id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10779v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10779v1
|
LLM-based Conversational AI Therapist for Daily Functioning Screening and Psychotherapeutic Intervention via Everyday Smart Devices
| 2024-03-16T02:48:50 | 2024-03-16T02:48:50 |
Jingping Nie, Hanya Shao, Yuang Fan, Qijia Shao, Haoxuan You, Matthias Preindl, Xiaofan Jiang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Despite the global mental health crisis, access to screenings, professionals,
and treatments remains high. In collaboration with licensed psychotherapists,
we propose a Conversational AI Therapist with psychotherapeutic Interventions
(CaiTI), a platform that leverages large language models (LLM)s and smart
devices to enable better mental health self-care. CaiTI can screen the
day-to-day functioning using natural and psychotherapeutic conversations. CaiTI
leverages reinforcement learning to provide personalized conversation flow.
CaiTI can accurately understand and interpret user responses. When the user
needs further attention during the conversation, CaiTI can provide
conversational psychotherapeutic interventions, including cognitive behavioral
therapy (CBT) and motivational interviewing (MI). Leveraging the datasets
prepared by the licensed psychotherapists, we experiment and microbenchmark
various LLMs' performance in tasks along CaiTI's conversation flow and discuss
their strengths and weaknesses. With the psychotherapists, we implement CaiTI
and conduct 14-day and 24-week studies. The study results, validated by
therapists, demonstrate that CaiTI can converse with users naturally,
accurately understand and interpret user responses, and provide
psychotherapeutic interventions appropriately and effectively. We showcase the
potential of CaiTI LLMs to assist the mental therapy diagnosis and treatment
and improve day-to-day functioning screening and precautionary
psychotherapeutic intervention systems.
|
[
-0.10335680097341537,
-0.8221427798271179,
0.7130042910575867,
0.3455076515674591,
-0.09311968833208084,
0.17611831426620483,
0.01259277667850256,
-0.5542163848876953,
0.35588207840919495,
0.30548879504203796,
-0.7710590362548828,
-0.4966779351234436,
-0.4944515526294708,
-0.18141403794288635,
-0.2139623612165451,
1.1160433292388916,
0.2405245006084442,
0.40541884303092957,
0.14235755801200867,
0.037680428475141525,
-0.8278059363365173,
-0.5256586670875549,
-1.3067814111709595,
-0.36508071422576904,
0.683037281036377,
0.3700583875179291,
0.7058056592941284,
0.07653090357780457,
0.32682350277900696,
0.2951488494873047,
0.23805730044841766,
0.24754789471626282,
-0.14818476140499115,
0.32268908619880676,
0.06482179462909698,
-0.4546900987625122,
-0.6930529475212097,
0.05763090029358864,
0.15521757304668427,
0.3949778079986572,
-0.4056597352027893,
0.11729780584573746,
0.17372557520866394,
0.21220527589321136,
-0.39774033427238464,
0.028303848579525948,
-0.2715590298175812,
0.18737977743148804,
0.16665984690189362,
0.009592578746378422,
-0.10513874888420105,
-0.43078702688217163,
-0.15481381118297577,
-0.18825003504753113,
-0.031247127801179886,
-0.2508479952812195,
0.4087246060371399,
0.46646884083747864,
-0.608920693397522,
-0.2624523937702179,
-1.0979782342910767,
0.4915531575679779,
-0.6344941854476929,
0.490924596786499,
0.5935677886009216,
0.37153494358062744,
-0.2986718714237213,
-0.4560600221157074,
-0.3492836356163025,
-0.6549695134162903,
-0.06443057209253311,
0.12368462979793549,
-0.20910191535949707,
0.29647010564804077,
0.4200957715511322,
0.14352597296237946,
-0.5219783186912537,
0.0750146359205246,
-0.12271653115749359,
-0.47890233993530273,
0.6924821138381958,
0.615445613861084,
0.5450713634490967,
0.2306772768497467,
-0.06737066805362701,
0.40100041031837463,
-0.2577769458293915,
0.2605230510234833,
-0.09543813765048981,
-0.03321199119091034,
-0.2273700088262558,
0.4508628845214844,
-0.11725103855133057,
0.41657719016075134,
0.06264474242925644,
-0.7359089255332947,
-0.4375400245189667,
-0.16388556361198425,
-0.2661571204662323,
0.24328762292861938,
0.7773006558418274,
0.33673784136772156,
-0.059723418205976486,
-0.04718869552016258,
0.011331083253026009,
-0.001306098303757608,
0.25274592638015747,
-0.7947561740875244,
-0.5043257474899292,
0.3725277781486511,
-0.14904214441776276,
-0.1173735111951828,
-0.46505528688430786,
-0.44970703125,
-0.7255299091339111,
-0.18380558490753174,
0.42066261172294617,
-0.5550352334976196,
-0.2553102374076843,
0.07527629286050797,
0.17250807583332062,
-0.11501272022724152,
0.3589700162410736,
-0.904449462890625,
0.5292116403579712,
0.5171400904655457,
1.0333802700042725,
-0.13561014831066132,
0.12281240522861481,
-0.4759758710861206,
0.3399905860424042,
-0.10186908394098282,
0.7690384984016418,
-0.19582165777683258,
-0.5431212186813354,
-0.14769381284713745,
-0.20096950232982635,
-0.6554955840110779,
-0.24264703691005707,
0.43213003873825073,
-0.22358569502830505,
0.2494656890630722,
0.055543143302202225,
-0.20758572220802307,
0.286542147397995,
0.820563793182373,
-0.32898828387260437,
0.5241296887397766,
-0.010337764397263527,
-0.8047267198562622,
-0.015478936955332756,
-1.2650115489959717,
-0.4840967655181885,
0.17395839095115662,
-0.08385175466537476,
-0.04541878029704094,
-0.2600365877151489,
0.3722337782382965,
0.3051471412181854,
-0.15492023527622223,
0.460797518491745,
-0.25867342948913574,
-0.5610402822494507,
0.5248183608055115,
-0.6915217041969299,
0.7078977823257446,
0.42886555194854736,
-0.521054208278656,
0.37226197123527527,
-0.5743532180786133,
-0.00638514943420887,
0.07194572687149048,
-0.19670157134532928,
-0.11484794318675995,
-0.11343598365783691,
0.15785594284534454,
-0.029303736984729767,
0.21504151821136475,
-0.7435992360115051,
-0.06420338898897171,
-0.3020334243774414,
0.6404096484184265,
0.5721858739852905,
0.22258403897285461,
-0.3417430520057678,
-0.4892546534538269,
0.8894965052604675,
0.06078255921602249,
0.2729993760585785,
-0.23051436245441437,
-0.39419156312942505,
-0.6604114174842834,
-0.9470770359039307,
-0.0067299967631697655,
0.8753010034561157,
-0.5236281156539917,
0.34626302123069763,
-0.33918875455856323,
-0.6088866591453552,
-0.3807529807090759,
-0.0846586525440216,
0.19898389279842377,
0.7731513381004333,
-0.05474499240517616,
-0.21538753807544708,
-0.40450921654701233,
-0.6038370132446289,
-0.2894260287284851,
-0.3029067814350128,
0.019847728312015533,
0.40995070338249207,
0.03867096081376076,
-0.7146705389022827,
0.9507529139518738,
-0.29058489203453064,
-0.36497926712036133,
-0.5770564079284668,
0.158045694231987,
0.12992343306541443,
0.3321370780467987,
0.015822548419237137,
-0.4611164629459381,
-0.5588843822479248,
0.063420869410038,
-0.7424042820930481,
-0.05031152442097664,
-0.3816479444503784,
0.19721640646457672,
0.23551715910434723,
0.402706503868103,
-0.6067813634872437,
0.4723682701587677,
0.2833000719547272,
-0.44467148184776306,
0.23035480082035065,
-0.24038700759410858,
0.24421797692775726,
-0.9376089572906494,
0.19678686559200287,
-0.012730368413031101,
-0.5728696584701538,
-0.6242318749427795,
-0.42855408787727356,
-0.44567275047302246,
-0.5722021460533142,
-0.407978355884552,
0.5760421752929688,
0.1329091191291809,
0.21938276290893555,
-0.25538310408592224,
-0.009431370534002781,
-0.38397490978240967,
0.5271568894386292,
-0.13385087251663208,
0.8512992858886719,
0.33848491311073303,
-0.45036453008651733,
0.31098419427871704,
0.16650906205177307,
-0.1312192976474762,
0.7624941468238831,
-0.5750397443771362,
0.2844026982784271,
0.12904809415340424,
0.5021483898162842,
-0.8697087168693542,
-0.2850912809371948,
0.5408838987350464,
-0.04127908870577812,
-0.08308754116296768,
0.2422211766242981,
-0.32082247734069824,
-0.20712131261825562,
-0.19082650542259216,
0.39609041810035706,
0.047832902520895004,
-0.17413583397865295,
0.49684667587280273,
0.3472099006175995,
-0.5712254643440247,
-0.15398898720741272,
-0.4149799048900604,
0.37533292174339294,
-0.5582748055458069,
-0.6871116757392883,
0.04269179701805115,
-0.2329026460647583,
-0.23915867507457733,
-0.47043225169181824,
-0.0347789004445076,
0.0820179283618927,
0.28820499777793884,
0.47446802258491516,
0.4434105455875397,
0.11883199959993362,
0.2552439570426941,
-0.005054169800132513,
-0.32353475689888,
0.2880518138408661,
-0.1960926055908203,
0.6886479258537292,
-0.4685514569282532,
-0.8466197848320007,
-0.9172264933586121,
0.3208756446838379,
0.4895525574684143,
-0.03741909936070442,
0.3844831883907318,
1.1336472034454346,
-0.3793931007385254,
0.41649898886680603,
-0.7269994020462036,
-0.33200815320014954,
-0.45923513174057007,
0.16263137757778168,
-0.5041826367378235,
-1.0682400465011597,
0.5169408321380615,
-0.014134043827652931,
-0.06383112818002701,
0.02585900016129017,
0.8263763189315796,
-0.3619098365306854,
1.6241997480392456,
0.4436652958393097,
-0.39770594239234924,
0.8993774056434631,
-0.19023148715496063,
0.6948760747909546,
-0.6080594658851624,
-0.2593621611595154,
0.036732159554958344,
-0.3705236315727234,
-0.7297528386116028,
0.0001142814799095504,
0.7577166557312012,
-0.4027509093284607,
-0.7697629332542419,
-0.08125734329223633,
-0.5605908036231995,
-0.01917288824915886,
0.7138497233390808,
0.628325343132019,
0.4310520589351654,
-0.2533666789531708,
-0.16313624382019043,
-0.5117721557617188,
-0.5190483331680298,
-0.4646558165550232,
0.9513144493103027,
0.4771086573600769,
0.9220317602157593,
-0.013337234035134315,
0.8570722937583923,
0.5375937819480896,
0.6889201402664185,
-0.9736906290054321,
0.6125152707099915,
0.4947786033153534,
-0.6579253673553467,
-0.0948222279548645,
-0.19427454471588135,
-1.059030532836914,
-0.04638794809579849,
0.19181358814239502,
-1.4905153512954712,
0.08911100029945374,
0.05713164061307907,
-0.7499008178710938,
0.10870690643787384,
-0.7172085642814636,
0.8991191983222961,
-0.7204457521438599,
-0.3546747863292694,
-0.5374906659126282,
-0.43524816632270813,
0.5228402614593506,
-0.03492593765258789,
0.3242604732513428,
-0.4366518259048462,
0.1674365997314453,
0.44208958745002747,
-0.2274160534143448,
0.9642714858055115,
-0.20994305610656738,
-0.034967150539159775,
0.242700457572937,
0.23126167058944702,
0.19459488987922668,
0.5066718459129333,
0.17612574994564056,
-0.23489581048488617,
0.6164596080780029,
-0.21182985603809357,
-0.7312718629837036,
0.6501752734184265,
-0.8153368830680847,
-0.8864200115203857,
-0.4522135853767395,
-0.6712199449539185,
-0.581857442855835,
0.13600002229213715,
-0.012903248891234398,
0.41289758682250977,
-0.41123923659324646,
-0.05768765136599541,
0.3567166030406952,
0.04986878111958504,
0.06268300116062164,
0.5512407422065735,
-0.15296058356761932,
-0.3713170886039734,
1.0263651609420776,
-0.31077060103416443,
-0.25386640429496765,
-0.06473565101623535,
0.22689694166183472,
-0.09378879517316818,
-0.30525755882263184,
0.07070335745811462,
0.16386999189853668,
-0.5193754434585571,
-0.15778444707393646,
-0.906330406665802,
-0.4743964672088623,
-0.6280322074890137,
0.06885456293821335,
-0.03587488830089569,
-0.2669897675514221,
-0.01384491566568613,
-0.011609584093093872,
0.21922896802425385,
0.44566893577575684,
-0.2309139519929886,
0.5265785455703735,
-0.7428027391433716,
0.38614335656166077,
0.46839237213134766,
0.12336428463459015,
-0.06144437566399574,
-0.20047278702259064,
-0.5558968186378479,
0.3670138120651245,
-0.8249351382255554,
-0.8229113221168518,
0.5432040095329285,
0.30165380239486694,
0.4611443281173706,
0.5078683495521545,
0.011458157561719418,
0.8695323467254639,
-0.0607430599629879,
0.7182048559188843,
0.2280258983373642,
-0.6750741600990295,
0.8086983561515808,
-0.4763636291027069,
0.19742611050605774,
0.6358174085617065,
0.30790412425994873,
-0.9606842994689941,
-0.487994909286499,
-0.44266289472579956,
-0.6878806948661804,
0.6635318398475647,
-0.04188260808587074,
0.21315346658229828,
0.05961030349135399,
0.1398693174123764,
-0.4192732572555542,
0.13859491050243378,
-0.855854332447052,
0.08117588609457016,
-0.16898927092552185,
-0.6243498921394348,
0.10170933604240417,
-0.10959033668041229,
-0.7227004766464233,
-0.3545060157775879,
0.7140145301818848,
-0.3173278570175171,
0.8027931451797485,
0.4589961767196655,
0.04734557121992111,
0.16216087341308594,
0.2280530482530594,
0.3734634518623352,
0.17658080160617828,
-0.239607036113739,
-0.1925589144229889,
0.17991550266742706,
-0.6422187089920044,
0.0787719264626503,
0.39936327934265137,
0.25387075543403625,
-0.26488548517227173,
0.18937602639198303,
0.6635133028030396,
0.2745443880558014,
-1.0956300497055054,
0.1844078004360199,
-0.3812382221221924,
0.042981456965208054,
-0.5232051610946655,
0.49276822805404663,
0.15610133111476898,
0.7410364151000977,
0.012001750990748405,
-0.35007017850875854,
0.4713168740272522,
-0.633459210395813,
0.04593462496995926,
0.6412383913993835,
-0.8226993680000305,
-0.16008418798446655,
0.7380737662315369,
0.0015384036814793944,
-0.8926864266395569,
0.7033969759941101,
0.10136255621910095,
-0.2688901424407959,
0.3869471549987793,
0.7111883759498596,
0.8683909177780151,
-0.10013138502836227,
0.3681669235229492,
-0.029671458527445793,
-0.004828060511499643,
0.26075229048728943,
0.31471240520477295,
-0.3597564101219177,
-0.7068252563476562,
0.044801805168390274,
-0.021999938413500786,
-0.7909783124923706,
0.21942190825939178,
-0.4966060221195221,
0.03955109417438507,
-0.6358441114425659,
-0.4465085566043854,
-0.03579656407237053,
0.3145306408405304,
-0.596823513507843,
0.1809413731098175,
0.4424428939819336,
0.6164764165878296,
-0.5217361450195312,
0.9533951878547668,
0.8358736038208008,
-0.2455432116985321,
-0.7850838899612427,
0.1002582311630249,
0.24657182395458221,
-0.7187251448631287,
0.24447304010391235,
0.2787344753742218,
-0.3180749714374542,
0.16642984747886658,
-0.5283599495887756,
-0.8353481888771057,
1.441234827041626,
0.7397939562797546,
-0.06836759299039841,
-0.06039322540163994,
0.3752768933773041,
0.8709923624992371,
-0.4698121249675751,
0.6560200452804565,
0.8567346930503845,
0.4911789894104004,
0.15988633036613464,
-0.9787770509719849,
-0.21242421865463257,
-0.4564986526966095,
-0.17325596511363983,
-0.19111761450767517,
-0.5873117446899414,
0.017209412530064583,
-0.16268344223499298,
-0.2780974805355072,
0.2878207266330719,
0.1707901656627655,
0.6114169359207153,
0.5894263386726379,
0.48809337615966797,
0.2425001859664917,
0.8812499642372131,
0.10189954936504364,
0.8357802629470825,
-0.7685727477073669,
0.012416600249707699,
0.9696377515792847,
-0.26012709736824036,
0.5067533850669861,
0.4012523889541626,
-0.09053114056587219,
0.5821745991706848,
0.8798134922981262,
0.15672525763511658,
0.2268337607383728,
-0.12564386427402496,
-0.7969780564308167,
-0.24119804799556732,
-0.6103055477142334,
0.1086498498916626,
0.2914482653141022,
0.6306251287460327,
-0.04735010862350464,
-0.09799060970544815,
0.5439671874046326,
0.16239722073078156,
-0.11525946110486984,
0.09006831794977188,
0.699324369430542,
0.34372586011886597,
-0.5641710758209229,
0.5451253056526184,
0.12099213153123856,
0.41113048791885376,
-0.5227028131484985,
0.3282134234905243,
-0.3678148090839386,
0.4326168894767761,
-0.1255515068769455,
-0.16191451251506805,
0.31279709935188293,
0.06781767308712006,
0.43543362617492676,
-0.5915353298187256,
0.9642014503479004,
-0.26378703117370605,
-0.7175191640853882,
0.08326275646686554,
0.592931866645813,
0.24551738798618317,
-0.1736297607421875,
-1.0106816291809082,
-0.1902880072593689,
-0.21514098346233368,
-0.1755155473947525,
0.4964194893836975,
0.09957173466682434,
-0.2627602219581604,
1.1707334518432617,
0.5900768637657166,
0.034046720713377,
-0.32808825373649597,
-0.025189055129885674,
0.8326979875564575,
-0.7121347784996033,
-0.6113265156745911,
-0.7867546081542969,
0.381609171628952,
0.03162910044193268,
-0.2203109860420227,
0.4976549744606018,
0.3548451364040375,
0.18614336848258972,
0.4219758212566376,
0.49178972840309143,
0.0014503777492791414,
0.4441549479961395,
-0.09644662588834763,
0.5826494097709656,
-0.4177497923374176,
0.2003745436668396,
0.23605488240718842,
-0.4854881763458252,
-0.27049484848976135,
0.7019399404525757,
-0.5408043265342712,
-0.06503678113222122,
0.493324875831604,
0.7657793164253235,
0.03461198881268501,
0.2597659230232239,
0.2755616307258606,
0.08371461927890778,
0.8482201099395752,
0.5459575057029724,
0.8975188732147217,
-0.13215087354183197,
0.2934686541557312,
-0.11491266638040543,
-0.09852320700883865,
-0.20068670809268951,
-0.41397520899772644,
-0.8245749473571777,
-0.243617981672287,
-0.16965602338314056,
0.03267436847090721,
0.5150998830795288,
1.2784184217453003,
0.635170042514801,
-0.5798328518867493,
-0.3508017361164093,
-0.1528545618057251,
0.17062215507030487,
-0.3008609712123871,
-0.24452176690101624,
0.05996948480606079,
-0.38714170455932617,
-0.7585433125495911,
0.5409916043281555,
0.24894456565380096,
-0.06103503704071045,
-0.4438801109790802,
-0.002920691156759858,
0.07956734299659729,
0.0260184146463871,
0.3898291289806366,
0.21935884654521942,
-0.45817556977272034,
-0.17591507732868195,
0.04190090298652649,
-0.49970513582229614,
0.33925655484199524,
0.9430076479911804,
-0.9035948514938354,
0.23678886890411377,
0.04248923808336258,
0.6753250956535339,
0.6241866946220398,
0.021766703575849533,
0.6654662489891052,
-0.06127097085118294,
0.2935616672039032,
0.5267752408981323,
0.1277991086244583,
0.13034306466579437,
-0.555427610874176,
0.41845500469207764,
0.09317239373922348,
-0.5418206453323364,
-0.7963164448738098,
0.24589021503925323,
-0.7599568367004395,
0.13592755794525146,
0.8557540774345398,
-0.42027121782302856,
0.025573842227458954,
-0.5210571885108948,
-0.6121198534965515,
0.25922513008117676,
-0.44302475452423096,
1.1457581520080566,
0.38542473316192627,
-0.6756125688552856,
-0.24060861766338348,
-0.5903245806694031,
0.3587757647037506,
0.5041106343269348,
-0.7653093934059143,
-0.45518729090690613,
0.29546406865119934,
0.3295643925666809,
-0.018750613555312157,
1.135796070098877,
0.07039733231067657,
0.13388292491436005,
-0.41457781195640564,
-0.07173606753349304,
-0.1408294290304184,
-0.07499329000711441,
-0.24099400639533997,
-0.23134927451610565,
0.10691282153129578,
-0.10439399629831314
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10774v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10774v1
|
Detecting Bias in Large Language Models: Fine-tuned KcBERT
| 2024-03-16T02:27:19 | 2024-03-16T02:27:19 |
J. K. Lee, T. M. Chung
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The rapid advancement of large language models (LLMs) has enabled natural
language processing capabilities similar to those of humans, and LLMs are being
widely utilized across various societal domains such as education and
healthcare. While the versatility of these models has increased, they have the
potential to generate subjective and normative language, leading to
discriminatory treatment or outcomes among social groups, especially due to
online offensive language. In this paper, we define such harm as societal bias
and assess ethnic, gender, and racial biases in a model fine-tuned with Korean
comments using Bidirectional Encoder Representations from Transformers (KcBERT)
and KOLD data through template-based Masked Language Modeling (MLM). To
quantitatively evaluate biases, we employ LPBS and CBS metrics. Compared to
KcBERT, the fine-tuned model shows a reduction in ethnic bias but demonstrates
significant changes in gender and racial biases. Based on these results, we
propose two methods to mitigate societal bias. Firstly, a data balancing
approach during the pre-training phase adjusts the uniformity of data by
aligning the distribution of the occurrences of specific words and converting
surrounding harmful words into non-harmful words. Secondly, during the
in-training phase, we apply Debiasing Regularization by adjusting dropout and
regularization, confirming a decrease in training loss. Our contribution lies
in demonstrating that societal bias exists in Korean language models due to
language-dependent characteristics.
|
[
-0.389019638299942,
-0.7692342400550842,
0.22520317137241364,
0.22203031182289124,
-0.11019374430179596,
0.18078941106796265,
-0.4672274887561798,
-0.31227242946624756,
0.02638998255133629,
1.0139875411987305,
-0.398013174533844,
-0.5769059658050537,
-0.6920472979545593,
0.044778190553188324,
-0.02651129849255085,
1.0804522037506104,
0.003373723942786455,
0.6875159740447998,
-0.1475270688533783,
-0.15751148760318756,
-0.4434821307659149,
-0.7870186567306519,
-0.3273850679397583,
-0.5862558484077454,
0.360991895198822,
0.3073771595954895,
0.6366456151008606,
0.3842909038066864,
0.35261213779449463,
0.238423153758049,
-0.21234558522701263,
-0.024006104096770287,
-0.8261517882347107,
0.12797458469867706,
-0.11991768330335617,
-0.411960631608963,
-0.335554838180542,
0.01626312918961048,
0.4830097556114197,
0.8388368487358093,
0.30447694659233093,
0.5182594060897827,
0.2532985210418701,
0.7699211239814758,
-0.8316594958305359,
0.01277758926153183,
-0.680044949054718,
0.10564012825489044,
-0.04677294194698334,
0.009717005304992199,
-0.4433356523513794,
-0.674704372882843,
0.029301224276423454,
-0.13821905851364136,
0.18181933462619781,
-0.2972090542316437,
0.6483909487724304,
0.462970495223999,
-0.6775861978530884,
-0.42254096269607544,
-0.7630411982536316,
0.9264976382255554,
-0.8028370141983032,
0.6434037685394287,
0.5553950667381287,
0.11761320382356644,
-0.2029394656419754,
-0.29688480496406555,
-0.4337868094444275,
-0.5162307620048523,
-0.07830344885587692,
0.014088230207562447,
0.14734148979187012,
0.24183115363121033,
0.28003600239753723,
-0.14773447811603546,
-0.37262749671936035,
0.2977880537509918,
-0.42606669664382935,
-0.5153011083602905,
0.7940649390220642,
0.12520118057727814,
0.41987574100494385,
-0.3190600275993347,
-0.0833408311009407,
0.07521795481443405,
-0.735840916633606,
-0.06354068219661713,
0.8552552461624146,
0.380863755941391,
-0.08492116630077362,
0.5815723538398743,
-0.31000155210494995,
0.31440621614456177,
0.21527282893657684,
-0.23849201202392578,
0.23996303975582123,
-0.13733893632888794,
-0.13539965450763702,
0.3969067335128784,
0.5677765011787415,
0.775317370891571,
0.7592703104019165,
-0.1811402440071106,
0.13380099833011627,
0.566927433013916,
0.22008860111236572,
-0.8664729595184326,
-0.15067188441753387,
-0.002195516601204872,
-0.7113274335861206,
-0.6106120944023132,
-0.36106187105178833,
-0.9080095887184143,
-0.7411932349205017,
-0.3931327760219574,
0.01711689680814743,
0.08604573458433151,
-0.18515115976333618,
0.14655017852783203,
0.10928700119256973,
-0.011214567348361015,
-0.05858851969242096,
-0.6726037859916687,
0.15306921303272247,
0.46602100133895874,
0.4895070195198059,
-0.05755438283085823,
0.26561102271080017,
-0.25845590233802795,
0.10800869017839432,
-0.25069719552993774,
0.340874582529068,
-0.7050994038581848,
-0.17790599167346954,
0.17641417682170868,
0.07389519363641739,
0.23276537656784058,
-0.6857686042785645,
0.9030000567436218,
-0.4927186369895935,
0.0056862724013626575,
-0.3428588807582855,
-0.4078863561153412,
-0.019160151481628418,
0.14161376655101776,
-0.493032306432724,
0.8820154666900635,
-0.019896250218153,
-1.0038789510726929,
0.6170171499252319,
-0.3960084319114685,
-0.36459028720855713,
-0.019745489582419395,
-0.08547326922416687,
-0.489180326461792,
-0.11550091952085495,
0.18057581782341003,
0.4568788707256317,
-0.08389085531234741,
0.49928292632102966,
-0.6920773983001709,
-0.21420808136463165,
0.14948832988739014,
-0.3136841952800751,
0.8293125033378601,
0.18832169473171234,
-0.4782090485095978,
0.12908954918384552,
-0.6491541862487793,
0.05401432886719704,
-0.012177318334579468,
-0.3770657479763031,
-0.6301285624504089,
0.017918236553668976,
0.2768840491771698,
0.4746752679347992,
0.0881783664226532,
-0.5728839635848999,
-0.16153891384601593,
-0.3859791159629822,
0.24130244553089142,
0.9365876317024231,
-0.2511932849884033,
0.6851718425750732,
-0.014694453217089176,
0.4904952645301819,
0.07607780396938324,
0.17210426926612854,
0.26270902156829834,
-0.15112824738025665,
-0.6807986497879028,
-0.24293117225170135,
0.3486345410346985,
0.4802722632884979,
-0.7481923699378967,
0.5410547256469727,
-0.2649529278278351,
-0.41240963339805603,
-0.6124427914619446,
0.1061176210641861,
0.3817182779312134,
0.4804302752017975,
0.0759861171245575,
-0.2733937203884125,
-0.8275552988052368,
-1.1970100402832031,
-0.5738570690155029,
0.0045775738544762135,
-0.21278168261051178,
0.4640176296234131,
0.4078838527202606,
-0.5012032985687256,
0.8329136371612549,
-0.3737085163593292,
-0.18508516252040863,
-0.1343609243631363,
-0.008561420254409313,
-0.13295906782150269,
0.35007816553115845,
0.3874067962169647,
-0.5540410876274109,
-0.7249832153320312,
-0.15964211523532867,
-0.5910089612007141,
-0.65432208776474,
0.054378073662519455,
-0.05262120068073273,
0.2065119743347168,
0.6538811326026917,
-0.35777392983436584,
0.4041111171245575,
0.5046274065971375,
-0.37867072224617004,
0.6153979301452637,
0.23056179285049438,
0.17954868078231812,
-0.7492916584014893,
-0.10700751096010208,
0.18961796164512634,
-0.24785633385181427,
-0.8766524195671082,
-0.05688862502574921,
0.08962421119213104,
0.24746708571910858,
-0.27566105127334595,
0.46594810485839844,
-0.22571931779384613,
0.2554933726787567,
-0.4130876660346985,
0.1806337535381317,
-0.25276613235473633,
0.27996477484703064,
-0.0851365402340889,
0.4105679392814636,
0.21738013625144958,
-0.6265010237693787,
0.05087330937385559,
-0.043908365070819855,
-0.34683990478515625,
0.4345566928386688,
-0.5941573977470398,
0.31315913796424866,
-0.599216639995575,
0.5255098342895508,
-0.7267594337463379,
-0.298322856426239,
0.4737536311149597,
-0.474491685628891,
0.01128046028316021,
-0.2945809066295624,
-0.3319418728351593,
-0.28023532032966614,
-0.3009697198867798,
0.45958372950553894,
0.331716388463974,
-0.3491685092449188,
0.24626564979553223,
0.7913503646850586,
-0.2131938636302948,
-0.6400795578956604,
-0.45804688334465027,
-0.012195941060781479,
-0.4427194595336914,
-0.583237886428833,
0.07110195606946945,
-0.0032127578742802143,
-0.3966779112815857,
-0.3363860249519348,
-0.021161120384931564,
-0.019252192229032516,
0.11027450114488602,
0.1544908732175827,
0.3503625988960266,
0.0428839772939682,
0.15461169183254242,
0.13653601706027985,
0.11033035069704056,
0.2325875163078308,
-0.18981142342090607,
0.8783624768257141,
0.09264500439167023,
-0.05244945362210274,
-0.033499184995889664,
0.08385731279850006,
0.5759060382843018,
0.059769902378320694,
0.7444157600402832,
0.5936360955238342,
-0.5171808004379272,
0.08878255635499954,
-0.6419395208358765,
-0.41700291633605957,
-0.46164068579673767,
0.843157172203064,
0.21960851550102234,
-1.166475534439087,
0.4693954885005951,
-0.10127535462379456,
-0.15808804333209991,
0.0680612102150917,
0.909661591053009,
0.20419618487358093,
1.3677562475204468,
0.4146858751773834,
-0.4204348623752594,
0.3084683418273926,
0.1789865642786026,
0.5552895069122314,
-0.7387431859970093,
-0.151141956448555,
-0.6082847118377686,
-0.2837930917739868,
-0.9573188424110413,
-0.2918236553668976,
0.26323267817497253,
0.1830170601606369,
-0.5172706842422485,
-0.012346907518804073,
-0.367570161819458,
0.5727157592773438,
0.15623152256011963,
0.13839423656463623,
0.02345537208020687,
-0.06983531266450882,
-0.2456260770559311,
-0.49282175302505493,
-0.5350397825241089,
-0.9398714303970337,
1.280224323272705,
0.6004810929298401,
0.8801729083061218,
-0.1964726448059082,
0.28424984216690063,
0.4536070227622986,
0.5082425475120544,
-0.5868149399757385,
0.46983984112739563,
-0.19322092831134796,
-0.8707531094551086,
-0.16898375749588013,
-0.5304760932922363,
-0.7223622798919678,
0.23571765422821045,
-0.25193682312965393,
-0.9421788454055786,
0.11363722383975983,
0.36656486988067627,
0.014812690205872059,
0.20428740978240967,
-0.6151108145713806,
0.5829973816871643,
-0.14162500202655792,
-0.4478524625301361,
-0.15737763047218323,
-0.575007438659668,
0.5779711008071899,
-0.1348423957824707,
0.2392996847629547,
-0.30820536613464355,
0.2452065795660019,
0.5757959485054016,
-0.0327063612639904,
1.0477334260940552,
-0.292866051197052,
-0.23259340226650238,
-0.07895052433013916,
-0.06102101132273674,
0.5030611753463745,
0.00014422382810153067,
-0.018376875668764114,
0.3892415761947632,
-0.27368396520614624,
-0.3723040223121643,
-0.27023136615753174,
0.6653257608413696,
-0.7696017622947693,
-0.1923070102930069,
-0.08002844452857971,
-0.5490749478340149,
-0.29074764251708984,
0.21717777848243713,
0.3123335540294647,
0.10837478190660477,
-0.22267787158489227,
0.15194545686244965,
0.6437886953353882,
-0.6282156109809875,
-0.034169189631938934,
0.41760528087615967,
-0.17061595618724823,
-0.4336104989051819,
0.7109379768371582,
0.04898267239332199,
0.4575890302658081,
-0.2141636461019516,
0.20470529794692993,
-0.25197213888168335,
-0.24073314666748047,
-0.30404606461524963,
0.06564746052026749,
-0.7925663590431213,
-0.0760357528924942,
-0.7266777753829956,
-0.1666174829006195,
-0.6797276735305786,
-0.1335083246231079,
-0.45334935188293457,
-0.1546027511358261,
-0.03404969722032547,
0.03760375455021858,
-0.0892949178814888,
0.587593674659729,
0.21217888593673706,
0.47418713569641113,
-0.5534408688545227,
0.2811611294746399,
0.01109353732317686,
0.49771979451179504,
0.17294616997241974,
-0.5553010106086731,
-0.2396697700023651,
0.3928500711917877,
-0.3109927177429199,
-0.7923917770385742,
0.40150967240333557,
-0.10239161550998688,
0.436222642660141,
0.4532141089439392,
0.25864094495773315,
0.4005438983440399,
-0.46765196323394775,
0.6359556317329407,
0.13908803462982178,
-0.7757428288459778,
0.22150985896587372,
-0.3608224391937256,
0.34411758184432983,
0.4892778992652893,
0.4842071533203125,
-0.9642881751060486,
-0.6789912581443787,
-0.350710928440094,
-0.8838344812393188,
0.6182442903518677,
0.15083998441696167,
0.29917284846305847,
-0.17325671017169952,
0.19301959872245789,
0.061976250261068344,
0.32224172353744507,
-0.9717188477516174,
-0.4256279170513153,
-0.19050849974155426,
-0.3647156357765198,
0.14244161546230316,
-0.3951650559902191,
0.04426617547869682,
-0.3340012729167938,
0.8091381192207336,
-0.13567784428596497,
-0.025486893951892853,
0.04003000259399414,
-0.4295427203178406,
-0.20906750857830048,
0.4352870285511017,
0.6651479005813599,
0.44916030764579773,
-0.06172262132167816,
0.13207434117794037,
0.26155519485473633,
-0.8192217946052551,
0.18273423612117767,
-0.21936315298080444,
-0.6481325626373291,
-0.0059172906912863255,
0.19287315011024475,
0.7821022272109985,
0.09923892468214035,
-0.7173899412155151,
0.30919089913368225,
0.06328950822353363,
-0.07756504416465759,
-0.12892110645771027,
-0.14179053902626038,
0.06167016178369522,
0.10502181947231293,
0.029647255316376686,
0.021812088787555695,
0.20044776797294617,
-0.3142327070236206,
0.02747366391122341,
0.6277738213539124,
-0.6313786506652832,
-0.19578607380390167,
0.5262769460678101,
0.32805126905441284,
-0.24747999012470245,
0.3597348630428314,
-0.06278813630342484,
-1.034936785697937,
0.5745980739593506,
0.5310207605361938,
0.8806597590446472,
-0.2692379951477051,
0.3559677302837372,
0.4939008951187134,
0.5918505191802979,
0.031058084219694138,
-0.04607587680220604,
0.290552020072937,
-1.016528844833374,
-0.3918783962726593,
-0.6106805801391602,
0.026567816734313965,
0.4608803391456604,
-0.7149884104728699,
0.27901405096054077,
-0.5060072541236877,
-0.30807408690452576,
0.0967547670006752,
-0.10081067681312561,
-0.6206391453742981,
0.03491082042455673,
0.34986045956611633,
0.4701966941356659,
-1.1289043426513672,
0.5413772463798523,
0.5740748643875122,
0.033331651240587234,
-0.40788114070892334,
0.2678506076335907,
0.08623185008764267,
-0.6797915697097778,
0.95863276720047,
0.3188270330429077,
-0.17047089338302612,
-0.2885569632053375,
-0.7337183356285095,
-0.6898941993713379,
0.33735141158103943,
0.5848825573921204,
-0.6276775002479553,
0.3722659647464752,
0.5935196280479431,
0.6433851718902588,
-0.2800743877887726,
0.21270568668842316,
0.8512601852416992,
0.41826796531677246,
-0.36005091667175293,
-0.9458212852478027,
0.03883485496044159,
0.014882243238389492,
0.06569643318653107,
0.3587423264980316,
-0.4905361235141754,
0.4856775104999542,
0.19406194984912872,
-0.12887844443321228,
-0.36983543634414673,
0.2652488946914673,
0.15161025524139404,
0.3749192953109741,
0.5835767388343811,
0.2650563418865204,
0.713208019733429,
0.07351648807525635,
0.6415738463401794,
-0.28202059864997864,
0.3576732277870178,
1.094667673110962,
-0.46457162499427795,
0.2013205736875534,
0.4040868878364563,
-0.0781145840883255,
0.15408086776733398,
0.502859354019165,
0.16674697399139404,
0.569238543510437,
0.6226162910461426,
-0.35571205615997314,
-0.24600863456726074,
-0.4491831660270691,
-0.11888602375984192,
0.5104805827140808,
0.23204673826694489,
-0.5292675495147705,
-0.10596363246440887,
0.18576224148273468,
0.36541715264320374,
0.34894970059394836,
-0.538140594959259,
0.5929343104362488,
0.026514749974012375,
-0.5606472492218018,
0.46143123507499695,
0.22341252863407135,
1.0637305974960327,
-0.3273409307003021,
0.10085352510213852,
-0.12081366032361984,
0.29956820607185364,
-0.23132506012916565,
-0.30900758504867554,
0.15952524542808533,
0.10515403002500534,
-0.34166619181632996,
0.03592822700738907,
1.1401798725128174,
-0.6563835740089417,
-0.7013764381408691,
0.40537354350090027,
0.09103469550609589,
-0.09772041440010071,
0.03182404860854149,
-0.5526348352432251,
0.11150471866130829,
0.12348132580518723,
0.10970157384872437,
0.4017188251018524,
0.05926242843270302,
-0.45603153109550476,
0.7112166285514832,
0.5534690022468567,
0.2956930100917816,
0.22186194360256195,
0.44693973660469055,
0.7917028069496155,
-0.35824161767959595,
-0.4097174108028412,
-1.0308382511138916,
0.15714986622333527,
-0.3572196960449219,
-0.08643633127212524,
0.7728012204170227,
0.3945483863353729,
1.036492109298706,
-0.18549960851669312,
0.9339883923530579,
0.17017762362957,
0.4474307894706726,
-0.322125107049942,
0.9657922983169556,
-0.08452891558408737,
0.10190838575363159,
-0.6409198641777039,
-0.7594046592712402,
-0.2212788611650467,
0.6890998482704163,
-0.4518798291683197,
0.22214047610759735,
0.2781549096107483,
0.9755148887634277,
0.13665468990802765,
-0.010839974507689476,
0.1923540234565735,
0.37093570828437805,
0.23526979982852936,
0.12866626679897308,
0.755073606967926,
-0.17861975729465485,
0.3121941387653351,
-0.15457166731357574,
-0.24294741451740265,
-0.19285744428634644,
-0.8128093481063843,
-1.209429144859314,
-0.12977278232574463,
-0.22699707746505737,
-0.4941379427909851,
0.11646182835102081,
1.0944665670394897,
0.5836729407310486,
-0.8963216543197632,
-0.18095695972442627,
0.1355370283126831,
0.259368360042572,
0.23786605894565582,
-0.2915146052837372,
0.17317408323287964,
-0.206716850399971,
-0.6383302211761475,
-0.17380273342132568,
0.07232256233692169,
-0.2640079855918884,
-0.4723066985607147,
-0.29562607407569885,
0.061396192759275436,
0.05507969856262207,
0.8266717791557312,
-0.22474078834056854,
-0.7310188412666321,
-0.5498297214508057,
-0.03083045221865177,
-0.13218079507350922,
-0.2282029688358307,
0.906121551990509,
-0.5236259698867798,
0.5533468127250671,
0.38971957564353943,
0.4705706536769867,
0.08913995325565338,
-0.12095435708761215,
0.6839891672134399,
-0.6641620397567749,
0.21209920942783356,
0.44134679436683655,
0.1291263848543167,
0.3731749355792999,
-0.6536287665367126,
0.28892943263053894,
0.03220178559422493,
-0.7252201437950134,
-0.9718474745750427,
0.3744526207447052,
-0.42263680696487427,
-0.2009238749742508,
1.2896593809127808,
0.19755995273590088,
0.01404582429677248,
-0.5038929581642151,
-0.3932882845401764,
0.5563308596611023,
-0.2677033841609955,
1.1765762567520142,
0.843835175037384,
0.3684428036212921,
0.15651482343673706,
-0.9415915608406067,
0.6747859120368958,
0.4365033209323883,
-0.6036245822906494,
0.31203415989875793,
0.5661031603813171,
0.46596595644950867,
-0.0988348200917244,
0.38578611612319946,
-0.13754147291183472,
0.1374298334121704,
-0.30689534544944763,
0.35043495893478394,
0.36730456352233887,
-0.02666601911187172,
-0.3268083333969116,
-0.2067890167236328,
-0.1700718104839325,
0.04019675776362419
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10764v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10764v1
|
ECRC: Emotion-Causality Recognition in Korean Conversation for GCN
| 2024-03-16T02:07:31 | 2024-03-16T02:07:31 |
J. K. Lee, T. M. Chung
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In this multi-task learning study on simultaneous analysis of emotions and
their underlying causes in conversational contexts, deep neural network methods
were employed to effectively process and train large labeled datasets. However,
these approaches are typically limited to conducting context analyses across
the entire corpus because they rely on one of the two methods: word- or
sentence-level embedding. The former struggles with polysemy and homonyms,
whereas the latter causes information loss when processing long sentences. In
this study, we overcome the limitations of previous embeddings by utilizing
both word- and sentence-level embeddings. Furthermore, we propose the
emotion-causality recognition in conversation (ECRC) model, which is based on a
novel graph structure, thereby leveraging the strengths of both embedding
methods. This model uniquely integrates the bidirectional long short-term
memory (Bi-LSTM) and graph neural network (GCN) models for Korean conversation
analysis. Compared with models that rely solely on one embedding method, the
proposed model effectively structures abstract concepts, such as language
features and relationships, thereby minimizing information loss. To assess
model performance, we compared the multi-task learning results of three deep
neural network models with varying graph structures. Additionally, we evaluated
the proposed model using Korean and English datasets. The experimental results
show that the proposed model performs better in emotion and causality
multi-task learning (74.62% and 75.30%, respectively) when node and edge
characteristics are incorporated into the graph structure. Similar results were
recorded for the Korean ECC and Wellness datasets (74.62% and 73.44%,
respectively) with 71.35% on the IEMOCAP English dataset.
|
[
-0.3210785984992981,
-1.047091007232666,
0.5630536079406738,
0.2050398588180542,
-0.30677613615989685,
-0.06354638189077377,
-0.4457791745662689,
-0.4880196154117584,
0.34941211342811584,
0.23707428574562073,
-0.517105758190155,
-0.6914176344871521,
-0.6462368965148926,
0.07697651535272598,
0.11789920181035995,
0.8753525018692017,
-0.30158770084381104,
0.16145263612270355,
-0.3363506495952606,
-0.31515786051750183,
-0.40394386649131775,
-0.6972348093986511,
-0.9225897789001465,
-0.39383774995803833,
0.9905344247817993,
0.3471565246582031,
0.2032945454120636,
0.25306254625320435,
0.33158960938453674,
0.41977033019065857,
-0.11251724511384964,
0.32405710220336914,
-0.5706294775009155,
0.27478453516960144,
0.15662755072116852,
-0.09016559273004532,
-0.41518813371658325,
-0.1920987069606781,
0.2532614469528198,
0.6433956027030945,
-0.0037393849343061447,
-0.0808011069893837,
0.1781506985425949,
0.7049388289451599,
-0.5492666959762573,
0.771146833896637,
-0.27733832597732544,
0.20029999315738678,
0.2100120633840561,
-0.050598498433828354,
-0.36730876564979553,
-0.12150734663009644,
0.3048645257949829,
-0.2313433736562729,
-0.03662599250674248,
0.00152529776096344,
0.6604576110839844,
0.1683695912361145,
-1.0365034341812134,
-0.6196085214614868,
-0.5509653091430664,
0.3180226981639862,
-0.570353627204895,
0.41845977306365967,
0.15624909102916718,
-0.013619165867567062,
0.08601099252700806,
-0.5556107759475708,
-0.5603442788124084,
-0.2600644528865814,
-0.34705424308776855,
0.5065516233444214,
-0.43215295672416687,
0.4287310540676117,
0.17482636868953705,
-0.03851088508963585,
-0.6267645955085754,
0.21219204366207123,
-0.24207085371017456,
-0.17696957290172577,
0.34106460213661194,
0.4394558370113373,
0.3485249876976013,
-0.5221856832504272,
-0.24388191103935242,
-0.15756317973136902,
-0.39858636260032654,
0.14104293286800385,
0.42468228936195374,
0.4704812169075012,
-0.24658547341823578,
0.33099237084388733,
-0.1897711157798767,
0.16781213879585266,
-0.03396886587142944,
0.07422798871994019,
0.27899837493896484,
-0.1325330287218094,
-0.22311069071292877,
0.28960850834846497,
0.8925392627716064,
0.38003209233283997,
0.015552839264273643,
-0.20981010794639587,
0.44422847032546997,
0.4320489168167114,
0.017236068844795227,
-0.9965476989746094,
-0.23854295909404755,
0.41409286856651306,
-0.5869081020355225,
-0.04030885919928551,
0.10809863358736038,
-0.7744038701057434,
-0.3652307391166687,
-0.5516818761825562,
-0.2768609821796417,
-0.15112359821796417,
-0.28386637568473816,
0.049568746238946915,
0.22694368660449982,
-0.21195846796035767,
0.1880379021167755,
-0.3208887279033661,
0.33575835824012756,
0.5196136832237244,
0.7685266733169556,
-0.14789865911006927,
-0.1925758570432663,
-0.242552250623703,
-0.03260714188218117,
0.017800578847527504,
0.5088553428649902,
-0.2959112823009491,
-0.08740440011024475,
0.16591833531856537,
0.4820944368839264,
-0.39981499314308167,
-0.1774808019399643,
0.793205738067627,
-0.4005216360092163,
0.16341660916805267,
-0.2098369300365448,
-0.6243115067481995,
-0.5095431804656982,
0.28943100571632385,
-0.786746621131897,
0.7622831463813782,
-0.289512038230896,
-0.9245960116386414,
0.017415590584278107,
-0.41060635447502136,
-0.6096316576004028,
-0.28059476613998413,
-0.116876982152462,
-0.5769128203392029,
0.07082728296518326,
0.020528187975287437,
0.9035359025001526,
-0.21215549111366272,
0.5860801935195923,
-0.6384841203689575,
0.0510997399687767,
0.12533697485923767,
-0.3511313199996948,
0.4544954299926758,
0.06406569480895996,
-0.37180382013320923,
0.27351540327072144,
-0.6349889636039734,
0.0017080038087442517,
-0.08105507493019104,
-0.059373486787080765,
-0.5902233123779297,
0.019717298448085785,
0.011300556361675262,
0.9181769490242004,
-0.08652663230895996,
-0.6548221707344055,
-0.28086352348327637,
-0.10411711037158966,
0.45213937759399414,
0.5960020422935486,
-0.05100899934768677,
0.27175256609916687,
0.1279037892818451,
0.3861581087112427,
0.44482892751693726,
-0.2446274310350418,
-0.16189557313919067,
-0.22368301451206207,
-0.7774741649627686,
-0.13115984201431274,
-0.08574967086315155,
0.7599229216575623,
-0.6245585083961487,
0.5012272596359253,
-0.1998973786830902,
-0.41292592883110046,
-0.2719012498855591,
-0.09249076247215271,
0.6680771708488464,
0.7867028713226318,
0.23422476649284363,
-0.2311597317457199,
-0.6815450191497803,
-0.765064537525177,
-0.11106370389461517,
-0.06795647740364075,
0.21823112666606903,
1.0679982900619507,
0.6009779572486877,
-0.19107262790203094,
0.3979596197605133,
-0.40138232707977295,
-0.14327672123908997,
-0.3133671283721924,
0.5379340052604675,
0.07484504580497742,
0.21285511553287506,
0.1616300642490387,
-0.7139555811882019,
-0.6387131810188293,
0.11444583535194397,
-0.8256864547729492,
-0.11224883049726486,
-0.16897529363632202,
-0.16459612548351288,
0.22341439127922058,
0.5992408990859985,
-0.6717957258224487,
0.6290997862815857,
0.5912231206893921,
-0.5423234701156616,
0.3010469377040863,
-0.19010360538959503,
0.24379773437976837,
-1.1335104703903198,
0.039653975516557693,
0.2564173638820648,
-0.15372371673583984,
-0.853492796421051,
-0.4223083257675171,
0.1997876763343811,
-0.14247432351112366,
-0.48321962356567383,
0.46967798471450806,
-0.47205254435539246,
0.15831536054611206,
-0.3100946545600891,
0.5197826027870178,
-0.05079197511076927,
0.9361878037452698,
0.10117451101541519,
0.1068914383649826,
0.3452845811843872,
-0.6457923650741577,
0.5003871917724609,
0.33623331785202026,
-0.2570064663887024,
0.8229214549064636,
-0.6852941513061523,
0.3374863862991333,
-0.40798136591911316,
0.4968416392803192,
-1.1539015769958496,
-0.14941591024398804,
0.4210349917411804,
-0.18954575061798096,
0.41671767830848694,
0.024744996801018715,
-0.221594899892807,
-0.5666842460632324,
-0.008384143002331257,
0.3666163980960846,
0.09062932431697845,
-0.3605804145336151,
0.6670897006988525,
0.3416801393032074,
-0.35364586114883423,
-0.3484075367450714,
-0.4972101151943207,
-0.02318245731294155,
-0.3450961709022522,
-0.7503944039344788,
0.3899724781513214,
0.141062393784523,
0.13358107209205627,
0.06973119080066681,
0.002633314812555909,
0.19217991828918457,
-0.14298489689826965,
0.6016629338264465,
0.2515397071838379,
-0.07217204570770264,
0.3689725697040558,
-0.018187373876571655,
-0.1991139054298401,
0.25416240096092224,
0.024597791954874992,
0.6629753112792969,
-0.26066476106643677,
-0.23551076650619507,
-0.5865775346755981,
0.5761004090309143,
0.486206978559494,
-0.023834573104977608,
0.8105936646461487,
0.7845447063446045,
-0.34409239888191223,
0.2390749454498291,
-0.38639646768569946,
-0.027220528572797775,
-0.3720446527004242,
0.9758377075195312,
-0.17559821903705597,
-1.1167372465133667,
0.8625806570053101,
-0.5002099275588989,
-0.5761043429374695,
0.3681240677833557,
0.7165336012840271,
-0.16612084209918976,
1.080000877380371,
0.40231549739837646,
-0.45425570011138916,
0.4549707770347595,
-0.08895719051361084,
0.5255727767944336,
-1.134416103363037,
-0.3799726366996765,
-0.5084989070892334,
-0.548255980014801,
-0.6282177567481995,
-0.25341084599494934,
0.3395889699459076,
-0.00425066938623786,
-0.6547235250473022,
0.1427554190158844,
-0.17178396880626678,
0.17219692468643188,
0.1325943022966385,
0.5008772015571594,
-0.04742494970560074,
-0.1528061032295227,
-0.05879366397857666,
-0.07917433977127075,
-0.6890007853507996,
-0.25513914227485657,
0.7574654221534729,
0.3157867193222046,
0.523280680179596,
-0.13929904997348785,
0.5258145332336426,
-0.12311799079179764,
0.2855096757411957,
-0.7562551498413086,
0.5166746377944946,
-0.26798564195632935,
-0.1787032037973404,
-0.25382328033447266,
-0.7938002347946167,
-1.1027885675430298,
0.22519543766975403,
-0.04660046473145485,
-1.0952225923538208,
0.234927698969841,
-0.023396676406264305,
-0.049344178289175034,
0.2861999273300171,
-0.5808442831039429,
1.1307867765426636,
-0.3307521343231201,
-0.26140090823173523,
-0.25370436906814575,
-0.7481470704078674,
0.30980363488197327,
0.3176824748516083,
0.1640189290046692,
-0.20721030235290527,
0.3957085609436035,
0.7572874426841736,
-0.22027753293514252,
1.075722336769104,
-0.13823166489601135,
0.14799585938453674,
0.22742688655853271,
-0.10623686760663986,
0.8860305547714233,
0.01180294994264841,
0.2483469843864441,
0.17757607996463776,
-0.4754071533679962,
-0.07044024020433426,
-0.6677234768867493,
0.6552051305770874,
-0.7648320198059082,
-0.30116918683052063,
-0.14566168189048767,
-0.5798966884613037,
-0.21719364821910858,
0.13823221623897552,
0.07499534636735916,
0.3768843114376068,
-0.40321803092956543,
0.3016435205936432,
0.5003858804702759,
-0.411565899848938,
0.3908553123474121,
0.26989153027534485,
0.07269265502691269,
-0.6088311076164246,
0.7327812910079956,
-0.10990922898054123,
0.23591570556163788,
0.17812789976596832,
0.2273891419172287,
-0.11945763230323792,
0.14873963594436646,
-0.05015520378947258,
0.250652015209198,
-0.7604306936264038,
-0.3167305886745453,
-0.9216051697731018,
-0.09917028993368149,
-0.3104223906993866,
0.03823680430650711,
-0.37780073285102844,
-0.09747271984815598,
-0.32316771149635315,
-0.3112918436527252,
0.30561017990112305,
0.3987976908683777,
0.11742743104696274,
0.23113657534122467,
-0.6079394817352295,
0.25598323345184326,
0.21886086463928223,
0.23351427912712097,
0.48679524660110474,
-0.16067273914813995,
-0.306608647108078,
0.26010072231292725,
-0.39940422773361206,
-1.0253580808639526,
0.5414753556251526,
0.18359380960464478,
0.27282842993736267,
0.5422910451889038,
-0.007592902984470129,
0.7873668074607849,
-0.5135679244995117,
0.47614961862564087,
0.5253757238388062,
-0.9033894538879395,
0.22195766866207123,
-0.18037866055965424,
0.1395483911037445,
0.32012173533439636,
0.5604942440986633,
-1.0868110656738281,
-0.2767452001571655,
-0.6213164925575256,
-1.12691068649292,
0.6510841846466064,
0.07260648906230927,
0.20822040736675262,
-0.21496495604515076,
0.16086198389530182,
-0.2261781096458435,
0.2549217641353607,
-0.6050277948379517,
-0.5260613560676575,
-0.042043302208185196,
-0.44654616713523865,
-0.01730317249894142,
-0.32443708181381226,
-0.15842196345329285,
-0.3164132535457611,
0.4208914637565613,
-0.15429869294166565,
0.6354272961616516,
0.27878549695014954,
-0.05807715654373169,
-0.012743553146719933,
0.32033443450927734,
0.5454885959625244,
0.06450159102678299,
-0.03761366754770279,
0.17128902673721313,
0.23690342903137207,
-0.35545507073402405,
0.06702699512243271,
0.20065703988075256,
0.39567965269088745,
-0.07481376081705093,
0.305702805519104,
1.3591196537017822,
0.5348103046417236,
-0.3087807297706604,
0.4410852789878845,
-0.0394805446267128,
-0.11964693665504456,
-0.0566830113530159,
-0.5001320242881775,
0.4135732054710388,
0.5028557181358337,
-0.08091405779123306,
-0.24209429323673248,
0.13432708382606506,
-0.6500896215438843,
0.1626434475183487,
0.2782919704914093,
-0.5824083089828491,
-0.3441469669342041,
0.5027483105659485,
0.1140698492527008,
-0.048180531710386276,
0.756637454032898,
-0.28150850534439087,
-1.040574073791504,
0.9925609230995178,
0.6265921592712402,
1.0824955701828003,
-0.23228996992111206,
0.515844464302063,
0.5152224898338318,
-0.17556606233119965,
-0.01960538700222969,
0.4417482614517212,
0.09396138787269592,
-0.7907459139823914,
-0.34059327840805054,
-0.11535461246967316,
-0.44108426570892334,
-0.18283596634864807,
-0.7646805644035339,
0.04131234064698219,
0.07092338055372238,
-0.1849740445613861,
-0.23456725478172302,
-0.06072232499718666,
-1.0585695505142212,
0.06490108370780945,
0.3362836241722107,
0.29071009159088135,
-1.014050841331482,
0.6328438520431519,
0.42010846734046936,
-0.2035594880580902,
-1.0450736284255981,
-0.4880451261997223,
0.017647942528128624,
-0.47369784116744995,
0.8107268810272217,
0.34936952590942383,
0.03177589550614357,
-0.31096315383911133,
-0.26681262254714966,
-0.7787801027297974,
1.401664137840271,
0.22697092592716217,
-0.619144856929779,
0.06261447817087173,
0.15812121331691742,
0.6678872108459473,
-0.6998853087425232,
0.4886627495288849,
0.24053603410720825,
0.34960970282554626,
0.003513675881549716,
-0.8130049705505371,
0.25152793526649475,
-0.3135475814342499,
-0.174960196018219,
0.2782215178012848,
-0.8223910927772522,
0.904834508895874,
-0.011955853551626205,
-0.3121146559715271,
-0.31473085284233093,
0.573261022567749,
0.2853991687297821,
0.721887469291687,
0.39075398445129395,
0.6332505345344543,
1.0854672193527222,
-0.12391157448291779,
0.9224159121513367,
-0.4863532483577728,
0.5950879454612732,
1.2761619091033936,
-0.425717294216156,
0.5681425333023071,
0.30570539832115173,
-0.13046909868717194,
0.6749267578125,
0.5493912100791931,
0.32020819187164307,
0.5269182324409485,
0.329211950302124,
-0.05995038524270058,
-0.06554065644741058,
-0.20622605085372925,
-0.12513671815395355,
0.2504742741584778,
0.3966733515262604,
-0.465960830450058,
-0.14179156720638275,
0.2531224191188812,
0.49429208040237427,
-0.4462655186653137,
-0.40302449464797974,
0.722618579864502,
0.44135797023773193,
-0.35242533683776855,
0.1225397139787674,
-0.25487396121025085,
0.4962444305419922,
-0.4610666036605835,
0.15014073252677917,
-0.1684538871049881,
0.034099966287612915,
-0.2794345021247864,
-0.2352566123008728,
0.23942160606384277,
-0.17697933316230774,
0.010081465356051922,
-0.09301374107599258,
0.9329727292060852,
-0.903833270072937,
-0.41460540890693665,
0.5931985974311829,
0.5108956098556519,
0.01553120743483305,
-0.1603061556816101,
-0.6041970252990723,
-0.03228643536567688,
-0.3699282109737396,
-0.4932272732257843,
0.3937135636806488,
0.8215214610099792,
0.04411677271127701,
0.459332138299942,
0.38601359724998474,
0.044597331434488297,
-0.21494682133197784,
0.27560174465179443,
0.910987913608551,
-0.7442419528961182,
-0.6770099997520447,
-0.8865752816200256,
0.6529488563537598,
-0.31953662633895874,
-0.287506103515625,
0.6216505169868469,
0.249435156583786,
0.6437552571296692,
0.04935796931385994,
0.5816224813461304,
0.006331451237201691,
0.13563145697116852,
-0.49108442664146423,
0.542184591293335,
-0.3290480971336365,
-0.15006819367408752,
-0.9279739260673523,
-0.5710451006889343,
-0.3025157153606415,
0.4750150442123413,
-0.3883588910102844,
0.0414760522544384,
1.048326849937439,
0.5481233596801758,
0.0570773109793663,
0.3106699585914612,
0.20233695209026337,
0.2705268859863281,
0.28903928399086,
1.1137868165969849,
0.6976034045219421,
-0.35409975051879883,
0.3271542191505432,
-0.29215356707572937,
0.013361012563109398,
-0.09188401699066162,
-1.0181065797805786,
-0.9654712677001953,
-0.7035114765167236,
-0.48172610998153687,
-0.3890976309776306,
-0.05247747525572777,
0.8609235286712646,
0.39049994945526123,
-0.724441647529602,
-0.10243253409862518,
-0.0870346650481224,
0.21685634553432465,
-0.15742774307727814,
-0.20273873209953308,
0.933447003364563,
-0.2185375839471817,
-0.519436240196228,
0.024723855778574944,
0.30391356348991394,
-0.20632466673851013,
0.11430565267801285,
-0.268852174282074,
-0.07906723022460938,
-0.1375843584537506,
0.723013699054718,
0.21783852577209473,
-0.5287753343582153,
-0.5229673385620117,
0.04148799926042557,
-0.1952730417251587,
0.06640159338712692,
1.1928094625473022,
-0.4500943422317505,
0.41677021980285645,
0.32048365473747253,
0.7591871023178101,
0.484004408121109,
-0.15828073024749756,
0.38050687313079834,
-0.610867977142334,
0.20529238879680634,
0.09061191976070404,
0.6530340909957886,
0.18368929624557495,
-0.5886304378509521,
0.34200766682624817,
0.12168358266353607,
-0.7474203109741211,
-0.5729090571403503,
0.24638602137565613,
-1.1584022045135498,
-0.17245176434516907,
1.1783493757247925,
-0.4347953498363495,
-0.1786877065896988,
-0.1802091896533966,
-0.340104877948761,
0.7862659096717834,
-0.4035833179950714,
0.7681967616081238,
0.9081116318702698,
-0.4780491292476654,
-0.20086584985256195,
-0.4990304112434387,
0.23378749191761017,
0.27233177423477173,
-0.9339885115623474,
0.2827698588371277,
0.4540630578994751,
-0.08009540289640427,
0.04885060712695122,
0.48646119236946106,
0.08396705240011215,
0.0877893790602684,
-0.28367891907691956,
0.12960770726203918,
-0.15893106162548065,
-0.36827877163887024,
-0.302446186542511,
0.17990264296531677,
-0.7709140181541443,
0.014946512877941132
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10758v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10758v1
|
Rules still work for Open Information Extraction
| 2024-03-16T01:40:36 | 2024-03-16T01:40:36 |
Jialin Hua, Liangqing Luo, Weiying Ping, Yan Liao, Chunhai Tao, Xuewen Lub
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Open information extraction (OIE) aims to extract surface relations and their
corresponding arguments from natural language text, irrespective of domain.
This paper presents an innovative OIE model, APRCOIE, tailored for Chinese
text. Diverging from previous models, our model generates extraction patterns
autonomously. The model defines a new pattern form for Chinese OIE and proposes
an automated pattern generation methodology. In that way, the model can handle
a wide array of complex and diverse Chinese grammatical phenomena. We design a
preliminary filter based on tensor computing to conduct the extraction
procedure efficiently. To train the model, we manually annotated a large-scale
Chinese OIE dataset. In the comparative evaluation, we demonstrate that APRCOIE
outperforms state-of-the-art Chinese OIE models and significantly expands the
boundaries of achievable OIE performance. The code of APRCOIE and the annotated
dataset are released on GitHub (https://github.com/jialin666/APRCOIE_v1)
|
[
-0.11155971884727478,
-0.8451711535453796,
0.47617605328559875,
0.16592875123023987,
-0.2596248984336853,
-0.7781475782394409,
-0.37561747431755066,
-0.5851156115531921,
-0.15067176520824432,
0.5559093356132507,
-0.3786648213863373,
-0.8489606976509094,
-0.42210495471954346,
0.027965852990746498,
-0.21573664247989655,
0.7430683970451355,
-0.17074330151081085,
0.0038391088601201773,
0.17295856773853302,
-0.04893893748521805,
-0.21941536664962769,
-0.16036343574523926,
-0.8395001292228699,
0.21649666130542755,
0.20245537161827087,
0.2738119959831238,
0.5168559551239014,
1.3388617038726807,
0.44202059507369995,
0.24604415893554688,
0.12095798552036285,
0.5115489363670349,
-0.2888523042201996,
0.10071417689323425,
0.21381807327270508,
-0.6128110289573669,
-0.46375134587287903,
0.3370625376701355,
0.47453659772872925,
0.2918473780155182,
-0.18839791417121887,
0.02437610924243927,
-0.09536293894052505,
0.26479053497314453,
-0.7121173143386841,
0.528092086315155,
-0.5780700445175171,
-0.18184000253677368,
-0.13394248485565186,
-0.042522579431533813,
-0.522761344909668,
-0.32714325189590454,
-0.17493946850299835,
-1.0125421285629272,
0.07747866958379745,
-0.0142343295738101,
1.1364426612854004,
0.014054273255169392,
-0.11264818906784058,
-0.5718969106674194,
-0.39911243319511414,
0.6480236649513245,
-0.9578883051872253,
0.4704221189022064,
0.03438323363661766,
0.21704618632793427,
-0.3936787545681,
-1.0933703184127808,
-0.5974113345146179,
-0.32196736335754395,
-0.34818774461746216,
0.08609072118997574,
0.013553018681704998,
-0.24474817514419556,
-0.06773632764816284,
0.4263068437576294,
-0.2904444634914398,
0.1323777735233307,
-0.1967172622680664,
0.2462744414806366,
0.9536925554275513,
-0.07157706469297409,
0.9262747764587402,
-0.29798218607902527,
-0.3762412369251251,
0.1002512201666832,
-0.601527988910675,
0.3719187378883362,
0.35045692324638367,
0.6125670671463013,
0.08524884283542633,
0.5041257739067078,
-0.13303875923156738,
0.6345208287239075,
-0.08659125119447708,
0.029860109090805054,
-0.1608431190252304,
-0.10984624177217484,
-0.48872071504592896,
-0.04746196046471596,
1.2665880918502808,
0.04054216295480728,
0.28913334012031555,
-0.46159401535987854,
-0.3637022376060486,
-0.45739132165908813,
0.043688274919986725,
-0.8706738352775574,
-0.480263888835907,
0.3048988878726959,
-0.7813680768013,
-0.291715532541275,
0.9320308566093445,
-0.7269629836082458,
-0.4107133448123932,
-0.3109266459941864,
0.1304164081811905,
-0.6215171813964844,
-0.5281293392181396,
-0.0521479956805706,
-0.32526153326034546,
0.10277365893125534,
0.45790010690689087,
-0.5992889404296875,
0.3909933567047119,
0.7879371643066406,
1.1129274368286133,
-0.3267502784729004,
0.00802402663975954,
-0.8323063850402832,
0.008988420478999615,
-0.3295709192752838,
0.4928845763206482,
-0.5137380361557007,
0.11107137054204941,
-0.062186166644096375,
0.16477499902248383,
-0.33379223942756653,
-0.3567083179950714,
0.5486665368080139,
-0.6155454516410828,
0.5412529110908508,
0.08381921052932739,
-0.24355848133563995,
-0.17759838700294495,
-0.15392085909843445,
-1.1269676685333252,
0.8384338617324829,
-0.09503838419914246,
-0.6571053862571716,
0.18282805383205414,
-1.2109925746917725,
-0.1520089954137802,
0.10644324123859406,
-0.28182166814804077,
-0.31187236309051514,
-0.056477371603250504,
0.19788819551467896,
0.17574340105056763,
-0.29834404587745667,
0.2748693823814392,
-0.16083216667175293,
-0.18741829693317413,
-0.1686621606349945,
-0.013000410981476307,
1.4148539304733276,
0.5426474213600159,
-0.2529575526714325,
0.053487278521060944,
-1.0559911727905273,
0.05052163079380989,
0.46263790130615234,
-0.3019980192184448,
-0.7623375654220581,
0.12154221534729004,
0.06157652661204338,
0.1652929186820984,
0.2316596806049347,
-1.1160482168197632,
0.45433956384658813,
-0.28959786891937256,
0.8199999332427979,
0.5205535292625427,
0.19555236399173737,
0.4333779215812683,
0.014227931387722492,
0.07371097803115845,
0.04083572328090668,
0.004972642287611961,
-0.4908781945705414,
-0.5410659909248352,
-0.4035336375236511,
-0.7621274590492249,
0.3867381513118744,
0.5428580641746521,
-0.5639779567718506,
0.3553776144981384,
-0.21254658699035645,
-0.6005274057388306,
-0.6496666073799133,
0.05393503978848457,
0.2277933806180954,
0.15929891169071198,
0.29157882928848267,
-0.3059287369251251,
-0.5627415180206299,
-0.4923560321331024,
-0.30466628074645996,
-0.0728832259774208,
-0.12168095260858536,
0.2624668478965759,
0.06350816786289215,
0.30615589022636414,
1.229851245880127,
-0.582413911819458,
-0.4846664369106293,
-0.05723722651600838,
0.5118017196655273,
0.2955096364021301,
0.42156529426574707,
0.771756649017334,
-1.1492952108383179,
-0.37789350748062134,
0.44890570640563965,
-1.0665053129196167,
-0.33404818177223206,
0.09379677474498749,
-0.42667657136917114,
0.18464386463165283,
0.6417236328125,
-0.8081881999969482,
0.6530032157897949,
0.2316461205482483,
-0.22934590280056,
0.15948888659477234,
0.10915031284093857,
0.19412775337696075,
-0.8985676169395447,
0.34747177362442017,
0.3314129412174225,
-0.03754096105694771,
-0.730518639087677,
0.41704145073890686,
0.14230701327323914,
-0.1377129852771759,
-0.4556659758090973,
0.6856762766838074,
-0.7324627637863159,
0.4234829843044281,
-0.38026928901672363,
0.35149142146110535,
0.03947560489177704,
0.5907841920852661,
0.42775121331214905,
0.4144894480705261,
0.2953810691833496,
-0.9819613099098206,
0.027863074094057083,
0.4351173937320709,
-0.32132112979888916,
-0.21984310448169708,
-0.560549259185791,
0.2378259152173996,
-0.2539204955101013,
-0.16107231378555298,
-1.1007241010665894,
-0.0673050805926323,
0.4563661217689514,
-0.5580171346664429,
0.2139531821012497,
-0.2499716728925705,
-0.2993800938129425,
0.20728559792041779,
-0.23814699053764343,
0.14573831856250763,
0.37977170944213867,
-0.728369414806366,
0.6939921975135803,
0.3871546983718872,
-0.27357882261276245,
-0.5841797590255737,
-0.3682032525539398,
-0.016033032909035683,
0.007275493815541267,
-0.6270394325256348,
0.3399524390697479,
0.125178262591362,
-0.5737539529800415,
0.22278694808483124,
0.01345087680965662,
-0.5365092158317566,
0.23618368804454803,
0.14618857204914093,
0.31389525532722473,
-0.6531360149383545,
-0.10299346596002579,
-0.2353786826133728,
0.42818403244018555,
0.08931715041399002,
-0.3601829707622528,
0.4213811457157135,
0.38772425055503845,
0.03738369792699814,
-0.38513559103012085,
0.23327063024044037,
0.3814801573753357,
-0.6551242470741272,
0.626561164855957,
0.543790876865387,
-0.5550631284713745,
-0.39078110456466675,
-0.05570429190993309,
0.0833434984087944,
-0.41050729155540466,
0.3338584005832672,
-0.533361554145813,
-0.17048010230064392,
0.23009246587753296,
0.22394712269306183,
0.7908968329429626,
0.556212842464447,
0.09624836593866348,
0.38683831691741943,
0.9914151430130005,
0.8930945992469788,
0.07977386564016342,
0.7842437028884888,
-0.06705371290445328,
0.29767629504203796,
-0.43378809094429016,
-0.1093161329627037,
-0.6730963587760925,
0.3400430977344513,
-0.7347797751426697,
0.2378709614276886,
0.06402304023504257,
0.34795865416526794,
-0.011725681833922863,
0.5968239307403564,
-0.42598187923431396,
-0.0024310273583978415,
0.7288991212844849,
0.20595157146453857,
0.3859574496746063,
-0.11886441707611084,
0.2208736538887024,
0.25634896755218506,
-0.6902731657028198,
-0.6786851286888123,
0.7041389346122742,
0.3341420292854309,
0.45745939016342163,
0.241952583193779,
0.6974998116493225,
0.270485520362854,
0.44349226355552673,
-0.7016800045967102,
0.5669911503791809,
-0.5223211050033569,
-0.177066832780838,
-0.6894183158874512,
-0.3976476788520813,
-1.0034993886947632,
0.23758143186569214,
-0.07381457835435867,
-0.6899217367172241,
0.22742168605327606,
-0.1055290549993515,
-0.07811978459358215,
0.43828749656677246,
-0.6904534101486206,
0.8351194262504578,
-0.06412934511899948,
-0.5382658839225769,
0.4690040647983551,
-0.43501830101013184,
0.5346503853797913,
0.06879889219999313,
0.3344264626502991,
-0.04510215297341347,
0.008398876525461674,
0.7030830979347229,
-0.43937456607818604,
0.6859961152076721,
-0.49601230025291443,
-0.33919310569763184,
0.6688284873962402,
0.054359070956707,
0.43120917677879333,
-0.0544598214328289,
-0.23330524563789368,
0.528795063495636,
-0.06621279567480087,
-0.17647844552993774,
-0.6566109657287598,
0.45056775212287903,
-0.779891848564148,
-0.4632299542427063,
-0.09648202359676361,
-0.16574996709823608,
0.3437252938747406,
0.7446480393409729,
0.24073989689350128,
0.29451751708984375,
-0.4563325345516205,
-0.14251527190208435,
0.3784368932247162,
-0.17295916378498077,
0.8622269630432129,
0.5916358828544617,
0.02149711176753044,
-0.41838324069976807,
0.9164419174194336,
0.0870785042643547,
-0.04386153817176819,
0.5803259015083313,
0.287249892950058,
0.07621166855096817,
-0.571313738822937,
-0.5346013307571411,
0.22211377322673798,
-0.6327130794525146,
-0.07892382144927979,
-0.723149836063385,
-0.5222412943840027,
-0.8953936696052551,
0.4932457208633423,
-0.17647193372249603,
-0.39968141913414,
-0.1778731793165207,
0.15897825360298157,
0.03307471051812172,
1.0488766431808472,
0.10893236100673676,
0.11986836791038513,
-0.9025934934616089,
0.49858349561691284,
-0.1487368494272232,
0.2919464707374573,
-0.13867302238941193,
-0.26785901188850403,
-0.27528053522109985,
0.04927181079983711,
-0.22011928260326385,
-0.7124492526054382,
0.5562502145767212,
0.2492237538099289,
0.8040540218353271,
0.36633890867233276,
0.38071325421333313,
0.5243291258811951,
-0.5438147783279419,
0.8159617781639099,
-0.04518640413880348,
-0.9638426899909973,
0.4601796567440033,
-0.22219569981098175,
-0.06094760075211525,
0.21784020960330963,
0.4412060081958771,
-0.4321633279323578,
-0.5797353386878967,
-0.5115943551063538,
-0.8505926728248596,
1.085044264793396,
0.18848802149295807,
-0.3233034014701843,
-0.17176149785518646,
0.546160101890564,
0.5023659467697144,
0.16559341549873352,
-1.025085210800171,
-0.09092831611633301,
-0.3656771779060364,
-0.5069227814674377,
0.2257463037967682,
0.0773513987660408,
0.2888745665550232,
0.4267532229423523,
0.810088038444519,
-0.053604092448949814,
0.42938095331192017,
0.5201026201248169,
-0.24519427120685577,
-0.26004403829574585,
0.0025533156003803015,
0.32466524839401245,
0.3524293303489685,
-0.27431827783584595,
-0.266228049993515,
-0.5665559768676758,
-0.7330774068832397,
-0.3565996587276459,
0.31881240010261536,
-0.36971282958984375,
0.27060171961784363,
0.5441561341285706,
0.6452736854553223,
-0.4723089933395386,
-0.6337448358535767,
0.7789040207862854,
-0.27443018555641174,
-0.23364286124706268,
-0.4715467691421509,
0.2891164720058441,
-0.6183673143386841,
-0.12797455489635468,
0.24576357007026672,
-0.14438122510910034,
0.23716095089912415,
-0.5804019570350647,
0.3486276865005493,
0.3179105520248413,
-0.3347163498401642,
-0.3290078043937683,
0.890536367893219,
0.05631699413061142,
-0.3953075706958771,
0.6490833759307861,
0.02281906269490719,
0.017683474346995354,
0.7149662971496582,
0.28288397192955017,
0.8240854740142822,
-0.25807294249534607,
-0.09124167263507843,
0.6071751713752747,
0.39119765162467957,
-0.036480966955423355,
0.10689684003591537,
-0.1656273901462555,
-0.657587468624115,
-0.26076582074165344,
-0.32447734475135803,
-0.04436385631561279,
0.3155144155025482,
-0.6795305013656616,
0.8848522901535034,
-0.4660820960998535,
0.4272511601448059,
0.12453649938106537,
-0.08037804812192917,
-0.45804330706596375,
0.5321292281150818,
0.27651703357696533,
1.2188146114349365,
-0.6839988231658936,
0.9247745871543884,
0.9119133353233337,
-0.7551279664039612,
-0.5670526027679443,
0.15215477347373962,
-0.4213095009326935,
-0.95920729637146,
0.6912375688552856,
0.5164690613746643,
-0.03124735876917839,
-0.06183754652738571,
-0.8229880928993225,
-0.7609730958938599,
1.192624807357788,
0.20765246450901031,
-0.3271021544933319,
-0.34415823221206665,
-0.19158028066158295,
0.23740360140800476,
-0.774965226650238,
0.5974115133285522,
0.2763751447200775,
0.5305203795433044,
-0.16182179749011993,
-0.6781026721000671,
0.23251467943191528,
-0.8060282468795776,
-0.4038178622722626,
0.2058088630437851,
-0.7755613923072815,
1.1935654878616333,
-0.11655209958553314,
-0.7660225629806519,
0.5200904607772827,
0.7652543783187866,
-0.1737743616104126,
0.49945637583732605,
0.742323637008667,
0.2182314246892929,
0.5880259275436401,
0.0654030591249466,
0.7293301224708557,
-0.26766595244407654,
-0.08048833906650543,
1.0500317811965942,
-0.22256194055080414,
0.8326942920684814,
-0.03413042426109314,
0.4274609386920929,
0.7387085556983948,
0.5175888538360596,
-0.018157433718442917,
0.6168699860572815,
-0.07368223369121552,
0.09315500408411026,
0.1285683810710907,
-0.09666533023118973,
0.1280384510755539,
0.7289106845855713,
0.03010784275829792,
-0.6641098856925964,
-0.1299242079257965,
-0.0692780613899231,
0.2886563837528229,
0.3315057158470154,
-0.40701910853385925,
1.1349551677703857,
-0.17885930836200714,
-1.0805120468139648,
0.35962486267089844,
0.5427605509757996,
0.18207460641860962,
-0.6783058047294617,
-0.45835229754447937,
0.06455231457948685,
0.04124993085861206,
-0.36042076349258423,
-0.34545138478279114,
-0.03668375685811043,
-0.06517384946346283,
0.012780648656189442,
0.017120685428380966,
0.6133943200111389,
-0.6425282955169678,
0.055909186601638794,
0.2503555119037628,
0.3761787712574005,
0.05743255093693733,
-0.1528480350971222,
-0.2590175271034241,
-0.24345053732395172,
0.21093003451824188,
-0.5039700865745544,
-0.020554138347506523,
1.015386700630188,
-0.35053202509880066,
0.09016675502061844,
0.6794389486312866,
0.15833882987499237,
0.11683445423841476,
-0.20889759063720703,
0.8510899543762207,
-0.7614207863807678,
-0.6838305592536926,
-0.9047304391860962,
0.5600922703742981,
-0.4065008759498596,
-0.3254168629646301,
0.6688112616539001,
0.5801236033439636,
0.5733366012573242,
0.08613777905702591,
1.2336270809173584,
-0.3955451250076294,
0.3687545359134674,
-0.8516809344291687,
0.6247514486312866,
-0.5048559308052063,
0.025080282241106033,
-0.07002036273479462,
-0.6820215582847595,
-0.20295193791389465,
0.2351112812757492,
-0.1403225213289261,
-0.20836295187473297,
0.8172780275344849,
0.49597781896591187,
-0.18068861961364746,
0.5428929924964905,
0.07816282659769058,
0.2945462167263031,
0.6319319009780884,
0.27697232365608215,
0.5051356554031372,
-0.5885319113731384,
0.6011964678764343,
-0.17808209359645844,
-0.6708342432975769,
0.30514225363731384,
-1.0420124530792236,
-0.8945808410644531,
-0.4981195628643036,
-0.25566017627716064,
-0.09462106972932816,
0.03704454377293587,
0.8943884968757629,
0.771750807762146,
-0.833438515663147,
-0.2731221616268158,
-0.5795274376869202,
-0.07003434747457504,
-0.3787437975406647,
-0.3436068594455719,
0.4769129157066345,
-0.5147936940193176,
-1.1260355710983276,
0.4725150465965271,
-0.05795855447649956,
-0.06368634849786758,
0.11355762183666229,
0.18189255893230438,
-0.369375079870224,
0.20157429575920105,
0.3536143898963928,
0.41182494163513184,
-0.4702892005443573,
-0.15336671471595764,
0.1002870500087738,
-0.20348012447357178,
0.3502994775772095,
1.0843768119812012,
-0.3167089819908142,
0.2935827076435089,
0.3800174593925476,
0.5876648426055908,
0.056035954505205154,
0.27497559785842896,
0.7810932993888855,
-0.5534607768058777,
0.06875045597553253,
-0.15424656867980957,
0.3682861328125,
0.01766423135995865,
-0.740353524684906,
0.6037010550498962,
0.260727196931839,
-0.20934632420539856,
-0.7004665732383728,
0.11811815202236176,
-0.7999716401100159,
-0.6075371503829956,
1.2752724885940552,
-0.6437765955924988,
-0.7042551040649414,
-0.09560741484165192,
-0.41183602809906006,
0.48829537630081177,
-0.5774661302566528,
0.7067933678627014,
0.7159626483917236,
-0.10198914259672165,
-0.1330145299434662,
-0.4284897446632385,
0.26802366971969604,
-0.13486143946647644,
-0.7988740801811218,
0.2269628494977951,
0.3102845251560211,
0.07215828448534012,
0.23545579612255096,
0.5819008350372314,
-0.2929004728794098,
0.32777702808380127,
0.014112093485891819,
0.39227521419525146,
-0.7019917368888855,
-0.37044501304626465,
-0.03611588850617409,
0.6321948766708374,
0.06540993601083755,
-0.618200421333313
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10750v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10750v1
|
Depression Detection on Social Media with Large Language Models
| 2024-03-16T01:01:16 | 2024-03-16T01:01:16 |
Xiaochong Lan, Yiming Cheng, Li Sheng, Chen Gao, Yong Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Depression harms. However, due to a lack of mental health awareness and fear
of stigma, many patients do not actively seek diagnosis and treatment, leading
to detrimental outcomes. Depression detection aims to determine whether an
individual suffers from depression by analyzing their history of posts on
social media, which can significantly aid in early detection and intervention.
It mainly faces two key challenges: 1) it requires professional medical
knowledge, and 2) it necessitates both high accuracy and explainability. To
address it, we propose a novel depression detection system called DORIS,
combining medical knowledge and the recent advances in large language models
(LLMs). Specifically, to tackle the first challenge, we proposed an LLM-based
solution to first annotate whether high-risk texts meet medical diagnostic
criteria. Further, we retrieve texts with high emotional intensity and
summarize critical information from the historical mood records of users,
so-called mood courses. To tackle the second challenge, we combine LLM and
traditional classifiers to integrate medical knowledge-guided features, for
which the model can also explain its prediction results, achieving both high
accuracy and explainability. Extensive experimental results on benchmarking
datasets show that, compared to the current best baseline, our approach
improves by 0.036 in AUPRC, which can be considered significant, demonstrating
the effectiveness of our approach and its high value as an NLP application.
|
[
-0.3505716025829315,
-0.8472480773925781,
1.200814962387085,
0.2104697972536087,
-0.4180302023887634,
-0.1549212634563446,
-0.33590325713157654,
-0.5222757458686829,
0.4866656959056854,
0.3059144616127014,
-0.6188405752182007,
-1.0834124088287354,
-1.0889273881912231,
0.19977989792823792,
-0.36586445569992065,
0.8498581647872925,
-0.21184727549552917,
0.11902865767478943,
-0.012820441275835037,
0.13305073976516724,
-0.3943498432636261,
-0.3934650123119354,
-1.140920877456665,
-0.2096664309501648,
0.6731892228126526,
0.39266452193260193,
0.6045019626617432,
0.15877796709537506,
0.46056458353996277,
0.20186886191368103,
-0.49676960706710815,
0.1420762836933136,
-0.4671192765235901,
0.03029743954539299,
-0.12919220328330994,
-0.44611304998397827,
-0.442853182554245,
-0.46310606598854065,
0.3044711649417877,
0.443283349275589,
-0.05451466143131256,
-0.04778183996677399,
0.15185551345348358,
0.6015326976776123,
-0.5614371299743652,
0.21824586391448975,
-0.1850045621395111,
0.2857438325881958,
-0.1252419650554657,
0.0023151696659624577,
-0.09557053446769714,
-0.4146319627761841,
-0.008264891803264618,
-0.3153137266635895,
0.10963424295186996,
-0.4597773551940918,
0.6725499033927917,
0.33361390233039856,
-0.5628790259361267,
-0.44760408997535706,
-0.708899736404419,
0.6744577288627625,
-0.6629763245582581,
0.12490496039390564,
0.6294295191764832,
0.3567395806312561,
-0.0589972622692585,
-0.327924519777298,
-0.3781813085079193,
0.17359374463558197,
0.06709560751914978,
0.17798356711864471,
-0.3867185413837433,
-0.13254910707473755,
0.18212340772151947,
0.48903679847717285,
-0.5550353527069092,
0.31622543931007385,
-0.16680482029914856,
0.020432397723197937,
0.6401292681694031,
0.20828106999397278,
0.374322772026062,
-0.5642009973526001,
-0.11646901071071625,
0.231977179646492,
-0.0822385922074318,
-0.07364750653505325,
0.024709263816475868,
0.12583643198013306,
-0.34461426734924316,
0.5857177376747131,
-0.05484842136502266,
0.4116828143596649,
-0.07203853875398636,
-0.13823091983795166,
0.006866110023111105,
0.2529906630516052,
-0.10477631539106369,
0.23646670579910278,
0.8548508286476135,
0.4524272084236145,
0.18660910427570343,
0.18659301102161407,
-0.21783584356307983,
0.47652551531791687,
0.11993782222270966,
-0.5715383887290955,
-0.33416587114334106,
0.5905900001525879,
-0.6227085590362549,
-0.3778513967990875,
-0.49030259251594543,
-0.731012225151062,
-0.8859679102897644,
-0.24698777496814728,
0.42786362767219543,
-0.7374088168144226,
-0.4595233201980591,
0.5664193034172058,
0.0013947454281151295,
-0.10665464401245117,
0.47752493619918823,
-0.7426618337631226,
0.131403848528862,
0.8004537224769592,
1.0872204303741455,
-0.0009284719126299024,
0.3381562829017639,
-0.2922112047672272,
-0.08800677210092545,
-0.3828611671924591,
0.9745218753814697,
-0.05264974385499954,
-0.32364416122436523,
0.21096670627593994,
0.16006864607334137,
0.2552450895309448,
-0.418730229139328,
0.8401909470558167,
-0.06730823963880539,
0.09552822262048721,
-0.23879291117191315,
-0.6264276504516602,
-0.07357639819383621,
0.14163106679916382,
-0.6378968954086304,
0.939813494682312,
0.2518104314804077,
-1.0018380880355835,
0.12381564825773239,
-0.3113170564174652,
-0.5119722485542297,
0.1577746421098709,
0.07790601253509521,
-0.4875948131084442,
0.1684086173772812,
0.3355501592159271,
0.9694362878799438,
-0.4071718156337738,
0.48537686467170715,
-0.6094599962234497,
-0.27476122975349426,
0.2510783076286316,
-0.10839433968067169,
0.6248816847801208,
0.09422330558300018,
-0.12226195633411407,
-0.06681377440690994,
-0.843591034412384,
-0.4014534652233124,
0.3401547074317932,
-0.3639548420906067,
-0.7579925060272217,
0.07127579301595688,
0.009588857181370258,
0.06520158797502518,
0.2522220313549042,
-0.4185555577278137,
-0.16493256390094757,
-0.21771880984306335,
0.29606330394744873,
0.7996523380279541,
0.06941648572683334,
0.051037952303886414,
-0.253050297498703,
0.6513333916664124,
0.08565741032361984,
0.40388262271881104,
-0.007224849425256252,
-0.6593858599662781,
-0.3382173478603363,
-0.573100745677948,
0.145127534866333,
0.7325995564460754,
-0.34352046251296997,
0.8543791770935059,
0.027883172035217285,
-0.5243653655052185,
-0.5671595335006714,
0.0730922743678093,
0.2808458209037781,
0.40594401955604553,
0.5574677586555481,
-0.31743714213371277,
-0.4408408999443054,
-0.6705357432365417,
-0.24841590225696564,
0.007052460685372353,
-0.16052573919296265,
0.4111473858356476,
0.1940566897392273,
-0.5297898650169373,
0.44057565927505493,
-0.8377556204795837,
-0.4263317584991455,
-0.41933783888816833,
0.1180146262049675,
0.4421766400337219,
0.07746119797229767,
0.2942085266113281,
-0.6905301213264465,
-0.459778755903244,
0.02427946962416172,
-0.9601075649261475,
-0.30574876070022583,
0.1073007732629776,
-0.03447174280881882,
-0.012030712328851223,
0.27454352378845215,
-0.6309418082237244,
0.3255341947078705,
0.535901665687561,
-0.44555142521858215,
0.37965768575668335,
-0.05834748223423958,
-0.08119198679924011,
-1.31118905544281,
-0.11012838035821915,
0.5429322719573975,
-0.396930456161499,
-0.3648921251296997,
-0.6545396447181702,
0.10253606736660004,
-0.32959654927253723,
-0.10492146015167236,
0.3575091063976288,
-0.10689444094896317,
0.1335509568452835,
-0.2730679512023926,
0.2689703702926636,
0.02636120282113552,
-0.02159082517027855,
-0.22509926557540894,
-0.08161769062280655,
0.7573392987251282,
-0.5888358950614929,
0.28337591886520386,
0.3867214322090149,
-0.4938332140445709,
0.8587729930877686,
-0.361419677734375,
-0.2669232487678528,
-0.5129656195640564,
0.19225375354290009,
-0.9709082841873169,
-0.3285757899284363,
0.206480011343956,
-0.45746859908103943,
0.18499894440174103,
-0.16657021641731262,
-0.3910929560661316,
-0.45447099208831787,
-0.11582927405834198,
0.09077734500169754,
0.451430082321167,
-0.3707451820373535,
0.5429331064224243,
0.40871748328208923,
-0.45842140913009644,
-0.36504173278808594,
-0.4453520178794861,
0.2426280528306961,
-0.5105727314949036,
-0.6062971949577332,
0.5618987083435059,
0.015042302198708057,
-0.32852795720100403,
0.12869426608085632,
-0.04218652844429016,
-0.053526002913713455,
0.2830704152584076,
0.2760208547115326,
0.22184328734874725,
-0.11512108147144318,
0.5687072277069092,
0.18785156309604645,
-0.36183199286460876,
0.15447497367858887,
0.07622773200273514,
0.7201655507087708,
0.2615806758403778,
0.012165575288236141,
-0.9159335494041443,
0.5207744240760803,
0.44982442259788513,
0.07511164993047714,
0.7629907131195068,
0.5682060718536377,
-0.7104030847549438,
-0.189297616481781,
-0.5078060030937195,
-0.08143937587738037,
-0.4192679226398468,
0.21464803814888,
-0.20280277729034424,
-0.7645889520645142,
0.4802985191345215,
-0.3730219304561615,
-0.32026970386505127,
0.3578416109085083,
0.5148009657859802,
-0.20427349209785461,
1.3371084928512573,
0.7655271887779236,
-0.29315271973609924,
0.45459529757499695,
-0.05426110699772835,
0.3443877398967743,
-0.5637571811676025,
0.06888148188591003,
-0.43559956550598145,
-0.11823204904794693,
-0.4089048504829407,
-0.14394889771938324,
0.43616747856140137,
0.3355131149291992,
-0.03378433361649513,
0.1332862824201584,
-0.4673754572868347,
0.07832863926887512,
0.24424123764038086,
0.5742080807685852,
0.32676181197166443,
-0.21684277057647705,
0.14375780522823334,
-0.18184414505958557,
-0.36159414052963257,
-0.5351952910423279,
0.9118720889091492,
0.39924755692481995,
0.7558462619781494,
0.09992574155330658,
0.8994211554527283,
0.43115758895874023,
0.38557642698287964,
-0.9229750037193298,
0.4004025161266327,
-0.5377116203308105,
-0.27375486493110657,
-0.15697239339351654,
-0.47609156370162964,
-0.8447402119636536,
-0.16911911964416504,
-0.44195711612701416,
-0.5597445368766785,
0.12713947892189026,
0.12566930055618286,
-0.5026041269302368,
0.16982565820217133,
-0.6314142942428589,
0.9018164277076721,
-0.391925185918808,
-0.0032132710330188274,
-0.32501667737960815,
-0.5382036566734314,
0.37180978059768677,
-0.37621113657951355,
0.7030820846557617,
-0.45616695284843445,
0.39779117703437805,
0.6046912670135498,
-0.13730788230895996,
0.9393168687820435,
-0.15454967319965363,
-0.3549997806549072,
-0.036476194858551025,
0.08032219111919403,
0.4068126082420349,
0.14949257671833038,
-0.007605803199112415,
0.07996770739555359,
0.07706233859062195,
-0.23540595173835754,
-0.407460480928421,
0.6953114867210388,
-0.6923679113388062,
-0.42333003878593445,
-0.21537043154239655,
-0.39435875415802,
-0.04794098436832428,
0.20374229550361633,
0.2001454085111618,
0.12186215817928314,
-0.2795591354370117,
-0.21306191384792328,
0.7355730533599854,
-0.6190416812896729,
0.013131221756339073,
0.5707488656044006,
-0.34397730231285095,
-0.4993045926094055,
0.6084837317466736,
0.053123753517866135,
-0.0210848618298769,
0.256413996219635,
0.5323741436004639,
0.006963067688047886,
-0.3554711639881134,
0.08047133684158325,
0.6284094452857971,
-0.9063295722007751,
-0.15055780112743378,
-0.8733000159263611,
0.137108713388443,
-0.6008520126342773,
-0.2711296081542969,
-0.3844014108181,
-0.2775545120239258,
-0.6790297627449036,
-0.32220757007598877,
0.5754119753837585,
0.8251056671142578,
-0.34319329261779785,
0.17016461491584778,
-0.869330883026123,
0.6717455983161926,
0.15352769196033478,
0.34847038984298706,
-0.19374552369117737,
-0.1474052220582962,
-0.26068076491355896,
-0.2668326497077942,
-0.26440319418907166,
-1.0956180095672607,
0.5258755683898926,
-0.05044116824865341,
0.10032094269990921,
0.8814802169799805,
0.2691602110862732,
0.493746280670166,
-0.3188001215457916,
0.4764711558818817,
0.41557392477989197,
-0.9574792981147766,
0.9230061173439026,
-0.19377802312374115,
0.06004961207509041,
0.2832980751991272,
0.98058021068573,
-1.0153414011001587,
-0.4313749670982361,
-0.4929523169994354,
-0.9329488277435303,
0.4798390865325928,
-0.15733815729618073,
0.027001963928341866,
-0.3468987047672272,
0.6671507358551025,
0.009421879425644875,
-0.3441913425922394,
-0.5779128074645996,
-0.07030154019594193,
0.13996928930282593,
-0.7034205794334412,
-0.49021366238594055,
-0.540700376033783,
-0.15613962709903717,
-0.12273074686527252,
0.6748747825622559,
0.012413124553859234,
0.2930585443973541,
0.38173556327819824,
0.04213079437613487,
-0.43345990777015686,
0.22096939384937286,
-0.0353965163230896,
0.47049835324287415,
-0.2799471318721771,
0.3191378712654114,
0.08629593253135681,
-0.1967846155166626,
-0.05868258327245712,
0.3496416509151459,
-0.03234774246811867,
0.20741163194179535,
0.3380986452102661,
0.6259893774986267,
0.4300960302352905,
-0.6909441351890564,
0.5814446210861206,
-0.18285973370075226,
-0.19257549941539764,
-0.6714205145835876,
0.012266851961612701,
0.47815385460853577,
0.6219440698623657,
0.14030718803405762,
-0.38652947545051575,
0.18083927035331726,
-0.3774142861366272,
-0.021305380389094353,
0.5297152400016785,
-0.5881704092025757,
-0.4237082004547119,
0.42629244923591614,
-0.18177002668380737,
-0.5745810270309448,
0.12174227088689804,
-0.016650553792715073,
-0.4730607271194458,
0.5717534422874451,
0.47636356949806213,
0.7168025970458984,
-0.5642109513282776,
0.5046903491020203,
0.24904276430606842,
0.0641360878944397,
-0.4035915434360504,
0.7046300768852234,
0.20730581879615784,
-0.8131225109100342,
-0.25895389914512634,
-0.7868093252182007,
-0.39995077252388,
0.3184639811515808,
-0.787625253200531,
0.7807597517967224,
-0.4567684531211853,
-0.4987456500530243,
0.41868335008621216,
-0.1984776109457016,
-0.4079502820968628,
0.31002703309059143,
0.5103865265846252,
0.7125149965286255,
-1.0268136262893677,
0.44554445147514343,
0.6622636914253235,
-0.0060522835701704025,
-0.4030873477458954,
0.024804268032312393,
0.19788599014282227,
-0.5113712549209595,
0.22781118750572205,
0.5937811136245728,
0.11666974425315857,
0.06822093576192856,
-0.3991566300392151,
-0.5886997580528259,
1.0543005466461182,
0.27209383249282837,
-0.536882758140564,
-0.008396623656153679,
-0.12042944878339767,
0.5343241691589355,
-0.15464800596237183,
-0.15199774503707886,
0.35552915930747986,
0.4060528576374054,
-0.15581075847148895,
-0.7752112746238708,
0.11041340231895447,
-0.06065129116177559,
-0.08326484262943268,
0.41672298312187195,
-0.24678482115268707,
0.7527438402175903,
-0.15011285245418549,
-0.5649921298027039,
-0.22408291697502136,
0.18229758739471436,
0.13004453480243683,
0.49333447217941284,
0.5323948264122009,
0.9528117775917053,
1.0310858488082886,
0.18600279092788696,
1.181515097618103,
-0.2980312705039978,
0.5512853860855103,
0.6212357878684998,
-0.39841824769973755,
0.8138391971588135,
0.07179562002420425,
-0.1976177841424942,
0.5603058338165283,
0.7460439801216125,
0.16391520202159882,
0.447141170501709,
0.10097005218267441,
-0.763338565826416,
-0.5304619073867798,
-0.20411637425422668,
-0.14490437507629395,
0.13323934376239777,
0.6308197379112244,
-0.6807580590248108,
-0.28231099247932434,
0.41200268268585205,
0.39161792397499084,
0.03482917323708534,
-0.43531906604766846,
0.811714231967926,
0.4409216046333313,
-0.30651095509529114,
0.6695859432220459,
0.22196635603904724,
0.6023008823394775,
-0.415759414434433,
0.16270849108695984,
-0.1233307272195816,
0.4855083227157593,
-0.25707924365997314,
-0.7528015971183777,
0.38115572929382324,
0.15941238403320312,
-0.17581425607204437,
-0.06507662683725357,
1.0332653522491455,
-0.20319028198719025,
-0.6021478772163391,
0.8051693439483643,
0.4977799355983734,
0.2523444592952728,
-0.3243510127067566,
-0.5493496060371399,
-0.1141587570309639,
-0.28380411863327026,
-0.21369414031505585,
0.26724132895469666,
0.8334929943084717,
0.08885961025953293,
0.648864209651947,
0.5393068194389343,
0.1532263308763504,
-0.4030974805355072,
0.12135358154773712,
0.8507559299468994,
-0.8626764416694641,
-0.5368558764457703,
-1.0074903964996338,
0.30388015508651733,
0.032179027795791626,
-0.17523197829723358,
0.4103739857673645,
0.19805382192134857,
0.33821016550064087,
0.09966626763343811,
0.8346821665763855,
0.1549859642982483,
0.886488676071167,
-0.45909684896469116,
0.5296770334243774,
-0.7018530964851379,
0.10662691295146942,
-0.405606746673584,
-0.48849570751190186,
-0.5794489979743958,
0.6667632460594177,
-0.4582635164260864,
-0.33103692531585693,
0.7727176547050476,
0.5241079330444336,
0.023319954052567482,
0.11208148300647736,
0.18286338448524475,
0.5876365303993225,
0.24696891009807587,
0.7554208636283875,
0.8417054414749146,
-0.0378328412771225,
0.2506694495677948,
-0.28182363510131836,
-0.5716978311538696,
-0.34153875708580017,
-0.6350686550140381,
-0.9929957389831543,
-0.45213332772254944,
-0.42209309339523315,
-0.5545504689216614,
0.04454908147454262,
0.6827364563941956,
0.14356617629528046,
-0.5129031538963318,
0.1545661985874176,
-0.016795188188552856,
0.21520398557186127,
-0.23601002991199493,
-0.25604885816574097,
0.5226353406906128,
-0.12756659090518951,
-0.3821794092655182,
0.26695212721824646,
0.33013567328453064,
0.023979267105460167,
-0.26691335439682007,
0.1195112094283104,
-0.10922413319349289,
-0.051371168345212936,
0.8190852999687195,
-0.09616811573505402,
-0.382855087518692,
-0.17517022788524628,
-0.21793335676193237,
-0.20780062675476074,
0.1387321650981903,
0.682340681552887,
-0.5177750587463379,
0.08553784340620041,
0.2951204478740692,
0.32132038474082947,
0.528002142906189,
-0.15475276112556458,
0.2419644445180893,
-0.3010016083717346,
-0.2660817503929138,
0.3211488127708435,
0.482806533575058,
0.5544790029525757,
-0.9209720492362976,
0.2567780911922455,
0.2510477304458618,
-0.49907687306404114,
-0.67888343334198,
0.32217657566070557,
-0.969666063785553,
-0.7685689926147461,
1.0938208103179932,
-0.2896708846092224,
-0.2386629283428192,
-0.4487670660018921,
-0.278444766998291,
0.48469579219818115,
-0.2762294411659241,
1.3723596334457397,
0.7444561719894409,
-0.08596515655517578,
-0.25312280654907227,
-0.7718231081962585,
0.46498435735702515,
0.3757838010787964,
-0.7665943503379822,
0.10816999524831772,
0.43194419145584106,
0.3403555154800415,
0.12211649119853973,
0.8621662259101868,
-0.2213410586118698,
0.10463304817676544,
-0.6110616326332092,
0.34127870202064514,
0.4231606423854828,
0.03945852071046829,
-0.5070607662200928,
0.13798050582408905,
-0.1261141002178192,
0.273126482963562
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10707v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10707v1
|
Uncovering Latent Themes of Messaging on Social Media by Integrating LLMs: A Case Study on Climate Campaigns
| 2024-03-15T21:54:00 | 2024-03-15T21:54:00 |
Tunazzina Islam, Dan Goldwasser
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG, cs.SI
|
This paper introduces a novel approach to uncovering and analyzing themes in
social media messaging. Recognizing the limitations of traditional topic-level
analysis, which tends to capture only the overarching patterns, this study
emphasizes the need for a finer-grained, theme-focused exploration.
Conventional methods of theme discovery, involving manual processes and a
human-in-the-loop approach, are valuable but face challenges in scalability,
consistency, and resource intensity in terms of time and cost. To address these
challenges, we propose a machine-in-the-loop approach that leverages the
advanced capabilities of Large Language Models (LLMs). This approach allows for
a deeper investigation into the thematic aspects of social media discourse,
enabling us to uncover a diverse array of themes, each with unique
characteristics and relevance, thereby offering a comprehensive understanding
of the nuances present within broader topics. Furthermore, this method
efficiently maps the text and the newly discovered themes, enhancing our
understanding of the thematic nuances in social media messaging. We employ
climate campaigns as a case study and demonstrate that our methodology yields
more accurate and interpretable results compared to traditional topic models.
Our results not only demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach in
uncovering latent themes but also illuminate how these themes are tailored for
demographic targeting in social media contexts. Additionally, our work sheds
light on the dynamic nature of social media, revealing the shifts in the
thematic focus of messaging in response to real-world events.
|
[
-0.37190109491348267,
-0.8705736994743347,
0.718529462814331,
0.13794571161270142,
-0.8373187184333801,
0.8394799828529358,
-0.30551475286483765,
0.03630237653851509,
0.6524046659469604,
0.5838383436203003,
-0.9556700587272644,
-0.7162066698074341,
-0.7657044529914856,
-0.3431491255760193,
-0.4681725800037384,
0.9347342252731323,
-0.05177838355302811,
-0.27136147022247314,
-0.09591815620660782,
-0.00356496125459671,
-0.35961225628852844,
-0.4096657335758209,
-0.25417202711105347,
-0.3108116388320923,
0.8209764361381531,
0.6754902005195618,
0.1859767735004425,
0.40109017491340637,
0.8691263198852539,
0.11177985370159149,
-0.39448148012161255,
0.20986723899841309,
-1.1897566318511963,
0.1430273801088333,
-0.4692856967449188,
-0.2247011661529541,
-0.09852837026119232,
0.2683790326118469,
0.6409178972244263,
0.28199559450149536,
-0.006214882712811232,
0.39281195402145386,
0.2193208485841751,
0.5554715394973755,
-0.6288180351257324,
0.20414084196090698,
-1.2004722356796265,
-0.18924537301063538,
-0.21396134793758392,
-0.7757803797721863,
-0.008486159145832062,
-0.1793229728937149,
-0.038060262799263,
-0.4090057611465454,
0.31354475021362305,
-0.0020194612443447113,
0.7255706787109375,
0.02325504645705223,
-0.6386545300483704,
-0.7941756844520569,
-0.9934194087982178,
0.8707354664802551,
-0.4398200213909149,
-0.2062739133834839,
0.17317819595336914,
0.3099392354488373,
-0.025615360587835312,
-0.47727179527282715,
-0.4093055725097656,
0.2657455503940582,
0.2305096983909607,
0.2827611267566681,
-0.23728623986244202,
-0.4805396497249603,
-0.21665963530540466,
0.2277888059616089,
-0.46904605627059937,
-0.028665101155638695,
-0.3200536072254181,
0.00002725290323724039,
0.7724699974060059,
0.40230655670166016,
0.1926637887954712,
-0.44254931807518005,
-0.04934784397482872,
0.1512604057788849,
-0.6760050654411316,
-0.07286472618579865,
0.4125145673751831,
0.795691967010498,
-0.6647418141365051,
0.6570029854774475,
0.149282768368721,
0.13166171312332153,
-0.043243441730737686,
-0.08454786241054535,
-0.30164292454719543,
-0.5902357697486877,
0.3150816261768341,
0.10620629042387009,
0.5481024980545044,
0.5966823697090149,
0.1014588251709938,
0.15332505106925964,
-0.14174242317676544,
0.1769736260175705,
0.19943304359912872,
-0.7563629746437073,
0.07920531928539276,
0.17647741734981537,
-0.649223804473877,
-0.3758818507194519,
0.16604089736938477,
-0.8113059401512146,
-0.6267564296722412,
-0.4079187214374542,
-0.27106672525405884,
0.004628389608114958,
-0.29027730226516724,
-0.24704496562480927,
-0.12569960951805115,
0.17425042390823364,
0.3658282458782196,
-0.4926910400390625,
-0.27789121866226196,
1.1618247032165527,
1.05351722240448,
-0.16286282241344452,
0.3139834403991699,
-0.1542792022228241,
0.15610425174236298,
-0.4984382390975952,
0.9373342990875244,
-1.1006789207458496,
-0.308170348405838,
0.26069557666778564,
0.05467627942562103,
0.11964574456214905,
-0.1952349692583084,
0.17340053617954254,
-0.7950379848480225,
0.0362635962665081,
-0.5298764705657959,
-0.6143504977226257,
0.17419546842575073,
0.02154284156858921,
-0.3743366301059723,
0.9073427319526672,
-0.12253864109516144,
-0.8755448460578918,
0.2584765553474426,
-0.6532807350158691,
-0.0022104973904788494,
-0.1197081208229065,
-0.3050152361392975,
-0.36766427755355835,
0.44715264439582825,
0.13324834406375885,
0.5908452272415161,
-0.6086057424545288,
0.5970075726509094,
-0.5722804069519043,
-0.41674649715423584,
0.19286099076271057,
-0.34763678908348083,
0.5503348708152771,
0.391757071018219,
-0.27048739790916443,
0.38038891553878784,
-0.4496508836746216,
-0.631887674331665,
0.4395592510700226,
0.03788485750555992,
-0.24473991990089417,
0.2206534445285797,
0.15182726085186005,
0.12529341876506805,
0.37111490964889526,
-0.2911219894886017,
0.18734414875507355,
0.05719241499900818,
0.6714059114456177,
0.8890385627746582,
0.3839573562145233,
0.6818739771842957,
-0.31039413809776306,
0.6889511346817017,
0.0023859459906816483,
-0.1164504662156105,
-0.5104884505271912,
-0.5882521271705627,
-0.5153496861457825,
-0.02477949485182762,
-0.3072848618030548,
0.4901376962661743,
-0.790467381477356,
0.26073938608169556,
-0.34024128317832947,
-0.7365195155143738,
-0.28715234994888306,
0.2491181343793869,
0.007361027877777815,
0.05995887890458107,
-0.07026921957731247,
0.013664637692272663,
-0.2124321162700653,
-0.5181037187576294,
-0.33066827058792114,
-0.44916075468063354,
0.15195457637310028,
0.6347178220748901,
0.7506130337715149,
-0.28581520915031433,
1.0407741069793701,
-0.7946028709411621,
0.15467438101768494,
-0.3456313908100128,
0.4296380877494812,
0.3393785357475281,
0.11002756655216217,
0.5841293334960938,
-0.9616706967353821,
-0.4930001199245453,
-0.04180203378200531,
-0.6781865954399109,
-0.2568831741809845,
-0.25754213333129883,
-0.12706531584262848,
-0.19436369836330414,
0.5804132223129272,
-0.08407246321439743,
0.5040042400360107,
0.5451871752738953,
-0.4430045485496521,
0.2751380205154419,
0.07200675457715988,
0.1882409304380417,
-1.1927375793457031,
-0.19415588676929474,
0.5497193932533264,
0.12873004376888275,
-0.5090595483779907,
-0.08783693611621857,
-0.07719604671001434,
-0.3684699237346649,
-0.4672141373157501,
0.5118647813796997,
-0.2553037703037262,
0.03326289728283882,
-0.6236651539802551,
0.21842622756958008,
0.0971749797463417,
0.10398630797863007,
-0.057395681738853455,
0.5575446486473083,
0.443706214427948,
-0.21637339890003204,
0.5084874629974365,
-0.14641976356506348,
-0.17902269959449768,
0.6430038213729858,
-0.4287928342819214,
0.6125401854515076,
-0.7602086067199707,
0.4875454604625702,
-1.3085802793502808,
-0.22613438963890076,
0.32166415452957153,
-0.36616653203964233,
0.06884723156690598,
-0.3182523548603058,
-0.7024762034416199,
-0.41267260909080505,
-0.21106326580047607,
0.10863420367240906,
0.2670707702636719,
-0.23509158194065094,
0.3772350251674652,
0.62444669008255,
-0.22120332717895508,
0.1072639748454094,
-0.20230276882648468,
0.2591005265712738,
-0.93772953748703,
-0.43647998571395874,
0.4256298243999481,
0.07903813570737839,
-0.5362318158149719,
-0.18293625116348267,
-0.2753007411956787,
0.054328132420778275,
0.24374264478683472,
0.08496378362178802,
-0.15141500532627106,
-0.25711339712142944,
0.06082713603973389,
-0.18113850057125092,
-0.07499642670154572,
-0.05317186936736107,
-0.3415892720222473,
0.8443709015846252,
-0.09397102892398834,
-0.29994717240333557,
-0.5568547248840332,
0.7085420489311218,
0.5890077352523804,
-0.13643929362297058,
0.8044921159744263,
0.722971498966217,
-0.48711666464805603,
0.032537803053855896,
-0.5275360345840454,
-0.3641723394393921,
-0.49798980355262756,
-0.10781019181013107,
0.12496431916952133,
-1.187892198562622,
0.7141843438148499,
-0.3134360611438751,
0.00963687989860773,
0.28280431032180786,
0.47907301783561707,
-0.5400630831718445,
0.5328570008277893,
0.9812108278274536,
-0.2823629379272461,
0.8156517148017883,
-0.4207448363304138,
0.32852187752723694,
-0.4937796890735626,
-0.3419572710990906,
-0.5919301509857178,
-0.14811469614505768,
-0.5768606662750244,
-0.7043278813362122,
0.12437347322702408,
0.04914979264140129,
-0.28540369868278503,
0.1652679741382599,
-0.4204387366771698,
0.17488951981067657,
0.2212584763765335,
-0.020285412669181824,
-0.0608140304684639,
0.2518756091594696,
0.22989366948604584,
-0.34731218218803406,
-0.46669942140579224,
-1.0300941467285156,
0.7964720726013184,
0.2951503098011017,
0.8727094531059265,
0.014263702556490898,
0.7416897416114807,
0.5706260204315186,
0.6125577092170715,
-0.5803161263465881,
0.592586100101471,
-0.13589829206466675,
-0.5094049572944641,
-0.09139880537986755,
-0.3320089876651764,
-1.0981605052947998,
0.09302881360054016,
-0.3214390277862549,
-0.9915607571601868,
0.06635694950819016,
-0.07436041533946991,
-0.08931652456521988,
0.48760855197906494,
-0.2661391496658325,
0.547029435634613,
-0.34317049384117126,
-0.37204915285110474,
-0.42269328236579895,
-0.5085721611976624,
0.09101703017950058,
-0.5185558199882507,
0.6186096668243408,
-0.7794008851051331,
-0.1448720395565033,
0.6370016932487488,
-0.17649145424365997,
1.2476534843444824,
0.1787755787372589,
-0.5544164180755615,
0.4902949631214142,
-0.5184922218322754,
0.5911380648612976,
0.0674639567732811,
0.08682654052972794,
0.006888579577207565,
-0.49572518467903137,
-0.5398680567741394,
-0.4692445695400238,
0.8199241757392883,
-0.6269641518592834,
-0.7267810106277466,
-0.1789664775133133,
-0.4087974429130554,
0.02064017951488495,
-0.04877794161438942,
-0.14921797811985016,
0.3074759840965271,
-0.43726691603660583,
0.25675448775291443,
0.5059706568717957,
-0.40609899163246155,
0.41512802243232727,
0.5179526805877686,
-0.23938891291618347,
-0.42193520069122314,
1.1478034257888794,
0.18334190547466278,
0.07517547160387039,
0.47890910506248474,
0.4980389475822449,
-0.17607012391090393,
-0.43524497747421265,
0.06964299827814102,
0.3280028700828552,
-0.7936533689498901,
-0.07658474147319794,
-0.7041393518447876,
-0.013980267569422722,
-0.4316136837005615,
-0.44915321469306946,
-0.24750451743602753,
0.18408146500587463,
-0.8625150322914124,
0.11669839918613434,
0.5334767699241638,
0.8081501126289368,
0.13434980809688568,
1.0670058727264404,
-0.660881757736206,
0.31028449535369873,
0.01001464668661356,
-0.0041970303282141685,
-0.1327667534351349,
-0.4507731795310974,
-0.2303905189037323,
0.2195570319890976,
-0.569034218788147,
-1.257689118385315,
0.45196831226348877,
-0.07671109586954117,
0.46198102831840515,
0.6164105534553528,
0.04350971058011055,
0.6293483376502991,
-0.2642850875854492,
0.8946502208709717,
0.17733849585056305,
-0.907731831073761,
1.0195132493972778,
-0.8931580781936646,
0.1984325647354126,
0.31406867504119873,
0.46639397740364075,
-0.5810136198997498,
-0.546194851398468,
-0.8329441547393799,
-1.1756067276000977,
0.4571984112262726,
0.5229301452636719,
0.5982492566108704,
-0.07314231991767883,
0.5488057136535645,
-0.2579417824745178,
0.4060063362121582,
-0.29274696111679077,
-0.3923528790473938,
-0.07997306436300278,
0.018497632816433907,
-0.4454236924648285,
-0.34668073058128357,
-0.03315732255578041,
-0.14962506294250488,
0.4968075454235077,
-0.2651917636394501,
0.07800409942865372,
-0.24167348444461823,
0.12094729393720627,
-0.15081237256526947,
0.16055390238761902,
0.6128109097480774,
0.8577472567558289,
-0.3330342769622803,
0.0468202605843544,
-0.04686472564935684,
-0.2723027467727661,
0.10291717946529388,
-0.2221543937921524,
0.017018338665366173,
0.2260928601026535,
0.5980637073516846,
0.7101518511772156,
0.21065498888492584,
-0.2625362277030945,
0.23846855759620667,
-0.08193494379520416,
0.13882805407047272,
-0.13315710425376892,
-0.2815778851509094,
0.6884956955909729,
0.38773226737976074,
0.9306173324584961,
-0.3277440369129181,
-0.15340706706047058,
-0.979407787322998,
0.1878773421049118,
0.590860903263092,
-0.6789353489875793,
-0.44550371170043945,
0.6008976101875305,
0.2379520684480667,
-0.44293469190597534,
0.17584948241710663,
0.08308939635753632,
-0.4868134558200836,
1.1103605031967163,
0.5167859196662903,
0.8033732175827026,
-0.10098091512918472,
0.5353593826293945,
-0.0270039401948452,
0.5206781029701233,
0.305291086435318,
0.3340795040130615,
0.041723500937223434,
-0.7831926941871643,
-0.27413469552993774,
-0.5188615322113037,
-0.43774649500846863,
0.3284359574317932,
-0.7059844732284546,
0.24072343111038208,
-0.4433107078075409,
-0.41768839955329895,
0.22468315064907074,
0.2762000560760498,
-0.4990878105163574,
0.029922418296337128,
0.395803838968277,
0.6831055879592896,
-1.2237184047698975,
0.4638925790786743,
0.922367513179779,
0.11499419063329697,
-0.4143175482749939,
0.39695554971694946,
0.5105008482933044,
-0.7966626882553101,
0.427287220954895,
0.19376763701438904,
-0.19011691212654114,
-0.0641857162117958,
-0.944036066532135,
-0.9599542021751404,
1.1576067209243774,
0.23239672183990479,
-0.5373807549476624,
0.38584014773368835,
0.22325491905212402,
0.6303743720054626,
-1.0013002157211304,
0.004131285473704338,
0.5518871545791626,
0.41283118724823,
0.3967956006526947,
-0.4071207642555237,
-0.07916589081287384,
-0.255267858505249,
0.16440349817276,
0.02673494443297386,
-0.873788595199585,
0.48298341035842896,
0.0036783339455723763,
-0.446990966796875,
-0.3539530038833618,
0.9268279075622559,
0.4840410351753235,
0.9391175508499146,
0.32749244570732117,
-0.13319499790668488,
0.7969526648521423,
-0.002851024502888322,
0.901969313621521,
-0.4810471832752228,
0.705119252204895,
0.674342930316925,
-0.32717397809028625,
0.49463826417922974,
0.6715826392173767,
0.032440125942230225,
0.24639970064163208,
0.924523651599884,
0.2857280671596527,
0.7182292342185974,
0.719831109046936,
-0.2773040235042572,
-0.3541223406791687,
-0.635231614112854,
-0.13062219321727753,
0.3992493152618408,
0.8461176156997681,
-0.19512630999088287,
-0.5065575242042542,
0.06868865340948105,
0.1283387690782547,
0.3303433954715729,
-0.41830164194107056,
0.8084625005722046,
0.35313680768013,
-0.2904423773288727,
0.22459916770458221,
-0.11647640913724899,
0.7809553146362305,
-0.2810239791870117,
-0.1687965989112854,
-0.31260165572166443,
-0.0070509035140275955,
0.013940621167421341,
-0.7532169818878174,
0.5643947720527649,
0.15615516901016235,
-0.0035753461997956038,
-0.5543603897094727,
0.9769654273986816,
-0.30030396580696106,
-0.6983991861343384,
0.275519460439682,
0.6522111892700195,
0.09450727701187134,
-0.1616472601890564,
-0.9768980145454407,
0.5021988153457642,
-0.041840896010398865,
-0.057539258152246475,
-0.005733387544751167,
0.6552855968475342,
-0.17603422701358795,
0.6475251317024231,
0.7016794085502625,
-0.1295222043991089,
-0.39643412828445435,
0.1475386619567871,
1.158177137374878,
-0.8612196445465088,
-0.48674362897872925,
-1.1667708158493042,
0.3256193995475769,
-0.2822275161743164,
-0.1982460916042328,
0.7986037135124207,
0.5579670667648315,
0.3727577030658722,
0.32350364327430725,
0.9144109487533569,
0.34152647852897644,
0.2988506555557251,
-0.3497112989425659,
0.6266458034515381,
-0.7603342533111572,
0.7206660509109497,
-0.5925838947296143,
-0.8157914280891418,
-0.06895964592695236,
0.4081668555736542,
-0.5267600417137146,
-0.1441188007593155,
0.3534863591194153,
0.6554362177848816,
-0.05647091940045357,
0.287609726190567,
-0.06641402095556259,
-0.13626861572265625,
0.5975576639175415,
0.16728724539279938,
1.393815040588379,
0.3220628499984741,
0.30594098567962646,
-0.10747943073511124,
-0.2791747450828552,
-0.4555636942386627,
-1.0965632200241089,
-1.1110976934432983,
-0.7854657769203186,
-0.5364698767662048,
-0.5006483793258667,
0.2855280339717865,
0.858333170413971,
0.4038136601448059,
-0.5829346776008606,
-0.26634469628334045,
0.17045795917510986,
0.48342350125312805,
0.1974654346704483,
-0.25892993807792664,
0.4294360280036926,
-0.153733029961586,
-0.5127068758010864,
0.16646508872509003,
0.5183437466621399,
0.06219176948070526,
-0.4840942919254303,
0.3109382092952728,
-0.12667860090732574,
0.5408706068992615,
0.5501684546470642,
-0.13060030341148376,
-0.6464405059814453,
-0.2302963137626648,
0.1371682733297348,
-0.15707628428936005,
0.09476029127836227,
1.4085054397583008,
-0.32750266790390015,
0.015242558903992176,
0.450188010931015,
0.42897945642471313,
0.7639675736427307,
0.09303154796361923,
0.3683116137981415,
-0.6343935132026672,
-0.003234818112105131,
0.2641146183013916,
0.22519360482692719,
0.6385918259620667,
-0.4957033395767212,
0.28976619243621826,
0.4510907530784607,
-0.1396099328994751,
-0.7773615121841431,
0.19782735407352448,
-0.9085448980331421,
-0.5526638031005859,
1.5206040143966675,
0.021477049216628075,
-0.21065887808799744,
-0.3801218867301941,
-0.11672338843345642,
0.20158487558364868,
-0.5313191413879395,
0.8434306979179382,
0.7731799483299255,
0.3057316243648529,
-0.2637482285499573,
-0.47911471128463745,
-0.04727118834853172,
-0.0017767782555893064,
-0.7192829251289368,
0.014798689633607864,
0.37484800815582275,
0.26198312640190125,
0.2981874346733093,
0.8543938994407654,
0.165754035115242,
-0.4189334809780121,
-0.273502379655838,
-0.4561540484428406,
0.6544559597969055,
-0.3195739984512329,
-0.15665984153747559,
0.18045388162136078,
-0.5211042761802673,
0.22770678997039795
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10704v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10704v1
|
PERL: Parameter Efficient Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback
| 2024-03-15T21:43:46 | 2024-03-15T21:43:46 |
Hakim Sidahmed, Samrat Phatale, Alex Hutcheson, Zhuonan Lin, Zhang Chen, Zac Yu, Jarvis Jin, Roman Komarytsia, Christiane Ahlheim, Yonghao Zhu, Simral Chaudhary, Bowen Li, Saravanan Ganesh, Bill Byrne, Jessica Hoffmann, Hassan Mansoor, Wei Li, Abhinav Rastogi, Lucas Dixon
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) has proven to be a strong
method to align Pretrained Large Language Models (LLMs) with human preferences.
But training models with RLHF is computationally expensive, and an overall
complex process. In this work, we study RLHF where the underlying models are
trained using the parameter efficient method of Low-Rank Adaptation (LoRA)
introduced by Hu et al. [2021]. We investigate the setup of "Parameter
Efficient Reinforcement Learning" (PERL), in which we perform reward model
training and reinforcement learning using LoRA. We compare PERL to conventional
fine-tuning (full-tuning) across various configurations for 7 benchmarks,
including 2 novel datasets, of reward modeling and reinforcement learning. We
find that PERL performs on par with the conventional RLHF setting, while
training faster, and with less memory. This enables the high performance of
RLHF, while reducing the computational burden that limits its adoption as an
alignment technique for Large Language Models. We also release 2 novel thumbs
up/down preference datasets: "Taskmaster Coffee", and "Taskmaster Ticketing" to
promote research around RLHF.
|
[
-0.11059421300888062,
-0.7100840210914612,
0.516733705997467,
0.14224928617477417,
-0.07961773872375488,
0.028933413326740265,
-0.4425458312034607,
-0.20368540287017822,
0.006257941946387291,
0.6920443177223206,
-0.6559373140335083,
-0.5044257044792175,
-0.44296184182167053,
-0.15362723171710968,
-0.051598358899354935,
0.9462811350822449,
0.02794748544692993,
-0.0035562943667173386,
0.09045524150133133,
-0.3805205225944519,
-0.16198763251304626,
-0.755865216255188,
-0.8113332986831665,
-0.6213281750679016,
1.145951509475708,
0.7334038019180298,
0.44244322180747986,
0.8560677170753479,
0.5400505661964417,
0.2120017111301422,
0.32572346925735474,
0.1911451667547226,
-0.8378799557685852,
0.120235376060009,
-0.15332606434822083,
-0.2982715964317322,
-0.3739658296108246,
0.01598791778087616,
0.6867891550064087,
0.535825788974762,
-0.44640251994132996,
0.31490084528923035,
-0.10550525784492493,
0.9377987384796143,
-0.8519709706306458,
0.13613292574882507,
-0.6268482804298401,
0.20258717238903046,
-0.23766864836215973,
-0.41652554273605347,
-0.47114214301109314,
-0.3216281235218048,
-0.09083064645528793,
-0.8606545925140381,
-0.35517245531082153,
0.2113351970911026,
0.7754181027412415,
0.5980062484741211,
-0.19634206593036652,
0.03853432089090347,
-0.817908763885498,
0.8968227505683899,
-0.8213095664978027,
0.3754088282585144,
0.4196570813655853,
0.32807862758636475,
-0.23144488036632538,
-0.4240018129348755,
-0.38891294598579407,
-0.3922562599182129,
0.12097520381212234,
0.061375316232442856,
0.18552231788635254,
0.18337382376194,
0.4392230808734894,
0.08735280483961105,
-0.4549923539161682,
0.4964073896408081,
0.032701462507247925,
0.007261714898049831,
0.5384395122528076,
0.2560167610645294,
-0.023678988218307495,
-0.09244482219219208,
-0.34815001487731934,
-0.519147515296936,
-0.8036587238311768,
0.27617591619491577,
0.55192631483078,
0.6118439435958862,
-0.08786382526159286,
0.3334433436393738,
-0.3519599139690399,
0.7051510810852051,
0.17313724756240845,
-0.3022652566432953,
0.009189914911985397,
0.05262305587530136,
-0.12827488780021667,
-0.014038118533790112,
0.7576180696487427,
0.030745096504688263,
0.08883082121610641,
-0.05229125916957855,
-0.4128008484840393,
0.020272448658943176,
0.35148605704307556,
-0.6516724824905396,
-0.28265801072120667,
0.03711952641606331,
-0.449419766664505,
-0.30851030349731445,
0.0056586493737995625,
-0.4861854016780853,
-0.5235485434532166,
-0.2900546193122864,
0.5866517424583435,
-0.25169113278388977,
-0.001606303034350276,
0.059711020439863205,
0.1345571130514145,
0.526340901851654,
0.5294758677482605,
-1.1533130407333374,
0.4545096755027771,
0.7761306166648865,
0.3476712703704834,
-0.476078599691391,
-0.6352396607398987,
-1.2594144344329834,
0.08541877567768097,
-0.19741226732730865,
0.975520133972168,
-0.5814639329910278,
-0.15099966526031494,
-0.08680539578199387,
-0.12396469712257385,
-0.1178143173456192,
-0.800263524055481,
0.5071150064468384,
-0.7010361552238464,
-0.0493716225028038,
-0.5064799189567566,
-0.33194559812545776,
0.016722727566957474,
0.08296793699264526,
-0.6634957790374756,
0.965184211730957,
0.2787284851074219,
-0.6321117281913757,
0.3721294105052948,
-0.9641572833061218,
-0.4252924919128418,
-0.12911957502365112,
-0.0013933562440797687,
-0.41937604546546936,
-0.1023528128862381,
0.12983182072639465,
0.10731858015060425,
-0.22797921299934387,
-0.13182175159454346,
-0.5077597498893738,
-0.5942203402519226,
0.4077537953853607,
-0.2742747962474823,
0.3003631830215454,
0.3769703507423401,
-0.2660200297832489,
0.5988234281539917,
-0.5543076395988464,
-0.00243939645588398,
0.051438745111227036,
-0.925157368183136,
-0.1347350925207138,
0.1448032259941101,
0.1737992912530899,
-0.0266469307243824,
0.31258538365364075,
-0.3113473355770111,
0.35234931111335754,
-0.2976232171058655,
0.47535842657089233,
0.9172199964523315,
-0.12176889181137085,
0.3751126229763031,
-0.14928916096687317,
0.5673414468765259,
-0.11776269227266312,
0.3163376748561859,
0.3096539378166199,
0.16440828144550323,
-0.7549349665641785,
-0.11054053902626038,
0.622768223285675,
0.5697072744369507,
-0.4407462477684021,
0.35548877716064453,
0.030125495046377182,
-0.14173482358455658,
-0.5808307528495789,
0.32710954546928406,
0.5631352663040161,
0.4560406804084778,
0.22348912060260773,
-0.2172614336013794,
-0.44110438227653503,
-0.8572854399681091,
-0.20821338891983032,
-0.3367985486984253,
0.21557773649692535,
0.43379509449005127,
0.251025915145874,
-0.04142434522509575,
0.65179842710495,
-0.5475651025772095,
-0.07582350075244904,
-0.27818763256073,
0.1884259432554245,
0.10581939667463303,
0.3552981913089752,
0.1885075867176056,
-0.5346886515617371,
-0.4738861620426178,
0.006801072973757982,
-0.511827826499939,
-0.0173704382032156,
0.1771536022424698,
-0.2722605764865875,
0.31261754035949707,
0.3082486391067505,
-0.20764261484146118,
0.04445074871182442,
0.6102275252342224,
-0.22728420794010162,
0.375886470079422,
-0.5052415132522583,
0.1446220725774765,
-0.49208706617355347,
0.16137419641017914,
-0.1429683119058609,
-0.49340564012527466,
-0.3877648115158081,
0.09139584749937057,
0.03288916498422623,
-0.18175382912158966,
-0.44564536213874817,
0.5824097990989685,
-0.1520431637763977,
-0.2844043970108032,
-0.3990634083747864,
-0.014167851768434048,
-0.4081164300441742,
0.9158022999763489,
0.06851900368928909,
0.8008595108985901,
0.2111244648694992,
-0.6135182976722717,
0.3866150975227356,
0.1591685563325882,
-0.13402871787548065,
0.44874459505081177,
-0.48616477847099304,
0.34647732973098755,
0.2480444312095642,
0.17205294966697693,
-0.6581131219863892,
-0.36762166023254395,
0.4416661858558655,
-0.1898038536310196,
0.03242143616080284,
-0.06133356690406799,
-0.41256362199783325,
0.035308174788951874,
-0.40449947118759155,
0.29385995864868164,
0.6171878576278687,
-0.7895705103874207,
0.29578524827957153,
0.47843658924102783,
0.041335612535476685,
-0.6680880188941956,
-0.2256164848804474,
-0.19060705602169037,
-0.39743107557296753,
0.024873873218894005,
0.18297410011291504,
-0.11703462898731232,
-0.14149953424930573,
-0.12402069568634033,
-0.0565783828496933,
0.15250281989574432,
0.2835075259208679,
0.13513615727424622,
0.05317694693803787,
-0.10671042650938034,
0.15393240749835968,
-0.1718854308128357,
-0.38113272190093994,
-0.1987292617559433,
-0.40502986311912537,
0.5391301512718201,
-0.2002873569726944,
-0.48359251022338867,
-0.45377662777900696,
0.15700063109397888,
0.401321142911911,
-0.2758595049381256,
0.4708214998245239,
0.5823431015014648,
-0.010426154360175133,
-0.3901000916957855,
-0.4146856367588043,
-0.3330399692058563,
-0.41090333461761475,
0.4558315873146057,
-0.1735587865114212,
-0.8716571927070618,
0.26997339725494385,
-0.11020659655332565,
0.0764690712094307,
0.18863001465797424,
0.40644267201423645,
-0.19491294026374817,
1.1153978109359741,
0.6732597351074219,
-0.33993813395500183,
0.776499330997467,
0.04336951673030853,
-0.02524196356534958,
-0.6278248429298401,
0.16572712361812592,
-0.48142558336257935,
-0.5557112097740173,
-0.5238999128341675,
-0.29603856801986694,
0.4443352520465851,
0.19455501437187195,
-0.6541025042533875,
0.12682150304317474,
-0.25193989276885986,
0.41461271047592163,
0.7347922921180725,
0.18247775733470917,
0.445987343788147,
0.08522352576255798,
0.18015994131565094,
0.06816235184669495,
-0.8740273714065552,
-0.36494582891464233,
1.0712685585021973,
0.2649255394935608,
1.1133400201797485,
0.04939969629049301,
0.7908728718757629,
0.46995899081230164,
0.15744100511074066,
-0.7341610193252563,
0.5227206349372864,
-0.4361954629421234,
0.023099597543478012,
-0.7830120921134949,
-0.5013960003852844,
-1.0352795124053955,
0.06310035288333893,
-0.3310708999633789,
-0.5965229868888855,
-0.05403844639658928,
0.49833667278289795,
-0.5907053351402283,
0.24189451336860657,
-0.5556470155715942,
0.843518853187561,
-0.5562447309494019,
-0.3473549783229828,
-0.5407456755638123,
-0.6196107268333435,
0.2466486096382141,
0.07063183188438416,
-0.01703655906021595,
-0.11980003118515015,
-0.14494702219963074,
1.0076274871826172,
-0.48995813727378845,
0.6642203330993652,
-0.45696821808815,
-0.2417508363723755,
-0.19967670738697052,
-0.22115163505077362,
0.6952383518218994,
0.16442136466503143,
-0.14712630212306976,
-0.3286699056625366,
0.11576142907142639,
-0.5677723288536072,
-0.7757470011711121,
0.8143871426582336,
-1.1515130996704102,
-0.5212344527244568,
-0.37264010310173035,
-0.6225728392601013,
-0.5218722820281982,
-0.05412067472934723,
-0.06015477702021599,
0.29281070828437805,
-0.09785021841526031,
-0.0815308690071106,
1.0091572999954224,
-0.4137360751628876,
0.13065417110919952,
0.5487933158874512,
-0.4577403962612152,
-0.5029288530349731,
1.0701801776885986,
-0.09217379987239838,
0.24915017187595367,
0.6785198450088501,
0.21271522343158722,
-0.2430124580860138,
-0.45237502455711365,
-0.4797624945640564,
0.38402143120765686,
-0.5526427626609802,
-0.01317534875124693,
-0.28832516074180603,
-0.11899343132972717,
-0.15282610058784485,
0.0298481248319149,
-0.4791264235973358,
-0.34449899196624756,
-0.16923372447490692,
0.10664697736501694,
0.419822096824646,
0.8504835367202759,
0.019776970148086548,
0.2674759328365326,
-0.5014901161193848,
0.3283252716064453,
0.5763283967971802,
0.5893252491950989,
0.11690270155668259,
-0.4312105178833008,
-0.41894394159317017,
-0.16882602870464325,
-0.05795195326209068,
-0.5299126505851746,
0.09440859407186508,
-0.0022091229911893606,
0.6030064821243286,
0.39565253257751465,
0.33246222138404846,
0.59479159116745,
-0.21277950704097748,
0.5188788771629333,
0.12713582813739777,
-0.7344817519187927,
0.3527117073535919,
-0.4466397762298584,
0.3293388783931732,
0.7356316447257996,
0.09493996202945709,
-0.5152931809425354,
-0.0179474838078022,
-0.39487192034721375,
-0.7338132858276367,
0.9674304723739624,
-0.4418944716453552,
-0.1528179794549942,
0.35909026861190796,
0.49218136072158813,
0.26645785570144653,
0.07777605950832367,
-0.6431168913841248,
-0.13681946694850922,
-0.12041633576154709,
-0.13854831457138062,
-0.30163124203681946,
-0.10943389683961868,
-0.23368510603904724,
-0.30456340312957764,
0.7468730211257935,
-0.36453527212142944,
0.267071932554245,
-0.14717495441436768,
-0.2766663730144501,
-0.35024550557136536,
0.4279860258102417,
0.5835612416267395,
0.520764172077179,
-0.36102572083473206,
0.13189160823822021,
0.37446123361587524,
-0.05933096632361412,
0.28555217385292053,
-0.07277213782072067,
-0.048127930611371994,
-0.6562989354133606,
0.27514731884002686,
1.1594343185424805,
0.5343245267868042,
-0.8651538491249084,
0.18635140359401703,
-0.14956408739089966,
-0.36674007773399353,
-0.16714870929718018,
0.4918608069419861,
0.2774476408958435,
0.3364884555339813,
0.18804965913295746,
-0.353039026260376,
-0.1955607682466507,
-0.5523871183395386,
-0.0601450577378273,
0.39613285660743713,
-0.668161153793335,
-0.1725853681564331,
0.43426570296287537,
0.18090906739234924,
-0.4734130799770355,
0.6540252566337585,
-0.14402763545513153,
-0.33594101667404175,
0.18932214379310608,
0.41322365403175354,
0.6535748243331909,
0.10926618427038193,
0.3030620515346527,
0.21473439037799835,
-0.2242177277803421,
-0.2009800374507904,
0.2832658290863037,
-0.27218911051750183,
-0.4895467460155487,
-0.43666988611221313,
-0.8076282739639282,
-0.7900563478469849,
0.24321486055850983,
-0.5915339589118958,
0.012633738107979298,
-0.6887233257293701,
-0.06835628300905228,
-0.17232424020767212,
0.3103291988372803,
-0.26492905616760254,
-0.19529302418231964,
0.11604314297437668,
0.7465437054634094,
-0.7050194144248962,
1.1614573001861572,
0.9372992515563965,
-0.4290010333061218,
-1.0164061784744263,
0.19503918290138245,
-0.2247765213251114,
-0.5944734215736389,
0.8305703997612,
-0.32860124111175537,
-0.47474974393844604,
0.21928319334983826,
-0.6206144690513611,
-0.8558363318443298,
0.9739840626716614,
0.6335115432739258,
-0.42729881405830383,
-0.0011722469935193658,
-0.07433909922838211,
0.4490220844745636,
-0.34124326705932617,
0.02946191094815731,
0.6814740896224976,
0.7875277996063232,
-0.11372189968824387,
-0.7855497002601624,
-0.019243458285927773,
-0.08252563327550888,
0.03025483526289463,
0.20208598673343658,
-0.803435206413269,
0.870981752872467,
-0.12053085118532181,
-0.003806800814345479,
0.1450342983007431,
0.6861180663108826,
0.46240270137786865,
0.025586294010281563,
0.7936212420463562,
0.5700979828834534,
0.8405912518501282,
0.140658438205719,
0.9375548362731934,
-0.12772832810878754,
0.23471643030643463,
0.9517683982849121,
-0.6525344848632812,
1.1800696849822998,
0.5198092460632324,
-0.4183610677719116,
0.6426152586936951,
0.7240495681762695,
0.21810004115104675,
0.6013410091400146,
0.39319339394569397,
-0.03743264451622963,
-0.6445639729499817,
0.02276112698018551,
-0.0854717269539833,
0.29072386026382446,
-0.015591529197990894,
0.14686967432498932,
-0.15671907365322113,
-0.005153126548975706,
-0.20013518631458282,
0.2307584136724472,
-0.30397722125053406,
1.0411535501480103,
-0.05346648767590523,
-0.9779501557350159,
0.7600162029266357,
0.06530463695526123,
0.7858520150184631,
-0.8708682656288147,
-0.10410436987876892,
-0.26572003960609436,
0.4629642069339752,
-0.18168681859970093,
-0.32375457882881165,
-0.13610924780368805,
-0.0482742041349411,
-0.3186832368373871,
-0.19093717634677887,
0.5624130964279175,
-0.39205294847488403,
-0.035340502858161926,
0.44736647605895996,
0.3971111476421356,
0.08216020464897156,
0.1816982924938202,
-0.7741049528121948,
0.10156026482582092,
-0.11584953963756561,
-0.2723870277404785,
0.9905337691307068,
-0.018739886581897736,
-0.16080887615680695,
0.6479161381721497,
0.7254931330680847,
0.2862972021102905,
-0.22827865183353424,
0.15386837720870972,
0.6745960116386414,
-0.8517343401908875,
-0.5462222695350647,
-0.5356552004814148,
-0.027357403188943863,
0.10513720661401749,
-0.21202489733695984,
0.5423567295074463,
0.29955434799194336,
0.7248089909553528,
-0.1417512595653534,
0.7363871335983276,
0.305828720331192,
0.6276254653930664,
-0.7701393961906433,
0.5777887105941772,
-0.6113549470901489,
0.4072258174419403,
-0.10881523787975311,
-0.7614961862564087,
-0.16485092043876648,
0.465885728597641,
-0.5048609972000122,
0.04180406033992767,
0.6704673767089844,
0.9206240177154541,
-0.14968517422676086,
-0.20907045900821686,
0.2996380627155304,
0.027550023049116135,
0.07904026657342911,
0.6765264868736267,
0.9568995237350464,
0.046598952263593674,
0.4497517943382263,
-0.08640779554843903,
-0.15801775455474854,
-0.4968843162059784,
-0.8304047584533691,
-0.5201629996299744,
-0.48587408661842346,
-0.1945013850927353,
-0.23862271010875702,
0.4605439007282257,
1.3569426536560059,
0.912253201007843,
-0.9464451670646667,
-0.7378408312797546,
0.13709387183189392,
0.26492220163345337,
-0.6013637781143188,
-0.14879952371120453,
0.5065621733665466,
-0.5245035886764526,
-0.5462468862533569,
0.444703072309494,
0.3931581676006317,
-0.4360062777996063,
-0.5058596730232239,
-0.7496398091316223,
-0.3030831217765808,
0.052374545484781265,
0.4506247639656067,
0.7412734031677246,
-0.6988746523857117,
-0.40869492292404175,
-0.1316884160041809,
-0.27752700448036194,
0.21433492004871368,
0.9988718032836914,
-0.76774001121521,
-0.07526566833257675,
0.46349698305130005,
0.7334538102149963,
0.6275264024734497,
0.26687121391296387,
0.5578770637512207,
-0.39033713936805725,
-0.1720954179763794,
-0.05984732136130333,
0.007013283669948578,
0.2684325575828552,
-0.22103720903396606,
0.3457253873348236,
0.07846391946077347,
-0.7098343372344971,
-0.8726538419723511,
0.3566298186779022,
-1.094088077545166,
-0.2806054949760437,
1.1268972158432007,
-0.061822254210710526,
-0.3847070634365082,
0.017444832250475883,
-0.2606295049190521,
0.1656060367822647,
-0.6563329100608826,
0.8190320730209351,
0.3083035945892334,
-0.5363808274269104,
-0.26207390427589417,
-0.37880653142929077,
0.6865069270133972,
0.5677050948143005,
-0.9739531874656677,
0.3948938846588135,
0.3176060914993286,
0.3222093880176544,
-0.2926886975765228,
0.8094253540039062,
0.0874868631362915,
0.3753953278064728,
-0.34092003107070923,
0.08470665663480759,
-0.17320361733436584,
-0.22538185119628906,
-0.5745701789855957,
0.26067236065864563,
0.9373859763145447,
0.09085406363010406
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10700v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10700v1
|
Mind the Error! Detection and Localization of Instruction Errors in Vision-and-Language Navigation
| 2024-03-15T21:36:15 | 2024-03-15T21:36:15 |
Francesco Taioli, Stefano Rosa, Alberto Castellini, Lorenzo Natale, Alessio Del Bue, Alessandro Farinelli, Marco Cristani, Yiming Wang
|
cs.RO
|
cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Vision-and-Language Navigation in Continuous Environments (VLN-CE) is one of
the most intuitive yet challenging embodied AI tasks. Agents are tasked to
navigate towards a target goal by executing a set of low-level actions,
following a series of natural language instructions. All VLN-CE methods in the
literature assume that language instructions are exact. However, in practice,
instructions given by humans can contain errors when describing a spatial
environment due to inaccurate memory or confusion. Current VLN-CE benchmarks do
not address this scenario, making the state-of-the-art methods in VLN-CE
fragile in the presence of erroneous instructions from human users. For the
first time, we propose a novel benchmark dataset that introduces various types
of instruction errors considering potential human causes. This benchmark
provides valuable insight into the robustness of VLN systems in continuous
environments. We observe a noticeable performance drop (up to -25%) in Success
Rate when evaluating the state-of-the-art VLN-CE methods on our benchmark.
Moreover, we formally define the task of Instruction Error Detection and
Localization, and establish an evaluation protocol on top of our benchmark
dataset. We also propose an effective method, based on a cross-modal
transformer architecture, that achieves the best performance in error detection
and localization, compared to baselines. Surprisingly, our proposed method has
revealed errors in the validation set of the two commonly used datasets for
VLN-CE, i.e., R2R-CE and RxR-CE, demonstrating the utility of our technique in
other tasks. Code and dataset will be made available upon acceptance at
https://intelligolabs.github.io/R2RIE-CE
|
[
-0.13636814057826996,
-0.7097619771957397,
0.681005597114563,
0.018132340162992477,
0.021872078999876976,
-0.11586234718561172,
-0.29353299736976624,
-0.34746164083480835,
-0.24381844699382782,
0.32322949171066284,
-0.5734490156173706,
-0.8234100937843323,
-0.3629205822944641,
-0.2643602192401886,
-0.2644466161727905,
0.4532946050167084,
-0.24835823476314545,
0.36172881722450256,
-0.52250736951828,
-0.48452118039131165,
-0.8197951316833496,
-0.38932669162750244,
-0.3960656225681305,
-0.07563997060060501,
0.339547723531723,
0.5579453706741333,
0.45804670453071594,
0.5902642607688904,
0.44330087304115295,
0.2571924328804016,
0.3028290271759033,
0.4763484001159668,
-0.267348974943161,
-0.11084036529064178,
-0.15064409375190735,
-0.5935238599777222,
-0.28290924429893494,
-0.6043609380722046,
0.5890581607818604,
0.534589946269989,
-0.15823417901992798,
-0.019872009754180908,
0.028089938685297966,
0.7831991910934448,
-0.8952034115791321,
0.3201654553413391,
-0.13743256032466888,
0.22346624732017517,
-0.1757604479789734,
-0.0041495724581182,
-0.6940953135490417,
-0.2986617386341095,
0.1152447983622551,
-0.6996385455131531,
0.2717841863632202,
0.16195383667945862,
0.6584598422050476,
0.7288245558738708,
-0.11808124929666519,
-0.06820005923509598,
-0.8972359895706177,
0.8108330368995667,
-0.4154285788536072,
0.7012463212013245,
0.11516296863555908,
0.5193418264389038,
-0.09595444053411484,
-0.5163644552230835,
-0.6799845099449158,
-0.017152711749076843,
-0.20810440182685852,
0.41329294443130493,
-0.3402499258518219,
-0.006929392460733652,
0.3095008432865143,
-0.2296871691942215,
-0.7497137188911438,
0.119686059653759,
-0.21623273193836212,
-0.1723705679178238,
0.1941017508506775,
0.16284118592739105,
0.46955135464668274,
0.10905378311872482,
-0.31869786977767944,
-0.6209831833839417,
-0.6006849408149719,
0.16715821623802185,
-0.15271171927452087,
0.0554087832570076,
-0.449385404586792,
0.33054959774017334,
-0.3494398891925812,
0.8591145873069763,
-0.30054351687431335,
0.1094028502702713,
0.38512182235717773,
-0.3317253589630127,
-0.15463249385356903,
0.14659158885478973,
0.5240166783332825,
0.5101137757301331,
0.24694757163524628,
-0.16293969750404358,
-0.11855348944664001,
0.2552834153175354,
0.45662274956703186,
-0.23612459003925323,
-0.3178729712963104,
0.04763350635766983,
-0.15062323212623596,
0.08894088864326477,
0.0802965760231018,
-0.8062400221824646,
-0.34743383526802063,
-0.22123371064662933,
0.33347374200820923,
-0.2286321222782135,
-0.04913882538676262,
0.06168033182621002,
0.18297803401947021,
0.6209095120429993,
0.4392794966697693,
-0.5473524928092957,
0.2918797731399536,
0.6087201833724976,
0.48465436697006226,
-0.1746096909046173,
-0.4173383116722107,
-0.568985641002655,
-0.09820112586021423,
-0.3404363989830017,
0.8513277769088745,
-0.3270508348941803,
-0.5725491642951965,
0.013224154710769653,
0.11822155117988586,
-0.2891804575920105,
-0.6591932773590088,
0.6038389801979065,
-0.24639904499053955,
0.052741821855306625,
-0.5773681998252869,
-0.22336146235466003,
-0.25430402159690857,
0.24681365489959717,
-0.6241804361343384,
0.9487325549125671,
0.12574402987957,
-0.3930950462818146,
0.2832271158695221,
-0.6932163834571838,
-0.2853059768676758,
0.011526348069310188,
-0.4527786374092102,
-0.4977661967277527,
0.06444986164569855,
0.3308744430541992,
-0.0104580232873559,
-0.11152008175849915,
-0.11545495688915253,
0.17951714992523193,
-0.6518226265907288,
0.12012259662151337,
-0.6288265585899353,
0.6735262274742126,
-0.2993127703666687,
-0.95731520652771,
0.07718144357204437,
-0.7166702151298523,
0.21721939742565155,
0.1247325912117958,
-0.15081632137298584,
-0.34161677956581116,
0.4120090901851654,
-0.1337319165468216,
-0.04883332550525665,
0.26339641213417053,
-0.5151358246803284,
0.06188356131315231,
-0.17069011926651,
-0.14597594738006592,
0.5438961386680603,
-0.1717604249715805,
0.4417349696159363,
-0.07543525099754333,
0.3495469391345978,
0.21736198663711548,
0.4803003966808319,
-0.20395517349243164,
-0.5765306949615479,
-1.1121469736099243,
0.20594735443592072,
-0.04323011636734009,
1.0405632257461548,
-0.8572454452514648,
0.29538264870643616,
-0.38138073682785034,
-0.43750491738319397,
-0.4194906949996948,
-0.05574214830994606,
0.9375041127204895,
0.7282626032829285,
0.6553491950035095,
-0.14843428134918213,
-0.5475561618804932,
-0.6384875774383545,
-0.08439493179321289,
-0.3005022704601288,
0.01097437646239996,
0.3631064295768738,
0.16206605732440948,
-0.5065115690231323,
0.8581411242485046,
-0.24626952409744263,
-0.14901351928710938,
0.229572132229805,
0.026064790785312653,
-0.14990301430225372,
0.61814284324646,
0.28011780977249146,
-0.8980661630630493,
-0.1886022388935089,
0.3252260386943817,
-1.0471267700195312,
0.027508510276675224,
-0.21310840547084808,
-0.12549111247062683,
0.4148409068584442,
0.4973030090332031,
-0.2319551408290863,
0.8387852311134338,
0.46281203627586365,
-0.21412678062915802,
0.4123135209083557,
-0.5277721285820007,
0.37861937284469604,
-0.5848438143730164,
-0.18002338707447052,
0.18489129841327667,
-0.10365983098745346,
-0.36851513385772705,
0.18177001178264618,
0.32808899879455566,
0.213189497590065,
-0.5702340602874756,
0.28144189715385437,
-0.4838366210460663,
-0.22660015523433685,
0.05344247817993164,
0.23437844216823578,
-0.005636682268232107,
0.7479875683784485,
0.11107176542282104,
0.7631255984306335,
0.5073257684707642,
-0.4211554527282715,
0.5200789570808411,
0.13165690004825592,
-0.14421795308589935,
0.7558197975158691,
-0.5295159816741943,
0.25483816862106323,
-0.22929580509662628,
0.150915265083313,
-0.9083247780799866,
-0.2156403809785843,
0.5367674231529236,
-0.46033793687820435,
0.29649150371551514,
-0.021033164113759995,
-0.23770244419574738,
-0.393046498298645,
0.06274088472127914,
0.4609009623527527,
0.6675605177879333,
-0.704180121421814,
0.6712941527366638,
0.08733455836772919,
0.4815419316291809,
-0.7612470984458923,
-0.8397283554077148,
-0.024438751861453056,
0.162836492061615,
-0.522754430770874,
0.06213528662919998,
-0.1403040736913681,
-0.23189550638198853,
0.09638498723506927,
-0.34940460324287415,
-0.04283125326037407,
-0.00907508097589016,
0.5883472561836243,
0.5297218561172485,
-0.24178797006607056,
-0.17202408611774445,
-0.15679408609867096,
-0.33914533257484436,
0.19994932413101196,
-0.3100023865699768,
0.07610992342233658,
-0.5538917183876038,
-0.8507837653160095,
-0.6259931325912476,
0.07575027644634247,
0.6413894295692444,
-0.07518695294857025,
0.5308253169059753,
0.49801936745643616,
-0.49134084582328796,
-0.2573106586933136,
-0.5887529850006104,
-0.0026770257391035557,
-0.4510210454463959,
0.4711167514324188,
-0.09350240975618362,
-0.3578634262084961,
0.35620492696762085,
-0.06119043007493019,
0.06644194573163986,
0.0900278091430664,
0.17601996660232544,
-0.3453483581542969,
0.8170043230056763,
0.6353209018707275,
-0.037627242505550385,
0.23791749775409698,
-0.27790307998657227,
0.30370092391967773,
-0.7088718414306641,
-0.4421141743659973,
-0.6041923761367798,
-0.42986926436424255,
-0.41328752040863037,
-0.7674899697303772,
0.6672194600105286,
-0.19705457985401154,
-0.14465558528900146,
0.3523428738117218,
-0.6279950737953186,
0.5978350043296814,
0.632856547832489,
0.27754202485084534,
-0.013378455303609371,
-0.025957195088267326,
-0.1614527553319931,
-0.3296172320842743,
-0.7998232245445251,
-0.2858467698097229,
0.8998117446899414,
0.040506619960069656,
0.6196289658546448,
-0.11385922133922577,
0.7232692837715149,
0.5060214996337891,
0.1839202493429184,
-0.7178766131401062,
0.6359821557998657,
-0.05417180061340332,
-0.13955232501029968,
-0.42746269702911377,
-0.29570600390434265,
-0.6905704736709595,
0.025042863562703133,
0.03859370946884155,
-0.8369505405426025,
0.3889983594417572,
0.28854987025260925,
-0.33038604259490967,
0.41525593400001526,
-0.8144465684890747,
1.2506622076034546,
-0.4337344169616699,
-0.44822046160697937,
-0.0796428695321083,
-0.8479827642440796,
0.08192294090986252,
0.09192261099815369,
0.2613379955291748,
0.30362677574157715,
-0.10370039194822311,
0.43962550163269043,
-0.22287660837173462,
0.7294824123382568,
-0.49501004815101624,
0.038150906562805176,
0.3203265070915222,
-0.02340131253004074,
0.7652472853660583,
-0.24597811698913574,
0.10480880737304688,
0.2896364629268646,
-0.3595545291900635,
-0.473578542470932,
-0.6441072821617126,
0.6869266629219055,
-0.7315838932991028,
-0.29677289724349976,
-0.3514830768108368,
-0.10236182063817978,
-0.1817615032196045,
0.0840998962521553,
0.39071911573410034,
0.6949515342712402,
-0.17358742654323578,
0.20252907276153564,
1.0534870624542236,
-0.3497687876224518,
0.3305759131908417,
0.5557270050048828,
0.21445946395397186,
-0.04200160503387451,
1.2466845512390137,
0.043788760900497437,
0.04812886565923691,
0.5181000828742981,
-0.1706463098526001,
-0.09923623502254486,
-0.6188791394233704,
-0.7788833379745483,
-0.06910829246044159,
-0.8228354454040527,
-0.03651963174343109,
-0.36146411299705505,
-0.13952115178108215,
0.04072412848472595,
-0.3847508430480957,
-0.7521229386329651,
0.2885855436325073,
-0.19422167539596558,
0.11165652424097061,
-0.18133893609046936,
0.5443980693817139,
0.02471022680401802,
0.25065383315086365,
-0.9054152965545654,
0.10880003124475479,
0.2875818908214569,
0.09364808350801468,
-0.15245135128498077,
-0.10098260641098022,
-0.4780106842517853,
0.26113900542259216,
0.045037370175123215,
-0.6393620371818542,
0.0458223894238472,
-0.15953297913074493,
0.6593320965766907,
0.0731457769870758,
0.06574206799268723,
0.5615537166595459,
-0.43400126695632935,
0.8266836404800415,
0.02109047956764698,
-0.8020139932632446,
0.736228883266449,
-0.02195894718170166,
0.6044254302978516,
0.6253809332847595,
0.09526596963405609,
-0.619447648525238,
-0.25282302498817444,
-0.39940202236175537,
-0.9514172673225403,
0.6165848970413208,
0.049806006252765656,
-0.24284812808036804,
-0.03329070657491684,
0.15952302515506744,
-0.3021444082260132,
-0.2922230660915375,
-0.5281686186790466,
-0.4359511733055115,
0.05838661268353462,
-0.2792375385761261,
0.23203521966934204,
-0.040877919644117355,
-0.10106318444013596,
0.003420168301090598,
0.6290091872215271,
-0.25808000564575195,
0.3344103991985321,
0.518134593963623,
-0.37286487221717834,
-0.3826381266117096,
0.05521334335207939,
0.8496787548065186,
0.8862488865852356,
-0.040758389979600906,
-0.1664835512638092,
0.5179342031478882,
-0.5503520369529724,
0.1259269416332245,
-0.14024440944194794,
-0.4004741609096527,
0.16727302968502045,
0.35668444633483887,
0.7104271054267883,
0.7047467827796936,
-0.9260516166687012,
0.6282788515090942,
-0.4009975790977478,
0.22467859089374542,
-0.6372025012969971,
0.29316407442092896,
-0.15994921326637268,
0.41985857486724854,
0.36162883043289185,
0.555027186870575,
0.08218665421009064,
-0.15542198717594147,
0.25674957036972046,
0.05639847740530968,
-0.6459962725639343,
-0.23936957120895386,
0.7164978981018066,
0.26860511302948,
-0.42502766847610474,
0.7542659640312195,
-0.2469380795955658,
-0.42503154277801514,
0.8322819471359253,
0.1188427209854126,
0.9812838435173035,
-0.020398559048771858,
0.11763493716716766,
0.4676382839679718,
0.4545658528804779,
-0.07019299268722534,
0.018101826310157776,
-0.294295072555542,
-0.8256776332855225,
-0.2622315585613251,
-0.30372893810272217,
-0.6735392212867737,
-0.41318652033805847,
-0.826698362827301,
0.07607696205377579,
-0.46052753925323486,
0.0915854200720787,
-0.43188464641571045,
-0.3727583587169647,
-0.8628242015838623,
0.36902767419815063,
0.5613625049591064,
0.7242520451545715,
-0.5978376269340515,
0.8215305209159851,
0.7745121717453003,
0.02124461904168129,
-0.5915105938911438,
0.15040457248687744,
0.3305104374885559,
-0.7886961102485657,
0.4706134796142578,
0.15339623391628265,
-0.4558646082878113,
-0.18972794711589813,
-0.34585970640182495,
-0.5895180702209473,
1.2954587936401367,
-0.06025960296392441,
-0.9576991200447083,
-0.1180044561624527,
0.06079572066664696,
0.3844790458679199,
-0.1563861072063446,
0.09810921549797058,
0.71430903673172,
0.6081559062004089,
-0.11812172085046768,
-0.7725329399108887,
-0.08565826714038849,
-0.16785594820976257,
0.05783507972955704,
0.1891559213399887,
-0.7111437320709229,
0.38728880882263184,
-0.33113861083984375,
-0.24810561537742615,
0.06066848337650299,
0.6600589752197266,
0.13980254530906677,
0.5713878870010376,
0.5156804919242859,
0.7176138162612915,
0.8218022584915161,
-0.5306310057640076,
1.0404404401779175,
-0.17588818073272705,
0.1303136944770813,
1.2814725637435913,
-0.16697296500205994,
0.8415911197662354,
0.2751617729663849,
-0.13658572733402252,
0.5884729027748108,
0.2385062873363495,
0.09704635292291641,
0.3970283269882202,
0.025818927213549614,
-0.39074286818504333,
-0.10860981047153473,
0.26322582364082336,
-0.34849125146865845,
0.3998638093471527,
0.45293909311294556,
-0.060989152640104294,
-0.22278617322444916,
0.1906535029411316,
-0.042613185942173004,
0.25048285722732544,
-0.21211031079292297,
0.6616256833076477,
-0.3537841737270355,
-0.7262880206108093,
0.5618352890014648,
-0.15371590852737427,
0.6381968259811401,
-0.49648964405059814,
-0.2118399441242218,
-0.42481958866119385,
0.3874857425689697,
-0.0843179002404213,
-0.570729672908783,
0.24292658269405365,
0.028395410627126694,
-0.09647099673748016,
-0.006698837503790855,
0.6494964957237244,
-0.11605838686227798,
-0.2704894542694092,
0.3624918460845947,
0.39039769768714905,
0.06838010996580124,
0.23422807455062866,
-0.6106767058372498,
0.5356980562210083,
0.21466784179210663,
-0.07413506507873535,
0.0862201377749443,
0.29703909158706665,
-0.17518357932567596,
0.6898001432418823,
0.29971855878829956,
-0.2238442599773407,
0.2673480808734894,
-0.010957807302474976,
0.5910406112670898,
-0.6331647634506226,
-0.18173748254776,
-0.5681701898574829,
0.8359503149986267,
-0.13174134492874146,
-0.3235093057155609,
0.7655452489852905,
0.4447343349456787,
1.2240523099899292,
-0.11458486318588257,
0.6433178186416626,
0.04628124460577965,
0.081069715321064,
-0.4230349063873291,
0.5025262236595154,
-0.3933657109737396,
0.3671453595161438,
-0.10531718283891678,
-0.8595150113105774,
-0.26625847816467285,
0.5174790620803833,
-0.3577291965484619,
-0.08145185559988022,
0.7286208271980286,
1.0621757507324219,
-0.019435079768300056,
-0.06066446751356125,
0.47328442335128784,
0.10566602647304535,
0.19264467060565948,
0.8841816782951355,
0.5402770042419434,
-0.7168151140213013,
0.5371666550636292,
-0.3560427129268646,
-0.35481634736061096,
-0.3280298113822937,
-0.5314342975616455,
-0.37376394867897034,
-0.5139003992080688,
-0.6678346991539001,
-0.4436510503292084,
0.4912957549095154,
0.6446983218193054,
0.8043025135993958,
-0.8715007305145264,
-0.13696330785751343,
-0.3640269935131073,
0.2821527123451233,
-0.5106828212738037,
-0.19869142770767212,
0.15177413821220398,
-0.3593354821205139,
-0.7473466992378235,
0.7518651485443115,
0.3906650245189667,
-0.06045945733785629,
-0.3712674677371979,
-0.4566781222820282,
0.13864532113075256,
-0.19090650975704193,
0.3435441553592682,
0.6762000918388367,
-0.7673746347427368,
-0.5504192113876343,
-0.009643160738050938,
-0.24083133041858673,
0.12564986944198608,
0.5684956908226013,
-0.8782975673675537,
1.0163556337356567,
0.2707846760749817,
0.8545786142349243,
0.25131887197494507,
-0.31199660897254944,
0.44325926899909973,
-0.752862811088562,
0.1509004384279251,
0.11612500250339508,
0.45740175247192383,
0.41764456033706665,
-0.3860306441783905,
0.6553232669830322,
0.44977378845214844,
-0.5493206977844238,
-0.6346635222434998,
-0.04048366844654083,
-1.224385380744934,
0.04396620765328407,
0.747186541557312,
-0.2994063198566437,
-0.9059944152832031,
0.008847328834235668,
-0.3442980945110321,
0.20664791762828827,
-0.08700362592935562,
0.6333580613136292,
0.5038098096847534,
0.02557806484401226,
-0.20600298047065735,
-0.7484765648841858,
0.31596437096595764,
0.43335166573524475,
-0.817367434501648,
0.0027830693870782852,
0.8565458059310913,
0.09362933784723282,
0.3905116617679596,
0.18075956404209137,
-0.06464418023824692,
0.9067859053611755,
0.2966412901878357,
0.19570882618427277,
0.0044403173960745335,
-0.5205335021018982,
-0.2329014390707016,
-0.02592655085027218,
-0.21979214251041412,
-0.6956852078437805
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10699v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10699v1
|
A Multilingual Perspective on Probing Gender Bias
| 2024-03-15T21:35:21 | 2024-03-15T21:35:21 |
Karolina Stańczak
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Gender bias represents a form of systematic negative treatment that targets
individuals based on their gender. This discrimination can range from subtle
sexist remarks and gendered stereotypes to outright hate speech. Prior research
has revealed that ignoring online abuse not only affects the individuals
targeted but also has broader societal implications. These consequences extend
to the discouragement of women's engagement and visibility within public
spheres, thereby reinforcing gender inequality. This thesis investigates the
nuances of how gender bias is expressed through language and within language
technologies. Significantly, this thesis expands research on gender bias to
multilingual contexts, emphasising the importance of a multilingual and
multicultural perspective in understanding societal biases. In this thesis, I
adopt an interdisciplinary approach, bridging natural language processing with
other disciplines such as political science and history, to probe gender bias
in natural language and language models.
|
[
-0.5660539865493774,
-0.937370240688324,
0.27468711137771606,
0.26881200075149536,
0.34185129404067993,
0.28198209404945374,
-0.0825621709227562,
-0.49738600850105286,
0.17274238169193268,
0.41513440012931824,
-0.9203961491584778,
-0.050041716545820236,
-0.7521377205848694,
0.2676214575767517,
-0.17276549339294434,
0.7005677223205566,
0.15898512303829193,
0.7251585125923157,
-0.028407249599695206,
-0.2890932559967041,
-0.6874676942825317,
-0.6462386846542358,
-0.2744154632091522,
-0.6241400241851807,
0.26542598009109497,
0.38582685589790344,
0.46611249446868896,
0.11047346144914627,
0.2361850142478943,
0.2847926914691925,
-0.2630593776702881,
-0.023446695879101753,
-0.6935964226722717,
0.1982565075159073,
-0.3821142911911011,
-0.5770571231842041,
-0.04333362355828285,
0.1609429568052292,
0.5775704383850098,
0.7431545853614807,
0.015906641259789467,
0.4486970603466034,
0.13582192361354828,
0.7718777656555176,
-0.7101953625679016,
0.059046074748039246,
-0.41570931673049927,
0.13169743120670319,
-0.2769632935523987,
-0.042893119156360626,
-0.18300098180770874,
-0.4173077940940857,
0.22421176731586456,
-0.38622555136680603,
0.4375547468662262,
-0.11557438969612122,
0.6020283699035645,
-0.13112032413482666,
-0.966765284538269,
-0.28580281138420105,
-0.6088948249816895,
1.0794845819473267,
-0.3122067153453827,
0.6623087525367737,
0.5693114399909973,
0.2377806454896927,
0.1826970875263214,
-0.10927244275808334,
-0.37965819239616394,
0.022881314158439636,
-0.15824739634990692,
-0.1326805204153061,
-0.17391173541545868,
-0.308912992477417,
0.3143400251865387,
0.12613016366958618,
-0.2050001472234726,
-0.067957304418087,
-0.42144322395324707,
-0.29331082105636597,
0.3684527277946472,
-0.056399617344141006,
0.654679000377655,
-0.23264338076114655,
-0.15659387409687042,
0.14438104629516602,
-0.5518549680709839,
-0.008761604316532612,
1.172908902168274,
0.5205919742584229,
-0.16092956066131592,
0.4370749294757843,
-0.013365690596401691,
0.4743647277355194,
-0.08182846754789352,
0.0250313151627779,
0.17271877825260162,
-0.40726178884506226,
0.09869332611560822,
0.26093077659606934,
0.2931429445743561,
0.4772062599658966,
0.3828828036785126,
0.166687473654747,
0.28792908787727356,
0.40259045362472534,
0.466289758682251,
-0.4832542836666107,
0.4307776987552643,
0.029976511374115944,
-0.5500438213348389,
-0.23610295355319977,
-0.12044765055179596,
-1.370717167854309,
-0.6653818488121033,
-0.34535205364227295,
0.15303005278110504,
-0.13293485343456268,
-0.6476537585258484,
0.0427587628364563,
-0.44347742199897766,
0.09622307866811752,
0.17371191084384918,
-1.004906415939331,
0.2966918349266052,
0.5339052677154541,
0.6775758862495422,
0.18527495861053467,
-0.2505355477333069,
-0.2824896275997162,
0.0700262114405632,
-0.1532997190952301,
0.5076157450675964,
-0.5957581400871277,
-0.24739697575569153,
0.30044519901275635,
0.024351276457309723,
0.04182756319642067,
-0.3702157735824585,
0.5629146099090576,
-0.27111318707466125,
0.4929886758327484,
-0.5875144004821777,
-0.1394033432006836,
-0.274148553609848,
0.5133273601531982,
-0.6483578085899353,
1.0186539888381958,
-0.21406318247318268,
-1.153139352798462,
0.564520537853241,
-1.188104510307312,
-0.37436676025390625,
-0.3991851806640625,
-0.17484791576862335,
-0.2741183340549469,
-0.07946235686540604,
0.3599202036857605,
0.024561138823628426,
-0.340932160615921,
0.516755223274231,
-0.25200575590133667,
-0.002217539120465517,
0.05594959482550621,
-0.42973586916923523,
1.0013890266418457,
-0.0074899629689753056,
-0.5013932585716248,
0.04649744927883148,
-0.4934538006782532,
-0.46493837237358093,
0.20632928609848022,
-0.2308783233165741,
-0.8350006937980652,
0.08102244883775711,
0.3074016869068146,
0.2271614968776703,
0.03240714222192764,
-0.9244706034660339,
-0.029188670217990875,
-0.43542543053627014,
0.46412867307662964,
0.6245484948158264,
-0.36722448468208313,
0.6895797848701477,
-0.2297392040491104,
0.4279136657714844,
-0.006544789299368858,
0.1991756558418274,
-0.11970953643321991,
-0.46528494358062744,
-0.38209059834480286,
0.1631595641374588,
0.14368556439876556,
0.49807873368263245,
-0.8863968253135681,
-0.3217455744743347,
-0.16947275400161743,
-0.174708753824234,
-0.8195377588272095,
0.09967133402824402,
0.3841930329799652,
0.3848556578159332,
0.2837456166744232,
-0.07733135670423508,
-0.719774603843689,
-1.3183506727218628,
-0.9825447797775269,
-0.1599726676940918,
0.2347327023744583,
0.29146912693977356,
0.6602341532707214,
-0.15943631529808044,
0.9946253299713135,
-0.30918076634407043,
-0.47112688422203064,
-0.326742947101593,
0.5168350338935852,
-0.08136558532714844,
0.3592379689216614,
0.575856626033783,
-1.0013309717178345,
-0.21254761517047882,
-0.03326636552810669,
-0.7077698111534119,
-0.4384664297103882,
0.1530144065618515,
-0.21718861162662506,
0.025242475792765617,
0.20996367931365967,
-0.12888099253177643,
0.33121177554130554,
0.7178712487220764,
-0.6839816570281982,
0.41581931710243225,
0.23313675820827484,
0.5232231020927429,
-0.9159943461418152,
-0.03626423701643944,
0.33729857206344604,
-0.1844901442527771,
-0.9815671443939209,
0.19425490498542786,
-0.007888627238571644,
0.06074493005871773,
-0.8122842907905579,
0.6625626683235168,
-0.719139575958252,
0.07673681527376175,
-0.11547838896512985,
-0.2015935182571411,
-0.0007385152857750654,
-0.1551923155784607,
0.028842680156230927,
0.6885398030281067,
0.3135415315628052,
-0.43290194869041443,
-0.14348626136779785,
0.17778433859348297,
-0.07884220033884048,
0.9368890523910522,
-0.22453415393829346,
0.03176109865307808,
-0.6508514285087585,
0.03631741926074028,
-0.7945206165313721,
-0.11487140506505966,
0.24248632788658142,
-0.5914847254753113,
0.11094886809587479,
-0.26286444067955017,
-0.39635035395622253,
-0.2752506732940674,
-0.6334452629089355,
0.6343478560447693,
-0.21555395424365997,
-0.2762119472026825,
0.5540810227394104,
0.9308663606643677,
-0.09805233031511307,
-0.8424558639526367,
-0.9959679245948792,
0.13260811567306519,
-0.31889036297798157,
-0.49179908633232117,
0.07364451140165329,
0.0047858706675469875,
-0.8719884753227234,
-0.5601232647895813,
0.2961445450782776,
-0.25905534625053406,
0.0506233274936676,
0.12069743126630783,
0.06371556967496872,
-0.0993613675236702,
0.04507633298635483,
0.23160406947135925,
0.1288977861404419,
0.17180541157722473,
0.05821571126580238,
0.8044757843017578,
-0.0165963526815176,
-0.3420245945453644,
-0.15502388775348663,
1.0058462619781494,
0.5927438139915466,
0.0009050916414707899,
0.9186118841171265,
0.718210756778717,
-0.6035610437393188,
0.25952738523483276,
-0.8461592793464661,
-0.38570907711982727,
-0.37756696343421936,
0.061718668788671494,
-0.207661971449852,
-1.0417145490646362,
0.539075493812561,
0.20108991861343384,
-0.017742665484547615,
0.292266309261322,
0.5308955907821655,
0.21879325807094574,
0.9231507182121277,
0.8303717374801636,
-0.19119973480701447,
0.2422715723514557,
0.022269345819950104,
0.18760639429092407,
-0.7571334838867188,
-0.14197637140750885,
-0.7813250422477722,
-0.17312732338905334,
-0.6430945992469788,
-0.19390881061553955,
0.05951964110136032,
-0.3363887369632721,
-0.22426444292068481,
-0.01770203933119774,
-0.47748976945877075,
0.2611115574836731,
0.5518699288368225,
-0.009444745257496834,
0.3187125027179718,
0.036863863468170166,
-0.09785100072622299,
-0.6638261079788208,
-0.4533190131187439,
-0.7259831428527832,
0.849745512008667,
0.5284405946731567,
0.5483279824256897,
0.4277605414390564,
0.09527193754911423,
0.4943244159221649,
0.3265518546104431,
-0.3407583236694336,
0.08763889223337173,
0.2789865732192993,
-1.4538131952285767,
-0.18819358944892883,
-0.31513863801956177,
-1.0559920072555542,
0.6880431175231934,
-0.05317585915327072,
-0.9057011604309082,
0.44050925970077515,
0.056953057646751404,
0.17489315569400787,
0.5865570902824402,
-0.6541891694068909,
0.701297402381897,
-0.02326425164937973,
-0.571405291557312,
-0.225505068898201,
-0.5835689306259155,
0.750905454158783,
0.12886230647563934,
0.9055585861206055,
-0.27391335368156433,
0.16551116108894348,
0.5896371006965637,
0.02884230762720108,
1.105638861656189,
-0.11669640988111496,
-0.35970932245254517,
-0.1954524666070938,
0.2507692575454712,
-0.27404117584228516,
0.04743817076086998,
-0.2196769267320633,
0.6834731698036194,
-0.026951158419251442,
-0.46277597546577454,
0.24176396429538727,
0.6518161296844482,
-0.7383409142494202,
-0.42034921050071716,
-0.5937662124633789,
-0.6482588052749634,
-0.07484634965658188,
0.2970948815345764,
0.0290168896317482,
0.3656369745731354,
-0.443591833114624,
-0.318010538816452,
0.6353209614753723,
-0.6771068572998047,
0.2949758768081665,
0.4522853493690491,
-0.37054330110549927,
0.10693199187517166,
0.5894067287445068,
0.18654873967170715,
0.2137664556503296,
0.5295701026916504,
0.25978776812553406,
-0.42944419384002686,
0.2633526027202606,
-0.6491053104400635,
0.18192890286445618,
-0.8086327910423279,
0.156350776553154,
-0.7748594880104065,
0.1720058172941208,
-0.6628294587135315,
0.0023855678737163544,
-0.4413200318813324,
-0.05449929088354111,
-0.1988762617111206,
-0.14889298379421234,
0.17969033122062683,
0.9220624566078186,
-0.1295941174030304,
0.34127888083457947,
-0.3949073851108551,
0.5779287815093994,
0.24947187304496765,
0.2083626687526703,
0.029796386137604713,
-0.13951699435710907,
0.32299602031707764,
0.08030331879854202,
-0.42998626828193665,
-1.407826542854309,
0.5369424223899841,
-0.058918118476867676,
0.5602918267250061,
0.0018318953225389123,
-0.19645293056964874,
0.43212467432022095,
-0.5368425250053406,
1.0687432289123535,
0.050555162131786346,
-1.0545088052749634,
0.7730224132537842,
-0.7245089411735535,
0.4788972735404968,
0.4282210171222687,
0.5676835775375366,
-0.7878271341323853,
-0.4805293381214142,
-0.4263063073158264,
-0.9539933800697327,
0.7777283191680908,
0.16567859053611755,
0.4278249144554138,
0.0013686117017641664,
0.0266718752682209,
0.4199536442756653,
0.5820824503898621,
-1.0608490705490112,
-0.6966074109077454,
-0.13623419404029846,
0.20412252843379974,
0.15265779197216034,
-0.48187726736068726,
-0.23548351228237152,
-0.20553936064243317,
0.5310552716255188,
-0.13005726039409637,
0.3798956871032715,
0.17587341368198395,
-0.45372164249420166,
-0.16766966879367828,
0.5615373253822327,
0.7600083947181702,
0.9501261711120605,
0.10261772572994232,
0.12091704457998276,
0.25468581914901733,
-0.5821346044540405,
0.2943681478500366,
-0.14159482717514038,
-0.3958061933517456,
0.34397193789482117,
0.26768600940704346,
0.5052213668823242,
0.2160356193780899,
-0.3584131896495819,
0.4571111798286438,
-0.2985101640224457,
-0.15297847986221313,
-0.2294413149356842,
-0.7511627078056335,
0.1800561249256134,
-0.05568673089146614,
0.6023763418197632,
-0.04068822041153908,
0.35337650775909424,
-0.9649322032928467,
-0.11086049675941467,
0.4649919271469116,
-0.46542099118232727,
-0.12600386142730713,
0.8481497168540955,
0.07549772411584854,
-0.24383404850959778,
0.15489064157009125,
0.002846039831638336,
-0.7045449018478394,
0.45469191670417786,
0.5177175402641296,
0.5393767952919006,
-0.35293376445770264,
0.405495822429657,
0.3970523476600647,
0.6680549383163452,
0.1253042072057724,
0.4154188632965088,
0.2711307108402252,
-0.8595225811004639,
-0.2561033070087433,
-0.39409616589546204,
-0.20940537750720978,
-0.1672210693359375,
-0.7873865365982056,
0.21621568500995636,
-0.2185715287923813,
-0.49029096961021423,
-0.009772813878953457,
-0.2420981526374817,
-0.8155891299247742,
-0.07697109878063202,
0.39523524045944214,
0.5795831084251404,
-1.1159332990646362,
0.29689404368400574,
0.6616905331611633,
-0.27354976534843445,
-0.16112321615219116,
-0.06941232830286026,
0.7131032347679138,
-0.6316823363304138,
0.742913544178009,
0.3760285973548889,
-0.27238574624061584,
-0.3146468997001648,
-0.18017342686653137,
-0.7007120251655579,
0.4537116289138794,
0.6397898197174072,
-0.2215755432844162,
0.22914808988571167,
0.43155941367149353,
0.37307924032211304,
-0.15428735315799713,
0.6871105432510376,
0.6806625127792358,
0.8554313778877258,
-0.8200026154518127,
-1.1935179233551025,
-0.12305304408073425,
-0.1752648949623108,
-0.0000466707642772235,
0.2597183883190155,
-0.6066924929618835,
0.9558257460594177,
0.3110424280166626,
-0.07328449934720993,
-0.5451235771179199,
0.2846848964691162,
0.01832730881869793,
0.3264463245868683,
0.2604846954345703,
0.15615397691726685,
0.4591274559497833,
-0.360117107629776,
1.186055302619934,
0.059837352484464645,
0.10111428052186966,
0.7522355914115906,
-0.2782120406627655,
0.28236737847328186,
0.7326678037643433,
-0.06846022605895996,
0.47687211632728577,
0.24327366054058075,
0.4131677746772766,
0.07702556997537613,
0.2586211562156677,
-0.341000497341156,
0.1644107550382614,
-0.7779116034507751,
-0.3019140362739563,
0.4890799820423126,
0.326876163482666,
-0.2219875305891037,
-0.4206078350543976,
0.4022371470928192,
0.25921550393104553,
0.6415666341781616,
-0.4746673107147217,
0.5754941701889038,
0.04647816717624664,
-0.5490506291389465,
-0.07297168672084808,
0.26291584968566895,
1.0815147161483765,
-0.6100990176200867,
-0.1117938756942749,
-0.0010648795869201422,
0.0430537573993206,
-0.19442187249660492,
-0.6224945187568665,
0.39799007773399353,
0.01225330587476492,
-0.41703540086746216,
-0.5531526207923889,
0.9367661476135254,
-0.32871073484420776,
-0.5714178681373596,
0.6923825740814209,
0.8735823631286621,
-0.11331269145011902,
-0.09302373230457306,
-0.7665014863014221,
0.3291763365268707,
0.05845516175031662,
-0.05026698857545853,
0.4811769723892212,
0.02442641742527485,
-0.17753179371356964,
0.8988953232765198,
0.5219398140907288,
0.16137102246284485,
0.2557664215564728,
0.5584019422531128,
0.3486846089363098,
-0.5119036436080933,
-0.48023056983947754,
-1.07120943069458,
0.41866645216941833,
-0.20468980073928833,
-0.44315212965011597,
0.9235889315605164,
0.45042893290519714,
0.8484788537025452,
0.050710421055555344,
0.8256120085716248,
0.016993356868624687,
0.8036798238754272,
-0.20303907990455627,
0.8172429800033569,
-0.35500356554985046,
-0.051917824894189835,
-0.6115617156028748,
-0.5759150385856628,
-0.3075754642486572,
0.6582317352294922,
-0.4531465172767639,
0.08390095829963684,
0.3409797251224518,
0.5814216136932373,
-0.10082865506410599,
0.3415265679359436,
0.09932450205087662,
0.23996800184249878,
0.2893924415111542,
-0.06508688628673553,
1.054423451423645,
-0.39757010340690613,
0.15389233827590942,
-0.12946420907974243,
-0.025150692090392113,
0.11138706654310226,
-0.8394969701766968,
-0.9259765148162842,
-0.45199522376060486,
-0.16490381956100464,
-0.11267488449811935,
0.12830956280231476,
0.8211861848831177,
0.5140748620033264,
-0.5702829957008362,
-0.5438528060913086,
0.32127150893211365,
0.41040802001953125,
-0.041493356227874756,
-0.3579869866371155,
-0.13687245547771454,
-0.09530549496412277,
-0.9379613399505615,
0.13015791773796082,
0.05042635276913643,
-0.39416542649269104,
-0.7247797250747681,
0.24467499554157257,
-0.8296147584915161,
-0.09159433096647263,
0.7499399781227112,
-0.1309456080198288,
-0.7573285102844238,
-0.20074649155139923,
-0.12623484432697296,
0.16933727264404297,
0.18807312846183777,
1.0611763000488281,
-0.4940667748451233,
0.5465414524078369,
0.4970308244228363,
0.4702196717262268,
0.28222230076789856,
-0.1730824112892151,
0.9875600337982178,
-0.7703052759170532,
0.2555358111858368,
0.27441665530204773,
0.36863264441490173,
0.8342175483703613,
-0.4712892770767212,
0.22215919196605682,
0.2984054982662201,
-0.22120966017246246,
-0.8502234220504761,
0.4160100519657135,
-0.2637731432914734,
-0.6315469741821289,
0.9955347180366516,
0.3675917387008667,
0.11098354309797287,
-0.6116670966148376,
-0.5646073818206787,
0.43401286005973816,
-0.4961327910423279,
0.735558807849884,
1.0667386054992676,
0.11684469133615494,
-0.30488821864128113,
-1.4116675853729248,
0.26590174436569214,
0.4863867163658142,
-0.5270552039146423,
0.00962131004780531,
0.31238317489624023,
0.3378342092037201,
0.3107041120529175,
0.5824323296546936,
-0.24053722620010376,
-0.046004023402929306,
-0.15669706463813782,
0.2671351134777069,
0.498382568359375,
-0.006680804304778576,
-0.5022647380828857,
0.2644234895706177,
-0.2464989870786667,
0.24800868332386017
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10692v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10692v1
|
EXPLORER: Exploration-guided Reasoning for Textual Reinforcement Learning
| 2024-03-15T21:22:37 | 2024-03-15T21:22:37 |
Kinjal Basu, Keerthiram Murugesan, Subhajit Chaudhury, Murray Campbell, Kartik Talamadupula, Tim Klinger
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LO
|
Text-based games (TBGs) have emerged as an important collection of NLP tasks,
requiring reinforcement learning (RL) agents to combine natural language
understanding with reasoning. A key challenge for agents attempting to solve
such tasks is to generalize across multiple games and demonstrate good
performance on both seen and unseen objects. Purely deep-RL-based approaches
may perform well on seen objects; however, they fail to showcase the same
performance on unseen objects. Commonsense-infused deep-RL agents may work
better on unseen data; unfortunately, their policies are often not
interpretable or easily transferable. To tackle these issues, in this paper, we
present EXPLORER which is an exploration-guided reasoning agent for textual
reinforcement learning. EXPLORER is neurosymbolic in nature, as it relies on a
neural module for exploration and a symbolic module for exploitation. It can
also learn generalized symbolic policies and perform well over unseen data. Our
experiments show that EXPLORER outperforms the baseline agents on Text-World
cooking (TW-Cooking) and Text-World Commonsense (TWC) games.
|
[
-0.04212985187768936,
-0.8634974360466003,
0.7999963164329529,
0.44274696707725525,
0.16149559617042542,
0.28522881865501404,
-0.291986882686615,
-0.21353694796562195,
0.31911033391952515,
0.5836945176124573,
-0.8386706709861755,
-0.8697500228881836,
-0.5838033556938171,
0.30099910497665405,
-0.020890481770038605,
0.8909040689468384,
-0.11828894913196564,
-0.7558823823928833,
-0.12968875467777252,
-0.11981098353862762,
-0.6636829376220703,
-0.03588254377245903,
-0.8338561058044434,
-0.5080918669700623,
0.5530747771263123,
0.45239657163619995,
0.9077986478805542,
0.46653270721435547,
0.15761473774909973,
0.38901805877685547,
-0.07433250546455383,
0.9068962335586548,
-0.36419111490249634,
0.5669683218002319,
-0.6511042714118958,
-0.42352595925331116,
-0.14909560978412628,
-0.17183265089988708,
0.27925845980644226,
0.14668570458889008,
-0.10908010601997375,
-0.3623385429382324,
0.004582141060382128,
0.4377081096172333,
-0.4147203266620636,
0.431183397769928,
-0.27893078327178955,
0.32884469628334045,
0.3572676181793213,
-0.40488263964653015,
-0.6496575474739075,
-0.20877490937709808,
0.5379794239997864,
-1.568078875541687,
-0.09237539023160934,
0.14897170662879944,
0.8605559468269348,
0.46050727367401123,
-0.7417994737625122,
-0.5149281024932861,
-0.5478475093841553,
1.0883702039718628,
-0.18203788995742798,
0.08465718477964401,
0.4416341185569763,
0.35321173071861267,
-0.35986289381980896,
-0.9498263001441956,
-0.38290899991989136,
-0.2163137048482895,
-0.32556915283203125,
0.32082507014274597,
-0.38298824429512024,
0.11643124371767044,
0.016180112957954407,
-0.2835576832294464,
-0.8402098417282104,
0.16193626821041107,
-0.19255481660366058,
-0.1038350984454155,
0.6502256393432617,
0.41429704427719116,
0.2894773781299591,
-0.043769825249910355,
-0.5886538028717041,
-0.37492406368255615,
-0.48216134309768677,
0.1993948221206665,
0.1056264117360115,
0.27149105072021484,
0.143520787358284,
0.3384397029876709,
-0.17231717705726624,
0.48639410734176636,
-0.09337355941534042,
0.12040390074253082,
0.10406870394945145,
0.2822497487068176,
-0.12413462996482849,
-0.04521256685256958,
0.5272958278656006,
0.5070826411247253,
0.20605099201202393,
-0.35028621554374695,
-0.5498414039611816,
-0.0004320175212342292,
0.39905184507369995,
-0.5527843832969666,
-0.22969965636730194,
0.22122372686862946,
-0.2508648633956909,
-0.2997377812862396,
-0.25140583515167236,
-0.6936008334159851,
-0.44199299812316895,
-0.11919932812452316,
0.877093493938446,
-0.5824907422065735,
-0.20200428366661072,
0.3310301601886749,
-0.6066554188728333,
0.1577804833650589,
0.5268529653549194,
-0.8630167841911316,
0.2895781099796295,
0.700965404510498,
0.7479342818260193,
-0.18276208639144897,
-0.5160982608795166,
-0.9274353981018066,
0.2280684858560562,
-0.2535310983657837,
0.9033474922180176,
-0.8232815265655518,
-0.7365755438804626,
0.17253237962722778,
0.1760515719652176,
-0.2899203598499298,
-0.29746392369270325,
0.5962572693824768,
-0.6410759091377258,
0.49788862466812134,
-0.22298529744148254,
-0.44823798537254333,
-0.5000814199447632,
0.7703249454498291,
-0.6754217743873596,
0.985838770866394,
-0.013211854733526707,
-0.29675012826919556,
0.44017186760902405,
-1.0578640699386597,
-0.4253271222114563,
0.16948117315769196,
-0.05910583585500717,
0.028652235865592957,
-0.09952966868877411,
0.7758183479309082,
0.18198642134666443,
0.257267028093338,
0.15268056094646454,
-0.0768900215625763,
-0.7176666855812073,
0.10263258218765259,
-0.3452923595905304,
0.36325791478157043,
0.10863553732633591,
-0.4024289846420288,
0.2217997908592224,
-0.2739504277706146,
0.286820650100708,
0.05616943538188934,
-0.32163184881210327,
-0.5482946038246155,
0.23368075489997864,
0.00021858126274310052,
-0.03790976479649544,
-0.004297482781112194,
-0.36574894189834595,
0.5962378978729248,
-0.39921489357948303,
0.34490305185317993,
0.8358892202377319,
0.20445549488067627,
0.5387508869171143,
-0.2568972706794739,
0.8603764772415161,
-0.20452609658241272,
0.06065531447529793,
-0.25437554717063904,
-0.48730799555778503,
-0.3889058530330658,
-0.19823694229125977,
0.13883501291275024,
0.6598110795021057,
-1.3605177402496338,
0.10017115622758865,
-0.2517387568950653,
-0.23255428671836853,
-0.22931891679763794,
-0.4131356477737427,
0.3246138393878937,
0.24840055406093597,
0.6947892308235168,
0.17641068994998932,
-0.1738184541463852,
-0.7145688533782959,
-0.6890223026275635,
-0.143177330493927,
-0.049136724323034286,
0.6848627328872681,
0.6021528840065002,
-0.5679612755775452,
0.5936901569366455,
-0.6527613401412964,
-0.4013316035270691,
-0.45957717299461365,
0.42753344774246216,
0.06438729912042618,
0.35419830679893494,
0.19077982008457184,
-0.5196521878242493,
-0.34907400608062744,
0.19593074917793274,
-0.8541115522384644,
0.05079382285475731,
-0.3396020233631134,
-0.10094206780195236,
0.27699998021125793,
0.4383823573589325,
-0.8486826419830322,
0.39861223101615906,
0.3289141356945038,
-0.7559866309165955,
0.21573761105537415,
-0.4995860159397125,
0.07067965716123581,
-0.42855143547058105,
-0.14618627727031708,
0.028723200783133507,
-0.2596408426761627,
-0.3693159818649292,
0.4502197206020355,
-0.06684324890375137,
-0.030979618430137634,
-0.21224746108055115,
0.9256249666213989,
-0.3026648163795471,
0.12071224302053452,
-0.38882580399513245,
0.41198989748954773,
0.377708375453949,
0.6663467288017273,
0.5183050036430359,
0.8032228350639343,
0.6078293919563293,
-0.6015757918357849,
0.15603384375572205,
0.407602459192276,
0.21993541717529297,
0.4313013255596161,
-0.6843754053115845,
0.150548055768013,
-0.24611076712608337,
0.3378041386604309,
-0.5481382608413696,
0.2505565881729126,
0.08028419315814972,
-0.4840037524700165,
0.268802672624588,
0.059155434370040894,
-0.38882219791412354,
-0.07314768433570862,
-0.27808451652526855,
0.06914671510457993,
0.31599658727645874,
-0.9002683162689209,
0.9858283400535583,
0.1028837040066719,
0.1816689670085907,
-1.115830421447754,
-0.5814217925071716,
0.19722652435302734,
-0.34360599517822266,
-0.3595743179321289,
0.1999015063047409,
0.13676534593105316,
-0.13258278369903564,
0.27127617597579956,
-0.30341610312461853,
-0.006483869627118111,
0.11335626989603043,
0.2646842896938324,
0.019044972956180573,
-0.17270560562610626,
0.4564897119998932,
0.39914512634277344,
-0.2062269002199173,
0.3588513135910034,
-0.6036275029182434,
0.08231210708618164,
-0.43032267689704895,
-0.026703940704464912,
0.1333225667476654,
0.3631180226802826,
0.05725438520312309,
-0.18134194612503052,
0.3865981101989746,
0.36091259121894836,
-0.07397831976413727,
-0.8312934041023254,
0.03762629255652428,
-0.26937294006347656,
-0.5573591589927673,
0.47311460971832275,
-0.37546902894973755,
-0.7894852161407471,
0.28693482279777527,
-0.2655247747898102,
0.2840752899646759,
0.4057804346084595,
-0.13317349553108215,
-0.13045917451381683,
0.8772420883178711,
0.5692378282546997,
0.30559808015823364,
-0.12753424048423767,
-0.5169011950492859,
-0.3048997223377228,
-0.5237514972686768,
-0.5186141729354858,
-0.2993932366371155,
-0.5824331641197205,
-0.744717001914978,
-0.38755977153778076,
0.32462239265441895,
-0.5553688406944275,
-0.24393151700496674,
0.32524919509887695,
-0.5850217342376709,
0.926298975944519,
0.6096450686454773,
0.18064182996749878,
0.41263657808303833,
-0.1616826206445694,
-0.4609352946281433,
-0.10363991558551788,
-0.586869478225708,
-0.6036208271980286,
1.1429102420806885,
0.1461719572544098,
0.7280839085578918,
0.21994522213935852,
0.7841342091560364,
0.5985278487205505,
0.2354455292224884,
-0.6386134028434753,
0.6256652474403381,
0.020344281569123268,
-0.6099897027015686,
-0.5673618316650391,
-0.2821231186389923,
-1.1345880031585693,
0.5627832412719727,
-0.2516641616821289,
-0.5766028761863708,
0.09604662656784058,
-0.049444083124399185,
-0.1910579949617386,
0.1968204379081726,
-0.7896971702575684,
0.9296936988830566,
-0.2724519968032837,
-0.6287358999252319,
-0.35835278034210205,
-0.5904883146286011,
0.215162456035614,
0.38737887144088745,
-0.09501764923334122,
0.575051486492157,
-0.452959805727005,
0.4346682131290436,
0.04995177313685417,
0.4659055173397064,
-0.4099222421646118,
0.15963342785835266,
0.05213070660829544,
0.4791586995124817,
0.7668759226799011,
0.28854605555534363,
0.28524041175842285,
-0.2877124547958374,
-0.09077246487140656,
-0.3584508001804352,
-0.8564508557319641,
0.8005226254463196,
-0.7020472288131714,
-0.7254518270492554,
-0.8731256723403931,
-0.6014910340309143,
-0.33618834614753723,
0.1234767884016037,
-0.14312338829040527,
0.23070387542247772,
-0.27352234721183777,
0.08832364529371262,
1.0195729732513428,
-0.66709965467453,
0.4507324695587158,
0.7141159176826477,
-0.4696637690067291,
-0.0532454214990139,
1.0286531448364258,
-0.24138186872005463,
-0.09054621309041977,
0.848177433013916,
-0.003369245445355773,
-0.6945825815200806,
-0.4630570113658905,
-0.3772580027580261,
-0.0741843581199646,
-0.6195225119590759,
-0.01995242014527321,
-0.7465267777442932,
0.017026595771312714,
0.4159890115261078,
-0.25345468521118164,
0.0072961593978106976,
-0.5029111504554749,
-0.14446325600147247,
-0.33667832612991333,
0.3743959665298462,
0.6574238538742065,
-0.1682308167219162,
0.4074097275733948,
-0.5562311410903931,
0.15819019079208374,
0.4998462200164795,
0.2709696590900421,
-0.16723859310150146,
-0.26948586106300354,
-0.06850729882717133,
-0.2786279320716858,
-0.4296061396598816,
-0.7750813364982605,
0.5898269414901733,
0.06130097806453705,
0.47863689064979553,
0.2925458550453186,
0.009657694026827812,
0.3327256441116333,
-0.15177039802074432,
0.628692090511322,
-0.42968782782554626,
-0.643886923789978,
0.486298531293869,
-0.5302006602287292,
0.3283776640892029,
0.4506034553050995,
0.2885703146457672,
-0.5715360045433044,
-0.5082486271858215,
-0.7503569722175598,
-0.7032996416091919,
0.774519681930542,
0.21568971872329712,
-0.11248863488435745,
-0.012408506125211716,
-0.10160107910633087,
0.20985223352909088,
0.21223439276218414,
-0.7395535111427307,
-0.08365164697170258,
-0.3678044080734253,
0.19690942764282227,
-0.14159326255321503,
0.26665613055229187,
-0.033158887177705765,
0.14430329203605652,
0.7373438477516174,
-0.19630512595176697,
0.12906253337860107,
0.3689284324645996,
-0.3606284260749817,
0.15727874636650085,
0.3596440553665161,
0.5554062724113464,
0.3350110352039337,
-0.576820969581604,
0.0980551466345787,
0.01375905517488718,
-0.5216763615608215,
-0.04092768579721451,
0.4015616774559021,
-0.15864652395248413,
-0.017315559089183807,
0.4348217248916626,
0.5731391906738281,
-0.025063637644052505,
-1.105127215385437,
0.3735281229019165,
-0.37599092721939087,
-0.328453004360199,
-0.18988382816314697,
0.2498762160539627,
0.040308501571416855,
0.5880376696586609,
0.37930285930633545,
0.10237237811088562,
0.26790112257003784,
-0.41173380613327026,
0.10889279842376709,
0.3554714620113373,
-0.32025182247161865,
-0.03046233020722866,
0.6296864748001099,
0.37068137526512146,
-0.3365567624568939,
0.7845590710639954,
-0.5734630227088928,
-0.5794002413749695,
0.7289073467254639,
0.38501062989234924,
0.9171863794326782,
0.24336157739162445,
0.6575164198875427,
0.18159030377864838,
0.8677173256874084,
0.13219262659549713,
0.34671470522880554,
-0.19297559559345245,
-0.4184116721153259,
-0.5383744835853577,
0.14785245060920715,
-0.5834704637527466,
0.1833469122648239,
-0.19904056191444397,
-0.12261176854372025,
-0.3551253378391266,
0.09207066893577576,
-0.3341033160686493,
0.22768534719944,
-0.7618920207023621,
0.09239183366298676,
-0.1820993423461914,
1.051040768623352,
-0.713213324546814,
0.507542610168457,
0.8107892274856567,
-0.31231924891471863,
-0.8282791376113892,
0.02477770671248436,
-0.08105238527059555,
-0.8074742555618286,
0.6930693984031677,
0.33144503831863403,
-0.06595809012651443,
-0.2160233110189438,
-0.4899442493915558,
-0.4346984326839447,
1.2357977628707886,
0.08354822546243668,
-0.14231809973716736,
-0.09808732569217682,
-0.11704450100660324,
0.7586466670036316,
-0.3045255243778229,
0.7167867422103882,
0.25412988662719727,
0.8215329647064209,
-0.06148482859134674,
-0.5236679911613464,
0.08189025521278381,
-0.23591357469558716,
-0.37597090005874634,
0.19255724549293518,
-0.532238781452179,
0.6176420450210571,
-0.3352394998073578,
-0.22360897064208984,
-0.20639634132385254,
0.5365758538246155,
0.645049512386322,
0.8624547719955444,
0.4557131230831146,
0.6001591682434082,
0.6942866444587708,
-0.1706307977437973,
0.9587069153785706,
0.3106580376625061,
0.07778532803058624,
0.8668400645256042,
-0.38375023007392883,
0.44202733039855957,
0.26824328303337097,
0.22435709834098816,
0.8093528747558594,
0.40754008293151855,
0.1590033918619156,
0.7030850648880005,
-0.01764877513051033,
-0.12436789274215698,
-0.21745385229587555,
-0.12651042640209198,
-0.17881333827972412,
0.44703951478004456,
0.6137518882751465,
-0.26205912232398987,
-0.5700881481170654,
-0.09888004511594772,
-0.11903485655784607,
0.6158905029296875,
-0.26506784558296204,
0.5585498213768005,
-0.14697787165641785,
-0.9750048518180847,
0.3325240910053253,
0.16837158799171448,
0.6012499928474426,
-0.670255184173584,
-0.4764644503593445,
-0.4888477921485901,
0.10853347927331924,
-0.049026597291231155,
-0.9853237867355347,
0.027178145945072174,
-0.2032666802406311,
0.21569961309432983,
-0.5110490918159485,
0.6916071176528931,
-0.24443764984607697,
0.11070717126131058,
0.22339420020580292,
0.7377984523773193,
0.017585188150405884,
-0.13275296986103058,
-0.6285093426704407,
-0.4229680895805359,
-0.1372932344675064,
-0.49939438700675964,
0.21919915080070496,
0.8178922533988953,
-0.0014401638181880116,
0.9570642709732056,
0.34443506598472595,
-0.12056390196084976,
-0.26474955677986145,
-0.5256701707839966,
0.7671090960502625,
-0.9258144497871399,
-0.8830893635749817,
-0.41716262698173523,
0.3959408402442932,
-0.22358953952789307,
-0.37910905480384827,
0.6549566984176636,
0.6529501080513,
0.44358599185943604,
-0.1674877107143402,
0.5924754738807678,
0.2745499312877655,
0.317396879196167,
-0.5786325335502625,
0.40336868166923523,
-0.5152745842933655,
0.3319091796875,
0.035665787756443024,
-0.7143950462341309,
-0.10387102514505386,
0.6236123442649841,
-0.18468129634857178,
-0.11190330982208252,
1.0066148042678833,
0.8588186502456665,
-0.08235607296228409,
0.22830511629581451,
0.157448410987854,
-0.014127246104180813,
0.43222108483314514,
1.0451865196228027,
1.1724251508712769,
-0.15663385391235352,
0.5513824224472046,
0.2732296288013458,
-0.02300194278359413,
0.05113610625267029,
-0.935312807559967,
-0.9739664793014526,
-0.3150046765804291,
-0.028285030275583267,
-0.34482863545417786,
0.5374727249145508,
0.9722862243652344,
0.3452993929386139,
-0.12093310803174973,
-0.004682991188019514,
-0.21739192306995392,
0.5758631825447083,
-0.8206586837768555,
-0.29442283511161804,
0.518278956413269,
-0.162191703915596,
-0.7862113118171692,
0.8338204026222229,
0.26906025409698486,
-0.2943631410598755,
-0.21591216325759888,
-0.4020254909992218,
-0.16423054039478302,
0.2339225709438324,
0.5092156529426575,
0.6336100101470947,
-0.43344029784202576,
-0.1702549010515213,
0.3405681848526001,
0.11555784940719604,
-0.2892957627773285,
0.5843976140022278,
-1.4325915575027466,
0.48960888385772705,
0.20745056867599487,
0.8564819693565369,
0.7005749344825745,
-0.33942726254463196,
0.4559311866760254,
-0.830092191696167,
0.0064152260310947895,
0.5184001922607422,
-0.008683981373906136,
0.018050584942102432,
-0.2488180547952652,
0.6669705510139465,
-0.08371070772409439,
-0.6793606877326965,
-0.8279432654380798,
0.10961908847093582,
-0.8985939025878906,
-0.4162457287311554,
1.0988839864730835,
-0.08096683025360107,
-0.056342415511608124,
0.005467436276376247,
-0.22272346913814545,
-0.29064226150512695,
-0.8872687816619873,
0.872856616973877,
0.5243249535560608,
-0.07674574851989746,
-0.017482692375779152,
-0.6401785612106323,
0.5131941437721252,
0.4063932001590729,
-0.8202208876609802,
-0.08165665715932846,
0.525613009929657,
-0.19236691296100616,
0.08959496766328812,
0.3459758460521698,
0.254483699798584,
0.3616052269935608,
-0.03429724648594856,
-0.30240145325660706,
-0.5214194059371948,
-0.5458201169967651,
-0.2554395794868469,
0.2112853080034256,
-0.0570635162293911,
-0.2711644768714905
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10691v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10691v1
|
MYTE: Morphology-Driven Byte Encoding for Better and Fairer Multilingual Language Modeling
| 2024-03-15T21:21:11 | 2024-03-15T21:21:11 |
Tomasz Limisiewicz, Terra Blevins, Hila Gonen, Orevaoghene Ahia, Luke Zettlemoyer
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
A major consideration in multilingual language modeling is how to best
represent languages with diverse vocabularies and scripts. Although
contemporary text encoding methods cover most of the world's writing systems,
they exhibit bias towards the high-resource languages of the Global West. As a
result, texts of underrepresented languages tend to be segmented into long
sequences of linguistically meaningless units. To address the disparities, we
introduce a new paradigm that encodes the same information with segments of
consistent size across diverse languages. Our encoding convention (MYTE) is
based on morphemes, as their inventories are more balanced across languages
than characters, which are used in previous methods. We show that MYTE produces
shorter encodings for all 99 analyzed languages, with the most notable
improvements for non-European languages and non-Latin scripts. This, in turn,
improves multilingual LM performance and diminishes the perplexity gap
throughout diverse languages.
|
[
-0.2890058159828186,
-0.3376501500606537,
0.3608875870704651,
0.4325442612171173,
0.06497958302497864,
0.1586298793554306,
-0.3566575348377228,
-0.4556221663951874,
0.6079466342926025,
0.4135739803314209,
-0.5436464548110962,
-0.5835152268409729,
-0.5345861315727234,
0.6004748940467834,
-0.20773601531982422,
0.6884167194366455,
0.368242084980011,
0.33518123626708984,
-0.0563138872385025,
-0.25587713718414307,
-0.14928506314754486,
-0.8789892792701721,
-0.1236097440123558,
-0.26369568705558777,
0.7491166591644287,
0.3261624574661255,
1.0557955503463745,
0.9550563097000122,
0.4828246533870697,
0.30189281702041626,
-0.11422400176525116,
0.20420654118061066,
-0.18698108196258545,
0.2055508941411972,
-0.14799173176288605,
-0.6339448690414429,
-0.39079394936561584,
-0.4818350672721863,
0.8027235269546509,
0.7789919972419739,
-0.18382030725479126,
-0.08619993925094604,
-0.15414273738861084,
0.6215284466743469,
-0.872434139251709,
-0.14042635262012482,
-0.5570334196090698,
0.10389380902051926,
-0.5223128199577332,
-0.19048282504081726,
-0.6181554198265076,
0.018129894509911537,
-0.3082028329372406,
-0.21945583820343018,
0.09090635925531387,
-0.2340214103460312,
0.6420462727546692,
-0.14753153920173645,
-0.28333142399787903,
-0.35122981667518616,
-0.7677006721496582,
0.7093045115470886,
-0.6405789256095886,
0.7719353437423706,
0.14064952731132507,
0.162839874625206,
-0.016936777159571648,
-0.46163415908813477,
-0.48685213923454285,
0.03559025749564171,
0.10092803090810776,
0.0641934871673584,
-0.14277921617031097,
0.14398500323295593,
0.07430096715688705,
0.15695835649967194,
-0.7905837297439575,
0.4893855154514313,
-0.41778564453125,
-0.48960599303245544,
0.5565747618675232,
0.17731639742851257,
0.602325975894928,
-0.2940365672111511,
-0.31214427947998047,
-0.1925484836101532,
-0.8096352219581604,
-0.26597851514816284,
0.7521339058876038,
0.48442304134368896,
-0.20847803354263306,
0.5076319575309753,
-0.126069113612175,
0.47221317887306213,
-0.13015487790107727,
-0.2779228687286377,
0.38428446650505066,
-0.16861838102340698,
0.03223925828933716,
0.40566062927246094,
0.5956493616104126,
0.2854818105697632,
0.1080571636557579,
-0.2090592384338379,
-0.1823219209909439,
-0.024534005671739578,
0.1828560084104538,
-1.0789729356765747,
0.04287847504019737,
0.21129168570041656,
-0.4657038748264313,
0.06892319768667221,
-0.15103650093078613,
-1.060326337814331,
-0.29809194803237915,
-0.2434978187084198,
0.11032011359930038,
-0.5400605797767639,
-0.5753198862075806,
0.395368754863739,
-0.010561533272266388,
0.2794664800167084,
0.2768644690513611,
-1.406554937362671,
0.24950233101844788,
0.6084744334220886,
0.9855083227157593,
-0.007756518200039864,
-0.39232826232910156,
-0.31096088886260986,
0.1968885362148285,
-0.24543780088424683,
0.6243554949760437,
-0.8023505210876465,
-0.3074812889099121,
0.2064845860004425,
-0.12430863082408905,
-0.03143123537302017,
-0.4437243342399597,
0.28835469484329224,
-0.5240398645401001,
-0.05286386236548424,
-0.14120428264141083,
-0.45942291617393494,
0.009193136356770992,
0.21664239466190338,
-0.8718011379241943,
0.6056123971939087,
0.05552339926362038,
-0.6724761128425598,
0.25211238861083984,
-0.675956130027771,
-0.24554255604743958,
0.08129946142435074,
-0.4116537272930145,
0.034216176718473434,
0.06397376209497452,
0.19245781004428864,
0.280009001493454,
-0.09361260384321213,
-0.08814074844121933,
-0.08749312907457352,
-0.1310838907957077,
0.06313405185937881,
-0.5424668788909912,
0.5431389212608337,
0.4073832333087921,
0.09320509433746338,
0.19328996539115906,
-0.7345444560050964,
0.1420910358428955,
-0.015764519572257996,
-0.4099539816379547,
-0.3370296359062195,
-0.16814200580120087,
0.30396348237991333,
0.19875963032245636,
0.20409855246543884,
-0.7769375443458557,
0.32381653785705566,
-0.5132506489753723,
0.498386949300766,
0.5330666899681091,
-0.5219376683235168,
0.7672275304794312,
-0.12371839582920074,
0.4169093668460846,
0.35138100385665894,
-0.005024426616728306,
-0.3349182605743408,
-0.36800703406333923,
-0.5447156429290771,
-0.2555208206176758,
0.504128634929657,
0.43846359848976135,
-0.709170937538147,
0.0649777427315712,
-0.7325232625007629,
-0.24874553084373474,
-0.6744455695152283,
0.02898537367582321,
0.41129210591316223,
0.04367053508758545,
0.3905302882194519,
-0.5302228927612305,
-0.5264407992362976,
-1.0228219032287598,
0.01752275787293911,
0.03635267913341522,
0.16186119616031647,
-0.11156422644853592,
0.33584633469581604,
-0.6565124988555908,
0.7925897836685181,
-0.20638637244701385,
0.05285624787211418,
-0.7082563638687134,
-0.03403053805232048,
0.1320892870426178,
0.7041779160499573,
0.6824729442596436,
-0.9258202314376831,
-0.30198147892951965,
0.003588796127587557,
-0.3439262807369232,
0.009991449303925037,
-0.08629544824361801,
-0.3031720519065857,
0.4109072685241699,
0.47258129715919495,
-0.5030404329299927,
0.06132965534925461,
0.8576210737228394,
-0.3565939664840698,
0.8730847239494324,
-0.4701560139656067,
0.4085347056388855,
-1.030000925064087,
-0.2127268761396408,
-0.1339215189218521,
-0.14718376100063324,
-0.8480026125907898,
0.23039396107196808,
0.5108535885810852,
-0.17892825603485107,
-0.5604491233825684,
0.5877209305763245,
-0.5221314430236816,
-0.0065648616291582584,
-0.21580687165260315,
0.08736636489629745,
0.12230496853590012,
0.5212493538856506,
0.1234143078327179,
0.8728760480880737,
0.37854957580566406,
-0.7982807755470276,
0.10530578345060349,
0.3513581454753876,
-0.2554783523082733,
0.31175747513771057,
-0.2249237447977066,
0.09977640956640244,
-0.5123405456542969,
-0.08032649010419846,
-0.3835700750350952,
-0.27394625544548035,
0.05332530289888382,
-0.27664417028427124,
0.6822181940078735,
-0.44437375664711,
-0.493121474981308,
0.012202118523418903,
-0.4003438949584961,
0.7943274974822998,
0.4721818268299103,
-0.5692025423049927,
0.5393052697181702,
0.3205178678035736,
-0.07125154137611389,
-0.7015537619590759,
-0.9114797711372375,
0.20829863846302032,
-0.16562587022781372,
-1.039501667022705,
0.6699012517929077,
-0.2627396285533905,
-0.20392882823944092,
-0.17864032089710236,
-0.20966528356075287,
-0.32269129157066345,
-0.2402881681919098,
-0.015143933705985546,
-0.0963781327009201,
-0.6781228184700012,
0.4339069128036499,
0.15272828936576843,
-0.23867103457450867,
-0.4074920117855072,
-0.42745068669319153,
1.042559027671814,
-0.020375749096274376,
-0.5866391062736511,
-0.10655433684587479,
0.6621735692024231,
0.5684212446212769,
-0.5579285621643066,
0.7912999987602234,
0.5068700909614563,
-0.4719432294368744,
-0.13564687967300415,
-0.6245477199554443,
-0.1525544673204422,
-0.4789290130138397,
0.6323086619377136,
-0.9272068738937378,
-0.8915008902549744,
0.6301522850990295,
0.09983889013528824,
0.02144630067050457,
0.395407110452652,
0.6237451434135437,
0.157370463013649,
0.9740257263183594,
0.8847305774688721,
-0.11218823492527008,
0.4363747537136078,
-0.017941337078809738,
0.26129022240638733,
-0.556835412979126,
-0.11610031127929688,
-0.6462205648422241,
-0.26269200444221497,
-0.6587005257606506,
-0.6160973906517029,
0.03814870864152908,
0.0334005169570446,
0.16264571249485016,
0.38282719254493713,
-0.2614229917526245,
0.6531645655632019,
0.43782687187194824,
-0.10322073101997375,
0.21477267146110535,
0.12041139602661133,
-0.1957446038722992,
-0.4599955976009369,
-0.8892356157302856,
-0.8281061053276062,
0.8542085886001587,
0.22120891511440277,
0.9866457581520081,
0.20968855917453766,
0.9725815057754517,
0.26452475786209106,
-0.16893400251865387,
-0.5740163326263428,
0.26504650712013245,
-0.48217272758483887,
-0.4399140477180481,
-0.1549939215183258,
-0.3491441607475281,
-1.0812729597091675,
0.6694042682647705,
-0.10494137555360794,
-0.6819164156913757,
0.2445167452096939,
0.16642342507839203,
-0.2313007414340973,
0.5842182636260986,
-0.7588306069374084,
0.9433354735374451,
-0.21437425911426544,
-0.2744784653186798,
-0.4800933003425598,
-0.43098849058151245,
0.10988229513168335,
0.16882291436195374,
0.36348211765289307,
-0.4668213427066803,
-0.05834626406431198,
0.6494113802909851,
-0.4150773584842682,
0.6969627737998962,
0.19125616550445557,
-0.15096105635166168,
0.24821621179580688,
0.3742799460887909,
0.047506723552942276,
-0.04129718616604805,
-0.29297977685928345,
0.36655575037002563,
0.36127200722694397,
-0.6177687644958496,
-0.4381594955921173,
0.6705639362335205,
-0.5395858287811279,
-0.5220616459846497,
-0.2787232995033264,
-0.48438504338264465,
0.05090377479791641,
0.16027937829494476,
0.41679295897483826,
0.7838364839553833,
-0.164470374584198,
0.08669432252645493,
0.6689034104347229,
-0.24696965515613556,
0.47285136580467224,
0.23491647839546204,
-0.17424674332141876,
-0.06702104210853577,
0.9027503728866577,
0.21639865636825562,
0.3177347779273987,
0.8281846046447754,
0.03703215345740318,
-0.3264129161834717,
-0.6262301802635193,
-0.8088033199310303,
0.12460098415613174,
-0.9985871911048889,
-0.22537349164485931,
-0.7191067337989807,
-0.24089637398719788,
-0.3773309588432312,
-0.00830056332051754,
-0.5916104912757874,
-0.4489990174770355,
0.2409677356481552,
0.02392413094639778,
0.14086014032363892,
0.562954843044281,
-0.03136686980724335,
0.46816617250442505,
-1.1771926879882812,
-0.026248561218380928,
-0.17925691604614258,
0.3585606813430786,
-0.09128701686859131,
-0.25947025418281555,
-0.4182681143283844,
0.21565404534339905,
-0.12903112173080444,
-0.9678423404693604,
0.45339521765708923,
0.34360745549201965,
0.6559274792671204,
0.2078307718038559,
-0.3289116621017456,
0.6760509014129639,
-0.6812201738357544,
0.5058504939079285,
0.3067465126514435,
-0.9436219334602356,
0.27257299423217773,
0.07081255316734314,
0.42417535185813904,
0.14812639355659485,
0.3733402490615845,
-1.1290359497070312,
-0.5301170349121094,
-0.4515032470226288,
-0.8646801114082336,
0.6161302328109741,
0.26743534207344055,
0.5094531178474426,
-0.14489898085594177,
0.1445356160402298,
0.4905559718608856,
-0.0019064850639551878,
-0.8452068567276001,
-0.10425488650798798,
-0.15057840943336487,
-0.66469407081604,
0.1977345049381256,
-0.609239935874939,
0.19342705607414246,
0.16504104435443878,
0.39575663208961487,
-0.10779032111167908,
0.3615770936012268,
0.2629794776439667,
-0.8035352826118469,
0.3353751003742218,
0.5076351165771484,
0.7712323665618896,
0.5445924997329712,
0.1977447271347046,
0.5237376689910889,
0.009006517939269543,
-0.7982463836669922,
0.11900737136602402,
-0.5307777523994446,
-0.1316717267036438,
0.2425164431333542,
0.4778175950050354,
0.47463521361351013,
0.12722282111644745,
-0.8439251780509949,
0.262597918510437,
0.04501514509320259,
-0.0050851134583354,
0.14083270728588104,
0.07797716557979584,
0.11011742800474167,
0.24142570793628693,
0.011170808225870132,
0.19090484082698822,
0.23359251022338867,
-0.28072312474250793,
0.1892486810684204,
0.1532527357339859,
-0.18529993295669556,
-0.6151357889175415,
0.36865198612213135,
0.3210567235946655,
-0.09641772508621216,
0.6620321869850159,
-0.25470131635665894,
-0.40409499406814575,
0.678980827331543,
0.7009414434432983,
0.6707688570022583,
-0.25029122829437256,
-0.02216695062816143,
0.6221364140510559,
0.4693433344364166,
-0.020299188792705536,
0.2853524684906006,
0.1571120321750641,
-0.9625587463378906,
-0.3524128198623657,
-1.0347685813903809,
-0.16949142515659332,
-0.0015932341339066625,
-0.2687736749649048,
0.2961083650588989,
-0.4216534197330475,
-0.08645180612802505,
-0.02641945332288742,
-0.434655100107193,
-0.4079648554325104,
0.08966518938541412,
0.6338440775871277,
1.0294941663742065,
-0.6756994724273682,
0.911885142326355,
0.4422537088394165,
-0.550520122051239,
-0.4168832004070282,
-0.13333937525749207,
-0.007439720444381237,
-0.834419846534729,
0.41591310501098633,
0.40687263011932373,
-0.2692156732082367,
-0.28088852763175964,
-0.20732104778289795,
-1.0829071998596191,
0.625953197479248,
0.5587264895439148,
-0.8123659491539001,
0.14257477223873138,
0.28268080949783325,
0.33445340394973755,
-0.6484100818634033,
0.18783511221408844,
0.4294508099555969,
0.3123292624950409,
-0.08448588103055954,
-0.8279695510864258,
-0.23510950803756714,
-0.4164718687534332,
0.15397989749908447,
0.5626425743103027,
-0.31912603974342346,
0.8249871134757996,
-0.2907649278640747,
-0.31049397587776184,
0.07920733839273453,
0.6302351951599121,
-0.14206953346729279,
-0.19884110987186432,
0.06656580418348312,
0.16325125098228455,
0.8676199316978455,
-0.16963854432106018,
0.9935681223869324,
-0.4730162024497986,
-0.11822129786014557,
0.9893295168876648,
-0.11072520911693573,
0.7560994625091553,
0.44204968214035034,
-0.05213659629225731,
0.5506482720375061,
0.5830671787261963,
0.041972566395998,
0.37637755274772644,
0.1083759218454361,
-0.22428372502326965,
-0.27158409357070923,
0.09949810802936554,
-0.4050023555755615,
0.4777800142765045,
0.4394975006580353,
-0.004846054129302502,
-0.5162694454193115,
0.14964458346366882,
0.07230375707149506,
0.35347050428390503,
-0.5330585241317749,
0.4588610529899597,
-0.09567964822053909,
-0.13034018874168396,
0.5819320678710938,
0.572560727596283,
1.1117290258407593,
-0.8203263282775879,
0.15631729364395142,
-0.3519146740436554,
0.08703416585922241,
-0.5337920784950256,
-0.6603410243988037,
0.4027750492095947,
0.0063594612292945385,
-0.5284891128540039,
-0.30890002846717834,
0.6691684722900391,
-0.8466227054595947,
-0.36594855785369873,
0.3621235191822052,
0.5853711366653442,
0.3529353439807892,
0.015593115240335464,
-0.35304033756256104,
0.08800733089447021,
-0.04196247085928917,
0.10334337502717972,
0.30849745869636536,
0.4783135652542114,
-0.46953627467155457,
0.8466407060623169,
0.42710208892822266,
-0.019589444622397423,
0.7833189964294434,
0.5156804919242859,
0.48735594749450684,
-0.8197795152664185,
-0.7362992167472839,
-1.2462462186813354,
0.5139644145965576,
0.045527972280979156,
-0.21182771027088165,
0.570258378982544,
0.9650803208351135,
0.9280222654342651,
-0.34570372104644775,
0.5907278656959534,
-0.12202797830104828,
0.04504506662487984,
-0.8078440427780151,
0.7556254267692566,
-0.5321718454360962,
-0.07053069770336151,
0.11218205094337463,
-0.8620185256004333,
-0.322918176651001,
0.4378519058227539,
0.02859635092318058,
-0.01525211799889803,
0.6225671172142029,
0.8710733652114868,
-0.38899800181388855,
-0.05926055833697319,
0.5173303484916687,
0.03204764425754547,
0.2728431224822998,
0.4493536055088043,
0.6552013754844666,
-0.18854406476020813,
0.6939159631729126,
-0.22621524333953857,
0.0771685242652893,
-0.28458285331726074,
-0.6142035126686096,
-0.5110185146331787,
-0.5163652896881104,
-0.3792480528354645,
-0.15195083618164062,
-0.0257734227925539,
1.2399786710739136,
0.7059735655784607,
-0.8630647659301758,
-0.5478886365890503,
0.298427551984787,
0.25571122765541077,
0.007867246866226196,
-0.055098265409469604,
0.02120976336300373,
-0.8354530334472656,
-0.9591575860977173,
0.2164609283208847,
0.739989161491394,
0.3122829794883728,
-0.03217844292521477,
-0.40518808364868164,
0.01503465510904789,
-0.0005642196047119796,
0.6644759178161621,
0.06359994411468506,
-0.5675369501113892,
-0.10032244026660919,
0.017924902960658073,
-0.6202611923217773,
0.8225124478340149,
0.832249104976654,
-0.31832456588745117,
0.431220144033432,
0.46077558398246765,
0.5121484994888306,
0.44361016154289246,
-0.5365337133407593,
0.7222196459770203,
-0.8742241859436035,
0.5316762328147888,
0.45263469219207764,
0.49284982681274414,
0.46102088689804077,
-0.2139955759048462,
0.2978631556034088,
-0.02915199100971222,
0.037198375910520554,
-0.6506115198135376,
0.4768925905227661,
-0.7940258979797363,
-0.31751102209091187,
0.9527802467346191,
0.027304120361804962,
-0.40993356704711914,
0.09175191074609756,
-0.21828041970729828,
0.008978010155260563,
-0.43595972657203674,
0.472677618265152,
0.8000898957252502,
0.04886142909526825,
-0.03143449127674103,
-0.39412203431129456,
0.5180584788322449,
0.3088131248950958,
-0.5836849808692932,
0.10376644879579544,
0.4410192668437958,
0.2430010885000229,
0.3853778839111328,
0.6574922204017639,
-0.3464623987674713,
0.2751920521259308,
0.2621709406375885,
0.4879733920097351,
0.2948974668979645,
-0.543001115322113,
-0.41734063625335693,
0.09751083701848984,
0.24508552253246307,
-0.022546259686350822
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10667v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10667v2
|
Towards Unified Multi-Modal Personalization: Large Vision-Language Models for Generative Recommendation and Beyond
| 2024-03-15T20:21:31 | 2024-03-27T21:11:19 |
Tianxin Wei, Bowen Jin, Ruirui Li, Hansi Zeng, Zhengyang Wang, Jianhui Sun, Qingyu Yin, Hanqing Lu, Suhang Wang, Jingrui He, Xianfeng Tang
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.MM
|
Developing a universal model that can effectively harness heterogeneous
resources and respond to a wide range of personalized needs has been a
longstanding community aspiration. Our daily choices, especially in domains
like fashion and retail, are substantially shaped by multi-modal data, such as
pictures and textual descriptions. These modalities not only offer intuitive
guidance but also cater to personalized user preferences. However, the
predominant personalization approaches mainly focus on the ID or text-based
recommendation problem, failing to comprehend the information spanning various
tasks or modalities. In this paper, our goal is to establish a Unified paradigm
for Multi-modal Personalization systems (UniMP), which effectively leverages
multi-modal data while eliminating the complexities associated with task- and
modality-specific customization. We argue that the advancements in foundational
generative modeling have provided the flexibility and effectiveness necessary
to achieve the objective. In light of this, we develop a generic and extensible
personalization generative framework, that can handle a wide range of
personalized needs including item recommendation, product search, preference
prediction, explanation generation, and further user-guided image generation.
