899593353,
-0.0006764343706890941,
0.21156728267669678,
0.2740379273891449,
0.5884537100791931,
-1.122480869293213,
-0.4331100881099701,
-0.642653226852417,
-0.6647108793258667,
0.04070119932293892,
0.026962094008922577,
-0.09325803071260452,
0.34704554080963135,
0.1066892072558403,
-1.2176471948623657,
0.44015419483184814,
0.5804661512374878,
-0.490302711725235,
0.7843564748764038,
0.2433462142944336,
-0.0376703180372715,
-1.2504509687423706,
0.27209603786468506,
0.016129950061440468,
0.0219732653349638,
-0.7537454962730408,
0.24470509588718414,
0.05325881391763687,
-0.07540934532880783,
-0.30853062868118286,
0.5748783349990845,
-0.32036760449409485,
-0.19377848505973816,
-0.20595215260982513,
0.03111974149942398,
0.12387914955615997,
0.3753216564655304,
-0.021617939695715904,
0.7012534141540527,
0.4007897973060608,
-0.40336716175079346,
0.4131845235824585,
0.340243399143219,
-0.20690740644931793,
0.2746273875236511,
-0.8281134366989136,
0.45166879892349243,
-0.18874280154705048,
0.4331215023994446,
-1.1905288696289062,
-0.3538172245025635,
0.4033944606781006,
-0.6128635406494141,
0.1292642056941986,
-0.12473776936531067,
-0.7341988682746887,
-0.5188947916030884,
-0.36959102749824524,
0.7203525900840759,
0.6267397403717041,
-0.44084447622299194,
0.3163164556026459,
0.3481663465499878,
-0.14003431797027588,
-0.5786080956459045,
-0.3162009119987488,
-0.02354421280324459,
-0.0859944224357605,
-0.7491178512573242,
-0.051059529185295105,
0.18948355317115784,
-0.5745490193367004,
0.11713728308677673,
-0.4620484411716461,
-0.0699889212846756,
0.2713260054588318,
0.13363783061504364,
0.3043939173221588,
-0.46977439522743225,
0.20881080627441406,
0.020870249718427658,
-0.047706857323646545,
0.5926328301429749,
-0.15551580488681793,
0.3600058853626251,
0.11182539910078049,
-0.1796691119670868,
-0.5732248425483704,
0.27370789647102356,
0.45199960470199585,
-0.2832503318786621,
0.5474159121513367,
0.5423044562339783,
-0.5753575563430786,
-0.1483868956565857,
-0.5515429973602295,
-0.57065749168396,
-0.4298272132873535,
0.3642518222332001,
-0.4334307014942169,
-0.554793655872345,
0.49587512016296387,
0.3194616436958313,
-0.03245595842599869,
0.816088855266571,
0.4300300180912018,
-0.3552529513835907,
1.128125548362732,
0.3325185775756836,
0.1431867629289627,
-0.14027360081672668,
-0.18279343843460083,
0.4002892076969147,
-0.5958418846130371,
-0.19973814487457275,
-0.6610962152481079,
-0.15520811080932617,
-0.9646059274673462,
-0.534988284111023,
0.47612887620925903,
0.1229507178068161,
-0.04564706236124039,
0.29520711302757263,
-0.05069908872246742,
0.36699768900871277,
0.5575168132781982,
0.04036201164126396,
0.06086500734090805,
-0.24735265970230103,
0.35746195912361145,
0.21325919032096863,
-0.7757989764213562,
-0.44538038969039917,
1.224496841430664,
0.45978283882141113,
0.5533585548400879,
0.3050578534603119,
0.30183646082878113,
0.10731563717126846,
-0.22340774536132812,
-0.6904547810554504,
0.3191092908382416,
0.17969544231891632,
-1.006385326385498,
-0.49738430976867676,
-0.48158395290374756,
-0.9510371685028076,
0.1214321106672287,
-0.3383454978466034,
-0.6209322810173035,
0.28297868371009827,
0.2708176076412201,
-0.4734826683998108,
0.23750074207782745,
-0.6796274185180664,
0.9638360142707825,
0.049046993255615234,
-0.410884290933609,
-0.19310961663722992,
-0.9932239055633545,
0.4542679786682129,
-0.12544874846935272,
-0.01752234250307083,
-0.12064320594072342,
0.2113199532032013,
0.7498125433921814,
-0.11928193271160126,
0.7045997381210327,
-0.3553728759288788,
-0.3024177551269531,
0.8508898615837097,
0.4133378565311432,
0.8900544047355652,
0.17432960867881775,
-0.06140148267149925,
-0.17185552418231964,
0.6362186074256897,
-0.6391072273254395,
-0.9533405900001526,
0.3471270203590393,
-0.5823139548301697,
-0.7512339353561401,
-0.5036142468452454,
-0.4100239872932434,
-0.5069369077682495,
0.1975349485874176,
0.2507893741130829,
0.3748268783092499,
0.04065370559692383,
0.015655869618058205,
0.5772508978843689,
-0.33417022228240967,
-0.07345335185527802,
0.39555707573890686,
-0.0834377184510231,
0.06035466119647026,
0.767162561416626,
0.13566088676452637,
0.48551231622695923,
0.11776016652584076,
0.04625644162297249,
-0.6979162096977234,
-0.483964204788208,
-0.30508750677108765,
0.3426167666912079,
-0.4411914646625519,
-0.06268811970949173,
-0.5638980269432068,
-0.13170838356018066,
-0.47246164083480835,
0.5627509951591492,
-0.27060753107070923,
-0.6149535775184631,
-0.18317660689353943,
-0.12425802648067474,
-0.00673520565032959,
0.5207176208496094,
0.12890169024467468,
-0.2953738570213318,
-0.6322450637817383,
0.8131713271141052,
0.31948480010032654,
0.08991282433271408,
-0.24980509281158447,
-0.49577027559280396,
0.05118795856833458,
0.3441389501094818,
-0.18018269538879395,
-0.959979236125946,
0.08583109080791473,
-0.07064153254032135,
0.3306349813938141,
0.10459617525339127,
0.4388934373855591,
0.36155593395233154,
-0.07310004532337189,
0.929639995098114,
-0.09267815947532654,
-0.5555899143218994,
0.5720741152763367,
-0.36855077743530273,
0.17834869027137756,
0.46423569321632385,
0.7447361946105957,
-0.35526666045188904,
-0.46199968457221985,
-0.9114508628845215,
-0.5826783180236816,
0.4461583197116852,
0.3814207911491394,
0.29924631118774414,
-0.08976339548826218,
0.4821389317512512,
0.20587486028671265,
0.07268916070461273,
-0.39583706855773926,
-0.3092770576477051,
-0.04427799955010414,
-0.06351582705974579,
0.08286844938993454,
-0.5649763941764832,
-0.08862540870904922,
0.010419530794024467,
0.46907931566238403,
-0.3533988893032074,
0.2543702721595764,
0.18770307302474976,
0.05171738192439079,
-0.46102267503738403,
0.2593623697757721,
0.28129708766937256,
0.7422741651535034,
-0.23908798396587372,
0.12247562408447266,
0.11646900326013565,
-0.24996531009674072,
0.13246431946754456,
0.005177824757993221,
-0.4709368646144867,
0.0818740501999855,
0.3542536497116089,
0.6601514220237732,
-0.18221737444400787,
-0.6718931794166565,
0.5504958033561707,
0.12616291642189026,
-0.08837949484586716,
-0.5316861867904663,
-0.0005071060732007027,
-0.07765789330005646,
0.09949694573879242,
0.4245171844959259,
0.13150636851787567,
0.35858970880508423,
-0.9354100823402405,
0.2614845633506775,
0.5616669654846191,
-0.1851591318845749,
-0.9263209700584412,
0.5488576292991638,
0.046233296394348145,
-0.09076468646526337,
0.8984559774398804,
-0.29887324571609497,
-0.7153917551040649,
0.8328269124031067,
0.6275052428245544,
0.656817615032196,
0.09015487134456635,
0.32321345806121826,
0.5554203391075134,
0.2993238568305969,
0.035923078656196594,
0.6666898727416992,
0.11077974736690521,
-0.8436639308929443,
-0.29756927490234375,
-0.31313204765319824,
-0.30664992332458496,
0.2990666925907135,
-0.8128731846809387,
0.13414044678211212,
-0.3195294737815857,
-0.4513854384422302,
0.1811080276966095,
0.20351137220859528,
-0.5887906551361084,
0.2294623851776123,
0.016673976555466652,
0.9177294969558716,
-0.8514131903648376,
0.5196450352668762,
0.4610406160354614,
-0.3578437268733978,
-0.8398545980453491,
0.3431686460971832,
0.10161511600017548,
-0.45098525285720825,
0.5342066884040833,
0.0030730171129107475,
0.0942031592130661,
-0.1777494102716446,
-0.5759912133216858,
-1.0040889978408813,
0.8205668926239014,
0.37359583377838135,
-0.4005025029182434,
-0.36865875124931335,
0.15019774436950684,
0.7569412589073181,
0.24931062757968903,
0.14023740589618683,
0.6350142359733582,
0.5083176493644714,
-0.051665253937244415,
-1.0303112268447876,
0.24738562107086182,
-0.3682548999786377,
-0.26639628410339355,
0.32553279399871826,
-0.7543938755989075,
0.7091253995895386,
-0.5440062880516052,
-0.5821295380592346,
0.2664659321308136,
0.4937075078487396,
0.3549838066101074,
0.6671064496040344,
0.668311357498169,
0.3846198618412018,
0.635360062122345,
-0.1525549441576004,
1.0632238388061523,
-0.1944078952074051,
0.35874706506729126,
1.0925871133804321,
-0.4305250644683838,
0.8507043719291687,
0.6519104838371277,
-0.5145266056060791,
0.5794827342033386,
0.7248347997665405,
-0.05970504507422447,
0.11802119016647339,
0.2612875699996948,
-0.04171539843082428,
-0.3111502528190613,
-0.09879623353481293,
-0.3772403299808502,
0.48717400431632996,
0.35445737838745117,
0.09773297607898712,
-0.2299482375383377,
-0.38372835516929626,
-0.3441539406776428,
0.14667432010173798,
0.16969166696071625,
0.6325637698173523,
0.0029406778048723936,
-0.723747193813324,
0.5551238656044006,
-0.06794839352369308,
0.357205867767334,
-0.5122308135032654,
-0.19035372138023376,
-0.3203730881214142,
-0.33491015434265137,
-0.2052123248577118,
-0.9138548970222473,
0.35772398114204407,
-0.0015886477194726467,
-0.2887214720249176,
0.37070563435554504,
0.7219319939613342,
-0.3526504933834076,
-0.3964671492576599,
0.11417482048273087,
0.6150051951408386,
0.1717054396867752,
-0.28760048747062683,
-0.6637539267539978,
-0.15363389253616333,
-0.11251553148031235,
-0.40963855385780334,
0.11510559916496277,
0.39594560861587524,
-0.3891458213329315,
0.6825043559074402,
0.7373025417327881,
-0.03143179044127464,
0.06525885313749313,
-0.31461101770401,
0.7189494371414185,
-0.5661182999610901,
-0.3935803174972534,
-0.3482402265071869,
0.2713991105556488,
0.11518808454275131,
-0.3529331684112549,
0.7345373034477234,
0.5979974865913391,
0.7528818249702454,
0.01374020241200924,
0.7139802575111389,
-0.19507278501987457,
0.7584536671638489,
-0.5448288917541504,
0.4105849266052246,
-0.36418890953063965,
0.17158803343772888,
0.029888084158301353,
-1.159686803817749,
0.15202416479587555,
0.07565872371196747,
-0.3048560917377472,
0.0735175833106041,
0.6529141068458557,
0.9602733254432678,
-0.027493661269545555,
-0.0110719483345747,
0.09938597679138184,
0.3730742931365967,
0.12440484017133713,
0.6315643787384033,
0.942882239818573,
-0.8306213617324829,
0.34430497884750366,
-0.48364731669425964,
0.2861291170120239,
0.03904227167367935,
-0.2917402684688568,
-0.5542383193969727,
-0.787785530090332,
-0.33310666680336,
-0.8793195486068726,
0.12166246771812439,
0.9533199667930603,
0.347394198179245,
-1.1174335479736328,
0.1630614548921585,
0.0676637813448906,
0.20333300530910492,
-0.16413015127182007,
-0.30365878343582153,
0.5252213478088379,
-0.18680556118488312,
-0.5912733674049377,
0.36475813388824463,
-0.16694709658622742,
0.1802157312631607,
-0.39888331294059753,
0.1156654879450798,
-0.1723618507385254,
0.13541360199451447,
0.40354570746421814,
0.6844552755355835,
-0.6174360513687134,
-0.40410149097442627,
0.17248255014419556,
-0.1486641764640808,
-0.1742158681154251,
0.5661476254463196,
-0.8816556334495544,
0.38152697682380676,
0.6089907288551331,
0.5512470602989197,
0.3388075530529022,
0.23553717136383057,
0.7114765644073486,
-0.4942246675491333,
-0.05731814354658127,
0.5405085682868958,
-0.18039065599441528,
0.0852888822555542,
-0.45214515924453735,
0.4667852222919464,
0.5072126388549805,
-0.110111303627491,
-1.2264798879623413,
0.25994089245796204,
-0.867140531539917,
-0.19308342039585114,
1.2696822881698608,
0.0596863329410553,
-0.16776059567928314,
-0.24387747049331665,
0.05187540873885155,
0.10193284600973129,
0.011725696735084057,
0.9127997159957886,
0.4689316749572754,
-0.03655441105365753,
0.11851577460765839,
-0.6141994595527649,
0.6105361580848694,
0.5949525833129883,
-0.7424642443656921,
0.054968539625406265,
0.5226926803588867,
0.5453246235847473,
0.20726867020130157,
0.3991818428039551,
-0.11579398810863495,
0.7921739816665649,
0.2451629936695099,
-0.325936883687973,
0.16514065861701965,
-0.3026805818080902,
-0.15243591368198395,
0.2691726088523865,
0.07185793668031693,
-0.15780343115329742
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.12027v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.12027v2
|
From Pixels to Insights: A Survey on Automatic Chart Understanding in the Era of Large Foundation Models
| 2024-03-18T17:57:09 | 2024-03-25T17:39:10 |
Kung-Hsiang Huang, Hou Pong Chan, Yi R. Fung, Haoyi Qiu, Mingyang Zhou, Shafiq Joty, Shih-Fu Chang, Heng Ji
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV
|
Data visualization in the form of charts plays a pivotal role in data
analysis, offering critical insights and aiding in informed decision-making.
Automatic chart understanding has witnessed significant advancements with the
rise of large foundation models in recent years. Foundation models, such as
large language models, have revolutionized various natural language processing
tasks and are increasingly being applied to chart understanding tasks. This
survey paper provides a comprehensive overview of the recent developments,
challenges, and future directions in chart understanding within the context of
these foundation models. We review fundamental building blocks crucial for
studying chart understanding tasks. Additionally, we explore various tasks and
their evaluation metrics and sources of both charts and textual inputs. Various
modeling strategies are then examined, encompassing both classification-based
and generation-based approaches, along with tool augmentation techniques that
enhance chart understanding performance. Furthermore, we discuss the
state-of-the-art performance of each task and discuss how we can improve the
performance. Challenges and future directions are addressed, highlighting the
importance of several topics, such as domain-specific charts, lack of efforts
in developing evaluation metrics, and agent-oriented settings. This survey
paper serves as a comprehensive resource for researchers and practitioners in
the fields of natural language processing, computer vision, and data analysis,
providing valuable insights and directions for future research in chart
understanding leveraging large foundation models. The studies mentioned in this
paper, along with emerging new research, will be continually updated at:
https://github.com/khuangaf/Awesome-Chart-Understanding.
|
[
-0.4247898459434509,
-0.890397310256958,
0.6638021469116211,
0.043099306523799896,
-0.24413183331489563,
0.13352109491825104,
0.031351134181022644,
-0.7936595678329468,
-0.07418855279684067,
0.7339967489242554,
-0.6120274662971497,
-0.7745034098625183,
-0.9849056601524353,
-0.10049033910036087,
-0.6342769265174866,
0.6274583339691162,
-0.1785999834537506,
0.012925341725349426,
-0.255342572927475,
0.003455948084592819,
-0.5775900483131409,
-0.20974300801753998,
-0.6375333666801453,
-0.15650758147239685,
0.024148903787136078,
0.6313384771347046,
0.7341271638870239,
0.8936088681221008,
0.6488305926322937,
0.38390281796455383,
0.09146186709403992,
0.06922252476215363,
-0.746503472328186,
0.15908177196979523,
0.10042613744735718,
-0.3374916613101959,
-0.5341898798942566,
0.10565097630023956,
0.5485574007034302,
1.0901299715042114,
0.4034721255302429,
0.12679050862789154,
-0.1334688365459442,
0.9954228401184082,
-0.6795130968093872,
0.8982173800468445,
-0.1753171682357788,
0.2650085985660553,
0.05537475273013115,
-0.179547518491745,
-0.49310630559921265,
-0.2908201515674591,
0.5239136815071106,
-0.7298343777656555,
0.44755831360816956,
-0.12342115491628647,
0.6732609272003174,
0.28268542885780334,
-0.8036640286445618,
-0.6780986785888672,
-0.5982744693756104,
0.5140923857688904,
-0.18097977340221405,
0.480733186006546,
0.4422592520713806,
0.8376142978668213,
0.09875425696372986,
-1.1447032690048218,
-0.11803390830755234,
0.02166157402098179,
-0.17325101792812347,
0.0887988954782486,
-0.6405876278877258,
-0.08870860934257507,
-0.0900915116071701,
0.5506811738014221,
-0.4068213403224945,
0.18432165682315826,
-0.16789036989212036,
-0.20964780449867249,
0.8096029758453369,
0.31364065408706665,
0.39215531945228577,
-0.32669806480407715,
-0.17757639288902283,
-0.2884458899497986,
-0.42023006081581116,
0.20943626761436462,
-0.030010845512151718,
0.16525781154632568,
-0.3669079542160034,
0.29818975925445557,
-0.2998843193054199,
1.1029255390167236,
0.08061635494232178,
0.24276909232139587,
-0.07494291663169861,
-0.47321850061416626,
-0.331364244222641,
-0.2518330514431,
0.5976945161819458,
0.3351466655731201,
0.4219059944152832,
-0.37736886739730835,
-0.09383465349674225,
-0.00785865169018507,
0.2973577380180359,
-0.854348361492157,
-0.6459403038024902,
-0.044648557901382446,
-0.48643073439598083,
-0.3096398115158081,
0.05980052798986435,
-0.837662398815155,
-1.0433281660079956,
-0.7514147758483887,
0.07314649969339371,
-0.4606650471687317,
-0.20716366171836853,
0.006501502823084593,
-0.1122509017586708,
-0.055261727422475815,
0.6968072056770325,
-0.6672617793083191,
0.31665459275245667,
0.7517041563987732,
0.8575760126113892,
0.0019012074917554855,
-0.05987151339650154,
-0.4594217836856842,
-0.10342184454202652,
-0.6626439094543457,
0.8566398620605469,
-0.6392848491668701,
-0.28537335991859436,
-0.13481265306472778,
0.036457985639572144,
-0.14677682518959045,
-0.27115538716316223,
0.24881994724273682,
-0.5918563604354858,
-0.20502670109272003,
-0.2847573459148407,
-0.7257770299911499,
-0.5790481567382812,
0.12392950057983398,
-0.8381238579750061,
0.4311155378818512,
0.031092828139662743,
-0.3040600121021271,
0.5496252179145813,
-0.9047635197639465,
-0.3028637170791626,
0.03242270648479462,
-0.41769176721572876,
-0.3121865391731262,
0.008524160832166672,
0.514960527420044,
0.8476872444152832,
-0.37928327918052673,
0.17964968085289001,
-0.044945649802684784,
-0.20827332139015198,
0.1465383768081665,
-0.13503260910511017,
0.6722381711006165,
0.21586184203624725,
-0.628860354423523,
0.33421197533607483,
-0.68711256980896,
-0.048925139009952545,
0.4218025803565979,
0.4230794310569763,
0.23917120695114136,
0.24810606241226196,
0.2296372801065445,
-0.011271175928413868,
0.06286309659481049,
0.01717480458319187,
-0.08507979661226273,
-0.209907665848732,
0.6458315849304199,
0.711887001991272,
0.1461639404296875,
0.6166157722473145,
0.09645342081785202,
0.7991579174995422,
-0.1488407403230667,
0.06679791212081909,
-0.4533614218235016,
-0.5745058059692383,
-0.5516530275344849,
-0.22294464707374573,
0.1555025279521942,
-0.007960246875882149,
-0.31489434838294983,
0.5154014229774475,
-0.7056751847267151,
-0.8398744463920593,
-0.13793149590492249,
-0.019317835569381714,
0.06272340565919876,
0.5902077555656433,
0.2120790034532547,
-0.5884238481521606,
-0.35137930512428284,
-0.7698094844818115,
0.013452548533678055,
-0.006775618996471167,
0.3844563364982605,
0.5229411125183105,
0.523298442363739,
-0.20576146245002747,
1.3865907192230225,
-0.7118024230003357,
-0.17588068544864655,
-0.4355405867099762,
0.49057233333587646,
-0.11877256631851196,
0.20860986411571503,
1.002832055091858,
-1.045287013053894,
-0.6495426297187805,
0.09254449605941772,
-0.5113037824630737,
0.1325262486934662,
-0.13095305860042572,
-0.29589974880218506,
-0.18919916450977325,
0.442838579416275,
-0.27518323063850403,
0.7868372201919556,
0.39321088790893555,
-0.8781071305274963,
0.36681053042411804,
0.15287341177463531,
0.2782382071018219,
-0.42816632986068726,
0.23401711881160736,
0.1813451647758484,
-0.2939162254333496,
-0.7012960910797119,
0.07109839469194412,
0.2835763990879059,
-0.4036281704902649,
0.23816101253032684,
0.37928977608680725,
-0.7031344771385193,
-0.33694514632225037,
-0.3186635971069336,
0.2330978810787201,
0.10890070348978043,
0.06888530403375626,
0.11472602933645248,
0.6323115229606628,
0.6778092980384827,
-0.369444876909256,
0.5724465250968933,
0.39660847187042236,
-0.5728791356086731,
0.4532328248023987,
-0.3591712415218353,
0.19777867197990417,
-0.2737855911254883,
0.4992392659187317,
-1.3632172346115112,
-0.36876189708709717,
0.39142265915870667,
-0.5197888612747192,
0.3386188745498657,
-0.4161057770252228,
-0.5613149404525757,
-0.2930610179901123,
-0.07884079217910767,
0.08485617488622665,
0.26632294058799744,
-0.48238441348075867,
0.299381822347641,
0.5263459086418152,
-0.09307213127613068,
-0.44882312417030334,
-0.5895932912826538,
0.39270344376564026,
0.027011049911379814,
-0.8788763880729675,
-0.004370683804154396,
0.1439226120710373,
-0.3166429400444031,
0.03237612918019295,
-0.22511328756809235,
-0.3507611155509949,
0.20047901570796967,
0.3365355432033539,
0.042917054146528244,
-0.3158430755138397,
0.2571272552013397,
-0.35174277424812317,
-0.45318132638931274,
0.16591644287109375,
-0.2769487202167511,
0.46604281663894653,
-0.15678825974464417,
-0.5365192890167236,
-0.5558087825775146,
0.03546363487839699,
0.8508723378181458,
-0.4394693076610565,
0.4932943284511566,
0.5983006954193115,
-0.38862231373786926,
0.008525004610419273,
-0.2642437517642975,
-0.03993409872055054,
-0.409114807844162,
0.6013064384460449,
-0.15406209230422974,
-0.500408947467804,
0.3606976270675659,
-0.085416279733181,
0.1531122773885727,
0.6160611510276794,
0.47215965390205383,
-0.15421198308467865,
0.934434175491333,
0.9049520492553711,
-0.2291627824306488,
0.4611455202102661,
-0.7056215405464172,
0.4556860625743866,
-0.15375685691833496,
0.008951129391789436,
-0.556073009967804,
-0.5938250422477722,
-0.06501013040542603,
-0.4681498110294342,
0.29452162981033325,
-0.08081454783678055,
0.056273143738508224,
0.0943063348531723,
-0.4977865517139435,
0.3554039001464844,
-0.11936374008655548,
-0.014093100093305111,
0.3884240686893463,
-0.13826705515384674,
0.481033056974411,
-0.038341112434864044,
-0.547171413898468,
-0.545128583908081,
1.2792927026748657,
0.37212061882019043,
0.4095584750175476,
-0.09602875262498856,
0.25096115469932556,
0.2920638918876648,
0.2963050603866577,
-1.0415524244308472,
0.3506413400173187,
0.04378486052155495,
-0.5800782442092896,
-0.5544228553771973,
-0.3956805169582367,
-1.1811078786849976,
0.29366543889045715,
-0.04416883364319801,
-0.759951114654541,
0.3517616391181946,
0.21046186983585358,
0.0014343521324917674,
0.21797984838485718,
-1.1621285676956177,
1.2464944124221802,
-0.3016323149204254,
0.12614667415618896,
-0.41898664832115173,
-0.6572558879852295,
0.1836954802274704,
0.035527605563402176,
0.39257821440696716,
-0.0718291699886322,
0.02271149307489395,
0.7521642446517944,
-0.24548721313476562,
0.9049193263053894,
-0.36441195011138916,
-0.20491205155849457,
0.2071915566921234,
0.02237926982343197,
0.4863770604133606,
-0.2679179310798645,
-0.05579010397195816,
-0.19203145802021027,
0.06153221055865288,
-0.5189506411552429,
-0.828346312046051,
0.4517313241958618,
-0.6937302350997925,
-0.09041217714548111,
-0.05707067251205444,
-0.6359755396842957,
-0.42511674761772156,
-0.022982891649007797,
0.025732077658176422,
0.6881253123283386,
-0.13549603521823883,
0.3275102376937866,
0.14063845574855804,
0.05667818710207939,
0.1711779683828354,
0.22445975244045258,
-0.15563271939754486,
-0.07198166102170944,
0.9416422247886658,
0.29771697521209717,
0.1736534982919693,
0.20229163765907288,
-0.03611878678202629,
-0.3569549024105072,
-0.8210703730583191,
-0.4605979323387146,
0.1725926548242569,
-1.129591941833496,
0.0006992889102548361,
-0.4346804618835449,
0.0480259470641613,
-0.47200465202331543,
-0.2515760362148285,
-0.17487753927707672,
-0.3850034177303314,
-0.38695523142814636,
-0.21735936403274536,
0.5642927885055542,
1.1834628582000732,
0.051637280732393265,
0.35337033867836,
-0.5906816124916077,
0.4885234832763672,
0.20046700537204742,
0.48793575167655945,
0.6057787537574768,
-0.1066417470574379,
-0.5622130632400513,
0.07475748658180237,
-0.3329995274543762,
-1.1256945133209229,
0.21209071576595306,
-0.04114975407719612,
0.29755547642707825,
0.7000865340232849,
-0.10573311895132065,
0.891119122505188,
-0.00204238248988986,
0.45042628049850464,
0.18454952538013458,
-0.9426702260971069,
0.49899670481681824,
-0.33402013778686523,
0.2628457844257355,
0.4492154121398926,
0.31491565704345703,
-0.6937174201011658,
-0.06168220564723015,
-0.520444393157959,
-0.7995424270629883,
0.9134741425514221,
0.2714851200580597,
-0.25511643290519714,
0.48796987533569336,
0.15505440533161163,
0.31332165002822876,
0.12846042215824127,
-0.399732381105423,
-0.2820199131965637,
-0.21834416687488556,
-0.37682044506073,
-0.6034595966339111,
0.11963734775781631,
-0.014524376019835472,
-0.6775864362716675,
0.25916847586631775,
-0.2682032287120819,
0.1416444331407547,
-0.059718139469623566,
-0.6671426296234131,
-0.32529217004776,
-0.12079960107803345,
0.0050398362800478935,
1.368241310119629,
0.15116439759731293,
-0.13696976006031036,
-0.23845107853412628,
-0.7158156037330627,
-0.22497257590293884,
0.24881698191165924,
0.19210371375083923,
-0.18904374539852142,
0.6890971064567566,
1.0237618684768677,
0.3722096383571625,
-0.7412598133087158,
0.4901319444179535,
-0.017451850697398186,
-0.03402582183480263,
-0.05866267904639244,
-0.0476771742105484,
0.15812380611896515,
0.11812183260917664,
0.4353460669517517,
0.00440624263137579,
0.2611989378929138,
-0.5388175249099731,
0.029315274208784103,
0.26284247636795044,
-0.5095258951187134,
-0.21938125789165497,
0.23718851804733276,
0.2236069142818451,
0.06644579023122787,
0.5878104567527771,
0.12627795338630676,
-0.3631095290184021,
1.1686556339263916,
0.1558929681777954,
0.7216137647628784,
0.29448065161705017,
0.43690362572669983,
0.0028136137407273054,
0.18211588263511658,
0.5812774896621704,
-0.19786494970321655,
-0.558143138885498,
-0.5112167596817017,
-0.34822478890419006,
-0.22460535168647766,
-0.5806629657745361,
0.0046726311556994915,
-0.5421925187110901,
-0.00003478617509244941,
-0.40616995096206665,
-0.07030508667230606,
0.3021372854709625,
0.21394921839237213,
-0.9575321078300476,
0.5464569926261902,
0.13845255970954895,
0.7116560935974121,
-0.731797993183136,
0.31344732642173767,
0.8521134853363037,
-0.2589367926120758,
-0.40186169743537903,
-0.07741592079401016,
0.35493338108062744,
-0.85149747133255,
0.5692741870880127,
0.30033940076828003,
-0.23809389770030975,
0.15781283378601074,
-0.6650599837303162,
-0.7194092869758606,
1.1337616443634033,
0.33774447441101074,
-0.13597987592220306,
0.036911334842443466,
0.25537222623825073,
0.5252171158790588,
-0.2324095070362091,
0.3714313507080078,
1.0628280639648438,
0.709061324596405,
-0.08429000526666641,
-0.6516848802566528,
-0.10628287494182587,
-0.39258313179016113,
-0.21711814403533936,
0.18813300132751465,
-0.27957940101623535,
0.5834149718284607,
-0.025760645046830177,
-0.3785680830478668,
0.01798536814749241,
0.4861461818218231,
-0.13546818494796753,
0.5674744248390198,
0.6464207172393799,
0.3132435977458954,
0.7266512513160706,
-0.26425254344940186,
0.899513304233551,
-0.31922879815101624,
0.43823638558387756,
0.6850870847702026,
0.24191614985466003,
0.4553021490573883,
0.10769116878509521,
-0.2791481912136078,
0.3602025806903839,
0.9041575193405151,
0.027024369686841965,
0.18972820043563843,
0.026292497292160988,
0.32884490489959717,
-0.36334964632987976,
0.2073463648557663,
-0.47323963046073914,
0.6171467900276184,
0.616938591003418,
-0.4769527018070221,
-0.4809410870075226,
-0.15370771288871765,
-0.33321964740753174,
0.16569484770298004,
-0.23587249219417572,
0.6750711798667908,
-0.15366443991661072,
-0.10709923505783081,
0.43464118242263794,
-0.17242133617401123,
0.15408945083618164,
-0.6708877086639404,
-0.06999906152486801,
0.13837584853172302,
-0.13508881628513336,
-0.2157415896654129,
-0.9640451073646545,
0.23993803560733795,
0.16249550879001617,
-0.05116173252463341,
-0.5798665285110474,
0.5930472612380981,
0.2582535445690155,
-0.3450150787830353,
0.37953272461891174,
0.5962035059928894,
0.08743878453969955,
-0.3475602865219116,
-0.6068167686462402,
0.11546912789344788,
-0.11879782378673553,
-0.12171133607625961,
0.07226187735795975,
0.6397860646247864,
0.16951453685760498,
0.799633800983429,
0.3500370979309082,
-0.27722564339637756,
0.05242866650223732,
0.05697675794363022,
0.57208251953125,
-0.6778383851051331,
-0.9937283396720886,
-0.5422539710998535,
0.6114019751548767,
-0.24405960738658905,
-0.16778816282749176,
0.5527607798576355,
0.4924190640449524,
0.4361709654331207,
-0.15444917976856232,
0.7374410033226013,
0.08546152710914612,
0.33696162700653076,
-0.37868741154670715,
1.2861402034759521,
-0.5951163172721863,
-0.28126972913742065,
-0.5654506683349609,
-0.6831525564193726,
-0.17870913445949554,
0.41434770822525024,
-0.9204984903335571,
-0.07000160217285156,
0.5275664329528809,
0.2694738805294037,
-0.1541840136051178,
0.5380838513374329,
-0.12712959945201874,
0.3647657334804535,
0.4020524024963379,
0.2965121567249298,
0.6438291668891907,
-0.11867546290159225,
0.6249741315841675,
-0.48722174763679504,
-0.3088923394680023,
-0.2862558960914612,
-0.519921064376831,
-0.5260685086250305,
-1.0424633026123047,
-0.3809562921524048,
0.3165571391582489,
-0.15088769793510437,
0.4154287576675415,
0.9370687007904053,
-0.806479275226593,
-0.4969514310359955,
-0.4353258013725281,
0.15416735410690308,
-0.0463624969124794,
-0.2689528167247772,
0.7489632368087769,
-0.38348034024238586,
-0.6969695091247559,
0.3469606935977936,
0.32012397050857544,
0.11361509561538696,
-0.06304087489843369,
-0.03278857842087746,
0.12319859862327576,
-0.37181225419044495,
0.592962384223938,
0.30667340755462646,
-0.577980637550354,
-0.12094573676586151,
-0.2277185618877411,
0.052988555282354355,
0.3381204903125763,
0.9525267481803894,
-0.8071354031562805,
0.8821905851364136,
0.5489041209220886,
0.9079917073249817,
0.6921724081039429,
-0.006787375081330538,
0.6642960906028748,
-0.23549680411815643,
-0.031182020902633667,
0.30226415395736694,
0.3613097667694092,
0.4045199453830719,
-0.4548265039920807,
0.6061941385269165,
0.2248559147119522,
-0.15671630203723907,
-0.6841742992401123,
0.2510278522968292,
-0.8549062013626099,
-0.31371593475341797,
0.5246406197547913,
0.03194455802440643,
0.13593219220638275,
-0.25573286414146423,
-0.3782181143760681,
0.3337324261665344,
-0.09649308770895004,
0.7843542098999023,
0.8893491625785828,
-0.4954623579978943,
-0.18311409652233124,
-0.5310276746749878,
0.2702673077583313,
0.30380165576934814,
-1.030415415763855,
0.21570919454097748,
0.8814570307731628,
-0.21565216779708862,
0.05065168812870979,
0.4877110421657562,
-0.01720554381608963,
0.4933629035949707,
-0.11356425285339355,
-0.3648820221424103,
0.057963162660598755,
-0.28405600786209106,
-0.3900332450866699,
0.2963598370552063,
0.1475670486688614,
-0.12543003261089325
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.12026v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.12026v1
|
FlexCap: Generating Rich, Localized, and Flexible Captions in Images
| 2024-03-18T17:57:02 | 2024-03-18T17:57:02 |
Debidatta Dwibedi, Vidhi Jain, Jonathan Tompson, Andrew Zisserman, Yusuf Aytar
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We introduce a versatile $\textit{flexible-captioning}$ vision-language model
(VLM) capable of generating region-specific descriptions of varying lengths.
The model, FlexCap, is trained to produce length-conditioned captions for input
bounding boxes, and this allows control over the information density of its
output, with descriptions ranging from concise object labels to detailed
captions. To achieve this we create large-scale training datasets of image
region descriptions of varying length, starting from captioned images. This
flexible-captioning capability has several valuable applications.
First, FlexCap demonstrates superior performance in dense captioning tasks on
the Visual Genome dataset. Second, a visual question answering (VQA) system can
be built by employing FlexCap to generate localized descriptions as inputs to a
large language model. The resulting system achieves state-of-the-art zero-shot
performance on a number of VQA datasets. We also demonstrate a
$\textit{localize-then-describe}$ approach with FlexCap can be better at
open-ended object detection than a $\textit{describe-then-localize}$ approach
with other VLMs. We highlight a novel characteristic of FlexCap, which is its
ability to extract diverse visual information through prefix conditioning.
Finally, we qualitatively demonstrate FlexCap's broad applicability in tasks
such as image labeling, object attribute recognition, and visual dialog.
Project webpage: https://flex-cap.github.io .