Our methodology enhances the capabilities of foundational language models for
personalized tasks by seamlessly ingesting interleaved cross-modal user history
information, ensuring a more precise and customized experience for users. To
train and evaluate the proposed multi-modal personalized tasks, we also
introduce a novel and comprehensive benchmark covering a variety of user
requirements. Our experiments on the real-world benchmark showcase the model's
potential, outperforming competitive methods specialized for each task.
|
[
-0.3616867661476135,
-0.4891473352909088,
0.5244296789169312,
0.24916087090969086,
-0.2843983769416809,
-0.09454133361577988,
-0.403703510761261,
-0.4440809190273285,
0.0413762666285038,
0.323178231716156,
-0.5799770355224609,
-0.5980138778686523,
-0.09424129128456116,
-0.215142160654068,
-0.11613047122955322,
0.861731231212616,
0.3108535706996918,
0.048171140253543854,
-0.3543702960014343,
-0.13528884947299957,
-0.9724991321563721,
-0.4919305741786957,
-0.18943293392658234,
-0.3414517939090729,
0.45663538575172424,
0.38701245188713074,
0.5514863133430481,
0.25764673948287964,
0.2952316701412201,
0.3326687812805176,
0.06944387406110764,
0.18896569311618805,
-0.1796053797006607,
0.34619802236557007,
-0.30243033170700073,
-0.07439493387937546,
-0.37815219163894653,
-0.25104427337646484,
0.25033971667289734,
0.9042224287986755,
-0.28678005933761597,
0.150146946310997,
0.2938210666179657,
0.5104843378067017,
-0.7642550468444824,
0.0799017995595932,
-0.4892658591270447,
-0.034692008048295975,
-0.17367632687091827,
-0.2515624463558197,
-0.3612796664237976,
0.32066333293914795,
0.18134507536888123,
-0.8408029079437256,
0.3632402718067169,
0.09709677845239639,
0.41297245025634766,
0.02442804165184498,
-0.781539797782898,
0.07498402148485184,
-1.1159619092941284,
0.7314199805259705,
-0.4537755250930786,
0.6990392208099365,
0.3241134583950043,
0.2970244288444519,
0.055319614708423615,
-0.6992058753967285,
-0.11390305310487747,
-0.33760660886764526,
0.010302947834134102,
0.12653885781764984,
-0.19670124351978302,
-0.048765845596790314,
-0.009716682136058807,
0.4595271944999695,
-0.5631026029586792,
-0.16851352155208588,
-0.13811615109443665,
0.04211650416254997,
0.37324783205986023,
0.21525688469409943,
0.3178042471408844,
-0.09346484392881393,
-0.7766696214675903,
0.09317760169506073,
-0.48754483461380005,
0.23296721279621124,
0.13785287737846375,
0.2880513668060303,
-0.20423009991645813,
0.5680716037750244,
-0.6175537109375,
0.806125283241272,
0.1605486422777176,
-0.10157753527164459,
0.22843371331691742,
-0.7397700548171997,
-0.42532476782798767,
-0.3302110433578491,
0.7448575496673584,
0.591863751411438,
0.1267041563987732,
-0.49112600088119507,
-0.11708555370569229,
-0.18127082288265228,
0.32233312726020813,
-0.6661056876182556,
-0.0789012610912323,
-0.05109189450740814,
-0.6025007963180542,
-0.13054560124874115,
0.19965137541294098,
-0.7974709868431091,
-0.3483278155326843,
-0.6721681356430054,
0.23561979830265045,
-0.4410177171230316,
-0.10237223654985428,
0.2826641798019409,
-0.04584440588951111,
-0.4251351058483124,
0.5023259520530701,
-0.9627097249031067,
-0.039508964866399765,
0.24508675932884216,
0.5869693756103516,
-0.16162128746509552,
-0.26362961530685425,
-0.1084095761179924,
0.5838401317596436,
0.08419695496559143,
0.9067727327346802,
-0.9289453029632568,
-0.5252147316932678,
0.0625748261809349,
-0.08658917248249054,
-0.041553109884262085,
-0.35027462244033813,
0.42654332518577576,
-0.4350241720676422,
0.2646123766899109,
-0.5325819253921509,
-0.28270700573921204,
-0.46557530760765076,
0.21651116013526917,
-0.3641969561576843,
0.5635467171669006,
0.1575397551059723,
-0.4365631341934204,
0.5914168953895569,
-0.8343889117240906,
-0.5819579362869263,
0.3233574330806732,
-0.244842991232872,
0.023227659985423088,
0.3800954520702362,
0.19716542959213257,
0.7480248808860779,
-0.8202592134475708,
0.5105909705162048,
-0.5328203439712524,
-0.27063414454460144,
-0.02324586734175682,
-0.6335387825965881,
0.4604872167110443,
0.18293124437332153,
-0.4587794542312622,
0.4961373507976532,
-0.6871212720870972,
-0.017325717955827713,
0.06368358433246613,
-0.5069003701210022,
-0.45405787229537964,
-0.06306286156177521,
0.9365434050559998,
0.15708699822425842,
0.4029633104801178,
-0.5679840445518494,
0.35435765981674194,
-0.042778726667165756,
0.322374165058136,
0.9002489447593689,
-0.2897634208202362,
0.503051221370697,
-0.3087080717086792,
0.28373026847839355,
-0.019548002630472183,
0.3042812645435333,
-0.6195428967475891,
-0.46452972292900085,
-0.43527689576148987,
-0.2753375768661499,
0.09058946371078491,
0.2510736882686615,
-0.35947325825691223,
0.5448559522628784,
-0.2639982998371124,
-0.2252229005098343,
0.29043230414390564,
0.2936480939388275,
0.4640916585922241,
0.33256301283836365,
0.38841190934181213,
-0.529504656791687,
-0.433335542678833,
-0.9369984865188599,
-0.12794049084186554,
0.1054496243596077,
-0.24047473073005676,
0.46616944670677185,
0.017099393531680107,
-0.6692259311676025,
0.8874236941337585,
-0.5605258941650391,
-0.670001208782196,
-0.22481709718704224,
0.09916803985834122,
-0.05818526819348335,
0.473599910736084,
0.457218736410141,
-1.0440443754196167,
-0.2942345142364502,
0.21503214538097382,
-0.7261874675750732,
0.02106895111501217,
-0.27596235275268555,
0.129036083817482,
-0.17723119258880615,
0.3076699376106262,
-0.25551992654800415,
0.3137871026992798,
0.469703733921051,
-0.6975679397583008,
0.3266283869743347,
-0.5916767120361328,
0.40010249614715576,
-1.4646873474121094,
0.24812516570091248,
0.40815773606300354,
-0.1869041919708252,
-0.5421155095100403,
0.08756834268569946,
-0.0972973182797432,
-0.16355323791503906,
-0.1431495100259781,
0.5800078511238098,
-0.4238733947277069,
0.07373438030481339,
-0.19654017686843872,
-0.41300883889198303,
0.1209716796875,
0.7085764408111572,
-0.17620150744915009,
0.49228981137275696,
0.48636171221733093,
-0.49491086602211,
0.4702754020690918,
0.21741755306720734,
-0.30548542737960815,
1.0263102054595947,
-0.7160876393318176,
0.006731996312737465,
-0.09078548103570938,
0.23837639391422272,
-1.0191713571548462,
-0.306165874004364,
0.16873762011528015,
0.17867253720760345,
0.12000780552625656,
-0.17094293236732483,
-0.5521517395973206,
-0.09737839549779892,
-0.09541454911231995,
0.7043951153755188,
0.3487185537815094,
-0.6874340176582336,
0.9193295240402222,
0.1609032154083252,
0.0623493567109108,
-0.34614142775535583,
-0.3259914517402649,
0.2210228145122528,
-0.20088718831539154,
-0.6643982529640198,
0.7646291255950928,
-0.7505684494972229,
0.0697561651468277,
-0.1791234165430069,
-0.09331966936588287,
-0.12857592105865479,
0.018899934366345406,
0.7216421365737915,
0.3779676556587219,
-0.08373245596885681,
0.26324784755706787,
-0.05981409549713135,
-0.23097608983516693,
-0.3969978988170624,
-0.37860238552093506,
0.7308293581008911,
-0.2947916090488434,
-0.6388296484947205,
-0.5065559148788452,
0.6668433547019958,
0.8140866756439209,
-0.4037396013736725,
0.31163620948791504,
0.8602983355522156,
-0.22122885286808014,
0.06668666005134583,
-0.8432155847549438,
-0.015917249023914337,
-0.49784329533576965,
0.29167312383651733,
-0.6276994943618774,
-0.8112995028495789,
0.24524223804473877,
-0.211334228515625,
0.08799596130847931,
0.15965470671653748,
0.7919155359268188,
-0.09160451591014862,
1.286449670791626,
0.9737898111343384,
-0.09742482006549835,
0.6366059184074402,
-0.05423598363995552,
0.03662234917283058,
-1.0377528667449951,
-0.733371376991272,
-0.1062222570180893,
-0.4043455123901367,
-0.04908769577741623,
-0.23282498121261597,
0.5689036846160889,
0.08406607061624527,
-0.19891765713691711,
0.24855171144008636,
-0.7487106323242188,
0.33593669533729553,
0.8618583083152771,
0.22199808061122894,
0.5244644284248352,
0.17628584802150726,
-0.1991051733493805,
-0.008224277757108212,
-0.5045515894889832,
-0.23739466071128845,
1.2680439949035645,
-0.10098101198673248,
1.0182890892028809,
0.0008242508629336953,
0.029772557318210602,
0.5302280187606812,
0.1179625391960144,
-0.6298134326934814,
0.38673537969589233,
-0.36949753761291504,
-0.48752111196517944,
0.05602305755019188,
0.0007291849469766021,
-0.9528555274009705,
0.42514297366142273,
-0.39992794394493103,
-0.8522859811782837,
0.5503749251365662,
0.4245666563510895,
-0.47647127509117126,
0.32132309675216675,
-0.5430476069450378,
0.9674457907676697,
-0.40174946188926697,
-0.26495179533958435,
-0.3214390277862549,
-0.5236218571662903,
0.25030776858329773,
-0.1056746244430542,
0.10549473017454147,
-0.29165711998939514,
0.008033022284507751,
0.4010598063468933,
0.2500405013561249,
0.9020974040031433,
0.13654933869838715,
0.12679210305213928,
-0.2229914367198944,
-0.011475693434476852,
0.05199296772480011,
0.23343384265899658,
0.2574402391910553,
0.2664144039154053,
0.06325826048851013,
-0.14578860998153687,
-0.36612239480018616,
0.8320286870002747,
-0.4634873867034912,
-0.38685426115989685,
-0.19899792969226837,
-0.7627966403961182,
-0.2980082333087921,
0.33006176352500916,
0.40667274594306946,
0.8679745197296143,
-0.5709543824195862,
0.6209582686424255,
0.5424471497535706,
0.006993429269641638,
0.4541555345058441,
0.5174952149391174,
-0.037800487130880356,
-0.3187539875507355,
0.8702834844589233,
-0.2531226873397827,
-0.17519237101078033,
0.5466885566711426,
0.28197553753852844,
-0.2655763328075409,
-0.362964004278183,
-0.6831942200660706,
-0.17221000790596008,
-0.6495769619941711,
-0.18076634407043457,
-0.6008419990539551,
0.476654976606369,
-0.4900079667568207,
-0.391289085149765,
-0.33933383226394653,
0.058268025517463684,
-0.34159794449806213,
0.4445422887802124,
-0.05603383481502533,
0.8263477683067322,
0.0323212593793869,
0.12781713902950287,
-0.6439932584762573,
0.749824047088623,
0.5495190620422363,
0.5270604491233826,
-0.1382928490638733,
-0.29326164722442627,
-0.11656329035758972,
0.1331099420785904,
-0.33046895265579224,
-0.7274893522262573,
0.11346165835857391,
0.15091559290885925,
0.603308379650116,
0.856447160243988,
-0.08688177913427353,
0.5291271805763245,
-0.5769944787025452,
0.44520530104637146,
0.6087232232093811,
-0.7885592579841614,
0.35971686244010925,
-0.5410172343254089,
0.5148662328720093,
0.535108208656311,
0.12298955023288727,
-0.9023592472076416,
0.32058846950531006,
-0.35367393493652344,
-0.8820040822029114,
0.4620603024959564,
-0.21620598435401917,
0.3857688307762146,
0.23050938546657562,
0.25332382321357727,
0.2712947428226471,
0.3781909942626953,
-0.6182268261909485,
-0.18348604440689087,
-0.16655200719833374,
-0.09903671592473984,
-0.28229036927223206,
-0.30670851469039917,
-0.3252134323120117,
-0.268551230430603,
0.24978777766227722,
-0.43714991211891174,
0.09640531986951828,
-0.1270485371351242,
-0.020605076104402542,
-0.16117675602436066,
0.49684983491897583,
0.5468530058860779,
0.8840098977088928,
-0.1025531068444252,
-0.1432989239692688,
-0.21138469874858856,
-0.1040349155664444,
0.09547563642263412,
0.24274782836437225,
-0.29700568318367004,
-0.22702045738697052,
-0.1411934345960617,
0.6993095278739929,
0.4980788230895996,
-0.795383632183075,
0.7192933559417725,
-0.13801877200603485,
0.1056748703122139,
-0.38208842277526855,
-0.08242014795541763,
-0.08910302072763443,
0.338282972574234,
0.3756047487258911,
0.6130480170249939,
0.40853551030158997,
-0.7315120697021484,
0.025067036971449852,
0.7633082866668701,
-0.4069831371307373,
-0.6236705780029297,
0.9805908203125,
0.4126874804496765,
-0.12283103168010712,
0.2716923952102661,
0.15483713150024414,
-0.0393657423555851,
0.10741975158452988,
0.6489067673683167,
1.0275628566741943,
-0.23072122037410736,
0.29919764399528503,
0.024915987625718117,
0.011585013940930367,
-0.19066709280014038,
-0.10436411201953888,
-0.40696287155151367,
-0.7038715481758118,
-0.06359901279211044,
-0.6720549464225769,
-0.1427779346704483,
0.16007556021213531,
-0.6837879419326782,
0.17217864096164703,
-0.42926880717277527,
-0.12451782822608948,
0.11209943890571594,
-0.6013941168785095,
-0.9490342736244202,
0.38673582673072815,
0.16749471426010132,
0.39899057149887085,
-0.6964710354804993,
0.5627567768096924,
1.1354323625564575,
-0.49701419472694397,
-0.406879186630249,
-0.061793483793735504,
0.1485321819782257,
-0.5860122442245483,
0.4653048813343048,
0.15671329200267792,
-0.20826900005340576,
-0.31274858117103577,
-0.11299439519643784,
-0.6674968600273132,
1.134097933769226,
0.4065060019493103,
-0.5479418635368347,
-0.3550873398780823,
-0.004712559282779694,
0.33148640394210815,
-0.5432301759719849,
0.060772623866796494,
0.2622087597846985,
0.5099689364433289,
0.28530243039131165,
-0.8062570095062256,
0.08507301658391953,
-0.44428977370262146,
0.3703306019306183,
0.02384515106678009,
-0.419820636510849,
0.8526965975761414,
-0.23872201144695282,
-0.12185925990343094,
0.18700148165225983,
0.37372463941574097,
-0.1271274834871292,
0.40264084935188293,
0.6240755319595337,
0.6297808885574341,
0.2764692008495331,
0.10113131254911423,
1.1876364946365356,
-0.41972577571868896,
0.07733020186424255,
1.120497703552246,
-0.17087802290916443,
0.4925738275051117,
0.31574925780296326,
0.12250752747058868,
0.3834220767021179,
0.431169718503952,
-0.14230071008205414,
0.5039020776748657,
-0.29260513186454773,
-0.3268454670906067,
-0.5709186792373657,
-0.3704441785812378,
-0.4415626525878906,
0.5907297134399414,
-0.10110574215650558,
-0.30993685126304626,
-0.2848583459854126,
0.446601539850235,
-0.31280070543289185,
0.1143699660897255,
-0.10176916420459747,
0.7324753403663635,
-0.250274658203125,
-0.45564472675323486,
0.40324270725250244,
0.2691152095794678,
1.0642162561416626,
-0.639529824256897,
0.014200229197740555,
0.03821840137243271,
0.16638711094856262,
-0.07443409413099289,
-0.41748836636543274,
-0.17136621475219727,
-0.2749658524990082,
-0.5708974599838257,
-0.48384395241737366,
0.7944372296333313,
-0.4268825948238373,
-0.46679025888442993,
0.25692078471183777,
0.6080054044723511,
-0.3778335154056549,
-0.48550447821617126,
-0.7352492809295654,
-0.08203805983066559,
-0.03225235641002655,
-0.27926063537597656,
0.4777323305606842,
0.02901611663401127,
0.053846873342990875,
0.7190884947776794,
0.9476016759872437,
-0.27218541502952576,
-0.15149544179439545,
0.25094354152679443,
0.84294193983078,
-0.4738258719444275,
-0.5391000509262085,
-0.5788403749465942,
0.5824673771858215,
0.15205536782741547,
-0.6550384163856506,
0.6643230319023132,
0.5876709818840027,
0.9435938000679016,
-0.26966825127601624,
0.7460708022117615,
-0.16082046926021576,
0.0687326192855835,
-0.21269366145133972,
0.38224825263023376,
-1.0616881847381592,
0.3367014229297638,
-0.20838753879070282,
-1.159462332725525,
-0.28633585572242737,
0.25961944460868835,
0.08571410179138184,
0.42660465836524963,
0.4908994138240814,
0.4593753218650818,
-0.44648921489715576,
-0.12895138561725616,
0.5666542649269104,
-0.3091561496257782,
0.23506832122802734,
0.47996601462364197,
0.635063648223877,
-0.09241121262311935,
0.47079506516456604,
-0.34997040033340454,
-0.18687036633491516,
-0.3515574038028717,
-0.6338369846343994,
-0.7358769774436951,
-1.0746275186538696,
-0.09920753538608551,
0.034959979355335236,
0.06747111678123474,
1.158473014831543,
1.1198039054870605,
-0.623712420463562,
-0.3232227563858032,
-0.037033095955848694,
-0.2665124833583832,
-0.27069562673568726,
-0.16930173337459564,
0.08787029981613159,
-0.15877710282802582,
-0.8571180701255798,
0.6478679776191711,
0.7605604529380798,
0.0786464735865593,
-0.3379289507865906,
0.11213503777980804,
0.13716842234134674,
-0.11476808786392212,
0.7814309000968933,
0.2853497564792633,
-0.928014874458313,
-0.0843765065073967,
-0.036382537335157394,
0.02353321760892868,
0.17951034009456635,
1.298512578010559,
-0.6974173784255981,
0.7753381133079529,
0.36847713589668274,
0.470036119222641,
0.27598366141319275,
-0.01659904420375824,
0.7216430306434631,
-0.5986194610595703,
0.10120341181755066,
0.07791851460933685,
0.5073696374893188,
0.2910085618495941,
-0.2803358733654022,
0.28991496562957764,
0.34152984619140625,
-0.3750835061073303,
-0.600208044052124,
0.5390847325325012,
-1.310017466545105,
-0.5006798505783081,
1.1032346487045288,
-0.0224003829061985,
0.3099015951156616,
-0.3314579725265503,
-0.3586373031139374,
-0.09378358721733093,
-0.4873504340648651,
0.8652794361114502,
0.2516060173511505,
-0.04975106939673424,
0.04900510981678963,
-0.33134767413139343,
0.1887892186641693,
0.5086793899536133,
-0.7935532331466675,
0.08203037828207016,
0.7587546110153198,
0.35752686858177185,
0.11531984061002731,
0.5873984098434448,
0.1720084547996521,
0.35764819383621216,
-0.4690079092979431,
0.19407902657985687,
-0.3698377311229706,
-0.6452124714851379,
-0.28106436133384705,
0.5782186388969421,
-0.18809984624385834,
-0.006500041112303734
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15436v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15436v2
|
Using Contextual Information for Sentence-level Morpheme Segmentation
| 2024-03-15T20:12:32 | 2024-05-14T17:22:05 |
Prabin Bhandari, Abhishek Paudel
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent advancements in morpheme segmentation primarily emphasize word-level
segmentation, often neglecting the contextual relevance within the sentence. In
this study, we redefine the morpheme segmentation task as a
sequence-to-sequence problem, treating the entire sentence as input rather than
isolating individual words. Our findings reveal that the multilingual model
consistently exhibits superior performance compared to monolingual
counterparts. While our model did not surpass the performance of the current
state-of-the-art, it demonstrated comparable efficacy with high-resource
languages while revealing limitations in low-resource language scenarios.
|
[
-0.26077890396118164,
-0.863697350025177,
0.46746084094047546,
0.28981906175613403,
-0.4486231207847595,
-0.2650611400604248,
0.03208027780056,
-0.5481308102607727,
-0.0026170960627496243,
0.3567461669445038,
-0.7368807792663574,
-0.5089483261108398,
-0.7762745022773743,
0.43619537353515625,
-0.39787447452545166,
0.6721527576446533,
0.32348141074180603,
-0.07961498945951462,
-0.34127625823020935,
-0.26575037837028503,
-0.7106187343597412,
-0.7133527994155884,
-0.49425873160362244,
-0.1024966612458229,
0.6874593496322632,
0.36953815817832947,
0.6127747893333435,
0.8633043766021729,
0.5678881406784058,
0.27556708455085754,
-0.39777955412864685,
0.09928299486637115,
-0.17804720997810364,
0.6060924530029297,
-0.2082299143075943,
-0.47965964674949646,
-0.019581565633416176,
-0.24227099120616913,
0.7651881575584412,
1.004433512687683,
0.04096159338951111,
-0.0984669104218483,
-0.3273405432701111,
0.649618923664093,
-0.6907492876052856,
0.0585259310901165,
-0.6605183482170105,
0.2066241055727005,
-0.48089519143104553,
-0.2525547444820404,
-0.6070709824562073,
0.09870105981826782,
0.5020798444747925,
-0.35197776556015015,
-0.0687374472618103,
-0.08649386465549469,
0.764745831489563,
0.19511766731739044,
-0.564324676990509,
-0.2988784909248352,
-0.4473254978656769,
0.5033855438232422,
-0.5971761345863342,
0.40399354696273804,
0.08695217221975327,
-0.16258974373340607,
0.12760990858078003,
-0.5020912289619446,
-0.11915244907140732,
-0.07591612637042999,
-0.14789189398288727,
-0.16445431113243103,
-0.06428854167461395,
0.03677371144294739,
0.4571349322795868,
0.21792645752429962,
-0.4801805913448334,
0.05618976801633835,
-0.6231608986854553,
-0.16921517252922058,
0.32415109872817993,
0.08483796566724777,
0.7775615453720093,
-0.6321776509284973,
-0.3116806149482727,
0.04176343232393265,
-0.5874033570289612,
0.15745362639427185,
0.03316657617688179,
0.5748960971832275,
0.08293367922306061,
0.8426707983016968,
0.09520263224840164,
0.9164348244667053,
-0.035011760890483856,
-0.4068344831466675,
0.4162346124649048,
-0.3734915554523468,
-0.19324684143066406,
0.18445247411727905,
0.4932927191257477,
0.17528539896011353,
0.25984302163124084,
-0.13940143585205078,
-0.12881429493427277,
-0.1433226466178894,
0.19611160457134247,
-0.7646977305412292,
0.1825922280550003,
0.06836596876382828,
-0.20959950983524323,
0.20472152531147003,
0.14002108573913574,
-0.9495636820793152,
-0.06866993010044098,
-0.049448177218437195,
0.30662649869918823,
-0.6622346043586731,
0.11337369680404663,
-0.049102749675512314,
-0.2123134732246399,
0.05874346196651459,
0.08960817754268646,
-1.126510739326477,
-0.1328182965517044,
0.5758256912231445,
1.4190443754196167,
-0.39074012637138367,
-0.30949515104293823,
-0.6555025577545166,
0.07377713918685913,
-0.20146307349205017,
0.9057551622390747,
-0.8589601516723633,
-0.8181330561637878,
0.011670159175992012,
0.17086608707904816,
-0.6963955760002136,
-0.6254094839096069,
0.20036353170871735,
-0.5012199282646179,
0.35717111825942993,
0.029096582904458046,
-0.49748116731643677,
-0.22809381783008575,
0.1952299326658249,
-0.7202720046043396,
0.5160665512084961,
0.18494437634944916,
-0.643435001373291,
0.25985637307167053,
-1.0348199605941772,
-1.0208972692489624,
-0.029981449246406555,
-0.045998673886060715,
-0.015350164845585823,
0.23005859553813934,
0.41844192147254944,
0.20926831662654877,
0.0704372227191925,
0.08404647558927536,
0.03966895490884781,
-0.20060479640960693,
0.06330074369907379,
-0.5683955550193787,
0.5951383113861084,
0.1848093420267105,
-0.12837782502174377,
0.22008082270622253,
-0.6098697185516357,
-0.09479987621307373,
0.0709538459777832,
-0.4170549213886261,
-0.5810746550559998,
0.03478750213980675,
0.07219470292329788,
0.30511367321014404,
0.14720670878887177,
-0.4483623504638672,
0.2622837722301483,
-0.8155409097671509,
0.76591557264328,
0.3324100077152252,
-0.06387261301279068,
0.734271228313446,
-0.04803144559264183,
0.7056689858436584,
0.13512323796749115,
-0.17552390694618225,
-0.84642493724823,
-0.6239349246025085,
-0.5955939292907715,
-0.28868645429611206,
0.4066556394100189,
0.7403029799461365,
-0.564946174621582,
0.14638647437095642,
-0.2799866795539856,
-0.016729963943362236,
-0.32166242599487305,
-0.276531457901001,
0.28212231397628784,
0.6328449249267578,
0.3972988724708557,
-0.23989050090312958,
-0.5341202616691589,
-1.066525936126709,
0.01135010551661253,
0.05411476269364357,
0.23869411647319794,
0.23848369717597961,
0.42952582240104675,
-0.36398231983184814,
0.9623233079910278,
-0.5967310070991516,
-0.026255326345562935,
-0.5078995823860168,
0.3359204828739166,
0.08408753573894501,
0.5098316669464111,
0.5026301741600037,
-1.0626331567764282,
-0.33041301369667053,
-0.07612113654613495,
-0.4058621823787689,
-0.10668680816888809,
0.04968511313199997,
-0.18132653832435608,
0.1647406667470932,
0.6034519076347351,
-0.5208724141120911,
0.39027777314186096,
0.6527939438819885,
-0.47027134895324707,
0.2483067661523819,
-0.2253134846687317,
0.19794274866580963,
-1.2677967548370361,
0.23015935719013214,
0.013902410864830017,
-0.13951681554317474,
-0.9345413446426392,
0.08235927671194077,
-0.0022901934571564198,
-0.2522081732749939,
-0.6755557656288147,
0.5786135196685791,
-0.42238807678222656,
-0.287477046251297,
-0.13158276677131653,
0.14937089383602142,
0.009796054102480412,
0.29765093326568604,
0.15646377205848694,
1.0734785795211792,
0.36033105850219727,
-0.5607002377510071,
-0.018898647278547287,
0.44287869334220886,
-0.5553733110427856,
0.4366592764854431,
-0.594016432762146,
-0.0405598022043705,
-0.34592580795288086,
-0.09443604946136475,
-0.9923849701881409,
-0.4121330976486206,
0.20315758883953094,
-0.22104324400424957,
0.06283430755138397,
-0.14935551583766937,
-0.26304516196250916,
-0.049104273319244385,
0.10165233165025711,
0.9490506052970886,
0.3548101484775543,
-0.18968752026557922,
0.30529481172561646,
0.48784518241882324,
-0.32396554946899414,
-0.44441884756088257,
-0.7361233830451965,
0.06402959674596786,
-0.3995670676231384,
-0.9846943616867065,
0.7420471906661987,
0.16695788502693176,
-0.2387678623199463,
-0.4222666621208191,
-0.10894963145256042,
-0.4472062289714813,
0.02649467997252941,
0.11458586156368256,
0.15739351511001587,
-0.21849340200424194,
0.3550044000148773,
-0.023293964564800262,
-0.14401233196258545,
-0.16830989718437195,
-0.1114770844578743,
0.8569225668907166,
0.2592557966709137,
-0.3789162337779999,
-0.3866351842880249,
0.8085180521011353,
0.8142502307891846,
-0.42395976185798645,
0.5491111874580383,
0.3304715156555176,
-0.3914230465888977,
0.04634951427578926,
-0.25429943203926086,
0.0364672988653183,
-0.3890956938266754,
0.693152904510498,
-0.37391719222068787,
-0.9940763115882874,
0.23557698726654053,
0.12501566112041473,
0.08731289952993393,
0.5785346627235413,
0.24351024627685547,
0.01664191298186779,
1.1094012260437012,
0.5775734782218933,
-0.011143174953758717,
0.8015556931495667,
0.14233453571796417,
0.28908267617225647,
-1.0472283363342285,
-0.3096551299095154,
-0.4675893485546112,
-0.2216765284538269,
-0.34988492727279663,
-0.4460514783859253,
0.505181610584259,
0.12534260749816895,
0.16943396627902985,
0.3497771918773651,
-0.3722650706768036,
0.2537405788898468,
0.6346661448478699,
0.09568790346384048,
0.2204822301864624,
0.16926708817481995,
-0.157536581158638,
0.0025484799407422543,
-0.7044045925140381,
-0.43069517612457275,
0.5334107279777527,
0.0893922820687294,
0.34782302379608154,
-0.09117642045021057,
0.4570581316947937,
0.10835734754800797,
-0.07398834079504013,
-0.9869697690010071,
0.42061156034469604,
-0.4364337921142578,
-0.6282137632369995,
-0.5159425735473633,
-0.3534144163131714,
-1.3510578870773315,
0.7773506045341492,
0.19254495203495026,
-1.063741683959961,
0.15949413180351257,
-0.03699508309364319,
-0.6116480231285095,
0.055779047310352325,
-0.6069542765617371,
1.1261826753616333,
-0.164070725440979,
0.15132366120815277,
-0.05108678713440895,
-0.7009450793266296,
0.05103478953242302,
-0.01945834420621395,
0.5041701197624207,
-0.3617568612098694,
0.016738664358854294,
0.8730851411819458,
-0.46530893445014954,
0.5443626642227173,
0.03560212627053261,
-0.23513257503509521,
0.20272992551326752,
-0.19553329050540924,
0.07155609130859375,
-0.033117227256298065,
-0.08003335446119308,
0.17689473927021027,
0.214482381939888,
-0.2217559665441513,
-0.484725683927536,
0.2961125373840332,
-0.23194444179534912,
-0.8023987412452698,
-0.2164996713399887,
-0.7210209369659424,
-0.47011882066726685,
0.16592025756835938,
0.6345219612121582,
0.7317494750022888,
-0.08897276967763901,
0.297194242477417,
0.5143547654151917,
-0.21532022953033447,
0.7081612348556519,
-0.03903617337346077,
-0.17740999162197113,
-0.2874554693698883,
0.39360275864601135,
0.1517760157585144,
0.4018382728099823,
0.7398973703384399,
0.1692245900630951,
-0.32358938455581665,
-0.43906739354133606,
-0.5684452056884766,
0.12413450330495834,
-0.728853702545166,
0.1696207970380783,
-0.7553770542144775,
-0.20413047075271606,
-0.41164273023605347,
-0.08281076699495316,
-0.27798160910606384,
-0.34659549593925476,
-0.2615280747413635,
0.08346259593963623,
-0.16431182622909546,
0.4568095803260803,
0.1265106499195099,
0.31596529483795166,
-1.1663061380386353,
0.21934308111667633,
0.20177726447582245,
-0.18746550381183624,
-0.2154151052236557,
-0.6754934787750244,
-0.033764176070690155,
0.11280329525470734,
-0.10108138620853424,
-1.0998681783676147,
0.3880820572376251,
0.39344674348831177,
0.5354219675064087,
0.3777422308921814,
-0.31625497341156006,
0.9768750667572021,
-0.7307919859886169,
0.8852595090866089,
0.3186115324497223,
-1.0345770120620728,
0.912899911403656,
-0.14391641318798065,
1.065611720085144,
0.3604453504085541,
0.2174864113330841,
-0.9813979864120483,
-0.029388217255473137,
-0.005761595908552408,
-1.2437442541122437,
0.8095020055770874,
0.16154472529888153,
0.3863012194633484,
-0.4501396119594574,
0.31754785776138306,
0.13036899268627167,
0.19700729846954346,
-0.814449667930603,
-0.0663522332906723,
0.11100310832262039,
-0.18162685632705688,
0.0004183105193078518,
-0.48549315333366394,
0.05258310213685036,
-0.08737283945083618,
0.22163771092891693,
0.04940415173768997,
0.38501855731010437,
0.26420578360557556,
-0.5378655791282654,
0.15552343428134918,
0.6124840974807739,
0.9259851574897766,
0.8855207562446594,
0.1724291294813156,
0.09041377156972885,
0.008116742596030235,
-0.4040761888027191,
0.2742675840854645,
-0.023777130991220474,
-0.3904608488082886,
0.20898252725601196,
0.8795158863067627,
0.8317614793777466,
0.511213481426239,
-0.848838746547699,
0.5440747141838074,
0.3971700370311737,
-0.24477830529212952,
0.343174546957016,
-0.012469571083784103,
-0.006547218654304743,
0.3006170988082886,
0.26367202401161194,
0.14521650969982147,
0.09093015640974045,
-0.690778911113739,
0.25361889600753784,
0.37787845730781555,
-0.34467655420303345,
-0.2640879154205322,
0.2964015305042267,
0.3126523196697235,
-0.46361497044563293,
0.7807093858718872,
0.184406578540802,
-0.8193361163139343,
0.8239843249320984,
0.7841015458106995,
0.6694689393043518,
-0.40142765641212463,
0.23349100351333618,
0.42128846049308777,
0.013921466656029224,
-0.23774653673171997,
0.26859229803085327,
-0.09752905368804932,
-0.7240005135536194,
-0.46480926871299744,
-0.5196528434753418,
0.04575300216674805,
-0.10930892825126648,
-0.595836877822876,
-0.12637995183467865,
-0.11611640453338623,
-0.3234412968158722,
-0.043408870697021484,
-0.8903554081916809,
-0.37282904982566833,
0.35491931438446045,
0.2768341898918152,
0.7635140419006348,
-0.2681869566440582,
0.6909602880477905,
0.877647876739502,
-0.21864692866802216,
-0.35544678568840027,
0.1365399956703186,
-0.1975277066230774,
-0.8278127312660217,
0.8768554925918579,
0.7802048325538635,
-0.23261301219463348,
-0.20888996124267578,
-0.08497413992881775,
-1.1980743408203125,
0.8523157238960266,
0.3849542438983917,
-0.7241451144218445,
-0.6387200355529785,
0.13573431968688965,
0.29805925488471985,
-0.6025007963180542,
-0.14385835826396942,
0.2985798418521881,
0.4782528579235077,
0.35007745027542114,
-0.982173502445221,
-0.2475462704896927,
-0.1892259567975998,
0.3443625569343567,
0.3432965874671936,
-0.2440468966960907,
0.9122189283370972,
-0.23455843329429626,
-0.7343849539756775,
0.08137959241867065,
0.5942078232765198,
-0.2082120180130005,
0.17535428702831268,
0.7414628863334656,
0.2962379455566406,
0.7268679738044739,
-0.23500646650791168,
0.8091452717781067,
-0.4552033841609955,
0.18445813655853271,
1.0536655187606812,
-0.028467178344726562,
0.8845100998878479,
0.6358630657196045,
0.08280956745147705,
0.5156583189964294,
0.8110097050666809,
0.12670095264911652,
0.8491625785827637,
0.0855112299323082,
-0.1779053956270218,
-0.3043932020664215,
-0.09088925272226334,
-0.4029645323753357,
0.6829366087913513,
0.2664332389831543,
-0.5224228501319885,
-0.23628054559230804,
0.3809448182582855,
-0.03263154253363609,
-0.08518432825803757,
-0.5004560947418213,
0.6794731020927429,
-0.059140708297491074,
-0.9261210560798645,
0.3103724420070648,
0.25491863489151,
0.8200814127922058,
-0.6019114851951599,
0.11264746636152267,
-0.060057904571294785,
-0.2516862154006958,
-0.21168425679206848,
-0.43823307752609253,
0.6705271005630493,
-0.11002916097640991,
-0.18709340691566467,
-0.08203411847352982,
0.4196836054325104,
-0.5741897225379944,
-0.37830886244773865,
0.17779961228370667,
0.6314778327941895,
-0.11580779403448105,
-0.144026979804039,
-0.43363291025161743,
-0.06450677663087845,
-0.009027156978845596,
-0.0425817146897316,
0.1876925230026245,
0.33766433596611023,
0.120002880692482,
0.6757915616035461,
0.24772286415100098,
-0.20854483544826508,
0.09282343089580536,
0.15825702250003815,
0.3833836019039154,
-0.7856073975563049,
-0.7136583924293518,
-1.190376877784729,
0.5701730847358704,
-0.015536797232925892,
-0.6441958546638489,
0.4847400188446045,
0.42546311020851135,
0.8402121067047119,
-0.08964590728282928,
0.6875677108764648,
-0.01681089587509632,
0.11952554434537888,
-0.7191131114959717,
0.16109077632427216,
-0.7136411666870117,
0.02095702663064003,
-0.2704901695251465,
-0.7876089811325073,
-0.49299195408821106,
0.9287252426147461,
-0.47016602754592896,
0.11017167568206787,
1.0279980897903442,
0.47924482822418213,
0.06126406416296959,
-0.005894172005355358,
0.6166226267814636,
-0.2822040915489197,
0.006542126648128033,
0.4932654798030853,
0.8446950912475586,
-0.029666567221283913,
0.3543007969856262,
-0.16482335329055786,
-0.07707458734512329,
-0.19286677241325378,
-0.6260998249053955,
-0.7805633544921875,
-0.6818069815635681,
-0.1403535157442093,
0.0976400375366211,
0.17990654706954956,
1.0879045724868774,
0.9445579648017883,
-0.7284013628959656,
-0.24760115146636963,
-0.0006691404851153493,
0.1712919920682907,
-0.161778062582016,
-0.21279102563858032,
0.14105087518692017,
-0.672187089920044,
-0.939427375793457,
0.7076115012168884,
0.7831364274024963,
-0.055010877549648285,
-0.061071377247571945,
0.3188873827457428,
-0.4448206126689911,
0.09330093860626221,
0.9719387888908386,
-0.0027969020884484053,
-0.8660457730293274,
-0.21651816368103027,
0.018519073724746704,
-0.23494404554367065,
0.6932514905929565,
1.089478611946106,
-0.22661468386650085,
0.355928897857666,
0.40801382064819336,
0.6298778653144836,
0.2376881241798401,
0.31565937399864197,
0.7258153557777405,
-0.5546908974647522,
0.029778311029076576,
0.14541487395763397,
0.6790275573730469,
0.3142324984073639,
-0.36809611320495605,
0.38811472058296204,
0.3696652948856354,
-0.18690960109233856,
-0.4675081670284271,
0.5625556111335754,
-0.7779510021209717,
-0.6209556460380554,
1.3689637184143066,
-0.23254969716072083,
-0.1819288432598114,
-0.08379042148590088,
-0.4461311399936676,
0.06950488686561584,
-0.30274122953414917,
0.5344343185424805,
0.955841064453125,
-0.2063433825969696,
-0.2687284052371979,
-0.22022922337055206,
0.19010084867477417,
0.5079188346862793,
-0.9271209836006165,
-0.2250293642282486,
0.6733306050300598,
0.12671200931072235,
0.41978222131729126,
0.577562689781189,
-0.18029935657978058,
0.1562066525220871,
-0.09351081401109695,
-0.4133419394493103,
0.05169623717665672,
-0.4519987106323242,
-0.339301735162735,
0.8949280381202698,
-0.06235841289162636,
-0.2436312586069107
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10616v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10616v1
|
DiPaCo: Distributed Path Composition
| 2024-03-15T18:26:51 | 2024-03-15T18:26:51 |
Arthur Douillard, Qixuan Feng, Andrei A. Rusu, Adhiguna Kuncoro, Yani Donchev, Rachita Chhaparia, Ionel Gog, Marc'Aurelio Ranzato, Jiajun Shen, Arthur Szlam
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Progress in machine learning (ML) has been fueled by scaling neural network
models. This scaling has been enabled by ever more heroic feats of engineering,
necessary for accommodating ML approaches that require high bandwidth
communication between devices working in parallel. In this work, we propose a
co-designed modular architecture and training approach for ML models, dubbed
DIstributed PAth COmposition (DiPaCo). During training, DiPaCo distributes
computation by paths through a set of shared modules. Together with a Local-SGD
inspired optimization (DiLoCo) that keeps modules in sync with drastically
reduced communication, Our approach facilitates training across poorly
connected and heterogeneous workers, with a design that ensures robustness to
worker failures and preemptions. At inference time, only a single path needs to
be executed for each input, without the need for any model compression. We
consider this approach as a first prototype towards a new paradigm of
large-scale learning, one that is less synchronous and more modular. Our
experiments on the widely used C4 benchmark show that, for the same amount of
training steps but less wall-clock time, DiPaCo exceeds the performance of a 1
billion-parameter dense transformer language model by choosing one of 256
possible paths, each with a size of 150 million parameters.
|
[
-0.2772691249847412,
-0.6117948293685913,
0.08349853754043579,
0.5375650525093079,
0.03568962961435318,
0.04615316912531853,
-0.2598625719547272,
-0.5432482361793518,
0.29632338881492615,
0.2610354721546173,
-0.8683511018753052,
-0.29165545105934143,
-0.3135126233100891,
0.20404011011123657,
-0.17690934240818024,
0.891761064529419,
-0.21574604511260986,
0.16694505512714386,
-0.3402092754840851,
-0.23221617937088013,
-0.25226467847824097,
-0.18015876412391663,
-0.5731500387191772,
-0.3730180263519287,
0.7961061596870422,
0.2248116284608841,
0.6540036201477051,
0.7405600547790527,
0.4881924092769623,
0.31527817249298096,
-0.07839524745941162,
0.25849443674087524,
-0.388307124376297,
0.18179425597190857,
0.1395372450351715,
-0.70465087890625,
-0.8748984336853027,
-0.08910078555345535,
0.7894684672355652,
1.1507654190063477,
-0.09524066746234894,
-0.12002081423997879,
-0.07129239290952682,
0.6598731279373169,
-0.6815922260284424,
-0.08493335545063019,
-0.31683608889579773,
0.5764386057853699,
0.0878213495016098,
0.15929432213306427,
-0.5497087240219116,
-0.20045311748981476,
0.2997562885284424,
-0.8236411213874817,
0.19188250601291656,
-0.33404621481895447,
0.3209196627140045,
0.2794233560562134,
-0.38334164023399353,
-0.3159596920013428,
-0.7087188959121704,
0.733526885509491,
-0.3534156382083893,
0.09539079666137695,
0.015974322333931923,
0.5599490404129028,
0.06674391776323318,
-0.8457937240600586,
-0.1568429172039032,
-0.054859112948179245,
0.12183617800474167,
0.2017902135848999,
0.2529729902744293,
0.12885470688343048,
-0.0241237822920084,
0.3319472670555115,
-0.41191717982292175,
0.3373193144798279,
-0.37251490354537964,
-0.2235574871301651,
0.5882953405380249,
0.5325033068656921,
0.2351752370595932,
0.3530066907405853,
-0.4301922023296356,
0.13164584338665009,
-0.6998706459999084,
-0.10978680849075317,
0.4131559729576111,
0.4216320216655731,
-0.21303482353687286,
0.08701563626527786,
0.004087464418262243,
0.6979583501815796,
0.1222185492515564,
-0.11328988522291183,
0.10915235430002213,
-0.15408171713352203,
-0.134927898645401,
0.028218301013112068,
0.8167770504951477,
-0.0833907276391983,
-0.11678507179021835,
-0.31580671668052673,
-0.20511400699615479,
-0.23997661471366882,
0.5139415860176086,
-1.0035604238510132,
-0.2687118947505951,
0.19667042791843414,
-0.2183438390493393,
-0.33655932545661926,
-0.3152695894241333,
-0.5556613802909851,
-0.36292195320129395,
-0.5204894542694092,
0.4581502377986908,
-0.150682732462883,
-0.2143206149339676,
0.03636746108531952,
0.09834149479866028,
-0.12435277551412582,
0.5086660385131836,
-1.2082022428512573,
0.46278494596481323,
0.9463708996772766,
1.260988712310791,
-0.444765567779541,
-0.7614347338676453,
-0.24532872438430786,
0.10314120352268219,
-0.45941242575645447,
0.43941760063171387,
-0.45100003480911255,
-0.48699018359184265,
-0.064725860953331,
-0.28025585412979126,
-0.3352460265159607,
-0.545315682888031,
0.24090564250946045,
-0.5262372493743896,
0.2534421682357788,
-0.05281874164938927,
-0.6874299645423889,
0.008098481222987175,
0.36059799790382385,
-0.6805438995361328,
0.5854917168617249,
0.1589641273021698,
-1.141047716140747,
0.27225345373153687,
-0.8050695061683655,
-0.8237690925598145,
0.06912963092327118,
-0.20041325688362122,
-0.500056803226471,
-0.2301201969385147,
0.054121844470500946,
0.46391087770462036,
-0.1504727005958557,
0.31591272354125977,
-0.24821333587169647,
-0.7524768114089966,
-0.17976395785808563,
-0.46499666571617126,
1.2703989744186401,
0.03269762173295021,
-0.496921569108963,
0.21204422414302826,
-0.8462103009223938,
-0.3063566982746124,
-0.36725035309791565,
-0.8554138541221619,
-0.045149605721235275,
-0.08061116188764572,
-0.060486242175102234,
0.02201656810939312,
0.38767677545547485,
-0.5638306140899658,
0.5396744608879089,
-0.4671146273612976,
0.431532621383667,
1.1300042867660522,
-0.27604082226753235,
0.7795470356941223,
-0.3268706202507019,
0.5266759991645813,
-0.042706262320280075,
0.6520617008209229,
-0.014866800978779793,
-0.287373811006546,
-0.6194562315940857,
-0.8553577065467834,
-0.08604328334331512,
0.233955517411232,
-0.2171163558959961,
0.5410879850387573,
-0.4458932876586914,
-0.7832819819450378,
-0.3560005724430084,
-0.10292594879865646,
-0.1421634554862976,
0.39019662141799927,
0.3576374650001526,
-0.22131973505020142,
-0.6139394640922546,
-0.6268855929374695,
0.24556337296962738,
0.13636741042137146,
-0.21541574597358704,
0.6407443284988403,
0.22418175637722015,
-0.7060391306877136,
0.8897900581359863,
-0.5306630730628967,
-0.034486979246139526,
-0.1261698603630066,
0.10577604174613953,
0.4560835659503937,
0.44502681493759155,
0.3380168080329895,
-0.5447750687599182,
-0.8060657978057861,
0.16484951972961426,
-0.6377593278884888,
-0.008733914233744144,
-0.13289134204387665,
-0.21519862115383148,
-0.17477785050868988,
0.2278309315443039,
-0.6774940490722656,
-0.2707350552082062,
0.6915680170059204,
0.08151806890964508,
0.8322213292121887,
-0.4254578649997711,
-0.07491302490234375,
-1.3190271854400635,
0.05374537408351898,
-0.32197806239128113,
-0.12609614431858063,
-0.4416905641555786,
-0.17248748242855072,
-0.2345992624759674,
-0.1934170126914978,
-0.392930805683136,
0.036502230912446976,
-0.1923777312040329,
-0.20515738427639008,
-0.3185834586620331,
-0.28050515055656433,
0.032843902707099915,
0.6520858407020569,
-0.09405046701431274,
0.719843864440918,
1.2264008522033691,
-0.7399224042892456,
0.6568447351455688,
0.2246086597442627,
0.03212279453873634,
0.7044625282287598,
-0.8100100755691528,
0.18795496225357056,
0.06367135792970657,
0.6497024297714233,
-0.36733347177505493,
-0.17927968502044678,
-0.13871707022190094,
-0.10473155230283737,
0.234619602560997,
-0.11326541751623154,
-0.2499302625656128,
-0.2318742722272873,
-0.19116456806659698,
0.5321645140647888,
0.35757842659950256,
-0.6842918395996094,
0.7512802481651306,
0.3513968288898468,
0.5069435238838196,
-0.8039247989654541,
-0.5427258014678955,
-0.10389402508735657,
-0.17605268955230713,
-0.8103843927383423,
0.38645437359809875,
-0.3569784462451935,
0.14742031693458557,
-0.5483191013336182,
-0.1529609113931656,
-0.5194722414016724,
0.36567768454551697,
0.6539632081985474,
0.3191794455051422,
-0.1836729645729065,
-0.03885994106531143,
0.02947419509291649,
0.04116565361618996,
0.1645597219467163,
-0.5219647884368896,
0.48621028661727905,
0.04961414635181427,
-0.3920116722583771,
-0.6613953709602356,
0.36847713589668274,
0.9073852896690369,
0.10930071771144867,
0.9337287545204163,
0.764225423336029,
-0.07331003248691559,
-0.7457911372184753,
0.36350685358047485,
-0.2686574459075928,
-0.6094500422477722,
0.1504785716533661,
-0.3366353511810303,
-1.0406135320663452,
0.42795562744140625,
-0.3794598877429962,
0.2568071782588959,
0.12350065261125565,
0.6760661005973816,
-0.18642421066761017,
0.5296787619590759,
0.6954388618469238,
-0.2750988304615021,
0.5578719973564148,
-0.6110783219337463,
0.17277954518795013,
-0.5292431116104126,
-0.2907174229621887,
-0.2353033870458603,
-0.5231109261512756,
-0.7222135663032532,
-0.5895317792892456,
0.48155710101127625,
-0.16052410006523132,
-0.512183666229248,
0.6196571588516235,
-0.4654659330844879,
0.4418558180332184,
0.6696202754974365,
0.3471388816833496,
-0.036452971398830414,
-0.16423583030700684,
-0.40867477655410767,
0.33041059970855713,
-0.9147427082061768,
-0.1075175404548645,
1.015994668006897,
0.4747828245162964,
0.7121452689170837,
-0.234152689576149,
0.9074200391769409,
0.4020331799983978,
0.17821434140205383,
-0.7337823510169983,
0.6331673264503479,
-0.05861881375312805,
-0.6277554631233215,
-0.2132081240415573,
-0.6148889660835266,
-0.7851698994636536,
0.13771271705627441,
0.04741091653704643,
-0.4484269618988037,
0.14858901500701904,
0.11215659976005554,
-0.2519969940185547,
0.46064066886901855,
-0.3792073726654053,
0.6584569215774536,
0.13592369854450226,
-0.535283088684082,
-0.43743327260017395,
-0.7993282079696655,
0.1183740422129631,
-0.04434705898165703,
-0.14092206954956055,
0.17812511324882507,
0.11749891936779022,
0.6881988048553467,
-0.43342170119285583,
0.897164523601532,
-0.18321868777275085,
-0.04748283699154854,
0.29826292395591736,
0.06777919083833694,
0.4483366310596466,
0.022860055789351463,
-0.11731044948101044,
0.38062384724617004,
-0.3360385596752167,
-0.4723222255706787,
-0.3248528838157654,
0.6817266345024109,
-1.057863712310791,
-0.044568344950675964,
0.09454592317342758,
-0.7063778638839722,
-0.2558678686618805,
0.011674805544316769,
0.17530560493469238,
0.6688739061355591,
-0.2000025361776352,
0.1936570703983307,
0.5481271147727966,
-0.1289118379354477,
0.6451454162597656,
0.29759734869003296,
0.3641187846660614,
-0.5292515754699707,
0.6498677134513855,
-0.20683515071868896,
0.2632831633090973,
0.7353456020355225,
0.16858582198619843,
0.13884006440639496,
-0.3799424469470978,
-0.26723310351371765,
-0.07322042435407639,
-0.6509932279586792,
0.07235409319400787,
-0.6715630888938904,
-0.2786349952220917,
-0.09278149902820587,
-0.5487268567085266,
-0.9713841080665588,
-0.17888900637626648,
-0.5714935660362244,
-0.04983655735850334,
0.08803509175777435,
0.7382407188415527,
-0.3069866895675659,
0.38719701766967773,
-0.6375438570976257,
-0.1086534932255745,
0.4997991621494293,
0.3324028551578522,
0.17604859173297882,
-0.24750235676765442,
-0.7552696466445923,
0.016071364283561707,
-0.2774856984615326,
-0.3397044539451599,
-0.015878979116678238,
0.16510765254497528,
0.2932397723197937,
0.6804801821708679,
-0.15737174451351166,
0.4634053409099579,
-0.8080083727836609,
0.664912223815918,
0.46075010299682617,
-0.7507705092430115,
0.2438839077949524,
-0.4646192789077759,
0.05876478925347328,
0.5111767053604126,
0.7369949817657471,
-0.45627090334892273,
-0.11716943234205246,
-0.2397068738937378,
-0.6197853088378906,
0.5767541527748108,
-0.0032043915707618,
0.3214832842350006,
0.22366191446781158,
0.11877340823411942,
0.5120614767074585,
0.013964359648525715,
-0.6114113926887512,
-0.14044152200222015,
0.01466715894639492,
-0.3223734200000763,
0.272414892911911,
0.1704477071762085,
-0.28687697649002075,
-0.5685374736785889,
0.5003864765167236,
-0.15194755792617798,
0.28927814960479736,
0.07300378382205963,
0.023333728313446045,
-0.009295918047428131,
-0.18457730114459991,
0.38723260164260864,
0.8578912615776062,
-0.07435494661331177,
0.1693512201309204,
-0.13420918583869934,
-0.699079692363739,
0.31327691674232483,
-0.23130403459072113,
-0.11208117753267288,
-0.04122898355126381,
0.607250452041626,
0.9226863384246826,
-0.019376903772354126,
-0.4528418481349945,
0.5078742504119873,
0.002990255132317543,
-0.34195849299430847,
0.16681455075740814,
0.3307037949562073,
0.1133558377623558,
0.4353148937225342,
0.16250361502170563,
0.420654296875,
0.09660845994949341,
-0.2795051336288452,
0.40704503655433655,
0.1279880553483963,
-0.35691213607788086,
-0.7293335795402527,
0.45005977153778076,
0.45738092064857483,
-0.24259907007217407,
0.5492621064186096,
0.2481747418642044,
-0.6579656004905701,
0.5604255795478821,
0.3651076555252075,
0.8992342948913574,
-0.20487567782402039,
0.4912737309932709,
0.37130308151245117,
0.20386795699596405,
-0.10627167671918869,
-0.27480828762054443,
-0.571161687374115,
-0.46308454871177673,
-0.35145315527915955,
-0.8358296155929565,
-0.5534939169883728,
-0.4113663136959076,
-0.17439144849777222,
0.1433381587266922,
-0.5414459109306335,
0.04271138459444046,
-0.26601842045783997,
0.08268941938877106,
-0.41082292795181274,
0.24819138646125793,
0.07055705040693283,
0.7633713483810425,
-1.134002923965454,
0.7388874292373657,
0.5674216747283936,
-0.10136491805315018,
-0.8210058808326721,
-0.008635607548058033,
-0.5309918522834778,
-0.4106813073158264,
0.6656726002693176,
0.3526575267314911,
-0.024348469451069832,
-0.12561430037021637,
-0.3174276053905487,
-0.4382612109184265,
1.1964361667633057,
0.45761069655418396,
-0.5149078369140625,
-0.029292475432157516,
0.3866172432899475,
0.6648502349853516,
-0.3197517693042755,
0.2906387448310852,
0.17904649674892426,
0.0888797864317894,
0.280806303024292,
-1.0044301748275757,
-0.18379870057106018,
0.22001239657402039,
-0.2642865478992462,
-0.041654352098703384,
-0.6449111700057983,
1.28978431224823,
-0.05092565715312958,
-0.027619071304798126,
-0.3273774981498718,
0.30000174045562744,
0.015563671477138996,
0.20887941122055054,
0.3463430404663086,
0.63665771484375,
0.8153738379478455,
0.32662010192871094,
0.8871083855628967,
-0.16361816227436066,
0.4633925259113312,
1.115765929222107,
-0.14819449186325073,
0.5155361890792847,
0.30966246128082275,
-0.47532275319099426,
0.6379045844078064,
0.7691102027893066,
0.3341394066810608,
0.8177570700645447,
0.32876211404800415,
-0.7363260388374329,
-0.06908110529184341,
0.16120152175426483,
0.023078083992004395,
0.4190096855163574,
-0.20252400636672974,
-0.2824977934360504,
-0.11414389312267303,
0.17413389682769775,
-0.27416345477104187,
-0.17468909919261932,
-0.4786488711833954,
0.6283185482025146,
-0.06325999647378922,
-0.45458006858825684,
0.6729279160499573,
-0.25360631942749023,
0.6995982527732849,
-0.4681265950202942,
0.3174658715724945,
-0.660155713558197,
0.4097864627838135,
-0.216912642121315,
-0.289715975522995,
0.3977587819099426,
-0.3137913942337036,
-0.044738899916410446,
-0.20620045065879822,
0.35157260298728943,
-0.15863773226737976,
-0.1508117914199829,
0.24998946487903595,
0.13985104858875275,
-0.028552163392305374,
0.09629998356103897,
-0.5763442516326904,
0.0400177426636219,
-0.2997346520423889,
-0.20778489112854004,
0.16469047963619232,
0.4942813515663147,
0.3039582073688507,
0.8405091166496277,
0.3735004663467407,
0.05631304532289505,
0.34873679280281067,
0.03672841563820839,
1.024232268333435,
-0.21672934293746948,
-0.6248898506164551,
-0.8485613465309143,
0.41074439883232117,
-0.07913336902856827,
-0.04527417570352554,
0.5683392286300659,
0.5738138556480408,
0.5818161964416504,
-0.11843621730804443,
0.4069560468196869,
0.028773976489901543,
-0.19125494360923767,
-0.06869316846132278,
0.6037402749061584,
-0.4283333122730255,
0.15912120044231415,
0.08988073468208313,
-0.9703494310379028,
-0.15602584183216095,
0.5050925612449646,
0.05142848938703537,
-0.025463368743658066,
0.6698004007339478,
0.7241743206977844,
-0.3963938057422638,
0.024452347308397293,
0.20819243788719177,
0.07516083866357803,
0.3279039263725281,
0.780245304107666,
0.5741026997566223,
-0.20503288507461548,
0.2755938470363617,
-0.1520334631204605,
-0.17549753189086914,
-0.3408105969429016,
-0.5746771693229675,
-0.9931167960166931,
-0.4819110929965973,
-0.300192266702652,
-0.025080816820263863,
-0.03664283826947212,
0.6784862875938416,
1.1158283948898315,
-0.5354195833206177,
-0.4486348330974579,
-0.8827211260795593,
0.04438963904976845,
-0.2980170249938965,
-0.16744033992290497,
0.2677038609981537,
-0.26182180643081665,
-0.7634153366088867,
0.5840701460838318,
0.5546064376831055,
-0.15120115876197815,
-0.6853944063186646,
-0.34730663895606995,
-0.030544351786375046,
0.13941869139671326,
0.38998469710350037,
-0.17322547733783722,
-0.05764494836330414,
-0.030867096036672592,
0.00653385603800416,
-0.396925151348114,
0.3331146240234375,
0.9250504970550537,
-0.45199552178382874,
0.5987439751625061,
0.6384730935096741,
0.8577998280525208,
0.567150890827179,
-0.27315109968185425,
0.7535991072654724,
-1.0158573389053345,
0.30171582102775574,
0.49856290221214294,
0.2167883664369583,
0.3048928678035736,
-0.2866077125072479,
0.22613421082496643,
0.4575337767601013,
-0.7494654059410095,
-0.5844747424125671,
0.23062089085578918,
-0.9691426753997803,
-0.4043313264846802,
0.7892863750457764,
-0.5366644263267517,
-0.4513467252254486,
0.21267151832580566,
-0.005770614370703697,
0.37783434987068176,
0.08163926750421524,
0.9148411750793457,
0.25312376022338867,
-0.09664363414049149,
0.29986000061035156,
-0.12495628744363785,
0.266216903924942,
0.06493238359689713,
-0.8445814847946167,
0.17204754054546356,
0.6506096124649048,
0.26353657245635986,
0.17204149067401886,
0.5913342833518982,
0.3079184889793396,
0.05878744274377823,
0.4016943573951721,
-0.025678252801299095,
-0.10154829174280167,
-0.6925235390663147,
-0.08960442990064621,
0.32495927810668945,
-0.30670714378356934,
-0.4957214891910553
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10596v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10596v1
|
Neural Erosion: Emulating Controlled Neurodegeneration and Aging in AI Systems
| 2024-03-15T18:00:00 | 2024-03-15T18:00:00 |
Antonios Alexos, Yu-Dai Tsai, Ian Domingo, Maryam Pishgar, Pierre Baldi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, q-bio.NC
|
Creating controlled methods to simulate neurodegeneration in artificial
intelligence (AI) is crucial for applications that emulate brain function
decline and cognitive disorders. We use IQ tests performed by Large Language
Models (LLMs) and, more specifically, the LLaMA 2 to introduce the concept of
``neural erosion." This deliberate erosion involves ablating synapses or
neurons, or adding Gaussian noise during or after training, resulting in a
controlled progressive decline in the LLMs' performance. We are able to
describe the neurodegeneration in the IQ tests and show that the LLM first
loses its mathematical abilities and then its linguistic abilities, while
further losing its ability to understand the questions. To the best of our
knowledge, this is the first work that models neurodegeneration with text data,
compared to other works that operate in the computer vision domain. Finally, we
draw similarities between our study and cognitive decline clinical studies
involving test subjects. We find that with the application of neurodegenerative
methods, LLMs lose abstract thinking abilities, followed by mathematical
degradation, and ultimately, a loss in linguistic ability, responding to
prompts incoherently. These findings are in accordance with human studies.
|
[
-0.30069974064826965,
-1.333467960357666,
0.6297780871391296,
0.10996369272470474,
0.18735641241073608,
0.22398415207862854,
-0.2764442563056946,
-0.49276095628738403,
0.4049956500530243,
0.42323800921440125,
-0.6021834015846252,
-0.26662757992744446,
-0.409934401512146,
-0.1780124306678772,
-0.53998863697052,
0.8290541172027588,
-0.019001413136720657,
0.46278926730155945,
-0.6543220281600952,
0.1406530737876892,
-0.23689314723014832,
-0.3613468408584595,
-1.084366798400879,
-0.9149871468544006,
0.3537404537200928,
0.12421483546495438,
0.6753398776054382,
0.4967373311519623,
0.534101665019989,
0.34590259194374084,
-0.41012394428253174,
-0.26059114933013916,
-0.5167154669761658,
0.1271345019340515,
-0.031402915716171265,
-0.655252993106842,
-0.5119733214378357,
-0.21279457211494446,
0.47584524750709534,
0.8336689472198486,
-0.2472658008337021,
-0.13577544689178467,
-0.012899046763777733,
0.5757269263267517,
-0.5203418731689453,
-0.09667225182056427,
-0.4216974079608917,
0.2737545669078827,
0.0032472002785652876,
-0.2543365955352783,
-0.32764682173728943,
-0.39015865325927734,
0.17613179981708527,
-0.5075925588607788,
-0.05366751551628113,
-0.18229061365127563,
0.7085850834846497,
0.5439382791519165,
-0.09984113276004791,
-0.22255249321460724,
-0.7540519833564758,
0.6869944930076599,
-0.7534950375556946,
-0.058246172964572906,
0.8582741022109985,
0.19187258183956146,
-0.20534135401248932,
-0.6544046401977539,
-0.6803801655769348,
-0.7377526164054871,
0.38525253534317017,
0.1495686024427414,
-0.2019546777009964,
0.2878844738006592,
0.22865836322307587,
0.20009098947048187,
-0.47365468740463257,
0.5476929545402527,
-0.7625188231468201,
-0.2940466105937958,
0.5971001386642456,
0.43973276019096375,
0.7702468037605286,
0.11381518840789795,
-0.24262197315692902,
0.04863051325082779,
-0.8319567441940308,
-0.13685622811317444,
0.5267413854598999,
-0.2660808265209198,
-0.022390730679035187,
0.6657127737998962,
-0.08761661499738693,
0.3112887144088745,
-0.14792819321155548,
0.022729650139808655,
0.16461656987667084,
-0.12208916991949081,
-0.04141087457537651,
0.0666671171784401,
0.5419406294822693,
0.766026496887207,
0.505032479763031,
-0.3934198021888733,
-0.09616782516241074,
0.26231205463409424,
0.34437400102615356,
-0.5008604526519775,
-0.4519259035587311,
0.27383285760879517,
-0.625569224357605,
-0.25827154517173767,
-0.7339470386505127,
-0.7825390100479126,
-0.6461610794067383,
-0.2339015007019043,
0.574388325214386,
-0.881949782371521,
-0.16193078458309174,
-0.019713955000042915,
-0.530516505241394,
0.16953960061073303,
0.188522607088089,
-0.8444363474845886,
0.5950208902359009,
0.45862820744514465,
0.6154427528381348,
-0.2636783719062805,
-0.4315204322338104,
0.07580707222223282,
-0.270504355430603,
-0.3729490339756012,
0.8446149826049805,
-0.44325122237205505,
-0.11994960159063339,
-0.12472949922084808,
-0.4069875180721283,
0.010249649174511433,
-0.7285075783729553,
0.2687945067882538,
-0.6137402057647705,
0.008354690857231617,
0.3399614095687866,
-0.3513084650039673,
-0.45045047998428345,
0.06676795333623886,
-0.6140689849853516,
0.6519033908843994,
0.06812180578708649,
-0.3368847370147705,
0.21448542177677155,
-0.7551316618919373,
-0.3753058612346649,
-0.07421543449163437,
-0.09632609784603119,
-0.3058692514896393,
0.31058886647224426,
-0.13891683518886566,
0.029071785509586334,
-0.307117223739624,
0.14124730229377747,
-0.6169589757919312,
-0.2808228135108948,
0.08769766241312027,
-0.44306668639183044,
0.980811595916748,
-0.06280697882175446,
-0.4984545409679413,
-0.06706622987985611,
-0.524465799331665,
0.2946191430091858,
0.2903933525085449,
-0.25118035078048706,
-0.5528662204742432,
0.677460789680481,
-0.1805572509765625,
-0.05954965204000473,
0.18238165974617004,
-0.555145800113678,
0.1294579803943634,
-0.6375502943992615,
0.7353025674819946,
0.7451564073562622,
0.20788589119911194,
0.4666229784488678,
-0.5568851232528687,
0.538604736328125,
0.018408002331852913,
0.2546062469482422,
0.06679769605398178,
-0.34726399183273315,
-0.9799439907073975,
0.33394137024879456,
0.3247480094432831,
0.8097040057182312,
-0.8208413124084473,
0.1417258381843567,
-0.33098506927490234,
-0.4465317130088806,
-0.2353058159351349,
-0.04615972191095352,
0.1846802681684494,
0.3300896883010864,
0.46964114904403687,
-0.4143340587615967,
-0.2275829315185547,
-1.2199187278747559,
0.16099324822425842,
-0.2619723975658417,
-0.13255272805690765,
-0.016053538769483566,
0.422286719083786,
-0.27584901452064514,
0.4956202805042267,
-0.23746976256370544,
-0.10536296665668488,
0.1458648294210434,
0.23031456768512726,
-0.487090140581131,
0.7280054688453674,
0.4029013216495514,
-0.42163950204849243,
0.4043046236038208,
-0.19624391198158264,
-0.6389001607894897,
0.09451787918806076,
-0.1852647215127945,
-0.13000401854515076,
0.24216356873512268,
0.6290019750595093,
-0.602343738079071,
0.7723528742790222,
0.5473591685295105,
-0.35673198103904724,
0.5409662127494812,
-0.2281271517276764,
-0.07182679325342178,
-0.4776594340801239,
-0.07867128401994705,
-0.06776731461286545,
0.2064439207315445,
-0.5544660091400146,
-0.22471965849399567,
-0.2951164245605469,
-0.0698481872677803,
-0.1774754524230957,
0.24921920895576477,
-0.18044555187225342,
0.1292019933462143,
-0.41680970788002014,
0.15838122367858887,
-0.03399044647812843,
0.28510424494743347,
-0.33774298429489136,
0.5731748342514038,
0.6127225756645203,
-0.780613899230957,
0.22290639579296112,
0.13511286675930023,
-0.16549983620643616,
0.4223169982433319,
-0.8576235175132751,
0.13677750527858734,
-0.4075743556022644,
-0.06362855434417725,
-0.8595589399337769,
0.030869634822010994,
0.15914729237556458,
-0.5788499116897583,
0.25194817781448364,
0.5135806202888489,
-0.29512542486190796,
-0.22845491766929626,
-0.42966631054878235,
0.29621902108192444,
0.6765770316123962,
-0.17004670202732086,
0.7771293520927429,
0.630132257938385,
-0.504894495010376,
-0.25305598974227905,
-1.3073009252548218,
0.44044333696365356,
-0.13344261050224304,
-0.6100296974182129,
0.7440406084060669,
-0.3146837651729584,
-0.7188222408294678,
0.15772004425525665,
0.27189138531684875,
-0.3288877010345459,
0.31649768352508545,
0.24808064103126526,
-0.13474920392036438,
-0.2531169056892395,
0.3487364947795868,
0.3427450656890869,
0.10009976476430893,
0.4316496253013611,
0.21725349128246307,
0.855934202671051,
0.28901609778404236,
-0.27957892417907715,
-0.8232656717300415,
0.5279298424720764,
0.8502407073974609,
-0.14156442880630493,
0.40689292550086975,
-0.08279344439506531,
-0.538135826587677,
-0.3887171745300293,
-0.3733629286289215,
-0.43226155638694763,
-0.45194852352142334,
0.5139504671096802,
-0.18901237845420837,
-0.3994617462158203,
0.7091168165206909,
-0.27969613671302795,
-0.09705580025911331,
0.6890296936035156,
0.5509451031684875,
-0.21573178470134735,
1.3550711870193481,
0.9498835206031799,
-0.12277714163064957,
0.42397287487983704,
-0.3950514793395996,
-0.1920926868915558,
-0.7664327621459961,
-0.3230360150337219,
-0.34410449862480164,
-0.6457827687263489,
-0.43412742018699646,
-0.203205868601799,
-0.0007602858240716159,
-0.014113642275333405,
-0.45543748140335083,
-0.20517127215862274,
-0.5251172780990601,
0.5223899483680725,
0.6879491806030273,
0.5908069610595703,
0.044609181582927704,
0.09009135514497757,
-0.03142882511019707,
-0.032468751072883606,
-0.8018541932106018,
-0.5465179681777954,
0.8858338594436646,
0.4706844687461853,
1.0129115581512451,
-0.30831244587898254,
0.542372465133667,
0.5746265053749084,
0.5512528419494629,
-0.8081619739532471,
0.4960699677467346,
-0.06656514108181,
-0.5110489130020142,
-0.19004420936107635,
-0.3842320144176483,
-0.8542020320892334,
-0.5997328758239746,
-0.08240649849176407,
-0.6977536082267761,
0.31884709000587463,
0.14459538459777832,
-0.48636600375175476,
0.34310874342918396,
-0.725295901298523,
0.4214265048503876,
-0.5629013180732727,
-0.17715588212013245,
-0.6934354305267334,
-0.6654072403907776,
0.5754989981651306,
-0.013963592238724232,
-0.17326414585113525,
-0.034898582845926285,
-0.2934225797653198,
0.8178476095199585,
-0.3154878318309784,
1.0704374313354492,
-0.292296826839447,
0.1328492909669876,
0.48825275897979736,
0.23881085216999054,
-0.004352149553596973,
-0.16172382235527039,
-0.24384468793869019,
0.25450003147125244,
-0.1438896507024765,
-0.35280174016952515,
-0.6193896532058716,
0.8843523263931274,
-0.9264881610870361,
-0.4675601124763489,
-0.5408341288566589,
-0.5768678188323975,
0.040116891264915466,
0.053149621933698654,
0.05058297887444496,
0.3365863859653473,
-0.26071152091026306,
-0.170749232172966,
0.5052958130836487,
-0.4828376770019531,
0.577307939529419,
0.09295953810214996,
-0.10671624541282654,
-0.8372276425361633,
0.816993772983551,
0.2837302088737488,
0.4159511625766754,
-0.2042391449213028,
0.0520295575261116,
-0.003448633011430502,
-0.9685137867927551,
-0.2335750162601471,
0.13628749549388885,
-0.6587804555892944,
-0.19321981072425842,
-0.15392522513866425,
-0.156088724732399,
-0.08803640305995941,
-0.009870543144643307,
0.05877496674656868,
-0.6546348929405212,
-0.2764028310775757,
-0.11048606038093567,
0.56716388463974,
0.968121349811554,
-0.09326811134815216,
0.5219537019729614,
-0.2610628306865692,
0.2988322377204895,
0.08228448033332825,
0.374836802482605,
0.022568918764591217,
-0.2814693748950958,
0.07215648144483566,
0.34577611088752747,
-0.4314832091331482,
-0.9455118775367737,
0.31223776936531067,
0.5039108991622925,
0.5010722875595093,
0.4203551113605499,
-0.1411397010087967,
0.5762100219726562,
-0.5031697154045105,
0.8019640445709229,
0.10076474398374557,
-0.7637853026390076,
0.4571266174316406,
-0.13321685791015625,
0.3163231611251831,
0.8217337131500244,
0.4495929479598999,
-0.425808310508728,
-0.3566049635410309,
-0.7283589839935303,
-1.0700078010559082,
0.381100594997406,
-0.17229802906513214,
0.3926856219768524,
-0.15009620785713196,
0.6323657631874084,
-0.13846425712108612,
-0.2521895170211792,
-0.5005369186401367,
-0.24947255849838257,
0.09528917074203491,
-0.1535746455192566,
-0.07245093584060669,
-0.3425319194793701,
-0.26103436946868896,
-0.2738226056098938,
0.5303158760070801,
-0.02286837249994278,
0.5131758451461792,
0.483136922121048,
-0.2312467396259308,
-0.15591467916965485,
-0.43524909019470215,
0.9511663317680359,
0.6565762162208557,
0.026980405673384666,
0.11102442443370819,
0.4290608763694763,
-0.521814227104187,
0.15989819169044495,
0.022368473932147026,
-0.6084536910057068,
-0.2835228741168976,
0.24593877792358398,
0.5176308751106262,
-0.0401325449347496,
-0.9540770649909973,
0.16005194187164307,
-0.14138613641262054,
-0.308948278427124,
-0.7101605534553528,
0.14533287286758423,
0.2139274626970291,
0.1799219846725464,
0.3553065061569214,
0.5254820585250854,
0.127751886844635,
-0.5257766842842102,
0.6406769156455994,
0.30067479610443115,
-0.5741633176803589,
-0.19216345250606537,
0.7039336562156677,
0.09782176464796066,
-0.6899381279945374,
1.1061538457870483,
-0.01800346001982689,
-0.5168245434761047,
1.1218788623809814,
0.5915371179580688,
0.8906438946723938,
-0.1343097686767578,
0.035646554082632065,
0.04426279291510582,
0.5811519026756287,
0.11125830560922623,
0.4131987690925598,
0.10299906134605408,
-0.5289289951324463,
-0.8112680912017822,
-0.4236016273498535,
-0.3475744426250458,
0.11324838548898697,
-0.5106102228164673,
0.03034551441669464,
-0.9093717336654663,
-0.4849097430706024,
0.1433795541524887,
-0.3937981426715851,
-0.3549852967262268,
0.1630965918302536,
0.5067288875579834,
1.1595181226730347,
-0.723531186580658,
0.425994336605072,
0.5584917664527893,
-0.5685123801231384,
-0.12274659425020218,
0.13170459866523743,
-0.0845549926161766,
-0.7864468693733215,
0.9539850354194641,
0.10455349832773209,
-0.12896376848220825,
0.15401072800159454,
-0.7997203469276428,
-0.7925509810447693,
0.9572671055793762,
0.49562862515449524,
0.039643384516239166,
-0.017093125730752945,
-0.07290297746658325,
0.6584874391555786,
-0.11325383931398392,
0.4454255700111389,
0.6926845908164978,
0.5408279299736023,
-0.418268084526062,
-0.747441828250885,
-0.13960763812065125,
-0.3965705633163452,
-0.052078407257795334,
0.08195021748542786,
-0.8357511162757874,
0.6922674179077148,
-0.46177148818969727,
-0.25715816020965576,
0.3161923289299011,
0.762126624584198,
0.11404582113027573,
0.5105311274528503,
0.3614923655986786,
0.8854291439056396,
0.5622800588607788,
-0.19452039897441864,
1.176810383796692,
-0.43951544165611267,
-0.14690425992012024,
0.6402723789215088,
-0.03445035591721535,
0.9441328048706055,
0.4894677996635437,
0.11813138425350189,
0.6009706854820251,
0.5975423455238342,
0.07154127955436707,
0.4037204384803772,
0.8172820210456848,
-0.3232710063457489,
0.17647942900657654,
-0.24326738715171814,
-0.05099128186702728,
0.6517398953437805,
0.5865526795387268,
-0.4694168269634247,
-0.22533158957958221,
0.33047962188720703,
0.1757434755563736,
0.2573772966861725,
-0.36319980025291443,
0.6115685105323792,
0.09181143343448639,
-0.5003133416175842,
0.7015954256057739,
-0.05132361873984337,
0.7609090209007263,
-0.576837420463562,
-0.1564617156982422,
-0.30102816224098206,
0.31604450941085815,
0.090410977602005,
-0.5019996762275696,
0.5810924768447876,
-0.3374456763267517,
-0.24414503574371338,
-0.1068815216422081,
0.5198154449462891,
-0.31929072737693787,
-0.4992516338825226,
0.6024765968322754,
0.4105003774166107,
0.3780306875705719,
0.10577176511287689,
-0.848135232925415,
0.16124969720840454,
-0.15116183459758759,
-0.5042877793312073,
0.08630702644586563,
0.1285228431224823,
-0.14937663078308105,
1.0802679061889648,
0.33889591693878174,
0.2312256097793579,
0.2638273239135742,
0.03205212950706482,
0.8901126384735107,
-0.7688411474227905,
0.20741808414459229,
-1.0316641330718994,
0.2524908483028412,
-0.2085098922252655,
-0.6117733716964722,
0.40745413303375244,
0.5517663955688477,
0.5050050020217896,
0.11483336240053177,
0.7017029523849487,
-0.23312383890151978,
-0.019858641549944878,
-0.5313090085983276,
1.0938818454742432,
-0.6474770903587341,
-0.25968700647354126,
0.13409943878650665,
-0.6237049698829651,
-0.639303982257843,
0.42069244384765625,
-0.40498992800712585,
0.3795943558216095,
0.7859268188476562,
0.9104036688804626,
0.34582340717315674,
-0.31931430101394653,
0.18453280627727509,
0.4016394019126892,
0.1792842447757721,
0.6356481909751892,
1.044606328010559,
-0.381390780210495,
0.4240974187850952,
-0.5496878027915955,
-0.3320148289203644,
-0.007185155525803566,
-0.5458952188491821,
-0.5256972312927246,
-0.2791019678115845,
-0.5625159740447998,
-0.3020629584789276,
0.39841577410697937,
0.4950476288795471,
0.44539588689804077,
-0.5329084396362305,
-0.11753188073635101,
-0.19035841524600983,
-0.01182748842984438,
-0.3858218789100647,
-0.23286616802215576,
0.4328908920288086,
-0.32842710614204407,
-0.7259925007820129,
0.4508819282054901,
0.274155855178833,
0.27488431334495544,
-0.6023958325386047,
0.1723000854253769,
-0.13445739448070526,
-0.1457320749759674,
0.5146024823188782,
0.33416470885276794,
-0.6429740190505981,
-0.2673357129096985,
0.13379837572574615,
-0.05216458812355995,
-0.12672486901283264,
0.41064250469207764,
-0.911594808101654,
0.3539479970932007,
0.8501425385475159,
0.678824782371521,
0.10458377003669739,
0.10968713462352753,
0.8221224546432495,
0.053322918713092804,
-0.03366835042834282,
0.759274959564209,
0.07020926475524902,
0.28321412205696106,
-0.372362345457077,
0.16768909990787506,
0.09269237518310547,
-0.8440995812416077,
-0.6492190957069397,
0.023159123957157135,
-0.782444179058075,
-0.20287220180034637,
0.7076074481010437,
0.29939326643943787,
-0.7168355584144592,
-0.05072656273841858,
-0.2007264792919159,
0.19019143283367157,
-0.16853010654449463,
1.061145305633545,
0.6605459451675415,
-0.395203173160553,
-0.27284005284309387,
-0.9154456853866577,
0.46584299206733704,
0.8300784826278687,
-0.8489370942115784,
0.11318916827440262,
0.6827482581138611,
0.10493282973766327,
0.3556951582431793,
0.40830832719802856,
-0.21543243527412415,
0.42685961723327637,
0.36979833245277405,
0.6306852102279663,
0.09650114178657532,
-0.26748743653297424,
-0.7198275327682495,
0.1328260898590088,
0.2617819309234619,
0.029681431129574776
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10517v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10517v1
|
VideoAgent: Long-form Video Understanding with Large Language Model as Agent
| 2024-03-15T17:57:52 | 2024-03-15T17:57:52 |
Xiaohan Wang, Yuhui Zhang, Orr Zohar, Serena Yeung-Levy
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Long-form video understanding represents a significant challenge within
computer vision, demanding a model capable of reasoning over long multi-modal
sequences. Motivated by the human cognitive process for long-form video
understanding, we emphasize interactive reasoning and planning over the ability
to process lengthy visual inputs. We introduce a novel agent-based system,
VideoAgent, that employs a large language model as a central agent to
iteratively identify and compile crucial information to answer a question, with
vision-language foundation models serving as tools to translate and retrieve
visual information. Evaluated on the challenging EgoSchema and NExT-QA
benchmarks, VideoAgent achieves 54.1% and 71.3% zero-shot accuracy with only
8.4 and 8.2 frames used on average. These results demonstrate superior
effectiveness and efficiency of our method over the current state-of-the-art
methods, highlighting the potential of agent-based approaches in advancing
long-form video understanding.
|
[
-0.3032226264476776,
-0.9926442503929138,
0.8767768740653992,
0.09141508489847183,
-0.25120455026626587,
0.12957698106765747,
-0.4312361478805542,
-0.4963914752006531,
0.10483972728252411,
0.5111293196678162,
-0.5202732682228088,
-0.38593780994415283,
-0.6722428798675537,
-0.19285589456558228,
-0.44481566548347473,
0.40238863229751587,
-0.3295396864414215,
0.05364103987812996,
-0.12831425666809082,
-0.2505284547805786,
-0.5208203196525574,
-0.27582651376724243,
-0.7053149938583374,
-0.3982555568218231,
0.2621973752975464,
0.4200923442840576,
1.0180648565292358,
0.5006759166717529,
0.5682334303855896,
0.4728441834449768,
0.24958087503910065,
0.11234108358621597,
-0.25659653544425964,
0.10865617543458939,
-0.33480557799339294,
-0.33991339802742004,
-0.47576671838760376,
-0.36508649587631226,
0.680815577507019,
0.4188707172870636,
-0.10012414306402206,
0.416887104511261,
-0.5021805167198181,
0.5155792832374573,
-0.8289242386817932,
0.46358925104141235,
-0.3238903880119324,
0.09397580474615097,
0.121623694896698,
-0.260128915309906,
-0.48521581292152405,
0.12600404024124146,
0.2260395735502243,
-0.6651219129562378,
0.16801846027374268,
-0.5046465992927551,
0.565741240978241,
0.49125102162361145,
-0.4402361512184143,
0.10559173673391342,
-0.9970781803131104,
0.38670119643211365,
-0.1510309875011444,
0.631174623966217,
0.5915293097496033,
0.9734337329864502,
0.01783796027302742,
-0.5270178318023682,
-0.7666670083999634,
-0.30129319429397583,
0.47758182883262634,
0.06722923368215561,
-0.2749664783477783,
0.3023684620857239,
0.20631574094295502,
-0.12806937098503113,
-0.8172004222869873,
0.05349494889378548,
-0.23901115357875824,
-0.1633567214012146,
0.6267929673194885,
0.0031638657674193382,
0.3192555904388428,
-0.09449964761734009,
-0.25513139367103577,
-0.2040647715330124,
0.01733015477657318,
0.18419915437698364,
-0.07567574828863144,
-0.1881662756204605,
0.13516612350940704,
0.6306126713752747,
-0.4148643910884857,
0.736613929271698,
-0.16677241027355194,
-0.19163331389427185,
0.08858555555343628,
0.1673922836780548,
-0.6726048588752747,
-0.013569566421210766,
0.485896497964859,
0.5494697690010071,
0.39552775025367737,
-0.02430003508925438,
-0.21488624811172485,
0.2941291928291321,
0.07936051487922668,
-0.7960965037345886,
-0.07846911251544952,
0.2363109588623047,
-0.21023619174957275,
0.04915837571024895,
0.18084804713726044,
-0.5607088208198547,
-0.38965141773223877,
-0.41812774538993835,
0.7706242203712463,
-0.3665581941604614,
-0.26147639751434326,
0.334819495677948,
-0.17058494687080383,
0.7793190479278564,
0.9047779440879822,
-0.37709829211235046,
0.2705170214176178,
0.4711920917034149,
0.6334322690963745,
-0.08485545963048935,
-0.6654939651489258,
-0.9216554760932922,
0.31871265172958374,
-0.5096089243888855,
0.8356436491012573,
-0.3854856789112091,
0.09111838787794113,
0.08742422610521317,
0.28807333111763,
0.26330891251564026,
-0.4081187844276428,
-0.09326648712158203,
-0.728410542011261,
-0.10636863857507706,
0.11590036004781723,
-0.2832469046115875,
-0.37818166613578796,
0.525507926940918,
-0.827763557434082,
0.6203742623329163,
-0.08177268505096436,
0.12173417210578918,
0.41446322202682495,
-0.4896327555179596,
-0.08613882213830948,
0.3205586075782776,
-0.3679055869579315,
-0.10197865217924118,
-0.17952634394168854,
0.19912289083003998,
0.36961156129837036,
-0.3014765977859497,
0.45177939534187317,
-0.13908080756664276,
-0.24342015385627747,
0.372746080160141,
-0.8017438054084778,
0.19300279021263123,
0.02537134476006031,
-0.4626571834087372,
0.15492160618305206,
-0.7236502170562744,
-0.113310806453228,
0.08319684118032455,
0.15510116517543793,
0.1539192497730255,
-0.10138074308633804,
0.015159793198108673,
0.2502656877040863,
0.21208502352237701,
-0.38678935170173645,
0.2004159688949585,
0.10042601078748703,
0.3504328429698944,
0.8695397973060608,
-0.262859582901001,
0.5020319819450378,
0.1123470887541771,
0.7721676230430603,
-0.2500648498535156,
0.4473341405391693,
-0.3298257291316986,
-0.1807313710451126,
-0.5329442024230957,
-0.19595780968666077,
-0.3485584855079651,
0.44399020075798035,
-1.0536978244781494,
-0.169433131814003,
-0.3731517791748047,
-0.32626041769981384,
-0.051874011754989624,
0.25324034690856934,
0.2911036014556885,
0.16983215510845184,
0.32044708728790283,
-0.36032727360725403,
-0.14325886964797974,
-0.7060254812240601,
0.2897603511810303,
-0.44958698749542236,
0.08733316510915756,
0.1618121713399887,
0.6357465982437134,
-0.277098685503006,
0.9161586165428162,
-0.7581624388694763,
-0.2852289378643036,
-0.36117109656333923,
0.158767968416214,
0.13517537713050842,
-0.02356133423745632,
0.5411268472671509,
-1.0116426944732666,
-0.33548879623413086,
0.23647864162921906,
-1.009809136390686,
0.2413649708032608,
-0.2546216547489166,
-0.049742620438337326,
0.23877142369747162,
0.6720700263977051,
-0.9012406468391418,
0.7184406518936157,
0.3441610634326935,
-0.4085424542427063,
0.5024312734603882,
-0.40019500255584717,
0.3639377951622009,
-0.7754569053649902,
-0.03263914957642555,
-0.022693177685141563,
-0.6222641468048096,
-0.4561331272125244,
0.3453770875930786,
-0.21149851381778717,
-0.48362812399864197,
-0.7105296850204468,
0.46207132935523987,
-0.5224170088768005,
-0.3276640772819519,
-0.5872282385826111,
0.24243690073490143,
0.01658540405333042,
0.5739779472351074,
0.308406800031662,
0.6786344051361084,
0.6427014470100403,
-0.3946618139743805,
1.1713838577270508,
0.1296526938676834,
-0.26216694712638855,
0.7186465263366699,
-0.5274384617805481,
0.0564836785197258,
-0.6179701685905457,
0.3814811408519745,
-0.6953434348106384,
-0.7041568160057068,
0.09642374515533447,
-0.5697828531265259,
0.10932408273220062,
-0.3312305212020874,
-0.2654576003551483,
-0.417272686958313,
0.003115752013400197,
0.7531471848487854,
0.3482966125011444,
-0.4930567443370819,
0.871997594833374,
0.167034313082695,
-0.10734440386295319,
-0.7587557435035706,
-0.43037286400794983,
0.4700486958026886,
0.017859503626823425,
-0.942057728767395,
0.024524016305804253,
-0.08650446683168411,
-0.39823511242866516,
-0.05475722998380661,
-0.12289606034755707,
-0.5331225395202637,
-0.2668429911136627,
0.1920536905527115,
0.09444238245487213,
-0.1620018631219864,
0.45748457312583923,
-0.524533212184906,
-0.056272007524967194,
0.20616398751735687,
-0.17912524938583374,
0.40129294991493225,
-0.24726441502571106,
-0.4993879199028015,
-0.47130829095840454,
0.7634422183036804,
1.0204346179962158,
-0.49327924847602844,
0.3547394573688507,
0.47776371240615845,
-0.5022222995758057,
-0.3264731764793396,
-0.6619259119033813,
-0.009242106229066849,
-0.44291412830352783,
0.9028847813606262,
-0.47465184330940247,
-0.5264779925346375,
0.6606780886650085,
0.0774337649345398,
-0.36938026547431946,
0.16784018278121948,
0.500390887260437,
-0.030398467555642128,
1.071277141571045,
0.8451736569404602,
0.03898919001221657,
0.6807777881622314,
-0.48849835991859436,
-0.25041472911834717,
0.052538853138685226,
-0.43436187505722046,
-0.03136638551950455,
0.018827104941010475,
-0.09664732217788696,
-0.7892101407051086,
0.5151659250259399,
-0.3080408573150635,
-0.3165682256221771,
0.3165662884712219,
-0.09783151000738144,
0.7620004415512085,
0.13523492217063904,
0.3884815275669098,
0.3691224753856659,
-0.18417732417583466,
0.5289633870124817,
0.40085312724113464,
-0.3269556760787964,
-0.33898088335990906,
0.5770536661148071,
0.5201766490936279,
1.0298446416854858,
0.4825800657272339,
0.16280095279216766,
0.46352091431617737,
-0.22700059413909912,
-1.2026211023330688,
0.8128321766853333,
0.08253918588161469,
-0.44466596841812134,
-0.6081418991088867,
0.0033406217116862535,
-0.826251745223999,
0.02895190753042698,
0.07330523431301117,
-0.7601962089538574,
0.005591879598796368,
0.026019245386123657,
-0.19392023980617523,
0.20807014405727386,
-0.6411771774291992,
1.071000337600708,
-0.3846602141857147,
-0.5551134347915649,
-0.5060268640518188,
-0.8237007856369019,
0.03733493387699127,
0.06206423416733742,
0.09057191014289856,
0.06260742992162704,
0.10016090422868729,
0.32396581768989563,
-0.7836993932723999,
0.6386627554893494,
-0.21207654476165771,
-0.06626518815755844,
0.6289582848548889,
0.11467913538217545,
0.46480923891067505,
0.09195548295974731,
0.3125930726528168,
-0.35086920857429504,
0.011839466169476509,
-0.5726532340049744,
-1.1246120929718018,
0.14390943944454193,
-0.8326582908630371,
-0.6541077494621277,
-0.5019711852073669,
-0.3090018928050995,
0.14486268162727356,
0.1725306659936905,
-0.06456515192985535,
0.49440813064575195,
-0.21735960245132446,
0.18026305735111237,
0.6947887539863586,
-0.22816017270088196,
0.5263287425041199,
0.5725014805793762,
-0.38612663745880127,
-0.358089417219162,
0.831039547920227,
-0.01780635491013527,
0.471270352602005,
0.4375704228878021,
-0.1211911290884018,
-0.03160581365227699,
-0.25420719385147095,
-0.72673499584198,
0.03806685656309128,
-0.9858207106590271,
-0.17096473276615143,
-0.2239280492067337,
-0.27733156085014343,
-0.19665274024009705,
-0.18445684015750885,
-0.5732163786888123,
0.053081728518009186,
-0.08421113342046738,
-0.18967662751674652,
0.3051014542579651,
0.5682891607284546,
0.17054374516010284,
0.3553299307823181,
-0.74770188331604,
0.6146205067634583,
0.895159900188446,
0.4506932497024536,
-0.28275570273399353,
-0.4417887032032013,
-0.37153542041778564,
-0.20473194122314453,
-0.140851691365242,
-1.2180856466293335,
0.3390708863735199,
0.16221104562282562,
0.5937975645065308,
0.40954115986824036,
-0.33819183707237244,
0.8321660161018372,
-0.3844285011291504,
0.848044216632843,
0.14522328972816467,
-0.9381669163703918,
0.6715237498283386,
-0.32793962955474854,
0.5842313766479492,
0.4924905300140381,
0.10963957011699677,
-0.5120802521705627,
0.003890457097440958,
-0.35356077551841736,
-0.5683873891830444,
0.4474268853664398,
0.12585529685020447,
-0.041169315576553345,
0.21386989951133728,
0.2231636941432953,
-0.09048354625701904,
0.0766289010643959,
-0.6113721132278442,
0.30589520931243896,
-0.32088589668273926,
0.15136253833770752,
-0.31218421459198,
0.10676773637533188,
0.07404335588216782,
-0.10889243334531784,
0.47517886757850647,
-0.6231228709220886,
0.2319519966840744,
0.5103611350059509,
-0.7739340662956238,
-0.26105934381484985,
0.31444868445396423,
0.5980585813522339,
0.9808127284049988,
-0.2995045781135559,
0.14835602045059204,
0.23916424810886383,
-0.5961360335350037,
0.3619341552257538,
0.21110942959785461,
0.1604861468076706,
0.03607271611690521,
0.48230257630348206,
0.77000892162323,
-0.20232336223125458,
-1.012236475944519,
0.9713981747627258,
0.06385433673858643,
-0.20391838252544403,
-0.9192261695861816,
-0.27919816970825195,
-0.48074066638946533,
0.6851999759674072,
0.5470064282417297,
-0.1632906198501587,
0.23582963645458221,
-0.81402587890625,
0.2667442262172699,
0.42007744312286377,
-0.5454833507537842,
-0.36191004514694214,
0.3770604431629181,
0.07107488811016083,
-0.28586429357528687,
0.553505003452301,
-0.0855066105723381,
-0.5018829703330994,
1.0691903829574585,
0.2417161762714386,
0.9218044877052307,
-0.09946603327989578,
0.7528722286224365,
-0.04797585681080818,
0.26264524459838867,
-0.3187531530857086,
0.33990874886512756,
-0.2679795026779175,
-0.6443727016448975,
-1.001661777496338,
-0.22976139187812805,
-0.5700268149375916,
0.13670267164707184,
-0.5231014490127563,
0.3660126030445099,
-0.16876071691513062,
-0.14453920722007751,
0.09390964359045029,
-0.24454639852046967,
-0.7862333655357361,
0.31666162610054016,
0.43979865312576294,
0.9580124616622925,
-0.8149558901786804,
0.7012468576431274,
0.8970189094543457,
-0.7322062849998474,
-0.83060622215271,
-0.300611287355423,
-0.12847985327243805,
-0.7368806600570679,
0.7261878252029419,
0.28827494382858276,
-0.47172653675079346,
-0.3310650885105133,
-0.813956618309021,
-0.6633334159851074,
1.290146827697754,
0.7000724077224731,
-0.2928221523761749,
-0.31152090430259705,
0.1800418645143509,
0.5313637852668762,
-0.09871946275234222,
0.5742615461349487,
0.3157920837402344,
0.3889315128326416,
0.45908012986183167,
-1.0015798807144165,
-0.22785168886184692,
-0.32822349667549133,
-0.33837297558784485,
0.26307904720306396,
-0.7953459620475769,
0.46308550238609314,
-0.26880866289138794,
0.12108684331178665,
0.011510035954415798,
0.6912370920181274,
-0.11068576574325562,
0.6844692826271057,
0.5980851650238037,
0.25438064336776733,
0.3049887418746948,
0.4826473593711853,
0.6306905150413513,
0.09442684054374695,
0.2800064980983734,
1.0888718366622925,
-0.08725462853908539,
0.677675187587738,
0.44499313831329346,
0.014487160369753838,
0.601556122303009,
0.3151158392429352,
0.08018721640110016,
0.05433512479066849,
-0.05128934234380722,
-0.5014605522155762,
-0.8105406761169434,
-0.14109787344932556,
0.005214477889239788,
1.128389835357666,
0.10226283222436905,
-0.32434725761413574,
-0.26199397444725037,
0.2822090983390808,
-0.3374006450176239,
0.10918962955474854,
-0.5409043431282043,
0.8088662028312683,
-0.09353949874639511,
-0.8353961706161499,
0.29635098576545715,
-0.2580672800540924,
0.03975372761487961,
-0.6584462523460388,
-0.3218979835510254,
0.07353223860263824,
0.24797682464122772,
-0.11827816069126129,
-0.9482599496841431,
-0.028862688690423965,
0.08178966492414474,
-0.18326422572135925,
-0.08870180696249008,
0.7370905876159668,
-0.5121397972106934,
-0.2931175231933594,
0.19673852622509003,
0.5171514749526978,
0.34900930523872375,
-0.45909377932548523,
-0.34956833720207214,
0.02091434970498085,
-0.43349209427833557,
-0.093131422996521,
-0.02580028586089611,
0.4927560091018677,
-0.42907240986824036,
0.8960265517234802,
0.18898668885231018,
-0.12394735962152481,
-0.31660112738609314,
0.16305963695049286,
0.7602764368057251,
-0.7285788655281067,
-0.4380224049091339,
-0.9446218013763428,
0.46950381994247437,
-0.10196608304977417,
0.015484435483813286,
0.2651507258415222,
0.4138600826263428,
0.7709375619888306,
-0.10638473927974701,
0.5760070085525513,
0.23596008121967316,
-0.3123106062412262,
-0.530401885509491,
0.3724532723426819,
-0.5501030087471008,
-0.16722582280635834,
-0.3755458891391754,
-0.9009264707565308,
-0.21379296481609344,
0.5184488892555237,
-0.25897499918937683,
-0.19434726238250732,
0.5749045014381409,
0.6510853171348572,
-0.13137422502040863,
-0.21534283459186554,
0.60960853099823,
0.17707355320453644,
0.5765647292137146,
0.8337201476097107,
0.8983330130577087,
-0.2314191311597824,
0.8575207591056824,
-0.03087354451417923,
-0.4542624354362488,
-0.1312292069196701,
-0.7367650270462036,
-0.8277270197868347,
-0.5637995004653931,
-0.15964016318321228,
-0.10756412893533707,
0.28217893838882446,
1.1023868322372437,
0.7730560898780823,
-0.1747763454914093,
-0.35941725969314575,
0.036699917167425156,
0.027197111397981644,
-0.16183948516845703,
-0.18021591007709503,
0.30388790369033813,
0.16853922605514526,
-0.5822173357009888,
0.3187253773212433,
0.4150449335575104,
-0.014019571244716644,
-0.6299973130226135,
-0.20843270421028137,
-0.058602120727300644,
0.03188565373420715,
1.0098936557769775,
0.5898230671882629,
-0.6840975284576416,
-0.6246773600578308,
0.34628140926361084,
0.05571945756673813,
0.11656638234853745,
0.6843414306640625,
-0.9049281477928162,
0.9594501852989197,
0.5632503032684326,
0.6120872497558594,
0.8987718820571899,
-0.01749158650636673,
0.6913549900054932,
-0.24472498893737793,
0.2305070459842682,
0.16297979652881622,
0.2533397674560547,
0.2219902127981186,
-0.296872615814209,
0.3095239996910095,
0.11876987665891647,
-0.667079508304596,
-0.5295410752296448,
0.5792666077613831,
-1.3861536979675293,
-0.3315436542034149,
1.2067060470581055,
0.024632811546325684,
-0.573229968547821,
0.10644803196191788,
-0.5430436134338379,
0.4597877264022827,
-0.47948503494262695,
0.4645540714263916,
0.5140751004219055,
-0.08256539702415466,
-0.6154323220252991,
-0.5511203408241272,
0.10854825377464294,
0.26460370421409607,
-0.9068603515625,
-0.14294081926345825,
0.7658258080482483,
0.14453744888305664,
0.08516416698694229,
0.7256302833557129,
0.17587606608867645,
0.8733935356140137,
-0.14662101864814758,
0.16084115207195282,
-0.014386150054633617,
-0.7736124992370605,
-0.3064916431903839,
0.309003084897995,
0.07589709758758545,
-0.22697047889232635
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10499v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10499v1
|
Benchmarking Zero-Shot Robustness of Multimodal Foundation Models: A Pilot Study
| 2024-03-15T17:33:49 | 2024-03-15T17:33:49 |
Chenguang Wang, Ruoxi Jia, Xin Liu, Dawn Song
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Pre-training image representations from the raw text about images enables
zero-shot vision transfer to downstream tasks. Through pre-training on millions
of samples collected from the internet, multimodal foundation models, such as
CLIP, produce state-of-the-art zero-shot results that often reach
competitiveness with fully supervised methods without the need for
task-specific training. Besides the encouraging performance on classification
accuracy, it is reported that these models close the robustness gap by matching
the performance of supervised models trained on ImageNet under natural
distribution shift. Because robustness is critical to real-world applications,
especially safety-critical ones, in this paper, we present a comprehensive
evaluation based on a large-scale robustness benchmark covering 7 natural, 3
synthetic distribution shifts, and 11 adversarial attacks. We use CLIP as a
pilot study. We show that CLIP leads to a significant robustness drop compared
to supervised ImageNet models on our benchmark, especially under synthetic
distribution shift and adversarial attacks. Furthermore, data overlap analysis
suggests that the observed robustness under natural distribution shifts could
be attributed, at least in part, to data overlap. In summary, our evaluation
shows a comprehensive evaluation of robustness is necessary; and there is a
significant need to improve the robustness of zero-shot multimodal models.
|
[
-0.511726438999176,
-0.7073628306388855,
0.15192557871341705,
0.04658827185630798,
-0.14996318519115448,
-0.12781794369220734,
0.06785313785076141,
-0.6002371311187744,
-0.03874965384602547,
0.4164096415042877,
-0.5615522265434265,
-0.46284306049346924,
-0.6935755014419556,
0.11129006743431091,
-0.7962973713874817,
0.6770601272583008,
-0.023504672572016716,
-0.16717226803302765,
-0.24970825016498566,
-0.3644610643386841,
-0.37667810916900635,
-0.3790709674358368,
-0.20854176580905914,
0.21566030383110046,
0.23399792611598969,
-0.030410021543502808,
0.7324522137641907,
0.8139481544494629,
0.8575098514556885,
0.2604238986968994,
0.1698848307132721,
-0.26346296072006226,
-0.5352378487586975,
0.004870004951953888,
-0.17552386224269867,
-0.5200216174125671,
-0.27597612142562866,
-0.029588736593723297,
0.6765657067298889,
0.5301955342292786,
0.09153307974338531,
0.06957711279392242,
-0.1415533572435379,
0.40710151195526123,
-1.3708747625350952,
-0.16621960699558258,
-0.7438246607780457,
0.13398423790931702,
-0.26116788387298584,
-0.08072592318058014,
-0.32456573843955994,
-0.2333815097808838,
0.18653613328933716,
-0.5900734663009644,
0.5225836634635925,
-0.29468828439712524,
1.0364789962768555,
0.35542023181915283,
-0.7009284496307373,
0.17118802666664124,
-0.614452600479126,
0.6977646946907043,
-0.4669658839702606,
0.4565201997756958,
0.13609452545642853,
0.619202196598053,
0.05503535643219948,
-0.6635919809341431,
-0.42354995012283325,
-0.15799719095230103,
0.43166303634643555,
0.14451123774051666,
-0.2599174380302429,
-0.004189800936728716,
0.18734529614448547,
0.19860294461250305,
-0.38718268275260925,
-0.07443767786026001,
-0.18674230575561523,
-0.2982880175113678,
0.46953970193862915,
0.09843053668737411,
0.23581463098526,
0.08695292472839355,
-0.7699110507965088,
-0.8083920478820801,
-0.7638498544692993,
0.26016926765441895,
0.2772402763366699,
0.12262526154518127,
-0.15880267322063446,
0.44443386793136597,
-0.3156745731830597,
0.7542064189910889,
-0.02811812423169613,
-0.3520503342151642,
0.1333286166191101,
-0.6609571576118469,
-0.23928771913051605,
-0.2881971597671509,
0.7694420218467712,
0.7787884473800659,
0.2690007984638214,
-0.2607123553752899,
-0.06420983374118805,
0.5338118672370911,
0.4850841164588928,
-0.9784569144248962,
-0.20845526456832886,
-0.03250710293650627,
-0.34115564823150635,
-0.6707870960235596,
0.19758974015712738,
-0.8039353489875793,
-0.06897604465484619,
0.08553710579872131,
0.5667616128921509,
-0.29575008153915405,
-0.2356567084789276,
0.24830681085586548,
-0.15632155537605286,
0.15490692853927612,
0.26729655265808105,
-0.6311145424842834,
0.1111743301153183,
0.39645683765411377,
1.1069676876068115,
-0.33260878920555115,
-0.31484562158584595,
-0.365024596452713,
0.18487481772899628,
-0.41504567861557007,
0.892716646194458,
-0.15126293897628784,
-0.2268117219209671,
0.21117530763149261,
0.18325072526931763,
-0.32465508580207825,
-0.38926172256469727,
0.46130281686782837,
-0.24354536831378937,
-0.24723580479621887,
0.02191448211669922,
-0.26472193002700806,
-0.14848822355270386,
0.8855776190757751,
-0.7884507775306702,
0.643073320388794,
-0.10577649623155594,
-0.7141662240028381,
0.5501753687858582,
-0.5116048455238342,
-0.4249761402606964,
-0.4193924367427826,
0.013506438583135605,
-0.4783123731613159,
-0.0000657099808449857,
0.3926664888858795,
0.42496171593666077,
-0.049006760120391846,
0.025527866557240486,
-1.008884072303772,
-0.3178802728652954,
0.42764851450920105,
-0.8002011179924011,
0.8426316380500793,
-0.08898190408945084,
-0.42924654483795166,
0.03620760887861252,
-0.77107834815979,
0.12191520631313324,
0.10844321548938751,
0.19250105321407318,
-0.15626497566699982,
-0.30767977237701416,
0.20768879354000092,
0.3118506073951721,
-0.27137526869773865,
-0.5046449303627014,
0.14556796848773956,
-0.1411498636007309,
0.36506906151771545,
0.6252734065055847,
0.07523557543754578,
0.46369612216949463,
-0.43428927659988403,
0.5139742493629456,
0.054105911403894424,
0.5401904582977295,
-0.528650164604187,
-0.24655188620090485,
-0.40210995078086853,
-0.587120771408081,
0.42248186469078064,
0.5125543475151062,
-0.7095425724983215,
0.023897208273410797,
-0.3216812312602997,
-0.44637617468833923,
-0.12491604685783386,
-0.07918015122413635,
0.277371883392334,
0.5850587487220764,
0.25346803665161133,
-0.6429858803749084,
-0.1298845410346985,
-0.9303315281867981,
0.028833743184804916,
0.10296061635017395,
0.05966345593333244,
0.160014808177948,
0.6769309639930725,
-0.18807904422283173,
0.9889533519744873,
-0.5521130561828613,
-0.16969546675682068,
0.1912345439195633,
0.13688978552818298,
-0.17784638702869415,
0.4606494903564453,
1.0909180641174316,
-0.951406717300415,
-0.4111965596675873,
-0.36211949586868286,
-0.8217312097549438,
0.16959574818611145,
-0.06506118178367615,
-0.3269355595111847,
-0.11909052729606628,
0.10472586750984192,
-0.5976119637489319,
0.7917497158050537,
0.4974820911884308,
-0.07100952416658401,
0.7035589218139648,
0.09475863724946976,
0.2006150484085083,
-1.0259168148040771,
0.3152059316635132,
0.07089254260063171,
-0.2935301959514618,
-0.6434980630874634,
0.23393614590168,
0.17795538902282715,
-0.35767853260040283,
-0.7310972809791565,
0.2444024682044983,
-0.2782224714756012,
-0.1829679310321808,
-0.06457425653934479,
-0.1380707323551178,
0.25437331199645996,
0.2810021936893463,
0.08901814371347427,
0.6846694946289062,
0.792205274105072,
-0.5477104187011719,
0.232438325881958,
0.32990583777427673,
-0.33367669582366943,
0.957050621509552,
-0.721977949142456,
-0.09743203222751617,
0.06092245131731033,
0.36964932084083557,
-0.7897642850875854,
-0.30325549840927124,
0.15811629593372345,
-0.18667684495449066,
0.3088902533054352,
-0.28573036193847656,
-0.2855064868927002,
0.014538119547069073,
-0.6512576341629028,
0.4196107089519501,
0.14665204286575317,
-0.3096717298030853,
0.13112486898899078,
0.19567494094371796,
0.23194707930088043,
-0.8422994613647461,
-0.7909495830535889,
0.18362241983413696,
-0.08360724151134491,
-0.789605975151062,
0.45013824105262756,
-0.18063680827617645,
0.1434064656496048,
0.1267346441745758,
-0.2603546380996704,
-0.5095746517181396,
0.36090323328971863,
0.38230934739112854,
0.3866659998893738,
-0.24824786186218262,
-0.33270660042762756,
-0.39704009890556335,
-0.08007771521806717,
-0.04526191204786301,
0.01142442598938942,
0.07095792889595032,
-0.048719048500061035,
-0.7073438167572021,
-0.40158575773239136,
0.30501723289489746,
0.8272464871406555,
-0.09176461398601532,
0.6897352337837219,
0.5009596347808838,
-0.38748899102211,
-0.0750802531838417,
-0.4134651720523834,
-0.2112819105386734,
-0.4036175012588501,
0.23259618878364563,
-0.17474502325057983,
-0.6828346252441406,
0.3992353677749634,
-0.054167747497558594,
-0.025638028979301453,
0.3003164529800415,
0.2109835147857666,
-0.08823241293430328,
0.9139425754547119,
0.6983901858329773,
0.14862442016601562,
0.6602951288223267,
-0.41382598876953125,
-0.03341072052717209,
-0.5227047204971313,
-0.009903422556817532,
-0.29111799597740173,
-0.22424361109733582,
-0.3454590439796448,
-0.3194791376590729,
0.40742436051368713,
0.24602940678596497,
-0.07882249355316162,
0.5037285089492798,
-0.26804319024086,
0.3424678444862366,
0.39044278860092163,
0.05886642262339592,
0.13564330339431763,
0.12850335240364075,
-0.09172181040048599,
0.09004682302474976,
-0.5389100909233093,
-0.14071804285049438,
1.3332587480545044,
0.17152291536331177,
0.7141755223274231,
0.14041592180728912,
0.33833226561546326,
0.3314192593097687,
0.2061922401189804,
-0.43505731225013733,
0.3503676652908325,
-0.09019628167152405,
-0.7912431955337524,
-0.05161219462752342,
-0.4033726751804352,
-0.7584107518196106,
0.30639585852622986,
-0.7312639951705933,
-0.5465887784957886,
0.5138566493988037,
0.2655373811721802,
-0.21116505563259125,
0.33747947216033936,
-0.5609411597251892,
1.1416023969650269,
-0.3533375561237335,
-0.4705468714237213,
0.09160848706960678,
-0.8016055822372437,
0.496805876493454,
-0.05303586274385452,
-0.013441607356071472,
-0.29394274950027466,
0.11622127890586853,
0.18942424654960632,
-0.28249937295913696,
0.8549439907073975,
-0.02339036576449871,
0.28453290462493896,
0.1194879487156868,
0.1226077452301979,
0.27892521023750305,
-0.13816457986831665,
0.271413654088974,
0.4779379069805145,
0.33777105808258057,
-0.5388570427894592,
-0.6736123561859131,
0.4141143560409546,
-0.6340411305427551,
-0.057485923171043396,
-0.5058801174163818,
-0.39214053750038147,
-0.3275391757488251,
0.3305203318595886,
0.5658798813819885,
0.738321840763092,
-0.37815359234809875,
0.7319403290748596,
0.5222383737564087,
0.14609681069850922,
0.6353444457054138,
0.27714553475379944,
0.07178489863872528,
-0.627611517906189,
0.6616804003715515,
0.19574756920337677,
0.5185810327529907,
0.42427557706832886,
-0.16083025932312012,
-0.4425046443939209,
-0.5935344099998474,
-0.8388751149177551,
-0.35616496205329895,
-0.6959149837493896,
-0.414143830537796,
-0.34687137603759766,
-0.16726231575012207,
-0.578735888004303,
-0.40331020951271057,
-0.6296290159225464,
-0.4062430262565613,
-0.029852889478206635,
-0.0067514353431761265,
-0.11304398626089096,
0.5007228851318359,
0.007386247161775827,
0.2517344057559967,
-0.832159161567688,
0.32389122247695923,
0.3809061646461487,
0.3956916034221649,
-0.0734662115573883,
-0.13781000673770905,
-0.048432301729917526,
0.1665486991405487,
-0.5405473709106445,
-0.9125311374664307,
0.13013482093811035,
0.3171464204788208,
0.5250970125198364,
0.8356894254684448,
0.3474615514278412,
0.8063868284225464,
-0.2624533176422119,
0.680402934551239,
0.5729663372039795,
-0.8092339038848877,
0.2624785006046295,
-0.3033679127693176,
0.25669124722480774,
0.7554653286933899,
0.2973451614379883,
-0.06283656507730484,
0.08779545873403549,
-0.4230690896511078,
-0.7639710903167725,
0.46898311376571655,
0.4455409646034241,
-0.04981124401092529,
0.055099792778491974,
0.011032450944185257,
-0.0952007994055748,
0.21781544387340546,
-0.7770551443099976,
-0.11932333558797836,
-0.7501652836799622,
0.04892837256193161,
0.11785178631544113,
-0.0982639342546463,
-0.3473958969116211,
0.04381942003965378,
0.253802090883255,
-0.4007549285888672,
0.1635839343070984,
0.19775062799453735,
-0.3639011085033417,
0.13837406039237976,
0.12933963537216187,
0.7594628930091858,
0.6064353585243225,
-0.3574766218662262,
0.22551017999649048,
0.09693130850791931,
-0.5701518654823303,
0.3857618570327759,
0.11610106378793716,
-0.47248396277427673,
-0.17313162982463837,
0.708450436592102,
0.8062723278999329,
0.5473940372467041,
-0.6636534929275513,
1.1550806760787964,
-0.16301573812961578,
-0.28861793875694275,
-0.057185277342796326,
0.004298992455005646,
-0.3897493779659271,
0.03602936118841171,
0.30209678411483765,
0.6607939600944519,
0.2774692177772522,
-0.42654117941856384,
0.39168781042099,
0.6705052852630615,
-0.40232717990875244,
-0.5303296446800232,
0.6191934943199158,
0.0599856972694397,
0.16316452622413635,
0.3216067850589752,
0.07715354114770889,
-0.3804495632648468,
0.7127358913421631,
0.6952152252197266,
0.930781364440918,
0.03552555665373802,
0.3883976936340332,
0.16326755285263062,
0.4116672873497009,
-0.37204086780548096,
-0.28236815333366394,
-0.3050011396408081,
-0.7130998969078064,
-0.3250886797904968,
-0.3357691764831543,
-0.5470874309539795,
-0.16931921243667603,
-0.9813751578330994,
0.12649841606616974,
-0.5467773079872131,
-0.40748393535614014,
-0.08257140964269638,
-0.5013920664787292,
-0.7097032070159912,
0.28275683522224426,
0.04255540668964386,
0.9288208484649658,
-0.9742927551269531,
0.5315898060798645,
0.6460345983505249,
-0.23778308928012848,
-0.39330312609672546,
0.02230348438024521,
0.04673837497830391,
-0.5033910274505615,
0.26513445377349854,
0.552768349647522,
-0.2678479254245758,
-0.3886534869670868,
-0.5695982575416565,
-0.9413454532623291,
1.1686573028564453,
0.8738040924072266,
-0.34246110916137695,
0.23301799595355988,
0.1700306087732315,
0.28930696845054626,
-0.24240891635417938,
0.370099276304245,
-0.05539131164550781,
0.027280541136860847,
0.5094466805458069,
-0.7217714786529541,
-0.14620965719223022,
-0.2724152207374573,
0.09746367484331131,
0.18319834768772125,
-0.5145862698554993,
0.9204682111740112,
0.02842116355895996,
-0.40353208780288696,
-0.07852910459041595,
0.1689370572566986,
-0.10661578178405762,
0.5219407677650452,
0.6344583034515381,
0.8053634166717529,
0.2899978756904602,
-0.05236256122589111,
1.145578145980835,
-0.47719791531562805,
0.443729043006897,
0.8437964916229248,
-0.4738418757915497,
1.0644901990890503,
0.22249191999435425,
-0.031156983226537704,
0.1523103415966034,
0.3383806347846985,
-0.12979204952716827,
0.8902585506439209,
-0.3284578323364258,
-0.16594931483268738,
-0.38726866245269775,
-0.14399918913841248,
-0.36682406067848206,
0.5103676319122314,
-0.12767402827739716,
-0.15353569388389587,
-0.47278138995170593,
0.12332071363925934,
-0.1467546820640564,
-0.27261650562286377,
-0.09887833148241043,
0.48927122354507446,
-0.13764670491218567,
-0.46238818764686584,
0.5880767107009888,
-0.11022290587425232,
0.6202941536903381,
-0.7339699864387512,
-0.03235860913991928,
-0.12152307480573654,
0.42890849709510803,
-0.15823905169963837,
-0.6721569299697876,
0.3860892951488495,
-0.018486956134438515,
-0.18203125894069672,
-0.1415783017873764,
0.8639228940010071,
0.05854833126068115,
-0.4807828366756439,
0.21962803602218628,
0.05464405566453934,
-0.11119040846824646,
-0.2093808948993683,
-0.5833157896995544,
0.14998668432235718,
-0.2092476785182953,
-0.038914550095796585,
0.6088817119598389,
0.061214227229356766,
-0.19558905065059662,
0.6572523713111877,
1.0927740335464478,
-0.06292340159416199,
0.39980727434158325,
-0.3039723336696625,
0.8383037447929382,
-0.5287411212921143,
-0.4092189073562622,
-0.89247727394104,
0.3651652932167053,
-0.3610081672668457,
-0.49343952536582947,
0.8076287508010864,
0.37294965982437134,
0.8220199942588806,
-0.12702660262584686,
0.708121120929718,
0.008576123043894768,
-0.09854421019554138,
-0.45486852526664734,
0.5453084707260132,
-0.39415955543518066,
-0.241279736161232,
-0.4168793559074402,
-1.0289920568466187,
-0.5260982513427734,
0.5859661102294922,
-0.01987224817276001,
-0.1863643229007721,
0.4507445693016052,
0.7339288592338562,
-0.4340895414352417,
-0.13405364751815796,
0.5078169703483582,
-0.18785759806632996,
0.2972054183483124,
0.468119353055954,
0.610332190990448,
-0.5577808022499084,
0.8207665085792542,
-0.6743676066398621,
-0.20061010122299194,
-0.29313528537750244,
-1.3350610733032227,
-0.9398174285888672,
-0.30047082901000977,
-0.40141376852989197,
-0.17685431241989136,
0.17733746767044067,
0.47961780428886414,
1.3821206092834473,
-0.8797086477279663,
0.10460387915372849,
0.014247538521885872,
-0.17407017946243286,
-0.37147438526153564,
-0.18774916231632233,
0.32424992322921753,
0.13325858116149902,
-0.25664541125297546,
0.424429714679718,
0.5156347751617432,
0.31815120577812195,
-0.31138578057289124,
0.24027840793132782,
-0.12162908911705017,
0.10380648821592331,
0.462579607963562,
0.4676970839500427,
-0.4150196313858032,
-0.34468477964401245,
0.22890250384807587,
-0.02364925481379032,
0.036138590425252914,
0.6484284996986389,
-0.49313509464263916,
0.7571766376495361,
0.4335387945175171,
0.8509538769721985,
0.592810332775116,
0.21907848119735718,
0.41444095969200134,
-0.7821604609489441,
0.38579344749450684,
0.014790256507694721,
0.3601001799106598,
0.47442567348480225,
-0.011788214556872845,
0.5695268511772156,
0.4870832860469818,
-0.3243115544319153,
-1.1046029329299927,
0.2527965307235718,
-1.0245165824890137,
-0.10222604125738144,
0.7226513624191284,
-0.5451061129570007,
-0.3596227169036865,
0.07702513039112091,
0.12978918850421906,
0.021508488804101944,
0.0019893820863217115,
0.7038260102272034,
0.6491256356239319,
0.1257319152355194,
-0.331987202167511,
-0.5230100154876709,
0.11519625782966614,
0.27794015407562256,
-0.6814645528793335,
-0.3981577157974243,
0.45626300573349,
0.5402761101722717,
0.3186011016368866,
0.35139548778533936,
-0.051740944385528564,
0.35664883255958557,
0.2792350947856903,
-0.03869915008544922,
-0.29739004373550415,
-0.48802292346954346,
-0.3899276554584503,
0.6335986256599426,
-0.22360369563102722,
-0.6146442890167236
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10446v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10446v1
|
Enhancing LLM Factual Accuracy with RAG to Counter Hallucinations: A Case Study on Domain-Specific Queries in Private Knowledge-Bases
| 2024-03-15T16:30:14 | 2024-03-15T16:30:14 |
Jiarui Li, Ye Yuan, Zehua Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We proposed an end-to-end system design towards utilizing Retrieval Augmented
Generation (RAG) to improve the factual accuracy of Large Language Models
(LLMs) for domain-specific and time-sensitive queries related to private
knowledge-bases. Our system integrates RAG pipeline with upstream datasets
processing and downstream performance evaluation. Addressing the challenge of
LLM hallucinations, we finetune models with a curated dataset which originates
from CMU's extensive resources and annotated with the teacher model. Our
experiments demonstrate the system's effectiveness in generating more accurate
answers to domain-specific and time-sensitive inquiries. The results also
revealed the limitations of fine-tuning LLMs with small-scale and skewed
datasets. This research highlights the potential of RAG systems in augmenting
LLMs with external datasets for improved performance in knowledge-intensive
tasks. Our code and models are available on Github.
|
[
-0.22480474412441254,
-0.7460338473320007,
0.6628468632698059,
0.028123188763856888,
-0.021547509357333183,
0.3742550015449524,
-0.3518480658531189,
-0.5553516745567322,
0.3765340745449066,
0.7925758957862854,
-0.3172041177749634,
-0.5182590484619141,
-0.5311909914016724,
0.08732686936855316,
-0.548738956451416,
0.9483634829521179,
0.20658646523952484,
0.12049737572669983,
-0.3015899062156677,
-0.25533992052078247,
-0.5010084509849548,
-0.801685094833374,
-0.5207759737968445,
-0.1389942616224289,
0.4916776418685913,
0.31055933237075806,
0.6584336161613464,
0.44917914271354675,
0.5455799698829651,
0.20816576480865479,
-0.05140794441103935,
0.7558934688568115,
-0.8263059258460999,
0.42350834608078003,
-0.5238218903541565,
-0.4220067858695984,
-0.42855966091156006,
-0.334342360496521,
0.4346955418586731,
0.7833243608474731,
-0.18107110261917114,
0.33753353357315063,
0.0642012506723404,
0.7059483528137207,
-0.7862065434455872,
0.18130739033222198,
-0.9456198215484619,
0.020513691008090973,
-0.16289110481739044,
-0.33639490604400635,
-0.5833262205123901,
-0.3558824062347412,
0.055157605558633804,
-0.5916649699211121,
0.4049912095069885,
0.27957287430763245,
0.687892735004425,
0.632509708404541,
-0.21271227300167084,
-0.3911353349685669,
-0.8821209669113159,
0.6085643172264099,
-0.518649697303772,
0.5155929327011108,
0.3819306492805481,
0.3466354310512543,
-0.22899967432022095,
-0.8057935237884521,
-0.44170403480529785,
-0.2094060629606247,
-0.35244402289390564,
-0.04263550415635109,
0.081337109208107,
-0.035433270037174225,
0.3328970968723297,
0.4390682876110077,
-0.49295350909233093,
-0.02932644635438919,
-0.3448564410209656,
-0.32866400480270386,
0.6145679950714111,
0.48688939213752747,
-0.07294031232595444,
-0.21529999375343323,
-0.14833258092403412,
0.18324804306030273,
-0.6041581034660339,
-0.29874441027641296,
0.33608192205429077,
0.3907108008861542,
0.29861125349998474,
0.8844534158706665,
-0.36904045939445496,
0.7641856670379639,
0.12182861566543579,
-0.039578650146722794,
-0.010259589180350304,
0.0622241385281086,
-0.15053971111774445,
0.06393900513648987,
0.3037293553352356,
0.3331243097782135,
0.34675687551498413,
-0.5252571105957031,
-0.3713468015193939,
0.18136999011039734,
0.5408410429954529,
-0.6105162501335144,
-0.2532489597797394,
0.24593712389469147,
-0.1228698194026947,
-0.3942759335041046,
-0.03053225576877594,
-0.8116710782051086,
-0.908989667892456,
-0.66266930103302,
0.5817179679870605,
-0.2803082764148712,
-0.20540432631969452,
0.18261180818080902,
0.08017738908529282,
0.0017048860900104046,
0.26944416761398315,
-0.4776875376701355,
0.6180301904678345,
0.8444401025772095,
0.641001284122467,
-0.5251677632331848,
-0.04393657669425011,
-0.5701318383216858,
0.3960592746734619,
-0.4033970534801483,
0.6492875218391418,
-0.584302544593811,
-0.39007437229156494,
-0.09843583405017853,
0.013270493596792221,
0.017856618389487267,
-0.9510977864265442,
0.6338937282562256,
-0.9069176912307739,
0.19063788652420044,
-0.19550083577632904,
-0.6870209574699402,
-0.04682031646370888,
0.3108898103237152,
-0.487446129322052,
0.8896276950836182,
0.18785394728183746,
-0.6963836550712585,
0.07851382344961166,
-0.4479767978191376,
-0.37981534004211426,
0.08887619525194168,
-0.3889833986759186,
-0.28871431946754456,
0.21533356606960297,
0.23929379880428314,
0.4402218759059906,
-0.2814059555530548,
0.5362645387649536,
-0.006956441327929497,
-0.44606971740722656,
0.3202013075351715,
-0.2931220829486847,
0.6163906455039978,
0.29224011301994324,
-0.3555973768234253,
-0.02542898617684841,
-0.9659445285797119,
0.0422818660736084,
0.16046638786792755,
-0.13540802896022797,
-0.48971596360206604,
-0.05471063777804375,
-0.26100021600723267,
-0.18726573884487152,
0.4067685902118683,
-0.2004241794347763,
0.08894532173871994,
-0.2444530874490738,
-0.34229353070259094,
0.7914749979972839,
0.023416049778461456,
0.3915218412876129,
-0.4543493986129761,
0.36117351055145264,
0.06900186836719513,
0.1278776079416275,
0.12052769213914871,
-0.3995717763900757,
-0.854814350605011,
-0.2158759981393814,
0.31158462166786194,
0.5464024543762207,
-0.8074407577514648,
0.24619963765144348,
-0.31993192434310913,
-0.2677106261253357,
-0.4453233480453491,
-0.08899391442537308,
0.3367505967617035,
0.7693020701408386,
0.46001818776130676,
-0.2566527724266052,
-0.7138271927833557,
-0.632803738117218,
-0.26151227951049805,
0.036623794585466385,
-0.007158868480473757,
0.6686451435089111,
0.3885248601436615,
-0.3304356634616852,
0.8518362045288086,
-0.7118914723396301,
-0.391839861869812,
0.18328560888767242,
0.027290863916277885,
0.21641920506954193,
0.18400204181671143,
0.2318039983510971,
-0.7944226264953613,
-0.3923468291759491,
-0.015182005241513252,
-0.8963298201560974,
-0.25546056032180786,
0.15853136777877808,
-0.17737559974193573,
0.612361490726471,
0.23672091960906982,
-0.6047481298446655,
0.4132048785686493,
0.4474872350692749,
-0.5001856088638306,
0.8414228558540344,
0.016740066930651665,
0.30107802152633667,
-0.9703739285469055,
0.08599463105201721,
-0.4384003281593323,
-0.2529720664024353,
-0.5305938124656677,
0.1852632462978363,
-0.05144582688808441,
-0.03692241013050079,
-0.11812654882669449,
0.43456223607063293,
-0.3567257523536682,
-0.34723997116088867,
-0.427772581577301,
0.19959712028503418,
0.18221791088581085,
0.405388206243515,
-0.04398851841688156,
0.9020349383354187,
0.45402342081069946,
-0.7226932644844055,
0.3267820179462433,
0.11377466470003128,
-0.39321082830429077,
0.46256786584854126,
-0.2254786342382431,
0.3213501274585724,
0.036128684878349304,
-0.046611420810222626,
-0.5007617473602295,
-0.5338442325592041,
0.24919520318508148,
-0.42675039172172546,
0.4270922839641571,
-0.22435571253299713,
-0.5074527859687805,
-0.044208429753780365,
-0.028298111632466316,
0.1643473505973816,
0.431762158870697,
-0.7593693137168884,
0.6011915802955627,
0.6176237463951111,
-0.010390473529696465,
-0.8292505145072937,
-0.4186441898345947,
0.19006562232971191,
0.004262085538357496,
-0.5414372086524963,
0.4713882505893707,
0.01229188870638609,
-0.5678024888038635,
0.12188395112752914,
-0.21193121373653412,
-0.13656851649284363,
-0.08840559422969818,
0.1750219166278839,
0.3479172885417938,
-0.24306295812129974,
0.0557844340801239,
0.018572159111499786,
0.17343676090240479,
0.3338085114955902,
-0.42661163210868835,
0.6353880763053894,
0.006940873339772224,
-0.380852073431015,
-0.03146185353398323,
0.053523626178503036,
0.4608728289604187,
-0.06598863750696182,
0.9828715324401855,
0.3687775731086731,
-0.6038338541984558,
-0.4660828709602356,
-0.8410482406616211,
-0.3811330199241638,
-0.46376776695251465,
-0.0350327305495739,
-0.37136492133140564,
-0.9974945187568665,
0.6097593307495117,
-0.0341237373650074,
-0.23456087708473206,
0.345919668674469,
0.5544308423995972,
0.09743324667215347,
0.7434238195419312,
0.5025560855865479,
0.010454796254634857,
0.0908893421292305,
-0.33924466371536255,
0.1281222403049469,
-0.7704833149909973,
-0.36223042011260986,
-0.3199196457862854,
-0.10211902856826782,
-0.6407973766326904,
-0.6447010636329651,
0.35989463329315186,
-0.1252530813217163,
-0.13184213638305664,
-0.13845497369766235,
-0.7409873008728027,
0.4788636267185211,
0.2749423384666443,
0.17603352665901184,
0.6524959802627563,
0.15783219039440155,
-0.07618648558855057,
-0.13315652310848236,
-0.5533753633499146,
-0.5368746519088745,
1.1629979610443115,
0.07192297279834747,
0.8557050228118896,
0.08713598549365997,
0.49864462018013,
0.36632058024406433,
0.2899283170700073,
-0.6657733917236328,
0.6313444972038269,
-0.14052227139472961,
-0.7545517086982727,
-0.27516528964042664,
-0.6587810516357422,
-0.6151142120361328,
0.1410541981458664,
-0.2217298299074173,
-0.571704089641571,
0.33367466926574707,
-0.027886439114809036,
-0.2669614255428314,
0.4421541392803192,
-0.5356619358062744,
0.37248852849006653,
-0.15109851956367493,
-0.6150720119476318,
-0.18466152250766754,
-0.4887484908103943,
0.5122185349464417,
-0.37049102783203125,
0.07144581526517868,
0.09463769197463989,
0.018864555284380913,
0.5669770240783691,
-0.33988216519355774,
0.8265198469161987,
-0.2733166515827179,
-0.1610087752342224,
0.3821958899497986,
0.3558448255062103,
0.7082890868186951,
0.13238626718521118,
-0.26550576090812683,
0.23160608112812042,
-0.10663556307554245,
-0.06910181045532227,
-0.7774229049682617,
0.8328152894973755,
-0.6209618449211121,
-0.8358780145645142,
-0.43572935461997986,
-0.8037087917327881,
-0.41295596957206726,
0.0055287424474954605,
0.05741691589355469,
0.44145986437797546,
0.05064856633543968,
0.18793568015098572,
0.9674113988876343,
-0.18387213349342346,
-0.25636428594589233,
0.742011308670044,
-0.5560588836669922,
-0.24660469591617584,
0.9840407967567444,
0.4166034758090973,
-0.03431399539113045,
0.31972405314445496,
0.06646613031625748,
-0.22886046767234802,
-0.7057044506072998,
-0.20297871530056,
0.27052614092826843,
-0.6753197908401489,
-0.4166237413883209,
-0.8443973064422607,
-0.4688774049282074,
-0.7147524356842041,
0.17963315546512604,
-0.41429248452186584,
-0.6546427607536316,
-0.36157283186912537,
-0.004895670339465141,
0.6712185740470886,
0.7738582491874695,
-0.046210747212171555,
0.044030945748090744,
-0.6291521191596985,
0.6433390378952026,
0.13748331367969513,
0.520515501499176,
-0.20304620265960693,
-0.9259701371192932,
-0.3627467751502991,
-0.09771297127008438,
-0.2090158313512802,
-0.545918881893158,
0.4350526034832001,
-0.041191183030605316,
0.4337393641471863,
0.09896490722894669,
0.37390533089637756,
0.6813997030258179,
-0.6046566367149353,
0.6535935997962952,
-0.43894192576408386,
-0.6589652299880981,
0.4040134847164154,
-0.3541867434978485,
-0.1413840353488922,
0.4054519832134247,
0.4315899610519409,
-0.270699679851532,
-0.559438943862915,
-0.47101324796676636,
-0.7708067297935486,
0.5393143892288208,
0.199608713388443,
-0.05240602791309357,
0.18791396915912628,
0.6797546148300171,
0.286190003156662,
0.18916018307209015,
-0.36240410804748535,
-0.454878568649292,
0.04933865740895271,
-0.28427329659461975,
0.11720225214958191,
-0.3730190694332123,
-0.39128366112709045,
-0.24603711068630219,
0.7588971853256226,
-0.15822835266590118,
0.19846923649311066,
0.21554988622665405,
-0.14209647476673126,
-0.24280747771263123,
0.11048075556755066,
0.4375625550746918,
0.9657855033874512,
-0.24801138043403625,
0.05841134488582611,
0.48955100774765015,
-0.5858249664306641,
-0.10369361191987991,
0.1667177677154541,
-0.06455586850643158,
0.08718928694725037,
0.010563374496996403,
0.4318596422672272,
0.021827522665262222,
-0.6074394583702087,
0.28687208890914917,
-0.1728953719139099,
0.02327127754688263,
-0.5536743998527527,
0.1545201539993286,
-0.05133814364671707,
0.5244133472442627,
0.4490381181240082,
0.03865571692585945,
0.35381364822387695,
-0.18312285840511322,
0.1931217461824417,
0.3297078609466553,
0.028620397672057152,
-0.09861443936824799,
0.7398744225502014,
-0.1414840966463089,
-0.3224860727787018,
0.5374687910079956,
-0.11447572708129883,
-0.37715548276901245,
0.3518000841140747,
0.510378360748291,
0.7502478957176208,
-0.15218520164489746,
0.07508008182048798,
0.0969601571559906,
0.2977415919303894,
-0.033397890627384186,
0.3277604579925537,
-0.021681658923625946,
-0.7496720552444458,
-0.6484387516975403,
-0.7037689089775085,
-0.8084495067596436,
0.3048035204410553,
-0.6935577988624573,
0.25746408104896545,
-0.38760989904403687,
-0.21771623194217682,
-0.4440881311893463,
0.18200547993183136,
-0.39269140362739563,
0.3471161723136902,
0.09132750332355499,
0.76435387134552,
-0.28846126794815063,
0.7694756984710693,
0.48511138558387756,
-0.10569798946380615,
-0.676702618598938,
0.006510092876851559,
-0.18154464662075043,
-0.5474172830581665,
0.7065302133560181,
-0.12966763973236084,
-0.4459582567214966,
-0.10063303261995316,
-0.6155868172645569,
-0.8142827749252319,
1.111512303352356,
0.47498223185539246,
-0.6460314393043518,
-0.030268803238868713,
0.34911835193634033,
0.7690765261650085,
-0.3773077726364136,
-0.31067201495170593,
0.6384724378585815,
0.21876206994056702,
-0.03652771934866905,
-0.7213259935379028,
-0.02317890152335167,
0.05591781437397003,
-0.3018346428871155,
0.037339553236961365,
-0.469448059797287,
0.48703110218048096,
-0.18846914172172546,
-0.17972274124622345,
-0.08716580271720886,
0.828540563583374,
0.5046898722648621,
0.7144551277160645,
0.37275606393814087,
0.6713874936103821,
1.0689218044281006,
-0.06216985359787941,
1.0650475025177002,
-0.5681806802749634,
0.18714605271816254,
1.4448137283325195,
-0.42600491642951965,
0.6294334530830383,
0.4561581313610077,
0.056611526757478714,
0.26166653633117676,
0.33764466643333435,
0.13113875687122345,
0.4619024693965912,
0.12280303239822388,
-0.42983368039131165,
0.01298548188060522,
-0.3264370858669281,
-0.3967633545398712,
0.17328299582004547,
0.6511105298995972,
-0.26423516869544983,
0.182924285531044,
-0.07762698829174042,
-0.100099116563797,
0.23189999163150787,
-0.20137551426887512,
0.713379442691803,
0.08291266858577728,
-0.6142076253890991,
0.4700652062892914,
-0.13623128831386566,
0.5982245206832886,
-0.3076704144477844,
-0.019861066713929176,
-0.35283055901527405,
0.27093246579170227,
-0.3396495282649994,
-0.7080317139625549,
0.6459400653839111,
0.2465152144432068,
-0.28330323100090027,
-0.06128304451704025,
1.0470715761184692,
-0.29825329780578613,
-0.44807618856430054,
0.36966025829315186,
0.6603427529335022,
0.2894735634326935,
-0.16005665063858032,
-0.49278441071510315,
0.17791368067264557,
-0.1917395442724228,
-0.26940643787384033,
0.1372983157634735,
0.7703557014465332,
-0.039330076426267624,
0.6038113236427307,
0.5455997586250305,
0.3031383156776428,
0.23612108826637268,
0.40409085154533386,
0.9554108381271362,
-0.5520360469818115,
-0.030459975823760033,
-0.5706931948661804,
0.27521786093711853,
-0.08478688448667526,
0.05605630949139595,
0.6978664398193359,
0.728623628616333,
1.0763633251190186,
-0.12178657948970795,
0.6520630121231079,
0.023225227370858192,
1.0182546377182007,
-0.5057146549224854,
0.9580724835395813,
-0.5138064026832581,
0.5444915294647217,
-0.03201177716255188,
-0.825893759727478,
-0.3150582015514374,
0.4067862033843994,
-0.41871026158332825,
-0.01680145598948002,
0.5896288156509399,
1.2399959564208984,
0.03143696114420891,
0.07365453243255615,
0.5907734036445618,
0.4257424473762512,
0.1538219302892685,
-0.07849707454442978,
1.0974165201187134,
-0.3735853433609009,
0.5045363306999207,
-0.5752384066581726,
0.09558887034654617,
-0.20055778324604034,
-0.5696709156036377,
-0.8206480741500854,
-0.6120557188987732,
-0.2526453137397766,
-0.5381109714508057,
0.4307803511619568,
0.8290828466415405,
0.33243218064308167,
-0.9494501948356628,
-0.18296687304973602,
0.14958401024341583,
0.22148114442825317,
0.1917014867067337,
-0.3326747417449951,
0.3922746181488037,
-0.5910699367523193,
-0.6415390372276306,
0.41880640387535095,
0.09897831827402115,
-0.18165354430675507,
-0.31556016206741333,
-0.014591963961720467,
-0.001610438572242856,
0.06970971077680588,
0.781392514705658,
-0.15112881362438202,
-0.5306392908096313,
-0.3697117567062378,
0.30486294627189636,
-0.2815011143684387,
-0.08835895359516144,
0.8428137898445129,
-0.9221184849739075,
0.30954936146736145,
0.24087703227996826,
0.858126699924469,
0.41441595554351807,
0.05298703908920288,
0.30602994561195374,
-0.826375424861908,
-0.1439618468284607,
0.42521336674690247,
0.23051217198371887,
0.47873881459236145,
-0.8379033207893372,
0.8118348717689514,
0.3465660810470581,
-0.8617702722549438,
-1.0387964248657227,
-0.0015302937244996428,
-0.7660365700721741,
-0.2634144723415375,
1.0981981754302979,
0.10951884090900421,
-0.32681554555892944,
-0.2964942753314972,
-0.2959626019001007,
0.3931828439235687,
-0.09923021495342255,
1.1522263288497925,
0.6171702146530151,
-0.22660890221595764,
0.14819562435150146,
-0.6722957491874695,
0.5574387907981873,
0.32886770367622375,
-0.758598804473877,
0.21682174503803253,
0.6716738343238831,
0.22064651548862457,
0.2639215588569641,
0.4218810498714447,
-0.23157180845737457,
0.07127977907657623,
-0.17346909642219543,
-0.0888044536113739,
-0.042498186230659485,
-0.5987288355827332,
-0.24543744325637817,
0.23895308375358582,
0.029964692890644073,
0.03475283086299896
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10444v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10444v1
|
Optimal Block-Level Draft Verification for Accelerating Speculative Decoding
| 2024-03-15T16:28:22 | 2024-03-15T16:28:22 |
Ziteng Sun, Jae Hun Ro, Ahmad Beirami, Ananda Theertha Suresh
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.DS, cs.IT, math.IT
|
Speculative decoding has shown to be an effective method for lossless
acceleration of large language models (LLMs) during inference. In each
iteration, the algorithm first uses a smaller model to draft a block of tokens.
The tokens are then verified by the large model in parallel and only a subset
of tokens will be kept to guarantee that the final output follows the
distribution of the large model. In all of the prior speculative decoding
works, the draft verification is performed token-by-token independently. In
this work, we propose a better draft verification algorithm that provides
additional wall-clock speedup without incurring additional computation cost and
draft tokens. We first formulate the draft verification step as a block-level
optimal transport problem. The block-level formulation allows us to consider a
wider range of draft verification algorithms and obtain a higher number of
accepted tokens in expectation in one draft block. We propose a verification
algorithm that achieves the optimal accepted length for the block-level
transport problem. We empirically evaluate our proposed block-level
verification algorithm in a wide range of tasks and datasets, and observe
consistent improvements in wall-clock speedup when compared to token-level
verification algorithm. To the best of our knowledge, our work is the first to
establish improvement over speculative decoding through a better draft
verification algorithm.
|
[
-0.24940890073776245,
-0.7575502991676331,
0.6293254494667053,
0.5735386610031128,
-0.423522412776947,
0.4876648485660553,
-0.1687914878129959,
-0.7815576791763306,
0.12161111831665039,
0.34135523438453674,
-0.5061055421829224,
-0.3349914848804474,
-0.6995652318000793,
0.15071168541908264,
-0.6374644637107849,
0.34540513157844543,
-0.3420737385749817,
-0.29280373454093933,
-0.046547502279281616,
0.41614869236946106,
-0.23319368064403534,
-0.32800769805908203,
-0.7222189903259277,
-0.24537909030914307,
-0.08226101100444794,
0.2612295150756836,
0.23271849751472473,
1.061340093612671,
0.4661809206008911,
0.29967546463012695,
-0.43896061182022095,
0.5889559388160706,
-0.6004384160041809,
0.23833498358726501,
0.06981959193944931,
-0.28035032749176025,
-0.5302320122718811,
-0.534532904624939,
0.8356252312660217,
0.3615509867668152,
0.011629377491772175,
0.19924166798591614,
-0.527417004108429,
0.6091180443763733,
-0.8560450673103333,
-0.09990209341049194,
-0.7678542137145996,
-0.156851127743721,
-0.4499095678329468,
-0.8436833620071411,
-0.7015535235404968,
-0.4641803503036499,
-0.2846969664096832,
-0.5730891823768616,
0.23145174980163574,
0.6122759580612183,
0.760611355304718,
-0.09754844009876251,
-0.5973994135856628,
0.0331634059548378,
-0.7420894503593445,
0.41934046149253845,
-0.45851948857307434,
0.6010735630989075,
0.3790108561515808,
0.09837078303098679,
-0.2919338047504425,
-0.6922287940979004,
-0.515398383140564,
-0.15417975187301636,
0.09830890595912933,
0.015844574198126793,
-0.19252006709575653,
0.20091713964939117,
0.46159061789512634,
0.4890178143978119,
-0.7238712906837463,
0.31066229939460754,
-0.46602022647857666,
-0.8772186040878296,
0.6805016398429871,
0.4450346529483795,
-0.00011768694821512327,
0.11934354901313782,
-0.3901822865009308,
0.019389266148209572,
-0.796227216720581,
0.28411605954170227,
0.4774675667285919,
-0.023866519331932068,
-0.1008124127984047,
0.3360772430896759,
-0.7364334464073181,
0.6367671489715576,
0.1992587149143219,
-0.07674015313386917,
0.27151983976364136,
-0.5647144913673401,
0.11170679330825806,
0.03674325346946716,
0.5015428066253662,
0.3776535093784332,
-0.09336873143911362,
-0.26815709471702576,
-0.45026886463165283,
0.08964740484952927,
-0.08006876707077026,
-1.0548912286758423,
0.09526296705007553,
0.397356241941452,
-0.42486751079559326,
-0.28675517439842224,
-0.11028973013162613,
-0.6198428273200989,
-0.2858717739582062,
0.22330807149410248,
0.04182753711938858,
-0.22694995999336243,
-0.4857728183269501,
0.6615085005760193,
-0.19923409819602966,
0.1912711262702942,
0.1608416736125946,
-1.140644907951355,
0.4504135847091675,
0.8102878332138062,
0.8040077090263367,
-0.26693785190582275,
-0.1995229870080948,
-0.6618661880493164,
0.0638996958732605,
-0.7940459847450256,
1.1434998512268066,
-0.37263134121894836,
-0.3133781850337982,
0.06741934269666672,
-0.2080860137939453,
0.14692440629005432,
-0.18496446311473846,
0.8908795714378357,
-0.748941957950592,
-0.4206715226173401,
-0.5039093494415283,
-0.7347682118415833,
0.19748704135417938,
0.33462485671043396,
-0.3794042468070984,
0.9732235670089722,
-0.06019938737154007,
-0.837275505065918,
0.3831956684589386,
-0.5794092416763306,
-0.6705642938613892,
0.08270371705293655,
0.1476214975118637,
0.042741525918245316,
0.29593372344970703,
0.5735683441162109,
0.4111531674861908,
-0.3406171202659607,
-0.07613091915845871,
-0.15070120990276337,
-0.7960052490234375,
0.0908237099647522,
-0.40515002608299255,
0.6838023662567139,
0.3075854480266571,
-0.18169225752353668,
0.18238860368728638,
-0.7735285758972168,
0.21793465316295624,
0.10056047886610031,
-0.3693590462207794,
-0.10262978076934814,
-0.13237929344177246,
-0.1767720878124237,
-0.19541464745998383,
0.22911255061626434,
-0.8386487364768982,
0.21883010864257812,
-0.4931042194366455,
0.33820125460624695,
1.09798264503479,
0.1564178764820099,
0.3870616555213928,
-0.2619972229003906,
0.5030126571655273,
-0.012231443077325821,
0.20296470820903778,
-0.33785682916641235,
-0.2881196439266205,
-0.6273094415664673,
-0.32086512446403503,
0.30272743105888367,
0.32412904500961304,
-0.5950126647949219,
0.2598297595977783,
-0.17576003074645996,
-0.30296871066093445,
-0.41501423716545105,
-0.22725100815296173,
0.2655521631240845,
0.4067765772342682,
0.3532806634902954,
0.13857534527778625,
-0.738783061504364,
-0.6581528782844543,
-0.21885833144187927,
-0.48377296328544617,
0.4397242069244385,
-0.07344245910644531,
0.19064152240753174,
-0.01793038472533226,
0.25847920775413513,
-0.4963354170322418,
0.44735029339790344,
-0.19299215078353882,
0.07098327577114105,
0.13209015130996704,
0.6495071053504944,
0.3495723605155945,
-0.2742704749107361,
-0.3252975046634674,
0.26983994245529175,
-0.35661250352859497,
-0.29614412784576416,
-0.26350000500679016,
-0.43068769574165344,
0.20351682603359222,
0.7707017064094543,
-0.6221684813499451,
0.32026413083076477,
0.5784627795219421,
-0.612885594367981,
0.7593092322349548,
-0.36667609214782715,
0.3667512536048889,
-0.6348591446876526,
0.06716147065162659,
-0.3522920608520508,
-0.6183865666389465,
-0.5467826128005981,
0.48047468066215515,
0.3199085295200348,
0.19622303545475006,
-0.16293218731880188,
0.5296124815940857,
-0.6047840118408203,
0.16450151801109314,
-0.5229023098945618,
0.11223898828029633,
0.04758831113576889,
0.16271336376667023,
-0.024130718782544136,
0.8597820997238159,
0.7815468907356262,
-0.4155636429786682,
0.21877306699752808,
-0.2461395561695099,
-0.4742683470249176,
0.200019970536232,
-0.459674209356308,
0.502144992351532,
-0.289255827665329,
0.5552067160606384,
-0.9537402987480164,
0.22802092134952545,
0.1394488364458084,
-0.10641307383775711,
0.2031632512807846,
-0.06633555889129639,
-0.5134868025779724,
-0.7235704660415649,
-0.1597939133644104,
0.6747212409973145,
0.6975104808807373,
-0.5778228640556335,
0.5447056889533997,
0.10461708158254623,
0.324476957321167,
-0.9271848201751709,
-0.526688814163208,
0.05591680482029915,
0.24540241062641144,
-0.7400791645050049,
0.5042440891265869,
-0.2593025267124176,
-0.15185008943080902,
-0.09653674066066742,
-0.548697292804718,
-0.0672714039683342,
-0.014108406379818916,
0.14549317955970764,
0.2414889931678772,
-0.14849814772605896,
-0.3837323486804962,
0.5313125848770142,
-0.34270069003105164,
0.1101822704076767,
-0.8269407749176025,
0.5219898819923401,
-0.10238789021968842,
-0.330554723739624,
-0.6478672623634338,
0.484103262424469,
0.6154093146324158,
-0.07635515928268433,
0.4027444124221802,
0.8273521661758423,
-0.3694518506526947,
-0.47180336713790894,
-0.9508330821990967,
-0.0782654732465744,
-0.5205124616622925,
0.33841729164123535,
-0.7712087631225586,
-1.0831371545791626,
0.8064270615577698,
-0.09400138258934021,
0.13038863241672516,
0.4588456451892853,
0.5847256183624268,
0.2636033594608307,
0.7990506887435913,
0.7845540046691895,
-0.05444205179810524,
0.2174995392560959,
-0.20489095151424408,
0.09942500293254852,
-0.7597379088401794,
-0.45074790716171265,
-0.7339354753494263,
-0.28268173336982727,
-0.17914004623889923,
-0.6207178831100464,
-0.05153689906001091,
0.048279065638780594,
-0.02854185737669468,
0.26329755783081055,
-0.3287661671638489,
0.8492721319198608,
0.09432888776063919,
0.20546340942382812,
0.5407420992851257,
0.0753290131688118,
-0.5315898656845093,
0.37598034739494324,
-0.7321820855140686,
0.02818525955080986,
0.9625552296638489,
0.4223821461200714,
0.6673468351364136,
-0.19785532355308533,
0.7936885356903076,
0.39568808674812317,
0.09404335916042328,
-0.5365535616874695,
0.7851765155792236,
0.013170885853469372,
-0.7181199193000793,
-0.2370000034570694,
-0.7547270655632019,
-0.552915632724762,
0.1584250032901764,
-0.19309602677822113,
-0.8958324193954468,
0.4235602021217346,
0.32503002882003784,
-0.1840970814228058,
0.5081838965415955,
-0.505426824092865,
0.4849752187728882,
0.18824979662895203,
-0.2812938094139099,
-0.5807176232337952,
-0.17263761162757874,
0.6643821001052856,
-0.02500111050903797,
-0.022439531981945038,
-0.24605686962604523,
-0.10622871667146683,
0.5388167500495911,
-0.5255295634269714,
0.24921734631061554,
-0.197986900806427,
-0.2830283045768738,
0.18583378195762634,
0.4098694324493408,
1.0684247016906738,
0.14459824562072754,
-0.345477432012558,
0.0771552175283432,
0.0653781145811081,
-0.570183515548706,
-0.3771168887615204,
0.6568584442138672,
-0.7097272276878357,
-0.66382896900177,
-0.1449376940727234,
-0.5519956946372986,
-0.14008361101150513,
0.346650093793869,
0.42438286542892456,
0.4469066560268402,
0.03688419237732887,
-0.14930467307567596,
0.46530982851982117,
0.2068127542734146,
0.42787808179855347,
0.4254685342311859,
-0.3058123290538788,
-0.0693635642528534,
0.8004146218299866,
-0.18446001410484314,
0.20170360803604126,
0.6715177893638611,
0.3597261905670166,
-0.4507749378681183,
-1.5159951448440552,
-0.4308868646621704,
0.035466279834508896,
-0.7750964164733887,
-0.21337993443012238,
-0.5531760454177856,
-0.17666852474212646,
-0.2705504298210144,
-0.07267654687166214,
-0.5309286713600159,
-0.6165974736213684,
0.24267607927322388,
-0.252947598695755,
0.3099631667137146,
0.5143749713897705,
-0.32235202193260193,
0.027249572798609734,
-0.5305472016334534,
0.442789226770401,
0.028632234781980515,
0.37072765827178955,
0.21380814909934998,
-0.8692451119422913,
-0.3288746774196625,
-0.24110469222068787,
0.12431518733501434,
-0.4695078134536743,
-0.16682057082653046,
-0.2853836715221405,
0.5698302984237671,
0.5972411036491394,
0.30661505460739136,
1.08576238155365,
-0.421904593706131,
0.5356866717338562,
0.12103968113660812,
-1.3236531019210815,
0.16426712274551392,
-0.27729329466819763,
0.2758474051952362,
0.4041607677936554,
-0.004322217311710119,
-0.43620064854621887,
-0.5595133900642395,
-0.2559308409690857,
-0.7965444326400757,
0.4500139057636261,
0.27579569816589355,
0.043652668595314026,
-0.011131919920444489,
0.5529484152793884,
0.19784845411777496,
-0.28473997116088867,
-0.22882400453090668,
-0.2150816023349762,
-0.16501742601394653,
0.27797731757164,
0.34222304821014404,
-0.468948632478714,
0.06022189185023308,
-0.1355239748954773,
0.6731008887290955,
0.008780277334153652,
0.3448854982852936,
0.30386924743652344,
0.01492356788367033,
-0.4925868809223175,
0.16890209913253784,
0.8569889068603516,
0.8599364757537842,
-0.3771999478340149,
0.3041541278362274,
0.3040408492088318,
-0.5490350127220154,
0.4228123426437378,
-0.07937438040971756,
-0.3027174472808838,
-0.009026329033076763,
0.47846856713294983,
0.9639008045196533,
-0.30633360147476196,
-0.5345590114593506,
0.48822280764579773,
-0.22620078921318054,
-0.48883509635925293,
0.16084150969982147,
-0.17022711038589478,
-0.08165624737739563,
0.3282063603401184,
0.5413285493850708,
0.38210850954055786,
0.030296092852950096,
0.022385289892554283,
0.05557536706328392,
0.3655056357383728,
0.19956646859645844,
-0.39887142181396484,
0.5451120734214783,
0.29941532015800476,
-0.2665317952632904,
0.5126799941062927,
-0.4300435185432434,
-0.30416882038116455,
0.49669405817985535,
0.8284609913825989,
1.0264555215835571,
0.09812866896390915,
0.08485148102045059,
0.3831499218940735,
0.6865034699440002,
-0.504766583442688,
0.5216841101646423,
-0.12067078053951263,
-0.8062918186187744,
-0.754915714263916,
-0.49418359994888306,
-0.30444058775901794,
-0.0645432323217392,
-0.383142352104187,
-0.008145108819007874,
-0.7432478666305542,
-0.26472723484039307,
-0.4205533266067505,
-0.05025222525000572,
-0.7304750084877014,
-0.15818805992603302,
0.3430444300174713,
1.4331179857254028,
-0.5676317811012268,
0.7313594818115234,
0.1291452795267105,
0.3772871196269989,
-0.8832105994224548,
0.10029372572898865,
-0.2732745409011841,
-0.9419287443161011,
0.5444278120994568,
-0.01983853057026863,
-0.4123953580856323,
0.10071264952421188,
-0.10618007928133011,
-0.8431808948516846,
0.9836236834526062,
0.4468010365962982,
-0.7816619277000427,
0.06519237160682678,
-0.27609798312187195,
0.33127307891845703,
-0.3516328036785126,
0.4108753502368927,
0.30195412039756775,
0.48785528540611267,
0.18290166556835175,
-0.7178782820701599,
0.6184518933296204,
-0.23008255660533905,
0.08164208382368088,
0.18481196463108063,
-0.569243311882019,
0.5434172749519348,
-0.394592821598053,
-0.40202200412750244,
0.39299532771110535,
0.9494126439094543,
0.18671782314777374,
0.08768899738788605,
0.6109576225280762,
0.3790121376514435,
1.13504958152771,
0.05889227241277695,
0.9766249656677246,
-0.5920262336730957,
0.11214162409305573,
0.5289061069488525,
-0.2755342721939087,
0.835358202457428,
0.4466426968574524,
-0.11917039006948471,
0.6082748770713806,
0.6976128816604614,
0.2262125164270401,
0.29231953620910645,
0.47899264097213745,
-0.24190421402454376,
-0.3674922585487366,
-0.2967902719974518,
-0.5242153406143188,
0.14857785403728485,
0.04252117499709129,
-0.06738670915365219,
-0.030425237491726875,
-0.30928149819374084,
-0.05575093999505043,
-0.1404651552438736,
-0.43090882897377014,
0.36535826325416565,
-0.2123846709728241,
-0.5635694265365601,
1.047153353691101,
0.4029715359210968,
0.5865253806114197,
-0.7198318243026733,
0.5034436583518982,
-0.3754179775714874,
0.08208193629980087,
-0.20622698962688446,
-0.37289074063301086,
0.13264699280261993,
-0.021441351622343063,
-0.19170457124710083,
-0.41355541348457336,
0.6605434417724609,
-0.1688118577003479,
-0.5982304811477661,
0.16965800523757935,
0.45083680748939514,
0.14152373373508453,
0.031956885010004044,
-0.19160178303718567,
0.7990782260894775,
-0.17289474606513977,
-0.25489482283592224,
0.06796320527791977,
0.5599805116653442,
-0.012054520659148693,
0.7192369103431702,
1.0492075681686401,
0.6013985872268677,
0.24703113734722137,
0.14348748326301575,
1.025669813156128,
-0.642251193523407,
-0.7905399799346924,
-1.0443772077560425,
0.3542685806751251,
-0.15221107006072998,
-0.24836167693138123,
0.5234507918357849,
0.5298374891281128,
0.6323358416557312,
0.03817398473620415,
0.6678643226623535,
0.10721803456544876,
-0.024965930730104446,
-0.879289984703064,
0.3053909242153168,
-0.22090372443199158,
0.4693964719772339,
-0.17718659341335297,
-0.821940004825592,
-0.1602575033903122,
0.3278888165950775,
-0.04670495539903641,
-0.2368704080581665,
1.1965245008468628,
1.0277715921401978,
0.007344591431319714,
0.1550358384847641,
0.2003496289253235,
0.20375624299049377,
0.30402904748916626,
0.9059919714927673,
1.0382187366485596,
-0.5311262011528015,
0.6282010674476624,
-0.3443886339664459,
-0.2535805404186249,
0.03649738058447838,
-1.2236205339431763,
-1.1130285263061523,
-0.25719937682151794,
-0.3246932327747345,
-0.6114657521247864,
0.3011351227760315,
0.9705654978752136,
1.0211979150772095,
-0.5047861933708191,
-0.44509202241897583,
-0.23764750361442566,
0.32194072008132935,
-0.6691397428512573,
-0.14734011888504028,
0.3468300402164459,
-0.15237732231616974,
-0.4447163939476013,
0.7903634905815125,
0.49260368943214417,
0.05758056417107582,
-0.24861115217208862,
-0.15290404856204987,
0.11897899210453033,
0.3464582860469818,
0.4862842857837677,
0.330727756023407,
-0.5992062091827393,
-0.13917598128318787,
0.12189356982707977,
0.0007417871966026723,
-0.12863270938396454,
1.4677022695541382,
-0.5748288631439209,
0.3115689158439636,
0.9472076296806335,
0.8873664140701294,
0.916654109954834,
0.09736428409814835,
0.5525374412536621,
-0.43563419580459595,
0.4245869517326355,
0.05773520842194557,
0.27891120314598083,
-0.1519891619682312,
-0.6752055883407593,
0.04528482258319855,
0.5075079798698425,
-0.29635003209114075,
-1.062955617904663,
0.19475094974040985,
-1.0627446174621582,
-0.19698546826839447,
0.9909222722053528,
-0.23757734894752502,
-0.2883532643318176,
-0.09959414601325989,
0.03926421329379082,
-0.22324784100055695,
-0.6794524192810059,
0.7410483360290527,
0.6046480536460876,
-0.05061079561710358,
-0.34729644656181335,
-0.022947920486330986,
0.45470917224884033,
0.17483322322368622,
-0.7000356316566467,
0.589852511882782,
0.128013476729393,
0.11336532235145569,
-0.12787310779094696,
1.1095514297485352,
-0.13941514492034912,
0.1814315915107727,
0.3496111333370209,
-0.34900394082069397,
-0.6493179798126221,
-0.40998250246047974,
-0.051589444279670715,
0.3099524974822998,
0.05302950739860535,
-0.09287973493337631
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10381v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10381v1
|
Monotonic Representation of Numeric Properties in Language Models
| 2024-03-15T15:10:41 | 2024-03-15T15:10:41 |
Benjamin Heinzerling, Kentaro Inui
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Language models (LMs) can express factual knowledge involving numeric
properties such as Karl Popper was born in 1902. However, how this information
is encoded in the model's internal representations is not understood well.
Here, we introduce a simple method for finding and editing representations of
numeric properties such as an entity's birth year. Empirically, we find
low-dimensional subspaces that encode numeric properties monotonically, in an
interpretable and editable fashion. When editing representations along
directions in these subspaces, LM output changes accordingly. For example, by
patching activations along a "birthyear" direction we can make the LM express
an increasingly late birthyear: Karl Popper was born in 1929, Karl Popper was
born in 1957, Karl Popper was born in 1968. Property-encoding directions exist
across several numeric properties in all models under consideration, suggesting
the possibility that monotonic representation of numeric properties
consistently emerges during LM pretraining. Code:
https://github.com/bheinzerling/numeric-property-repr
|
[
-0.5890244245529175,
-0.39240872859954834,
0.3873203992843628,
0.37789690494537354,
-0.04009567201137543,
0.0009283323888666928,
-0.3667311370372772,
-0.29361507296562195,
0.37562814354896545,
0.5258685946464539,
-0.5293911099433899,
-0.5177791118621826,
-0.4811067581176758,
-0.20875504612922668,
0.12806436419487,
1.059178352355957,
0.12728241086006165,
-0.19696511328220367,
-0.32430964708328247,
-0.3359299898147583,
-0.2167828381061554,
-1.0218876600265503,
-0.35299986600875854,
-0.2523306608200073,
0.44998711347579956,
0.43438592553138733,
1.0202397108078003,
0.8883482217788696,
0.1556558609008789,
0.30891454219818115,
-0.5027753710746765,
-0.24997645616531372,
-0.6418116688728333,
0.017146145924925804,
0.17275717854499817,
-0.2110501229763031,
-0.7335303425788879,
0.04203849285840988,
0.8931734561920166,
1.1956161260604858,
0.07281798869371414,
0.15518614649772644,
-0.033992525190114975,
0.8242000341415405,
-0.378097802400589,
0.174250990152359,
-0.6170273423194885,
0.2523331344127655,
-0.03647357597947121,
-0.507546603679657,
-0.6558220982551575,
-0.5472341179847717,
-0.004116502590477467,
-0.44727709889411926,
0.3200843036174774,
-0.4685378670692444,
0.7258273363113403,
0.19110755622386932,
-0.42233020067214966,
-0.26699674129486084,
-0.86748868227005,
0.8777555227279663,
-0.7773268222808838,
0.6141722202301025,
0.18237867951393127,
0.10314831137657166,
-0.09839198738336563,
-0.1677025854587555,
-0.13065049052238464,
-0.5300917029380798,
-0.39481109380722046,
-0.41797542572021484,
-0.059379942715168,
-0.11436986923217773,
0.4594959318637848,
0.39489614963531494,
-0.5706565976142883,
-0.0529308058321476,
-0.6545855402946472,
-0.27927592396736145,
0.7727534174919128,
-0.006811799481511116,
0.09608428925275803,
-0.31316831707954407,
-0.5912636518478394,
-0.16154290735721588,
-0.6420603394508362,
0.05970369651913643,
0.27404212951660156,
0.6146728992462158,
-0.25153663754463196,
0.6107826828956604,
0.019490569829940796,
0.7054427266120911,
-0.022776978090405464,
-0.36375170946121216,
0.4263288080692291,
-0.36769115924835205,
-0.02256886102259159,
0.29875701665878296,
0.4342272877693176,
-0.06218794360756874,
0.5272318124771118,
-0.03517177328467369,
-0.25552499294281006,
-0.1164044588804245,
0.18898208439350128,
-0.870585560798645,
-0.020077364519238472,
0.025228045880794525,
-0.4528263211250305,
-0.34377649426460266,
0.2658556401729584,
-0.6145098805427551,
-0.5301830768585205,
-0.4041352868080139,
0.13720765709877014,
-0.5358860492706299,
-0.0009073037654161453,
0.3578421473503113,
-0.06880433112382889,
-0.02618836797773838,
0.22058184444904327,
-0.8820850849151611,
0.3973301351070404,
0.4745124280452728,
0.5130353569984436,
0.36251726746559143,
-0.25512102246284485,
-0.2600523829460144,
-0.31325042247772217,
-0.4595840275287628,
0.3062191903591156,
-0.5191251039505005,
-0.3691696524620056,
-0.15306882560253143,
-0.3271805942058563,
0.3614654839038849,
-0.7594937086105347,
-0.061309799551963806,
-0.8412874937057495,
-0.11736675351858139,
0.22024066746234894,
-0.467138409614563,
0.2670683264732361,
-0.248139888048172,
-0.7271423935890198,
0.7339603900909424,
0.3730529844760895,
-0.6902147531509399,
0.611798107624054,
-0.6711658835411072,
-0.08911921083927155,
-0.048237916082143784,
-0.09814897179603577,
-0.477914422750473,
0.39155179262161255,
0.14448212087154388,
0.16245445609092712,
0.3030473291873932,
0.09677459299564362,
-0.32875770330429077,
-0.0630892813205719,
0.425728976726532,
-0.41125330328941345,
1.1162476539611816,
0.1594303697347641,
0.33943402767181396,
0.07885773479938507,
-1.3060566186904907,
0.04323732107877731,
0.2781630754470825,
-0.44713324308395386,
-0.4148465394973755,
-0.20556221902370453,
-0.1972193568944931,
0.11353020370006561,
0.886154294013977,
-0.32663068175315857,
0.6874546408653259,
-0.1950680911540985,
-0.0028062204364687204,
0.47299760580062866,
0.4587644338607788,
0.7511789202690125,
-0.2737400233745575,
0.6792519688606262,
0.4506676495075226,
0.024380002170801163,
-0.6290487051010132,
-0.34907329082489014,
-0.5870377421379089,
-0.1481219232082367,
0.23420295119285583,
0.32377323508262634,
-0.25326207280158997,
0.40872159600257874,
-0.37810736894607544,
-0.6095950603485107,
-0.5595056414604187,
0.5148464441299438,
0.1664147824048996,
0.2936132252216339,
0.48274120688438416,
-0.24891918897628784,
-0.7275647521018982,
-0.8938109278678894,
-0.27884024381637573,
-0.2631049156188965,
0.19955632090568542,
0.04341427609324455,
0.1332358717918396,
-0.061678942292928696,
1.1171766519546509,
-0.7595303058624268,
0.12387903034687042,
-0.007240411825478077,
0.7779175639152527,
0.42922523617744446,
0.7890313863754272,
0.66008061170578,
-0.47100114822387695,
-0.21981360018253326,
0.042856357991695404,
-0.5828338861465454,
-0.182876318693161,
-0.20646482706069946,
0.15489087998867035,
0.17174050211906433,
0.5214211344718933,
-0.3361462950706482,
0.7263414859771729,
0.28689590096473694,
-0.7297716736793518,
0.6156425476074219,
-0.7257882356643677,
-0.2519603967666626,
-0.5496236085891724,
-0.13305512070655823,
0.04399251192808151,
-0.4835250675678253,
-0.8597427010536194,
-0.07149607688188553,
0.16640295088291168,
-0.14501367509365082,
-0.46089738607406616,
0.37725919485092163,
-0.5596334934234619,
-0.044255178421735764,
-0.04388991370797157,
-0.24875150620937347,
-0.14447437226772308,
0.39559900760650635,
0.08527249842882156,
0.7622973322868347,
0.3604339063167572,
-0.6257638931274414,
-0.09947367012500763,
0.1428970992565155,
-0.2896873354911804,
0.4722186326980591,
-0.3762577474117279,
0.45109906792640686,
-0.6404999494552612,
-0.08110833913087845,
-0.7504249811172485,
0.19291843473911285,
-0.01731577329337597,
-0.4807210862636566,
0.29692599177360535,
-0.6106168031692505,
-0.4038117527961731,
-0.08574852347373962,
-0.2156372368335724,
0.5629759430885315,
0.5715397596359253,
-0.3587131202220917,
0.3815903961658478,
0.25170499086380005,
-0.4111894369125366,
-0.4560503661632538,
-0.5519867539405823,
-0.19760578870773315,
-0.3363628685474396,
-0.7276894450187683,
0.27356821298599243,
-0.1984771341085434,
-0.3296799957752228,
0.07188320904970169,
-0.031634051352739334,
-0.4673687517642975,
0.02185262180864811,
0.0022505302913486958,
0.47763222455978394,
-0.6826855540275574,
0.013972669839859009,
-0.09293363988399506,
-0.43469637632369995,
0.06258204579353333,
-0.24737973511219025,
0.5696070790290833,
-0.2299201786518097,
-0.2585766911506653,
0.03357745707035065,
0.06128017231822014,
0.8516862988471985,
-0.24856822192668915,
0.9207414388656616,
0.1192055195569992,
-0.49727556109428406,
-0.4404650628566742,
-0.21741564571857452,
-0.2511499524116516,
-0.42100411653518677,
0.15623947978019714,
-0.3515664339065552,
-0.7550173997879028,
0.8040199279785156,
0.13127675652503967,
-0.24204620718955994,
0.36681392788887024,
0.4018644392490387,
0.18119879066944122,
0.9225078225135803,
0.5703564882278442,
0.09549824148416519,
0.4421710968017578,
-0.3167475461959839,
0.2409178465604782,
-0.6560646891593933,
-0.16235916316509247,
-0.41954293847084045,
-0.31412336230278015,
-0.7927436828613281,
-0.5134641528129578,
0.5931843519210815,
0.257365345954895,
-0.46357014775276184,
0.4304628074169159,
-0.3527693748474121,
0.4583391547203064,
0.4172987639904022,
0.04319005832076073,
0.5518722534179688,
-0.18337851762771606,
0.019341321662068367,
-0.562785804271698,
-0.7386890053749084,
-0.6734208464622498,
0.9325075149536133,
0.5635365843772888,
0.9605733156204224,
-0.017379097640514374,
0.875237762928009,
0.10910151898860931,
0.5316099524497986,
-0.506870687007904,
0.5320996046066284,
-0.10648293793201447,
-0.7522180080413818,
-0.37930718064308167,
-0.6325652003288269,
-0.7096043825149536,
0.055021271109580994,
-0.23780076205730438,
-0.8656246662139893,
0.7449104189872742,
0.4577781558036804,
-0.43844476342201233,
0.2403980940580368,
-0.510749876499176,
1.100957989692688,
-0.4515136778354645,
-0.36930879950523376,
0.007454036734998226,
-0.5100565552711487,
0.26666659116744995,
-0.07168405503034592,
0.3343171179294586,
-0.07996669411659241,
-0.040910203009843826,
0.39747220277786255,
-0.7988643050193787,
0.8164574503898621,
-0.5414546132087708,
-0.14729022979736328,
0.1701519936323166,
0.568942666053772,
0.26524004340171814,
0.23967385292053223,
-0.09847234189510345,
-0.11133338510990143,
0.15878556668758392,
-0.546428382396698,
-0.7947214841842651,
0.7283151149749756,
-0.7380861639976501,
-0.3140152394771576,
-0.5611839890480042,
-0.6088773012161255,
-0.12132390588521957,
0.24059249460697174,
-0.06712882220745087,
0.6603309512138367,
-0.30497679114341736,
0.13393570482730865,
0.41730359196662903,
-0.2614000141620636,
0.1437649428844452,
0.4466032087802887,
-0.8720512986183167,
-0.20191936194896698,
0.9441382884979248,
0.5826653242111206,
0.2373991161584854,
0.2300700545310974,
0.28229275345802307,
-0.19583512842655182,
-0.11257262527942657,
-0.30165788531303406,
0.3730710744857788,
-0.9648572206497192,
0.01633799821138382,
-0.309926301240921,
-0.38010290265083313,
-0.14778843522071838,
-0.2583329677581787,
-0.54572993516922,
-0.729984700679779,
-0.3079405426979065,
-0.06620924174785614,
0.3030174672603607,
0.9708254337310791,
-0.3822469711303711,
0.10678360611200333,
-0.6949189901351929,
0.2986995279788971,
0.48250290751457214,
0.4716321527957916,
0.03208030387759209,
-0.6696366667747498,
-0.3724924325942993,
0.023489367216825485,
-0.03568696603178978,
-1.0873063802719116,
0.3724246621131897,
0.05795656889677048,
0.07910413295030594,
0.7010478377342224,
-0.19663700461387634,
0.8449900150299072,
-0.2479795664548874,
0.6876117587089539,
-0.12552563846111298,
-1.1284382343292236,
0.5119668841362,
-0.21435832977294922,
0.6450685858726501,
0.6990686058998108,
0.34980565309524536,
-0.4850512444972992,
-0.12326526641845703,
-0.8149281740188599,
-0.7596439123153687,
0.6715990900993347,
-0.11871162056922913,
0.4144572913646698,
0.21236057579517365,
0.23301276564598083,
0.3651898205280304,
0.2701372504234314,
-0.8843668103218079,
-0.5436066389083862,
-0.24734769761562347,
-0.007882388308644295,
-0.008698866702616215,
-0.4329988658428192,
0.1313888132572174,
-0.6852147579193115,
0.5326024293899536,
0.07597582787275314,
0.23378679156303406,
0.1449146568775177,
-0.17088302969932556,
-0.09450963884592056,
0.5466957092285156,
0.8711501955986023,
1.0634499788284302,
-0.6528018116950989,
0.5938528180122375,
0.2781509757041931,
-0.03322664275765419,
0.4270993173122406,
0.08114810287952423,
-0.2189638316631317,
0.25192055106163025,
0.6082813143730164,
0.8962408900260925,
0.7945501804351807,
-0.38250860571861267,
0.4086218774318695,
0.3592688739299774,
0.12739111483097076,
-0.5375362634658813,
0.06143000349402428,
0.0765131264925003,
-0.258308082818985,
0.4408179819583893,
0.030959386378526688,
-0.3111719489097595,
-0.6580348610877991,
0.27710622549057007,
0.2199344038963318,
-0.591290295124054,
-0.5973652601242065,
0.5307921171188354,
-0.5292325615882874,
-0.29320603609085083,
0.44027259945869446,
-0.4916335940361023,
-0.32528814673423767,
0.4356956481933594,
0.6852548122406006,
0.6250779032707214,
-0.336914598941803,
0.3343152403831482,
0.4913772642612457,
0.33639654517173767,
0.3463880121707916,
0.2793411612510681,
0.08241105079650879,
-1.0348867177963257,
-0.2975704073905945,
-0.564801812171936,
-0.1920483559370041,
0.2617971897125244,
-0.6967737674713135,
0.48695462942123413,
-0.5524867177009583,
-0.34900951385498047,
0.2355082929134369,
-0.42353445291519165,
-0.9587656855583191,
0.1074301227927208,
0.5591232180595398,
1.1521084308624268,
-0.8686116337776184,
0.5320683121681213,
0.9679937362670898,
-0.5592633485794067,
-0.524391770362854,
-0.3590937852859497,
0.023211095482110977,
-0.6747267246246338,
0.9335039854049683,
-0.35374757647514343,
-0.049032922834157944,
0.05190115049481392,
-0.7088984251022339,
-0.808278501033783,
0.6945032477378845,
0.4597955644130707,
-0.37960246205329895,
-0.11029345542192459,
0.5095112323760986,
0.8094791173934937,
-0.5608837008476257,
0.06453453749418259,
0.5010537505149841,
0.7491068243980408,
-0.014979925006628036,
-0.6537278294563293,
-0.25978854298591614,
-0.24200473725795746,
0.15407933294773102,
0.11107804626226425,
-0.21215102076530457,
1.0520031452178955,
-0.3261163532733917,
-0.29244205355644226,
-0.2521519660949707,
0.6959658265113831,
0.3300796449184418,
0.30582723021507263,
0.41655176877975464,
0.7327763438224792,
0.7145114541053772,
0.04960571601986885,
1.0205265283584595,
-0.8909956812858582,
0.5206927061080933,
0.796772301197052,
0.09406204521656036,
0.644207775592804,
0.5397179126739502,
-0.2409113496541977,
0.6095525622367859,
0.09020213782787323,
0.2652159035205841,
0.3136684000492096,
0.4428279995918274,
-0.28330737352371216,
-0.03131737932562828,
0.18867923319339752,
-0.278548926115036,
0.32762253284454346,
0.06203931197524071,
-0.5043624639511108,
-0.2498517632484436,
-0.14608435332775116,
0.6763026714324951,
0.1497359722852707,
-0.28688448667526245,
0.8486646413803101,
0.2137504667043686,
-0.5274085402488708,
0.9035061597824097,
-0.07184270024299622,
0.2923874855041504,
-0.6487730741500854,
-0.01614495925605297,
-0.2455543875694275,
0.03979670628905296,
-0.20966005325317383,
-0.7879124879837036,
0.348947137594223,
0.056142594665288925,
-0.42056939005851746,
-0.514748752117157,
0.7624092698097229,
-0.7662529349327087,
-0.7771963477134705,
0.26333969831466675,
0.5924900770187378,
-0.06391937285661697,
0.2218191772699356,
-0.2987915873527527,
0.3372565805912018,
-0.2319881021976471,
-0.19818513095378876,
-0.036828119307756424,
0.6760008335113525,
0.015150713734328747,
0.4556068181991577,
0.49179619550704956,
0.607781708240509,
0.33747562766075134,
-0.058771684765815735,
0.8019841313362122,
-0.9451798796653748,
-0.5456893444061279,
-0.8016300797462463,
0.7981989979743958,
0.06951258331537247,
-0.4759540855884552,
0.48854872584342957,
0.6571203470230103,
0.819102942943573,
-0.3910750150680542,
0.7894889712333679,
0.06772954761981964,
0.3454025983810425,
-0.39946937561035156,
0.6354294419288635,
-0.34020090103149414,
0.2301451712846756,
0.024468345567584038,
-1.0828107595443726,
-0.37693509459495544,
0.7314663529396057,
-0.6169294118881226,
0.12322483956813812,
0.46345964074134827,
0.8538210988044739,
-0.27485325932502747,
-0.18946729600429535,
0.26656344532966614,
0.44980964064598083,
-0.05908092111349106,
0.14909584820270538,
0.9249794483184814,
-0.08637016266584396,
-0.1866919845342636,
-0.5998106002807617,
-0.2967506945133209,
-0.36014288663864136,
-1.1396825313568115,
-0.5476409196853638,
-0.6676352024078369,
-0.2844613194465637,
-0.2187061309814453,
-0.09020625054836273,
1.324324131011963,
0.7714892029762268,
-0.9442405104637146,
-0.4851877987384796,
0.2752033770084381,
0.18288744986057281,
-0.16943423449993134,
-0.26831796765327454,
-0.008140940219163895,
-0.2840944230556488,
-0.3039093315601349,
0.47145646810531616,
0.35036131739616394,
0.24849890172481537,
-0.6459217071533203,
-0.18764349818229675,
0.0990895926952362,
0.2655051052570343,
0.3856965899467468,
0.4579735994338989,
-0.29498371481895447,
-0.42653700709342957,
-0.13989730179309845,
-0.2373250275850296,
0.7356635332107544,
1.1356351375579834,
-0.8286026120185852,
0.695290207862854,
0.7027503848075867,
0.22152955830097198,
0.5761871337890625,
0.34240397810935974,
0.4219300150871277,
-0.9413679242134094,
0.38618791103363037,
0.38224121928215027,
0.36716634035110474,
0.525111973285675,
-0.2010919451713562,
0.0609046071767807,
0.20610520243644714,
-0.306876003742218,
-0.882804811000824,
0.14612700045108795,
-1.0221798419952393,
0.01934196613729,
0.5784270763397217,
0.24606426060199738,
-0.12195973843336105,
0.04116000235080719,
-0.16611748933792114,
-0.028488410636782646,
-0.24390560388565063,
0.6921494007110596,
0.7004749774932861,
-0.039293695241212845,
-0.4127601683139801,
-0.4420436918735504,
0.4612814486026764,
0.23678037524223328,
-0.562298595905304,
0.1447913646697998,
0.27188825607299805,
0.10040987282991409,
0.5722879767417908,
0.6341084837913513,
-0.4437771439552307,
0.09013678878545761,
-0.0063584474846720695,
0.38294821977615356,
-0.12484601140022278,
-0.42384737730026245,
-0.5318276286125183,
0.24304993450641632,
0.5128425359725952,
0.35146352648735046
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10378v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10378v1
|
EXAMS-V: A Multi-Discipline Multilingual Multimodal Exam Benchmark for Evaluating Vision Language Models
| 2024-03-15T15:08:39 | 2024-03-15T15:08:39 |
Rocktim Jyoti Das, Simeon Emilov Hristov, Haonan Li, Dimitar Iliyanov Dimitrov, Ivan Koychev, Preslav Nakov
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
We introduce EXAMS-V, a new challenging multi-discipline multimodal
multilingual exam benchmark for evaluating vision language models. It consists
of 20,932 multiple-choice questions across 20 school disciplines covering
natural science, social science, and other miscellaneous studies, e.g.,
religion, fine arts, business, etc. EXAMS-V includes a variety of multimodal
features such as text, images, tables, figures, diagrams, maps, scientific
symbols, and equations. The questions come in 11 languages from 7 language
families. Unlike existing benchmarks, EXAMS-V is uniquely curated by gathering
school exam questions from various countries, with a variety of education
systems. This distinctive approach calls for intricate reasoning across diverse
languages and relies on region-specific knowledge. Solving the problems in the
dataset requires advanced perception and joint reasoning over the text and the
visual content of the image. Our evaluation results demonstrate that this is a
challenging dataset, which is difficult even for advanced vision-text models
such as GPT-4V and Gemini; this underscores the inherent complexity of the
dataset and its significance as a future benchmark.
|
[
-0.37852826714515686,
-0.5312995314598083,
0.5019657611846924,
0.2016306072473526,
-0.2511521279811859,
0.030589986592531204,
-0.08194119483232498,
-0.5371283292770386,
-0.12247958034276962,
0.5198784470558167,
-0.5815127491950989,
-0.41356074810028076,
-0.22311976552009583,
0.2024654746055603,
-0.30041247606277466,
0.5218392610549927,
-0.2425735741853714,
0.41959312558174133,
-0.677043080329895,
-0.4529520273208618,
-0.19307059049606323,
-0.4041166305541992,
-0.27827829122543335,
0.10974475741386414,
0.38962870836257935,
0.03284820169210434,
0.11922116577625275,
0.5466642379760742,
1.0403492450714111,
0.34375977516174316,
0.02279578521847725,
0.2728729248046875,
-0.13811016082763672,
0.023512814193964005,
-0.2436465471982956,
-0.39807939529418945,
-0.25477251410484314,
-0.034690387547016144,
0.7224720120429993,
0.7384887933731079,
0.06425291299819946,
0.3853536546230316,
-0.17844988405704498,
0.5451722741127014,
-0.8341206908226013,
0.19005008041858673,
-0.5008671283721924,
-0.23676639795303345,
-0.3326292634010315,
-0.07495568692684174,
-0.31529128551483154,
-0.24952156841754913,
0.3159903287887573,
-0.4539649486541748,
-0.0660044327378273,
-0.20014917850494385,
1.2797719240188599,
0.135268896818161,
-0.9541429877281189,
0.06537393480539322,
-0.31603509187698364,
0.8319393396377563,
0.12907683849334717,
0.8344867825508118,
0.02021906152367592,
0.5853886604309082,
0.41239240765571594,
-0.7605589628219604,
-0.44862499833106995,
-0.051104553043842316,
0.4237860143184662,
0.5068099498748779,
-0.013132793828845024,
-0.0015315748751163483,
-0.02261613868176937,
0.32116368412971497,
-0.5981321334838867,
-0.16144788265228271,
-0.898914098739624,
-0.2297716736793518,
0.5892425179481506,
0.4313889443874359,
0.18811744451522827,
-0.12610800564289093,
-0.6704198122024536,
-0.5489559769630432,
-0.5029944777488708,
0.25927698612213135,
0.43523460626602173,
-0.07429772615432739,
0.057291191071271896,
0.4282854497432709,
-0.511093258857727,
1.0077978372573853,
-0.6311395168304443,
0.03834689036011696,
0.5769275426864624,
-0.8390274047851562,
-0.1365908533334732,
-0.479160875082016,
0.7710138559341431,
0.8093313574790955,
0.2995171546936035,
0.30617475509643555,
-0.04794435575604439,
0.4154241383075714,
0.20751126110553741,
-0.6021397113800049,
-0.2688787877559662,
0.09238902479410172,
-0.12957096099853516,
-0.12434898316860199,
-0.14935632050037384,
-1.0336964130401611,
-0.24734996259212494,
-0.4056605100631714,
0.6340608596801758,
-0.40660789608955383,
-0.16687791049480438,
0.3713378310203552,
-0.33680394291877747,
0.713848352432251,
0.6973646283149719,
-0.4947771430015564,
0.19020600616931915,
0.5716469287872314,
0.38827669620513916,
-0.25265228748321533,
-0.6786423921585083,
-0.3495450019836426,
-0.4267389178276062,
-0.45021021366119385,
0.9450550675392151,
-0.8524425625801086,
-0.2617749869823456,
-0.19302701950073242,
-0.05163371190428734,
-0.18300332129001617,
-0.4047999978065491,
0.27161547541618347,
-0.3039197623729706,
0.1337887942790985,
-0.5014768242835999,
-0.2874332070350647,
-0.4405099153518677,
0.7592691779136658,
-0.6146377921104431,
1.07514488697052,
0.1285368800163269,
-0.3454766571521759,
0.5205292701721191,
-0.19223181903362274,
-0.038307469338178635,
0.3104996681213379,
-0.6844468712806702,
-0.22373168170452118,
-0.06252309679985046,
0.2528039515018463,
0.21298424899578094,
-0.6077059507369995,
0.10095228999853134,
-0.2866244614124298,
-0.21298928558826447,
0.0585295706987381,
-0.5858584642410278,
0.8655520677566528,
0.10995859652757645,
-0.08815693110227585,
-0.0095448549836874,
-0.9074885845184326,
0.5008160471916199,
0.09541090577840805,
-0.18048809468746185,
-0.5815450549125671,
0.016813170164823532,
0.17353655397891998,
0.27686017751693726,
0.41768813133239746,
-0.5107589960098267,
0.38021472096443176,
-0.049773018807172775,
0.18984556198120117,
0.6169650554656982,
-0.01638198457658291,
-0.03185826539993286,
-0.04933277890086174,
0.6148800849914551,
0.33474352955818176,
0.5773220658302307,
-0.3729763627052307,
-0.8137183785438538,
-0.7093967795372009,
-0.10074956715106964,
0.23783643543720245,
0.7878665328025818,
-1.0042294263839722,
-0.4412984848022461,
-0.3387046754360199,
-0.9728952646255493,
-0.6768116354942322,
0.09693306684494019,
0.8403306603431702,
0.36372673511505127,
0.19565629959106445,
-0.5912929177284241,
-0.2721412181854248,
-1.0229061841964722,
-0.3329065144062042,
-0.3541112542152405,
0.49087297916412354,
0.41375258564949036,
1.0029301643371582,
-0.08908872306346893,
0.44006791710853577,
-0.5115618705749512,
-0.1223241463303566,
0.03400126099586487,
0.020010896027088165,
-0.12159962207078934,
0.15043306350708008,
0.6755110025405884,
-1.166225552558899,
-0.39411661028862,
0.11953098326921463,
-0.6855424642562866,
-0.05603468418121338,
-0.013421539217233658,
0.011800003238022327,
0.006376086268573999,
0.44742730259895325,
-0.054168716073036194,
0.17882034182548523,
0.7261912226676941,
-0.4638195037841797,
0.7575022578239441,
-0.28923457860946655,
0.5626033544540405,
-0.8121917247772217,
-0.1908886730670929,
0.24726168811321259,
0.16845466196537018,
-0.36200398206710815,
0.5521897077560425,
0.4654310643672943,
-0.02554599568247795,
-0.8242117762565613,
0.6917892694473267,
-0.5060492753982544,
-0.07269367575645447,
0.39377811551094055,
0.10594012588262558,
0.19521978497505188,
0.34766313433647156,
0.05288280174136162,
0.8679985404014587,
0.8605554103851318,
-0.4451887905597687,
0.6195904612541199,
0.19345355033874512,
-0.6128402948379517,
1.0381325483322144,
-0.4518168568611145,
-0.1216360554099083,
-0.12413372844457626,
-0.17694804072380066,
-0.8310739398002625,
-0.04498251900076866,
-0.12172827869653702,
-0.33697274327278137,
-0.19931918382644653,
0.1085025817155838,
-0.22088970243930817,
-0.4027608335018158,
-0.2252793312072754,
0.6906684637069702,
0.2880604863166809,
-0.5113545060157776,
0.5171458721160889,
0.2535695731639862,
0.21267540752887726,
-0.8050096035003662,
-0.5510433912277222,
0.04406644403934479,
-0.03239619359374046,
-0.7199993133544922,
0.11803802102804184,
-0.3240900933742523,
-0.48921358585357666,
0.0691143125295639,
-0.07309433817863464,
-0.4703039526939392,
0.06382721662521362,
-0.0843261331319809,
0.3643741011619568,
-0.42266663908958435,
-0.10002131760120392,
-0.22403879463672638,
0.03418440371751785,
0.07762297987937927,
-0.056154247373342514,
0.24036096036434174,
-0.6632979512214661,
-0.5040658116340637,
-0.14446845650672913,
0.38117504119873047,
0.9285136461257935,
-0.7667679190635681,
0.05474293231964111,
0.3758537173271179,
-0.42169085144996643,
-0.13201867043972015,
-0.5417143106460571,
-0.009252557530999184,
-0.47859105467796326,
0.7207313179969788,
-0.7682307958602905,
-0.5468826293945312,
0.4096589982509613,
0.012103159911930561,
0.026556378230452538,
0.33598804473876953,
0.5237061977386475,
0.1966148316860199,
0.9078678488731384,
0.3981861472129822,
0.23572133481502533,
0.2867923080921173,
-0.18915440142154694,
-0.0564572848379612,
-0.5584350824356079,
-0.37584787607192993,
-0.4453986883163452,
0.05098266154527664,
-0.5862097144126892,
-0.6241035461425781,
0.4892004430294037,
-0.2736241817474365,
0.07838920503854752,
0.2795371115207672,
-0.5081802010536194,
0.651691198348999,
0.7199538350105286,
0.023017875850200653,
0.2719328999519348,
-0.1586465835571289,
-0.16807569563388824,
-0.32814475893974304,
-0.3016894459724426,
-0.26176875829696655,
1.3403902053833008,
-0.09481360018253326,
0.5435240268707275,
0.03538134694099426,
0.49906229972839355,
-0.2458212524652481,
0.12165622413158417,
-0.6974837183952332,
0.6888185143470764,
-0.38847002387046814,
-1.026065468788147,
-0.02885124459862709,
-0.32717764377593994,
-0.7458463311195374,
0.8512415289878845,
-0.14742082357406616,
-0.7667827010154724,
0.21453483402729034,
-0.03736009821295738,
-0.23320907354354858,
0.24413061141967773,
-0.8917214870452881,
1.1145442724227905,
-0.4644748866558075,
-0.5397830605506897,
-0.016757672652602196,
-0.6224163174629211,
0.536305844783783,
-0.17601945996284485,
0.27543067932128906,
0.06733144074678421,
-0.12427905946969986,
0.7665762901306152,
-0.03963631018996239,
0.6045897006988525,
0.18560153245925903,
0.19548097252845764,
0.3433983325958252,
-0.15172383189201355,
0.0020441077649593353,
-0.06411465257406235,
0.0009911321103572845,
0.08393342792987823,
0.5404160022735596,
-0.42066532373428345,
-0.45102325081825256,
0.4530352056026459,
-0.816490650177002,
-0.4439498484134674,
-0.7623094320297241,
-0.28660568594932556,
-0.2912429869174957,
0.31339114904403687,
0.15416055917739868,
0.8590055704116821,
-0.1911192387342453,
0.25736501812934875,
0.620204746723175,
-0.4178323745727539,
0.03272319585084915,
0.6265138983726501,
-0.30408775806427,
-0.5048105716705322,
1.3365498781204224,
0.3293300271034241,
0.4677859842777252,
0.37884199619293213,
0.0509016290307045,
-0.27662110328674316,
-0.46629902720451355,
-0.6300431489944458,
0.28971952199935913,
-1.1371140480041504,
0.07131040841341019,
-0.578143835067749,
-0.2568695545196533,
-0.21301932632923126,
-0.06926591694355011,
-0.6868461966514587,
0.11021500825881958,
0.14851772785186768,
0.1422697752714157,
0.15720635652542114,
0.6083710789680481,
0.21086490154266357,
0.006279123015701771,
-0.6695021390914917,
0.42064371705055237,
0.4707775115966797,
0.45640742778778076,
-0.6496729850769043,
-0.034060411155223846,
0.207154780626297,
-0.24831722676753998,
-0.4162667691707611,
-0.9693136811256409,
0.11476694047451019,
0.27460888028144836,
0.4984852373600006,
0.3279522657394409,
-0.2270837128162384,
0.8006321787834167,
-0.5591239929199219,
0.9996258020401001,
0.13834244012832642,
-0.8444751501083374,
0.31651538610458374,
-0.34206801652908325,
0.31411394476890564,
0.8513060808181763,
0.28129181265830994,
-0.481289267539978,
-0.26301053166389465,
-0.4641200602054596,
-0.8398865461349487,
0.43320295214653015,
-0.04500308260321617,
0.16714748740196228,
0.16250920295715332,
0.11141553521156311,
0.09655225276947021,
0.2944453954696655,
-0.7258195877075195,
-0.3554498255252838,
-0.12999200820922852,
-0.23773670196533203,
-0.08682873100042343,
-0.11567734181880951,
-0.011741014197468758,
-0.5576188564300537,
0.2665988504886627,
-0.13929039239883423,
0.033574290573596954,
0.14293597638607025,
0.1306706964969635,
0.24266238510608673,
0.3204449415206909,
0.6957932710647583,
0.7120314836502075,
-0.14417122304439545,
0.14846503734588623,
0.17752666771411896,
-0.8444663286209106,
0.04262121021747589,
0.14099639654159546,
-0.1465947926044464,
-0.08179870247840881,
0.2838711440563202,
0.6594993472099304,
0.09647756814956665,
-0.9934543371200562,
0.7596471905708313,
-0.30481696128845215,
-0.6697735786437988,
-0.3721613585948944,
-0.08346425741910934,
-0.13979971408843994,
0.1994183510541916,
0.2607627511024475,
0.048312872648239136,
0.2397068738937378,
-0.4712226688861847,
0.24574211239814758,
0.15081852674484253,
-0.6922188997268677,
-0.2639257609844208,
0.7153330445289612,
0.26118022203445435,
0.047067198902368546,
0.5418090224266052,
-0.2813670337200165,
-0.6448841094970703,
0.8544089794158936,
0.09742578864097595,
0.4153001308441162,
-0.2017407864332199,
0.29678624868392944,
0.40642398595809937,
0.821411669254303,
-0.09934978187084198,
1.1113150119781494,
0.15068697929382324,
-0.6269012689590454,
-0.2742545008659363,
-0.4896737039089203,
-0.8074060678482056,
0.2762044668197632,
-0.6207804679870605,
0.41824907064437866,
-0.1967010796070099,
0.09302055090665817,
0.10617797821760178,
-0.05839787796139717,
-0.8075255751609802,
0.7117249965667725,
0.16713681817054749,
0.9643359780311584,
-1.000841736793518,
0.6336206197738647,
1.0779563188552856,
-0.4364694356918335,
-0.48208704590797424,
-0.3953339755535126,
0.16950726509094238,
-0.7838315367698669,
0.6973010301589966,
0.38522979617118835,
-0.05945572257041931,
-0.12259382754564285,
-0.3733671307563782,
-0.8283299207687378,
0.8438197374343872,
0.3484249711036682,
-0.5336422324180603,
0.1954869031906128,
0.04349765181541443,
0.5942471027374268,
-0.08460071682929993,
0.32618072628974915,
0.26525989174842834,
0.566724956035614,
-0.31242623925209045,
-0.90278160572052,
-0.38371381163597107,
-0.7690259218215942,
-0.24823340773582458,
0.36117231845855713,
-0.813187837600708,
1.190112829208374,
-0.09446652978658676,
-0.07459792494773865,
-0.049772609025239944,
0.50079345703125,
0.40479740500450134,
0.4595722556114197,
0.5788125991821289,
0.4878186583518982,
0.4683602452278137,
-0.4668678045272827,
1.1312906742095947,
-0.3377809226512909,
0.2559466063976288,
0.7294977903366089,
-0.41363486647605896,
0.8662989139556885,
0.8075846433639526,
-0.12993621826171875,
0.19767756760120392,
0.7174685001373291,
-0.2559382915496826,
0.4369293749332428,
0.1728600710630417,
-0.019994832575321198,
-0.7127949595451355,
-0.13529659807682037,
-0.500638484954834,
0.8438428640365601,
0.38845035433769226,
0.0635032057762146,
-0.30188098549842834,
0.11675789952278137,
-0.4298973083496094,
0.1776534616947174,
-0.25970152020454407,
0.29196590185165405,
-0.006912974640727043,
-0.906673789024353,
0.29784154891967773,
-0.15449801087379456,
0.3872889578342438,
-0.6701486706733704,
-0.03542318567633629,
0.0103902667760849,
0.3981969952583313,
0.2663590908050537,
-0.8915920257568359,
0.11615460366010666,
-0.1163649708032608,
0.33673733472824097,
-0.3621864318847656,
0.28794845938682556,
-0.37760409712791443,
-0.7019122838973999,
0.4231233596801758,
0.7091436982154846,
0.34331944584846497,
-0.009347313083708286,
-0.7474414706230164,
0.15237021446228027,
-0.1256258487701416,
-0.39695218205451965,
0.06551224738359451,
0.43353527784347534,
-0.26559770107269287,
0.7746566534042358,
0.3058720827102661,
0.04579641669988632,
0.23171120882034302,
-0.014376995153725147,
0.6847850680351257,
-0.5001745820045471,
-0.4760800004005432,
-0.6178603172302246,
0.5887207984924316,
0.010908009484410286,
-1.0030300617218018,
0.7619926333427429,
0.6395580172538757,
1.287207007408142,
-0.11621637642383575,
0.7864623069763184,
0.26269200444221497,
0.003550516441464424,
-0.4481801390647888,
0.4643752872943878,
-1.3600720167160034,
-0.19400383532047272,
-0.4799610376358032,
-0.5260348320007324,
-0.33085882663726807,
0.32441389560699463,
-0.3800957202911377,
0.12181392312049866,
1.0197826623916626,
0.5430691242218018,
0.008105836808681488,
-0.058805353939533234,
0.4619289040565491,
-0.2687062621116638,
0.09989462792873383,
0.796113908290863,
0.8855254650115967,
-0.7685550451278687,
0.8683222532272339,
-0.4713341295719147,
-0.1756156086921692,
-0.006203836295753717,
-0.5207009315490723,
-0.881499171257019,
-1.1997419595718384,
-0.6233623027801514,
-0.22292600572109222,
0.06966545432806015,
0.4732666313648224,
0.4204825758934021,
-0.4921634793281555,
-0.2067379206418991,
0.21971890330314636,
-0.08652883768081665,
-0.5707430243492126,
-0.16485099494457245,
0.23697040975093842,
0.0695769190788269,
-0.8363061547279358,
0.2797069847583771,
0.45291492342948914,
-0.02341882698237896,
-0.5179648995399475,
0.2151145339012146,
-0.1475449800491333,
0.10605713725090027,
0.5039227604866028,
0.03536703810095787,
-0.7040569186210632,
-0.20919670164585114,
0.45364877581596375,
-0.3618733286857605,
0.08509312570095062,
0.47764500975608826,
-0.4768582582473755,
0.975453794002533,
0.7837284803390503,
0.6541978120803833,
0.3096596598625183,
-0.41828176379203796,
0.357584685087204,
-0.3046649694442749,
-0.014739619567990303,
0.1309196949005127,
0.5847174525260925,
0.23628830909729004,
0.06163365766406059,
0.48795920610427856,
0.489551305770874,
-0.24691589176654816,
-1.060641884803772,
0.3664725720882416,
-1.2207962274551392,
-0.2768009305000305,
1.0871708393096924,
-0.003375893458724022,
-0.6584962606430054,
-0.05935431271791458,
-0.13350947201251984,
-0.21332818269729614,
0.0819525346159935,
0.5382933616638184,
0.9210582375526428,
0.2541581392288208,
-0.35046547651290894,
-0.8835926055908203,
0.15738797187805176,
0.5972946286201477,
-0.9343594312667847,
-0.22417722642421722,
0.40809422731399536,
0.22029109299182892,
0.2098948359489441,
0.7751915454864502,
-0.34352630376815796,
0.6680004596710205,
0.3024727702140808,
0.2740423381328583,
0.04743752256035805,
-0.608947217464447,
-0.3432050943374634,
0.3031892776489258,
-0.29521051049232483,
-0.287789523601532
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10351v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10351v1
|
TriSum: Learning Summarization Ability from Large Language Models with Structured Rationale
| 2024-03-15T14:36:38 | 2024-03-15T14:36:38 |
Pengcheng Jiang, Cao Xiao, Zifeng Wang, Parminder Bhatia, Jimeng Sun, Jiawei Han
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The advent of large language models (LLMs) has significantly advanced natural
language processing tasks like text summarization. However, their large size
and computational demands, coupled with privacy concerns in data transmission,
limit their use in resource-constrained and privacy-centric settings. To
overcome this, we introduce TriSum, a framework for distilling LLMs' text
summarization abilities into a compact, local model. Initially, LLMs extract a
set of aspect-triple rationales and summaries, which are refined using a
dual-scoring method for quality. Next, a smaller local model is trained with
these tasks, employing a curriculum learning strategy that evolves from simple
to complex tasks. Our method enhances local model performance on various
benchmarks (CNN/DailyMail, XSum, and ClinicalTrial), outperforming baselines by
4.5%, 8.5%, and 7.4%, respectively. It also improves interpretability by
providing insights into the summarization rationale.
|
[
0.035693977028131485,
-0.46184536814689636,
0.708592414855957,
0.13844549655914307,
-0.4070362448692322,
0.22542625665664673,
-0.3967263698577881,
-0.14107635617256165,
0.07724972069263458,
0.7164406776428223,
-0.04360174015164375,
-0.8513450026512146,
-0.5714569091796875,
0.06868275254964828,
-0.3954000174999237,
1.3257721662521362,
-0.13431252539157867,
0.06749477237462997,
-0.3971167504787445,
-0.018868541345000267,
-0.2727836072444916,
-0.5549654960632324,
-0.43750497698783875,
-0.11125286668539047,
0.42495378851890564,
0.8773878216743469,
0.485092431306839,
0.6551768183708191,
0.39974063634872437,
0.21592338383197784,
-0.17496269941329956,
0.4976213276386261,
-0.603823184967041,
0.1592443883419037,
-0.13515546917915344,
-0.61332768201828,
-0.5573951005935669,
0.031295523047447205,
0.8687105178833008,
0.8822895288467407,
-0.13285645842552185,
0.16909700632095337,
0.30127617716789246,
0.7723493576049805,
-0.7631427049636841,
0.34541285037994385,
-0.33887821435928345,
-0.24091431498527527,
-0.12236049771308899,
-0.20301993191242218,
-0.431605726480484,
-0.8255565166473389,
0.22650058567523956,
-0.4711560010910034,
0.37424132227897644,
0.026012547314167023,
0.6853529810905457,
0.2561100423336029,
-0.6201438307762146,
-0.2755732536315918,
-0.6126219034194946,
0.9345777630805969,
-0.7996394634246826,
-0.10413384437561035,
0.5553942918777466,
0.3553644120693207,
0.10955540835857391,
-0.7760600447654724,
-0.209400936961174,
-0.20140516757965088,
-0.28689658641815186,
-0.01247993391007185,
0.13376465439796448,
0.010965079069137573,
0.12660446763038635,
0.8722881078720093,
-0.32464301586151123,
-0.1190195232629776,
-0.4111528694629669,
0.056408125907182693,
0.7079599499702454,
0.2338958978652954,
0.3723300099372864,
-0.31311920285224915,
-0.20486126840114594,
0.18452908098697662,
-0.6028527021408081,
0.03878369927406311,
0.0968397855758667,
0.35854700207710266,
-0.508307933807373,
0.6843761801719666,
-0.2502847909927368,
0.5485807657241821,
-0.1590198427438736,
-0.4104759395122528,
-0.01604665257036686,
-0.4981621205806732,
-0.23003138601779938,
0.1892155408859253,
0.7002590894699097,
0.38261678814888,
0.3501085042953491,
-0.1610409915447235,
0.07018810510635376,
-0.2825274169445038,
0.10209854692220688,
-0.9432096481323242,
-0.23299793899059296,
0.3832755386829376,
-0.3910418152809143,
-0.4085089862346649,
-0.04888887703418732,
-0.6589614748954773,
-0.37784576416015625,
-0.49794870615005493,
0.1767885535955429,
-0.6154390573501587,
0.03326885402202606,
0.363427996635437,
-0.07091324776411057,
-0.03656163439154625,
0.3471373915672302,
-1.0390822887420654,
0.5405762195587158,
0.6766616702079773,
1.237257719039917,
-0.36512598395347595,
-0.23710742592811584,
-0.5768069624900818,
0.4216460883617401,
-0.158486470580101,
0.7551836967468262,
-0.30655035376548767,
-0.37662243843078613,
-0.15251046419143677,
-0.35102567076683044,
-0.06523461639881134,
-0.4704967141151428,
0.3178461790084839,
-0.286655992269516,
0.5655906200408936,
-0.17768748104572296,
-0.535818338394165,
-0.4435221254825592,
0.0858016312122345,
-0.7304410934448242,
0.8274310827255249,
0.15977749228477478,
-0.8727766275405884,
0.2287248820066452,
-0.6443734169006348,
-0.7813436985015869,
-0.1441543698310852,
0.13634607195854187,
-0.422512024641037,
0.3608663082122803,
0.41857099533081055,
0.7914608120918274,
-0.2965781092643738,
0.5542663931846619,
-0.3120129704475403,
-0.2608189284801483,
-0.08540092408657074,
-0.27243921160697937,
0.8564990758895874,
0.13436424732208252,
0.018371056765317917,
0.17440477013587952,
-0.746781587600708,
-0.18541319668293,
0.0813208669424057,
-0.22053395211696625,
-0.5740729570388794,
-0.052826765924692154,
-0.45216676592826843,
-0.0742340162396431,
0.4140784442424774,
-0.27399778366088867,
0.06695195287466049,
-0.5935496687889099,
0.31258782744407654,
0.2633472979068756,
0.36652496457099915,
0.7685460448265076,
-0.6181696653366089,
0.3115067183971405,
-0.2026728093624115,
-0.04972858354449272,
-0.34445300698280334,
-0.1828119158744812,
-0.5461500287055969,
-0.6729243993759155,
0.21575422585010529,
0.32296982407569885,
-0.5321994423866272,
0.21452416479587555,
-0.4438179135322571,
-0.5527887344360352,
-0.2769246995449066,
0.21489781141281128,
0.25325676798820496,
0.6388027667999268,
0.3552362620830536,
0.052913106977939606,
-0.32412856817245483,
-0.798136293888092,
-0.31169214844703674,
0.032539546489715576,
-0.31919240951538086,
0.028345778584480286,
0.4744464159011841,
0.25749123096466064,
1.0924575328826904,
-0.6946200728416443,
-0.5379958748817444,
-0.7304929494857788,
0.42867982387542725,
0.25432538986206055,
0.12004482001066208,
0.4613470435142517,
-0.9118625521659851,
-0.4209967851638794,
-0.26309511065483093,
-0.9076048135757446,
-0.3655697703361511,
-0.05473118647933006,
0.14565743505954742,
0.16456277668476105,
0.3385176658630371,
-0.19167567789554596,
0.3419766426086426,
0.5641562342643738,
-0.0565003827214241,
0.5182958841323853,
-0.44214755296707153,
0.03473615646362305,
-1.6567047834396362,
0.03708016127347946,
-0.021955236792564392,
-0.4457249939441681,
-0.48904022574424744,
-0.12267842888832092,
0.13124632835388184,
-0.003862777492031455,
-0.4274616837501526,
0.4703858494758606,
-0.494527667760849,
-0.17074677348136902,
-0.441938579082489,
0.3356490731239319,
0.31335845589637756,
0.4475553035736084,
0.2121766209602356,
0.8528489470481873,
0.2045086771249771,
-0.8738577365875244,
0.06696062535047531,
0.14159512519836426,
-0.47635218501091003,
0.43961021304130554,
-0.7273575067520142,
-0.38440078496932983,
-0.10759644955396652,
0.24951811134815216,
-0.8288216590881348,
-0.649616539478302,
-0.21070437133312225,
-0.3198080062866211,
0.3277624547481537,
0.02198324166238308,
-0.38545241951942444,
0.23588933050632477,
-0.5707920789718628,
0.5326134562492371,
0.21871435642242432,
-0.5444332361221313,
0.9502034783363342,
0.7807227373123169,
-0.4936864674091339,
-0.369251549243927,
-0.5115765929222107,
0.09428782016038895,
-0.16300447285175323,
-0.5846192836761475,
0.5217059254646301,
0.048282984644174576,
-0.4948216676712036,
0.00370262423530221,
-0.021291473880410194,
-0.12820559740066528,
0.3761032223701477,
0.16988322138786316,
0.30068108439445496,
0.00632002018392086,
0.04131549596786499,
0.09173176437616348,
-0.21568846702575684,
0.016633523628115654,
-0.15483184158802032,
0.44012215733528137,
-0.2806502878665924,
-0.08714611083269119,
-0.2977055609226227,
0.4659469723701477,
0.5659253001213074,
-0.3843716084957123,
0.7629322409629822,
0.20597557723522186,
-0.5228902697563171,
-0.30621352791786194,
-0.2834889590740204,
0.008751323446631432,
-0.3898550868034363,
0.3701506555080414,
0.004622208420187235,
-1.0805509090423584,
0.3812007009983063,
0.04406272992491722,
0.4962465167045593,
0.4609318673610687,
0.7979359030723572,
-0.06595253199338913,
0.9035782814025879,
0.6581215858459473,
-0.008228696882724762,
0.48909908533096313,
-0.23649029433727264,
0.25478672981262207,
-0.782890260219574,
-0.3722895681858063,
-0.4283037483692169,
-0.04149052873253822,
-0.3535727560520172,
-0.32055559754371643,
0.5220685005187988,
-0.05938620865345001,
-0.12947769463062286,
0.20277048647403717,
-0.12360561639070511,
0.8098604083061218,
0.46797114610671997,
0.029313454404473305,
0.6698708534240723,
-0.030150795355439186,
-0.044642724096775055,
0.04565375670790672,
-0.6020216345787048,
-0.6844567656517029,
1.0306459665298462,
0.4440719783306122,
0.6879609823226929,
0.33051660656929016,
0.9285857081413269,
0.27862685918807983,
0.4817536175251007,
-0.7383726835250854,
0.4741488993167877,
-0.2919873595237732,
-0.4269871115684509,
-0.19390983879566193,
-0.7719075083732605,
-0.5112323760986328,
0.1828474998474121,
-0.1400567889213562,
-0.684846043586731,
-0.11993419378995895,
-0.00946530420333147,
-0.6255442500114441,
0.3634500205516815,
-0.8351094722747803,
0.5370875000953674,
-0.3035510778427124,
-0.44310322403907776,
-0.2830340266227722,
-0.5443152785301208,
0.7494457364082336,
-0.23168526589870453,
0.4098816215991974,
-0.22248852252960205,
-0.16507446765899658,
0.7088354229927063,
-0.3543078303337097,
1.064009189605713,
0.1698811948299408,
-0.19194307923316956,
0.03382837399840355,
0.2898421287536621,
0.1474662572145462,
0.3090841770172119,
0.03582700341939926,
0.3408813178539276,
0.028760267421603203,
-0.3280390799045563,
-0.5636557340621948,
0.5871327519416809,
-0.5354359745979309,
-0.4666697084903717,
-0.4979988634586334,
-0.894399106502533,
-0.32455945014953613,
0.4055729806423187,
0.26677268743515015,
0.5076174736022949,
-0.20809206366539001,
0.3503028452396393,
0.6862179040908813,
-0.08196333795785904,
0.46361976861953735,
0.5117228031158447,
-0.2006058543920517,
-0.7028527855873108,
0.8286284804344177,
0.057474132627248764,
0.48253220319747925,
0.6074535846710205,
0.38918712735176086,
-0.26900193095207214,
-0.5601227283477783,
0.08536644279956818,
0.4352743625640869,
-0.6368352174758911,
-0.206461563706398,
-0.6952381134033203,
-0.1740533709526062,
-0.34906479716300964,
-0.34152206778526306,
-0.28726130723953247,
-0.6610625982284546,
-0.4185180366039276,
-0.06458459049463272,
0.05401995778083801,
0.8791210055351257,
0.05849570780992508,
0.4986044764518738,
-1.0024440288543701,
0.5995141863822937,
0.20804312825202942,
0.4728655219078064,
-0.10438340157270432,
-0.7914072871208191,
-0.4016706347465515,
0.029962463304400444,
-0.10145110636949539,
-0.7456730604171753,
0.5539563298225403,
0.16676312685012817,
0.2764534652233124,
0.2666051983833313,
0.25374963879585266,
0.44662806391716003,
-0.20658892393112183,
0.755764901638031,
-0.02213785983622074,
-1.0335431098937988,
0.43815818428993225,
-0.325151652097702,
0.3134940564632416,
0.7501306533813477,
0.43929192423820496,
-0.3227218985557556,
-0.45448780059814453,
-0.5466167330741882,
-0.8361246585845947,
0.7620418071746826,
0.2057432383298874,
-0.0426141619682312,
0.12852743268013,
0.2908063232898712,
0.06982280313968658,
0.20197919011116028,
-0.606907844543457,
0.011346263810992241,
0.03872925043106079,
-0.4561947286128998,
-0.16799139976501465,
-0.6283040642738342,
-0.12398102879524231,
-0.08225782960653305,
0.7825078368186951,
-0.17677371203899384,
-0.32837748527526855,
0.05564827471971512,
-0.2986599802970886,
0.32375437021255493,
0.2629588842391968,
0.5901525020599365,
0.6504654288291931,
-0.42298755049705505,
0.2745959162712097,
0.393218457698822,
-0.49694377183914185,
-0.14404690265655518,
0.03155585005879402,
-0.1912100613117218,
-0.02222357876598835,
0.611732006072998,
0.3454182744026184,
0.6799429059028625,
-0.343941330909729,
0.6415808796882629,
-0.39730918407440186,
-0.16701841354370117,
-0.15552827715873718,
0.13288076221942902,
0.059141822159290314,
0.0026252013631165028,
0.18900352716445923,
-0.22998270392417908,
0.12864378094673157,
-0.3266141414642334,
0.25190749764442444,
0.027508802711963654,
-0.18034498393535614,
-0.14263005554676056,
0.49146896600723267,
0.1410996913909912,
0.027381204068660736,
0.1895395964384079,
0.009962250478565693,
-0.4405336081981659,
0.3374926745891571,
0.5838488936424255,
1.0606024265289307,
-0.20423586666584015,
0.29346996545791626,
0.5051497220993042,
0.16944269835948944,
-0.367391437292099,
0.1381480097770691,
-0.23432657122612,
-0.45845797657966614,
-0.5387856364250183,
-0.6857938766479492,
-0.7731288075447083,
-0.2073131799697876,
-0.6292027235031128,
0.4514721632003784,
-0.5158079266548157,
0.16970467567443848,
-0.05084829777479172,
0.2146395593881607,
-0.06527514010667801,
0.06761405616998672,
0.19328948855400085,
0.9155220985412598,
-0.7905926704406738,
0.6398350596427917,
0.4079180359840393,
-0.4543476700782776,
-0.776658296585083,
0.026444431394338608,
-0.05006458982825279,
-0.6073489189147949,
0.15577304363250732,
0.23362816870212555,
-0.2213563770055771,
-0.08996779471635818,
-0.48798826336860657,
-0.8861564993858337,
1.1462230682373047,
0.5291460752487183,
-0.2870871424674988,
-0.2522379159927368,
0.10086502879858017,
0.3720824718475342,
-0.671312153339386,
0.24780504405498505,
0.5604264140129089,
0.08284943550825119,
0.18655048310756683,
-0.6406738758087158,
-0.07437131553888321,
-0.02614656463265419,
-0.08233631402254105,
0.07714685052633286,
-0.48674318194389343,
0.8079250454902649,
-0.5801883935928345,
-0.3659203350543976,
-0.26440852880477905,
0.7982496619224548,
0.3594945967197418,
0.40028321743011475,
0.1611475646495819,
0.22344978153705597,
1.0507808923721313,
-0.04423076659440994,
1.296923041343689,
-0.3519379198551178,
0.31855782866477966,
1.5202126502990723,
-0.327079713344574,
0.6868423223495483,
0.14623664319515228,
0.26231932640075684,
0.6158801317214966,
0.4178101122379303,
0.32577887177467346,
0.44117075204849243,
-0.2323688119649887,
-0.34096759557724,
-0.41101816296577454,
-0.3038800358772278,
0.05378377065062523,
0.493818074464798,
0.34608355164527893,
-0.2902332842350006,
-0.7402607798576355,
-0.24294912815093994,
0.39513498544692993,
0.31936153769493103,
-0.36780962347984314,
0.8829944133758545,
0.38520199060440063,
-0.5343648791313171,
0.24184876680374146,
0.13985362648963928,
0.19048462808132172,
-0.6912786364555359,
-0.13462239503860474,
-0.2446279674768448,
0.1894417703151703,
-0.36356475949287415,
-0.823564350605011,
0.43795323371887207,
0.2022545039653778,
-0.3105279803276062,
-0.1811293214559555,
0.5140140652656555,
-0.5012515187263489,
-0.4285767674446106,
-0.04613438993692398,
0.31014811992645264,
-0.046593260020017624,
-0.09278912842273712,
-0.051705360412597656,
-0.3590622544288635,
-0.02243243157863617,
-0.08360970765352249,
0.20924870669841766,
0.5316752195358276,
-0.25281500816345215,
0.7183144688606262,
0.8153956532478333,
0.36481228470802307,
-0.5132381319999695,
0.20205403864383698,
0.7548297047615051,
-0.6597105264663696,
-0.7754287123680115,
-1.1777408123016357,
0.384511798620224,
-0.4367513060569763,
-0.12322675436735153,
0.8805227279663086,
0.7714884877204895,
0.6656056642532349,
0.387696772813797,
0.7947580814361572,
0.2511274516582489,
0.7310836911201477,
-0.6728585362434387,
0.6585898995399475,
-0.5074111819267273,
0.5695099234580994,
-0.029894165694713593,
-0.7817667126655579,
-0.6756317615509033,
0.30675143003463745,
-0.7899188995361328,
-0.03448769822716713,
0.8118808269500732,
0.4520644247531891,
-0.06745525449514389,
0.32422104477882385,
0.2392835170030594,
0.15217846632003784,
0.42597219347953796,
0.5444090366363525,
0.5486408472061157,
-0.020852908492088318,
0.4044586718082428,
-0.36562609672546387,
-0.5862187147140503,
-0.24971707165241241,
-1.196744680404663,
-1.23380446434021,
-0.4492082893848419,
-0.15200400352478027,
-0.20537018775939941,
-0.3841305077075958,
0.9559532999992371,
0.4938659369945526,
-0.8114065527915955,
-0.26722511649131775,
0.1803591102361679,
0.433783620595932,
0.07141702622175217,
-0.18965652585029602,
0.5628778338432312,
-0.4692515730857849,
-0.5626092553138733,
0.14465247094631195,
0.5387539863586426,
-0.01543560903519392,
-0.0760512501001358,
0.08308186382055283,
-0.020277703180909157,
0.12089912593364716,
0.6358272433280945,
0.09091892093420029,
-0.2721903324127197,
-0.04398379847407341,
-0.09608843177556992,
-0.3355669379234314,
-0.059810739010572433,
0.8823049664497375,
-0.5463818311691284,
0.3237460255622864,
0.49142885208129883,
0.477262407541275,
0.3994865417480469,
0.28107932209968567,
0.8020671606063843,
-0.7585569620132446,
-0.2827676832675934,
0.36945876479148865,
0.5367856025695801,
0.4237578511238098,
-0.35446980595588684,
0.3183823227882385,
0.01167610939592123,
-0.4719456732273102,
-0.7285121083259583,
0.06906656175851822,
-0.9250659346580505,
-0.2813577950000763,
1.310592770576477,
-0.07710643112659454,
-0.5407124757766724,
-0.2519444227218628,
-0.1971471905708313,
0.44767555594444275,
-0.22587421536445618,
1.0255064964294434,
0.4432980418205261,
0.2558005750179291,
0.08127983659505844,
-0.46665725111961365,
0.540690541267395,
0.24262645840644836,
-0.9680633544921875,
0.4927101135253906,
0.5779112577438354,
0.39241456985473633,
0.09928437322378159,
0.6014957427978516,
-0.4078938066959381,
0.2574561536312103,
-0.5174949169158936,
-0.011603825725615025,
-0.436610609292984,
-0.6421288251876831,
-0.5506904721260071,
0.4796541929244995,
-0.13960842788219452,
-0.056682147085666656
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14694v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14694v1
|
Application of GPT Language Models for Innovation in Activities in University Teaching
| 2024-03-15T14:31:52 | 2024-03-15T14:31:52 |
Manuel de Buenaga, Francisco Javier Bueno
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
The GPT (Generative Pre-trained Transformer) language models are an
artificial intelligence and natural language processing technology that enables
automatic text generation. There is a growing interest in applying GPT language
models to university teaching in various dimensions. From the perspective of
innovation in student and teacher activities, they can provide support in
understanding and generating content, problem-solving, as well as
personalization and test correction, among others. From the dimension of
internationalization, the misuse of these models represents a global problem
that requires taking a series of common measures in universities from different
geographical areas. In several countries, there has been a review of assessment
tools to ensure that work is done by students and not by AI. To this end, we
have conducted a detailed experiment in a representative subject of Computer
Science such as Software Engineering, which has focused on evaluating the use
of ChatGPT as an assistant in theory activities, exercises, and laboratory
practices, assessing its potential use as a support tool for both students and
teachers.
|
[
-0.3820299506187439,
-1.1668378114700317,
0.4438916742801666,
0.102835513651371,
-0.10184594243764877,
0.1169806644320488,
-0.09627316147089005,
-0.21039250493049622,
-0.3941272795200348,
0.204803466796875,
-0.21817751228809357,
-0.06026094779372215,
-0.28578945994377136,
0.114412322640419,
-0.7849434614181519,
1.0803602933883667,
-0.3834208846092224,
0.327813059091568,
-0.12700720131397247,
0.2866818904876709,
-0.6852448582649231,
-0.6303070783615112,
-0.8452489376068115,
-0.47174742817878723,
-0.06862343102693558,
0.2934834659099579,
0.7457335591316223,
-0.2002103179693222,
0.677596390247345,
0.3700728416442871,
0.23992863297462463,
-0.47076788544654846,
-0.042502764612436295,
-0.3004909157752991,
-0.15339653193950653,
-0.4699430763721466,
-0.21844139695167542,
0.24367153644561768,
0.8144322633743286,
0.6702703833580017,
-0.21968293190002441,
0.0019658657256513834,
0.396709680557251,
0.2339375764131546,
0.040988706052303314,
0.2871735394001007,
-0.31816965341567993,
0.07944919914007187,
0.08424137532711029,
0.18846270442008972,
-0.2647281885147095,
-0.7177240252494812,
0.3429622948169708,
-0.5500559210777283,
0.5602300763130188,
-0.39046141505241394,
0.6787222623825073,
-0.04359233006834984,
-0.21947786211967468,
-0.41179943084716797,
-1.0845444202423096,
0.4885769188404083,
-0.6226967573165894,
0.3135761320590973,
-0.0002654049312695861,
0.5631502866744995,
-0.3933764696121216,
-0.8040139079093933,
-0.8104040026664734,
-0.4629477560520172,
-0.16650529205799103,
0.3013167083263397,
0.012931980192661285,
0.11192644387483597,
0.09077589213848114,
0.6747929453849792,
-0.7424892783164978,
-0.0651121437549591,
-0.5245127081871033,
0.006539161317050457,
0.5218653678894043,
-0.0649881586432457,
0.8107874393463135,
0.08554570376873016,
-0.17325575649738312,
-0.2201903909444809,
-0.657543420791626,
0.14334246516227722,
0.370286226272583,
0.09342770278453827,
-0.04711182788014412,
0.43734583258628845,
-0.06620225310325623,
0.4979732632637024,
-0.5452934503555298,
0.2699045240879059,
-0.1041412353515625,
-0.23038554191589355,
-0.4092421233654022,
-0.27173054218292236,
0.7987881898880005,
-0.27058151364326477,
0.38471555709838867,
-0.31263700127601624,
-0.052676983177661896,
0.3702956736087799,
0.2169484943151474,
-0.7322185039520264,
-0.6238024234771729,
-0.14814110100269318,
-0.016983797773718834,
-0.36497101187705994,
0.05641385167837143,
-0.5874016284942627,
0.011866672895848751,
-0.35953274369239807,
0.5988487005233765,
-0.3710642158985138,
-0.6619951725006104,
0.0691368505358696,
-0.0973835289478302,
0.2676248550415039,
0.36426079273223877,
-0.9341859817504883,
0.5161159038543701,
0.5123382806777954,
0.760981559753418,
-0.19799040257930756,
-0.6051470041275024,
0.12989918887615204,
-0.15442219376564026,
-0.09606728702783585,
0.738901674747467,
-0.624853789806366,
-0.9421796202659607,
-0.004735165275633335,
0.09557925909757614,
-0.12768064439296722,
-0.2590561509132385,
0.5197697281837463,
-0.36434075236320496,
0.62660813331604,
-0.07708924263715744,
-0.49405187368392944,
-0.21925631165504456,
0.10902608186006546,
-0.4257296323776245,
1.3742166757583618,
0.45151016116142273,
-0.43718793988227844,
0.3499374985694885,
-1.3220616579055786,
-0.24582697451114655,
0.5716315507888794,
-0.5189505219459534,
-0.5846306681632996,
0.0056373183615505695,
0.05711651220917702,
0.2690463066101074,
-0.1863061785697937,
0.44878697395324707,
0.39079487323760986,
-0.4698815643787384,
0.4447998106479645,
-0.6741575598716736,
0.7474575638771057,
0.03462258726358414,
-0.5492427349090576,
0.27806517481803894,
-0.45343974232673645,
0.0477583222091198,
0.4324593245983124,
-0.49339738488197327,
-0.1884603500366211,
-0.16242237389087677,
0.35068461298942566,
0.13655082881450653,
-0.15819776058197021,
-0.5567165613174438,
0.7337024211883545,
-0.26273584365844727,
0.6469813585281372,
0.5847622156143188,
0.010298104025423527,
0.44745662808418274,
-0.14178232848644257,
0.6823105812072754,
-0.29205766320228577,
0.2024274319410324,
-0.0951182022690773,
-0.8933706879615784,
-0.6442409157752991,
-0.014354881830513477,
0.29999613761901855,
0.5840561985969543,
-0.9822004437446594,
-0.19368605315685272,
-0.08745554089546204,
-0.5149123668670654,
-0.5440385937690735,
0.003044568933546543,
0.13202062249183655,
0.4336757957935333,
0.22655464708805084,
-0.30239376425743103,
-0.34216228127479553,
-0.544834315776825,
-0.33927249908447266,
-0.18870794773101807,
-0.23959292471408844,
0.022449692711234093,
0.5331671237945557,
-0.22795894742012024,
1.1242765188217163,
-0.3973277807235718,
-0.06260965019464493,
-0.46100494265556335,
0.42906901240348816,
0.03730045631527901,
0.6334648728370667,
0.41934630274772644,
-1.101165533065796,
-0.6592912077903748,
0.07552807033061981,
-0.7366817593574524,
-0.05946648493409157,
-0.09096643328666687,
-0.07507797330617905,
0.09866231679916382,
0.13369987905025482,
-0.6544846296310425,
0.591506838798523,
0.4623998701572418,
-0.3594537079334259,
0.7589606642723083,
-0.3578034043312073,
0.5178192257881165,
-0.9960584044456482,
-0.1253391057252884,
-0.11773484200239182,
-0.011525535024702549,
-0.8495874404907227,
0.1095302477478981,
-0.018229614943265915,
-0.606916606426239,
-0.31960299611091614,
0.561951220035553,
-0.3880085051059723,
0.07790447026491165,
-0.5008673667907715,
0.18140225112438202,
-0.3204863369464874,
0.16752156615257263,
0.08461732417345047,
1.3673698902130127,
0.62083500623703,
-0.5942086577415466,
0.4217706024646759,
0.23620544373989105,
-0.32692092657089233,
0.37887099385261536,
-0.6154676675796509,
0.347453236579895,
0.22795337438583374,
-0.01164188887923956,
-0.9716863036155701,
-0.20004917681217194,
0.05220001935958862,
-0.5102449655532837,
0.09035326540470123,
-0.2791227400302887,
-0.5858812928199768,
-0.7137650847434998,
0.09764374792575836,
0.3125467300415039,
0.7939000725746155,
-0.4013129472732544,
0.42657020688056946,
0.23530444502830505,
-0.3933517038822174,
-0.19128648936748505,
-0.5574842095375061,
-0.016920730471611023,
-0.1529817432165146,
-0.6675161719322205,
0.2672474682331085,
-0.1617465615272522,
-0.08412639796733856,
0.06469447165727615,
0.20464111864566803,
-0.23848971724510193,
0.3307673931121826,
0.16764849424362183,
0.4548516273498535,
-0.342398464679718,
0.015453080646693707,
-0.2922685742378235,
-0.131264790892601,
0.13873019814491272,
-0.28938668966293335,
0.5966779589653015,
-0.4018409848213196,
-0.617185652256012,
-0.47026556730270386,
0.3592699468135834,
0.32266750931739807,
-0.006045806221663952,
0.5019991397857666,
0.9044089317321777,
-0.26822319626808167,
-0.06586142629384995,
-0.5842466354370117,
-0.31635361909866333,
-0.5687645673751831,
0.5412905216217041,
-0.30475229024887085,
-0.8675180673599243,
0.34045448899269104,
-0.24737393856048584,
0.058792710304260254,
0.16273334622383118,
0.5076960325241089,
0.2063269168138504,
0.8919211030006409,
1.0131454467773438,
-0.22294166684150696,
0.6882457137107849,
-0.34245413541793823,
0.6040581464767456,
-0.6564795970916748,
0.08661893010139465,
-0.6056612133979797,
0.23150084912776947,
-0.6974227428436279,
-0.17141342163085938,
0.40330058336257935,
0.21673919260501862,
-0.09623663127422333,
0.2713490426540375,
-0.7770683765411377,
0.6417858600616455,
0.7238591909408569,
-0.218195378780365,
0.1827651858329773,
0.07465312629938126,
-0.06071239709854126,
0.08285298198461533,
-0.6137163043022156,
-0.8264943361282349,
1.112931251525879,
0.19517096877098083,
0.7083070278167725,
0.10692183673381805,
0.5400959849357605,
0.24085882306098938,
0.8507561683654785,
-0.6490896344184875,
0.5698763728141785,
0.01701095700263977,
-0.40898144245147705,
-0.681397557258606,
-0.3676128387451172,
-0.8081154823303223,
0.2825498878955841,
0.10166123509407043,
-0.7984931468963623,
-0.4699455499649048,
0.1484578400850296,
0.025153279304504395,
0.4078543782234192,
-1.1197370290756226,
1.1323039531707764,
-0.14119000732898712,
-0.049882952123880386,
0.022238951176404953,
0.04367195442318916,
0.01962541602551937,
0.028033994138240814,
0.266965389251709,
0.2819134294986725,
0.6673915982246399,
0.7730596661567688,
-0.09307176619768143,
0.7509759068489075,
-0.28914836049079895,
-0.11956990510225296,
0.6546916961669922,
0.1985136866569519,
0.4983054995536804,
0.03582870215177536,
0.034345705062150955,
-0.0604628287255764,
-0.07599405944347382,
-0.3182705044746399,
-0.5587949752807617,
0.582181453704834,
-0.9930184483528137,
-0.9320810437202454,
-0.27791932225227356,
-0.6314541697502136,
-0.12591037154197693,
0.22994926571846008,
0.1932719349861145,
0.13946130871772766,
-0.506415605545044,
-0.1333090215921402,
0.442428857088089,
-0.07312333583831787,
0.5216787457466125,
0.5650845766067505,
-0.36745554208755493,
0.0636366531252861,
1.023988962173462,
0.16666199266910553,
0.29071298241615295,
0.07598908245563507,
0.39399030804634094,
-0.15746721625328064,
-0.5484575033187866,
-0.6267168521881104,
-0.006031900644302368,
-0.7057282328605652,
0.2010393589735031,
-0.5914517641067505,
-0.4997956156730652,
-0.7229110598564148,
-0.37880396842956543,
-0.10546328872442245,
-0.32073622941970825,
0.18818221986293793,
-0.11354950815439224,
0.15490613877773285,
1.0518741607666016,
0.1675063818693161,
0.6627422571182251,
-0.5618985295295715,
0.027148030698299408,
0.632430911064148,
0.2514359652996063,
-0.2966059446334839,
-0.22414302825927734,
-0.12975311279296875,
-0.022595014423131943,
-0.790640652179718,
-0.8281822204589844,
0.25872454047203064,
0.001640627975575626,
0.7892355918884277,
-0.07923882454633713,
-0.3574587106704712,
0.1982085406780243,
-0.520046591758728,
1.0829721689224243,
0.015661651268601418,
-1.0614726543426514,
0.686256468296051,
-0.3790415823459625,
0.3266682028770447,
0.009968293830752373,
0.408945769071579,
-0.8670860528945923,
-0.6220424771308899,
-0.7042331099510193,
-0.6955727338790894,
0.4783366620540619,
0.5385372042655945,
0.44043776392936707,
0.38480085134506226,
0.38309159874916077,
0.17405802011489868,
0.18754492700099945,
-1.1310912370681763,
-0.1556878685951233,
-0.3229829668998718,
-0.23937395215034485,
-0.007968627847731113,
-0.14966394007205963,
0.021031968295574188,
-0.15938225388526917,
0.9627155065536499,
-0.06317929923534393,
0.41387927532196045,
0.09754042327404022,
-0.15357302129268646,
0.13802550733089447,
0.8062771558761597,
0.3998822569847107,
0.8610088229179382,
0.20835590362548828,
-0.1560378223657608,
0.2591792941093445,
-1.0892657041549683,
0.2806163430213928,
0.23850370943546295,
-0.24764171242713928,
0.009289012290537357,
-0.18653331696987152,
0.3027799129486084,
-0.07105051726102829,
-0.2810550332069397,
0.437278151512146,
-0.24644355475902557,
0.001075470121577382,
-0.4616723358631134,
0.2814493775367737,
-0.10177592933177948,
-0.0009547556983307004,
0.4215249717235565,
-0.1493755578994751,
0.2726563513278961,
-0.6230019330978394,
0.14132504165172577,
0.37271589040756226,
-0.27355122566223145,
-0.47033458948135376,
0.5853636264801025,
0.18415310978889465,
-0.5611299872398376,
0.744779109954834,
-0.2029905915260315,
-0.6792137026786804,
0.6047288775444031,
0.9278219938278198,
0.870292603969574,
-0.6750379800796509,
0.5234561562538147,
0.09678414463996887,
0.375668466091156,
-0.04052851349115372,
0.33292660117149353,
0.030570460483431816,
-0.7043320536613464,
-0.23416531085968018,
-0.4150278568267822,
-0.6043530106544495,
0.288552463054657,
-0.302817165851593,
0.41345903277397156,
0.02657189965248108,
-0.07943416386842728,
0.055959831923246384,
-0.2218833565711975,
-0.8800796270370483,
0.14409227669239044,
-0.10552964359521866,
0.40237027406692505,
-1.025190830230713,
1.1097915172576904,
1.1628408432006836,
-0.5092868208885193,
-0.8729473948478699,
-0.17798376083374023,
-0.09488428384065628,
-0.6192135214805603,
0.642884373664856,
0.0029966062866151333,
0.13949166238307953,
0.1285695880651474,
-0.3989560306072235,
-0.5281459093093872,
0.9350631833076477,
0.14167673885822296,
-0.27479085326194763,
-0.20055900514125824,
0.7694390416145325,
0.5512686967849731,
-0.21878646314144135,
0.47370126843452454,
0.47898605465888977,
0.19704775512218475,
-0.08904368430376053,
-1.161684274673462,
-0.16049213707447052,
-0.29566314816474915,
0.0773625522851944,
0.3685847818851471,
-0.28600063920021057,
1.0718042850494385,
0.060866862535476685,
-0.23606443405151367,
-0.1344188153743744,
0.4592476487159729,
-0.10053914040327072,
0.17057698965072632,
0.15795281529426575,
0.17558027803897858,
0.5533207058906555,
-0.3686900734901428,
0.8870776891708374,
-0.1788780838251114,
0.5281521081924438,
0.855701208114624,
0.02871822752058506,
0.43993180990219116,
0.3620055019855499,
-0.517967939376831,
0.3753935992717743,
0.32702282071113586,
-0.14539265632629395,
0.20519548654556274,
0.3413897454738617,
-0.4828989505767822,
0.20832058787345886,
0.1846863031387329,
-0.5069643259048462,
0.1904112845659256,
0.43066665530204773,
-0.041032712906599045,
-0.24187155067920685,
0.5018933415412903,
0.07928258180618286,
-0.03949911892414093,
-0.25363889336586,
0.7202650308609009,
0.033632997423410416,
-0.5906278491020203,
0.1681814342737198,
-0.05997557193040848,
0.4443269968032837,
-0.516913890838623,
-0.26457178592681885,
-0.0708484947681427,
0.2243225872516632,
-0.05255512893199921,
-0.9077640771865845,
0.24937096238136292,
0.10294175893068314,
0.09339223057031631,
-0.17670780420303345,
0.6940495371818542,
-0.3383582830429077,
-0.624077558517456,
-0.10691124200820923,
0.4102035164833069,
0.30428260564804077,
-0.10871198028326035,
-0.5870314836502075,
-0.22836682200431824,
-0.1375369429588318,
-0.12991869449615479,
0.23402951657772064,
0.5044593811035156,
-0.23783227801322937,
0.6608598828315735,
0.4888942837715149,
0.10716745257377625,
0.22643497586250305,
0.37271353602409363,
0.9013365507125854,
-0.40819916129112244,
-0.6294791102409363,
-0.701580822467804,
0.5722601413726807,
0.036924686282873154,
-0.2033606320619583,
0.866012454032898,
0.5245534777641296,
1.1944820880889893,
-0.14570973813533783,
1.2622125148773193,
-0.11254595965147018,
0.14383423328399658,
-0.4049969017505646,
0.6926718354225159,
0.055403660982847214,
0.1406090259552002,
-0.5066841244697571,
-0.9613584280014038,
-0.01582225039601326,
0.6282588243484497,
-0.6370339393615723,
0.15161563456058502,
0.6750986576080322,
0.4910721182823181,
-0.10441210865974426,
0.4723743200302124,
0.49840328097343445,
0.015847735106945038,
0.8147496581077576,
0.30876797437667847,
0.9834237694740295,
-0.5708686709403992,
0.4454265832901001,
-0.31753191351890564,
-0.45717230439186096,
0.09303641319274902,
-0.43717920780181885,
-1.0299594402313232,
-0.735466718673706,
-0.4683060944080353,
-0.2113785743713379,
0.0909419134259224,
0.6735543012619019,
0.5199644565582275,
-0.8455868363380432,
-0.4347379803657532,
-0.5004156231880188,
-0.20557621121406555,
-0.2299308031797409,
-0.35616883635520935,
0.44477948546409607,
-0.5015046000480652,
-0.7178879976272583,
0.22642096877098083,
-0.07227568328380585,
0.6327542066574097,
-0.5435572266578674,
0.25306737422943115,
0.034885525703430176,
-0.18168336153030396,
0.5581277012825012,
0.19452336430549622,
-0.545595645904541,
-0.33145761489868164,
-0.0807618498802185,
0.11224842816591263,
0.07076616585254669,
1.0534437894821167,
-0.7361229658126831,
0.35535553097724915,
0.2570040225982666,
0.6494442820549011,
0.3535933494567871,
-0.1979599893093109,
0.7614555358886719,
-0.5442115068435669,
0.4187113344669342,
0.18630358576774597,
0.28051823377609253,
0.45530015230178833,
-0.5131539106369019,
0.6658293008804321,
0.28861066699028015,
-0.9586055278778076,
-0.6736094355583191,
0.10137224942445755,
-0.4241364002227783,
-0.07102056592702866,
0.865361213684082,
-0.3536362648010254,
0.03628969565033913,
-0.20231127738952637,
-0.509354293346405,
0.36810269951820374,
-0.21580740809440613,
1.1507399082183838,
0.9028013944625854,
-0.25717824697494507,
-0.10727480798959732,
-1.1792476177215576,
0.7563621401786804,
0.2697194814682007,
-1.011925220489502,
-0.1774279922246933,
-0.07628314942121506,
0.43902361392974854,
0.15602141618728638,
0.708246111869812,
-0.09008565545082092,
0.29718902707099915,
-0.0064041693694889545,
0.31455615162849426,
0.17972064018249512,
-0.08874990791082382,
-0.06539933383464813,
0.04690852388739586,
0.195611834526062,
-0.13008463382720947
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10338v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10338v1
|
Investigating grammatical abstraction in language models using few-shot learning of novel noun gender
| 2024-03-15T14:25:59 | 2024-03-15T14:25:59 |
Priyanka Sukumaran, Conor Houghton, Nina Kazanina
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Humans can learn a new word and infer its grammatical properties from very
few examples. They have an abstract notion of linguistic properties like
grammatical gender and agreement rules that can be applied to novel syntactic
contexts and words. Drawing inspiration from psycholinguistics, we conduct a
noun learning experiment to assess whether an LSTM and a decoder-only
transformer can achieve human-like abstraction of grammatical gender in French.
Language models were tasked with learning the gender of a novel noun embedding
from a few examples in one grammatical agreement context and predicting
agreement in another, unseen context. We find that both language models
effectively generalise novel noun gender from one to two learning examples and
apply the learnt gender across agreement contexts, albeit with a bias for the
masculine gender category. Importantly, the few-shot updates were only applied
to the embedding layers, demonstrating that models encode sufficient gender
information within the word embedding space. While the generalisation behaviour
of models suggests that they represent grammatical gender as an abstract
category, like humans, further work is needed to explore the details of how
exactly this is implemented. For a comparative perspective with human
behaviour, we conducted an analogous one-shot novel noun gender learning
experiment, which revealed that native French speakers, like language models,
also exhibited a masculine gender bias and are not excellent one-shot learners
either.
|
[
-0.1775011420249939,
-0.8191942572593689,
0.6190385818481445,
0.19090470671653748,
0.13908196985721588,
0.00962995458394289,
-0.1739867478609085,
-0.4292225241661072,
-0.04173034057021141,
0.19207699596881866,
-0.6347296833992004,
-0.41103827953338623,
-0.5906244516372681,
0.44295576214790344,
-0.40725070238113403,
0.5117827653884888,
0.23603391647338867,
0.04966072738170624,
-0.33459433913230896,
-0.024553418159484863,
-0.34618791937828064,
-0.5210038423538208,
-0.558645486831665,
-0.6101750731468201,
0.5984813570976257,
0.14540714025497437,
0.5236533284187317,
0.5366064310073853,
0.2966616451740265,
0.3663006126880646,
-0.1686050444841385,
0.10423191636800766,
-0.4760396480560303,
-0.15519528090953827,
-0.43412718176841736,
-0.5727640390396118,
-0.43723732233047485,
0.101737380027771,
0.669246256351471,
0.9929867386817932,
0.04874267056584358,
-0.08879370987415314,
0.18930844962596893,
0.7734926342964172,
-0.7789878845214844,
0.4889938235282898,
-0.4661978483200073,
0.0687413290143013,
0.16285823285579681,
0.09855227917432785,
-0.4607383608818054,
-0.07262680679559708,
0.06573403626680374,
-0.33948689699172974,
0.2943347096443176,
-0.31196707487106323,
0.7669187188148499,
-0.17851018905639648,
-0.4809757173061371,
-0.010789762251079082,
-0.7887795567512512,
0.7182647585868835,
-0.6357219219207764,
0.5924738645553589,
0.5966740846633911,
0.17128635942935944,
-0.11876767873764038,
-0.5217600464820862,
-0.5378825068473816,
-0.25485554337501526,
-0.40693023800849915,
-0.0557931512594223,
-0.49944010376930237,
0.018351593986153603,
0.14373527467250824,
-0.04315486177802086,
-0.5529245138168335,
0.14480115473270416,
-0.5149069428443909,
0.032954733818769455,
0.6452066898345947,
-0.1654871255159378,
0.35023635625839233,
-0.4303967356681824,
-0.2677331268787384,
0.11868973076343536,
-0.4819832742214203,
0.10627566277980804,
0.5751914978027344,
0.8763827681541443,
-0.4590551555156708,
0.4474411606788635,
-0.07531283795833588,
0.584958553314209,
-0.049196526408195496,
0.0982888713479042,
0.4245787560939789,
-0.203470841050148,
-0.05378992110490799,
-0.04349227249622345,
0.8302515745162964,
0.08754862844944,
0.384418249130249,
-0.42458781599998474,
-0.27236485481262207,
0.22178229689598083,
0.3097889721393585,
-0.5242078900337219,
-0.1598237007856369,
0.021310940384864807,
-0.1747111976146698,
-0.1441611498594284,
0.2237376570701599,
-0.45582643151283264,
-0.1967403143644333,
-0.3102940022945404,
0.37268686294555664,
-0.34162724018096924,
-0.593770444393158,
0.1952255219221115,
-0.20773263275623322,
0.414796382188797,
0.1451723426580429,
-1.2043629884719849,
0.5371841788291931,
0.8577790260314941,
0.6680955290794373,
-0.04669345170259476,
-0.5674189329147339,
-0.1978636384010315,
-0.23079894483089447,
-0.5169537663459778,
0.6239529252052307,
-0.5083668231964111,
-0.30538663268089294,
0.011090515181422234,
0.08157929033041,
-0.3593561351299286,
-0.34909310936927795,
0.06546682119369507,
-0.10129623115062714,
0.22324202954769135,
-0.07413439452648163,
-0.5551588535308838,
-0.2724733054637909,
0.26856759190559387,
-0.680088222026825,
0.7488743662834167,
0.13156896829605103,
-0.3788087069988251,
0.30351492762565613,
-0.6328904032707214,
-0.137276753783226,
-0.13527414202690125,
-0.6615695953369141,
-0.19818928837776184,
0.30256566405296326,
0.015160767361521721,
0.5161617398262024,
0.032174255698919296,
0.06562449038028717,
0.09102880209684372,
-0.14533278346061707,
0.4442656934261322,
-0.15631093084812164,
0.6613483428955078,
-0.2660689651966095,
-0.0014841145602986217,
-0.08256687223911285,
-0.5543301701545715,
-0.2164449691772461,
0.2918129563331604,
-0.03197561949491501,
-0.34434252977371216,
-0.15411517024040222,
0.03450983017683029,
0.1697031855583191,
-0.03273158147931099,
-0.6542100310325623,
0.23648133873939514,
-0.49797743558883667,
0.5037965178489685,
0.5370539426803589,
0.07465289533138275,
1.0074454545974731,
-0.3000688850879669,
0.4455328583717346,
-0.042662736028432846,
-0.33931273221969604,
-0.23377633094787598,
-0.4265193045139313,
-0.4140721559524536,
-0.4213855564594269,
0.5234861373901367,
0.4315936863422394,
-0.23990143835544586,
0.3333982229232788,
-0.2614949643611908,
-0.019678903743624687,
-0.31901678442955017,
0.4742940366268158,
0.6196884512901306,
0.23044030368328094,
0.09397239983081818,
-0.3031734228134155,
-0.5184334516525269,
-1.131760597229004,
-0.5509365797042847,
-0.4914137125015259,
0.046109121292829514,
0.08214496076107025,
0.7403600811958313,
-0.209985613822937,
1.2595772743225098,
-0.29897409677505493,
-0.35179126262664795,
-0.7453939318656921,
0.445851594209671,
0.010657123290002346,
0.4889686703681946,
0.8797479867935181,
-0.6036701202392578,
0.27790433168411255,
0.025059301406145096,
-0.9679043292999268,
0.129747673869133,
-0.03785165399312973,
-0.12934626638889313,
0.1971234530210495,
0.6710716485977173,
-0.4356459081172943,
0.27660107612609863,
0.33909112215042114,
-0.40909746289253235,
0.39741599559783936,
-0.10324575006961823,
-0.3147610127925873,
-0.8598496317863464,
-0.2772755026817322,
0.18047162890434265,
-0.6168410778045654,
-0.8953403830528259,
0.3892982602119446,
0.04366222769021988,
0.08045905828475952,
-0.8846096992492676,
0.8063259720802307,
-0.464832603931427,
0.01800430566072464,
-0.26422426104545593,
0.09816303849220276,
-0.2001013457775116,
0.6792935132980347,
0.35579565167427063,
0.3369207978248596,
0.3080745339393616,
-0.6911634802818298,
-0.3345949053764343,
0.09148704260587692,
-0.20916274189949036,
0.174242302775383,
-0.4395706057548523,
0.31891345977783203,
-0.6372342109680176,
-0.18558312952518463,
-1.131156086921692,
-0.2709060609340668,
0.28677690029144287,
-0.46928152441978455,
0.3281661868095398,
-0.2662881314754486,
-0.24323289096355438,
0.14407067000865936,
-0.06215427815914154,
0.598227322101593,
0.3911028504371643,
-0.10896032303571701,
0.8640337586402893,
0.11309617012739182,
-0.19021503627300262,
-0.40635332465171814,
-0.91472989320755,
-0.12351560592651367,
0.11213484406471252,
-0.18482398986816406,
0.06785441935062408,
0.24460354447364807,
-0.4851030111312866,
0.00054056232329458,
-0.014058136381208897,
-0.24335148930549622,
0.18656225502490997,
0.3355165421962738,
0.04512619972229004,
-0.2629290223121643,
0.3195682466030121,
-0.06116103380918503,
-0.02586817927658558,
0.07847945392131805,
-0.020249921828508377,
0.5864547491073608,
-0.45908308029174805,
-0.23612892627716064,
-0.48610082268714905,
0.36681538820266724,
0.41662153601646423,
0.055039770901203156,
0.6627598404884338,
0.31885045766830444,
-0.7180050015449524,
-0.29965609312057495,
-0.16201989352703094,
-0.45898059010505676,
-0.39059463143348694,
0.5406765341758728,
-0.613010585308075,
-0.5448972582817078,
0.5365394949913025,
-0.04822716861963272,
0.24076861143112183,
0.39249297976493835,
0.3161167800426483,
-0.3890293538570404,
0.5419742465019226,
0.9149282574653625,
0.0016451281262561679,
0.4302237033843994,
-0.7161490321159363,
-0.11568859964609146,
-0.4382029175758362,
-0.13491404056549072,
-0.49572575092315674,
-0.6501848697662354,
-0.6086939573287964,
-0.3037610352039337,
0.018219541758298874,
0.19660696387290955,
-0.3084031939506531,
0.4434177875518799,
0.19487594068050385,
0.7289242744445801,
0.28899866342544556,
0.44798415899276733,
0.3675486743450165,
0.208182230591774,
-0.10986518859863281,
-0.23010127246379852,
-0.7098983526229858,
-0.633765697479248,
0.8933255076408386,
0.3644022047519684,
0.5880140662193298,
0.3262734115123749,
0.8806196451187134,
0.2865332067012787,
-0.03749985247850418,
-0.972206175327301,
0.5175648927688599,
-0.38155412673950195,
-0.4422384202480316,
-0.1780596524477005,
-0.3114906847476959,
-1.0636982917785645,
0.43116024136543274,
-0.37850505113601685,
-0.7168647646903992,
0.6304637789726257,
0.020051700994372368,
-0.10531949251890182,
0.2690695524215698,
-0.3916301429271698,
0.8913318514823914,
-0.07304341346025467,
-0.3710934519767761,
0.11291851103305817,
-0.44265010952949524,
0.5079468488693237,
0.014857150614261627,
0.44360923767089844,
-0.06578594446182251,
-0.09632362425327301,
0.5737990736961365,
-0.1395655870437622,
1.3436118364334106,
0.16083723306655884,
-0.3949641287326813,
-0.03918205946683884,
0.5068002343177795,
0.0383460558950901,
-0.16853012144565582,
-0.07515062391757965,
0.4214272201061249,
-0.3460526466369629,
-0.5915207862854004,
-0.7117622494697571,
0.24240820109844208,
-0.9799884557723999,
-0.4709201157093048,
-0.5054528117179871,
-0.6035098433494568,
-0.07374931126832962,
0.005704955197870731,
0.2808035612106323,
0.48182642459869385,
-0.6057301759719849,
-0.07954433560371399,
0.26030004024505615,
0.050515066832304,
0.5833609700202942,
0.4563434422016144,
-0.5933317542076111,
0.2045365571975708,
0.7024466395378113,
-0.19571582973003387,
0.6036220788955688,
0.5738762021064758,
0.3605935871601105,
-0.12020506709814072,
-0.193259596824646,
-0.23073498904705048,
0.43253159523010254,
-0.7180771231651306,
0.19193322956562042,
-0.6722244620323181,
-0.4502750337123871,
-0.27802202105522156,
-0.06929755210876465,
-0.6292433142662048,
-0.7262359261512756,
-0.2521970570087433,
-0.32277029752731323,
0.1843491643667221,
0.8212407231330872,
0.08234503120183945,
0.33956852555274963,
-0.5990898609161377,
0.47229892015457153,
0.4792075753211975,
-0.19343745708465576,
-0.24929291009902954,
-0.6810165643692017,
0.17529699206352234,
0.18772228062152863,
-0.2199985831975937,
-0.9965060353279114,
0.31421133875846863,
0.6519234776496887,
0.45465102791786194,
0.5717231035232544,
-0.23917612433433533,
0.39701494574546814,
-0.5468161702156067,
0.8620212078094482,
0.23237894475460052,
-1.0100226402282715,
0.39020952582359314,
-0.3927585184574127,
0.532872200012207,
0.4853716492652893,
0.25861167907714844,
-0.5214290618896484,
-0.4806053042411804,
-0.3784191906452179,
-0.6255403757095337,
0.569869339466095,
0.3919486701488495,
0.596822202205658,
-0.032680608332157135,
0.6198990345001221,
0.41841110587120056,
0.16548073291778564,
-0.9826723337173462,
-0.35661932826042175,
0.1566644161939621,
0.05672823637723923,
-0.2643456757068634,
-0.09090695530176163,
-0.013760058209300041,
-0.3404850363731384,
0.3568088114261627,
-0.20207996666431427,
0.5207763314247131,
-0.01929750107228756,
-0.517069399356842,
0.06477486342191696,
0.6180451512336731,
0.6666955351829529,
0.8911106586456299,
-0.18481482565402985,
0.3408564627170563,
-0.03092118911445141,
-0.30922654271125793,
0.45705336332321167,
-0.3326738178730011,
-0.3168407380580902,
0.34023317694664,
0.8089498281478882,
0.7853776812553406,
0.49401313066482544,
-0.37431588768959045,
0.5567108392715454,
-0.11741040647029877,
-0.6894895434379578,
-0.17025645077228546,
-0.023141734302043915,
0.20847362279891968,
0.23406119644641876,
0.2643146514892578,
0.2838679552078247,
-0.041333701461553574,
-0.911612331867218,
0.14723971486091614,
0.36783909797668457,
-0.3299788236618042,
-0.5387884378433228,
0.35825014114379883,
-0.025620684027671814,
-0.3895834982395172,
0.44508031010627747,
-0.6279444098472595,
-0.5234180688858032,
0.616805374622345,
0.5649644732475281,
1.2194126844406128,
-0.3173775374889374,
0.4451495409011841,
0.418433278799057,
0.6874516606330872,
-0.28139880299568176,
0.5061219334602356,
0.09270728379487991,
-1.114200472831726,
-0.16304850578308105,
-0.5169618129730225,
-0.22171759605407715,
-0.025746947154402733,
-0.6990850567817688,
0.3342554569244385,
-0.4677119851112366,
-0.07525411248207092,
-0.028144771233201027,
-0.5960816144943237,
-0.9049811959266663,
-0.28514382243156433,
0.2929912507534027,
0.6401109099388123,
-1.3096493482589722,
0.4768848419189453,
0.8949447870254517,
-0.4233655035495758,
-0.5762035250663757,
-0.14601126313209534,
0.15137702226638794,
-0.4888836443424225,
1.0762813091278076,
0.17574454843997955,
-0.394763708114624,
-0.13078205287456512,
-0.4349803030490875,
-0.43360933661460876,
0.774328351020813,
0.6870183944702148,
-0.7742276787757874,
-0.32478049397468567,
0.4037984311580658,
0.452464759349823,
-0.5046095252037048,
0.26644086837768555,
0.6353030204772949,
0.2559458911418915,
-0.12348555028438568,
-0.9355565309524536,
-0.1926880180835724,
-0.2545739412307739,
0.10324887931346893,
0.03231530636548996,
-0.196353480219841,
1.1266928911209106,
-0.31098636984825134,
-0.3853996992111206,
0.0718199610710144,
0.8778986930847168,
-0.03959290683269501,
0.20722772181034088,
0.493051141500473,
0.40712079405784607,
0.6876752972602844,
-0.06205550953745842,
1.0428720712661743,
0.11296038329601288,
0.3053571879863739,
1.3486582040786743,
-0.14071348309516907,
1.0134464502334595,
0.434992253780365,
-0.26409587264060974,
0.8739863038063049,
0.24977128207683563,
0.49273377656936646,
0.3940264880657196,
0.16621819138526917,
-0.3546436131000519,
-0.46404150128364563,
0.12682700157165527,
-0.184501051902771,
0.9435213208198547,
0.3939627408981323,
-0.5349459648132324,
-0.3946359157562256,
0.3576246201992035,
-0.1403598040342331,
0.4023303985595703,
-0.41188356280326843,
1.0358918905258179,
0.3336637616157532,
-0.1545109748840332,
0.6824679374694824,
0.14926904439926147,
0.5245109796524048,
-0.5089301466941833,
-0.06646440923213959,
-0.2728745639324188,
0.1883305311203003,
-0.28247472643852234,
-0.2453441470861435,
-0.05069654434919357,
-0.04156697914004326,
-0.31702443957328796,
-0.15803347527980804,
0.474336177110672,
-0.6538823843002319,
-0.9450345635414124,
0.29468101263046265,
0.9828473329544067,
0.30110734701156616,
0.02035895735025406,
-0.51646488904953,
-0.31640133261680603,
-0.4939335882663727,
0.14715974032878876,
0.2691783607006073,
0.12186703830957413,
-0.06310179084539413,
0.6457028388977051,
0.25637781620025635,
0.2425103336572647,
0.16545462608337402,
0.18585199117660522,
0.4611935317516327,
-0.6749234795570374,
-0.6024032235145569,
-1.1273677349090576,
0.4287789762020111,
0.394178181886673,
-0.06697721034288406,
0.6019943952560425,
0.4990628957748413,
0.9614102244377136,
-0.27459606528282166,
0.7043701410293579,
0.2600102126598358,
0.02791198156774044,
-0.6215144395828247,
0.551419198513031,
-0.552734375,
0.20856043696403503,
-0.3866386413574219,
-0.950890064239502,
-0.3848181664943695,
0.8078905344009399,
-0.27017316222190857,
0.0479326955974102,
0.7758049964904785,
0.9184948205947876,
-0.3501865267753601,
0.09456264227628708,
0.504202663898468,
0.2760835289955139,
-0.08087819069623947,
0.3801444470882416,
0.9685190320014954,
-0.5800734162330627,
-0.06437288969755173,
-0.29707685112953186,
0.020879874005913734,
0.18374134600162506,
-0.9525030851364136,
-0.9990596175193787,
-0.5189416408538818,
-0.5322833061218262,
-0.056939419358968735,
0.2330319583415985,
1.3875818252563477,
0.6470967531204224,
-0.6470139622688293,
-0.5626716613769531,
-0.24959537386894226,
0.10745404660701752,
-0.5539432764053345,
-0.20182205736637115,
0.1306685358285904,
-0.49640482664108276,
-0.9833405613899231,
0.4100765287876129,
0.003150521544739604,
-0.10842833667993546,
-0.30533313751220703,
-0.079145148396492,
-0.5101207494735718,
-0.11716485023498535,
0.7148793935775757,
0.3949333131313324,
-0.8775903582572937,
-0.16165068745613098,
-0.0784096047282219,
-0.10393387079238892,
0.06181945651769638,
1.0328972339630127,
-0.9184816479682922,
0.45758798718452454,
0.5910954475402832,
0.5914658904075623,
0.2123987376689911,
-0.002532572951167822,
0.7333957552909851,
-1.3018471002578735,
0.40037572383880615,
0.03493141382932663,
0.43559208512306213,
0.11402856558561325,
-0.13033081591129303,
0.2765161693096161,
0.3305865228176117,
0.016863329336047173,
-0.6871529221534729,
0.3654825687408447,
-0.8435420393943787,
-0.5932766795158386,
1.1543278694152832,
-0.04463076591491699,
-0.3190923035144806,
-0.06885820627212524,
-0.05780213326215744,
0.05705586075782776,
-0.4588397741317749,
0.4307166039943695,
0.5790349245071411,
-0.10848245769739151,
-0.5509922504425049,
-0.6127005815505981,
0.34451162815093994,
0.356785386800766,
-0.6548093557357788,
0.04833249747753143,
0.3476611375808716,
0.33855539560317993,
0.24316735565662384,
0.4007069766521454,
-0.04805237427353859,
0.5648558139801025,
-0.2191586047410965,
0.12570717930793762,
-0.05134446173906326,
-0.4800741672515869,
-0.8066479563713074,
0.14528240263462067,
0.04618208855390549,
-0.34660452604293823
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10326v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10326v1
|
CDGP: Automatic Cloze Distractor Generation based on Pre-trained Language Model
| 2024-03-15T14:14:26 | 2024-03-15T14:14:26 |
Shang-Hsuan Chiang, Ssu-Cheng Wang, Yao-Chung Fan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Manually designing cloze test consumes enormous time and efforts. The major
challenge lies in wrong option (distractor) selection. Having carefully-design
distractors improves the effectiveness of learner ability assessment. As a
result, the idea of automatically generating cloze distractor is motivated. In
this paper, we investigate cloze distractor generation by exploring the
employment of pre-trained language models (PLMs) as an alternative for
candidate distractor generation. Experiments show that the PLM-enhanced model
brings a substantial performance improvement. Our best performing model
advances the state-of-the-art result from 14.94 to 34.17 (NDCG@10 score). Our
code and dataset is available at https://github.com/AndyChiangSH/CDGP.
|
[
-0.6340392231941223,
-0.9204578399658203,
0.3873256742954254,
-0.017309576272964478,
-0.4575630724430084,
-0.2893552780151367,
-0.5051270127296448,
-0.2981892228126526,
-0.37615904211997986,
0.601875364780426,
-0.4197671115398407,
-0.49499306082725525,
-0.774892270565033,
0.11793800443410873,
-0.30518752336502075,
0.9104711413383484,
0.09548026323318481,
-0.15479916334152222,
0.012089080177247524,
0.28293928503990173,
-0.6670107245445251,
-0.3237931728363037,
-0.8681728839874268,
0.008732710964977741,
0.05349297821521759,
0.3261834681034088,
0.5569799542427063,
0.44071099162101746,
0.26169195771217346,
0.34940728545188904,
0.11877758800983429,
0.21330411732196808,
-0.33335942029953003,
-0.10204818099737167,
0.10674576461315155,
-0.1351214051246643,
-0.435594767332077,
0.1850648820400238,
0.3173636496067047,
0.40977561473846436,
-0.3453986346721649,
0.13867202401161194,
0.19117142260074615,
0.4947579503059387,
-0.7116240859031677,
0.006613132078200579,
-0.8410704135894775,
-0.18075862526893616,
-0.21835774183273315,
0.09108040481805801,
-0.5543734431266785,
-0.5167556405067444,
0.4217264950275421,
-0.4942394495010376,
0.4093756675720215,
-0.12604835629463196,
0.7346525192260742,
0.5385596752166748,
-0.20988576114177704,
-0.627589762210846,
-0.3519337475299835,
0.7914568185806274,
-0.8358736634254456,
0.29448387026786804,
0.27296575903892517,
0.25386008620262146,
-0.1107855960726738,
-0.7400779724121094,
-0.575447142124176,
-0.8048759698867798,
-0.04121755436062813,
0.12530425190925598,
0.30316951870918274,
0.16358733177185059,
0.17979596555233002,
0.2987198233604431,
-0.7747522592544556,
0.12132007628679276,
-0.38574129343032837,
-0.13601961731910706,
0.8516891598701477,
-0.030662693083286285,
0.458028107881546,
0.0032426698599010706,
-0.6247707605361938,
0.047646429389715195,
-0.6209756135940552,
-0.2193640172481537,
0.374047189950943,
0.0516994334757328,
0.11880412697792053,
0.26689472794532776,
-0.10153788328170776,
1.3292288780212402,
0.3091243803501129,
-0.08802559971809387,
0.15769022703170776,
-0.3314596712589264,
-0.08788086473941803,
0.15771333873271942,
0.7748432159423828,
0.012383329682052135,
0.39078953862190247,
0.10398732870817184,
-0.05875429883599281,
0.14021998643875122,
0.3029516339302063,
-0.8161919713020325,
-0.6275619268417358,
0.22089049220085144,
-0.11586450040340424,
-0.3869410753250122,
-0.03417208790779114,
-0.8040745854377747,
-0.1762910634279251,
-0.3535396158695221,
0.21034400165081024,
-0.6211308240890503,
-0.16932694613933563,
0.28708121180534363,
0.12548580765724182,
-0.017588157206773758,
0.15026527643203735,
-0.4906155467033386,
0.12441868335008621,
0.1516091376543045,
0.5967329144477844,
-0.463097482919693,
-0.3201964497566223,
-0.6104934811592102,
-0.018293535336852074,
-0.1335771530866623,
0.8260766863822937,
-0.5123509764671326,
-0.5336369872093201,
-0.009463478811085224,
-0.40126141905784607,
-0.4022819697856903,
-0.8056566119194031,
0.6335838437080383,
-0.4422082304954529,
0.5082452297210693,
0.1007341518998146,
-0.7554941773414612,
-0.12719808518886566,
0.024448348209261894,
-0.5156842470169067,
1.196183681488037,
0.14505133032798767,
-0.5287474989891052,
0.6305280327796936,
-0.9856892228126526,
-0.2644122540950775,
0.39344272017478943,
0.16674759984016418,
-0.7422538995742798,
-0.2712012231349945,
0.3072267472743988,
0.1945231705904007,
-0.05904726684093475,
0.49870485067367554,
-0.1625862568616867,
-0.24173837900161743,
0.3187238574028015,
-0.018340881913900375,
0.8552870750427246,
0.30901920795440674,
-0.5339213609695435,
0.2755683958530426,
-0.9415992498397827,
0.4766557812690735,
0.07063138484954834,
-0.47775739431381226,
-0.1426619440317154,
0.10177218168973923,
-0.029095856472849846,
0.6404159069061279,
0.3648133873939514,
-0.36366182565689087,
-0.21307890117168427,
-0.17119668424129486,
0.1526983380317688,
0.6630007028579712,
-0.2253057062625885,
0.46991750597953796,
-0.1885545253753662,
0.566204845905304,
-0.09740176051855087,
0.0767681822180748,
0.04738976061344147,
-0.23517905175685883,
-0.7646136283874512,
-0.6559360027313232,
0.5075427293777466,
0.6144136786460876,
-0.4575715661048889,
0.916435956954956,
0.00999708753079176,
-0.45291945338249207,
-0.44147780537605286,
0.6128926277160645,
0.40714094042778015,
0.3085702359676361,
0.2898794114589691,
-0.47015801072120667,
-0.5054466128349304,
-0.4828352928161621,
-0.1468702107667923,
0.05774880573153496,
-0.10789570957422256,
0.25648000836372375,
0.293161004781723,
-0.10403871536254883,
1.0932539701461792,
-0.7438759207725525,
-0.4030488431453705,
-0.669471800327301,
0.09857167303562164,
-0.22314892709255219,
0.4783317446708679,
0.6532036662101746,
-0.7839492559432983,
-0.8041499853134155,
-0.382946640253067,
-0.40800270438194275,
-0.7364736795425415,
-0.05700226500630379,
-0.1144380122423172,
0.3533085882663727,
0.3340885043144226,
-0.6736851334571838,
0.3244214355945587,
0.3868037462234497,
-0.09885309636592865,
0.9285557270050049,
-0.2087068110704422,
-0.305087685585022,
-0.7947803139686584,
0.23739047348499298,
-0.10059362649917603,
-0.1352420151233673,
-0.7915701270103455,
0.0508151613175869,
-0.054491475224494934,
-0.38448217511177063,
-0.6130459904670715,
0.6283518075942993,
-0.6268071532249451,
0.3051166832447052,
-0.72267085313797,
0.6255503296852112,
-0.289416640996933,
0.30413326621055603,
0.46296176314353943,
0.7965319752693176,
0.6863998174667358,
-0.9669017195701599,
0.08130286633968353,
0.23408786952495575,
-0.35342076420783997,
0.24193832278251648,
-0.5663906931877136,
0.2927558124065399,
0.07551576942205429,
0.06224191561341286,
-0.8432040810585022,
-0.10841146856546402,
0.27451589703559875,
-0.15041185915470123,
0.32900339365005493,
0.06730064749717712,
-0.34433069825172424,
-0.6549283862113953,
-0.09898886829614639,
0.19763775169849396,
0.7519406676292419,
-0.6203871965408325,
0.2295481115579605,
0.3929136395454407,
-0.38221806287765503,
-0.39935848116874695,
-0.15353137254714966,
-0.14331413805484772,
-0.4441864490509033,
-0.6624555587768555,
0.11963704973459244,
-0.5024829506874084,
-0.07695762068033218,
-0.4387235939502716,
0.08299171179533005,
-0.2807054817676544,
0.15235359966754913,
0.06325790286064148,
0.21388307213783264,
-0.06093772128224373,
-0.03229793161153793,
-0.39196592569351196,
-0.09247935563325882,
0.028376499190926552,
-0.21369123458862305,
0.8493989706039429,
0.045082926750183105,
-0.11932829022407532,
-0.30852171778678894,
0.023376023396849632,
0.07029920816421509,
-0.64031583070755,
0.5642767548561096,
0.6622586846351624,
0.0187037605792284,
-0.6929357647895813,
-0.6699700355529785,
-0.2132650464773178,
-0.5383838415145874,
0.4939037561416626,
-0.08775221556425095,
-0.5970644354820251,
0.21808430552482605,
-0.23867958784103394,
-0.2671312987804413,
-0.17587418854236603,
0.5752644538879395,
0.33414214849472046,
0.7667365670204163,
0.4343177080154419,
0.09753386676311493,
0.7538921236991882,
-0.03262817859649658,
0.3937620520591736,
-0.5296632647514343,
0.16431915760040283,
-0.09180725365877151,
0.18860109150409698,
-0.31753042340278625,
-0.24831730127334595,
0.30720236897468567,
0.323998361825943,
0.09170792251825333,
0.35438159108161926,
-0.6348573565483093,
0.3848987817764282,
0.5290668606758118,
0.08510015159845352,
-0.07948969304561615,
-0.31349706649780273,
-0.14880245923995972,
0.1958879977464676,
-0.6989683508872986,
-0.7828266024589539,
1.0165075063705444,
-0.04866268113255501,
0.4997786283493042,
-0.19550500810146332,
0.7926904559135437,
0.16993950307369232,
0.430010050535202,
-0.3624372184276581,
0.9622461795806885,
-0.002469441154971719,
-0.7571364045143127,
-0.33496740460395813,
-0.2521125078201294,
-0.9055541157722473,
0.35354506969451904,
-0.04276285320520401,
-0.5981264114379883,
-0.09281966090202332,
0.4735771417617798,
-0.5450785160064697,
-0.014498022384941578,
-0.9175199866294861,
1.0589854717254639,
-0.5456907749176025,
-0.5197387337684631,
-0.08046574145555496,
-0.559112548828125,
0.5777305960655212,
-0.2557528614997864,
-0.072676882147789,
-0.04057435318827629,
0.3327040672302246,
0.6159158945083618,
-0.5421959757804871,
0.7936308979988098,
-0.391805499792099,
-0.08933541923761368,
1.038238763809204,
0.13112317025661469,
0.42856115102767944,
-0.015525368973612785,
-0.15322338044643402,
0.019010035321116447,
-0.4891943037509918,
-0.4259699285030365,
-0.20052692294120789,
0.47956517338752747,
-0.4864204227924347,
-0.8399471640586853,
-0.3567536175251007,
-0.8420059680938721,
0.10433164238929749,
0.40961572527885437,
0.2635260820388794,
0.19794206321239471,
-0.26915955543518066,
-0.33471977710723877,
0.4815598726272583,
-0.4107552468776703,
0.6495562791824341,
0.807701826095581,
-0.012113676406443119,
-0.29311540722846985,
0.8452571630477905,
0.10533754527568817,
0.49672847986221313,
-0.05481022968888283,
0.047064900398254395,
-0.3618827760219574,
-0.7958221435546875,
-0.32091230154037476,
0.2061445116996765,
-0.4544168710708618,
0.024594025686383247,
-0.3570520877838135,
-0.30832523107528687,
-0.40460970997810364,
-0.3040692210197449,
-0.1804744452238083,
-0.07409324496984482,
-0.3213129937648773,
-0.1789921671152115,
-0.07558295130729675,
0.6215717196464539,
-0.05292798578739166,
0.636336088180542,
-0.6569173336029053,
0.03150278702378273,
0.4069216251373291,
0.11203782260417938,
-0.32346710562705994,
-0.23712776601314545,
-0.17597080767154694,
-0.030128823593258858,
-0.8697639107704163,
-0.7938805818557739,
0.6079827547073364,
0.2542063891887665,
0.6327009201049805,
0.6028069853782654,
0.2004585713148117,
0.4789848029613495,
-0.48945724964141846,
0.8424186706542969,
-0.03848540410399437,
-1.1310064792633057,
0.6698099970817566,
-0.27924782037734985,
0.23161408305168152,
0.37017619609832764,
0.04884040355682373,
0.04674985632300377,
-0.5428281426429749,
-0.7919004559516907,
-0.7239323258399963,
0.7400693297386169,
0.3283819556236267,
-0.3921531140804291,
-0.31843262910842896,
0.20011396706104279,
0.29652291536331177,
0.3344520330429077,
-0.9479902982711792,
-0.05914276838302612,
-0.2131391167640686,
-0.3004758656024933,
-0.09837939590215683,
-0.42186081409454346,
0.2597132921218872,
0.25463202595710754,
0.718836784362793,
-0.02244064211845398,
0.07723429054021835,
0.14722581207752228,
-0.5966230034828186,
0.12099462002515793,
0.5084074139595032,
0.8288019895553589,
0.848721981048584,
-0.22820530831813812,
0.02340545877814293,
0.40260806679725647,
-0.372628778219223,
0.02630191668868065,
0.42384135723114014,
-0.23647631704807281,
0.0569026954472065,
-0.0032887200359255075,
0.6651920080184937,
-0.015698585659265518,
-0.9728236794471741,
0.5243108868598938,
0.3367418646812439,
0.015938129276037216,
-0.6955676674842834,
0.41250360012054443,
-0.16366441547870636,
-0.22892895340919495,
0.10059552639722824,
-0.029700320214033127,
0.04107680544257164,
-0.06955929100513458,
0.4380863606929779,
0.5237401127815247,
-0.1508716344833374,
-0.35031771659851074,
0.8082885146141052,
0.5138252377510071,
-0.24081851541996002,
0.4247552752494812,
-0.455747127532959,
-0.7506662011146545,
0.7031318545341492,
0.7521224617958069,
0.5148971080780029,
-0.684329628944397,
0.30787402391433716,
0.45920753479003906,
0.20307114720344543,
0.04228978976607323,
0.23973697423934937,
-0.07473906874656677,
-0.6202360987663269,
-0.2783856689929962,
-0.4013439416885376,
0.06813667714595795,
0.2941094636917114,
-0.44351884722709656,
0.4837125539779663,
-0.18463629484176636,
-0.23258306086063385,
-0.4516552984714508,
0.07322419434785843,
-0.6834644079208374,
0.4896971881389618,
0.5395143032073975,
0.7215776443481445,
-0.6946885585784912,
0.9893284440040588,
0.5996217131614685,
-0.3789682388305664,
-0.4223850667476654,
0.008237008936703205,
-0.35077911615371704,
-0.6232397556304932,
0.9506540894508362,
0.2599886655807495,
0.06783285737037659,
0.04311072453856468,
-0.4038034677505493,
-0.8110955953598022,
0.8918768167495728,
0.265179306268692,
-0.5333658456802368,
-0.039200309664011,
0.5947450399398804,
0.5115746259689331,
-0.4058620035648346,
0.4717114567756653,
0.5356626510620117,
0.39896857738494873,
-0.5213868021965027,
-0.9767720699310303,
0.07604247331619263,
0.010684109292924404,
0.1671282947063446,
0.2842753529548645,
-0.7547231316566467,
0.6757349371910095,
-0.39248159527778625,
-0.39559778571128845,
0.21228604018688202,
0.46312034130096436,
0.5299338102340698,
0.2666918933391571,
0.684411346912384,
0.7104979753494263,
0.6828201413154602,
0.0900677740573883,
1.0587818622589111,
-0.6473764777183533,
0.29142019152641296,
1.2265901565551758,
-0.6461519598960876,
0.6089026927947998,
0.24429826438426971,
0.06628373265266418,
0.4586818516254425,
0.5045062899589539,
-0.027844222262501717,
0.6715551018714905,
0.5429851412773132,
-0.3773110508918762,
-0.5392603278160095,
0.17910021543502808,
-0.11208569258451462,
0.3793655335903168,
0.2876775860786438,
-0.4775404632091522,
-0.2624519169330597,
0.13491086661815643,
-0.022504733875393867,
0.15850646793842316,
-0.16763822734355927,
0.6381765604019165,
0.10519729554653168,
-0.8409729599952698,
0.6394209861755371,
-0.27805963158607483,
0.5922091007232666,
-0.7783415913581848,
0.1046004593372345,
0.14409595727920532,
0.4228230118751526,
0.04931075498461723,
-0.37659409642219543,
-0.04737845063209534,
-0.1400139182806015,
0.06269550323486328,
-0.051468390971422195,
0.9681560397148132,
-0.8217414617538452,
-0.3049546480178833,
0.3843698799610138,
0.4525339901447296,
0.05665731057524681,
0.11697445064783096,
-0.8206453919410706,
-0.26986101269721985,
0.04785837233066559,
-0.17675000429153442,
0.28455764055252075,
0.1903887838125229,
0.11194451153278351,
0.8061456680297852,
0.611740231513977,
0.017418954521417618,
0.7428848147392273,
-0.24318033456802368,
0.49430522322654724,
-0.289127916097641,
-0.6072105169296265,
-0.7800984382629395,
0.5778082609176636,
-0.15439319610595703,
-0.447414368391037,
0.8131880760192871,
0.6321234107017517,
1.030235767364502,
-0.5321376919746399,
1.0621949434280396,
-0.22893159091472626,
0.5982263684272766,
-0.5366693139076233,
0.6627726554870605,
-0.04739367961883545,
0.19704985618591309,
-0.12865731120109558,
-0.7144775390625,
-0.13515205681324005,
0.5994377136230469,
-0.8275959491729736,
0.24836167693138123,
0.8507881164550781,
0.9102606773376465,
-0.04988966882228851,
-0.14874961972236633,
0.3174237608909607,
0.0037975504528731108,
0.22919951379299164,
0.7266748547554016,
0.9186882972717285,
-0.24132271111011505,
0.7638775706291199,
-0.26937735080718994,
-0.03535046800971031,
-0.11729971319437027,
-0.7356909513473511,
-1.288927435874939,
-0.4387742280960083,
-0.7089328169822693,
-0.034681107848882675,
0.14246098697185516,
0.8984968066215515,
0.8235338926315308,
-0.821440577507019,
-0.2367265820503235,
-0.33645251393318176,
-0.11011328548192978,
-0.23282267153263092,
-0.2752663791179657,
0.4741073250770569,
-0.7699505686759949,
-0.8748630881309509,
0.28399938344955444,
-0.3104887306690216,
0.05895482748746872,
0.16116368770599365,
-0.22753050923347473,
-0.28355056047439575,
0.004643421620130539,
0.4370565116405487,
0.04859399050474167,
-0.664991557598114,
-0.23614972829818726,
-0.402866393327713,
0.003285001963376999,
0.12070035189390182,
0.8758286833763123,
-0.7511336803436279,
0.3576098382472992,
0.2027146965265274,
0.3841560184955597,
0.1947706937789917,
0.29875749349594116,
0.6501177549362183,
-0.7663541436195374,
0.19769610464572906,
0.07280725985765457,
0.4164341986179352,
0.32754045724868774,
-0.34347429871559143,
0.29112762212753296,
0.08928177505731583,
-0.7651711106300354,
-0.7589450478553772,
0.28744956851005554,
-0.7910605072975159,
-0.29656437039375305,
1.2975128889083862,
-0.2782638669013977,
-0.10760742425918579,
-0.17960448563098907,
-0.6002532243728638,
0.30254682898521423,
-0.29056409001350403,
1.1907161474227905,
0.6228367686271667,
-0.08896246552467346,
-0.23144617676734924,
-0.4706982672214508,
0.7821680903434753,
0.6379712820053101,
-0.9643911123275757,
-0.012644026428461075,
0.4705282747745514,
0.6157700419425964,
0.28149911761283875,
0.5785358548164368,
0.10570340603590012,
0.39986899495124817,
-0.19914016127586365,
0.45244309306144714,
-0.2641589045524597,
-0.11067799478769302,
-0.0167846642434597,
0.3505713939666748,
0.09236785024404526,
-0.3637489974498749
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10301v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10301v2
|
Uni-SMART: Universal Science Multimodal Analysis and Research Transformer
| 2024-03-15T13:43:47 | 2024-06-15T16:03:29 |
Hengxing Cai, Xiaochen Cai, Shuwen Yang, Jiankun Wang, Lin Yao, Zhifeng Gao, Junhan Chang, Sihang Li, Mingjun Xu, Changxin Wang, Hongshuai Wang, Yongge Li, Mujie Lin, Yaqi Li, Yuqi Yin, Linfeng Zhang, Guolin Ke
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
In scientific research and its application, scientific literature analysis is
crucial as it allows researchers to build on the work of others. However, the
fast growth of scientific knowledge has led to a massive increase in scholarly
articles, making in-depth literature analysis increasingly challenging and
time-consuming. The emergence of Large Language Models (LLMs) has offered a new
way to address this challenge. Known for their strong abilities in summarizing
texts, LLMs are seen as a potential tool to improve the analysis of scientific
literature. However, existing LLMs have their own limits. Scientific literature
often includes a wide range of multimodal elements, such as tables, charts, and
molecule, which are hard for text-focused LLMs to understand and analyze. This
issue points to the urgent need for new solutions that can fully understand and
analyze multimodal content in scientific literature. To answer this demand, we
present \textbf{Uni-SMART} (Universal Science Multimodal Analysis and Research
Transformer), an innovative model designed for in-depth understanding of
multimodal scientific literature. Through rigorous quantitative evaluation
across several domains, Uni-SMART demonstrates superior performance over other
text-focused LLMs. Furthermore, our exploration extends to practical
applications, including patent infringement detection and nuanced analysis of
charts. These applications not only highlight Uni-SMART's adaptability but also
its potential to revolutionize how we interact with scientific literature.