|
[
-0.42052486538887024,
-0.6089539527893066,
0.4312137961387634,
-0.12054315954446793,
-0.4515484869480133,
0.19936084747314453,
-0.2258417010307312,
-0.6068060994148254,
0.18046148121356964,
0.39713814854621887,
-0.48935145139694214,
-0.25219520926475525,
-0.2490069568157196,
0.16061243414878845,
-0.33816906809806824,
0.8011568784713745,
-0.3137996196746826,
-0.05705497786402702,
-0.39357656240463257,
-0.45949310064315796,
-0.5558419227600098,
-0.14331358671188354,
-0.2580749988555908,
0.113263800740242,
0.5357227325439453,
0.689670205116272,
1.1708428859710693,
0.8716990351676941,
0.6083226203918457,
0.31520047783851624,
0.08364728838205338,
0.13344931602478027,
-0.5523337125778198,
0.14108245074748993,
0.07906273752450943,
-0.4941502511501312,
-0.0788821280002594,
-0.10231386870145798,
0.7799042463302612,
0.7558005452156067,
-0.0564156137406826,
0.15809790790081024,
-0.5487813353538513,
0.5236674547195435,
-0.5708374977111816,
-0.04204297065734863,
-0.6517888903617859,
0.43287748098373413,
-0.20892281830310822,
-0.21650180220603943,
-0.19207213819026947,
0.16285791993141174,
0.19374963641166687,
-0.7543902397155762,
0.5950270891189575,
0.3061676025390625,
1.08993399143219,
0.15733802318572998,
0.06904444843530655,
0.39810672402381897,
-0.7141039967536926,
0.6374683380126953,
-0.3199262022972107,
0.18331046402454376,
0.10728590935468674,
1.0151612758636475,
0.21215136349201202,
-0.997289776802063,
-0.7557670474052429,
0.08397655934095383,
-0.11119138449430466,
0.10048168897628784,
-0.06169101595878601,
0.00823395885527134,
0.18471375107765198,
0.7110850214958191,
-0.49920153617858887,
-0.061786629259586334,
-0.5925469398498535,
-0.20117001235485077,
0.4313521981239319,
0.294498085975647,
0.5134924650192261,
0.156060129404068,
-0.46412667632102966,
-0.0755080133676529,
-0.7965494990348816,
0.15704338252544403,
0.13648101687431335,
0.21301701664924622,
-0.07657040655612946,
0.9307361841201782,
-0.44756636023521423,
0.63462895154953,
-0.26578593254089355,
0.07907480001449585,
0.22335703670978546,
-0.23932214081287384,
-0.4378162622451782,
-0.2865690588951111,
0.593386709690094,
0.4365435242652893,
0.0673522800207138,
-0.3663601577281952,
-0.2201927900314331,
-0.16797982156276703,
0.18678925931453705,
-0.6974666118621826,
0.1066071093082428,
0.20230020582675934,
-0.5183705687522888,
-0.05402689799666405,
0.2498842477798462,
-0.7634438276290894,
-0.5216373205184937,
-0.3326813578605652,
0.399232417345047,
-0.07581649720668793,
-0.06381474435329437,
0.5264493823051453,
-0.34035754203796387,
0.8183476328849792,
0.19945375621318817,
-0.5914086103439331,
0.4320716857910156,
0.15809831023216248,
0.8026484251022339,
-0.5163426399230957,
-0.49227333068847656,
-0.7359873056411743,
0.14236919581890106,
-0.060602620244026184,
0.7909266352653503,
-0.5154935121536255,
0.01684652827680111,
0.06945254653692245,
0.14842665195465088,
0.26055967807769775,
-0.4256379306316376,
-0.1103874072432518,
-0.28830933570861816,
0.1394057720899582,
-0.14025373756885529,
-0.18182529509067535,
0.12194250524044037,
0.1285264641046524,
-0.7519629001617432,
0.6347073316574097,
0.1212817057967186,
-0.8127428889274597,
0.29488927125930786,
-0.7040673494338989,
-0.5074540376663208,
0.6072949767112732,
-0.4275929629802704,
-0.6426798105239868,
0.16892372071743011,
0.38109317421913147,
0.4599372446537018,
-0.3768846392631531,
0.07505859434604645,
-0.1888877898454666,
-0.38987359404563904,
0.6855101585388184,
-0.24368497729301453,
0.30569222569465637,
0.20576664805412292,
-0.40909305214881897,
0.47231560945510864,
-0.3148376941680908,
-0.19274719059467316,
0.5192554593086243,
-0.0802152007818222,
0.3344534933567047,
-0.12231558561325073,
0.1254524439573288,
-0.5020971894264221,
0.11540919542312622,
-0.7360486388206482,
0.1296631246805191,
-0.08874887228012085,
0.4801205098628998,
0.40424060821533203,
-0.18522393703460693,
0.5187069177627563,
-0.17775943875312805,
0.6830381155014038,
-0.2795851528644562,
0.6542553901672363,
-0.5470797419548035,
-0.3357245922088623,
-0.8109181523323059,
-0.5827072858810425,
0.15902459621429443,
0.48788362741470337,
-1.0743260383605957,
-0.11030088365077972,
-0.1400252878665924,
-0.3301478624343872,
-0.3063800036907196,
-0.04889311268925667,
0.35743770003318787,
0.5898640751838684,
0.4311434328556061,
-0.6341699957847595,
-0.34046033024787903,
-1.0450266599655151,
0.18937373161315918,
0.051110487431287766,
-0.043380577117204666,
0.46920081973075867,
0.25498712062835693,
-0.19420310854911804,
0.9492121934890747,
-0.9376024603843689,
-0.20479996502399445,
-0.5925507545471191,
-0.06331976503133774,
0.15432769060134888,
0.11743666976690292,
0.6649340987205505,
-1.0731133222579956,
-0.3857593536376953,
0.06210701912641525,
-0.3183622658252716,
0.0451149083673954,
-0.286213219165802,
-0.0915994644165039,
0.051687683910131454,
0.44782397150993347,
-0.7186265587806702,
0.6081633567810059,
0.07023026794195175,
-0.512465238571167,
0.7814834117889404,
-0.1828269511461258,
-0.002874111058190465,
-0.5291932821273804,
0.27035441994667053,
-0.21911045908927917,
-0.5850719213485718,
-0.5424396395683289,
0.3474147319793701,
-0.20617106556892395,
-0.35505059361457825,
-0.9383459687232971,
0.5540449023246765,
-0.5556462407112122,
-0.38701167702674866,
-0.138006329536438,
-0.09653368592262268,
0.0653185322880745,
0.5637087821960449,
0.4625787138938904,
0.648285448551178,
0.9253849983215332,
-0.16757023334503174,
0.612427294254303,
0.24649441242218018,
-0.4205750524997711,
0.332712858915329,
-0.7469395399093628,
-0.25284385681152344,
-0.4291866719722748,
0.008842742070555687,
-1.1509246826171875,
-0.5119677782058716,
0.08000291138887405,
-0.32819217443466187,
0.40104517340660095,
0.2728428244590759,
-0.4275636672973633,
-0.7169057726860046,
-0.40873056650161743,
0.608099639415741,
0.5086567401885986,
-0.4394189715385437,
0.42943909764289856,
0.38636651635169983,
-0.002150467364117503,
-0.6769394874572754,
-0.9498891234397888,
0.0535476878285408,
-0.14821292459964752,
-0.15821464359760284,
0.10219503939151764,
-0.24937447905540466,
0.23810842633247375,
0.03923918679356575,
-0.21534788608551025,
-0.27060794830322266,
-0.016236256808042526,
0.2232407182455063,
0.44960248470306396,
-0.2059415876865387,
0.15062366425991058,
-0.15350325405597687,
0.18580691516399384,
-0.4353444576263428,
0.008822520263493061,
0.3177568316459656,
-0.8321229815483093,
-0.2557382881641388,
-0.18338124454021454,
0.44844359159469604,
0.7464863657951355,
-0.4396490752696991,
0.5606207251548767,
0.6496015191078186,
-0.2767883837223053,
-0.10561517626047134,
-0.40338289737701416,
-0.21750137209892273,
-0.47791048884391785,
0.2784971296787262,
-0.21011897921562195,
-1.135127067565918,
0.49353089928627014,
0.11360670626163483,
-0.14144714176654816,
0.2041233777999878,
0.402476042509079,
-0.18943524360656738,
0.4438280761241913,
0.7935106158256531,
0.2769816219806671,
0.5363365411758423,
-0.30729779601097107,
0.1525963842868805,
-0.561524510383606,
-0.329870343208313,
0.014206076972186565,
-0.5412814617156982,
-0.15458472073078156,
-0.7167955040931702,
0.24500656127929688,
-0.10952116549015045,
-0.2713879942893982,
0.43792489171028137,
-0.6910088658332825,
1.007287859916687,
0.48426246643066406,
0.04881875962018967,
-0.21359221637248993,
0.20338600873947144,
-0.03781410679221153,
0.05415691062808037,
-0.8373650908470154,
-0.12887266278266907,
0.914124608039856,
0.5177136063575745,
0.6368741393089294,
-0.004558438900858164,
0.16571275889873505,
0.39327263832092285,
0.2579348087310791,
-0.7921667695045471,
0.6956042051315308,
-0.17339512705802917,
-0.4370404779911041,
-0.5715926289558411,
-0.20284077525138855,
-1.1443519592285156,
0.0251053087413311,
-0.432862788438797,
-0.5590524077415466,
0.250832736492157,
0.03173312544822693,
-0.48789605498313904,
0.3914635181427002,
-0.47254815697669983,
1.095699429512024,
-0.3973208963871002,
-0.3227599859237671,
0.36967435479164124,
-1.0606575012207031,
0.2504189908504486,
0.31731846928596497,
-0.1948331594467163,
-0.2041257619857788,
-0.2290712296962738,
0.1772078275680542,
-0.35605281591415405,
1.1016870737075806,
-0.1153239980340004,
0.544643759727478,
0.6056388020515442,
0.034757453948259354,
-0.16514332592487335,
0.13233724236488342,
0.43540817499160767,
0.013627380132675171,
0.022990796715021133,
-0.5038339495658875,
-0.30812638998031616,
0.20646865665912628,
-0.6601158976554871,
-0.4613037109375,
-0.26417040824890137,
-0.88433837890625,
0.022322043776512146,
0.39510154724121094,
0.1872885823249817,
0.403214693069458,
0.017170719802379608,
0.5217283368110657,
0.746157705783844,
-0.8296384215354919,
0.5424252152442932,
0.38781237602233887,
-0.285445898771286,
-0.6216397881507874,
0.8901186585426331,
-0.33429190516471863,
0.19095277786254883,
0.6489185094833374,
0.2529568374156952,
-0.204032763838768,
-0.3795276880264282,
-0.4825500249862671,
0.3700439929962158,
-0.7302192449569702,
-0.8716533184051514,
-0.1514207124710083,
-0.2428746521472931,
-0.13668473064899445,
-0.5374736785888672,
-0.3824227750301361,
-0.5775121450424194,
-0.21556740999221802,
-0.2939961552619934,
0.35522985458374023,
0.3279314339160919,
0.1734333485364914,
0.5004702210426331,
-0.43493425846099854,
0.808203399181366,
0.622239887714386,
0.5726397037506104,
-0.39777809381484985,
-0.17365849018096924,
-0.038901135325431824,
-0.36263307929039,
-0.17939259111881256,
-0.856658399105072,
0.39014506340026855,
0.41719019412994385,
0.6675089001655579,
0.3146740198135376,
0.13320200145244598,
0.4739433526992798,
-0.3939967453479767,
1.0282716751098633,
0.48705774545669556,
-0.8959980010986328,
0.5179888010025024,
-0.2830575406551361,
0.622814416885376,
0.4509691596031189,
0.13543693721294403,
-0.40535616874694824,
-0.5221226811408997,
-0.3664867579936981,
-1.0401067733764648,
0.43240752816200256,
0.2501344084739685,
0.36081641912460327,
-0.06873926520347595,
0.5437610149383545,
0.34638625383377075,
0.38120514154434204,
-1.0848884582519531,
-0.12781402468681335,
-0.4251282215118408,
-0.16533163189888,
0.2913956046104431,
-0.21100357174873352,
-0.3305680453777313,
-0.33767616748809814,
0.18974503874778748,
-0.549732506275177,
0.5428755879402161,
0.5968804359436035,
-0.1471244990825653,
-0.026823827996850014,
0.09477147459983826,
0.6995056867599487,
0.5861594676971436,
0.008224600926041603,
0.351081520318985,
0.10929898172616959,
-0.21811816096305847,
-0.3240412175655365,
0.1489180326461792,
-0.14507684111595154,
-0.05223548412322998,
0.42313599586486816,
1.0909597873687744,
-0.29154178500175476,
-1.1453667879104614,
0.848537802696228,
-0.1394810974597931,
-0.16999804973602295,
-0.0379997082054615,
-0.14302462339401245,
-0.2544175684452057,
0.2171030044555664,
0.30801835656166077,
-0.05360569432377815,
0.30765897035598755,
-0.6662558317184448,
0.1355516016483307,
0.41033434867858887,
-0.36810925602912903,
-0.09911054372787476,
0.8216036558151245,
0.11016951501369476,
0.15680095553398132,
0.47002628445625305,
-0.03845488280057907,
-0.5535489320755005,
0.8822775483131409,
0.5375362634658813,
0.7131460309028625,
0.007587631698697805,
0.5592109560966492,
0.1975187063217163,
0.35314005613327026,
-0.030797351151704788,
0.40831056237220764,
-0.36406034231185913,
-0.5601277351379395,
-0.3736504316329956,
-0.5339889526367188,
-0.5497344136238098,
0.04938188195228577,
-0.37513747811317444,
0.16385191679000854,
-0.37781205773353577,
-0.025030113756656647,
-0.1577211171388626,
-0.4237653613090515,
-0.8187386393547058,
0.13418807089328766,
0.595108687877655,
1.0780290365219116,
-0.8638277649879456,
0.52076256275177,
0.7224680781364441,
-0.4762779772281647,
-0.5002861022949219,
-0.4816771149635315,
-0.4875403940677643,
-0.6346340179443359,
0.3237459659576416,
0.598255455493927,
-0.029918519780039787,
-0.6265808343887329,
-1.0811142921447754,
-0.650227963924408,
1.379468321800232,
0.5083186030387878,
-0.3378834128379822,
0.42443281412124634,
0.5505253076553345,
0.6469034552574158,
-0.7390907406806946,
-0.10478760302066803,
0.3962845206260681,
0.366300106048584,
0.3700121343135834,
-0.785650372505188,
0.10924018919467926,
-0.21529166400432587,
0.12194126099348068,
-0.09103649854660034,
-0.5908289551734924,
0.4709344208240509,
-0.5588663816452026,
-0.31779688596725464,
0.4400854706764221,
0.8048571348190308,
0.05269775539636612,
0.3684946298599243,
0.41499119997024536,
0.35925450921058655,
0.599162220954895,
-0.21735402941703796,
1.2336595058441162,
0.2403533160686493,
-0.0078458646312356,
1.2580488920211792,
-0.144775390625,
0.844845712184906,
0.6243876218795776,
0.17000877857208252,
0.2801779806613922,
0.4555104970932007,
-0.3843401074409485,
0.5768494606018066,
0.3780288100242615,
-0.0776648074388504,
-0.21558450162410736,
-0.26468631625175476,
0.013575764372944832,
0.2886121869087219,
0.2710248529911041,
-0.21031002700328827,
0.21367327868938446,
0.30887094140052795,
-0.4491517245769501,
0.13933944702148438,
-0.45857080817222595,
0.46988460421562195,
-0.17322850227355957,
-0.529693067073822,
0.38508087396621704,
-0.2780517041683197,
0.31959500908851624,
-0.5433269739151001,
0.02021627128124237,
-0.4496781826019287,
-0.030032917857170105,
-0.11149633675813675,
-1.269676923751831,
0.5086847543716431,
-0.03574588894844055,
-0.10923659056425095,
-0.3038713335990906,
0.7448447942733765,
-0.6115984916687012,
-0.3345790207386017,
-0.20132628083229065,
0.29104286432266235,
0.25500911474227905,
0.15016598999500275,
-0.5316362977027893,
0.15130215883255005,
-0.17093345522880554,
-0.1435748040676117,
-0.2084188014268875,
0.376293420791626,
-0.031670041382312775,
0.6865187287330627,
0.32861918210983276,
0.018913278356194496,
0.15364506840705872,
0.044453006237745285,
0.8646149635314941,
-0.4834507405757904,
-0.13362658023834229,
-0.3425927758216858,
0.7372348308563232,
-0.18338337540626526,
0.04716290533542633,
0.12937137484550476,
0.633450984954834,
0.7395860552787781,
-0.6626525521278381,
0.5572564005851746,
-0.25981470942497253,
0.008268673904240131,
-0.2560957074165344,
0.3984818160533905,
-0.6116501688957214,
0.043928809463977814,
0.2792390286922455,
-0.9239935874938965,
-0.9749375581741333,
0.2988665699958801,
-0.0717339888215065,
-0.4171540439128876,
0.6763268113136292,
0.5447829365730286,
-0.25075244903564453,
-0.5503857731819153,
0.4235408306121826,
-0.08380254358053207,
0.15322592854499817,
0.5663228034973145,
0.7063031792640686,
-0.29448866844177246,
0.9558365941047668,
-0.1193140372633934,
-0.07926736772060394,
-0.03270052373409271,
-0.9257075190544128,
-0.9174227118492126,
-0.5390477776527405,
-0.6043437719345093,
0.03581123799085617,
-0.3027136027812958,
0.24740564823150635,
0.8009597063064575,
-0.6645655035972595,
-0.1798895001411438,
-0.0814267247915268,
0.15361446142196655,
-0.27589917182922363,
-0.2462887465953827,
0.23792879283428192,
-0.25502103567123413,
-0.4612460434436798,
0.16448281705379486,
0.5654496550559998,
0.4074839949607849,
-0.1119336262345314,
-0.1396445333957672,
0.1868840754032135,
0.17706884443759918,
0.6209707856178284,
0.9027009010314941,
-0.7653530836105347,
-0.30073344707489014,
0.1761104166507721,
0.08994490653276443,
0.22915302217006683,
0.758271336555481,
-0.7484647035598755,
0.8742361664772034,
0.6294610500335693,
0.8829976916313171,
0.5755570530891418,
-0.1720111072063446,
0.610014796257019,
-0.8749619722366333,
0.22207993268966675,
0.0331922210752964,
0.5954501032829285,
0.6689814329147339,
-0.31711459159851074,
0.637959361076355,
0.14586322009563446,
-0.36358708143234253,
-0.7926092743873596,
0.4979877471923828,
-1.4868910312652588,
-0.501183807849884,
1.1493706703186035,
-0.20185314118862152,
-0.47312435507774353,
0.2517029345035553,
-0.48563525080680847,
0.09747474640607834,
0.020714346319437027,
0.43840572237968445,
0.1598881632089615,
-0.050675611943006516,
-0.5481331944465637,
-0.3407902121543884,
0.2673071026802063,
0.2648090124130249,
-0.9232489466667175,
0.1479736715555191,
0.6220045685768127,
0.22399559617042542,
0.17135417461395264,
0.3730814456939697,
-0.24014438688755035,
0.6680171489715576,
-0.1957903653383255,
0.32514238357543945,
-0.3314970135688782,
-0.5447613596916199,
-0.08836330473423004,
0.3453769385814667,
0.12259019166231155,
-0.5047078728675842
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.12025v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.12025v1
|
A Toolbox for Surfacing Health Equity Harms and Biases in Large Language Models
| 2024-03-18T17:56:37 | 2024-03-18T17:56:37 |
Stephen R. Pfohl, Heather Cole-Lewis, Rory Sayres, Darlene Neal, Mercy Asiedu, Awa Dieng, Nenad Tomasev, Qazi Mamunur Rashid, Shekoofeh Azizi, Negar Rostamzadeh, Liam G. McCoy, Leo Anthony Celi, Yun Liu, Mike Schaekermann, Alanna Walton, Alicia Parrish, Chirag Nagpal, Preeti Singh, Akeiylah Dewitt, Philip Mansfield, Sushant Prakash, Katherine Heller, Alan Karthikesalingam, Christopher Semturs, Joelle Barral, Greg Corrado, Yossi Matias, Jamila Smith-Loud, Ivor Horn, Karan Singhal
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) hold immense promise to serve complex health
information needs but also have the potential to introduce harm and exacerbate
health disparities. Reliably evaluating equity-related model failures is a
critical step toward developing systems that promote health equity. In this
work, we present resources and methodologies for surfacing biases with
potential to precipitate equity-related harms in long-form, LLM-generated
answers to medical questions and then conduct an empirical case study with
Med-PaLM 2, resulting in the largest human evaluation study in this area to
date. Our contributions include a multifactorial framework for human assessment
of LLM-generated answers for biases, and EquityMedQA, a collection of seven
newly-released datasets comprising both manually-curated and LLM-generated
questions enriched for adversarial queries. Both our human assessment framework
and dataset design process are grounded in an iterative participatory approach
and review of possible biases in Med-PaLM 2 answers to adversarial queries.
Through our empirical study, we find that the use of a collection of datasets
curated through a variety of methodologies, coupled with a thorough evaluation
protocol that leverages multiple assessment rubric designs and diverse rater
groups, surfaces biases that may be missed via narrower evaluation approaches.
Our experience underscores the importance of using diverse assessment
methodologies and involving raters of varying backgrounds and expertise. We
emphasize that while our framework can identify specific forms of bias, it is
not sufficient to holistically assess whether the deployment of an AI system
promotes equitable health outcomes. We hope the broader community leverages and
builds on these tools and methods towards realizing a shared goal of LLMs that
promote accessible and equitable healthcare for all.
|
[
-0.1548672467470169,
-0.65175861120224,
0.5775724649429321,
0.14856019616127014,
0.16205057501792908,
0.17347636818885803,
-0.0038800016045570374,
-0.43687209486961365,
0.16795389354228973,
0.37805500626564026,
-0.354606956243515,
-0.38011807203292847,
-0.7981043457984924,
-0.2729317247867584,
-0.1021314263343811,
1.1594666242599487,
-0.005014814902096987,
0.386608749628067,
-0.1248161643743515,
-0.1647183746099472,
-0.4922316074371338,
-0.5055054426193237,
-0.6256266236305237,
-0.2030089944601059,
0.7280502915382385,
0.38714614510536194,
1.0245896577835083,
0.47903311252593994,
0.4723021686077118,
0.18838083744049072,
-0.20590423047542572,
-0.08576849848031998,
-0.48320531845092773,
0.10183483362197876,
-0.08270628750324249,
-0.5289389491081238,
-0.6431807279586792,
0.2251976728439331,
0.40772321820259094,
1.0640147924423218,
-0.1270763874053955,
0.49609294533729553,
0.2693435251712799,
0.7308809757232666,
-0.9573681354522705,
-0.0959557443857193,
-0.2841997742652893,
0.4052661657333374,
-0.3602585196495056,
-0.0482369065284729,
-0.09774190932512283,
-0.4197337031364441,
0.0804850310087204,
-0.32351794838905334,
-0.06933201104402542,
0.022643499076366425,
0.5011096000671387,
0.4166291654109955,
-0.74688720703125,
-0.3847232162952423,
-0.34876564145088196,
0.8660047650337219,
-0.5805295705795288,
0.24135802686214447,
0.37464067339897156,
0.40434685349464417,
-0.3293401598930359,
-0.4699237048625946,
-0.4331217408180237,
-0.011827201582491398,
0.014501544646918774,
0.18394623696804047,
-0.17995160818099976,
0.043328605592250824,
0.2589135766029358,
0.2910156846046448,
-0.4989595413208008,
0.38655897974967957,
-0.3226095139980316,
-0.33008596301078796,
0.749824583530426,
0.30184003710746765,
0.4626772403717041,
-0.2682946026325226,
-0.08572541922330856,
-0.1967947781085968,
-0.9463992118835449,
0.0952545627951622,
0.566149115562439,
0.04264521598815918,
-0.32218077778816223,
0.7308589220046997,
0.33544138073921204,
0.45975568890571594,
-0.35029542446136475,
-0.21030069887638092,
0.3135431408882141,
-0.08427391946315765,
-0.26091471314430237,
0.003843240672722459,
0.7026180028915405,
0.7395884394645691,
0.18296660482883453,
-0.036541420966386795,
-0.07609490305185318,
-0.19060824811458588,
0.2201341837644577,
-0.6956843137741089,
0.056255463510751724,
0.47132161259651184,
-0.595103919506073,
-0.19082266092300415,
-0.07156148552894592,
-1.0757826566696167,
-0.9670308232307434,
-0.07778412103652954,
0.16434641182422638,
0.10523136705160141,
-0.15783344209194183,
-0.00041654318920336664,
-0.09979084134101868,
0.1645365208387375,
0.30534330010414124,
-0.45220574736595154,
0.313592791557312,
0.7563815116882324,
0.6248332262039185,
-0.08198235183954239,
0.02400493621826172,
-0.41564664244651794,
-0.11580349504947662,
-0.3285946249961853,
0.33863458037376404,
-0.3194177746772766,
-0.5526279807090759,
0.08007903397083282,
-0.08831837773323059,
0.32603177428245544,
-0.7687341570854187,
0.7797865867614746,
-0.36392077803611755,
0.06992745399475098,
-0.6391076445579529,
-0.22191335260868073,
0.04194418340921402,
0.2193104773759842,
-0.6558495759963989,
0.5394682288169861,
0.071022629737854,
-0.9477289319038391,
0.522441029548645,
-0.8294748663902283,
-0.5486974120140076,
-0.22273999452590942,
-0.41197460889816284,
-0.5978766083717346,
-0.0019693165086209774,
0.4218113422393799,
0.34449586272239685,
-0.679972767829895,
0.5211121439933777,
-0.5094320178031921,
-0.21927854418754578,
0.3709644079208374,
-0.8730149269104004,
1.0554306507110596,
0.1011207178235054,
-0.45062461495399475,
0.12184698134660721,
-0.41310086846351624,
-0.08964771777391434,
0.2965206205844879,
-0.18808884918689728,
-0.1375051587820053,
0.06801837682723999,
0.3033498227596283,
0.17321261763572693,
0.13280685245990753,
-0.32274171710014343,
-0.10694467276334763,
-0.4689335823059082,
0.22321149706840515,
1.0048025846481323,
0.021218035370111465,
0.3518325686454773,
-0.4045591354370117,
0.6523006558418274,
0.09675423055887222,
0.6245180368423462,
-0.10953531414270401,
-0.486873060464859,
-0.44402968883514404,
-0.2866245210170746,
0.27750810980796814,
0.4351477026939392,
-0.26480990648269653,
0.4382477104663849,
-0.2839473783969879,
-0.3247630000114441,
-0.8923087120056152,
0.10217251628637314,
0.47929301857948303,
0.567679226398468,
0.23928605020046234,
-0.5083923935890198,
-0.2508474588394165,
-1.2335736751556396,
-0.4772285521030426,
-0.09695602208375931,
-0.16329090297222137,
0.6749600172042847,
0.5057441592216492,
-0.2642207443714142,
0.7922292947769165,
-0.4001741409301758,
-0.2622038424015045,
0.14318019151687622,
0.04288299009203911,
0.06845343858003616,
0.34376004338264465,
0.396151602268219,
-0.6793586611747742,
-0.13260620832443237,
-0.2606063783168793,
-0.6813983917236328,
-0.23721790313720703,
0.15582828223705292,
-0.17119331657886505,
-0.24968108534812927,
0.046818993985652924,
-0.2971296012401581,
0.5293700695037842,
0.4811173677444458,
-0.19907815754413605,
0.27039188146591187,
0.119558185338974,
0.18378381431102753,
-0.989890456199646,
0.23585976660251617,
0.18818823993206024,
-0.04626711085438728,
-0.2906894087791443,
0.06025918200612068,
-0.10090657323598862,
-0.09862103313207626,
-0.40429726243019104,
0.8285228610038757,
-0.4044494926929474,
-0.4194362163543701,
-0.16948507726192474,
-0.1652631014585495,
0.006190502550452948,
0.11194199323654175,
-0.4850449562072754,
0.7437199354171753,
0.37142807245254517,
-0.18828019499778748,
0.03897003084421158,
-0.13731515407562256,
-0.24456334114074707,
0.4887082576751709,
-0.7227126955986023,
0.14912110567092896,
-0.30849549174308777,
0.42922624945640564,
-0.8095054626464844,
-0.36677286028862,
0.45800551772117615,
-0.2954874634742737,
0.2091660052537918,
-0.16323237121105194,
-0.6324346661567688,
-0.47795966267585754,
-0.6229175329208374,
0.6068764925003052,
0.37712785601615906,
-0.43805959820747375,
0.16648003458976746,
1.1501716375350952,
-0.43907639384269714,
-0.9803923964500427,
-0.5812135338783264,
0.23584654927253723,
-0.29033544659614563,
-0.5017799139022827,
-0.04239235073328018,
0.14273303747177124,
-0.5497481822967529,
-0.2862679958343506,
-0.11926251649856567,
-0.03263002261519432,
0.4454239010810852,
0.6092418432235718,
0.34313902258872986,
0.09728552401065826,
0.1430959701538086,
0.2868901491165161,
0.13743726909160614,
0.281925767660141,
0.18215972185134888,
0.3362555503845215,
0.07864011824131012,
-0.8635551333427429,
-0.12140920013189316,
0.5386366248130798,
0.6261913776397705,
-0.1344684213399887,
0.39558619260787964,
0.4763016700744629,
-0.5554883480072021,
0.24233898520469666,
-0.6188761591911316,
-0.15754434466362,
-0.35416480898857117,
0.7137439846992493,
0.08872487396001816,
-0.9748121500015259,
0.41399669647216797,
-0.05037018284201622,
0.39203235507011414,
0.2561589777469635,
0.8492928147315979,
-0.09246009588241577,
1.0083060264587402,
0.4348663091659546,
-0.4655476212501526,
-0.04399845004081726,
-0.10108685493469238,
0.2922532558441162,
-0.9088888168334961,
-0.25872671604156494,
-0.3105623722076416,
-0.4254860281944275,
-0.46523675322532654,
-0.7556731104850769,
0.8656705617904663,
-0.009437932632863522,
-0.4450337290763855,
-0.5330912470817566,
-0.3578304946422577,
0.2656671106815338,
0.18967081606388092,
0.3289344608783722,
0.07445777952671051,
-0.11737596243619919,
0.029610294848680496,
-0.2201937735080719,
-0.5633741617202759,
-0.6405026912689209,
1.5466938018798828,
0.9060620665550232,
0.782526969909668,
0.1397281438112259,
0.4197866916656494,
0.5088207125663757,
0.9186761975288391,
-0.7348557114601135,
0.1588057428598404,
0.09880587458610535,
-0.7989106774330139,
-0.38100799918174744,
-0.3947257101535797,
-1.1540225744247437,
0.25969046354293823,
-0.07164871692657471,
-0.6426486372947693,
0.18631786108016968,
0.12377078086137772,
-0.38454580307006836,
0.05301506072282791,
-0.552466094493866,
0.7952771782875061,
-0.5615076422691345,
-0.507120668888092,
-0.1044832319021225,
-0.8225630521774292,
0.4758726954460144,
-0.19036324322223663,
0.6345037817955017,
-0.24184761941432953,
-0.15412238240242004,
0.8199092745780945,
-0.3987765908241272,
0.9417895674705505,
-0.33614581823349,
-0.29616236686706543,
0.09542785584926605,
-0.1177525669336319,
0.011260062456130981,
0.20680612325668335,
-0.2535731792449951,
0.2752263844013214,
-0.31604015827178955,
-0.5643393397331238,
-0.5512024760246277,
0.650005578994751,
-0.9859812259674072,
-0.6114687919616699,
-0.5216968059539795,
-0.5460657477378845,
-0.4047059416770935,
0.0508696548640728,
-0.21469548344612122,
0.13930831849575043,
-0.31826868653297424,
-0.37719276547431946,
0.31678506731987,
-0.7288457751274109,
0.03770013526082039,
0.3620384931564331,
-0.15250302851200104,
-0.23391970992088318,
0.5776591897010803,
0.06550322473049164,
-0.08431830257177353,
-0.06434819847345352,
0.06952402740716934,
-0.22866275906562805,
-0.3908032774925232,
-0.4288138747215271,
0.030894121155142784,
-0.7053739428520203,
-0.3700959086418152,
-0.5709391832351685,
-0.13425377011299133,
-0.3924664258956909,
0.014285576529800892,
-0.17875827848911285,
0.04963028058409691,
-0.031188270077109337,
-0.14248673617839813,
0.016043955460190773,
0.7482742667198181,
-0.05562509596347809,
0.04313117265701294,
-0.5899351239204407,
0.28177136182785034,
0.25606900453567505,
0.12580512464046478,
0.2601141333580017,
-0.37698230147361755,
-0.08558661490678787,
0.22532297670841217,
-0.5260019302368164,
-1.0028293132781982,
0.30273887515068054,
-0.18633559346199036,
0.5907168984413147,
0.26765891909599304,
-0.04958590492606163,
0.6987752914428711,
-0.5904831886291504,
0.6979464888572693,
0.379820853471756,
-0.7063101530075073,
0.5005192756652832,
-0.10435546934604645,
0.02610498107969761,
0.6246612668037415,
0.4305018186569214,
-0.38968947529792786,
-0.2997664213180542,
-0.31575796008110046,
-1.2309437990188599,
0.2932887673377991,
-0.09988132864236832,
0.03214631974697113,
-0.1268715262413025,
0.31043630838394165,
0.08490477502346039,
0.20639334619045258,
-0.6616568565368652,
-0.3463405966758728,
0.08314117789268494,
-0.18833397328853607,
-0.07046856731176376,
-0.3164648413658142,
-0.48996034264564514,
0.02949264459311962,
0.3751988410949707,
-0.19761084020137787,
-0.006872142665088177,
0.21400655806064606,
-0.24059642851352692,
-0.14971759915351868,
0.6736639142036438,
0.18323880434036255,
0.5618079900741577,
-0.0736469030380249,
0.0947503000497818,
0.15205197036266327,
-0.38658955693244934,
0.2585224211215973,
0.21747484803199768,
0.12713228166103363,
-0.38264232873916626,
0.48193371295928955,
0.41639888286590576,
0.22987104952335358,
-0.9742720723152161,
0.8717594146728516,
0.05284324288368225,
0.26882046461105347,
-0.16929148137569427,
-0.31493598222732544,
0.018578603863716125,
0.06509419530630112,
0.2777647376060486,
-0.13766169548034668,
0.5963923931121826,
-0.7657181620597839,
0.18882820010185242,
0.48423242568969727,
-0.5153404474258423,
0.022638913244009018,
0.4402673840522766,
0.22166414558887482,
0.016896666958928108,
0.5055210590362549,
0.12828393280506134,
-0.4280376434326172,
0.6534641981124878,
0.11720588058233261,
0.6388916373252869,
-0.14649976789951324,
0.03681831806898117,
0.10762593895196915,
0.4846353530883789,
0.05322790518403053,
0.2187381237745285,
0.245902881026268,
-0.5325201749801636,
-0.4687035381793976,
-0.5807511210441589,
-0.37060728669166565,
0.028685150668025017,
-0.7429257035255432,
-0.02027166076004505,
-0.4271155893802643,
-0.4848029315471649,
-0.009713631123304367,
0.011354159563779831,
-0.845151424407959,
0.2070370614528656,
0.31489038467407227,
0.8518330454826355,
-1.0362130403518677,
0.3559063971042633,
0.6334362626075745,
-0.4320700466632843,
-0.7398354411125183,
0.4375399649143219,
0.4028661847114563,
-1.1288152933120728,
0.8513266444206238,
0.05535391718149185,
0.10067591816186905,
-0.6245585083961487,
-0.3917960524559021,
-0.49799302220344543,
1.0272445678710938,
0.7005667686462402,
-0.6834233999252319,
0.09304745495319366,
0.3500887155532837,
0.5346795320510864,
-0.07964815944433212,
0.6607394218444824,
0.604131281375885,
0.6136636137962341,
-0.3141908347606659,
-1.2789279222488403,
0.19706016778945923,
-0.18083937466144562,
0.020193595439195633,
-0.06936551630496979,
-0.5840892791748047,
0.7454502582550049,
-0.4373721480369568,
-0.1103142574429512,
-0.02939113974571228,
0.34553995728492737,
0.41194647550582886,
0.37973347306251526,
0.43806615471839905,
0.7332203388214111,
0.9327566623687744,
0.04214265197515488,
1.370637059211731,
-0.13473336398601532,
0.2731465697288513,
0.8967358469963074,
-0.5756774544715881,
0.4840587079524994,
0.5505708456039429,
-0.5584073066711426,
-0.005839651916176081,
0.5927056670188904,
0.3449239730834961,
0.20464427769184113,
0.9981063008308411,
-0.28325679898262024,
0.15024493634700775,
-0.5045706033706665,
-0.2690735161304474,
0.2322435975074768,
0.37549445033073425,
-0.41972845792770386,
-0.2551313638687134,
0.051486026495695114,
0.39695242047309875,
-0.03985071927309036,
-0.37956640124320984,
0.5225297808647156,
0.20469899475574493,
-0.47741222381591797,
0.10330169647932053,
0.22878557443618774,
0.7751225829124451,
-0.20976291596889496,
-0.21818317472934723,
-0.23117905855178833,
-0.10228993743658066,
-0.2570565640926361,
-1.0002497434616089,
0.09271902590990067,
0.1027536541223526,
-0.24735116958618164,
0.0387515090405941,
0.564423143863678,
-0.0700509175658226,
-0.5509204864501953,
0.41085976362228394,
0.7755827307701111,
0.25266003608703613,
0.05893890559673309,
-1.0258269309997559,
0.37143221497535706,
-0.24210476875305176,
-0.16585972905158997,
0.6759355664253235,
0.22507184743881226,
-0.14942260086536407,
0.5665149688720703,
0.5748719573020935,
0.2607162594795227,
-0.08444582670927048,
0.3615606725215912,
0.7492532134056091,
-0.35786575078964233,
-0.17808997631072998,
-0.8845452070236206,
0.34895649552345276,
-0.26593878865242004,
-0.18866191804409027,
0.644676148891449,
0.7015643119812012,
0.3812532424926758,
0.27829962968826294,
1.034555435180664,
0.13341672718524933,
0.42194685339927673,
-0.3027399182319641,
0.9019135236740112,
-0.6289973855018616,
0.4978303015232086,
-0.28808775544166565,
-0.6424050331115723,
-0.37189021706581116,
0.5565668344497681,
-0.32023850083351135,
0.37542349100112915,
0.22037574648857117,
0.7782148718833923,
0.1599200814962387,
-0.24301554262638092,
0.13580895960330963,
0.3642195165157318,
0.44125500321388245,
0.5987224578857422,
0.7661089897155762,
-0.44710084795951843,
0.08692756295204163,
0.11275670677423477,
-0.6058818697929382,
-0.15751038491725922,
-0.687361478805542,
-0.6811899542808533,
-0.19347597658634186,
-0.1845514327287674,
-0.5318256616592407,
0.5722683072090149,
1.0888779163360596,
0.6658952832221985,
-0.5909230709075928,
-0.2782308757305145,
0.5125540494918823,
0.371446430683136,
0.3531585931777954,
-0.2580084204673767,
0.6161337494850159,
0.03471820801496506,
-0.5464909076690674,
0.018498245626688004,
0.4983316659927368,
-0.19832979142665863,
-0.5573127865791321,
-0.037157487124204636,
0.36660173535346985,
-0.1316068172454834,
0.4885961413383484,
0.23547793924808502,
-0.6781477332115173,
-0.1892075538635254,
-0.271557480096817,
-0.3081786036491394,
-0.006806991063058376,
0.7939102649688721,
-0.5526335835456848,
0.24437235295772552,
-0.009009834378957748,
0.8409949541091919,
-0.20242613554000854,
-0.3959628939628601,
0.6748966574668884,
-0.508671760559082,
-0.08901756256818771,
0.5500258803367615,
0.6604814529418945,
0.409839004278183,
-0.4133571982383728,
0.31239110231399536,
-0.1969054639339447,
-0.47403672337532043,
-0.9216585159301758,
0.1500651091337204,
-0.8336164355278015,
-0.30942752957344055,
1.1439125537872314,
-0.21780480444431305,
-0.14949995279312134,
-0.24140556156635284,
-0.3691169023513794,
0.20629604160785675,
-0.33932432532310486,
0.8929988741874695,
0.6357465386390686,
0.013670718297362328,
0.13631023466587067,
-0.6556158065795898,
0.2584887146949768,
0.46175336837768555,
-1.0196127891540527,
0.22837264835834503,
0.5636790990829468,
0.38737937808036804,
-0.08206809312105179,
0.9067455530166626,
-0.6448800563812256,
0.39287227392196655,
-0.31712862849235535,
0.19609132409095764,
0.285248726606369,
-0.13154835999011993,
-0.4379543960094452,
0.1905648410320282,
0.17092512547969818,
0.23753628134727478
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.12024v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.12024v2
|
Enhancing Taiwanese Hokkien Dual Translation by Exploring and Standardizing of Four Writing Systems
| 2024-03-18T17:56:13 | 2024-05-14T05:49:00 |
Bo-Han Lu, Yi-Hsuan Lin, En-Shiun Annie Lee, Richard Tzong-Han Tsai
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Machine translation focuses mainly on high-resource languages (HRLs), while
low-resource languages (LRLs) like Taiwanese Hokkien are relatively
under-explored. The study aims to address this gap by developing a dual
translation model between Taiwanese Hokkien and both Traditional Mandarin
Chinese and English. We employ a pre-trained LLaMA 2-7B model specialized in
Traditional Mandarin Chinese to leverage the orthographic similarities between
Taiwanese Hokkien Han and Traditional Mandarin Chinese. Our comprehensive
experiments involve translation tasks across various writing systems of
Taiwanese Hokkien as well as between Taiwanese Hokkien and other HRLs. We find
that the use of a limited monolingual corpus still further improves the model's
Taiwanese Hokkien capabilities. We then utilize our translation model to
standardize all Taiwanese Hokkien writing systems into Hokkien Han, resulting
in further performance improvements. Additionally, we introduce an evaluation
method incorporating back-translation and GPT-4 to ensure reliable translation
quality assessment even for LRLs. The study contributes to narrowing the
resource gap for Taiwanese Hokkien and empirically investigates the advantages
and limitations of pre-training and fine-tuning based on LLaMA 2.