|
[
-0.16993167996406555,
-0.3853294551372528,
0.43764549493789673,
0.43242865800857544,
-0.3134995102882385,
0.2808777391910553,
-0.09907460957765579,
-0.33734825253486633,
0.09412764012813568,
0.6158266067504883,
-0.2562701404094696,
-0.2697112560272217,
-0.44106990098953247,
0.2609560191631317,
-0.4908544421195984,
1.1583142280578613,
0.18155908584594727,
0.259834885597229,
-0.5315178036689758,
-0.261699914932251,
-0.13353055715560913,
-0.2931101322174072,
0.16434186697006226,
-0.4385746121406555,
0.5887079834938049,
0.5024459958076477,
0.6246404647827148,
0.05878165364265442,
0.7806481122970581,
0.46834009885787964,
0.016007330268621445,
0.115328848361969,
-0.30816650390625,
0.20561692118644714,
-0.3962869942188263,
-0.5345451831817627,
-0.541304349899292,
-0.15114612877368927,
0.8330344557762146,
0.804456353187561,
0.34836694598197937,
0.1887224167585373,
-0.013867651112377644,
0.7343071103096008,
-0.4078198969364166,
0.1879144161939621,
-0.5041166543960571,
0.11610564589500427,
-0.24503159523010254,
-0.3842281401157379,
-0.46670815348625183,
-0.02419366128742695,
0.13074186444282532,
-0.6541666388511658,
0.19615298509597778,
0.04957391694188118,
0.6523522734642029,
0.07310079783201218,
-0.7634205222129822,
0.11187382787466049,
-0.921798825263977,
0.9724950790405273,
-0.611396849155426,
0.3954564332962036,
-0.5300047993659973,
0.20918087661266327,
-0.4208222031593323,
-1.240005373954773,
-0.8234978914260864,
-0.2305108904838562,
-0.09201614558696747,
0.25517597794532776,
-0.30316123366355896,
-0.08622327446937561,
-0.1296420693397522,
0.1003551259636879,
-0.7344908714294434,
0.10105318576097488,
-0.4569784998893738,
-0.19877532124519348,
0.5606561899185181,
0.3195265233516693,
0.5851818323135376,
-0.5666810274124146,
-0.5213577151298523,
-0.05396650359034538,
-0.29299506545066833,
0.022228995338082314,
-0.07102268189191818,
0.029171137139201164,
0.22931122779846191,
0.6988627910614014,
-0.01745523512363434,
0.33658021688461304,
-0.42281386256217957,
-0.22585925459861755,
0.05886523425579071,
-0.5157545804977417,
-0.05985176935791969,
-0.06274301558732986,
1.1993930339813232,
0.3450016677379608,
0.28403007984161377,
-0.08321253955364227,
0.01944270171225071,
0.0019065975211560726,
0.11529498547315598,
-1.011130452156067,
-0.23727728426456451,
0.25681957602500916,
-0.5499986410140991,
-0.13593648374080658,
-0.04442017525434494,
-1.1008418798446655,
-0.600145697593689,
-0.3823637366294861,
0.3610689640045166,
-0.3517935276031494,
-0.3976154923439026,
0.17993885278701782,
-0.21605801582336426,
-0.1385449767112732,
0.15116117894649506,
-0.6088618040084839,
0.13111867010593414,
0.4616853892803192,
0.908401370048523,
-0.2629244327545166,
-0.25591376423835754,
0.022806737571954727,
0.3154688775539398,
0.06737153977155685,
1.2128218412399292,
-0.6465272307395935,
-0.6190241575241089,
-0.46840035915374756,
0.11103439331054688,
-0.2864583730697632,
-0.05410429462790489,
0.6479743719100952,
-0.5739176869392395,
0.15789048373699188,
-0.013392460532486439,
-0.3771005868911743,
-0.3101380467414856,
0.02148016169667244,
-0.7725553512573242,
0.6555267572402954,
-0.004933438263833523,
-0.9125213623046875,
0.13690826296806335,
-1.1863540410995483,
-0.19451767206192017,
0.3137443959712982,
-0.23579025268554688,
-0.39312541484832764,
0.18699216842651367,
0.13828632235527039,
0.5149611234664917,
-0.47655174136161804,
0.5504777431488037,
-0.3658248484134674,
-0.2591996490955353,
0.8064270615577698,
-0.5652144551277161,
0.7749258875846863,
0.4792744219303131,
-0.05625347048044205,
0.5377287268638611,
-0.8864384293556213,
-0.02732383832335472,
0.1508425772190094,
-0.18827442824840546,
-0.5151703357696533,
-0.13116802275180817,
0.7652329802513123,
-0.07898756116628647,
0.26952433586120605,
-0.8844122886657715,
0.37429022789001465,
0.01206147763878107,
0.5903044939041138,
0.4015255868434906,
-0.39449256658554077,
0.5551467537879944,
0.03925897553563118,
0.492177814245224,
-0.19604909420013428,
0.2591964304447174,
-0.33636584877967834,
-0.4108751714229584,
-0.44328567385673523,
-0.7350388765335083,
0.6605885624885559,
0.6110685467720032,
-0.5315586924552917,
0.17403608560562134,
-0.6590297222137451,
-0.5277244448661804,
-0.4506402611732483,
0.10540038347244263,
0.13771650195121765,
0.3899614214897156,
0.284159779548645,
-0.26548293232917786,
-0.5939846634864807,
-0.6365430951118469,
-0.35890302062034607,
0.1795547753572464,
-0.1683860868215561,
-0.08158191293478012,
0.7381749153137207,
-0.6930399537086487,
1.179349660873413,
-0.3803732991218567,
-0.3366810381412506,
-0.5536642074584961,
0.46814659237861633,
0.06845470517873764,
0.3778555691242218,
0.323281466960907,
-1.1807423830032349,
-0.3892083466053009,
0.1979396939277649,
-0.9399778246879578,
-0.07181859016418457,
-0.06513483077287674,
0.024703938513994217,
-0.10339720547199249,
0.5880274772644043,
-0.7088902592658997,
0.28525587916374207,
0.3658961355686188,
-0.6081513166427612,
0.5414100885391235,
-0.3499203324317932,
0.15676288306713104,
-1.0721267461776733,
0.421229749917984,
0.058994799852371216,
0.08892793208360672,
-0.6053202748298645,
0.011593235656619072,
0.3635486364364624,
-0.4218010902404785,
-0.35429030656814575,
0.5690608024597168,
-0.4334057569503784,
0.062831349670887,
-0.38085681200027466,
-0.017034148797392845,
0.41137686371803284,
0.0877213180065155,
-0.1831308752298355,
0.4776909053325653,
0.19352267682552338,
-0.2890970706939697,
0.3061876893043518,
0.1875634789466858,
-0.3573663830757141,
0.395851731300354,
-0.772446870803833,
-0.1655176877975464,
-0.27699199318885803,
0.34455373883247375,
-1.1570258140563965,
-0.3538528382778168,
-0.2769705057144165,
-0.273196280002594,
0.473243772983551,
0.19768904149532318,
-0.6450543999671936,
-0.43600165843963623,
-0.4395608901977539,
0.5840821266174316,
0.11926104873418808,
-0.423605740070343,
1.0752570629119873,
0.35760223865509033,
-0.410434365272522,
-0.4896021783351898,
-0.41350874304771423,
0.2470676153898239,
-0.18251773715019226,
-0.8419236540794373,
0.5007286071777344,
-0.33583781123161316,
-0.42529091238975525,
0.15692134201526642,
0.07276450842618942,
-0.1809658259153366,
-0.07706571370363235,
0.200340136885643,
0.495833158493042,
-0.039843928068876266,
0.09735269844532013,
0.10737890005111694,
-0.39379942417144775,
-0.057867784053087234,
-0.15929365158081055,
0.2571117579936981,
-0.3321717381477356,
-0.1901635378599167,
-0.5749307870864868,
0.5011130571365356,
1.2938613891601562,
-0.3474460244178772,
0.35298940539360046,
0.7152858376502991,
-0.00662846677005291,
0.19920910894870758,
-0.4083688259124756,
-0.062144935131073,
-0.5120474100112915,
0.6195455193519592,
-0.191157728433609,
-0.8478726744651794,
0.4010164737701416,
-0.37880727648735046,
0.020602185279130936,
0.47474610805511475,
0.32933494448661804,
-0.19878050684928894,
1.1791478395462036,
1.001255750656128,
-0.03900020942091942,
0.2857836186885834,
-0.045149415731430054,
0.33049169182777405,
-0.7767356634140015,
-0.7230108380317688,
-0.5982527136802673,
-0.34439152479171753,
-0.4427931010723114,
-0.25352731347084045,
0.7750053405761719,
-0.050161924213171005,
-0.13756108283996582,
-0.029581112787127495,
-0.7192437648773193,
0.510487973690033,
0.3814331293106079,
-0.24796177446842194,
0.7696506381034851,
0.19269435107707977,
-0.25430354475975037,
-0.2605791389942169,
-0.6050288677215576,
-0.5854014754295349,
1.241410255432129,
0.4600975215435028,
1.0564342737197876,
0.022805413231253624,
0.05904664099216461,
0.3040624260902405,
0.3724038898944855,
-0.8082417845726013,
0.6079075336456299,
-0.27092593908309937,
-0.5357091426849365,
-0.3818161189556122,
-0.2885834574699402,
-1.1392722129821777,
0.6265816688537598,
-0.18807584047317505,
-0.6022176146507263,
0.29411375522613525,
-0.2047402411699295,
-0.425462007522583,
0.4113725423812866,
-0.7308673858642578,
0.8177862167358398,
-0.5655723214149475,
-0.13188615441322327,
-0.11692781746387482,
-0.6085560917854309,
0.40100881457328796,
-0.17808547616004944,
0.42688560485839844,
-0.07958520948886871,
-0.059452448040246964,
0.8535796403884888,
-0.012394048273563385,
0.7811304926872253,
0.1767481118440628,
0.03254205361008644,
0.22951053082942963,
0.2107265442609787,
0.045248229056596756,
0.23772978782653809,
0.06358349323272705,
0.12942473590373993,
0.2583767771720886,
-0.3936246335506439,
-0.6435742378234863,
0.8648602962493896,
-0.6275100111961365,
-0.28827837109565735,
-0.6371842622756958,
-1.2129422426223755,
0.0021850853227078915,
0.3179241418838501,
0.06461694836616516,
0.41910848021507263,
-0.10497961938381195,
0.3455042243003845,
0.7694642543792725,
-0.09450690448284149,
0.6056114435195923,
0.9362074732780457,
-0.422717809677124,
-0.27151283621788025,
1.1011252403259277,
0.0653180480003357,
-0.2005566656589508,
0.4608266353607178,
0.4147985279560089,
-0.4285793900489807,
-0.5604615211486816,
-0.3048590421676636,
0.28423911333084106,
-0.524395227432251,
-0.195917010307312,
-0.990985631942749,
0.02497430332005024,
-0.513677179813385,
0.0528952032327652,
-0.34295353293418884,
-0.5687446594238281,
-0.3524915277957916,
0.07232192158699036,
0.6186051368713379,
0.7945826053619385,
-0.17748768627643585,
0.07294093072414398,
-1.0054394006729126,
0.33616751432418823,
0.41209885478019714,
0.231693834066391,
-0.23580621182918549,
-0.38288894295692444,
0.03192006051540375,
-0.2955855429172516,
-0.4936244785785675,
-0.6771149039268494,
0.6079413890838623,
0.24509978294372559,
0.3240533471107483,
0.566030740737915,
-0.07734528928995132,
0.4371306896209717,
-0.4685746729373932,
0.566211998462677,
0.41754037141799927,
-0.7596521377563477,
0.21818135678768158,
-0.45490700006484985,
0.3937664031982422,
0.4459909200668335,
0.5817921161651611,
-0.3855462074279785,
-0.05043374001979828,
-0.2788366675376892,
-1.0759567022323608,
0.14120028913021088,
-0.07333513349294662,
0.12878750264644623,
0.42480823397636414,
0.009821011684834957,
0.1572996973991394,
0.07185965031385422,
-0.9849703907966614,
0.1090787723660469,
-0.4822898805141449,
-0.31714415550231934,
-0.06654558330774307,
-0.26805952191352844,
-0.19394433498382568,
-0.643051028251648,
0.33624911308288574,
-0.4329918622970581,
0.3070710003376007,
0.167461559176445,
-0.2597515881061554,
-0.07137072831392288,
0.6542088985443115,
0.48111334443092346,
0.6253775954246521,
-0.23279327154159546,
0.284640371799469,
-0.18779289722442627,
-0.6218525767326355,
-0.26415809988975525,
0.4179081916809082,
-0.12083398550748825,
-0.011411168612539768,
0.33460333943367004,
0.2604743540287018,
0.5212389826774597,
-1.0673714876174927,
0.28813132643699646,
-0.13618218898773193,
0.038838908076286316,
-0.1715053915977478,
-0.16766181588172913,
0.17536205053329468,
0.4291587173938751,
0.656987726688385,
0.1933850795030594,
0.4184630215167999,
-0.6131898760795593,
0.20203746855258942,
0.5979595184326172,
-0.4551530182361603,
-0.41386035084724426,
0.606063187122345,
0.2678050994873047,
0.015062294900417328,
0.40403488278388977,
-0.08826348930597305,
-0.5989195108413696,
0.555768609046936,
0.672687828540802,
0.5322428941726685,
-0.0887136235833168,
0.47048506140708923,
-0.18013878166675568,
0.16022680699825287,
0.25162437558174133,
0.48959535360336304,
0.26493293046951294,
-0.5045911073684692,
-0.5479090213775635,
-0.653749942779541,
-0.2968418300151825,
0.12413759529590607,
-0.4545230269432068,
-0.06891896575689316,
-0.1603425145149231,
-0.03841196000576019,
0.2452097088098526,
-0.06260994076728821,
-0.43795233964920044,
-0.02073279768228531,
-0.1368086040019989,
0.6758437752723694,
-0.6503108143806458,
0.7216261029243469,
0.6939899921417236,
-0.3232802748680115,
-0.34824270009994507,
-0.45774441957473755,
0.12197863310575485,
-0.35531851649284363,
0.8212016224861145,
0.09819959849119186,
-0.13723087310791016,
-0.06600158661603928,
-0.8048584461212158,
-0.8167202472686768,
1.251391887664795,
0.28100505471229553,
-0.63924241065979,
0.22009606659412384,
0.2728934586048126,
0.6945298910140991,
-0.2957489788532257,
0.5683161020278931,
0.5018576979637146,
0.6730530858039856,
-0.091938816010952,
-0.8841174840927124,
-0.0248692836612463,
-0.5221397876739502,
-0.13145790994167328,
0.25267499685287476,
-0.6887450218200684,
0.9857805967330933,
-0.3689287006855011,
0.010430953465402126,
0.1732141524553299,
0.9147685170173645,
0.12982715666294098,
0.6490641236305237,
0.18401837348937988,
0.340657502412796,
0.8009892702102661,
0.045799482613801956,
0.9019539952278137,
-0.06861501932144165,
0.44261130690574646,
0.6860657930374146,
-0.477577269077301,
0.5918848514556885,
0.5045477151870728,
-0.006003126036375761,
0.8421118259429932,
0.11070221662521362,
-0.267234742641449,
0.32314252853393555,
0.05774524062871933,
-0.4568295478820801,
-0.15023669600486755,
-0.5724394917488098,
-0.31570664048194885,
0.4879360795021057,
0.5593239068984985,
-0.0850321352481842,
-0.20980246365070343,
0.289838582277298,
0.13922210037708282,
0.24062581360340118,
-0.3678082823753357,
0.33724722266197205,
0.12411057949066162,
-0.2505270838737488,
0.13570402562618256,
0.0437532477080822,
0.8406230211257935,
-0.821855902671814,
0.09824693948030472,
-0.05359184741973877,
0.35910677909851074,
-0.296955943107605,
-0.6914559006690979,
-0.01056390255689621,
0.02611200511455536,
-0.24865642189979553,
0.012799820862710476,
0.8680005073547363,
-0.20655207335948944,
-0.8321084976196289,
0.4447466731071472,
0.4108167588710785,
0.09621066600084305,
0.04870090261101723,
-0.6848219037055969,
-0.04883642494678497,
-0.09399198740720749,
-0.3933681547641754,
0.5710683465003967,
0.6126484870910645,
-0.2154455929994583,
0.9713010191917419,
0.8162738084793091,
-0.25951409339904785,
0.01602059416472912,
0.174588143825531,
0.9100820422172546,
-0.7706842422485352,
-0.14675378799438477,
-0.5704228281974792,
0.7939180135726929,
-0.11171822249889374,
-0.36380821466445923,
0.8357475399971008,
0.4894081652164459,
0.3308412432670593,
-0.1607542484998703,
0.9101301431655884,
0.0774872750043869,
0.3080562353134155,
-0.17537659406661987,
1.0647052526474,
-0.5918222069740295,
0.0762864425778389,
-0.3621377646923065,
-0.6473160982131958,
-0.7212550640106201,
0.27640366554260254,
0.08852539211511612,
-0.2324032187461853,
0.8902894854545593,
0.647378146648407,
-0.2068832963705063,
0.2730712294578552,
0.2103601098060608,
0.2708415985107422,
0.3884888291358948,
0.12971723079681396,
0.7288196682929993,
-0.15236233174800873,
0.7625688314437866,
-0.02821865864098072,
-0.37617942690849304,
-0.10347199440002441,
-1.0005288124084473,
-1.0538893938064575,
-0.41285592317581177,
-0.12968608736991882,
-0.18122315406799316,
-0.32605209946632385,
0.718066930770874,
0.4140804409980774,
-0.9412829875946045,
-0.32474949955940247,
0.06540972739458084,
0.016170630231499672,
0.002624664455652237,
-0.2762123942375183,
0.5764631628990173,
-0.1387176662683487,
-0.6749223470687866,
0.6139369010925293,
0.49394211173057556,
0.028561795130372047,
-0.5512253046035767,
0.13478659093379974,
-0.26925116777420044,
0.2835291624069214,
0.8112194538116455,
0.5520943403244019,
-0.4270155727863312,
0.24941854178905487,
0.14588412642478943,
0.0720263198018074,
-0.1835484802722931,
1.2323508262634277,
-0.6626530289649963,
0.7475214600563049,
0.6401423811912537,
0.4626663327217102,
0.3402630090713501,
-0.33610644936561584,
0.4630686938762665,
-0.2996288239955902,
0.1709909290075302,
0.32444658875465393,
0.5894957184791565,
0.3573458790779114,
-0.2947908639907837,
0.35873672366142273,
0.3353731632232666,
-0.7510247230529785,
-0.8737963438034058,
0.04828619956970215,
-1.294075846672058,
-0.7426556348800659,
1.0206785202026367,
0.08501807600259781,
-0.25707393884658813,
-0.449398010969162,
-0.2826557457447052,
0.277981162071228,
-0.3580271005630493,
0.8541519045829773,
0.30958104133605957,
-0.35999593138694763,
0.0728418305516243,
-0.4851749539375305,
-0.03341427817940712,
0.5795934796333313,
-0.8650151491165161,
-0.2238779515028,
0.18155477941036224,
0.28360387682914734,
0.628791093826294,
0.3556267321109772,
-0.4157516360282898,
0.10459940135478973,
-0.36351272463798523,
0.287834495306015,
-0.21040421724319458,
-0.6902092695236206,
-0.2738994061946869,
0.47518765926361084,
-0.2744397819042206,
0.16310200095176697
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10293v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10293v1
|
MaiBaam: A Multi-Dialectal Bavarian Universal Dependency Treebank
| 2024-03-15T13:33:10 | 2024-03-15T13:33:10 |
Verena Blaschke, Barbara Kovačić, Siyao Peng, Hinrich Schütze, Barbara Plank
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Despite the success of the Universal Dependencies (UD) project exemplified by
its impressive language breadth, there is still a lack in `within-language
breadth': most treebanks focus on standard languages. Even for German, the
language with the most annotations in UD, so far no treebank exists for one of
its language varieties spoken by over 10M people: Bavarian. To contribute to
closing this gap, we present the first multi-dialect Bavarian treebank
(MaiBaam) manually annotated with part-of-speech and syntactic dependency
information in UD, covering multiple text genres (wiki, fiction, grammar
examples, social, non-fiction). We highlight the morphosyntactic differences
between the closely-related Bavarian and German and showcase the rich
variability of speakers' orthographies. Our corpus includes 15k tokens,
covering dialects from all Bavarian-speaking areas spanning three countries. We
provide baseline parsing and POS tagging results, which are lower than results
obtained on German and vary substantially between different graph-based
parsers. To support further research on Bavarian syntax, we make our dataset,
language-specific guidelines and code publicly available.
|
[
-0.6321749687194824,
-0.6178902387619019,
0.4087401032447815,
0.4917410910129547,
-0.14696067571640015,
0.05168503522872925,
0.049969907850027084,
-0.38244470953941345,
0.6659103631973267,
0.4951765239238739,
-0.2729617655277252,
-0.8387963771820068,
-0.6915152668952942,
0.12909577786922455,
-0.2155889868736267,
0.7428023815155029,
0.14042510092258453,
0.292451411485672,
0.07356910407543182,
-0.6156058311462402,
-0.17243646085262299,
-0.9557854533195496,
-0.2353898286819458,
-0.03407377749681473,
0.788415253162384,
0.4342036545276642,
0.5212401747703552,
0.35448920726776123,
0.2857550382614136,
0.2903979420661926,
-0.3919214904308319,
-0.080896757543087,
0.09706799685955048,
0.053152285516262054,
0.07035937905311584,
-0.3617216646671295,
-0.5642465353012085,
-0.4263285994529724,
0.7629424333572388,
0.8348984718322754,
-0.2272258698940277,
0.14479736983776093,
-0.019175736233592033,
0.7260295748710632,
-0.6982637643814087,
0.644733726978302,
-0.5057657361030579,
-0.3562401235103607,
-0.7860560417175293,
0.12127295136451721,
-0.3385497033596039,
0.04686707258224487,
-0.05414848029613495,
-0.1548967957496643,
0.10300788283348083,
-0.2778272032737732,
1.0033317804336548,
0.007454019505530596,
-0.8705949783325195,
0.23788639903068542,
-0.44381457567214966,
0.31508520245552063,
-0.63409823179245,
0.4262138307094574,
0.6119816899299622,
0.37064024806022644,
-0.215781107544899,
-0.40507620573043823,
-0.11072610318660736,
-0.08387170732021332,
-0.2380724996328354,
0.07844877243041992,
-0.287433385848999,
0.1567370742559433,
-0.13489489257335663,
0.1319383829832077,
-0.2963951826095581,
0.08272329717874527,
-0.2629531919956207,
-0.3270840048789978,
0.25574737787246704,
0.034377507865428925,
0.22288770973682404,
-0.41827893257141113,
0.18387962877750397,
0.09134375303983688,
-0.703919529914856,
0.08308585733175278,
0.5196775197982788,
0.5290814638137817,
-0.2741798460483551,
0.3869718015193939,
-0.3994252681732178,
0.8006978034973145,
-0.2674047648906708,
-0.13781651854515076,
0.2282038778066635,
0.04773780331015587,
-0.160936176776886,
0.12681351602077484,
0.7399205565452576,
-0.02296019159257412,
0.11554181575775146,
-0.09918402135372162,
0.050954919308423996,
-0.14699190855026245,
-0.009575949050486088,
-0.9997318387031555,
-0.5876224040985107,
0.006392475683242083,
-0.18728317320346832,
0.011824391782283783,
0.4155891537666321,
-0.7427322864532471,
-0.42123138904571533,
-0.21899917721748352,
-0.10757426917552948,
-0.49126872420310974,
-0.4130457937717438,
-0.24183881282806396,
0.06329303234815598,
0.009769816882908344,
0.18464522063732147,
-1.0595800876617432,
-0.021532727405428886,
0.4977908432483673,
0.896939754486084,
0.11742731183767319,
-0.35870760679244995,
-0.3645092844963074,
0.5063803195953369,
-0.2707440257072449,
0.9849603176116943,
-0.5272883176803589,
-0.4508562684059143,
0.12048274278640747,
0.15032243728637695,
0.209822416305542,
-0.6079124808311462,
0.5321425795555115,
-0.38164088129997253,
0.0765332356095314,
-0.09677239507436752,
-0.31293678283691406,
-0.7792128920555115,
-0.03828056529164314,
-0.950483500957489,
0.6612672805786133,
0.5433596968650818,
-0.9033455848693848,
0.3361065089702606,
-0.39936745166778564,
-0.9381234049797058,
0.024021098390221596,
-0.46409109234809875,
-0.17519041895866394,
0.18377210199832916,
0.2883322238922119,
0.5054450035095215,
-0.15292204916477203,
0.6027869582176208,
-0.48148444294929504,
-0.051745008677244186,
-0.21969440579414368,
-0.5452281832695007,
1.5507915019989014,
-0.2877425253391266,
-0.27972280979156494,
0.20416103303432465,
-1.202139973640442,
-0.3480322062969208,
0.21373781561851501,
-0.34276923537254333,
-0.2380954921245575,
0.06922043859958649,
0.3501504361629486,
-0.09667898714542389,
0.07433956861495972,
-0.5010620951652527,
0.09557272493839264,
-0.3866908550262451,
0.37692520022392273,
0.783096969127655,
-0.14140547811985016,
0.023481158539652824,
-0.13017629086971283,
0.5282607078552246,
0.39131492376327515,
-0.11150076240301132,
-0.3715263903141022,
-0.5096520185470581,
-0.8043602705001831,
-0.6943366527557373,
0.57979816198349,
0.6044527888298035,
0.006564713548868895,
0.7244325876235962,
-0.0534558966755867,
-0.6481630802154541,
-0.5973201990127563,
0.0923866331577301,
0.02709999866783619,
0.2904404103755951,
0.31566986441612244,
-0.49862000346183777,
-0.6120257377624512,
-1.2698733806610107,
0.4123045802116394,
-0.4850171208381653,
0.027977094054222107,
-0.03481702879071236,
0.11227486282587051,
-0.3517276644706726,
1.1001331806182861,
-0.2857213616371155,
-0.7306947708129883,
-0.31272146105766296,
0.05765681341290474,
0.026313941925764084,
0.22732491791248322,
1.0307782888412476,
-0.5620500445365906,
-0.5036987662315369,
0.05340394377708435,
-0.3277779817581177,
-0.324899822473526,
0.26435795426368713,
-0.23344236612319946,
0.5382099151611328,
0.15955933928489685,
-0.6769511699676514,
0.19470182061195374,
1.0124276876449585,
-0.27481353282928467,
0.48638466000556946,
-0.011205870658159256,
0.00820525549352169,
-1.265453815460205,
0.09957721829414368,
-0.21964174509048462,
-0.2241770327091217,
-0.41298767924308777,
-0.32045137882232666,
0.034626737236976624,
0.27439847588539124,
-0.3921501934528351,
0.534967303276062,
-0.34354570508003235,
0.22696124017238617,
0.04614004120230675,
0.024550650268793106,
0.13887947797775269,
0.5925154685974121,
-0.1925419569015503,
0.3886031210422516,
0.8533037900924683,
-0.45923012495040894,
0.4701409935951233,
0.2872842252254486,
-0.24051901698112488,
0.6600785851478577,
-0.296516478061676,
-0.3188178241252899,
-0.23767006397247314,
0.35433655977249146,
-0.9486066699028015,
-0.5321250557899475,
0.36445480585098267,
-0.3709012269973755,
0.6100254654884338,
-0.46509233117103577,
-0.7565367221832275,
0.2013116180896759,
0.009771456941962242,
0.19781017303466797,
0.21742726862430573,
-0.3756803572177887,
0.8080538511276245,
0.7789019346237183,
-0.3462696075439453,
-0.25143885612487793,
-0.5873600840568542,
0.21414917707443237,
-0.38476327061653137,
-0.6400882601737976,
0.05092247202992439,
0.26138490438461304,
-0.42644497752189636,
-0.020637309178709984,
-0.12405824661254883,
-0.29848530888557434,
0.44766727089881897,
0.47269314527511597,
0.2733256220817566,
-0.2831902801990509,
0.14476001262664795,
0.25763002038002014,
-0.3374919891357422,
-0.02226368710398674,
-0.28746354579925537,
0.5347258448600769,
-0.29090189933776855,
-0.6193618774414062,
-0.445453941822052,
0.5869814157485962,
0.27962881326675415,
-0.40063050389289856,
0.7105462551116943,
0.4553852081298828,
-0.3367765545845032,
0.15275323390960693,
-0.41593629121780396,
0.07646608352661133,
-0.35248544812202454,
0.37493282556533813,
-0.6768085956573486,
-1.0387226343154907,
0.304411381483078,
-0.029124325141310692,
0.3113967478275299,
0.7452938556671143,
0.7096554040908813,
-0.1972961276769638,
1.0357706546783447,
0.8655708432197571,
-0.6219439506530762,
0.489380419254303,
0.09321598708629608,
-0.0778917595744133,
-0.13240459561347961,
0.024202503263950348,
-0.7403010725975037,
-0.00937415286898613,
-0.8532360792160034,
0.09677685052156448,
0.1065140813589096,
0.40366998314857483,
-0.08126132190227509,
0.5414804816246033,
-0.08744394779205322,
0.045302242040634155,
0.6427406668663025,
-0.41504809260368347,
0.4063330292701721,
0.05213461443781853,
-0.16488908231258392,
0.13227196037769318,
-0.5576817393302917,
-0.606987714767456,
0.8415083289146423,
-0.08371365815401077,
0.28025075793266296,
0.3169911503791809,
0.8843227028846741,
0.24300968647003174,
0.5652281045913696,
-0.6793337464332581,
0.30866023898124695,
-0.10103830695152283,
-0.8120870590209961,
-0.0709766373038292,
-0.46522057056427,
-1.2312260866165161,
0.4988184869289398,
0.1651812344789505,
-1.029441475868225,
-0.19255149364471436,
0.16012179851531982,
-0.1942637860774994,
0.28903040289878845,
-0.7185646891593933,
1.0021103620529175,
-0.18466173112392426,
0.39065495133399963,
-0.12555888295173645,
-0.8333947658538818,
0.23902378976345062,
-0.20281532406806946,
0.37182557582855225,
-0.6502828001976013,
0.20490211248397827,
0.660481870174408,
-0.21502594649791718,
0.9728341698646545,
0.002293322002515197,
-0.04273039102554321,
0.4189837574958801,
0.2759189307689667,
-0.13315504789352417,
0.04683327302336693,
0.1800149828195572,
0.7368682026863098,
0.5671277046203613,
-0.6573672294616699,
-0.2649529278278351,
0.337191104888916,
-0.5636464953422546,
-0.7507014870643616,
-0.4643714427947998,
-0.4221762418746948,
-0.6383308172225952,
0.4357004761695862,
0.012377254664897919,
0.520592987537384,
-0.5659031867980957,
0.11855418235063553,
0.06883008778095245,
0.10598049312829971,
0.3241688311100006,
0.5319353938102722,
-0.6642082333564758,
-0.5643094778060913,
0.8995729684829712,
0.16724850237369537,
-0.026457127183675766,
0.4550882875919342,
0.028210334479808807,
-0.0017755950102582574,
-0.24289675056934357,
-1.0168836116790771,
0.40421971678733826,
-0.6005711555480957,
-0.14919248223304749,
-0.7445587515830994,
-0.15889954566955566,
-0.5230403542518616,
-0.024914607405662537,
-0.08304302394390106,
-0.6802036166191101,
-0.13617751002311707,
-0.3631651997566223,
0.36987245082855225,
0.791847825050354,
-0.20326434075832367,
0.6021928191184998,
-1.2649117708206177,
0.23602859675884247,
-0.00760264415293932,
0.1341048628091812,
-0.2502443194389343,
-0.29412612318992615,
-0.3630388379096985,
-0.05389640852808952,
-0.37032318115234375,
-1.266344428062439,
0.04808344319462776,
0.10603807121515274,
0.5290647745132446,
0.8707219362258911,
-0.10043870657682419,
0.4400685429573059,
-0.36372828483581543,
0.5505093336105347,
0.2597281336784363,
-0.7664190530776978,
0.26814866065979004,
-0.2953735291957855,
0.3246377408504486,
0.6901530623435974,
0.24149587750434875,
-0.6442437767982483,
-0.8861290812492371,
-0.8357160687446594,
-1.0183018445968628,
0.8053203225135803,
-0.056425079703330994,
0.1436770111322403,
0.019008763134479523,
-0.3447752892971039,
0.24848580360412598,
0.28240159153938293,
-0.3569839894771576,
-0.46715307235717773,
0.03500812500715256,
-0.2838182747364044,
-0.1883695274591446,
-0.2708466947078705,
-0.27608954906463623,
-0.459325909614563,
0.8512336015701294,
-0.11690686643123627,
-0.11064913123846054,
-0.3020244836807251,
-0.16233398020267487,
0.06077861040830612,
0.4028218984603882,
0.04810316488146782,
0.7626266479492188,
-0.07694399356842041,
0.4966587424278259,
-0.06524955481290817,
-0.14961734414100647,
0.1922987550497055,
0.5269426107406616,
-0.5771685242652893,
0.5318096280097961,
0.37883079051971436,
0.7005810737609863,
-0.001122967922128737,
-0.7358110547065735,
0.16255372762680054,
0.3641887605190277,
0.0530671626329422,
-0.22768235206604004,
-0.16286931931972504,
0.8884415030479431,
0.17213356494903564,
-0.006761501077562571,
-0.14627490937709808,
0.12135891616344452,
-0.4551601707935333,
0.33312320709228516,
0.3697180151939392,
-0.5058928728103638,
-0.37358975410461426,
0.46827682852745056,
-0.05923805385828018,
-0.13720251619815826,
0.49568304419517517,
-0.2472049593925476,
-0.5276328921318054,
0.5856358408927917,
0.19824254512786865,
0.8704375624656677,
-0.20718801021575928,
0.4212903380393982,
0.32209983468055725,
0.22317877411842346,
0.3948283791542053,
0.23857323825359344,
-0.1885143369436264,
-0.4404328167438507,
-0.10933379083871841,
-0.8953540921211243,
-0.3295389413833618,
-0.26865649223327637,
-0.545000433921814,
0.3603369891643524,
-0.2769523859024048,
-0.35476163029670715,
0.19008003175258636,
-0.3721664249897003,
-0.23076772689819336,
-0.14609122276306152,
0.027345500886440277,
0.6854750514030457,
-0.6416197419166565,
1.175349235534668,
0.8008002042770386,
-0.6313967704772949,
-0.5288245677947998,
0.1779012680053711,
0.3617734909057617,
-0.7451083064079285,
0.2743583023548126,
0.5473995804786682,
-0.19537626206874847,
0.012791678309440613,
-0.035831913352012634,
-0.555268406867981,
0.7055779099464417,
0.6276350617408752,
-0.3338722586631775,
0.16972187161445618,
0.3359469175338745,
0.4311272203922272,
-0.10374991595745087,
0.14797016978263855,
0.8318796157836914,
0.773522675037384,
-0.061377618461847305,
-0.5702580213546753,
-0.28313952684402466,
-0.024629175662994385,
-0.11537747830152512,
0.6905590295791626,
-0.7897870540618896,
0.4490220248699188,
-0.05148230865597725,
-0.4591904580593109,
0.037567391991615295,
0.9109089970588684,
-0.005640923045575619,
-0.02333008125424385,
0.4933544397354126,
0.6560657024383545,
0.60605388879776,
-0.08010276407003403,
0.5505971312522888,
-0.6064285635948181,
0.165470153093338,
1.2982620000839233,
-0.05709221959114075,
0.7960335612297058,
0.4540284276008606,
-0.48881471157073975,
0.5729836225509644,
0.8973535299301147,
0.04516642168164253,
0.1833343207836151,
0.1543826013803482,
-0.39326781034469604,
-0.14019232988357544,
-0.362701416015625,
-0.24353443086147308,
0.5325202941894531,
0.057834357023239136,
-0.12773609161376953,
-0.6282234191894531,
-0.36339542269706726,
0.6933106780052185,
-0.2513258755207062,
0.14054599404335022,
0.6840207576751709,
0.21844545006752014,
-0.32810938358306885,
0.2830962538719177,
0.3174920678138733,
0.32687926292419434,
-0.8711990714073181,
0.10495137423276901,
-0.41650789976119995,
0.00047669882769696414,
-0.26732468605041504,
-0.5593535304069519,
0.3608802258968353,
-0.016797194257378578,
0.04159777611494064,
0.1337435096502304,
0.14266198873519897,
-0.4792330861091614,
-0.6294301152229309,
0.7121338248252869,
0.8480824828147888,
0.19084873795509338,
-0.3871309459209442,
-0.20728835463523865,
-0.38362574577331543,
-0.0649595558643341,
-0.3882378935813904,
0.4765087366104126,
0.625743567943573,
-0.13617612421512604,
0.23628458380699158,
0.30955496430397034,
0.03728732466697693,
0.1700913906097412,
0.3983043432235718,
0.600652813911438,
-0.6429756879806519,
-0.32462409138679504,
-1.0140345096588135,
0.4027748107910156,
0.28075429797172546,
-0.34221795201301575,
0.8042393922805786,
0.6466740369796753,
0.9619690179824829,
0.3272668719291687,
0.8934907913208008,
-0.46139007806777954,
0.033250387758016586,
-0.1358705461025238,
0.6375807523727417,
-0.8809814453125,
-0.38106775283813477,
-0.09505490213632584,
-1.124083161354065,
-0.5990771055221558,
0.15040378272533417,
0.3290678858757019,
-0.12517249584197998,
0.5503612160682678,
0.6928232908248901,
0.0051712882705032825,
0.08390069007873535,
0.4807024598121643,
0.20145602524280548,
0.21754373610019684,
0.30040159821510315,
0.5988426208496094,
0.36216190457344055,
0.7346997857093811,
-0.5393694639205933,
-0.3558042049407959,
-0.22125552594661713,
-0.5908169150352478,
-0.7155906558036804,
-0.7808043956756592,
0.016347290948033333,
-0.3770401179790497,
-0.2536415755748749,
0.7891743183135986,
0.5799347162246704,
-1.2046483755111694,
-0.41135406494140625,
0.1202288568019867,
0.14175860583782196,
-0.25244590640068054,
-0.21202974021434784,
0.5489901900291443,
-0.31183603405952454,
-0.7002880573272705,
0.27986082434654236,
0.6750851273536682,
0.12995439767837524,
-0.4202713370323181,
0.11943795531988144,
-0.20853476226329803,
0.004700105637311935,
0.5173545479774475,
0.1965470016002655,
-0.7430509924888611,
-0.135162815451622,
-0.40383589267730713,
-0.42180460691452026,
0.6542492508888245,
0.7476899027824402,
-0.2659599483013153,
0.4547337293624878,
0.45914971828460693,
0.7502405047416687,
0.37393972277641296,
-0.18681102991104126,
0.22424086928367615,
-0.464812308549881,
0.35759466886520386,
0.07723569869995117,
0.7866247296333313,
0.3178054988384247,
0.12925569713115692,
0.4813788831233978,
0.5559097528457642,
-0.167718768119812,
-0.29417484998703003,
0.48904383182525635,
-1.1354495286941528,
-0.287494033575058,
1.0418493747711182,
-0.4325190484523773,
-0.008183161728084087,
-0.3724263608455658,
-0.6577556133270264,
0.4156496822834015,
-0.4793076515197754,
0.7395268678665161,
1.089381456375122,
-0.06197719648480415,
0.026118282228708267,
-0.4649312496185303,
0.1391221135854721,
0.3930840492248535,
-1.0498971939086914,
0.11025135964155197,
1.001520037651062,
0.028023511171340942,
0.16411660611629486,
0.8451001644134521,
-0.06388337165117264,
-0.1360073983669281,
0.2433716356754303,
0.17340826988220215,
-0.015052379108965397,
-0.631625771522522,
-0.3090934455394745,
0.38965916633605957,
0.27419835329055786,
-0.1340184211730957
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10581v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10581v2
|
Large Language Model-informed ECG Dual Attention Network for Heart Failure Risk Prediction
| 2024-03-15T13:25:09 | 2024-03-22T16:00:24 |
Chen Chen, Lei Li, Marcel Beetz, Abhirup Banerjee, Ramneek Gupta, Vicente Grau
|
q-bio.QM
|
q-bio.QM, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.SP
|
Heart failure (HF) poses a significant public health challenge, with a rising
global mortality rate. Early detection and prevention of HF could significantly
reduce its impact. We introduce a novel methodology for predicting HF risk
using 12-lead electrocardiograms (ECGs). We present a novel, lightweight
dual-attention ECG network designed to capture complex ECG features essential
for early HF risk prediction, despite the notable imbalance between low and
high-risk groups. This network incorporates a cross-lead attention module and
twelve lead-specific temporal attention modules, focusing on cross-lead
interactions and each lead's local dynamics. To further alleviate model
overfitting, we leverage a large language model (LLM) with a public ECG-Report
dataset for pretraining on an ECG-report alignment task. The network is then
fine-tuned for HF risk prediction using two specific cohorts from the UK
Biobank study, focusing on patients with hypertension (UKB-HYP) and those who
have had a myocardial infarction (UKB-MI).The results reveal that LLM-informed
pre-training substantially enhances HF risk prediction in these cohorts. The
dual-attention design not only improves interpretability but also predictive
accuracy, outperforming existing competitive methods with C-index scores of
0.6349 for UKB-HYP and 0.5805 for UKB-MI. This demonstrates our method's
potential in advancing HF risk assessment with clinical complex ECG data.
|
[
-0.35441306233406067,
-0.6110833287239075,
0.6355636119842529,
0.1924348920583725,
-0.19520717859268188,
-0.10142683982849121,
-0.29336637258529663,
-0.583950936794281,
0.1658175140619278,
0.3664710223674774,
-0.8257552981376648,
-0.5711819529533386,
-0.5751453638076782,
-0.041389960795640945,
0.050528548657894135,
0.9015690684318542,
-0.014278803020715714,
0.3909352421760559,
-0.04537506774067879,
0.2748371660709381,
-0.5019233226776123,
-0.4328555166721344,
-0.5655453205108643,
-0.49383345246315,
0.826493501663208,
0.5191659927368164,
0.3676784932613373,
0.2927372455596924,
0.9607359766960144,
0.1461895853281021,
0.03766847029328346,
-0.06724449247121811,
-0.43608444929122925,
-0.011459235101938248,
0.21983683109283447,
-0.3211876451969147,
-0.8874838352203369,
-0.2924376130104065,
0.5171991586685181,
0.574402391910553,
0.0963878482580185,
0.453315794467926,
0.07091069221496582,
0.9342525005340576,
-0.5277988910675049,
0.17050157487392426,
-0.14759713411331177,
0.17257475852966309,
-0.15567754209041595,
-0.30391865968704224,
-0.4176272749900818,
0.1283443570137024,
0.4871070086956024,
-0.18643556535243988,
0.0726170465350151,
0.4796102046966553,
0.3674493730068207,
0.617184579372406,
-0.48585283756256104,
0.06708625704050064,
-0.6661515831947327,
0.5271333456039429,
-0.31542181968688965,
0.4347701072692871,
0.44541028141975403,
0.40469515323638916,
0.03196641430258751,
-0.2783506512641907,
-0.11789581179618835,
-0.05437195673584938,
-0.16455906629562378,
0.3720296025276184,
0.07322822511196136,
0.316718190908432,
0.18452385067939758,
0.50882488489151,
-0.7778797149658203,
-0.02673271857202053,
-0.3964572846889496,
-0.15391463041305542,
0.6805151104927063,
-0.08526697009801865,
0.12094536423683167,
0.10545767843723297,
-0.6731830835342407,
0.11048944294452667,
-0.7632399201393127,
-0.23280386626720428,
0.32993581891059875,
0.35241788625717163,
-0.5914155840873718,
0.41223976016044617,
0.036695659160614014,
0.38679563999176025,
0.22403356432914734,
0.21558429300785065,
0.39102259278297424,
-0.24122515320777893,
-0.31340351700782776,
0.6355014443397522,
0.7810636162757874,
0.2233809232711792,
0.47116175293922424,
0.019116343930363655,
0.07056262344121933,
0.11080024391412735,
0.27173087000846863,
-0.6127026081085205,
-0.31050360202789307,
0.47064208984375,
-0.5687469244003296,
-0.3689364790916443,
0.07340000569820404,
-0.754112958908081,
-0.36754724383354187,
-0.05802648887038231,
0.35110411047935486,
-0.1174156591296196,
-0.36170294880867004,
0.18161197006702423,
0.1723148673772812,
-0.17348390817642212,
-0.10433302819728851,
-0.5003592371940613,
0.17854218184947968,
0.40957316756248474,
0.7388486862182617,
-0.08814343810081482,
-0.26947811245918274,
-0.6788684129714966,
0.014326771721243858,
0.02586742490530014,
0.7979201078414917,
0.06293342262506485,
-0.1846081167459488,
-0.08960748463869095,
0.11489879339933395,
0.01097231823951006,
-0.18518073856830597,
0.6746774911880493,
-0.3477647304534912,
-0.14482472836971283,
-0.02668914943933487,
-0.3151510953903198,
-0.08293024450540543,
0.14324861764907837,
-1.0203893184661865,
0.7615338563919067,
-0.11697026342153549,
-0.9781635999679565,
0.16849201917648315,
-0.3590812087059021,
-0.991693377494812,
0.0743865966796875,
-0.0504729263484478,
-0.9050966501235962,
-0.11064134538173676,
0.3013313412666321,
0.7157133221626282,
-0.45545142889022827,
0.25057879090309143,
-0.6747705936431885,
-0.15764378011226654,
0.12054511159658432,
-0.38061460852622986,
0.1675480455160141,
-0.3724382221698761,
-0.33943358063697815,
0.4599505066871643,
-0.9314266443252563,
0.10771461576223373,
0.06134893745183945,
-0.1462687849998474,
-0.13799282908439636,
-0.16885752975940704,
0.17773890495300293,
0.5556004643440247,
-0.0031375582329928875,
-0.5359634160995483,
-0.3240622878074646,
-0.4337778389453888,
0.2999916076660156,
0.5937032103538513,
0.18155412375926971,
0.07531231641769409,
-0.46576279401779175,
0.5074480772018433,
-0.09101554751396179,
0.2986278533935547,
-0.041452668607234955,
-0.3908607065677643,
-0.3300410509109497,
-0.14579777419567108,
0.004115148913115263,
0.6500350832939148,
0.11898472905158997,
0.9664210081100464,
-0.14571543037891388,
-0.543097972869873,
-0.5222789645195007,
-0.06951513141393661,
0.503778874874115,
0.5257349014282227,
0.6047899127006531,
-0.15624050796031952,
-0.5960392951965332,
-0.8658877015113831,
0.13243676722049713,
-0.2471432238817215,
0.17975449562072754,
0.34387946128845215,
0.19210544228553772,
-0.3458998501300812,
0.11428339034318924,
-0.6774775981903076,
-0.4042589068412781,
-0.5204658508300781,
-0.052370309829711914,
0.32984283566474915,
0.35739412903785706,
0.06927010416984558,
-0.7260447144508362,
-0.5748533606529236,
0.06256551295518875,
-0.4173784852027893,
0.10019975900650024,
-0.11766710132360458,
-0.5339934229850769,
-0.31792229413986206,
0.2221883088350296,
-0.3552125096321106,
0.4783838093280792,
0.7892401814460754,
-0.5326790809631348,
0.5940797328948975,
-0.3035076856613159,
-0.06693008542060852,
-0.8452386856079102,
0.2511904537677765,
0.30084672570228577,
-0.09429018944501877,
-0.4839629530906677,
-0.4834671914577484,
0.2852073907852173,
-0.14405614137649536,
-0.07131170481443405,
0.6903193593025208,
-0.541948676109314,
0.08032681047916412,
-0.23298479616641998,
-0.3666830062866211,
-0.15262678265571594,
0.3988057076931,
0.1374005675315857,
0.030858641490340233,
0.7386985421180725,
-0.45541712641716003,
0.25309932231903076,
0.39075392484664917,
-0.36777645349502563,
0.46588847041130066,
-0.8001582622528076,
0.07938411831855774,
-0.13592375814914703,
0.3537519872188568,
-1.0475401878356934,
-0.297419935464859,
0.12352367490530014,
-0.3810168504714966,
0.5964311957359314,
-0.03902418911457062,
-0.04683762788772583,
-0.9201012849807739,
-0.06730086356401443,
0.6825568079948425,
0.28958702087402344,
-0.3658778667449951,
0.4367433786392212,
0.27797526121139526,
-0.413414865732193,
-0.41952741146087646,
-0.9368818998336792,
-0.352155864238739,
-0.049536652863025665,
-0.750209629535675,
0.19116075336933136,
-0.3482820391654968,
0.17612282931804657,
-0.1007097139954567,
-0.32092615962028503,
-0.035820603370666504,
0.1894368976354599,
0.9231432676315308,
0.44115087389945984,
-0.017944734543561935,
0.6096974015235901,
-0.1981298178434372,
-0.2427583932876587,
0.192905992269516,
-0.35707226395606995,
0.6213700175285339,
-0.08884187042713165,
-0.501112699508667,
-0.9344013929367065,
0.5800456404685974,
0.7541601657867432,
-0.6941016316413879,
0.5973875522613525,
0.6110560894012451,
-0.6170061230659485,
-0.26241299510002136,
-0.45529377460479736,
-0.3232646882534027,
-0.3476269543170929,
0.5792354345321655,
0.035345934331417084,
-0.4256608188152313,
0.222905695438385,
0.16862940788269043,
-0.2446039617061615,
0.3421330749988556,
0.6848849654197693,
-0.21988463401794434,
0.8716699481010437,
0.7347791194915771,
-0.17668837308883667,
0.46262234449386597,
-0.24992257356643677,
0.15203994512557983,
-0.7715864181518555,
-0.37349411845207214,
-0.17984828352928162,
-0.6909773349761963,
-0.10792779922485352,
-0.30455562472343445,
0.5461031198501587,
-0.15729224681854248,
-0.38139158487319946,
-0.12807676196098328,
-0.3344537317752838,
0.059082165360450745,
0.28346315026283264,
0.5883718729019165,
0.24606451392173767,
-0.05954495817422867,
0.04360654205083847,
0.19852900505065918,
-0.6028113961219788,
-0.12872743606567383,
1.7867088317871094,
0.37506741285324097,
0.7231951951980591,
-0.2706332802772522,
0.713211178779602,
0.2867226004600525,
0.6951627731323242,
-0.960662305355072,
-0.015195805579423904,
0.11124411225318909,
-0.6561282277107239,
-0.4102429151535034,
-0.4771152436733246,
-0.7651430368423462,
-0.25300464034080505,
-0.6341338753700256,
-0.1553260236978531,
-0.103349469602108,
0.619979739189148,
-0.8806341886520386,
-0.0282097477465868,
-0.7606592774391174,
1.0115132331848145,
-0.6634196639060974,
-0.1960584819316864,
-0.3151930272579193,
-0.8460366725921631,
0.3924088478088379,
-0.35702452063560486,
0.415289968252182,
-0.2174624353647232,
0.2070445865392685,
0.4162260890007019,
-0.20698095858097076,
0.8139976859092712,
0.16286389529705048,
0.0763225108385086,
0.1759345680475235,
-0.47857147455215454,
0.5799317955970764,
0.3780907690525055,
-0.11485763639211655,
0.0858493521809578,
-0.3253839612007141,
-0.4579143226146698,
-0.2831107974052429,
0.6905887722969055,
-0.7245354056358337,
-0.16082324087619781,
-0.31219276785850525,
-0.3025344908237457,
-0.3990660011768341,
0.4787677228450775,
0.4200640022754669,
0.5718383193016052,
-0.3012876808643341,
-0.058232054114341736,
0.5625404715538025,
0.2289944440126419,
0.13458193838596344,
-0.08479800075292587,
0.4102908670902252,
-0.6103648543357849,
0.4084857404232025,
-0.11554478853940964,
0.42583203315734863,
0.5702380537986755,
0.3609723746776581,
-0.1667218655347824,
-0.4221610426902771,
-0.1656978279352188,
0.46258866786956787,
-0.39530059695243835,
-0.24539978802204132,
-0.6436383128166199,
-0.1253802478313446,
-0.31821033358573914,
-0.0142725994810462,
-0.35062044858932495,
0.19981738924980164,
-0.0736759752035141,
-0.42584073543548584,
0.13122878968715668,
0.42973992228507996,
0.10851263254880905,
0.34913909435272217,
-0.8839139938354492,
0.33801016211509705,
0.2904488742351532,
0.5295013785362244,
0.1468120962381363,
-0.16372619569301605,
-0.39720556139945984,
-0.21948084235191345,
-0.07174722105264664,
-1.2294081449508667,
0.1746523678302765,
0.18897594511508942,
0.6069353818893433,
0.4847162365913391,
0.15750877559185028,
0.3189704716205597,
-0.6573686599731445,
0.09396237134933472,
0.6243908405303955,
-0.6128674745559692,
0.6585729718208313,
-0.16884462535381317,
0.17003394663333893,
0.5061126351356506,
0.3375491201877594,
-0.5454597473144531,
0.03444509580731392,
-0.7504355311393738,
-0.9301600456237793,
0.5432133674621582,
0.08370901644229889,
-0.5666011571884155,
-0.0414494052529335,
0.21410812437534332,
0.055030178278684616,
0.18110263347625732,
-0.6204997301101685,
-0.5415160655975342,
0.11831040680408478,
-0.6639611721038818,
-0.4310746490955353,
-0.2163492739200592,
-0.31209784746170044,
-0.04136338457465172,
0.7272857427597046,
-0.1566126048564911,
0.24286524951457977,
0.4897014796733856,
-0.09845361113548279,
-0.6665430665016174,
0.2596248984336853,
0.16196301579475403,
0.29160353541374207,
-0.3510586619377136,
0.18816044926643372,
-0.07099013775587082,
-0.5947694778442383,
0.25913265347480774,
0.3820604085922241,
0.09817437082529068,
-0.4050609767436981,
0.6470854878425598,
0.8524529337882996,
0.3595156669616699,
-0.8114539980888367,
0.5936421155929565,
-0.15724457800388336,
-0.07419668883085251,
-0.38057172298431396,
-0.20881833136081696,
0.32492291927337646,
0.21990428864955902,
0.10741952806711197,
0.31078678369522095,
-0.1520383208990097,
-0.3076323866844177,
0.43128785490989685,
0.12662941217422485,
-0.6419743895530701,
-0.4428839087486267,
0.6131018400192261,
0.4708382487297058,
-0.14393171668052673,
0.0851420909166336,
0.0383024737238884,
-0.37628328800201416,
0.959289014339447,
0.47004926204681396,
0.9706012606620789,
-0.4105917513370514,
0.17809997498989105,
0.5862204432487488,
0.3944709300994873,
-0.3762373924255371,
0.5250310301780701,
0.17576147615909576,
-0.49466830492019653,
-0.44755083322525024,
-0.5311508178710938,
-0.23914451897144318,
0.12511974573135376,
-0.8341489434242249,
0.46668583154678345,
-0.6217142343521118,
-0.319754958152771,
-0.10854583233594894,
0.20216841995716095,
-1.1157656908035278,
0.5913276076316833,
0.850088894367218,
0.7017088532447815,
-0.9145388603210449,
0.531611979007721,
1.0320826768875122,
-0.015529111959040165,
-0.8678277134895325,
0.32276031374931335,
0.17174199223518372,
-0.5666593909263611,
0.25227704644203186,
0.6236637234687805,
0.10344959795475006,
0.08809911459684372,
0.12022728472948074,
-1.1546235084533691,
1.1898908615112305,
0.054368384182453156,
-1.009216070175171,
-0.04802331328392029,
-0.4304656982421875,
0.24752193689346313,
-0.263847291469574,
0.14653708040714264,
0.334993839263916,
0.5100578665733337,
-0.11738231033086777,
-0.7901237607002258,
0.1346030831336975,
-0.14476646482944489,
-0.5195510983467102,
0.4230329990386963,
-0.9334940910339355,
0.6376073956489563,
-0.6916210651397705,
-0.2484886795282364,
-0.2639709413051605,
0.5257387161254883,
0.19565130770206451,
0.3718491494655609,
0.4516185224056244,
0.5809837579727173,
0.99582839012146,
0.07833027839660645,
0.8912058472633362,
-0.378330796957016,
0.38219743967056274,
1.2154676914215088,
-0.27570053935050964,
0.7824894189834595,
0.23935022950172424,
-0.19664444029331207,
0.36606675386428833,
0.6306604146957397,
0.09690291434526443,
0.5752577185630798,
0.21745729446411133,
-0.07964736968278885,
-0.5203304290771484,
0.3609727621078491,
-0.4654563069343567,
0.04663832485675812,
0.49674880504608154,
-0.46217724680900574,
0.040122438222169876,
0.07969970256090164,
-0.3117431104183197,
-0.12670038640499115,
-0.6018201112747192,
0.3837589919567108,
0.20376980304718018,
-0.4877154231071472,
0.44238919019699097,
-0.42561960220336914,
0.4736645519733429,
-0.375691294670105,
0.3482895493507385,
0.05304901301860809,
0.43814656138420105,
-0.25238126516342163,
-0.39540737867355347,
0.0049738455563783646,
-0.24330350756645203,
-0.6368330717086792,
-0.035603903234004974,
0.6278464198112488,
-0.6782976984977722,
-0.573107898235321,
0.6979178786277771,
0.4488180875778198,
-0.28488531708717346,
-0.5433065891265869,
-0.47955241799354553,
-0.04042155295610428,
-0.164788156747818,
-0.4210496246814728,
0.20179937779903412,
0.30759572982788086,
0.18016575276851654,
0.5486327409744263,
0.4696539640426636,
0.5193977952003479,
-0.13945837318897247,
0.10276255756616592,
0.5374644994735718,
-0.8708438277244568,
-0.86366206407547,
-0.7003316283226013,
0.5653120279312134,
0.03187323361635208,
-0.3374292552471161,
0.06358840316534042,
0.21014942228794098,
0.5957940220832825,
0.1289970874786377,
1.166347861289978,
0.4476476311683655,
0.5182426571846008,
-0.41633340716362,
0.7282204627990723,
-0.5646318793296814,
-0.10484246164560318,
-0.07999714463949203,
-0.6033182740211487,
-0.5164470076560974,
0.26515305042266846,
-0.6152644753456116,
-0.2493492215871811,
0.9793251752853394,
0.3113414943218231,
-0.07502777129411697,
-0.055058833211660385,
0.24787072837352753,
0.2884182929992676,
0.2527889609336853,
1.0192595720291138,
0.40253904461860657,
-0.18555331230163574,
0.6241035461425781,
-0.31213027238845825,
-0.4128306806087494,
-0.6349416971206665,
-0.6353877186775208,
-1.0862492322921753,
-0.12470898777246475,
-0.4098837673664093,
-0.1711038202047348,
-0.03607022762298584,
1.0492007732391357,
0.7631149888038635,
-0.7158042192459106,
0.16731974482536316,
-0.1340489387512207,
0.121210016310215,
-0.30339813232421875,
-0.0039515807293355465,
0.6869838833808899,
-0.08615636825561523,
-0.22646212577819824,
0.3660159707069397,
0.5329394936561584,
0.2565779685974121,
-0.19866417348384857,
-0.006910549942404032,
0.002799208974465728,
-0.2794550955295563,
0.16175737977027893,
0.1819113940000534,
-0.4937146306037903,
-0.10073743015527725,
-0.1378515511751175,
-0.31017786264419556,
0.06614632904529572,
0.6838492751121521,
-0.44776856899261475,
0.2629449963569641,
0.3718448281288147,
0.732883870601654,
0.14672839641571045,
0.07042244076728821,
0.5505751371383667,
-0.5473681092262268,
0.15290674567222595,
0.4710323214530945,
0.5673905611038208,
0.496398389339447,
-0.959013819694519,
0.022526374086737633,
0.3923851251602173,
-0.6697321534156799,
-0.5311599969863892,
0.3442144989967346,
-0.9702648520469666,
0.07973777502775192,
1.1357163190841675,
-0.06849285960197449,
-0.3671547472476959,
-0.15323077142238617,
-0.14297467470169067,
0.40076884627342224,
-0.2910040616989136,
0.7280343770980835,
0.7180379033088684,
-0.12797752022743225,
0.10968736559152603,
-0.5149437785148621,
0.45638835430145264,
0.6632278561592102,
-0.8596138954162598,
0.1861773133277893,
0.4184989333152771,
0.16902317106723785,
0.03951052576303482,
0.4664067327976227,
0.179849773645401,
0.5406778454780579,
-0.38305389881134033,
0.35369765758514404,
-0.237308070063591,
-0.6609034538269043,
-0.42536672949790955,
0.13902905583381653,
-0.2208397388458252,
-0.24083802103996277
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10281v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10281v1
|
Team Trifecta at Factify5WQA: Setting the Standard in Fact Verification with Fine-Tuning
| 2024-03-15T13:24:28 | 2024-03-15T13:24:28 |
Shang-Hsuan Chiang, Ming-Chih Lo, Lin-Wei Chao, Wen-Chih Peng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
In this paper, we present Pre-CoFactv3, a comprehensive framework comprised
of Question Answering and Text Classification components for fact verification.
Leveraging In-Context Learning, Fine-tuned Large Language Models (LLMs), and
the FakeNet model, we address the challenges of fact verification. Our
experiments explore diverse approaches, comparing different Pre-trained LLMs,
introducing FakeNet, and implementing various ensemble methods. Notably, our
team, Trifecta, secured first place in the AAAI-24 Factify 3.0 Workshop,
surpassing the baseline accuracy by 103% and maintaining a 70% lead over the
second competitor. This success underscores the efficacy of our approach and
its potential contributions to advancing fact verification research.
|
[
-0.5394811630249023,
-0.8342239856719971,
0.7511215209960938,
0.15200035274028778,
-0.22015626728534698,
0.26246950030326843,
0.14693951606750488,
-0.40376609563827515,
-0.10145411640405655,
0.5144429206848145,
-0.4893190264701843,
-0.5633834004402161,
-0.36204811930656433,
0.17014393210411072,
-0.4640469253063202,
1.0431833267211914,
-0.15088477730751038,
-0.3175557851791382,
-0.43990689516067505,
-0.34575799107551575,
-0.42038917541503906,
-0.5321895480155945,
-0.41203129291534424,
-0.5551646947860718,
0.39151909947395325,
0.9353643655776978,
0.7454373836517334,
0.5026016235351562,
0.32952162623405457,
0.22718125581741333,
0.3580418825149536,
0.6964403986930847,
-0.6192842125892639,
-0.2572189271450043,
-0.11387749761343002,
-0.8154582381248474,
-0.487179696559906,
0.32050561904907227,
0.24923764169216156,
0.3475740849971771,
-0.23000289499759674,
0.4083661437034607,
-0.17764897644519806,
0.30405014753341675,
-0.7086452841758728,
0.056968435645103455,
-0.5231583714485168,
-0.1019548699259758,
-0.30739158391952515,
-0.465177983045578,
-0.48626402020454407,
-0.6519502997398376,
0.04171406850218773,
-0.8965350985527039,
0.5952395796775818,
0.6342291235923767,
1.2468862533569336,
0.5785126686096191,
-0.5080085396766663,
-0.1149468645453453,
-0.7514281868934631,
0.635871946811676,
-0.43246662616729736,
0.38894763588905334,
0.24378718435764313,
0.1555968075990677,
-0.5037214756011963,
-0.9031537771224976,
-0.8661460876464844,
0.21272645890712738,
-0.05551326647400856,
0.05610913038253784,
-0.12515871226787567,
-0.07169771939516068,
0.270639568567276,
0.4569832980632782,
-0.44143596291542053,
0.05543294548988342,
-0.17987793684005737,
-0.5424212217330933,
0.653931736946106,
-0.0643988847732544,
0.4911446273326874,
0.09233874827623367,
-0.322885662317276,
0.07921131700277328,
-0.884096086025238,
0.05521073564887047,
-0.0684356614947319,
0.09201028943061829,
-0.1487235277891159,
0.36933550238609314,
-0.33283042907714844,
0.6430652141571045,
0.28837302327156067,
0.023542221635580063,
0.22975917160511017,
-0.6060795783996582,
-0.45257502794265747,
0.34448349475860596,
0.607243537902832,
0.21768838167190552,
-0.07751458138227463,
-0.16905830800533295,
0.28364965319633484,
-0.09947086870670319,
0.1497238427400589,
-0.7733511924743652,
-0.3016766905784607,
0.5200579762458801,
-0.2915123403072357,
-0.2703796625137329,
0.03996524214744568,
-0.5350275039672852,
-0.4477061927318573,
-0.27376997470855713,
0.9119458794593811,
-0.1872377246618271,
-0.07275641709566116,
0.3663367033004761,
-0.12439291924238205,
0.20171545445919037,
0.6052747964859009,
-0.5752937197685242,
0.2963133156299591,
1.0017831325531006,
0.6648605465888977,
-0.04070078581571579,
-0.42575520277023315,
-0.8011992573738098,
0.0017745158402249217,
-0.5174137353897095,
0.6628184914588928,
-0.07401061058044434,
0.29620397090911865,
-0.2572875916957855,
-0.310727596282959,
0.33465269207954407,
-0.3826659917831421,
0.7233324646949768,
-0.9681647419929504,
0.4216560423374176,
-0.4006636440753937,
-0.6939055323600769,
-0.32570210099220276,
0.5675239562988281,
-0.7863063216209412,
0.8976570963859558,
-0.2223353236913681,
-0.9138151407241821,
0.6544739603996277,
-0.6061378717422485,
-0.4924243688583374,
0.10609288513660431,
0.10235840827226639,
-0.657889187335968,
-0.10438989847898483,
0.19875690340995789,
0.7269716262817383,
-0.33940935134887695,
0.4039866328239441,
-0.42277565598487854,
-0.36981338262557983,
0.1785818338394165,
-0.25245097279548645,
0.7873249650001526,
0.09266733378171921,
-0.35552868247032166,
0.1051105484366417,
-1.0501865148544312,
-0.12068919092416763,
-0.11846950650215149,
-0.24651940166950226,
-0.3295837342739105,
-0.1894455850124359,
-0.5746906995773315,
0.15989865362644196,
0.24440765380859375,
-0.7916268706321716,
0.0785531997680664,
-0.24075698852539062,
0.2880017161369324,
0.19672136008739471,
0.3162061870098114,
0.11112447082996368,
-0.3604189455509186,
-0.029731789603829384,
0.18193021416664124,
0.3830452859401703,
0.32535797357559204,
-0.4566951096057892,
-1.0376501083374023,
-0.31118568778038025,
0.5239855647087097,
0.5093860030174255,
-1.1268891096115112,
0.22564378380775452,
-0.19533199071884155,
-0.5581677556037903,
-0.2748034596443176,
-0.043409187346696854,
0.04788307845592499,
0.6815360188484192,
0.6322265267372131,
0.18517041206359863,
-0.9431152939796448,
-0.990106999874115,
-0.33888736367225647,
-0.21433477103710175,
0.1210172101855278,
-0.19400615990161896,
0.6867557764053345,
0.11146863549947739,
1.1446948051452637,
-0.395153671503067,
-0.22047102451324463,
-0.0829925537109375,
0.6205500364303589,
0.34002241492271423,
0.24523475766181946,
0.3627219498157501,
-0.9698784351348877,
-0.265179842710495,
-0.22622403502464294,
-0.6146863102912903,
0.022731725126504898,
0.240393728017807,
0.17587243020534515,
0.1779327094554901,
0.665931224822998,
-0.35603639483451843,
0.41452497243881226,
0.617440402507782,
-0.43822672963142395,
0.3724926710128784,
-0.13313636183738708,
0.6345576643943787,
-1.177299976348877,
-0.013895074836909771,
-0.255474716424942,
-0.7524721026420593,
-0.71755450963974,
-0.07732797414064407,
0.0546141043305397,
0.31656894087791443,
-0.6505193710327148,
0.28773120045661926,
-0.27160608768463135,
0.19449786841869354,
-0.13830135762691498,
-0.02362024039030075,
0.0039452374912798405,
0.367204874753952,
-0.046313393861055374,
1.0304744243621826,
0.24956323206424713,
-0.9647680521011353,
0.32199403643608093,
0.20919376611709595,
-0.5208330750465393,
0.36284106969833374,
-0.5745241641998291,
-0.12069611996412277,
0.3102754056453705,
0.5039762258529663,
-0.7097676396369934,
-0.5207312107086182,
0.06288580596446991,
-0.36394304037094116,
-0.23716291785240173,
0.02899261936545372,
-0.9068626761436462,
-0.35307902097702026,
-0.07966233044862747,
0.44457879662513733,
0.3698866367340088,
-0.7548531889915466,
0.7141977548599243,
0.40761783719062805,
0.3593848943710327,
-0.6229941844940186,
-0.4070972204208374,
0.10163041204214096,
-0.1257537603378296,
-0.5265060067176819,
0.40830591320991516,
-0.04603607580065727,
-0.1964000165462494,
-0.3253478407859802,
0.029262349009513855,
-0.3440404236316681,
0.5532835721969604,
0.1892574429512024,
0.20907624065876007,
-0.1796295940876007,
0.05949795991182327,
-0.33117377758026123,
0.17752838134765625,
0.0001721229637041688,
-0.15594594180583954,
0.2867145240306854,
-0.3173394799232483,
-0.3397503197193146,
-0.42806336283683777,
-0.0850493386387825,
0.5104222297668457,
-0.15976370871067047,
0.6567308902740479,
0.6382443904876709,
-0.5242241024971008,
-0.20187799632549286,
-0.6865045428276062,
-0.03682544827461243,
-0.40995028614997864,
-0.01554480567574501,
-0.2351798415184021,
-1.4214247465133667,
0.4801248610019684,
-0.10876806080341339,
0.05512359365820885,
0.5838644504547119,
0.4664607346057892,
-0.05653424561023712,
0.9872019290924072,
0.7422888278961182,
0.3181338608264923,
0.047120217233896255,
0.05789051949977875,
0.3279706835746765,
-0.36366480588912964,
-0.2729613184928894,
-0.6136784553527832,
0.047423772513866425,
-0.6769916415214539,
-0.4899693727493286,
0.7124049067497253,
-0.11303640156984329,
-0.25983789563179016,
0.314588725566864,
0.12478163093328476,
0.535207986831665,
0.6289304494857788,
0.1314043402671814,
0.5189324021339417,
-0.3709135949611664,
-0.04932573810219765,
0.42058753967285156,
-0.892179012298584,
-0.4139714241027832,
0.9223052859306335,
0.3376803398132324,
0.15860654413700104,
0.3145214021205902,
0.710502564907074,
0.3302256464958191,
0.2937970757484436,
-0.49302938580513,
0.47208505868911743,
-0.06833365559577942,
-0.929288923740387,
-0.555306077003479,
-0.3141629099845886,
-0.5543109774589539,
-0.0733521357178688,
-0.3568325638771057,
-0.5152944326400757,
0.24341337382793427,
0.33320873975753784,
-1.0226263999938965,
0.18029527366161346,
-0.580531656742096,
0.6231634616851807,
0.042813900858163834,
-0.7068225741386414,
-0.4036047160625458,
-0.5518286824226379,
0.6482029557228088,
-0.06392324715852737,
0.4547462463378906,
-0.06189063563942909,
0.023260558024048805,
0.6043508052825928,
-0.49056506156921387,
0.8123019933700562,
0.12633776664733887,
-0.2594749331474304,
0.279185950756073,
0.09613029658794403,
0.4502972960472107,
0.4858527183532715,
-0.03860245272517204,
0.19418831169605255,
0.11020256578922272,
-0.45882487297058105,
-0.7391209006309509,
0.46905824542045593,
-0.9079391956329346,
-0.6745356917381287,
-0.5849809050559998,
-0.27562424540519714,
-0.5709793567657471,
0.5226883292198181,
0.25593969225883484,
0.6007469892501831,
-0.6075842380523682,
0.3765673041343689,
1.26295006275177,
0.05773182958364487,
0.5260898470878601,
0.7836859822273254,
-0.20452319085597992,
-0.3506471812725067,
0.9171333312988281,
-0.003004108788445592,
-0.0788009911775589,
0.7593340277671814,
0.12508194148540497,
-0.13686954975128174,
-0.7813953161239624,
-0.2662920355796814,
0.01527219358831644,
-0.5271469950675964,
-0.2748810350894928,
-0.6637953519821167,
-0.19046615064144135,
-0.27590256929397583,
0.17102374136447906,
-0.6640750169754028,
-0.40680256485939026,
-0.4421958029270172,
0.09887030720710754,
0.13041986525058746,
1.0149028301239014,
-0.23316751420497894,
0.2433321475982666,
-0.7538689970970154,
0.6768345236778259,
0.647545576095581,
0.5623733401298523,
-0.5892693996429443,
-0.4447561204433441,
-0.3463952839374542,
0.025147950276732445,
-0.11959931999444962,
-0.4280220866203308,
-0.11981166899204254,
0.13738228380680084,
0.3600468635559082,
0.17266397178173065,
0.22416415810585022,
0.46091505885124207,
-0.34195104241371155,
1.083020806312561,
0.09369324892759323,
-1.1055018901824951,
0.4658809006214142,
-0.29976263642311096,
0.16199131309986115,
0.7838883399963379,
0.3862776756286621,
-0.3358442783355713,
-0.24141617119312286,
-1.016744613647461,
-0.3911404609680176,
0.6764399409294128,
0.44027045369148254,
-0.3639622926712036,
0.3417196273803711,
0.4209754467010498,
0.25162220001220703,
0.29120588302612305,
-0.3639760911464691,
-0.35549792647361755,
-0.39876627922058105,
-0.3479965627193451,
-0.3245844542980194,
-0.3680287003517151,
-0.3968132734298706,
-0.1180301383137703,
1.0338482856750488,
-0.34422633051872253,
-0.18640199303627014,
0.3765616714954376,
-0.2926104962825775,
0.148103728890419,
0.28266528248786926,
0.9557083249092102,
0.907744824886322,
-0.32442113757133484,
0.410110205411911,
0.40460941195487976,
-0.4282475411891937,
0.31481584906578064,
0.06830163300037384,
-0.2373422086238861,
-0.21234089136123657,
0.6658013463020325,
0.7819139361381531,
0.2521272599697113,
0.05141333118081093,
0.7663851976394653,
-0.5808289647102356,
-0.42544785141944885,
-0.038083892315626144,
0.3398623466491699,
-0.16676320135593414,
-0.06310725957155228,
0.4032941460609436,
0.2871879041194916,
0.40472620725631714,
-0.48207947611808777,
0.4656203091144562,
0.0843425840139389,
-0.312467098236084,
-0.4604531228542328,
0.2628338932991028,
0.47744622826576233,
0.1087067499756813,
0.2983803451061249,
-0.23141884803771973,
-0.7915905117988586,
0.5594307780265808,
0.17917366325855255,
0.6679564714431763,
0.05253487825393677,
0.4181530177593231,
0.42295730113983154,
0.3394259512424469,
-0.3989890217781067,
0.3655725419521332,
0.02844798006117344,
-1.053971290588379,
-0.48163267970085144,
-0.5546941757202148,
-0.6988570690155029,
0.35055258870124817,
-0.2958718538284302,
0.6471205949783325,
-0.42320331931114197,
0.21193455159664154,
0.13543425500392914,
0.45394495129585266,
-0.7762395143508911,
0.7448868751525879,
0.21390730142593384,
1.0036683082580566,
-1.0303468704223633,
0.5862653255462646,
0.8600223660469055,
-0.41330358386039734,
-1.0215516090393066,
0.12520812451839447,
0.017087191343307495,
-0.6676482558250427,
0.34735262393951416,
0.02948644571006298,
-0.37401828169822693,
0.2537250220775604,
-1.1452943086624146,
-1.060673475265503,
0.9822113513946533,
0.3853813409805298,
-0.31678837537765503,
0.21702326834201813,
0.06280754506587982,
0.5962556600570679,
-0.349806010723114,
0.2857045829296112,
0.692363977432251,
0.5578489303588867,
0.34837108850479126,
-0.9325335025787354,
0.11699960380792618,
0.030535804107785225,
-0.4573138952255249,
-0.23444266617298126,
-1.0273146629333496,
0.5598729848861694,
-0.27199599146842957,
-0.3780507743358612,
-0.21738919615745544,
1.214139461517334,
0.36783620715141296,
0.43794289231300354,
0.6720186471939087,
0.5958139896392822,
1.1185991764068604,
-0.18534089624881744,
0.8319558501243591,
-0.13389666378498077,
0.1261497586965561,
1.4231621026992798,
-0.1696813404560089,
0.6329635977745056,
0.4336552321910858,
0.008247829973697662,
0.7859313488006592,
0.8788822889328003,
0.16503146290779114,
0.21391555666923523,
-0.06919759511947632,
0.018995007500052452,
-0.8979951739311218,
-0.3130502998828888,
-0.13435868918895721,
0.786437451839447,
0.17196157574653625,
0.29612311720848083,
-0.17258107662200928,
-0.11587236076593399,
0.24463941156864166,
-0.08570226281881332,
-0.43325716257095337,
0.8281687498092651,
-0.15584422647953033,
-1.0880913734436035,
0.4394802153110504,
-0.2066318392753601,
0.38623055815696716,
-0.26068541407585144,
-0.2573763132095337,
-0.021392226219177246,
0.24163831770420074,
-0.3948063552379608,
-0.9223719835281372,
0.06930583715438843,
-0.30153051018714905,
-0.34550219774246216,
-0.027966851368546486,
0.648021399974823,
-0.3473573327064514,
-0.1907128244638443,
-0.22710050642490387,
0.24799443781375885,
-0.17753295600414276,
-0.024949243292212486,
-0.30732327699661255,
0.1264718472957611,
-0.048887502402067184,
0.15479356050491333,
-0.29945680499076843,
0.5594911575317383,
-0.27589553594589233,
0.6921371221542358,
0.4737756550312042,
-0.10685446113348007,
-0.09093160182237625,
0.11923980712890625,
0.6258238554000854,
-0.25106069445610046,
-0.5521641969680786,
-0.803234338760376,
0.32693710923194885,
-0.27065250277519226,
-0.2708578407764435,
0.9194309115409851,
0.7338426113128662,
0.8034388422966003,
0.08182327449321747,
0.7954636216163635,
-0.08183134347200394,
0.6332575082778931,
-0.5470133423805237,
0.6791784167289734,
-0.5630850195884705,
-0.06266223639249802,
0.03721977770328522,
-0.4056791365146637,
-0.532550036907196,
-0.26965606212615967,
-0.16513065993785858,
-0.3389574885368347,
0.8868206143379211,
0.6907732486724854,
-0.3238622546195984,
0.4964545965194702,
0.28558534383773804,
0.532583475112915,
0.3227713108062744,
0.20968124270439148,
0.8615987300872803,
-0.7868412733078003,
0.39230117201805115,
-0.2037227600812912,
-0.3230765759944916,
-0.4396703541278839,
-1.2819114923477173,
-0.949579119682312,
-0.6556136012077332,
-0.6637903451919556,
-0.33169326186180115,
-0.07900286465883255,
0.930584192276001,
0.7853633165359497,
-1.1831296682357788,
0.05735551565885544,
-0.28296712040901184,
0.49758708477020264,
-0.07911428064107895,
-0.1565498262643814,
0.2279200404882431,
-0.2754456400871277,
-0.2869349420070648,
0.2917552590370178,
0.20222431421279907,
0.08703434467315674,
-0.1287892758846283,
0.2214002162218094,
-0.6934733986854553,
0.4124942123889923,
0.5102720260620117,
0.2513357400894165,
-0.5457826852798462,
-0.7325139045715332,
-0.21186380088329315,
-0.09802620857954025,
0.07208790630102158,
0.8170128464698792,
-0.6932039260864258,
0.21971462666988373,
0.7123809456825256,
0.4991002678871155,
0.2071935534477234,
0.23755760490894318,
0.8876919150352478,
-0.7100659608840942,
-0.3191986680030823,
-0.07219555228948593,
0.14310793578624725,
0.5361457467079163,
-0.5093613862991333,
0.4205630421638489,
0.26029279828071594,
-0.6259076595306396,
-0.7488822937011719,
0.17409668862819672,
-0.808169424533844,
-0.07104642689228058,
0.8935405611991882,
0.07570680230855942,
-0.6245564222335815,
-0.662749707698822,
0.14524778723716736,
0.6803053021430969,
-0.11867319047451019,
0.8197197318077087,
0.8914471864700317,
-0.13229387998580933,
0.04294626787304878,
-0.15376372635364532,
1.1111881732940674,
0.33735793828964233,
-0.974063515663147,
-0.04060318320989609,
0.39061975479125977,
0.5329335331916809,
0.3728698492050171,
0.5418938398361206,
0.21181432902812958,
0.4982927143573761,
-0.45270422101020813,
0.3287869989871979,
-0.17290368676185608,
-0.6049970388412476,
-0.007670490071177483,
0.5514440536499023,
0.02816237322986126,
-0.043109629303216934
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10275v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10275v1
|
A Question on the Explainability of Large Language Models and the Word-Level Univariate First-Order Plausibility Assumption
| 2024-03-15T13:15:23 | 2024-03-15T13:15:23 |
Jeremie Bogaert, Francois-Xavier Standaert
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The explanations of large language models have recently been shown to be
sensitive to the randomness used for their training, creating a need to
characterize this sensitivity. In this paper, we propose a characterization
that questions the possibility to provide simple and informative explanations
for such models. To this end, we give statistical definitions for the
explanations' signal, noise and signal-to-noise ratio. We highlight that, in a
typical case study where word-level univariate explanations are analyzed with
first-order statistical tools, the explanations of simple feature-based models
carry more signal and less noise than those of transformer ones. We then
discuss the possibility to improve these results with alternative definitions
of signal and noise that would capture more complex explanations and analysis
methods, while also questioning the tradeoff with their plausibility for
readers.
|
[
-0.3614906370639801,
-0.756730318069458,
0.7632742524147034,
0.1878466159105301,
-0.18747501075267792,
-0.6872443556785583,
-0.470500111579895,
-0.20858527719974518,
-0.3996957242488861,
0.1822441965341568,
-0.6881595253944397,
-0.2171594649553299,
-0.7115052342414856,
0.01979593001306057,
-1.0050331354141235,
0.9830710291862488,
0.04642440378665924,
-0.004444196820259094,
0.055334076285362244,
-0.09060122817754745,
-0.18745315074920654,
-0.3589865267276764,
-0.592407763004303,
-0.3415818214416504,
0.8179430365562439,
-0.01594952493906021,
1.0970114469528198,
0.6334359049797058,
0.4554476737976074,
0.2822374105453491,
-0.07155594974756241,
-0.5511643290519714,
-0.36630022525787354,
-0.08298248052597046,
-0.2433006316423416,
-0.7447724342346191,
-0.23702740669250488,
-0.25077927112579346,
0.5856937170028687,
1.4887572526931763,
0.09517823904752731,
0.3256003260612488,
0.14006175100803375,
0.544795036315918,
-0.20259688794612885,
0.1646936684846878,
-0.607618510723114,
-0.13177523016929626,
-0.09056022018194199,
-0.3210962116718292,
-0.5349940657615662,
-0.09883815050125122,
0.19276033341884613,
-0.7140867114067078,
0.762845516204834,
0.1465369313955307,
0.8667023777961731,
0.0796603187918663,
-0.31568101048469543,
-0.2690631151199341,
-1.135749340057373,
0.9037954211235046,
-0.5601613521575928,
0.3404960334300995,
0.19357305765151978,
0.4197460412979126,
-0.13595175743103027,
-0.6359280943870544,
-0.6248716711997986,
-0.15216508507728577,
-0.2990589439868927,
-0.09067324548959732,
-0.5617969632148743,
0.09949320554733276,
0.5375458598136902,
0.5895757079124451,
-0.4253692328929901,
0.28369179368019104,
-0.3323858678340912,
-0.25716301798820496,
0.6837080121040344,
0.02521728165447712,
0.26118770241737366,
0.3401574194431305,
-0.13792236149311066,
0.06284651905298233,
-0.4927627146244049,
0.2691202461719513,
0.5492090582847595,
0.29246053099632263,
-0.2722908854484558,
0.38528895378112793,
-0.03097318671643734,
0.6628431677818298,
-0.1314917951822281,
-0.05869090184569359,
-0.14376725256443024,
-0.19944898784160614,
-0.1888936161994934,
-0.07402294874191284,
0.5833105444908142,
0.16714902222156525,
0.32830584049224854,
-0.30314522981643677,
-0.22301270067691803,
0.019492439925670624,
-0.03673043102025986,
-0.7981147170066833,
-0.31768500804901123,
0.29859787225723267,
-0.9950277805328369,
-0.4434937536716461,
0.07487349957227707,
-0.8020339012145996,
-0.3633325397968292,
-0.27364078164100647,
0.5320597887039185,
-0.16119995713233948,
-0.6039111614227295,
0.24736939370632172,
-0.19907575845718384,
0.22551430761814117,
0.3391861617565155,
-1.0788683891296387,
0.29672205448150635,
0.6304182410240173,
0.522542417049408,
-0.11780416965484619,
-0.3017408847808838,
-0.053169071674346924,
-0.13392473757266998,
-0.4073815643787384,
0.7716785073280334,
-0.2899503707885742,
-0.018033793196082115,
-0.09571915119886398,
0.04138312116265297,
-0.10721234232187271,
-0.2005205601453781,
0.3207221031188965,
-0.33084166049957275,
0.27204450964927673,
-0.39941832423210144,
-0.27245745062828064,
-0.3157367408275604,
-0.6431040167808533,
-0.5565235018730164,
0.6408025622367859,
0.27906742691993713,
-0.8930075764656067,
0.7114680409431458,
-0.5737468600273132,
-0.5916735529899597,
-0.2773567736148834,
0.05634686350822449,
-0.26348087191581726,
0.5967117547988892,
0.06510453671216965,
0.27105170488357544,
-0.3860666751861572,
0.24210375547409058,
-0.5245673656463623,
-0.5138340592384338,
0.8932099342346191,
-1.0454314947128296,
0.963661253452301,
0.5127436518669128,
-0.12870749831199646,
-0.10883855819702148,
-1.1254397630691528,
-0.13024194538593292,
0.22394263744354248,
-0.3305976092815399,
-0.26964476704597473,
0.2610410451889038,
-0.20185081660747528,
-0.016100231558084488,
0.08015628904104233,
-0.31608062982559204,
-0.19593475759029388,
-0.3709878921508789,
0.4485451281070709,
0.6326192021369934,
-0.23646681010723114,
0.48906266689300537,
-0.37407949566841125,
0.4615090787410736,
0.32575127482414246,
0.41164037585258484,
-0.026255512610077858,
-0.45081594586372375,
-0.7125131487846375,
-0.6080507636070251,
0.15558280050754547,
0.09140964597463608,
-0.2389834076166153,
-0.052611108869314194,
-0.3621409237384796,
-0.1730998307466507,
-0.5157362818717957,
0.09994543343782425,
0.1557088941335678,
0.3240461051464081,
-0.0018674187595024705,
-0.13204547762870789,
-0.5345302224159241,
-0.9049487113952637,
-0.6070722937583923,
-0.20945553481578827,
-0.47113147377967834,
-0.05356873199343681,
0.3094576597213745,
0.31122100353240967,
0.8960482478141785,
-0.1281614899635315,
0.4879884421825409,
-0.5860758423805237,
0.23675976693630219,
0.582431435585022,
-0.10542597621679306,
0.5210585594177246,
-0.7026622295379639,
-0.0714942142367363,
-0.21163310110569,
-0.5704767107963562,
-0.36718761920928955,
-0.06138715147972107,
0.23602665960788727,
-0.14255782961845398,
0.4910166561603546,
-0.5219780206680298,
0.5371984839439392,
0.32499390840530396,
-0.1723872274160385,
0.3604939877986908,
-0.37891849875450134,
-0.28603261709213257,
-0.875161349773407,
0.022241249680519104,
0.1613457351922989,
0.12328308820724487,
-1.0033130645751953,
0.035712163895368576,
-0.6577602028846741,
-0.18170373141765594,
-0.1429472267627716,
0.3569255769252777,
-0.43367454409599304,
-0.37412166595458984,
-0.25247839093208313,
0.16956035792827606,
-0.07590141147375107,
0.17405547201633453,
-0.16349487006664276,
0.5108650326728821,
0.7206020355224609,
-0.8430212140083313,
-0.11219316720962524,
0.04425786808133125,
-0.4245510995388031,
0.4412195682525635,
-0.9403500556945801,
-0.39694151282310486,
-0.6933355927467346,
0.006947312504053116,
-1.4546947479248047,
-0.40382739901542664,
-0.16768886148929596,
-0.5505086183547974,
0.007947038859128952,
-0.2741128206253052,
-0.42787766456604004,
-0.5527073740959167,
0.029856758192181587,
0.24245871603488922,
0.6250450611114502,
-0.6265595555305481,
0.21058405935764313,
0.02692735195159912,
-0.0091857323423028,
-0.19289439916610718,
-0.7316758036613464,
-0.41060900688171387,
-0.5451769828796387,
-0.7097933888435364,
-0.2447311282157898,
-0.1543942093849182,
-0.6557390093803406,
-0.2625587582588196,
-0.09569773823022842,
-0.3458510637283325,
0.6809725761413574,
0.5520192980766296,
0.2586575746536255,
-0.6785573363304138,
0.27311959862709045,
-0.24371559917926788,
-0.2980259954929352,
0.41984638571739197,
0.03800852224230766,
0.32842934131622314,
0.11684456467628479,
-0.404680997133255,
-0.4663776159286499,
0.33998915553092957,
0.5230243802070618,
0.1895376294851303,
0.7690812945365906,
0.44699767231941223,
-0.14627809822559357,
-0.3573490381240845,
-0.0652814731001854,
-0.4411878287792206,
-0.40482297539711,
0.32633936405181885,
-0.6669859886169434,
-0.6436017751693726,
0.6331450343132019,
0.1333581656217575,
0.05339495465159416,
0.8008779883384705,
0.7511542439460754,
-0.10250762850046158,
1.503772258758545,
0.5215649604797363,
0.10917932540178299,
0.19885767996311188,
0.4138570725917816,
0.8325720429420471,
-0.14466512203216553,
0.15094171464443207,
-0.8361772894859314,
-0.19994699954986572,
-0.7759127020835876,
0.018140291795134544,
-0.03195047751069069,
0.15698306262493134,
-0.4702012836933136,
-0.006816937122493982,
-0.46319612860679626,
0.33148935437202454,
0.5324597954750061,
-0.23391254246234894,
0.5149722099304199,
0.363623708486557,
0.34056413173675537,
0.19079875946044922,
-0.8923894762992859,
-0.499158650636673,
0.8667380213737488,
0.8069479465484619,
1.1555379629135132,
0.1129508838057518,
0.10603604465723038,
-0.2168809175491333,
0.3029650151729584,
-0.6000993847846985,
0.34380051493644714,
-0.3517758548259735,
-0.8852066397666931,
-0.5893070697784424,
-0.35150957107543945,
-1.0886632204055786,
0.38108575344085693,
-0.2969723641872406,
-1.1004157066345215,
0.2118188738822937,
0.34695515036582947,
-0.4442678391933441,
0.2436899095773697,
-0.8748649954795837,
0.7226782441139221,
-0.0961008369922638,
0.2214299887418747,
0.10703787952661514,
-0.3615640103816986,
0.6677845120429993,
-0.09553126245737076,
0.7785395979881287,
-0.09819372743368149,
0.3267287313938141,
0.6833694577217102,
-0.6132459044456482,
0.8996869921684265,
-0.06598203629255295,
-0.12813246250152588,
0.26071950793266296,
0.2173670083284378,
0.24425779283046722,
-0.2495340257883072,
-0.09674201160669327,
0.21579958498477936,
0.23928214609622955,
-0.37451183795928955,
-0.6703240275382996,
0.3959179222583771,
-0.8926263451576233,
-0.4784575402736664,
0.06379807740449905,
-0.9156086444854736,
0.07984562963247299,
-0.0037507638335227966,
0.5466864705085754,
0.43415650725364685,
0.12841875851154327,
0.29845884442329407,
0.8590537905693054,
-0.48091837763786316,
0.4718974530696869,
0.5911120176315308,
-0.3583887815475464,
0.2875981032848358,
0.9643701910972595,
0.22251777350902557,
0.2478545755147934,
0.2722265422344208,
0.5756687521934509,
-0.1214672401547432,
-0.8029094338417053,
0.03171614930033684,
0.01151443924754858,
-0.7031078338623047,
0.6095570921897888,
-0.45516109466552734,
-0.07738027721643448,
0.03317784145474434,
-0.08301899582147598,
-0.03088701330125332,
-0.5608712434768677,
-0.16172711551189423,
-0.15370015799999237,
0.3821113109588623,
0.7726948857307434,
0.1633729338645935,
0.7443272471427917,
-0.12409988790750504,
0.5912919044494629,
0.3568768799304962,
0.49192360043525696,
0.23637837171554565,
-1.0658087730407715,
-0.00171571911778301,
0.11990214139223099,
0.17399001121520996,
-0.8229277729988098,
0.13351242244243622,
0.14059342443943024,
0.5363391041755676,
0.47706735134124756,
0.03605184704065323,
0.3847846984863281,
-0.09761685878038406,
0.7381808757781982,
0.26899009943008423,
-0.960132360458374,
0.4042856693267822,
-0.5114414095878601,
0.038281407207250595,
0.21765275299549103,
0.2181454449892044,
0.07484474778175354,
-0.6404520869255066,
-0.7745122313499451,
-0.7913401126861572,
0.5659312605857849,
0.10982978343963623,
0.15112338960170746,
0.2847868800163269,
0.3763951063156128,
0.4262281358242035,
0.12470030039548874,
-0.89446622133255,
-0.2772766053676605,
-0.2066468447446823,
-0.30503758788108826,
-0.1818125993013382,
-0.41260209679603577,
-0.2875958979129791,
-0.012928485870361328,
0.46128979325294495,
-0.08242576569318771,
0.4766169488430023,
-0.08775424212217331,
-0.2854384481906891,
-0.2068660408258438,
0.6091449856758118,
0.6242021918296814,
1.0813541412353516,
-0.03522730991244316,
0.5018621683120728,
-0.0017634890973567963,
-0.27211323380470276,
0.026038536801934242,
0.11558887362480164,
-0.3704100549221039,
0.23188680410385132,
0.7022395133972168,
1.0382001399993896,
0.21632610261440277,
-0.2051241546869278,
0.8242185711860657,
-0.04780411347746849,
-0.3823464810848236,
-0.2410956621170044,
-0.015930047258734703,
-0.07225808501243591,
0.07806818932294846,
0.3546064794063568,
-0.254362553358078,
0.024104559794068336,
-0.6202021837234497,
-0.05327873304486275,
0.4620647728443146,
-0.342731237411499,
-0.5311898589134216,
0.8497816920280457,
-0.16396941244602203,
-0.09461522847414017,
0.1905299574136734,
-0.042172450572252274,
-0.07795929163694382,
0.7866983413696289,
0.48442521691322327,
0.5688607692718506,
0.0827975794672966,
0.3484799563884735,
0.13828180730342865,
0.49399563670158386,
-0.07240105420351028,
0.37315165996551514,
0.37001940608024597,
-0.7249839901924133,
-0.5738386511802673,
-0.7059600353240967,
-0.1706549972295761,
0.3364572525024414,
-0.8584050536155701,
0.05683597922325134,
-0.3037959635257721,
0.001258229254744947,
0.8780031800270081,
-0.604131817817688,
-0.7113296985626221,
0.19852113723754883,
-0.02506452053785324,
0.7846984267234802,
-1.2257755994796753,
0.4740782082080841,
0.28364482522010803,
-0.4841472804546356,
-1.0831228494644165,
0.05541554093360901,
-0.1606249064207077,
-1.1397547721862793,
0.6352793574333191,
-0.01787232980132103,
0.2550283968448639,
-0.30957624316215515,
-0.5061787962913513,
-0.7988080382347107,
0.804573118686676,
0.6708261370658875,
-0.5383340716362,
0.12008204311132431,
0.3851870596408844,
0.7402796745300293,
-0.14266109466552734,
0.48640045523643494,
0.6712488532066345,
0.6282854080200195,
-0.061698053032159805,
-0.5539259910583496,
0.18997807800769806,
0.2258673757314682,
0.2949940860271454,
0.12289777398109436,
-0.3942977488040924,
0.90413498878479,
-0.48940548300743103,
-0.16955403983592987,
-0.03124392218887806,
0.7322161793708801,
-0.25081703066825867,
0.5600636601448059,
0.7445492148399353,
0.06260267645120621,
0.6032634377479553,
-0.33777737617492676,
1.408909797668457,
-0.4467215836048126,
0.4796501398086548,
0.8446279168128967,
0.17945335805416107,
0.46206000447273254,
0.6222865581512451,
-0.5719408988952637,
0.3771771490573883,
0.6256199479103088,
-0.0991600826382637,
0.2876138389110565,
0.5920925736427307,
-0.12702499330043793,
-0.2671121656894684,
0.12161105871200562,
-0.0861082598567009,
0.3512498438358307,
0.0037536572199314833,
-0.6317856907844543,
-0.49446067214012146,
0.18937556445598602,
-0.12439930438995361,
-0.24872523546218872,
-0.5270009636878967,
0.5804439187049866,
0.19970618188381195,
-0.4498179852962494,
0.5240231156349182,
-0.2948065400123596,
0.20046661794185638,
-0.4555204212665558,
0.3911283314228058,
-0.16606608033180237,
0.29442182183265686,
-0.3881547451019287,
-0.7347024083137512,
0.31487151980400085,
-0.11261895298957825,
-0.685060977935791,
-0.09469940513372421,
0.49029457569122314,
-0.35295453667640686,
-0.6001260280609131,
-0.04597710072994232,
0.38040223717689514,
0.4446686804294586,
0.0076335277408361435,
-0.29215943813323975,
0.04177577421069145,
-0.09229152649641037,
-0.39295437932014465,
0.5001458525657654,
0.7193048596382141,
-0.07922934740781784,
0.7451391816139221,
0.5401208996772766,
0.11464613676071167,
0.2666650116443634,
0.33214670419692993,
0.2614883780479431,
-0.2566629946231842,
-0.22526200115680695,
-0.7274251580238342,
0.42380520701408386,
0.26931488513946533,
-0.29189908504486084,
0.6176179647445679,
0.14868927001953125,
0.3631468713283539,
-0.26323193311691284,
1.0549812316894531,
0.02566135860979557,
0.6566009521484375,
-0.45910096168518066,
0.4838770627975464,
-0.27816012501716614,
0.46152809262275696,
0.08338772505521774,
-0.8590145111083984,
-0.06469979137182236,
0.5208436250686646,
-0.27047422528266907,
0.082285575568676,
0.7997081875801086,
0.8813214898109436,
-0.19634032249450684,
0.2909586727619171,
0.5993525981903076,
0.8263503909111023,
-0.08945539593696594,
0.21565081179141998,
0.6795101761817932,
-0.22638241946697235,
0.8361842632293701,
-0.22334341704845428,
-0.2926079034805298,
-0.1836174577474594,
-0.9297600388526917,
-0.769045352935791,
-0.5345892906188965,
-0.44966626167297363,
-0.5150249600410461,
-0.08321955054998398,
0.3259045481681824,
0.47375988960266113,
-1.0300636291503906,
-0.041392210870981216,
-0.1737166792154312,
0.3004533350467682,
-0.33860597014427185,
-0.21701198816299438,
0.37076687812805176,
-0.23305608332157135,
-0.3753722906112671,
0.19993191957473755,
-0.06340757012367249,
0.11829104274511337,
-0.25279664993286133,
0.3201734721660614,
0.6102438569068909,
0.41016218066215515,
0.6599153876304626,
0.42305830121040344,
-0.8369925618171692,
-0.6106030941009521,
-0.2928990423679352,
0.15561191737651825,
-0.18469953536987305,
0.9526419639587402,
-0.06674683094024658,
0.22638797760009766,
0.427608847618103,
0.14165537059307098,
0.14964604377746582,
-0.11762889474630356,
0.7125003337860107,
-0.48289087414741516,
0.2632897198200226,
-0.5279902815818787,
0.4551374614238739,
0.10542023926973343,
-0.35172244906425476,
0.17087233066558838,
0.10754475742578506,
-0.34043821692466736,
-0.8962385654449463,
0.3250434100627899,
-1.0654654502868652,
-0.3337405025959015,
1.3114542961120605,
-0.18390530347824097,
-0.18122261762619019,
-0.3277861773967743,
0.1162395104765892,
0.16536656022071838,
-0.017964433878660202,
0.8288953900337219,
0.9787842631340027,
0.02280394546687603,
-0.27644264698028564,
-1.1035879850387573,
0.4549419581890106,
0.3719221353530884,
-0.5373259782791138,
0.3944202959537506,
0.2561057507991791,
0.6265473365783691,
-0.05584259703755379,
0.2719539701938629,
-0.1989731341600418,
0.2367832064628601,
0.1292029768228531,
-0.21617983281612396,
0.17543518543243408,
-0.024319631978869438,
-0.7384660840034485,
0.3479880094528198,
0.5297108292579651,
-0.12903784215450287
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10258v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10258v2
|
Is Translation All You Need? A Study on Solving Multilingual Tasks with Large Language Models
| 2024-03-15T12:47:39 | 2024-06-20T11:09:42 |
Chaoqun Liu, Wenxuan Zhang, Yiran Zhao, Anh Tuan Luu, Lidong Bing
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated multilingual capabilities;
yet, they are mostly English-centric due to the imbalanced training corpora.
Existing works leverage this phenomenon to improve their multilingual
performances through translation, primarily on natural language processing
(NLP) tasks. This work extends the evaluation from NLP tasks to real user
queries and from English-centric LLMs to non-English-centric LLMs. While
translation into English can help improve the performance of multilingual NLP
tasks for English-centric LLMs, it may not be optimal for all scenarios. For
culture-related tasks that need deep language understanding, prompting in the
native language tends to be more promising as it better captures the nuances of
culture and language. Our experiments reveal varied behaviors among different
LLMs and tasks in the multilingual context. Therefore, we advocate for more
comprehensive multilingual evaluation and more efforts toward developing
multilingual LLMs beyond English-centric ones.
|
[
-0.2585448920726776,
-0.6514381766319275,
0.5724900364875793,
0.4671390950679779,
-0.23403333127498627,
0.22777988016605377,
-0.6209086179733276,
-0.7447907328605652,
0.2705581486225128,
0.4120657444000244,
-0.5777493715286255,
-0.27161452174186707,
-0.7208975553512573,
0.4905819296836853,
-0.31211715936660767,
0.9443643689155579,
-0.07072638720273972,
0.48138412833213806,
-0.5050631761550903,
-0.22043220698833466,
-0.730525016784668,
-0.5669947862625122,
-0.8618155717849731,
-0.5218204855918884,
0.6412898302078247,
0.46428990364074707,
0.40057843923568726,
0.1965320110321045,
0.5021993517875671,
0.2680976986885071,
-0.13710594177246094,
0.4261437952518463,
-0.45798587799072266,
0.16621221601963043,
-0.29956763982772827,
-0.47182220220565796,
-0.3298115134239197,
-0.012025808915495872,
0.40857911109924316,
0.8928343057632446,
0.04029921069741249,
0.45542463660240173,
0.11196429282426834,
0.5390121340751648,
-0.508207380771637,
0.053445637226104736,
-0.39935562014579773,
0.20240004360675812,
-0.011485928669571877,
-0.27132919430732727,
-0.4506939947605133,
-0.007087341044098139,
-0.12772133946418762,
-0.6000757813453674,
-0.030465219169855118,
0.22744035720825195,
0.3360697627067566,
0.13900284469127655,
-0.867698073387146,
-0.2781631648540497,
-0.9123898148536682,
0.9737939238548279,
-0.6166501641273499,
0.5915979743003845,
0.2459113746881485,
0.12636993825435638,
-0.09197653830051422,
-0.4177720844745636,
-0.41964980959892273,
-0.3063287138938904,
-0.12344302237033844,
0.1324152797460556,
-0.005444849841296673,
-0.20484444499015808,
0.210337296128273,
0.3410181701183319,
-0.7070271372795105,
0.3336241841316223,
-0.4618733525276184,
-0.2829544246196747,
0.6450644731521606,
0.1859678328037262,
0.5015115141868591,
-0.018602073192596436,
-0.22514386475086212,
-0.08070049434900284,
-0.5231329798698425,
0.06485485285520554,
0.15685364603996277,
0.3630279004573822,
-0.28166434168815613,
0.6130245923995972,
0.0306794922798872,
0.6719946265220642,
-0.2589019238948822,
-0.39156749844551086,
0.22824342548847198,
-0.6717870831489563,
0.03364028409123421,
-0.22229690849781036,
0.5785805583000183,
0.5850582122802734,
0.5464726686477661,
-0.4576357901096344,
-0.20469681918621063,
-0.18744321167469025,
0.24951691925525665,
-0.5937843322753906,
0.4526532292366028,
0.3149257004261017,
-0.3859516680240631,
0.01293246354907751,
-0.3674643337726593,
-0.582238495349884,
-0.29206201434135437,
-0.5505903959274292,
0.20266970992088318,
-0.19981978833675385,
-0.4267739951610565,
0.18597762286663055,
0.06409160792827606,
0.3223664164543152,
0.28646916151046753,
-0.7891277074813843,
-0.01502997986972332,
0.7356969714164734,
0.92584228515625,
-0.4231317937374115,
-0.5989832282066345,
-0.49920734763145447,
0.00020115716324653476,
-0.43245217204093933,
0.635102391242981,
-0.26632776856422424,
-0.3839660584926605,
0.2779986560344696,
0.17972160875797272,
-0.27814120054244995,
-0.5145982503890991,
0.8411659598350525,
-0.4898567497730255,
0.19750608503818512,
-0.40639954805374146,
-0.2737460732460022,
-0.21286185085773468,
0.5599740743637085,
-0.6198164820671082,
0.7285324931144714,
-0.2579772472381592,
-0.4141175150871277,
0.2952873706817627,
-0.6029592156410217,
-0.8783649206161499,
0.09214029461145401,
0.18457183241844177,
0.07067446410655975,
0.26726579666137695,
0.37412217259407043,
0.4433736205101013,
-0.38172563910484314,
0.2515128552913666,
-0.19622376561164856,
-0.3459802567958832,
0.19307585060596466,
-0.24437202513217926,
0.5715290307998657,
0.3753272593021393,
-0.08991794288158417,
0.1825464814901352,
-0.3982656002044678,
0.15670283138751984,
0.047073714435100555,
-0.6217761039733887,
-0.2376161515712738,
0.012947923503816128,
0.42199134826660156,
0.464218407869339,
0.5770362615585327,
-0.5345145463943481,
0.23378325998783112,
-0.4279070794582367,
0.3164399564266205,
0.4964680075645447,
-0.33718404173851013,
0.7498080134391785,
-0.15112003684043884,
0.8112444281578064,
-0.0679856613278389,
0.020546123385429382,
0.002074922900646925,
-0.5826520323753357,
-0.5143164992332458,
-0.07510516792535782,
0.10054010897874832,
0.6758951544761658,
-0.837566077709198,
0.1070597916841507,
-0.35078758001327515,
-0.41793695092201233,
-0.5982812643051147,
0.4946059286594391,
0.3901340663433075,
0.23845896124839783,
0.48765066266059875,
-0.09653735160827637,
-0.5648549199104309,
-0.9774003028869629,
-0.22636663913726807,
-0.013327746652066708,
-0.13732993602752686,
0.009978332556784153,
0.4425595700740814,
-0.32407018542289734,
0.41164499521255493,
-0.2145635336637497,
-0.6111087203025818,
-0.7692789435386658,
-0.020267818123102188,
0.30875164270401,
0.1930495649576187,
0.5023812651634216,
-0.8372035026550293,
-0.6711365580558777,
0.46271076798439026,
-0.675281822681427,
-0.18677639961242676,
-0.010147379711270332,
-0.14320075511932373,
0.2971833646297455,
0.5467357635498047,
-0.6977925300598145,
-0.14669157564640045,
0.8589735627174377,
-0.14891669154167175,
0.3000377118587494,
-0.41509220004081726,
0.2509668171405792,
-1.2156124114990234,
0.2782230079174042,
0.11264420300722122,
-0.4596242904663086,
-0.6763156652450562,
0.5082663893699646,
0.29255858063697815,
-0.215213343501091,
-0.43610188364982605,
0.6925349831581116,
-0.47050008177757263,
-0.10000216960906982,
-0.3427537977695465,
0.22048933804035187,
0.19266584515571594,
0.16047914326190948,
0.11400196701288223,
0.8756170272827148,
0.4495528042316437,
-0.49705439805984497,
0.5178610682487488,
0.257271945476532,
-0.3831382095813751,
0.697114884853363,
-0.4410765767097473,
0.048225514590740204,
-0.21280083060264587,
0.08775357156991959,
-0.8835999369621277,
-0.21680836379528046,
-0.06600471585988998,
-0.31452393531799316,
0.492434024810791,
0.048470985144376755,
-0.5475576519966125,
-0.3640435039997101,
-0.07757604122161865,
0.2299833595752716,
0.23210401833057404,
-0.5443929433822632,
0.49192166328430176,
0.057733096182346344,
-0.2967608571052551,
-0.6316214203834534,
-0.6368284821510315,
0.38501936197280884,
-0.12786929309368134,
-0.6572538018226624,
0.21349398791790009,
-0.34418442845344543,
-0.30419406294822693,
-0.2782542109489441,
0.060042139142751694,
0.007800351828336716,
0.2654059827327728,
-0.058601077646017075,
0.19393764436244965,
-0.22479881346225739,
0.10886331647634506,
-0.16466505825519562,
-0.023195017129182816,
0.12621380388736725,
-0.27548208832740784,
0.3996966779232025,
-0.013578607700765133,
-0.3992120921611786,
-0.12277228385210037,
0.8430432677268982,
0.8934412002563477,
-0.5800313353538513,
0.6489472389221191,
0.7348641157150269,
-0.1908690482378006,
-0.06550716608762741,
-0.7280186414718628,
-0.18928496539592743,
-0.3180868625640869,
0.653740406036377,
-0.39769500494003296,
-0.9111719131469727,
0.40903690457344055,
0.09817162901163101,
0.29606738686561584,
0.2824549376964569,
0.6109305620193481,
-0.2632901668548584,
1.2345610857009888,
0.6680129766464233,
-0.29253870248794556,
0.15307340025901794,
0.10187830775976181,
0.5531676411628723,
-0.7038406133651733,
-0.20596392452716827,
-0.3724862039089203,
-0.5968869924545288,
-0.39163681864738464,
-0.3521597683429718,
0.43565481901168823,
0.014925436116755009,
0.30755576491355896,
0.17344264686107635,
-0.287651002407074,
0.3950861990451813,
0.16880738735198975,
-0.13690806925296783,
0.4626576900482178,
0.06551721692085266,
0.17809464037418365,
-0.3258621096611023,
-0.5305666923522949,
-0.4017937481403351,
0.9502878785133362,
0.19223706424236298,
0.5182530879974365,
0.36339548230171204,
0.35914865136146545,
0.08215244859457016,
0.38575461506843567,
-1.0612062215805054,
0.33565884828567505,
-0.3315911293029785,
-0.7432082891464233,
-0.24521800875663757,
-0.41054239869117737,
-1.1207810640335083,
0.6220781207084656,
-0.32608264684677124,
-0.3688252866268158,
-0.23661160469055176,
-0.10128359496593475,
-0.011602209880948067,
0.17549528181552887,
-0.6257761716842651,
0.89655601978302,
-0.7047096490859985,
-0.2735300660133362,
-0.38528817892074585,
-0.32212966680526733,
0.3411027491092682,
-0.3754020035266876,
0.702555775642395,
-0.07422380149364471,
-0.024975135922431946,
0.296251505613327,
0.22107075154781342,
0.7030776143074036,
-0.019681410863995552,
-0.28246787190437317,
-0.10569608211517334,
0.16009365022182465,
0.31885817646980286,
-0.0244198776781559,
-0.3051781952381134,
0.04869756102561951,
0.16391031444072723,
-0.4233732521533966,
-0.6274697184562683,
0.7700241208076477,
-0.6690223813056946,
-0.7159548997879028,
-0.3117920458316803,
-0.8288739919662476,
-0.2631973326206207,
0.11421798169612885,
0.23780670762062073,
-0.04562108591198921,
-0.19380195438861847,
0.23067641258239746,
0.3778282105922699,
0.042987652122974396,
0.4291718006134033,
0.763094961643219,
-0.28228050470352173,
0.05662890151143074,
0.699320912361145,
0.07853826135396957,
0.17556306719779968,
0.4816550314426422,
0.1416494995355606,
-0.4346429407596588,
-0.5932765603065491,
-0.8050738573074341,
0.31852987408638,
-0.7175208926200867,
-0.0008850688464008272,
-0.4656619429588318,
0.18973027169704437,
-0.5541996359825134,
-0.1409239023923874,
-0.3360207974910736,
-0.05142582207918167,
-0.24477697908878326,
-0.15863311290740967,
0.0618332140147686,
0.6371368765830994,
-0.03566509112715721,
0.020458031445741653,
-0.8775151371955872,
0.28294724225997925,
0.1513839066028595,
0.05536270514130592,
0.027528928592801094,
-0.7113053202629089,
-0.4928141236305237,
0.06662917137145996,
-0.28158262372016907,
-0.7049511075019836,
0.6011125445365906,
0.32676368951797485,
0.5891427993774414,
0.14110246300697327,
-0.2161344289779663,
0.7084382772445679,
-0.6386404037475586,
0.7712224721908569,
0.2015436738729477,
-0.7540238499641418,
0.14561259746551514,
-0.08219877630472183,
0.38848093152046204,
0.5535996556282043,
0.7020927667617798,
-0.9873983263969421,
-0.11985801160335541,
0.030850330367684364,
-0.9747940301895142,
0.46645981073379517,
-0.15580974519252777,
0.4970320165157318,
0.057060692459344864,
0.3950427174568176,
-0.17383386194705963,
0.2968561351299286,
-1.0561851263046265,
0.041957173496484756,
0.28062689304351807,
0.08871758729219437,
-0.5184041857719421,
-0.22938419878482819,
-0.14281392097473145,
-0.1546558439731598,
0.4954226613044739,
-0.30666592717170715,
-0.23350107669830322,
0.04182209447026253,
-0.3623828887939453,
-0.21270586550235748,
0.544439435005188,
0.5116553902626038,
0.8917578458786011,
0.046680036932229996,
-0.0610407255589962,
0.4224112629890442,
-0.19933101534843445,
0.17048229277133942,
-0.16689427196979523,
0.1064358800649643,
-0.05700046941637993,
0.5919412970542908,
0.5654646158218384,
0.2637600004673004,
-0.7508621215820312,
0.7562273144721985,
-0.07396816462278366,
0.06662320345640182,
-0.38974547386169434,
-0.1827765703201294,
0.3576628863811493,
0.17943179607391357,
0.37943682074546814,
-0.2714790105819702,
0.009646721184253693,
-0.5991337895393372,
-0.27451032400131226,
0.60157710313797,
-0.1719188690185547,
-0.15175925195217133,
0.604545533657074,
0.32855865359306335,
-0.2508406937122345,
0.6177663207054138,
-0.08965817838907242,
-0.2757575809955597,
0.4318322241306305,
0.7484672665596008,
0.6535825133323669,
-0.27516037225723267,
0.09098323434591293,
0.4360301196575165,
0.46474334597587585,
-0.18939730525016785,
0.1859733760356903,
0.01309943851083517,
-0.6845111846923828,
-1.266811490058899,
-0.7813313603401184,
-0.43492481112480164,
0.20099417865276337,
-0.7778469920158386,
0.30561092495918274,
0.019595609977841377,
-0.0019616533536463976,
-0.196965292096138,
-0.21488797664642334,
-0.6624946594238281,
0.1373833864927292,
0.2498386949300766,
0.838814914226532,
-0.9346194267272949,
0.7530792355537415,
1.0635095834732056,
-0.1278453767299652,
-0.47091326117515564,
-0.39192995429039,
-0.110719695687294,
-0.5249459147453308,
0.8170503973960876,
0.02722925879061222,
-0.05770143121480942,
-0.11632748693227768,
-0.3498644232749939,
-0.6832981109619141,
0.7202373147010803,
0.49976521730422974,
-0.6308181881904602,
-0.1793091595172882,
0.315030574798584,
0.6656718254089355,
-0.39938560128211975,
0.250130832195282,
0.4648706614971161,
0.6526563763618469,
-0.19689133763313293,
-1.1158360242843628,
-0.27945417165756226,
-0.216841921210289,
0.05386799946427345,
0.12146935611963272,
-0.4004814326763153,
0.6549202799797058,
-0.17452867329120636,
0.06514198333024979,
-0.007145766634494066,
0.48086997866630554,
0.04865569993853569,
0.3003634810447693,
0.5185681581497192,
0.3598654568195343,
0.5858288407325745,
0.007028708700090647,
1.3151735067367554,
-0.37415340542793274,
-0.015854405239224434,
0.9683982133865356,
-0.5049086213111877,
1.0254848003387451,
0.730158805847168,
-0.067689910531044,
-0.043890632688999176,
0.7838090062141418,
0.17484340071678162,
0.10543946921825409,
0.07180313020944595,
-0.2696719169616699,
-0.6493207812309265,
-0.28435608744621277,
-0.20687635242938995,
0.5158733129501343,
0.34076476097106934,
-0.08416817337274551,
-0.11454053968191147,
0.4145553708076477,
0.08816399425268173,
0.3802192509174347,
-0.2876136600971222,
0.6520314812660217,
0.26638251543045044,
-0.9258285760879517,
0.5248541831970215,
0.35314294695854187,
0.9170594811439514,
-0.8320766687393188,
0.1801673024892807,
-0.3660354018211365,
-0.12283868342638016,
-0.38262122869491577,
-0.7798866033554077,
0.42513197660446167,
-0.026952313259243965,
-0.3831046521663666,
-0.6265891194343567,
0.42591437697410583,
-0.5368382930755615,
-0.5611963868141174,
0.809057891368866,
0.894382655620575,
0.3630380630493164,
-0.2851831018924713,
-0.37283700704574585,
-0.016705622896552086,
0.055699948221445084,
-0.21866504848003387,
0.544815719127655,
0.2250055968761444,
-0.10488690435886383,
0.6821121573448181,
0.9387167096138,
0.3561851680278778,
0.10627741366624832,
0.14768072962760925,
0.4386269748210907,
-0.4282468259334564,
-0.2269316166639328,
-0.8138140439987183,
0.30966994166374207,
0.11629724502563477,
-0.2429499328136444,
0.8363868594169617,
0.5522093176841736,
1.0520566701889038,
-0.33886370062828064,
0.7227879166603088,
0.04097094014286995,
0.37540847063064575,
-0.48310133814811707,
0.5452234745025635,
-1.0284878015518188,
-0.03773551806807518,
0.06841528415679932,
-1.1728652715682983,
-0.2477857619524002,
0.3828465938568115,
-0.3635503649711609,
-0.31088143587112427,
0.6473106741905212,
0.5436111688613892,
-0.06733990460634232,
-0.14172124862670898,
0.720169186592102,
0.013400939293205738,
0.3062043786048889,
0.5400547981262207,
0.8428919911384583,
-0.036469876766204834,
0.7167479395866394,
-0.09393808990716934,
-0.03198147192597389,
-0.11427879333496094,
-0.8956508040428162,
-0.6969040036201477,
-0.5089779496192932,
-0.16416259109973907,
-0.14478635787963867,
-0.13526244461536407,
1.0329079627990723,
0.6550947427749634,
-0.695663332939148,
-0.622995913028717,
0.43279585242271423,
0.1096574068069458,
-0.2874390184879303,
-0.13302530348300934,
-0.15994799137115479,
-0.6775306463241577,
-1.196869134902954,
0.743679940700531,
0.16832974553108215,
-0.15549276769161224,
-0.44745445251464844,
0.010894973762333393,
-0.23237086832523346,
-0.23901347815990448,
0.9890031218528748,
0.25194618105888367,
-0.6294554471969604,
-0.11634501069784164,
0.10871279984712601,
-0.19012418389320374,
-0.027759985998272896,
0.8837569952011108,
-0.1862209290266037,
0.5162001252174377,
0.5953534245491028,
0.785802960395813,
0.4588316082954407,
-0.3658657371997833,
0.7215844392776489,
-0.7396202087402344,
0.33882465958595276,
0.23782514035701752,
0.49945303797721863,
0.5321441292762756,
-0.3909936547279358,
0.5055670142173767,
-0.10382288694381714,
-0.6705488562583923,
-0.6442295908927917,
0.29443639516830444,
-0.7290363311767578,
-0.21439482271671295,
1.3185173273086548,
-0.07854553312063217,
-0.1037350445985794,
-0.08752188831567764,
-0.2400369644165039,
0.10803304612636566,
-0.10089325904846191,
0.33374133706092834,
0.9503220915794373,
-0.09475338459014893,
-0.2209768295288086,
-1.0195839405059814,
0.12872053682804108,
0.6939546465873718,
-0.6224767565727234,
-0.1192392036318779,
0.39250704646110535,
0.137937530875206,
0.3883219361305237,
0.46876469254493713,
0.030857015401124954,
0.07199404388666153,
-0.7161846160888672,
0.28458142280578613,
0.11317681521177292,
-0.25216832756996155,
-0.46564817428588867,
0.11067268997430801,
0.574394166469574,
0.11519557982683182
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10239v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10239v1
|
A Big Data Approach to Understand Sub-national Determinants of FDI in Africa
| 2024-03-15T12:12:54 | 2024-03-15T12:12:54 |
A. Fronzetti Colladon, R. Vestrelli, S. Bait, M. M. Schiraldi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, econ.EM, physics.soc-ph, I.2.7; J.4; H.4.0
|
Various macroeconomic and institutional factors hinder FDI inflows, including
corruption, trade openness, access to finance, and political instability.
Existing research mostly focuses on country-level data, with limited
exploration of firm-level data, especially in developing countries. Recognizing
this gap, recent calls for research emphasize the need for qualitative data
analysis to delve into FDI determinants, particularly at the regional level.
This paper proposes a novel methodology, based on text mining and social
network analysis, to get information from more than 167,000 online news
articles to quantify regional-level (sub-national) attributes affecting FDI
ownership in African companies. Our analysis extends information on obstacles
to industrial development as mapped by the World Bank Enterprise Surveys.
Findings suggest that regional (sub-national) structural and institutional
characteristics can play an important role in determining foreign ownership.
|
[
-0.7979391813278198,
-1.0308563709259033,
0.6288794875144958,
0.23164062201976776,
-0.21994000673294067,
0.24371249973773956,
0.06296810507774353,
-0.6048071980476379,
0.47762688994407654,
0.3578561544418335,
-0.7148318290710449,
-0.4995856285095215,
-0.7129452228546143,
0.13295653462409973,
-0.25334432721138,
0.9051411151885986,
-0.3100240230560303,
-0.49347737431526184,
-0.004415599163621664,
-0.08183547854423523,
-0.05013219267129898,
-0.7147212624549866,
-0.720091700553894,
0.06001374498009682,
0.5336548089981079,
0.2876298725605011,
0.5675270557403564,
0.11880631744861603,
0.5045487880706787,
0.2550760805606842,
-0.2809876799583435,
0.3342537581920624,
-0.20610660314559937,
-0.39648953080177307,
-0.38353240489959717,
-0.2571108043193817,
-0.1901669204235077,
-0.21277712285518646,
0.42959311604499817,
0.704750657081604,
0.04353898763656616,
0.1614290028810501,
0.03371264040470123,
0.6412375569343567,
-0.4724476635456085,
0.48601484298706055,
-0.2542991638183594,
0.04751013219356537,
-0.5334279537200928,
-0.10727628320455551,
0.293057918548584,
-0.6756623387336731,
0.5269896388053894,
-0.23146437108516693,
0.49339985847473145,
-0.20523665845394135,
0.9029433131217957,
-0.0735490471124649,
-0.6739612817764282,
-0.4178544580936432,
-0.8115501999855042,
0.6787571907043457,
-0.41058358550071716,
0.2871851921081543,
0.6227152347564697,
0.2117491513490677,
-0.256191611289978,
-0.46424177289009094,
-0.3439708650112152,
0.21480989456176758,
-0.17626801133155823,
-0.4028069078922272,
-0.17055116593837738,
-0.26829275488853455,
0.13886266946792603,
0.7738887071609497,
-0.057672422379255295,
0.0017547991592437029,
-0.39060550928115845,
-0.20487186312675476,
0.7014501094818115,
0.021759696304798126,
0.6884551048278809,
0.045417189598083496,
-0.3347311019897461,
-0.05877635255455971,
-0.7772635221481323,
0.12494433671236038,
0.6230230331420898,
0.4185720682144165,
-0.2678442597389221,
0.3581479489803314,
-0.34797143936157227,
0.3836647570133209,
0.08186012506484985,
-0.0640217512845993,
0.39055171608924866,
-0.930066704750061,
0.2119365930557251,
0.32319405674934387,
0.4732156991958618,
-0.0041980925016105175,
0.18969625234603882,
-0.15673939883708954,
-0.11179320514202118,
-0.26055803894996643,
0.011784798465669155,
-0.7921276092529297,
0.16919277608394623,
0.3764995336532593,
-0.6613875031471252,
-0.24610763788223267,
0.4311113655567169,
-1.0584230422973633,
-0.4873758852481842,
-0.08899830281734467,
0.29891836643218994,
-0.12202654033899307,
-0.5112830996513367,
-0.34673094749450684,
-0.24632807075977325,
0.4001944661140442,
-0.0021358428057283163,
-0.8847150802612305,
-0.036719441413879395,
0.7105978727340698,
1.168805718421936,
0.26447147130966187,
-0.013118005357682705,
0.17600783705711365,
0.016288110986351967,
-0.4927378296852112,
0.5190251469612122,
-0.3296234607696533,
-0.43001922965049744,
0.2510308027267456,
0.1814197301864624,
0.03298661857843399,
-0.7116696834564209,
-0.0939323902130127,
-0.3294733166694641,
-0.4408121407032013,
-0.8081877827644348,
0.0014609998324885964,
-0.4032062590122223,
0.15574538707733154,
-0.9503875970840454,
0.5225494503974915,
0.43495720624923706,
-0.6527901887893677,
1.0120033025741577,
-0.6389554738998413,
-0.6242418885231018,
-0.20923219621181488,
-0.3956206738948822,
-0.2966530919075012,
0.30047765374183655,
0.5225046277046204,
0.4387378394603729,
-0.42511290311813354,
0.5386619567871094,
-0.23606105148792267,
0.02376299723982811,
0.13924719393253326,
-0.20944401621818542,
0.8858329653739929,
-0.10368628799915314,
-0.47382956743240356,
-0.14809539914131165,
-0.8231163620948792,
-0.536195695400238,
-0.07920464128255844,
0.335848867893219,
-0.6997102499008179,
0.10111472010612488,
-0.5024923086166382,
0.44233977794647217,
0.23625856637954712,
-1.0246009826660156,
0.3084450662136078,
-0.2895650565624237,
0.3720671534538269,
0.5046889185905457,
0.9022446870803833,
0.38213515281677246,
-0.1792188435792923,
0.5126378536224365,
0.6893458366394043,
0.17328712344169617,
0.3837987184524536,
-0.19301128387451172,
-0.6901328563690186,
-0.20529566705226898,
0.721963107585907,
0.22632718086242676,
-0.9683102369308472,
-0.16016662120819092,
0.004532671999186277,
-0.5189926624298096,
-0.6800247430801392,
0.186533123254776,
-0.12899233400821686,
0.11803854256868362,
-0.050224095582962036,
-0.29557445645332336,
-0.5156953930854797,
-1.1653755903244019,
0.23139971494674683,
0.22056816518306732,
0.12100443989038467,
0.2126719355583191,
0.8784657120704651,
-0.38084089756011963,
1.0221143960952759,
-0.5090155005455017,
-0.842538595199585,
-0.35982316732406616,
0.142057403922081,
0.41537901759147644,
0.26676300168037415,
0.9110320210456848,
-0.8423259258270264,
-0.08656744658946991,
0.33350783586502075,
-0.5973808765411377,
0.08260626345872879,
-0.18831686675548553,
-0.25533100962638855,
0.23705486953258514,
0.5543960332870483,
-0.39986833930015564,
0.8576687574386597,
0.22346742451190948,
-0.23136518895626068,
0.04973805323243141,
-0.047921113669872284,
-0.05038916692137718,
-0.7852197885513306,
0.05881496146321297,
0.4458712339401245,
0.3156581521034241,
-0.3088073432445526,
-0.12464476376771927,
-0.28698715567588806,
-0.14403440058231354,
-0.27988722920417786,
0.34715336561203003,
-0.43059206008911133,
-0.3310753107070923,
0.15592849254608154,
0.05548820644617081,
-0.071627177298069,
0.14737559854984283,
-0.039280232042074203,
0.7731564044952393,
0.23214289546012878,
-0.5139511227607727,
0.12149880081415176,
0.419773131608963,
-0.8581377863883972,
0.67149418592453,
-0.45127004384994507,
-0.3693453371524811,
-0.11976649612188339,
0.391546368598938,
-0.7469710111618042,
-0.021496905013918877,
-0.30976471304893494,
-0.27432548999786377,
0.059396278113126755,
-0.02946333959698677,
-0.052734989672899246,
0.016439372673630714,
-0.08949384093284607,
0.0788891538977623,
-0.1356283277273178,
-0.40350615978240967,
0.45998066663742065,
0.3979349434375763,
-0.6743356585502625,
-0.41769444942474365,
-0.7327570915222168,
-0.012432157061994076,
-0.14798851311206818,
-0.7655391097068787,
0.14830449223518372,
0.5092301964759827,
-0.4904007315635681,
0.21926073729991913,
-0.1965816169977188,
-0.3422762453556061,
0.29494065046310425,
0.0873682051897049,
-0.11375405639410019,
-0.22428444027900696,
-0.49400001764297485,
0.21427284181118011,
-0.2756136655807495,
0.4265233874320984,
0.11420569568872452,
0.43609482049942017,
0.27149972319602966,
0.23607471585273743,
-0.7579989433288574,
0.4716302454471588,
0.4423772096633911,
-0.6928579211235046,
1.1504095792770386,
0.5093927383422852,
-0.4141220152378082,
-0.6116982698440552,
-0.07745013386011124,
0.09731431305408478,
-0.4551371932029724,
0.23446768522262573,
-0.25348424911499023,
-0.2336348295211792,
0.6779524087905884,
-0.05331665277481079,
0.09599609673023224,
0.6021729111671448,
0.602264940738678,
0.2682276666164398,
0.7175708413124084,
0.9397352337837219,
-0.29679548740386963,
0.2161695808172226,
-1.007606029510498,
0.9619063138961792,
-0.6408953666687012,
-0.5082252025604248,
-0.6188818216323853,
-0.6805863380432129,
-0.4398537576198578,
0.05161571502685547,
0.27282625436782837,
-0.09364037215709686,
0.011713255196809769,
-0.16524505615234375,
0.17779803276062012,
0.06303027272224426,
0.45644062757492065,
0.15374226868152618,
0.13828282058238983,
-0.01946886070072651,
-0.26112625002861023,
0.00437656557187438,
-0.4244837760925293,
-0.2585274279117584,
0.6614980101585388,
0.3289905786514282,
0.6586678624153137,
0.35822436213493347,
0.9418153166770935,
0.5088563561439514,
0.18429884314537048,
-0.5968262553215027,
0.03867713361978531,
-0.17937912046909332,
-0.5725208520889282,
-0.17189769446849823,
-0.32860976457595825,
-0.8201951384544373,
-0.2448129653930664,
-0.27349114418029785,
-0.7305103540420532,
1.207722783088684,
-0.05888481065630913,
-0.4367086887359619,
0.4517947733402252,
-0.34893056750297546,
0.7116631865501404,
-0.08918687701225281,
-0.011101598851382732,
0.28393101692199707,
-0.03374447301030159,
0.5570615530014038,
-0.40327826142311096,
0.43965408205986023,
0.20076118409633636,
0.1798696666955948,
0.6349465250968933,
-0.8780210614204407,
0.6669715046882629,
-0.48120981454849243,
-0.18491952121257782,
0.5906347036361694,
0.06453920155763626,
0.15338371694087982,
0.022459624335169792,
0.005795144475996494,
0.6111524105072021,
-0.16821765899658203,
-0.3659929633140564,
-0.45356613397598267,
0.8728745579719543,
-0.9264445900917053,
-0.10021264851093292,
-0.46644681692123413,
-0.5061842799186707,
-0.35882171988487244,
-0.15419022738933563,
0.41163498163223267,
0.7957201600074768,
-0.2556011974811554,
0.7099676132202148,
0.3984709084033966,
-0.12642702460289001,
0.714813768863678,
-0.09385284781455994,
0.09965728223323822,
-0.24546021223068237,
0.850045382976532,
0.9786514639854431,
0.21802851557731628,
0.13086217641830444,
-0.0042278822511434555,
-0.287005215883255,
-0.6342486143112183,
-0.2708546817302704,
0.1590631902217865,
-0.18387959897518158,
-0.04128381237387657,
-0.40632638335227966,
-0.09942159056663513,
-0.22333522140979767,
-0.33378201723098755,
-0.010798274539411068,
-0.06649219989776611,
-0.19458405673503876,
-0.5028278231620789,
0.2583064138889313,
0.6041347980499268,
-0.21081393957138062,
0.5548839569091797,
-0.36369308829307556,
0.5470466613769531,
-0.01648440770804882,
0.2713361978530884,
0.545132577419281,
0.25201818346977234,
-0.5151126384735107,
0.3753175139427185,
-0.23817206919193268,
-0.6464818120002747,
0.4594463109970093,
-0.060552097856998444,
0.4171349108219147,
0.7924869656562805,
0.3744899332523346,
0.6868239045143127,
-0.12224116176366806,
0.7632713913917542,
-0.3766188323497772,
-0.727195680141449,
0.37084582448005676,
-0.29348570108413696,
-0.23774655163288116,
0.6449485421180725,
0.8711910247802734,
-0.11488080769777298,
0.058961961418390274,
-0.914246141910553,
-1.294954538345337,
0.497001975774765,
0.1775892823934555,
-0.3911036550998688,
0.06627234071493149,
0.18989087641239166,
-0.024327091872692108,
0.37480035424232483,
-0.17059743404388428,
-0.09973810613155365,
0.2002839893102646,
-0.17992651462554932,
-0.3039480745792389,
-0.26971161365509033,
0.1526256650686264,
0.054070353507995605,
0.8348754048347473,
0.34918102622032166,
-0.02231532335281372,
0.7153928279876709,
-0.34103015065193176,
-0.04276719689369202,
-0.04960516095161438,
0.12826889753341675,
1.2109514474868774,
-0.29491207003593445,
-0.39436593651771545,
-0.49798861145973206,
-0.4324548542499542,
0.2447739839553833,
0.04169204831123352,
-0.5949525237083435,
0.24558456242084503,
0.36499857902526855,
0.5817468762397766,
-0.528376042842865,
0.07523593306541443,
0.47570762038230896,
0.09041231870651245,
-0.7199551463127136,
-0.2738822400569916,
-0.42371469736099243,
-0.1613614410161972,
0.39828014373779297,
0.4608614146709442,
-0.6793714761734009,
-0.01567894220352173,
-0.9209963083267212,
0.21249672770500183,
0.3052271604537964,
-0.6766154170036316,
-0.17000947892665863,
0.5174118280410767,
0.41032761335372925,
-0.171519473195076,
0.6233013272285461,
0.06316934525966644,
-0.4152396619319916,
1.1434687376022339,
0.2879558801651001,
0.6145880222320557,
0.009965813718736172,
0.4742561876773834,
0.02611742727458477,
0.8613405823707581,
0.2345900535583496,
0.7515666484832764,
0.20272578299045563,
-0.506959080696106,
-0.34234148263931274,
-0.5940184593200684,
-0.35003745555877686,
0.4463047385215759,
-0.6693854928016663,
-0.05070153623819351,
-0.653014600276947,
-0.22847120463848114,
0.4048437774181366,
0.35567760467529297,
-0.8273812532424927,
0.32819533348083496,
-0.21001999080181122,
0.6843596696853638,
-1.1741083860397339,
0.4011887311935425,
0.2579539120197296,
-0.6683345437049866,
-0.3958818018436432,
-0.06243119761347771,
0.13741199672222137,
-0.2226010262966156,
0.4851166307926178,
0.026765329763293266,
0.22520624101161957,
-0.3547578454017639,
-0.19941991567611694,
-0.6956450343132019,
0.8054419159889221,
-0.3100017011165619,
-0.5517211556434631,
0.3496928811073303,
0.330512672662735,
0.16911429166793823,
-0.3664453625679016,
-0.2427726536989212,
1.0148974657058716,
0.5078561902046204,
-0.47955751419067383,
-0.3161788284778595,
-0.11779090017080307,
0.08871082216501236,
0.09110960364341736,
0.9909837245941162,
-0.8216037750244141,
0.772735059261322,
-0.01309079397469759,
0.06785144656896591,
-0.2975311577320099,
0.7326026558876038,
-0.12845006585121155,
0.7368003129959106,
0.5902130007743835,
0.25301074981689453,
0.3913514316082001,
-0.38957422971725464,
0.8737245202064514,
-0.3636564612388611,
0.23602958023548126,
0.5370987057685852,
-0.4322243332862854,
0.5004485845565796,
0.405012309551239,
-0.18733613193035126,
0.6422191262245178,
0.5777011513710022,
-0.05278460681438446,
0.44766250252723694,
0.14291642606258392,
-0.041560616344213486,
0.3729782998561859,
-0.35211342573165894,
-0.14977890253067017,
0.6651785969734192,
0.6110545992851257,
-0.476967453956604,
-0.22784404456615448,
-0.16897760331630707,
0.05098962038755417,
-0.14159397780895233,
-0.5469388365745544,
0.5737959146499634,
0.13437440991401672,
-0.09583226591348648,
-0.07119323313236237,
-0.09535373002290726,
0.5075504183769226,
-0.8030720353126526,
-0.1659332662820816,
-0.6753364205360413,
0.34288734197616577,
-0.4780554473400116,
-0.5994476675987244,
0.807365357875824,
0.13469575345516205,
-0.2867864966392517,
0.07813844084739685,
0.5057521462440491,
-0.23738843202590942,
-0.5595443248748779,
0.1856178492307663,
0.6792197227478027,
-0.03230948746204376,
-0.10760278254747391,
-0.09995195269584656,
-0.08651754260063171,
0.26014161109924316,
-0.07931983470916748,
0.4126162528991699,
0.9134592413902283,
-0.5279558897018433,
0.22420325875282288,
0.6289730072021484,
0.11794563382863998,
-0.3070596158504486,
-0.06522279232740402,
0.45094171166419983,
-0.9455394148826599,
-0.5976197719573975,
-0.741318941116333,
0.2064419686794281,
-0.3131766617298126,
-0.5760628581047058,
0.8111491799354553,
0.43850016593933105,
0.9330354928970337,
0.19969385862350464,
0.7965381145477295,
-0.49974381923675537,
0.2998155951499939,
-0.16804249584674835,
0.8617021441459656,
-0.29269880056381226,
-0.2885427176952362,
-0.5517736077308655,
-1.0771535634994507,
0.07691933959722519,
0.6387697458267212,
-0.3938843905925751,
-0.2049832046031952,
0.2889343202114105,
0.7802512645721436,
-0.26060500741004944,
0.03406804800033569,
-0.19208389520645142,
0.3792717158794403,
0.409487247467041,
0.08012204617261887,
0.5263802409172058,
-0.15623949468135834,
0.25009265542030334,
-0.9459185600280762,
-0.20518818497657776,
-0.1762658953666687,
-0.9729188680648804,
-0.5660097002983093,
-0.4246729910373688,
-0.40386202931404114,
-0.32853177189826965,
-0.27214154601097107,
0.41469621658325195,
0.31781864166259766,
-0.7585338950157166,
-0.2754669487476349,
0.407632440328598,
0.3460804522037506,
-0.3991142511367798,
-0.2801972031593323,
0.6799413561820984,
0.20801688730716705,
-0.4270181953907013,
-0.016575533896684647,
0.058991994708776474,
-0.01780424825847149,
-0.48164767026901245,
0.7204527854919434,
-0.700224757194519,
0.29192981123924255,
0.716027021408081,
0.20261052250862122,
-0.03149709850549698,
0.0699559673666954,
-0.5162637829780579,
0.3682391047477722,
-0.411053866147995,
0.8875278830528259,
-0.45325055718421936,
-0.018813930451869965,
0.41402846574783325,
0.7683058381080627,
0.29626166820526123,
0.2667054533958435,
0.6513734459877014,
-0.7275127172470093,
0.49798521399497986,
-0.17187663912773132,
0.1803387999534607,
0.11871486902236938,
-0.49084168672561646,
0.5977253317832947,
0.039206624031066895,
-0.5025851130485535,
-0.5804047584533691,
-0.2242165058851242,
-0.6089903116226196,
-0.053176332265138626,
0.8091230392456055,
-0.014219453558325768,
-0.5776028037071228,
-0.3656880557537079,
-0.2168755680322647,
-0.1044178381562233,
-0.5461616516113281,
0.5118870735168457,
0.8284123539924622,
-0.02745712548494339,
0.19472326338291168,
-0.6899080872535706,
0.38829317688941956,
-0.4384884536266327,
-0.48767581582069397,
-0.07104486227035522,
0.6127786636352539,
0.19714367389678955,
0.08338639885187149,
0.41313669085502625,
-0.09408770501613617,
-0.1540875881910324,
0.04765235632658005,
-0.1633557379245758,
0.08457562327384949,
-0.6874260306358337,
-0.12576158344745636,
0.3004583716392517,
-0.24912285804748535,
-0.4332417845726013
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10237v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10237v1
|
A comprehensive study on Frequent Pattern Mining and Clustering categories for topic detection in Persian text stream
| 2024-03-15T12:08:58 | 2024-03-15T12:08:58 |
Elnaz Zafarani-Moattar, Mohammad Reza Kangavari, Amir Masoud Rahmani
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Topic detection is a complex process and depends on language because it
somehow needs to analyze text. There have been few studies on topic detection
in Persian, and the existing algorithms are not remarkable. Therefore, we aimed
to study topic detection in Persian. The objectives of this study are: 1) to
conduct an extensive study on the best algorithms for topic detection, 2) to
identify necessary adaptations to make these algorithms suitable for the
Persian language, and 3) to evaluate their performance on Persian social
network texts. To achieve these objectives, we have formulated two research
questions: First, considering the lack of research in Persian, what
modifications should be made to existing frameworks, especially those developed
in English, to make them compatible with Persian? Second, how do these
algorithms perform, and which one is superior? There are various topic
detection methods that can be categorized into different categories. Frequent
pattern and clustering are selected for this research, and a hybrid of both is
proposed as a new category. Then, ten methods from these three categories are
selected. All of them are re-implemented from scratch, changed, and adapted
with Persian. These ten methods encompass different types of topic detection
methods and have shown good performance in English. The text of Persian social
network posts is used as the dataset. Additionally, a new multiclass evaluation
criterion, called FS, is used in this paper for the first time in the field of
topic detection. Approximately 1.4 billion tokens are processed during
experiments. The results indicate that if we are searching for keyword-topics
that are easily understandable by humans, the hybrid category is better.
However, if the aim is to cluster posts for further analysis, the frequent
pattern category is more suitable.
|
[
-0.5499219298362732,
-1.0328764915466309,
0.7343530058860779,
0.37286093831062317,
-0.8192917704582214,
0.525505542755127,
-0.41106078028678894,
-0.18968817591667175,
0.817003071308136,
0.2993100583553314,
-0.36090463399887085,
-0.6472223997116089,
-0.7369067668914795,
0.156956747174263,
-0.7438294291496277,
0.8011140823364258,
-0.0075567374005913734,
-0.2056165337562561,
0.2386033833026886,
0.0021398942917585373,
-0.6329872608184814,
-0.5737100839614868,
-0.8867905735969543,
0.18969663977622986,
0.43225160241127014,
0.7300139665603638,
0.21064093708992004,
0.37873661518096924,
0.5282783508300781,
0.3340839445590973,
-0.41526201367378235,
0.2851598858833313,
-0.4386180341243744,
0.22534018754959106,
-0.3635580837726593,
-0.25356826186180115,
-0.11991080641746521,
-0.26082950830459595,
0.9922114014625549,
0.5178231000900269,
-0.2720218598842621,
0.0018579695606604218,
0.1393168568611145,
0.8639681935310364,
-0.430012583732605,
-0.28769996762275696,
-0.5704942941665649,
-0.09097655862569809,
-0.865065336227417,
-0.37530672550201416,
-0.2846009433269501,
-0.11202867329120636,
-0.339028537273407,
-0.28127533197402954,
0.2972377836704254,
0.29882144927978516,
0.6949180960655212,
-0.1921359896659851,
-0.6141549944877625,
-0.18735092878341675,
-0.7083005905151367,
1.0080152750015259,
-0.176154226064682,
0.11735676974058151,
0.32494986057281494,
0.08887732774019241,
-0.41634830832481384,
-0.5699175596237183,
-0.4751872420310974,
0.13258422911167145,
-0.1421116292476654,
-0.07071027159690857,
-0.34143325686454773,
-0.4524013102054596,
0.00807781983166933,
0.6531080007553101,
-1.1203006505966187,
-0.3899551033973694,
-0.11251521855592728,
-0.06821054965257645,
0.6506955027580261,
0.19357211887836456,
0.6053310632705688,
-0.2034391611814499,
-0.05443987995386124,
0.18237806856632233,
-0.2884703278541565,
0.009520888328552246,
0.27436134219169617,
0.06862494349479675,
-0.021868640556931496,
0.27995094656944275,
-0.555077075958252,
0.6490467190742493,
0.1589210331439972,
0.08585076779127121,
0.12465538829565048,
-0.6019337177276611,
0.4669954478740692,
0.19479088485240936,
0.516668975353241,
0.08372334390878677,
0.13926061987876892,
-0.0019929311238229275,
0.0874687060713768,
0.14663326740264893,
0.23643971979618073,
-0.5101741552352905,
-0.03720303997397423,
0.14758579432964325,
-1.0789769887924194,
-0.34467068314552307,
0.29298731684684753,
-0.5384348034858704,
-0.31140434741973877,
-0.041348110884428024,
-0.004590329714119434,
-0.3708559572696686,
-0.6599776744842529,
0.24338605999946594,
-0.20030945539474487,
0.13938936591148376,
0.2849026620388031,
-0.6977503895759583,
0.6566718816757202,
1.0048185586929321,
1.157576560974121,
-0.6971745491027832,
-0.12262336909770966,
-0.27249079942703247,
-0.05760525166988373,
-0.5502132177352905,
1.3258181810379028,
-0.5395516157150269,
-0.3742941617965698,
-0.34110355377197266,
0.220563605427742,
-0.1918996274471283,
-0.10690097510814667,
0.7026025056838989,
-0.44237470626831055,
0.11201854050159454,
-0.06318630278110504,
-0.5373950004577637,
-0.28373491764068604,
0.06518957763910294,
-0.5167349576950073,
0.9110122323036194,
-0.4220185875892639,
-0.9547000527381897,
0.26383939385414124,
-0.6759852766990662,
-0.531059741973877,
0.180561825633049,
0.017203286290168762,
-0.32020843029022217,
0.041861966252326965,
-0.11081630736589432,
0.5366466641426086,
-0.3591102063655853,
0.6854734420776367,
0.10827270150184631,
-0.6930431723594666,
0.45138081908226013,
-0.1878342479467392,
0.2771713435649872,
0.5554686188697815,
-0.3457011878490448,
0.49986016750335693,
-0.5978028774261475,
-0.03276119753718376,
0.08903396874666214,
0.21671542525291443,
-0.7786821126937866,
0.6902551651000977,
0.30998286604881287,
-0.011489758267998695,
0.16577692329883575,
-0.4707941710948944,
-0.23351988196372986,
-0.35543596744537354,
0.2830992043018341,
0.71014004945755,
0.6727032661437988,
0.3254100978374481,
-0.36887112259864807,
0.33401331305503845,
-0.09594741463661194,
-0.09067893028259277,
-0.22281666100025177,
-0.6695860028266907,
-0.6023944020271301,
-0.20276066660881042,
0.19075044989585876,
0.39665672183036804,
-0.48023340106010437,
0.5835773348808289,
0.05836477875709534,
-0.7801284790039062,
0.45694345235824585,
-0.1304483860731125,
0.14694873988628387,
-0.23892724514007568,
0.10169228166341782,
-0.6394903659820557,
-0.3806201219558716,
-0.5724981427192688,
-0.5558951497077942,
0.004452546127140522,
0.49013420939445496,
0.04189266264438629,
0.37838783860206604,
0.12219620496034622,
0.598860502243042,
-0.7305778861045837,
-0.16274894773960114,
-0.5739203095436096,
0.24928155541419983,
0.4754171371459961,
0.5405306220054626,
0.5726082921028137,
-1.1319942474365234,
-1.0451418161392212,
0.11616946756839752,
-0.4121815264225006,
0.13090166449546814,
-0.10308077186346054,
-0.42515015602111816,
0.1135510802268982,
0.7217502593994141,
0.015050245448946953,
0.4845691919326782,
0.2829726040363312,
-0.8533069491386414,
0.17530129849910736,
0.3773345649242401,
0.2761414051055908,
-1.2850133180618286,
0.07983994483947754,
0.30361253023147583,
-0.23082906007766724,
-0.9443382024765015,
0.040717724710702896,
-0.23666900396347046,
-0.29149332642555237,
-0.1176653504371643,
0.6640180349349976,
-0.2293371558189392,
0.27182286977767944,
-0.6635287404060364,
-0.33520251512527466,
-0.3766668140888214,
0.21476833522319794,
0.42747196555137634,
0.7055017948150635,
0.7960794568061829,
-0.5992782115936279,
0.29918667674064636,
-0.041511695832014084,
-0.3920246362686157,
0.4086286425590515,
-0.55824875831604,
-0.015859955921769142,
-0.10755135864019394,
0.21226486563682556,
-1.1764838695526123,
-0.05138947069644928,
0.6049085259437561,
-0.45468583703041077,
0.16911496222019196,
0.01944517344236374,
-0.49650487303733826,
-0.057683076709508896,
-0.4575965702533722,
0.13634254038333893,
0.3619101643562317,
-0.07001780718564987,
0.4348156154155731,
0.3806886374950409,
-0.546690046787262,
-0.23869511485099792,
0.05963212996721268,
0.207577645778656,
-0.5194305181503296,
-0.5497421026229858,
0.37376779317855835,
0.10340328514575958,
-0.3903653919696808,
0.21739809215068817,
-0.3362566828727722,
-0.36218103766441345,
0.4074999690055847,
0.12302248179912567,
-0.18354077637195587,
-0.22875098884105682,
0.11324923485517502,
0.14580561220645905,
-0.41158661246299744,
-0.22131389379501343,
-0.1635502427816391,
0.9712382555007935,
-0.07778847217559814,
-0.3261915147304535,
-0.5331085920333862,
0.7724036574363708,
0.1617388129234314,
-0.40571075677871704,
0.7427715063095093,
0.8707655668258667,
-0.33224743604660034,
-0.20781458914279938,
-0.5333856344223022,
-0.19146548211574554,
-0.47109031677246094,
0.3012695908546448,
-0.19375227391719818,
-0.724941611289978,
0.31275027990341187,
-0.1804887354373932,
-0.2061036378145218,
0.5981526374816895,
0.43644005060195923,
0.04778292775154114,
0.8203163743019104,
0.7532115578651428,
-0.30734655261039734,
0.6710054874420166,
0.042308662086725235,
0.3761918544769287,
-0.34594181180000305,
0.21613161265850067,
-0.7677338719367981,
-0.28117337822914124,
-0.8050987720489502,
-0.36093637347221375,
0.18834827840328217,
-0.17436788976192474,
0.1155245453119278,
0.026418769732117653,
-0.49783286452293396,
0.5033695697784424,
0.5970062017440796,
0.10052584111690521,
0.4151063561439514,
0.4947488009929657,
0.5100714564323425,
-0.06516119092702866,
-0.47919124364852905,
-0.5004397034645081,
0.9288946986198425,
0.06342729181051254,
0.4075802266597748,
0.18256747722625732,
0.9264817237854004,
0.7054833173751831,
-0.047013845294713974,
-0.5480108857154846,
0.7102336883544922,
-0.5565510392189026,
-0.4707576334476471,
-0.39460378885269165,
-0.1291731595993042,
-1.0467530488967896,
0.2645609378814697,
-0.15420161187648773,
-0.5795518159866333,
0.3017621636390686,
-0.2918533384799957,
-0.0005528436740860343,
0.34131625294685364,
-0.19882094860076904,
0.8842703104019165,
-0.08050380647182465,
-0.3511606752872467,
-0.8874759078025818,
-0.29163140058517456,
0.3919692039489746,
-0.20460480451583862,
0.3692821264266968,
-0.15504863858222961,
0.09628095477819443,
1.0165319442749023,
-0.3395392596721649,
0.5690947771072388,
0.03724495694041252,
0.19486740231513977,
0.5238362550735474,
-0.19824135303497314,
0.0900348424911499,
0.07995760440826416,
0.07532310485839844,
0.20277254283428192,
0.06250758469104767,
-0.5589497089385986,
-0.10271997004747391,
0.6110004782676697,
-0.5555025935173035,
-0.6996058821678162,
-1.0737792253494263,
0.021076837554574013,
-0.006459823809564114,
0.15852420032024384,
0.054943282157182693,
0.3054068088531494,
-0.5424582362174988,
0.28406983613967896,
0.6692677736282349,
-0.2978614270687103,
0.389248788356781,
0.5291874408721924,
-0.2610599994659424,
0.10243941098451614,
1.4637855291366577,
-0.3779353201389313,
-0.266695111989975,
0.3042829632759094,
0.15483370423316956,
0.22513628005981445,
-0.7227957248687744,
-0.28896665573120117,
0.2738802433013916,
-0.3218301832675934,
0.09324809163808823,
-0.621043860912323,
-0.3018612265586853,
-0.11628447473049164,
-0.05680403858423233,
-0.11586738377809525,
-0.26329895853996277,
-0.359632670879364,
0.28834423422813416,
0.6411193609237671,
0.5629309415817261,
-0.2155998796224594,
0.31989341974258423,
-0.8411767482757568,
0.5904476046562195,
0.018874861299991608,
0.1850748509168625,
0.04769386351108551,
-0.34701669216156006,
-0.18363822996616364,
-0.4478834569454193,
-0.30425652861595154,
-0.987726092338562,
0.349292129278183,
0.30360206961631775,
0.4758099317550659,
0.665696918964386,
-0.11456013470888138,
0.46216100454330444,
-0.5020795464515686,
0.6594028472900391,
-0.10197918862104416,
-0.9432582259178162,
0.7809479236602783,
-0.4089791178703308,
-0.2543256878852844,
0.42750805616378784,
0.4905429482460022,
-1.2251496315002441,
-0.3693702220916748,
-0.491536021232605,
-0.7388327121734619,
0.9737192392349243,
0.30701181292533875,
0.22252289950847626,
-0.0970127061009407,
0.3776385486125946,
-0.03625074774026871,
0.22323726117610931,
-0.454163134098053,
-0.6389868855476379,
0.049686871469020844,
-0.024808324873447418,
-0.26879990100860596,
-0.534122884273529,
0.3144504427909851,
-0.11875058710575104,
0.5666024088859558,
0.23788951337337494,
0.23028942942619324,
-0.09066803753376007,
0.04438287019729614,
-0.23878127336502075,
0.359152227640152,
0.41247692704200745,
0.6360516548156738,
-0.09047312289476395,
-0.12205413728952408,
-0.24441787600517273,
-0.7901410460472107,
0.1379518210887909,
0.09288384765386581,
-0.1647249162197113,
0.45025116205215454,
0.20042848587036133,
0.36690670251846313,
0.035729143768548965,
-0.5220593810081482,
0.3818192481994629,
-0.2577822804450989,
-0.008431881666183472,
-0.5223107933998108,
0.34047478437423706,
-0.09513449668884277,
-0.07274791598320007,
0.619429349899292,
-0.027846215292811394,
0.4806811511516571,
-0.8624442219734192,
0.21029818058013916,
0.4259955883026123,
-0.23158274590969086,
-0.11316626518964767,
0.0015375163638964295,
0.1532236635684967,
-0.042153336107730865,
0.03020291216671467,
-0.7254646420478821,
-0.8437120318412781,
0.8156254291534424,
0.33787035942077637,
0.6618367433547974,
-0.34018346667289734,
0.5005574822425842,
0.464447021484375,
0.015526295639574528,
-0.36825695633888245,
0.7698543071746826,
-0.1082385927438736,
-0.7036657929420471,
-0.5067030191421509,
-0.5807121992111206,
-0.31706979870796204,
-0.16935566067695618,
-0.6013909578323364,
0.3372964859008789,
-0.31499695777893066,
0.10597109794616699,
0.05958586558699608,
0.4096601605415344,
0.14738304913043976,
-0.058763206005096436,
0.02964317612349987,
0.6356847286224365,
-0.888319194316864,
0.6267667412757874,
1.112945795059204,
0.08229050040245056,
-0.5537482500076294,
0.12570905685424805,
0.19680173695087433,
-0.39106428623199463,
0.46101170778274536,
-0.17291681468486786,
0.012627711519598961,
0.16447529196739197,
-0.4217316210269928,
-1.1792106628417969,
0.7858361601829529,
-0.9511758685112,
-0.44544145464897156,
0.36288005113601685,
-0.1880454123020172,
0.3034679591655731,
-0.0003572934365365654,
-0.09859266132116318,
0.26147279143333435,
0.4716103672981262,
-0.016036806628108025,
-0.6518843173980713,
0.04760054126381874,
-0.5163704752922058,
-0.11616762727499008,
0.6486192941665649,
-0.7723999619483948,
1.049879789352417,
0.5547928214073181,
-0.3313261568546295,
0.4678896963596344,
0.5167325139045715,
0.2661026120185852,
0.8398721814155579,
0.5123369693756104,
0.22855019569396973,
0.474998414516449,
-0.11326895654201508,
0.7756296396255493,
-0.5135253071784973,
0.15821631252765656,
0.49183934926986694,
-0.25123533606529236,
0.581678569316864,
0.20596230030059814,
-0.2543509602546692,
0.7440272569656372,
0.807595431804657,
-0.07672127336263657,
0.8036912083625793,
0.3059402108192444,
-0.2536405324935913,
-0.494293749332428,
-0.4065450131893158,
-0.5572183132171631,
0.39804306626319885,
0.7155424952507019,
-0.1480102390050888,
-0.13941821455955505,
-0.04064277186989784,
-0.003410767763853073,
0.346622109413147,
-0.5866533517837524,
0.8409364223480225,
0.046587876975536346,
-0.47960665822029114,
0.09823078662157059,
0.7238522171974182,
0.7334942817687988,
-0.6541633605957031,
-0.0742102712392807,
-0.2859041094779968,
-0.009991126134991646,
-0.1372857540845871,
-0.4399675726890564,
0.4674317538738251,
0.18412065505981445,
-0.10591576993465424,
-0.0981932133436203,
1.3479424715042114,
0.06277283281087875,
-0.5746400356292725,
-0.11516817659139633,
0.8811631202697754,
0.4216332733631134,
-0.4872289001941681,
-0.5343955755233765,
0.0990845337510109,
0.09119705855846405,
-0.06293005496263504,
0.33821964263916016,
0.5228257775306702,
-0.5121975541114807,
0.1322631686925888,
0.8550044894218445,
0.24693942070007324,
-0.32827481627464294,
-0.100837342441082,
0.8614943623542786,
-0.9364097118377686,
-0.8918540477752686,
-0.8297868371009827,
0.06612908840179443,
-0.3212532699108124,
-0.22267316281795502,
0.96671462059021,
0.5569325089454651,
0.3992287814617157,
0.28717851638793945,
0.5846309065818787,
-0.15402907133102417,
0.989395260810852,
-0.5162678956985474,
0.6967357993125916,
-0.7260503172874451,
0.14545246958732605,
-0.5017597079277039,
-0.9909802675247192,
-0.15682561695575714,
0.9118751287460327,
-0.26034724712371826,
-0.24517379701137543,
1.005929946899414,
0.43389707803726196,
-0.21376119554042816,
0.3759084939956665,
-0.026129107922315598,
-0.03999973088502884,
-0.04356979578733444,
0.3057797849178314,
1.2926543951034546,
-0.04045560583472252,
0.20312851667404175,
-0.3586549460887909,
-0.23369073867797852,
-0.31567561626434326,
-0.44038379192352295,
-1.036136507987976,
-0.6940363049507141,
-0.3071320354938507,
-0.03381870687007904,
0.3322242498397827,
0.7215039134025574,
0.47045958042144775,
-0.9914226531982422,
-0.449249804019928,
-0.16841284930706024,
0.5317413806915283,
-0.2817690968513489,
-0.22948993742465973,
0.5527916550636292,
-0.3065301477909088,
-0.44728609919548035,
0.16320683062076569,
0.28119128942489624,
-0.3323173522949219,
0.015138725750148296,
0.2396577000617981,
-0.4909351170063019,
-0.27192601561546326,
0.49314457178115845,
0.27840656042099,
-0.3127339780330658,
0.15690939128398895,
0.3618409335613251,
-0.016540130600333214,
-0.10855188965797424,
1.2185477018356323,
-0.40125715732574463,
-0.11794926971197128,
0.4350416660308838,
0.17847703397274017,
0.591598391532898,
0.21270494163036346,
0.18282358348369598,
-0.43027275800704956,
0.3065030872821808,
0.03699568659067154,
0.3260420560836792,
-0.089269258081913,
-0.33868908882141113,
0.5684766173362732,
0.4921095669269562,
-0.3489953577518463,
-0.7492120862007141,
0.19957032799720764,
-0.7744180560112,
-0.736535906791687,
1.1987134218215942,
0.17770028114318848,
-0.034414976835250854,
-0.7253922820091248,
-0.44254839420318604,
-0.025335462763905525,
-0.5432021617889404,
0.6225599646568298,
0.8667310476303101,
-0.15089690685272217,
0.035107336938381195,
-0.39800000190734863,
0.31104573607444763,
0.5562613010406494,
-0.6204217672348022,
-0.446323037147522,
0.4186878800392151,
0.10433278232812881,
0.23217757046222687,
0.7839616537094116,
0.2618483901023865,
0.49390527606010437,
-0.4403323531150818,
-0.279630571603775,
0.5138278007507324,
-0.33669188618659973,
-0.40020471811294556,
0.040301233530044556,
0.22872832417488098,
0.010692696087062359
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10228v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10228v1
|
HawkEye: Training Video-Text LLMs for Grounding Text in Videos
| 2024-03-15T11:58:18 | 2024-03-15T11:58:18 |
Yueqian Wang, Xiaojun Meng, Jianxin Liang, Yuxuan Wang, Qun Liu, Dongyan Zhao
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Video-text Large Language Models (video-text LLMs) have shown remarkable
performance in answering questions and holding conversations on simple videos.
However, they perform almost the same as random on grounding text queries in
long and complicated videos, having little ability to understand and reason
about temporal information, which is the most fundamental difference between
videos and images. In this paper, we propose HawkEye, one of the first
video-text LLMs that can perform temporal video grounding in a fully
text-to-text manner. To collect training data that is applicable for temporal
video grounding, we construct InternVid-G, a large-scale video-text corpus with
segment-level captions and negative spans, with which we introduce two new
time-aware training objectives to video-text LLMs. We also propose a
coarse-grained method of representing segments in videos, which is more robust
and easier for LLMs to learn and follow than other alternatives. Extensive
experiments show that HawkEye is better at temporal video grounding and
comparable on other video-text tasks with existing video-text LLMs, which
verifies its superior video-text multi-modal understanding abilities.
|
[
-0.21716037392616272,
-0.8465604186058044,
0.7940227389335632,
0.459808886051178,
-0.6737517714500427,
0.24985620379447937,
-0.07561977207660675,
-0.23846837878227234,
0.217184379696846,
0.19173051416873932,
-0.5539385080337524,
-0.6293348073959351,
-1.1346601247787476,
0.053255464881658554,
-0.7753661870956421,
0.9548786282539368,
-0.1722274124622345,
0.117667056620121,
-0.18925528228282928,
-0.4239974021911621,
-0.3053835332393646,
-0.5183964371681213,
-0.6919152140617371,
-0.48535871505737305,
0.2004522830247879,
0.27150750160217285,
0.5638899207115173,
0.7154996395111084,
0.5180830955505371,
0.17396923899650574,
-0.0739300400018692,
0.20340977609157562,
-0.36715641617774963,
0.04280320554971695,
-0.1725326031446457,
-0.24278441071510315,
-0.2583395838737488,
-0.018348678946495056,
0.822967529296875,
0.15905015170574188,
0.45219284296035767,
0.2541845440864563,
-0.29514989256858826,
0.5698732137680054,
-0.8612565398216248,
-0.02012343518435955,
-0.6815676093101501,
0.5272008180618286,
0.08164647221565247,
-0.7264797687530518,
-0.31468814611434937,
0.13754884898662567,
-0.08221928030252457,
-0.5750056505203247,
0.288521409034729,
0.1910957545042038,
1.097741723060608,
0.7486866116523743,
-0.47392457723617554,
0.019752878695726395,
-0.6232944130897522,
0.5569573640823364,
-0.27487483620643616,
0.258192241191864,
0.47125405073165894,
0.31297412514686584,
0.18664765357971191,
-0.6480833888053894,
-0.5933668613433838,
-0.3161211311817169,
0.24230779707431793,
0.30528825521469116,
0.2032126933336258,
0.24217289686203003,
0.33023226261138916,
0.6024633646011353,
-0.32977956533432007,
0.20023909211158752,
-0.03254977986216545,
0.12267082929611206,
0.2784824073314667,
0.19980807602405548,
0.4018607437610626,
-0.279053270816803,
-0.4149378538131714,
0.0563109889626503,
-0.34257519245147705,
0.08294063806533813,
-0.01832132786512375,
-0.3990565538406372,
-0.43914860486984253,
0.9880558848381042,
-0.2069818079471588,
0.45724037289619446,
0.29504215717315674,
-0.44087404012680054,
-0.0239067655056715,
0.17163336277008057,
-0.5065463781356812,
0.08777859807014465,
0.6718593239784241,
0.7294514179229736,
0.3122287392616272,
-0.3988044559955597,
0.06299008429050446,
0.23296846449375153,
0.2941381633281708,
-0.8535705804824829,
0.06809259951114655,
0.1835382878780365,
-0.4320548176765442,
-0.36118730902671814,
0.06777399778366089,
-0.3740895092487335,
-0.4039376974105835,
-0.36919596791267395,
0.6462311744689941,
-0.32481005787849426,
0.27879422903060913,
-0.04441511631011963,
-0.48576074838638306,
0.6583387851715088,
0.39226409792900085,
-0.9246106743812561,
0.3419319987297058,
0.4082908630371094,
1.0754318237304688,
-0.2557617127895355,
-0.4160761833190918,
-1.0455434322357178,
0.5046282410621643,
-0.386670857667923,
0.6288568377494812,
-0.5890299081802368,
-0.11525248736143112,
0.011138051748275757,
0.2876327931880951,
0.28944382071495056,
-0.2269376963376999,
0.22317585349082947,
-0.4904330372810364,
0.03309480473399162,
0.25108078122138977,
-0.3750324845314026,
0.03322196006774902,
0.6550484895706177,
-0.3987267017364502,
0.9968875646591187,
-0.27532002329826355,
-0.7428786754608154,
0.4042217433452606,
-0.2407619059085846,
-0.4747650623321533,
-0.19955289363861084,
-0.5596674084663391,
-0.455626517534256,
0.13958556950092316,
0.6619775295257568,
0.6314800381660461,
-0.3511067032814026,
0.4889321029186249,
0.0077018532902002335,
-0.5074553489685059,
0.1813259869813919,
-0.6764248013496399,
0.07250931113958359,
-0.13021531701087952,
-0.5558878183364868,
-0.17975598573684692,
-0.7874114513397217,
-0.07711321115493774,
0.09207557886838913,
-0.12368401139974594,
-0.11076116561889648,
0.16980181634426117,
-0.062156762927770615,
0.00465385802090168,
0.012251438573002815,
-0.32604116201400757,
-0.014656776562333107,
-0.2574807405471802,
0.4354264438152313,
0.7855871915817261,
-0.0779649168252945,
0.6406280994415283,
-0.2893696129322052,
0.4296177625656128,
-0.23634688556194305,
0.17846079170703888,
-0.5209905505180359,
-0.41774967312812805,
-0.8902838230133057,
-0.10648320615291595,
-0.5089242458343506,
0.7013530135154724,
-0.5703436732292175,
-0.028761647641658783,
-0.1950429379940033,
-0.17990775406360626,
-0.0983721911907196,
0.0656963586807251,
0.5078493356704712,
0.5856621265411377,
0.5763659477233887,
-0.15983256697654724,
-0.46031227707862854,
-0.6823145151138306,
-0.0024443520233035088,
-0.2545495331287384,
-0.11201689392328262,
0.6115243434906006,
0.6189337372779846,
-0.34393182396888733,
0.943257749080658,
-0.611147403717041,
-0.2695596516132355,
0.031553663313388824,
0.2163916677236557,
0.08992817252874374,
0.05824055150151253,
0.4271062910556793,
-0.9922415614128113,
-0.4368303716182709,
-0.059915125370025635,
-1.149842381477356,
0.024547290056943893,
-0.23337194323539734,
0.26398414373397827,
-0.0222453773021698,
0.7935234904289246,
-0.5479791164398193,
0.48514482378959656,
0.7013156414031982,
-0.08305341005325317,
0.5636816024780273,
-0.33445751667022705,
0.4419846832752228,
-1.1810708045959473,
-0.09773154556751251,
-0.0917479619383812,
-0.40718382596969604,
-0.38052815198898315,
-0.12083274871110916,
-0.24969692528247833,
-0.5396969318389893,
-0.76781165599823,
0.82349693775177,
-0.31717827916145325,
-0.3220539093017578,
-0.4106045067310333,
0.16825124621391296,
0.006782056763768196,
0.40759631991386414,
0.2870873808860779,
1.1034215688705444,
0.6741229891777039,
-0.8462696075439453,
0.4181181788444519,
0.4836598038673401,
-0.16357576847076416,
0.5904020667076111,
-0.7884493470191956,
0.1767769455909729,
-0.6895413398742676,
0.2336893528699875,
-0.8127157092094421,
-0.5187308192253113,
0.045378781855106354,
-0.7052070498466492,
0.12492717057466507,
-0.5701624155044556,
-0.13396811485290527,
-0.008487365208566189,
-0.25678181648254395,
0.4673978090286255,
0.5145152807235718,
-0.8120424151420593,
0.5515552759170532,
0.471882700920105,
-0.0067169442772865295,
-0.883298933506012,
-0.6660735011100769,
0.5441457629203796,
-0.505652129650116,
-0.6430288553237915,
0.9320554137229919,
0.12174142897129059,
-0.23309427499771118,
-0.19753509759902954,
-0.47247594594955444,
-0.4019731283187866,
-0.11596311628818512,
0.5107756853103638,
0.02858656644821167,
0.1664632111787796,
0.2813786566257477,
-0.15937697887420654,
-0.4106272757053375,
-0.006468408741056919,
-0.34388840198516846,
0.36154142022132874,
-0.16970044374465942,
-0.0541025847196579,
-0.25055596232414246,
0.46672433614730835,
0.5857263803482056,
0.1162458211183548,
0.5856695175170898,
0.7969037890434265,
-0.47545748949050903,
-0.0173675287514925,
-0.5908036231994629,
-0.17033055424690247,
-0.45966166257858276,
0.31680139899253845,
-0.12482782453298569,
-1.0183900594711304,
0.03384435176849365,
-0.1769947111606598,
-0.00861671008169651,
0.18780024349689484,
0.244780033826828,
-0.6449558734893799,
0.8853928446769714,
0.9397051334381104,
-0.21305589377880096,
0.7329710721969604,
-0.48948749899864197,
-0.280132919549942,
-0.6585658192634583,
-0.28257471323013306,
-0.2773345708847046,
-0.18909865617752075,
-0.15391387045383453,
-0.5461050868034363,
0.42592698335647583,
0.16195037961006165,
-0.5463302731513977,
-0.027363386005163193,
-0.17016969621181488,
0.810191810131073,
0.1024523451924324,
0.11610917747020721,
0.19382233917713165,
0.3411804437637329,
0.2265985757112503,
-0.3072075843811035,
-0.3250367045402527,
-0.5801076292991638,
0.8108300566673279,
0.3895847201347351,
1.221014142036438,
-0.10060331225395203,
0.3592360019683838,
0.5367520451545715,
-0.2529306709766388,
-0.7700042128562927,
0.6597411632537842,
-0.7515602111816406,
-0.1923137754201889,
-0.1305074542760849,
-0.10328970849514008,
-0.4115016460418701,
-0.17695552110671997,
-0.3296703100204468,
-0.7102836966514587,
-0.5322754383087158,
0.28629156947135925,
0.1110118180513382,
0.31874188780784607,
-0.273867130279541,
0.6374414563179016,
-0.44688013195991516,
-0.463070809841156,
-0.2526249289512634,
-0.886714518070221,
0.01648997701704502,
0.42505356669425964,
0.09335844963788986,
-0.11992063373327255,
-0.17643381655216217,
0.6802661418914795,
-0.3583000898361206,
0.8531258702278137,
-0.01965530961751938,
0.14694122970104218,
0.2605644464492798,
-0.18001912534236908,
0.5364992618560791,
0.8096306920051575,
0.633781373500824,
0.04425027221441269,
-0.6206924319267273,
-0.17856767773628235,
-0.6126455664634705,
0.3892430067062378,
-1.0160341262817383,
-0.6711382269859314,
-0.6049367189407349,
-0.22434064745903015,
-0.09015101194381714,
0.0037685465067625046,
0.4715288579463959,
0.6104686260223389,
-0.09819252043962479,
0.45887261629104614,
1.05614173412323,
-0.2281920611858368,
0.6139659285545349,
0.31850260496139526,
-0.14410825073719025,
-0.7573926448822021,
0.7102805376052856,
-0.42644041776657104,
0.10520824790000916,
1.0181020498275757,
-0.002621093764901161,
-0.20604954659938812,
-0.4860592782497406,
-0.44501733779907227,
0.14518272876739502,
-0.762213945388794,
-0.02501278929412365,
-0.8681519031524658,
-0.46956753730773926,
-0.006233425810933113,
-0.6897027492523193,
-0.4104436933994293,
-0.3011035621166229,
-0.522764265537262,
-0.30418992042541504,
0.5487248301506042,
0.14977923035621643,
0.27513232827186584,
0.6571930050849915,
-0.8009644150733948,
1.044433832168579,
0.6993529796600342,
0.18066895008087158,
-0.6870957612991333,
-0.8020029067993164,
-0.11512920260429382,
-0.4157285988330841,
-0.3147001564502716,
-0.701443612575531,
0.15072903037071228,
0.595737636089325,
0.20608414709568024,
0.20694032311439514,
-0.381475567817688,
0.9317982792854309,
-0.7923761606216431,
1.0277619361877441,
0.3485492765903473,
-0.9226354360580444,
0.7342337965965271,
-0.2984657287597656,
0.43414658308029175,
0.3695890009403229,
0.3390577733516693,
-0.6759600639343262,
-0.4415438175201416,
-0.30885687470436096,
-0.9560536742210388,
0.502470076084137,
0.45041048526763916,
0.35815200209617615,
-0.009637103416025639,
0.5723084211349487,
-0.05488952249288559,
0.1749984472990036,
-1.0178078413009644,
-0.21333156526088715,
-0.4138697385787964,
0.13161036372184753,
-0.30298662185668945,
-0.2584916651248932,
-0.1600646823644638,
-0.018536429852247238,
0.4306357204914093,
-0.5540412664413452,
0.419353723526001,
0.4003680944442749,
-0.6254739761352539,
0.21497637033462524,
0.39108404517173767,
0.4682798981666565,
0.3339741826057434,
-0.38254863023757935,
0.3206116259098053,
0.5288740396499634,
-0.8000974655151367,
0.8141791224479675,
-0.28490254282951355,
-0.2615595757961273,
0.16665205359458923,
0.45499828457832336,
0.9916922450065613,
0.3732658922672272,
-0.7058074474334717,
0.5460211634635925,
-0.022704223170876503,
-0.18720948696136475,
-0.7053499817848206,
-0.06335907429456711,
-0.49198389053344727,
0.24007850885391235,
0.5705853700637817,
-0.1701725870370865,
-0.10285122692584991,
-0.5139452815055847,
0.22101914882659912,
0.2599644660949707,
-0.4272145926952362,
-0.14998219907283783,
0.9849228858947754,
0.17460843920707703,
-0.33021435141563416,
0.4493319094181061,
0.014051182195544243,
-0.32753434777259827,
0.816781222820282,
0.7434927821159363,
1.0882515907287598,
0.2929419279098511,
0.5108708143234253,
0.32704320549964905,
0.27887895703315735,
-0.3166482746601105,
0.17636892199516296,
-0.0269344262778759,
-0.41746819019317627,
-0.7163618206977844,
-0.4589554965496063,
-0.6347328424453735,
0.3207302689552307,
-0.4780289828777313,
0.48053407669067383,
-0.7320748567581177,
-0.32081568241119385,
-0.22482767701148987,
-0.22176817059516907,
-0.44694197177886963,
0.7423357367515564,
0.31570932269096375,
0.8866186141967773,
-0.804004430770874,
0.4867236614227295,
1.041538953781128,
-0.16478174924850464,
-0.2336195707321167,
0.1007310077548027,
-0.14336799085140228,
-0.7680794596672058,
0.9173109531402588,
0.6780129671096802,
-0.36865708231925964,
0.011509999632835388,
-0.6250602602958679,
-0.6370074152946472,
1.3460099697113037,
0.4052756428718567,
-0.42959773540496826,
-0.32637083530426025,
0.16306723654270172,
0.2772185206413269,
-0.4142211079597473,
0.26143085956573486,
0.1740015149116516,
0.05393281206488609,
0.09982241690158844,
-0.510845422744751,
-0.5964469909667969,
-0.18716874718666077,
0.023665696382522583,
0.24856488406658173,
-0.7431010603904724,
0.7138403058052063,
-0.14471320807933807,
-0.2828340530395508,
-0.09328895807266235,
0.7788884043693542,
0.20552147924900055,
0.7160117626190186,
0.3243565857410431,
0.7900691032409668,
0.3386259078979492,
-0.07701602578163147,
0.8464292883872986,
-0.15507571399211884,
0.13475301861763,
1.2765100002288818,
0.09338615834712982,
0.5320878028869629,
0.6504418253898621,
0.11279838532209396,
0.29426103830337524,
0.24627861380577087,
0.07614259421825409,
0.5088118314743042,
-0.20127497613430023,
-0.3625331223011017,
-0.4027232527732849,
-0.167643204331398,
-0.22805891931056976,
0.4322609603404999,
0.12451312690973282,
-0.2642943263053894,
-0.2272620052099228,
0.2985904812812805,
-0.09981722384691238,
0.2187906801700592,
-0.6339613199234009,
0.8021993637084961,
0.27778342366218567,
-0.3686307966709137,
0.3650244474411011,
0.057381484657526016,
0.6262068152427673,
-0.7866175174713135,
-0.022348547354340553,
-0.2621994912624359,
0.11047607660293579,
-0.17584551870822906,
-0.9504841566085815,
0.20320715010166168,
0.6520709991455078,
-0.5051019191741943,
-0.17197875678539276,
0.6997439861297607,
-0.2257373332977295,
-0.12143908441066742,
0.28815117478370667,
-0.10527172684669495,
0.1984834223985672,
-0.06469999253749847,
-0.48489248752593994,
0.10803528130054474,
-0.4564046263694763,
0.20326751470565796,
0.2624538838863373,
0.09104744344949722,
-0.1411789357662201,
0.8783532381057739,
0.2541307508945465,
-0.18690156936645508,
0.00519714318215847,
0.2501223087310791,
0.7106973528862,
-0.9247583150863647,
-0.49688106775283813,
-0.9969411492347717,
0.6041894555091858,
-0.1016465350985527,
-0.3894408941268921,
0.7065638303756714,
0.44184058904647827,
0.5592827796936035,
-0.24151679873466492,
0.7946720719337463,
-0.11692054569721222,
-0.24089878797531128,
-1.232155203819275,
0.21047836542129517,
-0.5453885793685913,
-0.10996972024440765,
-0.26949208974838257,
-1.141066074371338,
-0.22557704150676727,
0.5705499649047852,
0.022674523293972015,
-0.27011510729789734,
0.8958625793457031,
0.48108601570129395,
0.032190173864364624,
-0.2665195167064667,
0.2050493359565735,
0.0937698557972908,
0.6383491158485413,
0.70947265625,
0.9926509261131287,
-0.7708458304405212,
0.8168251514434814,
0.01337355189025402,
-0.2956137955188751,
-0.23697903752326965,
-1.2237725257873535,
-1.3864202499389648,
-0.4033811092376709,
-0.17795483767986298,
-0.026900600641965866,
0.46448373794555664,
0.7507210969924927,
0.7947819232940674,
-0.3308786451816559,
-0.06920601427555084,
-0.2570149302482605,
-0.1571909636259079,
0.0648481696844101,
-0.12546467781066895,
0.2386959046125412,
-0.3001273274421692,
-0.6731966733932495,
0.7561488151550293,
0.7497358918190002,
0.3132864832878113,
0.007792235352098942,
-0.2875326871871948,
-0.03858756273984909,
-0.10567130893468857,
0.7611329555511475,
0.4894138276576996,
-0.4893062114715576,
-0.5558239221572876,
0.1995517462491989,
-0.02792052924633026,
0.20778398215770721,
1.0085647106170654,
-0.8053870797157288,
0.4047926366329193,
0.2788453996181488,
0.8205925822257996,
1.0603212118148804,
0.21060900390148163,
0.45834773778915405,
-1.0510306358337402,
0.6413633227348328,
0.17201927304267883,
0.2095308005809784,
0.29125866293907166,
-0.18702754378318787,
0.5703209638595581,
0.20586290955543518,
-0.6603156328201294,
-0.5178931951522827,
0.2217703014612198,
-1.1189099550247192,
0.024134350940585136,
1.3630098104476929,
0.09292220324277878,
-0.049593813717365265,
0.055290013551712036,
-0.44533708691596985,
0.0858684778213501,
-0.12342561036348343,
0.9402831792831421,
0.6612420082092285,
0.3323535621166229,
-0.3747155964374542,
-0.5620545744895935,
0.3230206370353699,
0.4122210144996643,
-0.9297206997871399,
-0.3138611316680908,
0.3088487982749939,
0.2204880565404892,
-0.0662141665816307,
0.8302829265594482,
-0.015916917473077774,
0.5569102168083191,
-0.05159445106983185,
-0.44816160202026367,
-0.1829427033662796,
-1.0490365028381348,
-0.2873305380344391,
0.1845867782831192,
-0.07399282604455948,
-0.29038530588150024
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10214v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10214v1
|
Enhanced Coherence-Aware Network with Hierarchical Disentanglement for Aspect-Category Sentiment Analysis
| 2024-03-15T11:32:44 | 2024-03-15T11:32:44 |
Jin Cui, Fumiyo Fukumoto, Xinfeng Wang, Yoshimi Suzuki, Jiyi Li, Noriko Tomuro, Wanzeng Kong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Aspect-category-based sentiment analysis (ACSA), which aims to identify
aspect categories and predict their sentiments has been intensively studied due
to its wide range of NLP applications. Most approaches mainly utilize
intrasentential features. However, a review often includes multiple different
aspect categories, and some of them do not explicitly appear in the review.
Even in a sentence, there is more than one aspect category with its sentiments,
and they are entangled intra-sentence, which makes the model fail to
discriminately preserve all sentiment characteristics. In this paper, we
propose an enhanced coherence-aware network with hierarchical disentanglement
(ECAN) for ACSA tasks. Specifically, we explore coherence modeling to capture
the contexts across the whole review and to help the implicit aspect and
sentiment identification. To address the issue of multiple aspect categories
and sentiment entanglement, we propose a hierarchical disentanglement module to
extract distinct categories and sentiment features. Extensive experimental and
visualization results show that our ECAN effectively decouples multiple
categories and sentiments entangled in the coherence representations and
achieves state-of-the-art (SOTA) performance. Our codes and data are available
online: \url{https://github.com/cuijin-23/ECAN}.
|
[
-0.7587606310844421,
-0.9555009007453918,
0.233731210231781,
0.4350897967815399,
-0.5241572856903076,
0.2563583254814148,
0.10028712451457977,
-0.6062139868736267,
0.7451891303062439,
0.032917607575654984,
-0.6687679886817932,
-0.41329634189605713,
-0.6468806862831116,
0.17377543449401855,
-0.3995159864425659,
1.0881943702697754,
-0.07925163954496384,
-0.06401301175355911,
-0.3097801208496094,
-0.2761848568916321,
-0.009485946036875248,
-0.6777614951133728,
-0.773327648639679,
-0.4186406135559082,
0.3137997090816498,
0.23161587119102478,
0.4537801444530487,
0.017496246844530106,
0.8604357838630676,
0.26442185044288635,
-0.5763698220252991,
0.3517861068248749,
0.03496968373656273,
0.16854746639728546,
-0.12312478572130203,
-0.2853957414627075,
-1.1722685098648071,
-0.3575194776058197,
0.4781184792518616,
0.6689378619194031,
-0.209609717130661,
0.14197073876857758,
0.6202052235603333,
0.9835511445999146,
-0.606938898563385,
0.3040773868560791,
-0.3884129524230957,
0.38759511709213257,
0.05214442312717438,
-0.10701343417167664,
0.0844494104385376,
-0.03791189193725586,
0.30881738662719727,
-0.6246435642242432,
0.0067101228050887585,
0.2535366714000702,
1.1496232748031616,
0.19848626852035522,
-0.32712021470069885,
-0.24935053288936615,
-0.5157982707023621,
0.5501971244812012,
-0.49575722217559814,
0.30101537704467773,
0.4010397791862488,
0.11295673996210098,
0.17956626415252686,
-0.40344682335853577,
-0.7433630228042603,
-0.01952427066862583,
-0.05763568729162216,
0.7987329363822937,
-0.28677818179130554,
0.29957497119903564,
-0.19283072650432587,
0.925973117351532,
-0.29103660583496094,
0.02777223289012909,
0.3505423367023468,
-0.1301671713590622,
0.46268823742866516,
0.3275805413722992,
0.17636598646640778,
-0.5018165707588196,
-0.3835793137550354,
-0.07540101557970047,
-0.4476398527622223,
0.18173956871032715,
0.44762367010116577,
0.07655049860477448,
-0.3470590114593506,
0.40680602192878723,
-0.4938662648200989,
0.19973677396774292,
0.6911624670028687,
0.1484249234199524,
0.41532132029533386,
-0.38154447078704834,
-0.37045276165008545,
0.3065605163574219,
0.88886559009552,
0.07309090346097946,
-0.597391664981842,
0.08112812787294388,
-0.12431827932596207,
0.06823089718818665,
0.03462604060769081,
-0.6286091208457947,
-0.2423407882452011,
0.604336142539978,
-0.6612328886985779,
-0.2891254425048828,
-0.006170603912323713,
-1.0115165710449219,
-0.31443583965301514,
-0.2090989351272583,
0.4651966392993927,
-0.08182917535305023,
-0.760975182056427,
0.18536320328712463,
-0.0822734534740448,
-0.1267794519662857,
0.2939987778663635,
-0.8318597078323364,
0.45640745759010315,
0.8734990358352661,
0.9537268280982971,
-0.12043100595474243,
-0.19093234837055206,
-0.07236548513174057,
-0.22847284376621246,
-0.24227173626422882,
0.6062225699424744,
-0.4757794141769409,
0.06756386160850525,
-0.32409608364105225,
0.12424876540899277,
0.15228153765201569,
-0.4852290749549866,
0.18727952241897583,
-0.7988966703414917,
-0.17307864129543304,
-0.06364433467388153,
-0.4438943564891815,
-0.42792659997940063,
0.9467451572418213,
-1.0037294626235962,
0.6257134675979614,
-0.27547940611839294,
-0.8560749292373657,
0.22280222177505493,
-0.6936721801757812,
-0.3007638454437256,
-0.20689629018306732,
-0.1633928120136261,
-0.9618880152702332,
0.13271261751651764,
0.35848885774612427,
0.44341495633125305,
-0.07941395044326782,
0.4008415937423706,
-0.5447154641151428,
-0.04004427790641785,
0.11966945976018906,
-0.5982909798622131,
0.7022565603256226,
0.08676206320524216,
-0.4835989773273468,
-0.01632627099752426,
-0.683232307434082,
-0.3007252514362335,
-0.1776381880044937,
-0.28438737988471985,
-0.5447114109992981,
-0.06069663166999817,
-0.04807185381650925,
0.11545126885175705,
0.4935513138771057,
-0.7608276009559631,
-0.20252545177936554,
-0.49290305376052856,
0.17702175676822662,
0.5441727638244629,
0.36128464341163635,
0.5369401574134827,
0.06385429203510284,
0.36127588152885437,
0.9194126725196838,
0.333372563123703,
0.12518663704395294,
-0.27237334847450256,
-0.9738813042640686,
-0.2821333408355713,
0.002011507749557495,
0.30176183581352234,
-0.774701714515686,
1.021929383277893,
-0.11276540905237198,
-0.13548900187015533,
-0.6335365772247314,
-0.06365296244621277,
0.2948881983757019,
0.26928186416625977,
0.46417081356048584,
-0.6769962906837463,
-0.5627519488334656,
-0.7890341877937317,
-0.10033107548952103,
-0.2575748860836029,
0.2759125232696533,
0.08195699751377106,
0.5828115344047546,
-0.17809158563613892,
0.7879694104194641,
-0.2809284031391144,
-0.6691768169403076,
-0.1848573088645935,
0.11167573183774948,
-0.02461428940296173,
0.46800684928894043,
-0.053986262530088425,
-0.9061540961265564,
-0.27433761954307556,
0.24484948813915253,
-0.8000113368034363,
0.33556994795799255,
-0.21913966536521912,
-0.39331957697868347,
0.05450065806508064,
0.22018778324127197,
-0.2237558662891388,
0.3133818507194519,
0.7793116569519043,
-0.3026813566684723,
0.16424719989299774,
0.03261667117476463,
0.21460950374603271,
-1.6118624210357666,
-0.06580133736133575,
0.3033790588378906,
-0.22307774424552917,
-0.347720742225647,
0.12744927406311035,
-0.04749161750078201,
0.12096790224313736,
-0.18144720792770386,
-0.25798657536506653,
-0.5110253095626831,
0.16314630210399628,
-0.2729553282260895,
0.0008693408453837037,
0.5265412330627441,
0.8105134963989258,
0.2563815414905548,
0.07243460416793823,
0.7040289044380188,
-0.3579801023006439,
0.31902626156806946,
0.26254427433013916,
-0.17726418375968933,
0.6865522861480713,
-0.5396369695663452,
0.11451208591461182,
-0.2557424306869507,
0.31240314245224,
-0.822498083114624,
-0.09029372781515121,
0.2929253876209259,
-0.22902648150920868,
0.26815882325172424,
0.12591931223869324,
-0.3530450761318207,
0.03170984238386154,
-0.3437593877315521,
0.30818235874176025,
0.09063544124364853,
-0.781295120716095,
0.61527419090271,
0.6502386927604675,
0.02503718063235283,
-0.5895087122917175,
-0.8567192554473877,
0.22359463572502136,
-0.2229638546705246,
-0.22987501323223114,
0.4902212917804718,
0.09404230117797852,
-0.05644969642162323,
0.2958351969718933,
-0.1440115123987198,
-0.21702323853969574,
0.054462775588035583,
0.2791674733161926,
0.2302360087633133,
-0.12606799602508545,
0.029548319056630135,
0.794010579586029,
0.025446264073252678,
0.09455573558807373,
0.059764329344034195,
0.5211583971977234,
-0.6720675826072693,
-0.46927177906036377,
-0.8293083906173706,
0.6753891706466675,
0.5282790064811707,
-0.367832213640213,
0.8237722516059875,
0.5099842548370361,
-0.5049889087677002,
-0.12727048993110657,
-0.10497520864009857,
0.02660856395959854,
-0.45573076605796814,
0.8921505808830261,
-0.43180713057518005,
-1.1820087432861328,
0.5856007933616638,
-0.15720950067043304,
-0.1864248514175415,
0.440801739692688,
0.36101508140563965,
-0.31541723012924194,
1.20462167263031,
0.6601591110229492,
-0.26806995272636414,
0.5664383172988892,
-0.6112371683120728,
0.46306294202804565,
-1.427757740020752,
-0.4445127546787262,
-0.18139226734638214,
-0.3379614055156708,
-0.5404258966445923,
-0.008724783547222614,
0.6082348823547363,
0.5046217441558838,
-0.3259459137916565,
0.043889179825782776,
-0.6260042786598206,
0.10824146121740341,
0.005128977820277214,
0.5361301898956299,
0.6686872243881226,
0.18506208062171936,
0.10315023362636566,
0.200197234749794,
-0.6065496206283569,
-0.31322181224823,
0.46846523880958557,
0.6243695616722107,
0.613779604434967,
0.25594499707221985,
0.8069491386413574,
-0.027620986104011536,
0.041805922985076904,
-0.9415766596794128,
0.6233460307121277,
-0.37410473823547363,
-0.483785480260849,
-0.20351020991802216,
-0.4826159179210663,
-0.7478962540626526,
0.26065146923065186,
-0.265095978975296,
-0.33443397283554077,
0.7544090151786804,
0.09500827640295029,
-0.3450726866722107,
0.34016042947769165,
-0.16313423216342926,
0.399792343378067,
0.0812247022986412,
-0.1801130771636963,
-0.41148990392684937,
-0.38482826948165894,
0.26731303334236145,
0.07822496443986893,
-0.21948018670082092,
0.05083131417632103,
-0.0623089000582695,
0.7127508521080017,
-0.5324716567993164,
1.0238107442855835,
0.021072175353765488,
0.10803196579217911,
0.45360687375068665,
-0.028691530227661133,
0.26902565360069275,
0.3485244810581207,
0.11556968092918396,
0.6186554431915283,
-0.0834355428814888,
-0.0047706058248877525,
-0.5313814282417297,
0.696433424949646,
-0.8497089147567749,
-0.42300108075141907,
-0.2954500615596771,
-0.17894238233566284,
-0.2429092675447464,
-0.013160635717213154,
0.33294180035591125,
0.6716147065162659,
-0.1650107055902481,
0.2149326503276825,
0.5611673593521118,
0.050760120153427124,
0.7937453389167786,
0.1824677735567093,
-0.011064678430557251,
-0.5301998257637024,
0.9022687673568726,
0.118507981300354,
0.16609631478786469,
0.5329285264015198,
0.23647890985012054,
-0.21545003354549408,
-0.4031951427459717,
-0.5486125349998474,
-0.2722739577293396,
-0.4829445779323578,
-0.36804065108299255,
-0.7437928318977356,
-0.43295472860336304,
-0.08090199530124664,
0.22870022058486938,
-0.5602411031723022,
-0.24516937136650085,
-0.24149863421916962,
-0.13789081573486328,
0.5734535455703735,
0.5901788473129272,
-0.025229500606656075,
0.040157660841941833,
-0.7916781306266785,
0.3972133994102478,
0.3134364187717438,
0.46998274326324463,
0.6429505944252014,
-0.1654617190361023,
-0.4273797869682312,
0.04157460480928421,
-0.4054524302482605,
-0.7251195311546326,
0.267627090215683,
0.34025898575782776,
0.3234718441963196,
0.3845779299736023,
0.1341474950313568,
0.9061206579208374,
-0.23061496019363403,
0.7892459630966187,
0.5472967028617859,
-1.1152065992355347,
0.5138378739356995,
-0.03351588547229767,
0.3294150233268738,
0.6544480323791504,
0.2979627549648285,
-0.3949658274650574,
-0.7892168164253235,
-0.30345070362091064,
-0.9736853837966919,
0.5343223214149475,
0.13082364201545715,
0.13005271553993225,
-0.1766217201948166,
0.20974014699459076,
0.1777317225933075,
0.2371262162923813,
-0.5841060280799866,
-0.3244192600250244,
-0.4316104054450989,
-0.5695887207984924,
0.4318670928478241,
-0.06229497119784355,
-0.10126831382513046,
-0.270168662071228,
0.5710591673851013,
-0.12232654541730881,
0.2615388333797455,
0.7274823188781738,
-0.007897032424807549,
-0.11916109174489975,
0.3607819378376007,
-0.1865442395210266,
0.14378085732460022,
0.009018465876579285,
0.22949285805225372,
0.07366225868463516,
-0.932796835899353,
0.20782892405986786,
-0.015543882735073566,
-0.012026183307170868,
-0.1906067579984665,
0.30007925629615784,
0.8491800427436829,
-0.2658711373806,
0.05050856992602348,
0.5733044147491455,
-0.18590427935123444,
-0.014325233176350594,
-0.21854819357395172,
-0.2096261978149414,
0.12741321325302124,
0.44615110754966736,
0.18920819461345673,
0.47606390714645386,
0.5070545673370361,
-0.673326849937439,
0.1381063312292099,
0.3880859613418579,
-0.6906204223632812,
-0.5040054321289062,
0.381997674703598,
0.3703930377960205,
-0.005401293747127056,
0.3131764233112335,
-0.37957102060317993,
-0.5719504356384277,
0.70622318983078,
0.42687833309173584,
1.2623035907745361,
-0.014540338888764381,
0.2802392244338989,
0.3924453854560852,
0.21050722897052765,
-0.013333351351320744,
0.1964806318283081,
-0.2843356132507324,
-0.808729350566864,
-0.3178185820579529,
-0.813398003578186,
-0.5296478271484375,
-0.1168135404586792,
-1.184859275817871,
-0.3275601863861084,
-0.5073398351669312,
-0.1784130185842514,
-0.349752813577652,
0.16657336056232452,
-0.40472859144210815,
0.46224245429039,
0.1519438922405243,
0.42075735330581665,
-0.9217923283576965,
0.5697851181030273,
0.7978702187538147,
-0.4484826326370239,
-0.8669262528419495,
0.4217696785926819,
-0.17120668292045593,
-0.1660270094871521,
0.15642298758029938,
0.08572790026664734,
-0.46434369683265686,
-0.23215802013874054,
-0.1689319759607315,
-0.6552554368972778,
1.282947063446045,
-0.016314493492245674,
-0.9008587002754211,
0.3242526352405548,
0.16878773272037506,
0.8249035477638245,
-0.5834051370620728,
0.12005581706762314,
0.4087137281894684,
-0.03955287113785744,
-0.059072356671094894,
-0.7545348405838013,
0.1451081782579422,
-0.3524533808231354,
0.00009584915096638724,
0.0810587927699089,
-0.997420608997345,
0.809476912021637,
0.33806705474853516,
-0.21549734473228455,
-0.2052099108695984,
0.9998114705085754,
0.3651375472545624,
0.5895153880119324,
0.771969735622406,
0.6362801790237427,
0.6767309308052063,
0.08563141524791718,
0.6381046772003174,
-0.17277736961841583,
0.5193312168121338,
1.0754969120025635,
-0.08562114089727402,
1.2414698600769043,
0.5029535889625549,
0.0723024532198906,
0.8829068541526794,
0.7610228657722473,
0.5136297345161438,
0.7533302903175354,
-0.33912378549575806,
-0.527259886264801,
-0.2408449351787567,
-0.16874779760837555,
-0.311009019613266,
0.4742467701435089,
0.3800024390220642,
-0.3189755380153656,
-0.0304612684994936,
0.17086021602153778,
-0.045591726899147034,
-0.17193949222564697,
-0.8437341451644897,
1.0444190502166748,
0.4019828736782074,
-0.5004920363426208,
0.05863985791802406,
-0.18285588920116425,
0.9002978205680847,
-0.32487109303474426,
-0.11599189788103104,
-0.2001248002052307,
0.27606046199798584,
-0.6340728402137756,
-0.9530296921730042,
0.6459763646125793,
-0.052692387253046036,
-0.22003871202468872,
0.04155915603041649,
0.6082285046577454,
-0.614682137966156,
-0.5682249665260315,
0.4700155556201935,
0.3804450035095215,
-0.23973825573921204,
-0.09403479844331741,
-0.7882587313652039,
-0.044548243284225464,
-0.35804057121276855,
-0.5070549845695496,
0.4637417793273926,
0.420767605304718,
0.0343039333820343,
0.17130638659000397,
0.30905359983444214,
0.020930185914039612,
-0.29424092173576355,
0.29500457644462585,
0.9290845394134521,
-0.44240790605545044,
-0.9287895560264587,
-0.9979686737060547,
0.5051615834236145,
-0.3526427447795868,
-0.3923783004283905,
0.811672031879425,
0.3247677683830261,
0.70542311668396,
0.2592824101448059,
0.43284159898757935,
-0.035158202052116394,
0.02306227944791317,
-0.45557817816734314,
1.0248186588287354,
-0.8356373906135559,
0.2848793566226959,
-0.3594127893447876,
-0.8811509013175964,
-0.2967272400856018,
0.5038102269172668,
0.049678198993206024,
-0.12657947838306427,
0.9180365800857544,
0.809369683265686,
-0.08678480982780457,
0.3307136297225952,
0.11767323315143585,
0.139255553483963,
0.2046559602022171,
0.5457500219345093,
0.8449493050575256,
-0.6074146628379822,
0.2920644283294678,
-0.4174521863460541,
-0.46233683824539185,
0.03819216415286064,
-0.7913408279418945,
-0.8430153131484985,
-0.6810967326164246,
-0.6248892545700073,
-0.3977229595184326,
-0.10450108349323273,
0.7311320900917053,
0.6832959055900574,
-0.8219954967498779,
0.014639507979154587,
-0.5691179633140564,
0.051057182252407074,
-0.5189829468727112,
-0.21575726568698883,
0.6602376699447632,
-0.03076983615756035,
-0.660831868648529,
0.06963895261287689,
0.7492261528968811,
-0.245750293135643,
-0.4581218659877777,
0.00206558033823967,
0.010484980419278145,
0.18102720379829407,
0.668030321598053,
-0.23840254545211792,
-0.5023985505104065,
-0.3136863112449646,
-0.1248028501868248,
-0.07750872522592545,
0.21985381841659546,
0.35121816396713257,
-0.37091195583343506,
0.6840853691101074,
0.5769090056419373,
0.5362958312034607,
0.33101019263267517,
-0.06398703902959824,
0.16359096765518188,
-0.6713784337043762,
0.04748373106122017,
0.2727701961994171,
0.45183858275413513,
0.2654998302459717,
-0.6458941698074341,
-0.0711221992969513,
0.06524819880723953,
-0.405643492937088,
-0.48480358719825745,
0.251952201128006,
-1.2271584272384644,
-0.03309868648648262,
0.8336782455444336,
-0.33602070808410645,
-0.6546200513839722,
-0.24502235651016235,
-0.01817992329597473,
0.28766733407974243,
-0.3128979802131653,
0.8814270496368408,
0.49056538939476013,
-0.29499053955078125,
-0.16920921206474304,
0.15927137434482574,
0.3784821927547455,
0.6433261036872864,
-1.0646203756332397,
-0.29878100752830505,
0.2599479556083679,
-0.07263574004173279,
0.335904061794281,
0.5869868397712708,
-0.3461710512638092,
0.261027455329895,
0.2673380374908447,
0.025847766548395157,
-0.18594831228256226,
-0.5165907144546509,
-0.8101656436920166,
0.45378926396369934,
-0.08679655939340591,
-0.6104281544685364
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10205v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10205v1
|
Read between the lines -- Functionality Extraction From READMEs
| 2024-03-15T11:11:57 | 2024-03-15T11:11:57 |
Prince Kumar, Srikanth Tamilselvam, Dinesh Garg
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
While text summarization is a well-known NLP task, in this paper, we
introduce a novel and useful variant of it called functionality extraction from
Git README files. Though this task is a text2text generation at an abstract
level, it involves its own peculiarities and challenges making existing
text2text generation systems not very useful. The motivation behind this task
stems from a recent surge in research and development activities around the use
of large language models for code-related tasks, such as code refactoring, code
summarization, etc. We also release a human-annotated dataset called FuncRead,
and develop a battery of models for the task. Our exhaustive experimentation
shows that small size fine-tuned models beat any baseline models that can be
designed using popular black-box or white-box large language models (LLMs) such
as ChatGPT and Bard. Our best fine-tuned 7 Billion CodeLlama model exhibit 70%
and 20% gain on the F1 score against ChatGPT and Bard respectively.
|
[
-0.26990440487861633,
-0.599345862865448,
0.40742984414100647,
-0.21288183331489563,
-0.38296428322792053,
0.1456611156463623,
-0.3366028964519501,
-0.6921054720878601,
0.2276383638381958,
0.9421366453170776,
-0.46217870712280273,
-0.4648146629333496,
-0.5487592816352844,
-0.028610743582248688,
-0.6118759512901306,
1.3255773782730103,
0.051950328052043915,
-0.23621657490730286,
0.012945389375090599,
0.17501823604106903,
-0.3694710433483124,
-0.1887863129377365,
-0.18627221882343292,
-0.19355428218841553,
0.38063424825668335,
0.7089314460754395,
0.5918344259262085,
0.26785096526145935,
0.6916919350624084,
0.23225486278533936,
-0.27631184458732605,
0.17516319453716278,
-0.39826199412345886,
0.20889753103256226,
0.005343646742403507,
-0.5729161500930786,
-0.5310243964195251,
-0.05613865703344345,
0.32130518555641174,
0.5968126058578491,
0.1113165020942688,
0.26059606671333313,
0.22703653573989868,
0.8391953706741333,
-0.2658449411392212,
0.2884865999221802,
-0.4664001762866974,
-0.07858718931674957,
-0.022458313032984734,
-0.12364272028207779,
-0.3056384325027466,
-0.4721546471118927,
0.44279366731643677,
-0.4649840295314789,
0.03836779296398163,
-0.23731394112110138,
0.9153382182121277,
0.1833040416240692,
-0.1618073433637619,
-0.7333132028579712,
-0.5145748257637024,
0.5428220629692078,
-1.0188026428222656,
-0.07994141429662704,
0.24786201119422913,
0.16808009147644043,
-0.18192274868488312,
-0.8873708844184875,
-0.23447749018669128,
-0.31764474511146545,
-0.18700364232063293,
-0.044179730117321014,
-0.07467880100011826,
-0.04801708459854126,
0.38776639103889465,
0.5145934224128723,
-0.5445256233215332,
-0.15250414609909058,
-0.7181190848350525,
0.04061133414506912,
0.7022422552108765,
-0.17394353449344635,
0.559246301651001,
-0.4295545816421509,
-0.27898505330085754,
0.2907918393611908,
-0.743420422077179,
0.18974080681800842,
0.22172050178050995,
0.06764955073595047,
-0.2558773159980774,
0.8417711853981018,
-0.17890846729278564,
0.4864330589771271,
-0.45434775948524475,
-0.03054819628596306,
0.10089335590600967,
-0.445331871509552,
-0.15458384156227112,
-0.3990998864173889,
0.654045820236206,
0.31309592723846436,
0.760473906993866,
-0.34782716631889343,
-0.41600915789604187,
-0.19133010506629944,
0.6277345418930054,
-0.9849237203598022,
-0.5505595803260803,
0.21370373666286469,
-0.6781091690063477,
-0.4956843852996826,
0.30056267976760864,
-0.7651420831680298,
-0.3396964967250824,
-0.44492968916893005,
0.13026441633701324,
-0.6191317439079285,
-0.3926597237586975,
0.014913578517735004,
-0.3234870731830597,
0.29165932536125183,
0.23841330409049988,
-0.9720468521118164,
0.018877197057008743,
0.9610562324523926,
1.1720887422561646,
-0.0860072672367096,
0.14135318994522095,
-0.42681801319122314,
-0.3331453204154968,
-0.21467867493629456,
0.8778414130210876,
-0.2754634618759155,
-0.38959288597106934,
-0.10347957909107208,
0.03557568043470383,
0.2703322470188141,
-0.48961544036865234,
0.17107504606246948,
-0.4239664673805237,
0.045834992080926895,
-0.13094504177570343,
-0.5637718439102173,
-0.41886818408966064,
0.13657714426517487,
-0.6608524322509766,
0.8277913928031921,
0.38450759649276733,
-0.7364500761032104,
0.2099418193101883,
-0.9304028749465942,
-0.5990386009216309,
0.17672927677631378,
-0.14829093217849731,
-0.3879460096359253,
0.4775029420852661,
-0.18536724150180817,
0.40888717770576477,
-0.16307252645492554,
0.35505211353302,
-0.42127302289009094,
-0.25609585642814636,
0.5716185569763184,
-0.007880041375756264,
0.8173466324806213,
0.41688552498817444,
-0.26574039459228516,
0.1692989319562912,
-0.5984662175178528,
0.09677178412675858,
-0.23920322954654694,
-0.313457727432251,
-0.3926754593849182,
0.28830060362815857,
0.08712020516395569,
0.33473142981529236,
0.25381991267204285,
-0.36620888113975525,
0.24883103370666504,
-0.6053953170776367,
0.6540146470069885,
0.29631876945495605,
-0.13168635964393616,
0.3825876712799072,
-0.4299706816673279,
0.9387375712394714,
-0.2811982333660126,
-0.26991593837738037,
-0.6370132565498352,
-0.6099030375480652,
-0.3270930349826813,
-0.46362271904945374,
0.44528260827064514,
0.6487957835197449,
-0.9670836925506592,
0.5785550475120544,
-0.17331548035144806,
-0.7623847126960754,
-0.22642309963703156,
0.19446878135204315,
0.36319467425346375,
0.4084705114364624,
0.11608481407165527,
-0.311939001083374,
-0.4324290156364441,
-0.7270758152008057,
-0.3104464113712311,
-0.21335484087467194,
-0.3725806474685669,
-0.03308030590415001,
0.60765141248703,
-0.2429938167333603,
1.1392349004745483,
-0.835806667804718,
-0.06560999155044556,
-0.45607736706733704,
0.11829584836959839,
0.16134317219257355,
0.4137685298919678,
0.5841759443283081,
-0.6336861252784729,
-0.12084337323904037,
0.13075821101665497,
-0.8223078846931458,
-0.4625815451145172,
0.009557667188346386,
0.0024980793241411448,
0.020650094375014305,
0.8182574510574341,
-0.41827788949012756,
0.2686755955219269,
0.72596275806427,
-0.483547180891037,
0.514662504196167,
-0.1476459801197052,
0.05667382478713989,
-1.2899565696716309,
0.30194538831710815,
0.10589884966611862,
-0.4914570152759552,
-0.4144585132598877,
0.40647390484809875,
0.2007826715707779,
-0.32758480310440063,
-0.22372011840343475,
0.44238296151161194,
-0.5391757488250732,
-0.2887970209121704,
-0.4351852834224701,
0.317226767539978,
-0.00034383111051283777,
0.32095468044281006,
-0.13780231773853302,
0.8088874220848083,
0.3125292956829071,
-0.45122188329696655,
0.25586098432540894,
0.15715977549552917,
-0.5463187098503113,
0.00472945487126708,
-0.7923698425292969,
-0.074162557721138,
0.09560109674930573,
0.06262790411710739,
-1.225034475326538,
-0.37643906474113464,
0.06927726417779922,
-0.38234421610832214,
0.15303140878677368,
-0.22519797086715698,
-0.4480801224708557,
0.005991823971271515,
-0.5819290280342102,
0.12648701667785645,
0.8331979513168335,
-0.41198548674583435,
0.4142131805419922,
0.8116092085838318,
-0.6481664776802063,
-0.13170219957828522,
-0.785622239112854,
0.05106943100690842,
-0.3447284996509552,
-0.6713829636573792,
0.05888641998171806,
0.0679812803864479,
-0.2690032124519348,
-0.21857956051826477,
-0.12754260003566742,
0.002876752056181431,
0.4481598138809204,
0.44316864013671875,
0.2747390568256378,
-0.3200252056121826,
0.2846265733242035,
0.193036749958992,
-0.14738471806049347,
0.03778388723731041,
-0.3590342402458191,
0.23854106664657593,
-0.12738007307052612,
0.02519553154706955,
-0.1700829118490219,
0.34984058141708374,
0.5160183310508728,
-0.466081827878952,
0.2159440964460373,
0.45233651995658875,
-0.2290453016757965,
-0.2213854342699051,
-0.15668943524360657,
-0.09660765528678894,
-0.44488269090652466,
0.5667418241500854,
-0.2758813798427582,
-1.115193486213684,
0.5947466492652893,
-0.3159819543361664,
0.6487656831741333,
0.37973257899284363,
0.3144350051879883,
-0.2888275384902954,
0.44381749629974365,
0.8665201663970947,
0.3002414107322693,
0.9067938923835754,
-0.14846982061862946,
0.1709090769290924,
-0.5504403114318848,
-0.0015973543049767613,
-0.8406112194061279,
-0.22235646843910217,
-0.7593289613723755,
-0.31293097138404846,
0.22461168467998505,
0.4643407166004181,
0.39997175335884094,
0.6889784336090088,
-0.4574200212955475,
0.42482802271842957,
0.2806853950023651,
-0.06760237365961075,
0.34581518173217773,
0.04667950049042702,
0.17991410195827484,
0.00836882647126913,
-0.42755600810050964,
-1.016430139541626,
1.1505409479141235,
0.4830600321292877,
0.7628494501113892,
0.33391422033309937,
0.6750779747962952,
0.43667155504226685,
0.39660733938217163,
-0.921379804611206,
0.6429076194763184,
-0.5794247984886169,
-0.3606548011302948,
-0.23361100256443024,
-0.36205241084098816,
-0.929753839969635,
0.06892867386341095,
-0.07078105211257935,
-0.8578231930732727,
-0.15633906424045563,
0.1278851181268692,
-0.38902151584625244,
0.04861292615532875,
-1.3054711818695068,
0.9124476909637451,
0.06616345047950745,
0.2180139422416687,
-0.12066967040300369,
-0.6336743831634521,
0.5785560011863708,
-0.27532583475112915,
0.3586377501487732,
-0.07122094929218292,
-0.2875564992427826,
0.7227981090545654,
-0.4714994430541992,
0.7663783431053162,
0.06868674606084824,
-0.6647219061851501,
0.48477980494499207,
0.08468534052371979,
0.278422474861145,
0.34021297097206116,
-0.07471910864114761,
0.3049432933330536,
0.2545167803764343,
-0.2485640048980713,
-0.48675015568733215,
0.4859200716018677,
-0.3311058282852173,
-0.21901585161685944,
0.04217270761728287,
-0.5042307376861572,
0.17196124792099,
0.2929926812648773,
0.2184019833803177,
0.7418845891952515,
-0.1574523001909256,
0.2728244960308075,
0.5032024383544922,
-0.23307529091835022,
0.9552732110023499,
0.30213406682014465,
-0.4917023181915283,
-0.3688526451587677,
0.7670862674713135,
0.038222748786211014,
0.4444521367549896,
0.39999285340309143,
-0.10386715829372406,
-0.07000533491373062,
-0.5235031247138977,
-0.35557296872138977,
0.0753404051065445,
-0.526652455329895,
-0.08988472819328308,
-0.6532499194145203,
-0.2597506642341614,
-0.3339116871356964,
-0.2477295994758606,
-0.21567684412002563,
-0.7842909097671509,
-0.34839245676994324,
0.04870237037539482,
0.3306836783885956,
0.9187794327735901,
0.2916751503944397,
0.5011942982673645,
-1.169816017150879,
0.6269516348838806,
-0.022420328110456467,
0.31628134846687317,
-0.45522621273994446,
-0.5253995060920715,
-0.511318027973175,
-0.08445834368467331,
-0.4339120090007782,
-1.0521628856658936,
0.40940427780151367,
-0.10718818008899689,
0.11199669539928436,
0.24399827420711517,
-0.040129177272319794,
0.24414393305778503,
-0.21601346135139465,
0.7281979918479919,
-0.0044199624098837376,
-0.8827934265136719,
0.48833876848220825,
-0.2305021584033966,
0.6076564788818359,
0.5161454677581787,
-0.20109127461910248,
-0.4858558177947998,
-0.6659838557243347,
-0.6848627328872681,
-0.7982250452041626,
0.7753581404685974,
0.2699836492538452,
0.1334758698940277,
0.12157043069601059,
0.5434970259666443,
0.25495418906211853,
0.333321750164032,
-0.673172652721405,
0.20653922855854034,
0.06706313043832779,
-0.4044508934020996,
-0.01412508636713028,
-0.3702060878276825,
0.14510369300842285,
0.19042105972766876,
0.5969992280006409,
-0.3087766766548157,
0.09242513030767441,
0.1545034945011139,
-0.3173612952232361,
0.2085038423538208,
0.4824378490447998,
0.855518639087677,
0.846649706363678,
-0.06216691806912422,
0.10258982330560684,
-0.19094257056713104,
-0.639929473400116,
-0.2787170708179474,
0.3041743040084839,
-0.3589424788951874,
0.18869468569755554,
0.677910327911377,
0.40663012862205505,
0.20590989291667938,
-0.9549330472946167,
0.32846853137016296,
-0.10470656305551529,
-0.10702492296695709,
-0.35175997018814087,
0.4702514708042145,
0.08752726763486862,
0.3742157816886902,
0.1291995644569397,
0.2547076642513275,
0.21118009090423584,
-0.41034117341041565,
0.5140228867530823,
0.3994830548763275,
-0.4905625283718109,
-0.4442884027957916,
0.4200981557369232,
0.5547642111778259,
-0.5857981443405151,
0.17890653014183044,
-0.38937240839004517,
-0.3129953145980835,
0.8701301217079163,
0.023946613073349,
1.0263603925704956,
0.17251697182655334,
0.20612676441669464,
0.28298965096473694,
0.4824700653553009,
-0.1346776783466339,
0.3630125820636749,
-0.11673571914434433,
-0.3581972122192383,
-0.5731500387191772,
-0.44708237051963806,
-0.11241123825311661,
-0.012714103795588017,
-0.4604000449180603,
0.6818520426750183,
-0.2497294545173645,
-0.07903291285037994,
0.28001663088798523,
0.020450405776500702,
-0.04043038561940193,
-0.04796318709850311,
-0.058716218918561935,
0.87192302942276,
-0.6213384866714478,
0.9334557056427002,
0.798873245716095,
-0.4736670255661011,
-0.6835348010063171,
0.12310177087783813,
-0.0834813192486763,
-0.33155733346939087,
0.07303564250469208,
0.33724701404571533,
0.09528118371963501,
-0.05341876298189163,
-0.5089632868766785,
-0.5804989337921143,
0.9825347065925598,
0.393521785736084,
-0.7516835927963257,
-0.30689460039138794,
-0.36348551511764526,
0.5627813339233398,
-0.5533728003501892,
0.41728970408439636,
0.7066524624824524,
0.14832057058811188,
-0.19589723646640778,
-0.7929293513298035,
0.017441924661397934,
-0.34629714488983154,
-0.039877261966466904,
0.34871146082878113,
-0.31211337447166443,
0.6263775825500488,
-0.43064984679222107,
-0.07311975955963135,
0.18580535054206848,
0.5610732436180115,
0.216318279504776,
0.1224387064576149,
0.47052136063575745,
-0.010341217741370201,
0.44793590903282166,
-0.07572188228368759,
1.0863665342330933,
-0.17534476518630981,
0.4538947343826294,
1.2046432495117188,
0.004784864839166403,
0.6000245213508606,
0.5252498984336853,
0.06001283973455429,
0.4496880769729614,
0.41957882046699524,
-0.019551139324903488,
0.33197054266929626,
0.19210700690746307,
0.07857567816972733,
0.073210209608078,
0.3705800473690033,
-0.3280249834060669,
0.45767924189567566,
0.33890265226364136,
-0.4342975318431854,
-0.23886814713478088,
-0.20883925259113312,
0.2960938513278961,
0.017022788524627686,
0.022697335109114647,
1.012668490409851,
0.34681472182273865,
-1.066750168800354,
0.23637211322784424,
0.14880478382110596,
0.6919480562210083,
-0.6023091673851013,
-0.16598086059093475,
-0.13824400305747986,
0.14839869737625122,
-0.29666051268577576,
-0.9157578349113464,
0.6068045496940613,
0.2834116518497467,
-0.1887400597333908,
-0.1897190660238266,
0.7583061456680298,
-0.6520970463752747,
-0.32581111788749695,
0.25960397720336914,
0.44171854853630066,
0.2630281448364258,
-0.030462928116321564,
-0.5879859328269958,
-0.22847719490528107,
0.39673081040382385,
-0.474422425031662,
0.1645614504814148,
0.6558905839920044,
0.06793341785669327,
0.4447806477546692,
0.5828237533569336,
0.17295429110527039,
-0.06667681783437729,
-0.1301424503326416,
0.7980841398239136,
-0.8541252613067627,
-0.743036687374115,
-0.8743016123771667,
0.8853632211685181,
-0.19535233080387115,
-0.4042661786079407,
0.372763454914093,
0.511693000793457,
0.5375550389289856,
-0.26455187797546387,
0.8221529126167297,
-0.3556816279888153,
0.49465182423591614,
-0.6959030628204346,
0.8164976239204407,
-0.5242782235145569,
0.6164947152137756,
-0.38463878631591797,
-0.6931687593460083,
-0.18960194289684296,
0.36118441820144653,
-0.07327445596456528,
0.005901172291487455,
0.829269289970398,
0.8114081025123596,
-0.033216338604688644,
0.2868388295173645,
0.2384399175643921,
-0.0690465196967125,
0.6146861910820007,
0.4027923345565796,
0.701208233833313,
-0.43885594606399536,
0.6689857244491577,
0.10427837073802948,
-0.43732792139053345,
-0.2642277181148529,
-0.9382508397102356,
-0.9655970931053162,
-0.551314115524292,
-0.47511738538742065,
-0.350289523601532,
-0.35032832622528076,
0.6552716493606567,
0.7079400420188904,
-0.6998634338378906,
-0.2583363652229309,
-0.1823028326034546,
0.36542820930480957,
-0.08075515180826187,
-0.2562403976917267,
-0.06067351996898651,
-0.6108708381652832,
-0.47357556223869324,
0.24744336307048798,
0.4448455274105072,
0.020217234268784523,
-0.18445689976215363,
0.10064636170864105,
-0.19818586111068726,
0.04076683893799782,
0.6210074424743652,
0.2702087163925171,
-0.5706157684326172,
-0.22154484689235687,
-0.07845400273799896,
-0.32360661029815674,
-0.08809372782707214,
1.219264268875122,
-0.48775503039360046,
0.3163098990917206,
0.7317282557487488,
0.6921199560165405,
0.28533700108528137,
0.08066387474536896,
0.7481386065483093,
-0.7842860221862793,
0.14004193246364594,
-0.1176535040140152,
0.3491448163986206,
0.0856604129076004,
-0.2763918340206146,
0.7667855024337769,
-0.03625137731432915,
-0.49709752202033997,
-0.7218031883239746,
0.296875536441803,
-1.0981295108795166,
-0.5457059144973755,
1.2466988563537598,
-0.5097092986106873,
-0.08596745133399963,
-0.2781151831150055,
-0.4100225269794464,
0.31343507766723633,
-0.36165091395378113,
0.75898677110672,
0.8071388602256775,
0.15415239334106445,
-0.14440348744392395,
-0.8319933414459229,
0.5775874853134155,
0.31439337134361267,
-1.3581513166427612,
0.21422606706619263,
0.5816614627838135,
0.3291662633419037,
0.26869234442710876,
0.6226717829704285,
-0.33044520020484924,
0.35960695147514343,
-0.25304171442985535,
0.3456273674964905,
-0.027026649564504623,
-0.21712739765644073,
-0.46812233328819275,
0.4567161202430725,
0.07652968168258667,
-0.21824268996715546
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10185v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10185v2
|
Can Factual Statements be Deceptive? The DeFaBel Corpus of Belief-based Deception
| 2024-03-15T10:46:00 | 2024-05-10T06:58:04 |
Aswathy Velutharambath, Amelie Wührl, Roman Klinger
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
If a person firmly believes in a non-factual statement, such as "The Earth is
flat", and argues in its favor, there is no inherent intention to deceive. As
the argumentation stems from genuine belief, it may be unlikely to exhibit the
linguistic properties associated with deception or lying. This interplay of
factuality, personal belief, and intent to deceive remains an understudied
area. Disentangling the influence of these variables in argumentation is
crucial to gain a better understanding of the linguistic properties attributed
to each of them. To study the relation between deception and factuality, based
on belief, we present the DeFaBel corpus, a crowd-sourced resource of
belief-based deception. To create this corpus, we devise a study in which
participants are instructed to write arguments supporting statements like
"eating watermelon seeds can cause indigestion", regardless of its factual
accuracy or their personal beliefs about the statement. In addition to the
generation task, we ask them to disclose their belief about the statement. The
collected instances are labelled as deceptive if the arguments are in
contradiction to the participants' personal beliefs. Each instance in the
corpus is thus annotated (or implicitly labelled) with personal beliefs of the
author, factuality of the statement, and the intended deceptiveness. The
DeFaBel corpus contains 1031 texts in German, out of which 643 are deceptive
and 388 are non-deceptive. It is the first publicly available corpus for
studying deception in German. In our analysis, we find that people are more
confident in the persuasiveness of their arguments when the statement is
aligned with their belief, but surprisingly less confident when they are
generating arguments in favor of facts. The DeFaBel corpus can be obtained from
https://www.ims.uni-stuttgart.de/data/defabel
|
[
-0.3097412884235382,
-1.1404448747634888,
0.7745326161384583,
0.10380508750677109,
-0.20785319805145264,
0.03266769275069237,
-0.14327523112297058,
-0.455188512802124,
0.3558504581451416,
0.35576730966567993,
-0.46494096517562866,
-0.6586527824401855,
-0.7157774567604065,
0.5107102394104004,
-0.5722723603248596,
1.050294280052185,
-0.017521420493721962,
0.007130162324756384,
-0.6072606444358826,
-0.08576679974794388,
-0.38204672932624817,
-0.5359445214271545,
-0.09364186972379684,
-0.07945294678211212,
0.45777830481529236,
0.3607389032840729,
0.7332412004470825,
0.4330252707004547,
0.2920001149177551,
0.4005889892578125,
0.1278132051229477,
0.0047092130407691,
-0.6155827045440674,
0.3523576855659485,
-0.48448675870895386,
-0.7488418221473694,
0.3798610270023346,
0.4019772410392761,
0.2567932903766632,
0.5967392921447754,
-0.1575896143913269,
0.26986321806907654,
-0.20803992450237274,
0.49097365140914917,
-0.5201022624969482,
0.1234411895275116,
-0.7086866497993469,
-0.0086757717654109,
-0.2632277011871338,
-0.05043288320302963,
-0.5690995454788208,
-0.829545259475708,
0.07834074646234512,
-0.4872056841850281,
0.5848766565322876,
0.05953924357891083,
1.1500898599624634,
0.5183568000793457,
-0.3150431215763092,
-0.6117426156997681,
-0.6623471975326538,
0.5290133357048035,
-0.6178594827651978,
0.22557996213436127,
0.50496506690979,
0.010464707389473915,
-0.12590433657169342,
-0.5678873062133789,
-0.8417338132858276,
-0.5537306666374207,
-0.4077402353286743,
0.20844539999961853,
-0.2580229341983795,
0.024243474006652832,
0.47250810265541077,
0.45595523715019226,
-0.6049543023109436,
-0.24909023940563202,
-0.1736176609992981,
-0.4340912103652954,
0.4314551055431366,
-0.2512925863265991,
0.3035113215446472,
-0.1477920114994049,
-0.6190858483314514,
-0.0870492085814476,
-0.4368549585342407,
-0.29959413409233093,
0.5677436590194702,
0.0003001255390699953,
-0.14084386825561523,
0.6314639449119568,
-0.19733119010925293,
0.5567642450332642,
0.5882862210273743,
-0.369731068611145,
0.13871613144874573,
-0.1356501579284668,
-0.3858194649219513,
0.6554487943649292,
0.45037174224853516,
0.2540929913520813,
0.2900807559490204,
-0.02706657536327839,
-0.06994232535362244,
0.837765634059906,
0.30371972918510437,
-0.7763248085975647,
-0.3297225534915924,
0.3572428524494171,
-0.36893430352211,
-0.5947839021682739,
0.4515514671802521,
-0.8699482083320618,
-0.6375567317008972,
-0.031167928129434586,
0.08294112235307693,
-0.6575459241867065,
-0.0859861671924591,
0.12209457159042358,
-0.23872010409832,
-0.13675659894943237,
0.1360178291797638,
-0.8287270665168762,
0.23178857564926147,
0.4199483096599579,
0.36377590894699097,
0.16713328659534454,
-0.11105934530496597,
-0.32392966747283936,
0.1432369202375412,
-0.644616425037384,
0.9517197012901306,
-0.6635780334472656,
-0.4423427879810333,
0.18094795942306519,
0.18706783652305603,
-0.12887364625930786,
-0.5905774235725403,
1.0501227378845215,
-0.4744745194911957,
0.49673327803611755,
-0.5206106305122375,
-0.5794560313224792,
-0.5532744526863098,
0.1459084153175354,
-0.5892515182495117,
0.8543479442596436,
-0.0447903648018837,
-0.7201371788978577,
0.4138002395629883,
-0.397850900888443,
-0.685425877571106,
-0.013257685117423534,
-0.6003825068473816,
-0.248672753572464,
0.32011789083480835,
-0.1614140272140503,
0.05241664499044418,
-0.25442269444465637,
0.4088343679904938,
-0.029236631467938423,
-0.035237982869148254,
0.9575050473213196,
-0.8729875087738037,
0.6688212156295776,
0.11245810985565186,
-0.7905077338218689,
-0.2815791666507721,
-0.51362544298172,
-0.12350428104400635,
0.22425462305545807,
-0.3463762700557709,
-0.37453508377075195,
0.019074130803346634,
-0.30097517371177673,
-0.024378962814807892,
0.35099348425865173,
-0.928552508354187,
0.14126816391944885,
-0.5873504877090454,
-0.11368326842784882,
0.5656242370605469,
0.12161698192358017,
0.008987692184746265,
-0.3997543752193451,
0.23689022660255432,
0.169778510928154,
0.01762542501091957,
-0.05294743552803993,
-0.4429749846458435,
-0.4941869378089905,
-0.11099596321582794,
0.5599021315574646,
0.47228699922561646,
-0.5438185930252075,
0.3752063810825348,
-0.24120725691318512,
-0.35654234886169434,
-0.6898000836372375,
-0.1203247532248497,
0.6332910656929016,
0.927047073841095,
0.31480178236961365,
0.2925524413585663,
-0.3653850853443146,
-1.1924887895584106,
-0.087893046438694,
-0.46540072560310364,
-0.08808434754610062,
-0.03416234254837036,
0.6572322845458984,
0.01587696373462677,
0.9927195310592651,
-0.7608795762062073,
-0.3327273428440094,
0.09657757729291916,
0.4165848195552826,
0.03421006351709366,
0.09306968748569489,
0.8298338055610657,
-1.4169172048568726,
-0.44532689452171326,
-0.016261355951428413,
-0.8864080309867859,
-0.3284531533718109,
-0.08633986860513687,
0.13722296059131622,
0.7336433529853821,
-0.08421578258275986,
-0.6499899625778198,
0.7070015072822571,
0.5874078869819641,
-0.8336368203163147,
0.6176703572273254,
-0.23020435869693756,
0.30861136317253113,
-0.5824863910675049,
-0.12473028153181076,
-0.0070367916487157345,
-0.028612250462174416,
-0.5141388177871704,
-0.19426225125789642,
-0.06293923407793045,
0.40616896748542786,
-0.40777355432510376,
0.19497138261795044,
-0.22293204069137573,
0.3102017939090729,
-0.29604682326316833,
0.07513156533241272,
0.4104943573474884,
0.2846428155899048,
0.07480394095182419,
0.5386740565299988,
0.46443477272987366,
-0.5365917086601257,
0.45358532667160034,
0.41966256499290466,
-0.3982028365135193,
0.758689820766449,
-0.32833102345466614,
-0.21017317473888397,
-0.4458496868610382,
0.2326699197292328,
-1.0865697860717773,
-0.38854047656059265,
0.5862722992897034,
-0.5843278765678406,
0.16481231153011322,
0.13856013119220734,
-0.2919576168060303,
-0.04355090484023094,
-0.04486330598592758,
-0.15221147239208221,
0.32883623242378235,
-0.5314936637878418,
0.6098206043243408,
0.009810308925807476,
0.1782464236021042,
-0.5157656073570251,
-1.0701111555099487,
0.0519256591796875,
-0.38798007369041443,
-0.5909325480461121,
0.7327013611793518,
-0.18140250444412231,
-0.7419445514678955,
0.3156694173812866,
-0.4860471189022064,
0.03470756486058235,
-0.1207030713558197,
0.480088472366333,
0.27962934970855713,
-0.02674572542309761,
0.17918461561203003,
-0.09935782104730606,
-0.11909954994916916,
0.18002988398075104,
-0.12761540710926056,
0.3448111116886139,
-0.16934865713119507,
-0.457351952791214,
-0.5456416010856628,
0.2913697063922882,
0.4300113916397095,
0.233010396361351,
0.8862488269805908,
0.2912862300872803,
-0.24165041744709015,
0.04322134703397751,
-0.7989346981048584,
-0.22424378991127014,
-0.44808873534202576,
-0.2136521339416504,
-0.4213393032550812,
-0.4155679941177368,
0.20632408559322357,
-0.15950147807598114,
-0.1292644590139389,
0.5404815673828125,
0.519300639629364,
-0.2987161874771118,
0.5480836629867554,
0.28007107973098755,
0.13088034093379974,
-0.07457464188337326,
-0.1548207402229309,
0.0791965052485466,
-0.1223195493221283,
-0.3891561031341553,
-0.4799218475818634,
-0.27746254205703735,
-0.6686956882476807,
-0.3433086574077606,
0.10714265704154968,
-0.2183309644460678,
0.03535553440451622,
-0.014692447148263454,
-0.5931810736656189,
0.38418176770210266,
0.27030760049819946,
-0.04660675302147865,
0.2901919186115265,
0.14813871681690216,
-0.29031533002853394,
-0.1037939265370369,
-0.45650139451026917,
-0.7950921058654785,
0.5199241638183594,
0.26648443937301636,
0.4740840494632721,
0.40216219425201416,
0.5677754282951355,
0.5687642693519592,
0.3418843448162079,
-0.7160587906837463,
0.537537157535553,
0.0022084468510001898,
-1.0586507320404053,
-0.1629592776298523,
-0.3698875606060028,
-0.8690729737281799,
0.12081076949834824,
-0.18961793184280396,
-0.7058376669883728,
0.33689841628074646,
0.0036264897789806128,
-0.31161782145500183,
0.14605629444122314,
-0.794365406036377,
0.6915413737297058,
-0.6397767663002014,
-0.4788607060909271,
-0.21442849934101105,
-0.661770224571228,
0.26530128717422485,
-0.1390867680311203,
0.280803918838501,
-0.22484655678272247,
0.13654689490795135,
0.7390953302383423,
-0.33351361751556396,
1.1467559337615967,
-0.3720913231372833,
-0.40214967727661133,
0.5856227278709412,
0.34596672654151917,
0.4554447531700134,
0.17641256749629974,
-0.1671716868877411,
0.29592660069465637,
0.1636231392621994,
-0.2777639329433441,
-0.77898770570755,
0.6258736848831177,
-0.5220060348510742,
-0.9966609477996826,
-0.5857483744621277,
-0.1270231008529663,
-0.1220787838101387,
0.13125838339328766,
0.2890772223472595,
0.5278155207633972,
-0.5563470721244812,
0.1649949550628662,
0.9773561358451843,
-0.2132088840007782,
0.0911664143204689,
0.5533002018928528,
-0.21005268394947052,
-0.2115037441253662,
0.8852349519729614,
0.03340078517794609,
0.31061163544654846,
0.6308809518814087,
0.5595104098320007,
-0.6141061782836914,
-0.33458393812179565,
-0.03351598232984543,
0.2912178337574005,
-0.6610330939292908,
-0.1783396601676941,
-0.19447365403175354,
0.21401560306549072,
-0.5180650949478149,
-0.10358186811208725,
-0.13883614540100098,
-0.34074485301971436,
-0.015504729002714157,
-0.50477534532547,
0.4358980655670166,
0.6129693388938904,
-0.060068279504776,
0.14074359834194183,
-0.45633694529533386,
0.6268122792243958,
0.16713964939117432,
0.09590840339660645,
-0.5601423978805542,
-0.3077623248100281,
0.06295573711395264,
0.5888053178787231,
-0.30093324184417725,
-1.1618156433105469,
0.25825127959251404,
-0.2562404274940491,
0.40373364090919495,
0.9389352202415466,
0.43625810742378235,
0.42955464124679565,
-0.16099713742733002,
0.8058446049690247,
0.3016902506351471,
-0.7866182327270508,
0.32697078585624695,
-0.09631316363811493,
-0.0903235450387001,
0.6527231931686401,
0.6241706609725952,
-0.5217975378036499,
-0.4096011519432068,
-0.9146031141281128,
-0.3062233328819275,
0.35726606845855713,
0.29650041460990906,
0.03120790421962738,
-0.13828733563423157,
0.020312432199716568,
0.5155752897262573,
0.37440869212150574,
-0.6079217791557312,
-0.653661847114563,
-0.5099505186080933,
-0.2898501753807068,
0.3822329342365265,
-0.3725567162036896,
-0.698505699634552,
-0.1305922567844391,
0.5869194865226746,
-0.21104615926742554,
0.31878548860549927,
0.518274188041687,
0.06845071166753769,
-0.0970185250043869,
0.1792861819267273,
0.696675717830658,
0.6641473174095154,
-0.10206552594900131,
0.625349223613739,
0.09734030812978745,
-0.5012430548667908,
0.1325635015964508,
0.31190818548202515,
-0.3773374557495117,
0.315327912569046,
0.35931193828582764,
0.7659605145454407,
0.2564813494682312,
-0.6305554509162903,
0.4480319321155548,
0.10962022840976715,
-0.4632289409637451,
-0.5322908163070679,
-0.10956526547670364,
0.09080567210912704,
0.03214980289340019,
0.4361361861228943,
0.05653951317071915,
-0.17634885013103485,
-0.6867888569831848,
0.008223818615078926,
0.3143564462661743,
-0.09957814961671829,
-0.42674657702445984,
0.6825655698776245,
0.042656250298023224,
0.06934854388237,
0.5769015550613403,
-0.12260004132986069,
-0.5208562016487122,
0.4568386673927307,
0.5654411315917969,
0.5659152269363403,
-0.25113603472709656,
0.8499757647514343,
0.14950570464134216,
0.2632228434085846,
0.204509437084198,
0.1147696003317833,
0.11177213490009308,
-0.935642659664154,
-0.15609872341156006,
-0.7010728120803833,
-0.0926329642534256,
0.22459819912910461,
-0.1531888246536255,
-0.026063552126288414,
-0.15291284024715424,
-0.15518522262573242,
0.022132838144898415,
-0.020419543609023094,
-0.31126707792282104,
0.32150357961654663,
0.3177001178264618,
0.8707911968231201,
-0.7039169073104858,
0.6315100193023682,
0.5712397694587708,
-0.6846610307693481,
-0.44829097390174866,
0.5116888880729675,
0.225230872631073,
-0.5910928845405579,
0.6014592051506042,
0.048945505172014236,
-0.22747400403022766,
-0.22097840905189514,
-0.6821357607841492,
-0.8555921912193298,
0.7562010884284973,
0.5189166069030762,
-0.2578474283218384,
-0.051206570118665695,
0.6853393912315369,
0.5230294466018677,
-0.3006010353565216,
0.0025786508340388536,
0.4774777293205261,
1.1401162147521973,
0.3946816623210907,
-0.41424161195755005,
0.3407139778137207,
0.39858636260032654,
-0.2708103358745575,
-0.05786541476845741,
-0.639471709728241,
0.5514622330665588,
-0.18505701422691345,
-0.7363874912261963,
-0.13179022073745728,
0.8391450047492981,
0.11583831906318665,
0.47203296422958374,
0.47783201932907104,
0.43996140360832214,
1.091869831085205,
-0.20234909653663635,
1.131709337234497,
-0.34306174516677856,
0.0755329579114914,
0.7272905111312866,
-0.3696883022785187,
0.3650512397289276,
0.501125156879425,
-0.07535611093044281,
0.962092936038971,
0.4789980947971344,
-0.21053682267665863,
0.5577006340026855,
0.10482089221477509,
-0.3958840072154999,
-0.08443943411111832,
-0.31223979592323303,
0.00793488696217537,
0.5278009176254272,
0.6659709215164185,
-0.29699060320854187,
-0.188207745552063,
-0.027476923540234566,
0.3436534106731415,
0.5289700031280518,
0.10285169631242752,
0.43692389130592346,
0.008371394127607346,
-0.7005221247673035,
0.7028768062591553,
0.04007650911808014,
0.4072986841201782,
-0.5322855710983276,
-0.1193106546998024,
-0.12773534655570984,
-0.11071830987930298,
-0.6082252264022827,
-0.7698085904121399,
0.4520380198955536,
-0.05856841057538986,
-0.1261598765850067,
-0.34687888622283936,
0.9261724352836609,
-0.2886500656604767,
-0.26365959644317627,
-0.10829508304595947,
0.43089693784713745,
0.22234351933002472,
0.029353661462664604,
-0.474185973405838,
0.06333388388156891,
0.2099584937095642,
-0.2927185595035553,
0.18014676868915558,
0.5822561979293823,
0.125992089509964,
0.36004698276519775,
0.7293545007705688,
-0.01691615767776966,
-0.2164805382490158,
-0.17123866081237793,
0.6444401741027832,
-0.5117774605751038,
-0.158227801322937,
-0.9394853115081787,
0.36223259568214417,
-0.21558503806591034,
-0.061947017908096313,
0.9709164500236511,
0.6629482507705688,
0.7050526142120361,
-0.15800318121910095,
1.016901969909668,
-0.406002402305603,
0.4733998775482178,
-0.48805710673332214,
0.4630693793296814,
-0.09395232051610947,
-0.1302582323551178,
0.13265585899353027,
-0.7078967690467834,
0.08891615271568298,
0.6485682725906372,
-0.7299763560295105,
-0.11963377147912979,
0.966931939125061,
0.5659515857696533,
0.21026112139225006,
0.37550753355026245,
0.4493691921234131,
0.6755849123001099,
0.06064706668257713,
0.0357140451669693,
0.8441798090934753,
-0.13651739060878754,
0.37756165862083435,
-0.3556317985057831,
-0.24084803462028503,
-0.17211785912513733,
-0.7082566022872925,
-0.6013076901435852,
-0.6085836291313171,
-0.6850057244300842,
-0.5011888742446899,
-0.10343105345964432,
0.47780925035476685,
0.04892315715551376,
-0.6429737210273743,
0.10972511768341064,
-0.1631597876548767,
0.29331356287002563,
-0.23752616345882416,
-0.37398195266723633,
0.31423255801200867,
0.018289577215909958,
-0.9995813369750977,
0.5356361269950867,
0.04649568349123001,
0.1896069198846817,
-0.34581565856933594,
0.19378462433815002,
-0.14513376355171204,
0.3885788917541504,
0.40692904591560364,
0.3995074927806854,
-0.7557387948036194,
-0.48791688680648804,
-0.07649705559015274,
-0.08870772272348404,
0.05034421756863594,
0.5768110156059265,
-1.0182180404663086,
0.25022026896476746,
0.23317177593708038,
0.28456997871398926,
0.2913581430912018,
0.51497483253479,
0.2874417304992676,
-0.8188888430595398,
0.08920872211456299,
0.23934254050254822,
0.21923382580280304,
0.35542258620262146,
-0.5823694467544556,
0.3350714445114136,
0.6026052236557007,
-0.3048584759235382,
-0.7076337337493896,
0.2975102663040161,
-0.884801983833313,
-0.7257379293441772,
1.3694859743118286,
0.10131628066301346,
-0.42931219935417175,
-0.18539699912071228,
-0.4050061106681824,
0.16540668904781342,
-0.49140164256095886,
1.0528820753097534,
0.9823204278945923,
-0.19453172385692596,
0.552414059638977,
-0.613777220249176,
0.6752431988716125,
0.16757598519325256,
-0.6076733469963074,
0.30401960015296936,
0.713083028793335,
0.2561121881008148,
0.7203381061553955,
0.25596073269844055,
0.028070781379938126,
-0.09025561809539795,
0.36848360300064087,
-0.16797630488872528,
0.07553889602422714,
-0.17038372159004211,
0.1001683846116066,
0.39740562438964844,
-0.17240199446678162,
-0.2747749388217926
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10144v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10144v2
|
NLP Verification: Towards a General Methodology for Certifying Robustness
| 2024-03-15T09:43:52 | 2024-05-31T13:11:15 |
Marco Casadio, Tanvi Dinkar, Ekaterina Komendantskaya, Luca Arnaboldi, Matthew L. Daggitt, Omri Isac, Guy Katz, Verena Rieser, Oliver Lemon
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.LO, cs.PL
|
Deep neural networks have exhibited substantial success in the field of
Natural Language Processing and ensuring their safety and reliability is
crucial: there are safety critical contexts where such models must be robust to
variability or attack, and give guarantees over their output. Unlike Computer
Vision, NLP lacks a unified verification methodology and, despite recent
advancements in literature, they are often light on the pragmatical issues of
NLP verification. In this paper, we attempt to distil and evaluate general
components of an NLP verification pipeline, that emerges from the progress in
the field to date. Our contributions are two-fold. Firstly, we give a general
(i.e. algorithm-independent) characterisation of verifiable subspaces that
result from embedding sentences into continuous spaces. We identify, and give
an effective method to deal with, the technical challenge of semantic
generalisability of verified subspaces; and propose it as a standard metric in
the NLP verification pipelines (alongside with the standard metrics of model
accuracy and model verifiability). Secondly, we propose a general methodology
to analyse the effect of the embedding gap -- a problem that refers to the
discrepancy between verification of geometric subspaces, and the semantic
meaning of sentences which the geometric subspaces are supposed to represent.
In extreme cases, poor choices in embedding of sentences may invalidate
verification results. We propose a number of practical NLP methods that can
help to quantify the effects of the embedding gap; and in particular we propose
the metric of falsifiability of semantic subspaces as another fundamental
metric to be reported as part of the NLP verification pipeline. We believe that
together these general principles pave the way towards a more consolidated and
effective development of this new domain.
|
[
-0.16976723074913025,
-1.0107219219207764,
0.5670561194419861,
0.10805398970842361,
-0.07382780313491821,
0.0527484267950058,
-0.315278023481369,
-0.3209257423877716,
0.0885796993970871,
0.37013205885887146,
-0.1308026909828186,
-0.7116526961326599,
-0.7393484711647034,
-0.009298257529735565,
-0.6344688534736633,
0.6844024062156677,
-0.248722642660141,
-0.2750653326511383,
-0.5499197840690613,
-0.2497224509716034,
-0.6685947775840759,
-0.755833625793457,
-0.2122335433959961,
-0.095771424472332,
0.19414231181144714,
-0.27807101607322693,
0.9154128432273865,
0.6592267155647278,
0.5872255563735962,
0.3498717248439789,
-0.3549530804157257,
0.31825852394104004,
0.011661475524306297,
0.31763267517089844,
-0.21202878654003143,
-0.43296805024147034,
-0.4383382797241211,
-0.24057553708553314,
0.7153072357177734,
0.8117876648902893,
-0.06733798235654831,
-0.07564482092857361,
0.38197553157806396,
0.3970256745815277,
-0.7018247842788696,
-0.037114132195711136,
-0.5904109477996826,
0.34374648332595825,
-0.00504289148375392,
-0.09758730977773666,
-0.2717075049877167,
-0.37693026661872864,
0.14557939767837524,
-0.2532617151737213,
0.20900219678878784,
-0.01786056160926819,
0.999987006187439,
0.45888540148735046,
-0.46477317810058594,
-0.5899601578712463,
-0.9200388193130493,
0.7782886624336243,
-0.6395388841629028,
0.5109841227531433,
0.478161484003067,
0.21518772840499878,
-0.10555685311555862,
-0.9256954789161682,
-0.39267081022262573,
-0.5293018221855164,
-0.032845575362443924,
-0.24085962772369385,
-0.18740825355052948,
0.08230546116828918,
0.26399996876716614,
0.7016476392745972,
-0.6010534763336182,
0.02883511781692505,
0.019466830417513847,
-0.5830725431442261,
0.4761793315410614,
0.07382605969905853,
0.5792635679244995,
0.08061534911394119,
-0.21784836053848267,
0.11104514449834824,
-0.6029805541038513,
0.05268412083387375,
0.4420693814754486,
0.03364607319235802,
-0.04486615210771561,
0.587756872177124,
-0.23596052825450897,
0.6163642406463623,
-0.43819746375083923,
0.0884724035859108,
0.1909431517124176,
-0.6907088756561279,
-0.1341089904308319,
-0.5023249387741089,
0.6581082344055176,
0.27747842669487,
0.17507092654705048,
-0.4498329758644104,
-0.15263646841049194,
0.5880799889564514,
0.3472580909729004,
-0.20466360449790955,
-0.13852949440479279,
0.4603067636489868,
-0.21739941835403442,
-0.2699826955795288,
-0.10143760591745377,
-0.43939051032066345,
-0.03153003007173538,
-0.41361331939697266,
0.24981997907161713,
-0.3288731873035431,
-0.24304766952991486,
0.48100391030311584,
0.11289093643426895,
0.2506785988807678,
0.22693024575710297,
-0.7709271311759949,
0.346993625164032,
1.1062703132629395,
0.7743369936943054,
0.028541995212435722,
-0.3102912902832031,
-0.339352548122406,
-0.18675899505615234,
-0.3388158679008484,
0.4739065170288086,
-0.2770189046859741,
-0.0030788807198405266,
0.477126806974411,
-0.09700043499469757,
0.0838974192738533,
-0.26625433564186096,
0.8691893219947815,
-0.2427254319190979,
0.1986875981092453,
-0.19017459452152252,
-0.6997864246368408,
-0.03790542483329773,
0.6380722522735596,
-0.40063515305519104,
0.8395026922225952,
-0.2435109168291092,
-0.7760167717933655,
0.4852624535560608,
-0.4272679090499878,
-0.18477696180343628,
-0.13935419917106628,
-0.326859712600708,
-0.3568228781223297,
0.04352908581495285,
0.20592287182807922,
0.4583040475845337,
-0.10206704586744308,
0.4386311173439026,
-0.42881280183792114,
-0.1582598090171814,
0.41129836440086365,
-0.5241260528564453,
0.9056648015975952,
-0.04378997161984444,
-0.23420292139053345,
-0.05932832509279251,
-0.8217830657958984,
0.2788674831390381,
-0.14483970403671265,
-0.2487618774175644,
-0.15627190470695496,
0.1761312335729599,
-0.09514933079481125,
-0.04222015663981438,
-0.041906580328941345,
-0.531876802444458,
0.11140093952417374,
-0.5873251557350159,
0.6165549159049988,
0.46792805194854736,
0.05698474869132042,
0.40840548276901245,
0.023533066734671593,
0.3289047181606293,
-0.22254812717437744,
0.281745582818985,
-0.0320243276655674,
-0.7056826949119568,
-0.8292415142059326,
-0.03610120713710785,
0.6790573596954346,
0.5371556282043457,
-0.44771528244018555,
0.8311712741851807,
0.05768556520342827,
-0.08770692348480225,
-0.22103948891162872,
0.2674427628517151,
0.3618738055229187,
0.33164432644844055,
0.27302631735801697,
-0.5325303673744202,
-0.5384884476661682,
-0.7241504192352295,
-0.2539271116256714,
-0.32460957765579224,
-0.3227614462375641,
0.056491680443286896,
0.656543493270874,
-0.36992135643959045,
1.0281692743301392,
-0.20833151042461395,
-0.22859780490398407,
0.08212262392044067,
-0.03129715099930763,
0.061442431062459946,
0.6650424003601074,
0.5981883406639099,
-0.6963903903961182,
-0.021770089864730835,
-0.06209256872534752,
-0.9901964068412781,
0.12935630977153778,
-0.09178881347179413,
0.012388446368277073,
-0.0423387847840786,
0.6473731994628906,
-0.5838393568992615,
0.6989518404006958,
0.5470889806747437,
-0.5413034558296204,
0.5232638120651245,
-0.24321776628494263,
-0.13995099067687988,
-0.4725290536880493,
0.11853192746639252,
-0.020535582676529884,
-0.4226197898387909,
-0.5538462996482849,
0.5825482606887817,
-0.23681724071502686,
0.015199495479464531,
-0.27805814146995544,
0.06631938368082047,
-0.21610888838768005,
0.20128928124904633,
-0.060641784220933914,
0.32523342967033386,
0.14906711876392365,
0.2809191942214966,
-0.27200454473495483,
0.23842810094356537,
0.6207590103149414,
-0.7300100326538086,
0.398373544216156,
0.17084696888923645,
-0.2501693367958069,
0.49261754751205444,
-0.9408019781112671,
0.34221750497817993,
-0.06208822503685951,
0.18143434822559357,
-1.0618524551391602,
0.03204923868179321,
0.40330687165260315,
-0.5221317410469055,
0.13252827525138855,
-0.1636129468679428,
-0.5190650224685669,
-0.24504630267620087,
0.04071631655097008,
0.2597794532775879,
0.4434489607810974,
-0.26107674837112427,
0.5955466628074646,
0.21307598054409027,
0.11761438846588135,
-0.7605307698249817,
-0.8047444820404053,
0.2942129075527191,
-0.08752623945474625,
-0.7831517457962036,
0.22673848271369934,
0.17367126047611237,
-0.4209328293800354,
0.012369568459689617,
0.012198141776025295,
-0.34903091192245483,
0.5156654119491577,
0.30181190371513367,
0.12373725324869156,
-0.2735868990421295,
0.033539146184921265,
0.02332378551363945,
-0.41561970114707947,
0.2625388205051422,
-0.36032798886299133,
0.15890319645404816,
-0.5477014780044556,
-0.7502397894859314,
-0.37589746713638306,
0.47882604598999023,
0.31383588910102844,
-0.17695528268814087,
0.3843822479248047,
0.743840754032135,
-0.5359002351760864,
-0.3305254876613617,
-0.43061158061027527,
-0.05814480036497116,
-0.41397690773010254,
0.1945779174566269,
-0.04414286091923714,
-1.2000707387924194,
0.5598243474960327,
-0.20474852621555328,
0.22271324694156647,
0.5707889199256897,
0.5157449245452881,
0.03293537348508835,
0.8532067537307739,
0.8536525368690491,
0.1219746321439743,
-0.28282395005226135,
-0.055770423263311386,
0.48794570565223694,
-0.5844724774360657,
-0.2366408109664917,
-0.9338244795799255,
-0.19727851450443268,
-0.4272342324256897,
-0.5994499325752258,
-0.017718803137540817,
0.3043181598186493,
-0.00697247963398695,
0.266022652387619,
-0.5863009691238403,
0.541532039642334,
0.26374658942222595,
-0.23136702179908752,
0.3773610293865204,
-0.22399266064167023,
-0.5929129719734192,
-0.29868605732917786,
-0.4646884799003601,
-0.8420370817184448,
0.8259222507476807,
0.7891160845756531,
0.34494853019714355,
0.2232963740825653,
0.5620957016944885,
0.4015829563140869,
-0.13151606917381287,
-0.5297645926475525,
0.4612669348716736,
-0.13222788274288177,
-0.5313307642936707,
-0.17500676214694977,
-0.1670004278421402,
-0.7332844138145447,
0.10044676810503006,
-0.2888944447040558,
-1.0639041662216187,
0.2080850601196289,
0.24930013716220856,
-0.346590518951416,
0.24417458474636078,
-0.48112115263938904,
0.7309785485267639,
-0.1744430661201477,
-0.21535839140415192,
-0.06327705085277557,
-0.6851213574409485,
0.3517647087574005,
0.2772567570209503,
-0.009758291766047478,
-0.21304816007614136,
-0.034614045172929764,
0.32969897985458374,
-0.45612242817878723,
1.0230112075805664,
-0.17148837447166443,
-0.19527782499790192,
0.1806643009185791,
0.046501852571964264,
0.29912641644477844,
0.26418593525886536,
0.30418622493743896,
0.36180442571640015,
0.04983281344175339,
-0.23923836648464203,
-0.5856831669807434,
0.40852153301239014,
-0.5412814021110535,
-0.3838147222995758,
-0.271879643201828,
-0.12667737901210785,
-0.4566119909286499,
0.0839182436466217,
0.29587969183921814,
0.34638676047325134,
-0.4326143264770508,
0.4885246455669403,
0.8740248680114746,
-0.33256277441978455,
0.28969430923461914,
-0.13824667036533356,
-0.46823835372924805,
-0.35814934968948364,
0.48516303300857544,
-0.06787378340959549,
0.0496118888258934,
0.4038732945919037,
0.039753761142492294,
-0.3582550287246704,
-0.7987240552902222,
-0.29516905546188354,
-0.15085427463054657,
-0.9353656768798828,
-0.058727819472551346,
-0.5405139923095703,
-0.2459912896156311,
-0.09511538594961166,
-0.24275417625904083,
-0.453065425157547,
-0.5327484011650085,
-0.1371210664510727,
-0.04287368804216385,
-0.03878461942076683,
0.7317763566970825,
-0.10843490809202194,
-0.10117542743682861,
-0.5586932301521301,
0.27985242009162903,
0.4500645101070404,
0.5051339268684387,
-0.1639329344034195,
-0.3514726758003235,
-0.08255353569984436,
0.022302845492959023,
-0.158983513712883,
-0.37602075934410095,
0.011975427158176899,
0.1789170503616333,
0.660700798034668,
0.2871817648410797,
-0.13980647921562195,
0.2622455358505249,
-0.46431854367256165,
1.1459380388259888,
0.2584839165210724,
-1.2270112037658691,
0.6385830044746399,
-0.28176864981651306,
-0.16365419328212738,
0.5737740397453308,
0.10736288875341415,
-0.5050830245018005,
-0.6686161160469055,
-0.6459696888923645,
-0.9977825880050659,
-0.3634633719921112,
0.39065638184547424,
0.3843820095062256,
0.044777464121580124,
0.482930988073349,
-0.024578526616096497,
0.03851430118083954,
-0.6135125160217285,
-0.21058563888072968,
-0.25607964396476746,
0.0891055166721344,
0.14233572781085968,
-0.40641728043556213,
-0.4426608681678772,
0.061131399124860764,
0.31769099831581116,
-0.16451698541641235,
0.3888828754425049,
0.3682304620742798,
-0.08040516078472137,
0.5052574276924133,
0.4107533097267151,
0.5642006993293762,
0.8393649458885193,
-0.1792767196893692,
0.21204619109630585,
0.13542428612709045,
-0.3373645842075348,
0.33522507548332214,
-0.270525723695755,
-0.3365127742290497,
0.45859476923942566,
0.5732175707817078,
0.5020558834075928,
0.1678190529346466,
-0.15836447477340698,
0.7488630414009094,
-0.32467174530029297,
-0.4006398916244507,
-0.3210168182849884,
-0.03143324330449104,
-0.17053763568401337,
0.04032033309340477,
0.14044132828712463,
0.35905274748802185,
0.13687030971050262,
-0.27571457624435425,
0.43219056725502014,
0.3271852135658264,
-0.38264113664627075,
-0.26959651708602905,
0.6602523326873779,
0.16077733039855957,
-0.3539688289165497,
0.6737186908721924,
-0.1638370305299759,
-0.37430915236473083,
0.5030475854873657,
0.2462088167667389,
1.171370267868042,
0.15053783357143402,
0.3110407590866089,
0.25649455189704895,
0.6624184250831604,
-0.13070864975452423,
0.08823215216398239,
-0.01054446306079626,
-0.8721926808357239,
-0.8478555083274841,
-0.43447890877723694,
-0.6864792704582214,
-0.2341790646314621,
-0.7625521421432495,
-0.025154750794172287,
-0.8368058800697327,
-0.36122608184814453,
-0.07448519766330719,
-0.23483075201511383,
-0.6218228340148926,
0.21085640788078308,
0.3913787007331848,
0.9055185914039612,
-0.9722951054573059,
0.532675564289093,
0.46625232696533203,
-0.18974363803863525,
-0.695021390914917,
0.08979931473731995,
0.07046577334403992,
-0.6125520467758179,
0.3349756896495819,
0.08409029990434647,
-0.1304917186498642,
-0.5422656536102295,
-0.6953021287918091,
-0.6564406156539917,
0.7799967527389526,
0.505467414855957,
-0.48508158326148987,
-0.03831452503800392,
0.2901804745197296,
0.7607617974281311,
-0.20105403661727905,
-0.15145210921764374,
0.37523752450942993,
0.26290732622146606,
-0.2101905345916748,
-0.7928569316864014,
0.1154196634888649,
-0.3465091586112976,
0.38645800948143005,
-0.14717119932174683,
-0.10414093732833862,
0.5078612565994263,
0.053639139980077744,
-0.23419727385044098,
0.2812032103538513,
0.7490361928939819,
0.09446865320205688,
0.15859554708003998,
0.4327894151210785,
0.8151575326919556,
1.0615427494049072,
-0.4514257311820984,
1.099763035774231,
-0.12241742759943008,
0.5952101945877075,
0.8449385762214661,
-0.15283988416194916,
0.90032958984375,
0.44781532883644104,
-0.36117082834243774,
0.5784514546394348,
0.061418257653713226,
-0.08165737241506577,
0.2837221920490265,
0.3919488787651062,
-0.07361117750406265,
-0.2033592015504837,
-0.2182098925113678,
-0.5605420470237732,
0.4906434118747711,
0.3833625018596649,
-0.3932579755783081,
-0.11387557536363602,
-0.13277848064899445,
0.017056429758667946,
0.19618412852287292,
-0.06447606533765793,
0.4670896530151367,
0.14269830286502838,
-0.5255551338195801,
0.41358473896980286,
0.11966106295585632,
0.7027028203010559,
-0.7102615237236023,
0.020046263933181763,
-0.009873906150460243,
0.38629576563835144,
-0.26400119066238403,
-0.776415228843689,
0.7990284562110901,
-0.025796405971050262,
0.04257221892476082,
-0.2969599962234497,
0.8660194277763367,
-0.10393442958593369,
-0.2634074091911316,
0.11800454556941986,
0.4253738522529602,
-0.08618024736642838,
0.13772818446159363,
-0.7459334135055542,
0.36821022629737854,
0.01872023567557335,
0.09822794049978256,
0.23897163569927216,
0.42450782656669617,
0.415838360786438,
0.5602673292160034,
0.653797447681427,
0.07627365738153458,
0.023331893607974052,
0.15738478302955627,
0.5989787578582764,
-0.4092230200767517,
-0.5174030661582947,
-0.8267956376075745,
0.8374200463294983,
-0.018052829429507256,
-0.5629799962043762,
0.8369288444519043,
0.09294229000806808,
0.7831880450248718,
0.16408957540988922,
0.7432737350463867,
-0.11380036175251007,
0.28182101249694824,
-0.7940616607666016,
0.4144134521484375,
-0.1251804232597351,
0.4323938488960266,
-0.33987972140312195,
-0.8580669164657593,
-0.9314917325973511,
0.8713197112083435,
-0.0610576830804348,
-0.11303136497735977,
0.7514488101005554,
0.5916128158569336,
0.07253149896860123,
0.10788847506046295,
0.2783924341201782,
-0.08396095037460327,
0.27242517471313477,
0.48026612401008606,
1.120323657989502,
-0.5857424736022949,
0.3731842041015625,
-0.37426385283470154,
-0.030866973102092743,
0.07735338062047958,
-1.2535896301269531,
-0.6547279357910156,
-0.5838679075241089,
-0.7909722924232483,
-0.6939616799354553,
0.09108388423919678,
0.39194920659065247,
0.565351128578186,
-0.7713046073913574,
0.16844183206558228,
-0.3989197015762329,
0.23089654743671417,
-0.42172861099243164,
-0.14605551958084106,
0.30686190724372864,
-0.396207332611084,
-0.32064858078956604,
0.27129656076431274,
0.5075840353965759,
-0.037208572030067444,
-0.6779541373252869,
-0.01828554831445217,
-0.03486701846122742,
-0.09515649825334549,
0.47671136260032654,
0.4858948588371277,
-0.8724842071533203,
-0.5331963896751404,
-0.16616734862327576,
0.04904257878661156,
-0.032056692987680435,
0.8383975625038147,
-0.39215120673179626,
0.309147447347641,
0.47293925285339355,
0.996296763420105,
-0.03604288399219513,
-0.32995957136154175,
0.7322909235954285,
-1.0930792093276978,
-0.001941038528457284,
0.5258076786994934,
0.6100940108299255,
0.3682602047920227,
-0.24028627574443817,
0.7247756123542786,
0.14703600108623505,
-0.8320802450180054,
-0.9767274260520935,
0.3322378396987915,
-0.8972780108451843,
0.08455751091241837,
1.003206491470337,
-0.5983551144599915,
-0.05686083808541298,
-0.47887346148490906,
0.1367923766374588,
-0.1584850698709488,
0.24271763861179352,
0.6447214484214783,
0.8864352107048035,
0.26515311002731323,
0.10788469016551971,
-0.4408094882965088,
0.40990009903907776,
0.5265399217605591,
-0.6315877437591553,
0.015568085946142673,
0.41574934124946594,
0.2278997004032135,
0.6373036503791809,
0.4161204695701599,
-0.2636624872684479,
0.15381614863872528,
0.2566140294075012,
-0.261394202709198,
0.11943692713975906,
-0.35617902874946594,
-0.534984290599823,
0.48188722133636475,
0.14317244291305542,
-0.22601772844791412
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10135v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10135v1
|
The Whole is Better than the Sum: Using Aggregated Demonstrations in In-Context Learning for Sequential Recommendation
| 2024-03-15T09:28:19 | 2024-03-15T09:28:19 |
Lei Wang, Ee-Peng Lim
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have shown excellent performance on various NLP
tasks. To use LLMs as strong sequential recommenders, we explore the in-context
learning approach to sequential recommendation. We investigate the effects of
instruction format, task consistency, demonstration selection, and number of
demonstrations. As increasing the number of demonstrations in ICL does not
improve accuracy despite using a long prompt, we propose a novel method called
LLMSRec-Syn that incorporates multiple demonstration users into one aggregated
demonstration. Our experiments on three recommendation datasets show that
LLMSRec-Syn outperforms state-of-the-art LLM-based sequential recommendation
methods. In some cases, LLMSRec-Syn can perform on par with or even better than
supervised learning methods. Our code is publicly available at
https://github.com/demoleiwang/LLMSRec_Syn.
|
[
-0.26814717054367065,
-0.5426972508430481,
0.6184092164039612,
0.592671811580658,
-0.5578503608703613,
-0.006725362502038479,
-0.2747901678085327,
-0.23954682052135468,
0.282894104719162,
0.2933559715747833,
-0.47368064522743225,
-0.5950466990470886,
-0.5038814544677734,
0.11402104049921036,
-0.7537803649902344,
1.1775915622711182,
0.016590578481554985,
0.13844236731529236,
-0.6613592505455017,
-0.28741326928138733,
-0.6675109267234802,
-0.23824411630630493,
-0.7340423464775085,
-0.6305365562438965,
0.6448266506195068,
0.6631460785865784,
0.30656343698501587,
0.22823110222816467,
0.15980832278728485,
0.36984938383102417,
0.11963305622339249,
0.45530712604522705,
-0.5641281008720398,
0.30109667778015137,
-0.18222296237945557,
-0.15868760645389557,
-0.18502581119537354,
-0.16647963225841522,
0.7415661811828613,
0.7203021049499512,
-0.35218775272369385,
-0.1191108450293541,
0.2886579632759094,
0.6786314845085144,
-0.5076925754547119,
-0.3136141896247864,
-0.33783164620399475,
-0.06775199621915817,
-0.055741626769304276,
0.014542671851813793,
-0.8527469635009766,
-0.3815799951553345,
0.42170795798301697,
-0.37754321098327637,
-0.2355075478553772,
0.35080552101135254,
0.26640260219573975,
0.026454174891114235,
-0.6218488216400146,
-0.1224713996052742,
-0.7220301032066345,
0.931645393371582,
-0.7479870319366455,
0.27763399481773376,
0.3019331693649292,
0.23185206949710846,
-0.2205921858549118,
-1.0400323867797852,
-0.31547266244888306,
-0.5062082409858704,
-0.14953680336475372,
0.2143692523241043,
-0.07340401411056519,
-0.2197950780391693,
0.25507834553718567,
0.3690973222255707,
-0.5316464900970459,
0.3297936022281647,
-0.10538993030786514,
-0.009418201632797718,
0.5212727189064026,
0.11662916839122772,
0.22663593292236328,
0.37322917580604553,
-0.7606961131095886,
-0.04649168625473976,
-0.8831444978713989,
0.088448666036129,
0.0366329662501812,
0.1068662479519844,
-0.19758836925029755,
0.6261304020881653,
-0.20665983855724335,
0.7827640175819397,
0.2863392233848572,
-0.2328495979309082,
0.1308826059103012,
-0.40350133180618286,
-0.2707139551639557,
0.03860625624656677,
0.7672937512397766,
0.3693097233772278,
0.22700734436511993,
-0.2298857420682907,
-0.18487565219402313,
-0.14957746863365173,
0.15989065170288086,
-0.7696124911308289,
-0.04079759865999222,
0.019379643723368645,
-0.4367726743221283,
0.05993599817156792,
0.4265589714050293,
-0.2077462524175644,
-0.4312673509120941,
-0.4982732832431793,
0.5603271722793579,
-0.35040566325187683,
0.3334532380104065,
0.08264712989330292,
-0.06951305270195007,
-0.2551467716693878,
0.5052411556243896,
-0.8186529874801636,
0.7946877479553223,
0.6449630856513977,
0.98239666223526,
-0.5832857489585876,
-0.6241790652275085,
-0.7911617755889893,
0.008128144778311253,
-0.32766151428222656,
1.0426274538040161,
-0.23850490152835846,
-0.4740227460861206,
-0.038988739252090454,
0.03752829134464264,
0.15633970499038696,
-0.7009883522987366,
0.2782793939113617,
-0.4301646649837494,
0.3822813630104065,
-0.10710854828357697,
-0.9272854328155518,
-0.10327838361263275,
-0.010064976289868355,
-0.3406333029270172,
1.0257315635681152,
0.07090362906455994,
-0.47857391834259033,
0.644444465637207,
-0.4470571279525757,
-0.7010162472724915,
0.1297282725572586,
-0.057009659707546234,
-0.12868094444274902,
-0.1946808397769928,
0.3071141242980957,
0.7356554865837097,
-0.03123757615685463,
0.504317581653595,
-0.42532071471214294,
-0.6955136656761169,
0.25924524664878845,
-0.2097538709640503,
0.47085699439048767,
-0.08308234810829163,
-0.26210570335388184,
0.6569215059280396,
-0.40631821751594543,
-0.40763914585113525,
-0.07212945818901062,
-0.2169148325920105,
-0.4643039405345917,
0.16516494750976562,
-0.22160255908966064,
0.058317746967077255,
0.07612089067697525,
-0.21928195655345917,
0.25313082337379456,
-0.7160000205039978,
0.10389985889196396,
0.9792423844337463,
0.08936591446399689,
0.7701994180679321,
-0.6731215119361877,
0.2538655996322632,
-0.23519842326641083,
-0.07368861138820648,
-0.45790165662765503,
-0.43138357996940613,
-0.644805371761322,
-0.24041341245174408,
0.15712857246398926,
0.24286262691020966,
-0.6987436413764954,
0.5917938947677612,
-0.027764810249209404,
-0.22987248003482819,
0.1851734220981598,
0.21222132444381714,
0.3463686406612396,
0.40344783663749695,
0.27572906017303467,
-0.4032643139362335,
-0.6631220579147339,
-0.823186993598938,
-0.19954653084278107,
-0.2762734591960907,
-0.2795916795730591,
0.4197303056716919,
0.369240403175354,
-0.09150605648756027,
0.648859977722168,
-0.1882643699645996,
-0.2192133665084839,
-0.33504053950309753,
-0.11640284210443497,
0.5248326063156128,
0.09185776114463806,
0.4054873585700989,
-0.32279491424560547,
-0.763867974281311,
-0.3014543652534485,
-0.4566674828529358,
-0.07242762297391891,
-0.25630566477775574,
-0.06871580332517624,
-0.0789652168750763,
0.3257100284099579,
-0.1788296401500702,
0.1365102380514145,
0.47734689712524414,
-0.3643851578235626,
0.3912438154220581,
-0.3998059630393982,
-0.04702632874250412,
-1.012104868888855,
-0.4331464469432831,
0.2698853313922882,
-0.5058917999267578,
-0.32994580268859863,
-0.1512008011341095,
-0.02395583875477314,
0.31563350558280945,
-0.4871126711368561,
0.8155099153518677,
-0.1169670894742012,
-0.28305962681770325,
-0.3594582676887512,
0.3135809898376465,
-0.1505592316389084,
0.33041563630104065,
-0.13013078272342682,
0.898180365562439,
0.6690586805343628,
-0.7812168002128601,
0.2748471796512604,
0.22637732326984406,
-0.9061338305473328,
0.29466381669044495,
-0.740089476108551,
0.09685967117547989,
0.13732336461544037,
0.8301547169685364,
-1.123011827468872,
-0.06520485132932663,
-0.017179299145936966,
0.11771723628044128,
0.042424656450748444,
0.037472061812877655,
-0.4821440577507019,
-0.08846446871757507,
-0.40190523862838745,
0.14023958146572113,
0.5792785882949829,
-0.9843553304672241,
0.38703498244285583,
0.16725988686084747,
-0.16158892214298248,
-0.6420207023620605,
-0.3648402988910675,
0.07898953557014465,
-0.2237272411584854,
-0.4423842132091522,
0.7573003172874451,
-0.3152364492416382,
-0.36195871233940125,
-0.39513805508613586,
0.019621754065155983,
0.47650814056396484,
0.08135741204023361,
0.5081518888473511,
0.23508493602275848,
-0.0161854550242424,
0.31788119673728943,
-0.10356657207012177,
-0.0742848739027977,
-0.1839146614074707,
-0.573322594165802,
0.49949347972869873,
-0.16385772824287415,
-0.51519376039505,
-0.38587063550949097,
0.4175347685813904,
0.37114188075065613,
0.23831366002559662,
0.4486692547798157,
0.4543142318725586,
-0.11071117967367172,
-0.517850935459137,
-0.5077007412910461,
-0.3428592085838318,
-0.4865644872188568,
0.30562451481819153,
0.012570248916745186,
-0.9304644465446472,
0.08803959935903549,
-0.26316243410110474,
0.37420088052749634,
0.2998178005218506,
0.6672140955924988,
-0.2885054349899292,
0.8462339639663696,
0.5047076940536499,
-0.33225536346435547,
0.8060399293899536,
-0.38318637013435364,
-0.025428958237171173,
-0.7436620593070984,
-0.19309258460998535,
-0.10719013959169388,
-0.4456730782985687,
0.03872557729482651,
-0.20089617371559143,
0.3101641535758972,
0.16462305188179016,
-0.39987167716026306,
0.24997323751449585,
-0.13580043613910675,
0.5832173824310303,
0.677501380443573,
0.3830835223197937,
0.28171858191490173,
0.10071975737810135,
-0.343648225069046,
0.06402940303087234,
-0.6685304045677185,
-0.4843190014362335,
0.8226321339607239,
0.1054401770234108,
0.7519642114639282,
0.24682195484638214,
0.5883668065071106,
0.5139351487159729,
0.42967134714126587,
-0.9820560812950134,
0.7506068348884583,
-0.6342161893844604,
0.0423230305314064,
-0.36324813961982727,
-0.005237731151282787,
-0.8495854735374451,
0.2920083701610565,
-0.3068600594997406,
-0.7457579374313354,
0.02515866607427597,
0.07263101637363434,
-0.37100231647491455,
0.19107235968112946,
-0.4720021188259125,
0.6170770525932312,
-0.4121456742286682,
-0.4729023575782776,
-0.5334429740905762,
-0.4853823781013489,
0.2342626005411148,
0.07111218571662903,
0.09739051759243011,
0.10546964406967163,
-0.14253181219100952,
0.9175268411636353,
-0.5966216921806335,
0.9310035705566406,
-0.10978175699710846,
-0.04874064773321152,
0.2525174915790558,
-0.0579502172768116,
0.9182106256484985,
0.09573815017938614,
-0.08450445532798767,
-0.2414255142211914,
-0.6001389026641846,
-0.05213586241006851,
-0.8241353034973145,
0.9460839629173279,
-0.5467159152030945,
-0.5962350964546204,
-0.061873909085989,
-0.23661376535892487,
-0.2410626858472824,
0.034475360065698624,
-0.06637933850288391,
0.8551169037818909,
-0.165404811501503,
0.5264505743980408,
0.4659976661205292,
-0.0976896733045578,
0.597136914730072,
0.45829182863235474,
-0.3490106463432312,
-0.6268848180770874,
0.728320300579071,
-0.1789497286081314,
0.16677828133106232,
0.5263075828552246,
0.6408976912498474,
-0.5251884460449219,
-0.6966394782066345,
-0.5694509148597717,
0.06303150951862335,
-0.7928479909896851,
0.030065514147281647,
-0.8840848803520203,
0.25736191868782043,
-0.34247061610221863,
-0.28403422236442566,
0.033024515956640244,
-0.37232789397239685,
-0.2839511036872864,
-0.22929494082927704,
0.2959413528442383,
0.8621573448181152,
0.22458897531032562,
0.5156800150871277,
-0.444856196641922,
0.40031513571739197,
0.7224758267402649,
0.3261202871799469,
0.20130515098571777,
-0.8141716718673706,
-0.3787343204021454,
-0.22035810351371765,
-0.20723102986812592,
-0.4820000231266022,
0.28256744146347046,
0.3570702373981476,
0.6929730176925659,
0.8054980039596558,
0.14098480343818665,
0.7629009485244751,
-0.7145746946334839,
1.0221902132034302,
0.29555872082710266,
-0.6017169952392578,
0.2650803327560425,
-0.18112795054912567,
0.4227098226547241,
0.4781782329082489,
0.49907171726226807,
-0.47797954082489014,
-0.32688263058662415,
-0.5052636861801147,
-1.0678844451904297,
0.6443842649459839,
-0.1705435812473297,
-0.01957089453935623,
-0.044094476848840714,
0.021572822704911232,
0.31031888723373413,
-0.10321328788995743,
-0.49246305227279663,
-0.3999617099761963,
0.1051853820681572,
-0.03826494887471199,
-0.36167314648628235,
-0.5334495306015015,
-0.17148318886756897,
-0.12183678895235062,
0.8839356899261475,
-0.10810470581054688,
-0.08336241543292999,
0.10056133568286896,
-0.13431806862354279,
0.06958276033401489,
0.21614128351211548,
0.8075778484344482,
0.7094212770462036,
-0.03470057621598244,
-0.002844045637175441,
0.495437890291214,
-0.09556054323911667,
0.24945038557052612,
-0.23136435449123383,
0.045809004455804825,
0.0383785218000412,
0.5581158995628357,
0.9747598171234131,
0.5870576500892639,
-0.6643616557121277,
0.7343918681144714,
-0.07973858714103699,
-0.30729368329048157,
-0.5199400782585144,
-0.051479093730449677,
0.11941193044185638,
0.20613721013069153,
0.3275946378707886,
0.16802233457565308,
0.2605411410331726,
-0.544884204864502,
0.521202027797699,
0.2506992518901825,
-0.3524071276187897,
0.03727388009428978,
0.3017384111881256,
0.24825561046600342,
-0.39163467288017273,
0.554980993270874,
0.2356853038072586,
-0.35100677609443665,
0.5311421751976013,
0.8767865300178528,
0.8180323243141174,
0.15513041615486145,
0.21726049482822418,
0.32165661454200745,
-0.1955578327178955,
-0.7343471646308899,
-0.23173227906227112,
-0.5539699792861938,
-0.6742658615112305,
-0.6816933155059814,
-0.21850767731666565,
-0.6497138738632202,
-0.41294461488723755,
-0.4734235107898712,
0.4643697440624237,
-0.38617005944252014,
0.007964914664626122,
0.008029080927371979,
-0.06031535938382149,
-0.26013830304145813,
-0.05291379615664482,
0.11690595000982285,
0.7971353530883789,
-0.7972406148910522,
0.8881837129592896,
0.7420377135276794,
-0.004836376290768385,
-0.5926746129989624,
-0.15196074545383453,
-0.0906103178858757,
-0.5352941155433655,
0.6647745966911316,
0.19535163044929504,
-0.328421413898468,
-0.19426900148391724,
-0.5838192105293274,
-0.6134639382362366,
1.0866811275482178,
0.07857395708560944,
-0.64224773645401,
0.3276878893375397,
-0.6857132315635681,
0.4484500586986542,
-0.6740601062774658,
0.6047419905662537,
-0.10165048390626907,
0.3533026874065399,
0.2820291519165039,
-0.7116696834564209,
-0.006855971645563841,
0.07219092547893524,
-0.09761194884777069,
0.0049997372552752495,
-0.7956795692443848,
0.6176132559776306,
-0.6094033122062683,
-0.44201940298080444,
0.2835504114627838,
0.8538010716438293,
0.6886637210845947,
0.5080569982528687,
0.9105575680732727,
0.2524123191833496,
0.6252139210700989,
0.22836974263191223,
1.3631508350372314,
0.14971564710140228,
-0.13567441701889038,
1.6678030490875244,
-0.6096773743629456,
0.8356406688690186,
0.4850113093852997,
-0.4928658902645111,
1.0766421556472778,
0.7756781578063965,
0.011247245594859123,
0.5625357627868652,
0.2240372747182846,
-0.29216524958610535,
-0.36991918087005615,
-0.24544627964496613,
-0.05756477639079094,
-0.10984320938587189,
0.23522301018238068,
-0.2512977421283722,
-0.08091823011636734,
0.13412031531333923,
-0.4915928542613983,
0.2498088777065277,
-0.05151183903217316,
1.1789207458496094,
0.3161919414997101,
-0.6998358368873596,
0.34060531854629517,
-0.09715092182159424,
0.9569896459579468,
-0.7484298348426819,
-0.37408196926116943,
-0.4070798456668854,
0.11232602596282959,
-0.27188992500305176,
-0.5904790163040161,
-0.16618122160434723,
-0.19681909680366516,
-0.31842508912086487,
-0.469448447227478,
0.5655168294906616,
-0.45841294527053833,
-0.33853864669799805,
0.33892738819122314,
0.24222268164157867,
0.3262638449668884,
0.2192886471748352,
-0.3373351991176605,
-0.6359490156173706,
0.02694805897772312,
0.04401315748691559,
0.5687271952629089,
0.06666820496320724,
-0.3933267295360565,
1.0151249170303345,
0.655846118927002,
-0.028851721435785294,
-0.2919812500476837,
0.6712889671325684,
0.6919971704483032,
-0.4250236451625824,
-0.4413939416408539,
-1.0561739206314087,
0.5353050231933594,
-0.18108701705932617,
-0.1852526068687439,
0.9851165413856506,
0.6066972613334656,
1.0974987745285034,
-0.13198085129261017,
0.40867146849632263,
0.22587397694587708,
0.5005484223365784,
-0.5745708346366882,
0.18367579579353333,
-0.5686153769493103,
0.7069105505943298,
-0.05194288119673729,
-0.9084422588348389,
-0.3390538692474365,
0.4855363965034485,
0.015005665831267834,
0.2178185135126114,
0.9641817212104797,
0.6172252893447876,
0.02234753966331482,
0.1505821794271469,
0.5096852779388428,
0.08415291458368301,
0.08488874137401581,
0.3131820857524872,
1.2643070220947266,
-0.25892215967178345,
0.2403518259525299,
-0.46097201108932495,
-0.1723765879869461,
-0.19994406402111053,
-0.9196821451187134,
-0.9702160358428955,
-0.3952158987522125,
-0.2813526690006256,
-0.2236911803483963,
0.1026114672422409,
1.4291936159133911,
0.8542550206184387,
-0.9246837496757507,
-0.6872536540031433,
0.15387177467346191,
0.3587300479412079,
-0.7650837302207947,
-0.18847428262233734,
0.42697393894195557,
-0.21442048251628876,
-0.6810922622680664,
1.0102062225341797,
0.26968708634376526,
0.049002476036548615,
-0.2912226617336273,
-0.21938379108905792,
-0.2107943892478943,
-0.43463900685310364,
0.944216787815094,
-0.23153023421764374,
-0.8569547533988953,
-0.007671352010220289,
-0.0993887409567833,
0.12103908509016037,
-0.16081075370311737,
1.23195481300354,
-1.055445909500122,
0.22669076919555664,
0.5831936001777649,
0.4519932270050049,
0.6098920702934265,
0.18305854499340057,
0.7212552428245544,
-0.6418858766555786,
-0.034787844866514206,
0.10476625710725784,
0.6385658979415894,
0.09870989620685577,
-0.25277402997016907,
0.5180600881576538,
0.030978215858340263,
-0.6441273093223572,
-0.4647281765937805,
0.0002494520740583539,
-1.0973814725875854,
-0.30031970143318176,
1.2633191347122192,
-0.25487643480300903,
0.19236263632774353,
-0.15777842700481415,
-0.2586134076118469,
-0.19346500933170319,
-0.8695939183235168,
0.6923847794532776,
0.41315579414367676,
-0.14931535720825195,
-0.07345348596572876,
-0.21016909182071686,
-0.07906439900398254,
0.4442533850669861,
-0.3930305540561676,
0.024904044345021248,
0.5528258681297302,
0.1783313900232315,
-0.3832237124443054,
0.7261937260627747,
0.04227650538086891,
-0.0038244666066020727,
-0.39389702677726746,
-0.21883566677570343,
-0.1262030452489853,
-0.620000958442688,
-0.5310484766960144,
0.1624498814344406,
0.28746098279953003,
0.012135072611272335
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10131v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10131v2
|
RAFT: Adapting Language Model to Domain Specific RAG
| 2024-03-15T09:26:02 | 2024-06-05T17:27:51 |
Tianjun Zhang, Shishir G. Patil, Naman Jain, Sheng Shen, Matei Zaharia, Ion Stoica, Joseph E. Gonzalez
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Pretraining Large Language Models (LLMs) on large corpora of textual data is
now a standard paradigm. When using these LLMs for many downstream
applications, it is common to additionally bake in new knowledge (e.g.,
time-critical news, or private domain knowledge) into the pretrained model
either through RAG-based-prompting, or fine-tuning. However, the optimal
methodology for the model to gain such new knowledge remains an open question.
In this paper, we present Retrieval Augmented FineTuning (RAFT), a training
recipe that improves the model's ability to answer questions in a "open-book"
in-domain settings. In RAFT, given a question, and a set of retrieved
documents, we train the model to ignore those documents that don't help in
answering the question, which we call, distractor documents. RAFT accomplishes
this by citing verbatim the right sequence from the relevant document that
would help answer the question. This coupled with RAFT's chain-of-thought-style
response helps improve the model's ability to reason. In domain-specific RAG,
RAFT consistently improves the model's performance across PubMed, HotpotQA, and
Gorilla datasets, presenting a post-training recipe to improve pre-trained LLMs
to in-domain RAG. RAFT's code and demo are open-sourced at
github.com/ShishirPatil/gorilla.
|
[
-0.38826197385787964,
-0.7413439154624939,
0.253606915473938,
0.1472957283258438,
-0.37593191862106323,
0.012312235310673714,
-0.4457998275756836,
-0.3200792372226715,
0.020423104986548424,
0.7755184769630432,
-0.30576103925704956,
-0.3331408202648163,
-0.5480129718780518,
-0.03172735124826431,
-0.2592974901199341,
1.4135993719100952,
-0.034929074347019196,
-0.10689535737037659,
-0.23411846160888672,
-0.08596687763929367,
-0.6689061522483826,
-0.620119571685791,
-0.7539455890655518,
-0.1906876116991043,
0.6257400512695312,
0.3837965726852417,
0.3618690073490143,
0.4767633378505707,
0.40674838423728943,
0.20681238174438477,
-0.17102129757404327,
0.34177181124687195,
-0.7901890873908997,
0.2374226301908493,
-0.5264505743980408,
-0.4646663963794708,
-0.4826149344444275,
-0.05867846682667732,
0.4770427346229553,
0.5412401556968689,
-0.03571689873933792,
0.3001020848751068,
0.2973824143409729,
0.745366096496582,
-0.788563072681427,
0.02874448336660862,
-0.8623637557029724,
-0.29511216282844543,
-0.30036240816116333,
-0.35250458121299744,
-0.5444579720497131,
-0.14012527465820312,
0.3581078350543976,
-0.870226263999939,
0.34621304273605347,
0.18471719324588776,
0.8341900706291199,
0.4616290032863617,
-0.27443140745162964,
-0.5396355986595154,
-0.6702309846878052,
0.6837918162345886,
-0.6260359287261963,
0.4822695851325989,
0.8094669580459595,
0.21228305995464325,
-0.19823749363422394,
-0.8117737770080566,
-0.4664710760116577,
-0.09267133474349976,
-0.1756603866815567,
0.1529749035835266,
0.17820808291435242,
-0.12783709168434143,
0.05439143255352974,
0.5104008316993713,
-0.6183493733406067,
-0.07054731994867325,
-0.36318105459213257,
-0.03508366644382477,
0.46733206510543823,
-0.1854511797428131,
0.13894127309322357,
-0.08719243854284286,
-0.4296565353870392,
-0.002639524172991514,
-0.5369261503219604,
0.04593324661254883,
0.07955680042505264,
0.5179792046546936,
-0.019200684502720833,
0.48874354362487793,
-0.11318563669919968,
0.910113513469696,
0.22762012481689453,
0.009882406331598759,
0.2387211173772812,
0.17290665209293365,
-0.27688583731651306,
0.04500343278050423,
0.041758209466934204,
0.23013010621070862,
0.3641003966331482,
0.008662828244268894,
-0.4509790241718292,
-0.44771885871887207,
0.5640463829040527,
-0.721802830696106,
-0.3199877142906189,
0.2987724542617798,
-0.20527267456054688,
-0.01028816681355238,
-0.23807744681835175,
-0.5148224234580994,
-0.5961639285087585,
-0.4418748617172241,
0.6819358468055725,
-0.6205182671546936,
-0.13901345431804657,
0.12352676689624786,
-0.20324945449829102,
0.32648539543151855,
0.41974085569381714,
-0.8915483951568604,
0.3739481568336487,
0.7453123927116394,
0.7552756667137146,
-0.31820935010910034,
-0.10911556333303452,
-1.0702202320098877,
0.3311050236225128,
-0.28577515482902527,
1.0229418277740479,
-0.3754172623157501,
-0.13485220074653625,
0.13424861431121826,
0.10643141716718674,
-0.20704276859760284,
-0.7125085592269897,
0.5721449851989746,
-1.0176682472229004,
0.19127844274044037,
-0.050211530178785324,
-0.8479360938072205,
-0.16476164758205414,
0.34472817182540894,
-0.6034603714942932,
0.7621477246284485,
0.14528392255306244,
-0.6640974879264832,
0.19672973453998566,
-0.5534193515777588,
-0.3489900231361389,
0.15614046156406403,
0.2741721570491791,
-0.2744227647781372,
0.023212064057588577,
0.334221750497818,
0.4769176244735718,
-0.2664717733860016,
0.15400034189224243,
-0.08377435803413391,
-0.3325948417186737,
0.04549012333154678,
0.02868024818599224,
0.5061721801757812,
0.3123679459095001,
0.12282872945070267,
0.19743232429027557,
-0.7852272987365723,
-0.05928921699523926,
0.19967138767242432,
-0.6117416620254517,
-0.8506791591644287,
-0.1745983064174652,
0.061730965971946716,
-0.1646004319190979,
0.07653999328613281,
-0.240462988615036,
0.17029748857021332,
-0.4945012629032135,
0.1280602663755417,
0.8123697638511658,
0.16647881269454956,
0.6059788465499878,
-0.5686659216880798,
0.33571717143058777,
-0.16353793442249298,
-0.0752837210893631,
-0.3063543736934662,
-0.30371713638305664,
-0.7738717198371887,
-0.5239083766937256,
0.5200070142745972,
0.473447322845459,
-0.8325096964836121,
0.09431497007608414,
-0.10266711562871933,
-0.4058374762535095,
-0.6434879899024963,
0.13756471872329712,
0.390760213136673,
0.70639568567276,
0.5863646864891052,
-0.3622818887233734,
-0.4864249527454376,
-0.3935897648334503,
-0.5046325325965881,
0.2451733946800232,
-0.24672141671180725,
0.3926334083080292,
0.28521600365638733,
-0.2326516956090927,
0.6991090178489685,
-0.6566285490989685,
-0.5973825454711914,
-0.20020057260990143,
0.08611265569925308,
0.10309471935033798,
0.5192564725875854,
0.35780924558639526,
-1.0602480173110962,
-0.6082620620727539,
-0.025954945012927055,
-0.40210625529289246,
-0.2068900614976883,
-0.03884372487664223,
-0.2386409491300583,
0.4242474138736725,
0.5974822640419006,
-0.42388007044792175,
0.27883827686309814,
0.46244657039642334,
-0.23459219932556152,
0.5795533061027527,
-0.30382323265075684,
0.0016753021627664566,
-0.9908179044723511,
0.17729048430919647,
-0.22457469999790192,
-0.2199617326259613,
-0.7434930205345154,
0.15324263274669647,
0.08522999286651611,
-0.10627123713493347,
-0.3308374881744385,
1.010434627532959,
-0.4404360353946686,
-0.028216414153575897,
-0.40744099020957947,
0.38425928354263306,
0.04971527308225632,
0.5001654028892517,
0.12942343950271606,
0.8031564950942993,
0.37394869327545166,
-0.8475228548049927,
-0.028071202337741852,
0.5966656804084778,
-0.3416632115840912,
0.43102481961250305,
-0.5428174734115601,
0.4426168203353882,
-0.26074957847595215,
0.10720442235469818,
-0.942154586315155,
-0.46169447898864746,
-0.03660033643245697,
-0.4268743097782135,
0.6308125257492065,
-0.4227882921695709,
-0.11557029187679291,
-0.14557203650474548,
-0.2438717633485794,
0.3394515812397003,
0.3687424957752228,
-0.7634692788124084,
0.6543420553207397,
0.5101504325866699,
-0.48255056142807007,
-0.6407793760299683,
-0.3587021231651306,
-0.24428561329841614,
-0.05871536210179329,
-0.2713561952114105,
0.5540976524353027,
-0.351063072681427,
-0.08135727047920227,
0.035482101142406464,
-0.2999630272388458,
-0.3928990066051483,
-0.04320744052529335,
-0.0028754461091011763,
0.29195988178253174,
-0.2881488502025604,
0.20211173593997955,
-0.013194152154028416,
-0.07381772249937057,
-0.33272409439086914,
-0.5488681793212891,
0.6069602370262146,
-0.055940479040145874,
-0.007503358181566,
0.1386207938194275,
0.11893504112958908,
0.19813479483127594,
-0.5208814740180969,
0.774168074131012,
0.4895903766155243,
-0.33056649565696716,
-0.5207125544548035,
-0.6299033164978027,
0.036714181303977966,
-0.4848785996437073,
0.24019521474838257,
-0.45427635312080383,
-1.1760753393173218,
0.39716440439224243,
-0.2918075919151306,
-0.011492573656141758,
0.26227739453315735,
0.564532995223999,
-0.07849807292222977,
0.36625242233276367,
0.9139984846115112,
0.13016033172607422,
0.5529271960258484,
-0.16950316727161407,
0.058334238827228546,
-1.0243726968765259,
-0.0610014945268631,
-0.3776135742664337,
-0.09445439279079437,
-0.26144787669181824,
-0.5967546105384827,
0.2024359256029129,
0.37826529145240784,
-0.3434329032897949,
0.2909505069255829,
-0.4496360421180725,
0.5547487139701843,
0.5655567049980164,
-0.04352397471666336,
0.2717360854148865,
-0.05852646380662918,
-0.2047216147184372,
0.11984837055206299,
-0.7103872299194336,
-0.472463458776474,
1.054548978805542,
0.09645581245422363,
0.6398403644561768,
-0.05656088888645172,
0.6105572581291199,
0.20151835680007935,
0.5975997447967529,
-0.7390671372413635,
0.3288564682006836,
-0.2597534954547882,
-0.7477513551712036,
-0.2713389992713928,
-0.45069265365600586,
-0.9636732339859009,
0.18021181225776672,
-0.13923567533493042,
-0.4808919131755829,
0.10189979523420334,
0.16672024130821228,
-0.35876142978668213,
0.1675361841917038,
-0.7087300419807434,
0.8967615962028503,
-0.07210882753133774,
-0.2042754739522934,
-0.06499780714511871,
-0.5328778624534607,
0.3067721724510193,
-0.6295610070228577,
0.3134963810443878,
-0.027079256251454353,
-0.09134320914745331,
0.7193796634674072,
-0.23388727009296417,
0.6605138778686523,
-0.21299651265144348,
-0.07013696432113647,
0.33405864238739014,
0.16144010424613953,
0.3715738356113434,
-0.22864162921905518,
-0.2137605994939804,
-0.0888969749212265,
-0.024438465014100075,
-0.37151193618774414,
-0.6201211810112,
0.6190241575241089,
-0.7244739532470703,
-0.7430189847946167,
-0.2669406831264496,
-0.9088423252105713,
-0.4322511851787567,
0.38950401544570923,
0.044154830276966095,
0.35556650161743164,
-0.17366084456443787,
0.08520612120628357,
0.7770171761512756,
-0.49678856134414673,
0.21596865355968475,
0.8238716125488281,
-0.35627076029777527,
-0.528198778629303,
0.8094863891601562,
0.2211599200963974,
0.32083860039711,
0.47300922870635986,
0.17961041629314423,
-0.14309805631637573,
-0.5246932506561279,
-0.27038851380348206,
0.28017690777778625,
-0.7170348763465881,
-0.396904319524765,
-0.5516524314880371,
-0.38263437151908875,
-0.4755053222179413,
-0.23061764240264893,
-0.22025087475776672,
-0.5132331848144531,
-0.2524054944515228,
0.019506923854351044,
0.5663172602653503,
0.7298227548599243,
0.052930209785699844,
0.33645933866500854,
-0.8790918588638306,
0.4577564299106598,
0.3210751414299011,
0.5227878093719482,
-0.0629149079322815,
-1.0548168420791626,
-0.44082576036453247,
-0.19075076282024384,
-0.1984296441078186,
-0.45892372727394104,
0.3872655928134918,
0.44028380513191223,
0.4683811068534851,
-0.01299759279936552,
0.29656273126602173,
0.6988219618797302,
-0.9080013036727905,
0.4807737171649933,
-0.2967020273208618,
-0.7978256940841675,
0.5721074938774109,
-0.46278291940689087,
0.22073973715305328,
0.37726232409477234,
0.7684241533279419,
-0.4297536611557007,
-0.4167143404483795,
-0.3402990698814392,
-0.9288533926010132,
0.6672508120536804,
-0.034650035202503204,
0.22054283320903778,
0.06430231034755707,
0.7742818593978882,
0.17581816017627716,
0.1538010686635971,
-0.47508975863456726,
0.009650597348809242,
-0.12087807804346085,
-0.19616460800170898,
-0.2683001458644867,
-0.31450968980789185,
0.0018849294865503907,
-0.24008524417877197,
0.8844013214111328,
-0.2829880714416504,
0.11407171189785004,
0.2745419442653656,
-0.2745617628097534,
-0.13108156621456146,
0.1082010269165039,
0.5693456530570984,
0.5267277956008911,
-0.33051174879074097,
0.23075130581855774,
0.16602537035942078,
-0.6253424286842346,
-0.050093263387680054,
0.33006882667541504,
-0.06521255522966385,
-0.21012748777866364,
0.2867952883243561,
0.6097822785377502,
0.1528082937002182,
-0.7246702313423157,
0.36504969000816345,
0.029858417809009552,
0.018258770927786827,
-0.08872488141059875,
0.13590198755264282,
0.07415341585874557,
0.3764381408691406,
0.44722455739974976,
0.16863146424293518,
-0.15538440644741058,
-0.3640928864479065,
0.4269920587539673,
0.19498862326145172,
-0.24880392849445343,
-0.14494794607162476,
0.7536210417747498,
-0.0037125912494957447,
-0.43722623586654663,
0.3376023769378662,
-0.10971131175756454,
-0.5548428297042847,
0.1934504359960556,
0.8384928107261658,
0.7707685828208923,
-0.41516703367233276,
-0.042870618402957916,
0.21750298142433167,
0.13524073362350464,
0.06785890460014343,
0.16760991513729095,
0.10580874234437943,
-0.7207298874855042,
-0.5640001893043518,
-0.8893959522247314,
-0.46722254157066345,
0.21402542293071747,
-0.6108591556549072,
0.32559293508529663,
-0.43002668023109436,
0.036770790815353394,
0.06280197203159332,
0.03855873644351959,
-0.48604005575180054,
0.29707884788513184,
0.08133524656295776,
1.1955777406692505,
-0.3578975200653076,
1.0023592710494995,
0.7023011445999146,
-0.5554751753807068,
-0.7463967800140381,
0.35417476296424866,
-0.1394643932580948,
-0.7382808327674866,
0.6138615608215332,
0.04619158059358597,
0.06238749250769615,
0.1877603381872177,
-0.537458062171936,
-0.9775587320327759,
0.8469531536102295,
0.4030073583126068,
-0.3377766013145447,
0.08751250058412552,
-0.03416592627763748,
0.5231327414512634,
-0.4633140563964844,
-0.2293204814195633,
0.34118950366973877,
0.13069674372673035,
0.1072264164686203,
-0.9582635760307312,
-0.050165463238954544,
-0.2311852127313614,
0.020745791494846344,
0.038828294724226,
-0.47383883595466614,
0.8014954924583435,
-0.21106936037540436,
0.06321510672569275,
0.07649638503789902,
0.7460907697677612,
0.3088283836841583,
0.4104127287864685,
0.5257800221443176,
0.5072109699249268,
1.0728154182434082,
0.21073408424854279,
1.1935652494430542,
-0.1679488867521286,
0.28934162855148315,
1.4901729822158813,
-0.4568662941455841,
1.1929049491882324,
0.2816289961338043,
0.30994993448257446,
0.49701574444770813,
0.5402276515960693,
0.2396954447031021,
0.880256175994873,
0.28888171911239624,
-0.15897119045257568,
-0.034083642065525055,
-0.1529223769903183,
-0.1433200091123581,
0.15992404520511627,
0.3962460160255432,
-0.03358164429664612,
-0.0772719457745552,
0.3802979290485382,
-0.07370700687170029,
0.13285307586193085,
-0.5652649998664856,
0.9131483435630798,
0.25201526284217834,
-0.7664636969566345,
1.0776094198226929,
0.01762983947992325,
0.51728755235672,
-0.6178947687149048,
0.08552691340446472,
-0.29733791947364807,
0.4991385042667389,
-0.10772325098514557,
-0.624879002571106,
0.5037238001823425,
0.2853856384754181,
-0.3910619914531708,
-0.18150170147418976,
1.0926274061203003,
-0.593873143196106,
-0.08276861906051636,
0.2964017391204834,
0.4710070490837097,
0.142364040017128,
-0.1998022347688675,
-0.5175569653511047,
0.12197766453027725,
-0.17466451227664948,
-0.3684327304363251,
0.4489923119544983,
0.609305739402771,
-0.12208296358585358,
0.6352468729019165,
0.6764577627182007,
-0.09557544440031052,
0.026148516684770584,
0.1787574142217636,
1.0960663557052612,
-0.42131108045578003,
-0.3100984990596771,
-0.4474516212940216,
0.4758909046649933,
0.09796350449323654,
-0.19411157071590424,
0.8388311862945557,
0.6643340587615967,
1.0625051259994507,
-0.3381674587726593,
0.5591728091239929,
0.1349724531173706,
0.8207984566688538,
-0.44050440192222595,
0.8937559127807617,
-0.6377730369567871,
0.18746601045131683,
-0.30487269163131714,
-0.8873713612556458,
-0.4449135363101959,
0.6109863519668579,
-0.5570247173309326,
-0.10933343321084976,
0.5893402695655823,
0.7536280155181885,
-0.17692126333713531,
0.04148773476481438,
0.25215959548950195,
0.36387792229652405,
0.15047882497310638,
0.25333067774772644,
0.8027022480964661,
-0.33984270691871643,
0.4751944839954376,
0.0877051129937172,
-0.37726348638534546,
-0.11082274466753006,
-0.8650996685028076,
-0.9545873403549194,
-0.7338970303535461,
-0.2942742109298706,
-0.2727662920951843,
0.22669818997383118,
0.9402388334274292,
0.6543627381324768,
-0.8556203246116638,
-0.17667776346206665,
0.15447436273097992,
0.0830124244093895,
-0.0862962156534195,
-0.1852724403142929,
0.4281518757343292,
-0.8952294588088989,
-0.5008019804954529,
0.39390796422958374,
0.15610484778881073,
0.07717155665159225,
0.3101014494895935,
-0.0994633138179779,
-0.49969005584716797,
0.4340457022190094,
0.7611757516860962,
0.14280842244625092,
-0.33786916732788086,
-0.3109979033470154,
0.0614360049366951,
0.039590686559677124,
-0.013461299240589142,
0.7851877808570862,
-0.8271817564964294,
0.33204925060272217,
0.20538638532161713,
1.0364127159118652,
0.801148533821106,
-0.03231634944677353,
0.48735129833221436,
-0.9908161163330078,
0.1952650249004364,
0.2513141632080078,
0.1580142229795456,
0.4630560874938965,
-0.35783395171165466,
0.6522877812385559,
0.04860318452119827,
-0.7788413763046265,
-0.8316101431846619,
-0.0453512966632843,
-0.8260946869850159,
-0.42749693989753723,
1.111762285232544,
-0.3476373851299286,
-0.389378160238266,
-0.1708955615758896,
-0.4590241014957428,
0.3266831338405609,
0.012457896023988724,
0.7209110260009766,
0.6327641606330872,
0.21057642996311188,
0.05892801284790039,
-0.7739490270614624,
0.8152743577957153,
0.40476104617118835,
-0.7400659918785095,
0.34309569001197815,
0.3140326738357544,
0.4174817204475403,
0.10387931019067764,
0.826451301574707,
0.04343022033572197,
0.11214318871498108,
-0.3295409381389618,
-0.08053161203861237,
0.019188961014151573,
-0.4618034362792969,
-0.36115530133247375,
0.03709307312965393,
0.16818532347679138,
0.042827341705560684
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15434v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15434v1
|
ChatPattern: Layout Pattern Customization via Natural Language
| 2024-03-15T09:15:22 | 2024-03-15T09:15:22 |
Zixiao Wang, Yunheng Shen, Xufeng Yao, Wenqian Zhao, Yang Bai, Farzan Farnia, Bei Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Existing works focus on fixed-size layout pattern generation, while the more
practical free-size pattern generation receives limited attention. In this
paper, we propose ChatPattern, a novel Large-Language-Model (LLM) powered
framework for flexible pattern customization. ChatPattern utilizes a two-part
system featuring an expert LLM agent and a highly controllable layout pattern
generator. The LLM agent can interpret natural language requirements and
operate design tools to meet specified needs, while the generator excels in
conditional layout generation, pattern modification, and memory-friendly
patterns extension. Experiments on challenging pattern generation setting shows
the ability of ChatPattern to synthesize high-quality large-scale patterns.
|
[
-0.17084193229675293,
-0.9015209078788757,
0.3544689118862152,
0.7503413558006287,
-0.31486549973487854,
0.1404130607843399,
-0.2575159966945648,
-0.2750808894634247,
0.7081584334373474,
0.9171199202537537,
-0.6367023587226868,
-0.40551480650901794,
-0.27098309993743896,
-0.0770227238535881,
-0.3009334206581116,
0.6694809794425964,
0.06232455372810364,
-0.28284555673599243,
0.28812816739082336,
0.2972586452960968,
-0.8216809630393982,
-0.2530044913291931,
-0.5681314468383789,
-0.36253121495246887,
0.48718664050102234,
0.34511616826057434,
0.8424561619758606,
0.8172082304954529,
0.46313971281051636,
0.44041165709495544,
-0.2687136232852936,
0.41822609305381775,
-0.41415250301361084,
0.2765061557292938,
0.157751202583313,
-0.4189613461494446,
-0.8377783298492432,
-0.21241609752178192,
0.3219528794288635,
0.4299458861351013,
-0.33725085854530334,
-0.14280322194099426,
-0.016556447371840477,
0.5154203772544861,
-0.48793476819992065,
0.25983619689941406,
-0.6192101240158081,
0.1690998375415802,
-0.15377332270145416,
-0.13298234343528748,
-0.6783389449119568,
-0.5494658946990967,
-0.33534494042396545,
-0.7496166229248047,
0.262701153755188,
0.08831652998924255,
0.705219030380249,
0.4194034934043884,
-0.3283894956111908,
-0.39232876896858215,
-0.8555452227592468,
0.6259238123893738,
-0.7649688720703125,
0.3554154634475708,
0.1809641569852829,
0.6306663751602173,
-0.6945179104804993,
-1.0104717016220093,
-0.3436654210090637,
-0.2255886048078537,
-0.29546961188316345,
0.001617581583559513,
0.15209265053272247,
0.04088996350765228,
0.16336292028427124,
0.4015975594520569,
-0.7524661421775818,
-0.21349799633026123,
0.03353715315461159,
-0.12712733447551727,
0.8219908475875854,
0.4654518961906433,
0.6186551451683044,
-0.2296781688928604,
-0.09140614420175552,
0.2561960518360138,
-0.6186709403991699,
-0.1728828251361847,
0.3321225047111511,
0.5887230634689331,
-0.20069900155067444,
0.41868510842323303,
-0.26425668597221375,
0.8924601674079895,
0.22064630687236786,
-0.24091830849647522,
-0.12148774415254593,
-0.033664967864751816,
-0.5199660062789917,
0.3598274886608124,
0.7577911019325256,
0.1790609359741211,
0.1684984713792801,
-0.21759343147277832,
-0.23039433360099792,
-0.3108484148979187,
0.23825404047966003,
-0.9784124493598938,
-0.6906420588493347,
0.19497235119342804,
-0.47962453961372375,
-0.33075517416000366,
0.12639892101287842,
-0.6469348669052124,
-0.6742372512817383,
-0.36798790097236633,
0.05110101401805878,
-0.4903107285499573,
-0.4025505483150482,
0.589602530002594,
-0.2668505907058716,
0.4767504930496216,
0.4029070734977722,
-0.9533036947250366,
0.17221172153949738,
0.8966923356056213,
1.1225348711013794,
-0.12998980283737183,
-0.014684886671602726,
-0.40293869376182556,
0.4133056104183197,
-0.5462112426757812,
0.7332865595817566,
-0.636276125907898,
-0.635900616645813,
0.028770189732313156,
-0.055618274956941605,
-0.0027775929775089025,
-0.3216186761856079,
-0.09968919306993484,
-0.6563242673873901,
0.4639666974544525,
0.2361036092042923,
-0.5934311747550964,
0.28915202617645264,
0.186391681432724,
-0.7399620413780212,
0.5249078273773193,
-0.013503344729542732,
-0.675616979598999,
0.2244057059288025,
-0.7814288139343262,
-0.794747531414032,
0.5161982178688049,
-0.19037020206451416,
-0.43999016284942627,
-0.10478568077087402,
-0.2434108406305313,
0.32042500376701355,
0.25396865606307983,
0.1599222719669342,
-0.13985399901866913,
-0.1638382375240326,
0.42034855484962463,
-0.27951911091804504,
0.6414575576782227,
0.28798118233680725,
-0.24188657104969025,
0.20941491425037384,
-1.1238504648208618,
0.19532571732997894,
0.24971291422843933,
-0.820952296257019,
-0.0897560864686966,
-0.083511121571064,
0.30501171946525574,
0.08267077803611755,
0.6549444198608398,
-0.682016909122467,
0.421159029006958,
-0.3309972584247589,
0.3735803961753845,
0.7746118307113647,
-0.058829180896282196,
0.6817906498908997,
-0.6128986477851868,
0.6384159326553345,
-0.8778549432754517,
0.16291846334934235,
-0.24062319099903107,
-0.5827208161354065,
-0.7795990705490112,
-0.6934900283813477,
0.09804828464984894,
0.4663712978363037,
-0.44069987535476685,
0.7635049819946289,
-0.18846583366394043,
-0.42656612396240234,
0.15855775773525238,
0.05679059773683548,
0.3465688228607178,
0.02369992621243,
-0.06715010106563568,
-0.2251969277858734,
-0.8496931791305542,
-0.8993247151374817,
-0.3486384451389313,
0.23057225346565247,
-0.47500285506248474,
0.16995660960674286,
0.044384539127349854,
-0.12637017667293549,
0.9838896989822388,
-0.6795514822006226,
-0.4154894948005676,
-0.6081103682518005,
-0.1461620032787323,
0.34377554059028625,
0.5072591304779053,
0.431365042924881,
-0.740961492061615,
-0.7569412589073181,
0.22163665294647217,
-0.20956535637378693,
-0.30075785517692566,
-0.3550455868244171,
-0.5004408955574036,
0.181197851896286,
0.49361130595207214,
-0.8852436542510986,
0.4365943968296051,
0.6804790496826172,
-0.7120165228843689,
0.41082724928855896,
-0.38732030987739563,
-0.23482565581798553,
-1.5914545059204102,
-0.1979697197675705,
-0.3465542793273926,
-0.3560709059238434,
-0.830600380897522,
0.03917073830962181,
0.08028259873390198,
-0.14350515604019165,
-0.3964889347553253,
0.7282337546348572,
-0.4779679477214813,
0.13414828479290009,
-0.6264049410820007,
-0.24881906807422638,
0.3816753625869751,
0.3992413580417633,
0.0720323920249939,
0.49268466234207153,
0.03688386082649231,
-0.46710026264190674,
0.4103472828865051,
0.3499569296836853,
-0.4393392503261566,
0.18347394466400146,
-0.7194896936416626,
0.15480893850326538,
-0.10259488970041275,
0.5338939428329468,
-1.0912679433822632,
-0.9185190200805664,
0.01724269613623619,
0.08809606730937958,
0.24180461466312408,
-0.29604798555374146,
-0.5938887000083923,
-0.055634066462516785,
0.008390038274228573,
-0.09161892533302307,
0.56553053855896,
-0.7031024694442749,
0.9646894335746765,
0.14891687035560608,
-0.2127348929643631,
0.16640688478946686,
-0.7775515913963318,
0.20467506349086761,
-0.09532545506954193,
-0.9990746974945068,
0.48846474289894104,
-0.5034288167953491,
-0.2590610682964325,
-0.7613380551338196,
0.05894399434328079,
-0.017064085230231285,
0.012713749893009663,
0.5790761113166809,
0.08178038895130157,
-0.2356758564710617,
0.22061853110790253,
-0.11256847530603409,
0.020988324657082558,
-0.31216496229171753,
-0.09922206401824951,
0.9841969609260559,
-0.09005861729383469,
-0.3229994773864746,
-0.1761169135570526,
0.523834764957428,
0.5788620710372925,
-0.40262019634246826,
0.45869579911231995,
0.10081615298986435,
-0.17141056060791016,
-0.5282532572746277,
-0.40740668773651123,
0.10116332769393921,
-0.6879139542579651,
0.33381080627441406,
-0.4304462671279907,
-0.8852479457855225,
0.3935985565185547,
0.04867761582136154,
0.39382031559944153,
-0.2458115816116333,
0.6894755959510803,
0.17527595162391663,
1.1771323680877686,
0.849849283695221,
0.4330463409423828,
0.889995813369751,
0.030106903985142708,
0.3114732503890991,
-0.34614646434783936,
-0.24933120608329773,
-0.24901652336120605,
-0.5561996698379517,
-0.7639444470405579,
-0.4195522964000702,
-0.009098903276026249,
-0.3026293218135834,
-0.6351311802864075,
0.4000430703163147,
-0.6871416568756104,
0.9359700679779053,
0.37217390537261963,
-0.004098961129784584,
0.33775433897972107,
-0.13744507730007172,
0.17452476918697357,
0.24260887503623962,
-0.46159473061561584,
-0.7900210618972778,
0.44340193271636963,
0.26003050804138184,
1.001396656036377,
0.5182191133499146,
0.6583458185195923,
0.134329691529274,
0.318458616733551,
-0.8991783857345581,
0.7505833506584167,
-0.27384427189826965,
-0.5156379342079163,
-0.42289382219314575,
-0.16498486697673798,
-1.1908719539642334,
0.35827162861824036,
0.02959020435810089,
-0.8100816011428833,
-0.07443346083164215,
0.21188244223594666,
-0.15546920895576477,
0.48511117696762085,
-1.0600898265838623,
0.5974622964859009,
-0.2442837655544281,
-0.05227626860141754,
0.23484958708286285,
-0.12416573613882065,
0.27788516879081726,
0.11896747350692749,
0.08306598663330078,
-0.28819960355758667,
-0.06606857478618622,
0.4369595944881439,
-0.4968754053115845,
0.9521190524101257,
0.10981817543506622,
-0.3788057565689087,
0.04005972668528557,
0.8363856673240662,
0.7830553650856018,
0.2680087983608246,
-0.19826042652130127,
-0.25928995013237,
-0.36074042320251465,
-0.4191797077655792,
-0.5733275413513184,
0.670062780380249,
-0.4473901391029358,
-0.6572931408882141,
0.11700320988893509,
-0.7182712554931641,
-0.14515486359596252,
0.5338075160980225,
0.34607648849487305,
0.3036784827709198,
-0.5871046781539917,
0.1293306052684784,
0.5458260774612427,
-0.24067702889442444,
0.7628614902496338,
0.5522041320800781,
-0.5822888016700745,
-0.2439345121383667,
0.8694252371788025,
-0.21254442632198334,
0.010242139920592308,
0.6506010890007019,
0.34657514095306396,
0.29417070746421814,
-0.14650799334049225,
-0.45217540860176086,
-0.03491383418440819,
-0.21815943717956543,
-0.16836215555667877,
-0.3881564736366272,
-0.4035477936267853,
-0.17619875073432922,
-0.5833231806755066,
-0.5963729619979858,
-0.5793997645378113,
-0.038494888693094254,
-0.01846093125641346,
0.5534672141075134,
0.8811733722686768,
0.2669501006603241,
0.5736872553825378,
-0.5263115763664246,
0.3052845597267151,
0.6495596170425415,
0.7067508101463318,
-0.1652977615594864,
-0.35342615842819214,
-0.07430841773748398,
-0.1016068160533905,
-0.3370036482810974,
-0.5960195660591125,
0.5714362859725952,
0.046654343605041504,
0.25250011682510376,
0.42930901050567627,
-0.171251580119133,
0.21540158987045288,
-0.8486841320991516,
0.7574417591094971,
0.477263480424881,
-0.6396698951721191,
0.7010324001312256,
-0.6486765146255493,
0.816006064414978,
-0.20905932784080505,
-0.2590373158454895,
-0.7324458956718445,
-0.640081524848938,
-0.5751610398292542,
-0.7880878448486328,
0.5955530405044556,
0.4124284088611603,
0.4827883243560791,
0.06231484189629555,
0.241022989153862,
0.24955587089061737,
0.003589172847568989,
-0.4462791681289673,
-0.00848140474408865,
-0.6035669445991516,
-0.10479112714529037,
0.12625660002231598,
-0.036731526255607605,
-0.20090438425540924,
0.18193753063678741,
0.450174480676651,
-0.23704051971435547,
0.35685837268829346,
-0.2183769941329956,
0.16038459539413452,
-0.07618923485279083,
0.4571191072463989,
0.9264419674873352,
0.6492421627044678,
-0.24660059809684753,
-0.08287473022937775,
-0.06713826209306717,
-0.5995898246765137,
0.016826819628477097,
0.0307877566665411,
-0.18963147699832916,
0.15613152086734772,
0.4526521563529968,
0.8885159492492676,
-0.1497473120689392,
-0.35621216893196106,
0.35028454661369324,
-0.44540318846702576,
-0.302141398191452,
-0.5610653758049011,
0.519769012928009,
0.2625053822994232,
0.1705111414194107,
0.08671768009662628,
-0.11072184890508652,
-0.25604042410850525,
0.026072505861520767,
0.16853204369544983,
0.3603588044643402,
-0.3025284707546234,
-0.4184238314628601,
0.552436888217926,
0.14732956886291504,
-0.9842604994773865,
0.20451661944389343,
-0.039602261036634445,
0.0864068940281868,
0.7923213839530945,
0.7742865085601807,
0.9995065331459045,
-0.23371589183807373,
0.39968669414520264,
0.14044424891471863,
-0.051944535225629807,
0.15582497417926788,
0.24773363769054413,
0.03744028881192207,
-0.6696303486824036,
-0.4428965747356415,
-0.7082934379577637,
-0.3807602822780609,
0.37761253118515015,
-0.20170079171657562,
0.2787514626979828,
-1.003656268119812,
0.01544016133993864,
-0.09760762751102448,
-0.309498131275177,
-0.4310953915119171,
0.03983521834015846,
0.053381625562906265,
1.1349115371704102,
-0.26286160945892334,
0.7444883584976196,
0.9903153777122498,
-0.04555635526776314,
-0.8743177652359009,
0.014601710252463818,
0.06325379014015198,
-0.662102222442627,
0.2745405435562134,
0.2398681342601776,
0.0004214136570226401,
-0.3590543866157532,
-0.6957213878631592,
-0.8754094243049622,
1.11833918094635,
0.363226056098938,
-0.637977123260498,
-0.1855277419090271,
0.24966569244861603,
0.5787104964256287,
-0.5775191783905029,
0.04234812781214714,
0.47500911355018616,
0.4947558343410492,
0.2590588927268982,
-0.7663156986236572,
0.1772426813840866,
-0.5223522186279297,
0.38194453716278076,
0.5538305044174194,
-1.1666207313537598,
0.675656259059906,
0.22906288504600525,
-0.09569592773914337,
0.42099541425704956,
0.40479886531829834,
0.4004824757575989,
-0.16433337330818176,
0.3657952845096588,
0.12573635578155518,
0.8113779425621033,
0.14208732545375824,
0.920561671257019,
-0.3831328749656677,
-0.09260091185569763,
1.3525581359863281,
-0.2832008898258209,
0.5524249076843262,
0.3681662082672119,
0.07895661145448685,
0.7701702117919922,
0.24696315824985504,
0.2170991450548172,
0.45552289485931396,
0.514534592628479,
-0.3306390643119812,
-0.5344420075416565,
0.14114999771118164,
-0.11833375692367554,
0.5606064200401306,
0.4052371084690094,
-0.2419005036354065,
-0.2189856469631195,
-0.14061059057712555,
0.03226255998015404,
0.1608993262052536,
-0.1303934007883072,
0.8491728901863098,
0.11154167354106903,
-0.4055923819541931,
0.4036741554737091,
0.23230652511119843,
0.6711922883987427,
-0.7683214545249939,
-0.1353372037410736,
-0.6186221241950989,
0.3251584768295288,
-0.24468320608139038,
-0.6529353857040405,
0.17778421938419342,
-0.12817692756652832,
-0.15663932263851166,
-0.5852696299552917,
0.903053879737854,
-0.0768282413482666,
-0.5122417211532593,
0.03578703850507736,
0.34195345640182495,
-0.22049178183078766,
0.1797141283750534,
-0.36304333806037903,
-0.0007263114675879478,
0.09929027408361435,
-0.5009073615074158,
0.3845783472061157,
0.659251868724823,
0.044099852442741394,
0.8704448342323303,
0.5848068594932556,
0.0871790200471878,
0.2609477639198303,
0.2450043112039566,
0.7530718445777893,
-0.5467262864112854,
-0.8442497849464417,
-0.5972205400466919,
0.527195394039154,
-0.24738849699497223,
-0.2114047408103943,
0.5811200737953186,
0.5516510009765625,
0.45358410477638245,
-0.2571897804737091,
0.770709753036499,
-0.1915549337863922,
0.29702264070510864,
-0.48571768403053284,
0.9411596059799194,
-0.315304696559906,
0.2683408856391907,
-0.1328246146440506,
-0.7947725057601929,
-0.592309832572937,
0.6011773943901062,
-0.21139419078826904,
-0.0008983578300103545,
0.20714202523231506,
1.22500479221344,
-0.45198822021484375,
0.29006722569465637,
0.48910343647003174,
0.00539455795660615,
0.7829785943031311,
0.4489349126815796,
0.8159766793251038,
0.0031070064287632704,
0.8377937078475952,
-0.20104476809501648,
-0.34996497631073,
-0.35899925231933594,
-0.9017757177352905,
-0.997277021408081,
-0.517698347568512,
-0.24784250557422638,
-0.32636910676956177,
-0.18921169638633728,
0.8069934248924255,
0.9148063659667969,
-0.7435383796691895,
-0.408888041973114,
-0.5139796733856201,
0.2709794342517853,
0.2076994925737381,
-0.34081631898880005,
0.21648579835891724,
-0.14895017445087433,
-0.5315515995025635,
0.4877154231071472,
0.4415481388568878,
0.32821932435035706,
-0.047885503619909286,
-0.3265737295150757,
0.26327967643737793,
0.43071505427360535,
0.706809937953949,
0.32733985781669617,
-0.5493596792221069,
-0.2757856249809265,
0.05056570842862129,
-0.4528803825378418,
0.17434582114219666,
1.0240046977996826,
-0.4052888751029968,
0.2671177089214325,
0.5980318784713745,
0.4108535945415497,
0.24554619193077087,
-0.2540567219257355,
0.7463321089744568,
-1.1285051107406616,
0.2986069321632385,
-0.057991039007902145,
0.4892439544200897,
0.22060908377170563,
-0.4322144687175751,
0.1588415652513504,
-0.27480828762054443,
-0.466376394033432,
-0.2533220052719116,
0.794955849647522,
-0.901313841342926,
-0.5920835733413696,
1.4230197668075562,
0.22933971881866455,
-0.35665032267570496,
-0.058295197784900665,
-0.649871826171875,
0.07929912209510803,
-0.5069242715835571,
0.9463386535644531,
0.4306377172470093,
-0.3895477056503296,
-0.0905238687992096,
-0.11816418170928955,
0.44925597310066223,
0.22188135981559753,
-0.6780673861503601,
0.17918048799037933,
0.5591894388198853,
0.23404142260551453,
0.4412917494773865,
0.6316512227058411,
0.14382266998291016,
0.3994603753089905,
-0.18860341608524323,
0.365867555141449,
-0.2684796452522278,
-0.008332408964633942,
0.15259794890880585,
0.14180903136730194,
0.1328568011522293,
-0.04880259931087494
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10088v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10088v1
|
Intent-conditioned and Non-toxic Counterspeech Generation using Multi-Task Instruction Tuning with RLAIF
| 2024-03-15T08:03:49 | 2024-03-15T08:03:49 |
Amey Hengle, Aswini Kumar, Sahajpreet Singh, Anil Bandhakavi, Md Shad Akhtar, Tanmoy Chakroborty
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Counterspeech, defined as a response to mitigate online hate speech, is
increasingly used as a non-censorial solution. Addressing hate speech
effectively involves dispelling the stereotypes, prejudices, and biases often
subtly implied in brief, single-sentence statements or abuses. These implicit
expressions challenge language models, especially in seq2seq tasks, as model
performance typically excels with longer contexts. Our study introduces CoARL,
a novel framework enhancing counterspeech generation by modeling the pragmatic
implications underlying social biases in hateful statements. CoARL's first two
phases involve sequential multi-instruction tuning, teaching the model to
understand intents, reactions, and harms of offensive statements, and then
learning task-specific low-rank adapter weights for generating
intent-conditioned counterspeech. The final phase uses reinforcement learning
to fine-tune outputs for effectiveness and non-toxicity. CoARL outperforms
existing benchmarks in intent-conditioned counterspeech generation, showing an
average improvement of 3 points in intent-conformity and 4 points in
argument-quality metrics. Extensive human evaluation supports CoARL's efficacy
in generating superior and more context-appropriate responses compared to
existing systems, including prominent LLMs like ChatGPT.
|
[
-0.4247705042362213,
-1.0772171020507812,
0.05332892760634422,
0.2670809328556061,
-0.27212002873420715,
-0.01192941889166832,
-0.17563967406749725,
-0.1638563722372055,
-0.09440437704324722,
0.5259141325950623,
-0.7708341479301453,
-0.21928372979164124,
-0.6044988632202148,
-0.042432934045791626,
-0.22220121324062347,
1.4849941730499268,
0.3164103031158447,
0.20182400941848755,
-0.06376282125711441,
-0.1723397970199585,
-0.4693301022052765,
-0.5653329491615295,
-0.7444356083869934,
-0.2670210301876068,
0.5326908826828003,
0.7408707737922668,
0.3783795237541199,
0.2431543469429016,
0.2529732584953308,
0.19887326657772064,
0.2807846665382385,
0.3475152850151062,
-0.8653506636619568,
0.5031221508979797,
-0.17376801371574402,
0.006333246361464262,
-0.16632330417633057,
0.0022597527131438255,
0.29370465874671936,
0.09426870197057724,
-0.3297921419143677,
0.28201019763946533,
0.08216218650341034,
0.48530277609825134,
-0.8312565684318542,
-0.2263728678226471,
-0.776519775390625,
-0.007562614977359772,
-0.27875062823295593,
-0.16824810206890106,
-0.920240581035614,
-0.12722885608673096,
-0.24624982476234436,
-0.6097941398620605,
0.3311888873577118,
0.14734017848968506,
0.2784629464149475,
0.4440864324569702,
-0.5382821559906006,
-0.394202321767807,
-0.4558767080307007,
0.9967188239097595,
-0.7173406481742859,
0.4949927031993866,
0.23208823800086975,
0.051427729427814484,
-0.30119138956069946,
-0.5492179989814758,
-0.5009718537330627,
-0.24216043949127197,
-0.03958864510059357,
0.3004724383354187,
0.012999290600419044,
0.12988491356372833,
0.4568403363227844,
-0.1955895572900772,
-0.560289204120636,
0.0927729457616806,
-0.303422212600708,
-0.3099144697189331,
0.6529355049133301,
0.2592848241329193,
-0.022120554000139236,
-0.046932999044656754,
-0.578340470790863,
-0.00016221853729803115,
-0.5166364908218384,
0.03752841427922249,
0.4233018755912781,
0.3618023097515106,
-0.13543447852134705,
0.3094404339790344,
-0.19998995959758759,
0.8062238693237305,
0.4669613838195801,
-0.12287532538175583,
-0.17597028613090515,
0.09196224808692932,
-0.015316333621740341,
0.3144635260105133,
0.7109752297401428,
0.39218634366989136,
0.37717288732528687,
0.1533510386943817,
0.24530456960201263,
0.3818013668060303,
0.755256175994873,
-1.016081690788269,
-0.3520396947860718,
0.10345175862312317,
-0.16651444137096405,
-0.5565518140792847,
-0.2928830087184906,
-0.9899822473526001,
-0.44811177253723145,
-0.07640321552753448,
0.16114075481891632,
-0.36802396178245544,
-0.1143750250339508,
-0.40721479058265686,
-0.21748319268226624,
-0.014625622890889645,
0.15326373279094696,
-0.6099101901054382,
0.5390008687973022,
0.46152523159980774,
0.568795382976532,
-0.5023413300514221,
-0.19721774756908417,
-1.0500777959823608,
0.17403854429721832,
-0.4472685754299164,
0.7511608600616455,
-0.6424684524536133,
-0.5085840821266174,
-0.06723390519618988,
-0.36783912777900696,
0.07591501623392105,
-0.4796935021877289,
0.6586078405380249,
-0.639131486415863,
0.08632352948188782,
-0.12594924867153168,
-0.32886236906051636,
0.05490804463624954,
0.11901015788316727,
-0.4820254147052765,
1.1169579029083252,
0.001162914908491075,
-0.7907000780105591,
0.3188769519329071,
-0.6799522638320923,
-0.9421395659446716,
0.1626882702112198,
-0.058712437748909,
-0.6950435638427734,
0.10561788827180862,
-0.039623089134693146,
0.10982156544923782,
-0.16170565783977509,
0.17730920016765594,
-0.17466381192207336,
-0.14336061477661133,
0.3241969347000122,
-0.35623255372047424,
0.5775226354598999,
0.34417280554771423,
-0.6720629930496216,
0.40634623169898987,
-0.38946935534477234,
0.20058470964431763,
0.08639774471521378,
-0.09077731519937515,
-0.2742164134979248,
0.08886027336120605,
0.06994327157735825,
0.3468555510044098,
-0.08382774144411087,
-0.6119534969329834,
-0.43648386001586914,
-0.1636056900024414,
0.18479450047016144,
0.9258163571357727,
0.15672160685062408,
0.14401358366012573,
-0.3954535722732544,
0.4523448646068573,
0.09551341086626053,
0.3243613839149475,
0.15423035621643066,
-0.5837473273277283,
-0.6703115701675415,
-0.09099689871072769,
-0.35348886251449585,
0.48724520206451416,
-0.7683159112930298,
-0.2205697000026703,
0.2303859293460846,
-0.4379032552242279,
-0.22271370887756348,
-0.062316007912158966,
0.9601634740829468,
0.9604837894439697,
0.5836844444274902,
-0.36688709259033203,
-0.7525482773780823,
-0.7395258545875549,
-0.5356774926185608,
-0.011706361547112465,
0.4454565942287445,
0.4103388786315918,
0.28085240721702576,
0.35889336466789246,
0.76496422290802,
-0.4795719385147095,
-0.06106500327587128,
-0.27108296751976013,
0.5438094139099121,
-0.2792845368385315,
0.21445682644844055,
0.2265683114528656,
-0.9083632826805115,
-0.9320343732833862,
-0.4205209016799927,
-0.2752603590488434,
-0.34360986948013306,
-0.019408835098147392,
-0.07723801583051682,
0.4603602886199951,
0.45548298954963684,
-0.10013676434755325,
0.45690324902534485,
0.48709192872047424,
-0.2569156289100647,
0.8567636013031006,
0.233049213886261,
0.4361734092235565,
-0.7236095666885376,
-0.11898496001958847,
-0.28266364336013794,
-0.17205804586410522,
-0.985982358455658,
0.025567801669239998,
-0.16119948029518127,
-0.291890949010849,
-0.8879489898681641,
0.5868160724639893,
-0.021927490830421448,
0.2707171142101288,
-0.39973604679107666,
0.004056878853589296,
-0.13886547088623047,
0.5543822050094604,
0.24389328062534332,
0.9231584072113037,
0.027827076613903046,
-0.8430804014205933,
0.0571136400103569,
0.2773233652114868,
-0.1768975406885147,
0.9631243348121643,
-0.4122488498687744,
0.38460099697113037,
-0.044007912278175354,
0.44933637976646423,
-0.7565832734107971,
-0.07654324173927307,
0.28288981318473816,
-0.466621458530426,
-0.0052250768058001995,
-0.07772671431303024,
0.10309302061796188,
-0.2680078446865082,
-0.18272851407527924,
0.557263970375061,
0.4060734212398529,
-0.3814079165458679,
0.4880099892616272,
0.3911222815513611,
-0.15037836134433746,
-0.9451257586479187,
-0.5880769491195679,
-0.13692118227481842,
-0.18820543587207794,
-0.2261752188205719,
0.2468724101781845,
-0.33064475655555725,
-0.2562744915485382,
-0.30729275941848755,
-0.11682689934968948,
0.004316133446991444,
-0.07215946167707443,
0.4033590853214264,
-0.0632234662771225,
0.17393340170383453,
0.04799099266529083,
0.10021066665649414,
0.0024356755893677473,
0.18097692728042603,
-0.13804392516613007,
0.5574926733970642,
0.16747437417507172,
-0.20029523968696594,
-0.047255512326955795,
0.5776671171188354,
0.28583481907844543,
-0.1823957860469818,
0.6264097094535828,
0.7393144965171814,
0.09108015149831772,
-0.6735857725143433,
-0.440946102142334,
-0.37943434715270996,
-0.44557708501815796,
0.40628549456596375,
-0.26568758487701416,
-1.125762701034546,
0.09381332993507385,
-0.0019273714860901237,
0.2949174642562866,
0.15282726287841797,
0.7323353886604309,
0.0659155622124672,
0.8967236876487732,
0.1414707750082016,
0.4446607828140259,
0.5063828825950623,
0.32213300466537476,
0.3092254400253296,
-0.7330184578895569,
-0.07013537734746933,
-0.36694854497909546,
-0.1715840995311737,
-0.44623038172721863,
-0.571984589099884,
0.45822158455848694,
-0.2800584137439728,
-0.6722113490104675,
0.059075020253658295,
-0.5857880115509033,
0.35284629464149475,
0.4481721520423889,
0.19196513295173645,
0.024887943640351295,
0.04545922204852104,
-0.28203198313713074,
-0.3387071490287781,
-0.7348052263259888,
0.0055329096503555775,
0.898658037185669,
-0.0966244637966156,
0.620947539806366,
0.27380460500717163,
0.6029244065284729,
0.5862612724304199,
0.655692994594574,
-0.6616382002830505,
0.6060687899589539,
-0.3914187252521515,
-0.874980092048645,
-0.22093333303928375,
-0.46749433875083923,
-0.6135687828063965,
0.1787959337234497,
-0.22907938063144684,
-0.4799979329109192,
-0.12935569882392883,
0.5593010783195496,
-0.3726651072502136,
0.13496197760105133,
-0.5896044969558716,
0.7736093401908875,
-0.3728463649749756,
-0.9376760721206665,
-0.5690067410469055,
-0.5764063000679016,
0.61042320728302,
-0.045639462769031525,
0.5477986931800842,
-0.04391975328326225,
0.13699954748153687,
0.8426646590232849,
-0.1700146198272705,
0.9999423623085022,
-0.4765501618385315,
0.010858401656150818,
0.40905269980430603,
0.32331764698028564,
0.6333410739898682,
-0.2479148954153061,
-0.2195405215024948,
0.030418403446674347,
-0.317634642124176,
-0.2175484001636505,
-0.388379842042923,
0.6853015422821045,
-0.4940092861652374,
-0.5544350147247314,
-0.28487932682037354,
-0.734388530254364,
-0.40849193930625916,
0.29954567551612854,
0.3271135985851288,
0.2945600748062134,
-0.6001594662666321,
-0.031385328620672226,
0.8554718494415283,
-0.380248099565506,
0.0703284963965416,
0.7914252877235413,
-0.04314624145627022,
-0.44992291927337646,
1.046040654182434,
-0.1449870765209198,
0.5469381809234619,
0.1961928755044937,
0.46197351813316345,
-0.31837964057922363,
-0.06341122835874557,
-0.3154957890510559,
-0.16995428502559662,
-0.549814760684967,
-0.38069334626197815,
-0.7207643389701843,
-0.11457256972789764,
-0.6509666442871094,
-0.2740617096424103,
-0.33750876784324646,
-0.3249939978122711,
0.01883981190621853,
0.08031615614891052,
0.46794506907463074,
0.8896855115890503,
-0.4143093228340149,
0.5698612332344055,
-0.2329321652650833,
0.8192206621170044,
0.3705187141895294,
0.26212114095687866,
0.07921098172664642,
-0.7170882225036621,
-0.14626245200634003,
0.09676019847393036,
-0.339798241853714,
-1.0667036771774292,
0.2880581319332123,
0.2661488950252533,
0.3819330930709839,
0.11370282620191574,
0.5263636112213135,
0.7972307801246643,
-0.7535613179206848,
0.6780096888542175,
0.19077277183532715,
-0.6444687247276306,
0.526843786239624,
-0.21504735946655273,
0.22518391907215118,
0.42058831453323364,
0.3778914511203766,
-0.7025761008262634,
-0.47707027196884155,
-0.6526263356208801,
-0.8004209399223328,
0.7408338785171509,
-0.09214552491903305,
0.06778435409069061,
-0.42477038502693176,
-0.041021909564733505,
0.038154974579811096,
0.2254059761762619,
-0.539244532585144,
-0.3749496340751648,
-0.6724722981452942,
-0.22053244709968567,
0.09056738764047623,
-0.347282350063324,
-0.3771011233329773,
0.0357360914349556,
0.9178755283355713,
0.000058935700508300215,
0.11390484869480133,
-0.026692690327763557,
-0.41531872749328613,
-0.1687236726284027,
0.423082560300827,
0.9789495468139648,
0.17938105762004852,
0.12623029947280884,
0.28187963366508484,
0.3757671117782593,
-0.5984101891517639,
0.105209119617939,
-0.2392367422580719,
-0.13484123349189758,
-0.2554556727409363,
0.04130268841981888,
0.7847756743431091,
0.4322313964366913,
-0.4471510648727417,
0.43199869990348816,
-0.09800975769758224,
-0.1507440060377121,
-0.31582701206207275,
0.2591686248779297,
-0.04588119685649872,
-0.06491772085428238,
0.20046034455299377,
-0.025168824940919876,
0.043392907828092575,
-0.06874680519104004,
0.789723813533783,
0.5834737420082092,
-0.4775257706642151,
0.13057227432727814,
0.6929405927658081,
0.2980242073535919,
-0.39084330201148987,
0.537651538848877,
-0.3187883198261261,
-0.5854684114456177,
0.4715077877044678,
0.9621558785438538,
0.5815281271934509,
-0.4846460819244385,
0.5201691389083862,
0.6345607042312622,
0.21419844031333923,
0.37844836711883545,
0.1979246586561203,
-0.1786334216594696,
-0.6588807702064514,
-0.3505868911743164,
-0.7138051986694336,
-0.43031734228134155,
0.090538889169693,
-0.5862619876861572,
-0.012195419520139694,
-0.7128694653511047,
-0.12373226135969162,
-0.2110222578048706,
-0.21223360300064087,
-0.41474393010139465,
0.17819197475910187,
-0.04121459275484085,
0.542233407497406,
-1.0138144493103027,
0.4842860698699951,
0.47418296337127686,
-0.18708758056163788,
-0.6658596396446228,
-0.007268049754202366,
0.5006361603736877,
-1.015352487564087,
0.7631143927574158,
0.013255155645310879,
-0.6211971640586853,
0.32734039425849915,
-0.6058549284934998,
-0.45229092240333557,
0.46315979957580566,
0.00041198814869858325,
-0.4848925471305847,
0.44814544916152954,
0.3462410271167755,
0.40808746218681335,
-0.41897374391555786,
0.29445910453796387,
0.25391024351119995,
0.4183870255947113,
0.12964731454849243,
-0.4607164263725281,
0.24592214822769165,
-0.023572148755192757,
-0.2337258905172348,
0.15423712134361267,
-0.7923205494880676,
0.6742529273033142,
-0.32173222303390503,
-0.336503267288208,
-0.24543367326259613,
0.5611898899078369,
0.4573914706707001,
0.05260999873280525,
0.5180515050888062,
0.6980336308479309,
0.35240137577056885,
0.17523108422756195,
0.7244635224342346,
-0.2670655846595764,
-0.08713450282812119,
1.5613206624984741,
-0.3379334509372711,
0.7456522583961487,
0.36729657649993896,
0.09902580827474594,
0.7475915551185608,
0.07779346406459808,
0.30504274368286133,
0.4301634430885315,
0.34990930557250977,
-0.6077335476875305,
-0.32265523076057434,
-0.6277002096176147,
-0.07723292708396912,
0.39204666018486023,
0.6181992888450623,
0.09284203499555588,
-0.2982102632522583,
0.11122213304042816,
0.10980132222175598,
0.3806156516075134,
-0.15354765951633453,
0.8888992667198181,
0.04896491765975952,
-0.9008322954177856,
0.5235105752944946,
-0.09887966513633728,
0.7233386635780334,
-0.6214569211006165,
-0.19990427792072296,
-0.06338972598314285,
0.18389758467674255,
-0.26630163192749023,
-0.6100510358810425,
0.3523401618003845,
0.18127381801605225,
-0.1974971443414688,
-0.34218648076057434,
0.8139815330505371,
-0.345174103975296,
-0.23180079460144043,
0.21131856739521027,
0.07279837131500244,
0.027121471241116524,
0.12150818109512329,
-0.9270885586738586,
0.17270874977111816,
0.013795360922813416,
-0.09275759011507034,
0.35622501373291016,
0.20567689836025238,
-0.1980227679014206,
0.3900044560432434,
0.6932782530784607,
-0.0035886254627257586,
0.21157503128051758,
0.3008835017681122,
0.5358759760856628,
-0.3899456560611725,
-0.3858756124973297,
-0.5608482360839844,
0.6929156184196472,
-0.1466951221227646,
-0.333427757024765,
0.6191591620445251,
0.4838322699069977,
0.8087977766990662,
-0.022767391055822372,
0.8126276135444641,
-0.2875629961490631,
0.8352640867233276,
-0.13497671484947205,
0.493750661611557,
-0.28281262516975403,
-0.39922142028808594,
-0.24800129234790802,
-0.36488938331604004,
-0.10485734045505524,
0.5759890675544739,
-0.3726290166378021,
0.06752609461545944,
0.7920475602149963,
1.003756046295166,
0.07743917405605316,
-0.08456970006227493,
0.3412129878997803,
0.18047064542770386,
0.2920810580253601,
0.49035507440567017,
0.6833309531211853,
-0.29355716705322266,
0.6450579762458801,
-0.29260316491127014,
-0.35609033703804016,
-0.05253532901406288,
-0.8405017852783203,
-0.7142793536186218,
-0.5015774965286255,
-0.12671416997909546,
-0.34222984313964844,
0.4506506025791168,
0.5555495619773865,
0.5917164087295532,
-0.8972893357276917,
-0.283032089471817,
0.00793804693967104,
0.14114704728126526,
-0.40401580929756165,
-0.3102450370788574,
-0.08529044687747955,
-0.6148164868354797,
-0.4053622782230377,
0.47403737902641296,
0.06800346821546555,
-0.524569571018219,
0.03933284431695938,
-0.33237147331237793,
-0.5088273882865906,
0.2693493664264679,
0.8616986870765686,
0.360403448343277,
-0.6185557842254639,
-0.3301837146282196,
-0.05083319544792175,
-0.07120107859373093,
-0.11470125615596771,
1.076166033744812,
-0.6595441102981567,
0.3473547399044037,
0.20673097670078278,
0.4030008912086487,
0.47975048422813416,
0.23245757818222046,
0.3927740156650543,
-1.074639916419983,
0.22783097624778748,
0.36420291662216187,
-0.24881871044635773,
0.12156170606613159,
-0.37359166145324707,
0.18149717152118683,
0.08908569812774658,
-0.5869535803794861,
-0.6469632387161255,
0.8968319296836853,
-0.7514928579330444,
-0.47453707456588745,
1.1011115312576294,
0.12936364114284515,
-0.0497363917529583,
-0.4013611376285553,
-0.19312728941440582,
0.6501878499984741,
-0.6070214509963989,
0.7177819013595581,
0.4087071716785431,
-0.5362855195999146,
-0.3662498891353607,
-0.4600093960762024,
0.7926580309867859,
0.6967065334320068,
-0.750779390335083,
0.40884312987327576,
0.7615987062454224,
0.2586500346660614,
-0.031497772783041,
0.6523684859275818,
-0.05322184041142464,
0.5020579099655151,
0.07755780220031738,
0.09769578278064728,
-0.22863620519638062,
-0.3656390905380249,
0.21473009884357452,
0.1275809109210968,
0.018841754645109177,
0.15832823514938354
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10081v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10081v2
|
DRAGIN: Dynamic Retrieval Augmented Generation based on the Information Needs of Large Language Models
| 2024-03-15T07:45:37 | 2024-06-05T18:44:59 |
Weihang Su, Yichen Tang, Qingyao Ai, Zhijing Wu, Yiqun Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Dynamic retrieval augmented generation (RAG) paradigm actively decides when
and what to retrieve during the text generation process of Large Language
Models (LLMs). There are two key elements of this paradigm: identifying the
optimal moment to activate the retrieval module (deciding when to retrieve) and
crafting the appropriate query once retrieval is triggered (determining what to
retrieve). However, current dynamic RAG methods fall short in both aspects.
Firstly, the strategies for deciding when to retrieve often rely on static
rules. Moreover, the strategies for deciding what to retrieve typically limit
themselves to the LLM's most recent sentence or the last few tokens, while the
LLM's real-time information needs may span across the entire context. To
overcome these limitations, we introduce a new framework, DRAGIN, i.e., Dynamic
Retrieval Augmented Generation based on the real-time Information Needs of
LLMs. Our framework is specifically designed to make decisions on when and what
to retrieve based on the LLM's real-time information needs during the text
generation process. We evaluate DRAGIN along with existing methods
comprehensively over 4 knowledge-intensive generation datasets. Experimental
results show that DRAGIN achieves superior performance on all tasks,
demonstrating the effectiveness of our method. We have open-sourced all the
code, data, and models in GitHub: https://github.com/oneal2000/DRAGIN/tree/main
|
[
-0.2654978036880493,
-0.8958879709243774,
0.5015637874603271,
0.20350119471549988,
-0.22056496143341064,
0.4484238624572754,
-0.1399935930967331,
-0.68207186460495,
0.5754603147506714,
0.28676044940948486,
-0.7297197580337524,
-0.14375270903110504,
-0.4242505729198456,
-0.06262410432100296,
-0.7379885911941528,
0.8385083675384521,
0.025780990719795227,
-0.34945714473724365,
-0.24797455966472626,
0.04733261093497276,
-0.28270310163497925,
-0.37428975105285645,
-0.6398964524269104,
-0.14877218008041382,
0.9670425057411194,
0.4169869124889374,
0.6162882447242737,
0.9719074368476868,
0.5778685212135315,
0.22354592382907867,
-0.4034561216831207,
0.3052937984466553,
-0.758274257183075,
0.6375218629837036,
0.04412277042865753,
-0.25535571575164795,
-0.25453755259513855,
-0.1371411383152008,
0.6764940023422241,
0.3288443982601166,
-0.1858474761247635,
0.4157896041870117,
-0.15974105894565582,
0.6798245906829834,
-1.0632660388946533,
-0.2754007875919342,
-0.688658595085144,
0.298787921667099,
-0.5547734498977661,
-0.45311325788497925,
-0.13464295864105225,
-0.42686980962753296,
0.1129656434059143,
-0.5841801762580872,
0.12134071439504623,
0.03730352967977524,
0.929997444152832,
0.13254430890083313,
-0.47465139627456665,
-0.4961044192314148,
-0.825600266456604,
0.6791186332702637,
-0.4840486943721771,
0.45171621441841125,
0.29380595684051514,
0.22895798087120056,
-0.17113851010799408,
-0.9323763251304626,
-0.5322508811950684,
-0.48821669816970825,
-0.0527397096157074,
0.1101289764046669,
0.21239617466926575,
-0.27157822251319885,
0.3167334496974945,
0.304751992225647,
-0.2602679431438446,
0.10634692013263702,
-0.10666029155254364,
0.054725781083106995,
0.5059013366699219,
0.13685525953769684,
0.16731467843055725,
-0.3888673484325409,
-0.468759685754776,
0.00883319042623043,
-0.7380183339118958,
-0.09971467405557632,
0.5213741660118103,
0.358143150806427,
-0.055611059069633484,
0.4384191334247589,
-0.18221057951450348,
0.6271114349365234,
0.5715911984443665,
-0.15820209681987762,
0.14559943974018097,
-0.4338397681713104,
0.23451274633407593,
0.05216987431049347,
0.6910542845726013,
-0.16017481684684753,
-0.10841993242502213,
-0.002120422199368477,
-0.5323576927185059,
-0.777428150177002,
0.5172463655471802,
-0.9285510182380676,
0.11780863255262375,
0.15237708389759064,
-0.43910592794418335,
-0.8779768943786621,
0.04059326648712158,
-0.8375773429870605,
-0.6652383208274841,
-0.4241686463356018,
0.3236386775970459,
-0.24671585857868195,
-0.4616541266441345,
-0.37723734974861145,
0.20535849034786224,
0.09244122356176376,
0.23598122596740723,
-0.6512090563774109,
-0.02936001494526863,
0.6942468285560608,
0.9268986582756042,
-0.5725836157798767,
-0.0592205636203289,
-1.0700488090515137,
0.14153257012367249,
-0.32512104511260986,
0.8633533716201782,
-0.7504377961158752,
-0.2822776138782501,
0.22570207715034485,
-0.30783721804618835,
0.10458123683929443,
-0.5522730946540833,
0.5089823603630066,
-0.8034058809280396,
0.15902182459831238,
-0.27267685532569885,
-0.4240249991416931,
0.10949154198169708,
0.10636832565069199,
-0.7941204905509949,
1.2447052001953125,
-0.05720624327659607,
-0.8760117292404175,
0.2779613435268402,
-0.507781982421875,
-0.5287613272666931,
0.3917720317840576,
-0.2848491072654724,
-0.45584604144096375,
0.21086980402469635,
-0.23905599117279053,
0.46131226420402527,
-0.42708441615104675,
0.5099600553512573,
-0.21751630306243896,
-0.1562417447566986,
0.21411147713661194,
-0.27048811316490173,
0.5246943235397339,
0.5185742974281311,
-0.18165649473667145,
0.07944376021623611,
-1.071171522140503,
-0.014914003200829029,
0.14740662276744843,
-0.6906964182853699,
-0.4156828820705414,
0.3346305191516876,
0.06261846423149109,
0.15994511544704437,
0.40715891122817993,
-0.39832183718681335,
0.12680374085903168,
-0.3007310926914215,
-0.07673816382884979,
0.6537066102027893,
0.03285226225852966,
0.5231214165687561,
-0.14074508845806122,
0.6236845254898071,
-0.1759682595729828,
0.11480049043893814,
-0.08186537772417068,
0.013454548083245754,
-0.6922321915626526,
-0.07548348605632782,
0.492817223072052,
0.7110588550567627,
-0.91059809923172,
0.3655250072479248,
-0.1770765483379364,
-0.47210070490837097,
-0.15640032291412354,
-0.0022757970727980137,
0.2300833761692047,
0.3900361657142639,
0.05175331234931946,
-0.08716215193271637,
-0.6296083927154541,
-0.5852479934692383,
-0.27727389335632324,
-0.1828247308731079,
0.10327106714248657,
0.3817198574542999,
0.23996998369693756,
-0.09745898842811584,
0.821317732334137,
-0.5306862592697144,
0.07557816803455353,
-0.465576171875,
0.29024791717529297,
0.16313426196575165,
0.25625813007354736,
0.6759822964668274,
-1.0160093307495117,
-0.4558548331260681,
-0.030002355575561523,
-0.5980655550956726,
-0.4540897011756897,
-0.34274330735206604,
-0.44667306542396545,
0.06836849451065063,
0.36017489433288574,
-0.6472689509391785,
0.5352553725242615,
0.524372398853302,
-0.36729422211647034,
0.7904974222183228,
-0.1349797397851944,
0.17949636280536652,
-1.1993998289108276,
0.28659942746162415,
-0.30120763182640076,
-0.3685954809188843,
-0.797871470451355,
0.15511472523212433,
0.05918149650096893,
-0.08246900141239166,
-0.4182876646518707,
0.8354554176330566,
-0.5501232147216797,
0.15279620885849,
-0.47552746534347534,
0.39933380484580994,
-0.1309056431055069,
0.1437113881111145,
-0.24909548461437225,
0.7371861934661865,
0.35166457295417786,
-0.9012656807899475,
0.778878390789032,
0.004501031246036291,
-0.44086676836013794,
0.38006293773651123,
-0.3494821786880493,
0.003565469989553094,
-0.2242421805858612,
0.0714481845498085,
-0.4068089723587036,
-0.29325011372566223,
0.17024213075637817,
-0.30010899901390076,
0.4821258783340454,
-0.14926497638225555,
-0.4778152108192444,
-0.3345855176448822,
-0.23350167274475098,
0.33009231090545654,
0.2893994450569153,
-0.6697719693183899,
0.9258451461791992,
0.5720968246459961,
-0.2686014771461487,
-0.8719704747200012,
-0.3279575705528259,
0.09622130542993546,
-0.10295942425727844,
-0.21079637110233307,
0.2754344642162323,
-0.20640850067138672,
-0.332385778427124,
-0.11112049967050552,
-0.2078995257616043,
-0.06106267496943474,
0.13283845782279968,
0.15028788149356842,
0.13072524964809418,
0.10028886049985886,
0.13170036673545837,
0.1007697731256485,
-0.18243886530399323,
-0.2785155773162842,
-0.2880420982837677,
0.4433341920375824,
0.6390125155448914,
-0.311180055141449,
-0.23547935485839844,
0.2845308482646942,
0.5685341954231262,
-0.4365922808647156,
0.7482814192771912,
0.7657018899917603,
-0.12006580829620361,
-0.2962183952331543,
-0.753189206123352,
-0.18884094059467316,
-0.45640766620635986,
0.3843999207019806,
-0.39811182022094727,
-0.8518266081809998,
0.5256747603416443,
-0.29416966438293457,
0.19160142540931702,
0.21008619666099548,
0.6792352795600891,
-0.07124859094619751,
0.7592133283615112,
0.8018642067909241,
-0.0662878230214119,
0.9589885473251343,
-0.10136081278324127,
0.20699472725391388,
-0.49324169754981995,
-0.3339948058128357,
-0.45898669958114624,
-0.4761993885040283,
-0.4669303894042969,
-0.3477681577205658,
0.34688693284988403,
0.1743205040693283,
0.033806927502155304,
0.13751322031021118,
-0.35578325390815735,
0.3212601840496063,
0.6035088896751404,
-0.1702369600534439,
0.17009907960891724,
0.2529667317867279,
-0.42380857467651367,
0.08639247715473175,
-0.6389832496643066,
-0.17721177637577057,
0.6884212493896484,
0.08526896685361862,
0.804060161113739,
0.1562119573354721,
0.43620797991752625,
0.3872005045413971,
0.030972132459282875,
-0.7606112360954285,
0.8268189430236816,
-0.18234199285507202,
-0.576268196105957,
-0.03570958971977234,
-0.6897820830345154,
-1.1803067922592163,
0.115238718688488,
-0.6287747621536255,
-0.36373013257980347,
0.23424707353115082,
0.22913476824760437,
-0.30104365944862366,
0.49165797233581543,
-0.2308063954114914,
0.40867170691490173,
-0.45815229415893555,
-0.6674051880836487,
-0.40121227502822876,
-0.6558712720870972,
0.17126470804214478,
-0.43251314759254456,
0.022871455177664757,
-0.19699278473854065,
-0.28330743312835693,
0.6859117746353149,
-0.4958445131778717,
0.5859424471855164,
-0.15207596123218536,
-0.30845603346824646,
0.48190683126449585,
0.38930270075798035,
0.8347933292388916,
0.007689330726861954,
-0.3984060287475586,
-0.2523808181285858,
-0.13384507596492767,
-0.032737284898757935,
-0.651077151298523,
0.8900454640388489,
-0.3479466438293457,
-0.3775179088115692,
-0.3811498284339905,
-0.3747066855430603,
0.10844182223081589,
0.3705492317676544,
0.21647121012210846,
0.7356947660446167,
-0.00030992794199846685,
0.11113032698631287,
0.7367333769798279,
-0.3196532726287842,
0.42160889506340027,
0.839295506477356,
-0.6453928351402283,
-0.2730637490749359,
0.9502406716346741,
0.31092914938926697,
0.010287942364811897,
0.7202462553977966,
0.2943178713321686,
-0.03542224317789078,
-0.538572371006012,
-0.39944177865982056,
0.39609894156455994,
-0.3599400818347931,
-0.3741169273853302,
-0.6435624957084656,
-0.32033950090408325,
-0.2150195688009262,
0.13282731175422668,
-0.44343101978302,
-0.6699926853179932,
-0.35794541239738464,
-0.09278441220521927,
0.5502505898475647,
0.8489510416984558,
-0.09155712276697159,
0.111557237803936,
-1.0096380710601807,
0.39813703298568726,
0.1905159205198288,
0.46316808462142944,
0.1612657904624939,
-0.5847864747047424,
-0.5879093408584595,
-0.21589235961437225,
-0.34476566314697266,
-0.7537868618965149,
0.34162256121635437,
0.0067785317078232765,
0.5114827752113342,
0.3353714644908905,
0.12014629691839218,
0.6192668080329895,
-0.6984917521476746,
0.7360351085662842,
-0.13052766025066376,
-0.509104311466217,
0.7252190113067627,
-0.33597299456596375,
0.32520920038223267,
0.3848986029624939,
0.4289456009864807,
-0.6162431240081787,
-0.44949662685394287,
-0.5349292159080505,
-1.153978943824768,
0.7702488899230957,
0.22474192082881927,
0.115788035094738,
0.10386830568313599,
0.8007949590682983,
0.17751838266849518,
0.32868194580078125,
-0.3415372669696808,
-0.3127110004425049,
0.33235710859298706,
-0.2725417912006378,
0.408159077167511,
-0.6283660531044006,
0.13725076615810394,
0.04798397794365883,
0.6669590473175049,
0.16025611758232117,
0.23330217599868774,
-0.14181169867515564,
-0.0388542115688324,
-0.35263076424598694,
0.02717253379523754,
0.5400813817977905,
0.7898516058921814,
-0.11497974395751953,
0.04557553678750992,
0.16644816100597382,
-0.8284615874290466,
0.0037546914536505938,
0.1586337685585022,
-0.6182282567024231,
0.1586000770330429,
0.3598731756210327,
0.8912526369094849,
0.06635648757219315,
-0.8049680590629578,
0.44628793001174927,
-0.09784239530563354,
-0.0007115486660040915,
-0.5060819983482361,
0.1750613898038864,
-0.32883360981941223,
0.244781494140625,
0.5526224374771118,
-0.06232483312487602,
-0.03223614767193794,
-0.18316149711608887,
0.30931031703948975,
0.3108519911766052,
-0.21558688580989838,
-0.4428141713142395,
0.6894432902336121,
0.2325483113527298,
-0.35462456941604614,
0.40465840697288513,
-0.160491481423378,
-0.26240670680999756,
0.2997271418571472,
0.38805314898490906,
0.9160490036010742,
-0.32008111476898193,
0.18778301775455475,
0.4786272346973419,
-0.12474662810564041,
-0.09654799103736877,
0.3351293206214905,
-0.10607510060071945,
-0.5259796380996704,
-0.7584830522537231,
-0.7909980416297913,
-0.31172677874565125,
0.17660512030124664,
-0.36279982328414917,
0.4915733337402344,
-0.316181480884552,
-0.3997713327407837,
-0.498975545167923,
0.05644480511546135,
-0.20507895946502686,
0.018117669969797134,
0.1426946222782135,
0.9575303196907043,
-0.35555145144462585,
0.5519875884056091,
0.869651198387146,
-0.2917962670326233,
-0.7699716687202454,
0.16130511462688446,
0.2406526803970337,
-0.4723874628543854,
0.8932743072509766,
-0.2950364649295807,
-0.35072061419487,
-0.10960540920495987,
-0.7046152949333191,
-1.3207261562347412,
1.06719970703125,
0.2773856222629547,
-0.5605919361114502,
-0.1773817539215088,
-0.14659403264522552,
0.41355204582214355,
-0.2804069519042969,
0.24248188734054565,
0.21862876415252686,
0.4471821188926697,
0.5504149794578552,
-0.811732292175293,
-0.10830438882112503,
-0.32400864362716675,
0.034399889409542084,
0.4413084387779236,
-0.694948136806488,
0.6643437147140503,
0.0025660027749836445,
-0.352836936712265,
0.11497092992067337,
0.835186779499054,
0.34609776735305786,
0.08420821279287338,
0.5287181735038757,
0.44191664457321167,
0.8554341793060303,
0.1184626966714859,
1.1556848287582397,
-0.4650927186012268,
0.11761970818042755,
1.029605746269226,
-0.19735205173492432,
0.8570951819419861,
0.1366729438304901,
0.08578784763813019,
0.3904139995574951,
0.3747306168079376,
0.24599121510982513,
0.4638694226741791,
0.1240772008895874,
-0.4367722272872925,
-0.1253121793270111,
-0.3087958097457886,
-0.12766829133033752,
0.35195308923721313,
0.189933642745018,
-0.08176425844430923,
0.015460686758160591,
0.11564748734235764,
0.2430797964334488,
0.07969767600297928,
-0.1541741043329239,
0.8325093388557434,
-0.1835060715675354,
-0.5090240836143494,
0.6348733901977539,
-0.0836872011423111,
0.6346167325973511,
-0.8148084878921509,
0.0066334945149719715,
-0.3882051706314087,
0.03131081163883209,
-0.18688824772834778,
-0.7208691835403442,
0.07721906155347824,
0.312427818775177,
-0.3398181200027466,
-0.3490746021270752,
0.9985973834991455,
-0.5974517464637756,
-0.5058476328849792,
0.2849954664707184,
0.5628840327262878,
0.17002181708812714,
0.321659117937088,
-0.7435117959976196,
0.30506113171577454,
0.013385103084146976,
-0.5604114532470703,
0.41325274109840393,
0.7913593053817749,
-0.00031687525915913284,
1.070533037185669,
0.4969344735145569,
0.6126180291175842,
0.10901355743408203,
0.30841317772865295,
0.8763297200202942,
-0.5818026065826416,
-0.2998572587966919,
-0.5659106373786926,
0.3951791226863861,
-0.10324470698833466,
0.10735434293746948,
0.6115099191665649,
0.7838956713676453,
0.4012075662612915,
0.037989482283592224,
0.6771856546401978,
-0.37716925144195557,
1.0662298202514648,
-0.5162435173988342,
0.855341374874115,
-0.9419634938240051,
0.4185463488101959,
-0.1071237251162529,
-0.996163010597229,
-0.3306570053100586,
0.4776226282119751,
-0.10076278448104858,
0.11322463303804398,
0.6914924383163452,
0.7977011799812317,
-0.0843174010515213,
-0.23114325106143951,
0.1372530162334442,
0.3316817283630371,
0.39087581634521484,
0.04752487316727638,
0.9148195385932922,
-0.09169042855501175,
0.7464814782142639,
-0.08640053868293762,
-0.19285397231578827,
-0.31049567461013794,
-1.0667301416397095,
-0.5097289681434631,
-0.6482890844345093,
-0.24284727871418,
-0.35691162943840027,
0.14231497049331665,
1.17259681224823,
0.567031979560852,
-0.6462423205375671,
-0.37855952978134155,
0.13090021908283234,
0.26432734727859497,
-0.03563234582543373,
-0.23476816713809967,
0.29690149426460266,
-0.6197876930236816,
-0.6009925007820129,
0.5124655961990356,
0.2527462840080261,
0.013234836049377918,
-0.09998440742492676,
0.08513575047254562,
-0.5424943566322327,
0.0945436879992485,
0.6893539428710938,
0.25774434208869934,
-0.2794725000858307,
-0.14742697775363922,
-0.1454409807920456,
-0.1670895367860794,
-0.05992862954735756,
1.087954044342041,
-0.9987958669662476,
0.34074389934539795,
0.8632230758666992,
0.7421529293060303,
0.42493030428886414,
0.15407246351242065,
0.459066241979599,
-0.7948424220085144,
0.1451498419046402,
0.16535961627960205,
-0.1630973517894745,
0.11711359769105911,
-0.48882898688316345,
0.4764232933521271,
0.41975468397140503,
-0.7214151620864868,
-0.7500538229942322,
0.34533369541168213,
-0.7220967411994934,
-0.21731890738010406,
1.0912065505981445,
0.25041401386260986,
-0.19186022877693176,
0.09916163235902786,
-0.17788030207157135,
0.3292933404445648,
-0.40176665782928467,
0.6451755166053772,
0.3697740435600281,
-0.12226595729589462,
-0.16191795468330383,
-0.7449473142623901,
0.6145064830780029,
0.23029828071594238,
-0.6018320322036743,
0.3224729895591736,
0.6154221296310425,
0.02666206657886505,
0.2217763066291809,
0.5794872641563416,
0.04101801663637161,
-0.10042595118284225,
-0.3244551420211792,
0.04758366569876671,
0.023362353444099426,
-0.4401738941669464,
-0.019458141177892685,
0.3014627695083618,
0.00031634519109502435,
0.266742467880249
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10065v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10065v1
|
Triple GNNs: Introducing Syntactic and Semantic Information for Conversational Aspect-Based Quadruple Sentiment Analysis
| 2024-03-15T07:15:48 | 2024-03-15T07:15:48 |
Binbin Li, Yuqing Li, Siyu Jia, Bingnan Ma, Yu Ding, Zisen Qi, Xingbang Tan, Menghan Guo, Shenghui Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Conversational Aspect-Based Sentiment Analysis (DiaASQ) aims to detect
quadruples \{target, aspect, opinion, sentiment polarity\} from given
dialogues. In DiaASQ, elements constituting these quadruples are not
necessarily confined to individual sentences but may span across multiple
utterances within a dialogue. This necessitates a dual focus on both the
syntactic information of individual utterances and the semantic interaction
among them. However, previous studies have primarily focused on coarse-grained
relationships between utterances, thus overlooking the potential benefits of
detailed intra-utterance syntactic information and the granularity of
inter-utterance relationships. This paper introduces the Triple GNNs network to
enhance DiaAsQ. It employs a Graph Convolutional Network (GCN) for modeling
syntactic dependencies within utterances and a Dual Graph Attention Network
(DualGATs) to construct interactions between utterances. Experiments on two
standard datasets reveal that our model significantly outperforms
state-of-the-art baselines. The code is available at
\url{https://github.com/nlperi2b/Triple-GNNs-}.
|
[
-0.3007039725780487,
-0.790865421295166,
0.4344325065612793,
0.3963331878185272,
-0.33418598771095276,
0.35541337728500366,
-0.008188345469534397,
-0.5801506638526917,
0.48516663908958435,
0.654847264289856,
-0.22886009514331818,
-0.7375004887580872,
-0.3829837143421173,
0.05765712261199951,
-0.284572958946228,
1.2815155982971191,
0.3054908812046051,
0.1789879947900772,
-0.2579440474510193,
-0.2599198520183563,
-0.08186791837215424,
-0.7587146162986755,
-0.8880676031112671,
-0.16762283444404602,
0.6004231572151184,
0.4197879135608673,
0.7857438325881958,
-0.030469505116343498,
0.5295617580413818,
0.32598748803138733,
-0.28080227971076965,
0.32289552688598633,
-0.21388907730579376,
0.2908005714416504,
0.24061772227287292,
-0.41730278730392456,
-0.5910258889198303,
-0.16424785554409027,
0.723731279373169,
0.8097474575042725,
-0.02500765025615692,
-0.03199322149157524,
0.4055556058883667,
0.8079655170440674,
-0.48435813188552856,
0.6278305649757385,
-0.23714452981948853,
0.02745548076927662,
-0.08376283198595047,
0.12316335737705231,
-0.02529713697731495,
-0.5600894689559937,
0.3806234896183014,
-0.3599478006362915,
0.15643242001533508,
-0.07559945434331894,
0.9238052368164062,
0.0011077848030254245,
-0.5097414255142212,
-0.18256710469722748,
-0.7210711240768433,
0.5850189924240112,
-0.7496647238731384,
0.1322910636663437,
0.29628539085388184,
0.1305387020111084,
0.06988019496202469,
-0.7511698007583618,
-0.706807017326355,
-0.15424691140651703,
-0.18018025159835815,
0.2339160293340683,
-0.2879205644130707,
0.4190595746040344,
-0.1607397198677063,
0.7517278790473938,
-0.2639808654785156,
-0.16566786170005798,
-0.21850436925888062,
-0.22294263541698456,
0.5056037306785583,
0.41146522760391235,
0.30977800488471985,
-0.5790202021598816,
-0.32113078236579895,
0.23472857475280762,
-0.2605821490287781,
0.20857472717761993,
0.5527552962303162,
0.5115765929222107,
-0.2814152240753174,
0.4299665689468384,
-0.37981143593788147,
0.7247011661529541,
0.07596446573734283,
0.059575993567705154,
0.6212694644927979,
-1.0757452249526978,
-0.21942783892154694,
-0.11586309969425201,
1.324837327003479,
0.5759648680686951,
0.24122735857963562,
-0.031339410692453384,
0.18033835291862488,
0.10527873784303665,
0.26352590322494507,
-0.5164496898651123,
-0.5025018453598022,
0.2749767303466797,
-0.2436964362859726,
-0.609373927116394,
-0.1255226731300354,
-0.7830886840820312,
-0.41278088092803955,
-0.4591197371482849,
0.057008061558008194,
-0.4513990581035614,
-0.4049232602119446,
0.16118782758712769,
-0.03176083043217659,
0.08790164440870285,
0.2832024097442627,
-0.9573906064033508,
0.5280589461326599,
0.6192857623100281,
1.106164813041687,
0.1297156810760498,
-0.15779812633991241,
-0.358947217464447,
0.0915253758430481,
-0.08550997078418732,
0.7701926827430725,
-0.440817654132843,
-0.23929300904273987,
-0.15412083268165588,
-0.21350091695785522,
-0.1303371638059616,
-0.3558149039745331,
0.5418678522109985,
-0.47951140999794006,
0.2929389774799347,
-0.15904060006141663,
-0.07596774399280548,
-0.6323503255844116,
0.44058704376220703,
-0.9299026727676392,
1.1191526651382446,
0.07196073234081268,
-1.0082708597183228,
0.1391214281320572,
-0.6683715581893921,
-0.517182469367981,
0.03855212777853012,
-0.35543355345726013,
-0.5361450910568237,
-0.02937789261341095,
0.3150312900543213,
0.39783596992492676,
-0.24625487625598907,
0.26975029706954956,
-0.5342563390731812,
-0.11760734766721725,
0.225929856300354,
-0.24673452973365784,
0.7120943665504456,
-0.23849476873874664,
-0.1891026794910431,
0.22678889334201813,
-0.6174471974372864,
0.10697265714406967,
-0.11143285781145096,
-0.3196086585521698,
-0.33934277296066284,
-0.12103907763957977,
-0.28138336539268494,
0.33908751606941223,
0.06788499653339386,
-0.6042961478233337,
-0.013841051608324051,
-0.6979100108146667,
0.577965497970581,
0.31202375888824463,
0.2893129289150238,
0.37303322553634644,
-0.028299760073423386,
0.594202995300293,
0.3318882882595062,
0.33652469515800476,
0.26176854968070984,
-0.598365306854248,
-0.9497761130332947,
-0.09279873222112656,
0.22642777860164642,
0.5804474949836731,
-0.9893409013748169,
0.4857513904571533,
-0.32706981897354126,
0.04027261212468147,
-0.6024911403656006,
0.12881939113140106,
0.5380871891975403,
0.4419211745262146,
0.3203185498714447,
-0.46881720423698425,
-0.7012231349945068,
-1.0943000316619873,
0.021313631907105446,
-0.4864286482334137,
0.12346574664115906,
0.24483399093151093,
0.22725185751914978,
0.22648455202579498,
0.9804127812385559,
-0.32149749994277954,
-0.31070995330810547,
-0.4547578692436218,
0.06728383153676987,
0.12668092548847198,
-0.09709000587463379,
0.5874375104904175,
-0.845241367816925,
-0.5650097131729126,
-0.07889647781848907,
-0.7841659188270569,
0.07526861131191254,
0.3690751791000366,
-0.19197231531143188,
0.07136324048042297,
0.39437049627304077,
-0.5472339391708374,
0.4273971617221832,
0.7481876611709595,
-0.18474526703357697,
0.6487510204315186,
0.27674996852874756,
-0.0005030657630413771,
-1.2252014875411987,
-0.07158457487821579,
0.10685338824987411,
-0.1835557222366333,
-0.8641265034675598,
-0.39205092191696167,
-0.2446642965078354,
0.09325001388788223,
-0.3479844927787781,
0.09542141854763031,
-0.40553563833236694,
-0.18540355563163757,
-0.05360224470496178,
0.3108814060688019,
0.698550283908844,
0.6820725798606873,
-0.2682519853115082,
0.8356077075004578,
0.6019424200057983,
-0.5440308451652527,
0.7578831315040588,
0.38450899720191956,
-0.22942988574504852,
0.7646960020065308,
-0.8289883732795715,
0.19743536412715912,
0.008236516267061234,
0.5771943926811218,
-0.9986158013343811,
0.06099053844809532,
0.7385376691818237,
-0.4707344174385071,
0.0500061921775341,
-0.2263285517692566,
-0.408631294965744,
-0.5813287496566772,
-0.44704732298851013,
0.48840513825416565,
-0.2833006680011749,
-0.3407158851623535,
0.673949122428894,
0.5650029182434082,
-0.44461649656295776,
-0.5800072550773621,
-0.7473253607749939,
0.5395946502685547,
-0.24462741613388062,
-0.8962814807891846,
0.13872799277305603,
0.0933828353881836,
-0.32164984941482544,
-0.0396401546895504,
0.13042795658111572,
0.10988830029964447,
0.006417915690690279,
0.20161955058574677,
0.2953093647956848,
-0.2769075930118561,
0.21968527138233185,
-0.3048804998397827,
-0.22649474442005157,
0.24815988540649414,
-0.5687816739082336,
0.5531896948814392,
-0.7474240064620972,
0.029240665957331657,
-0.7613269686698914,
0.5937283039093018,
0.5690020322799683,
-0.38477835059165955,
0.49449285864830017,
0.5781720876693726,
-0.03615355119109154,
0.14832033216953278,
-0.3358117640018463,
0.2322797328233719,
-0.4161757528781891,
0.4137509763240814,
-0.4021800458431244,
-0.8808822631835938,
0.49604660272598267,
0.32941344380378723,
-0.38495802879333496,
0.2774322032928467,
0.5361477732658386,
-0.09776968508958817,
1.1896060705184937,
0.45754125714302063,
-0.29173171520233154,
0.4979482591152191,
-0.5610074996948242,
0.5353508591651917,
-1.3420666456222534,
-0.3609631657600403,
-0.41743189096450806,
-0.23002608120441437,
-0.40237873792648315,
-0.27555400133132935,
0.554427981376648,
0.14163163304328918,
-0.1283656656742096,
-0.021663539111614227,
-0.3964211642742157,
0.2627420127391815,
0.5198333263397217,
0.2135927528142929,
0.3766743540763855,
-0.08490248024463654,
-0.18162134289741516,
0.250423789024353,
-0.4702371060848236,
-0.4601213037967682,
0.8698358535766602,
0.3015585243701935,
0.40713030099868774,
0.4576219916343689,
0.5717174410820007,
0.14040197432041168,
-0.20668333768844604,
-1.100794792175293,
0.5733320713043213,
-0.2391643524169922,
-0.22387290000915527,
-0.24839504063129425,
-0.5385682582855225,
-0.9708932638168335,
0.3745076060295105,
0.08934447169303894,
-0.9298259615898132,
0.17809049785137177,
-0.10553949326276779,
-0.8923318982124329,
0.1346282809972763,
-0.706498920917511,
0.6220278143882751,
-0.09928525984287262,
-0.1534896343946457,
-0.030293451622128487,
-0.8745001554489136,
0.3882378935813904,
0.31369253993034363,
0.1724250167608261,
-0.2143869251012802,
0.14297699928283691,
0.7123718857765198,
-0.3657561242580414,
1.0553584098815918,
-0.11687058955430984,
-0.03748606890439987,
0.3925834596157074,
-0.07449518889188766,
0.1107444316148758,
0.3640391230583191,
-0.11492197215557098,
0.4982359707355499,
-0.09920500963926315,
-0.24039004743099213,
-0.789506196975708,
0.7527661323547363,
-0.8675628900527954,
-0.4945421516895294,
-0.272661030292511,
-0.4594120681285858,
-0.5410475134849548,
0.050740450620651245,
-0.12187346071004868,
0.7691589593887329,
-0.2595599591732025,
0.013750321231782436,
0.30451202392578125,
0.2990610897541046,
0.5037457942962646,
0.1457747370004654,
-0.27123627066612244,
-0.7661426067352295,
0.6222085952758789,
-0.16705061495304108,
0.4750625193119049,
0.22441378235816956,
0.30414584279060364,
-0.27962931990623474,
-0.5911790132522583,
-0.5272285342216492,
0.21587862074375153,
-0.5569154620170593,
-0.3731447756290436,
-0.9503782987594604,
-0.40077340602874756,
-0.5150858163833618,
0.32279065251350403,
0.00003198682315996848,
-0.5550642609596252,
-0.26205068826675415,
-0.18847441673278809,
0.4802760183811188,
0.8494211435317993,
-0.17468957602977753,
0.476595014333725,
-0.9119271039962769,
0.4089653789997101,
0.4562789499759674,
0.37058067321777344,
-0.006279445718973875,
-0.16948674619197845,
-0.4376384913921356,
0.29537612199783325,
-0.27915436029434204,
-0.828982949256897,
0.17935068905353546,
0.26349419355392456,
0.2901450991630554,
0.36149105429649353,
-0.29607120156288147,
0.3393920361995697,
-0.14047148823738098,
1.0949357748031616,
0.4430634379386902,
-1.0532211065292358,
0.3922344446182251,
-0.42258045077323914,
0.37852421402931213,
0.7596694827079773,
0.06506280601024628,
-0.7869146466255188,
-0.5179464221000671,
-0.6039886474609375,
-0.8260893821716309,
0.9669082760810852,
0.28130921721458435,
0.07178489863872528,
-0.1868559569120407,
0.17175142467021942,
-0.20015224814414978,
0.3762340247631073,
-0.476360946893692,
-0.20942558348178864,
-0.29356053471565247,
-0.3336910009384155,
0.020302439108490944,
-0.34304341673851013,
-0.27975553274154663,
-0.30594122409820557,
0.651416540145874,
-0.4068280756473541,
0.21630147099494934,
0.02399536781013012,
0.3023628890514374,
0.18295089900493622,
0.0534374825656414,
0.1728435456752777,
0.2065449357032776,
-0.203294575214386,
0.251980721950531,
-0.04732381924986839,
-0.755372166633606,
-0.0660087987780571,
0.1945967823266983,
0.016108835116028786,
0.026372890919446945,
0.23399576544761658,
1.071345567703247,
0.1548350602388382,
0.28235524892807007,
0.7078243494033813,
-0.3879469931125641,
-0.15383444726467133,
-0.3052119016647339,
-0.1461174637079239,
0.15634283423423767,
0.2657392621040344,
-0.026308689266443253,
0.08865547925233841,
0.46219852566719055,
-0.47102880477905273,
0.08923740684986115,
0.34963226318359375,
-0.6166872382164001,
-0.4629477560520172,
0.151298388838768,
0.6017699837684631,
-0.13791759312152863,
0.7100673317909241,
-0.30377066135406494,
-0.8502440452575684,
0.6163188219070435,
0.17901456356048584,
1.0170761346817017,
-0.22670423984527588,
0.7055754661560059,
0.20293143391609192,
0.007912575267255306,
0.31406185030937195,
0.4380571246147156,
-0.17091086506843567,
-0.9784132838249207,
-0.45838838815689087,
-0.6341796517372131,
-0.4545658230781555,
0.03208158165216446,
-0.8118335008621216,
0.19231025874614716,
-0.4101414084434509,
-0.44619739055633545,
0.4251196086406708,
0.11453660577535629,
-0.6391861438751221,
0.19481857120990753,
0.3410581350326538,
0.19215844571590424,
-0.6798332333564758,
0.6412195563316345,
0.6259768605232239,
-0.7517707943916321,
-0.7125556468963623,
0.10319463163614273,
0.1429625004529953,
-0.8224872946739197,
0.4020315110683441,
0.2528455853462219,
-0.5668119192123413,
-0.019013574346899986,
-0.3607030212879181,
-1.0826046466827393,
0.900685727596283,
-0.08463156968355179,
-0.24856401979923248,
-0.2941790819168091,
0.3979998826980591,
0.5763329267501831,
-0.48387691378593445,
0.46651190519332886,
0.9598286151885986,
0.3013456165790558,
0.16049528121948242,
-0.9954709410667419,
-0.06953417509794235,
-0.4186703860759735,
0.08615205436944962,
0.5475665330886841,
-0.8451634645462036,
0.7493665218353271,
-0.17987829446792603,
-0.21552444994449615,
-0.08700021356344223,
0.646606981754303,
-0.08397824317216873,
0.19575440883636475,
0.7641069889068604,
0.6161580681800842,
0.7389078736305237,
-0.1579008847475052,
0.9090413451194763,
-0.2696216404438019,
0.3131018280982971,
1.2377532720565796,
-0.29814013838768005,
0.5100314617156982,
0.33037322759628296,
-0.3012048006057739,
1.062904715538025,
0.41322585940361023,
0.25435590744018555,
0.3822613060474396,
0.3279918432235718,
-0.5071011781692505,
-0.16199609637260437,
-0.35279691219329834,
-0.17696556448936462,
0.7521950602531433,
0.8107191324234009,
-0.14554201066493988,
-0.2547653913497925,
0.048444103449583054,
0.20548102259635925,
-0.22968393564224243,
-0.0831526666879654,
1.0569156408309937,
0.31667083501815796,
-0.27700895071029663,
0.39871904253959656,
-0.30850672721862793,
0.39395439624786377,
-0.5218068361282349,
0.0679738000035286,
-0.20785918831825256,
0.10674024373292923,
-0.3854549825191498,
-1.1672983169555664,
0.4196029305458069,
-0.42329731583595276,
-0.22932010889053345,
0.2366926521062851,
0.5854423642158508,
-0.509444534778595,
-0.43039804697036743,
0.5806683301925659,
0.47564697265625,
-0.025068920105695724,
-0.2063046246767044,
-0.846666157245636,
0.013474049977958202,
0.007803865242749453,
-0.1493322253227234,
0.05668068304657936,
0.623539388179779,
-0.03265606611967087,
0.26751509308815,
0.48085105419158936,
0.08799510449171066,
-0.40755289793014526,
0.8755943179130554,
1.016510248184204,
-0.5460564494132996,
-0.8009355664253235,
-0.7202289700508118,
0.44000443816185,
-0.5161311030387878,
-0.32418373227119446,
0.774870753288269,
0.48191481828689575,
0.4160201847553253,
0.5706886053085327,
1.1042370796203613,
0.10607396066188812,
0.4644516408443451,
-0.5938212275505066,
0.282677561044693,
-0.26787257194519043,
0.10059211403131485,
-0.2701539993286133,
-0.7453032732009888,
-0.6339404582977295,
0.1153658777475357,
-0.5344018936157227,
0.016208024695515633,
0.8778512477874756,
0.7676460146903992,
0.009769891388714314,
0.6699698567390442,
0.08489804714918137,
0.26884031295776367,
0.3475089967250824,
0.5831002593040466,
1.1533068418502808,
-0.30482643842697144,
0.6914241909980774,
-0.3004061281681061,
-0.3162677586078644,
-0.1606617122888565,
-0.6032640337944031,
-0.8223766088485718,
-0.5094723105430603,
-0.29767248034477234,
-0.708777666091919,
0.048989374190568924,
0.4730921983718872,
0.5221182703971863,
-0.7091556191444397,
-0.11834049224853516,
-0.10537117719650269,
0.020153438672423363,
-0.12075374275445938,
-0.31862112879753113,
0.4957679808139801,
-0.3392428159713745,
-0.5415781736373901,
0.38980504870414734,
0.561570942401886,
-0.004052590113133192,
-0.47103577852249146,
0.2330949902534485,
-0.3505631387233734,
0.1748950481414795,
0.6434165835380554,
0.003879860509186983,
-0.6240891814231873,
-0.49296095967292786,
-0.18092773854732513,
-0.1779874563217163,
0.3019784390926361,
0.7914994359016418,
-0.7302016615867615,
0.5208712220191956,
0.3368856906890869,
0.25341707468032837,
0.3470148742198944,
0.09769436717033386,
0.5757253766059875,
-0.8784480094909668,
-0.044943299144506454,
0.47766637802124023,
0.2673712372779846,
0.6911261677742004,
-0.5169771313667297,
0.27686941623687744,
0.21338865160942078,
-0.6018823385238647,
-0.24980047345161438,
0.4379757344722748,
-1.0173548460006714,
0.09140688180923462,
1.4207334518432617,
-0.0036611303221434355,
-0.205664724111557,
-0.5630607008934021,
-0.276761531829834,
0.22615979611873627,
-0.5436744689941406,
0.6155749559402466,
0.6483702659606934,
-0.3688356578350067,
0.21968789398670197,
-0.4981946051120758,
0.4836665987968445,
0.4388040602207184,
-0.8528528213500977,
0.096481554210186,
0.6739343404769897,
0.0046827648766338825,
0.3535636067390442,
0.919013500213623,
-0.10016872733831406,
0.01668609119951725,
-0.08486531674861908,
0.21648746728897095,
0.07741286605596542,
-0.5484515428543091,
-0.45085039734840393,
0.12435796111822128,
-0.2012723982334137,
-0.6252714991569519
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10059v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10059v2
|
Repoformer: Selective Retrieval for Repository-Level Code Completion
| 2024-03-15T06:59:43 | 2024-06-04T10:04:33 |
Di Wu, Wasi Uddin Ahmad, Dejiao Zhang, Murali Krishna Ramanathan, Xiaofei Ma
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.CL
|
Recent advances in retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) have initiated a new
era in repository-level code completion. However, the invariable use of
retrieval in existing methods exposes issues in both efficiency and robustness,
with a large proportion of the retrieved contexts proving unhelpful or harmful
to code language models (code LMs). In this paper, we propose a selective RAG
framework to avoid retrieval when unnecessary. To power this framework, we
design a self-supervised learning approach to enable a code LM to accurately
self-evaluate whether retrieval can improve its output quality and robustly
leverage the potentially noisy retrieved contexts. Using this LM as both the
selective RAG policy and the generation model, our framework achieves
state-of-the-art repository-level code completion performance on diverse
benchmarks including RepoEval, CrossCodeEval, and CrossCodeLongEval, a new
long-form code completion benchmark. Meanwhile, our analyses show that
selectively retrieving brings as much as 70% inference speedup in the online
serving setting without harming the performance. We further demonstrate that
our framework is able to accommodate different generation models, retrievers,
and programming languages. These advancements position our framework as an
important step towards more accurate and efficient repository-level code
completion.
|
[
-0.5898206233978271,
-0.05038345977663994,
0.2166394591331482,
0.1644686758518219,
-0.14724090695381165,
0.3197968900203705,
-0.16370908915996552,
-0.43963032960891724,
0.28536197543144226,
1.0251141786575317,
-0.30651697516441345,
-0.36313921213150024,
-0.3260471522808075,
0.41702523827552795,
-0.5145202279090881,
0.9177840948104858,
0.015992339700460434,
-0.14193163812160492,
-0.2941729724407196,
-0.24694368243217468,
-0.33308103680610657,
-0.40504515171051025,
-0.2687402665615082,
-0.2921629250049591,
0.547393798828125,
0.47762930393218994,
0.23370125889778137,
0.8108410835266113,
0.6015297770500183,
0.2862192690372467,
0.16130563616752625,
0.06877512484788895,
-0.7014514207839966,
0.6477975845336914,
-0.36759820580482483,
-0.39914318919181824,
-0.1472763568162918,
-0.057035502046346664,
0.3529262840747833,
0.20455946028232574,
-0.3992973566055298,
0.3863670527935028,
0.10285041481256485,
1.114803433418274,
-1.130964994430542,
-0.2981066107749939,
-0.5662743449211121,
0.13974109292030334,
0.024817895144224167,
-0.1631753295660019,
-0.7642269134521484,
-0.17895585298538208,
-0.023675622418522835,
-0.4854063391685486,
0.3406357169151306,
-0.024905692785978317,
0.7386941313743591,
0.562964916229248,
-0.3036535978317261,
-0.353259414434433,
-0.5506983399391174,
0.7924973368644714,
-0.29216378927230835,
0.533234179019928,
0.8181105852127075,
0.5578237771987915,
-0.035644978284835815,
-1.1222487688064575,
0.154453307390213,
-0.38270723819732666,
-0.3682391345500946,
0.21074017882347107,
-0.027980690822005272,
0.02291104756295681,
0.27497416734695435,
0.5680087804794312,
-0.5807012319564819,
-0.19019083678722382,
-0.41112443804740906,
-0.21660089492797852,
0.42727887630462646,
-0.27594247460365295,
-0.14872699975967407,
-0.4567930996417999,
-0.6249520182609558,
0.015508417040109634,
-0.4940198063850403,
-0.22502125799655914,
0.29498863220214844,
0.11859481781721115,
0.1464870572090149,
0.3682151734828949,
-0.27991199493408203,
0.819198727607727,
0.2838187515735626,
0.13469161093235016,
0.3334154784679413,
-0.11773171275854111,
-0.21074841916561127,
-0.3504529893398285,
0.38892629742622375,
-0.20784707367420197,
0.08481988310813904,
-0.3600752055644989,
-0.4963811933994293,
-0.13737446069717407,
0.8856973648071289,
-0.8432825803756714,
-0.27269530296325684,
0.33824488520622253,
-0.7032778263092041,
-0.23466964066028595,
0.3287120461463928,
-0.8987452387809753,
-0.36128947138786316,
-0.051276735961437225,
0.025224866345524788,
-0.2617647051811218,
-0.328092098236084,
-0.35445335507392883,
-0.18870621919631958,
0.11804512143135071,
-0.0703921988606453,
-0.5159127712249756,
-0.028913114219903946,
0.687279999256134,
0.3950842022895813,
-0.42777061462402344,
-0.025522220879793167,
-0.8898699879646301,
0.31710684299468994,
-0.3913324475288391,
0.6361045837402344,
-0.8417190909385681,
-0.6147809624671936,
-0.1041252464056015,
-0.04739456623792648,
0.22330400347709656,
-0.8812668323516846,
0.31593024730682373,
-0.8817265629768372,
0.20435181260108948,
0.14609093964099884,
-0.6210383176803589,
-0.013569020666182041,
0.11751402914524078,
-0.7920743823051453,
0.9006578326225281,
0.622957706451416,
-0.6311467289924622,
0.4176405370235443,
0.057628434151411057,
-0.3666461408138275,
0.12968376278877258,
-0.4617897868156433,
-0.5318149924278259,
0.16108576953411102,
0.032397132366895676,
0.22531865537166595,
-0.016661185771226883,
0.42970308661460876,
-0.11990705132484436,
-0.5567741990089417,
-0.04792333394289017,
-0.07498206198215485,
0.421670138835907,
0.8950909972190857,
-0.2764551341533661,
-0.02725815214216709,
-0.8625938296318054,
0.35443776845932007,
-0.21972352266311646,
-0.6779030561447144,
-0.19782187044620514,
-0.15374235808849335,
-0.21290968358516693,
0.15332283079624176,
0.2906593978404999,
-0.1412183791399002,
0.19233305752277374,
-0.1964791864156723,
0.03652167320251465,
0.62328040599823,
0.06687802076339722,
0.8855017423629761,
-0.3747870624065399,
1.0469812154769897,
-0.36147844791412354,
0.2678840756416321,
-0.32439956068992615,
-0.09960679709911346,
-0.642339825630188,
-0.8280478119850159,
0.4529409110546112,
0.37333035469055176,
-1.0312941074371338,
0.23403829336166382,
0.13731740415096283,
-0.4953349232673645,
-0.5659990310668945,
0.4455571472644806,
0.9798650741577148,
0.45218974351882935,
0.5393340587615967,
-0.27769750356674194,
-0.8763954639434814,
-0.8767703771591187,
-0.5259926319122314,
-0.02688072808086872,
-0.29863426089286804,
0.5249707698822021,
0.1531321257352829,
-0.5488179326057434,
0.9573035836219788,
-0.2791251242160797,
-0.5164187550544739,
-0.18642398715019226,
-0.044765833765268326,
0.3985110819339752,
0.6641268134117126,
0.5737504959106445,
-0.9823502898216248,
-0.4999457597732544,
-0.17852315306663513,
-0.6056045293807983,
-0.3927146792411804,
-0.027792025357484818,
-0.1314481645822525,
0.4116699993610382,
0.6327243447303772,
-0.08471141755580902,
0.4008260667324066,
0.8411528468132019,
-0.15516358613967896,
0.11440280079841614,
-0.37636128067970276,
0.25622275471687317,
-0.7980730533599854,
0.15269894897937775,
-0.22866152226924896,
-0.449194997549057,
-0.30766764283180237,
0.6191744208335876,
0.47608721256256104,
-0.0626457929611206,
-0.3314913213253021,
0.5421853065490723,
-0.7788154482841492,
-0.1974511295557022,
-0.4078894555568695,
-0.15167152881622314,
0.2591090798377991,
0.3435966670513153,
-0.14073938131332397,
0.9001684188842773,
0.24699236452579498,
-0.6542202234268188,
-0.11114710569381714,
-0.15305636823177338,
-0.0700475424528122,
0.27357161045074463,
-0.4988411068916321,
0.07110743224620819,
-0.22609880566596985,
0.2481539398431778,
-0.7882729172706604,
-0.3155156373977661,
0.3435400426387787,
-0.46828728914260864,
0.7082438468933105,
-0.7514292597770691,
-0.008655896410346031,
-0.3574790954589844,
0.072966068983078,
0.41495969891548157,
0.6826927065849304,
-0.6519235968589783,
0.9215511679649353,
0.5133600831031799,
0.3737012445926666,
-0.910043478012085,
-0.7241930365562439,
-0.20089830458164215,
0.024310950189828873,
-0.08792697638273239,
0.3304084539413452,
0.11579587310552597,
0.06715839356184006,
-0.24734002351760864,
-0.5592384338378906,
-0.26889604330062866,
0.08527005463838577,
0.27843111753463745,
0.10720290243625641,
0.09415800124406815,
0.10115072131156921,
-0.06891702860593796,
-0.518449068069458,
-0.16245882213115692,
-0.35146817564964294,
0.34511861205101013,
0.1525178998708725,
-0.42867201566696167,
0.02624858170747757,
0.3680056035518646,
0.09548076242208481,
-0.5041251182556152,
0.28598570823669434,
0.44373106956481934,
-0.018746498972177505,
-0.4589383602142334,
-0.8074552416801453,
-0.1862896829843521,
-0.5199113488197327,
0.06940446048974991,
-0.4235793650150299,
-1.1987255811691284,
0.5076669454574585,
0.13025341928005219,
-0.05848032981157303,
0.14667052030563354,
0.031951893121004105,
0.06580555438995361,
0.7579825520515442,
0.5296239256858826,
0.05260416865348816,
0.7692403197288513,
-0.3374961316585541,
-0.10218056291341782,
-0.5955713391304016,
-0.1691044270992279,
-0.7815324068069458,
-0.003847583197057247,
-0.9026340246200562,
-0.5181537866592407,
-0.056150540709495544,
0.3236891031265259,
-0.22773127257823944,
0.6509398818016052,
-1.0448975563049316,
0.5372592806816101,
0.44800060987472534,
0.049213606864213943,
0.27016258239746094,
0.1980353593826294,
-0.1271953284740448,
0.09833543747663498,
-0.6787456274032593,
-0.14890260994434357,
0.8635153770446777,
0.1627335101366043,
1.0167698860168457,
0.08809258788824081,
1.2628586292266846,
0.46760401129722595,
0.6784945726394653,
-0.20818227529525757,
0.3262023329734802,
-0.21245847642421722,
-0.911961019039154,
0.06271931529045105,
-0.9646431803703308,
-1.028629183769226,
0.37973979115486145,
0.12381818145513535,
-0.3954058587551117,
0.5001860857009888,
0.2995486259460449,
-0.028176257386803627,
-0.14147986471652985,
-0.6761138439178467,
0.7442433834075928,
-0.09352496266365051,
-0.37763747572898865,
-0.2825951874256134,
-0.5109952092170715,
0.1649942845106125,
-0.21733105182647705,
0.21090823411941528,
-0.035477165132761,
-0.37877941131591797,
0.18647626042366028,
-0.16940052807331085,
0.4705491065979004,
-0.2940180003643036,
-0.07716141641139984,
0.4164331555366516,
0.608795166015625,
0.49940237402915955,
0.21315540373325348,
-0.3515905439853668,
0.17657876014709473,
-0.08848311007022858,
-0.4325202703475952,
-0.4852752089500427,
0.8105748891830444,
-0.47769466042518616,
-0.8311216831207275,
-0.42472925782203674,
-0.10048334300518036,
0.11400210112333298,
0.4570227861404419,
0.38354387879371643,
0.2828967273235321,
0.27426478266716003,
0.3522300720214844,
0.6182140111923218,
-0.23072463274002075,
0.3366306722164154,
0.6318076848983765,
-0.7040894031524658,
-0.7333150506019592,
1.1186604499816895,
0.04733145609498024,
0.4003197252750397,
0.3629719018936157,
-0.032606448978185654,
-0.2822870910167694,
-0.3751084804534912,
-0.22619938850402832,
0.13664264976978302,
-0.7971799969673157,
-0.6700300574302673,
-0.712909460067749,
-0.17299750447273254,
-0.3983142673969269,
-0.23631404340267181,
-0.46172383427619934,
-0.27893969416618347,
-0.33494219183921814,
0.100710429251194,
0.24018234014511108,
0.488780677318573,
-0.01732231304049492,
-0.03537461534142494,
-1.050009846687317,
0.6707225441932678,
0.18458382785320282,
0.753541111946106,
-0.1291390061378479,
-0.5933438539505005,
-0.172015979886055,
-0.16741272807121277,
-0.039011672139167786,
-0.6684201955795288,
0.4490848183631897,
0.03623426705598831,
0.9694375395774841,
0.27593794465065,
0.43772006034851074,
0.5394533276557922,
-0.221028670668602,
0.2316562533378601,
-0.01505893561989069,
-0.680960476398468,
0.666602611541748,
-0.2268364131450653,
0.34744009375572205,
0.8673093318939209,
0.2815544009208679,
-0.0666031762957573,
-0.6373664736747742,
-0.5412207245826721,
-1.047633409500122,
0.5054356455802917,
0.2217768430709839,
-0.04039856046438217,
-0.3518344759941101,
0.5293592810630798,
0.10747350007295609,
0.3150714039802551,
-0.5577015280723572,
-0.31186342239379883,
-0.31303584575653076,
0.1628512144088745,
0.28667038679122925,
-0.40151405334472656,
0.1086563691496849,
0.022659920156002045,
0.4962364137172699,
-0.2299518883228302,
0.10710558295249939,
0.42316940426826477,
-0.26660123467445374,
-0.16858422756195068,
0.16213294863700867,
0.17514681816101074,
0.9228332042694092,
-0.21955914795398712,
-0.15890908241271973,
-0.08572424948215485,
-0.31761878728866577,
0.10101096332073212,
0.07294657826423645,
-0.25172799825668335,
0.10247458517551422,
0.134492889046669,
0.01266258955001831,
0.28069907426834106,
-0.6659192442893982,
0.3735365569591522,
-0.09433607012033463,
0.028913229703903198,
-0.5270278453826904,
0.4013788104057312,
-0.31687065958976746,
0.26608511805534363,
0.7598399519920349,
0.2966274917125702,
0.34717220067977905,
-0.10287994146347046,
0.8287066221237183,
0.19951525330543518,
-0.48519885540008545,
0.4700620472431183,
0.6776939630508423,
0.19798414409160614,
-0.25567081570625305,
0.5858737230300903,
-0.2238803654909134,
-0.1539498269557953,
0.7125048637390137,
0.3534057140350342,
1.0492855310440063,
-0.2921355962753296,
0.22242441773414612,
0.4587583839893341,
-0.10346297919750214,
-0.22533628344535828,
0.30845800042152405,
-0.34360039234161377,
-0.31567811965942383,
-0.5643085241317749,
-0.8018323183059692,
-0.05299992114305496,
-0.4523751437664032,
-1.022829532623291,
0.005507167894393206,
-0.4619852602481842,
-0.3674280345439911,
-0.6386823654174805,
-0.040861405432224274,
-0.33031171560287476,
0.02774522826075554,
-0.1067357063293457,
1.1834938526153564,
-0.0021298008505254984,
0.8619804978370667,
0.37476155161857605,
-0.5679804086685181,
-0.662326455116272,
-0.049407850950956345,
-0.23202407360076904,
-0.5187152624130249,
0.5155122876167297,
0.2761823832988739,
-0.18829816579818726,
0.05605565756559372,
-0.24537065625190735,
-1.1164661645889282,
0.9603946805000305,
0.38376033306121826,
-0.6591841578483582,
0.10762236267328262,
-0.34992581605911255,
0.6077843308448792,
-0.5765599608421326,
0.3031844198703766,
0.3755894899368286,
0.41084176301956177,
0.19558484852313995,
-0.5970996618270874,
0.0550726056098938,
-0.14789395034313202,
0.3878171145915985,
0.31164222955703735,
-0.5511044859886169,
0.5376812815666199,
-0.2343997210264206,
-0.32579630613327026,
0.33247432112693787,
0.8698626756668091,
0.6190984845161438,
0.16624461114406586,
0.4184034466743469,
0.28547775745391846,
0.478077232837677,
0.06506800651550293,
1.333788275718689,
-0.5274752974510193,
0.5276519656181335,
1.132943868637085,
-0.16409553587436676,
0.7809434533119202,
0.5722135305404663,
0.17768104374408722,
0.3732949197292328,
0.37917909026145935,
-0.17388245463371277,
0.6757296919822693,
0.28311148285865784,
0.07648160308599472,
-0.42148497700691223,
-0.07937780022621155,
-0.6768369674682617,
0.390390545129776,
0.10172034054994583,
-0.6275721192359924,
-0.19900977611541748,
-0.09538300335407257,
-0.39672476053237915,
0.42873701453208923,
-0.20113374292850494,
0.7186593413352966,
0.2218165397644043,
-0.9529796838760376,
0.7329167723655701,
-0.28514519333839417,
0.6041039824485779,
-0.5124378800392151,
-0.25508546829223633,
-0.5403770804405212,
0.41815975308418274,
-0.4062161445617676,
-0.5734907984733582,
0.3712923526763916,
-0.12742382287979126,
-0.2834881544113159,
-0.5981431007385254,
0.7836170196533203,
-0.3956384062767029,
-0.18999402225017548,
0.888393759727478,
0.5207822918891907,
-0.03784208372235298,
0.04439115151762962,
-0.801045835018158,
0.17540784180164337,
0.15205560624599457,
-0.49970683455467224,
0.5207701921463013,
0.33141422271728516,
0.19879558682441711,
0.8887353539466858,
0.5393988490104675,
-0.12377828359603882,
-0.06750363111495972,
0.24877800047397614,
1.0141676664352417,
-0.5746932625770569,
-0.3614366352558136,
-0.4322948455810547,
0.3168792724609375,
-0.058754194527864456,
-0.08796180784702301,
0.7147848606109619,
0.6432742476463318,
1.3188257217407227,
-0.1224970668554306,
0.4386695623397827,
-0.1874774843454361,
0.7425594925880432,
-0.31983211636543274,
0.8149042129516602,
-0.6689745783805847,
0.5578691959381104,
-0.12211504578590393,
-0.9262142181396484,
-0.17530415952205658,
0.7968756556510925,
-0.12740126252174377,
0.4134502708911896,
0.3181940019130707,
0.9262863397598267,
0.1631220132112503,
-0.2991989850997925,
0.5073000192642212,
-0.13930664956569672,
0.11015427857637405,
0.13850317895412445,
0.897237241268158,
-0.34656500816345215,
0.9100080132484436,
-0.368923544883728,
-0.044501759111881256,
-0.25387537479400635,
-0.717800498008728,
-0.748160719871521,
-0.26750215888023376,
-0.00982959195971489,
-0.5996410846710205,
0.1113816648721695,
0.7947148084640503,
0.6638152599334717,
-0.9072933197021484,
-0.16490744054317474,
-0.021147165447473526,
0.3889271914958954,
-0.2192593812942505,
-0.25481918454170227,
-0.09054174274206161,
-0.7799241542816162,
-0.46587079763412476,
0.3580743670463562,
0.26583215594291687,
-0.26998621225357056,
-0.1964864730834961,
-0.32129719853401184,
-0.14046134054660797,
-0.4155990779399872,
0.2594105303287506,
0.40283071994781494,
-0.7147318124771118,
-0.11983015388250351,
0.27681511640548706,
-0.6630749106407166,
0.23317033052444458,
1.0932013988494873,
-1.1974772214889526,
0.4779038429260254,
0.7009801864624023,
0.7899235486984253,
0.4797164499759674,
0.1568143218755722,
0.5517855286598206,
-0.7493458390235901,
0.0997496098279953,
0.5657217502593994,
0.3773883879184723,
-0.011141481809318066,
-0.5135170817375183,
0.864850640296936,
-0.11647462844848633,
-0.7515518665313721,
-0.6884875297546387,
0.36037033796310425,
-0.4512120187282562,
-0.6521233916282654,
1.0294114351272583,
-0.3835065960884094,
-0.29436400532722473,
-0.21704833209514618,
0.026052141562104225,
0.2124558836221695,
-0.5882333517074585,
0.7741597890853882,
0.10188669711351395,
-0.009871138259768486,
-0.4231368899345398,
-0.4403723180294037,
0.5768356323242188,
0.33890897035598755,
-0.37354394793510437,
-0.036730483174324036,
0.7879010438919067,
0.22343501448631287,
0.21379660069942474,
0.6437294483184814,
-0.1951989084482193,
0.3956378996372223,
-0.19347091019153595,
0.17112691700458527,
-0.10226332396268845,
-0.5885062217712402,
-0.2932969927787781,
0.41228631138801575,
-0.10377166420221329,
0.07013261318206787
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.12094v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.12094v1
|
Are LLMs Good Cryptic Crossword Solvers?
| 2024-03-15T06:57:08 | 2024-03-15T06:57:08 |
Abdelrahman "Boda" Sadallah, Daria Kotova, Ekaterina Kochmar
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Cryptic crosswords are puzzles that rely not only on general knowledge but
also on the solver's ability to manipulate language on different levels and
deal with various types of wordplay. Previous research suggests that solving
such puzzles is a challenge even for modern NLP models. However, the abilities
of large language models (LLMs) have not yet been tested on this task. In this
paper, we establish the benchmark results for three popular LLMs -- LLaMA2,
Mistral, and ChatGPT -- showing that their performance on this task is still
far from that of humans.
|
[
-0.21213743090629578,
-0.2766050696372986,
0.6708393096923828,
0.28535428643226624,
-0.48634055256843567,
0.42230746150016785,
-0.22651027143001556,
-0.9921199679374695,
0.10826046019792557,
0.36244747042655945,
-0.6120595932006836,
-0.5406299829483032,
-1.0196774005889893,
0.5057801604270935,
-0.7522788643836975,
0.7986756563186646,
-0.2692234218120575,
0.003012311179190874,
-0.028056152164936066,
-0.18039962649345398,
-0.2658481001853943,
-0.6982513070106506,
-0.7085464596748352,
-0.3517566919326782,
0.8214728236198425,
-0.0830710157752037,
0.8053710460662842,
0.6970123648643494,
0.698375940322876,
0.30673930048942566,
-0.49615541100502014,
0.2659600079059601,
-0.7197362780570984,
0.29419946670532227,
-0.446499764919281,
-1.0214192867279053,
0.23594410717487335,
-0.04331379011273384,
0.30873045325279236,
0.5612981915473938,
-0.16736336052417755,
0.00459646712988615,
0.05787551403045654,
0.39706143736839294,
-0.36472299695014954,
0.007205980829894543,
-0.8715934157371521,
0.09786753356456757,
-0.5724635720252991,
-0.03397012874484062,
-0.008174008689820766,
-0.39659953117370605,
0.238742396235466,
-0.6323931217193604,
0.4311353862285614,
0.3135751485824585,
0.6253227591514587,
0.668755292892456,
-0.33269211649894714,
-0.8723334074020386,
-0.8937351703643799,
0.77909255027771,
-0.7726507782936096,
0.15830793976783752,
0.19321298599243164,
0.48249536752700806,
-0.44005629420280457,
-0.6951873302459717,
-0.1096302792429924,
-0.23889824748039246,
-0.011034040711820126,
-0.018636254593729973,
-0.5020231008529663,
0.02428136207163334,
0.2699069678783417,
0.3952832818031311,
-0.4357031583786011,
0.4742000997066498,
-0.23833073675632477,
-0.12930122017860413,
0.5231643915176392,
0.6690340042114258,
0.3486412465572357,
0.16042128205299377,
-0.48475608229637146,
0.3670143187046051,
-0.7949166893959045,
-0.0777026042342186,
0.2320055216550827,
-0.07140593230724335,
0.05121428146958351,
0.8091806173324585,
-0.05451983958482742,
0.5744533538818359,
-0.2771317660808563,
-0.21934117376804352,
-0.1355498880147934,
-0.25431618094444275,
0.3730993866920471,
-0.17702549695968628,
0.7086406350135803,
0.3338903784751892,
0.5979188680648804,
-0.6616009473800659,
-0.46836012601852417,
0.3210875391960144,
-0.02092200145125389,
-0.31167736649513245,
-0.12802676856517792,
0.11020849645137787,
-0.3663949966430664,
-0.011561859399080276,
-0.3543787896633148,
-0.29925069212913513,
-0.18431133031845093,
0.10126722604036331,
0.43518728017807007,
-0.2085457295179367,
0.046939682215452194,
0.3410206139087677,
-0.4810921847820282,
0.24134641885757446,
0.3648662567138672,
-0.6890299320220947,
0.39536428451538086,
0.7378581166267395,
0.856042742729187,
-0.645695686340332,
-0.38364434242248535,
-0.311105877161026,
0.11230366677045822,
-0.372316837310791,
0.9173815250396729,
-0.6216217875480652,
-0.3652683198451996,
-0.10986420512199402,
-0.03464442864060402,
0.05990288779139519,
-0.8541120290756226,
0.4370194971561432,
-0.4672103524208069,
-0.10109272599220276,
-0.5431901216506958,
-0.4747859537601471,
0.05389711260795593,
0.31819555163383484,
-0.7501254081726074,
0.970809817314148,
0.041506458073854446,
-0.8598771095275879,
0.047168001532554626,
-0.05506888031959534,
-0.2744157910346985,
0.11320440471172333,
-0.16170190274715424,
-0.017243938520550728,
0.29230639338493347,
0.14138130843639374,
0.3236841857433319,
-0.7915300130844116,
0.06951271742582321,
-0.016116483137011528,
-0.6081523299217224,
0.5031044483184814,
-0.1725456565618515,
0.3412722647190094,
0.07736561447381973,
-0.45168960094451904,
-0.33414167165756226,
-0.6129319071769714,
-0.08077872544527054,
0.12960417568683624,
-0.39790084958076477,
-0.22995226085186005,
0.08872292190790176,
-0.16858293116092682,
0.3610042929649353,
0.27415233850479126,
-0.60127192735672,
0.18456542491912842,
-0.2637871205806732,
0.5265095233917236,
0.4392973482608795,
-0.18100270628929138,
-0.08387982845306396,
-0.596860408782959,
0.8564220666885376,
0.007179408799856901,
-0.2206907868385315,
0.23461420834064484,
-0.9367815852165222,
-0.7658557891845703,
-0.24969366192817688,
0.3955109715461731,
0.7294856309890747,
-0.9455100297927856,
-0.01827317290008068,
-0.015010417439043522,
-0.7103656530380249,
-0.5418055653572083,
0.39704403281211853,
0.6182088851928711,
-0.07129199057817459,
0.23563936352729797,
-0.07131724804639816,
-0.39018160104751587,
-0.9204232096672058,
-0.8921750783920288,
0.07130476087331772,
-0.2666228115558624,
0.23526473343372345,
0.4732198119163513,
-0.2546732425689697,
0.6457626819610596,
-0.2837091088294983,
-0.3207310438156128,
-0.25394564867019653,
0.32880812883377075,
0.1910599172115326,
-0.02451377548277378,
0.3322809338569641,
-0.4719812572002411,
-0.2543431222438812,
-0.07882923632860184,
-0.6667639017105103,
-0.39647573232650757,
0.26418402791023254,
0.44286516308784485,
-0.06439720839262009,
0.5703109502792358,
-0.7496946454048157,
0.2808726131916046,
0.8722763061523438,
-0.06769496947526932,
0.5141416788101196,
-0.15657106041908264,
-0.37097856402397156,
-0.8682730197906494,
-0.05358537286520004,
-0.0976366177201271,
-0.25113341212272644,
-0.7305078506469727,
0.16298767924308777,
-0.03409751504659653,
0.21032515168190002,
-0.5295582413673401,
0.48576852679252625,
-0.8075488805770874,
-0.12833328545093536,
-0.26632624864578247,
0.308794766664505,
-0.4483366012573242,
0.13262514770030975,
0.4188072979450226,
0.532496452331543,
0.46883177757263184,
-0.4687976837158203,
0.5840555429458618,
-0.0028459457680583,
-0.6506657004356384,
0.06276553869247437,
-0.9386860728263855,
0.2632213234901428,
0.004098949953913689,
0.23783209919929504,
-1.28584885597229,
0.08207451552152634,
-0.0006321492255665362,
-0.16225731372833252,
-0.07657893002033234,
0.1041460856795311,
-0.7173609733581543,
-0.537057101726532,
-0.014590729027986526,
0.6702824234962463,
0.3563935458660126,
-0.5681754350662231,
0.31608647108078003,
0.04267428442835808,
-0.11457233875989914,
-0.5572489500045776,
-0.8591631650924683,
0.295674592256546,
-0.20464573800563812,
-0.3350192904472351,
0.44741711020469666,
-0.03289582580327988,
-0.27891039848327637,
-0.0457112081348896,
-0.10839326679706573,
0.18444080650806427,
-0.07109412550926208,
0.19888579845428467,
-0.06966017931699753,
-0.2504766881465912,
-0.011107174679636955,
-0.4286898970603943,
-0.26744258403778076,
0.15214316546916962,
0.30376681685447693,
0.699171245098114,
-0.10333355516195297,
-0.49154627323150635,
-0.0399472713470459,
0.4048283100128174,
0.3437480926513672,
-0.39749401807785034,
0.41461479663848877,
0.5158789753913879,
-0.34040600061416626,
-0.20773985981941223,
-0.954430103302002,
0.03773773834109306,
-0.4560511112213135,
0.3289428651332855,
-0.476345419883728,
-1.37360417842865,
1.0614876747131348,
-0.23015829920768738,
-0.09981872886419296,
0.3756309449672699,
0.7438764572143555,
0.27149173617362976,
0.948189914226532,
0.4148240089416504,
-0.07413538545370102,
-0.1706066131591797,
0.11540162563323975,
0.19914697110652924,
-0.7688165307044983,
-0.30890122056007385,
-0.7180038094520569,
-0.5617386102676392,
-0.8504199981689453,
-0.5988889336585999,
0.20984038710594177,
0.21903333067893982,
0.147555872797966,
0.4134696424007416,
-0.5407276749610901,
0.592389702796936,
0.39732301235198975,
-0.13287264108657837,
0.509273111820221,
-0.27209901809692383,
-0.01758839562535286,
-0.17436090111732483,
-0.7600166201591492,
-0.23810966312885284,
1.1699236631393433,
0.41416701674461365,
1.2550880908966064,
0.16144831478595734,
0.7859740257263184,
-0.34908780455589294,
0.2338731586933136,
-0.6419825553894043,
0.5133852362632751,
-0.20922064781188965,
-0.8783087134361267,
-0.17922255396842957,
-0.5035965442657471,
-1.0983964204788208,
0.16901040077209473,
-0.17845356464385986,
-0.8824452757835388,
0.06003587320446968,
-0.42028018832206726,
-0.31802889704704285,
0.4043240249156952,
-0.18402527272701263,
0.2206754982471466,
-0.4392988979816437,
0.06986954063177109,
0.0963146761059761,
-0.6534222960472107,
0.5412058234214783,
-0.13479068875312805,
0.07307333499193192,
-0.279710978269577,
-0.7590950727462769,
0.7540183663368225,
0.012219584546983242,
0.6389308571815491,
0.3341343104839325,
-0.4424775242805481,
0.18848490715026855,
0.25014615058898926,
0.7354859709739685,
0.039987605065107346,
0.02615542896091938,
0.3162141442298889,
0.020945444703102112,
-0.18184126913547516,
-0.5644257664680481,
0.6265408396720886,
-0.7535273432731628,
-0.8645650148391724,
-0.3458506464958191,
-0.8097880482673645,
-0.2238314151763916,
0.032225288450717926,
0.6486930251121521,
0.239887535572052,
-0.07253710180521011,
0.13872508704662323,
0.7631752490997314,
0.0015093485126271844,
0.36262157559394836,
0.4790072441101074,
-0.04647115245461464,
-0.22347848117351532,
0.6816842555999756,
0.2664450705051422,
0.3635919690132141,
0.618276059627533,
0.18904301524162292,
-0.2612285912036896,
-0.8595889806747437,
-0.17115718126296997,
0.3541383445262909,
-0.6367015242576599,
-0.13327760994434357,
-0.7150481343269348,
-0.5349622964859009,
0.10439379513263702,
-0.021875182166695595,
-0.22089049220085144,
-0.5860176682472229,
-0.15264159440994263,
0.32185935974121094,
0.24905472993850708,
1.0766316652297974,
0.07815297693014145,
0.2925705909729004,
-0.6614591479301453,
0.6569819450378418,
0.6402231454849243,
0.3207380175590515,
-0.22759614884853363,
-0.3754109740257263,
-0.01613258570432663,
-0.2918500006198883,
0.04671100527048111,
-0.8021705150604248,
0.16620847582817078,
-0.017113028094172478,
0.8016031980514526,
0.38119807839393616,
-0.1794690042734146,
0.3289470970630646,
-0.411254346370697,
0.951949954032898,
0.09994824975728989,
-0.638128936290741,
0.07836863398551941,
-0.3403264582157135,
0.576370120048523,
0.3448008596897125,
0.7242497205734253,
-0.6461668014526367,
-0.8282425999641418,
-0.3559548258781433,
-0.5036854147911072,
0.4156467616558075,
0.39049965143203735,
-0.05367356911301613,
-0.12151797860860825,
0.614825963973999,
0.14886543154716492,
0.2535269558429718,
-0.7704640030860901,
-0.39493176341056824,
0.2553061842918396,
-0.06286154687404633,
-0.44811028242111206,
-0.37548092007637024,
-0.1903008371591568,
0.04531916230916977,
0.08396052569150925,
0.11321616172790527,
0.157634437084198,
0.0838095024228096,
-0.008836260065436363,
-0.23432160913944244,
0.24852614104747772,
0.7195537686347961,
0.6416917443275452,
-0.20472905039787292,
0.1731637567281723,
0.45691102743148804,
-0.5659604668617249,
0.30046963691711426,
0.12871073186397552,
0.11512552201747894,
0.23687976598739624,
0.6655480861663818,
0.325790673494339,
0.39862769842147827,
-0.804719090461731,
0.43528684973716736,
-0.23062646389007568,
-0.4652882218360901,
-0.01396836619824171,
0.1936594843864441,
0.5694012641906738,
0.4873938262462616,
0.43888047337532043,
-0.2199658304452896,
0.19731354713439941,
-0.6432641744613647,
-0.29754573106765747,
0.8109415769577026,
-0.21444231271743774,
-0.13024845719337463,
0.8379811644554138,
0.11995074152946472,
-0.5313008427619934,
0.41925516724586487,
-0.11573095619678497,
-0.9694175720214844,
0.6400337219238281,
0.8117032051086426,
0.7915868759155273,
-0.4273119866847992,
-0.19195067882537842,
-0.00478588929399848,
0.7079790830612183,
-0.29341936111450195,
0.36236482858657837,
0.07581304758787155,
-0.7285254597663879,
-0.4308871030807495,
-0.30782434344291687,
-0.5592745542526245,
0.24261601269245148,
-0.46796274185180664,
0.0483349934220314,
-0.39516937732696533,
-0.1444273591041565,
-0.06231774762272835,
0.11425644904375076,
-0.9029791951179504,
0.08416670560836792,
0.32135435938835144,
1.1795655488967896,
-0.4781970977783203,
0.6870971918106079,
0.613525927066803,
0.185939222574234,
-0.5764017105102539,
-0.16000039875507355,
-0.007230235729366541,
-0.8398721218109131,
0.8723801374435425,
0.17341487109661102,
-0.1487390100955963,
-0.13707979023456573,
-0.42956313490867615,
-1.0579032897949219,
1.0416532754898071,
0.2935456931591034,
-1.0860530138015747,
-0.6742965579032898,
0.7829963564872742,
0.7136216163635254,
-0.44105929136276245,
0.4133235514163971,
0.6548526287078857,
0.47441938519477844,
0.04412776231765747,
-1.1624902486801147,
0.09041175991296768,
-0.0841134712100029,
0.22743725776672363,
0.15503953397274017,
-0.8991439938545227,
1.1126923561096191,
-0.1425183266401291,
-0.18064112961292267,
0.4957839548587799,
0.4850434958934784,
0.44312962889671326,
0.1029280573129654,
0.48576870560646057,
0.8368907570838928,
0.4665110409259796,
-0.24402837455272675,
0.8556263446807861,
-0.38505470752716064,
0.1687779426574707,
0.9419956207275391,
-0.283719003200531,
0.8311997652053833,
0.5238186120986938,
-0.15309694409370422,
0.3619764745235443,
0.5966407656669617,
0.0589526928961277,
0.38656264543533325,
0.7634392976760864,
-0.09537100791931152,
-0.6341979503631592,
0.14473171532154083,
-0.48266249895095825,
0.5273336172103882,
0.6075642108917236,
-0.24186669290065765,
-0.550458550453186,
-0.3656995892524719,
-0.29554054141044617,
-0.10776456445455551,
-0.39394429326057434,
0.6371458768844604,
0.5374211668968201,
-0.5476487278938293,
0.6379398703575134,
0.01784033142030239,
1.0340709686279297,
-0.6050710082054138,
0.08843568712472916,
-0.18447686731815338,
0.12293334305286407,
-0.043085817247629166,
-0.9784809350967407,
0.0505143366754055,
-0.017269782721996307,
0.16447776556015015,
0.3012729287147522,
0.9051847457885742,
-0.5121679306030273,
-0.42938101291656494,
0.5460570454597473,
0.6852515935897827,
0.2340911328792572,
-0.1833115518093109,
-0.5940079092979431,
0.10908249020576477,
-0.3226545453071594,
-0.14481744170188904,
0.13444077968597412,
0.5987497568130493,
-0.08554933220148087,
1.1167904138565063,
0.3937847316265106,
0.20348219573497772,
0.3977714776992798,
-0.1872703582048416,
0.9028606414794922,
-0.9763182401657104,
-0.14100301265716553,
-0.7672552466392517,
-0.007795026991516352,
0.2813371419906616,
-0.6078667044639587,
0.9651845693588257,
0.6155372262001038,
0.6379527449607849,
0.059827279299497604,
0.5902711749076843,
0.39591914415359497,
0.7292742729187012,
-0.5726402997970581,
0.5162935853004456,
-0.3689177632331848,
0.16414570808410645,
-0.18142539262771606,
-1.2322880029678345,
-0.32185447216033936,
0.08904165029525757,
-0.2884094715118408,
-0.032663460820913315,
0.6894568800926208,
0.8432484269142151,
0.018339689821004868,
0.22650213539600372,
0.3352619409561157,
0.11721250414848328,
0.17546261847019196,
1.2072168588638306,
1.5242149829864502,
-0.3736530840396881,
0.7674267888069153,
-0.14622825384140015,
-0.028280846774578094,
-0.15270349383354187,
-0.8127416372299194,
-1.4631394147872925,
-0.33391764760017395,
0.08954121172428131,
-0.02685559168457985,
0.3050365447998047,
0.5292357802391052,
0.2962055206298828,
-0.4811801612377167,
-0.19179517030715942,
0.05903251841664314,
0.11207645386457443,
-0.11320385336875916,
-0.0968494713306427,
0.11582857370376587,
-0.20097783207893372,
-0.5701203942298889,
0.2319951206445694,
0.16456462442874908,
0.06976014375686646,
-0.4482509195804596,
0.040814358741045,
-0.09036681056022644,
0.23671658337116241,
0.5008404850959778,
0.06625708192586899,
-1.0173366069793701,
-0.30583682656288147,
0.018994366750121117,
-0.26006412506103516,
-0.214944526553154,
0.8770405650138855,
-0.7986962199211121,
0.10851067304611206,
0.5317895412445068,
0.675145149230957,
0.7148290276527405,
-0.0543794110417366,
0.27784061431884766,
-0.33649876713752747,
-0.13152192533016205,
0.37096306681632996,
0.2521555721759796,
0.21599407494068146,
-0.3003241717815399,
0.6183474659919739,
0.14000408351421356,
-0.7008084058761597,
-0.6543149948120117,
0.1427307277917862,
-0.8405274152755737,
-0.16615356504917145,
1.3604025840759277,
0.009995141066610813,
-0.46180593967437744,
-0.2545507550239563,
-0.03191502392292023,
-0.043426044285297394,
-0.013151527382433414,
0.7456463575363159,
1.0093474388122559,
-0.0947713851928711,
-0.20716828107833862,
-0.5744134187698364,
0.623593270778656,
0.5370029211044312,
-0.5867152214050293,
-0.20140290260314941,
-0.25907236337661743,
0.5023306012153625,
0.29843437671661377,
0.41377347707748413,
-0.015797240659594536,
0.3272261619567871,
-0.1240801066160202,
-0.23095153272151947,
0.19152621924877167,
-0.2590676546096802,
-0.16436058282852173,
-0.16771240532398224,
0.17973843216896057,
0.14253169298171997
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10056v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10056v1
|
Don't Half-listen: Capturing Key-part Information in Continual Instruction Tuning
| 2024-03-15T06:54:20 | 2024-03-15T06:54:20 |
Yongquan He, Xuancheng Huang, Minghao Tang, Lingxun Meng, Xiang Li, Wei Lin, Wenyuan Zhang, Yifu Gao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Instruction tuning for large language models (LLMs) can drive them to produce
results consistent with human goals in specific downstream tasks. However, the
process of continual instruction tuning (CIT) for LLMs may bring about the
catastrophic forgetting (CF) problem, where previously learned abilities are
degraded. Recent methods try to alleviate the CF problem by modifying models or
replaying data, which may only remember the surface-level pattern of
instructions and get confused on held-out tasks. In this paper, we propose a
novel continual instruction tuning method based on Key-part Information Gain
(KPIG). Our method computes the information gain on masked parts to dynamically
replay data and refine the training objective, which enables LLMs to capture
task-aware information relevant to the correct response and alleviate
overfitting to general descriptions in instructions. In addition, we propose
two metrics, P-score and V-score, to measure the generalization and
instruction-following abilities of LLMs. Experiments demonstrate our method
achieves superior performance on both seen and held-out tasks.
|
[
-0.1601460725069046,
-0.7773132920265198,
0.5171725749969482,
0.04835343733429909,
-0.4353359639644623,
0.2918129563331604,
-0.4577365517616272,
0.03969148173928261,
0.09723124653100967,
0.4501884877681732,
-0.7224026322364807,
-0.731478750705719,
-0.6286152005195618,
-0.5096203088760376,
-0.058288827538490295,
0.6310985088348389,
0.23104549944400787,
0.0192242618650198,
-0.20503740012645721,
0.13494932651519775,
-0.6756808757781982,
-0.3820282816886902,
-0.9044933915138245,
-0.2942739427089691,
0.43295952677726746,
0.8919421434402466,
0.247003436088562,
0.9334473609924316,
0.08550189435482025,
0.21489441394805908,
0.04914342612028122,
0.23095527291297913,
-0.5415935516357422,
0.13238392770290375,
-0.05512615665793419,
-0.7784168124198914,
-0.5998147130012512,
0.006116798613220453,
0.8260990381240845,
0.4467383027076721,
-0.30654099583625793,
0.3554057478904724,
0.21526770293712616,
0.7885308265686035,
-0.5989174246788025,
0.5026375651359558,
-0.8512881398200989,
-0.005990318953990936,
-0.16323943436145782,
-0.5042353868484497,
-0.6364601254463196,
-0.2823276221752167,
-0.32140880823135376,
-0.6254758834838867,
0.41314080357551575,
0.1353301852941513,
0.5456604361534119,
0.5179415941238403,
-0.036053214222192764,
-0.47131943702697754,
-0.5678223371505737,
0.7592989802360535,
-0.875192403793335,
0.38844484090805054,
0.7179192900657654,
0.06229915842413902,
-0.36905962228775024,
-0.21819226443767548,
-0.5394323468208313,
-0.2359510213136673,
0.14465485513210297,
0.2460099309682846,
0.23454323410987854,
0.2883630692958832,
0.07606005668640137,
0.27163708209991455,
-0.3116267919540405,
-0.07399190962314606,
-0.26508086919784546,
-0.35443177819252014,
0.38899722695350647,
-0.08750031143426895,
0.1232612282037735,
0.38038086891174316,
-0.2621198296546936,
-0.20821496844291687,
-0.9249473214149475,
0.0031170090660452843,
0.06803971529006958,
0.06488119065761566,
0.06725822389125824,
0.15730343759059906,
-0.0009587652748450637,
0.6542089581489563,
0.448391318321228,
-0.2794787287712097,
0.08359931409358978,
-0.11042395979166031,
-0.27244940400123596,
0.2808155119419098,
0.5357615947723389,
0.4799668490886688,
0.2004653960466385,
-0.5945900082588196,
-0.0022647820878773928,
-0.062319524586200714,
0.3144226670265198,
-0.4403071999549866,
-0.396745502948761,
-0.09672000259160995,
-0.29167813062667847,
0.14332367479801178,
-0.09453298151493073,
-0.6595332622528076,
0.03993762657046318,
-0.5423448085784912,
0.428855836391449,
-0.568766713142395,
-0.20090730488300323,
0.03821413591504097,
0.020511211827397346,
0.3512336015701294,
-0.08670637011528015,
-0.735847532749176,
0.10664591193199158,
0.8328806757926941,
0.7748947739601135,
-0.06458166241645813,
-0.31945329904556274,
-0.7804180979728699,
0.19531980156898499,
-0.48417457938194275,
0.47926291823387146,
-0.598546028137207,
-0.38115009665489197,
0.007839573547244072,
0.138654887676239,
-0.4092639684677124,
-0.7926660776138306,
0.53989577293396,
-0.6285221576690674,
-0.12163864821195602,
-0.4638617932796478,
-0.9076020121574402,
-0.09755248576402664,
0.13174882531166077,
-0.2029343992471695,
0.8701350688934326,
-0.018005957826972008,
-0.1808205246925354,
0.5269809365272522,
-0.05155251920223236,
-0.43589332699775696,
0.04594728723168373,
-0.11965804547071457,
-0.7991945147514343,
0.35044416785240173,
0.10174985975027084,
0.43908655643463135,
0.2127765715122223,
0.06446174532175064,
-0.3253813087940216,
-0.7081721425056458,
-0.06391547620296478,
-0.2655033767223358,
0.019588036462664604,
-0.3267876207828522,
-0.4092545509338379,
-0.24918828904628754,
-0.6599130034446716,
0.27345818281173706,
-0.18077293038368225,
-0.5142994523048401,
-0.27211853861808777,
0.23899786174297333,
-0.5442238450050354,
0.0023817787878215313,
0.3154487907886505,
-0.7981864213943481,
0.27358290553092957,
-0.08323196321725845,
0.37795862555503845,
0.6758635640144348,
0.25883421301841736,
0.29555365443229675,
-0.6686937212944031,
0.5571610331535339,
-0.02986234612762928,
0.12692971527576447,
-0.5034549236297607,
-0.18757487833499908,
-1.2238434553146362,
-0.10438124090433121,
0.1831999123096466,
0.5603582859039307,
-0.7144702076911926,
0.42823901772499084,
-0.15987130999565125,
-0.33882537484169006,
-0.6800253391265869,
0.20800445973873138,
0.6193875074386597,
0.3682153820991516,
0.2887301445007324,
-0.08949481695890427,
-0.42836281657218933,
-0.6310756802558899,
-0.2840293347835541,
-0.12823832035064697,
-0.23457105457782745,
0.37377697229385376,
0.13366074860095978,
0.32939913868904114,
0.3630330264568329,
-0.2714514434337616,
-0.422717422246933,
0.1721678227186203,
0.24035660922527313,
0.14677079021930695,
0.518004298210144,
0.09194887429475784,
-0.33758974075317383,
-0.66087806224823,
-0.15949320793151855,
-0.4339938759803772,
-0.03864901512861252,
-0.39024263620376587,
-0.293396919965744,
0.08714086562395096,
0.8452915549278259,
-0.48260220885276794,
0.11980824917554855,
0.3583294749259949,
-0.2631114423274994,
0.30384886264801025,
-0.3918476998806,
0.2717747390270233,
-0.7364014387130737,
-0.08470109105110168,
-0.3247998356819153,
-0.49886173009872437,
-0.3226422369480133,
-0.12615738809108734,
0.485865980386734,
0.1294555962085724,
-0.15092560648918152,
0.16203179955482483,
-0.6574541926383972,
0.34029915928840637,
-0.6684669256210327,
0.1295366734266281,
-0.2709186375141144,
0.8615776896476746,
-0.14128144085407257,
0.8371834754943848,
0.5973799824714661,
-0.7883714437484741,
0.2877234220504761,
-0.17141307890415192,
-0.23877455294132233,
0.5690483450889587,
-0.40371081233024597,
0.5833179354667664,
-0.29092004895210266,
0.05854598805308342,
-0.8243281841278076,
0.026371875777840614,
0.2758542001247406,
-0.5403323173522949,
0.8802337050437927,
-0.2963457405567169,
-0.4778536260128021,
-0.13886454701423645,
-0.05519776791334152,
0.0974353775382042,
0.7105340957641602,
-0.3608873784542084,
0.46586674451828003,
0.31477877497673035,
-0.3340439200401306,
-0.11818186193704605,
-0.3331008553504944,
-0.15020953118801117,
-0.1598045378923416,
-0.10484624654054642,
0.5392962694168091,
-0.08876185864210129,
0.5430099964141846,
-0.16126170754432678,
-0.75741046667099,
0.08705338090658188,
-0.14018602669239044,
0.3094693124294281,
0.20229433476924896,
-0.2356119453907013,
0.437630295753479,
0.24349865317344666,
-0.12397779524326324,
0.19083468616008759,
-0.4791763126850128,
0.5109692215919495,
0.19744111597537994,
-0.3993266522884369,
-0.585983395576477,
0.43150079250335693,
0.7406783103942871,
0.005622141528874636,
0.45399442315101624,
0.44288116693496704,
-0.13587342202663422,
-0.3499263823032379,
-0.7409208416938782,
-0.203421950340271,
-0.4467960298061371,
0.536165177822113,
-0.12559308111667633,
-0.8435664176940918,
0.2397553026676178,
-0.3342059552669525,
0.19142644107341766,
0.06881306320428848,
0.4165491461753845,
-0.5614917278289795,
0.7867130637168884,
0.9987981915473938,
-0.5196186900138855,
0.5635499358177185,
-0.17158813774585724,
0.13495056331157684,
-0.8668006658554077,
-0.5374833941459656,
-0.37750038504600525,
-0.534286618232727,
-0.18516339361667633,
-0.4110238552093506,
0.5367907285690308,
0.53839111328125,
-0.17744587361812592,
0.16528752446174622,
-0.5195419192314148,
0.6028484106063843,
0.6815104484558105,
0.42036744952201843,
0.1960325539112091,
-0.10189638286828995,
0.13857512176036835,
-0.1156950518488884,
-0.7998233437538147,
-0.28688085079193115,
0.9223030805587769,
0.19781258702278137,
0.7832528948783875,
-0.2784292697906494,
0.6270283460617065,
0.4045219123363495,
0.10405828058719635,
-0.6314010620117188,
0.43964460492134094,
-0.1735314428806305,
-0.2933486998081207,
-0.24694834649562836,
-0.4452965557575226,
-0.508338451385498,
0.0031740593258291483,
0.35644468665122986,
-0.6847723126411438,
-0.023332899436354637,
0.7470178604125977,
-0.4039035737514496,
0.21482893824577332,
-0.6403323411941528,
0.5201312899589539,
-0.18447110056877136,
-0.07294482737779617,
-0.400058776140213,
-0.33916810154914856,
0.09567014873027802,
-0.023851407691836357,
0.030402187258005142,
-0.17407765984535217,
-0.11618517339229584,
0.767856776714325,
-0.1451544612646103,
1.075353980064392,
-0.3187231719493866,
0.12591563165187836,
0.1509980708360672,
0.001358097419142723,
0.5221980810165405,
-0.012586896307766438,
0.1181282252073288,
-0.08020102977752686,
0.09810111671686172,
-0.7114077806472778,
-0.7143839001655579,
0.6989372968673706,
-0.6042289137840271,
-0.5398144125938416,
-0.1882314234972,
-0.4224337935447693,
-0.5610479116439819,
0.019358446821570396,
0.4268008768558502,
0.016640106216073036,
0.05701678246259689,
0.27323922514915466,
1.063119888305664,
-0.04490172490477562,
0.3863815665245056,
0.7407698631286621,
0.26396444439888,
-0.30962544679641724,
1.1528551578521729,
0.10029301792383194,
0.6172239780426025,
0.46217408776283264,
0.03930560126900673,
-0.06088728457689285,
-0.2352912276983261,
-0.3734818398952484,
0.3271898329257965,
-0.24183739721775055,
-0.4670308530330658,
-0.1919577568769455,
-0.3197878301143646,
-0.03976232185959816,
-0.02913546934723854,
-0.5585232973098755,
0.03275877982378006,
-0.13398663699626923,
0.1611798256635666,
0.1020638570189476,
0.26843369007110596,
0.014692345634102821,
0.6421999335289001,
-0.8278059959411621,
0.14247065782546997,
0.173891082406044,
0.45195600390434265,
0.18491078913211823,
-0.7198024392127991,
-0.4444478750228882,
0.31987160444259644,
-0.5012139678001404,
-0.7075082659721375,
0.07584097236394882,
0.6947442889213562,
0.6845215559005737,
0.1426982432603836,
0.03158209100365639,
0.8176523447036743,
-0.43723630905151367,
0.5040608644485474,
0.05257832258939743,
-0.8860937356948853,
0.5688683390617371,
0.019083330407738686,
0.8467822670936584,
0.5002414584159851,
0.2854384481906891,
-0.6571438908576965,
-0.562432587146759,
-0.2881578505039215,
-0.8446736335754395,
0.7204456329345703,
-0.033446360379457474,
0.1525132805109024,
-0.03607390075922012,
0.6742669939994812,
-0.02263391762971878,
0.2992972433567047,
-0.25075578689575195,
-0.13707435131072998,
-0.0403340682387352,
-0.2280855029821396,
0.1172390729188919,
-0.3539486527442932,
0.1216125637292862,
-0.13661392033100128,
1.0129213333129883,
-0.07544754445552826,
0.3726790249347687,
0.08337997645139694,
-0.004127314314246178,
-0.16261780261993408,
0.2825581729412079,
0.6239309310913086,
0.45780548453330994,
-0.12502819299697876,
-0.06208020821213722,
0.17785927653312683,
-0.7202428579330444,
0.10687936842441559,
-0.3172692060470581,
-0.2518691420555115,
0.08539215475320816,
0.4717535078525543,
0.8047173619270325,
0.33464452624320984,
-0.4451802372932434,
0.2736067771911621,
0.04208967089653015,
-0.11016334593296051,
-0.5180737376213074,
0.3197166323661804,
0.1475515216588974,
0.34981128573417664,
0.2852455675601959,
-0.10304776579141617,
-0.3666340410709381,
-0.5978378653526306,
0.35192906856536865,
0.21591494977474213,
-0.575706958770752,
-0.33193454146385193,
0.3819943964481354,
-0.11036510765552521,
-0.5251217484474182,
0.8447476625442505,
-0.23794402182102203,
-0.6207268238067627,
0.5976372957229614,
0.5714006423950195,
0.6751193404197693,
-0.4234200417995453,
0.20623214542865753,
0.4429446756839752,
0.21307113766670227,
0.04805396869778633,
0.4149104952812195,
-0.6186517477035522,
-0.33157041668891907,
-0.6498432159423828,
-0.5321686267852783,
-0.1691390722990036,
0.4166041612625122,
-0.9053645133972168,
-0.1587538868188858,
-0.5303312540054321,
-0.088290274143219,
-0.25780022144317627,
-0.13304078578948975,
-0.5048291683197021,
0.06557998806238174,
0.06746196746826172,
0.8762865662574768,
-0.6170350909233093,
0.9686360955238342,
0.3096846342086792,
-0.13067753612995148,
-0.7149909734725952,
0.3360103368759155,
-0.13339462876319885,
-0.9371156692504883,
0.2789265811443329,
-0.10801590234041214,
-0.045217759907245636,
-0.04773096367716789,
-0.41095128655433655,
-0.7784260511398315,
1.0768728256225586,
0.33751949667930603,
-1.2533334493637085,
-0.3373905420303345,
0.024635253474116325,
0.21918751299381256,
-0.21637791395187378,
-0.11190977692604065,
0.9202260971069336,
0.27738937735557556,
0.37776827812194824,
-0.8935067653656006,
-0.26009422540664673,
0.027868101373314857,
-0.26070722937583923,
0.4803387522697449,
-0.9286986589431763,
0.4046066403388977,
0.014360493049025536,
-0.22373951971530914,
0.10963282734155655,
0.38735443353652954,
0.2028452754020691,
0.32191044092178345,
0.46105319261550903,
0.6263903379440308,
0.7382581830024719,
-0.18725042045116425,
0.5644873380661011,
-0.5096594095230103,
0.41212719678878784,
1.5143500566482544,
0.12991230189800262,
0.8520589470863342,
0.4211038649082184,
-0.008103488013148308,
0.0011573564261198044,
0.4194720983505249,
0.10162874311208725,
0.8799595832824707,
0.21510827541351318,
-0.43150031566619873,
-0.582673966884613,
0.24964667856693268,
-0.25097891688346863,
0.4089907705783844,
0.4854772984981537,
-0.4572126865386963,
-0.12982431054115295,
0.20182804763317108,
0.3261960744857788,
0.02771504782140255,
-0.44705238938331604,
0.9388899803161621,
0.29967954754829407,
-0.8065822720527649,
0.7250055074691772,
-0.16387899219989777,
0.5006614327430725,
-0.5462722182273865,
-0.2184726446866989,
-0.3768402636051178,
0.41376104950904846,
0.1922072321176529,
-0.3242079019546509,
0.3465130031108856,
-0.29378607869148254,
-0.5328558683395386,
-0.2428542822599411,
0.1257917284965515,
-0.7991557121276855,
-0.5104935169219971,
0.05235707014799118,
-0.15473943948745728,
0.09007587283849716,
-0.22782771289348602,
-0.36761367321014404,
0.3137749135494232,
0.23358337581157684,
0.07106529176235199,
0.33874961733818054,
0.39469191431999207,
0.26824304461479187,
0.5874751806259155,
0.20831313729286194,
0.33653226494789124,
0.4450933635234833,
-0.12978503108024597,
0.5898672938346863,
-0.7283748984336853,
-0.32945516705513,
-0.7343398928642273,
0.30437391996383667,
-0.19435115158557892,
-0.31988251209259033,
0.4682472050189972,
0.6095331907272339,
1.0515440702438354,
0.01640411652624607,
0.7172127962112427,
0.1386624127626419,
0.8447446227073669,
-0.7904878258705139,
0.7310657501220703,
-0.36796581745147705,
0.21484310925006866,
0.11228936165571213,
-0.7348217368125916,
0.09574335813522339,
0.4325864017009735,
-0.05421862751245499,
0.028624434024095535,
0.4743899703025818,
0.8573163747787476,
-0.24162013828754425,
-0.0768415778875351,
0.616069495677948,
0.37828677892684937,
0.20146164298057556,
0.9950987100601196,
0.3823091685771942,
-0.4477258026599884,
0.4843316078186035,
-0.06104088947176933,
-0.5451843738555908,
-0.11199422180652618,
-0.5794959664344788,
-0.6988813877105713,
-0.553801417350769,
-0.5250752568244934,
-0.026749685406684875,
0.3859718441963196,
0.35074570775032043,
1.0863109827041626,
-0.7639890909194946,
-0.0664559155702591,
-0.1565287858247757,
-0.07289107888936996,
-0.40068861842155457,
-0.16130027174949646,
0.45407214760780334,
-0.7251920104026794,
-0.4952465295791626,
0.671759843826294,
0.4321071207523346,
-0.3455187678337097,
-0.18474145233631134,
-0.09411312639713287,
0.08806582540273666,
0.14884987473487854,
0.41188618540763855,
0.4423861801624298,
-0.5929135084152222,
-0.3359615206718445,
0.09656161814928055,
0.1672326922416687,
0.014093786478042603,
0.8625178933143616,
-0.692291259765625,
0.6635569930076599,
0.053971417248249054,
0.6683734059333801,
0.721180260181427,
-0.04540400207042694,
0.5469667315483093,
-0.8640145659446716,
-0.04005873203277588,
0.2924676835536957,
0.07641267031431198,
0.16952182352542877,
-0.4016622304916382,
-0.1738969087600708,
0.07823273539543152,
-0.8663063645362854,
-0.42923134565353394,
0.22102409601211548,
-0.7034191489219666,
-0.05545424669981003,
0.7004846930503845,
-0.5512352585792542,
-0.24038413166999817,
0.12121536582708359,
-0.14396555721759796,
0.4298776686191559,
-0.33375293016433716,
1.0893418788909912,
0.8174536824226379,
-0.06627693772315979,
-0.49634331464767456,
-0.5930309891700745,
0.42032307386398315,
0.5329518914222717,
-0.38795986771583557,
-0.0018566653598099947,
0.30688023567199707,
0.5379277467727661,
-0.0818079337477684,
0.6260824203491211,
-0.10672498494386673,
0.4678676128387451,
0.025569692254066467,
-0.07967919856309891,
-0.17084845900535583,
-0.44976356625556946,
0.0930175930261612,
0.09813110530376434,
0.19093117117881775,
-1.0300860404968262
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10576v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10576v2
|
Ignore Me But Don't Replace Me: Utilizing Non-Linguistic Elements for Pretraining on the Cybersecurity Domain
| 2024-03-15T05:35:02 | 2024-04-02T08:46:42 |
Eugene Jang, Jian Cui, Dayeon Yim, Youngjin Jin, Jin-Woo Chung, Seungwon Shin, Yongjae Lee
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.CL, cs.LG, I.2.7
|
Cybersecurity information is often technically complex and relayed through
unstructured text, making automation of cyber threat intelligence highly
challenging. For such text domains that involve high levels of expertise,
pretraining on in-domain corpora has been a popular method for language models
to obtain domain expertise. However, cybersecurity texts often contain
non-linguistic elements (such as URLs and hash values) that could be unsuitable
with the established pretraining methodologies. Previous work in other domains
have removed or filtered such text as noise, but the effectiveness of these
methods have not been investigated, especially in the cybersecurity domain. We
propose different pretraining methodologies and evaluate their effectiveness
through downstream tasks and probing tasks. Our proposed strategy (selective
MLM and jointly training NLE token classification) outperforms the commonly
taken approach of replacing non-linguistic elements (NLEs). We use our
domain-customized methodology to train CyBERTuned, a cybersecurity domain
language model that outperforms other cybersecurity PLMs on most tasks.
|
[
-0.5674047470092773,
-0.8494619727134705,
0.18858614563941956,
-0.0562264509499073,
-0.2401798963546753,
0.7511378526687622,
-0.08529461920261383,
-0.591120719909668,
0.4892875850200653,
0.547993540763855,
-0.7984134554862976,
-0.4767526090145111,
-0.618039608001709,
0.22581878304481506,
-0.38291653990745544,
1.1799721717834473,
0.09121672809123993,
-0.07982111722230911,
-0.2813282310962677,
0.31052690744400024,
-0.4863378405570984,
-1.111103892326355,
-0.4865451455116272,
-0.3030221462249756,
0.3336227536201477,
0.19600312411785126,
0.2554337978363037,
0.09876073896884918,
0.6046430468559265,
0.3557318449020386,
0.11815200746059418,
0.14553873240947723,
-0.47434553503990173,
-0.26494625210762024,
-0.49185433983802795,
-0.2916911840438843,
-0.4194651246070862,
0.1883867233991623,
-0.18032270669937134,
0.7233357429504395,
0.12313202768564224,
0.14135746657848358,
0.11911685764789581,
0.24497155845165253,
-0.7506263852119446,
-0.2959427535533905,
-0.992920458316803,
-0.004714864771813154,
-0.3194310665130615,
-0.5892148613929749,
-0.6653764247894287,
0.07839800417423248,
0.3675246238708496,
-1.0429226160049438,
0.2498122751712799,
0.3126065135002136,
0.5222873091697693,
0.06277496367692947,
0.007507548667490482,
0.07981391996145248,
-0.8459440469741821,
0.9017432928085327,
-0.2868236303329468,
0.2653355598449707,
0.9075917601585388,
-0.1258668452501297,
-0.09175384044647217,
-0.6928082704544067,
-0.31336715817451477,
-0.1127026155591011,
-0.16726234555244446,
0.18016698956489563,
-0.38103944063186646,
0.25519177317619324,
0.14245223999023438,
-0.13386793434619904,
-0.9170966148376465,
0.2672789394855499,
-0.43499454855918884,
-0.31007423996925354,
0.6088775396347046,
-0.17774051427841187,
0.3915604054927826,
0.4050561189651489,
-0.4953721761703491,
-0.040844790637493134,
-0.7008143663406372,
-0.12101757526397705,
0.5360507369041443,
0.15360470116138458,
0.07266256213188171,
0.26334843039512634,
-0.2148791402578354,
0.4884350299835205,
0.23118872940540314,
-0.11144783347845078,
0.2668372094631195,
-0.5108730792999268,
-0.463338166475296,
0.06187332421541214,
0.5074634552001953,
-0.16244283318519592,
0.30376118421554565,
-0.6170476675033569,
-0.02282789908349514,
0.14193806052207947,
1.0868556499481201,
-0.41499510407447815,
-0.46069493889808655,
0.30092382431030273,
-0.5834082365036011,
-0.538919985294342,
0.04734528064727783,
-0.6907706260681152,
-0.24439989030361176,
-0.5130205750465393,
0.5652830600738525,
-0.4485616385936737,
-0.3746322989463806,
-0.14313295483589172,
-0.2390240579843521,
0.0375431627035141,
0.20446346700191498,
-0.6871516108512878,
0.38173261284828186,
0.5553099513053894,
0.44385671615600586,
-0.23090313374996185,
-0.3670008182525635,
-0.28367793560028076,
-0.07753247022628784,
-0.36342692375183105,
0.5892458558082581,
-0.6606867909431458,
-0.44226914644241333,
-0.09906162321567535,
-0.06659747660160065,
-0.30298912525177,
-0.6344256401062012,
0.049330562353134155,
-0.8183985948562622,
0.034867189824581146,
0.06353318691253662,
-0.24443873763084412,
-0.003961730748414993,
0.30061620473861694,
-0.3077954649925232,
0.720575749874115,
0.11691388487815857,
-0.664720892906189,
0.24771727621555328,
-0.5360497832298279,
-0.47624704241752625,
0.48591962456703186,
0.004317969083786011,
-0.4207720160484314,
-0.20662781596183777,
0.06381931155920029,
0.15337395668029785,
-0.09765071421861649,
0.15077237784862518,
-0.496731162071228,
-0.6031774878501892,
0.18008239567279816,
-0.23840197920799255,
0.6936804056167603,
0.00046934900456108153,
-0.85141521692276,
0.24049505591392517,
-0.5372822284698486,
0.19446197152137756,
0.04065428301692009,
0.23891383409500122,
-0.49989843368530273,
-0.17617373168468475,
0.2617630362510681,
0.2426498979330063,
0.3375006914138794,
-0.5204557776451111,
-0.3806073069572449,
-0.6344839334487915,
0.14216157793998718,
1.0394498109817505,
0.12207340449094772,
0.640498697757721,
-0.5770495533943176,
0.7714160680770874,
0.3092295229434967,
0.28158310055732727,
0.18755756318569183,
-0.1252772957086563,
-0.623581051826477,
-0.40626826882362366,
0.022830210626125336,
0.9824060201644897,
-1.2877870798110962,
0.5827601552009583,
-0.006602671463042498,
-0.6618844866752625,
-0.4472883939743042,
0.37725040316581726,
0.6274818181991577,
0.25926703214645386,
0.8800331354141235,
-0.08779806643724442,
-0.8633142709732056,
-0.7408497333526611,
-0.4857575297355652,
-0.21576867997646332,
-0.03596087172627449,
-0.20076225697994232,
0.4801817238330841,
-0.35574737191200256,
0.8652022480964661,
-0.2172960638999939,
-0.3433432877063751,
-0.3346980810165405,
0.15747874975204468,
-0.26569864153862,
0.6001874208450317,
0.4124912619590759,
-0.7272700667381287,
-0.3817790150642395,
-0.09201321750879288,
-0.7551323771476746,
0.07441464811563492,
-0.1376478224992752,
0.024588357657194138,
0.07526273280382156,
0.9026333689689636,
-0.30872422456741333,
0.7699872851371765,
0.20039725303649902,
0.010967724025249481,
0.5049410462379456,
-0.11577171087265015,
0.0397658497095108,
-1.0231857299804688,
0.32383444905281067,
-0.10717857629060745,
-0.35489314794540405,
-0.9746671319007874,
0.14098502695560455,
-0.25178003311157227,
-0.4064989686012268,
-0.5473319292068481,
0.6448380351066589,
-0.31742623448371887,
0.30144163966178894,
-0.31513074040412903,
0.11250156164169312,
-0.09130894392728806,
0.6563290357589722,
0.11331983655691147,
0.8706774711608887,
0.5375964045524597,
-0.7494825124740601,
-0.016959182918071747,
0.40150442719459534,
-0.11241188645362854,
0.9268634915351868,
-0.7006228566169739,
0.2899378836154938,
-0.11803136020898819,
0.047699425369501114,
-0.46334922313690186,
0.10293169319629669,
0.36973822116851807,
-0.3383764326572418,
0.3564640283584595,
-0.03734392672777176,
-0.336687833070755,
-0.22316347062587738,
-0.43406668305397034,
0.4672897160053253,
0.47426673769950867,
-0.43214982748031616,
0.3660719394683838,
0.5585454702377319,
-0.3363329768180847,
-0.7033214569091797,
-0.5221548080444336,
0.21881337463855743,
-0.393748939037323,
-0.1612534373998642,
0.5727874636650085,
-0.25234031677246094,
-0.23728837072849274,
-0.32160821557044983,
-0.21213987469673157,
-0.4060834050178528,
0.5338690280914307,
0.283750057220459,
0.48640701174736023,
-0.1699523627758026,
-0.16269657015800476,
-0.3227138817310333,
-0.2413249909877777,
0.04614116996526718,
-0.564850926399231,
0.3831152021884918,
0.15914767980575562,
-0.553927481174469,
-0.67582768201828,
0.39450061321258545,
0.27114811539649963,
-0.38405677676200867,
0.7431313395500183,
0.7760427594184875,
-0.28462281823158264,
-0.18626925349235535,
-0.5553226470947266,
-0.67023766040802,
-0.5533153414726257,
0.421489417552948,
-0.12525077164173126,
-0.9741247892379761,
0.0338873527944088,
-0.15773044526576996,
0.13040012121200562,
0.10631527751684189,
0.23063941299915314,
-0.4698645770549774,
0.43546199798583984,
0.68421471118927,
-0.31215086579322815,
0.5550777316093445,
-0.0067426105961203575,
0.678219735622406,
-0.4233095049858093,
-0.202254980802536,
-0.39611315727233887,
-0.18657608330249786,
-0.5956950187683105,
-0.08361253887414932,
0.3580000102519989,
-0.17957332730293274,
-0.14090397953987122,
0.6190013289451599,
-0.29521650075912476,
0.24064208567142487,
0.5791416168212891,
0.3802763521671295,
-0.16603794693946838,
0.28132638335227966,
0.2860810458660126,
0.025537140667438507,
-0.7263715863227844,
-0.33910712599754333,
1.1763362884521484,
0.11237085610628128,
0.6369404792785645,
0.011587835848331451,
0.8468583822250366,
0.5327432155609131,
-0.04220203310251236,
-0.29250842332839966,
0.6075897216796875,
-0.2162150889635086,
-0.4876284599304199,
-0.17129766941070557,
-0.44504404067993164,
-1.157297134399414,
0.005076556466519833,
-0.4115811288356781,
-0.757944643497467,
0.011099325492978096,
0.13948549330234528,
-0.30763188004493713,
0.448842316865921,
-0.5187005400657654,
0.8327150940895081,
0.09092606604099274,
-0.038259800523519516,
-0.29759901762008667,
-0.5988128185272217,
-0.06515689939260483,
-0.6349611878395081,
0.3315994143486023,
0.2485046684741974,
0.16342267394065857,
0.7527686953544617,
-0.4662594497203827,
1.337965965270996,
-0.0663922131061554,
0.38989511132240295,
0.4249778389930725,
-0.07634054124355316,
0.43459296226501465,
-0.1562465876340866,
0.26289933919906616,
0.605664074420929,
-0.17161214351654053,
-0.5910136103630066,
-0.1664355844259262,
0.41859087347984314,
-0.8590189814567566,
-0.5709774494171143,
-0.4827796518802643,
-0.04472583159804344,
-0.4063485562801361,
0.4141063690185547,
0.636946976184845,
0.34249645471572876,
-0.4651779234409332,
0.22517825663089752,
0.9533994793891907,
-0.04863731190562248,
0.5799406170845032,
0.35854753851890564,
0.5992961525917053,
-0.29064497351646423,
1.1117397546768188,
-0.003799638245254755,
0.3049650192260742,
0.6670550107955933,
-0.33133697509765625,
-0.16475370526313782,
-0.6064826250076294,
-0.14391160011291504,
-0.20601995289325714,
-0.42841359972953796,
-0.30676108598709106,
-0.9581470489501953,
-0.6597650051116943,
-0.5564455986022949,
-0.4856579005718231,
-0.16152574121952057,
-0.0427735261619091,
-0.5826413035392761,
-0.20909737050533295,
0.3686451315879822,
0.5658996105194092,
0.2504935562610626,
0.7213602066040039,
-0.7908238172531128,
0.32898661494255066,
0.15507981181144714,
0.08203456550836563,
-0.18152594566345215,
-0.609004020690918,
-0.31852591037750244,
-0.00993911363184452,
-0.2889857888221741,
-0.699833333492279,
0.2937001883983612,
0.016889633610844612,
0.7573570609092712,
-0.10302417725324631,
0.30931785702705383,
0.7559108138084412,
-0.37294983863830566,
0.6196072101593018,
0.216912642121315,
-1.1319972276687622,
0.3498113751411438,
-0.16398924589157104,
0.09524069726467133,
0.9545809626579285,
0.46039170026779175,
-0.10994604974985123,
-0.6944029927253723,
-0.9901884198188782,
-0.8579886555671692,
0.5997741222381592,
0.3605373799800873,
0.18492993712425232,
0.14645810425281525,
0.11788605898618698,
-0.20864742994308472,
0.4354317784309387,
-0.8164465427398682,
-0.32721492648124695,
-0.19375823438167572,
-0.20734809339046478,
0.011994886212050915,
-0.09486879408359528,
0.06897498667240143,
0.32356464862823486,
1.0328338146209717,
0.029157985001802444,
0.24859772622585297,
0.08269407600164413,
-0.45384150743484497,
0.2824426293373108,
0.14036020636558533,
0.6080593466758728,
0.779316246509552,
0.1958012878894806,
-0.0030593890696763992,
0.3145904541015625,
-0.7640523910522461,
0.1751532405614853,
-0.26211363077163696,
-0.03902720659971237,
0.2008824199438095,
0.5672280788421631,
0.4027264714241028,
0.2280147522687912,
-0.6391099691390991,
0.745572566986084,
0.1285020411014557,
-0.364101767539978,
-0.6414845585823059,
0.014691820368170738,
-0.32703208923339844,
-0.04540400207042694,
0.29638370871543884,
0.41588184237480164,
-0.161594957113266,
-0.27572542428970337,
0.531461775302887,
0.4711754620075226,
-0.5131020545959473,
-0.37500667572021484,
0.5258548259735107,
0.1790425181388855,
-0.18407949805259705,
0.5433083176612854,
-0.23320002853870392,
-0.49113819003105164,
0.48674917221069336,
0.48190000653266907,
0.9442915916442871,
-0.35376104712486267,
0.36098575592041016,
0.09820125997066498,
0.8148530125617981,
0.1984950304031372,
0.27381327748298645,
0.21576666831970215,
-0.518589973449707,
-0.350117564201355,
-0.4305896461009979,
-0.20692168176174164,
0.5268059372901917,
-0.47045379877090454,
0.36367136240005493,
-1.0675055980682373,
-0.14947670698165894,
0.0676146149635315,
-0.2931627035140991,
-0.8898890614509583,
0.4800196886062622,
-0.17187650501728058,
0.6666660904884338,
-0.9399077296257019,
0.7142024636268616,
0.5902386903762817,
-0.271493524312973,
-0.4091632068157196,
0.07158804684877396,
0.00894777663052082,
-0.6624634265899658,
0.5936835408210754,
-0.08770299702882767,
0.01739910989999771,
-0.059364255517721176,
-0.3316921591758728,
-0.5447458624839783,
0.6248165369033813,
0.03913475573062897,
-0.19135503470897675,
0.13336628675460815,
0.2242421954870224,
0.3375411927700043,
-0.15673182904720306,
0.14975421130657196,
0.14393550157546997,
0.409976601600647,
-0.2842611074447632,
-0.8376137614250183,
-0.17309419810771942,
-0.3905033767223358,
-0.15095621347427368,
0.06452759355306625,
-0.30037951469421387,
0.631690263748169,
0.17410646378993988,
0.05303464084863663,
-0.16782987117767334,
0.4209795296192169,
-0.009874061681330204,
0.4172404706478119,
0.47506141662597656,
0.31106123328208923,
0.7476062774658203,
0.2494465410709381,
0.4910371005535126,
-0.1751708686351776,
-0.17415927350521088,
1.1916627883911133,
-0.37874606251716614,
0.6155011653900146,
0.4170665442943573,
-0.04253975674510002,
0.4682563245296478,
0.6900333166122437,
-0.08572135120630264,
0.5555555820465088,
0.07697603106498718,
-0.42065927386283875,
-0.2907349169254303,
-0.128424271941185,
-0.31677865982055664,
0.6021934151649475,
0.1768733412027359,
-0.1728794127702713,
-0.10975644737482071,
0.19281451404094696,
0.14136669039726257,
0.05967983976006508,
-0.28191083669662476,
1.2148480415344238,
0.07178148627281189,
-0.34918174147605896,
0.539304792881012,
0.332072913646698,
0.654108464717865,
-0.8485982418060303,
0.3069828748703003,
0.021956687793135643,
0.014011157676577568,
-0.23720362782478333,
-0.03865291550755501,
0.7101654410362244,
0.11187469214200974,
-0.2201661467552185,
-0.5408685207366943,
0.752609372138977,
-0.21642997860908508,
-0.23276479542255402,
0.4075724482536316,
0.3978378176689148,
0.13510093092918396,
-0.4908450245857239,
-0.7310469150543213,
-0.33119910955429077,
0.0447748638689518,
0.16344420611858368,
0.8619620203971863,
0.1306479126214981,
-0.13329453766345978,
0.4658840596675873,
1.1877081394195557,
-0.03439578786492348,
-0.06419700384140015,
-0.23018133640289307,
0.795750617980957,
-0.34685957431793213,
-0.7196475863456726,
-1.0329571962356567,
0.26580867171287537,
-0.3162309229373932,
-0.274522989988327,
0.6862531304359436,
0.4158528745174408,
1.103804588317871,
-0.3196674585342407,
0.9416435956954956,
0.34584569931030273,
0.3790878355503082,
-0.3976977467536926,
0.7240166664123535,
-0.34610748291015625,
0.27689144015312195,
-0.3854004144668579,
-0.7732674479484558,
0.0960240289568901,
0.3781856298446655,
-0.0907326191663742,
0.20522646605968475,
0.7655820250511169,
0.7722689509391785,
-0.15190629661083221,
0.05389859154820442,
0.6107833385467529,
-0.04681026563048363,
0.17511023581027985,
0.23321561515331268,
0.5365769863128662,
-0.3445518910884857,
0.42979520559310913,
-0.06846388429403305,
-0.36054015159606934,
-0.24700100719928741,
-0.5879959464073181,
-1.3115251064300537,
-0.28758272528648376,
-0.501937747001648,
-0.4196155071258545,
0.17126941680908203,
0.969155490398407,
1.0370972156524658,
-0.9456884264945984,
0.008413341827690601,
0.09726155549287796,
0.050316449254751205,
-0.22695817053318024,
-0.18073727190494537,
-0.14040234684944153,
-0.5579476952552795,
-0.22679004073143005,
0.9537935853004456,
0.32389700412750244,
0.2188951075077057,
-0.06260640174150467,
0.3918047547340393,
-0.23553386330604553,
0.26204758882522583,
0.5039179921150208,
0.34506940841674805,
-0.41542869806289673,
-0.18980132043361664,
0.3115323781967163,
-0.14569982886314392,
-0.30250462889671326,
0.8041858673095703,
-0.7802133560180664,
0.16196973621845245,
0.2987828850746155,
1.0878965854644775,
0.046601444482803345,
-0.04785803332924843,
0.5384899377822876,
-1.1767210960388184,
0.5537646412849426,
0.2822721600532532,
0.09054388105869293,
0.10833482444286346,
-0.6613226532936096,
0.3212551176548004,
0.5592990517616272,
-0.20764708518981934,
-0.5503945350646973,
0.17730866372585297,
-0.548726499080658,
-0.674677848815918,
0.7784134745597839,
-0.36505916714668274,
-0.11045298725366592,
-0.9698906540870667,
0.17788881063461304,
-0.10232751816511154,
0.07167639583349228,
0.7261320948600769,
0.39182841777801514,
0.40426430106163025,
0.18696731328964233,
-0.42521968483924866,
0.5858498811721802,
0.6445603370666504,
-1.0161808729171753,
-0.164128378033638,
-0.16055633127689362,
0.19665208458900452,
0.23714123666286469,
0.9059844613075256,
0.0841476321220398,
0.17341285943984985,
-0.07459618896245956,
0.09265643358230591,
-0.005299650132656097,
-0.759427547454834,
-0.15013080835342407,
0.003907215315848589,
-0.24505044519901276,
-0.216729536652565
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10020v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10020v1
|
Lost in Overlap: Exploring Watermark Collision in LLMs
| 2024-03-15T05:06:21 | 2024-03-15T05:06:21 |
Yiyang Luo, Ke Lin, Chao Gu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.MM
|
The proliferation of large language models (LLMs) in generating content
raises concerns about text copyright. Watermarking methods, particularly
logit-based approaches, embed imperceptible identifiers into text to address
these challenges. However, the widespread use of watermarking across diverse
LLMs has led to an inevitable issue known as watermark collision during common
tasks like question answering and paraphrasing. This study focuses on dual
watermark collisions, where two watermarks are present simultaneously in the
same text. The research demonstrates that watermark collision poses a threat to
detection performance for detectors of both upstream and downstream watermark
algorithms.
|
[
-0.40935471653938293,
-0.5942500233650208,
0.6889792084693909,
0.07752629369497299,
-0.47086045145988464,
0.48179513216018677,
0.3587527871131897,
-0.8594802618026733,
-0.050859443843364716,
0.819982647895813,
-0.5089632272720337,
-0.0311487577855587,
-0.8648614883422852,
-0.20743325352668762,
-0.5950106382369995,
0.6783915758132935,
-0.36704036593437195,
-0.14674188196659088,
-0.7090007066726685,
-0.4661865234375,
-0.7031781673431396,
-0.7541989684104919,
-0.7603038549423218,
-0.1177506074309349,
0.41271233558654785,
0.12740547955036163,
0.5938714146614075,
0.5010098218917847,
0.7567108273506165,
0.27817320823669434,
-0.2567521333694458,
0.27152273058891296,
-0.3537786602973938,
0.45052555203437805,
-0.23989702761173248,
-0.4007582366466522,
0.32660558819770813,
-0.14814116060733795,
0.8475098609924316,
0.42346954345703125,
0.3514728546142578,
-0.1244952455163002,
0.30177536606788635,
0.504587709903717,
-0.7738935351371765,
-0.17219196259975433,
-0.6877974271774292,
-0.05699900537729263,
-0.4673141837120056,
-0.29792851209640503,
-0.13461551070213318,
-0.07748059928417206,
0.031147073954343796,
-0.29441624879837036,
0.045298583805561066,
0.07937587052583694,
0.9638635516166687,
0.5237110257148743,
-0.4483432471752167,
-0.5411278605461121,
-0.7227717041969299,
0.8860693573951721,
-0.6915682554244995,
0.01966148242354393,
0.122498519718647,
0.022422563284635544,
-0.11589745432138443,
-0.8331477642059326,
-0.7342416644096375,
0.5157194137573242,
-0.12293087691068649,
0.07206079363822937,
-0.5095440149307251,
-0.11241748929023743,
0.11668664216995239,
0.3658458888530731,
-0.4493038058280945,
0.14410823583602905,
0.016095535829663277,
-0.2020677626132965,
0.7012689113616943,
0.5415143966674805,
0.6064097881317139,
0.20851179957389832,
-0.519351065158844,
-0.009010466746985912,
-0.7701888084411621,
0.09738001227378845,
0.7697678208351135,
0.12502869963645935,
0.12628111243247986,
0.3801506757736206,
0.30280688405036926,
0.7497382760047913,
-0.45898768305778503,
0.04561206325888634,
-0.16904397308826447,
-0.4361754059791565,
-0.007688989397138357,
0.10925192385911942,
0.9531285166740417,
0.3983277678489685,
0.14723116159439087,
-0.08026600629091263,
-0.12384716421365738,
-0.17814993858337402,
0.022917404770851135,
-0.470711886882782,
0.1149151399731636,
0.05491099879145622,
-0.11867315322160721,
-0.07473540306091309,
0.2693101167678833,
-0.6702025532722473,
-0.5900469422340393,
-0.15772612392902374,
0.8859896659851074,
-0.12447354197502136,
-0.3545137941837311,
0.20522843301296234,
-0.5897185206413269,
0.12977924942970276,
0.12617862224578857,
-0.5769806504249573,
0.29248493909835815,
0.9060502648353577,
0.8501527309417725,
-0.3625437617301941,
-0.42740899324417114,
-0.3394956588745117,
0.4454060196876526,
-0.1474662721157074,
0.9630775451660156,
-0.7280091047286987,
-0.3123532831668854,
-0.020774826407432556,
0.05651130527257919,
-0.33467721939086914,
-0.6881843209266663,
0.30829617381095886,
-0.832040548324585,
0.5083417296409607,
-0.37876763939857483,
-0.9838318824768066,
-0.37176722288131714,
-0.02138824760913849,
-1.0008742809295654,
1.265161395072937,
-0.045534614473581314,
-1.3365620374679565,
0.2761572301387787,
-0.2462322860956192,
-0.5217281579971313,
0.291582316160202,
-0.2877630889415741,
-0.5987637639045715,
-0.10689462721347809,
-0.3209163546562195,
0.3014838993549347,
-0.2264658808708191,
0.07422211766242981,
-0.026862632483243942,
-0.7230604290962219,
0.3137214183807373,
-0.4115626811981201,
0.5696011781692505,
-0.4153584837913513,
-0.4488983750343323,
-0.16573360562324524,
-0.5851377248764038,
0.011214741505682468,
0.2649625241756439,
-0.4687185287475586,
-0.9251858592033386,
0.015062258578836918,
0.20899784564971924,
0.10320653766393661,
0.562818169593811,
-0.48619329929351807,
-0.04953732341527939,
0.21467368304729462,
0.4638380706310272,
0.6124351024627686,
0.45603498816490173,
0.02245490625500679,
-0.6390840411186218,
0.637749969959259,
0.17270438373088837,
-0.15172739326953888,
-0.08667910844087601,
-0.8064236044883728,
-0.5234977602958679,
-0.11408083885908127,
0.42855823040008545,
0.6285263299942017,
-0.7282686233520508,
0.18065676093101501,
-0.2186146080493927,
-0.30963602662086487,
-0.5244880318641663,
0.2575303316116333,
0.4812535047531128,
0.11687206476926804,
0.3652339279651642,
-0.41675248742103577,
-0.6088764071464539,
-0.9271343946456909,
-0.8555682897567749,
-0.06587778031826019,
0.12810344994068146,
0.45619869232177734,
0.44168904423713684,
-0.11909303814172745,
0.9285020232200623,
-0.41362789273262024,
-0.15888531506061554,
-0.20918764173984528,
0.217239648103714,
-0.06894214451313019,
0.49772024154663086,
0.4119063913822174,
-1.0595147609710693,
-0.8296410441398621,
-0.16833293437957764,
-0.5845386981964111,
-0.292147696018219,
-0.20262479782104492,
-0.030113304033875465,
0.21432295441627502,
0.7223013639450073,
-0.3873617649078369,
0.5738722085952759,
0.7838742136955261,
-0.3415733277797699,
0.36826184391975403,
0.026765160262584686,
0.30358704924583435,
-0.8705116510391235,
-0.017037011682987213,
-0.3835545778274536,
-0.13166110217571259,
-0.6537010073661804,
-0.02998669072985649,
0.11783479899168015,
0.30114272236824036,
-0.36628320813179016,
0.4150090515613556,
-0.5170618891716003,
-0.08986448496580124,
-0.6029868125915527,
0.026238802820444107,
0.24850770831108093,
0.14333543181419373,
0.035380177199840546,
1.0716142654418945,
0.597074568271637,
-0.36631613969802856,
0.07625660300254822,
-0.02107454091310501,
-0.5009962916374207,
0.5818859934806824,
-0.602480947971344,
0.3129784166812897,
-0.3138919174671173,
-0.11805032938718796,
-1.4285132884979248,
0.07740915566682816,
0.3187413215637207,
-0.08850507438182831,
0.4432387948036194,
-0.29295170307159424,
-0.7254924774169922,
-0.054209623485803604,
-0.40954849123954773,
0.8768625259399414,
0.346878319978714,
-0.4749089479446411,
0.3749816417694092,
0.615430474281311,
-0.18163557350635529,
-0.6420117616653442,
-1.0775902271270752,
0.3594904839992523,
-0.5658630728721619,
-0.6514066457748413,
0.5260167717933655,
0.0438755638897419,
-0.126675546169281,
0.2346988022327423,
-0.07264942675828934,
-0.21307110786437988,
-0.06006510183215141,
0.5439183712005615,
-0.005757930222898722,
-0.23708850145339966,
0.020836416631937027,
0.16503703594207764,
0.09469471126794815,
-0.07189374417066574,
-0.038066115230321884,
0.580675482749939,
0.11488544940948486,
-0.5543923377990723,
-0.5069249272346497,
0.7048436403274536,
0.706865668296814,
-0.09764191508293152,
0.7967430949211121,
0.26866811513900757,
-0.5034649968147278,
0.15666905045509338,
-0.7591412663459778,
0.30237674713134766,
-0.5150783658027649,
0.13321419060230255,
-0.18520598113536835,
-1.1359858512878418,
0.6552080512046814,
0.1181270107626915,
0.03468792513012886,
0.3540588617324829,
0.10827478766441345,
-0.16578258574008942,
0.536429762840271,
0.6636728644371033,
-0.14530624449253082,
0.5197561383247375,
0.010205447673797607,
0.34520891308784485,
-0.914014995098114,
-0.28807884454727173,
-0.3999693989753723,
-0.4830303490161896,
-0.2644746005535126,
-0.5591429471969604,
0.026198647916316986,
0.3292941153049469,
0.10138211399316788,
0.787233293056488,
-0.3257448971271515,
0.7798699140548706,
0.5989382266998291,
0.06383977085351944,
0.5738332867622375,
0.025940842926502228,
-0.1776183843612671,
-0.36623790860176086,
-0.7115229368209839,
-0.6095512509346008,
0.8527304530143738,
0.10193348675966263,
0.442251592874527,
0.16652646660804749,
0.8699447512626648,
0.34554994106292725,
-0.007515773177146912,
-0.3152267038822174,
0.5457959771156311,
0.011319619603455067,
-0.8061994910240173,
-0.3121412992477417,
-0.3011585474014282,
-1.3298441171646118,
0.2805563807487488,
0.14133569598197937,
-0.7070842981338501,
0.04028906673192978,
-0.31893786787986755,
-0.08085616677999496,
0.6534796953201294,
-0.40831729769706726,
0.8715814352035522,
-0.12888261675834656,
-0.5829800963401794,
-0.2417021542787552,
-0.6228492856025696,
0.21294651925563812,
-0.4460813105106354,
0.40008077025413513,
-0.1456814706325531,
-0.3875941336154938,
0.9620189666748047,
-0.17239518463611603,
0.6167711615562439,
0.03128751367330551,
-0.2555251717567444,
0.582536518573761,
0.18038883805274963,
0.19011634588241577,
-0.13474386930465698,
0.19145335257053375,
0.24869412183761597,
0.06842692941427231,
-0.3562880754470825,
-0.31062081456184387,
0.7113797068595886,
-0.2479809820652008,
-0.7289247512817383,
-0.5528813600540161,
-0.6381902694702148,
-0.11891012638807297,
0.14054353535175323,
0.3747018277645111,
0.25828713178634644,
0.01222632359713316,
-0.11673586070537567,
0.708084225654602,
-0.20621202886104584,
0.8067048788070679,
0.5211639404296875,
0.19420957565307617,
-0.2700378894805908,
0.7412081956863403,
0.08329477161169052,
0.2784216105937958,
0.39907264709472656,
-0.006463649682700634,
-0.2699354588985443,
-0.6451448798179626,
-0.25095024704933167,
0.4118470549583435,
-0.9270761013031006,
-0.24169394373893738,
-0.6300179362297058,
-0.41176918148994446,
0.17947065830230713,
0.12771783769130707,
-0.17800970375537872,
-0.32580819725990295,
-0.3917718529701233,
0.27217602729797363,
0.2914798855781555,
0.9856832027435303,
-0.10461734980344772,
0.40158146619796753,
-0.9747527837753296,
-0.0235200934112072,
0.4314717948436737,
0.3719704747200012,
0.0674111619591713,
-0.6912025809288025,
-0.24685482680797577,
-0.06583249568939209,
-0.27929359674453735,
-0.9304158687591553,
-0.19123299419879913,
0.10968650877475739,
0.5686331987380981,
0.2897225618362427,
-0.10693886876106262,
0.6489225625991821,
-0.4907253384590149,
0.6811767220497131,
0.13782495260238647,
-1.0623360872268677,
0.21611662209033966,
-0.08525896817445755,
0.4111277461051941,
0.48500433564186096,
0.5809257626533508,
-0.6683096289634705,
-0.6977089643478394,
-0.5387744903564453,
-0.9836891293525696,
0.4621880352497101,
0.26326754689216614,
0.3322514295578003,
0.16565710306167603,
0.22015932202339172,
0.154078409075737,
0.25986045598983765,
-0.7923287749290466,
-0.1434316635131836,
0.5605129599571228,
-0.15646691620349884,
0.3321167826652527,
-0.48332497477531433,
-0.16750755906105042,
-0.10624539852142334,
0.5051507353782654,
0.2916317284107208,
0.07273679971694946,
0.12801259756088257,
-0.063905730843544,
-0.28909817337989807,
-0.039941925555467606,
0.39686891436576843,
0.44997143745422363,
0.21027804911136627,
0.3577572703361511,
-0.014703650958836079,
-0.3804391324520111,
0.2032567709684372,
-0.03973158448934555,
-0.04326765611767769,
0.37393707036972046,
0.8381807804107666,
0.6236347556114197,
0.38857796788215637,
-0.9769222140312195,
0.6101282238960266,
-0.16268667578697205,
-0.21693108975887299,
-0.02238411270081997,
-0.04199216887354851,
0.3881501257419586,
0.36404380202293396,
0.4644838869571686,
-0.08493907749652863,
-0.03479199483990669,
-0.3860585391521454,
0.3418039083480835,
0.7110167741775513,
-0.3292824923992157,
0.041624512523412704,
0.8454133868217468,
-0.09447073191404343,
-0.3175809383392334,
0.28106412291526794,
0.1792885810136795,
-1.009688138961792,
0.7511059045791626,
0.1740071028470993,
0.8022229075431824,
-0.15648135542869568,
-0.3276548683643341,
0.15017199516296387,
0.3627288341522217,
-0.17719119787216187,
0.3427118957042694,
-0.058802757412195206,
-0.7410047054290771,
-0.27685806155204773,
-0.3221161663532257,
-0.4740077257156372,
0.23002506792545319,
-0.7086108922958374,
0.2511320114135742,
-0.15450382232666016,
-0.13206744194030762,
0.1738685816526413,
-0.29358887672424316,
-0.33006399869918823,
-0.11675781011581421,
0.3373698592185974,
0.5331535935401917,
-0.7967918515205383,
0.5787280201911926,
0.7185786366462708,
-0.04081426560878754,
-0.2716173827648163,
0.3460099399089813,
-0.12004266679286957,
-0.652391254901886,
0.3216267228126526,
0.5120776295661926,
-0.19326640665531158,
-0.11263331025838852,
-0.49184632301330566,
-0.89670729637146,
0.9454805850982666,
0.17932476103305817,
-0.5653373003005981,
0.08636125177145004,
0.6447776556015015,
0.4855208992958069,
-0.06653201580047607,
-0.2736356556415558,
0.7500324845314026,
0.386845201253891,
-0.14037449657917023,
-0.9646401405334473,
0.31597986817359924,
-0.06128941476345062,
-0.06362943351268768,
0.6819496154785156,
-0.7981473803520203,
0.7481638789176941,
0.11532315611839294,
-0.5715165734291077,
0.10724083334207535,
0.1260083019733429,
0.21231578290462494,
0.5151548385620117,
0.5104649066925049,
0.8587532043457031,
0.4278733730316162,
-0.13826528191566467,
0.6422193050384521,
-0.24772879481315613,
0.4164107143878937,
0.9787279963493347,
-0.37860924005508423,
0.9507852792739868,
0.7934885621070862,
-0.5066609978675842,
0.517883837223053,
0.5562929511070251,
-0.07600812613964081,
0.5878477692604065,
0.22949016094207764,
-0.7643343806266785,
-0.18904562294483185,
-0.08700674772262573,
-0.4846448004245758,
0.1254492551088333,
0.4496634900569916,
-0.10972162336111069,
-0.19395016133785248,
-0.10941121727228165,
-0.038770753890275955,
0.20994974672794342,
-0.007363086100667715,
0.7716237306594849,
0.06205814704298973,
-0.6021215319633484,
0.27466320991516113,
0.0012760745594277978,
0.8987767100334167,
-0.4699214696884155,
0.03724820166826248,
-0.2336844801902771,
-0.010122719220817089,
-0.14559289813041687,
-1.3098771572113037,
0.4623471200466156,
-0.35565707087516785,
-0.023120950907468796,
-0.1498955637216568,
0.8211151361465454,
-0.824317991733551,
-0.06196700781583786,
0.7644738554954529,
0.4192194938659668,
0.17100299894809723,
-0.2360592484474182,
-0.7021989822387695,
0.31320956349372864,
0.011645840480923653,
-0.18098773062229156,
0.32132482528686523,
0.46948471665382385,
0.06801963597536087,
0.7424051761627197,
0.37605521082878113,
-0.3312760591506958,
0.5343321561813354,
-0.17745180428028107,
0.7899959087371826,
-0.6104916930198669,
-0.3863620460033417,
-1.1060731410980225,
0.3166964054107666,
-0.10000406950712204,
-0.0354459285736084,
0.8701863884925842,
0.851434051990509,
0.8489134311676025,
-0.04835404083132744,
0.9797180891036987,
-0.0019089941633865237,
0.38852253556251526,
-0.4867035746574402,
0.5674848556518555,
-0.8368054032325745,
0.2815335988998413,
-0.4455031454563141,
-0.7799891233444214,
-0.3305591642856598,
0.021518593654036522,
-0.03228403627872467,
-0.17631599307060242,
0.8385204076766968,
0.6712923645973206,
-0.10068880021572113,
0.0658152773976326,
0.32486799359321594,
-0.4911377429962158,
0.029125336557626724,
1.0161055326461792,
1.2047288417816162,
-0.8172860145568848,
0.8691125512123108,
-0.2727227210998535,
0.1216849610209465,
-0.05319223180413246,
-0.8999406695365906,
-0.930136501789093,
-0.7417319416999817,
-0.7509317398071289,
-0.22754648327827454,
0.08205512911081314,
0.10350537300109863,
0.25684159994125366,
-0.8654019832611084,
-0.2858659029006958,
-0.19466103613376617,
0.34746235609054565,
0.03794911503791809,
-0.3197355270385742,
0.3084433674812317,
0.03182202950119972,
-0.9175075888633728,
0.17497143149375916,
0.5127866268157959,
0.6851545572280884,
0.02777615375816822,
0.08037196099758148,
-0.4782369136810303,
0.17622117698192596,
0.03333989903330803,
0.289785772562027,
-0.5017004013061523,
-0.06143688037991524,
-0.5618709921836853,
-0.2869206368923187,
-0.011433578096330166,
1.092002034187317,
-0.5486043691635132,
0.2113649696111679,
0.7089078426361084,
0.9941657185554504,
0.41951969265937805,
0.1452666074037552,
0.29666757583618164,
-0.816946268081665,
0.3631591498851776,
0.25482550263404846,
0.3512217104434967,
0.5151895880699158,
-0.4169863164424896,
0.3895549774169922,
0.648992657661438,
-0.5124345421791077,
-1.1213418245315552,
0.26770541071891785,
-0.7193641662597656,
-0.5677716135978699,
1.0400406122207642,
-0.20605212450027466,
0.2677660882472992,
-0.37876448035240173,
-0.09552165120840073,
0.03182986006140709,
0.0529693067073822,
0.44652149081230164,
1.3706527948379517,
-0.07786760479211807,
-0.2899610698223114,
-0.47996607422828674,
0.41476520895957947,
0.6668092608451843,
-0.5353680849075317,
0.018685288727283478,
0.023850983008742332,
0.4266376197338104,
0.11878786236047745,
0.27546149492263794,
-0.08348525315523148,
0.17402005195617676,
0.15511807799339294,
-0.10920645296573639,
0.11845573782920837,
-0.11904554069042206,
-0.3368436396121979,
0.015220033936202526,
0.046937234699726105,
-0.39235350489616394
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10575v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10575v1
|
Exploring Language Model's Code Generation Ability with Auxiliary Functions
| 2024-03-15T04:41:50 | 2024-03-15T04:41:50 |
Seonghyeon Lee, Sanghwan Jang, Seongbo Jang, Dongha Lee, Hwanjo Yu
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Auxiliary function is a helpful component to improve language model's code
generation ability. However, a systematic exploration of how they affect has
yet to be done. In this work, we comprehensively evaluate the ability to
utilize auxiliary functions encoded in recent code-pretrained language models.
First, we construct a human-crafted evaluation set, called HumanExtension,
which contains examples of two functions where one function assists the other.
With HumanExtension, we design several experiments to examine their ability in
a multifaceted way. Our evaluation processes enable a comprehensive
understanding of including auxiliary functions in the prompt in terms of
effectiveness and robustness. An additional implementation style analysis
captures the models' various implementation patterns when they access the
auxiliary function. Through this analysis, we discover the models' promising
ability to utilize auxiliary functions including their self-improving behavior
by implementing the two functions step-by-step. However, our analysis also
reveals the model's underutilized behavior to call the auxiliary function,
suggesting the future direction to enhance their implementation by eliciting
the auxiliary function call ability encoded in the models. We release our code
and dataset to facilitate this research direction.
|
[
-0.37910783290863037,
-0.7159311175346375,
0.5162383317947388,
0.24958549439907074,
-0.324285626411438,
0.0054854219779372215,
-0.3226848244667053,
-0.40094855427742004,
-0.15064583718776703,
0.5029796361923218,
-0.7940029501914978,
-0.3928971290588379,
-0.2661139965057373,
0.49368876218795776,
-0.31600138545036316,
0.7531318664550781,
0.1211019977927208,
0.11234808713197708,
-0.2504129707813263,
-0.0726635679602623,
-0.5744166970252991,
-0.6257537007331848,
-0.3716309368610382,
-0.08169492334127426,
0.22867953777313232,
0.5425375699996948,
0.5719257593154907,
0.6186472773551941,
0.48599451780319214,
0.3499905467033386,
0.3920734226703644,
0.03409497067332268,
-0.425295889377594,
-0.10132525861263275,
0.10078445822000504,
-0.32103297114372253,
-0.49892497062683105,
-0.3229690492153168,
0.8452335000038147,
0.3688991665840149,
-0.053901541978120804,
0.15503868460655212,
0.027027053758502007,
0.28776657581329346,
-0.42811912298202515,
0.16271358728408813,
-0.48217636346817017,
-0.12268707156181335,
-0.12069889158010483,
-0.31917524337768555,
-0.4674700200557709,
-0.43891441822052,
-0.12675759196281433,
-0.2495616376399994,
-0.05673570930957794,
-0.09723955392837524,
0.5300818085670471,
0.14488592743873596,
-0.367288202047348,
-0.35574209690093994,
-0.6902446150779724,
0.8309352993965149,
-1.0123099088668823,
0.3714589774608612,
0.5043277740478516,
0.07030999660491943,
-0.16015806794166565,
-0.778274416923523,
-0.5894597768783569,
-0.7011033892631531,
0.015570152550935745,
-0.1430300772190094,
-0.31003355979919434,
0.19073058664798737,
0.4164888560771942,
0.3430855870246887,
-0.4580109119415283,
0.13321171700954437,
-0.4218076765537262,
-0.2583165168762207,
0.6799342036247253,
0.1769443303346634,
0.6679214835166931,
-0.32121041417121887,
-0.06774862855672836,
-0.2944652736186981,
-0.5075744390487671,
0.282581090927124,
0.46620458364486694,
0.2860907018184662,
-0.2570502758026123,
0.3962500989437103,
-0.28143322467803955,
0.4934079349040985,
-0.24643783271312714,
0.282264769077301,
0.39539504051208496,
-0.45356285572052,
-0.1775733083486557,
-0.3353544771671295,
0.6035469174385071,
0.2968262732028961,
0.3455333113670349,
0.07479650527238846,
-0.4256558418273926,
0.01550534088164568,
0.47922828793525696,
-0.7276772856712341,
-0.1613001972436905,
0.21869806945323944,
-0.730061948299408,
-0.5419990420341492,
-0.14672017097473145,
-0.32980573177337646,
0.0013495967723429203,
-0.32674896717071533,
0.1782878041267395,
-0.39152708649635315,
-0.4603498876094818,
0.04789762943983078,
-0.06726356595754623,
0.22062791883945465,
-0.01076430082321167,
-0.9347715973854065,
0.3801516592502594,
0.5497297048568726,
0.687896192073822,
-0.0008012915495783091,
-0.1868475079536438,
-0.7989324927330017,
-0.2598627507686615,
-0.08350679278373718,
0.7370408773422241,
-0.7294919490814209,
-0.7858211398124695,
0.22555981576442719,
-0.05071604624390602,
0.01922687701880932,
-0.24484609067440033,
0.7974225878715515,
-0.4861314296722412,
-0.17421604692935944,
-0.3818584680557251,
-0.4827072322368622,
-0.07660400122404099,
-0.09070415794849396,
-0.6417078375816345,
0.7562533020973206,
0.2431829869747162,
-0.7268704771995544,
0.15606896579265594,
-0.8369355201721191,
-0.4880361258983612,
0.2387872040271759,
-0.35619494318962097,
-0.45172441005706787,
0.4716299772262573,
0.22725391387939453,
0.4645892083644867,
-0.15301355719566345,
0.16726833581924438,
-0.369497150182724,
-0.17394506931304932,
0.38724398612976074,
-0.44659945368766785,
0.8229832053184509,
0.10636510699987411,
-0.1029973179101944,
0.38483017683029175,
-0.7970624566078186,
0.14610859751701355,
0.18154367804527283,
-0.2203194499015808,
-0.3329274356365204,
-0.023563263937830925,
0.14313367009162903,
0.19026124477386475,
0.07344673573970795,
-0.37069395184516907,
0.24207782745361328,
-0.33821624517440796,
0.36692243814468384,
0.7267835736274719,
0.18724451959133148,
0.5323131680488586,
-0.3989621102809906,
0.8367865085601807,
-0.5158243775367737,
0.3074517846107483,
-0.4627305865287781,
-0.3968762457370758,
-0.5504931807518005,
-0.1348191648721695,
0.271393746137619,
0.3778876066207886,
-0.6742365956306458,
0.4004347324371338,
0.17593985795974731,
-0.3477422595024109,
-0.3359113931655884,
0.03491928055882454,
0.5090964436531067,
0.6647834777832031,
0.33318889141082764,
-0.39821764826774597,
-0.5942023992538452,
-0.9401885867118835,
0.10305499285459518,
-0.24062183499336243,
0.1474091112613678,
0.2515585124492645,
0.4160013794898987,
-0.5224523544311523,
0.8202077150344849,
-0.2839800715446472,
0.399404913187027,
-0.3344258666038513,
0.3426147401332855,
0.07291831821203232,
0.6798141002655029,
0.6093999147415161,
-0.4568350315093994,
-0.04788997024297714,
-0.1402280628681183,
-0.49433785676956177,
-0.3200199604034424,
-0.1549365222454071,
-0.32529976963996887,
0.09030646830797195,
0.4088285267353058,
-0.3441343605518341,
0.3342154920101166,
0.41378405690193176,
-0.2157217413187027,
0.9954594373703003,
-0.43579375743865967,
0.2096259742975235,
-0.6563094854354858,
0.22727277874946594,
-0.31932908296585083,
-0.055935803800821304,
-0.8427526950836182,
0.2373686581850052,
0.3331506848335266,
-0.09393831342458725,
-0.25542929768562317,
0.519048273563385,
-0.5165311694145203,
-0.04761747270822525,
-0.40315666794776917,
-0.3561336100101471,
-0.2543298900127411,
0.4357749819755554,
0.3382267653942108,
0.5824469327926636,
0.6276372671127319,
-0.689975917339325,
0.04404095560312271,
0.15280483663082123,
-0.15606753528118134,
-0.1758391261100769,
-0.8062931895256042,
0.3939816653728485,
-0.010165712796151638,
-0.11224303394556046,
-0.9484853744506836,
-0.2174793779850006,
0.10983946919441223,
-0.3414675295352936,
0.2295948565006256,
-0.051328688859939575,
-0.44620758295059204,
-0.4864514470100403,
-0.2733849585056305,
0.35070380568504333,
0.7497256994247437,
-0.2974538207054138,
0.36516132950782776,
0.17955636978149414,
-0.5079846978187561,
-0.3461725115776062,
-0.25474119186401367,
-0.27421388030052185,
-0.16651798784732819,
-0.7512431144714355,
0.1297471523284912,
-0.23487447202205658,
-0.24176688492298126,
-0.3005278706550598,
0.02088610641658306,
0.09432019293308258,
0.2263098508119583,
0.06339612603187561,
0.4606200158596039,
-0.19765377044677734,
0.14979708194732666,
0.3252109885215759,
-0.07330504059791565,
0.3096213638782501,
-0.1030430793762207,
0.7153757810592651,
-0.1660585105419159,
-0.49753260612487793,
-0.2761150300502777,
0.5226553082466125,
0.29750856757164,
-0.6210349202156067,
0.15761041641235352,
0.5853047966957092,
-0.30815064907073975,
-0.24036486446857452,
-0.5398769378662109,
-0.4350851774215698,
-0.5588110685348511,
0.4466632306575775,
-0.41162237524986267,
-0.7622086405754089,
0.5892979502677917,
0.16931039094924927,
0.2692177891731262,
0.1778145581483841,
0.5522623062133789,
0.13448290526866913,
1.2427728176116943,
0.8704702258110046,
0.18484950065612793,
0.6063606142997742,
-0.20995914936065674,
-0.09626653045415878,
-0.759931206703186,
-0.13561546802520752,
-0.7489383816719055,
0.12200748920440674,
-0.5495149493217468,
-0.42469343543052673,
0.1545935720205307,
0.23842206597328186,
0.0346066877245903,
0.37455451488494873,
-0.36497190594673157,
0.20110785961151123,
0.7114680409431458,
0.09699346870183945,
0.28867819905281067,
-0.006788835860788822,
-0.22060349583625793,
-0.008674933575093746,
-0.6597435474395752,
-0.6604800224304199,
1.1537213325500488,
0.6354125142097473,
0.7236749529838562,
-0.1272803246974945,
0.9576541185379028,
0.3730255663394928,
0.38734713196754456,
-0.6301053166389465,
0.4102449417114258,
0.07343235611915588,
-0.17086903750896454,
-0.3289226293563843,
-0.3540823757648468,
-0.6917245388031006,
0.04112877696752548,
-0.189235657453537,
-0.6543024778366089,
0.29453524947166443,
0.48500382900238037,
-0.6654156446456909,
-0.38326141238212585,
-0.9042559862136841,
0.8600402474403381,
-0.517676591873169,
-0.42522770166397095,
-0.3618070185184479,
-0.45390331745147705,
0.5003494024276733,
0.059458356350660324,
0.3304845988750458,
0.13185690343379974,
0.2822900116443634,
0.5594313144683838,
-0.3726576268672943,
0.7701206207275391,
-0.10761770606040955,
-0.33463817834854126,
0.23265808820724487,
0.19873270392417908,
0.5147190690040588,
0.23327840864658356,
-0.044755302369594574,
0.0226408913731575,
-0.03934473544359207,
-0.20732294023036957,
-0.6447699069976807,
0.43814393877983093,
-0.4982227385044098,
-0.6497975587844849,
0.01824560947716236,
-0.3970901072025299,
-0.3303092420101166,
0.3053157329559326,
0.2887488305568695,
0.9401663541793823,
-0.3297443985939026,
-0.10018032044172287,
0.44411370158195496,
-0.3235768675804138,
0.7348802089691162,
0.39665544033050537,
-0.3440583050251007,
-0.22132621705532074,
0.9365853071212769,
-0.2542893886566162,
0.3328428566455841,
0.1703161597251892,
0.30189743638038635,
-0.615923285484314,
-0.550432026386261,
-0.5673103928565979,
0.17663417756557465,
-0.6243846416473389,
-0.1380300670862198,
-0.8560097813606262,
0.04038911685347557,
-0.5647604465484619,
-0.1774146854877472,
-0.09896931052207947,
-0.5039440989494324,
-0.20284931361675262,
-0.1292220801115036,
0.05568711832165718,
0.8644635677337646,
-0.22324290871620178,
0.2667160928249359,
-1.0890556573867798,
0.17409884929656982,
0.3452625274658203,
0.12514498829841614,
0.2467651516199112,
-0.30604520440101624,
-0.21064229309558868,
0.11048954725265503,
-0.2858982980251312,
-1.0828088521957397,
0.4472254514694214,
0.05966780707240105,
0.8268458843231201,
0.5013178586959839,
0.03263382613658905,
0.48010194301605225,
-0.6256894469261169,
0.4802340567111969,
0.08622978627681732,
-1.0973490476608276,
0.6037821173667908,
-0.39683401584625244,
0.3782956302165985,
0.2993626892566681,
-0.013809739612042904,
-0.3234610855579376,
-0.44555729627609253,
-0.7289090156555176,
-0.5588619709014893,
0.8079061508178711,
0.5923349857330322,
0.49120303988456726,
-0.07380872219800949,
0.08204125612974167,
0.07342725247144699,
0.13025625050067902,
-0.7174897193908691,
0.013130666688084602,
-0.30234766006469727,
0.03374982252717018,
0.04789816588163376,
-0.35484710335731506,
0.06647203862667084,
-0.14745333790779114,
0.4041622281074524,
-0.07111983746290207,
0.42639103531837463,
0.005921335890889168,
-0.1706189215183258,
-0.1532122641801834,
0.4302189350128174,
0.8392753601074219,
0.46593376994132996,
-0.08326791971921921,
-0.16628217697143555,
0.13194586336612701,
-0.3412891924381256,
-0.1034940555691719,
0.21765561401844025,
0.05738276243209839,
-0.06901572644710541,
0.768275797367096,
0.7152581810951233,
0.1666160225868225,
-0.8165640830993652,
0.45273664593696594,
-0.2397112101316452,
0.17309533059597015,
-0.2525584399700165,
0.3237879276275635,
-0.09731950610876083,
0.02096824161708355,
0.27377453446388245,
0.01761416718363762,
0.6249905824661255,
-0.5853427052497864,
0.5106785893440247,
0.5501587390899658,
-0.2165835052728653,
-0.5524276494979858,
0.427121102809906,
0.5328190922737122,
-0.3884885907173157,
0.681016743183136,
-0.29047054052352905,
-0.6664489507675171,
0.853196382522583,
0.8043815493583679,
1.0195797681808472,
-0.4087580740451813,
0.27332228422164917,
0.43565958738327026,
0.37240543961524963,
0.11981956660747528,
0.5067320466041565,
-0.5409462451934814,
-0.7666090726852417,
-0.4903041124343872,
-0.6855760216712952,
-0.05906972289085388,
-0.08078764379024506,
-0.7525835633277893,
0.4125877022743225,
-0.22979478538036346,
-0.18372566998004913,
-0.31733325123786926,
-0.19770008325576782,
-0.7391884922981262,
0.10993131995201111,
0.17758327722549438,
0.9937569499015808,
-0.8176445960998535,
0.8251487612724304,
0.7188965678215027,
-0.5350550413131714,
-0.9329919815063477,
0.09661088138818741,
-0.17546896636486053,
-0.8322579264640808,
0.7273797988891602,
0.1988234668970108,
-0.2310059368610382,
0.1906171590089798,
-0.39867594838142395,
-0.5908404588699341,
0.7991416454315186,
0.13469965755939484,
-0.6132192611694336,
-0.20410527288913727,
-0.1011882945895195,
0.5260658264160156,
-0.6067692637443542,
0.5956400632858276,
0.5921266078948975,
0.4263963997364044,
-0.08805973827838898,
-0.8818656802177429,
0.1352788358926773,
-0.5942080020904541,
0.259930282831192,
-0.10869144648313522,
-0.22007369995117188,
0.663838267326355,
-0.5580353736877441,
-0.4245644211769104,
0.24206024408340454,
0.7825379371643066,
0.19520874321460724,
-0.017425931990146637,
0.4331427812576294,
0.027244023978710175,
0.5969021320343018,
0.23712441325187683,
1.2953637838363647,
-0.2958538234233856,
0.19396226108074188,
1.0965794324874878,
-0.14554740488529205,
0.7571589946746826,
0.34654903411865234,
0.12818700075149536,
0.46358734369277954,
0.24154959619045258,
0.15674936771392822,
0.6116576194763184,
0.3130780756473541,
-0.1895524114370346,
-0.4251914620399475,
-0.09460333734750748,
-0.4439772367477417,
0.3770869970321655,
0.3009803593158722,
-0.42180222272872925,
-0.21894629299640656,
0.2366114854812622,
-0.18559731543064117,
0.003185481997206807,
-0.1428898721933365,
0.7386182546615601,
0.04793497174978256,
-0.7478483319282532,
0.5584933161735535,
0.20434144139289856,
0.4250025451183319,
-0.583470344543457,
-0.4367920160293579,
-0.3044295310974121,
-0.17032060027122498,
-0.08189810067415237,
-0.463466078042984,
0.24422988295555115,
0.015561910346150398,
0.017466045916080475,
-0.14853407442569733,
0.8920024037361145,
-0.2634633481502533,
-0.4343407154083252,
0.24116729199886322,
0.4285256564617157,
-0.23770634829998016,
0.18171167373657227,
-0.5168525576591492,
0.4030126929283142,
0.2743363082408905,
-0.002447735983878374,
-0.18069885671138763,
0.1208336129784584,
-0.11834157258272171,
0.6794455051422119,
0.7397534251213074,
0.03584394231438637,
0.15950331091880798,
0.4112054407596588,
0.7810433506965637,
-0.5182995796203613,
-0.5999342203140259,
-0.7916883826255798,
0.9305119514465332,
-0.11941003054380417,
-0.423072874546051,
0.7222987413406372,
0.1902853101491928,
0.814308762550354,
-0.48080921173095703,
1.042896032333374,
-0.1543172150850296,
0.2012668251991272,
-0.7898932695388794,
0.554621696472168,
-0.26848623156547546,
0.3968174457550049,
-0.4966887831687927,
-0.7275300621986389,
-0.179064080119133,
0.685719907283783,
-0.2697735130786896,
0.20852677524089813,
0.6039848327636719,
1.0141843557357788,
-0.04385058209300041,
0.2986174523830414,
0.42931511998176575,
0.01003971416503191,
0.24602250754833221,
0.25202569365501404,
1.212990403175354,
-0.15953198075294495,
0.17417922616004944,
-0.6176404356956482,
-0.5552824139595032,
-0.20506726205348969,
-0.7418351173400879,
-1.1818053722381592,
-0.7475519776344299,
-0.21574892103672028,
-0.10206735134124756,
-0.0021499001886695623,
1.1356631517410278,
0.8347046375274658,
-0.8033050894737244,
-0.3407444655895233,
-0.4117678701877594,
-0.06603873521089554,
-0.16537971794605255,
-0.17278257012367249,
0.2532188296318054,
-0.6205616593360901,
-0.7771037220954895,
0.4591815769672394,
0.08900350332260132,
0.08906177431344986,
-0.27650952339172363,
-0.2531938850879669,
0.09254685044288635,
0.11646340042352676,
0.5955091118812561,
0.43284496665000916,
-0.468464732170105,
-0.1798594892024994,
0.33760350942611694,
0.13670848309993744,
-0.24222588539123535,
1.262169361114502,
-0.484133780002594,
0.5456965565681458,
0.5718780755996704,
0.5081532001495361,
0.0025732992216944695,
0.25804537534713745,
1.0677413940429688,
-0.7822718620300293,
-0.11816611886024475,
0.270442396402359,
0.4633047580718994,
0.24528229236602783,
-0.5135155320167542,
0.18878678977489471,
-0.1530679315328598,
-0.48969343304634094,
-0.922495424747467,
0.39483729004859924,
-0.6862260103225708,
0.03739435225725174,
1.18363618850708,
0.03978058323264122,
0.020633665844798088,
-0.16811764240264893,
-0.44939836859703064,
0.29496216773986816,
-0.6527926921844482,
0.6512469053268433,
0.5518632531166077,
-0.42604297399520874,
-0.2704777717590332,
-0.2590632438659668,
0.7291721701622009,
0.3622228801250458,
-0.8694704174995422,
-0.00045939142000861466,
0.7041218280792236,
0.09693703055381775,
0.014570123516023159,
0.8333365321159363,
-0.1616741120815277,
0.5842543244361877,
-0.04531010240316391,
0.13050900399684906,
-0.21298471093177795,
-0.3280124068260193,
-0.7081559896469116,
-0.13105714321136475,
0.39050376415252686,
-0.07274436950683594
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.13840v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.13840v1
|
Whose Side Are You On? Investigating the Political Stance of Large Language Models
| 2024-03-15T04:02:24 | 2024-03-15T04:02:24 |
Pagnarasmey Pit, Xingjun Ma, Mike Conway, Qingyu Chen, James Bailey, Henry Pit, Putrasmey Keo, Watey Diep, Yu-Gang Jiang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have gained significant popularity for their
application in various everyday tasks such as text generation, summarization,
and information retrieval. As the widespread adoption of LLMs continues to
surge, it becomes increasingly crucial to ensure that these models yield
responses that are politically impartial, with the aim of preventing
information bubbles, upholding fairness in representation, and mitigating
confirmation bias. In this paper, we propose a quantitative framework and
pipeline designed to systematically investigate the political orientation of
LLMs. Our investigation delves into the political alignment of LLMs across a
spectrum of eight polarizing topics, spanning from abortion to LGBTQ issues.