|
[
0.04926460608839989,
-0.733761727809906,
0.24884378910064697,
0.27830836176872253,
-0.8441469073295593,
0.4403058886528015,
-0.5724571943283081,
-0.6943862438201904,
0.1570095419883728,
0.831013023853302,
-0.003273364156484604,
-0.49382928013801575,
-0.5620318055152893,
0.4076058268547058,
0.2963312268257141,
0.8973451852798462,
-0.5363948345184326,
0.13073831796646118,
0.5093743205070496,
-0.49482059478759766,
-0.657677173614502,
-0.4544992744922638,
-0.6600354909896851,
-0.338501900434494,
0.6509098410606384,
0.3648114502429962,
0.7647082805633545,
0.5996308326721191,
0.6759157776832581,
0.1900830864906311,
-0.13912761211395264,
0.4477706849575043,
-0.6420938372612,
-0.09519586712121964,
0.24034041166305542,
-0.21576885879039764,
-0.8525633215904236,
-0.11559479683637619,
0.8599805235862732,
0.4533369243144989,
0.002805916126817465,
0.40312597155570984,
0.5572561621665955,
0.24382534623146057,
-0.4451904296875,
0.16931672394275665,
-0.3413860499858856,
0.20925898849964142,
-0.5024905800819397,
-0.02755207195878029,
-0.4657454788684845,
-0.42214301228523254,
-0.08818185329437256,
-0.8561137318611145,
-0.1931740939617157,
-0.005447941366583109,
0.8749372959136963,
0.21847690641880035,
-1.0721726417541504,
0.08217525482177734,
-0.5526360869407654,
0.8013688921928406,
-0.7915406823158264,
0.49333858489990234,
0.06770825386047363,
0.14845633506774902,
0.08329189568758011,
-0.6353349685668945,
-0.6101996302604675,
-0.3258129954338074,
-0.4064893126487732,
0.20716619491577148,
0.21014665067195892,
0.24614658951759338,
0.17895276844501495,
0.4566858112812042,
-0.7039135694503784,
0.25887203216552734,
-0.41775789856910706,
-0.13852311670780182,
0.5371496081352234,
0.09399215131998062,
0.41641148924827576,
-0.36141514778137207,
-0.348201185464859,
-0.19339409470558167,
-0.553562343120575,
0.10654585808515549,
0.13250409066677094,
0.32403993606567383,
-0.27696493268013,
0.5843174457550049,
0.34861016273498535,
0.5031686425209045,
0.0582222044467926,
-0.3130725026130676,
0.29339876770973206,
-0.7250179052352905,
-0.34561458230018616,
0.23982150852680206,
0.8068934679031372,
0.4643787145614624,
0.06755303591489792,
-0.023510433733463287,
-0.294140100479126,
-0.15757890045642853,
-0.057730916887521744,
-0.6426445841789246,
0.23357930779457092,
-0.3014001250267029,
-0.5927239656448364,
-0.2945207357406616,
-0.33418041467666626,
-0.5136979222297668,
-0.3610759675502777,
-0.20005600154399872,
0.3047676682472229,
-0.3815838694572449,
-0.7402357459068298,
0.08484360575675964,
-0.09019850939512253,
0.4131948947906494,
0.1926221400499344,
-0.8072298765182495,
0.26917150616645813,
0.41223978996276855,
0.9558534622192383,
-0.28284022212028503,
-0.6227590441703796,
-0.2095913290977478,
0.5147262215614319,
-0.544294536113739,
0.4637683629989624,
-0.1833249181509018,
-0.6557638049125671,
-0.21621467173099518,
0.05419209226965904,
0.05644112825393677,
-0.5109257698059082,
0.5730550289154053,
-0.439866840839386,
0.09409468621015549,
-0.34850436449050903,
0.01836324855685234,
-0.21719294786453247,
0.07422313839197159,
-0.8737118244171143,
1.3486061096191406,
0.3627054989337921,
-0.8025674819946289,
0.2243659645318985,
-0.5743332505226135,
-0.8106639981269836,
0.11008536070585251,
0.12414087355136871,
-0.3525138795375824,
0.23859532177448273,
0.015117918141186237,
0.14029091596603394,
-0.2901577949523926,
0.3854058086872101,
-0.08970525115728378,
-0.5945743322372437,
-0.30321770906448364,
-0.48334789276123047,
1.1022861003875732,
0.1951226443052292,
-0.39156052470207214,
0.049474917352199554,
-0.30503323674201965,
0.0357351116836071,
0.2892470955848694,
-0.8435513377189636,
-0.47399720549583435,
-0.745451807975769,
0.25226491689682007,
0.004342526663094759,
0.6438093781471252,
-0.5661860704421997,
0.25008946657180786,
-0.3059288561344147,
0.56235671043396,
0.7015767097473145,
-0.3479979634284973,
0.5790866017341614,
-0.08578188717365265,
0.44290289282798767,
0.12676052749156952,
0.03466305136680603,
0.03121882677078247,
-0.47681766748428345,
-0.6494317054748535,
0.071170374751091,
0.43599796295166016,
0.7440335750579834,
-0.7177301645278931,
0.2845276892185211,
-0.4129972457885742,
-0.205582857131958,
-1.0002650022506714,
0.275885671377182,
0.5472245216369629,
0.51821368932724,
0.3650645911693573,
-0.5230121612548828,
-0.6981568336486816,
-0.7252777814865112,
-0.22511433064937592,
-0.2942560017108917,
0.1677737832069397,
0.08939589560031891,
-0.005717850290238857,
-0.22598904371261597,
0.1838497668504715,
-0.04157732427120209,
-0.12529005110263824,
-0.4250490069389343,
-0.01840836927294731,
0.22409769892692566,
0.4132585823535919,
0.397901326417923,
-0.6187406778335571,
-1.0256484746932983,
0.5061748623847961,
-0.8871598839759827,
0.07145757228136063,
0.06744126230478287,
-0.4553323984146118,
0.4198351800441742,
0.253871351480484,
-0.673426628112793,
0.4942754805088043,
0.8009722232818604,
-0.16360461711883545,
0.4840879738330841,
-0.518047034740448,
0.32561689615249634,
-1.0611679553985596,
0.04616011306643486,
-0.4110194444656372,
-0.25445497035980225,
-0.5755152702331543,
0.20619720220565796,
0.2571345567703247,
-0.3024894893169403,
-0.25147032737731934,
0.6971290707588196,
-0.682824969291687,
0.02204744890332222,
-0.2122448980808258,
0.16506370902061462,
0.11786249279975891,
0.4784293472766876,
0.3022478222846985,
0.8506115078926086,
-0.023035960271954536,
-0.30665379762649536,
0.36650097370147705,
0.07030695676803589,
-0.015779439359903336,
0.3338298499584198,
-0.694216787815094,
0.3599011301994324,
0.13611119985580444,
0.27407190203666687,
-0.7226131558418274,
-0.031243255361914635,
0.3382706642150879,
-0.0933234766125679,
0.5116389989852905,
0.1471855491399765,
-0.4766467809677124,
-0.4265303313732147,
-0.2795787453651428,
0.5552960634231567,
0.5743354558944702,
-0.3248426020145416,
0.519232988357544,
0.42588818073272705,
-0.20566977560520172,
-0.48330652713775635,
-0.7886288166046143,
0.33547642827033997,
-0.2654584050178528,
-0.664628267288208,
0.5544771552085876,
0.0949694886803627,
-0.04022404924035072,
-0.017125776037573814,
0.032339178025722504,
-0.090836301445961,
-0.09171560406684875,
-0.20921878516674042,
0.40233850479125977,
-0.7610489726066589,
-0.018953127786517143,
0.38845953345298767,
-0.07362618297338486,
-0.3194935917854309,
-0.5111237168312073,
0.3310565650463104,
-0.26227352023124695,
-0.05580801144242287,
-0.405380517244339,
0.31705206632614136,
0.4383106529712677,
-0.4938031733036041,
0.601494312286377,
0.8024789690971375,
-0.33982160687446594,
0.2511804401874542,
-0.6623218655586243,
-0.08373475074768066,
-0.43797340989112854,
0.41510140895843506,
-0.6820117831230164,
-0.8678221106529236,
0.24908876419067383,
0.051281996071338654,
0.2159990519285202,
0.21599918603897095,
0.5516718029975891,
-0.006378043442964554,
0.8825876712799072,
0.8461300134658813,
-0.09765852242708206,
0.4217776954174042,
-0.08879464119672775,
0.36105450987815857,
-0.9022871851921082,
0.1057841032743454,
-0.004789063706994057,
-0.464952677488327,
-1.0006804466247559,
-0.5891369581222534,
0.4903223514556885,
0.2657967805862427,
-0.29868289828300476,
0.6979023218154907,
-0.6831216812133789,
0.47446492314338684,
0.7303569316864014,
0.1818356215953827,
0.6397217512130737,
0.06037013232707977,
-0.2983331084251404,
-0.06580495834350586,
-0.5239084959030151,
-0.9542179107666016,
1.1924728155136108,
0.29108357429504395,
0.32980018854141235,
0.07338732481002808,
0.8248609304428101,
-0.030775491148233414,
0.27968382835388184,
-0.33871880173683167,
0.35658031702041626,
-0.5542106032371521,
-0.5896397233009338,
-0.6822191476821899,
-0.3169873356819153,
-0.7421810030937195,
0.4054892063140869,
0.1513044238090515,
-0.14749771356582642,
-0.21526393294334412,
0.29112616181373596,
-0.32049334049224854,
0.4747380018234253,
-0.8493347764015198,
1.12660551071167,
-0.6713571548461914,
-0.3532785177230835,
-0.39886173605918884,
-0.6717991828918457,
0.425927996635437,
-0.0766255185008049,
-0.012654741294682026,
-0.026752501726150513,
-0.12869855761528015,
0.5597512125968933,
-0.06100357323884964,
0.8201122283935547,
-0.06325589120388031,
-0.26953059434890747,
0.5418945550918579,
0.12465010583400726,
0.42119163274765015,
0.2239437699317932,
-0.21171389520168304,
0.46383988857269287,
0.1442745327949524,
-0.5949767231941223,
-0.3302789330482483,
0.4296649992465973,
-0.9612642526626587,
-0.7395333051681519,
-0.2568090856075287,
-0.5140482783317566,
0.08529078215360641,
0.5786644816398621,
0.37568965554237366,
-0.3094823360443115,
-0.29069584608078003,
-0.23931646347045898,
0.5864510536193848,
-0.1668112576007843,
0.2505892813205719,
0.5916982889175415,
-0.06634820252656937,
-0.5167534947395325,
0.6103236675262451,
0.1747387945652008,
0.2455221265554428,
0.33325764536857605,
0.3320769667625427,
-0.2527521550655365,
-0.2954263985157013,
-0.9173087477684021,
0.5837563276290894,
-0.509371280670166,
-0.027399452403187752,
-0.32361117005348206,
-0.2957597076892853,
-0.8437989354133606,
-0.09539967775344849,
-0.18397773802280426,
-0.549340546131134,
-0.2936267852783203,
-0.19502615928649902,
-0.02195977233350277,
0.7663800120353699,
-0.09761209040880203,
0.31709855794906616,
-0.8119902610778809,
0.25235745310783386,
0.2168763130903244,
0.08817677199840546,
-0.04245330020785332,
-0.8016512989997864,
-0.3557875156402588,
0.13893739879131317,
-0.6318867206573486,
-0.9366054534912109,
0.22446498274803162,
-0.11641945689916611,
0.3846696615219116,
0.09573885053396225,
-0.24238187074661255,
0.8729018568992615,
-0.6969461441040039,
0.6807947754859924,
0.2191181480884552,
-1.025817632675171,
0.4797267019748688,
-0.3666748106479645,
0.25227877497673035,
0.34521904587745667,
0.0774545669555664,
-1.0035171508789062,
-0.2823462188243866,
-0.3022901117801666,
-0.4597219228744507,
0.46701714396476746,
0.04439637064933777,
0.25632569193840027,
0.35003861784935,
0.4922497272491455,
0.1777316927909851,
0.27345892786979675,
-1.1024657487869263,
0.18947376310825348,
-0.4992212653160095,
-0.18143898248672485,
-0.3069039285182953,
-0.25357335805892944,
0.1811525821685791,
-0.15950395166873932,
0.5770197510719299,
0.0036440780386328697,
-0.0057578785344958305,
-0.006891356315463781,
-0.13548174500465393,
-0.2733657658100128,
0.28376883268356323,
0.39321231842041016,
0.26194044947624207,
-0.08092977851629257,
0.29577964544296265,
0.7557755708694458,
-0.684767484664917,
0.28485971689224243,
-0.07792975753545761,
-0.2546211779117584,
0.21965909004211426,
0.5136984586715698,
0.7820785045623779,
0.051689330488443375,
-0.3208746016025543,
0.11764874309301376,
0.23253533244132996,
0.25765177607536316,
-0.034978121519088745,
-0.2402312308549881,
0.29102271795272827,
0.03693699091672897,
-0.35950151085853577,
-0.26655855774879456,
-0.07143198698759079,
-0.4836990237236023,
-0.28764909505844116,
0.10020638257265091,
-0.3851509094238281,
-0.7346559762954712,
0.5904045701026917,
0.3746841847896576,
-0.26754382252693176,
0.6728512048721313,
-0.3849080502986908,
-0.46425122022628784,
0.3905617296695709,
0.9246540069580078,
0.7292461395263672,
-0.6309505105018616,
0.1479451209306717,
0.45830339193344116,
0.5930962562561035,
-0.14107103645801544,
0.4580354690551758,
-0.06954578310251236,
-0.5676041841506958,
-0.32661178708076477,
-0.5464739203453064,
-0.2114674597978592,
0.07681474089622498,
-0.5584878325462341,
0.7585132718086243,
-0.19430002570152283,
-0.47032415866851807,
-0.5155045986175537,
0.16445550322532654,
-0.5876144170761108,
-0.16716255247592926,
0.21317821741104126,
0.6221733689308167,
-0.5660263895988464,
1.2049241065979004,
0.9747765064239502,
-0.5241784453392029,
-1.019555926322937,
-0.227683886885643,
-0.21608832478523254,
-0.9400455355644226,
0.7552356719970703,
-0.0016214041970670223,
-0.20781470835208893,
0.0867510512471199,
-0.0012822321150451899,
-0.8298453092575073,
1.2631467580795288,
0.5346305966377258,
-0.5844595432281494,
-0.7790915369987488,
0.4047508239746094,
0.6870440244674683,
-0.12737634778022766,
0.06703749299049377,
0.7447336316108704,
0.5910223722457886,
-0.4356059432029724,
-1.5020110607147217,
0.07313860207796097,
-0.08816593140363693,
0.37841859459877014,
0.28473687171936035,
-1.0096168518066406,
0.8103970289230347,
-0.2590935230255127,
-0.29956960678100586,
0.010815931484103203,
0.6017619371414185,
0.2582553029060364,
0.3115110397338867,
0.2977222800254822,
0.5410503149032593,
0.8998230695724487,
0.21131497621536255,
0.6141379475593567,
-0.32793450355529785,
0.12345822900533676,
1.0005927085876465,
-0.702418863773346,
0.8664495944976807,
0.6191869974136353,
-0.06839524209499359,
0.5066044330596924,
0.7224247455596924,
0.2555058002471924,
0.3923054039478302,
0.04668186977505684,
-0.35453858971595764,
-0.24045433104038239,
-0.3593291938304901,
-0.34077414870262146,
0.2727692127227783,
0.24648481607437134,
-0.16143997013568878,
-0.009688847698271275,
0.2493029087781906,
0.14395923912525177,
0.04755197465419769,
-0.05349932983517647,
0.6094032526016235,
0.41631993651390076,
-0.7067159414291382,
0.9464138150215149,
0.2478039413690567,
0.6487331390380859,
-0.3679271936416626,
0.049784742295742035,
-0.30331704020500183,
0.10896950215101242,
-0.002408422762528062,
-0.6695048809051514,
0.29980117082595825,
0.06254804134368896,
0.07073195278644562,
-0.5371197462081909,
0.6890183687210083,
-0.4848736822605133,
-0.4586819112300873,
0.494681715965271,
0.43167582154273987,
0.05436355993151665,
0.3146294951438904,
-0.5822826027870178,
-0.015162124298512936,
0.08449456095695496,
-0.12499178200960159,
0.14986415207386017,
0.7653533816337585,
-0.3652209937572479,
0.11431041359901428,
0.30391374230384827,
0.34354621171951294,
0.13511346280574799,
-0.11300741881132126,
0.6656074523925781,
-0.6081904172897339,
-0.5528976917266846,
-0.7823551297187805,
0.338723361492157,
0.05101453885436058,
-0.4268125593662262,
0.7531929612159729,
0.7739874124526978,
0.9380664229393005,
-0.036964353173971176,
0.8963980674743652,
0.2319655418395996,
0.44656917452812195,
-0.5494709610939026,
0.6662596464157104,
-0.523012638092041,
0.13526472449302673,
0.04093209281563759,
-0.7596526741981506,
-0.10481943935155869,
0.477695107460022,
-0.24957938492298126,
-0.22644637525081635,
0.8540502190589905,
0.6757491230964661,
-0.2835710644721985,
-0.059765662997961044,
0.4128485918045044,
0.13983094692230225,
0.06915844231843948,
0.8710229396820068,
0.7959820032119751,
-0.5811094045639038,
0.9284982681274414,
-0.45574626326560974,
-0.2896448075771332,
-0.024571113288402557,
-0.755945086479187,
-0.9956212043762207,
-0.3163951337337494,
-0.12976416945457458,
-0.47738900780677795,
0.25603345036506653,
0.5415084362030029,
0.5022693276405334,
-0.7130325436592102,
-0.787534236907959,
0.24280917644500732,
0.16368918120861053,
-0.19616244733333588,
-0.14305494725704193,
0.48302456736564636,
-0.234699547290802,
-0.6563142538070679,
0.20512408018112183,
0.5207685232162476,
0.4098801016807556,
-0.2132166475057602,
-0.19442103803157806,
0.22885161638259888,
-0.09591396898031235,
0.6744714379310608,
-0.02801717072725296,
-0.8818661570549011,
-0.04529614746570587,
0.5302881598472595,
-0.539002537727356,
0.3610506057739258,
1.0076255798339844,
-0.41127675771713257,
0.1930326521396637,
0.46635186672210693,
0.4887326657772064,
0.5177076458930969,
-0.2765444815158844,
0.5303546786308289,
-0.5325594544410706,
0.33282214403152466,
0.22382299602031708,
0.21028147637844086,
0.37192302942276,
-0.5785912275314331,
0.5280902981758118,
0.2042526751756668,
-0.5065010786056519,
-0.8235728144645691,
0.2855013608932495,
-0.5619979500770569,
-0.05383753776550293,
1.0910513401031494,
-0.18045863509178162,
-0.1942097246646881,
-0.06575464457273483,
-0.4059503674507141,
0.7898730635643005,
-0.18863937258720398,
0.5844475626945496,
0.7365255355834961,
0.09768602252006531,
-0.00952388159930706,
-0.5736807584762573,
0.3838018476963043,
0.4605155885219574,
-0.5843008756637573,
0.19726087152957916,
0.19551445543766022,
0.19179140031337738,
0.11990351229906082,
0.9873520135879517,
-0.07513941824436188,
0.48162421584129333,
-0.08772394806146622,
0.14251737296581268,
0.0905645489692688,
0.03357778862118721,
-0.2954999804496765,
-0.38215532898902893,
0.29067370295524597,
0.01949610933661461
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.12017v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.12017v1
|
Supervised Fine-Tuning as Inverse Reinforcement Learning
| 2024-03-18T17:52:57 | 2024-03-18T17:52:57 |
Hao Sun
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
The prevailing approach to aligning Large Language Models (LLMs) typically
relies on human or AI feedback and assumes access to specific types of
preference datasets. In our work, we question the efficacy of such datasets and
explore various scenarios where alignment with expert demonstrations proves
more realistic. We build a sequential decision-making framework to formulate
the problem of aligning LLMs using demonstration datasets. Drawing insights
from inverse reinforcement learning and imitation learning, we introduce
various approaches for divergence minimization in the LLM alignment tasks. Our
analysis highlights the mass-covering and mode-seeking behaviors of these
different approaches. Inclusively, we examine the pros and cons of the
classical supervised fine-tuning method, elaborating on scenarios where
different methods shine.