Across topics, the results indicate that LLMs exhibit a tendency to provide
responses that closely align with liberal or left-leaning perspectives rather
than conservative or right-leaning ones when user queries include details
pertaining to occupation, race, or political affiliation. The findings
presented in this study not only reaffirm earlier observations regarding the
left-leaning characteristics of LLMs but also surface particular attributes,
such as occupation, that are particularly susceptible to such inclinations even
when directly steered towards conservatism. As a recommendation to avoid these
models providing politicised responses, users should be mindful when crafting
queries, and exercise caution in selecting neutral prompt language.
|
[
-0.4298926591873169,
-0.6489593982696533,
0.6876574754714966,
0.1602972000837326,
-0.4313638210296631,
0.22287963330745697,
-0.4329504072666168,
0.1720326989889145,
0.46079543232917786,
0.943117618560791,
-0.4472545087337494,
-0.42424216866493225,
-0.7896857261657715,
-0.00005928788959863596,
-0.33380529284477234,
0.9020448923110962,
0.5160090327262878,
0.2244507074356079,
-0.2985689043998718,
-0.26901936531066895,
-0.20624905824661255,
-0.8927127718925476,
-0.6043058633804321,
-0.5764360427856445,
0.6796541810035706,
0.45299187302589417,
1.0372300148010254,
0.6524118781089783,
0.21576091647148132,
0.24586868286132812,
-0.07868679612874985,
-0.5311523079872131,
-0.6121691465377808,
0.3214259445667267,
-0.3905659019947052,
-0.6358478665351868,
-0.21876391768455505,
0.3372328281402588,
0.4095623195171356,
0.5788909792900085,
-0.16076236963272095,
0.28830793499946594,
-0.05312265083193779,
0.8617547750473022,
-0.6342567801475525,
-0.17343737185001373,
-0.9243243336677551,
0.1339017003774643,
-0.43846914172172546,
-0.1529616415500641,
-0.4014575481414795,
-0.39168334007263184,
0.07775605469942093,
-0.09488600492477417,
-0.04369549825787544,
0.010470191948115826,
0.49491968750953674,
-0.01489698514342308,
-0.8713467121124268,
-0.366010844707489,
-0.40757131576538086,
0.9853647351264954,
-1.0447229146957397,
0.47659677267074585,
0.4277069568634033,
0.19200779497623444,
-0.17616219818592072,
-0.18853366374969482,
-0.7607558965682983,
0.10499520599842072,
-0.027003541588783264,
0.17939823865890503,
0.05080114305019379,
0.07564535737037659,
0.03544650599360466,
0.2167566567659378,
-0.4958448112010956,
0.48424890637397766,
0.020824845880270004,
-0.07976026087999344,
0.6758173704147339,
0.1957852840423584,
0.11414557695388794,
-0.435170441865921,
-0.4811892807483673,
0.3192640542984009,
-1.0425596237182617,
0.2672218084335327,
1.0776560306549072,
0.48674458265304565,
-0.22576108574867249,
1.137477993965149,
0.10798501968383789,
0.6075462698936462,
0.4623046815395355,
0.13318809866905212,
-0.2333727926015854,
-0.15037965774536133,
-0.3338884115219116,
0.017906418070197105,
1.1079648733139038,
0.45588091015815735,
0.4167504906654358,
0.33361679315567017,
-0.20240569114685059,
-0.29214879870414734,
0.07915063947439194,
-0.5981037616729736,
0.27913448214530945,
0.3689490854740143,
-0.6959440112113953,
-0.19612063467502594,
-0.1446065604686737,
-0.9080398082733154,
-1.188245415687561,
-0.4860951006412506,
-0.2651924192905426,
0.06961715221405029,
-0.5082994699478149,
-0.04655102267861366,
0.1552598476409912,
0.2982785701751709,
0.06282906979322433,
-0.9034993648529053,
-0.07586167752742767,
1.2806298732757568,
0.6185764074325562,
-0.12266187369823456,
0.24646225571632385,
-0.7278614640235901,
-0.12298960238695145,
-0.38347846269607544,
0.48447445034980774,
-0.9713024497032166,
-0.4074864983558655,
0.353933185338974,
0.05567461624741554,
0.17658305168151855,
-0.42852404713630676,
0.3612522482872009,
-0.5766726136207581,
0.5650151968002319,
-0.7118387222290039,
-0.5996423363685608,
-0.007613264489918947,
0.3811817169189453,
-0.5443277359008789,
0.6976705193519592,
-0.3198491036891937,
-1.1368557214736938,
0.2563798129558563,
-0.44213271141052246,
-0.0027839643880724907,
-0.04971490427851677,
-0.9242020845413208,
-0.21270990371704102,
0.19716423749923706,
-0.22982284426689148,
0.64323490858078,
-0.46647152304649353,
0.6647053956985474,
-0.5540875792503357,
-0.08681495487689972,
0.6211118698120117,
-0.1384243220090866,
1.090251088142395,
-0.013788891956210136,
-0.35483142733573914,
0.4875526428222656,
-0.4360485374927521,
-0.4512031078338623,
-0.06018567085266113,
-0.1680140644311905,
-0.4112905263900757,
0.35652482509613037,
-0.19110703468322754,
0.4560879170894623,
0.3520064651966095,
-0.6524965763092041,
0.11502917110919952,
-0.4214656949043274,
0.40814271569252014,
1.162832260131836,
-0.2652222514152527,
0.6990612149238586,
-0.12818504869937897,
0.6886084675788879,
-0.06803452223539352,
0.1144939437508583,
0.5519633889198303,
-0.6176572442054749,
-0.4303847849369049,
-0.1749180257320404,
0.07409390062093735,
0.6188210248947144,
-0.30450984835624695,
0.38409286737442017,
-0.08843886852264404,
-0.2645736634731293,
-0.3499274253845215,
0.11971601843833923,
0.11085164546966553,
0.2546536922454834,
-0.18649984896183014,
0.3142666816711426,
-0.4207572340965271,
-1.4236191511154175,
-0.7872620820999146,
-0.6105177998542786,
-0.03381353244185448,
0.24059009552001953,
0.3654877841472626,
-0.051524147391319275,
0.9839754104614258,
-0.10308436304330826,
0.2091241180896759,
-0.31007829308509827,
0.12524352967739105,
0.5970265865325928,
-0.05214458703994751,
0.35216060280799866,
-0.9951054453849792,
-0.4917253851890564,
0.03698184713721275,
-0.3516410291194916,
-0.2767685353755951,
0.13757741451263428,
-0.2165977507829666,
0.38777026534080505,
0.4083530008792877,
-0.4928872883319855,
0.07392013072967529,
1.0755482912063599,
-0.639065146446228,
0.28168758749961853,
0.3243171274662018,
-0.07859551906585693,
-1.150075912475586,
0.07218517363071442,
0.040184956043958664,
-0.2736513614654541,
-0.568074643611908,
-0.12435472011566162,
-0.17040002346038818,
0.191076397895813,
-0.45379722118377686,
0.3960864543914795,
-0.2772032618522644,
-0.03532394394278526,
-0.18234141170978546,
0.1721293032169342,
-0.23973998427391052,
-0.26002687215805054,
0.07381797581911087,
0.4548649787902832,
0.34848102927207947,
-0.06247034668922424,
0.2732572555541992,
0.05971277877688408,
-0.1619480848312378,
0.5506288409233093,
-0.5108852982521057,
0.39240625500679016,
-0.4627035856246948,
0.13718071579933167,
-1.014158844947815,
-0.32749316096305847,
0.3397507071495056,
-0.11796507239341736,
0.22526678442955017,
-0.37164831161499023,
-0.31609609723091125,
-0.22048518061637878,
-0.42515090107917786,
0.1360512226819992,
0.34821271896362305,
-0.1995953768491745,
0.8712946176528931,
0.7952210903167725,
-0.2812202274799347,
-1.0264395475387573,
-0.6917771697044373,
-0.10361601412296295,
-0.5810105204582214,
-0.4243721067905426,
-0.03014906495809555,
0.14182154834270477,
-0.8960720300674438,
-0.15627212822437286,
0.0455562062561512,
0.15398278832435608,
-0.1599196046590805,
0.31420817971229553,
0.11349908262491226,
-0.20137576758861542,
0.15202182531356812,
-0.15149261057376862,
0.26792165637016296,
0.13278037309646606,
0.2657800614833832,
0.74495929479599,
-0.019542120397090912,
-0.37117600440979004,
-0.2339565008878708,
0.5240749716758728,
0.9635347723960876,
-0.23042534291744232,
0.9684207439422607,
0.1617691069841385,
-0.13463953137397766,
0.03526488319039345,
-0.6591265201568604,
-0.009314730763435364,
-0.48690086603164673,
0.2720104455947876,
0.05330466851592064,
-0.8988917469978333,
0.7386164665222168,
0.3295089304447174,
0.3007201850414276,
0.23140138387680054,
0.8906948566436768,
0.017731325700879097,
0.8202421069145203,
0.7344993948936462,
-0.17642538249492645,
0.31757864356040955,
0.19847893714904785,
0.6787861585617065,
-0.5181562304496765,
-0.3440808951854706,
-0.5889912247657776,
-0.3458367884159088,
-0.8841997385025024,
-0.26961636543273926,
0.050441961735486984,
-0.2449081689119339,
-0.5651425123214722,
-0.1442556381225586,
-0.5606319904327393,
0.23300163447856903,
0.04666620492935181,
-0.17587421834468842,
0.1123184859752655,
-0.13488143682479858,
0.4717625081539154,
-0.3010883033275604,
-0.4070194363594055,
-0.6677656173706055,
1.0264331102371216,
0.5272677540779114,
0.848209023475647,
0.19534717500209808,
0.48723357915878296,
0.22455091774463654,
0.4415833353996277,
-0.7573207020759583,
0.7193372249603271,
-0.24589233100414276,
-0.7520206570625305,
-0.32046976685523987,
-0.38740092515945435,
-0.5659350156784058,
0.3835987150669098,
-0.1595660001039505,
-0.5365532636642456,
0.27205899357795715,
-0.0607842318713665,
-0.10223225504159927,
0.6259957551956177,
-0.10605748742818832,
0.7745265960693359,
-0.5175016522407532,
-0.27985143661499023,
-0.0834871456027031,
-0.7623950839042664,
0.2748783528804779,
-0.0816350132226944,
0.4337075352668762,
-0.5131705403327942,
-0.5324278473854065,
0.6670167446136475,
-0.18996649980545044,
0.9065386652946472,
-0.2015342265367508,
-0.45988965034484863,
0.10181377083063126,
-0.07592365890741348,
0.45821526646614075,
0.07112231105566025,
-0.6077459454536438,
0.1612263321876526,
-0.13960975408554077,
-0.2890033423900604,
-0.1925170123577118,
1.0470426082611084,
-0.7531476616859436,
-1.0841370820999146,
-0.6206719875335693,
-0.6591885089874268,
-0.045946937054395676,
0.07197216898202896,
0.39178261160850525,
0.12141737341880798,
-0.14517183601856232,
0.3568305969238281,
0.5049930810928345,
-0.2519068717956543,
0.33284956216812134,
0.4041074514389038,
-0.715715765953064,
-0.05993232876062393,
0.3828623592853546,
0.4437777101993561,
0.46045178174972534,
0.15802431106567383,
0.3762727379798889,
-0.5417550802230835,
-0.3476122319698334,
-0.4504021108150482,
0.42249178886413574,
-0.5719047784805298,
-0.13365693390369415,
-0.633630096912384,
0.020756781101226807,
-0.2762588560581207,
-0.148289754986763,
-0.5681688785552979,
-0.09915530681610107,
-0.3720817565917969,
0.063003771007061,
0.2217375636100769,
0.8510702252388,
0.3121943771839142,
0.15034730732440948,
-0.1184820830821991,
0.041418883949518204,
0.15821973979473114,
0.1205974593758583,
-0.6078231930732727,
-0.5907865762710571,
0.3255552649497986,
0.15969890356063843,
-0.14564579725265503,
-1.2118587493896484,
0.02269529365003109,
-0.08184768259525299,
0.36051908135414124,
0.5206480622291565,
0.3399234116077423,
0.17748920619487762,
-0.37836918234825134,
1.0383884906768799,
0.13917236030101776,
-0.8304775357246399,
0.1838219165802002,
-0.5503200888633728,
-0.039961859583854675,
0.41601142287254333,
0.7041181921958923,
-0.3850176930427551,
-0.8177003264427185,
-0.281342089176178,
-0.5993615984916687,
0.25269752740859985,
-0.06296051293611526,
0.5392544865608215,
-0.017166979610919952,
0.3388808071613312,
0.28787410259246826,
0.5075981616973877,
-0.6895115375518799,
-0.2114027589559555,
-0.1850244253873825,
-0.26883500814437866,
0.17214761674404144,
-0.28837940096855164,
-0.41882485151290894,
0.06467696279287338,
0.5955379605293274,
-0.22439895570278168,
-0.13699917495250702,
-0.015927284955978394,
0.611430823802948,
-0.1493469476699829,
0.5873017311096191,
0.35897889733314514,
0.9261236190795898,
-0.06735257059335709,
0.24298733472824097,
-0.17391762137413025,
-0.02919790707528591,
0.2285214513540268,
-0.20106688141822815,
-0.1355203092098236,
0.1338806003332138,
0.03903061896562576,
0.2662644684314728,
-0.3217485547065735,
-0.32041797041893005,
0.8342429399490356,
0.10759134590625763,
0.20612329244613647,
-0.4164254665374756,
-0.38338199257850647,
0.507671058177948,
0.3186582624912262,
0.31557294726371765,
-0.4251430928707123,
-0.10784817487001419,
-1.007583737373352,
-0.4248836934566498,
1.1596317291259766,
-0.14111284911632538,
-0.2771456241607666,
0.36080440878868103,
0.21329665184020996,
-0.4385771155357361,
0.43647101521492004,
0.03385985270142555,
-0.6316472291946411,
0.5119937658309937,
0.48617804050445557,
0.70600426197052,
-0.26245784759521484,
0.3292037844657898,
0.03184598684310913,
0.29298967123031616,
0.2318570762872696,
0.3102525472640991,
0.5165521502494812,
-0.661798357963562,
-0.40373513102531433,
-0.5626593828201294,
-0.41022995114326477,
0.48486387729644775,
-0.6997535824775696,
0.5207124352455139,
-0.5171027779579163,
-0.6547947525978088,
-0.1710432916879654,
-0.005675410386174917,
-0.2128986418247223,
-0.09158488363027573,
0.45479846000671387,
0.7147252559661865,
-0.9516655206680298,
0.5962879657745361,
0.7338472008705139,
0.1733260154724121,
-0.2337425798177719,
0.25880926847457886,
0.42517152428627014,
-0.5293899178504944,
0.3231286406517029,
0.01785159669816494,
-0.25399050116539,
-0.5071308612823486,
-0.6363841891288757,
-0.5132303237915039,
0.6212462782859802,
0.7127134799957275,
-0.8764827847480774,
-0.24254049360752106,
0.3441535234451294,
0.2664971351623535,
-0.5699086785316467,
0.15286560356616974,
0.21681344509124756,
0.5009793043136597,
-0.43263837695121765,
-0.6359257102012634,
0.2062886655330658,
0.14157190918922424,
-0.02114473655819893,
0.40485450625419617,
-1.0501494407653809,
1.0312378406524658,
0.2134086936712265,
-0.24989773333072662,
-0.09318673610687256,
0.5168789625167847,
0.12807758152484894,
0.2970336377620697,
0.6181873679161072,
0.06914698332548141,
0.724682092666626,
0.01681102067232132,
0.8847945332527161,
-0.4449046552181244,
0.17899203300476074,
0.9266117811203003,
-0.5531905293464661,
0.7324838042259216,
0.9512351155281067,
0.1443166434764862,
0.5008776783943176,
0.5680772066116333,
0.18399527668952942,
0.3510250747203827,
0.4167304039001465,
-0.4419262409210205,
-0.3944471776485443,
-0.21310697495937347,
-0.3181343078613281,
0.4306522011756897,
0.33913159370422363,
-0.4764834940433502,
-0.05094270035624504,
-0.1400882750749588,
0.35338351130485535,
0.44513076543807983,
-0.2522945702075958,
0.4416009485721588,
0.18438932299613953,
-0.7312511801719666,
0.048530463129282,
-0.09866836667060852,
0.6706738471984863,
-0.5782442688941956,
0.19772641360759735,
-0.1401834934949875,
-0.050821494311094284,
-0.49023333191871643,
-1.3740228414535522,
0.29680612683296204,
0.12037324905395508,
-0.3227218687534332,
-0.1670854091644287,
0.40467527508735657,
-0.40855684876441956,
-0.3497907221317291,
0.47929397225379944,
0.577392578125,
0.017647933214902878,
0.050209980458021164,
-0.7495076656341553,
0.5269401669502258,
0.11441894620656967,
-0.4558369219303131,
0.388279527425766,
0.523422122001648,
-0.026053860783576965,
0.4622085690498352,
0.5117449760437012,
0.10710073262453079,
-0.13384832441806793,
-0.10658614337444305,
0.844416618347168,
-0.5257160067558289,
-0.07378548383712769,
-1.188820719718933,
0.4963291585445404,
-0.13346600532531738,
-0.47050797939300537,
0.8675239682197571,
0.7208155989646912,
0.5842395424842834,
0.2894345819950104,
0.7074864506721497,
-0.08017151057720184,
0.3731359839439392,
-0.41021499037742615,
0.8320777416229248,
-0.45837724208831787,
0.2573949694633484,
0.10918878763914108,
-0.7139574289321899,
-0.0843253955245018,
0.41388577222824097,
-0.7684143781661987,
-0.08236534148454666,
0.11646066606044769,
0.8982234001159668,
-0.1390618532896042,
0.12080007046461105,
0.18755745887756348,
0.3692723214626312,
0.34885290265083313,
0.1986311376094818,
1.244558334350586,
0.36092469096183777,
0.09912586957216263,
-0.23418483138084412,
-0.14267875254154205,
-0.16561934351921082,
-1.0563369989395142,
-1.1879316568374634,
-0.4484989047050476,
-0.2646460235118866,
-0.572460412979126,
-0.12046723812818527,
1.083029866218567,
0.4540055990219116,
-0.6040151119232178,
-0.6000956892967224,
0.0657898336648941,
0.2180095911026001,
0.665341854095459,
-0.2307884246110916,
0.052875492721796036,
0.06606531143188477,
-0.7218981981277466,
-0.06748349219560623,
0.25456252694129944,
-0.4166233241558075,
-0.6254071593284607,
0.11143361777067184,
-0.4856622517108917,
0.5306704044342041,
0.4930068850517273,
0.18108591437339783,
-1.2020232677459717,
-0.4363488554954529,
0.11133124679327011,
-0.3522302210330963,
0.05636324733495712,
0.8042560815811157,
-0.27452483773231506,
0.3991760313510895,
0.6046565771102905,
0.4385537803173065,
-0.11671434342861176,
0.23375225067138672,
0.69541996717453,
-0.20044103264808655,
0.2264849841594696,
0.5617895126342773,
0.3057514429092407,
0.7108362317085266,
-0.5037148594856262,
0.2843630909919739,
-0.19113197922706604,
-0.8945834040641785,
-0.991393506526947,
0.4503481984138489,
-0.7504917979240417,
-0.02153831534087658,
1.4055616855621338,
0.0742410272359848,
-0.23875996470451355,
0.051104284822940826,
-0.18614141643047333,
0.10869604349136353,
-0.39081037044525146,
0.31435880064964294,
0.6907276511192322,
-0.2235260009765625,
-0.037641752511262894,
-0.7101296782493591,
0.32262682914733887,
0.47137320041656494,
-0.3713628947734833,
0.2545338571071625,
0.33680233359336853,
0.47131651639938354,
0.08473134785890579,
0.6926414966583252,
-0.16782936453819275,
-0.29563653469085693,
-0.6874674558639526,
-0.2929583489894867,
0.5388964414596558,
-0.019597286358475685,
-0.5281729102134705,
0.19276437163352966,
0.09877172112464905,
0.006209849379956722
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09997v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09997v1
|
Identifying Health Risks from Family History: A Survey of Natural Language Processing Techniques
| 2024-03-15T03:43:07 | 2024-03-15T03:43:07 |
Xiang Dai, Sarvnaz Karimi, Nathan O'Callaghan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Electronic health records include information on patients' status and medical
history, which could cover the history of diseases and disorders that could be
hereditary. One important use of family history information is in precision
health, where the goal is to keep the population healthy with preventative
measures. Natural Language Processing (NLP) and machine learning techniques can
assist with identifying information that could assist health professionals in
identifying health risks before a condition is developed in their later years,
saving lives and reducing healthcare costs.
We survey the literature on the techniques from the NLP field that have been
developed to utilise digital health records to identify risks of familial
diseases. We highlight that rule-based methods are heavily investigated and are
still actively used for family history extraction. Still, more recent efforts
have been put into building neural models based on large-scale pre-trained
language models. In addition to the areas where NLP has successfully been
utilised, we also identify the areas where more research is needed to unlock
the value of patients' records regarding data collection, task formulation and
downstream applications.
|
[
-0.019639724865555763,
-0.6757250428199768,
0.4991376996040344,
-0.3726876676082611,
0.09740269184112549,
-0.07458451390266418,
0.11369119584560394,
-0.8865747451782227,
0.18131476640701294,
0.7278192043304443,
-0.6668841242790222,
-0.4924080967903137,
-0.7832736968994141,
-0.055307142436504364,
-0.21847280859947205,
0.9193788766860962,
-0.05057840049266815,
0.065523162484169,
-0.03575942665338516,
0.1493760198354721,
-0.10195193439722061,
-0.9095266461372375,
-0.864085853099823,
-0.23128627240657806,
0.44204095005989075,
0.4390079379081726,
0.6517358422279358,
0.8181471824645996,
0.59056156873703,
0.07755478471517563,
-0.2003028243780136,
0.07515289634466171,
-0.13797731697559357,
0.37204664945602417,
0.10862463712692261,
-0.3663123548030853,
-0.4101804792881012,
-0.09586258232593536,
0.2463151067495346,
0.9452322125434875,
0.08383474498987198,
0.4082784950733185,
-0.1920347958803177,
1.0080113410949707,
-0.5459102392196655,
0.11327391117811203,
-0.2712952792644501,
0.700300931930542,
-0.39577221870422363,
-0.8299859762191772,
-0.263069212436676,
-0.5397328734397888,
0.4775265157222748,
-0.22818537056446075,
0.3245887756347656,
-0.0732896700501442,
1.0555908679962158,
0.37506207823753357,
-0.46488243341445923,
-0.5781394243240356,
-1.157553791999817,
0.6197184920310974,
-0.5757511854171753,
0.3895502984523773,
0.8462902307510376,
0.2434915155172348,
-0.30582281947135925,
-0.5698394775390625,
0.02511710487306118,
-0.13121791183948517,
-0.17504099011421204,
-0.14859521389007568,
-0.5090168118476868,
0.03193192183971405,
0.48993754386901855,
0.5918352007865906,
-0.6507477760314941,
0.07684037834405899,
-0.6115617752075195,
-0.37235498428344727,
0.8117496371269226,
0.24089030921459198,
0.6640081405639648,
-0.1892472803592682,
-0.07361388206481934,
0.27591997385025024,
-0.8120118379592896,
0.14505654573440552,
0.3068530559539795,
0.10086450725793839,
-0.026425858959555626,
0.6747345924377441,
-0.34071850776672363,
0.6450381875038147,
0.04042894393205643,
-0.5043608546257019,
0.10174617916345596,
-0.5366077423095703,
0.09125934541225433,
0.2149745225906372,
0.4781424105167389,
0.43506181240081787,
0.14837442338466644,
-0.3952502906322479,
0.14732681214809418,
-0.13338212668895721,
0.24700796604156494,
-0.4970204830169678,
-0.1563723385334015,
0.24301527440547943,
-0.7310335040092468,
-0.04205503314733505,
-0.1917259693145752,
-1.1737544536590576,
-0.56913822889328,
-0.2531810402870178,
-0.120272696018219,
-0.5891981720924377,
-0.07741424441337585,
0.117617167532444,
-0.2710895240306854,
0.3099270164966583,
-0.0771123543381691,
-0.9859405755996704,
0.6939151287078857,
0.8433612585067749,
0.7652789950370789,
0.017145996913313866,
0.2910838723182678,
-0.48988309502601624,
-0.013834393583238125,
-0.11058666557073593,
0.44069477915763855,
-0.14125511050224304,
-0.41893231868743896,
0.21063940227031708,
-0.16151462495326996,
-0.08079131692647934,
-0.7407121658325195,
0.6108846664428711,
-0.22323492169380188,
0.14036598801612854,
0.0256663728505373,
-0.5395888090133667,
-0.11275668442249298,
0.0827312171459198,
-0.9937795996665955,
0.6516843438148499,
0.1868550330400467,
-0.854376494884491,
0.5270416736602783,
-0.31616392731666565,
-0.9743266701698303,
0.13986709713935852,
0.00015588998212479055,
-0.8494469523429871,
0.02076776698231697,
0.14786384999752045,
0.6657824516296387,
-0.27473142743110657,
0.21763338148593903,
-0.05575433745980263,
0.0025552520528435707,
-0.1232021301984787,
-0.3298134505748749,
0.904977560043335,
0.3282261788845062,
-0.40355926752090454,
0.03926043212413788,
-0.7018133401870728,
-0.2948734164237976,
0.1333262175321579,
-0.2556504011154175,
-0.42899489402770996,
0.30362623929977417,
-0.14743320643901825,
0.43458884954452515,
0.010898876003921032,
-0.23135922849178314,
0.055772460997104645,
-0.45873498916625977,
0.3940694332122803,
0.05837664753198624,
0.5603336095809937,
0.2211708426475525,
-0.7122055292129517,
0.6355151534080505,
-0.23462672531604767,
0.5223333835601807,
-0.0940188392996788,
-1.017928957939148,
-0.22115643322467804,
0.03384922817349434,
0.4520152807235718,
0.6497483253479004,
-0.46687954664230347,
0.7861621379852295,
-0.4270690679550171,
-0.4184721112251282,
-0.5377068519592285,
0.022044440731406212,
0.09215981513261795,
0.6678897142410278,
0.4109024703502655,
-0.10046897828578949,
-0.8070005774497986,
-0.7300443649291992,
-0.18665684759616852,
-0.07108188420534134,
0.014764749445021152,
0.32303377985954285,
0.1762688159942627,
-0.24678805470466614,
0.84324049949646,
-0.7716559767723083,
-0.20687104761600494,
-0.20834161341190338,
0.2831391394138336,
-0.24883008003234863,
0.41047194600105286,
0.5050642490386963,
-1.0267090797424316,
-0.30905571579933167,
0.22564156353473663,
-0.6886017918586731,
-0.015778347849845886,
0.07441417872905731,
0.07053232938051224,
0.3877429664134979,
0.2071446031332016,
-0.36431965231895447,
0.7524530291557312,
0.637290894985199,
-0.30006781220436096,
0.28818708658218384,
-0.15972864627838135,
0.0057180155999958515,
-0.8567208051681519,
0.12327062338590622,
0.2741888463497162,
-0.21674305200576782,
-1.0360842943191528,
-0.03909381851553917,
-0.1338871866464615,
-0.07557835429906845,
-0.20658844709396362,
0.4959525763988495,
-0.32224810123443604,
0.19364546239376068,
-0.006860906258225441,
-0.5776494741439819,
-0.1406293511390686,
-0.09088956564664841,
0.12510830163955688,
0.13097938895225525,
0.30191394686698914,
-0.5842620134353638,
0.22054587304592133,
-0.142416313290596,
-0.1031346395611763,
0.4853203296661377,
-0.1539945900440216,
0.014179804362356663,
0.04542999714612961,
-0.010280548594892025,
-0.45079031586647034,
-0.27205678820610046,
0.5075193047523499,
-0.5835195183753967,
0.47882118821144104,
-0.17457416653633118,
-0.4827736020088196,
-0.6108891367912292,
-0.20008313655853271,
-0.17891918122768402,
0.5152541399002075,
-0.15164825320243835,
0.6327508091926575,
0.8661855459213257,
-0.4705592095851898,
-0.45476800203323364,
-0.6270555853843689,
0.0707976445555687,
-0.410830020904541,
-0.6007805466651917,
0.4060615301132202,
0.18515028059482574,
-0.30846020579338074,
0.22564521431922913,
-0.354558527469635,
-0.7485970258712769,
0.5813480019569397,
0.4674546718597412,
0.234609916806221,
-0.1106342300772667,
0.2892312705516815,
-0.001281634089536965,
-0.2748085558414459,
0.21040396392345428,
-0.04625679552555084,
0.5776534080505371,
0.202595517039299,
0.16216440498828888,
-0.48449352383613586,
0.8062244057655334,
0.2795902192592621,
-0.03447526693344116,
0.7650850415229797,
0.16427801549434662,
-0.9744607210159302,
0.17343448102474213,
-0.6201725006103516,
-0.11962220072746277,
-0.34608784317970276,
-0.1419253796339035,
0.2647567391395569,
-0.8315553665161133,
0.3536389470100403,
-0.1248600035905838,
-0.0104602612555027,
0.5829842686653137,
0.3218057155609131,
-0.307508647441864,
0.6148386597633362,
0.5149005651473999,
-0.23128730058670044,
0.1959093064069748,
-0.09479513019323349,
0.2765801250934601,
-0.28385084867477417,
-0.015557197853922844,
-0.737211287021637,
0.0212562158703804,
-0.8102074861526489,
-0.07429318875074387,
0.41902002692222595,
-0.22570547461509705,
0.18713319301605225,
0.19721755385398865,
-0.3567168712615967,
-0.08326561003923416,
0.7047781348228455,
0.35396140813827515,
0.6120131611824036,
-0.31472131609916687,
0.23878535628318787,
0.01154263038188219,
-0.5129047632217407,
-0.5471715927124023,
1.1281801462173462,
0.3942810595035553,
0.4313325583934784,
-0.1352170705795288,
1.0087178945541382,
0.3133789300918579,
0.34953972697257996,
-0.8182274699211121,
0.09964243322610855,
-0.2864078879356384,
-0.9061155319213867,
-0.3254093527793884,
-0.5887240767478943,
-1.35419762134552,
-0.5188814997673035,
-0.51423180103302,
-0.6470131278038025,
-0.035193897783756256,
0.3338524103164673,
-0.7805772423744202,
0.2344800978899002,
-0.5849080085754395,
0.6370678544044495,
-0.5178408026695251,
-0.06601814925670624,
0.22933965921401978,
-1.0060081481933594,
0.3740070164203644,
-0.09595755487680435,
0.18695227801799774,
-0.05465029925107956,
0.3291723430156708,
0.6881460547447205,
-0.1585722714662552,
0.6648242473602295,
0.20306234061717987,
0.2589864432811737,
0.006729339715093374,
-0.21622411906719208,
0.08757185190916061,
-0.15504774451255798,
-0.049745455384254456,
0.3829241096973419,
0.30589303374290466,
-0.22647912800312042,
-0.28611835837364197,
0.5951581597328186,
-0.3796711266040802,
-0.49100250005722046,
-0.6039077639579773,
-0.19812586903572083,
-0.13440224528312683,
0.28886374831199646,
0.23655995726585388,
0.260833203792572,
-0.12303875386714935,
0.179737851023674,
0.41268831491470337,
-0.07932684570550919,
0.43907198309898376,
0.21209073066711426,
0.1428523063659668,
-0.10907667875289917,
0.7475259304046631,
0.5262022018432617,
0.08138347417116165,
0.5500952005386353,
0.8059377074241638,
0.041142549365758896,
-0.6758872270584106,
-0.09947684407234192,
0.08955530822277069,
-0.5456182360649109,
0.0348193384706974,
-0.5221421122550964,
-0.41373229026794434,
-0.435075044631958,
-0.02635289542376995,
0.036684874445199966,
-0.20452511310577393,
-0.40380388498306274,
-0.34395402669906616,
0.4117060899734497,
0.653461217880249,
-0.009877296164631844,
-0.13905251026153564,
-1.0614219903945923,
0.6224137544631958,
0.28857696056365967,
0.3770846724510193,
-0.1289394646883011,
0.2953251302242279,
-0.007958764210343361,
-0.1566111296415329,
-0.12158774584531784,
-1.080788016319275,
0.7627341151237488,
-0.018307192251086235,
0.7455127835273743,
0.3787870407104492,
0.23146149516105652,
0.4923298954963684,
-0.7003557682037354,
0.6863129734992981,
-0.05029425770044327,
-0.7008202075958252,
0.6378187537193298,
-0.15767337381839752,
-0.17990462481975555,
0.8083789348602295,
1.1347644329071045,
-0.9135996103286743,
0.30516019463539124,
-0.9385406374931335,
-0.9305407404899597,
0.19680753350257874,
0.04869893193244934,
-0.3576546013355255,
0.044908035546541214,
0.459221214056015,
0.18276461958885193,
0.1315881758928299,
-0.22996430099010468,
-0.5155946016311646,
0.12663884460926056,
-0.34091442823410034,
0.17551307380199432,
-0.1383725106716156,
-0.17875221371650696,
-0.281202495098114,
0.3791668117046356,
0.008598214946687222,
0.10951821506023407,
0.4022384285926819,
-0.013012486509978771,
-0.286348432302475,
0.28444573283195496,
0.5748752355575562,
0.35286396741867065,
-0.441816121339798,
0.2345009446144104,
-0.25393280386924744,
-0.6036434173583984,
0.010862679220736027,
0.3788970410823822,
-0.39309772849082947,
0.04595756158232689,
0.48454147577285767,
0.49137720465660095,
0.45563995838165283,
-0.6573757529258728,
0.5148912072181702,
-0.06241060420870781,
-0.21407043933868408,
-0.6584481000900269,
0.045164190232753754,
0.12684404850006104,
-0.301344633102417,
0.226883664727211,
-0.011339991353452206,
0.4146715998649597,
-0.6967101097106934,
0.6376696825027466,
0.3200714886188507,
-0.4700082838535309,
-0.22413432598114014,
0.43322619795799255,
0.15027084946632385,
-0.6570706367492676,
0.4897313714027405,
0.22952553629875183,
-0.11517758667469025,
0.5166950225830078,
0.22904597222805023,
0.6462917923927307,
-0.3916302025318146,
0.007059368770569563,
0.1937844604253769,
0.30491819977760315,
-0.03540818765759468,
0.2015955001115799,
0.18469958007335663,
-0.4921269714832306,
-0.436043918132782,
-0.317659854888916,
-0.5955519676208496,
0.3537319004535675,
-0.8768506646156311,
0.19910918176174164,
-0.3142240345478058,
-0.29986244440078735,
0.4539671838283539,
-0.01080492977052927,
-0.7895544171333313,
0.2531576156616211,
0.587268590927124,
0.5847839117050171,
-0.9368808269500732,
0.5443493723869324,
0.23183679580688477,
-0.1630920022726059,
-0.5781757235527039,
0.30953386425971985,
0.5237558484077454,
-0.2778717279434204,
0.5184047818183899,
0.18438993394374847,
0.02118297666311264,
-0.2563401162624359,
-0.3073878288269043,
-0.8127467036247253,
0.6737852692604065,
0.048150427639484406,
-0.34898632764816284,
-0.3642951250076294,
0.1463373601436615,
0.5994305610656738,
-0.06822852790355682,
-0.06514130532741547,
0.827037513256073,
0.4852866232395172,
-0.16105970740318298,
-0.9174339175224304,
0.003929189406335354,
-0.16188810765743256,
-0.32664772868156433,
0.38626986742019653,
0.07021745294332504,
0.46537962555885315,
-0.11329077929258347,
-0.5081116557121277,
-0.13374872505664825,
0.13116958737373352,
-0.059384241700172424,
0.6485685706138611,
0.2943270802497864,
0.3995596468448639,
0.9681851863861084,
-0.2409023642539978,
1.6115933656692505,
-0.1467348039150238,
0.1432369500398636,
0.899120032787323,
-0.42283082008361816,
0.7100126147270203,
0.27302122116088867,
-0.24792592227458954,
0.14842438697814941,
0.6065234541893005,
0.37135082483291626,
0.31322017312049866,
0.2914946973323822,
-0.3094347417354584,
0.1403525173664093,
0.03796890005469322,
-0.10057425498962402,
0.3068576455116272,
0.8625800013542175,
-0.6930243372917175,
-0.08560946583747864,
-0.058195196092128754,
0.32752346992492676,
0.049381520599126816,
-0.3120298981666565,
0.841995358467102,
0.05446023494005203,
-0.6314698457717896,
0.2207065373659134,
-0.16022342443466187,
0.753538191318512,
-0.6265966892242432,
-0.3751862049102783,
0.47299569845199585,
-0.2689753472805023,
-0.40554749965667725,
-0.6112877726554871,
0.7872064709663391,
-0.20135991275310516,
-0.35000327229499817,
-0.17704568803310394,
0.9430772066116333,
-0.2211732268333435,
-0.4088696539402008,
0.25691187381744385,
0.47069188952445984,
-0.09084432572126389,
0.02419164404273033,
-0.3799857199192047,
-0.38721609115600586,
-0.14850226044654846,
-0.1331295371055603,
0.08797983080148697,
0.054983362555503845,
-0.31077730655670166,
0.4518512189388275,
0.8406306505203247,
0.6419499516487122,
0.3512764275074005,
-0.24533767998218536,
0.34313249588012695,
-0.9106650948524475,
-0.16404038667678833,
-0.8668972253799438,
0.19386497139930725,
-0.2837373912334442,
-0.4623839557170868,
0.5851609110832214,
0.19366273283958435,
0.6008851528167725,
-0.1046476662158966,
0.7635261416435242,
0.20189709961414337,
0.8678648471832275,
-0.6011991500854492,
0.6643229722976685,
-0.13480804860591888,
-0.3337845802307129,
-0.15733112394809723,
-0.01974443532526493,
-0.947514533996582,
0.5013276934623718,
-0.4754256308078766,
-0.40055233240127563,
0.7534926533699036,
0.27361035346984863,
0.5245172381401062,
0.22735083103179932,
0.143824964761734,
-0.12445449829101562,
0.4103553891181946,
0.3954984247684479,
0.35488802194595337,
-0.29193204641342163,
0.01821277290582657,
-0.8370612263679504,
-0.12432752549648285,
-0.5874797701835632,
-1.021048903465271,
-0.36358314752578735,
-0.5854766964912415,
-0.4788035452365875,
-0.1337069869041443,
0.246417835354805,
1.0404726266860962,
0.6837193369865417,
-0.747337281703949,
0.2682415246963501,
0.08128727972507477,
0.17453865706920624,
-0.8354973196983337,
-0.23909203708171844,
0.42477092146873474,
0.2992885410785675,
-0.38009998202323914,
0.4252396523952484,
0.32413747906684875,
0.015041280537843704,
0.14980080723762512,
0.3372129797935486,
-0.28269368410110474,
-0.38715216517448425,
0.41665467619895935,
0.8927136063575745,
-0.6189193725585938,
-0.2582773268222809,
-0.0694236159324646,
-0.20708289742469788,
0.27815890312194824,
0.7957645058631897,
-0.3775472939014435,
0.4851207137107849,
0.6394707560539246,
0.7221813797950745,
0.22787313163280487,
-0.024027206003665924,
0.5968254804611206,
-0.5262248516082764,
-0.29296937584877014,
0.6993759274482727,
0.565215528011322,
0.28515225648880005,
-1.0323846340179443,
0.60897296667099,
0.15389735996723175,
-0.381527304649353,
-0.42224326729774475,
-0.02765616588294506,
-1.0378049612045288,
-0.1384509801864624,
1.1510218381881714,
0.02555336058139801,
-0.3731205463409424,
-0.9062952995300293,
-0.1778072714805603,
0.42271357774734497,
-0.11680959910154343,
0.6244623064994812,
0.5603126883506775,
-0.5933950543403625,
-0.04291470721364021,
-1.0850805044174194,
0.6200630068778992,
-0.0817623883485794,
-1.1333093643188477,
-0.1199285164475441,
0.246913880109787,
0.22385770082473755,
0.42464369535446167,
0.6557400226593018,
-0.3852626085281372,
0.41077303886413574,
-0.3270823359489441,
0.1302793323993683,
0.14774306118488312,
-0.36770808696746826,
-0.42909714579582214,
0.36860156059265137,
-0.04654155671596527,
0.05035141110420227
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09974v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09974v1
|
GET: Unlocking the Multi-modal Potential of CLIP for Generalized Category Discovery
| 2024-03-15T02:40:13 | 2024-03-15T02:40:13 |
Enguang Wang, Zhimao Peng, Zhengyuan Xie, Xialei Liu, Ming-Ming Cheng
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Given unlabelled datasets containing both old and new categories, generalized
category discovery (GCD) aims to accurately discover new classes while
correctly classifying old classes, leveraging the class concepts learned from
labeled samples. Current GCD methods only use a single visual modality of
information, resulting in poor classification of visually similar classes.
Though certain classes are visually confused, their text information might be
distinct, motivating us to introduce text information into the GCD task.
However, the lack of class names for unlabelled data makes it impractical to
utilize text information. To tackle this challenging problem, in this paper, we
propose a Text Embedding Synthesizer (TES) to generate pseudo text embeddings
for unlabelled samples. Specifically, our TES leverages the property that CLIP
can generate aligned vision-language features, converting visual embeddings
into tokens of the CLIP's text encoder to generate pseudo text embeddings.
Besides, we employ a dual-branch framework, through the joint learning and
instance consistency of different modality branches, visual and semantic
information mutually enhance each other, promoting the interaction and fusion
of visual and text embedding space. Our method unlocks the multi-modal
potentials of CLIP and outperforms the baseline methods by a large margin on
all GCD benchmarks, achieving new state-of-the-art. The code will be released
at \url{https://github.com/enguangW/GET}.
|
[
-0.5321412086486816,
-0.8069019913673401,
0.7609838247299194,
-0.23121079802513123,
-0.6972074508666992,
0.5620167851448059,
-0.30828404426574707,
-0.17990906536579132,
0.5834899544715881,
-0.06371086090803146,
-0.5491944551467896,
-0.6564918756484985,
-0.3601914942264557,
0.09832502156496048,
-0.3315369784832001,
0.8803445100784302,
-0.06587745994329453,
-0.13090503215789795,
-0.23063279688358307,
-0.06195840612053871,
-0.4790564179420471,
-0.8298851251602173,
0.17377117276191711,
0.37577924132347107,
0.1638331413269043,
0.3109607994556427,
0.5716816782951355,
0.417005330324173,
0.04133155196905136,
0.2842094600200653,
0.09525701403617859,
0.3987227976322174,
-0.24012798070907593,
-0.03454926982522011,
-0.11251690983772278,
-0.21070197224617004,
-0.23730890452861786,
-0.03642701357603073,
0.6780214309692383,
0.04479824751615524,
-0.12945474684238434,
-0.08156964927911758,
0.15147367119789124,
0.006822382565587759,
-0.83673095703125,
0.09435738623142242,
-0.8510271310806274,
0.08248095214366913,
-0.4226023256778717,
-0.5391626954078674,
-0.3128001391887665,
-0.2085980474948883,
0.19965243339538574,
-0.8985640406608582,
0.5686704516410828,
-0.03048102557659149,
0.9278276562690735,
-0.03771044686436653,
-0.4821123778820038,
-0.3493560254573822,
-0.4609799385070801,
0.9796956181526184,
0.014401894062757492,
0.6324541568756104,
0.37147456407546997,
0.28913193941116333,
0.2375272661447525,
-0.9302951693534851,
-0.47393545508384705,
0.1261436492204666,
0.26517295837402344,
0.1408524215221405,
-0.0702018067240715,
0.062944695353508,
-0.0606398768723011,
0.6404728889465332,
-0.3186658024787903,
-0.508819580078125,
-0.18639373779296875,
-0.4455849528312683,
0.20763738453388214,
0.04143024981021881,
0.7831417322158813,
-0.33491086959838867,
-0.5620943307876587,
-0.4795190989971161,
-0.45896589756011963,
0.21353231370449066,
0.3389279842376709,
0.13491792976856232,
-0.12660285830497742,
0.6659608483314514,
0.33466726541519165,
0.5602580904960632,
0.09314161539077759,
-0.2911672592163086,
0.4893115758895874,
-0.8476393818855286,
-0.1868351697921753,
-0.0010046085808426142,
0.816520094871521,
0.4490162134170532,
-0.024725450202822685,
-0.19245219230651855,
-0.036560866981744766,
0.19565658271312714,
0.5126915574073792,
-0.8200377225875854,
-0.35078632831573486,
-0.2421308159828186,
-0.4061528146266937,
-0.2510555684566498,
0.43798360228538513,
-1.0971009731292725,
0.09121787548065186,
-0.1728227138519287,
0.7340564727783203,
-0.5993415117263794,
-0.19328057765960693,
0.16340699791908264,
-0.4702654778957367,
-0.1990737020969391,
0.29530587792396545,
-0.9052528142929077,
-0.12620997428894043,
0.18916594982147217,
1.062058687210083,
-0.17225044965744019,
-0.1453159749507904,
-0.3863639533519745,
0.45694541931152344,
-0.17968536913394928,
0.6706535816192627,
-1.0008186101913452,
-0.6464336514472961,
0.21578852832317352,
0.18694327771663666,
-0.1210746169090271,
-0.32153043150901794,
0.5076839327812195,
-0.2326725274324417,
0.21460655331611633,
-0.3668224811553955,
-0.3040042817592621,
-0.2335387021303177,
0.1400233805179596,
-0.6387285590171814,
0.9888518452644348,
0.049918320029973984,
-0.7822569608688354,
0.5301007628440857,
-0.2594398558139801,
-0.1855379343032837,
-0.13684941828250885,
-0.5388580560684204,
-0.6003820896148682,
0.276153028011322,
0.566372811794281,
0.2577100992202759,
-0.3967210352420807,
0.5137661099433899,
-0.3266196548938751,
-0.24325202405452728,
0.26967525482177734,
-0.4568014144897461,
0.2348015308380127,
-0.10198953747749329,
-0.1895321011543274,
0.29700204730033875,
-0.5872675776481628,
0.3179317116737366,
-0.10626465827226639,
-0.0758109912276268,
-0.6258352994918823,
0.14021745324134827,
0.14000189304351807,
0.14394323527812958,
-0.14415307343006134,
-0.605122983455658,
0.48620128631591797,
-0.007448070216923952,
0.5569136142730713,
0.7586895227432251,
0.24503536522388458,
0.4014124274253845,
-0.1465936154127121,
0.6808294653892517,
-0.1402066946029663,
0.16990092396736145,
-0.3398255705833435,
-0.44276878237724304,
-0.38462164998054504,
-0.8309175968170166,
0.3726750612258911,
0.37772876024246216,
-1.3149257898330688,
0.5036805272102356,
-0.08803720027208328,
-0.11408182978630066,
-0.46627554297447205,
0.10674537718296051,
0.3163689076900482,
0.2249743491411209,
0.7090442180633545,
-0.5691633820533752,
-0.5404171347618103,
-0.8863972425460815,
0.03693176060914993,
0.051163479685783386,
-0.40611761808395386,
0.1913917362689972,
0.23454336822032928,
-0.3441084921360016,
1.1065653562545776,
-0.6954178810119629,
-0.7518252730369568,
-0.3842482566833496,
0.13600675761699677,
-0.1895240843296051,
0.27755147218704224,
0.5699162483215332,
-0.9057600498199463,
-0.3519187271595001,
-0.20451661944389343,
-0.6595873832702637,
-0.002004595473408699,
-0.13331365585327148,
-0.2435610592365265,
-0.1904342919588089,
0.4646790623664856,
-0.05142788216471672,
0.5798341035842896,
0.5053812861442566,
-0.23880763351917267,
0.3310847878456116,
-0.22971034049987793,
0.22749997675418854,
-0.9977875351905823,
-0.02322041243314743,
-0.07711927592754364,
-0.037363044917583466,
-0.5041336417198181,
-0.31445592641830444,
0.3611550033092499,
-0.19133566319942474,
-0.3848119378089905,
0.13821488618850708,
-0.7985234260559082,
0.26600000262260437,
0.06523706018924713,
-0.14035286009311676,
0.03862534463405609,
0.7329930663108826,
0.18286862969398499,
1.0457345247268677,
0.7569523453712463,
-0.5455510020256042,
0.03534745052456856,
0.3567960262298584,
-0.42349207401275635,
0.37722957134246826,
-0.527812659740448,
0.13731326162815094,
0.012924173846840858,
0.22661744058132172,
-0.7199556827545166,
-0.3125658333301544,
0.34701693058013916,
-0.1851319819688797,
0.4242918789386749,
-0.23902736604213715,
-0.42020779848098755,
-0.3125309348106384,
-0.8660157322883606,
0.8867644667625427,
0.24096551537513733,
-0.6755263805389404,
0.6400969624519348,
0.786704421043396,
0.1472976803779602,
-0.32991865277290344,
-0.586646556854248,
0.020843958482146263,
-0.007694837171584368,
-0.4463035464286804,
0.7307397723197937,
-0.21182510256767273,
0.5930469632148743,
0.04885689169168472,
-0.1788434088230133,
-0.12849467992782593,
-0.3562808930873871,
0.18926657736301422,
0.4718776345252991,
0.07300775498151779,
0.3832387924194336,
0.47958865761756897,
-0.09271713346242905,
-0.22165493667125702,
-0.25484880805015564,
0.6243645548820496,
-0.12533441185951233,
-0.5003343820571899,
-0.2332686185836792,
0.43545863032341003,
0.43917974829673767,
-0.42625436186790466,
0.3189379572868347,
0.5575006604194641,
-0.2686854600906372,
-0.3390562832355499,
-0.2499668449163437,
-0.04179208353161812,
-0.5170480012893677,
0.47241395711898804,
-0.414524108171463,
-1.0105429887771606,
0.16398151218891144,
-0.1257653832435608,
-0.42600682377815247,
0.22511470317840576,
0.6010384559631348,
0.5714478492736816,
0.9409069418907166,
0.9437757134437561,
0.25091108679771423,
0.6289099454879761,
-0.4345894753932953,
0.3343029320240021,
-0.9313222765922546,
-0.6045516729354858,
-0.13832898437976837,
-0.21228039264678955,
-0.2740301787853241,
-0.9627031087875366,
0.9261044859886169,
0.385665625333786,
0.4580548405647278,
0.22968998551368713,
-1.0159786939620972,
0.6517007350921631,
0.594886064529419,
0.24643605947494507,
0.3152950704097748,
0.24123863875865936,
-0.46187493205070496,
-0.37659740447998047,
-0.5001567006111145,
-0.3067323863506317,
1.1776543855667114,
0.15739977359771729,
0.9577605724334717,
0.12184848636388779,
0.6939963102340698,
0.24772758781909943,
0.006708468776196241,
-0.853455662727356,
0.4315575957298279,
-0.09853366762399673,
-0.3419434726238251,
0.007430610712617636,
-0.20179471373558044,
-0.5098845958709717,
0.3432822823524475,
-0.4368247985839844,
-0.7434791326522827,
0.530058741569519,
0.2361113578081131,
0.03731079399585724,
0.6046305298805237,
-0.6808132529258728,
0.7724437117576599,
-0.24556931853294373,
-0.3098803460597992,
-0.000656594755128026,
-0.5339788198471069,
0.379972368478775,
-0.19307078421115875,
0.012213609181344509,
0.13311214745044708,
-0.18466293811798096,
0.5889331102371216,
-0.3170361816883087,
0.8424281477928162,
0.026194246485829353,
-0.0011671427637338638,
0.6264485120773315,
-0.045659154653549194,
0.11891257017850876,
0.34268659353256226,
0.4381973147392273,
0.11027741432189941,
-0.06687799841165543,
0.08460915833711624,
-0.4496883451938629,
0.5293587446212769,
-0.4893472492694855,
-0.29046785831451416,
-0.48420435190200806,
-0.31086644530296326,
-0.30622974038124084,
0.1648796945810318,
0.6709175705909729,
0.9306857585906982,
-0.4292994439601898,
0.27069157361984253,
0.5165275931358337,
-0.39701610803604126,
0.5516409873962402,
0.08299992233514786,
-0.2611951231956482,
-1.0052728652954102,
1.3911664485931396,
-0.08961281925439835,
0.28046584129333496,
0.5661362409591675,
0.06886577606201172,
-0.5233777165412903,
-0.20519526302814484,
-0.8979899287223816,
0.04013344272971153,
-0.4338306486606598,
-0.5691848397254944,
-0.7377015352249146,
-0.0034062680788338184,
-0.15271052718162537,
-0.3544447124004364,
-0.2883911728858948,
-0.25275084376335144,
-0.322754442691803,
-0.05476059392094612,
0.16003847122192383,
0.6139149069786072,
-0.2397504299879074,
-0.130039244890213,
-0.9265740513801575,
0.7420417666435242,
0.6157181262969971,
0.31106454133987427,
0.08285947144031525,
-0.07031606137752533,
-0.15987655520439148,
-0.02579820528626442,
-0.6510328054428101,
-1.1114894151687622,
0.4149249792098999,
0.43767037987709045,
0.4577862620353699,
0.5191478729248047,
0.188205748796463,
0.6059985756874084,
-0.5956703424453735,
0.9052069187164307,
0.6879609823226929,
-1.3893423080444336,
0.42955833673477173,
-0.1298723667860031,
0.13430249691009521,
0.5022707581520081,
0.37103205919265747,
-0.43675264716148376,
-0.5105072855949402,
-0.44538938999176025,
-0.9405673146247864,
0.75856614112854,
0.16477487981319427,
-0.05392889678478241,
-0.27637311816215515,
-0.342764675617218,
0.3181821405887604,
0.42482617497444153,
-0.5421164631843567,
-0.19254277646541595,
-0.7065684795379639,
-0.2301878184080124,
0.08373938500881195,
-0.5298115611076355,
-0.10341110825538635,
-0.3760485351085663,
0.3051678538322449,
-0.3792494535446167,
0.6031212210655212,
0.5908883213996887,
-0.10994451493024826,
-0.03750518336892128,
0.5294831395149231,
0.5738000273704529,
0.48958948254585266,
-0.1938057690858841,
0.4554867744445801,
-0.03165913745760918,
-0.8526679873466492,
0.33056923747062683,
-0.09117890894412994,
-0.22974903881549835,
0.2929439842700958,
0.11352839320898056,
0.7820332050323486,
0.38018468022346497,
-0.7037513852119446,
0.8662586808204651,
-0.14310885965824127,
-0.3355640769004822,
0.038780637085437775,
-0.09175708889961243,
-0.29802411794662476,
-0.08554671704769135,
0.6079341173171997,
0.0217613335698843,
0.25174397230148315,
-0.8026522397994995,
0.3691406846046448,
0.5271472930908203,
-0.27593928575515747,
-0.7023504972457886,
0.7434048056602478,
0.1470504254102707,
-0.04067467525601387,
0.21844381093978882,
-0.25842443108558655,
-0.954495906829834,
0.17007611691951752,
0.6943193674087524,
1.1351888179779053,
-0.09002626687288284,
0.592835545539856,
0.33324506878852844,
0.07556524127721786,
-0.08451329171657562,
0.08254527300596237,
-0.35046085715293884,
-0.4514685273170471,
-0.1912880688905716,
-0.5597150921821594,
-0.42628392577171326,
-0.03843154013156891,
-0.7102778553962708,
0.39028578996658325,
-0.4054878056049347,
-0.21892210841178894,
-0.41314953565597534,
-0.5622739791870117,
-0.4179321527481079,
-0.09224870800971985,
-0.053725000470876694,
0.3841169774532318,
-0.7623587250709534,
0.9905404448509216,
0.6945502758026123,
-0.2605321705341339,
-0.6276397705078125,
0.2421075701713562,
0.17272523045539856,
-0.4807872176170349,
0.2503124475479126,
0.3458540737628937,
-0.23920077085494995,
-0.2866981029510498,
-0.41444045305252075,
-0.8161344528198242,
0.9465020298957825,
0.23125559091567993,
-0.40772294998168945,
-0.20569707453250885,
-0.012117170728743076,
0.3750983774662018,
-0.2702641189098358,
0.27791842818260193,
0.013832459226250648,
0.321211040019989,
0.21920959651470184,
-0.8689454197883606,
0.05055000260472298,
-0.3398153483867645,
0.11554671823978424,
0.534150242805481,
-0.3524322509765625,
0.9624798893928528,
-0.1940649151802063,
-0.7286880016326904,
0.005725073162466288,
0.5312078595161438,
0.07270180433988571,
0.40578389167785645,
0.4287528991699219,
0.5289558172225952,
0.6671823263168335,
-0.11069703102111816,
0.9402320981025696,
-0.01114724949002266,
0.5442937612533569,
0.7552582025527954,
0.06197163462638855,
0.48907315731048584,
0.49072664976119995,
-0.06058761104941368,
0.4861767292022705,
0.14839138090610504,
-0.19553060829639435,
1.1434762477874756,
0.042494650930166245,
-0.39461749792099,
-0.45619142055511475,
-0.19775424897670746,
-0.6665871739387512,
0.23875750601291656,
0.33514198660850525,
-0.39821481704711914,
-0.24986372888088226,
0.28807252645492554,
-0.2246752232313156,
0.004871513228863478,
-0.17042121291160583,
0.5548562407493591,
-0.11927490681409836,
-0.320468544960022,
0.6588273644447327,
0.024832604452967644,
0.9095709919929504,
-0.7684109210968018,
-0.2962195575237274,
0.3384687304496765,
0.10238172113895416,
0.07855101674795151,
-0.7856015563011169,
0.1456347554922104,
-0.10394122451543808,
-0.3282632529735565,
-0.3260350823402405,
0.5933241248130798,
-0.8290488719940186,
-0.4178314805030823,
0.29867875576019287,
0.33935147523880005,
-0.29113051295280457,
0.011315242387354374,
-0.22599302232265472,
0.3984057307243347,
0.3202133774757385,
0.18449561297893524,
0.4253115653991699,
0.6386044025421143,
-0.08091731369495392,
0.38542619347572327,
0.6468682885169983,
-0.22394251823425293,
0.11782217025756836,
-0.09173572808504105,
1.1328524351119995,
-0.6844229102134705,
-0.5879291892051697,
-0.5720645785331726,
0.2702428102493286,
0.011972333304584026,
-0.4957221448421478,
0.5780050754547119,
0.7170687913894653,
0.9008260369300842,
-0.5240685343742371,
0.6413362622261047,
-0.2422955185174942,
0.41419026255607605,
-0.954969048500061,
0.41486361622810364,
-0.7719566822052002,
-0.03570694848895073,
-0.6134955286979675,
-0.8085270524024963,
-0.2580671012401581,
0.44550666213035583,
0.12652358412742615,
-0.22963547706604004,
1.088151216506958,
0.6522254347801208,
-0.3713931441307068,
0.10762748122215271,
0.22480884194374084,
-0.2607770562171936,
0.5238495469093323,
0.656834065914154,
0.7586054801940918,
-0.2692997455596924,
0.8194000720977783,
-0.3446865677833557,
-0.1854078471660614,
0.014429192990064621,
-0.7559426426887512,
-1.075993299484253,
-0.9238922595977783,
-0.11246135085821152,
0.014699379913508892,
-0.05090488865971565,
0.6786805391311646,
0.5324857831001282,
-0.6459171175956726,
0.06013298034667969,
-0.08575458079576492,
0.09864909201860428,
0.07635930180549622,
-0.28715237975120544,
0.6681333780288696,
-0.19309578835964203,
-0.9142906665802002,
0.563107967376709,
0.46879416704177856,
0.14908596873283386,
0.1215595006942749,
0.07419052720069885,
-0.10065560787916183,
-0.24959653615951538,
0.5474310517311096,
0.3391304016113281,
-0.677895724773407,
-0.5269615650177002,
0.06108256056904793,
0.13637115061283112,
0.10543844103813171,
1.268657922744751,
-0.9603634476661682,
0.6987884044647217,
0.42209431529045105,
0.6946613788604736,
0.3332802653312683,
0.16440753638744354,
0.6084908246994019,
-0.9951981902122498,
0.23389144241809845,
0.08041112869977951,
0.3491879403591156,
0.10982279479503632,
-0.053400132805109024,
0.35914310812950134,
0.5281151533126831,
-0.3003619909286499,
-0.8339456915855408,
0.2409919798374176,
-1.332628846168518,
-0.2963797450065613,
0.9181179404258728,
0.3369608223438263,
-0.08149581402540207,
-0.13520662486553192,
-0.6246863007545471,
0.13687117397785187,
-0.6560428142547607,
0.5692489147186279,
0.3635178804397583,
0.15827380120754242,
0.027951352298259735,
-0.10631822794675827,
0.7292091250419617,
0.24118374288082123,
-0.5837835669517517,
-0.2185516357421875,
0.6588314175605774,
0.053380414843559265,
0.3214985132217407,
0.5207270383834839,
-0.2556997239589691,
0.14214132726192474,
-0.17480310797691345,
0.08025413006544113,
-0.3338102102279663,
-0.8052835464477539,
0.013627982698380947,
0.37734222412109375,
-0.5412179827690125,
-0.6059587597846985
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09972v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09972v2
|
Think Twice Before Trusting: Self-Detection for Large Language Models through Comprehensive Answer Reflection
| 2024-03-15T02:38:26 | 2024-06-04T05:42:12 |
Moxin Li, Wenjie Wang, Fuli Feng, Fengbin Zhu, Qifan Wang, Tat-Seng Chua
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Self-detection for Large Language Model (LLM) seeks to evaluate the LLM
output trustability by leveraging LLM's own capabilities, alleviating the
output hallucination issue. However, existing self-detection approaches only
retrospectively evaluate answers generated by LLM, typically leading to the
over-trust in incorrectly generated answers. To tackle this limitation, we
propose a novel self-detection paradigm that considers the comprehensive answer
space beyond LLM-generated answers. It thoroughly compares the trustability of
multiple candidate answers to mitigate the over-trust in LLM-generated
incorrect answers. Building upon this paradigm, we introduce a two-step
framework, which firstly instructs LLM to reflect and provide justifications
for each candidate answer, and then aggregates the justifications for
comprehensive target answer evaluation. This framework can be seamlessly
integrated with existing approaches for superior self-detection. Extensive
experiments on six datasets spanning three tasks demonstrate the effectiveness
of the proposed framework.
|
[
-0.3769284188747406,
-0.7034159302711487,
1.0741934776306152,
0.37950780987739563,
-0.01934388093650341,
0.09591042250394821,
0.05401923507452011,
-0.43405333161354065,
0.04351670667529106,
0.70643550157547,
-0.50489342212677,
-0.08159273862838745,
-0.5464057326316833,
0.014690657146275043,
-0.5468778610229492,
0.7850272059440613,
-0.008354371413588524,
-0.08044259250164032,
-0.4553995430469513,
-0.04978954792022705,
-0.2931162118911743,
-0.4151374399662018,
-0.7211466431617737,
-0.5238860249519348,
0.30727702379226685,
0.40059414505958557,
0.605004072189331,
0.461616575717926,
0.20244275033473969,
0.26045355200767517,
0.41010287404060364,
0.2922168970108032,
-0.3230845034122467,
0.1257423609495163,
-0.26032212376594543,
-0.3580281436443329,
-0.5041930675506592,
0.10232117772102356,
0.5351540446281433,
0.02827969379723072,
-0.20105098187923431,
0.7232504487037659,
0.13511283695697784,
0.3723733425140381,
-0.6778271198272705,
-0.04248405992984772,
-0.752918004989624,
-0.06767579913139343,
-0.06594009697437286,
-0.34628868103027344,
-0.6125202178955078,
-0.3101454973220825,
-0.1030336543917656,
-0.30328038334846497,
0.17339089512825012,
-0.06198696792125702,
0.150837704539299,
0.41729986667633057,
-0.4077419638633728,
-0.12134037911891937,
-0.6135601997375488,
0.7041289210319519,
-0.7114084959030151,
0.2492666393518448,
0.27326497435569763,
0.3563571274280548,
0.012391501106321812,
-0.6008477807044983,
-0.8226882815361023,
-0.06468033790588379,
-0.06407485157251358,
0.13953760266304016,
-0.15850730240345,
-0.23289501667022705,
0.07504402846097946,
0.03657228872179985,
-0.8892083168029785,
-0.10363826900720596,
0.19490967690944672,
-0.48843613266944885,
0.6358069777488708,
0.08258634060621262,
0.022855598479509354,
-0.004853272344917059,
-0.5899049043655396,
-0.16403762996196747,
-0.5590515732765198,
-0.24084070324897766,
0.21916446089744568,
0.11814114451408386,
0.3538581430912018,
0.3576034903526306,
-0.2082056850194931,
0.39818477630615234,
0.2787033021450043,
0.00871719978749752,
0.11155831068754196,
-0.37134280800819397,
-0.30696743726730347,
0.1683979332447052,
1.0033247470855713,
0.16634219884872437,
0.4813987910747528,
-0.08410140126943588,
-0.31363046169281006,
0.14663231372833252,
0.5412850975990295,
-0.741284966468811,
-0.01219384279102087,
0.5387800931930542,
-0.4194223880767822,
-0.5547322630882263,
-0.18925900757312775,
-0.6120280623435974,
-0.4452412724494934,
-0.0019048732938244939,
0.7067215442657471,
-0.1438978910446167,
-0.5443664193153381,
0.3404349088668823,
0.31914886832237244,
0.36869123578071594,
0.29383784532546997,
-0.40472477674484253,
0.3783045709133148,
0.8063902258872986,
0.7127880454063416,
-0.2706727087497711,
-0.5423734188079834,
-0.7620449066162109,
0.10578992962837219,
-0.4805334210395813,
0.8029597997665405,
-0.28756144642829895,
-0.3099009096622467,
0.08658337593078613,
-0.25489071011543274,
0.2874382734298706,
-0.4106846749782562,
0.49254411458969116,
-0.7952774167060852,
0.28585755825042725,
-0.3493971824645996,
-0.4693097472190857,
-0.026084305718541145,
0.5320408940315247,
-0.42468032240867615,
1.2295844554901123,
-0.046169791370630264,
-0.9212798476219177,
0.37125828862190247,
-0.35570839047431946,
-0.3860732316970825,
-0.04232582077383995,
-0.25241732597351074,
-0.3877205550670624,
0.04985450208187103,
0.3927267789840698,
0.531643271446228,
0.016069790348410606,
0.39051657915115356,
-0.7101914882659912,
-0.21416768431663513,
0.3483138978481293,
-0.5646491646766663,
0.6458207368850708,
0.09117718786001205,
-0.4334646463394165,
0.0007631350308656693,
-0.49577659368515015,
0.5262817740440369,
0.25343891978263855,
0.01868714950978756,
-0.20272302627563477,
-0.3098248541355133,
-0.08696572482585907,
0.4936513900756836,
0.5719214677810669,
-0.7168930768966675,
-0.08522909879684448,
-0.3078438937664032,
-0.01081110816448927,
1.0375078916549683,
-0.2480698972940445,
0.12679339945316315,
-0.3463364243507385,
0.642867386341095,
0.060029517859220505,
0.16617359220981598,
-0.2061680555343628,
-0.21681655943393707,
-0.757545530796051,
0.20512843132019043,
-0.2394842654466629,
0.5899575352668762,
-0.6447357535362244,
0.5192803144454956,
-0.26318538188934326,
-0.3810373544692993,
-0.6816966533660889,
0.3375003933906555,
0.7780436873435974,
0.5239837169647217,
0.6156374216079712,
-0.3186475932598114,
-0.45042240619659424,
-1.0964592695236206,
-0.659989595413208,
-0.5109420418739319,
0.188717320561409,
0.2687155306339264,
0.5705496072769165,
-0.020885851234197617,
0.9531115889549255,
-0.7535951137542725,
-0.2884712517261505,
-0.005425275769084692,
0.09821519255638123,
0.08529701083898544,
0.27684473991394043,
0.32624155282974243,
-0.5922958850860596,
-0.6424642205238342,
-0.3536176085472107,
-0.8155959248542786,
-0.006144755054265261,
-0.20555222034454346,
-0.06320441514253616,
0.23295524716377258,
0.5969187021255493,
-0.46082714200019836,
0.23735260963439941,
0.5333766937255859,
-0.37806209921836853,
0.5661349296569824,
-0.23766137659549713,
0.053061194717884064,
-1.1611921787261963,
0.03587513417005539,
-0.21684245765209198,
-0.7135002017021179,
-0.4005430042743683,
0.1455073356628418,
0.2628656327724457,
0.46013158559799194,
-0.04730530083179474,
0.7866387367248535,
-0.3301711082458496,
-0.2114076018333435,
-0.5356816649436951,
0.08822933584451675,
-0.041729625314474106,
0.1771082729101181,
0.07515991479158401,
1.055724859237671,
0.3656062185764313,
-0.304033100605011,
0.21398885548114777,
0.13405348360538483,
-0.26885169744491577,
0.6763709187507629,
-0.7484416365623474,
0.7069519758224487,
-0.054411761462688446,
0.4309796392917633,
-1.2972440719604492,
0.0016790969530120492,
0.17506641149520874,
-0.8570932745933533,
0.4347606301307678,
-0.04437266290187836,
-0.5461211800575256,
-0.6693795919418335,
-0.4506083130836487,
0.4760131239891052,
0.20349472761154175,
-0.7967336773872375,
0.5579137206077576,
0.34685105085372925,
-0.05414185672998428,
-0.985883355140686,
-0.8295508623123169,
0.1011195182800293,
-0.09274216741323471,
-0.7425370216369629,
-0.05033743381500244,
-0.42432892322540283,
-0.16776429116725922,
-0.17463088035583496,
-0.37295788526535034,
-0.15772034227848053,
0.2098028063774109,
0.08211647719144821,
0.15115241706371307,
-0.12694495916366577,
0.15340128540992737,
-0.11810291558504105,
-0.241973876953125,
0.49175843596458435,
-0.5711522698402405,
0.5583674311637878,
-0.3381800353527069,
-0.4548614025115967,
-0.2579324543476105,
0.32786378264427185,
0.46447402238845825,
-0.2839319109916687,
0.7018697261810303,
0.6992810368537903,
-0.1792582869529724,
-0.2806582450866699,
-1.0942124128341675,
-0.45284464955329895,
-0.5300654172897339,
0.28522664308547974,
-0.45618876814842224,
-1.0805970430374146,
0.3647225797176361,
0.3747735023498535,
0.16898612678050995,
0.12527251243591309,
0.6678719520568848,
-0.07085490971803665,
0.9074487090110779,
0.4726809561252594,
-0.2343212366104126,
-0.06475882977247238,
0.08613983541727066,
0.4391449987888336,
-0.7720901966094971,
-0.16414329409599304,
-0.31514546275138855,
0.16502194106578827,
-0.37801849842071533,
-0.7806381583213806,
0.3449628949165344,
-0.2923624813556671,
-0.12223593890666962,
0.15683817863464355,
-0.5016626715660095,
0.4714405834674835,
0.2833920121192932,
0.18377159535884857,
0.44565752148628235,
-0.4119460880756378,
0.10153651982545853,
0.0775861069560051,
-0.3374551236629486,
-0.6103140115737915,
1.420028567314148,
0.380230188369751,
0.6619967222213745,
0.08575019240379333,
0.9609493017196655,
0.41154250502586365,
0.5123090147972107,
-0.7185094952583313,
0.6087029576301575,
0.17472252249717712,
-0.9486002922058105,
-0.5708223581314087,
-0.39972469210624695,
-0.5365233421325684,
0.43707984685897827,
0.13959579169750214,
-0.4490887224674225,
-0.2324019819498062,
0.370575487613678,
-0.5503694415092468,
0.18591180443763733,
-0.436927855014801,
0.7099599242210388,
-0.3239608705043793,
-0.4375135600566864,
-0.3173459768295288,
-0.5741550326347351,
0.5757809281349182,
-0.4106324017047882,
0.21370771527290344,
0.0698617473244667,
-0.14306870102882385,
0.8327100872993469,
0.2018563449382782,
0.7514761686325073,
-0.11241447925567627,
-0.29399287700653076,
0.3690277338027954,
0.5417408347129822,
0.5863298773765564,
0.32855963706970215,
0.060502443462610245,
0.018031610175967216,
0.17310255765914917,
-0.31282839179039,
-0.7197349071502686,
0.8545887470245361,
-0.41960567235946655,
-0.8898148536682129,
-0.579490602016449,
-0.1873285472393036,
-0.49738848209381104,
0.49462828040122986,
0.11372022330760956,
0.23233970999717712,
-0.35090768337249756,
0.027008056640625,
0.8913729786872864,
-0.015792053192853928,
0.3621075451374054,
0.7189045548439026,
-0.4772055447101593,
-0.39617645740509033,
0.47631919384002686,
-0.11212961375713348,
0.21758446097373962,
0.07869278639554977,
0.317587286233902,
-0.5976940393447876,
-0.4031832218170166,
-0.32666411995887756,
0.3215877115726471,
-0.6028647422790527,
-0.28893229365348816,
-0.877095639705658,
-0.1357990950345993,
-0.6855283975601196,
0.21249976754188538,
-0.7306719422340393,
-0.16651785373687744,
-0.010697992518544197,
-0.2696741819381714,
-0.11699164658784866,
0.7689464688301086,
-0.25088897347450256,
0.06824187934398651,
-0.6263021230697632,
0.41346779465675354,
0.7837934494018555,
0.32281363010406494,
0.23695947229862213,
-0.6858312487602234,
0.010494250804185867,
0.02166401594877243,
-0.28272780776023865,
-0.7191941142082214,
0.05331749469041824,
-0.03875067085027695,
0.547584056854248,
0.33363965153694153,
0.07813579589128494,
0.5007774829864502,
-0.5363503098487854,
0.4866734445095062,
0.13942524790763855,
-1.0195317268371582,
0.5720020532608032,
-0.19243445992469788,
0.17788147926330566,
0.7043659687042236,
0.3549917936325073,
-0.5106959342956543,
-0.35967588424682617,
-0.5982341170310974,
-0.4860527515411377,
0.47501102089881897,
0.0617874339222908,
0.4227752685546875,
-0.1328628659248352,
0.34410253167152405,
0.13252970576286316,
0.23686620593070984,
-0.9626802802085876,
-0.2642371952533722,
-0.2168552428483963,
0.129013329744339,
-0.268716037273407,
-0.6639368534088135,
-0.28867843747138977,
0.05837290734052658,
0.6182266473770142,
-0.5435079336166382,
0.20506973564624786,
0.5998464226722717,
-0.10512279719114304,
-0.27690383791923523,
0.2783728539943695,
0.3143796920776367,
0.769828736782074,
-0.06416874378919601,
0.22852455079555511,
0.24020498991012573,
-0.17042413353919983,
0.1124979555606842,
-0.24319669604301453,
-0.10192997753620148,
-0.24218405783176422,
0.7279573678970337,
0.24530361592769623,
-0.001422271248884499,
-0.27386656403541565,
0.7920868992805481,
0.008456310257315636,
-0.03402053192257881,
-0.7663155794143677,
-0.05407479777932167,
0.20840075612068176,
0.15673933923244476,
0.2132406085729599,
-0.11323269456624985,
0.37024983763694763,
-0.6260618567466736,
0.6578049063682556,
0.6397315263748169,
-0.3948184847831726,
-0.3042429983615875,
0.5123871564865112,
-0.0493222251534462,
-0.15498575568199158,
0.43955251574516296,
-0.15028031170368195,
-0.8653689622879028,
0.4464370012283325,
0.6816750168800354,
1.0625245571136475,
-0.6649845838546753,
0.4349328875541687,
0.47178271412849426,
0.3547063171863556,
-0.20121914148330688,
0.4872346520423889,
-0.1428777575492859,
-1.1601744890213013,
-0.5378831624984741,
-0.47060132026672363,
-0.0999859943985939,
0.18772989511489868,
-0.9877682328224182,
-0.1476956009864807,
-0.470527708530426,
-0.09969128668308258,
-0.16230159997940063,
0.06432003527879715,
-0.48473164439201355,
0.2982962429523468,
0.31398046016693115,
0.9694837331771851,
-0.8929612040519714,
0.9215490221977234,
0.3876802921295166,
-0.10503838956356049,
-0.7189450860023499,
0.43255558609962463,
0.10345952957868576,
-1.2306009531021118,
0.4982421398162842,
0.3721091151237488,
-0.7420821189880371,
-0.19888107478618622,
-0.6368928551673889,
-0.6309009790420532,
0.9816997647285461,
0.19004447758197784,
-0.4735894203186035,
0.22260956466197968,
0.017767589539289474,
0.6231335997581482,
-0.3538791239261627,
0.26348453760147095,
0.7468289136886597,
0.5525080561637878,
0.2312702089548111,
-1.0640987157821655,
0.2689722776412964,
0.19931912422180176,
-0.3194466233253479,
0.019829943776130676,
-0.8629671931266785,
0.5418890118598938,
-0.45055973529815674,
-0.08552943170070648,
0.035329315811395645,
0.6413257122039795,
0.3987962603569031,
0.3359239995479584,
0.8351741433143616,
0.6012936234474182,
0.682152271270752,
0.33844712376594543,
0.9538683891296387,
-0.12306381016969681,
0.4316791296005249,
1.7483340501785278,
-0.44007089734077454,
0.9978023767471313,
0.4933149516582489,
-0.27081742882728577,
0.33076998591423035,
0.3097105324268341,
0.18248602747917175,
0.3447892963886261,
0.07899926602840424,
-0.08888734877109528,
-0.9175941944122314,
0.05617668107151985,
-0.4480268359184265,
0.7462314963340759,
0.043931808322668076,
-0.2357630878686905,
-0.10880813747644424,
-0.4322719871997833,
0.28847068548202515,
0.38317784667015076,
-0.053985994309186935,
0.6033689975738525,
0.28503721952438354,
-0.819726824760437,
0.26471978425979614,
-0.34782668948173523,
0.5863446593284607,
-0.45475903153419495,
0.0441538468003273,
-0.3325191140174866,
0.30500584840774536,
-0.1541711986064911,
-1.2940950393676758,
0.3066265285015106,
-0.12653788924217224,
-0.09779532253742218,
-0.4638577699661255,
0.7364810705184937,
-0.39941245317459106,
-0.4518936574459076,
0.7963392734527588,
0.7270575761795044,
-0.1385325789451599,
-0.48266246914863586,
-0.7899448275566101,
-0.24248766899108887,
0.04736294597387314,
-0.2825511395931244,
0.19563330709934235,
0.30247440934181213,
0.20517228543758392,
1.100892424583435,
0.5490552186965942,
-0.02486346662044525,
-0.09607958793640137,
-0.10590822994709015,
0.7698666453361511,
-0.3291821777820587,
-0.5281909108161926,
-0.933326005935669,
0.10333951562643051,
-0.34422484040260315,
-0.14101873338222504,
0.9599206447601318,
0.6362171173095703,
0.9532331228256226,
0.0712868794798851,
0.8226248621940613,
0.3168642818927765,
0.6852092742919922,
-0.37030336260795593,
0.6569706797599792,
-0.717644989490509,
0.1793392300605774,
-0.44194531440734863,
-0.904518723487854,
-0.18760545551776886,
0.6023040413856506,
-0.38039225339889526,
0.2007935494184494,
0.7817389965057373,
0.8159598708152771,
-0.05278661474585533,
-0.10522264242172241,
0.48710665106773376,
0.4306742250919342,
0.37472841143608093,
0.6299740076065063,
0.8535060882568359,
-0.31220555305480957,
0.7559842467308044,
-0.14387354254722595,
-0.22025389969348907,
0.019584082067012787,
-0.8939710259437561,
-0.9506180286407471,
-0.551957368850708,
-0.21172456443309784,
-0.7070583701133728,
-0.22663040459156036,
0.5248041749000549,
0.8440797328948975,
-1.0798001289367676,
-0.1586666703224182,
0.23691003024578094,
0.08374575525522232,
0.056898847222328186,
-0.18851010501384735,
0.251228004693985,
-0.17804017663002014,
-0.19165275990962982,
0.5277501344680786,
0.37386006116867065,
-0.1939544975757599,
-0.7073927521705627,
-0.0021247861441224813,
0.0703556165099144,
0.2906481623649597,
0.42896348237991333,
0.05365235358476639,
-0.7857385873794556,
-0.564613938331604,
0.08071436733007431,
-0.1007118672132492,
0.0518161915242672,
0.8826869130134583,
-0.8542487621307373,
0.7007764577865601,
0.2689392566680908,
0.5918128490447998,
0.37659168243408203,
-0.0044982354156672955,
0.6187447905540466,
-0.41359803080558777,
-0.2421819269657135,
0.3749280273914337,
0.17801694571971893,
0.31260624527931213,
-0.7142198085784912,
0.5426979064941406,
-0.109976626932621,
-0.5853559374809265,
-0.8407230377197266,
0.5570962429046631,
-0.8677719235420227,
-0.2571287751197815,
1.082140326499939,
-0.36083415150642395,
0.09314556419849396,
-0.24377226829528809,
0.02202608250081539,
-0.08592284470796585,
-0.2692042291164398,
1.0280019044876099,
0.8852015137672424,
-0.04657747223973274,
0.03451484814286232,
-0.25844740867614746,
0.43390634655952454,
0.569290280342102,
-0.7471860647201538,
0.40146055817604065,
0.2512187063694,
0.6022005081176758,
0.31312695145606995,
0.9416384100914001,
-0.18805311620235443,
0.341947078704834,
-0.17320062220096588,
-0.17436480522155762,
-0.1808084398508072,
-0.721683144569397,
-0.38715168833732605,
0.1702902615070343,
0.32157155871391296,
-0.047986216843128204
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09963v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09963v2
|
Take Care of Your Prompt Bias! Investigating and Mitigating Prompt Bias in Factual Knowledge Extraction
| 2024-03-15T02:04:35 | 2024-03-26T04:08:47 |
Ziyang Xu, Keqin Peng, Liang Ding, Dacheng Tao, Xiliang Lu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
Recent research shows that pre-trained language models (PLMs) suffer from
"prompt bias" in factual knowledge extraction, i.e., prompts tend to introduce
biases toward specific labels. Prompt bias presents a significant challenge in
assessing the factual knowledge within PLMs. Therefore, this paper aims to
improve the reliability of existing benchmarks by thoroughly investigating and
mitigating prompt bias. We show that: 1) all prompts in the experiments exhibit
non-negligible bias, with gradient-based prompts like AutoPrompt and OptiPrompt
displaying significantly higher levels of bias; 2) prompt bias can amplify
benchmark accuracy unreasonably by overfitting the test datasets, especially on
imbalanced datasets like LAMA. Based on these findings, we propose a
representation-based approach to mitigate the prompt bias during inference
time. Specifically, we first estimate the biased representation using
prompt-only querying, and then remove it from the model's internal
representations to generate the debiased representations, which are used to
produce the final debiased outputs. Experiments across various prompts, PLMs,
and benchmarks show that our approach can not only correct the overfitted
performance caused by prompt bias, but also significantly improve the prompt
retrieval capability (up to 10% absolute performance gain). These results
indicate that our approach effectively alleviates prompt bias in knowledge
evaluation, thereby enhancing the reliability of benchmark assessments.
Hopefully, our plug-and-play approach can be a golden standard to strengthen
PLMs toward reliable knowledge bases. Code and data are released in
https://github.com/FelliYang/PromptBias.
|
[
-0.6075982451438904,
-0.7434690594673157,
0.5878984332084656,
0.3722259998321533,
-0.17159555852413177,
-0.05147678405046463,
-0.26734498143196106,
-0.0533461831510067,
-0.14053358137607574,
0.521344780921936,
-0.5493493676185608,
-0.40353938937187195,
-0.5907106995582581,
0.02919762395322323,
0.11671051383018494,
0.8568903207778931,
0.144271582365036,
0.3220272362232208,
-0.4185279607772827,
-0.39584699273109436,
-0.7535833120346069,
-0.38924604654312134,
-0.4624093770980835,
-0.17491139471530914,
0.39583802223205566,
0.4133578836917877,
0.590816855430603,
0.4884224236011505,
0.17205072939395905,
0.153265118598938,
-0.0768442153930664,
0.2035001963376999,
-0.2917099893093109,
0.2386016994714737,
-0.1497844159603119,
-0.3996146023273468,
-0.17041562497615814,
0.33585429191589355,
0.6187065839767456,
0.7557207942008972,
-0.05936218798160553,
0.261905699968338,
0.14572328329086304,
0.5405994653701782,
-0.8113590478897095,
0.251397043466568,
-0.48111021518707275,
0.042430609464645386,
-0.2711803615093231,
-0.2654350697994232,
-0.6684695482254028,
-0.6481972932815552,
0.10872291773557663,
-0.6934284567832947,
0.33713918924331665,
0.3845858871936798,
0.46566352248191833,
0.5921755433082581,
-0.37370792031288147,
-0.11367276310920715,
-0.3778725564479828,
0.8191513419151306,
-0.6674014925956726,
0.22720852494239807,
0.3405333161354065,
0.5058078765869141,
-0.217875674366951,
-0.45861169695854187,
-0.4831107556819916,
-0.3736622631549835,
-0.15861202776432037,
0.0047806487418711185,
-0.02295394241809845,
-0.03361024707555771,
0.9813104271888733,
0.06171322986483574,
-0.4996616244316101,
0.18536940217018127,
0.001402886351570487,
-0.4732309579849243,
0.3524993360042572,
0.03159802779555321,
0.33986589312553406,
-0.18727117776870728,
-0.6239426136016846,
-0.06910954415798187,
-1.0489263534545898,
0.23798204958438873,
0.3534224033355713,
0.23228293657302856,
0.2797466218471527,
0.4676350951194763,
-0.1721590906381607,
0.7052433490753174,
0.19157728552818298,
0.030133113265037537,
0.37792831659317017,
-0.300300657749176,
-0.07145791500806808,
0.31333157420158386,
0.7187556028366089,
0.35943013429641724,
0.255620539188385,
-0.10178930312395096,
-0.1771218180656433,
0.08185628801584244,
0.07101497054100037,
-0.6877418756484985,
-0.09602770954370499,
0.0787007063627243,
-0.3708066940307617,
-0.06717290729284286,
-0.008218072354793549,
-1.0179351568222046,
-0.9075321555137634,
-0.3518727123737335,
0.3107244372367859,
-0.29321491718292236,
-0.18448011577129364,
-0.11248518526554108,
-0.06339361518621445,
-0.012174328789114952,
0.3120242655277252,
-0.4996413290500641,
0.23351097106933594,
0.3778476119041443,
0.6354086995124817,
-0.19067098200321198,
-0.15766240656375885,
-1.1108229160308838,
-0.10920457541942596,
-0.29333117604255676,
0.6509516835212708,
-0.47970467805862427,
-0.51133131980896,
0.013065910898149014,
-0.06936047971248627,
-0.026055168360471725,
-0.7061655521392822,
0.8624151945114136,
-0.464519202709198,
0.5310060977935791,
-1.1712017059326172,
-0.5817029476165771,
0.13753102719783783,
0.18673689663410187,
-0.7716988921165466,
1.0505801439285278,
-0.08476374298334122,
-1.0431511402130127,
0.632779061794281,
-0.5361564755439758,
-0.3158029317855835,
-0.15190955996513367,
-0.26349419355392456,
-0.2206578105688095,
-0.2132931649684906,
0.7736170291900635,
0.09935339540243149,
-0.5551388263702393,
0.6898804903030396,
-0.2727755308151245,
-0.36580243706703186,
0.26194754242897034,
-0.5653107166290283,
1.003226637840271,
0.19281050562858582,
-0.6053528189659119,
0.01374142151325941,
-0.7968605756759644,
-0.26201626658439636,
-0.13247144222259521,
-0.016948644071817398,
-0.33535486459732056,
-0.13040286302566528,
-0.4180598855018616,
0.3522624671459198,
0.11758223921060562,
-0.6263226270675659,
0.1983495056629181,
-0.2493859976530075,
-0.030692098662257195,
0.833172619342804,
0.1739715188741684,
0.6453785300254822,
-0.31655076146125793,
0.5927053689956665,
0.29876819252967834,
0.22063148021697998,
-0.38843873143196106,
-0.35679593682289124,
-0.6555535197257996,
-0.36626896262168884,
0.3559923768043518,
0.4261220097541809,
-0.9827631115913391,
0.45509955286979675,
-0.03955364599823952,
-0.3618861138820648,
-0.6005006432533264,
0.02683231793344021,
0.4262305498123169,
1.3368312120437622,
0.5875868201255798,
-0.2010895162820816,
-0.46197569370269775,
-0.662894070148468,
-0.5433306694030762,
-0.2434987872838974,
-0.03640828654170036,
0.12472949177026749,
0.06525684148073196,
-0.07856101542711258,
1.3447338342666626,
-0.5332443118095398,
-0.0235618706792593,
-0.050208982080221176,
0.46374112367630005,
0.19528983533382416,
0.6662678718566895,
0.707202136516571,
-0.6242014169692993,
-0.22016340494155884,
-0.6299950480461121,
-0.5844279527664185,
-0.7544440627098083,
-0.24277806282043457,
-0.23751600086688995,
0.09369510412216187,
0.3143163323402405,
-0.9017446041107178,
0.2693479061126709,
-0.26046550273895264,
-0.3766788840293884,
0.7565091252326965,
0.18549351394176483,
0.05665522813796997,
-0.5267449617385864,
0.3089691400527954,
0.2288738638162613,
-0.1884773224592209,
-0.2908329963684082,
-0.37439095973968506,
0.12227091938257217,
-0.007898444309830666,
-0.190166637301445,
0.7996103763580322,
-0.4249097406864166,
-0.09107600152492523,
-0.16915971040725708,
0.012354392558336258,
0.40339332818984985,
0.4327315092086792,
-0.022339019924402237,
1.044522762298584,
0.6082454323768616,
-0.6161256432533264,
0.20574946701526642,
0.28665730357170105,
-0.37869811058044434,
0.54783695936203,
-0.6154606342315674,
-0.17221257090568542,
-0.37957653403282166,
0.2771289050579071,
-0.9594170451164246,
0.2942952513694763,
0.7771705389022827,
-0.35884907841682434,
0.4523485600948334,
-0.12521758675575256,
-0.5129263997077942,
-0.24892951548099518,
-0.4078177213668823,
0.06430048495531082,
0.6828522682189941,
-0.8222317695617676,
0.2863626182079315,
0.2798388600349426,
-0.38004016876220703,
-0.9337948560714722,
-0.26452165842056274,
-0.2840366065502167,
-0.31174683570861816,
-0.22039145231246948,
0.15677589178085327,
-0.17697395384311676,
-0.27877041697502136,
-0.21852025389671326,
-0.42635592818260193,
0.10523886233568192,
0.042309653013944626,
0.10486488789319992,
0.2639641761779785,
-0.09667586535215378,
0.32566314935684204,
0.029190026223659515,
-0.2762991189956665,
0.4608842730522156,
-0.21623657643795013,
0.5102288126945496,
0.15531541407108307,
-0.5481058359146118,
-0.15374335646629333,
-0.008142992854118347,
0.6186737418174744,
-0.3461605906486511,
0.5193480253219604,
0.6734516024589539,
-0.15096138417720795,
-0.22502928972244263,
-0.9437713623046875,
-0.3573848307132721,
-0.4533480405807495,
-0.10637914389371872,
-0.04360459744930267,
-0.39261263608932495,
0.5324828028678894,
-0.27131393551826477,
0.02925875596702099,
0.3644857704639435,
0.3797648549079895,
0.02886122465133667,
0.9997404217720032,
0.2601509988307953,
-0.24023060500621796,
0.40516629815101624,
0.012816809117794037,
-0.10523691028356552,
-0.8229067325592041,
-0.2642632722854614,
-0.5734395384788513,
-0.046646881848573685,
-0.13711842894554138,
-0.3602658808231354,
0.30276378989219666,
-0.03921270743012428,
-0.3820907771587372,
-0.1530977338552475,
-0.36536458134651184,
0.1675342321395874,
0.815093994140625,
0.09203047305345535,
0.07204356789588928,
-0.16432063281536102,
-0.3353448510169983,
-0.3433087170124054,
-0.6912874579429626,
-0.47644948959350586,
0.9164175391197205,
0.22646166384220123,
0.6390613317489624,
-0.3189525604248047,
0.38273856043815613,
0.5432689785957336,
0.1551145613193512,
-0.3730248808860779,
0.506991982460022,
0.4008033573627472,
-0.4970746636390686,
-0.10077313333749771,
-0.6379104256629944,
-0.45937347412109375,
0.2693685293197632,
0.01848824881017208,
-0.3999894857406616,
0.6163780093193054,
0.12800052762031555,
-0.48216238617897034,
0.06548601388931274,
-0.769858717918396,
0.8204189538955688,
-0.22815243899822235,
-0.6254204511642456,
0.23636266589164734,
-0.7792356610298157,
0.41157716512680054,
0.09484192728996277,
0.2004135698080063,
-0.18473747372627258,
0.12726432085037231,
0.7898658514022827,
-0.5274356603622437,
0.9782252907752991,
-0.7232392430305481,
0.027314715087413788,
0.43092644214630127,
0.04146615043282509,
0.570791482925415,
0.3885352313518524,
-0.2855404019355774,
-0.03301196172833443,
-0.1871022880077362,
-0.5068632960319519,
-0.7364184856414795,
0.4944551885128021,
-0.6577808260917664,
-0.6795859932899475,
-0.5801016688346863,
-0.3934398293495178,
-0.4535992443561554,
0.09489956498146057,
0.34402838349342346,
0.6360606551170349,
-0.21883666515350342,
-0.34854233264923096,
0.8761751055717468,
-0.37812381982803345,
0.45099663734436035,
0.7282834053039551,
-0.019935259595513344,
-0.36794888973236084,
0.7283366918563843,
0.303771436214447,
-0.08027787506580353,
0.018239924684166908,
0.17992107570171356,
-0.5789365768432617,
-0.2588508427143097,
-0.5066134929656982,
0.041767120361328125,
-0.9348074793815613,
-0.3032594919204712,
-0.6921764016151428,
0.10644995421171188,
-0.48103490471839905,
0.2583250403404236,
-0.1531272679567337,
-0.48048651218414307,
-0.4872904419898987,
-0.26973164081573486,
0.19286136329174042,
0.3248268663883209,
-0.0861484482884407,
0.49611911177635193,
-0.6488949656486511,
0.3196466565132141,
0.1729164719581604,
0.03718492388725281,
-0.05528903752565384,
-0.44106653332710266,
0.09346920996904373,
-0.09402331709861755,
-0.08234632760286331,
-0.8598961234092712,
0.30294620990753174,
-0.12286707758903503,
0.9663931131362915,
0.5313473343849182,
0.42282021045684814,
0.4228072166442871,
-0.4210108518600464,
0.8311417698860168,
0.1637592911720276,
-0.9663318991661072,
0.5774043798446655,
-0.06127641350030899,
0.2977011501789093,
0.7685914039611816,
0.42722320556640625,
-0.23078981041908264,
-0.0834866315126419,
-0.6463056206703186,
-0.5518532395362854,
0.6988818645477295,
0.0011276033474132419,
-0.32341036200523376,
-0.07537326961755753,
0.26656919717788696,
0.484048992395401,
0.6388275623321533,
-0.43594852089881897,
-0.2679390013217926,
-0.35775521397590637,
-0.08874957263469696,
-0.08153461664915085,
-0.6316191554069519,
-0.1292106956243515,
-0.27788209915161133,
0.6910768747329712,
-0.10777445882558823,
-0.11473063379526138,
0.2975673973560333,
-0.414989709854126,
-0.043738555163145065,
0.23436912894248962,
0.37533438205718994,
0.7967928647994995,
-0.11983848363161087,
0.29842132329940796,
0.07730516791343689,
-0.3909603953361511,
0.08597221225500107,
0.39705297350883484,
-0.5307287573814392,
0.2920253574848175,
0.31229349970817566,
0.6832318305969238,
0.07115726172924042,
-0.5947057008743286,
0.5603442192077637,
-0.04330321028828621,
0.5798584818840027,
0.09148012101650238,
-0.055004097521305084,
-0.4159533679485321,
-0.0014739036560058594,
0.38938426971435547,
0.40023720264434814,
0.2258995771408081,
-0.11991944909095764,
0.31583482027053833,
0.3026132881641388,
-0.2637781500816345,
-0.37014687061309814,
0.5726497173309326,
0.3689050078392029,
0.26870378851890564,
0.5091465711593628,
-0.3104562759399414,
-0.6288709044456482,
0.6119941473007202,
0.4135599136352539,
0.5694138407707214,
-0.24636319279670715,
0.46323755383491516,
0.5305793881416321,
0.4405997097492218,
-0.25370192527770996,
0.3046167194843292,
-0.23267044126987457,
-0.6281495094299316,
-0.3665112555027008,
-0.35365813970565796,
-0.31894177198410034,
-0.1888028383255005,
-0.6578356623649597,
0.29819509387016296,
-0.43089067935943604,
-0.33771491050720215,
-0.36723124980926514,
0.3443533480167389,
-0.7125443816184998,
0.18657317757606506,
0.09680982679128647,
1.0082361698150635,
-0.950375497341156,
0.6611292362213135,
0.5450423955917358,
-0.6373452544212341,
-0.4072166681289673,
-0.07023907452821732,
-0.11180544644594193,
-0.7118796706199646,
0.6144687533378601,
0.2933160662651062,
0.25524401664733887,
-0.022774748504161835,
-0.6303813457489014,
-0.6438275575637817,
0.7740545868873596,
0.6995810866355896,
-0.6557184457778931,
0.20848996937274933,
0.02503485232591629,
0.13829126954078674,
-0.3026203215122223,
0.5193572640419006,
0.7556357979774475,
0.6817284822463989,
0.018892360851168633,
-0.5986002683639526,
0.3481048047542572,
-0.22627262771129608,
-0.2488836795091629,
-0.1593252271413803,
-0.3479781150817871,
0.8636585474014282,
-0.10795287042856216,
-0.2135029286146164,
-0.1958269625902176,
0.39517202973365784,
0.45273464918136597,
0.5756792426109314,
0.48034340143203735,
0.5647141337394714,
1.271552324295044,
-0.11258810013532639,
0.8789293766021729,
-0.2360403835773468,
0.0726781040430069,
1.21401846408844,
-0.6581724882125854,
0.025356825441122055,
0.5923349857330322,
0.036072876304388046,
0.2982442080974579,
0.6203398108482361,
-0.07690203934907913,
0.7593190670013428,
0.1580243557691574,
-0.2759399712085724,
-0.18172284960746765,
-0.5696040391921997,
-0.6238435506820679,
-0.13186156749725342,
0.275061696767807,
-0.29636576771736145,
-0.3394339382648468,
0.15342772006988525,
0.17534787952899933,
0.046350765973329544,
-0.24340443313121796,
0.6318560242652893,
0.03854271396994591,
-0.8116556406021118,
0.42122122645378113,
-0.3752497434616089,
0.5604143142700195,
-0.4608211815357208,
-0.06138167902827263,
-0.34328100085258484,
-0.23581674695014954,
-0.05658349394798279,
-0.411213219165802,
-0.098948635160923,
-0.08036791533231735,
-0.3250788152217865,
-0.29801949858665466,
1.027998924255371,
-0.34960296750068665,
-0.30328452587127686,
0.003614108543843031,
0.8393599390983582,
-0.1775561273097992,
-0.2253490835428238,
-0.5461405515670776,
0.2197311669588089,
-0.07707890123128891,
-0.3334028124809265,
0.04106861352920532,
0.5388001799583435,
0.014857931062579155,
0.5195098519325256,
0.6168739199638367,
0.2361142486333847,
0.2110135853290558,
0.25545984506607056,
1.0805065631866455,
-0.47807931900024414,
-0.37779855728149414,
-0.9956712126731873,
0.4435899257659912,
-0.34240561723709106,
-0.22840797901153564,
0.8230438232421875,
0.37552526593208313,
0.35829994082450867,
-0.05337904393672943,
0.9378206729888916,
0.10595186799764633,
0.6071563363075256,
-0.5385754108428955,
0.7284179329872131,
-0.06948991864919662,
0.4706440269947052,
-0.14845164120197296,
-0.8506121039390564,
-0.06119862198829651,
0.2704828977584839,
-0.6532285809516907,
-0.0006929393857717514,
0.44668349623680115,
0.6057059168815613,
0.10252153128385544,
0.11788636445999146,
0.03838485851883888,
0.2160325050354004,
0.3239462077617645,
0.1735842227935791,
1.0877294540405273,
-0.18304207921028137,
0.21191926300525665,
-0.30275461077690125,
-0.2904002070426941,
-0.06918739527463913,
-0.9718713164329529,
-0.9257195591926575,
-0.27458852529525757,
-0.45195192098617554,
-0.23311737179756165,
0.145497128367424,
0.923419713973999,
0.4765278398990631,
-0.8136900067329407,
0.29323431849479675,
-0.08345804363489151,
0.4912834167480469,
-0.13046176731586456,
-0.23057222366333008,
0.41606953740119934,
-0.8238555788993835,
-0.4676806628704071,
0.43598267436027527,
-0.14125271141529083,
-0.045034781098365784,
-0.21444785594940186,
0.004755455069243908,
-0.007393260486423969,
-0.13542360067367554,
0.2910313308238983,
0.3163395822048187,
-0.4734768569469452,
-0.1557479053735733,
0.13503842055797577,
-0.08025063574314117,
0.15460093319416046,
0.8247779607772827,
-1.3093268871307373,
0.6150704622268677,
0.5916243195533752,
0.7108917236328125,
-0.03213156759738922,
0.345623254776001,
0.8110361695289612,
-1.0079081058502197,
0.26611608266830444,
0.3623694181442261,
0.530933141708374,
0.5258136987686157,
-0.46153905987739563,
0.4462881088256836,
0.3586605489253998,
-0.4633333683013916,
-1.037811040878296,
0.1582798808813095,
-0.7238791584968567,
-0.17533324658870697,
1.12447988986969,
-0.21828201413154602,
-0.08530756831169128,
-0.09383614361286163,
-0.522393524646759,
0.5234410166740417,
-0.5317469239234924,
0.8374047875404358,
0.674983024597168,
0.22481974959373474,
-0.11553367972373962,
-0.5428328514099121,
0.7045019865036011,
0.678517758846283,
-0.5223674774169922,
0.19128847122192383,
0.6541023850440979,
0.16279390454292297,
0.14757214486598969,
0.5510516166687012,
-0.0590839609503746,
0.26706382632255554,
-0.2612573802471161,
0.09684747457504272,
-0.20786918699741364,
-0.3294016718864441,
-0.4620887339115143,
0.12606197595596313,
0.003008622443303466,
-0.24751251935958862
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09919v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09919v3
|
Recurrent Drafter for Fast Speculative Decoding in Large Language Models
| 2024-03-14T23:40:56 | 2024-05-30T17:55:19 |
Aonan Zhang, Chong Wang, Yi Wang, Xuanyu Zhang, Yunfei Cheng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
In this paper, we introduce an improved approach of speculative decoding
aimed at enhancing the efficiency of serving large language models. Our method
capitalizes on the strengths of two established techniques: the classic
two-model speculative decoding approach, and the more recent single-model
approach, Medusa. Drawing inspiration from Medusa, our approach adopts a
single-model strategy for speculative decoding. However, our method
distinguishes itself by employing a single, lightweight draft head with a
recurrent dependency design, akin in essence to the small, draft model uses in
classic speculative decoding, but without the complexities of the full
transformer architecture. And because of the recurrent dependency, we can use
beam search to swiftly filter out undesired candidates with the draft head. The
outcome is a method that combines the simplicity of single-model design and
avoids the need to create a data-dependent tree attention structure only for
inference in Medusa. We empirically demonstrate the effectiveness of the
proposed method on several popular open source language models, along with a
comprehensive analysis of the trade-offs involved in adopting this approach.
|
[
-0.33081045746803284,
-0.5365720391273499,
0.48583874106407166,
0.2592935860157013,
-0.5153014063835144,
0.12256887555122375,
-0.015629762783646584,
-0.5348258018493652,
0.42549383640289307,
0.8690440058708191,
-0.6699743270874023,
-0.28049883246421814,
-0.5173984169960022,
0.12855787575244904,
-0.4489278793334961,
0.7648161053657532,
-0.055258527398109436,
-0.368539035320282,
0.1949063539505005,
0.12418734282255173,
-0.2187257558107376,
-0.2710912227630615,
-0.9730505347251892,
-0.21897606551647186,
0.6380509734153748,
0.23790156841278076,
0.5761770009994507,
0.6036344170570374,
0.3322165906429291,
0.2551339268684387,
-0.27416935563087463,
0.35425040125846863,
-0.7876449823379517,
0.2733745872974396,
-0.17535540461540222,
-0.3915986120700836,
-0.46065810322761536,
-0.10939399152994156,
0.8063873648643494,
0.5435102581977844,
-0.29951319098472595,
0.2534719705581665,
-0.20365767180919647,
0.7929713726043701,
-0.7429403066635132,
0.21688319742679596,
-0.8517865538597107,
0.02993653528392315,
-0.555031418800354,
-0.5148136615753174,
-1.15494704246521,
-0.205460786819458,
0.04265326261520386,
-0.663702130317688,
0.3920670449733734,
0.10439376533031464,
0.4616927206516266,
0.28854942321777344,
-0.24413494765758514,
0.20380017161369324,
-0.9831419587135315,
0.7735126614570618,
-0.709173321723938,
0.5095001459121704,
0.3259024918079376,
0.31463733315467834,
-0.14380189776420593,
-0.9066840410232544,
-0.41136184334754944,
-0.07310453802347183,
-0.15280774235725403,
-0.026327311992645264,
-0.4314262866973877,
0.003917316906154156,
0.1581103354692459,
0.2953000068664551,
-0.5353401899337769,
0.013195985928177834,
-0.4577224850654602,
-0.15186002850532532,
0.38336116075515747,
0.3362235724925995,
-0.13814136385917664,
0.08725491166114807,
-0.12900690734386444,
-0.029026826843619347,
-0.691510021686554,
-0.174904465675354,
0.1933051198720932,
0.29147955775260925,
0.10865434259176254,
0.36719945073127747,
-0.2598114609718323,
0.8028200268745422,
0.38380730152130127,
-0.10582656413316727,
0.0900813639163971,
-0.2017412930727005,
-0.09358008205890656,
-0.15893948078155518,
0.5556848049163818,
0.13532711565494537,
-0.02557557262480259,
-0.42289209365844727,
-0.10318698734045029,
0.15183353424072266,
0.46575140953063965,
-0.9059172868728638,
-0.07758211344480515,
0.27543777227401733,
-0.8542578220367432,
-0.4692860543727875,
-0.09293076395988464,
-0.9718146324157715,
-0.2906304895877838,
0.01729472167789936,
-0.1516333967447281,
-0.453386127948761,
-0.4787047505378723,
0.5701435804367065,
-0.27329930663108826,
0.08483162522315979,
0.21804694831371307,
-1.1227678060531616,
0.3205412030220032,
0.5949448943138123,
0.7142004370689392,
-0.08127520233392715,
-0.3341866731643677,
-0.6283196210861206,
0.1046178862452507,
-0.356554239988327,
1.084180474281311,
-0.5890822410583496,
-0.28031131625175476,
-0.26340779662132263,
-0.1910410225391388,
-0.00017277512233704329,
-0.15395554900169373,
0.610875129699707,
-0.7546095252037048,
0.15943439304828644,
0.06860329955816269,
-0.43073606491088867,
-0.3034549057483673,
0.03309021517634392,
-0.9724192023277283,
0.6997401714324951,
0.2515236735343933,
-1.1708780527114868,
0.2545028626918793,
-0.37967976927757263,
-0.35343754291534424,
0.005996709689497948,
-0.2334788739681244,
-0.20029127597808838,
0.39508742094039917,
0.22382180392742157,
0.19594420492649078,
-0.6483054757118225,
0.06754201650619507,
-0.3878587484359741,
-0.5049954652786255,
0.01009636651724577,
-0.7057998776435852,
0.704871654510498,
0.5518833994865417,
0.010992718860507011,
0.10176245123147964,
-0.7901268005371094,
0.15473335981369019,
0.26954999566078186,
-0.3426383435726166,
-0.3407926559448242,
0.23345829546451569,
0.33353182673454285,
-0.055485036224126816,
-0.03324354067444801,
-0.6677864789962769,
0.46163997054100037,
-0.7387962341308594,
0.40232977271080017,
0.5547858476638794,
0.07517776638269424,
0.3710390031337738,
-0.21036949753761292,
0.7326597571372986,
-0.14008364081382751,
0.0016148200957104564,
-0.3672996461391449,
-0.19978901743888855,
-0.6030824780464172,
-0.360731840133667,
0.2707561254501343,
0.1878572255373001,
-0.9378275275230408,
0.10908036679029465,
-0.052941031754016876,
-0.5490416884422302,
-0.9096656441688538,
-0.16783647239208221,
0.428785115480423,
0.04242691397666931,
0.18578597903251648,
0.06309335678815842,
-0.9073344469070435,
-0.7993320226669312,
-0.354295939207077,
-0.09210958331823349,
0.2745252847671509,
-0.22797466814517975,
0.0420762300491333,
-0.26510804891586304,
0.7795454859733582,
-0.7038347125053406,
0.20084743201732635,
-0.6017584800720215,
0.25559377670288086,
0.452495276927948,
0.45902469754219055,
0.832952082157135,
-0.698276937007904,
-0.43415942788124084,
0.2229987531900406,
-0.4494952857494354,
0.26730987429618835,
-0.19285741448402405,
-0.0557868555188179,
0.36913758516311646,
0.5481245517730713,
-0.8349228501319885,
0.20820800960063934,
0.6565887331962585,
-0.5807221531867981,
0.49111947417259216,
-0.1562318056821823,
0.030168117955327034,
-1.1789195537567139,
0.538540244102478,
-0.3211045265197754,
-0.08317691832780838,
-0.8184347152709961,
0.455722451210022,
0.12349533289670944,
-0.06898625940084457,
-0.45494192838668823,
0.6370882391929626,
-0.4570094048976898,
0.3836292028427124,
-0.5931064486503601,
-0.2434222251176834,
-0.08658535033464432,
0.4189315438270569,
0.26785245537757874,
0.6826377511024475,
0.42965590953826904,
-0.20232410728931427,
0.042262718081474304,
0.0015926018822938204,
-0.3031807541847229,
-0.11851689964532852,
-0.6910858750343323,
0.498442679643631,
-0.5597382187843323,
0.4867129325866699,
-0.8305801749229431,
-0.031993165612220764,
0.3176420331001282,
-0.2936641573905945,
0.46213990449905396,
-0.38071057200431824,
-0.4547753930091858,
-0.7164372205734253,
-0.3309173285961151,
0.7098615169525146,
0.1473110169172287,
-0.48667579889297485,
0.6900386810302734,
0.31410810351371765,
-0.13553696870803833,
-0.7634373307228088,
-0.6770379543304443,
-0.09386182576417923,
-0.08843602985143661,
-0.5884501338005066,
0.32612019777297974,
-0.17264239490032196,
-0.09396050125360489,
0.0266487468034029,
-0.26445314288139343,
-0.17127203941345215,
-0.002679242519661784,
0.01846189610660076,
0.5038048028945923,
-0.424693763256073,
-0.24196691811084747,
0.08146043866872787,
-0.7382996082305908,
-0.1737602800130844,
-0.6275207996368408,
0.4748177230358124,
0.023892441764473915,
-0.019115440547466278,
-0.41901615262031555,
0.8511491417884827,
1.1044540405273438,
-0.4369376599788666,
0.6411175727844238,
0.3629010021686554,
-0.3090774714946747,
-0.4346730709075928,
-0.8201083540916443,
-0.18548691272735596,
-0.4854402542114258,
0.3637279272079468,
-0.5777693390846252,
-1.034600019454956,
0.3840491771697998,
0.1530052274465561,
0.3554059565067291,
0.3514593243598938,
0.45510709285736084,
0.3028366267681122,
1.022625207901001,
1.0521316528320312,
-0.31537410616874695,
0.4124646484851837,
-0.24988776445388794,
0.13275769352912903,
-0.5568214058876038,
0.038057841360569,
-0.5760717988014221,
-0.06341968476772308,
-0.32225966453552246,
-0.4787411391735077,
-0.032757263630628586,
-0.22830501198768616,
0.0061538852751255035,
0.38253480195999146,
-0.4528762996196747,
0.6758375763893127,
0.42551568150520325,
0.0889970138669014,
0.4781799614429474,
0.2179279923439026,
-0.037692658603191376,
-0.10217005759477615,
-0.8794623613357544,
-0.2090950310230255,
1.0676631927490234,
0.44354480504989624,
1.0975642204284668,
-0.03245971351861954,
0.5537875890731812,
-0.10332309454679489,
0.26379624009132385,
-0.7202174663543701,
0.2636714279651642,
-0.4876164495944977,
-0.6961418390274048,
-0.046183791011571884,
-0.5905113816261292,
-0.9473584890365601,
0.5071341395378113,
-0.1829708069562912,
-0.7545223832130432,
0.3329417109489441,
0.37288036942481995,
-0.7228327989578247,
0.45537617802619934,
-0.6021449565887451,
0.8836045265197754,
0.3143377900123596,
-0.054019495844841,
-0.4668023884296417,
-0.26915350556373596,
0.6240333318710327,
-0.14437955617904663,
-0.0890054851770401,
0.18335507810115814,
0.1614006906747818,
0.6207354664802551,
-0.21708452701568604,
0.7783289551734924,
0.028527606278657913,
-0.05327003076672554,
0.29424598813056946,
0.3006781041622162,
0.8094512820243835,
0.06866670399904251,
-0.3558465838432312,
-0.13810977339744568,
0.13499684631824493,
-0.42513105273246765,
-0.44464489817619324,
0.5540505647659302,
-0.6078458428382874,
-0.4409278929233551,
-0.2805373966693878,
-0.8065595030784607,
-0.21936950087547302,
0.5253233313560486,
0.5510037541389465,
0.5041349530220032,
-0.34592902660369873,
0.14631536602973938,
0.630702018737793,
0.13601769506931305,
0.2448951005935669,
0.7859272956848145,
-0.38778582215309143,
-0.3230474293231964,
0.5790250301361084,
-0.1685863584280014,
0.2744661867618561,
0.6574094891548157,
-0.08677046746015549,
0.0026077579241245985,
-0.7279362678527832,
-0.21293462812900543,
0.4581739604473114,
-0.4076409935951233,
-0.26809537410736084,
-0.7030197978019714,
-0.23778750002384186,
-0.22206997871398926,
0.003966859541833401,
-0.7876465916633606,
-0.3526242971420288,
0.07836057990789413,
-0.05983058735728264,
0.37128445506095886,
0.7552794814109802,
0.32871970534324646,
0.1676342785358429,
-0.816948413848877,
0.42967793345451355,
0.0314701646566391,
0.42792171239852905,
0.29743748903274536,
-0.5123102068901062,
-0.3085566461086273,
-0.21340112388134003,
-0.007525947876274586,
-0.7119200229644775,
0.37467363476753235,
-0.291082501411438,
0.5782440900802612,
0.6532725691795349,
0.20431429147720337,
0.5070673823356628,
-0.6310440897941589,
0.18269000947475433,
0.14701643586158752,
-0.717125415802002,
0.42433300614356995,
-0.3840699791908264,
0.6436012387275696,
0.689178466796875,
0.12924280762672424,
-0.6458372473716736,
-0.6425517797470093,
-0.4244996905326843,
-0.6756461262702942,
1.076096534729004,
0.15175330638885498,
-0.18213823437690735,
-0.07367563247680664,
0.23424310982227325,
0.4078907072544098,
-0.07090525329113007,
-0.3194877505302429,
-0.4142153561115265,
0.06547108292579651,
0.12541915476322174,
-0.12074609845876694,
-0.6894499659538269,
0.14968779683113098,
-0.04909464716911316,
0.44671428203582764,
-0.1170668974518776,
0.27326318621635437,
-0.012502140365540981,
0.23940245807170868,
-0.40297815203666687,
0.2842685282230377,
0.42419469356536865,
0.44246968626976013,
-0.5198811292648315,
0.3258904218673706,
-0.05374526232481003,
-0.5715389251708984,
0.009426603093743324,
0.12777121365070343,
-0.42217761278152466,
0.26849299669265747,
0.31981295347213745,
0.7522064447402954,
0.5235132575035095,
-0.48931971192359924,
-0.06671594083309174,
-0.18808527290821075,
-0.13779878616333008,
-0.039292577654123306,
-0.23336246609687805,
0.21042750775814056,
0.3044640123844147,
0.3075445592403412,
0.7073320746421814,
0.18805867433547974,
-0.4170854389667511,
0.2588900029659271,
0.08894999325275421,
0.11307679116725922,
-0.30505043268203735,
0.47526776790618896,
0.1912829428911209,
0.015771545469760895,
0.5876787900924683,
-0.213600292801857,
-0.10591121017932892,
0.43609458208084106,
0.939319372177124,
1.0722187757492065,
-0.18068984150886536,
0.14350174367427826,
0.5096012949943542,
0.3610706627368927,
-0.4048430025577545,
0.5256960988044739,
0.184774249792099,
-0.6560894250869751,
-0.8158467411994934,
-0.45045921206474304,
-0.17345495522022247,
0.14890418946743011,
-0.695000946521759,
0.10903996974229813,
-0.39170047640800476,
-0.16467706859111786,
0.138776034116745,
-0.30128026008605957,
-0.5910931825637817,
-0.4813985526561737,
0.2797801196575165,
1.3361185789108276,
-0.4363541007041931,
1.2058069705963135,
0.5232605338096619,
-0.23907215893268585,
-0.788321852684021,
0.06825917959213257,
0.18164782226085663,
-0.4063451290130615,
0.3624206781387329,
0.024266524240374565,
-0.4832640290260315,
0.18937534093856812,
-0.07598452270030975,
-1.2405441999435425,
0.8540430665016174,
0.5125157237052917,
-0.7364110350608826,
-0.3518434166908264,
-0.5491133332252502,
0.35018599033355713,
-0.4675678312778473,
0.14855824410915375,
0.6824206709861755,
0.36312174797058105,
0.163755863904953,
-0.7418628931045532,
0.2570691406726837,
-0.45227253437042236,
0.23768554627895355,
0.4233146905899048,
-0.4853133261203766,
0.7355139851570129,
-0.4413915276527405,
-0.675375759601593,
0.48811689019203186,
0.8408902883529663,
0.1700141429901123,
0.07822136580944061,
0.369894802570343,
0.40328091382980347,
0.6265474557876587,
0.38348376750946045,
1.199599266052246,
-0.31974297761917114,
0.6088532209396362,
1.26847505569458,
0.008164922706782818,
1.1935312747955322,
0.5034381151199341,
-0.23776130378246307,
0.28774526715278625,
0.20928072929382324,
0.2749667167663574,
0.6988840699195862,
-0.11838994175195694,
-0.17423266172409058,
-0.3782137632369995,
0.17806722223758698,
-0.44052883982658386,
0.33176854252815247,
0.30445927381515503,
-0.2551032602787018,
-0.5314106941223145,
0.029126908630132675,
0.0659642294049263,
0.028823619708418846,
-0.2428816854953766,
0.44926053285598755,
0.12647393345832825,
-0.821144163608551,
0.7738405466079712,
0.08433643728494644,
0.7244042754173279,
-0.7817420363426208,
0.06774000078439713,
-0.28672993183135986,
0.579642653465271,
-0.021111207082867622,
-0.579594612121582,
0.46970975399017334,
0.04897342622280121,
-0.6873310804367065,
-0.16481053829193115,
0.6062847375869751,
-0.4543546140193939,
-0.615210771560669,
0.3623599410057068,
0.4302104711532593,
-0.023531388491392136,
-0.1826789826154709,
-0.3711149990558624,
0.5421908497810364,
0.12536826729774475,
-0.218462735414505,
-0.007060398813337088,
0.4452162981033325,
0.26384878158569336,
0.6515586376190186,
0.5778416991233826,
0.06427313387393951,
-0.2690776586532593,
0.09169876575469971,
0.977647602558136,
-0.8145371079444885,
-0.6721027493476868,
-0.7435564398765564,
0.37709492444992065,
0.24608944356441498,
-0.3319960832595825,
0.6259624361991882,
0.3794765770435333,
0.6201804280281067,
-0.3318379521369934,
0.7517327666282654,
-0.056147534400224686,
0.6179131865501404,
-0.5745581984519958,
0.8293437957763672,
-0.23191332817077637,
0.32541584968566895,
-0.188487246632576,
-0.8112180233001709,
-0.242317333817482,
0.39725035429000854,
0.01593083143234253,
-0.22607484459877014,
0.9682556390762329,
0.8356946706771851,
-0.23995907604694366,
0.19352605938911438,
0.24752067029476166,
0.4287564754486084,
-0.019805939868092537,
0.8116568922996521,
0.8038780689239502,
-0.29394373297691345,
0.5220001339912415,
-0.21018603444099426,
-0.2881632149219513,
-0.26713404059410095,
-0.6602692008018494,
-1.0639986991882324,
-0.4582269489765167,
-0.08457827568054199,
-0.30217796564102173,
0.09955494105815887,
1.0051950216293335,
0.8206777572631836,
-0.8326429724693298,
-0.15391816198825836,
-0.07743541896343231,
0.02029198780655861,
-0.5369069576263428,
-0.18291617929935455,
0.27890005707740784,
-0.42644786834716797,
-0.5664533972740173,
0.7816063761711121,
0.25093379616737366,
-0.258762925863266,
-0.277964323759079,
-0.0017833621241152287,
-0.02911461517214775,
0.13155511021614075,
0.7476057410240173,
0.4554925858974457,
-0.8445164561271667,
-0.07448545098304749,
0.045843783766031265,
-0.06946711987257004,
-0.2581750750541687,
1.2807984352111816,
-0.9231763482093811,
0.503394603729248,
0.6376147270202637,
0.6196524500846863,
0.7002843618392944,
-0.2870144546031952,
0.8104129433631897,
-0.3294923007488251,
0.5752410888671875,
0.2847941517829895,
0.4932817816734314,
-0.18683308362960815,
-0.3940320312976837,
0.3858599066734314,
0.11580178886651993,
-0.20202793180942535,
-0.7088778614997864,
0.325825959444046,
-1.1376285552978516,
-0.5626775622367859,
0.8917109370231628,
-0.09470527619123459,
-0.13525542616844177,
-0.13351203501224518,
-0.45880258083343506,
-0.14274300634860992,
-0.526896059513092,
0.8106098175048828,
0.4476855397224426,
0.21794918179512024,
-0.32750701904296875,
-0.43665194511413574,
0.3126097619533539,
0.23038651049137115,
-0.4803643524646759,
0.5412829518318176,
0.3576772212982178,
0.170416459441185,
0.24542194604873657,
0.8422852158546448,
-0.14957976341247559,
0.6261119842529297,
0.4825611114501953,
-0.04887423291802406,
-0.16688582301139832,
-0.5273723602294922,
-0.24313518404960632,
0.36303359270095825,
0.245300754904747,
0.04547051712870598
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09892v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09892v1
|
Geographically-Informed Language Identification
| 2024-03-14T21:55:17 | 2024-03-14T21:55:17 |
Jonathan Dunn, Lane Edwards-Brown
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper develops an approach to language identification in which the set
of languages considered by the model depends on the geographic origin of the
text in question. Given that many digital corpora can be geo-referenced at the
country level, this paper formulates 16 region-specific models, each of which
contains the languages expected to appear in countries within that region.
These regional models also each include 31 widely-spoken international
languages in order to ensure coverage of these linguae francae regardless of
location. An upstream evaluation using traditional language identification
testing data shows an improvement in f-score ranging from 1.7 points (Southeast
Asia) to as much as 10.4 points (North Africa). A downstream evaluation on
social media data shows that this improved performance has a significant impact
on the language labels which are applied to large real-world corpora. The
result is a highly-accurate model that covers 916 languages at a sample size of
50 characters, the performance improved by incorporating geographic information
into the model.
|
[
-0.5421262383460999,
-0.8457667827606201,
0.5790558457374573,
0.4126755893230438,
-0.0323525108397007,
0.4042869210243225,
-0.5915531516075134,
-0.919435441493988,
0.23151983320713043,
0.42952072620391846,
-0.36306992173194885,
-0.6980562210083008,
-0.5888386964797974,
0.31418827176094055,
-0.4961962103843689,
0.6677790284156799,
-0.05504484474658966,
-0.1366749405860901,
0.4833025634288788,
-0.2060154527425766,
-0.15311852097511292,
-0.7922713160514832,
-0.2972589433193207,
-0.01921519823372364,
0.4556127190589905,
0.4121497571468353,
0.72450852394104,
0.8161997199058533,
0.4951961934566498,
0.3702544569969177,
-0.24717770516872406,
0.0896228700876236,
-0.39591237902641296,
-0.4181472957134247,
-0.18295790255069733,
-0.5316763520240784,
-0.015532721765339375,
-0.13515828549861908,
0.6681684851646423,
0.785625159740448,
0.04231473430991173,
0.2905155122280121,
-0.17272356152534485,
0.40800511837005615,
-0.3957977592945099,
0.14044062793254852,
-0.6096210479736328,
-0.12098860740661621,
-0.47840416431427,
-0.0752401053905487,
-0.35862258076667786,
-0.672336220741272,
0.5486935973167419,
-0.42264750599861145,
0.495940625667572,
-0.12176540493965149,
1.0249158143997192,
-0.34341755509376526,
-0.42645585536956787,
-0.5619415044784546,
-1.1556830406188965,
0.698359489440918,
-0.36749202013015747,
0.4441055655479431,
0.6580716371536255,
0.39339950680732727,
-0.03715506196022034,
-0.15176858007907867,
-0.226782888174057,
-0.05497835576534271,
-0.14898091554641724,
-0.1636151522397995,
-0.07463633269071579,
-0.2669597566127777,
0.2068282812833786,
0.3913848102092743,
-0.557440996170044,
0.17908361554145813,
-0.6235899925231934,
-0.23814518749713898,
0.7243285775184631,
-0.2702180743217468,
0.6631126403808594,
-0.05985966697335243,
-0.20044927299022675,
0.18760177493095398,
-0.9303833246231079,
0.024826422333717346,
0.6188748478889465,
0.8242320418357849,
-0.43303191661834717,
0.5077270269393921,
-0.4545883536338806,
0.758700430393219,
0.04363087937235832,
-0.38246092200279236,
0.2987218499183655,
-0.4257718324661255,
-0.04592352360486984,
0.1611369550228119,
0.6869298815727234,
0.0069090453907847404,
0.4664999544620514,
-0.30619391798973083,
-0.2685926556587219,
-0.2869773507118225,
-0.1503290981054306,
-0.4690661132335663,
-0.08588045835494995,
0.15204715728759766,
-0.3095532953739166,
-0.06207874044775963,
0.3502171039581299,
-0.7340439558029175,
-0.29795950651168823,
-0.4746512770652771,
0.0016104000387713313,
-0.4452846944332123,
-0.5996283292770386,
-0.32837599515914917,
0.08798614889383316,
0.17535065114498138,
-0.0801311731338501,
-1.11539888381958,
0.19990552961826324,
0.6840209364891052,
0.945690929889679,
0.08790962398052216,
-0.3165140151977539,
-0.05458395555615425,
-0.0259593166410923,
-0.5409465432167053,
0.9227439761161804,
-0.755128026008606,
-0.12209729105234146,
0.42324668169021606,
0.3980908989906311,
0.14149712026119232,
-0.6635340452194214,
0.16667939722537994,
-0.958985447883606,
0.29218757152557373,
-0.7382718324661255,
-0.09920325875282288,
-0.5495789647102356,
0.037840135395526886,
-1.0339890718460083,
1.247693419456482,
0.4810284674167633,
-0.7077309489250183,
0.5605918169021606,
-0.3537820279598236,
-0.3011431396007538,
0.3259963393211365,
0.013368592597544193,
-0.002058823360130191,
0.13942396640777588,
0.4133423864841461,
0.15061944723129272,
-0.316218763589859,
0.6497381925582886,
-0.2155744433403015,
-0.34405696392059326,
0.13243579864501953,
-0.3387131989002228,
1.0858869552612305,
0.42255836725234985,
-0.4125240743160248,
-0.05370447039604187,
-1.075838565826416,
-0.06771894544363022,
0.047210924327373505,
-0.27292197942733765,
-0.6785524487495422,
-0.04737113416194916,
0.11492814123630524,
0.07788582146167755,
0.4197421967983246,
-0.6680901050567627,
-0.07694058120250702,
-0.4952488839626312,
0.11918126046657562,
0.4856785535812378,
0.02863161265850067,
0.7595572471618652,
0.021050121635198593,
0.7718772292137146,
-0.1755143702030182,
-0.06986663490533829,
0.141751229763031,
-0.48829385638237,
-0.46931543946266174,
-0.5510605573654175,
0.773716151714325,
0.9011560678482056,
-0.689072847366333,
0.4801262617111206,
-0.38993141055107117,
-0.8675718903541565,
-0.4846363961696625,
0.07956255972385406,
0.263461709022522,
0.06125807762145996,
0.055808089673519135,
-0.1308874785900116,
-0.7201535105705261,
-0.9094803929328918,
0.06255105882883072,
-0.3066932260990143,
-0.2590663731098175,
0.2624131739139557,
0.3685237467288971,
-0.10062126815319061,
1.0905834436416626,
-0.3180932104587555,
0.19163502752780914,
-0.4057876467704773,
-0.12088599801063538,
0.16922762989997864,
-0.049348849803209305,
0.8222103118896484,
-0.7016189098358154,
-0.568105161190033,
0.2739105522632599,
-0.574755847454071,
-0.5468325614929199,
0.026854725554585457,
-0.30276259779930115,
0.29788199067115784,
0.3559487760066986,
-0.08434895426034927,
0.3172345757484436,
0.8739697933197021,
-0.236811563372612,
0.3403189182281494,
-0.32332444190979004,
0.27647385001182556,
-0.9811217188835144,
0.2012830376625061,
0.32981187105178833,
0.14176253974437714,
-0.6260499358177185,
0.06712385267019272,
0.13217762112617493,
-0.17658746242523193,
-0.2954222857952118,
0.7074538469314575,
-0.5027439594268799,
-0.11185235530138016,
0.07125881314277649,
0.48462435603141785,
-0.3746020197868347,
0.24850615859031677,
0.420727014541626,
0.7609646320343018,
0.39508873224258423,
-0.5634464621543884,
0.13980801403522491,
-0.07236558943986893,
-0.864294171333313,
0.33471012115478516,
-0.5408271551132202,
-0.19818659126758575,
-0.2824275493621826,
0.05277930200099945,
-1.0437802076339722,
-0.25832241773605347,
0.09287634491920471,
-0.2500419616699219,
0.014512824825942516,
-0.3298071622848511,
-0.3743816614151001,
-0.06690366566181183,
0.4404526948928833,
0.3809662461280823,
-0.013996931724250317,
-0.7660087943077087,
0.3936004936695099,
0.7253434658050537,
-0.5361723899841309,
-0.589481770992279,
-0.567753791809082,
0.08087418228387833,
-0.599459707736969,
-0.4406227469444275,
0.24305351078510284,
0.05655525624752045,
-0.5194671750068665,
-0.17694519460201263,
0.4606839418411255,
-0.5375739336013794,
0.2947969138622284,
0.07432551681995392,
0.0721936896443367,
-0.270682692527771,
0.2576369643211365,
-0.15749146044254303,
0.012771139852702618,
-0.020965496078133583,
-0.16867704689502716,
0.4241548776626587,
0.015940938144922256,
-0.043390240520238876,
-0.36803585290908813,
0.669448971748352,
0.43605414032936096,
-0.7348789572715759,
0.8292033076286316,
0.43322548270225525,
-0.5669696927070618,
-0.1373385488986969,
-0.34524866938591003,
0.1262180507183075,
-0.4463946223258972,
0.40032392740249634,
-0.632376492023468,
-0.6061124205589294,
0.9928485751152039,
-0.1274336278438568,
-0.2629826068878174,
0.4832497239112854,
0.49721434712409973,
0.2799271047115326,
0.7896556854248047,
1.1780415773391724,
-0.5525259971618652,
0.7386360764503479,
-0.08209183812141418,
0.6064305305480957,
-0.15128889679908752,
-0.15228360891342163,
-0.9564349055290222,
-0.03952181339263916,
-1.1978117227554321,
-0.32758840918540955,
0.0040386333130300045,
0.17264695465564728,
-0.26380807161331177,
0.5512120127677917,
-0.23940034210681915,
0.5830340385437012,
0.6095836162567139,
-0.1647534966468811,
0.1486780196428299,
0.4043176770210266,
-0.3936043381690979,
-0.095229871571064,
-0.677527666091919,
-0.8089076280593872,
0.7690370678901672,
0.41042274236679077,
0.45082974433898926,
0.5840084552764893,
0.5884748101234436,
0.037365105003118515,
0.5540220141410828,
-0.5487893223762512,
0.2705804705619812,
-0.02402147278189659,
-0.898434579372406,
-0.19510748982429504,
-0.36099961400032043,
-0.7670618891716003,
0.10934893786907196,
-0.10202483832836151,
-0.942040205001831,
0.2061028927564621,
-0.24382522702217102,
-0.2953047454357147,
0.08333093672990799,
-0.8077895641326904,
0.5418601036071777,
-0.4633016586303711,
0.10856649279594421,
0.21024268865585327,
-0.3983045518398285,
0.29681453108787537,
-0.44940051436424255,
0.5982944369316101,
-0.14106887578964233,
0.2613236606121063,
0.5658644437789917,
-0.2346941977739334,
0.920704185962677,
-0.22602307796478271,
-0.3591476082801819,
0.5800459384918213,
-0.02679499238729477,
0.09686192870140076,
-0.05898120626807213,
-0.3446615934371948,
0.6314014792442322,
0.05023480951786041,
-0.37732288241386414,
-0.47807392477989197,
0.6700894832611084,
-0.8863855600357056,
-0.2127358466386795,
-0.2916521728038788,
-0.3386664092540741,
-0.046211741864681244,
0.45960676670074463,
0.1843041181564331,
0.793642520904541,
-0.28499796986579895,
0.0027297327760607004,
0.5547803044319153,
-0.5998502969741821,
0.3369320333003998,
0.7817584276199341,
-0.2505916953086853,
-0.5695178508758545,
0.7045325040817261,
0.3232713043689728,
0.17003056406974792,
0.5302577614784241,
0.20469249784946442,
-0.4535249173641205,
-0.2583838701248169,
-0.4283674359321594,
0.5349540114402771,
-0.7840263247489929,
0.1792808175086975,
-0.256939560174942,
-0.02526658959686756,
-0.16523440182209015,
-0.2264004647731781,
-0.14824289083480835,
-0.10807442665100098,
-0.05788886919617653,
-0.21662187576293945,
0.2968640923500061,
1.0617960691452026,
-0.05681440979242325,
0.49211880564689636,
-0.574564516544342,
0.05886293202638626,
-0.26145312190055847,
0.5634840130805969,
-0.10290461033582687,
-0.42170649766921997,
-0.32172316312789917,
0.1077202633023262,
0.2808964252471924,
-1.061212420463562,
0.46008187532424927,
0.04421638697385788,
0.7057858109474182,
0.4044840633869171,
-0.059293124824762344,
0.8797447681427002,
-0.6509180665016174,
0.6887807846069336,
-0.3397456407546997,
-0.8542394042015076,
0.44169914722442627,
-0.34435412287712097,
0.618108332157135,
0.5375335812568665,
0.8446641564369202,
-0.6327807307243347,
-0.7034953832626343,
-0.3400377929210663,
-0.8522796630859375,
0.3974755108356476,
-0.3513842821121216,
0.12810732424259186,
-0.36399462819099426,
0.40342360734939575,
-0.014590892009437084,
-0.22088073194026947,
-0.7411186099052429,
-0.09244472533464432,
0.3544370234012604,
-0.4254375994205475,
-0.2913956940174103,
-0.39383792877197266,
0.010605644434690475,
0.06298699975013733,
0.6722864508628845,
-0.17928126454353333,
0.20954236388206482,
0.2115553766489029,
-0.2891268730163574,
-0.11864025145769119,
0.14538060128688812,
0.8192349672317505,
1.1487736701965332,
-0.11382652074098587,
0.1150464415550232,
-0.0388396680355072,
-0.33465468883514404,
0.01303795538842678,
-0.02763277478516102,
-0.303833931684494,
0.28695186972618103,
0.3953128755092621,
0.5044191479682922,
-0.03023388981819153,
-0.4387761652469635,
0.10488971322774887,
-0.27431929111480713,
0.12420041859149933,
-0.4352525472640991,
-0.3686504364013672,
0.10725808143615723,
0.31426385045051575,
0.39765211939811707,
-0.22133409976959229,
-0.046392299234867096,
-0.49732300639152527,
0.19334061443805695,
0.34249943494796753,
-0.5514872670173645,
-0.5238078236579895,
0.43004709482192993,
0.22808389365673065,
-0.464097261428833,
0.6298059225082397,
-0.2065040022134781,
-0.883761465549469,
0.774356484413147,
0.627216100692749,
0.6427933573722839,
-0.5150916576385498,
0.29624488949775696,
0.7650160789489746,
0.675209641456604,
0.11174684017896652,
0.3830787241458893,
0.09128358960151672,
-0.6861175894737244,
-0.4629487693309784,
-0.5957809686660767,
-0.18026220798492432,
0.10967407375574112,
-0.5795819163322449,
0.398807168006897,
-0.2544737756252289,
-0.25125956535339355,
0.046300001442432404,
0.28801706433296204,
-0.7084360122680664,
0.41770726442337036,
0.4365703761577606,
1.0165636539459229,
-1.4513415098190308,
0.821208119392395,
0.4887239336967468,
-0.10156727582216263,
-0.7574652433395386,
-0.019153594970703125,
0.13807399570941925,
-0.4453008770942688,
0.830240786075592,
0.22863641381263733,
-0.20736809074878693,
-0.2221999168395996,
-0.4034004509449005,
-1.5499992370605469,
0.701955258846283,
0.0494576096534729,
-0.4708938002586365,
0.4665779173374176,
0.26620808243751526,
0.8375481367111206,
-0.5637012124061584,
0.44076022505760193,
0.5821853876113892,
0.25694021582603455,
-0.10628538578748703,
-1.0903642177581787,
0.015049786306917667,
-0.13435660302639008,
0.29248321056365967,
0.3292813003063202,
-0.4255574643611908,
0.4351550340652466,
-0.3255215883255005,
-0.5062196254730225,
0.1274126023054123,
0.7084800601005554,
0.35997116565704346,
-0.07278551906347275,
0.46019041538238525,
-0.008070659823715687,
1.1931055784225464,
-0.23233522474765778,
0.9095495343208313,
-0.706940770149231,
0.2669890522956848,
1.0840916633605957,
-0.21573209762573242,
1.0353021621704102,
0.0847114846110344,
-0.09621869027614594,
0.522252082824707,
0.8734884858131409,
0.1133953407406807,
0.6385919451713562,
0.20497481524944305,
-0.39634349942207336,
0.23330503702163696,
-0.21256132423877716,
-0.14520412683486938,
0.883898138999939,
0.4639304578304291,
-0.47893738746643066,
-0.1623331755399704,
-0.17597313225269318,
0.20662997663021088,
0.07979722321033478,
-0.09165508300065994,
0.5780948996543884,
-0.38169920444488525,
-0.8964794278144836,
0.4770723879337311,
0.3688504099845886,
0.33630576729774475,
-0.629048228263855,
0.1511128842830658,
-0.31094032526016235,
0.15022030472755432,
-0.18935537338256836,
-0.5486434698104858,
0.3337796628475189,
0.23443475365638733,
-0.34852394461631775,
0.0021659855265170336,
0.4547679126262665,
-0.9482197761535645,
-0.7198733687400818,
0.41727012395858765,
0.3440869450569153,
0.25927457213401794,
0.1840180605649948,
-0.49091488122940063,
0.11302141100168228,
0.17153728008270264,
-0.022004136815667152,
0.02632169798016548,
0.6563909649848938,
-0.6595091819763184,
0.46205413341522217,
0.48128411173820496,
0.15980547666549683,
0.06886693835258484,
0.0925116315484047,
0.12987975776195526,
-0.7036535739898682,
-0.6038830876350403,
-0.6355955004692078,
0.18067492544651031,
-0.15724791586399078,
-0.26363205909729004,
0.8298645615577698,
0.5364603996276855,
1.0509735345840454,
0.02705463580787182,
1.0682328939437866,
-0.2715202867984772,
0.6999070644378662,
-0.17586219310760498,
0.7478368282318115,
-0.22122210264205933,
0.2304171323776245,
-0.3684949278831482,
-0.9679441452026367,
-0.4449005424976349,
0.6927412748336792,
-0.776634693145752,
0.043013982474803925,
0.5589537620544434,
0.8702496886253357,
0.026526978239417076,
-0.043634455651044846,
0.10973074287176132,
-0.09996526688337326,
0.39733704924583435,
0.17342837154865265,
0.5428791046142578,
-0.40646475553512573,
0.20757423341274261,
-0.6828917264938354,
-0.434702068567276,
-0.00022686412557959557,
-1.026165246963501,
-0.5329587459564209,
-0.643692135810852,
-0.4124545156955719,
-0.20473246276378632,
-0.38296592235565186,
0.5993847846984863,
0.6755167841911316,
-1.0167280435562134,
-0.4254469871520996,
0.4369974136352539,
0.11451993137598038,
-0.18758106231689453,
-0.2566867768764496,
0.2881457805633545,
0.10702242702245712,
-0.8763970136642456,
0.34948644042015076,
0.13816286623477936,
-0.05926410108804703,
-0.3290131390094757,
0.21079391241073608,
-0.3555312156677246,
0.025934606790542603,
0.7270265221595764,
0.3856283724308014,
-0.7084223628044128,
-0.48956629633903503,
0.0325559563934803,
-0.2659907042980194,
-0.09167321026325226,
0.5931446552276611,
-0.5869629383087158,
0.6497822999954224,
0.3987341821193695,
0.3869898319244385,
0.0013750563375651836,
0.37956589460372925,
0.6862363815307617,
-0.7417335510253906,
0.37213853001594543,
-0.2541000247001648,
0.18630629777908325,
0.7092971205711365,
-0.3546370267868042,
0.5351972579956055,
0.016658777371048927,
-0.5095488429069519,
-0.5199874043464661,
0.11527860164642334,
-0.580467939376831,
-0.03108852170407772,
1.3407171964645386,
-0.3567308783531189,
-0.44697803258895874,
-0.3190633952617645,
-0.018722467124462128,
0.07018183916807175,
-0.02829779125750065,
0.7740378975868225,
0.9887638092041016,
0.4919293522834778,
-0.06821241974830627,
-0.8390266299247742,
0.33940449357032776,
-0.14340178668498993,
-0.5794221758842468,
-0.01492257695645094,
0.48834630846977234,
0.6773953437805176,
0.45494017004966736,
0.7111417055130005,
-0.24566034972667694,
-0.09584826231002808,
-0.19691647589206696,
0.16893567144870758,
0.7834065556526184,
-0.5680814981460571,
-0.3997673988342285,
0.14868542551994324,
0.19854162633419037,
0.08488838374614716
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09891v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09891v3
|
Fisher Mask Nodes for Language Model Merging
| 2024-03-14T21:52:26 | 2024-05-03T13:12:40 |
Thennal D K, Ganesh Nathan, Suchithra M S
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Fine-tuning pre-trained models provides significant advantages in downstream
performance. The ubiquitous nature of pre-trained models such as BERT and its
derivatives in natural language processing has also led to a proliferation of
task-specific fine-tuned models. As these models typically only perform one
task well, additional training or ensembling is required in multi-task
scenarios. The growing field of model merging provides a solution, dealing with
the challenge of combining multiple task-specific models into a single
multi-task model. In this study, we introduce a novel model merging method for
Transformers, combining insights from previous work in Fisher-weighted
averaging and the use of Fisher information in model pruning. Utilizing the
Fisher information of mask nodes within the Transformer architecture, we devise
a computationally efficient weighted-averaging scheme. Our method exhibits a
regular and significant performance increase across various models in the BERT
family, outperforming full-scale Fisher-weighted averaging in a fraction of the
computational cost, with baseline performance improvements of up to +6.5 and a
speedup between 57.4x and 321.7x across models. Our results prove the potential
of our method in current multi-task learning environments and suggest its
scalability and adaptability to new model architectures and learning scenarios.
|
[
-0.6195226907730103,
-0.37068596482276917,
0.09510235488414764,
0.07539761811494827,
-0.4025530517101288,
0.21745911240577698,
-0.38688895106315613,
-0.5886172652244568,
0.06799229234457016,
0.4055790901184082,
-0.5645442008972168,
-0.1980847269296646,
-0.8727317452430725,
-0.1746087372303009,
-0.47127798199653625,
0.7712972164154053,
0.12109678983688354,
-0.081634521484375,
0.08600624650716782,
-0.06698759645223618,
-0.5561782717704773,
-0.25137823820114136,
-0.7061414122581482,
-0.24315263330936432,
0.5065330266952515,
0.20777615904808044,
0.7607879042625427,
0.6361003518104553,
0.7589433193206787,
0.44225698709487915,
0.1720389574766159,
0.4995304048061371,
-0.3039391338825226,
0.1980508416891098,
-0.21167223155498505,
-0.21776250004768372,
-0.7302831411361694,
0.28121083974838257,
0.8851401209831238,
0.7632086873054504,
-0.08813100308179855,
0.3765917122364044,
0.39116355776786804,
0.451768696308136,
-0.7151163220405579,
0.1786060780286789,
-0.7638517618179321,
0.22333765029907227,
-0.11933282017707825,
-0.222052201628685,
-0.4984738230705261,
-0.10107877105474472,
0.07976716011762619,
-0.5745880007743835,
0.37243688106536865,
-0.11698883771896362,
0.825825572013855,
0.3143291175365448,
-0.3425496518611908,
0.2725178897380829,
-0.9119871258735657,
1.222817063331604,
-0.8152440786361694,
0.5868158340454102,
-0.016959568485617638,
0.3511524796485901,
0.22304636240005493,
-0.6204381585121155,
-0.8126428127288818,
0.28784066438674927,
-0.4223689138889313,
-0.003990932367742062,
-0.6197951436042786,
0.08857520669698715,
0.03760555014014244,
0.08994203805923462,
-0.4559199810028076,
-0.0017562555149197578,
-0.7266011238098145,
-0.15792341530323029,
0.5753350257873535,
-0.02306474931538105,
-0.010437135584652424,
0.03908412903547287,
-0.5498664379119873,
-0.5553582906723022,
-0.26124653220176697,
0.028827538713812828,
0.44011741876602173,
0.7984209060668945,
0.08989221602678299,
0.5139906406402588,
-0.041344355791807175,
0.8895760178565979,
0.007907325401902199,
-0.18605086207389832,
0.3057129681110382,
-0.32280203700065613,
-0.3600753843784332,
-0.09236270934343338,
0.7400960326194763,
0.44520533084869385,
0.3873237073421478,
-0.10115362703800201,
-0.29702264070510864,
0.12385623157024384,
0.5832312703132629,
-0.6060613393783569,
-0.380776047706604,
0.08747823536396027,
-0.45025691390037537,
-0.278167724609375,
-0.07812211662530899,
-0.5153704285621643,
-0.04778392240405083,
-0.6197229623794556,
0.6066897511482239,
-0.25297775864601135,
-0.6235591769218445,
0.0955987423658371,
-0.1531365066766739,
0.2216184288263321,
0.2369258850812912,
-0.5635693073272705,
0.27367159724235535,
0.9092733263969421,
0.6375330686569214,
-0.3659690320491791,
-0.4503052234649658,
-0.6984620690345764,
-0.018228493630886078,
-0.34060782194137573,
0.67519611120224,
-0.47757285833358765,
-0.18248887360095978,
-0.05543583258986473,
-0.04108427092432976,
-0.563980221748352,
-0.643178403377533,
0.4441184997558594,
-0.62918621301651,
0.20978029072284698,
0.19625915586948395,
-0.29723578691482544,
-0.2933652997016907,
0.18671497702598572,
-0.765017569065094,
1.3310744762420654,
0.41462939977645874,
-0.5808320641517639,
0.2678830027580261,
-0.5363956689834595,
-0.564712405204773,
0.03738866001367569,
0.20118290185928345,
-0.4969361126422882,
0.10898987948894501,
0.20373572409152985,
0.8947407007217407,
-0.4155256152153015,
0.319114089012146,
-0.11576119065284729,
-0.3378514349460602,
0.04477429389953613,
-0.2335660457611084,
0.723239004611969,
0.29563605785369873,
-0.08735227584838867,
0.36137035489082336,
-0.5688353180885315,
0.0728829875588417,
-0.13676655292510986,
-0.14220310747623444,
-0.22534015774726868,
-0.23869995772838593,
0.15859071910381317,
0.3667498826980591,
0.11598779261112213,
-0.3448517918586731,
0.13134512305259705,
-0.12853698432445526,
0.3404412865638733,
0.593115508556366,
-0.23624376952648163,
0.8720484375953674,
-0.6839486360549927,
0.5264880061149597,
0.25569525361061096,
0.23533891141414642,
-0.25488168001174927,
-0.6846824884414673,
-0.7881606817245483,
-0.5891370177268982,
0.45357048511505127,
0.40326637029647827,
-0.6814066767692566,
0.3946293592453003,
-0.4771435260772705,
-0.7372721433639526,
-0.7659512758255005,
0.290530264377594,
0.3800596594810486,
0.7620088458061218,
0.7227339148521423,
-0.5641719102859497,
-0.6481519341468811,
-0.9065725803375244,
-0.3891472816467285,
0.04427848383784294,
-0.5243733525276184,
0.050803929567337036,
0.025765713304281235,
-0.10701137781143188,
1.1766917705535889,
-0.43846598267555237,
-0.51002037525177,
-0.18782523274421692,
0.2374931424856186,
0.4669433534145355,
0.8586254119873047,
0.4556771516799927,
-0.8089304566383362,
-0.7038025856018066,
-0.008672946132719517,
-0.3117186725139618,
0.11797468364238739,
-0.08758815377950668,
-0.2541896104812622,
-0.0921519473195076,
0.3855656683444977,
-0.8897767663002014,
0.15974538028240204,
0.6810805797576904,
0.08515072613954544,
0.34463271498680115,
0.13877733051776886,
0.06732673197984695,
-1.119173526763916,
-0.05197262018918991,
0.09922923892736435,
-0.31608328223228455,
-0.9363318085670471,
0.0983678549528122,
0.2169419825077057,
-0.080024354159832,
-0.5268992185592651,
0.47755947709083557,
-0.32060864567756653,
0.18199722468852997,
-0.2136630117893219,
0.03330526500940323,
-0.053667277097702026,
0.8019020557403564,
-0.23492257297039032,
0.472223162651062,
0.7978184819221497,
-0.8081693053245544,
0.1999465972185135,
0.04945291206240654,
-0.15041998028755188,
0.48857036232948303,
-0.3660238981246948,
0.02004387229681015,
-0.19311928749084473,
0.11632826179265976,
-1.0954500436782837,
0.11219223588705063,
0.25899478793144226,
-0.4049500823020935,
0.5485678315162659,
-0.2364380657672882,
-0.1391025334596634,
-0.23598219454288483,
-0.47653424739837646,
0.5847892165184021,
0.558268129825592,
-0.5128989815711975,
1.44579017162323,
0.32932594418525696,
-0.30382341146469116,
-0.7869433164596558,
-0.5115600824356079,
-0.17735788226127625,
-0.2536334693431854,
-0.7272930145263672,
0.9259105920791626,
-0.0701628252863884,
0.1149175688624382,
0.18162734806537628,
-0.14011946320533752,
-0.29776379466056824,
-0.10341032594442368,
0.004795074462890625,
0.5177416205406189,
-0.4300289750099182,
0.12795746326446533,
0.18908651173114777,
-0.12274814397096634,
-0.33467191457748413,
-0.2944142818450928,
0.5291510224342346,
0.24285900592803955,
-0.18272802233695984,
-0.48667994141578674,
0.32614684104919434,
0.6263946294784546,
-0.4948870539665222,
0.9369586706161499,
0.8759552240371704,
-0.5038067102432251,
-0.34273236989974976,
-0.7784655094146729,
-0.2750476002693176,
-0.51270991563797,
0.2834119498729706,
-0.2583829462528229,
-0.9612184166908264,
0.586172878742218,
-0.12371695041656494,
0.4207324981689453,
0.6644006371498108,
0.2114487886428833,
-0.12305406481027603,
0.9509009122848511,
0.7787078619003296,
-0.13888798654079437,
0.6812986731529236,
-0.2510995864868164,
0.6169558167457581,
-0.8822249174118042,
-0.014086460694670677,
-0.406878262758255,
-0.6795366406440735,
-0.4578193724155426,
-0.8137117028236389,
0.1832205057144165,
0.2548713684082031,
-0.16997130215168,
0.702728807926178,
-0.7517616748809814,
0.42689093947410583,
0.6227436065673828,
-0.011451004073023796,
0.3762189745903015,
0.16203097999095917,
-0.012480217032134533,
0.14418944716453552,
-0.8625733852386475,
-0.16091714799404144,
1.0137418508529663,
0.30866101384162903,
0.31476572155952454,
0.0700460746884346,
0.5341446995735168,
0.03326671943068504,
0.5372884273529053,
-0.7419916391372681,
0.5686020255088806,
-0.3794671595096588,
-0.3903016746044159,
-0.5650152564048767,
-0.4800419509410858,
-0.8958578705787659,
0.7021847367286682,
-0.5382663011550903,
-0.5303467512130737,
0.3723335564136505,
0.2983224391937256,
-0.5310992002487183,
0.27313876152038574,
-0.8130189180374146,
0.6404398679733276,
0.31478238105773926,
-0.018137531355023384,
-0.26567962765693665,
-0.5256715416908264,
0.6294497847557068,
-0.4262688457965851,
0.19570741057395935,
-0.33722513914108276,
0.2608374357223511,
0.7332241535186768,
-0.10938334465026855,
0.7273268699645996,
-0.10816720128059387,
-0.06151686608791351,
0.2470104992389679,
0.032185789197683334,
0.44884607195854187,
-0.360455185174942,
0.07277017831802368,
0.4153708517551422,
-0.06587964296340942,
-0.19610801339149475,
-0.5445725917816162,
0.3837571442127228,
-0.5137969851493835,
-0.3638649880886078,
-0.05897898972034454,
-0.7049733996391296,
-0.3341110348701477,
0.10349646210670471,
-0.03607974946498871,
0.36535224318504333,
0.38535499572753906,
0.2215697169303894,
0.37297847867012024,
0.07241911441087723,
0.6233190894126892,
0.5370151996612549,
0.01793772168457508,
-0.25877103209495544,
0.8009814620018005,
0.11739949136972427,
0.13642294704914093,
0.4861576557159424,
0.09557007998228073,
-0.057868264615535736,
-0.31666094064712524,
-0.04125882312655449,
0.11464804410934448,
-0.48363056778907776,
-0.8677695393562317,
-0.6355255842208862,
-0.5418521761894226,
-0.5249148011207581,
-0.02426338940858841,
-0.5141194462776184,
-0.5665408372879028,
0.07439684122800827,
0.19229131937026978,
0.1632661372423172,
0.45407605171203613,
0.024450471624732018,
0.8259841203689575,
-1.219936490058899,
0.28433138132095337,
0.587267279624939,
0.4969361126422882,
0.2946385443210602,
-0.43432554602622986,
-0.2731283903121948,
-0.026894068345427513,
-0.3325546979904175,
-0.7032749056816101,
0.35882920026779175,
0.3722538352012634,
0.5528044700622559,
0.2827305197715759,
0.17304694652557373,
0.82757568359375,
-0.5477607250213623,
0.41565361618995667,
0.36240333318710327,
-1.0220017433166504,
-0.03863392025232315,
-0.17386874556541443,
0.3293505609035492,
0.2474432736635208,
0.3694670498371124,
-0.5226557850837708,
-0.4348200261592865,
-0.45082053542137146,
-0.9770344495773315,
0.9111809730529785,
0.26045188307762146,
0.13107830286026,
0.1694236695766449,
0.003958573564887047,
-0.27591031789779663,
0.21224719285964966,
-0.4907088279724121,
-0.16460801661014557,
0.05897526815533638,
-0.5120804905891418,
-0.23762686550617218,
-0.03592262044548988,
-0.3364030420780182,
-0.6302141547203064,
0.6508876085281372,
-0.13332927227020264,
0.28457072377204895,
-0.21611528098583221,
-0.34448298811912537,
-0.19461771845817566,
0.01507322397083044,
0.4961482584476471,
0.5958964228630066,
-0.10631878674030304,
0.2667282223701477,
0.25730812549591064,
-0.5272111296653748,
-0.31899482011795044,
0.38420408964157104,
0.350162148475647,
0.1428438276052475,
0.509774386882782,
0.6262966990470886,
0.6084645390510559,
-0.49571919441223145,
0.4665208160877228,
-0.14636291563510895,
-0.28663384914398193,
0.12200624495744705,
0.22340993583202362,
0.08585276454687119,
0.5592708587646484,
0.7448813319206238,
0.584190309047699,
-0.19120316207408905,
-0.15698456764221191,
0.24451355636119843,
0.5632925033569336,
-0.06370366364717484,
-0.23551110923290253,
0.34603625535964966,
0.11816474050283432,
-0.31501829624176025,
0.6858890652656555,
-0.048115815967321396,
-0.7061440348625183,
0.4463568925857544,
0.2526794970035553,
0.8785185217857361,
-0.7329832911491394,
-0.02740979939699173,
0.5082369446754456,
0.48636361956596375,
-0.10305845737457275,
-0.004392907954752445,
-0.31706178188323975,
-1.1131174564361572,
-0.8054907917976379,
-0.8521756529808044,
-0.1856110394001007,
-0.14948491752147675,
-0.5859280824661255,
0.28024646639823914,
-0.07200171053409576,
-0.4155428409576416,
0.2252151519060135,
-0.1645105481147766,
-0.8941571116447449,
0.13952212035655975,
-0.06764808297157288,
0.6840362548828125,
-0.9006152749061584,
0.9832115769386292,
0.47596436738967896,
0.1799827218055725,
-1.041911005973816,
-0.32153812050819397,
-0.4556407034397125,
-0.5039056539535522,
0.44539809226989746,
0.18267300724983215,
-0.1779746562242508,
0.0847148448228836,
-0.07888805121183395,
-0.9847893118858337,
0.9978327751159668,
0.5794371962547302,
-0.5926870107650757,
-0.05725574865937233,
0.18209755420684814,
0.2029644399881363,
-0.5709249377250671,
0.18137647211551666,
0.6806426644325256,
0.398539662361145,
0.26871269941329956,
-1.2151659727096558,
-0.0033414140343666077,
-0.28493428230285645,
-0.014853695407509804,
0.5547037720680237,
-0.17579349875450134,
1.1543667316436768,
0.17132960259914398,
-0.45832547545433044,
-0.3571585714817047,
0.5783296823501587,
0.06443675607442856,
0.08081748336553574,
0.9460084438323975,
0.3550156354904175,
0.8282418251037598,
-0.1411624699831009,
0.49356552958488464,
-0.7962211966514587,
0.6649524569511414,
1.0981968641281128,
-0.17268869280815125,
0.9537658095359802,
0.4338383376598358,
-0.2876166105270386,
0.19216479361057281,
0.2666768729686737,
0.01608061045408249,
0.3606007397174835,
-0.12490144371986389,
-0.18347905576229095,
-0.37463563680648804,
-0.00927193183451891,
-0.3298831582069397,
0.6059362888336182,
0.09354878216981888,
-0.2853645086288452,
-0.28702467679977417,
0.07209572196006775,
-0.25521281361579895,
-0.10597946494817734,
-0.23058505356311798,
0.5850836634635925,
-0.1436431109905243,
-0.7165787816047668,
0.4028579890727997,
0.2796851098537445,
1.0095202922821045,
-0.6573631763458252,
-0.16556809842586517,
0.15816199779510498,
0.22997386753559113,
-0.19678157567977905,
-0.3765954375267029,
0.5284174680709839,
-0.25709637999534607,
-0.22399333119392395,
-0.6335080862045288,
0.8258431553840637,
-0.777739405632019,
-0.5935661792755127,
0.32627272605895996,
0.368818461894989,
-0.2174207866191864,
-0.27380141615867615,
-0.46423017978668213,
0.18941542506217957,
-0.2217859923839569,
-0.03324822336435318,
0.2434842437505722,
-0.05581548437476158,
0.04655139148235321,
0.40890365839004517,
0.7798473238945007,
-0.13410203158855438,
0.43568792939186096,
-0.12378963828086853,
1.011887788772583,
-0.3133237063884735,
-0.3884136378765106,
-0.7371484041213989,
0.7756383419036865,
-0.08154672384262085,
-0.17919187247753143,
0.5570600628852844,
0.5448252558708191,
1.0935957431793213,
-0.11619327962398529,
0.33079490065574646,
0.18768972158432007,
0.6827830076217651,
-0.30085426568984985,
0.8412621021270752,
-0.4415179491043091,
0.06967966258525848,
-0.14580138027668,
-1.3628337383270264,
-0.2918202579021454,
0.6661238074302673,
0.12045387923717499,
0.20128008723258972,
0.5353530049324036,
0.7593987584114075,
-0.39289799332618713,
-0.11435685306787491,
0.3263477087020874,
0.024769915267825127,
0.08229531347751617,
0.355420857667923,
0.4043937623500824,
-0.517530620098114,
0.34551119804382324,
-0.508137583732605,
-0.11712954938411713,
0.013244465924799442,
-0.9368085265159607,
-0.7388708591461182,
-0.7268841862678528,
-0.3923960030078888,
-0.05602440610527992,
-0.37281307578086853,
0.9185460805892944,
1.0644497871398926,
-0.7374261617660522,
-0.1688995659351349,
0.2686471939086914,
0.1348721981048584,
-0.5916093587875366,
-0.23682767152786255,
0.34894460439682007,
-0.505588173866272,
-1.008467674255371,
0.44152307510375977,
0.19493402540683746,
-0.1997937262058258,
-0.18176232278347015,
-0.02665984258055687,
-0.20052583515644073,
0.296642929315567,
0.6646115183830261,
-0.06448331475257874,
-0.3895454406738281,
0.07593348622322083,
-0.1349496990442276,
0.10812586545944214,
0.061636362224817276,
1.0423541069030762,
-0.9903656840324402,
0.5454627275466919,
0.41425707936286926,
0.692634105682373,
0.44512906670570374,
-0.06101693958044052,
0.6743744611740112,
-1.1967968940734863,
0.16486863791942596,
0.30993130803108215,
0.2709892988204956,
0.3754241168498993,
-0.2621070146560669,
0.37185797095298767,
-0.013306331820786,
-0.0300713162869215,
-1.1668589115142822,
0.0751807764172554,
-1.0012611150741577,
-0.15754881501197815,
0.5087798237800598,
0.046559881418943405,
0.0033408908639103174,
0.0647532045841217,
0.20526345074176788,
0.6569094061851501,
-0.0834304466843605,
0.42274996638298035,
0.5046124458312988,
0.051579974591732025,
-0.24457795917987823,
-0.49025553464889526,
0.4110057055950165,
0.4255315065383911,
-0.4426285922527313,
-0.1509568989276886,
-0.2349635511636734,
0.15053893625736237,
0.4807446002960205,
0.27849000692367554,
0.14860540628433228,
0.19750440120697021,
-0.30721989274024963,
0.18115057051181793,
-0.1697995811700821,
-0.5074069499969482,
-0.4424818456172943,
0.33844196796417236,
-0.32900270819664,
-0.3017699420452118
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09887v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09887v2
|
Sabiá-2: A New Generation of Portuguese Large Language Models
| 2024-03-14T21:44:48 | 2024-03-26T23:52:35 |
Thales Sales Almeida, Hugo Abonizio, Rodrigo Nogueira, Ramon Pires
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We introduce Sabi\'a-2, a family of large language models trained on
Portuguese texts. The models are evaluated on a diverse range of exams,
including entry-level tests for Brazilian universities, professional
certification exams, and graduate-level exams for various disciplines such as
accounting, economics, engineering, law and medicine. Our results reveal that
our best model so far, Sabi\'a-2 Medium, matches or surpasses GPT-4's
performance in 23 out of 64 exams and outperforms GPT-3.5 in 58 out of 64
exams. Notably, specialization has a significant impact on a model's
performance without the need to increase its size, allowing us to offer
Sabi\'a-2 Medium at a price per token that is 10 times cheaper than GPT-4.
Finally, we identified that math and coding are key abilities that need
improvement.
|
[
-0.38739389181137085,
-0.6907191276550293,
0.22790835797786713,
0.4143386781215668,
-0.36165645718574524,
0.02070704475045204,
-0.2376917004585266,
-0.719486653804779,
0.21362638473510742,
0.677266001701355,
-0.03890170156955719,
-0.14553971588611603,
-0.9909177422523499,
-0.07407299429178238,
-0.6645745635032654,
1.0618622303009033,
0.10052941739559174,
0.36419880390167236,
0.06569088250398636,
-0.1788146197795868,
-0.21279001235961914,
-0.3757762312889099,
-0.9097968339920044,
-0.2682778239250183,
0.3507536053657532,
0.27548912167549133,
0.8208706378936768,
0.620096743106842,
0.5694112777709961,
0.179002046585083,
-0.004091338720172644,
-0.06111808121204376,
-0.2904394567012787,
-0.04386860132217407,
-0.2371751070022583,
-0.5846191644668579,
-0.44256648421287537,
0.07708963751792908,
0.686612606048584,
0.4275009334087372,
-0.2586503326892853,
0.22127263247966766,
-0.11876390874385834,
0.5877663493156433,
-0.25431686639785767,
0.49999621510505676,
-0.5019773840904236,
-0.5022261142730713,
-0.2418571412563324,
0.04710395261645317,
-0.5756147503852844,
-0.5032492876052856,
0.1595800668001175,
-0.26108407974243164,
0.11989982426166534,
-0.28657492995262146,
1.3757108449935913,
0.34516382217407227,
-0.8654946088790894,
-0.7479681968688965,
-0.48554909229278564,
0.6315897107124329,
-0.3728368580341339,
0.6448639631271362,
0.24672015011310577,
0.5733233690261841,
0.0675288513302803,
-0.5653741359710693,
-0.10699152946472168,
-0.4186910092830658,
0.200714111328125,
0.10336237400770187,
-0.33021506667137146,
-0.04971254616975784,
0.02946278639137745,
0.026705943048000336,
-0.5853700637817383,
0.29795515537261963,
-1.0565235614776611,
-0.12173304706811905,
0.7997063994407654,
-0.194756418466568,
0.061442792415618896,
0.24942344427108765,
-0.39262136816978455,
0.13610336184501648,
-1.0959864854812622,
-0.4828526973724365,
0.512141764163971,
0.011705695651471615,
-0.07612743228673935,
0.3548622727394104,
0.17703887820243835,
0.7881065011024475,
-0.36578452587127686,
-0.4762944281101227,
0.27704086899757385,
-0.089728944003582,
-0.003452911041676998,
-0.16674336791038513,
0.4853564202785492,
0.08215523511171341,
0.3478096127510071,
-0.12333647906780243,
-0.3284432590007782,
0.433847039937973,
0.0757637470960617,
-0.9877959489822388,
-0.26844990253448486,
-0.03714773431420326,
-0.3688764274120331,
-0.30858367681503296,
-0.153570294380188,
-0.7730581164360046,
-0.40565866231918335,
-0.29354822635650635,
0.4512059986591339,
-0.2699057161808014,
-0.36142221093177795,
0.19760210812091827,
0.02934393659234047,
0.5793280005455017,
0.45402929186820984,
-0.9000993967056274,
0.38403427600860596,
0.6507480144500732,
0.7405697703361511,
-0.10614414513111115,
-0.2585481107234955,
-0.35761556029319763,
0.139317587018013,
-0.7848514318466187,
1.001726746559143,
-0.7314329147338867,
-0.5741369724273682,
0.006169942207634449,
-0.43715858459472656,
0.24583622813224792,
-0.3807089030742645,
0.5294274091720581,
-0.6086326241493225,
0.05413464829325676,
-0.6000066995620728,
-0.19511942565441132,
-0.3371136784553528,
0.21879421174526215,
-0.4873217046260834,
1.34308660030365,
0.6178709268569946,
-0.3368622958660126,
0.37204352021217346,
-0.8951807618141174,
-0.428891122341156,
0.20754331350326538,
-0.4220752716064453,
-0.061157211661338806,
-0.06100987270474434,
-0.09253616631031036,
0.09819632023572922,
-1.21763277053833,
0.3255021274089813,
-0.05426958575844765,
-0.6552634835243225,
0.05194494500756264,
-0.3518773019313812,
0.633172869682312,
0.47759565711021423,
-0.300948828458786,
-0.13358758389949799,
-0.8109146356582642,
-0.14984744787216187,
0.19568613171577454,
-0.2509411871433258,
-0.03564988449215889,
-0.23095743358135223,
0.11762915551662445,
0.4784480333328247,
0.2746080756187439,
-0.5801036357879639,
0.5755446553230286,
-0.5274573564529419,
0.8769169449806213,
0.5685288310050964,
0.04269852116703987,
0.5475130081176758,
0.19468998908996582,
0.8219934701919556,
-0.04153190925717354,
0.13411985337734222,
-0.014329244382679462,
-0.7149434089660645,
-1.0873420238494873,
-0.3125361502170563,
0.6913329362869263,
0.6306986808776855,
-0.7182071208953857,
0.10512425750494003,
-0.08991953730583191,
-1.1506361961364746,
-0.5618245601654053,
0.20455202460289001,
0.4681747257709503,
0.14227008819580078,
0.2015271931886673,
-0.3570101857185364,
-0.2874848544597626,
-1.2243648767471313,
-0.21454595029354095,
-0.11620662361383438,
0.13825497031211853,
0.361162394285202,
0.7576160430908203,
-0.5868323445320129,
0.7459763288497925,
-0.6574487686157227,
-0.30707627534866333,
-0.3488485515117645,
0.22206313908100128,
0.04539176821708679,
0.3337917625904083,
1.3654731512069702,
-0.8308096528053284,
-0.40726256370544434,
-0.05804385989904404,
-0.47116225957870483,
-0.33864226937294006,
0.0917927548289299,
-0.04517575725913048,
0.4358726143836975,
0.3655380308628082,
-0.27597498893737793,
0.2934802770614624,
0.6826421022415161,
-0.46934911608695984,
0.4109213352203369,
-0.3097919821739197,
-0.053993090987205505,
-0.9350352883338928,
-0.23506894707679749,
0.23901204764842987,
0.301139235496521,
-0.4024272859096527,
0.286143958568573,
0.10780850052833557,
-0.2966129183769226,
-0.16809481382369995,
0.734893798828125,
-0.601513683795929,
-0.6919301748275757,
-0.34758520126342773,
0.09650608152151108,
-0.03094003163278103,
0.1441079080104828,
-0.09282898157835007,
1.2183629274368286,
0.7993167042732239,
-0.4285264015197754,
0.4056527614593506,
0.2208508402109146,
-0.535351037979126,
0.24922500550746918,
-0.8328292965888977,
0.12366954237222672,
-0.21135418117046356,
0.48012205958366394,
-1.0160542726516724,
-0.33787375688552856,
-0.08452894538640976,
-0.3697105050086975,
0.33308854699134827,
-0.36488568782806396,
-0.6210097670555115,
-0.46461597084999084,
0.25026190280914307,
0.1549888551235199,
0.5828914046287537,
-0.44881999492645264,
0.8586642742156982,
0.35716959834098816,
-0.4512483477592468,
-0.6894346475601196,
-1.062680959701538,
0.2167244553565979,
-0.016642067581415176,
-0.58429354429245,
-0.12024521082639694,
0.1813306212425232,
0.0027327388525009155,
-0.17659157514572144,
0.13527625799179077,
-0.3707205355167389,
0.2288961410522461,
0.1699109673500061,
0.3965337574481964,
-0.422633558511734,
0.11112789064645767,
0.4355587363243103,
-0.35410016775131226,
0.07588431239128113,
-0.039659492671489716,
0.8558370471000671,
-0.5689087510108948,
-0.14920297265052795,
-0.1759282946586609,
0.29158031940460205,
0.6584091782569885,
-0.9682504534721375,
0.761207103729248,
0.6721945405006409,
-0.45285406708717346,
0.14614780247211456,
-0.8758569955825806,
-0.020702406764030457,
-0.5145728588104248,
0.7266826033592224,
-0.6542848944664001,
-0.8409120440483093,
0.4674787223339081,
0.016207454726099968,
0.11768992990255356,
0.4354991316795349,
0.835896372795105,
0.5119994282722473,
1.0328965187072754,
0.4876015782356262,
-0.0415322370827198,
0.45450878143310547,
-0.4045119881629944,
0.3971344828605652,
-0.33815300464630127,
-0.2678104341030121,
-0.6904110312461853,
-0.06716660410165787,
-0.6074525117874146,
-0.3758057951927185,
0.5640884637832642,
0.08815231174230576,
-0.42591795325279236,
0.480228990316391,
-0.3371386229991913,
0.709922194480896,
0.6768518090248108,
-0.15272289514541626,
0.035251129418611526,
-0.07893197238445282,
0.2825964093208313,
0.09431317448616028,
-0.638645589351654,
-0.6641654968261719,
1.3590482473373413,
0.532474160194397,
0.541623055934906,
0.39484351873397827,
0.6716206669807434,
0.017656389623880386,
0.8226467370986938,
-0.7657947540283203,
0.4360883831977844,
-0.12870760262012482,
-1.027215838432312,
-0.11511651426553726,
-0.27370378375053406,
-0.6749960780143738,
0.2894480526447296,
-0.32495495676994324,
-0.6154676675796509,
0.06318792700767517,
0.05332832783460617,
-0.17108352482318878,
-0.006789942272007465,
-0.9106380939483643,
0.7368994355201721,
-0.41253405809402466,
-0.43213409185409546,
-0.32793989777565,
-0.6992067694664001,
0.4423331618309021,
-0.2120639532804489,
0.3104744255542755,
-0.006860330700874329,
-0.4290076494216919,
0.8184669613838196,
0.14839118719100952,
0.376351922750473,
-0.24678094685077667,
-0.2611769139766693,
0.6255461573600769,
0.4439927935600281,
0.37681928277015686,
0.2616974413394928,
-0.44662150740623474,
0.15161976218223572,
0.18287397921085358,
-0.8306891918182373,
-0.6803894639015198,
0.7504907846450806,
-1.0190049409866333,
-0.3856793940067291,
-0.7923585772514343,
-0.4718177020549774,
-0.3515310287475586,
0.2820589542388916,
0.4054068624973297,
0.6407656073570251,
-0.2217293530702591,
0.2736932337284088,
0.338727205991745,
-0.22444145381450653,
0.0625699907541275,
0.680426299571991,
-0.11572806537151337,
-0.440646231174469,
0.9710605144500732,
0.4055527448654175,
0.34304603934288025,
-0.09140665084123611,
0.09081799536943436,
-0.4358965754508972,
-0.5806931853294373,
-0.7486791610717773,
0.5821635723114014,
-0.8288707137107849,
-0.18012069165706635,
-0.6018414497375488,
-0.1466374546289444,
-0.689123272895813,
-0.36335375905036926,
-0.572003185749054,
-0.1718229204416275,
-0.004517397377640009,
-0.19758780300617218,
0.182858407497406,
1.0642249584197998,
-0.012833443470299244,
0.5544672012329102,
-0.812688946723938,
-0.15796194970607758,
0.04131928086280823,
0.2308676838874817,
-0.26041892170906067,
-0.6471598148345947,
0.031461067497730255,
-0.11464782059192657,
-0.35650840401649475,
-1.0441006422042847,
0.16558390855789185,
0.12019786238670349,
0.32835134863853455,
0.8475465178489685,
-0.49277108907699585,
0.20770256221294403,
-0.32067444920539856,
0.962830662727356,
0.22658070921897888,
-1.012342095375061,
0.36186155676841736,
-0.6088750958442688,
-0.34084171056747437,
0.586398720741272,
0.44988709688186646,
-0.36467981338500977,
0.20822490751743317,
-0.6390835642814636,
-0.614680290222168,
0.469678670167923,
0.09421636909246445,
0.2499505877494812,
-0.09511083364486694,
0.809779942035675,
0.08137060701847076,
0.37402012944221497,
-0.7027552127838135,
-0.20468826591968536,
-0.0715753510594368,
0.08136492222547531,
-0.2788834571838379,
-0.676268458366394,
-0.07719430327415466,
-0.15122704207897186,
0.8336519598960876,
-0.008788242004811764,
0.4153989553451538,
-0.44007235765457153,
0.16672763228416443,
0.15988345444202423,
0.3181329667568207,
0.6787055730819702,
0.9530799984931946,
0.14910462498664856,
-0.2543313205242157,
0.3034883737564087,
-0.4344499707221985,
0.2074975222349167,
0.133427694439888,
-0.25677981972694397,
-0.16253721714019775,
0.23796284198760986,
0.7456783652305603,
0.24019895493984222,
-0.7034765481948853,
0.74493008852005,
0.4845368564128876,
-0.40908440947532654,
-0.3417041003704071,
0.16053612530231476,
0.11828054487705231,
0.2307891994714737,
0.17093268036842346,
-0.017944354563951492,
0.40345412492752075,
-0.8843613266944885,
-0.043867163360118866,
0.07318797707557678,
-0.28128212690353394,
-0.0911814346909523,
0.6438130140304565,
0.5407984256744385,
-0.23221565783023834,
0.46201497316360474,
-0.46993526816368103,
-0.8094926476478577,
0.7455187439918518,
0.79388028383255,
0.20803029835224152,
-0.4796581268310547,
0.32210880517959595,
0.43128615617752075,
0.5995171070098877,
-0.5124260187149048,
0.5753124952316284,
0.30811628699302673,
-0.5382781028747559,
-0.10925844311714172,
-0.6337101459503174,
-0.6783171892166138,
-0.1094781756401062,
-0.9062689542770386,
0.6035958528518677,
-0.4214276671409607,
0.03254041075706482,
-0.19840125739574432,
0.2398165911436081,
-0.603961169719696,
0.6980301737785339,
-0.11645805090665817,
1.2113991975784302,
-1.1603790521621704,
0.9693823456764221,
0.6915741562843323,
-0.7707845568656921,
-0.736416757106781,
-0.3895983397960663,
-0.12467751652002335,
-0.8087490200996399,
0.3993016481399536,
0.1242407038807869,
-0.013912871479988098,
-0.01342629175633192,
-0.5044612288475037,
-1.357080101966858,
1.121759057044983,
0.6258025169372559,
-0.5981304049491882,
-0.4273669719696045,
-0.13112545013427734,
0.6530702114105225,
-0.3556431829929352,
0.3897172510623932,
1.0464547872543335,
0.5223006010055542,
0.1215924322605133,
-0.8152437210083008,
-0.36526432633399963,
-0.30679240822792053,
-0.08487708121538162,
0.5627257227897644,
-1.3726609945297241,
0.8856048583984375,
-0.332504540681839,
0.2621590197086334,
0.38161250948905945,
0.8569992184638977,
0.3396773338317871,
0.24642802774906158,
0.4441875219345093,
0.1385105699300766,
0.6743567585945129,
-0.4972415566444397,
0.972358226776123,
-0.5938825011253357,
0.327208548784256,
0.9409508109092712,
-0.42635974287986755,
0.883029580116272,
0.17994193732738495,
-0.12771497666835785,
0.6181696653366089,
0.6580959558486938,
-0.3747471272945404,
0.24831165373325348,
0.20603273808956146,
-0.0661776214838028,
-0.4452705681324005,
-0.030650990083813667,
-0.8278679847717285,
0.9623993635177612,
0.7168710827827454,
-0.32434818148612976,
-0.059365902096033096,
0.06101328507065773,
0.2998442053794861,
0.03958990424871445,
-0.13081960380077362,
0.1640920639038086,
0.012235728092491627,
-0.7131767868995667,
0.1946626454591751,
0.5271462202072144,
0.4806225299835205,
-0.8937386870384216,
0.13840077817440033,
-0.11660721898078918,
0.23850619792938232,
0.01247057318687439,
-0.5845867991447449,
0.15660013258457184,
0.06264693289995193,
0.39053046703338623,
0.05156746506690979,
0.5885100364685059,
-0.35180914402008057,
-0.6937649250030518,
0.4088847041130066,
0.3084377646446228,
0.5002436637878418,
0.03863213211297989,
-0.7271053791046143,
0.25041094422340393,
-0.21892701089382172,
-0.3561975955963135,
0.25886714458465576,
0.15794534981250763,
-0.14186887443065643,
0.7100913524627686,
0.3636390268802643,
0.04930314049124718,
-0.21372421085834503,
-0.011875846423208714,
0.8920571208000183,
-0.3916529715061188,
-0.8062541484832764,
-0.33577704429626465,
-0.17062848806381226,
-0.03424513339996338,
-0.8815015554428101,
0.3796808421611786,
0.9896875619888306,
0.6323708295822144,
0.12252510339021683,
0.9471893310546875,
0.13735860586166382,
0.4351648986339569,
-0.3026832044124603,
0.8211274147033691,
-0.6657463908195496,
0.08322034031152725,
-0.16964900493621826,
-1.2397454977035522,
-0.13108356297016144,
0.8097641468048096,
-0.4990082085132599,
0.38706618547439575,
0.4972682595252991,
0.821468710899353,
0.1396041363477707,
0.18496468663215637,
0.12207042425870895,
0.4157780706882477,
0.3905784487724304,
0.7869988679885864,
0.3911595642566681,
-0.7047754526138306,
0.7750924229621887,
0.06609626859426498,
-0.5807350277900696,
-0.30295225977897644,
-0.5711060762405396,
-0.9965642690658569,
-0.49720078706741333,
-0.13708634674549103,
-0.8244789242744446,
0.13092581927776337,
0.9482448101043701,
0.49311208724975586,
-0.5939449071884155,
-0.1989474892616272,
0.1844923198223114,
-0.518673837184906,
0.033421166241168976,
-0.09354360401630402,
0.3706774413585663,
0.23391187191009521,
-0.6912788152694702,
0.396810382604599,
0.3149121105670929,
0.19594988226890564,
-0.4529757797718048,
-0.15220783650875092,
0.06091601029038429,
0.5848034620285034,
0.6188233494758606,
0.04393241927027702,
-0.6951952576637268,
-0.2875695526599884,
-0.09216097742319107,
-0.2690962255001068,
-0.15055184066295624,
0.637582004070282,
-0.3138885498046875,
0.06369844079017639,
0.29741016030311584,
0.6135549545288086,
0.7597886919975281,
-0.12955141067504883,
0.37655308842658997,
-0.14818163216114044,
0.610965371131897,
0.21441444754600525,
0.5003090500831604,
0.17901714146137238,
-0.10931901633739471,
1.0627185106277466,
0.2174074947834015,
-0.39826634526252747,
-1.031389832496643,
0.465496689081192,
-1.1160329580307007,
-0.14022086560726166,
1.6997085809707642,
-0.027977004647254944,
0.016950758174061775,
0.1853514313697815,
-0.45418664813041687,
0.1543332040309906,
-0.38051992654800415,
0.5811099410057068,
0.9448953866958618,
0.13854385912418365,
0.1366472989320755,
-0.668422281742096,
0.14211609959602356,
0.4544450044631958,
-0.81490159034729,
-0.2633054256439209,
0.4808953106403351,
0.596050500869751,
-0.00025927062961272895,
0.6441308259963989,
-0.3778596520423889,
0.6669746041297913,
0.27721187472343445,
0.07754715532064438,
-0.19630125164985657,
-0.8245450258255005,
-0.09566246718168259,
0.16158562898635864,
0.283153235912323,
0.1978183388710022
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09858v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09858v2
|
FakeWatch: A Framework for Detecting Fake News to Ensure Credible Elections
| 2024-03-14T20:39:26 | 2024-05-04T18:53:38 |
Shaina Raza, Tahniat Khan, Veronica Chatrath, Drai Paulen-Patterson, Mizanur Rahman, Oluwanifemi Bamgbose
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In today's technologically driven world, the rapid spread of fake news,
particularly during critical events like elections, poses a growing threat to
the integrity of information. To tackle this challenge head-on, we introduce
FakeWatch, a comprehensive framework carefully designed to detect fake news.
Leveraging a newly curated dataset of North American election-related news
articles, we construct robust classification models. Our framework integrates a
model hub comprising of both traditional machine learning (ML) techniques, and
state-of-the-art Language Models (LMs) to discern fake news effectively. Our
objective is to provide the research community with adaptable and precise
classification models adept at identifying fake news for the elections agenda.
Quantitative evaluations of fake news classifiers on our dataset reveal that,
while state-of-the-art LMs exhibit a slight edge over traditional ML models,
classical models remain competitive due to their balance of accuracy and
computational efficiency. Additionally, qualitative analyses shed light on
patterns within fake news articles. We provide our labeled data at
https://huggingface.co/datasets/newsmediabias/fake_news_elections_labelled_data
and model https://huggingface.co/newsmediabias/FakeWatch for reproducibility
and further research.
|
[
-0.13806146383285522,
-1.0357426404953003,
0.7512190341949463,
0.14581966400146484,
-0.38816186785697937,
0.3668603003025055,
0.348856657743454,
-0.4831482172012329,
0.2585469186306,
0.536308765411377,
-0.5085681676864624,
-0.35570889711380005,
-0.3507819175720215,
-0.11265383660793304,
-0.9918097853660583,
0.934664249420166,
0.08216159045696259,
0.24993754923343658,
-0.2129676192998886,
-0.03658495843410492,
0.03755949065089226,
-0.5304318070411682,
-0.2351023107767105,
-0.2799292206764221,
0.2676885724067688,
0.1516060084104538,
0.5913968086242676,
1.0510257482528687,
0.1965368092060089,
0.1558666229248047,
0.1477557122707367,
0.3801965117454529,
-0.36482423543930054,
-0.3219548165798187,
-0.1764635294675827,
-0.5034186840057373,
-0.3489442467689514,
0.5648937225341797,
0.2424527406692505,
0.002998092444613576,
-0.20171400904655457,
0.41613510251045227,
-0.23146717250347137,
0.31487229466438293,
-0.608936607837677,
0.07972759753465652,
-0.7747011780738831,
-0.11933553963899612,
-0.5338265299797058,
-0.387395977973938,
-0.3906252980232239,
-0.5781559348106384,
-0.02573666162788868,
-0.3816095292568207,
0.5787991285324097,
0.3656831979751587,
0.9598327875137329,
-0.009775093756616116,
-0.4556625187397003,
-0.2458287626504898,
-0.651282548904419,
0.42196589708328247,
-0.6509124636650085,
0.5101592540740967,
0.2647792100906372,
0.48744460940361023,
0.14851175248622894,
-0.8024566173553467,
-1.0043294429779053,
0.07751630246639252,
0.28793373703956604,
0.18101508915424347,
-0.32247406244277954,
-0.4024234414100647,
-0.047230396419763565,
0.33166393637657166,
-0.8225293159484863,
-0.04458993673324585,
-0.15586893260478973,
-0.4825688600540161,
0.5084983110427856,
-0.05607450380921364,
0.3789474070072174,
-0.17029829323291779,
-0.5076479911804199,
0.004363879095762968,
-0.5739747285842896,
-0.2898811399936676,
0.8268744349479675,
0.3848744332790375,
-0.20460014045238495,
0.2131950706243515,
-0.3507029712200165,
0.752937376499176,
0.28544747829437256,
-0.13984636962413788,
0.09969896078109741,
-0.37255293130874634,
-0.288320928812027,
0.24055711925029755,
0.49616390466690063,
0.19825105369091034,
0.07836978137493134,
-0.013466940261423588,
-0.4051665961742401,
0.8836541771888733,
0.5379186272621155,
-0.5421912670135498,
-0.26312968134880066,
0.13526403903961182,
-0.6924490332603455,
-1.0472246408462524,
0.3736323416233063,
-0.6058003902435303,
-0.40901780128479004,
-0.6163135766983032,
0.7246053814888,
0.1591167449951172,
-0.3441259562969208,
0.13916140794754028,
-0.32578882575035095,
-0.13714683055877686,
0.23705269396305084,
-0.012456086464226246,
0.11668039113283157,
0.7998509407043457,
0.6525354981422424,
-0.007254283409565687,
0.03861407935619354,
-0.6343104243278503,
-0.2513178884983063,
-0.5989456176757812,
0.8417455554008484,
-0.46442312002182007,
0.32165297865867615,
0.13067178428173065,
0.16216479241847992,
0.10477806627750397,
-0.5545832514762878,
0.6406192779541016,
-0.954283595085144,
0.6322022080421448,
-0.03983549028635025,
-0.723296046257019,
-0.172563374042511,
0.4952598810195923,
-0.8622724413871765,
0.8968883752822876,
0.04599558934569359,
-0.68400639295578,
0.6801254153251648,
-0.3023228347301483,
-0.41545674204826355,
-0.03872864693403244,
0.23859180510044098,
-0.7317554950714111,
0.10296492278575897,
0.27360260486602783,
0.41557279229164124,
0.20396767556667328,
0.2440042495727539,
-0.5831784009933472,
-0.2757079005241394,
0.14949090778827667,
-0.46323075890541077,
0.7637815475463867,
0.09936298429965973,
-0.6189110279083252,
0.13097341358661652,
-0.6116454005241394,
-0.09862828999757767,
0.014842448756098747,
0.052647653967142105,
-0.14534756541252136,
0.3392038643360138,
0.39177629351615906,
0.2563764750957489,
0.05959337577223778,
-0.6973568797111511,
-0.03546702489256859,
-0.16602180898189545,
0.34626826643943787,
0.8861232399940491,
-0.021647514775395393,
0.4067392945289612,
-0.6256970763206482,
0.22049587965011597,
0.29237866401672363,
0.37143170833587646,
-0.20623064041137695,
-0.30472245812416077,
-0.6164193749427795,
-0.1382167637348175,
0.422567754983902,
1.0433756113052368,
-0.8712117671966553,
0.4519813358783722,
-0.289605975151062,
-0.5611836314201355,
-0.4036487936973572,
-0.05937706679105759,
0.09655218571424484,
0.39279597997665405,
0.3299241065979004,
0.03363919258117676,
-0.6548513174057007,
-0.6366809606552124,
-0.8018639087677002,
-0.26207253336906433,
0.15262600779533386,
-0.25904014706611633,
0.7626640796661377,
-0.41886043548583984,
1.1427446603775024,
0.029235810041427612,
-0.18156640231609344,
0.08283756673336029,
0.034018851816654205,
0.13694368302822113,
0.13183319568634033,
0.49955737590789795,
-1.2167569398880005,
-0.1625380665063858,
-0.06981521099805832,
-0.5439615249633789,
-0.09081550687551498,
-0.23678968846797943,
0.13135544955730438,
0.3148728907108307,
0.5417332053184509,
-0.2989954948425293,
0.7804763913154602,
0.6951104402542114,
-0.46613144874572754,
0.661747395992279,
0.3081120550632477,
0.2396288514137268,
-0.9558663964271545,
-0.02809840254485607,
-0.18077051639556885,
-0.9705843925476074,
-0.7657550573348999,
-0.1562090516090393,
0.16513483226299286,
-0.10596783459186554,
-0.37057599425315857,
0.8705347776412964,
-0.05651956796646118,
0.17177654802799225,
-0.5094033479690552,
-0.09935476630926132,
0.05311425030231476,
-0.166203111410141,
0.1266949623823166,
0.3659980893135071,
0.3322475552558899,
-0.4759320616722107,
0.5788784027099609,
-0.009395718574523926,
-0.785508394241333,
0.6867887377738953,
-0.659682035446167,
0.08363939821720123,
-0.1577429324388504,
0.6178571581840515,
-0.5116216540336609,
-0.5505228042602539,
0.3469639718532562,
-0.8268368244171143,
0.019332703202962875,
-0.038932304829359055,
-0.9010134935379028,
-0.34761735796928406,
0.02815457619726658,
-0.10366994142532349,
0.24170780181884766,
-0.8455083966255188,
0.5412315130233765,
0.4712951183319092,
0.3738407790660858,
-0.32996615767478943,
-0.4600411355495453,
-0.05957036837935448,
-0.15749076008796692,
-0.3581823706626892,
0.26743757724761963,
0.18640488386154175,
-0.2582837641239166,
0.3541673421859741,
-0.4352681338787079,
-0.31502193212509155,
-0.006554951425641775,
0.060783181339502335,
0.27797624468803406,
-0.19693586230278015,
0.02246352843940258,
-0.22129428386688232,
0.029875172302126884,
-0.09349916875362396,
-0.3733278214931488,
0.2517314553260803,
0.09869213402271271,
-0.3327504098415375,
-0.7992004156112671,
0.14638347923755646,
0.8632081747055054,
-0.1849585473537445,
0.7073396444320679,
0.8909416794776917,
-0.7702428102493286,
-0.5309593677520752,
-0.6649850010871887,
-0.5490743517875671,
-0.42746230959892273,
0.14518824219703674,
0.08535736799240112,
-0.6587374210357666,
0.3860867917537689,
0.07028276473283768,
0.012509874999523163,
0.18964038789272308,
0.36774444580078125,
-0.0030060906428843737,
1.2761436700820923,
0.5435885787010193,
-0.5899556279182434,
0.4095104932785034,
0.25616171956062317,
0.39674466848373413,
0.02479853294789791,
-0.07851221412420273,
-0.3233489990234375,
-0.14245595037937164,
-0.3482356667518616,
-0.5600085258483887,
0.16623654961585999,
-0.009850401431322098,
-0.25687283277511597,
0.10021168738603592,
-0.6306465268135071,
0.3167679011821747,
0.652664840221405,
0.19124291837215424,
0.13598784804344177,
0.26006880402565,
0.2629024088382721,
0.03308165445923805,
-0.8260424137115479,
-0.6234546303749084,
0.9121301174163818,
0.352172315120697,
0.547546923160553,
-0.047456126660108566,
0.32011598348617554,
0.8464908003807068,
0.8131213188171387,
-0.3463708758354187,
0.08646897971630096,
0.005912751890718937,
-1.0960865020751953,
0.11362390220165253,
-0.5567752122879028,
-0.5002566576004028,
-0.024966688826680183,
-0.32730382680892944,
-0.10644524544477463,
0.16071368753910065,
0.37477150559425354,
0.07953318953514099,
0.6678417921066284,
-0.2748715579509735,
0.8706534504890442,
-0.2939334809780121,
-0.17276360094547272,
-0.21007144451141357,
-0.3643416464328766,
0.40636277198791504,
-0.21843159198760986,
0.4750502109527588,
-0.10630679130554199,
-0.01616501621901989,
0.4334344267845154,
-0.13355763256549835,
0.9808835983276367,
-0.14004667103290558,
0.48597824573516846,
0.18059475719928741,
0.12929360568523407,
0.7180159091949463,
0.04021705314517021,
0.23238448798656464,
0.19415612518787384,
0.17526017129421234,
-0.5658720135688782,
-0.18185356259346008,
0.5698756575584412,
-0.415781706571579,
-0.006323919631540775,
-0.8571321368217468,
-0.10542601346969604,
-0.08361484110355377,
0.140004962682724,
0.4932805001735687,
0.3727738857269287,
-0.5172319412231445,
0.25184527039527893,
0.6178069710731506,
0.038253024220466614,
0.10362492501735687,
0.7527158260345459,
-0.30880844593048096,
-0.25341251492500305,
1.1333359479904175,
0.09603385627269745,
-0.22310279309749603,
0.17643119394779205,
0.19985979795455933,
-0.6125160455703735,
-0.2669064402580261,
-0.44169551134109497,
-0.027294564992189407,
-0.18714416027069092,
-0.33241117000579834,
-0.325066477060318,
-0.08312862366437912,
-0.4930775463581085,
-0.10060331970453262,
-0.42677366733551025,
-0.04362925514578819,
-0.6043795347213745,
-0.1270613968372345,
0.23683777451515198,
0.5357677340507507,
-0.09400100260972977,
0.4039615988731384,
-0.5313295722007751,
0.5734134316444397,
0.29272016882896423,
0.3810177147388458,
-0.32356032729148865,
-0.5557136535644531,
-0.014450174756348133,
0.21123063564300537,
-0.38598647713661194,
-1.0622079372406006,
0.6053146719932556,
0.178677499294281,
0.5368555188179016,
0.7456288933753967,
0.2399444282054901,
0.5088512897491455,
-0.515723466873169,
0.6456650495529175,
-0.10502484440803528,
-1.074865460395813,
0.4948241710662842,
-0.6248740553855896,
-0.004233500920236111,
0.2734549343585968,
0.3590048849582672,
-0.38506102561950684,
-0.3937167823314667,
-0.9015325307846069,
-0.4862593114376068,
0.3848394751548767,
0.15200799703598022,
0.19332723319530487,
-0.09847857058048248,
0.17867019772529602,
-0.053588464856147766,
0.6351614594459534,
-0.9301947951316833,
-0.08693873137235641,
-0.4460023045539856,
-0.35968050360679626,
0.06764562427997589,
-0.13222986459732056,
-0.16031339764595032,
0.04473688080906868,
0.7847203612327576,
-0.28054240345954895,
0.13710381090641022,
0.28849971294403076,
-0.17713432013988495,
-0.06710217148065567,
-0.1327364295721054,
0.6478457450866699,
0.7718991041183472,
-0.031311970204114914,
-0.0014682537876069546,
-0.06258929520845413,
-0.2780260443687439,
-0.16732166707515717,
-0.05528935417532921,
-0.453044593334198,
0.4634750783443451,
0.723962128162384,
0.6456348896026611,
0.1689622700214386,
-0.6010722517967224,
0.7313721776008606,
0.16956980526447296,
-0.2754693925380707,
-0.6111316084861755,
-0.2894587218761444,
0.01197099220007658,
0.03934124484658241,
0.7260425090789795,
0.4031781554222107,
0.13602329790592194,
-0.9225523471832275,
0.6616900563240051,
0.49032333493232727,
-0.630788266658783,
-0.6490336060523987,
0.9712838530540466,
0.18957364559173584,
-0.3527364432811737,
0.3236057758331299,
-0.1857934445142746,
-1.0939851999282837,
0.6028201580047607,
0.37980663776397705,
0.4281134307384491,
-0.591296911239624,
0.5759692788124084,
0.08849260956048965,
0.7256100177764893,
-0.5794996023178101,
0.15244640409946442,
0.22810141742229462,
-0.9699571132659912,
-0.22215904295444489,
-0.6692026853561401,
-0.2464248239994049,
0.462093323469162,
-0.6649606823921204,
0.2105318158864975,
-0.49246156215667725,
-0.2150828242301941,
-0.06009633466601372,
0.18952986598014832,
-0.36937639117240906,
0.3818928599357605,
0.3054748475551605,
1.1609522104263306,
-1.229973316192627,
0.4848683774471283,
0.43142807483673096,
0.3840954005718231,
-0.177422434091568,
-0.030885230749845505,
0.7310694456100464,
-0.5130856037139893,
0.125949889421463,
0.3140599727630615,
0.11866439878940582,
-0.2627396583557129,
-0.8328677415847778,
-0.40370452404022217,
0.4678257405757904,
0.27339157462120056,
-0.6362823843955994,
0.06919907033443451,
-0.10296091437339783,
0.43446072936058044,
-0.48824024200439453,
-0.24002055823802948,
0.24892722070217133,
0.6784628033638,
-0.5077677369117737,
-0.7177006602287292,
-0.276764839887619,
-0.002581189153715968,
-0.4865421950817108,
0.17485441267490387,
-0.6207058429718018,
0.6569640040397644,
0.2807280123233795,
-0.36395934224128723,
-0.0035620499402284622,
0.6506381630897522,
0.18201036751270294,
1.1481441259384155,
0.612724244594574,
0.6565291881561279,
0.7862086296081543,
-0.3430000841617584,
1.1026325225830078,
-0.2751610279083252,
0.30240169167518616,
0.8385457992553711,
-0.3044049143791199,
0.7036038041114807,
0.03658389672636986,
0.24885819852352142,
0.658178448677063,
0.7635697722434998,
-0.19502775371074677,
0.3491220772266388,
-0.02313345856964588,
-0.32186660170555115,
-0.6430810689926147,
0.01795637048780918,
-0.08007001131772995,
0.5646132230758667,
0.46416768431663513,
-0.33731985092163086,
-0.019727740436792374,
0.09886564314365387,
0.14207057654857635,
0.49481201171875,
-0.4650858938694,
0.2504820227622986,
-0.11780909448862076,
-0.22509481012821198,
-0.04029709845781326,
-0.03292880579829216,
0.538488507270813,
-0.46595361828804016,
-0.10121463239192963,
0.024562368169426918,
0.3322511613368988,
-0.10224315524101257,
-0.3102208971977234,
0.3981952667236328,
-0.11438556015491486,
-0.5723443031311035,
-0.41154953837394714,
0.6934109926223755,
-0.3805168867111206,
-0.6980379223823547,
0.23309627175331116,
0.5760942101478577,
-0.2359050065279007,
-0.525740921497345,
-0.7548474073410034,
0.35989129543304443,
-0.08329018205404282,
-0.1777506321668625,
0.1077984869480133,
0.03882448375225067,
-0.29581084847450256,
0.7495827078819275,
1.315293550491333,
0.2937077283859253,
-0.06832726299762726,
-0.4041098654270172,
0.4850784242153168,
-0.3208978772163391,
-0.8941035270690918,
-0.5572000741958618,
0.1839958280324936,
-0.4073007106781006,
-0.2683500647544861,
0.8520076870918274,
0.8739071488380432,
0.6826168298721313,
-0.20517833530902863,
0.721954345703125,
0.14906740188598633,
1.2774813175201416,
-0.34809261560440063,
0.9828327298164368,
-0.7367424964904785,
0.042206089943647385,
0.15625666081905365,
-0.7003800868988037,
-0.24054186046123505,
0.42835769057273865,
-0.15022720396518707,
-0.1399347186088562,
0.28792527318000793,
0.7910190224647522,
-0.419338583946228,
-0.10630856454372406,
0.10768434405326843,
0.1938009411096573,
0.08150763809680939,
-0.08532483875751495,
0.7634819746017456,
-0.4215446710586548,
0.5844684839248657,
-0.05919506028294563,
-0.1300533264875412,
-0.5523563027381897,
-0.7358759045600891,
-0.8748137950897217,
-0.566981852054596,
-0.44368812441825867,
-0.5105037689208984,
0.16276897490024567,
0.21152938902378082,
1.3744797706604004,
-0.8866201043128967,
0.20303191244602203,
-0.05206682160496712,
0.26033395528793335,
-0.3275815546512604,
-0.44595110416412354,
0.32574817538261414,
0.1037936806678772,
-0.7003957629203796,
0.5932913422584534,
0.0876675546169281,
-0.051235049962997437,
-0.12133356183767319,
0.2673254907131195,
-0.06570154428482056,
0.5305737257003784,
0.5359614491462708,
0.42993247509002686,
-0.7445999383926392,
-0.5998280048370361,
0.24334551393985748,
-0.06461722403764725,
-0.6050294041633606,
0.7926245927810669,
-1.1883121728897095,
0.40617290139198303,
0.44363152980804443,
0.4446985721588135,
0.3486649990081787,
0.3294215500354767,
0.4126304090023041,
-0.7458527088165283,
0.19948510825634003,
0.3518940806388855,
-0.13738441467285156,
0.3598679304122925,
-0.36954358220100403,
0.37755924463272095,
0.6016345620155334,
-0.5877463221549988,
-1.5174880027770996,
0.2814805209636688,
-0.8097645044326782,
-0.3413016200065613,
0.7903622984886169,
0.4389977753162384,
-0.39339950680732727,
-0.43465864658355713,
0.2895686626434326,
0.047347962856292725,
-0.14731410145759583,
0.7937307953834534,
0.5678282380104065,
0.20727625489234924,
-0.18858247995376587,
-0.7686034440994263,
0.7255954146385193,
-0.10362178087234497,
-0.6467471718788147,
-0.3180106282234192,
0.5163257122039795,
0.6893569231033325,
0.2270572930574417,
0.32961252331733704,
0.06735442578792572,
0.7072663307189941,
0.014961754903197289,
-0.27228012681007385,
-0.10628944635391235,
-0.40689224004745483,
-0.08763622492551804,
0.015962785109877586,
-0.896925687789917,
-0.1937035769224167
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09849v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09849v1
|
Self-Consistency Boosts Calibration for Math Reasoning
| 2024-03-14T20:17:10 | 2024-03-14T20:17:10 |
Ante Wang, Linfeng Song, Ye Tian, Baolin Peng, Lifeng Jin, Haitao Mi, Jinsong Su, Dong Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Calibration, which establishes the correlation between accuracy and model
confidence, is important for LLM development. We design three off-the-shelf
calibration methods based on self-consistency (Wang et al., 2022) for math
reasoning tasks. Evaluation on two popular benchmarks (GSM8K and MathQA) using
strong open-source LLMs (Mistral and LLaMA2), our methods better bridge model
confidence and accuracy than existing methods based on p(True) (Kadavath et
al., 2022) or logit (Kadavath et al., 2022).
|
[
-0.028890646994113922,
-0.25745654106140137,
0.8239046335220337,
0.47618818283081055,
0.0709686204791069,
-0.11110404133796692,
0.0731106624007225,
-0.19376330077648163,
-0.07319279760122299,
0.442315012216568,
-0.4516518712043762,
-0.28456470370292664,
-0.2018595039844513,
0.05732796713709831,
0.0027328473515808582,
0.6322476267814636,
-0.4355664849281311,
0.4769977033138275,
-0.6750176548957825,
-0.31176337599754333,
-0.5440827012062073,
-0.5323270559310913,
-0.09987261146306992,
-0.6714379191398621,
0.2590537369251251,
0.3094146251678467,
0.8604862689971924,
0.7262203097343445,
0.550718367099762,
0.2964065968990326,
0.2369864284992218,
0.4698789417743683,
-0.43039828538894653,
0.24401789903640747,
-0.24396419525146484,
-0.6233808398246765,
-0.5572491884231567,
0.1466410607099533,
0.2702729403972626,
0.3123244643211365,
-0.3708372712135315,
0.24263660609722137,
0.13416777551174164,
0.8483405113220215,
-0.9646482467651367,
0.21476975083351135,
-0.3598323464393616,
-0.2684379518032074,
-0.034099843353033066,
-0.17722772061824799,
-0.38140612840652466,
-0.7017311453819275,
-0.2605557441711426,
-0.8368152976036072,
-0.14776891469955444,
-0.24633781611919403,
0.457892507314682,
0.7120187282562256,
-0.4132317006587982,
-0.30961671471595764,
-0.7325206995010376,
0.971363365650177,
-0.8045774102210999,
0.5156598091125488,
0.7076913118362427,
0.5138340592384338,
-0.2539959251880646,
-0.5788887143135071,
-0.27072668075561523,
0.17017331719398499,
0.14109696447849274,
0.39966845512390137,
0.20810897648334503,
-0.08793604373931885,
0.3443140983581543,
0.46333885192871094,
-0.20809753239154816,
-0.22445793449878693,
-0.20850369334220886,
-0.38006946444511414,
0.7218508720397949,
0.20595796406269073,
-0.0785832554101944,
0.041850026696920395,
-0.2916422188282013,
-0.10376138985157013,
-1.118219017982483,
-0.07535961270332336,
0.43877649307250977,
-0.07044017314910889,
0.026126045733690262,
0.7238548994064331,
-0.08341247588396072,
0.7351633906364441,
0.21295060217380524,
-0.6864726543426514,
0.17951545119285583,
-0.46407371759414673,
-0.28838202357292175,
-0.10010340064764023,
0.46722936630249023,
0.1337236911058426,
0.4717542827129364,
0.1077127754688263,
-0.2167237251996994,
0.09630357474088669,
0.006951487623155117,
-0.5875456929206848,
-0.6070972084999084,
-0.05351746827363968,
-0.12531161308288574,
-0.1629541665315628,
-0.051183879375457764,
-0.2639581859111786,
-0.1180431917309761,
-0.7734987139701843,
0.9346415996551514,
-0.09157808870077133,
-0.04556373134255409,
0.16877949237823486,
0.22472023963928223,
0.15397857129573822,
0.8014571070671082,
-0.8622586131095886,
0.16680534183979034,
0.8609189987182617,
0.5319222211837769,
-0.14783450961112976,
-0.20859843492507935,
-0.5570883750915527,
0.1568594127893448,
-0.7138917446136475,
0.6469400525093079,
-0.01021219789981842,
-0.3342921733856201,
-0.24545541405677795,
-0.2807700037956238,
0.07256901264190674,
-0.6376100778579712,
0.7451156973838806,
-0.3397045433521271,
0.20736496150493622,
-0.46379220485687256,
-0.6687825918197632,
-0.21809814870357513,
0.2854962944984436,
-0.47022518515586853,
1.4500977993011475,
0.1818629503250122,
-0.34112733602523804,
0.05550071969628334,
-0.10316301882266998,
0.024879232048988342,
-0.1569608896970749,
-0.45316967368125916,
-0.3644431233406067,
0.18496935069561005,
0.20935003459453583,
0.04503053426742554,
-0.30626505613327026,
0.24981755018234253,
-0.5495848655700684,
-0.5858041644096375,
0.18538451194763184,
-0.6403821110725403,
0.916302502155304,
0.3710336983203888,
-0.2285291999578476,
-0.3285727798938751,
-0.5981549620628357,
0.5972840785980225,
-0.15273593366146088,
-0.0533100962638855,
-0.08316005021333694,
-0.01756267249584198,
-0.6670473217964172,
0.23213863372802734,
0.40816688537597656,
-0.47602343559265137,
0.06611216068267822,
-0.22258338332176208,
0.21398082375526428,
0.8166371583938599,
-0.2501519024372101,
0.2002372294664383,
-0.6338311433792114,
0.4178430736064911,
-0.04918569326400757,
-0.07954907417297363,
-0.41244837641716003,
-0.6753079891204834,
-0.8199904561042786,
-0.3140948712825775,
0.5202536582946777,
0.6083463430404663,
-0.19589151442050934,
0.476150780916214,
0.02644851990044117,
-0.5930325388908386,
-0.36044803261756897,
0.5676343441009521,
0.4152470827102661,
0.7302121520042419,
0.39214134216308594,
0.13486269116401672,
-0.4266281723976135,
-0.564839243888855,
-0.450476735830307,
-0.20403678715229034,
-0.06191857159137726,
0.16948990523815155,
0.24942155182361603,
-0.033657509833574295,
1.165097951889038,
-0.44678938388824463,
-0.24274151027202606,
0.31232187151908875,
0.08025890588760376,
0.1579606533050537,
0.46187034249305725,
0.4421376585960388,
-0.44878053665161133,
-0.7367329597473145,
-0.46344614028930664,
-0.9027299880981445,
-0.4538547694683075,
0.19081270694732666,
-0.37359893321990967,
0.09160109609365463,
0.2900267243385315,
-0.4227747321128845,
0.7876991033554077,
0.6777218580245972,
-0.11164015531539917,
0.5317051410675049,
-0.2639671266078949,
0.24928376078605652,
-0.8917383551597595,
-0.30982574820518494,
0.09275238960981369,
-0.5301936268806458,
-0.3739367425441742,
-0.06404660642147064,
0.4380970001220703,
0.27568477392196655,
-0.34944096207618713,
0.7243261337280273,
-0.37217429280281067,
-0.09782489389181137,
-0.14943575859069824,
0.06974314153194427,
0.4705314040184021,
-0.015179506503045559,
-0.16277863085269928,
1.1997780799865723,
0.3492712378501892,
-0.5568079948425293,
0.39369136095046997,
0.15885129570960999,
-0.22779622673988342,
0.6611717343330383,
-0.7726908922195435,
0.13983172178268433,
0.29774045944213867,
0.2133178412914276,
-1.2335973978042603,
0.061988189816474915,
0.2059222161769867,
-0.4262337386608124,
0.023173989728093147,
-0.12965507805347443,
-0.6115726232528687,
-0.21171283721923828,
-0.2867174744606018,
0.685200572013855,
0.5589756965637207,
-0.8891004323959351,
0.8890740275382996,
0.06833186000585556,
0.24760986864566803,
-0.6097754836082458,
-0.8299710750579834,
-0.4431284964084625,
0.051563724875450134,
-0.6974814534187317,
0.1862301081418991,
-0.5169006586074829,
-0.5691989660263062,
-0.42732125520706177,
-0.5602564215660095,
-0.03193240612745285,
0.08337880671024323,
0.5495643019676208,
0.5381621718406677,
-0.25913360714912415,
0.22961333394050598,
-0.1818447858095169,
-0.34840330481529236,
0.19796927273273468,
0.00579884322360158,
0.06660918891429901,
-0.28270673751831055,
-0.8795263171195984,
-0.6435555815696716,
-0.11933528631925583,
0.3239787518978119,
0.05018482357263565,
0.11978729814291,
0.26898685097694397,
-0.4620727002620697,
0.03997945785522461,
-0.8948707580566406,
-0.22513051331043243,
-0.5384686589241028,
-0.4631325304508209,
-0.6403535604476929,
-0.6704155802726746,
0.5203083753585815,
-0.1777496337890625,
0.056237731128931046,
0.6126968264579773,
0.5836418271064758,
-0.20440886914730072,
1.1811317205429077,
0.30666953325271606,
0.20899686217308044,
-0.010328665375709534,
0.07074495404958725,
0.23723869025707245,
-0.8806378841400146,
-0.10918858647346497,
-0.4067862331867218,
-0.010598720982670784,
-0.37973111867904663,
-0.617127537727356,
0.1604318916797638,
0.36070477962493896,
-0.45675021409988403,
0.1434023529291153,
-0.44551607966423035,
0.6912843585014343,
0.6347187757492065,
0.04405587911605835,
0.5254727602005005,
0.016794627532362938,
-0.4528959095478058,
-0.5719740986824036,
-0.39963722229003906,
-0.45002588629722595,
1.336756944656372,
0.13034328818321228,
1.3812135457992554,
0.17567047476768494,
0.767943263053894,
0.024743152782320976,
0.4984622895717621,
-0.6529811024665833,
0.4382281005382538,
0.07939217984676361,
-0.8498221635818481,
-0.05054019019007683,
-0.5750308036804199,
-0.4848234951496124,
0.12233518809080124,
0.0056250025518238544,
-0.5994770526885986,
0.06730014830827713,
0.43343251943588257,
-0.30231231451034546,
0.16906985640525818,
-0.7025247812271118,
0.5075451731681824,
-0.42336925864219666,
-0.4892756938934326,
-0.12526217103004456,
-0.21826490759849548,
0.5165586471557617,
-0.23175834119319916,
0.11998142302036285,
-0.574718177318573,
0.013737540692090988,
0.2375151515007019,
-0.6030924916267395,
0.6654329299926758,
0.15788665413856506,
-0.3721124827861786,
0.7409104704856873,
0.5382620096206665,
0.3832104802131653,
0.3034456670284271,
-0.40880751609802246,
0.3881637156009674,
0.2941257357597351,
-0.29683932662010193,
-0.8702923655509949,
0.9606236219406128,
-0.8086257576942444,
-0.8843644261360168,
-0.6315652132034302,
-0.7088048458099365,
-0.2139960080385208,
0.19052526354789734,
-0.03080250509083271,
0.3871302902698517,
0.22999507188796997,
0.12688162922859192,
0.7225943803787231,
0.42512038350105286,
0.18429414927959442,
0.35999786853790283,
-0.3857007324695587,
-0.8622239232063293,
0.6087138652801514,
0.25287488102912903,
0.43499556183815,
0.1749090552330017,
0.38444381952285767,
-0.5620790719985962,
0.2219715267419815,
-0.5119758248329163,
0.36506763100624084,
-0.9897592663764954,
-0.6852381825447083,
-0.12710663676261902,
-0.476188063621521,
-0.49483153223991394,
-0.25456055998802185,
-0.636476993560791,
-0.8197691440582275,
-0.38478586077690125,
0.1756656914949417,
0.39961448311805725,
0.6952593922615051,
-0.3958626091480255,
0.13982604444026947,
-0.5557273030281067,
0.32846084237098694,
0.49639952182769775,
0.34387460350990295,
-0.20792695879936218,
-0.6916005611419678,
0.04540623351931572,
0.461313396692276,
-0.5326118469238281,
-0.6043235063552856,
-0.009658842347562313,
0.06996604055166245,
0.6515204310417175,
0.5161879658699036,
-0.024621350690722466,
0.974659264087677,
-0.23082615435123444,
0.5340650081634521,
0.2692858874797821,
-1.1457993984222412,
0.48229697346687317,
-0.013448894023895264,
0.3065338134765625,
0.6577856540679932,
0.27540892362594604,
-0.1138945147395134,
0.13648124039173126,
-0.48933371901512146,
0.0879952684044838,
0.25253382325172424,
0.2611019015312195,
-0.08677919954061508,
0.19365623593330383,
0.6776111721992493,
0.025888949632644653,
0.0010029732948169112,
-0.5873750448226929,
-0.44630932807922363,
-0.4086103141307831,
-0.5021194815635681,
-0.13569273054599762,
-0.38165417313575745,
-0.5245506167411804,
-0.5177556276321411,
0.5945844650268555,
-0.35064026713371277,
0.09220310300588608,
0.216638445854187,
0.06488321721553802,
-0.30123165249824524,
-0.15047071874141693,
0.7154731750488281,
1.1006920337677002,
-0.18949219584465027,
0.39556771516799927,
0.27041909098625183,
-0.45717915892601013,
0.4489639699459076,
-0.1502235382795334,
-0.31984683871269226,
-0.09778086841106415,
0.009088960476219654,
0.05597750097513199,
0.36611485481262207,
-0.3435349464416504,
0.6136608719825745,
-0.013494305312633514,
-0.49651119112968445,
-0.5711308121681213,
0.2816790044307709,
0.14765775203704834,
0.07647363096475601,
0.18385672569274902,
0.10579713433980942,
-0.14162331819534302,
-0.2310686856508255,
0.08810589462518692,
0.49290263652801514,
-0.11203456670045853,
-0.12576229870319366,
0.7985599637031555,
-0.21633465588092804,
-0.25740617513656616,
0.5500552654266357,
0.020948097109794617,
-0.46247100830078125,
0.5415528416633606,
0.865234375,
0.5399846434593201,
-0.4017164409160614,
0.03970976546406746,
0.5363487005233765,
0.11975018680095673,
-0.5948160290718079,
0.6012365221977234,
-0.17600977420806885,
-0.8396350741386414,
-0.5718826651573181,
-0.31652572751045227,
-0.9625629782676697,
-0.3002449870109558,
-0.6098122596740723,
0.4258738160133362,
-0.5331652760505676,
-0.16515140235424042,
-0.26564323902130127,
0.28690609335899353,
-0.5748457908630371,
0.37801414728164673,
-0.001811143709346652,
0.9671984910964966,
-0.5452255606651306,
0.822320818901062,
0.4089890718460083,
-0.04623613879084587,
-1.1483113765716553,
-0.42857474088668823,
0.3564828932285309,
-1.1522762775421143,
0.5339226126670837,
0.1748417317867279,
-0.45782700181007385,
0.15204280614852905,
-0.5381332635879517,
-1.3582029342651367,
1.4955756664276123,
0.4835929274559021,
-0.507986307144165,
0.12312446534633636,
0.07167363911867142,
0.3494698107242584,
-0.4610653519630432,
0.5564413070678711,
0.2605169713497162,
0.4623885452747345,
0.5729629397392273,
-0.9075899720191956,
-0.17056706547737122,
-0.002522598020732403,
0.03217146545648575,
0.12437295913696289,
-0.7491922974586487,
0.6791226267814636,
-0.3210492432117462,
0.0523572713136673,
0.35342347621917725,
0.7287183403968811,
0.895167887210846,
0.4212234914302826,
0.2980737090110779,
1.1189411878585815,
0.858310341835022,
-0.35713550448417664,
0.5504166483879089,
-0.5839340090751648,
0.39207354187965393,
1.351212978363037,
-0.3164066970348358,
0.8490505814552307,
0.3063092529773712,
-0.4030512869358063,
0.6653222441673279,
0.5631338953971863,
-0.10506590455770493,
0.20731158554553986,
0.07476534694433212,
-0.22794699668884277,
-0.7724870443344116,
0.3173266649246216,
-0.5926681756973267,
0.3203388452529907,
0.4232726991176605,
-0.07719361782073975,
-0.32993248105049133,
-0.6189787983894348,
0.03824466094374657,
0.0810333862900734,
-0.3682144582271576,
0.15841825306415558,
0.39497509598731995,
-0.7722895741462708,
0.4989834427833557,
-0.1354188621044159,
0.25221768021583557,
-0.4296555519104004,
-0.12956398725509644,
-0.1829652637243271,
0.5150968432426453,
-0.3917365074157715,
-0.8327017426490784,
0.12984132766723633,
-0.454340398311615,
0.03799257054924965,
-0.15068186819553375,
0.9342743754386902,
-0.22560305893421173,
-0.5765588879585266,
0.007762345019727945,
0.7850227952003479,
0.1369808167219162,
0.028920095413923264,
-0.6727809309959412,
0.041144564747810364,
-0.1369655728340149,
0.06089143827557564,
0.09576379507780075,
0.4393799901008606,
0.22970972955226898,
0.9049575924873352,
0.7964292168617249,
-0.09765323996543884,
0.2304006814956665,
0.08668293803930283,
0.6559799909591675,
-0.5045586824417114,
-0.14826491475105286,
-0.8531571626663208,
0.20934411883354187,
0.16607451438903809,
-0.34654051065444946,
1.191406011581421,
0.7761678695678711,
0.6866828203201294,
0.23125506937503815,
0.33211174607276917,
0.6174665689468384,
0.6390271782875061,
-0.3853332996368408,
0.19933533668518066,
-0.5632137656211853,
0.2931002676486969,
-0.054088886827230453,
-1.0671907663345337,
-0.6108272671699524,
1.1106586456298828,
-0.41069522500038147,
0.24627679586410522,
0.6982672810554504,
0.6820372343063354,
-0.11052902787923813,
0.005309406202286482,
0.41199278831481934,
-0.2364387810230255,
0.1595233678817749,
0.4577663540840149,
0.7422146201133728,
-0.645857036113739,
0.4610307514667511,
-0.42581701278686523,
-0.21419645845890045,
-0.19950832426548004,
-1.1600759029388428,
-0.8327545523643494,
-0.06334716081619263,
-0.4477479159832001,
-0.7376973032951355,
-0.16572712361812592,
0.7331534624099731,
0.8559654355049133,
-0.7473836541175842,
-0.3262672424316406,
-0.23898625373840332,
0.18806849420070648,
-0.10567430406808853,
-0.17628419399261475,
0.05317741259932518,
-0.358393132686615,
-0.4149278700351715,
0.21386750042438507,
0.49252668023109436,
0.361684650182724,
-0.669900119304657,
-0.37253350019454956,
0.20942458510398865,
0.4400763511657715,
0.2453429400920868,
0.41340047121047974,
-0.9470338821411133,
-0.16149219870567322,
0.25674667954444885,
-0.4056566655635834,
0.5830150842666626,
0.6376166343688965,
-0.8172052502632141,
0.5953091979026794,
0.5076801776885986,
0.5876149535179138,
0.453186571598053,
0.4942437708377838,
0.5905807614326477,
-0.022137148305773735,
-0.2173173576593399,
0.014337658882141113,
0.33388370275497437,
0.30750513076782227,
-0.32431983947753906,
0.8798582553863525,
0.30914753675460815,
-1.0102565288543701,
-0.7300620675086975,
0.24676233530044556,
-0.7769877910614014,
0.441001832485199,
0.9343395829200745,
-0.41439950466156006,
-0.11019904911518097,
0.1592622548341751,
0.02443944476544857,
-0.06990654766559601,
-0.13313190639019012,
0.7442476153373718,
0.9321320652961731,
-0.3196873962879181,
-0.24248133599758148,
-0.5178107619285583,
0.447746604681015,
0.7162418365478516,
-0.6828640103340149,
-0.15194770693778992,
0.35359305143356323,
0.5006335973739624,
0.3178179860115051,
0.7107216715812683,
-0.31521475315093994,
0.5024706125259399,
-0.01626271940767765,
-0.20195770263671875,
0.08500681817531586,
-0.3093232214450836,
-0.16091743111610413,
-0.29154545068740845,
0.15218940377235413,
0.21763743460178375
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09832v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09832v1
|
Scaling Behavior of Machine Translation with Large Language Models under Prompt Injection Attacks
| 2024-03-14T19:39:10 | 2024-03-14T19:39:10 |
Zhifan Sun, Antonio Valerio Miceli-Barone
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are increasingly becoming the preferred
foundation platforms for many Natural Language Processing tasks such as Machine
Translation, owing to their quality often comparable to or better than
task-specific models, and the simplicity of specifying the task through natural
language instructions or in-context examples. Their generality, however, opens
them up to subversion by end users who may embed into their requests
instructions that cause the model to behave in unauthorized and possibly unsafe
ways. In this work we study these Prompt Injection Attacks (PIAs) on multiple
families of LLMs on a Machine Translation task, focusing on the effects of
model size on the attack success rates. We introduce a new benchmark data set
and we discover that on multiple language pairs and injected prompts written in
English, larger models under certain conditions may become more susceptible to
successful attacks, an instance of the Inverse Scaling phenomenon (McKenzie et
al., 2023). To our knowledge, this is the first work to study non-trivial LLM
scaling behaviour in a multi-lingual setting.
|
[
-0.14610570669174194,
-0.9603830575942993,
0.5576370358467102,
0.4976418912410736,
-0.062299516052007675,
-0.3616839647293091,
-0.13726072013378143,
-0.3998025059700012,
0.012835046276450157,
0.8055381774902344,
-0.5188880562782288,
-0.16974098980426788,
-1.00016450881958,
0.382093220949173,
-0.4802332818508148,
0.8658298254013062,
-0.02641231007874012,
0.3650820255279541,
0.01654832996428013,
-0.187140092253685,
-0.571091890335083,
-0.8065222501754761,
-0.6272817850112915,
-0.05997582525014877,
0.4258118271827698,
0.29129758477211,
0.7561852931976318,
0.6190624833106995,
0.7526991963386536,
0.3138192892074585,
-0.039663203060626984,
-0.22877539694309235,
-0.408740758895874,
0.4321935176849365,
-0.0960828885436058,
-0.5819833278656006,
-0.6095645427703857,
-0.11019019782543182,
0.9468685388565063,
0.8236672878265381,
0.1365978717803955,
0.06734149158000946,
0.20154426991939545,
0.5343184471130371,
-0.45032891631126404,
-0.17730817198753357,
-0.6910562515258789,
-0.1031690388917923,
-0.07065379619598389,
-0.026626581326127052,
-0.9917334914207458,
-0.003301392076537013,
-0.10358524322509766,
-0.47153058648109436,
-0.09587317705154419,
0.21833421289920807,
0.577182948589325,
0.1857539564371109,
-0.7179386615753174,
-0.3467544615268707,
-0.31478047370910645,
0.7559317350387573,
-0.706793487071991,
0.2963959872722626,
0.010275238193571568,
0.2811843454837799,
-0.6373676061630249,
-0.6336175799369812,
-0.34945356845855713,
-0.3289794325828552,
-0.21580584347248077,
-0.42516934871673584,
-0.6813691258430481,
0.1303412914276123,
0.4777196943759918,
0.12977227568626404,
-0.6394153237342834,
0.6548840999603271,
-0.039708759635686874,
-0.15401838719844818,
0.2919057309627533,
0.3805050551891327,
0.6183639764785767,
-0.40603524446487427,
-0.5362849235534668,
-0.058087561279535294,
-1.036512017250061,
-0.07057926803827286,
0.4175419807434082,
0.6605411767959595,
-0.2850568890571594,
0.706829309463501,
-0.1716899573802948,
0.8363239765167236,
0.06797142326831818,
-0.09071997553110123,
0.07749882340431213,
-0.5520621538162231,
-0.2785317897796631,
-0.1228371113538742,
1.1119953393936157,
0.42838254570961,
0.3619350492954254,
0.04818802699446678,
-0.22292937338352203,
-0.472298264503479,
0.23459239304065704,
-1.1131939888000488,
0.1611010879278183,
0.10751927644014359,
-0.3654670715332031,
-0.3398912250995636,
-0.06896278262138367,
-0.6091804504394531,
-0.6313484311103821,
0.13504523038864136,
0.5288495421409607,
-0.3118251860141754,
-0.15852569043636322,
0.026533218100667,
0.048753008246421814,
0.4605606198310852,
0.08602412790060043,
-0.7438012361526489,
0.297781765460968,
0.6069324016571045,
1.0034918785095215,
-0.24080482125282288,
-0.4209187626838684,
-0.9454607367515564,
0.024515675380825996,
-0.3593534827232361,
0.4281007647514343,
-0.31305432319641113,
-0.5329916477203369,
0.04328050836920738,
0.2706841230392456,
-0.12737692892551422,
-0.46883559226989746,
0.4399729371070862,
-0.7396159172058105,
0.017100227996706963,
-0.3146930932998657,
-0.465833455324173,
0.09026279300451279,
0.4207300543785095,
-0.5598523616790771,
0.4968465268611908,
-0.1993357241153717,
-0.7392211556434631,
0.13917957246303558,
-0.5307612419128418,
-0.5602021217346191,
-0.060413770377635956,
0.05576123297214508,
-0.2514920234680176,
0.2294207066297531,
0.28743696212768555,
0.648953378200531,
-0.4863353669643402,
0.11668284237384796,
-0.2977701425552368,
-0.045643460005521774,
0.48728498816490173,
-0.7189930081367493,
1.0851712226867676,
0.005613615736365318,
-0.1879645735025406,
0.18267709016799927,
-0.47325924038887024,
-0.08103841543197632,
0.2452418953180313,
-0.11169898509979248,
-0.4122062921524048,
-0.3052874505519867,
-0.22303186357021332,
0.21212109923362732,
0.3484802544116974,
-0.45496106147766113,
0.6207541823387146,
-0.5027472376823425,
0.5115407109260559,
0.7013295292854309,
0.6250821352005005,
0.48257625102996826,
0.044447578489780426,
0.6985558867454529,
-0.04948392137885094,
0.4055839776992798,
-0.4558696448802948,
-0.7505919933319092,
-0.42806050181388855,
-0.49399638175964355,
0.10119573026895523,
0.6046888828277588,
-0.5134210586547852,
0.09732526540756226,
-0.47471940517425537,
-0.4726370573043823,
-0.18946494162082672,
0.14441359043121338,
0.48483461141586304,
0.5613459944725037,
0.3072461187839508,
0.008114878088235855,
-0.08091424405574799,
-1.298017978668213,
-0.46149685978889465,
-0.24498271942138672,
-0.44921383261680603,
0.23453426361083984,
0.5498027205467224,
-0.2908584177494049,
0.6145716309547424,
-0.48495718836784363,
-0.19938798248767853,
-0.23238879442214966,
0.24660737812519073,
0.5310888290405273,
0.6095907688140869,
0.6114544868469238,
-0.8044717311859131,
-0.6186031699180603,
-0.03508175536990166,
-0.4786098301410675,
-0.4339343011379242,
-0.3336261510848999,
-0.0013369583757594228,
0.21137352287769318,
0.6060410737991333,
-0.5642003417015076,
0.14981530606746674,
0.8166272640228271,
-0.25010088086128235,
0.6066516637802124,
-0.3704071640968323,
0.33179259300231934,
-1.2617645263671875,
-0.012669016607105732,
-0.08888143301010132,
-0.08388667553663254,
-1.036582589149475,
0.4695744514465332,
0.4838401675224304,
-0.07618705928325653,
-0.8224959373474121,
0.49439749121665955,
-0.4707273840904236,
-0.14860385656356812,
-0.21108128130435944,
-0.07481594383716583,
0.09591762721538544,
0.29714179039001465,
-0.30225399136543274,
1.0081565380096436,
0.7133381366729736,
-0.5896130204200745,
0.17725153267383575,
-0.12389401346445084,
-0.08544889837503433,
0.6150205135345459,
-0.9304887652397156,
0.10268650203943253,
0.19500362873077393,
0.32260483503341675,
-1.1351933479309082,
-0.3335156738758087,
0.31294724345207214,
-0.5301270484924316,
0.5165717005729675,
-0.3462294340133667,
-0.7289602756500244,
-0.047725703567266464,
-0.3484952449798584,
0.4042796492576599,
0.4159596562385559,
-0.4932776391506195,
0.5696243047714233,
0.037704821676015854,
-0.13677404820919037,
-0.6099214553833008,
-0.7387784719467163,
0.3470345139503479,
-0.3093269169330597,
-0.822593092918396,
0.09196721762418747,
-0.030191024765372276,
-0.44595056772232056,
-0.41917410492897034,
0.2642090916633606,
-0.18061283230781555,
0.34224066138267517,
0.32350748777389526,
0.2680099308490753,
-0.13921470940113068,
-0.0847335010766983,
0.1751076728105545,
0.02817281149327755,
0.2989807426929474,
-0.20289617776870728,
0.5972254276275635,
-0.05524677038192749,
-0.6116941571235657,
-0.5733996629714966,
0.5145204663276672,
1.075840950012207,
-0.0799354538321495,
1.2532033920288086,
0.07316018640995026,
-0.27251389622688293,
0.17073267698287964,
-0.3584321439266205,
-0.2309015393257141,
-0.4729011356830597,
0.5272899270057678,
-0.7280668020248413,
-0.6016014218330383,
0.7408081889152527,
-0.042247556149959564,
0.13163363933563232,
0.5900858044624329,
0.5382806062698364,
0.01178499311208725,
1.4171122312545776,
0.598800778388977,
-0.14773701131343842,
0.31358757615089417,
-0.043923817574977875,
0.041104063391685486,
-0.9082719087600708,
0.06664735078811646,
-0.722897469997406,
-0.2261015623807907,
-0.6936240196228027,
-0.5104188919067383,
0.6060525178909302,
0.16701781749725342,
-0.2713349461555481,
0.49304428696632385,
-0.017100157216191292,
0.453117311000824,
0.3742690980434418,
-0.203433558344841,
0.377534419298172,
-0.18989308178424835,
-0.206093430519104,
-0.12117040902376175,
-0.5272786617279053,
-0.4185926616191864,
1.1796770095825195,
0.3535439670085907,
0.5379628539085388,
0.41391897201538086,
0.43609902262687683,
0.2950877845287323,
0.2853616774082184,
-0.7161479592323303,
0.5365291237831116,
-0.023211315274238586,
-0.5083472728729248,
-0.261114239692688,
-0.5447168946266174,
-1.0506936311721802,
0.43089503049850464,
-0.022651029750704765,
-0.5986800193786621,
0.11746620386838913,
0.018934492021799088,
-0.09863672405481339,
0.3027558922767639,
-0.9262922406196594,
0.8648325204849243,
-0.24792639911174774,
-0.11566324532032013,
-0.25269410014152527,
-0.6955708861351013,
0.4037187099456787,
-0.5354189276695251,
0.36494964361190796,
0.17102909088134766,
-0.34697550535202026,
0.4520225524902344,
-0.285209983587265,
1.0164427757263184,
-0.10292324423789978,
-0.3456527590751648,
-0.1334000676870346,
0.44255155324935913,
0.9454264640808105,
0.10307169705629349,
-0.08848222345113754,
0.4938657283782959,
-0.28399142622947693,
-0.6583755612373352,
-0.6168838143348694,
0.7938088774681091,
-0.6092607975006104,
-0.982816755771637,
-0.23955391347408295,
-0.5528231859207153,
-0.14724603295326233,
0.35963910818099976,
0.4394395649433136,
0.31297290325164795,
-0.06738721579313278,
0.18964359164237976,
0.7182005047798157,
-0.5252941846847534,
0.30603718757629395,
0.8227808475494385,
-0.2635321319103241,
-0.3381156027317047,
0.6505900621414185,
0.2614861726760864,
0.9395242929458618,
0.40626662969589233,
0.0977223739027977,
0.09091681987047195,
-0.7704636454582214,
-0.8178425431251526,
0.3654117286205292,
-0.5099303126335144,
-0.30105772614479065,
-0.698040246963501,
-0.00033289927523583174,
-0.6638657450675964,
-0.18765749037265778,
-0.3278723657131195,
-0.48310235142707825,
-0.12238683551549911,
0.04635068401694298,
0.11242546141147614,
0.6029492616653442,
0.19657473266124725,
0.5078305602073669,
-0.7978871464729309,
0.09762197732925415,
0.15532276034355164,
0.005430059507489204,
-0.19232895970344543,
-1.0433871746063232,
-0.07259886711835861,
-0.002570181852206588,
-0.10214047878980637,
-1.2863035202026367,
0.5153458118438721,
-0.017964044585824013,
0.2908983826637268,
0.5043141841888428,
0.14785417914390564,
0.3461796045303345,
-0.8403676152229309,
0.8697402477264404,
0.18070170283317566,
-0.8421825766563416,
0.42178618907928467,
-0.4382874369621277,
0.6469459533691406,
0.1793137788772583,
0.5811073780059814,
-0.7831148505210876,
-0.535230815410614,
-0.23594282567501068,
-0.8307380676269531,
0.5404936075210571,
0.04920953884720802,
0.4303527772426605,
-0.019407475367188454,
0.3592311143875122,
0.13374489545822144,
0.05373594909906387,
-0.7150003910064697,
-0.33456045389175415,
0.23278886079788208,
0.19964328408241272,
-0.010768541134893894,
-0.4333139955997467,
0.05324719101190567,
0.13615891337394714,
0.5902969837188721,
-0.06425443291664124,
-0.032658375799655914,
-0.11791268736124039,
-0.26402637362480164,
-0.06818749755620956,
0.4456181526184082,
0.6794496774673462,
0.2852788269519806,
0.157243013381958,
0.16703076660633087,
0.27876266837120056,
-0.4185613691806793,
0.25697046518325806,
-0.03310985490679741,
-0.2998882830142975,
-0.33148661255836487,
0.6769965887069702,
0.6327839493751526,
0.37128588557243347,
-0.757414698600769,
0.5898205041885376,
-0.16696612536907196,
0.12242963910102844,
-0.1121576651930809,
-0.21012049913406372,
-0.15665040910243988,
0.1039285957813263,
0.3757070004940033,
-0.045651938766241074,
0.0908900797367096,
-0.26510512828826904,
-0.08809773623943329,
0.5694981813430786,
-0.3072516918182373,
-0.3530236482620239,
0.33277812600135803,
0.09751509130001068,
-0.36398133635520935,
0.7485203146934509,
0.061934325844049454,
-0.6532016396522522,
0.5030881762504578,
0.6338004469871521,
0.8956761360168457,
-0.46601730585098267,
-0.07242807000875473,
0.37268373370170593,
0.8334208130836487,
0.18277591466903687,
-0.2533072531223297,
0.23598438501358032,
-0.4841148257255554,
-0.5463294386863708,
-0.44253355264663696,
-0.44742676615715027,
0.07016889750957489,
-0.5763317346572876,
0.23411254584789276,
-0.268044114112854,
-0.16223712265491486,
-0.20919865369796753,
-0.3302891254425049,
-0.33387699723243713,
-0.40116143226623535,
-0.06991086900234222,
0.9772183895111084,
-1.0631725788116455,
0.7808673977851868,
0.6210164427757263,
-0.3101981282234192,
-0.5247097015380859,
0.008326822891831398,
0.1952829360961914,
-0.7047637701034546,
0.9470586180686951,
0.2258085310459137,
-0.014542335644364357,
-0.10839353501796722,
-0.2618778944015503,
-1.0486130714416504,
0.5990425944328308,
0.6498880386352539,
-0.4665188789367676,
0.02126295119524002,
0.4508543312549591,
0.4276566207408905,
-0.26628026366233826,
-0.058826953172683716,
0.39147838950157166,
0.4567217528820038,
-0.35126379132270813,
-1.093226671218872,
0.16004592180252075,
0.008141442202031612,
-0.15410298109054565,
0.5227532386779785,
-0.4958280920982361,
0.9441431760787964,
-0.2068004310131073,
-0.10620225965976715,
0.010160049423575401,
0.554396390914917,
0.028724689036607742,
-0.11764950305223465,
0.5778072476387024,
0.35182321071624756,
0.5450718998908997,
0.23546135425567627,
1.412995457649231,
-0.269085168838501,
-0.12445694953203201,
1.2118899822235107,
-0.2804390788078308,
0.9236835837364197,
0.8038613796234131,
0.02077159844338894,
0.3117928206920624,
0.34200942516326904,
0.25979599356651306,
0.12297845631837845,
0.16506130993366241,
-0.05986510589718819,
-0.0926872193813324,
-0.24524186551570892,
-0.38044849038124084,
0.13702106475830078,
0.3884851634502411,
-0.5869612693786621,
-0.0034288621973246336,
0.36191651225090027,
0.3363535702228546,
-0.09062938392162323,
-0.2748127281665802,
0.6807963252067566,
0.0443439856171608,
-0.5032908320426941,
0.6033021807670593,
0.24337971210479736,
0.5353728532791138,
-0.7277828454971313,
0.16683389246463776,
-0.34291407465934753,
-0.030050339177250862,
0.09056162089109421,
-0.6538451313972473,
0.09672464430332184,
0.2553776204586029,
-0.4615738093852997,
-0.46067938208580017,
0.32593777775764465,
-0.05717075988650322,
-0.40594154596328735,
0.4438937306404114,
0.22985690832138062,
0.18944677710533142,
-0.25015789270401,
-0.5333710312843323,
0.16649943590164185,
-0.11757341772317886,
-0.6659440994262695,
0.7008776068687439,
0.32663866877555847,
-0.2823677957057953,
0.8512420058250427,
0.5472491979598999,
0.3099217414855957,
0.419376403093338,
0.0057858750224113464,
0.7680001258850098,
-0.15539439022541046,
-0.19543635845184326,
-1.217500925064087,
0.20471151173114777,
-0.18290016055107117,
-0.09390811622142792,
1.2645035982131958,
0.43819689750671387,
0.6241155862808228,
0.00980423204600811,
0.31030625104904175,
0.18548205494880676,
0.11512158066034317,
-0.42031267285346985,
0.6452784538269043,
-0.3841301202774048,
0.4146135151386261,
-0.26793181896209717,
-0.8514901399612427,
-0.3823625445365906,
-0.07494260370731354,
-0.38942083716392517,
-0.2727155387401581,
0.6585274934768677,
0.8683161735534668,
0.1910218894481659,
-0.2174742966890335,
0.40858083963394165,
0.6926267147064209,
0.6319827437400818,
0.39280426502227783,
0.47491154074668884,
-0.2940366268157959,
0.6881603002548218,
-0.08121906965970993,
-0.39130446314811707,
-0.21872779726982117,
-0.895150899887085,
-0.7995044589042664,
-0.4581792652606964,
-0.12693001329898834,
-0.28142544627189636,
-0.08158055692911148,
0.7743089199066162,
0.4128200113773346,
-0.8285648822784424,
-0.15240325033664703,
0.014663380570709705,
0.12636539340019226,
-0.1818438619375229,
-0.1863020956516266,
0.35585424304008484,
-0.354025661945343,
-0.8144426345825195,
0.6193902492523193,
0.30965977907180786,
0.14885680377483368,
-0.560072660446167,
-0.10659512877464294,
-0.17302894592285156,
0.2442842274904251,
0.36630532145500183,
0.1893651932477951,
-0.7177540063858032,
-0.25460150837898254,
0.14922872185707092,
-0.33803805708885193,
-0.2282024323940277,
0.8827794194221497,
-0.5704930424690247,
0.5166075229644775,
0.5647734999656677,
0.8096638321876526,
0.011450110003352165,
-0.2631358206272125,
0.8106949329376221,
-0.8638476133346558,
0.22045473754405975,
-0.01143648661673069,
0.47190725803375244,
0.2658374011516571,
-0.4288575351238251,
0.2270078808069229,
0.08071278035640717,
-0.4594683051109314,
-1.2388635873794556,
0.5206397771835327,
-0.5781182646751404,
-0.40370333194732666,
1.1694486141204834,
-0.33925801515579224,
-0.2610090970993042,
0.10561393946409225,
-0.1329137086868286,
-0.09814360737800598,
-0.24638031423091888,
0.3235950171947479,
0.8018482327461243,
-0.050128526985645294,
0.2447681725025177,
-0.7146376371383667,
0.01815473660826683,
0.609519362449646,
-0.5406705141067505,
0.4311631917953491,
0.5690778493881226,
0.09687823057174683,
0.11012546718120575,
0.2123211771249771,
-0.08107046782970428,
0.14765116572380066,
-0.14323651790618896,
-0.21258874237537384,
0.02206668071448803,
-0.294036865234375,
-0.7257306575775146,
0.4909477233886719,
0.26514363288879395,
0.06328293681144714
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09795v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09795v1
|
Helpful or Harmful? Exploring the Efficacy of Large Language Models for Online Grooming Prevention
| 2024-03-14T18:27:43 | 2024-03-14T18:27:43 |
Ellie Prosser, Matthew Edwards
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Powerful generative Large Language Models (LLMs) are becoming popular tools
amongst the general public as question-answering systems, and are being
utilised by vulnerable groups such as children. With children increasingly
interacting with these tools, it is imperative for researchers to scrutinise
the safety of LLMs, especially for applications that could lead to serious
outcomes, such as online child safety queries. In this paper, the efficacy of
LLMs for online grooming prevention is explored both for identifying and
avoiding grooming through advice generation, and the impact of prompt design on
model performance is investigated by varying the provided context and prompt
specificity. In results reflecting over 6,000 LLM interactions, we find that no
models were clearly appropriate for online grooming prevention, with an
observed lack of consistency in behaviours, and potential for harmful answer
generation, especially from open-source models. We outline where and how models
fall short, providing suggestions for improvement, and identify prompt designs
that heavily altered model performance in troubling ways, with findings that
can be used to inform best practice usage guides.
|
[
-0.24502384662628174,
-1.0198684930801392,
0.6474278569221497,
0.3251635432243347,
-0.46392834186553955,
-0.38573122024536133,
0.18125198781490326,
-0.7457460761070251,
-0.09852634370326996,
0.45155179500579834,
-0.45642420649528503,
-0.22668574750423431,
-0.4548642039299011,
0.3263252079486847,
-0.5711526274681091,
0.6041175127029419,
0.08591143786907196,
0.15204942226409912,
-0.47520384192466736,
0.44208866357803345,
-0.7693970203399658,
-0.5857773423194885,
-0.970953106880188,
0.1496647447347641,
0.7102301716804504,
0.17325666546821594,
0.5081371665000916,
0.49876144528388977,
0.6875994205474854,
0.22482043504714966,
-0.37399062514305115,
0.18449875712394714,
-0.5783568620681763,
0.48000138998031616,
-0.2625490725040436,
-0.5492844581604004,
-0.5352792143821716,
-0.1692502349615097,
0.152764692902565,
0.5902704000473022,
-0.4711538553237915,
-0.11014922708272934,
0.3432406783103943,
0.3217986524105072,
-0.6695197224617004,
-0.23714397847652435,
-0.6154748797416687,
-0.07609204202890396,
-0.1032850369811058,
-0.18366387486457825,
-0.6174204349517822,
-0.43372347950935364,
0.05785959213972092,
-0.5111144781112671,
-0.12603513896465302,
-0.20001016557216644,
0.434232622385025,
0.08601468056440353,
-0.39941927790641785,
-0.6064468622207642,
-0.8002261519432068,
0.6916300058364868,
-0.9091195464134216,
0.10759700834751129,
0.8263556361198425,
0.1905519962310791,
-0.32595476508140564,
-0.5267355442047119,
-0.20407773554325104,
-0.1322794109582901,
-0.1721520721912384,
-0.10972525179386139,
-0.5290379524230957,
0.20682792365550995,
0.4460495114326477,
-0.1351357251405716,
-0.404337078332901,
0.43355870246887207,
-0.11319012194871902,
-0.06982379406690598,
0.599052369594574,
0.38639113306999207,
0.4649900794029236,
-0.1513994038105011,
-0.22942273318767548,
0.06000612676143646,
-1.1725103855133057,
0.42710554599761963,
0.35198450088500977,
0.4366203844547272,
-0.09944965690374374,
0.47826728224754333,
0.1920146942138672,
0.6327705383300781,
0.2010589987039566,
-0.47429442405700684,
-0.38159677386283875,
-0.2846476137638092,
0.07753737270832062,
-0.16052711009979248,
0.5927718281745911,
0.8959059715270996,
0.3756124675273895,
-0.04694409295916557,
-0.2678542733192444,
-0.16911347210407257,
0.4811888039112091,
-1.0911387205123901,
0.2580071985721588,
0.14699514210224152,
-0.42987358570098877,
-0.4530213475227356,
0.0849011018872261,
-0.7444865107536316,
-0.640418529510498,
0.1854163557291031,
0.10297906398773193,
-0.13369014859199524,
-0.3830142319202423,
0.12164253741502762,
-0.13614650070667267,
0.3180330991744995,
0.385257363319397,
-0.8802746534347534,
0.23364059627056122,
0.5916382670402527,
0.6686627268791199,
-0.1540042906999588,
0.273752897977829,
-0.5043937563896179,
0.13629044592380524,
-0.5023177862167358,
0.48473578691482544,
-0.5668041706085205,
-0.9513429999351501,
0.3835914731025696,
0.14317446947097778,
0.07704885303974152,
-0.5463708639144897,
0.8005470633506775,
-0.4606305658817291,
0.10948120057582855,
-0.3794991374015808,
-0.4780179262161255,
0.015282290056347847,
0.12613961100578308,
-0.5001229643821716,
0.6181139945983887,
-0.28779876232147217,
-0.8704766035079956,
0.28331032395362854,
-0.3351835012435913,
-0.5860796570777893,
0.05088791623711586,
0.10937406867742538,
-0.5173802375793457,
0.2004382610321045,
0.30496087670326233,
0.5916970372200012,
-0.29837390780448914,
0.4829685688018799,
-0.49857956171035767,
-0.2733219563961029,
0.42344558238983154,
-0.5243842005729675,
0.872782826423645,
0.1695908010005951,
-0.2904092073440552,
0.30128854513168335,
-0.3338579535484314,
-0.07996868342161179,
0.40202468633651733,
-0.08437861502170563,
-0.6008851528167725,
-0.0702582597732544,
-0.16136610507965088,
0.48047035932540894,
0.022587314248085022,
-0.4266854524612427,
-0.03242236375808716,
-0.2512456178665161,
0.4805006682872772,
0.7544542551040649,
0.3101182281970978,
-0.15954044461250305,
-0.7276641726493835,
0.7521862387657166,
-0.34481093287467957,
0.4157233238220215,
-0.3742557764053345,
-0.7444354295730591,
-0.4251340329647064,
-0.058958228677511215,
-0.06847164779901505,
0.3537486493587494,
-0.8010348081588745,
0.36533406376838684,
0.1911243200302124,
-0.5713043212890625,
-0.09144334495067596,
0.11631783097982407,
0.6686039566993713,
0.3356688320636749,
0.02509927935898304,
-0.1024458184838295,
-0.24343962967395782,
-0.9091179370880127,
-0.47682154178619385,
-0.20397871732711792,
-0.21568964421749115,
0.4689592719078064,
0.2717517018318176,
-0.05678315460681915,
0.7423663139343262,
-0.28215864300727844,
0.15473370254039764,
-0.23486900329589844,
-0.24426685273647308,
-0.07415439933538437,
0.3055279552936554,
0.8321167826652527,
-0.6824876666069031,
-0.3864233195781708,
-0.6279189586639404,
-0.7401852607727051,
-0.24867501854896545,
-0.053566914051771164,
0.08505713194608688,
-0.099973164498806,
0.4976012110710144,
-0.6264791488647461,
0.33411112427711487,
0.29718440771102905,
-0.24462153017520905,
0.6320274472236633,
-0.09453381597995758,
-0.009303756058216095,
-0.9345316290855408,
0.147293820977211,
0.264538049697876,
-0.22047936916351318,
-0.9891442656517029,
0.3159233629703522,
0.0708167776465416,
-0.06605606526136398,
-0.8812956809997559,
0.49206167459487915,
-0.10984427481889725,
0.5142037272453308,
-0.2421661913394928,
0.17971694469451904,
0.00940541923046112,
0.03376896679401398,
-0.10770374536514282,
1.1183041334152222,
0.45186224579811096,
-0.7885106801986694,
0.06697768718004227,
0.27666330337524414,
-0.19646140933036804,
0.6265560984611511,
-1.0302807092666626,
0.4072793424129486,
0.09068524837493896,
-0.0110075818374753,
-0.8181208968162537,
-0.4125698506832123,
0.22886906564235687,
-0.21937672793865204,
0.22947265207767487,
-0.09434465318918228,
-0.42177435755729675,
-0.38912874460220337,
-0.6469120979309082,
0.3832423686981201,
0.4505155086517334,
-0.5498022437095642,
0.23606041073799133,
0.5839041471481323,
-0.6147816181182861,
-0.3112064003944397,
-0.36664652824401855,
0.14726851880550385,
-0.6975826621055603,
-0.844619870185852,
0.09158523380756378,
-0.1386813521385193,
-0.5931243896484375,
-0.2845132052898407,
-0.032354261726140976,
0.013158909976482391,
0.6672772169113159,
0.3095758855342865,
0.3306143581867218,
0.13891127705574036,
0.18418560922145844,
-0.09688456356525421,
0.19021475315093994,
0.4437975287437439,
0.3813020884990692,
0.4701644778251648,
0.09909752756357193,
-0.5240347385406494,
-0.4455113112926483,
0.585202693939209,
0.3116990625858307,
-0.03926690295338631,
0.8898616433143616,
0.09743483364582062,
-0.45105433464050293,
-0.3421633541584015,
-0.4178110957145691,
-0.3109642267227173,
-0.5719443559646606,
0.13584257662296295,
0.047539833933115005,
-0.8934012055397034,
0.27066585421562195,
-0.047972314059734344,
-0.009896411560475826,
0.16666342318058014,
0.21803978085517883,
-0.23516544699668884,
1.3539056777954102,
0.7557554841041565,
0.2141347974538803,
0.6117803454399109,
0.14436230063438416,
0.18559730052947998,
-0.6310717463493347,
-0.3771895170211792,
-0.4877564013004303,
0.2292500138282776,
-0.6196041703224182,
-0.06975765526294708,
0.4190692603588104,
0.3785282075405121,
-0.1449865698814392,
0.16740305721759796,
-0.3632980287075043,
0.3334972858428955,
0.36375775933265686,
0.19459518790245056,
0.17996177077293396,
0.05948278680443764,
-0.15607932209968567,
-0.08381599932909012,
-0.7812179327011108,
-0.7148981690406799,
0.9219689965248108,
0.37743493914604187,
1.1054036617279053,
0.2838907539844513,
0.22451567649841309,
0.3672822415828705,
0.2221301794052124,
-0.6988076567649841,
0.657978892326355,
0.03591896593570709,
-0.652208149433136,
-0.12510398030281067,
-0.40730324387550354,
-1.1255035400390625,
0.11764875054359436,
-0.14316421747207642,
-0.887833297252655,
-0.0484791062772274,
0.18556730449199677,
-0.4113880395889282,
0.30966538190841675,
-0.5779465436935425,
0.4816848039627075,
-0.5101297497749329,
-0.787401556968689,
-0.07913222908973694,
-0.5816314816474915,
0.544735848903656,
-0.33047863841056824,
0.3269402086734772,
0.06508195400238037,
0.05435260757803917,
0.9887171983718872,
-0.3286338448524475,
1.1665735244750977,
-0.1663576364517212,
-0.3862059414386749,
0.3966785967350006,
0.09907805174589157,
0.7807338237762451,
-0.270489364862442,
-0.12391076982021332,
-0.02545793168246746,
-0.07872401922941208,
-0.1364431530237198,
-0.3170633912086487,
0.7098643779754639,
-0.49837982654571533,
-1.3091919422149658,
-0.16650651395320892,
-0.1991831660270691,
-0.4213723838329315,
0.29500195384025574,
-0.026235617697238922,
0.59385085105896,
-0.13661238551139832,
0.3637135624885559,
0.7681898474693298,
-0.640274167060852,
0.47505825757980347,
0.39286884665489197,
-0.4554192125797272,
-0.37574702501296997,
0.7184460163116455,
-0.13739296793937683,
0.565679132938385,
-0.06609239429235458,
0.5168460011482239,
-0.5006993412971497,
-0.653378427028656,
-0.36591947078704834,
0.28064876794815063,
-0.9155853390693665,
-0.2455485761165619,
-0.3813134431838989,
-0.15716899931430817,
-0.5392302870750427,
-0.21123844385147095,
0.21243688464164734,
-0.22410191595554352,
-0.3181134760379791,
-0.24815258383750916,
0.3952479064464569,
1.242534875869751,
0.25197041034698486,
0.3855990469455719,
-0.8451154828071594,
-0.06333789229393005,
0.41866233944892883,
0.35401207208633423,
0.06966143846511841,
-0.21514135599136353,
0.03282909467816353,
-0.06984220445156097,
-0.3977218270301819,
-0.9201779365539551,
0.31513693928718567,
-0.1071460098028183,
0.8430918455123901,
0.9237397313117981,
0.37346571683883667,
0.3771095275878906,
-0.25779566168785095,
0.8453727960586548,
0.31531769037246704,
-0.4495348334312439,
0.39890605211257935,
-0.6947087645530701,
0.10560951381921768,
0.23942677676677704,
0.7036779522895813,
-0.7401202321052551,
-0.3469862937927246,
-0.4087286591529846,
-0.7409576773643494,
0.6035466194152832,
0.12573762238025665,
0.24451790750026703,
-0.1538437008857727,
0.14669260382652283,
0.295316219329834,
0.42367294430732727,
-0.5782358050346375,
-0.23730723559856415,
-0.009397841989994049,
0.16563384234905243,
0.27739250659942627,
-0.7088320255279541,
-0.19594250619411469,
0.08918704837560654,
0.665189802646637,
0.24935705959796906,
0.07958097010850906,
-0.1369306892156601,
0.019329728558659554,
-0.351004034280777,
0.3458935618400574,
0.727374792098999,
0.7087678909301758,
-0.014646713621914387,
0.11711959540843964,
0.09602188318967819,
-0.26862671971321106,
0.16461466252803802,
-0.19356220960617065,
-0.5278987288475037,
-0.28036218881607056,
0.5027061104774475,
0.6190121173858643,
0.21361245214939117,
-0.6819565892219543,
0.6746634840965271,
-0.20605097711086273,
-0.0014858036302030087,
-0.15906499326229095,
0.25718384981155396,
0.33232834935188293,
-0.27854689955711365,
0.1503697782754898,
-0.16099610924720764,
-0.011017958633601665,
-0.42476552724838257,
0.02660180814564228,
0.8237404823303223,
-0.2564209997653961,
-0.20177406072616577,
0.6004924178123474,
0.5345665216445923,
-0.6872475743293762,
0.268001914024353,
-0.029812946915626526,
-0.508330225944519,
0.5480676889419556,
0.7057275176048279,
0.7363533973693848,
-0.4531557559967041,
0.09630704671144485,
0.40770280361175537,
0.22469989955425262,
0.11543204635381699,
0.12089473754167557,
0.12851789593696594,
-0.48116153478622437,
-0.1018398106098175,
-0.47558578848838806,
-0.38469189405441284,
0.46206605434417725,
-0.6190102100372314,
0.26840126514434814,
-0.5667725205421448,
-0.3676913380622864,
-0.20058400928974152,
-0.49153026938438416,
-0.5261754393577576,
-0.08464035391807556,
0.08737918734550476,
0.8680041432380676,
-0.8717015981674194,
0.40116387605667114,
0.4045669436454773,
-0.41770538687705994,
-0.8400355577468872,
0.22900404036045074,
0.21488834917545319,
-0.6694366931915283,
0.31684964895248413,
0.35148414969444275,
-0.5034728050231934,
-0.4041900038719177,
-0.5757226347923279,
-0.8265228867530823,
0.6444937586784363,
0.3729548752307892,
-0.7166682481765747,
-0.31874388456344604,
0.29130491614341736,
0.40309447050094604,
0.017185315489768982,
0.27900266647338867,
0.33606740832328796,
0.3630083501338959,
0.18325930833816528,
-0.9951424598693848,
0.35529598593711853,
-0.36645370721817017,
0.021976202726364136,
0.11532840132713318,
-0.30612170696258545,
0.5224898457527161,
-0.2847785949707031,
-0.5443649888038635,
0.41883385181427,
-0.0982799306511879,
0.21129782497882843,
0.03406592085957527,
0.48915529251098633,
0.24012315273284912,
0.6620059013366699,
0.046313248574733734,
1.2161399126052856,
-0.21959254145622253,
-0.15502211451530457,
0.8658792972564697,
-0.2455967515707016,
0.7036253213882446,
0.4508567750453949,
-0.19922950863838196,
0.10594093799591064,
0.475410521030426,
0.13772284984588623,
0.5558919310569763,
0.29166412353515625,
-0.33358296751976013,
-0.5074669718742371,
-0.5499905347824097,
-0.47058072686195374,
0.17691980302333832,
0.5032171010971069,
-0.4379911720752716,
-0.26523420214653015,
0.1867009550333023,
0.26297178864479065,
-0.0006607553805224597,
-0.3880547285079956,
1.0123553276062012,
0.32350677251815796,
-0.6728865504264832,
0.5627800226211548,
-0.04549418389797211,
0.6813517808914185,
-0.5753940939903259,
-0.2889304459095001,
-0.15255090594291687,
0.0601583756506443,
-0.22074666619300842,
-0.7535811066627502,
0.08772532641887665,
0.36109215021133423,
0.21480602025985718,
-0.31665971875190735,
1.1153106689453125,
-0.034713614732027054,
-0.4709151089191437,
0.3463054597377777,
0.7457228302955627,
0.1217840313911438,
0.19547344744205475,
-0.502344012260437,
-0.2030263990163803,
-0.2908093333244324,
-0.2601681053638458,
0.47874724864959717,
0.14925721287727356,
-0.3379753828048706,
1.0107336044311523,
0.7603442668914795,
0.06374858319759369,
0.07120468467473984,
-0.018604326993227005,
1.0082050561904907,
-0.47448527812957764,
-0.425606369972229,
-0.9552488923072815,
0.3783889412879944,
-0.1454647034406662,
-0.12706489861011505,
1.1360276937484741,
0.18144221603870392,
0.8930937647819519,
0.10868549346923828,
0.6668261885643005,
0.20347562432289124,
0.4593360126018524,
-0.39810600876808167,
0.7954223155975342,
-0.43298718333244324,
0.5341707468032837,
-0.33834734559059143,
-0.583655059337616,
-0.3529253900051117,
0.44819632172584534,
-0.5828444957733154,
0.2287917286157608,
0.5630233287811279,
0.9322292804718018,
0.29089194536209106,
0.24302293360233307,
0.6125503778457642,
0.07442238181829453,
0.704258918762207,
0.0930483490228653,
1.2811496257781982,
0.37729695439338684,
0.4734555184841156,
-0.38971036672592163,
0.058173563331365585,
-0.3577077090740204,
-1.0401396751403809,
-1.1045031547546387,
-0.16822421550750732,
0.11372913420200348,
-0.26200905442237854,
0.3131796419620514,
1.0380738973617554,
0.5351091623306274,
-0.732173502445221,
-0.08252033591270447,
-0.061073314398527145,
-0.08037998527288437,
0.03075339086353779,
-0.14604602754116058,
0.17143206298351288,
0.02491430751979351,
-0.24610914289951324,
0.6006100177764893,
-0.11696876585483551,
0.1382286250591278,
-0.3749226927757263,
0.14062654972076416,
0.01937716081738472,
0.13074891269207,
0.61575847864151,
0.14263182878494263,
-0.8919299244880676,
-0.4654199779033661,
0.07684622704982758,
-0.27594345808029175,
0.014313937164843082,
0.7326967716217041,
-0.27869975566864014,
0.45831552147865295,
0.23734050989151,
0.5241448283195496,
0.09371697902679443,
0.1739872545003891,
0.6995025277137756,
-0.5101574063301086,
-0.2860003709793091,
0.38282716274261475,
0.5554046630859375,
0.6263343095779419,
-0.5766441226005554,
0.35568711161613464,
0.07653681188821793,
-0.44137904047966003,
-0.7623336911201477,
0.3527853786945343,
-0.5598492622375488,
-0.47262081503868103,
1.4894636869430542,
-0.42893198132514954,
-0.11943559348583221,
-0.3069433569908142,
-0.4980158507823944,
0.011341355741024017,
-0.5263947248458862,
0.8693915605545044,
0.544028639793396,
-0.08650297671556473,
0.03416700288653374,
-0.5233641266822815,
0.550139844417572,
0.15329845249652863,
-0.900175929069519,
0.2792704403400421,
0.37334176898002625,
0.4658927619457245,
-0.09801499545574188,
0.24765314161777496,
0.07102232426404953,
0.32938286662101746,
-0.1223910003900528,
-0.2809402644634247,
-0.3596387207508087,
-0.39959290623664856,
-0.6410788893699646,
0.19449032843112946,
0.5577517151832581,
0.2795650064945221
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09792v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09792v2
|
Images are Achilles' Heel of Alignment: Exploiting Visual Vulnerabilities for Jailbreaking Multimodal Large Language Models
| 2024-03-14T18:24:55 | 2024-04-14T11:57:55 |
Yifan Li, Hangyu Guo, Kun Zhou, Wayne Xin Zhao, Ji-Rong Wen
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
In this paper, we study the harmlessness alignment problem of multimodal
large language models (MLLMs). We conduct a systematic empirical analysis of
the harmlessness performance of representative MLLMs and reveal that the image
input poses the alignment vulnerability of MLLMs. Inspired by this, we propose
a novel jailbreak method named HADES, which hides and amplifies the harmfulness
of the malicious intent within the text input, using meticulously crafted
images. Experimental results show that HADES can effectively jailbreak existing
MLLMs, which achieves an average Attack Success Rate (ASR) of 90.26% for
LLaVA-1.5 and 71.60% for Gemini Pro Vision. Our code and data will be publicly
released.
|
[
-0.21951082348823547,
-0.724057674407959,
0.6445598602294922,
-0.007376157213002443,
-0.39688804745674133,
0.05992904305458069,
0.004706496372818947,
-0.6334362626075745,
0.02107520028948784,
0.8364635705947876,
-0.3846708834171295,
-0.5407840013504028,
-0.8926371335983276,
-0.18225370347499847,
-0.5494095087051392,
0.9584695100784302,
0.0944644957780838,
-0.11670154333114624,
0.09529776871204376,
-0.5107654929161072,
-0.4657689034938812,
-0.15715552866458893,
-0.456101655960083,
0.49841126799583435,
0.965040922164917,
0.2108204960823059,
1.1694073677062988,
0.752804696559906,
1.124804973602295,
0.40892425179481506,
0.20166169106960297,
0.055878933519124985,
-0.4461233913898468,
0.43859365582466125,
-0.3016234338283539,
-0.2894574999809265,
-0.2578798234462738,
-0.09515997767448425,
0.49543485045433044,
0.01556332316249609,
0.1426216959953308,
0.13492128252983093,
-0.09286338835954666,
0.8797890543937683,
-1.0043820142745972,
-0.3482886254787445,
-0.8448747396469116,
-0.13105431199073792,
-0.6072085499763489,
0.013089875690639019,
-0.7069390416145325,
-0.24696652591228485,
-0.2230386584997177,
-0.5600188970565796,
-0.36522039771080017,
0.27295196056365967,
0.7187839150428772,
0.5633245706558228,
-0.21126689016819,
-0.34851446747779846,
-0.590023934841156,
0.8114662170410156,
-0.6249575614929199,
0.28142866492271423,
0.13416358828544617,
0.6306275129318237,
-0.02112930454313755,
-0.6078200936317444,
-0.5846472978591919,
-0.16865228116512299,
-0.12923681735992432,
-0.18767155706882477,
-0.5441576242446899,
-0.1604454219341278,
0.29490044713020325,
-0.09909258037805557,
-0.6267403364181519,
0.2971588969230652,
-0.49079421162605286,
-0.19301965832710266,
0.609006404876709,
0.12567682564258575,
0.901473343372345,
0.0007936686160974205,
-0.4688444137573242,
-0.2743096947669983,
-0.7849951982498169,
0.012045515701174736,
0.5890336036682129,
0.19924727082252502,
-0.13903175294399261,
0.9661580324172974,
0.5779877305030823,
0.8333041071891785,
-0.12449005246162415,
-0.5625699758529663,
0.17767582833766937,
-0.06233884021639824,
-0.24907179176807404,
0.006826639641076326,
0.9841845631599426,
0.8163691759109497,
0.2547221779823303,
-0.2693733274936676,
-0.18294133245944977,
0.21573108434677124,
0.6519155502319336,
-0.47331565618515015,
-0.07848835736513138,
0.4733620882034302,
-0.23181292414665222,
-0.6116430759429932,
-0.1223096251487732,
-0.8618434071540833,
-1.1448934078216553,
0.1853998452425003,
0.4623459577560425,
-0.8560106754302979,
0.11295509338378906,
-0.3239777386188507,
-0.023030128329992294,
0.28079497814178467,
0.34679603576660156,
-0.7076035141944885,
-0.06474003940820694,
0.5634925365447998,
0.6363192796707153,
0.0667373463511467,
-0.40895307064056396,
-0.6808063983917236,
0.1415129005908966,
-0.3692152202129364,
0.544603168964386,
-0.3068530857563019,
0.0515596829354763,
-0.19444705545902252,
-0.015492983162403107,
-0.03724781796336174,
-0.28169259428977966,
0.6527075171470642,
-0.5851779580116272,
-0.3168892562389374,
0.10663091391324997,
-0.2978566884994507,
0.045329511165618896,
0.3085951507091522,
-0.9112905859947205,
0.42949381470680237,
-0.25890496373176575,
-1.1329772472381592,
0.1937723159790039,
-0.2896614670753479,
-0.23019413650035858,
-0.32232365012168884,
-0.16714826226234436,
-0.7415450215339661,
0.042974796146154404,
0.38665762543678284,
0.33966052532196045,
0.36292344331741333,
0.211772620677948,
-0.5993300080299377,
-0.442101389169693,
0.6122409105300903,
-0.47104230523109436,
0.9372982978820801,
0.4566633701324463,
-0.5948722958564758,
0.16883786022663116,
-0.6335567235946655,
-0.23483572900295258,
0.331795871257782,
0.09217303991317749,
-0.7093906998634338,
0.09184790402650833,
0.23233191668987274,
0.3981056809425354,
0.10168107599020004,
-0.5788299441337585,
0.30930647253990173,
-0.3474930226802826,
0.15823517739772797,
0.9393066763877869,
-0.4803847074508667,
0.44256335496902466,
-0.13253624737262726,
0.2859381437301636,
-0.033291276544332504,
0.4881422221660614,
-0.36969736218452454,
-0.5195879936218262,
-0.39012402296066284,
-0.5642585754394531,
0.2187328189611435,
0.6644243597984314,
-0.8063566088676453,
0.0723169818520546,
-0.24422846734523773,
-0.8496401309967041,
-0.7864970564842224,
0.40365898609161377,
0.8765421509742737,
0.41273033618927,
0.14227919280529022,
-0.3071887493133545,
-0.302555114030838,
-1.3417108058929443,
-0.6614676117897034,
0.1060836911201477,
0.26722556352615356,
0.19927991926670074,
0.5117345452308655,
-0.18392710387706757,
0.5220072269439697,
-0.25089335441589355,
-0.14235875010490417,
-0.08731002360582352,
-0.25275298953056335,
-0.011481250636279583,
0.7301639914512634,
1.0304770469665527,
-0.8814007043838501,
-0.3699103891849518,
-0.11381396651268005,
-0.9022561311721802,
0.19805239140987396,
-0.07736063003540039,
-0.024427935481071472,
0.3076823055744171,
0.5997759699821472,
-0.6611390113830566,
0.7770863771438599,
0.7221308946609497,
-0.6256267428398132,
0.670173704624176,
-0.11359228938817978,
0.1511857956647873,
-1.082500696182251,
0.26761844754219055,
0.19802887737751007,
-0.22894525527954102,
-0.537017285823822,
0.7236391305923462,
0.4590567946434021,
-0.3705500066280365,
-0.6893391013145447,
0.5188860893249512,
-0.40074774622917175,
-0.10541032254695892,
-0.0038798025343567133,
0.1560085266828537,
-0.11969328671693802,
0.19937089085578918,
-0.39570745825767517,
0.6535830497741699,
0.7367949485778809,
-0.06079522892832756,
0.442627876996994,
0.08512546867132187,
-0.6016005277633667,
0.578285813331604,
-0.3763202726840973,
0.08442886918783188,
-0.32304146885871887,
-0.09935972839593887,
-1.1002752780914307,
-0.357551246881485,
0.413991779088974,
-0.40336209535598755,
0.5815294981002808,
-0.1499626189470291,
-0.5163564085960388,
-0.25011104345321655,
-0.4477570056915283,
0.4813472032546997,
0.2976936101913452,
-0.47476446628570557,
0.4527963697910309,
0.3131144344806671,
-0.1357259303331375,
-1.1985520124435425,
-0.6134057641029358,
0.43794313073158264,
-0.6446918249130249,
-0.8715269565582275,
0.1726369857788086,
0.11720774322748184,
-0.6704767346382141,
-0.08251065760850906,
0.09799981862306595,
0.21566841006278992,
0.1417630910873413,
0.4286961853504181,
0.5037336349487305,
-0.0992402657866478,
-0.240857794880867,
-0.34208905696868896,
-0.15652111172676086,
-0.15622100234031677,
-0.11618991196155548,
0.4408227503299713,
-0.15942597389221191,
-0.660210371017456,
-0.6449236869812012,
0.2848864495754242,
1.2791320085525513,
-0.2069101333618164,
0.8656132221221924,
0.39368459582328796,
-0.3278976380825043,
0.37366366386413574,
-0.5517392754554749,
0.07672020047903061,
-0.500511109828949,
0.3126687705516815,
-0.12121765315532684,
-0.548278272151947,
0.589878261089325,
0.1724989414215088,
0.36250701546669006,
0.178310364484787,
0.2538639307022095,
-0.5116642117500305,
1.0713696479797363,
0.7357189655303955,
-0.21681763231754303,
0.35133805871009827,
0.12311477214097977,
0.42844825983047485,
-0.7496551275253296,
-0.2544437348842621,
-0.4254254400730133,
-0.649352490901947,
-0.597235381603241,
-0.24986374378204346,
0.3842926323413849,
0.11587955057621002,
-0.25144100189208984,
0.6149224042892456,
-0.32161927223205566,
0.6198346614837646,
0.418774276971817,
0.15967310965061188,
-0.02521839179098606,
0.011675674468278885,
-0.43238288164138794,
-0.4311006963253021,
-0.04669177904725075,
-0.5229811668395996,
1.0477865934371948,
0.39820653200149536,
1.1950913667678833,
0.45198091864585876,
0.5870493054389954,
0.04930545762181282,
0.22618335485458374,
-0.508819580078125,
0.27675294876098633,
-0.3500758707523346,
-0.7953565120697021,
-0.358259916305542,
-0.06077258288860321,
-0.884878396987915,
0.2039031982421875,
-0.4800386130809784,
-1.3777159452438354,
-0.06813336163759232,
0.37585267424583435,
-0.37147945165634155,
0.7625661492347717,
-0.7990012764930725,
0.9714218974113464,
-0.637306272983551,
-0.746676504611969,
0.028963683173060417,
-1.020980954170227,
0.6899155378341675,
-0.24165335297584534,
0.7695669531822205,
0.08394213020801544,
0.19297370314598083,
0.37672343850135803,
-0.376797080039978,
0.9483901858329773,
-0.20546339452266693,
-0.25387948751449585,
-0.1258241981267929,
0.4330301582813263,
0.7473049759864807,
-0.1661910116672516,
0.14201053977012634,
-0.26626861095428467,
-0.29906752705574036,
-0.5830252170562744,
-0.7605212926864624,
0.7037367820739746,
-0.45252808928489685,
-0.595104992389679,
-0.3173675835132599,
-0.5853027105331421,
-0.23002125322818756,
0.1744937002658844,
0.4724217355251312,
0.39666858315467834,
0.08726519346237183,
0.06920572370290756,
0.5414175987243652,
-0.643642783164978,
0.6158703565597534,
0.09437070786952972,
-0.4035511016845703,
-0.6301937699317932,
0.9310053586959839,
-0.06643462926149368,
0.36199751496315,
0.008728726767003536,
-0.15382665395736694,
-0.15138016641139984,
-0.6576787233352661,
-0.8057488799095154,
0.14195965230464935,
-0.7358137369155884,
-0.20541277527809143,
-0.40588894486427307,
-0.1698617935180664,
-0.47597822546958923,
-0.5435589551925659,
-0.6345171928405762,
-0.500870943069458,
0.20252105593681335,
0.1528518944978714,
0.08445248007774353,
0.5305072069168091,
0.16656063497066498,
0.4056311249732971,
-0.9815821051597595,
0.30569496750831604,
0.21734224259853363,
0.28780996799468994,
-0.26472824811935425,
-0.31669387221336365,
0.045473966747522354,
-0.30285850167274475,
-0.4529065489768982,
-1.0785883665084839,
0.4528801441192627,
-0.14657674729824066,
0.4205351769924164,
0.8454940319061279,
-0.05507300794124603,
0.7397332191467285,
-0.6140140295028687,
0.5599223375320435,
0.684303879737854,
-0.6308863162994385,
0.7703827619552612,
-0.4003834128379822,
0.1962313950061798,
0.6288247108459473,
0.07533399760723114,
-0.3751000463962555,
-0.9952895641326904,
-0.6034998297691345,
-0.981565535068512,
0.45551496744155884,
0.48819753527641296,
0.371672123670578,
0.4618366062641144,
0.17206236720085144,
0.1381516009569168,
-0.059275057166814804,
-0.9944808483123779,
-0.35534125566482544,
0.0291956327855587,
-0.28330323100090027,
-0.08453265577554703,
-0.15809454023838043,
-0.37088149785995483,
-0.32459667325019836,
0.4713740944862366,
0.09990531206130981,
-0.07415039837360382,
0.05514616519212723,
-0.36823877692222595,
0.010609460063278675,
0.32396119832992554,
0.8883018493652344,
0.6184845566749573,
-0.15480342507362366,
0.379515677690506,
-0.3194531202316284,
-0.641415536403656,
0.16501952707767487,
-0.028416046872735023,
-0.162690207362175,
-0.23478730022907257,
0.5747081637382507,
0.7552739381790161,
0.18706969916820526,
-0.8368390202522278,
0.7418393492698669,
-0.22385212779045105,
0.08712542802095413,
-0.2185741662979126,
-0.020872993394732475,
0.1512957066297531,
0.3825627267360687,
0.2070838063955307,
0.6111446619033813,
-0.06658083945512772,
-0.493088036775589,
0.21576502919197083,
0.6168210506439209,
-0.5790624618530273,
-0.09818048030138016,
0.7857134342193604,
-0.15838314592838287,
-0.17535914480686188,
0.6881011724472046,
0.18679897487163544,
-0.39098212122917175,
0.7383718490600586,
0.6627830862998962,
0.6113613247871399,
-0.3092630207538605,
0.10066308081150055,
0.23035582900047302,
0.8761422634124756,
0.31666913628578186,
-0.016590172424912453,
0.37499749660491943,
-0.7392088174819946,
-0.26979586482048035,
-0.5888839960098267,
-0.10995393991470337,
0.06979119032621384,
-0.48340684175491333,
0.42188283801078796,
-0.4987100660800934,
-0.19419018924236298,
0.4106873571872711,
-0.8278352618217468,
-0.22122837603092194,
0.20166462659835815,
0.4787482023239136,
0.7735491991043091,
-0.71919184923172,
0.8633740544319153,
0.6463471055030823,
-0.04073456674814224,
-0.7148634791374207,
-0.07974112778902054,
0.5010182857513428,
-0.9017038345336914,
0.48643285036087036,
0.44875383377075195,
-0.044939201325178146,
-0.3482131361961365,
-0.9970331192016602,
-0.8418774604797363,
0.8022773861885071,
0.8616713881492615,
-0.7185478806495667,
0.049185194075107574,
-0.12574738264083862,
0.1881934404373169,
-0.10930115729570389,
-0.31655871868133545,
0.47496914863586426,
0.6915170550346375,
-0.005058795213699341,
-0.8311026096343994,
0.05533699318766594,
-0.5492768883705139,
-0.3303111791610718,
0.3840680718421936,
-0.3382068872451782,
0.6996813416481018,
-0.8151009678840637,
-0.15866102278232574,
0.253208726644516,
0.0789412409067154,
0.5495635271072388,
0.44848328828811646,
0.4321485161781311,
1.1698133945465088,
0.6117987036705017,
-0.0539267398416996,
1.2309321165084839,
-0.1382521092891693,
0.11728091537952423,
1.1225106716156006,
-0.11207067221403122,
0.7304132580757141,
0.958010196685791,
0.17262457311153412,
0.42268192768096924,
0.2952236533164978,
-0.2429792582988739,
0.8361616134643555,
0.07441354542970657,
-0.04399508237838745,
-0.053095605224370956,
0.43702319264411926,
-0.1466311812400818,
0.6354156732559204,
0.42144060134887695,
-0.8265935778617859,
-0.22317622601985931,
0.3276248574256897,
0.3244316875934601,
0.10483422875404358,
-0.30718475580215454,
0.6569206714630127,
0.002122439444065094,
-0.49850937724113464,
0.47076863050460815,
0.011749827302992344,
0.5903478860855103,
-0.2847166955471039,
0.17747652530670166,
0.08155839890241623,
0.22230176627635956,
-0.33658552169799805,
-0.9949182271957397,
0.5000997185707092,
0.24688145518302917,
0.28274568915367126,
0.16205334663391113,
0.8681558966636658,
0.19237931072711945,
-0.5737970471382141,
0.3559921383857727,
0.16522575914859772,
0.06965703517198563,
-0.03829273581504822,
-0.6680366396903992,
0.20165573060512543,
-0.09026919305324554,
-0.05534655228257179,
0.53315669298172,
0.06972203403711319,
-0.20306655764579773,
0.8497796058654785,
0.542074978351593,
-0.1394578069448471,
0.2616053819656372,
-0.2598884701728821,
1.0103967189788818,
-0.6755656003952026,
-0.13157838582992554,
-1.3792393207550049,
0.9661155343055725,
-0.28833693265914917,
-0.22561527788639069,
0.7178301215171814,
0.581088125705719,
0.464539498090744,
-0.1419847011566162,
0.6211286783218384,
-0.22361573576927185,
-0.19426172971725464,
-0.6870206594467163,
1.1276580095291138,
-0.7122529745101929,
0.3917330503463745,
-0.8228349685668945,
-0.825651228427887,
-0.6476204991340637,
0.41319066286087036,
-0.31712260842323303,
-0.49433305859565735,
0.7041670083999634,
0.8422524929046631,
-0.13376539945602417,
-0.22534501552581787,
0.47763121128082275,
0.1805974692106247,
-0.017841968685388565,
0.45774146914482117,
0.9164436459541321,
-0.4498685300350189,
0.5748684406280518,
-0.5061208009719849,
-0.26097020506858826,
-0.10402785241603851,
-0.7746223211288452,
-0.7695054411888123,
-0.5745129585266113,
-0.12624508142471313,
-0.634876012802124,
0.18801137804985046,
0.2908378541469574,
0.4868472218513489,
-0.7391894459724426,
0.23788760602474213,
0.15533770620822906,
0.21098677814006805,
-0.055652014911174774,
-0.14377744495868683,
0.4640263319015503,
-0.20925699174404144,
-0.6301838755607605,
0.21375314891338348,
0.575827419757843,
0.19714002311229706,
-0.17636357247829437,
0.0496743768453598,
-0.009561172686517239,
-0.15721163153648376,
0.33861470222473145,
0.31866487860679626,
-0.9535637497901917,
-0.29285046458244324,
0.001547270338051021,
-0.5538781881332397,
0.14463749527931213,
0.6633175015449524,
-0.371010422706604,
0.5874725580215454,
0.13321952521800995,
0.5311190485954285,
0.13549014925956726,
-0.08386029303073883,
0.49232494831085205,
-0.7896015048027039,
0.49273157119750977,
0.14168168604373932,
0.6882314682006836,
0.4102286696434021,
-0.5462285280227661,
0.21587584912776947,
0.018189210444688797,
-0.2991849482059479,
-0.8860798478126526,
0.2986582815647125,
-1.0553706884384155,
-0.7099986672401428,
0.8078672289848328,
-0.2275915890932083,
-0.6107119917869568,
0.002831697463989258,
-0.381504088640213,
0.008848014287650585,
-0.07008656114339828,
0.9573972821235657,
0.6784511804580688,
-0.011621544137597084,
-0.2721690833568573,
-0.6961756944656372,
0.39053797721862793,
0.2072896957397461,
-0.5810719728469849,
0.01576979085803032,
0.4913598597049713,
0.3590123653411865,
0.6542769074440002,
0.2681904733181,
-0.756591260433197,
0.4121107757091522,
0.14090360701084137,
0.10172252357006073,
0.18858997523784637,
-0.3771471083164215,
-0.30485790967941284,
0.38423195481300354,
0.05735466629266739,
-0.06443940848112106
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09636v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09636v1
|
Dynamic Memory Compression: Retrofitting LLMs for Accelerated Inference
| 2024-03-14T17:59:26 | 2024-03-14T17:59:26 |
Piotr Nawrot, Adrian Łańcucki, Marcin Chochowski, David Tarjan, Edoardo M. Ponti
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Transformers have emerged as the backbone of large language models (LLMs).
However, generation remains inefficient due to the need to store in memory a
cache of key-value representations for past tokens, whose size scales linearly
with the input sequence length and batch size. As a solution, we propose
Dynamic Memory Compression (DMC), a method for on-line key-value cache
compression at inference time. Most importantly, the model learns to apply
different compression rates in different heads and layers. We retrofit
pre-trained LLMs such as Llama 2 (7B, 13B and 70B) into DMC Transformers,
achieving up to ~3.7x throughput increase in auto-regressive inference on a
NVIDIA H100 GPU. DMC is applied via continued pre-training on a negligible
percentage of the original data without adding any extra parameters. We find
that DMC preserves the original downstream performance with up to 4x cache
compression, outperforming up-trained grouped-query attention (GQA). GQA and
DMC can be even combined to obtain compounded gains. As a result DMC fits
longer contexts and larger batches within any given memory budget.
|
[
-0.4252670109272003,
-0.6065409779548645,
0.7098286151885986,
0.15262830257415771,
-0.20888455212116241,
0.5275404453277588,
-0.2848179340362549,
-0.2931878864765167,
0.3408285975456238,
0.42927849292755127,
-0.6257840991020203,
-0.16145628690719604,
-0.5456220507621765,
-0.0897040069103241,
-0.46218031644821167,
0.3314701318740845,
-0.025067228823900223,
-0.146907776594162,
-0.11784625053405762,
0.047966983169317245,
-0.5168418288230896,
-0.46687525510787964,
-0.7102112770080566,
-0.08801070600748062,
0.46689438819885254,
0.3932012617588043,
0.6139155626296997,
0.8989611864089966,
0.21258458495140076,
0.345039963722229,
-0.19337037205696106,
0.30810847878456116,
-0.5155051350593567,
0.43700751662254333,
0.07319515198469162,
-0.5450835824012756,
-0.6688387989997864,
-0.09722338616847992,
0.7715054154396057,
0.4509744942188263,
-0.3563387095928192,
0.266549676656723,
-0.15939831733703613,
0.6062551736831665,
-0.8005610704421997,
0.15751026570796967,
-0.954931914806366,
0.14856012165546417,
0.06912883371114731,
-0.37572187185287476,
-0.56560879945755,
-0.3515474498271942,
-0.3011293113231659,
-0.4084540903568268,
0.14719118177890778,
0.0957358330488205,
0.7983975410461426,
0.9046967625617981,
-0.1120285615324974,
-0.06661826372146606,
-0.7926264405250549,
0.7250268459320068,
-0.7791911959648132,
0.41955578327178955,
0.1725991815328598,
0.48950275778770447,
-0.3803650140762329,
-1.0476722717285156,
-0.7682645320892334,
-0.0407952144742012,
0.19076542556285858,
0.08435261249542236,
-0.09414910525083542,
-0.06451447308063507,
0.3794725239276886,
0.6885277032852173,
-0.09130590409040451,
0.37935471534729004,
-0.07070668041706085,
0.0131554389372468,
0.45040658116340637,
0.26972317695617676,
-0.05949749797582626,
0.1831578016281128,
-0.3048998713493347,
-0.36211004853248596,
-0.8955230116844177,
-0.3801889419555664,
0.5374829173088074,
0.16005662083625793,
0.20859281718730927,
0.20382985472679138,
-0.12673832476139069,
0.7221404314041138,
0.32709434628486633,
-0.15242236852645874,
0.07342023402452469,
-0.07292354851961136,
-0.12833742797374725,
0.2096712440252304,
0.4825807213783264,
0.025954371318221092,
0.28407254815101624,
-0.29351431131362915,
-0.2274889498949051,
0.034629832953214645,
0.4215211570262909,
-0.9640065431594849,
-0.31450411677360535,
0.09396199882030487,
-0.3747695982456207,
-0.2786080837249756,
-0.07761265337467194,
-1.1687363386154175,
-0.18044805526733398,
-0.33045530319213867,
0.3916405439376831,
0.10597838461399078,
0.021159972995519638,
0.31878525018692017,
-0.05608522519469261,
0.14742910861968994,
0.3587963581085205,
-0.9611719846725464,
0.33455711603164673,
0.29641279578208923,
0.6541054248809814,
-0.21158379316329956,
0.056620042771101,
-0.6999960541725159,
0.30941855907440186,
0.059890683740377426,
0.8765363693237305,
-0.5058561563491821,
-0.32868874073028564,
-0.016286225989460945,
-0.09234818071126938,
0.18051280081272125,
-0.7832366228103638,
0.4436279535293579,
-0.744282603263855,
-0.058212701231241226,
-0.01750183291733265,
-0.47016748785972595,
0.17470286786556244,
0.09905031323432922,
-0.7846946716308594,
1.3015286922454834,
0.10127317905426025,
-0.471944659948349,
0.2922517657279968,
-0.09285083413124084,
-0.3459719121456146,
-0.11096370965242386,
-0.2483588606119156,
-0.3471839427947998,
0.3731050193309784,
0.5556290149688721,
0.4889855980873108,
-0.3220210671424866,
0.27342626452445984,
-0.40898096561431885,
-0.6793433427810669,
-0.0014238221338018775,
-0.6580618619918823,
0.35349133610725403,
0.11475396156311035,
-0.4133438467979431,
-0.18982581794261932,
-0.9038408994674683,
-0.1093311533331871,
0.24860547482967377,
-0.748155415058136,
0.011383519507944584,
0.2669737637042999,
-0.39615392684936523,
0.20327593386173248,
0.24265742301940918,
-0.402847558259964,
0.5971270203590393,
-0.20305249094963074,
0.49022766947746277,
0.7246274352073669,
-0.1250041127204895,
0.24967500567436218,
0.045571137219667435,
0.43225106596946716,
-0.07867108285427094,
0.12617449462413788,
-0.292001873254776,
-0.3305310606956482,
-1.134211778640747,
-0.3226383626461029,
0.2852597236633301,
0.4953755736351013,
-0.7542040348052979,
0.5807188749313354,
-0.5018330216407776,
-0.3293594717979431,
-0.4162899851799011,
0.014152023941278458,
-0.07840046286582947,
0.538640022277832,
0.5904255509376526,
-0.23216241598129272,
-0.6122006773948669,
-0.7773565053939819,
-0.22527840733528137,
-0.27937084436416626,
-0.15725117921829224,
0.43644046783447266,
0.05064576491713524,
-0.361508846282959,
0.8933402895927429,
-0.6725333333015442,
0.0877174660563469,
-0.1095246747136116,
0.28287431597709656,
0.2524396777153015,
0.371669203042984,
0.27976194024086,
-0.4039996564388275,
-0.2372639924287796,
-0.5344951152801514,
-0.19844229519367218,
-0.41917213797569275,
-0.17407138645648956,
-0.002239459427073598,
0.06812349706888199,
0.6288225650787354,
-0.6626902222633362,
0.42860281467437744,
0.7232052087783813,
0.05779053643345833,
0.31572818756103516,
-0.4454824924468994,
0.041225824505090714,
-1.0631794929504395,
-0.17413833737373352,
-0.5232706665992737,
-0.37888413667678833,
-0.3229053020477295,
-0.11949235945940018,
0.20255139470100403,
0.03289560228586197,
-0.4683373272418976,
0.6226284503936768,
-0.6189664602279663,
-0.2364329695701599,
-0.5457805395126343,
0.11907939612865448,
-0.07063807547092438,
0.5171489715576172,
0.0856836587190628,
0.9390623569488525,
0.3012852072715759,
-0.7427794933319092,
0.3626711070537567,
0.07517343759536743,
-0.4075067341327667,
0.04123528301715851,
-0.4178817570209503,
0.3995437026023865,
-0.12951801717281342,
0.7241190075874329,
-1.1029351949691772,
-0.048987507820129395,
0.0006099462043493986,
-0.18449167907238007,
0.7283543944358826,
0.006260058376938105,
-0.797273576259613,
-0.46297356486320496,
-0.16938495635986328,
0.5365027189254761,
0.8687862157821655,
-1.0258699655532837,
0.7511612772941589,
0.30602556467056274,
0.19572702050209045,
-0.6174265146255493,
-0.9622842669487,
0.23143400251865387,
-0.3512033522129059,
-0.34304744005203247,
0.677868664264679,
0.10490170121192932,
0.012995434924960136,
-0.07173077017068863,
-0.2037210464477539,
0.03430603817105293,
0.05830254778265953,
0.10215716809034348,
0.16669580340385437,
-0.2861439287662506,
0.24265052378177643,
0.14358358085155487,
-0.056308016180992126,
-0.12100844830274582,
-0.3040415644645691,
0.809408962726593,
0.06405492126941681,
-0.1730818748474121,
-0.28409838676452637,
0.06304419785737991,
0.5255082249641418,
0.03470558300614357,
0.780414879322052,
0.6209607720375061,
-0.2378680557012558,
-0.19516631960868835,
-0.8854902386665344,
-0.3373997211456299,
-0.5624350905418396,
0.13852137327194214,
-0.17801380157470703,
-0.9518583416938782,
0.5257073044776917,
-0.41089433431625366,
0.012727429158985615,
0.5157457590103149,
0.8109557628631592,
0.08151806145906448,
0.8803701400756836,
0.3073823153972626,
-0.1602019965648651,
0.5262743830680847,
-0.14893072843551636,
0.25738525390625,
-0.7409140467643738,
-0.03675087168812752,
-0.31946176290512085,
-0.7323926091194153,
-0.4719059467315674,
-0.78902667760849,
-0.03878546133637428,
0.17405252158641815,
-0.29926788806915283,
0.39180663228034973,
-0.3441251516342163,
0.3464830815792084,
0.30874601006507874,
0.06503800302743912,
0.3098042607307434,
0.055008720606565475,
0.0606352835893631,
0.12693792581558228,
-0.8410249352455139,
-0.3518819212913513,
0.8801924586296082,
0.42720988392829895,
1.0967686176300049,
0.10212530195713043,
0.5398120880126953,
0.11568500846624374,
0.47681766748428345,
-0.7747003436088562,
0.6953328251838684,
-0.12693975865840912,
-0.43917685747146606,
0.2252022624015808,
-0.5656934380531311,
-0.8734928369522095,
-0.06497575342655182,
-0.0878315418958664,
-0.7368515133857727,
0.18423552811145782,
0.6060553193092346,
-0.6203935146331787,
0.5662097334861755,
-0.454456627368927,
0.4207916259765625,
-0.3546796441078186,
-0.4594043493270874,
-0.4550461173057556,
-0.545459508895874,
0.46302664279937744,
-0.22702860832214355,
-0.19018371403217316,
-0.07764264196157455,
-0.3509499728679657,
0.45045846700668335,
-0.3422439694404602,
0.7717181444168091,
-0.16636888682842255,
-0.012423744425177574,
0.23409225046634674,
-0.097347192466259,
0.7406157851219177,
0.12337508052587509,
0.10552525520324707,
0.07380740344524384,
-0.2889309227466583,
-0.32210230827331543,
-0.9356409311294556,
0.8411127924919128,
-0.4609510004520416,
-0.8673178553581238,
-0.15601623058319092,
-0.6908553838729858,
-0.4587344229221344,
-0.20896881818771362,
-0.08449829369783401,
0.4385550022125244,
0.18374262750148773,
0.15864038467407227,
0.7594429850578308,
-0.6027609705924988,
0.5276409983634949,
0.34618738293647766,
-0.05871143192052841,
-0.29887548089027405,
0.5691705942153931,
-0.19256101548671722,
0.4287908375263214,
0.5557332038879395,
0.22080066800117493,
-0.36728009581565857,
-0.4904913902282715,
-0.5698161125183105,
0.1705886572599411,
-0.6710087656974792,
-0.2931268811225891,
-0.7078889608383179,
-0.10122578591108322,
-0.3466295003890991,
0.03740626573562622,
-0.7065290808677673,
-0.6799615621566772,
-0.35520419478416443,
0.14007744193077087,
0.4811691641807556,
0.5297929644584656,
0.10940395295619965,
0.5545290112495422,
-0.8766868710517883,
0.24517278373241425,
0.3157399594783783,
0.2120189070701599,
0.2464449256658554,
-0.7293893694877625,
-0.25234267115592957,
-0.16877567768096924,
-0.24370908737182617,
-0.5948413610458374,
0.45672449469566345,
0.2827222943305969,
0.5513977408409119,
0.44052854180336,
-0.029230641201138496,
1.1241177320480347,
-0.8255319595336914,
0.8001115918159485,
-0.18031713366508484,
-0.5772603750228882,
0.26030898094177246,
0.09617731720209122,
0.46732139587402344,
0.6028042435646057,
0.41852229833602905,
-0.19279959797859192,
-0.17079304158687592,
-0.6266992688179016,
-1.0604634284973145,
0.18706178665161133,
-0.1424698382616043,
0.3376455008983612,
-0.22617049515247345,
0.7323136925697327,
-0.07969855517148972,
0.2120453119277954,
-0.27025163173675537,
-0.19264179468154907,
-0.1062670573592186,
-0.371158242225647,
-0.029925210401415825,
-0.3089810609817505,
0.2193407565355301,
-0.518888533115387,
0.3493637144565582,
-0.12028590589761734,
0.612328290939331,
0.0613175593316555,
-0.14360085129737854,
0.11301721632480621,
-0.0892583429813385,
0.6110224723815918,
0.31435462832450867,
-0.33452174067497253,
0.39086467027664185,
0.3894287347793579,
-0.5506023168563843,
0.25263506174087524,
0.07967203110456467,
0.29972219467163086,
-0.16654767096042633,
0.10654965788125992,
0.9492331147193909,
0.5228340029716492,
-0.8471572995185852,
0.11073385179042816,
-0.3702937960624695,
0.08372535556554794,
-0.332692950963974,
0.11655566096305847,
0.015000300481915474,
0.3092323839664459,
0.3155139982700348,
-0.1589914858341217,
-0.18784059584140778,
-0.6129888892173767,
0.365894615650177,
0.28579363226890564,
-0.10300106555223465,
-0.15026149153709412,
0.8409401774406433,
0.030529897660017014,
-0.14418204128742218,
0.8816244006156921,
0.07049389183521271,
-0.5945719480514526,
0.2792207598686218,
0.4770714342594147,
0.9208294749259949,
-0.30377328395843506,
-0.49383118748664856,
0.5019383430480957,
-0.0034593651071190834,
-0.3480420410633087,
0.036066535860300064,
-0.3872166574001312,
-0.6703448295593262,
-0.7328751683235168,
-0.8229162693023682,
-0.300365149974823,
0.1553814560174942,
-0.473088800907135,
0.2714093029499054,
-0.431510865688324,
-0.1759481579065323,
-0.46329396963119507,
-0.13089150190353394,
-0.5805603861808777,
0.14008983969688416,
0.2686595916748047,
1.1582967042922974,
-0.40222689509391785,
1.1584316492080688,
0.1383083611726761,
-0.09738484770059586,
-0.7600464820861816,
0.23528091609477997,
-0.08456386625766754,
-1.0073798894882202,
0.9643169641494751,
0.06479176133871078,
-0.16010618209838867,
0.27251869440078735,
-0.18162982165813446,
-1.09920334815979,
1.2522761821746826,
0.5372968316078186,
-0.7085879445075989,
-0.15879933536052704,
0.04406818374991417,
0.3775246739387512,
-0.3365635573863983,
0.17792001366615295,
0.6979304552078247,
0.43360772728919983,
0.36802706122398376,
-0.5685130953788757,
0.01462688110768795,
0.04987461864948273,
-0.033402688801288605,
0.3431849777698517,
-0.4824742078781128,
0.7312408089637756,
0.00013406775542534888,
-0.2837963104248047,
0.17896337807178497,
0.8750218749046326,
0.26992717385292053,
-0.2260916829109192,
0.6620693802833557,
0.8927648663520813,
0.6552023887634277,
-0.11338575929403305,
1.1947400569915771,
-0.5732523202896118,
0.18185687065124512,
1.2389485836029053,
-0.16502678394317627,
1.0863105058670044,
0.748927891254425,
-0.08752648532390594,
0.4855489730834961,
0.7411352396011353,
0.013383869081735611,
0.5394115447998047,
0.4920203387737274,
-0.33039411902427673,
-0.21065713465213776,
0.1398208886384964,
-0.26950713992118835,
0.31658390164375305,
0.3115069568157196,
-0.46854257583618164,
-0.04025963693857193,
-0.3501585125923157,
-0.025090936571359634,
-0.24622413516044617,
-0.24296513199806213,
0.34342890977859497,
0.06382210552692413,
-0.7597503662109375,
0.690196692943573,
-0.13757212460041046,
0.7910783290863037,
-0.4366835355758667,
0.02730860374867916,
-0.3171425461769104,
0.5284163951873779,
0.032754890620708466,
-0.5576351881027222,
0.43061205744743347,
-0.03327122703194618,
-0.030684567987918854,
-0.5107696652412415,
0.7375386953353882,
-0.5379120707511902,
-0.3839220702648163,
0.1677500158548355,
0.24317026138305664,
0.22550927102565765,
-0.010601789690554142,
-0.38737741112709045,
0.3254442811012268,
-0.31364715099334717,
-0.5317636132240295,
0.45816516876220703,
0.12007114291191101,
0.19241978228092194,
0.6541011333465576,
0.5304338932037354,
0.1980210244655609,
0.47318321466445923,
0.12281036376953125,
1.0549609661102295,
-0.5187088847160339,
-0.1195276752114296,
-0.9217789769172668,
0.40819495916366577,
-0.05199473723769188,
-0.10949810594320297,
0.6799097061157227,
0.46446239948272705,
0.6774206161499023,
-0.027466781437397003,
0.18425437808036804,
0.2421555370092392,
0.24555259943008423,
-0.6715357899665833,
0.5753344893455505,
-0.7409209609031677,
0.35300490260124207,
0.0028558510821312666,
-1.0812022686004639,
-0.265798956155777,
0.5459465384483337,
-0.03462802991271019,
0.0676460862159729,
0.4774329364299774,
0.7316874861717224,
-0.20982173085212708,
-0.2340417057275772,
0.20962798595428467,
0.16077639162540436,
0.3651799261569977,
0.6265878677368164,
0.8997500538825989,
-0.40904009342193604,
0.4887740910053253,
-0.10039081424474716,
-0.06501094251871109,
-0.12181208282709122,
-1.242460012435913,
-0.7118573188781738,
-0.23803316056728363,
-0.3240896463394165,
-0.23578262329101562,
-0.12242617458105087,
0.7044816017150879,
0.6676807403564453,
-0.48920372128486633,
-0.147428959608078,
-0.2590520977973938,
-0.37374621629714966,
-0.05261057987809181,
-0.18451952934265137,
0.26078587770462036,
-0.3216378092765808,
-0.9748944044113159,
0.6818287968635559,
0.38529106974601746,
0.1174127608537674,
-0.7685258984565735,
-0.056011006236076355,
-0.2101641297340393,
0.2824884355068207,
0.5290152430534363,
0.22129347920417786,
-0.7218544483184814,
-0.36288297176361084,
-0.09819794446229935,
0.16868768632411957,
0.17964738607406616,
1.0853443145751953,
-1.3433352708816528,
0.2518180310726166,
0.6042477488517761,
1.1642450094223022,
0.9290086627006531,
0.008982312865555286,
0.7323338985443115,
-0.7193386554718018,
0.4774433672428131,
0.24981658160686493,
0.4891456961631775,
0.2396877408027649,
-0.30514371395111084,
0.3147605061531067,
0.30126121640205383,
-0.6459441184997559,
-0.9500035643577576,
0.3159504532814026,
-0.8965327739715576,
-0.27047988772392273,
1.1021825075149536,
-0.08572922646999359,
-0.20001204311847687,
0.20599223673343658,
-0.013945800252258778,
0.5128275752067566,
-0.2349935621023178,
0.9011974930763245,
0.5874186158180237,
-0.12092985957860947,
-0.4487099349498749,
-0.69776850938797,
0.48711326718330383,
0.44861188530921936,
-0.7503007054328918,
0.0716959685087204,
0.1709022969007492,
-0.14631445705890656,
-0.07702229917049408,
0.14214053750038147,
-0.03857896849513054,
-0.12040286511182785,
0.03923744335770607,
0.04920175299048424,
-0.042247746139764786,
-0.25558996200561523,
-0.2576417922973633,
0.02544919215142727,
-0.13065052032470703,
-0.11262025684118271
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09635v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09635v1
|
Transformers Get Stable: An End-to-End Signal Propagation Theory for Language Models
| 2024-03-14T17:59:14 | 2024-03-14T17:59:14 |
Akhil Kedia, Mohd Abbas Zaidi, Sushil Khyalia, Jungho Jung, Harshith Goka, Haejun Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.LG, I.2.7; I.2.10
|
In spite of their huge success, transformer models remain difficult to scale
in depth. In this work, we develop a unified signal propagation theory and
provide formulae that govern the moments of the forward and backward signal
through the transformer model. Our framework can be used to understand and
mitigate vanishing/exploding gradients, rank collapse, and instability
associated with high attention scores. We also propose DeepScaleLM, an
initialization and scaling scheme that conserves unit output/gradient moments
throughout the model, enabling the training of very deep models with 100s of
layers. We find that transformer models could be much deeper - our deep models
with fewer parameters outperform shallow models in Language Modeling, Speech
Translation, and Image Classification, across Encoder-only, Decoder-only and
Encoder-Decoder variants, for both Pre-LN and Post-LN transformers, for
multiple datasets and model sizes. These improvements also translate into
improved performance on downstream Question Answering tasks and improved
robustness for image classification.
|
[
-0.6034451127052307,
-0.7995820045471191,
0.11801796406507492,
0.3490915894508362,
-0.13085298240184784,
-0.0480092316865921,
-0.46282991766929626,
-0.23948560655117035,
-0.3084637522697449,
0.4221562445163727,
-0.33375704288482666,
-0.2597925066947937,
-0.9561260342597961,
-0.3398890197277069,
-0.7886455059051514,
1.0431724786758423,
0.46260589361190796,
0.11569805443286896,
-0.0063972482457757,
-0.15756115317344666,
-0.28849679231643677,
-0.28476014733314514,
-0.9459433555603027,
-0.5619471073150635,
0.6108600497245789,
0.3760588467121124,
1.2246659994125366,
0.37102988362312317,
0.8116565942764282,
0.3239009380340576,
-0.5162664651870728,
-0.5209288597106934,
-0.7215836644172668,
0.4191659688949585,
0.011757302097976208,
-0.4289742708206177,
-0.37185588479042053,
-0.17350368201732635,
0.6532719731330872,
1.0677978992462158,
-0.20196424424648285,
0.2492765635251999,
-0.014191190712153912,
0.5611276030540466,
-0.2224350869655609,
0.03185167536139488,
-0.4714088439941406,
0.0766768679022789,
0.11453907191753387,
0.09555531293153763,
-0.6396341919898987,
-0.18048638105392456,
0.2877015173435211,
-0.14249256253242493,
0.3655547499656677,
-0.19748595356941223,
0.8715232610702515,
0.3837760388851166,
-0.6145439743995667,
0.2788698077201843,
-1.2369168996810913,
0.8034965395927429,
-0.456661194562912,
1.0012913942337036,
-0.09337757527828217,
0.5274204015731812,
-0.1064448207616806,
-1.054205060005188,
-0.2949877381324768,
-0.1803600788116455,
-0.09432662278413773,
0.28716737031936646,
-0.25909602642059326,
0.224336177110672,
0.11434414982795715,
0.4958697259426117,
-0.08269457519054413,
0.10524070262908936,
-0.4183568060398102,
-0.036336906254291534,
0.3913516402244568,
0.030792035162448883,
0.24117110669612885,
0.20518507063388824,
-0.18627315759658813,
-0.2604898512363434,
-0.7359434366226196,
0.20799051225185394,
0.21475909650325775,
0.3049766421318054,
-0.12044423818588257,
0.361634224653244,
0.17542585730552673,
0.2786545753479004,
0.47661125659942627,
0.0999707281589508,
0.0020519024692475796,
-0.08730534464120865,
-0.22297915816307068,
-0.2258976697921753,
0.6803178191184998,
0.2830897569656372,
0.2625383138656616,
-0.556207001209259,
-0.19091229140758514,
0.20680972933769226,
0.46927115321159363,
-0.7017577886581421,
-0.22067953646183014,
0.17176763713359833,
-0.5828633308410645,
-0.379239559173584,
-0.3152661621570587,
-0.9158642292022705,
-0.1912851780653,
-0.40865838527679443,
0.4311535060405731,
-0.045405223965644836,
-0.5731555223464966,
0.2197667807340622,
0.05547580495476723,
0.5396637320518494,
0.025675754994153976,
-0.9499151706695557,
0.592067301273346,
0.39692431688308716,
0.38194361329078674,
0.07449252158403397,
-0.22638247907161713,
-0.11044438928365707,
-0.078546442091465,
-0.5121884346008301,
0.613568127155304,
-0.37368276715278625,
-0.3199659287929535,
0.03941009193658829,
0.1919616162776947,
0.007255889941006899,
-0.15057770907878876,
0.890670657157898,
-0.7327428460121155,
0.3477090895175934,
0.028446996584534645,
-0.1604434698820114,
0.06133289262652397,
0.014572164043784142,
-0.8158586025238037,
0.9133384227752686,
0.19918020069599152,
-0.6560451984405518,
0.1548822969198227,
-0.6875093579292297,
-0.6065425276756287,
-0.31704947352409363,
0.09130417555570602,
-0.7317312359809875,
0.3728771209716797,
0.2724190056324005,
0.4834597110748291,
-0.3807027041912079,
0.4337449371814728,
-0.05681517347693443,
-0.24943146109580994,
0.21393176913261414,
-0.8260545134544373,
0.7562905550003052,
0.1178181990981102,
-0.38138002157211304,
0.27652639150619507,
-0.4789968729019165,
-0.21349510550498962,
0.22470210492610931,
-0.15416549146175385,
0.1638425588607788,
0.06639862060546875,
0.19411738216876984,
0.3355809450149536,
-0.1259351223707199,
-0.5049770474433899,
0.11125747859477997,
-0.3387272357940674,
0.6112144589424133,
0.397565633058548,
-0.0704326331615448,
0.8847100138664246,
0.11666814982891083,
0.41349145770072937,
0.20658600330352783,
0.5010078549385071,
-0.49684998393058777,
-0.538227379322052,
-1.0388010740280151,
0.15591517090797424,
0.27513161301612854,
0.40985509753227234,
-0.1620175987482071,
0.2123529464006424,
-0.7913909554481506,
-0.6517345905303955,
-0.7264987230300903,
-0.15189562737941742,
0.24690930545330048,
0.6043410301208496,
0.578652560710907,
-0.02771073393523693,
-0.3396560847759247,
-0.8566997647285461,
-0.07545772939920425,
0.02169712819159031,
-0.1682242751121521,
-0.07484202086925507,
0.18136636912822723,
-0.362190842628479,
0.8698298931121826,
-0.2944141626358032,
-0.14780452847480774,
-0.4155048429965973,
0.11880079656839371,
0.35145026445388794,
0.4137691557407379,
0.38540393114089966,
-0.8886982202529907,
-0.09409066289663315,
0.08164213597774506,
-0.4357292652130127,
0.2960484027862549,
0.10381148755550385,
0.023745838552713394,
-0.08718276768922806,
0.43357646465301514,
-0.8465670347213745,
0.28566423058509827,
0.6766124963760376,
-0.2630097568035126,
0.16740021109580994,
-0.14653468132019043,
-0.12591338157653809,
-1.1810821294784546,
-0.18400025367736816,
0.26289331912994385,
-0.23902179300785065,
-0.7853729724884033,
0.06600255519151688,
0.1777259111404419,
-0.28320884704589844,
-0.22408416867256165,
0.2813447117805481,
-0.41859206557273865,
0.07902539521455765,
-0.008280090987682343,
0.11013658344745636,
-0.038438256829977036,
0.3701321482658386,
-0.0862993448972702,
0.3775925636291504,
0.8878991007804871,
-0.5145940780639648,
0.16885840892791748,
0.13364186882972717,
0.16199131309986115,
0.4879111647605896,
-1.093672275543213,
0.005576453637331724,
-0.4387558102607727,
0.1392166018486023,
-1.3098700046539307,
-0.0926988497376442,
-0.10064465552568436,
-0.5508247017860413,
0.6812122464179993,
-0.3769381642341614,
-0.09847086668014526,
-0.5439833402633667,
-0.09874092787504196,
0.3867727816104889,
1.0022852420806885,
-0.6796641945838928,
0.7336664199829102,
0.5883945226669312,
0.02693210169672966,
-0.6705562472343445,
-0.7338240742683411,
-0.06352982670068741,
-0.21079766750335693,
-0.7255663871765137,
0.1514255851507187,
0.027028577402234077,
-0.0034955181181430817,
-0.09103353321552277,
-0.034970223903656006,
-0.06183385103940964,
-0.031912390142679214,
0.3811154067516327,
-0.07474567741155624,
-0.5261890292167664,
0.13812047243118286,
0.29455262422561646,
-0.5185749530792236,
0.16339178383350372,
-0.33064785599708557,
0.3499126136302948,
-0.38894322514533997,
-0.27008986473083496,
-0.218680277466774,
0.33493268489837646,
1.0561976432800293,
-0.3383197784423828,
0.666313648223877,
0.7830577492713928,
-0.22189317643642426,
-0.06286061555147171,
-0.308220237493515,
-0.5603818297386169,
-0.5235267281532288,
0.3781713545322418,
-0.35820475220680237,
-0.7899933457374573,
0.6578494310379028,
-0.39727675914764404,
0.2238806039094925,
0.6050596237182617,
0.5218736529350281,
-0.003845653962343931,
1.3593974113464355,
1.0408620834350586,
-0.23404107987880707,
0.22598087787628174,
-0.42449381947517395,
0.6729601621627808,
-0.7495825886726379,
-0.19805443286895752,
-0.4024139642715454,
-0.5186203122138977,
-0.36176690459251404,
-0.24738305807113647,
0.11314705014228821,
0.4152064025402069,
-0.5267809629440308,
0.36007070541381836,
-0.7136645913124084,
0.4470529854297638,
0.23697321116924286,
-0.07380464673042297,
0.15666018426418304,
0.06117454916238785,
0.07532241195440292,
-0.06214413419365883,
-0.6181593537330627,
-0.2744538187980652,
0.7571659684181213,
0.8747371435165405,
0.9307463765144348,
-0.012404827401041985,
0.12793271243572235,
-0.07306166738271713,
0.47137463092803955,
-0.7264145016670227,
0.29595351219177246,
-0.22580206394195557,
-0.47513651847839355,
-0.6234005093574524,
-0.15178854763507843,
-1.0667365789413452,
0.145247682929039,
0.007718442007899284,
-0.7295595407485962,
0.35063689947128296,
0.29979291558265686,
-0.06388254463672638,
0.32651373744010925,
-0.5312693119049072,
0.8209590315818787,
-0.07959778606891632,
-0.1671353429555893,
0.08261324465274811,
-0.9219253063201904,
0.1772640198469162,
0.19534727931022644,
0.3496816158294678,
-0.08274678140878677,
-0.024331610649824142,
0.47736576199531555,
0.12183461338281631,
0.9199535250663757,
-0.041553519666194916,
-0.3689071238040924,
0.305545836687088,
0.20018431544303894,
0.3794397711753845,
0.3329654037952423,
0.00822055246680975,
0.3295150697231293,
-0.4590740203857422,
-0.32095572352409363,
-0.7273203730583191,
0.40604233741760254,
-1.0408101081848145,
-0.3072673976421356,
0.2939586937427521,
-0.39370840787887573,
-0.07339388132095337,
0.18526741862297058,
0.7431996464729309,
0.6184934377670288,
-0.019129576161503792,
0.5194253325462341,
0.6858837604522705,
0.32840386033058167,
0.6720940470695496,
0.15147681534290314,
-0.3249911069869995,
-0.5360704660415649,
0.5890039801597595,
0.07770297676324844,
0.3518613278865814,
0.32311636209487915,
0.10539291054010391,
-0.48112908005714417,
-0.5169225931167603,
-0.3639658987522125,
-0.02293975278735161,
-1.0308676958084106,
-0.27056580781936646,
-0.6445561647415161,
-0.5909686088562012,
-0.15946823358535767,
-0.12522616982460022,
-0.9255028367042542,
-0.3683214485645294,
0.040745995938777924,
-0.2667945623397827,
0.24729366600513458,
0.664280354976654,
0.13848371803760529,
0.7572654485702515,
-0.6269658803939819,
0.23678138852119446,
0.23798364400863647,
0.6299750804901123,
0.08182989060878754,
-0.8114100098609924,
-0.35402804613113403,
0.11052116751670837,
-0.2286049872636795,
-0.7401835918426514,
0.2312890589237213,
0.17610043287277222,
0.712835431098938,
0.45441916584968567,
0.005197819322347641,
0.47454553842544556,
-0.5231390595436096,
0.8095620274543762,
0.3079812228679657,
-1.0399291515350342,
0.43615567684173584,
-0.45232853293418884,
0.4134804606437683,
0.27204617857933044,
0.31466028094291687,
-0.5818624496459961,
-0.5531324148178101,
-0.6063938736915588,
-1.0463169813156128,
0.20252758264541626,
0.29015737771987915,
0.6769879460334778,
0.040287602692842484,
0.305541455745697,
-0.02088237553834915,
0.04299559444189072,
-0.9304127097129822,
-0.44824105501174927,
-0.39855682849884033,
-0.30210837721824646,
-0.14218628406524658,
-0.4553356170654297,
-0.17740043997764587,
-0.5610832571983337,
0.2411702275276184,
-0.2150171846151352,
0.5707511305809021,
0.0009047299972735345,
0.008862070739269257,
-0.4783986210823059,
0.2874516248703003,
0.4252015948295593,
0.5767201781272888,
0.04806620627641678,
0.3455328047275543,
0.1703239530324936,
-0.5749232172966003,
0.3715997636318207,
-0.10480664670467377,
-0.042682111263275146,
-0.09004154801368713,
0.27595654129981995,
0.8690472841262817,
0.6280840635299683,
-0.16227222979068756,
0.5548132658004761,
-0.42099931836128235,
-0.08360059559345245,
-0.2146918922662735,
-0.24909204244613647,
0.19220122694969177,
0.1989945024251938,
0.48738306760787964,
0.291596382856369,
-0.21006110310554504,
-0.08165965974330902,
0.31135332584381104,
0.21055325865745544,
-0.6585633754730225,
-0.666236937046051,
0.9191914200782776,
0.21881350874900818,
-0.47815725207328796,
0.8407709002494812,
0.24129927158355713,
-0.4019690155982971,
0.5268505215644836,
0.8525400757789612,
0.9235838651657104,
-0.4741246700286865,
0.26559019088745117,
0.15454480051994324,
0.5661523342132568,
-0.33878910541534424,
0.17711034417152405,
0.17058803141117096,
-0.7454494833946228,
-0.6889203786849976,
-0.6372882127761841,
-0.19197997450828552,
0.008056916296482086,
-0.6721271872520447,
0.26396748423576355,
-0.241295725107193,
-0.3858143389225006,
-0.12220432609319687,
-0.4189452528953552,
-0.6022008657455444,
0.4530385136604309,
0.09347593784332275,
0.7397462129592896,
-0.8508081436157227,
0.6906648874282837,
0.5846455693244934,
-0.37642142176628113,
-0.9148112535476685,
-0.1843874305486679,
-0.5014082193374634,
-0.41604700684547424,
0.6698362231254578,
0.13998129963874817,
-0.20946452021598816,
0.37255021929740906,
-0.6361967921257019,
-1.2998696565628052,
1.0565437078475952,
0.6314429640769958,
-0.6086540222167969,
0.007564477622509003,
0.15353916585445404,
0.7727291584014893,
-0.30410823225975037,
0.44386541843414307,
0.6077487468719482,
0.3823763430118561,
0.2656421661376953,
-0.6413469910621643,
-0.11989006400108337,
-0.21917805075645447,
0.12182248383760452,
0.5176147222518921,
-0.455110102891922,
0.9667708277702332,
-0.40108317136764526,
-0.20589229464530945,
-0.04396156966686249,
0.7661194801330566,
-0.34524771571159363,
0.05840915068984032,
0.32732972502708435,
0.6125866174697876,
0.3304727077484131,
-0.377102792263031,
0.9648752212524414,
-0.6165385842323303,
0.7438540458679199,
0.7765507698059082,
0.23341992497444153,
0.893072247505188,
0.3822161555290222,
-0.15043604373931885,
0.27435824275016785,
0.4412071704864502,
-0.0070278225466609,
0.36180052161216736,
-0.024708053097128868,
0.13683710992336273,
-0.2308943271636963,
0.08689381182193756,
-0.46718069911003113,
0.24182549118995667,
0.3555040657520294,
-0.4599606990814209,
-0.29956263303756714,
0.23832669854164124,
0.013343227095901966,
-0.04939825087785721,
-0.3355589210987091,
0.4437553882598877,
0.24590733647346497,
-0.30546990036964417,
0.5318673849105835,
-0.2388232946395874,
0.401179701089859,
-0.3483600616455078,
0.24567662179470062,
-0.42681071162223816,
0.41202202439308167,
-0.12359703332185745,
-0.9321589469909668,
0.41980427503585815,
-0.49909016489982605,
-0.36868536472320557,
-0.17798925936222076,
0.9503082036972046,
-0.5257149338722229,
-0.6216297745704651,
0.5895431637763977,
0.41040724515914917,
-0.09344294667243958,
0.10974843055009842,
-0.451980322599411,
0.25136834383010864,
-0.5159151554107666,
-0.6800498962402344,
0.12275227159261703,
0.39513757824897766,
0.15152999758720398,
0.7354810833930969,
0.5828752517700195,
-0.21746870875358582,
0.4257233738899231,
0.27178239822387695,
0.8968653082847595,
-0.6196163296699524,
-0.1894126534461975,
-0.7753599286079407,
0.9879568219184875,
-0.10366728901863098,
-0.22198648750782013,
0.6516832709312439,
0.2522324323654175,
0.6207208633422852,
-0.10205867886543274,
0.4260372817516327,
0.3172447383403778,
0.017879216000437737,
-0.07536674290895462,
0.8709701895713806,
-0.3216661214828491,
0.19806550443172455,
-0.2989581823348999,
-1.1446579694747925,
-0.7085871696472168,
0.29516294598579407,
-0.18883050978183746,
0.1288069486618042,
0.4044865667819977,
0.5527677536010742,
-0.15379197895526886,
0.013117187656462193,
0.5337831377983093,
0.2937345802783966,
0.5023584365844727,
0.2795688509941101,
0.7951115965843201,
-0.7920609712600708,
0.8152456283569336,
-0.4521612823009491,
0.11282412707805634,
-0.061806581914424896,
-0.7181288599967957,
-0.8014522790908813,
-0.5306225419044495,
-0.31200364232063293,
-0.26122552156448364,
-0.03385123983025551,
0.2630099654197693,
0.9393209218978882,
-0.6094812154769897,
-0.06530232727527618,
-0.5545076727867126,
0.08857548981904984,
-0.21341374516487122,
-0.22494858503341675,
0.285106360912323,
-0.6056709885597229,
-0.5258353352546692,
0.14073848724365234,
0.4630427658557892,
0.24991385638713837,
-0.4375962018966675,
-0.17888124287128448,
0.35959550738334656,
0.16574715077877045,
0.8167452812194824,
0.24535003304481506,
-0.6419559121131897,
-0.41113147139549255,
0.1807437688112259,
-0.15419794619083405,
0.2273079752922058,
0.6340099573135376,
-0.8585208654403687,
0.14605015516281128,
0.2605021297931671,
0.7523500919342041,
0.2591250538825989,
-0.2303345501422882,
0.7114301919937134,
-0.6956079602241516,
0.25199341773986816,
0.21150954067707062,
0.38760024309158325,
0.35169756412506104,
-0.33220553398132324,
0.42306238412857056,
0.018419012427330017,
-0.7628269791603088,
-0.8168808221817017,
0.3704194724559784,
-0.9145586490631104,
-0.004741853568702936,
0.8550845384597778,
0.032861217856407166,
-0.29000017046928406,
0.051626380532979965,
-0.1527923047542572,
0.4279690980911255,
-0.1827368289232254,
0.7319449782371521,
0.28982824087142944,
0.049271728843450546,
-0.7314264178276062,
-0.2088782787322998,
0.3538832664489746,
0.37211084365844727,
-0.4303390681743622,
0.1481781154870987,
-0.008779101073741913,
0.24633492529392242,
0.4752441942691803,
0.11649703234434128,
-0.25316211581230164,
0.14602306485176086,
0.1521953046321869,
-0.12066435068845749,
0.16590742766857147,
-0.6585697531700134,
-0.5206255316734314,
0.45673879981040955,
0.09248895943164825,
-0.1165580227971077
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09631v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09631v1
|
3D-VLA: A 3D Vision-Language-Action Generative World Model
| 2024-03-14T17:58:41 | 2024-03-14T17:58:41 |
Haoyu Zhen, Xiaowen Qiu, Peihao Chen, Jincheng Yang, Xin Yan, Yilun Du, Yining Hong, Chuang Gan
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.RO
|
Recent vision-language-action (VLA) models rely on 2D inputs, lacking
integration with the broader realm of the 3D physical world. Furthermore, they
perform action prediction by learning a direct mapping from perception to
action, neglecting the vast dynamics of the world and the relations between
actions and dynamics. In contrast, human beings are endowed with world models
that depict imagination about future scenarios to plan actions accordingly. To
this end, we propose 3D-VLA by introducing a new family of embodied foundation
models that seamlessly link 3D perception, reasoning, and action through a
generative world model. Specifically, 3D-VLA is built on top of a 3D-based
large language model (LLM), and a set of interaction tokens is introduced to
engage with the embodied environment. Furthermore, to inject generation
abilities into the model, we train a series of embodied diffusion models and
align them into the LLM for predicting the goal images and point clouds. To
train our 3D-VLA, we curate a large-scale 3D embodied instruction dataset by
extracting vast 3D-related information from existing robotics datasets. Our
experiments on held-in datasets demonstrate that 3D-VLA significantly improves
the reasoning, multimodal generation, and planning capabilities in embodied
environments, showcasing its potential in real-world applications.
|
[
-0.20781461894512177,
-0.8978952169418335,
0.760524332523346,
0.04275137186050415,
-0.020501112565398216,
-0.1622556746006012,
0.6136037111282349,
-0.7231259942054749,
0.2297588437795639,
0.6912626028060913,
-0.44304540753364563,
-0.42379093170166016,
-0.37013232707977295,
-0.15408319234848022,
-0.3596106171607971,
0.23250587284564972,
-0.028462527319788933,
0.07235002517700195,
-0.2710154354572296,
-0.059091053903102875,
-0.2644788324832916,
-0.5356695055961609,
-0.31053945422172546,
-0.37226250767707825,
0.48590168356895447,
0.2102762758731842,
0.6642177104949951,
0.48181813955307007,
0.25408250093460083,
0.34557655453681946,
-0.08175752311944962,
0.21378739178180695,
-0.3045061230659485,
-0.13598592579364777,
-0.040972959250211716,
-0.38127973675727844,
-0.7053957581520081,
-0.36587050557136536,
0.51087486743927,
0.7822378873825073,
-0.18284070491790771,
-0.07966534048318863,
-0.037431150674819946,
0.77032470703125,
-0.9055774211883545,
0.2736765146255493,
-0.09528558701276779,
0.38157716393470764,
0.24101942777633667,
0.18357525765895844,
-0.13567106425762177,
-0.16108213365077972,
0.2386568784713745,
-0.7219316363334656,
0.19313018023967743,
-0.10648570954799652,
0.5034997463226318,
0.20539987087249756,
-0.2992396950721741,
0.024646306410431862,
-0.829670786857605,
0.32763174176216125,
-0.4247150123119354,
0.57627272605896,
0.2533710300922394,
0.5174315571784973,
-0.014370321296155453,
-0.5648921132087708,
-1.045062780380249,
-0.13766638934612274,
0.1657799929380417,
0.34954389929771423,
-0.11812994629144669,
0.18219763040542603,
0.192612424492836,
0.25418490171432495,
-0.5277532935142517,
0.07983046025037766,
-0.6855128407478333,
0.11945288628339767,
0.6149615049362183,
0.30090299248695374,
0.3678056001663208,
-0.11783679574728012,
-0.5940899848937988,
-0.3168909549713135,
-0.9366503357887268,
-0.03988039121031761,
0.037857621908187866,
0.3291827440261841,
-0.526988685131073,
1.0321866273880005,
-0.2680845558643341,
1.131049633026123,
-0.3275492191314697,
0.011751298792660236,
0.2417958378791809,
-0.04040015861392021,
-0.5951323509216309,
-0.18133030831813812,
0.6237732172012329,
0.5522254705429077,
0.029426494613289833,
0.1555067002773285,
-0.05837181210517883,
0.07969861477613449,
0.43057361245155334,
-0.6246176958084106,
-0.08015814423561096,
0.344067245721817,
-0.23700650036334991,
-0.13311943411827087,
0.02032514661550522,
-0.78571617603302,
-0.7339776158332825,
-0.6295174360275269,
0.5722939968109131,
-0.34096887707710266,
-0.49843308329582214,
0.6501742601394653,
-0.10502120852470398,
0.5326375365257263,
0.681930661201477,
-0.7855507135391235,
0.06234193593263626,
0.4018372595310211,
0.8621930480003357,
-0.01571640931069851,
-0.375767320394516,
-0.4246217906475067,
0.4752148687839508,
-0.4857563078403473,
0.6994982361793518,
-0.5217352509498596,
-0.5768570303916931,
0.3232395052909851,
-0.15765506029129028,
0.03489021584391594,
-0.4543456435203552,
-0.04962325096130371,
-0.34444287419319153,
0.2188621163368225,
-0.11156438291072845,
-0.26749563217163086,
-0.563984215259552,
0.37079882621765137,
-0.9998366236686707,
0.6546132564544678,
0.2493313103914261,
-0.2930757403373718,
0.3873429000377655,
-0.7944321632385254,
-0.3287699222564697,
0.2656039893627167,
-0.366800993680954,
-0.1375879943370819,
0.1661362200975418,
0.1145835816860199,
0.6309258937835693,
-0.32724621891975403,
0.015503398142755032,
-0.4640336036682129,
-0.395713746547699,
-0.2411787360906601,
-0.18098793923854828,
0.6639734506607056,
0.006833829451352358,
-0.28366559743881226,
0.16430453956127167,
-0.6616818308830261,
-0.2417691946029663,
0.18441994488239288,
-0.18366171419620514,
-0.1036372110247612,
0.0027457866817712784,
-0.12186918407678604,
0.3902215361595154,
0.14967848360538483,
-0.4314805269241333,
0.2060924470424652,
-0.6253473162651062,
-0.01026324275881052,
0.5768036842346191,
-0.3894415497779846,
0.60698002576828,
-0.10987818986177444,
0.6508742570877075,
0.08919820189476013,
0.15622134506702423,
-0.14481660723686218,
-0.6790310740470886,
-0.8416981101036072,
-0.1295071840286255,
-0.46737879514694214,
0.4882844090461731,
-1.0426045656204224,
0.3290727436542511,
-0.32956841588020325,
-0.43794670701026917,
-0.16853109002113342,
0.054342154413461685,
0.5010532140731812,
0.3346828520298004,
0.36801496148109436,
0.014191973954439163,
-0.5353608131408691,
-0.755615770816803,
0.39087194204330444,
-0.3173844516277313,
-0.15831421315670013,
0.05915306881070137,
0.48644116520881653,
-0.19052648544311523,
0.957321286201477,
-0.4064662754535675,
-0.3781658411026001,
-0.5863075852394104,
-0.19776663184165955,
-0.06141050532460213,
0.18260720372200012,
0.6616829037666321,
-1.1172667741775513,
-0.0986793041229248,
0.28944140672683716,
-1.1638457775115967,
0.3547503352165222,
0.06374719738960266,
-0.17668753862380981,
0.08031269162893295,
0.5967161059379578,
-0.6625673770904541,
0.602889358997345,
0.788635790348053,
-0.388207346200943,
0.20812202990055084,
-0.2954936623573303,
-0.17947043478488922,
-1.225219488143921,
0.04019484668970108,
0.026669608429074287,
0.20590636134147644,
-0.6424935460090637,
0.28741592168807983,
-0.059254907071590424,
-0.28226450085639954,
-0.8834339380264282,
1.0755895376205444,
-0.38290977478027344,
-0.48081234097480774,
-0.2506023347377777,
0.14845356345176697,
0.15684151649475098,
0.6210410594940186,
0.6724537014961243,
0.3520013988018036,
0.8266169428825378,
-1.0708935260772705,
0.3972293734550476,
0.47721442580223083,
-0.5256989002227783,
0.3803638219833374,
-0.5726880431175232,
-0.16114495694637299,
-0.16826674342155457,
0.27074435353279114,
-0.6265848278999329,
-0.45407307147979736,
0.3232985734939575,
-0.25227412581443787,
-0.0429137721657753,
-0.036465536803007126,
-0.30408957600593567,
-0.6348589658737183,
0.057200413197278976,
0.2819806933403015,
0.307693749666214,
-0.706221878528595,
1.2325602769851685,
0.3612547814846039,
0.2556556761264801,
-0.5776592493057251,
-0.7999005913734436,
-0.07033426314592361,
0.007923712953925133,
-0.5072875022888184,
0.35112282633781433,
-0.18797077238559723,
-0.3171123266220093,
-0.15216483175754547,
-0.02186047099530697,
-0.053734149783849716,
0.03681115433573723,
0.46738070249557495,
0.4492281973361969,
-0.27359646558761597,
-0.3022327721118927,
-0.007457636296749115,
-0.08598640561103821,
0.09437219053506851,
-0.03164556249976158,
0.4735789895057678,
-0.10733196884393692,
-0.6638730764389038,
-0.33042970299720764,
0.265957772731781,
0.927802324295044,
-0.04957013577222824,
0.719926655292511,
0.2773776054382324,
-0.564358115196228,
-0.08669503778219223,
-0.08001957833766937,
0.17882458865642548,
-0.4841398298740387,
0.5267075896263123,
-0.4869292974472046,
-0.669985830783844,
0.060490529984235764,
-0.06462002545595169,
0.31210488080978394,
0.059755660593509674,
0.5901739597320557,
-0.2722010612487793,
0.9609972834587097,
0.8638594746589661,
0.3997567594051361,
0.42057159543037415,
-0.7517364025115967,
0.2782101035118103,
-1.0983058214187622,
-0.614630401134491,
-0.016227032989263535,
-0.3347984254360199,
-0.033988311886787415,
-0.8800783753395081,
0.3090541362762451,
0.26488175988197327,
-0.41430985927581787,
0.40221208333969116,
-0.16804763674736023,
0.39706477522850037,
0.3577525019645691,
-0.028844056650996208,
-0.1593727022409439,
0.027966435998678207,
-0.15516136586666107,
0.3401017487049103,
-0.5962775945663452,
-0.5809571743011475,
0.8355607390403748,
-0.020186491310596466,
0.45151305198669434,
0.4652256369590759,
0.49120622873306274,
0.2267947643995285,
0.20419907569885254,
-0.7797362208366394,
0.8316043615341187,
-0.01631838269531727,
-0.1702616810798645,
-0.2016821652650833,
0.03575989976525307,
-0.9338485598564148,
0.6517688035964966,
-0.431991845369339,
-0.7089269757270813,
0.28844159841537476,
0.48781120777130127,
-0.7274372577667236,
0.5001834034919739,
-0.7640129327774048,
0.7944920659065247,
-0.38870126008987427,
-0.478222131729126,
-0.14309558272361755,
-0.45999354124069214,
0.5481452941894531,
0.12371554225683212,
0.1591603308916092,
-0.008641938678920269,
0.0611405149102211,
0.02655433490872383,
-0.13511385023593903,
1.0842735767364502,
-0.3577224612236023,
-0.5433410406112671,
0.2593381404876709,
0.2621469497680664,
0.27505022287368774,
-0.07011212408542633,
-0.011995562352240086,
0.31080639362335205,
-0.5405443906784058,
-0.15969300270080566,
-0.6260457634925842,
0.49238112568855286,
-0.6728829741477966,
-0.6124825477600098,
-0.2881377041339874,
-0.29691582918167114,
-0.3877629339694977,
0.06044534593820572,
0.1339522898197174,
0.38691508769989014,
-0.5335742235183716,
0.21846088767051697,
0.6121340394020081,
-0.5057945847511292,
0.345817506313324,
0.6590332984924316,
-0.6824443340301514,
-0.10708577930927277,
0.9009318351745605,
-0.37299492955207825,
0.3329891264438629,
0.854069709777832,
0.1116497591137886,
-0.3287920653820038,
-0.302189439535141,
-0.5817156434059143,
-0.052707791328430176,
-0.5923740267753601,
-0.10788634419441223,
-0.8251457214355469,
-0.4389454424381256,
-0.3109605014324188,
-0.6330298185348511,
-0.3342006504535675,
-0.210928276181221,
-0.23405618965625763,
-0.48507535457611084,
0.10362832993268967,
1.0551795959472656,
-0.22773998975753784,
0.32047951221466064,
-0.6685976386070251,
1.0002793073654175,
0.6611959338188171,
0.16975221037864685,
-0.02520175278186798,
-0.21683309972286224,
-0.20450739562511444,
0.36991560459136963,
-0.20667563378810883,
-0.4057357907295227,
0.5166691541671753,
0.172438383102417,
0.4815647006034851,
0.2911868095397949,
-0.3289470672607422,
0.7734547853469849,
-0.5290495157241821,
1.0161107778549194,
0.5154592394828796,
-0.6208475828170776,
0.6488714814186096,
-0.2525215148925781,
0.32538339495658875,
-0.24560843408107758,
0.30718740820884705,
-0.2648700773715973,
-0.1731058657169342,
-0.40008988976478577,
-0.8277787566184998,
0.7430671453475952,
0.08555302768945694,
0.2503940463066101,
-0.01883089356124401,
0.05040940269827843,
0.058727364987134933,
-0.061262018978595734,
-0.7694959044456482,
-0.029190421104431152,
-0.4564787447452545,
-0.03979760408401489,
-0.012095753103494644,
-0.34093064069747925,
-0.06661545485258102,
-0.2576991617679596,
0.2908329367637634,
-0.39169642329216003,
0.30048248171806335,
-0.09148426353931427,
-0.10465265065431595,
0.07602227479219437,
-0.35407310724258423,
0.7871547937393188,
0.5201436877250671,
0.03242996335029602,
-0.0460323803126812,
0.015267948620021343,
-0.42238447070121765,
0.013966820202767849,
-0.08012501895427704,
0.003779781749472022,
-0.2896156311035156,
0.41253146529197693,
1.0436244010925293,
0.3271983563899994,
-0.8325214982032776,
0.4809317886829376,
0.038464419543743134,
-0.43942832946777344,
-0.5682399868965149,
0.3475598394870758,
0.2921904921531677,
0.424469530582428,
0.07704386115074158,
0.2268664687871933,
0.15144610404968262,
-0.34142112731933594,
0.023298390209674835,
0.12430964410305023,
-0.4193117916584015,
-0.4268128275871277,
0.7889481782913208,
0.41002705693244934,
-0.17932185530662537,
0.570225715637207,
0.13077335059642792,
-0.24503691494464874,
0.7623293399810791,
0.5286132097244263,
0.8888887166976929,
-0.3496372699737549,
0.44579946994781494,
0.8022862076759338,
0.09409716725349426,
-0.14996063709259033,
0.5358095169067383,
-0.1615438610315323,
-1.0925383567810059,
-0.2713817059993744,
-0.883618950843811,
-0.31854215264320374,
0.2357056587934494,
-0.6069180965423584,
0.3582858443260193,
-0.455181747674942,
0.32472702860832214,
-0.3091311454772949,
-0.570504903793335,
-0.729213535785675,
0.44533756375312805,
0.6058669686317444,
0.6176364421844482,
-0.7704358696937561,
0.9662581086158752,
0.5887047052383423,
-0.4841381013393402,
-0.22433455288410187,
-0.05752984806895256,
0.20377536118030548,
-1.0857877731323242,
0.837934136390686,
0.39049944281578064,
-0.7311546206474304,
-0.11960947513580322,
-0.3936403691768646,
-1.0025601387023926,
1.1898730993270874,
0.4739915430545807,
-0.7074301838874817,
-0.176626518368721,
0.18604987859725952,
0.4246992766857147,
-0.2820018529891968,
-0.22871658205986023,
0.17913301289081573,
0.1877911388874054,
0.5088138580322266,
-0.4703572392463684,
-0.47319233417510986,
-0.5071850419044495,
0.24170644581317902,
0.018331697210669518,
-0.5514451265335083,
0.6620572209358215,
-0.5879793763160706,
-0.24180151522159576,
0.2628372609615326,
0.953477680683136,
0.7048337459564209,
0.001596717513166368,
0.5460864305496216,
0.5497815608978271,
0.4236912131309509,
0.0576770156621933,
1.306334137916565,
-0.13062040507793427,
-0.2690867483615875,
1.2051656246185303,
-0.7575167417526245,
1.0478370189666748,
0.216256245970726,
0.10219574719667435,
0.573676586151123,
0.18944059312343597,
0.3121455907821655,
0.5801541209220886,
0.13560061156749725,
-0.3869902193546295,
-0.3815377652645111,
0.1788184642791748,
-0.20197708904743195,
0.7250329852104187,
0.773890495300293,
0.04467349499464035,
-0.03680507838726044,
0.3656076192855835,
-0.4285351037979126,
0.17827443778514862,
-0.17941401898860931,
0.6146039366722107,
-0.005703495815396309,
-0.4308816194534302,
0.32773256301879883,
-0.36973875761032104,
0.3546602427959442,
-0.7686468958854675,
-0.5849362015724182,
-0.38180428743362427,
0.19045618176460266,
0.16644421219825745,
-0.9542442560195923,
0.33983659744262695,
-0.04217524081468582,
0.0035639642737805843,
-0.45559319853782654,
0.19860775768756866,
-0.2924121916294098,
-0.5189156532287598,
0.49258050322532654,
0.5305681824684143,
-0.004151417873799801,
0.10752305388450623,
-0.695112943649292,
0.15442901849746704,
-0.09846042841672897,
-0.1887863725423813,
0.27101191878318787,
0.4712556004524231,
-0.09420747309923172,
0.890414297580719,
0.49640265107154846,
-0.22045525908470154,
-0.07335534691810608,
0.06301437318325043,
0.6534930467605591,
-0.7161411046981812,
-0.3755796253681183,
-0.42198219895362854,
0.743309497833252,
-0.04833623021841049,
-0.34346482157707214,
0.43452340364456177,
0.6157910227775574,
0.8401253819465637,
-0.06692838668823242,
0.9221283197402954,
-0.4057488739490509,
0.06947723776102066,
-0.8677123188972473,
0.48954474925994873,
-0.9251696467399597,
0.019395453855395317,
-0.19150282442569733,
-0.9410434365272522,
-0.4935548007488251,
0.877870500087738,
0.0729733556509018,
0.21824656426906586,
0.39817681908607483,
0.6830877065658569,
-0.16808360815048218,
-0.16761229932308197,
0.8192286491394043,
0.08642951399087906,
0.3795790672302246,
0.5606677532196045,
0.8264881372451782,
-0.29357174038887024,
0.13623486459255219,
-0.1502285897731781,
-0.003945737145841122,
-0.2899727523326874,
-0.6856414079666138,
-0.7169621586799622,
-0.8982030749320984,
-0.19625428318977356,
-0.09058671444654465,
-0.04273803532123566,
0.5263015627861023,
0.7047919034957886,
-0.49401482939720154,
-0.3316883444786072,
-0.4787454605102539,
-0.09945032745599747,
-0.3793178200721741,
-0.14749884605407715,
0.25455865263938904,
0.14502134919166565,
-0.9047240018844604,
0.9127988219261169,
0.508224606513977,
0.4022786021232605,
-0.5232709050178528,
-0.3647800385951996,
-0.07929081469774246,
-0.1557120680809021,
1.1372814178466797,
0.5938337445259094,
-0.9657174348831177,
-0.1955488622188568,
-0.04949971288442612,
-0.00519957672804594,
-0.14641249179840088,
0.594468355178833,
-0.9922752380371094,
0.8061990737915039,
0.2793596088886261,
0.34407123923301697,
0.45636215806007385,
-0.3848622441291809,
1.2323392629623413,
-0.47255516052246094,
0.3933356702327728,
0.12472424656152725,
0.6176230311393738,
0.40657031536102295,
-0.05219045281410217,
0.7294014096260071,
-0.04818166047334671,
0.1735752373933792,
-0.4841850697994232,
0.44738274812698364,
-0.9917796850204468,
-0.3505990207195282,
1.1651403903961182,
0.04501938819885254,
-0.43915656208992004,
0.021286966279149055,
-0.39572665095329285,
-0.06380616128444672,
0.2814781069755554,
0.7028866410255432,
0.31706681847572327,
-0.028790270909667015,
-0.3279702663421631,
-0.6277852058410645,
0.4290263056755066,
0.028056930750608444,
-0.9253911375999451,
0.27172866463661194,
0.9240719676017761,
-0.3723389208316803,
0.23218810558319092,
0.5360201001167297,
-0.010895336046814919,
0.5760864615440369,
0.10010243207216263,
0.4869380593299866,
0.09577393531799316,
-0.6841843724250793,
-0.07239066809415817,
0.21704243123531342,
-0.3482971787452698,
-0.17268286645412445
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09629v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09629v2
|
Quiet-STaR: Language Models Can Teach Themselves to Think Before Speaking
| 2024-03-14T17:58:16 | 2024-03-18T07:56:48 |
Eric Zelikman, Georges Harik, Yijia Shao, Varuna Jayasiri, Nick Haber, Noah D. Goodman
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
When writing and talking, people sometimes pause to think. Although
reasoning-focused works have often framed reasoning as a method of answering
questions or completing agentic tasks, reasoning is implicit in almost all
written text. For example, this applies to the steps not stated between the
lines of a proof or to the theory of mind underlying a conversation. In the
Self-Taught Reasoner (STaR, Zelikman et al. 2022), useful thinking is learned
by inferring rationales from few-shot examples in question-answering and
learning from those that lead to a correct answer. This is a highly constrained
setting -- ideally, a language model could instead learn to infer unstated
rationales in arbitrary text. We present Quiet-STaR, a generalization of STaR
in which LMs learn to generate rationales at each token to explain future text,
improving their predictions. We address key challenges, including 1) the
computational cost of generating continuations, 2) the fact that the LM does
not initially know how to generate or use internal thoughts, and 3) the need to
predict beyond individual next tokens. To resolve these, we propose a tokenwise
parallel sampling algorithm, using learnable tokens indicating a thought's
start and end, and an extended teacher-forcing technique. Encouragingly,
generated rationales disproportionately help model difficult-to-predict tokens
and improve the LM's ability to directly answer difficult questions. In
particular, after continued pretraining of an LM on a corpus of internet text
with Quiet-STaR, we find zero-shot improvements on GSM8K
(5.9%$\rightarrow$10.9%) and CommonsenseQA (36.3%$\rightarrow$47.2%) and
observe a perplexity improvement of difficult tokens in natural text.
Crucially, these improvements require no fine-tuning on these tasks. Quiet-STaR
marks a step towards LMs that can learn to reason in a more general and
scalable way.
|
[
-0.43974703550338745,
-0.9814406633377075,
0.9212251901626587,
-0.22259029746055603,
-0.10647972673177719,
-0.11169236153364182,
-0.4910404086112976,
-0.35849636793136597,
0.012285858392715454,
0.5555487275123596,
-0.8198547959327698,
-0.3665141463279724,
-0.38454577326774597,
0.0729178711771965,
-0.18254317343235016,
1.0107150077819824,
-0.005254448391497135,
0.08180630952119827,
-0.0037402964662760496,
-0.0637894868850708,
-0.5740246176719666,
-0.4884200096130371,
-0.7282264828681946,
-0.2585641145706177,
0.7033871412277222,
0.734865128993988,
0.5525636672973633,
0.5771968364715576,
0.29060760140419006,
0.26988327503204346,
0.06388076394796371,
0.07174702733755112,
-0.6386679410934448,
0.4395206570625305,
-0.3368164598941803,
-0.838561475276947,
-0.09836193919181824,
0.07050430029630661,
0.4064440429210663,
0.9227645397186279,
0.2535874843597412,
0.24409306049346924,
-0.11203857511281967,
0.8251932859420776,
-0.6939489245414734,
0.3560069501399994,
-0.7949739694595337,
-0.13241827487945557,
-0.09785548597574234,
0.06656814366579056,
-0.45704376697540283,
-0.17125330865383148,
-0.01943795196712017,
-0.6409435272216797,
0.07242699712514877,
0.1505325585603714,
0.774790346622467,
0.3949248790740967,
-0.04376981779932976,
-0.4376707375049591,
-0.8638103604316711,
1.0110141038894653,
-0.4800839424133301,
0.3478693664073944,
0.5288974046707153,
0.32079800963401794,
-0.07121793925762177,
-0.8719935417175293,
-0.8178359270095825,
-0.2492498755455017,
-0.006165394559502602,
0.15908212959766388,
-0.04159872978925705,
0.09018877893686295,
0.5599573850631714,
0.1254846453666687,
-0.1997109055519104,
-0.1082598939538002,
-0.40600109100341797,
-0.12579725682735443,
0.37900781631469727,
0.11558748781681061,
0.10808897763490677,
-0.2487397938966751,
-0.21028369665145874,
-0.019390365108847618,
-0.5478255748748779,
0.408908486366272,
0.12445355951786041,
0.2859290540218353,
0.07940312474966049,
0.40090417861938477,
-0.3769274652004242,
0.5997234582901001,
0.05675478279590607,
-0.24722544848918915,
-0.10294415056705475,
-0.1887737363576889,
-0.31056368350982666,
-0.2400766909122467,
0.5229063034057617,
0.08558035641908646,
0.49847713112831116,
0.05736566707491875,
-0.39404213428497314,
0.48043280839920044,
0.02149590104818344,
-0.7575367093086243,
-0.38597363233566284,
0.42515015602111816,
-0.38667353987693787,
-0.096194326877594,
-0.24341772496700287,
-0.6298930644989014,
-0.3234829604625702,
-0.695343554019928,
0.5532552003860474,
-0.29440605640411377,
-0.05894765257835388,
0.15877209603786469,
0.12454894930124283,
-0.159625843167305,
0.4285462498664856,
-0.8352405428886414,
0.36815980076789856,
0.49833348393440247,
0.42884624004364014,
0.17331746220588684,
-0.457274854183197,
-0.5662586688995361,
-0.09447604417800903,
-0.5168938636779785,
1.023993968963623,
-0.646602213382721,
-0.15051791071891785,
-0.21122057735919952,
-0.2281477302312851,
-0.29029062390327454,
-0.36285653710365295,
0.7410052418708801,
-0.15396566689014435,
0.5608783960342407,
-0.5282503366470337,
-0.7568243145942688,
-0.3719312250614166,
0.1180994063615799,
-0.44187435507774353,
0.7552213668823242,
-0.016720212996006012,
-0.6815759539604187,
0.3018590211868286,
-0.4730815291404724,
-0.002219036454334855,
0.036312516778707504,
-0.45581939816474915,
-0.10683216899633408,
0.027214128524065018,
0.3920884430408478,
0.6024485230445862,
-0.22633975744247437,
0.1772923469543457,
-0.23775236308574677,
-0.614281415939331,
0.3638497591018677,
-0.29470813274383545,
0.49501916766166687,
0.4444696307182312,
-0.44894739985466003,
0.3486693203449249,
-0.45360949635505676,
0.30356264114379883,
0.10060670971870422,
0.12253894656896591,
-0.12137307226657867,
-0.019177716225385666,
-0.2997133135795593,
0.15133458375930786,
-0.16165287792682648,
-0.32075443863868713,
0.04746454581618309,
-0.45641377568244934,
0.36962005496025085,
0.6014912724494934,
-0.010146001353859901,
0.5490186810493469,
-0.6486364006996155,
0.4412784278392792,
-0.020748309791088104,
0.2744387090206146,
-0.6376612782478333,
-0.32892704010009766,
-1.3301283121109009,
-0.2641487717628479,
0.12950366735458374,
0.39815258979797363,
-0.7410012483596802,
-0.08669418096542358,
0.11337784677743912,
-0.4926549792289734,
-0.6197909712791443,
0.40912190079689026,
0.41810381412506104,
0.7136877179145813,
0.3872487246990204,
0.13875767588615417,
-0.36603403091430664,
-0.6930549144744873,
-0.5038229823112488,
-0.2708757221698761,
0.28713154792785645,
0.25188130140304565,
0.43837061524391174,
-0.04680158942937851,
0.7259935140609741,
-0.4960905909538269,
-0.13351427018642426,
-0.49480244517326355,
0.051192060112953186,
0.3544274568557739,
0.357243150472641,
0.15562598407268524,
-0.591469407081604,
-0.540949821472168,
-0.3771502375602722,
-0.7487821578979492,
-0.005213649943470955,
-0.40096554160118103,
-0.14354923367500305,
0.24544106423854828,
0.7404963970184326,
-0.8526158332824707,
0.16517473757266998,
-0.016970515251159668,
-0.5076475739479065,
0.6225093007087708,
0.007530551869422197,
-0.16187484562397003,
-0.8122615814208984,
0.15867917239665985,
-0.20396532118320465,
-0.15048126876354218,
-0.6218721866607666,
0.13535332679748535,
-0.10332504659891129,
-0.23410789668560028,
-0.30536630749702454,
0.7178009748458862,
-0.6023420095443726,
0.32317882776260376,
-0.6203905344009399,
0.2916838526725769,
-0.10031552612781525,
0.7326086163520813,
-0.036348339170217514,
0.6228572130203247,
0.6948668360710144,
-0.6069502830505371,
-0.08952806144952774,
-0.13770145177841187,
-0.3644132912158966,
0.31292465329170227,
-0.36457499861717224,
0.171444371342659,
-0.5238039493560791,
0.18180839717388153,
-0.7400447726249695,
-0.20684312283992767,
0.3770471513271332,
-0.4344284236431122,
0.10971524566411972,
-0.1457461714744568,
-0.1720770001411438,
-0.3459814786911011,
0.015397831797599792,
0.21592944860458374,
0.822607159614563,
-0.4322010576725006,
0.389835000038147,
0.3124774396419525,
-0.40260493755340576,
-0.8010571599006653,
-0.3370186686515808,
-0.11315053701400757,
0.001787684508599341,
-0.2718333601951599,
-0.1225738674402237,
-0.2497219443321228,
-0.626911997795105,
0.15900959074497223,
-0.17282606661319733,
-0.07419704645872116,
0.04588859900832176,
0.21074149012565613,
0.27981165051460266,
-0.32207852602005005,
0.5024794936180115,
-0.13363850116729736,
-0.270812451839447,
0.1154472678899765,
-0.4405573904514313,
0.3899373710155487,
-0.3974181115627289,
-0.250730037689209,
-0.4111463129520416,
0.27749332785606384,
0.5966655015945435,
-0.06395874172449112,
0.4834502637386322,
0.4488271474838257,
-0.37467625737190247,
-0.8372043967247009,
-0.680213451385498,
-0.4687390923500061,
-0.43544653058052063,
0.1645130217075348,
-0.43713581562042236,
-0.9668158888816833,
0.3873175382614136,
-0.09237567335367203,
0.07104472815990448,
0.4033772647380829,
0.49989432096481323,
-0.2609993815422058,
0.7877247929573059,
0.7760397791862488,
0.1822354644536972,
0.27803248167037964,
-0.3114304840564728,
0.20209002494812012,
-0.34663763642311096,
-0.16051743924617767,
-0.2589888274669647,
-0.19872410595417023,
-0.28120657801628113,
-0.640224039554596,
0.030452705919742584,
0.5637194514274597,
-0.2527026832103729,
-0.05930561199784279,
-0.567186176776886,
0.8352409601211548,
0.4308151602745056,
-0.10042940825223923,
0.1597522795200348,
-0.17681129276752472,
-0.4065200984477997,
-0.14533883333206177,
-0.7859340906143188,
-0.6333004832267761,
1.0719795227050781,
0.3354380130767822,
0.6126246452331543,
-0.2162860929965973,
0.7501221895217896,
-0.12280066311359406,
0.5819129943847656,
-0.8979575634002686,
0.680320143699646,
0.13887055218219757,
-0.5474650859832764,
-0.3575994372367859,
-0.3609141707420349,
-0.6981911659240723,
0.4130409359931946,
-0.35988810658454895,
-0.6988864541053772,
0.03114578127861023,
0.29222941398620605,
-0.4037395715713501,
0.3431795835494995,
-0.9184158444404602,
0.8069856762886047,
-0.0612463541328907,
-0.47312694787979126,
-0.2107185274362564,
-0.4042896330356598,
0.6401206254959106,
-0.22726085782051086,
0.3039343059062958,
-0.33239641785621643,
0.09110081940889359,
0.602869987487793,
-0.4574702978134155,
0.9074034690856934,
-0.16527420282363892,
0.29557114839553833,
0.7684091329574585,
0.16286036372184753,
0.5528658628463745,
0.07477634400129318,
0.047484058886766434,
-0.1966504007577896,
-0.10787088423967361,
-0.5685643553733826,
-0.720320463180542,
0.6572571992874146,
-0.6147422194480896,
-0.9036505222320557,
-0.3586553633213043,
-0.4691428244113922,
-0.23657701909542084,
0.3648987412452698,
0.24850650131702423,
0.23169423639774323,
-0.010226530954241753,
-0.08455731719732285,
0.6392375230789185,
0.12949301302433014,
0.6647744178771973,
0.4724607765674591,
-0.4812987446784973,
-0.4964739680290222,
0.8549296855926514,
0.17745138704776764,
0.16994640231132507,
0.2407820224761963,
0.46391811966896057,
-0.5092288255691528,
-0.40951111912727356,
-0.308277428150177,
0.4050777852535248,
-1.1023308038711548,
-0.005792793817818165,
-0.770322322845459,
-0.20772846043109894,
0.05903646722435951,
-0.33250781893730164,
-0.31307676434516907,
-0.5761982202529907,
-0.1505243331193924,
-0.0786222442984581,
0.17149564623832703,
0.8348377346992493,
0.12781524658203125,
0.17139025032520294,
-0.5294419527053833,
0.12859372794628143,
0.41716063022613525,
0.15864971280097961,
0.17717145383358002,
-0.3880414366722107,
-0.23133599758148193,
-0.05703938379883766,
-0.1845731884241104,
-0.6323212385177612,
0.2673419713973999,
-0.056942302733659744,
0.6026604175567627,
0.372969388961792,
0.2650552988052368,
0.5790867805480957,
-0.4122605323791504,
0.7296014428138733,
0.34971240162849426,
-1.0109164714813232,
0.4725136160850525,
-0.3076796233654022,
0.4308711588382721,
0.7222994565963745,
0.27874287962913513,
-0.5328072309494019,
-0.5356622338294983,
-0.6563950777053833,
-0.4572993814945221,
0.468599408864975,
0.36723893880844116,
-0.009259817190468311,
-0.05582211911678314,
0.48465585708618164,
0.295771062374115,
0.14182908833026886,
-0.7864592671394348,
-0.22150790691375732,
-0.4684446454048157,
-0.23623380064964294,
-0.36411547660827637,
-0.18113958835601807,
-0.0024097312707453966,
-0.41148608922958374,
0.45673444867134094,
-0.4053798019886017,
0.2592869699001312,
0.36491456627845764,
-0.11198166757822037,
-0.19517704844474792,
0.4523160755634308,
0.700127363204956,
0.7546294331550598,
0.02753058634698391,
0.4268985986709595,
0.22669294476509094,
-0.27923229336738586,
0.020561866462230682,
-0.04483042284846306,
-0.3243009150028229,
-0.05234932526946068,
0.33791980147361755,
0.874586820602417,
0.18004320561885834,
-0.7263872623443604,
0.4034677743911743,
-0.024808282032608986,
-0.3095589876174927,
-0.38877227902412415,
0.28881192207336426,
0.31981977820396423,
0.22767704725265503,
0.16126279532909393,
0.48673588037490845,
-0.2312622368335724,
-0.6024623513221741,
0.2323853224515915,
0.18877317011356354,
-0.5579962730407715,
-0.4565412402153015,
0.8258482813835144,
0.26289600133895874,
-0.27064913511276245,
0.3722623586654663,
-0.12678827345371246,
-0.47697940468788147,
0.44686993956565857,
0.5568165183067322,
1.1172616481781006,
0.23814570903778076,
0.24994134902954102,
0.47106584906578064,
0.21215489506721497,
-0.24295133352279663,
0.682553768157959,
-0.28156840801239014,
-0.803684651851654,
-0.6201962232589722,
-0.5064659118652344,
-0.5055140256881714,
0.3657492399215698,
-0.14591360092163086,
0.1548553854227066,
-0.7975976467132568,
-0.18257877230644226,
0.07140413671731949,
0.166372150182724,
-0.6953185200691223,
0.27242422103881836,
0.27752426266670227,
0.8260050415992737,
-0.536105751991272,
0.8315719962120056,
0.5617577433586121,
-0.6496871709823608,
-1.086230754852295,
0.17120134830474854,
-0.04416786506772041,
-0.6388844847679138,
0.7825018763542175,
0.41229334473609924,
-0.26941075921058655,
0.0747728943824768,
-0.5942520499229431,
-0.8873939514160156,
0.8222436308860779,
0.43887415528297424,
-0.7155042290687561,
0.18645596504211426,
-0.1003367155790329,
0.5170019268989563,
-0.38024038076400757,
0.45763832330703735,
0.04160384461283684,
0.4305275082588196,
0.03093808889389038,
-0.6962866187095642,
0.09251619875431061,
-0.2566719353199005,
-0.4803219139575958,
0.1509406417608261,
-0.8181460499763489,
1.108422875404358,
-0.6825248599052429,
-0.409707635641098,
0.057985059916973114,
0.6358078718185425,
0.23207731544971466,
0.37075889110565186,
0.5725348591804504,
0.4995935559272766,
1.195603370666504,
0.10241915285587311,
0.8964899182319641,
-0.4443780481815338,
0.12216569483280182,
0.990132212638855,
-0.16613106429576874,
0.9564450979232788,
0.4074198603630066,
0.2509746253490448,
0.6597779989242554,
0.41030946373939514,
0.1624118685722351,
0.17662301659584045,
0.11495428532361984,
-0.45751750469207764,
-0.6453097462654114,
-0.11653293669223785,
-0.1121617779135704,
0.40938547253608704,
0.37537723779678345,
-0.2544935643672943,
-0.19912207126617432,
-0.10852989554405212,
0.20843997597694397,
0.4567302167415619,
-0.5168116092681885,
0.5443317890167236,
0.47251036763191223,
-1.1361407041549683,
0.7483696341514587,
-0.13576604425907135,
0.41745850443840027,
-0.5465257167816162,
0.04057231917977333,
-0.26014620065689087,
0.46703076362609863,
0.008991957642138004,
-0.5858533382415771,
0.0613393597304821,
0.054029252380132675,
-0.4165412485599518,
-0.33639761805534363,
0.8837640285491943,
-0.42171862721443176,
-0.5250864624977112,
0.12713441252708435,
0.886554479598999,
0.30036190152168274,
0.04648492857813835,
-0.7801674008369446,
-0.0855664312839508,
0.03371570259332657,
-0.21832162141799927,
0.18841513991355896,
0.4396720230579376,
-0.09657543897628784,
0.9448737502098083,
0.9030422568321228,
0.15701055526733398,
-0.1510286182165146,
0.2447347491979599,
0.8674538731575012,
-0.9741750955581665,
-0.6159534454345703,
-0.7645679712295532,
0.3725489377975464,
0.018390176817774773,
-0.4900107979774475,
0.6678106784820557,
0.29371774196624756,
0.876053512096405,
-0.08747324347496033,
0.8029366135597229,
0.34443625807762146,
0.7288451194763184,
-0.7101885676383972,
0.8297169804573059,
-0.3395342230796814,
0.3179073631763458,
-0.11151427030563354,
-0.8490822315216064,
-0.07564640790224075,
0.5088019371032715,
-0.29501330852508545,
-0.09668590873479843,
1.207343339920044,
0.6715957522392273,
0.17917124927043915,
0.16889382898807526,
0.5917625427246094,
0.1305433213710785,
0.0030790013261139393,
0.6757411956787109,
1.0658464431762695,
-0.24007199704647064,
0.6156604886054993,
-0.3563830256462097,
-0.019511723890900612,
0.12087346613407135,
-0.5381865501403809,
-1.319818139076233,
-0.4408843517303467,
-0.16703763604164124,
-0.24208223819732666,
0.048354923725128174,
0.9538453221321106,
0.7014096975326538,
-0.815120279788971,
-0.19463349878787994,
-0.4336000382900238,
0.37943223118782043,
-0.230218768119812,
-0.19350109994411469,
0.38718321919441223,
-1.0344874858856201,
-0.706179141998291,
0.4412952959537506,
0.12093249708414078,
0.04242776706814766,
-0.30185484886169434,
-0.19861814379692078,
0.14503507316112518,
0.43084976077079773,
0.5082151889801025,
0.4867209196090698,
-0.9751431941986084,
-0.3201310932636261,
0.24486851692199707,
-0.12870454788208008,
-0.16200265288352966,
0.8570189476013184,
-1.0350042581558228,
0.6274023056030273,
0.372234582901001,
0.48933130502700806,
0.3736906349658966,
-0.057337842881679535,
0.4692450761795044,
-0.26663368940353394,
0.2370845228433609,
0.5129172205924988,
0.2815549373626709,
0.18425485491752625,
-0.22638143599033356,
0.19300156831741333,
0.6354327201843262,
-0.583537220954895,
-0.7822638154029846,
0.4406714141368866,
-0.74542236328125,
-0.7553116083145142,
1.0911513566970825,
-0.020763859152793884,
-0.3100394904613495,
-0.3332676291465759,
-0.2197590321302414,
-0.005290632601827383,
-0.3190518617630005,
0.6848127841949463,
0.7202413082122803,
-0.2193114161491394,
-0.49550437927246094,
-0.49086862802505493,
0.9533804059028625,
0.9000056982040405,
-0.6442668437957764,
0.1331600695848465,
0.3251313865184784,
0.26129889488220215,
0.04310307651758194,
0.9752786755561829,
0.22331295907497406,
0.18702344596385956,
0.3829828202724457,
-0.05163594335317612,
-0.18141411244869232,
-0.5374863147735596,
-0.07136321067810059,
0.3373817503452301,
0.16883833706378937,
0.03307107090950012
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09613v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09613v1
|
Reawakening knowledge: Anticipatory recovery from catastrophic interference via structured training
| 2024-03-14T17:51:54 | 2024-03-14T17:51:54 |
Yanlai Yang, Matt Jones, Michael C. Mozer, Mengye Ren
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
We explore the training dynamics of neural networks in a structured non-IID
setting where documents are presented cyclically in a fixed, repeated sequence.
Typically, networks suffer from catastrophic interference when training on a
sequence of documents; however, we discover a curious and remarkable property
of LLMs fine-tuned sequentially in this setting: they exhibit anticipatory
behavior, recovering from the forgetting on documents before encountering them
again. The behavior emerges and becomes more robust as the architecture scales
up its number of parameters. Through comprehensive experiments and
visualizations, we uncover new insights into training over-parameterized
networks in structured environments.
|
[
-0.06455276906490326,
-0.7249472141265869,
0.2840053141117096,
0.112302765250206,
-0.2671823501586914,
0.27257341146469116,
0.05232885479927063,
-0.3553112745285034,
0.6242525577545166,
0.5584695935249329,
-0.638075053691864,
-0.10684162378311157,
-0.6752328872680664,
-0.06305458396673203,
-0.7906159162521362,
1.2223870754241943,
-0.2216409593820572,
0.050366636365652084,
-0.2831555902957916,
-0.14441131055355072,
-0.08146965503692627,
-0.3929692208766937,
-1.0437791347503662,
-0.9518682956695557,
0.7180768251419067,
0.0594562366604805,
0.13696126639842987,
0.45185163617134094,
0.3622840940952301,
0.42637312412261963,
0.12861759960651398,
0.2731724977493286,
-0.8922815322875977,
0.39999422430992126,
-0.16140320897102356,
-0.5193302631378174,
-0.043085869401693344,
0.29015547037124634,
0.9241561889648438,
0.8790121078491211,
-0.39597615599632263,
-0.30679386854171753,
0.36864644289016724,
0.7474139928817749,
-0.5451620817184448,
0.13776983320713043,
-0.7578613758087158,
0.2493993639945984,
0.14377012848854065,
-0.7732401490211487,
-0.3382602334022522,
-0.30978262424468994,
-0.051186755299568176,
-0.8376480937004089,
0.30797550082206726,
0.04993106797337532,
0.5708058476448059,
0.5052893161773682,
-0.21470458805561066,
-0.19839230179786682,
-0.8815174102783203,
0.49646085500717163,
-0.24241463840007782,
0.29722049832344055,
0.41530415415763855,
0.023586256429553032,
-0.680884063243866,
-1.1640973091125488,
-0.29002222418785095,
0.04696455970406532,
0.19346119463443756,
0.41315436363220215,
0.16120070219039917,
0.15478788316249847,
0.40251922607421875,
0.301984578371048,
-0.18846309185028076,
0.013973530381917953,
-0.4572743773460388,
0.1814420074224472,
0.616115152835846,
0.2918943762779236,
-0.013594080694019794,
0.14665137231349945,
-0.4015067517757416,
0.11985528469085693,
-0.6535537242889404,
-0.051626257598400116,
0.5310700535774231,
-0.15111294388771057,
0.1685517132282257,
0.15579278767108917,
-0.19235408306121826,
0.5987262725830078,
0.0339791476726532,
0.1835346519947052,
0.25933223962783813,
-0.10320586711168289,
-0.23441927134990692,
0.32016509771347046,
0.6942611336708069,
0.07099412381649017,
0.4611330032348633,
-0.47515952587127686,
-0.257386177778244,
-0.404214471578598,
0.8749338388442993,
-0.5862846374511719,
-0.4799700379371643,
-0.002977765165269375,
-0.5200889110565186,
-0.5202191472053528,
-0.10441993921995163,
-0.29898524284362793,
-0.40415820479393005,
-0.4872759282588959,
0.34679317474365234,
-0.5842680931091309,
-0.4069989025592804,
0.16143494844436646,
-0.2671884000301361,
0.04332472383975983,
0.32702314853668213,
-1.060723066329956,
0.124196358025074,
0.6916166543960571,
0.9402281641960144,
0.14209270477294922,
-0.6504773497581482,
-0.1713731586933136,
0.12990544736385345,
-0.577307939529419,
0.768600344657898,
-0.18740735948085785,
-0.6592228412628174,
0.07920372486114502,
0.25659793615341187,
-0.42968857288360596,
-0.609307587146759,
0.11988377571105957,
-0.8328284025192261,
-0.1386813074350357,
-0.2751021981239319,
-0.599273145198822,
0.05452201887965202,
0.5340427756309509,
-0.5208439230918884,
0.7951514720916748,
0.020679231733083725,
-0.8361251354217529,
0.47983381152153015,
-0.4706791341304779,
-0.3714686632156372,
-0.22325465083122253,
-0.2237975299358368,
-0.5852911472320557,
0.2035467028617859,
-0.7752195596694946,
-0.11401265114545822,
0.03091006726026535,
0.05645696446299553,
-0.3991185128688812,
-0.6146512627601624,
0.24782000482082367,
-0.4530071020126343,
0.5606429576873779,
0.0825289636850357,
-0.1480451226234436,
0.1905043125152588,
-1.2016119956970215,
0.14664120972156525,
0.06906604766845703,
-0.8353453874588013,
-0.39886021614074707,
0.40827885270118713,
-0.4443782567977905,
0.13151520490646362,
0.04790574312210083,
-0.7183765769004822,
0.45153963565826416,
-0.5083934664726257,
0.8518251180648804,
0.6922335624694824,
0.47322648763656616,
0.28009364008903503,
-0.5784585475921631,
0.09846854209899902,
0.27194058895111084,
0.10420956462621689,
-0.2741791009902954,
-0.32077956199645996,
-0.9463856816291809,
0.1541561633348465,
-0.1327340304851532,
0.5190184712409973,
-0.8780191540718079,
0.03449396789073944,
-0.1295027732849121,
-0.2293069064617157,
-0.1809941530227661,
0.28705036640167236,
0.6585207581520081,
0.6892499923706055,
0.446103572845459,
-0.5486088395118713,
-0.8152172565460205,
-0.7860019207000732,
-0.14071352779865265,
-0.1309472620487213,
-0.1373356729745865,
0.25928714871406555,
0.6171634197235107,
-0.22874228656291962,
0.7621533870697021,
-0.3053090572357178,
-0.1514497846364975,
0.12391311675310135,
0.6543945670127869,
0.10773979127407074,
0.9237295985221863,
0.07097996026277542,
-0.48892778158187866,
-0.18389827013015747,
-0.33606386184692383,
-1.01016366481781,
0.20283567905426025,
-0.520058810710907,
-0.1536472588777542,
0.10797286033630371,
1.106112003326416,
-0.2882286310195923,
0.4331244230270386,
-0.08681070804595947,
0.0009141970076598227,
0.4655979871749878,
-0.4073912501335144,
0.025915540754795074,
-1.059576153755188,
0.1372591257095337,
-0.44546085596084595,
0.03758224472403526,
-0.4387454688549042,
-0.4159494638442993,
-0.07256641238927841,
0.3601962625980377,
-0.08746647089719772,
0.009828705340623856,
-0.4897492825984955,
-0.19986242055892944,
-0.5892130136489868,
-0.0066220685839653015,
-0.04682992398738861,
0.4207077622413635,
0.23967520892620087,
0.6936521530151367,
0.2640362083911896,
-0.330112099647522,
0.3298237919807434,
0.4202682673931122,
-0.3507327735424042,
0.4063326120376587,
-0.6589931845664978,
0.27450522780418396,
-0.3767869472503662,
0.19095560908317566,
-0.9671942591667175,
-0.10496576875448227,
0.12254892289638519,
-0.2334393858909607,
0.624524712562561,
-0.21932649612426758,
-0.32602277398109436,
-0.17660222947597504,
-0.25639522075653076,
0.49338844418525696,
0.2642841935157776,
-0.40830832719802856,
0.3671495318412781,
-0.016901811584830284,
0.4073537588119507,
-0.45221424102783203,
-0.5691094994544983,
0.29231321811676025,
0.06217347830533981,
-0.469243586063385,
0.2315717339515686,
-0.04372536391019821,
-0.25918805599212646,
-0.06387868523597717,
-0.042531177401542664,
-0.026989873498678207,
0.29873597621917725,
0.729499101638794,
-0.1637517511844635,
-0.15306729078292847,
0.009374951012432575,
-0.05780154466629028,
-0.2566668391227722,
0.18312828242778778,
-0.7406967282295227,
0.49822574853897095,
-0.024349596351385117,
-0.506313145160675,
-0.24507999420166016,
0.2998085021972656,
0.3581407070159912,
0.24906624853610992,
1.0157185792922974,
0.40055105090141296,
-0.41093793511390686,
-0.1039762794971466,
-0.2838537096977234,
-0.20165400207042694,
-0.5047902464866638,
0.3892979919910431,
-0.23492534458637238,
-0.384709894657135,
0.7511439323425293,
-0.3094375431537628,
0.09908338636159897,
0.18678003549575806,
0.2978588342666626,
-0.5023420453071594,
0.5657776594161987,
0.6026120185852051,
0.19355563819408417,
0.8302434086799622,
-0.6797399520874023,
-0.02860860712826252,
-0.9758055806159973,
-0.7497334480285645,
0.02493421919643879,
-0.7840778827667236,
-0.23556703329086304,
0.049760833382606506,
0.3224460184574127,
0.5776338577270508,
-0.3996790051460266,
0.11052975058555603,
-0.23479583859443665,
0.5666914582252502,
0.765326201915741,
0.4607127010822296,
0.14258547127246857,
-0.20261748135089874,
-0.055260200053453445,
0.022830931469798088,
-0.7432032823562622,
-0.1381790041923523,
1.0750190019607544,
0.05395406112074852,
0.7166239619255066,
-0.12745589017868042,
0.9591193795204163,
0.15222810208797455,
0.4838566184043884,
-0.6510095000267029,
0.20699523389339447,
0.0696054995059967,
-0.31505876779556274,
-0.2880241870880127,
-0.32244667410850525,
-1.3399614095687866,
-0.071476049721241,
-0.4866413474082947,
-0.6853727698326111,
0.44601884484291077,
0.17275069653987885,
-0.4185762107372284,
0.48200300335884094,
-0.3595046401023865,
0.3188317120075226,
0.007574295159429312,
-0.6294299364089966,
-0.3019310235977173,
-0.8522030115127563,
0.4255674183368683,
-0.22741538286209106,
-0.20260153710842133,
0.40712225437164307,
0.11084143072366714,
0.9192939400672913,
-0.4400208592414856,
1.0096869468688965,
-0.07954040169715881,
0.10848347097635269,
0.19240623712539673,
0.09395190328359604,
0.46511608362197876,
-0.023009194061160088,
0.05327555909752846,
0.04737614095211029,
-0.22023914754390717,
-0.5021796226501465,
-0.5417040586471558,
0.6625183820724487,
-0.9752408266067505,
-0.6080719232559204,
-0.2590577304363251,
-0.733527421951294,
-0.3087996244430542,
0.3293251693248749,
0.4890935719013214,
0.48889991641044617,
-0.19678324460983276,
0.4178476333618164,
1.1108022928237915,
0.09597519785165787,
0.7512650489807129,
0.5920398831367493,
0.22604945302009583,
-0.5303171277046204,
0.7889527678489685,
0.5428935885429382,
0.37261706590652466,
-0.02271765097975731,
-0.4047721028327942,
0.10178981721401215,
-0.8732573986053467,
-0.2016950398683548,
-0.02125810831785202,
-0.703065812587738,
-0.07689525187015533,
-0.6970540881156921,
-0.8108846545219421,
-0.07091689109802246,
-0.25140637159347534,
-0.46513959765434265,
-0.4983038902282715,
-0.5956587195396423,
-0.231906920671463,
0.18381507694721222,
1.0527734756469727,
-0.2565664052963257,
0.4080483317375183,
-0.9216263294219971,
-0.02141544595360756,
0.10952108353376389,
0.4580760598182678,
0.11819341778755188,
-0.6020886898040771,
-0.5664122104644775,
-0.11532711982727051,
-0.4486626088619232,
-0.655025839805603,
0.1588059365749359,
0.5551398396492004,
0.6924469470977783,
0.7158921957015991,
-0.1107364371418953,
0.3659137189388275,
-0.7513506412506104,
0.5129777193069458,
0.2961142659187317,
-0.2898217737674713,
0.3965041935443878,
-0.5826930403709412,
0.14745187759399414,
0.5439234375953674,
0.5886203050613403,
-0.5157257318496704,
-0.11816469579935074,
-0.7532789707183838,
-1.1403427124023438,
0.5189211368560791,
-0.13103072345256805,
0.07039332389831543,
-0.22406207025051117,
0.9795612692832947,
-0.25493448972702026,
0.3627043664455414,
-0.2596266567707062,
-0.053710706532001495,
-0.7320765256881714,
-0.1494339406490326,
0.03708292543888092,
-0.6844751238822937,
-0.646970272064209,
-0.025893323123455048,
0.5068697929382324,
0.010273534804582596,
0.2833493947982788,
0.40983515977859497,
-0.0038841781206429005,
-0.184599831700325,
-0.25202062726020813,
0.8176921010017395,
0.4989950954914093,
-0.11063888669013977,
0.19965484738349915,
0.03235064819455147,
-0.6258742213249207,
0.16913765668869019,
-0.17977146804332733,
-0.13164670765399933,
-0.44776302576065063,
0.888339638710022,
0.8090951442718506,
0.6621054410934448,
-0.05106206610798836,
0.2063625007867813,
-0.11042385548353195,
-0.6977373957633972,
-0.6104726791381836,
0.4767552614212036,
0.03224834427237511,
0.5926015973091125,
0.32068338990211487,
0.3464649021625519,
0.012349884025752544,
-0.6631386280059814,
0.5886590480804443,
0.37991979718208313,
-0.34121257066726685,
-0.33434373140335083,
0.7687174677848816,
0.18934111297130585,
-0.8740784525871277,
1.0621232986450195,
0.025034137070178986,
-0.5586655139923096,
0.6699367165565491,
0.767853856086731,
0.8444299697875977,
0.03527582809329033,
-0.20098240673542023,
0.4233359098434448,
0.246998131275177,
-0.17936831712722778,
0.44015759229660034,
-0.25236645340919495,
-0.8328983783721924,
-0.029858039692044258,
-0.6206001043319702,
-0.20150896906852722,
-0.16663748025894165,
-0.8384362459182739,
-0.3280320167541504,
-1.0741982460021973,
-0.1877335160970688,
-0.2815380096435547,
0.0035640422720462084,
-0.14342698454856873,
0.07734978199005127,
-0.252651572227478,
1.1280596256256104,
-0.8528119921684265,
1.1996407508850098,
0.2897949814796448,
-0.5207890868186951,
-0.5735980868339539,
-0.13280217349529266,
0.03899287432432175,
-0.9555655717849731,
0.7287676930427551,
-0.09915295988321304,
-0.11058097332715988,
0.29982006549835205,
-0.4667256772518158,
-0.929732620716095,
1.305440068244934,
0.12710896134376526,
-0.6304739713668823,
0.07336875796318054,
0.10663941502571106,
0.5848076343536377,
-0.13350054621696472,
-0.005114668980240822,
0.5806455016136169,
0.1588698923587799,
0.3385653793811798,
-0.5980724096298218,
-0.15162114799022675,
-0.5104453563690186,
-0.15232057869434357,
0.3772594630718231,
-0.6964735388755798,
0.6991430521011353,
-0.13031333684921265,
0.10300521552562714,
0.2390640527009964,
0.553521454334259,
0.038364164531230927,
0.34971189498901367,
0.4283618628978729,
0.7704141139984131,
0.7605080604553223,
-0.18692712485790253,
0.7433531284332275,
-0.5179153084754944,
0.07143806666135788,
1.2504477500915527,
0.0852552130818367,
0.7988388538360596,
0.6784112453460693,
-0.033522386103868484,
0.6067996621131897,
0.8169200420379639,
0.2238505482673645,
0.6495918035507202,
0.2923303246498108,
-0.38804879784584045,
-0.2747126519680023,
0.0022892355918884277,
-0.4692550301551819,
0.08102786540985107,
0.42607975006103516,
-0.543462872505188,
-0.1697121113538742,
0.11520646512508392,
-0.11978713423013687,
-0.018781600520014763,
-0.3705075681209564,
1.0578789710998535,
0.4156016409397125,
-0.59620201587677,
0.6199418306350708,
-0.4580642282962799,
0.408160924911499,
-0.6215066909790039,
-0.013148186728358269,
-0.3330555856227875,
0.2439349740743637,
-0.3988506495952606,
-0.5896416902542114,
0.6628949642181396,
-0.7305735349655151,
-0.5833539366722107,
-0.2735807001590729,
0.5789836049079895,
-0.5209639072418213,
-0.034718435257673264,
0.4078056216239929,
0.018224680796265602,
0.0986851155757904,
0.265952467918396,
-0.5368439555168152,
-0.05906232073903084,
-0.19516471028327942,
-0.5727114081382751,
0.5188944339752197,
0.4054967164993286,
-0.034257594496011734,
0.7602015733718872,
0.584571361541748,
0.004812735598534346,
0.24358254671096802,
0.11060680449008942,
1.0033048391342163,
-0.4242085814476013,
-0.29480841755867004,
-0.7110916972160339,
0.3926153779029846,
-0.09353556483983994,
-0.28249692916870117,
0.5835118293762207,
0.3827374279499054,
0.7126109600067139,
0.19628793001174927,
0.4097056984901428,
0.40739476680755615,
0.08543774485588074,
-0.7000162601470947,
0.8424860239028931,
-0.5148676037788391,
0.286569207906723,
0.19943751394748688,
-0.5548185110092163,
-0.14603886008262634,
0.4199121594429016,
-0.3427838087081909,
-0.14260299503803253,
0.6417145729064941,
0.5681546330451965,
0.10036470741033554,
0.282976359128952,
0.20366567373275757,
0.4790819585323334,
0.3043792247772217,
0.5251962542533875,
0.8391963243484497,
-0.30088531970977783,
0.3642471730709076,
0.22859975695610046,
-0.2990531623363495,
-0.07080698013305664,
-0.7086033225059509,
-0.5500591397285461,
-0.6546568274497986,
-0.08832576870918274,
-0.6516542434692383,
0.3767735958099365,
0.7092431783676147,
0.5433960556983948,
-0.5510118007659912,
0.01602340117096901,
-0.5869320034980774,
0.06843958795070648,
0.11566620320081711,
-0.1247527226805687,
0.10077832639217377,
-0.6724382042884827,
-0.31831276416778564,
0.6814207434654236,
0.2974015474319458,
0.235482856631279,
-0.24217253923416138,
-0.12694311141967773,
-0.3480633795261383,
0.23183110356330872,
0.27204662561416626,
0.7818995714187622,
0.07570195943117142,
-0.2598295509815216,
-0.4129965007305145,
-0.03758454695343971,
0.14226071536540985,
1.1176308393478394,
-0.7642114162445068,
0.30997273325920105,
0.5300169587135315,
0.5936237573623657,
0.63869309425354,
-0.043867114931344986,
0.636078953742981,
-0.7479092478752136,
0.32896989583969116,
0.060470301657915115,
0.6182537078857422,
-0.0028665922582149506,
-0.46155261993408203,
0.5053889751434326,
0.6277720928192139,
-0.8356354236602783,
-0.8520028591156006,
0.3451136350631714,
-0.5494116544723511,
-0.4068686068058014,
0.8283846378326416,
-0.5811933875083923,
-0.05387534573674202,
-0.419478178024292,
0.1584058552980423,
0.39326798915863037,
0.2080545276403427,
1.3466010093688965,
0.5825422406196594,
-0.45252710580825806,
0.029903480783104897,
-0.2640017867088318,
0.7030413746833801,
0.41303128004074097,
-0.4971243143081665,
-0.20749431848526,
0.33354073762893677,
0.4926620125770569,
0.2118431031703949,
0.9257868528366089,
0.031341176480054855,
0.1561458855867386,
0.437636137008667,
-0.354256272315979,
-0.5551803112030029,
-0.7908539175987244,
-0.2512166202068329,
0.17796450853347778,
0.12175880372524261,
-0.3273726999759674
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09611v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09611v4
|
MM1: Methods, Analysis & Insights from Multimodal LLM Pre-training
| 2024-03-14T17:51:32 | 2024-04-18T18:51:04 |
Brandon McKinzie, Zhe Gan, Jean-Philippe Fauconnier, Sam Dodge, Bowen Zhang, Philipp Dufter, Dhruti Shah, Xianzhi Du, Futang Peng, Floris Weers, Anton Belyi, Haotian Zhang, Karanjeet Singh, Doug Kang, Ankur Jain, Hongyu Hè, Max Schwarzer, Tom Gunter, Xiang Kong, Aonan Zhang, Jianyu Wang, Chong Wang, Nan Du, Tao Lei, Sam Wiseman, Guoli Yin, Mark Lee, Zirui Wang, Ruoming Pang, Peter Grasch, Alexander Toshev, Yinfei Yang
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
In this work, we discuss building performant Multimodal Large Language Models
(MLLMs). In particular, we study the importance of various architecture
components and data choices. Through careful and comprehensive ablations of the
image encoder, the vision language connector, and various pre-training data
choices, we identified several crucial design lessons. For example, we
demonstrate that for large-scale multimodal pre-training using a careful mix of
image-caption, interleaved image-text, and text-only data is crucial for
achieving state-of-the-art (SOTA) few-shot results across multiple benchmarks,
compared to other published pre-training results. Further, we show that the
image encoder together with image resolution and the image token count has
substantial impact, while the vision-language connector design is of
comparatively negligible importance. By scaling up the presented recipe, we
build MM1, a family of multimodal models up to 30B parameters, including both
dense models and mixture-of-experts (MoE) variants, that are SOTA in
pre-training metrics and achieve competitive performance after supervised
fine-tuning on a range of established multimodal benchmarks. Thanks to
large-scale pre-training, MM1 enjoys appealing properties such as enhanced
in-context learning, and multi-image reasoning, enabling few-shot
chain-of-thought prompting.
|
[
-0.6868667602539062,
-0.6142715811729431,
0.3723277449607849,
0.06633350253105164,
-0.30907726287841797,
-0.1441996991634369,
-0.08203640580177307,
-0.372931569814682,
-0.009943364188075066,
0.4834415316581726,
-0.7948049306869507,
-0.19274793565273285,
-0.780022382736206,
-0.0005796621553599834,
-0.16963808238506317,
0.7726142406463623,
0.007691478356719017,
0.23180820047855377,
-0.35495755076408386,
-0.26791948080062866,
-0.18836531043052673,
-0.5921412706375122,
-0.5621784329414368,
0.041786111891269684,
0.8492485284805298,
0.48847880959510803,
0.5149998664855957,
0.5111992359161377,
0.6757403016090393,
0.2943038046360016,
0.12851588428020477,
0.4076799154281616,
-0.626604437828064,
-0.2545073926448822,
0.18823553621768951,
-0.49153637886047363,
-0.7219787240028381,
0.18388976156711578,
0.7146965861320496,
0.5219913125038147,
0.06349632889032364,
0.3681504726409912,
0.1288565695285797,
0.6602979302406311,
-0.5943785905838013,
0.21504417061805725,
-0.7000940442085266,
0.07937279343605042,
-0.5109126567840576,
-0.30037906765937805,
-0.5652155876159668,
0.25268495082855225,
0.05302341282367706,
-0.47313931584358215,
-0.2235720455646515,
0.23069733381271362,
0.6005120277404785,
0.48350831866264343,
-0.6373614072799683,
-0.27965888381004333,
-0.5134015083312988,
0.8464147448539734,
-0.6560648083686829,
0.5266307592391968,
0.34177786111831665,
0.4375256597995758,
0.005274005699902773,
-0.6203966736793518,
-0.6156989336013794,
-0.09591223299503326,
-0.10254864394664764,
0.13267873227596283,
0.028093505650758743,
0.1428547352552414,
0.2769539952278137,
0.12315856665372849,
-0.7332221865653992,
0.3776979446411133,
-0.49807095527648926,
-0.0451868511736393,
0.4304434061050415,
0.28815552592277527,
-0.09340392053127289,
0.12335006892681122,
-0.4897516369819641,
0.031068148091435432,
-0.9989759922027588,
-0.04007728025317192,
0.3583385646343231,
0.1236865296959877,
-0.2557462751865387,
0.7335965037345886,
0.009157971478998661,
0.7893057465553284,
-0.16621536016464233,
-0.544174313545227,
0.20833253860473633,
-0.6329569220542908,
-0.11143290251493454,
-0.2780030071735382,
0.7699494957923889,
0.3368520140647888,
0.45826151967048645,
0.07060637325048447,
-0.18843990564346313,
0.05263764038681984,
0.2868190407752991,
-1.0025808811187744,
-0.05994516238570213,
0.15535861253738403,
-0.584879994392395,
-0.07792439311742783,
-0.10014647245407104,
-0.5718347430229187,
-0.19057190418243408,
-0.6194990277290344,
0.5510733723640442,
-0.30065467953681946,
-0.32883214950561523,
0.08774207532405853,
0.125362366437912,
0.3233611583709717,
0.3152669072151184,
-1.0329746007919312,
-0.05197746679186821,
0.4280058741569519,
0.5548605918884277,
-0.11459552496671677,
-0.5061328411102295,
-0.32137584686279297,
0.046661995351314545,
-0.3826328217983246,
0.6684818267822266,
-0.5174872875213623,
-0.16792313754558563,
0.005663069896399975,
-0.1308688521385193,
-0.05780448019504547,
-0.5438708066940308,
0.07896995544433594,
-0.4634270966053009,
0.16954976320266724,
-0.07078830152750015,
-0.3697635233402252,
-0.13761533796787262,
0.4980839192867279,
-0.6308436393737793,
0.6370481848716736,
0.01931886002421379,
-0.8839601874351501,
0.5597362518310547,
-0.8346977829933167,
-0.37243354320526123,
-0.21657326817512512,
-0.3002513647079468,
-0.1729542464017868,
0.1413879692554474,
0.2747212052345276,
0.7820670008659363,
-0.10784570127725601,
-0.09646894037723541,
-0.2990298271179199,
-0.15487518906593323,
0.23796948790550232,
-0.5878347158432007,
0.43864861130714417,
0.3529006242752075,
0.0904221385717392,
0.12482970207929611,
-0.9347974061965942,
-0.18670591711997986,
0.07410234957933426,
-0.46144574880599976,
0.11672569811344147,
0.015335479751229286,
0.17125169932842255,
0.4536835253238678,
0.2830333113670349,
-0.36800244450569153,
0.0998459979891777,
-0.12494122236967087,
0.27647122740745544,
0.803218424320221,
-0.3962829113006592,
0.5343859195709229,
-0.18017257750034332,
0.5474012494087219,
0.44499579071998596,
0.5082932114601135,
-0.7983694672584534,
-0.37542086839675903,
-0.8042296767234802,
-0.5692633390426636,
0.13852159678936005,
0.46912017464637756,
-1.1796563863754272,
-0.12007122486829758,
-0.265505313873291,
-0.38610273599624634,
-0.6938971281051636,
0.5009419918060303,
0.49278730154037476,
0.3887495994567871,
0.230715811252594,
-0.29945966601371765,
-0.7149694561958313,
-1.0575820207595825,
0.24243681132793427,
-0.07349621504545212,
0.1697494387626648,
0.2855866253376007,
0.43941858410835266,
-0.4323331117630005,
0.9683586359024048,
-0.4227881133556366,
-0.18876832723617554,
-0.4140965938568115,
-0.00618233485147357,
0.13857309520244598,
0.41394999623298645,
0.698939859867096,
-0.754002571105957,
-0.3142162561416626,
-0.048228953033685684,
-0.8896417021751404,
0.21532122790813446,
-0.06564225256443024,
0.04326469823718071,
0.19251905381679535,
0.5223897099494934,
-0.7089513540267944,
0.14397943019866943,
0.7478969097137451,
-0.0891261026263237,
0.6878647804260254,
-0.2719888985157013,
0.08393564820289612,
-1.0872687101364136,
-0.0951063483953476,
0.04321873188018799,
-0.12903648614883423,
-0.7044062614440918,
0.23912736773490906,
0.005308175925165415,
0.021769078448414803,
-0.9529756903648376,
0.7288053631782532,
-0.4244425892829895,
-0.004651237744837999,
-0.20847736299037933,
-0.2518307566642761,
-0.09878703951835632,
0.5425005555152893,
-0.14233312010765076,
0.8043111562728882,
0.6734281182289124,
-0.6527156829833984,
0.1343735307455063,
0.10044244676828384,
-0.5870383977890015,
0.43105337023735046,
-0.44765570759773254,
0.17957673966884613,
-0.39774489402770996,
0.030853265896439552,
-1.138999104499817,
-0.12256504595279694,
0.028896210715174675,
-0.3799940049648285,
0.5674642324447632,
-0.13884592056274414,
-0.9385234117507935,
-0.28700873255729675,
-0.15938249230384827,
0.49699658155441284,
0.25849297642707825,
-0.43884316086769104,
0.7527196407318115,
0.4125320315361023,
-0.17539656162261963,
-0.49621304869651794,
-0.7372058629989624,
0.026925457641482353,
-0.24895581603050232,
-0.7485945820808411,
-0.07270175218582153,
-0.2760104835033417,
-0.13123531639575958,
-0.3923189043998718,
0.2670910954475403,
-0.16317424178123474,
0.15958212316036224,
0.2932727038860321,
0.43233707547187805,
-0.41549837589263916,
0.0461263470351696,
-0.16500650346279144,
-0.4103374183177948,
-0.13466207683086395,
0.02279038168489933,
0.6170399785041809,
-0.15832896530628204,
-0.4532673954963684,
-0.35947945713996887,
0.27665072679519653,
0.7592881321907043,
-0.3999975919723511,
0.8161534667015076,
0.9195975661277771,
-0.07067302614450455,
0.22580330073833466,
-0.7119779586791992,
-0.15528249740600586,
-0.48425471782684326,
0.5516229271888733,
-0.607934832572937,
-1.0216933488845825,
0.20782232284545898,
-0.04146460071206093,
0.26708081364631653,
0.06530696898698807,
0.783671498298645,
-0.5680299997329712,
1.0260930061340332,
0.7617150545120239,
0.009782602079212666,
0.6763376593589783,
-0.24306656420230865,
-0.07786067575216293,
-0.6199336647987366,
-0.1751643866300583,
-0.04752924665808678,
-0.36588913202285767,
-0.4519580006599426,
-0.706226646900177,
0.3981759250164032,
-0.058690521866083145,
-0.1942460834980011,
0.1493486613035202,
0.17507125437259674,
0.4920867383480072,
0.44176873564720154,
0.042658671736717224,
0.054967448115348816,
0.1579742729663849,
-0.1993781179189682,
-0.14702923595905304,
-0.8409761786460876,
-0.5781077146530151,
1.3581006526947021,
0.54248046875,
1.0387729406356812,
0.11543320119380951,
0.4429958462715149,
-0.17173980176448822,
0.2841311991214752,
-0.6906622648239136,
0.6377245783805847,
-0.4764625132083893,
-0.7472062706947327,
-0.08647174388170242,
-0.24521860480308533,
-0.8212229013442993,
0.5228129029273987,
-0.5419594645500183,
-0.199198916554451,
-0.2210979461669922,
0.30128610134124756,
-0.3055048882961273,
0.12561170756816864,
-0.866654634475708,
0.9284554719924927,
-0.4417867362499237,
-0.32112759351730347,
-0.29926106333732605,
-0.7778304219245911,
0.4413943588733673,
-0.2274063378572464,
0.3339141309261322,
0.12308823317289352,
-0.06378740817308426,
0.4347775876522064,
0.13537810742855072,
0.8141508102416992,
-0.14015613496303558,
-0.08043859153985977,
0.24476687610149384,
-0.05168319493532181,
0.2418353110551834,
-0.25796037912368774,
0.2121860384941101,
0.20961305499076843,
-0.06682276725769043,
-0.40440383553504944,
-0.46130985021591187,
0.1912544071674347,
-0.6345002055168152,
-0.45572999119758606,
0.18114252388477325,
-0.5773501992225647,
-0.24972867965698242,
0.09992251545190811,
0.1976582407951355,
0.8847792148590088,
0.010049600154161453,
0.522874653339386,
0.7352741360664368,
-0.19236136972904205,
0.5438722372055054,
0.46267515420913696,
-0.5029791593551636,
-0.34466248750686646,
0.7993950843811035,
0.2921125888824463,
0.4571382999420166,
0.5271968245506287,
-0.09234987944364548,
-0.2530721127986908,
-0.5665372610092163,
-0.5542961955070496,
0.15119467675685883,
-0.8885074257850647,
0.19057060778141022,
-0.665641188621521,
-0.13788732886314392,
-0.2292371541261673,
-0.04377299174666405,
-0.6376922130584717,
-0.18416625261306763,
-0.3639937937259674,
-0.07666625082492828,
-0.14966601133346558,
0.6641802191734314,
0.15619362890720367,
0.5709355473518372,
-0.9102506637573242,
0.26301464438438416,
0.42942488193511963,
0.16041503846645355,
0.017531106248497963,
-0.46452054381370544,
-0.5042091012001038,
-0.11814650148153305,
-0.23408137261867523,
-0.38911083340644836,
0.17354410886764526,
0.24598443508148193,
0.8623476624488831,
0.8038077354431152,
-0.6197249293327332,
0.825485110282898,
-0.8412325978279114,
0.720659077167511,
0.4472692310810089,
-0.3633916974067688,
0.5030837059020996,
-0.23281672596931458,
0.4866594672203064,
0.48675116896629333,
0.5590362548828125,
-0.10634984821081161,
-0.10511524975299835,
-0.20157457888126373,
-0.5175940990447998,
0.4749985635280609,
0.06841349601745605,
0.23659870028495789,
0.022652996703982353,
0.08225048333406448,
0.3296487629413605,
0.257828950881958,
-0.8438834547996521,
-0.3688448667526245,
-0.24523548781871796,
-0.32596543431282043,
-0.4179365336894989,
-0.5132635831832886,
-0.1363137662410736,
-0.3656354546546936,
0.246933251619339,
-0.29601603746414185,
0.13544920086860657,
-0.29851675033569336,
-0.4515882134437561,
0.30500251054763794,
0.22565527260303497,
0.9921092987060547,
0.8867615461349487,
-0.09018976241350174,
0.3077581226825714,
0.03186584264039993,
-0.35923880338668823,
0.13643895089626312,
-0.18206541240215302,
0.287665992975235,
-0.1466684639453888,
0.5163405537605286,
0.9915511608123779,
0.35368916392326355,
-0.7725600004196167,
0.5221061706542969,
0.04524261876940727,
-0.33880504965782166,
-0.034489259123802185,
-0.165879026055336,
0.05558669567108154,
0.42153871059417725,
0.35742512345314026,
0.08249843865633011,
-0.10846614837646484,
-0.6319726705551147,
0.21681496500968933,
0.6002689003944397,
-0.2877321243286133,
-0.573467493057251,
0.4479694962501526,
0.1595674604177475,
0.1300194263458252,
0.4332910478115082,
-0.18392245471477509,
-0.36252355575561523,
0.3617987334728241,
0.4310652017593384,
0.4652608036994934,
-0.007516880985349417,
0.0029289955273270607,
0.2610822916030884,
0.6612265706062317,
0.07398956269025803,
0.2215692102909088,
-0.08844861388206482,
-0.7929757833480835,
-0.624871015548706,
-0.6501639485359192,
-0.2083718478679657,
-0.15258432924747467,
-0.27594220638275146,
0.2934302091598511,
-0.40017521381378174,
-0.20896556973457336,
-0.10604411363601685,
-0.2396160513162613,
-0.9370931386947632,
0.29448574781417847,
0.5056800246238708,
0.8348433971405029,
-0.6065869331359863,
0.9825255274772644,
0.7637534141540527,
-0.3609105348587036,
-0.607483446598053,
-0.47741925716400146,
0.22586305439472198,
-0.927849531173706,
1.024962067604065,
0.3193172216415405,
-0.028841836377978325,
0.10854019969701767,
-0.6271027326583862,
-0.8548071980476379,
1.1662964820861816,
0.3886575698852539,
-0.5702744722366333,
0.02474847435951233,
0.25982925295829773,
0.2927289605140686,
-0.6589008569717407,
0.38596606254577637,
0.29453083872795105,
0.24907545745372772,
0.4220966398715973,
-1.0408443212509155,
-0.3778040111064911,
-0.05816318467259407,
-0.07436530292034149,
0.08308310061693192,
-0.5506907105445862,
1.040572166442871,
-0.2919672429561615,
-0.15165944397449493,
-0.013434302061796188,
0.46442171931266785,
0.38684338331222534,
0.2862248718738556,
0.48095494508743286,
0.6381248235702515,
0.26042336225509644,
0.08777293562889099,
1.0722236633300781,
-0.2645001709461212,
0.03932052478194237,
1.1235055923461914,
-0.15194366872310638,
1.1411247253417969,
0.758488118648529,
-0.28860801458358765,
0.16852790117263794,
0.5742413401603699,
0.15397459268569946,
0.6634420156478882,
-0.07563332468271255,
-0.09567023068666458,
-0.3749046325683594,
0.10166279971599579,
-0.39245015382766724,
0.7956767678260803,
0.33964765071868896,
-0.4026789665222168,
-0.22166556119918823,
0.33067208528518677,
-0.1343805491924286,
-0.4386902451515198,
-0.4270086884498596,
0.8142387866973877,
0.16425466537475586,
-0.38130518794059753,
0.3081251382827759,
-0.3373689353466034,
1.0316264629364014,
-0.7485206723213196,
0.16697309911251068,
-0.15368513762950897,
0.19859406352043152,
-0.12492100894451141,
-0.7420496940612793,
0.1575031876564026,
-0.15495535731315613,
-0.27037036418914795,
-0.5033094882965088,
0.6882210969924927,
-0.4594184458255768,
-0.5760628581047058,
0.09922181069850922,
0.7052456140518188,
0.24728834629058838,
-0.13164392113685608,
-0.5634119510650635,
0.14540766179561615,
-0.2970457077026367,
-0.30044642090797424,
0.5602971315383911,
0.34292346239089966,
0.29844754934310913,
0.8302440643310547,
0.7553579807281494,
-0.08189257979393005,
0.4410930871963501,
0.18895885348320007,
0.9464307427406311,
-0.4520069360733032,
-0.17055313289165497,
-1.0434473752975464,
0.8891200423240662,
0.21233947575092316,
-0.18335828185081482,
0.6785134673118591,
0.6086025238037109,
0.7945659160614014,
-0.30756518244743347,
0.3423226475715637,
0.23412464559078217,
0.05718524754047394,
-0.9282881617546082,
0.7159881591796875,
-0.8356469869613647,
0.016636790707707405,
-0.09110280871391296,
-0.9570337533950806,
-0.2969481945037842,
0.5269564390182495,
-0.060161326080560684,
-0.02960563264787197,
0.5707863569259644,
1.0100371837615967,
0.061827924102544785,
-0.3049483001232147,
0.7246271371841431,
0.08488409221172333,
0.3614177405834198,
0.39305561780929565,
1.0441322326660156,
-0.3543582260608673,
0.5667733550071716,
0.05597652122378349,
-0.11351072788238525,
-0.16594839096069336,
-0.8431821465492249,
-0.9744948148727417,
-0.5251219868659973,
-0.12947320938110352,
0.08917135000228882,
-0.38813599944114685,
0.9696210622787476,
1.048822283744812,
-0.40952542424201965,
-0.21394526958465576,
0.4601839780807495,
-0.1710892617702484,
0.19486013054847717,
-0.12787795066833496,
-0.18478980660438538,
-0.38117897510528564,
-0.4981117844581604,
0.3548875153064728,
0.678061306476593,
0.2723195552825928,
-0.6695506572723389,
-0.33020955324172974,
-0.32623207569122314,
0.008596169762313366,
1.255019187927246,
-0.11284767836332321,
-0.8931401371955872,
-0.0194579865783453,
-0.06287316232919693,
-0.20550335943698883,
0.1506836861371994,
0.686398983001709,
-0.5762811899185181,
0.6877179741859436,
0.24427279829978943,
0.6866562962532043,
0.5565914511680603,
-0.25879237055778503,
0.296508252620697,
-0.8697789907455444,
0.5001845955848694,
-0.05735892802476883,
0.5736960768699646,
0.26980525255203247,
0.22947755455970764,
0.5252811312675476,
0.01780504733324051,
-0.34792640805244446,
-0.7823415398597717,
0.23271837830543518,
-1.0949058532714844,
-0.1950773447751999,
1.1422353982925415,
-0.21139350533485413,
-0.08655039966106415,
0.01514646876603365,
-0.3784623444080353,
-0.13123370707035065,
0.22309258580207825,
0.2996377944946289,
1.0230904817581177,
0.09099505841732025,
-0.7617970108985901,
-0.7925971150398254,
0.16469746828079224,
0.2250608652830124,
-0.8805386424064636,
-0.4492781460285187,
0.47125521302223206,
0.1256505250930786,
0.17973144352436066,
0.8182128071784973,
-0.2016371637582779,
0.0668216124176979,
0.22431039810180664,
-0.03304346650838852,
-0.26128190755844116,
-0.660762369632721,
-0.14524853229522705,
0.2246970683336258,
0.18095533549785614,
-0.2391071617603302
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09606v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09606v1
|
Large Language Models and Causal Inference in Collaboration: A Comprehensive Survey
| 2024-03-14T17:47:20 | 2024-03-14T17:47:20 |
Xiaoyu Liu, Paiheng Xu, Junda Wu, Jiaxin Yuan, Yifan Yang, Yuhang Zhou, Fuxiao Liu, Tianrui Guan, Haoliang Wang, Tong Yu, Julian McAuley, Wei Ai, Furong Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Causal inference has shown potential in enhancing the predictive accuracy,
fairness, robustness, and explainability of Natural Language Processing (NLP)
models by capturing causal relationships among variables. The emergence of
generative Large Language Models (LLMs) has significantly impacted various NLP
domains, particularly through their advanced reasoning capabilities. This
survey focuses on evaluating and improving LLMs from a causal view in the
following areas: understanding and improving the LLMs' reasoning capacity,
addressing fairness and safety issues in LLMs, complementing LLMs with
explanations, and handling multimodality. Meanwhile, LLMs' strong reasoning
capacities can in turn contribute to the field of causal inference by aiding
causal relationship discovery and causal effect estimations. This review
explores the interplay between causal inference frameworks and LLMs from both
perspectives, emphasizing their collective potential to further the development
of more advanced and equitable artificial intelligence systems.
|
[
-0.30057215690612793,
-0.934227705001831,
1.0305875539779663,
0.3643202781677246,
0.2693365216255188,
-0.20435790717601776,
-0.3101331889629364,
-0.7774032354354858,
0.008496994152665138,
0.5762304663658142,
-0.36968550086021423,
-0.25985804200172424,
-0.6709745526313782,
0.1806078404188156,
-0.4315638542175293,
0.5110948085784912,
0.14515244960784912,
0.3348243534564972,
-0.647936999797821,
-0.06285474449396133,
-0.5815316438674927,
-0.6413464546203613,
-0.8466501832008362,
-0.6311874985694885,
0.810096800327301,
0.021022336557507515,
0.7665769457817078,
0.34983542561531067,
0.5845211744308472,
0.4648069739341736,
-0.10231062024831772,
-0.003360387869179249,
-0.21038252115249634,
0.3146726191043854,
-0.3764970600605011,
-0.555946409702301,
-0.4072004556655884,
-0.1044134721159935,
0.6975917816162109,
1.30155611038208,
-0.11238443106412888,
-0.1423279047012329,
-0.0035051454324275255,
0.5115480422973633,
-0.6043599843978882,
0.25544315576553345,
-0.4149985611438751,
0.008923245593905449,
0.009560839273035526,
-0.10665782541036606,
-0.5752373337745667,
-0.252927303314209,
0.14834493398666382,
-0.39703282713890076,
0.12074709683656693,
0.24384737014770508,
0.35032716393470764,
0.407267302274704,
-0.5827526450157166,
-0.17802299559116364,
-1.0282171964645386,
1.0592379570007324,
-0.8637542128562927,
0.5426669716835022,
0.3841659426689148,
0.14949193596839905,
-0.6586419939994812,
-0.9456374049186707,
-0.6510938405990601,
-0.32926324009895325,
-0.02180674858391285,
0.11391559988260269,
-0.10468097776174545,
0.37540262937545776,
0.3068981468677521,
0.14982575178146362,
-0.2663786709308624,
0.657200038433075,
-0.05268215015530586,
-0.020290745422244072,
0.8503842949867249,
0.3134448826313019,
0.3476184904575348,
-0.05340428277850151,
-0.13535714149475098,
0.28305894136428833,
-0.8720105886459351,
-0.41698354482650757,
0.23115457594394684,
0.08279512077569962,
-0.1627236306667328,
0.4813412129878998,
-0.04977748915553093,
0.9263743162155151,
-0.3520817756652832,
-0.06598798930644989,
-0.158225879073143,
-0.4291849732398987,
-0.5763349533081055,
-0.1443677842617035,
0.8374449610710144,
0.20779357850551605,
0.017589068040251732,
-0.3882918953895569,
0.19025975465774536,
0.14431260526180267,
0.04649361968040466,
-0.3099527060985565,
0.10779392719268799,
0.27370238304138184,
-0.5352413654327393,
0.024877754971385002,
0.14254501461982727,
-0.6554109454154968,
-0.6271882057189941,
-0.7804462909698486,
0.13680465519428253,
0.049639757722616196,
-0.18764157593250275,
0.24991057813167572,
-0.08494521677494049,
0.26329851150512695,
0.5775055885314941,
-0.8687434792518616,
0.13996627926826477,
1.0024399757385254,
0.5676866769790649,
-0.09765532612800598,
-0.4628758430480957,
-0.40863344073295593,
0.506620466709137,
-0.3084198534488678,
0.7175145745277405,
-0.3734899163246155,
-0.2095242738723755,
0.22449541091918945,
-0.02328072302043438,
-0.1840897649526596,
-0.3685600161552429,
0.6131295561790466,
-0.7129161953926086,
0.31838148832321167,
-0.304146409034729,
-0.7546603679656982,
-0.3070797622203827,
0.09263540804386139,
-0.7861075401306152,
0.42821839451789856,
-0.3730926513671875,
-0.8306472897529602,
0.4433838427066803,
-0.5993708968162537,
-0.6136783361434937,
0.04511171951889992,
-0.4284052848815918,
-0.32206615805625916,
0.08976832032203674,
0.08709415048360825,
0.6354634761810303,
-0.9353436231613159,
1.0955700874328613,
-0.6455528140068054,
-0.07337987422943115,
0.30986547470092773,
-0.6171661615371704,
0.9496802687644958,
0.0012050046352669597,
-0.3279314339160919,
0.5218871831893921,
-0.5154533982276917,
-0.3457375764846802,
0.05848491191864014,
-0.16986840963363647,
-0.3073798418045044,
0.5269278287887573,
-0.11736872047185898,
0.23257076740264893,
0.09006807208061218,
-0.12764230370521545,
-0.11372624337673187,
-0.22653789818286896,
0.3109510838985443,
0.829281747341156,
0.01339730154722929,
0.4706226587295532,
-0.17521508038043976,
0.2998029589653015,
-0.2396724373102188,
0.2728382647037506,
0.08017829805612564,
-0.5912184119224548,
-0.7388302683830261,
-0.16691841185092926,
-0.09569322317838669,
0.356717050075531,
-0.747013509273529,
0.6492253541946411,
-0.006878531537950039,
-0.13170813024044037,
0.049747977405786514,
0.08198057115077972,
0.32852262258529663,
0.4181644022464752,
0.13589522242546082,
0.012050912715494633,
-0.5528240203857422,
-0.7855916023254395,
-0.379486083984375,
-0.3850284814834595,
-0.11792071908712387,
0.25442782044410706,
0.46653178334236145,
-0.19956272840499878,
0.8993980884552002,
-0.379696786403656,
0.08538930118083954,
-0.37110039591789246,
0.061071377247571945,
0.22629134356975555,
0.34204357862472534,
0.46705007553100586,
-0.9658416509628296,
-0.11037110537290573,
-0.34654682874679565,
-1.1104397773742676,
-0.23755590617656708,
-0.09121657907962799,
-0.1929340362548828,
0.04242595657706261,
1.0085642337799072,
-0.572537899017334,
0.066642165184021,
0.6157469749450684,
-0.5175526738166809,
0.607399046421051,
-0.1801305115222931,
0.23580975830554962,
-0.9439056515693665,
-0.08394499868154526,
0.09223303943872452,
0.05532704293727875,
-0.6929406523704529,
0.05517483130097389,
-0.4132552146911621,
0.29524436593055725,
-0.24715788662433624,
0.5002251267433167,
-0.5112777948379517,
-0.3395252823829651,
-0.15739938616752625,
0.20116056501865387,
-0.03579249605536461,
0.05697822943329811,
0.017975063994526863,
0.48454850912094116,
0.5322208404541016,
-0.60100257396698,
0.4978225529193878,
0.17804233729839325,
-0.31533023715019226,
0.6259812712669373,
-0.7251148223876953,
-0.23277853429317474,
-0.24726350605487823,
0.3882952034473419,
-0.7780982851982117,
-0.5749765038490295,
-0.07208434492349625,
-0.2026757150888443,
0.16313372552394867,
0.138729989528656,
-0.8676039576530457,
-0.40911951661109924,
-0.03377246484160423,
0.4086278975009918,
0.1368657499551773,
-0.6192190647125244,
0.5200000405311584,
0.5174007415771484,
-0.06999015063047409,
-0.4502539038658142,
-0.668009340763092,
0.3682878315448761,
-0.3713361322879791,
-0.8086664080619812,
0.11305217444896698,
0.03370007127523422,
-0.857940673828125,
-0.11385238915681839,
0.3607458472251892,
-0.11681769043207169,
0.35218024253845215,
0.2754799425601959,
0.26945212483406067,
-0.18275852501392365,
0.3911432921886444,
-0.055645328015089035,
-0.10927009582519531,
0.4439801871776581,
-0.09617245942354202,
0.524120032787323,
0.07496721297502518,
-0.635823667049408,
-0.2810661196708679,
0.46127429604530334,
0.6026754975318909,
-0.1577998846769333,
1.1241705417633057,
0.3234294056892395,
-0.4213593602180481,
0.06899043917655945,
-0.7119585871696472,
-0.1887287050485611,
-0.35834801197052,
0.30673933029174805,
0.14321748912334442,
-1.2530845403671265,
0.48460957407951355,
-0.21836958825588226,
-0.10894984751939774,
0.5583726763725281,
0.6398879289627075,
0.19625422358512878,
1.044805645942688,
0.6770385503768921,
-0.34397459030151367,
0.4003521203994751,
0.08336301892995834,
0.3604361414909363,
-0.7837336659431458,
-0.47915035486221313,
-0.7093650698661804,
0.1409861296415329,
-0.6916576027870178,
-0.46920785307884216,
0.39380398392677307,
0.24007175862789154,
-0.5628713369369507,
-0.16055314242839813,
0.0497911237180233,
0.22962312400341034,
0.5774872899055481,
-0.0398700051009655,
0.5403899550437927,
-0.1791776716709137,
0.13984277844429016,
0.10227024555206299,
-0.7179853320121765,
-0.39642542600631714,
0.7364904880523682,
0.3149399161338806,
0.7793750762939453,
0.40456920862197876,
0.3345513343811035,
0.13192172348499298,
0.38421040773391724,
-0.5201037526130676,
0.5581901669502258,
0.027757475152611732,
-0.6588508486747742,
-0.3659580945968628,
-0.4570934772491455,
-0.9397698044776917,
0.28540197014808655,
-0.3898998498916626,
-0.849323570728302,
-0.015341302379965782,
-0.055269043892621994,
-0.03925560787320137,
0.30826857686042786,
-0.699445903301239,
0.7659170627593994,
-0.21836735308170319,
-0.7350817918777466,
-0.6156005263328552,
-0.7234039306640625,
0.8488109111785889,
-0.09490973502397537,
0.3716188371181488,
-0.1321149468421936,
0.07629526406526566,
0.6725732088088989,
-0.30400949716567993,
1.129124402999878,
0.06217561662197113,
-0.304852694272995,
0.1610020399093628,
-0.19658026099205017,
0.1374308466911316,
0.07793071866035461,
-0.3896087110042572,
0.41668158769607544,
-0.47740891575813293,
-0.2696737051010132,
-0.4978657364845276,
0.9142595529556274,
-0.5950823426246643,
-0.8792972564697266,
-0.277591347694397,
-0.8060566782951355,
-0.4172532260417938,
0.15711970627307892,
-0.23981879651546478,
0.23809772729873657,
-0.2970278561115265,
0.20149463415145874,
0.43360355496406555,
-0.6530426144599915,
0.7500073909759521,
0.3668975532054901,
-0.19990792870521545,
-0.3239240348339081,
0.2470894604921341,
-0.2925468981266022,
0.37162351608276367,
0.40875905752182007,
0.24110935628414154,
-0.3834083080291748,
-0.5296446681022644,
-0.11298251152038574,
0.41296127438545227,
-0.6636204719543457,
-0.14473514258861542,
-0.7010108828544617,
-0.04971330240368843,
-0.49538546800613403,
-0.4299062490463257,
-0.06858128309249878,
-0.16330091655254364,
-0.24364402890205383,
-0.047709014266729355,
0.35943329334259033,
0.9308621883392334,
-0.15856675803661346,
0.28744301199913025,
-0.6878477931022644,
0.2274206131696701,
0.3371303975582123,
0.39024031162261963,
0.4067504405975342,
-0.190201535820961,
-0.08696199953556061,
-0.2578601539134979,
-0.027807075530290604,
-0.6722803115844727,
0.1599082499742508,
-0.15757137537002563,
0.6670713424682617,
0.4626915454864502,
-0.17273063957691193,
0.6115666031837463,
-0.5279290080070496,
0.9266797304153442,
0.5871059894561768,
-0.8771268129348755,
0.32483479380607605,
-0.49878817796707153,
0.14989155530929565,
0.051284607499837875,
0.3745309114456177,
-0.5039927363395691,
-0.4756394922733307,
-0.48895731568336487,
-0.7676554918289185,
0.49561166763305664,
0.11712273955345154,
-0.08609463274478912,
-0.15379498898983002,
0.17632023990154266,
-0.08346710354089737,
0.19136008620262146,
-0.7439649701118469,
-0.19959388673305511,
0.5027421116828918,
-0.08585663139820099,
-0.3120156228542328,
-0.32066139578819275,
-0.1474546194076538,
-0.3602127432823181,
0.48551279306411743,
0.024416105821728706,
0.07362458854913712,
0.07297170162200928,
0.03250289335846901,
-0.1324426531791687,
0.24419711530208588,
0.5592312216758728,
0.888484537601471,
0.23704996705055237,
0.31825703382492065,
0.1239130049943924,
-0.003021183190867305,
-0.005011549219489098,
0.1824045479297638,
0.03297518566250801,
-0.35455942153930664,
0.9972403049468994,
0.699011504650116,
0.21701355278491974,
-0.638755202293396,
0.48259490728378296,
-0.023581936955451965,
-0.02867947332561016,
-0.30719828605651855,
0.07159645855426788,
0.47975456714630127,
0.5661464333534241,
0.2059064656496048,
-0.21552665531635284,
0.13340696692466736,
-0.6201965808868408,
0.05720393732190132,
0.6201373934745789,
-0.11538579314947128,
-0.13833056390285492,
0.9845437407493591,
0.19893263280391693,
-0.11384972184896469,
0.4243597984313965,
0.2117369920015335,
-0.3984512388706207,
0.8044314980506897,
0.6442173719406128,
0.79327791929245,
-0.35553979873657227,
0.03868299722671509,
0.2666199207305908,
0.25834062695503235,
-0.23659808933734894,
-0.09537231177091599,
0.1470261812210083,
-0.9127283692359924,
-0.9095653891563416,
-0.5751239657402039,
-0.4291362166404724,
0.10131976753473282,
-0.3974497318267822,
0.08624549955129623,
-0.19921408593654633,
-0.007121626753360033,
0.20612983405590057,
-0.11721597611904144,
-0.48109185695648193,
0.07231022417545319,
0.14821770787239075,
0.4802120327949524,
-0.9901471734046936,
0.4787709414958954,
0.45430314540863037,
-0.5114726424217224,
-0.6384224891662598,
-0.009189099073410034,
-0.028097497299313545,
-0.5393513441085815,
0.8918243050575256,
-0.010929984040558338,
-0.1684444397687912,
-0.19194717705249786,
-0.7141073942184448,
-0.7831303477287292,
0.976851224899292,
0.5198104977607727,
-0.6420478820800781,
0.04935431852936745,
0.2363712042570114,
0.6252622604370117,
-0.10050629079341888,
0.14975005388259888,
0.5510911345481873,
0.5686630010604858,
-0.10030155628919601,
-0.9360235929489136,
0.13176658749580383,
0.24327516555786133,
0.050334349274635315,
0.32282882928848267,
-0.5529652237892151,
0.5503864884376526,
-0.2515150308609009,
0.04861198365688324,
0.05312195047736168,
0.7892864346504211,
0.31793665885925293,
0.48439183831214905,
0.4233810603618622,
0.49184370040893555,
0.611939013004303,
0.057237107306718826,
1.1856852769851685,
-0.09125300496816635,
0.13112448155879974,
1.0909887552261353,
-0.4668942987918854,
0.5068761706352234,
0.6157500147819519,
-0.33819133043289185,
0.49480167031288147,
0.36843112111091614,
0.12345188111066818,
0.06963018327951431,
0.2427237629890442,
-0.6255435347557068,
-0.31614166498184204,
-0.3442172110080719,
-0.15183831751346588,
0.4205925464630127,
0.5078420042991638,
-0.5090284943580627,
-0.15757998824119568,
-0.06056612730026245,
0.15794134140014648,
0.1658840924501419,
-0.3638884425163269,
0.704923152923584,
0.39561015367507935,
-0.8188427090644836,
-0.059488020837306976,
0.12299235165119171,
0.5082393884658813,
-0.34371641278266907,
-0.09125771373510361,
0.011747662909328938,
0.1996600329875946,
-0.2090437263250351,
-0.6992534399032593,
0.3241388201713562,
-0.11431074887514114,
-0.23929424583911896,
-0.09647765755653381,
0.7447667121887207,
-0.35730019211769104,
-0.41646119952201843,
0.6992743015289307,
0.7648509740829468,
-0.0573088712990284,
0.15321779251098633,
-0.5245019793510437,
0.1372203379869461,
-0.2999919056892395,
-0.06463908404111862,
0.23586691915988922,
0.3658706843852997,
-0.22013916075229645,
0.6233910918235779,
0.646400511264801,
0.06246121972799301,
0.06563509255647659,
0.5591791868209839,
0.7029411196708679,
-0.8110485076904297,
-0.22902649641036987,
-1.0722638368606567,
0.2660922408103943,
-0.16742055118083954,
0.18582656979560852,
0.8160306811332703,
0.3111843466758728,
0.5061092376708984,
-0.006351699586957693,
0.744206428527832,
-0.027009397745132446,
0.2518391013145447,
-0.6894405484199524,
0.5894939303398132,
-0.4210246801376343,
0.24498750269412994,
-0.5405592322349548,
-0.8168959617614746,
-0.8221938014030457,
0.3631422817707062,
-0.5333698987960815,
0.16372570395469666,
0.7107785940170288,
0.4690776765346527,
0.11948668956756592,
0.049710873514413834,
0.40923985838890076,
0.3687467575073242,
0.5972746014595032,
0.39005085825920105,
0.9760655164718628,
-0.08708661794662476,
-0.03183561563491821,
0.19761696457862854,
-0.2084958702325821,
-0.10508126020431519,
-1.1284788846969604,
-0.8405500054359436,
-0.4749576449394226,
-0.2291851043701172,
-0.05765528604388237,
-0.08882418274879456,
0.6975805759429932,
0.336093932390213,
-0.5516660809516907,
-0.42564526200294495,
-0.558951199054718,
0.6132113337516785,
0.10931684821844101,
-0.2729240953922272,
0.4019732177257538,
-0.44075578451156616,
-0.7360289096832275,
0.3536238968372345,
0.48016685247421265,
-0.2076404094696045,
-0.4819144010543823,
-0.09965316206216812,
-0.3999486565589905,
0.0521855354309082,
1.1432582139968872,
0.16373930871486664,
-0.8808861970901489,
-0.3768528401851654,
-0.2366696000099182,
0.17923177778720856,
-0.34121954441070557,
0.9009601473808289,
-0.404651403427124,
0.28640642762184143,
0.5336238145828247,
0.7202396988868713,
0.17279070615768433,
-0.33741456270217896,
0.9189981818199158,
-0.24449670314788818,
0.3065762221813202,
0.10136794298887253,
0.6855272054672241,
0.410360187292099,
-0.19193588197231293,
0.5116485357284546,
0.28359857201576233,
-0.8084391355514526,
-0.7721635699272156,
0.4939815402030945,
-0.7046536207199097,
-0.43241074681282043,
1.2446701526641846,
0.009931952692568302,
0.05793379619717598,
-0.38021478056907654,
0.15977227687835693,
0.47311779856681824,
0.17762640118598938,
0.6745335459709167,
0.5812543630599976,
-0.47097495198249817,
0.040652431547641754,
-0.7306858897209167,
0.2808789610862732,
0.39261722564697266,
-1.2583905458450317,
0.10707949846982956,
0.9682247638702393,
-0.07963813841342926,
0.028860552236437798,
0.5870851874351501,
-0.1242356225848198,
-0.0082860691472888,
-0.12090346962213516,
0.010726097971200943,
0.470671147108078,
-0.36067694425582886,
-0.3967178165912628,
0.04364025592803955,
0.32726505398750305,
0.3236028850078583
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10568v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10568v1
|
MoPE: Parameter-Efficient and Scalable Multimodal Fusion via Mixture of Prompt Experts
| 2024-03-14T17:47:10 | 2024-03-14T17:47:10 |
Ruixiang Jiang, Lingbo Liu, Changwen Chen
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Prompt-tuning has demonstrated parameter-efficiency in fusing unimodal
foundation models for multimodal tasks. However, its limited adaptivity and
expressiveness lead to suboptimal performance when compared with other tuning
methods. In this paper, we address this issue by disentangling the vanilla
prompts to adaptively capture dataset-level and instance-level features.
Building upon this disentanglement, we introduce the mixture of prompt experts
(MoPE) technique to enhance expressiveness. MoPE leverages multimodal pairing
priors to route the most effective prompt on a per-instance basis. Compared to
vanilla prompting, our MoPE-based conditional prompting exhibits greater
expressiveness for multimodal fusion, scaling better with the training data and
the overall number of trainable parameters. We also study a regularization term
for expert routing, leading to emergent expert specialization, where different
experts focus on different concepts, enabling interpretable soft prompting.
Extensive experiments across three multimodal datasets demonstrate that our
method achieves state-of-the-art results, matching or even surpassing the
performance of fine-tuning, while requiring only 0.8% of the trainable
parameters. Code will be released: https://github.com/songrise/MoPE.
|
[
-0.6149110198020935,
-0.8019506335258484,
0.5801807641983032,
0.19925783574581146,
-0.14778532087802887,
0.1327688843011856,
-0.4160088896751404,
-0.0585223063826561,
0.23291799426078796,
0.09298483282327652,
-1.0082913637161255,
-0.15112993121147156,
-0.357022762298584,
-0.06541009247303009,
-0.08655049651861191,
0.506663978099823,
0.28499695658683777,
-0.23987245559692383,
-0.5444114208221436,
-0.12658892571926117,
-0.7610495090484619,
0.17565271258354187,
-0.47313857078552246,
0.054233480244874954,
0.8186291456222534,
0.6640655398368835,
0.6037409901618958,
0.37789011001586914,
-0.012327386997640133,
0.42203718423843384,
0.18259473145008087,
0.7252403497695923,
-0.3451615869998932,
0.513145387172699,
-0.3108675181865692,
-0.12569968402385712,
-0.3057125210762024,
0.07450444996356964,
0.28516122698783875,
0.45084092020988464,
-0.1239686906337738,
-0.0977066233754158,
-0.07977504283189774,
0.4089661240577698,
-0.690811812877655,
-0.06940388679504395,
-0.8267503380775452,
-0.1795913577079773,
-0.21081003546714783,
-0.379751056432724,
-0.5019274353981018,
0.04611639678478241,
0.09203555434942245,
-0.7530825734138489,
0.4024079144001007,
0.2702995836734772,
0.4942793548107147,
0.4354398250579834,
-0.6248193383216858,
0.16841638088226318,
-0.2344910204410553,
0.7870273590087891,
-0.4775601923465729,
0.28344103693962097,
0.18632268905639648,
0.6023260354995728,
-0.31087055802345276,
-0.4915764033794403,
-0.7645561695098877,
-0.17890655994415283,
-0.05552038177847862,
0.27234429121017456,
-0.02606438845396042,
0.1361677646636963,
0.20654627680778503,
0.3905404210090637,
-0.5608251690864563,
0.12431715428829193,
0.01711185649037361,
-0.5772382020950317,
0.5790954232215881,
0.165293350815773,
0.19153821468353271,
-0.14719396829605103,
-0.6180239319801331,
-0.28575393557548523,
-0.27269425988197327,
0.33694422245025635,
0.2671158015727997,
0.27707794308662415,
-0.22275406122207642,
0.3465014696121216,
-0.4868786633014679,
1.0815222263336182,
0.5604206919670105,
-0.35821670293807983,
0.26548582315444946,
-0.5340644121170044,
0.00014314182044472545,
-0.3075501322746277,
0.9172990918159485,
0.5677851438522339,
-0.09260252863168716,
-0.004937539808452129,
-0.14478379487991333,
0.019180748611688614,
0.014751340262591839,
-0.41842854022979736,
-0.40332645177841187,
0.3134157359600067,
-0.30281850695610046,
-0.09720747917890549,
-0.08000350743532181,
-1.1960656642913818,
-0.7909183502197266,
-0.36335915327072144,
0.6190929412841797,
-0.6170992851257324,
-0.5828204154968262,
-0.05059778690338135,
-0.480430543422699,
-0.10264812409877777,
0.49234840273857117,
-1.1008813381195068,
-0.24336935579776764,
0.478935182094574,
0.6853612065315247,
-0.009487388655543327,
-0.32332953810691833,
-0.8710517287254333,
-0.01856188289821148,
0.01050922553986311,
0.9269750714302063,
-0.8692938089370728,
-0.4094122648239136,
-0.13323968648910522,
-0.17053310573101044,
-0.3528152108192444,
-0.29122889041900635,
0.40483635663986206,
-0.17223714292049408,
0.45037660002708435,
-0.25582146644592285,
-0.32821133732795715,
-0.2420782744884491,
0.20299109816551208,
-0.4852345287799835,
0.8932128548622131,
0.32790470123291016,
-0.2142053097486496,
0.5409417748451233,
-0.45975247025489807,
-0.35120564699172974,
0.16025756299495697,
-0.28686317801475525,
0.08888603746891022,
0.21553181111812592,
0.7036558985710144,
0.7047843933105469,
-0.2773802876472473,
0.15715265274047852,
-0.33077549934387207,
0.11683747172355652,
0.2074708789587021,
-0.42374104261398315,
0.289847731590271,
0.22347554564476013,
-0.19209030270576477,
0.5293772220611572,
-1.0495805740356445,
0.142764613032341,
-0.2986399829387665,
-0.0225702952593565,
-0.18846328556537628,
-0.1299738883972168,
-0.026175251230597496,
0.4304537773132324,
0.2189648598432541,
-0.26865628361701965,
0.30296310782432556,
-0.02553492598235607,
0.4294399321079254,
0.9655386805534363,
0.021166056394577026,
0.5678279399871826,
-0.45707187056541443,
0.4789545238018036,
0.0601930133998394,
0.09440169483423233,
-0.7869794964790344,
-0.5589576959609985,
-0.6034281849861145,
-0.8190584778785706,
0.35713738203048706,
0.24979601800441742,
-1.1782689094543457,
0.2656094431877136,
-0.018247490748763084,
-0.596136212348938,
-0.6753700375556946,
0.3444274961948395,
0.38434943556785583,
0.9877280592918396,
0.4185693860054016,
-0.0048537165857851505,
-0.30963775515556335,
-1.1598892211914062,
-0.11238714307546616,
-0.00393885700032115,
-0.17545200884342194,
0.40441426634788513,
-0.09916204959154129,
0.12322016060352325,
1.0795810222625732,
-0.2832615077495575,
-0.10654768347740173,
-0.05050955340266228,
0.40821442008018494,
0.08358927816152573,
0.7115188241004944,
0.664415180683136,
-1.0341627597808838,
-0.6692398190498352,
-0.06793803721666336,
-0.40581223368644714,
-0.29205867648124695,
-0.383758008480072,
-0.1940053105354309,
-0.22749683260917664,
0.2433735728263855,
-0.705381453037262,
-0.20727476477622986,
0.6418757438659668,
-0.48834770917892456,
0.3515247702598572,
-0.08052068203687668,
0.6708590984344482,
-1.106363296508789,
-0.19193902611732483,
0.21704676747322083,
-0.2604600787162781,
-0.6154422760009766,
0.030348923057317734,
0.23295475542545319,
-0.28893402218818665,
-0.5178318619728088,
0.5867839455604553,
-0.5622296333312988,
0.44192564487457275,
-0.12840718030929565,
0.05238671973347664,
0.11533129960298538,
0.6444541215896606,
-0.04802944138646126,
0.7947827577590942,
1.017256498336792,
-0.8186453580856323,
0.5898408889770508,
0.13101977109909058,
-0.22650863230228424,
0.9968299269676208,
-0.502657949924469,
0.20183345675468445,
0.1111716702580452,
0.12280034273862839,
-1.3509705066680908,
-0.6231937408447266,
0.21021564304828644,
-0.46123987436294556,
0.1854562908411026,
-0.2808322310447693,
-0.4190845787525177,
-0.12929388880729675,
-0.2486012727022171,
0.3144393265247345,
0.7868335843086243,
-0.4485940933227539,
1.2422131299972534,
-0.034039296209812164,
-0.17907245457172394,
-0.30206769704818726,
-0.2565320134162903,
-0.10034135729074478,
-0.20671647787094116,
-1.2099684476852417,
0.5508705377578735,
-0.2683638632297516,
-0.0763087272644043,
-0.32230308651924133,
-0.11826744675636292,
-0.0615803487598896,
0.05581512674689293,
0.297646701335907,
0.22992074489593506,
-0.14128132164478302,
0.10000623762607574,
0.3763445019721985,
-0.2994212806224823,
-0.2348840981721878,
0.010668808594346046,
0.49454787373542786,
0.08276920765638351,
-0.4168905019760132,
-0.6269246935844421,
0.48848456144332886,
0.803036093711853,
-0.2510077655315399,
0.4815604090690613,
0.8394460678100586,
-0.007381615694612265,
-0.01769392006099224,
-0.9318040609359741,
-0.27795910835266113,
-0.5716161727905273,
0.023741574957966805,
-0.5443177223205566,
-0.5931639075279236,
0.4612725079059601,
-0.18271829187870026,
0.12847769260406494,
0.3705393373966217,
0.6605538725852966,
-0.18765491247177124,
1.232848048210144,
0.5765866637229919,
0.2678118646144867,
0.5873835682868958,
0.20990946888923645,
-0.32004958391189575,
-0.5354077219963074,
-0.5373107194900513,
-0.32419082522392273,
-0.6642885208129883,
-0.2148829996585846,
-0.45526832342147827,
0.6093323826789856,
-0.1928701251745224,
0.3243206739425659,
0.08192450553178787,
-0.31318727135658264,
0.40281620621681213,
0.759597897529602,
0.3739769458770752,
-0.01054474152624607,
-0.03759845718741417,
-0.047349680215120316,
-0.0004612442571669817,
-0.7612785696983337,
0.07107941806316376,
0.5004631280899048,
-0.007002875674515963,
0.8633629679679871,
0.09456449747085571,
0.19597555696964264,
0.26298192143440247,
-0.5012335181236267,
-0.6058987975120544,
0.7261071801185608,
0.1502479910850525,
-0.40781378746032715,
-0.1325630098581314,
-0.32221871614456177,
-0.6210126876831055,
0.41260865330696106,
-0.8328332901000977,
-0.4681961238384247,
0.6012819409370422,
0.554758608341217,
-0.6484633684158325,
-0.02011478878557682,
-1.028648018836975,
0.6371299028396606,
-0.1283147931098938,
-0.4032401144504547,
-0.33671754598617554,
-0.8034343719482422,
0.19644753634929657,
0.13212232291698456,
0.08811069279909134,
-0.32643479108810425,
-0.2201148122549057,
0.4079992175102234,
-0.2337469756603241,
0.7941328883171082,
-0.37847521901130676,
-0.046802472323179245,
-0.01704668626189232,
0.1258431375026703,
0.4689140319824219,
0.14152152836322784,
0.015233036130666733,
-0.18701335787773132,
-0.4022769629955292,
-0.5602969527244568,
-1.0092378854751587,
0.8036065101623535,
-0.4430842995643616,
-0.6057354211807251,
0.04165119677782059,
-0.7917789816856384,
-0.7124543190002441,
0.10615427047014236,
0.4416928291320801,
0.801010251045227,
0.3046813905239105,
0.3093542754650116,
0.930308997631073,
0.09307387471199036,
0.5431447625160217,
0.6225798726081848,
0.2130737602710724,
-0.40041664242744446,
1.0402034521102905,
-0.31377357244491577,
0.2923522889614105,
0.5109307765960693,
0.3297664523124695,
-0.3665824234485626,
-0.3808346092700958,
-0.8143671751022339,
-0.2532164752483368,
-0.4754655957221985,
-0.13561107218265533,
-0.7373907566070557,
0.368828684091568,
-0.5084701776504517,
-0.36016470193862915,
-0.2500843107700348,
-0.5814841985702515,
-0.36720892786979675,
0.13326992094516754,
0.6586973071098328,
0.061149682849645615,
-0.01854553446173668,
0.316829115152359,
-0.8285939693450928,
0.4675386846065521,
0.7904132008552551,
0.06183793395757675,
-0.1886359006166458,
-0.43893367052078247,
0.10828453302383423,
0.12491031736135483,
-0.0732777789235115,
-0.836428165435791,
0.03437136858701706,
0.4551214277744293,
0.8060892224311829,
0.6452266573905945,
0.15685251355171204,
0.9354304075241089,
-0.2761618494987488,
0.9744443297386169,
0.6243528127670288,
-0.8781545758247375,
0.7149827480316162,
-0.5864606499671936,
0.27982059121131897,
0.7495371699333191,
0.305056095123291,
-0.4498189091682434,
-0.22965863347053528,
-0.44213706254959106,
-0.8838558197021484,
0.5712108016014099,
-0.14847172796726227,
0.1711917370557785,
0.16338594257831573,
-0.043348170816898346,
0.6066889762878418,
0.3593094050884247,
-0.21145473420619965,
-0.22278882563114166,
-0.427054226398468,
-0.4532895088195801,
-0.07391564548015594,
-0.2823536694049835,
-0.4349137842655182,
-0.20502950251102448,
0.3898739516735077,
-0.3705369830131531,
-0.029057243838906288,
-0.07969368994235992,
-0.3121609389781952,
-0.01622786559164524,
0.3401051461696625,
0.8007847666740417,
0.7118968367576599,
-0.012847895734012127,
0.117234967648983,
-0.12550131976604462,
-0.07175430655479431,
0.22220727801322937,
0.06273464113473892,
0.05975617840886116,
-0.03945039212703705,
0.3666107952594757,
0.9395515322685242,
0.3787629306316376,
-0.7522540092468262,
0.5339030623435974,
-0.027750538662075996,
-0.21554310619831085,
0.1403491050004959,
0.5879435539245605,
-0.3265625238418579,
0.31890493631362915,
0.5644546747207642,
0.5894801616668701,
0.10995922237634659,
-0.3913927376270294,
0.06587715446949005,
0.34686675667762756,
-0.24880115687847137,
-0.3815092444419861,
0.4997811019420624,
0.7756516933441162,
-0.1492042988538742,
0.4704743027687073,
0.04128950461745262,
-0.13977858424186707,
0.345689982175827,
0.17393894493579865,
0.6825430393218994,
-0.2062980830669403,
0.3604471683502197,
0.047200579196214676,
-0.07403545081615448,
0.23284326493740082,
0.16599586606025696,
-0.2546784281730652,
-0.5344998836517334,
-0.4088645279407501,
-0.13548627495765686,
-0.3497650921344757,
-0.1661449819803238,
-0.6283818483352661,
0.31738823652267456,
-0.27890458703041077,
-0.06478545069694519,
0.05836748704314232,
-0.5237952470779419,
-0.5310879945755005,
0.10743585228919983,
0.08192583173513412,
1.0703392028808594,
-0.9376630187034607,
0.32086795568466187,
0.9918124675750732,
-0.31715598702430725,
-0.5859418511390686,
-0.22060686349868774,
0.3043724298477173,
-0.7055771350860596,
0.13189828395843506,
0.12386735528707504,
0.08676765859127045,
0.07175755500793457,
-0.5061970949172974,
-0.5190228819847107,
0.9934682846069336,
0.4128607213497162,
-0.6003502607345581,
0.11686675995588303,
-0.4260610342025757,
0.21969924867153168,
-0.35872137546539307,
0.5788639783859253,
0.25697973370552063,
0.7039061188697815,
0.2804948389530182,
-0.9594413638114929,
0.052133992314338684,
-0.4533627927303314,
-0.15219728648662567,
0.04578174650669098,
-0.8684777021408081,
1.0731171369552612,
-0.04754531383514404,
-0.10297130793333054,
0.06406773626804352,
0.7993268966674805,
0.132522314786911,
0.3608055114746094,
1.0678552389144897,
0.2005963772535324,
0.9235066175460815,
-0.1601940393447876,
0.8270794749259949,
-0.26512813568115234,
-0.15013885498046875,
0.7466015815734863,
-0.09200847148895264,
0.4281095266342163,
0.49852585792541504,
0.2539372146129608,
0.7049713730812073,
0.8138718008995056,
0.11998292058706284,
0.905886709690094,
-0.57538241147995,
-0.40375614166259766,
-0.821410596370697,
-0.1159685030579567,
-0.4795163571834564,
0.4216254651546478,
0.2338622510433197,
-0.20230236649513245,
-0.15617555379867554,
0.4353833794593811,
-0.36846405267715454,
0.2633213996887207,
-0.4753842353820801,
0.7585059404373169,
-0.3330869674682617,
-0.8215273022651672,
0.37085479497909546,
-0.3126397728919983,
0.9618116617202759,
-0.7907171249389648,
-0.09727831929922104,
-0.1726561039686203,
-0.2907741665840149,
-0.29228469729423523,
-0.621165931224823,
-0.4409612715244293,
-0.43481650948524475,
-0.5183663964271545,
-0.413620263338089,
0.6798295378684998,
-0.7094141244888306,
-0.22581014037132263,
-0.2968210279941559,
0.6144750714302063,
-0.32853084802627563,
-0.17972460389137268,
-0.648284375667572,
-0.1338169276714325,
0.024003498256206512,
-0.15645982325077057,
0.4487078785896301,
0.4984721839427948,
0.15789644420146942,
0.893596351146698,
0.7630009055137634,
-0.2040792852640152,
0.07559752464294434,
0.020136555656790733,
1.0678761005401611,
-0.4355721175670624,
-0.5828279256820679,
-0.7754295468330383,
1.02860426902771,
-0.15696251392364502,
-0.60381019115448,
0.7985249757766724,
0.09109175950288773,
0.4181375503540039,
-0.33762192726135254,
0.5494276285171509,
-0.3878621459007263,
0.4194912910461426,
-0.9361945390701294,
0.39435818791389465,
-0.7606486678123474,
-0.042837031185626984,
-0.14731638133525848,
-0.6909103393554688,
0.245441272854805,
0.2982226610183716,
0.12656213343143463,
0.228706493973732,
0.5605412125587463,
0.9113369584083557,
-0.29796186089515686,
-0.09608924388885498,
0.41510292887687683,
0.08919644355773926,
0.18631400167942047,
0.4634745419025421,
0.9726273417472839,
0.19074690341949463,
0.3813857138156891,
-0.4408276081085205,
-0.4317436218261719,
-0.4399779140949249,
-0.9710909128189087,
-0.8525019884109497,
-0.852045476436615,
-0.4230283796787262,
-0.12407772988080978,
-0.20706233382225037,
1.112994909286499,
1.14518141746521,
-0.6377735137939453,
0.37227579951286316,
0.2977127134799957,
0.2164899706840515,
-0.6417859792709351,
-0.2464800775051117,
0.06691399216651917,
-0.3213927149772644,
-0.83478844165802,
0.9111111164093018,
0.2513749599456787,
-0.039229199290275574,
-0.35802385210990906,
0.11136197298765182,
0.049852289259433746,
-0.09318658709526062,
0.5836001634597778,
0.18776549398899078,
-0.7177670001983643,
-0.12221591919660568,
0.04739949479699135,
0.217902272939682,
-0.12380492687225342,
0.9178842902183533,
-0.9930393099784851,
0.8484928011894226,
0.7655404210090637,
0.43820706009864807,
-0.010275375097990036,
0.3095695674419403,
0.8625550866127014,
-1.0668293237686157,
0.35827308893203735,
0.21833908557891846,
0.5587953925132751,
0.19777746498584747,
-0.46169060468673706,
0.2647833228111267,
0.4190464913845062,
-0.3373290002346039,
-0.6777185797691345,
0.3818645179271698,
-1.49715256690979,
-0.07595178484916687,
1.1515601873397827,
0.058665987104177475,
-0.094821497797966,
-0.11821647733449936,
-0.5715711712837219,
-0.30161136388778687,
-0.8668635487556458,
0.586800754070282,
0.5444352626800537,
-0.22568123042583466,
-0.5792560577392578,
-0.023955874145030975,
0.3267762362957001,
0.47865527868270874,
-0.4874371886253357,
-0.28476160764694214,
0.8070899844169617,
0.09588324278593063,
0.19390521943569183,
0.5293843746185303,
0.41760656237602234,
0.6576682925224304,
0.20850762724876404,
-0.023744704201817513,
-0.7490259408950806,
-0.5179747939109802,
-0.06500730663537979,
0.35128331184387207,
-0.20323938131332397,
-0.2640990912914276
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09559v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09559v2
|
Less is More: Data Value Estimation for Visual Instruction Tuning
| 2024-03-14T16:47:25 | 2024-03-21T06:51:16 |
Zikang Liu, Kun Zhou, Wayne Xin Zhao, Dawei Gao, Yaliang Li, Ji-Rong Wen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Visual instruction tuning is the key to building multimodal large language
models (MLLMs), which greatly improves the reasoning capabilities of large
language models (LLMs) in vision scenario. However, existing MLLMs mostly rely
on a mixture of multiple highly diverse visual instruction datasets for
training (even more than a million instructions), which may introduce data
redundancy. To investigate this issue, we conduct a series of empirical
studies, which reveal a significant redundancy within the visual instruction
datasets, and show that greatly reducing the amount of several instruction
dataset even do not affect the performance. Based on the findings, we propose a
new data selection approach TIVE, to eliminate redundancy within visual
instruction data. TIVE first estimates the task-level and instance-level value
of the visual instructions based on computed gradients. Then, according to the
estimated values, TIVE determines the task proportion within the visual
instructions, and selects representative instances to compose a smaller visual
instruction subset for training. Experiments on LLaVA-1.5 show that our
approach using only about 7.5% data can achieve comparable performance as the
full-data fine-tuned model across seven benchmarks, even surpassing it on four
of the benchmarks. Our code and data will be publicly released.
|
[
-0.4457082748413086,
-0.8073768615722656,
0.34539783000946045,
-0.14131058752536774,
-0.27234750986099243,
-0.19637784361839294,
-0.35120752453804016,
-0.2895868420600891,
-0.08075469732284546,
0.5692561268806458,
-0.6391142010688782,
-0.64301598072052,
-0.6142048835754395,
-0.27841633558273315,
-0.2559199929237366,
0.6458900570869446,
0.1571519672870636,
0.23209203779697418,
-0.4849146902561188,
-0.30048128962516785,
-0.8174003958702087,
0.02983502298593521,
-0.3804534375667572,
-0.13254742324352264,
0.5193586945533752,
0.8313416242599487,
0.3964214622974396,
1.0083595514297485,
0.6359718441963196,
0.3172033131122589,
-0.036177750676870346,
0.571628212928772,
-0.8416540622711182,
-0.0059515307657420635,
0.16548176109790802,
-0.6311064958572388,
-0.3862175941467285,
-0.01589908078312874,
0.654934287071228,
0.5840144157409668,
-0.08007894456386566,
0.471339613199234,
-0.11302286386489868,
1.0683051347732544,
-0.859703779220581,
0.20774473249912262,
-0.5904030203819275,
0.11600479483604431,
-0.10266979783773422,
-0.15369291603565216,
-0.5037784576416016,
-0.4844747483730316,
0.12209585309028625,
-0.5813317894935608,
0.25338664650917053,
0.1318327784538269,
0.6141794323921204,
0.5980607867240906,
-0.22860325872898102,
0.42663973569869995,
-0.5679242610931396,
1.199235200881958,
-0.39793357253074646,
0.533072829246521,
0.36473724246025085,
0.4332904517650604,
0.14114907383918762,
-0.4347468912601471,
-0.38757044076919556,
-0.13300751149654388,
0.2241288423538208,
0.12846176326274872,
-0.13303083181381226,
0.09122022241353989,
0.48360371589660645,
0.21762806177139282,
-0.6025471687316895,
0.15739163756370544,
-0.5176452398300171,
0.03725839778780937,
0.6323292255401611,
0.4197663962841034,
0.07252701371908188,
0.11374233663082123,
-0.373286634683609,
-0.4418165981769562,
-0.8030818700790405,
0.011881503276526928,
0.08274860680103302,
0.20984816551208496,
-0.2652890086174011,
0.6521292328834534,
-0.24026958644390106,
1.1313083171844482,
-0.09902913123369217,
-0.3623497784137726,
0.41958484053611755,
-0.42746368050575256,
-0.5618899464607239,
-0.19671902060508728,
0.37285318970680237,
0.6861521601676941,
0.589894711971283,
0.05024892836809158,
-0.1554315984249115,
0.19321590662002563,
0.40847569704055786,
-0.7994822263717651,
-0.3754633665084839,
-0.04518871754407883,
-0.45259755849838257,
0.018122270703315735,
-0.1338013857603073,
-0.884687066078186,
-0.48731696605682373,
-0.7772267460823059,
-0.052235834300518036,
-0.3200654983520508,
0.09808960556983948,
-0.0905410572886467,
-0.14642050862312317,
0.17148113250732422,
0.5967657566070557,
-0.8321245908737183,
-0.07400140911340714,
0.5677402019500732,
0.6553962230682373,
-0.3228960633277893,
-0.3964722156524658,
-0.9160436987876892,
0.009597085416316986,
-0.39284268021583557,
0.7010929584503174,
-1.1206672191619873,
-0.3214605450630188,
-0.19615674018859863,
-0.017535150051116943,
-0.10437574237585068,
-0.5661718845367432,
0.17081688344478607,
-0.3917566239833832,
-0.020731154829263687,
-0.31028029322624207,
-0.6403408050537109,
-0.22557635605335236,
0.08450568467378616,
-0.7842087149620056,
0.9814070463180542,
0.1679391860961914,
-0.5899364352226257,
0.7361851334571838,
-0.3477717638015747,
-0.3759000897407532,
-0.07023242115974426,
-0.29016315937042236,
-0.59543776512146,
0.35244542360305786,
0.4345915615558624,
0.35532283782958984,
-0.32421329617500305,
-0.10745494812726974,
-0.5526958703994751,
-0.7162799835205078,
-0.011374121531844139,
-0.7680642008781433,
0.5086609721183777,
0.12693776190280914,
-0.26007112860679626,
0.24512700736522675,
-0.892184853553772,
0.280723512172699,
-0.2395363450050354,
-0.3821479380130768,
-0.17845141887664795,
-0.07768896967172623,
0.01991300657391548,
-0.04509267583489418,
0.04782625660300255,
-0.5442673563957214,
0.25856828689575195,
-0.25931495428085327,
0.04079897329211235,
0.7639281153678894,
-0.10531286150217056,
0.4744042754173279,
-0.24778802692890167,
0.6205311417579651,
-0.1263633519411087,
0.4165117144584656,
-0.0542263425886631,
-0.5155069231987,
-0.9831472039222717,
-0.472943514585495,
0.08768725395202637,
0.5453777313232422,
-0.8832321763038635,
-0.008129259571433067,
-0.3993915617465973,
-0.308675616979599,
-0.744900107383728,
0.34773218631744385,
0.6161516308784485,
0.46219369769096375,
0.48671093583106995,
0.2133132964372635,
-0.5890920758247375,
-0.8881746530532837,
0.06713256239891052,
0.21671347320079803,
0.10858893394470215,
0.33952197432518005,
0.42725029587745667,
-0.012401117011904716,
0.725430965423584,
-0.7184115648269653,
-0.1368875950574875,
-0.11162635684013367,
-0.05438968166708946,
-0.09532541781663895,
0.36076998710632324,
0.465947687625885,
-0.7253655791282654,
-0.5814008712768555,
0.09533780068159103,
-0.6937511563301086,
0.1478814333677292,
0.06551966071128845,
-0.15947693586349487,
0.2305300384759903,
0.41726207733154297,
-0.19080856442451477,
0.6053394675254822,
0.5635581612586975,
0.015713239088654518,
0.08075404912233353,
-0.3355453610420227,
0.3359442949295044,
-0.6691164970397949,
-0.14242595434188843,
0.14112353324890137,
-0.15041445195674896,
-0.375424325466156,
-0.15728415548801422,
0.23531198501586914,
-0.03356220945715904,
-0.45330527424812317,
0.5163134932518005,
-0.5988349914550781,
-0.10623930394649506,
-0.24225755035877228,
0.01836012862622738,
0.0060848151333630085,
0.7178635001182556,
0.02764737792313099,
0.9194124341011047,
0.6128532886505127,
-0.4822145104408264,
0.6810615658760071,
0.2235497534275055,
-0.7371611595153809,
0.6700108647346497,
-0.46913737058639526,
0.0018179987091571093,
-0.3123733103275299,
-0.2262071818113327,
-0.9182448983192444,
-0.17482416331768036,
0.0313488133251667,
-0.2809506356716156,
0.4187905192375183,
-0.45838040113449097,
-0.1095418632030487,
-0.15247049927711487,
-0.31179413199424744,
0.1563762128353119,
0.46312668919563293,
-0.6092044115066528,
0.2880437672138214,
0.48572197556495667,
-0.1348423808813095,
-0.739838719367981,
-0.740160346031189,
-0.1338159143924713,
-0.23836757242679596,
-0.49212154746055603,
-0.1310940682888031,
-0.03858835622668266,
-0.09061015397310257,
-0.07390133291482925,
-0.15386536717414856,
-0.23748010396957397,
0.003337811678647995,
0.3445163369178772,
0.5904073715209961,
-0.2857310473918915,
0.3125205934047699,
0.026077350601553917,
-0.165904700756073,
-0.30531764030456543,
-0.16055095195770264,
0.20507605373859406,
-0.03620622307062149,
-0.5914546847343445,
-0.44651004672050476,
0.31630152463912964,
0.5592040419578552,
-0.3660986125469208,
0.6323636770248413,
0.7446054220199585,
-0.0970812514424324,
-0.29398593306541443,
-0.584526777267456,
0.03492943197488785,
-0.4300355315208435,
0.5807108283042908,
-0.07569978386163712,
-0.6443886160850525,
-0.027493488043546677,
0.1590149849653244,
0.2735435962677002,
-0.10231448709964752,
0.3108765482902527,
-0.27392101287841797,
1.0529563426971436,
0.690647304058075,
-0.009616110473871231,
1.0046353340148926,
-0.4327101409435272,
-0.13319982588291168,
-0.6794212460517883,
-0.3708711564540863,
-0.14536458253860474,
-0.5349437594413757,
-0.5156890749931335,
-0.6024669408798218,
0.5875133275985718,
-0.1818944364786148,
-0.1864301860332489,
0.007761016488075256,
-0.5784206986427307,
0.7167361378669739,
0.7280340194702148,
0.38002318143844604,
0.11247380077838898,
0.567006528377533,
0.3764621317386627,
-0.18558187782764435,
-0.7031346559524536,
-0.2518639862537384,
1.2354316711425781,
-0.01671999879181385,
1.0635466575622559,
-0.15125615894794464,
0.4386991262435913,
0.1378546506166458,
0.18196773529052734,
-0.6506430506706238,
0.5079740881919861,
-0.46038618683815,
-0.2815096378326416,
-0.5049414038658142,
-0.6730036735534668,
-0.9282932281494141,
0.3052961230278015,
-0.43256625533103943,
-0.6799021363258362,
0.12322457879781723,
0.4865148663520813,
-0.31416457891464233,
0.1896786391735077,
-1.1114941835403442,
0.9195705652236938,
-0.2845227122306824,
-0.5438350439071655,
-0.2319173663854599,
-0.42775920033454895,
0.2899131774902344,
0.10724543035030365,
-0.13838239014148712,
-0.07998000830411911,
-0.012904742732644081,
0.5138961672782898,
-0.33637484908103943,
0.8780539631843567,
-0.24286803603172302,
-0.019786648452281952,
0.19334259629249573,
-0.382734477519989,
0.6795322895050049,
-0.12893424928188324,
0.08935859054327011,
-0.03371180221438408,
-0.16591238975524902,
-0.5317720770835876,
-0.7606824636459351,
0.7977609038352966,
-0.5567662715911865,
-0.38303422927856445,
0.1259865015745163,
-0.5592640042304993,
-0.34041646122932434,
-0.049864161759614944,
0.24380092322826385,
0.6615264415740967,
0.12280399352312088,
0.5228772759437561,
0.888745903968811,
-0.19266635179519653,
0.36993008852005005,
0.2560109496116638,
0.18151098489761353,
-0.5965541005134583,
1.246652364730835,
0.09242711216211319,
0.3564634621143341,
0.6161789894104004,
-0.045661650598049164,
-0.16528883576393127,
-0.655452311038971,
-0.6178268194198608,
-0.018147213384509087,
-0.6541002988815308,
-0.19082458317279816,
-0.2953254282474518,
0.1924731284379959,
-0.053668174892663956,
-0.08663754910230637,
-0.5453218221664429,
-0.18576876819133759,
-0.2901270389556885,
-0.0018883425509557128,
0.5181827545166016,
0.48202016949653625,
0.3074343204498291,
0.34032562375068665,
-0.9143140912055969,
0.47142350673675537,
0.4371442198753357,
0.5126218199729919,
-0.04283304512500763,
-0.44803833961486816,
-0.5537226796150208,
0.39185112714767456,
0.01415402814745903,
-0.4816375970840454,
0.3424185812473297,
0.11868645250797272,
0.6344082355499268,
0.2691259980201721,
-0.1872635930776596,
1.1634916067123413,
-0.43603578209877014,
0.4393904209136963,
0.34209194779396057,
-0.6043774485588074,
0.5864299535751343,
0.08170076459646225,
0.36549609899520874,
0.5427579879760742,
-0.06527942419052124,
-0.26258015632629395,
-0.0694156289100647,
-0.289419025182724,
-0.6627052426338196,
0.9006086587905884,
0.03465006500482559,
-0.10691836476325989,
0.34825992584228516,
0.045356981456279755,
0.020966961979866028,
0.35413286089897156,
-0.32607725262641907,
-0.473349928855896,
-0.09190105646848679,
-0.3034292161464691,
-0.04079441353678703,
-0.18979810178279877,
-0.17989042401313782,
-0.37452349066734314,
0.38718825578689575,
-0.1190449520945549,
0.10392318665981293,
-0.3026815354824066,
-0.2724711298942566,
-0.1125694289803505,
0.06599905341863632,
0.6552532315254211,
0.8096321821212769,
-0.13581861555576324,
-0.10717962682247162,
0.28701648116111755,
-0.6024728417396545,
0.062051013112068176,
-0.1412941962480545,
-0.20434820652008057,
-0.15360823273658752,
0.5633631348609924,
1.3229702711105347,
0.17873422801494598,
-0.8010435104370117,
0.5090909004211426,
0.012372614815831184,
-0.06601016968488693,
-0.00958043523132801,
0.4721444249153137,
-0.17327310144901276,
0.49367988109588623,
-0.06942584365606308,
0.21732667088508606,
-0.07066993415355682,
-0.1761939525604248,
0.1505512297153473,
0.4875311851501465,
-0.27888959646224976,
0.07044947892427444,
0.46197718381881714,
0.36303943395614624,
0.07985494285821915,
0.7848697900772095,
0.051667455583810806,
0.09639830142259598,
0.7019709944725037,
0.017897043377161026,
0.5936816930770874,
0.07637906074523926,
0.2631208896636963,
0.3080081641674042,
0.30181193351745605,
-0.08204588294029236,
0.37026017904281616,
-0.028290707617998123,
-0.5302562713623047,
-0.6557717323303223,
-0.4731349050998688,
-0.20288707315921783,
0.2251470535993576,
-0.7425612211227417,
0.22280104458332062,
-0.3121460974216461,
-0.12155915796756744,
-0.06012443080544472,
0.02637811005115509,
-0.7056461572647095,
0.2700407803058624,
0.2863759994506836,
0.6775842308998108,
-0.8660887479782104,
0.8833562135696411,
0.6087115406990051,
-0.4316907823085785,
-0.4990081191062927,
-0.3460884392261505,
0.0019103435333818197,
-1.0353670120239258,
0.7660930752754211,
-0.0800878182053566,
-0.21686215698719025,
-0.1806374490261078,
-0.6683418154716492,
-0.7964251637458801,
0.9571511149406433,
0.7295666933059692,
-0.7731705904006958,
0.07395503669977188,
-0.09026266634464264,
0.3824346363544464,
-0.26740762591362,
0.07612757384777069,
0.7094055414199829,
0.5648452043533325,
0.4230814278125763,
-0.5325568318367004,
-0.39132723212242126,
-0.23653127253055573,
0.24971801042556763,
0.3001604974269867,
-0.5148051977157593,
0.7719910144805908,
-0.49576258659362793,
-0.29556411504745483,
-0.07201644778251648,
0.4128361940383911,
0.15866264700889587,
0.32885077595710754,
0.3239808976650238,
0.5193246006965637,
0.871537446975708,
-0.046770766377449036,
1.1047768592834473,
-0.10520333051681519,
0.27961012721061707,
1.3847488164901733,
0.050382349640131,
0.7092125415802002,
0.37634503841400146,
-0.21236370503902435,
-0.03300478309392929,
0.5348259210586548,
-0.3515891134738922,
0.5593871474266052,
-0.09445471316576004,
-0.055125750601291656,
-0.5449228882789612,
0.021843239665031433,
-0.36708903312683105,
0.5333783030509949,
0.17352642118930817,
-0.3044011890888214,
-0.03810924291610718,
0.037217799574136734,
-0.2720305025577545,
-0.03647422045469284,
-0.30147066712379456,
0.7560375928878784,
-0.3036118149757385,
-0.6308374404907227,
0.9910289645195007,
-0.3477097749710083,
0.3056633174419403,
-0.3941131830215454,
-0.4657112956047058,
-0.46446460485458374,
0.20987559854984283,
-0.22488416731357574,
-0.7380351424217224,
-0.10173133760690689,
0.24657094478607178,
-0.3804454207420349,
-0.19142980873584747,
0.27088695764541626,
-0.7024204134941101,
-0.6691544651985168,
-0.11178918182849884,
0.4969136416912079,
0.017257943749427795,
0.0043405527248978615,
-0.4519205391407013,
0.2055443823337555,
0.37227460741996765,
-0.17250947654247284,
0.37444981932640076,
0.36802634596824646,
-0.060722656548023224,
0.9954115152359009,
0.5406882762908936,
0.359221488237381,
0.25629159808158875,
0.2017498016357422,
0.8432315587997437,
-0.6249164342880249,
-0.16243824362754822,
-0.7408840656280518,
0.557232141494751,
-0.3398374915122986,
-0.3998340368270874,
0.626532793045044,
0.5801323652267456,
0.9084579944610596,
-0.22427548468112946,
0.7529058456420898,
0.4131852090358734,
0.325461745262146,
-0.877493679523468,
0.2832731604576111,
-0.7460773587226868,
0.38194993138313293,
-0.21312189102172852,
-0.8860132098197937,
-0.19824166595935822,
0.6126121282577515,
-0.41974225640296936,
0.08359234780073166,
0.5247400403022766,
0.9408606886863708,
-0.17113693058490753,
-0.01422564871609211,
0.5898910164833069,
-0.10904809832572937,
0.02120310068130493,
0.6229180693626404,
0.7500181198120117,
-0.17247407138347626,
0.6448706388473511,
-0.17043881118297577,
-0.14486943185329437,
-0.35344988107681274,
-0.6067546010017395,
-0.9370599389076233,
-0.2204374074935913,
-0.2851647734642029,
0.17630687355995178,
-0.006208416540175676,
0.732559859752655,
0.9122506976127625,
-0.7186784148216248,
-0.13781599700450897,
0.0001823591155698523,
0.33552423119544983,
-0.4054999351501465,
-0.128632590174675,
0.3020922541618347,
-0.2586249113082886,
-0.9628708362579346,
0.4021737575531006,
0.3869161009788513,
0.036958735436201096,
0.02496415562927723,
-0.0581112876534462,
-0.03587910905480385,
-0.20039483904838562,
0.7071684002876282,
0.07367458939552307,
-0.6791799664497375,
-0.23164239525794983,
-0.006936836056411266,
-0.027203356847167015,
0.25728410482406616,
0.630476176738739,
-0.6260026693344116,
0.8598296046257019,
0.5504306554794312,
0.7041395306587219,
0.700103223323822,
0.026250604540109634,
0.35691308975219727,
-0.9847345948219299,
0.21208985149860382,
-0.06658447533845901,
0.394275963306427,
0.3719850480556488,
-0.09175064414739609,
0.5985598564147949,
0.12555861473083496,
-0.18228808045387268,
-0.7426323294639587,
0.1726895272731781,
-0.9170694947242737,
-0.2236398607492447,
1.0768502950668335,
-0.0745852068066597,
-0.26599448919296265,
0.2025720775127411,
-0.30874913930892944,
0.18165025115013123,
-0.48040467500686646,
0.48121312260627747,
0.3489172160625458,
-0.29335227608680725,
-0.5353944897651672,
-0.7939855456352234,
0.42748114466667175,
0.22836986184120178,
-0.8535496592521667,
0.34954923391342163,
1.009228229522705,
0.147996723651886,
-0.16505911946296692,
0.06417819112539291,
0.25203531980514526,
0.3752762973308563,
0.2789476811885834,
0.02106802724301815,
-0.420425683259964,
-0.6121066808700562,
-0.17781293392181396,
0.1438918262720108,
-0.16619150340557098,
-0.7189813256263733
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09539v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09539v2
|
Logits of API-Protected LLMs Leak Proprietary Information
| 2024-03-14T16:27:49 | 2024-03-15T02:07:30 |
Matthew Finlayson, Xiang Ren, Swabha Swayamdipta
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR, cs.LG, 68T50, I.2.7
|
The commercialization of large language models (LLMs) has led to the common
practice of high-level API-only access to proprietary models. In this work, we
show that even with a conservative assumption about the model architecture, it
is possible to learn a surprisingly large amount of non-public information
about an API-protected LLM from a relatively small number of API queries (e.g.,
costing under $1,000 for OpenAI's gpt-3.5-turbo). Our findings are centered on
one key observation: most modern LLMs suffer from a softmax bottleneck, which
restricts the model outputs to a linear subspace of the full output space. We
show that this lends itself to a model image or a model signature which unlocks
several capabilities with affordable cost: efficiently discovering the LLM's
hidden size, obtaining full-vocabulary outputs, detecting and disambiguating
different model updates, identifying the source LLM given a single full LLM
output, and even estimating the output layer parameters. Our empirical
investigations show the effectiveness of our methods, which allow us to
estimate the embedding size of OpenAI's gpt-3.5-turbo to be about 4,096.
Lastly, we discuss ways that LLM providers can guard against these attacks, as
well as how these capabilities can be viewed as a feature (rather than a bug)
by allowing for greater transparency and accountability.
|
[
-0.196439728140831,
-0.43730026483535767,
0.6571789383888245,
-0.17586007714271545,
-0.13543300330638885,
0.04264746606349945,
-0.08647453784942627,
-0.8279264569282532,
-0.04854761064052582,
0.959455132484436,
-0.4180625081062317,
-0.5912765264511108,
-0.6909534335136414,
-0.2835710644721985,
-0.28190189599990845,
0.905179500579834,
0.044287458062171936,
-0.20317134261131287,
-0.0057458276860415936,
-0.1325179487466812,
-0.3653637170791626,
-0.7674682140350342,
-0.43424323201179504,
-0.03783117234706879,
0.5637377500534058,
0.12999525666236877,
0.5338611006736755,
0.920915961265564,
0.2855221927165985,
0.22037169337272644,
-0.1370740532875061,
-0.028843039646744728,
-0.6186232566833496,
-0.0836196169257164,
0.0690828263759613,
-0.8951009511947632,
-0.4602242112159729,
-0.13305018842220306,
0.684841513633728,
0.35122978687286377,
0.07694786041975021,
0.5415478348731995,
0.1445690095424652,
0.8192128539085388,
-0.6639173030853271,
0.4297136962413788,
-0.9173920750617981,
0.025911053642630577,
-0.5110403299331665,
0.04336845502257347,
-0.6044651865959167,
-0.06545206159353256,
0.014124153181910515,
-0.5603367686271667,
0.05071403831243515,
0.014307139441370964,
0.8814687132835388,
0.4256405830383301,
-0.27343884110450745,
-0.26181280612945557,
-0.7460914254188538,
0.9742709994316101,
-0.566089928150177,
0.23998962342739105,
0.25357577204704285,
0.33112186193466187,
0.04499414935708046,
-0.5461676716804504,
-0.0008987980545498431,
-0.09392328560352325,
0.09635312855243683,
-0.2687705457210541,
-0.35704419016838074,
0.09935560822486877,
0.35796523094177246,
0.37934964895248413,
-0.46714282035827637,
0.4029165804386139,
-0.3931431770324707,
-0.4034653604030609,
0.7029382586479187,
0.021192675456404686,
0.20963524281978607,
0.0036869419272989035,
-0.5243749022483826,
-0.006499638315290213,
-1.3597544431686401,
0.040984801948070526,
0.540106475353241,
0.24927762150764465,
-0.04881419613957405,
0.508878767490387,
0.23542910814285278,
0.3902931213378906,
-0.4907119870185852,
-0.08384235948324203,
0.053510408848524094,
-0.0614803321659565,
-0.34297481179237366,
-0.1074804961681366,
0.6609795093536377,
-0.22429661452770233,
0.3757614493370056,
-0.25237810611724854,
-0.40245941281318665,
-0.2110729068517685,
-0.027187200263142586,
-0.626052975654602,
0.07343817502260208,
0.3877713084220886,
-0.502936601638794,
-0.10072749853134155,
0.13461552560329437,
-0.7192881107330322,
-0.4714891016483307,
-0.06056973338127136,
0.3203367292881012,
0.05803929641842842,
-0.4760282337665558,
-0.05857313051819801,
-0.08247978240251541,
0.3229120671749115,
0.029660027474164963,
-0.7559922933578491,
0.3311063349246979,
1.0420657396316528,
1.1079928874969482,
0.07050512731075287,
0.030549757182598114,
-0.4463760256767273,
0.253329873085022,
-0.2985544502735138,
0.5862357020378113,
-0.2422008365392685,
-0.3675365746021271,
0.12325762957334518,
-0.01953952945768833,
0.09242119640111923,
-0.699923038482666,
0.1742531806230545,
-0.7323424220085144,
-0.47424405813217163,
-0.09532326459884644,
-0.5688967108726501,
0.12125805020332336,
-0.0402102917432785,
-0.8595713973045349,
0.5122753381729126,
-0.19794590771198273,
-0.5969854593276978,
0.20319026708602905,
-0.5218865275382996,
-0.021344834938645363,
0.19766461849212646,
-0.4548952281475067,
-0.4045969545841217,
0.2275313287973404,
0.20066215097904205,
0.36570531129837036,
-0.06912672519683838,
-0.0526006817817688,
-0.36486613750457764,
-0.43747302889823914,
0.6086671352386475,
-0.4273594915866852,
0.7947496771812439,
0.3186836540699005,
-0.3777429759502411,
0.07948700338602066,
-0.5992762446403503,
-0.16241607069969177,
0.20940032601356506,
-0.45069313049316406,
-0.3602370321750641,
-0.2590169906616211,
-0.5003160834312439,
-0.19681711494922638,
0.4841748774051666,
-0.565186619758606,
0.16798831522464752,
-0.36755189299583435,
0.5876816511154175,
1.2059788703918457,
-0.15680448710918427,
0.44800227880477905,
-0.29905208945274353,
0.4848288297653198,
-0.17138893902301788,
0.42617708444595337,
-0.33206459879875183,
-0.7042754888534546,
-0.549698531627655,
-0.6615467667579651,
0.3342083692550659,
0.3423837125301361,
-0.21596954762935638,
-0.017333421856164932,
-0.26095011830329895,
-0.48299670219421387,
-0.6902329325675964,
0.6323385238647461,
0.6070799827575684,
0.15257875621318817,
-0.054911527782678604,
-0.09497302770614624,
-0.16757269203662872,
-1.070435643196106,
-0.4615594148635864,
-0.14611530303955078,
-0.27207356691360474,
0.7345332503318787,
0.30275169014930725,
0.06670223921537399,
0.5504251718521118,
-0.7164906859397888,
-0.4191732704639435,
-0.08324366062879562,
0.07873649895191193,
0.39453643560409546,
0.35919323563575745,
0.5248988270759583,
-0.5180990695953369,
-0.23880423605442047,
-0.15970049798488617,
-0.6022932529449463,
-0.007754978258162737,
-0.11721358448266983,
-0.1932920664548874,
0.21658745408058167,
0.4786551296710968,
-0.8656643629074097,
0.3260211944580078,
0.6917607188224792,
-0.22833633422851562,
0.49434125423431396,
-0.2727563977241516,
-0.6453388929367065,
-0.7168260216712952,
-0.06887387484312057,
-0.05326180160045624,
-0.30494633316993713,
-0.37402307987213135,
0.4221244156360626,
0.10375646501779556,
-0.24517177045345306,
-0.6280534863471985,
0.5332028865814209,
-0.6565234065055847,
-0.30538493394851685,
-0.35191094875335693,
-0.05110298842191696,
-0.1556852012872696,
0.5200161933898926,
-0.11560004204511642,
0.9495261907577515,
0.6071490049362183,
-0.5722267031669617,
0.05412892997264862,
0.09171485900878906,
-0.23149064183235168,
-0.14918072521686554,
-0.5598073601722717,
0.47818800806999207,
-0.040702901780605316,
0.21848222613334656,
-0.6725430488586426,
-0.16526924073696136,
0.08585333079099655,
-0.3958621621131897,
0.3115239441394806,
-0.6199263334274292,
-0.5284003615379333,
-0.014186684973537922,
-0.40311434864997864,
0.23827120661735535,
0.7919553518295288,
-0.7601147890090942,
0.5438927412033081,
0.6128753423690796,
-0.1472727507352829,
-0.7925077676773071,
-1.032318353652954,
0.08828765153884888,
-0.07231346517801285,
-0.6024656295776367,
-0.08312417566776276,
-0.027900181710720062,
-0.21456515789031982,
0.1588728278875351,
-0.15259800851345062,
-0.2651069760322571,
0.2065274566411972,
0.5691473484039307,
0.24475663900375366,
-0.5456516146659851,
0.08750949054956436,
-0.2229006141424179,
-0.08092173933982849,
0.25016504526138306,
-0.5569581985473633,
0.47175726294517517,
-0.31636181473731995,
-0.5278679728507996,
-0.33119678497314453,
0.14662419259548187,
0.6254184246063232,
-0.15712590515613556,
0.6607720255851746,
0.26017501950263977,
-0.4334532618522644,
-0.4618871510028839,
-0.4406416714191437,
-0.026783807203173637,
-0.5260730981826782,
0.1789712756872177,
-0.14237166941165924,
-0.8498594164848328,
0.5417400598526001,
-0.10505612194538116,
0.3014558255672455,
0.36545872688293457,
0.36254748702049255,
0.2608466148376465,
0.8958232998847961,
0.697494626045227,
-0.24459819495677948,
0.3327982425689697,
-0.38531988859176636,
0.23463031649589539,
-0.6280736923217773,
-0.42158207297325134,
-0.42951640486717224,
-0.3877333104610443,
-0.7076472043991089,
-0.37030890583992004,
0.26100054383277893,
-0.05093102529644966,
-0.32605475187301636,
0.11213091015815735,
-0.3846820890903473,
0.6115449070930481,
0.944599986076355,
0.19088800251483917,
0.44973620772361755,
0.07882920652627945,
0.1212344542145729,
0.07120431214570999,
-0.5247769951820374,
-0.67674720287323,
1.4798109531402588,
0.8430686593055725,
0.8584235310554504,
0.42098915576934814,
0.6878445148468018,
0.12109126150608063,
0.42806968092918396,
-0.6980156898498535,
0.5957608819007874,
-0.19257868826389313,
-0.7328847050666809,
-0.1702880561351776,
-0.5344544649124146,
-0.8893512487411499,
-0.05434337258338928,
0.006033341400325298,
-0.7374628186225891,
0.3326568007469177,
0.37937623262405396,
-0.33483830094337463,
0.6198237538337708,
-0.8117848038673401,
0.538783609867096,
-0.4336290955543518,
-0.47987064719200134,
-0.06642479449510574,
-0.3376365602016449,
0.6037458777427673,
-0.3248134255409241,
0.27451810240745544,
-0.2591763734817505,
-0.3838917911052704,
0.5990850329399109,
-0.346324622631073,
1.1285375356674194,
-0.38004785776138306,
-0.15695229172706604,
0.3235395848751068,
0.14721491932868958,
0.46224233508110046,
0.3424469232559204,
0.2065347284078598,
0.5428969264030457,
-0.07224753499031067,
-0.5211939811706543,
-0.38744646310806274,
0.7848048806190491,
-0.8935173749923706,
-0.7551805377006531,
-0.3105432689189911,
-0.4030987322330475,
-0.14281311631202698,
0.21947015821933746,
0.17746470868587494,
0.44975998997688293,
0.16781385242938995,
0.2602442502975464,
0.9739293456077576,
-0.4980575144290924,
0.29225867986679077,
0.49257537722587585,
-0.18716128170490265,
-0.14511358737945557,
0.9615969061851501,
0.12266351282596588,
0.3721981644630432,
0.22496025264263153,
0.3240494728088379,
-0.307543009519577,
-0.8014429807662964,
-0.327205628156662,
0.4685901403427124,
-0.7214863300323486,
-0.5027727484703064,
-0.33785778284072876,
-0.48136085271835327,
-0.20948399603366852,
0.197696715593338,
-0.59808349609375,
-0.526203453540802,
-0.2561013400554657,
-0.16935840249061584,
0.3046896159648895,
1.0555542707443237,
-0.1349124163389206,
0.249860942363739,
-0.8509467244148254,
-0.03670603409409523,
0.3572668135166168,
0.5349540710449219,
0.17713239789009094,
-0.2755512297153473,
-0.08798807114362717,
-0.17576953768730164,
-0.32622310519218445,
-0.544043779373169,
0.2761997878551483,
0.14671967923641205,
0.510582685470581,
0.6727688312530518,
0.08274274319410324,
0.26661524176597595,
-0.30640068650245667,
0.9688423275947571,
0.058820292353630066,
-0.8241544365882874,
0.3113057315349579,
-0.21973788738250732,
0.12057217210531235,
0.1220843493938446,
0.30133962631225586,
-0.03860095515847206,
-0.513001561164856,
-0.6011074185371399,
-0.969170331954956,
0.45399200916290283,
-0.05669660121202469,
0.483102411031723,
0.2174653261899948,
0.4886637032032013,
0.14986015856266022,
0.24170929193496704,
-0.9699370265007019,
-0.1840336173772812,
-0.11666031181812286,
-0.16041706502437592,
0.25328367948532104,
-0.46947380900382996,
-0.4016040563583374,
0.16079828143119812,
0.42537400126457214,
-0.019086305052042007,
0.4157543480396271,
0.08198369294404984,
-0.20489010214805603,
0.2149365395307541,
0.34891632199287415,
0.46965882182121277,
0.5347393155097961,
-0.2986508011817932,
0.47798800468444824,
-0.022102775052189827,
-0.5149494409561157,
-0.07045599073171616,
-0.10505999624729156,
-0.22331412136554718,
-0.0592404380440712,
0.5212767720222473,
0.7508236765861511,
0.04070587083697319,
-1.0022248029708862,
0.7024246454238892,
0.06293482333421707,
-0.3702560067176819,
-0.43580687046051025,
0.0593656525015831,
0.09718628227710724,
0.41338762640953064,
0.36690783500671387,
-0.10241736471652985,
0.000517752836458385,
-0.47173431515693665,
0.13306854665279388,
0.5466473698616028,
-0.22595691680908203,
-0.46606799960136414,
0.648077666759491,
-0.0030745845288038254,
0.023442815989255905,
0.4599888026714325,
0.09101766347885132,
-0.31487932801246643,
0.49758821725845337,
0.4355957508087158,
0.8311240673065186,
0.00983260665088892,
0.06494096666574478,
0.09300609678030014,
0.4752873182296753,
-0.04618784412741661,
0.12671132385730743,
-0.046465687453746796,
-0.4351154565811157,
-0.3792242109775543,
-0.4926750361919403,
-0.39941704273223877,
0.5555611848831177,
-0.45188578963279724,
0.09101651608943939,
-0.9554444551467896,
-0.12441472709178925,
-0.27249714732170105,
-0.1723335236310959,
-0.7562448978424072,
-0.3618239164352417,
0.37302273511886597,
1.0409823656082153,
-0.5563892126083374,
0.6773421764373779,
0.2351037859916687,
-0.5061970353126526,
-0.8831007480621338,
-0.1318332552909851,
0.0687796026468277,
-1.2722983360290527,
0.876617431640625,
0.07236801087856293,
-0.03855128213763237,
-0.2914009392261505,
-0.6844525933265686,
-0.8449901938438416,
1.0728548765182495,
0.6817384958267212,
-0.8707565665245056,
-0.15669885277748108,
0.46651625633239746,
0.33247730135917664,
-0.2231660932302475,
-0.07818111032247543,
0.41828829050064087,
0.28436657786369324,
-0.09063909202814102,
-0.6443846225738525,
0.24038974940776825,
0.0017219020519405603,
-0.1531674712896347,
0.05963721126317978,
-0.7038571238517761,
0.9146693348884583,
-0.10866888612508774,
-0.4044658839702606,
0.06282452493906021,
0.303476482629776,
0.19540466368198395,
0.29683566093444824,
0.43381717801094055,
0.3691413104534149,
0.9324498176574707,
0.09816568344831467,
1.2116950750350952,
-0.409591943025589,
0.11534144729375839,
0.8949263095855713,
-0.04142021760344505,
1.0512598752975464,
0.3640817105770111,
0.15073227882385254,
0.12419711798429489,
0.43227115273475647,
-0.1327635794878006,
0.513069212436676,
0.32004478573799133,
-0.39705783128738403,
0.03915053606033325,
-0.11447596549987793,
-0.24274924397468567,
0.16470825672149658,
0.39556360244750977,
-0.523686945438385,
0.05307575315237045,
-0.1922045648097992,
0.16839593648910522,
-0.08339396864175797,
-0.48754340410232544,
0.9375421404838562,
0.4744163751602173,
-0.27239319682121277,
0.517037034034729,
-0.2635937035083771,
0.660494327545166,
-0.6473757028579712,
0.24514652788639069,
-0.24322770535945892,
0.36396002769470215,
-0.2203366607427597,
-0.6537683606147766,
0.36831754446029663,
0.31199049949645996,
0.2438066601753235,
-0.33931106328964233,
0.8478164076805115,
-0.0297201219946146,
-0.29775118827819824,
0.49660733342170715,
0.4956059157848358,
0.2676100432872772,
-0.27967190742492676,
-0.48553091287612915,
0.36579272150993347,
-0.2844558656215668,
-0.19067738950252533,
0.401690274477005,
0.1886138617992401,
0.09802976995706558,
0.6305566430091858,
0.5946846008300781,
0.6599535346031189,
0.4520280063152313,
-0.1481245905160904,
0.8479917645454407,
-0.46078383922576904,
-0.24994775652885437,
-0.8963584899902344,
0.13578200340270996,
-0.10653223842382431,
-0.10785669088363647,
0.6117662787437439,
0.5842329263687134,
1.0127696990966797,
-0.11828017979860306,
1.1132696866989136,
0.5799375176429749,
0.3719799518585205,
-0.8460476994514465,
0.767717182636261,
-0.43761783838272095,
0.7114574313163757,
0.1472052037715912,
-0.7622573971748352,
-0.23930536210536957,
0.020719576627016068,
-0.33211269974708557,
-0.4438357949256897,
0.31501880288124084,
0.8236718773841858,
-0.18187101185321808,
-0.10624460875988007,
0.2962922751903534,
0.34853535890579224,
0.5599458813667297,
0.6333240866661072,
0.8869158625602722,
-0.04306377097964287,
0.8650731444358826,
-0.030290670692920685,
-0.4378887116909027,
-0.07930541783571243,
-0.8560003638267517,
-0.830367922782898,
-0.26210877299308777,
-0.13669055700302124,
-0.19975566864013672,
0.016572849825024605,
0.6276389956474304,
0.9313709139823914,
-0.6655492782592773,
-0.29364141821861267,
-0.0584758035838604,
0.18682990968227386,
-0.028442643582820892,
-0.13175863027572632,
0.3142682909965515,
-0.24336808919906616,
-0.5544759631156921,
0.37848594784736633,
0.14681489765644073,
0.12781061232089996,
-0.5921016335487366,
-0.041681721806526184,
0.3624843657016754,
0.4235045313835144,
0.2570893466472626,
0.5932555794715881,
-0.6855147480964661,
-0.14485742151737213,
-0.019717330113053322,
0.09186647087335587,
0.12485519796609879,
1.072453498840332,
-0.340197890996933,
0.12305346131324768,
0.31790676712989807,
1.0987731218338013,
0.6055393815040588,
-0.3357194662094116,
0.5882630944252014,
-1.0050565004348755,
0.438289999961853,
0.08189220726490021,
0.39704182744026184,
0.24210357666015625,
-0.5870844721794128,
0.23290252685546875,
0.11698881536722183,
-0.5160415768623352,
-0.9810936450958252,
0.529228687286377,
-0.6291090250015259,
-0.5129371881484985,
0.936463475227356,
-0.4225316345691681,
-0.5764786005020142,
-0.029743529856204987,
0.003823254955932498,
-0.08801195025444031,
-0.43904685974121094,
0.541824221611023,
0.5037078261375427,
-0.13103631138801575,
-0.18870826065540314,
-0.8998278379440308,
0.5070660710334778,
0.004657356068491936,
-0.6081660389900208,
0.3052486181259155,
0.21211446821689606,
0.41021689772605896,
0.23061789572238922,
0.48003363609313965,
-0.5273354053497314,
-0.12127136439085007,
0.04339897632598877,
-0.18352757394313812,
-0.4194619357585907,
-0.35802146792411804,
-0.4406198263168335,
0.285207062959671,
0.5798890590667725,
-0.29769405722618103
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09530v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09530v2
|
VisionGPT-3D: A Generalized Multimodal Agent for Enhanced 3D Vision Understanding
| 2024-03-14T16:13:00 | 2024-03-22T15:26:05 |
Chris Kelly, Luhui Hu, Jiayin Hu, Yu Tian, Deshun Yang, Bang Yang, Cindy Yang, Zihao Li, Zaoshan Huang, Yuexian Zou
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.GR
|
The evolution of text to visual components facilitates people's daily lives,
such as generating image, videos from text and identifying the desired elements
within the images. Computer vision models involving the multimodal abilities in
the previous days are focused on image detection, classification based on
well-defined objects. Large language models (LLMs) introduces the
transformation from nature language to visual objects, which present the visual
layout for text contexts. OpenAI GPT-4 has emerged as the pinnacle in LLMs,
while the computer vision (CV) domain boasts a plethora of state-of-the-art
(SOTA) models and algorithms to convert 2D images to their 3D representations.
However, the mismatching between the algorithms with the problem could lead to
undesired results. In response to this challenge, we propose an unified
VisionGPT-3D framework to consolidate the state-of-the-art vision models,
thereby facilitating the development of vision-oriented AI. VisionGPT-3D
provides a versatile multimodal framework building upon the strengths of
multimodal foundation models. It seamlessly integrates various SOTA vision
models and brings the automation in the selection of SOTA vision models,
identifies the suitable 3D mesh creation algorithms corresponding to 2D depth
maps analysis, generates optimal results based on diverse multimodal inputs
such as text prompts.
Keywords: VisionGPT-3D, 3D vision understanding, Multimodal agent
|
[
-0.577924907207489,
-0.8115018606185913,
0.92254638671875,
0.2034241408109665,
-0.30247223377227783,
-0.14742198586463928,
0.2325904369354248,
-0.5944339632987976,
-0.11637087166309357,
0.4885910451412201,
-0.31117093563079834,
-0.45182955265045166,
-0.6302735209465027,
0.04994552582502365,
-0.15338073670864105,
0.7115333676338196,
-0.20877628028392792,
0.01656879484653473,
-0.14699411392211914,
-0.19453415274620056,
-0.302584171295166,
-0.41180941462516785,
-0.7565405964851379,
-0.2593344748020172,
0.4018455147743225,
0.14716795086860657,
0.7758544087409973,
0.4447365701198578,
0.644443929195404,
0.4325738847255707,
0.25743433833122253,
0.10670027881860733,
-0.11449692398309708,
-0.30602744221687317,
-0.16285115480422974,
-0.15694989264011383,
-0.8516606688499451,
-0.13813844323158264,
0.5823186635971069,
0.39845946431159973,
0.04632861167192459,
-0.2583509087562561,
0.10130869597196579,
0.5683469176292419,
-0.5556811690330505,
0.4791525900363922,
-0.11038928478956223,
0.1303853690624237,
0.0970267578959465,
-0.3255195617675781,
0.002604849636554718,
-0.1840641051530838,
0.3691094219684601,
-0.7546404600143433,
0.341239333152771,
-0.2364214062690735,
0.5645943284034729,
0.24481889605522156,
-0.5727980732917786,
-0.07947240769863129,
-0.458917498588562,
0.4581368565559387,
-0.24692849814891815,
0.43242397904396057,
-0.20841243863105774,
0.7577128410339355,
-0.09609426558017731,
-0.8088568449020386,
-0.9739946722984314,
-0.13033181428909302,
-0.01748138852417469,
0.46817272901535034,
0.08064018934965134,
0.41812485456466675,
-0.17664499580860138,
0.3793233335018158,
-0.8983381986618042,
-0.17985886335372925,
-0.34405866265296936,
-0.24045488238334656,
0.3259837031364441,
0.045595377683639526,
0.7373682856559753,
-0.06028822436928749,
-0.8348900675773621,
-0.3439260721206665,
-0.2694506347179413,
-0.2036326378583908,
-0.05527281016111374,
0.12512505054473877,
-0.24262383580207825,
0.5905836820602417,
-0.23566441237926483,
0.8960279226303101,
-0.4085595905780792,
-0.29180625081062317,
0.3762436509132385,
-0.43567267060279846,
-0.5491982102394104,
-0.22958646714687347,
0.8858039379119873,
0.6484561562538147,
0.30689653754234314,
0.029199469834566116,
-0.23626652359962463,
0.22595596313476562,
0.0563967190682888,
-0.6329461336135864,
-0.20564737915992737,
0.12557297945022583,
-0.3565728962421417,
-0.22323480248451233,
0.14289285242557526,
-1.1232801675796509,
-0.6407762765884399,
-0.24137140810489655,
0.7237223386764526,
-0.3567231297492981,
-0.6342133283615112,
0.4918118715286255,
-0.28775060176849365,
0.3192628026008606,
0.6852893829345703,
-0.8077448010444641,
-0.14047102630138397,
0.23419515788555145,
0.8568137288093567,
-0.22288274765014648,
-0.569645345211029,
-0.2114010602235794,
0.5231427550315857,
-0.08397546410560608,
1.0374923944473267,
-0.478298544883728,
-0.36475878953933716,
-0.10055845230817795,
-0.1533598005771637,
-0.3412055969238281,
-0.16088330745697021,
0.1600467562675476,
-0.3536977171897888,
0.5156357884407043,
0.12075182795524597,
0.12502293288707733,
-0.7068477272987366,
0.8179578185081482,
-0.884843111038208,
0.4850895404815674,
0.19161812961101532,
-0.6397367715835571,
0.26966601610183716,
-1.0948506593704224,
0.02408035472035408,
0.35000649094581604,
-0.6131914854049683,
-0.1879572719335556,
-0.16800883412361145,
0.5860255360603333,
0.5943492650985718,
-0.389508992433548,
0.1330670565366745,
-0.18392565846443176,
-0.2138238102197647,
-0.23714618384838104,
-0.5568867921829224,
0.4741467535495758,
0.05017408728599548,
-0.2687157988548279,
0.4008607566356659,
-0.5674844980239868,
-0.02412984147667885,
0.27909597754478455,
-0.3883192241191864,
0.007443449925631285,
-0.24624162912368774,
0.3390079736709595,
0.1796470582485199,
0.341030478477478,
-0.39425402879714966,
0.3222160041332245,
-0.19053758680820465,
0.3906390070915222,
0.6394411325454712,
-0.05372113734483719,
0.43303540349006653,
-0.05883987247943878,
0.5055996775627136,
0.0381806343793869,
0.37239208817481995,
-0.4140703082084656,
-0.8001366853713989,
-0.49744856357574463,
-0.5378757119178772,
-0.2781822979450226,
0.6850795745849609,
-1.3605276346206665,
-0.16366255283355713,
-0.5421433448791504,
-0.16294606029987335,
-0.09178510308265686,
-0.04733289033174515,
0.35394367575645447,
0.24669845402240753,
0.3857724070549011,
-0.2811902165412903,
-0.3585842549800873,
-0.8711342811584473,
-0.1469234973192215,
-0.16862426698207855,
-0.12640860676765442,
0.03213623911142349,
0.5261874198913574,
-0.6685692667961121,
0.9485877752304077,
-0.3127509355545044,
-0.6726654171943665,
-0.676473081111908,
0.019391115754842758,
0.0561039038002491,
0.46439167857170105,
0.7446972131729126,
-1.3937633037567139,
-0.39523088932037354,
0.5127632021903992,
-1.0265437364578247,
0.24316279590129852,
-0.05723585933446884,
0.07627824693918228,
0.06929352134466171,
0.4651181697845459,
-0.5040504336357117,
0.4867049753665924,
0.7942811846733093,
-0.4118736982345581,
0.37744778394699097,
-0.31933915615081787,
0.4025152027606964,
-1.155158519744873,
-0.10272406041622162,
0.19340771436691284,
-0.1901576668024063,
-0.6983861923217773,
0.32728254795074463,
0.011160135269165039,
-0.0880156084895134,
-0.551053524017334,
0.5705451369285583,
-0.4195142388343811,
-0.1985028088092804,
-0.12513533234596252,
0.40164855122566223,
0.09036864340305328,
0.7682816386222839,
0.17716722190380096,
0.7159108519554138,
0.6912420988082886,
-0.6861670613288879,
0.801842987537384,
0.15709204971790314,
-0.1269710659980774,
0.7423867583274841,
-0.4941513240337372,
0.10996648669242859,
-0.21542613208293915,
0.19799770414829254,
-0.9074376821517944,
-0.5769472718238831,
0.5319162607192993,
-0.33330264687538147,
0.045928120613098145,
-0.1140938326716423,
-0.5140800476074219,
-0.25055453181266785,
-0.23865124583244324,
0.6189693808555603,
-0.03249479830265045,
-0.7546356916427612,
1.3249691724777222,
0.19961731135845184,
-0.08008168637752533,
-0.44473186135292053,
-0.5847447514533997,
0.22249531745910645,
-0.013418380171060562,
-0.9214063286781311,
0.3069007694721222,
-0.1125047579407692,
-0.05256543681025505,
0.0831669345498085,
0.01399810891598463,
-0.3084011673927307,
-0.3211456537246704,
-0.0005708073731511831,
0.29255515336990356,
-0.23669295012950897,
-0.10203197598457336,
-0.2425488829612732,
-0.32685917615890503,
-0.17669810354709625,
-0.30891188979148865,
0.3989022970199585,
-0.504592776298523,
-0.5261606574058533,
-0.4566604197025299,
0.37689703702926636,
0.940056562423706,
-0.2971341907978058,
0.2732560634613037,
0.8895962238311768,
-0.1931348443031311,
0.22163079679012299,
-0.503868043422699,
0.17437119781970978,
-0.48979413509368896,
0.799583375453949,
-0.7440406084060669,
-0.8384690880775452,
0.2302241325378418,
-0.11398638784885406,
-0.12228067964315414,
0.340487539768219,
0.5360592007637024,
0.10075831413269043,
1.2171639204025269,
1.0610560178756714,
0.08336535096168518,
0.48229241371154785,
-0.22767961025238037,
0.20201937854290009,
-0.7712443470954895,
-0.5620077848434448,
0.04650475084781647,
-0.062051285058259964,
-0.3879050314426422,
-0.4372797906398773,
0.67418372631073,
-0.20146821439266205,
-0.09299752861261368,
0.02478588931262493,
-0.5875640511512756,
0.6298108100891113,
0.3508094549179077,
0.08469726145267487,
0.3618336021900177,
0.14771242439746857,
-0.21517454087734222,
0.5331035256385803,
-0.521756112575531,
-0.40631118416786194,
0.8176618814468384,
0.3095338046550751,
0.5353524684906006,
0.43416956067085266,
0.2352384775876999,
0.12798210978507996,
0.10559483617544174,
-0.5987316966056824,
0.7459877133369446,
-0.06090984866023064,
-0.3972841799259186,
-0.2360086292028427,
-0.3650282621383667,
-0.7105726003646851,
0.8228901624679565,
-0.1339966505765915,
-0.7375725507736206,
0.18136563897132874,
0.19025461375713348,
-0.4261423945426941,
0.6053259968757629,
-0.9641650319099426,
1.2179133892059326,
-0.26697826385498047,
-0.24339936673641205,
-0.03906477615237236,
-0.5288594961166382,
0.5116472840309143,
0.0004238718538545072,
0.08625136315822601,
0.06902868300676346,
-0.045499175786972046,
0.2997465431690216,
-0.030376669019460678,
0.7685158848762512,
-0.22351911664009094,
-0.2574763000011444,
0.1979255974292755,
0.05458962917327881,
0.20519883930683136,
0.13068053126335144,
0.3913947641849518,
0.22538071870803833,
0.06826628744602203,
-0.30911844968795776,
-0.74057537317276,
0.40468522906303406,
-0.7323612570762634,
-0.5522215366363525,
-0.381071001291275,
-0.49977442622184753,
-0.03960738703608513,
0.4239591062068939,
0.23671644926071167,
0.5450525283813477,
-0.2669784724712372,
0.04077788442373276,
0.5381209254264832,
-0.3821071684360504,
0.37970486283302307,
0.32990384101867676,
-0.5135584473609924,
-0.45621103048324585,
1.0171408653259277,
-0.48132404685020447,
0.1537647545337677,
0.6512390971183777,
0.059203531593084335,
-0.38537299633026123,
-0.6019328832626343,
-0.6948490738868713,
-0.07410991936922073,
-0.876215934753418,
-0.09180119633674622,
-0.5903263092041016,
-0.23541571199893951,
-0.5611344575881958,
-0.28669312596321106,
-0.1162574291229248,
0.02361125499010086,
-0.0958438366651535,
-0.05812210217118263,
0.11334675550460815,
0.895969808101654,
-0.10316532850265503,
0.4647766351699829,
-0.8991227746009827,
0.8379732370376587,
0.8456907272338867,
0.4100325405597687,
-0.34326067566871643,
-0.05796325206756592,
0.08715930581092834,
0.04540397599339485,
-0.1720053255558014,
-0.7228626608848572,
0.33915162086486816,
0.18382662534713745,
0.6355989575386047,
0.48024600744247437,
-0.5466276407241821,
0.6028069853782654,
-0.16740074753761292,
0.8542594313621521,
0.5305654406547546,
-0.714806079864502,
0.3755015730857849,
-0.5419604182243347,
0.4568822383880615,
0.11623156815767288,
-0.09441051632165909,
-0.5425571799278259,
-0.08120176196098328,
-0.1469496786594391,
-0.700175404548645,
0.7567545771598816,
0.2822854816913605,
-0.1574489027261734,
0.31676384806632996,
0.1618945598602295,
-0.048078183084726334,
0.025291044265031815,
-0.9186708331108093,
0.2293798327445984,
-0.8235172629356384,
-0.44985589385032654,
-0.12735167145729065,
-0.2732394337654114,
0.02553465962409973,
0.0030287737026810646,
0.216932475566864,
-0.46995875239372253,
0.4906083047389984,
0.37165674567222595,
-0.2630666196346283,
0.35198840498924255,
0.20645539462566376,
0.7462906837463379,
0.6064584851264954,
-0.17318004369735718,
0.24028067290782928,
0.036433570086956024,
-0.9249688386917114,
-0.02608620934188366,
0.11296577006578445,
0.17274165153503418,
-0.4024122953414917,
0.4501584470272064,
0.6729515194892883,
-0.047332026064395905,
-0.5252254009246826,
0.7607928514480591,
-0.17149408161640167,
-0.5513396859169006,
-0.2762584984302521,
0.11928808689117432,
-0.3193855881690979,
0.5826317667961121,
0.3591058850288391,
0.33364608883857727,
0.20216374099254608,
-0.47277286648750305,
0.08645354211330414,
0.27087318897247314,
-0.3915913999080658,
-0.4485566318035126,
0.6914247274398804,
0.4350673258304596,
0.1431853026151657,
0.5806508660316467,
-0.07249018549919128,
-0.7911587357521057,
0.6443764567375183,
0.34275272488594055,
0.9646480679512024,
-0.23601725697517395,
0.3320784270763397,
0.14543698728084564,
0.40112894773483276,
-0.17766457796096802,
0.37420985102653503,
-0.07191530615091324,
-1.1578632593154907,
-0.33016282320022583,
-0.4478989243507385,
-0.14590144157409668,
0.22377769649028778,
-0.15989266335964203,
-0.017189133912324905,
-0.35667091608047485,
0.16036738455295563,
-0.25721925497055054,
-0.43444547057151794,
-0.7862155437469482,
0.4475157558917999,
0.17496126890182495,
0.5493876934051514,
-0.5659909844398499,
0.8541650176048279,
1.0255287885665894,
-0.6799141764640808,
-0.36442914605140686,
-0.03632267192006111,
0.2682051956653595,
-1.0291680097579956,
0.5302949547767639,
0.38177525997161865,
-0.5696468949317932,
0.29332926869392395,
-0.49130210280418396,
-0.530134379863739,
1.1601842641830444,
0.34899768233299255,
-0.18822766840457916,
-0.1580473631620407,
0.3856845498085022,
0.31439995765686035,
-0.38087648153305054,
0.2503955364227295,
0.39353856444358826,
0.7050652503967285,
0.4354233145713806,
-0.8871593475341797,
-0.138904869556427,
-0.3662528097629547,
0.21755532920360565,
0.11287815868854523,
-0.42453840374946594,
0.9518911242485046,
-0.25283968448638916,
-0.3727204501628876,
0.11588513851165771,
0.36941102147102356,
0.1018199771642685,
0.2549282908439636,
0.6410042643547058,
0.5120031237602234,
0.09381909668445587,
-0.08518407493829727,
1.0182991027832031,
0.12834790349006653,
0.13309834897518158,
0.7291275858879089,
-0.07054862380027771,
0.3097366392612457,
0.30340883135795593,
0.204128235578537,
0.19390138983726501,
0.4784807860851288,
-0.1442568004131317,
0.5963714122772217,
-0.406631737947464,
-0.33577150106430054,
-0.26737743616104126,
0.3474205732345581,
-0.4001465439796448,
0.6548309922218323,
0.38578981161117554,
-0.0735192820429802,
-0.4614078104496002,
0.31311631202697754,
-0.37788036465644836,
-0.1678445190191269,
-0.4744955897331238,
0.8264234662055969,
-0.174761101603508,
-0.3358203172683716,
0.20552067458629608,
-0.05517439544200897,
0.5950927734375,
-0.6187170743942261,
-0.2431669533252716,
-0.164236918091774,
0.3806818127632141,
-0.1309969425201416,
-0.9567265510559082,
0.11869028955698013,
-0.2203107327222824,
-0.0179081279784441,
-0.25911688804626465,
0.5661554932594299,
-0.34038588404655457,
-0.29663676023483276,
0.3665889501571655,
0.5739362835884094,
0.24315261840820312,
-0.6019684076309204,
-0.6804936528205872,
0.10280787944793701,
0.14564941823482513,
-0.1344739943742752,
0.18245981633663177,
0.6946573853492737,
-0.010645936243236065,
0.6673876643180847,
0.565485954284668,
-0.30455097556114197,
-0.12566129863262177,
0.09610778093338013,
0.7998259663581848,
-0.6246058344841003,
-0.5562713146209717,
-0.8546860814094543,
0.5944930911064148,
-0.05457714572548866,
-0.1246519461274147,
0.5149296522140503,
0.3404604494571686,
0.9007562398910522,
-0.13327758014202118,
0.9523130059242249,
-0.015302115119993687,
-0.01041620783507824,
-0.7269858121871948,
0.6942471861839294,
-0.9153880476951599,
-0.02159818634390831,
-0.41830360889434814,
-1.2201517820358276,
-0.7056910991668701,
0.7273918986320496,
0.025742610916495323,
0.24293076992034912,
0.7751050591468811,
0.6945946216583252,
-0.289218544960022,
-0.05091773718595505,
0.6757015585899353,
-0.07902083545923233,
0.6354452967643738,
0.738285481929779,
0.7853867411613464,
-0.28294411301612854,
0.9026201963424683,
0.23950029909610748,
-0.4539906978607178,
-0.21158765256404877,
-0.6484516859054565,
-0.8687598705291748,
-0.7971662282943726,
-0.05712524801492691,
0.23575641214847565,
-0.052146974951028824,
0.46353328227996826,
0.5648512244224548,
-0.3476591110229492,
0.07120803743600845,
-0.27494049072265625,
-0.04855681210756302,
-0.24051468074321747,
-0.1868663877248764,
0.4662359654903412,
-0.028047731146216393,
-0.8207245469093323,
0.38343504071235657,
0.6451711654663086,
0.4640456438064575,
-0.3198704123497009,
-0.13741157948970795,
0.06901049613952637,
-0.09858507663011551,
0.9266152381896973,
0.2629930377006531,
-0.6384079456329346,
-0.3273410499095917,
-0.3046248257160187,
-0.1411067694425583,
0.14947545528411865,
0.6015445590019226,
-0.7756997346878052,
0.9024472832679749,
0.5038890838623047,
0.3763851225376129,
0.3641665279865265,
-0.2327350527048111,
0.7036384344100952,
-0.4073478877544403,
0.43389609456062317,
0.00015186799282673746,
0.4865504205226898,
0.38347986340522766,
-0.22138947248458862,
0.5886984467506409,
0.3005223274230957,
-0.18868526816368103,
-0.37450429797172546,
0.502666175365448,
-1.1930214166641235,
-0.2705073654651642,
0.9980015158653259,
0.003921451512724161,
-0.3252929747104645,
-0.19244484603405,
-0.5167460441589355,
0.07799482345581055,
-0.21256503462791443,
0.56611168384552,
0.3505697250366211,
-0.05541549250483513,
-0.6809291243553162,
-0.6834800243377686,
0.3875398337841034,
-0.17036360502243042,
-0.9154676198959351,
-0.30446457862854004,
0.49408596754074097,
-0.03366157039999962,
0.3492599427700043,
0.8176363706588745,
-0.24823084473609924,
0.3263408839702606,
0.017624972388148308,
0.415962278842926,
-0.2497720867395401,
-0.5945069193840027,
-0.14015546441078186,
0.4525529444217682,
-0.3875897526741028,
-0.5079967975616455
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09522v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09522v2
|
MT-PATCHER: Selective and Extendable Knowledge Distillation from Large Language Models for Machine Translation
| 2024-03-14T16:07:39 | 2024-04-01T07:11:32 |
Jiahuan Li, Shanbo Cheng, Shujian Huang, Jiajun Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLM) have demonstrated their strong ability in the
field of machine translation (MT), yet they suffer from high computational cost
and latency. Therefore, transferring translation knowledge from giant LLMs to
medium-sized machine translation models is a promising research direction.