|
[
-0.5531153678894043,
-0.9275641441345215,
0.55510014295578,
-0.1709635704755783,
-0.03015008196234703,
-0.07612677663564682,
-0.5148352384567261,
-0.08210903406143188,
-0.01848847232758999,
0.5581096410751343,
-0.9497568011283875,
-0.40914466977119446,
-0.4499166011810303,
0.05248909443616867,
-0.2335796356201172,
0.8875254392623901,
-0.3466973304748535,
0.07970146834850311,
-0.28455716371536255,
-0.15709485113620758,
-0.5016659498214722,
0.08111099898815155,
-0.8359007239341736,
-0.3729315400123596,
0.48871883749961853,
0.9885848760604858,
0.9184392094612122,
1.1147780418395996,
0.2681732475757599,
0.35085293650627136,
0.1624564528465271,
0.5982093811035156,
-0.6552851796150208,
-0.02187301218509674,
-0.23905375599861145,
-0.5927177667617798,
-0.059280525892972946,
0.26939478516578674,
0.630427360534668,
0.734955370426178,
-0.0798228532075882,
-0.07161440700292587,
0.061156682670116425,
0.7747596502304077,
-0.682927668094635,
-0.14898917078971863,
-0.49174150824546814,
0.07246282696723938,
0.03238144516944885,
-0.1234607845544815,
-0.205778568983078,
-0.3811756670475006,
0.12052180618047714,
-0.689136803150177,
0.017521599307656288,
0.3386826515197754,
0.8554784059524536,
0.6076202988624573,
-0.47617706656455994,
-0.16340434551239014,
-0.803726315498352,
1.0747896432876587,
-0.6925094127655029,
0.34967753291130066,
0.5450491905212402,
0.3045906722545624,
-0.26070016622543335,
-0.19573865830898285,
-0.5251783728599548,
-0.19002126157283783,
-0.22372892498970032,
0.07080032676458359,
0.06804131716489792,
0.11053246259689331,
0.29862162470817566,
0.37271276116371155,
-0.5449752807617188,
1.001046895980835,
-0.03296441584825516,
-0.0029959415551275015,
0.7623871564865112,
0.40035101771354675,
0.05438151955604553,
0.4681502878665924,
-0.25817635655403137,
-0.21344216167926788,
-0.9593555927276611,
0.13589416444301605,
0.8103029131889343,
0.5626490712165833,
-0.00869174674153328,
0.8627107739448547,
-0.48067665100097656,
0.9675282835960388,
0.4538695812225342,
-0.13306252658367157,
-0.07312888652086258,
-0.18758989870548248,
-0.3778356909751892,
0.2448122650384903,
0.6897914409637451,
0.42913827300071716,
0.23915737867355347,
0.007281132508069277,
-0.28257474303245544,
-0.2993452847003937,
0.19562911987304688,
-0.5256919264793396,
-0.13299134373664856,
0.16268794238567352,
-0.27867433428764343,
-0.37721338868141174,
0.13173505663871765,
-0.5312296748161316,
-0.5251466035842896,
-1.0851736068725586,
0.5935153961181641,
-0.1739848405122757,
0.011380662210285664,
0.2586241364479065,
-0.07312479615211487,
0.23991458117961884,
0.3465767502784729,
-1.1388890743255615,
0.44108736515045166,
0.8960512280464172,
0.5776546001434326,
-0.2124876230955124,
-0.263950377702713,
-0.6174474954605103,
0.1819605529308319,
-0.5742154717445374,
0.5092809796333313,
-0.38369861245155334,
-0.10110263526439667,
0.15840931236743927,
0.13129708170890808,
0.04692213982343674,
-0.6341978311538696,
0.5032398104667664,
-0.46903347969055176,
0.3946070969104767,
-0.4197002649307251,
-0.808347225189209,
-0.3045966625213623,
0.18018203973770142,
-0.5196896195411682,
0.7768126130104065,
-0.075724758207798,
-0.6865047216415405,
0.5929277539253235,
-0.2811404764652252,
-0.32977294921875,
-0.32804402709007263,
-0.2897203266620636,
-0.5942972302436829,
-0.019467582926154137,
0.4571390151977539,
0.5153342485427856,
0.05612955242395401,
0.003716316306963563,
-0.43803492188453674,
-0.5726355314254761,
0.13777954876422882,
-0.29922565817832947,
0.5219346284866333,
0.1771334707736969,
-0.3499765396118164,
0.3689761459827423,
-0.4533785283565521,
-0.21058733761310577,
-0.0450570248067379,
-0.17024865746498108,
-0.5704905986785889,
0.28808102011680603,
-0.4054831564426422,
-0.007169234100729227,
0.2733810842037201,
-0.31233564019203186,
0.6683533787727356,
-0.6224363446235657,
0.21263357996940613,
1.0432935953140259,
-0.09013625234365463,
0.7020493149757385,
-0.6176820993423462,
0.5031390190124512,
0.1508171260356903,
0.09775378555059433,
0.11166869103908539,
0.13514189422130585,
-0.8157877922058105,
-0.3674861192703247,
0.4628814458847046,
0.5053030848503113,
-0.43682417273521423,
0.5446036458015442,
-0.24344336986541748,
-0.0976114496588707,
-0.8382666707038879,
0.4211551249027252,
0.46886417269706726,
0.5258563160896301,
0.32707512378692627,
0.05933672934770584,
-0.6459930539131165,
-1.2881381511688232,
-0.2322206199169159,
0.02317497506737709,
0.04319518432021141,
0.318276047706604,
0.11860836297273636,
-0.21772071719169617,
0.9977259039878845,
-0.49473071098327637,
-0.4821726977825165,
-0.19466322660446167,
0.004354674834758043,
0.037976354360580444,
0.6688048243522644,
0.35108429193496704,
-0.6645197868347168,
-0.4676564931869507,
0.22748620808124542,
-0.4588644802570343,
-0.04749010130763054,
-0.2787996828556061,
-0.030060015618801117,
0.2901113033294678,
0.8209665417671204,
-0.1696486622095108,
0.06302595138549805,
0.6007786989212036,
0.36278557777404785,
0.3594357371330261,
-0.23161637783050537,
0.17030999064445496,
-0.7996819615364075,
-0.2815426290035248,
0.10038676857948303,
-0.4692271947860718,
-0.4094533324241638,
-0.035479336977005005,
-0.031085029244422913,
0.5304898023605347,
-0.18365252017974854,
0.5359160304069519,
-0.49942511320114136,
-0.021255197003483772,
-0.33255404233932495,
0.3187091648578644,
-0.4652339816093445,
0.407621830701828,
0.09632951766252518,
0.8627907037734985,
0.5021174550056458,
-0.7049359679222107,
0.2975773215293884,
0.20760253071784973,
-0.47071224451065063,
0.5149552226066589,
-0.511411190032959,
-0.031911451369524,
-0.1979702115058899,
0.028697311878204346,
-1.0854291915893555,
-0.27662622928619385,
0.1500771939754486,
-0.04792426899075508,
0.4930329918861389,
-0.35609835386276245,
-0.5032492876052856,
-0.23266340792179108,
-0.2621280252933502,
0.12863221764564514,
0.6774845719337463,
-0.8050195574760437,
0.3166636526584625,
0.2371492087841034,
-0.05857923999428749,
-0.9591972827911377,
-0.35290685296058655,
-0.20866477489471436,
-0.5776781439781189,
-0.30629071593284607,
0.42734941840171814,
0.07421785593032837,
-0.41834741830825806,
-0.23871448636054993,
-0.02526840940117836,
0.2887360751628876,
0.26950258016586304,
0.36272695660591125,
0.01763434335589409,
-0.20292438566684723,
0.13949353992938995,
0.5019038319587708,
0.06110908463597298,
-0.380561888217926,
-0.23329885303974152,
0.3316502571105957,
-0.2154863178730011,
-0.6117725372314453,
-0.6051051020622253,
0.05473298206925392,
0.09593920409679413,
0.14133904874324799,
0.48102283477783203,
0.33844566345214844,
-0.09858681261539459,
-0.26231852173805237,
-0.5843043327331543,
-0.26349467039108276,
-0.5116860270500183,
0.27589502930641174,
-0.29009127616882324,
-0.7442647218704224,
0.3188892602920532,
-0.45229002833366394,
0.18499305844306946,
0.20665965974330902,
0.582122802734375,
-0.3816035985946655,
1.4055970907211304,
0.8358801007270813,
-0.2400616854429245,
0.6219989657402039,
-0.22708182036876678,
-0.04120007902383804,
-0.6896381974220276,
0.0047996873036026955,
-0.3774910867214203,
-0.6750836372375488,
-0.6300669312477112,
0.20532071590423584,
0.21662013232707977,
0.47964757680892944,
-0.4277069866657257,
0.4650883078575134,
-0.20853212475776672,
0.6853543519973755,
0.5719952583312988,
0.2738945484161377,
0.45297467708587646,
-0.2304750233888626,
-0.28596779704093933,
-0.12611277401447296,
-0.6136761903762817,
-0.5817700624465942,
0.8502811193466187,
0.2344101518392563,
1.0133968591690063,
0.08579778671264648,
0.6273598670959473,
0.014702658168971539,
0.25297388434410095,
-1.0020334720611572,
0.4410971701145172,
-0.12096961587667465,
-0.27926522493362427,
-0.7118582725524902,
-0.1728244572877884,
-1.012627124786377,
0.21864457428455353,
-0.21208330988883972,
-0.49619120359420776,
-0.09384717792272568,
0.3505684435367584,
-0.23303908109664917,
0.13848035037517548,
-0.5312201380729675,
0.8030017018318176,
-0.31049996614456177,
-0.31621500849723816,
-0.199199378490448,
-0.7738898396492004,
0.528620719909668,
0.05535047501325607,
0.22741088271141052,
0.16146624088287354,
-0.1708388328552246,
0.4931480288505554,
-0.30887457728385925,
1.0442167520523071,
-0.16836607456207275,
-0.38447675108909607,
-0.2165418565273285,
0.19216254353523254,
0.5744805335998535,
0.09410642087459564,
0.20909836888313293,
-0.434500515460968,
-0.1278279572725296,
-0.2058798223733902,
-0.658335268497467,
0.9214571714401245,
-0.823379397392273,
-0.8446098566055298,
0.12837916612625122,
-0.6077799797058105,
-0.5224435329437256,
0.19772732257843018,
-0.029102275148034096,
0.0383133664727211,
-0.2767722010612488,
0.024237265810370445,
0.9543944597244263,
-0.05519986152648926,
0.30327942967414856,
0.7211392521858215,
-0.3487728536128998,
-0.23605185747146606,
0.7913506627082825,
-0.08039843291044235,
0.30758580565452576,
0.5929585695266724,
0.29957082867622375,
-0.32849910855293274,
-0.6767544746398926,
-0.4416949450969696,
0.21851365268230438,
-0.4880070388317108,
-0.055753882974386215,
-0.3845582604408264,
0.22565925121307373,
-0.2722068428993225,
-0.3072608411312103,
-0.41957327723503113,
-0.3608168065547943,
-0.5664655566215515,
-0.25307926535606384,
0.2277923822402954,
0.5194794535636902,
-0.08572636544704437,
0.4990392327308655,
-0.37024441361427307,
0.1287202537059784,
0.5017342567443848,
0.24152499437332153,
-0.21222053468227386,
-0.5783801674842834,
-0.22338320314884186,
0.37005797028541565,
-0.3645085394382477,
-0.4020542502403259,
0.23211760818958282,
0.12823432683944702,
0.6369376182556152,
0.745389461517334,
0.05107734352350235,
0.9437124133110046,
-0.4382060468196869,
0.6995318531990051,
-0.16037839651107788,
-0.6985151171684265,
0.5053935050964355,
-0.2812768220901489,
-0.06783922761678696,
0.7703803181648254,
0.8077033758163452,
-0.35129037499427795,
-0.42983192205429077,
-0.39757466316223145,
-0.5888043642044067,
0.5566731095314026,
-0.3326282501220703,
-0.02966134063899517,
0.24154788255691528,
0.25716662406921387,
0.4366755783557892,
0.06775957345962524,
-0.24378907680511475,
-0.23924967646598816,
0.15201303362846375,
-0.46768832206726074,
-0.4066294729709625,
0.24900293350219727,
-0.5572233200073242,
-0.37105393409729004,
0.8321003913879395,
-0.38911932706832886,
-0.23496463894844055,
-0.10128198564052582,
-0.21331647038459778,
-0.2563082277774811,
0.18668073415756226,
1.1069856882095337,
0.3155636191368103,
-0.12147322297096252,
0.044517166912555695,
0.21278230845928192,
0.1014861911535263,
0.1915852427482605,
-0.06859631091356277,
-0.11707212775945663,
-0.38734331727027893,
0.20055925846099854,
1.006771445274353,
0.1520005464553833,
-0.6610544323921204,
0.6159921884536743,
0.19929373264312744,
-0.4052678644657135,
-0.30317920446395874,
0.17807137966156006,
0.0211343914270401,
0.29528510570526123,
0.09577621519565582,
-0.03441958874464035,
-0.04098093509674072,
-0.3435038626194,
0.10376662015914917,
0.8765923380851746,
-0.7255961894989014,
-0.14425966143608093,
0.4863204061985016,
-0.24670223891735077,
-0.025111213326454163,
0.8376438617706299,
0.2304021269083023,
-0.34560173749923706,
0.6409446001052856,
0.2430160641670227,
0.661191463470459,
0.07314547151327133,
0.05268864333629608,
0.15399426221847534,
0.12733784317970276,
-0.46431463956832886,
-0.03550565242767334,
-0.09936998784542084,
-0.8143941760063171,
-0.6150869727134705,
-0.26140734553337097,
-0.46958547830581665,
0.10462076216936111,
-0.7633986473083496,
0.667410135269165,
-0.18867962062358856,
0.11479457467794418,
-0.01896343007683754,
-0.04963400214910507,
-0.48129358887672424,
-0.07095802575349808,
-0.1299358606338501,
0.7333815693855286,
-1.1481032371520996,
0.8220046162605286,
0.585969090461731,
-0.40112563967704773,
-0.7253705263137817,
-0.0253918319940567,
0.10372470319271088,
-0.9679562449455261,
0.8476782441139221,
-0.10572832077741623,
-0.07001344114542007,
0.20846374332904816,
-0.9312857389450073,
-0.684406578540802,
1.0073989629745483,
0.28291386365890503,
-0.6050121784210205,
0.07532113045454025,
-0.19268378615379333,
0.4897513687610626,
-0.300006628036499,
0.09285109490156174,
0.6141273975372314,
0.6383139491081238,
-0.05002153664827347,
-0.9302321672439575,
-0.0864017978310585,
0.42244353890419006,
-0.0801873728632927,
0.24799607694149017,
-0.6537229418754578,
0.46093904972076416,
-0.45599278807640076,
-0.19063055515289307,
0.34428170323371887,
0.6882160902023315,
0.06984136998653412,
-0.08559142798185349,
0.5351500511169434,
0.7505145072937012,
0.47451168298721313,
-0.0946500152349472,
0.9234707951545715,
0.12099777907133102,
0.25502195954322815,
1.2961294651031494,
-0.256351113319397,
0.7337225079536438,
0.7586763501167297,
-0.222385436296463,
0.4193771481513977,
0.8819963335990906,
-0.09646765142679214,
0.7810918092727661,
0.4072381854057312,
0.15180060267448425,
-0.4490501880645752,
-0.06030067428946495,
-0.21944567561149597,
0.3653806447982788,
0.28199252486228943,
-0.2978385090827942,
-0.09471704065799713,
0.06930895894765854,
-0.2681249976158142,
0.3387417197227478,
-0.3475770354270935,
1.1543161869049072,
-0.21865303814411163,
-0.8049387335777283,
0.5589521527290344,
0.03436735272407532,
0.7374343872070312,
-0.34064966440200806,
-0.042188793420791626,
-0.3303593099117279,
0.27964502573013306,
-0.3157061040401459,
-0.7744591236114502,
0.05930652096867561,
-0.6129223704338074,
-0.1952829658985138,
-0.42720159888267517,
0.10544893890619278,
-0.7780434489250183,
0.023951979354023933,
-0.2621590197086334,
0.27324533462524414,
-0.029081860557198524,
0.36134883761405945,
-0.4898904263973236,
-0.23834294080734253,
-0.12983207404613495,
-0.19884546101093292,
0.7062289714813232,
0.22256715595722198,
-0.25568103790283203,
0.7799078822135925,
0.3973664343357086,
0.05170305445790291,
-0.08609887212514877,
-0.01775621809065342,
0.6810840368270874,
-0.32430097460746765,
-0.19454796612262726,
-0.9123322367668152,
0.23634293675422668,
0.015285365283489227,
-0.13438954949378967,
0.8398892283439636,
0.6986994743347168,
1.1754282712936401,
-0.3130429983139038,
0.6405782699584961,
0.3921382427215576,
0.6359961628913879,
-0.9200274348258972,
0.2151167243719101,
-0.6499335169792175,
0.28234946727752686,
-0.12220700830221176,
-0.6181044578552246,
-0.27769774198532104,
0.5507767796516418,
-0.34654125571250916,
-0.12235493957996368,
0.37771788239479065,
1.014791488647461,
-0.28556331992149353,
-0.033285994082689285,
0.2717905044555664,
0.025143316015601158,
0.164958193898201,
0.4256797134876251,
1.1325597763061523,
-0.31220394372940063,
0.11781120300292969,
-0.3116408884525299,
-0.2028200775384903,
-0.28831878304481506,
-1.0223379135131836,
-0.833166778087616,
-0.589930534362793,
-0.4444054067134857,
-0.004660183563828468,
-0.088931143283844,
1.132967233657837,
0.6910279393196106,
-0.8218541145324707,
-0.1769268810749054,
-0.24516893923282623,
0.2714688181877136,
-0.7886744141578674,
-0.22768990695476532,
0.27240094542503357,
-0.4614851772785187,
-1.0366849899291992,
0.49518507719039917,
-0.044948216527700424,
0.4376421868801117,
-0.28235116600990295,
-0.23042263090610504,
-0.00953203346580267,
-0.055937863886356354,
0.2190483659505844,
0.5811368227005005,
-0.9550771117210388,
-0.2688698470592499,
-0.1667797863483429,
-0.21136000752449036,
-0.04335455223917961,
0.8793054223060608,
-0.7924147248268127,
0.2631455063819885,
0.43711334466934204,
0.7558643817901611,
0.49037960171699524,
0.42734256386756897,
0.6845819354057312,
-0.7934828400611877,
-0.044708408415317535,
0.05456026270985603,
0.22267454862594604,
0.10872069001197815,
-0.2800823748111725,
0.23286469280719757,
-0.2249022275209427,
-0.704323947429657,
-0.8117384314537048,
0.3767056465148926,
-1.0067628622055054,
-0.3797939419746399,
1.2598261833190918,
0.12536433339118958,
0.18303266167640686,
-0.05798998475074768,
-0.48216506838798523,
0.046165984123945236,
-0.22761882841587067,
0.7058863639831543,
0.6077888607978821,
-0.31044432520866394,
-0.15630903840065002,
-0.3293117880821228,
0.6970248222351074,
0.5502930879592896,
-0.43628424406051636,
0.2589094340801239,
0.594292938709259,
0.3263109624385834,
-0.2871510088443756,
0.1662289947271347,
0.07333311438560486,
-0.20840808749198914,
-0.47959259152412415,
-0.21338346600532532,
-0.301513135433197,
-0.31454282999038696,
-0.7209089398384094,
-0.18600325286388397,
0.3419806659221649,
-0.09952642023563385
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.12014v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.12014v1
|
EnvGen: Generating and Adapting Environments via LLMs for Training Embodied Agents
| 2024-03-18T17:51:16 | 2024-03-18T17:51:16 |
Abhay Zala, Jaemin Cho, Han Lin, Jaehong Yoon, Mohit Bansal
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Recent SOTA approaches for embodied learning via interaction directly employ
large language models (LLMs) as agents to determine the next steps in an
environment. Due to their world knowledge and reasoning capabilities, LLM
agents achieve stronger performance than previous smaller agents based on
reinforcement learning (RL); however, frequently calling LLMs is slow and
expensive. Instead of directly employing LLMs as agents, can we use LLMs'
reasoning capabilities to adaptively create training environments to help
smaller embodied RL agents learn useful skills that they are weak at? We
propose EnvGen, a novel framework to address this question. First, we prompt an
LLM to generate training environments that allow agents to quickly learn
different tasks in parallel. Concretely, the LLM is given the task description
and simulator objectives that the agents should learn and is then asked to
generate a set of environment configurations (e.g., different terrains, items
given to agents, etc.). Next, we train a small RL agent in a mixture of the
original and LLM-generated environments. Then, we enable the LLM to
continuously adapt the generated environments to progressively improve the
skills that the agent is weak at, by providing feedback to the LLM in the form
of the agent's performance. We demonstrate the usefulness of EnvGen with
comprehensive experiments in Crafter and Heist environments. We find that a
small RL agent trained with EnvGen can outperform SOTA methods, including a
GPT-4 agent, and learns long-horizon tasks significantly faster. We show
qualitatively how the LLM adapts training environments to help improve RL
agents' weaker skills over time. Additionally, EnvGen is substantially more
efficient as it only uses a small number of LLM calls (e.g., 4 in total),
whereas LLM agents require thousands of LLM calls. Lastly, we present detailed
ablation studies for our design choices.