However, traditional knowledge distillation methods do not take the capability
of student and teacher models into consideration, therefore repeatedly teaching
student models on the knowledge they have learned, and failing to extend to
novel contexts and knowledge. In this paper, we propose a framework called
MT-Patcher, which transfers knowledge from LLMs to existing MT models in a
selective, comprehensive and proactive manner. Considering the current
translation ability of student MT models, we only identify and correct their
translation errors, instead of distilling the whole translation from the
teacher. Leveraging the strong language abilities of LLMs, we instruct LLM
teachers to synthesize diverse contexts and anticipate more potential errors
for the student. Experiment results on translating both specific language
phenomena and general MT benchmarks demonstrate that finetuning the student MT
model on about 10% examples can achieve comparable results to the traditional
knowledge distillation method, and synthesized potential errors and diverse
contexts further improve translation performances on unseen contexts and words.
|
[
-0.3064441680908203,
-0.8629132509231567,
0.7763851881027222,
0.13767465949058533,
-0.35931921005249023,
0.39758020639419556,
-0.2893773019313812,
-0.09237590432167053,
0.06292059272527695,
0.7548407912254333,
-0.4400358200073242,
-0.1743580847978592,
-0.9080728888511658,
0.14460891485214233,
-0.579554557800293,
1.031468391418457,
-0.4468246102333069,
0.04424675181508064,
-0.13918523490428925,
-0.032174546271562576,
-0.6047755479812622,
-0.44396987557411194,
-0.30118528008461,
-0.4868401885032654,
0.3357694447040558,
0.3062831163406372,
0.16972987353801727,
0.5390860438346863,
0.5018851161003113,
0.3476308286190033,
-0.16622120141983032,
0.41838735342025757,
-0.5163311958312988,
0.16202202439308167,
-0.40788698196411133,
-0.6443235278129578,
-0.46133896708488464,
0.06806082278490067,
0.7866721153259277,
0.6092091798782349,
-0.03806279972195625,
0.21050800383090973,
0.3269517421722412,
0.7654930353164673,
-0.3346116840839386,
-0.11394002288579941,
-1.0726231336593628,
-0.10184279829263687,
-0.278071790933609,
-0.036033034324645996,
-0.5550873279571533,
-0.2577859163284302,
-0.030003592371940613,
-0.5738979578018188,
0.19903020560741425,
-0.19841773808002472,
0.49607330560684204,
0.38341590762138367,
-0.6770424246788025,
-0.09525395184755325,
-0.8422417044639587,
0.9501339197158813,
-0.7811594605445862,
0.022987382486462593,
0.32382068037986755,
0.8169317245483398,
-0.311870276927948,
-0.819703221321106,
-0.704890787601471,
0.0482235848903656,
-0.060270171612501144,
0.007136054802685976,
-0.15597377717494965,
-0.17154823243618011,
0.15604987740516663,
0.47550395131111145,
-0.15364831686019897,
-0.14181925356388092,
-0.5336002111434937,
0.03277354687452316,
0.2808469831943512,
0.03501372039318085,
0.24559684097766876,
0.057379599660634995,
-0.5039157867431641,
-0.09127966314554214,
-0.5457746982574463,
-0.22977207601070404,
0.055275265127420425,
0.128954216837883,
0.11901800334453583,
0.4861154556274414,
-0.059468723833560944,
0.8005510568618774,
0.022647125646471977,
-0.42239609360694885,
0.16325131058692932,
-0.17277193069458008,
-0.15094172954559326,
-0.204667329788208,
0.639439582824707,
0.30593279004096985,
-0.0013518057530745864,
-0.23697634041309357,
-0.4112791121006012,
-0.16135835647583008,
0.17456793785095215,
-0.7921069860458374,
-0.25952500104904175,
0.021561339497566223,
-0.028473390266299248,
-0.4435085952281952,
-0.1443556398153305,
-0.7420753240585327,
-0.3478269875049591,
-0.4392573833465576,
0.5368842482566833,
-0.4502944350242615,
-0.34663647413253784,
-0.15591388940811157,
-0.3019641637802124,
-0.4195358157157898,
0.23401722311973572,
-0.642509937286377,
0.02774915099143982,
0.3976629376411438,
0.7302208542823792,
-0.27928832173347473,
-0.5115686655044556,
-0.46585211157798767,
0.4603516459465027,
-0.21498551964759827,
0.6406468152999878,
-0.5183411836624146,
-0.20523379743099213,
-0.22026929259300232,
0.20024403929710388,
-0.2911320626735687,
-0.697758138179779,
0.25743257999420166,
-0.4454476535320282,
0.15723735094070435,
-0.27889755368232727,
-0.387381911277771,
-0.3205605149269104,
0.4552735388278961,
-0.6280452609062195,
0.827319324016571,
0.45823583006858826,
-0.5349981784820557,
0.30653268098831177,
-0.6198055148124695,
-0.4506392776966095,
-0.08238829672336578,
0.25684741139411926,
-0.3430781364440918,
0.25475361943244934,
0.5024287104606628,
0.414077490568161,
-0.3560466766357422,
0.7089236974716187,
-0.2247963696718216,
-0.14821067452430725,
0.5853255391120911,
-0.5779973864555359,
0.4567791819572449,
0.32571691274642944,
-0.1759166270494461,
0.10219456255435944,
-0.7693153619766235,
-0.29436051845550537,
-0.07241415232419968,
-0.5630614757537842,
-0.5263645648956299,
-0.2464233934879303,
-0.005217419937252998,
0.3425663113594055,
0.04369090870022774,
-0.2742650806903839,
0.5050426721572876,
-0.12748540937900543,
0.7252174615859985,
0.8823363780975342,
0.024439310654997826,
0.6952091455459595,
-0.3096975088119507,
0.5286914706230164,
0.24627798795700073,
0.015255838632583618,
-0.2092607319355011,
-0.3010016083717346,
-0.7568320035934448,
-0.6356141567230225,
0.5129101276397705,
0.4520011246204376,
-1.2899526357650757,
0.24967555701732635,
-0.3390340805053711,
-0.42568328976631165,
-0.7337741255760193,
0.5091267228126526,
0.2657279074192047,
0.6324739456176758,
0.5080267786979675,
0.00820962991565466,
-0.6584270596504211,
-0.6387279033660889,
-0.45817244052886963,
0.11486009508371353,
-0.1287662237882614,
-0.10808613896369934,
0.3933587670326233,
-0.3370632827281952,
0.8381938338279724,
-0.4541747570037842,
-0.5852100253105164,
-0.5458447933197021,
-0.10428349673748016,
0.34171727299690247,
0.5817294716835022,
0.5796073079109192,
-0.660677969455719,
-0.6738380193710327,
0.18242351710796356,
-0.5746285319328308,
-0.18610656261444092,
-0.13378877937793732,
-0.34513384103775024,
-0.14151199162006378,
0.48579904437065125,
-0.28157752752304077,
-0.02238314412534237,
0.905062735080719,
-0.258293479681015,
0.23717540502548218,
-0.2570713460445404,
0.22876180708408356,
-1.5894989967346191,
0.1195608377456665,
-0.1948883831501007,
-0.49446940422058105,
-0.7476216554641724,
0.2370145469903946,
0.11418403685092926,
0.2813730239868164,
-0.4506699740886688,
0.7013631463050842,
-0.45662859082221985,
0.41583067178726196,
-0.5152543187141418,
0.2369328886270523,
0.1491698920726776,
0.2180231511592865,
-0.1594524085521698,
0.6226826906204224,
0.3003125786781311,
-0.5273167490959167,
0.4156297743320465,
0.016635069623589516,
-0.41396135091781616,
0.6376416683197021,
-0.36295086145401,
0.11208054423332214,
0.15384365618228912,
0.220172718167305,
-0.9009507894515991,
-0.23167194426059723,
0.11591928452253342,
-0.22185400128364563,
0.39552992582321167,
-0.6202482581138611,
-0.5416743755340576,
-0.46028921008110046,
0.22758448123931885,
0.40736186504364014,
0.7009499073028564,
-0.6081693172454834,
0.7229575514793396,
0.40353259444236755,
-0.1828102171421051,
-0.43341344594955444,
-0.7939264178276062,
0.10578101128339767,
-0.4132619798183441,
-0.34997087717056274,
0.13806137442588806,
-0.061221156269311905,
-0.12170444428920746,
0.007685248274356127,
-0.12702670693397522,
-0.4466992914676666,
0.13753558695316315,
-0.05208473652601242,
0.3116951286792755,
-0.07249897718429565,
-0.07409471273422241,
0.4394148290157318,
-0.1315714567899704,
-0.1660047322511673,
-0.5587419271469116,
0.4319136440753937,
0.24766913056373596,
-0.3576625883579254,
0.09085845947265625,
0.07936994731426239,
0.8172657489776611,
-0.2595202922821045,
0.8925506472587585,
0.6500722169876099,
-0.23253388702869415,
-0.2273208200931549,
-0.8489118814468384,
-0.3114256262779236,
-0.4342869818210602,
0.49409279227256775,
-0.5332363843917847,
-0.8769314289093018,
0.4646982252597809,
-0.5017375946044922,
0.09108636528253555,
0.3300067186355591,
0.3924791216850281,
0.058521464467048645,
0.9030807018280029,
0.7039356231689453,
-0.21295151114463806,
0.5429064035415649,
-0.19355210661888123,
-0.051042597740888596,
-0.990347146987915,
0.007277950178831816,
-0.24873778223991394,
-0.6003037095069885,
-0.179100900888443,
-0.7983964681625366,
0.27355989813804626,
0.39926353096961975,
0.20535728335380554,
0.4506675899028778,
-0.423077255487442,
0.597647488117218,
0.47372519969940186,
0.06004395708441734,
0.49760204553604126,
0.31733188033103943,
-0.4461098611354828,
-0.017738500609993935,
-0.6539727449417114,
-0.5194771885871887,
1.154343843460083,
0.3030640184879303,
0.35252419114112854,
0.15897905826568604,
0.645771324634552,
-0.07721754163503647,
0.7643688917160034,
-0.47513335943222046,
0.3405369818210602,
-0.2032936066389084,
-0.7635648846626282,
-0.2381674200296402,
-0.7435430288314819,
-0.6205467581748962,
0.5598189830780029,
-0.23037537932395935,
-0.4292944073677063,
-0.08053870499134064,
0.22456784546375275,
0.12958066165447235,
0.7353665232658386,
-0.5722890496253967,
0.8634486198425293,
-0.009016317315399647,
-0.11836080998182297,
-0.04532026872038841,
-0.3822244703769684,
0.577355146408081,
-0.6347474455833435,
0.6509578227996826,
-0.028305962681770325,
0.21380338072776794,
0.524436354637146,
-0.33603063225746155,
0.8247590065002441,
-0.30090123414993286,
-0.13507038354873657,
0.29297924041748047,
0.35809126496315,
0.745398998260498,
-0.22052925825119019,
-0.05864865705370903,
0.0009365021251142025,
0.04576509818434715,
-0.4679471552371979,
-0.6071985960006714,
0.5776459574699402,
-0.5700931549072266,
-0.6585996150970459,
0.06078602001070976,
-0.8014160990715027,
-0.1591903567314148,
0.4721992015838623,
0.10259886831045151,
0.028841907158493996,
-0.041373640298843384,
0.13601195812225342,
0.6057741045951843,
0.09086920320987701,
0.24456076323986053,
0.8182255625724792,
-0.5471673011779785,
-0.6492393612861633,
1.1034283638000488,
0.1544988751411438,
0.49851977825164795,
0.4235541820526123,
0.2592719495296478,
-0.07692532241344452,
-0.764477550983429,
-0.6889371871948242,
0.18086546659469604,
-0.6583698391914368,
-0.2547098398208618,
-0.6137935519218445,
-0.066757932305336,
-0.19414430856704712,
-0.12345517426729202,
-0.5165565609931946,
-0.530301034450531,
-0.040627770125865936,
-0.10057580471038818,
0.32612332701683044,
0.5887928009033203,
0.020215321332216263,
0.5681466460227966,
-1.1002479791641235,
0.31293919682502747,
0.34284618496894836,
0.15726172924041748,
-0.21963545680046082,
-0.9573931694030762,
-0.28034183382987976,
0.2679736018180847,
-0.48842400312423706,
-0.8408847451210022,
0.5822792649269104,
-0.057942844927310944,
0.6544079780578613,
0.24643413722515106,
0.2526841461658478,
0.8531030416488647,
-0.6733280420303345,
0.5808890461921692,
0.36093100905418396,
-0.9875242710113525,
0.5586114525794983,
-0.22511139512062073,
0.277551531791687,
0.6177574992179871,
0.0461898148059845,
-0.46735885739326477,
-0.8225598335266113,
-0.2930248975753784,
-0.9161613583564758,
0.6076911687850952,
0.14673776924610138,
0.12069613486528397,
0.11731679737567902,
0.29374516010284424,
0.25665226578712463,
0.1834605634212494,
-0.7918404936790466,
-0.08351893723011017,
-0.019335150718688965,
-0.32904642820358276,
-0.36139336228370667,
-0.12312004715204239,
-0.29822230339050293,
-0.21568089723587036,
0.7016662359237671,
-0.12383205443620682,
-0.29864901304244995,
-0.0150971794500947,
-0.4618116319179535,
-0.13348692655563354,
0.4288681745529175,
0.5016028881072998,
0.7987402081489563,
0.018036412075161934,
0.5044195055961609,
0.5707864165306091,
-0.5226679444313049,
0.31616950035095215,
0.08249880373477936,
-0.21355962753295898,
-0.003002282464876771,
0.14360545575618744,
0.613940954208374,
-0.013076202012598515,
-0.47951364517211914,
0.4047304689884186,
0.1490505039691925,
-0.2910829782485962,
0.01571432128548622,
-0.07129333168268204,
0.17995402216911316,
0.44913938641548157,
0.3708522617816925,
0.41623321175575256,
0.00832144170999527,
-0.3297305405139923,
0.07220364362001419,
0.055229552090168,
-0.5446150898933411,
-0.31470683217048645,
0.570323646068573,
0.21967363357543945,
0.03155840188264847,
0.453584223985672,
-0.01965256966650486,
-0.6529268026351929,
0.28743356466293335,
0.7440212368965149,
0.6637058258056641,
-0.5759067535400391,
0.018886040896177292,
0.29632315039634705,
0.4216097593307495,
-0.39713457226753235,
-0.1375734806060791,
0.05176768824458122,
-0.47164270281791687,
-0.6802272200584412,
-0.6122669577598572,
-0.12963715195655823,
0.07660644501447678,
-0.5618517398834229,
0.17572209239006042,
-0.04846278205513954,
-0.20858289301395416,
-0.3299624025821686,
-0.3052757978439331,
-0.5059682726860046,
-0.048379600048065186,
-0.26279279589653015,
0.7993005514144897,
-0.9123920798301697,
1.202715277671814,
0.8705829381942749,
-0.25117772817611694,
-0.7511172294616699,
-0.1093023493885994,
-0.1279435008764267,
-0.6065670847892761,
0.6419257521629333,
-0.12000808119773865,
0.28657054901123047,
0.08424391597509384,
-0.1410098671913147,
-0.5450927019119263,
1.1568570137023926,
0.6520546674728394,
-0.8805179595947266,
0.06259043514728546,
0.3428730368614197,
0.3339187204837799,
-0.2305828183889389,
0.08936310559511185,
0.4386747479438782,
0.5327404141426086,
0.46513837575912476,
-0.9755994081497192,
0.2775154709815979,
-0.1843976080417633,
0.09610404819250107,
0.1946752518415451,
-0.3099184036254883,
0.6255635023117065,
-0.026944687590003014,
0.0048104384914040565,
-0.04452844336628914,
0.4048216640949249,
0.31766122579574585,
0.3196295201778412,
0.4417699873447418,
0.4832412004470825,
0.7285062074661255,
-0.10510574281215668,
0.7798566222190857,
-0.2767082750797272,
0.2082206755876541,
1.0587186813354492,
0.08181542903184891,
0.9160007834434509,
0.9339419603347778,
-0.25655117630958557,
0.27815356850624084,
0.23681402206420898,
-0.0315154530107975,
0.6301661133766174,
0.27741310000419617,
-0.25055015087127686,
-0.37446898221969604,
0.23331379890441895,
-0.46370869874954224,
0.0298707764595747,
0.23491868376731873,
-0.5795997977256775,
0.0022028996609151363,
0.2828226387500763,
0.09143226593732834,
0.08838993310928345,
-0.09208343178033829,
0.8548107147216797,
0.24196887016296387,
-0.8516884446144104,
0.6052550077438354,
0.10869086533784866,
0.5197598934173584,
-0.45796874165534973,
-0.10924667119979858,
-0.34316152334213257,
0.57090163230896,
-0.020007336512207985,
-0.6232585310935974,
0.3762493133544922,
0.04536008834838867,
-0.4608514904975891,
-0.4112103581428528,
0.59957355260849,
-0.7117179036140442,
-0.6977394819259644,
-0.014496264047920704,
0.571320116519928,
0.23651689291000366,
-0.32128003239631653,
-0.40128037333488464,
-0.010527144186198711,
0.19534222781658173,
-0.09851939976215363,
0.44379353523254395,
0.7322229146957397,
0.10748790204524994,
0.608840823173523,
0.8413234353065491,
0.3592328429222107,
0.13979287445545197,
-0.041100695729255676,
1.1927953958511353,
-0.29301610589027405,
-0.22917315363883972,
-1.0915671586990356,
0.8618242144584656,
-0.17395497858524323,
0.15283358097076416,
0.7814139723777771,
0.37359243631362915,
0.747025728225708,
-0.28871622681617737,
0.9659699201583862,
0.17294763028621674,
0.5836386680603027,
-0.47039082646369934,
0.9188886284828186,
-0.3936252295970917,
0.6851258277893066,
-0.3921549320220947,
-1.146406888961792,
-0.13129402697086334,
0.5036688446998596,
-0.3909173607826233,
-0.27368730306625366,
0.5382061004638672,
0.4946245849132538,
-0.3484669029712677,
-0.3913334906101227,
0.4971895217895508,
0.34864872694015503,
0.5014744400978088,
0.5851624011993408,
0.9474175572395325,
-0.4596913158893585,
0.7658087015151978,
-0.05544722452759743,
-0.5412865877151489,
-0.1509181708097458,
-0.8227359652519226,
-1.247029185295105,
-0.5944082140922546,
-0.2628686726093292,
-0.266884982585907,
0.06801667809486389,
0.6949813365936279,
0.6967517733573914,
-0.7106093168258667,
-0.033225711435079575,
-0.09916519373655319,
0.3829050064086914,
-0.36360737681388855,
-0.16819658875465393,
0.07582392543554306,
-0.3913976550102234,
-0.8487704992294312,
0.48615193367004395,
-0.03708454221487045,
0.16421495378017426,
-0.08944007754325867,
-0.08308105170726776,
0.1937190741300583,
0.0443321093916893,
0.6132835745811462,
-0.10564437508583069,
-0.693364679813385,
0.097268246114254,
-0.0026536271907389164,
-0.04653321951627731,
-0.19118331372737885,
0.7683285474777222,
-0.6241474747657776,
0.5806887745857239,
0.37802854180336,
0.6364938616752625,
0.6391048431396484,
-0.37989944219589233,
0.8205510377883911,
-0.7679259777069092,
0.13427263498306274,
-0.1484057903289795,
0.3784179091453552,
0.23791038990020752,
-0.007869635708630085,
0.34519681334495544,
0.43128788471221924,
-0.3476583659648895,
-1.1095298528671265,
0.14181749522686005,
-0.6773419380187988,
-0.48458370566368103,
1.1721535921096802,
-0.5656877160072327,
-0.10789632797241211,
0.04941545054316521,
-0.4451361298561096,
0.42449888586997986,
-0.044909898191690445,
0.8499506115913391,
0.5943818688392639,
0.6341684460639954,
-0.2941197156906128,
-0.7234737277030945,
0.15926994383335114,
0.13114595413208008,
-0.6240459084510803,
0.1136246994137764,
0.18395818769931793,
0.7051773071289062,
0.04397875815629959,
0.2935938537120819,
-0.22026915848255157,
-0.15537957847118378,
-0.022684456780552864,
-0.000150276260683313,
-0.40233832597732544,
-0.19079571962356567,
0.03554002195596695,
0.0948554128408432,
0.18763276934623718,
-0.008563254028558731
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09516v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09516v3
|
Leveraging Prototypical Representations for Mitigating Social Bias without Demographic Information
| 2024-03-14T15:58:36 | 2024-04-05T18:35:37 |
Shadi Iskander, Kira Radinsky, Yonatan Belinkov
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG
|
Mitigating social biases typically requires identifying the social groups
associated with each data sample. In this paper, we present DAFair, a novel
approach to address social bias in language models. Unlike traditional methods
that rely on explicit demographic labels, our approach does not require any
such information. Instead, we leverage predefined prototypical demographic
texts and incorporate a regularization term during the fine-tuning process to
mitigate bias in the model's representations. Our empirical results across two
tasks and two models demonstrate the effectiveness of our method compared to
previous approaches that do not rely on labeled data. Moreover, with limited
demographic-annotated data, our approach outperforms common debiasing
approaches.
|
[
-0.44922906160354614,
-0.6771905422210693,
0.22473245859146118,
0.2931419610977173,
-0.03139893710613251,
0.43556520342826843,
-0.17516396939754486,
-0.04196103662252426,
0.37182745337486267,
0.6103543043136597,
-0.6046164631843567,
-0.4111451804637909,
-0.6566655039787292,
-0.18671315908432007,
-0.02279142662882805,
0.873690128326416,
0.2635765075683594,
0.08526352792978287,
-0.10481318831443787,
-0.000318131351377815,
-0.010012349113821983,
-0.608651876449585,
-0.6277658343315125,
-0.4928356111049652,
0.3843701481819153,
0.7180259227752686,
0.9307337403297424,
0.7412708401679993,
0.08546935021877289,
0.1774664670228958,
-0.32603099942207336,
0.22220289707183838,
-0.8434756994247437,
-0.07659433782100677,
0.05174620822072029,
-0.17109720408916473,
-0.3204861283302307,
0.2348307967185974,
0.762505054473877,
1.1148464679718018,
0.006800854578614235,
0.43360263109207153,
0.14369358122348785,
0.9748753905296326,
-0.7914682030677795,
0.3073926866054535,
-0.5918464660644531,
-0.08020129799842834,
-0.3982253968715668,
-0.09479165077209473,
-0.2047598510980606,
-0.6400490999221802,
-0.16354314982891083,
-0.3747624456882477,
0.7081961631774902,
-0.19189468026161194,
0.6480752229690552,
0.1081760823726654,
-0.6180984377861023,
0.08149708062410355,
-1.10560142993927,
0.8238766193389893,
-0.454987108707428,
0.21287095546722412,
0.8060839176177979,
0.2836199998855591,
-0.3190678060054779,
-0.1126919537782669,
-0.5793406367301941,
-0.03283321484923363,
-0.1816548854112625,
-0.21607869863510132,
-0.2286585420370102,
0.06284736841917038,
0.25602978467941284,
0.05959758535027504,
-0.21043361723423004,
-0.1529809683561325,
-0.5782439708709717,
-0.21964624524116516,
0.6484032869338989,
-0.09171748161315918,
0.28921809792518616,
-0.10359083861112595,
-0.17432597279548645,
-0.17581231892108917,
-0.7328305244445801,
-0.04209665209054947,
0.8098514080047607,
0.34404537081718445,
-0.263202965259552,
0.3496865928173065,
-0.17629246413707733,
0.2426021546125412,
0.6226423382759094,
0.16707387566566467,
0.3565099835395813,
-0.0478888638317585,
0.22887027263641357,
0.014963570050895214,
0.5283499956130981,
0.5947942733764648,
0.8341872692108154,
-0.2351941019296646,
-0.17991754412651062,
0.37633103132247925,
-0.11960072815418243,
-0.735958456993103,
-0.1338125616312027,
0.024009184911847115,
-0.475033700466156,
-0.3542073667049408,
0.10456741601228714,
-1.490413784980774,
-0.5704829096794128,
0.01320090051740408,
-0.2442464828491211,
0.056899543851614,
-0.5131760239601135,
0.04959007725119591,
-0.4711718261241913,
0.029873911291360855,
-0.07056532055139542,
-1.1742429733276367,
0.5902706384658813,
0.36657917499542236,
0.7439640164375305,
0.30177104473114014,
0.28957831859588623,
-0.5152655839920044,
0.5051072239875793,
-0.4230412542819977,
0.5940330028533936,
-1.0336295366287231,
-0.5477607846260071,
0.009412042796611786,
-0.23460160195827484,
0.098486989736557,
-0.6177675127983093,
0.34569841623306274,
-0.6264075636863708,
-0.31403446197509766,
-0.368956983089447,
-0.14096319675445557,
0.06627172976732254,
-0.3347001373767853,
-0.9850435256958008,
0.9141409993171692,
0.03296832740306854,
-0.8760483264923096,
0.7825265526771545,
-0.4147348403930664,
-0.33335283398628235,
0.03246249258518219,
-0.4099109470844269,
-0.3018130362033844,
0.11931608617305756,
0.4502066373825073,
0.24933011829853058,
-0.10384044051170349,
0.5103991031646729,
-0.5632259249687195,
-0.41530641913414,
0.0007803522748872638,
-0.3683604598045349,
0.8845060467720032,
0.37912002205848694,
-0.5565593242645264,
-0.16194383800029755,
-0.7381952404975891,
-0.5584943294525146,
0.17731596529483795,
0.06077836453914642,
-0.8454025387763977,
0.0731094479560852,
0.3321841359138489,
0.07050970941781998,
0.040673017501831055,
-0.8959182500839233,
0.037830453366041183,
-0.33916839957237244,
0.3199496269226074,
1.0141711235046387,
-0.010685483925044537,
0.9363760352134705,
-0.6076743006706238,
0.6445074677467346,
-0.15561915934085846,
0.17483974993228912,
0.27195537090301514,
-0.2506484091281891,
-0.7081223726272583,
-0.4994800388813019,
0.31397131085395813,
0.13800875842571259,
-0.8398917317390442,
0.289521723985672,
-0.06285253167152405,
-0.40801650285720825,
-0.3819190263748169,
0.3807167112827301,
0.29648298025131226,
0.1922425478696823,
0.0911388024687767,
-0.035192910581827164,
-0.7987746000289917,
-0.9774708151817322,
-0.2729424238204956,
-0.28863251209259033,
0.07860645651817322,
0.24720339477062225,
0.2503478229045868,
-0.3080132305622101,
0.9606280326843262,
-0.5050347447395325,
-0.4455926716327667,
-0.2587355077266693,
0.3206940293312073,
-0.031775400042533875,
0.5500609874725342,
0.8151193261146545,
-1.0963549613952637,
-0.36895498633384705,
-0.258379191160202,
-0.3312411904335022,
-0.5783059597015381,
-0.06954828649759293,
-0.24755671620368958,
0.07058560103178024,
0.45601409673690796,
-0.15056711435317993,
0.5813963413238525,
0.5837729573249817,
-0.4772385358810425,
-0.026701126247644424,
-0.01633099466562271,
-0.1658175140619278,
-0.6284775137901306,
0.10249641537666321,
0.46740028262138367,
-0.11352688819169998,
-0.7541074156761169,
-0.22292472422122955,
0.050833091139793396,
0.07116920500993729,
-0.06931423395872116,
1.1208252906799316,
-0.5691983699798584,
0.5738149881362915,
-0.08090707659721375,
-0.23507292568683624,
0.038275640457868576,
0.1353158950805664,
0.14046408236026764,
0.6883203983306885,
0.08152393996715546,
-0.566046953201294,
-0.405975341796875,
0.2691536247730255,
-0.009832172654569149,
0.27047979831695557,
-0.6804936528205872,
0.5093335509300232,
-0.9663688540458679,
0.35292157530784607,
-1.0942150354385376,
-0.26696422696113586,
0.32046255469322205,
-0.49911800026893616,
-0.04393609240651131,
-0.5464312434196472,
-0.3713376820087433,
-0.3008071780204773,
-0.4193388819694519,
0.4710233807563782,
0.6929022669792175,
-0.2546575665473938,
0.576159656047821,
0.7139501571655273,
-0.32197073101997375,
-0.5023831129074097,
-0.4488978981971741,
-0.24168682098388672,
-0.4745490550994873,
-0.40715712308883667,
0.4925646483898163,
-0.056900810450315475,
-0.5113051533699036,
-0.27460721135139465,
-0.19106894731521606,
-0.3825399875640869,
0.020272908732295036,
0.12521569430828094,
0.25227090716362,
0.2770669758319855,
0.11895999312400818,
0.2285095751285553,
-0.16319797933101654,
-0.2278568595647812,
0.1349971890449524,
0.743751049041748,
0.521841287612915,
0.049527376890182495,
0.01017178874462843,
0.5884501934051514,
0.5220720767974854,
-0.3729313015937805,
0.7252556085586548,
0.48583000898361206,
-0.4719178378582001,
-0.14225925505161285,
-1.0227195024490356,
-0.22294199466705322,
-0.5304574370384216,
0.07704072445631027,
-0.02473536878824234,
-0.8978909850120544,
0.6798548102378845,
0.01726834662258625,
0.010131428018212318,
0.19867925345897675,
0.5626000165939331,
0.13876347243785858,
1.281284213066101,
0.9069111347198486,
-0.0645814836025238,
0.7558940649032593,
-0.16149955987930298,
-0.0049874866381287575,
-0.5700138807296753,
-0.13028134405612946,
-0.7909500598907471,
-0.1268927901983261,
-0.5225206613540649,
-0.4895453155040741,
0.18213945627212524,
-0.16602765023708344,
-0.3133423626422882,
-0.015220324508845806,
-0.2148340791463852,
0.4454619288444519,
0.36192187666893005,
0.1279180496931076,
0.07987412065267563,
0.13703219592571259,
-0.17900946736335754,
-0.05812787264585495,
-0.6029905080795288,
-0.9689609408378601,
1.2002849578857422,
0.3661234974861145,
1.0403081178665161,
0.07503336668014526,
0.9553725719451904,
0.730754554271698,
0.429537832736969,
-0.14327789843082428,
0.43107870221138,
-0.553761899471283,
-1.1008141040802002,
-0.20139333605766296,
-0.6728389859199524,
-1.0069832801818848,
0.15330757200717926,
-0.29783809185028076,
-0.8860233426094055,
1.0052918195724487,
0.345884770154953,
-0.4559566080570221,
0.12031857669353485,
-0.6030446887016296,
0.5024580359458923,
0.24261723458766937,
-0.35998982191085815,
-0.1738576740026474,
-0.3144984245300293,
0.17373685538768768,
-0.2670276463031769,
0.7112230658531189,
-0.5556122660636902,
0.2089020162820816,
1.0385587215423584,
-0.2911948561668396,
1.3431549072265625,
-0.6815415620803833,
0.37540319561958313,
0.09302852302789688,
-0.059051211923360825,
0.3370751738548279,
-0.010859405621886253,
-0.4052315950393677,
0.13121774792671204,
0.3540342152118683,
-0.798573911190033,
-0.4095425307750702,
0.5106337666511536,
-0.8713569045066833,
-0.5503363013267517,
-0.2640751898288727,
-0.6718945503234863,
-0.18855565786361694,
-0.010170727036893368,
-0.251027911901474,
0.25764888525009155,
-0.5638611912727356,
0.12426301836967468,
0.44395431876182556,
-0.03565819188952446,
0.12500730156898499,
0.3916040062904358,
-0.1757223904132843,
-0.32393914461135864,
0.3440992832183838,
0.4315560758113861,
0.25966617465019226,
-0.12220431864261627,
0.4017462134361267,
-0.15843965113162994,
-0.094315305352211,
-0.41285964846611023,
0.4237610399723053,
-0.6284846663475037,
0.12523312866687775,
-0.8937206864356995,
0.18215636909008026,
-0.7456824779510498,
-0.0784781202673912,
-0.20088869333267212,
-0.3262529671192169,
-0.029057124629616737,
-0.05300125479698181,
0.23202042281627655,
0.7753199338912964,
-0.2905541658401489,
0.6438187956809998,
-0.511039137840271,
0.6945188045501709,
0.2286950647830963,
0.18343482911586761,
0.270369291305542,
-0.3684515357017517,
0.03412631154060364,
0.3112250566482544,
0.04485092684626579,
-0.9877598881721497,
0.4319562017917633,
0.35695716738700867,
0.9918403625488281,
0.4667152166366577,
0.533974289894104,
0.6278275847434998,
-0.44049033522605896,
0.28731173276901245,
-0.13006389141082764,
-0.8732191324234009,
0.6121939420700073,
-0.3425295352935791,
0.1153133437037468,
0.7917460799217224,
0.5081566572189331,
-0.45563358068466187,
-0.39754873514175415,
-0.4819798469543457,
-1.0493324995040894,
0.4173489809036255,
0.11238934099674225,
0.7053423523902893,
-0.5063004493713379,
0.4723280370235443,
0.1256057620048523,
0.14644277095794678,
-0.4678250551223755,
-0.2508523464202881,
0.08837141841650009,
-0.39651164412498474,
-0.10848987102508545,
-0.6194725632667542,
-0.19262568652629852,
-0.32451537251472473,
0.3306436240673065,
0.009821360930800438,
-0.11766598373651505,
0.37162360548973083,
-0.17836466431617737,
-0.34529587626457214,
0.1317172795534134,
0.26500099897384644,
0.6829313635826111,
-0.525165855884552,
0.14175014197826385,
-0.2711385190486908,
-0.7666206359863281,
0.5575870275497437,
0.3453773856163025,
-0.6964336633682251,
0.1594020128250122,
0.2132168859243393,
0.2976871430873871,
-0.06793996691703796,
-0.3180302381515503,
0.4567203223705292,
-0.09560482203960419,
-0.04256150871515274,
-0.32879364490509033,
-0.04726732149720192,
-0.2319381833076477,
0.1875670999288559,
0.7511694431304932,
-0.04727555066347122,
0.1545381397008896,
-0.5320606827735901,
0.26246652007102966,
0.5260511040687561,
-0.7548850178718567,
-0.3560740053653717,
0.8228143453598022,
0.4512207806110382,
-0.041022032499313354,
0.23124733567237854,
-0.043184854090213776,
-0.22732055187225342,
0.8242449760437012,
0.5071516633033752,
0.7419260740280151,
-0.4299369156360626,
0.636604368686676,
0.285453736782074,
0.38996320962905884,
0.005432287696748972,
0.09291468560695648,
0.11266226321458817,
-1.0432049036026,
-0.36064937710762024,
-0.6770700216293335,
-0.1705113798379898,
-0.208683043718338,
-0.8463918566703796,
0.15728792548179626,
-0.7682572603225708,
-0.6596488952636719,
0.32724398374557495,
-0.22951258718967438,
-0.901142418384552,
0.06965230405330658,
0.18932440876960754,
0.802654504776001,
-1.5279277563095093,
0.7755841612815857,
0.8710778951644897,
-0.3822339177131653,
-0.2996227443218231,
0.34666091203689575,
0.27773401141166687,
-0.7837064266204834,
1.075472116470337,
0.030802054330706596,
-0.2775854766368866,
-0.02020196244120598,
-0.4278443157672882,
-0.6666994690895081,
0.5540353655815125,
0.5409517884254456,
-0.4835457503795624,
0.025880856439471245,
0.05639258027076721,
0.33000704646110535,
-0.5676128268241882,
0.10606203228235245,
0.7584793567657471,
0.7014951109886169,
0.19627441465854645,
-0.6777122020721436,
0.03079613484442234,
-0.4067053198814392,
0.29976019263267517,
-0.10853654891252518,
-0.6521556973457336,
0.7035397887229919,
-0.15070714056491852,
-0.5285692811012268,
-0.2434568852186203,
0.3816590905189514,
0.13650085031986237,
0.3328850269317627,
0.9115193486213684,
-0.08868476003408432,
0.7084459662437439,
0.13530856370925903,
0.7401272058486938,
-0.1568693369626999,
0.030361348763108253,
0.8930177688598633,
-0.5539607405662537,
0.16239969432353973,
0.8137661218643188,
-0.12327048182487488,
0.26650145649909973,
0.5304532051086426,
0.35029909014701843,
0.7760338187217712,
0.3647881746292114,
-0.2551894187927246,
-0.22404082119464874,
-0.48219072818756104,
-0.030791105702519417,
0.6459584832191467,
0.1736663430929184,
-0.2667015492916107,
-0.33540841937065125,
-0.08944635838270187,
0.3917993903160095,
0.7596452832221985,
-0.2729620337486267,
0.7171882390975952,
-0.07721274346113205,
-0.18059709668159485,
0.5311204195022583,
-0.15425987541675568,
0.9319859147071838,
-0.4212401807308197,
-0.4462953507900238,
-0.6078672409057617,
0.1194542795419693,
-0.09250350296497345,
-0.21002495288848877,
0.45679622888565063,
-0.00574771361425519,
-0.46450239419937134,
-0.08366084098815918,
0.7754517793655396,
-0.522659420967102,
-0.9750936031341553,
0.45304903388023376,
0.541913628578186,
-0.18504133820533752,
0.009695143438875675,
-0.3153710663318634,
0.0555373840034008,
0.06607592105865479,
-0.030712855979800224,
0.0836949497461319,
0.3618192970752716,
-0.5588938593864441,
0.6912927627563477,
0.6047772765159607,
0.5029663443565369,
-0.1777569204568863,
0.3299424350261688,
1.028276801109314,
-0.5332186818122864,
-0.39317768812179565,
-1.0437119007110596,
0.393621027469635,
-0.38921797275543213,
0.03709624707698822,
0.6075446009635925,
0.22136043012142181,
0.7414948344230652,
0.0014684031484648585,
0.9111955761909485,
0.01617126725614071,
0.5618200898170471,
-0.17014986276626587,
0.9079974889755249,
-0.24789613485336304,
0.1969115436077118,
-0.5244045853614807,
-0.9878252148628235,
-0.3797280788421631,
0.6980295181274414,
-0.6056113839149475,
0.26506492495536804,
0.00824188906699419,
1.013800859451294,
0.020208226516842842,
-0.3101676404476166,
0.30128368735313416,
0.04883728548884392,
0.24752363562583923,
0.08342886716127396,
0.6282463073730469,
0.02181379683315754,
0.3703139126300812,
-0.3087848722934723,
-0.8363233804702759,
-0.08506285399198532,
-0.8176741003990173,
-1.2812448740005493,
-0.2840365767478943,
-0.28373458981513977,
-0.20348747074604034,
0.6346280574798584,
0.9878572821617126,
0.9469140768051147,
-0.6808287501335144,
-0.20567096769809723,
0.5315239429473877,
0.05668274313211441,
-0.17117516696453094,
-0.18788735568523407,
0.2759435772895813,
-0.09352793544530869,
-0.806194007396698,
-0.1628257930278778,
-0.045056525617837906,
0.04741942137479782,
-0.5608624815940857,
-0.00009795704681891948,
-0.2174689620733261,
0.47114941477775574,
0.21082085371017456,
-0.028186198323965073,
-0.5348495841026306,
-0.48370903730392456,
-0.12342962622642517,
0.12452219426631927,
0.034161802381277084,
0.715706467628479,
-0.6591283679008484,
0.5475784540176392,
0.3473159372806549,
0.3250804841518402,
0.42671793699264526,
0.12714789807796478,
0.9066705107688904,
-0.8097295165061951,
0.708766520023346,
0.2866194546222687,
0.23331820964813232,
0.5672990083694458,
-0.6972960233688354,
0.4878191649913788,
-0.059705883264541626,
-0.2561947703361511,
-0.645140528678894,
0.32483142614364624,
-0.6302807927131653,
-0.05621163919568062,
1.3241854906082153,
-0.10780483484268188,
-0.222340926527977,
-0.6535425782203674,
-0.27961528301239014,
0.32284894585609436,
-0.6733098030090332,
1.1673007011413574,
0.7093403339385986,
0.5742447972297668,
-0.3585376739501953,
-0.6777233481407166,
0.3625634014606476,
0.3338153064250946,
-0.15779194235801697,
0.3666834831237793,
0.4539875388145447,
0.31492576003074646,
-0.16520531475543976,
1.1542596817016602,
-0.4346173405647278,
0.09106133133172989,
-0.09563970565795898,
0.29606732726097107,
0.09440455585718155,
-0.08477532118558884,
-0.10161198675632477,
-0.17507392168045044,
0.20599991083145142,
0.01979614980518818
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09762v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09762v1
|
Emotional Intelligence Through Artificial Intelligence : NLP and Deep Learning in the Analysis of Healthcare Texts
| 2024-03-14T15:58:13 | 2024-03-14T15:58:13 |
Prashant Kumar Nag, Amit Bhagat, R. Vishnu Priya, Deepak kumar Khare
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC, cs.LG, cs.NE
|
This manuscript presents a methodical examination of the utilization of
Artificial Intelligence in the assessment of emotions in texts related to
healthcare, with a particular focus on the incorporation of Natural Language
Processing and deep learning technologies. We scrutinize numerous research
studies that employ AI to augment sentiment analysis, categorize emotions, and
forecast patient outcomes based on textual information derived from clinical
narratives, patient feedback on medications, and online health discussions. The
review demonstrates noteworthy progress in the precision of algorithms used for
sentiment classification, the prognostic capabilities of AI models for
neurodegenerative diseases, and the creation of AI-powered systems that offer
support in clinical decision-making. Remarkably, the utilization of AI
applications has exhibited an enhancement in personalized therapy plans by
integrating patient sentiment and contributing to the early identification of
mental health disorders. There persist challenges, which encompass ensuring the
ethical application of AI, safeguarding patient confidentiality, and addressing
potential biases in algorithmic procedures. Nevertheless, the potential of AI
to revolutionize healthcare practices is unmistakable, offering a future where
healthcare is not only more knowledgeable and efficient but also more
empathetic and centered around the needs of patients. This investigation
underscores the transformative influence of AI on healthcare, delivering a
comprehensive comprehension of its role in examining emotional content in
healthcare texts and highlighting the trajectory towards a more compassionate
approach to patient care. The findings advocate for a harmonious synergy
between AI's analytical capabilities and the human aspects of healthcare.
|
[
-0.23451349139213562,
-0.6218349933624268,
0.5999623537063599,
0.19222794473171234,
0.10902077704668045,
0.0821620523929596,
-0.18291006982326508,
-0.6550208926200867,
0.2893565595149994,
0.3480868935585022,
-0.653139591217041,
-0.2962394654750824,
-0.7384886145591736,
0.2319764792919159,
-0.11626636236906052,
0.9580911993980408,
0.12163043022155762,
0.42578282952308655,
-0.31251394748687744,
-0.17572057247161865,
-0.06730607151985168,
-0.7906582951545715,
-0.6710477471351624,
-0.6596173048019409,
0.42025959491729736,
0.21702693402767181,
0.7291087508201599,
0.15974357724189758,
0.7854090332984924,
0.37943315505981445,
0.07456718385219574,
0.05944790691137314,
0.08808979392051697,
0.23526428639888763,
0.36486873030662537,
-0.29678207635879517,
-0.6660562753677368,
0.020249342545866966,
0.24009419977664948,
0.5143495202064514,
-0.21077920496463776,
0.05786297842860222,
-0.130605548620224,
1.0576709508895874,
-0.2857751250267029,
0.21059003472328186,
-0.10993277281522751,
0.7362189888954163,
0.085695780813694,
-0.3453337252140045,
-0.18886636197566986,
-0.25930511951446533,
0.33984678983688354,
-0.3497856557369232,
-0.1891786903142929,
-0.011841448955237865,
0.4388888478279114,
0.8769545555114746,
-0.4667573571205139,
-0.5964065790176392,
-0.6439340114593506,
0.7185772657394409,
-0.7636825442314148,
0.21276433765888214,
0.26765701174736023,
0.17159727215766907,
0.2842850983142853,
-0.9333292841911316,
-0.6572345495223999,
-0.3411926031112671,
-0.1414182335138321,
0.43082112073898315,
-0.43917250633239746,
0.35867756605148315,
0.30716177821159363,
0.45719125866889954,
-0.4147282540798187,
0.1532059907913208,
-0.22096550464630127,
0.09725525975227356,
0.9948082566261292,
0.49538952112197876,
0.7046489715576172,
-0.083759605884552,
0.03219239413738251,
0.20252107083797455,
0.12740319967269897,
0.055640000849962234,
0.11050727963447571,
-0.03777346760034561,
-0.07565230876207352,
0.7648714184761047,
-0.1657710075378418,
0.022952953353524208,
-0.22134770452976227,
-0.06432150304317474,
0.5402796864509583,
-0.03116748109459877,
-0.40571609139442444,
0.372171550989151,
0.9211480617523193,
0.6329352259635925,
0.16552025079727173,
0.05993196740746498,
0.00014796391769777983,
0.31388571858406067,
0.8173067569732666,
-0.7293146848678589,
-0.24921070039272308,
0.6203286647796631,
-0.9602962732315063,
-0.3539201617240906,
-0.06707873940467834,
-1.0088714361190796,
-0.6224751472473145,
-0.5864354372024536,
-0.3435717225074768,
-0.4994824528694153,
-0.10813654959201813,
0.15369939804077148,
0.03817712143063545,
0.12356549501419067,
0.00818307138979435,
-0.6541558504104614,
0.3719499409198761,
0.8860054016113281,
0.5469605326652527,
0.12616248428821564,
-0.12126803398132324,
-0.05750475451350212,
-0.41105055809020996,
-0.3010566532611847,
0.5691011548042297,
-0.5732315182685852,
-0.2570861577987671,
0.34834325313568115,
-0.23797670006752014,
0.03647229075431824,
-0.4134044051170349,
0.8422495126724243,
-0.10803265869617462,
0.30305013060569763,
-0.03152533993124962,
-0.6756151914596558,
-0.2448950707912445,
0.2405637800693512,
-0.6028515696525574,
0.5694202780723572,
0.24964334070682526,
-0.6205516457557678,
0.1225295439362526,
-1.1664700508117676,
-0.7197561860084534,
0.31157782673835754,
0.029507381841540337,
-0.45333781838417053,
0.5495217442512512,
0.10037204623222351,
0.45163607597351074,
-0.21683017909526825,
0.09867430478334427,
-0.3227361738681793,
-0.12472587078809738,
0.36554762721061707,
-0.2059435248374939,
0.8118140697479248,
0.21991795301437378,
-0.4658714234828949,
0.25879424810409546,
-0.5293141007423401,
-0.001372666796669364,
0.08086328208446503,
0.032409872859716415,
-0.20566268265247345,
0.1212206482887268,
0.03890989348292351,
0.12385911494493484,
0.21346622705459595,
-0.2262209802865982,
0.0513608418405056,
-0.7146757245063782,
0.44982948899269104,
0.4746782183647156,
0.02808874100446701,
0.5492927432060242,
-0.3167508840560913,
0.6681905388832092,
-0.22818228602409363,
0.6342858076095581,
-0.16690634191036224,
-0.4931231439113617,
-0.5524135828018188,
-0.04958415776491165,
0.00003554768409230746,
0.7056928277015686,
-0.3427109718322754,
0.48261556029319763,
0.17693369090557098,
-0.4502706825733185,
-1.245124340057373,
-0.26705828309059143,
0.18361273407936096,
0.7515416741371155,
0.4953697919845581,
-0.27381452918052673,
-0.42143601179122925,
-0.6933498382568359,
-0.25412118434906006,
-0.2701694667339325,
0.24995794892311096,
0.612116813659668,
0.5417752861976624,
-0.7629740834236145,
0.3337046205997467,
-0.379682332277298,
-0.44830408692359924,
-0.1449597179889679,
0.36944565176963806,
-0.025784829631447792,
0.4676674008369446,
0.23959386348724365,
-0.7095772624015808,
-0.36603090167045593,
0.2358451634645462,
-1.1041316986083984,
-0.08175994455814362,
-0.14390097558498383,
0.14111287891864777,
0.11921840906143188,
0.17403864860534668,
-0.5017221570014954,
0.4531215727329254,
0.22568221390247345,
-0.36903682351112366,
0.3270457684993744,
-0.23554670810699463,
0.2270207703113556,
-0.8580203056335449,
0.04104289785027504,
0.20368538796901703,
0.2723582088947296,
-0.8034372329711914,
-0.10567621141672134,
-0.3464853763580322,
0.02500879392027855,
-0.13940741121768951,
0.47090163826942444,
-0.07898949086666107,
0.33757349848747253,
-0.43481069803237915,
-0.25350815057754517,
-0.021381765604019165,
0.07878617197275162,
-0.2655290365219116,
0.11979427188634872,
0.4162899851799011,
-0.14533717930316925,
0.7854748964309692,
0.4502234160900116,
0.17138685286045074,
0.9249581694602966,
-0.4680592119693756,
0.22996094822883606,
-0.2787361145019531,
0.11947760730981827,
-0.29460254311561584,
-0.30346307158470154,
0.4421307444572449,
-0.7114897966384888,
0.07213887572288513,
0.3894919455051422,
-0.24151118099689484,
-0.44115716218948364,
-0.14924004673957825,
0.08735498785972595,
0.5491275191307068,
0.16879689693450928,
0.7500333786010742,
0.7347734570503235,
-0.5116448402404785,
-0.43443191051483154,
-0.8422632813453674,
0.4909476041793823,
-0.1210426390171051,
-0.23116400837898254,
0.39762604236602783,
-0.09062743186950684,
-0.8024604916572571,
0.08056730777025223,
0.16539360582828522,
-0.2447352409362793,
0.3715015947818756,
0.38557565212249756,
0.24525198340415955,
-0.09579850733280182,
0.5058999061584473,
0.29268693923950195,
-0.3029142916202545,
0.7679743766784668,
-0.1644687056541443,
0.3027210533618927,
-0.4699012339115143,
-0.170589417219162,
-0.9025111794471741,
0.8314769268035889,
0.6467795372009277,
-0.2969237267971039,
0.6938141584396362,
0.7638158798217773,
-0.6974478960037231,
0.12408483028411865,
-0.3938279449939728,
-0.22159548103809357,
-0.26746028661727905,
0.4437617361545563,
0.294299840927124,
-0.6798198819160461,
0.33789557218551636,
-0.11598377674818039,
-0.17839550971984863,
0.6864352822303772,
0.7310671210289001,
-0.5438572764396667,
1.2574667930603027,
0.666692852973938,
-0.23627744615077972,
0.20121406018733978,
-0.19432827830314636,
0.3421785533428192,
-0.6860048174858093,
-0.44211864471435547,
-0.5229138731956482,
-0.5268831849098206,
-0.9949661493301392,
0.020833777263760567,
0.2534632980823517,
-0.5135043263435364,
-0.3313623368740082,
-0.5516176819801331,
-0.9114774465560913,
-0.11265157163143158,
0.6153711080551147,
0.5276320576667786,
0.08323373645544052,
-0.5879725217819214,
0.31489548087120056,
-0.3068693280220032,
-0.2632315754890442,
-0.44570791721343994,
0.714688777923584,
0.6081613302230835,
0.25478893518447876,
-0.24244365096092224,
0.6784633994102478,
0.596415638923645,
0.5546669960021973,
-1.0755889415740967,
0.25061678886413574,
-0.142739936709404,
-0.34297484159469604,
-0.16427548229694366,
-0.2747577130794525,
-0.8548204898834229,
-0.40534189343452454,
-0.35461512207984924,
-0.33551445603370667,
0.02626815065741539,
-0.08454684168100357,
-0.46405336260795593,
0.01759941875934601,
-0.6161860227584839,
0.7438830137252808,
-0.7811487317085266,
0.19696791470050812,
-0.4077235162258148,
-1.0813987255096436,
0.0281732939183712,
0.1614278256893158,
-0.1415649801492691,
-0.04366057738661766,
-0.22436590492725372,
0.6709823608398438,
-0.015911223366856575,
0.647162139415741,
-0.021132098510861397,
0.2075585275888443,
-0.0897509753704071,
-0.28468579053878784,
-0.07497744262218475,
0.07462915778160095,
-0.25710329413414,
0.21216535568237305,
-0.15456850826740265,
-0.29574212431907654,
-0.8936553597450256,
0.4064386487007141,
-0.8410804271697998,
-0.3722113072872162,
-0.6338008046150208,
-0.5418446063995361,
-0.27761346101760864,
0.2594890892505646,
-0.09733176976442337,
0.2557680010795593,
-0.22521375119686127,
0.016737833619117737,
0.4169379770755768,
-0.33051419258117676,
0.22888128459453583,
-0.017813298851251602,
0.180755615234375,
-0.3942182660102844,
0.8788857460021973,
-0.06469836086034775,
-0.4365350902080536,
0.4082738757133484,
0.46234211325645447,
-0.10743111371994019,
-0.6758224964141846,
-0.05046398192644119,
0.23287732899188995,
-0.5690131187438965,
-0.020124243572354317,
-0.6619556546211243,
-0.32586434483528137,
-0.33116406202316284,
-0.37752100825309753,
-0.13207483291625977,
0.02119525335729122,
-0.7762755155563354,
-0.2145020216703415,
0.20309682190418243,
0.9492688179016113,
0.39821916818618774,
0.14517244696617126,
-0.8625950217247009,
0.14849595725536346,
0.1445329785346985,
0.3789002299308777,
0.23130707442760468,
0.156943678855896,
-0.10554376989603043,
-0.08966653794050217,
-0.22408823668956757,
-1.0677978992462158,
0.7999974489212036,
0.15161484479904175,
0.4297592341899872,
0.5035114288330078,
0.16724467277526855,
0.3163888156414032,
-0.3670245110988617,
0.8213281631469727,
0.2676153779029846,
-0.8627457022666931,
0.6914870142936707,
-0.10158421099185944,
0.20513121783733368,
0.7312349677085876,
0.7005833387374878,
-0.532143235206604,
-0.011934913694858551,
-0.8905454874038696,
-0.8150155544281006,
0.3267543911933899,
-0.09058382362127304,
0.251761257648468,
-0.07533913850784302,
0.48118770122528076,
-0.00640439847484231,
0.3122367560863495,
-0.34629401564598083,
-0.35221877694129944,
-0.17255836725234985,
-0.8727692365646362,
0.03896201401948929,
-0.1691036969423294,
-0.2812625765800476,
-0.21086890995502472,
0.44449901580810547,
-0.3278755247592926,
0.6325459480285645,
0.45481082797050476,
0.05841097980737686,
-0.1442161649465561,
0.10491222888231277,
0.4035681188106537,
0.2619433104991913,
0.07064218819141388,
-0.05625274032354355,
0.1275663673877716,
-0.4980917274951935,
-0.18036329746246338,
0.41952991485595703,
0.1273394078016281,
-0.044261232018470764,
0.49476468563079834,
0.6517519950866699,
-0.15821900963783264,
-0.8013493418693542,
0.35969316959381104,
-0.25949856638908386,
-0.07441601902246475,
-0.5005661249160767,
-0.16596221923828125,
-0.23658083379268646,
0.6934360265731812,
0.25087589025497437,
0.27234092354774475,
0.6534402370452881,
-0.5426772832870483,
0.2741501033306122,
0.3436230421066284,
-0.9825442433357239,
-0.23933538794517517,
0.3888419270515442,
0.23479242622852325,
-0.7854866981506348,
0.8322024941444397,
0.0914468765258789,
-0.6202757358551025,
0.6095065474510193,
-0.004744899924844503,
1.1046080589294434,
-0.1958884298801422,
0.21159499883651733,
-0.12245368212461472,
0.13151568174362183,
0.17886590957641602,
0.2873767018318176,
0.05628099665045738,
-0.40634655952453613,
-0.19913360476493835,
-0.2813422679901123,
-0.7011263370513916,
-0.2162415236234665,
-0.676206111907959,
-0.14359211921691895,
-0.3882995843887329,
-0.3271466791629791,
-0.04251265898346901,
0.42552417516708374,
-0.6603177189826965,
0.5408453345298767,
0.6314531564712524,
0.6647430658340454,
-0.5366520285606384,
0.38878414034843445,
0.7673010230064392,
-0.34892991185188293,
-0.5529595017433167,
0.20736666023731232,
0.2601994574069977,
-0.7147517204284668,
0.3414561450481415,
0.3099879324436188,
0.09609528630971909,
-0.13358981907367706,
-0.4059782922267914,
-0.11470229178667068,
0.7729409337043762,
0.06754940748214722,
-0.09558794647455215,
-0.0753541886806488,
-0.07900885492563248,
1.1266322135925293,
-0.5109452605247498,
0.6407800316810608,
0.6259698271751404,
0.5824054479598999,
-0.3745415210723877,
-0.6062771081924438,
-0.05450383573770523,
-0.6976644992828369,
-0.4036955237388611,
-0.20438365638256073,
-0.5476701259613037,
0.5138537883758545,
-0.3047730028629303,
0.1603361964225769,
-0.10426574945449829,
0.7170444130897522,
-0.14550600945949554,
0.8034653663635254,
0.1876019537448883,
0.7630873322486877,
1.2153105735778809,
-0.1333482712507248,
1.230251431465149,
-0.1286323070526123,
0.16634221374988556,
0.5248214602470398,
-0.5369047522544861,
0.4641934931278229,
0.22064419090747833,
-0.20985831320285797,
0.6750022172927856,
0.5730215311050415,
-0.027887769043445587,
0.17352266609668732,
0.14760804176330566,
-0.4895542860031128,
0.18192200362682343,
-0.5415055155754089,
-0.3952208459377289,
0.5108430981636047,
0.4175836145877838,
-0.4364384412765503,
0.46393072605133057,
0.2380765974521637,
0.06530149281024933,
0.16364090144634247,
-0.3875728249549866,
1.076298713684082,
0.39697569608688354,
-0.6079596281051636,
-0.24062573909759521,
-0.22256585955619812,
0.3119147717952728,
-0.22589601576328278,
-0.05321423336863518,
0.014585837721824646,
0.21349315345287323,
-0.3390520513057709,
-0.7451075315475464,
0.6187628507614136,
0.04815194383263588,
-0.3195910155773163,
-0.49181056022644043,
0.7149679660797119,
-0.02310800924897194,
-0.6672561764717102,
0.29083770513534546,
0.49000313878059387,
-0.10844524949789047,
-0.0328381285071373,
-1.1879488229751587,
-0.06278789788484573,
-0.15127800405025482,
-0.4582974314689636,
0.3189147710800171,
0.6043030023574829,
0.2764432430267334,
0.5966563820838928,
0.6470279097557068,
0.3260679244995117,
-0.39444780349731445,
0.22058632969856262,
0.5664389133453369,
-1.013156771659851,
-0.3417941927909851,
-1.1571764945983887,
0.6360200047492981,
-0.1783774197101593,
-0.42840248346328735,
0.21894504129886627,
0.09149405360221863,
0.19083142280578613,
0.26807308197021484,
0.8884108662605286,
0.05355089530348778,
0.2637242376804352,
-0.19063785672187805,
0.8397580981254578,
-0.5842801928520203,
-0.229522705078125,
-0.26947513222694397,
-0.17230311036109924,
-0.7741007208824158,
0.5992029905319214,
-0.28493908047676086,
0.06268439441919327,
0.5828573703765869,
0.012615994550287724,
0.756370484828949,
0.5503334999084473,
0.01775832660496235,
0.42344459891319275,
0.3216775059700012,
0.4995484948158264,
0.7544185519218445,
-0.35070276260375977,
-0.18085505068302155,
-0.4935842752456665,
-0.3348197638988495,
-0.33036527037620544,
-0.6939473748207092,
-0.5007264018058777,
-0.5272265672683716,
-0.34506434202194214,
-0.3849087655544281,
0.08125553280115128,
1.0827594995498657,
0.29134708642959595,
-0.6512063145637512,
0.11728470027446747,
0.047224536538124084,
0.28498682379722595,
-0.4751001000404358,
-0.23054930567741394,
0.25926968455314636,
-0.38160431385040283,
-0.6252296566963196,
0.06376808136701584,
0.6642026901245117,
-0.1432591825723648,
-0.3425036072731018,
-0.212947279214859,
0.003608990926295519,
0.04140666127204895,
0.4711952209472656,
0.0498737134039402,
-0.6064784526824951,
0.21346013247966766,
0.2601363956928253,
-0.31924745440483093,
0.23855356872081757,
0.6787474751472473,
-0.6745866537094116,
0.4631483256816864,
0.36128947138786316,
0.9370954632759094,
-0.22000475227832794,
-0.07237501442432404,
0.487170547246933,
0.042949412018060684,
-0.2684676945209503,
1.177089810371399,
0.5675331354141235,
0.17894230782985687,
-0.8075077533721924,
0.29123982787132263,
0.1797216534614563,
-0.7599472999572754,
-0.7996417880058289,
-0.07892528176307678,
-1.0327892303466797,
-0.31718212366104126,
0.6111261248588562,
0.05866338312625885,
-0.20541752874851227,
-0.10745018720626831,
-0.44323378801345825,
0.3561787009239197,
-0.4029538631439209,
1.0881454944610596,
0.35085609555244446,
-0.5859758853912354,
-0.28314152359962463,
-0.7915690541267395,
0.6167209148406982,
0.5903527140617371,
-1.1763068437576294,
-0.12717096507549286,
0.1357075721025467,
-0.6275468468666077,
0.1506538838148117,
0.4980739653110504,
-0.03573744371533394,
0.22888407111167908,
-0.26476022601127625,
0.1922750025987625,
0.07804577052593231,
-0.10460139065980911,
-0.5686798095703125,
0.3434714674949646,
-0.4100138545036316,
0.255980521440506
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09498v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09498v1
|
From Skepticism to Acceptance: Simulating the Attitude Dynamics Toward Fake News
| 2024-03-14T15:40:13 | 2024-03-14T15:40:13 |
Yuhan Liu, Xiuying Chen, Xiaoqing Zhang, Xing Gao, Ji Zhang, Rui Yan
|
cs.SI
|
cs.SI, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
In the digital era, the rapid propagation of fake news and rumors via social
networks brings notable societal challenges and impacts public opinion
regulation. Traditional fake news modeling typically forecasts the general
popularity trends of different groups or numerically represents opinions shift.
However, these methods often oversimplify real-world complexities and overlook
the rich semantic information of news text. The advent of large language models
(LLMs) provides the possibility of modeling subtle dynamics of opinion.
Consequently, in this work, we introduce a Fake news Propagation Simulation
framework (FPS) based on LLM, which studies the trends and control of fake news
propagation in detail. Specifically, each agent in the simulation represents an
individual with a distinct personality. They are equipped with both short-term
and long-term memory, as well as a reflective mechanism to mimic human-like
thinking. Every day, they engage in random opinion exchanges, reflect on their
thinking, and update their opinions. Our simulation results uncover patterns in
fake news propagation related to topic relevance, and individual traits,
aligning with real-world observations. Additionally, we evaluate various
intervention strategies and demonstrate that early and appropriately frequent
interventions strike a balance between governance cost and effectiveness,
offering valuable insights for practical applications. Our study underscores
the significant utility and potential of LLMs in combating fake news.
|
[
-0.26085010170936584,
-1.1503276824951172,
0.8774471282958984,
0.6012499928474426,
-0.24701693654060364,
0.1603403389453888,
-0.15853574872016907,
-0.26240161061286926,
0.462857723236084,
0.27342700958251953,
-0.46746155619621277,
-0.24762336909770966,
-0.5826776623725891,
-0.22694389522075653,
-0.545796811580658,
0.8605768084526062,
-0.13768790662288666,
0.17412136495113373,
0.119386687874794,
0.36864885687828064,
0.14174583554267883,
-0.5404143333435059,
-0.487457811832428,
-0.337424099445343,
0.6180626749992371,
0.02549154683947563,
0.6659932136535645,
0.40483802556991577,
-0.012329584918916225,
0.1743440181016922,
-0.2553047835826874,
-0.0202010627835989,
-0.6610692739486694,
-0.46659258008003235,
-0.33921751379966736,
-0.46099570393562317,
-0.4485381245613098,
0.5316995978355408,
0.8678295016288757,
0.25278839468955994,
-0.5271307229995728,
0.09347013384103775,
-0.07854368537664413,
0.2627545893192291,
-0.14472591876983643,
-0.11974150687456131,
-0.7254769206047058,
-0.028193090111017227,
0.039836421608924866,
-0.2010343372821808,
-0.27466946840286255,
-0.5009143948554993,
0.20445480942726135,
-0.5375267267227173,
-0.0005309088155627251,
0.09995105117559433,
0.8053513765335083,
-0.2945694625377655,
-0.7576798796653748,
-0.500828742980957,
-1.011421799659729,
0.49089741706848145,
-0.6475751399993896,
0.2582184076309204,
-0.03204327076673508,
0.3888968229293823,
-0.4597603380680084,
-0.45355620980262756,
-1.0542809963226318,
0.0015886272303760052,
0.38796791434288025,
0.14341293275356293,
-0.32530856132507324,
-0.027287038043141365,
0.0010974304750561714,
0.06121153011918068,
-0.30575376749038696,
-0.11161629855632782,
-0.4036467373371124,
-0.17653533816337585,
0.5446438193321228,
-0.05702205374836922,
0.12418083101511002,
-0.29765355587005615,
-0.4982709586620331,
-0.06447495520114899,
-0.5792049169540405,
0.07291165739297867,
0.5610000491142273,
0.1435091495513916,
-0.3026418685913086,
0.5167529582977295,
-0.3854592740535736,
0.42254018783569336,
0.39073997735977173,
-0.23197054862976074,
0.3352891504764557,
-0.013000009581446648,
-0.5216659903526306,
0.11465948820114136,
0.6100106239318848,
0.35651955008506775,
0.2572055160999298,
0.316502183675766,
-0.06378144025802612,
0.534982442855835,
0.6870248317718506,
-0.5472428202629089,
0.2987358272075653,
0.2904510498046875,
-0.7095953822135925,
-0.7498565912246704,
-0.04641597345471382,
-0.970594584941864,
-0.5619763135910034,
-0.4378921091556549,
0.6742198467254639,
-0.2093917429447174,
-0.5977323651313782,
0.429522842168808,
-0.002649571280926466,
0.29778704047203064,
0.8658475279808044,
-0.1080322116613388,
0.18590104579925537,
0.7457687854766846,
0.725237250328064,
-0.01183422189205885,
-0.0863337591290474,
-0.15716230869293213,
0.09237412363290787,
-0.5757055282592773,
0.44831356406211853,
-0.4149479866027832,
-0.32634595036506653,
0.05633930861949921,
-0.10969778895378113,
0.09447193145751953,
-0.23514501750469208,
0.39895039796829224,
-0.8968449234962463,
0.027490099892020226,
-0.2668989598751068,
-0.5029217004776001,
-0.11444486677646637,
0.6090990304946899,
-0.2458237260580063,
0.49067220091819763,
-0.1586296707391739,
-0.5851853489875793,
0.2912672758102417,
-0.5297508835792542,
-0.19378060102462769,
-0.5106557011604309,
0.028132503852248192,
-0.14336223900318146,
0.4917404055595398,
0.1153821274638176,
0.4569861888885498,
0.06642124056816101,
0.3394865393638611,
-0.4221084713935852,
-0.3737734258174896,
0.33954232931137085,
-0.6906372308731079,
0.5990443229675293,
0.30141741037368774,
-0.5058167576789856,
0.16174034774303436,
-0.23194606602191925,
-0.36049583554267883,
0.039845049381256104,
-0.0712653249502182,
-0.30274713039398193,
0.0938061997294426,
-0.022191355004906654,
0.58033287525177,
-0.16671769320964813,
-0.5918672680854797,
0.5353407859802246,
-0.3590140640735626,
0.32694652676582336,
0.9547500610351562,
0.5352030396461487,
0.5666848421096802,
-0.45641928911209106,
0.46290603280067444,
0.507328450679779,
0.5392554998397827,
0.14495261013507843,
-0.509331226348877,
-0.6469259262084961,
0.15086573362350464,
0.0761646255850792,
0.48266515135765076,
-0.8318830132484436,
-0.3135654330253601,
-0.42170825600624084,
-0.5040923953056335,
-0.6108308434486389,
-0.10657554864883423,
0.13559667766094208,
0.09591879695653915,
0.1671214997768402,
0.14742666482925415,
-0.2707636058330536,
-0.7600399255752563,
-0.6951100826263428,
-0.46319177746772766,
0.16232821345329285,
-0.02081570215523243,
0.3838416635990143,
-0.1932515799999237,
0.863735556602478,
-0.20145860314369202,
-0.12532895803451538,
-0.21087278425693512,
0.40193986892700195,
0.2002328634262085,
0.1543309986591339,
0.4870443046092987,
-1.1911299228668213,
-0.13003133237361908,
-0.21509335935115814,
-0.47633400559425354,
0.31660720705986023,
-0.401547908782959,
0.013516463339328766,
0.5030896067619324,
0.20494510233402252,
-0.6496308445930481,
0.6786957383155823,
0.9162638187408447,
-0.3477877974510193,
0.6923880577087402,
0.062277719378471375,
0.47209852933883667,
-1.065553903579712,
-0.29901933670043945,
0.38126155734062195,
-0.3676917254924774,
-0.5661776065826416,
0.1668010950088501,
-0.11018027365207672,
0.15196681022644043,
-0.7209871411323547,
0.7070372104644775,
-0.3142157196998596,
0.10909152776002884,
-0.23879699409008026,
0.21480144560337067,
-0.11308667063713074,
0.13197600841522217,
0.11082068830728531,
0.519163966178894,
0.46516576409339905,
-0.6325817704200745,
0.24295054376125336,
-0.2893684208393097,
-0.5531732439994812,
0.5118287801742554,
-0.4909670054912567,
-0.08414967358112335,
-0.5272243022918701,
0.6956424117088318,
-0.9191102981567383,
-0.497933030128479,
0.5171427726745605,
-0.5462560653686523,
-0.030847201123833656,
-0.03602960333228111,
-0.6375563740730286,
-0.41376543045043945,
-0.12001532316207886,
-0.11576606333255768,
0.7668108344078064,
-0.409403920173645,
1.0288580656051636,
0.337377667427063,
0.14844153821468353,
-0.3525470197200775,
-0.5729582905769348,
0.10927601903676987,
-0.286989688873291,
-0.4163911044597626,
0.1178465411067009,
-0.06819453090429306,
-0.6058643460273743,
-0.02397044003009796,
-0.11602919548749924,
0.14515097439289093,
-0.2643912136554718,
0.26981502771377563,
-0.10908716917037964,
-0.03738206624984741,
-0.07672902941703796,
0.3063586354255676,
0.4567607343196869,
0.1530606746673584,
-0.2643515467643738,
0.29700082540512085,
-0.08930487185716629,
-0.4134434163570404,
-0.6975047588348389,
0.09486106783151627,
0.8444567322731018,
0.30398303270339966,
0.7860376834869385,
0.20455101132392883,
-0.3335908353328705,
-0.5614855885505676,
-0.7617926001548767,
-0.36972954869270325,
-0.4574853479862213,
0.19209334254264832,
-0.28646183013916016,
-0.5443786382675171,
0.25478696823120117,
-0.34899118542671204,
0.1604016274213791,
-0.08600398153066635,
0.5832659602165222,
-0.10129193216562271,
1.194767951965332,
0.4375639259815216,
-0.2445090413093567,
0.2751399576663971,
0.04654455929994583,
0.15769778192043304,
-0.3106374144554138,
-0.2374364584684372,
-0.1650134027004242,
-0.2541378438472748,
-0.2749277353286743,
-0.9840525984764099,
0.33946165442466736,
0.22075681388378143,
0.08568184822797775,
-0.17995257675647736,
-0.0843307375907898,
0.24504844844341278,
0.11060770601034164,
0.18440817296504974,
0.4765940010547638,
0.35005903244018555,
-0.17352519929409027,
-0.08855457603931427,
-0.5684340000152588,
-0.48554185032844543,
0.7536288499832153,
0.6953123211860657,
0.7079005837440491,
0.012857130728662014,
0.4420892596244812,
0.6251922249794006,
1.1184399127960205,
-0.7322465181350708,
0.6167111396789551,
0.18554529547691345,
-0.640693187713623,
-0.04550448805093765,
-0.48853012919425964,
-0.13799868524074554,
0.204124316573143,
-0.2508436143398285,
-0.48675286769866943,
0.23032526671886444,
0.5394935607910156,
-0.12309499830007553,
0.6129502654075623,
-0.4680473804473877,
0.3497736155986786,
0.0249743964523077,
-0.25644248723983765,
-0.7733137607574463,
-0.45271193981170654,
0.5454071164131165,
-0.19307807087898254,
0.7439571022987366,
-0.10618861764669418,
0.06838314980268478,
0.2335050255060196,
0.024571837857365608,
1.134982943534851,
-0.3066460192203522,
-0.2823757827281952,
0.36726114153862,
0.2543966770172119,
0.7812811732292175,
0.12829558551311493,
-0.36925336718559265,
0.2570362389087677,
-0.2865741550922394,
-0.26186034083366394,
-0.5461127758026123,
0.7306614518165588,
-0.8284947276115417,
-0.692374050617218,
-0.5172119140625,
-0.20289671421051025,
-0.08532854169607162,
-0.05446699634194374,
0.13545359671115875,
0.14295262098312378,
-0.5544325709342957,
-0.19072048366069794,
0.704806387424469,
-0.2076801061630249,
0.2323998659849167,
0.6347795128822327,
-0.8569555878639221,
-0.3661842346191406,
0.7176052331924438,
0.21843144297599792,
0.39725086092948914,
0.007498580031096935,
0.39203888177871704,
-0.2612735331058502,
-0.4220189154148102,
-0.41728129982948303,
0.3526531755924225,
-0.5165772438049316,
0.20880328118801117,
-0.6719920039176941,
-0.20677907764911652,
-0.4917200803756714,
-0.22527994215488434,
-0.25889894366264343,
0.00611110869795084,
-0.09842486679553986,
-0.1272733062505722,
0.20642100274562836,
0.8135819435119629,
-0.021011479198932648,
0.6720951199531555,
-0.32889893651008606,
0.4688566029071808,
0.13191358745098114,
0.4203718900680542,
0.09125516563653946,
-0.6071012020111084,
-0.03171493485569954,
0.5432795286178589,
-0.17276205122470856,
-1.0604280233383179,
0.4415651559829712,
-0.3372403383255005,
0.3870726227760315,
0.584237277507782,
0.01692090556025505,
0.5707347393035889,
-0.44334736466407776,
0.8273450136184692,
-0.01361039001494646,
-1.0316362380981445,
0.3917008936405182,
-0.8279227018356323,
-0.04861816018819809,
0.0655503198504448,
0.6243906021118164,
-0.7502237558364868,
-0.5882298946380615,
-0.8134995102882385,
-0.42217057943344116,
0.44576188921928406,
-0.05081850290298462,
0.46629688143730164,
-0.05448439344763756,
0.528300940990448,
-0.2788761556148529,
0.5595998764038086,
-0.8645119667053223,
-0.2572704553604126,
-0.32542577385902405,
-0.046370696276426315,
-0.1358184814453125,
-0.37991154193878174,
-0.13348503410816193,
-0.17969509959220886,
0.8524271249771118,
0.02784689888358116,
0.1818179041147232,
0.3230039179325104,
0.062006875872612,
-0.20189101994037628,
0.2852309048175812,
0.8448636531829834,
0.5378745198249817,
-0.13840252161026,
0.03762279823422432,
-0.1639937162399292,
-0.4490663707256317,
0.22539401054382324,
-0.4633942246437073,
-0.44183745980262756,
0.1355154812335968,
-0.169053316116333,
0.7094559073448181,
0.1929623782634735,
-0.301296204328537,
0.7738338112831116,
0.16976861655712128,
-0.48230013251304626,
-0.5348184704780579,
-0.22322791814804077,
0.35552656650543213,
0.24438144266605377,
0.5568671226501465,
0.2641107439994812,
-0.08224115520715714,
-0.7883473038673401,
0.06707500666379929,
0.37552499771118164,
-0.5031358599662781,
-0.6162225604057312,
0.6822665333747864,
0.13523149490356445,
-0.2157648503780365,
0.22031521797180176,
-0.21400973200798035,
-0.4127905070781708,
0.6439990401268005,
0.6518500447273254,
0.46133357286453247,
-0.3410356342792511,
0.6897180080413818,
-0.036127109080553055,
0.49717292189598083,
-0.615174412727356,
0.34517672657966614,
0.5742456912994385,
-0.8607921004295349,
-0.49024727940559387,
-0.9115850329399109,
-0.2140263170003891,
0.22385342419147491,
-0.33337458968162537,
0.42319950461387634,
-0.6864131093025208,
-0.33373528718948364,
-0.07426199316978455,
-0.05976749211549759,
-0.2825983464717865,
0.16431637108325958,
0.19375509023666382,
1.3876872062683105,
-1.0887281894683838,
0.9870936870574951,
0.781810462474823,
0.05673263967037201,
-0.7885774970054626,
0.6056928038597107,
0.6586365699768066,
-0.6105765104293823,
0.4776967763900757,
-0.008289801888167858,
-0.1598825454711914,
0.20173686742782593,
-0.6810199618339539,
-0.6591693758964539,
0.5388268828392029,
0.14265389740467072,
-0.6657741069793701,
-0.22053392231464386,
0.03206394612789154,
0.6883814930915833,
-0.5699690580368042,
-0.18119019269943237,
0.16647174954414368,
0.6418737173080444,
0.1649257391691208,
-0.6810624599456787,
-0.11029273271560669,
0.11141276359558105,
-0.006766168400645256,
-0.05804251879453659,
-0.8995480537414551,
0.7885074019432068,
-0.10920384526252747,
-0.13416877388954163,
-0.15869303047657013,
0.845276951789856,
0.3341486155986786,
0.5835050940513611,
0.6061626076698303,
0.13576051592826843,
0.29991427063941956,
0.08167650550603867,
1.1561673879623413,
-0.20342771708965302,
0.18309715390205383,
0.821110725402832,
-0.31049644947052,
0.9293164014816284,
0.583965003490448,
0.09118539094924927,
0.7639484405517578,
0.37515127658843994,
0.1429639607667923,
0.20766261219978333,
0.4033055305480957,
-0.3061886727809906,
-0.14587819576263428,
-0.13287590444087982,
-0.16909559071063995,
0.37750640511512756,
0.5193866491317749,
-0.3511652946472168,
-0.1742403507232666,
0.27869269251823425,
0.28117257356643677,
0.376468300819397,
-0.7061924338340759,
0.19386017322540283,
0.20246772468090057,
-0.42789745330810547,
0.06356647610664368,
0.3080391585826874,
0.9426782727241516,
-0.6243599057197571,
-0.09137865155935287,
0.0509016327559948,
0.04277602210640907,
0.03456581011414528,
-0.6791185140609741,
0.3027745485305786,
-0.27522483468055725,
-0.4422619640827179,
-0.5934752225875854,
0.5844107866287231,
-0.3881452977657318,
-0.4482320547103882,
0.37875303626060486,
0.47996559739112854,
0.02392742596566677,
-0.26219573616981506,
-0.5631253123283386,
0.4236491024494171,
-0.11624347418546677,
-0.7007506489753723,
0.3550742268562317,
0.3278224468231201,
-0.35381773114204407,
0.553398847579956,
0.7751448750495911,
0.6304150223731995,
0.08918331563472748,
-0.1341213434934616,
0.8565501570701599,
-0.35876116156578064,
-0.6983514428138733,
-0.7281160354614258,
0.28861960768699646,
-0.28104087710380554,
-0.07056421786546707,
0.8874672055244446,
0.18273106217384338,
0.5873122811317444,
-0.12254496663808823,
0.6938091516494751,
0.14716045558452606,
0.6700682640075684,
-0.37706243991851807,
0.9611080884933472,
-0.6165716052055359,
0.1820705384016037,
-0.5175148844718933,
-0.7436809539794922,
0.01792905665934086,
0.2817923128604889,
-0.40473201870918274,
-0.07278712093830109,
0.10884090512990952,
0.7379083037376404,
0.0074086240492761135,
0.09702791273593903,
0.19500529766082764,
0.7087136507034302,
0.2597849667072296,
0.05460188165307045,
0.8591336011886597,
-0.1244930550456047,
0.30551621317863464,
-0.08847886323928833,
-0.2949002683162689,
-0.40894815325737,
-1.0704423189163208,
-0.6886757612228394,
-0.28466784954071045,
-0.02828977257013321,
-0.7298834919929504,
0.3925328254699707,
1.0533441305160522,
0.7853043675422668,
-0.4257407784461975,
-0.22300805151462555,
-0.1730303317308426,
0.17746345698833466,
-0.3607555031776428,
-0.3598845899105072,
0.008068878203630447,
0.23885592818260193,
-0.7341569066047668,
0.3111085891723633,
0.026182232424616814,
0.2898872494697571,
-0.5431305766105652,
0.01374317891895771,
-0.20612642168998718,
0.7485581636428833,
0.6068695187568665,
0.314073771238327,
-0.8733811378479004,
-0.3410225212574005,
0.05035598576068878,
-0.2933332026004791,
-0.29017210006713867,
0.8076422810554504,
-1.0794312953948975,
0.22660724818706512,
0.29994285106658936,
0.19667083024978638,
0.2227758765220642,
0.3572855591773987,
0.7400947213172913,
-0.6071415543556213,
0.19834114611148834,
0.09070014953613281,
-0.21080246567726135,
-0.01329317782074213,
-0.5036459565162659,
-0.01600281335413456,
0.4780639708042145,
-0.2009560465812683,
-0.9806733131408691,
0.2616448402404785,
-0.7862940430641174,
-0.5283966064453125,
1.3541245460510254,
0.27399590611457825,
-0.30083131790161133,
-0.03504393994808197,
0.02494414709508419,
0.07697008550167084,
-0.6693918704986572,
1.1064403057098389,
0.7725617289543152,
0.025997966527938843,
-0.18481147289276123,
-0.757269561290741,
0.5975141525268555,
-0.001840964425355196,
-0.6988800764083862,
0.0102981673553586,
0.6018974184989929,
0.6295498609542847,
0.18661247193813324,
0.8842045664787292,
-0.08017744868993759,
-0.04143723100423813,
-0.05244184285402298,
-0.15435467660427094,
0.02131723053753376,
-0.6505983471870422,
-0.4618523120880127,
0.28256645798683167,
-0.24217085540294647,
0.5479644536972046
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09490v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09490v2
|
Hyper-CL: Conditioning Sentence Representations with Hypernetworks
| 2024-03-14T15:30:25 | 2024-06-07T02:24:05 |
Young Hyun Yoo, Jii Cha, Changhyeon Kim, Taeuk Kim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
While the introduction of contrastive learning frameworks in sentence
representation learning has significantly contributed to advancements in the
field, it still remains unclear whether state-of-the-art sentence embeddings
can capture the fine-grained semantics of sentences, particularly when
conditioned on specific perspectives. In this paper, we introduce Hyper-CL, an
efficient methodology that integrates hypernetworks with contrastive learning
to compute conditioned sentence representations. In our proposed approach, the
hypernetwork is responsible for transforming pre-computed condition embeddings
into corresponding projection layers. This enables the same sentence embeddings
to be projected differently according to various conditions. Evaluation on two
representative conditioning benchmarks, namely conditional semantic text
similarity and knowledge graph completion, demonstrates that Hyper-CL is
effective in flexibly conditioning sentence representations, showcasing its
computational efficiency at the same time. We also provide a comprehensive
analysis of the inner workings of our approach, leading to a better
interpretation of its mechanisms.
|
[
-0.27534133195877075,
-0.6614041924476624,
0.9171634912490845,
0.2846740782260895,
-0.31166255474090576,
-0.352396696805954,
-0.5348347425460815,
-0.19973431527614594,
0.3582632541656494,
0.501860499382019,
-0.48862260580062866,
-0.6362990736961365,
-0.5050414800643921,
0.01578247919678688,
-0.5046720504760742,
1.0647320747375488,
-0.008308655582368374,
-0.021006127819418907,
-0.5708507895469666,
-0.1336425542831421,
-0.15180277824401855,
-0.6257085204124451,
-0.00762682082131505,
-0.48872998356819153,
0.36409157514572144,
0.41079261898994446,
0.8893733620643616,
0.6983263492584229,
0.6362028121948242,
0.34526753425598145,
0.10701317340135574,
0.02605636790394783,
-0.5877207517623901,
0.15316201746463776,
-0.2867576479911804,
-0.2590559720993042,
0.127538800239563,
0.07048096507787704,
0.5795275568962097,
0.9076849222183228,
-0.05520813167095184,
0.0238947793841362,
0.17616286873817444,
0.7840260863304138,
-1.016672134399414,
0.33126139640808105,
-0.616168200969696,
0.27340245246887207,
-0.010201003402471542,
-0.3332420587539673,
-0.6104599237442017,
-0.10003200173377991,
0.29142481088638306,
-0.9097318053245544,
-0.05983513221144676,
0.34032130241394043,
0.8989760279655457,
0.3448006212711334,
-0.4175429344177246,
0.014846477657556534,
-0.6032103300094604,
0.7966922521591187,
-0.4742277264595032,
0.3643025755882263,
0.1797052025794983,
0.35483992099761963,
0.015011616051197052,
-1.1220388412475586,
-0.6337316036224365,
-0.43752244114875793,
-0.42055997252464294,
0.4120403826236725,
-0.22272782027721405,
0.35881397128105164,
0.2587372958660126,
0.2205323874950409,
-0.6141250133514404,
-0.006410393863916397,
-0.05498024448752403,
-0.3314094841480255,
0.09727535396814346,
0.19715102016925812,
-0.03405718505382538,
-0.23956751823425293,
-0.8886712789535522,
-0.14850686490535736,
-0.4704805910587311,
-0.4901506304740906,
0.170064315199852,
0.29187801480293274,
-0.1181299015879631,
0.47577211260795593,
-0.3866029679775238,
0.7211721539497375,
-0.1844763308763504,
0.2711104452610016,
0.3952540457248688,
-0.15321584045886993,
-0.5664951801300049,
0.007634246721863747,
0.5623639225959778,
0.6481781005859375,
0.46413159370422363,
-0.1531839668750763,
-0.14743848145008087,
0.1152401939034462,
0.1253969967365265,
-0.7594418525695801,
-0.2147267609834671,
0.06419211626052856,
-0.5245397090911865,
-0.05394115671515465,
0.08256201446056366,
-0.5307593941688538,
-0.5476277470588684,
-0.5598506331443787,
0.16419778764247894,
-0.3334168791770935,
0.15923790633678436,
0.22135286033153534,
-0.35887378454208374,
0.0672159269452095,
0.11589861661195755,
-0.388967365026474,
0.32681527733802795,
0.41208264231681824,
0.6129896640777588,
-0.13351458311080933,
-0.3845846354961395,
-0.5829024314880371,
0.519978404045105,
-0.045170173048973083,
0.6399835348129272,
-0.6816279292106628,
0.004408145789057016,
0.5189594626426697,
-0.3296554386615753,
-0.056193917989730835,
-0.5370482802391052,
0.5917788147926331,
-0.4932326674461365,
0.10742481052875519,
-0.05600736662745476,
-0.7105494141578674,
0.09939034283161163,
0.5569607615470886,
-0.686460554599762,
0.5077176690101624,
0.06216348707675934,
-1.2472562789916992,
-0.05634532868862152,
-0.20214487612247467,
-0.3309217691421509,
-0.09693248569965363,
-0.0024009407497942448,
-0.2673793435096741,
-0.04372195154428482,
-0.08240143209695816,
0.6642265319824219,
-0.2987983822822571,
0.008139821700751781,
-0.487569659948349,
-0.4570457339286804,
0.3886178433895111,
-0.15628479421138763,
0.2582421600818634,
0.3025091290473938,
-0.0970999002456665,
0.18643523752689362,
-0.5237144827842712,
0.15806441009044647,
-0.0862569510936737,
-0.32378989458084106,
-0.47124409675598145,
-0.1802441030740738,
0.32684215903282166,
0.2739854156970978,
0.31319957971572876,
-0.5387549996376038,
0.04414741322398186,
-0.5607075095176697,
0.4517071843147278,
0.44733521342277527,
0.1403535008430481,
0.4281022548675537,
-0.048460669815540314,
0.12218665331602097,
0.34962984919548035,
0.021810315549373627,
-0.13374213874340057,
-0.05819251760840416,
-0.924088180065155,
0.13828715682029724,
0.3751150369644165,
0.5941687226295471,
-1.1320340633392334,
0.2467675507068634,
-0.01693832315504551,
-0.033554937690496445,
-0.39087367057800293,
0.19494688510894775,
0.8372666835784912,
0.33754533529281616,
0.7769083976745605,
-0.006007450167089701,
-0.7508178353309631,
-1.1664443016052246,
-0.32578516006469727,
-0.07777892798185349,
0.438050776720047,
0.010446281172335148,
0.42646533250808716,
-0.21483325958251953,
0.552273154258728,
-0.8163431882858276,
-0.33195483684539795,
-0.6360088586807251,
0.08746948093175888,
0.054595947265625,
0.7471027970314026,
0.5007949471473694,
-0.9269746541976929,
-0.4618551731109619,
-0.16919447481632233,
-0.5735209584236145,
-0.05255027860403061,
-0.34694650769233704,
-0.3698612153530121,
-0.06425846368074417,
1.1823625564575195,
-0.8037477135658264,
0.5816823244094849,
0.6072096824645996,
-0.32399672269821167,
0.6886687278747559,
-0.3665273189544678,
-0.07966199517250061,
-0.7901626825332642,
0.06009368225932121,
0.24273619055747986,
-0.5030383467674255,
-0.49286434054374695,
0.22881026566028595,
-0.07738921791315079,
-0.2639620304107666,
-0.5192559957504272,
0.121707983314991,
-0.35696908831596375,
0.13782672584056854,
-0.3396102786064148,
0.5338555574417114,
0.024217024445533752,
0.8122175335884094,
-0.07643221318721771,
0.23281250894069672,
0.44213107228279114,
-0.585671603679657,
0.3586418926715851,
0.03660757094621658,
-0.2335754781961441,
0.6113926768302917,
-0.6029309630393982,
0.041002996265888214,
-0.18199509382247925,
0.565126895904541,
-0.6711554527282715,
0.023528220131993294,
0.23555870354175568,
-0.21640917658805847,
0.046225208789110184,
0.15258455276489258,
-0.5044937133789062,
-0.25754979252815247,
-0.27736490964889526,
0.28873515129089355,
0.36128565669059753,
-0.2989153265953064,
0.2656390964984894,
-0.0012417435646057129,
0.37367796897888184,
-0.6134544014930725,
-1.106155514717102,
-0.018873125314712524,
-0.013245471753180027,
-0.09257723391056061,
0.8582438826560974,
-0.019172783941030502,
-0.3544823229312897,
0.46864867210388184,
-0.07451364398002625,
-0.20946016907691956,
0.021708505228161812,
0.06793487817049026,
-0.010946691036224365,
-0.1471601277589798,
0.1733642816543579,
0.050979893654584885,
-0.37808361649513245,
-0.05768623575568199,
-0.7311252951622009,
0.4693165421485901,
0.056002434343099594,
-0.3662187159061432,
-0.7378947138786316,
0.6245938539505005,
0.5035856366157532,
-0.18897709250450134,
0.7309162020683289,
0.748388946056366,
-0.4045063257217407,
-0.38250231742858887,
-0.26772910356521606,
0.0485529787838459,
-0.4274454712867737,
0.28930172324180603,
-0.3059369623661041,
-0.7818901538848877,
0.08304698020219803,
-0.15643832087516785,
-0.24645479023456573,
0.27033114433288574,
0.59036785364151,
-0.044307634234428406,
0.8640784025192261,
0.807991623878479,
-0.005544411018490791,
0.5824142098426819,
-0.3666594922542572,
0.09542054682970047,
-0.7402172684669495,
-0.19694747030735016,
-0.5465203523635864,
-0.2841273844242096,
-0.5327675342559814,
-0.3139367997646332,
0.2798425555229187,
-0.0851132944226265,
-0.4786210060119629,
0.3662758767604828,
-0.07522743940353394,
0.4851386547088623,
0.6791785359382629,
0.43769803643226624,
0.11610456556081772,
-0.40635329484939575,
-0.5840126276016235,
0.12071549892425537,
-0.6952961683273315,
-0.29291489720344543,
0.6571947336196899,
-0.10255781561136246,
0.3144357204437256,
-0.10285753756761551,
0.8543518781661987,
0.4194439649581909,
0.03875476121902466,
-0.7937800288200378,
0.6383202075958252,
-0.3839494585990906,
-0.25944337248802185,
0.050462596118450165,
-0.43208056688308716,
-0.954559862613678,
0.14833946526050568,
-0.5635712742805481,
-0.7040066719055176,
0.20282883942127228,
0.31114768981933594,
-0.340684711933136,
-0.039181917905807495,
-0.8418052792549133,
1.023696780204773,
0.23113204538822174,
-0.587182343006134,
-0.6094105839729309,
-0.9055158495903015,
0.09042955189943314,
0.4708038866519928,
-0.05294749513268471,
0.03196917101740837,
0.12274942547082901,
0.5405487418174744,
-0.3622273802757263,
0.8003062009811401,
-0.5188494324684143,
0.5009345412254333,
0.20984198153018951,
0.1428001970052719,
0.318937748670578,
-0.010638708248734474,
-0.10697615146636963,
-0.6734787821769714,
-0.12133006006479263,
-0.6569386720657349,
-1.1017385721206665,
0.8904646635055542,
-0.6073099970817566,
-0.5925869941711426,
-0.2419234812259674,
-0.707930326461792,
-0.4837869107723236,
0.21738196909427643,
-0.04356078431010246,
0.533831775188446,
-0.3625721037387848,
0.3351127505302429,
0.47554731369018555,
-0.19874778389930725,
0.3647761642932892,
0.15613895654678345,
-0.17470204830169678,
-0.3536338210105896,
0.7903610467910767,
-0.1706615686416626,
0.3447628617286682,
0.7444584369659424,
0.0989571139216423,
-0.0940198004245758,
-0.6437848210334778,
0.09147283434867859,
0.21915830671787262,
-0.9696236252784729,
-0.3156620264053345,
-0.42810070514678955,
-0.022892817854881287,
-0.2503623962402344,
-0.2647620141506195,
-0.03802819922566414,
-0.4591629207134247,
-0.2536109387874603,
-0.1841040402650833,
-0.030241770669817924,
0.47795701026916504,
0.16825006902217865,
0.3107101619243622,
-0.62921142578125,
0.38298141956329346,
0.11663559079170227,
0.21907174587249756,
-0.11427440494298935,
-0.13469016551971436,
-0.6941096186637878,
-0.23042032122612,
-0.24847133457660675,
-0.7096022963523865,
0.21712584793567657,
0.23121453821659088,
0.6010622978210449,
0.4269445538520813,
0.39046040177345276,
0.5780471563339233,
-0.2839523255825043,
0.6589395403862,
0.29387736320495605,
-1.0279064178466797,
0.41204723715782166,
0.140658900141716,
0.44402340054512024,
0.9191958904266357,
0.5794168710708618,
-0.47761112451553345,
-0.3515857756137848,
-0.596538782119751,
-0.8176809549331665,
0.14402681589126587,
0.3550824224948883,
0.175471693277359,
-0.01340225338935852,
0.35166019201278687,
-0.273283451795578,
0.16597561538219452,
-0.6582860350608826,
-0.12283657491207123,
-0.4270073175430298,
-0.5103885531425476,
-0.1799527257680893,
-0.1152801588177681,
-0.14481736719608307,
-0.2531929314136505,
0.5593169331550598,
-0.20581264793872833,
0.3431474566459656,
0.4893365502357483,
-0.6060743927955627,
0.4868725836277008,
0.256621390581131,
0.15677624940872192,
0.26122424006462097,
-0.16258367896080017,
0.6084314584732056,
0.0343267098069191,
-0.017651833593845367,
-0.18722215294837952,
0.2161346673965454,
0.12286034971475601,
-0.07874322682619095,
0.6227992177009583,
0.8215715885162354,
0.3148738741874695,
-0.6463797092437744,
0.7577126026153564,
0.2632577419281006,
0.09322305768728256,
0.06422492861747742,
-0.14466507732868195,
0.10603173822164536,
0.30232468247413635,
-0.10939712822437286,
-0.040784917771816254,
0.43051087856292725,
-0.8329078555107117,
0.3435336649417877,
0.005656354129314423,
-0.7316280603408813,
-0.029761040583252907,
0.44051405787467957,
0.409373939037323,
0.08629747480154037,
0.8143625259399414,
-0.3512051999568939,
-0.8367149233818054,
0.41140639781951904,
0.8475497364997864,
0.8378691077232361,
0.35326963663101196,
0.13775981962680817,
0.13888105750083923,
-0.0176068302243948,
0.09039417654275894,
0.06710255891084671,
-0.18380890786647797,
-0.9053014516830444,
-0.43494415283203125,
-0.32143595814704895,
-0.5810140371322632,
-0.38164639472961426,
-0.7483760118484497,
0.058040957897901535,
-0.48076537251472473,
-0.1394364982843399,
-0.08615477383136749,
-0.08034182339906693,
-0.7568507790565491,
0.32186341285705566,
0.492084264755249,
1.072935938835144,
-1.0036218166351318,
1.0019583702087402,
0.8391882181167603,
-0.4715921878814697,
-0.45256322622299194,
0.4401339590549469,
-0.07884807884693146,
-0.49856096506118774,
0.7014643549919128,
0.29751333594322205,
-0.3106929063796997,
0.07523048669099808,
-0.6797417998313904,
-0.4632352292537689,
0.870121419429779,
0.533178985118866,
-0.41431108117103577,
0.061812013387680054,
0.008260074071586132,
0.7127417325973511,
-0.49261966347694397,
0.2074940949678421,
0.7210225462913513,
0.7182053327560425,
-0.33645322918891907,
-0.6185864806175232,
0.2581017017364502,
-0.44301214814186096,
0.1675303876399994,
-0.15190674364566803,
-0.6378836035728455,
0.4752900004386902,
-0.10865743458271027,
-0.1440228670835495,
0.10018165409564972,
1.104469656944275,
0.11594737321138382,
0.3419199585914612,
0.615554690361023,
0.841499388217926,
0.5787272453308105,
-0.06569025665521622,
1.2097166776657104,
-0.4944571554660797,
0.3798205852508545,
0.8613343834877014,
-0.23322035372257233,
0.7220085263252258,
0.5582691431045532,
0.25634995102882385,
1.0203372240066528,
0.17319247126579285,
0.2340882569551468,
0.7946794629096985,
0.6980882287025452,
0.018959099426865578,
-0.46030569076538086,
-0.47065529227256775,
-0.06603503972291946,
0.36825183033943176,
0.2993481755256653,
-0.2578565776348114,
-0.18261383473873138,
0.2137637883424759,
0.13454967737197876,
0.682628333568573,
-0.30365270376205444,
0.4991368055343628,
0.17293879389762878,
-0.6119555830955505,
0.5366925597190857,
-0.0035485774278640747,
0.5754636526107788,
-0.5182023644447327,
-0.0884988009929657,
-0.14702866971492767,
0.3038158416748047,
-0.40628671646118164,
-0.8139508962631226,
0.3898005485534668,
-0.18683235347270966,
-0.2601231038570404,
-0.3897077143192291,
0.7344396710395813,
-0.4925837516784668,
0.05034326761960983,
0.4583858549594879,
0.47186195850372314,
-0.010239548981189728,
-0.08337820321321487,
-0.7290114760398865,
0.1525917947292328,
-0.18183621764183044,
-0.21044059097766876,
0.22468417882919312,
0.6392789483070374,
0.2548872232437134,
0.6178193092346191,
0.2933819591999054,
0.036791808903217316,
-0.3549606502056122,
0.3766354024410248,
1.0735241174697876,
-0.7864697575569153,
-0.49165454506874084,
-0.736926794052124,
0.4607681930065155,
-0.27148351073265076,
-0.4979262351989746,
0.5033451914787292,
0.5479646325111389,
0.8361779451370239,
-0.031069329008460045,
0.653668999671936,
0.05621876195073128,
0.16158117353916168,
-1.0119547843933105,
0.33130431175231934,
-0.2500305473804474,
0.10044494271278381,
-0.26137086749076843,
-0.8785160779953003,
-0.5612911581993103,
0.26249733567237854,
-0.2531428635120392,
-0.2639285922050476,
1.3379652500152588,
0.6323109865188599,
-0.11638347804546356,
-0.34956052899360657,
0.1698637753725052,
0.2375013381242752,
-0.02604493498802185,
0.9516558051109314,
0.7966390252113342,
-0.03962422162294388,
0.7275775671005249,
-0.3624798357486725,
0.02131246216595173,
-0.275197833776474,
-0.9497939944267273,
-0.7307383418083191,
-0.7489238977432251,
-0.47562891244888306,
-0.3941109776496887,
0.38630232214927673,
1.1907894611358643,
0.6908997297286987,
-0.6202735900878906,
-0.16513648629188538,
-0.19181549549102783,
0.1780567616224289,
-0.37930959463119507,
-0.2052696943283081,
0.4610373079776764,
-0.5287784337997437,
-0.6806458830833435,
0.28765347599983215,
0.09973882138729095,
-0.19440945982933044,
-0.36791202425956726,
0.03379911556839943,
-0.30321407318115234,
0.2585985064506531,
0.6118056178092957,
-0.04590887203812599,
-0.17329593002796173,
-0.3802303373813629,
-0.3684442937374115,
-0.42594802379608154,
-0.08097519725561142,
1.234774112701416,
-1.052100419998169,
0.2701655626296997,
0.7828318476676941,
0.7869697213172913,
0.8190444111824036,
0.045118141919374466,
0.620310366153717,
-0.6743366122245789,
0.3188891112804413,
0.2894359827041626,
0.5857114791870117,
0.3926318883895874,
0.008197834715247154,
0.14273719489574432,
0.4669911861419678,
-0.3343830406665802,
-0.6045013666152954,
0.5323151350021362,
-1.2314090728759766,
-0.5040652751922607,
1.3302466869354248,
-0.41873303055763245,
-0.12233864516019821,
-0.06291644275188446,
-0.10766319930553436,
0.4012606739997864,
-0.159184992313385,
0.39267516136169434,
0.39363256096839905,
-0.022890383377671242,
0.1381140947341919,
-0.3651019036769867,
0.2756728231906891,
0.592364490032196,
-0.7267037034034729,
-0.005568230990320444,
0.405320942401886,
-0.3141902685165405,
0.15770651400089264,
0.09096145629882812,
0.10890839993953705,
0.22439081966876984,
-0.10481362789869308,
0.07772382348775864,
-0.2372816950082779,
-0.5209423899650574,
-0.062432918697595596,
0.4154786467552185,
-0.06794719398021698,
-0.14949025213718414
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09488v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09488v3
|
Rectifying Demonstration Shortcut in In-Context Learning
| 2024-03-14T15:30:14 | 2024-04-15T04:29:33 |
Joonwon Jang, Sanghwan Jang, Wonbin Kweon, Minjin Jeon, Hwanjo Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) are able to solve various tasks with only a few
demonstrations utilizing their in-context learning (ICL) abilities. However,
LLMs often rely on their pre-trained semantic priors of demonstrations rather
than on the input-label relationships to proceed with ICL prediction. In this
work, we term this phenomenon as the 'Demonstration Shortcut'. While previous
works have primarily focused on improving ICL prediction results for predefined
tasks, we aim to rectify the Demonstration Shortcut, thereby enabling the LLM
to effectively learn new input-label relationships from demonstrations. To
achieve this, we introduce In-Context Calibration, a demonstration-aware
calibration method. We evaluate the effectiveness of the proposed method in two
settings: (1) the Original ICL Task using the standard label space and (2) the
Task Learning setting, where the label space is replaced with semantically
unrelated tokens. In both settings, In-Context Calibration demonstrates
substantial improvements, with results generalized across three LLM families
(OPT, GPT, and Llama2) under various configurations.
|
[
-0.1694200485944748,
-0.5962343215942383,
0.726475179195404,
-0.05983450636267662,
-0.40851861238479614,
0.07321294397115707,
-0.3112780749797821,
0.01810346730053425,
-0.2131093293428421,
0.29337450861930847,
-0.6920441389083862,
-0.4724900424480438,
-0.5790106058120728,
0.005926160141825676,
-0.219330295920372,
1.1838126182556152,
-0.32399407029151917,
-0.08598203957080841,
-0.7459744811058044,
-0.2189311683177948,
-0.6696481704711914,
-0.31574001908302307,
-0.47453126311302185,
-0.6999236345291138,
0.4377804398536682,
0.7587711215019226,
0.4325038492679596,
0.5017391443252563,
-0.10840915888547897,
0.17881980538368225,
-0.10279715806245804,
0.14887163043022156,
-0.5951920747756958,
-0.15575580298900604,
-0.18766911327838898,
-0.49757182598114014,
0.08133590221405029,
0.012937796302139759,
0.789216160774231,
1.0862207412719727,
0.3131123483181,
0.2603021562099457,
0.5648753643035889,
0.44413307309150696,
-0.8040207028388977,
0.12559184432029724,
-0.6676306128501892,
0.025282474234700203,
-0.09720521420240402,
-0.2560943365097046,
-0.591987669467926,
-0.3395518660545349,
0.13763320446014404,
-0.6107149720191956,
0.034109655767679214,
-0.17245671153068542,
0.5438714027404785,
0.454460471868515,
-0.7015326023101807,
-0.08362046629190445,
-0.646460235118866,
1.065609097480774,
-0.7240820527076721,
0.3461081385612488,
0.3177710175514221,
0.5047919154167175,
-0.34306949377059937,
-0.8231109976768494,
-0.3860335052013397,
-0.38799890875816345,
-0.24320867657661438,
-0.09362443536520004,
-0.06280438601970673,
-0.046074286103248596,
0.4888710081577301,
-0.0473080575466156,
-0.08298621326684952,
0.27070876955986023,
-0.1242164671421051,
-0.44248902797698975,
0.05553648993372917,
0.13149859011173248,
0.028743278235197067,
0.162795752286911,
-0.5383317470550537,
-0.3161281645298004,
-1.4151942729949951,
0.32211554050445557,
0.014143706299364567,
0.2041698545217514,
0.026036057621240616,
0.41210517287254333,
-0.15029670298099518,
0.8713775873184204,
0.09584467113018036,
-0.4649849534034729,
0.29413244128227234,
-0.23252570629119873,
-0.3430437445640564,
0.08743052184581757,
0.2473893016576767,
0.26401641964912415,
-0.1803935021162033,
0.08156302571296692,
-0.22155439853668213,
-0.21799622476100922,
-0.23624302446842194,
-0.9262617826461792,
-0.055666759610176086,
-0.1692831814289093,
-0.09130923449993134,
0.0002343075757380575,
-0.09869828075170517,
-0.21971626579761505,
-0.3949323892593384,
-0.49014565348625183,
0.9328046441078186,
-0.1807883083820343,
0.08692274242639542,
-0.1516721546649933,
-0.13247378170490265,
0.12582865357398987,
0.5630238652229309,
-0.4788036048412323,
0.15615184605121613,
0.6922520399093628,
0.5565628409385681,
0.008627106435596943,
-0.35815900564193726,
-0.9606572985649109,
0.43695273995399475,
-0.30640357732772827,
0.34966063499450684,
-0.2593079209327698,
-0.49979302287101746,
-0.042973268777132034,
-0.08970995992422104,
-0.1341233104467392,
-0.7822656035423279,
0.3111952543258667,
-0.23490144312381744,
0.11339179426431656,
-0.32096996903419495,
-0.7921043038368225,
-0.20140835642814636,
0.42960071563720703,
-0.39307528734207153,
0.7272600531578064,
0.046677976846694946,
-0.6243975758552551,
0.5565330386161804,
-0.47856849431991577,
-0.5114657282829285,
-0.06325550377368927,
-0.3230655789375305,
-0.3381848633289337,
-0.09244600683450699,
0.2537709176540375,
0.5484705567359924,
-0.10030567646026611,
0.1877618283033371,
-0.32726189494132996,
-0.5769064426422119,
0.24101632833480835,
-0.5180597305297852,
0.4791796803474426,
-0.13786640763282776,
-0.6537950038909912,
0.24912835657596588,
-0.6713641285896301,
0.015622357837855816,
-0.13551756739616394,
-0.20636141300201416,
-0.3832404315471649,
0.017492899671196938,
-0.3353769779205322,
0.37800857424736023,
0.20928020775318146,
-0.6471899747848511,
0.06315519660711288,
-0.6751199960708618,
0.4306817948818207,
0.7397057414054871,
0.015514967031776905,
0.2803327739238739,
-0.21919482946395874,
0.43999168276786804,
-0.12914833426475525,
0.017942065373063087,
-0.1985410451889038,
-0.11193785816431046,
-0.7812823057174683,
-0.27809852361679077,
0.12228471040725708,
0.09094301611185074,
-0.89654141664505,
0.21032822132110596,
-0.41508474946022034,
-0.3469800055027008,
-0.0017737428424879909,
0.2126171588897705,
0.7185648083686829,
0.9662815928459167,
0.25840842723846436,
-0.036367468535900116,
-0.22058649361133575,
-0.99680095911026,
-0.3479653298854828,
-0.17496249079704285,
-0.27026882767677307,
0.39531630277633667,
0.5439265966415405,
0.00044223322765901685,
1.0402777194976807,
-0.43634146451950073,
-0.5635968446731567,
-0.30268171429634094,
0.09903907030820847,
0.17143087089061737,
0.34950530529022217,
0.3181909918785095,
-0.6814390420913696,
-0.6716254949569702,
-0.10894548147916794,
-0.19420360028743744,
-0.07149507105350494,
0.007200098596513271,
0.16435612738132477,
-0.006415847688913345,
0.7928008437156677,
-0.1566217690706253,
0.7437056303024292,
0.3793720304965973,
-0.08288781344890594,
0.5654990673065186,
-0.27742016315460205,
0.007540544029325247,
-0.8009814620018005,
-0.24505549669265747,
-0.2066650092601776,
-0.44818824529647827,
-0.5560418367385864,
-0.03386720269918442,
0.4436696767807007,
0.06452112644910812,
-0.9065055251121521,
0.8265499472618103,
-0.20899955928325653,
-0.06155088543891907,
-0.4424465298652649,
0.16415435075759888,
0.19097521901130676,
0.4176099896430969,
0.0005692440900020301,
0.9884316921234131,
0.4412132203578949,
-0.6144789457321167,
-0.1494458168745041,
0.12353859096765518,
-0.5039386749267578,
0.3004022538661957,
-0.4296211302280426,
0.09595736861228943,
0.0606895349919796,
0.654416024684906,
-1.2261322736740112,
-0.1837502121925354,
0.07384379208087921,
-0.02989235334098339,
0.18542645871639252,
-0.06100554019212723,
-0.6066556572914124,
-0.14745905995368958,
-0.31038975715637207,
0.8136290907859802,
0.4424460828304291,
-1.022584319114685,
0.4445589780807495,
-0.07929079979658127,
0.19914740324020386,
-0.44867992401123047,
-0.5928518176078796,
-0.22413715720176697,
-0.4220394194126129,
-0.3079908490180969,
0.6634418368339539,
-0.110877625644207,
0.08553928136825562,
-0.4363463222980499,
-0.14586018025875092,
0.24424277245998383,
0.10492824763059616,
0.47632232308387756,
0.01809549704194069,
0.07167637348175049,
0.30187779664993286,
0.11053168028593063,
-0.00133882078807801,
0.03881414979696274,
0.24386276304721832,
0.45214831829071045,
-0.08399660885334015,
-0.7100787162780762,
-0.5423769354820251,
0.16300731897354126,
0.5084043741226196,
-0.043667446821928024,
0.46210977435112,
0.19698791205883026,
-0.43108484148979187,
-0.2189565747976303,
-0.3545570373535156,
-0.2765323221683502,
-0.49431881308555603,
0.560897946357727,
-0.338483065366745,
-0.8322221636772156,
0.2014164924621582,
-0.5613181591033936,
0.023944370448589325,
0.12085998058319092,
0.27858608961105347,
-0.09391986578702927,
1.0229251384735107,
0.7320196032524109,
-0.02720002643764019,
0.4942876100540161,
-0.29006096720695496,
0.21286840736865997,
-1.1845651865005493,
-0.1795833259820938,
-0.37087583541870117,
-0.37280625104904175,
0.12122757732868195,
-0.41886308789253235,
0.6998940706253052,
0.18685954809188843,
-0.43355944752693176,
0.43171343207359314,
-0.004379464779049158,
0.616949200630188,
0.523553729057312,
0.38171836733818054,
0.07178216427564621,
-0.15904146432876587,
-0.43981945514678955,
-0.29742005467414856,
-0.5288692116737366,
-0.4935261309146881,
1.0340659618377686,
0.18015119433403015,
0.5291216373443604,
0.007856965996325016,
0.8603156805038452,
-0.14838847517967224,
0.7460001707077026,
-0.598660409450531,
0.6846898794174194,
-0.11540285497903824,
-0.21073639392852783,
-0.3849780857563019,
-0.20429877936840057,
-0.7331746816635132,
0.2085859179496765,
0.14876164495944977,
-0.9707939624786377,
-0.013691086322069168,
0.5205384492874146,
-0.34462034702301025,
0.17530380189418793,
-0.7683200240135193,
1.0277056694030762,
-0.2651965320110321,
-0.277699738740921,
-0.32903945446014404,
-0.6387275457382202,
0.31525152921676636,
-0.07696409523487091,
0.35793498158454895,
-0.05059482902288437,
0.05449473857879639,
0.5897670984268188,
-0.7354739308357239,
1.1844359636306763,
-0.35168278217315674,
-0.14369221031665802,
-0.012338818982243538,
0.11631723493337631,
0.830858051776886,
-0.22139978408813477,
0.0995376706123352,
-0.5714775323867798,
-0.24008241295814514,
-0.09328024834394455,
-0.8998061418533325,
0.7324485182762146,
-0.4273732900619507,
-0.7682155966758728,
0.03186873346567154,
-0.48813244700431824,
-0.734735369682312,
-0.0793386697769165,
0.2700957655906677,
0.7296813726425171,
-0.27029067277908325,
0.3715416491031647,
0.47686830163002014,
-0.32360032200813293,
0.468782514333725,
0.2893047034740448,
-0.22559313476085663,
-0.25929561257362366,
0.8791286945343018,
-0.11206187307834625,
0.7390293478965759,
0.621461808681488,
0.2667641043663025,
-0.5347203612327576,
-0.30547115206718445,
-0.28179827332496643,
0.0939721092581749,
-1.1969175338745117,
-0.28251901268959045,
-0.2941019535064697,
0.11844693869352341,
-0.13790947198867798,
-0.3223213255405426,
-0.1877278983592987,
-0.3695346415042877,
-0.5682233572006226,
-0.1179526150226593,
-0.01994594745337963,
0.35706445574760437,
0.31921738386154175,
0.5165209770202637,
-0.3569994270801544,
0.12661013007164001,
0.5613428950309753,
-0.03588024526834488,
0.15915092825889587,
-0.7941124439239502,
-0.15949083864688873,
0.2791476845741272,
-0.584010899066925,
-0.7838330864906311,
0.19267958402633667,
0.5525248646736145,
0.5810884237289429,
0.5059226155281067,
0.09445615112781525,
1.1023762226104736,
-0.5804071426391602,
0.8431492447853088,
0.3751697838306427,
-1.0174890756607056,
0.7169591784477234,
0.13921962678432465,
0.48337990045547485,
0.5773028135299683,
0.22074247896671295,
-0.45525750517845154,
-0.4144444167613983,
-0.45178458094596863,
-0.872133731842041,
0.375276654958725,
-0.041850075125694275,
0.19705136120319366,
0.15250666439533234,
0.1539134532213211,
0.3117290139198303,
0.20218251645565033,
-0.78262859582901,
-0.3502824902534485,
-0.175200954079628,
-0.16549184918403625,
-0.40871283411979675,
-0.0961339920759201,
-0.2630492150783539,
-0.5408214926719666,
0.8280110359191895,
-0.44229409098625183,
-0.12963998317718506,
-0.055289749056100845,
-0.4319605529308319,
0.16091570258140564,
0.40528491139411926,
0.7311212420463562,
0.9792492389678955,
-0.015593871474266052,
0.14716501533985138,
0.2711852192878723,
-0.0450018085539341,
0.37277472019195557,
0.09817861020565033,
-0.27126410603523254,
0.02144668437540531,
0.2827584445476532,
1.0654072761535645,
0.8461892008781433,
-0.8391539454460144,
1.0058470964431763,
0.1351202428340912,
-0.1591864377260208,
-0.27618005871772766,
-0.011651284992694855,
-0.054022010415792465,
0.23057152330875397,
0.39153581857681274,
0.002165398793295026,
0.18191920220851898,
-0.44045546650886536,
0.24677538871765137,
0.6416411995887756,
-0.4809063971042633,
-0.13025802373886108,
0.6770167946815491,
-0.09908183664083481,
-0.14163120090961456,
0.354457825422287,
0.1565292924642563,
-0.6324149370193481,
0.6910806894302368,
0.8748145699501038,
0.7590372562408447,
0.22999608516693115,
0.3503325581550598,
0.2668178975582123,
-0.07212940603494644,
0.1372215747833252,
-0.2446228563785553,
-0.3788771331310272,
-0.66633141040802,
-0.5270141363143921,
-0.2514220178127289,
-0.5999731421470642,
0.20820297300815582,
-0.6195693612098694,
0.3336673080921173,
-0.24157869815826416,
0.04992290586233139,
-0.026487747207283974,
-0.11000856012105942,
-0.8051843047142029,
0.2400180548429489,
0.014462742954492569,
0.9849267601966858,
-0.9171843528747559,
1.1285086870193481,
0.6918261647224426,
0.01636899635195732,
-1.029594898223877,
0.22202956676483154,
-0.031842850148677826,
-0.7241453528404236,
1.0114675760269165,
0.5709537863731384,
-0.20475168526172638,
0.055005889385938644,
-0.4946296513080597,
-0.8476658463478088,
1.3135508298873901,
0.7036142945289612,
-0.4967799484729767,
0.2984188199043274,
0.34018781781196594,
0.32141050696372986,
-0.5089271068572998,
0.056799113750457764,
0.4607657790184021,
0.347175270318985,
0.0635460615158081,
-0.9995814561843872,
0.09926458448171616,
0.1680695116519928,
0.008278311230242252,
0.18309904634952545,
-0.45035630464553833,
0.41215452551841736,
-0.23216290771961212,
-0.21211332082748413,
0.2857852578163147,
0.7649015188217163,
0.6030451655387878,
0.2462576925754547,
0.9721171855926514,
0.24459411203861237,
0.50840163230896,
-0.25524991750717163,
1.0225212574005127,
0.13357038795948029,
0.13979582488536835,
1.3903779983520508,
-0.38856497406959534,
0.9084241390228271,
1.0863043069839478,
-0.023920034989714622,
0.4201798737049103,
0.541782557964325,
0.5331308245658875,
0.8746104836463928,
0.27239519357681274,
-0.5158904790878296,
-0.42178091406822205,
-0.13091929256916046,
-0.28350144624710083,
0.20086108148097992,
0.5156329870223999,
-0.3583226799964905,
-0.5494910478591919,
0.59397953748703,
-0.10317672044038773,
0.15295815467834473,
-0.43593236804008484,
0.6599348187446594,
-0.024625984951853752,
-0.7287471890449524,
0.7021148204803467,
-0.15002931654453278,
0.5687702894210815,
-0.5728588104248047,
-0.2778543531894684,
-0.056998346000909805,
0.2745876908302307,
0.10966428369283676,
-0.6791865825653076,
-0.02648489736020565,
-0.37349921464920044,
0.04585558921098709,
-0.4390180706977844,
0.5693500638008118,
-0.5678473711013794,
-0.17717216908931732,
0.17619439959526062,
0.13286282122135162,
0.18431340157985687,
-0.09265653043985367,
-0.3759397268295288,
-0.0705917477607727,
0.19091160595417023,
-0.03750983998179436,
0.6200469732284546,
0.30689072608947754,
-0.2940063774585724,
0.7019045948982239,
0.26738661527633667,
-0.2278382033109665,
0.14780694246292114,
0.08885287493467331,
1.055069923400879,
-0.3478749096393585,
-0.4202063977718353,
-0.767453670501709,
0.40058767795562744,
0.08184073120355606,
-0.41626447439193726,
0.6272473931312561,
0.5889317393302917,
1.230345368385315,
-0.3406539857387543,
0.5936963558197021,
0.2859744727611542,
0.6316912770271301,
-0.6426619291305542,
0.3772711753845215,
-0.7851243615150452,
0.2696540057659149,
-0.33268865942955017,
-0.6926178932189941,
-0.42789778113365173,
0.398163378238678,
-0.42948082089424133,
-0.21683770418167114,
0.6671612858772278,
0.809749186038971,
-0.09319773316383362,
-0.34545600414276123,
0.5479835867881775,
-0.02138255164027214,
0.39968109130859375,
0.6861026287078857,
0.8721505999565125,
-0.24769562482833862,
0.5559910535812378,
-0.7110050916671753,
-0.3100649416446686,
-0.24926316738128662,
-1.2897734642028809,
-0.7342082262039185,
-0.5779957175254822,
-0.4608342945575714,
0.011540139093995094,
-0.013143256306648254,
0.9635661840438843,
0.6154701113700867,
-0.6073604226112366,
-0.21830731630325317,
0.07490020245313644,
0.14109595119953156,
-0.5564067363739014,
-0.17061394453048706,
0.5668531060218811,
-0.14846383035182953,
-0.6979318261146545,
0.6039413809776306,
0.11276353150606155,
0.1994994580745697,
-0.0068001230247318745,
-0.27176523208618164,
0.13123676180839539,
-0.1945815235376358,
0.7067714333534241,
0.4725765585899353,
-1.063295841217041,
-0.6374022960662842,
-0.5221823453903198,
0.14304521679878235,
0.11187240481376648,
0.9291301369667053,
-1.1243555545806885,
0.39491406083106995,
0.19427631795406342,
0.6337816715240479,
0.5533509254455566,
-0.10703296959400177,
0.5309396386146545,
-1.3797262907028198,
0.40690866112709045,
0.11806650459766388,
0.6027539372444153,
0.4403291940689087,
-0.17216432094573975,
0.18109264969825745,
-0.1984536051750183,
-0.42448145151138306,
-0.8691890835762024,
0.41583314538002014,
-0.6680437922477722,
-0.19051533937454224,
1.0927914381027222,
-0.3037797808647156,
-0.1579197645187378,
0.02743743732571602,
-0.44666558504104614,
0.17858542501926422,
-0.06401769071817398,
0.4980386793613434,
0.5081119537353516,
-0.018770309165120125,
-0.07171259075403214,
-0.42094355821609497,
0.5551626086235046,
0.6094117164611816,
-0.5957313776016235,
0.19822882115840912,
0.4838639795780182,
0.40895622968673706,
-0.08810027688741684,
0.5857464075088501,
-0.014469292014837265,
0.40776872634887695,
-0.7579816579818726,
-0.07976418733596802,
-0.13219211995601654,
-0.3820088803768158,
-0.3079937696456909,
0.07934834063053131,
0.32907992601394653,
-0.3699222207069397
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09479v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09479v1
|
Laying the Foundation First? Investigating the Generalization from Atomic Skills to Complex Reasoning Tasks
| 2024-03-14T15:20:54 | 2024-03-14T15:20:54 |
Yuncheng Huang, Qianyu He, Yipei Xu, Jiaqing Liang, Yanghua Xiao
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Current language models have demonstrated their capability to develop basic
reasoning, but struggle in more complicated reasoning tasks that require a
combination of atomic skills, such as math word problem requiring skills like
arithmetic and unit conversion. Previous methods either do not improve the
inherent atomic skills of models or not attempt to generalize the atomic skills
to complex reasoning tasks. In this paper, we first propose a probing framework
to investigate whether the atomic skill can spontaneously generalize to complex
reasoning tasks. Then, we introduce a hierarchical curriculum learning training
strategy to achieve better skill generalization. In our experiments, we find
that atomic skills can not spontaneously generalize to compositional tasks. By
leveraging hierarchical curriculum learning, we successfully induce
generalization, significantly improve the performance of open-source LMs on
complex reasoning tasks. Promisingly, the skill generalization exhibit
effective in cross-dataset and cross-domain scenarios. Complex reasoning can
also help enhance atomic skills. Our findings offer valuable guidance for
designing better training strategies for complex reasoning tasks.
|
[
-0.41301533579826355,
-1.14480459690094,
0.7661435604095459,
-0.3212491571903229,
0.04134909063577652,
0.2095290720462799,
-0.2285933494567871,
-0.18708986043930054,
-0.32326164841651917,
0.2615151107311249,
-0.5591402053833008,
-0.7353675365447998,
-0.5912994742393494,
-0.21324144303798676,
0.1128871962428093,
0.7993488907814026,
0.03255188465118408,
0.0743338018655777,
-0.17405915260314941,
0.049985501915216446,
-0.3449513018131256,
-0.305503785610199,
-0.6396968960762024,
-0.4934512972831726,
0.17258624732494354,
0.5927302241325378,
0.7533749341964722,
0.628612220287323,
0.34758418798446655,
0.2910039722919464,
0.0618535652756691,
0.48677098751068115,
-0.5875775218009949,
-0.1972227543592453,
-0.5436464548110962,
-0.7577109336853027,
-0.5546361804008484,
-0.12708626687526703,
0.43824151158332825,
1.115463137626648,
-0.04118279367685318,
-0.21814319491386414,
-0.32393506169319153,
0.7020662426948547,
-0.6591540575027466,
0.4750858247280121,
-0.696359395980835,
0.0846007689833641,
0.012200764380395412,
-0.20473068952560425,
-0.5202919244766235,
0.04952910915017128,
0.13490453362464905,
-0.8634188175201416,
0.36640167236328125,
0.15216848254203796,
0.6450825333595276,
0.10114786773920059,
-0.5844333171844482,
-0.10946173965930939,
-0.7708410620689392,
1.0378363132476807,
-0.49930185079574585,
0.3697788417339325,
0.40988537669181824,
0.4038989245891571,
-0.06639544665813446,
-0.4260670840740204,
-0.2944376468658447,
-0.4781331419944763,
0.11216258257627487,
-0.03317825496196747,
0.11999616026878357,
0.36344414949417114,
0.3236836791038513,
0.5529598593711853,
-0.6296853423118591,
-0.17629577219486237,
-0.05748515576124191,
-0.1846799999475479,
0.5313780307769775,
0.3572492003440857,
0.45937761664390564,
0.34943994879722595,
0.05449109897017479,
-0.4303869605064392,
-0.6640435457229614,
0.19655591249465942,
0.1131657063961029,
0.4332183599472046,
-0.19931791722774506,
0.6344600319862366,
-0.5439314246177673,
0.5734238028526306,
0.008392059244215488,
0.03374830260872841,
-0.10832877457141876,
-0.4326407313346863,
-0.1285417675971985,
-0.04158793389797211,
0.0974147692322731,
0.014350300654768944,
0.6184293627738953,
-0.3349396288394928,
0.07316922396421432,
0.4248468577861786,
0.4239994287490845,
-0.6023603677749634,
-0.2380802482366562,
0.24221208691596985,
-0.12710557878017426,
-0.08927102386951447,
0.1370452493429184,
0.015332893468439579,
0.23241910338401794,
-0.5854453444480896,
0.5011842846870422,
-0.5663292407989502,
-0.18439039587974548,
0.44464561343193054,
-0.20908866822719574,
0.056307725608348846,
0.3960171043872833,
-1.1203675270080566,
0.5803979635238647,
0.9633076786994934,
0.474509596824646,
-0.009800149127840996,
-0.4191172420978546,
-0.35050979256629944,
0.3621305823326111,
-0.5715813040733337,
0.6004412770271301,
-0.44991442561149597,
-0.05559149011969566,
-0.017957180738449097,
-0.3576558530330658,
0.08213287591934204,
-0.685910165309906,
0.10400817543268204,
-0.630435049533844,
-0.21713314950466156,
-0.23081578314304352,
-0.4390089511871338,
-0.0665285661816597,
0.3609696626663208,
-0.4846096932888031,
0.673324465751648,
0.5109865069389343,
-0.6023370027542114,
0.36979007720947266,
-0.47768527269363403,
-0.41357818245887756,
-0.02876485511660576,
-0.5221611261367798,
-0.2772197723388672,
-0.08016587048768997,
0.21345247328281403,
0.5440273284912109,
-0.26212847232818604,
0.4232896566390991,
-0.37297216057777405,
-0.4316276013851166,
-0.18480800092220306,
0.1530330777168274,
0.657112181186676,
-0.01993652805685997,
-0.5722125768661499,
0.03401956707239151,
-0.5439909100532532,
0.35320159792900085,
0.0733388289809227,
-0.39817169308662415,
-0.3609928786754608,
0.029966088011860847,
-0.4177493751049042,
-0.1262919008731842,
0.002416021190583706,
-0.2277829945087433,
0.45130813121795654,
-0.7428440451622009,
0.19466371834278107,
0.6190646290779114,
0.054050493985414505,
0.8498613834381104,
-0.5473582148551941,
0.22523266077041626,
0.32602471113204956,
-0.32299086451530457,
0.029619932174682617,
-0.45347923040390015,
-0.8686249256134033,
0.035761862993240356,
-0.14794623851776123,
0.6174188256263733,
-0.6901695132255554,
0.46734875440597534,
-0.18873584270477295,
-0.486823171377182,
-0.3131481111049652,
0.18490299582481384,
0.7805626392364502,
0.22852276265621185,
0.7519333362579346,
-0.0654497742652893,
-0.4980884790420532,
-0.9702306389808655,
-0.44572314620018005,
-0.15506963431835175,
-0.061238888651132584,
0.15984602272510529,
0.7308041453361511,
-0.4057668149471283,
0.9054962396621704,
-0.6670454740524292,
-0.14085489511489868,
-0.18056218326091766,
0.41257813572883606,
-0.023948105052113533,
0.6523803472518921,
-0.021418360993266106,
-0.9257731437683105,
-0.07107602804899216,
0.35468050837516785,
-0.9416002035140991,
0.15474601089954376,
-0.10358590632677078,
-0.29215726256370544,
-0.10609576106071472,
0.542663037776947,
-0.5808447003364563,
0.0050981612876057625,
0.07561413198709488,
-0.18171189725399017,
0.5878553986549377,
0.06076803058385849,
0.21917885541915894,
-0.9432640671730042,
-0.0784703940153122,
-0.08808890730142593,
0.19236618280410767,
-0.6953999996185303,
0.47554847598075867,
0.0753653272986412,
-0.041589558124542236,
-0.3437654674053192,
0.5941065549850464,
-0.5660308003425598,
-0.053960539400577545,
-0.07523946464061737,
-0.18044286966323853,
-0.16876037418842316,
0.5311379432678223,
0.057132598012685776,
0.6747493743896484,
0.6365432143211365,
-0.9499644041061401,
0.10927661508321762,
-0.04497762396931648,
-0.26927220821380615,
0.48203766345977783,
-0.4042948782444,
-0.050872668623924255,
-0.12832333147525787,
0.011571436189115047,
-0.908821165561676,
-0.11614751070737839,
-0.15615150332450867,
-0.5070925354957581,
0.25026148557662964,
0.08894634246826172,
-0.20598024129867554,
-0.11509304493665695,
-0.033137086778879166,
0.345536470413208,
0.26309388875961304,
0.04262314736843109,
0.8680369257926941,
0.017809271812438965,
0.07250244170427322,
-0.6510851979255676,
-0.6597189903259277,
-0.5164010524749756,
0.2158406674861908,
-0.7509257197380066,
0.431831419467926,
-0.23854494094848633,
-0.5608882904052734,
0.009047319181263447,
-0.3785687983036041,
-0.27876946330070496,
0.38338708877563477,
0.19741763174533844,
-0.06854118406772614,
-0.5659046769142151,
0.04929152503609657,
0.5540513396263123,
-0.3542194068431854,
0.0557706281542778,
-0.25626489520072937,
0.4834175109863281,
-0.3428281843662262,
-0.6180325150489807,
-0.3715808093547821,
0.40641099214553833,
0.5960693359375,
-0.14228451251983643,
0.5774831175804138,
0.206029012799263,
-0.38189634680747986,
-0.7262045741081238,
-0.5716245174407959,
-0.6767818927764893,
-0.45609742403030396,
0.656617283821106,
-0.7040539383888245,
-1.052181363105774,
0.31505969166755676,
-0.46450769901275635,
0.11123033612966537,
0.38075557351112366,
0.5008836984634399,
-0.028464939445257187,
1.1800824403762817,
0.5279431343078613,
-0.09039617329835892,
0.05412817373871803,
-0.7921573519706726,
0.12125598639249802,
-0.6851511001586914,
-0.26565027236938477,
-0.3499852418899536,
-0.03892258182168007,
0.11076249927282333,
-0.5411444902420044,
0.2336956411600113,
0.22477564215660095,
-0.7900568246841431,
0.04575899988412857,
-0.16991525888442993,
0.4775829017162323,
0.47307872772216797,
0.41720783710479736,
0.4909382164478302,
0.10368360579013824,
-0.29880374670028687,
0.11910443753004074,
-0.6411944031715393,
-0.26453787088394165,
0.9692611694335938,
0.15874764323234558,
0.6259714365005493,
0.0060857441276311874,
0.5879630446434021,
0.18447856605052948,
0.031147459521889687,
-0.8198516368865967,
0.6365736722946167,
-0.0054708183743059635,
-0.5488625168800354,
-0.46096131205558777,
-0.5976670384407043,
-0.7101494073867798,
0.2629832625389099,
-0.21038147807121277,
0.00823360588401556,
-0.27544137835502625,
0.06182108074426651,
-0.11902684718370438,
0.3118194341659546,
-0.4536456763744354,
0.598755419254303,
-0.12181763350963593,
-0.08315015584230423,
-0.4069335162639618,
-0.5601749420166016,
0.3585289716720581,
0.16814573109149933,
0.4299013018608093,
0.04659778252243996,
-0.13505291938781738,
0.3030191957950592,
-0.20789562165737152,
0.9137544631958008,
-0.06713257730007172,
0.04880736395716667,
0.2184213250875473,
0.5140957236289978,
0.23044967651367188,
-0.08494678884744644,
-0.07327953726053238,
-0.038142286241054535,
-0.5765769481658936,
-0.6775577664375305,
-0.6923574805259705,
0.5084396600723267,
-1.1450457572937012,
-0.862979531288147,
-0.034383852034807205,
-0.8281447291374207,
-0.49484848976135254,
0.3672367036342621,
0.3288448452949524,
0.03521043807268143,
-0.32496559619903564,
0.3027542531490326,
1.2476658821105957,
0.6998503804206848,
-0.059175919741392136,
0.32867535948753357,
0.3422786593437195,
-0.30365097522735596,
0.5755379796028137,
0.1766725778579712,
0.6570317149162292,
0.758755624294281,
0.39201560616493225,
0.20645272731781006,
-0.5725694298744202,
-0.5314974784851074,
0.20425507426261902,
-0.7328169345855713,
-0.05540961027145386,
-0.7989373207092285,
-0.23455476760864258,
-0.510936439037323,
-0.7513495683670044,
-0.37275928258895874,
-0.19439402222633362,
-0.269173264503479,
-0.22141563892364502,
0.051348667591810226,
0.37506765127182007,
0.24335743486881256,
0.15578001737594604,
-0.7732821702957153,
0.437899112701416,
0.6855241060256958,
-0.09129142761230469,
0.3747556507587433,
-0.40788954496383667,
-0.40858185291290283,
0.2776558995246887,
-0.27838072180747986,
-0.4905225336551666,
-0.1636786013841629,
0.3529709577560425,
0.8659816384315491,
0.6701014041900635,
-0.015243137255311012,
0.6751149296760559,
-0.43877384066581726,
0.49479320645332336,
-0.10244789719581604,
-1.1757538318634033,
0.7688446044921875,
-0.5524208545684814,
0.3457068204879761,
0.4879121482372284,
0.8411663174629211,
-0.08239897340536118,
-0.5986292958259583,
-0.6759012341499329,
-0.6223400235176086,
0.5411766767501831,
0.13128136098384857,
0.1693437397480011,
0.0926218181848526,
0.4640491306781769,
-0.07912425696849823,
0.21651889383792877,
-0.4468889534473419,
-0.22123931348323822,
0.07904548197984695,
-0.06755278259515762,
-0.10943031311035156,
0.08683288097381592,
-0.4380987882614136,
-0.33864226937294006,
0.5741613507270813,
-0.40364497900009155,
-0.13016104698181152,
0.15727421641349792,
-0.17461344599723816,
-0.3767208456993103,
0.2730501890182495,
0.36468806862831116,
0.644392192363739,
-0.023032352328300476,
0.2550275921821594,
0.2621070146560669,
-0.30528977513313293,
0.3070638179779053,
-0.4940083622932434,
0.04924571141600609,
-0.510733425617218,
0.7390455603599548,
0.49891677498817444,
0.608306884765625,
-0.7188664674758911,
0.4102568030357361,
0.529418408870697,
-0.3818254768848419,
-0.07324254512786865,
0.7260804772377014,
0.35857638716697693,
0.25055211782455444,
0.419838011264801,
-0.13695243000984192,
0.19210240244865417,
-0.9963818192481995,
0.35449886322021484,
0.5279302597045898,
0.10370257496833801,
-0.16194918751716614,
0.3739287555217743,
-0.15144410729408264,
-0.052203238010406494,
0.672888994216919,
-0.019695749506354332,
-0.5151492953300476,
0.9105679392814636,
0.9789447784423828,
0.47415944933891296,
-0.48694467544555664,
0.023190462961792946,
0.38419198989868164,
0.30909934639930725,
-0.2801360785961151,
0.3609265983104706,
-0.3910958766937256,
-1.0229443311691284,
-0.19537895917892456,
-0.1560499519109726,
-0.7624351978302002,
-0.3779776394367218,
-0.5013636946678162,
0.12204676121473312,
-0.7335930466651917,
0.15630711615085602,
-0.16298893094062805,
0.26296722888946533,
-0.3515430688858032,
0.5760196447372437,
0.04060441255569458,
0.6928562521934509,
-1.1496362686157227,
0.6042953133583069,
0.8438662886619568,
-0.5302470922470093,
-0.9726991653442383,
-0.25482049584388733,
0.01618911325931549,
-0.8065188527107239,
0.9519487619400024,
0.13816450536251068,
-0.3604959547519684,
0.2730095684528351,
-0.7960325479507446,
-0.750318706035614,
1.2979296445846558,
0.15299740433692932,
-0.29616042971611023,
-0.3811091482639313,
0.2505947947502136,
0.42349281907081604,
-0.6090964078903198,
0.22640787065029144,
0.28720834851264954,
0.4150041341781616,
0.2619493007659912,
-0.699589729309082,
0.03514562174677849,
-0.2920713424682617,
0.03113318793475628,
0.1817529797554016,
-0.4778769910335541,
1.5871410369873047,
-0.45502376556396484,
-0.1942184567451477,
-0.12152533233165741,
0.7579850554466248,
0.5097395181655884,
0.6506192684173584,
0.27151843905448914,
1.0705958604812622,
0.6978312730789185,
0.07987020909786224,
0.6703498363494873,
0.09479404240846634,
0.28470930457115173,
0.8067764043807983,
-0.3958049714565277,
0.7739855647087097,
0.2112903594970703,
-0.10685782134532928,
0.8709741830825806,
0.304505318403244,
0.14086392521858215,
0.4440454840660095,
0.3743458390235901,
-0.30525895953178406,
-0.6666299104690552,
0.274898499250412,
-0.4621196985244751,
0.13690097630023956,
0.6621410250663757,
0.008029032498598099,
-0.4979695677757263,
0.15374547243118286,
0.18258754909038544,
0.2239631861448288,
-0.6289288401603699,
0.7572976350784302,
0.15678495168685913,
-0.6079269647598267,
0.6231922507286072,
-0.06347876042127609,
0.4293966293334961,
-0.761160671710968,
-0.36586275696754456,
0.0016172161558642983,
0.36328381299972534,
-0.2909163236618042,
-0.6015470027923584,
0.23673486709594727,
-0.4952535033226013,
-0.4269927144050598,
0.24095551669597626,
0.5902079939842224,
-0.2285793423652649,
-0.09414472430944443,
0.4311769902706146,
0.6917643547058105,
-0.0129724545404315,
-0.34857177734375,
-0.5001842975616455,
-0.18008902668952942,
-0.16084028780460358,
-0.10012970864772797,
0.5446009635925293,
0.6870703101158142,
-0.2837716042995453,
0.8093860745429993,
0.9917035102844238,
-0.012748691253364086,
-0.10605211555957794,
-0.2508106827735901,
1.0598869323730469,
-0.7562411427497864,
-0.48458132147789,
-0.7279275059700012,
0.6436582207679749,
0.2208351343870163,
-0.2369406819343567,
0.5214923024177551,
0.5535094141960144,
1.3453103303909302,
-0.34759342670440674,
0.7080090641975403,
0.25624051690101624,
0.16464687883853912,
-0.7045615911483765,
0.5831438302993774,
-0.5649975538253784,
0.053302016109228134,
-0.11177907139062881,
-0.8844706416130066,
-0.43725156784057617,
0.6674901843070984,
-0.24205651879310608,
0.20618221163749695,
1.0013152360916138,
0.7543479800224304,
-0.2028070092201233,
-0.061211127787828445,
0.5538650155067444,
0.24661915004253387,
0.3399534523487091,
0.8430058360099792,
0.5456922054290771,
-0.267423152923584,
-0.03779001906514168,
-0.49290692806243896,
-0.45663440227508545,
-0.4132852554321289,
-0.5891097784042358,
-0.9703633785247803,
-0.4686872065067291,
-0.04146156460046768,
-0.2549903690814972,
0.1679423600435257,
0.7774707674980164,
0.8727703094482422,
-0.74000483751297,
-0.4414076507091522,
-0.49068108201026917,
0.06357044726610184,
-0.48148083686828613,
-0.22690221667289734,
0.23896294832229614,
-0.5452836155891418,
-0.556801438331604,
0.5237700939178467,
0.08089074492454529,
-0.20549102127552032,
-0.11433762311935425,
-0.11305765062570572,
-0.16161490976810455,
0.10143930464982986,
0.6051913499832153,
0.2742499113082886,
-0.6283593773841858,
-0.1654604971408844,
0.03379162773489952,
-0.2934110164642334,
-0.010149870067834854,
0.9963093400001526,
-0.6660299301147461,
0.2105005383491516,
0.4669813811779022,
0.8192857503890991,
0.2157660871744156,
0.02681570127606392,
0.19611197710037231,
-0.3267766237258911,
0.058560580015182495,
0.5530527234077454,
0.16529875993728638,
-0.21342480182647705,
-0.6156889796257019,
0.4419001638889313,
0.3777327537536621,
-0.5202486515045166,
-0.49334338307380676,
0.4564295709133148,
-1.1706427335739136,
-0.44801443815231323,
0.9372336268424988,
-0.08886232227087021,
-0.10149894654750824,
-0.30796706676483154,
-0.17314602434635162,
0.40890026092529297,
-0.22883884608745575,
0.7011420726776123,
0.6653410792350769,
-0.28767281770706177,
0.19421115517616272,
-0.32374855875968933,
0.2385958433151245,
0.6945267915725708,
-0.9478632211685181,
-0.041934121400117874,
0.41742804646492004,
0.2514737546443939,
0.3808453381061554,
0.6489310264587402,
0.029250871390104294,
0.75374436378479,
0.2158537209033966,
0.04288099333643913,
-0.3023069500923157,
-0.8107602596282959,
-0.05843527242541313,
0.42230409383773804,
0.22737811505794525,
0.32382306456565857
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09472v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09472v1
|
Easy-to-Hard Generalization: Scalable Alignment Beyond Human Supervision
| 2024-03-14T15:12:38 | 2024-03-14T15:12:38 |
Zhiqing Sun, Longhui Yu, Yikang Shen, Weiyang Liu, Yiming Yang, Sean Welleck, Chuang Gan
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Current AI alignment methodologies rely on human-provided demonstrations or
judgments, and the learned capabilities of AI systems would be upper-bounded by
human capabilities as a result. This raises a challenging research question:
How can we keep improving the systems when their capabilities have surpassed
the levels of humans? This paper answers this question in the context of
tackling hard reasoning tasks (e.g., level 4-5 MATH problems) via learning from
human annotations on easier tasks (e.g., level 1-3 MATH problems), which we
term as \textit{easy-to-hard generalization}. Our key insight is that an
evaluator (reward model) trained on supervisions for easier tasks can be
effectively used for scoring candidate solutions of harder tasks and hence
facilitating easy-to-hard generalization over different levels of tasks. Based
on this insight, we propose a novel approach to scalable alignment, which
firstly trains the process-supervised reward models on easy problems (e.g.,
level 1-3), and then uses them to evaluate the performance of policy models on
hard problems. We show that such \textit{easy-to-hard generalization from
evaluators} can enable \textit{easy-to-hard generalizations in generators}
either through re-ranking or reinforcement learning (RL). Notably, our
process-supervised 7b RL model achieves an accuracy of 34.0\% on MATH500,
despite only using human supervision on easy problems. Our approach suggests a
promising path toward AI systems that advance beyond the frontier of human
supervision.
|
[
-0.23516060411930084,
-0.5555008053779602,
0.7263516783714294,
0.05388716608285904,
0.3454550504684448,
0.06863167881965637,
-0.5086542367935181,
-0.2879898250102997,
-0.05566305294632912,
0.33303722739219666,
-0.558920681476593,
-0.3424052596092224,
-0.8061621189117432,
-0.06434093415737152,
-0.16554969549179077,
1.3184622526168823,
-0.08311757445335388,
-0.16211295127868652,
-0.41064855456352234,
-0.23051761090755463,
-0.4782593846321106,
-0.41917526721954346,
-0.6794033646583557,
-0.5835527777671814,
0.5196086168289185,
0.36428070068359375,
0.8179373741149902,
0.9557353258132935,
0.9527952671051025,
0.3675708472728729,
-0.08656889200210571,
0.201095849275589,
-0.38691481947898865,
0.028182607144117355,
-0.2481166273355484,
-0.6690161824226379,
-0.7595152854919434,
0.1089937835931778,
0.41623494029045105,
1.1031678915023804,
-0.5011906027793884,
0.06259002536535263,
0.1372327208518982,
0.8592082858085632,
-0.6339086294174194,
0.3138638138771057,
-0.48150327801704407,
0.021596720442175865,
0.14017875492572784,
0.28209689259529114,
-0.4128190875053406,
-0.20402735471725464,
0.01880238763988018,
-0.9505162835121155,
0.4020449221134186,
-0.07574372738599777,
0.8199203014373779,
0.8451257944107056,
-0.36795854568481445,
-0.26508888602256775,
-0.8848114013671875,
0.9617875814437866,
-0.19632910192012787,
0.1739124208688736,
0.3140062391757965,
0.7394876480102539,
-0.16605164110660553,
-0.7366970181465149,
-0.15035167336463928,
-0.1769608110189438,
-0.1625048667192459,
-0.10267623513936996,
-0.23679688572883606,
0.1791609227657318,
0.6761186718940735,
0.1677161455154419,
-0.18373344838619232,
0.08975550532341003,
-0.3108042776584625,
-0.18232367932796478,
0.7315662503242493,
0.2456735372543335,
0.17684201896190643,
0.0889645367860794,
-0.10843101888895035,
-0.38318753242492676,
-0.5027191042900085,
0.3244006931781769,
0.13841107487678528,
0.32830411195755005,
0.14407290518283844,
0.5224793553352356,
-0.32639628648757935,
0.6629836559295654,
0.3762134611606598,
0.11231178790330887,
0.17952296137809753,
-0.26695671677589417,
-0.019293684512376785,
-0.21979139745235443,
0.5130059719085693,
0.021279847249388695,
0.1545298993587494,
-0.19431214034557343,
-0.34040939807891846,
0.2619437873363495,
0.6261184215545654,
-0.40526634454727173,
-0.35232165455818176,
0.07664467394351959,
-0.2634534537792206,
-0.18137669563293457,
0.04431913048028946,
-0.46090734004974365,
-0.5501322746276855,
-0.49510708451271057,
0.329999178647995,
-0.2665516436100006,
-0.028132082894444466,
-0.05422959104180336,
0.018604544922709465,
0.3300469219684601,
0.5610240697860718,
-1.1054500341415405,
0.32643115520477295,
1.1715376377105713,
0.616712749004364,
-0.1544376015663147,
-0.39883357286453247,
-0.7472497820854187,
0.2429809719324112,
-0.42507824301719666,
0.5386694073677063,
-0.3549444377422333,
-0.019627433270215988,
-0.18319426476955414,
-0.14467890560626984,
0.11766862124204636,
-0.5560063123703003,
0.6086934804916382,
-0.27180707454681396,
0.04788000509142876,
-0.0018933429382741451,
-0.5226181149482727,
0.0034255918581038713,
0.39585378766059875,
-0.6443659663200378,
0.7077449560165405,
0.18682453036308289,
-0.2822818458080292,
0.6489308476448059,
-0.834418535232544,
-0.280062198638916,
-0.16899695992469788,
-0.18590833246707916,
-0.6734344959259033,
0.20559264719486237,
0.4549992084503174,
0.43853113055229187,
-0.18798497319221497,
0.5944065451622009,
-0.3762052357196808,
-0.42898479104042053,
-0.1122947484254837,
-0.2752512991428375,
0.6248780488967896,
0.17404700815677643,
-0.6230491995811462,
0.40434911847114563,
-0.6661112308502197,
0.2040044218301773,
-0.050049565732479095,
-0.41834694147109985,
-0.3458561599254608,
0.11107168346643448,
-0.43459489941596985,
-0.038141027092933655,
0.4036460816860199,
-0.25792089104652405,
0.6659269332885742,
-0.40061357617378235,
0.38473471999168396,
0.922763466835022,
-0.47623395919799805,
0.8098083138465881,
-0.29173848032951355,
0.47115573287010193,
-0.2684593200683594,
0.13044406473636627,
0.02924562804400921,
-0.3872477412223816,
-0.8329914808273315,
-0.3717227876186371,
0.4367334544658661,
0.6547659039497375,
-0.6696100234985352,
0.5793197154998779,
-0.46474000811576843,
-0.4970027506351471,
-0.7233397960662842,
0.5142183303833008,
0.6875450611114502,
0.42904147505760193,
0.4703591763973236,
-0.09076705574989319,
-0.29047417640686035,
-0.9903037548065186,
-0.41805747151374817,
-0.12406313419342041,
-0.44384685158729553,
0.18675260245800018,
0.34734588861465454,
-0.2902049720287323,
0.8266812562942505,
-0.7178173661231995,
-0.3448851704597473,
-0.2158605456352234,
0.4103885591030121,
0.353718638420105,
0.8296249508857727,
0.06265057623386383,
-0.8133514523506165,
-0.2822459042072296,
0.20081083476543427,
-0.9489637613296509,
0.0016965464456006885,
-0.07435496896505356,
-0.1264527589082718,
0.01991232857108116,
0.5489881038665771,
-0.5750460624694824,
0.43082675337791443,
0.05756442993879318,
-0.34940311312675476,
0.12808580696582794,
-0.3956791162490845,
-0.08253703266382217,
-0.7584421634674072,
0.00343882548622787,
0.18676920235157013,
-0.33524778485298157,
-0.6761460900306702,
0.3525712192058563,
0.1431264728307724,
-0.14265865087509155,
-0.11723172664642334,
0.11219450831413269,
-0.36697670817375183,
-0.05990559607744217,
-0.08347465842962265,
-0.28884169459342957,
-0.212294802069664,
0.8293325901031494,
-0.05429847165942192,
0.527772068977356,
0.44729378819465637,
-0.4608384370803833,
0.4382437765598297,
0.08102960139513016,
-0.14649249613285065,
0.8732666969299316,
-0.7584196329116821,
0.13188686966896057,
-0.23253096640110016,
0.44293639063835144,
-0.8342409133911133,
-0.3354673683643341,
0.1553439050912857,
-0.3045380115509033,
0.3518725037574768,
-0.16797591745853424,
-0.08568336814641953,
-0.20729508996009827,
-0.15347743034362793,
0.6457234025001526,
0.46929922699928284,
-0.644523561000824,
0.6731323003768921,
0.15889550745487213,
0.03396797180175781,
-0.6639750003814697,
-0.4780271649360657,
-0.020343804731965065,
-0.36443641781806946,
-0.5307782888412476,
0.2905137538909912,
0.15064311027526855,
-0.31585583090782166,
-0.01678621582686901,
-0.0814560204744339,
-0.14959323406219482,
0.32679709792137146,
0.4268416464328766,
0.3255884349346161,
-0.005818699486553669,
0.22453022003173828,
0.01780538260936737,
-0.37575584650039673,
-0.016527103260159492,
-0.20007357001304626,
0.14730684459209442,
-0.5172796249389648,
-0.5623114109039307,
-0.5507369041442871,
0.2761395573616028,
0.30065369606018066,
-0.02811315469443798,
0.4708500802516937,
0.587001621723175,
-0.49592325091362,
-0.010548422113060951,
-0.4989679157733917,
-0.13317908346652985,
-0.4883626103401184,
0.31949958205223083,
-0.4691815972328186,
-0.8588221073150635,
0.17204366624355316,
-0.1870735138654709,
0.21939508616924286,
0.5477388501167297,
0.14991629123687744,
-0.23085153102874756,
1.5679826736450195,
0.6927285194396973,
-0.1136639192700386,
0.3248917758464813,
-0.4886738955974579,
-0.0415545217692852,
-0.7464131116867065,
-0.14470475912094116,
-0.34717389941215515,
-0.624147891998291,
-0.7847064733505249,
-0.33005794882774353,
0.39906948804855347,
0.2110612839460373,
-0.5518320798873901,
0.3361934721469879,
-0.8465799689292908,
0.5180203914642334,
0.7102306485176086,
0.1262255162000656,
0.1917322278022766,
-0.08469831198453903,
0.3968658745288849,
-0.0003071017563343048,
-0.6792441606521606,
-0.3450271487236023,
1.271920084953308,
0.40324780344963074,
0.7084348201751709,
0.12265646457672119,
0.9444147944450378,
0.5387715697288513,
0.5978388786315918,
-0.7935941219329834,
0.41465550661087036,
-0.12380727380514145,
-0.6006125807762146,
-0.7758758664131165,
-0.5334916114807129,
-1.0796458721160889,
0.21400733292102814,
-0.23689520359039307,
-0.581842839717865,
0.16643227636814117,
0.3976256847381592,
-0.40521541237831116,
0.22689397633075714,
-0.8823556900024414,
0.9135875105857849,
-0.16502569615840912,
-0.3418450355529785,
-0.26839569211006165,
-0.6589826345443726,
0.32819560170173645,
0.15985795855522156,
0.2660318613052368,
0.1257472187280655,
-0.18732666969299316,
0.6962708830833435,
-0.6958414316177368,
0.7506401538848877,
-0.4646375775337219,
-0.006679032929241657,
0.12816296517848969,
-0.1059083640575409,
0.6628174781799316,
-0.21441583335399628,
0.18768174946308136,
0.030382497236132622,
-0.19483253359794617,
-0.8276563882827759,
-1.0956681966781616,
0.5556813478469849,
-0.8798251748085022,
-0.8519935607910156,
-0.40002524852752686,
-0.6818121075630188,
-0.29325759410858154,
-0.04855078458786011,
-0.08820681273937225,
0.03669982776045799,
0.030257634818553925,
0.12652316689491272,
0.5874328017234802,
0.16567780077457428,
0.19144226610660553,
0.028734013438224792,
-0.030047625303268433,
-0.3764847218990326,
1.2247849702835083,
-0.010859298519790173,
0.11873301863670349,
0.2752183675765991,
0.18569882214069366,
-0.1060371920466423,
-0.33003005385398865,
-0.46828123927116394,
0.074612095952034,
-0.5230756402015686,
-0.20077656209468842,
-0.35456472635269165,
0.005780885461717844,
-0.4143061935901642,
-0.5194805264472961,
-0.3837110698223114,
-0.6584714651107788,
-0.25963282585144043,
-0.07332218438386917,
-0.0533897839486599,
0.8826212286949158,
-0.27423325181007385,
0.3055866062641144,
-0.3683701753616333,
0.35264959931373596,
0.7678436636924744,
0.32070761919021606,
-0.05497187376022339,
-0.3353038430213928,
-0.1154508888721466,
0.03453276678919792,
-0.5219332575798035,
-0.3774021863937378,
0.05980417877435684,
0.12520119547843933,
0.32743045687675476,
0.48320335149765015,
-0.14829708635807037,
0.8109846115112305,
-0.441203773021698,
0.43019992113113403,
0.35562431812286377,
-0.9936539530754089,
0.5456503033638,
-0.20670437812805176,
0.13631433248519897,
0.7092660665512085,
0.26049143075942993,
-0.22121034562587738,
-0.23187147080898285,
-0.6238680481910706,
-0.8441603183746338,
0.7513251900672913,
0.08500033617019653,
-0.07796746492385864,
0.3493676781654358,
0.6613697409629822,
0.04523899406194687,
0.11555711925029755,
-0.7036628723144531,
-0.027896558865904808,
-0.22410430014133453,
-0.3513018488883972,
-0.2924101650714874,
0.05210958421230316,
-0.2696550786495209,
-0.4119512438774109,
0.5601826310157776,
-0.29137709736824036,
0.10515140742063522,
-0.13927322626113892,
-0.1236565038561821,
-0.07769361883401871,
0.45458984375,
0.4660433530807495,
0.5560598969459534,
-0.1463494896888733,
0.12090238183736801,
0.20514312386512756,
0.015185038559138775,
0.5932275652885437,
0.17646613717079163,
-0.17798854410648346,
-0.6163362860679626,
0.5641932487487793,
0.8031625151634216,
0.11396612226963043,
-0.4659149646759033,
0.5268721580505371,
0.17001686990261078,
-0.27849000692367554,
-0.22663678228855133,
0.3577435612678528,
-0.027850592508912086,
0.4174598455429077,
0.3908540606498718,
-0.048385653644800186,
0.12592697143554688,
-0.5056427121162415,
0.17870540916919708,
0.6495022177696228,
-0.616858720779419,
-0.19250941276550293,
0.7791768312454224,
0.1735532432794571,
-0.62945556640625,
0.7701619267463684,
-0.31092751026153564,
-0.32047486305236816,
0.7945910692214966,
0.35301101207733154,
0.5968522429466248,
-0.08598124980926514,
0.1739456206560135,
0.28151461482048035,
0.1344325989484787,
-0.3980277180671692,
-0.11346352100372314,
-0.30117735266685486,
-0.5148124694824219,
-0.6198832392692566,
-0.3343876302242279,
-0.6338436007499695,
-0.21648430824279785,
-0.957214891910553,
0.09770677238702774,
-0.6529553532600403,
-0.21293148398399353,
0.15601395070552826,
-0.03999462351202965,
-0.6977546215057373,
0.24671590328216553,
-0.09609724581241608,
0.46673086285591125,
-0.8135747909545898,
0.4954434335231781,
0.8293215036392212,
-0.3500059247016907,
-0.9213098287582397,
-0.2321242243051529,
-0.12222172319889069,
-0.8615050911903381,
0.7237837314605713,
0.16080142557621002,
0.21495477855205536,
-0.12278157472610474,
-0.8118811249732971,
-0.7283679842948914,
1.2003955841064453,
0.3477020263671875,
-0.5697375535964966,
-0.4048464000225067,
-0.0014836288755759597,
0.7720432877540588,
-0.30473753809928894,
0.18842384219169617,
0.7540647983551025,
0.6320075392723083,
-0.0120714595541358,
-0.8136566281318665,
0.022075919434428215,
-0.21166132390499115,
-0.099967822432518,
0.4937998354434967,
-0.5867817401885986,
0.7811112403869629,
-0.33599990606307983,
0.10329847782850266,
-0.005226991139352322,
0.8866642713546753,
0.18766389787197113,
0.6196291446685791,
0.7596805691719055,
0.8412769436836243,
0.7532590627670288,
-0.2470889687538147,
1.120412826538086,
0.16855084896087646,
0.36590492725372314,
1.1892757415771484,
-0.029902037233114243,
0.5684430599212646,
0.5448925495147705,
-0.4555414319038391,
0.66045743227005,
0.31227895617485046,
0.010614181868731976,
0.2644366919994354,
0.4218970835208893,
0.055188290774822235,
-0.6618813872337341,
-0.07671639323234558,
-0.07781936228275299,
0.45252102613449097,
0.18511563539505005,
-0.04922807589173317,
-0.0937361791729927,
-0.017045803368091583,
-0.2686045467853546,
0.3385637402534485,
-0.5147929787635803,
0.934303879737854,
-0.19365209341049194,
-0.9838801622390747,
0.5630913376808167,
-0.184168741106987,
0.7216892838478088,
-0.3576476573944092,
-0.318814754486084,
0.030190512537956238,
0.1516331285238266,
-0.28789570927619934,
-0.6394965052604675,
0.29623275995254517,
0.054398681968450546,
-0.30935952067375183,
-0.3532622456550598,
0.5057878494262695,
-0.2955303192138672,
-0.6434096693992615,
-0.06578610092401505,
0.6003576517105103,
0.043651457875967026,
0.04483100399374962,
-0.5691083073616028,
-0.34020739793777466,
-0.0771283209323883,
-0.19348658621311188,
0.4526839256286621,
0.29523801803588867,
-0.36399176716804504,
0.8044050335884094,
0.5299414396286011,
0.008378725498914719,
-0.0911233052611351,
-0.19017623364925385,
0.781237781047821,
-0.7995234727859497,
-0.33797281980514526,
-0.768802285194397,
0.43109893798828125,
-0.16744959354400635,
-0.1290695071220398,
0.24124732613563538,
0.2691211700439453,
0.8230361938476562,
0.20646417140960693,
0.7215292453765869,
-0.11158902943134308,
0.4987674057483673,
-0.2256026566028595,
0.49140769243240356,
-0.6920756101608276,
0.2574768364429474,
-0.29810595512390137,
-0.8380632400512695,
-0.46904492378234863,
0.6396719813346863,
-0.4499683678150177,
-0.0013722507283091545,
0.36134740710258484,
0.49212417006492615,
-0.14033766090869904,
-0.4307129383087158,
0.2528027296066284,
-0.20064345002174377,
0.5355458855628967,
0.8714377880096436,
0.8641771674156189,
-0.08733797818422318,
0.823917806148529,
-0.3584608733654022,
-0.3764991760253906,
-0.09222663938999176,
-0.7624942064285278,
-0.6066213846206665,
-0.4181692898273468,
-0.27535730600357056,
-0.36183130741119385,
0.04407336935400963,
0.9278117418289185,
0.49699199199676514,
-0.8207571506500244,
-0.21999995410442352,
-0.26244795322418213,
0.45115986466407776,
-0.640382707118988,
-0.20948423445224762,
0.5027035474777222,
-0.5295562148094177,
-0.9262198805809021,
0.24147965013980865,
0.08620509505271912,
-0.17917191982269287,
-0.21485131978988647,
-0.2445525974035263,
0.0833086371421814,
-0.13584932684898376,
0.2044759839773178,
0.5509830713272095,
-0.6814541220664978,
-0.4550040364265442,
-0.2240762561559677,
-0.18095874786376953,
0.10262436419725418,
0.8540144562721252,
-0.7409219741821289,
0.3304155170917511,
0.1972704529762268,
0.9233753085136414,
0.38066694140434265,
0.2949003577232361,
0.5612994432449341,
-0.5277935862541199,
-0.07950568944215775,
0.1463862955570221,
0.3310078978538513,
0.3516339063644409,
-0.2810789942741394,
0.856454074382782,
0.05749987065792084,
-0.6343322992324829,
-0.93780517578125,
0.3590720295906067,
-0.8470043540000916,
-0.051775865256786346,
0.8437142372131348,
-0.41554588079452515,
-0.18925411999225616,
0.08865338563919067,
-0.1476166993379593,
0.4068390727043152,
-0.4057352840900421,
1.2760140895843506,
0.6356581449508667,
-0.4561653435230255,
0.21928922832012177,
-0.0989418551325798,
0.5244084596633911,
0.9302353858947754,
-0.7889118790626526,
0.020564323291182518,
0.5827303528785706,
0.06479411572217941,
0.5276632308959961,
0.4554004967212677,
0.3286055624485016,
0.4946728050708771,
-0.2646738886833191,
0.05139879137277603,
-0.19197672605514526,
-0.4146610200405121,
-0.6065953969955444,
0.48405763506889343,
0.18952545523643494,
-0.09818213433027267
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09409v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09409v1
|
"Like a Nesting Doll": Analyzing Recursion Analogies Generated by CS Students using Large Language Models
| 2024-03-14T14:01:26 | 2024-03-14T14:01:26 |
Seth Bernstein, Paul Denny, Juho Leinonen, Lauren Kan, Arto Hellas, Matt Littlefield, Sami Sarsa, Stephen MacNeil
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Grasping complex computing concepts often poses a challenge for students who
struggle to anchor these new ideas to familiar experiences and understandings.
To help with this, a good analogy can bridge the gap between unfamiliar
concepts and familiar ones, providing an engaging way to aid understanding.
However, creating effective educational analogies is difficult even for
experienced instructors. We investigate to what extent large language models
(LLMs), specifically ChatGPT, can provide access to personally relevant
analogies on demand. Focusing on recursion, a challenging threshold concept, we
conducted an investigation analyzing the analogies generated by more than 350
first-year computing students. They were provided with a code snippet and
tasked to generate their own recursion-based analogies using ChatGPT,
optionally including personally relevant topics in their prompts. We observed a
great deal of diversity in the analogies produced with student-prescribed
topics, in contrast to the otherwise generic analogies, highlighting the value
of student creativity when working with LLMs. Not only did students enjoy the
activity and report an improved understanding of recursion, but they described
more easily remembering analogies that were personally and culturally relevant.
|
[
-0.29786205291748047,
-0.9412400126457214,
0.4766136705875397,
0.15551036596298218,
-0.12378651648759842,
0.5223228931427002,
-0.08709012717008591,
-0.27603718638420105,
-0.21073845028877258,
0.05761715769767761,
-0.7847944498062134,
-0.1797320395708084,
-0.2549179196357727,
-0.06049636751413345,
-0.7391897439956665,
0.8779587745666504,
0.07595489919185638,
-0.14821140468120575,
-0.5660266876220703,
0.5275160074234009,
-0.5702375769615173,
-0.6125383973121643,
-0.6473682522773743,
-0.34112653136253357,
0.3541468679904938,
0.3051813840866089,
0.7266251444816589,
0.6852544546127319,
0.37258219718933105,
0.4209047257900238,
0.10004328936338425,
-0.45861685276031494,
-0.7797815799713135,
0.17768898606300354,
-0.1981884390115738,
-0.4767393171787262,
-0.01059652492403984,
0.1631748229265213,
0.5916503667831421,
1.0131371021270752,
-0.21069419384002686,
0.325497567653656,
0.232908695936203,
0.8065122961997986,
-0.39701178669929504,
0.3796609044075012,
-0.835645318031311,
0.36349672079086304,
-0.018607785925269127,
-0.19470465183258057,
-0.30838844180107117,
-0.43705621361732483,
0.3295707702636719,
-0.6109417676925659,
0.39341631531715393,
-0.334943950176239,
0.7581804990768433,
-0.17755825817584991,
0.009232749231159687,
-0.5444435477256775,
-0.7295034527778625,
0.8172730207443237,
-0.46315935254096985,
0.3226454257965088,
-0.06665690988302231,
0.4546539783477783,
-0.47142452001571655,
-0.6831422448158264,
-0.6729023456573486,
-0.005100550130009651,
0.02361871674656868,
0.01364213414490223,
-0.5419320464134216,
-0.2514110803604126,
0.4006679058074951,
0.5092247128486633,
-0.5729848742485046,
-0.14365291595458984,
-0.41779986023902893,
0.0600888729095459,
0.24207395315170288,
0.41871377825737,
0.5611493587493896,
-0.1940043866634369,
-0.20094671845436096,
-0.09741409868001938,
-0.7081915736198425,
0.09023288637399673,
0.5494687557220459,
0.38126152753829956,
-0.11067678034305573,
0.3703547716140747,
-0.0034306298475712538,
0.7344989776611328,
-0.05690715089440346,
0.015497390180826187,
0.29004135727882385,
0.1434044986963272,
-0.1018582209944725,
-0.29770660400390625,
0.3502886891365051,
0.24432596564292908,
0.7982388734817505,
-0.29518017172813416,
0.1054205521941185,
0.28792569041252136,
0.3089357018470764,
-0.819454550743103,
-0.386519193649292,
0.03134855628013611,
-0.44332432746887207,
-0.3564985692501068,
-0.05366105958819389,
-0.8675488233566284,
-0.463065505027771,
-0.556806206703186,
0.41121792793273926,
-0.14085453748703003,
-0.44245752692222595,
0.07669101655483246,
-0.08359335362911224,
0.35392045974731445,
0.3386051058769226,
-1.0300629138946533,
0.6091194152832031,
0.9749119281768799,
0.9246972799301147,
-0.33663517236709595,
-0.3065579831600189,
-0.1763327568769455,
-0.2697570025920868,
-0.32645151019096375,
0.584050178527832,
-0.9284201264381409,
-0.5701080560684204,
0.15080033242702484,
0.007719801738858223,
-0.10145535320043564,
-0.605232298374176,
-0.039867740124464035,
-0.2885441780090332,
0.28836020827293396,
0.17807233333587646,
-0.5546033978462219,
-0.033889371901750565,
0.35630691051483154,
-0.3406625986099243,
0.8222960233688354,
0.19746758043766022,
-0.37518057227134705,
-0.26797452569007874,
-0.40276867151260376,
-0.2808886468410492,
-0.10550430417060852,
-0.544744074344635,
-0.0017583150183781981,
0.23798885941505432,
-0.13985233008861542,
0.621791660785675,
-0.22909022867679596,
-0.17565393447875977,
-0.14702993631362915,
-0.39316457509994507,
0.5596678853034973,
-0.2537941634654999,
0.6726216673851013,
0.2659074068069458,
-0.10567053407430649,
-0.09214946627616882,
-0.5932525992393494,
0.10327927023172379,
0.352008193731308,
-0.09095684438943863,
-0.29804661870002747,
0.027730772271752357,
-0.24718588590621948,
0.13855715095996857,
0.19171962141990662,
-0.40457242727279663,
0.2635003924369812,
-0.522193193435669,
0.8516913652420044,
0.8727154731750488,
0.035306233912706375,
0.2677299380302429,
-0.7016538381576538,
0.7947035431861877,
-0.1692834049463272,
-0.19413012266159058,
-0.5086548924446106,
-0.40809109807014465,
-0.6913449168205261,
-0.008717204444110394,
-0.07380348443984985,
0.3080493211746216,
-0.43710288405418396,
-0.3469228446483612,
-0.2720619738101959,
-0.6836287379264832,
-0.38936561346054077,
-0.01957201398909092,
0.22277981042861938,
0.4612792134284973,
-0.10901239514350891,
-0.41862258315086365,
-0.5361054539680481,
-0.7032012939453125,
-0.06162247434258461,
-0.1100478321313858,
-0.4443092346191406,
0.3652454912662506,
0.3981323540210724,
0.0461597740650177,
0.9122825264930725,
-0.7134912610054016,
-0.09618290513753891,
0.24379482865333557,
0.1760275810956955,
0.6448396444320679,
0.5440136790275574,
0.29873979091644287,
-0.6802931427955627,
-0.38626953959465027,
0.007099498063325882,
-0.42129769921302795,
0.046973273158073425,
-0.4574824571609497,
-0.2142915278673172,
-0.07592534273862839,
0.6705375909805298,
-0.5178889632225037,
0.23155105113983154,
0.5059781670570374,
0.06888647377490997,
0.8825163841247559,
-0.00496585201472044,
0.07667064666748047,
-0.8948865532875061,
-0.02998403273522854,
-0.08622997254133224,
-0.11237353086471558,
-0.5039198398590088,
0.42160266637802124,
-0.29109838604927063,
-0.5378715991973877,
-0.5379488468170166,
0.32311829924583435,
-0.5791563987731934,
-0.2864511013031006,
-0.20688685774803162,
0.5351969003677368,
-0.27262958884239197,
0.3920704424381256,
0.16785955429077148,
0.788273274898529,
0.699901819229126,
-0.39175868034362793,
0.2856951355934143,
-0.021920135244727135,
-0.4385293424129486,
0.5218392014503479,
-0.6491761207580566,
0.3237207531929016,
0.08566683530807495,
0.17217206954956055,
-1.2492402791976929,
-0.03368983045220375,
-0.06716659665107727,
-0.6132198572158813,
0.05481209605932236,
-0.35576385259628296,
-0.42156410217285156,
-0.40671631693840027,
-0.3356134295463562,
0.6173523664474487,
0.8237597942352295,
-0.5265741944313049,
0.5842621922492981,
0.3930342495441437,
-0.31095579266548157,
-0.3388448655605316,
-0.6156604290008545,
0.0011299364268779755,
-0.34535133838653564,
-0.44053882360458374,
0.16061589121818542,
-0.3690923750400543,
-0.24145792424678802,
0.05269017070531845,
-0.08145672082901001,
-0.15953098237514496,
0.2919202744960785,
0.4936864376068115,
0.2361038476228714,
-0.38567620515823364,
0.30865341424942017,
-0.38444483280181885,
0.04654582962393761,
0.36782705783843994,
-0.055194154381752014,
0.8288956880569458,
-0.4803330600261688,
-0.5753317475318909,
-0.12009863555431366,
0.2693687379360199,
0.5702900886535645,
0.18585938215255737,
0.3270595669746399,
0.22763998806476593,
-0.6090380549430847,
-0.2999434173107147,
-0.3642721474170685,
-0.21149662137031555,
-0.515807569026947,
0.2814297378063202,
-0.6142310500144958,
-0.9110612869262695,
0.6927875280380249,
-0.10606423765420914,
0.3934467136859894,
-0.18920044600963593,
0.5513370037078857,
-0.16027113795280457,
0.7128923535346985,
0.40267762541770935,
0.1503203809261322,
0.4572325348854065,
-0.16322076320648193,
0.3808163106441498,
-0.7230596542358398,
0.0873851552605629,
-0.5443052649497986,
-0.24400123953819275,
-0.8196370005607605,
-0.5295179486274719,
0.016835374757647514,
-0.18758933246135712,
-0.5924506187438965,
0.37269070744514465,
-0.6819907426834106,
0.7452836632728577,
0.464626282453537,
0.109279565513134,
0.1987495869398117,
0.29581475257873535,
0.2770516276359558,
-0.13961562514305115,
-0.5831910967826843,
-0.5100944638252258,
0.7347298860549927,
0.2630098760128021,
0.8541274666786194,
0.25428348779678345,
0.7656511068344116,
0.24411752820014954,
0.37991204857826233,
-1.120629906654358,
0.7661716341972351,
-0.3312765657901764,
-0.19839519262313843,
-0.08702501654624939,
-0.4553315043449402,
-1.428710699081421,
0.20465563237667084,
-0.4024456739425659,
-1.2404475212097168,
-0.08562172949314117,
0.07912056893110275,
-0.06689334660768509,
0.228818878531456,
-0.6512598991394043,
0.7807347774505615,
0.1941087543964386,
-0.3530787229537964,
-0.22807852923870087,
-0.33279648423194885,
0.22534333169460297,
-0.15197809040546417,
0.41684991121292114,
-0.02282613143324852,
0.30127376317977905,
0.5425826907157898,
-0.15885411202907562,
1.1116563081741333,
0.4505371153354645,
0.028331687673926353,
0.683354377746582,
0.9183982014656067,
0.1958381086587906,
-0.6070389151573181,
-0.16808928549289703,
0.03389601409435272,
0.32631316781044006,
-0.5250656008720398,
-0.7975684404373169,
0.9918670058250427,
-0.9029457569122314,
-1.1282800436019897,
-0.6009799242019653,
-0.8333556056022644,
-0.18185733258724213,
0.03978702425956726,
-0.399253785610199,
0.3326426148414612,
-0.12543106079101562,
0.31638649106025696,
0.3233906924724579,
-0.1896827071905136,
0.2843734323978424,
0.3941986858844757,
-0.24060215055942535,
0.27045586705207825,
1.1938109397888184,
-0.07290438562631607,
0.642276406288147,
0.3834019899368286,
0.551437258720398,
-0.03242512419819832,
-0.17536893486976624,
-0.47308114171028137,
0.09245788305997849,
-0.8290055394172668,
0.016175879165530205,
-0.4720185101032257,
-0.42524105310440063,
-0.3347335457801819,
-0.5960638523101807,
-0.14205718040466309,
-0.5834296345710754,
-0.3028498589992523,
-0.07551673799753189,
0.05481541156768799,
0.6681287884712219,
0.006839060690253973,
0.30485281348228455,
-0.5350587368011475,
0.01553716417402029,
0.6005369424819946,
0.1680738627910614,
0.6564944982528687,
-0.5532239079475403,
0.07313163578510284,
0.05575914680957794,
-0.5646662712097168,
-0.8428786993026733,
0.1626565307378769,
0.09776285290718079,
0.5246222019195557,
0.42985057830810547,
-0.10128949582576752,
0.8298271894454956,
-0.7182064652442932,
0.9933650493621826,
0.4097549617290497,
-1.1529347896575928,
0.14480756223201752,
-0.4855038523674011,
0.46299710869789124,
-0.017875203862786293,
0.3210163414478302,
-0.7644798755645752,
-0.3436844050884247,
-0.6256246566772461,
-0.8664050102233887,
0.31848302483558655,
0.37575775384902954,
0.905325710773468,
-0.31943807005882263,
0.29609400033950806,
0.07960483431816101,
0.44567304849624634,
-0.8711856603622437,
-0.17289288341999054,
-0.15030813217163086,
-0.22992633283138275,
0.23850958049297333,
-0.12099548429250717,
0.06159324571490288,
0.12895002961158752,
0.48247644305229187,
0.12245563417673111,
0.2321746051311493,
-0.28956377506256104,
0.19274680316448212,
-0.2825663983821869,
0.36038723587989807,
0.2944263517856598,
0.9357984662055969,
0.044235870242118835,
0.42284518480300903,
0.20169119536876678,
-0.3443933129310608,
0.01672079600393772,
-0.1491001695394516,
0.18090304732322693,
-0.26191258430480957,
0.2792901396751404,
0.02855328842997551,
0.3779783546924591,
-0.9732651710510254,
0.3729531168937683,
0.11268790811300278,
0.15945644676685333,
-0.49787580966949463,
0.32342177629470825,
0.4368293881416321,
0.19507502019405365,
0.3208225667476654,
-0.3721673786640167,
0.09712830185890198,
-1.0792772769927979,
0.22354340553283691,
0.5034334659576416,
-0.3590933084487915,
-0.06246238574385643,
0.26489704847335815,
0.02605561353266239,
-0.7279911637306213,
0.6840968132019043,
0.21153105795383453,
-0.3430095314979553,
1.0062190294265747,
0.8892801403999329,
0.9010864496231079,
-0.1612103432416916,
0.31594759225845337,
0.47061532735824585,
0.20682547986507416,
-0.014167854562401772,
-0.14458419382572174,
-0.06891749799251556,
-0.6579523086547852,
-0.22644083201885223,
-0.6545688509941101,
-0.543681800365448,
0.1481851041316986,
-0.7562691569328308,
0.32091471552848816,
-0.6245911717414856,
0.15310917794704437,
0.09025515615940094,
-0.3787200450897217,
-0.8588167428970337,
0.03787674754858017,
0.008053039200603962,
0.6249100565910339,
-0.8628801107406616,
0.3503142297267914,
0.7924613356590271,
-0.25232425332069397,
-0.7720999717712402,
-0.13106736540794373,
0.23162642121315002,
-0.96063232421875,
0.5304493308067322,
0.17286500334739685,
-0.2998969256877899,
-0.1522892266511917,
-0.323688805103302,
-0.6200670003890991,
0.8663553595542908,
0.005119664594531059,
-0.805825412273407,
-0.035686101764440536,
0.29769402742385864,
0.8564152717590332,
-0.7133865356445312,
0.29264169931411743,
0.48065048456192017,
-0.059457823634147644,
0.3072745203971863,
-0.6487041711807251,
0.15647105872631073,
-0.2850572466850281,
-0.10888952016830444,
0.17799441516399384,
-0.44396141171455383,
1.1129529476165771,
-0.37435805797576904,
-0.5324535369873047,
0.3718799352645874,
0.45608842372894287,
0.2714425027370453,
0.5142486691474915,
0.6897374987602234,
0.15826600790023804,
0.4087950885295868,
0.0860310047864914,
0.6827570796012878,
-0.2434253692626953,
0.47583141922950745,
1.509016513824463,
0.13887682557106018,
0.842616081237793,
0.6348052620887756,
-0.3998686671257019,
0.7474051117897034,
0.7552716135978699,
-0.1165885403752327,
0.03896880894899368,
1.0553570985794067,
-0.21363502740859985,
-0.48002752661705017,
0.048352569341659546,
-0.39292386174201965,
0.15781961381435394,
0.5536768436431885,
-0.27508825063705444,
-0.42487865686416626,
-0.23490607738494873,
0.08512146025896072,
0.5748019814491272,
-0.26717042922973633,
0.6396263837814331,
0.2827848792076111,
-0.38815656304359436,
0.4286850094795227,
-0.5271432399749756,
0.09999814629554749,
-0.5657436847686768,
-0.4906814396381378,
0.0030047642067074776,
-0.041025348007678986,
-0.14553411304950714,
-1.0712729692459106,
-0.035419948399066925,
0.17000126838684082,
-0.26035475730895996,
-0.009145609103143215,
0.37101441621780396,
-0.4198113977909088,
-0.7187997102737427,
0.03706939145922661,
0.5549437999725342,
0.7069814801216125,
0.21148023009300232,
-0.7399651408195496,
0.18643587827682495,
0.055519480258226395,
-0.009733537212014198,
0.4032291769981384,
0.5747253894805908,
-0.03395232558250427,
0.9806544184684753,
0.6975389719009399,
0.022697702050209045,
-0.10362562537193298,
-0.11398917436599731,
0.9217703342437744,
-0.43801307678222656,
-0.32579970359802246,
-0.7395744323730469,
0.38302356004714966,
0.19821147620677948,
-0.07993372529745102,
0.6819313764572144,
0.5633924603462219,
1.1180342435836792,
-0.37892621755599976,
0.703938364982605,
0.02939237840473652,
0.3885555565357208,
-0.2628833055496216,
0.40004846453666687,
-0.5045756101608276,
0.4193134605884552,
-0.7028387188911438,
-1.115600824356079,
-0.11749532073736191,
0.9676011800765991,
-0.4462926387786865,
-0.020297439768910408,
0.47083526849746704,
0.8376286625862122,
-0.353719562292099,
0.1080542504787445,
0.4785141348838806,
0.44106540083885193,
0.4540651738643646,
0.6689246296882629,
1.0873502492904663,
0.05437123402953148,
0.6958920359611511,
-0.19287028908729553,
-0.28577741980552673,
-0.08496035635471344,
-1.1239664554595947,
-1.0857981443405151,
-0.6960453391075134,
-0.44685378670692444,
-0.49434900283813477,
0.05483172833919525,
1.0503959655761719,
0.5988522171974182,
-0.6012575030326843,
-0.6602256894111633,
-0.06879223138093948,
0.3197346031665802,
-0.20287777483463287,
-0.28548792004585266,
0.4403057396411896,
-0.35520511865615845,
-0.8842847943305969,
-0.04254770651459694,
-0.2018003761768341,
0.10715912282466888,
-0.4636920988559723,
0.42327043414115906,
0.1543547809123993,
0.3126746714115143,
0.7329890727996826,
0.3393585979938507,
-0.6013391017913818,
-0.6995753645896912,
-0.06024535372853279,
0.10741893202066422,
0.019133225083351135,
1.0205491781234741,
-0.6612916588783264,
0.8412600755691528,
0.5920360088348389,
0.7370085716247559,
0.5102072358131409,
0.24590788781642914,
0.33558347821235657,
-0.49482086300849915,
-0.08112110197544098,
0.14867310225963593,
0.24249647557735443,
0.38886353373527527,
-0.17354154586791992,
0.4661652743816376,
0.14361634850502014,
-0.5251101851463318,
-0.7941060662269592,
0.5118144154548645,
-1.130928874015808,
-0.5008878111839294,
1.0669878721237183,
-0.4136076867580414,
-0.19833403825759888,
0.1276455670595169,
-0.3400748372077942,
-0.03683377429842949,
-0.319759339094162,
1.3103471994400024,
0.8906176686286926,
-0.19272924959659576,
-0.2545105814933777,
-0.6298427581787109,
0.15176434814929962,
0.27043259143829346,
-0.609309196472168,
0.2221914529800415,
0.4640507698059082,
0.5126277804374695,
0.25447434186935425,
0.2167736142873764,
-0.19834598898887634,
0.21440356969833374,
-0.08384402096271515,
-0.06282962113618851,
-0.02217123471200466,
0.009550010785460472,
0.12040111422538757,
0.1749248504638672,
-0.03680654242634773,
-0.33287209272384644
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09362v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09362v2
|
Komodo: A Linguistic Expedition into Indonesia's Regional Languages
| 2024-03-14T13:12:21 | 2024-03-19T05:49:01 |
Louis Owen, Vishesh Tripathi, Abhay Kumar, Biddwan Ahmed
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The recent breakthroughs in Large Language Models (LLMs) have mostly focused
on languages with easily available and sufficient resources, such as English.
However, there remains a significant gap for languages that lack sufficient
linguistic resources in the public domain. Our work introduces Komodo-7B,
7-billion-parameter Large Language Models designed to address this gap by
seamlessly operating across Indonesian, English, and 11 regional languages in
Indonesia. Komodo-7B is a family of LLMs that consist of Komodo-7B-Base and
Komodo-7B-Instruct. Komodo-7B-Instruct stands out by achieving state-of-the-art
performance in various tasks and languages, outperforming the benchmarks set by
OpenAI's GPT-3.5, Cohere's Aya-101, Llama-2-Chat-13B,
Mixtral-8x7B-Instruct-v0.1, Gemma-7B-it , and many more. This model not only
demonstrates superior performance in both language-specific and overall
assessments but also highlights its capability to excel in linguistic
diversity. Our commitment to advancing language models extends beyond
well-resourced languages, aiming to bridge the gap for those with limited
linguistic assets. Additionally, Komodo-7B-Instruct's better cross-language
understanding contributes to addressing educational disparities in Indonesia,
offering direct translations from English to 11 regional languages, a
significant improvement compared to existing language translation services.
Komodo-7B represents a crucial step towards inclusivity and effectiveness in
language models, providing to the linguistic needs of diverse communities.
|
[
-0.44069209694862366,
-0.6083824634552002,
0.4665229916572571,
0.46559619903564453,
-0.39175477623939514,
-0.04296164959669113,
-0.4758836328983307,
-0.46238550543785095,
-0.018711209297180176,
1.0401767492294312,
-0.3765275776386261,
-0.3443300127983093,
-0.753686785697937,
0.5633471608161926,
-0.0274814460426569,
0.5626537799835205,
0.05804157629609108,
-0.1835820972919464,
-0.10336116701364517,
-0.3644773066043854,
-0.6451597809791565,
-0.2711423337459564,
-0.3757384121417999,
-0.4237609803676605,
0.6412545442581177,
0.3618130087852478,
0.48261964321136475,
0.7496200799942017,
0.39322400093078613,
0.3310104310512543,
-0.323770135641098,
0.104568250477314,
-0.20146925747394562,
0.1762632429599762,
-0.787837028503418,
-0.8258206248283386,
-0.40263473987579346,
-0.4990485608577728,
0.4984704554080963,
1.0391350984573364,
-0.05386209115386009,
-0.02729177661240101,
-0.3003891110420227,
0.6678861379623413,
-0.5488016605377197,
0.4530602991580963,
-0.5906621813774109,
-0.32524046301841736,
-0.535754382610321,
0.13993072509765625,
-0.281011164188385,
-0.37661147117614746,
0.18680259585380554,
-0.4874626398086548,
0.0012418366968631744,
-0.15279975533485413,
0.632793664932251,
-0.05187995731830597,
-0.9736100435256958,
-0.6589155793190002,
-0.4606223702430725,
0.8178293704986572,
-0.7376776337623596,
0.3076801300048828,
0.4242582619190216,
0.35851794481277466,
-0.5565322637557983,
-0.29535022377967834,
-0.4541824758052826,
-0.14903749525547028,
0.3012063503265381,
0.10704115033149719,
0.24943587183952332,
0.3315267264842987,
0.011902602389454842,
0.539871871471405,
-0.4604412615299225,
0.16112978756427765,
-0.6878353357315063,
0.12267928570508957,
0.7272717356681824,
-0.012624146416783333,
0.4413328766822815,
-0.3783409595489502,
-0.04140264540910721,
-0.07230310887098312,
-0.8337216973304749,
-0.1587810069322586,
0.6478875279426575,
0.6534486413002014,
0.04117633029818535,
0.6965091228485107,
-0.5214343667030334,
0.7384495735168457,
-0.31471675634384155,
-0.739931046962738,
0.07540181279182434,
-0.34885454177856445,
-0.10347376018762589,
0.2841047942638397,
0.5641295909881592,
0.10231026262044907,
-0.0007817207369953394,
0.0670563131570816,
-0.22362135350704193,
0.34642788767814636,
-0.12024010717868805,
-0.41417017579078674,
-0.030777763575315475,
0.013617188669741154,
-0.42871949076652527,
-0.24709933996200562,
-0.10679664462804794,
-0.7488260269165039,
-0.4682936668395996,
-0.22721458971500397,
0.3792915940284729,
-0.2643866539001465,
-0.9327268600463867,
0.3456660211086273,
0.10433952510356903,
0.02380635216832161,
0.4462023675441742,
-0.7125226259231567,
0.1862078309059143,
0.5141105055809021,
0.7235156893730164,
0.05555645003914833,
-0.157258078455925,
0.10617125779390335,
0.23739653825759888,
-0.514163613319397,
0.6816378831863403,
-1.024816632270813,
-0.7026628851890564,
0.2670597434043884,
0.2527184784412384,
0.03442712128162384,
-0.6746193766593933,
0.6507717370986938,
-0.19620274007320404,
0.14154036343097687,
-0.17278917133808136,
-0.4092090427875519,
-0.7186117768287659,
0.22247324883937836,
-0.6954697370529175,
1.1667063236236572,
0.30593833327293396,
-0.32262304425239563,
0.021654153242707253,
-0.7075294852256775,
-0.3792042136192322,
0.18447934091091156,
-0.06344553828239441,
-0.012614808045327663,
0.5705224871635437,
0.15038400888442993,
0.44691699743270874,
-0.3094118535518646,
0.3091476857662201,
-0.5151863694190979,
-0.13652244210243225,
0.030736373737454414,
-0.31647947430610657,
0.8102741837501526,
0.37459731101989746,
-0.12652716040611267,
-0.04427633434534073,
-0.833018958568573,
-0.3111691474914551,
0.2750108242034912,
-0.28529712557792664,
-1.1706615686416626,
-0.25787481665611267,
-0.1426876038312912,
0.23796023428440094,
0.3902798593044281,
-0.6568728685379028,
0.7917516827583313,
-0.6836739778518677,
0.34132084250450134,
0.6398183107376099,
-0.07809687405824661,
0.5125722289085388,
-0.028462139889597893,
0.8290162086486816,
0.07813818752765656,
-0.02355138398706913,
-0.6991702914237976,
-0.523073136806488,
-0.7006430625915527,
-0.31960323452949524,
0.3431702256202698,
0.30486878752708435,
-0.9113910794258118,
0.29228273034095764,
-0.42754197120666504,
-0.533428966999054,
-0.6604698896408081,
0.27275586128234863,
0.25742533802986145,
0.12405058741569519,
-0.1347426027059555,
-0.1473168432712555,
-0.4593959450721741,
-0.8599501848220825,
0.048444509506225586,
-0.007345974445343018,
0.131409153342247,
0.22283975780010223,
0.5932672619819641,
-0.2841186821460724,
0.5489256978034973,
0.16750314831733704,
-0.26368436217308044,
-0.6866323947906494,
-0.320600301027298,
0.5984245538711548,
0.19780641794204712,
0.47734498977661133,
-0.6924246549606323,
-0.4486655294895172,
0.713995635509491,
-0.5126325488090515,
-0.38000884652137756,
0.29747650027275085,
-0.09948533773422241,
0.41523221135139465,
0.17124958336353302,
-0.5189602375030518,
0.22720859944820404,
0.9602159857749939,
-0.2331627905368805,
0.25857648253440857,
-0.4488820731639862,
0.2997453510761261,
-1.401716947555542,
-0.22506389021873474,
-0.3551596999168396,
-0.0967923253774643,
-0.26739245653152466,
0.20055857300758362,
0.013716832734644413,
-0.16723808646202087,
-0.34431397914886475,
0.7550243735313416,
-0.5245689749717712,
-0.14538243412971497,
-0.3811635375022888,
0.3084251284599304,
-0.15676626563072205,
0.10474089533090591,
-0.14392299950122833,
0.5456097722053528,
0.4375748634338379,
-0.4824039340019226,
0.5546517968177795,
-0.03811586648225784,
-0.43173080682754517,
0.6347318887710571,
-0.49192044138908386,
0.0758422389626503,
0.06343059241771698,
0.25181058049201965,
-0.9025880694389343,
-0.7251752018928528,
0.19864554703235626,
-0.14249356091022491,
0.16411374509334564,
-0.7076171040534973,
-0.5494283437728882,
-0.3421494662761688,
0.09055589884519577,
0.6158146858215332,
0.4668101370334625,
-0.6178675293922424,
0.6554667949676514,
0.2720668315887451,
-0.6654239892959595,
-0.38746434450149536,
-0.3942625820636749,
0.09400361776351929,
-0.4442504942417145,
-0.6674844026565552,
-0.1529187113046646,
0.29678231477737427,
-0.20760321617126465,
0.02444203570485115,
-0.11155054718255997,
-0.05513156205415726,
0.09486321359872818,
0.1698731929063797,
0.12667836248874664,
-0.29279524087905884,
0.013030585832893848,
0.6043941974639893,
0.07004016637802124,
0.04218253493309021,
-0.5599117875099182,
0.5918444991111755,
0.08662997931241989,
-0.2999042570590973,
-0.15893878042697906,
0.5251047015190125,
0.6658490300178528,
-0.4824018180370331,
0.4746105372905731,
0.06429855525493622,
-0.3568434715270996,
-0.3780376613140106,
-0.5126014947891235,
0.3192099928855896,
-0.4208313226699829,
0.5569728016853333,
-0.6993108987808228,
-0.9534792900085449,
0.6244881749153137,
-0.43939465284347534,
0.007046523038297892,
0.3507446050643921,
0.6304344534873962,
0.2690385580062866,
1.0551742315292358,
0.8016499280929565,
0.00008761716890148818,
0.51246178150177,
0.019366327673196793,
0.34418249130249023,
-0.6028205156326294,
-0.250600665807724,
-0.7016186714172363,
0.09945088624954224,
-0.882982075214386,
-0.3698202967643738,
0.27965858578681946,
0.19341839849948883,
0.2564353346824646,
0.3018631339073181,
-0.21238896250724792,
0.5263587832450867,
0.36457207798957825,
-0.23819486796855927,
0.38825008273124695,
0.07357009500265121,
-0.09235609322786331,
0.0461750403046608,
-0.8304917812347412,
-0.703793466091156,
1.3404767513275146,
0.26861709356307983,
0.9059771299362183,
0.13502472639083862,
0.9346718192100525,
0.20270033180713654,
0.19472280144691467,
-0.4131137728691101,
0.3600875437259674,
-0.24918082356452942,
-0.6372542977333069,
-0.16493405401706696,
-0.3002954423427582,
-1.0607318878173828,
0.5776137709617615,
0.42868971824645996,
-0.5691342353820801,
0.04506485536694527,
0.016554024070501328,
0.03974945843219757,
0.23324550688266754,
-0.7685321569442749,
0.8336188197135925,
-0.12011197954416275,
-0.05475578084588051,
-0.34655484557151794,
-0.32090193033218384,
0.5464218854904175,
0.19756776094436646,
0.4780224561691284,
-0.33393898606300354,
-0.15488599240779877,
0.6070074439048767,
-0.1536494791507721,
0.7242319583892822,
-0.026918303221464157,
-0.3772270083427429,
0.3108137547969818,
0.18060481548309326,
0.3189168870449066,
-0.03510851785540581,
0.08098171651363373,
0.2040567249059677,
0.24924537539482117,
-0.7287048697471619,
-0.6056221723556519,
1.0128157138824463,
-0.7027252912521362,
-0.3238069713115692,
-0.4549294412136078,
-0.6003244519233704,
-0.005978995934128761,
0.39170604944229126,
-0.10146511346101761,
0.5869644284248352,
0.37172627449035645,
0.3801369071006775,
0.9966185092926025,
-0.4628218114376068,
0.25168126821517944,
0.3604152202606201,
-0.5768358707427979,
-0.659199059009552,
1.1803338527679443,
0.3462885320186615,
0.4988365173339844,
0.21280352771282196,
0.30343279242515564,
-0.5672767758369446,
-0.4368680417537689,
-0.3710496425628662,
0.5382702946662903,
-0.689469039440155,
-0.10400877147912979,
-0.37778499722480774,
0.17750562727451324,
-0.573627769947052,
-0.2796260714530945,
-0.6881306767463684,
-0.3003588616847992,
0.40896573662757874,
-0.05616625398397446,
0.061897411942481995,
1.0320926904678345,
0.19431938230991364,
0.270308256149292,
-0.6755965948104858,
-0.041271958500146866,
-0.03131606802344322,
0.21366038918495178,
-0.20230227708816528,
-0.49110880494117737,
-0.04400748386979103,
-0.04639540985226631,
-0.04440575838088989,
-0.7147138714790344,
0.3538995385169983,
-0.0979841873049736,
0.5242453217506409,
0.39013415575027466,
0.22025667130947113,
0.7257265448570251,
-0.15549947321414948,
0.7147785425186157,
0.056990429759025574,
-0.5722094178199768,
0.8520191311836243,
-0.7099746465682983,
0.41184428334236145,
0.06965694576501846,
0.22673502564430237,
-0.6161608695983887,
-0.6710737347602844,
-0.7527002692222595,
-0.9117103219032288,
0.6977136731147766,
0.11593079566955566,
0.2601727545261383,
-0.14165087044239044,
0.24052056670188904,
0.5340089797973633,
0.3855978548526764,
-0.6719769835472107,
0.11902127414941788,
-0.052039872854948044,
-0.413440465927124,
0.022787678986787796,
-0.31185099482536316,
0.07715999335050583,
0.14543838798999786,
0.5669699907302856,
-0.07100562751293182,
0.1061328798532486,
0.17966978251934052,
-0.20313560962677002,
0.13430283963680267,
0.42822933197021484,
0.7438539862632751,
0.7119476199150085,
0.008131489157676697,
0.10054551810026169,
-0.05617216229438782,
-0.35514092445373535,
0.06206638738512993,
-0.03940467908978462,
-0.10898546874523163,
0.2606344521045685,
0.5457113981246948,
0.6842171549797058,
0.22059346735477448,
-0.7624635100364685,
0.24063000082969666,
0.16813422739505768,
0.09085063636302948,
-0.278674453496933,
0.1595640331506729,
-0.046432822942733765,
0.2427121251821518,
0.1737600564956665,
-0.31394317746162415,
-0.07342115044593811,
-0.568903923034668,
-0.4767932593822479,
-0.10043260455131531,
-0.07221926748752594,
-0.44285741448402405,
0.45641908049583435,
0.6125829815864563,
-0.2749766409397125,
0.36904120445251465,
-0.1008615717291832,
-0.5189229249954224,
0.6335147619247437,
0.6485249996185303,
0.7179433107376099,
-0.49283328652381897,
-0.007572471629828215,
0.3824050724506378,
0.5054214596748352,
-0.2528323829174042,
0.40018075704574585,
-0.13828346133232117,
-0.29003968834877014,
-0.421217143535614,
-0.6508986353874207,
-0.3759767711162567,
0.20773117244243622,
-0.7094254493713379,
0.20426252484321594,
-0.28129690885543823,
0.09241794049739838,
-0.5895112752914429,
0.27555400133132935,
-0.42685335874557495,
0.1280137151479721,
0.019717223942279816,
0.9470416903495789,
-1.0297048091888428,
0.9739412069320679,
1.0320501327514648,
-0.39653095602989197,
-0.47685787081718445,
-0.46987906098365784,
-0.2757343053817749,
-0.5092201232910156,
0.35706233978271484,
0.2522936761379242,
0.12886343896389008,
-0.12282948195934296,
-0.36844927072525024,
-0.7989667057991028,
0.881827712059021,
0.37542715668678284,
-0.5664112567901611,
0.08789847046136856,
0.2413216531276703,
0.3538511097431183,
-0.43844377994537354,
0.2610020041465759,
0.5152351260185242,
0.3383486568927765,
-0.281108558177948,
-1.1091994047164917,
-0.17601604759693146,
-0.13916513323783875,
0.6145135760307312,
0.43506675958633423,
-0.584782063961029,
0.5872214436531067,
0.11447156220674515,
0.21972507238388062,
0.3252822458744049,
0.7572819590568542,
0.3441353142261505,
0.2006477266550064,
0.45755863189697266,
0.29109978675842285,
0.5356130003929138,
-0.3411875367164612,
1.2612224817276,
-0.054060615599155426,
0.24837060272693634,
0.8657095432281494,
-0.15318451821804047,
0.7689244747161865,
0.5405133366584778,
-0.34958386421203613,
0.17221583425998688,
0.6173965930938721,
0.5399048924446106,
0.3865545988082886,
-0.18437497317790985,
-0.4868757426738739,
-0.31896844506263733,
-0.3961963653564453,
-0.5422959923744202,
0.3125159740447998,
0.5637801885604858,
-0.1197924092411995,
-0.3280468285083771,
0.275739461183548,
0.19444435834884644,
0.29957738518714905,
-0.5677309036254883,
0.28271177411079407,
0.06667277216911316,
-0.6368842720985413,
0.15967056155204773,
0.08675353229045868,
0.514890730381012,
-1.023563027381897,
-0.15854613482952118,
-0.7119670510292053,
0.4361575245857239,
0.008750277571380138,
-0.699028730392456,
0.055285174399614334,
-0.24016647040843964,
-0.097512386739254,
-0.1217878982424736,
0.5632743835449219,
-0.7672681212425232,
-0.6415560245513916,
0.30171680450439453,
-0.21244333684444427,
0.13249799609184265,
0.028889616951346397,
-0.3438124656677246,
0.6435129046440125,
-0.0007831844268366694,
0.016898179426789284,
0.3343440592288971,
0.8526272773742676,
-0.48969244956970215,
0.8236769437789917,
0.5461925864219666,
0.28936442732810974,
0.5352646708488464,
-0.01875714212656021,
0.3904235363006592,
-0.47488853335380554,
-0.7344294786453247,
-0.2893155515193939,
0.41203269362449646,
-0.14294816553592682,
-0.6304650902748108,
0.7881717681884766,
0.424272745847702,
1.4952008724212646,
-0.2718755900859833,
1.039139986038208,
-0.3133102059364319,
0.5095136761665344,
-0.4430547058582306,
0.39327022433280945,
-0.7182006239891052,
0.11576922237873077,
-0.3331822454929352,
-1.021706461906433,
-0.11056093871593475,
0.6637789011001587,
-0.36047855019569397,
0.03297815099358559,
0.4595404863357544,
0.6757517457008362,
-0.08921317011117935,
-0.2865651249885559,
0.7479631304740906,
0.49328455328941345,
0.5567975640296936,
0.6087000966072083,
0.822235643863678,
-0.485537588596344,
0.5766944885253906,
-0.5943516492843628,
-0.27277857065200806,
-0.27158936858177185,
-0.6099704504013062,
-1.024084448814392,
-0.5639188289642334,
-0.13773824274539948,
-0.184111088514328,
0.12725453078746796,
1.0150576829910278,
0.27668166160583496,
-0.7057608366012573,
-0.5405883193016052,
0.0848538801074028,
0.3368954360485077,
-0.06562355905771255,
-0.18988445401191711,
0.014925929717719555,
-0.27453863620758057,
-1.1716052293777466,
0.37156957387924194,
0.7130817174911499,
-0.2257479578256607,
-0.520187497138977,
-0.1194794550538063,
-0.1540648639202118,
0.0977066159248352,
0.845889687538147,
0.33452701568603516,
-1.2014223337173462,
-0.05778246745467186,
-0.15120279788970947,
-0.01909128576517105,
-0.3776387870311737,
0.5917049050331116,
-0.3922588527202606,
0.9477702379226685,
0.5541074275970459,
0.7363646626472473,
0.07901081442832947,
-0.3895234763622284,
0.6898602247238159,
-0.20742110908031464,
0.534644603729248,
-0.03599614277482033,
0.4039996564388275,
0.3414924144744873,
0.16832375526428223,
0.5895439982414246,
0.5728949904441833,
-0.3399774730205536,
-1.1144325733184814,
0.1810215562582016,
-1.0800155401229858,
0.0032928739674389362,
1.1406928300857544,
-0.22101368010044098,
-0.5901871919631958,
-0.09850071370601654,
-0.589398205280304,
-0.04516658931970596,
-0.24495035409927368,
0.7522515058517456,
0.8823343515396118,
0.1677517294883728,
-0.15089040994644165,
-0.7504549026489258,
-0.19594639539718628,
0.17410480976104736,
-0.5289025902748108,
-0.06979180872440338,
0.2977212965488434,
0.4798252582550049,
-0.016949422657489777,
0.4299166798591614,
-0.3107047975063324,
0.3384927809238434,
0.10051281005144119,
-0.04124485328793526,
-0.04413050413131714,
-0.36058565974235535,
-0.30851617455482483,
0.08287549763917923,
0.04016568139195442,
-0.15508201718330383
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09298v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09298v1
|
More than words: Advancements and challenges in speech recognition for singing
| 2024-03-14T11:37:02 | 2024-03-14T11:37:02 |
Anna Kruspe
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG, eess.AS
|
This paper addresses the challenges and advancements in speech recognition
for singing, a domain distinctly different from standard speech recognition.
Singing encompasses unique challenges, including extensive pitch variations,
diverse vocal styles, and background music interference. We explore key areas
such as phoneme recognition, language identification in songs, keyword
spotting, and full lyrics transcription. I will describe some of my own
experiences when performing research on these tasks just as they were starting
to gain traction, but will also show how recent developments in deep learning
and large-scale datasets have propelled progress in this field. My goal is to
illuminate the complexities of applying speech recognition to singing, evaluate
current capabilities, and outline future research directions.
|
[
-0.39246925711631775,
-0.5823438167572021,
0.3785465359687805,
0.21702507138252258,
0.21186481416225433,
0.7496997117996216,
-0.2749635875225067,
-0.876841127872467,
0.21000397205352783,
0.4976428151130676,
-0.6290807127952576,
-0.22602225840091705,
-0.902013897895813,
0.10938873142004013,
-0.8411523103713989,
0.6779745221138,
0.29472702741622925,
0.11809049546718597,
-0.0667891651391983,
-0.03135501593351364,
-0.6899693012237549,
-0.6927603483200073,
-0.6992153525352478,
-0.07429343461990356,
0.6693819165229797,
0.4435451328754425,
0.2212207317352295,
0.13481105864048004,
0.5750539898872375,
0.3561459183692932,
-0.3582797646522522,
0.21212056279182434,
-0.039538025856018066,
0.35343170166015625,
0.14041537046432495,
-0.4282664358615875,
-0.26839107275009155,
0.36704114079475403,
0.9867056012153625,
0.6977537870407104,
-0.10603778809309006,
0.1398797184228897,
-0.244795560836792,
0.8501715064048767,
-0.17514866590499878,
0.15199343860149384,
-0.9911549687385559,
0.37550538778305054,
-0.5653704404830933,
-0.1085585355758667,
0.31045767664909363,
-0.3069947361946106,
0.528589129447937,
-0.6785702109336853,
0.4847027361392975,
0.03267165273427963,
0.8698105216026306,
-0.11733106523752213,
-0.353765070438385,
-1.1198220252990723,
-0.8478897213935852,
0.825689971446991,
-0.21385204792022705,
0.63841712474823,
0.4184824526309967,
0.6071439981460571,
0.005260242149233818,
-0.7836523056030273,
-0.6822975873947144,
-0.2715635895729065,
0.46915102005004883,
0.08948861062526703,
-0.24035614728927612,
0.05621308460831642,
0.5645475387573242,
0.7964398264884949,
-0.3356250822544098,
-0.17224054038524628,
-0.5420644879341125,
-0.09673230350017548,
0.6887843012809753,
0.017720671370625496,
0.5242403745651245,
0.03174474462866783,
-0.22100558876991272,
0.014582309871912003,
-0.5201000571250916,
0.47380027174949646,
-0.011928283609449863,
0.7092774510383606,
-0.01346184965223074,
0.5842425227165222,
-0.2765609622001648,
0.877738356590271,
-0.01405894011259079,
-0.08873255550861359,
0.42754799127578735,
-0.08690798282623291,
-0.2556730806827545,
0.2283596396446228,
0.063059963285923,
0.032525770366191864,
0.18614090979099274,
-0.28737199306488037,
0.0872732475399971,
0.06812814623117447,
-0.0034477878361940384,
-0.3317617177963257,
0.021170705556869507,
0.13758833706378937,
-0.1943095475435257,
-0.11749201267957687,
0.010819484479725361,
-0.5716022849082947,
-0.750489354133606,
-0.7824257016181946,
0.5114786624908447,
-0.2530270218849182,
-0.18188580870628357,
0.20633523166179657,
-0.5987069010734558,
0.4809124171733856,
0.11997264623641968,
-0.634639322757721,
0.18930324912071228,
0.970551609992981,
1.0265634059906006,
0.06968117505311966,
-0.39111626148223877,
-0.5432772040367126,
-0.05470524728298187,
-0.35450777411460876,
0.7083171606063843,
-0.6249308586120605,
-0.31614935398101807,
0.06128399074077606,
0.01973949559032917,
-0.35743972659111023,
-0.8061650395393372,
0.45081984996795654,
-0.3973356783390045,
-0.007641478907316923,
-0.6956192255020142,
-1.0323182344436646,
-0.254148930311203,
0.009133746847510338,
-0.7219878435134888,
0.4375607371330261,
-0.07610223442316055,
-0.20770759880542755,
0.36805853247642517,
-0.7044644355773926,
-0.6347922086715698,
0.14914345741271973,
-0.33184686303138733,
-0.3842717409133911,
0.8179196119308472,
-0.2580666244029999,
0.41543397307395935,
-0.1072431206703186,
-0.1516980081796646,
0.12207959592342377,
-0.35773295164108276,
0.8950299024581909,
-0.20348364114761353,
0.5399186611175537,
0.3763475716114044,
-0.29525449872016907,
-0.09555549174547195,
-0.9087028503417969,
0.36211809515953064,
-0.03775551915168762,
-0.3849563002586365,
0.11960204690694809,
0.19927199184894562,
0.2642233669757843,
0.07289714366197586,
0.13073784112930298,
-0.7976188659667969,
0.16072528064250946,
-0.20314882695674896,
0.6562274098396301,
-0.015773244202136993,
-0.23173832893371582,
0.1825886070728302,
-0.528838574886322,
0.6193847060203552,
-0.32174837589263916,
-0.09569694101810455,
-0.09335388988256454,
-0.8466213941574097,
-0.3250623941421509,
-0.018168319016695023,
0.47914496064186096,
0.6167048215866089,
-0.3445752263069153,
0.3869290351867676,
-0.1079520657658577,
-0.560379147529602,
-0.6865937113761902,
0.12020750343799591,
0.3957652151584625,
0.26314133405685425,
0.4108707308769226,
-0.2084956020116806,
-0.8076644539833069,
-0.39568546414375305,
-0.3834991455078125,
0.0475798062980175,
-0.06915941089391708,
0.6231499910354614,
0.0771346241235733,
0.06331463903188705,
0.6121261715888977,
-0.5069465041160583,
-1.030800223350525,
-0.3935439884662628,
0.16733324527740479,
0.15959832072257996,
0.6481972932815552,
0.42753639817237854,
-1.0798370838165283,
-0.6194973587989807,
0.016313854604959488,
-0.19576582312583923,
-0.032269466668367386,
-0.11787250638008118,
0.38132932782173157,
-0.2490195780992508,
0.6420074105262756,
-0.5547147989273071,
-0.09735438972711563,
0.6720096468925476,
-0.2608189284801483,
0.30165842175483704,
0.2613913118839264,
0.2672581076622009,
-0.7330941557884216,
-0.08769245445728302,
-0.22057636082172394,
-0.09539281576871872,
-1.0785706043243408,
-0.1265224814414978,
-0.13671572506427765,
-0.39802804589271545,
-0.14707958698272705,
-0.1507960855960846,
-0.576015055179596,
-0.30466577410697937,
-0.5722159147262573,
0.11471010744571686,
0.14702735841274261,
-0.15589524805545807,
0.3381028473377228,
0.6244863867759705,
1.1575344800949097,
-0.44643959403038025,
0.7946481704711914,
0.25897887349128723,
-0.7521005272865295,
0.614797055721283,
-0.40738561749458313,
0.3793019950389862,
0.02014521136879921,
-0.091313935816288,
-1.0795964002609253,
-0.23752442002296448,
-0.3944648504257202,
-0.9841143488883972,
0.7427874803543091,
0.040174033492803574,
-0.15221180021762848,
-0.34827324748039246,
0.06314238905906677,
0.09752718359231949,
0.5644121170043945,
-0.29105690121650696,
0.4282870292663574,
0.62839275598526,
-0.2139216661453247,
-0.25849950313568115,
-0.672837495803833,
0.5209943056106567,
-0.39412882924079895,
-0.11838100850582123,
0.5321397185325623,
0.14071528613567352,
-0.010693120770156384,
-0.5541876554489136,
-0.08077536523342133,
-0.4092566967010498,
0.12889960408210754,
0.06333985179662704,
-0.5121960043907166,
-0.17468474805355072,
0.3689986765384674,
-0.07777700573205948,
-0.2971668541431427,
-0.04399504140019417,
-0.1835399717092514,
0.5554835796356201,
0.0460597425699234,
-0.10350164771080017,
-0.5692636370658875,
0.9268791079521179,
0.5008114576339722,
-0.20884966850280762,
-0.041059963405132294,
0.8249496221542358,
-0.3934624493122101,
0.18152779340744019,
-0.6192015409469604,
0.3421795666217804,
-0.46862298250198364,
0.6485350728034973,
-0.42377886176109314,
-0.8376466035842896,
0.41214609146118164,
-0.2747909426689148,
0.10520371049642563,
-0.08508621901273727,
0.23311656713485718,
-0.6878848671913147,
1.0384441614151,
0.748952329158783,
-0.20619389414787292,
0.677475094795227,
-0.23852358758449554,
0.1216416209936142,
-1.0858409404754639,
-0.3025754392147064,
-0.860207200050354,
-0.5583829283714294,
-0.7310396432876587,
-0.556336522102356,
0.2987526059150696,
-0.03416988626122475,
0.26299169659614563,
0.4600814878940582,
-0.5739968419075012,
0.3562164008617401,
0.5432726740837097,
-0.10340360552072525,
0.25501808524131775,
-0.13809077441692352,
0.2608211040496826,
-0.08726561069488525,
-0.186165452003479,
-0.003356411587446928,
0.7167008519172668,
0.28719934821128845,
0.5820611715316772,
0.22166480123996735,
0.49908721446990967,
0.22824549674987793,
-0.1572553962469101,
-1.0916030406951904,
0.1863304227590561,
-0.47210821509361267,
-1.038356065750122,
-0.40818315744400024,
-0.25055190920829773,
-0.7772794961929321,
0.026842664927244186,
-0.16338618099689484,
-0.5702379941940308,
0.31444185972213745,
0.17778679728507996,
-0.32069677114486694,
0.23512478172779083,
-0.4462442100048065,
0.11898095905780792,
-0.38423478603363037,
0.4982531666755676,
0.04991992563009262,
-0.5943328738212585,
-0.2025061398744583,
-0.033528536558151245,
0.23882800340652466,
-0.32736751437187195,
-0.23429369926452637,
0.8467332720756531,
0.1798165738582611,
0.6660172939300537,
-0.3417623043060303,
-0.08154182136058807,
0.08239723742008209,
-0.4598982334136963,
0.11249244213104248,
-0.4568631947040558,
0.1547178477048874,
0.09850054234266281,
0.10613062232732773,
-0.3184323310852051,
-0.4599631726741791,
0.5701817274093628,
-0.35738950967788696,
-0.43999871611595154,
-0.4749327003955841,
-0.5217756032943726,
-0.7538208961486816,
-0.12316446751356125,
0.42732492089271545,
0.3584972321987152,
0.22010615468025208,
0.5240465998649597,
0.5698119401931763,
-0.36699193716049194,
0.4040132164955139,
0.42524483799934387,
-0.3961186408996582,
-0.6708617806434631,
1.3630114793777466,
0.5318469405174255,
0.28393465280532837,
0.3764953017234802,
0.36188963055610657,
-0.6796372532844543,
-0.8433821201324463,
-0.48468828201293945,
-0.0035351638216525316,
-0.4014086127281189,
-0.02417328953742981,
-0.5433366298675537,
-0.2400016039609909,
-0.5103955268859863,
0.05139065533876419,
-0.25772756338119507,
-0.4592668116092682,
-0.19422964751720428,
-0.09254971146583557,
0.6059173941612244,
0.8527337908744812,
-0.05532543361186981,
0.3768221437931061,
-0.8967193365097046,
0.4523252844810486,
0.4992293417453766,
0.41453561186790466,
0.07378500699996948,
-0.47663062810897827,
-0.4945310950279236,
-0.2224961817264557,
-0.2524377703666687,
-1.077440619468689,
0.03833805024623871,
0.8620152473449707,
0.3643222153186798,
0.36098310351371765,
-0.37089410424232483,
1.1454519033432007,
-0.4101271629333496,
1.0063942670822144,
0.25397902727127075,
-1.1860872507095337,
0.4683853089809418,
-0.10396435111761093,
0.047091610729694366,
0.5007987022399902,
0.40421396493911743,
-0.8254091143608093,
-0.08517026901245117,
-0.4458419680595398,
-0.7264588475227356,
0.13082854449748993,
0.3620118200778961,
0.49168381094932556,
0.46803849935531616,
0.44284433126449585,
-0.24262215197086334,
0.7390919327735901,
-0.2581227421760559,
-0.4011000096797943,
-0.16056260466575623,
0.16357846558094025,
-0.3686942160129547,
-0.04900636523962021,
0.019342614337801933,
-0.659576416015625,
0.2948983907699585,
-0.02433362416923046,
0.31133073568344116,
0.32937169075012207,
0.039271462708711624,
0.05230379104614258,
0.3410627841949463,
0.6779409646987915,
0.2773960828781128,
0.15813978016376495,
-0.21220965683460236,
0.2507849633693695,
-0.7159496545791626,
0.10950521379709244,
0.24072258174419403,
0.14625927805900574,
0.26976901292800903,
0.4899299740791321,
0.8783619999885559,
-0.034722428768873215,
-0.7489997744560242,
0.3490637242794037,
-0.0988592654466629,
-0.39489760994911194,
-0.5331764221191406,
0.022836526855826378,
0.2324639856815338,
0.41328689455986023,
0.516463577747345,
-0.15031006932258606,
0.459849089384079,
-0.8007050156593323,
0.30036163330078125,
0.5923546552658081,
-0.9552070498466492,
-0.16785018146038055,
0.3631187975406647,
-0.04656866192817688,
-0.5304696559906006,
0.14103631675243378,
0.12631499767303467,
-0.7767602205276489,
0.6705871224403381,
0.5228819847106934,
0.87087482213974,
-0.35821324586868286,
-0.11384126543998718,
-0.2029058039188385,
-0.1488640308380127,
0.2755347788333893,
0.8947243094444275,
-0.5485514998435974,
-0.5328857898712158,
-0.2570410370826721,
-0.6278830170631409,
-0.7015281319618225,
0.411243736743927,
-0.7883356809616089,
-0.03167618811130524,
-0.49030449986457825,
-0.41490721702575684,
0.5074983239173889,
0.41655173897743225,
-0.3636317849159241,
0.43128257989883423,
0.3641955852508545,
0.675434410572052,
-0.6669260859489441,
0.6322845220565796,
0.9268971085548401,
-0.010136575438082218,
-0.7426279783248901,
-0.06465306878089905,
0.30143633484840393,
-0.5834636092185974,
0.27391794323921204,
0.3515659272670746,
-0.15700119733810425,
-0.0060183098539710045,
-0.3974228799343109,
-0.9965592622756958,
0.680583655834198,
-0.2250777930021286,
-1.0296472311019897,
-0.04266130179166794,
0.3217304050922394,
0.5282629728317261,
-0.4085869789123535,
-0.35446882247924805,
0.7477942109107971,
0.4968551695346832,
0.2914299964904785,
-0.8669409155845642,
-0.5651350617408752,
-0.12382502108812332,
-0.03301634266972542,
-0.15420426428318024,
-0.5129271149635315,
1.184456706047058,
-0.09891165792942047,
-0.28332245349884033,
0.5831594467163086,
0.4702324867248535,
0.2591020166873932,
0.6463817954063416,
0.6560682654380798,
0.41907086968421936,
0.9344844222068787,
-0.4571431577205658,
0.7515720725059509,
0.050514332950115204,
0.2996463477611542,
1.098815679550171,
-0.6040471196174622,
0.7158203721046448,
0.13515505194664001,
-0.5511384010314941,
0.08036278188228607,
0.34503045678138733,
-0.11643810570240021,
0.2590007185935974,
0.5382201075553894,
-0.6101303696632385,
-0.21870970726013184,
-0.2631123661994934,
-0.6631193161010742,
0.7384271621704102,
0.5635279417037964,
-0.46182435750961304,
0.023536771535873413,
0.4074535071849823,
-0.273053377866745,
0.10665474086999893,
-0.1427367627620697,
1.100603699684143,
0.3057476282119751,
-0.27114108204841614,
0.17596016824245453,
-0.4896332621574402,
0.7428991794586182,
-0.5824325680732727,
-0.33922287821769714,
0.5585534572601318,
-0.10173539072275162,
-0.37972742319107056,
-0.857271134853363,
0.4624217450618744,
0.06076516956090927,
-0.258620947599411,
-0.2382744997739792,
0.6629348397254944,
-0.41928938031196594,
-0.6388047337532043,
0.3079543113708496,
0.30319276452064514,
0.1925588697195053,
-0.5932238698005676,
-0.7668201327323914,
0.12055866420269012,
-0.0976080447435379,
0.21212029457092285,
0.1861952692270279,
0.4215047359466553,
0.45989471673965454,
0.5279936194419861,
0.937859833240509,
0.8681185841560364,
0.4186135232448578,
0.43356987833976746,
0.4894392490386963,
-1.1471638679504395,
-0.5333119034767151,
-0.3122616112232208,
0.15729846060276031,
-0.14990054070949554,
-0.4189431965351105,
0.5828772187232971,
0.6049802899360657,
0.6469850540161133,
-0.03916345536708832,
0.8748696446418762,
-0.14376375079154968,
1.3210734128952026,
-0.5334317088127136,
0.7830954194068909,
-0.6471548676490784,
-0.054806433618068695,
-0.49621543288230896,
-0.4423481523990631,
-0.3683990240097046,
0.6303078532218933,
0.15280534327030182,
0.05996005982160568,
0.24096965789794922,
0.42980995774269104,
0.15135157108306885,
0.27755504846572876,
0.6188744306564331,
-0.17130805552005768,
0.4620839059352875,
0.5364894866943359,
1.265992522239685,
-0.36008980870246887,
0.27434423565864563,
-0.3854621648788452,
-0.02748597040772438,
0.11253513395786285,
-0.5433717966079712,
-0.44975510239601135,
-1.1050095558166504,
-0.3173019587993622,
-0.1342320293188095,
-0.2200593203306198,
0.8268875479698181,
0.947628915309906,
-1.0381890535354614,
-0.27353423833847046,
-0.014896437525749207,
0.3106796443462372,
-0.617424488067627,
-0.23831309378147125,
0.20140159130096436,
-0.39062944054603577,
-0.905781090259552,
0.5215241312980652,
-0.01148346159607172,
0.3920820355415344,
-0.15100781619548798,
0.17856132984161377,
-0.011596239171922207,
0.11502370983362198,
0.7875370383262634,
0.5592426657676697,
-0.593169093132019,
-0.13823723793029785,
0.0792013555765152,
0.430020272731781,
0.10790767520666122,
1.3623363971710205,
-0.4493771195411682,
0.2840927839279175,
0.5820310711860657,
0.5754576325416565,
0.18020080029964447,
0.00933962594717741,
0.3233407437801361,
-0.7195494174957275,
-0.41368943452835083,
0.4387924373149872,
0.2507060170173645,
0.41226181387901306,
-0.2865077257156372,
-0.030044183135032654,
0.23627427220344543,
-0.3449064791202545,
-0.9646131992340088,
0.43161454796791077,
-1.2384108304977417,
0.18922528624534607,
0.6736130118370056,
-0.14589892327785492,
0.27597883343696594,
-0.5067827701568604,
-0.18789808452129364,
0.16679230332374573,
-0.1538645625114441,
0.7534576654434204,
0.7626180648803711,
-0.5807206630706787,
-0.20911532640457153,
-0.5214956998825073,
1.1034895181655884,
0.2275353968143463,
-0.48649415373802185,
0.06828594952821732,
0.3712061047554016,
0.3804301917552948,
0.5234461426734924,
0.31394487619400024,
-0.41979384422302246,
0.43399953842163086,
-0.29385191202163696,
-0.31316232681274414,
0.07701318711042404,
-0.4451829493045807,
-0.7185778021812439,
0.3928983509540558,
0.20167995989322662,
-0.5019766688346863
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09294v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09294v1
|
Anatomical Structure-Guided Medical Vision-Language Pre-training
| 2024-03-14T11:29:47 | 2024-03-14T11:29:47 |
Qingqiu Li, Xiaohan Yan, Jilan Xu, Runtian Yuan, Yuejie Zhang, Rui Feng, Quanli Shen, Xiaobo Zhang, Shujun Wang
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Learning medical visual representations through vision-language pre-training
has reached remarkable progress. Despite the promising performance, it still
faces challenges, i.e., local alignment lacks interpretability and clinical
relevance, and the insufficient internal and external representation learning
of image-report pairs. To address these issues, we propose an Anatomical
Structure-Guided (ASG) framework. Specifically, we parse raw reports into
triplets <anatomical region, finding, existence>, and fully utilize each
element as supervision to enhance representation learning. For anatomical
region, we design an automatic anatomical region-sentence alignment paradigm in
collaboration with radiologists, considering them as the minimum semantic units
to explore fine-grained local alignment. For finding and existence, we regard
them as image tags, applying an image-tag recognition decoder to associate
image features with their respective tags within each sample and constructing
soft labels for contrastive learning to improve the semantic association of
different image-report pairs. We evaluate the proposed ASG framework on two
downstream tasks, including five public benchmarks. Experimental results
demonstrate that our method outperforms the state-of-the-art methods.
|
[
-0.05907243862748146,
-0.41923388838768005,
0.6918153166770935,
-0.1495562046766281,
-0.7422810196876526,
-0.313525527715683,
-0.09738043695688248,
-0.6769880056381226,
0.5776691436767578,
0.3489232361316681,
-0.31667327880859375,
-0.9019598960876465,
-0.6434891819953918,
0.11210240423679352,
0.053835365921258926,
0.6599876880645752,
-0.2945600152015686,
0.6055770516395569,
-0.10764110088348389,
-0.3445380926132202,
-0.5309752821922302,
-0.18005253374576569,
-0.4678817093372345,
-0.130074605345726,
0.5911413431167603,
0.14691485464572906,
0.6148077249526978,
1.4750697612762451,
0.9511417150497437,
0.27856820821762085,
0.163557231426239,
0.19586318731307983,
0.20365871489048004,
-0.1880999207496643,
0.09271369129419327,
-0.45262861251831055,
-0.663711667060852,
-0.32743361592292786,
0.6128995418548584,
0.9903968572616577,
-0.26706662774086,
-0.29858964681625366,
-0.030049825087189674,
0.7542575001716614,
-0.4111400842666626,
0.43181732296943665,
-0.27017462253570557,
0.11682230234146118,
-0.31026744842529297,
-0.29923802614212036,
-0.18753424286842346,
-0.3227792978286743,
0.44181400537490845,
-0.8654085397720337,
0.03246544674038887,
0.12066692113876343,
1.1401132345199585,
0.5285303592681885,
-0.5244136452674866,
-0.4686390459537506,
0.0399290956556797,
0.2725696563720703,
-0.32684820890426636,
0.4511096775531769,
0.33908918499946594,
0.23737221956253052,
0.07681387662887573,
-0.7607548236846924,
0.1056569516658783,
-0.0026742774061858654,
-0.4728240966796875,
0.1954978108406067,
-0.0010871009435504675,
0.4919891655445099,
-0.13638003170490265,
0.46447086334228516,
-0.6762370467185974,
0.06474366039037704,
-0.5356698036193848,
-0.05044271796941757,
0.5229382514953613,
-0.009697811678051949,
0.44554710388183594,
-0.23672597110271454,
-0.6755327582359314,
-0.055486131459474564,
-1.0552605390548706,
-0.45251986384391785,
-0.12175745517015457,
0.2576760947704315,
-0.23568055033683777,
0.5142122507095337,
0.04506564140319824,
0.6206246018409729,
-0.0866355374455452,
0.13242121040821075,
0.5661234259605408,
-0.11240515112876892,
-0.3583068549633026,
0.3366521894931793,
0.6038476228713989,
0.27463772892951965,
-0.07588212937116623,
-0.04320723935961723,
-0.021194197237491608,
0.33520418405532837,
0.462367445230484,
-0.6110044717788696,
-0.45917803049087524,
-0.08530593663454056,
-0.7440899610519409,
-0.22063744068145752,
0.01055491529405117,
-0.18789230287075043,
-0.25843164324760437,
-0.4818027913570404,
0.5954388976097107,
-0.6707539558410645,
-0.03086668998003006,
0.4838525056838989,
0.16093790531158447,
0.2910704016685486,
0.47064363956451416,
-0.6988781690597534,
0.22704346477985382,
0.29807770252227783,
0.8265403509140015,
-0.029154060408473015,
-0.18782861530780792,
-0.4126632511615753,
0.5210738778114319,
-0.44482681155204773,
1.105684757232666,
-0.38066598773002625,
-0.17194484174251556,
-0.02334827184677124,
0.15209060907363892,
0.16546520590782166,
-0.6346566081047058,
0.21875955164432526,
-0.17661787569522858,
0.2870362102985382,
-0.18598654866218567,
-0.44329389929771423,
-0.2476487010717392,
0.34415706992149353,
-0.47850677371025085,
0.42973625659942627,
0.05514991283416748,
-0.4933036267757416,
0.46280816197395325,
-0.7649827599525452,
-0.6672000288963318,
0.26450830698013306,
-0.9317477941513062,
-0.4630966782569885,
0.08915799111127853,
0.586264431476593,
0.4810599386692047,
-0.1135537251830101,
0.254181832075119,
-0.043892282992601395,
-0.4480631351470947,
-0.4962633550167084,
0.20823204517364502,
0.5668273568153381,
-0.19834813475608826,
-0.31771788001060486,
0.5443245768547058,
-0.6803973913192749,
-0.19205453991889954,
0.13638193905353546,
-0.29507651925086975,
-0.37868139147758484,
0.1596885472536087,
-0.3443267047405243,
-0.1741008460521698,
-0.0029815305024385452,
-0.4814859926700592,
0.43906712532043457,
-0.6762155294418335,
0.1256456822156906,
0.6117074489593506,
-0.1530889868736267,
0.5415766835212708,
-0.26294848322868347,
0.49591490626335144,
0.14306233823299408,
0.045917343348264694,
-0.22150550782680511,
-0.3879219889640808,
-0.6702823042869568,
-0.4744797348976135,
0.04225999861955643,
0.36393797397613525,
-1.015259861946106,
0.4470162093639374,
-0.2071816325187683,
-0.34089961647987366,
-0.7471773028373718,
-0.11541755497455597,
0.8149802684783936,
0.8207858204841614,
0.6618354916572571,
-0.5804373025894165,
-0.5711615681648254,
-1.113006830215454,
0.03170733526349068,
-0.3202492892742157,
-0.2480577975511551,
0.2692430913448334,
0.2626858353614807,
-0.3373359441757202,
0.4297209680080414,
-0.7365710139274597,
-0.9156113862991333,
0.2353840470314026,
0.16700461506843567,
0.02191414311528206,
0.5011482834815979,
0.49454036355018616,
-0.6877063512802124,
-0.2861977219581604,
0.16720397770404816,
-0.9020578861236572,
-0.017790719866752625,
0.33253228664398193,
-0.1197882667183876,
0.19640406966209412,
0.5692937970161438,
-0.08577064424753189,
0.5390247106552124,
0.2848985195159912,
-0.3356902301311493,
0.1511688381433487,
-0.4666205048561096,
0.18493108451366425,
-1.0374464988708496,
-0.038083650171756744,
0.053689174354076385,
-0.19547918438911438,
-0.293784499168396,
0.07647205889225006,
0.23143810033798218,
-0.013568517751991749,
-0.30743733048439026,
0.4300037622451782,
-0.8211349844932556,
-0.08284779638051987,
0.0008124611340463161,
-0.2609076499938965,
-0.044446900486946106,
0.3860449492931366,
0.6877617239952087,
0.15957137942314148,
0.9815369844436646,
-0.35027921199798584,
-0.05066628381609917,
0.5245776772499084,
-0.3331277668476105,
0.7172548770904541,
-0.4983605444431305,
0.14346787333488464,
-0.3451099991798401,
0.23687687516212463,
-0.5952984690666199,
-0.4125407934188843,
0.206525981426239,
-0.37893009185791016,
0.6750955581665039,
-0.44704553484916687,
-0.3349034786224365,
-0.08000575006008148,
-0.1766558438539505,
0.4774749279022217,
0.337315171957016,
-0.4993152916431427,
0.735899031162262,
0.4027346968650818,
-0.10082189738750458,
-0.5109027028083801,
-0.7903527617454529,
-0.0465429425239563,
-0.07900086045265198,
-0.8596246838569641,
0.5789924263954163,
0.3413546085357666,
0.08415540307760239,
0.06674232333898544,
-0.40652570128440857,
-0.1901734173297882,
-0.19671520590782166,
0.3431006371974945,
0.3839990198612213,
-0.758662760257721,
0.23032677173614502,
-0.14635516703128815,
-0.03622216731309891,
-0.006220979616045952,
-0.37471193075180054,
0.16631020605564117,
-0.28143730759620667,
-0.43727606534957886,
-0.3895982801914215,
0.41976115107536316,
0.03351464495062828,
-0.29047104716300964,
0.23639975488185883,
0.4995342195034027,
-0.6355375647544861,
0.201172336935997,
-0.36276775598526,
-0.13158245384693146,
-0.4526129961013794,
0.49980202317237854,
-0.12674660980701447,
-0.8663643002510071,
0.1625613272190094,
0.09557140618562698,
-0.06678660213947296,
0.2732757031917572,
0.37469232082366943,
-0.65149986743927,
0.9403581619262695,
0.5934672355651855,
0.602637529373169,
0.40417906641960144,
-0.12268713861703873,
-0.08717702329158783,
-0.7717241644859314,
-0.6184365749359131,
-0.17289358377456665,
-0.3176306486129761,
-0.237232506275177,
-0.48695725202560425,
0.7020580172538757,
0.016183707863092422,
0.0027079477440565825,
0.15966856479644775,
-0.8249088525772095,
0.5211321711540222,
0.2325284630060196,
0.36274486780166626,
0.19137044250965118,
0.06264100223779678,
-0.07578422129154205,
-0.11476725339889526,
-0.5919827818870544,
-0.3782327175140381,
0.9225701093673706,
0.30676648020744324,
0.8807219862937927,
0.043009452521800995,
0.9880958795547485,
-0.17612043023109436,
0.46278104186058044,
-0.8666409850120544,
0.40262988209724426,
-0.5852816104888916,
-0.31853723526000977,
-0.009236952289938927,
-0.2933497130870819,
-1.0194467306137085,
0.29591044783592224,
-0.18852511048316956,
-0.45299166440963745,
0.18092283606529236,
0.5582243204116821,
-0.46847277879714966,
0.10776454210281372,
-0.878730297088623,
0.9522433280944824,
-0.42681851983070374,
-0.0656745657324791,
0.0350140817463398,
-1.0927633047103882,
0.01713874377310276,
0.23559385538101196,
0.10671374201774597,
0.03800236061215401,
-0.24314583837985992,
0.5373423099517822,
-0.4795416593551636,
0.7452392578125,
-0.2931367754936218,
0.0548066608607769,
-0.06592246890068054,
-0.05938859283924103,
-0.07575555890798569,
0.027856172993779182,
0.5838027000427246,
0.12719884514808655,
0.08923263847827911,
-0.3806488811969757,
-0.3310718834400177,
0.31466788053512573,
-0.5718567371368408,
-0.47264155745506287,
-0.3873231112957001,
-0.38073351979255676,
-0.31437236070632935,
0.34794092178344727,
0.34875985980033875,
0.7862588167190552,
0.011012000031769276,
0.3665311634540558,
0.6794423460960388,
-0.17832840979099274,
-0.006575815379619598,
0.30146557092666626,
-0.12531115114688873,
-0.5512303113937378,
0.7057059407234192,
-0.05880676209926605,
-0.09434991329908371,
0.6417294144630432,
0.24131207168102264,
-0.276917964220047,
-0.825143039226532,
-0.5143865346908569,
0.4541533589363098,
-0.6429790258407593,
-0.4555645287036896,
-0.33420267701148987,
-0.0687805637717247,
-0.30525100231170654,
-0.5510314106941223,
-0.36559993028640747,
0.17449215054512024,
-0.26037174463272095,
0.19418998062610626,
-0.0015121797332540154,
0.8196242451667786,
0.04451686516404152,
0.47067326307296753,
-0.7123025059700012,
0.4486512541770935,
-0.02392221987247467,
0.5821982622146606,
-0.5403314828872681,
-0.1461055874824524,
-0.15602606534957886,
-0.37298259139060974,
-0.05806770920753479,
-0.8132408261299133,
0.14606286585330963,
0.14241841435432434,
0.24894942343235016,
0.5500146746635437,
-0.28721800446510315,
1.1864070892333984,
-0.776556134223938,
0.27453041076660156,
0.5283718705177307,
-0.5602380633354187,
0.9459229111671448,
-0.35187727212905884,
0.2732984125614166,
0.48317256569862366,
0.17941826581954956,
0.03009367734193802,
-0.2610906660556793,
-0.4656132757663727,
-0.8656211495399475,
0.7018604874610901,
0.05960598587989807,
-0.23949435353279114,
-0.07682599872350693,
0.47040411829948425,
-0.03672796115279198,
0.05742770805954933,
-0.5736154913902283,
-0.17294631898403168,
-0.16916003823280334,
-0.524624764919281,
0.21436896920204163,
0.08028216660022736,
-0.26252448558807373,
-0.3070031404495239,
0.40098837018013,
-0.5150685906410217,
0.37159934639930725,
0.50959712266922,
-0.23829248547554016,
0.03105504810810089,
-0.032436490058898926,
0.32428422570228577,
0.4747985899448395,
-0.3088478744029999,
0.2507888078689575,
-0.19196419417858124,
-0.6398448348045349,
-0.01509119477123022,
0.3222143054008484,
0.3026909828186035,
-0.02598339132964611,
0.5386531352996826,
0.6838345527648926,
0.350190669298172,
-0.5156793594360352,
0.7699038982391357,
-0.2603759467601776,
-0.43882113695144653,
-0.1610856056213379,
-0.059377629309892654,
0.1451656073331833,
0.20160970091819763,
0.23219826817512512,
0.07819171994924545,
0.2052905261516571,
-0.42559123039245605,
0.3835861384868622,
0.35238441824913025,
-0.6632872819900513,
-0.30507931113243103,
0.6472104787826538,
0.19666209816932678,
0.11345414817333221,
0.47100213170051575,
0.12334408611059189,
-0.3262976408004761,
0.49088621139526367,
0.4478954076766968,
0.44559764862060547,
-0.16875474154949188,
-0.010399488732218742,
0.2105902135372162,
0.2746947109699249,
-0.2627495229244232,
0.4379790425300598,
-0.11363273113965988,
-0.5627826452255249,
-0.4161434471607208,
-0.47961315512657166,
-0.0033799137454479933,
-0.03227200359106064,
-0.7985431551933289,
0.5869258046150208,
-0.4172697365283966,
0.16571594774723053,
0.07780833542346954,
-0.09034749865531921,
-0.5723881721496582,
0.601315975189209,
0.4186460077762604,
0.7441277503967285,
-0.542113184928894,
0.9434249401092529,
1.3149759769439697,
-0.47423264384269714,
-0.942062258720398,
-0.06520155072212219,
0.13281048834323883,
-1.1537615060806274,
0.4145536422729492,
0.3785903751850128,
-0.2458900809288025,
-0.12763243913650513,
-0.5407267808914185,
-0.6811500787734985,
1.1866780519485474,
0.6720491051673889,
-0.3367960751056671,
-0.7027130126953125,
-0.3226780593395233,
0.5123847723007202,
-0.6056410670280457,
-0.1600298136472702,
0.14712727069854736,
-0.019807780161499977,
0.4277508556842804,
-0.7723077535629272,
0.03660808131098747,
-0.23522424697875977,
-0.1330709308385849,
0.4086140990257263,
-0.3112969398498535,
0.31720882654190063,
-0.23811903595924377,
-0.3526351749897003,
-0.020663361996412277,
0.554465651512146,
0.28900378942489624,
0.1495462954044342,
0.5566717982292175,
0.4631311595439911,
0.4612438678741455,
-0.24172638356685638,
0.8963759541511536,
0.08836285024881363,
0.005009994376450777,
1.2092043161392212,
-0.055803533643484116,
0.6357171535491943,
0.5141730904579163,
0.21363772451877594,
0.6475094556808472,
0.5714907050132751,
-0.04450191557407379,
0.4847664535045624,
0.014248483814299107,
0.08071182668209076,
-0.25183209776878357,
-0.0914248377084732,
-0.531832754611969,
0.6357892155647278,
0.5072529315948486,
-0.5948059558868408,
-0.26412370800971985,
-0.19244974851608276,
-0.2160647064447403,
-0.0164096150547266,
-0.4514232873916626,
0.9240778088569641,
0.2014523297548294,
-0.31567057967185974,
0.41962167620658875,
-0.3592952489852905,
0.6127029061317444,
-0.7866202592849731,
-0.26194247603416443,
-0.007965289987623692,
0.16158168017864227,
-0.4387514293193817,
-0.6501192450523376,
0.5188363194465637,
-0.2944227457046509,
0.18609701097011566,
-0.39548343420028687,
0.650661051273346,
-0.6209456324577332,
-0.17858649790287018,
0.11726265400648117,
0.2691853940486908,
0.1407555192708969,
0.05535341426730156,
-0.4614514410495758,
-0.023869190365076065,
0.00482518645003438,
0.13040950894355774,
0.18920013308525085,
0.41357284784317017,
-0.04541373997926712,
0.2859339714050293,
0.26717114448547363,
0.2555275559425354,
-0.3382350504398346,
-0.037333324551582336,
0.8182646036148071,
-0.44284334778785706,
-0.7624717354774475,
-0.6003052592277527,
0.42706936597824097,
0.018732666969299316,
-0.22401189804077148,
0.1615210622549057,
0.5593777298927307,
0.9323159456253052,
0.11820585280656815,
0.26504430174827576,
-0.008013893850147724,
0.03556386008858681,
-0.8483229279518127,
0.7663455009460449,
-0.8981629014015198,
0.0913485661149025,
-0.27843883633613586,
-0.7054407000541687,
-0.9247864484786987,
0.978219747543335,
-0.2320965677499771,
-0.27562156319618225,
1.0053746700286865,
0.5501561164855957,
-0.0836794525384903,
-0.10399463027715683,
0.3072354793548584,
0.07727985829114914,
0.11628381162881851,
0.5378035306930542,
0.6438590288162231,
-0.2129729688167572,
0.5704286694526672,
-0.06559780985116959,
-0.24135249853134155,
-0.03792145475745201,
-0.6197938323020935,
-0.8518000841140747,
-0.6748465299606323,
-0.5632485747337341,
-0.30674004554748535,
0.034608371555805206,
0.9244555234909058,
1.0668662786483765,
-0.3546965718269348,
0.001542431302368641,
-0.04268870875239372,
-0.2255076766014099,
0.11824777722358704,
-0.030701985582709312,
0.9642686247825623,
-0.21044804155826569,
-0.21113334596157074,
0.38060617446899414,
0.8261152505874634,
0.18319639563560486,
0.037031687796115875,
-0.0534638911485672,
-0.0885922983288765,
-0.48763155937194824,
0.3589034974575043,
0.10641992837190628,
-0.7159467339515686,
-0.2774972915649414,
-0.0713212788105011,
-0.23718991875648499,
0.776161253452301,
0.8582503199577332,
-0.6693379878997803,
0.6089003682136536,
0.02251724898815155,
0.6335978507995605,
0.34519580006599426,
0.06385601311922073,
0.5212691426277161,
-0.9156011343002319,
0.010684852488338947,
0.5175468325614929,
0.6438551545143127,
0.4128434658050537,
-0.28307586908340454,
0.6094858646392822,
0.15255503356456757,
-0.19442875683307648,
-0.7650636434555054,
0.3600017726421356,
-0.9843834638595581,
-0.24013204872608185,
0.8554165363311768,
-0.3229391872882843,
-0.35473355650901794,
-0.013038689270615578,
-0.3548930287361145,
0.29822272062301636,
-0.031632620841264725,
0.542281985282898,
0.26751646399497986,
-0.4658341705799103,
-0.09386619180440903,
-0.08560618758201599,
0.6433680653572083,
0.34143197536468506,
-1.0769670009613037,
-0.3340190649032593,
0.7838138937950134,
0.32159334421157837,
0.23728786408901215,
0.8973060250282288,
-0.5451111197471619,
0.32396838068962097,
-0.2136441469192505,
0.12160135805606842,
0.00793385785073042,
-0.3712700307369232,
-0.5511403679847717,
0.06459356099367142,
0.027646420523524284,
-0.46677353978157043
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14690v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14690v1
|
Incorporating Graph Attention Mechanism into Geometric Problem Solving Based on Deep Reinforcement Learning
| 2024-03-14T11:00:09 | 2024-03-14T11:00:09 |
Xiuqin Zhong, Shengyuan Yan, Gongqi Lin, Hongguang Fu, Liang Xu, Siwen Jiang, Lei Huang, Wei Fang
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
In the context of online education, designing an automatic solver for
geometric problems has been considered a crucial step towards general math
Artificial Intelligence (AI), empowered by natural language understanding and
traditional logical inference. In most instances, problems are addressed by
adding auxiliary components such as lines or points. However, adding auxiliary
components automatically is challenging due to the complexity in selecting
suitable auxiliary components especially when pivotal decisions have to be
made. The state-of-the-art performance has been achieved by exhausting all
possible strategies from the category library to identify the one with the
maximum likelihood. However, an extensive strategy search have to be applied to
trade accuracy for ef-ficiency. To add auxiliary components automatically and
efficiently, we present deep reinforcement learning framework based on the
language model, such as BERT. We firstly apply the graph attention mechanism to
reduce the strategy searching space, called AttnStrategy, which only focus on
the conclusion-related components. Meanwhile, a novel algorithm, named
Automatically Adding Auxiliary Components using Reinforcement Learning
framework (A3C-RL), is proposed by forcing an agent to select top strategies,
which incorporates the AttnStrategy and BERT as the memory components. Results
from extensive experiments show that the proposed A3C-RL algorithm can
substantially enhance the average precision by 32.7% compared to the
traditional MCTS. In addition, the A3C-RL algorithm outperforms humans on the
geometric questions from the annual University Entrance Mathematical
Examination of China.
|
[
-0.634303629398346,
-1.3484355211257935,
0.7049034237861633,
0.08937855064868927,
-0.06758926063776016,
0.3232497572898865,
-0.21490594744682312,
-0.5179336667060852,
0.03328757360577583,
0.183920219540596,
-0.8803274631500244,
-0.46273547410964966,
-0.5347311496734619,
-0.12333178520202637,
0.15358330309391022,
0.40119126439094543,
-0.37513214349746704,
-0.08527331799268723,
-0.0018051783554255962,
-0.038225553929805756,
-0.4194270074367523,
-0.4274453818798065,
-1.1692688465118408,
-0.3407534658908844,
0.4493359625339508,
0.3574969470500946,
0.6146138310432434,
0.702725887298584,
0.7082133293151855,
0.4933052062988281,
0.06091941520571709,
0.4191214442253113,
-0.4868331551551819,
-0.1384429782629013,
-0.0003347667516209185,
-0.26027074456214905,
-0.28590822219848633,
-0.1552921086549759,
0.504344642162323,
0.6474851965904236,
-0.2116115540266037,
-0.17865288257598877,
0.22213317453861237,
0.7830029129981995,
-0.4172350764274597,
0.6197877526283264,
-0.2235661894083023,
0.3127197027206421,
0.2044471651315689,
-0.14617851376533508,
-0.35770949721336365,
-0.6939871311187744,
0.3616306185722351,
-1.1451973915100098,
0.11419335007667542,
-0.034039147198200226,
0.8383820056915283,
0.5706726908683777,
-0.19999192655086517,
-0.34214287996292114,
-0.5484552979469299,
0.6159342527389526,
-0.44238388538360596,
0.4462555944919586,
0.04910599812865257,
0.4859353303909302,
-0.3861654996871948,
-0.5871568918228149,
-0.2756127417087555,
-0.21680580079555511,
-0.04811817780137062,
0.17068345844745636,
-0.22793231904506683,
0.5135024189949036,
0.36180809140205383,
0.06727157533168793,
-0.44146063923835754,
0.08643311262130737,
-0.33691099286079407,
-0.15988337993621826,
0.6366186141967773,
0.11981090158224106,
0.19020117819309235,
0.08919420093297958,
-0.19524678587913513,
-0.32770949602127075,
-0.4869282841682434,
0.40512725710868835,
0.299505352973938,
0.2557411789894104,
0.17211447656154633,
0.5655608773231506,
-0.2211569845676422,
0.6106312274932861,
0.2842358648777008,
0.39560821652412415,
0.06034374609589577,
-0.05017215013504028,
-0.0652308240532875,
0.13554197549819946,
0.7328464984893799,
-0.06641114503145218,
0.4691094756126404,
0.09996778517961502,
0.007314146496355534,
0.10917700827121735,
0.4166351556777954,
-0.5134047269821167,
-0.4614408612251282,
-0.06089387461543083,
-0.31341347098350525,
-0.059016261249780655,
-0.1873520016670227,
-0.3734690845012665,
-0.0470905676484108,
-0.5728313326835632,
0.2944430410861969,
-0.6806828379631042,
0.11671287566423416,
0.13420066237449646,
0.188607856631279,
0.09036831557750702,
0.5075781941413879,
-0.577163577079773,
0.4173734188079834,
0.7033601999282837,
0.7376097440719604,
-0.09853489696979523,
-0.29975923895835876,
-0.7095675468444824,
0.13969700038433075,
-0.4028688669204712,
0.9392060041427612,
-0.47506698966026306,
-0.2533927261829376,
0.005564440041780472,
-0.18846771121025085,
-0.12914855778217316,
-0.2859369218349457,
0.30284741520881653,
-0.4419313967227936,
0.23844678699970245,
-0.3577958643436432,
-0.6150543093681335,
-0.575676441192627,
0.43432924151420593,
-0.8076165318489075,
1.0330932140350342,
-0.023299839347600937,
-0.30451738834381104,
0.20167574286460876,
-0.8938174843788147,
-0.44013547897338867,
0.17076465487480164,
-0.3143148720264435,
-0.6390843987464905,
-0.01723182015120983,
0.6718524694442749,
0.3793507218360901,
0.13231602311134338,
0.06200697645545006,
-0.7089812159538269,
-0.38417914509773254,
0.3527987599372864,
-0.2966131865978241,
0.580004870891571,
-0.03868205472826958,
-0.3103621006011963,
0.40642839670181274,
-0.41933298110961914,
0.2886964678764343,
0.24315232038497925,
-0.26331114768981934,
0.014315000735223293,
0.113496795296669,
-0.3119813799858093,
0.365876168012619,
0.049842510372400284,
-0.42808350920677185,
0.08485347032546997,
-0.721555233001709,
0.3381294310092926,
1.0622974634170532,
0.13173876702785492,
0.3316991329193115,
-0.13523058593273163,
0.4382617771625519,
-0.5060132741928101,
0.15668509900569916,
0.42162755131721497,
-0.5158617496490479,
-0.9654799699783325,
-0.18953488767147064,
0.02408256195485592,
0.467075377702713,
-0.9060089588165283,
0.4210784137248993,
-0.04328015819191933,
-0.10950759798288345,
-0.33936989307403564,
0.028803614899516106,
0.5582939386367798,
0.296631395816803,
0.30379247665405273,
-0.3767641484737396,
-0.3000209629535675,
-0.6844336986541748,
-0.06390903890132904,
-0.0064047956839203835,
0.018254613503813744,
0.6764795184135437,
0.1341116577386856,
0.10728994756937027,
0.8587590456008911,
-0.8849941492080688,
-0.5919889211654663,
-0.21817094087600708,
0.31385621428489685,
0.042488403618335724,
0.2520045340061188,
0.4269177317619324,
-0.34625375270843506,
-0.4680604040622711,
0.14175501465797424,
-0.8390493392944336,
0.23518051207065582,
0.12410479784011841,
-0.32152995467185974,
0.3154023289680481,
0.39259210228919983,
-0.5749943256378174,
0.5028957724571228,
0.10577015578746796,
-0.29252880811691284,
0.21367929875850677,
-0.4025801420211792,
-0.11908236891031265,
-0.45625555515289307,
-0.11945145577192307,
0.3674919903278351,
-0.16794461011886597,
-0.24927465617656708,
0.2452666461467743,
-0.17842935025691986,
-0.4110316336154938,
-0.470646470785141,
0.5661823153495789,
-0.2773955166339874,
-0.27901116013526917,
-0.26115602254867554,
0.20698970556259155,
-0.08227451145648956,
1.1479496955871582,
0.04757291451096535,
0.5286862850189209,
0.3530229926109314,
-0.8609601855278015,
0.7899900078773499,
0.2859654426574707,
-0.015446124598383904,
0.3980118930339813,
-0.5648954510688782,
0.13739202916622162,
-0.1639961153268814,
0.4232294261455536,
-0.9689992666244507,
0.10251224786043167,
0.6584067344665527,
-0.5191468000411987,
0.4068240225315094,
-0.00027667987160384655,
-0.2498912662267685,
-0.5911139249801636,
-0.2246866524219513,
0.3711565434932709,
0.17001402378082275,
-0.47410839796066284,
0.7796555757522583,
0.2291904240846634,
-0.30128633975982666,
-0.5621859431266785,
-0.30862531065940857,
-0.22090020775794983,
0.0931297019124031,
-0.5676952004432678,
0.18871524930000305,
-0.04306825250387192,
0.1655990481376648,
0.45888662338256836,
0.0076303668320178986,
0.04101324826478958,
0.2647128105163574,
-0.3096947968006134,
0.25098103284835815,
-0.03400406986474991,
0.06202360987663269,
-0.15662918984889984,
-0.6331171989440918,
0.327892541885376,
-0.5210791230201721,
0.5351670384407043,
-0.28767818212509155,
-0.576988697052002,
-0.6771764159202576,
0.3305341899394989,
0.048191800713539124,
-0.17918068170547485,
0.07714764028787613,
0.6810323596000671,
-0.3592775762081146,
-0.14257214963436127,
-0.4482022225856781,
-0.3198082149028778,
-0.5371605157852173,
0.812354564666748,
-0.46006131172180176,
-0.6647524833679199,
0.4958428740501404,
0.04767865687608719,
0.003557686461135745,
0.40353667736053467,
0.4427122473716736,
-0.12869790196418762,
1.4894909858703613,
0.5399710536003113,
-0.041929829865694046,
0.5915490984916687,
-0.6243739128112793,
0.31017500162124634,
-0.7247280478477478,
-0.3245178163051605,
-0.3224966824054718,
-0.5217456221580505,
-0.5375171303749084,
-0.39675408601760864,
0.3463433086872101,
-0.20997779071331024,
-0.519329845905304,
0.27068156003952026,
-0.812785267829895,
0.5116637945175171,
0.7401115894317627,
0.40565571188926697,
0.14812873303890228,
0.1178341805934906,
-0.223872572183609,
-0.06032305955886841,
-0.8812583088874817,
0.1921464502811432,
1.0163391828536987,
0.43568921089172363,
0.7044524550437927,
0.0690595954656601,
0.5202906727790833,
0.1760779470205307,
0.09175961464643478,
-1.0418504476547241,
0.6377788186073303,
-0.08777365833520889,
-0.1476864516735077,
-0.6249231100082397,
-0.592988133430481,
-0.7185682654380798,
0.20239801704883575,
0.07858690619468689,
-0.6632999777793884,
0.0597759373486042,
0.215310201048851,
-0.6065686345100403,
0.14351314306259155,
-0.5599245429039001,
0.7950770854949951,
-0.6467168927192688,
-0.4557855725288391,
-0.5108986496925354,
-0.2686474323272705,
0.08428184688091278,
0.4340727925300598,
0.021606262773275375,
-0.18478666245937347,
0.14598098397254944,
0.6848715543746948,
-0.3529570698738098,
0.5900552272796631,
-0.2491753250360489,
-0.11041966080665588,
0.24135589599609375,
0.17295601963996887,
0.9502753019332886,
0.010985550470650196,
0.46832433342933655,
-0.12896046042442322,
-0.662172257900238,
-0.40708908438682556,
-0.8247037529945374,
0.7363083958625793,
-0.9795516133308411,
-0.5635870695114136,
-0.5259081721305847,
-0.5008712410926819,
-0.31059151887893677,
0.14936378598213196,
-0.018962731584906578,
0.3356461524963379,
-0.1304832547903061,
-0.06041387841105461,
0.8869307637214661,
-0.17134568095207214,
0.5981199145317078,
0.15570200979709625,
-0.007809121627360582,
-0.5823791027069092,
1.2931181192398071,
0.1635255515575409,
-0.06437651813030243,
0.335735559463501,
0.17028874158859253,
-0.6240240335464478,
-0.4130248427391052,
-0.49667224287986755,
0.29019102454185486,
-0.7929578423500061,
-0.08575067669153214,
-0.5824858546257019,
-0.4874434173107147,
-0.08366569131612778,
-0.5108423829078674,
-0.3772241175174713,
-0.36362460255622864,
-0.12673434615135193,
-0.1283392310142517,
0.20785599946975708,
0.6295222043991089,
0.035697393119335175,
0.08171691000461578,
-0.5236881375312805,
0.3062789738178253,
0.6395207643508911,
0.6206324100494385,
0.26668107509613037,
0.008082399144768715,
-0.1787685602903366,
0.09892667829990387,
-0.585039496421814,
-0.40608763694763184,
0.38451775908470154,
-0.016268640756607056,
0.7952731847763062,
0.4180622398853302,
-0.20907427370548248,
0.750067412853241,
-0.34264758229255676,
0.17690503597259521,
0.20775926113128662,
-0.8244158029556274,
0.30304810404777527,
-0.3358268737792969,
0.13032320141792297,
0.16585129499435425,
0.2393111288547516,
-0.3819979429244995,
-0.3976941704750061,
-0.658784806728363,
-0.8588466644287109,
1.0288881063461304,
0.3679408133029938,
-0.363766610622406,
0.23105378448963165,
0.11731180548667908,
-0.4534359574317932,
-0.06950422376394272,
-0.6431245803833008,
-0.2089400440454483,
-0.2845889925956726,
-0.39079704880714417,
0.03555901721119881,
0.04911622032523155,
-0.014210282824933529,
-0.3345935344696045,
0.873835027217865,
-0.32739999890327454,
0.5980385541915894,
0.08602465689182281,
-0.16917917132377625,
-0.17769750952720642,
-0.034114737063646317,
0.4745016396045685,
0.559028148651123,
-0.199439138174057,
-0.47543203830718994,
0.2672640085220337,
-0.14845365285873413,
0.14625920355319977,
0.4803147614002228,
0.03270233795046806,
-0.27325984835624695,
0.1790594607591629,
0.8837904334068298,
0.37830302119255066,
-0.4856403172016144,
0.1951509267091751,
-0.12478185445070267,
-0.4161430299282074,
-0.47072386741638184,
0.0493231862783432,
-0.22814099490642548,
0.2751609981060028,
0.5153341889381409,
-0.1356409788131714,
0.3278457224369049,
-0.26637473702430725,
0.2395051121711731,
0.5753283500671387,
-0.7795912623405457,
0.09321627020835876,
0.46377530694007874,
0.3753719925880432,
-0.20781242847442627,
0.7261534333229065,
-0.24608585238456726,
-0.9394238591194153,
0.8538987636566162,
0.23141424357891083,
0.9020372033119202,
-0.09998026490211487,
0.3253881335258484,
0.48268958926200867,
0.15943196415901184,
0.2210632711648941,
0.13903942704200745,
-0.03555147722363472,
-0.6213707327842712,
-0.7828019261360168,
-0.17326687276363373,
-0.4258597493171692,
-0.06335709989070892,
-0.2637336254119873,
0.058841850608587265,
-0.7454639673233032,
0.05294020101428032,
-0.22888785600662231,
0.47136378288269043,
-0.7182658910751343,
0.1069907546043396,
0.33468687534332275,
0.3256332278251648,
-0.46915188431739807,
0.3289194107055664,
0.6680576801300049,
-0.2236110270023346,
-0.9128137826919556,
-0.3380391597747803,
0.05010250583291054,
-0.9230126142501831,
0.5548009872436523,
0.20645242929458618,
-0.2537268102169037,
0.2062058299779892,
-0.20752011239528656,
-1.1303738355636597,
0.8211763501167297,
0.17655612528324127,
-0.43689560890197754,
-0.29671722650527954,
0.014247438870370388,
0.2786027789115906,
-0.20402361452579498,
0.40220385789871216,
0.36740195751190186,
0.49044492840766907,
0.4975021183490753,
-0.6106249690055847,
0.16992653906345367,
-0.23168709874153137,
0.10091808438301086,
0.5145448446273804,
-0.6349213719367981,
0.7902208566665649,
-0.12470204383134842,
-0.20594455301761627,
-0.24959427118301392,
0.5927721858024597,
0.3812585771083832,
0.09488767385482788,
0.3199346363544464,
0.83348548412323,
0.6416944861412048,
-0.2532096803188324,
0.944915771484375,
-0.06732767075300217,
0.5951899886131287,
0.8442040085792542,
-0.08381813019514084,
0.3593328297138214,
0.059572502970695496,
-0.2752746343612671,
0.47191184759140015,
0.868263304233551,
-0.0024058178532868624,
0.5303443670272827,
0.3019894063472748,
-0.016786720603704453,
-0.46106651425361633,
0.01835579425096512,
-0.4960818588733673,
0.2551732063293457,
0.5722436308860779,
0.033962443470954895,
-0.558234691619873,
0.06380034238100052,
-0.1393793821334839,
0.03333020955324173,
-0.4162105321884155,
1.1111396551132202,
-0.008205885998904705,
-0.553406298160553,
0.37001052498817444,
-0.06668586283922195,
0.19695128500461578,
-0.5258407592773438,
-0.3248153626918793,
-0.01633577048778534,
0.5852270126342773,
0.09098111838102341,
-0.8044862151145935,
0.09288608282804489,
-0.5473254919052124,
0.20334258675575256,
-0.049192819744348526,
0.5512736439704895,
-0.3346991240978241,
-0.8544275164604187,
0.29254722595214844,
0.2813635766506195,
-0.3495134115219116,
-0.07717552036046982,
-1.0905512571334839,
-0.10332794487476349,
-0.13339175283908844,
-0.22347497940063477,
0.09357873350381851,
0.6882212162017822,
0.03357171267271042,
1.0119577646255493,
0.8467615246772766,
-0.05793081223964691,
-0.0680621787905693,
-0.14410576224327087,
1.0950583219528198,
-0.554499089717865,
-1.001144289970398,
-0.593995213508606,
0.2748167812824249,
-0.35544347763061523,
-0.07671397179365158,
0.5857700109481812,
0.4750473201274872,
0.9859787821769714,
0.24386334419250488,
0.7555891275405884,
0.16575418412685394,
0.26998376846313477,
-0.7039358615875244,
0.4576970040798187,
-0.2897777259349823,
0.07224435359239578,
-0.39006850123405457,
-1.0171260833740234,
-0.3558095097541809,
1.003014326095581,
-0.4914681613445282,
0.06417427957057953,
1.0529769659042358,
0.3848681151866913,
-0.12134690582752228,
-0.1364479809999466,
-0.009218408726155758,
0.0861918106675148,
0.5368139147758484,
1.1461836099624634,
0.6739428043365479,
-0.23763999342918396,
0.7842052578926086,
-0.5066975355148315,
-0.12301551550626755,
-0.45538565516471863,
-0.5536049604415894,
-0.9032998085021973,
-0.19077648222446442,
-0.3514484167098999,
-0.3618530333042145,
0.26215603947639465,
1.0316334962844849,
0.511175811290741,
-0.7105797529220581,
-0.11859095841646194,
-0.4605642259120941,
0.31334754824638367,
-0.5737276077270508,
-0.2490437775850296,
0.8034617304801941,
-0.6661591529846191,
-0.6236622929573059,
0.16862280666828156,
0.2458852231502533,
0.08396431803703308,
-0.2606637179851532,
-0.4484696686267853,
-0.1793278604745865,
-0.07980664074420929,
0.4999801218509674,
0.4338800609111786,
-0.7661497592926025,
-0.5082292556762695,
0.05406436324119568,
0.032867033034563065,
0.1472805142402649,
1.054499864578247,
-0.843441367149353,
0.46996837854385376,
0.3392259180545807,
0.9086421132087708,
0.7027678489685059,
0.007864262908697128,
0.7791461944580078,
-0.634493887424469,
0.19579437375068665,
0.3525334894657135,
0.3443555533885956,
0.12104342132806778,
-0.504711389541626,
0.42917606234550476,
0.2874346375465393,
-0.3198220431804657,
-0.24532561004161835,
0.37886175513267517,
-0.6958602070808411,
-0.35243821144104004,
0.7037771344184875,
-0.06647147983312607,
-0.38791173696517944,
-0.22246907651424408,
-0.3302031457424164,
0.43147483468055725,
-0.6993125081062317,
1.012912392616272,
0.6606874465942383,
-0.3378332257270813,
-0.32304155826568604,
-0.21710094809532166,
0.6419298648834229,
0.4258742034435272,
-0.695526123046875,
-0.0623256079852581,
0.6770346760749817,
-0.2612361013889313,
-0.034227143973112106,
0.39833876490592957,
0.2611733376979828,
0.6489322781562805,
-0.3795255124568939,
-0.0414569191634655,
-0.5279509425163269,
-0.5022047758102417,
-0.12344372272491455,
0.2401447892189026,
-0.1328997164964676,
-0.36240389943122864
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.12092v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.12092v1
|
Methods for Matching English Language Addresses
| 2024-03-14T10:39:14 | 2024-03-14T10:39:14 |
Keshav Ramani, Daniel Borrajo
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Addresses occupy a niche location within the landscape of textual data, due
to the positional importance carried by every word, and the geographical scope
it refers to. The task of matching addresses happens everyday and is present in
various fields like mail redirection, entity resolution, etc. Our work defines,
and formalizes a framework to generate matching and mismatching pairs of
addresses in the English language, and use it to evaluate various methods to
automatically perform address matching. These methods vary widely from distance
based approaches to deep learning models. By studying the Precision, Recall and
Accuracy metrics of these approaches, we obtain an understanding of the best
suited method for this setting of the address matching task.
|
[
-0.2539338767528534,
-0.3838563859462738,
0.36321839690208435,
0.04463775083422661,
0.19877402484416962,
-0.19455590844154358,
0.07509772479534149,
-0.8833709359169006,
0.1266668140888214,
0.3819723129272461,
-0.3261117935180664,
-0.41474226117134094,
-0.1675603687763214,
0.19238410890102386,
-0.23403015732765198,
0.48577865958213806,
-0.12496280670166016,
-0.20957058668136597,
-0.223861962556839,
-0.36211511492729187,
-0.8809612989425659,
-0.6265786290168762,
-0.6250277161598206,
0.06344781816005707,
0.2859404683113098,
0.49255621433258057,
0.6329751014709473,
1.0108541250228882,
0.7751714587211609,
0.38250160217285156,
0.3229333162307739,
0.4014509916305542,
-0.30849918723106384,
0.17532184720039368,
-0.49399974942207336,
-0.3530852198600769,
0.004580107983201742,
-0.06430687010288239,
0.5606021881103516,
0.8656732439994812,
0.13130798935890198,
0.18300636112689972,
-0.394923597574234,
0.5845542550086975,
-0.8345007300376892,
-0.344379186630249,
-0.908832311630249,
0.15594691038131714,
-0.5774716138839722,
-0.47677454352378845,
-0.3706185221672058,
-0.6623515486717224,
0.16423121094703674,
-0.3761398494243622,
0.6404281258583069,
0.5199270844459534,
0.952233076095581,
-0.14040634036064148,
-0.39571917057037354,
-0.5904287695884705,
-0.7639921307563782,
0.4007146656513214,
-0.42233580350875854,
0.5081169605255127,
0.6741777658462524,
0.5841173529624939,
-0.1906849592924118,
-0.10755717754364014,
-0.2948407828807831,
0.16385573148727417,
-0.4850863218307495,
-0.1634472906589508,
0.11400637030601501,
0.11757996678352356,
0.3129258453845978,
0.6502690315246582,
-0.5510726571083069,
0.018524114042520523,
-0.39521801471710205,
-0.03367673605680466,
0.6238992810249329,
0.1903952956199646,
0.4103480577468872,
0.2688556909561157,
-0.09754045307636261,
-0.1286439299583435,
-0.6114774942398071,
-0.10626288503408432,
0.616363525390625,
0.4240257441997528,
0.1129201352596283,
0.4577828645706177,
-0.22309930622577667,
0.855193018913269,
0.1384771168231964,
-0.19010111689567566,
0.23905791342258453,
-0.2088310569524765,
-0.3731076419353485,
0.26721203327178955,
0.5788013935089111,
0.4730748236179352,
0.30900079011917114,
-0.2526271343231201,
-0.2107289433479309,
-0.10430772602558136,
0.1777430921792984,
-0.3603765368461609,
-0.13921710848808289,
0.14659756422042847,
-0.3088819682598114,
-0.18681849539279938,
0.12759408354759216,
-0.47251415252685547,
-0.031740620732307434,
-0.32726573944091797,
0.1355605125427246,
-0.26564615964889526,
0.1240030825138092,
0.0758645087480545,
0.01835109107196331,
0.34030789136886597,
0.306670218706131,
-1.2662413120269775,
0.3223845064640045,
0.8557142019271851,
0.47397613525390625,
-0.15593595802783966,
-0.479116827249527,
-0.24855145812034607,
0.28177762031555176,
-0.3742535412311554,
0.8575164079666138,
-0.5447277426719666,
0.015248731710016727,
0.42618870735168457,
-0.052748870104551315,
-0.03633725643157959,
-0.8856395483016968,
0.2807239890098572,
-0.7526156902313232,
0.41767314076423645,
-0.031244993209838867,
-0.6556569933891296,
-0.1155814602971077,
0.4096834361553192,
-0.7991193532943726,
1.1704931259155273,
-0.012787580490112305,
-0.8025972247123718,
-0.009846385568380356,
-0.6578110456466675,
-0.7600732445716858,
0.11389756202697754,
0.43988680839538574,
-0.10143237560987473,
0.31227418780326843,
-0.038394518196582794,
0.5136073231697083,
-0.19911962747573853,
-0.029072396457195282,
-0.10622178763151169,
-0.22115829586982727,
-0.04917676001787186,
-0.3262433707714081,
0.7189661860466003,
0.42373549938201904,
-0.12486724555492401,
-0.42218509316444397,
-0.8536424040794373,
-0.12069754302501678,
0.09290161728858948,
-0.17553718388080597,
-0.7462627291679382,
-0.022016698494553566,
0.060065582394599915,
0.03514125570654869,
0.5688591599464417,
-0.1861366480588913,
-0.010515494272112846,
-0.5177944898605347,
0.30092206597328186,
0.3838249742984772,
-0.04798341542482376,
0.5584895610809326,
-0.43494537472724915,
0.33722159266471863,
-0.011254111304879189,
-0.30926164984703064,
-0.40041384100914,
-0.2829616367816925,
-0.425506591796875,
-0.006963932421058416,
0.6565924286842346,
0.9824917912483215,
0.06068442761898041,
0.4362671971321106,
-0.43726739287376404,
-0.7080193758010864,
-0.9323088526725769,
-0.045669179409742355,
0.35893452167510986,
0.34335339069366455,
0.3249032199382782,
-0.13248227536678314,
-0.7356811165809631,
-0.9156814813613892,
-0.4669046700000763,
0.0705651044845581,
-0.11082347482442856,
0.7289440631866455,
0.03297162428498268,
-0.23280611634254456,
0.77998286485672,
-0.4444606602191925,
-0.12670423090457916,
0.20852501690387726,
-0.3387702405452728,
0.038255054503679276,
0.38182517886161804,
0.6547917127609253,
-0.724219799041748,
-0.6704948544502258,
0.17817488312721252,
-0.6926702260971069,
-0.23488196730613708,
-0.04092194512486458,
-0.29645952582359314,
0.15935787558555603,
0.3734670877456665,
-0.3791795074939728,
0.2999042570590973,
0.3475205600261688,
-0.3319675326347351,
0.07609865069389343,
-0.23107321560382843,
0.6483927965164185,
-1.2923210859298706,
0.12097270041704178,
0.14622248709201813,
-0.6042532324790955,
-0.6577823758125305,
0.2757043242454529,
0.006871378514915705,
-0.12349525839090347,
-0.5038201212882996,
0.6981302499771118,
-0.7561003565788269,
-0.30440518260002136,
-0.025755712762475014,
0.46345949172973633,
-0.010055482387542725,
0.008724784478545189,
0.07948575913906097,
0.6774939894676208,
0.15483202040195465,
-0.49352186918258667,
0.6222720146179199,
0.17256812751293182,
-0.10336422920227051,
0.8545458316802979,
-0.16210119426250458,
0.2772967219352722,
-0.24233794212341309,
-0.20690710842609406,
-1.3357890844345093,
-0.0709548220038414,
-0.008244619704782963,
-0.4440467953681946,
0.23384353518486023,
0.01399102434515953,
-0.514901340007782,
-0.3606867790222168,
-0.0792754739522934,
0.792546272277832,
0.3707604706287384,
-0.6957451701164246,
0.4183485805988312,
0.4088362455368042,
-0.31214502453804016,
-0.7393004298210144,
-0.41447269916534424,
0.16393916308879852,
-0.3373837471008301,
-0.3864005506038666,
0.5848411917686462,
-0.06424408406019211,
-0.3167054057121277,
-0.1123446375131607,
0.23152777552604675,
-0.22034534811973572,
0.2277282327413559,
-0.1490176022052765,
0.054021190851926804,
-0.24542205035686493,
-0.18751084804534912,
-0.35038748383522034,
-0.11315187811851501,
-0.0934479758143425,
-0.27138692140579224,
0.04997999966144562,
0.33272165060043335,
-0.3664815425872803,
-0.4355934262275696,
0.8949882984161377,
0.7145615220069885,
-0.2363402545452118,
0.520404577255249,
-0.265645295381546,
-0.9637376070022583,
-0.003587667364627123,
-0.966335117816925,
0.07926999032497406,
-0.4271138608455658,
0.22815905511379242,
-0.6337801814079285,
-0.4544582664966583,
0.5807482600212097,
0.004690011031925678,
0.10642680525779724,
0.27981898188591003,
0.3588821589946747,
-0.18219426274299622,
0.297333687543869,
0.7355836033821106,
-0.44520410895347595,
0.05501934513449669,
0.446237176656723,
0.6141182780265808,
-0.3645140528678894,
-0.11991672217845917,
-1.1097410917282104,
-0.487201064825058,
-0.4771236181259155,
-0.13188759982585907,
-0.4181097745895386,
0.00039082032162696123,
0.15016303956508636,
0.9300366640090942,
-0.7360950708389282,
0.902319610118866,
0.6879526972770691,
-0.5021560788154602,
-0.023379236459732056,
0.09371928125619888,
-0.45217713713645935,
-0.22732526063919067,
-0.6020025014877319,
-0.2625640332698822,
0.6087473034858704,
0.3168652355670929,
0.5456916093826294,
0.36456313729286194,
0.4708034098148346,
0.1596541851758957,
0.1394023299217224,
-0.3276398181915283,
0.4440527558326721,
-0.100516177713871,
-0.38416215777397156,
-0.2887932360172272,
-0.12755447626113892,
-1.3030647039413452,
-0.053420230746269226,
-0.2100454866886139,
-0.5318083167076111,
-0.02037612907588482,
0.2856735587120056,
0.0009852999355643988,
0.21825763583183289,
-0.6644186973571777,
0.8879483342170715,
-0.1575230062007904,
-0.1308578997850418,
0.3609880805015564,
-0.6822120547294617,
-0.04123678058385849,
-0.02359314262866974,
0.275553822517395,
0.07660555839538574,
0.4375854432582855,
0.489740252494812,
-0.06096683815121651,
0.587433934211731,
-0.021358976140618324,
-0.17399156093597412,
-0.06712698936462402,
0.25140857696533203,
0.5314791202545166,
-0.33343714475631714,
-0.06092889979481697,
0.2570055425167084,
0.10934348404407501,
-0.3090842664241791,
-0.23268665373325348,
0.892773449420929,
-0.5624670386314392,
-0.17935408651828766,
-0.23855583369731903,
-0.7402973175048828,
0.013106483034789562,
0.19432216882705688,
0.2715192139148712,
0.2278938591480255,
-0.2145226001739502,
-0.17649061977863312,
0.8100343942642212,
0.05671340972185135,
0.38036054372787476,
0.5103926062583923,
0.21580104529857635,
-0.31552159786224365,
0.635516881942749,
0.11787641793489456,
-0.22219093143939972,
1.0140548944473267,
-0.19137586653232574,
-0.6798639893531799,
-0.24446269869804382,
-0.24267973005771637,
0.1894768476486206,
-0.6918232440948486,
-0.5914164781570435,
-0.3888930082321167,
-0.2504342496395111,
-0.5577900409698486,
-0.6147682666778564,
-0.13216227293014526,
-0.05525507405400276,
-0.0421309657394886,
0.12246964126825333,
0.25798094272613525,
0.7221435904502869,
0.14613290131092072,
-0.2426738440990448,
-0.7470340132713318,
0.3075408935546875,
0.2580239772796631,
0.4678612947463989,
-0.2445240318775177,
-0.18207776546478271,
-0.03801847621798515,
-0.03367002680897713,
-0.06715893000364304,
-1.1916253566741943,
0.1332513689994812,
0.3094545304775238,
0.6846910119056702,
0.19563040137290955,
-0.03243279829621315,
0.8461132049560547,
-1.1090056896209717,
0.4925731122493744,
-0.2822192311286926,
-0.6390650868415833,
0.9001220464706421,
-0.03696274012327194,
0.19241978228092194,
0.7940940260887146,
0.7010275721549988,
-0.6871620416641235,
-0.2816637456417084,
-0.7332421541213989,
-0.8763912320137024,
0.23681727051734924,
0.0682314783334732,
0.07695046812295914,
-0.44061416387557983,
0.6837559342384338,
-0.1389581710100174,
0.10344811528921127,
-0.5238946080207825,
-0.4804916977882385,
0.5307632088661194,
-0.7704576253890991,
-0.20486484467983246,
-0.24309584498405457,
-0.0600346215069294,
0.05850997194647789,
0.6197683215141296,
0.16286487877368927,
0.49375566840171814,
-0.10689739882946014,
-0.16114453971385956,
-0.0747278556227684,
0.11698433011770248,
0.8380593657493591,
0.4762221574783325,
-0.06346529722213745,
0.10064572840929031,
0.3297836184501648,
-0.43103235960006714,
0.3990897834300995,
0.20064112544059753,
-0.4390779137611389,
0.6117581129074097,
0.1447736769914627,
0.47054845094680786,
-0.03178722411394119,
-0.5897829532623291,
0.7929309606552124,
0.13813233375549316,
-0.1784643679857254,
-0.43348515033721924,
-0.1147693321108818,
0.11641626805067062,
-0.24770742654800415,
0.25171804428100586,
0.10154902935028076,
0.24930565059185028,
-0.3764931559562683,
0.12800230085849762,
0.785975456237793,
-0.3306135833263397,
-0.07213091850280762,
0.5917686223983765,
0.37165096402168274,
-1.285444974899292,
0.5944041013717651,
-0.12482402473688126,
-0.5252411961555481,
0.5295772552490234,
0.8500075936317444,
0.8852924704551697,
-0.6113977432250977,
-0.4983299970626831,
0.5070443153381348,
0.25343477725982666,
-0.13917531073093414,
-0.12403824925422668,
-0.0008669072994962335,
-0.7005770206451416,
-0.19899193942546844,
-0.28111574053764343,
-0.3678429126739502,
0.21865351498126984,
-0.5926242470741272,
0.40907028317451477,
-0.19996336102485657,
0.3676762580871582,
0.13080358505249023,
-0.183275505900383,
-0.9666745066642761,
0.4045342803001404,
0.2642279267311096,
1.2225850820541382,
-1.1428985595703125,
0.5833113789558411,
1.11704683303833,
0.3461301624774933,
-0.6433908939361572,
-0.10113923996686935,
0.004401718731969595,
-0.663960337638855,
0.6136218905448914,
0.35823479294776917,
-0.37744393944740295,
-0.07487297058105469,
0.006328532472252846,
-0.7860207557678223,
0.9266397953033447,
0.07956513017416,
-0.677667498588562,
0.20811377465724945,
0.24337522685527802,
0.4472000002861023,
-0.5353724360466003,
0.31620311737060547,
0.5749018788337708,
0.07938908785581589,
-0.08096279203891754,
-1.0060136318206787,
-0.03266066312789917,
-0.40022337436676025,
0.26598218083381653,
0.623076856136322,
-0.27746304869651794,
0.21326574683189392,
0.07171082496643066,
-0.065676748752594,
-0.0059069739654660225,
0.536067008972168,
0.23234856128692627,
0.053890299052000046,
0.2584742307662964,
0.8785094022750854,
0.9475727677345276,
-0.07779498398303986,
0.4033282995223999,
-0.48977985978126526,
0.45546042919158936,
0.9819028377532959,
-0.6552274823188782,
1.0442192554473877,
0.3653653562068939,
-0.4211198389530182,
0.30607888102531433,
0.5523664355278015,
-0.0893227756023407,
0.6528021693229675,
0.5844149589538574,
-0.05195479467511177,
0.3545081913471222,
0.22126181423664093,
-0.4055580496788025,
0.07273631542921066,
0.29466676712036133,
-0.30835387110710144,
-0.3168673813343048,
0.0023437044583261013,
-0.19378359615802765,
0.4967862069606781,
-0.14360064268112183,
1.0476540327072144,
-0.5243718028068542,
-0.8269128203392029,
0.44096750020980835,
0.2807427644729614,
0.7141135931015015,
-0.2966841459274292,
-0.0983344316482544,
-0.48115304112434387,
0.07074454426765442,
0.15574927628040314,
-0.5770490765571594,
0.5767216682434082,
-0.2288893610239029,
-0.5313160419464111,
-0.19964177906513214,
0.7236636877059937,
-0.6080702543258667,
-0.30505165457725525,
0.12043281644582748,
-0.1718759387731552,
0.4049684703350067,
0.2739091217517853,
-0.6754344701766968,
-0.1990641951560974,
-0.10103443264961243,
0.2688838839530945,
0.211289644241333,
0.9248736500740051,
0.08830862492322922,
0.49715444445610046,
0.3669714331626892,
0.08329837024211884,
0.05653202906250954,
-0.24407421052455902,
0.02870294451713562,
-0.714842677116394,
-0.712593674659729,
-0.748836874961853,
0.11400188505649567,
-0.17244534194469452,
-0.39321422576904297,
0.6029386520385742,
1.0278089046478271,
0.9707633256912231,
-0.3114030957221985,
0.6966226100921631,
0.10602962225675583,
0.7682183384895325,
-0.37852343916893005,
0.2308763712644577,
-0.26190415024757385,
0.32944607734680176,
-0.11375585198402405,
-1.3228907585144043,
-0.4804408550262451,
1.0249325037002563,
-0.14369386434555054,
-0.15003685653209686,
0.6839430928230286,
0.8069279193878174,
-0.37915608286857605,
-0.3938206136226654,
0.2978225648403168,
-0.17406703531742096,
-0.15870745480060577,
0.973212480545044,
0.4644662141799927,
-1.0899335145950317,
0.28283655643463135,
-0.08341002464294434,
-0.11218878626823425,
-0.5420911908149719,
-1.0159461498260498,
-0.7233111262321472,
-0.691717267036438,
-0.513937771320343,
-0.49468472599983215,
0.27739107608795166,
0.9676693677902222,
0.7364187240600586,
-1.0226398706436157,
-0.13982073962688446,
0.17419129610061646,
-0.05912493169307709,
-0.29816702008247375,
-0.16655604541301727,
0.4236610233783722,
-0.16391432285308838,
-0.7882458567619324,
0.0978269875049591,
0.5092548131942749,
0.4765225648880005,
-0.054841186851263046,
0.26371756196022034,
-0.4647260308265686,
0.12326304614543915,
0.3409152328968048,
0.5124258399009705,
-0.7796117067337036,
-0.6032339930534363,
0.21229258179664612,
-0.8780223727226257,
0.11679760366678238,
0.6761490106582642,
-0.6797692775726318,
0.028569452464580536,
0.6643810272216797,
1.1376177072525024,
-0.20687204599380493,
0.21631138026714325,
0.5325453281402588,
-1.0136693716049194,
0.2890348434448242,
0.056432176381349564,
0.2894321084022522,
0.6036775708198547,
-0.7827416658401489,
0.5039796233177185,
0.11657404899597168,
-0.5329311490058899,
-0.6807226538658142,
0.21404151618480682,
-0.8492014408111572,
-0.08655570447444916,
0.9132329821586609,
-0.05069049075245857,
-0.13094119727611542,
-0.4228969216346741,
-0.2570662200450897,
-0.3462566137313843,
0.23228535056114197,
0.6267749071121216,
0.9394705891609192,
0.44233018159866333,
-0.34625986218452454,
-0.5293624997138977,
0.6339473724365234,
0.22687391936779022,
-0.7791259288787842,
-0.06771582365036011,
0.25750643014907837,
0.46921220421791077,
0.4034910500049591,
0.74851393699646,
0.14489175379276276,
0.335114449262619,
-0.30208298563957214,
0.14334550499916077,
0.28737765550613403,
-0.3873739242553711,
-0.04493235424160957,
0.3775058686733246,
0.09630820155143738,
-0.33077168464660645
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09259v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09259v1
|
To Label or Not to Label: Hybrid Active Learning for Neural Machine Translation
| 2024-03-14T10:33:28 | 2024-03-14T10:33:28 |
Abdul Hameed Azeemi, Ihsan Ayyub Qazi, Agha Ali Raza
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Active learning (AL) techniques reduce labeling costs for training neural
machine translation (NMT) models by selecting smaller representative subsets
from unlabeled data for annotation. Diversity sampling techniques select
heterogeneous instances, while uncertainty sampling methods select instances
with the highest model uncertainty. Both approaches have limitations -
diversity methods may extract varied but trivial examples, while uncertainty
sampling can yield repetitive, uninformative instances. To bridge this gap, we
propose HUDS, a hybrid AL strategy for domain adaptation in NMT that combines
uncertainty and diversity for sentence selection. HUDS computes uncertainty
scores for unlabeled sentences and subsequently stratifies them. It then
clusters sentence embeddings within each stratum using k-MEANS and computes
diversity scores by distance to the centroid. A weighted hybrid score that
combines uncertainty and diversity is then used to select the top instances for
annotation in each AL iteration. Experiments on multi-domain German-English
datasets demonstrate the better performance of HUDS over other strong AL
baselines. We analyze the sentence selection with HUDS and show that it
prioritizes diverse instances having high model uncertainty for annotation in
early AL iterations.
|
[
-0.14642558991909027,
-0.9445496797561646,
0.24217109382152557,
0.23344315588474274,
-0.34280601143836975,
0.3682650923728943,
-0.3727799952030182,
-0.34763896465301514,
0.04130253940820694,
0.3656698167324066,
-0.1930570751428604,
-0.5614240765571594,
-0.4201442003250122,
0.037517886608839035,
0.14188861846923828,
1.3376315832138062,
-0.3637765347957611,
-0.03300243616104126,
-0.07434402406215668,
-0.5254709124565125,
-0.2597438395023346,
-0.44613316655158997,
-0.29667460918426514,
-0.13114137947559357,
0.5835186839103699,
0.28770437836647034,
1.051883578300476,
0.7079606056213379,
0.4894050359725952,
0.25158318877220154,
-0.2070932537317276,
0.6233281493186951,
-0.013296404853463173,
0.49558231234550476,
-0.07593902200460434,
-0.4128117263317108,
-0.5026621222496033,
0.057697393000125885,
0.5636250376701355,
0.9424418210983276,
0.00968138501048088,
-0.03610016405582428,
-0.25362086296081543,
0.23521116375923157,
-0.8250455260276794,
-0.23703448474407196,
-0.5986403226852417,
0.28858569264411926,
-0.23729753494262695,
-0.06450285017490387,
-0.3163175582885742,
-0.14005941152572632,
0.45270299911499023,
-0.8143078088760376,
0.10092330724000931,
0.2693304121494293,
0.8991584777832031,
0.3355506956577301,
-0.8119303584098816,
0.0016627202276140451,
-1.0602190494537354,
0.9862527251243591,
-0.44947493076324463,
0.1350899040699005,
0.4950818717479706,
0.15843510627746582,
0.09255050122737885,
-0.5187792778015137,
-0.31596454977989197,
-0.11934243142604828,
0.2347327023744583,
0.3490649461746216,
-0.1347261667251587,
0.22809211909770966,
0.08619165420532227,
0.6709882020950317,
-0.3657550513744354,
0.17199335992336273,
-0.43707484006881714,
-0.3357301652431488,
0.5231332778930664,
-0.3065462112426758,
0.1771601438522339,
-0.17593739926815033,
-0.6482653617858887,
-0.22021958231925964,
-0.5040938854217529,
-0.03964850306510925,
0.4024815261363983,
0.4228159189224243,
0.008366042748093605,
0.7349395751953125,
0.001149542978964746,
0.7142056822776794,
0.012646324001252651,
-0.06257668137550354,
0.5821847319602966,
-0.2836628556251526,
-0.23587293922901154,
-0.19602853059768677,
0.8163082599639893,
-0.09507670998573303,
0.07436057925224304,
-0.40725529193878174,
-0.6771865487098694,
-0.07142886519432068,
0.47890329360961914,
-0.18217822909355164,
0.03414859622716904,
0.12068276852369308,
-0.3125039041042328,
-0.04657253995537758,
0.06908828765153885,
-0.6627538204193115,
-0.09405754506587982,
-0.18103212118148804,
0.7790426015853882,
-0.3885078430175781,
-0.01812760904431343,
0.05547385290265083,
-0.08458606153726578,
-0.2454380840063095,
0.09910958260297775,
-0.6237636804580688,
0.3995039463043213,
0.013775257393717766,
0.8467940092086792,
-0.7136720418930054,
-0.33323338627815247,
-0.45595282316207886,
0.18190987408161163,
-0.27143338322639465,
0.6454805135726929,
-0.2977229952812195,
-0.312890887260437,
-0.016724295914173126,
-0.2896158993244171,
-0.3595718443393707,
-0.7672697305679321,
0.6144731044769287,
-0.5559974312782288,
0.21435029804706573,
0.062087032943964005,
-0.20357345044612885,
-0.39006245136260986,
0.0316782221198082,
-0.7827646732330322,
1.4227080345153809,
0.5622774362564087,
-0.538527250289917,
0.37685784697532654,
-0.7093349695205688,
-0.977823793888092,
-0.007348454091697931,
-0.030620062723755836,
-0.8099291920661926,
0.05053078755736351,
0.16163481771945953,
0.30778738856315613,
0.09960879385471344,
0.26352643966674805,
-0.21416813135147095,
-0.01613137125968933,
0.26999303698539734,
-0.30745425820350647,
0.5446069836616516,
0.6031810641288757,
-0.5171713829040527,
0.38129037618637085,
-0.5850454568862915,
-0.05623634159564972,
-0.21055054664611816,
-0.7010421752929688,
-0.5038801431655884,
-0.11463063210248947,
0.21198931336402893,
0.18062534928321838,
-0.08681623637676239,
-0.3411610722541809,
0.2586623728275299,
-0.2800353467464447,
0.20802295207977295,
0.5675119161605835,
0.13031497597694397,
0.8649277687072754,
-0.33569663763046265,
0.9169954657554626,
0.17578479647636414,
-0.038251977413892746,
0.0738321840763092,
-0.7398420572280884,
-0.8483524322509766,
-0.2692812383174896,
0.7457320690155029,
0.8773425221443176,
-1.2216789722442627,
0.7590959668159485,
-0.03885547071695328,
-0.29174935817718506,
-0.9342321157455444,
0.2666660249233246,
0.4076882600784302,
0.14808693528175354,
0.6091702580451965,
-0.15196014940738678,
-0.5011424422264099,
-1.0387564897537231,
-0.1613389551639557,
0.02583189308643341,
0.24034063518047333,
0.21661488711833954,
0.637639045715332,
-0.022035948932170868,
0.8522067666053772,
-0.23738864064216614,
-0.24331295490264893,
-0.1756461262702942,
0.37659522891044617,
-0.14125825464725494,
0.48863840103149414,
0.5540863871574402,
-1.1401035785675049,
-0.3950638473033905,
0.3412814140319824,
-0.6386174559593201,
0.10030481964349747,
-0.42858341336250305,
-0.3518195152282715,
-0.06258527934551239,
0.08106587082147598,
-0.6405002474784851,
0.5236243009567261,
0.6379781365394592,
-0.21626365184783936,
0.051091957837343216,
-0.3407115936279297,
0.04644531384110451,
-1.1277039051055908,
-0.06422340869903564,
0.08356431126594543,
-0.17566333711147308,
-0.31644120812416077,
-0.1626245081424713,
0.07924187183380127,
0.08492643386125565,
-0.3910295069217682,
0.4091752767562866,
-0.8291948437690735,
-0.19876474142074585,
-0.21943160891532898,
-0.22653105854988098,
0.023509716615080833,
0.2835068702697754,
0.022438261657953262,
0.6716897487640381,
0.5570021867752075,
-0.6349985003471375,
0.3439788818359375,
0.18469662964344025,
-0.41291871666908264,
0.026763619855046272,
-0.2170778512954712,
0.06603308022022247,
0.1484215408563614,
0.3364948034286499,
-0.6767902970314026,
0.07620477676391602,
0.20685923099517822,
-0.27014440298080444,
0.18389062583446503,
0.17046403884887695,
-0.2641102373600006,
-0.4257066547870636,
-0.044252485036849976,
0.4491971731185913,
0.48699164390563965,
-0.2261005938053131,
0.6193297505378723,
0.382355660200119,
0.02885172888636589,
-0.45317646861076355,
-0.900709331035614,
-0.03949849307537079,
-0.12971623241901398,
-0.34585830569267273,
0.575931966304779,
0.03428580239415169,
-0.29942670464515686,
0.2760302722454071,
-0.2734794020652771,
-0.1323525607585907,
0.41877955198287964,
0.15404276549816132,
0.18743129074573517,
-0.5436172485351562,
0.05886441096663475,
0.41000431776046753,
0.04411311075091362,
-0.3929038643836975,
-0.6674718856811523,
-0.0069571565836668015,
-0.005487716291099787,
-0.3098542392253876,
-0.11236242204904556,
0.5253470540046692,
0.43012121319770813,
-0.38167262077331543,
0.8830291032791138,
0.7357853055000305,
-0.4741971790790558,
-0.7863892316818237,
-0.1450062394142151,
-0.11061681807041168,
-0.3561183512210846,
0.300606369972229,
-0.25860220193862915,
-0.8455878496170044,
0.22928909957408905,
-0.06812272220849991,
0.3127874433994293,
0.5225033760070801,
0.7213590145111084,
-0.15666352212429047,
0.7547065615653992,
0.5503017902374268,
0.2216832935810089,
0.5562780499458313,
-0.3501622974872589,
0.416899174451828,
-0.6256136298179626,
-0.09753590822219849,
-0.3506503403186798,
-0.7905229926109314,
-0.304261177778244,
-0.8582034111022949,
0.38451457023620605,
0.1562340408563614,
0.31664156913757324,
0.20951281487941742,
-0.4639427065849304,
0.16194216907024384,
0.9412294626235962,
0.11494291573762894,
0.16629020869731903,
0.20208491384983063,
-0.2550095021724701,
-0.11995512992143631,
-0.8242409825325012,
-0.3398626446723938,
1.0658071041107178,
0.23120635747909546,
0.5550183057785034,
0.1479903757572174,
0.48730915784835815,
0.5023154020309448,
0.3091259300708771,
-1.0125579833984375,
0.32400792837142944,
-0.17855305969715118,
-0.8431674242019653,
-0.15230028331279755,
-0.5740768909454346,
-1.0695669651031494,
0.5117106437683105,
-0.43745192885398865,
-0.2240801304578781,
0.27417656779289246,
0.14187850058078766,
-0.8101739883422852,
0.5278335213661194,
-0.8245857357978821,
0.6537167429924011,
-0.4977409243583679,
-0.04938089847564697,
0.168002188205719,
-0.6956157088279724,
0.10710423439741135,
-0.2831847071647644,
0.1911918669939041,
0.031735919415950775,
-0.2557860314846039,
0.9387443661689758,
0.032357197254896164,
0.8829358220100403,
0.04738224670290947,
0.1477896273136139,
0.4500850439071655,
0.1072959154844284,
0.18467290699481964,
-0.16619457304477692,
-0.2494036853313446,
-0.20071639120578766,
-0.559421956539154,
-0.5573806166648865,
-0.37416884303092957,
0.48112812638282776,
-0.9180594086647034,
-0.32293564081192017,
-0.6416788101196289,
-0.9939469695091248,
-0.36557912826538086,
0.12462908029556274,
0.4033588171005249,
-0.04962640628218651,
0.04567832127213478,
0.27679988741874695,
0.8167190551757812,
-0.16802667081356049,
0.39655834436416626,
0.18515722453594208,
0.13450191915035248,
-0.722023606300354,
0.726140558719635,
0.3615805506706238,
0.5191978812217712,
0.4649481177330017,
0.11024536192417145,
-0.08767540007829666,
-1.0205557346343994,
-0.6252104043960571,
0.06227567046880722,
-0.6262115836143494,
-0.4009712040424347,
-0.8107754588127136,
-0.22605638206005096,
-0.4998088777065277,
-0.28370997309684753,
-0.2768394947052002,
-0.6713820099830627,
-0.19234788417816162,
-0.5333050489425659,
0.5292655229568481,
0.5533248782157898,
-0.02796143665909767,
0.4847008287906647,
-0.5617813467979431,
0.6042853593826294,
0.19961346685886383,
0.020489001646637917,
-0.39861592650413513,
-0.6564655303955078,
-0.45409852266311646,
0.03897791728377342,
-0.5986841917037964,
-0.9200375080108643,
0.3745044469833374,
0.46433308720588684,
0.9274798631668091,
0.2725493609905243,
0.4641600549221039,
0.2401505410671234,
-0.22979982197284698,
0.6646328568458557,
-0.019463445991277695,
-0.6336404085159302,
0.6314396858215332,
-0.4759035110473633,
0.23885619640350342,
0.5279611349105835,
0.5629971623420715,
-0.3534792363643646,
-0.4104132652282715,
-0.7291023135185242,
-1.1401116847991943,
0.633483350276947,
0.42507821321487427,
0.10309906303882599,
0.006621250417083502,
0.250531941652298,
0.3464408218860626,
0.25069209933280945,
-0.834263026714325,
-0.5135343074798584,
-0.04799690097570419,
-0.40980321168899536,
0.013348018750548363,
0.265250027179718,
-0.2220960259437561,
-0.33271369338035583,
0.8350491523742676,
-0.1949716955423355,
0.09118849784135818,
0.08566455543041229,
-0.23090484738349915,
-0.36605557799339294,
0.2136949747800827,
0.3839249908924103,
0.4016668498516083,
-0.20771542191505432,
0.22994419932365417,
0.17933644354343414,
-0.5008277297019958,
0.061377111822366714,
0.06907239556312561,
-0.6241641044616699,
0.30575066804885864,
0.34463179111480713,
1.3573521375656128,
0.26264142990112305,
-0.3923303484916687,
0.37057656049728394,
0.3963225781917572,
-0.3652067482471466,
0.16459470987319946,
-0.011754894629120827,
-0.06496599316596985,
-0.02248334512114525,
0.39342159032821655,
0.6633620858192444,
-0.02392488904297352,
-0.6115209460258484,
0.3632637560367584,
0.04245452210307121,
-0.42995887994766235,
-0.3715999126434326,
0.6482412219047546,
0.40219536423683167,
-0.5144792199134827,
0.48279431462287903,
-0.07311508804559708,
-0.5764274597167969,
0.4789769947528839,
0.5778583884239197,
0.8330472111701965,
-0.46798473596572876,
0.46616697311401367,
0.12126818299293518,
0.3844645321369171,
-0.27622777223587036,
0.3071415424346924,
-0.02026444859802723,
-0.795299768447876,
-0.3693320155143738,
-0.6220746636390686,
-0.3932594358921051,
-0.10289455205202103,
-0.9729865789413452,
0.06091965362429619,
-0.48438796401023865,
-0.46869587898254395,
0.020824024453759193,
-0.19203133881092072,
-0.32255324721336365,
0.3712500333786011,
0.4101330637931824,
0.6319670677185059,
-1.1308130025863647,
0.9803391098976135,
1.2044552564620972,
-0.3989056348800659,
-0.37165001034736633,
-0.1830911487340927,
-0.11133058369159698,
-0.49282607436180115,
0.17816407978534698,
-0.22539275884628296,
0.27232852578163147,
0.036669082939624786,
-0.3222709894180298,
-0.6833398342132568,
0.8366336822509766,
0.31934282183647156,
-0.16056811809539795,
-0.06901594996452332,
-0.14798051118850708,
0.4267565906047821,
-0.3817075788974762,
-0.02430681884288788,
0.3445305824279785,
0.5457677841186523,
0.015898093581199646,
-0.9134142398834229,
-0.30198127031326294,
-0.2827642560005188,
-0.17377594113349915,
0.35523417592048645,
-0.4541465640068054,
0.975551187992096,
-0.3080408275127411,
-0.04468134418129921,
-0.04967841878533363,
0.9329304099082947,
0.11717449128627777,
0.3039993643760681,
0.5997070074081421,
0.3475896418094635,
0.9071599841117859,
-0.13013166189193726,
1.1075025796890259,
0.26898252964019775,
0.24000436067581177,
0.7812866568565369,
-0.3120476305484772,
0.8710206747055054,
0.7145851254463196,
-0.17615462839603424,
0.3762343227863312,
0.9537493586540222,
-0.16150648891925812,
0.6917129755020142,
0.19154635071754456,
-0.3727370798587799,
-0.4233400225639343,
-0.10736411809921265,
-0.22125129401683807,
0.25465479493141174,
0.3771764934062958,
-0.3315761089324951,
-0.1609223186969757,
0.43623101711273193,
0.005995493847876787,
0.31170690059661865,
0.04080602154135704,
0.6544468998908997,
0.33939310908317566,
-0.9191405773162842,
0.45682454109191895,
0.2210533320903778,
0.7932054996490479,
-0.6672429442405701,
0.2129979282617569,
-0.14478251338005066,
0.16835647821426392,
-0.05709301680326462,
-0.624332845211029,
0.11714845150709152,
-0.20929881930351257,
-0.45189645886421204,
-0.687371551990509,
0.30124402046203613,
-0.6090882420539856,
-0.5122841596603394,
0.33472341299057007,
0.755649983882904,
-0.07176320999860764,
0.017423445358872414,
-0.9122137427330017,
-0.21532557904720306,
0.2121986597776413,
-0.4990924894809723,
0.4315999746322632,
0.6620716452598572,
-0.5089206695556641,
0.381915420293808,
0.7216098308563232,
0.41232216358184814,
0.4253407120704651,
-0.10544076561927795,
0.7162300944328308,
-0.5486236810684204,
-0.5040479302406311,
-0.38409173488616943,
0.5471923351287842,
0.10446882992982864,
-0.8882756233215332,
0.7159255146980286,
0.5521821975708008,
0.7885128259658813,
-0.07282508909702301,
1.0254878997802734,
-0.0012495862320065498,
0.3869932293891907,
-0.5397463440895081,
0.5473372936248779,
-0.4929931163787842,
0.145600363612175,
0.16183766722679138,
-1.202816367149353,
-0.40715616941452026,
0.7728400826454163,
-0.42475202679634094,
0.06060364469885826,
1.0430186986923218,
0.44540706276893616,
-0.3093687891960144,
-0.19074605405330658,
0.31616485118865967,
0.09363970905542374,
-0.09845959395170212,
0.29696646332740784,
0.7946716547012329,
-0.6143468022346497,
0.6464311480522156,
-0.45158621668815613,
-0.179819256067276,
-0.11035360395908356,
-0.5402142405509949,
-0.7009143829345703,
-0.5443437695503235,
-0.6496509909629822,
-0.4556061923503876,
0.04106012359261513,
0.8384661674499512,
1.0171892642974854,
-1.0504652261734009,
-0.22749055922031403,
0.4204597771167755,
0.19993863999843597,
-0.6588478088378906,
-0.1459255814552307,
0.40433141589164734,
-0.19078247249126434,
-0.7417176365852356,
0.669723391532898,
0.17963172495365143,
0.23478956520557404,
0.033171966671943665,
-0.03825432434678078,
-0.606572687625885,
-0.0899341031908989,
0.24475504457950592,
0.2323305606842041,
-0.7807601094245911,
0.12805666029453278,
0.06045845150947571,
-0.3157452344894409,
0.18152004480361938,
0.8687114715576172,
-0.6316174268722534,
0.37679678201675415,
0.3552244305610657,
1.050652265548706,
0.35261762142181396,
0.042205192148685455,
0.7443804144859314,
-0.9582580924034119,
0.33045175671577454,
0.7175451517105103,
0.12082137912511826,
0.3919453024864197,
-0.4023425579071045,
0.40585628151893616,
0.47915348410606384,
-0.3425385057926178,
-0.7989853024482727,
0.033009592443704605,
-1.3242970705032349,
-0.4141857624053955,
1.5532163381576538,
-0.2661482095718384,
-0.40716680884361267,
-0.49556297063827515,
-0.1125817596912384,
0.22607062757015228,
-0.33586186170578003,
0.5198525190353394,
0.6601759791374207,
0.1329241245985031,
0.1534605771303177,
-0.898539125919342,
0.38448086380958557,
0.74517422914505,
-0.6544806957244873,
-0.31323370337486267,
0.2758435606956482,
0.00013975531328469515,
0.1497359424829483,
0.24515290558338165,
0.20607911050319672,
0.2684755027294159,
-0.04721643030643463,
0.37448665499687195,
0.1045738235116005,
-0.2690182626247406,
-0.26362520456314087,
0.13638396561145782,
-0.06617964804172516,
-0.4769788384437561
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09226v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09226v2
|
Retrieval augmented text-to-SQL generation for epidemiological question answering using electronic health records
| 2024-03-14T09:45:05 | 2024-05-16T13:00:56 |
Angelo Ziletti, Leonardo D'Ambrosi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Electronic health records (EHR) and claims data are rich sources of
real-world data that reflect patient health status and healthcare utilization.
Querying these databases to answer epidemiological questions is challenging due
to the intricacy of medical terminology and the need for complex SQL queries.
Here, we introduce an end-to-end methodology that combines text-to-SQL
generation with retrieval augmented generation (RAG) to answer epidemiological
questions using EHR and claims data. We show that our approach, which
integrates a medical coding step into the text-to-SQL process, significantly
improves the performance over simple prompting. Our findings indicate that
although current language models are not yet sufficiently accurate for
unsupervised use, RAG offers a promising direction for improving their
capabilities, as shown in a realistic industry setting.
|
[
-0.03875022381544113,
-1.0272650718688965,
0.7813577651977539,
-0.3180095851421356,
-0.1841762214899063,
0.08551108837127686,
0.07811369001865387,
-0.5942991375923157,
0.6594188809394836,
0.6476227045059204,
-0.2947322726249695,
-0.3055459260940552,
-0.2356550246477127,
0.1962500512599945,
-0.1644664704799652,
1.2537893056869507,
0.07818187028169632,
-0.038884907960891724,
-0.6113991141319275,
0.06514301151037216,
-0.1513126790523529,
-1.0052821636199951,
-0.4223172664642334,
-0.026272768154740334,
0.5002342462539673,
0.3941660225391388,
0.3830803632736206,
0.47422733902931213,
0.453019917011261,
0.06142902374267578,
-0.13847573101520538,
0.46701547503471375,
-0.3908616602420807,
0.5875736474990845,
-0.03982333466410637,
-0.5382717251777649,
-0.5185527205467224,
-0.6027922630310059,
0.06406562775373459,
0.6586441993713379,
-0.5017874836921692,
0.6389362215995789,
-0.37787631154060364,
0.8728710412979126,
-0.7180413007736206,
-0.35369038581848145,
-0.5595716238021851,
-0.06402275711297989,
-0.32781463861465454,
-0.9528594017028809,
-0.5826095938682556,
-0.19278040528297424,
0.11790112406015396,
-0.5117203593254089,
0.28175947070121765,
0.23537947237491608,
0.808928370475769,
0.3091743290424347,
-0.46927309036254883,
-0.6271097660064697,
-0.8775961995124817,
0.35005617141723633,
-0.3075001835823059,
0.343727707862854,
0.6948716044425964,
0.32902592420578003,
0.029849238693714142,
-0.9004810452461243,
-0.22558189928531647,
-0.10772574692964554,
-0.23733502626419067,
0.23634645342826843,
-0.179867684841156,
0.034524884074926376,
0.23621726036071777,
0.37915414571762085,
-0.5422131419181824,
-0.3029012382030487,
-0.3878515660762787,
-0.1423014998435974,
0.5822249054908752,
0.22688820958137512,
0.6028773188591003,
-0.23020192980766296,
-0.1708541214466095,
0.3224174380302429,
-0.8210422396659851,
-0.16357707977294922,
-0.08608441799879074,
0.36074158549308777,
0.005496862810105085,
0.9612108469009399,
-0.05236068740487099,
0.7967487573623657,
0.14008593559265137,
0.05503527447581291,
0.2987035810947418,
-0.32723096013069153,
-0.10671281814575195,
0.42143183946609497,
0.07166220992803574,
0.4253503680229187,
-0.3334725499153137,
-0.2313522845506668,
-0.16430050134658813,
-0.18910656869411469,
0.44815313816070557,
-0.685996413230896,
-0.22335746884346008,
0.7648194432258606,
-0.3890845775604248,
-0.04039940983057022,
-0.17900192737579346,
-0.9464484453201294,
-0.3037361204624176,
-0.16548261046409607,
0.49650970101356506,
-0.11632655560970306,
-0.1617407351732254,
-0.11546424776315689,
-0.3948039710521698,
0.22584669291973114,
0.19284632802009583,
-0.5553924441337585,
0.44129103422164917,
0.5169326663017273,
0.5209881067276001,
0.10594698786735535,
0.5666282773017883,
-0.8274276256561279,
0.3896273374557495,
-0.22133275866508484,
0.8895649313926697,
-0.37110471725463867,
-0.49285492300987244,
0.16875819861888885,
-0.22024478018283844,
0.07345021516084671,
-0.7580470442771912,
0.45796623826026917,
-0.44409531354904175,
0.38240310549736023,
-0.1668609231710434,
-0.581232488155365,
0.24220962822437286,
0.3649612069129944,
-0.5428060293197632,
0.9656280875205994,
0.1462937444448471,
-0.929125189781189,
0.2650104761123657,
-0.48912984132766724,
-0.48225873708724976,
0.3425430357456207,
-0.4238678812980652,
-0.8587827086448669,
0.1575154960155487,
0.3146570920944214,
0.23461371660232544,
-0.6493240594863892,
0.16996829211711884,
0.21732328832149506,
0.011637566611170769,
0.2508558928966522,
-0.1605217009782791,
0.5682395100593567,
0.31915155053138733,
0.1366490125656128,
-0.18047943711280823,
-0.7355644702911377,
0.18524359166622162,
0.3903033137321472,
-0.5303356647491455,
-0.7410745024681091,
0.21621493995189667,
0.13902433216571808,
-0.16461855173110962,
0.30705776810646057,
-0.6138362288475037,
-0.16686668992042542,
-0.514956533908844,
-0.044592417776584625,
0.09915624558925629,
0.5421721935272217,
0.08514933288097382,
-0.8760510087013245,
0.498585045337677,
-0.14280587434768677,
-0.07775980234146118,
-0.4850788116455078,
-0.7725927233695984,
-0.23968887329101562,
-0.22765891253948212,
0.2766352891921997,
0.8119572997093201,
-0.9296610951423645,
0.08700936287641525,
-0.11944647878408432,
-0.23959305882453918,
-0.6874057054519653,
-0.42593148350715637,
0.5037091970443726,
0.7732431888580322,
0.6528956294059753,
0.019469110295176506,
-0.7355635166168213,
-0.49167323112487793,
-0.48609480261802673,
-0.35804760456085205,
-0.3621775209903717,
0.6994506120681763,
0.15716098248958588,
0.054936736822128296,
0.7215070724487305,
-0.7428922057151794,
-0.14826692640781403,
-0.20140501856803894,
0.041173506528139114,
0.13539154827594757,
0.27840957045555115,
0.33922144770622253,
-0.9964277744293213,
-0.6069656014442444,
0.35216188430786133,
-0.567972719669342,
-0.19219554960727692,
0.10806810110807419,
0.05981765314936638,
0.35846057534217834,
0.30409443378448486,
-0.19532227516174316,
0.4623589515686035,
0.3107958137989044,
-0.3919810950756073,
0.46700403094291687,
-0.6191394925117493,
0.5233913660049438,
-1.3169914484024048,
0.28608953952789307,
0.03442012518644333,
-0.22737891972064972,
-1.0358680486679077,
0.2255801111459732,
-0.10423800349235535,
-0.2604961395263672,
-0.33967989683151245,
0.311649352312088,
-0.6136842370033264,
0.09942544251680374,
0.11536774784326553,
-0.31053730845451355,
-0.012930887751281261,
-0.07224929332733154,
-0.20313233137130737,
0.7329533696174622,
0.3507949709892273,
-0.6394603848457336,
0.07144971191883087,
0.44081488251686096,
-0.13235214352607727,
0.8330907225608826,
-0.6648301482200623,
0.22404330968856812,
-0.49411001801490784,
-0.02997555583715439,
-0.7099114656448364,
-0.6233735680580139,
-0.11706235259771347,
-0.8995932936668396,
0.426373153924942,
-0.14648385345935822,
-0.3501058518886566,
-0.27312347292900085,
-0.20461216568946838,
0.10437101870775223,
0.7544846534729004,
-0.46748048067092896,
0.5867699384689331,
0.8126726746559143,
-0.4142518937587738,
-0.3582104742527008,
-0.786822497844696,
0.1340499371290207,
-0.23327869176864624,
-0.3141886591911316,
0.6982570290565491,
0.18405646085739136,
-0.4110361635684967,
0.12383062392473221,
-0.04326149448752403,
-0.507698118686676,
-0.2577245533466339,
-0.1467956006526947,
0.4194256067276001,
-0.11712806671857834,
0.3166019916534424,
0.21618521213531494,
0.1747702807188034,
0.12845906615257263,
0.13313338160514832,
0.3358907699584961,
0.5493167042732239,
-0.4107908308506012,
-0.17487911880016327,
0.796276867389679,
0.2595534026622772,
-0.3890451192855835,
0.8222772479057312,
-0.1439596563577652,
-0.8093867897987366,
-0.01725626550614834,
-0.542421281337738,
-0.12247318774461746,
-0.34717583656311035,
0.31989970803260803,
-0.256612628698349,
-0.7720067501068115,
0.4794986844062805,
-0.21526116132736206,
0.18954813480377197,
0.32028070092201233,
0.6572083830833435,
-0.3055470287799835,
1.056609869003296,
0.3655957281589508,
0.6988234519958496,
0.010748232714831829,
0.19445794820785522,
0.033349793404340744,
-0.8001000285148621,
-0.5681058168411255,
-0.8501231670379639,
0.44610196352005005,
-0.5366316437721252,
-0.7316198348999023,
1.03428053855896,
-0.007874362170696259,
-0.20789507031440735,
0.04216870665550232,
-0.7731633186340332,
0.29661956429481506,
0.034163348376750946,
0.7129101753234863,
0.5524951815605164,
0.23152275383472443,
0.047587934881448746,
-0.08928027749061584,
-0.7233535647392273,
-0.23762568831443787,
1.1617467403411865,
0.11003323644399643,
0.5777059197425842,
0.5302475094795227,
0.786688506603241,
0.29774314165115356,
0.30165737867355347,
-0.5194211006164551,
0.15639767050743103,
-0.2788122296333313,
-0.8374362587928772,
-0.13728395104408264,
-0.5130148530006409,
-1.0961613655090332,
0.03831075131893158,
-0.46122726798057556,
-0.6186918020248413,
0.10190359503030777,
0.48729172348976135,
-0.45976823568344116,
0.20437569916248322,
-0.5069385766983032,
0.40293487906455994,
-0.13668067753314972,
-0.168962299823761,
0.14226779341697693,
-0.8122415542602539,
0.10061454772949219,
-0.251941442489624,
0.43648234009742737,
0.25522729754447937,
-0.22905980050563812,
0.5622850060462952,
-0.7591693997383118,
0.5948663353919983,
0.017559556290507317,
0.19340448081493378,
0.4977183938026428,
-0.21028466522693634,
0.5887943506240845,
-0.03706657141447067,
-0.1491735279560089,
-0.2698041498661041,
0.21394659578800201,
-0.2839809060096741,
-0.4143063724040985,
0.350779265165329,
-0.30370602011680603,
-0.5174430012702942,
-0.43370479345321655,
-0.1897801011800766,
-0.3757990598678589,
-0.01083135325461626,
0.34209463000297546,
0.6099302768707275,
-0.18656082451343536,
-0.06512065976858139,
0.9171621203422546,
-0.6240379810333252,
-0.1472776234149933,
0.48669400811195374,
-0.25362372398376465,
-0.38159677386283875,
0.8570291996002197,
0.23009803891181946,
0.3788909614086151,
0.7028936147689819,
0.32413846254348755,
-0.3739314675331116,
-0.16148751974105835,
-0.7143315076828003,
0.20123693346977234,
-0.5418967008590698,
-0.3502209782600403,
-0.8844261169433594,
-0.224721759557724,
-0.30013471841812134,
-0.1535891592502594,
0.043512601405382156,
-0.33579394221305847,
-0.33419227600097656,
-0.10354354977607727,
0.8412767648696899,
0.6388894319534302,
0.19445554912090302,
-0.20299705862998962,
-1.13740873336792,
0.49247825145721436,
0.23001013696193695,
0.28065595030784607,
-0.2084307223558426,
-0.483378142118454,
-0.12133549898862839,
-0.24568279087543488,
0.08583088964223862,
-1.457512378692627,
0.4494119882583618,
0.3833470046520233,
0.5036094188690186,
-0.15773136913776398,
0.42466846108436584,
0.7118802070617676,
-0.9386280179023743,
0.6841184496879578,
0.2729031443595886,
-0.51667320728302,
0.8242536187171936,
-0.2855003774166107,
0.057692594826221466,
0.5465646982192993,
0.6236460208892822,
-0.45370644330978394,
-0.14950747787952423,
-0.5863417983055115,
-1.0574930906295776,
0.27979519963264465,
0.15990020334720612,
-0.17244359850883484,
-0.2919102907180786,
0.4567471146583557,
-0.2034534066915512,
0.14419275522232056,
0.12809039652347565,
-0.6040119528770447,
0.2942941188812256,
-0.11409963667392731,
0.19229118525981903,
-0.2648824453353882,
-0.22649165987968445,
-0.15399225056171417,
0.3777504861354828,
0.06271722912788391,
0.49512553215026855,
0.6868369579315186,
-0.02612297609448433,
-0.3905266523361206,
0.5551812052726746,
0.2134011834859848,
0.5858096480369568,
-0.207362100481987,
0.0011779520427808166,
0.22992780804634094,
-0.5649093389511108,
0.09391556680202484,
0.2497439980506897,
-0.26141467690467834,
0.3463570773601532,
-0.02405628375709057,
0.38572147488594055,
-0.04139561206102371,
-0.8721715807914734,
0.48911532759666443,
0.10812505334615707,
-0.07993093878030777,
-0.3598860204219818,
-0.48520514369010925,
-0.0054203844629228115,
-0.3699007034301758,
0.6825042366981506,
-0.28655120730400085,
0.4739869236946106,
-0.6393155455589294,
0.6644410490989685,
0.22761833667755127,
-0.36564508080482483,
-0.010576561093330383,
0.9801247119903564,
0.16017423570156097,
-0.49437108635902405,
0.3313964009284973,
0.13892556726932526,
-0.2603403627872467,
0.8134475946426392,
0.9534837007522583,
0.37058451771736145,
-0.526438295841217,
0.19873400032520294,
0.5846099257469177,
0.21607494354248047,
0.060161564499139786,
0.8481120467185974,
0.3459928035736084,
-0.2228584736585617,
-0.7548331618309021,
-0.4758296608924866,
-0.7093307971954346,
-0.23119542002677917,
-1.0487967729568481,
0.2721865475177765,
-0.05602145195007324,
-0.22463202476501465,
0.2133442759513855,
-0.5427722334861755,
-0.36932915449142456,
0.3167620599269867,
-0.059746257960796356,
0.644153356552124,
-0.647935688495636,
0.35404759645462036,
1.0825998783111572,
-0.454123318195343,
-0.6902663707733154,
0.05940026044845581,
0.13993500173091888,
-0.47235748171806335,
0.18336886167526245,
-0.0700000748038292,
0.4321048855781555,
0.1335458755493164,
-0.4202958047389984,
-0.6469067931175232,
0.8115590214729309,
0.08694198727607727,
-0.38472703099250793,
-0.09810052812099457,
0.05359073355793953,
0.7403958439826965,
-0.09443333745002747,
0.23569977283477783,
0.41969937086105347,
0.06252750754356384,
0.16404257714748383,
-1.1594442129135132,
0.07050207257270813,
-0.2271382361650467,
-0.08235209435224533,
0.7352465391159058,
0.016486376523971558,
0.6291102766990662,
-0.619767427444458,
-0.4415474236011505,
-0.16744361817836761,
0.49401402473449707,
0.374326229095459,
0.7212539911270142,
0.2355542629957199,
0.5989043712615967,
0.8670310378074646,
-0.0858260989189148,
1.3902896642684937,
-0.20516888797283173,
0.3407098650932312,
1.0876538753509521,
-0.3098410665988922,
1.0080827474594116,
0.4701082408428192,
-0.42097997665405273,
0.2874029278755188,
0.4996250569820404,
0.549932599067688,
0.38604044914245605,
0.2735700011253357,
-0.7162113785743713,
-0.10316985845565796,
-0.5199625492095947,
-0.4418156147003174,
-0.045182958245277405,
0.815209686756134,
-0.35257184505462646,
-0.27541598677635193,
0.16681940853595734,
-0.008709199726581573,
0.35857459902763367,
-0.47819116711616516,
1.013100266456604,
-0.0010590326273813844,
-0.548648476600647,
0.32340991497039795,
-0.18315619230270386,
0.44760140776634216,
-0.37561067938804626,
-0.5802599787712097,
0.20436112582683563,
-0.32416343688964844,
-0.3045516014099121,
-0.7737135291099548,
0.7174370288848877,
0.3231024444103241,
-0.18544167280197144,
0.1927991658449173,
0.9870771169662476,
-0.5919415354728699,
-0.3051435947418213,
-0.143522247672081,
0.7434805631637573,
0.3919781446456909,
0.16800087690353394,
-0.47931021451950073,
-0.2813599705696106,
-0.13339772820472717,
-0.05991971120238304,
0.2991648018360138,
0.3349345922470093,
-0.07794845104217529,
0.3289045989513397,
0.7783938646316528,
0.3702816367149353,
0.027233097702264786,
-0.057375214993953705,
0.7774232029914856,
-0.40437692403793335,
-0.4411998391151428,
-0.42129650712013245,
0.6462874412536621,
-0.17542846500873566,
-0.09647770971059799,
0.4633689820766449,
0.7321740984916687,
0.5894731283187866,
-0.04820719361305237,
0.8129097819328308,
-0.4435998499393463,
1.3709022998809814,
-0.37240734696388245,
0.8392557501792908,
-0.6840729713439941,
0.13425786793231964,
0.006298085208982229,
-0.36875301599502563,
-0.49053940176963806,
0.09172496199607849,
-0.005440454464405775,
-0.2276572436094284,
0.5217090249061584,
0.6164562106132507,
0.44275543093681335,
-0.3105618357658386,
0.47337812185287476,
0.07018484175205231,
0.13239340484142303,
0.2658354341983795,
0.28641214966773987,
-0.37292465567588806,
0.22691425681114197,
-0.18376028537750244,
-0.37496015429496765,
-0.3396587073802948,
-0.6605445146560669,
-0.50218266248703,
-0.6001407504081726,
-0.2816387414932251,
-0.8117655515670776,
0.5357115864753723,
1.1956943273544312,
0.09309802949428558,
-0.7699368000030518,
0.19086092710494995,
0.15202364325523376,
-0.2531278431415558,
-0.17626617848873138,
-0.203718364238739,
0.46797558665275574,
-0.01956174522638321,
-0.44569259881973267,
0.19419562816619873,
0.22654637694358826,
-0.0454285703599453,
0.09306972473859787,
0.15394476056098938,
-0.2691721022129059,
0.24881501495838165,
0.6016836166381836,
0.6556870937347412,
-0.3150387406349182,
0.20013082027435303,
0.17557671666145325,
-0.20647646486759186,
0.11842904984951019,
0.7271103858947754,
-0.691429853439331,
0.7710806131362915,
0.682837188243866,
1.00486421585083,
0.4842102527618408,
0.36851853132247925,
0.3934575319290161,
-0.8315776586532593,
-0.42618775367736816,
0.5235000848770142,
0.13204535841941833,
0.39354363083839417,
-0.9766457080841064,
0.293183296918869,
-0.03529542684555054,
-0.695763885974884,
-0.8845424652099609,
0.18107423186302185,
-0.7344657182693481,
-0.15249371528625488,
0.8216837048530579,
0.02324039489030838,
-0.3462812900543213,
-0.6675764322280884,
-0.14519500732421875,
0.3229280114173889,
-0.16991578042507172,
0.5161957740783691,
0.09828689694404602,
-0.47803008556365967,
-0.12100957334041595,
-0.8594009876251221,
0.4626990854740143,
0.39772504568099976,
-1.2779548168182373,
-0.07325556874275208,
0.4801836907863617,
0.2083183228969574,
0.04846826195716858,
1.0486509799957275,
-0.3784297704696655,
0.6176563501358032,
-0.10865828394889832,
0.11422478407621384,
0.17233242094516754,
-0.21920627355575562,
-0.2634498178958893,
0.009481304325163364,
-0.054733436554670334,
-0.04307177662849426
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09751v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09751v1
|
What Was Your Prompt? A Remote Keylogging Attack on AI Assistants
| 2024-03-14T09:38:12 | 2024-03-14T09:38:12 |
Roy Weiss, Daniel Ayzenshteyn, Guy Amit, Yisroel Mirsky
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
AI assistants are becoming an integral part of society, used for asking
advice or help in personal and confidential issues. In this paper, we unveil a
novel side-channel that can be used to read encrypted responses from AI
Assistants over the web: the token-length side-channel. We found that many
vendors, including OpenAI and Microsoft, have this side-channel.
However, inferring the content of a response from a token-length sequence
alone proves challenging. This is because tokens are akin to words, and
responses can be several sentences long leading to millions of grammatically
correct sentences. In this paper, we show how this can be overcome by (1)
utilizing the power of a large language model (LLM) to translate these
sequences, (2) providing the LLM with inter-sentence context to narrow the
search space and (3) performing a known-plaintext attack by fine-tuning the
model on the target model's writing style.
Using these methods, we were able to accurately reconstruct 29\% of an AI
assistant's responses and successfully infer the topic from 55\% of them. To
demonstrate the threat, we performed the attack on OpenAI's ChatGPT-4 and
Microsoft's Copilot on both browser and API traffic.
|
[
-0.3825230598449707,
-0.8510814905166626,
0.46791377663612366,
-0.2824050486087799,
-0.4580681025981903,
0.0822933092713356,
0.1364874392747879,
-0.42996707558631897,
0.4162885248661041,
0.6594242453575134,
-0.6056040525436401,
-0.25028207898139954,
-0.7972916960716248,
0.35799911618232727,
-0.5610894560813904,
0.911000669002533,
0.34270256757736206,
0.23157982528209686,
-0.10042621940374374,
-0.057251546531915665,
-0.6229149699211121,
-0.6636252999305725,
-0.7298952341079712,
0.2940632998943329,
0.40464746952056885,
0.3464133143424988,
0.6942328214645386,
0.2749369442462921,
0.6537553071975708,
0.3314177095890045,
0.23194879293441772,
-0.0305541530251503,
-0.11315539479255676,
0.1934005469083786,
0.033724721521139145,
-0.6424641609191895,
-0.4353630244731903,
0.03377751633524895,
0.3303746283054352,
0.3117378056049347,
0.32859501242637634,
0.2965031564235687,
-0.03832210227847099,
0.3935203552246094,
-0.47037389874458313,
-0.30930614471435547,
-0.6442121267318726,
-0.010830437764525414,
-0.28133121132850647,
-0.2196076512336731,
-0.7302308678627014,
0.3006381094455719,
-0.1743827760219574,
-0.4763181507587433,
-0.010573427192866802,
0.12471413612365723,
0.7803781032562256,
0.3442046642303467,
-0.17202550172805786,
-0.6064428687095642,
-0.42924174666404724,
0.5174402594566345,
-0.692314624786377,
0.2393440157175064,
0.9541690349578857,
0.42417505383491516,
-0.2252163290977478,
-0.8501051068305969,
-0.5872166752815247,
-0.4447135925292969,
-0.13750751316547394,
-0.04247251898050308,
-0.39207473397254944,
0.206182062625885,
0.2491367608308792,
-0.1627480387687683,
-0.6420676112174988,
0.055302493274211884,
-0.431392639875412,
-0.20762597024440765,
0.6070521473884583,
0.15858767926692963,
0.5651417374610901,
-0.1379823237657547,
-0.06754177063703537,
0.13423041999340057,
-0.6264166831970215,
0.07876934111118317,
0.6275171637535095,
0.4012221693992615,
-0.1951415091753006,
0.661613404750824,
-0.10602309554815292,
0.835290253162384,
0.15367306768894196,
-0.14871472120285034,
-0.4655693769454956,
-0.11986400932073593,
-0.234373077750206,
0.03895103186368942,
0.7084624767303467,
0.2446148544549942,
0.1014939472079277,
-0.3227011561393738,
-0.03873762860894203,
-0.2754904627799988,
0.28438660502433777,
-0.5302231311798096,
-0.05210168659687042,
0.41666319966316223,
-0.6486752033233643,
-0.28022778034210205,
-0.0020146118476986885,
-0.8598952889442444,
-0.6360036134719849,
0.05109691619873047,
0.046257134526968,
-0.20014801621437073,
0.09884331375360489,
-0.24665063619613647,
-0.30653998255729675,
0.5706722736358643,
0.23390620946884155,
-0.7280780673027039,
0.4709049165248871,
0.9930500388145447,
1.055243968963623,
0.21603995561599731,
-0.1756802797317505,
-0.8363010883331299,
-0.05207952857017517,
-0.1460980474948883,
0.2797216475009918,
-0.7312760949134827,
-0.659410297870636,
0.023641811683773994,
-0.11541368067264557,
0.05316299572587013,
-0.15441776812076569,
0.0020883025135844946,
-0.969921886920929,
0.3423824906349182,
-0.11578308790922165,
-0.4386886656284332,
0.33399155735969543,
0.3906278908252716,
-0.7303037643432617,
0.2680872678756714,
-0.35963135957717896,
-0.8938709497451782,
-0.11668821424245834,
-0.6877797842025757,
-0.564081609249115,
0.0695045068860054,
-0.500277578830719,
-0.08787544071674347,
-0.02696027234196663,
0.3344539403915405,
0.3115830719470978,
-0.33312085270881653,
0.01108100637793541,
-0.28694581985473633,
-0.2298315167427063,
0.5985355973243713,
-0.7933962941169739,
0.9133948683738708,
0.17528463900089264,
-0.3984675705432892,
0.12461365759372711,
-0.8186736702919006,
-0.35886847972869873,
-0.030225643888115883,
0.03148259222507477,
-0.28499385714530945,
-0.2921934127807617,
-0.4753868877887726,
-0.008106253109872341,
0.6172535419464111,
-0.834093451499939,
0.2386309951543808,
-0.31040456891059875,
0.6428332328796387,
1.0187667608261108,
0.10247109085321426,
0.47474804520606995,
-0.11657310277223587,
0.9118586778640747,
-0.36103492975234985,
0.301169753074646,
-0.2919694185256958,
-0.739624559879303,
-0.29934921860694885,
-0.2171652913093567,
0.161118283867836,
0.3749837875366211,
-0.774386465549469,
0.11876659840345383,
-0.15217070281505585,
-0.31771257519721985,
-0.719031810760498,
-0.06971000880002975,
0.4028516113758087,
0.4923446476459503,
0.3483423888683319,
0.1971251219511032,
-0.14141012728214264,
-0.8214539885520935,
-0.5177146792411804,
-0.33480215072631836,
-0.3024231493473053,
0.2200244665145874,
0.3034561276435852,
-0.18386612832546234,
0.8985940217971802,
-0.5614505410194397,
-0.29020652174949646,
-0.1584155112504959,
0.08120634406805038,
-0.04295928403735161,
0.5317546725273132,
0.2870282530784607,
-0.7812055945396423,
-0.42048031091690063,
-0.1845961958169937,
-0.3790352940559387,
0.0671127513051033,
-0.43568235635757446,
-0.071589395403862,
0.1715339720249176,
0.9036713242530823,
-0.7346509695053101,
0.5878177881240845,
0.5188527703285217,
-0.4549531042575836,
0.2332422286272049,
-0.18157298862934113,
-0.050039518624544144,
-1.3795313835144043,
0.22224576771259308,
-0.41397401690483093,
-0.2833092212677002,
-0.5983997583389282,
0.425811767578125,
-0.1162881925702095,
-0.5849868059158325,
-0.2702762484550476,
0.5901273488998413,
-0.31889981031417847,
-0.06364696472883224,
-0.35360243916511536,
0.08685772866010666,
-0.16833700239658356,
0.5361743569374084,
-0.2907176911830902,
0.8160306215286255,
0.2674066424369812,
-0.1447911113500595,
0.666708767414093,
0.3209126591682434,
0.2996883690357208,
0.516827404499054,
-0.6205105185508728,
0.801530659198761,
-0.06207553297281265,
0.43816131353378296,
-1.1779611110687256,
-0.3631146550178528,
0.4792645275592804,
-0.9416283369064331,
0.2587481141090393,
-0.09777843952178955,
-0.37502822279930115,
-0.08799495548009872,
-0.24936898052692413,
0.44310903549194336,
0.3773099184036255,
-0.5199806690216064,
1.0596168041229248,
0.24756507575511932,
-0.10390157997608185,
-0.5154080986976624,
-0.7070667743682861,
0.5020858645439148,
-0.1935322880744934,
-0.6577872037887573,
-0.10380662977695465,
0.09439928829669952,
-0.39630788564682007,
-0.10943702608346939,
-0.030689263716340065,
-0.08707299828529358,
0.3212391138076782,
0.5903825759887695,
0.11283904314041138,
-0.02069380320608616,
-0.08046463876962662,
-0.23197492957115173,
0.02206978015601635,
0.37546712160110474,
-0.10496154427528381,
0.768944501876831,
0.07952363044023514,
-0.6221048831939697,
-0.8927238583564758,
0.6956345438957214,
0.7577356696128845,
-0.32543694972991943,
0.8046407103538513,
0.26193755865097046,
-0.4188721477985382,
0.018895838409662247,
-0.2408580631017685,
-0.5533509254455566,
-0.5520160794258118,
0.23051419854164124,
-0.4982094168663025,
-0.7276099920272827,
0.5869916677474976,
0.22777554392814636,
0.12316072732210159,
0.15363213419914246,
0.004923420492559671,
-0.022004641592502594,
1.23958420753479,
0.5478498935699463,
-0.6028991937637329,
0.44399580359458923,
-0.06045506149530411,
0.24179288744926453,
-0.6324572563171387,
-0.3010423481464386,
-0.5630847811698914,
-0.3049638569355011,
-0.6531396508216858,
-0.07891617715358734,
0.24763186275959015,
-0.1820080727338791,
-0.1870724856853485,
0.16644394397735596,
-0.1177217960357666,
0.1879822462797165,
0.8525934815406799,
0.2604566514492035,
0.07584716379642487,
-0.33451494574546814,
0.2965487241744995,
0.4275214970111847,
-0.3420458734035492,
-0.4340212047100067,
1.1974818706512451,
0.6063618063926697,
0.8308026790618896,
0.05581960827112198,
0.6580596566200256,
0.6299569606781006,
-0.1347835510969162,
-0.44411900639533997,
0.7407475709915161,
-0.08249696344137192,
-0.46561259031295776,
-0.4637402892112732,
-0.1606334149837494,
-1.0453227758407593,
-0.1345478743314743,
0.3400699198246002,
-0.8118057250976562,
-0.18385839462280273,
0.21938593685626984,
-0.7313781976699829,
0.2904333770275116,
-0.5217732787132263,
0.7180558443069458,
-0.23731443285942078,
0.00652728509157896,
-0.11878543347120285,
-1.008890151977539,
0.1356145590543747,
0.07314448058605194,
0.1468244045972824,
0.12592369318008423,
-0.17762617766857147,
0.9609516263008118,
-0.7978623509407043,
1.1776785850524902,
-0.2561625838279724,
0.07119603455066681,
0.31516483426094055,
0.06209845840930939,
0.6973378658294678,
0.2575056254863739,
0.3328644931316376,
0.013768427073955536,
-0.055101241916418076,
-0.6170753836631775,
-0.7557638883590698,
0.6299536824226379,
-0.8952064514160156,
-1.0807974338531494,
-0.4138292670249939,
-0.1417587250471115,
-0.19655592739582062,
0.030077068135142326,
0.37434595823287964,
0.6692564487457275,
-0.10135506838560104,
0.08740224689245224,
0.2682463824748993,
-0.33082160353660583,
0.5136559009552002,
0.3219050168991089,
0.06708793342113495,
-0.3216654062271118,
0.8131641149520874,
-0.22598931193351746,
0.4628443717956543,
0.5686591267585754,
0.004044702742248774,
-0.0734899714589119,
-0.3403345048427582,
-0.6433834433555603,
0.19381554424762726,
-0.6964901089668274,
-0.4930291473865509,
-0.6879935264587402,
-0.16831693053245544,
-0.8921189308166504,
-0.21513983607292175,
-0.16494563221931458,
-0.3152439296245575,
-0.522614061832428,
-0.06966471672058105,
0.5030376315116882,
0.857775866985321,
0.1484101116657257,
0.6278124451637268,
-0.788963258266449,
0.24340632557868958,
0.34081923961639404,
-0.06847445666790009,
-0.009253406897187233,
-0.5071308016777039,
-0.07105594128370285,
0.2031565010547638,
0.022976774722337723,
-1.372413992881775,
0.5016356110572815,
-0.16700479388237,
0.10071619600057602,
0.37744614481925964,
0.24007926881313324,
0.5549637675285339,
-0.4089829623699188,
1.2517813444137573,
-0.01780865527689457,
-0.9532586336135864,
0.35589876770973206,
-0.05974554270505905,
0.5423915386199951,
0.5073333978652954,
0.2364758998155594,
-0.8055090308189392,
-0.6391724348068237,
-0.6584522724151611,
-0.7780112028121948,
0.442841500043869,
0.063923180103302,
0.27267804741859436,
-0.05771981552243233,
0.27905037999153137,
-0.18042248487472534,
0.20448102056980133,
-0.4051685333251953,
-0.19492517411708832,
-0.19955115020275116,
-0.2070930153131485,
0.1772191971540451,
0.014809190295636654,
-0.10180139541625977,
0.22618542611598969,
0.4726579189300537,
-0.26960620284080505,
0.5928913354873657,
0.2511211335659027,
-0.04383466765284538,
0.03635295480489731,
0.12892340123653412,
0.6872138381004333,
0.4067813754081726,
0.23977090418338776,
0.1974366456270218,
0.27616792917251587,
-0.5869408249855042,
-0.13519799709320068,
0.16892234981060028,
0.07569137960672379,
0.10644248872995377,
0.7580395340919495,
0.49112725257873535,
-0.4069168269634247,
-0.7535140514373779,
0.8338849544525146,
-0.4036901593208313,
0.41153597831726074,
-0.6042352914810181,
-0.37197840213775635,
-0.14932125806808472,
0.1887606382369995,
0.39902186393737793,
-0.0565030500292778,
0.18592104315757751,
-0.5278460383415222,
0.05726694315671921,
0.7121983766555786,
-0.45790955424308777,
-0.39029279351234436,
0.6082460880279541,
0.33374109864234924,
-0.6448890566825867,
0.785456657409668,
-0.12462456524372101,
-0.6098834276199341,
0.9073731303215027,
0.5195279121398926,
1.0629572868347168,
-0.24022237956523895,
0.15771673619747162,
-0.025869013741612434,
0.4330313801765442,
0.4097064733505249,
0.11131840944290161,
-0.2320237010717392,
-0.1820376068353653,
0.011488856747746468,
-0.33467915654182434,
-0.27091118693351746,
0.422420471906662,
-0.6396143436431885,
0.06974141299724579,
-0.7877867221832275,
-0.024117201566696167,
-0.0076597146689891815,
-0.31666815280914307,
-0.7108593583106995,
-0.07183163613080978,
0.09734805673360825,
1.0123779773712158,
-0.6238527297973633,
0.5825009942054749,
0.29812780022621155,
-0.49367043375968933,
-0.7807896137237549,
0.328321248292923,
0.1266075223684311,
-1.0516527891159058,
0.6234089136123657,
0.11772166192531586,
-0.10099998116493225,
-0.263161838054657,
-0.7364879250526428,
-0.8354743123054504,
0.7293246984481812,
0.029968786984682083,
-0.5597927570343018,
-0.414883553981781,
0.44579795002937317,
0.5081379413604736,
-0.2252182513475418,
0.23858514428138733,
0.48989906907081604,
0.15041905641555786,
-0.40913212299346924,
-0.9822747707366943,
0.2973252236843109,
-0.2138546109199524,
-0.1677989959716797,
0.053083356469869614,
-0.7755144238471985,
0.7444548606872559,
0.1673547774553299,
-0.1211315467953682,
0.48783987760543823,
0.7497158050537109,
-0.30206575989723206,
0.2965792715549469,
0.13387416303157806,
0.21339718997478485,
0.7096855044364929,
0.4205076992511749,
0.9485517740249634,
-0.4676697254180908,
-0.39583665132522583,
1.2264530658721924,
-0.03865683078765869,
0.9628244638442993,
0.6405507326126099,
0.18611036241054535,
0.31670212745666504,
0.5171751379966736,
0.15528258681297302,
0.6527166962623596,
0.23944619297981262,
-0.313714861869812,
0.2389707863330841,
-0.02732359804213047,
-0.3998583257198334,
0.4688538610935211,
0.3811419606208801,
-0.5944926142692566,
-0.03589716553688049,
0.720454216003418,
0.14612825214862823,
0.04801077023148537,
-0.41123396158218384,
1.112158179283142,
0.09032876789569855,
-0.8268797993659973,
0.21792390942573547,
0.2973080277442932,
0.4747544527053833,
-0.5671915411949158,
0.003518235171213746,
-0.24197159707546234,
0.06674117594957352,
0.03093642182648182,
-0.35454344749450684,
0.08172733336687088,
0.26852884888648987,
0.21867810189723969,
-0.11146098375320435,
0.5737359523773193,
-0.20199422538280487,
-0.21999748051166534,
-0.003885172074660659,
0.14023332297801971,
0.20570887625217438,
-0.17650432884693146,
-0.5395045876502991,
0.21374857425689697,
0.05064597725868225,
0.06095990538597107,
0.363128662109375,
0.21265290677547455,
0.0364217534661293,
0.5105810761451721,
0.5348140597343445,
-0.16413864493370056,
0.2270546853542328,
-0.16618867218494415,
0.932178258895874,
-0.47151467204093933,
-0.7740388512611389,
-1.20168137550354,
0.07698442786931992,
-0.35476547479629517,
-0.4500257074832916,
0.8173373937606812,
0.5638493299484253,
0.8138161301612854,
0.1676030158996582,
0.902902364730835,
0.09828753024339676,
0.3222011923789978,
-0.4270545244216919,
0.6384029388427734,
-0.16440996527671814,
0.38756051659584045,
0.016713440418243408,
-0.14566011726856232,
-0.084307461977005,
0.02532247267663479,
-0.48013871908187866,
-0.02579426020383835,
0.4870463013648987,
0.7160648107528687,
0.2218896597623825,
0.20096509158611298,
0.24372422695159912,
0.16174915432929993,
0.7562593221664429,
0.2220761477947235,
0.7219935059547424,
-0.2029925435781479,
0.5774775743484497,
-0.029032547026872635,
-0.31274929642677307,
-0.268042653799057,
-0.3697887063026428,
-1.2185465097427368,
-0.6184672117233276,
-0.03665422648191452,
-0.4916315972805023,
0.5132579803466797,
0.9811636805534363,
0.4231615960597992,
-0.618699848651886,
-0.06668245792388916,
-0.2687828242778778,
-0.13567906618118286,
0.19959023594856262,
-0.17152442038059235,
0.4329640567302704,
-0.17927025258541107,
-0.4842872619628906,
0.45722442865371704,
-0.07633872330188751,
0.1189303919672966,
-0.5456253290176392,
0.1332560032606125,
-0.20942482352256775,
0.20941965281963348,
0.056348901242017746,
0.5451586842536926,
-0.9159462451934814,
-0.3560934364795685,
0.29842960834503174,
-0.2556917071342468,
-0.2116665542125702,
0.8424612879753113,
-0.5264248251914978,
0.36202824115753174,
0.5275351405143738,
1.1173663139343262,
0.1137789711356163,
0.18162085115909576,
0.8552428483963013,
-0.910612940788269,
0.19261059165000916,
0.42962923645973206,
0.29993611574172974,
0.29411813616752625,
-0.8219813108444214,
0.08710679411888123,
-0.003194027580320835,
-0.5017873644828796,
-0.8074827790260315,
0.39298000931739807,
-0.5927805304527283,
-0.7600643634796143,
1.0176440477371216,
-0.3135826885700226,
-0.5602125525474548,
-0.08110696077346802,
-0.5493319034576416,
0.10131245851516724,
-0.5905436873435974,
0.8230751156806946,
0.5584525465965271,
-0.08050914853811264,
0.08743797242641449,
-0.19178292155265808,
0.7719238996505737,
0.37284839153289795,
-0.7218893766403198,
-0.09553337097167969,
0.32652366161346436,
0.03700784966349602,
0.41517212986946106,
0.6782627105712891,
0.2090175449848175,
0.39876216650009155,
0.3427792489528656,
-0.6696391701698303,
-0.12830878794193268,
-0.47543105483055115,
-0.5840380787849426,
0.37688902020454407,
0.12384046614170074,
-0.8584274649620056
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09207v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09207v2
|
TaxoLLaMA: WordNet-based Model for Solving Multiple Lexical Semantic Tasks
| 2024-03-14T09:21:25 | 2024-06-17T16:43:10 |
Viktor Moskvoretskii, Ekaterina Neminova, Alina Lobanova, Alexander Panchenko, Irina Nikishina
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this paper, we explore the capabilities of LLMs in capturing
lexical-semantic knowledge from WordNet on the example of the LLaMA-2-7b model
and test it on multiple lexical semantic tasks. As the outcome of our
experiments, we present TaxoLLaMA, the everything-in-one model, lightweight due
to 4-bit quantization and LoRA. It achieves 11 SotA results, 4 top-2 results
out of 16 tasks for the Taxonomy Enrichment, Hypernym Discovery, Taxonomy
Construction, and Lexical Entailment tasks. Moreover, it demonstrates very
strong zero-shot performance on Lexical Entailment and Taxonomy Construction
with no fine-tuning. We also explore its hidden multilingual and domain
adaptation capabilities with a little tuning or few-shot learning. All
datasets, code, and model are available online at
https://github.com/VityaVitalich/TaxoLLaMA
|
[
-0.04462642967700958,
-0.6707139015197754,
0.5515052080154419,
0.13230974972248077,
-0.20080673694610596,
-0.15885542333126068,
-0.0874682292342186,
-0.344624400138855,
0.6074527502059937,
0.7107508182525635,
-0.43060946464538574,
-0.6424707174301147,
-0.7813609838485718,
0.17310956120491028,
-0.5388094186782837,
0.7712140083312988,
-0.060793470591306686,
-0.17786818742752075,
-0.23401062190532684,
-0.3241480886936188,
-0.5219815969467163,
-0.3960777223110199,
-0.3711402416229248,
0.05465107411146164,
0.6438928842544556,
0.5984978079795837,
0.4712172746658325,
0.5179674625396729,
0.4662603735923767,
0.15410082042217255,
0.016483310610055923,
0.22007744014263153,
-0.4969521462917328,
0.06636593490839005,
-0.21798589825630188,
-0.7264844179153442,
-0.4283303916454315,
-0.32693201303482056,
0.4840543568134308,
0.3441266417503357,
-0.3492673337459564,
0.6359500885009766,
-0.13075882196426392,
0.22415633499622345,
-1.0338990688323975,
-0.01455621886998415,
-1.1754544973373413,
-0.48496168851852417,
-0.29301682114601135,
0.00039743760135024786,
0.03989427536725998,
-0.11424273252487183,
-0.1179075613617897,
-1.0139343738555908,
-0.054951757192611694,
0.11742306500673294,
0.8564467430114746,
0.5206721425056458,
-0.5042017698287964,
-0.5265972018241882,
-0.3827363848686218,
0.7743164300918579,
-0.7989299893379211,
0.20412079989910126,
0.3963930606842041,
-0.020453020930290222,
0.10129085183143616,
-0.7555353045463562,
-0.8061453104019165,
0.06570291519165039,
0.3611660897731781,
0.2840620279312134,
-0.25014182925224304,
-0.18963298201560974,
-0.0009017187403514981,
0.013182416558265686,
-0.51047283411026,
0.1048155128955841,
-0.2476857304573059,
-0.27569061517715454,
0.24054089188575745,
0.2869095802307129,
0.24173879623413086,
-0.35082748532295227,
-0.6773614287376404,
-0.08735571801662445,
-0.8795836567878723,
-0.17908354103565216,
0.18252971768379211,
0.4250713586807251,
0.08489835262298584,
0.6850494742393494,
-0.050429314374923706,
0.6256159543991089,
-0.7943978905677795,
-0.25560078024864197,
0.02559579536318779,
-0.521187961101532,
-0.31076639890670776,
0.21449784934520721,
0.5742614269256592,
-0.09593425691127777,
0.055301882326602936,
-0.08926146477460861,
-0.1723138689994812,
0.47426679730415344,
0.17159678041934967,
-0.9357659220695496,
0.2822165787220001,
0.2979256212711334,
-0.36093899607658386,
-0.4177314043045044,
-0.40947702527046204,
-0.6408957839012146,
-0.2443447858095169,
-0.1691579520702362,
1.0867946147918701,
-0.38081490993499756,
-0.4190947711467743,
0.6281279921531677,
-0.061418045312166214,
0.21025753021240234,
0.25607427954673767,
-0.3765046298503876,
0.47964367270469666,
0.9460991024971008,
0.989060640335083,
-0.18910011649131775,
-0.5009539127349854,
-0.44877129793167114,
0.1834656298160553,
-0.3644011318683624,
0.792757511138916,
-0.4308910369873047,
-0.17399168014526367,
-0.016504211351275444,
-0.19764459133148193,
-0.2374565601348877,
-0.5234240889549255,
0.17557865381240845,
-0.7230335474014282,
-0.1452537626028061,
-0.08197362720966339,
-0.7407350540161133,
-0.5491447448730469,
0.67339026927948,
-0.8157835602760315,
0.9144458174705505,
-0.0021240555215626955,
-0.7017076015472412,
0.14740417897701263,
-0.5093684792518616,
-0.057672034949064255,
0.2250121384859085,
0.22264844179153442,
-0.22741377353668213,
0.24469096958637238,
-0.28882771730422974,
0.4018840193748474,
-0.540734052658081,
0.499827116727829,
-0.24187670648097992,
-0.4151470959186554,
0.05148489028215408,
-0.04426790401339531,
0.732056736946106,
0.249282106757164,
-0.19274362921714783,
0.03777448460459709,
-0.9352866411209106,
-0.10884653776884079,
0.2770407497882843,
-0.16514535248279572,
-0.5507185459136963,
-0.17383883893489838,
0.16818155348300934,
0.1445585936307907,
0.566831648349762,
-0.7401126027107239,
0.38311928510665894,
-0.449169397354126,
0.29539352655410767,
0.34745368361473083,
-0.22636660933494568,
0.010790166445076466,
-0.2061459720134735,
0.6444783210754395,
0.2349427044391632,
0.059772077947854996,
0.11448300629854202,
-0.5695490837097168,
-1.007235050201416,
-0.40167108178138733,
0.6627886295318604,
0.6975958943367004,
-0.9727672934532166,
-0.05027380958199501,
-0.49775180220603943,
-0.4571433961391449,
-0.4042178690433502,
0.30238890647888184,
0.2224300056695938,
0.2191212773323059,
0.2680880129337311,
-0.2945208251476288,
-0.2111443728208542,
-0.6415079832077026,
-0.013363108038902283,
-0.03137844428420067,
0.21561141312122345,
0.014761485159397125,
0.8476872444152832,
-0.2912946045398712,
0.9022619128227234,
-0.5689306855201721,
-0.6761448979377747,
-0.2602301239967346,
0.12329519540071487,
0.24698993563652039,
0.14769481122493744,
0.3981800377368927,
-0.5015912652015686,
0.16666559875011444,
-0.295883446931839,
-0.608261227607727,
-0.0007773637771606445,
0.18428094685077667,
-0.40155938267707825,
-0.06282977759838104,
0.1545320451259613,
-0.6236522197723389,
0.7274880409240723,
0.4261767566204071,
-0.40131738781929016,
0.3708580732345581,
-0.0017466730205342174,
-0.31852665543556213,
-1.6012096405029297,
0.08829980343580246,
-0.24603582918643951,
-0.2632155120372772,
-0.6534168124198914,
0.35173431038856506,
0.10124681890010834,
-0.14868241548538208,
-0.5813136100769043,
0.6565871238708496,
-0.08210190385580063,
-0.04277600347995758,
-0.5743038058280945,
0.2813703119754791,
0.11932351440191269,
0.5735207796096802,
0.11332441866397858,
0.7049669623374939,
0.6247246265411377,
-0.6304033398628235,
0.37098658084869385,
0.3481828272342682,
-0.36497440934181213,
0.20724116265773773,
-0.704001784324646,
0.10621187835931778,
-0.14003615081310272,
-0.10052987933158875,
-0.9962584972381592,
-0.017778925597667694,
0.030383655801415443,
-0.25511297583580017,
-0.0955253392457962,
0.10394261032342911,
-0.8413673639297485,
0.010638638399541378,
-0.557384192943573,
0.5304057002067566,
0.1162884309887886,
-0.4037790298461914,
0.8359090685844421,
0.40345776081085205,
0.1572720855474472,
-0.4976046681404114,
-0.5530011057853699,
0.29618096351623535,
-0.32173386216163635,
-0.35881754755973816,
0.5008440613746643,
0.22765812277793884,
-0.07964733242988586,
0.24515704810619354,
0.059813614934682846,
-0.0017143398290500045,
0.38697484135627747,
0.03997122123837471,
0.4862836003303528,
-0.1862477958202362,
0.43948015570640564,
-0.22560614347457886,
0.086543507874012,
-0.1873314529657364,
-0.4683348536491394,
0.546855092048645,
-0.07365047931671143,
-0.23552821576595306,
-0.13747763633728027,
0.2661111056804657,
0.17450281977653503,
-0.40301212668418884,
0.7992414832115173,
0.5499045848846436,
-0.6954730153083801,
-0.09825791418552399,
-0.6806219816207886,
0.017689719796180725,
-0.32676932215690613,
0.34779515862464905,
-0.5876505970954895,
-1.0777612924575806,
0.5516796708106995,
-0.24962928891181946,
-0.06342913955450058,
0.5352555513381958,
0.5923099517822266,
0.3361686170101166,
0.47894102334976196,
0.7204313278198242,
-0.21133537590503693,
-0.015278339385986328,
-0.6797722578048706,
0.08972997963428497,
-0.7938054203987122,
-0.1401807963848114,
-0.6407313346862793,
-0.29834163188934326,
-0.7660555839538574,
-0.3104785084724426,
0.5487764477729797,
0.25292500853538513,
-0.33204975724220276,
0.5890322327613831,
-0.39562177658081055,
0.15459862351417542,
0.6845057010650635,
0.10706839710474014,
0.39116212725639343,
-0.03554398939013481,
0.1251946985721588,
0.42307233810424805,
-0.8171146512031555,
-0.47923728823661804,
1.2367995977401733,
-0.0340430848300457,
0.7382305860519409,
0.561072826385498,
0.7405264973640442,
0.02732391282916069,
0.1478288620710373,
-1.2540091276168823,
0.4258083403110504,
-0.4180770516395569,
-0.6230126619338989,
-0.14954091608524323,
-0.4531480371952057,
-1.006973147392273,
0.3767300546169281,
-0.03496512770652771,
-0.8483706116676331,
0.19354768097400665,
-0.24106372892856598,
-0.49064356088638306,
0.28538909554481506,
-0.20956413447856903,
0.8511427044868469,
-0.1495693027973175,
-0.48545151948928833,
-0.491312175989151,
-0.4949547052383423,
0.4370287358760834,
-0.2236441671848297,
0.4025181233882904,
-0.48898619413375854,
-0.6020152568817139,
1.1100784540176392,
-0.5446969866752625,
0.8924905061721802,
-0.016099926084280014,
-0.24262939393520355,
0.5176312923431396,
0.577412486076355,
0.13139492273330688,
-0.011751900427043438,
0.09611701965332031,
0.372752845287323,
0.6705293655395508,
-0.21984319388866425,
-0.5115861296653748,
0.684862494468689,
-0.7644848823547363,
-0.5008764266967773,
-0.47529155015945435,
-0.4100053310394287,
-0.29911816120147705,
0.2521298825740814,
-0.07882879674434662,
0.9098284840583801,
0.1808224320411682,
-0.10383808612823486,
0.40642306208610535,
-0.06645640730857849,
0.38750162720680237,
0.47832679748535156,
-0.2666501998901367,
-0.3933335542678833,
1.1917121410369873,
0.05668874830007553,
0.03006168082356453,
0.5063085556030273,
0.4050601124763489,
-0.25668421387672424,
-0.2002858966588974,
-0.43382135033607483,
0.2804325819015503,
-0.7806313633918762,
-0.7805735468864441,
-0.4847905933856964,
0.06685890257358551,
-0.29057392477989197,
0.38847747445106506,
-0.3982747495174408,
-0.6663396954536438,
-0.4777844548225403,
0.25325196981430054,
0.6550414562225342,
1.074900507926941,
0.1122526302933693,
0.35136860609054565,
-0.7909860610961914,
0.30803874135017395,
0.24599048495292664,
0.05797874554991722,
0.30162617564201355,
-0.5342606902122498,
-0.06216279789805412,
-0.08873230963945389,
-0.27381211519241333,
-0.7349476218223572,
0.419904500246048,
0.40213143825531006,
0.022088758647441864,
0.011600883677601814,
-0.2863224148750305,
0.6444734334945679,
-0.30492857098579407,
0.8575323224067688,
0.07422445714473724,
-1.1126834154129028,
0.3883400559425354,
0.007737528067082167,
0.37127068638801575,
0.6747811436653137,
0.5538240075111389,
-0.4933752119541168,
0.04467569664120674,
-0.3751946687698364,
-0.7154701352119446,
0.5196211338043213,
0.044922199100255966,
0.23172734677791595,
-0.06253029406070709,
0.3179461359977722,
0.2708528935909271,
0.33729466795921326,
-0.3548016846179962,
0.05649379640817642,
-0.394601047039032,
-0.6565783023834229,
0.2364593893289566,
-0.5151469111442566,
0.004134902730584145,
0.008956731297075748,
0.5636099576950073,
-0.41058871150016785,
0.004437444265931845,
0.06365957111120224,
-0.30448275804519653,
0.5395111441612244,
0.26573920249938965,
0.6551867127418518,
0.6754786968231201,
0.0185761209577322,
0.46128690242767334,
0.2690217196941376,
-0.6277860403060913,
0.11831929534673691,
-0.13083136081695557,
0.01476866565644741,
-0.15690568089485168,
0.5185468196868896,
0.794758141040802,
0.4746946692466736,
-0.655489981174469,
0.7353824377059937,
0.10533856600522995,
-0.339979350566864,
-0.17515288293361664,
-0.24910622835159302,
0.21690085530281067,
-0.04766811057925224,
0.0698719397187233,
-0.3155168294906616,
0.3080099821090698,
-0.4934843182563782,
-0.05234825611114502,
0.367299884557724,
-0.08514720946550369,
-0.35512104630470276,
0.7396059632301331,
-0.1319170445203781,
0.1214643120765686,
0.46107253432273865,
-0.35367706418037415,
-0.836490273475647,
0.6074016094207764,
0.6872696876525879,
0.6227523684501648,
0.2547757029533386,
0.0884917825460434,
0.14959634840488434,
0.03779194504022598,
-0.04161887988448143,
0.6352924704551697,
-0.36074674129486084,
-1.0792677402496338,
-0.5356638431549072,
-0.8888635039329529,
-0.37402811646461487,
-0.17051546275615692,
-0.46746790409088135,
0.23954235017299652,
-0.08624788373708725,
-0.11993079632520676,
-0.1703757643699646,
0.017439167946577072,
-0.7803482413291931,
0.028000358492136,
0.10944513231515884,
1.0749473571777344,
-0.40224725008010864,
0.845081627368927,
0.6440600156784058,
-0.45572593808174133,
-1.1028639078140259,
-0.1979956328868866,
0.05607892572879791,
-1.367220163345337,
0.9868934154510498,
0.025057390332221985,
-0.490262895822525,
0.38857409358024597,
-0.5351916551589966,
-1.2382655143737793,
1.0952099561691284,
0.14324979484081268,
-0.4339164197444916,
-0.005217153578996658,
0.3708438277244568,
0.20816153287887573,
-0.20834077894687653,
0.37440139055252075,
0.5485342144966125,
0.20684050023555756,
0.3619230389595032,
-0.8723170161247253,
0.023908095434308052,
0.01703307032585144,
0.31451615691185,
0.04825576767325401,
-0.7766391038894653,
0.6521484851837158,
0.11982057988643646,
-0.15999522805213928,
0.2978082001209259,
0.4596397280693054,
0.3397060036659241,
0.06265618652105331,
0.6030454635620117,
1.1035352945327759,
0.6136953830718994,
0.08947919309139252,
0.9082800149917603,
-0.5121333003044128,
0.47188517451286316,
0.8841375112533569,
-0.7210754752159119,
1.0691978931427002,
0.354876309633255,
-0.09231435507535934,
0.3061140775680542,
0.457166463136673,
0.28120914101600647,
0.570071816444397,
0.5078709125518799,
-0.39789044857025146,
-0.38072317838668823,
-0.6684897541999817,
-0.0490906685590744,
1.15015709400177,
0.4496282637119293,
0.5397268533706665,
-0.35518908500671387,
0.1740836501121521,
0.2380884885787964,
-0.24904365837574005,
-0.5578529238700867,
0.9668827652931213,
0.20030108094215393,
-0.3148934543132782,
0.6285481452941895,
0.06345660984516144,
1.1117061376571655,
-0.7399961948394775,
-0.044454511255025864,
-0.012294941581785679,
0.03663506358861923,
-0.16424906253814697,
-0.48175808787345886,
0.30652162432670593,
0.07828295230865479,
0.21855725347995758,
0.07438982278108597,
1.0262598991394043,
-0.3217635452747345,
-0.8902315497398376,
0.294974148273468,
0.6745945811271667,
0.324805349111557,
-0.21697303652763367,
-0.32434478402137756,
0.2893347144126892,
-0.4782582223415375,
-0.24492275714874268,
0.12078292667865753,
0.39862143993377686,
-0.0587749220430851,
0.4846351444721222,
0.3711455464363098,
0.3913383185863495,
0.2389923483133316,
0.453472763299942,
0.6898962259292603,
-0.6033486127853394,
-0.12015482038259506,
-0.8932416439056396,
-0.10427803546190262,
0.2979731559753418,
-0.526716411113739,
0.537729024887085,
0.6338266730308533,
0.8718517422676086,
0.1044800877571106,
0.3345820903778076,
0.03422833979129791,
0.36699581146240234,
-0.6431112289428711,
0.4845171868801117,
-0.9758172631263733,
-0.15967302024364471,
0.23712708055973053,
-0.7849131226539612,
-0.3354761302471161,
0.1260097175836563,
0.16568797826766968,
-0.2583117187023163,
0.7952707409858704,
0.8202996253967285,
-0.029523244127631187,
0.17248684167861938,
0.44058316946029663,
-0.145450621843338,
-0.0354117713868618,
0.8076220750808716,
0.8540155291557312,
-0.5537580847740173,
0.4325799345970154,
-0.22874628007411957,
-0.12129108607769012,
0.03302036598324776,
-0.8223602771759033,
-0.5486093759536743,
-0.6939734220504761,
-0.24106644093990326,
-0.1135888621211052,
-0.12280680239200592,
0.863942563533783,
0.5959199070930481,
-0.757182776927948,
-0.4001017212867737,
0.08342152833938599,
0.10154999792575836,
0.0821683257818222,
-0.19330008327960968,
0.4560639560222626,
-0.456014484167099,
-0.43470337986946106,
0.25519412755966187,
0.22922027111053467,
-0.33509111404418945,
-0.24759778380393982,
0.48901721835136414,
-0.344759076833725,
0.14523503184318542,
0.7288342118263245,
-0.320142924785614,
-0.7352497577667236,
-0.14604951441287994,
0.10120062530040741,
-0.04624687507748604,
-0.19238750636577606,
0.8254132866859436,
-0.7921779155731201,
0.23494887351989746,
0.40925243496894836,
0.9067105650901794,
0.6272940039634705,
-0.2761712074279785,
0.04704448953270912,
-0.4292527735233307,
0.20648309588432312,
-0.03297320753335953,
0.520094096660614,
0.13304907083511353,
-0.2770257592201233,
0.6607189774513245,
0.3354198932647705,
-0.2913093864917755,
-0.5784503221511841,
0.07290241867303848,
-0.9500877261161804,
-0.33465632796287537,
1.205521821975708,
0.07595592737197876,
-0.6204296946525574,
0.1958101987838745,
0.12260690331459045,
0.2678937613964081,
0.06107195094227791,
0.41365355253219604,
0.7263832092285156,
0.21452288329601288,
0.2212323099374771,
-0.745863139629364,
0.15024596452713013,
0.5169278383255005,
-0.8775854110717773,
-0.2658628821372986,
0.1277259886264801,
0.46331340074539185,
0.21107612550258636,
0.6000241041183472,
0.04363635182380676,
0.0783638283610344,
-0.0746532529592514,
0.31455016136169434,
-0.19129791855812073,
-0.37004977464675903,
-0.31637683510780334,
0.16348782181739807,
0.2036958485841751,
-0.4165589213371277
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09167v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09167v1
|
Dial-insight: Fine-tuning Large Language Models with High-Quality Domain-Specific Data Preventing Capability Collapse
| 2024-03-14T08:27:32 | 2024-03-14T08:27:32 |
Jianwei Sun, Chaoyang Mei, Linlin Wei, Kaiyu Zheng, Na Liu, Ming Cui, Tianyi Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The efficacy of large language models (LLMs) is heavily dependent on the
quality of the underlying data, particularly within specialized domains. A
common challenge when fine-tuning LLMs for domain-specific applications is the
potential degradation of the model's generalization capabilities. To address
these issues, we propose a two-stage approach for the construction of
production prompts designed to yield high-quality data. This method involves
the generation of a diverse array of prompts that encompass a broad spectrum of
tasks and exhibit a rich variety of expressions. Furthermore, we introduce a
cost-effective, multi-dimensional quality assessment framework to ensure the
integrity of the generated labeling data. Utilizing a dataset comprised of
service provider and customer interactions from the real estate sector, we
demonstrate a positive correlation between data quality and model performance.
Notably, our findings indicate that the domain-specific proficiency of general
LLMs can be enhanced through fine-tuning with data produced via our proposed
method, without compromising their overall generalization abilities, even when
exclusively domain-specific data is employed for fine-tuning.
|
[
-0.42022010684013367,
-0.8322573900222778,
0.4578419625759125,
-0.11412887275218964,
-0.06946968287229538,
0.1424064040184021,
-0.25317561626434326,
-0.18282178044319153,
-0.28012511134147644,
0.9166302680969238,
-0.458621621131897,
-0.7595970034599304,
-0.2893211841583252,
-0.019177276641130447,
-0.12214743345975876,
0.7820547819137573,
0.09426857531070709,
0.00232909107580781,
-0.32354703545570374,
-0.00936712697148323,
-0.7704885005950928,
-0.5461907982826233,
-0.660869300365448,
-0.2354295700788498,
0.24279506504535675,
0.6231479048728943,
0.9623592495918274,
0.7739794850349426,
0.39982813596725464,
0.18772627413272858,
0.09544162452220917,
0.8147696852684021,
-0.6234340071678162,
0.328940749168396,
-0.18435236811637878,
-0.2807024121284485,
-0.7297983765602112,
0.056072935461997986,
0.5154290199279785,
0.9783653616905212,
-0.012060494162142277,
0.04919245094060898,
0.3241618871688843,
0.4968234598636627,
-0.27307024598121643,
0.2651683986186981,
-0.6563696265220642,
-0.17368310689926147,
0.05725602060556412,
-0.4198858439922333,
-0.5434344410896301,
-0.4853406250476837,
0.22311897575855255,
-0.7287945747375488,
0.34822773933410645,
0.19470523297786713,
1.070765733718872,
0.224021315574646,
-0.4367096424102783,
-0.17004726827144623,
-0.6993460655212402,
0.8720770478248596,
-0.7107653021812439,
0.3064632713794708,
0.5122818350791931,
0.2690989673137665,
-0.3399585485458374,
-0.3634309768676758,
-0.29081612825393677,
-0.03812485933303833,
0.11285346001386642,
-0.01851576194167137,
-0.005701867863535881,
0.10016938298940659,
0.21348024904727936,
0.22284479439258575,
-0.4981037676334381,
0.32834798097610474,
-0.2448674887418747,
-0.45337241888046265,
0.583347499370575,
0.49625363945961,
0.09801964461803436,
-0.16162535548210144,
-0.08692474663257599,
0.08319021761417389,
-1.022963523864746,
0.17996016144752502,
0.4482174515724182,
0.7544044852256775,
0.23576712608337402,
0.5619745254516602,
-0.38948312401771545,
0.5080588459968567,
-0.09309850633144379,
-0.1892339289188385,
0.10737285763025284,
-0.6362433433532715,
-0.20443925261497498,
-0.38094601035118103,
0.5759328007698059,
0.48592719435691833,
0.34384024143218994,
-0.1565186083316803,
-0.46500149369239807,
-0.1314796358346939,
0.17906132340431213,
-0.8158736228942871,
0.0167341697961092,
0.5687831044197083,
-0.3383040130138397,
-0.15432646870613098,
-0.1074427142739296,
-0.7672843337059021,
-0.3488312363624573,
-0.6654742360115051,
0.2475419044494629,
-0.3127150535583496,
-0.19108426570892334,
0.2408970296382904,
0.18341146409511566,
0.15970872342586517,
0.4933677017688751,
-0.5949256420135498,
0.23831164836883545,
0.7651475071907043,
0.6989279389381409,
-0.26140281558036804,
-0.10692891478538513,
-0.9556998610496521,
-0.013602802529931068,
-0.49643343687057495,
0.5847232937812805,
-0.7640110850334167,
-0.44806382060050964,
0.4285799562931061,
-0.06170351430773735,
0.1139538511633873,
-1.086235761642456,
0.6200308203697205,
-0.6964679956436157,
0.07245735079050064,
-0.16054712235927582,
-0.6568176746368408,
-0.01767558977007866,
0.18878382444381714,
-0.4839605391025543,
0.8536797761917114,
0.3971762955188751,
-0.2646819055080414,
0.39238977432250977,
-0.3704738914966583,
-0.3729036748409271,
0.18731088936328888,
-0.13629752397537231,
-0.48536416888237,
0.16075550019741058,
0.2978542149066925,
0.5698469281196594,
-0.5631601214408875,
0.4709922969341278,
-0.11252723634243011,
0.06416038423776627,
0.3675253689289093,
-0.3213562071323395,
0.4304082989692688,
0.3226834833621979,
-0.012114450335502625,
0.09110702574253082,
-0.9983453750610352,
0.12163557857275009,
-0.12959548830986023,
-0.40746790170669556,
-0.05615995079278946,
-0.08745953440666199,
-0.118735671043396,
0.22032953798770905,
0.23984721302986145,
-0.21741999685764313,
0.23097285628318787,
-0.26722487807273865,
0.35042813420295715,
0.4955292344093323,
0.041676536202430725,
0.3854547142982483,
-0.41201481223106384,
0.8143091201782227,
0.34347668290138245,
0.17443227767944336,
-0.3992829918861389,
-0.45046448707580566,
-0.8599776029586792,
-0.173368901014328,
0.42031988501548767,
0.4875994324684143,
-0.6893683671951294,
0.5473194122314453,
-0.32245391607284546,
-0.3620876371860504,
-0.6479875445365906,
0.23014774918556213,
0.2897070646286011,
0.6123939752578735,
0.35986751317977905,
-0.3599887490272522,
-0.1864672750234604,
-0.8305395245552063,
0.004912060219794512,
0.22099296748638153,
-0.07354417443275452,
0.5611498951911926,
0.16015015542507172,
-0.36006394028663635,
1.1540318727493286,
-0.7648881673812866,
-0.29986652731895447,
-0.19079576432704926,
0.22340577840805054,
0.3675568401813507,
0.45999598503112793,
0.380003958940506,
-0.6492862701416016,
-0.3008653223514557,
-0.003560985904186964,
-0.48466160893440247,
-0.2470138520002365,
-0.20219317078590393,
-0.13396625220775604,
0.0882914736866951,
0.3535454273223877,
-0.5513424277305603,
0.27783071994781494,
0.3944109380245209,
-0.2955569922924042,
0.8777191638946533,
-0.3034045398235321,
0.19670473039150238,
-0.9264543056488037,
-0.19023436307907104,
0.11344335973262787,
-0.22626137733459473,
-0.8309240341186523,
-0.2666069567203522,
-0.11557649075984955,
-0.5059689879417419,
-0.23925112187862396,
0.37066367268562317,
-0.3599003255367279,
-0.05246681720018387,
-0.18327374756336212,
0.12198885530233383,
0.360310435295105,
0.40132495760917664,
-0.07053237408399582,
1.1057862043380737,
0.5949402451515198,
-0.8123026490211487,
0.15033531188964844,
0.4338234066963196,
-0.5816906094551086,
0.554780900478363,
-0.7196770906448364,
0.12048180401325226,
-0.041643738746643066,
-0.12405461072921753,
-1.0431849956512451,
-0.449165016412735,
-0.026450054720044136,
-0.33228054642677307,
0.20595242083072662,
-0.09878800064325333,
-0.5232657194137573,
-0.029119819402694702,
-0.21497711539268494,
0.284918874502182,
0.4178033471107483,
-0.3964233100414276,
0.46251001954078674,
0.2998582720756531,
-0.6093462109565735,
-0.2040100395679474,
-0.4580766260623932,
0.10937737673521042,
-0.18438269197940826,
-0.7931739687919617,
0.006020916625857353,
-0.08687831461429596,
-0.09744235128164291,
-0.30488699674606323,
0.13145945966243744,
-0.3061657249927521,
0.17968536913394928,
0.12590178847312927,
0.20752431452274323,
-0.320669025182724,
0.16078098118305206,
0.36916476488113403,
-0.11890619993209839,
0.06570449471473694,
-0.2948041558265686,
0.5873665809631348,
0.2901396155357361,
-0.28741127252578735,
-0.6597860455513,
0.47618454694747925,
0.9202256798744202,
-0.4153757691383362,
0.609920859336853,
0.15082904696464539,
-0.3266863226890564,
-0.4870721101760864,
-0.44008052349090576,
-0.11159010231494904,
-0.5150485038757324,
0.2436767816543579,
-0.6052605509757996,
-0.9371636509895325,
0.6729703545570374,
-0.47190403938293457,
0.021255232393741608,
0.232796311378479,
0.42642906308174133,
0.10578014701604843,
1.2126471996307373,
0.7158477902412415,
0.07452686131000519,
0.2559705078601837,
-0.30914855003356934,
0.45036035776138306,
-0.7108478546142578,
-0.31184226274490356,
-0.711731493473053,
0.13694289326667786,
-0.27429068088531494,
-0.6132971048355103,
0.46953344345092773,
0.2567993998527527,
-0.2483263909816742,
0.20324523746967316,
-0.3775782883167267,
0.13148626685142517,
0.45972496271133423,
0.026306726038455963,
0.5012648701667786,
0.20990437269210815,
-0.013347538188099861,
-0.13265924155712128,
-0.5677844882011414,
-0.8742347359657288,
0.9879066944122314,
0.5990942120552063,
0.6983506679534912,
0.02957497164607048,
0.29313206672668457,
0.3027365505695343,
-0.12371227890253067,
-0.8676806092262268,
0.3508741855621338,
-0.1296326071023941,
-0.29175788164138794,
-0.5024974942207336,
-0.5869059562683105,
-0.8867355585098267,
0.08561938256025314,
0.03770511597394943,
-0.5041033029556274,
0.4890795350074768,
0.1412317305803299,
-0.613435685634613,
-0.1566777229309082,
-0.7662067413330078,
0.6912112832069397,
-0.06828195601701736,
-0.32879993319511414,
-0.21398603916168213,
-0.17645177245140076,
0.1259109526872635,
-0.4863975942134857,
0.4501890242099762,
-0.4074731469154358,
0.07648167759180069,
0.4253958463668823,
-0.6217367053031921,
0.9082805514335632,
-0.25333285331726074,
-0.5457748770713806,
0.337514728307724,
0.15875719487667084,
0.5808485150337219,
0.1821419894695282,
-0.3208371102809906,
0.059542786329984665,
-0.31755393743515015,
-0.4359113574028015,
-0.6282731890678406,
0.5677483677864075,
-0.772819459438324,
-0.466499924659729,
0.2516230046749115,
-0.5721879601478577,
-0.7927761673927307,
0.07138191908597946,
0.21308119595050812,
0.8524574637413025,
-0.011398602277040482,
-0.012398877181112766,
0.7292343974113464,
-0.30594566464424133,
0.008301771245896816,
0.3604505658149719,
-0.0013511581346392632,
-0.5255504250526428,
1.0930323600769043,
0.206135094165802,
0.5498875975608826,
0.12145097553730011,
0.026772955432534218,
-0.33106866478919983,
-0.8428218960762024,
-0.26153984665870667,
0.10702494531869888,
-0.5598861575126648,
-0.5500649213790894,
-0.5432725548744202,
-0.17180930078029633,
-0.5965072512626648,
-0.09356001764535904,
-0.3852222263813019,
-0.31423690915107727,
-0.5114386677742004,
0.026913480833172798,
0.15674902498722076,
0.7159808874130249,
0.24718686938285828,
0.4152415096759796,
-1.094955325126648,
0.2301904261112213,
0.3697167932987213,
0.3184911608695984,
-0.03754694014787674,
-0.6984170079231262,
-0.5819066166877747,
0.2797528803348541,
-0.3336564302444458,
-0.3569021224975586,
0.5449344515800476,
0.3262222707271576,
0.4619652330875397,
0.53439861536026,
0.11959977447986603,
0.44565579295158386,
-0.4005606174468994,
0.920780599117279,
0.05991097167134285,
-1.0651814937591553,
0.8196302652359009,
-0.6495020985603333,
0.22030149400234222,
0.47052788734436035,
0.2511201500892639,
-0.3324824869632721,
-0.45303666591644287,
-0.39529523253440857,
-0.9933056831359863,
0.5201223492622375,
0.013106876984238625,
0.25139120221138,
0.06644845753908157,
0.5380563139915466,
0.4054056406021118,
0.42424386739730835,
-0.1329016238451004,
-0.04933265969157219,
-0.0981040894985199,
-0.026750899851322174,
0.1490752398967743,
-0.47475314140319824,
-0.12522096931934357,
-0.20456020534038544,
0.5042811632156372,
-0.5059023499488831,
-0.11556412279605865,
0.03774600476026535,
-0.09683181345462799,
-0.08775916695594788,
0.39328163862228394,
0.5065547227859497,
1.0234630107879639,
-0.008130338042974472,
-0.07795526832342148,
-0.03849904239177704,
-0.2543695569038391,
0.2610723078250885,
-0.25448814034461975,
-0.2665579915046692,
-0.012175748124718666,
0.4594864845275879,
0.8698821067810059,
-0.09230981022119522,
-0.6468973755836487,
0.32635927200317383,
0.09857784956693649,
-0.194047212600708,
0.18095123767852783,
0.17703959345817566,
-0.3448461592197418,
0.12017188966274261,
0.4279644787311554,
-0.11929775029420853,
0.1450599879026413,
-0.5460664629936218,
0.3077378571033478,
0.06564333289861679,
-0.2688857316970825,
-0.4183761775493622,
0.5358375906944275,
0.5001423358917236,
-0.10784226655960083,
0.8029727935791016,
-0.20767168700695038,
-0.4188265800476074,
0.6426871418952942,
0.35478031635284424,
0.7637344598770142,
-0.19131189584732056,
0.38209056854248047,
0.3154391050338745,
0.0739297941327095,
-0.013553477823734283,
0.4208286702632904,
0.3433741331100464,
-1.0051660537719727,
-0.5780089497566223,
-0.501368522644043,
-0.5187400579452515,
0.14920221269130707,
-0.7199373245239258,
0.19051119685173035,
-0.5470794439315796,
-0.4830127954483032,
-0.09623845666646957,
0.059961676597595215,
-0.8600083589553833,
0.4053393006324768,
-0.031774550676345825,
0.9462009072303772,
-0.6818874478340149,
0.7825336456298828,
0.4682748317718506,
-0.35788020491600037,
-0.8134387135505676,
0.03845061734318733,
-0.25191739201545715,
-0.7024449706077576,
0.8763480186462402,
0.124268539249897,
-0.14853383600711823,
-0.025910012423992157,
-0.5797649621963501,
-0.6835547089576721,
0.8982535600662231,
0.5091456770896912,
-0.8847816586494446,
0.1568945050239563,
0.5159695744514465,
0.4972130358219147,
-0.6259527802467346,
-0.11202102154493332,
0.9298063516616821,
0.5175836682319641,
-0.08892995864152908,
-1.022080898284912,
0.013286512345075607,
0.052826978266239166,
0.09389901161193848,
-0.03759389370679855,
-0.5474114418029785,
0.5510719418525696,
-0.22264809906482697,
-0.3190953731536865,
0.08480264991521835,
0.6443703174591064,
-0.0820612758398056,
0.23198920488357544,
0.48932045698165894,
0.44222909212112427,
1.13652503490448,
-0.3441694676876068,
0.7546131014823914,
-0.47881820797920227,
0.4493444859981537,
0.9802426099777222,
-0.3924691677093506,
0.7480697631835938,
0.13771656155586243,
-0.09480342268943787,
0.10922902822494507,
0.5331836342811584,
-0.02501502074301243,
0.5292048454284668,
0.3333185315132141,
-0.0448293536901474,
-0.5505213141441345,
-0.7185329794883728,
-0.184993714094162,
0.4057522416114807,
0.6204462647438049,
-0.033708106726408005,
-0.0653323158621788,
0.1102411225438118,
-0.045660436153411865,
0.1799129843711853,
-0.145510733127594,
0.7200664281845093,
0.04894968494772911,
-0.5304747819900513,
0.6373233199119568,
-0.26165616512298584,
0.4821160137653351,
-0.3980780243873596,
-0.050006695091724396,
-0.444953590631485,
-0.005129173398017883,
-0.2397272139787674,
-0.6933613419532776,
0.23612333834171295,
-0.18263909220695496,
-0.396393746137619,
-0.30781376361846924,
0.4009057283401489,
-0.534803569316864,
-0.2373160570859909,
0.25307387113571167,
0.6094514727592468,
0.03091517463326454,
-0.107369065284729,
-0.36359718441963196,
0.33521997928619385,
-0.02008763514459133,
-0.07607003301382065,
0.15795902907848358,
0.758645236492157,
0.011189404875040054,
0.7024365067481995,
0.5731542110443115,
0.250728964805603,
-0.10702133178710938,
0.42147529125213623,
1.0384800434112549,
-0.6729716658592224,
-0.12111160904169083,
-0.28276878595352173,
0.6718517541885376,
-0.21173273026943207,
-0.5712469220161438,
0.4961203634738922,
0.724560558795929,
0.7044662237167358,
0.07031266391277313,
1.010387659072876,
0.5867461562156677,
0.5917132496833801,
-0.7253692746162415,
0.46059662103652954,
-0.4678833782672882,
0.5299367308616638,
0.06684903800487518,
-0.948164701461792,
-0.2676108479499817,
0.21641038358211517,
-0.2613358497619629,
-0.11224357038736343,
0.5035825967788696,
0.9609925746917725,
0.13254950940608978,
-0.23420356214046478,
0.5155724287033081,
0.15963253378868103,
0.818877637386322,
0.2530602812767029,
0.8885777592658997,
-0.37633514404296875,
0.41026121377944946,
0.051359836012125015,
-0.3150647282600403,
-0.2819502651691437,
-0.6127234101295471,
-0.8804406523704529,
-0.5998741388320923,
-0.6258118748664856,
-0.31736186146736145,
-0.1313755363225937,
0.7697762846946716,
0.8767949938774109,
-1.1044292449951172,
-0.18029771745204926,
0.2142365574836731,
-0.027640873566269875,
-0.00038045644760131836,
-0.2736046612262726,
0.424856036901474,
-0.7838271856307983,
-0.7810803651809692,
0.524871289730072,
0.4859774708747864,
0.08545131981372833,
-0.3511662483215332,
-0.015558925457298756,
0.5329784154891968,
0.22673460841178894,
0.7366020679473877,
-0.10677503794431686,
-0.520893931388855,
-0.4235358238220215,
0.053025029599666595,
-0.20825666189193726,
0.10453295707702637,
1.1390963792800903,
-0.46382662653923035,
0.3730795681476593,
0.4704892039299011,
0.8951178193092346,
-0.047403015196323395,
0.14720112085342407,
0.9982736706733704,
-0.7437618970870972,
-0.13330815732479095,
0.25575315952301025,
0.3360687494277954,
0.4716299772262573,
-0.6338730454444885,
0.27032047510147095,
-0.04960789903998375,
-0.6852023601531982,
-0.6108139157295227,
0.3691461384296417,
-0.903314471244812,
-0.2399720847606659,
1.2493208646774292,
-0.15163958072662354,
0.10716168582439423,
-0.549078106880188,
-0.32971033453941345,
-0.020795876160264015,
-0.7340485453605652,
0.6535319089889526,
0.7307132482528687,
-0.10039959102869034,
0.07943102717399597,
-0.5826584696769714,
0.5617175102233887,
0.3180955946445465,
-0.9098756909370422,
0.521165668964386,
0.8043605089187622,
0.07442411780357361,
0.23247621953487396,
0.3609875738620758,
-0.04100380465388298,
0.05372725427150726,
-0.25389331579208374,
-0.23692812025547028,
-0.05504179373383522,
-0.6090791821479797,
-0.404479444026947,
0.366895467042923,
0.4168897569179535,
-0.1616894006729126
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09164v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09164v1
|
Exploring the Comprehension of ChatGPT in Traditional Chinese Medicine Knowledge
| 2024-03-14T08:20:40 | 2024-03-14T08:20:40 |
Li Yizhen, Huang Shaohan, Qi Jiaxing, Quan Lei, Han Dongran, Luan Zhongzhi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, stat.AP
|
No previous work has studied the performance of Large Language Models (LLMs)
in the context of Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM), an essential and distinct
branch of medical knowledge with a rich history. To bridge this gap, we present
a TCM question dataset named TCM-QA, which comprises three question types:
single choice, multiple choice, and true or false, to examine the LLM's
capacity for knowledge recall and comprehensive reasoning within the TCM
domain. In our study, we evaluate two settings of the LLM, zero-shot and
few-shot settings, while concurrently discussing the differences between
English and Chinese prompts. Our results indicate that ChatGPT performs best in
true or false questions, achieving the highest precision of 0.688 while scoring
the lowest precision is 0.241 in multiple-choice questions. Furthermore, we
observed that Chinese prompts outperformed English prompts in our evaluations.
Additionally, we assess the quality of explanations generated by ChatGPT and
their potential contribution to TCM knowledge comprehension. This paper offers
valuable insights into the applicability of LLMs in specialized domains and
paves the way for future research in leveraging these powerful models to
advance TCM.
|
[
-0.03759562596678734,
-0.9681713581085205,
0.873958945274353,
-0.13879455626010895,
-0.3557288348674774,
-0.050758395344018936,
-0.5154208540916443,
-0.2801080048084259,
-0.1763046830892563,
0.5260162949562073,
-0.33858007192611694,
-0.531886637210846,
-0.38444414734840393,
-0.02360440045595169,
0.011148876510560513,
0.7528995275497437,
-0.20943009853363037,
0.4133731424808502,
0.15033109486103058,
-0.06197245046496391,
-0.7230522632598877,
-0.5530642867088318,
-0.9298821687698364,
-0.6038756370544434,
0.46994704008102417,
0.3735976815223694,
0.5541030764579773,
0.41235101222991943,
0.5363448858261108,
0.07666057348251343,
-0.30439576506614685,
0.29941511154174805,
-0.5092194080352783,
0.020470861345529556,
0.031168479472398758,
-0.8175095319747925,
-0.268002986907959,
0.06166059151291847,
0.7358434796333313,
0.6541446447372437,
-0.35798877477645874,
-0.13821785151958466,
0.1324947476387024,
0.5398201942443848,
-0.1315222978591919,
0.09306708723306656,
-0.7601423859596252,
0.2614016532897949,
0.038386020809412,
-0.5395315885543823,
-0.4153917729854584,
-0.35352829098701477,
0.5223404765129089,
-0.5355557203292847,
0.10719950497150421,
0.05750811845064163,
1.0370339155197144,
0.14635245501995087,
-0.8019111156463623,
-0.1492820680141449,
-0.6945114731788635,
0.4714556038379669,
-0.8516398668289185,
0.07796341180801392,
0.19621151685714722,
0.5759460926055908,
-0.26337572932243347,
-0.8257248997688293,
-0.48748597502708435,
-0.4675298035144806,
-0.1490972340106964,
0.420993447303772,
0.013223974034190178,
0.16912654042243958,
0.2850552201271057,
0.5625345706939697,
-1.04447340965271,
-0.0018759544473141432,
-0.34301212430000305,
-0.12267047166824341,
0.14126165211200714,
0.35216131806373596,
0.5008106827735901,
-0.06843655556440353,
-0.5615736246109009,
0.24823670089244843,
-0.9183502197265625,
0.12792371213436127,
-0.41416823863983154,
0.054297469556331635,
-0.08208388835191727,
0.43972787261009216,
0.07071574032306671,
0.9575983285903931,
-0.20356914401054382,
-0.42371866106987,
-0.4316197335720062,
-0.3326645493507385,
-0.388482928276062,
-0.10341619700193405,
0.8382090926170349,
0.3601706326007843,
0.34383267164230347,
-0.12508170306682587,
0.1529517024755478,
-0.35353025794029236,
-0.050572481006383896,
-0.6620847582817078,
-0.30107852816581726,
0.285458505153656,
-0.38339853286743164,
0.056432563811540604,
-0.08571895211935043,
-0.251157283782959,
-0.4898824393749237,
-0.16300024092197418,
0.3095977306365967,
-0.8007687926292419,
-0.4027267396450043,
0.3769618570804596,
-0.20570245385169983,
0.7711780071258545,
0.3438176214694977,
-0.5994967818260193,
0.051727622747421265,
0.7070162892341614,
0.9045218825340271,
-0.3101021647453308,
-0.24238786101341248,
-0.1512601226568222,
0.08344912528991699,
-0.549109697341919,
0.8419948220252991,
-0.3445235788822174,
-0.3418377637863159,
-0.07446923851966858,
-0.04575830325484276,
-0.5192632675170898,
-0.6857104301452637,
0.4647294282913208,
-0.6135268211364746,
0.3191259503364563,
-0.5214691162109375,
-0.6718801259994507,
-0.515968382358551,
0.7305676341056824,
-0.31479012966156006,
0.5106779932975769,
-0.03138961270451546,
-0.7427541613578796,
0.26998838782310486,
-0.29375267028808594,
-0.2578122019767761,
0.24341240525245667,
-0.16519567370414734,
0.022697623819112778,
-0.22523240745067596,
0.13354656100273132,
0.45367431640625,
-0.42323192954063416,
0.45965805649757385,
-0.028948212042450905,
-0.3631349205970764,
0.4784673750400543,
-0.757222592830658,
0.7038873434066772,
0.2549939751625061,
-0.09306090325117111,
-0.13641461730003357,
-0.2779306173324585,
0.06971865147352219,
0.33316028118133545,
-0.2287863790988922,
-0.10058432072401047,
-0.08656708151102066,
-0.44542601704597473,
0.29064279794692993,
0.07474295794963837,
-0.2167341113090515,
0.2577030062675476,
-0.2890537977218628,
0.6700667142868042,
0.31419312953948975,
0.3591543138027191,
-0.05016868934035301,
-0.6934404373168945,
0.4822348952293396,
0.0676289051771164,
0.06492980569601059,
-0.4803672730922699,
-0.6456665396690369,
-0.6552695631980896,
-0.04609401896595955,
0.23881645500659943,
0.5590484738349915,
-0.8950188159942627,
-0.09768401086330414,
-0.19248197972774506,
-0.6695799827575684,
-0.2635507881641388,
-0.18973886966705322,
0.0644901841878891,
0.8643080592155457,
0.1613166481256485,
-0.09897362440824509,
0.040318813174963,
-0.5994943976402283,
-0.2092941552400589,
-0.35929110646247864,
-0.1865704506635666,
0.5760467648506165,
0.37041911482810974,
0.11253461986780167,
0.6132839918136597,
-0.5918490886688232,
-0.20966938138008118,
-0.380830854177475,
-0.11832104623317719,
0.1954844444990158,
0.11377732455730438,
0.35586926341056824,
-0.7095121741294861,
-0.6332867741584778,
0.22976790368556976,
-0.6620741486549377,
0.026244034990668297,
-0.37308210134506226,
-0.18678490817546844,
0.07628915458917618,
-0.10994844883680344,
-0.5788072943687439,
0.09313076734542847,
0.525621771812439,
-0.38749516010284424,
0.7534579634666443,
-0.2826314866542816,
0.38455966114997864,
-1.0543230772018433,
0.1804499477148056,
-0.03452422469854355,
-0.13505060970783234,
-0.8938068151473999,
0.22161456942558289,
0.2282021939754486,
0.02584359422326088,
-0.574994683265686,
0.4864169955253601,
-0.30425530672073364,
0.4073885679244995,
-0.2723727822303772,
0.4819791913032532,
0.0251317098736763,
0.44103333353996277,
0.5299797058105469,
0.6111573576927185,
0.6492495536804199,
-0.6264249682426453,
0.40612462162971497,
-0.025881335139274597,
-0.08744210749864578,
0.5092096924781799,
-0.9206779599189758,
0.2358064502477646,
0.07036256045103073,
0.2699596881866455,
-1.116302490234375,
-0.21333853900432587,
0.2223202884197235,
-0.5368714332580566,
0.35052451491355896,
-0.2546400725841522,
-0.3848247528076172,
-0.25188148021698,
0.03418150544166565,
0.15015627443790436,
0.6405398845672607,
-0.41691523790359497,
0.2674744725227356,
0.08551697432994843,
0.1209995225071907,
-0.43058714270591736,
-0.44750627875328064,
0.09160216152667999,
-0.33507025241851807,
-0.8884875774383545,
0.024409931153059006,
-0.03331753611564636,
-0.20241016149520874,
-0.2771906852722168,
-0.20076815783977509,
-0.2786599397659302,
0.06030957028269768,
-0.15773405134677887,
0.4782506823539734,
-0.6400684714317322,
0.31144681572914124,
-0.299564003944397,
0.039727047085762024,
0.05038614571094513,
-0.39263835549354553,
0.7396959662437439,
-0.14171966910362244,
-0.5706799626350403,
-0.2761751711368561,
-0.024457121267914772,
0.3687593340873718,
-0.1538633406162262,
0.6639581322669983,
0.3875691890716553,
-0.34722116589546204,
-0.17243118584156036,
-0.5823404788970947,
-0.22803948819637299,
-0.3587292730808258,
0.18717588484287262,
-0.27780723571777344,
-0.9425413012504578,
0.5894293189048767,
0.2156486213207245,
0.08563252538442612,
0.3542497754096985,
0.7494931817054749,
0.03311272710561752,
0.675570547580719,
-0.00534984702244401,
0.042671505361795425,
-0.008334536105394363,
-0.20133225619792938,
0.04827217385172844,
-0.6100453734397888,
-0.16429480910301208,
-0.3036980926990509,
-0.0012985656503587961,
-0.4660428762435913,
-0.6428136825561523,
0.5817651152610779,
-0.16395053267478943,
-0.2628476917743683,
-0.09066975861787796,
-0.3357566297054291,
0.4322967231273651,
0.5310460329055786,
0.25648853182792664,
0.6087115406990051,
-0.3179750442504883,
0.03463875502347946,
0.26344242691993713,
-0.9394921660423279,
-0.7068178653717041,
0.8505327105522156,
0.4184257984161377,
0.5516847372055054,
-0.12051250040531158,
0.25315701961517334,
-0.3252672255039215,
-0.07391617447137833,
-1.041581153869629,
0.34214821457862854,
-0.0954274982213974,
-0.7557178139686584,
-0.31343865394592285,
-0.4695521891117096,
-1.0203125476837158,
0.4347444772720337,
0.097187340259552,
-0.3412041664123535,
-0.46068042516708374,
0.11488354206085205,
-0.830100417137146,
0.6343314051628113,
-0.722429633140564,
0.815048098564148,
-0.32763785123825073,
0.0265828687697649,
0.08510465919971466,
-0.6497126221656799,
0.8604912757873535,
0.01615447923541069,
-0.06588517874479294,
-0.11106596142053604,
0.03185927867889404,
0.49557408690452576,
-0.06504874676465988,
0.6614357829093933,
0.06545425951480865,
-0.13900764286518097,
0.4031088054180145,
0.25174570083618164,
0.14890798926353455,
0.23490263521671295,
0.09924116730690002,
0.15756896138191223,
0.45411932468414307,
-0.518231213092804,
-0.6174048185348511,
0.5445913672447205,
-0.6425941586494446,
-0.8481642007827759,
-0.5708738565444946,
-0.47306448221206665,
-0.2999514043331146,
0.2062305063009262,
0.21190761029720306,
0.3067069351673126,
-0.3239172101020813,
0.0924399122595787,
1.084236741065979,
-0.6404137015342712,
0.12991425395011902,
0.9704620242118835,
-0.019285831600427628,
0.07475282996892929,
0.5001878142356873,
0.27523571252822876,
0.6271076798439026,
0.48761335015296936,
0.52840656042099,
-0.047448623925447464,
-0.7448262572288513,
-0.40544232726097107,
0.3481712341308594,
-0.5059471130371094,
0.025455037131905556,
-0.5066248774528503,
-0.6850574612617493,
-0.23355725407600403,
0.1496163010597229,
-0.04315803572535515,
-0.0920911356806755,
-0.08148577064275742,
-0.02429037168622017,
0.2066076546907425,
0.6436818838119507,
0.23461993038654327,
0.15203675627708435,
-0.8894038200378418,
0.5009922981262207,
0.44858604669570923,
0.4435359537601471,
0.15228228271007538,
-0.645875096321106,
-0.042229726910591125,
0.3864654302597046,
-0.35295867919921875,
-0.9526172280311584,
0.4175601005554199,
0.022632993757724762,
0.7126628756523132,
0.5500994324684143,
0.062019478529691696,
0.5950000286102295,
-0.5180038809776306,
1.265823483467102,
-0.052657924592494965,
-0.4675613343715668,
0.3494219481945038,
-0.43526914715766907,
0.5749607086181641,
0.08494649827480316,
0.3982962965965271,
-1.3203129768371582,
-0.4355636537075043,
-0.40007972717285156,
-0.46480441093444824,
0.7423814535140991,
0.11659745872020721,
0.10354577749967575,
-0.04327761009335518,
0.5402593612670898,
0.2764757573604584,
-0.2458915412425995,
-0.5638415217399597,
-0.38983598351478577,
0.04862610623240471,
0.1816391944885254,
0.09093832224607468,
-0.343808650970459,
-0.0816144272685051,
-0.016093425452709198,
0.6012067794799805,
-0.005469102878123522,
0.15733115375041962,
0.35743072628974915,
0.027278201654553413,
-0.013804464600980282,
0.46014946699142456,
0.5874106884002686,
0.9178600907325745,
-0.08576563000679016,
0.33551090955734253,
0.471956729888916,
-0.5811288356781006,
-0.04654063656926155,
-0.18600156903266907,
-0.17007064819335938,
-0.06544457376003265,
0.5098996758460999,
0.735821545124054,
-0.2582947909832001,
-0.665884256362915,
0.34379062056541443,
-0.2069651037454605,
-0.20450028777122498,
-0.2925429046154022,
0.1406465470790863,
0.20695336163043976,
0.07880484312772751,
0.37529706954956055,
-0.4041365683078766,
0.03256304934620857,
-0.5121932029724121,
0.0834771916270256,
0.3941071927547455,
-0.5342106223106384,
-0.20108453929424286,
0.5598522424697876,
-0.20477528870105743,
-0.0965757817029953,
0.6602731943130493,
0.05750773102045059,
-0.6271155476570129,
0.7051892876625061,
0.4464336335659027,
0.5209522247314453,
-0.12735019624233246,
0.3935472369194031,
0.43419337272644043,
0.34144604206085205,
-0.1657133549451828,
0.2508755624294281,
0.2610310912132263,
-0.77864009141922,
-0.4637948274612427,
-0.12890824675559998,
-0.5413307547569275,
0.3142639398574829,
-0.401199609041214,
0.2854079306125641,
-0.1919204145669937,
0.027729300782084465,
-0.11167795211076736,
0.08992291986942291,
-0.5111172795295715,
0.18740491569042206,
0.32572779059410095,
1.1514476537704468,
-0.33372437953948975,
0.866142749786377,
0.5400588512420654,
-0.37768474221229553,
-1.27938973903656,
0.19405946135520935,
0.07471340894699097,
-1.1803069114685059,
0.27053889632225037,
-0.1304728090763092,
0.14620563387870789,
-0.23127715289592743,
-0.4835244119167328,
-0.5936672687530518,
1.2883576154708862,
0.2707008719444275,
-0.38978686928749084,
-0.15804874897003174,
0.3908146321773529,
0.762617290019989,
0.028521310538053513,
0.6439933776855469,
0.9083900451660156,
0.4036921560764313,
0.48006218671798706,
-1.2052162885665894,
0.07366544008255005,
0.0913519486784935,
-0.19578036665916443,
-0.11309169977903366,
-0.8375449180603027,
0.6178095936775208,
-0.22351136803627014,
-0.39092957973480225,
0.03031003102660179,
0.15563637018203735,
0.5807687640190125,
0.39464688301086426,
0.1507081687450409,
0.15361201763153076,
0.7714970111846924,
-0.3085697591304779,
1.0058156251907349,
-0.4514545202255249,
0.1527933031320572,
0.7844728231430054,
-0.1628911793231964,
0.5733141303062439,
0.27185994386672974,
-0.24037010967731476,
0.2446192055940628,
1.0554791688919067,
0.20023508369922638,
0.12051104009151459,
0.2273254245519638,
-0.20129044353961945,
-0.38471895456314087,
-0.07970058917999268,
-0.5147058367729187,
0.36848488450050354,
0.1878095418214798,
-0.2464979887008667,
-0.10216695070266724,
-0.1989677995443344,
0.2966339588165283,
-0.10746557265520096,
-0.34337928891181946,
1.1270078420639038,
0.43983206152915955,
-0.9463900923728943,
0.8353405594825745,
-0.09800843149423599,
0.386991024017334,
-0.8170368671417236,
-0.1436000019311905,
-0.4412037134170532,
-0.23488377034664154,
-0.038354430347681046,
-1.1358473300933838,
0.0707140862941742,
-0.27356988191604614,
0.17769908905029297,
0.05503347888588905,
0.7370460629463196,
-0.6174342632293701,
-0.14377498626708984,
-0.18927429616451263,
0.6954847574234009,
0.3135127127170563,
-0.22522962093353271,
-0.49713990092277527,
-0.5575603246688843,
0.028902146965265274,
-0.23731201887130737,
0.1553421914577484,
0.9441129565238953,
-0.026365380734205246,
0.8863768577575684,
0.369571328163147,
0.44159871339797974,
-0.010885411873459816,
-0.06194284185767174,
0.6808156967163086,
-0.7419725060462952,
-0.2848223149776459,
-1.152316689491272,
0.29889100790023804,
0.16174755990505219,
-0.09322730451822281,
0.7093549370765686,
0.3541874885559082,
0.5813108086585999,
-0.048532430082559586,
0.8400574922561646,
0.2105395793914795,
0.5573238134384155,
-0.6550767421722412,
0.8897802233695984,
-0.3130720555782318,
0.2827554941177368,
0.06421120464801788,
-0.39854535460472107,
-0.36692604422569275,
0.22438345849514008,
-0.48302754759788513,
-0.0664352998137474,
0.8951048254966736,
0.6352314949035645,
0.1104791909456253,
0.20071318745613098,
0.6154392957687378,
0.2958217263221741,
0.35474324226379395,
1.1113179922103882,
1.1653670072555542,
-0.1164642944931984,
0.7135017514228821,
-0.2470664083957672,
-0.1380254477262497,
0.041506197303533554,
-0.6828336715698242,
-0.9922733306884766,
-0.4412394165992737,
-0.107396200299263,
-0.2587597370147705,
0.002103799721226096,
1.0164170265197754,
0.5671647191047668,
-0.7527316808700562,
-0.20945928990840912,
0.318184494972229,
0.4272958040237427,
-0.2656775414943695,
-0.20454025268554688,
0.629298746585846,
-0.40671440958976746,
-0.5257623791694641,
-0.009150922298431396,
0.2513052821159363,
0.08209807425737381,
-0.06476790457963943,
-0.11216416209936142,
0.1068715751171112,
0.05879659578204155,
0.6127045750617981,
0.11265852302312851,
-0.8485371470451355,
-0.24968963861465454,
0.5908157825469971,
-0.19992029666900635,
0.19584298133850098,
0.9755373597145081,
-0.6005578637123108,
0.4473375380039215,
0.5345422029495239,
0.3633698523044586,
0.27176713943481445,
-0.02929200790822506,
0.7958512306213379,
-0.2509075403213501,
-0.37337085604667664,
0.35488221049308777,
0.48635217547416687,
0.1668347418308258,
-0.3047025501728058,
0.3985496759414673,
0.21255744993686676,
-0.6214070320129395,
-0.565418004989624,
0.05291818082332611,
-1.0592982769012451,
-0.5383962988853455,
1.6299192905426025,
-0.31689080595970154,
0.001686188974417746,
-0.33916106820106506,
-0.861107587814331,
0.37920081615448,
-0.1141781359910965,
0.8974034786224365,
0.9662697315216064,
-0.11194845288991928,
-0.4618430435657501,
-0.8041608333587646,
0.48910248279571533,
0.235399067401886,
-0.5698394775390625,
0.06727413088083267,
0.338277667760849,
0.4743471145629883,
-0.34334734082221985,
0.7358145117759705,
-0.21649698913097382,
0.426839143037796,
-0.31002822518348694,
-0.3165183961391449,
-0.028773991391062737,
0.1947472095489502,
-0.2560522258281708,
0.16502010822296143,
0.42426034808158875,
-0.06787674874067307
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09163v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09163v1
|
Caveat Lector: Large Language Models in Legal Practice
| 2024-03-14T08:19:41 | 2024-03-14T08:19:41 |
Eliza Mik
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY
|
The current fascination with large language models, or LLMs, derives from the
fact that many users lack the expertise to evaluate the quality of the
generated text. LLMs may therefore appear more capable than they actually are.
The dangerous combination of fluency and superficial plausibility leads to the
temptation to trust the generated text and creates the risk of overreliance.
Who would not trust perfect legalese? Relying recent findings in both technical
and legal scholarship, this Article counterbalances the overly optimistic
predictions as to the role of LLMs in legal practice. Integrating LLMs into
legal workstreams without a better comprehension of their limitations, will
create inefficiencies if not outright risks. Notwithstanding their
unprecedented ability to generate text, LLMs do not understand text. Without
the ability to understand meaning, LLMs will remain unable to use language, to
acquire knowledge and to perform complex reasoning tasks. Trained to model
language on the basis of stochastic word predictions, LLMs cannot distinguish
fact from fiction. Their knowledge of the law is limited to word strings
memorized in their parameters. It is also incomplete and largely incorrect.
LLMs operate at the level of word distributions, not at the level of verified
facts. The resulting propensity to hallucinate, to produce statements that are
incorrect but appear helpful and relevant, is alarming in high-risk areas like
legal services. At present, lawyers should beware of relying on text generated
by LLMs.
|
[
-0.18134815990924835,
-0.5843632221221924,
1.113472580909729,
-0.028232121840119362,
-0.48095589876174927,
-0.07680553197860718,
-0.04369836300611496,
-0.43176740407943726,
0.1819024533033371,
0.8142046928405762,
-0.08072244375944138,
-0.1728103905916214,
-0.968527615070343,
-0.11352723836898804,
-0.4931029677391052,
0.8696664571762085,
0.0027233180589973927,
0.2541087865829468,
-0.33497416973114014,
-0.205099418759346,
-0.4261414110660553,
-0.740006685256958,
-0.4865822494029999,
-0.5497777462005615,
0.41248026490211487,
-0.008776919916272163,
0.8249015808105469,
0.23204346001148224,
0.45952001214027405,
0.20811541378498077,
-0.18176469206809998,
-0.17681053280830383,
-0.7532981634140015,
0.24687997996807098,
-0.19248037040233612,
-0.5606823563575745,
-0.3173607587814331,
0.07227757573127747,
0.4951430857181549,
0.682658851146698,
-0.3444055914878845,
-0.2566175162792206,
-0.26344260573387146,
0.6398119330406189,
-0.5523263812065125,
-0.07539292424917221,
-0.7457253932952881,
0.1428755223751068,
-0.06043018028140068,
-0.34343841671943665,
-0.3004581928253174,
-0.2902165651321411,
0.11022627353668213,
-0.4269942045211792,
-0.07485394179821014,
0.1295541226863861,
0.7039180397987366,
0.5334950685501099,
-0.48705095052719116,
-0.6012924909591675,
-0.658288836479187,
0.43251216411590576,
-0.9273330569267273,
0.2767409384250641,
0.335801899433136,
0.3255348801612854,
-0.31790822744369507,
-0.5478264093399048,
-0.7100677490234375,
-0.7719757556915283,
0.011845252476632595,
0.1658877581357956,
-0.05300956219434738,
0.10217203944921494,
0.5048977136611938,
0.1500038504600525,
-0.2916489541530609,
0.3777068853378296,
-0.25841474533081055,
-0.11556174606084824,
0.6643898487091064,
0.14977170526981354,
0.193081796169281,
0.021735424175858498,
0.06679712235927582,
0.16525115072727203,
-0.9815477728843689,
-0.09003598242998123,
0.4946715533733368,
0.1777181327342987,
0.00527823343873024,
0.8693253397941589,
0.32871490716934204,
0.36519744992256165,
-0.11864222586154938,
-0.46512866020202637,
0.010048235766589642,
0.16765309870243073,
-0.4251272976398468,
0.36165687441825867,
0.8402369022369385,
0.2000848799943924,
0.6833685040473938,
0.045518938452005386,
-0.29293590784072876,
-0.22041518986225128,
0.386035293340683,
-0.6579496264457703,
0.21446283161640167,
0.33529844880104065,
-0.2740895450115204,
-0.19710057973861694,
0.25498852133750916,
-0.5396583080291748,
-0.8416166305541992,
-0.33907055854797363,
0.11371555179357529,
-0.3687591254711151,
-0.17606230080127716,
0.2461445927619934,
-0.03384872525930405,
0.03577548637986183,
0.5000687837600708,
-0.4772191643714905,
0.3014706075191498,
0.5635990500450134,
0.5980113744735718,
0.21730771660804749,
-0.05779168754816055,
-0.6656824946403503,
0.4264271855354309,
-0.6256090402603149,
0.4566900432109833,
-0.5746611952781677,
-0.5768191814422607,
0.35509219765663147,
0.039057254791259766,
0.07870088517665863,
-0.5497621893882751,
0.5378380417823792,
-0.3754028379917145,
-0.2048218548297882,
-0.18266727030277252,
-0.8323038220405579,
-0.03547719493508339,
-0.04239939525723457,
-0.48292943835258484,
0.4765283465385437,
0.00970458984375,
-0.7185092568397522,
0.4738016128540039,
-0.4178543984889984,
-0.5754135847091675,
0.2870716154575348,
-0.5711303353309631,
-0.20086230337619781,
0.41281330585479736,
-0.16014550626277924,
0.5596844553947449,
-0.20102643966674805,
0.41822004318237305,
-0.4517577290534973,
-0.3942161500453949,
0.594063401222229,
-0.35611966252326965,
0.7552566528320312,
0.4232383370399475,
-0.3465433716773987,
-0.22183838486671448,
-0.2838314473628998,
-0.462543785572052,
0.10892175883054733,
-0.3146494925022125,
-0.3391997218132019,
0.15918470919132233,
-0.23211778700351715,
0.13612182438373566,
0.14749935269355774,
-0.31697168946266174,
-0.08735454082489014,
-0.5119585394859314,
0.4188028573989868,
0.7853305339813232,
-0.03337177634239197,
0.27362197637557983,
-0.3882068693637848,
0.6345216631889343,
-0.15122899413108826,
-0.19236333668231964,
0.06024455651640892,
-0.3689107894897461,
-0.5930159687995911,
-0.21124367415905,
0.2589240074157715,
0.4967401325702667,
-0.3769727051258087,
0.17532649636268616,
-0.49816933274269104,
-0.4144297242164612,
-0.4937717318534851,
0.4475584626197815,
0.06966376304626465,
0.013439069502055645,
0.0073253558948636055,
0.02497350610792637,
-0.4870094656944275,
-0.7844269871711731,
-0.44784674048423767,
-0.15879669785499573,
0.11534931510686874,
0.4530119299888611,
0.668633759021759,
-0.2754363417625427,
0.5865471363067627,
-0.04156104847788811,
-0.4218386113643646,
-0.494729608297348,
0.005713371094316244,
0.32228246331214905,
0.17848914861679077,
0.5615429282188416,
-0.7423092722892761,
-0.48813238739967346,
0.09094344079494476,
-0.8821476697921753,
-0.1267196238040924,
-0.33309251070022583,
0.4171624779701233,
0.3645424246788025,
0.8289462327957153,
-0.8493433594703674,
0.22137030959129333,
0.28587138652801514,
-0.43539056181907654,
0.6193810105323792,
-0.48708829283714294,
-0.235937237739563,
-0.8735041618347168,
-0.14944858849048615,
0.1710481196641922,
-0.41897231340408325,
-0.45244187116622925,
0.3648032248020172,
-0.16926002502441406,
0.27875232696533203,
-0.5937142968177795,
0.5756731033325195,
-0.4897415339946747,
-0.12300662696361542,
-0.5249476432800293,
0.40942782163619995,
-0.25827109813690186,
-0.17540818452835083,
-0.3161579668521881,
0.7691469788551331,
0.5632668733596802,
-0.6616398096084595,
0.33857885003089905,
-0.13594672083854675,
-0.32022565603256226,
0.7492521405220032,
-0.6060231924057007,
-0.23682184517383575,
-0.20492896437644958,
0.04067549109458923,
-0.42493605613708496,
-0.4571654498577118,
0.012852794490754604,
-0.24013665318489075,
0.7272926568984985,
-0.16199548542499542,
-0.8590092658996582,
-0.4725058972835541,
-0.11086397618055344,
0.0346284918487072,
0.7730156183242798,
-0.034998707473278046,
0.7675017714500427,
0.6771895289421082,
-0.10645759850740433,
-0.6404234766960144,
-1.0562784671783447,
0.34020841121673584,
-0.1886492669582367,
-0.3744928240776062,
-0.007185482420027256,
0.13273245096206665,
-0.8930397629737854,
0.055492985993623734,
-0.04031970351934433,
0.09896966069936752,
0.009807555936276913,
0.5628547072410583,
-0.037630464881658554,
-0.04759532958269119,
0.31566646695137024,
-0.04548131674528122,
0.23709754645824432,
0.318301260471344,
-0.11765436828136444,
0.43129903078079224,
0.011274040676653385,
-0.5268741846084595,
-0.2675357162952423,
0.15992134809494019,
0.822114109992981,
0.225956529378891,
0.7700409293174744,
0.19324040412902832,
-0.3303375542163849,
-0.05995815619826317,
-0.856209933757782,
0.025011641904711723,
-0.43424755334854126,
0.35521063208580017,
-0.2154424637556076,
-1.0175892114639282,
0.2540026903152466,
0.04106017202138901,
-0.03758106753230095,
0.5960291028022766,
0.6929954886436462,
-0.395423024892807,
0.6208170652389526,
0.7351731061935425,
-0.07967790216207504,
0.2214350700378418,
0.046428751200437546,
0.45099976658821106,
-0.5690891146659851,
-0.13778579235076904,
-0.40682119131088257,
0.27780991792678833,
-0.760301947593689,
-0.3444787561893463,
0.07746598869562149,
-0.0021907109767198563,
-0.18096299469470978,
0.14666083455085754,
-0.06128153204917908,
0.4172299802303314,
0.3454091250896454,
-0.19389644265174866,
0.19056980311870575,
0.030813826248049736,
-0.3886851668357849,
-0.11237332969903946,
-0.6453362703323364,
-0.8533521294593811,
1.2180160284042358,
0.5656629204750061,
0.9739216566085815,
0.1885954588651657,
0.6174856424331665,
0.44037550687789917,
0.21468298137187958,
-0.915040135383606,
0.6373172998428345,
-0.2395334392786026,
-0.5163854360580444,
-0.23826941847801208,
-0.4111364781856537,
-0.7181169390678406,
0.12445252388715744,
-0.3012447655200958,
-0.8278085589408875,
0.07272480428218842,
0.00818768423050642,
-0.35317838191986084,
0.4198951721191406,
-0.3846804201602936,
0.38195502758026123,
-0.1639760583639145,
-0.5316896438598633,
-0.2902308702468872,
-0.31150513887405396,
0.5496532917022705,
-0.3225933611392975,
0.6688672304153442,
-0.20229469239711761,
-0.03430777043104172,
0.7412197589874268,
-0.47962987422943115,
0.8789887428283691,
0.025312112644314766,
-0.43772056698799133,
0.36829766631126404,
0.2998432517051697,
0.6982954144477844,
0.12533584237098694,
0.06598220020532608,
-0.22572225332260132,
0.22209639847278595,
-0.30378082394599915,
-0.2879727780818939,
0.726286768913269,
-0.6190153956413269,
-0.9208651185035706,
-0.652247965335846,
-0.6824547648429871,
-0.10970742255449295,
0.08624692261219025,
0.19603104889392853,
0.06877123564481735,
-0.23587580025196075,
0.16608141362667084,
0.7703366279602051,
-0.12955492734909058,
0.27042800188064575,
0.4161244332790375,
-0.09797203540802002,
-0.39576974511146545,
0.779360830783844,
0.31893935799598694,
0.14201493561267853,
0.013862800784409046,
0.1018281802535057,
-0.5119644403457642,
-0.7822943329811096,
0.12315437942743301,
0.6764300465583801,
-1.0311671495437622,
0.2187146544456482,
-0.6466766595840454,
-0.3223147392272949,
-0.4273550808429718,
-0.24486306309700012,
-0.10149981826543808,
-0.15972986817359924,
-0.42820584774017334,
-0.1580720841884613,
0.21591845154762268,
0.9511061906814575,
0.02241656742990017,
0.2509668469429016,
-0.6722314953804016,
0.09942107647657394,
0.3176940381526947,
0.05733519047498703,
-0.3527263104915619,
-0.8688077330589294,
-0.039983537048101425,
-0.2189001590013504,
-0.0583120658993721,
-0.7626872062683105,
0.2719264626502991,
-0.10853791981935501,
0.9652424454689026,
0.601908266544342,
-0.095364511013031,
0.44003212451934814,
-0.6806468367576599,
0.7394523620605469,
0.30612143874168396,
-0.8611231446266174,
0.3542448878288269,
-0.40024757385253906,
-0.05677825212478638,
0.4668327569961548,
0.48653966188430786,
-0.29883119463920593,
-0.8519553542137146,
-0.7096869945526123,
-0.6025238633155823,
0.33465179800987244,
0.04969413951039314,
0.6311473250389099,
0.19361612200737,
0.5573839545249939,
0.024751346558332443,
0.41856032609939575,
-0.9784112572669983,
0.1215977594256401,
-0.03749111667275429,
-0.1381801813840866,
-0.20977577567100525,
-0.6982213854789734,
-0.3114381730556488,
-0.23196274042129517,
0.5783633589744568,
-0.15691670775413513,
0.11751864850521088,
0.1886516958475113,
-0.27885034680366516,
-0.28254464268684387,
0.4134258031845093,
1.0181056261062622,
1.040945291519165,
-0.1568525731563568,
0.3393767774105072,
0.21365289390087128,
-0.5296545624732971,
0.11501498520374298,
-0.12418486177921295,
-0.09320136159658432,
0.123029924929142,
0.514482319355011,
0.5689029097557068,
-0.019530219957232475,
-0.9739936590194702,
0.6626835465431213,
0.23639054596424103,
-0.661015510559082,
-0.7182701230049133,
0.13544312119483948,
0.4223651587963104,
0.3824193477630615,
0.23316866159439087,
0.07629620283842087,
-0.11487367004156113,
-0.8538263440132141,
0.0706912949681282,
0.664848268032074,
-0.4623222351074219,
0.019884273409843445,
0.6509434580802917,
-0.029667353257536888,
-0.2669290602207184,
0.04326825216412544,
-0.1071866825222969,
-0.35673123598098755,
0.46518203616142273,
0.36489278078079224,
0.6640864014625549,
0.13879269361495972,
0.06980441510677338,
0.16724012792110443,
0.6694363951683044,
-0.4700741469860077,
0.21284589171409607,
0.5857399106025696,
-0.5275593400001526,
-0.5534932613372803,
-0.5303181409835815,
-0.33488062024116516,
0.3829672038555145,
-0.17805957794189453,
0.10864248126745224,
-0.6268011927604675,
-0.2074977159500122,
-0.4086032807826996,
-0.08061094582080841,
-0.4861777126789093,
-0.04390519857406616,
0.1391361653804779,
1.0593444108963013,
-0.5498324036598206,
0.8174183964729309,
0.4227745234966278,
-0.43226584792137146,
-0.4282141625881195,
0.23640593886375427,
-0.023041371256113052,
-0.6901165843009949,
0.6700160503387451,
0.09802898019552231,
-0.0784263089299202,
-0.31095075607299805,
-0.6899281144142151,
-0.3947877883911133,
0.9399895071983337,
0.7035796046257019,
-0.8787348866462708,
-0.09281366318464279,
0.3436850309371948,
0.671784520149231,
-0.6059257388114929,
-0.03949796035885811,
0.4683636724948883,
0.5075417160987854,
0.37809622287750244,
-0.761220395565033,
0.3717081844806671,
0.17955073714256287,
0.08932149410247803,
-0.03946034237742424,
-0.18870243430137634,
0.830915093421936,
-0.5005998015403748,
-0.16956213116645813,
-0.0570906400680542,
0.3063735067844391,
0.22860340774059296,
0.09876720607280731,
0.22414982318878174,
0.5868483185768127,
0.8392269611358643,
0.005087283905595541,
1.3271315097808838,
-0.2322099655866623,
0.1717708706855774,
1.1438512802124023,
-0.5700935125350952,
0.8606168627738953,
0.7908315062522888,
-0.07761725038290024,
0.27715906500816345,
0.42782673239707947,
-0.2993493974208832,
0.3940695524215698,
0.3775119483470917,
-0.19688373804092407,
-0.5277737975120544,
-0.17927764356136322,
-0.18054883182048798,
0.16869792342185974,
0.5550259351730347,
-0.730317234992981,
-0.09013407677412033,
-0.26952454447746277,
0.06458993256092072,
0.3220348656177521,
-0.2862066626548767,
0.7418792247772217,
0.6457823514938354,
-0.49560001492500305,
0.3634285032749176,
-0.15284818410873413,
0.4836151897907257,
-0.4541001319885254,
0.034985706210136414,
0.012642559595406055,
-0.07096574455499649,
-0.17719803750514984,
-0.8764057159423828,
0.20475895702838898,
0.0726257935166359,
0.35824263095855713,
-0.10722803324460983,
0.6916141510009766,
0.07014232128858566,
-0.5545936822891235,
0.3838386535644531,
0.8227319121360779,
0.36243584752082825,
-0.009182197041809559,
-0.6679883599281311,
-0.13188275694847107,
-0.32439449429512024,
-0.16462916135787964,
0.3436860740184784,
0.6939194202423096,
0.2777099609375,
0.8250781297683716,
0.5070222020149231,
0.5787421464920044,
0.0016777379205450416,
0.26384246349334717,
0.7519770860671997,
-0.5979211926460266,
-0.24989816546440125,
-1.0996026992797852,
0.3295803666114807,
-0.1319844275712967,
-0.0277498047798872,
0.5059250593185425,
0.30448436737060547,
0.5470430254936218,
0.14641173183918,
0.8664644956588745,
0.1479474902153015,
0.1351507157087326,
-0.8916633129119873,
0.8638848662376404,
-0.6883589625358582,
0.48872995376586914,
-0.0689297690987587,
-0.8885316252708435,
-0.2953472435474396,
0.5700511336326599,
-0.47100338339805603,
0.20368041098117828,
0.8716174364089966,
0.5079530477523804,
-0.04053167253732681,
-0.3583388924598694,
0.9195110201835632,
0.48238635063171387,
0.26908791065216064,
0.28796690702438354,
0.7736450433731079,
-0.008097955025732517,
0.6458492279052734,
0.28257685899734497,
0.1313726156949997,
-0.6931611895561218,
-0.8820235133171082,
-1.2580047845840454,
-0.08536684513092041,
-0.08290943503379822,
-0.42390480637550354,
-0.04173382744193077,
0.7641065716743469,
0.4095480442047119,
-0.6604639887809753,
-0.381038099527359,
-0.44751912355422974,
0.05676725506782532,
0.25604721903800964,
-0.19794100522994995,
-0.012275557033717632,
-0.5163300633430481,
-0.5341956615447998,
0.22456467151641846,
0.2874239981174469,
0.47355061769485474,
-0.44282063841819763,
-0.3962724506855011,
-0.10309159010648727,
0.3588116765022278,
0.532825767993927,
0.16496914625167847,
-1.037010908126831,
-0.12152326107025146,
-0.38194701075553894,
-0.41604867577552795,
0.052397776395082474,
0.775574803352356,
-0.31437671184539795,
0.25795355439186096,
0.28528815507888794,
0.525568425655365,
0.3314434289932251,
-0.5539807081222534,
0.7617892622947693,
-0.2060507982969284,
0.07917982339859009,
0.3605550527572632,
0.9178537130355835,
0.28909844160079956,
-0.3519716262817383,
0.5183516144752502,
0.24747240543365479,
-0.34817761182785034,
-0.9697422981262207,
0.31224942207336426,
-0.6702583432197571,
-0.6279168725013733,
1.2970644235610962,
-0.1370052695274353,
-0.3349204659461975,
-0.22289706766605377,
-0.13776952028274536,
0.0016778920544311404,
-0.43330034613609314,
0.6160507202148438,
0.8371674418449402,
0.18534553050994873,
-0.17400772869586945,
-1.351891279220581,
0.5589666366577148,
0.23881523311138153,
-0.6017089486122131,
0.03638428449630737,
0.3401675522327423,
0.4528771936893463,
0.2985803186893463,
0.7334144711494446,
-0.07659520208835602,
0.1787945181131363,
0.1031813696026802,
-0.20973417162895203,
-0.06521189957857132,
-0.14269790053367615,
-0.35925132036209106,
0.2120862603187561,
0.44795629382133484,
0.5629827380180359
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09162v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09162v1
|
Unveiling the Generalization Power of Fine-Tuned Large Language Models
| 2024-03-14T08:18:59 | 2024-03-14T08:18:59 |
Haoran Yang, Yumeng Zhang, Jiaqi Xu, Hongyuan Lu, Pheng Ann Heng, Wai Lam
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
While Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated exceptional multitasking
abilities, fine-tuning these models on downstream, domain-specific datasets is
often necessary to yield superior performance on test sets compared to their
counterparts without fine-tuning. However, the comprehensive effects of
fine-tuning on the LLMs' generalization ability are not fully understood. This
paper delves into the differences between original, unmodified LLMs and their
fine-tuned variants. Our primary investigation centers on whether fine-tuning
affects the generalization ability intrinsic to LLMs. To elaborate on this, we
conduct extensive experiments across five distinct language tasks on various
datasets. Our main findings reveal that models fine-tuned on generation and
classification tasks exhibit dissimilar behaviors in generalizing to different
domains and tasks. Intriguingly, we observe that integrating the in-context
learning strategy during fine-tuning on generation tasks can enhance the
model's generalization ability. Through this systematic investigation, we aim
to contribute valuable insights into the evolving landscape of fine-tuning
practices for LLMs.
|
[
-0.4407653212547302,
-0.9063484072685242,
0.5304881930351257,
-0.1392958164215088,
-0.17960335314273834,
0.04075784981250763,
-0.826508641242981,
-0.4504811465740204,
-0.37035396695137024,
0.5490014553070068,
-0.5727968811988831,
-0.3942645490169525,
-0.7914609909057617,
0.1039712056517601,
-0.23044833540916443,
1.1097038984298706,
0.13218359649181366,
-0.06475070118904114,
-0.0704437792301178,
-0.035894233733415604,
-0.4682122766971588,
-0.5068812370300293,
-0.45127615332603455,
-0.46099087595939636,
0.5039432644844055,
0.4429420828819275,
0.6296653747558594,
0.7879494428634644,
0.4327775537967682,
0.3082756996154785,
-0.2056475430727005,
0.5359861254692078,
-0.8033362627029419,
0.11849231272935867,
-0.3254183530807495,
-0.5008512139320374,
-0.41874438524246216,
0.015119646675884724,
0.8231630921363831,
0.9616977572441101,
0.0077986326068639755,
0.24894633889198303,
0.495339035987854,
0.7051740884780884,
-0.7170122861862183,
0.21691922843456268,
-1.117954969406128,
-0.3227193057537079,
-0.2542962431907654,
-0.3185994029045105,
-0.3229837119579315,
0.09209301322698593,
0.033932071179151535,
-0.5209712386131287,
0.5712729692459106,
0.0798027366399765,
0.7727927565574646,
0.4214248061180115,
-0.5263857841491699,
-0.25562983751296997,
-1.0017896890640259,
1.1137168407440186,
-0.8033128380775452,
0.28581783175468445,
0.1205536350607872,
0.13738028705120087,
-0.32701003551483154,
-0.5164310336112976,
-0.2717108726501465,
-0.09264257550239563,
0.029233550652861595,
-0.47192615270614624,
-0.14152628183364868,
0.3445920944213867,
0.47491133213043213,
0.6635469198226929,
-0.22253075242042542,
0.4671207666397095,
-0.18406923115253448,
0.04527796432375908,
0.5934621691703796,
0.20248684287071228,
0.27231159806251526,
0.14815355837345123,
0.23061314225196838,
0.14006870985031128,
-0.8730267882347107,
0.14163389801979065,
0.25996625423431396,
0.6535078287124634,
0.1037508174777031,
0.5330175161361694,
-0.5889791250228882,
0.9658094644546509,
0.0979212075471878,
-0.054438721388578415,
-0.01596245728433132,
-0.5052803754806519,
-0.46596458554267883,
-0.4519105553627014,
0.5167006254196167,
0.22684788703918457,
0.7884229421615601,
-0.43780648708343506,
-0.285959392786026,
-0.18290504813194275,
0.1436866968870163,
-0.7811232209205627,
-0.12351114302873611,
-0.04660787433385849,
-0.430841863155365,
-0.1126909852027893,
0.06351333111524582,
-0.3553217351436615,
-0.2901892364025116,
-0.7822238206863403,
0.2441987842321396,
-0.25667107105255127,
-0.22650574147701263,
0.4433944523334503,
-0.04297209903597832,
0.1780778467655182,
0.24479377269744873,
-1.323754072189331,
0.2626012861728668,
1.0197111368179321,
0.5867271423339844,
-0.2425285279750824,
-0.4029332399368286,
-0.626365065574646,
0.15997788310050964,
-0.3417440950870514,
0.6190169453620911,
-0.8202748894691467,
-0.14786890149116516,
0.06868276745080948,
0.18553878366947174,
-0.2894759178161621,
-0.9079381227493286,
0.2739594578742981,
-0.5247327089309692,
-0.31190556287765503,
-0.40157338976860046,
-0.6544477343559265,
-0.14693082869052887,
-0.06945164501667023,
-0.3777370750904083,
0.5621720552444458,
-0.05800354480743408,
-0.4036633372306824,
0.6509924530982971,
-0.40433269739151,
-0.49921175837516785,
-0.03458719328045845,
-0.10130099207162857,
-0.25809016823768616,
0.7292711138725281,
0.08633201569318771,
0.8854471445083618,
-0.4684041738510132,
0.2336798459291458,
-0.3971931040287018,
-0.44091400504112244,
0.10823383182287216,
-0.20278210937976837,
0.4122248589992523,
0.09058709442615509,
-0.21585753560066223,
0.14443129301071167,
-0.7241679430007935,
0.17680968344211578,
0.038615789264440536,
-0.5946922302246094,
-0.44090041518211365,
0.1822488009929657,
-0.16072137653827667,
0.05564023181796074,
0.24655477702617645,
-0.4259985685348511,
0.4244675636291504,
-0.40452274680137634,
0.6288980841636658,
0.6195436120033264,
-0.029559381306171417,
0.5938335657119751,
-0.36037981510162354,
0.28541651368141174,
-0.13145777583122253,
-0.04345773532986641,
-0.13058483600616455,
-0.34729206562042236,
-0.7839410901069641,
-0.17631840705871582,
0.38055193424224854,
0.2093469500541687,
-0.2033962905406952,
0.27396559715270996,
-0.30484288930892944,
-0.39404287934303284,
-0.47937649488449097,
0.5736050605773926,
0.5524331331253052,
0.0324527770280838,
0.24027249217033386,
-0.07643655687570572,
-0.33565178513526917,
-1.0064202547073364,
-0.5287721157073975,
0.4713573455810547,
-0.13951346278190613,
0.4275319278240204,
0.4052402079105377,
-0.4272775948047638,
0.7029644846916199,
-0.5242785811424255,
-0.23954802751541138,
-0.3388291299343109,
0.023027410730719566,
0.06060970947146416,
0.4820917248725891,
0.5420509576797485,
-0.5761150121688843,
-0.5264825820922852,
0.32124823331832886,
-0.5073274970054626,
-0.10202816128730774,
-0.04275287687778473,
0.11726763099431992,
0.150098517537117,
0.7340906262397766,
-0.42228272557258606,
0.011836020275950432,
0.5799701809883118,
-0.07653965055942535,
0.4333547055721283,
-0.5081287026405334,
-0.02121378667652607,
-0.8749997019767761,
-0.05827896296977997,
-0.030822791159152985,
-0.010627794079482555,
-0.8131589293479919,
0.32032331824302673,
0.20802292227745056,
0.1544051468372345,
-0.3241969645023346,
0.32553303241729736,
-0.6204853653907776,
-0.15714901685714722,
-0.39737677574157715,
-0.11969363689422607,
-0.217118039727211,
0.4538029134273529,
-0.2474743276834488,
0.7680685520172119,
0.7466186881065369,
-1.0369569063186646,
-0.00848417915403843,
-0.042204249650239944,
-0.5472386479377747,
0.07958047091960907,
-0.6675241589546204,
0.1762220859527588,
-0.1753884106874466,
-0.11581861227750778,
-0.858247697353363,
-0.33378028869628906,
-0.45123377442359924,
-0.10532236844301224,
0.5607520341873169,
-0.21543484926223755,
-0.7505879402160645,
-0.009741220623254776,
-0.005896895192563534,
0.31248730421066284,
0.4565850794315338,
-0.4477881193161011,
0.39466893672943115,
0.26536303758621216,
-0.08300434798002243,
-0.26316460967063904,
-0.47994399070739746,
-0.20107315480709076,
-0.30920931696891785,
-0.45702722668647766,
0.4096776843070984,
-0.15818242728710175,
-0.3480805456638336,
-0.47263863682746887,
-0.08877869695425034,
0.09867153316736221,
0.3479732871055603,
0.27599602937698364,
-0.08334439247846603,
-0.145369753241539,
0.2687957286834717,
0.31786227226257324,
0.00034172149025835097,
-0.140900656580925,
-0.18698005378246307,
0.7041813135147095,
-0.10601110011339188,
-0.23168444633483887,
-0.28858959674835205,
0.18419326841831207,
0.7328460216522217,
-0.46560895442962646,
0.7436162829399109,
0.24894212186336517,
-0.23673629760742188,
-0.4807751476764679,
-0.5839024782180786,
-0.19392620027065277,
-0.5217828750610352,
0.5137131214141846,
-0.5911889672279358,
-1.2421544790267944,
0.47885259985923767,
-0.37289130687713623,
0.25430309772491455,
0.44753941893577576,
0.6037085652351379,
0.01248454861342907,
1.3493854999542236,
0.9535370469093323,
-0.02986481785774231,
0.48948442935943604,
-0.23856927454471588,
0.08737815171480179,
-1.0325828790664673,
-0.03678090497851372,
-0.5836239457130432,
-0.4906330704689026,
-0.8418816328048706,
-0.09188016504049301,
0.07586116343736649,
0.2768048346042633,
-0.22753067314624786,
0.054432228207588196,
-0.4596962630748749,
0.7271292209625244,
0.355211466550827,
-0.10386382788419724,
0.4914168417453766,
0.11883538216352463,
0.054318588227033615,
0.10331030935049057,
-0.5707124471664429,
-0.47069355845451355,
1.351639747619629,
0.2607475817203522,
0.7143651843070984,
0.08848784863948822,
0.43339934945106506,
-0.014620469883084297,
0.038818009197711945,
-0.7114949822425842,
0.49192965030670166,
-0.6742805242538452,
-0.4630488157272339,
-0.3173905313014984,
-0.352570503950119,
-1.1043322086334229,
0.2839469015598297,
-0.2157631665468216,
-0.653550922870636,
0.01069694198668003,
0.23834042251110077,
-0.4531760811805725,
0.2974936366081238,
-0.7744742035865784,
0.6898102164268494,
0.014491940848529339,
-0.06188908591866493,
-0.5100629329681396,
-0.22724634408950806,
0.32550162076950073,
-0.32588791847229004,
0.10392230749130249,
-0.2302231341600418,
0.07385269552469254,
0.4412615895271301,
0.001639715046621859,
0.982907235622406,
-0.04682617262005806,
-0.31098228693008423,
-0.1160849928855896,
0.06895875930786133,
0.48474350571632385,
-0.04702536389231682,
0.03243853896856308,
0.18565963208675385,
-0.0912804901599884,
-0.4062586724758148,
-0.48198312520980835,
1.0339380502700806,
-0.744001567363739,
-0.908786952495575,
0.18033714592456818,
-0.7966764569282532,
-0.5214110016822815,
0.2649606764316559,
0.33643898367881775,
0.4458200931549072,
-0.200034037232399,
0.4411391317844391,
0.9497019648551941,
-0.10948459804058075,
0.379319429397583,
0.7538896203041077,
-0.13424775004386902,
0.25696447491645813,
0.8947688341140747,
0.20909136533737183,
0.6344175934791565,
0.37015822529792786,
0.1007402315735817,
-0.0018667969852685928,
-0.8642106652259827,
-0.24562054872512817,
0.35434016585350037,
-0.4197188913822174,
0.034111738204956055,
-0.5889362096786499,
-0.09507177025079727,
-0.40849506855010986,
-0.09970349073410034,
-0.33302250504493713,
-0.22583931684494019,
-0.4732152819633484,
0.05411534383893013,
0.2096848338842392,
1.0266858339309692,
0.11511598527431488,
0.30996939539909363,
-0.6210088729858398,
0.2873742878437042,
0.5377210974693298,
0.4905467629432678,
0.06810171157121658,
-0.7468124032020569,
-0.3532657027244568,
0.25963783264160156,
-0.22859488427639008,
-0.2097262740135193,
0.06063532829284668,
0.5949201583862305,
0.4574093222618103,
0.4978020489215851,
-0.3658844232559204,
0.7004494667053223,
-0.7021656036376953,
0.6055102944374084,
-0.28013160824775696,
-0.7947772741317749,
0.35805365443229675,
-0.6107706427574158,
0.48967352509498596,
0.40472784638404846,
0.01716284453868866,
-0.37704962491989136,
-0.38981473445892334,
-0.3646581768989563,
-0.6030956506729126,
0.5986555814743042,
-0.1436651349067688,
0.40629124641418457,
0.20238535106182098,
0.6287309527397156,
0.3348831236362457,
0.327965646982193,
-0.35090863704681396,
-0.17611666023731232,
0.24210213124752045,
0.19269128143787384,
-0.6374790668487549,
-0.3086414933204651,
-0.006236132699996233,
-0.4779838025569916,
0.3146023154258728,
-0.20762407779693604,
-0.06230413541197777,
-0.350619375705719,
-0.1380881518125534,
-0.3359249234199524,
0.510273277759552,
0.7331284880638123,
0.596619188785553,
-0.07887669652700424,
0.056530363857746124,
0.25223392248153687,
-0.18668484687805176,
-0.17193540930747986,
-0.00611859792843461,
-0.07640098035335541,
-0.2524630129337311,
0.3604362905025482,
0.9338288903236389,
0.3534521758556366,
-0.5865217447280884,
0.1959538608789444,
0.048974450677633286,
-0.2881002426147461,
0.05293601378798485,
0.6479398608207703,
0.13264204561710358,
0.30299803614616394,
0.30127203464508057,
0.04419760778546333,
0.03055250458419323,
-0.7186212539672852,
-0.07425443828105927,
0.8783257007598877,
-0.005002768710255623,
-0.4495931565761566,
0.46529701352119446,
0.008344768546521664,
-0.19774428009986877,
0.4533371031284332,
-0.11955807358026505,
-0.1708933413028717,
0.5624924898147583,
0.6039666533470154,
0.7742944955825806,
-0.1573261171579361,
-0.12464161217212677,
0.13481953740119934,
0.21917590498924255,
-0.14612950384616852,
0.06188352033495903,
-0.12403805553913116,
-0.7674151062965393,
-0.5383249521255493,
-0.7412702441215515,
-0.19419609010219574,
0.3942948877811432,
-0.5978107452392578,
-0.0571402832865715,
-0.3534896969795227,
-0.06050897017121315,
0.13848648965358734,
0.00851008202880621,
-0.851984441280365,
0.20537030696868896,
0.07195042818784714,
0.6427307724952698,
-0.7121347188949585,
0.8754557371139526,
0.8007084131240845,
0.08809342980384827,
-0.7204928398132324,
0.18289954960346222,
-0.22497808933258057,
-0.7161920070648193,
0.7119849324226379,
0.15320371091365814,
-0.10710353404283524,
0.24243780970573425,
-0.5507838726043701,
-1.0017895698547363,
0.9828935265541077,
0.4881420433521271,
-0.7919778227806091,
-0.16415737569332123,
0.4951636791229248,
0.7015255093574524,
-0.43098142743110657,
-0.18510191142559052,
0.9172404408454895,
0.2512401044368744,
-0.29885831475257874,
-1.3013038635253906,
-0.15137819945812225,
-0.04653420299291611,
0.23361937701702118,
0.41019707918167114,
-0.6919358968734741,
0.9436047077178955,
-0.32546693086624146,
-0.3150947093963623,
-0.01412022951990366,
0.3752901256084442,
0.025381166487932205,
-0.062143176794052124,
0.34130948781967163,
0.3943711221218109,
0.7273620367050171,
-0.12986591458320618,
1.0013868808746338,
-0.3573717474937439,
0.295515775680542,
1.0420935153961182,
-0.16996577382087708,
0.7325952649116516,
0.41832268238067627,
0.01994020864367485,
0.2503751814365387,
0.4307285249233246,
0.05419909954071045,
0.514173686504364,
0.3623630404472351,
-0.05714394897222519,
-0.49111634492874146,
-0.08858291059732437,
-0.2435077279806137,
0.46411842107772827,
0.481533020734787,
-0.41212499141693115,
-0.265103816986084,
0.12380354106426239,
-0.07815462350845337,
-0.02125317044556141,
-0.6047723889350891,
0.8396110534667969,
0.059811852872371674,
-0.7867451906204224,
0.8316490650177002,
0.12079460173845291,
0.8628057241439819,
-0.5383560061454773,
0.20766477286815643,
-0.059153586626052856,
0.3483371138572693,
-0.13463987410068512,
-0.6295107007026672,
0.2205686718225479,
-0.1007891297340393,
-0.4590124785900116,
-0.23232851922512054,
0.6942671537399292,
-0.3259667456150055,
-0.14465370774269104,
0.27043458819389343,
0.5866395831108093,
-0.14442329108715057,
-0.39869794249534607,
-0.3778236210346222,
0.08312565088272095,
0.18086370825767517,
-0.3411716818809509,
0.7557662725448608,
0.5451520085334778,
0.06399789452552795,
0.7815618515014648,
0.689666211605072,
0.1419408917427063,
0.1620764136314392,
0.0395658053457737,
0.829042911529541,
-0.5040572881698608,
-0.10695601999759674,
-0.9312115907669067,
0.35892343521118164,
0.2210550159215927,
-0.5292540192604065,
0.7295403480529785,
0.4851548969745636,
1.1063573360443115,
-0.36875098943710327,
0.8055140972137451,
0.24376384913921356,
0.5529183149337769,
-0.5896449685096741,
0.6079211831092834,
-0.8081536293029785,
0.1378675252199173,
-0.03356455639004707,
-0.9203612208366394,
-0.27547919750213623,
0.18003547191619873,
-0.4150010049343109,
0.14017322659492493,
0.5369355082511902,
0.8429109454154968,
-0.2589466869831085,
-0.24716930091381073,
0.6201441884040833,
0.2882518172264099,
0.2514769732952118,
0.4601554572582245,
0.5834245681762695,
-0.12312367558479309,
0.27660301327705383,
-0.08320441097021103,
-0.2022709846496582,
-0.21451541781425476,
-0.6750508546829224,
-1.1517850160598755,
-0.730561375617981,
-0.15370722115039825,
0.14785222709178925,
-0.018221428617835045,
0.6056522727012634,
0.6472706198692322,
-0.8970442414283752,
-0.15450525283813477,
-0.3044871985912323,
-0.14866095781326294,
-0.17910628020763397,
-0.17716416716575623,
0.12437836080789566,
-0.7115465402603149,
-0.9134190678596497,
0.38663843274116516,
0.18294498324394226,
0.01568993553519249,
-0.16714629530906677,
0.03619060665369034,
0.20484770834445953,
0.18287809193134308,
0.664432168006897,
0.270731657743454,
-0.7911403179168701,
-0.22152075171470642,
-0.0011436328059062362,
-0.052243202924728394,
-0.10484521090984344,
0.9949601888656616,
-0.43121010065078735,
0.27020806074142456,
0.31674399971961975,
0.5598798394203186,
0.2502885162830353,
-0.10754633694887161,
0.6439120173454285,
-0.7213950157165527,
-0.045125339180231094,
-0.15836572647094727,
0.3909268379211426,
0.14771796762943268,
-0.2646348774433136,
0.267355740070343,
-0.0689365491271019,
-0.9378368854522705,
-0.8257326483726501,
0.5131811499595642,
-0.5966407060623169,
-0.4319591522216797,
1.4815921783447266,
0.19948667287826538,
0.20463839173316956,
-0.10089138150215149,
-0.22449098527431488,
0.29851034283638,
-0.2189725935459137,
0.7857429385185242,
0.778465747833252,
-0.13611918687820435,
0.07346665114164352,
-0.684868574142456,
0.8317568898200989,
0.5935059785842896,
-0.5947617888450623,
0.5385942459106445,
0.3745328187942505,
0.5676568746566772,
-0.07650920003652573,
0.2364160120487213,
0.2780337929725647,
0.055489443242549896,
-0.5852571129798889,
-0.22857718169689178,
-0.09302497655153275,
-0.3071134388446808,
-0.5246374011039734,
0.17855465412139893,
0.4241967499256134,
0.06691907346248627
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09159v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09159v1
|
Basque and Spanish Counter Narrative Generation: Data Creation and Evaluation
| 2024-03-14T08:12:47 | 2024-03-14T08:12:47 |
Jaione Bengoetxea, Yi-Ling Chung, Marco Guerini, Rodrigo Agerri
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Counter Narratives (CNs) are non-negative textual responses to Hate Speech
(HS) aiming at defusing online hatred and mitigating its spreading across
media. Despite the recent increase in HS content posted online, research on
automatic CN generation has been relatively scarce and predominantly focused on
English. In this paper, we present CONAN-EUS, a new Basque and Spanish dataset
for CN generation developed by means of Machine Translation (MT) and
professional post-edition. Being a parallel corpus, also with respect to the
original English CONAN, it allows to perform novel research on multilingual and
crosslingual automatic generation of CNs. Our experiments on CN generation with
mT5, a multilingual encoder-decoder model, show that generation greatly
benefits from training on post-edited data, as opposed to relying on silver MT
data only. These results are confirmed by their correlation with a qualitative
manual evaluation, demonstrating that manually revised training data remains
crucial for the quality of the generated CNs. Furthermore, multilingual data
augmentation improves results over monolingual settings for structurally
similar languages such as English and Spanish, while being detrimental for
Basque, a language isolate. Similar findings occur in zero-shot crosslingual
evaluations, where model transfer (fine-tuning in English and generating in a
different target language) outperforms fine-tuning mT5 on machine translated
data for Spanish but not for Basque. This provides an interesting insight into
the asymmetry in the multilinguality of generative models, a challenging topic
which is still open to research.
|
[
-0.5776185989379883,
-0.6467152833938599,
0.03795510157942772,
0.24073554575443268,
-0.2533227205276489,
0.3004661798477173,
-0.2893863320350647,
-0.6192634105682373,
0.6335518956184387,
0.706646203994751,
-0.682886004447937,
-0.43034014105796814,
-0.7101640701293945,
0.5883963704109192,
-0.5032931566238403,
1.2971103191375732,
0.010358093306422234,
0.2626993656158447,
0.13913486897945404,
-0.43729299306869507,
-0.4735962748527527,
-0.5846734046936035,
-0.7743650078773499,
-0.17460231482982635,
0.7008545994758606,
0.09707285463809967,
0.7365211248397827,
0.4989760220050812,
0.10467857867479324,
0.2455323338508606,
0.43649980425834656,
0.3670438528060913,
-0.8384289741516113,
0.13740848004817963,
-0.35579368472099304,
-0.5039930939674377,
-0.25834688544273376,
-0.05999713018536568,
0.22589200735092163,
0.5632032752037048,
0.17416895925998688,
0.24552616477012634,
0.22559754550457,
0.449642151594162,
-0.31092631816864014,
-0.2182401716709137,
-0.8154152631759644,
0.252275675535202,
-0.3357236385345459,
-0.523000955581665,
-0.40787050127983093,
-0.5176961421966553,
0.06952688097953796,
-0.642955482006073,
0.7952724695205688,
-0.08662758767604828,
0.6493011116981506,
0.3208760619163513,
-0.5623384714126587,
-0.5904882550239563,
-0.615692138671875,
0.9385600686073303,
-0.5059274435043335,
0.3049812614917755,
0.25469598174095154,
0.22866620123386383,
-0.29941749572753906,
-0.4881775379180908,
-0.6857302188873291,
-0.0549444779753685,
0.11144040524959564,
0.3771483600139618,
-0.8621159195899963,
-0.33440735936164856,
-0.11918119341135025,
0.2520884573459625,
-0.936423659324646,
0.44327476620674133,
-0.8707307577133179,
-0.11196844279766083,
0.7963575720787048,
0.34747743606567383,
0.46991491317749023,
-0.21719710528850555,
-0.22276665270328522,
-0.1335856318473816,
-1.16049063205719,
-0.24044948816299438,
1.0191930532455444,
0.2870059013366699,
-0.1389203816652298,
0.5990625023841858,
0.00764396321028471,
0.6031365990638733,
-0.01602860540151596,
-0.12183202058076859,
0.38616788387298584,
-0.13253282010555267,
0.04041163623332977,
0.20640388131141663,
1.1473361253738403,
0.6629458069801331,
0.5133935213088989,
-0.3015577495098114,
0.38996192812919617,
0.6532287001609802,
0.5627853870391846,
-0.576611340045929,
-0.08132146298885345,
0.012783761136233807,
-0.381462424993515,
-0.568286120891571,
-0.26179295778274536,
-0.9220661520957947,
-0.24876566231250763,
-0.22444674372673035,
0.07047712057828903,
-0.2600502073764801,
-0.25758641958236694,
0.20480218529701233,
-0.30239737033843994,
-0.07039766013622284,
0.2503190040588379,
-0.5003364682197571,
0.2250402569770813,
0.22934088110923767,
0.553762674331665,
-0.6269726157188416,
-0.4616069197654724,
-0.4456152021884918,
0.11608826369047165,
-0.5842434763908386,
0.6791235208511353,
-0.2601279616355896,
-0.4038101136684418,
0.044682737439870834,
0.3291620910167694,
-0.06635785102844238,
-0.48708248138427734,
0.5489714741706848,
-0.3469392657279968,
0.5855891108512878,
-0.10538111627101898,
0.008770117536187172,
-0.2717572748661041,
0.3462684154510498,
-0.6742594838142395,
1.2479772567749023,
-0.19369646906852722,
-0.7811567783355713,
0.22981134057044983,
-0.32900163531303406,
-0.5376209020614624,
-0.19533032178878784,
-0.2696632444858551,
-0.1570170670747757,
0.057412780821323395,
0.2901735007762909,
0.22890040278434753,
-0.7151350378990173,
0.5053483247756958,
-0.08012783527374268,
0.1388128250837326,
0.028313670307397842,
-0.715535581111908,
1.0290659666061401,
0.346464067697525,
-0.5723795890808105,
0.0340893529355526,
-0.8343693017959595,
-0.24486148357391357,
0.3814249336719513,
-0.06518585979938507,
-0.2010522186756134,
0.025428203865885735,
-0.04387550428509712,
0.37842583656311035,
0.03793095424771309,
-0.9033164978027344,
-0.2539385259151459,
-0.3285176753997803,
0.039826374500989914,
0.44785624742507935,
-0.05804245173931122,
-0.20418569445610046,
-0.4313373267650604,
0.9949407577514648,
-0.292215496301651,
-0.04889995977282524,
-0.08437979221343994,
-0.7315277457237244,
-0.5643463134765625,
0.08739087730646133,
0.11541835218667984,
0.781143307685852,
-1.1920701265335083,
0.24458496272563934,
-0.1461341828107834,
-0.5883191227912903,
-0.6338439583778381,
-0.029993217438459396,
0.5779364705085754,
0.6057862043380737,
0.5725802779197693,
-0.41186654567718506,
-0.9506580233573914,
-0.6748396754264832,
-0.17609423398971558,
0.029241949319839478,
-0.15315359830856323,
-0.006533913780003786,
0.2278110235929489,
-0.09028881043195724,
0.6170371770858765,
-0.46464622020721436,
-0.029435496777296066,
-0.5880987048149109,
0.413696825504303,
0.015855122357606888,
0.32171061635017395,
0.8335474729537964,
-0.4457544684410095,
-0.7376319766044617,
-0.008725914172828197,
-0.9350388646125793,
-0.3113395869731903,
-0.024994421750307083,
0.024119019508361816,
0.1302495151758194,
0.4389573037624359,
-0.06692831963300705,
0.610273003578186,
0.9952448606491089,
-0.10801555216312408,
0.6699403524398804,
-0.24603627622127533,
0.3986382484436035,
-1.1318556070327759,
-0.09459177404642105,
-0.10742763429880142,
-0.19448581337928772,
-0.6789238452911377,
-0.0615178644657135,
-0.5308907628059387,
-0.2773544490337372,
-0.5578632354736328,
0.38270774483680725,
-0.3545483648777008,
0.139837384223938,
-0.34966397285461426,
0.18572506308555603,
0.06627361476421356,
0.5415582656860352,
0.29428789019584656,
0.42882999777793884,
0.30952024459838867,
-0.48512497544288635,
0.489777147769928,
0.16551852226257324,
-0.19275961816310883,
0.71799635887146,
-0.7940138578414917,
0.1648239940404892,
-0.2463819831609726,
0.351336807012558,
-0.7290271520614624,
0.14106041193008423,
0.16506756842136383,
-0.5422284007072449,
-0.1479080319404602,
-0.151701420545578,
-0.4247903525829315,
-0.5500900149345398,
-0.34685054421424866,
0.42345479130744934,
0.2842881679534912,
-0.6245973110198975,
0.0587303526699543,
0.5309485793113708,
-0.38796189427375793,
-0.6033480763435364,
-0.9278991222381592,
0.3809424340724945,
-0.4360145032405853,
-0.4763079285621643,
0.2617063820362091,
-0.14649122953414917,
-0.1089479923248291,
-0.05899011343717575,
0.3296833634376526,
0.06891178339719772,
-0.320585161447525,
-0.09354756772518158,
0.05642170086503029,
-0.23756344616413116,
-0.2478867918252945,
0.3192678987979889,
-0.13868528604507446,
0.03551078960299492,
-0.35476553440093994,
0.8236216306686401,
0.37834179401397705,
-0.22805722057819366,
-0.17194797098636627,
0.5518075823783875,
0.3743285536766052,
-0.4138188064098358,
0.6852598786354065,
0.6797488927841187,
-0.21961481869220734,
-0.27860602736473083,
-0.4633316099643707,
0.24371878802776337,
-0.3776117265224457,
0.15579476952552795,
-0.49037882685661316,
-0.6833794116973877,
0.5946923494338989,
0.1557019203901291,
0.10197185724973679,
0.815948486328125,
0.7887773513793945,
0.11465547978878021,
0.9661604166030884,
0.43923553824424744,
0.12079648673534393,
0.23621737957000732,
-0.23496520519256592,
0.07475299388170242,
-0.5546036958694458,
-0.14437411725521088,
-0.7829485535621643,
-0.19077926874160767,
-0.7341707944869995,
-0.3928597867488861,
0.5306262373924255,
-0.12634611129760742,
0.09416093677282333,
0.6490980386734009,
-0.529640257358551,
0.4412447214126587,
0.3206607699394226,
-0.11138680577278137,
0.4065690040588379,
0.0184145737439394,
-0.14985497295856476,
-0.38930588960647583,
-0.9096129536628723,
-0.4322243332862854,
1.4756509065628052,
0.08378395438194275,
0.50291508436203,
0.169768288731575,
0.5025777220726013,
0.3898012936115265,
0.1374818980693817,
-0.3304632604122162,
0.173376202583313,
-0.5993790030479431,
-0.3895273208618164,
-0.2037292718887329,
-0.43178635835647583,
-1.4151074886322021,
0.4023343026638031,
-0.2041226178407669,
-0.5049000978469849,
0.2724631428718567,
0.02290920354425907,
-0.30753427743911743,
0.3338925838470459,
-0.30238085985183716,
0.935612678527832,
-0.3125912547111511,
-0.2380022257566452,
-0.47058892250061035,
-0.5098084211349487,
0.18341472744941711,
-0.046486157923936844,
0.24143365025520325,
0.18960455060005188,
0.28004616498947144,
0.9055973291397095,
-0.37797999382019043,
0.8859107494354248,
0.02720513567328453,
-0.4479033946990967,
0.5834053754806519,
0.3359660804271698,
0.3969877362251282,
-0.2724960148334503,
-0.2924363911151886,
0.3251413404941559,
-0.12626709043979645,
-0.21621768176555634,
-0.3243449926376343,
0.6256830096244812,
-0.6052372455596924,
-0.30905410647392273,
-0.16103053092956543,
-0.6578385829925537,
-0.124296173453331,
0.2152033895254135,
0.6248686909675598,
0.5465339422225952,
-0.6615729331970215,
0.3229234516620636,
0.5993354320526123,
-0.7760769724845886,
0.21204867959022522,
0.636806845664978,
-0.20537425577640533,
-0.6534311771392822,
0.9919646382331848,
0.4785824120044708,
0.34994032979011536,
0.1460692286491394,
0.199445441365242,
-0.2923402190208435,
-0.5377536416053772,
-1.0673611164093018,
-0.02941678650677204,
-0.26213979721069336,
-0.17188072204589844,
-0.8367100954055786,
0.05305210128426552,
-0.38147613406181335,
-0.4030712842941284,
-0.40016844868659973,
-0.5544174313545227,
0.030255254358053207,
-0.330467164516449,
0.3633834719657898,
0.9347703456878662,
-0.2513309121131897,
0.3054620325565338,
-0.4670022428035736,
0.8332217335700989,
-0.08922746777534485,
-0.1072697639465332,
-0.038530342280864716,
-0.5165318250656128,
-0.1813402622938156,
0.17520537972450256,
-0.4102550148963928,
-1.1761401891708374,
0.7609823346138,
-0.21203124523162842,
0.43166884779930115,
0.16301469504833221,
0.22212854027748108,
0.675081729888916,
-0.706401526927948,
0.723016619682312,
0.3138108253479004,
-0.5313757061958313,
0.5189896821975708,
-0.6770070195198059,
0.1536092758178711,
0.5094818472862244,
0.681563138961792,
-0.5904675722122192,
-0.8980945944786072,
-0.844375729560852,
-0.7351276278495789,
0.5778878331184387,
0.030153639614582062,
0.22993764281272888,
-0.29773011803627014,
-0.3552071452140808,
0.6918570399284363,
0.3423890471458435,
-0.8737924695014954,
-0.19086243212223053,
-0.3553047478199005,
-0.26964476704597473,
-0.23628218472003937,
0.13924624025821686,
-0.06443769484758377,
-0.22670479118824005,
0.6457350254058838,
-0.08147914707660675,
-0.17295043170452118,
0.11440295726060867,
-0.1629187911748886,
-0.22572621703147888,
0.03428399935364723,
0.41371405124664307,
0.514276921749115,
0.16916772723197937,
0.09396877139806747,
0.3852370083332062,
-0.29166850447654724,
-0.09791862219572067,
-0.166347935795784,
-0.3899933695793152,
0.3734559416770935,
0.2945845425128937,
0.8650416135787964,
0.07473675161600113,
-0.5905510187149048,
0.3950132131576538,
0.10771271586418152,
-0.26569700241088867,
-0.4193399250507355,
-0.2561165392398834,
-0.23837405443191528,
-0.062418464571237564,
0.2746219038963318,
0.015609247609972954,
0.03425639122724533,
-0.7687666416168213,
0.13378483057022095,
0.21991583704948425,
-0.06869358569383621,
-0.42424970865249634,
0.7928786873817444,
0.1248261034488678,
-0.15336553752422333,
0.24645660817623138,
-0.4411208927631378,
-0.6424073576927185,
0.6513493061065674,
0.9707419276237488,
0.6808971762657166,
-0.3971087634563446,
0.6047170758247375,
0.6505804657936096,
0.6078367233276367,
0.2027333378791809,
0.2548869252204895,
0.1206081435084343,
-0.756957471370697,
-0.27931100130081177,
-0.5557110905647278,
-0.227908194065094,
0.2406473606824875,
-0.7525452971458435,
0.2958909571170807,
-0.18995140492916107,
0.15586048364639282,
-0.1988227814435959,
-0.14912524819374084,
-0.6748204827308655,
0.2696245014667511,
-0.15313689410686493,
0.4395115077495575,
-1.0125999450683594,
0.8071971535682678,
0.11260611563920975,
-0.5126512050628662,
-0.3962889313697815,
-0.2860707640647888,
0.15767261385917664,
-0.7156953811645508,
0.39060792326927185,
-0.19496944546699524,
-0.3788979947566986,
-0.1089244857430458,
-0.05949467048048973,
-0.6120560765266418,
0.6321358680725098,
0.590057909488678,
-0.2848367691040039,
0.16004692018032074,
0.6718725562095642,
1.110231637954712,
-0.4698489010334015,
0.06814026832580566,
0.32229292392730713,
0.28740763664245605,
-0.05823111906647682,
-0.984431266784668,
-0.07780004292726517,
-0.40229272842407227,
-0.3853141665458679,
0.0444285124540329,
-0.6190028786659241,
0.8694291710853577,
0.18841640651226044,
-0.17271997034549713,
-0.04795994982123375,
0.44832953810691833,
0.09606923162937164,
0.21377885341644287,
0.23657459020614624,
0.7470378279685974,
0.5714048147201538,
0.10383287072181702,
1.0791009664535522,
-0.20083248615264893,
-0.22846293449401855,
1.249973177909851,
-0.12132640928030014,
0.5968907475471497,
0.1969071626663208,
-0.14725235104560852,
0.7117581367492676,
0.3057853877544403,
-0.16982857882976532,
0.1804681122303009,
0.318733274936676,
-0.08235581964254379,
0.29602107405662537,
-0.4538401663303375,
-0.49235716462135315,
0.6952636241912842,
0.20150451362133026,
-0.3890421390533447,
-0.33938831090927124,
0.2919532060623169,
0.3566723167896271,
0.5491076707839966,
-0.24145083129405975,
0.7429710626602173,
-0.16348212957382202,
-0.8539608716964722,
0.7249788641929626,
0.24281679093837738,
0.813426673412323,
-0.5790817737579346,
0.08242310583591461,
-0.08854977786540985,
-0.14037315547466278,
-0.31580737233161926,
-0.5138773918151855,
0.8245719075202942,
0.7536582946777344,
-0.2848534882068634,
-0.4518451690673828,
0.2621334195137024,
-0.5919216871261597,
-0.6972752809524536,
0.5955171585083008,
0.513063371181488,
0.4608764052391052,
0.1725156009197235,
-0.4902576804161072,
0.13483954966068268,
0.1787688434123993,
0.11386053264141083,
0.22238494455814362,
0.5066214203834534,
-0.43189769983291626,
0.13712212443351746,
0.7128668427467346,
0.357960969209671,
0.5483070015907288,
0.417521595954895,
0.460096538066864,
-0.38368499279022217,
-0.5626545548439026,
-0.5914927124977112,
0.3179551661014557,
0.014702488668262959,
-0.604316234588623,
0.9613975286483765,
0.8797897696495056,
1.322337031364441,
-0.04301196709275246,
0.9617443084716797,
-0.15388022363185883,
0.6972569227218628,
-0.36029213666915894,
0.5949893593788147,
-0.3508376479148865,
-0.10802683234214783,
-0.44213807582855225,
-0.7031419277191162,
-0.19304752349853516,
0.2244003713130951,
-0.43908941745758057,
-0.45060619711875916,
0.684969425201416,
0.8267279267311096,
0.0028254971839487553,
0.06131206452846527,
0.22718240320682526,
0.11434657871723175,
0.15645059943199158,
0.4396369159221649,
0.765864908695221,
-0.6766639947891235,
0.6856579184532166,
-0.08309570699930191,
-0.07115387171506882,
0.4234412610530853,
-0.5998324751853943,
-0.7984310388565063,
-0.5025937557220459,
-0.11932051181793213,
-0.24900639057159424,
0.1292281299829483,
0.6000486612319946,
0.1526087075471878,
-0.9573087692260742,
-0.5280696153640747,
-0.1116923913359642,
0.03527265042066574,
-0.07192764431238174,
-0.2277819663286209,
0.27652356028556824,
-0.11265829205513,
-0.9941994547843933,
0.8192802667617798,
0.006498752161860466,
-0.22533364593982697,
-0.35594725608825684,
-0.25380852818489075,
-0.10651929676532745,
0.13425113260746002,
0.6595008969306946,
0.4872788190841675,
-0.5777064561843872,
-0.04195849969983101,
-0.17513149976730347,
0.15723983943462372,
0.0722317025065422,
0.9596917629241943,
-0.8095707893371582,
0.55607008934021,
0.474641889333725,
0.7102876305580139,
0.6520088911056519,
-0.24429309368133545,
1.005383014678955,
-0.7634109258651733,
0.4663303792476654,
0.11911316961050034,
0.3088807463645935,
0.3079596757888794,
-0.24701857566833496,
0.6462209820747375,
0.24793705344200134,
-0.04099566116929054,
-0.9352073669433594,
0.34267479181289673,
-0.541512131690979,
-0.1924522966146469,
0.8547319173812866,
-0.03803955763578415,
0.16149446368217468,
-0.4742039740085602,
-0.26917076110839844,
0.5059897303581238,
0.10332062840461731,
0.781863808631897,
0.45481109619140625,
-0.1587747186422348,
0.0771634429693222,
-0.767540454864502,
0.40709060430526733,
0.422285258769989,
-0.7612921595573425,
-0.12367010861635208,
0.562604546546936,
0.0023321849294006824,
0.20818324387073517,
0.5838829278945923,
-0.4554581642150879,
0.2713669538497925,
0.2524997591972351,
0.20752626657485962,
-0.03441890329122543,
-0.56298828125,
-0.10597748309373856,
0.3720070719718933,
-0.47412392497062683,
-0.04151298850774765
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09148v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09148v1
|
Evaluating LLMs for Gender Disparities in Notable Persons
| 2024-03-14T07:58:27 | 2024-03-14T07:58:27 |
Lauren Rhue, Sofie Goethals, Arun Sundararajan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
This study examines the use of Large Language Models (LLMs) for retrieving
factual information, addressing concerns over their propensity to produce
factually incorrect "hallucinated" responses or to altogether decline to even
answer prompt at all. Specifically, it investigates the presence of
gender-based biases in LLMs' responses to factual inquiries. This paper takes a
multi-pronged approach to evaluating GPT models by evaluating fairness across
multiple dimensions of recall, hallucinations and declinations. Our findings
reveal discernible gender disparities in the responses generated by GPT-3.5.
While advancements in GPT-4 have led to improvements in performance, they have
not fully eradicated these gender disparities, notably in instances where
responses are declined. The study further explores the origins of these
disparities by examining the influence of gender associations in prompts and
the homogeneity in the responses.
|
[
-0.3116612434387207,
-0.7978184819221497,
0.972205638885498,
0.11592705547809601,
0.12919175624847412,
0.07876934856176376,
0.02113025262951851,
-0.4407580494880676,
0.063516765832901,
0.17305253446102142,
-0.5972191691398621,
-0.36136290431022644,
-1.0066736936569214,
0.41943517327308655,
-0.5502042174339294,
0.7699127793312073,
0.2922334671020508,
0.37271928787231445,
0.010748767293989658,
0.09653995931148529,
-0.9552169442176819,
-0.8422763347625732,
-0.37360626459121704,
-0.2459588646888733,
0.5004602074623108,
0.12343087047338486,
0.6393844485282898,
0.19726137816905975,
0.5694540739059448,
0.3305417001247406,
-0.26573365926742554,
0.10576556622982025,
-0.6693740487098694,
0.031500864773988724,
-0.18553462624549866,
-0.4789727032184601,
-0.4285552203655243,
0.32968154549598694,
0.8161221742630005,
0.998300313949585,
-0.29376131296157837,
0.0696667730808258,
0.07441532611846924,
0.721021294593811,
-0.42069002985954285,
0.07216865569353104,
-0.775576651096344,
0.3625124990940094,
-0.0979333221912384,
-0.1735675185918808,
-0.31283998489379883,
-0.7040043473243713,
0.45537233352661133,
-0.2504603862762451,
0.7579934000968933,
0.15630747377872467,
0.6289232969284058,
-0.04104220122098923,
-0.5267823934555054,
-0.5944610834121704,
-0.7774888277053833,
0.6712610125541687,
-0.41466060280799866,
0.42852139472961426,
0.49611490964889526,
0.38073915243148804,
-0.19581037759780884,
-0.4463656544685364,
-0.48396989703178406,
-0.5388666987419128,
-0.24337512254714966,
-0.09424754232168198,
-0.12215780466794968,
-0.06991876661777496,
0.6989902257919312,
0.46711423993110657,
-0.625636100769043,
0.06546599417924881,
-0.4614725410938263,
-0.20687665045261383,
0.4211227595806122,
0.39531898498535156,
0.16771487891674042,
-0.21263901889324188,
-0.07443317770957947,
0.25689205527305603,
-0.7051281332969666,
-0.33342185616493225,
0.7941500544548035,
0.37118473649024963,
0.12391038984060287,
0.6261934638023376,
-0.042093198746442795,
0.41225603222846985,
0.11492642015218735,
-0.22277399897575378,
0.29917585849761963,
-0.20880070328712463,
-0.052493203431367874,
0.1210002526640892,
0.45432746410369873,
0.39532020688056946,
0.23491303622722626,
-0.2686368525028229,
-0.30175116658210754,
-0.06077881157398224,
0.2720578908920288,
-0.7266342639923096,
0.081575907766819,
-0.13660234212875366,
-0.555929958820343,
0.06300391256809235,
0.15226173400878906,
-0.9318467378616333,
-0.7956096529960632,
-0.32078275084495544,
0.4155588448047638,
-0.17549428343772888,
-0.305306077003479,
0.13884322345256805,
-0.2720710039138794,
0.17803244292736053,
0.4847414791584015,
-1.0717662572860718,
0.2601749300956726,
0.5955238342285156,
0.800143301486969,
-0.046766605228185654,
-0.157913476228714,
-0.48869001865386963,
-0.06660236418247223,
-0.2719654440879822,
0.5495947003364563,
-0.5181865692138672,
-0.5566869974136353,
0.03296998143196106,
0.1556895226240158,
-0.12862055003643036,
-0.7357563972473145,
0.47666430473327637,
-0.31053999066352844,
0.3464517891407013,
-1.0766907930374146,
-0.3816513419151306,
-0.2236894816160202,
0.2969576120376587,
-0.7471672892570496,
0.7505984902381897,
0.16128985583782196,
-0.8969820737838745,
0.5115569233894348,
-0.4856245219707489,
-0.11121896654367447,
-0.022695384919643402,
-0.6623439788818359,
-0.26649436354637146,
0.2559945583343506,
0.12694744765758514,
0.26761314272880554,
-0.4074154496192932,
0.599028468132019,
-0.08594684302806854,
-0.6209732294082642,
0.25015318393707275,
-0.7338613271713257,
0.4498498737812042,
-0.004949796013534069,
-0.5638139247894287,
0.050859905779361725,
-0.6015816926956177,
-0.6944661736488342,
0.2709732949733734,
-0.12896662950515747,
-0.2935289740562439,
0.03205882012844086,
-0.33175453543663025,
0.13228389620780945,
0.031107613816857338,
-0.46406352519989014,
0.039852406829595566,
-0.05309794470667839,
0.24455299973487854,
1.0320982933044434,
-0.24084170162677765,
0.25096234679222107,
-0.3982703983783722,
0.41958463191986084,
0.14370641112327576,
0.11383625864982605,
0.1955583095550537,
-0.5880988240242004,
-0.5024911761283875,
-0.3162374198436737,
0.16586807370185852,
0.3506423234939575,
-0.7467141151428223,
0.13125182688236237,
-0.20435605943202972,
-0.03604520112276077,
-0.33088812232017517,
-0.1605921983718872,
0.2271624207496643,
0.6718994975090027,
0.19028358161449432,
-0.20162789523601532,
-0.36438021063804626,
-1.2687188386917114,
-0.23698286712169647,
-0.2578577399253845,
-0.1541343778371811,
0.25426697731018066,
0.7294207215309143,
-0.2005806714296341,
0.7622876167297363,
-0.43344607949256897,
-0.13990186154842377,
-0.2208460569381714,
0.20297442376613617,
0.11465214192867279,
0.1605476289987564,
0.5812616944313049,
-0.7056308388710022,
0.04524754732847214,
-0.3974432647228241,
-0.8657131791114807,
-0.07558687776327133,
0.19054724276065826,
-0.015641331672668457,
0.18598543107509613,
0.211528941988945,
-0.6967172026634216,
0.4746665060520172,
0.38198453187942505,
-0.6364547610282898,
0.6594730615615845,
0.012245604768395424,
0.5327907800674438,
-0.5051925182342529,
-0.006224947981536388,
0.022449271753430367,
-0.03457958623766899,
-0.5123154520988464,
-0.3623539209365845,
-0.13473044335842133,
0.28726574778556824,
-0.1951458901166916,
0.36312875151634216,
-0.5705275535583496,
-0.49084851145744324,
-0.009344223886728287,
0.33386120200157166,
-0.21373917162418365,
0.03843598812818527,
-0.02687661349773407,
0.8272054195404053,
0.20559528470039368,
-0.5539724230766296,
-0.03588971495628357,
0.23921909928321838,
-0.20743848383426666,
0.7384505867958069,
-0.5049935579299927,
0.2767897844314575,
-0.4692780375480652,
0.09962023049592972,
-1.1542636156082153,
-0.2788187563419342,
0.3062872588634491,
-0.3074619770050049,
0.15542641282081604,
-0.004117810633033514,
-0.6075742840766907,
-0.6641119122505188,
-0.3987569212913513,
0.40220555663108826,
0.45851293206214905,
-0.435065895318985,
0.5831151008605957,
0.37504372000694275,
-0.22549480199813843,
-0.5570040941238403,
-0.5413656830787659,
0.03056536428630352,
-0.3807870149612427,
-0.3645422160625458,
-0.005840310826897621,
-0.27140170335769653,
-0.498884379863739,
-0.41516101360321045,
-0.18842509388923645,
0.09858844429254532,
0.05339014157652855,
0.08770649880170822,
0.3209575116634369,
0.013044439256191254,
0.22418393194675446,
-0.05497480183839798,
0.13414007425308228,
0.31123125553131104,
0.2428666055202484,
0.6403419971466064,
-0.062411025166511536,
-0.588828444480896,
-0.3141053318977356,
0.40635666251182556,
0.445405513048172,
0.16747304797172546,
0.7549256682395935,
0.628403902053833,
-0.52152419090271,
0.2556705176830292,
-0.9009082913398743,
-0.6313474178314209,
-0.42120349407196045,
0.5799269676208496,
-0.477897971868515,
-1.328012228012085,
0.8053340315818787,
0.3356119394302368,
-0.12248688191175461,
0.44092756509780884,
0.616926372051239,
0.16834591329097748,
1.0052598714828491,
0.4750514626502991,
0.10183083266019821,
0.2558354437351227,
0.07298613339662552,
0.3171407878398895,
-0.7528848052024841,
-0.4404247999191284,
-0.7299053072929382,
-0.15001548826694489,
-0.8156822323799133,
-0.2502250671386719,
0.09446238726377487,
-0.2502096891403198,
-0.43601304292678833,
-0.3278615474700928,
-0.5349041819572449,
0.32810282707214355,
0.41594642400741577,
0.2046179324388504,
0.41901442408561707,
-0.06356535106897354,
0.13475337624549866,
-0.4349304437637329,
-0.5281167030334473,
-0.6787448525428772,
1.0899624824523926,
0.7228497266769409,
0.630222499370575,
0.44529056549072266,
0.302350789308548,
0.5248828530311584,
0.33847761154174805,
-0.5855041742324829,
0.6698232293128967,
-0.06482696533203125,
-0.8796292543411255,
-0.385177344083786,
-0.6393994092941284,
-0.8093738555908203,
0.5243582129478455,
-0.019006306305527687,
-0.8278282284736633,
0.25994035601615906,
-0.16841809451580048,
-0.24564215540885925,
0.32201048731803894,
-0.45450618863105774,
0.38237878680229187,
0.004117803648114204,
-0.217390239238739,
0.14338836073875427,
-0.5542249083518982,
0.8294541835784912,
-0.27669277787208557,
0.2072562575340271,
-0.37075889110565186,
0.22909170389175415,
0.7650494575500488,
-0.13284245133399963,
0.8589513897895813,
-0.3983583152294159,
-0.45024609565734863,
0.1327521651983261,
0.15615785121917725,
0.36441779136657715,
0.21795985102653503,
-0.14813174307346344,
0.5587947368621826,
-0.2623620629310608,
-0.1877359300851822,
-0.414897084236145,
0.6188870668411255,
-0.7702126502990723,
-0.9722192287445068,
-0.6499909162521362,
-0.7536287903785706,
-0.1548626720905304,
-0.022391024976968765,
0.0280454084277153,
0.3315861225128174,
-0.2529779374599457,
-0.13261301815509796,
0.8879348635673523,
-0.5744282007217407,
0.32656675577163696,
0.7755168080329895,
-0.27602049708366394,
-0.15409205853939056,
0.33192527294158936,
0.33319997787475586,
0.24977974593639374,
0.1281563639640808,
0.06926512718200684,
-0.6072030067443848,
-0.5134802460670471,
-0.28394046425819397,
0.44185641407966614,
-0.8117403388023376,
0.00464671803638339,
-0.8217787146568298,
-0.1821533739566803,
-0.45408618450164795,
0.24275106191635132,
-0.2133665531873703,
-0.10168854147195816,
-0.19468291103839874,
-0.3478030562400818,
0.20620612800121307,
1.0135027170181274,
0.06466076523065567,
0.13968335092067719,
-0.3402513861656189,
0.5491363406181335,
0.5514734387397766,
0.204920694231987,
0.08129432797431946,
-0.8582573533058167,
0.19804218411445618,
-0.14041855931282043,
-0.307857483625412,
-1.0210716724395752,
0.15677113831043243,
-0.37390756607055664,
0.8299106359481812,
0.018908731639385223,
-0.20045973360538483,
0.5809831023216248,
-0.6048850417137146,
1.0779486894607544,
0.29303044080734253,
-1.0196213722229004,
0.36148500442504883,
-0.43578454852104187,
0.11337310075759888,
0.39531630277633667,
0.4180300235748291,
-0.4399833381175995,
-0.4452687203884125,
-0.21787534654140472,
-0.7240821719169617,
0.767117977142334,
0.3521151840686798,
0.2077387571334839,
-0.40212005376815796,
0.5991735458374023,
0.3540340065956116,
0.4553791284561157,
-0.8503338098526001,
-0.43622153997421265,
0.016780098900198936,
0.06225181743502617,
0.1244247779250145,
-0.686626136302948,
-0.169258251786232,
-0.3747814893722534,
0.30116140842437744,
-0.009094088338315487,
0.6427459716796875,
0.29770874977111816,
-0.13399119675159454,
0.09226434677839279,
0.4223107397556305,
0.9352598190307617,
0.9939834475517273,
-0.3237450420856476,
0.2799176871776581,
0.4469050467014313,
-0.7579841613769531,
0.32368022203445435,
-0.02217189408838749,
-0.07061192393302917,
0.19268843531608582,
0.3040449023246765,
0.8112220168113708,
-0.17833012342453003,
-0.4148995578289032,
0.4821168780326843,
-0.4681248664855957,
-0.461313933134079,
-0.18473564088344574,
-0.18026043474674225,
-0.04334476590156555,
0.3934904634952545,
0.5419467687606812,
-0.2584547996520996,
0.4485117197036743,
-0.667708694934845,
-0.013147324323654175,
0.5452013611793518,
-0.4285694658756256,
-0.25425437092781067,
0.8063103556632996,
0.04375842586159706,
-0.147976353764534,
0.8636905550956726,
-0.2259702831506729,
-0.4267604351043701,
0.6241108775138855,
0.5988754034042358,
0.9593310952186584,
-0.369741290807724,
0.29675987362861633,
0.3902200162410736,
0.6545536518096924,
-0.3584728538990021,
0.2332501858472824,
0.4242197871208191,
-0.5888932943344116,
-0.15629643201828003,
-0.5640580654144287,
-0.1678152084350586,
0.30490946769714355,
-0.5085811614990234,
0.16365136206150055,
-0.35180649161338806,
-0.5323621034622192,
-0.32664111256599426,
-0.17136920988559723,
-0.803221583366394,
0.031248750165104866,
0.22733622789382935,
0.535934567451477,
-0.9717680811882019,
0.3395836651325226,
0.31981441378593445,
-0.5840039849281311,
-0.6680433750152588,
0.26943308115005493,
0.181708425283432,
-0.6739552021026611,
0.9681143760681152,
0.2825681269168854,
-0.26441866159439087,
-0.21813273429870605,
-0.19957371056079865,
-0.6859807372093201,
1.160083293914795,
0.6793138384819031,
-0.9289528131484985,
-0.06925762444734573,
0.42145246267318726,
0.42980140447616577,
-0.31991738080978394,
0.699323832988739,
0.8776426315307617,
0.5813581943511963,
0.06682029366493225,
-1.2294557094573975,
0.2809843122959137,
0.16450442373752594,
0.3439010977745056,
-0.04563033580780029,
-0.5223895907402039,
1.1786452531814575,
-0.24782532453536987,
-0.13050693273544312,
0.021341122686862946,
0.4475906491279602,
0.693803071975708,
0.43420955538749695,
0.4865296483039856,
0.21838133037090302,
1.0940123796463013,
-0.3723929226398468,
1.009817361831665,
0.194564551115036,
0.41938307881355286,
0.9191527962684631,
-0.49943581223487854,
0.20190449059009552,
0.43307921290397644,
-0.3362109959125519,
0.24941478669643402,
0.5669320821762085,
0.0993945300579071,
0.4556916356086731,
0.5417820811271667,
-0.3433752954006195,
0.015313913114368916,
-0.008298509754240513,
-0.6928600668907166,
0.2529086172580719,
0.19414468109607697,
-0.564863920211792,
-0.12401601672172546,
-0.0916888490319252,
0.0869692787528038,
0.073166623711586,
-0.2560284435749054,
0.460381418466568,
0.16638563573360443,
-0.31623348593711853,
0.36851391196250916,
0.007831386290490627,
0.7206937074661255,
-0.4225398004055023,
-0.25533872842788696,
-0.5608545541763306,
-0.0520002618432045,
-0.14006394147872925,
-0.6583574414253235,
0.15185803174972534,
0.0462554506957531,
-0.57648766040802,
0.17272250354290009,
0.5756073594093323,
-0.314240962266922,
-0.4870394170284271,
0.3911131024360657,
0.5974066257476807,
0.2684154510498047,
-0.09867711365222931,
-0.6444922089576721,
0.2985292375087738,
0.08271720260381699,
-0.18633991479873657,
0.3169490396976471,
0.6110260486602783,
-0.32009202241897583,
0.6194084286689758,
0.30518394708633423,
-0.09626934677362442,
0.1663660854101181,
0.6484947204589844,
0.6268406510353088,
-0.8005629181861877,
-0.32250654697418213,
-1.1292803287506104,
0.3603118658065796,
-0.03330308571457863,
-0.054762620478868484,
0.9411430954933167,
0.5433894395828247,
0.4982036054134369,
-0.14560972154140472,
0.6730695366859436,
0.1488265097141266,
0.6580840349197388,
-0.5585523247718811,
0.693331241607666,
-0.2897554039955139,
0.7310636043548584,
-0.6383402347564697,
-1.2351819276809692,
-0.17737695574760437,
0.7361849546432495,
-0.6150007247924805,
0.8042763471603394,
0.8211134672164917,
0.8891448974609375,
0.09906674176454544,
0.2336302101612091,
0.5210381746292114,
0.2870580554008484,
0.5084089636802673,
0.3460288345813751,
1.3193076848983765,
-0.3943134844303131,
0.12550325691699982,
0.35020893812179565,
-0.2509046494960785,
-0.1777949184179306,
-0.7843403220176697,
-1.0780876874923706,
-0.35854393243789673,
-0.20732736587524414,
-0.24344518780708313,
0.3687499165534973,
0.6439240574836731,
0.4175635278224945,
-0.46504759788513184,
-0.1662776619195938,
0.2195890098810196,
0.2398330569267273,
0.21587233245372772,
-0.24555134773254395,
0.27739381790161133,
-0.15065662562847137,
-0.7299114465713501,
-0.049698926508426666,
0.1558762937784195,
0.07370881736278534,
-0.5043002963066101,
-0.14280728995800018,
0.050826020538806915,
0.026740599423646927,
0.8412997722625732,
-0.3988701105117798,
-0.9462342858314514,
-0.5353178381919861,
0.02345101162791252,
-0.14495670795440674,
0.029224447906017303,
0.6937996745109558,
-0.5818939208984375,
0.06980924308300018,
0.2261573225259781,
0.23237863183021545,
0.22515632212162018,
0.014224395155906677,
0.39219343662261963,
-0.57025545835495,
0.05681084096431732,
0.08507797122001648,
0.3262477219104767,
0.5721249580383301,
-0.5362353920936584,
0.49235016107559204,
0.5718308091163635,
-0.6729956269264221,
-0.9033845067024231,
0.10936452448368073,
-0.7166057229042053,
-0.30100807547569275,
1.2464370727539062,
0.19697706401348114,
0.2071022093296051,
-0.23822829127311707,
-0.38697823882102966,
0.09758683294057846,
-0.45260679721832275,
1.0764538049697876,
0.9309859871864319,
-0.0984961986541748,
-0.18021215498447418,
-1.1702229976654053,
0.32380416989326477,
0.2381461262702942,
-0.6733968257904053,
0.10351774841547012,
0.8749547600746155,
0.43332940340042114,
-0.040633127093315125,
0.8874439001083374,
-0.43814346194267273,
-0.0031049614772200584,
-0.010083477944135666,
0.03281072899699211,
0.25732743740081787,
-0.3735874593257904,
-0.3893754780292511,
0.19038832187652588,
0.18655157089233398,
0.050552550703287125
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09131v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09131v3
|
ProSwitch: Knowledge-Guided Instruction Tuning to Generate Professional and Non-Professional Styled Text
| 2024-03-14T06:49:16 | 2024-04-16T03:31:25 |
Chang Zong, Yuyan Chen, Weiming Lu, Jian Shao, Yueting Zhuang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, 68T50, I.2.7
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated efficacy in various linguistic
applications, including text summarization and controlled text generation.
However, studies into their capacity of switching between styles via
fine-tuning remain underexplored. This study concentrates on textual
professionalism and introduces a novel methodology, named ProSwitch, which
equips a language model with the ability to produce both professional and
non-professional responses through knowledge-guided instruction tuning.
ProSwitch unfolds across three phases: data preparation for gathering domain
knowledge and training corpus; instruction tuning for optimizing language
models with multiple levels of instruction formats; and comprehensive
evaluation for assessing the professionalism discrimination and reference-based
quality of generated text. Comparative analysis of ProSwitch against both
general and specialized language models reveals that our approach outperforms
baselines in switching between professional and non-professional text
generation.
|
[
-0.2503378093242645,
-0.7768827080726624,
0.28805410861968994,
0.021094195544719696,
-0.29888996481895447,
0.1402054727077484,
-0.25068220496177673,
-0.13397164642810822,
-0.01712387055158615,
0.9738806486129761,
-0.7595672607421875,
-0.5469914078712463,
-0.4425515830516815,
0.18577498197555542,
-0.4023481607437134,
1.1120295524597168,
-0.11410405486822128,
0.33887776732444763,
-0.128590390086174,
0.12942661345005035,
-0.4693847894668579,
-0.11565214395523071,
-0.5069239139556885,
-0.5136312246322632,
0.14960666000843048,
0.5304557085037231,
0.8675940036773682,
0.4845649302005768,
0.7099264860153198,
0.26913779973983765,
0.27260223031044006,
0.6321315169334412,
-0.46527424454689026,
0.0613795667886734,
-0.3338097035884857,
-0.5668824911117554,
-0.5677985548973083,
0.32113391160964966,
0.44883713126182556,
0.318747341632843,
-0.06335430592298508,
0.4060034155845642,
0.0920419842004776,
0.6624013781547546,
-0.5532824397087097,
-0.04448135942220688,
-0.7851006388664246,
-0.22584034502506256,
-0.5252107977867126,
-0.5947871208190918,
-0.7224641442298889,
-0.6849813461303711,
-0.06288357824087143,
-0.7524217963218689,
0.47762617468833923,
0.14177244901657104,
0.5974416732788086,
0.06743674725294113,
-0.3689580261707306,
-0.3472954332828522,
-0.6710132360458374,
0.8216681480407715,
-0.8307528495788574,
0.4934822916984558,
0.40072596073150635,
0.36777934432029724,
-0.05273059383034706,
-0.7770944237709045,
-0.6073194146156311,
-0.26064881682395935,
0.05154011771082878,
0.4395887851715088,
0.29134422540664673,
0.19201824069023132,
-0.3264967203140259,
0.03506668284535408,
-0.25097304582595825,
0.1895417720079422,
-0.0966126099228859,
0.04309112951159477,
0.7319583892822266,
0.27087196707725525,
0.24665936827659607,
0.1727169305086136,
-0.09260397404432297,
0.017037654295563698,
-0.9460812211036682,
-0.1416882574558258,
0.7783539295196533,
0.13526372611522675,
0.24794821441173553,
0.37394794821739197,
-0.007438382599502802,
0.8687645196914673,
0.2615538239479065,
-0.41928526759147644,
-0.28651824593544006,
-0.48283201456069946,
-0.019491812214255333,
-0.13345518708229065,
0.6853304505348206,
0.7408319711685181,
0.7801724076271057,
-0.3105027973651886,
-0.20696943998336792,
-0.21707986295223236,
0.6654035449028015,
-0.6262727975845337,
-0.4405183792114258,
0.012954887002706528,
-0.4084313213825226,
-0.63912034034729,
0.012101495638489723,
-0.8163143992424011,
-0.35042092204093933,
-0.6473195552825928,
0.235085591673851,
-0.42789795994758606,
-0.29136666655540466,
0.1467519998550415,
-0.04761272296309471,
0.09246242046356201,
0.253423810005188,
-1.060325026512146,
0.5164886116981506,
0.6037930250167847,
0.6301942467689514,
-0.2867385447025299,
-0.16997112333774567,
-0.31905728578567505,
0.14336811006069183,
-0.7827548980712891,
0.6172879338264465,
-0.9314150810241699,
-0.5776025056838989,
0.21454618871212006,
-0.10754439979791641,
-0.1858925074338913,
-0.8929242491722107,
0.2501019239425659,
-0.8099791407585144,
0.020948942750692368,
-0.0592598058283329,
-0.5235209465026855,
0.2359684407711029,
-0.12055444717407227,
-0.4757922291755676,
1.0745773315429688,
0.28697946667671204,
-0.8884572386741638,
0.29617464542388916,
-0.43680453300476074,
-0.4126532971858978,
0.19383761286735535,
-0.1485573798418045,
-0.5315214991569519,
0.08907916396856308,
-0.29247981309890747,
0.3153952360153198,
-0.3656393587589264,
0.5320367813110352,
0.032367806881666183,
-0.42999890446662903,
0.1905364841222763,
-0.019641904160380363,
0.3340986967086792,
-0.11312974989414215,
-0.3997541069984436,
0.22888395190238953,
-0.6229467391967773,
-0.050840944051742554,
0.08853793889284134,
-0.3530222773551941,
-0.3729552924633026,
0.2622889280319214,
0.06689555943012238,
0.002124010119587183,
0.20055066049098969,
-0.34065788984298706,
0.3787725269794464,
-0.20974862575531006,
0.30407097935676575,
0.7200406193733215,
0.07441690564155579,
0.6877672076225281,
-0.3515295684337616,
0.584984540939331,
-0.2612590789794922,
0.20640429854393005,
0.16226103901863098,
-0.23729395866394043,
-0.6805055141448975,
0.05660504475235939,
0.40966352820396423,
0.7439178824424744,
-0.989565372467041,
0.2870393991470337,
0.1518888622522354,
-0.559923529624939,
-0.8273638486862183,
0.10911133885383606,
0.6961923241615295,
0.6992927193641663,
0.6002762913703918,
-0.017875704914331436,
-0.46843013167381287,
-0.827059805393219,
-0.6675981879234314,
0.10481616854667664,
-0.020606685429811478,
0.07775937020778656,
0.4078386425971985,
0.08124750107526779,
1.091235876083374,
-0.6159344911575317,
-0.31355714797973633,
-0.5177364945411682,
0.4206801652908325,
0.07676008343696594,
0.26006555557250977,
0.5467379093170166,
-0.43614640831947327,
-0.5276954174041748,
-0.10245207697153091,
-0.5023396015167236,
-0.46373438835144043,
-0.5711186528205872,
-0.389652818441391,
-0.0012277697678655386,
0.5701261162757874,
-0.31979939341545105,
0.0248863585293293,
0.3106510639190674,
-0.13169319927692413,
1.3986129760742188,
-0.1693510264158249,
0.05332845076918602,
-0.9786273837089539,
-0.04126456752419472,
0.021268319338560104,
-0.0202496238052845,
-0.7643147706985474,
0.24425964057445526,
0.2269531637430191,
0.24393627047538757,
-0.33706530928611755,
0.7807416319847107,
-0.5688079595565796,
0.28441235423088074,
-0.41600698232650757,
0.12629149854183197,
-0.027611659839749336,
0.11062344908714294,
0.2909550964832306,
1.1815378665924072,
0.13363012671470642,
-0.8480383157730103,
0.09630758315324783,
0.40121960639953613,
-0.3354978561401367,
0.5873239040374756,
-0.4920378625392914,
0.0942549929022789,
0.0009597858879715204,
0.08225343376398087,
-0.4554165005683899,
-0.2119162678718567,
-0.060512710362672806,
-0.12039361149072647,
0.5313604474067688,
0.0691014900803566,
-0.5271133184432983,
-0.2243819236755371,
-0.4971991181373596,
-0.14654383063316345,
0.47291290760040283,
-0.1209450513124466,
0.38868504762649536,
0.2093302607536316,
-0.25310707092285156,
-0.43852075934410095,
-0.4555506706237793,
-0.06423157453536987,
0.02907339110970497,
-0.3423566520214081,
0.6637370586395264,
-0.057676877826452255,
-0.49670276045799255,
-0.42470818758010864,
-0.31355294585227966,
0.06287895143032074,
0.0052338456735014915,
-0.4586341679096222,
0.29771021008491516,
-0.020868003368377686,
-0.09892431646585464,
0.5972023010253906,
-0.04279463365674019,
0.0564337894320488,
-0.3346130847930908,
0.5262308716773987,
0.4064580798149109,
-0.1826677918434143,
-0.3502686023712158,
0.304555743932724,
0.22600135207176208,
-0.5507778525352478,
0.9103554487228394,
0.5904473066329956,
0.11592487245798111,
-0.5854796767234802,
-0.3801400065422058,
-0.5614120364189148,
-0.5786094665527344,
0.5940185189247131,
-0.2584511935710907,
-0.6051150560379028,
0.18169674277305603,
-0.4378322958946228,
0.57314133644104,
0.10813778638839722,
0.4976769983768463,
-0.305947482585907,
0.8020191192626953,
0.5648741126060486,
0.4911442995071411,
0.75008225440979,
-0.17310528457164764,
0.37241828441619873,
-0.7991988062858582,
-0.17442819476127625,
-0.48441797494888306,
-0.3810036778450012,
-0.5247525572776794,
-0.26904189586639404,
0.5077834725379944,
0.3778947591781616,
-0.3617275655269623,
0.33495810627937317,
-0.46180975437164307,
0.5819196105003357,
0.698404848575592,
0.21269086003303528,
0.1910630464553833,
-0.32124951481819153,
-0.16583092510700226,
-0.32929757237434387,
-0.4966363310813904,
-0.9168791770935059,
0.9711611270904541,
0.08968706429004669,
0.8454856276512146,
0.1105145812034607,
0.7578254342079163,
0.22795429825782776,
0.2567561864852905,
-0.6032723784446716,
0.8776514530181885,
-0.7243530750274658,
-0.3305128812789917,
-0.31182652711868286,
-0.11635465919971466,
-0.6294727325439453,
-0.03863776475191116,
-0.30483388900756836,
-0.36787280440330505,
-0.07492928951978683,
0.43426525592803955,
0.009466713294386864,
0.17728367447853088,
-0.6700398921966553,
0.5882581472396851,
-0.14716501533985138,
-0.5072916150093079,
-0.07658834755420685,
-0.5703663229942322,
0.43864142894744873,
-0.3142363429069519,
0.33084240555763245,
0.03167226165533066,
-0.23677268624305725,
0.8292989134788513,
-0.3549937605857849,
1.1016535758972168,
-0.21752987802028656,
-0.2133024036884308,
0.2947583794593811,
0.7520273327827454,
0.5452756881713867,
0.003561371471732855,
-0.1710221916437149,
-0.1772739440202713,
-0.2025524228811264,
-0.02248278819024563,
-0.37038788199424744,
0.38134264945983887,
-0.8397611975669861,
-0.6563846468925476,
0.2376183122396469,
-0.5322792530059814,
-0.580091655254364,
0.49095773696899414,
0.4156743586063385,
0.6752872467041016,
-0.17096735537052155,
0.07587281614542007,
1.1066521406173706,
-0.14649036526679993,
0.29541072249412537,
0.810472309589386,
-0.1277211755514145,
-0.2430727630853653,
1.0833089351654053,
0.3146432936191559,
0.4833470582962036,
0.6385235786437988,
0.30167156457901,
-0.31803640723228455,
-0.764041543006897,
-0.4709562361240387,
0.28256896138191223,
-0.5080136656761169,
-0.31056785583496094,
-0.4890657663345337,
-0.1954599916934967,
-0.4793111979961395,
-0.5638721585273743,
-0.4129997193813324,
-0.1517147570848465,
-0.5784398317337036,
0.008839072659611702,
0.33520233631134033,
0.7435410618782043,
0.5549103021621704,
0.6110960245132446,
-0.8407584428787231,
0.45972833037376404,
0.21865613758563995,
0.2912857234477997,
-0.4057890474796295,
-0.6314277648925781,
-0.13382188975811005,
-0.23019051551818848,
-0.5981799364089966,
-1.3200581073760986,
0.27599549293518066,
0.5434568524360657,
0.7018190026283264,
0.3524879813194275,
0.34650719165802,
0.12583650648593903,
-0.8787273168563843,
0.8841816186904907,
0.11837481707334518,
-0.9186015129089355,
0.5507041215896606,
-0.8183702826499939,
0.47870779037475586,
0.639316201210022,
0.42293623089790344,
-0.4144405722618103,
-0.7248681783676147,
-0.3673265278339386,
-0.8842592835426331,
0.6432167291641235,
-0.07665180414915085,
0.24256566166877747,
-0.17999015748500824,
0.30722782015800476,
0.40435752272605896,
0.37390780448913574,
-0.206527978181839,
0.02648400329053402,
-0.3049115538597107,
-0.5438721179962158,
0.15969900786876678,
-0.1239449679851532,
-0.31423068046569824,
0.007948082871735096,
0.542984127998352,
-0.4335331916809082,
0.3346620500087738,
-0.13631008565425873,
-0.19712769985198975,
0.14680297672748566,
0.35525593161582947,
0.6789835095405579,
0.8494815826416016,
0.12659811973571777,
0.20575734972953796,
0.08674588054418564,
-0.7551445364952087,
-0.0935622975230217,
-0.4108316898345947,
-0.4185952842235565,
0.032905034720897675,
0.8662758469581604,
0.9196127653121948,
0.5613064169883728,
-0.33301639556884766,
0.253611296415329,
0.32266664505004883,
-0.7435575127601624,
0.2230951339006424,
0.45528557896614075,
0.3367542624473572,
-0.029597049579024315,
0.1715625822544098,
0.07240049540996552,
0.005220890510827303,
-0.34195828437805176,
0.22399522364139557,
0.2546483278274536,
0.12916669249534607,
-0.4716768264770508,
0.9501340985298157,
0.5370563268661499,
-0.6093690395355225,
0.4692968726158142,
0.10454604774713516,
-0.17824682593345642,
0.5471889972686768,
0.8912766575813293,
0.7304527163505554,
-0.31537702679634094,
0.6841445565223694,
0.2434019297361374,
0.26917406916618347,
-0.292283296585083,
0.41240060329437256,
0.06101882830262184,
-0.7010090351104736,
-0.21421317756175995,
-0.7183991074562073,
-0.6503111720085144,
-0.13545578718185425,
-0.8512412905693054,
0.3093162178993225,
-0.45890411734580994,
-0.3550470173358917,
-0.2134454846382141,
-0.16534028947353363,
-0.5156143307685852,
0.2392699122428894,
-0.4238641858100891,
1.2847213745117188,
-0.8653745055198669,
0.9082744121551514,
0.765119731426239,
-0.24429015815258026,
-0.5498486161231995,
0.37593430280685425,
-0.08190348744392395,
-0.7311080098152161,
0.4445272982120514,
-0.13669440150260925,
-0.5746909379959106,
0.35300055146217346,
-0.5575527548789978,
-0.26339495182037354,
1.024640440940857,
0.4230646789073944,
-0.8917497396469116,
-0.14857517182826996,
0.07390572875738144,
0.6159671545028687,
-0.19443395733833313,
0.350230872631073,
0.9835564494132996,
0.47414255142211914,
-0.17516237497329712,
-0.9729468822479248,
-0.24277891218662262,
-0.060647156089544296,
0.036228589713573456,
0.2596465051174164,
-0.9727150201797485,
0.435872346162796,
-0.01588968001306057,
0.08697089552879333,
-0.26446032524108887,
0.46167874336242676,
0.3576612174510956,
0.02257527969777584,
0.11829850822687149,
-0.1690157800912857,
0.6584652066230774,
-0.15020062029361725,
0.5904819965362549,
-0.5376594066619873,
-0.013696241192519665,
1.155327558517456,
-0.3251390755176544,
0.9505161046981812,
0.33112645149230957,
-0.23667855560779572,
0.454250693321228,
0.48959866166114807,
0.2869892418384552,
0.6954830288887024,
0.039330191910266876,
-0.2772119641304016,
-0.30060192942619324,
0.02162552811205387,
-0.33327287435531616,
0.455353319644928,
0.19095760583877563,
-0.3796905279159546,
0.02584953047335148,
-0.07833641767501831,
0.47418704628944397,
0.42226043343544006,
-0.24009820818901062,
0.9236266613006592,
-0.04541618749499321,
-0.934665322303772,
0.5072044134140015,
0.2074202299118042,
0.752382755279541,
-0.7777260541915894,
0.031073011457920074,
-0.33884531259536743,
0.22556903958320618,
-0.13459427654743195,
-1.0234081745147705,
0.41973841190338135,
0.07036718726158142,
-0.2575238049030304,
-0.7138338685035706,
0.7101683616638184,
-0.3400668203830719,
-0.4052210748195648,
0.06612016260623932,
0.2200174480676651,
-0.16392698884010315,
0.3533482551574707,
-0.5646733641624451,
-0.18111945688724518,
-0.21187683939933777,
-0.4196633994579315,
0.4942968189716339,
0.16231931746006012,
-0.43523433804512024,
0.49861812591552734,
0.29121133685112,
0.07550221681594849,
0.07159384340047836,
0.43114975094795227,
0.8347342014312744,
-0.2599620819091797,
-0.42483004927635193,
-0.6523615121841431,
0.4263981580734253,
-0.10277557373046875,
-0.5602234601974487,
0.5246458053588867,
0.3258962631225586,
0.8059448599815369,
-0.4994228482246399,
0.8090431690216064,
0.23302097618579865,
0.4462708532810211,
-0.8600851893424988,
0.8754107356071472,
-0.3286929726600647,
-0.04612096771597862,
-0.23263606429100037,
-0.6237832307815552,
-0.2122572362422943,
0.3782297968864441,
-0.5238633155822754,
0.09997383505105972,
0.7701382040977478,
0.8573240637779236,
0.08737412095069885,
0.02519700489938259,
0.1337665617465973,
-0.06851883232593536,
0.2596871554851532,
-0.06647934764623642,
0.2983255088329315,
0.09921526908874512,
0.26968708634376526,
0.2817457318305969,
-0.519361674785614,
-0.2502462565898895,
-0.7864816784858704,
-0.9956686496734619,
-0.3448210656642914,
-0.22846822440624237,
-0.07448488473892212,
0.32620683312416077,
0.5042904019355774,
0.7570300698280334,
-0.7371805906295776,
-0.23040500283241272,
-0.29566246271133423,
-0.2878111004829407,
-0.5776258111000061,
-0.23054276406764984,
0.12946689128875732,
-0.5553740859031677,
-0.6622016429901123,
0.5693696141242981,
0.05292171239852905,
-0.27969491481781006,
-0.3637365400791168,
-0.07580268383026123,
-0.06165330484509468,
0.7126610279083252,
0.5535834431648254,
-0.16246390342712402,
-0.47362324595451355,
0.07904046773910522,
0.3559625446796417,
-0.06661033630371094,
-0.3060804605484009,
1.1428829431533813,
-0.26651129126548767,
0.47871217131614685,
0.6502969264984131,
0.4273323714733124,
0.07284805923700333,
0.02802409790456295,
0.7874929308891296,
-1.0574311017990112,
-0.24191266298294067,
0.09633496403694153,
-0.2609705626964569,
-0.025051841512322426,
-0.39618343114852905,
0.2121763676404953,
0.2552958130836487,
-0.5442115068435669,
-0.6301605701446533,
0.5175626873970032,
-0.48470574617385864,
-0.43708479404449463,
1.1887894868850708,
0.09438631683588028,
0.06160757318139076,
-0.19544868171215057,
-0.5677934288978577,
0.47688308358192444,
-0.0951327383518219,
0.6467960476875305,
0.6181446313858032,
-0.3241049647331238,
-0.34746554493904114,
-0.7544469833374023,
0.7004029750823975,
0.25447407364845276,
-0.9707520604133606,
0.1374388486146927,
0.18774685263633728,
0.32217684388160706,
-0.282022088766098,
0.9704926013946533,
-0.015691112726926804,
0.21694403886795044,
0.1328555792570114,
0.17447489500045776,
-0.3913344442844391,
-0.7059847712516785,
0.5200964212417603,
0.16397562623023987,
0.1640200912952423,
-0.12356308102607727
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.