|
[
-0.2920287847518921,
-0.7680512070655823,
0.5134707689285278,
0.20827250182628632,
-0.05716124176979065,
0.12773634493350983,
-0.30291563272476196,
-0.6298887133598328,
0.10914360731840134,
0.4959789216518402,
-0.7928682565689087,
-0.4425959587097168,
-0.16128075122833252,
0.38206449151039124,
0.13112889230251312,
0.5504106283187866,
-0.03231853246688843,
-0.08926673233509064,
-0.6254405379295349,
-0.24172250926494598,
-0.38541358709335327,
-0.17946888506412506,
-0.6428670287132263,
-0.5866979956626892,
0.3643319308757782,
0.5648375153541565,
0.26629436016082764,
0.6970457434654236,
0.1866295486688614,
0.4550226330757141,
0.12907017767429352,
0.4189094007015228,
-0.4704298973083496,
0.5234749913215637,
-0.21956396102905273,
-0.4930269122123718,
-0.29427704215049744,
-0.3767641484737396,
0.6268872022628784,
0.09310059994459152,
-0.15442612767219543,
0.037874363362789154,
0.12745891511440277,
0.4986320734024048,
-0.554638683795929,
0.10864574462175369,
-0.52194744348526,
0.32639244198799133,
0.138849139213562,
-0.37546706199645996,
-0.4367014765739441,
0.06305830925703049,
-0.058947671204805374,
-0.8792182803153992,
0.2666087746620178,
0.13097164034843445,
0.39194050431251526,
0.6642055511474609,
-0.07190928608179092,
-0.1716822385787964,
-0.7060801982879639,
0.6203421354293823,
-0.4939943253993988,
0.5167543888092041,
-0.1419665813446045,
0.35778573155403137,
-0.36172622442245483,
-0.7876062393188477,
-0.4434312582015991,
-0.3438020348548889,
0.20575958490371704,
0.48726117610931396,
0.22872969508171082,
0.1229555681347847,
0.5043027997016907,
-0.19964049756526947,
-0.40852445363998413,
0.33280518651008606,
-0.3088572025299072,
-0.18887344002723694,
0.6024869084358215,
0.42246535420417786,
0.4281446635723114,
0.14238324761390686,
-0.5620225071907043,
-0.45129328966140747,
-1.0081121921539307,
0.09691249579191208,
0.37679633498191833,
0.386056125164032,
0.033852387219667435,
0.4358765780925751,
-0.08851896971464157,
0.5947288870811462,
-0.10280575603246689,
-0.2657475471496582,
0.15850567817687988,
0.12197072058916092,
-0.06675592064857483,
0.29186585545539856,
0.41566896438598633,
0.13496755063533783,
-0.06800731271505356,
-0.15927055478096008,
-0.31648439168930054,
-0.11294924467802048,
0.5943453311920166,
-0.987241268157959,
0.1010814905166626,
0.038283176720142365,
-0.3255094885826111,
-0.12340689450502396,
-0.3359871506690979,
-0.7480232119560242,
-0.6137427091598511,
-0.2904934287071228,
0.45464953780174255,
-0.6060599088668823,
-0.22956831753253937,
0.12183911353349686,
-0.4266646206378937,
0.6769052743911743,
0.4594261646270752,
-0.748893678188324,
0.3231504261493683,
0.56805020570755,
0.8507524132728577,
0.0036779697984457016,
-0.5907785892486572,
-0.5783786177635193,
0.14087729156017303,
-0.28383466601371765,
0.8816789984703064,
-0.6605507135391235,
-0.5472076535224915,
0.011871748603880405,
0.04057011380791664,
-0.029604308307170868,
-0.6746047139167786,
-0.08919432014226913,
-0.4550338685512543,
-0.25761210918426514,
-0.33210548758506775,
-0.33490294218063354,
0.0725182518362999,
0.2646195590496063,
-0.46994757652282715,
1.0052106380462646,
0.07751598954200745,
-0.5203166007995605,
0.36789217591285706,
-0.8506194949150085,
-0.3967474699020386,
0.1988765150308609,
-0.17670641839504242,
-0.4817045331001282,
0.04696018993854523,
0.0003475392295513302,
0.29828080534935,
-0.20310309529304504,
-0.3812394440174103,
-0.34339043498039246,
-0.41987088322639465,
0.0617264024913311,
0.0633280873298645,
0.34583747386932373,
0.18131713569164276,
-0.4257957637310028,
0.30215713381767273,
-0.6209281086921692,
-0.013664187863469124,
0.30053800344467163,
-0.40701165795326233,
-0.2956838607788086,
0.19947096705436707,
-0.2277902215719223,
0.12050450593233109,
0.09661492705345154,
-0.5433834791183472,
0.2258080244064331,
-0.6714755296707153,
0.3916678726673126,
0.9290189146995544,
0.10806961357593536,
0.5894632935523987,
-0.3972477316856384,
0.6515093445777893,
-0.2958926856517792,
-0.09617017954587936,
0.025689877569675446,
-0.09693888574838638,
-1.0261260271072388,
-0.3106176555156708,
-0.177573099732399,
0.31492874026298523,
-1.3336341381072998,
0.15746626257896423,
-0.04596833139657974,
-0.6744964122772217,
-0.25290200114250183,
0.21465103328227997,
0.4850514829158783,
0.1406470686197281,
0.3129630386829376,
-0.39815130829811096,
-0.749342679977417,
-0.5579087734222412,
-0.29542243480682373,
-0.21662388741970062,
0.01576944999396801,
0.3382369577884674,
0.7656835317611694,
-0.27109289169311523,
0.906152606010437,
-0.22819088399410248,
-0.05299656465649605,
-0.2592695355415344,
-0.02430422231554985,
-0.23084406554698944,
0.45373475551605225,
0.5174146294593811,
-0.4804603159427643,
-0.30084410309791565,
0.04975553974509239,
-0.9944840669631958,
0.04292330890893936,
-0.22080354392528534,
-0.35326898097991943,
-0.036847736686468124,
0.7890174984931946,
-0.44947871565818787,
0.22527973353862762,
0.20669955015182495,
-0.3711439371109009,
0.40919461846351624,
-0.5530587434768677,
-0.23646247386932373,
-0.8534833788871765,
-0.26838213205337524,
0.02302880771458149,
-0.3395703434944153,
-0.6522762775421143,
0.3022037148475647,
-0.13132086396217346,
-0.0604439377784729,
-0.715041995048523,
0.8639249801635742,
-0.5515524744987488,
-0.40690290927886963,
-0.4269178509712219,
-0.019985860213637352,
-0.22192269563674927,
0.6298235654830933,
0.36696213483810425,
0.7478468418121338,
0.6847336292266846,
-0.7690760493278503,
0.4920414388179779,
0.4227493405342102,
-0.09995535761117935,
0.4974169135093689,
-0.5993527173995972,
0.5581616759300232,
-0.2327956110239029,
0.33595871925354004,
-0.42792806029319763,
-0.17189043760299683,
0.17411623895168304,
-0.20309510827064514,
0.16100473701953888,
0.01980416662991047,
-0.4573425352573395,
-0.043739814311265945,
-0.20919544994831085,
0.10229738801717758,
0.8237552046775818,
-0.7587571144104004,
1.1751149892807007,
0.07032952457666397,
-0.08672809600830078,
-0.3725205063819885,
-0.40292081236839294,
-0.13318191468715668,
-0.466453492641449,
-0.5917772650718689,
0.28727400302886963,
-0.13540783524513245,
-0.36008599400520325,
0.048424966633319855,
-0.355095237493515,
0.24172386527061462,
0.3119859993457794,
0.4584912955760956,
0.016429422423243523,
-0.21940666437149048,
0.26402026414871216,
-0.06220890209078789,
-0.09977971762418747,
0.11577293276786804,
-0.4900432527065277,
0.34646302461624146,
-0.3419375717639923,
-0.4548599123954773,
0.40741950273513794,
0.06923740357160568,
0.4556894302368164,
-0.18785487115383148,
0.8900278210639954,
0.6863799095153809,
-0.4144306182861328,
-0.8248047232627869,
-0.22349034249782562,
-0.3509376049041748,
-0.5517142415046692,
0.4126289486885071,
-0.47889232635498047,
-0.8364445567131042,
0.4612567126750946,
-0.23544210195541382,
0.4246947467327118,
0.2605764865875244,
0.857257604598999,
-0.09571469575166702,
0.6577206254005432,
0.8234867453575134,
0.45987817645072937,
0.7738427519798279,
-0.3828132450580597,
-0.20577570796012878,
-0.8404871821403503,
-0.413582444190979,
-0.26470786333084106,
-0.3558899462223053,
-0.4534858167171478,
-0.6983470916748047,
0.5089085698127747,
-0.32322826981544495,
-0.5007175207138062,
0.23800045251846313,
-0.4024650454521179,
0.5657424926757812,
0.6167547106742859,
0.539124608039856,
-0.016041092574596405,
-0.029214197769761086,
-0.010924567468464375,
0.18265315890312195,
-0.9043682813644409,
-0.5580139756202698,
0.8947756886482239,
0.3739490211009979,
0.9948542714118958,
0.02477841265499592,
0.9992406964302063,
0.21088100969791412,
0.46768078207969666,
-0.6237576007843018,
0.666349470615387,
0.2347496896982193,
-0.29193419218063354,
-0.47134339809417725,
-0.2363082468509674,
-0.9294991493225098,
0.422161728143692,
-0.35713446140289307,
-0.45902568101882935,
0.19086207449436188,
0.13704223930835724,
-0.33733701705932617,
0.12150437384843826,
-0.5240390300750732,
0.7647945284843445,
-0.32253390550613403,
-0.7964457869529724,
-0.2689889073371887,
-0.6919408440589905,
-0.012924465350806713,
0.002764251548796892,
0.020910628139972687,
-0.16385100781917572,
-0.17798438668251038,
0.6341730356216431,
-0.43581587076187134,
1.063289761543274,
-0.45381322503089905,
-0.17949844896793365,
0.4869379699230194,
0.006981669459491968,
0.6549519896507263,
0.059534117579460144,
0.028667528182268143,
-0.2944760024547577,
-0.3440742492675781,
-0.3169618248939514,
-0.6393994092941284,
0.5517839789390564,
-0.9840211272239685,
-0.6066102981567383,
-0.31544843316078186,
-0.5322214365005493,
-0.317428320646286,
0.04734497517347336,
0.23460495471954346,
0.37905624508857727,
-0.33864766359329224,
0.22275668382644653,
0.9440372586250305,
-0.5842776298522949,
0.23691630363464355,
0.7054787874221802,
0.1623692661523819,
-0.023028690367937088,
1.0879487991333008,
-0.026021642610430717,
0.26945438981056213,
0.12711435556411743,
0.08787406980991364,
-0.20765937864780426,
-0.3376457393169403,
-0.30885130167007446,
-0.07247305661439896,
-0.9682080745697021,
-0.1594662070274353,
-0.7334508299827576,
-0.32903221249580383,
-0.11323687434196472,
-0.48080310225486755,
-0.41399428248405457,
0.10963383316993713,
-0.324310302734375,
-0.2163047194480896,
0.4794502258300781,
0.6387456655502319,
-0.23053115606307983,
0.11066915094852448,
-0.6398112773895264,
0.3139575719833374,
0.6547056436538696,
0.15960702300071716,
-0.12876832485198975,
-0.5339389443397522,
-0.4306902587413788,
-0.06489699333906174,
-0.317132830619812,
-0.6908393502235413,
0.469870924949646,
0.3717593848705292,
0.6502552032470703,
-0.1638476699590683,
0.06585469841957092,
0.6056920289993286,
-0.6057134866714478,
0.5522505044937134,
0.03768350929021835,
-0.6711118221282959,
0.5359610915184021,
-0.23969167470932007,
0.17120535671710968,
0.27132517099380493,
0.029689617455005646,
-0.40988296270370483,
-0.5388473272323608,
-0.7861618995666504,
-0.9055202603340149,
0.764219343662262,
0.09609892964363098,
0.0979011282324791,
0.17530891299247742,
0.3529520034790039,
0.2904486358165741,
-0.06139778345823288,
-0.5716627240180969,
0.09584496170282364,
-0.3445124328136444,
-0.2617906928062439,
-0.11657175421714783,
-0.04634588211774826,
-0.2154833972454071,
-0.07490120083093643,
0.7891368269920349,
-0.544563353061676,
0.5169433951377869,
0.2516343891620636,
-0.33957937359809875,
-0.1030416488647461,
0.14145493507385254,
0.3697879910469055,
0.23018012940883636,
0.0034823936875909567,
0.1282256841659546,
0.7444964647293091,
-0.12187693268060684,
0.431898832321167,
-0.18953345715999603,
0.14680591225624084,
-0.3537669777870178,
0.6409844160079956,
0.9747404456138611,
0.1514626145362854,
-1.0489771366119385,
0.20923124253749847,
-0.17163944244384766,
-0.45714452862739563,
-0.41713932156562805,
0.6162344217300415,
0.12157473713159561,
0.8159518837928772,
-0.06901049613952637,
0.20016539096832275,
-0.029379241168498993,
-0.5584337711334229,
0.17873238027095795,
0.17518822848796844,
-0.3634718656539917,
-0.28847435116767883,
0.7086396217346191,
0.4190126061439514,
-0.4096205234527588,
0.6127634644508362,
-0.13858570158481598,
-0.4135423004627228,
0.9888141751289368,
0.7150992751121521,
1.1755521297454834,
-0.07708307355642319,
0.1040864810347557,
0.2523300349712372,
0.3960408866405487,
-0.25908735394477844,
0.28383785486221313,
-0.15336094796657562,
-0.9959076046943665,
-0.2698311507701874,
-0.6544050574302673,
-0.6465486884117126,
-0.2259133756160736,
-0.35666653513908386,
0.11846735328435898,
-0.599511444568634,
0.2601434290409088,
-0.40853452682495117,
-0.2663061022758484,
-1.0456651449203491,
0.0377061627805233,
0.32461437582969666,
0.8818369507789612,
-1.0452505350112915,
0.4687076508998871,
1.1150476932525635,
-0.27856895327568054,
-0.5950570702552795,
0.03169282525777817,
-0.01761206053197384,
-0.9629760384559631,
0.5721737742424011,
0.2386418581008911,
-0.28941357135772705,
0.20904530584812164,
-0.7561210989952087,
-0.7035583257675171,
1.2909915447235107,
0.5533833503723145,
-0.3064253628253937,
0.06451068073511124,
-0.11107736080884933,
0.7349899411201477,
-0.49292027950286865,
0.10180876404047012,
0.6170276999473572,
0.3788605332374573,
0.07592036575078964,
-0.4127584397792816,
0.2184668779373169,
-0.4350029528141022,
0.19729046523571014,
-0.08401831239461899,
-0.8908568024635315,
0.47268712520599365,
-0.286526620388031,
-0.2544131577014923,
0.035573069006204605,
0.781046450138092,
0.5712876319885254,
0.22092686593532562,
0.5763972997665405,
0.43219107389450073,
0.4442439377307892,
-0.1676855981349945,
0.9248563647270203,
-0.11105620861053467,
0.12841658294200897,
0.7153741717338562,
-0.41642656922340393,
0.5237444043159485,
0.2654370069503784,
0.09423022717237473,
0.5442875027656555,
0.6887662410736084,
0.2819148898124695,
0.6556586623191833,
0.4120003581047058,
-0.33323150873184204,
-0.5801037549972534,
-0.02257092483341694,
-0.2649039626121521,
0.36823999881744385,
0.43001222610473633,
0.0964454859495163,
-0.0879555270075798,
0.5208054780960083,
-0.4576318562030792,
0.056231722235679626,
-0.16223491728305817,
1.0921120643615723,
0.1292847841978073,
-0.536440372467041,
0.35717499256134033,
-0.12164416909217834,
0.4731444716453552,
-0.6763756275177002,
-0.29052358865737915,
-0.2034161388874054,
0.2454681545495987,
-0.1498449593782425,
-0.4378293454647064,
0.18139611184597015,
0.05035414174199104,
0.2737133800983429,
-0.6258869767189026,
1.1258450746536255,
-0.36677086353302,
-0.22113323211669922,
0.2511466145515442,
0.6061857342720032,
0.07467898726463318,
0.26086142659187317,
-0.6045730710029602,
0.009759445674717426,
-0.2396335005760193,
-0.4995923638343811,
0.48764532804489136,
0.6276076436042786,
0.153072789311409,
0.8558182716369629,
0.5139909386634827,
-0.08622841536998749,
0.007943178527057171,
-0.17444542050361633,
1.0068379640579224,
-0.7589637637138367,
-0.5096584558486938,
-0.750840425491333,
0.44707947969436646,
0.10412230342626572,
-0.047051407396793365,
0.6064119935035706,
0.32982346415519714,
0.8521364331245422,
-0.1930045783519745,
1.005656361579895,
-0.23778727650642395,
-0.03660710155963898,
-0.9468269944190979,
0.24621888995170593,
-0.639610230922699,
0.2010861039161682,
-0.004945751745253801,
-1.0031675100326538,
0.13473400473594666,
0.7362803220748901,
-0.15061065554618835,
0.15890443325042725,
0.6063872575759888,
0.873264729976654,
0.14007769525051117,
-0.1657220721244812,
0.36421629786491394,
0.1864912062883377,
0.5264531970024109,
0.5993174910545349,
1.297505497932434,
0.07113704830408096,
0.2747696340084076,
0.02257191389799118,
0.013069456443190575,
-0.2497049868106842,
-0.6663442850112915,
-0.9822144508361816,
-0.38290542364120483,
-0.2589927613735199,
-0.3868304491043091,
0.31594181060791016,
1.2316044569015503,
0.6290255188941956,
-0.169039785861969,
-0.16873909533023834,
-0.33421340584754944,
0.06267716735601425,
-0.5575962662696838,
-0.13949771225452423,
0.002663402119651437,
-0.43020254373550415,
-0.6973094940185547,
0.8448610305786133,
0.37283721566200256,
0.033744148910045624,
-0.33908650279045105,
-0.5586787462234497,
0.3654673993587494,
0.13856050372123718,
0.5395348072052002,
0.5568416714668274,
-0.4030221700668335,
-0.5726927518844604,
0.016786035150289536,
-0.06642135977745056,
0.00005308854451868683,
0.7502944469451904,
-0.8787237405776978,
0.6358722448348999,
0.40155598521232605,
0.8092454075813293,
0.7279187440872192,
-0.23832719027996063,
0.6197726130485535,
-1.0370804071426392,
0.34121859073638916,
0.2660754919052124,
0.43296563625335693,
0.22679969668388367,
-0.32498082518577576,
0.6412221193313599,
0.22402577102184296,
-0.39219263195991516,
-0.610641598701477,
0.24220556020736694,
-0.5615354776382446,
-0.2937914729118347,
1.333215594291687,
-0.07587181776762009,
-0.6244326829910278,
-0.022692272439599037,
-0.2985789179801941,
0.23103764653205872,
-0.12629252672195435,
0.6027029752731323,
0.30930501222610474,
-0.24660013616085052,
-0.1547844409942627,
-0.4565066993236542,
0.4117366373538971,
0.23830777406692505,
-1.1187729835510254,
-0.021470004692673683,
0.4273935854434967,
0.44613105058670044,
-0.016394952312111855,
0.7513160109519958,
0.2984309792518616,
0.46070387959480286,
0.4941662549972534,
0.5415385365486145,
-0.4018574655056,
-0.5011417865753174,
-0.04712831228971481,
-0.12468037009239197,
0.3074322044849396,
-0.06060327962040901
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.12766v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.12766v2
|
NovelQA: Benchmarking Question Answering on Documents Exceeding 200K Tokens
| 2024-03-18T17:32:32 | 2024-06-17T13:53:15 |
Cunxiang Wang, Ruoxi Ning, Boqi Pan, Tonghui Wu, Qipeng Guo, Cheng Deng, Guangsheng Bao, Xiangkun Hu, Zheng Zhang, Qian Wang, Yue Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The rapid advancement of Large Language Models (LLMs) has introduced a new
frontier in natural language processing, particularly in understanding and
processing long-context information. However, the evaluation of these models'
long-context abilities remains a challenge due to the limitations of current
benchmarks. To address this gap, we introduce NovelQA, a benchmark specifically
designed to test the capabilities of LLMs with extended texts. Constructed from
English novels, NovelQA offers a unique blend of complexity, length, and
narrative coherence, making it an ideal tool for assessing deep textual
understanding in LLMs. This paper presents the design and construction of
NovelQA, highlighting its manual annotation, and diverse question types. Our
evaluation of Long-context LLMs on NovelQA reveals significant insights into
the models' performance, particularly emphasizing the challenges they face with
multi-hop reasoning, detail-oriented questions, and extremely long input with
an average length more than 200,000 tokens. The results underscore the
necessity for further advancements in LLMs to improve their long-context
comprehension.
|
[
-0.4420945644378662,
-0.8228719234466553,
0.7554779052734375,
0.06481028348207474,
-0.12586894631385803,
0.39711636304855347,
-0.08263232558965683,
-0.5140933394432068,
-0.255658358335495,
0.5285623073577881,
-0.5508195757865906,
-0.259354829788208,
-0.3360995650291443,
0.39810800552368164,
-0.41620171070098877,
0.7457435727119446,
-0.2703700363636017,
-0.10247483849525452,
-0.5825293660163879,
-0.41488125920295715,
-0.37137433886528015,
-0.48685336112976074,
-0.6877667307853699,
-0.09804315865039825,
0.6609939336776733,
0.06408523768186569,
0.7862274050712585,
0.3774648904800415,
0.34677475690841675,
0.30451759696006775,
-0.35564759373664856,
0.3211544156074524,
-0.3171612620353699,
0.31803837418556213,
-0.23837237060070038,
-0.5246898531913757,
-0.4163021445274353,
-0.09849463403224945,
1.0340688228607178,
0.8707720041275024,
0.4091004729270935,
0.205348938703537,
0.025208447128534317,
0.4915328323841095,
-0.5507155656814575,
-0.19072401523590088,
-0.31327521800994873,
-0.057236719876527786,
-0.2129557877779007,
-0.03869711980223656,
-0.41490933299064636,
-0.32400059700012207,
0.1295497864484787,
-0.5884784460067749,
0.10235878080129623,
0.030600273981690407,
0.7087216377258301,
0.21756327152252197,
-0.8461471199989319,
-0.38406994938850403,
-0.43126314878463745,
0.7056056261062622,
-0.626056969165802,
0.3582989573478699,
0.18318898975849152,
0.5135624408721924,
-0.2736276090145111,
-0.9063959717750549,
-0.6251866817474365,
-0.2919571101665497,
0.07995873689651489,
-0.09575877338647842,
0.0351242758333683,
0.045030757784843445,
0.3309873640537262,
0.6003871560096741,
-0.848389744758606,
0.19038523733615875,
-0.06280258297920227,
-0.04418446496129036,
0.55108243227005,
0.38389015197753906,
0.22579030692577362,
-0.37519028782844543,
-0.6656751036643982,
0.07941041886806488,
-0.5958564281463623,
0.4637431204319,
0.2759109437465668,
0.14691050350666046,
0.06975676864385605,
0.41781580448150635,
-0.550492525100708,
0.5732174515724182,
-0.28000307083129883,
0.1718093454837799,
0.2750599980354309,
-0.4730466604232788,
-0.14241938292980194,
-0.5066185593605042,
0.5160635709762573,
0.2040569931268692,
0.048906754702329636,
-0.2557845115661621,
-0.3430942893028259,
-0.45017680525779724,
-0.0158961471170187,
-0.853964626789093,
0.2487170696258545,
0.536764919757843,
-0.22481496632099152,
0.12623924016952515,
-0.302998423576355,
-0.583245038986206,
-0.5677210688591003,
-0.09045236557722092,
0.5431711673736572,
-0.2576397955417633,
0.01794719509780407,
0.11606037616729736,
-0.39998361468315125,
0.5321152210235596,
0.28616228699684143,
-0.6105731725692749,
0.3812769949436188,
0.983474850654602,
0.7562920451164246,
-0.4798815846443176,
-0.27949661016464233,
-0.7018304467201233,
-0.03381625562906265,
-0.41895538568496704,
0.7846012115478516,
-0.38515353202819824,
-0.06388576328754425,
0.11013468354940414,
-0.00739333825185895,
0.09891531616449356,
-0.5035688281059265,
0.9431841373443604,
-0.677293598651886,
0.19929349422454834,
-0.43166738748550415,
-0.7114382386207581,
-0.035459764301776886,
0.557917058467865,
-0.8100407719612122,
1.2811989784240723,
0.21013177931308746,
-0.5977781414985657,
0.25856438279151917,
-0.5837913751602173,
-0.37264105677604675,
0.5038529634475708,
-0.29403257369995117,
0.13075044751167297,
0.06537384539842606,
0.29156363010406494,
0.4974290430545807,
-0.6567662358283997,
0.5410913825035095,
-0.0418412871658802,
-0.6353068351745605,
0.5284386277198792,
-0.7334297895431519,
0.662179172039032,
0.21946494281291962,
-0.12017488479614258,
-0.015542924404144287,
-0.7343112826347351,
0.15370820462703705,
0.059540633112192154,
-0.556562066078186,
-0.3754294812679291,
-0.27728456258773804,
0.07679199427366257,
0.010806654579937458,
0.4849162697792053,
-0.5069604516029358,
0.15129515528678894,
-0.4431583285331726,
0.49284619092941284,
0.49318936467170715,
0.026183046400547028,
0.32779088616371155,
-0.6180148720741272,
0.7791674137115479,
-0.2798551619052887,
0.006373542360961437,
-0.6593793034553528,
-0.3282891809940338,
-0.7204846739768982,
-0.42309147119522095,
0.478344589471817,
0.2917121648788452,
-0.8521775007247925,
0.1816442757844925,
-0.3773551881313324,
-0.37106284499168396,
-0.4368750751018524,
0.026345442980527878,
0.3182299733161926,
0.11963172256946564,
0.32510748505592346,
-0.2299729883670807,
-0.3351941406726837,
-0.9570879340171814,
-0.6721410751342773,
-0.05315002053976059,
-0.35416433215141296,
0.3262392282485962,
0.6255435347557068,
-0.12405835837125778,
0.93546062707901,
-0.2705463469028473,
0.242935448884964,
-0.15602874755859375,
0.19807764887809753,
0.23351173102855682,
0.21338026225566864,
0.21445703506469727,
-0.8048821687698364,
-0.21177075803279877,
-0.2526674270629883,
-0.6403476595878601,
0.028274916112422943,
-0.37879398465156555,
0.07421765476465225,
-0.006610711570829153,
0.5382841229438782,
-0.744016170501709,
0.12095628678798676,
0.4570765495300293,
-0.3913666605949402,
0.6078976988792419,
-0.0963558629155159,
0.21886055171489716,
-1.0545037984848022,
0.26264891028404236,
-0.23736974596977234,
-0.3958089351654053,
-0.4908251166343689,
0.5534656047821045,
0.263160765171051,
-0.0685887336730957,
-0.34685373306274414,
1.0142515897750854,
-0.5034470558166504,
-0.07585768401622772,
-0.16119104623794556,
0.2986336052417755,
0.39506444334983826,
0.42865946888923645,
-0.19027748703956604,
0.9207111597061157,
0.051166705787181854,
-0.33328333497047424,
0.46678024530410767,
0.2037111073732376,
-0.7718803882598877,
0.40362119674682617,
-0.7421979308128357,
0.185247004032135,
-0.05876919999718666,
0.5222563743591309,
-1.3356022834777832,
-0.06993212550878525,
-0.32919442653656006,
-0.4798879325389862,
0.018929343670606613,
0.11851780861616135,
-0.5865288972854614,
-0.3083403706550598,
-0.29175448417663574,
0.8687053918838501,
0.22300636768341064,
-0.5852948427200317,
0.7010602355003357,
0.07219825685024261,
-0.493705153465271,
-0.6425860524177551,
-0.5707974433898926,
0.5156713724136353,
-0.15974289178848267,
-0.5436568856239319,
0.3113163411617279,
-0.38372936844825745,
-0.26029396057128906,
-0.35988670587539673,
0.11198829114437103,
-0.3133704364299774,
0.18797935545444489,
0.21204368770122528,
-0.07267147302627563,
-0.3087773025035858,
0.3441765606403351,
0.2717793583869934,
0.08964939415454865,
0.2156158685684204,
0.10369659215211868,
0.48345163464546204,
-0.1527189016342163,
-0.11300519853830338,
-0.2038889229297638,
0.6258293390274048,
0.667217493057251,
-0.2622562050819397,
0.3988320231437683,
0.2880018651485443,
-0.4455357789993286,
-0.5109647512435913,
-0.49017590284347534,
0.16607914865016937,
-0.5234588384628296,
0.6390386819839478,
-0.822239100933075,
-0.9785047173500061,
0.48002612590789795,
-0.17180977761745453,
0.1723581999540329,
0.4107901155948639,
0.41803839802742004,
0.05789332091808319,
0.598617434501648,
0.3145941197872162,
0.0664873868227005,
0.04538159444928169,
0.031059112399816513,
-0.07662243396043777,
-0.7864209413528442,
-0.17697763442993164,
-0.5753747224807739,
-0.1042012944817543,
-0.32841914892196655,
-0.8483693599700928,
0.06378630548715591,
-0.07139453291893005,
-0.42940396070480347,
0.251985639333725,
-0.09217804670333862,
0.6504923701286316,
0.38814353942871094,
-0.10100515931844711,
0.6005688309669495,
-0.5339770913124084,
-0.4464367926120758,
0.0787116065621376,
-0.5000508427619934,
-0.6930599808692932,
0.9679187536239624,
0.8566588163375854,
0.4148348569869995,
0.1946069598197937,
0.40948840975761414,
0.3612784147262573,
0.029262755066156387,
-0.7875261902809143,
0.6288126707077026,
0.0567396804690361,
-0.8385505676269531,
-0.5118684768676758,
-0.38194453716278076,
-0.813601016998291,
0.2838999927043915,
-0.061028677970170975,
-0.36185184121131897,
0.05168890208005905,
-0.4318135678768158,
-0.6547061204910278,
0.04474618658423424,
-0.36977192759513855,
0.8417212963104248,
-0.36034655570983887,
-0.32751554250717163,
0.12043702602386475,
-0.40555593371391296,
0.28492844104766846,
-0.22686034440994263,
0.18651454150676727,
-0.1395123153924942,
-0.5228931903839111,
0.8801468014717102,
-0.07515887916088104,
0.5512626767158508,
0.11405083537101746,
-0.2855670154094696,
0.16030637919902802,
-0.024112584069371223,
0.334450364112854,
0.2630508244037628,
-0.3601685166358948,
-0.11383852362632751,
0.4514133930206299,
-0.586742103099823,
-0.5516597032546997,
0.6286647915840149,
-0.5482218861579895,
-0.583215594291687,
-0.5194377899169922,
-0.8522596955299377,
-0.5839662551879883,
0.254595011472702,
0.011983425356447697,
0.5768386125564575,
-0.5522504448890686,
0.48185423016548157,
0.6283050775527954,
-0.38466253876686096,
0.4566538333892822,
0.4565446078777313,
-0.2641582489013672,
-0.40529459714889526,
0.3217334747314453,
0.02384776622056961,
0.30668526887893677,
0.5877810716629028,
-0.021482238546013832,
-0.5711084604263306,
-0.886889636516571,
-0.6182613372802734,
-0.000577446655370295,
-0.8630335330963135,
-0.1128394678235054,
-0.6466579437255859,
-0.301285058259964,
-0.3102373778820038,
0.035133544355630875,
-0.23929926753044128,
-0.3890441954135895,
0.020919069647789,
0.0261361226439476,
0.0763096883893013,
0.7325812578201294,
0.5768126845359802,
-0.05299163609743118,
-0.6785021424293518,
0.42330390214920044,
0.4686408042907715,
0.3760850727558136,
0.014256239868700504,
-0.8166472315788269,
-0.23323586583137512,
-0.0867428332567215,
-0.09527886658906937,
-0.5830952525138855,
-0.07787784188985825,
0.1657727062702179,
0.5121349692344666,
0.08626857399940491,
0.4654422998428345,
0.4231521785259247,
-0.49085095524787903,
0.900378406047821,
-0.15954552590847015,
-0.8915106654167175,
-0.0016206282889470458,
-0.5440256595611572,
0.9054384231567383,
0.8742303252220154,
0.5722861886024475,
-0.730211079120636,
-0.32480132579803467,
-0.20140954852104187,
-0.7363275289535522,
0.06550084054470062,
0.14607028663158417,
0.38675960898399353,
-0.054610494524240494,
0.5876343846321106,
0.314593106508255,
0.12199781835079193,
-0.6139392852783203,
0.06797963380813599,
0.39225974678993225,
-0.2783471643924713,
-0.27750664949417114,
-0.3838118016719818,
0.0035835918970406055,
-0.19369128346443176,
0.32025501132011414,
-0.3082487881183624,
-0.0748712569475174,
0.21384268999099731,
-0.03255361318588257,
0.17302747070789337,
0.4170481264591217,
0.2968531847000122,
0.7785933613777161,
-0.11609464138746262,
0.06482549756765366,
0.46416833996772766,
-0.2534855306148529,
0.02989388071000576,
0.27147573232650757,
-0.06148221343755722,
0.0185417328029871,
0.5162928700447083,
0.46424147486686707,
0.22163839638233185,
-1.1933125257492065,
0.6968833208084106,
-0.4083505868911743,
-0.27181681990623474,
-0.421719491481781,
0.00010243557335343212,
0.4003622829914093,
0.4743058979511261,
0.8213143944740295,
-0.3760715425014496,
0.23639163374900818,
-0.7916975021362305,
0.34617382287979126,
0.4986288845539093,
-0.24899713695049286,
0.06965319812297821,
0.459991455078125,
0.4748707413673401,
-0.3648291230201721,
0.24048884212970734,
-0.16497494280338287,
-0.43740811944007874,
0.6811615824699402,
0.23513558506965637,
0.7360732555389404,
0.09239917993545532,
0.08060681074857712,
0.36172258853912354,
0.25179728865623474,
0.11873146146535873,
0.2564046382904053,
-0.2749151885509491,
-0.41081956028938293,
-0.4734657108783722,
-0.701749324798584,
-0.7609811425209045,
0.2514443099498749,
-0.6343274712562561,
0.12201924622058868,
-0.5079860091209412,
-0.001751886447891593,
0.12128184735774994,
0.5419487953186035,
-0.614562451839447,
0.39403536915779114,
0.07749711722135544,
1.3058289289474487,
-0.557750403881073,
0.7289116978645325,
0.4132903516292572,
-0.09893883019685745,
-0.32418689131736755,
0.1379929929971695,
-0.2482229471206665,
-0.5513198971748352,
0.30806684494018555,
0.5429872274398804,
0.007152667734771967,
-0.19670088589191437,
-0.24753637611865997,
-0.5947399139404297,
1.1633868217468262,
0.19373124837875366,
-0.6482722759246826,
-0.2129315584897995,
0.4700726270675659,
0.6201692223548889,
-0.3290586471557617,
0.43257731199264526,
0.6919575929641724,
0.2671840190887451,
0.0863686203956604,
-0.890030026435852,
0.29642465710639954,
-0.3650115430355072,
-0.1688580960035324,
0.07625062018632889,
-0.6300256252288818,
0.890186607837677,
-0.0016337832203134894,
-0.25868067145347595,
0.807200014591217,
0.6666252613067627,
0.17281799018383026,
0.5674047470092773,
0.443441778421402,
0.3522225618362427,
1.005006194114685,
0.019846154376864433,
0.7784110903739929,
-0.04457366466522217,
0.11018078029155731,
1.4016430377960205,
-0.3924122750759125,
1.273252248764038,
0.2870210111141205,
-0.23276765644550323,
0.6239179372787476,
0.6661677360534668,
0.25504210591316223,
0.03683384135365486,
0.4859970510005951,
-0.5741490125656128,
-0.30117785930633545,
-0.15802879631519318,
-0.42284634709358215,
0.5046422481536865,
0.15133999288082123,
-0.2402651607990265,
-0.11796654760837555,
0.04515894129872322,
-0.23028583824634552,
0.37156808376312256,
-0.18638348579406738,
0.6488261222839355,
0.1217983290553093,
-0.8492588996887207,
0.6503629684448242,
0.07865989208221436,
0.6447396874427795,
-0.49552062153816223,
0.1352090835571289,
-0.48148539662361145,
0.09520763903856277,
0.1814906746149063,
-0.8840768337249756,
0.01541914138942957,
0.15401776134967804,
-0.13258132338523865,
-0.018102772533893585,
0.3131706416606903,
-0.26774483919143677,
-0.32116425037384033,
0.2836732268333435,
0.5597209334373474,
0.11590499430894852,
-0.22603240609169006,
-0.6448032855987549,
0.11782240867614746,
-0.3040030300617218,
-0.30898961424827576,
0.2927986681461334,
0.622692346572876,
0.06600434333086014,
0.7271059155464172,
0.4659733176231384,
-0.2716495096683502,
-0.15093585848808289,
-0.08571218699216843,
0.7969633936882019,
-0.9975044131278992,
-0.535637617111206,
-0.5473107099533081,
0.36800310015678406,
-0.1413726508617401,
-0.7342573404312134,
0.7821372151374817,
0.8462748527526855,
0.620786726474762,
0.3318868577480316,
0.7584831714630127,
0.3725734353065491,
0.6797516942024231,
-0.40295419096946716,
0.6456906199455261,
-0.7075363993644714,
0.2562626302242279,
-0.03330886736512184,
-0.7440558671951294,
-0.07682471722364426,
0.049668509513139725,
-0.2563992738723755,
0.04317256063222885,
0.776985228061676,
0.6004136204719543,
0.2310241460800171,
0.10435677319765091,
0.5162228941917419,
0.07482171058654785,
0.18709629774093628,
1.014062523841858,
1.2176538705825806,
-0.7272497415542603,
0.507118821144104,
0.2898493707180023,
-0.19291090965270996,
0.07354576140642166,
-0.9094074368476868,
-1.1562312841415405,
-0.6784650683403015,
-0.08480208367109299,
-0.13252004981040955,
0.12199617922306061,
0.7072442173957825,
0.4161268174648285,
-0.6807534098625183,
-0.10925302654504776,
0.18990686535835266,
-0.008310663513839245,
0.0479305274784565,
-0.15179428458213806,
0.302139550447464,
-0.21881529688835144,
-0.9505681991577148,
0.5483835935592651,
0.17307093739509583,
-0.15572188794612885,
-0.4929679334163666,
-0.15531395375728607,
-0.38958925008773804,
0.5021382570266724,
0.5868725180625916,
0.26970627903938293,
-0.6110469102859497,
-0.18711937963962555,
0.12328935414552689,
-0.2733268737792969,
-0.062274590134620667,
0.6837679743766785,
-0.8378046154975891,
0.4445717930793762,
0.6193804144859314,
1.0387240648269653,
0.3745945692062378,
0.12578371167182922,
0.6366188526153564,
-0.5716082453727722,
-0.10833729803562164,
0.5063896775245667,
0.20829632878303528,
0.3702610731124878,
-0.19867029786109924,
0.2092655450105667,
-0.20311345160007477,
-0.632391631603241,
-0.974941611289978,
0.09890047460794449,
-0.903522253036499,
-0.6281246542930603,
1.1551071405410767,
-0.30139249563217163,
-0.13180366158485413,
-0.4692671298980713,
-0.14034058153629303,
-0.008132776245474815,
-0.06114131957292557,
0.4169991910457611,
0.8281057476997375,
0.2870519459247589,
-0.19478441774845123,
-0.7363311648368835,
0.4594120681285858,
0.7224978804588318,
-0.8263710737228394,
0.21059714257717133,
0.36272674798965454,
0.22432762384414673,
-0.09473511576652527,
0.6593838930130005,
0.04755031317472458,
0.40693870186805725,
-0.024901920929551125,
-0.3652569353580475,
0.0018276117043569684,
-0.32957616448402405,
-0.516391932964325,
0.5167745351791382,
0.3165926933288574,
-0.038589298725128174
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.